id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
40439	1	1	PLATO	PLATO	NNP
40439	1	2	'S	's	POS
40439	1	3	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNS
40439	1	4	RESPECTING	respecting	VBP
40439	1	5	THE	the	DT
40439	1	6	ROTATION	ROTATION	NNS
40439	1	7	OF	of	IN
40439	1	8	THE	the	DT
40439	1	9	EARTH	EARTH	NNP
40439	1	10	,	,	,
40439	1	11	AND	and	CC
40439	1	12	ARISTOTLE	ARISTOTLE	NNP
40439	1	13	'S	's	POS
40439	1	14	COMMENT	comment	NN
40439	1	15	UPON	upon	IN
40439	1	16	THAT	that	DT
40439	1	17	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
40439	1	18	.	.	.
40439	2	1	BY	by	IN
40439	2	2	GEORGE	GEORGE	NNP
40439	2	3	GROTE	GROTE	NNP
40439	2	4	,	,	,
40439	2	5	ESQ	ESQ	NNP
40439	2	6	.	.	.
40439	3	1	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
40439	3	2	:	:	:
40439	3	3	JOHN	JOHN	NNP
40439	3	4	MURRAY	MURRAY	NNP
40439	3	5	,	,	,
40439	3	6	ALBEMARLE	ALBEMARLE	NNP
40439	3	7	STREET	STREET	NNP
40439	3	8	.	.	.
40439	4	1	1860	1860	CD
40439	4	2	.	.	.
40439	5	1	_	_	NNP
40439	5	2	The	the	DT
40439	5	3	right	right	NN
40439	5	4	of	of	IN
40439	5	5	Translation	translation	NN
40439	5	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	5	7	reserved	reserve	VBN
40439	5	8	.	.	.
40439	5	9	_	_	NNP
40439	5	10	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
40439	5	11	:	:	:
40439	5	12	PRINTED	print	VBN
40439	5	13	BY	by	IN
40439	5	14	WILLIAM	WILLIAM	NNP
40439	5	15	CLOWES	CLOWES	NNP
40439	5	16	AND	and	CC
40439	5	17	SONS	son	NNS
40439	5	18	,	,	,
40439	5	19	STAMFORD	STAMFORD	NNP
40439	5	20	STREET	STREET	NNP
40439	5	21	,	,	,
40439	5	22	AND	and	CC
40439	5	23	CHARING	CHARING	NNP
40439	5	24	CROSS	CROSS	NNP
40439	5	25	.	.	.
40439	6	1	EXAMINATION	examination	NN
40439	6	2	OF	of	IN
40439	6	3	THE	the	DT
40439	6	4	THREE	three	CD
40439	6	5	FOLLOWING	follow	VBN
40439	6	6	QUESTIONS:--	QUESTIONS:--	NNP
40439	6	7	1	1	CD
40439	6	8	.	.	.
40439	7	1	WHETHER	whether	IN
40439	7	2	THE	the	DT
40439	7	3	DOCTRINE	DOCTRINE	NNP
40439	7	4	OF	of	IN
40439	7	5	THE	the	DT
40439	7	6	EARTH	EARTH	NNP
40439	7	7	'S	's	POS
40439	7	8	ROTATION	ROTATION	NNS
40439	7	9	IS	be	VBZ
40439	7	10	AFFIRMED	affirmed	NN
40439	7	11	OR	or	CC
40439	7	12	IMPLIED	IMPLIED	NNP
40439	7	13	IN	in	IN
40439	7	14	THE	the	DT
40439	7	15	PLATONIC	PLATONIC	NNP
40439	7	16	TIMÆUS	TIMÆUS	NNP
40439	7	17	?	?	.
40439	8	1	2	2	LS
40439	8	2	.	.	.
40439	9	1	IF	if	IN
40439	9	2	AFFIRMED	affirmed	NN
40439	9	3	OR	or	CC
40439	9	4	IMPLIED	IMPLIED	NNP
40439	9	5	,	,	,
40439	9	6	IN	in	IN
40439	9	7	WHAT	what	WDT
40439	9	8	SENSE	SENSE	NNS
40439	9	9	?	?	.
40439	10	1	3	3	LS
40439	10	2	.	.	.
40439	11	1	WHAT	what	WP
40439	11	2	IS	be	VBZ
40439	11	3	THE	the	DT
40439	11	4	COSMICAL	COSMICAL	NNP
40439	11	5	FUNCTION	function	NN
40439	11	6	WHICH	which	WDT
40439	11	7	PLATO	PLATO	NNS
40439	11	8	ASSIGNS	assign	VBD
40439	11	9	TO	to	IN
40439	11	10	THE	the	DT
40439	11	11	EARTH	earth	NN
40439	11	12	IN	in	IN
40439	11	13	THE	the	DT
40439	11	14	TIMÆUS	TIMÆUS	NNP
40439	11	15	?	?	.
40439	12	1	PREFACE	PREFACE	NNP
40439	12	2	.	.	.
40439	13	1	The	the	DT
40439	13	2	following	follow	VBG
40439	13	3	paper	paper	NN
40439	13	4	was	be	VBD
40439	13	5	originally	originally	RB
40439	13	6	intended	intend	VBN
40439	13	7	as	as	IN
40439	13	8	an	an	DT
40439	13	9	explanatory	explanatory	JJ
40439	13	10	note	note	NN
40439	13	11	on	on	IN
40439	13	12	the	the	DT
40439	13	13	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	13	14	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	13	15	,	,	,
40439	13	16	in	in	IN
40439	13	17	the	the	DT
40439	13	18	work	work	NN
40439	13	19	which	which	WDT
40439	13	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	13	21	am	be	VBP
40439	13	22	now	now	RB
40439	13	23	preparing	prepare	VBG
40439	13	24	on	on	IN
40439	13	25	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	13	26	and	and	CC
40439	13	27	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	13	28	.	.	.
40439	14	1	Interpreting	interpreting	NN
40439	14	2	,	,	,
40439	14	3	differently	differently	RB
40439	14	4	from	from	IN
40439	14	5	others	other	NNS
40439	14	6	,	,	,
40439	14	7	the	the	DT
40439	14	8	much	much	RB
40439	14	9	debated	debate	VBN
40439	14	10	passage	passage	NN
40439	14	11	in	in	IN
40439	14	12	which	which	WDT
40439	14	13	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	14	14	describes	describe	VBZ
40439	14	15	the	the	DT
40439	14	16	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	14	17	function	function	NN
40439	14	18	of	of	IN
40439	14	19	the	the	DT
40439	14	20	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	14	21	,	,	,
40439	14	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	14	23	found	find	VBD
40439	14	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	14	25	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
40439	14	26	to	to	TO
40439	14	27	give	give	VB
40439	14	28	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	14	29	reasons	reason	NNS
40439	14	30	for	for	IN
40439	14	31	this	this	DT
40439	14	32	new	new	JJ
40439	14	33	view	view	NN
40439	14	34	.	.	.
40439	15	1	But	but	CC
40439	15	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	15	3	soon	soon	RB
40439	15	4	discovered	discover	VBD
40439	15	5	that	that	IN
40439	15	6	those	those	DT
40439	15	7	reasons	reason	NNS
40439	15	8	could	could	MD
40439	15	9	not	not	RB
40439	15	10	be	be	VB
40439	15	11	comprised	comprise	VBN
40439	15	12	within	within	IN
40439	15	13	the	the	DT
40439	15	14	limits	limit	NNS
40439	15	15	of	of	IN
40439	15	16	a	a	DT
40439	15	17	note	note	NN
40439	15	18	.	.	.
40439	16	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
40439	16	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	16	3	here	here	RB
40439	16	4	publish	publish	VBP
40439	16	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	16	6	in	in	IN
40439	16	7	a	a	DT
40439	16	8	separate	separate	JJ
40439	16	9	Dissertation	dissertation	NN
40439	16	10	.	.	.
40439	17	1	The	the	DT
40439	17	2	manner	manner	NN
40439	17	3	in	in	IN
40439	17	4	which	which	WDT
40439	17	5	the	the	DT
40439	17	6	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	17	7	's	's	POS
40439	17	8	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	17	9	was	be	VBD
40439	17	10	conceived	conceive	VBN
40439	17	11	,	,	,
40439	17	12	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
40439	17	13	the	the	DT
40439	17	14	scientific	scientific	JJ
40439	17	15	character	character	NN
40439	17	16	of	of	IN
40439	17	17	the	the	DT
40439	17	18	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	17	19	and	and	CC
40439	17	20	Aristotelian	aristotelian	JJ
40439	17	21	age	age	NN
40439	17	22	,	,	,
40439	17	23	as	as	IN
40439	17	24	contrasted	contrast	VBN
40439	17	25	with	with	IN
40439	17	26	the	the	DT
40439	17	27	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
40439	17	28	development	development	NN
40439	17	29	and	and	CC
40439	17	30	improvement	improvement	NN
40439	17	31	of	of	IN
40439	17	32	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	17	33	.	.	.
40439	18	1	PLATO	PLATO	NNP
40439	18	2	--	--	:
40439	18	3	ON	on	IN
40439	18	4	THE	the	DT
40439	18	5	EARTH	EARTH	NNP
40439	18	6	'S	's	POS
40439	18	7	ROTATION	ROTATION	NNS
40439	18	8	.	.	.
40439	19	1	In	in	IN
40439	19	2	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	19	3	,	,	,
40439	19	4	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	19	5	,	,	,
40439	19	6	p.	p.	NN
40439	19	7	40	40	CD
40439	19	8	B	b	NN
40439	19	9	,	,	,
40439	19	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	19	11	read	read	VBP
40439	19	12	the	the	DT
40439	19	13	following	following	JJ
40439	19	14	words--[Greek	words--[greek	CD
40439	19	15	:	:	:
40439	19	16	Gê	Gê	NNS
40439	19	17	=	=	SYM
40439	19	18	n	n	CC
40439	19	19	de\	de\	NN
40439	19	20	tropho\n	tropho\n	-LRB-
40439	19	21	me\n	me\n	NNP
40439	19	22	ê(mete	ê(mete	NNP
40439	19	23	/	/	SYM
40439	19	24	ran	run	VBD
40439	19	25	,	,	,
40439	19	26	ei(llome	ei(llome	NNP
40439	19	27	/	/	SYM
40439	19	28	nên	nên	NN
40439	19	29	de\	de\	NN
40439	19	30	peri\	peri\	NNP
40439	19	31	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	19	32	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	19	33	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	19	34	po	po	NNP
40439	19	35	/	/	SYM
40439	19	36	lon	lon	NNP
40439	19	37	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	19	38	/	/	SYM
40439	19	39	non	non	NNP
40439	19	40	phu	phu	NNP
40439	19	41	/	/	SYM
40439	19	42	laka	laka	NNP
40439	19	43	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	19	44	dêmiourgo\n	dêmiourgo\n	NNP
40439	19	45	nukto	nukto	NNP
40439	19	46	/	/	SYM
40439	19	47	s	s	NNP
40439	19	48	te	te	NNP
40439	19	49	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	19	50	ê(me	ê(me	NNP
40439	19	51	/	/	SYM
40439	19	52	ras	ras	NNP
40439	19	53	e)mêchanê	e)mêchanê	NNP
40439	19	54	/	/	SYM
40439	19	55	sato	sato	NNP
40439	19	56	,	,	,
40439	19	57	prô	prô	NNP
40439	19	58	/	/	SYM
40439	19	59	tên	tên	NNP
40439	19	60	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	19	61	presbuta	presbuta	NNP
40439	19	62	/	/	SYM
40439	19	63	tên	tên	NNP
40439	19	64	theô	theô	NNP
40439	19	65	=	=	SYM
40439	19	66	n	n	NN
40439	19	67	,	,	,
40439	19	68	o(/soi	o(/soi	NNP
40439	19	69	e)nto\s	e)nto\s	NNP
40439	19	70	ou)ra	ou)ra	NNP
40439	19	71	/	/	SYM
40439	19	72	nou	nou	NNP
40439	19	73	gego	gego	NNP
40439	19	74	/	/	SYM
40439	19	75	nasi	nasi	NNP
40439	19	76	.	.	.
40439	19	77	]	]	-RRB-
40439	20	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	20	2	give	give	VBP
40439	20	3	the	the	DT
40439	20	4	text	text	NN
40439	20	5	as	as	IN
40439	20	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	20	7	stands	stand	VBZ
40439	20	8	in	in	IN
40439	20	9	Stallbaum	Stallbaum	NNP
40439	20	10	's	's	POS
40439	20	11	edition	edition	NN
40439	20	12	.	.	.
40439	21	1	The	the	DT
40439	21	2	obscurity	obscurity	NN
40439	21	3	of	of	IN
40439	21	4	this	this	DT
40439	21	5	passage	passage	NN
40439	21	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	21	7	amply	amply	RB
40439	21	8	attested	attest	VBN
40439	21	9	by	by	IN
40439	21	10	the	the	DT
40439	21	11	numerous	numerous	JJ
40439	21	12	differences	difference	NNS
40439	21	13	of	of	IN
40439	21	14	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	21	15	to	to	TO
40439	21	16	which	which	WDT
40439	21	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	21	18	has	have	VBZ
40439	21	19	given	give	VBN
40439	21	20	rise	rise	NN
40439	21	21	,	,	,
40439	21	22	both	both	CC
40439	21	23	in	in	IN
40439	21	24	ancient	ancient	JJ
40439	21	25	and	and	CC
40439	21	26	in	in	IN
40439	21	27	modern	modern	JJ
40439	21	28	times	time	NNS
40439	21	29	.	.	.
40439	22	1	Various	various	JJ
40439	22	2	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
40439	22	3	of	of	IN
40439	22	4	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	22	5	(	(	-LRB-
40439	22	6	[	[	-LRB-
40439	22	7	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	22	8	:	:	:
40439	22	9	e)/nioi]--Aristot	e)/nioi]--aristot	NN
40439	22	10	.	.	.
40439	23	1	De	De	NNP
40439	23	2	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	23	3	,	,	,
40439	23	4	II	II	NNP
40439	23	5	.	.	.
40439	24	1	13	13	CD
40439	24	2	,	,	,
40439	24	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	24	4	293	293	CD
40439	24	5	b.	b.	NN
40439	25	1	30	30	CD
40439	25	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	25	3	understood	understand	VBD
40439	25	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	25	5	as	as	IN
40439	25	6	asserting	assert	VBG
40439	25	7	or	or	CC
40439	25	8	implying	imply	VBG
40439	25	9	the	the	DT
40439	25	10	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	25	11	movement	movement	NN
40439	25	12	of	of	IN
40439	25	13	the	the	DT
40439	25	14	earth	earth	NN
40439	25	15	in	in	IN
40439	25	16	the	the	DT
40439	25	17	centre	centre	NN
40439	25	18	of	of	IN
40439	25	19	the	the	DT
40439	25	20	Kosmos	Kosmos	NNP
40439	25	21	,	,	,
40439	25	22	and	and	CC
40439	25	23	adhered	adhere	VBN
40439	25	24	to	to	IN
40439	25	25	this	this	DT
40439	25	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	25	27	as	as	IN
40439	25	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	25	29	own	own	JJ
40439	25	30	.	.	.
40439	26	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	26	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	26	3	alludes	allude	NNS
40439	26	4	to	to	IN
40439	26	5	these	these	DT
40439	26	6	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
40439	26	7	without	without	IN
40439	26	8	naming	name	VBG
40439	26	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	26	10	,	,	,
40439	26	11	and	and	CC
40439	26	12	adopts	adopt	VBZ
40439	26	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	26	14	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	26	15	of	of	IN
40439	26	16	the	the	DT
40439	26	17	passage	passage	NN
40439	26	18	;	;	:
40439	26	19	but	but	CC
40439	26	20	dissents	dissent	NNS
40439	26	21	from	from	IN
40439	26	22	the	the	DT
40439	26	23	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	26	24	,	,	,
40439	26	25	and	and	CC
40439	26	26	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
40439	26	27	to	to	IN
40439	26	28	impugn	impugn	VB
40439	26	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	26	30	by	by	IN
40439	26	31	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	26	32	.	.	.
40439	27	1	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
40439	27	2	mentions	mention	NNS
40439	27	3	(	(	-LRB-
40439	27	4	Academic	Academic	NNP
40439	27	5	II	II	NNP
40439	27	6	.	.	.
40439	28	1	39	39	LS
40439	28	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	28	3	that	that	IN
40439	28	4	there	there	EX
40439	28	5	were	be	VBD
40439	28	6	persons	person	NNS
40439	28	7	who	who	WP
40439	28	8	believed	believe	VBD
40439	28	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	28	10	to	to	TO
40439	28	11	have	have	VB
40439	28	12	indicated	indicate	VBN
40439	28	13	the	the	DT
40439	28	14	same	same	JJ
40439	28	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	28	16	obscurely	obscurely	RB
40439	28	17	,	,	,
40439	28	18	in	in	IN
40439	28	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	28	20	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	28	21	:	:	:
40439	28	22	this	this	DT
40439	28	23	passage	passage	NN
40439	28	24	must	must	MD
40439	28	25	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
40439	28	26	be	be	VB
40439	28	27	meant	mean	VBN
40439	28	28	.	.	.
40439	29	1	Plutarch	plutarch	NN
40439	29	2	devotes	devote	VBZ
40439	29	3	a	a	DT
40439	29	4	critical	critical	JJ
40439	29	5	chapter	chapter	NN
40439	29	6	to	to	IN
40439	29	7	the	the	DT
40439	29	8	enquiry	enquiry	NN
40439	29	9	,	,	,
40439	29	10	what	what	WP
40439	29	11	was	be	VBD
40439	29	12	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	29	13	's	's	POS
40439	29	14	real	real	JJ
40439	29	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	29	16	as	as	IN
40439	29	17	to	to	IN
40439	29	18	the	the	DT
40439	29	19	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	29	20	function	function	NN
40439	29	21	of	of	IN
40439	29	22	the	the	DT
40439	29	23	earth	earth	NN
40439	29	24	--	--	:
40439	29	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	29	26	movement	movement	NN
40439	29	27	or	or	CC
40439	29	28	rest	rest	NN
40439	29	29	(	(	-LRB-
40439	29	30	Quaestion	Quaestion	NNP
40439	29	31	.	.	.
40439	30	1	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	30	2	.	.	.
40439	31	1	VII	VII	NNP
40439	31	2	.	.	.
40439	32	1	3	3	CD
40439	32	2	,	,	,
40439	32	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	33	1	1006	1006	CD
40439	33	2	.	.	.
40439	33	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	34	1	There	there	EX
40439	34	2	exists	exist	VBZ
40439	34	3	a	a	DT
40439	34	4	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	34	5	,	,	,
40439	34	6	in	in	IN
40439	34	7	Doric	doric	JJ
40439	34	8	dialect	dialect	NN
40439	34	9	,	,	,
40439	34	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
40439	34	11	[	[	-LRB-
40439	34	12	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	34	13	:	:	:
40439	34	14	Ti	Ti	NNP
40439	34	15	/	/	SYM
40439	34	16	maio	maio	JJ
40439	34	17	*	*	NFP
40439	34	18	*	*	NFP
40439	34	19	tô=	tô=	:
40439	34	20	Lo	Lo	NNP
40439	34	21	/	/	SYM
40439	34	22	krô	krô	NNP
40439	34	23	Peri\	Peri\	NNP
40439	34	24	Psucha	Psucha	NNPS
40439	34	25	=	=	SYM
40439	34	26	s	s	VBZ
40439	34	27	Ko	Ko	NNP
40439	34	28	/	/	SYM
40439	34	29	smô	smô	NNP
40439	34	30	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	34	31	Phu	Phu	NNP
40439	34	32	/	/	SYM
40439	34	33	sios	sios	NNP
40439	34	34	]	]	-RRB-
40439	34	35	,	,	,
40439	34	36	which	which	WDT
40439	34	37	is	be	VBZ
40439	34	38	usually	usually	RB
40439	34	39	published	publish	VBN
40439	34	40	along	along	IN
40439	34	41	with	with	IN
40439	34	42	the	the	DT
40439	34	43	works	work	NNS
40439	34	44	of	of	IN
40439	34	45	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	34	46	.	.	.
40439	35	1	This	this	DT
40439	35	2	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	35	3	was	be	VBD
40439	35	4	supposed	suppose	VBN
40439	35	5	in	in	IN
40439	35	6	ancient	ancient	JJ
40439	35	7	times	time	NNS
40439	35	8	to	to	TO
40439	35	9	be	be	VB
40439	35	10	a	a	DT
40439	35	11	genuine	genuine	JJ
40439	35	12	production	production	NN
40439	35	13	of	of	IN
40439	35	14	the	the	DT
40439	35	15	Lokrian	Lokrian	NNP
40439	35	16	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	35	17	,	,	,
40439	35	18	whom	whom	WP
40439	35	19	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	35	20	introduces	introduce	VBZ
40439	35	21	as	as	IN
40439	35	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	35	23	spokesman	spokesman	NN
40439	35	24	in	in	IN
40439	35	25	the	the	DT
40439	35	26	dialogue	dialogue	NN
40439	35	27	so	so	RB
40439	35	28	called	call	VBD
40439	35	29	.	.	.
40439	36	1	As	as	IN
40439	36	2	such	such	JJ
40439	36	3	,	,	,
40439	36	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	36	5	was	be	VBD
40439	36	6	considered	consider	VBN
40439	36	7	to	to	TO
40439	36	8	be	be	VB
40439	36	9	of	of	IN
40439	36	10	much	much	JJ
40439	36	11	authority	authority	NN
40439	36	12	in	in	IN
40439	36	13	settling	settle	VBG
40439	36	14	questions	question	NNS
40439	36	15	of	of	IN
40439	36	16	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	36	17	as	as	IN
40439	36	18	to	to	IN
40439	36	19	the	the	DT
40439	36	20	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	36	21	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	36	22	.	.	.
40439	37	1	But	but	CC
40439	37	2	modern	modern	JJ
40439	37	3	critics	critic	NNS
40439	37	4	hold	hold	VBP
40439	37	5	,	,	,
40439	37	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	37	7	believe	believe	VBP
40439	37	8	unanimously	unanimously	RB
40439	37	9	,	,	,
40439	37	10	that	that	IN
40439	37	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	37	12	is	be	VBZ
40439	37	13	the	the	DT
40439	37	14	work	work	NN
40439	37	15	of	of	IN
40439	37	16	some	some	DT
40439	37	17	later	later	RB
40439	37	18	Pythagorean	pythagorean	JJ
40439	37	19	or	or	CC
40439	37	20	Platonist	platonist	JJ
40439	37	21	,	,	,
40439	37	22	excerpted	excerpted	JJ
40439	37	23	or	or	CC
40439	37	24	copied	copy	VBN
40439	37	25	from	from	IN
40439	37	26	the	the	DT
40439	37	27	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	37	28	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	37	29	.	.	.
40439	38	1	This	this	DT
40439	38	2	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	38	3	represents	represent	VBZ
40439	38	4	the	the	DT
40439	38	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	38	6	as	as	IN
40439	38	7	being	be	VBG
40439	38	8	in	in	IN
40439	38	9	the	the	DT
40439	38	10	centre	centre	NN
40439	38	11	and	and	CC
40439	38	12	at	at	IN
40439	38	13	rest	rest	NN
40439	38	14	.	.	.
40439	39	1	But	but	CC
40439	39	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	39	3	language	language	NN
40439	39	4	,	,	,
40439	39	5	besides	besides	IN
40439	39	6	being	be	VBG
40439	39	7	dark	dark	JJ
40439	39	8	and	and	CC
40439	39	9	metaphorical	metaphorical	JJ
40439	39	10	,	,	,
40439	39	11	departs	depart	VBZ
40439	39	12	widely	widely	RB
40439	39	13	from	from	IN
40439	39	14	the	the	DT
40439	39	15	phraseology	phraseology	NN
40439	39	16	of	of	IN
40439	39	17	the	the	DT
40439	39	18	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	39	19	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNPS
40439	39	20	:	:	:
40439	39	21	especially	especially	RB
40439	39	22	in	in	IN
40439	39	23	this	this	DT
40439	39	24	--	--	:
40439	39	25	that	that	IN
40439	39	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	39	27	makes	make	VBZ
40439	39	28	no	no	DT
40439	39	29	mention	mention	NN
40439	39	30	of	of	IN
40439	39	31	the	the	DT
40439	39	32	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	39	33	axis	axis	NN
40439	39	34	,	,	,
40439	39	35	nor	nor	CC
40439	39	36	of	of	IN
40439	39	37	the	the	DT
40439	39	38	word	word	NN
40439	39	39	[	[	-LRB-
40439	39	40	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	39	41	:	:	:
40439	39	42	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	39	43	/	/	SYM
40439	39	44	nên	nên	NN
40439	39	45	]	]	-RRB-
40439	39	46	or	or	CC
40439	39	47	[	[	-LRB-
40439	39	48	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	39	49	:	:	:
40439	39	50	ei(loume	ei(loume	NNP
40439	39	51	/	/	SYM
40439	39	52	nên	nên	NN
40439	39	53	]	]	-RRB-
40439	39	54	.	.	.
40439	40	1	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
40439	40	2	of	of	IN
40439	40	3	Aphrodisias	Aphrodisias	NNP
40439	40	4	(	(	-LRB-
40439	40	5	as	as	IN
40439	40	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	40	7	learn	learn	VBP
40439	40	8	from	from	IN
40439	40	9	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	40	10	ad	ad	NN
40439	40	11	Aristot	Aristot	NNP
40439	40	12	.	.	.
40439	41	1	De	De	NNP
40439	41	2	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	41	3	,	,	,
40439	41	4	fol	fol	NNP
40439	41	5	.	.	.
40439	42	1	126	126	CD
40439	42	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	42	3	followed	follow	VBD
40439	42	4	the	the	DT
40439	42	5	construction	construction	NN
40439	42	6	of	of	IN
40439	42	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	42	8	given	give	VBN
40439	42	9	by	by	IN
40439	42	10	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	42	11	.	.	.
40439	43	1	"	"	``
40439	43	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	43	3	was	be	VBD
40439	43	4	improbable	improbable	JJ
40439	43	5	(	(	-LRB-
40439	43	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	43	7	said	say	VBD
40439	43	8	)	)	-RRB-
40439	43	9	that	that	IN
40439	43	10	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	43	11	could	could	MD
40439	43	12	be	be	VB
40439	43	13	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
40439	43	14	either	either	CC
40439	43	15	what	what	WP
40439	43	16	the	the	DT
40439	43	17	word	word	NN
40439	43	18	signified	signify	VBD
40439	43	19	,	,	,
40439	43	20	or	or	CC
40439	43	21	what	what	WP
40439	43	22	was	be	VBD
40439	43	23	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	43	24	's	's	POS
40439	43	25	purpose	purpose	NN
40439	43	26	"	"	''
40439	43	27	(	(	-LRB-
40439	43	28	[	[	-LRB-
40439	43	29	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	43	30	:	:	:
40439	43	31	a)lla\	a)lla\	''
40439	43	32	tô=|	tô=|	NNP
40439	43	33	A)ristote	A)ristote	NNP
40439	43	34	/	/	SYM
40439	43	35	lei	lei	NNP
40439	43	36	,	,	,
40439	43	37	phêsi\n	phêsi\n	NNS
40439	43	38	,	,	,
40439	43	39	ou(/tô	ou(/tô	IN
40439	43	40	le	le	NNP
40439	43	41	/	/	SYM
40439	43	42	gonti	gonti	NNP
40439	43	43	_	_	NNP
40439	43	44	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	43	45	_	_	NNP
40439	43	46	,	,	,
40439	43	47	ou)k	ou)k	NNP
40439	43	48	eu)/logon	eu)/logon	NNP
40439	43	49	a)ntile	a)ntile	NNP
40439	43	50	/	/	SYM
40439	43	51	gein	gein	NN
40439	43	52	;	;	:
40439	43	53	ô(s	ô(s	NNP
40439	43	54	a)lêthô	a)lêthô	CD
40439	43	55	=	=	SYM
40439	43	56	s	s	NNP
40439	43	57	ga\r	ga\r	NNP
40439	43	58	ou)/te	ou)/te	NNP
40439	43	59	tê	tê	NNP
40439	43	60	=	=	SYM
40439	43	61	s	s	NNP
40439	43	62	le	le	NNP
40439	43	63	/	/	SYM
40439	43	64	xeôs	xeôs	NNP
40439	43	65	to\	to\	NNP
40439	43	66	sêmaino	sêmaino	NNP
40439	43	67	/	/	SYM
40439	43	68	menon	menon	NNP
40439	43	69	ei)ko\s	ei)ko\s	NNP
40439	43	70	ê)=n	ê)=n	RB
40439	43	71	a)gnoei	a)gnoei	NNPS
40439	43	72	=	=	SYM
40439	43	73	n	n	CC
40439	43	74	au)to\n	au)to\n	NNP
40439	43	75	,	,	,
40439	43	76	ou)/te	ou)/te	NNP
40439	43	77	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	43	78	Pla	Pla	NNP
40439	43	79	/	/	SYM
40439	43	80	tônos	tônos	NN
40439	43	81	skopo	skopo	JJ
40439	43	82	/	/	SYM
40439	43	83	n	n	NN
40439	43	84	.	.	.
40439	43	85	]	]	-RRB-
40439	44	1	This	this	DT
40439	44	2	passage	passage	NN
40439	44	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	44	4	not	not	RB
40439	44	5	given	give	VBN
40439	44	6	in	in	IN
40439	44	7	the	the	DT
40439	44	8	Scholia	Scholia	NNP
40439	44	9	of	of	IN
40439	44	10	Brandis	Brandis	NNP
40439	44	11	)	)	-RRB-
40439	44	12	.	.	.
40439	45	1	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
40439	45	2	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	45	3	construed	construe	VBD
40439	45	4	[	[	-LRB-
40439	45	5	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	45	6	:	:	:
40439	45	7	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	45	8	/	/	SYM
40439	45	9	nên	nên	NN
40439	45	10	]	]	-RRB-
40439	45	11	as	as	IN
40439	45	12	meaning	mean	VBG
40439	45	13	or	or	CC
40439	45	14	implying	implying	JJ
40439	45	15	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	45	16	movement	movement	NN
40439	45	17	,	,	,
40439	45	18	though	though	IN
40439	45	19	in	in	IN
40439	45	20	so	so	RB
40439	45	21	doing	do	VBG
40439	45	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	45	23	perverted	pervert	VBD
40439	45	24	(	(	-LRB-
40439	45	25	so	so	RB
40439	45	26	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	45	27	says	say	VBZ
40439	45	28	)	)	-RRB-
40439	45	29	the	the	DT
40439	45	30	true	true	JJ
40439	45	31	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	45	32	to	to	TO
40439	45	33	make	make	VB
40439	45	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	45	35	consonant	consonant	JJ
40439	45	36	with	with	IN
40439	45	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	45	38	own	own	JJ
40439	45	39	suppositions	supposition	NNS
40439	45	40	.	.	.
40439	46	1	Proklus	proklus	JJ
40439	46	2	maintains	maintain	NNS
40439	46	3	that	that	IN
40439	46	4	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	46	5	has	have	VBZ
40439	46	6	interpreted	interpret	VBN
40439	46	7	the	the	DT
40439	46	8	passage	passage	NN
40439	46	9	erroneously,--that	erroneously,--that	IN
40439	46	10	[	[	-LRB-
40439	46	11	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	46	12	:	:	:
40439	46	13	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	46	14	/	/	SYM
40439	46	15	nên	nên	NN
40439	46	16	]	]	-RRB-
40439	46	17	is	be	VBZ
40439	46	18	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
40439	46	19	to	to	IN
40439	46	20	[	[	-LRB-
40439	46	21	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	46	22	:	:	:
40439	46	23	sphiggome	sphiggome	NN
40439	46	24	/	/	SYM
40439	46	25	nên	nên	NN
40439	46	26	]	]	-RRB-
40439	46	27	or	or	CC
40439	46	28	[	[	-LRB-
40439	46	29	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	46	30	:	:	:
40439	46	31	xunechome	xunechome	NNP
40439	46	32	/	/	SYM
40439	46	33	nên]--and	nên]--and	NNP
40439	46	34	that	that	IN
40439	46	35	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	46	36	intends	intend	VBZ
40439	46	37	by	by	IN
40439	46	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	46	39	to	to	TO
40439	46	40	affirm	affirm	VB
40439	46	41	the	the	DT
40439	46	42	earth	earth	NN
40439	46	43	as	as	IN
40439	46	44	at	at	IN
40439	46	45	rest	rest	NN
40439	46	46	in	in	IN
40439	46	47	the	the	DT
40439	46	48	centre	centre	NN
40439	46	49	of	of	IN
40439	46	50	the	the	DT
40439	46	51	Kosmos	Kosmos	NNP
40439	46	52	(	(	-LRB-
40439	46	53	ad	ad	NN
40439	46	54	Timaeum	Timaeum	NNP
40439	46	55	,	,	,
40439	46	56	Book	Book	NNP
40439	46	57	iv	iv	NNP
40439	46	58	.	.	NNP
40439	46	59	,	,	,
40439	46	60	p.	p.	NN
40439	46	61	681	681	CD
40439	46	62	ed	ed	NN
40439	46	63	.	.	.
40439	47	1	Schneider	schneider	NN
40439	47	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	47	3	.	.	.
40439	48	1	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	48	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	48	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	48	4	greatly	greatly	RB
40439	48	5	perplexed	perplexed	JJ
40439	48	6	,	,	,
40439	48	7	and	and	CC
40439	48	8	scarcely	scarcely	RB
40439	48	9	ventures	venture	NNS
40439	48	10	to	to	TO
40439	48	11	give	give	VB
40439	48	12	a	a	DT
40439	48	13	positive	positive	JJ
40439	48	14	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	48	15	of	of	IN
40439	48	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	48	17	own	own	JJ
40439	48	18	.	.	.
40439	49	1	On	on	IN
40439	49	2	the	the	DT
40439	49	3	whole	whole	NN
40439	49	4	,	,	,
40439	49	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	49	6	inclines	incline	VBZ
40439	49	7	to	to	TO
40439	49	8	believe	believe	VB
40439	49	9	that	that	IN
40439	49	10	[	[	-LRB-
40439	49	11	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	49	12	:	:	:
40439	49	13	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	49	14	/	/	SYM
40439	49	15	nên	nên	NN
40439	49	16	]	]	-RRB-
40439	49	17	might	may	MD
40439	49	18	possibly	possibly	RB
40439	49	19	be	be	VB
40439	49	20	understood	understand	VBN
40439	49	21	,	,	,
40439	49	22	by	by	IN
40439	49	23	superficial	superficial	JJ
40439	49	24	readers	reader	NNS
40439	49	25	,	,	,
40439	49	26	so	so	IN
40439	49	27	as	as	IN
40439	49	28	to	to	TO
40439	49	29	signify	signify	VB
40439	49	30	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	49	31	,	,	,
40439	49	32	though	though	IN
40439	49	33	such	such	JJ
40439	49	34	is	be	VBZ
40439	49	35	not	not	RB
40439	49	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	49	37	proper	proper	JJ
40439	49	38	and	and	CC
40439	49	39	natural	natural	JJ
40439	49	40	sense	sense	NN
40439	49	41	:	:	:
40439	49	42	that	that	IN
40439	49	43	some	some	DT
40439	49	44	Platonists	Platonists	NNPS
40439	49	45	did	do	VBD
40439	49	46	so	so	RB
40439	49	47	misunderstand	misunderstand	VB
40439	49	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	49	49	:	:	:
40439	49	50	and	and	CC
40439	49	51	that	that	IN
40439	49	52	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	49	53	accepted	accept	VBD
40439	49	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	49	55	sense	sense	NN
40439	49	56	for	for	IN
40439	49	57	the	the	DT
40439	49	58	sake	sake	NN
40439	49	59	of	of	IN
40439	49	60	the	the	DT
40439	49	61	argument	argument	NN
40439	49	62	,	,	,
40439	49	63	without	without	IN
40439	49	64	intending	intend	VBG
40439	49	65	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	49	66	to	to	TO
40439	49	67	countenance	countenance	VB
40439	49	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	49	69	(	(	-LRB-
40439	49	70	ad	ad	NN
40439	49	71	Aristot	Aristot	NNP
40439	49	72	.	.	.
40439	50	1	De	De	NNP
40439	50	2	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	50	3	,	,	,
40439	50	4	p.	p.	NN
40439	50	5	126	126	CD
40439	50	6	)	)	-RRB-
40439	50	7	.	.	.
40439	51	1	Both	both	DT
40439	51	2	Proklus	Proklus	NNP
40439	51	3	and	and	CC
40439	51	4	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	51	5	,	,	,
40439	51	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	51	7	must	must	MD
40439	51	8	recollect	recollect	VB
40439	51	9	,	,	,
40439	51	10	believed	believe	VBN
40439	51	11	in	in	IN
40439	51	12	the	the	DT
40439	51	13	genuineness	genuineness	NN
40439	51	14	of	of	IN
40439	51	15	the	the	DT
40439	51	16	Doric	doric	JJ
40439	51	17	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	51	18	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	51	19	to	to	IN
40439	51	20	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	51	21	Locrus	Locrus	NNP
40439	51	22	.	.	.
40439	52	1	Reasoning	reason	VBG
40439	52	2	upon	upon	IN
40439	52	3	this	this	DT
40439	52	4	basis	basis	NN
40439	52	5	,	,	,
40439	52	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	52	7	of	of	IN
40439	52	8	course	course	NN
40439	52	9	saw	see	VBD
40439	52	10	,	,	,
40439	52	11	that	that	IN
40439	52	12	if	if	IN
40439	52	13	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	52	14	had	have	VBD
40439	52	15	correctly	correctly	RB
40439	52	16	interpreted	interpret	VBN
40439	52	17	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	52	18	,	,	,
40439	52	19	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	52	20	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	52	21	must	must	MD
40439	52	22	have	have	VB
40439	52	23	interpreted	interpret	VBN
40439	52	24	_	_	NNP
40439	52	25	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
40439	52	26	_	_	NNP
40439	52	27	the	the	DT
40439	52	28	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	52	29	of	of	IN
40439	52	30	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	52	31	.	.	.
40439	53	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
40439	53	2	had	have	VBD
40439	53	3	to	to	TO
40439	53	4	ascribe	ascribe	VB
40439	53	5	wrong	wrong	JJ
40439	53	6	construction	construction	NN
40439	53	7	either	either	CC
40439	53	8	to	to	IN
40439	53	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	53	10	or	or	CC
40439	53	11	to	to	IN
40439	53	12	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	53	13	:	:	:
40439	53	14	and	and	CC
40439	53	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	53	16	could	could	MD
40439	53	17	not	not	RB
40439	53	18	bear	bear	VB
40439	53	19	to	to	TO
40439	53	20	ascribe	ascribe	VB
40439	53	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	53	22	to	to	IN
40439	53	23	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	53	24	.	.	.
40439	54	1	Alkinous	alkinous	JJ
40439	54	2	,	,	,
40439	54	3	in	in	IN
40439	54	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	54	5	Eisagôge	Eisagôge	NNP
40439	54	6	(	(	-LRB-
40439	54	7	c.	c.	NNP
40439	54	8	15	15	CD
40439	54	9	)	)	-RRB-
40439	54	10	gives	give	VBZ
40439	54	11	the	the	DT
40439	54	12	same	same	JJ
40439	54	13	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	54	14	as	as	IN
40439	54	15	Proklus	Proklus	NNP
40439	54	16	.	.	.
40439	55	1	But	but	CC
40439	55	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	55	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	55	4	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
40439	55	5	that	that	IN
40439	55	6	in	in	IN
40439	55	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	55	8	paraphrase	paraphrase	NN
40439	55	9	of	of	IN
40439	55	10	the	the	DT
40439	55	11	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	55	12	words	word	NNS
40439	55	13	,	,	,
40439	55	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	55	15	calls	call	VBZ
40439	55	16	the	the	DT
40439	55	17	earth	earth	NN
40439	55	18	[	[	-LRB-
40439	55	19	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	55	20	:	:	:
40439	55	21	ê(me	ê(me	NNP
40439	55	22	/	/	SYM
40439	55	23	ras	ras	NNP
40439	55	24	phu	phu	NNP
40439	55	25	/	/	SYM
40439	55	26	lax	lax	NNP
40439	55	27	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	55	28	nukto	nukto	NNP
40439	55	29	/	/	SYM
40439	55	30	s	s	NNP
40439	55	31	]	]	-RRB-
40439	55	32	:	:	:
40439	55	33	omitting	omit	VBG
40439	55	34	the	the	DT
40439	55	35	significant	significant	JJ
40439	55	36	epithet	epithet	NN
40439	55	37	[	[	-LRB-
40439	55	38	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	55	39	:	:	:
40439	55	40	dêmiourgo	dêmiourgo	NNP
40439	55	41	/	/	SYM
40439	55	42	s	s	NNP
40439	55	43	]	]	-RRB-
40439	55	44	.	.	.
40439	56	1	In	in	IN
40439	56	2	regard	regard	NN
40439	56	3	to	to	IN
40439	56	4	modern	modern	JJ
40439	56	5	comments	comment	NNS
40439	56	6	upon	upon	IN
40439	56	7	the	the	DT
40439	56	8	same	same	JJ
40439	56	9	disputed	dispute	VBN
40439	56	10	point	point	NN
40439	56	11	,	,	,
40439	56	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	56	13	need	need	VBP
40439	56	14	only	only	RB
40439	56	15	mention	mention	VB
40439	56	16	(	(	-LRB-
40439	56	17	besides	besides	IN
40439	56	18	those	those	DT
40439	56	19	of	of	IN
40439	56	20	M.	M.	NNP
40439	56	21	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	56	22	,	,	,
40439	56	23	in	in	IN
40439	56	24	the	the	DT
40439	56	25	notes	note	NNS
40439	56	26	upon	upon	IN
40439	56	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	56	28	translation	translation	NN
40439	56	29	of	of	IN
40439	56	30	the	the	DT
40439	56	31	'	'	``
40439	56	32	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	56	33	'	'	''
40439	56	34	,	,	,
40439	56	35	and	and	CC
40439	56	36	of	of	IN
40439	56	37	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	56	38	in	in	IN
40439	56	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	56	40	'	'	``
40439	56	41	Études	étude	NNS
40439	56	42	sur	sur	FW
40439	56	43	le	le	NNP
40439	56	44	Timée	Timée	NNP
40439	56	45	'	'	''
40439	56	46	)	)	-RRB-
40439	56	47	the	the	DT
40439	56	48	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
40439	56	49	discussion	discussion	NN
40439	56	50	which	which	WDT
40439	56	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	56	52	has	have	VBZ
40439	56	53	received	receive	VBN
40439	56	54	in	in	IN
40439	56	55	the	the	DT
40439	56	56	two	two	CD
40439	56	57	recent	recent	JJ
40439	56	58	Dissertations	dissertation	NNS
40439	56	59	'	'	POS
40439	56	60	Ueber	Ueber	NNP
40439	56	61	die	die	NN
40439	56	62	kosmischen	kosmischen	NNP
40439	56	63	Systeme	Systeme	NNP
40439	56	64	der	der	IN
40439	56	65	Griechen	Griechen	NNP
40439	56	66	,	,	,
40439	56	67	'	'	''
40439	56	68	by	by	IN
40439	56	69	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	56	70	and	and	CC
40439	56	71	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	56	72	.	.	.
40439	57	1	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	57	2	has	have	VBZ
40439	57	3	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	57	4	,	,	,
40439	57	5	upon	upon	IN
40439	57	6	the	the	DT
40439	57	7	evidence	evidence	NN
40439	57	8	of	of	IN
40439	57	9	this	this	DT
40439	57	10	passage	passage	NN
40439	57	11	,	,	,
40439	57	12	supported	support	VBN
40439	57	13	by	by	IN
40439	57	14	other	other	JJ
40439	57	15	collateral	collateral	JJ
40439	57	16	proofs	proof	NNS
40439	57	17	,	,	,
40439	57	18	to	to	TO
40439	57	19	show	show	VB
40439	57	20	that	that	IN
40439	57	21	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	57	22	,	,	,
40439	57	23	towards	towards	IN
40439	57	24	the	the	DT
40439	57	25	close	close	NN
40439	57	26	of	of	IN
40439	57	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	57	28	life	life	NN
40439	57	29	,	,	,
40439	57	30	arrived	arrive	VBD
40439	57	31	at	at	IN
40439	57	32	a	a	DT
40439	57	33	belief	belief	NN
40439	57	34	,	,	,
40439	57	35	first	first	RB
40439	57	36	,	,	,
40439	57	37	in	in	IN
40439	57	38	the	the	DT
40439	57	39	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	57	40	of	of	IN
40439	57	41	the	the	DT
40439	57	42	earth	earth	NN
40439	57	43	round	round	IN
40439	57	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	57	45	own	own	JJ
40439	57	46	axis	axi	NNS
40439	57	47	,	,	,
40439	57	48	next	next	RB
40439	57	49	,	,	,
40439	57	50	at	at	IN
40439	57	51	the	the	DT
40439	57	52	double	double	JJ
40439	57	53	movement	movement	NN
40439	57	54	of	of	IN
40439	57	55	the	the	DT
40439	57	56	earth	earth	NN
40439	57	57	,	,	,
40439	57	58	both	both	DT
40439	57	59	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	57	60	and	and	CC
40439	57	61	translation	translation	NN
40439	57	62	,	,	,
40439	57	63	round	round	IN
40439	57	64	the	the	DT
40439	57	65	sun	sun	NN
40439	57	66	as	as	IN
40439	57	67	a	a	DT
40439	57	68	centre	centre	NN
40439	57	69	(	(	-LRB-
40439	57	70	that	that	RB
40439	57	71	is	is	RB
40439	57	72	,	,	,
40439	57	73	the	the	DT
40439	57	74	heliocentric	heliocentric	JJ
40439	57	75	or	or	CC
40439	57	76	Copernican	copernican	JJ
40439	57	77	system	system	NN
40439	57	78	)	)	-RRB-
40439	57	79	:	:	:
40439	57	80	that	that	IN
40439	57	81	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	57	82	was	be	VBD
40439	57	83	the	the	DT
40439	57	84	first	first	JJ
40439	57	85	to	to	TO
40439	57	86	make	make	VB
40439	57	87	this	this	DT
40439	57	88	discovery	discovery	NN
40439	57	89	,	,	,
40439	57	90	but	but	CC
40439	57	91	that	that	IN
40439	57	92	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	57	93	was	be	VBD
40439	57	94	compelled	compel	VBN
40439	57	95	to	to	TO
40439	57	96	announce	announce	VB
40439	57	97	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	57	98	in	in	IN
40439	57	99	terms	term	NNS
40439	57	100	intentionally	intentionally	RB
40439	57	101	equivocal	equivocal	JJ
40439	57	102	and	and	CC
40439	57	103	obscure	obscure	JJ
40439	57	104	,	,	,
40439	57	105	for	for	IN
40439	57	106	fear	fear	NN
40439	57	107	of	of	IN
40439	57	108	offending	offend	VBG
40439	57	109	the	the	DT
40439	57	110	religious	religious	JJ
40439	57	111	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
40439	57	112	of	of	IN
40439	57	113	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	57	114	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
40439	57	115	(	(	-LRB-
40439	57	116	'	'	``
40439	57	117	Die	die	VB
40439	57	118	kosmischen	kosmischen	''
40439	57	119	Systeme	Systeme	NNP
40439	57	120	der	der	IN
40439	57	121	Griechen	Griechen	NNP
40439	57	122	,	,	,
40439	57	123	von	von	NNP
40439	57	124	O.	O.	NNP
40439	57	125	F.	F.	NNP
40439	57	126	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	57	127	,	,	,
40439	57	128	'	'	''
40439	57	129	Berlin	Berlin	NNP
40439	57	130	,	,	,
40439	57	131	1851	1851	CD
40439	57	132	)	)	-RRB-
40439	57	133	.	.	.
40439	58	1	To	to	IN
40439	58	2	this	this	DT
40439	58	3	dissertation	dissertation	NN
40439	58	4	M.	M.	NNP
40439	58	5	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	58	6	--	--	:
40439	58	7	the	the	DT
40439	58	8	oldest	old	JJS
40439	58	9	as	as	RB
40439	58	10	well	well	RB
40439	58	11	as	as	IN
40439	58	12	the	the	DT
40439	58	13	ablest	able	JJS
40439	58	14	of	of	IN
40439	58	15	all	all	DT
40439	58	16	living	live	VBG
40439	58	17	philologists	philologist	NNS
40439	58	18	--	--	:
40439	58	19	has	have	VBZ
40439	58	20	composed	compose	VBN
40439	58	21	an	an	DT
40439	58	22	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
40439	58	23	reply	reply	NN
40439	58	24	,	,	,
40439	58	25	with	with	IN
40439	58	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	58	27	usual	usual	JJ
40439	58	28	fulness	fulness	NN
40439	58	29	of	of	IN
40439	58	30	illustrative	illustrative	JJ
40439	58	31	matter	matter	NN
40439	58	32	and	and	CC
40439	58	33	sobriety	sobriety	NN
40439	58	34	of	of	IN
40439	58	35	inference	inference	NN
40439	58	36	.	.	.
40439	59	1	Opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	59	2	previously	previously	RB
40439	59	3	delivered	deliver	VBN
40439	59	4	by	by	IN
40439	59	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	59	6	(	(	-LRB-
40439	59	7	in	in	IN
40439	59	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	59	9	early	early	JJ
40439	59	10	treatises	treatise	NNS
40439	59	11	on	on	IN
40439	59	12	the	the	DT
40439	59	13	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	59	14	and	and	CC
40439	59	15	Pythagoreian	pythagoreian	JJ
40439	59	16	philosophy	philosophy	NN
40439	59	17	)	)	-RRB-
40439	59	18	had	have	VBD
40439	59	19	been	be	VBN
40439	59	20	called	call	VBN
40439	59	21	in	in	IN
40439	59	22	question	question	NN
40439	59	23	by	by	IN
40439	59	24	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	59	25	:	:	:
40439	59	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	59	27	has	have	VBZ
40439	59	28	now	now	RB
40439	59	29	re	re	VBN
40439	59	30	-	-	VB
40439	59	31	asserted	assert	VBD
40439	59	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	59	33	and	and	CC
40439	59	34	defended	defend	VBD
40439	59	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	59	36	at	at	IN
40439	59	37	length	length	NN
40439	59	38	,	,	,
40439	59	39	maintaining	maintain	VBG
40439	59	40	that	that	IN
40439	59	41	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	59	42	always	always	RB
40439	59	43	held	hold	VBD
40439	59	44	the	the	DT
40439	59	45	earth	earth	NN
40439	59	46	to	to	TO
40439	59	47	be	be	VB
40439	59	48	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	59	49	and	and	CC
40439	59	50	the	the	DT
40439	59	51	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	59	52	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	59	53	rotatory	rotatory	NN
40439	59	54	--	--	:
40439	59	55	and	and	CC
40439	59	56	answering	answer	VBG
40439	59	57	or	or	CC
40439	59	58	extenuating	extenuate	VBG
40439	59	59	the	the	DT
40439	59	60	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	59	61	which	which	WDT
40439	59	62	point	point	VBP
40439	59	63	to	to	IN
40439	59	64	an	an	DT
40439	59	65	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	59	66	conclusion	conclusion	NN
40439	59	67	(	(	-LRB-
40439	59	68	'	'	''
40439	59	69	Untersuchungen	Untersuchungen	NNP
40439	59	70	über	über	NN
40439	59	71	das	das	NNP
40439	59	72	kosmische	kosmische	NN
40439	59	73	System	System	NNP
40439	59	74	des	des	FW
40439	59	75	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	59	76	,	,	,
40439	59	77	von	von	NNP
40439	59	78	August	August	NNP
40439	59	79	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	59	80	,	,	,
40439	59	81	'	'	''
40439	59	82	Berlin	Berlin	NNP
40439	59	83	,	,	,
40439	59	84	1852	1852	CD
40439	59	85	)	)	-RRB-
40439	59	86	.	.	.
40439	60	1	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	60	2	has	have	VBZ
40439	60	3	failed	fail	VBN
40439	60	4	in	in	IN
40439	60	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	60	6	purpose	purpose	NN
40439	60	7	of	of	IN
40439	60	8	proving	prove	VBG
40439	60	9	that	that	IN
40439	60	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	60	11	adopted	adopt	VBD
40439	60	12	either	either	CC
40439	60	13	of	of	IN
40439	60	14	the	the	DT
40439	60	15	two	two	CD
40439	60	16	above	above	RB
40439	60	17	-	-	HYPH
40439	60	18	mentioned	mention	VBN
40439	60	19	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
40439	60	20	--	--	:
40439	60	21	either	either	CC
40439	60	22	the	the	DT
40439	60	23	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	60	24	of	of	IN
40439	60	25	the	the	DT
40439	60	26	earth	earth	NN
40439	60	27	round	round	IN
40439	60	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	60	29	own	own	JJ
40439	60	30	axis	axis	NN
40439	60	31	,	,	,
40439	60	32	or	or	CC
40439	60	33	the	the	DT
40439	60	34	translation	translation	NN
40439	60	35	of	of	IN
40439	60	36	the	the	DT
40439	60	37	earth	earth	NN
40439	60	38	round	round	IN
40439	60	39	the	the	DT
40439	60	40	sun	sun	NN
40439	60	41	as	as	IN
40439	60	42	a	a	DT
40439	60	43	centre	centre	NN
40439	60	44	.	.	.
40439	61	1	On	on	IN
40439	61	2	both	both	PDT
40439	61	3	these	these	DT
40439	61	4	points	point	NNS
40439	61	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	61	6	concur	concur	VBP
40439	61	7	with	with	IN
40439	61	8	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	61	9	in	in	IN
40439	61	10	the	the	DT
40439	61	11	negative	negative	JJ
40439	61	12	view	view	NN
40439	61	13	.	.	.
40439	62	1	But	but	CC
40439	62	2	though	though	IN
40439	62	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	62	4	go	go	VBP
40439	62	5	along	along	RP
40439	62	6	with	with	IN
40439	62	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	62	8	reply	reply	NN
40439	62	9	as	as	IN
40439	62	10	to	to	IN
40439	62	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	62	12	negative	negative	JJ
40439	62	13	results	result	NNS
40439	62	14	,	,	,
40439	62	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	62	16	can	can	MD
40439	62	17	not	not	RB
40439	62	18	think	think	VB
40439	62	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	62	20	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
40439	62	21	in	in	IN
40439	62	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	62	23	positive	positive	JJ
40439	62	24	aspect	aspect	NN
40439	62	25	as	as	IN
40439	62	26	an	an	DT
40439	62	27	exposition	exposition	NN
40439	62	28	of	of	IN
40439	62	29	the	the	DT
40439	62	30	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	62	31	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	62	32	in	in	IN
40439	62	33	the	the	DT
40439	62	34	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	62	35	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	62	36	:	:	:
40439	62	37	nor	nor	CC
40439	62	38	can	can	MD
40439	62	39	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	62	40	admit	admit	VB
40439	62	41	that	that	IN
40439	62	42	the	the	DT
40439	62	43	main	main	JJ
40439	62	44	argument	argument	NN
40439	62	45	of	of	IN
40439	62	46	M.	M.	NNP
40439	62	47	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	62	48	's	's	POS
40439	62	49	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	62	50	is	be	VBZ
40439	62	51	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
40439	62	52	to	to	TO
40439	62	53	support	support	VB
40439	62	54	the	the	DT
40439	62	55	inference	inference	NN
40439	62	56	which	which	WDT
40439	62	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	62	58	rests	rest	VBZ
40439	62	59	upon	upon	IN
40439	62	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	62	61	.	.	.
40439	63	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
40439	63	2	,	,	,
40439	63	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	63	4	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	63	5	to	to	IN
40439	63	6	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	63	7	to	to	TO
40439	63	8	set	set	VB
40439	63	9	aside	aside	RB
40439	63	10	or	or	CC
40439	63	11	explain	explain	VB
40439	63	12	away	away	RB
40439	63	13	too	too	RB
40439	63	14	lightly	lightly	RB
40439	63	15	the	the	DT
40439	63	16	authority	authority	NN
40439	63	17	of	of	IN
40439	63	18	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	63	19	.	.	.
40439	64	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	64	2	agree	agree	VBP
40439	64	3	with	with	IN
40439	64	4	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
40439	64	5	of	of	IN
40439	64	6	Aphrodisias	Aphrodisias	NNP
40439	64	7	and	and	CC
40439	64	8	with	with	IN
40439	64	9	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	64	10	who	who	WP
40439	64	11	follows	follow	VBZ
40439	64	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	64	13	,	,	,
40439	64	14	in	in	IN
40439	64	15	pronouncing	pronounce	VBG
40439	64	16	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	64	17	to	to	TO
40439	64	18	be	be	VB
40439	64	19	a	a	DT
40439	64	20	good	good	JJ
40439	64	21	witness	witness	NN
40439	64	22	,	,	,
40439	64	23	when	when	WRB
40439	64	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	64	25	declares	declare	VBZ
40439	64	26	what	what	WP
40439	64	27	were	be	VBD
40439	64	28	the	the	DT
40439	64	29	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
40439	64	30	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	64	31	in	in	IN
40439	64	32	the	the	DT
40439	64	33	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	64	34	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	64	35	;	;	:
40439	64	36	though	though	IN
40439	64	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	64	38	think	think	VBP
40439	64	39	that	that	IN
40439	64	40	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	64	41	has	have	VBZ
40439	64	42	not	not	RB
40439	64	43	accurately	accurately	RB
40439	64	44	interpreted	interpret	VBN
40439	64	45	either	either	CC
40439	64	46	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	64	47	or	or	CC
40439	64	48	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	64	49	.	.	.
40439	65	1	The	the	DT
40439	65	2	capital	capital	NN
40439	65	3	argument	argument	NN
40439	65	4	of	of	IN
40439	65	5	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	65	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	65	7	as	as	IN
40439	65	8	follows	follow	VBZ
40439	65	9	:	:	:
40439	65	10	"	"	``
40439	65	11	The	the	DT
40439	65	12	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	65	13	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	65	14	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	65	15	,	,	,
40439	65	16	in	in	IN
40439	65	17	express	express	JJ
40439	65	18	and	and	CC
40439	65	19	unequivocal	unequivocal	JJ
40439	65	20	terms	term	NNS
40439	65	21	,	,	,
40439	65	22	the	the	DT
40439	65	23	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	65	24	of	of	IN
40439	65	25	the	the	DT
40439	65	26	outer	outer	JJ
40439	65	27	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	65	28	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	65	29	(	(	-LRB-
40439	65	30	the	the	DT
40439	65	31	sidereal	sidereal	NN
40439	65	32	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	65	33	or	or	CC
40439	65	34	Aplanes	Aplanes	NNP
40439	65	35	)	)	-RRB-
40439	65	36	in	in	IN
40439	65	37	twenty	twenty	CD
40439	65	38	-	-	HYPH
40439	65	39	four	four	CD
40439	65	40	hours	hour	NNS
40439	65	41	,	,	,
40439	65	42	as	as	IN
40439	65	43	bringing	bring	VBG
40439	65	44	about	about	RP
40439	65	45	and	and	CC
40439	65	46	determining	determine	VBG
40439	65	47	the	the	DT
40439	65	48	succession	succession	NN
40439	65	49	of	of	IN
40439	65	50	day	day	NN
40439	65	51	and	and	CC
40439	65	52	night	night	NN
40439	65	53	.	.	.
40439	66	1	Whoever	whoever	WP
40439	66	2	believes	believe	VBZ
40439	66	3	this	this	DT
40439	66	4	can	can	MD
40439	66	5	not	not	RB
40439	66	6	at	at	IN
40439	66	7	the	the	DT
40439	66	8	same	same	JJ
40439	66	9	time	time	NN
40439	66	10	believe	believe	VBP
40439	66	11	that	that	IN
40439	66	12	the	the	DT
40439	66	13	earth	earth	NN
40439	66	14	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	66	15	round	round	VB
40439	66	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	66	17	own	own	JJ
40439	66	18	axis	axis	NN
40439	66	19	in	in	IN
40439	66	20	twenty	twenty	CD
40439	66	21	-	-	HYPH
40439	66	22	four	four	CD
40439	66	23	hours	hour	NNS
40439	66	24	,	,	,
40439	66	25	and	and	CC
40439	66	26	that	that	IN
40439	66	27	the	the	DT
40439	66	28	succession	succession	NN
40439	66	29	of	of	IN
40439	66	30	day	day	NN
40439	66	31	and	and	CC
40439	66	32	night	night	NN
40439	66	33	is	be	VBZ
40439	66	34	determined	determine	VBN
40439	66	35	thereby	thereby	RB
40439	66	36	.	.	.
40439	67	1	The	the	DT
40439	67	2	one	one	CD
40439	67	3	of	of	IN
40439	67	4	these	these	DT
40439	67	5	two	two	CD
40439	67	6	affirmations	affirmation	NNS
40439	67	7	excludes	exclude	VBZ
40439	67	8	the	the	DT
40439	67	9	other	other	JJ
40439	67	10	;	;	:
40439	67	11	and	and	CC
40439	67	12	,	,	,
40439	67	13	as	as	IN
40439	67	14	the	the	DT
40439	67	15	first	first	JJ
40439	67	16	of	of	IN
40439	67	17	the	the	DT
40439	67	18	two	two	CD
40439	67	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	67	20	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	67	21	,	,	,
40439	67	22	beyond	beyond	IN
40439	67	23	all	all	DT
40439	67	24	possibility	possibility	NN
40439	67	25	of	of	IN
40439	67	26	doubt	doubt	NN
40439	67	27	,	,	,
40439	67	28	in	in	IN
40439	67	29	the	the	DT
40439	67	30	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	67	31	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	67	32	,	,	,
40439	67	33	so	so	RB
40439	67	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	67	35	may	may	MD
40439	67	36	be	be	VB
40439	67	37	sure	sure	JJ
40439	67	38	that	that	IN
40439	67	39	the	the	DT
40439	67	40	second	second	JJ
40439	67	41	of	of	IN
40439	67	42	the	the	DT
40439	67	43	two	two	CD
40439	67	44	can	can	MD
40439	67	45	not	not	RB
40439	67	46	be	be	VB
40439	67	47	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	67	48	in	in	IN
40439	67	49	that	that	DT
40439	67	50	same	same	JJ
40439	67	51	discourse	discourse	NN
40439	67	52	.	.	.
40439	68	1	If	if	IN
40439	68	2	any	any	DT
40439	68	3	passage	passage	NN
40439	68	4	therein	therein	RB
40439	68	5	seems	seem	VBZ
40439	68	6	to	to	TO
40439	68	7	countenance	countenance	VB
40439	68	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	68	9	,	,	,
40439	68	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	68	11	must	must	MD
40439	68	12	look	look	VB
40439	68	13	for	for	IN
40439	68	14	some	some	DT
40439	68	15	other	other	JJ
40439	68	16	mode	mode	NN
40439	68	17	of	of	IN
40439	68	18	interpreting	interpret	VBG
40439	68	19	the	the	DT
40439	68	20	passage	passage	NN
40439	68	21	.	.	.
40439	68	22	"	"	''
40439	69	1	This	this	DT
40439	69	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	69	3	the	the	DT
40439	69	4	main	main	JJ
40439	69	5	argument	argument	NN
40439	69	6	of	of	IN
40439	69	7	M.	M.	NNP
40439	69	8	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	69	9	,	,	,
40439	69	10	and	and	CC
40439	69	11	also	also	RB
40439	69	12	of	of	IN
40439	69	13	Messrs.	Messrs.	NNP
40439	69	14	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	69	15	and	and	CC
40439	69	16	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	69	17	.	.	.
40439	70	1	The	the	DT
40439	70	2	latter	latter	JJ
40439	70	3	protests	protest	NNS
40439	70	4	against	against	IN
40439	70	5	the	the	DT
40439	70	6	idea	idea	NN
40439	70	7	of	of	IN
40439	70	8	imputing	impute	VBG
40439	70	9	to	to	IN
40439	70	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	70	11	"	"	''
40439	70	12	un	un	NNP
40439	70	13	mélange	mélange	NNP
40439	70	14	monstrueux	monstrueux	NNP
40439	70	15	de	de	IN
40439	70	16	deux	deux	NNP
40439	70	17	systêmes	systêmes	NNP
40439	70	18	incompatibles	incompatible	NNS
40439	70	19	"	"	''
40439	70	20	(	(	-LRB-
40439	70	21	Études	étude	VBZ
40439	70	22	sur	sur	FW
40439	70	23	le	le	NNP
40439	70	24	Timée	Timée	NNP
40439	70	25	,	,	,
40439	70	26	vol	vol	NNP
40439	70	27	.	.	.
40439	71	1	ii	ii	LS
40439	71	2	.	.	.
40439	72	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	72	2	86	86	CD
40439	72	3	-	-	SYM
40439	72	4	88	88	CD
40439	72	5	)	)	-RRB-
40439	72	6	.	.	.
40439	73	1	As	as	IN
40439	73	2	applied	apply	VBN
40439	73	3	to	to	IN
40439	73	4	any	any	DT
40439	73	5	person	person	NN
40439	73	6	educated	educate	VBN
40439	73	7	in	in	IN
40439	73	8	the	the	DT
40439	73	9	modern	modern	JJ
40439	73	10	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	73	11	,	,	,
40439	73	12	the	the	DT
40439	73	13	argument	argument	NN
40439	73	14	is	be	VBZ
40439	73	15	irresistible	irresistible	JJ
40439	73	16	.	.	.
40439	74	1	But	but	CC
40439	74	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	74	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	74	4	equally	equally	RB
40439	74	5	irresistible	irresistible	JJ
40439	74	6	when	when	WRB
40439	74	7	applied	apply	VBN
40439	74	8	to	to	IN
40439	74	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	74	10	and	and	CC
40439	74	11	to	to	IN
40439	74	12	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	74	13	's	's	POS
40439	74	14	time	time	NN
40439	74	15	?	?	.
40439	75	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	75	2	think	think	VBP
40439	75	3	not	not	RB
40439	75	4	.	.	.
40439	76	1	The	the	DT
40439	76	2	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	76	3	which	which	WDT
40439	76	4	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	76	5	so	so	RB
40439	76	6	glaring	glare	VBG
40439	76	7	at	at	IN
40439	76	8	present	present	NN
40439	76	9	,	,	,
40439	76	10	did	do	VBD
40439	76	11	not	not	RB
40439	76	12	suggest	suggest	VB
40439	76	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	76	14	to	to	IN
40439	76	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	76	16	or	or	CC
40439	76	17	to	to	IN
40439	76	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	76	19	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
40439	76	20	.	.	.
40439	77	1	To	to	TO
40439	77	2	prove	prove	VB
40439	77	3	this	this	DT
40439	77	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	77	5	have	have	VBP
40439	77	6	only	only	RB
40439	77	7	to	to	TO
40439	77	8	look	look	VB
40439	77	9	at	at	IN
40439	77	10	the	the	DT
40439	77	11	reasoning	reasoning	NN
40439	77	12	of	of	IN
40439	77	13	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	77	14	,	,	,
40439	77	15	who	who	WP
40439	77	16	(	(	-LRB-
40439	77	17	in	in	IN
40439	77	18	the	the	DT
40439	77	19	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	77	20	De	De	NNP
40439	77	21	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	77	22	,	,	,
40439	77	23	ii	ii	NNP
40439	77	24	.	.	.
40439	78	1	13	13	CD
40439	78	2	-	-	SYM
40439	78	3	14	14	CD
40439	78	4	,	,	,
40439	78	5	p.	p.	NN
40439	78	6	293	293	CD
40439	78	7	.	.	.
40439	78	8	b.	b.	NNP
40439	79	1	30	30	CD
40439	79	2	,	,	,
40439	79	3	296	296	CD
40439	79	4	.	.	.
40439	79	5	a.	a.	NN
40439	80	1	25	25	CD
40439	80	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	80	3	notices	notice	NNS
40439	80	4	and	and	CC
40439	80	5	controverts	controvert	VBZ
40439	80	6	the	the	DT
40439	80	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	80	8	of	of	IN
40439	80	9	the	the	DT
40439	80	10	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	80	11	of	of	IN
40439	80	12	the	the	DT
40439	80	13	earth	earth	NN
40439	80	14	,	,	,
40439	80	15	with	with	IN
40439	80	16	express	express	JJ
40439	80	17	reference	reference	NN
40439	80	18	to	to	IN
40439	80	19	the	the	DT
40439	80	20	followers	follower	NNS
40439	80	21	of	of	IN
40439	80	22	the	the	DT
40439	80	23	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	80	24	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	80	25	--	--	:
40439	80	26	and	and	CC
40439	80	27	who	who	WP
40439	80	28	(	(	-LRB-
40439	80	29	if	if	IN
40439	80	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	80	31	follow	follow	VBP
40439	80	32	the	the	DT
40439	80	33	view	view	NN
40439	80	34	of	of	IN
40439	80	35	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	80	36	)	)	-RRB-
40439	80	37	imputes	impute	VBZ
40439	80	38	this	this	DT
40439	80	39	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	80	40	with	with	IN
40439	80	41	wilful	wilful	JJ
40439	80	42	falsehood	falsehood	NN
40439	80	43	to	to	IN
40439	80	44	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	80	45	,	,	,
40439	80	46	for	for	IN
40439	80	47	the	the	DT
40439	80	48	purpose	purpose	NN
40439	80	49	of	of	IN
40439	80	50	contemptuously	contemptuously	RB
40439	80	51	refuting	refute	VBG
40439	80	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	80	53	"	"	``
40439	80	54	pour	pour	VBP
40439	80	55	se	se	FW
40439	80	56	donner	donner	NNP
40439	80	57	le	le	NNP
40439	80	58	plaisir	plaisir	NNP
40439	80	59	de	de	NNP
40439	80	60	la	la	NNP
40439	80	61	réfuter	réfuter	NNP
40439	80	62	avec	avec	FW
40439	80	63	dédain	dédain	NN
40439	80	64	.	.	.
40439	80	65	"	"	''
40439	81	1	Granting	grant	VBG
40439	81	2	the	the	DT
40439	81	3	view	view	NN
40439	81	4	of	of	IN
40439	81	5	M.	M.	NNP
40439	81	6	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	81	7	(	(	-LRB-
40439	81	8	still	still	RB
40439	81	9	more	more	JJR
40439	81	10	that	that	DT
40439	81	11	of	of	IN
40439	81	12	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	81	13	)	)	-RRB-
40439	81	14	to	to	TO
40439	81	15	be	be	VB
40439	81	16	correct	correct	JJ
40439	81	17	,	,	,
40439	81	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	81	19	should	should	MD
40439	81	20	find	find	VB
40439	81	21	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	81	22	arguing	argue	VBG
40439	81	23	thus:--"Plato	thus:--"Plato	:
40439	81	24	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	81	25	the	the	DT
40439	81	26	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	81	27	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	81	28	of	of	IN
40439	81	29	the	the	DT
40439	81	30	earth	earth	NN
40439	81	31	round	round	IN
40439	81	32	the	the	DT
40439	81	33	centre	centre	NN
40439	81	34	of	of	IN
40439	81	35	the	the	DT
40439	81	36	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	81	37	axis	axis	NN
40439	81	38	.	.	.
40439	82	1	This	this	DT
40439	82	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	82	3	both	both	CC
40439	82	4	incredible	incredible	JJ
40439	82	5	,	,	,
40439	82	6	and	and	CC
40439	82	7	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
40439	82	8	with	with	IN
40439	82	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	82	10	own	own	JJ
40439	82	11	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	82	12	affirmation	affirmation	NN
40439	82	13	that	that	IN
40439	82	14	the	the	DT
40439	82	15	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	82	16	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	82	17	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	82	18	in	in	IN
40439	82	19	twenty	twenty	CD
40439	82	20	-	-	HYPH
40439	82	21	four	four	CD
40439	82	22	hours	hour	NNS
40439	82	23	.	.	.
40439	83	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	83	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	83	3	a	a	DT
40439	83	4	glaring	glaring	JJ
40439	83	5	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
40439	83	6	that	that	IN
40439	83	7	the	the	DT
40439	83	8	same	same	JJ
40439	83	9	author	author	NN
40439	83	10	should	should	MD
40439	83	11	affirm	affirm	VB
40439	83	12	both	both	CC
40439	83	13	the	the	DT
40439	83	14	one	one	NN
40439	83	15	and	and	CC
40439	83	16	the	the	DT
40439	83	17	other	other	JJ
40439	83	18	.	.	.
40439	83	19	"	"	''
40439	84	1	Such	such	JJ
40439	84	2	would	would	MD
40439	84	3	have	have	VB
40439	84	4	been	be	VBN
40439	84	5	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	84	6	's	's	POS
40439	84	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
40439	84	8	,	,	,
40439	84	9	on	on	IN
40439	84	10	the	the	DT
40439	84	11	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
40439	84	12	which	which	WDT
40439	84	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	84	14	am	be	VBP
40439	84	15	considering	consider	VBG
40439	84	16	;	;	:
40439	84	17	but	but	CC
40439	84	18	when	when	WRB
40439	84	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	84	20	turn	turn	VBP
40439	84	21	to	to	IN
40439	84	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	84	23	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	84	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	84	25	find	find	VBP
40439	84	26	that	that	IN
40439	84	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	84	28	does	do	VBZ
40439	84	29	not	not	RB
40439	84	30	employ	employ	VB
40439	84	31	this	this	DT
40439	84	32	argument	argument	NN
40439	84	33	at	at	RB
40439	84	34	all	all	RB
40439	84	35	.	.	.
40439	85	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	85	2	contests	contest	VBZ
40439	85	3	the	the	DT
40439	85	4	alleged	allege	VBN
40439	85	5	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	85	6	of	of	IN
40439	85	7	the	the	DT
40439	85	8	earth	earth	NN
40439	85	9	upon	upon	IN
40439	85	10	totally	totally	RB
40439	85	11	different	different	JJ
40439	85	12	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	85	13	--	--	:
40439	85	14	chiefly	chiefly	RB
40439	85	15	on	on	IN
40439	85	16	the	the	DT
40439	85	17	ground	ground	NN
40439	85	18	that	that	IN
40439	85	19	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	85	20	motion	motion	NN
40439	85	21	is	be	VBZ
40439	85	22	not	not	RB
40439	85	23	natural	natural	JJ
40439	85	24	to	to	IN
40439	85	25	the	the	DT
40439	85	26	earth	earth	NN
40439	85	27	,	,	,
40439	85	28	that	that	IN
40439	85	29	the	the	DT
40439	85	30	kind	kind	NN
40439	85	31	of	of	IN
40439	85	32	motion	motion	NN
40439	85	33	natural	natural	JJ
40439	85	34	to	to	IN
40439	85	35	the	the	DT
40439	85	36	earth	earth	NN
40439	85	37	is	be	VBZ
40439	85	38	rectilineal	rectilineal	JJ
40439	85	39	,	,	,
40439	85	40	towards	towards	IN
40439	85	41	the	the	DT
40439	85	42	centre	centre	NN
40439	85	43	;	;	:
40439	85	44	and	and	CC
40439	85	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	85	46	adds	add	VBZ
40439	85	47	various	various	JJ
40439	85	48	corollaries	corollary	NNS
40439	85	49	flowing	flow	VBG
40439	85	50	from	from	IN
40439	85	51	this	this	DT
40439	85	52	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	85	53	which	which	WDT
40439	85	54	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	85	55	shall	shall	MD
40439	85	56	not	not	RB
40439	85	57	now	now	RB
40439	85	58	consider	consider	VB
40439	85	59	.	.	.
40439	86	1	At	at	IN
40439	86	2	the	the	DT
40439	86	3	close	close	NN
40439	86	4	of	of	IN
40439	86	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	86	6	refutation	refutation	NN
40439	86	7	,	,	,
40439	86	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	86	9	states	state	VBZ
40439	86	10	in	in	IN
40439	86	11	general	general	JJ
40439	86	12	terms	term	NNS
40439	86	13	that	that	IN
40439	86	14	the	the	DT
40439	86	15	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	86	16	appearances	appearance	NNS
40439	86	17	,	,	,
40439	86	18	as	as	IN
40439	86	19	observed	observe	VBN
40439	86	20	by	by	IN
40439	86	21	scientific	scientific	JJ
40439	86	22	men	man	NNS
40439	86	23	,	,	,
40439	86	24	coincided	coincide	VBN
40439	86	25	with	with	IN
40439	86	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	86	27	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	86	28	.	.	.
40439	87	1	Hence	hence	RB
40439	87	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	87	3	may	may	MD
40439	87	4	plainly	plainly	RB
40439	87	5	see	see	VB
40439	87	6	that	that	IN
40439	87	7	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	87	8	probably	probably	RB
40439	87	9	did	do	VBD
40439	87	10	not	not	RB
40439	87	11	see	see	VB
40439	87	12	the	the	DT
40439	87	13	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	87	14	,	,	,
40439	87	15	supposed	suppose	VBN
40439	87	16	to	to	TO
40439	87	17	be	be	VB
40439	87	18	so	so	RB
40439	87	19	glaring	glare	VBG
40439	87	20	,	,	,
40439	87	21	upon	upon	IN
40439	87	22	which	which	WDT
40439	87	23	M.	M.	NNP
40439	87	24	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	87	25	's	's	POS
40439	87	26	argument	argument	NN
40439	87	27	is	be	VBZ
40439	87	28	founded	found	VBN
40439	87	29	.	.	.
40439	88	1	To	to	TO
40439	88	2	say	say	VB
40439	88	3	the	the	DT
40439	88	4	least	least	JJS
40439	88	5	,	,	,
40439	88	6	even	even	RB
40439	88	7	if	if	IN
40439	88	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	88	9	saw	see	VBD
40439	88	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	88	11	,	,	,
40439	88	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	88	13	did	do	VBD
40439	88	14	not	not	RB
40439	88	15	consider	consider	VB
40439	88	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	88	17	as	as	IN
40439	88	18	glaring	glaring	JJ
40439	88	19	and	and	CC
40439	88	20	decisive	decisive	JJ
40439	88	21	.	.	.
40439	89	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	89	2	would	would	MD
40439	89	3	have	have	VB
40439	89	4	put	put	VBN
40439	89	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	89	6	in	in	IN
40439	89	7	the	the	DT
40439	89	8	foreground	foreground	NN
40439	89	9	of	of	IN
40439	89	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	89	11	refutation	refutation	NN
40439	89	12	,	,	,
40439	89	13	if	if	IN
40439	89	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	89	15	had	have	VBD
40439	89	16	detected	detect	VBN
40439	89	17	the	the	DT
40439	89	18	gross	gross	JJ
40439	89	19	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	89	20	upon	upon	IN
40439	89	21	which	which	WDT
40439	89	22	M.	M.	NNP
40439	89	23	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	89	24	insists	insist	VBZ
40439	89	25	.	.	.
40439	90	1	But	but	CC
40439	90	2	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	90	3	does	do	VBZ
40439	90	4	not	not	RB
40439	90	5	stand	stand	VB
40439	90	6	alone	alone	RB
40439	90	7	in	in	IN
40439	90	8	this	this	DT
40439	90	9	dulness	dulness	NN
40439	90	10	of	of	IN
40439	90	11	vision	vision	NN
40439	90	12	.	.	.
40439	91	1	Among	among	IN
40439	91	2	the	the	DT
40439	91	3	various	various	JJ
40439	91	4	commentators	commentator	NNS
40439	91	5	,	,	,
40439	91	6	ancient	ancient	JJ
40439	91	7	and	and	CC
40439	91	8	modern	modern	JJ
40439	91	9	,	,	,
40439	91	10	who	who	WP
40439	91	11	follow	follow	VBP
40439	91	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	91	13	,	,	,
40439	91	14	discussing	discuss	VBG
40439	91	15	the	the	DT
40439	91	16	question	question	NN
40439	91	17	now	now	RB
40439	91	18	before	before	IN
40439	91	19	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	91	20	,	,	,
40439	91	21	not	not	RB
40439	91	22	one	one	CD
40439	91	23	takes	take	VBZ
40439	91	24	notice	notice	NN
40439	91	25	of	of	IN
40439	91	26	M.	M.	NNP
40439	91	27	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	91	28	's	's	POS
40439	91	29	argument	argument	NN
40439	91	30	.	.	.
40439	92	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	92	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	92	3	certifies	certify	VBZ
40439	92	4	to	to	IN
40439	92	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	92	6	this	this	DT
40439	92	7	fact	fact	NN
40439	92	8	,	,	,
40439	92	9	claiming	claim	VBG
40439	92	10	the	the	DT
40439	92	11	argument	argument	NN
40439	92	12	as	as	IN
40439	92	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	92	14	own	own	JJ
40439	92	15	,	,	,
40439	92	16	and	and	CC
40439	92	17	expressing	express	VBG
40439	92	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	92	19	astonishment	astonishment	NN
40439	92	20	that	that	IN
40439	92	21	all	all	PDT
40439	92	22	the	the	DT
40439	92	23	previous	previous	JJ
40439	92	24	critics	critic	NNS
40439	92	25	had	have	VBD
40439	92	26	passed	pass	VBN
40439	92	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	92	28	over	over	RP
40439	92	29	,	,	,
40439	92	30	though	though	IN
40439	92	31	employing	employ	VBG
40439	92	32	other	other	JJ
40439	92	33	reasons	reason	NNS
40439	92	34	much	much	RB
40439	92	35	weaker	weak	JJR
40439	92	36	to	to	TO
40439	92	37	prove	prove	VB
40439	92	38	the	the	DT
40439	92	39	same	same	JJ
40439	92	40	point	point	NN
40439	92	41	.	.	.
40439	93	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	93	2	read	read	VBP
40439	93	3	in	in	IN
40439	93	4	M.	M.	NNP
40439	93	5	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	93	6	's	's	POS
40439	93	7	second	second	JJ
40439	93	8	'	'	``
40439	93	9	Commentatio	Commentatio	NNP
40439	93	10	de	de	IN
40439	93	11	Platonico	Platonico	NNP
40439	93	12	Systemate	Systemate	NNP
40439	93	13	Coelestium	Coelestium	NNP
40439	93	14	Globorum	Globorum	NNP
40439	93	15	et	et	FW
40439	93	16	de	de	FW
40439	93	17	Verâ	Verâ	NNP
40439	93	18	Indole	Indole	NNP
40439	93	19	Astronomiæ	Astronomiæ	NNP
40439	93	20	Philolaicæ	Philolaicæ	NNP
40439	93	21	,	,	,
40439	93	22	'	'	''
40439	93	23	Heidelberg	Heidelberg	NNP
40439	93	24	,	,	,
40439	93	25	1810	1810	CD
40439	93	26	,	,	,
40439	93	27	p.	p.	NN
40439	93	28	9	9	CD
40439	93	29	,	,	,
40439	93	30	the	the	DT
40439	93	31	following	follow	VBG
40439	93	32	words:--	words:--	:
40439	93	33	"	"	``
40439	93	34	Non	Non	NNP
40439	93	35	moveri	moveri	NN
40439	93	36	tellurem	tellurem	NN
40439	93	37	,	,	,
40439	93	38	Proclus	Proclus	NNP
40439	93	39	et	et	FW
40439	93	40	Simplicius	Simplicius	JJR
40439	93	41	ostendunt	ostendunt	NN
40439	93	42	ex	ex	NNP
40439	93	43	Phædone	Phædone	NNP
40439	93	44	.	.	.
40439	94	1	Parum	Parum	NNP
40439	94	2	firmum	firmum	NN
40439	94	3	tamen	taman	NNS
40439	94	4	argumentum	argumentum	NN
40439	94	5	est	est	VBD
40439	94	6	ex	ex	NNP
40439	94	7	Phædone	Phædone	NNP
40439	94	8	ductum	ductum	NN
40439	94	9	ad	ad	NN
40439	94	10	interpretandum	interpretandum	NN
40439	94	11	Timæi	Timæi	NNP
40439	94	12	locum	locum	NNP
40439	94	13	:	:	:
40439	94	14	nec	nec	NNP
40439	94	15	melius	melius	NNP
40439	94	16	alterum	alterum	NNP
40439	94	17	,	,	,
40439	94	18	quod	quod	NN
40439	94	19	Locrus	Locrus	NNP
40439	94	20	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	94	21	,	,	,
40439	94	22	quem	quem	NN
40439	94	23	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	94	24	sequi	sequi	NN
40439	94	25	putabatur	putabatur	NNP
40439	94	26	,	,	,
40439	94	27	terram	terram	NNP
40439	94	28	stare	stare	NNP
40439	94	29	affirmat	affirmat	NN
40439	94	30	:	:	:
40439	94	31	quia	quia	NNP
40439	94	32	,	,	,
40439	94	33	ut	ut	NNP
40439	94	34	nuper	nuper	NNP
40439	94	35	explicuimus	explicuimus	NNP
40439	94	36	,	,	,
40439	94	37	non	non	AFX
40439	94	38	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	94	39	ex	ex	NNP
40439	94	40	Locro	Locro	NNP
40439	94	41	,	,	,
40439	94	42	sed	sed	JJ
40439	94	43	personatus	personatus	NN
40439	94	44	Locrus	Locrus	NNP
40439	94	45	ex	ex	NNP
40439	94	46	Platone	Platone	NNP
40439	94	47	,	,	,
40439	94	48	sua	sua	NN
40439	94	49	compilavit	compilavit	NN
40439	94	50	.	.	.
40439	95	1	At	at	IN
40439	95	2	omnium	omnium	NN
40439	95	3	firmissionum	firmissionum	NN
40439	95	4	et	et	NNP
40439	95	5	certissimum	certissimum	JJ
40439	95	6	argumentum	argumentum	NN
40439	95	7	ex	ex	NNP
40439	95	8	ipso	ipso	NNP
40439	95	9	nostro	nostro	NNP
40439	95	10	dialogo	dialogo	VBD
40439	95	11	sumptum	sumptum	NNP
40439	95	12	,	,	,
40439	95	13	_	_	NNP
40439	95	14	adhuc	adhuc	NN
40439	95	15	,	,	,
40439	95	16	quod	quod	NNP
40439	95	17	jure	jure	NNP
40439	95	18	mirere	mirere	NNP
40439	95	19	,	,	,
40439	95	20	nemo	nemo	NNP
40439	95	21	reperit	reperit	NNP
40439	95	22	_	_	NNP
40439	95	23	.	.	.
40439	96	1	Etenim	Etenim	NNP
40439	96	2	,	,	,
40439	96	3	quum	quum	NN
40439	96	4	,	,	,
40439	96	5	paulo	paulo	NNP
40439	96	6	supra	supra	NNP
40439	96	7	,	,	,
40439	96	8	orbem	orbem	NNP
40439	96	9	stellarum	stellarum	NNP
40439	96	10	fixarum	fixarum	NNP
40439	96	11	,	,	,
40439	96	12	quem	quem	NNP
40439	96	13	Græci	Græci	NNP
40439	96	14	[	[	-LRB-
40439	96	15	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	96	16	:	:	:
40439	96	17	a)planê=	a)planê=	JJ
40439	96	18	]	]	-RRB-
40439	96	19	appellant	appellant	NNP
40439	96	20	,	,	,
40439	96	21	dextrorsum	dextrorsum	NNP
40439	96	22	ferri	ferri	NNP
40439	96	23	quotidiano	quotidiano	NNP
40439	96	24	motu	motu	NNP
40439	96	25	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	96	26	statuebat	statuebat	NN
40439	96	27	,	,	,
40439	96	28	non	non	AFX
40439	96	29	poterat	poterat	NNP
40439	96	30	ullum	ullum	NNP
40439	96	31	terræ	terræ	NNP
40439	96	32	motum	motum	NNP
40439	96	33	admittere	admittere	NNP
40439	96	34	;	;	:
40439	96	35	quia	quia	NNP
40439	96	36	,	,	,
40439	96	37	_	_	NNP
40439	96	38	qui	qui	NNP
40439	96	39	hunc	hunc	NNP
40439	96	40	admittit	admittit	NNP
40439	96	41	,	,	,
40439	96	42	illum	illum	NNP
40439	96	43	non	non	NNP
40439	96	44	tollere	tollere	JJ
40439	96	45	non	non	AFX
40439	96	46	potest	potest	NNP
40439	96	47	_	_	NNP
40439	96	48	.	.	.
40439	96	49	"	"	''
40439	97	1	(	(	-LRB-
40439	97	2	This	this	DT
40439	97	3	passage	passage	NN
40439	97	4	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	97	5	again	again	RB
40439	97	6	cited	cite	VBN
40439	97	7	by	by	IN
40439	97	8	M.	M.	NNP
40439	97	9	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	97	10	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	97	11	in	in	IN
40439	97	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	97	13	more	more	RBR
40439	97	14	recent	recent	JJ
40439	97	15	dissertation	dissertation	NN
40439	97	16	'	'	''
40439	97	17	Untersuchungen	Untersuchungen	NNP
40439	97	18	über	über	NN
40439	97	19	das	das	NNP
40439	97	20	kosmische	kosmische	NN
40439	97	21	System	System	NNP
40439	97	22	des	des	FW
40439	97	23	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	97	24	,	,	,
40439	97	25	'	'	''
40439	97	26	p.	p.	NN
40439	97	27	11	11	CD
40439	97	28	)	)	-RRB-
40439	97	29	.	.	.
40439	98	1	The	the	DT
40439	98	2	writers	writer	NNS
40439	98	3	named	name	VBN
40439	98	4	(	(	-LRB-
40439	98	5	p.	p.	NN
40439	98	6	7	7	CD
40439	98	7	)	)	-RRB-
40439	98	8	as	as	IN
40439	98	9	having	have	VBG
40439	98	10	discussed	discuss	VBN
40439	98	11	the	the	DT
40439	98	12	question	question	NN
40439	98	13	,	,	,
40439	98	14	omitting	omit	VBG
40439	98	15	or	or	CC
40439	98	16	disregarding	disregard	VBG
40439	98	17	this	this	DT
40439	98	18	most	most	RBS
40439	98	19	cogent	cogent	JJ
40439	98	20	argument	argument	NN
40439	98	21	,	,	,
40439	98	22	are	be	VBP
40439	98	23	names	name	NNS
40439	98	24	extending	extend	VBG
40439	98	25	from	from	IN
40439	98	26	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	98	27	down	down	RP
40439	98	28	to	to	IN
40439	98	29	Ruhnken	Ruhnken	NNP
40439	98	30	and	and	CC
40439	98	31	Ideler	Ideler	NNP
40439	98	32	.	.	.
40439	99	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	99	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	99	3	honourable	honourable	JJ
40439	99	4	to	to	IN
40439	99	5	the	the	DT
40439	99	6	penetration	penetration	NN
40439	99	7	of	of	IN
40439	99	8	M.	M.	NNP
40439	99	9	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	99	10	that	that	IN
40439	99	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	99	12	should	should	MD
40439	99	13	have	have	VB
40439	99	14	pointed	point	VBN
40439	99	15	out	out	RP
40439	99	16	,	,	,
40439	99	17	what	what	WP
40439	99	18	so	so	RB
40439	99	19	many	many	JJ
40439	99	20	previous	previous	JJ
40439	99	21	critics	critic	NNS
40439	99	22	had	have	VBD
40439	99	23	overlooked	overlook	VBN
40439	99	24	,	,	,
40439	99	25	that	that	IN
40439	99	26	these	these	DT
40439	99	27	two	two	CD
40439	99	28	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	99	29	are	be	VBP
40439	99	30	scientifically	scientifically	RB
40439	99	31	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
40439	99	32	.	.	.
40439	100	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	100	2	wonders	wonder	VBZ
40439	100	3	,	,	,
40439	100	4	and	and	CC
40439	100	5	there	there	EX
40439	100	6	may	may	MD
40439	100	7	be	be	VB
40439	100	8	good	good	JJ
40439	100	9	ground	ground	NN
40439	100	10	for	for	IN
40439	100	11	wondering	wondering	NN
40439	100	12	,	,	,
40439	100	13	how	how	WRB
40439	100	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	100	15	happened	happen	VBD
40439	100	16	that	that	IN
40439	100	17	none	none	NN
40439	100	18	of	of	IN
40439	100	19	these	these	DT
40439	100	20	previous	previous	JJ
40439	100	21	writers	writer	NNS
40439	100	22	were	be	VBD
40439	100	23	aware	aware	JJ
40439	100	24	of	of	IN
40439	100	25	the	the	DT
40439	100	26	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	100	27	.	.	.
40439	101	1	But	but	CC
40439	101	2	the	the	DT
40439	101	3	fact	fact	NN
40439	101	4	that	that	IN
40439	101	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	101	6	did	do	VBD
40439	101	7	not	not	RB
40439	101	8	occur	occur	VB
40439	101	9	to	to	IN
40439	101	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	101	11	,	,	,
40439	101	12	is	be	VBZ
40439	101	13	not	not	RB
40439	101	14	the	the	DT
40439	101	15	less	less	RBR
40439	101	16	certain	certain	JJ
40439	101	17	,	,	,
40439	101	18	and	and	CC
40439	101	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	101	20	of	of	IN
40439	101	21	the	the	DT
40439	101	22	greatest	great	JJS
40439	101	23	moment	moment	NN
40439	101	24	in	in	IN
40439	101	25	reference	reference	NN
40439	101	26	to	to	IN
40439	101	27	the	the	DT
40439	101	28	question	question	NN
40439	101	29	now	now	RB
40439	101	30	under	under	IN
40439	101	31	debate	debate	NN
40439	101	32	;	;	:
40439	101	33	for	for	IN
40439	101	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	101	35	are	be	VBP
40439	101	36	not	not	RB
40439	101	37	now	now	RB
40439	101	38	inquiring	inquire	VBG
40439	101	39	what	what	WP
40439	101	40	is	be	VBZ
40439	101	41	or	or	CC
40439	101	42	is	be	VBZ
40439	101	43	not	not	RB
40439	101	44	scientifically	scientifically	RB
40439	101	45	true	true	JJ
40439	101	46	or	or	CC
40439	101	47	consistent	consistent	JJ
40439	101	48	,	,	,
40439	101	49	but	but	CC
40439	101	50	what	what	WP
40439	101	51	were	be	VBD
40439	101	52	the	the	DT
40439	101	53	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	101	54	of	of	IN
40439	101	55	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	101	56	.	.	.
40439	102	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	102	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	102	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	102	4	called	call	VBN
40439	102	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	102	6	attention	attention	NN
40439	102	7	to	to	IN
40439	102	8	the	the	DT
40439	102	9	fact	fact	NN
40439	102	10	,	,	,
40439	102	11	that	that	IN
40439	102	12	these	these	DT
40439	102	13	two	two	CD
40439	102	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	102	15	are	be	VBP
40439	102	16	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
40439	102	17	;	;	:
40439	102	18	but	but	CC
40439	102	19	can	can	MD
40439	102	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	102	21	safely	safely	RB
40439	102	22	assume	assume	VB
40439	102	23	that	that	IN
40439	102	24	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	102	25	must	must	MD
40439	102	26	have	have	VB
40439	102	27	perceived	perceive	VBN
40439	102	28	such	such	JJ
40439	102	29	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	102	30	between	between	IN
40439	102	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	102	32	?	?	.
40439	103	1	Surely	surely	RB
40439	103	2	not	not	RB
40439	103	3	.	.	.
40439	104	1	The	the	DT
40439	104	2	Pythagoreans	Pythagoreans	NNPS
40439	104	3	of	of	IN
40439	104	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	104	5	day	day	NN
40439	104	6	did	do	VBD
40439	104	7	not	not	RB
40439	104	8	perceive	perceive	VB
40439	104	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	104	10	;	;	:
40439	104	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	104	12	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	104	13	system	system	NN
40439	104	14	included	include	VBD
40439	104	15	both	both	CC
40439	104	16	the	the	DT
40439	104	17	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	104	18	of	of	IN
40439	104	19	the	the	DT
40439	104	20	earth	earth	NN
40439	104	21	and	and	CC
40439	104	22	the	the	DT
40439	104	23	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	104	24	of	of	IN
40439	104	25	the	the	DT
40439	104	26	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	104	27	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	104	28	round	round	IN
40439	104	29	the	the	DT
40439	104	30	central	central	JJ
40439	104	31	fire	fire	NN
40439	104	32	,	,	,
40439	104	33	ten	ten	CD
40439	104	34	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	104	35	bodies	body	NNS
40439	104	36	in	in	IN
40439	104	37	all	all	DT
40439	104	38	(	(	-LRB-
40439	104	39	Aristotel	Aristotel	NNP
40439	104	40	.	.	.
40439	105	1	Metaphysic	metaphysic	JJ
40439	105	2	.	.	.
40439	106	1	i.	i.	NNP
40439	107	1	35	35	CD
40439	107	2	,	,	,
40439	107	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	107	4	96	96	CD
40439	107	5	a.	a.	NN
40439	108	1	10	10	CD
40439	108	2	.	.	.
40439	109	1	De	De	NNP
40439	109	2	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	109	3	,	,	,
40439	109	4	ii	ii	NNP
40439	109	5	.	.	.
40439	110	1	13	13	CD
40439	110	2	,	,	,
40439	110	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	110	4	293	293	CD
40439	110	5	b.	b.	NN
40439	111	1	21	21	CD
40439	111	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	111	3	.	.	.
40439	112	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
40439	112	2	were	be	VBD
40439	112	3	not	not	RB
40439	112	4	aware	aware	JJ
40439	112	5	that	that	IN
40439	112	6	the	the	DT
40439	112	7	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	112	8	of	of	IN
40439	112	9	the	the	DT
40439	112	10	one	one	NN
40439	112	11	annulled	annul	VBD
40439	112	12	those	those	DT
40439	112	13	of	of	IN
40439	112	14	the	the	DT
40439	112	15	other	other	JJ
40439	112	16	as	as	IN
40439	112	17	to	to	TO
40439	112	18	effect	effect	VB
40439	112	19	,	,	,
40439	112	20	and	and	CC
40439	112	21	that	that	IN
40439	112	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	112	23	system	system	NN
40439	112	24	thus	thus	RB
40439	112	25	involved	involve	VBD
40439	112	26	the	the	DT
40439	112	27	two	two	CD
40439	112	28	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
40439	112	29	articles	article	NNS
40439	112	30	,	,	,
40439	112	31	or	or	CC
40439	112	32	"	"	``
40439	112	33	mélange	mélange	VBP
40439	112	34	monstrueux	monstrueux	NN
40439	112	35	,	,	,
40439	112	36	"	"	''
40439	112	37	of	of	IN
40439	112	38	which	which	WDT
40439	112	39	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	112	40	speaks	speak	VBZ
40439	112	41	so	so	RB
40439	112	42	disdainfully	disdainfully	RB
40439	112	43	.	.	.
40439	113	1	Nay	nay	UH
40439	113	2	,	,	,
40439	113	3	more	more	JJR
40439	113	4	,	,	,
40439	113	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	113	6	opponent	opponent	NN
40439	113	7	,	,	,
40439	113	8	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	113	9	,	,	,
40439	113	10	while	while	IN
40439	113	11	producing	produce	VBG
40439	113	12	other	other	JJ
40439	113	13	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	113	14	against	against	IN
40439	113	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	113	16	,	,	,
40439	113	17	never	never	RB
40439	113	18	points	point	VBZ
40439	113	19	out	out	RP
40439	113	20	the	the	DT
40439	113	21	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	113	22	.	.	.
40439	114	1	Since	since	IN
40439	114	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	114	3	did	do	VBD
40439	114	4	not	not	RB
40439	114	5	occur	occur	VB
40439	114	6	to	to	IN
40439	114	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	114	8	,	,	,
40439	114	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	114	10	can	can	MD
40439	114	11	have	have	VB
40439	114	12	no	no	DT
40439	114	13	greater	great	JJR
40439	114	14	difficulty	difficulty	NN
40439	114	15	in	in	IN
40439	114	16	believing	believe	VBG
40439	114	17	that	that	IN
40439	114	18	neither	neither	CC
40439	114	19	did	do	VBD
40439	114	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	114	21	occur	occur	VB
40439	114	22	to	to	IN
40439	114	23	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	114	24	.	.	.
40439	115	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
40439	115	2	,	,	,
40439	115	3	the	the	DT
40439	115	4	wonder	wonder	NN
40439	115	5	would	would	MD
40439	115	6	rather	rather	RB
40439	115	7	be	be	VB
40439	115	8	if	if	IN
40439	115	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	115	10	_	_	NNP
40439	115	11	had	have	VBD
40439	115	12	_	_	NNP
40439	115	13	seen	see	VBN
40439	115	14	an	an	DT
40439	115	15	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	115	16	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	115	17	which	which	WDT
40439	115	18	escaped	escape	VBD
40439	115	19	the	the	DT
40439	115	20	notice	notice	NN
40439	115	21	both	both	DT
40439	115	22	of	of	IN
40439	115	23	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	115	24	and	and	CC
40439	115	25	of	of	IN
40439	115	26	many	many	JJ
40439	115	27	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
40439	115	28	writers	writer	NNS
40439	115	29	who	who	WP
40439	115	30	wrote	write	VBD
40439	115	31	at	at	IN
40439	115	32	a	a	DT
40439	115	33	time	time	NN
40439	115	34	when	when	WRB
40439	115	35	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	115	36	theories	theory	NNS
40439	115	37	had	have	VBD
40439	115	38	been	be	VBN
40439	115	39	developed	develop	VBN
40439	115	40	and	and	CC
40439	115	41	compared	compare	VBN
40439	115	42	with	with	IN
40439	115	43	greater	great	JJR
40439	115	44	fulness	fulness	NN
40439	115	45	.	.	.
40439	116	1	Even	even	RB
40439	116	2	Ideler	Ideler	NNP
40439	116	3	,	,	,
40439	116	4	a	a	DT
40439	116	5	good	good	JJ
40439	116	6	astronomer	astronomer	NN
40439	116	7	as	as	RB
40439	116	8	well	well	RB
40439	116	9	as	as	IN
40439	116	10	a	a	DT
40439	116	11	good	good	JJ
40439	116	12	scholar	scholar	NN
40439	116	13	,	,	,
40439	116	14	though	though	IN
40439	116	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	116	16	must	must	MD
40439	116	17	surely	surely	RB
40439	116	18	have	have	VB
40439	116	19	known	know	VBN
40439	116	20	that	that	IN
40439	116	21	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	116	22	asserted	assert	VBD
40439	116	23	the	the	DT
40439	116	24	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	116	25	of	of	IN
40439	116	26	the	the	DT
40439	116	27	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	116	28	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	116	29	(	(	-LRB-
40439	116	30	for	for	IN
40439	116	31	no	no	DT
40439	116	32	man	man	NN
40439	116	33	can	can	MD
40439	116	34	read	read	VB
40439	116	35	the	the	DT
40439	116	36	'	'	``
40439	116	37	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	116	38	'	'	''
40439	116	39	without	without	IN
40439	116	40	knowing	know	VBG
40439	116	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	116	42	)	)	-RRB-
40439	116	43	,	,	,
40439	116	44	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	116	45	to	to	IN
40439	116	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	116	47	also	also	RB
40439	116	48	the	the	DT
40439	116	49	other	other	JJ
40439	116	50	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	116	51	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
40439	116	52	with	with	IN
40439	116	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	116	54	,	,	,
40439	116	55	not	not	RB
40439	116	56	noticing	notice	VBG
40439	116	57	such	such	JJ
40439	116	58	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
40439	116	59	until	until	IN
40439	116	60	M.	M.	NNP
40439	116	61	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	116	62	pointed	point	VBD
40439	116	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	116	64	out	out	RP
40439	116	65	.	.	.
40439	117	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	117	2	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	117	3	to	to	IN
40439	117	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	117	5	,	,	,
40439	117	6	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	117	7	,	,	,
40439	117	8	that	that	IN
40439	117	9	M.	M.	NNP
40439	117	10	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	117	11	has	have	VBZ
40439	117	12	not	not	RB
40439	117	13	satisfactorily	satisfactorily	RB
40439	117	14	made	make	VBN
40439	117	15	good	good	JJ
40439	117	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	117	17	point--"Plato	point--"plato	NN
40439	117	18	can	can	MD
40439	117	19	not	not	RB
40439	117	20	have	have	VB
40439	117	21	believed	believe	VBN
40439	117	22	in	in	IN
40439	117	23	the	the	DT
40439	117	24	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	117	25	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	117	26	of	of	IN
40439	117	27	the	the	DT
40439	117	28	earth	earth	NN
40439	117	29	,	,	,
40439	117	30	because	because	IN
40439	117	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	117	32	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
40439	117	33	believed	believe	VBD
40439	117	34	in	in	IN
40439	117	35	the	the	DT
40439	117	36	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	117	37	of	of	IN
40439	117	38	the	the	DT
40439	117	39	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	117	40	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	117	41	as	as	IN
40439	117	42	causing	cause	VBG
40439	117	43	the	the	DT
40439	117	44	succession	succession	NN
40439	117	45	of	of	IN
40439	117	46	night	night	NN
40439	117	47	and	and	CC
40439	117	48	day	day	NN
40439	117	49	.	.	.
40439	117	50	"	"	''
40439	118	1	For	for	IN
40439	118	2	,	,	,
40439	118	3	though	though	IN
40439	118	4	the	the	DT
40439	118	5	two	two	CD
40439	118	6	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
40439	118	7	really	really	RB
40439	118	8	are	be	VBP
40439	118	9	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
40439	118	10	,	,	,
40439	118	11	yet	yet	CC
40439	118	12	the	the	DT
40439	118	13	critics	critic	NNS
40439	118	14	antecedent	antecedent	VBP
40439	118	15	to	to	IN
40439	118	16	M.	M.	NNP
40439	118	17	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	118	18	took	take	VBD
40439	118	19	no	no	DT
40439	118	20	notice	notice	NN
40439	118	21	of	of	IN
40439	118	22	such	such	JJ
40439	118	23	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	118	24	.	.	.
40439	119	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	119	2	can	can	MD
40439	119	3	not	not	RB
40439	119	4	presume	presume	VB
40439	119	5	that	that	IN
40439	119	6	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	119	7	saw	see	VBD
40439	119	8	what	what	WP
40439	119	9	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	119	10	and	and	CC
40439	119	11	other	other	JJ
40439	119	12	authors	author	NNS
40439	119	13	,	,	,
40439	119	14	even	even	RB
40439	119	15	many	many	JJ
40439	119	16	writing	writing	NN
40439	119	17	under	under	IN
40439	119	18	a	a	DT
40439	119	19	more	more	RBR
40439	119	20	highly	highly	RB
40439	119	21	developed	developed	JJ
40439	119	22	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	119	23	,	,	,
40439	119	24	did	do	VBD
40439	119	25	not	not	RB
40439	119	26	see	see	VB
40439	119	27	.	.	.
40439	120	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	120	2	ought	ought	MD
40439	120	3	rather	rather	RB
40439	120	4	,	,	,
40439	120	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	120	6	think	think	VBP
40439	120	7	,	,	,
40439	120	8	to	to	TO
40439	120	9	presume	presume	VB
40439	120	10	the	the	DT
40439	120	11	contrary	contrary	NN
40439	120	12	,	,	,
40439	120	13	unless	unless	IN
40439	120	14	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	120	15	's	's	POS
40439	120	16	words	word	NNS
40439	120	17	distinctly	distinctly	RB
40439	120	18	attest	attest	VBP
40439	120	19	that	that	IN
40439	120	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	120	21	did	do	VBD
40439	120	22	see	see	VB
40439	120	23	farther	far	RBR
40439	120	24	than	than	IN
40439	120	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	120	26	successors	successor	NNS
40439	120	27	.	.	.
40439	121	1	Now	now	RB
40439	121	2	let	let	VB
40439	121	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	121	4	examine	examine	VB
40439	121	5	what	what	WP
40439	121	6	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	121	7	's	's	POS
40439	121	8	words	word	NNS
40439	121	9	do	do	VBP
40439	121	10	attest:--[Greek	attest:--[Greek	NNP
40439	121	11	:	:	:
40439	121	12	gê	gê	NNP
40439	121	13	=	=	NNS
40439	121	14	n	n	CC
40439	121	15	de\	de\	NNP
40439	121	16	tropho\n	tropho\n	-LRB-
40439	121	17	me\n	me\n	NNP
40439	121	18	ê(mete	ê(mete	NNP
40439	121	19	/	/	SYM
40439	121	20	ran	run	VBD
40439	121	21	,	,	,
40439	121	22	ei(llome	ei(llome	NNP
40439	121	23	/	/	SYM
40439	121	24	nên	nên	NN
40439	121	25	]	]	-RRB-
40439	121	26	(	(	-LRB-
40439	121	27	al	al	NNP
40439	121	28	.	.	.
40439	122	1	[	[	-LRB-
40439	122	2	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	122	3	:	:	:
40439	122	4	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	122	5	/	/	SYM
40439	122	6	nên	nên	NN
40439	122	7	,	,	,
40439	122	8	i)llome	i)llome	NNP
40439	122	9	/	/	SYM
40439	122	10	nên	nên	NN
40439	122	11	]	]	-RRB-
40439	122	12	)	)	-RRB-
40439	122	13	[	[	-LRB-
40439	122	14	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	122	15	:	:	:
40439	122	16	de\	de\	NN
40439	122	17	peri\	peri\	NNP
40439	122	18	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	122	19	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	122	20	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	122	21	po	po	NNP
40439	122	22	/	/	SYM
40439	122	23	lon	lon	NNP
40439	122	24	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	122	25	/	/	SYM
40439	122	26	non	non	NNP
40439	122	27	phu	phu	NNP
40439	122	28	/	/	SYM
40439	122	29	laka	laka	NNP
40439	122	30	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	122	31	dêmiourgo\n	dêmiourgo\n	NNP
40439	122	32	nukto	nukto	NNP
40439	122	33	/	/	SYM
40439	122	34	s	s	NNP
40439	122	35	te	te	NNP
40439	122	36	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	122	37	ê(me	ê(me	NNP
40439	122	38	/	/	SYM
40439	122	39	ras	ras	NNP
40439	122	40	e)mêchanê	e)mêchanê	NNP
40439	122	41	/	/	SYM
40439	122	42	sato	sato	NNP
40439	122	43	,	,	,
40439	122	44	prô	prô	NNP
40439	122	45	/	/	SYM
40439	122	46	tên	tên	NNP
40439	122	47	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	122	48	presbuta	presbuta	NNP
40439	122	49	/	/	SYM
40439	122	50	tên	tên	NNP
40439	122	51	theô	theô	NNP
40439	122	52	=	=	SYM
40439	122	53	n	n	NN
40439	122	54	,	,	,
40439	122	55	o(/soi	o(/soi	NNP
40439	122	56	e)nto\s	e)nto\s	NNP
40439	122	57	ou)ra	ou)ra	NNP
40439	122	58	/	/	SYM
40439	122	59	nou	nou	NNP
40439	122	60	gego	gego	NNP
40439	122	61	/	/	SYM
40439	122	62	nasi	nasi	NNP
40439	122	63	.	.	.
40439	122	64	]	]	-RRB-
40439	123	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	123	2	explain	explain	VBP
40439	123	3	these	these	DT
40439	123	4	words	word	NNS
40439	123	5	as	as	IN
40439	123	6	follows:--	follows:--	ADD
40439	123	7	In	in	IN
40439	123	8	the	the	DT
40439	123	9	passage	passage	NN
40439	123	10	immediately	immediately	RB
40439	123	11	preceding	precede	VBG
40439	123	12	,	,	,
40439	123	13	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	123	14	had	have	VBD
40439	123	15	described	describe	VBN
40439	123	16	the	the	DT
40439	123	17	uniform	uniform	NN
40439	123	18	and	and	CC
40439	123	19	unchanging	unchanging	JJ
40439	123	20	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	123	21	of	of	IN
40439	123	22	the	the	DT
40439	123	23	outer	outer	JJ
40439	123	24	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	123	25	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	123	26	,	,	,
40439	123	27	or	or	CC
40439	123	28	Circle	Circle	NNP
40439	123	29	of	of	IN
40439	123	30	The	the	DT
40439	123	31	Same	Same	NNP
40439	123	32	,	,	,
40439	123	33	and	and	CC
40439	123	34	the	the	DT
40439	123	35	erratic	erratic	JJ
40439	123	36	movements	movement	NNS
40439	123	37	of	of	IN
40439	123	38	the	the	DT
40439	123	39	sun	sun	NN
40439	123	40	,	,	,
40439	123	41	moon	moon	NN
40439	123	42	,	,	,
40439	123	43	and	and	CC
40439	123	44	planets	planet	NNS
40439	123	45	,	,	,
40439	123	46	in	in	IN
40439	123	47	the	the	DT
40439	123	48	interior	interior	JJ
40439	123	49	Circles	Circles	NNP
40439	123	50	of	of	IN
40439	123	51	the	the	DT
40439	123	52	Diverse	diverse	NN
40439	123	53	.	.	.
40439	124	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	124	2	now	now	RB
40439	124	3	explains	explain	VBZ
40439	124	4	the	the	DT
40439	124	5	situation	situation	NN
40439	124	6	and	and	CC
40439	124	7	functions	function	NNS
40439	124	8	of	of	IN
40439	124	9	the	the	DT
40439	124	10	earth	earth	NN
40439	124	11	.	.	.
40439	125	1	Being	be	VBG
40439	125	2	the	the	DT
40439	125	3	first	first	JJ
40439	125	4	and	and	CC
40439	125	5	most	most	RBS
40439	125	6	venerable	venerable	JJ
40439	125	7	of	of	IN
40439	125	8	the	the	DT
40439	125	9	intra	intra	JJ
40439	125	10	-	-	JJ
40439	125	11	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	125	12	deities	deity	NNS
40439	125	13	,	,	,
40439	125	14	the	the	DT
40439	125	15	earth	earth	NN
40439	125	16	has	have	VBZ
40439	125	17	the	the	DT
40439	125	18	most	most	RBS
40439	125	19	important	important	JJ
40439	125	20	place	place	NN
40439	125	21	in	in	IN
40439	125	22	the	the	DT
40439	125	23	interior	interior	NN
40439	125	24	of	of	IN
40439	125	25	the	the	DT
40439	125	26	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	125	27	--	--	:
40439	125	28	the	the	DT
40439	125	29	centre	centre	NN
40439	125	30	.	.	.
40439	126	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	126	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	126	3	packed	pack	VBN
40439	126	4	,	,	,
40439	126	5	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	126	6	,	,	,
40439	126	7	or	or	CC
40439	126	8	rolled	roll	VBN
40439	126	9	,	,	,
40439	126	10	close	close	RB
40439	126	11	round	round	RB
40439	126	12	the	the	DT
40439	126	13	axis	axis	NN
40439	126	14	which	which	WDT
40439	126	15	traverses	traverse	VBZ
40439	126	16	the	the	DT
40439	126	17	entire	entire	JJ
40439	126	18	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	126	19	;	;	:
40439	126	20	and	and	CC
40439	126	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	126	22	function	function	NN
40439	126	23	is	be	VBZ
40439	126	24	to	to	TO
40439	126	25	watch	watch	VB
40439	126	26	over	over	RP
40439	126	27	and	and	CC
40439	126	28	bring	bring	VB
40439	126	29	about	about	RP
40439	126	30	the	the	DT
40439	126	31	succession	succession	NN
40439	126	32	of	of	IN
40439	126	33	night	night	NN
40439	126	34	and	and	CC
40439	126	35	day	day	NN
40439	126	36	.	.	.
40439	127	1	_	_	NNP
40439	127	2	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	127	3	conceives	conceive	VBZ
40439	127	4	the	the	DT
40439	127	5	kosmic	kosmic	NN
40439	127	6	axis	axis	NNP
40439	127	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	127	8	as	as	IN
40439	127	9	a	a	DT
40439	127	10	solid	solid	JJ
40439	127	11	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	127	12	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	127	13	or	or	CC
40439	127	14	turning	turn	VBG
40439	127	15	round	round	NN
40439	127	16	,	,	,
40439	127	17	and	and	CC
40439	127	18	causing	cause	VBG
40439	127	19	thereby	thereby	RB
40439	127	20	the	the	DT
40439	127	21	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	127	22	of	of	IN
40439	127	23	the	the	DT
40439	127	24	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	127	25	or	or	CC
40439	127	26	the	the	DT
40439	127	27	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	127	28	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	127	29	.	.	.
40439	127	30	_	_	NNP
40439	127	31	The	the	DT
40439	127	32	outer	outer	JJ
40439	127	33	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	127	34	of	of	IN
40439	127	35	the	the	DT
40439	127	36	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	127	37	not	not	RB
40439	127	38	only	only	RB
40439	127	39	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	127	40	round	round	VB
40439	127	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	127	42	axis	axi	NNS
40439	127	43	,	,	,
40439	127	44	but	but	CC
40439	127	45	obeys	obey	VBZ
40439	127	46	a	a	DT
40439	127	47	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	127	48	impulse	impulse	NN
40439	127	49	emanating	emanate	VBG
40439	127	50	from	from	IN
40439	127	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	127	52	axis	axi	NNS
40439	127	53	,	,	,
40439	127	54	like	like	IN
40439	127	55	the	the	DT
40439	127	56	spinning	spinning	NN
40439	127	57	of	of	IN
40439	127	58	a	a	DT
40439	127	59	teetotum	teetotum	NN
40439	127	60	or	or	CC
40439	127	61	the	the	DT
40439	127	62	turning	turning	NN
40439	127	63	of	of	IN
40439	127	64	a	a	DT
40439	127	65	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	127	66	.	.	.
40439	128	1	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	128	2	in	in	IN
40439	128	3	the	the	DT
40439	128	4	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	128	5	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
40439	128	6	the	the	DT
40439	128	7	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	128	8	axis	axi	NNS
40439	128	9	by	by	IN
40439	128	10	comparison	comparison	NN
40439	128	11	with	with	IN
40439	128	12	a	a	DT
40439	128	13	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	128	14	turned	turn	VBN
40439	128	15	by	by	IN
40439	128	16	Necessity	necessity	NN
40439	128	17	,	,	,
40439	128	18	and	and	CC
40439	128	19	describes	describe	VBZ
40439	128	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	128	21	as	as	IN
40439	128	22	causing	cause	VBG
40439	128	23	by	by	IN
40439	128	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	128	25	own	own	JJ
40439	128	26	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	128	27	the	the	DT
40439	128	28	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	128	29	of	of	IN
40439	128	30	all	all	PDT
40439	128	31	the	the	DT
40439	128	32	heavenly	heavenly	JJ
40439	128	33	bodies	body	NNS
40439	128	34	(	(	-LRB-
40439	128	35	Republ	Republ	NNP
40439	128	36	.	.	.
40439	129	1	x.	x.	NNP
40439	129	2	p.	p.	NN
40439	129	3	616	616	CD
40439	129	4	,	,	,
40439	129	5	c.	c.	NN
40439	129	6	617	617	CD
40439	129	7	A	a	NN
40439	129	8	)	)	-RRB-
40439	129	9	.	.	.
40439	130	1	[	[	-LRB-
40439	130	2	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	130	3	:	:	:
40439	130	4	e)k	e)k	NNP
40439	130	5	de\	de\	NNP
40439	130	6	tô	tô	NNP
40439	130	7	=	=	SYM
40439	130	8	n	n	NNP
40439	130	9	a)/krôn	a)/krôn	NNP
40439	130	10	tetame	tetame	NN
40439	130	11	/	/	SYM
40439	130	12	non	non	NNP
40439	130	13	A)na	A)na	NNP
40439	130	14	/	/	SYM
40439	130	15	gkês	gkê	VBN
40439	130	16	a)/trakton	a)/trakton	NNP
40439	130	17	,	,	,
40439	130	18	di	di	NNP
40439	130	19	'	'	''
40439	130	20	ou(=	ou(=	NNP
40439	130	21	pa	pa	NNP
40439	130	22	/	/	SYM
40439	130	23	sas	sas	NNP
40439	130	24	e)pistre	e)pistre	NNP
40439	130	25	/	/	SYM
40439	130	26	phesthai	phesthai	NN
40439	130	27	ta\s	ta\s	NNP
40439	130	28	peri	peri	NN
40439	130	29	/	/	SYM
40439	130	30	phoras	phora	NNS
40439	130	31	.	.	.
40439	131	1	.	.	.
40439	132	1	.	.	.
40439	133	1	,	,	,
40439	133	2	kuklei	kuklei	NNP
40439	133	3	=	=	SYM
40439	133	4	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	133	5	de\	de\	NNP
40439	133	6	dê\	dê\	NNP
40439	133	7	strepho	strepho	NNP
40439	133	8	/	/	SYM
40439	133	9	menon	menon	NNP
40439	133	10	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	133	11	a)/trakton	a)/trakton	NNP
40439	133	12	o(/lon	o(/lon	NN
40439	133	13	me\n	me\n	NNP
40439	133	14	tê\n	tê\n	NNP
40439	133	15	au)tê\n	au)tê\n	NN
40439	133	16	phoran	phoran	NN
40439	133	17	.	.	.
40439	134	1	.	.	.
40439	135	1	.	.	.
40439	136	1	.	.	.
40439	137	1	stre	stre	NNP
40439	137	2	/	/	SYM
40439	137	3	phesthai	phesthai	NNP
40439	137	4	de\	de\	NNP
40439	137	5	au)to\n	au)to\n	NNP
40439	137	6	e)n	e)n	NNP
40439	137	7	toi	toi	NNP
40439	137	8	=	=	SYM
40439	137	9	s	s	NNP
40439	137	10	A)na	A)na	NNP
40439	137	11	/	/	SYM
40439	137	12	gkês	gkês	NNP
40439	137	13	go	go	NNP
40439	137	14	/	/	SYM
40439	137	15	nasin	nasin	NN
40439	137	16	.	.	.
40439	138	1	]	]	-RRB-
40439	138	2	[	[	-LRB-
40439	138	3	1	1	CD
40439	138	4	]	]	-RRB-
40439	138	5	[	[	-LRB-
40439	138	6	Footnote	footnote	NN
40439	138	7	1	1	CD
40439	138	8	:	:	:
40439	138	9	Proklus	proklus	NN
40439	138	10	in	in	IN
40439	138	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	138	12	Commentary	Commentary	NNP
40439	138	13	on	on	IN
40439	138	14	the	the	DT
40439	138	15	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	138	16	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	138	17	(	(	-LRB-
40439	138	18	p.	p.	NN
40439	138	19	682	682	CD
40439	138	20	,	,	,
40439	138	21	Schn	Schn	NNP
40439	138	22	.	.	.
40439	138	23	)	)	-RRB-
40439	139	1	notes	note	VBZ
40439	139	2	this	this	DT
40439	139	3	passage	passage	NN
40439	139	4	of	of	IN
40439	139	5	the	the	DT
40439	139	6	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	139	7	as	as	IN
40439	139	8	the	the	DT
40439	139	9	proper	proper	JJ
40439	139	10	comparison	comparison	NN
40439	139	11	from	from	IN
40439	139	12	which	which	WDT
40439	139	13	to	to	TO
40439	139	14	interpret	interpret	VB
40439	139	15	how	how	WRB
40439	139	16	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	139	17	conceived	conceive	VBD
40439	139	18	the	the	DT
40439	139	19	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	139	20	axis	axis	NN
40439	139	21	.	.	.
40439	140	1	In	in	IN
40439	140	2	many	many	JJ
40439	140	3	points	point	NNS
40439	140	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	140	5	explains	explain	VBZ
40439	140	6	this	this	DT
40439	140	7	correctly	correctly	RB
40439	140	8	;	;	:
40439	140	9	but	but	CC
40439	140	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	140	11	omits	omit	VBZ
40439	140	12	to	to	TO
40439	140	13	remark	remark	VB
40439	140	14	that	that	IN
40439	140	15	the	the	DT
40439	140	16	axis	axi	NNS
40439	140	17	is	be	VBZ
40439	140	18	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	140	19	described	describe	VBN
40439	140	20	as	as	IN
40439	140	21	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	140	22	,	,	,
40439	140	23	and	and	CC
40439	140	24	as	as	IN
40439	140	25	causing	cause	VBG
40439	140	26	the	the	DT
40439	140	27	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	140	28	of	of	IN
40439	140	29	the	the	DT
40439	140	30	peripheral	peripheral	JJ
40439	140	31	substance:--	substance:--	:
40439	140	32	----[Greek	----[greek	XX
40439	140	33	:	:	:
40439	140	34	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	140	35	de\	de\	NNP
40439	140	36	a)/xona	a)/xona	NNP
40439	140	37	mi	mi	NNP
40439	140	38	/	/	SYM
40439	140	39	an	an	DT
40439	140	40	theo	theo	NN
40439	140	41	/	/	SYM
40439	140	42	têta	têta	NN
40439	140	43	sunagôgo\n	sunagôgo\n	-LRB-
40439	140	44	me\n	me\n	NNP
40439	140	45	tô	tô	NNP
40439	140	46	=	=	SYM
40439	140	47	n	n	NNP
40439	140	48	ke	ke	NNP
40439	140	49	/	/	SYM
40439	140	50	ntrôn	ntrôn	IN
40439	140	51	tou=	tou=	NNP
40439	140	52	panto\s	panto\s	-LRB-
40439	140	53	sunektikê\n	sunektikê\n	DT
40439	140	54	de\	de\	NNP
40439	140	55	tou=	tou=	NNP
40439	140	56	o(/lou	o(/lou	NNP
40439	140	57	ko	ko	NNP
40439	140	58	/	/	SYM
40439	140	59	smou	smou	NNP
40439	140	60	,	,	,
40439	140	61	_	_	NNP
40439	140	62	kinêtikê\n	kinêtikê\n	ADD
40439	140	63	de\	de\	NNP
40439	140	64	tô	tô	NNP
40439	140	65	=	=	SYM
40439	140	66	n	n	CC
40439	140	67	thei	thei	NNP
40439	140	68	/	/	SYM
40439	140	69	ôn	ôn	NNP
40439	140	70	periphorô	periphorô	NNP
40439	140	71	=	=	SYM
40439	140	72	n	n	CC
40439	140	73	_	_	NNP
40439	140	74	,	,	,
40439	140	75	peri\	peri\	NNP
40439	140	76	ê(\n	ê(\n	NNP
40439	140	77	ê	ê	NNP
40439	140	78	(	(	-LRB-
40439	140	79	chorei	chorei	NNP
40439	140	80	/	/	SYM
40439	140	81	a	a	DT
40439	140	82	*	*	NFP
40439	140	83	*	*	NFP
40439	140	84	tô	tô	NN
40439	140	85	=	=	SYM
40439	140	86	n	n	CC
40439	140	87	o(/lôn	o(/lôn	NNP
40439	140	88	,	,	,
40439	140	89	peri\	peri\	NNP
40439	140	90	ê(\n	ê(\n	NNP
40439	140	91	ai	ai	NNP
40439	140	92	(	(	-LRB-
40439	140	93	a)nakuklê	a)nakuklê	NNP
40439	140	94	/	/	SYM
40439	140	95	seis	seis	NNP
40439	140	96	,	,	,
40439	140	97	a)ne	a)ne	RB
40439	140	98	/	/	SYM
40439	140	99	chousan	chousan	JJ
40439	140	100	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	140	101	o(/lon	o(/lon	NN
40439	140	102	ou)rano\n	ou)rano\n	NNP
40439	140	103	,	,	,
40439	140	104	*	*	NFP
40439	140	105	*	*	NFP
40439	140	106	ê(\n	ê(\n	NNP
40439	140	107	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	140	108	A)/tlanta	A)/tlanta	NNP
40439	140	109	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	140	110	tou	tou	NNP
40439	140	111	=	=	SYM
40439	140	112	to	to	TO
40439	140	113	proseirê	proseirê	VB
40439	140	114	/	/	SYM
40439	140	115	kasin	kasin	NNP
40439	140	116	,	,	,
40439	140	117	ô(s	ô(s	NNP
40439	140	118	a)/trepton	a)/trepton	NNP
40439	140	119	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	140	120	a)/truton	a)/truton	NNP
40439	140	121	e)ne	e)ne	NNP
40439	140	122	/	/	SYM
40439	140	123	rgeian	rgeian	NNP
40439	140	124	e)/chousan	e)/chousan	NNP
40439	140	125	.	.	.
40439	141	1	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	141	2	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	141	3	/	/	SYM
40439	141	4	ntoi	ntoi	NNP
40439	141	5	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	141	6	to\	to\	NNP
40439	141	7	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	141	8	/	/	SYM
40439	141	9	non	non	AFX
40439	141	10	*	*	NFP
40439	141	11	*	*	NFP
40439	141	12	e)ndei	e)ndei	CD
40439	141	13	/	/	SYM
40439	141	14	knutai	knutai	NN
40439	141	15	*	*	NFP
40439	141	16	*	*	NFP
40439	141	17	titê	titê	CD
40439	141	18	/	/	SYM
40439	141	19	nion	nion	NN
40439	141	20	ei)=nai	ei)=nai	CD
40439	141	21	tê\n	tê\n	NNP
40439	141	22	mi	mi	NNP
40439	141	23	/	/	SYM
40439	141	24	an	an	DT
40439	141	25	_	_	NNP
40439	141	26	tau	tau	NN
40439	141	27	/	/	SYM
40439	141	28	tên	tên	NNP
40439	141	29	du	du	NNP
40439	141	30	/	/	SYM
40439	141	31	namin	namin	NNP
40439	141	32	,	,	,
40439	141	33	tê\n	tê\n	NNP
40439	141	34	phrourêtikê\n	phrourêtikê\n	ADD
40439	141	35	tê	tê	NNP
40439	141	36	=	=	SYM
40439	141	37	s	s	NNP
40439	141	38	a)nakuklê	a)nakuklê	NNP
40439	141	39	/	/	SYM
40439	141	40	seôs	seôs	NNP
40439	141	41	tô	tô	NNP
40439	141	42	=	=	NFP
40439	141	43	n	n	NNP
40439	141	44	o(/lôn	o(/lôn	NNP
40439	141	45	_	_	NNP
40439	141	46	.	.	.
40439	141	47	]	]	-RRB-
40439	142	1	Here	here	RB
40439	142	2	Proklus	Proklus	NNP
40439	142	3	recognises	recognise	VBZ
40439	142	4	the	the	DT
40439	142	5	efficacy	efficacy	NN
40439	142	6	of	of	IN
40439	142	7	the	the	DT
40439	142	8	axis	axis	NN
40439	142	9	in	in	IN
40439	142	10	producing	produce	VBG
40439	142	11	and	and	CC
40439	142	12	maintaining	maintain	VBG
40439	142	13	the	the	DT
40439	142	14	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	142	15	of	of	IN
40439	142	16	the	the	DT
40439	142	17	Kosmos	Kosmos	NNP
40439	142	18	,	,	,
40439	142	19	but	but	CC
40439	142	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	142	21	does	do	VBZ
40439	142	22	not	not	RB
40439	142	23	remark	remark	VB
40439	142	24	that	that	IN
40439	142	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	142	26	initiates	initiate	VBZ
40439	142	27	this	this	DT
40439	142	28	movement	movement	NN
40439	142	29	by	by	IN
40439	142	30	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	142	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	142	32	.	.	.
40439	143	1	The	the	DT
40439	143	2	[	[	-LRB-
40439	143	3	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	143	4	:	:	:
40439	143	5	Theotê\s	Theotê\s	NNP
40439	143	6	]	]	-RRB-
40439	143	7	,	,	,
40439	143	8	which	which	WDT
40439	143	9	Proklus	Proklus	NNP
40439	143	10	ascribes	ascribe	VBZ
40439	143	11	to	to	IN
40439	143	12	the	the	DT
40439	143	13	axis	axis	NN
40439	143	14	,	,	,
40439	143	15	is	be	VBZ
40439	143	16	invested	invest	VBN
40439	143	17	in	in	IN
40439	143	18	the	the	DT
40439	143	19	earth	earth	NN
40439	143	20	packed	pack	VBN
40439	143	21	round	round	IN
40439	143	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	143	23	,	,	,
40439	143	24	by	by	IN
40439	143	25	the	the	DT
40439	143	26	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	143	27	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	143	28	.	.	.
40439	143	29	]	]	-RRB-
40439	144	1	Now	now	RB
40439	144	2	the	the	DT
40439	144	3	function	function	NN
40439	144	4	which	which	WDT
40439	144	5	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	144	6	ascribes	ascribe	VBZ
40439	144	7	to	to	IN
40439	144	8	the	the	DT
40439	144	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	144	10	in	in	IN
40439	144	11	the	the	DT
40439	144	12	passage	passage	NN
40439	144	13	of	of	IN
40439	144	14	the	the	DT
40439	144	15	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	144	16	before	before	IN
40439	144	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	144	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	144	19	very	very	RB
40439	144	20	analogous	analogous	JJ
40439	144	21	to	to	IN
40439	144	22	that	that	DT
40439	144	23	which	which	WDT
40439	144	24	in	in	IN
40439	144	25	the	the	DT
40439	144	26	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	144	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	144	28	ascribes	ascribe	VBZ
40439	144	29	to	to	IN
40439	144	30	Necessity	necessity	NN
40439	144	31	--	--	:
40439	144	32	the	the	DT
40439	144	33	active	active	JJ
40439	144	34	guardianship	guardianship	NN
40439	144	35	of	of	IN
40439	144	36	the	the	DT
40439	144	37	axis	axi	NNS
40439	144	38	of	of	IN
40439	144	39	the	the	DT
40439	144	40	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	144	41	and	and	CC
40439	144	42	the	the	DT
40439	144	43	maintenance	maintenance	NN
40439	144	44	of	of	IN
40439	144	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	144	46	regular	regular	JJ
40439	144	47	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	144	48	.	.	.
40439	145	1	With	with	IN
40439	145	2	a	a	DT
40439	145	3	view	view	NN
40439	145	4	to	to	IN
40439	145	5	the	the	DT
40439	145	6	exercise	exercise	NN
40439	145	7	of	of	IN
40439	145	8	this	this	DT
40439	145	9	function	function	NN
40439	145	10	,	,	,
40439	145	11	the	the	DT
40439	145	12	earth	earth	NN
40439	145	13	is	be	VBZ
40439	145	14	planted	plant	VBN
40439	145	15	in	in	IN
40439	145	16	the	the	DT
40439	145	17	centre	centre	NN
40439	145	18	of	of	IN
40439	145	19	the	the	DT
40439	145	20	axis	axis	NN
40439	145	21	,	,	,
40439	145	22	the	the	DT
40439	145	23	very	very	JJ
40439	145	24	root	root	NN
40439	145	25	of	of	IN
40439	145	26	the	the	DT
40439	145	27	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	145	28	soul	soul	NN
40439	145	29	(	(	-LRB-
40439	145	30	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	145	31	,	,	,
40439	145	32	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	145	33	,	,	,
40439	145	34	p.	p.	NN
40439	145	35	34	34	CD
40439	145	36	B	b	NN
40439	145	37	)	)	-RRB-
40439	145	38	.	.	.
40439	146	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	146	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	146	3	even	even	RB
40439	146	4	"	"	``
40439	146	5	packed	pack	VBN
40439	146	6	close	close	RB
40439	146	7	round	round	RB
40439	146	8	the	the	DT
40439	146	9	axis	axi	NNS
40439	146	10	,	,	,
40439	146	11	"	"	''
40439	146	12	in	in	IN
40439	146	13	order	order	NN
40439	146	14	to	to	TO
40439	146	15	make	make	VB
40439	146	16	sure	sure	JJ
40439	146	17	that	that	IN
40439	146	18	the	the	DT
40439	146	19	axis	axi	NNS
40439	146	20	shall	shall	MD
40439	146	21	not	not	RB
40439	146	22	be	be	VB
40439	146	23	displaced	displace	VBN
40439	146	24	from	from	IN
40439	146	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	146	26	proper	proper	JJ
40439	146	27	situation	situation	NN
40439	146	28	and	and	CC
40439	146	29	direction	direction	NN
40439	146	30	.	.	.
40439	147	1	The	the	DT
40439	147	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	147	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	147	4	thus	thus	RB
40439	147	5	not	not	RB
40439	147	6	merely	merely	RB
40439	147	7	active	active	JJ
40439	147	8	and	and	CC
40439	147	9	influential	influential	JJ
40439	147	10	,	,	,
40439	147	11	but	but	CC
40439	147	12	is	be	VBZ
40439	147	13	really	really	RB
40439	147	14	the	the	DT
40439	147	15	chief	chief	JJ
40439	147	16	regulator	regulator	NN
40439	147	17	of	of	IN
40439	147	18	the	the	DT
40439	147	19	march	march	NNP
40439	147	20	of	of	IN
40439	147	21	the	the	DT
40439	147	22	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	147	23	,	,	,
40439	147	24	being	be	VBG
40439	147	25	the	the	DT
40439	147	26	immediate	immediate	JJ
40439	147	27	neighbour	neighbour	NN
40439	147	28	and	and	CC
40439	147	29	auxiliary	auxiliary	JJ
40439	147	30	of	of	IN
40439	147	31	the	the	DT
40439	147	32	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	147	33	soul	soul	NN
40439	147	34	.	.	.
40439	148	1	Such	such	PDT
40439	148	2	a	a	DT
40439	148	3	function	function	NN
40439	148	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	148	5	worthy	worthy	JJ
40439	148	6	of	of	IN
40439	148	7	"	"	``
40439	148	8	the	the	DT
40439	148	9	first	first	JJ
40439	148	10	and	and	CC
40439	148	11	eldest	eld	JJS
40439	148	12	of	of	IN
40439	148	13	intra	intra	JJ
40439	148	14	-	-	JJ
40439	148	15	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	148	16	deities	deity	NNS
40439	148	17	,	,	,
40439	148	18	"	"	''
40439	148	19	as	as	IN
40439	148	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	148	21	calls	call	VBZ
40439	148	22	the	the	DT
40439	148	23	earth	earth	NN
40439	148	24	.	.	.
40439	149	1	With	with	IN
40439	149	2	perfect	perfect	JJ
40439	149	3	propriety	propriety	NN
40439	149	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	149	5	may	may	MD
40439	149	6	say	say	VB
40439	149	7	that	that	IN
40439	149	8	the	the	DT
40439	149	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	149	10	,	,	,
40439	149	11	in	in	IN
40439	149	12	the	the	DT
40439	149	13	exercise	exercise	NN
40439	149	14	of	of	IN
40439	149	15	such	such	PDT
40439	149	16	a	a	DT
40439	149	17	function	function	NN
40439	149	18	,	,	,
40439	149	19	"	"	''
40439	149	20	is	be	VBZ
40439	149	21	guardian	guardian	NN
40439	149	22	and	and	CC
40439	149	23	artificer	artificer	NN
40439	149	24	of	of	IN
40439	149	25	day	day	NN
40439	149	26	and	and	CC
40439	149	27	night	night	NN
40439	149	28	.	.	.
40439	149	29	"	"	''
40439	150	1	This	this	DT
40439	150	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	150	3	noway	noway	RB
40439	150	4	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
40439	150	5	with	with	IN
40439	150	6	that	that	DT
40439	150	7	which	which	WDT
40439	150	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	150	9	says	say	VBZ
40439	150	10	in	in	IN
40439	150	11	another	another	DT
40439	150	12	passage	passage	NN
40439	150	13	,	,	,
40439	150	14	that	that	IN
40439	150	15	the	the	DT
40439	150	16	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	150	17	of	of	IN
40439	150	18	the	the	DT
40439	150	19	outer	outer	JJ
40439	150	20	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	150	21	sphere	sphere	NNP
40439	150	22	determine	determine	NNP
40439	150	23	day	day	NN
40439	150	24	and	and	CC
40439	150	25	night	night	NN
40439	150	26	.	.	.
40439	151	1	For	for	IN
40439	151	2	these	these	DT
40439	151	3	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	151	4	of	of	IN
40439	151	5	the	the	DT
40439	151	6	outer	outer	JJ
40439	151	7	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	151	8	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	151	9	depend	depend	VBP
40439	151	10	upon	upon	IN
40439	151	11	the	the	DT
40439	151	12	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	151	13	of	of	IN
40439	151	14	the	the	DT
40439	151	15	axis	axi	NNS
40439	151	16	,	,	,
40439	151	17	which	which	WDT
40439	151	18	latter	latter	JJ
40439	151	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	151	20	kept	keep	VBN
40439	151	21	in	in	IN
40439	151	22	uniform	uniform	JJ
40439	151	23	position	position	NN
40439	151	24	and	and	CC
40439	151	25	movement	movement	NN
40439	151	26	by	by	IN
40439	151	27	the	the	DT
40439	151	28	earth	earth	NN
40439	151	29	grasping	grasp	VBG
40439	151	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	151	31	round	round	IN
40439	151	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	151	33	centre	centre	NN
40439	151	34	and	and	CC
40439	151	35	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	151	36	with	with	IN
40439	151	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	151	38	.	.	.
40439	152	1	The	the	DT
40439	152	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	152	3	does	do	VBZ
40439	152	4	not	not	RB
40439	152	5	determine	determine	VB
40439	152	6	days	day	NNS
40439	152	7	and	and	CC
40439	152	8	nights	night	NNS
40439	152	9	by	by	IN
40439	152	10	means	mean	NNS
40439	152	11	of	of	IN
40439	152	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	152	13	own	own	JJ
40439	152	14	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	152	15	,	,	,
40439	152	16	but	but	CC
40439	152	17	by	by	IN
40439	152	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	152	19	continued	continue	VBN
40439	152	20	influence	influence	NN
40439	152	21	upon	upon	IN
40439	152	22	the	the	DT
40439	152	23	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	152	24	of	of	IN
40439	152	25	the	the	DT
40439	152	26	kosmic	kosmic	NNP
40439	152	27	axis	axis	NNP
40439	152	28	,	,	,
40439	152	29	and	and	CC
40439	152	30	(	(	-LRB-
40439	152	31	through	through	IN
40439	152	32	this	this	DT
40439	152	33	latter	latter	JJ
40439	152	34	)	)	-RRB-
40439	152	35	upon	upon	IN
40439	152	36	those	those	DT
40439	152	37	of	of	IN
40439	152	38	the	the	DT
40439	152	39	outer	outer	JJ
40439	152	40	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	152	41	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	152	42	.	.	.
40439	153	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	153	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	153	3	important	important	JJ
40439	153	4	to	to	TO
40439	153	5	attend	attend	VB
40439	153	6	to	to	IN
40439	153	7	the	the	DT
40439	153	8	circumstance	circumstance	NN
40439	153	9	last	last	RB
40439	153	10	mentioned	mention	VBD
40439	153	11	,	,	,
40439	153	12	and	and	CC
40439	153	13	to	to	TO
40439	153	14	understand	understand	VB
40439	153	15	in	in	IN
40439	153	16	what	what	WDT
40439	153	17	sense	sense	NN
40439	153	18	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	153	19	admitted	admit	VBD
40439	153	20	a	a	DT
40439	153	21	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	153	22	movement	movement	NN
40439	153	23	of	of	IN
40439	153	24	the	the	DT
40439	153	25	earth	earth	NN
40439	153	26	.	.	.
40439	154	1	In	in	IN
40439	154	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	154	3	judgment	judgment	NN
40439	154	4	,	,	,
40439	154	5	the	the	DT
40439	154	6	conception	conception	NN
40439	154	7	respecting	respect	VBG
40439	154	8	the	the	DT
40439	154	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	154	10	and	and	CC
40439	154	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	154	12	functions	function	NNS
40439	154	13	,	,	,
40439	154	14	as	as	IN
40439	154	15	developed	develop	VBN
40439	154	16	in	in	IN
40439	154	17	the	the	DT
40439	154	18	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	154	19	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	154	20	,	,	,
40439	154	21	has	have	VBZ
40439	154	22	not	not	RB
40439	154	23	been	be	VBN
40439	154	24	considered	consider	VBN
40439	154	25	with	with	IN
40439	154	26	all	all	PDT
40439	154	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	154	28	points	point	NNS
40439	154	29	taken	take	VBN
40439	154	30	together	together	RB
40439	154	31	.	.	.
40439	155	1	One	one	CD
40439	155	2	point	point	NN
40439	155	3	among	among	IN
40439	155	4	several	several	JJ
40439	155	5	,	,	,
40439	155	6	and	and	CC
40439	155	7	that	that	IN
40439	155	8	too	too	RB
40439	155	9	the	the	DT
40439	155	10	least	least	RBS
40439	155	11	important	important	JJ
40439	155	12	point	point	NN
40439	155	13	,	,	,
40439	155	14	has	have	VBZ
40439	155	15	been	be	VBN
40439	155	16	discussed	discuss	VBN
40439	155	17	as	as	IN
40439	155	18	if	if	IN
40439	155	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	155	20	were	be	VBD
40439	155	21	the	the	DT
40439	155	22	whole	whole	NN
40439	155	23	,	,	,
40439	155	24	because	because	IN
40439	155	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	155	26	falls	fall	VBZ
40439	155	27	in	in	RP
40439	155	28	with	with	IN
40439	155	29	the	the	DT
40439	155	30	discussions	discussion	NNS
40439	155	31	of	of	IN
40439	155	32	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
40439	155	33	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	155	34	.	.	.
40439	156	1	Thus	thus	RB
40439	156	2	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	156	3	admits	admit	VBZ
40439	156	4	the	the	DT
40439	156	5	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	156	6	of	of	IN
40439	156	7	the	the	DT
40439	156	8	earth	earth	NN
40439	156	9	,	,	,
40439	156	10	but	but	CC
40439	156	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	156	12	does	do	VBZ
40439	156	13	not	not	RB
40439	156	14	admit	admit	VB
40439	156	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	156	16	as	as	IN
40439	156	17	producing	produce	VBG
40439	156	18	any	any	DT
40439	156	19	effects	effect	NNS
40439	156	20	,	,	,
40439	156	21	or	or	CC
40439	156	22	as	as	IN
40439	156	23	the	the	DT
40439	156	24	primary	primary	JJ
40439	156	25	function	function	NN
40439	156	26	of	of	IN
40439	156	27	the	the	DT
40439	156	28	earth	earth	NN
40439	156	29	:	:	:
40439	156	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	156	31	is	be	VBZ
40439	156	32	only	only	RB
40439	156	33	an	an	DT
40439	156	34	indirect	indirect	JJ
40439	156	35	consequence	consequence	NN
40439	156	36	of	of	IN
40439	156	37	the	the	DT
40439	156	38	position	position	NN
40439	156	39	which	which	WDT
40439	156	40	the	the	DT
40439	156	41	earth	earth	NN
40439	156	42	occupies	occupy	VBZ
40439	156	43	in	in	IN
40439	156	44	the	the	DT
40439	156	45	discharge	discharge	NN
40439	156	46	of	of	IN
40439	156	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	156	48	primary	primary	JJ
40439	156	49	function	function	NN
40439	156	50	--	--	:
40439	156	51	of	of	IN
40439	156	52	keeping	keep	VBG
40439	156	53	the	the	DT
40439	156	54	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	156	55	axis	axi	NNS
40439	156	56	steady	steady	JJ
40439	156	57	,	,	,
40439	156	58	and	and	CC
40439	156	59	maintaining	maintain	VBG
40439	156	60	the	the	DT
40439	156	61	uniformity	uniformity	NN
40439	156	62	of	of	IN
40439	156	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	156	64	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	156	65	.	.	.
40439	157	1	If	if	IN
40439	157	2	the	the	DT
40439	157	3	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	157	4	axis	axis	NN
40439	157	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	157	6	to	to	TO
40439	157	7	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	157	8	,	,	,
40439	157	9	the	the	DT
40439	157	10	earth	earth	NN
40439	157	11	,	,	,
40439	157	12	being	be	VBG
40439	157	13	closely	closely	RB
40439	157	14	packed	pack	VBN
40439	157	15	and	and	CC
40439	157	16	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	157	17	round	round	IN
40439	157	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	157	19	,	,	,
40439	157	20	must	must	MD
40439	157	21	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	157	22	along	along	IN
40439	157	23	with	with	IN
40439	157	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	157	25	.	.	.
40439	158	1	If	if	IN
40439	158	2	the	the	DT
40439	158	3	earth	earth	NN
40439	158	4	stood	stand	VBD
40439	158	5	still	still	RB
40439	158	6	,	,	,
40439	158	7	and	and	CC
40439	158	8	resisted	resist	VBD
40439	158	9	all	all	DT
40439	158	10	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	158	11	of	of	IN
40439	158	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	158	13	own	own	JJ
40439	158	14	,	,	,
40439	158	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	158	16	would	would	MD
40439	158	17	at	at	IN
40439	158	18	the	the	DT
40439	158	19	same	same	JJ
40439	158	20	time	time	NN
40439	158	21	arrest	arrest	VB
40439	158	22	the	the	DT
40439	158	23	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	158	24	of	of	IN
40439	158	25	the	the	DT
40439	158	26	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	158	27	axis	axis	NN
40439	158	28	,	,	,
40439	158	29	and	and	CC
40439	158	30	of	of	IN
40439	158	31	course	course	NN
40439	158	32	those	those	DT
40439	158	33	of	of	IN
40439	158	34	the	the	DT
40439	158	35	entire	entire	JJ
40439	158	36	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	158	37	besides	besides	RB
40439	158	38	.	.	.
40439	159	1	The	the	DT
40439	159	2	above	above	JJ
40439	159	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	159	4	the	the	DT
40439	159	5	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	159	6	which	which	WDT
40439	159	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	159	8	propose	propose	VBP
40439	159	9	of	of	IN
40439	159	10	the	the	DT
40439	159	11	passage	passage	NN
40439	159	12	in	in	IN
40439	159	13	the	the	DT
40439	159	14	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	159	15	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	159	16	,	,	,
40439	159	17	and	and	CC
40439	159	18	which	which	WDT
40439	159	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	159	20	shall	shall	MD
40439	159	21	show	show	VB
40439	159	22	to	to	TO
40439	159	23	coincide	coincide	VB
40439	159	24	with	with	IN
40439	159	25	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	159	26	's	's	POS
40439	159	27	comment	comment	NN
40439	159	28	upon	upon	IN
40439	159	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	159	30	.	.	.
40439	160	1	Messrs.	Messrs.	NNP
40439	160	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	160	3	and	and	CC
40439	160	4	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	160	5	interpret	interpret	VBP
40439	160	6	differently	differently	RB
40439	160	7	.	.	.
40439	161	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
40439	161	2	do	do	VBP
40439	161	3	not	not	RB
40439	161	4	advert	advert	VB
40439	161	5	to	to	IN
40439	161	6	the	the	DT
40439	161	7	sense	sense	NN
40439	161	8	in	in	IN
40439	161	9	which	which	WDT
40439	161	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	161	11	conceives	conceive	VBZ
40439	161	12	the	the	DT
40439	161	13	axis	axi	NNS
40439	161	14	of	of	IN
40439	161	15	the	the	DT
40439	161	16	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	161	17	--	--	:
40439	161	18	not	not	RB
40439	161	19	as	as	IN
40439	161	20	an	an	DT
40439	161	21	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	161	22	line	line	NN
40439	161	23	,	,	,
40439	161	24	but	but	CC
40439	161	25	as	as	IN
40439	161	26	a	a	DT
40439	161	27	solid	solid	JJ
40439	161	28	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	161	29	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	161	30	;	;	:
40439	161	31	and	and	CC
40439	161	32	moreover	moreover	RB
40439	161	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	161	34	understand	understand	VBP
40439	161	35	the	the	DT
40439	161	36	function	function	NN
40439	161	37	assigned	assign	VBN
40439	161	38	by	by	IN
40439	161	39	the	the	DT
40439	161	40	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	161	41	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	161	42	to	to	IN
40439	161	43	the	the	DT
40439	161	44	earth	earth	NN
40439	161	45	in	in	IN
40439	161	46	a	a	DT
40439	161	47	way	way	NN
40439	161	48	which	which	WDT
40439	161	49	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	161	50	can	can	MD
40439	161	51	not	not	RB
40439	161	52	admit	admit	VB
40439	161	53	.	.	.
40439	162	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
40439	162	2	suppose	suppose	VBP
40439	162	3	that	that	IN
40439	162	4	the	the	DT
40439	162	5	function	function	NN
40439	162	6	assigned	assign	VBN
40439	162	7	to	to	IN
40439	162	8	the	the	DT
40439	162	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	162	10	is	be	VBZ
40439	162	11	not	not	RB
40439	162	12	to	to	TO
40439	162	13	keep	keep	VB
40439	162	14	up	up	RP
40439	162	15	and	and	CC
40439	162	16	regularize	regularize	VB
40439	162	17	,	,	,
40439	162	18	but	but	CC
40439	162	19	to	to	TO
40439	162	20	withstand	withstand	VB
40439	162	21	and	and	CC
40439	162	22	countervail	countervail	VB
40439	162	23	,	,	,
40439	162	24	the	the	DT
40439	162	25	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	162	26	of	of	IN
40439	162	27	the	the	DT
40439	162	28	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	162	29	.	.	.
40439	163	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	163	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	163	3	comments	comment	NNS
40439	163	4	upon	upon	IN
40439	163	5	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	163	6	,	,	,
40439	163	7	who	who	WP
40439	163	8	had	have	VBD
40439	163	9	said	say	VBN
40439	163	10	(	(	-LRB-
40439	163	11	after	after	IN
40439	163	12	Ideler	Ideler	NNP
40439	163	13	)	)	-RRB-
40439	163	14	that	that	IN
40439	163	15	when	when	WRB
40439	163	16	the	the	DT
40439	163	17	earth	earth	NN
40439	163	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	163	19	called	call	VBN
40439	163	20	[	[	-LRB-
40439	163	21	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	163	22	:	:	:
40439	163	23	phu	phu	NNP
40439	163	24	/	/	SYM
40439	163	25	laka	laka	NNP
40439	163	26	_	_	NNP
40439	163	27	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	163	28	dêmiourgo\n	dêmiourgo\n	-LRB-
40439	163	29	_	_	NNP
40439	163	30	nukto\s	nukto\s	NNP
40439	163	31	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	163	32	ê(me	ê(me	NNP
40439	163	33	/	/	SYM
40439	163	34	ras	ras	NNP
40439	163	35	]	]	-RRB-
40439	163	36	,	,	,
40439	163	37	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	163	38	must	must	MD
40439	163	39	have	have	VB
40439	163	40	meant	mean	VBN
40439	163	41	to	to	TO
40439	163	42	designate	designate	VB
40439	163	43	some	some	DT
40439	163	44	active	active	JJ
40439	163	45	function	function	NN
40439	163	46	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	163	47	to	to	IN
40439	163	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	163	49	,	,	,
40439	163	50	and	and	CC
40439	163	51	not	not	RB
40439	163	52	any	any	DT
40439	163	53	function	function	NN
40439	163	54	merely	merely	RB
40439	163	55	passive	passive	JJ
40439	163	56	or	or	CC
40439	163	57	negative	negative	JJ
40439	163	58	.	.	.
40439	164	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	164	2	agree	agree	VBP
40439	164	3	with	with	IN
40439	164	4	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	164	5	in	in	IN
40439	164	6	this	this	DT
40439	164	7	remark	remark	NN
40439	164	8	,	,	,
40439	164	9	and	and	CC
40439	164	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	164	11	have	have	VBP
40439	164	12	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	164	13	to	to	TO
40439	164	14	point	point	VB
40439	164	15	out	out	RP
40439	164	16	what	what	WP
40439	164	17	this	this	DT
40439	164	18	active	active	JJ
40439	164	19	function	function	NN
40439	164	20	of	of	IN
40439	164	21	the	the	DT
40439	164	22	earth	earth	NN
40439	164	23	is	be	VBZ
40439	164	24	,	,	,
40439	164	25	in	in	IN
40439	164	26	the	the	DT
40439	164	27	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	164	28	theory	theory	NN
40439	164	29	.	.	.
40439	165	1	But	but	CC
40439	165	2	M.	M.	NNP
40439	165	3	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	165	4	(	(	-LRB-
40439	165	5	Untersuchungen	Untersuchungen	NNP
40439	165	6	,	,	,
40439	165	7	&	&	CC
40439	165	8	c.	c.	NNP
40439	165	9	,	,	,
40439	165	10	p.	p.	NNP
40439	165	11	69	69	CD
40439	165	12	-	-	SYM
40439	165	13	70	70	CD
40439	165	14	)	)	-RRB-
40439	165	15	controverts	controvert	VBZ
40439	165	16	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	165	17	's	's	POS
40439	165	18	remark	remark	NN
40439	165	19	,	,	,
40439	165	20	observing	observe	VBG
40439	165	21	,	,	,
40439	165	22	first	first	RB
40439	165	23	,	,	,
40439	165	24	that	that	IN
40439	165	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	165	26	is	be	VBZ
40439	165	27	enough	enough	JJ
40439	165	28	if	if	IN
40439	165	29	the	the	DT
40439	165	30	earth	earth	NN
40439	165	31	is	be	VBZ
40439	165	32	in	in	IN
40439	165	33	any	any	DT
40439	165	34	way	way	NN
40439	165	35	necessary	necessary	JJ
40439	165	36	to	to	IN
40439	165	37	the	the	DT
40439	165	38	production	production	NN
40439	165	39	of	of	IN
40439	165	40	the	the	DT
40439	165	41	given	give	VBN
40439	165	42	effect	effect	NN
40439	165	43	;	;	:
40439	165	44	secondly	secondly	RB
40439	165	45	,	,	,
40439	165	46	that	that	IN
40439	165	47	if	if	IN
40439	165	48	active	active	JJ
40439	165	49	force	force	NN
40439	165	50	be	be	VB
40439	165	51	required	require	VBN
40439	165	52	,	,	,
40439	165	53	the	the	DT
40439	165	54	earth	earth	NN
40439	165	55	(	(	-LRB-
40439	165	56	in	in	IN
40439	165	57	the	the	DT
40439	165	58	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	165	59	theory	theory	NN
40439	165	60	)	)	-RRB-
40439	165	61	does	do	VBZ
40439	165	62	exercise	exercise	VB
40439	165	63	such	such	JJ
40439	165	64	,	,	,
40439	165	65	by	by	IN
40439	165	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	165	67	purely	purely	RB
40439	165	68	passive	passive	JJ
40439	165	69	resistance	resistance	NN
40439	165	70	,	,	,
40439	165	71	which	which	WDT
40439	165	72	is	be	VBZ
40439	165	73	in	in	IN
40439	165	74	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	165	75	an	an	DT
40439	165	76	energetic	energetic	JJ
40439	165	77	putting	put	VBG
40439	165	78	forth	forth	RB
40439	165	79	of	of	IN
40439	165	80	power	power	NN
40439	165	81	.	.	.
40439	166	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	166	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	166	3	's	's	POS
40439	166	4	words	word	NNS
40439	166	5	are:--"Es	are:--"Es	NNP
40439	166	6	kommt	kommt	NNP
40439	166	7	nur	nur	NNP
40439	166	8	darauf	darauf	VBZ
40439	166	9	an	an	DT
40439	166	10	,	,	,
40439	166	11	dass	dass	NN
40439	166	12	er	er	UH
40439	166	13	ein	ein	NNP
40439	166	14	Werk	Werk	NNP
40439	166	15	,	,	,
40439	166	16	eine	eine	NN
40439	166	17	Wirkung	Wirkung	NNP
40439	166	18	,	,	,
40439	166	19	hervorbringt	hervorbringt	JJ
40439	166	20	oder	oder	NN
40439	166	21	zu	zu	NNP
40439	166	22	einer	einer	NN
40439	166	23	Wirkung	Wirkung	NNP
40439	166	24	beiträgt	beiträgt	NN
40439	166	25	,	,	,
40439	166	26	die	die	VBP
40439	166	27	ohne	ohne	NNP
40439	166	28	ihn	ihn	NNP
40439	166	29	nicht	nicht	NNP
40439	166	30	wäre	wäre	NNP
40439	166	31	:	:	:
40439	166	32	dann	dann	NNP
40439	166	33	ist	ist	NNP
40439	166	34	er	er	UH
40439	166	35	durch	durch	NNP
40439	166	36	seine	seine	NN
40439	166	37	Wirksamkeit	Wirksamkeit	NNP
40439	166	38	ein	ein	NNP
40439	166	39	Werkmeister	Werkmeister	NNP
40439	166	40	der	der	NN
40439	166	41	Sache	Sache	NNP
40439	166	42	,	,	,
40439	166	43	sey	sey	NNP
40439	166	44	es	es	NNP
40439	166	45	auch	auch	NNP
40439	166	46	ohne	ohne	NN
40439	166	47	active	active	JJ
40439	166	48	Thätigkeit	Thätigkeit	NNP
40439	166	49	,	,	,
40439	166	50	durch	durch	NN
40439	166	51	bloss	bloss	NN
40439	166	52	passiven	passiven	JJ
40439	166	53	Widerstand	Widerstand	NNP
40439	166	54	,	,	,
40439	166	55	der	der	XX
40439	166	56	auch	auch	NN
40439	166	57	eine	eine	NN
40439	166	58	mächtige	mächtige	NNP
40439	166	59	Kraft	Kraft	NNP
40439	166	60	-	-	HYPH
40439	166	61	äusserung	äusserung	NNP
40439	166	62	ist	ist	NN
40439	166	63	.	.	.
40439	167	1	Die	die	VB
40439	167	2	Erde	Erde	NNP
40439	167	3	ist	ist	NN
40439	167	4	Werkmeisterin	Werkmeisterin	NNP
40439	167	5	der	der	VBD
40439	167	6	Nacht	Nacht	NNP
40439	167	7	und	und	NN
40439	167	8	des	des	NNP
40439	167	9	Tages	Tages	NNP
40439	167	10	,	,	,
40439	167	11	wie	wie	NN
40439	167	12	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	167	13	(	(	-LRB-
40439	167	14	b.	b.	NNP
40439	167	15	ii	ii	NNP
40439	167	16	.	.	.
40439	168	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	168	2	88	88	CD
40439	168	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	168	4	sehr	sehr	NN
40439	168	5	treffend	treffend	NN
40439	168	6	sagt	sagt	NN
40439	168	7	'	'	''
40439	168	8	par	par	NNP
40439	168	9	son	son	NNP
40439	168	10	énergique	énergique	NNP
40439	168	11	existence	existence	NNP
40439	168	12	,	,	,
40439	168	13	c'est	c'est	VB
40439	168	14	à	à	FW
40439	168	15	dire	dire	FW
40439	168	16	,	,	,
40439	168	17	par	par	NNP
40439	168	18	son	son	NN
40439	168	19	immobilité	immobilité	NNP
40439	168	20	même	même	NNP
40439	168	21	:	:	:
40439	168	22	'	'	''
40439	168	23	denn	denn	NNS
40439	168	24	sie	sie	VBP
40439	168	25	setzt	setzt	VBN
40439	168	26	der	der	NN
40439	168	27	täglichen	täglichen	NNP
40439	168	28	Bewegung	Bewegung	NNP
40439	168	29	des	des	NNP
40439	168	30	Himmels	Himmels	NNP
40439	168	31	beständig	beständig	NN
40439	168	32	eine	eine	NN
40439	168	33	gleiche	gleiche	NN
40439	168	34	Kraft	Kraft	NNP
40439	168	35	in	in	IN
40439	168	36	entgegengesetzter	entgegengesetzt	JJR
40439	168	37	Richtung	Richtung	NNP
40439	168	38	entgegen	entgegen	NN
40439	168	39	.	.	.
40439	169	1	So	so	RB
40439	169	2	_	_	NNP
40439	169	3	muss	muss	NNP
40439	169	4	_	_	NNP
40439	169	5	nach	nach	RB
40439	169	6	dem	dem	NNP
40439	169	7	Zusammenhange	Zusammenhange	NNP
40439	169	8	ausgelegt	ausgelegt	NNP
40439	169	9	werden	werden	NNP
40439	169	10	:	:	:
40439	169	11	so	so	CC
40439	169	12	meint	meint	NNP
40439	169	13	es	es	NNP
40439	169	14	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	169	15	klar	klar	NNP
40439	169	16	und	und	JJ
40439	169	17	ohne	ohne	NN
40439	169	18	Verhüllungen	Verhüllungen	NNP
40439	169	19	:	:	:
40439	169	20	denn	denn	NNP
40439	169	21	wenige	wenige	NNP
40439	169	22	Zeilen	Zeilen	NNP
40439	169	23	vorher	vorher	NNP
40439	169	24	hat	hat	NNP
40439	169	25	er	er	UH
40439	169	26	gesagt	gesagt	NNP
40439	169	27	,	,	,
40439	169	28	Nacht	Nacht	NNP
40439	169	29	und	und	NN
40439	169	30	Tag	Tag	NNP
40439	169	31	,	,	,
40439	169	32	das	das	NNP
40439	169	33	heisst	heisst	NNP
40439	169	34	ein	ein	NNP
40439	169	35	Sterntag	Sterntag	NNP
40439	169	36	oder	oder	VBP
40439	169	37	Zeittag	Zeittag	NNP
40439	169	38	,	,	,
40439	169	39	sei	sei	NN
40439	169	40	ein	ein	NNP
40439	169	41	Umlauf	Umlauf	NNP
40439	169	42	des	des	NNP
40439	169	43	Kreises	Kreises	NNP
40439	169	44	des	des	FW
40439	169	45	Selbigen--_das	Selbigen--_das	NNP
40439	169	46	ist	ist	NN
40439	169	47	,	,	,
40439	169	48	eine	eine	NN
40439	169	49	tägliche	tägliche	NNP
40439	169	50	Umkreisung	Umkreisung	NNP
40439	169	51	des	des	NNP
40439	169	52	Himmels	Himmels	NNP
40439	169	53	von	von	NNP
40439	169	54	Osten	Osten	NNP
40439	169	55	nach	nach	NN
40439	169	56	Westen	Westen	NNP
40439	169	57	,	,	,
40439	169	58	wodurch	wodurch	NN
40439	169	59	also	also	RB
40439	169	60	die	die	VBP
40439	169	61	Erde	Erde	NNP
40439	169	62	in	in	IN
40439	169	63	Stillstand	Stillstand	NNP
40439	169	64	versetzt	versetzt	VBD
40439	169	65	ist	ist	NN
40439	169	66	:	:	:
40439	169	67	_	_	NNP
40439	169	68	und	und	JJ
40439	169	69	diese	diese	NNP
40439	169	70	tägliche	tägliche	NN
40439	169	71	Bewegung	Bewegung	NNP
40439	169	72	des	des	NNP
40439	169	73	Himmels	Himmels	NNP
40439	169	74	hat	hat	NN
40439	169	75	er	er	UH
40439	169	76	i	-PRON-	PRP
40439	169	77	m	be	VBP
40439	169	78	vorhergehenden	vorhergehenden	NNP
40439	169	79	immer	immer	NN
40439	169	80	und	und	NN
40439	169	81	immer	immer	NN
40439	169	82	gelehrt	gelehrt	NN
40439	169	83	.	.	.
40439	169	84	"	"	''
40439	170	1	.	.	.
40439	171	1	.	.	.
40439	172	1	.	.	.
40439	173	1	.	.	.
40439	174	1	"	"	``
40439	174	2	Indem	Indem	NNP
40439	174	3	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	174	4	die	die	VBP
40439	174	5	Erde	Erde	NNP
40439	174	6	nennt	nennt	RB
40439	174	7	[	[	-LRB-
40439	174	8	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	174	9	:	:	:
40439	174	10	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	174	11	/	/	SYM
40439	174	12	nên	nên	NN
40439	174	13	]	]	-RRB-
40439	174	14	,	,	,
40439	174	15	nicht	nicht	NNP
40439	174	16	[	[	-LRB-
40439	174	17	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	174	18	:	:	:
40439	174	19	peri\	peri\	JJ
40439	174	20	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	174	21	e(autê	e(autê	NNP
40439	174	22	=	=	SYM
40439	174	23	s	s	NNP
40439	174	24	po	po	NNP
40439	174	25	/	/	SYM
40439	174	26	lon	lon	NNP
40439	174	27	]	]	-RRB-
40439	174	28	,	,	,
40439	174	29	sondern	sondern	NN
40439	174	30	[	[	-LRB-
40439	174	31	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	174	32	:	:	:
40439	174	33	peri\	peri\	NN
40439	174	34	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	174	35	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	174	36	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	174	37	po	po	NNP
40439	174	38	/	/	SYM
40439	174	39	lon	lon	NNP
40439	174	40	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	174	41	/	/	SYM
40439	174	42	non	non	NNP
40439	174	43	]	]	-RRB-
40439	174	44	,	,	,
40439	174	45	setzt	setzt	VBD
40439	174	46	er	er	UH
40439	174	47	also	also	RB
40439	174	48	die	die	VBP
40439	174	49	tägliche	tägliche	NNP
40439	174	50	Bewegung	Bewegung	NNP
40439	174	51	des	des	NNP
40439	174	52	Himmels	Himmels	NNP
40439	174	53	voraus	voraus	NN
40439	174	54	"	"	''
40439	174	55	(	(	-LRB-
40439	174	56	p.	p.	NN
40439	175	1	70	70	CD
40439	175	2	-	-	SYM
40439	175	3	71	71	CD
40439	175	4	)	)	-RRB-
40439	175	5	.	.	.
40439	176	1	[	[	-LRB-
40439	176	2	2	2	CD
40439	176	3	]	]	-RRB-
40439	176	4	[	[	-LRB-
40439	176	5	Footnote	footnote	NN
40439	176	6	2	2	CD
40439	176	7	:	:	:
40439	176	8	"	"	``
40439	176	9	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	176	10	are	be	VBP
40439	176	11	only	only	RB
40439	176	12	required	require	VBN
40439	176	13	to	to	TO
40439	176	14	show	show	VB
40439	176	15	,	,	,
40439	176	16	that	that	IN
40439	176	17	the	the	DT
40439	176	18	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	176	19	produces	produce	VBZ
40439	176	20	a	a	DT
40439	176	21	work	work	NN
40439	176	22	or	or	CC
40439	176	23	an	an	DT
40439	176	24	effect,--or	effect,--or	NN
40439	176	25	contributes	contribute	VBZ
40439	176	26	to	to	IN
40439	176	27	an	an	DT
40439	176	28	effect	effect	NN
40439	176	29	which	which	WDT
40439	176	30	would	would	MD
40439	176	31	not	not	RB
40439	176	32	exist	exist	VB
40439	176	33	without	without	IN
40439	176	34	such	such	JJ
40439	176	35	help	help	NN
40439	176	36	:	:	:
40439	176	37	the	the	DT
40439	176	38	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	176	39	is	be	VBZ
40439	176	40	then	then	RB
40439	176	41	,	,	,
40439	176	42	through	through	IN
40439	176	43	such	such	JJ
40439	176	44	operation	operation	NN
40439	176	45	,	,	,
40439	176	46	an	an	DT
40439	176	47	_	_	NNP
40439	176	48	Artificer	Artificer	NNP
40439	176	49	_	_	NNP
40439	176	50	of	of	IN
40439	176	51	what	what	WP
40439	176	52	is	be	VBZ
40439	176	53	produced	produce	VBN
40439	176	54	,	,	,
40439	176	55	even	even	RB
40439	176	56	without	without	IN
40439	176	57	any	any	DT
40439	176	58	positive	positive	JJ
40439	176	59	activity	activity	NN
40439	176	60	,	,	,
40439	176	61	by	by	IN
40439	176	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	176	63	simply	simply	RB
40439	176	64	passive	passive	JJ
40439	176	65	resistance	resistance	NN
40439	176	66	,	,	,
40439	176	67	which	which	WDT
40439	176	68	indeed	indeed	RB
40439	176	69	is	be	VBZ
40439	176	70	in	in	IN
40439	176	71	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	176	72	a	a	DT
40439	176	73	powerful	powerful	JJ
40439	176	74	exercise	exercise	NN
40439	176	75	of	of	IN
40439	176	76	force	force	NN
40439	176	77	.	.	.
40439	177	1	*	*	NFP
40439	177	2	*	*	NFP
40439	177	3	The	the	DT
40439	177	4	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	177	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	177	6	Artificer	Artificer	NNP
40439	177	7	of	of	IN
40439	177	8	night	night	NN
40439	177	9	and	and	CC
40439	177	10	day	day	NN
40439	177	11	,	,	,
40439	177	12	according	accord	VBG
40439	177	13	to	to	IN
40439	177	14	the	the	DT
40439	177	15	striking	striking	JJ
40439	177	16	expression	expression	NN
40439	177	17	of	of	IN
40439	177	18	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	177	19	,	,	,
40439	177	20	'	'	''
40439	177	21	par	par	NNP
40439	177	22	son	son	NN
40439	177	23	énergique	énergique	NNP
40439	177	24	existence	existence	NNP
40439	177	25	,	,	,
40439	177	26	c'est	c'	JJS
40439	177	27	-	-	HYPH
40439	177	28	à	à	NN
40439	177	29	-	-	HYPH
40439	177	30	dire	dire	JJ
40439	177	31	,	,	,
40439	177	32	par	par	NNP
40439	177	33	son	son	NN
40439	177	34	immobilité	immobilité	NNP
40439	177	35	même	même	NNP
40439	177	36	:	:	:
40439	177	37	'	'	''
40439	177	38	for	for	IN
40439	177	39	the	the	DT
40439	177	40	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	177	41	opposes	oppose	VBZ
40439	177	42	,	,	,
40439	177	43	to	to	IN
40439	177	44	the	the	DT
40439	177	45	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	177	46	movement	movement	NN
40439	177	47	of	of	IN
40439	177	48	the	the	DT
40439	177	49	Heavens	Heavens	NNPS
40439	177	50	,	,	,
40439	177	51	a	a	DT
40439	177	52	constant	constant	JJ
40439	177	53	and	and	CC
40439	177	54	equal	equal	JJ
40439	177	55	force	force	NN
40439	177	56	in	in	IN
40439	177	57	the	the	DT
40439	177	58	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	177	59	direction	direction	NN
40439	177	60	.	.	.
40439	178	1	This	this	DT
40439	178	2	explanation	explanation	NN
40439	178	3	_	_	NNP
40439	178	4	must	must	MD
40439	178	5	_	_	NNP
40439	178	6	be	be	VB
40439	178	7	the	the	DT
40439	178	8	true	true	JJ
40439	178	9	one	one	NN
40439	178	10	required	require	VBN
40439	178	11	by	by	IN
40439	178	12	the	the	DT
40439	178	13	context	context	NN
40439	178	14	:	:	:
40439	178	15	this	this	DT
40439	178	16	is	be	VBZ
40439	178	17	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	178	18	's	's	POS
40439	178	19	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	178	20	,	,	,
40439	178	21	plainly	plainly	RB
40439	178	22	and	and	CC
40439	178	23	without	without	IN
40439	178	24	disguise	disguise	NN
40439	178	25	:	:	:
40439	178	26	for	for	IN
40439	178	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	178	28	has	have	VBZ
40439	178	29	said	say	VBN
40439	178	30	,	,	,
40439	178	31	a	a	DT
40439	178	32	few	few	JJ
40439	178	33	lines	line	NNS
40439	178	34	before	before	RB
40439	178	35	,	,	,
40439	178	36	that	that	DT
40439	178	37	Night	Night	NNP
40439	178	38	and	and	CC
40439	178	39	Day	Day	NNP
40439	178	40	(	(	-LRB-
40439	178	41	that	that	RB
40439	178	42	is	is	RB
40439	178	43	,	,	,
40439	178	44	a	a	DT
40439	178	45	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	178	46	day	day	NN
40439	178	47	,	,	,
40439	178	48	or	or	CC
40439	178	49	day	day	NN
40439	178	50	of	of	IN
40439	178	51	time	time	NN
40439	178	52	)	)	-RRB-
40439	178	53	is	be	VBZ
40439	178	54	a	a	DT
40439	178	55	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	178	56	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	178	57	of	of	IN
40439	178	58	the	the	DT
40439	178	59	Heaven	Heaven	NNP
40439	178	60	from	from	IN
40439	178	61	East	East	NNP
40439	178	62	to	to	IN
40439	178	63	West	West	NNP
40439	178	64	,	,	,
40439	178	65	whereby	whereby	WRB
40439	178	66	accordingly	accordingly	RB
40439	178	67	the	the	DT
40439	178	68	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	178	69	is	be	VBZ
40439	178	70	assumed	assume	VBN
40439	178	71	as	as	IN
40439	178	72	at	at	IN
40439	178	73	rest	rest	NN
40439	178	74	:	:	:
40439	178	75	And	and	CC
40439	178	76	this	this	DT
40439	178	77	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	178	78	movement	movement	NN
40439	178	79	of	of	IN
40439	178	80	the	the	DT
40439	178	81	Heaven	Heaven	NNP
40439	178	82	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	178	83	has	have	VBZ
40439	178	84	taught	teach	VBN
40439	178	85	over	over	RB
40439	178	86	and	and	CC
40439	178	87	over	over	RB
40439	178	88	again	again	RB
40439	178	89	in	in	IN
40439	178	90	the	the	DT
40439	178	91	preceding	precede	VBG
40439	178	92	part	part	NN
40439	178	93	of	of	IN
40439	178	94	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	178	95	discourse	discourse	NN
40439	178	96	.	.	.
40439	178	97	"	"	''
40439	179	1	--"Since	--"since	NN
40439	179	2	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	179	3	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	179	4	calls	call	VBZ
40439	179	5	the	the	DT
40439	179	6	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	179	7	[	[	-LRB-
40439	179	8	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	179	9	:	:	:
40439	179	10	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	179	11	/	/	SYM
40439	179	12	nên	nên	NN
40439	179	13	]	]	-RRB-
40439	179	14	,	,	,
40439	179	15	not	not	RB
40439	179	16	[	[	-LRB-
40439	179	17	Greek	greek	NN
40439	179	18	:	:	:
40439	179	19	peri\	peri\	JJ
40439	179	20	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	179	21	e(autê	e(autê	NNP
40439	179	22	=	=	SYM
40439	179	23	s	s	NNP
40439	179	24	po	po	NNP
40439	179	25	/	/	SYM
40439	179	26	lon	lon	NN
40439	179	27	]	]	-RRB-
40439	179	28	,	,	,
40439	179	29	but	but	CC
40439	179	30	[	[	-LRB-
40439	179	31	Greek	greek	NN
40439	179	32	:	:	:
40439	179	33	peri\	peri\	NN
40439	179	34	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	179	35	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	179	36	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	179	37	po	po	NNP
40439	179	38	/	/	SYM
40439	179	39	lon	lon	NNP
40439	179	40	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	179	41	/	/	SYM
40439	179	42	non	non	AFX
40439	179	43	]	]	-RRB-
40439	179	44	,	,	,
40439	179	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	179	46	implies	imply	VBZ
40439	179	47	thereby	thereby	RB
40439	179	48	the	the	DT
40439	179	49	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	179	50	movement	movement	NN
40439	179	51	of	of	IN
40439	179	52	the	the	DT
40439	179	53	Heaven	Heaven	NNP
40439	179	54	.	.	.
40439	179	55	"	"	''
40439	179	56	]	]	-RRB-
40439	180	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	180	2	not	not	RB
40439	180	3	only	only	RB
40439	180	4	admit	admit	VBP
40439	180	5	but	but	CC
40439	180	6	put	put	VBD
40439	180	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	180	8	in	in	IN
40439	180	9	the	the	DT
40439	180	10	front	front	NN
40439	180	11	of	of	IN
40439	180	12	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	180	13	own	own	JJ
40439	180	14	case	case	NN
40439	180	15	,	,	,
40439	180	16	that	that	IN
40439	180	17	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	180	18	in	in	IN
40439	180	19	the	the	DT
40439	180	20	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	180	21	assumes	assume	VBZ
40439	180	22	the	the	DT
40439	180	23	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	180	24	movement	movement	NN
40439	180	25	of	of	IN
40439	180	26	the	the	DT
40439	180	27	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	180	28	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	180	29	;	;	:
40439	180	30	but	but	CC
40439	180	31	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	180	32	contend	contend	VBP
40439	180	33	that	that	IN
40439	180	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	180	35	also	also	RB
40439	180	36	assumes	assume	VBZ
40439	180	37	the	the	DT
40439	180	38	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	180	39	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	180	40	of	of	IN
40439	180	41	the	the	DT
40439	180	42	earth	earth	NN
40439	180	43	.	.	.
40439	181	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	181	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	181	3	founds	found	VBZ
40439	181	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	181	5	contrary	contrary	JJ
40439	181	6	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	181	7	upon	upon	IN
40439	181	8	the	the	DT
40439	181	9	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
40439	181	10	truth	truth	NN
40439	181	11	that	that	WDT
40439	181	12	these	these	DT
40439	181	13	two	two	CD
40439	181	14	assumptions	assumption	NNS
40439	181	15	are	be	VBP
40439	181	16	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
40439	181	17	;	;	:
40439	181	18	and	and	CC
40439	181	19	upon	upon	IN
40439	181	20	the	the	DT
40439	181	21	inference	inference	NN
40439	181	22	that	that	IN
40439	181	23	because	because	IN
40439	181	24	the	the	DT
40439	181	25	two	two	CD
40439	181	26	can	can	MD
40439	181	27	not	not	RB
40439	181	28	stand	stand	VB
40439	181	29	together	together	RB
40439	181	30	in	in	IN
40439	181	31	fact	fact	NN
40439	181	32	,	,	,
40439	181	33	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	181	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	181	35	can	can	MD
40439	181	36	not	not	RB
40439	181	37	have	have	VB
40439	181	38	stood	stand	VBN
40439	181	39	together	together	RB
40439	181	40	in	in	IN
40439	181	41	the	the	DT
40439	181	42	mind	mind	NN
40439	181	43	of	of	IN
40439	181	44	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	181	45	.	.	.
40439	182	1	In	in	IN
40439	182	2	that	that	DT
40439	182	3	inference	inference	NN
40439	182	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	182	5	have	have	VBP
40439	182	6	already	already	RB
40439	182	7	stated	state	VBN
40439	182	8	that	that	IN
40439	182	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	182	10	can	can	MD
40439	182	11	not	not	RB
40439	182	12	acquiesce	acquiesce	VB
40439	182	13	.	.	.
40439	183	1	But	but	CC
40439	183	2	while	while	IN
40439	183	3	M.	M.	NNP
40439	183	4	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	183	5	takes	take	VBZ
40439	183	6	so	so	RB
40439	183	7	much	much	JJ
40439	183	8	pains	pain	NNS
40439	183	9	to	to	TO
40439	183	10	vindicate	vindicate	VB
40439	183	11	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	183	12	from	from	IN
40439	183	13	one	one	CD
40439	183	14	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	183	15	,	,	,
40439	183	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	183	17	unconsciously	unconsciously	RB
40439	183	18	involves	involve	VBZ
40439	183	19	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	183	20	in	in	IN
40439	183	21	another	another	DT
40439	183	22	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	183	23	,	,	,
40439	183	24	for	for	IN
40439	183	25	which	which	WDT
40439	183	26	,	,	,
40439	183	27	in	in	IN
40439	183	28	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	183	29	judgment	judgment	NN
40439	183	30	,	,	,
40439	183	31	there	there	EX
40439	183	32	is	be	VBZ
40439	183	33	no	no	DT
40439	183	34	foundation	foundation	NN
40439	183	35	whatever	whatever	WDT
40439	183	36	.	.	.
40439	184	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	184	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	184	3	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	184	4	that	that	IN
40439	184	5	the	the	DT
40439	184	6	function	function	NN
40439	184	7	of	of	IN
40439	184	8	the	the	DT
40439	184	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	184	10	(	(	-LRB-
40439	184	11	in	in	IN
40439	184	12	the	the	DT
40439	184	13	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	184	14	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	184	15	)	)	-RRB-
40439	184	16	is	be	VBZ
40439	184	17	to	to	TO
40439	184	18	put	put	VB
40439	184	19	forth	forth	RP
40439	184	20	a	a	DT
40439	184	21	great	great	JJ
40439	184	22	force	force	NN
40439	184	23	of	of	IN
40439	184	24	passive	passive	NNP
40439	184	25	resistance--"to	resistance--"to	NNP
40439	184	26	oppose	oppose	VBP
40439	184	27	constantly	constantly	RB
40439	184	28	,	,	,
40439	184	29	against	against	IN
40439	184	30	the	the	DT
40439	184	31	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	184	32	movement	movement	NN
40439	184	33	of	of	IN
40439	184	34	the	the	DT
40439	184	35	heavens	heavens	NNPS
40439	184	36	,	,	,
40439	184	37	an	an	DT
40439	184	38	equal	equal	JJ
40439	184	39	force	force	NN
40439	184	40	in	in	IN
40439	184	41	an	an	DT
40439	184	42	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	184	43	direction	direction	NN
40439	184	44	.	.	.
40439	184	45	"	"	''
40439	185	1	Is	be	VBZ
40439	185	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	185	3	not	not	RB
40439	185	4	plain	plain	JJ
40439	185	5	,	,	,
40439	185	6	upon	upon	IN
40439	185	7	this	this	DT
40439	185	8	supposition	supposition	NN
40439	185	9	,	,	,
40439	185	10	that	that	IN
40439	185	11	the	the	DT
40439	185	12	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	185	13	would	would	MD
40439	185	14	come	come	VB
40439	185	15	to	to	IN
40439	185	16	a	a	DT
40439	185	17	standstill	standstill	NN
40439	185	18	,	,	,
40439	185	19	and	and	CC
40439	185	20	that	that	IN
40439	185	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	185	22	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	185	23	would	would	MD
40439	185	24	cease	cease	VB
40439	185	25	altogether	altogether	RB
40439	185	26	?	?	.
40439	186	1	As	as	IN
40439	186	2	the	the	DT
40439	186	3	earth	earth	NN
40439	186	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	186	5	packed	pack	VBN
40439	186	6	close	close	RB
40439	186	7	or	or	CC
40439	186	8	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	186	9	round	round	IN
40439	186	10	the	the	DT
40439	186	11	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	186	12	axis	axi	NNS
40439	186	13	,	,	,
40439	186	14	so	so	CC
40439	186	15	,	,	,
40439	186	16	if	if	IN
40439	186	17	the	the	DT
40439	186	18	axis	axis	NN
40439	186	19	endeavours	endeavour	VBZ
40439	186	20	to	to	TO
40439	186	21	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	186	22	with	with	IN
40439	186	23	a	a	DT
40439	186	24	given	give	VBN
40439	186	25	force	force	NN
40439	186	26	,	,	,
40439	186	27	and	and	CC
40439	186	28	the	the	DT
40439	186	29	earth	earth	NN
40439	186	30	resists	resist	VBZ
40439	186	31	with	with	IN
40439	186	32	equal	equal	JJ
40439	186	33	force	force	NN
40439	186	34	,	,	,
40439	186	35	the	the	DT
40439	186	36	effect	effect	NN
40439	186	37	will	will	MD
40439	186	38	be	be	VB
40439	186	39	that	that	IN
40439	186	40	the	the	DT
40439	186	41	two	two	CD
40439	186	42	forces	force	NNS
40439	186	43	will	will	MD
40439	186	44	destroy	destroy	VB
40439	186	45	one	one	CD
40439	186	46	another	another	DT
40439	186	47	,	,	,
40439	186	48	and	and	CC
40439	186	49	that	that	IN
40439	186	50	neither	neither	CC
40439	186	51	the	the	DT
40439	186	52	earth	earth	NN
40439	186	53	nor	nor	CC
40439	186	54	the	the	DT
40439	186	55	axis	axi	NNS
40439	186	56	will	will	MD
40439	186	57	move	move	VB
40439	186	58	at	at	RB
40439	186	59	all	all	RB
40439	186	60	.	.	.
40439	187	1	There	there	EX
40439	187	2	would	would	MD
40439	187	3	be	be	VB
40439	187	4	the	the	DT
40439	187	5	same	same	JJ
40439	187	6	nullifying	nullifying	JJ
40439	187	7	antagonism	antagonism	NN
40439	187	8	as	as	IN
40439	187	9	if,--reverting	if,--reverting	CD
40439	187	10	to	to	IN
40439	187	11	the	the	DT
40439	187	12	analogous	analogous	JJ
40439	187	13	case	case	NN
40439	187	14	of	of	IN
40439	187	15	the	the	DT
40439	187	16	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	187	17	and	and	CC
40439	187	18	the	the	DT
40439	187	19	verticilli	verticilli	JJ
40439	187	20	(	(	-LRB-
40439	187	21	already	already	RB
40439	187	22	alluded	allude	VBN
40439	187	23	to	to	IN
40439	187	24	)	)	-RRB-
40439	187	25	in	in	IN
40439	187	26	the	the	DT
40439	187	27	tenth	tenth	JJ
40439	187	28	book	book	NN
40439	187	29	of	of	IN
40439	187	30	the	the	DT
40439	187	31	Republic,--as	republic,--as	NN
40439	187	32	if	if	IN
40439	187	33	,	,	,
40439	187	34	while	while	IN
40439	187	35	Ananké	Ananké	NNP
40439	187	36	turned	turn	VBD
40439	187	37	the	the	DT
40439	187	38	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	187	39	with	with	IN
40439	187	40	a	a	DT
40439	187	41	given	give	VBN
40439	187	42	force	force	NN
40439	187	43	in	in	IN
40439	187	44	one	one	CD
40439	187	45	direction	direction	NN
40439	187	46	,	,	,
40439	187	47	Klotho	Klotho	NNP
40439	187	48	(	(	-LRB-
40439	187	49	instead	instead	RB
40439	187	50	of	of	IN
40439	187	51	lending	lending	NN
40439	187	52	assistance	assistance	NN
40439	187	53	)	)	-RRB-
40439	187	54	were	be	VBD
40439	187	55	to	to	TO
40439	187	56	apply	apply	VB
40439	187	57	her	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	187	58	hand	hand	NN
40439	187	59	to	to	IN
40439	187	60	the	the	DT
40439	187	61	outermost	outermost	JJ
40439	187	62	verticillus	verticillus	NN
40439	187	63	with	with	IN
40439	187	64	equal	equal	JJ
40439	187	65	force	force	NN
40439	187	66	of	of	IN
40439	187	67	resistance	resistance	NN
40439	187	68	in	in	IN
40439	187	69	the	the	DT
40439	187	70	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	187	71	direction	direction	NN
40439	187	72	(	(	-LRB-
40439	187	73	see	see	VB
40439	187	74	Reipubl	Reipubl	NNS
40439	187	75	.	.	.
40439	188	1	x.	x.	NNP
40439	188	2	p.	p.	NN
40439	188	3	617	617	CD
40439	188	4	D	D	NNP
40439	188	5	)	)	-RRB-
40439	188	6	.	.	.
40439	189	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	189	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	189	3	plain	plain	JJ
40439	189	4	that	that	IN
40439	189	5	the	the	DT
40439	189	6	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	189	7	would	would	MD
40439	189	8	never	never	RB
40439	189	9	turn	turn	VB
40439	189	10	at	at	RB
40439	189	11	all	all	RB
40439	189	12	.	.	.
40439	190	1	Here	here	RB
40439	190	2	,	,	,
40439	190	3	then	then	RB
40439	190	4	,	,	,
40439	190	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	190	6	a	a	DT
40439	190	7	grave	grave	JJ
40439	190	8	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	190	9	attaching	attach	VBG
40439	190	10	to	to	IN
40439	190	11	the	the	DT
40439	190	12	view	view	NN
40439	190	13	of	of	IN
40439	190	14	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	190	15	and	and	CC
40439	190	16	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	190	17	as	as	IN
40439	190	18	to	to	IN
40439	190	19	the	the	DT
40439	190	20	function	function	NN
40439	190	21	of	of	IN
40439	190	22	the	the	DT
40439	190	23	earth	earth	NN
40439	190	24	.	.	.
40439	191	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
40439	191	2	have	have	VBP
40439	191	3	not	not	RB
40439	191	4	,	,	,
40439	191	5	in	in	IN
40439	191	6	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	191	7	judgment	judgment	NN
40439	191	8	,	,	,
40439	191	9	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
40439	191	10	investigated	investigate	VBD
40439	191	11	the	the	DT
40439	191	12	manner	manner	NN
40439	191	13	in	in	IN
40439	191	14	which	which	WDT
40439	191	15	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	191	16	represents	represent	VBZ
40439	191	17	to	to	IN
40439	191	18	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	191	19	the	the	DT
40439	191	20	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	191	21	axis	axis	NN
40439	191	22	:	:	:
40439	191	23	nor	nor	CC
40439	191	24	have	have	VB
40439	191	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	191	26	fully	fully	RB
40439	191	27	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
40439	191	28	what	what	WP
40439	191	29	is	be	VBZ
40439	191	30	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	191	31	or	or	CC
40439	191	32	implied	imply	VBN
40439	191	33	in	in	IN
40439	191	34	the	the	DT
40439	191	35	debated	debate	VBN
40439	191	36	word	word	NN
40439	191	37	[	[	-LRB-
40439	191	38	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	191	39	:	:	:
40439	191	40	ei(lo	ei(lo	NNP
40439	191	41	/	/	SYM
40439	191	42	menon	menon	NNP
40439	191	43	--	--	NNP
40439	191	44	ei(lou	ei(lou	NNP
40439	191	45	/	/	SYM
40439	191	46	menon	menon	NNP
40439	191	47	--	--	:
40439	191	48	i)llo	i)llo	NNP
40439	191	49	/	/	SYM
40439	191	50	menon	menon	NNP
40439	191	51	]	]	-RRB-
40439	191	52	.	.	.
40439	192	1	That	that	DT
40439	192	2	word	word	NN
40439	192	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	192	4	been	be	VBN
40439	192	5	explained	explain	VBN
40439	192	6	partly	partly	RB
40439	192	7	by	by	IN
40439	192	8	Ruhnken	Ruhnken	NNP
40439	192	9	in	in	IN
40439	192	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	192	11	notes	note	NNS
40439	192	12	on	on	IN
40439	192	13	Timæi	Timæi	NNP
40439	192	14	Lexicon	Lexicon	NNP
40439	192	15	,	,	,
40439	192	16	but	but	CC
40439	192	17	still	still	RB
40439	192	18	more	more	JJR
40439	192	19	by	by	IN
40439	192	20	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	192	21	in	in	IN
40439	192	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	192	23	Lexilogus	Lexilogus	NNP
40439	192	24	,	,	,
40439	192	25	so	so	RB
40439	192	26	accurately	accurately	RB
40439	192	27	and	and	CC
40439	192	28	copiously	copiously	RB
40439	192	29	as	as	IN
40439	192	30	to	to	TO
40439	192	31	leave	leave	VB
40439	192	32	nothing	nothing	NN
40439	192	33	further	further	RB
40439	192	34	wanting	want	VBG
40439	192	35	.	.	.
40439	193	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	193	2	accept	accept	VBP
40439	193	3	fully	fully	RB
40439	193	4	the	the	DT
40439	193	5	explanation	explanation	NN
40439	193	6	given	give	VBN
40439	193	7	by	by	IN
40439	193	8	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	193	9	,	,	,
40439	193	10	and	and	CC
40439	193	11	have	have	VBP
40439	193	12	followed	follow	VBN
40439	193	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	193	14	throughout	throughout	IN
40439	193	15	this	this	DT
40439	193	16	article	article	NN
40439	193	17	.	.	.
40439	194	1	After	after	IN
40439	194	2	going	go	VBG
40439	194	3	over	over	IN
40439	194	4	many	many	JJ
40439	194	5	other	other	JJ
40439	194	6	examples	example	NNS
40439	194	7	,	,	,
40439	194	8	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	194	9	comes	come	VBZ
40439	194	10	to	to	TO
40439	194	11	consider	consider	VB
40439	194	12	this	this	DT
40439	194	13	passage	passage	NN
40439	194	14	of	of	IN
40439	194	15	the	the	DT
40439	194	16	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	194	17	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	194	18	;	;	:
40439	194	19	and	and	CC
40439	194	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	194	21	explains	explain	VBZ
40439	194	22	the	the	DT
40439	194	23	word	word	NN
40439	194	24	[	[	-LRB-
40439	194	25	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	194	26	:	:	:
40439	194	27	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	194	28	/	/	SYM
40439	194	29	nên	nên	NN
40439	194	30	]	]	-RRB-
40439	194	31	or	or	CC
40439	194	32	[	[	-LRB-
40439	194	33	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	194	34	:	:	:
40439	194	35	i)llo	i)llo	NNP
40439	194	36	/	/	SYM
40439	194	37	menên	menên	NNP
40439	194	38	]	]	-RRB-
40439	194	39	as	as	IN
40439	194	40	meaning--"_sich	meaning--"_sich	NNP
40439	194	41	drängen	drängen	NNP
40439	194	42	oder	oder	NNP
40439	194	43	gedrängt	gedrängt	NNP
40439	194	44	werden	werden	VBN
40439	194	45	_	_	NNP
40439	194	46	um	um	UH
40439	194	47	die	die	VB
40439	194	48	Axe	Axe	NNP
40439	194	49	:	:	:
40439	194	50	d.	d.	NNP
40439	194	51	h.	h.	NNP
40439	194	52	von	von	NNP
40439	194	53	allen	allen	NNP
40439	194	54	Seiten	Seiten	NNP
40439	194	55	her	-PRON-	PRP
40439	194	56	an	an	DT
40439	194	57	die	die	NN
40439	194	58	Axe	Axe	NNP
40439	194	59	.	.	.
40439	195	1	Auch	Auch	NNP
40439	195	2	lasse	lasse	NN
40439	195	3	man	man	NN
40439	195	4	sich	sich	NNP
40439	195	5	das	das	NNP
40439	195	6	Praesens	Praesens	NNP
40439	195	7	nicht	nicht	NN
40439	195	8	irren	irren	NNS
40439	195	9	:	:	:
40439	195	10	die	die	VB
40439	195	11	Kräfte	Kräfte	NNP
40439	195	12	,	,	,
40439	195	13	welche	welche	NNP
40439	195	14	den	den	NN
40439	195	15	Weltbau	Weltbau	NNP
40439	195	16	machen	machen	NNP
40439	195	17	und	und	NNP
40439	195	18	zusammen	zusammen	NNP
40439	195	19	halten	halten	NNP
40439	195	20	,	,	,
40439	195	21	sind	sind	JJ
40439	195	22	als	als	NN
40439	195	23	fortdauernd	fortdauernd	NN
40439	195	24	thätig	thätig	NN
40439	195	25	gedacht	gedacht	NNP
40439	195	26	.	.	.
40439	196	1	Die	die	VB
40439	196	2	Erde	Erde	NNP
40439	196	3	drängt	drängt	NNP
40439	196	4	sich	sich	NN
40439	196	5	(	(	-LRB-
40439	196	6	ununterbrochen	ununterbrochen	NNP
40439	196	7	)	)	-RRB-
40439	196	8	an	an	DT
40439	196	9	den	den	NN
40439	196	10	Pol	Pol	NNP
40439	196	11	,	,	,
40439	196	12	_	_	NNP
40439	196	13	macht	macht	NNP
40439	196	14	,	,	,
40439	196	15	bildet	bildet	NNP
40439	196	16	eine	eine	NN
40439	196	17	Kugel	Kugel	NNP
40439	196	18	um	um	UH
40439	196	19	ihn	ihn	NNP
40439	196	20	_	_	NNP
40439	196	21	.	.	.
40439	197	1	Welcher	Welcher	NNP
40439	197	2	Gebrauch	Gebrauch	NNP
40439	197	3	völlig	völlig	NNP
40439	197	4	entspricht	entspricht	NN
40439	197	5	dem	dem	NNP
40439	197	6	wonach	wonach	NNP
40439	197	7	dasselbe	dasselbe	NNP
40439	197	8	Verbum	Verbum	NNP
40439	197	9	ein	ein	NNP
40439	197	10	_	_	NNP
40439	197	11	einwickeln	einwickeln	NN
40439	197	12	_	_	NNP
40439	197	13	,	,	,
40439	197	14	_	_	NNP
40439	197	15	einhüllen	einhüllen	NN
40439	197	16	_	_	NNP
40439	197	17	,	,	,
40439	197	18	bedeutet	bedeutet	NN
40439	197	19	.	.	.
40439	198	1	Auch	Auch	NNP
40439	198	2	hier	hi	JJR
40439	198	3	mengt	mengt	NN
40439	198	4	sich	sich	VBZ
40439	198	5	in	in	IN
40439	198	6	der	der	NN
40439	198	7	Vorstellung	Vorstellung	NNP
40439	198	8	einiges	einige	VBZ
40439	198	9	hinzu	hinzu	NN
40439	198	10	,	,	,
40439	198	11	was	be	VBD
40439	198	12	auf	auf	NNP
40439	198	13	ein	ein	NNP
40439	198	14	_	_	NNP
40439	198	15	biegen	biegen	NNP
40439	198	16	_	_	NNP
40439	198	17	_	_	NNP
40439	198	18	winden	winden	NNP
40439	198	19	_	_	NNP
40439	198	20	,	,	,
40439	198	21	und	und	JJ
40439	198	22	mitunter	mitunter	NN
40439	198	23	auf	auf	NNP
40439	198	24	ein	ein	NNP
40439	198	25	_	_	NNP
40439	198	26	drehen	drehen	NNP
40439	198	27	_	_	NNP
40439	198	28	führt	führt	NN
40439	198	29	:	:	:
40439	198	30	was	be	VBD
40439	198	31	aber	aber	NNP
40439	198	32	_	_	NNP
40439	198	33	überall	überall	NNP
40439	198	34	nur	nur	NNP
40439	198	35	ein	ein	NNP
40439	198	36	durch	durch	NN
40439	198	37	die	die	VBP
40439	198	38	Sache	Sache	NNP
40439	198	39	selbst	selbst	NN
40439	198	40	hinzutretender	hinzutretender	NN
40439	198	41	Begriff	Begriff	NNP
40439	198	42	ist	ist	NNP
40439	198	43	_	_	NNP
40439	198	44	,	,	,
40439	198	45	"	"	''
40439	198	46	p.	p.	NN
40439	198	47	151	151	CD
40439	198	48	.	.	.
40439	199	1	And	and	CC
40439	199	2	again	again	RB
40439	199	3	,	,	,
40439	199	4	p.	p.	NN
40439	199	5	154	154	CD
40439	199	6	,	,	,
40439	199	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	199	8	gives	give	VBZ
40439	199	9	the	the	DT
40439	199	10	result	result	NN
40439	199	11	--	--	:
40439	199	12	that	that	IN
40439	199	13	the	the	DT
40439	199	14	word	word	NN
40439	199	15	has	have	VBZ
40439	199	16	only	only	RB
40439	199	17	"	"	''
40439	199	18	die	die	NN
40439	199	19	Bedeutung	Bedeutung	NNP
40439	199	20	_	_	NNP
40439	199	21	drängen	drängen	NN
40439	199	22	_	_	NNP
40439	199	23	,	,	,
40439	199	24	_	_	NNP
40439	199	25	befestigen	befestigen	NNP
40439	199	26	_	_	NNP
40439	199	27	,	,	,
40439	199	28	nebst	nebst	NNP
40439	199	29	den	den	NNP
40439	199	30	davon	davon	NNP
40439	199	31	ausgehenden	ausgehenden	NNP
40439	199	32	--	--	:
40439	199	33	die	die	VBP
40439	199	34	von	von	NNP
40439	199	35	_	_	NNP
40439	199	36	drehen	drehen	NNP
40439	199	37	_	_	NNP
40439	199	38	,	,	,
40439	199	39	_	_	NNP
40439	199	40	winden	winden	NNP
40439	199	41	_	_	NNP
40439	199	42	,	,	,
40439	199	43	aber	aber	NNP
40439	199	44	ihm	ihm	NNP
40439	199	45	_	_	NNP
40439	199	46	gänzlich	gänzlich	NNP
40439	199	47	fremd	fremd	NNP
40439	199	48	_	_	NNP
40439	199	49	sind	sind	NN
40439	199	50	,	,	,
40439	199	51	_	_	NNP
40439	199	52	und	und	NNP
40439	199	53	nur	nur	NNP
40439	199	54	aus	aus	NNP
40439	199	55	der	der	NNP
40439	199	56	Natur	Natur	NNP
40439	199	57	der	der	NNP
40439	199	58	Gegenstände	Gegenstände	NNP
40439	199	59	in	in	IN
40439	199	60	einigen	einigen	NNP
40439	199	61	Fällen	Fällen	NNP
40439	199	62	als	als	NNP
40439	199	63	Nebengedanken	Nebengedanken	NNP
40439	199	64	hinzutreten	hinzutreten	NNP
40439	199	65	_	_	NNP
40439	199	66	.	.	.
40439	200	1	"	"	``
40439	200	2	[	[	-LRB-
40439	200	3	3	3	CD
40439	200	4	]	]	-RRB-
40439	200	5	[	[	-LRB-
40439	200	6	Footnote	footnote	NN
40439	200	7	3	3	CD
40439	200	8	:	:	:
40439	200	9	"	"	``
40439	200	10	To	To	NNP
40439	200	11	_	_	NNP
40439	200	12	pack	pack	VB
40439	200	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	200	14	_	_	NNP
40439	200	15	,	,	,
40439	200	16	or	or	CC
40439	200	17	to	to	IN
40439	200	18	_	_	NNP
40439	200	19	be	be	VB
40439	200	20	packed	pack	VBN
40439	200	21	_	_	NNP
40439	200	22	,	,	,
40439	200	23	round	round	IN
40439	200	24	the	the	DT
40439	200	25	axis	axi	NNS
40439	200	26	:	:	:
40439	200	27	that	that	DT
40439	200	28	is	is	RB
40439	200	29	,	,	,
40439	200	30	upon	upon	IN
40439	200	31	the	the	DT
40439	200	32	axis	axis	NN
40439	200	33	from	from	IN
40439	200	34	all	all	DT
40439	200	35	sides	side	NNS
40439	200	36	.	.	.
40439	201	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	201	2	must	must	MD
40439	201	3	not	not	RB
40439	201	4	be	be	VB
40439	201	5	misled	mislead	VBN
40439	201	6	by	by	IN
40439	201	7	the	the	DT
40439	201	8	present	present	JJ
40439	201	9	tense	tense	NN
40439	201	10	:	:	:
40439	201	11	for	for	IN
40439	201	12	the	the	DT
40439	201	13	forces	force	NNS
40439	201	14	,	,	,
40439	201	15	which	which	WDT
40439	201	16	compose	compose	VBP
40439	201	17	and	and	CC
40439	201	18	hold	hold	VBP
40439	201	19	together	together	RP
40439	201	20	the	the	DT
40439	201	21	structure	structure	NN
40439	201	22	of	of	IN
40439	201	23	the	the	DT
40439	201	24	universe	universe	NN
40439	201	25	,	,	,
40439	201	26	are	be	VBP
40439	201	27	conceived	conceive	VBN
40439	201	28	as	as	RB
40439	201	29	continuously	continuously	RB
40439	201	30	in	in	IN
40439	201	31	active	active	JJ
40439	201	32	operation	operation	NN
40439	201	33	.	.	.
40439	202	1	The	the	DT
40439	202	2	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	202	3	_	_	NNP
40439	202	4	packs	pack	VBZ
40439	202	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	202	6	_	_	VBD
40439	202	7	,	,	,
40439	202	8	or	or	CC
40439	202	9	_	_	NNP
40439	202	10	is	be	VBZ
40439	202	11	packed	pack	VBN
40439	202	12	_	_	NNP
40439	202	13	,	,	,
40439	202	14	on	on	IN
40439	202	15	to	to	IN
40439	202	16	the	the	DT
40439	202	17	axis--_makes	axis--_makes	IN
40439	202	18	or	or	CC
40439	202	19	forms	form	VBZ
40439	202	20	a	a	DT
40439	202	21	ball	ball	NN
40439	202	22	round	round	IN
40439	202	23	the	the	DT
40439	202	24	axis	axi	NNS
40439	202	25	:	:	:
40439	202	26	_	_	XX
40439	202	27	which	which	WDT
40439	202	28	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
40439	202	29	fully	fully	RB
40439	202	30	to	to	IN
40439	202	31	that	that	DT
40439	202	32	other	other	JJ
40439	202	33	usage	usage	NN
40439	202	34	of	of	IN
40439	202	35	the	the	DT
40439	202	36	word	word	NN
40439	202	37	,	,	,
40439	202	38	in	in	IN
40439	202	39	the	the	DT
40439	202	40	sense	sense	NN
40439	202	41	of	of	IN
40439	202	42	_	_	NNP
40439	202	43	wrapping	wrap	VBG
40439	202	44	up	up	RP
40439	202	45	_	_	NNP
40439	202	46	or	or	CC
40439	202	47	_	_	NNP
40439	202	48	swathing	swathe	VBG
40439	202	49	round	round	NN
40439	202	50	_	_	NNP
40439	202	51	.	.	.
40439	203	1	Here	here	RB
40439	203	2	too	too	RB
40439	203	3	there	there	EX
40439	203	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	203	5	a	a	DT
40439	203	6	superadded	superadded	JJ
40439	203	7	something	something	NN
40439	203	8	blended	blend	VBN
40439	203	9	with	with	IN
40439	203	10	the	the	DT
40439	203	11	idea	idea	NN
40439	203	12	,	,	,
40439	203	13	which	which	WDT
40439	203	14	conducts	conduct	VBZ
40439	203	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	203	16	to	to	IN
40439	203	17	_	_	NNP
40439	203	18	turning	turn	VBG
40439	203	19	_	_	NNP
40439	203	20	,	,	,
40439	203	21	_	_	NNP
40439	203	22	winding	wind	VBG
40439	203	23	_	_	NNP
40439	203	24	,	,	,
40439	203	25	and	and	CC
40439	203	26	thus	thus	RB
40439	203	27	to	to	IN
40439	203	28	_	_	NNP
40439	203	29	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	203	30	_	_	NNP
40439	203	31	:	:	:
40439	203	32	but	but	CC
40439	203	33	this	this	DT
40439	203	34	is	be	VBZ
40439	203	35	every	every	DT
40439	203	36	where	where	WRB
40439	203	37	nothing	nothing	NN
40439	203	38	more	more	JJR
40439	203	39	than	than	IN
40439	203	40	an	an	DT
40439	203	41	accessory	accessory	JJ
40439	203	42	notion	notion	NN
40439	203	43	,	,	,
40439	203	44	suggested	suggest	VBN
40439	203	45	by	by	IN
40439	203	46	the	the	DT
40439	203	47	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	203	48	of	of	IN
40439	203	49	the	the	DT
40439	203	50	case	case	NN
40439	203	51	.	.	.
40439	204	1	The	the	DT
40439	204	2	word	word	NN
40439	204	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	204	4	only	only	RB
40439	204	5	the	the	DT
40439	204	6	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	204	7	,	,	,
40439	204	8	to	to	IN
40439	204	9	_	_	NNP
40439	204	10	pack	pack	NN
40439	204	11	_	_	NNP
40439	204	12	,	,	,
40439	204	13	to	to	IN
40439	204	14	_	_	NNP
40439	204	15	fasten_--the	fasten_--the	DT
40439	204	16	senses	sense	NNS
40439	204	17	,	,	,
40439	204	18	to	to	IN
40439	204	19	_	_	NNP
40439	204	20	wind	wind	NN
40439	204	21	_	_	NNP
40439	204	22	,	,	,
40439	204	23	to	to	IN
40439	204	24	_	_	NNP
40439	204	25	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	204	26	_	_	NNP
40439	204	27	,	,	,
40439	204	28	are	be	VBP
40439	204	29	altogether	altogether	RB
40439	204	30	foreign	foreign	JJ
40439	204	31	to	to	IN
40439	204	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	204	33	,	,	,
40439	204	34	and	and	CC
40439	204	35	can	can	MD
40439	204	36	only	only	RB
40439	204	37	be	be	VB
40439	204	38	superadded	superadde	VBN
40439	204	39	as	as	IN
40439	204	40	accessory	accessory	JJ
40439	204	41	ideas	idea	NNS
40439	204	42	,	,	,
40439	204	43	in	in	IN
40439	204	44	certain	certain	JJ
40439	204	45	particular	particular	JJ
40439	204	46	instances	instance	NNS
40439	204	47	,	,	,
40439	204	48	by	by	IN
40439	204	49	the	the	DT
40439	204	50	special	special	JJ
40439	204	51	nature	nature	NN
40439	204	52	of	of	IN
40439	204	53	the	the	DT
40439	204	54	case	case	NN
40439	204	55	.	.	.
40439	204	56	"	"	''
40439	204	57	]	]	-RRB-
40439	205	1	In	in	IN
40439	205	2	these	these	DT
40439	205	3	last	last	JJ
40439	205	4	words	word	NNS
40439	205	5	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	205	6	has	have	VBZ
40439	205	7	exactly	exactly	RB
40439	205	8	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
40439	205	9	the	the	DT
40439	205	10	true	true	JJ
40439	205	11	,	,	,
40439	205	12	constant	constant	JJ
40439	205	13	,	,	,
40439	205	14	and	and	CC
40439	205	15	essential	essential	JJ
40439	205	16	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	205	17	of	of	IN
40439	205	18	the	the	DT
40439	205	19	word	word	NN
40439	205	20	,	,	,
40439	205	21	from	from	IN
40439	205	22	the	the	DT
40439	205	23	casual	casual	JJ
40439	205	24	accessories	accessory	NNS
40439	205	25	which	which	WDT
40439	205	26	become	become	VBP
40439	205	27	conjoined	conjoin	VBN
40439	205	28	with	with	IN
40439	205	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	205	30	by	by	IN
40439	205	31	the	the	DT
40439	205	32	special	special	JJ
40439	205	33	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	205	34	of	of	IN
40439	205	35	some	some	DT
40439	205	36	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
40439	205	37	cases	case	NNS
40439	205	38	.	.	.
40439	206	1	The	the	DT
40439	206	2	constant	constant	JJ
40439	206	3	and	and	CC
40439	206	4	true	true	JJ
40439	206	5	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	206	6	of	of	IN
40439	206	7	the	the	DT
40439	206	8	word	word	NN
40439	206	9	is	be	VBZ
40439	206	10	,	,	,
40439	206	11	_	_	NNP
40439	206	12	being	be	VBG
40439	206	13	packed	pack	VBN
40439	206	14	or	or	CC
40439	206	15	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	206	16	close	close	RB
40439	206	17	round	round	NN
40439	206	18	_	_	NNP
40439	206	19	,	,	,
40439	206	20	_	_	NNP
40439	206	21	squeezing	squeeze	VBG
40439	206	22	or	or	CC
40439	206	23	grasping	grasp	VBG
40439	206	24	around	around	IN
40439	206	25	_	_	NNP
40439	206	26	.	.	.
40439	207	1	The	the	DT
40439	207	2	idea	idea	NN
40439	207	3	of	of	IN
40439	207	4	_	_	NNP
40439	207	5	rotating	rotate	VBG
40439	207	6	_	_	NNP
40439	207	7	or	or	CC
40439	207	8	_	_	NNP
40439	207	9	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	207	10	_	_	NNP
40439	207	11	is	be	VBZ
40439	207	12	quite	quite	RB
40439	207	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
40439	207	14	to	to	IN
40439	207	15	this	this	DT
40439	207	16	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	207	17	,	,	,
40439	207	18	but	but	CC
40439	207	19	may	may	MD
40439	207	20	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
40439	207	21	become	become	VB
40439	207	22	conjoined	conjoin	VBN
40439	207	23	with	with	IN
40439	207	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	207	25	,	,	,
40439	207	26	in	in	IN
40439	207	27	certain	certain	JJ
40439	207	28	particular	particular	JJ
40439	207	29	cases	case	NNS
40439	207	30	,	,	,
40439	207	31	by	by	IN
40439	207	32	accidental	accidental	JJ
40439	207	33	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	207	34	.	.	.
40439	208	1	Let	let	VB
40439	208	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	208	3	illustrate	illustrate	VB
40439	208	4	this	this	DT
40439	208	5	.	.	.
40439	209	1	When	when	WRB
40439	209	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	209	3	say	say	VBP
40439	209	4	that	that	IN
40439	209	5	a	a	DT
40439	209	6	body	body	NN
40439	209	7	_	_	NNP
40439	209	8	A	A	NNP
40439	209	9	_	_	NNP
40439	209	10	is	be	VBZ
40439	209	11	[	[	-LRB-
40439	209	12	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	209	13	:	:	:
40439	209	14	ei(lo	ei(lo	NNP
40439	209	15	/	/	SYM
40439	209	16	menon	menon	NNP
40439	209	17	]	]	-RRB-
40439	209	18	or	or	CC
40439	209	19	[	[	-LRB-
40439	209	20	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	209	21	:	:	:
40439	209	22	i)llo	i)llo	NNP
40439	209	23	/	/	SYM
40439	209	24	menon	menon	NNP
40439	209	25	]	]	-RRB-
40439	209	26	(	(	-LRB-
40439	209	27	packed	pack	VBN
40439	209	28	or	or	CC
40439	209	29	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	209	30	close	close	JJ
40439	209	31	round	round	NN
40439	209	32	,	,	,
40439	209	33	squeezing	squeeze	VBG
40439	209	34	or	or	CC
40439	209	35	grasping	grasp	VBG
40439	209	36	around	around	RB
40439	209	37	)	)	-RRB-
40439	209	38	,	,	,
40439	209	39	another	another	DT
40439	209	40	body	body	NN
40439	209	41	_	_	NNP
40439	209	42	B	B	NNP
40439	209	43	_	_	NNP
40439	209	44	,	,	,
40439	209	45	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	209	46	affirm	affirm	VBP
40439	209	47	nothing	nothing	NN
40439	209	48	about	about	IN
40439	209	49	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	209	50	or	or	CC
40439	209	51	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	209	52	.	.	.
40439	210	1	This	this	DT
40439	210	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	210	3	an	an	DT
40439	210	4	idea	idea	NN
40439	210	5	foreign	foreign	JJ
40439	210	6	to	to	IN
40439	210	7	the	the	DT
40439	210	8	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	210	9	_	_	NNP
40439	210	10	per	per	FW
40439	210	11	se	se	FW
40439	210	12	_	_	NNP
40439	210	13	,	,	,
40439	210	14	yet	yet	CC
40439	210	15	capable	capable	JJ
40439	210	16	of	of	IN
40439	210	17	being	be	VBG
40439	210	18	annexed	annex	VBN
40439	210	19	or	or	CC
40439	210	20	implicated	implicate	VBN
40439	210	21	with	with	IN
40439	210	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	210	23	under	under	IN
40439	210	24	some	some	DT
40439	210	25	accidental	accidental	JJ
40439	210	26	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	210	27	.	.	.
40439	211	1	Whether	whether	IN
40439	211	2	in	in	IN
40439	211	3	any	any	DT
40439	211	4	particular	particular	JJ
40439	211	5	case	case	NN
40439	211	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	211	7	be	be	VB
40439	211	8	so	so	RB
40439	211	9	implicated	implicated	JJ
40439	211	10	or	or	CC
40439	211	11	not	not	RB
40439	211	12	depends	depend	VBZ
40439	211	13	on	on	IN
40439	211	14	the	the	DT
40439	211	15	question	question	NN
40439	211	16	"	"	``
40439	211	17	What	what	WP
40439	211	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	211	19	the	the	DT
40439	211	20	nature	nature	NN
40439	211	21	of	of	IN
40439	211	22	the	the	DT
40439	211	23	body	body	NN
40439	211	24	_	_	NNP
40439	211	25	B	B	NNP
40439	211	26	_	_	NNP
40439	211	27	,	,	,
40439	211	28	round	round	IN
40439	211	29	which	which	WDT
40439	211	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	211	31	affirm	affirm	VBP
40439	211	32	_	_	NNP
40439	211	33	A	A	NNP
40439	211	34	_	_	NNP
40439	211	35	to	to	TO
40439	211	36	be	be	VB
40439	211	37	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	211	38	?	?	.
40439	211	39	"	"	''
40439	212	1	1	1	LS
40439	212	2	.	.	.
40439	213	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	213	2	may	may	MD
40439	213	3	be	be	VB
40439	213	4	an	an	DT
40439	213	5	oak	oak	NN
40439	213	6	tree	tree	NN
40439	213	7	or	or	CC
40439	213	8	a	a	DT
40439	213	9	pillar	pillar	NN
40439	213	10	,	,	,
40439	213	11	firmly	firmly	RB
40439	213	12	planted	planted	JJ
40439	213	13	and	and	CC
40439	213	14	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	213	15	.	.	.
40439	214	1	2	2	LS
40439	214	2	.	.	.
40439	215	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	215	2	may	may	MD
40439	215	3	be	be	VB
40439	215	4	some	some	DT
40439	215	5	other	other	JJ
40439	215	6	body	body	NN
40439	215	7	,	,	,
40439	215	8	moving	move	VBG
40439	215	9	,	,	,
40439	215	10	but	but	CC
40439	215	11	moving	move	VBG
40439	215	12	in	in	IN
40439	215	13	a	a	DT
40439	215	14	rectilinear	rectilinear	JJ
40439	215	15	direction	direction	NN
40439	215	16	.	.	.
40439	216	1	3	3	LS
40439	216	2	.	.	.
40439	217	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
40439	217	2	,	,	,
40439	217	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	217	4	may	may	MD
40439	217	5	be	be	VB
40439	217	6	a	a	DT
40439	217	7	body	body	NN
40439	217	8	rotating	rotate	VBG
40439	217	9	or	or	CC
40439	217	10	intended	intend	VBD
40439	217	11	to	to	TO
40439	217	12	rotate	rotate	VB
40439	217	13	,	,	,
40439	217	14	like	like	IN
40439	217	15	a	a	DT
40439	217	16	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	217	17	,	,	,
40439	217	18	a	a	DT
40439	217	19	spit	spit	NN
40439	217	20	,	,	,
40439	217	21	or	or	CC
40439	217	22	the	the	DT
40439	217	23	rolling	roll	VBG
40439	217	24	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	217	25	of	of	IN
40439	217	26	a	a	DT
40439	217	27	machine	machine	NN
40439	217	28	.	.	.
40439	218	1	In	in	IN
40439	218	2	the	the	DT
40439	218	3	first	first	JJ
40439	218	4	supposition	supposition	NN
40439	218	5	,	,	,
40439	218	6	all	all	DT
40439	218	7	motion	motion	NN
40439	218	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	218	9	excluded	exclude	VBN
40439	218	10	:	:	:
40439	218	11	in	in	IN
40439	218	12	the	the	DT
40439	218	13	second	second	JJ
40439	218	14	,	,	,
40439	218	15	rectilinear	rectilinear	JJ
40439	218	16	motion	motion	NN
40439	218	17	is	be	VBZ
40439	218	18	implied	imply	VBN
40439	218	19	,	,	,
40439	218	20	but	but	CC
40439	218	21	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	218	22	motion	motion	NN
40439	218	23	is	be	VBZ
40439	218	24	excluded	exclude	VBN
40439	218	25	:	:	:
40439	218	26	in	in	IN
40439	218	27	the	the	DT
40439	218	28	third	third	JJ
40439	218	29	,	,	,
40439	218	30	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	218	31	motion	motion	NN
40439	218	32	is	be	VBZ
40439	218	33	implied	imply	VBN
40439	218	34	as	as	IN
40439	218	35	a	a	DT
40439	218	36	certain	certain	JJ
40439	218	37	adjunct	adjunct	NN
40439	218	38	.	.	.
40439	219	1	The	the	DT
40439	219	2	body	body	NN
40439	219	3	which	which	WDT
40439	219	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	219	5	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	219	6	round	round	RB
40439	219	7	another	another	DT
40439	219	8	,	,	,
40439	219	9	must	must	MD
40439	219	10	share	share	VB
40439	219	11	the	the	DT
40439	219	12	motion	motion	NN
40439	219	13	or	or	CC
40439	219	14	the	the	DT
40439	219	15	rest	rest	NN
40439	219	16	of	of	IN
40439	219	17	that	that	DT
40439	219	18	other	other	JJ
40439	219	19	.	.	.
40439	220	1	If	if	IN
40439	220	2	the	the	DT
40439	220	3	body	body	NN
40439	220	4	_	_	NNP
40439	220	5	B	B	NNP
40439	220	6	_	_	NNP
40439	220	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	220	8	a	a	DT
40439	220	9	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	220	10	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	220	11	,	,	,
40439	220	12	and	and	CC
40439	220	13	if	if	IN
40439	220	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	220	15	affirm	affirm	VBP
40439	220	16	that	that	IN
40439	220	17	_	_	NNP
40439	220	18	A	A	NNP
40439	220	19	_	_	NNP
40439	220	20	is	be	VBZ
40439	220	21	packed	pack	VBN
40439	220	22	or	or	CC
40439	220	23	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	220	24	close	close	RB
40439	220	25	round	round	NN
40439	220	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	220	27	,	,	,
40439	220	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	220	29	introduce	introduce	VBP
40439	220	30	the	the	DT
40439	220	31	idea	idea	NN
40439	220	32	of	of	IN
40439	220	33	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	220	34	;	;	:
40439	220	35	though	though	IN
40439	220	36	only	only	RB
40439	220	37	as	as	IN
40439	220	38	an	an	DT
40439	220	39	accessory	accessory	NN
40439	220	40	and	and	CC
40439	220	41	implied	imply	VBN
40439	220	42	fact	fact	NN
40439	220	43	,	,	,
40439	220	44	in	in	IN
40439	220	45	addition	addition	NN
40439	220	46	to	to	IN
40439	220	47	that	that	DT
40439	220	48	which	which	WDT
40439	220	49	the	the	DT
40439	220	50	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	220	51	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	220	52	.	.	.
40439	221	1	The	the	DT
40439	221	2	body	body	NN
40439	221	3	_	_	NNP
40439	221	4	A	A	NNP
40439	221	5	_	_	NNP
40439	221	6	,	,	,
40439	221	7	being	be	VBG
40439	221	8	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	221	9	round	round	IN
40439	221	10	the	the	DT
40439	221	11	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	221	12	_	_	NNP
40439	221	13	B	B	NNP
40439	221	14	_	_	NNP
40439	221	15	,	,	,
40439	221	16	must	must	MD
40439	221	17	either	either	CC
40439	221	18	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	221	19	along	along	IN
40439	221	20	with	with	IN
40439	221	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	221	22	and	and	CC
40439	221	23	round	round	VB
40439	221	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	221	25	,	,	,
40439	221	26	or	or	CC
40439	221	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	221	28	must	must	MD
40439	221	29	arrest	arrest	VB
40439	221	30	the	the	DT
40439	221	31	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	221	32	of	of	IN
40439	221	33	_	_	NNP
40439	221	34	B	B	NNP
40439	221	35	_	_	NNP
40439	221	36	.	.	.
40439	222	1	If	if	IN
40439	222	2	the	the	DT
40439	222	3	one	one	NN
40439	222	4	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	222	5	,	,	,
40439	222	6	so	so	RB
40439	222	7	must	must	MD
40439	222	8	the	the	DT
40439	222	9	other	other	JJ
40439	222	10	;	;	:
40439	222	11	both	both	DT
40439	222	12	must	must	MD
40439	222	13	either	either	CC
40439	222	14	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	222	15	together	together	RB
40439	222	16	,	,	,
40439	222	17	or	or	CC
40439	222	18	stand	stand	VB
40439	222	19	still	still	RB
40439	222	20	together	together	RB
40439	222	21	.	.	.
40439	223	1	This	this	DT
40439	223	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	223	3	a	a	DT
40439	223	4	new	new	JJ
40439	223	5	fact	fact	NN
40439	223	6	,	,	,
40439	223	7	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	223	8	from	from	IN
40439	223	9	what	what	WP
40439	223	10	is	be	VBZ
40439	223	11	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	223	12	in	in	IN
40439	223	13	the	the	DT
40439	223	14	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	223	15	,	,	,
40439	223	16	yet	yet	CC
40439	223	17	implied	imply	VBN
40439	223	18	in	in	IN
40439	223	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	223	20	or	or	CC
40439	223	21	capable	capable	JJ
40439	223	22	of	of	IN
40439	223	23	being	be	VBG
40439	223	24	inferred	infer	VBN
40439	223	25	from	from	IN
40439	223	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	223	27	through	through	IN
40439	223	28	induction	induction	NN
40439	223	29	and	and	CC
40439	223	30	experience	experience	NN
40439	223	31	.	.	.
40439	224	1	Here	here	RB
40439	224	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	224	3	see	see	VBP
40439	224	4	exactly	exactly	RB
40439	224	5	the	the	DT
40439	224	6	position	position	NN
40439	224	7	of	of	IN
40439	224	8	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	224	9	in	in	IN
40439	224	10	regard	regard	NN
40439	224	11	to	to	IN
40439	224	12	the	the	DT
40439	224	13	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	224	14	of	of	IN
40439	224	15	the	the	DT
40439	224	16	earth	earth	NN
40439	224	17	.	.	.
40439	225	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	225	2	does	do	VBZ
40439	225	3	not	not	RB
40439	225	4	affirm	affirm	VB
40439	225	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	225	6	in	in	IN
40439	225	7	express	express	JJ
40439	225	8	terms	term	NNS
40439	225	9	,	,	,
40439	225	10	but	but	CC
40439	225	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	225	12	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	225	13	what	what	WP
40439	225	14	implies	imply	VBZ
40439	225	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	225	16	.	.	.
40439	226	1	For	for	IN
40439	226	2	when	when	WRB
40439	226	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	226	4	says	say	VBZ
40439	226	5	that	that	IN
40439	226	6	the	the	DT
40439	226	7	earth	earth	NN
40439	226	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	226	9	packed	pack	VBN
40439	226	10	,	,	,
40439	226	11	or	or	CC
40439	226	12	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	226	13	close	close	RB
40439	226	14	round	round	IN
40439	226	15	the	the	DT
40439	226	16	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	226	17	axis	axis	NN
40439	226	18	,	,	,
40439	226	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	226	20	conveys	convey	VBZ
40439	226	21	to	to	IN
40439	226	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	226	23	by	by	IN
40439	226	24	implication	implication	NN
40439	226	25	the	the	DT
40439	226	26	knowledge	knowledge	NN
40439	226	27	of	of	IN
40439	226	28	another	another	DT
40439	226	29	and	and	CC
40439	226	30	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	226	31	fact	fact	NN
40439	226	32	--	--	:
40439	226	33	that	that	IN
40439	226	34	the	the	DT
40439	226	35	earth	earth	NN
40439	226	36	and	and	CC
40439	226	37	the	the	DT
40439	226	38	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	226	39	axis	axi	NNS
40439	226	40	must	must	MD
40439	226	41	either	either	CC
40439	226	42	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	226	43	together	together	RB
40439	226	44	or	or	CC
40439	226	45	remain	remain	VB
40439	226	46	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	226	47	together	together	RB
40439	226	48	--	--	:
40439	226	49	that	that	IN
40439	226	50	the	the	DT
40439	226	51	earth	earth	NN
40439	226	52	must	must	MD
40439	226	53	either	either	CC
40439	226	54	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	226	55	along	along	IN
40439	226	56	with	with	IN
40439	226	57	the	the	DT
40439	226	58	axis	axi	NNS
40439	226	59	or	or	CC
40439	226	60	arrest	arrest	VB
40439	226	61	the	the	DT
40439	226	62	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	226	63	of	of	IN
40439	226	64	the	the	DT
40439	226	65	axis	axi	NNS
40439	226	66	.	.	.
40439	227	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	227	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	227	3	manifest	manifest	NN
40439	227	4	that	that	IN
40439	227	5	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	227	6	does	do	VBZ
40439	227	7	not	not	RB
40439	227	8	mean	mean	VB
40439	227	9	the	the	DT
40439	227	10	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	227	11	of	of	IN
40439	227	12	the	the	DT
40439	227	13	axis	axi	NNS
40439	227	14	of	of	IN
40439	227	15	the	the	DT
40439	227	16	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	227	17	to	to	TO
40439	227	18	be	be	VB
40439	227	19	arrested	arrest	VBN
40439	227	20	:	:	:
40439	227	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	227	22	are	be	VBP
40439	227	23	absolutely	absolutely	RB
40439	227	24	essential	essential	JJ
40439	227	25	to	to	IN
40439	227	26	the	the	DT
40439	227	27	scheme	scheme	NN
40439	227	28	of	of	IN
40439	227	29	the	the	DT
40439	227	30	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	227	31	--	--	:
40439	227	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	227	33	are	be	VBP
40439	227	34	the	the	DT
40439	227	35	grand	grand	JJ
40439	227	36	motive	motive	JJ
40439	227	37	-	-	HYPH
40439	227	38	agency	agency	NN
40439	227	39	of	of	IN
40439	227	40	the	the	DT
40439	227	41	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	227	42	.	.	.
40439	228	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	228	2	must	must	MD
40439	228	3	,	,	,
40439	228	4	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	228	5	,	,	,
40439	228	6	mean	mean	VB
40439	228	7	to	to	TO
40439	228	8	imply	imply	VB
40439	228	9	that	that	IN
40439	228	10	the	the	DT
40439	228	11	earth	earth	NN
40439	228	12	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	228	13	along	along	IN
40439	228	14	with	with	IN
40439	228	15	and	and	CC
40439	228	16	around	around	IN
40439	228	17	the	the	DT
40439	228	18	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	228	19	axis	axis	NN
40439	228	20	.	.	.
40439	229	1	And	and	CC
40439	229	2	thus	thus	RB
40439	229	3	the	the	DT
40439	229	4	word	word	NN
40439	229	5	[	[	-LRB-
40439	229	6	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	229	7	:	:	:
40439	229	8	ei(lo	ei(lo	NNP
40439	229	9	/	/	SYM
40439	229	10	menon	menon	NNP
40439	229	11	]	]	-RRB-
40439	229	12	or	or	CC
40439	229	13	[	[	-LRB-
40439	229	14	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	229	15	:	:	:
40439	229	16	i)llo	i)llo	NNP
40439	229	17	/	/	SYM
40439	229	18	menon	menon	NNP
40439	229	19	]	]	-RRB-
40439	229	20	,	,	,
40439	229	21	according	accord	VBG
40439	229	22	to	to	IN
40439	229	23	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	229	24	's	's	POS
40439	229	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	229	26	,	,	,
40439	229	27	becomes	become	VBZ
40439	229	28	accidentally	accidentally	RB
40439	229	29	conjoined	conjoin	VBN
40439	229	30	,	,	,
40439	229	31	through	through	IN
40439	229	32	the	the	DT
40439	229	33	specialities	speciality	NNS
40439	229	34	of	of	IN
40439	229	35	this	this	DT
40439	229	36	case	case	NN
40439	229	37	,	,	,
40439	229	38	with	with	IN
40439	229	39	an	an	DT
40439	229	40	accessory	accessory	JJ
40439	229	41	idea	idea	NN
40439	229	42	of	of	IN
40439	229	43	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	229	44	or	or	CC
40439	229	45	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	229	46	;	;	,
40439	229	47	though	though	IN
40439	229	48	that	that	DT
40439	229	49	idea	idea	NN
40439	229	50	is	be	VBZ
40439	229	51	foreign	foreign	JJ
40439	229	52	to	to	IN
40439	229	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	229	54	constant	constant	JJ
40439	229	55	and	and	CC
40439	229	56	natural	natural	JJ
40439	229	57	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	229	58	.	.	.
40439	230	1	Now	now	RB
40439	230	2	if	if	IN
40439	230	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	230	4	turn	turn	VBP
40439	230	5	to	to	IN
40439	230	6	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	230	7	,	,	,
40439	230	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	230	9	shall	shall	MD
40439	230	10	find	find	VB
40439	230	11	that	that	IN
40439	230	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	230	13	understood	understand	VBD
40439	230	14	the	the	DT
40439	230	15	word	word	NN
40439	230	16	[	[	-LRB-
40439	230	17	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	230	18	:	:	:
40439	230	19	ei(lo	ei(lo	NNP
40439	230	20	/	/	SYM
40439	230	21	menon	menon	NNP
40439	230	22	]	]	-RRB-
40439	230	23	or	or	CC
40439	230	24	[	[	-LRB-
40439	230	25	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	230	26	:	:	:
40439	230	27	i)llo	i)llo	NNP
40439	230	28	/	/	SYM
40439	230	29	menon	menon	NNP
40439	230	30	]	]	-RRB-
40439	230	31	,	,	,
40439	230	32	and	and	CC
40439	230	33	the	the	DT
40439	230	34	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	230	35	of	of	IN
40439	230	36	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	230	37	,	,	,
40439	230	38	exactly	exactly	RB
40439	230	39	in	in	IN
40439	230	40	this	this	DT
40439	230	41	sense	sense	NN
40439	230	42	.	.	.
40439	231	1	Here	here	RB
40439	231	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	231	3	am	be	VBP
40439	231	4	compelled	compel	VBN
40439	231	5	to	to	TO
40439	231	6	depart	depart	VB
40439	231	7	from	from	IN
40439	231	8	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	231	9	,	,	,
40439	231	10	who	who	WP
40439	231	11	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	231	12	(	(	-LRB-
40439	231	13	p.	p.	NN
40439	231	14	152	152	CD
40439	231	15	)	)	-RRB-
40439	231	16	,	,	,
40439	231	17	with	with	IN
40439	231	18	an	an	DT
40439	231	19	expression	expression	NN
40439	231	20	of	of	IN
40439	231	21	astonishment	astonishment	NN
40439	231	22	,	,	,
40439	231	23	that	that	WDT
40439	231	24	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	231	25	misunderstood	misunderstand	VBD
40439	231	26	the	the	DT
40439	231	27	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	231	28	of	of	IN
40439	231	29	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	231	30	,	,	,
40439	231	31	and	and	CC
40439	231	32	interpreted	interpret	VBN
40439	231	33	[	[	-LRB-
40439	231	34	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	231	35	:	:	:
40439	231	36	ei(lo	ei(lo	NNP
40439	231	37	/	/	SYM
40439	231	38	menon	menon	NNP
40439	231	39	]	]	-RRB-
40439	231	40	or	or	CC
40439	231	41	[	[	-LRB-
40439	231	42	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	231	43	:	:	:
40439	231	44	i)llo	i)llo	NNP
40439	231	45	/	/	SYM
40439	231	46	menon	menon	NNP
40439	231	47	]	]	-RRB-
40439	231	48	as	as	IN
40439	231	49	if	if	IN
40439	231	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	231	51	meant	mean	VBD
40439	231	52	directly	directly	RB
40439	231	53	as	as	RB
40439	231	54	well	well	RB
40439	231	55	as	as	IN
40439	231	56	incontestably	incontestably	RB
40439	231	57	,	,	,
40439	231	58	_	_	NNP
40439	231	59	rotating	rotate	VBG
40439	231	60	_	_	NNP
40439	231	61	or	or	CC
40439	231	62	_	_	NNP
40439	231	63	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	231	64	_	_	NNP
40439	231	65	.	.	.
40439	232	1	Proklus	proklus	NN
40439	232	2	,	,	,
40439	232	3	in	in	IN
40439	232	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	232	5	Commentary	Commentary	NNP
40439	232	6	on	on	IN
40439	232	7	the	the	DT
40439	232	8	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	232	9	,	,	,
40439	232	10	had	have	VBD
40439	232	11	before	before	RB
40439	232	12	raised	raise	VBN
40439	232	13	the	the	DT
40439	232	14	same	same	JJ
40439	232	15	controversy	controversy	NN
40439	232	16	with	with	IN
40439	232	17	Aristotle--[Greek	Aristotle--[Greek	NNP
40439	232	18	:	:	:
40439	232	19	i)llome	i)llome	NNP
40439	232	20	/	/	SYM
40439	232	21	nên	nên	NNP
40439	232	22	de\	de\	NNP
40439	232	23	,	,	,
40439	232	24	tê\n	tê\n	NNP
40439	232	25	sphiggome	sphiggome	NN
40439	232	26	/	/	SYM
40439	232	27	nên	nên	NNP
40439	232	28	dêloi=	dêloi=	NNP
40439	232	29	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	232	30	sunechome	sunechome	NNP
40439	232	31	/	/	SYM
40439	232	32	nên	nên	NNP
40439	232	33	ou	ou	NNP
40439	232	34	)	)	-RRB-
40439	232	35	ga\r	ga\r	NNP
40439	232	36	ô(s	ô(s	NNP
40439	232	37	A)ristote	A)ristote	NNP
40439	232	38	/	/	SYM
40439	232	39	lês	lê	NNS
40439	232	40	oi)/etai	oi)/etai	RB
40439	232	41	,	,	,
40439	232	42	tê\n	tê\n	NNP
40439	232	43	kinoume	kinoume	NNP
40439	232	44	/	/	SYM
40439	232	45	nên	nên	NN
40439	232	46	]	]	-RRB-
40439	232	47	(	(	-LRB-
40439	232	48	Procl	procl	NN
40439	232	49	.	.	.
40439	233	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	233	2	681	681	CD
40439	233	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	233	4	.	.	.
40439	234	1	Let	let	VB
40439	234	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	234	3	,	,	,
40439	234	4	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	234	5	,	,	,
40439	234	6	examine	examine	VB
40439	234	7	the	the	DT
40439	234	8	passages	passage	NNS
40439	234	9	of	of	IN
40439	234	10	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	234	11	out	out	IN
40439	234	12	of	of	IN
40439	234	13	which	which	WDT
40439	234	14	this	this	DT
40439	234	15	difficulty	difficulty	NN
40439	234	16	arises	arise	VBZ
40439	234	17	.	.	.
40439	235	1	The	the	DT
40439	235	2	passages	passage	NNS
40439	235	3	are	be	VBP
40439	235	4	two	two	CD
40439	235	5	,	,	,
40439	235	6	both	both	DT
40439	235	7	of	of	IN
40439	235	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	235	9	in	in	IN
40439	235	10	the	the	DT
40439	235	11	second	second	JJ
40439	235	12	book	book	NN
40439	235	13	De	De	NNP
40439	235	14	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	235	15	;	;	:
40439	235	16	one	one	CD
40439	235	17	in	in	IN
40439	235	18	cap	cap	NN
40439	235	19	.	.	.
40439	236	1	13	13	CD
40439	236	2	,	,	,
40439	236	3	the	the	DT
40439	236	4	other	other	JJ
40439	236	5	in	in	IN
40439	236	6	cap	cap	NN
40439	236	7	.	.	.
40439	237	1	14	14	CD
40439	237	2	(	(	-LRB-
40439	237	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	237	4	293	293	CD
40439	237	5	b.	b.	NN
40439	238	1	30	30	CD
40439	238	2	,	,	,
40439	238	3	296	296	CD
40439	238	4	a.	a.	NN
40439	239	1	25	25	CD
40439	239	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	239	3	.	.	.
40439	240	1	1	1	LS
40439	240	2	.	.	.
40439	241	1	The	the	DT
40439	241	2	first	first	JJ
40439	241	3	stands--[Greek	stands--[greek	CD
40439	241	4	:	:	:
40439	241	5	e)/nioi	e)/nioi	NNP
40439	241	6	de\	de\	NNP
40439	241	7	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	241	8	keime	keime	NNP
40439	241	9	/	/	SYM
40439	241	10	nên	nên	NNP
40439	241	11	(	(	-LRB-
40439	241	12	tê\n	tê\n	NNP
40439	241	13	gê	gê	NNP
40439	241	14	=	=	SYM
40439	241	15	n	n	NN
40439	241	16	)	)	-RRB-
40439	241	17	e)pi\	e)pi\	NNP
40439	241	18	tou=	tou=	NNP
40439	241	19	ke	ke	NNP
40439	241	20	/	/	SYM
40439	241	21	ntrou	ntrou	NN
40439	241	22	phasi\n	phasi\n	NNPS
40439	241	23	au)tê\n	au)tê\n	NNP
40439	241	24	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	241	25	peri\	peri\	NN
40439	241	26	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	241	27	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	241	28	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	241	29	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	241	30	/	/	SYM
40439	241	31	non	non	NNP
40439	241	32	po	po	NNP
40439	241	33	/	/	SYM
40439	241	34	lon	lon	NN
40439	241	35	,	,	,
40439	241	36	ô(/sper	ô(/sper	NNP
40439	241	37	e)n	e)n	NNP
40439	241	38	tô=|	tô=|	NNP
40439	241	39	Timai	Timai	NNP
40439	241	40	/	/	SYM
40439	241	41	ô|	ô|	NNP
40439	241	42	*	*	NFP
40439	241	43	*	*	NFP
40439	241	44	ge	ge	NNP
40439	241	45	/	/	SYM
40439	241	46	graptai	graptai	NN
40439	241	47	.	.	.
40439	242	1	*	*	NFP
40439	242	2	*	*	NFP
40439	242	3	Such	such	JJ
40439	242	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	242	5	the	the	DT
40439	242	6	reading	reading	NN
40439	242	7	of	of	IN
40439	242	8	Bekker	Bekker	NNP
40439	242	9	in	in	IN
40439	242	10	the	the	DT
40439	242	11	Berlin	Berlin	NNP
40439	242	12	edition	edition	NN
40439	242	13	:	:	:
40439	242	14	but	but	CC
40439	242	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	242	16	gives	give	VBZ
40439	242	17	various	various	JJ
40439	242	18	readings	reading	NNS
40439	242	19	of	of	IN
40439	242	20	two	two	CD
40439	242	21	different	different	JJ
40439	242	22	MSS.--the	mss.--the	NN
40439	242	23	one	one	NN
40439	242	24	having	have	VBG
40439	242	25	[	[	-LRB-
40439	242	26	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	242	27	:	:	:
40439	242	28	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	242	29	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	242	30	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	242	31	=	=	SYM
40439	242	32	sthai]--the	sthai]--the	DT
40439	242	33	other	other	JJ
40439	242	34	ei(lei	ei(lei	NNP
40439	242	35	=	=	SYM
40439	242	36	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	242	37	*	*	NFP
40439	242	38	*	*	NFP
40439	242	39	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	242	40	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	242	41	=	=	SYM
40439	242	42	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	242	43	]	]	-RRB-
40439	242	44	.	.	.
40439	243	1	2	2	LS
40439	243	2	.	.	.
40439	244	1	The	the	DT
40439	244	2	second	second	JJ
40439	244	3	stands	stand	VBZ
40439	244	4	,	,	,
40439	244	5	beginning	begin	VBG
40439	244	6	chap	chap	NNP
40439	244	7	.	.	.
40439	245	1	14	14	CD
40439	245	2	-	-	HYPH
40439	245	3	-[Greek	-[greek	NN
40439	245	4	:	:	:
40439	245	5	ê(mei	ê(mei	NNP
40439	245	6	=	=	SYM
40439	245	7	s	s	NNP
40439	245	8	de\	de\	NNP
40439	245	9	le	le	NNP
40439	245	10	/	/	SYM
40439	245	11	gômen	gômen	NNP
40439	245	12	prô	prô	NNP
40439	245	13	=	=	SYM
40439	245	14	ton	ton	NNP
40439	245	15	po	po	NNP
40439	245	16	/	/	SYM
40439	245	17	teron	teron	NNP
40439	245	18	]	]	-RRB-
40439	245	19	(	(	-LRB-
40439	245	20	the	the	DT
40439	245	21	earth	earth	NN
40439	245	22	)	)	-RRB-
40439	245	23	[	[	-LRB-
40439	245	24	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	245	25	:	:	:
40439	245	26	e)/chei	e)/chei	NNP
40439	245	27	ki	ki	NNP
40439	245	28	/	/	SYM
40439	245	29	nêsin	nêsin	NNP
40439	245	30	ê)\	ê)\	IN
40439	245	31	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	245	32	/	/	SYM
40439	245	33	nei	nei	NN
40439	245	34	;	;	:
40439	245	35	katha	katha	NNP
40439	245	36	/	/	SYM
40439	245	37	per	per	IN
40439	245	38	ga\r	ga\r	NNP
40439	245	39	ei)/pomen	ei)/poman	NNS
40439	245	40	,	,	,
40439	245	41	oi	oi	NNP
40439	245	42	(	(	-LRB-
40439	245	43	me\n	me\n	NNP
40439	245	44	au)tê\n	au)tê\n	NNP
40439	245	45	e(\n	e(\n	NNP
40439	245	46	tô	tô	NNP
40439	245	47	=	=	SYM
40439	245	48	n	n	NNP
40439	245	49	a)/strôn	a)/strôn	NNP
40439	245	50	poiou	poiou	NNP
40439	245	51	=	=	SYM
40439	245	52	sin	sin	NN
40439	245	53	,	,	,
40439	245	54	oi	oi	PRP
40439	245	55	(	(	-LRB-
40439	245	56	d	d	NN
40439	245	57	'	'	''
40439	245	58	e)pi\	e)pi\	NN
40439	245	59	*	*	NFP
40439	245	60	*	*	NFP
40439	245	61	tou=	tou=	VB
40439	245	62	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	245	63	/	/	SYM
40439	245	64	sou	sou	VBP
40439	245	65	the	the	DT
40439	245	66	/	/	SYM
40439	245	67	ntes	ntes	NNP
40439	245	68	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	245	69	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	245	70	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	245	71	=	=	SYM
40439	245	72	shai/	shai/	``
40439	245	73	phasi	phasi	NN
40439	245	74	peri\	peri\	NN
40439	245	75	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	245	76	po	po	NNP
40439	245	77	/	/	SYM
40439	245	78	lon	lon	VB
40439	245	79	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	245	80	/	/	SYM
40439	245	81	son	son	NN
40439	245	82	.	.	.
40439	245	83	]	]	-RRB-
40439	246	1	Now	now	RB
40439	246	2	,	,	,
40439	246	3	in	in	IN
40439	246	4	the	the	DT
40439	246	5	first	first	JJ
40439	246	6	of	of	IN
40439	246	7	these	these	DT
40439	246	8	two	two	CD
40439	246	9	passages	passage	NNS
40439	246	10	,	,	,
40439	246	11	where	where	WRB
40439	246	12	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	246	13	simply	simply	RB
40439	246	14	brings	bring	VBZ
40439	246	15	the	the	DT
40439	246	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	246	17	to	to	TO
40439	246	18	view	view	VB
40439	246	19	without	without	IN
40439	246	20	any	any	DT
40439	246	21	comment	comment	NN
40439	246	22	,	,	,
40439	246	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	246	24	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	246	25	refers	refer	VBZ
40439	246	26	to	to	IN
40439	246	27	the	the	DT
40439	246	28	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	246	29	,	,	,
40439	246	30	and	and	CC
40439	246	31	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	246	32	quotes	quote	VBZ
40439	246	33	the	the	DT
40439	246	34	expression	expression	NN
40439	246	35	of	of	IN
40439	246	36	that	that	DT
40439	246	37	dialogue	dialogue	NN
40439	246	38	without	without	IN
40439	246	39	any	any	DT
40439	246	40	enlargement	enlargement	NN
40439	246	41	.	.	.
40439	247	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	247	2	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
40439	247	3	understands	understand	VBZ
40439	247	4	the	the	DT
40439	247	5	affirmation	affirmation	NN
40439	247	6	of	of	IN
40439	247	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	247	8	--	--	:
40439	247	9	that	that	IN
40439	247	10	the	the	DT
40439	247	11	earth	earth	NN
40439	247	12	was	be	VBD
40439	247	13	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	247	14	round	round	IN
40439	247	15	the	the	DT
40439	247	16	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	247	17	axis	axi	NNS
40439	247	18	--	--	:
40439	247	19	as	as	IN
40439	247	20	implying	imply	VBG
40439	247	21	that	that	IN
40439	247	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	247	23	rotated	rotate	VBD
40439	247	24	along	along	IN
40439	247	25	with	with	IN
40439	247	26	the	the	DT
40439	247	27	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	247	28	of	of	IN
40439	247	29	that	that	DT
40439	247	30	axis	axis	NN
40439	247	31	.	.	.
40439	248	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	248	2	thus	thus	RB
40439	248	3	construes	construe	NNS
40439	248	4	[	[	-LRB-
40439	248	5	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	248	6	:	:	:
40439	248	7	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NN
40439	248	8	]	]	-RRB-
40439	248	9	,	,	,
40439	248	10	_	_	NNP
40439	248	11	in	in	IN
40439	248	12	that	that	DT
40439	248	13	particular	particular	JJ
40439	248	14	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	248	15	_	_	NNP
40439	248	16	of	of	IN
40439	248	17	the	the	DT
40439	248	18	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	248	19	,	,	,
40439	248	20	as	as	IN
40439	248	21	implying	implying	JJ
40439	248	22	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	248	23	.	.	.
40439	249	1	But	but	CC
40439	249	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	249	3	plainly	plainly	RB
40439	249	4	did	do	VBD
40439	249	5	not	not	RB
40439	249	6	construe	construe	VB
40439	249	7	[	[	-LRB-
40439	249	8	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	249	9	:	:	:
40439	249	10	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	249	11	]	]	-RRB-
40439	249	12	as	as	IN
40439	249	13	naturally	naturally	RB
40439	249	14	and	and	CC
40439	249	15	constantly	constantly	RB
40439	249	16	either	either	CC
40439	249	17	denoting	denote	VBG
40439	249	18	or	or	CC
40439	249	19	implying	implying	JJ
40439	249	20	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	249	21	.	.	.
40439	250	1	This	this	DT
40439	250	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	250	3	proved	prove	VBN
40439	250	4	by	by	IN
40439	250	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	250	6	language	language	NN
40439	250	7	in	in	IN
40439	250	8	the	the	DT
40439	250	9	second	second	JJ
40439	250	10	passage	passage	NN
40439	250	11	,	,	,
40439	250	12	where	where	WRB
40439	250	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	250	14	reproduces	reproduce	VBZ
40439	250	15	the	the	DT
40439	250	16	very	very	RB
40439	250	17	same	same	JJ
40439	250	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	250	19	with	with	IN
40439	250	20	a	a	DT
40439	250	21	view	view	NN
40439	250	22	to	to	TO
40439	250	23	discuss	discuss	VB
40439	250	24	and	and	CC
40439	250	25	confute	confute	VB
40439	250	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	250	27	,	,	,
40439	250	28	and	and	CC
40439	250	29	without	without	IN
40439	250	30	special	special	JJ
40439	250	31	reference	reference	NN
40439	250	32	to	to	IN
40439	250	33	the	the	DT
40439	250	34	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	250	35	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	250	36	.	.	.
40439	251	1	Here	here	RB
40439	251	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	251	3	find	find	VBP
40439	251	4	that	that	IN
40439	251	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	251	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	251	7	not	not	RB
40439	251	8	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
40439	251	9	to	to	TO
40439	251	10	express	express	VB
40439	251	11	the	the	DT
40439	251	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	251	13	by	by	IN
40439	251	14	the	the	DT
40439	251	15	single	single	JJ
40439	251	16	word	word	NN
40439	251	17	[	[	-LRB-
40439	251	18	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	251	19	:	:	:
40439	251	20	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	251	21	]	]	-RRB-
40439	251	22	.	.	.
40439	252	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	252	2	subjoins	subjoin	VBZ
40439	252	3	another	another	DT
40439	252	4	verb--[Greek	verb--[greek	CD
40439	252	5	:	:	:
40439	252	6	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	252	7	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	252	8	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	252	9	=	=	SYM
40439	252	10	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	252	11	]	]	-RRB-
40439	252	12	:	:	:
40439	252	13	thus	thus	RB
40439	252	14	bringing	bring	VBG
40439	252	15	into	into	IN
40439	252	16	explicit	explicit	JJ
40439	252	17	enunciation	enunciation	NN
40439	252	18	the	the	DT
40439	252	19	fact	fact	NN
40439	252	20	of	of	IN
40439	252	21	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	252	22	movement	movement	NN
40439	252	23	,	,	,
40439	252	24	which	which	WDT
40439	252	25	,	,	,
40439	252	26	while	while	IN
40439	252	27	[	[	-LRB-
40439	252	28	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	252	29	:	:	:
40439	252	30	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	252	31	]	]	-RRB-
40439	252	32	stood	stand	VBD
40439	252	33	alone	alone	JJ
40439	252	34	,	,	,
40439	252	35	was	be	VBD
40439	252	36	only	only	RB
40439	252	37	known	know	VBN
40439	252	38	by	by	IN
40439	252	39	implication	implication	NN
40439	252	40	and	and	CC
40439	252	41	inference	inference	NN
40439	252	42	from	from	IN
40439	252	43	the	the	DT
40439	252	44	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	252	45	of	of	IN
40439	252	46	the	the	DT
40439	252	47	particular	particular	JJ
40439	252	48	case	case	NN
40439	252	49	.	.	.
40439	253	1	If	if	IN
40439	253	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	253	3	had	have	VBD
40439	253	4	supposed	suppose	VBN
40439	253	5	[	[	-LRB-
40439	253	6	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	253	7	:	:	:
40439	253	8	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NN
40439	253	9	]	]	-RRB-
40439	253	10	by	by	IN
40439	253	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	253	12	to	to	TO
40439	253	13	signify	signify	VB
40439	253	14	_	_	NNP
40439	253	15	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	253	16	_	_	NNP
40439	253	17	the	the	DT
40439	253	18	addition	addition	NN
40439	253	19	of	of	IN
40439	253	20	[	[	-LRB-
40439	253	21	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	253	22	:	:	:
40439	253	23	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	253	24	=	=	SYM
40439	253	25	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	253	26	]	]	-RRB-
40439	253	27	would	would	MD
40439	253	28	have	have	VB
40439	253	29	been	be	VBN
40439	253	30	useless	useless	JJ
40439	253	31	,	,	,
40439	253	32	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
40439	253	33	,	,	,
40439	253	34	and	and	CC
40439	253	35	even	even	RB
40439	253	36	impertinent	impertinent	JJ
40439	253	37	.	.	.
40439	254	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	254	2	,	,	,
40439	254	3	as	as	IN
40439	254	4	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	254	5	remarks	remark	NNS
40439	254	6	,	,	,
40439	254	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	254	8	not	not	RB
40439	254	9	given	give	VBN
40439	254	10	to	to	TO
40439	254	11	multiply	multiply	VB
40439	254	12	words	word	NNS
40439	254	13	unnecessarily	unnecessarily	RB
40439	254	14	.	.	.
40439	255	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	255	2	thus	thus	RB
40439	255	3	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	255	4	,	,	,
40439	255	5	when	when	WRB
40439	255	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	255	7	examine	examine	VBP
40439	255	8	the	the	DT
40439	255	9	passages	passage	NNS
40439	255	10	of	of	IN
40439	255	11	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	255	12	,	,	,
40439	255	13	that	that	IN
40439	255	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	255	15	understood	understand	VBD
40439	255	16	[	[	-LRB-
40439	255	17	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	255	18	:	:	:
40439	255	19	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	LS
40439	255	20	]	]	-RRB-
40439	255	21	quite	quite	RB
40439	255	22	in	in	IN
40439	255	23	conformity	conformity	NN
40439	255	24	with	with	IN
40439	255	25	Buttmann	Buttmann	NNP
40439	255	26	's	's	POS
40439	255	27	explanation	explanation	NN
40439	255	28	.	.	.
40439	256	1	Rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	256	2	movement	movement	NN
40439	256	3	forms	form	VBZ
40439	256	4	no	no	DT
40439	256	5	part	part	NN
40439	256	6	of	of	IN
40439	256	7	the	the	DT
40439	256	8	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	256	9	of	of	IN
40439	256	10	the	the	DT
40439	256	11	word	word	NN
40439	256	12	;	;	:
40439	256	13	yet	yet	CC
40439	256	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	256	15	may	may	MD
40439	256	16	accidentally	accidentally	RB
40439	256	17	,	,	,
40439	256	18	in	in	IN
40439	256	19	a	a	DT
40439	256	20	particular	particular	JJ
40439	256	21	case	case	NN
40439	256	22	,	,	,
40439	256	23	be	be	VB
40439	256	24	implied	imply	VBN
40439	256	25	as	as	IN
40439	256	26	an	an	DT
40439	256	27	adjunct	adjunct	NN
40439	256	28	of	of	IN
40439	256	29	the	the	DT
40439	256	30	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	256	31	,	,	,
40439	256	32	by	by	IN
40439	256	33	virtue	virtue	NN
40439	256	34	of	of	IN
40439	256	35	the	the	DT
40439	256	36	special	special	JJ
40439	256	37	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	256	38	of	of	IN
40439	256	39	that	that	DT
40439	256	40	case	case	NN
40439	256	41	.	.	.
40439	257	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	257	2	describes	describe	VBZ
40439	257	3	the	the	DT
40439	257	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	257	5	as	as	IN
40439	257	6	held	hold	VBN
40439	257	7	by	by	IN
40439	257	8	_	_	NNP
40439	257	9	some	some	DT
40439	257	10	persons	person	NNS
40439	257	11	_	_	NNP
40439	257	12	.	.	.
40439	258	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	258	2	doubtless	doubtless	RB
40439	258	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	258	4	in	in	IN
40439	258	5	view	view	NN
40439	258	6	various	various	JJ
40439	258	7	Platonists	Platonists	NNPS
40439	258	8	of	of	IN
40439	258	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	258	10	time	time	NN
40439	258	11	,	,	,
40439	258	12	who	who	WP
40439	258	13	adopted	adopt	VBD
40439	258	14	and	and	CC
40439	258	15	defended	defend	VBD
40439	258	16	what	what	WP
40439	258	17	had	have	VBD
40439	258	18	been	be	VBN
40439	258	19	originally	originally	RB
40439	258	20	advanced	advance	VBN
40439	258	21	by	by	IN
40439	258	22	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	258	23	in	in	IN
40439	258	24	the	the	DT
40439	258	25	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	258	26	.	.	.
40439	259	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	259	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	259	3	,	,	,
40439	259	4	in	in	IN
40439	259	5	a	a	DT
40439	259	6	discussion	discussion	NN
40439	259	7	of	of	IN
40439	259	8	some	some	DT
40439	259	9	length	length	NN
40439	259	10	(	(	-LRB-
40439	259	11	Untersuch	untersuch	JJ
40439	259	12	.	.	.
40439	260	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	260	2	76	76	CD
40439	260	3	-	-	SYM
40439	260	4	84	84	CD
40439	260	5	)	)	-RRB-
40439	260	6	,	,	,
40439	260	7	maintains	maintain	VBZ
40439	260	8	the	the	DT
40439	260	9	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	260	10	that	that	IN
40439	260	11	the	the	DT
40439	260	12	reading	reading	NN
40439	260	13	in	in	IN
40439	260	14	the	the	DT
40439	260	15	first	first	JJ
40439	260	16	passage	passage	NN
40439	260	17	of	of	IN
40439	260	18	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	260	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	260	20	incorrect	incorrect	JJ
40439	260	21	;	;	:
40439	260	22	that	that	IN
40439	260	23	the	the	DT
40439	260	24	two	two	CD
40439	260	25	words	word	NNS
40439	260	26	[	[	-LRB-
40439	260	27	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	260	28	:	:	:
40439	260	29	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	260	30	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	260	31	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	260	32	=	=	SYM
40439	260	33	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	260	34	]	]	-RRB-
40439	260	35	ought	ought	MD
40439	260	36	to	to	TO
40439	260	37	stand	stand	VB
40439	260	38	in	in	IN
40439	260	39	the	the	DT
40439	260	40	first	first	JJ
40439	260	41	as	as	IN
40439	260	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	260	43	do	do	VBP
40439	260	44	in	in	IN
40439	260	45	the	the	DT
40439	260	46	second,--as	second,--as	UH
40439	260	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	260	48	thinks	think	VBZ
40439	260	49	that	that	IN
40439	260	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	260	51	stood	stand	VBD
40439	260	52	in	in	IN
40439	260	53	the	the	DT
40439	260	54	copy	copy	NN
40439	260	55	of	of	IN
40439	260	56	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	260	57	:	:	:
40439	260	58	that	that	IN
40439	260	59	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	260	60	only	only	RB
40439	260	61	made	make	VBD
40439	260	62	reference	reference	NN
40439	260	63	to	to	IN
40439	260	64	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	260	65	with	with	IN
40439	260	66	a	a	DT
40439	260	67	view	view	NN
40439	260	68	to	to	IN
40439	260	69	the	the	DT
40439	260	70	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
40439	260	71	word	word	NN
40439	260	72	[	[	-LRB-
40439	260	73	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	260	74	:	:	:
40439	260	75	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NN
40439	260	76	]	]	-RRB-
40439	260	77	,	,	,
40439	260	78	and	and	CC
40439	260	79	not	not	RB
40439	260	80	to	to	IN
40439	260	81	the	the	DT
40439	260	82	general	general	JJ
40439	260	83	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	260	84	of	of	IN
40439	260	85	the	the	DT
40439	260	86	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	260	87	of	of	IN
40439	260	88	the	the	DT
40439	260	89	earth	earth	NN
40439	260	90	:	:	:
40439	260	91	that	that	IN
40439	260	92	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	260	93	comments	comment	VBZ
40439	260	94	upon	upon	IN
40439	260	95	this	this	DT
40439	260	96	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	260	97	as	as	IN
40439	260	98	held	hold	VBN
40439	260	99	by	by	IN
40439	260	100	others	other	NNS
40439	260	101	,	,	,
40439	260	102	but	but	CC
40439	260	103	not	not	RB
40439	260	104	by	by	IN
40439	260	105	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	260	106	--	--	:
40439	260	107	who	who	WP
40439	260	108	(	(	-LRB-
40439	260	109	according	accord	VBG
40439	260	110	to	to	IN
40439	260	111	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	260	112	)	)	-RRB-
40439	260	113	was	be	VBD
40439	260	114	known	know	VBN
40439	260	115	by	by	IN
40439	260	116	everyone	everyone	NN
40439	260	117	not	not	RB
40439	260	118	to	to	TO
40439	260	119	hold	hold	VB
40439	260	120	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	260	121	.	.	.
40439	261	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	261	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	261	3	gives	give	VBZ
40439	261	4	this	this	DT
40439	261	5	only	only	RB
40439	261	6	as	as	IN
40439	261	7	a	a	DT
40439	261	8	conjecture	conjecture	NN
40439	261	9	,	,	,
40439	261	10	and	and	CC
40439	261	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	261	12	can	can	MD
40439	261	13	not	not	RB
40439	261	14	regard	regard	VB
40439	261	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	261	16	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	261	17	in	in	IN
40439	261	18	support	support	NN
40439	261	19	of	of	IN
40439	261	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	261	21	as	as	IN
40439	261	22	convincing	convincing	JJ
40439	261	23	.	.	.
40439	262	1	But	but	CC
40439	262	2	even	even	RB
40439	262	3	if	if	IN
40439	262	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	262	5	had	have	VBD
40439	262	6	convinced	convince	VBN
40439	262	7	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	262	8	that	that	IN
40439	262	9	[	[	-LRB-
40439	262	10	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	262	11	:	:	:
40439	262	12	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	262	13	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	262	14	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	262	15	=	=	SYM
40439	262	16	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	262	17	]	]	-RRB-
40439	262	18	were	be	VBD
40439	262	19	the	the	DT
40439	262	20	true	true	JJ
40439	262	21	reading	reading	NN
40439	262	22	in	in	IN
40439	262	23	the	the	DT
40439	262	24	first	first	JJ
40439	262	25	passage	passage	NN
40439	262	26	,	,	,
40439	262	27	as	as	RB
40439	262	28	well	well	RB
40439	262	29	as	as	IN
40439	262	30	in	in	IN
40439	262	31	the	the	DT
40439	262	32	second	second	JJ
40439	262	33	,	,	,
40439	262	34	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	262	35	should	should	MD
40439	262	36	merely	merely	RB
40439	262	37	say	say	VB
40439	262	38	that	that	IN
40439	262	39	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	262	40	had	have	VBD
40439	262	41	not	not	RB
40439	262	42	thought	think	VBN
40439	262	43	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	262	44	precluded	preclude	VBN
40439	262	45	by	by	IN
40439	262	46	the	the	DT
40439	262	47	reference	reference	NN
40439	262	48	to	to	IN
40439	262	49	the	the	DT
40439	262	50	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	262	51	from	from	IN
40439	262	52	bringing	bring	VBG
40439	262	53	out	out	RP
40439	262	54	into	into	IN
40439	262	55	explicit	explicit	JJ
40439	262	56	enunciation	enunciation	NN
40439	262	57	what	what	WP
40439	262	58	the	the	DT
40439	262	59	Platonists	Platonists	NNPS
40439	262	60	whom	whom	WP
40439	262	61	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	262	62	had	have	VBD
40439	262	63	in	in	IN
40439	262	64	view	view	NN
40439	262	65	knew	know	VBD
40439	262	66	to	to	TO
40439	262	67	be	be	VB
40439	262	68	implied	imply	VBN
40439	262	69	and	and	CC
40439	262	70	intended	intend	VBN
40439	262	71	by	by	IN
40439	262	72	the	the	DT
40439	262	73	passage	passage	NN
40439	262	74	.	.	.
40439	263	1	This	this	DT
40439	263	2	indeed	indeed	RB
40439	263	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	263	4	a	a	DT
40439	263	5	loose	loose	JJ
40439	263	6	mode	mode	NN
40439	263	7	of	of	IN
40439	263	8	citation	citation	NN
40439	263	9	,	,	,
40439	263	10	which	which	WDT
40439	263	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	263	12	shall	shall	MD
40439	263	13	not	not	RB
40439	263	14	ascribe	ascribe	VB
40439	263	15	to	to	IN
40439	263	16	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	263	17	without	without	IN
40439	263	18	good	good	JJ
40439	263	19	evidence	evidence	NN
40439	263	20	.	.	.
40439	264	1	In	in	IN
40439	264	2	the	the	DT
40439	264	3	present	present	JJ
40439	264	4	case	case	NN
40439	264	5	such	such	JJ
40439	264	6	evidence	evidence	NN
40439	264	7	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	264	8	to	to	IN
40439	264	9	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	264	10	wanting	want	VBG
40439	264	11	.	.	.
40439	265	1	[	[	-LRB-
40439	265	2	4	4	CD
40439	265	3	]	]	-RRB-
40439	265	4	[	[	-LRB-
40439	265	5	Footnote	footnote	NN
40439	265	6	4	4	CD
40439	265	7	:	:	:
40439	265	8	Exactness	exactness	NN
40439	265	9	of	of	IN
40439	265	10	citation	citation	NN
40439	265	11	is	be	VBZ
40439	265	12	not	not	RB
40439	265	13	always	always	RB
40439	265	14	to	to	TO
40439	265	15	be	be	VB
40439	265	16	relied	rely	VBN
40439	265	17	on	on	RP
40439	265	18	among	among	IN
40439	265	19	ancient	ancient	JJ
40439	265	20	commentators	commentator	NNS
40439	265	21	.	.	.
40439	266	1	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	266	2	cites	cite	VBZ
40439	266	3	this	this	DT
40439	266	4	very	very	JJ
40439	266	5	passage	passage	NN
40439	266	6	of	of	IN
40439	266	7	the	the	DT
40439	266	8	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	266	9	with	with	IN
40439	266	10	more	more	JJR
40439	266	11	than	than	IN
40439	266	12	one	one	CD
40439	266	13	inaccuracy.--(ad	inaccuracy.--(ad	NNP
40439	266	14	Aristot	Aristot	NNP
40439	266	15	.	.	.
40439	267	1	De	De	NNP
40439	267	2	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	267	3	,	,	,
40439	267	4	fol	fol	NNP
40439	267	5	.	.	.
40439	268	1	125	125	CD
40439	268	2	.	.	.
40439	268	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	268	4	]	]	-RRB-
40439	269	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	269	2	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	269	3	attributes	attribute	VBZ
40439	269	4	to	to	IN
40439	269	5	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	269	6	something	something	NN
40439	269	7	more	more	JJR
40439	269	8	than	than	IN
40439	269	9	improper	improper	JJ
40439	269	10	citation	citation	NN
40439	269	11	.	.	.
40439	270	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	270	2	says	say	VBZ
40439	270	3	(	(	-LRB-
40439	270	4	Êtudes	Êtudes	NNP
40439	270	5	sur	sur	FW
40439	270	6	le	le	NNP
40439	270	7	Timée	Timée	NNP
40439	270	8	,	,	,
40439	270	9	vol	vol	NNP
40439	270	10	.	.	.
40439	271	1	ii	ii	LS
40439	271	2	.	.	.
40439	272	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	272	2	87	87	CD
40439	272	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	272	4	,	,	,
40439	272	5	"	"	``
40439	272	6	Si	Si	NNP
40439	272	7	Aristote	Aristote	NNP
40439	272	8	citait	citait	NNP
40439	272	9	l'opinion	l'opinion	NNP
40439	272	10	de	de	NNP
40439	272	11	la	la	NNP
40439	272	12	rotation	rotation	NNP
40439	272	13	de	de	NNP
40439	272	14	la	la	NNP
40439	272	15	terre	terre	NNP
40439	272	16	comme	comme	NNP
40439	272	17	un	un	NNP
40439	272	18	titre	titre	NNP
40439	272	19	de	de	NNP
40439	272	20	gloire	gloire	NNP
40439	272	21	pour	pour	NNP
40439	272	22	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	272	23	,	,	,
40439	272	24	je	je	NNP
40439	272	25	dirais	dirais	NNP
40439	272	26	--	--	:
40439	272	27	il	il	NNP
40439	272	28	est	est	NNP
40439	272	29	probable	probable	JJ
40439	272	30	que	que	NNP
40439	272	31	la	la	NNP
40439	272	32	vérité	vérité	NNP
40439	272	33	l'y	l'y	RB
40439	272	34	a	a	DT
40439	272	35	forcé	forcé	NN
40439	272	36	.	.	.
40439	273	1	Mais	Mais	NNP
40439	273	2	Aristote	Aristote	NNP
40439	273	3	,	,	,
40439	273	4	qui	qui	NNP
40439	273	5	admettait	admettait	NNP
40439	273	6	l'immobilité	l'immobilité	NNP
40439	273	7	complète	complète	NNP
40439	273	8	de	de	NNP
40439	273	9	la	la	NNP
40439	273	10	terre	terre	NNP
40439	273	11	,	,	,
40439	273	12	attribue	attribue	NNP
40439	273	13	à	à	NNP
40439	273	14	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	273	15	l'opinion	l'opinion	NN
40439	273	16	contraire	contraire	NN
40439	273	17	,	,	,
40439	273	18	_	_	NNP
40439	273	19	pour	pour	FW
40439	273	20	se	se	FW
40439	273	21	donner	donner	NNP
40439	273	22	le	le	NNP
40439	273	23	plaisir	plaisir	NNP
40439	273	24	de	de	NNP
40439	273	25	la	la	NNP
40439	273	26	réfuter	réfuter	NNP
40439	273	27	avec	avec	FW
40439	273	28	dédain	dédain	NNP
40439	273	29	_	_	NNP
40439	273	30	.	.	.
40439	273	31	"	"	''
40439	274	1	A	a	DT
40439	274	2	few	few	JJ
40439	274	3	lines	line	NNS
40439	274	4	before	before	RB
40439	274	5	,	,	,
40439	274	6	M.	M.	NNP
40439	274	7	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	274	8	had	have	VBD
40439	274	9	said	say	VBN
40439	274	10	that	that	IN
40439	274	11	the	the	DT
40439	274	12	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	274	13	whereby	whereby	WRB
40439	274	14	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	274	15	combated	combat	VBD
40439	274	16	this	this	DT
40439	274	17	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	274	18	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	274	19	to	to	IN
40439	274	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	274	21	were	be	VBD
40439	274	22	"	"	``
40439	274	23	very	very	RB
40439	274	24	feeble	feeble	JJ
40439	274	25	.	.	.
40439	274	26	"	"	''
40439	275	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	275	2	am	be	VBP
40439	275	3	at	at	IN
40439	275	4	a	a	DT
40439	275	5	loss	loss	NN
40439	275	6	to	to	TO
40439	275	7	imagine	imagine	VB
40439	275	8	in	in	IN
40439	275	9	which	which	WDT
40439	275	10	of	of	IN
40439	275	11	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	275	12	's	's	POS
40439	275	13	phrases	phrase	NNS
40439	275	14	M.	M.	NNP
40439	275	15	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	275	16	finds	find	VBZ
40439	275	17	any	any	DT
40439	275	18	trace	trace	NN
40439	275	19	of	of	IN
40439	275	20	disdain	disdain	NN
40439	275	21	or	or	CC
40439	275	22	contempt	contempt	NN
40439	275	23	,	,	,
40439	275	24	either	either	CC
40439	275	25	for	for	IN
40439	275	26	the	the	DT
40439	275	27	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	275	28	or	or	CC
40439	275	29	for	for	IN
40439	275	30	those	those	DT
40439	275	31	who	who	WP
40439	275	32	held	hold	VBD
40439	275	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	275	34	.	.	.
40439	276	1	For	for	IN
40439	276	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	276	3	part	part	NN
40439	276	4	,	,	,
40439	276	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	276	6	find	find	VBP
40439	276	7	none	none	NN
40439	276	8	.	.	.
40439	277	1	The	the	DT
40439	277	2	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	277	3	of	of	IN
40439	277	4	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	277	5	against	against	IN
40439	277	6	the	the	DT
40439	277	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	277	8	,	,	,
40439	277	9	whatever	whatever	WDT
40439	277	10	be	be	VBP
40439	277	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	277	12	probative	probative	JJ
40439	277	13	force	force	NN
40439	277	14	,	,	,
40439	277	15	are	be	VBP
40439	277	16	delivered	deliver	VBN
40439	277	17	in	in	IN
40439	277	18	that	that	DT
40439	277	19	brief	brief	NN
40439	277	20	,	,	,
40439	277	21	calm	calm	JJ
40439	277	22	,	,	,
40439	277	23	dry	dry	JJ
40439	277	24	manner	manner	NN
40439	277	25	which	which	WDT
40439	277	26	is	be	VBZ
40439	277	27	usual	usual	JJ
40439	277	28	with	with	IN
40439	277	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	277	30	,	,	,
40439	277	31	without	without	IN
40439	277	32	a	a	DT
40439	277	33	word	word	NN
40439	277	34	of	of	IN
40439	277	35	sentiment	sentiment	NN
40439	277	36	or	or	CC
40439	277	37	rhetoric	rhetoric	NN
40439	277	38	,	,	,
40439	277	39	or	or	CC
40439	277	40	anything	anything	NN
40439	277	41	[	[	-LRB-
40439	277	42	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	277	43	:	:	:
40439	277	44	e)/xô	e)/xô	''
40439	277	45	tou=	tou=	NNP
40439	277	46	pra	pra	NNP
40439	277	47	/	/	SYM
40439	277	48	gmatos	gmatos	NNP
40439	277	49	]	]	-RRB-
40439	277	50	.	.	.
40439	278	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
40439	278	2	,	,	,
40439	278	3	among	among	IN
40439	278	4	all	all	DT
40439	278	5	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
40439	278	6	who	who	WP
40439	278	7	have	have	VBP
40439	278	8	written	write	VBN
40439	278	9	much	much	RB
40439	278	10	,	,	,
40439	278	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	278	12	know	know	VBP
40439	278	13	none	none	NN
40439	278	14	who	who	WP
40439	278	15	is	be	VBZ
40439	278	16	less	less	RBR
40439	278	17	open	open	JJ
40439	278	18	to	to	IN
40439	278	19	the	the	DT
40439	278	20	reproach	reproach	NN
40439	278	21	of	of	IN
40439	278	22	mingling	mingling	JJ
40439	278	23	personal	personal	JJ
40439	278	24	sentiment	sentiment	NN
40439	278	25	with	with	IN
40439	278	26	argumentative	argumentative	JJ
40439	278	27	debate	debate	NN
40439	278	28	than	than	IN
40439	278	29	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	278	30	.	.	.
40439	279	1	Plato	plato	JJ
40439	279	2	indulges	indulge	VBZ
40439	279	3	frequently	frequently	RB
40439	279	4	in	in	IN
40439	279	5	irony	irony	NN
40439	279	6	,	,	,
40439	279	7	or	or	CC
40439	279	8	sneering	sneering	NN
40439	279	9	,	,	,
40439	279	10	or	or	CC
40439	279	11	rhetorical	rhetorical	JJ
40439	279	12	invective	invective	NN
40439	279	13	;	;	:
40439	279	14	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	279	15	very	very	RB
40439	279	16	rarely	rarely	RB
40439	279	17	.	.	.
40439	280	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
40439	280	2	,	,	,
40439	280	3	even	even	RB
40439	280	4	apart	apart	RB
40439	280	5	from	from	IN
40439	280	6	the	the	DT
40439	280	7	question	question	NN
40439	280	8	of	of	IN
40439	280	9	contempt	contempt	NN
40439	280	10	,	,	,
40439	280	11	the	the	DT
40439	280	12	part	part	NN
40439	280	13	which	which	WDT
40439	280	14	M.	M.	NNP
40439	280	15	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	280	16	here	here	RB
40439	280	17	assumes	assume	VBZ
40439	280	18	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	280	19	to	to	TO
40439	280	20	be	be	VB
40439	280	21	playing	play	VBG
40439	280	22	,	,	,
40439	280	23	is	be	VBZ
40439	280	24	among	among	IN
40439	280	25	the	the	DT
40439	280	26	strangest	strange	JJS
40439	280	27	anomalies	anomaly	NNS
40439	280	28	in	in	IN
40439	280	29	the	the	DT
40439	280	30	history	history	NN
40439	280	31	of	of	IN
40439	280	32	philosophy	philosophy	NN
40439	280	33	.	.	.
40439	281	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	281	2	holds	hold	VBZ
40439	281	3	,	,	,
40439	281	4	and	and	CC
40439	281	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	281	6	anxious	anxious	JJ
40439	281	7	to	to	TO
40439	281	8	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
40439	281	9	,	,	,
40439	281	10	the	the	DT
40439	281	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	281	12	of	of	IN
40439	281	13	the	the	DT
40439	281	14	earth	earth	NN
40439	281	15	's	's	POS
40439	281	16	immobility	immobility	NN
40439	281	17	;	;	:
40439	281	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	281	19	knows	know	VBZ
40439	281	20	(	(	-LRB-
40439	281	21	so	so	RB
40439	281	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	281	23	are	be	VBP
40439	281	24	required	require	VBN
40439	281	25	to	to	TO
40439	281	26	believe	believe	VB
40439	281	27	)	)	-RRB-
40439	281	28	that	that	IN
40439	281	29	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	281	30	not	not	RB
40439	281	31	only	only	RB
40439	281	32	holds	hold	VBZ
40439	281	33	the	the	DT
40439	281	34	same	same	JJ
40439	281	35	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	281	36	,	,	,
40439	281	37	but	but	CC
40439	281	38	has	have	VBZ
40439	281	39	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	281	40	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	281	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	281	42	in	in	IN
40439	281	43	the	the	DT
40439	281	44	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	281	45	:	:	:
40439	281	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	281	47	might	may	MD
40439	281	48	have	have	VB
40439	281	49	produced	produce	VBN
40439	281	50	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	281	51	as	as	IN
40439	281	52	an	an	DT
40439	281	53	authority	authority	NN
40439	281	54	in	in	IN
40439	281	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	281	56	favour	favour	NN
40439	281	57	,	,	,
40439	281	58	and	and	CC
40439	281	59	the	the	DT
40439	281	60	passage	passage	NN
40439	281	61	of	of	IN
40439	281	62	the	the	DT
40439	281	63	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	281	64	as	as	IN
40439	281	65	an	an	DT
40439	281	66	express	express	JJ
40439	281	67	declaration	declaration	NN
40439	281	68	;	;	:
40439	281	69	yet	yet	CC
40439	281	70	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	281	71	prefers	prefer	VBZ
40439	281	72	to	to	TO
40439	281	73	pervert	pervert	VB
40439	281	74	,	,	,
40439	281	75	knowingly	knowingly	RB
40439	281	76	and	and	CC
40439	281	77	deliberately	deliberately	RB
40439	281	78	,	,	,
40439	281	79	the	the	DT
40439	281	80	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	281	81	of	of	IN
40439	281	82	this	this	DT
40439	281	83	passage	passage	NN
40439	281	84	,	,	,
40439	281	85	and	and	CC
40439	281	86	to	to	TO
40439	281	87	cite	cite	VB
40439	281	88	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	281	89	as	as	IN
40439	281	90	a	a	DT
40439	281	91	hostile	hostile	NN
40439	281	92	instead	instead	RB
40439	281	93	of	of	IN
40439	281	94	a	a	DT
40439	281	95	friendly	friendly	JJ
40439	281	96	authority	authority	NN
40439	281	97	--	--	:
40439	281	98	simply	simply	RB
40439	281	99	"	"	``
40439	281	100	to	to	TO
40439	281	101	give	give	VB
40439	281	102	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	281	103	the	the	DT
40439	281	104	pleasure	pleasure	NN
40439	281	105	of	of	IN
40439	281	106	contemptuously	contemptuously	RB
40439	281	107	refuting	refute	VBG
40439	281	108	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	281	109	's	's	POS
40439	281	110	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	281	111	!	!	.
40439	281	112	"	"	''
40439	282	1	But	but	CC
40439	282	2	this	this	DT
40439	282	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	282	4	not	not	RB
40439	282	5	all	all	DT
40439	282	6	.	.	.
40439	283	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	283	2	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	283	3	tells	tell	VBZ
40439	283	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	283	5	that	that	IN
40439	283	6	the	the	DT
40439	283	7	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	283	8	which	which	WDT
40439	283	9	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	283	10	produces	produce	VBZ
40439	283	11	against	against	IN
40439	283	12	the	the	DT
40439	283	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	283	14	are	be	VBP
40439	283	15	,	,	,
40439	283	16	after	after	RB
40439	283	17	all	all	RB
40439	283	18	,	,	,
40439	283	19	very	very	RB
40439	283	20	feeble	feeble	JJ
40439	283	21	.	.	.
40439	284	1	But	but	CC
40439	284	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	284	3	farther	farther	RB
40439	284	4	tells	tell	VBZ
40439	284	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	284	6	that	that	IN
40439	284	7	there	there	EX
40439	284	8	was	be	VBD
40439	284	9	one	one	CD
40439	284	10	argument	argument	NN
40439	284	11	which	which	WDT
40439	284	12	might	may	MD
40439	284	13	have	have	VB
40439	284	14	been	be	VBN
40439	284	15	produced	produce	VBN
40439	284	16	,	,	,
40439	284	17	and	and	CC
40439	284	18	which	which	WDT
40439	284	19	,	,	,
40439	284	20	if	if	IN
40439	284	21	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	284	22	had	have	VBD
40439	284	23	produced	produce	VBN
40439	284	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	284	25	,	,	,
40439	284	26	would	would	MD
40439	284	27	have	have	VB
40439	284	28	convicted	convict	VBN
40439	284	29	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	284	30	of	of	IN
40439	284	31	"	"	``
40439	284	32	an	an	DT
40439	284	33	enormous	enormous	JJ
40439	284	34	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	284	35	"	"	''
40439	284	36	(	(	-LRB-
40439	284	37	p.	p.	NN
40439	284	38	88	88	CD
40439	284	39	)	)	-RRB-
40439	284	40	in	in	IN
40439	284	41	affirming	affirm	VBG
40439	284	42	that	that	IN
40439	284	43	the	the	DT
40439	284	44	earth	earth	NN
40439	284	45	revolved	revolve	VBD
40439	284	46	round	round	IN
40439	284	47	the	the	DT
40439	284	48	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	284	49	axis	axis	NN
40439	284	50	.	.	.
40439	285	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	285	2	might	may	MD
40439	285	3	have	have	VB
40439	285	4	said	say	VBN
40439	285	5	to	to	IN
40439	285	6	Plato--"You	plato--"you	PRP
40439	285	7	have	have	VBP
40439	285	8	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	285	9	,	,	,
40439	285	10	and	and	CC
40439	285	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
40439	285	12	assume	assume	VBP
40439	285	13	perpetually	perpetually	RB
40439	285	14	throughout	throughout	IN
40439	285	15	the	the	DT
40439	285	16	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	285	17	,	,	,
40439	285	18	the	the	DT
40439	285	19	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	285	20	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	285	21	of	of	IN
40439	285	22	the	the	DT
40439	285	23	outer	outer	JJ
40439	285	24	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	285	25	sphere	sphere	VBD
40439	285	26	;	;	:
40439	285	27	you	-PRON-	PRP
40439	285	28	now	now	RB
40439	285	29	assert	assert	VBP
40439	285	30	the	the	DT
40439	285	31	diurnal	diurnal	NNP
40439	285	32	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	285	33	of	of	IN
40439	285	34	the	the	DT
40439	285	35	earth	earth	NN
40439	285	36	at	at	IN
40439	285	37	the	the	DT
40439	285	38	centre	centre	NN
40439	285	39	.	.	.
40439	286	1	Here	here	RB
40439	286	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	286	3	an	an	DT
40439	286	4	enormous	enormous	JJ
40439	286	5	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	286	6	;	;	:
40439	286	7	the	the	DT
40439	286	8	two	two	CD
40439	286	9	can	can	MD
40439	286	10	not	not	RB
40439	286	11	stand	stand	VB
40439	286	12	together	together	RB
40439	286	13	.	.	.
40439	286	14	"	"	''
40439	287	1	--Yet	--Yet	NNP
40439	287	2	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	287	3	,	,	,
40439	287	4	having	have	VBG
40439	287	5	this	this	DT
40439	287	6	triumphant	triumphant	JJ
40439	287	7	argument	argument	NN
40439	287	8	in	in	IN
40439	287	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	287	10	hands	hand	NNS
40439	287	11	,	,	,
40439	287	12	says	say	VBZ
40439	287	13	not	not	RB
40439	287	14	a	a	DT
40439	287	15	word	word	NN
40439	287	16	about	about	IN
40439	287	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	287	18	,	,	,
40439	287	19	but	but	CC
40439	287	20	contents	content	VBZ
40439	287	21	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	287	22	with	with	IN
40439	287	23	various	various	JJ
40439	287	24	other	other	JJ
40439	287	25	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	287	26	which	which	WDT
40439	287	27	M.	M.	NNP
40439	287	28	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	287	29	pronounces	pronounce	VBZ
40439	287	30	to	to	TO
40439	287	31	be	be	VB
40439	287	32	very	very	RB
40439	287	33	feeble	feeble	JJ
40439	287	34	.	.	.
40439	288	1	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
40439	288	2	M.	M.	NNP
40439	288	3	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	288	4	might	may	MD
40439	288	5	say--"The	say--"the	$
40439	288	6	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	288	7	exists	exist	VBZ
40439	288	8	;	;	:
40439	288	9	but	but	CC
40439	288	10	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	288	11	was	be	VBD
40439	288	12	not	not	RB
40439	288	13	sharpsighted	sharpsighte	VBN
40439	288	14	enough	enough	RB
40439	288	15	to	to	TO
40439	288	16	perceive	perceive	VB
40439	288	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	288	18	;	;	:
40439	288	19	otherwise	otherwise	RB
40439	288	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	288	21	would	would	MD
40439	288	22	have	have	VB
40439	288	23	advanced	advance	VBN
40439	288	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	288	25	.	.	.
40439	288	26	"	"	''
40439	289	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	289	2	am	be	VBP
40439	289	3	quite	quite	RB
40439	289	4	of	of	IN
40439	289	5	this	this	DT
40439	289	6	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	289	7	.	.	.
40439	290	1	If	if	IN
40439	290	2	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	290	3	had	have	VBD
40439	290	4	perceived	perceive	VBN
40439	290	5	the	the	DT
40439	290	6	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	290	7	,	,	,
40439	290	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	290	9	would	would	MD
40439	290	10	have	have	VB
40439	290	11	brought	bring	VBN
40439	290	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	290	13	forward	forward	RB
40439	290	14	as	as	IN
40439	290	15	the	the	DT
40439	290	16	strongest	strong	JJS
40439	290	17	point	point	NN
40439	290	18	in	in	IN
40439	290	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	290	20	controversy	controversy	NN
40439	290	21	.	.	.
40439	291	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	291	2	silence	silence	NN
40439	291	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	291	4	to	to	IN
40439	291	5	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	291	6	a	a	DT
40439	291	7	proof	proof	NN
40439	291	8	that	that	IN
40439	291	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	291	10	did	do	VBD
40439	291	11	not	not	RB
40439	291	12	perceive	perceive	VB
40439	291	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	291	14	.	.	.
40439	292	1	But	but	CC
40439	292	2	this	this	DT
40439	292	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	292	4	a	a	DT
40439	292	5	part	part	NN
40439	292	6	of	of	IN
40439	292	7	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	292	8	case	case	NN
40439	292	9	against	against	IN
40439	292	10	M.	M.	NNP
40439	292	11	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	292	12	.	.	.
40439	293	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	293	2	believe	believe	VBP
40439	293	3	that	that	IN
40439	293	4	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	293	5	admitted	admit	VBD
40439	293	6	both	both	DT
40439	293	7	the	the	DT
40439	293	8	two	two	CD
40439	293	9	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
40439	293	10	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
40439	293	11	without	without	IN
40439	293	12	perceiving	perceive	VBG
40439	293	13	the	the	DT
40439	293	14	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	293	15	;	;	:
40439	293	16	and	and	CC
40439	293	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	293	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	293	19	a	a	DT
40439	293	20	strong	strong	JJ
40439	293	21	presumption	presumption	NN
40439	293	22	in	in	IN
40439	293	23	favour	favour	NN
40439	293	24	of	of	IN
40439	293	25	this	this	DT
40439	293	26	view	view	NN
40439	293	27	that	that	IN
40439	293	28	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	293	29	equally	equally	RB
40439	293	30	failed	fail	VBD
40439	293	31	to	to	TO
40439	293	32	perceive	perceive	VB
40439	293	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	293	34	--	--	:
40439	293	35	though	though	RB
40439	293	36	in	in	IN
40439	293	37	a	a	DT
40439	293	38	case	case	NN
40439	293	39	where	where	WRB
40439	293	40	,	,	,
40439	293	41	according	accord	VBG
40439	293	42	to	to	IN
40439	293	43	M.	M.	NNP
40439	293	44	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	293	45	,	,	,
40439	293	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	293	47	did	do	VBD
40439	293	48	not	not	RB
40439	293	49	scruple	scruple	JJ
40439	293	50	to	to	TO
40439	293	51	resort	resort	VB
40439	293	52	to	to	IN
40439	293	53	dishonest	dishonest	JJ
40439	293	54	artifice	artifice	NN
40439	293	55	.	.	.
40439	294	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	294	2	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	294	3	to	to	IN
40439	294	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	294	5	that	that	IN
40439	294	6	the	the	DT
40439	294	7	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
40439	294	8	and	and	CC
40439	294	9	anomalies	anomaly	NNS
40439	294	10	,	,	,
40439	294	11	in	in	IN
40439	294	12	which	which	WDT
40439	294	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	294	14	are	be	VBP
40439	294	15	involved	involve	VBN
40439	294	16	from	from	IN
40439	294	17	supposing	suppose	VBG
40439	294	18	that	that	IN
40439	294	19	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	294	20	either	either	CC
40439	294	21	misunderstood	misunderstood	NN
40439	294	22	or	or	CC
40439	294	23	perverted	pervert	VBD
40439	294	24	the	the	DT
40439	294	25	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	294	26	of	of	IN
40439	294	27	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	294	28	--	--	:
40439	294	29	are	be	VBP
40439	294	30	far	far	RB
40439	294	31	graver	graver	JJ
40439	294	32	than	than	IN
40439	294	33	those	those	DT
40439	294	34	which	which	WDT
40439	294	35	would	would	MD
40439	294	36	arise	arise	VB
40439	294	37	from	from	IN
40439	294	38	admitting	admit	VBG
40439	294	39	that	that	IN
40439	294	40	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	294	41	advanced	advance	VBD
40439	294	42	a	a	DT
40439	294	43	complicated	complicated	JJ
40439	294	44	theory	theory	NN
40439	294	45	involving	involve	VBG
40439	294	46	two	two	CD
40439	294	47	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
40439	294	48	propositions	proposition	NNS
40439	294	49	,	,	,
40439	294	50	in	in	IN
40439	294	51	the	the	DT
40439	294	52	same	same	JJ
40439	294	53	dialogue	dialogue	NN
40439	294	54	,	,	,
40439	294	55	without	without	IN
40439	294	56	perceiving	perceive	VBG
40439	294	57	the	the	DT
40439	294	58	contradiction	contradiction	NN
40439	294	59	;	;	:
40439	294	60	more	more	RBR
40439	294	61	especially	especially	RB
40439	294	62	when	when	WRB
40439	294	63	the	the	DT
40439	294	64	like	like	JJ
40439	294	65	failure	failure	NN
40439	294	66	of	of	IN
40439	294	67	perception	perception	NN
40439	294	68	is	be	VBZ
40439	294	69	indisputably	indisputably	RB
40439	294	70	ascribable	ascribable	JJ
40439	294	71	to	to	IN
40439	294	72	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	294	73	--	--	:
40439	294	74	upon	upon	IN
40439	294	75	every	every	DT
40439	294	76	view	view	NN
40439	294	77	of	of	IN
40439	294	78	the	the	DT
40439	294	79	case	case	NN
40439	294	80	.	.	.
40439	295	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	295	2	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	295	3	maintains	maintain	VBZ
40439	295	4	the	the	DT
40439	295	5	same	same	JJ
40439	295	6	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	295	7	of	of	IN
40439	295	8	the	the	DT
40439	295	9	Platonic	platonic	JJ
40439	295	10	passage	passage	NN
40439	295	11	as	as	IN
40439	295	12	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	295	13	and	and	CC
40439	295	14	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	295	15	,	,	,
40439	295	16	and	and	CC
40439	295	17	defends	defend	VBZ
40439	295	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	295	19	by	by	IN
40439	295	20	a	a	DT
40439	295	21	note	note	NN
40439	295	22	on	on	IN
40439	295	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	295	24	translation	translation	NN
40439	295	25	of	of	IN
40439	295	26	the	the	DT
40439	295	27	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	295	28	(	(	-LRB-
40439	295	29	p.	p.	NN
40439	295	30	339	339	CD
40439	295	31	)	)	-RRB-
40439	295	32	.	.	.
40439	296	1	The	the	DT
40439	296	2	five	five	CD
40439	296	3	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	296	4	which	which	WDT
40439	296	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	296	6	produces	produce	VBZ
40439	296	7	are	be	VBP
40439	296	8	considered	consider	VBN
40439	296	9	both	both	DT
40439	296	10	by	by	IN
40439	296	11	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	296	12	and	and	CC
40439	296	13	by	by	IN
40439	296	14	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	296	15	to	to	TO
40439	296	16	be	be	VB
40439	296	17	unanswerable	unanswerable	JJ
40439	296	18	.	.	.
40439	297	1	As	as	IN
40439	297	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	297	3	puts	put	VBZ
40439	297	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	297	5	with	with	IN
40439	297	6	great	great	JJ
40439	297	7	neatness	neatness	NN
40439	297	8	and	and	CC
40439	297	9	terseness	terseness	NN
40439	297	10	,	,	,
40439	297	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	297	12	here	here	RB
40439	297	13	bestow	bestow	VBP
40439	297	14	upon	upon	IN
40439	297	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	297	16	a	a	DT
40439	297	17	separate	separate	JJ
40439	297	18	examination	examination	NN
40439	297	19	.	.	.
40439	298	1	1	1	LS
40439	298	2	.	.	.
40439	299	1	"	"	``
40439	299	2	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	299	3	a	a	DT
40439	299	4	toujours	toujours	NN
40439	299	5	été	été	NN
40439	299	6	considéré	considéré	NN
40439	299	7	dans	dan	NNS
40439	299	8	l'antiquité	l'antiquité	NNP
40439	299	9	comme	comme	NNP
40439	299	10	partisan	partisan	FW
40439	299	11	de	de	FW
40439	299	12	l'immobilité	l'immobilité	NNP
40439	299	13	absolue	absolue	NNP
40439	299	14	de	de	NNP
40439	299	15	la	la	NNP
40439	299	16	terre	terre	NNP
40439	299	17	.	.	.
40439	299	18	"	"	''
40439	300	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	300	2	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	300	3	had	have	VBD
40439	300	4	before	before	RB
40439	300	5	said	say	VBN
40439	300	6	,	,	,
40439	300	7	"	"	``
40439	300	8	Aristote	aristote	NN
40439	300	9	se	se	NNP
40439	300	10	fonde	fonde	FW
40439	300	11	sur	sur	FW
40439	300	12	ce	ce	NNP
40439	300	13	passage	passage	NN
40439	300	14	pour	pour	NN
40439	300	15	établir	établir	NNP
40439	300	16	que	que	NNP
40439	300	17	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	300	18	a	a	DT
40439	300	19	fait	fait	NN
40439	300	20	tourner	tourner	NN
40439	300	21	la	la	NNP
40439	300	22	terre	terre	NNP
40439	300	23	sur	sur	NNP
40439	300	24	elle	elle	NNP
40439	300	25	-	-	HYPH
40439	300	26	même	même	NNP
40439	300	27	:	:	:
40439	300	28	mais	mais	NNP
40439	300	29	Aristote	Aristote	NNP
40439	300	30	est	est	NNP
40439	300	31	,	,	,
40439	300	32	dans	dan	VBZ
40439	300	33	l'antiquité	l'antiquité	NNP
40439	300	34	,	,	,
40439	300	35	le	le	NNP
40439	300	36	seul	seul	NNP
40439	300	37	qui	qui	NNP
40439	300	38	soutienne	soutienne	NNP
40439	300	39	cette	cette	NNP
40439	300	40	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	300	41	.	.	.
40439	300	42	"	"	''
40439	301	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	301	2	reply	reply	NN
40439	301	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	301	4	,	,	,
40439	301	5	that	that	IN
40439	301	6	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	301	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	301	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	301	9	a	a	DT
40439	301	10	portion	portion	NN
40439	301	11	and	and	CC
40439	301	12	member	member	NN
40439	301	13	of	of	IN
40439	301	14	antiquity	antiquity	NN
40439	301	15	,	,	,
40439	301	16	and	and	CC
40439	301	17	that	that	IN
40439	301	18	the	the	DT
40439	301	19	various	various	JJ
40439	301	20	Platonists	Platonists	NNPS
40439	301	21	,	,	,
40439	301	22	whom	whom	WP
40439	301	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	301	24	undertakes	undertake	VBZ
40439	301	25	to	to	TO
40439	301	26	refute	refute	VB
40439	301	27	,	,	,
40439	301	28	are	be	VBP
40439	301	29	portions	portion	NNS
40439	301	30	of	of	IN
40439	301	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	301	32	also	also	RB
40439	301	33	.	.	.
40439	302	1	If	if	IN
40439	302	2	M.	M.	NNP
40439	302	3	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	302	4	appeals	appeal	VBZ
40439	302	5	to	to	IN
40439	302	6	the	the	DT
40439	302	7	authority	authority	NN
40439	302	8	of	of	IN
40439	302	9	antiquity	antiquity	NN
40439	302	10	,	,	,
40439	302	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	302	12	must	must	MD
40439	302	13	be	be	VB
40439	302	14	to	to	IN
40439	302	15	antiquity	antiquity	NN
40439	302	16	,	,	,
40439	302	17	not	not	RB
40439	302	18	merely	merely	RB
40439	302	19	_	_	NNP
40439	302	20	minus	minus	NN
40439	302	21	_	_	NNP
40439	302	22	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	302	23	and	and	CC
40439	302	24	these	these	DT
40439	302	25	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
40439	302	26	Platonists	Platonists	NNPS
40439	302	27	,	,	,
40439	302	28	but	but	CC
40439	302	29	_	_	NNP
40439	302	30	against	against	IN
40439	302	31	_	_	NNP
40439	302	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	302	33	.	.	.
40439	303	1	Now	now	RB
40439	303	2	these	these	DT
40439	303	3	are	be	VBP
40439	303	4	just	just	RB
40439	303	5	the	the	DT
40439	303	6	witnesses	witness	NNS
40439	303	7	who	who	WP
40439	303	8	had	have	VBD
40439	303	9	the	the	DT
40439	303	10	best	good	JJS
40439	303	11	means	mean	NNS
40439	303	12	of	of	IN
40439	303	13	knowledge	knowledge	NN
40439	303	14	.	.	.
40439	304	1	Besides	besides	IN
40439	304	2	which	which	WDT
40439	304	3	,	,	,
40439	304	4	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	304	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	304	6	,	,	,
40439	304	7	adopting	adopt	VBG
40439	304	8	and	and	CC
40439	304	9	anxious	anxious	JJ
40439	304	10	to	to	TO
40439	304	11	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
40439	304	12	the	the	DT
40439	304	13	immobility	immobility	NN
40439	304	14	of	of	IN
40439	304	15	the	the	DT
40439	304	16	earth	earth	NN
40439	304	17	,	,	,
40439	304	18	had	have	VBD
40439	304	19	every	every	DT
40439	304	20	motive	motive	NN
40439	304	21	to	to	TO
40439	304	22	cite	cite	VB
40439	304	23	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	304	24	as	as	IN
40439	304	25	a	a	DT
40439	304	26	supporter	supporter	NN
40439	304	27	,	,	,
40439	304	28	if	if	IN
40439	304	29	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	304	30	was	be	VBD
40439	304	31	such	such	JJ
40439	304	32	--	--	:
40439	304	33	and	and	CC
40439	304	34	every	every	DT
40439	304	35	motive	motive	NN
40439	304	36	to	to	TO
40439	304	37	avoid	avoid	VB
40439	304	38	citing	cite	VBG
40439	304	39	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	304	40	as	as	IN
40439	304	41	an	an	DT
40439	304	42	opponent	opponent	NN
40439	304	43	,	,	,
40439	304	44	unless	unless	IN
40439	304	45	the	the	DT
40439	304	46	truth	truth	NN
40439	304	47	of	of	IN
40439	304	48	the	the	DT
40439	304	49	case	case	NN
40439	304	50	compelled	compel	VBD
40439	304	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	304	52	to	to	TO
40439	304	53	do	do	VB
40439	304	54	so	so	RB
40439	304	55	.	.	.
40439	305	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	305	2	must	must	MD
40439	305	3	here	here	RB
40439	305	4	add	add	VB
40439	305	5	,	,	,
40439	305	6	that	that	IN
40439	305	7	M.	M.	NNP
40439	305	8	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	305	9	represents	represent	VBZ
40439	305	10	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	305	11	as	as	IN
40439	305	12	ascribing	ascribe	VBG
40439	305	13	to	to	IN
40439	305	14	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	305	15	the	the	DT
40439	305	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	305	17	that	that	IN
40439	305	18	"	"	``
40439	305	19	la	la	NNP
40439	305	20	terre	terre	NNP
40439	305	21	tourne	tourne	NNP
40439	305	22	sur	sur	NNP
40439	305	23	elle	elle	NNP
40439	305	24	-	-	HYPH
40439	305	25	même	même	NNP
40439	305	26	.	.	.
40439	305	27	"	"	''
40439	306	1	This	this	DT
40439	306	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	306	3	not	not	RB
40439	306	4	strictly	strictly	RB
40439	306	5	exact	exact	JJ
40439	306	6	.	.	.
40439	307	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	307	2	understands	understand	VBZ
40439	307	3	the	the	DT
40439	307	4	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	307	5	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	307	6	as	as	IN
40439	307	7	saying	say	VBG
40439	307	8	,	,	,
40439	307	9	"	"	``
40439	307	10	That	that	IN
40439	307	11	the	the	DT
40439	307	12	earth	earth	NN
40439	307	13	is	be	VBZ
40439	307	14	packed	pack	VBN
40439	307	15	and	and	CC
40439	307	16	moved	move	VBN
40439	307	17	_	_	NNP
40439	307	18	round	round	IN
40439	307	19	the	the	DT
40439	307	20	axis	axi	NNS
40439	307	21	of	of	IN
40439	307	22	the	the	DT
40439	307	23	kosmos_"--a	kosmos_"--a	JJ
40439	307	24	different	different	JJ
40439	307	25	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	307	26	.	.	.
40439	308	1	2	2	LS
40439	308	2	.	.	.
40439	309	1	"	"	``
40439	309	2	Dans	dan	NNS
40439	309	3	plusieurs	plusieur	VBZ
40439	309	4	endroits	endroit	NNS
40439	309	5	de	de	IN
40439	309	6	ses	ses	NNP
40439	309	7	ouvrages	ouvrage	NNS
40439	309	8	où	où	IN
40439	309	9	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	309	10	parle	parle	NNP
40439	309	11	de	de	FW
40439	309	12	l'équilibre	l'équilibre	NNP
40439	309	13	de	de	NNP
40439	309	14	la	la	NNP
40439	309	15	terre	terre	NNP
40439	309	16	,	,	,
40439	309	17	il	il	NNP
40439	309	18	ne	ne	NNP
40439	309	19	dit	dit	NNP
40439	309	20	pas	pas	NNP
40439	309	21	un	un	NNP
40439	309	22	mot	mot	NNP
40439	309	23	de	de	NNP
40439	309	24	sa	sa	NNP
40439	309	25	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	309	26	.	.	.
40439	309	27	"	"	''
40439	310	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	310	2	know	know	VBP
40439	310	3	of	of	IN
40439	310	4	only	only	RB
40439	310	5	_	_	NNP
40439	310	6	one	one	CD
40439	310	7	_	_	NNP
40439	310	8	such	such	JJ
40439	310	9	passage	passage	NN
40439	310	10	--	--	:
40439	310	11	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	310	12	,	,	,
40439	310	13	p.	p.	NN
40439	310	14	108	108	CD
40439	310	15	-	-	HYPH
40439	310	16	-where	-where	JJ
40439	310	17	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
40439	310	18	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	310	19	does	do	VBZ
40439	310	20	not	not	RB
40439	310	21	speak	speak	VB
40439	310	22	of	of	IN
40439	310	23	the	the	DT
40439	310	24	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	310	25	of	of	IN
40439	310	26	the	the	DT
40439	310	27	earth	earth	NN
40439	310	28	;	;	:
40439	310	29	but	but	CC
40439	310	30	neither	neither	DT
40439	310	31	does	do	VBZ
40439	310	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	310	33	speak	speak	VB
40439	310	34	of	of	IN
40439	310	35	the	the	DT
40439	310	36	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	310	37	of	of	IN
40439	310	38	the	the	DT
40439	310	39	sidereal	sidereal	NN
40439	310	40	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	310	41	and	and	CC
40439	310	42	of	of	IN
40439	310	43	the	the	DT
40439	310	44	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	310	45	--	--	:
40439	310	46	nor	nor	CC
40439	310	47	of	of	IN
40439	310	48	the	the	DT
40439	310	49	axis	axi	NNS
40439	310	50	of	of	IN
40439	310	51	the	the	DT
40439	310	52	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	310	53	.	.	.
40439	311	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	311	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	311	3	the	the	DT
40439	311	4	figure	figure	NN
40439	311	5	and	and	CC
40439	311	6	properties	property	NNS
40439	311	7	of	of	IN
40439	311	8	the	the	DT
40439	311	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	311	10	,	,	,
40439	311	11	considered	consider	VBN
40439	311	12	in	in	IN
40439	311	13	reference	reference	NN
40439	311	14	to	to	IN
40439	311	15	mankind	mankind	NN
40439	311	16	who	who	WP
40439	311	17	inhabit	inhabit	VBP
40439	311	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	311	19	,	,	,
40439	311	20	that	that	IN
40439	311	21	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	311	22	sketches	sketch	VBZ
40439	311	23	in	in	IN
40439	311	24	the	the	DT
40439	311	25	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	311	26	;	;	:
40439	311	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	311	28	takes	take	VBZ
40439	311	29	little	little	JJ
40439	311	30	notice	notice	NN
40439	311	31	of	of	IN
40439	311	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	311	33	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	311	34	relations	relation	NNS
40439	311	35	,	,	,
40439	311	36	and	and	CC
40439	311	37	gives	give	VBZ
40439	311	38	no	no	DT
40439	311	39	general	general	JJ
40439	311	40	theory	theory	NN
40439	311	41	about	about	IN
40439	311	42	the	the	DT
40439	311	43	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	311	44	.	.	.
40439	312	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	312	2	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	312	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	312	4	not	not	RB
40439	312	5	adverted	advert	VBN
40439	312	6	to	to	IN
40439	312	7	the	the	DT
40439	312	8	tenth	tenth	JJ
40439	312	9	Book	Book	NNP
40439	312	10	of	of	IN
40439	312	11	the	the	DT
40439	312	12	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	312	13	,	,	,
40439	312	14	where	where	WRB
40439	312	15	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	312	16	does	do	VBZ
40439	312	17	propound	propound	VB
40439	312	18	a	a	DT
40439	312	19	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	312	20	theory	theory	NN
40439	312	21	,	,	,
40439	312	22	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	312	23	symbolising	symbolise	VBG
40439	312	24	the	the	DT
40439	312	25	axis	axi	NNS
40439	312	26	of	of	IN
40439	312	27	the	the	DT
40439	312	28	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	312	29	with	with	IN
40439	312	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	312	31	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	312	32	functions	function	NNS
40439	312	33	.	.	.
40439	313	1	3	3	LS
40439	313	2	.	.	.
40439	314	1	"	"	``
40439	314	2	Si	Si	NNP
40439	314	3	la	la	NNP
40439	314	4	_	_	NNP
40439	314	5	terre	terre	NNP
40439	314	6	suit	suit	NN
40439	314	7	le	le	NNP
40439	314	8	mouvement	mouvement	NNP
40439	314	9	de	de	FW
40439	314	10	l'axe	l'axe	NNP
40439	314	11	du	du	NNP
40439	314	12	monde	monde	NNP
40439	314	13	_	_	NNP
40439	314	14	,	,	,
40439	314	15	le	le	NNP
40439	314	16	mouvement	mouvement	NNP
40439	314	17	de	de	NNP
40439	314	18	la	la	NNP
40439	314	19	huitième	huitième	NNP
40439	314	20	sphère	sphère	NNP
40439	314	21	,	,	,
40439	314	22	qui	qui	NNP
40439	314	23	est	est	NNP
40439	314	24	Le	Le	NNP
40439	314	25	Même	Même	NNP
40439	314	26	,	,	,
40439	314	27	devient	devient	NN
40439	314	28	nul	nul	NNP
40439	314	29	par	par	NNP
40439	314	30	rapport	rapport	NNP
40439	314	31	à	à	NNP
40439	314	32	elle	elle	NNP
40439	314	33	,	,	,
40439	314	34	et	et	FW
40439	314	35	les	les	FW
40439	314	36	étoiles	étoiles	NNP
40439	314	37	fixes	fixes	NNP
40439	314	38	,	,	,
40439	314	39	qui	qui	NNP
40439	314	40	appartiennent	appartiennent	NNP
40439	314	41	à	à	NNP
40439	314	42	elle	elle	NNP
40439	314	43	,	,	,
40439	314	44	demeurent	demeurent	NN
40439	314	45	en	en	IN
40439	314	46	apparence	apparence	NN
40439	314	47	dans	dan	NNS
40439	314	48	une	une	NNP
40439	314	49	immobilité	immobilité	NNP
40439	314	50	absolue	absolue	NNP
40439	314	51	:	:	:
40439	314	52	ce	ce	NNP
40439	314	53	qui	qui	VBD
40439	314	54	est	est	NNP
40439	314	55	contraire	contraire	VBP
40439	314	56	à	à	NNP
40439	314	57	_	_	NNP
40439	314	58	l'expérience	l'expérience	NN
40439	314	59	et	et	NNP
40439	314	60	au	au	NNP
40439	314	61	sens	sens	NNP
40439	314	62	commun	commun	VBD
40439	314	63	_	_	NNP
40439	314	64	,	,	,
40439	314	65	et	et	NNP
40439	314	66	à	à	NNP
40439	314	67	l'opinion	l'opinion	NN
40439	314	68	de	de	NNP
40439	314	69	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	314	70	,	,	,
40439	314	71	exprimée	exprimée	NNP
40439	314	72	dans	dan	NNS
40439	314	73	ce	ce	VBP
40439	314	74	même	même	JJ
40439	314	75	passage	passage	NN
40439	314	76	.	.	.
40439	314	77	"	"	''
40439	315	1	This	this	DT
40439	315	2	third	third	JJ
40439	315	3	argument	argument	NN
40439	315	4	of	of	IN
40439	315	5	M.	M.	NNP
40439	315	6	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	315	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	315	8	the	the	DT
40439	315	9	same	same	JJ
40439	315	10	as	as	IN
40439	315	11	that	that	DT
40439	315	12	which	which	WDT
40439	315	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	315	14	have	have	VBP
40439	315	15	already	already	RB
40439	315	16	examined	examine	VBN
40439	315	17	in	in	IN
40439	315	18	remarking	remark	VBG
40439	315	19	upon	upon	IN
40439	315	20	M.	M.	NNP
40439	315	21	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	315	22	.	.	.
40439	316	1	The	the	DT
40439	316	2	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	316	3	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	316	4	of	of	IN
40439	316	5	the	the	DT
40439	316	6	earth	earth	NN
40439	316	7	can	can	MD
40439	316	8	not	not	RB
40439	316	9	stand	stand	VB
40439	316	10	in	in	IN
40439	316	11	the	the	DT
40439	316	12	same	same	JJ
40439	316	13	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	316	14	system	system	NN
40439	316	15	with	with	IN
40439	316	16	the	the	DT
40439	316	17	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	316	18	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	316	19	of	of	IN
40439	316	20	the	the	DT
40439	316	21	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	316	22	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	316	23	.	.	.
40439	317	1	Incontestably	incontestably	RB
40439	317	2	true	true	JJ
40439	317	3	(	(	-LRB-
40439	317	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	317	5	have	have	VBP
40439	317	6	already	already	RB
40439	317	7	said	say	VBN
40439	317	8	)	)	-RRB-
40439	317	9	as	as	IN
40439	317	10	a	a	DT
40439	317	11	point	point	NN
40439	317	12	of	of	IN
40439	317	13	science	science	NN
40439	317	14	.	.	.
40439	318	1	But	but	CC
40439	318	2	the	the	DT
40439	318	3	question	question	NN
40439	318	4	here	here	RB
40439	318	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	318	6	,	,	,
40439	318	7	not	not	RB
40439	318	8	what	what	WDT
40439	318	9	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	318	10	are	be	VBP
40439	318	11	scientifically	scientifically	RB
40439	318	12	consistent	consistent	JJ
40439	318	13	,	,	,
40439	318	14	but	but	CC
40439	318	15	what	what	WP
40439	318	16	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	318	17	were	be	VBD
40439	318	18	held	hold	VBN
40439	318	19	by	by	IN
40439	318	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	318	21	,	,	,
40439	318	22	and	and	CC
40439	318	23	whether	whether	IN
40439	318	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	318	25	detected	detect	VBD
40439	318	26	the	the	DT
40439	318	27	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
40439	318	28	between	between	IN
40439	318	29	the	the	DT
40439	318	30	two	two	CD
40439	318	31	.	.	.
40439	319	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	319	2	have	have	VBP
40439	319	3	shown	show	VBN
40439	319	4	grounds	ground	NNS
40439	319	5	for	for	IN
40439	319	6	believing	believe	VBG
40439	319	7	that	that	IN
40439	319	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	319	9	did	do	VBD
40439	319	10	not	not	RB
40439	319	11	--	--	:
40439	319	12	and	and	CC
40439	319	13	not	not	RB
40439	319	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	319	15	alone	alone	RB
40439	319	16	,	,	,
40439	319	17	but	but	CC
40439	319	18	many	many	JJ
40439	319	19	others	other	NNS
40439	319	20	along	along	IN
40439	319	21	with	with	IN
40439	319	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	319	23	,	,	,
40439	319	24	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	319	25	among	among	IN
40439	319	26	the	the	DT
40439	319	27	number	number	NN
40439	319	28	.	.	.
40439	320	1	How	how	WRB
40439	320	2	,	,	,
40439	320	3	indeed	indeed	RB
40439	320	4	,	,	,
40439	320	5	can	can	MD
40439	320	6	this	this	DT
40439	320	7	be	be	VB
40439	320	8	denied	deny	VBN
40439	320	9	,	,	,
40439	320	10	when	when	WRB
40439	320	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	320	12	find	find	VBP
40439	320	13	M.	M.	NNP
40439	320	14	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	320	15	announcing	announce	VBG
40439	320	16	that	that	IN
40439	320	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	320	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	320	19	the	the	DT
40439	320	20	_	_	NNP
40439	320	21	first	first	JJ
40439	320	22	_	_	NNP
40439	320	23	among	among	IN
40439	320	24	all	all	PDT
40439	320	25	the	the	DT
40439	320	26	critics	critic	NNS
40439	320	27	on	on	IN
40439	320	28	the	the	DT
40439	320	29	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	320	30	,	,	,
40439	320	31	who	who	WP
40439	320	32	has	have	VBZ
40439	320	33	brought	bring	VBN
40439	320	34	forward	forward	RB
40439	320	35	the	the	DT
40439	320	36	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
40439	320	37	as	as	IN
40439	320	38	a	a	DT
40439	320	39	special	special	JJ
40439	320	40	ground	ground	NN
40439	320	41	for	for	IN
40439	320	42	determining	determine	VBG
40439	320	43	what	what	WP
40439	320	44	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	320	45	's	's	POS
40439	320	46	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	320	47	was	be	VBD
40439	320	48	--	--	:
40439	320	49	that	that	IN
40439	320	50	no	no	DT
40439	320	51	other	other	JJ
40439	320	52	critic	critic	NN
40439	320	53	before	before	IN
40439	320	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	320	55	had	have	VBD
40439	320	56	noticed	notice	VBN
40439	320	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	320	58	?	?	.
40439	321	1	The	the	DT
40439	321	2	first	first	JJ
40439	321	3	words	word	NNS
40439	321	4	of	of	IN
40439	321	5	this	this	DT
40439	321	6	argument	argument	NN
40439	321	7	deserve	deserve	VBP
40439	321	8	particular	particular	JJ
40439	321	9	attention	attention	NN
40439	321	10	,	,	,
40439	321	11	"	"	''
40439	321	12	Si	Si	NNP
40439	321	13	la	la	NNP
40439	321	14	terre	terre	NNP
40439	321	15	suit	suit	NN
40439	321	16	le	le	NNP
40439	321	17	mouvement	mouvement	NNP
40439	321	18	de	de	FW
40439	321	19	l'axe	l'axe	NNP
40439	321	20	du	du	NNP
40439	321	21	monde	monde	NNP
40439	321	22	.	.	.
40439	321	23	"	"	''
40439	322	1	Here	here	RB
40439	322	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	322	3	have	have	VBP
40439	322	4	an	an	DT
40439	322	5	exact	exact	JJ
40439	322	6	recital	recital	NN
40439	322	7	of	of	IN
40439	322	8	the	the	DT
40439	322	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	322	10	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	322	11	by	by	IN
40439	322	12	the	the	DT
40439	322	13	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	322	14	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	322	15	,	,	,
40439	322	16	and	and	CC
40439	322	17	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	322	18	to	to	IN
40439	322	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	322	20	by	by	IN
40439	322	21	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	322	22	(	(	-LRB-
40439	322	23	quite	quite	RB
40439	322	24	different	different	JJ
40439	322	25	from	from	IN
40439	322	26	the	the	DT
40439	322	27	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	322	28	"	"	``
40439	322	29	que	que	NNP
40439	322	30	la	la	NNP
40439	322	31	terre	terre	NNP
40439	322	32	tourne	tourne	NNP
40439	322	33	sur	sur	NNP
40439	322	34	elle	elle	NNP
40439	322	35	-	-	HYPH
40439	322	36	même	même	NNP
40439	322	37	"	"	''
40439	322	38	)	)	-RRB-
40439	322	39	.	.	.
40439	323	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	323	2	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	323	3	here	here	RB
40439	323	4	speaks	speak	VBZ
40439	323	5	very	very	RB
40439	323	6	distinctly	distinctly	RB
40439	323	7	about	about	IN
40439	323	8	the	the	DT
40439	323	9	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	323	10	axis	axis	NN
40439	323	11	,	,	,
40439	323	12	and	and	CC
40439	323	13	about	about	IN
40439	323	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	323	15	movement	movement	NN
40439	323	16	;	;	:
40439	323	17	thus	thus	RB
40439	323	18	implying	imply	VBG
40439	323	19	that	that	IN
40439	323	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	323	21	conceived	conceive	VBD
40439	323	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	323	23	as	as	IN
40439	323	24	a	a	DT
40439	323	25	solid	solid	JJ
40439	323	26	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	323	27	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	323	28	.	.	.
40439	324	1	This	this	DT
40439	324	2	,	,	,
40439	324	3	in	in	IN
40439	324	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	324	5	judgment	judgment	NN
40439	324	6	,	,	,
40439	324	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	324	8	the	the	DT
40439	324	9	most	most	RBS
40439	324	10	essential	essential	JJ
40439	324	11	point	point	NN
40439	324	12	for	for	IN
40439	324	13	clearing	clear	VBG
40439	324	14	up	up	RP
40439	324	15	the	the	DT
40439	324	16	question	question	NN
40439	324	17	in	in	IN
40439	324	18	debate	debate	NN
40439	324	19	.	.	.
40439	325	1	The	the	DT
40439	325	2	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	325	3	axis	axi	NNS
40439	325	4	being	be	VBG
40439	325	5	of	of	IN
40439	325	6	this	this	DT
40439	325	7	character	character	NN
40439	325	8	,	,	,
40439	325	9	when	when	WRB
40439	325	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	325	11	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	325	12	that	that	IN
40439	325	13	the	the	DT
40439	325	14	earth	earth	NN
40439	325	15	is	be	VBZ
40439	325	16	_	_	NNP
40439	325	17	packed	pack	VBN
40439	325	18	or	or	CC
40439	325	19	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	325	20	round	round	IN
40439	325	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	325	22	_	_	NNP
40439	325	23	(	(	-LRB-
40439	325	24	_	_	NNP
40439	325	25	se	se	NNP
40439	325	26	roule_--Cousin	roule_--Cousin	NNP
40439	325	27	:	:	:
40439	325	28	_	_	NNP
40439	325	29	se	se	NNP
40439	325	30	serre	serre	NNP
40439	325	31	et	et	NNP
40439	325	32	s'enroule_--Martin	s'enroule_--Martin	NNS
40439	325	33	:	:	:
40439	325	34	_	_	NNP
40439	325	35	drängt	drängt	NNP
40439	325	36	sich	sich	NNP
40439	325	37	,	,	,
40439	325	38	macht	macht	NNP
40439	325	39	eine	eine	NN
40439	325	40	Kugel	Kugel	NNP
40439	325	41	um	um	UH
40439	325	42	ihn_--Buttmann	ihn_--Buttmann	NNP
40439	325	43	)	)	-RRB-
40439	325	44	,	,	,
40439	325	45	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	325	46	maintain	maintain	VBP
40439	325	47	that	that	IN
40439	325	48	,	,	,
40439	325	49	in	in	IN
40439	325	50	the	the	DT
40439	325	51	plainest	plain	JJS
40439	325	52	construction	construction	NN
40439	325	53	of	of	IN
40439	325	54	the	the	DT
40439	325	55	word	word	NN
40439	325	56	,	,	,
40439	325	57	the	the	DT
40439	325	58	earth	earth	NN
40439	325	59	does	do	VBZ
40439	325	60	and	and	CC
40439	325	61	must	must	MD
40439	325	62	follow	follow	VB
40439	325	63	the	the	DT
40439	325	64	movement	movement	NN
40439	325	65	of	of	IN
40439	325	66	the	the	DT
40439	325	67	axis	axi	NNS
40439	325	68	--	--	:
40439	325	69	or	or	CC
40439	325	70	arrest	arrest	VB
40439	325	71	the	the	DT
40439	325	72	movement	movement	NN
40439	325	73	of	of	IN
40439	325	74	the	the	DT
40439	325	75	axis	axi	NNS
40439	325	76	.	.	.
40439	326	1	The	the	DT
40439	326	2	word	word	NN
40439	326	3	[	[	-LRB-
40439	326	4	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	326	5	:	:	:
40439	326	6	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	326	7	/	/	SYM
40439	326	8	nên	nên	NN
40439	326	9	]	]	-RRB-
40439	326	10	or	or	CC
40439	326	11	[	[	-LRB-
40439	326	12	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	326	13	:	:	:
40439	326	14	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	326	15	/	/	SYM
40439	326	16	nên	nên	NNP
40439	326	17	]	]	-RRB-
40439	326	18	has	have	VBZ
40439	326	19	no	no	DT
40439	326	20	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	326	21	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	326	22	at	at	RB
40439	326	23	all	all	RB
40439	326	24	,	,	,
40439	326	25	if	if	IN
40439	326	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	326	27	does	do	VBZ
40439	326	28	not	not	RB
40439	326	29	mean	mean	VB
40439	326	30	this	this	DT
40439	326	31	.	.	.
40439	327	1	The	the	DT
40439	327	2	very	very	JJ
40439	327	3	synonyms	synonyms	NN
40439	327	4	(	(	-LRB-
40439	327	5	[	[	-LRB-
40439	327	6	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	327	7	:	:	:
40439	327	8	sphiggome	sphiggome	NN
40439	327	9	/	/	SYM
40439	327	10	nên	nên	NNP
40439	327	11	,	,	,
40439	327	12	peridedeme	peridedeme	NNP
40439	327	13	/	/	SYM
40439	327	14	nên	nên	NNP
40439	327	15	]	]	-RRB-
40439	327	16	,	,	,
40439	327	17	&	&	CC
40439	327	18	c.	c.	NNP
40439	327	19	)	)	-RRB-
40439	327	20	,	,	,
40439	327	21	which	which	WDT
40439	327	22	the	the	DT
40439	327	23	commentators	commentator	NNS
40439	327	24	produce	produce	VBP
40439	327	25	to	to	TO
40439	327	26	prove	prove	VB
40439	327	27	that	that	IN
40439	327	28	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	327	29	describes	describe	VBZ
40439	327	30	the	the	DT
40439	327	31	earth	earth	NN
40439	327	32	as	as	IN
40439	327	33	at	at	IN
40439	327	34	rest	rest	NN
40439	327	35	,	,	,
40439	327	36	do	do	VB
40439	327	37	really	really	RB
40439	327	38	prove	prove	VB
40439	327	39	that	that	IN
40439	327	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	327	41	describes	describe	VBZ
40439	327	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	327	43	as	as	IN
40439	327	44	rotating	rotate	VBG
40439	327	45	round	round	RB
40439	327	46	and	and	CC
40439	327	47	with	with	IN
40439	327	48	the	the	DT
40439	327	49	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	327	50	axis	axis	NN
40439	327	51	.	.	.
40439	328	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	328	2	ought	ought	MD
40439	328	3	not	not	RB
40439	328	4	to	to	TO
40439	328	5	be	be	VB
40439	328	6	driven	drive	VBN
40439	328	7	from	from	IN
40439	328	8	this	this	DT
40439	328	9	plain	plain	JJ
40439	328	10	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	328	11	of	of	IN
40439	328	12	the	the	DT
40439	328	13	word	word	NN
40439	328	14	,	,	,
40439	328	15	by	by	IN
40439	328	16	the	the	DT
40439	328	17	assurance	assurance	NN
40439	328	18	of	of	IN
40439	328	19	M.	M.	NNP
40439	328	20	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	328	21	and	and	CC
40439	328	22	others	other	NNS
40439	328	23	that	that	IN
40439	328	24	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	328	25	can	can	MD
40439	328	26	not	not	RB
40439	328	27	have	have	VB
40439	328	28	meant	mean	VBN
40439	328	29	so	so	RB
40439	328	30	,	,	,
40439	328	31	because	because	IN
40439	328	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	328	33	would	would	MD
40439	328	34	involve	involve	VB
40439	328	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	328	36	in	in	IN
40439	328	37	an	an	DT
40439	328	38	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	328	39	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
40439	328	40	.	.	.
40439	329	1	4	4	LS
40439	329	2	.	.	.
40439	330	1	"	"	``
40439	330	2	Les	Les	NNP
40439	330	3	divers	diver	NNS
40439	330	4	mouvemens	mouvemen	VBZ
40439	330	5	des	des	NNP
40439	330	6	huit	huit	NNP
40439	330	7	sphères	sphère	VBZ
40439	330	8	expliquent	expliquent	NNP
40439	330	9	toutes	toute	NNS
40439	330	10	les	les	NNP
40439	330	11	apparences	apparence	NNS
40439	330	12	célestes	céleste	NNS
40439	330	13	;	;	:
40439	330	14	il	il	NNP
40439	330	15	n'y	n'y	RB
40439	330	16	a	a	DT
40439	330	17	donc	donc	NNS
40439	330	18	aucune	aucune	NNP
40439	330	19	raison	raison	NNP
40439	330	20	pour	pour	NNP
40439	330	21	donner	donner	NN
40439	330	22	un	un	NNP
40439	330	23	mouvement	mouvement	NNP
40439	330	24	à	à	NNP
40439	330	25	la	la	NNP
40439	330	26	terre	terre	NNP
40439	330	27	.	.	.
40439	330	28	"	"	''
40439	331	1	The	the	DT
40439	331	2	terms	term	NNS
40439	331	3	of	of	IN
40439	331	4	this	this	DT
40439	331	5	fourth	fourth	JJ
40439	331	6	argument	argument	NN
40439	331	7	,	,	,
40439	331	8	if	if	IN
40439	331	9	literally	literally	RB
40439	331	10	construed	construe	VBN
40439	331	11	,	,	,
40439	331	12	would	would	MD
40439	331	13	imply	imply	VB
40439	331	14	that	that	IN
40439	331	15	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	331	16	had	have	VBD
40439	331	17	devised	devise	VBN
40439	331	18	a	a	DT
40439	331	19	complete	complete	JJ
40439	331	20	and	and	CC
40439	331	21	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
40439	331	22	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	331	23	theory	theory	NN
40439	331	24	.	.	.
40439	332	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	332	2	pass	pass	VBP
40439	332	3	over	over	RP
40439	332	4	this	this	DT
40439	332	5	point	point	NN
40439	332	6	,	,	,
40439	332	7	and	and	CC
40439	332	8	construe	construe	VB
40439	332	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	332	10	as	as	IN
40439	332	11	M.	M.	NNP
40439	332	12	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	332	13	probably	probably	RB
40439	332	14	intended	intend	VBD
40439	332	15	:	:	:
40439	332	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	332	17	argument	argument	NN
40439	332	18	will	will	MD
40439	332	19	then	then	RB
40439	332	20	stand	stand	VB
40439	332	21	thus--"The	thus--"The	NNP
40439	332	22	movement	movement	NN
40439	332	23	of	of	IN
40439	332	24	the	the	DT
40439	332	25	earth	earth	NN
40439	332	26	does	do	VBZ
40439	332	27	not	not	RB
40439	332	28	add	add	VB
40439	332	29	anything	anything	NN
40439	332	30	to	to	IN
40439	332	31	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	332	32	's	's	POS
40439	332	33	power	power	NN
40439	332	34	of	of	IN
40439	332	35	explaining	explain	VBG
40439	332	36	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	332	37	appearances	appearance	NNS
40439	332	38	;	;	:
40439	332	39	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	332	40	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	332	41	had	have	VBD
40439	332	42	no	no	DT
40439	332	43	motive	motive	NN
40439	332	44	to	to	TO
40439	332	45	suggest	suggest	VB
40439	332	46	a	a	DT
40439	332	47	movement	movement	NN
40439	332	48	of	of	IN
40439	332	49	the	the	DT
40439	332	50	earth	earth	NN
40439	332	51	.	.	.
40439	332	52	"	"	''
40439	333	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	333	2	have	have	VBP
40439	333	3	already	already	RB
40439	333	4	specified	specify	VBN
40439	333	5	the	the	DT
40439	333	6	sense	sense	NN
40439	333	7	in	in	IN
40439	333	8	which	which	WDT
40439	333	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	333	10	understand	understand	VBP
40439	333	11	the	the	DT
40439	333	12	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	333	13	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	333	14	to	to	TO
40439	333	15	affirm	affirm	VB
40439	333	16	,	,	,
40439	333	17	or	or	CC
40439	333	18	rather	rather	RB
40439	333	19	to	to	TO
40439	333	20	imply	imply	VB
40439	333	21	,	,	,
40439	333	22	the	the	DT
40439	333	23	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	333	24	of	of	IN
40439	333	25	the	the	DT
40439	333	26	earth	earth	NN
40439	333	27	;	;	:
40439	333	28	and	and	CC
40439	333	29	that	that	DT
40439	333	30	sense	sense	NN
40439	333	31	is	be	VBZ
40439	333	32	not	not	RB
40439	333	33	open	open	JJ
40439	333	34	to	to	IN
40439	333	35	the	the	DT
40439	333	36	objections	objection	NNS
40439	333	37	raised	raise	VBN
40439	333	38	in	in	IN
40439	333	39	M.	M.	NNP
40439	333	40	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	333	41	's	's	POS
40439	333	42	fourth	fourth	JJ
40439	333	43	and	and	CC
40439	333	44	fifth	fifth	JJ
40439	333	45	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	333	46	.	.	.
40439	334	1	The	the	DT
40439	334	2	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	334	3	of	of	IN
40439	334	4	the	the	DT
40439	334	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	334	6	,	,	,
40439	334	7	as	as	IN
40439	334	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	334	9	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	334	10	in	in	IN
40439	334	11	the	the	DT
40439	334	12	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	334	13	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	334	14	,	,	,
40439	334	15	explains	explain	VBZ
40439	334	16	nothing	nothing	NN
40439	334	17	,	,	,
40439	334	18	and	and	CC
40439	334	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	334	20	not	not	RB
40439	334	21	intended	intend	VBN
40439	334	22	to	to	TO
40439	334	23	explain	explain	VB
40439	334	24	anything	anything	NN
40439	334	25	.	.	.
40439	335	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	335	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	335	3	a	a	DT
40439	335	4	consequence	consequence	NN
40439	335	5	,	,	,
40439	335	6	not	not	RB
40439	335	7	a	a	DT
40439	335	8	cause	cause	NN
40439	335	9	:	:	:
40439	335	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	335	11	is	be	VBZ
40439	335	12	a	a	DT
40439	335	13	consequence	consequence	NN
40439	335	14	arising	arise	VBG
40439	335	15	from	from	IN
40439	335	16	the	the	DT
40439	335	17	position	position	NN
40439	335	18	of	of	IN
40439	335	19	the	the	DT
40439	335	20	earth	earth	NN
40439	335	21	,	,	,
40439	335	22	as	as	IN
40439	335	23	packed	pack	VBN
40439	335	24	or	or	CC
40439	335	25	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	335	26	round	round	IN
40439	335	27	the	the	DT
40439	335	28	centre	centre	NN
40439	335	29	of	of	IN
40439	335	30	the	the	DT
40439	335	31	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	335	32	axis	axi	NNS
40439	335	33	,	,	,
40439	335	34	whereby	whereby	WRB
40439	335	35	the	the	DT
40439	335	36	earth	earth	NN
40439	335	37	participates	participate	VBZ
40439	335	38	,	,	,
40439	335	39	of	of	IN
40439	335	40	necessity	necessity	NN
40439	335	41	and	and	CC
40439	335	42	as	as	IN
40439	335	43	a	a	DT
40439	335	44	matter	matter	NN
40439	335	45	of	of	IN
40439	335	46	course	course	NN
40439	335	47	,	,	,
40439	335	48	in	in	IN
40439	335	49	the	the	DT
40439	335	50	movements	movement	NNS
40439	335	51	of	of	IN
40439	335	52	that	that	DT
40439	335	53	axis	axis	NN
40439	335	54	.	.	.
40439	336	1	The	the	DT
40439	336	2	_	_	NNP
40439	336	3	function	function	NN
40439	336	4	_	_	NNP
40439	336	5	of	of	IN
40439	336	6	the	the	DT
40439	336	7	earth	earth	NN
40439	336	8	,	,	,
40439	336	9	thus	thus	RB
40439	336	10	planted	plant	VBN
40439	336	11	in	in	IN
40439	336	12	the	the	DT
40439	336	13	centre	centre	NN
40439	336	14	of	of	IN
40439	336	15	the	the	DT
40439	336	16	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	336	17	,	,	,
40439	336	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	336	19	to	to	TO
40439	336	20	uphold	uphold	VB
40439	336	21	and	and	CC
40439	336	22	regulate	regulate	VB
40439	336	23	the	the	DT
40439	336	24	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	336	25	of	of	IN
40439	336	26	the	the	DT
40439	336	27	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	336	28	axis	axi	NNS
40439	336	29	;	;	:
40439	336	30	and	and	CC
40439	336	31	this	this	DT
40439	336	32	function	function	NN
40439	336	33	explains	explain	VBZ
40439	336	34	,	,	,
40439	336	35	in	in	IN
40439	336	36	the	the	DT
40439	336	37	scheme	scheme	NN
40439	336	38	of	of	IN
40439	336	39	the	the	DT
40439	336	40	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	336	41	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	336	42	,	,	,
40439	336	43	why	why	WRB
40439	336	44	the	the	DT
40439	336	45	axis	axis	NN
40439	336	46	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	336	47	uniformly	uniformly	JJ
40439	336	48	and	and	CC
40439	336	49	constantly	constantly	RB
40439	336	50	without	without	IN
40439	336	51	change	change	NN
40439	336	52	or	or	CC
40439	336	53	displacement	displacement	NN
40439	336	54	.	.	.
40439	337	1	Now	now	RB
40439	337	2	upon	upon	IN
40439	337	3	these	these	DT
40439	337	4	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	337	5	of	of	IN
40439	337	6	the	the	DT
40439	337	7	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	337	8	axis	axi	NNS
40439	337	9	all	all	PDT
40439	337	10	the	the	DT
40439	337	11	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	337	12	of	of	IN
40439	337	13	the	the	DT
40439	337	14	exterior	exterior	NNP
40439	337	15	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	337	16	depend	depend	VBP
40439	337	17	.	.	.
40439	338	1	This	this	DT
40439	338	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	338	3	admitted	admit	VBN
40439	338	4	by	by	IN
40439	338	5	M.	M.	NNP
40439	338	6	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	338	7	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	338	8	in	in	IN
40439	338	9	argument	argument	NN
40439	338	10	3	3	CD
40439	338	11	.	.	.
40439	339	1	There	there	EX
40439	339	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	339	3	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	339	4	every	every	DT
40439	339	5	reason	reason	NN
40439	339	6	why	why	WRB
40439	339	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	339	8	should	should	MD
40439	339	9	assign	assign	VB
40439	339	10	such	such	JJ
40439	339	11	regulating	regulating	NN
40439	339	12	function	function	NN
40439	339	13	to	to	IN
40439	339	14	the	the	DT
40439	339	15	earth	earth	NN
40439	339	16	,	,	,
40439	339	17	the	the	DT
40439	339	18	"	"	``
40439	339	19	first	first	JJ
40439	339	20	and	and	CC
40439	339	21	oldest	old	JJS
40439	339	22	of	of	IN
40439	339	23	intra	intra	JJ
40439	339	24	-	-	JJ
40439	339	25	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	339	26	deities	deity	NNS
40439	339	27	.	.	.
40439	339	28	"	"	''
40439	340	1	The	the	DT
40439	340	2	movement	movement	NN
40439	340	3	of	of	IN
40439	340	4	the	the	DT
40439	340	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	340	6	(	(	-LRB-
40439	340	7	as	as	IN
40439	340	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	340	9	before	before	IN
40439	340	10	observed	observe	VBN
40439	340	11	)	)	-RRB-
40439	340	12	is	be	VBZ
40439	340	13	only	only	RB
40439	340	14	an	an	DT
40439	340	15	incidental	incidental	JJ
40439	340	16	consequence	consequence	NN
40439	340	17	of	of	IN
40439	340	18	the	the	DT
40439	340	19	position	position	NN
40439	340	20	necessary	necessary	JJ
40439	340	21	for	for	IN
40439	340	22	the	the	DT
40439	340	23	earth	earth	NN
40439	340	24	to	to	TO
40439	340	25	occupy	occupy	VB
40439	340	26	in	in	IN
40439	340	27	performing	perform	VBG
40439	340	28	such	such	JJ
40439	340	29	function	function	NN
40439	340	30	.	.	.
40439	341	1	5	5	CD
40439	341	2	.	.	.
40439	342	1	"	"	``
40439	342	2	Enfin	Enfin	NNP
40439	342	3	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	342	4	assigne	assigne	VBP
40439	342	5	un	un	NNP
40439	342	6	mouvement	mouvement	NNP
40439	342	7	aux	aux	NNP
40439	342	8	étoiles	étoile	NNS
40439	342	9	fixes	fix	NNS
40439	342	10	,	,	,
40439	342	11	et	et	FW
40439	342	12	deux	deux	NNP
40439	342	13	mouvemens	mouvemens	NNP
40439	342	14	aux	aux	NNP
40439	342	15	planètes	planètes	NNPS
40439	342	16	;	;	:
40439	342	17	puisqu'il	puisqu'il	NNP
40439	342	18	ne	ne	NNP
40439	342	19	range	range	NNP
40439	342	20	la	la	NNP
40439	342	21	terre	terre	NNP
40439	342	22	ni	ni	NNP
40439	342	23	avec	avec	FW
40439	342	24	les	les	FW
40439	342	25	unes	unes	NNP
40439	342	26	ni	ni	NNP
40439	342	27	avec	avec	FW
40439	342	28	les	les	FW
40439	342	29	autres	autres	NNPS
40439	342	30	,	,	,
40439	342	31	il	il	NNP
40439	342	32	y	y	NNP
40439	342	33	a	a	DT
40439	342	34	lieu	lieu	NN
40439	342	35	de	de	FW
40439	342	36	croire	croire	NN
40439	342	37	qu'elle	qu'elle	NNP
40439	342	38	ne	ne	NNP
40439	342	39	participe	participe	NNP
40439	342	40	à	à	NNP
40439	342	41	aucun	aucun	NN
40439	342	42	de	de	NNP
40439	342	43	leurs	leurs	NNP
40439	342	44	mouvemens	mouvemens	NNPS
40439	342	45	.	.	.
40439	342	46	"	"	''
40439	343	1	In	in	IN
40439	343	2	so	so	RB
40439	343	3	far	far	RB
40439	343	4	as	as	IN
40439	343	5	this	this	DT
40439	343	6	argument	argument	NN
40439	343	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	343	8	well	well	RB
40439	343	9	-	-	HYPH
40439	343	10	founded	found	VBN
40439	343	11	,	,	,
40439	343	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	343	13	strengthens	strengthen	VBZ
40439	343	14	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	343	15	case	case	NN
40439	343	16	more	more	JJR
40439	343	17	than	than	IN
40439	343	18	that	that	DT
40439	343	19	of	of	IN
40439	343	20	M.	M.	NNP
40439	343	21	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	343	22	.	.	.
40439	344	1	The	the	DT
40439	344	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	344	3	does	do	VBZ
40439	344	4	not	not	RB
40439	344	5	participate	participate	VB
40439	344	6	in	in	IN
40439	344	7	the	the	DT
40439	344	8	movements	movement	NNS
40439	344	9	either	either	CC
40439	344	10	of	of	IN
40439	344	11	the	the	DT
40439	344	12	fixed	fix	VBN
40439	344	13	stars	star	NNS
40439	344	14	or	or	CC
40439	344	15	of	of	IN
40439	344	16	the	the	DT
40439	344	17	planets	planet	NNS
40439	344	18	;	;	:
40439	344	19	but	but	CC
40439	344	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	344	21	does	do	VBZ
40439	344	22	participate	participate	VB
40439	344	23	in	in	IN
40439	344	24	the	the	DT
40439	344	25	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	344	26	of	of	IN
40439	344	27	the	the	DT
40439	344	28	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	344	29	axis	axis	NN
40439	344	30	,	,	,
40439	344	31	upon	upon	IN
40439	344	32	which	which	WDT
40439	344	33	these	these	DT
40439	344	34	movements	movement	NNS
40439	344	35	depend	depend	VBP
40439	344	36	--	--	:
40439	344	37	the	the	DT
40439	344	38	movements	movement	NNS
40439	344	39	of	of	IN
40439	344	40	the	the	DT
40439	344	41	outer	outer	JJ
40439	344	42	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	344	43	,	,	,
40439	344	44	wholly	wholly	RB
40439	344	45	and	and	CC
40439	344	46	exclusively	exclusively	RB
40439	344	47	--	--	:
40439	344	48	the	the	DT
40439	344	49	movements	movement	NNS
40439	344	50	of	of	IN
40439	344	51	the	the	DT
40439	344	52	planets	planet	NNS
40439	344	53	,	,	,
40439	344	54	to	to	IN
40439	344	55	a	a	DT
40439	344	56	very	very	RB
40439	344	57	great	great	JJ
40439	344	58	degree	degree	NN
40439	344	59	,	,	,
40439	344	60	but	but	CC
40439	344	61	not	not	RB
40439	344	62	exclusively	exclusively	RB
40439	344	63	.	.	.
40439	345	1	The	the	DT
40439	345	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	345	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	345	4	not	not	RB
40439	345	5	ranked	rank	VBN
40439	345	6	either	either	CC
40439	345	7	among	among	IN
40439	345	8	the	the	DT
40439	345	9	fixed	fix	VBN
40439	345	10	stars	star	NNS
40439	345	11	or	or	CC
40439	345	12	among	among	IN
40439	345	13	the	the	DT
40439	345	14	planets	planet	NNS
40439	345	15	;	;	:
40439	345	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	345	17	is	be	VBZ
40439	345	18	a	a	DT
40439	345	19	body	body	NN
40439	345	20	or	or	CC
40439	345	21	deity	deity	NN
40439	345	22	_	_	NNP
40439	345	23	sui	sui	NNP
40439	345	24	generis	generis	NNP
40439	345	25	_	_	NNP
40439	345	26	,	,	,
40439	345	27	having	have	VBG
40439	345	28	a	a	DT
40439	345	29	special	special	JJ
40439	345	30	central	central	JJ
40439	345	31	function	function	NN
40439	345	32	of	of	IN
40439	345	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	345	34	own	own	JJ
40439	345	35	,	,	,
40439	345	36	to	to	TO
40439	345	37	regulate	regulate	VB
40439	345	38	that	that	DT
40439	345	39	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	345	40	axis	axi	NNS
40439	345	41	which	which	WDT
40439	345	42	impels	impel	VBZ
40439	345	43	the	the	DT
40439	345	44	whole	whole	JJ
40439	345	45	system	system	NN
40439	345	46	.	.	.
40439	346	1	The	the	DT
40439	346	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	346	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	346	4	a	a	DT
40439	346	5	motion	motion	NN
40439	346	6	of	of	IN
40439	346	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	346	8	own	own	JJ
40439	346	9	,	,	,
40439	346	10	round	round	JJ
40439	346	11	and	and	CC
40439	346	12	along	along	RB
40439	346	13	with	with	IN
40439	346	14	the	the	DT
40439	346	15	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	346	16	axis	axis	NN
40439	346	17	to	to	TO
40439	346	18	which	which	WDT
40439	346	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	346	20	is	be	VBZ
40439	346	21	attached	attach	VBN
40439	346	22	;	;	:
40439	346	23	but	but	CC
40439	346	24	this	this	DT
40439	346	25	motion	motion	NN
40439	346	26	of	of	IN
40439	346	27	the	the	DT
40439	346	28	earth	earth	NN
40439	346	29	(	(	-LRB-
40439	346	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	346	31	will	will	MD
40439	346	32	again	again	RB
40439	346	33	repeat	repeat	VB
40439	346	34	,	,	,
40439	346	35	to	to	TO
40439	346	36	prevent	prevent	VB
40439	346	37	misapprehension	misapprehension	NN
40439	346	38	)	)	-RRB-
40439	346	39	is	be	VBZ
40439	346	40	a	a	DT
40439	346	41	fact	fact	NN
40439	346	42	not	not	RB
40439	346	43	important	important	JJ
40439	346	44	by	by	IN
40439	346	45	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	346	46	,	,	,
40439	346	47	nor	nor	CC
40439	346	48	explaining	explain	VBG
40439	346	49	anything	anything	NN
40439	346	50	.	.	.
40439	347	1	The	the	DT
40439	347	2	grand	grand	JJ
40439	347	3	and	and	CC
40439	347	4	capital	capital	JJ
40439	347	5	fact	fact	NN
40439	347	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	347	7	the	the	DT
40439	347	8	central	central	JJ
40439	347	9	position	position	NN
40439	347	10	and	and	CC
40439	347	11	regulating	regulate	VBG
40439	347	12	function	function	NN
40439	347	13	of	of	IN
40439	347	14	the	the	DT
40439	347	15	earth	earth	NN
40439	347	16	,	,	,
40439	347	17	whereby	whereby	WRB
40439	347	18	all	all	PDT
40439	347	19	the	the	DT
40439	347	20	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	347	21	motions	motion	NNS
40439	347	22	,	,	,
40439	347	23	first	first	RB
40439	347	24	those	those	DT
40439	347	25	of	of	IN
40439	347	26	the	the	DT
40439	347	27	axis	axi	NNS
40439	347	28	,	,	,
40439	347	29	next	next	IN
40439	347	30	those	those	DT
40439	347	31	of	of	IN
40439	347	32	the	the	DT
40439	347	33	exterior	exterior	NNP
40439	347	34	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	347	35	,	,	,
40439	347	36	are	be	VBP
40439	347	37	upheld	uphold	VBN
40439	347	38	and	and	CC
40439	347	39	kept	keep	VBD
40439	347	40	uniform	uniform	JJ
40439	347	41	.	.	.
40439	348	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	348	2	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	348	3	adds	add	VBZ
40439	348	4	,	,	,
40439	348	5	as	as	IN
40439	348	6	a	a	DT
40439	348	7	sixth	sixth	JJ
40439	348	8	argument:--	argument:--	NN
40439	348	9	"	"	``
40439	348	10	On	on	IN
40439	348	11	peut	peut	NN
40439	348	12	ajouter	ajouter	NN
40439	348	13	à	à	DT
40439	348	14	ces	ces	NN
40439	348	15	raisons	raison	NNS
40439	348	16	que	que	NNP
40439	348	17	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	348	18	aurait	aurait	VBP
40439	348	19	nécessairement	nécessairement	NN
40439	348	20	insisté	insisté	NN
40439	348	21	sur	sur	FW
40439	348	22	le	le	NNP
40439	348	23	mouvement	mouvement	NNP
40439	348	24	de	de	NNP
40439	348	25	la	la	NNP
40439	348	26	terre	terre	NNP
40439	348	27	,	,	,
40439	348	28	s'il	s'il	NNP
40439	348	29	l'avait	l'avait	NNP
40439	348	30	admis	admis	NNP
40439	348	31	;	;	:
40439	348	32	et	et	NNP
40439	348	33	que	que	NNP
40439	348	34	ce	ce	NNP
40439	348	35	point	point	VBP
40439	348	36	étoit	étoit	NNP
40439	348	37	trop	trop	NNP
40439	348	38	controversé	controversé	NNP
40439	348	39	de	de	NNP
40439	348	40	son	son	NNP
40439	348	41	temps	temps	NNP
40439	348	42	et	et	NNP
40439	348	43	trop	trop	FW
40439	348	44	important	important	JJ
40439	348	45	en	en	FW
40439	348	46	lui	lui	NN
40439	348	47	-	-	HYPH
40439	348	48	même	même	JJ
40439	348	49	,	,	,
40439	348	50	pour	pour	VBP
40439	348	51	qu'il	qu'il	NNP
40439	348	52	ne	ne	NNP
40439	348	53	fît	fît	NNP
40439	348	54	que	que	NNP
40439	348	55	l'indiquer	l'indiquer	NNP
40439	348	56	en	en	FW
40439	348	57	se	se	FW
40439	348	58	servant	servant	JJ
40439	348	59	d'une	d'une	NNP
40439	348	60	expression	expression	NN
40439	348	61	équivoque	équivoque	NN
40439	348	62	.	.	.
40439	348	63	"	"	''
40439	349	1	In	in	IN
40439	349	2	the	the	DT
40439	349	3	first	first	JJ
40439	349	4	place	place	NN
40439	349	5	,	,	,
40439	349	6	granting	grant	VBG
40439	349	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	349	8	to	to	TO
40439	349	9	have	have	VB
40439	349	10	believed	believe	VBN
40439	349	11	in	in	IN
40439	349	12	the	the	DT
40439	349	13	motion	motion	NN
40439	349	14	of	of	IN
40439	349	15	the	the	DT
40439	349	16	earth	earth	NN
40439	349	17	,	,	,
40439	349	18	can	can	MD
40439	349	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	349	20	also	also	RB
40439	349	21	assume	assume	VB
40439	349	22	that	that	IN
40439	349	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	349	24	would	would	MD
40439	349	25	necessarily	necessarily	RB
40439	349	26	have	have	VB
40439	349	27	asserted	assert	VBN
40439	349	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	349	29	with	with	IN
40439	349	30	distinctness	distinctness	NN
40439	349	31	and	and	CC
40439	349	32	emphasis	emphasis	NN
40439	349	33	,	,	,
40439	349	34	as	as	IN
40439	349	35	M.	M.	NNP
40439	349	36	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	349	37	contends	contend	VBZ
40439	349	38	?	?	.
40439	350	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	350	2	think	think	VBP
40439	350	3	not	not	RB
40439	350	4	.	.	.
40439	351	1	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	351	2	maintains	maintain	VBZ
40439	351	3	exactly	exactly	RB
40439	351	4	the	the	DT
40439	351	5	contrary	contrary	NN
40439	351	6	;	;	:
40439	351	7	telling	tell	VBG
40439	351	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	351	9	that	that	IN
40439	351	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	351	11	's	's	POS
40439	351	12	language	language	NN
40439	351	13	was	be	VBD
40439	351	14	intentionally	intentionally	RB
40439	351	15	obscure	obscure	JJ
40439	351	16	and	and	CC
40439	351	17	equivocal	equivocal	JJ
40439	351	18	--	--	:
40439	351	19	from	from	IN
40439	351	20	fear	fear	NN
40439	351	21	of	of	IN
40439	351	22	putting	put	VBG
40439	351	23	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	351	24	in	in	IN
40439	351	25	open	open	JJ
40439	351	26	conflict	conflict	NN
40439	351	27	with	with	IN
40439	351	28	the	the	DT
40439	351	29	pious	pious	JJ
40439	351	30	and	and	CC
40439	351	31	orthodox	orthodox	JJ
40439	351	32	sentiment	sentiment	NN
40439	351	33	prevalent	prevalent	JJ
40439	351	34	around	around	IN
40439	351	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	351	36	.	.	.
40439	352	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	352	2	do	do	VBP
40439	352	3	not	not	RB
40439	352	4	carry	carry	VB
40439	352	5	this	this	DT
40439	352	6	part	part	NN
40439	352	7	of	of	IN
40439	352	8	the	the	DT
40439	352	9	case	case	NN
40439	352	10	so	so	RB
40439	352	11	far	far	RB
40439	352	12	as	as	IN
40439	352	13	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	352	14	,	,	,
40439	352	15	but	but	CC
40439	352	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	352	17	admit	admit	VBP
40439	352	18	that	that	IN
40439	352	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	352	20	rests	rest	VBZ
40439	352	21	upon	upon	IN
40439	352	22	a	a	DT
40439	352	23	foundation	foundation	NN
40439	352	24	of	of	IN
40439	352	25	reality	reality	NN
40439	352	26	.	.	.
40439	353	1	When	when	WRB
40439	353	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	353	3	read	read	VBP
40439	353	4	(	(	-LRB-
40439	353	5	Plutarch	plutarch	NN
40439	353	6	,	,	,
40439	353	7	De	De	NNP
40439	353	8	Facie	Facie	NNP
40439	353	9	in	in	IN
40439	353	10	Orbe	Orbe	NNP
40439	353	11	Lunæ	Lunæ	NNP
40439	353	12	,	,	,
40439	353	13	p.	p.	NN
40439	353	14	923	923	CD
40439	353	15	)	)	-RRB-
40439	353	16	how	how	WRB
40439	353	17	the	the	DT
40439	353	18	motion	motion	NN
40439	353	19	of	of	IN
40439	353	20	the	the	DT
40439	353	21	earth	earth	NN
40439	353	22	,	,	,
40439	353	23	as	as	IN
40439	353	24	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	353	25	by	by	IN
40439	353	26	Aristarchus	Aristarchus	NNP
40439	353	27	of	of	IN
40439	353	28	Samos	Samos	NNP
40439	353	29	(	(	-LRB-
40439	353	30	doubtless	doubtless	RB
40439	353	31	in	in	IN
40439	353	32	a	a	DT
40439	353	33	far	far	RB
40439	353	34	larger	large	JJR
40439	353	35	sense	sense	NN
40439	353	36	than	than	IN
40439	353	37	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	353	38	ever	ever	RB
40439	353	39	imagined	imagine	VBD
40439	353	40	,	,	,
40439	353	41	including	include	VBG
40439	353	42	both	both	DT
40439	353	43	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	353	44	and	and	CC
40439	353	45	translation	translation	NN
40439	353	46	)	)	-RRB-
40439	353	47	,	,	,
40439	353	48	was	be	VBD
40439	353	49	afterwards	afterwards	RB
40439	353	50	denounced	denounce	VBN
40439	353	51	as	as	IN
40439	353	52	glaring	glare	VBG
40439	353	53	impiety	impiety	NN
40439	353	54	,	,	,
40439	353	55	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	353	56	understand	understand	VBP
40439	353	57	the	the	DT
40439	353	58	atmosphere	atmosphere	NN
40439	353	59	of	of	IN
40439	353	60	religious	religious	JJ
40439	353	61	opinion	opinion	NN
40439	353	62	with	with	IN
40439	353	63	which	which	WDT
40439	353	64	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	353	65	was	be	VBD
40439	353	66	surrounded	surround	VBN
40439	353	67	.	.	.
40439	354	1	And	and	CC
40439	354	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	354	3	also	also	RB
40439	354	4	perceive	perceive	VBP
40439	354	5	that	that	IN
40439	354	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	354	7	might	may	MD
40439	354	8	have	have	VB
40439	354	9	reasons	reason	NNS
40439	354	10	for	for	IN
40439	354	11	preferring	prefer	VBG
40439	354	12	to	to	TO
40439	354	13	indicate	indicate	VB
40439	354	14	an	an	DT
40439	354	15	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	354	16	heresy	heresy	NN
40439	354	17	in	in	IN
40439	354	18	terms	term	NNS
40439	354	19	suitable	suitable	JJ
40439	354	20	for	for	IN
40439	354	21	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
40439	354	22	hearers	hearer	NNS
40439	354	23	,	,	,
40439	354	24	rather	rather	RB
40439	354	25	than	than	IN
40439	354	26	to	to	TO
40439	354	27	proclaim	proclaim	VB
40439	354	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	354	29	in	in	IN
40439	354	30	such	such	JJ
40439	354	31	emphatic	emphatic	JJ
40439	354	32	unequivocal	unequivocal	JJ
40439	354	33	words	word	NNS
40439	354	34	,	,	,
40439	354	35	as	as	IN
40439	354	36	might	may	MD
40439	354	37	be	be	VB
40439	354	38	quoted	quote	VBN
40439	354	39	by	by	IN
40439	354	40	some	some	DT
40439	354	41	future	future	JJ
40439	354	42	Melêtus	Melêtus	NNP
40439	354	43	in	in	IN
40439	354	44	case	case	NN
40439	354	45	of	of	IN
40439	354	46	an	an	DT
40439	354	47	indictment	indictment	NN
40439	354	48	before	before	IN
40439	354	49	the	the	DT
40439	354	50	Dikasts	Dikasts	NNPS
40439	354	51	.	.	.
40439	355	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	355	2	must	must	MD
40439	355	3	remember	remember	VB
40439	355	4	that	that	IN
40439	355	5	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	355	6	had	have	VBD
40439	355	7	been	be	VBN
40439	355	8	actually	actually	RB
40439	355	9	present	present	JJ
40439	355	10	at	at	IN
40439	355	11	the	the	DT
40439	355	12	trial	trial	NN
40439	355	13	of	of	IN
40439	355	14	Sokrates	Sokrates	NNPS
40439	355	15	.	.	.
40439	356	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	356	2	had	have	VBD
40439	356	3	heard	hear	VBN
40439	356	4	the	the	DT
40439	356	5	stress	stress	NN
40439	356	6	laid	lay	VBN
40439	356	7	by	by	IN
40439	356	8	the	the	DT
40439	356	9	accusers	accuser	NNS
40439	356	10	on	on	IN
40439	356	11	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	356	12	heresies	heresy	NNS
40439	356	13	,	,	,
40439	356	14	analogous	analogous	JJ
40439	356	15	to	to	IN
40439	356	16	those	those	DT
40439	356	17	of	of	IN
40439	356	18	Anaxagoras	Anaxagoras	NNPS
40439	356	19	,	,	,
40439	356	20	which	which	WDT
40439	356	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	356	22	imputed	impute	VBD
40439	356	23	to	to	IN
40439	356	24	Sokrates	Sokrates	NNPS
40439	356	25	--	--	:
40439	356	26	and	and	CC
40439	356	27	the	the	DT
40439	356	28	pains	pain	NNS
40439	356	29	taken	take	VBN
40439	356	30	by	by	IN
40439	356	31	the	the	DT
40439	356	32	latter	latter	JJ
40439	356	33	to	to	TO
40439	356	34	deny	deny	VB
40439	356	35	that	that	IN
40439	356	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	356	37	held	hold	VBD
40439	356	38	such	such	JJ
40439	356	39	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	356	40	(	(	-LRB-
40439	356	41	see	see	VB
40439	356	42	the	the	DT
40439	356	43	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	356	44	Apology	Apology	NNP
40439	356	45	)	)	-RRB-
40439	356	46	.	.	.
40439	357	1	The	the	DT
40439	357	2	impression	impression	NN
40439	357	3	left	leave	VBN
40439	357	4	by	by	IN
40439	357	5	such	such	PDT
40439	357	6	a	a	DT
40439	357	7	scene	scene	NN
40439	357	8	on	on	IN
40439	357	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	357	10	's	's	POS
40439	357	11	mind	mind	NN
40439	357	12	was	be	VBD
40439	357	13	not	not	RB
40439	357	14	likely	likely	JJ
40439	357	15	to	to	TO
40439	357	16	pass	pass	VB
40439	357	17	away	away	RB
40439	357	18	:	:	:
40439	357	19	nor	nor	CC
40439	357	20	can	can	MD
40439	357	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	357	22	be	be	VB
40439	357	23	surprised	surprised	JJ
40439	357	24	that	that	IN
40439	357	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	357	26	preferred	prefer	VBD
40439	357	27	to	to	TO
40439	357	28	use	use	VB
40439	357	29	propositions	proposition	NNS
40439	357	30	which	which	WDT
40439	357	31	involved	involve	VBD
40439	357	32	and	and	CC
40439	357	33	implied	imply	VBN
40439	357	34	,	,	,
40439	357	35	rather	rather	RB
40439	357	36	than	than	IN
40439	357	37	those	those	DT
40439	357	38	which	which	WDT
40439	357	39	directly	directly	RB
40439	357	40	and	and	CC
40439	357	41	undisguisedly	undisguisedly	RB
40439	357	42	asserted	assert	VBD
40439	357	43	,	,	,
40439	357	44	the	the	DT
40439	357	45	heretical	heretical	JJ
40439	357	46	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	357	47	of	of	IN
40439	357	48	the	the	DT
40439	357	49	earth	earth	NN
40439	357	50	's	's	POS
40439	357	51	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	357	52	.	.	.
40439	358	1	That	that	IN
40439	358	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	358	3	phraseology	phraseology	NN
40439	358	4	,	,	,
40439	358	5	however	however	RB
40439	358	6	indirect	indirect	JJ
40439	358	7	,	,	,
40439	358	8	was	be	VBD
40439	358	9	perfectly	perfectly	RB
40439	358	10	understood	understand	VBN
40439	358	11	by	by	IN
40439	358	12	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
40439	358	13	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
40439	358	14	,	,	,
40439	358	15	both	both	DT
40439	358	16	assentient	assentient	NN
40439	358	17	and	and	CC
40439	358	18	dissentient	dissentient	NN
40439	358	19	,	,	,
40439	358	20	as	as	IN
40439	358	21	embodying	embody	VBG
40439	358	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	358	23	belief	belief	NN
40439	358	24	in	in	IN
40439	358	25	the	the	DT
40439	358	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	358	27	--	--	:
40439	358	28	is	be	VBZ
40439	358	29	attested	attest	VBN
40439	358	30	by	by	IN
40439	358	31	the	the	DT
40439	358	32	two	two	CD
40439	358	33	passages	passage	NNS
40439	358	34	of	of	IN
40439	358	35	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	358	36	.	.	.
40439	359	1	Upon	upon	IN
40439	359	2	these	these	DT
40439	359	3	reasons	reason	NNS
40439	359	4	alone	alone	RB
40439	359	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	359	6	should	should	MD
40439	359	7	dissent	dissent	VB
40439	359	8	from	from	IN
40439	359	9	M.	M.	NNP
40439	359	10	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	359	11	's	's	POS
40439	359	12	sixth	sixth	JJ
40439	359	13	argument	argument	NN
40439	359	14	.	.	.
40439	360	1	But	but	CC
40439	360	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	360	3	have	have	VBP
40439	360	4	other	other	JJ
40439	360	5	reasons	reason	NNS
40439	360	6	besides	besides	RB
40439	360	7	.	.	.
40439	361	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	361	2	rests	rest	VBZ
40439	361	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	361	4	upon	upon	IN
40439	361	5	the	the	DT
40439	361	6	two	two	CD
40439	361	7	allegations	allegation	NNS
40439	361	8	that	that	IN
40439	361	9	the	the	DT
40439	361	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	361	11	of	of	IN
40439	361	12	the	the	DT
40439	361	13	earth	earth	NN
40439	361	14	's	's	POS
40439	361	15	motion	motion	NN
40439	361	16	was	be	VBD
40439	361	17	the	the	DT
40439	361	18	subject	subject	NN
40439	361	19	of	of	IN
40439	361	20	much	much	JJ
40439	361	21	controversial	controversial	JJ
40439	361	22	debate	debate	NN
40439	361	23	in	in	IN
40439	361	24	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	361	25	's	's	POS
40439	361	26	time	time	NN
40439	361	27	,	,	,
40439	361	28	and	and	CC
40439	361	29	of	of	IN
40439	361	30	great	great	JJ
40439	361	31	importance	importance	NN
40439	361	32	in	in	IN
40439	361	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	361	34	.	.	.
40439	362	1	Now	now	RB
40439	362	2	the	the	DT
40439	362	3	first	first	JJ
40439	362	4	of	of	IN
40439	362	5	these	these	DT
40439	362	6	two	two	CD
40439	362	7	allegations	allegation	NNS
40439	362	8	can	can	MD
40439	362	9	hardly	hardly	RB
40439	362	10	be	be	VB
40439	362	11	proved	prove	VBN
40439	362	12	,	,	,
40439	362	13	as	as	IN
40439	362	14	to	to	IN
40439	362	15	the	the	DT
40439	362	16	time	time	NN
40439	362	17	of	of	IN
40439	362	18	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	362	19	;	;	:
40439	362	20	for	for	IN
40439	362	21	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	362	22	,	,	,
40439	362	23	when	when	WRB
40439	362	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	362	25	is	be	VBZ
40439	362	26	maintaining	maintain	VBG
40439	362	27	the	the	DT
40439	362	28	earth	earth	NN
40439	362	29	's	's	POS
40439	362	30	immobility	immobility	NN
40439	362	31	,	,	,
40439	362	32	does	do	VBZ
40439	362	33	not	not	RB
40439	362	34	specify	specify	VB
40439	362	35	any	any	DT
40439	362	36	other	other	JJ
40439	362	37	opponents	opponent	NNS
40439	362	38	than	than	IN
40439	362	39	the	the	DT
40439	362	40	Pythagoreians	Pythagoreians	NNPS
40439	362	41	and	and	CC
40439	362	42	the	the	DT
40439	362	43	followers	follower	NNS
40439	362	44	of	of	IN
40439	362	45	the	the	DT
40439	362	46	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	362	47	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	362	48	.	.	.
40439	363	1	And	and	CC
40439	363	2	the	the	DT
40439	363	3	second	second	JJ
40439	363	4	allegation	allegation	NN
40439	363	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	363	6	believe	believe	VBP
40439	363	7	to	to	TO
40439	363	8	be	be	VB
40439	363	9	unfounded	unfounded	JJ
40439	363	10	,	,	,
40439	363	11	speaking	speak	VBG
40439	363	12	with	with	IN
40439	363	13	reference	reference	NN
40439	363	14	to	to	IN
40439	363	15	the	the	DT
40439	363	16	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	363	17	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	363	18	.	.	.
40439	364	1	In	in	IN
40439	364	2	the	the	DT
40439	364	3	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	364	4	system	system	NN
40439	364	5	therein	therein	RB
40439	364	6	embodied	embody	VBD
40439	364	7	,	,	,
40439	364	8	the	the	DT
40439	364	9	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	364	10	of	of	IN
40439	364	11	the	the	DT
40439	364	12	earth	earth	NN
40439	364	13	round	round	IN
40439	364	14	the	the	DT
40439	364	15	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	364	16	axis	axi	NNS
40439	364	17	,	,	,
40439	364	18	though	though	IN
40439	364	19	a	a	DT
40439	364	20	real	real	JJ
40439	364	21	part	part	NN
40439	364	22	of	of	IN
40439	364	23	the	the	DT
40439	364	24	system	system	NN
40439	364	25	,	,	,
40439	364	26	was	be	VBD
40439	364	27	in	in	IN
40439	364	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	364	29	a	a	DT
40439	364	30	fact	fact	NN
40439	364	31	of	of	IN
40439	364	32	no	no	DT
40439	364	33	importance	importance	NN
40439	364	34	,	,	,
40439	364	35	and	and	CC
40439	364	36	determining	determine	VBG
40439	364	37	no	no	DT
40439	364	38	results	result	NNS
40439	364	39	.	.	.
40439	365	1	The	the	DT
40439	365	2	capital	capital	NN
40439	365	3	fact	fact	NN
40439	365	4	of	of	IN
40439	365	5	the	the	DT
40439	365	6	system	system	NN
40439	365	7	was	be	VBD
40439	365	8	the	the	DT
40439	365	9	position	position	NN
40439	365	10	and	and	CC
40439	365	11	function	function	NN
40439	365	12	of	of	IN
40439	365	13	the	the	DT
40439	365	14	earth	earth	NN
40439	365	15	,	,	,
40439	365	16	packed	pack	VBN
40439	365	17	close	close	RB
40439	365	18	round	round	RB
40439	365	19	the	the	DT
40439	365	20	centre	centre	NN
40439	365	21	of	of	IN
40439	365	22	the	the	DT
40439	365	23	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	365	24	axis	axis	NN
40439	365	25	,	,	,
40439	365	26	and	and	CC
40439	365	27	regulating	regulate	VBG
40439	365	28	the	the	DT
40439	365	29	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	365	30	of	of	IN
40439	365	31	that	that	DT
40439	365	32	axis	axis	NN
40439	365	33	.	.	.
40439	366	1	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	366	2	had	have	VBD
40439	366	3	no	no	DT
40439	366	4	motive	motive	NN
40439	366	5	to	to	TO
40439	366	6	bring	bring	VB
40439	366	7	prominently	prominently	RB
40439	366	8	forward	forward	RB
40439	366	9	the	the	DT
40439	366	10	circumstance	circumstance	NN
40439	366	11	that	that	WDT
40439	366	12	the	the	DT
40439	366	13	earth	earth	NN
40439	366	14	revolved	revolve	VBD
40439	366	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	366	16	along	along	RP
40439	366	17	with	with	IN
40439	366	18	the	the	DT
40439	366	19	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	366	20	axis	axi	NNS
40439	366	21	,	,	,
40439	366	22	which	which	WDT
40439	366	23	circumstance	circumstance	NN
40439	366	24	was	be	VBD
40439	366	25	only	only	RB
40439	366	26	an	an	DT
40439	366	27	incidental	incidental	JJ
40439	366	28	accompaniment	accompaniment	NN
40439	366	29	.	.	.
40439	367	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	367	2	have	have	VBP
40439	367	3	thus	thus	RB
40439	367	4	examined	examine	VBN
40439	367	5	all	all	PDT
40439	367	6	the	the	DT
40439	367	7	arguments	argument	NNS
40439	367	8	adduced	adduce	VBN
40439	367	9	by	by	IN
40439	367	10	M.	M.	NNP
40439	367	11	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	367	12	,	,	,
40439	367	13	and	and	CC
40439	367	14	have	have	VBP
40439	367	15	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	367	16	to	to	TO
40439	367	17	show	show	VB
40439	367	18	that	that	IN
40439	367	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	367	20	fail	fail	VBP
40439	367	21	in	in	IN
40439	367	22	establishing	establish	VBG
40439	367	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	367	24	conclusion	conclusion	NN
40439	367	25	.	.	.
40439	368	1	There	there	EX
40439	368	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	368	3	,	,	,
40439	368	4	however	however	RB
40439	368	5	,	,	,
40439	368	6	one	one	CD
40439	368	7	point	point	NN
40439	368	8	of	of	IN
40439	368	9	the	the	DT
40439	368	10	controversy	controversy	NN
40439	368	11	in	in	IN
40439	368	12	which	which	WDT
40439	368	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	368	14	concur	concur	VBP
40439	368	15	with	with	IN
40439	368	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	368	17	more	more	RBR
40439	368	18	than	than	IN
40439	368	19	with	with	IN
40439	368	20	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	368	21	and	and	CC
40439	368	22	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	368	23	.	.	.
40439	369	1	This	this	DT
40439	369	2	point	point	NN
40439	369	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	369	4	the	the	DT
40439	369	5	proper	proper	JJ
40439	369	6	conception	conception	NN
40439	369	7	of	of	IN
40439	369	8	what	what	WP
40439	369	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	369	10	means	mean	VBZ
40439	369	11	by	by	IN
40439	369	12	the	the	DT
40439	369	13	_	_	NNP
40439	369	14	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	369	15	axis	axis	NN
40439	369	16	_	_	NNP
40439	369	17	.	.	.
40439	370	1	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	370	2	and	and	CC
40439	370	3	Martin	Martin	NNP
40439	370	4	seem	seem	VBP
40439	370	5	to	to	TO
40439	370	6	assume	assume	VB
40439	370	7	this	this	DT
40439	370	8	upon	upon	IN
40439	370	9	the	the	DT
40439	370	10	analogy	analogy	NN
40439	370	11	of	of	IN
40439	370	12	what	what	WP
40439	370	13	is	be	VBZ
40439	370	14	now	now	RB
40439	370	15	spoken	speak	VBN
40439	370	16	of	of	IN
40439	370	17	as	as	IN
40439	370	18	the	the	DT
40439	370	19	axis	axi	NNS
40439	370	20	of	of	IN
40439	370	21	the	the	DT
40439	370	22	earth	earth	NN
40439	370	23	:	:	:
40439	370	24	M.	M.	NNP
40439	370	25	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	370	26	(	(	-LRB-
40439	370	27	p.	p.	NN
40439	370	28	13	13	CD
40439	370	29	)	)	-RRB-
40439	370	30	declares	declare	VBZ
40439	370	31	the	the	DT
40439	370	32	axis	axi	NNS
40439	370	33	of	of	IN
40439	370	34	the	the	DT
40439	370	35	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	370	36	to	to	TO
40439	370	37	be	be	VB
40439	370	38	a	a	DT
40439	370	39	prolongation	prolongation	NN
40439	370	40	of	of	IN
40439	370	41	that	that	DT
40439	370	42	axis	axis	NN
40439	370	43	.	.	.
40439	371	1	But	but	CC
40439	371	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	371	3	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	371	4	to	to	IN
40439	371	5	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	371	6	(	(	-LRB-
40439	371	7	and	and	CC
40439	371	8	M.	M.	NNP
40439	371	9	Cousin	Cousin	NNP
40439	371	10	's	's	POS
40439	371	11	language	language	NN
40439	371	12	indicates	indicate	VBZ
40439	371	13	the	the	DT
40439	371	14	same	same	JJ
40439	371	15	)	)	-RRB-
40439	371	16	that	that	IN
40439	371	17	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	371	18	's	's	POS
40439	371	19	conception	conception	NN
40439	371	20	was	be	VBD
40439	371	21	something	something	NN
40439	371	22	very	very	RB
40439	371	23	different	different	JJ
40439	371	24	.	.	.
40439	372	1	The	the	DT
40439	372	2	axis	axi	NNS
40439	372	3	of	of	IN
40439	372	4	the	the	DT
40439	372	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	372	6	(	(	-LRB-
40439	372	7	what	what	WDT
40439	372	8	astronomers	astronomer	NNS
40439	372	9	speak	speak	VBP
40439	372	10	of	of	IN
40439	372	11	as	as	RB
40439	372	12	such	such	JJ
40439	372	13	)	)	-RRB-
40439	372	14	is	be	VBZ
40439	372	15	an	an	DT
40439	372	16	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	372	17	line	line	NN
40439	372	18	traversing	traverse	VBG
40439	372	19	the	the	DT
40439	372	20	centre	centre	NN
40439	372	21	of	of	IN
40439	372	22	the	the	DT
40439	372	23	earth	earth	NN
40439	372	24	;	;	:
40439	372	25	a	a	DT
40439	372	26	line	line	NN
40439	372	27	round	round	NN
40439	372	28	which	which	WDT
40439	372	29	the	the	DT
40439	372	30	earth	earth	NN
40439	372	31	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	372	32	.	.	.
40439	373	1	Now	now	RB
40439	373	2	the	the	DT
40439	373	3	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	373	4	axis	axis	NN
40439	373	5	,	,	,
40439	373	6	as	as	IN
40439	373	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	373	8	conceives	conceive	VBZ
40439	373	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	373	10	,	,	,
40439	373	11	is	be	VBZ
40439	373	12	a	a	DT
40439	373	13	solid	solid	JJ
40439	373	14	material	material	NN
40439	373	15	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	373	16	,	,	,
40439	373	17	which	which	WDT
40439	373	18	not	not	RB
40439	373	19	only	only	RB
40439	373	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	373	21	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	373	22	,	,	,
40439	373	23	but	but	CC
40439	373	24	causes	cause	VBZ
40439	373	25	by	by	IN
40439	373	26	this	this	DT
40439	373	27	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	373	28	the	the	DT
40439	373	29	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	373	30	of	of	IN
40439	373	31	the	the	DT
40439	373	32	exterior	exterior	NNP
40439	373	33	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	373	34	of	of	IN
40439	373	35	the	the	DT
40439	373	36	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	373	37	.	.	.
40439	374	1	This	this	DT
40439	374	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	374	3	a	a	DT
40439	374	4	conception	conception	NN
40439	374	5	entirely	entirely	RB
40439	374	6	different	different	JJ
40439	374	7	from	from	IN
40439	374	8	that	that	DT
40439	374	9	which	which	WDT
40439	374	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	374	11	mean	mean	VBP
40439	374	12	when	when	WRB
40439	374	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	374	14	speak	speak	VBP
40439	374	15	of	of	IN
40439	374	16	the	the	DT
40439	374	17	axis	axi	NNS
40439	374	18	of	of	IN
40439	374	19	the	the	DT
40439	374	20	earth	earth	NN
40439	374	21	.	.	.
40439	375	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	375	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	375	3	,	,	,
40439	375	4	however	however	RB
40439	375	5	,	,	,
40439	375	6	a	a	DT
40439	375	7	conception	conception	NN
40439	375	8	symbolically	symbolically	RB
40439	375	9	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
40439	375	10	in	in	IN
40439	375	11	the	the	DT
40439	375	12	tenth	tenth	JJ
40439	375	13	book	book	NN
40439	375	14	of	of	IN
40439	375	15	the	the	DT
40439	375	16	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	375	17	,	,	,
40439	375	18	where	where	WRB
40439	375	19	the	the	DT
40439	375	20	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	375	21	of	of	IN
40439	375	22	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
40439	375	23	is	be	VBZ
40439	375	24	said	say	VBN
40439	375	25	to	to	TO
40439	375	26	be	be	VB
40439	375	27	composed	compose	VBN
40439	375	28	of	of	IN
40439	375	29	adamant	adamant	JJ
40439	375	30	,	,	,
40439	375	31	hard	hard	JJ
40439	375	32	and	and	CC
40439	375	33	solid	solid	JJ
40439	375	34	material	material	NN
40439	375	35	,	,	,
40439	375	36	and	and	CC
40439	375	37	to	to	TO
40439	375	38	cause	cause	VB
40439	375	39	by	by	IN
40439	375	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	375	41	own	own	JJ
40439	375	42	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	375	43	the	the	DT
40439	375	44	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	375	45	of	of	IN
40439	375	46	all	all	PDT
40439	375	47	the	the	DT
40439	375	48	_	_	NNP
40439	375	49	verticilli	verticilli	NNP
40439	375	50	_	_	NNP
40439	375	51	packed	pack	VBD
40439	375	52	and	and	CC
40439	375	53	fastened	fasten	VBD
40439	375	54	around	around	IN
40439	375	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	375	56	.	.	.
40439	376	1	What	what	WP
40439	376	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	376	3	thus	thus	RB
40439	376	4	enunciated	enunciate	VBN
40439	376	5	in	in	IN
40439	376	6	the	the	DT
40439	376	7	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	376	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	376	9	implied	imply	VBN
40439	376	10	in	in	IN
40439	376	11	the	the	DT
40439	376	12	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	376	13	.	.	.
40439	377	1	For	for	IN
40439	377	2	when	when	WRB
40439	377	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	377	4	read	read	VBP
40439	377	5	therein	therein	RB
40439	377	6	that	that	IN
40439	377	7	the	the	DT
40439	377	8	earth	earth	NN
40439	377	9	is	be	VBZ
40439	377	10	packed	pack	VBN
40439	377	11	or	or	CC
40439	377	12	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	377	13	round	round	IN
40439	377	14	the	the	DT
40439	377	15	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	377	16	axis	axis	NN
40439	377	17	,	,	,
40439	377	18	how	how	WRB
40439	377	19	can	can	MD
40439	377	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	377	21	understand	understand	VB
40439	377	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	377	23	to	to	TO
40439	377	24	be	be	VB
40439	377	25	packed	pack	VBN
40439	377	26	or	or	CC
40439	377	27	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	377	28	round	round	IN
40439	377	29	an	an	DT
40439	377	30	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	377	31	line	line	NN
40439	377	32	?	?	.
40439	378	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	378	2	will	will	MD
40439	378	3	add	add	VB
40439	378	4	that	that	IN
40439	378	5	the	the	DT
40439	378	6	very	very	RB
40439	378	7	same	same	JJ
40439	378	8	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	378	9	is	be	VBZ
40439	378	10	brought	bring	VBN
40439	378	11	out	out	RP
40439	378	12	in	in	IN
40439	378	13	the	the	DT
40439	378	14	translation	translation	NN
40439	378	15	of	of	IN
40439	378	16	Cicero--"_trajecto	Cicero--"_trajecto	NNP
40439	378	17	axe	axe	VBD
40439	378	18	sustinetur	sustinetur	NNP
40439	378	19	_	_	NNP
40439	378	20	"	"	''
40439	378	21	(	(	-LRB-
40439	378	22	terra	terra	NN
40439	378	23	)	)	-RRB-
40439	378	24	.	.	.
40439	379	1	The	the	DT
40439	379	2	axis	axis	JJ
40439	379	3	,	,	,
40439	379	4	round	round	IN
40439	379	5	which	which	WDT
40439	379	6	the	the	DT
40439	379	7	earth	earth	NN
40439	379	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	379	9	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	379	10	,	,	,
40439	379	11	and	and	CC
40439	379	12	which	which	WDT
40439	379	13	sustains	sustain	VBZ
40439	379	14	the	the	DT
40439	379	15	earth	earth	NN
40439	379	16	,	,	,
40439	379	17	must	must	MD
40439	379	18	be	be	VB
40439	379	19	conceived	conceive	VBN
40439	379	20	,	,	,
40439	379	21	not	not	RB
40439	379	22	as	as	IN
40439	379	23	an	an	DT
40439	379	24	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	379	25	line	line	NN
40439	379	26	,	,	,
40439	379	27	but	but	CC
40439	379	28	as	as	IN
40439	379	29	a	a	DT
40439	379	30	solid	solid	JJ
40439	379	31	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	379	32	,	,	,
40439	379	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	379	34	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	379	35	;	;	:
40439	379	36	while	while	IN
40439	379	37	the	the	DT
40439	379	38	earth	earth	NN
40439	379	39	,	,	,
40439	379	40	being	be	VBG
40439	379	41	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	379	42	round	round	IN
40439	379	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	379	44	,	,	,
40439	379	45	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	379	46	round	round	RB
40439	379	47	and	and	CC
40439	379	48	along	along	IN
40439	379	49	with	with	IN
40439	379	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	379	51	.	.	.
40439	380	1	The	the	DT
40439	380	2	axis	axi	NNS
40439	380	3	,	,	,
40439	380	4	in	in	IN
40439	380	5	the	the	DT
40439	380	6	sense	sense	NN
40439	380	7	of	of	IN
40439	380	8	an	an	DT
40439	380	9	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	380	10	line	line	NN
40439	380	11	,	,	,
40439	380	12	can	can	MD
40439	380	13	not	not	RB
40439	380	14	be	be	VB
40439	380	15	found	find	VBN
40439	380	16	in	in	IN
40439	380	17	the	the	DT
40439	380	18	conception	conception	NN
40439	380	19	of	of	IN
40439	380	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	380	21	.	.	.
40439	381	1	Those	those	DT
40439	381	2	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
40439	381	3	of	of	IN
40439	381	4	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	381	5	and	and	CC
40439	381	6	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	381	7	,	,	,
40439	381	8	who	who	WP
40439	381	9	all	all	DT
40439	381	10	agreed	agree	VBD
40439	381	11	in	in	IN
40439	381	12	asserting	assert	VBG
40439	381	13	the	the	DT
40439	381	14	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	381	15	of	of	IN
40439	381	16	the	the	DT
40439	381	17	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	381	18	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	381	19	,	,	,
40439	381	20	did	do	VBD
40439	381	21	not	not	RB
40439	381	22	all	all	DT
40439	381	23	agree	agree	VB
40439	381	24	in	in	IN
40439	381	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	381	26	idea	idea	NN
40439	381	27	of	of	IN
40439	381	28	the	the	DT
40439	381	29	force	force	NN
40439	381	30	whereby	whereby	WRB
40439	381	31	such	such	JJ
40439	381	32	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	381	33	was	be	VBD
40439	381	34	brought	bring	VBN
40439	381	35	about	about	RP
40439	381	36	.	.	.
40439	382	1	Some	some	DT
40439	382	2	thought	think	VBD
40439	382	3	that	that	IN
40439	382	4	the	the	DT
40439	382	5	poles	pole	NNS
40439	382	6	of	of	IN
40439	382	7	the	the	DT
40439	382	8	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	382	9	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	382	10	exercised	exercise	VBD
40439	382	11	a	a	DT
40439	382	12	determining	determine	VBG
40439	382	13	force	force	NN
40439	382	14	:	:	:
40439	382	15	others	other	NNS
40439	382	16	symbolised	symbolise	VBD
40439	382	17	the	the	DT
40439	382	18	mythical	mythical	NN
40439	382	19	Atlas	Atlas	NNP
40439	382	20	,	,	,
40439	382	21	as	as	IN
40439	382	22	an	an	DT
40439	382	23	axis	axis	NN
40439	382	24	traversing	traverse	VBG
40439	382	25	the	the	DT
40439	382	26	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	382	27	from	from	IN
40439	382	28	pole	pole	NN
40439	382	29	to	to	IN
40439	382	30	pole	pole	NN
40439	382	31	and	and	CC
40439	382	32	turning	turn	VBG
40439	382	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	382	34	round	round	RB
40439	382	35	.	.	.
40439	383	1	(	(	-LRB-
40439	383	2	Aristotel	Aristotel	NNP
40439	383	3	.	.	.
40439	384	1	De	De	NNP
40439	384	2	Motu	Motu	NNP
40439	384	3	Animal	Animal	NNP
40439	384	4	.	.	.
40439	385	1	3	3	LS
40439	385	2	.	.	.
40439	385	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	385	4	699	699	CD
40439	385	5	a.	a.	NN
40439	386	1	15	15	CD
40439	386	2	-	-	SYM
40439	386	3	30	30	CD
40439	386	4	.	.	.
40439	386	5	)	)	-RRB-
40439	387	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	387	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	387	3	advocated	advocate	VBD
40439	387	4	the	the	DT
40439	387	5	theory	theory	NN
40439	387	6	of	of	IN
40439	387	7	a	a	DT
40439	387	8	_	_	NNP
40439	387	9	primum	primum	NN
40439	387	10	movens	moven	VBZ
40439	387	11	immobile	immobile	NNP
40439	387	12	_	_	NNP
40439	387	13	acting	act	VBG
40439	387	14	upon	upon	IN
40439	387	15	the	the	DT
40439	387	16	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	387	17	from	from	IN
40439	387	18	without	without	IN
40439	387	19	the	the	DT
40439	387	20	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	387	21	.	.	.
40439	388	1	Even	even	RB
40439	388	2	in	in	IN
40439	388	3	the	the	DT
40439	388	4	succeeding	succeed	VBG
40439	388	5	centuries	century	NNS
40439	388	6	,	,	,
40439	388	7	when	when	WRB
40439	388	8	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	388	9	was	be	VBD
40439	388	10	more	more	RBR
40439	388	11	developed	developed	JJ
40439	388	12	,	,	,
40439	388	13	Aratus	Aratus	NNP
40439	388	14	,	,	,
40439	388	15	Eratosthenes	Eratosthenes	NNP
40439	388	16	,	,	,
40439	388	17	and	and	CC
40439	388	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	388	19	commentators	commentator	NNS
40439	388	20	,	,	,
40439	388	21	differed	differ	VBN
40439	388	22	in	in	IN
40439	388	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	388	24	way	way	NN
40439	388	25	of	of	IN
40439	388	26	conceiving	conceive	VBG
40439	388	27	the	the	DT
40439	388	28	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	388	29	axis	axis	NN
40439	388	30	.	.	.
40439	389	1	Most	Most	JJS
40439	389	2	of	of	IN
40439	389	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	4	considered	consider	VBD
40439	389	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	6	as	as	IN
40439	389	7	solid	solid	JJ
40439	389	8	:	:	:
40439	389	9	but	but	CC
40439	389	10	of	of	IN
40439	389	11	these	these	DT
40439	389	12	,	,	,
40439	389	13	some	some	DT
40439	389	14	thought	thought	NN
40439	389	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	16	was	be	VBD
40439	389	17	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	389	18	,	,	,
40439	389	19	with	with	IN
40439	389	20	the	the	DT
40439	389	21	sphere	sphere	RB
40439	389	22	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	389	23	round	round	IN
40439	389	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	25	--	--	:
40439	389	26	others	other	NNS
40439	389	27	that	that	IN
40439	389	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	29	revolved	revolve	VBD
40439	389	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	31	:	:	:
40439	389	32	again	again	RB
40439	389	33	,	,	,
40439	389	34	among	among	IN
40439	389	35	these	these	DT
40439	389	36	latter	latter	JJ
40439	389	37	,	,	,
40439	389	38	some	some	DT
40439	389	39	believed	believe	VBD
40439	389	40	that	that	IN
40439	389	41	the	the	DT
40439	389	42	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	389	43	of	of	IN
40439	389	44	the	the	DT
40439	389	45	axis	axi	NNS
40439	389	46	determined	determine	VBD
40439	389	47	those	those	DT
40439	389	48	of	of	IN
40439	389	49	the	the	DT
40439	389	50	surrounding	surround	VBG
40439	389	51	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	389	52	--	--	:
40439	389	53	others	other	NNS
40439	389	54	,	,	,
40439	389	55	that	that	IN
40439	389	56	the	the	DT
40439	389	57	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	389	58	of	of	IN
40439	389	59	the	the	DT
40439	389	60	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	389	61	caused	cause	VBD
40439	389	62	those	those	DT
40439	389	63	of	of	IN
40439	389	64	the	the	DT
40439	389	65	axis	axi	NNS
40439	389	66	within	within	IN
40439	389	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	389	68	.	.	.
40439	390	1	Again	again	RB
40439	390	2	,	,	,
40439	390	3	there	there	EX
40439	390	4	were	be	VBD
40439	390	5	some	some	DT
40439	390	6	physical	physical	JJ
40439	390	7	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
40439	390	8	who	who	WP
40439	390	9	looked	look	VBD
40439	390	10	at	at	IN
40439	390	11	the	the	DT
40439	390	12	axis	axis	NN
40439	390	13	as	as	IN
40439	390	14	airy	airy	NNP
40439	390	15	or	or	CC
40439	390	16	spiritual--[Greek	spiritual--[greek	ADD
40439	390	17	:	:	:
40439	390	18	to\	to\	NN
40439	390	19	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	390	20	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	390	21	/	/	SYM
40439	390	22	sou	sou	NNP
40439	390	23	tê	tê	NNP
40439	390	24	=	=	SYM
40439	390	25	s	s	NNP
40439	390	26	sphai	sphai	NNP
40439	390	27	/	/	SYM
40439	390	28	ras	ras	NNP
40439	390	29	diê	diê	NNP
40439	390	30	=	=	SYM
40439	390	31	kon	kon	NNP
40439	390	32	pneu	pneu	NNP
40439	390	33	=	=	SYM
40439	390	34	ma	ma	NNP
40439	390	35	]	]	-RRB-
40439	390	36	.	.	.
40439	391	1	Then	then	RB
40439	391	2	there	there	EX
40439	391	3	were	be	VBD
40439	391	4	geometers	geometer	NNS
40439	391	5	who	who	WP
40439	391	6	conceived	conceive	VBD
40439	391	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	391	8	only	only	RB
40439	391	9	as	as	IN
40439	391	10	an	an	DT
40439	391	11	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	391	12	line	line	NN
40439	391	13	.	.	.
40439	392	1	(	(	-LRB-
40439	392	2	See	see	VB
40439	392	3	the	the	DT
40439	392	4	Phaenomena	Phaenomena	NNP
40439	392	5	of	of	IN
40439	392	6	Aratus	Aratus	NNP
40439	392	7	20	20	CD
40439	392	8	-	-	HYPH
40439	392	9	25	25	CD
40439	392	10	-	-	HYPH
40439	392	11	-with	-with	NN
40439	392	12	the	the	DT
40439	392	13	Scholia	Scholia	NNP
40439	392	14	thereon	thereon	NN
40439	392	15	;	;	:
40439	392	16	Achilles	Achilles	NNP
40439	392	17	Tatius	Tatius	NNP
40439	392	18	ad	ad	NN
40439	392	19	Arati	Arati	NNP
40439	392	20	Phaenom	Phaenom	NNP
40439	392	21	.	.	.
40439	393	1	apud	apud	NNP
40439	393	2	Petavium	Petavium	NNP
40439	393	3	--	--	:
40439	393	4	Uranolog	Uranolog	NNP
40439	393	5	.	.	.
40439	394	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	394	2	88	88	CD
40439	394	3	;	;	:
40439	394	4	also	also	RB
40439	394	5	Hipparchus	Hipparchus	NNP
40439	394	6	ad	ad	NN
40439	394	7	Arat	Arat	NNP
40439	394	8	.	.	.
40439	395	1	ib	ib	IN
40439	395	2	.	.	.
40439	396	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	397	1	144	144	CD
40439	397	2	.	.	.
40439	397	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	398	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	398	2	do	do	VBP
40439	398	3	not	not	RB
40439	398	4	go	go	VB
40439	398	5	into	into	IN
40439	398	6	these	these	DT
40439	398	7	dissentient	dissentient	JJ
40439	398	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	398	9	farther	farther	RB
40439	398	10	than	than	IN
40439	398	11	to	to	TO
40439	398	12	show	show	VB
40439	398	13	,	,	,
40439	398	14	how	how	WRB
40439	398	15	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
40439	398	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	398	17	is	be	VBZ
40439	398	18	,	,	,
40439	398	19	when	when	WRB
40439	398	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	398	21	construe	construe	VBP
40439	398	22	the	the	DT
40439	398	23	passage	passage	NN
40439	398	24	in	in	IN
40439	398	25	the	the	DT
40439	398	26	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	398	27	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	398	28	,	,	,
40439	398	29	[	[	-LRB-
40439	398	30	Greek	greek	NN
40439	398	31	:	:	:
40439	398	32	peri\	peri\	NN
40439	398	33	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	398	34	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	398	35	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	398	36	po	po	NNP
40439	398	37	/	/	SYM
40439	398	38	lon	lon	NNP
40439	398	39	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	398	40	/	/	SYM
40439	398	41	non	non	AFX
40439	398	42	]	]	-RRB-
40439	398	43	,	,	,
40439	398	44	to	to	TO
40439	398	45	enquire	enquire	VB
40439	398	46	in	in	IN
40439	398	47	what	what	WDT
40439	398	48	sense	sense	NN
40439	398	49	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	398	50	understood	understand	VBD
40439	398	51	the	the	DT
40439	398	52	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	398	53	axis	axis	NN
40439	398	54	:	:	:
40439	398	55	and	and	CC
40439	398	56	how	how	WRB
40439	398	57	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
40439	398	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	398	59	is	be	VBZ
40439	398	60	to	to	TO
40439	398	61	assume	assume	VB
40439	398	62	at	at	IN
40439	398	63	once	once	RB
40439	398	64	that	that	IN
40439	398	65	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	398	66	must	must	MD
40439	398	67	have	have	VB
40439	398	68	conceived	conceive	VBN
40439	398	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	398	70	as	as	IN
40439	398	71	an	an	DT
40439	398	72	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	398	73	line	line	NN
40439	398	74	.	.	.
40439	399	1	Proklus	proklus	NN
40439	399	2	argues	argue	VBZ
40439	399	3	that	that	IN
40439	399	4	because	because	IN
40439	399	5	the	the	DT
40439	399	6	earth	earth	NN
40439	399	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	399	8	mentioned	mention	VBN
40439	399	9	by	by	IN
40439	399	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	399	11	in	in	IN
40439	399	12	the	the	DT
40439	399	13	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	399	14	as	as	IN
40439	399	15	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	399	16	in	in	IN
40439	399	17	the	the	DT
40439	399	18	centre	centre	NN
40439	399	19	of	of	IN
40439	399	20	the	the	DT
40439	399	21	heaven	heaven	NNP
40439	399	22	,	,	,
40439	399	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	399	24	can	can	MD
40439	399	25	not	not	RB
40439	399	26	imagine	imagine	VB
40439	399	27	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	399	28	to	to	TO
40439	399	29	affirm	affirm	VB
40439	399	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	399	31	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	399	32	in	in	IN
40439	399	33	the	the	DT
40439	399	34	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	399	35	.	.	.
40439	400	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	400	2	agree	agree	VBP
40439	400	3	with	with	IN
40439	400	4	M.	M.	NNP
40439	400	5	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	400	6	in	in	IN
40439	400	7	thinking	think	VBG
40439	400	8	this	this	DT
40439	400	9	argument	argument	NN
40439	400	10	inconclusive	inconclusive	JJ
40439	400	11	;	;	:
40439	400	12	all	all	PDT
40439	400	13	the	the	DT
40439	400	14	more	more	RBR
40439	400	15	,	,	,
40439	400	16	because	because	IN
40439	400	17	,	,	,
40439	400	18	in	in	IN
40439	400	19	the	the	DT
40439	400	20	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	400	21	,	,	,
40439	400	22	not	not	RB
40439	400	23	a	a	DT
40439	400	24	word	word	NN
40439	400	25	is	be	VBZ
40439	400	26	said	say	VBN
40439	400	27	either	either	CC
40439	400	28	about	about	IN
40439	400	29	the	the	DT
40439	400	30	axis	axi	NNS
40439	400	31	of	of	IN
40439	400	32	the	the	DT
40439	400	33	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	400	34	,	,	,
40439	400	35	or	or	CC
40439	400	36	about	about	IN
40439	400	37	the	the	DT
40439	400	38	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	400	39	of	of	IN
40439	400	40	the	the	DT
40439	400	41	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	400	42	;	;	:
40439	400	43	all	all	DT
40439	400	44	that	that	WDT
40439	400	45	Sokrates	Sokrates	NNP
40439	400	46	professes	profess	VBZ
40439	400	47	to	to	TO
40439	400	48	give	give	VB
40439	400	49	is	be	VBZ
40439	400	50	[	[	-LRB-
40439	400	51	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	400	52	:	:	:
40439	400	53	tê\n	tê\n	VB
40439	400	54	i)de	i)de	NNP
40439	400	55	/	/	,
40439	400	56	an	an	DT
40439	400	57	tê	tê	NNP
40439	400	58	=	=	SYM
40439	400	59	s	s	NNP
40439	400	60	gê	gê	NNP
40439	400	61	=	=	NNP
40439	400	62	s	s	NNP
40439	400	63	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	400	64	tou\s	tou\s	NNP
40439	400	65	to	to	IN
40439	400	66	/	/	SYM
40439	400	67	pous	pous	JJ
40439	400	68	au)tê	au)tê	NN
40439	400	69	=	=	SYM
40439	400	70	s	s	NN
40439	400	71	*	*	NFP
40439	400	72	*	*	NFP
40439	400	73	]	]	-RRB-
40439	400	74	(	(	-LRB-
40439	400	75	p.	p.	NN
40439	400	76	108	108	CD
40439	400	77	E	e	NN
40439	400	78	)	)	-RRB-
40439	400	79	.	.	.
40439	401	1	No	no	DT
40439	401	2	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	401	3	system	system	NN
40439	401	4	or	or	CC
40439	401	5	theory	theory	NN
40439	401	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	401	7	propounded	propound	VBN
40439	401	8	in	in	IN
40439	401	9	that	that	DT
40439	401	10	dialogue	dialogue	NN
40439	401	11	.	.	.
40439	402	1	When	when	WRB
40439	402	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	402	3	turn	turn	VBP
40439	402	4	to	to	IN
40439	402	5	the	the	DT
40439	402	6	Phædrus	Phædrus	NNP
40439	402	7	,	,	,
40439	402	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	402	9	find	find	VBP
40439	402	10	that	that	IN
40439	402	11	,	,	,
40439	402	12	in	in	IN
40439	402	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	402	14	highly	highly	RB
40439	402	15	poetical	poetical	JJ
40439	402	16	description	description	NN
40439	402	17	,	,	,
40439	402	18	the	the	DT
40439	402	19	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	402	20	of	of	IN
40439	402	21	the	the	DT
40439	402	22	heaven	heaven	NNP
40439	402	23	occupies	occupy	VBZ
40439	402	24	a	a	DT
40439	402	25	prominent	prominent	JJ
40439	402	26	place	place	NN
40439	402	27	.	.	.
40439	403	1	The	the	DT
40439	403	2	internal	internal	JJ
40439	403	3	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	403	4	of	of	IN
40439	403	5	the	the	DT
40439	403	6	heavenly	heavenly	JJ
40439	403	7	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	403	8	,	,	,
40439	403	9	as	as	RB
40439	403	10	well	well	RB
40439	403	11	as	as	IN
40439	403	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	403	13	external	external	JJ
40439	403	14	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	403	15	or	or	CC
40439	403	16	back	back	NN
40439	403	17	(	(	-LRB-
40439	403	18	[	[	-LRB-
40439	403	19	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	403	20	:	:	:
40439	403	21	nô	nô	NNP
40439	403	22	=	=	SYM
40439	403	23	ton	ton	NN
40439	403	24	]	]	-RRB-
40439	403	25	)	)	-RRB-
40439	403	26	,	,	,
40439	403	27	are	be	VBP
40439	403	28	mentioned	mention	VBN
40439	403	29	;	;	:
40439	403	30	also	also	RB
40439	403	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	403	32	periodical	periodical	JJ
40439	403	33	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	403	34	,	,	,
40439	403	35	during	during	IN
40439	403	36	which	which	WDT
40439	403	37	the	the	DT
40439	403	38	gods	god	NNS
40439	403	39	are	be	VBP
40439	403	40	carried	carry	VBN
40439	403	41	round	round	RB
40439	403	42	on	on	IN
40439	403	43	the	the	DT
40439	403	44	back	back	NN
40439	403	45	of	of	IN
40439	403	46	the	the	DT
40439	403	47	heaven	heaven	NNP
40439	403	48	,	,	,
40439	403	49	and	and	CC
40439	403	50	contemplate	contemplate	VB
40439	403	51	the	the	DT
40439	403	52	eternal	eternal	JJ
40439	403	53	Ideas	Ideas	NNPS
40439	403	54	occupying	occupy	VBG
40439	403	55	the	the	DT
40439	403	56	super	super	JJ
40439	403	57	-	-	JJ
40439	403	58	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	403	59	space	space	NN
40439	403	60	(	(	-LRB-
40439	403	61	p.	p.	NN
40439	403	62	247	247	CD
40439	403	63	,	,	,
40439	403	64	248	248	CD
40439	403	65	)	)	-RRB-
40439	403	66	,	,	,
40439	403	67	or	or	CC
40439	403	68	the	the	DT
40439	403	69	plain	plain	NN
40439	403	70	of	of	IN
40439	403	71	truth	truth	NN
40439	403	72	.	.	.
40439	404	1	[	[	-LRB-
40439	404	2	5	5	CD
40439	404	3	]	]	-RRB-
40439	404	4	But	but	CC
40439	404	5	the	the	DT
40439	404	6	purpose	purpose	NN
40439	404	7	of	of	IN
40439	404	8	this	this	DT
40439	404	9	poetical	poetical	JJ
40439	404	10	representation	representation	NN
40439	404	11	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	404	12	to	to	TO
40439	404	13	be	be	VB
40439	404	14	metaphysical	metaphysical	JJ
40439	404	15	and	and	CC
40439	404	16	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
40439	404	17	,	,	,
40439	404	18	to	to	TO
40439	404	19	illustrate	illustrate	VB
40439	404	20	the	the	DT
40439	404	21	antithesis	antithesis	NN
40439	404	22	presented	present	VBN
40439	404	23	by	by	IN
40439	404	24	the	the	DT
40439	404	25	world	world	NN
40439	404	26	of	of	IN
40439	404	27	Ideas	Ideas	NNP
40439	404	28	and	and	CC
40439	404	29	Truth	Truth	NNP
40439	404	30	on	on	IN
40439	404	31	one	one	CD
40439	404	32	side	side	NN
40439	404	33	--	--	:
40439	404	34	against	against	IN
40439	404	35	that	that	DT
40439	404	36	of	of	IN
40439	404	37	sense	sense	NN
40439	404	38	and	and	CC
40439	404	39	appearances	appearance	NNS
40439	404	40	on	on	IN
40439	404	41	the	the	DT
40439	404	42	other	other	JJ
40439	404	43	.	.	.
40439	405	1	Astronomically	astronomically	RB
40439	405	2	and	and	CC
40439	405	3	cosmically	cosmically	RB
40439	405	4	considered	consider	VBN
40439	405	5	,	,	,
40439	405	6	no	no	DT
40439	405	7	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
40439	405	8	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	405	9	is	be	VBZ
40439	405	10	conveyed	convey	VBN
40439	405	11	.	.	.
40439	406	1	Nor	nor	CC
40439	406	2	can	can	MD
40439	406	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	406	4	even	even	RB
40439	406	5	determine	determine	VB
40439	406	6	whether	whether	IN
40439	406	7	the	the	DT
40439	406	8	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	406	9	of	of	IN
40439	406	10	the	the	DT
40439	406	11	heaven	heaven	NNP
40439	406	12	,	,	,
40439	406	13	alluded	allude	VBD
40439	406	14	to	to	IN
40439	406	15	in	in	IN
40439	406	16	the	the	DT
40439	406	17	Phædrus	Phædrus	NNP
40439	406	18	,	,	,
40439	406	19	are	be	VBP
40439	406	20	intended	intend	VBN
40439	406	21	to	to	TO
40439	406	22	be	be	VB
40439	406	23	diurnal	diurnal	JJ
40439	406	24	or	or	CC
40439	406	25	not	not	RB
40439	406	26	;	;	:
40439	406	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	406	28	incline	incline	VBP
40439	406	29	to	to	TO
40439	406	30	believe	believe	VB
40439	406	31	not	not	RB
40439	406	32	(	(	-LRB-
40439	406	33	[	[	-LRB-
40439	406	34	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	406	35	:	:	:
40439	406	36	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	406	37	/	/	SYM
40439	406	38	chri	chri	NNP
40439	406	39	tê	tê	NNP
40439	406	40	=	=	SYM
40439	406	41	s	s	NNP
40439	406	42	_	_	NNP
40439	406	43	e(te	e(te	NNP
40439	406	44	/	/	SYM
40439	406	45	ras	ras	NNP
40439	406	46	_	_	NNP
40439	406	47	perio	perio	NNP
40439	406	48	/	/	SYM
40439	406	49	dou]--p	dou]--p	NNP
40439	406	50	.	.	.
40439	406	51	248	248	CD
40439	406	52	-	-	SYM
40439	406	53	-which	-which	NN
40439	406	54	can	can	MD
40439	406	55	hardly	hardly	RB
40439	406	56	be	be	VB
40439	406	57	understood	understand	VBN
40439	406	58	of	of	IN
40439	406	59	so	so	RB
40439	406	60	short	short	JJ
40439	406	61	a	a	DT
40439	406	62	time	time	NN
40439	406	63	as	as	IN
40439	406	64	one	one	CD
40439	406	65	day	day	NN
40439	406	66	)	)	-RRB-
40439	406	67	.	.	.
40439	407	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
40439	407	2	,	,	,
40439	407	3	nothing	nothing	NN
40439	407	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	407	5	said	say	VBN
40439	407	6	in	in	IN
40439	407	7	the	the	DT
40439	407	8	Phædrus	Phædrus	NNP
40439	407	9	about	about	IN
40439	407	10	the	the	DT
40439	407	11	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	407	12	axis	axi	NNS
40439	407	13	;	;	:
40439	407	14	and	and	CC
40439	407	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	407	16	is	be	VBZ
40439	407	17	upon	upon	IN
40439	407	18	this	this	DT
40439	407	19	that	that	IN
40439	407	20	the	the	DT
40439	407	21	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	407	22	of	of	IN
40439	407	23	the	the	DT
40439	407	24	earth	earth	NN
40439	407	25	intimated	intimate	VBN
40439	407	26	in	in	IN
40439	407	27	the	the	DT
40439	407	28	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	407	29	depend	depend	VBP
40439	407	30	.	.	.
40439	408	1	[	[	-LRB-
40439	408	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
40439	408	3	5	5	CD
40439	408	4	:	:	:
40439	408	5	Whether	whether	IN
40439	408	6	[	[	-LRB-
40439	408	7	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	408	8	:	:	:
40439	408	9	E)sti	e)sti	NN
40439	408	10	/	/	SYM
40439	408	11	a	a	NN
40439	408	12	]	]	-RRB-
40439	408	13	in	in	IN
40439	408	14	the	the	DT
40439	408	15	Phædrus	Phædrus	NNP
40439	408	16	,	,	,
40439	408	17	which	which	WDT
40439	408	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	408	19	said	say	VBN
40439	408	20	"	"	``
40439	408	21	to	to	TO
40439	408	22	remain	remain	VB
40439	408	23	alone	alone	RB
40439	408	24	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	408	25	in	in	IN
40439	408	26	the	the	DT
40439	408	27	house	house	NN
40439	408	28	of	of	IN
40439	408	29	the	the	DT
40439	408	30	Gods	Gods	NNPS
40439	408	31	,	,	,
40439	408	32	"	"	''
40439	408	33	can	can	MD
40439	408	34	be	be	VB
40439	408	35	held	hold	VBN
40439	408	36	to	to	TO
40439	408	37	mean	mean	VB
40439	408	38	the	the	DT
40439	408	39	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	408	40	,	,	,
40439	408	41	is	be	VBZ
40439	408	42	considered	consider	VBN
40439	408	43	by	by	IN
40439	408	44	Proklus	proklus	NN
40439	408	45	to	to	TO
40439	408	46	be	be	VB
40439	408	47	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
40439	408	48	(	(	-LRB-
40439	408	49	p.	p.	NN
40439	409	1	681	681	CD
40439	409	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	409	3	.	.	.
40439	409	4	]	]	-RRB-
40439	410	1	Among	among	IN
40439	410	2	the	the	DT
40439	410	3	different	different	JJ
40439	410	4	illustrations	illustration	NNS
40439	410	5	,	,	,
40439	410	6	given	give	VBN
40439	410	7	by	by	IN
40439	410	8	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	410	9	in	in	IN
40439	410	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	410	11	different	different	JJ
40439	410	12	dialogues	dialogue	NNS
40439	410	13	respecting	respect	VBG
40439	410	14	the	the	DT
40439	410	15	terrestrial	terrestrial	JJ
40439	410	16	and	and	CC
40439	410	17	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	410	18	bodies	body	NNS
40439	410	19	,	,	,
40439	410	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	410	21	select	select	VBP
40439	410	22	the	the	DT
40439	410	23	tenth	tenth	JJ
40439	410	24	book	book	NN
40439	410	25	of	of	IN
40439	410	26	the	the	DT
40439	410	27	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	410	28	as	as	IN
40439	410	29	that	that	DT
40439	410	30	which	which	WDT
40439	410	31	is	be	VBZ
40439	410	32	most	most	RBS
40439	410	33	suitable	suitable	JJ
40439	410	34	for	for	IN
40439	410	35	comparison	comparison	NN
40439	410	36	with	with	IN
40439	410	37	the	the	DT
40439	410	38	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	410	39	,	,	,
40439	410	40	because	because	IN
40439	410	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	410	42	is	be	VBZ
40439	410	43	only	only	RB
40439	410	44	therein	therein	RB
40439	410	45	that	that	IN
40439	410	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	410	47	learn	learn	VBP
40439	410	48	how	how	WRB
40439	410	49	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	410	50	conceived	conceive	VBD
40439	410	51	the	the	DT
40439	410	52	axis	axi	NNS
40439	410	53	of	of	IN
40439	410	54	the	the	DT
40439	410	55	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	410	56	.	.	.
40439	411	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	411	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	411	3	(	(	-LRB-
40439	411	4	Untersuchungen	Untersuchungen	NNP
40439	411	5	,	,	,
40439	411	6	p.	p.	NN
40439	411	7	86	86	CD
40439	411	8	)	)	-RRB-
40439	411	9	wishes	wish	VBZ
40439	411	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	411	11	to	to	TO
40439	411	12	regard	regard	VB
40439	411	13	the	the	DT
40439	411	14	difference	difference	NN
40439	411	15	between	between	IN
40439	411	16	the	the	DT
40439	411	17	view	view	NN
40439	411	18	taken	take	VBN
40439	411	19	in	in	IN
40439	411	20	the	the	DT
40439	411	21	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	411	22	,	,	,
40439	411	23	and	and	CC
40439	411	24	that	that	IN
40439	411	25	in	in	IN
40439	411	26	the	the	DT
40439	411	27	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	411	28	,	,	,
40439	411	29	as	as	IN
40439	411	30	no	no	DT
40439	411	31	way	way	NN
40439	411	32	important	important	JJ
40439	411	33	;	;	:
40439	411	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	411	35	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	411	36	that	that	IN
40439	411	37	the	the	DT
40439	411	38	adamantine	adamantine	NN
40439	411	39	spindle	spindle	NN
40439	411	40	in	in	IN
40439	411	41	the	the	DT
40439	411	42	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	411	43	is	be	VBZ
40439	411	44	altogether	altogether	RB
40439	411	45	mythical	mythical	JJ
40439	411	46	or	or	CC
40439	411	47	poetical	poetical	JJ
40439	411	48	,	,	,
40439	411	49	and	and	CC
40439	411	50	that	that	IN
40439	411	51	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	411	52	conceives	conceive	VBZ
40439	411	53	the	the	DT
40439	411	54	axis	axi	NNS
40439	411	55	as	as	IN
40439	411	56	not	not	RB
40439	411	57	being	be	VBG
40439	411	58	material	material	NN
40439	411	59	.	.	.
40439	412	1	On	on	IN
40439	412	2	this	this	DT
40439	412	3	point	point	NN
40439	412	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	412	5	dissent	dissent	NN
40439	412	6	from	from	IN
40439	412	7	M.	M.	NNP
40439	412	8	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	412	9	.	.	.
40439	413	1	The	the	DT
40439	413	2	mythical	mythical	JJ
40439	413	3	illustrations	illustration	NNS
40439	413	4	in	in	IN
40439	413	5	the	the	DT
40439	413	6	tenth	tenth	JJ
40439	413	7	book	book	NN
40439	413	8	of	of	IN
40439	413	9	the	the	DT
40439	413	10	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	413	11	appear	appear	VBP
40439	413	12	to	to	IN
40439	413	13	me	-PRON-	PRP
40439	413	14	quite	quite	RB
40439	413	15	unsuitable	unsuitable	JJ
40439	413	16	to	to	IN
40439	413	17	the	the	DT
40439	413	18	theory	theory	NN
40439	413	19	of	of	IN
40439	413	20	an	an	DT
40439	413	21	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	413	22	,	,	,
40439	413	23	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	413	24	,	,	,
40439	413	25	and	and	CC
40439	413	26	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
40439	413	27	axis	axi	NNS
40439	413	28	.	.	.
40439	414	1	Here	here	RB
40439	414	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	414	3	much	much	RB
40439	414	4	more	more	JJR
40439	414	5	agree	agree	VBP
40439	414	6	with	with	IN
40439	414	7	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	414	8	(	(	-LRB-
40439	414	9	p.	p.	NN
40439	414	10	15	15	CD
40439	414	11	,	,	,
40439	414	12	26	26	CD
40439	414	13	-	-	SYM
40439	414	14	29	29	CD
40439	414	15	)	)	-RRB-
40439	414	16	,	,	,
40439	414	17	who	who	WP
40439	414	18	recognises	recognise	VBZ
40439	414	19	the	the	DT
40439	414	20	solid	solid	JJ
40439	414	21	material	material	NN
40439	414	22	axis	axi	NNS
40439	414	23	as	as	IN
40439	414	24	an	an	DT
40439	414	25	essential	essential	JJ
40439	414	26	feature	feature	NN
40439	414	27	of	of	IN
40439	414	28	the	the	DT
40439	414	29	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	414	30	theory	theory	NN
40439	414	31	in	in	IN
40439	414	32	the	the	DT
40439	414	33	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	414	34	;	;	:
40439	414	35	and	and	CC
40439	414	36	recognises	recognise	VBZ
40439	414	37	also	also	RB
40439	414	38	the	the	DT
40439	414	39	marked	mark	VBN
40439	414	40	difference	difference	NN
40439	414	41	between	between	IN
40439	414	42	that	that	DT
40439	414	43	theory	theory	NN
40439	414	44	and	and	CC
40439	414	45	what	what	WP
40439	414	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	414	47	read	read	VBP
40439	414	48	in	in	IN
40439	414	49	the	the	DT
40439	414	50	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	414	51	.	.	.
40439	415	1	Yet	yet	RB
40439	415	2	,	,	,
40439	415	3	though	though	IN
40439	415	4	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	415	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	415	6	aware	aware	JJ
40439	415	7	of	of	IN
40439	415	8	this	this	DT
40439	415	9	important	important	JJ
40439	415	10	difference	difference	NN
40439	415	11	between	between	IN
40439	415	12	the	the	DT
40439	415	13	Republic	Republic	NNP
40439	415	14	and	and	CC
40439	415	15	the	the	DT
40439	415	16	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	415	17	,	,	,
40439	415	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	415	19	still	still	RB
40439	415	20	wishes	wish	VBZ
40439	415	21	to	to	TO
40439	415	22	illustrate	illustrate	VB
40439	415	23	the	the	DT
40439	415	24	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	415	25	by	by	IN
40439	415	26	the	the	DT
40439	415	27	latter	latter	JJ
40439	415	28	and	and	CC
40439	415	29	not	not	RB
40439	415	30	by	by	IN
40439	415	31	the	the	DT
40439	415	32	former	former	JJ
40439	415	33	.	.	.
40439	416	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	416	2	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	416	3	that	that	IN
40439	416	4	the	the	DT
40439	416	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	416	6	in	in	IN
40439	416	7	the	the	DT
40439	416	8	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	416	9	is	be	VBZ
40439	416	10	conceived	conceive	VBN
40439	416	11	as	as	IN
40439	416	12	unattached	unattache	VBN
40439	416	13	,	,	,
40439	416	14	and	and	CC
40439	416	15	freely	freely	RB
40439	416	16	suspended	suspend	VBN
40439	416	17	,	,	,
40439	416	18	the	the	DT
40439	416	19	same	same	JJ
40439	416	20	as	as	IN
40439	416	21	in	in	IN
40439	416	22	the	the	DT
40439	416	23	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	416	24	;	;	:
40439	416	25	but	but	CC
40439	416	26	that	that	IN
40439	416	27	in	in	IN
40439	416	28	the	the	DT
40439	416	29	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	416	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	416	31	is	be	VBZ
40439	416	32	conceived	conceive	VBN
40439	416	33	,	,	,
40439	416	34	besides	besides	RB
40439	416	35	,	,	,
40439	416	36	as	as	IN
40439	416	37	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	416	38	on	on	IN
40439	416	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	416	40	own	own	JJ
40439	416	41	axis	axi	NNS
40439	416	42	,	,	,
40439	416	43	which	which	WDT
40439	416	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	416	45	do	do	VBP
40439	416	46	not	not	RB
40439	416	47	find	find	VB
40439	416	48	in	in	IN
40439	416	49	the	the	DT
40439	416	50	Phædon	Phædon	NNP
40439	416	51	(	(	-LRB-
40439	416	52	p.	p.	NN
40439	416	53	28	28	CD
40439	416	54	,	,	,
40439	416	55	29	29	CD
40439	416	56	)	)	-RRB-
40439	416	57	.	.	.
40439	417	1	Here	here	RB
40439	417	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	417	3	think	think	VBP
40439	417	4	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	417	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	417	6	mistaken	mistaken	JJ
40439	417	7	.	.	.
40439	418	1	In	in	IN
40439	418	2	construing	construe	VBG
40439	418	3	the	the	DT
40439	418	4	words	word	NNS
40439	418	5	of	of	IN
40439	418	6	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	418	7	,	,	,
40439	418	8	[	[	-LRB-
40439	418	9	Greek	greek	JJ
40439	418	10	:	:	:
40439	418	11	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	418	12	/	/	SYM
40439	418	13	nên	nên	NN
40439	418	14	(	(	-LRB-
40439	418	15	i)llome	i)llome	NNP
40439	418	16	/	/	SYM
40439	418	17	nên	nên	NN
40439	418	18	)	)	-RRB-
40439	418	19	peri\	peri\	NN
40439	418	20	to\n	to\n	NNP
40439	418	21	dia\	dia\	NNP
40439	418	22	panto\s	panto\s	CC
40439	418	23	po	po	NNP
40439	418	24	/	/	SYM
40439	418	25	lon	lon	NNP
40439	418	26	tetame	tetame	NNP
40439	418	27	/	/	SYM
40439	418	28	non	non	AFX
40439	418	29	]	]	-RRB-
40439	418	30	,	,	,
40439	418	31	as	as	IN
40439	418	32	designating	designate	VBG
40439	418	33	"	"	``
40439	418	34	the	the	DT
40439	418	35	unattached	unattached	JJ
40439	418	36	earth	earth	NN
40439	418	37	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	418	38	round	round	IN
40439	418	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	418	40	own	own	JJ
40439	418	41	axis	axis	NN
40439	418	42	,	,	,
40439	418	43	"	"	''
40439	418	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	418	45	does	do	VBZ
40439	418	46	violence	violence	NN
40439	418	47	not	not	RB
40439	418	48	less	less	JJR
40439	418	49	to	to	IN
40439	418	50	the	the	DT
40439	418	51	text	text	NN
40439	418	52	of	of	IN
40439	418	53	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	418	54	than	than	IN
40439	418	55	to	to	IN
40439	418	56	the	the	DT
40439	418	57	expository	expository	JJ
40439	418	58	comment	comment	NN
40439	418	59	of	of	IN
40439	418	60	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	418	61	.	.	.
40439	419	1	Neither	neither	CC
40439	419	2	in	in	IN
40439	419	3	the	the	DT
40439	419	4	one	one	NN
40439	419	5	nor	nor	CC
40439	419	6	the	the	DT
40439	419	7	other	other	JJ
40439	419	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	419	9	anything	anything	NN
40439	419	10	said	say	VBD
40439	419	11	about	about	IN
40439	419	12	_	_	NNP
40439	419	13	an	an	DT
40439	419	14	axis	axis	NN
40439	419	15	of	of	IN
40439	419	16	the	the	DT
40439	419	17	earth	earth	NN
40439	419	18	_	_	NNP
40439	419	19	;	;	:
40439	419	20	in	in	IN
40439	419	21	both	both	DT
40439	419	22	,	,	,
40439	419	23	the	the	DT
40439	419	24	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	419	25	axis	axi	NNS
40439	419	26	is	be	VBZ
40439	419	27	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	419	28	designated	designate	VBN
40439	419	29	;	;	:
40439	419	30	and	and	CC
40439	419	31	,	,	,
40439	419	32	if	if	IN
40439	419	33	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	419	34	is	be	VBZ
40439	419	35	right	right	JJ
40439	419	36	in	in	IN
40439	419	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	419	38	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	419	39	of	of	IN
40439	419	40	[	[	-LRB-
40439	419	41	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	419	42	:	:	:
40439	419	43	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	419	44	/	/	SYM
40439	419	45	nên	nên	NN
40439	419	46	]	]	-RRB-
40439	419	47	,	,	,
40439	419	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	419	49	must	must	MD
40439	419	50	take	take	VB
40439	419	51	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	419	52	as	as	IN
40439	419	53	affirming	affirming	NN
40439	419	54	,	,	,
40439	419	55	not	not	RB
40439	419	56	that	that	IN
40439	419	57	the	the	DT
40439	419	58	earth	earth	NN
40439	419	59	is	be	VBZ
40439	419	60	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	419	61	round	round	IN
40439	419	62	the	the	DT
40439	419	63	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	419	64	axis	axis	NN
40439	419	65	,	,	,
40439	419	66	but	but	CC
40439	419	67	that	that	IN
40439	419	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	419	69	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	419	70	,	,	,
40439	419	71	though	though	IN
40439	419	72	unattached	unattache	VBN
40439	419	73	,	,	,
40439	419	74	around	around	IN
40439	419	75	that	that	DT
40439	419	76	axis	axis	NNP
40439	419	77	,	,	,
40439	419	78	which	which	WDT
40439	419	79	is	be	VBZ
40439	419	80	a	a	DT
40439	419	81	proposition	proposition	NN
40439	419	82	both	both	DT
40439	419	83	difficult	difficult	JJ
40439	419	84	to	to	TO
40439	419	85	understand	understand	VB
40439	419	86	,	,	,
40439	419	87	and	and	CC
40439	419	88	leading	lead	VBG
40439	419	89	to	to	IN
40439	419	90	none	none	NN
40439	419	91	of	of	IN
40439	419	92	those	those	DT
40439	419	93	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	419	94	consequences	consequence	NNS
40439	419	95	with	with	IN
40439	419	96	which	which	WDT
40439	419	97	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	419	98	would	would	MD
40439	419	99	connect	connect	VB
40439	419	100	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	419	101	.	.	.
40439	420	1	Again	again	RB
40439	420	2	,	,	,
40439	420	3	when	when	WRB
40439	420	4	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	420	5	says	say	VBZ
40439	420	6	that	that	IN
40439	420	7	[	[	-LRB-
40439	420	8	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	420	9	:	:	:
40439	420	10	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	420	11	/	/	SYM
40439	420	12	nên	nên	NN
40439	420	13	peri\	peri\	NNP
40439	420	14	]	]	-RRB-
40439	420	15	does	do	VBZ
40439	420	16	_	_	NNP
40439	420	17	not	not	RB
40439	420	18	_	_	NNP
40439	420	19	mean	mean	NN
40439	420	20	_	_	NNP
40439	420	21	packed	pack	VBD
40439	420	22	or	or	CC
40439	420	23	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	420	24	round	round	NN
40439	420	25	_	_	NNP
40439	420	26	,	,	,
40439	420	27	but	but	CC
40439	420	28	that	that	IN
40439	420	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	420	30	_	_	NNP
40439	420	31	does	do	VBZ
40439	420	32	_	_	NNP
40439	420	33	mean	mean	VB
40439	420	34	_	_	NNP
40439	420	35	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	420	36	round	round	NN
40439	420	37	_	_	NNP
40439	420	38	,	,	,
40439	420	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	420	40	has	have	VBZ
40439	420	41	both	both	CC
40439	420	42	the	the	DT
40439	420	43	analogies	analogy	NNS
40439	420	44	of	of	IN
40439	420	45	the	the	DT
40439	420	46	word	word	NN
40439	420	47	and	and	CC
40439	420	48	the	the	DT
40439	420	49	other	other	JJ
40439	420	50	commentators	commentator	NNS
40439	420	51	against	against	IN
40439	420	52	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	420	53	.	.	.
40439	421	1	The	the	DT
40439	421	2	main	main	JJ
40439	421	3	proof	proof	NN
40439	421	4	,	,	,
40439	421	5	if	if	IN
40439	421	6	not	not	RB
40439	421	7	the	the	DT
40439	421	8	only	only	JJ
40439	421	9	proof	proof	NN
40439	421	10	,	,	,
40439	421	11	which	which	WDT
40439	421	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	421	13	brings	bring	VBZ
40439	421	14	,	,	,
40439	421	15	is	be	VBZ
40439	421	16	that	that	IN
40439	421	17	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	421	18	so	so	RB
40439	421	19	construed	construe	VBD
40439	421	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	421	21	.	.	.
40439	422	1	Upon	upon	IN
40439	422	2	this	this	DT
40439	422	3	point	point	NN
40439	422	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	422	5	join	join	VBP
40439	422	6	issue	issue	NN
40439	422	7	with	with	IN
40439	422	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	422	9	.	.	.
40439	423	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	423	2	maintain	maintain	VBP
40439	423	3	that	that	IN
40439	423	4	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	423	5	does	do	VBZ
40439	423	6	_	_	NNP
40439	423	7	not	not	RB
40439	423	8	_	_	NNP
40439	423	9	understand	understand	VB
40439	423	10	[	[	-LRB-
40439	423	11	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	423	12	:	:	:
40439	423	13	ei(lome	ei(lome	VB
40439	423	14	/	/	SYM
40439	423	15	nên	nên	NN
40439	423	16	]	]	-RRB-
40439	423	17	or	or	CC
40439	423	18	[	[	-LRB-
40439	423	19	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	423	20	:	:	:
40439	423	21	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	423	22	/	/	SYM
40439	423	23	nên	nên	NNP
40439	423	24	peri\	peri\	NNP
40439	423	25	]	]	-RRB-
40439	423	26	as	as	IN
40439	423	27	naturally	naturally	RB
40439	423	28	meaning	mean	VBG
40439	423	29	_	_	NNP
40439	423	30	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	423	31	round	round	NN
40439	423	32	_	_	NNP
40439	423	33	,	,	,
40439	423	34	and	and	CC
40439	423	35	that	that	IN
40439	423	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	423	37	does	do	VBZ
40439	423	38	understand	understand	VB
40439	423	39	the	the	DT
40439	423	40	phrase	phrase	NN
40439	423	41	as	as	IN
40439	423	42	meaning	mean	VBG
40439	423	43	_	_	NNP
40439	423	44	fastened	fasten	VBD
40439	423	45	round	round	NN
40439	423	46	_	_	NNP
40439	423	47	.	.	.
40439	424	1	When	when	WRB
40439	424	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	424	3	find	find	VBP
40439	424	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	424	5	,	,	,
40439	424	6	in	in	IN
40439	424	7	the	the	DT
40439	424	8	second	second	JJ
40439	424	9	passage	passage	NN
40439	424	10	of	of	IN
40439	424	11	the	the	DT
40439	424	12	treatise	treatise	NN
40439	424	13	De	De	NNP
40439	424	14	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	424	15	,	,	,
40439	424	16	not	not	RB
40439	424	17	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
40439	424	18	with	with	IN
40439	424	19	the	the	DT
40439	424	20	verb	verb	NN
40439	424	21	[	[	-LRB-
40439	424	22	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	424	23	:	:	:
40439	424	24	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NN
40439	424	25	]	]	-RRB-
40439	424	26	alone	alone	RB
40439	424	27	,	,	,
40439	424	28	but	but	CC
40439	424	29	adding	add	VBG
40439	424	30	to	to	IN
40439	424	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	424	32	the	the	DT
40439	424	33	second	second	JJ
40439	424	34	verb	verb	NN
40439	424	35	[	[	-LRB-
40439	424	36	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	424	37	:	:	:
40439	424	38	_	_	NNP
40439	424	39	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	424	40	kinei	kinei	NNP
40439	424	41	=	=	SYM
40439	424	42	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	424	43	_	_	NNP
40439	424	44	]	]	-RRB-
40439	424	45	,	,	,
40439	424	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	424	47	may	may	MD
40439	424	48	be	be	VB
40439	424	49	sure	sure	JJ
40439	424	50	that	that	IN
40439	424	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	424	52	did	do	VBD
40439	424	53	not	not	RB
40439	424	54	consider	consider	VB
40439	424	55	[	[	-LRB-
40439	424	56	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	424	57	:	:	:
40439	424	58	i)/llesthai	i)/llesthai	NNP
40439	424	59	]	]	-RRB-
40439	424	60	as	as	IN
40439	424	61	naturally	naturally	RB
40439	424	62	and	and	CC
40439	424	63	properly	properly	RB
40439	424	64	denoting	denote	VBG
40439	424	65	_	_	NNP
40439	424	66	to	to	TO
40439	424	67	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	424	68	_	_	NNP
40439	424	69	or	or	CC
40439	424	70	_	_	NNP
40439	424	71	move	move	NN
40439	424	72	round	round	RB
40439	424	73	_	_	NNP
40439	424	74	.	.	.
40439	425	1	Agreeing	agree	VBG
40439	425	2	as	as	IN
40439	425	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	425	4	do	do	VBP
40439	425	5	with	with	IN
40439	425	6	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	425	7	in	in	IN
40439	425	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	425	9	view	view	NN
40439	425	10	,	,	,
40439	425	11	that	that	IN
40439	425	12	the	the	DT
40439	425	13	interpretation	interpretation	NN
40439	425	14	put	put	VBN
40439	425	15	by	by	IN
40439	425	16	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	425	17	is	be	VBZ
40439	425	18	the	the	DT
40439	425	19	best	good	JJS
40439	425	20	evidence	evidence	NN
40439	425	21	which	which	WDT
40439	425	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	425	23	can	can	MD
40439	425	24	follow	follow	VB
40439	425	25	in	in	IN
40439	425	26	determining	determine	VBG
40439	425	27	the	the	DT
40439	425	28	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	425	29	of	of	IN
40439	425	30	this	this	DT
40439	425	31	passage	passage	NN
40439	425	32	in	in	IN
40439	425	33	the	the	DT
40439	425	34	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	425	35	,	,	,
40439	425	36	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	425	37	contend	contend	VBP
40439	425	38	that	that	IN
40439	425	39	the	the	DT
40439	425	40	authority	authority	NN
40439	425	41	of	of	IN
40439	425	42	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	425	43	contradicts	contradict	VBZ
40439	425	44	instead	instead	RB
40439	425	45	of	of	IN
40439	425	46	justifying	justify	VBG
40439	425	47	the	the	DT
40439	425	48	conclusion	conclusion	NN
40439	425	49	at	at	IN
40439	425	50	which	which	WDT
40439	425	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	425	52	arrives	arrive	VBZ
40439	425	53	.	.	.
40439	426	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	426	2	understands	understand	VBZ
40439	426	3	[	[	-LRB-
40439	426	4	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	426	5	:	:	:
40439	426	6	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	426	7	/	/	SYM
40439	426	8	nên	nên	NN
40439	426	9	]	]	-RRB-
40439	426	10	as	as	IN
40439	426	11	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	426	12	_	_	NNP
40439	426	13	packed	pack	VBD
40439	426	14	or	or	CC
40439	426	15	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	426	16	round	round	NN
40439	426	17	_	_	NNP
40439	426	18	;	;	:
40439	426	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	426	20	does	do	VBZ
40439	426	21	not	not	RB
40439	426	22	understand	understand	VB
40439	426	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	426	24	as	as	IN
40439	426	25	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	426	26	,	,	,
40439	426	27	when	when	WRB
40439	426	28	taken	take	VBN
40439	426	29	by	by	IN
40439	426	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	426	31	,	,	,
40439	426	32	_	_	NNP
40439	426	33	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	426	34	round	round	NN
40439	426	35	_	_	NNP
40439	426	36	.	.	.
40439	427	1	The	the	DT
40439	427	2	two	two	CD
40439	427	3	meanings	meaning	NNS
40439	427	4	here	here	RB
40439	427	5	indicated	indicate	VBN
40439	427	6	are	be	VBP
40439	427	7	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
40439	427	8	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	427	9	and	and	CC
40439	427	10	independent	independent	JJ
40439	427	11	.	.	.
40439	428	1	But	but	CC
40439	428	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	428	3	are	be	VBP
40439	428	4	not	not	RB
40439	428	5	for	for	IN
40439	428	6	that	that	DT
40439	428	7	reason	reason	NN
40439	428	8	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
40439	428	9	and	and	CC
40439	428	10	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
40439	428	11	.	.	.
40439	429	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	429	2	has	have	VBZ
40439	429	3	been	be	VBN
40439	429	4	the	the	DT
40439	429	5	mistake	mistake	NN
40439	429	6	of	of	IN
40439	429	7	critics	critic	NNS
40439	429	8	to	to	TO
40439	429	9	conceive	conceive	VB
40439	429	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	429	11	as	as	IN
40439	429	12	thus	thus	RB
40439	429	13	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
40439	429	14	;	;	:
40439	429	15	so	so	IN
40439	429	16	that	that	IN
40439	429	17	if	if	IN
40439	429	18	one	one	CD
40439	429	19	of	of	IN
40439	429	20	the	the	DT
40439	429	21	two	two	CD
40439	429	22	were	be	VBD
40439	429	23	admitted	admit	VBN
40439	429	24	,	,	,
40439	429	25	the	the	DT
40439	429	26	other	other	JJ
40439	429	27	must	must	MD
40439	429	28	be	be	VB
40439	429	29	rejected	reject	VBN
40439	429	30	.	.	.
40439	430	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	430	2	have	have	VBP
40439	430	3	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	430	4	to	to	TO
40439	430	5	show	show	VB
40439	430	6	that	that	IN
40439	430	7	this	this	DT
40439	430	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	430	9	not	not	RB
40439	430	10	universally	universally	RB
40439	430	11	true	true	JJ
40439	430	12	,	,	,
40439	430	13	and	and	CC
40439	430	14	that	that	IN
40439	430	15	there	there	EX
40439	430	16	are	be	VBP
40439	430	17	certain	certain	JJ
40439	430	18	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
40439	430	19	in	in	IN
40439	430	20	which	which	WDT
40439	430	21	the	the	DT
40439	430	22	two	two	CD
40439	430	23	meanings	meaning	NNS
40439	430	24	not	not	RB
40439	430	25	only	only	RB
40439	430	26	may	may	MD
40439	430	27	come	come	VB
40439	430	28	together	together	RB
40439	430	29	,	,	,
40439	430	30	but	but	CC
40439	430	31	must	must	MD
40439	430	32	come	come	VB
40439	430	33	together	together	RB
40439	430	34	.	.	.
40439	431	1	Such	such	JJ
40439	431	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	431	3	the	the	DT
40439	431	4	case	case	NN
40439	431	5	when	when	WRB
40439	431	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	431	7	revert	revert	VBP
40439	431	8	to	to	IN
40439	431	9	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	431	10	's	's	POS
40439	431	11	conception	conception	NN
40439	431	12	of	of	IN
40439	431	13	the	the	DT
40439	431	14	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	431	15	axis	axis	NN
40439	431	16	as	as	IN
40439	431	17	a	a	DT
40439	431	18	solid	solid	JJ
40439	431	19	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	431	20	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	431	21	.	.	.
40439	432	1	That	that	DT
40439	432	2	which	which	WDT
40439	432	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	432	4	packed	pack	VBN
40439	432	5	or	or	CC
40439	432	6	fastened	fasten	VBN
40439	432	7	around	around	IN
40439	432	8	the	the	DT
40439	432	9	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	432	10	must	must	MD
40439	432	11	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	432	12	around	around	IN
40439	432	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	432	14	,	,	,
40439	432	15	and	and	CC
40439	432	16	along	along	IN
40439	432	17	with	with	IN
40439	432	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	432	19	.	.	.
40439	433	1	Both	both	CC
40439	433	2	M.	M.	NNP
40439	433	3	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	433	4	and	and	CC
40439	433	5	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	433	6	assume	assume	VBP
40439	433	7	the	the	DT
40439	433	8	incompatibility	incompatibility	NN
40439	433	9	of	of	IN
40439	433	10	the	the	DT
40439	433	11	two	two	CD
40439	433	12	meanings	meaning	NNS
40439	433	13	;	;	:
40439	433	14	and	and	CC
40439	433	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	433	16	find	find	VBP
40439	433	17	the	the	DT
40439	433	18	same	same	JJ
40439	433	19	assumption	assumption	NN
40439	433	20	in	in	IN
40439	433	21	Plutarch	Plutarch	NNP
40439	433	22	's	's	POS
40439	433	23	criticisms	criticism	NNS
40439	433	24	on	on	IN
40439	433	25	the	the	DT
40439	433	26	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	433	27	(	(	-LRB-
40439	433	28	Plutarch	Plutarch	NNP
40439	433	29	.	.	.
40439	434	1	Quæst	Quæst	NNP
40439	434	2	.	.	.
40439	435	1	Platon	Platon	NNP
40439	435	2	.	.	.
40439	436	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	436	2	1006	1006	CD
40439	436	3	C	C	NNP
40439	436	4	)	)	-RRB-
40439	436	5	,	,	,
40439	436	6	where	where	WRB
40439	436	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	436	8	discusses	discuss	VBZ
40439	436	9	what	what	WP
40439	436	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	436	11	means	mean	VBZ
40439	436	12	by	by	IN
40439	436	13	[	[	-LRB-
40439	436	14	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	436	15	:	:	:
40439	436	16	o)/rgana	o)/rgana	NNP
40439	436	17	chro	chro	NNP
40439	436	18	/	/	SYM
40439	436	19	nou	nou	NNP
40439	436	20	]	]	-RRB-
40439	436	21	;	;	:
40439	436	22	and	and	CC
40439	436	23	in	in	IN
40439	436	24	what	what	WDT
40439	436	25	sense	sense	NN
40439	436	26	the	the	DT
40439	436	27	earth	earth	NN
40439	436	28	as	as	RB
40439	436	29	well	well	RB
40439	436	30	as	as	IN
40439	436	31	the	the	DT
40439	436	32	moon	moon	NN
40439	436	33	can	can	MD
40439	436	34	be	be	VB
40439	436	35	reckoned	reckon	VBN
40439	436	36	as	as	IN
40439	436	37	[	[	-LRB-
40439	436	38	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	436	39	:	:	:
40439	436	40	o)/rganon	o)/rganon	NNP
40439	436	41	chro	chro	NNP
40439	436	42	/	/	SYM
40439	436	43	nou	nou	NNP
40439	436	44	]	]	-RRB-
40439	436	45	(	(	-LRB-
40439	436	46	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	436	47	,	,	,
40439	436	48	p.	p.	NN
40439	436	49	41	41	CD
40439	436	50	E	e	NN
40439	436	51	,	,	,
40439	436	52	42	42	CD
40439	436	53	D	d	NN
40439	436	54	)	)	-RRB-
40439	436	55	.	.	.
40439	437	1	Plutarch	plutarch	NN
40439	437	2	inquires	inquire	VBZ
40439	437	3	how	how	WRB
40439	437	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	437	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	437	6	possible	possible	JJ
40439	437	7	that	that	IN
40439	437	8	the	the	DT
40439	437	9	earth	earth	NN
40439	437	10	,	,	,
40439	437	11	if	if	IN
40439	437	12	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	437	13	and	and	CC
40439	437	14	at	at	IN
40439	437	15	rest	rest	NN
40439	437	16	,	,	,
40439	437	17	can	can	MD
40439	437	18	be	be	VB
40439	437	19	characterised	characterise	VBN
40439	437	20	as	as	IN
40439	437	21	"	"	``
40439	437	22	among	among	IN
40439	437	23	the	the	DT
40439	437	24	instruments	instrument	NNS
40439	437	25	of	of	IN
40439	437	26	time	time	NN
40439	437	27	;	;	:
40439	437	28	"	"	''
40439	437	29	and	and	CC
40439	437	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	437	31	explains	explain	VBZ
40439	437	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	437	33	by	by	IN
40439	437	34	saying	say	VBG
40439	437	35	that	that	IN
40439	437	36	this	this	DT
40439	437	37	is	be	VBZ
40439	437	38	true	true	JJ
40439	437	39	in	in	IN
40439	437	40	the	the	DT
40439	437	41	same	same	JJ
40439	437	42	sense	sense	NN
40439	437	43	as	as	IN
40439	437	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	437	45	call	call	VBP
40439	437	46	a	a	DT
40439	437	47	gnomon	gnomon	NN
40439	437	48	or	or	CC
40439	437	49	sun	sun	NN
40439	437	50	-	-	HYPH
40439	437	51	dial	dial	VB
40439	437	52	an	an	DT
40439	437	53	instrument	instrument	NN
40439	437	54	of	of	IN
40439	437	55	time	time	NN
40439	437	56	,	,	,
40439	437	57	because	because	IN
40439	437	58	,	,	,
40439	437	59	though	though	IN
40439	437	60	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	437	61	never	never	RB
40439	437	62	moves	move	VBZ
40439	437	63	,	,	,
40439	437	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	437	65	marks	mark	VBZ
40439	437	66	the	the	DT
40439	437	67	successive	successive	JJ
40439	437	68	movements	movement	NNS
40439	437	69	of	of	IN
40439	437	70	the	the	DT
40439	437	71	shadow	shadow	NN
40439	437	72	.	.	.
40439	438	1	This	this	DT
40439	438	2	explanation	explanation	NN
40439	438	3	might	may	MD
40439	438	4	be	be	VB
40439	438	5	admissible	admissible	JJ
40439	438	6	for	for	IN
40439	438	7	the	the	DT
40439	438	8	phrase	phrase	NN
40439	438	9	[	[	-LRB-
40439	438	10	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	438	11	:	:	:
40439	438	12	o)/rganon	o)/rganon	NNP
40439	438	13	chro	chro	NNP
40439	438	14	/	/	SYM
40439	438	15	nou	nou	NNP
40439	438	16	]	]	-RRB-
40439	438	17	;	;	:
40439	438	18	but	but	CC
40439	438	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	438	20	can	can	MD
40439	438	21	not	not	RB
40439	438	22	think	think	VB
40439	438	23	that	that	IN
40439	438	24	the	the	DT
40439	438	25	immobility	immobility	NN
40439	438	26	of	of	IN
40439	438	27	the	the	DT
40439	438	28	earth	earth	NN
40439	438	29	can	can	MD
40439	438	30	be	be	VB
40439	438	31	made	make	VBN
40439	438	32	compatible	compatible	JJ
40439	438	33	with	with	IN
40439	438	34	the	the	DT
40439	438	35	attribute	attribute	NN
40439	438	36	which	which	WDT
40439	438	37	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	438	38	bestows	bestow	VBZ
40439	438	39	upon	upon	IN
40439	438	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	438	41	of	of	IN
40439	438	42	being	be	VBG
40439	438	43	[	[	-LRB-
40439	438	44	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	438	45	:	:	:
40439	438	46	phu	phu	NNP
40439	438	47	/	/	SYM
40439	438	48	lax	lax	NNP
40439	438	49	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	438	50	_	_	NNP
40439	438	51	dêmiourgo\s	dêmiourgo\s	NNP
40439	438	52	_	_	NNP
40439	438	53	nukto\s	nukto\s	NNP
40439	438	54	te	te	NNP
40439	438	55	kai\	kai\	NNP
40439	438	56	ê(me	ê(me	NNP
40439	438	57	/	/	SYM
40439	438	58	ras	ras	NNP
40439	438	59	]	]	-RRB-
40439	438	60	.	.	.
40439	439	1	The	the	DT
40439	439	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
40439	439	3	,	,	,
40439	439	4	however	however	RB
40439	439	5	,	,	,
40439	439	6	vanishes	vanishe	NNS
40439	439	7	when	when	WRB
40439	439	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	439	9	understand	understand	VBP
40439	439	10	the	the	DT
40439	439	11	function	function	NN
40439	439	12	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	439	13	by	by	IN
40439	439	14	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	439	15	to	to	IN
40439	439	16	the	the	DT
40439	439	17	earth	earth	NN
40439	439	18	as	as	IN
40439	439	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	439	20	have	have	VBP
40439	439	21	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	439	22	to	to	TO
40439	439	23	elucidate	elucidate	VB
40439	439	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	439	25	.	.	.
40439	440	1	The	the	DT
40439	440	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	440	3	not	not	RB
40439	440	4	only	only	RB
40439	440	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	440	6	not	not	RB
40439	440	7	at	at	IN
40439	440	8	rest	rest	NN
40439	440	9	,	,	,
40439	440	10	but	but	CC
40439	440	11	can	can	MD
40439	440	12	not	not	RB
40439	440	13	be	be	VB
40439	440	14	at	at	IN
40439	440	15	rest	rest	NN
40439	440	16	,	,	,
40439	440	17	precisely	precisely	RB
40439	440	18	because	because	IN
40439	440	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	440	20	is	be	VBZ
40439	440	21	packed	pack	VBN
40439	440	22	round	round	IN
40439	440	23	the	the	DT
40439	440	24	solid	solid	JJ
40439	440	25	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	440	26	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	440	27	axis	axi	NNS
40439	440	28	,	,	,
40439	440	29	and	and	CC
40439	440	30	must	must	MD
40439	440	31	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	440	32	along	along	IN
40439	440	33	with	with	IN
40439	440	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	440	35	.	.	.
40439	441	1	The	the	DT
40439	441	2	function	function	NN
40439	441	3	of	of	IN
40439	441	4	the	the	DT
40439	441	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	441	6	,	,	,
40439	441	7	as	as	IN
40439	441	8	the	the	DT
40439	441	9	first	first	JJ
40439	441	10	and	and	CC
40439	441	11	oldest	old	JJS
40439	441	12	of	of	IN
40439	441	13	intra	intra	JJ
40439	441	14	-	-	JJ
40439	441	15	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	441	16	deities	deity	NNS
40439	441	17	,	,	,
40439	441	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	441	19	to	to	TO
40439	441	20	uphold	uphold	VB
40439	441	21	and	and	CC
40439	441	22	regulate	regulate	VB
40439	441	23	the	the	DT
40439	441	24	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	441	25	of	of	IN
40439	441	26	this	this	DT
40439	441	27	axis	axis	NN
40439	441	28	,	,	,
40439	441	29	upon	upon	IN
40439	441	30	which	which	WDT
40439	441	31	depend	depend	VBP
40439	441	32	the	the	DT
40439	441	33	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	441	34	of	of	IN
40439	441	35	the	the	DT
40439	441	36	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	441	37	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	441	38	or	or	CC
40439	441	39	outer	outer	JJ
40439	441	40	shell	shell	NN
40439	441	41	of	of	IN
40439	441	42	the	the	DT
40439	441	43	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	441	44	.	.	.
40439	442	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	442	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	442	3	by	by	IN
40439	442	4	virtue	virtue	NN
40439	442	5	of	of	IN
40439	442	6	this	this	DT
40439	442	7	regulating	regulate	VBG
40439	442	8	function	function	NN
40439	442	9	(	(	-LRB-
40439	442	10	and	and	CC
40439	442	11	not	not	RB
40439	442	12	by	by	IN
40439	442	13	virtue	virtue	NN
40439	442	14	of	of	IN
40439	442	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	442	16	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	442	17	)	)	-RRB-
40439	442	18	that	that	IN
40439	442	19	the	the	DT
40439	442	20	earth	earth	NN
40439	442	21	is	be	VBZ
40439	442	22	the	the	DT
40439	442	23	guardian	guardian	NN
40439	442	24	and	and	CC
40439	442	25	artificer	artificer	NN
40439	442	26	of	of	IN
40439	442	27	night	night	NN
40439	442	28	and	and	CC
40439	442	29	day	day	NN
40439	442	30	.	.	.
40439	443	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	443	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	443	3	not	not	RB
40439	443	4	only	only	RB
40439	443	5	"	"	''
40439	443	6	an	an	DT
40439	443	7	instrument	instrument	NN
40439	443	8	of	of	IN
40439	443	9	time	time	NN
40439	443	10	,	,	,
40439	443	11	"	"	''
40439	443	12	but	but	CC
40439	443	13	the	the	DT
40439	443	14	most	most	RBS
40439	443	15	potent	potent	JJ
40439	443	16	and	and	CC
40439	443	17	commanding	command	VBG
40439	443	18	among	among	IN
40439	443	19	all	all	DT
40439	443	20	instruments	instrument	NNS
40439	443	21	of	of	IN
40439	443	22	time	time	NN
40439	443	23	.	.	.
40439	444	1	What	what	WP
40439	444	2	has	have	VBZ
40439	444	3	just	just	RB
40439	444	4	been	be	VBN
40439	444	5	stated	state	VBN
40439	444	6	is	be	VBZ
40439	444	7	,	,	,
40439	444	8	in	in	IN
40439	444	9	my	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	444	10	belief	belief	NN
40439	444	11	,	,	,
40439	444	12	the	the	DT
40439	444	13	theory	theory	NN
40439	444	14	of	of	IN
40439	444	15	the	the	DT
40439	444	16	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	444	17	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	444	18	,	,	,
40439	444	19	signified	signify	VBN
40439	444	20	in	in	IN
40439	444	21	the	the	DT
40439	444	22	words	word	NNS
40439	444	23	of	of	IN
40439	444	24	that	that	DT
40439	444	25	dialogue	dialogue	NN
40439	444	26	,	,	,
40439	444	27	and	and	CC
40439	444	28	embodied	embody	VBD
40439	444	29	in	in	IN
40439	444	30	the	the	DT
40439	444	31	comment	comment	NN
40439	444	32	of	of	IN
40439	444	33	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	444	34	.	.	.
40439	445	1	The	the	DT
40439	445	2	commentators	commentator	NNS
40439	445	3	,	,	,
40439	445	4	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
40439	445	5	to	to	IN
40439	445	6	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	445	7	,	,	,
40439	445	8	so	so	RB
40439	445	9	far	far	RB
40439	445	10	as	as	IN
40439	445	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	445	12	know	know	VBP
40439	445	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	445	14	,	,	,
40439	445	15	understood	understand	VBD
40439	445	16	the	the	DT
40439	445	17	theory	theory	NN
40439	445	18	in	in	IN
40439	445	19	a	a	DT
40439	445	20	sense	sense	NN
40439	445	21	different	different	JJ
40439	445	22	from	from	IN
40439	445	23	what	what	WP
40439	445	24	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	445	25	intended	intend	VBD
40439	445	26	.	.	.
40439	446	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	446	2	think	think	VBP
40439	446	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	446	4	may	may	MD
40439	446	5	see	see	VB
40439	446	6	how	how	WRB
40439	446	7	this	this	DT
40439	446	8	misconception	misconception	NN
40439	446	9	arose	arise	VBD
40439	446	10	.	.	.
40439	447	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	447	2	arose	arise	VBD
40439	447	3	from	from	IN
40439	447	4	the	the	DT
40439	447	5	great	great	JJ
40439	447	6	development	development	NN
40439	447	7	and	and	CC
40439	447	8	elaboration	elaboration	NN
40439	447	9	of	of	IN
40439	447	10	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	447	11	theory	theory	NN
40439	447	12	during	during	IN
40439	447	13	the	the	DT
40439	447	14	two	two	CD
40439	447	15	or	or	CC
40439	447	16	three	three	CD
40439	447	17	generations	generation	NNS
40439	447	18	immediately	immediately	RB
40439	447	19	succeeding	succeed	VBG
40439	447	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	447	21	.	.	.
40439	448	1	Much	much	JJ
40439	448	2	was	be	VBD
40439	448	3	added	add	VBN
40439	448	4	by	by	IN
40439	448	5	Eudoxus	Eudoxus	NNP
40439	448	6	and	and	CC
40439	448	7	others	other	NNS
40439	448	8	,	,	,
40439	448	9	in	in	IN
40439	448	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	448	11	theory	theory	NN
40439	448	12	of	of	IN
40439	448	13	concentric	concentric	JJ
40439	448	14	spheres	sphere	NNS
40439	448	15	:	:	:
40439	448	16	more	more	RBR
40439	448	17	still	still	RB
40439	448	18	by	by	IN
40439	448	19	others	other	NNS
40439	448	20	of	of	IN
40439	448	21	whom	whom	WP
40439	448	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	448	23	read	read	VBP
40439	448	24	in	in	IN
40439	448	25	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
40439	448	26	(	(	-LRB-
40439	448	27	Academ	Academ	NNP
40439	448	28	.	.	.
40439	449	1	II	ii	CD
40439	449	2	.	.	.
40439	450	1	39	39	CD
40439	450	2	.	.	.
40439	450	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	451	1	"	"	``
40439	451	2	Hicetas	Hicetas	NNP
40439	451	3	Syracusius	Syracusius	NNP
40439	451	4	,	,	,
40439	451	5	ut	ut	UH
40439	451	6	ait	ait	CC
40439	451	7	Theophrastus	Theophrastus	NNP
40439	451	8	,	,	,
40439	451	9	coelum	coelum	NN
40439	451	10	,	,	,
40439	451	11	solem	solem	NNP
40439	451	12	,	,	,
40439	451	13	lunam	lunam	NNP
40439	451	14	,	,	,
40439	451	15	stellas	stellas	NNP
40439	451	16	,	,	,
40439	451	17	supera	supera	NNP
40439	451	18	denique	denique	NNP
40439	451	19	omnia	omnia	NNP
40439	451	20	,	,	,
40439	451	21	stare	stare	NNP
40439	451	22	censet	censet	NNP
40439	451	23	,	,	,
40439	451	24	neque	neque	NNP
40439	451	25	praeter	praeter	NNP
40439	451	26	terram	terram	NNP
40439	451	27	rem	rem	NNP
40439	451	28	ullam	ullam	NNP
40439	451	29	in	in	IN
40439	451	30	mundo	mundo	NNP
40439	451	31	moveri	moveri	NNP
40439	451	32	:	:	:
40439	451	33	quae	quae	NNP
40439	451	34	cum	cum	NNP
40439	451	35	circum	circum	NNP
40439	451	36	axem	axem	NNP
40439	451	37	se	se	NNP
40439	451	38	summâ	summâ	NNP
40439	451	39	celeritate	celeritate	NN
40439	451	40	convertat	convertat	NNP
40439	451	41	et	et	NNP
40439	451	42	torqueat	torqueat	NN
40439	451	43	,	,	,
40439	451	44	eadem	eadem	NN
40439	451	45	effici	effici	VBZ
40439	451	46	omnia	omnia	NNP
40439	451	47	,	,	,
40439	451	48	quae	quae	NNP
40439	451	49	si	si	NNP
40439	451	50	stante	stante	NNP
40439	451	51	terrâ	terrâ	NNP
40439	451	52	coelum	coelum	NNP
40439	451	53	moveretur	moveretur	NNP
40439	451	54	.	.	.
40439	452	1	Atque	Atque	NNP
40439	452	2	hoc	hoc	FW
40439	452	3	etiam	etiam	NNP
40439	452	4	Platonem	Platonem	NNP
40439	452	5	in	in	IN
40439	452	6	Timaeo	Timaeo	NNP
40439	452	7	dicere	dicere	RB
40439	452	8	quidam	quidam	NNP
40439	452	9	arbitrantur	arbitrantur	NNP
40439	452	10	,	,	,
40439	452	11	sed	sed	NNP
40439	452	12	paullo	paullo	NNP
40439	452	13	obscurius	obscurius	NNP
40439	452	14	.	.	.
40439	452	15	"	"	''
40439	453	1	The	the	DT
40439	453	2	same	same	JJ
40439	453	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	453	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	453	5	said	say	VBN
40439	453	6	to	to	TO
40439	453	7	have	have	VB
40439	453	8	been	be	VBN
40439	453	9	held	hold	VBN
40439	453	10	by	by	IN
40439	453	11	Herakleides	Herakleides	NNP
40439	453	12	of	of	IN
40439	453	13	Pontus	Pontus	NNP
40439	453	14	,	,	,
40439	453	15	the	the	DT
40439	453	16	contemporary	contemporary	NN
40439	453	17	of	of	IN
40439	453	18	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	453	19	,	,	,
40439	453	20	and	and	CC
40439	453	21	by	by	IN
40439	453	22	others	other	NNS
40439	453	23	along	along	IN
40439	453	24	with	with	IN
40439	453	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	453	26	.	.	.
40439	454	1	(	(	-LRB-
40439	454	2	Simplikius	Simplikius	NNP
40439	454	3	ad	ad	NN
40439	454	4	Aristot	Aristot	NNP
40439	454	5	.	.	.
40439	455	1	Physic	Physic	NNP
40439	455	2	.	.	.
40439	456	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	456	2	64	64	CD
40439	456	3	-	-	HYPH
40439	456	4	-De	-de	NN
40439	456	5	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	456	6	,	,	,
40439	456	7	p.	p.	NN
40439	456	8	132	132	CD
40439	456	9	-	-	HYPH
40439	456	10	-Plutarch	-Plutarch	NNP
40439	456	11	.	.	.
40439	457	1	Plac	Plac	NNS
40439	457	2	.	.	.
40439	458	1	Phil	Phil	NNP
40439	458	2	.	.	.
40439	459	1	III	iii	CD
40439	459	2	.	.	.
40439	460	1	13	13	CD
40439	460	2	.	.	.
40439	460	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	461	1	The	the	DT
40439	461	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	461	3	of	of	IN
40439	461	4	the	the	DT
40439	461	5	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	461	6	of	of	IN
40439	461	7	the	the	DT
40439	461	8	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	461	9	here	here	RB
40439	461	10	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	461	11	along	along	IN
40439	461	12	with	with	IN
40439	461	13	another	another	DT
40439	461	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	461	15	--	--	:
40439	461	16	the	the	DT
40439	461	17	immobility	immobility	NN
40439	461	18	of	of	IN
40439	461	19	the	the	DT
40439	461	20	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	461	21	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	461	22	and	and	CC
40439	461	23	of	of	IN
40439	461	24	the	the	DT
40439	461	25	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	461	26	bodies	body	NNS
40439	461	27	.	.	.
40439	462	1	The	the	DT
40439	462	2	two	two	CD
40439	462	3	are	be	VBP
40439	462	4	presented	present	VBN
40439	462	5	together	together	RB
40439	462	6	,	,	,
40439	462	7	as	as	IN
40439	462	8	correlative	correlative	JJ
40439	462	9	portions	portion	NNS
40439	462	10	of	of	IN
40439	462	11	one	one	CD
40439	462	12	and	and	CC
40439	462	13	the	the	DT
40439	462	14	same	same	JJ
40439	462	15	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	462	16	theory	theory	NN
40439	462	17	.	.	.
40439	463	1	There	there	EX
40439	463	2	are	be	VBP
40439	463	3	no	no	DT
40439	463	4	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	463	5	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	463	6	,	,	,
40439	463	7	and	and	CC
40439	463	8	therefore	therefore	RB
40439	463	9	there	there	EX
40439	463	10	is	be	VBZ
40439	463	11	no	no	DT
40439	463	12	solid	solid	JJ
40439	463	13	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	463	14	axis	axi	NNS
40439	463	15	.	.	.
40439	464	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
40439	464	2	,	,	,
40439	464	3	even	even	RB
40439	464	4	Aristarchus	Aristarchus	NNP
40439	464	5	of	of	IN
40439	464	6	Samos	Samos	NNP
40439	464	7	(	(	-LRB-
40439	464	8	who	who	WP
40439	464	9	attained	attain	VBD
40439	464	10	to	to	IN
40439	464	11	a	a	DT
40439	464	12	theory	theory	NN
40439	464	13	substantially	substantially	RB
40439	464	14	the	the	DT
40439	464	15	same	same	JJ
40439	464	16	as	as	IN
40439	464	17	the	the	DT
40439	464	18	Copernican	Copernican	NNP
40439	464	19	,	,	,
40439	464	20	with	with	IN
40439	464	21	the	the	DT
40439	464	22	double	double	JJ
40439	464	23	movement	movement	NN
40439	464	24	of	of	IN
40439	464	25	the	the	DT
40439	464	26	Earth	Earth	NNP
40439	464	27	,	,	,
40439	464	28	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	464	29	round	round	IN
40439	464	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	464	31	own	own	JJ
40439	464	32	axis	axis	NN
40439	464	33	,	,	,
40439	464	34	and	and	CC
40439	464	35	translation	translation	NN
40439	464	36	round	round	IN
40439	464	37	the	the	DT
40439	464	38	sun	sun	NN
40439	464	39	as	as	IN
40439	464	40	a	a	DT
40439	464	41	centre	centre	NN
40439	464	42	)	)	-RRB-
40439	464	43	comes	come	VBZ
40439	464	44	within	within	IN
40439	464	45	less	less	JJR
40439	464	46	than	than	IN
40439	464	47	a	a	DT
40439	464	48	century	century	NN
40439	464	49	after	after	IN
40439	464	50	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	464	51	's	's	POS
40439	464	52	death	death	NN
40439	464	53	.	.	.
40439	465	1	Though	though	IN
40439	465	2	the	the	DT
40439	465	3	_	_	NNP
40439	465	4	quidam	quidam	NNP
40439	465	5	_	_	NNP
40439	465	6	alluded	allude	VBD
40439	465	7	to	to	IN
40439	465	8	by	by	IN
40439	465	9	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
40439	465	10	looked	look	VBD
40439	465	11	upon	upon	IN
40439	465	12	the	the	DT
40439	465	13	obscure	obscure	JJ
40439	465	14	sentence	sentence	NN
40439	465	15	in	in	IN
40439	465	16	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	465	17	's	's	POS
40439	465	18	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	465	19	as	as	IN
40439	465	20	a	a	DT
40439	465	21	dim	dim	JJ
40439	465	22	indication	indication	NN
40439	465	23	of	of	IN
40439	465	24	the	the	DT
40439	465	25	theory	theory	NN
40439	465	26	of	of	IN
40439	465	27	Hicetas	Hicetas	NNP
40439	465	28	,	,	,
40439	465	29	yet	yet	CC
40439	465	30	the	the	DT
40439	465	31	two	two	CD
40439	465	32	agree	agree	VBP
40439	465	33	only	only	RB
40439	465	34	in	in	IN
40439	465	35	the	the	DT
40439	465	36	supposition	supposition	NN
40439	465	37	of	of	IN
40439	465	38	a	a	DT
40439	465	39	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	465	40	of	of	IN
40439	465	41	the	the	DT
40439	465	42	earth	earth	NN
40439	465	43	,	,	,
40439	465	44	and	and	CC
40439	465	45	differ	differ	VBP
40439	465	46	essentially	essentially	RB
40439	465	47	in	in	IN
40439	465	48	the	the	DT
40439	465	49	pervading	pervading	JJ
40439	465	50	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	465	51	conceptions	conception	NNS
40439	465	52	.	.	.
40439	466	1	Hicetas	Hicetas	NNP
40439	466	2	states	state	NNS
40439	466	3	distinctly	distinctly	RB
40439	466	4	that	that	IN
40439	466	5	which	which	WDT
40439	466	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	466	7	theory	theory	NN
40439	466	8	denies	deny	VBZ
40439	466	9	,	,	,
40439	466	10	as	as	RB
40439	466	11	well	well	RB
40439	466	12	as	as	IN
40439	466	13	that	that	DT
40439	466	14	which	which	WDT
40439	466	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	466	16	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	466	17	.	.	.
40439	467	1	The	the	DT
40439	467	2	negation	negation	NN
40439	467	3	of	of	IN
40439	467	4	the	the	DT
40439	467	5	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	467	6	rotations	rotation	NNS
40439	467	7	,	,	,
40439	467	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	467	9	in	in	IN
40439	467	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	467	11	theory	theory	NN
40439	467	12	a	a	DT
40439	467	13	point	point	NN
40439	467	14	of	of	IN
40439	467	15	capital	capital	NN
40439	467	16	and	and	CC
40439	467	17	coordinate	coordinate	VB
40439	467	18	importance	importance	NN
40439	467	19	,	,	,
40439	467	20	on	on	IN
40439	467	21	which	which	WDT
40439	467	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	467	23	contradicts	contradict	VBZ
40439	467	24	both	both	CC
40439	467	25	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	467	26	and	and	CC
40439	467	27	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	467	28	as	as	RB
40439	467	29	well	well	RB
40439	467	30	as	as	IN
40439	467	31	the	the	DT
40439	467	32	apparent	apparent	JJ
40439	467	33	evidence	evidence	NN
40439	467	34	of	of	IN
40439	467	35	sense	sense	NN
40439	467	36	.	.	.
40439	468	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	468	2	can	can	MD
40439	468	3	not	not	RB
40439	468	4	suppose	suppose	VB
40439	468	5	that	that	IN
40439	468	6	this	this	DT
40439	468	7	theory	theory	NN
40439	468	8	can	can	MD
40439	468	9	have	have	VB
40439	468	10	been	be	VBN
40439	468	11	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	468	12	or	or	CC
40439	468	13	known	know	VBN
40439	468	14	to	to	IN
40439	468	15	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	468	16	when	when	WRB
40439	468	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	468	18	works	work	NNS
40439	468	19	were	be	VBD
40439	468	20	composed	compose	VBN
40439	468	21	:	:	:
40439	468	22	for	for	IN
40439	468	23	the	the	DT
40439	468	24	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	468	25	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	468	26	are	be	VBP
40439	468	27	the	the	DT
40439	468	28	keystone	keystone	NN
40439	468	29	of	of	IN
40439	468	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	468	31	system	system	NN
40439	468	32	,	,	,
40439	468	33	and	and	CC
40439	468	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	468	35	could	could	MD
40439	468	36	hardly	hardly	RB
40439	468	37	have	have	VB
40439	468	38	abstained	abstain	VBN
40439	468	39	from	from	IN
40439	468	40	combating	combat	VBG
40439	468	41	a	a	DT
40439	468	42	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	468	43	which	which	WDT
40439	468	44	denied	deny	VBD
40439	468	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	468	46	altogether	altogether	RB
40439	468	47	.	.	.
40439	469	1	In	in	IN
40439	469	2	the	the	DT
40439	469	3	hands	hand	NNS
40439	469	4	of	of	IN
40439	469	5	Hicetas	Hicetas	NNP
40439	469	6	(	(	-LRB-
40439	469	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
40439	469	8	in	in	IN
40439	469	9	those	those	DT
40439	469	10	of	of	IN
40439	469	11	Herakleides	Herakleides	NNPS
40439	469	12	,	,	,
40439	469	13	if	if	IN
40439	469	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	469	15	may	may	MD
40439	469	16	believe	believe	VB
40439	469	17	what	what	WP
40439	469	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	469	19	said	say	VBN
40439	469	20	about	about	IN
40439	469	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	469	22	)	)	-RRB-
40439	469	23	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	469	24	appears	appear	VBZ
40439	469	25	treated	treat	VBN
40439	469	26	as	as	IN
40439	469	27	a	a	DT
40439	469	28	science	science	NN
40439	469	29	by	by	IN
40439	469	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	469	31	,	,	,
40439	469	32	with	with	IN
40439	469	33	a	a	DT
40439	469	34	view	view	NN
40439	469	35	"	"	''
40439	469	36	to	to	TO
40439	469	37	provide	provide	VB
40439	469	38	such	such	JJ
40439	469	39	hypotheses	hypothesis	NNS
40439	469	40	as	as	IN
40439	469	41	may	may	MD
40439	469	42	save	save	VB
40439	469	43	the	the	DT
40439	469	44	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
40439	469	45	"	"	''
40439	469	46	(	(	-LRB-
40439	469	47	[	[	-LRB-
40439	469	48	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	469	49	:	:	:
40439	469	50	sô	sô	NN
40439	469	51	/	/	SYM
40439	469	52	zein	zein	NNP
40439	469	53	ta\	ta\	NNP
40439	469	54	phaino	phaino	NNP
40439	469	55	/	/	SYM
40439	469	56	mena	mena	NN
40439	469	57	]	]	-RRB-
40439	469	58	,	,	,
40439	469	59	Simpl	Simpl	NNP
40439	469	60	.	.	.
40439	470	1	ad	ad	NN
40439	470	2	Aristot	Aristot	NNP
40439	470	3	.	.	.
40439	471	1	De	De	NNP
40439	471	2	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	471	3	,	,	,
40439	471	4	p.	p.	NN
40439	471	5	498	498	CD
40439	471	6	,	,	,
40439	471	7	Schol	Schol	NNP
40439	471	8	.	.	.
40439	472	1	Brandis	Brandis	NNP
40439	472	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	472	3	.	.	.
40439	473	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	473	2	becomes	become	VBZ
40439	473	3	detached	detach	VBN
40439	473	4	from	from	IN
40439	473	5	those	those	DT
40439	473	6	religious	religious	JJ
40439	473	7	,	,	,
40439	473	8	ethical	ethical	JJ
40439	473	9	,	,	,
40439	473	10	poetical	poetical	JJ
40439	473	11	,	,	,
40439	473	12	teleological	teleological	JJ
40439	473	13	,	,	,
40439	473	14	arithmetical	arithmetical	JJ
40439	473	15	decrees	decree	NNS
40439	473	16	or	or	CC
40439	473	17	fancies	fancy	NNS
40439	473	18	,	,	,
40439	473	19	in	in	IN
40439	473	20	which	which	WDT
40439	473	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	473	22	see	see	VBP
40439	473	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	473	24	immersed	immerse	VBD
40439	473	25	in	in	IN
40439	473	26	the	the	DT
40439	473	27	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	473	28	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	473	29	,	,	,
40439	473	30	and	and	CC
40439	473	31	even	even	RB
40439	473	32	(	(	-LRB-
40439	473	33	though	though	IN
40439	473	34	somewhat	somewhat	RB
40439	473	35	less	less	RBR
40439	473	36	)	)	-RRB-
40439	473	37	in	in	IN
40439	473	38	the	the	DT
40439	473	39	Aristotelian	Aristotelian	NNP
40439	473	40	Treatise	Treatise	NNP
40439	473	41	De	De	NNP
40439	473	42	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	473	43	.	.	.
40439	474	1	Hence	hence	RB
40439	474	2	the	the	DT
40439	474	3	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	474	4	of	of	IN
40439	474	5	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	474	6	,	,	,
40439	474	7	obscurely	obscurely	RB
40439	474	8	announced	announce	VBD
40439	474	9	from	from	IN
40439	474	10	the	the	DT
40439	474	11	beginning	beginning	NN
40439	474	12	,	,	,
40439	474	13	ceased	cease	VBD
40439	474	14	to	to	TO
40439	474	15	be	be	VB
40439	474	16	understood	understand	VBN
40439	474	17	:	:	:
40439	474	18	the	the	DT
40439	474	19	solid	solid	JJ
40439	474	20	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	474	21	axis	axi	NNS
40439	474	22	of	of	IN
40439	474	23	the	the	DT
40439	474	24	Kosmos	Kosmos	NNP
40439	474	25	,	,	,
40439	474	26	assumed	assume	VBN
40439	474	27	without	without	IN
40439	474	28	being	be	VBG
40439	474	29	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	474	30	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	474	31	in	in	IN
40439	474	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	474	33	Timaeus	Timaeus	NNP
40439	474	34	,	,	,
40439	474	35	dropped	drop	VBD
40439	474	36	out	out	IN
40439	474	37	of	of	IN
40439	474	38	sight	sight	NN
40439	474	39	:	:	:
40439	474	40	the	the	DT
40439	474	41	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	474	42	of	of	IN
40439	474	43	the	the	DT
40439	474	44	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	474	45	of	of	IN
40439	474	46	the	the	DT
40439	474	47	earth	earth	NN
40439	474	48	was	be	VBD
40439	474	49	presented	present	VBN
40439	474	50	in	in	IN
40439	474	51	a	a	DT
40439	474	52	new	new	JJ
40439	474	53	point	point	NN
40439	474	54	of	of	IN
40439	474	55	view	view	NN
40439	474	56	,	,	,
40439	474	57	as	as	IN
40439	474	58	a	a	DT
40439	474	59	substitute	substitute	NN
40439	474	60	for	for	IN
40439	474	61	the	the	DT
40439	474	62	celestial	celestial	JJ
40439	474	63	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	474	64	.	.	.
40439	475	1	But	but	CC
40439	475	2	no	no	DT
40439	475	3	proper	proper	JJ
40439	475	4	note	note	NN
40439	475	5	was	be	VBD
40439	475	6	taken	take	VBN
40439	475	7	of	of	IN
40439	475	8	this	this	DT
40439	475	9	transition	transition	NN
40439	475	10	.	.	.
40439	476	1	The	the	DT
40439	476	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	476	3	of	of	IN
40439	476	4	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	476	5	was	be	VBD
40439	476	6	assumed	assume	VBN
40439	476	7	to	to	TO
40439	476	8	be	be	VB
40439	476	9	the	the	DT
40439	476	10	same	same	JJ
40439	476	11	as	as	IN
40439	476	12	that	that	DT
40439	476	13	of	of	IN
40439	476	14	Hicetas	Hicetas	NNP
40439	476	15	.	.	.
40439	477	1	When	when	WRB
40439	477	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	477	3	read	read	VBP
40439	477	4	Plutarch	Plutarch	NNP
40439	477	5	's	's	POS
40439	477	6	criticism	criticism	NN
40439	477	7	(	(	-LRB-
40439	477	8	Quæst	Quæst	NNP
40439	477	9	.	.	.
40439	478	1	Plat	Plat	NNP
40439	478	2	.	.	.
40439	479	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	479	2	1006	1006	CD
40439	479	3	C	C	NNP
40439	479	4	)	)	-RRB-
40439	479	5	upon	upon	IN
40439	479	6	the	the	DT
40439	479	7	word	word	NN
40439	479	8	[	[	-LRB-
40439	479	9	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	479	10	:	:	:
40439	479	11	i)llome	i)llome	NN
40439	479	12	/	/	SYM
40439	479	13	nên	nên	NNP
40439	479	14	]	]	-RRB-
40439	479	15	,	,	,
40439	479	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	479	17	see	see	VBP
40439	479	18	that	that	IN
40439	479	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	479	20	puts	put	VBZ
40439	479	21	to	to	IN
40439	479	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	479	23	the	the	DT
40439	479	24	question	question	NN
40439	479	25	thus--"Does	thus--"Does	NNP
40439	479	26	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	479	27	in	in	IN
40439	479	28	the	the	DT
40439	479	29	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	479	30	conceive	conceive	VB
40439	479	31	the	the	DT
40439	479	32	earth	earth	NN
40439	479	33	as	as	IN
40439	479	34	kept	keep	VBN
40439	479	35	together	together	RB
40439	479	36	and	and	CC
40439	479	37	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	479	38	--	--	:
40439	479	39	or	or	CC
40439	479	40	as	as	IN
40439	479	41	turning	turn	VBG
40439	479	42	round	round	RB
40439	479	43	and	and	CC
40439	479	44	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	479	45	,	,	,
40439	479	46	agreeably	agreeably	RB
40439	479	47	to	to	IN
40439	479	48	the	the	DT
40439	479	49	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
40439	479	50	theory	theory	NN
40439	479	51	of	of	IN
40439	479	52	Aristarchus	Aristarchus	NNP
40439	479	53	and	and	CC
40439	479	54	Seleukus	Seleukus	NNP
40439	479	55	?	?	.
40439	479	56	"	"	''
40439	480	1	Here	here	RB
40439	480	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	480	3	find	find	VBP
40439	480	4	that	that	IN
40439	480	5	Plutarch	plutarch	NN
40439	480	6	conceives	conceive	VBZ
40439	480	7	the	the	DT
40439	480	8	alternative	alternative	NN
40439	480	9	thus	thus	RB
40439	480	10	--	--	:
40439	480	11	Either	either	CC
40439	480	12	the	the	DT
40439	480	13	earth	earth	NN
40439	480	14	does	do	VBZ
40439	480	15	not	not	RB
40439	480	16	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	480	17	at	at	RB
40439	480	18	all	all	RB
40439	480	19	,	,	,
40439	480	20	or	or	CC
40439	480	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	480	22	revolves	revolve	VBZ
40439	480	23	as	as	IN
40439	480	24	Aristarchus	Aristarchus	NNP
40439	480	25	understood	understand	VBD
40439	480	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	480	27	.	.	.
40439	481	1	One	one	CD
40439	481	2	or	or	CC
40439	481	3	other	other	JJ
40439	481	4	of	of	IN
40439	481	5	these	these	DT
40439	481	6	two	two	CD
40439	481	7	positions	position	NNS
40439	481	8	must	must	MD
40439	481	9	have	have	VB
40439	481	10	been	be	VBN
40439	481	11	laid	lay	VBN
40439	481	12	down	down	RP
40439	481	13	by	by	IN
40439	481	14	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	481	15	in	in	IN
40439	481	16	the	the	DT
40439	481	17	Timæus.--So	Timæus.--So	NNP
40439	481	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	481	19	read	read	VBP
40439	481	20	in	in	IN
40439	481	21	Plutarch	Plutarch	NNP
40439	481	22	.	.	.
40439	482	1	But	but	CC
40439	482	2	the	the	DT
40439	482	3	fact	fact	NN
40439	482	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	482	5	,	,	,
40439	482	6	that	that	IN
40439	482	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	482	8	meant	mean	VBD
40439	482	9	neither	neither	CC
40439	482	10	the	the	DT
40439	482	11	one	one	CD
40439	482	12	nor	nor	CC
40439	482	13	the	the	DT
40439	482	14	other	other	JJ
40439	482	15	.	.	.
40439	483	1	The	the	DT
40439	483	2	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	483	3	of	of	IN
40439	483	4	the	the	DT
40439	483	5	earth	earth	NN
40439	483	6	round	round	IN
40439	483	7	the	the	DT
40439	483	8	solid	solid	JJ
40439	483	9	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	483	10	axis	axi	NNS
40439	483	11	,	,	,
40439	483	12	which	which	WDT
40439	483	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	483	14	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	483	15	in	in	IN
40439	483	16	the	the	DT
40439	483	17	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	483	18	--	--	:
40439	483	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	483	20	a	a	DT
40439	483	21	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
40439	483	22	utterly	utterly	RB
40439	483	23	different	different	JJ
40439	483	24	from	from	IN
40439	483	25	the	the	DT
40439	483	26	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	483	27	of	of	IN
40439	483	28	the	the	DT
40439	483	29	earth	earth	NN
40439	483	30	as	as	IN
40439	483	31	a	a	DT
40439	483	32	free	free	JJ
40439	483	33	body	body	NN
40439	483	34	round	round	IN
40439	483	35	the	the	DT
40439	483	36	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
40439	483	37	line	line	NN
40439	483	38	called	call	VBD
40439	483	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	483	40	own	own	JJ
40439	483	41	axis	axi	NNS
40439	483	42	,	,	,
40439	483	43	which	which	WDT
40439	483	44	was	be	VBD
40439	483	45	the	the	DT
40439	483	46	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	483	47	of	of	IN
40439	483	48	Aristarchus	Aristarchus	NNP
40439	483	49	.	.	.
40439	484	1	When	when	WRB
40439	484	2	expositors	expositor	NNS
40439	484	3	in	in	IN
40439	484	4	Plutarch	Plutarch	NNP
40439	484	5	's	's	POS
40439	484	6	day	day	NN
40439	484	7	,	,	,
40439	484	8	and	and	CC
40439	484	9	since	since	IN
40439	484	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	484	11	day	day	NN
40439	484	12	,	,	,
40439	484	13	enquired	enquire	VBD
40439	484	14	whether	whether	IN
40439	484	15	or	or	CC
40439	484	16	not	not	RB
40439	484	17	the	the	DT
40439	484	18	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	484	19	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	484	20	affirmed	affirm	VBD
40439	484	21	the	the	DT
40439	484	22	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	484	23	of	of	IN
40439	484	24	the	the	DT
40439	484	25	earth	earth	NN
40439	484	26	,	,	,
40439	484	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	484	28	meant	mean	VBD
40439	484	29	to	to	TO
40439	484	30	designate	designate	VB
40439	484	31	the	the	DT
40439	484	32	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	484	33	of	of	IN
40439	484	34	the	the	DT
40439	484	35	earth	earth	NN
40439	484	36	in	in	IN
40439	484	37	the	the	DT
40439	484	38	sense	sense	NN
40439	484	39	of	of	IN
40439	484	40	Aristarchus	Aristarchus	NNP
40439	484	41	,	,	,
40439	484	42	and	and	CC
40439	484	43	in	in	IN
40439	484	44	the	the	DT
40439	484	45	sense	sense	NN
40439	484	46	in	in	IN
40439	484	47	which	which	WDT
40439	484	48	modern	modern	JJ
40439	484	49	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	484	50	understands	understand	VBZ
40439	484	51	that	that	IN
40439	484	52	capital	capital	NN
40439	484	53	fact	fact	NN
40439	484	54	.	.	.
40439	485	1	Now	now	RB
40439	485	2	speaking	speak	VBG
40439	485	3	the	the	DT
40439	485	4	language	language	NN
40439	485	5	of	of	IN
40439	485	6	modern	modern	JJ
40439	485	7	astronomy	astronomy	NN
40439	485	8	,	,	,
40439	485	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	485	10	think	think	VBP
40439	485	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	485	12	certain	certain	JJ
40439	485	13	that	that	IN
40439	485	14	the	the	DT
40439	485	15	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	485	16	of	of	IN
40439	485	17	the	the	DT
40439	485	18	earth	earth	NN
40439	485	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	485	20	_	_	NNP
40439	485	21	not	not	RB
40439	485	22	_	_	NNP
40439	485	23	to	to	TO
40439	485	24	be	be	VB
40439	485	25	found	find	VBN
40439	485	26	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	485	27	in	in	IN
40439	485	28	the	the	DT
40439	485	29	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	485	30	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	485	31	;	;	:
40439	485	32	and	and	CC
40439	485	33	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	485	34	agree	agree	VBP
40439	485	35	with	with	IN
40439	485	36	M.	M.	NNP
40439	485	37	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	485	38	when	when	WRB
40439	485	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	485	40	says	say	VBZ
40439	485	41	(	(	-LRB-
40439	485	42	Untersuch	Untersuch	NNP
40439	485	43	.	.	.
40439	486	1	p.	p.	NN
40439	486	2	77	77	CD
40439	486	3	)	)	-RRB-
40439	486	4	,	,	,
40439	486	5	"	"	``
40439	486	6	Granting	grant	VBG
40439	486	7	that	that	IN
40439	486	8	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	486	9	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
40439	486	10	to	to	IN
40439	486	11	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	486	12	the	the	DT
40439	486	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	486	14	of	of	IN
40439	486	15	the	the	DT
40439	486	16	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	486	17	of	of	IN
40439	486	18	the	the	DT
40439	486	19	earth	earth	NN
40439	486	20	,	,	,
40439	486	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	486	22	at	at	RB
40439	486	23	least	least	JJS
40439	486	24	did	do	VBD
40439	486	25	not	not	RB
40439	486	26	ascribe	ascribe	VB
40439	486	27	to	to	IN
40439	486	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	486	29	the	the	DT
40439	486	30	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	486	31	as	as	IN
40439	486	32	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	486	33	assumes	assume	VBZ
40439	486	34	,	,	,
40439	486	35	and	and	CC
40439	486	36	as	as	RB
40439	486	37	now	now	RB
40439	486	38	understood	understand	VBN
40439	486	39	.	.	.
40439	486	40	"	"	''
40439	487	1	As	as	IN
40439	487	2	between	between	IN
40439	487	3	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	487	4	--	--	:
40439	487	5	who	who	WP
40439	487	6	holds	hold	VBZ
40439	487	7	that	that	IN
40439	487	8	the	the	DT
40439	487	9	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	487	10	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	487	11	affirms	affirm	VBZ
40439	487	12	the	the	DT
40439	487	13	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	487	14	of	of	IN
40439	487	15	the	the	DT
40439	487	16	earth	earth	NN
40439	487	17	,	,	,
40439	487	18	and	and	CC
40439	487	19	that	that	IN
40439	487	20	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	487	21	ascribes	ascribe	VBZ
40439	487	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	487	23	to	to	IN
40439	487	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	487	25	,	,	,
40439	487	26	in	in	IN
40439	487	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	487	28	sense	sense	NN
40439	487	29	of	of	IN
40439	487	30	the	the	DT
40439	487	31	words	word	NNS
40439	487	32	--	--	:
40439	487	33	and	and	CC
40439	487	34	M.	M.	NNP
40439	487	35	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	487	36	,	,	,
40439	487	37	who	who	WP
40439	487	38	denies	deny	VBZ
40439	487	39	this	this	DT
40439	487	40	--	--	:
40439	487	41	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	487	42	stand	stand	VBP
40439	487	43	with	with	IN
40439	487	44	the	the	DT
40439	487	45	latter	latter	JJ
40439	487	46	for	for	IN
40439	487	47	the	the	DT
40439	487	48	negative	negative	NN
40439	487	49	.	.	.
40439	488	1	But	but	CC
40439	488	2	when	when	WRB
40439	488	3	M.	M.	NNP
40439	488	4	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	488	5	assumes	assume	VBZ
40439	488	6	that	that	IN
40439	488	7	the	the	DT
40439	488	8	only	only	JJ
40439	488	9	alternative	alternative	JJ
40439	488	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	488	11	is	be	VBZ
40439	488	12	the	the	DT
40439	488	13	immobility	immobility	NN
40439	488	14	of	of	IN
40439	488	15	the	the	DT
40439	488	16	earth	earth	NN
40439	488	17	,	,	,
40439	488	18	and	and	CC
40439	488	19	tries	try	VBZ
40439	488	20	to	to	TO
40439	488	21	show	show	VB
40439	488	22	that	that	IN
40439	488	23	this	this	DT
40439	488	24	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	488	25	is	be	VBZ
40439	488	26	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	488	27	in	in	IN
40439	488	28	the	the	DT
40439	488	29	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	488	30	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	488	31	--	--	:
40439	488	32	nay	nay	NN
40439	488	33	,	,	,
40439	488	34	that	that	IN
40439	488	35	no	no	DT
40439	488	36	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	488	37	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	488	38	_	_	NNP
40439	488	39	can	can	MD
40439	488	40	_	_	NNP
40439	488	41	be	be	VB
40439	488	42	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
40439	488	43	,	,	,
40439	488	44	because	because	IN
40439	488	45	the	the	DT
40439	488	46	discourse	discourse	NN
40439	488	47	expressly	expressly	RB
40439	488	48	announces	announce	VBZ
40439	488	49	the	the	DT
40439	488	50	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	488	51	of	of	IN
40439	488	52	the	the	DT
40439	488	53	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	488	54	heaven	heaven	NNP
40439	488	55	in	in	IN
40439	488	56	twenty	twenty	CD
40439	488	57	-	-	HYPH
40439	488	58	four	four	CD
40439	488	59	hours	hour	NNS
40439	488	60	--	--	:
40439	488	61	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	488	62	am	be	VBP
40439	488	63	compelled	compel	VBN
40439	488	64	to	to	IN
40439	488	65	dissent	dissent	NN
40439	488	66	from	from	IN
40439	488	67	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	488	68	as	as	IN
40439	488	69	to	to	IN
40439	488	70	the	the	DT
40439	488	71	conclusion	conclusion	NN
40439	488	72	,	,	,
40439	488	73	and	and	CC
40439	488	74	to	to	TO
40439	488	75	deny	deny	VB
40439	488	76	the	the	DT
40439	488	77	cogency	cogency	NN
40439	488	78	of	of	IN
40439	488	79	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	488	80	proof	proof	NN
40439	488	81	.	.	.
40439	489	1	M.	M.	NNP
40439	489	2	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	489	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	489	4	hardly	hardly	RB
40439	489	5	asked	ask	VBN
40439	489	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	489	7	the	the	DT
40439	489	8	question	question	NN
40439	489	9	,	,	,
40439	489	10	whether	whether	IN
40439	489	11	there	there	EX
40439	489	12	was	be	VBD
40439	489	13	not	not	RB
40439	489	14	some	some	DT
40439	489	15	other	other	JJ
40439	489	16	sense	sense	NN
40439	489	17	in	in	IN
40439	489	18	which	which	WDT
40439	489	19	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	489	20	might	may	MD
40439	489	21	have	have	VB
40439	489	22	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	489	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	489	24	in	in	IN
40439	489	25	the	the	DT
40439	489	26	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	489	27	.	.	.
40439	490	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	490	2	have	have	VBP
40439	490	3	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	490	4	to	to	TO
40439	490	5	show	show	VB
40439	490	6	that	that	IN
40439	490	7	there	there	EX
40439	490	8	was	be	VBD
40439	490	9	another	another	DT
40439	490	10	sense	sense	NN
40439	490	11	;	;	:
40439	490	12	that	that	IN
40439	490	13	there	there	EX
40439	490	14	are	be	VBP
40439	490	15	good	good	JJ
40439	490	16	analogies	analogy	NNS
40439	490	17	in	in	IN
40439	490	18	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	490	19	to	to	TO
40439	490	20	justify	justify	VB
40439	490	21	the	the	DT
40439	490	22	belief	belief	NN
40439	490	23	that	that	IN
40439	490	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
40439	490	25	intended	intend	VBD
40439	490	26	to	to	TO
40439	490	27	affirm	affirm	VB
40439	490	28	the	the	DT
40439	490	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	490	30	in	in	IN
40439	490	31	that	that	DT
40439	490	32	other	other	JJ
40439	490	33	sense	sense	NN
40439	490	34	;	;	:
40439	490	35	and	and	CC
40439	490	36	that	that	IN
40439	490	37	the	the	DT
40439	490	38	comments	comment	NNS
40439	490	39	of	of	IN
40439	490	40	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	490	41	--	--	:
40439	490	42	while	while	IN
40439	490	43	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
40439	490	44	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
40439	490	45	,	,	,
40439	490	46	if	if	IN
40439	490	47	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	490	48	thus	thus	RB
40439	490	49	understand	understand	VBP
40439	490	50	the	the	DT
40439	490	51	passage	passage	NN
40439	490	52	in	in	IN
40439	490	53	the	the	DT
40439	490	54	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	490	55	--	--	:
40439	490	56	become	become	VB
40439	490	57	either	either	CC
40439	490	58	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
40439	490	59	,	,	,
40439	490	60	dishonest	dishonest	JJ
40439	490	61	,	,	,
40439	490	62	or	or	CC
40439	490	63	absurd	absurd	JJ
40439	490	64	,	,	,
40439	490	65	if	if	IN
40439	490	66	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	490	67	construe	construe	VBP
40439	490	68	the	the	DT
40439	490	69	passage	passage	NN
40439	490	70	as	as	IN
40439	490	71	signifying	signify	VBG
40439	490	72	either	either	CC
40439	490	73	what	what	WP
40439	490	74	is	be	VBZ
40439	490	75	maintained	maintain	VBN
40439	490	76	by	by	IN
40439	490	77	M.	M.	NNP
40439	490	78	Boeckh	Boeckh	NNP
40439	490	79	or	or	CC
40439	490	80	what	what	WP
40439	490	81	is	be	VBZ
40439	490	82	maintained	maintain	VBN
40439	490	83	by	by	IN
40439	490	84	Gruppe	Gruppe	NNP
40439	490	85	.	.	.
40439	491	1	The	the	DT
40439	491	2	eminent	eminent	JJ
40439	491	3	critics	critic	NNS
40439	491	4	,	,	,
40439	491	5	whose	whose	WP$
40439	491	6	opinions	opinion	NNS
40439	491	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	491	8	here	here	RB
40439	491	9	controvert	controvert	VBP
40439	491	10	,	,	,
40439	491	11	have	have	VBP
40439	491	12	been	be	VBN
40439	491	13	apparently	apparently	RB
40439	491	14	misled	mislead	VBN
40439	491	15	by	by	IN
40439	491	16	the	the	DT
40439	491	17	superior	superior	JJ
40439	491	18	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	491	19	acquirements	acquirement	NNS
40439	491	20	of	of	IN
40439	491	21	the	the	DT
40439	491	22	present	present	JJ
40439	491	23	age	age	NN
40439	491	24	,	,	,
40439	491	25	and	and	CC
40439	491	26	have	have	VBP
40439	491	27	too	too	RB
40439	491	28	hastily	hastily	RB
40439	491	29	made	make	VBN
40439	491	30	the	the	DT
40439	491	31	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
40439	491	32	exigencies	exigency	NNS
40439	491	33	of	of	IN
40439	491	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	491	35	own	own	JJ
40439	491	36	minds	mind	NNS
40439	491	37	a	a	DT
40439	491	38	standard	standard	NN
40439	491	39	for	for	IN
40439	491	40	all	all	DT
40439	491	41	other	other	JJ
40439	491	42	minds	mind	NNS
40439	491	43	,	,	,
40439	491	44	in	in	IN
40439	491	45	different	different	JJ
40439	491	46	ages	age	NNS
40439	491	47	as	as	RB
40439	491	48	well	well	RB
40439	491	49	as	as	IN
40439	491	50	in	in	IN
40439	491	51	different	different	JJ
40439	491	52	states	state	NNS
40439	491	53	of	of	IN
40439	491	54	cultivation	cultivation	NN
40439	491	55	.	.	.
40439	492	1	The	the	DT
40439	492	2	question	question	NN
40439	492	3	before	before	IN
40439	492	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	492	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	492	6	,	,	,
40439	492	7	not	not	RB
40439	492	8	what	what	WDT
40439	492	9	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
40439	492	10	are	be	VBP
40439	492	11	scientifically	scientifically	RB
40439	492	12	true	true	JJ
40439	492	13	or	or	CC
40439	492	14	scientifically	scientifically	RB
40439	492	15	compatible	compatible	JJ
40439	492	16	with	with	IN
40439	492	17	each	each	DT
40439	492	18	other	other	JJ
40439	492	19	,	,	,
40439	492	20	but	but	CC
40439	492	21	what	what	WDT
40439	492	22	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
40439	492	23	were	be	VBD
40439	492	24	affirmed	affirm	VBN
40439	492	25	or	or	CC
40439	492	26	implied	imply	VBN
40439	492	27	by	by	IN
40439	492	28	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	492	29	.	.	.
40439	493	1	In	in	IN
40439	493	2	interpreting	interpret	VBG
40439	493	3	him	-PRON-	PRP
40439	493	4	,	,	,
40439	493	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	493	6	are	be	VBP
40439	493	7	required	require	VBN
40439	493	8	to	to	TO
40439	493	9	keep	keep	VB
40439	493	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	493	11	minds	mind	NNS
40439	493	12	independent	independent	JJ
40439	493	13	of	of	IN
40439	493	14	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
40439	493	15	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
40439	493	16	theories	theory	NNS
40439	493	17	.	.	.
40439	494	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
40439	494	2	must	must	MD
40439	494	3	look	look	VB
40439	494	4	,	,	,
40439	494	5	first	first	RB
40439	494	6	and	and	CC
40439	494	7	chiefly	chiefly	RB
40439	494	8	,	,	,
40439	494	9	to	to	IN
40439	494	10	what	what	WP
40439	494	11	is	be	VBZ
40439	494	12	said	say	VBN
40439	494	13	by	by	IN
40439	494	14	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	494	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
40439	494	16	;	;	:
40439	494	17	next	next	RB
40439	494	18	,	,	,
40439	494	19	if	if	IN
40439	494	20	that	that	DT
40439	494	21	be	be	VB
40439	494	22	obscure	obscure	JJ
40439	494	23	,	,	,
40439	494	24	to	to	IN
40439	494	25	the	the	DT
40439	494	26	construction	construction	NN
40439	494	27	and	and	CC
40439	494	28	comments	comment	NNS
40439	494	29	of	of	IN
40439	494	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	494	31	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
40439	494	32	so	so	RB
40439	494	33	far	far	RB
40439	494	34	as	as	IN
40439	494	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	494	36	are	be	VBP
40439	494	37	before	before	IN
40439	494	38	us	-PRON-	PRP
40439	494	39	.	.	.
40439	495	1	In	in	IN
40439	495	2	no	no	DT
40439	495	3	case	case	NN
40439	495	4	is	be	VBZ
40439	495	5	this	this	DT
40439	495	6	more	more	RBR
40439	495	7	essential	essential	JJ
40439	495	8	than	than	IN
40439	495	9	in	in	IN
40439	495	10	the	the	DT
40439	495	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	495	12	of	of	IN
40439	495	13	the	the	DT
40439	495	14	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	495	15	of	of	IN
40439	495	16	the	the	DT
40439	495	17	earth	earth	NN
40439	495	18	,	,	,
40439	495	19	which	which	WDT
40439	495	20	in	in	IN
40439	495	21	the	the	DT
40439	495	22	modern	modern	JJ
40439	495	23	mind	mind	NN
40439	495	24	has	have	VBZ
40439	495	25	risen	rise	VBN
40439	495	26	to	to	IN
40439	495	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	495	28	proper	proper	JJ
40439	495	29	rank	rank	NN
40439	495	30	in	in	IN
40439	495	31	scientific	scientific	JJ
40439	495	32	importance	importance	NN
40439	495	33	,	,	,
40439	495	34	and	and	CC
40439	495	35	has	have	VBZ
40439	495	36	become	become	VBN
40439	495	37	connected	connected	JJ
40439	495	38	with	with	IN
40439	495	39	collateral	collateral	JJ
40439	495	40	consequences	consequence	NNS
40439	495	41	and	and	CC
40439	495	42	associations	association	NNS
40439	495	43	foreign	foreign	JJ
40439	495	44	to	to	IN
40439	495	45	the	the	DT
40439	495	46	ideas	idea	NNS
40439	495	47	of	of	IN
40439	495	48	the	the	DT
40439	495	49	ancient	ancient	JJ
40439	495	50	Pythagoreans	Pythagoreans	NNPS
40439	495	51	,	,	,
40439	495	52	or	or	CC
40439	495	53	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	495	54	,	,	,
40439	495	55	or	or	CC
40439	495	56	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	495	57	.	.	.
40439	496	1	Unless	unless	IN
40439	496	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	496	3	disengage	disengage	VBP
40439	496	4	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
40439	496	5	from	from	IN
40439	496	6	these	these	DT
40439	496	7	more	more	JJR
40439	496	8	recent	recent	JJ
40439	496	9	associations	association	NNS
40439	496	10	,	,	,
40439	496	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	496	12	can	can	MD
40439	496	13	not	not	RB
40439	496	14	properly	properly	RB
40439	496	15	understand	understand	VB
40439	496	16	the	the	DT
40439	496	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	496	18	as	as	IN
40439	496	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	496	20	stands	stand	VBZ
40439	496	21	in	in	IN
40439	496	22	the	the	DT
40439	496	23	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	496	24	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	496	25	.	.	.
40439	497	1	This	this	DT
40439	497	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	497	3	,	,	,
40439	497	4	as	as	IN
40439	497	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	497	6	have	have	VBP
40439	497	7	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
40439	497	8	to	to	TO
40439	497	9	explain	explain	VB
40439	497	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	497	11	,	,	,
40439	497	12	leads	lead	VBZ
40439	497	13	to	to	IN
40439	497	14	an	an	DT
40439	497	15	instructive	instructive	JJ
40439	497	16	contrast	contrast	NN
40439	497	17	between	between	IN
40439	497	18	the	the	DT
40439	497	19	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	497	20	theories	theory	NNS
40439	497	21	of	of	IN
40439	497	22	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	497	23	(	(	-LRB-
40439	497	24	in	in	IN
40439	497	25	the	the	DT
40439	497	26	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	497	27	)	)	-RRB-
40439	497	28	and	and	CC
40439	497	29	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	497	30	.	.	.
40439	498	1	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	498	2	conceives	conceive	VBZ
40439	498	3	the	the	DT
40439	498	4	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	498	5	as	as	IN
40439	498	6	one	one	CD
40439	498	7	animated	animated	JJ
40439	498	8	and	and	CC
40439	498	9	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
40439	498	10	being	being	NN
40439	498	11	or	or	CC
40439	498	12	god	god	NNP
40439	498	13	,	,	,
40439	498	14	composed	compose	VBN
40439	498	15	of	of	IN
40439	498	16	body	body	NN
40439	498	17	and	and	CC
40439	498	18	soul	soul	NN
40439	498	19	.	.	.
40439	499	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	499	2	body	body	NN
40439	499	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	499	4	moved	move	VBN
40439	499	5	and	and	CC
40439	499	6	governed	govern	VBN
40439	499	7	by	by	IN
40439	499	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	499	9	soul	soul	NN
40439	499	10	,	,	,
40439	499	11	which	which	WDT
40439	499	12	is	be	VBZ
40439	499	13	fixed	fix	VBN
40439	499	14	or	or	CC
40439	499	15	rooted	root	VBN
40439	499	16	in	in	IN
40439	499	17	the	the	DT
40439	499	18	centre	centre	NN
40439	499	19	,	,	,
40439	499	20	but	but	CC
40439	499	21	stretches	stretch	VBZ
40439	499	22	to	to	IN
40439	499	23	the	the	DT
40439	499	24	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	499	25	on	on	IN
40439	499	26	all	all	DT
40439	499	27	sides	side	NNS
40439	499	28	,	,	,
40439	499	29	as	as	RB
40439	499	30	well	well	RB
40439	499	31	as	as	IN
40439	499	32	all	all	DT
40439	499	33	round	round	IN
40439	499	34	the	the	DT
40439	499	35	exterior	exterior	NN
40439	499	36	.	.	.
40439	500	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	500	2	has	have	VBZ
40439	500	3	a	a	DT
40439	500	4	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
40439	500	5	movement	movement	NN
40439	500	6	of	of	IN
40439	500	7	circular	circular	JJ
40439	500	8	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	500	9	in	in	IN
40439	500	10	the	the	DT
40439	500	11	same	same	JJ
40439	500	12	unchanged	unchanged	JJ
40439	500	13	place	place	NN
40439	500	14	,	,	,
40439	500	15	which	which	WDT
40439	500	16	is	be	VBZ
40439	500	17	the	the	DT
40439	500	18	sort	sort	NN
40439	500	19	of	of	IN
40439	500	20	movement	movement	NN
40439	500	21	most	most	RBS
40439	500	22	worthy	worthy	JJ
40439	500	23	of	of	IN
40439	500	24	a	a	DT
40439	500	25	rational	rational	JJ
40439	500	26	and	and	CC
40439	500	27	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
40439	500	28	being	being	NN
40439	500	29	.	.	.
40439	501	1	The	the	DT
40439	501	2	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	501	3	of	of	IN
40439	501	4	the	the	DT
40439	501	5	exterior	exterior	NNP
40439	501	6	or	or	CC
40439	501	7	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	501	8	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	501	9	(	(	-LRB-
40439	501	10	Circle	Circle	NNP
40439	501	11	of	of	IN
40439	501	12	the	the	DT
40439	501	13	Same	same	JJ
40439	501	14	)	)	-RRB-
40439	501	15	depend	depend	VBP
40439	501	16	on	on	RB
40439	501	17	and	and	CC
40439	501	18	are	be	VBP
40439	501	19	determined	determine	VBN
40439	501	20	by	by	IN
40439	501	21	the	the	DT
40439	501	22	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	501	23	of	of	IN
40439	501	24	the	the	DT
40439	501	25	solid	solid	JJ
40439	501	26	cylinder	cylinder	NN
40439	501	27	or	or	CC
40439	501	28	axis	axis	NNP
40439	501	29	,	,	,
40439	501	30	which	which	WDT
40439	501	31	traverses	traverse	VBZ
40439	501	32	the	the	DT
40439	501	33	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	501	34	in	in	IN
40439	501	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	501	36	whole	whole	JJ
40439	501	37	diameter	diameter	NN
40439	501	38	.	.	.
40439	502	1	Besides	besides	IN
40439	502	2	these	these	DT
40439	502	3	,	,	,
40439	502	4	there	there	EX
40439	502	5	are	be	VBP
40439	502	6	various	various	JJ
40439	502	7	interior	interior	JJ
40439	502	8	spheres	sphere	NNS
40439	502	9	or	or	CC
40439	502	10	circles	circle	NNS
40439	502	11	(	(	-LRB-
40439	502	12	Circles	Circles	NNP
40439	502	13	of	of	IN
40439	502	14	the	the	DT
40439	502	15	Different	Different	NNP
40439	502	16	)	)	-RRB-
40439	502	17	,	,	,
40439	502	18	which	which	WDT
40439	502	19	rotate	rotate	VBP
40439	502	20	by	by	IN
40439	502	21	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	502	22	and	and	CC
40439	502	23	variable	variable	JJ
40439	502	24	impulses	impulse	NNS
40439	502	25	in	in	IN
40439	502	26	a	a	DT
40439	502	27	direction	direction	NN
40439	502	28	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	502	29	to	to	IN
40439	502	30	the	the	DT
40439	502	31	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
40439	502	32	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	502	33	.	.	.
40439	503	1	This	this	DT
40439	503	2	latter	latter	NN
40439	503	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	503	4	so	so	RB
40439	503	5	much	much	RB
40439	503	6	more	more	RBR
40439	503	7	powerful	powerful	JJ
40439	503	8	than	than	IN
40439	503	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	503	10	,	,	,
40439	503	11	that	that	IN
40439	503	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	503	13	carries	carry	VBZ
40439	503	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	503	15	all	all	DT
40439	503	16	round	round	NN
40439	503	17	with	with	IN
40439	503	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	503	19	;	;	:
40439	503	20	yet	yet	CC
40439	503	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
40439	503	22	make	make	VBP
40439	503	23	good	good	JJ
40439	503	24	,	,	,
40439	503	25	to	to	IN
40439	503	26	a	a	DT
40439	503	27	certain	certain	JJ
40439	503	28	extent	extent	NN
40439	503	29	,	,	,
40439	503	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	503	31	own	own	JJ
40439	503	32	special	special	JJ
40439	503	33	opposite	opposite	JJ
40439	503	34	movement	movement	NN
40439	503	35	,	,	,
40439	503	36	which	which	WDT
40439	503	37	causes	cause	VBZ
40439	503	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	503	39	positions	position	NNS
40439	503	40	to	to	TO
40439	503	41	be	be	VB
40439	503	42	ever	ever	RB
40439	503	43	changing	change	VBG
40439	503	44	,	,	,
40439	503	45	and	and	CC
40439	503	46	the	the	DT
40439	503	47	whole	whole	JJ
40439	503	48	system	system	NN
40439	503	49	to	to	TO
40439	503	50	be	be	VB
40439	503	51	complicated	complicate	VBN
40439	503	52	.	.	.
40439	504	1	But	but	CC
40439	504	2	the	the	DT
40439	504	3	grand	grand	JJ
40439	504	4	capital	capital	NN
40439	504	5	,	,	,
40439	504	6	uniform	uniform	NN
40439	504	7	,	,	,
40439	504	8	overpowering	overpowering	JJ
40439	504	9	,	,	,
40439	504	10	movement	movement	NN
40439	504	11	of	of	IN
40439	504	12	the	the	DT
40439	504	13	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	504	14	,	,	,
40439	504	15	consists	consist	VBZ
40439	504	16	in	in	IN
40439	504	17	the	the	DT
40439	504	18	revolution	revolution	NN
40439	504	19	of	of	IN
40439	504	20	the	the	DT
40439	504	21	solid	solid	JJ
40439	504	22	axis	axi	NNS
40439	504	23	,	,	,
40439	504	24	which	which	WDT
40439	504	25	determines	determine	VBZ
40439	504	26	that	that	DT
40439	504	27	of	of	IN
40439	504	28	the	the	DT
40439	504	29	exterior	exterior	NNP
40439	504	30	sidereal	sidereal	NN
40439	504	31	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	504	32	.	.	.
40439	505	1	The	the	DT
40439	505	2	impulse	impulse	NN
40439	505	3	or	or	CC
40439	505	4	stimulus	stimulus	NN
40439	505	5	to	to	IN
40439	505	6	this	this	DT
40439	505	7	movement	movement	NN
40439	505	8	comes	come	VBZ
40439	505	9	from	from	IN
40439	505	10	the	the	DT
40439	505	11	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	505	12	soul	soul	NN
40439	505	13	,	,	,
40439	505	14	which	which	WDT
40439	505	15	has	have	VBZ
40439	505	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	505	17	root	root	NN
40439	505	18	in	in	IN
40439	505	19	the	the	DT
40439	505	20	centre	centre	NN
40439	505	21	.	.	.
40439	506	1	Just	just	RB
40439	506	2	at	at	IN
40439	506	3	this	this	DT
40439	506	4	point	point	NN
40439	506	5	is	be	VBZ
40439	506	6	situated	situate	VBN
40439	506	7	the	the	DT
40439	506	8	earth	earth	NN
40439	506	9	,	,	,
40439	506	10	"	"	''
40439	506	11	the	the	DT
40439	506	12	oldest	old	JJS
40439	506	13	and	and	CC
40439	506	14	most	most	RBS
40439	506	15	venerable	venerable	JJ
40439	506	16	of	of	IN
40439	506	17	intra	intra	JJ
40439	506	18	-	-	JJ
40439	506	19	kosmic	kosmic	JJ
40439	506	20	deities	deity	NNS
40439	506	21	,	,	,
40439	506	22	"	"	''
40439	506	23	packed	pack	VBN
40439	506	24	round	round	IN
40439	506	25	the	the	DT
40439	506	26	centre	centre	NN
40439	506	27	of	of	IN
40439	506	28	the	the	DT
40439	506	29	axis	axis	NN
40439	506	30	,	,	,
40439	506	31	and	and	CC
40439	506	32	having	have	VBG
40439	506	33	for	for	IN
40439	506	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	506	35	function	function	NN
40439	506	36	to	to	TO
40439	506	37	guard	guard	VB
40439	506	38	and	and	CC
40439	506	39	regulate	regulate	VB
40439	506	40	those	those	DT
40439	506	41	revolutions	revolution	NNS
40439	506	42	of	of	IN
40439	506	43	the	the	DT
40439	506	44	axis	axis	NN
40439	506	45	,	,	,
40439	506	46	and	and	CC
40439	506	47	through	through	IN
40439	506	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	506	49	those	those	DT
40439	506	50	of	of	IN
40439	506	51	the	the	DT
40439	506	52	outer	outer	JJ
40439	506	53	sphere	sphere	NN
40439	506	54	,	,	,
40439	506	55	on	on	IN
40439	506	56	which	which	WDT
40439	506	57	the	the	DT
40439	506	58	succession	succession	NN
40439	506	59	of	of	IN
40439	506	60	day	day	NN
40439	506	61	and	and	CC
40439	506	62	night	night	NN
40439	506	63	depends	depend	VBZ
40439	506	64	--	--	:
40439	506	65	as	as	RB
40439	506	66	well	well	RB
40439	506	67	as	as	IN
40439	506	68	to	to	IN
40439	506	69	nurse	nurse	JJ
40439	506	70	mankind	mankind	NN
40439	506	71	.	.	.
40439	507	1	In	in	IN
40439	507	2	all	all	PDT
40439	507	3	this	this	DT
40439	507	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	507	5	see	see	VBP
40439	507	6	that	that	IN
40439	507	7	the	the	DT
40439	507	8	ruling	rule	VBG
40439	507	9	principle	principle	NN
40439	507	10	and	and	CC
40439	507	11	force	force	NN
40439	507	12	of	of	IN
40439	507	13	the	the	DT
40439	507	14	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	507	15	(	(	-LRB-
40439	507	16	[	[	-LRB-
40439	507	17	Greek	Greek	NNP
40439	507	18	:	:	:
40439	507	19	to\	to\	NN
40439	507	20	ê(gemoniko\n	ê(gemoniko\n	NNP
40439	507	21	tou=	tou=	NNP
40439	507	22	ko	ko	NNP
40439	507	23	/	/	SYM
40439	507	24	smou	smou	NNP
40439	507	25	]	]	-RRB-
40439	507	26	)	)	-RRB-
40439	507	27	is	be	VBZ
40439	507	28	made	make	VBN
40439	507	29	to	to	TO
40439	507	30	dwell	dwell	VB
40439	507	31	in	in	RB
40439	507	32	and	and	CC
40439	507	33	emanate	emanate	VB
40439	507	34	from	from	IN
40439	507	35	_	_	NNP
40439	507	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	507	37	centre	centre	NN
40439	507	38	_	_	NNP
40439	507	39	.	.	.
40439	508	1	When	when	WRB
40439	508	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	508	3	come	come	VBP
40439	508	4	to	to	IN
40439	508	5	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	508	6	,	,	,
40439	508	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
40439	508	8	find	find	VBP
40439	508	9	that	that	IN
40439	508	10	the	the	DT
40439	508	11	ruling	rule	VBG
40439	508	12	principle	principle	NN
40439	508	13	or	or	CC
40439	508	14	force	force	NN
40439	508	15	of	of	IN
40439	508	16	the	the	DT
40439	508	17	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	508	18	is	be	VBZ
40439	508	19	placed	place	VBN
40439	508	20	,	,	,
40439	508	21	not	not	RB
40439	508	22	in	in	IN
40439	508	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	508	24	centre	centre	NN
40439	508	25	,	,	,
40439	508	26	but	but	CC
40439	508	27	in	in	IN
40439	508	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	508	29	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	508	30	.	.	.
40439	509	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
40439	509	2	recognises	recognise	VBZ
40439	509	3	no	no	DT
40439	509	4	solid	solid	JJ
40439	509	5	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	509	6	axis	axi	NNS
40439	509	7	traversing	traverse	VBG
40439	509	8	the	the	DT
40439	509	9	whole	whole	JJ
40439	509	10	diameter	diameter	NN
40439	509	11	of	of	IN
40439	509	12	the	the	DT
40439	509	13	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	509	14	The	the	DT
40439	509	15	interior	interior	NN
40439	509	16	of	of	IN
40439	509	17	the	the	DT
40439	509	18	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	509	19	is	be	VBZ
40439	509	20	occupied	occupy	VBN
40439	509	21	by	by	IN
40439	509	22	the	the	DT
40439	509	23	four	four	CD
40439	509	24	elements	element	NNS
40439	509	25	--	--	:
40439	509	26	earth	earth	NN
40439	509	27	,	,	,
40439	509	28	water	water	NN
40439	509	29	,	,	,
40439	509	30	air	air	NN
40439	509	31	,	,	,
40439	509	32	fire	fire	NN
40439	509	33	--	--	:
40439	509	34	neither	neither	DT
40439	509	35	of	of	IN
40439	509	36	which	which	WDT
40439	509	37	can	can	MD
40439	509	38	revolve	revolve	VB
40439	509	39	except	except	IN
40439	509	40	by	by	IN
40439	509	41	violence	violence	NN
40439	509	42	or	or	CC
40439	509	43	under	under	IN
40439	509	44	the	the	DT
40439	509	45	pressure	pressure	NN
40439	509	46	of	of	IN
40439	509	47	extraneous	extraneous	JJ
40439	509	48	force	force	NN
40439	509	49	.	.	.
40439	510	1	To	to	IN
40439	510	2	each	each	DT
40439	510	3	of	of	IN
40439	510	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
40439	510	5	rectilinear	rectilinear	JJ
40439	510	6	motion	motion	NN
40439	510	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	510	8	_	_	NNP
40439	510	9	natural	natural	JJ
40439	510	10	_	_	NNP
40439	510	11	;	;	:
40439	510	12	earth	earth	NN
40439	510	13	moves	move	VBZ
40439	510	14	naturally	naturally	RB
40439	510	15	towards	towards	IN
40439	510	16	the	the	DT
40439	510	17	centre	centre	NN
40439	510	18	--	--	:
40439	510	19	fire	fire	NN
40439	510	20	moves	move	NNS
40439	510	21	naturally	naturally	RB
40439	510	22	towards	towards	IN
40439	510	23	the	the	DT
40439	510	24	circumference	circumference	NN
40439	510	25	,	,	,
40439	510	26	away	away	RB
40439	510	27	from	from	IN
40439	510	28	the	the	DT
40439	510	29	centre	centre	NN
40439	510	30	.	.	.
40439	511	1	But	but	CC
40439	511	2	the	the	DT
40439	511	3	peripheral	peripheral	JJ
40439	511	4	substance	substance	NN
40439	511	5	of	of	IN
40439	511	6	the	the	DT
40439	511	7	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	511	8	is	be	VBZ
40439	511	9	radically	radically	RB
40439	511	10	distinct	distinct	JJ
40439	511	11	from	from	IN
40439	511	12	the	the	DT
40439	511	13	four	four	CD
40439	511	14	elements	element	NNS
40439	511	15	:	:	:
40439	511	16	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	511	17	motion	motion	NN
40439	511	18	in	in	IN
40439	511	19	a	a	DT
40439	511	20	circle	circle	NN
40439	511	21	is	be	VBZ
40439	511	22	_	_	NNP
40439	511	23	natural	natural	JJ
40439	511	24	_	_	NNP
40439	511	25	to	to	IN
40439	511	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	511	27	,	,	,
40439	511	28	and	and	CC
40439	511	29	is	be	VBZ
40439	511	30	the	the	DT
40439	511	31	only	only	JJ
40439	511	32	variety	variety	NN
40439	511	33	of	of	IN
40439	511	34	motion	motion	NN
40439	511	35	natural	natural	JJ
40439	511	36	to	to	IN
40439	511	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	511	38	.	.	.
40439	512	1	That	that	IN
40439	512	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	512	3	is	be	VBZ
40439	512	4	moved	move	VBN
40439	512	5	at	at	RB
40439	512	6	all	all	RB
40439	512	7	,	,	,
40439	512	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	512	9	owes	owe	VBZ
40439	512	10	to	to	IN
40439	512	11	a	a	DT
40439	512	12	_	_	NNP
40439	512	13	primum	primum	NN
40439	512	14	movens	moven	VBZ
40439	512	15	immobile	immobile	NNP
40439	512	16	_	_	NNP
40439	512	17	impelling	impel	VBG
40439	512	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	512	19	:	:	:
40439	512	20	but	but	CC
40439	512	21	the	the	DT
40439	512	22	two	two	CD
40439	512	23	are	be	VBP
40439	512	24	coeternal	coeternal	JJ
40439	512	25	,	,	,
40439	512	26	and	and	CC
40439	512	27	the	the	DT
40439	512	28	motion	motion	NN
40439	512	29	has	have	VBZ
40439	512	30	neither	neither	CC
40439	512	31	beginning	beginning	NN
40439	512	32	nor	nor	CC
40439	512	33	end	end	NN
40439	512	34	.	.	.
40439	513	1	That	that	IN
40439	513	2	when	when	WRB
40439	513	3	moved	move	VBD
40439	513	4	,	,	,
40439	513	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	513	6	motion	motion	NN
40439	513	7	is	be	VBZ
40439	513	8	rotatory	rotatory	JJ
40439	513	9	and	and	CC
40439	513	10	not	not	RB
40439	513	11	rectilinear	rectilinear	JJ
40439	513	12	,	,	,
40439	513	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	513	14	owes	owe	VBZ
40439	513	15	to	to	IN
40439	513	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	513	17	own	own	JJ
40439	513	18	nature	nature	NN
40439	513	19	.	.	.
40439	514	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
40439	514	2	rotates	rotate	VBZ
40439	514	3	perpetually	perpetually	RB
40439	514	4	,	,	,
40439	514	5	through	through	IN
40439	514	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	514	7	own	own	JJ
40439	514	8	nature	nature	NN
40439	514	9	and	and	CC
40439	514	10	inherent	inherent	JJ
40439	514	11	virtue	virtue	NN
40439	514	12	,	,	,
40439	514	13	not	not	RB
40439	514	14	by	by	IN
40439	514	15	constraining	constrain	VBG
40439	514	16	pressure	pressure	NN
40439	514	17	communicated	communicate	VBN
40439	514	18	from	from	IN
40439	514	19	a	a	DT
40439	514	20	centre	centre	NN
40439	514	21	or	or	CC
40439	514	22	from	from	IN
40439	514	23	a	a	DT
40439	514	24	soul	soul	NN
40439	514	25	.	.	.
40439	515	1	If	if	IN
40439	515	2	constraint	constraint	NN
40439	515	3	were	be	VBD
40439	515	4	required	require	VBN
40439	515	5	--	--	:
40439	515	6	if	if	IN
40439	515	7	there	there	EX
40439	515	8	were	be	VBD
40439	515	9	any	any	DT
40439	515	10	contrary	contrary	JJ
40439	515	11	tendency	tendency	NN
40439	515	12	to	to	TO
40439	515	13	be	be	VB
40439	515	14	overcome	overcome	VBN
40439	515	15	--	--	:
40439	515	16	the	the	DT
40439	515	17	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	515	18	periphery	periphery	NN
40439	515	19	would	would	MD
40439	515	20	become	become	VB
40439	515	21	fatigued	fatigued	JJ
40439	515	22	,	,	,
40439	515	23	and	and	CC
40439	515	24	would	would	MD
40439	515	25	require	require	VB
40439	515	26	periods	period	NNS
40439	515	27	of	of	IN
40439	515	28	repose	repose	NN
40439	515	29	;	;	:
40439	515	30	but	but	CC
40439	515	31	,	,	,
40439	515	32	since	since	IN
40439	515	33	in	in	IN
40439	515	34	revolving	revolve	VBG
40439	515	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	515	36	only	only	RB
40439	515	37	obeys	obey	VBZ
40439	515	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	515	39	own	own	JJ
40439	515	40	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
40439	515	41	nature	nature	NN
40439	515	42	,	,	,
40439	515	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	515	44	persists	persist	VBZ
40439	515	45	for	for	IN
40439	515	46	ever	ever	RB
40439	515	47	without	without	IN
40439	515	48	knowing	know	VBG
40439	515	49	fatigue	fatigue	NN
40439	515	50	.	.	.
40439	516	1	This	this	DT
40439	516	2	peripheral	peripheral	JJ
40439	516	3	or	or	CC
40439	516	4	fifth	fifth	JJ
40439	516	5	essence	essence	NN
40439	516	6	,	,	,
40439	516	7	perpetually	perpetually	RB
40439	516	8	revolving	revolving	JJ
40439	516	9	,	,	,
40439	516	10	is	be	VBZ
40439	516	11	the	the	DT
40439	516	12	divine	divine	JJ
40439	516	13	,	,	,
40439	516	14	venerable	venerable	JJ
40439	516	15	,	,	,
40439	516	16	and	and	CC
40439	516	17	commanding	commanding	JJ
40439	516	18	portion	portion	NN
40439	516	19	of	of	IN
40439	516	20	the	the	DT
40439	516	21	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	516	22	,	,	,
40439	516	23	more	more	RBR
40439	516	24	grand	grand	JJ
40439	516	25	and	and	CC
40439	516	26	honourable	honourable	JJ
40439	516	27	than	than	IN
40439	516	28	the	the	DT
40439	516	29	interior	interior	JJ
40439	516	30	parts	part	NNS
40439	516	31	or	or	CC
40439	516	32	the	the	DT
40439	516	33	centre	centre	NN
40439	516	34	.	.	.
40439	517	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	517	2	lays	lay	VBZ
40439	517	3	this	this	DT
40439	517	4	down	down	RP
40439	517	5	(	(	-LRB-
40439	517	6	De	De	NNP
40439	517	7	Coelo	Coelo	NNP
40439	517	8	,	,	,
40439	517	9	ii	ii	NNP
40439	517	10	.	.	.
40439	518	1	13	13	CD
40439	518	2	,	,	,
40439	518	3	p.	p.	NN
40439	518	4	293	293	CD
40439	518	5	,	,	,
40439	518	6	b.	b.	NNP
40439	519	1	10	10	LS
40439	519	2	)	)	-RRB-
40439	519	3	in	in	IN
40439	519	4	express	express	JJ
40439	519	5	antithesis	antithesis	NN
40439	519	6	to	to	IN
40439	519	7	the	the	DT
40439	519	8	Pythagoreans	Pythagoreans	NNPS
40439	519	9	,	,	,
40439	519	10	who	who	WP
40439	519	11	(	(	-LRB-
40439	519	12	like	like	IN
40439	519	13	Plato	Plato	NNP
40439	519	14	)	)	-RRB-
40439	519	15	considered	consider	VBD
40439	519	16	the	the	DT
40439	519	17	centre	centre	NN
40439	519	18	as	as	IN
40439	519	19	the	the	DT
40439	519	20	point	point	NN
40439	519	21	of	of	IN
40439	519	22	grandeur	grandeur	NN
40439	519	23	and	and	CC
40439	519	24	command	command	NN
40439	519	25	,	,	,
40439	519	26	placing	place	VBG
40439	519	27	fire	fire	NN
40439	519	28	in	in	IN
40439	519	29	the	the	DT
40439	519	30	centre	centre	NN
40439	519	31	for	for	IN
40439	519	32	that	that	DT
40439	519	33	reason	reason	NN
40439	519	34	.	.	.
40439	520	1	The	the	DT
40439	520	2	earth	earth	NN
40439	520	3	has	have	VBZ
40439	520	4	no	no	DT
40439	520	5	positive	positive	JJ
40439	520	6	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	520	7	function	function	NN
40439	520	8	in	in	IN
40439	520	9	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	520	10	;	;	:
40439	520	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	520	12	occupies	occupy	VBZ
40439	520	13	the	the	DT
40439	520	14	centre	centre	NN
40439	520	15	because	because	IN
40439	520	16	all	all	PDT
40439	520	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	520	18	parts	part	NNS
40439	520	19	have	have	VBP
40439	520	20	a	a	DT
40439	520	21	natural	natural	JJ
40439	520	22	movement	movement	NN
40439	520	23	towards	towards	IN
40439	520	24	the	the	DT
40439	520	25	centre	centre	NN
40439	520	26	:	:	:
40439	520	27	and	and	CC
40439	520	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
40439	520	29	is	be	VBZ
40439	520	30	unmoved	unmoved	JJ
40439	520	31	because	because	IN
40439	520	32	there	there	EX
40439	520	33	_	_	NNP
40439	520	34	must	must	MD
40439	520	35	be	be	VB
40439	520	36	_	_	NNP
40439	520	37	something	something	NN
40439	520	38	in	in	IN
40439	520	39	the	the	DT
40439	520	40	centre	centre	NN
40439	520	41	which	which	WDT
40439	520	42	is	be	VBZ
40439	520	43	always	always	RB
40439	520	44	stationary	stationary	JJ
40439	520	45	,	,	,
40439	520	46	as	as	IN
40439	520	47	a	a	DT
40439	520	48	contrary	contrary	NN
40439	520	49	or	or	CC
40439	520	50	antithesis	antithesis	NN
40439	520	51	to	to	IN
40439	520	52	the	the	DT
40439	520	53	fifth	fifth	JJ
40439	520	54	essence	essence	NN
40439	520	55	or	or	CC
40439	520	56	peripheral	peripheral	JJ
40439	520	57	substance	substance	NN
40439	520	58	of	of	IN
40439	520	59	the	the	DT
40439	520	60	kosmos	kosmo	NNS
40439	520	61	,	,	,
40439	520	62	which	which	WDT
40439	520	63	is	be	VBZ
40439	520	64	in	in	IN
40439	520	65	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
40439	520	66	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	520	67	by	by	IN
40439	520	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
40439	520	69	own	own	JJ
40439	520	70	immutable	immutable	JJ
40439	520	71	nature	nature	NN
40439	520	72	.	.	.
40439	521	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	521	2	do	do	VBP
40439	521	3	not	not	RB
40439	521	4	here	here	RB
40439	521	5	go	go	VB
40439	521	6	farther	farther	RB
40439	521	7	into	into	IN
40439	521	8	the	the	DT
40439	521	9	exposition	exposition	NN
40439	521	10	of	of	IN
40439	521	11	these	these	DT
40439	521	12	ancient	ancient	JJ
40439	521	13	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
40439	521	14	theories	theory	NNS
40439	521	15	.	.	.
40439	522	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	522	2	have	have	VBP
40439	522	3	adverted	advert	VBN
40439	522	4	to	to	IN
40439	522	5	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
40439	522	6	's	's	POS
40439	522	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
40439	522	8	only	only	RB
40439	522	9	so	so	RB
40439	522	10	far	far	RB
40439	522	11	as	as	IN
40439	522	12	was	be	VBD
40439	522	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
40439	522	14	to	to	TO
40439	522	15	elucidate	elucidate	VB
40439	522	16	,	,	,
40439	522	17	by	by	IN
40439	522	18	contrast	contrast	NN
40439	522	19	,	,	,
40439	522	20	that	that	IN
40439	522	21	which	which	WDT
40439	522	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
40439	522	23	believe	believe	VBP
40439	522	24	to	to	TO
40439	522	25	be	be	VB
40439	522	26	the	the	DT
40439	522	27	meaning	meaning	NN
40439	522	28	of	of	IN
40439	522	29	the	the	DT
40439	522	30	Platonic	Platonic	NNP
40439	522	31	Timæus	Timæus	NNP
40439	522	32	about	about	IN
40439	522	33	the	the	DT
40439	522	34	rotation	rotation	NN
40439	522	35	of	of	IN
40439	522	36	the	the	DT
40439	522	37	earth	earth	NN
40439	522	38	.	.	.
40439	523	1	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
40439	523	2	:	:	:
40439	523	3	PRINTED	PRINTED	NNP
40439	523	4	BY	by	IN
40439	523	5	W.	W.	NNP
40439	523	6	CLOWES	CLOWES	NNP
40439	523	7	AND	and	CC
40439	523	8	SONS	son	NNS
40439	523	9	,	,	,
40439	523	10	STAMFORD	STAMFORD	NNP
40439	523	11	STREET	STREET	NNP
40439	523	12	,	,	,
40439	523	13	AND	and	CC
40439	523	14	CHARING	CHARING	NNP
40439	523	15	CROSS	CROSS	NNP
40439	523	16	.	.	.
40439	524	1	*	*	NFP
40439	524	2	*	*	NFP
40439	524	3	*	*	NFP
40439	524	4	*	*	NFP
40439	524	5	*	*	NFP
40439	524	6	*	*	NFP
40439	524	7	*	*	NFP
40439	524	8	*	*	NFP
40439	524	9	*	*	NFP
40439	524	10	*	*	NFP
40439	524	11	*	*	NFP
40439	524	12	*	*	NFP
40439	524	13	*	*	NFP
40439	524	14	*	*	NFP
40439	524	15	*	*	NFP
40439	524	16	*	*	NFP
40439	524	17	*	*	NFP
40439	524	18	*	*	NFP
40439	524	19	*	*	NFP
40439	524	20	*	*	NFP
40439	524	21	*	*	NFP
40439	524	22	*	*	NFP
40439	524	23	*	*	NFP
40439	524	24	*	*	NFP
40439	524	25	*	*	NFP
40439	524	26	*	*	NFP
40439	524	27	*	*	NFP
40439	524	28	*	*	NFP
40439	524	29	*	*	NFP
40439	524	30	*	*	NFP
40439	524	31	*	*	NFP
40439	524	32	*	*	NFP
40439	524	33	*	*	NFP
40439	524	34	*	*	NFP
40439	524	35	*	*	NFP
40439	524	36	*	*	NFP
40439	524	37	*	*	NFP
40439	524	38	*	*	NFP
40439	524	39	*	*	NFP
40439	524	40	*	*	NFP
40439	524	41	*	*	NFP
40439	524	42	*	*	NFP
40439	524	43	*	*	NFP
40439	524	44	*	*	NFP
40439	524	45	*	*	NFP
40439	524	46	*	*	NFP
40439	524	47	*	*	NFP
40439	524	48	*	*	NFP
40439	524	49	*	*	NFP
40439	524	50	*	*	NFP
40439	524	51	*	*	NFP
40439	524	52	*	*	NFP
40439	524	53	*	*	NFP
40439	524	54	*	*	NFP
40439	524	55	*	*	NFP
40439	524	56	*	*	NFP
40439	524	57	*	*	NFP
40439	524	58	*	*	NFP
40439	524	59	*	*	NFP
40439	524	60	*	*	NFP
40439	524	61	*	*	NFP
40439	524	62	*	*	NFP
40439	524	63	*	*	NFP
40439	524	64	*	*	NFP
40439	524	65	Transcriber	Transcriber	NNP
40439	524	66	's	's	POS
40439	524	67	Note	Note	NNP
40439	524	68	The	the	DT
40439	524	69	text	text	NN
40439	524	70	is	be	VBZ
40439	524	71	based	base	VBN
40439	524	72	on	on	IN
40439	524	73	versions	version	NNS
40439	524	74	made	make	VBN
40439	524	75	available	available	JJ
40439	524	76	by	by	IN
40439	524	77	the	the	DT
40439	524	78	Internet	Internet	NNP
40439	524	79	Archive	Archive	NNP
40439	524	80	.	.	.
40439	525	1	For	for	IN
40439	525	2	the	the	DT
40439	525	3	Greek	greek	JJ
40439	525	4	transcriptions	transcription	NNS
40439	525	5	the	the	DT
40439	525	6	following	follow	VBG
40439	525	7	conventions	convention	NNS
40439	525	8	have	have	VBP
40439	525	9	been	be	VBN
40439	525	10	used	use	VBN
40439	525	11	:	:	:
40439	525	12	)	)	-RRB-
40439	525	13	is	be	VBZ
40439	525	14	for	for	IN
40439	525	15	smooth	smooth	JJ
40439	525	16	breathing	breathing	NN
40439	525	17	;	;	:
40439	525	18	(	(	-LRB-
40439	525	19	for	for	IN
40439	525	20	hard	hard	RB
40439	525	21	;	;	:
40439	525	22	+	+	CC
40439	525	23	for	for	IN
40439	525	24	diaeresis	diaeresis	NN
40439	525	25	;	;	,
40439	525	26	/	/	,
40439	525	27	for	for	IN
40439	525	28	acute	acute	JJ
40439	525	29	accent	accent	NN
40439	525	30	;	;	:
40439	525	31	\	\	VB
40439	525	32	for	for	IN
40439	525	33	grave	grave	NN
40439	525	34	;	;	:
40439	525	35	=	=	NFP
40439	525	36	for	for	IN
40439	525	37	circumflex	circumflex	NN
40439	525	38	;	;	:
40439	525	39	|	|	NNP
40439	525	40	for	for	IN
40439	525	41	iota	iota	NNP
40439	525	42	subscript	subscript	NNP
40439	525	43	.	.	.
40439	526	1	ch	ch	NNP
40439	526	2	is	be	VBZ
40439	526	3	used	use	VBN
40439	526	4	for	for	IN
40439	526	5	chi	chi	NNP
40439	526	6	,	,	,
40439	526	7	ph	ph	NNP
40439	526	8	for	for	IN
40439	526	9	phi	phi	NNP
40439	526	10	,	,	,
40439	526	11	ps	ps	NNP
40439	526	12	for	for	IN
40439	526	13	psi	psi	NNP
40439	526	14	,	,	,
40439	526	15	th	th	XX
40439	526	16	for	for	IN
40439	526	17	theta	theta	NN
40439	526	18	;	;	:
40439	526	19	ê	ê	NNP
40439	526	20	for	for	IN
40439	526	21	eta	eta	NNP
40439	526	22	and	and	CC
40439	526	23	ô	ô	NNP
40439	526	24	for	for	IN
40439	526	25	omega	omega	NN
40439	526	26	;	;	:
40439	526	27	u	u	NNP
40439	526	28	is	be	VBZ
40439	526	29	used	use	VBN
40439	526	30	for	for	IN
40439	526	31	upsilon	upsilon	NN
40439	526	32	in	in	IN
40439	526	33	all	all	DT
40439	526	34	cases	case	NNS
40439	526	35	.	.	.
40439	527	1	Corrections	correction	NNS
40439	527	2	to	to	IN
40439	527	3	the	the	DT
40439	527	4	text	text	NN
40439	527	5	,	,	,
40439	527	6	indicated	indicate	VBD
40439	527	7	with	with	IN
40439	527	8	*	*	NFP
40439	527	9	*	*	NFP
40439	527	10	Text	Text	NNP
40439	527	11	Correction	Correction	NNP
40439	527	12	Ti	Ti	NNP
40439	527	13	/	/	SYM
40439	527	14	ma	ma	NNP
40439	527	15	/	/	SYM
40439	527	16	iô	iô	NNP
40439	527	17	Ti	Ti	NNP
40439	527	18	/	/	SYM
40439	527	19	maio	maio	JJ
40439	527	20	chore	chore	NN
40439	527	21	/	/	SYM
40439	527	22	ia	ia	NNP
40439	527	23	chorei	chorei	NNP
40439	527	24	/	/	,
40439	527	25	a	a	DT
40439	527	26	ou)/ranon	ou)/ranon	NNP
40439	527	27	ou)rano\n	ou)rano\n	NNP
40439	527	28	tetamenon	tetamenon	NN
40439	527	29	tetame	tetame	NN
40439	527	30	/	/	SYM
40439	527	31	non	non	JJ
40439	527	32	e)ndeiknutai	e)ndeiknutai	CD
40439	527	33	e)ndei	e)ndei	CD
40439	527	34	/	/	SYM
40439	527	35	knutai	knutai	NN
40439	527	36	]	]	-RRB-
40439	527	37	forge	forge	NN
40439	527	38	force	force	NN
40439	527	39	Tima	Tima	NNP
40439	527	40	/	/	SYM
40439	527	41	iô|	iô|	NNP
40439	527	42	Timai	Timai	NNP
40439	527	43	/	/	SYM
40439	527	44	ô|	ô|	NNP
40439	527	45	gegraptai	gegraptai	NNP
40439	527	46	ge	ge	NNP
40439	527	47	/	/	SYM
40439	527	48	graptai	graptai	NNP
40439	527	49	]	]	-RRB-
40439	527	50	e(ilei	e(ilei	NNP
40439	527	51	=	=	SYM
40439	527	52	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	527	53	ei(lei	ei(lei	NNP
40439	527	54	=	=	SYM
40439	527	55	sthai	sthai	NNP
40439	527	56	e)/pi\	e)/pi\	:
40439	527	57	e)pi\	e)pi\	NNP
40439	527	58	a)utê	a)utê	NNPS
40439	527	59	=	=	SYM
40439	527	60	s	s	NNP
40439	527	61	au)tê	au)tê	NNP
40439	527	62	=	=	SYM
40439	527	63	s	s	NN