Libertas evangelica, or, A discourse of Christian liberty being a farther pursuance of the argument of the design of Christianity / by Edward Fowler ... Fowler, Edward, 1632-1714. 1680 Approx. 453 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 191 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2003-11 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A40082 Wing F1709 ESTC R15452 13593773 ocm 13593773 100709 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A40082) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 100709) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 788:20) Libertas evangelica, or, A discourse of Christian liberty being a farther pursuance of the argument of the design of Christianity / by Edward Fowler ... Fowler, Edward, 1632-1714. [37], 343, [2] p. : ill. Printed by R. Norton for Richard Royston and Walter Kettilby, London : 1680. Errata: p. [31] Advertisement: p. [2] at end. Reproduction of original in Bodleian Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Freedom of religion -- Early works to 1800. 2003-07 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2003-07 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2003-08 Rina Kor Sampled and proofread 2003-08 Rina Kor Text and markup reviewed and edited 2003-10 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion LIBERTAS EVANGELICA Ierusalem w ch . is above , is free , which is the mother of us all Gal. 4. 26. If the Son therefore shall make you free , ye shall be free indeed . S. l●h● S. 〈◊〉 . LIBERTAS EVANGELICA : OR , A DISCOURSE OF Christian Liberty . Being a farther Pursuance of the Argument of The Design of Christianity . By EDWARD FOWLER , Rector of Alhallows Breadstreet , London . LONDON , Printed by R. Norton , for Richard Royston , and Walter Kettilby , MDCLXXX . To the Right Honourable ANTHONY Earl of KENT , Lord Hastings , Waishford and Ruthyn . My Lord , THE Relation I formerly had to Your Lordship , and to the Excellent Countess Your Mother , who , like King Solomon's wise Woman , hath Builded Her House , and by Her extraordinary Prudence , accompanied with the Divine Blessing , hath raised the now Third Earldom in this Kingdom to its Ancient Greatness and Splendour ; this Double Relation , I say , hath Emboldened me to make a Dedication of this Discourse to Your Lordship : But there are also several other Considerations that induce me thereunto : As particularly , I know Your Lordship to be a Sober and Virtuous Person ; and that , as the Grace of God did Guard your Youth , and make the Pious and Solicitous Care of so Good a Mother happily successful to preserve you from all inclination to the Debaucheries of the Age ; which have proved so Fatal to not a few Great Men and Great Families ; so since your coming to years of Consideration and Iudgment , You have not onely upon deliberate Choice totally deelined them , but from the Love of Virtue heartily detested them . I know your Lordship to be excellently well Principled , both as a Subject of his Majesty , and a Son of the Church of England ; and to be a perfect Enemy to the two great Adversaries of both , viz. Popery and Fanaticism . And that , as a Noble Clergie-man of this Church was your Grandfather , so your Lordship hath always been an Affectionate Friend and Patron of her Clergie ; and have had a very particular Value for those of them whose Piety , Prudence and Learning intitle them to Esteem . But I will not enlarge so far as truly I might upon this subject , I shall onely add , that I know your Lordship to be a Lover of Books and Learning ( wherein you attained to very good Proficiency , by your noted Studiousness and Industry in the Vniversity ) but chiefly to Admire that sort of Learning which incomparably Excelleth all other , viz. That which our Great Master Christ Jesus hath so highly Advanc'd and Perfected : The Design of which is to make us wise to Salvation , and Happy both in this World and to All Eternity . And this ( if your Lordship shall vouchsafe to peruse it ) you will find is for a great part the immediate Business of the following Treatise : As it is of the remainder , to Vndermine and Subvert those Principles , both Popish and others , which are of so Pernicious Consequence , and infinitely Mischievous to that Design . I am so well Acquainted with your Lordships Candour and Ingenuity , as to presume that it will easily overlook the many Defects of this Discourse , for the sake of that Honest Meaning which your Charity will believe prompted me to the Writing and Publication of it . God Almighty continue to multiply His Blessings both Spiritual and Temporal upon Your Lordship , together with Your Pious and Eminently Charitable Lady , Your Hopeful Children , and the Rest of Your as Happy as Noble Family . This is , and shall be the Hearty Prayer of , MY LORD , Your Lordships most Faithful and Humble Servant , EDW. FOWLER . THE PREFACE . AS the right Understanding of the Nature of the Christian Religion will enable us to discover all Destructive and Dangerous Errors , so those cannot be Ignorant of its true Nature who are acquainted with its Design and Business ; and consequently to be well informed herein is the most sure and compendious Method that can be made choice of to preserve our selves from the Contagion of Heresie , and all such Opinions and Practices as are apt to make us Bad Christians . By this means men may save themselves the tedious labour of busying their Heads in particular Controversies , and in strictly examining all the Arguments whereby the many Sects among us do endeavour to make their proper Sentiments to pass for great Gospel Truths : It is sufficient to measure them all by this one Standard , and compare them with this Rule ; which having done , we may be fully satisfied , that all such as are opposite to the intendment of our Saviour's Coming are to be Rejected , all such as tend to promote it are to be embraced , and as for such as do neither Oppose nor Promote it ( if any such are ) it is not worth our while in the least to concern our selves about them . The Consideration hereof did heretofore induce me to write that Treatise , Intituled , The Design of Christianity : And whereas divers Worthy Persons about that time had written to excellently good purpose against certain Popular Notions in Religion , and abundantly exposed both the Falsity and Dangerousness of them , I employed my small Talent in Endeavouring in that Discourse to Undermine them all together in the lump , and to pluck them up by the Roots : And , I praise God for it , I have seen reason to hope that I did not wholly lose my Labour . Now the Reader will soon perceive that this plain Discourse of CHRISTIAN LIBERTY ( as is expressed in the Title-Page ) is a farther Pursuance and Improvement of the Argument of that Treatise : And that the self-same thing for substance is Endeavoured in both . And I was the more inclined to treat of this Subject , because , as clear and obvious as our Notion thereof is , I do not know that it hath hitherto happened to be fully expressed in any other Book , and much less Made out and Improved . Considering the near Relation between these two Discourses , I may save my Self and Reader the trouble of a long Preface , and shall do little more than acquaint him in a few words with these three things . First , The Body of the Discourse is as Practical as can be , and treats of as Weighty and Important Points as are to be found in the Gospel : Nor is there any one Notion started throughout the Whole , but what is both very Easie , and Improveable to the best and most Profitable purposes . Secondly , The Opinions and Practices which are exposed as False and Dangerous are none but such as are most Evidently Contradictory to Christian Liberty as 't is here Explicated , or to that Natural Liberty which is the not to be invaded Property of Mankind ; although some of them , we have shewed , are insisted upon by not a few , as so many Parts or Branches of Christian Liberty : And all those that we have concerned our selves with may be reduced to three Heads , Antinomian , Fanatical and Popish : Upon which last we have much more Enlarged than on the other two ; and not ( especially at this time ) without great reason . Thirdly , We have fully made it appear , that as no man can entertain a kind thought of Popery , so neither can he easily satisfie himself to separate from the Communion of the Church of England , while he hath the true notion of Christian Liberty . The present Separation of so great a number of our Protestant Brethren ( I meddle not here with the mere Non-conformity of Ministers ) is chiefly occasioned , the more is the shame , by things that are very little in their own nature ; By matters acknowledged by them generally to be Indifferent in themselves , and which they can never shew are forbidden by any express Law of God , nor can make them look in the least like Sinful things , otherwise than by using a deal of Artifice and Force in Interpreting and Applying of certain Scriptures . And the great Obstacle to our Peace and Unity , I mean next to Pride , Self-conceit and the want of the true Christian Spirit , is a gross Mistake concerning the nature of Christian Liberty : It being conceived that as Little things as are the Cause of the Breach , there is a Great thing parted with by Complying with them ; no less a thing than that which their Saviour judged to be worth the Expence of his Precious Bloud to purchase it for them , which is this Liberty . And could the Brethren of the Separation be once perswaded out of their darling Notion thereof ( as if they will they easily may ) and be satisfied that it is no way betrayed by obeying their Governours ; while nothing worse is imposed by them than what is Indifferent , the Well-meaning People amongst them would soon think it of far worse consequence to break the Peace of the Church about such things , than to Conform to them : Especially since these Divisions are no less dangerous to both the Church and State than Unchristian and Scandalous . For who doth not see what Advantage our Common Enemy doth make of them , and what farther Advantage , not to be thought of without horrour , he may be too like to make ? I have one humble Request to make to the Reader , viz. that he will be , I don't say so kind , but so just to me as not hastily to Censure me , if he happens now and then to light upon a passage which at first sight may seem somewhat odd to him , but have the Patience to suspend his displeasure till he hath read farther ; when he may possibly perceive that he misunderstood me in those Passages : For it is impossible ( I at least find it so ) to deliver the intire sense of ones Mind all at once , concerning any thing that requireth some considerable exercise of thoughts . I desire especially that this Right may be done me in the Fifteenth Chapter , which treats of that most ticklish Argument , Liberty of Conscience ; whereon I have endeavoured to give my most Sedate thoughts with all sincerity and impartiality . I will Conclude with this Advertisement , that whereas I have touched upon several things which I have since found in the Learned Dean of S. Paul's his most Excellent Discourse , Intituled the Mischief of Separation , I had perfectly completed all that Part where I have done so , and sent much of it to the Press too before I read that Discourse ; nor did it occasion the addition of any one thing . And it would have been , I am sensible , a weak thing of me had I industriously repeated things published to the World so immediately before by that Great Man , with so much greater Advantage . THE CONTENTS . SECT . I. That the most excellent and most highly to be valued Liberty doth consist in an intire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness : Or in Freedom from the dominion of corrupt and sinful Affections . CHAP. I. THis shewed in the General from Texts of Scripture , and further confirmed by those who were strangers to Divine Revelation . Page 1. CHAP. II. That the most excellent Freedom and Liberty consists in the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness , more distinctly and particularly demonstrated by three Arguments . Of which the First is , that this is Freedom from the worst and vilest of Slaveries . Where it is shewed in three particulars , that the Transgressors of those Laws are the most Slavish Creatures . pag. 7. CHAP. III. That the Liberty which resulteth from the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness is , Secondly , The Liberty of the Soul : and how it is so , is shewed in four Particulars . pag. 15. CHAP. IV. That this is , Thirdly , the Liberty of God himself , and his most Excellent Liberty . pag. 32. SECT . II. That this Freedom to holy Obedience and true Goodness , or which consisteth in an intire compliance with the Laws of Righteousness , is our Christian Liberty . CHAP. V. The foresaid Proposition Demonstrated by f●●r Arguments , viz. First , That this hath b●en proved to be the most Glorious Liberty . Secondly , This was that Liberty , the instating us wherein , was the whole business of our Saviour and his Apostles . Thirdly , Our 〈◊〉 Abolishing the Ceremonial Law was chiefly d●signed in 〈◊〉 to the thorough effecting this Liberty : Where it is shewed , that this Law accidentally became very prejudicial to the great Design of setting men free from the power of their Lusts , in several particulars . Fourthly , That none but the Jews were obliged to the Observance of this Law. pag. 40. CHAP. VI. What course our Lord hath taken to instate us in this Liberty shewed in several particulars , viz. that 1. He hath most fully informed us concerning all the Parts and Particulars of our Liberty . 2. He hath furnished us with the most potent Means , for the gaining of it . 3. He hath purchased a rich supply of Grace and Strength , to enable us to use these Means successfully . 4. He hath laid before us the most powerful Motives and Arguments to prevail on our Wills to make use of this Strength , and comply with this Grace . pag. 60. CHAP. VII . Wherein is discoursed the First of those Motives and Arguments which are offered in the Gospel , to perswade us to use the Means prescribed for our deliverance from the Power of Sin. Namely , The love of God in sending his Son upon the errand of our Redemption . And two most powerful Motives implied in this . pag. 78. CHAP. VIII . A Seasonable Digression concerning the Doctrine of Vniversal Redemption . The Antiquity and Catholicalness of this Doctrine . Large Citations out of Bishop Latimer and Bishop Hooper , expressing their sense of it . And full proof thereof presented out of the H. Scriptures . pag. 82. CHAP. IX . Wherein are contained Five more Evangelical Motives , which are of wonderful Power to excite us to diligence in using the Means of our Deliverance from the Dominion of Sin , viz. Our Saviours excellent Example . The assurance he hath given us , that he will not take such advantage of our Frailties and Weaknesses , as to cast us off for them . Our Saviours Mediation and Intercession . The Glorious Reward he hath purchased for , and promised to those , who , by the Assistance of his Grace , overcome their Lusts. And the most dismal Threatnings he hath pronounced against those who receive that Grace in vain , and will not be delivered from the Dominion of Sin. pag. 105. SECT . III. Containing the Inferences from each of the Arguments of the foregoing Sections . CHAP. X. Which treats of the First Inference from the First Proposition , [ That the most Excellent Liberty doth consist in an Intire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness ; Or in Freedom from the Dominion of Sinful Affections . ] Namely , That those are most Vnreasonable and Depraved People , who complain of the Divine Laws as intolerable Intrenchments upon their Liberty . Where it is shewed , First , That upon supposition our Liberty were restrained by the Laws of God , it would nevertheless be most unreasonable to complain upon that account . Secondly , That the Laws which oblige Christians do not restrain their Liberty . pag. 127. CHAP. XI . The Second Inference , viz. That such a Freedom of Will as consists in an Indifferency to good or evil , is no Perfection , but the Contrary . pag. 135. CHAP. XII . Which Treats of one Branch of the First Inference from the Argument of the Second Section , [ That in Freedom from the Dominion of Corrupt Affections doth that Liberty Principally or rather Wholly Consist , which Christ hath purchased for us . ] Namely , that several Notions of Christian Liberty , which have too much prevailed , are false and of dangerous Consequence . The First of which is , That which makes it to consist , wholly or in part , in Freedom from the Obligation of the Moral Law. Certain Texts , urged by the Antinomians in favour of it , vindicated from the sence they put upon them . And the extreme wildness and wickedness of it exposed in Five Particulars . pag. 143. CHAP. XIII . A Second False Notion of Christian Liberty , viz. That which makes it to consist in Freedom from the Obligation of those Laws of Men , which enjoyn or forbid indifferent things . This Notion differently managed by the Defenders of it . First , Some extend it so far as to make it to reach to all Humane Laws , the matter of which are things indifferent . Secondly , Others limit it to those which relate to Religion and the Worship of God. The 23. Vers. of the 7. Chap. of the 1 Epist. to the Corinthians cleared from giving any Countenance to either of these Opinions . The Former of them Confuted by three Arguments : And the Latter by four . Vnder the Second of which , several Texts of Scripture which are much insisted upon in the defence thereof , are taken into Consideration . An unjust Reflection upon the Church of England briefly replied to . And this Principle , that the imposing of things indifferent in Divine Worship is no Violation of Christian Liberty , proved to be no ways Serviceable to Popery , by considering what the Popish Impositions are in Three Particulars . pag. 164. CHAP. XIV . An Answer to this Question , Whether the Prescribing of Forms of Prayer , for the Publick Worship of God , be not an Encroachment upon Christian Liberty ? Wherein it is shewed , that this is not a Stifling of the Spirit , or Restraining the exercise of his Gift . And what in Prayer is not , as also what is the Gift of the Spirit . Whereby is occasioned an Answer to another Question , viz. Whether an Ability for Preaching be properly a Gift of the Spirit . pag. 198. CHAP. XV. A Third False Notion of Christian Liberty , viz. that which makes Liberty of Conscience a Branch of it . Two things premised , 1. That Conscience is not so sacred a thing as to be uncapable of being obliged by Humane Laws . 2. That no man can properly be deprived of the true Liberty of his Conscience by any Power on Earth . That what is contended for , is more properly Liberty of Practice than of Conscience . The Author's Opinion in reference to this Liberty delivered in Ten Propositions . That whatsoever Liberty of this Nature may be insisted on as our Right , it is not Christian Liberty but Natural Liberty . pag. 219. CHAP. XVI . The Third Inference from our Notion of Christian Liberty , viz. That Popery is the greatest Enemy in the World thereunto . Where it is shewed , First , That the Church of Rome Robs those who are subject to her of that Natural Liberty which necessarily belongs to them as they are Men , viz. That which consists in the free use of their Vnderstandings in matters of Religion . That She will not permit men to Examine either her Doctrines or Practices by the Holy Scriptures ; nor yet to receive the Holy Scriptures themselves otherwise than upon her Authority . The Wickedness of this exposed in two Particulars . The alledging of Scripture for it , shewed to be the grossest Absurdity . Their great Text 1 Tim. 3. 15. spoken to . Her Tyranny over mens Minds further shewed . pag. 254. CHAP. XVII . Where it is shewed , Secondly , That Popery is as great an Enemy as can be to Christian Liberty . And First , To that Liberty which our Saviour hath purchased for the World in general . As 1. That it tendeth as much as is possible to the Corrupting of mens Souls by subjecting them to vile Affections . This shewed in the general , viz. in that it is apt to beget false Notions of God ; and more particularly , in that it brings men under the Power of the Lusts of Malice , Revenge , Cruelty ; Pride and Ambition ; Covetousness ; Uncleanness ; Intemperance ; and the greatest Injustice and Unrighteousness . 2. That it no less tendeth to Disquiet mens Minds with certain troublesome Passions . pag. 272. CHAP. XVIII . The Third Particular discoursed on , viz. That the Admirable Method our Lord hath taken to Instate us in our Christian Liberty , is made lamentably Ineffectual by Popery . This shewed as to each of those four Particulars that Method consists of . The Second Head briefly spoken to , viz. That Popery is also the greatest Enemy to that Liberty Christ purchased for the Jews in Particular . A Pathetical Exhortation to a higher valuing of the Priviledges we enjoy in the Church of England concludes the Chapter . pag. 299. CHAP. XIX . The Fourth Inference , That he onely is a true Christian , that looks upon himself as obliged to be no less Watchful over his Heart and the frame and temper of his Mind , than over his Life and Conversation . pag. 318. CHAP. XX. The Last Inference , Viz. That the most Proper and Genuine Christian Obedience is that which hath most of Liberty in it ; namely , that which proceeds from the Principle of Love to God and Goodness . pag. 322 ERRATA . PAge 247. line 15. for Six , read Thirty Six . Page 259. line 6. after Controversie , add this Parenthesis ( if they could be ingenuous . ) Page 287. line 17. after opportunities for , add or in order to . A DISCOURSE OF Christian Liberty . The Introduction . THERE is nothing toward which Mankind is more naturally or vehemently affected than Freedom and Liberty ; there is so great a value and price set upon it , that Life it self is not thought too precious to be hazarded or laid down for it : And many have rather chosen to die by their Enemies hands than to be inslaved by them . It was the saying of Cato , Malui mori quàm uni parere , I had rather die than that one man ( meaning Iulius Caesar ) should Lord it over me : And he was as good as his word , he laid violent hands upon himself rather than that Usurper should be his Master . The Jewish Nation , being besieged in Ierusalem , thought it more Eligible to suffer the most direful Calamities , such as are not to be parallel'd in any other History , than yield themselves Captives to Titus , and put their Necks under the Roman Yoke . Both single persons and Communities esteem all their other Enjoyments but little worth , whilest Liberty is wanting , nor hath any one thing occasioned so much Bloudshed in the world , as the Defence or Recovery of Liberty . Though Tacitus tells us , that 't was greatly deliberated among the Gallican Cities , whether Liberty or Peace was to be preferred , yet ordinarily , without the least consultation , when these two stand in competition , the former is chosen , and Peace is forced to give way to and sold for Liberty . There is no Suffering so impatiently born as the loss , or but Infringment of Liberty , nor are any looked upon as such Enemies to Mankind , or have so hateful a character , as the Invaders of it . But yet as inamoured with Liberty as we all are , the generality are lamentably ignorant of its true nature , and wherein it mainly and principally consisteth . A Spartan being asked , Quid sciret ? replied , Scio quid est liberum esse : I know what Liberty and Freedom meaneth : But I fear there are very few Comparatively that can truly return this answer ; nay , that most are so strangely mistaken in this matter , as to account the worst of Slaveries the most desirable Liberty , and the chiefest of Liberties the most intolerable Slavery . But if we will believe our Blessed Saviour , who , being the Wisdom of the Father , can best inform us , we shall be satisfied that there is no Liberty like that which is of his bestowing : He hath said , Iohn 8. 36. If the Son shall make you free , ye shall be free indeed , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , ye shall be really free , and not only in shew , in outward appearance and opinion ; you shall be in the truest and most excellent sence free . Which words do plainly tell us , that all other Liberties are unworthy of that name , in comparison of that which is conferred by himself . And what I now said of Liberty in the general , may as truly be affirmed of Christian Liberty , viz. First , That there is nothing hath raised more dust , or occasioned more sad feuds in the Christian World than this hath done : The great Ball of Contention hath been Christian Liberty , among the professed Disciples of Christ. Such an opinion is conceived of it , that 't is never thought too dearly bought . This is the Good Old Cause , for which multitudes have been very liberal of both their Fortunes and Lives ; and no one thing hath been esteemed better , if so well , deserving the price of bloud . The pretence of Christian Liberty is of all other the most Plausible and Popular , and nothing hath been more unhappily successful in raising Tumults and exciting the People to take the Field . Nay , this hath been held so Sacred a thing ( if it be lawful to judge of mens opinions by their practices ) as to be able to hallow the unholiest actions , and to sanctifie the most apparently wicked , when designed for the preserving or regaining thereof . And therefore . Secondly , Too many that are called Christians ( as I should not need to add ) must needs very grosly mistake the nature of that they are so fond of . And , as great zeal as they shew for Christian Liberty , do as little desire that which really is so , and is the chiefest instance of it . Upon which account I presume 't will be thought no needless labour to endeavour to rectifie mens apprehensions about the nature of this Liberty . And in order hereunto I design , with Gods assistance , to shew in the following Discourse , First , That the most excellent and most highly to be valued Liberty doth consist in an intire compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness ; or in freedom from the dominion of corrupt and sinful Affections . Secondly , That herein that Liberty principally , or rather wholly consisteth , which our Blessed Saviour hath purchased for us , and in his Gospel proclaimed to us . Which two Propositions being demonstrated , we shall Thirdly , Draw distinctly from each several useful inferences , where particularly the false notions which too many have conceived of Christian Liberty shall be effectually confuted . SECT . I. That the most excellent and most highly to be valued Liberty doth consist in an intire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness : Or in Freedom from the dominion of corrupt and sinful Affections . CHAP. I. This shewed in the General from Texts of Scripture , and further confirmed by those who were strangers to Divine Revelation . NOW in the General that this is so , those forecited words of our Saviour , Iohn 8. 36. do give us assurance : For the Freedom which Christ there commends as the true Freedom by way of Eminence is this from the dominion of sin and corrupt affections . This will appear by considering the Context : Our Saviour having said , verse 31 , 32. to those Iews that believed on him , If you continue inmy words , then are ye my disciples indeed , and ye shall know the truth , and the truth shall make you free ; It follows ver . 33. They answered him , we be Abrahams seed , and were never in bondage to any man , how sayest thou , ye shall be made free . They answered , not the Believers , but some of the Company that came with no good design , We be Abrahams seed , we are not descended from the Canaanites or other servile people , but from Abraham , and from him , not by Hagar the Bond-woman , but by Sarah the Free-woman , We are of a Generous and Illustrious extract ; And were never in bondage to any man , as we were not born slaves , so neither have at any time been made slaves . But how could they say this , whenas they were formerly in bondage , both to the Egyptians and Babylonians , with divers others , and even now subjected to the power of the Romans ? The truth is , if they spake this concerning their Nation , the saying was an impudent and loud Falshood , as it is usual for men when they are vaunting and boasting , to make bold with truth ; but if they understood it of their own particulars , and they meant that they were not in Personal servitude , had not lost their natural Liberty as Men , though they were in a Political servitude as a Nation , their saying that they were Abrahams seed came in impertinently . It follows ver . 34. Iesus answered them , Verily verily I say unto you , whosoever committeth sin is the Servant of sin . He that is a worker of iniquity , is inslaved and brought into a servile state thereby : Ver. 35. And the servant abideth not in the house for ever , but the Son abideth for ever . Or those who are in this servile state , under sin , though they may for a time be members of Gods houshold , they shall at length be for ever Cast out , but the Son hath a right to continue there , and to the enjoyment of his Fathers Inheritance . Then next follow those words , If the Son therefore shall make you free , ye shall be free indeed . So that the Freedom which our Lord speaks of , ver . 32. being deliverance from the power of Sin , as appears by his explaining himself , ver . 34. It is manifest that he meaneth the same thing in these words , and consequently does in them give testimony to what we are now designing to prove , that to be rescued from under the dominion of our Lusts is Freedom and Liberty indeed , the true and most excellent Liberty . And of this the holy David was very sensible , when he uttered those words , Psal. 119. 45. I will walk at liberty , for I seek thy precepts . Whereby he signified , that the ways of Gods Commandments , though they seem to the fleshly and sensual strait and narrow , and though such look upon those that walk in them as too much confined and abridged of Liberty ; yet the spirit of a Regenerate and Good man finds no where such Freedom and Enlargement as in those ways . And therefore when he lapsed into those two hainous and provoking sins , he felt himself exceedingly straitned , and his Spirit was miserably pent up and contracted : As appears by that prayer in his Penitential Psalm , Psal. 51. 12. Restore to me the joy of thy salvation , and uphold ( or establish ) me with thy free Spirit . Or rather , with a free Spirit . In 2 Pet. 2. 19. the Apostle , speaking of a sort of wicked people , who were industrious to make others as vile as themselves , saith , that While they promise them liberty , they themselves are the servants of corruption , for of whom a man is overcome , of the same is he brought in bondage . They inticed others to all manner of carnality and filthiness , and tempted those that were clean escaped from the pollutions of the world to relapse into them , and this they did by the plausible pretence of giving them Liberty ; but alas ( saith the Apostle ) they themselves are the most wretched and miserable of Slaves , having yielded themselves up to their vile affections , and being under the power and command of Tyrannical Lusts. And Heathens have divers of them discoursed this excellently , and were great Masters of this Notion : That he who is gotten from under the dominion of his Sensitive part , and lives agreeably to the Dictates of Right Reason , and the Will of God , is the only Free Man. Arrian in his third Book upon Epictetus spends some time in shewing , that the true Liberty consisteth in the obedience of our Appetites to the Divine Will. And in his first Book , that there is no true bondage but that which ariseth from the Prevalence of Evil Affections ; and that a Good man can never be in real Slavery , though he be in his Enemies hands , that then his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , his Carkass only is taken Captive , but he himself is as Free still as ever . And he gives Diogenes for an instance , who having been set free from his corrupt Appetites by his Master Antisthenes , would deny that it was possible for any one to make a Slave of him , and , being taken by Pirates , behaved himself in their hands like one that was more their Lord than their Vassal . And this is one of the Stoical Paradoxes which Tully discourseth very bravely upon : That all wise men ( whereby they meant good men ) are free men , but all fools ( whereby they meant bad men ) are slaves . And under this head Tully , shewing who deserves the Title of Emperor , hath this saying , Let him bridle his lusts , despise pleasures , suppress anger , subdue a covetous humour , and other vicious affections : Then may be begin to take upon him the government of others , when he shall have ceased to be under the government of those most cruel Lords , shame and Turpitude , but whilest he yields obedience to these , as he ought not to be accounted an Emperor , so neither so much as a Free-man . Again he saith a little after . If Slavery be the Obedience of a broken , abject and base mind , and of a man that hath no power over himself , as it is , then who can deny that allwanton , all covetous , and lastly , all bad people whatsoever are very Slaves ? CHAP. II. That the most excellent Freedom and Liberty consists in the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness , more distinctly and particularly demonstrated by three Arguments . Of which the First is that this is Freedom from the worst and vilest of Slaveries . Where it is shewed in three particulars , that the Transgressors of those Laws are the most Slavish Creatures . IT may moreover be more distinctly and particularly proved , that the most excellent Freedom and Liberty consisteth in the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness by these following Arguments . First , This is Freedom from the worst and vilest of Slaveries . Secondly , This is the Liberty of the Soul. Thirdly , This is the Divine Liberty , the Liberty of God himself . First , This is Freedom from the worst and vilest of Slaveries . And that there is no such Slavish Creature as he who lives in the transgression of these Laws ( as the wicked man ) doth plainly appear , in that , First , His whole man , both Soul and Body is inslaved . Those who are Slaves in the vulgar sence , that are taken captive by the Turk , or such like merciless and inhumane Masters , are necessarily inslaved only as to their Viler part , their Bodies : It lieth not in the power of any man on Earth to inslave a Soul. The Mind and Will of him , who , as to his Outward man , is the most absolute Vassal to the Lusts of others , may retain their Liberty still in spight of them . No Tyrant can make me either think , or chuse , or love , or desire what he pleaseth . Where all the members of the Body are under constraint , the Soul may continue free in all its powers , no external Force is able to inthral that . But he who lives in disobedience to the Laws of Righteousness is perfectly inslaved , his whole man hath lost its Liberty . As his Body is at the command and dispose of his Lusts , as each of its members are Ministers of Unrighteousness , and made to fulfil the will of the flesh , so his Soul is subjected to their power and dominion , and his Slavery begins there . His Mind , Will and Affections are first subdued and brought into bondage by fleshly and impure Lusts , and then his Body is ingaged in the filthy drudgery of making provision for them , of gratifying them and giving satisfaction to them . That is the meaning of those words of S. Iames , Then when lust hath conceived , it bringeth forth sin , Chap. 1. 15. Secondly , The wicked man is thus subject to the Vilest and Basest of Masters . Such a one ( to repeat those words of Tully ) doth parere dedecori & turpitudini , is at the command of vile shame and filthiness it self . What is Sordid Covetousness , Swinish Lust , Beastly Intemperance , Devilish Rage and Malice , what I say are all these less than so ? To which I may add those other hateful Qualities of Fraud , Dissimulation , Envy , Pride , Selfishness , and the like . But some or other , nay most of these are all wicked men , servants to , and over-powered by . If Tully could say of the Lustful man , An ille mihi liber videtur cui mulier imperat ? Shall I think him a freeman who is at the command of a woman ? And if Arrian could say , What , miserable wretch , dost thou fancy thy self free , who art 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Slave of a Wench , and a vile sorry Wench too ; well may I say , what a wretched Slave art thou then , who art under the dominion of so many base , vile , opprobrious , shameful and hateful things ? To be subject to any one of these is vile Servitude ; what is it then to be at the command of so many such Masters , to serve divers Lusts ( as the Apostles expression is , Titus 3. 3. ) and all most vile , base and brutish . Thirdly , The wicked man is also inslaved by the most Tyrannical and Cruel Masters . Indeed 't is rare that the Base prove other than Cruel whensoever they happen to get into power . Having understood who are this mans Masters , we must needs be satisfied , that they are not more vile than they are Tyrannical . And their Tyranny is shewed in requiring the most Vnreasonable services , and the most Vneasie . Their Commands must necessarily be most unreasonable in that they themselves are so . The forementioned vile Affections , and the like , are therefore Vile , because perfect contradictions to the Reason of mens Minds , and degradations of the Humane and Intellectual Nature : Because they Brutifie mens Souls , yea , and make them more Vile than the Beasts which perish . In short , he who obeys these Masters preferreth the Creature before the Creator , God blessed for ever : He forsakes the fountain of living waters , and heweth out to himself broken Cisterns which can hold no water : His Body is far more dear to him than his Soul , and he esteems slight and momentany satisfactions and pleasures , above the most Substantial and Eternal . He fears the displeasure of a poor Creature , and some very tolerable and small evil , more than the wrath of the Omnipotent God , and than Hell it self . He is ever doing that which the sence of his own Mind upbraids him with , and what he knows before hand he shall wish undone as soon as done . In a word , he is always contradicting the Great Design of his Creation and coming into Being . Such things as these ( as I need not stand to shew ) do the Lusts of wicked men put them upon doing , such services as these are they perpetually imploying them in . And what we said of the Vnreasonableness of their commands speaks them also Vneasie , Grievous and Troublesome . It is impossible for a Creature to act contrary to its Nature and Essential principles , but it must needs feel much Pain in so doing ; the more Unnatural any thing is , the more Disquieting and Tormenting must it necessarily be . The very presence of evil Affections in the Soul must needs make it as uneasie , as evil Humours do the Body ; what then will the gratifying , the Nourishing and Cherishing them do ? I appeal to the Covetous and Ambitious , to the immoderate Lovers of Riches and Honours , to such Lovers of Wine , and such Lovers of Women , to the Revengeful and Malicious , and the like , whether they do not feel excessive disturbance and perturbation of Mind , from the several passions that denominate them such ; and whether the Pain they cause to their Souls , be not incomparably greater and more lasting , than the pleasure which their Flesh or Sensitive part receiveth from them . Add hereunto the grievous Disquiet and Torment that is occasioned by Reflecting upon the past pleasing and gratifying a Lust. Tully hath an excellent observation to this purpose , When a Lust hath ceased to exercise its dominion for a while , or to employ its vassal in new drudgery , he is not for that time at ease , but another Lord immediately tyrannizeth over him , viz. the Dread that ariseth from consciousness of Guilt , oh what a miserable slavery and bondage is this ! And ( by the way ) methinks it should much affect us , to find a Heathen expressing such a sense of the intolerable Slavery men are brought into by satisfying their Lusts. I might add further , that mens Lusts have no moderation with them neither , though ( as that Philosopher supposeth ) they may , after their commands are obeyed , for a while cease to command again , yet it is but for a very little while ; before the sinner hath recovered his spent spirits , they lay new burdens on his weary shoulders . What the Apostle saith of those who have eyes full of Adultery that they cannot cease from sin , is as true of those who are under the dominion of any lust whatsoever : And what Horace observes of the Tyranny of sensual Love , may as well be applied to every other corrupt Affection , namely , Vrget enim mentem dominus non lenis , & acres Subjectat lasso stimulos . This cruel Lord th' unhappy Creature rides , And , when be-jaded , claps sharp spurs to 's sides . I might moreover shew , were it needful , that the service which mens Lusts exact from them , is such as ordinarily is of fatal consequence to their Estates and Bodies as well as Souls , but there is nothing to which universal observation in all Ages , and Sinners Experience gives clearer evidence . I might also in the last place , shew , that mens Lusts do deliver up their Servants to the power of the Devil , such being said to be in his snare , and to be taken captive by him at his will , 2 Tim. 2. 26. And no man , I hope , shall need to be informed , what a Tyrant and Tormenter the Devil is . But enough hath been said of the service of Sin to make us cry out with the Philosopher in the forementioned words , Quàm illa misera , quàm dura Servitus ! What miserable and cruel Slavery is that Service ! Enough , I say , hath been said to assure us , that no Slavery is comparable to this , and consequently , that the careful observance of the Laws of Righteousness is the true , and most Glorious Liberty , in that , Freedom from such Bondage is implied therein , as is not to be found in any other sort of Liberty . CHAP. III. That the Liberty which resulteth from the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness , is the Liberty of the Soul : and how it is so , is shewed in four Particulars . SEcondly , The Liberty which resulteth from the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness is the truest and most excellent of Liberties , in that it is the Liberty and Freedom of the Soul. As this is apparent by what hath been already discoursed , so we may further take notice , that by the Observance of these Laws the Soul comes to be enlarged , to have Self-enjoyment , and to be as it would be , in that it is by this means delivered from those Passions which straiten , confine and pend it up , and put it into a Slavish state . Those Passions are chiefly , Fear , Shame , Trouble and Dejection of Mind , and an immoderate love to our own Bodily and particular concerns . And the Opposites to these do give the Soul great Enlargement and Liberty , viz. That Confidence that is opposite both to Fear and to Shame , Delight and joy , which are opposite to Trouble and Dejection of Mind , and Generosity and Nobleness of Spirit , whereby a man is carried forth to the loving of God the Chief Good in the first place , and a hearty concern for the general welfare of his Fellow-Creatures , which is opposite to immoderate Self-love . First , The Observance of the Rules of Righteousness casteth out Fear . This is a most servile Passion ; the Apostle speaketh of some , who through fear of ●●ath were all their life-time subject to bondage . By Fear I mean that which is expressed by the Greek word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , a cowardly and dispiriting Fear . None can imagine I mean 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , an Awful and Reverential Fear , such as is called , Heb. 12. 28. a Godly fear : Nor yet do I mean such a Fear as awakens and excites the Soul to the use of means for the shunning and keeping off evils . Such a Fear as this doth not at all inslave or put a man out of his own power , but is highly serviceable to the maintenance and preservation of Liberty . And therefore it is commended to us by the Apostle , Heb. 4. 1. Let us therefore fear lest a promise being left us of entering into his rest , any of you should seem to come short of it . But , as was said , the Fear which is enslaving is a Cowardly Dispiriting Fear , and this the Righteous and Good man is freed from . He hath not received the spirit of bondage again to fear , in this sence , but the spirit of Adoption whereby he crieth Abba Father , Rom. 8. 15. He is not afraid of God as a poor Slave is of his fierce Master , or as a wicked Servant of his justly provoked and incensed Lord ; but not being under the guilt of wilful sins , his Conscience being privy to no other guilt than that which upon good grounds he believes is expiated by the Bloud of Iesus , he can go to God as a child to his loving and tender Father . And as he hath no tumultuary , confounding or disheartening fear of God , so neither hath he of the Devil or Men , or any worldly evil ; as knowing that all these are subject to the restraint of that good Providence which ever chargeth it self with the care of good Souls and all their concerns . God hath not given him the Spirit of fear ( or timidity and fearfulness ) but of power , of love , and of a sound mind , 2 Tim. 1. 7. This man is an affectionate Lover of God , and therefore cannot question God's love to him , and is assured that all things shall work together for his good , for his good both in this life , and in the life to come . Herein is our love made perfect , saith S. Iohn in his 1 Epistle 4. 17. because as he is , so are we in this world ( because we follow the example of our Blessed Saviour in the conscientious observance of the Rules of Righteousness ) there is no fear in love , but perfect love casteth out fear , because fear hath torment , he that feareth is not made perfect in love : That is , he that is affected with such a fear as hath now been described . He who is not under the power of Cowardizing , dismaying Fear , his Spirit is at great Liberty ; but a care to keep an inoffensive Conscience both towards God and men , to adhere to the Rules of Righteousness and Goodness , and never to swerve from them , will banish this Fear . The wicked ( saith the Wise man ) fleeth when no man pursueth , but the righteous is bold as a Lion , Prov. 28. 1. He that walketh uprightly , walketh surely : or confidently and securely , Prov. 9. 10. To which great truth the Poet gives his Testimony in those known Verses ; Integer vitae scelerisque purus Non eget Mauri jaculis nec arcu , &c. He that 's in life upright and pure in heart Is too secure to need the Bow or Dart. — hic murus aheneus esto Nil conscire sibi , nullâ & pallescere culpâ . The strongest Bulwark's not so sure a Fence As is an inoffensive Conscience . Secondly , True Goodness begets that confidence which is opposed , as to Fear so , to Shame too . There is a highly commendable shame , which is proper to a Good man , namely that which is expressed by the Latine Verecundia : Which is a quick sense of whatsoever is indecorous and misbecoming . No man can have too much of this , for the more any one hath of it , the better man must he necessarily be . But there is another sort of Shame expressed by Pudor , which is a troublesome passion arising from a sense of disgrace , upon consciousness of Guilt . Of this Shame , the most learned Doctor Henry More observeth in his incomparable Ethicks , that it neither falleth upon the worst nor the best of men . For he who is conscious to himself that he constantly exerciseth his liberty in doing the best things , knows that he ought not to be contemned , and thereupon , being above all contempt , contempt it self is contemned by him ; which is a great instance , in good men , of Generosity , but in bad men , is the very height of improbity . This Shame is a good effect of a bad cause , for though it be an evil , yet 't is a necessary evil , and tends to the deterring men from unworthy actions for the time to come , and doth actually produce this good effect where the great uneasiness and perturbation of mind which was caused thereby upon past commissions of sin , is seriously and consideratively reflected upon . For where this Shame is , there is great Bondage , where there is consciousness of guilt , the mind of a man is miserably pent up , confined and straitned , so that he dares many times neither to look abroad into the world , nor to look up to Heaven , nor reflect upon himself . And therefore Liberty and Confidence are expressed by the same word ( viz. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ) in the Greek language . But while a man is careful in the observance of the Laws of Righteousness , to be Righteous before God , and to walk ( as it is said of Zacharias and Elizabeth ) in all the Commandments and Ordinances of the Lord blameless , he is not affected with this kind of Shame , and consequently enjoys a mighty Freedom by this means . Upright Iob had the happy experience of this effect of uprightness ; as we find Chap. 31. 35 , 36 , 37. Oh that one would hear me , ( saith he ) behold my desire is , that the Almighty would answer me , and that mine Adversary had written a book . Surely I would take it upon my shoulder , and bind it as a Crown unto me . I would declare to him the number of my steps , as a Prince would I go near unto him . Which is as much as if he had said , Oh that mine Adversary instead of secretly whispering evil things of me , had drawn up a charge in writing against me : I would be so far from endeavouring to have it concealed , that I would my self publish it to all the world , and instead of thinking it a disgrace and disparagement , I would esteem it as an ornament ; for my innocence would be the more cleared , and my good name vindicated by the means of it . And so far would I be from sneaking and skulking in corners , like one ashamed to shew his head , that I would like a Prince with Heroick courage and confidence go up to the face of mine Enemy , and expose and lay open my whole life before him . Or rather we will read these Verses as the sence of them is expressed in a late excellent Paraphrase upon this Book : Oh that the truth of all this [ that I have been accused of ] might be examined by some equal judge ! Behold I continue still to desire of God this favour : And let him that can accuse me , bring in his Libel in writing against me . Surely I would not endeavour to obscure it , but openly expose it to be read by all ; nay wear it as a singular ornament , which would turn to mine honour , when the world saw it disproved . I my self would assist him to draw up his charge , by declaring to him freely every action of my life : I would approach him as undauntedly as a Prince , who is assured of the goodness of his cause . These words , with many other of his sayings , shew , what a blessed Liberty the Soul of this Holy man was possessed with , even whilest he was deprived of all his outward comforts , and in the saddest and most dismal circumstances . Thirdly , Nothing will free a man from Trouble and Dejection of mind , like the careful observance of the Laws of Righteousness . This as it is a certain consequent of Fear and Shame , it must needs free a man from , as it freeth from those its Causes : But it incomparably beyond any thing in the world cureth this Malady of a wounded spirit how or by whatsoever it be occasioned . I have shewed that it is the fate of Sinners to feel great perturbation and disturbance of mind from their corrupt Affections , by the law in their members warring against the law of their minds , and also by reflecting upon their folly and madness , and by the fearful expectations that their manifold bold transgressions of the Divine Laws do raise in them . The wicked ( saith the Prophet ) are like the troubled Sea , which cannot rest , whose waters cast up mire and dirt : There is no peace , saith my God , to the wicked . Cain had no sooner given place to Envy and Revenge , but his Countenance fell , and the Disquiet of his mind was bewrayed by his looks . But there is no such Lightsomness and Sprightfulness of Soul , no such Pleasure and Self-satisfaction as that which results from true Religion , Righteousness and Goodness . It 's ways are ways of pleasantness , and all its paths peace , Prov. 3. 17. Light is sown for the Righteous , and joy for the Vpright in heart , Psal. 97. 11. Great peace have they that love thy law , and nothing shall offend them , Psal. 119. 165. The work of Rigteousness shall be peace , and the effect of Righteousness quietness , and assurance for ever , Esay 32. 17. The Good man is free from self-accusations , and from that gnawing Worm that is frequently felt in Guilty breasts . He is not appalled in thinking of what is past , nor cast down with the fore-thought of that which is to come . His Soul is like a calm and clear River , like the waters of Siloam which run softly , without noise or murmur . Whatsoever is Natural is for that reason highly pleasing , but nothing so natural to the Heaven-born Soul of man , nothing is so agreeable to our original Make , as to live in conformity to the Laws of Righteousness . Whilest this is our serious care , we act according to our Highest principle , that Principle which God and Nature designed for our 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , our Leader and Governour , I mean the Reason of our Minds . And therefore so long as we follow its Dictates , and behave our selves like those on whose souls the Divine image is imprinted , which consisteth in Righteousness and true Holiness , so long I say we live in our own Element , and therefore must necessarily have Self-enjoyment : And we shall enjoy our selves more or less according as we are more or less diligent in works of Righteousness and Goodness . The experience of every Good man will force him to subscribe to the truth of this ; no such man can withhold his assent from it , or call it into question any more than he can his own Feeling . Such a one feels such serenity of thoughts , and such great delight and satisfaction of mind in the exercise of love to God and love to men , in works of Piety , Justice and Charity , in the exercise of Humility , Meekness , Patience and Submission to the Divine will , and all other Christian Graces and Virtues , that , while he is so employed , all is as well within him as he can desire ; he accounts it a Heaven upon Earth to be so employed . I fear that many a one who would be thought a Christian cannot receive this Doctrine , that it seems to him a very strange Soloecism ; but I could tell him of many a Heathen of whom he may learn it as well as of Christians ; particularly Tully , who hath this brave saying in his Tusculan Questions : O Philosophy the Guide of our lives ! O thou seeker out of Virtues , and expeller of Vices ! One day well spent , and in obedience to thy precepts , ought to be preferred before a sinning immortality . And all those say for substance the self-same thing , who tell us , that Virtue is a Reward to it self . The Good man feels also no small pleasure in reflecting upon the fruits of Righteousness he hath brought forth : And much more in the Contemplation of that Glorious Reward , which God for Christ's sake hath promised to those who patiently persevere in well-doing . The fore-expectation whereof doth greatly support him under all the crosses and afflictions wherewith he is exercised in this life : And makes him not only Patient under those Tribulations he meets with for Righteousness sake , but even to Glory in them , as the Apostles did and Primitive Christians . And moreover , he receiveth great Refreshment and Comfort more immediately from the Holy Ghost , especially when he is called forth to any exceedingly great suffering , or extraordinary service . He then marvellously strengthens the Good man with strength in his Soul to bear the one and perform the other as becomes a servant of Iesus Christ. Which he doth chiefly by giving sensible , clear and lively representations to the Good mans mind of the Glory of Heaven , and by stedfastly fixing it upon the Crown of Righteousness and Life , which his Blessed Lord hath promised to all those who are faithful to the Death . Thus was the first Christian Martyr S. Stephen strengthened , who being full of the Holy Ghost looked up stedfastly into Heaven , and saw the Glory of God , saw the Heavens opened , as ready to receive him , and the Son of man standing on the right hand of God. And in the same manner have innumerable of his Followers been since strengthened ; and among others not a few of our own Country people who were burnt at stakes by the Bloudy Papists in the Reign of Queen Mary . And if ever such days should come again ( as God grant they may not ) all sincerely good Souls , who are sensible of their own weakness , and intirely confide in the power of Iesus , shall undoubtedly be enabled to suffer with great Patience and Constancy , if not with great Ioyfulness also and triumphantly . And indeed without this more immediate and special Divine Assistance , we could not well hope to endure a Fiery trial . All External encouragements , such is the infirmity of our Natures , accompanied but with the ordinary assistance of the Divine Grace , are like little to avail us in the hour of such a temptation . And the reason is , because we shall be in great danger of being totally deprived of the power of considering by very acute pain and torment : And a vigorous powerful sense of the Glory of Heaven , is necessary to our bearing with patience , and much more with joyfulness the sharpest sort of Tribulations ; the mere Belief thereof would certainly have but a very weak influence in such a circumstance . And therefore ( as was said ) all Good Souls may confidently expect extraordinary Assistance , whensoever they are called out to extraordinary sufferings . God is faithful ( saith the Apostle ) who will not suffer you to be tempted above what you are able , &c. 1. Cor. 10. 13. Now then , who after all this shall need to be told , what a Glorious Liberty of Soul is obtainable by the careful observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness ? But this will yet further appear , if we consider that , Fourthly , It delivereth from all immoderate self-love . Such a love of our selves as ties us down and determines us to our own bodily and particular concerns . A worthy person , in a Discourse of the Excellency of true Religion hath a saying to our present purpose well worth our reciting , viz. that Wicked men are of most narrow and confined Spirits , they are so contracted by the pinching particularities of Earthly and Created things , so imprisoned in the dark dungeon of Sensuality and Selfishness , so straitned through their carnal designs and ends , that they cannot stretch themselves , nor look beyond the Horizon of time and sense . And there he observeth , that Plato hath long since concluded concerning the condition of Sensual men , that They live 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , like a Shell-Fish , and can never move up and down , but in their own Prison , which they ever carry about with them . But true Religion and Goodness is so Generous and Noble a Principle , that he who is acted thereby cannot be confined to himself and his own things . His Soul is not imprisoned within himself , that is , within his own particular Being separated from the rest of the World ; but is enlarged by an Universal Charity , by a sincere good will to God's whole Creation . He hath an hearty concern for the good of the World , and carries on no designs for himself which are opposite thereunto , nor any other but such as some way or other do tend to promote the welfare and happiness of his Fellow-creatures : And 't is the greatest pleasure to his mind imaginable , to be instrumental thereunto . Again , his Soul is not tied down to any inferior good things , his love and desires are not terminated on such objects , but they are so extensive as to stretch themselves far beyond this world , and fix upon the Original and Supreme Good , and there to Centre . The Language of this man is the same with holy David ' s , Whom have I in Heaven but God , and there is nothing upon the Earth I desire in comparison of him . Though he hath a kindness for things below , yet his thoughts and affections are not confined to them , but soar aloft to him who is the Author of them , and from whom all the goodness that is in them is derived . Whereas ( as the foresaid Author expresseth it ) All the Freedom that wicked men have , is but like that of Banished men , to wander up and down in the Wilderness of this World , from one Den and Cave to another . And he saith before , that Tully could see so much in his Natural Philosophy , as made him to say , Scientia naturae ampliat animum & ad divina attollit : The knowledge of Nature enlargeth and dilates the mind , and carrieth it up to Divine things . But this is most true of Religion , that in an higher sence it doth work the Soul into a true and divine Amplitude . And thus have we shewed , that the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness gives the most excellent Liberty , in that the Liberty which results from thence is the Liberty of the Soul ; and also how the Soul is thereby set at Liberty . CHAP. IV. That this is the Liberty of God himself , and his most excellent Liberty . THirdly , I proceed to shew , that the Liberty which ariseth from the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness is the Divine Liberty , the Liberty of God himself , and his most Excellent Liberty . God Almighty is of all Beings infinitely the most unlimited and uncontroulable by any thing without himself . He doth whatsoever pleaseth him , in Heaven , the Earth , the Sea and all deep places . The whole Universe is in his hands as the Clay in the hands of the Potter , perfectly under his power , and at his dispose , so that there is no resisting him , nor hindering one thought of his . But as unboundable as his Will and Power are by any thing without him , they are both determined , by the internal Rectitude and Goodness of his Nature , to things Holy , Just and Good. He is so great a lover of Equity and Goodness , that he can neither do or will any thing , that is contrary or not agreeable thereunto . We read that He is a Rock whose work is perfect , and all his ways are judgment , a God of truth and without iniquity , just and right is he . That it is impossible for God to lye . That his ways are right and equal , and his judgment according to truth . That the judge of all the Earth will do right , and that he will not lay upon man more than is right , that he should enter into judgment with God. That he is of purer eyes than to behold evil , and cannot look on iniquity ( i. e. ) with approbation . That the righteous Lord loveth righteousness , and his countenance beholdeth the upright . That he is not tempted with evil ( is uncapable of the least inclination towards it ) neither tempteth he any man : Can not tempt any man to evil , and much less by any Decree determine him . That he is good unto all , and his tender mercies are over all his works . That he is full of compassion and long-suffering . That he hath no pleasure in the death of the wicked , but that the wicked man turn from his way and live . And a multitude of such Declarations we find in the Holy Scriptures , which abundantly speak the Divine Will and Power to be inseparably conjoyned with Righteousness and Goodness ; and never in the least to swerve from either . And if any such providences have fallen under our notice at any time , or come to our knowledge , which we have been to seek satisfactorily to reconcile with the Rules of Righteousness or Goodness , we ought to take occasion from thence to be humbled under a sense of our own short-sightedness and shallowness of Understanding , and to take great heed how we charge our Creator with that , which he hath so often professed to loath and abominate . Now let us observe , that this determination of God's Will and Power from within himself to things Just and Good , is that which gives a greater lustre to his Nature , and far more speaks him the most Excellent and most Happy Being , than his mere unlimitableness by any thing without him . Nay , Uncontroulableness and Absolute Soveraignty would make him so much the Worse , and less Happy Being , except the exercise thereof were determined by a Holy , Good and Righteous Nature . If God Almighty were made up of Will , and every thing were in it self indifferent to him , and he did this or that merely because 't is his pleasure so to do , he would ( I say ) be infinitely the Worse Being , for his Absolute Sovereignty and Uncontroulable Power . What is it that makes the Devils , the most vile and hateful of all Creatures , is it not this , that they are Spirits indued with great Strength and Power , with great Knowledge , Sagacity and quickness of Understanding , and with large Dominions , though Usurped , but have lost that integrity of Nature , and those good Principles , whereby they should govern themselves , and be determined in the exercise of their Power and Wisdom ? 'T is certain , they would be nothing so mischievous and wicked as they are , if with the loss of their Moral endowments , they had also been divested of their Natural : I mean their Strength and Power , their Knowledge and Acuteness of Understanding . The Devils are in these far more like to God , than any of us Men are in a possibility of being ( at least in this life ) but notwithstanding this , they are of all his Creation the most unlike God ; namely , because their great Power and Knowledge are utterly unacquainted with , and estranged from , Righteousness and Goodness ; are altogether employed in most unrighteous and wicked designs and enterprises . So that irresistible power and All-comprehending knowledge are so far from denominating a Being the most Absolutely perfect considered alone , that That would be the worst Being in the world , which is supposed to have those perfections , and is made to be the worst by those perfections , if they do not exert themselves in Righteous and Good actions , but the contrary : if the exercise of them be not determined by Rules and Principles of Righteousness and Goodness . And in saying that a Being will be the worse for Power and Knowledge , &c. separated from Goodness , I say also it will be the more unhappy : For the worse any one is , the less satisfaction he must needs take in himself , and the less he will necessarily have of self-enjoyment ; as hath been already shewed . Now , considering what hath been said , 't is most apparent that the Divine Liberty , the most excellent Liberty of God himself , is his absolute Freedom to Good , his being perfectly unbyassed by any evil Affection , and infinitely out of the reach of corrupt Appetites , so that he can as soon cease to be , as fail to exercise his Almighty power , his Omniscience and Unsearchable Wisdom , in doing what is most fit , most right and equal . This is the Liberty , which most highly commends the infinitely best of Beings , and therefore 't is that which will make us poor Mortals most like to him , and partakers of the Divine Nature . And thus it is sufficiently , I presume , demonstrated , that the most Excellent Liberty consisteth in , or results from , the Observance of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness . And to shew , that this is eminently ( nay and solely too ) our Christian Liberty will be the business of the next Section . SECT . II. That this Freedom to holy Obedience and true Goodness , or which consisteth in an intire compliance with the Laws of Righteousness , is our Christian Liberty . THis Phrase Christian Liberty being so much in the mouths of people professing Christianity , one would think that nothing is better understood ; that there is no point of our Religion in the nature of which we less need to be instructed . We mightily insist upon our Christian Liberty , a very warm Zeal we seem to have for it , and we are not a little concerned ( as hath been already intimated ) when we apprehend it to be invaded , or in the least infringed . And if we be not mistaken in our notion of this Liberty , 't is most commendably done of us to contend earnestly for it , to refuse to part with it , or to consent to the smallest violation or abatement thereof upon any terms whatsoever . But alas , nothing is more misunderstood than Christian Liberty , and nothing hath been more abused ; and therefore 't is well worth our while rightly to state the notion of it , and to fix it where it ought to be . How it hath been mistaken and abused shall be shewn in its due place , our immediate business is , First , To Demonstrate the foresaid Proposition . Secondly , To shew what our Lord hath done to instate us in this our Christian Liberty . CHAP. V. The foresaid Proposition Demonstrated by four Arguments , viz. First , That this hath been proved to be the most Glorious Liberty . Secondly , This was that Liberty , the instating us wherein , was the whole business of our Saviour and his Apostles . Thirdly , Our Saviours Abolishing the Ceremonial Law was chiefly designed in order to the thorough effecting this Liberty : Where it is shewed , that this Law accidentally became very prejudicial to the great Design of setting men free from the power of their Lusts , in several particulars . Fourthly , That none but the Jews were obliged to the Observance of this Law. FIrst , We will demonstrate the truth of this Assertion , that Christian Liberty consisteth in Freedom to holy Obedience , in deliverance from the Power and Dominion of sin , together with the direful effects and consequents thereof : This we will do by these following Arguments . First , This is , as we have shewed , incomparably the best and most Glorious of Liberties , and therefore it must needs be ( at least principally and in the most eminent sence ) our Christian Liberty . For whatsoever Benefits our Blessed Lord is any where said to have procured for us , the absolutely best of the kind is always to be understood . For instance , whereas he saith , that he is come that we might have life , he means the best of Lives , the Spiritual life of the Soul here , and Eternal life hereafter . By the Riches he is said to bestow , is meant those whereby the Soul is inriched , the Divine Graces and Virtues , called by himself the true Riches . By the Salvation which he is the Author of , is meant that from the worst of evils principally , and everlasting Salvation . So proportionably , whenas the Son is said to make us free , the meaning is free with the best of Freedoms , viz. that from sin , as also we have seen is manifest from the Context . Whenas Christ is said to be Anointed , according to the Prophecy of Esay concerning him , to preach deliverance to the captives , and to set at liberty them that are bruised ( with being long fettered and shackled ) we are likewise to understand the same most desirable of all Liberties and Deliverances . Whereas S. Iames calls the Gospel the law of Liberty ( Chap. 1. 25. ) and the perfect law of Liberty , ( Chap. 2. 12. ) we are primarily to understand it ( as will be further shewn ) of this same Liberty which infinitely surpasseth all other . In which sence the Apostle S. Paul understood it to be The perfect law of Liberty , when he called it The law of the Spirit of life , which is in Christ Iesus , adding that , it had made him free from the law of Sin and death , Rom. 8. 2. Secondly , We find this Liberty was that , the instating us wherein , our Saviour , when he was in the World , and his Apostles after him , were altogether bent and intent upon . The business of making men holy and obedient to the Laws of Righteousness , they had not only mostly in their Eye , but all they did was subordinated thereunto . All those powerful means that were used to perswade the world that Iesus is the Christ , were in order to this end : For the Son of God was manifested to take away our sins ; and to destroy the works of the Devil , 1 John 3. 5 , 8. Therefore is Faith so highly commended , and so much ascribed thereto , and men so excited to believe in Christ , or to believe his Gospel , because the Doctrine , Precepts , Promises and Threatnings therein contained have a great aptness and tendency , are of mighty force and efficacy , to the thorough Reformation of our Lives , and the cleansing our Natures from all filthiness both of flesh and spirit : Because that Faith which is terminated upon those Objects is such a Shield , as whereby we shall be able to quench all the fiery darts of the wicked one : Because it is most effectual to the purifying of the heart , and the overcoming of the world . In short , Christ gave himself for us that he might redeem us from all iniquity , and purifie to himself a peculiar people zealous of good works , Titus 2. 14. He died for all , that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves ( to the drudging service of their Lusts ) but unto him that died for them , and rose again , 2 Cor. 5. 15. Or , that they should be his Servants , that is , his Free-men ; according to that of S. Paul , 1 Cor. 7. 22. He that is called being a Servant is the Lords Free-man . He gave himself for the Church , that he might sanctifie and cleanse it , by the washing of water by the word ; That he might present it to himself a glorious Church , not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing , but that it should be holy and without blemish , Ephes. 5. 26 , 27. He his own self bare our sins in his own body on the tree , that we , being dead to sins , should live unto Righteousness , 1 Pet. 2. 24. Or as S. Paul saith , Rom. 6. 7. That being dead we might be freed from sin : That is , that being dead to it , we might be freed from the Bondage we were in under it . Or , as we have it , ver . 18. That being made free from sin , we might become the servants of righteousness . Our Saviour required nothing of us , forbad nothing to us , but what was apparently designed in order to our deliverance from sin , the making us pure in heart , and holy in all manner of conversation . He gave us not a Promise , but what was to encourage us hereunto , nor yet a Threatning , but what was intended to scare us from the serving of one Lust or other . And the Apostle tells us , that the whole of the Gospel , or , The grace of God that brings salvation is designed to teach us , that , denying ungodliness and worldly lusts , we should live soberly , righteously and godly in this present world , Tit. 2. 11 , 12. 'T is sufficiently evident from this little that hath been said , that the setting us free from Sin , and the making us Free to Righteousness was the business which took up our Blessed Saviour's time and thoughts when he was upon the Earth , and wherein his holy Apostles were employed after his departure : And therefore this must necessarily be our grand Christian Liberty . Abundantly more might have been said upon this Argument , but we have heretofore copiously handled it in another Treatise . Thirdly , Our Saviours abrogating the Ceremonial Law , his freeing from that yoke , was mainly designed in order to the thorough effecting this Freedom and Liberty . This was a yoke which the Apostle Peter saith , neither they nor their Fathers were able to bear , Acts 15. 10. It was a yoke of bondage , as S. Paul calls it , Gal. 5. 1. Stand fast in the Liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free , and be not intangled again with the yoke of bondage . This Liberty ( as appears by his discourse both before and after ) was that which Christ had given them from the burdensome services of the Mosaical Dispensation . And diverse other places there are which speak of this Liberty as an effect and fruit of the death of Christ. Now it is worthy our Observation , that the great reason wherefore our Saviour did put an end to the Obligation of this Law , and why the Apostles , especially S. Paul , insisted so much upon it , and so earnestly cautioned the Jewish Believers against intangling themselves again with this yoke , was because it became very highly injurious to the Grand Evangelical Design of setting men perfectly free from their Lusts : Because it gendered to that spiritual bondage , in deliverance from which consisteth our best Liberty . For this Law understood Carnally , and according to the letter only , ( which it ought not to have been ) was very apt to beget a sordid and low spirit , a temper of mind very much estranged from true Piety and Goodness . And it is too unquestionable , that the Iews generally had no higher a sense of it . The Law , the Author to the Hebrews saith , made nothing perfect , Chap. 7. 19. It gave no man Freedom from the power of Sin , no power to subdue corrupt Affections was obtainable thereby ; it did not make men truly and internally Righteous , but only Ritually and Externally . As the most eminently Good men under the Law did fall far short of the Apostles of our Saviour , and those whose lives have been most answerable to the Christian precepts , so those degrees of Virtue and Goodness they did attain to were not owing the Law , but to the Covenant made with Abraham , which was the same for substance with the Gospel Covenant . The Law is said to be weak through the flesh ; or in regard of the impetuosity and violence of mens fleshly Appetites , Rom. 8. 3. Nor is there any express mention in the Ceremonial Law of any necessity of purity of heart : This was only represented by the divers legal washings , and other Rites ; the mortification of corrupt Affections was signified by the cutting off the foreskin of the flesh , and the great substantial duties were veiled under dark shadows . So that a man might be very punctually observant of this Law , according to the mere literal sence thereof , and yet his Soul remain perfectly under the power of sinful Affections . And the Learned Mr. Chillingworth in his Sermon on Gal. 5. 5. saith thus even of the Moral Duties of the two Tables , as they are part of the Mosaical Jewish Law , viz. That they required only an external obedience and conformity to the Affirmative Precepts thereof , and an abstaining from an Outward practice of the Negative . They did not reach unto the Conscience , no more than the National Laws of other Kingdoms do . So that , for example , when the law of Moses forbids Adultery upon pain of death , he that should in his heart lust after a Woman , could not be accounted a Transgressor of Moses his law , neither was he liable to the punishment therein specified : Whereas the Gospel requires not only an Outward , and , as I may say , corporal obedience to God's Commandments , but also an inward sanctification of the Soul and Conscience upon the same penalty of everlasting damnation with the former . And what is now said ( proceeds he ) of the Moral Precepts ( as they are part of Moses his law ) by the same proportion likewise , is to be understood of the Iudicial . And as for the Promises of this Law they were only of Temporal good things , and therefore the Gospel is called by the Author to the Hebrews , The bringing in of a better hope , Chap. 7. 19. And is said to be established upon better promises , Chap. 8. 6. 'T is confessed that promises of Heavenly things were contained in those of Earthly , as some of the latter were Types of the former , particularly the land of Canaan of the Eternal Rest in Heaven ; and the promises of good things in the general had those of the other life implied in them ; but there is not the least express mention in this Law of any Life after this : I do not say , in any part of the Old Testament , but in this Law. Now then , seeing it abounded with Temporal Promises , and none but such being in express terms contained therein , 't is no wonder if it became an occasion to the sensual Iews of their being the more eager and vehement in prosecuting the profits , honours and pleasures of this life , as it was of their being the more Mercenary in their obedience . The like may be said of the Threatnings of this Law , they are all so expressed as if they were only of Present , Temporal Evils , and the Iews , for the most part , looking no farther than the outward letter of these Threatnings , it was not to be expected that they should be excited by them to obey from any higher motive than the mere fear of such evils ; as those that did not look beyond the letter of the Promises were obedient only from the hope of some sensual , present good : And by this means especially did this Law Gender to bondage , as we read it did , Gal. 4. 24. The terrible manner in which the Law was given , and the Threatnings of Present death or other temporal Calamities upon the Transgression thereof did occasion that slavish sear , which the Apostle calls the Spirit of bondage , in those words , Ye have not received the Spirit of bondage again to fear , Rom. 8. 5. God dealt with the Iews as it was most fit to deal with such a carnal , such a stiff-necked , stubborn and disingenuous people ; who would not be wrought upon and overcome by love to himself , or a sense of the loveliness of Virtue and true Goodness , nor regard any Laws , but such as were enforced with severe present Penalties , or promises of sensual good things : Which obedience of theirs was most truly and properly the obedience of Slaves , a Servile and Mercenary Obedience . So that this Law having been abused by the Iews to the so much the more captivating them to their fleshly lusts , for this reason chiefly was it laid aside , namely , because the Liberty which consisteth in a thorough compliance with the Rules of Righteousness , the Obligation of this Law would have greatly obstructed the promoting of . And the things expresly required in this Law being such as had no internal goodness in them , being weak and beggarly Elements , as the Apostle calls them , Gal. 4. 9. the imposition of many such must needs be apt to call away mens Minds and Affections from those that are essentially and immutably good , whilest the spiritual meaning of those injunctions is either not understood or not attended to . And that it had this effect upon the generality of the Iews , by this means , is a case too plain to need to be proved . And though the great substantial duties , which are in their own nature Good and Necessary , and of Eternal obligation , were inculcated upon them by all their Prophets , as well as taught by Natural Light , such as Doing Iustice , loving Mercy , walking humbly with God , and the like , yet they generally were so sottish as to think that He valued Sacrifices , and the other Ceremonial and External Performances of the Law so much above such Duties ( nay , though he had expresly also declared the quite contrary ) as that their exact and diligent observation of those would make expiation for their remisness in these , and fully satisfie for gross immoralities . They trusted in lying words , saying , The Temple of the Lord , the Temple of the Lord , the Temple of the Lord are these ; implying that their continual attendance on the services there performed , according to the prescription of the Law , would effectually secure them from Divine vengeance , although they refused to amend their ways , and were never so immoral in their Practices . And their constant Trading in Sacrifices , in Rituals and Ceremonial things , occasioned their having but very little sense of things Morally good ; so that that distinction was almost lost among them , of things Positively and Morally so , or things good only because commanded , and things commanded because good . Their being so intent upon a many little things caused them to sleight and overlook the great ones , as our Saviour told the Pharisees , Luke 11. 42. Ye tithe Mint and Rue , and all manner of Herbs , and pass over judgment and the love of God. And Mat. 23. 23. Ye pay tith of Mint and Anise , and Cummin , and have omitted the weightier matters of the Law , judgment , mercy and faith . And their omitting these things was too plain an Argument alone ( though there is other proof of it ) of their having scarcely any notion of things Absolutely , Immutably and Essentially Good and Evil , which was occasioned ( as I said ) by their minds being so employed about things which were in themselves neither Good nor Evil , but only by reason of Divine injunctions and prohibitions . Not that this great evil was necessarily occasioned thereby ( God forbid we should think so ) but 't was through their own default ; otherwise there could have been no truly good people among them , as there were innumerable : just as we see at this day , there are too many of a certain Profession , who , by means of their continual dabling in matter , are of so gross and course intellectuals , that they seem almost uncapable of any Idea and conception of things immaterial and incorporeal . Which is a great Unhappiness but as great a Fault . So that , this we have now said suggests to us another reason for the putting a period to the Ceremonial Law , in order to the introduction of that excellent and Divine Liberty , which we assert to be eminently Christian Liberty ; Because that the love of Righteousness and Goodness under that notion is necessary thereunto , as shall be farther shewn hereafter . And it is an evidence of a Soul imprisoned in Sense , and sunk in Selfishness to love Virtue and Goodness , merely for its dowry and the external Advantages that accrue by it , and not for its own sake : As also to avoid sin , only for the sake of the uneasie and sad circumstances that attend it , having no sense of its Moral Turpitude . Lastly , Whereas I have shewed , that by the observation of the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness a man is delivered from all immoderate Self-love to his own Bodily and Particular concerns , and acquireth that Generosity and Nobleness of spirit whereby he is carried forth and enlarged to the love of God in the first place , and a hearty concern for the General welfare of his Fellow-creatures , the Iews by the occasion of the forementioned Law , became less free , as Freedom is opposed to Confinement . For they being paled in and separated from the rest of the world by a Religion peculiar to themselves ; and it being forbidden by their Law to contract Marriages , or have any intimacy , and that they should so much as eat with the Gentiles ( though 't was but necessary they should be so restrained for the more effectual preventing their falling into Idolatry , and being infected with their other wicked customs and corrupt manners , to which they were naturally very strangely inclined , yet ) by this means they generally became wofully Narrow-spirited and contracted in their Love , and took occasion from hence to banish all from their Kindness and Charity , that were not of their own Nation and their own Religion . And therefore for this reason also it was highly fit that our Saviour should take off all future Obligation to the Observance of this Law ; his design being to Ampliate and Enlarge mens minds by the most Universal and Unlimited Charity ; in imitation of himself , who was a Propitiation not only for the sins of the Iewish Nation , but also of the whole World. And for this reason particularly S. Paul tells the Ephesians , This Law was Abolished , Chap. 2. 14 , 15 , 16. For he is our peace , who hath made both one ( Jews and Gentiles ) and hath broken down the middle wall of partition between us , having abolished in his flesh the enmity , even the Law of Commandments , contained in Ordinances ( or , having Abolished by his Sufferings the Ceremonial Law , which was such a Make-bate between the Iews and Gentiles ) for to make himself of twain one new man , so making peace . And that he might reconcile both unto God in one body on the Cross , having slain the enmity thereby . And that in the general , the great work of setting men perfectly at Liberty from the power of their Lusts , and the making them free to all holy Obedience was designed by the nullifying this Law , is asserted by the Apostle , Rom. 7. 5 , 6. For when we were in the flesh ( or under those Carnal Ordinances ) the motions of sin , which were by the Law , did work in our members , to bring forth fruit unto death . But now we are delivered from the Law , that being dead wherein we were held , that we should serve in newness of the spirit , and not in the oldness of the letter . That is , when we were under the Law , the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Sinful Affections , which were heightned thereby ( through our own blindness in not looking beyond the letter of the Law ) did so work in us , as to render us so much the more obnoxious to death : But now we are delivered by our Saviour Christ from that Law , it being dead , or abrogated , that in stead of a mere External Obedience , and a company of Bodily Washings , we should for the future be inwardly pure and spiritually obedient . To conclude this Argument : Wheresoever we find Liberty or Freedom mentioned throughout the New Testament , as that which belongeth to us under the notion of Christians , as that which we are beholden to the Gospel dispensation for , it is still , I dare affirm , to be understood either of Liberty from Sin ( the Power and the Punishment thereof ) or of Liberty from the Ceremonial and purely Mosaical Law. This I assert upon a particular consideration of all those Texts , wherein any thing is said relating to Liberty : And therefore this latter Deliverance being principally intended in order to the former , the former , viz. that from Sin , must necessarily be the Christian Liberty . Fourthly , None but the Israelites were obliged to the Observance of this Law. Indeed in order to a Gentiles partaking of the Iewish Priviledges in the Land of Canaan , it was necessary he should be Circumcised and become ( as their phrase was ) a Proselyte of Iustice , and so make himself a debtor to the whole Law : But it was not necessary to his Acceptance with God and Eternal Happiness to yield obedience to this Law. It was sufficient for him to worship the true God and renounce Idolatry , and to follow the Dictates of the Law of Nature . Even the Iews themselves , as ill affected as they were towards the Gentiles , did acknowledge no more to be necessary , than the Observation of the Seven Precepts of Noah , to their having their part in Seculo futuro ; and therefore they permitted the Proselytes of the Gate to worship in the Outward Court of the Temple . Which was therefore called Atrium Gentium & immundorum . The Court of the Gentiles and the Vnclean . And thus , as it appears from the three foregoing Arguments , that Liberty from Sin and to Righteousness is the Eminent Christian Liberty , which is procured for the World taking in the Iews , so from this fourth 't is as evident , that it is the only Christian Liberty which is procured and purchased for us Gentiles . There is no other Liberty mentioned either by our Saviour or his Apostles , besides this from the Power and Dominion of Sin ( wherein we always include deliverance from the sad consequents thereof ) which we Gentiles are obliged to Christianity for , or which we are invested with under the notion of Christians . CHAP. VI. What course our Lord hath taken to instate us in this Liberty shewed in several particulars , viz. that 1. He hath most fully informed us concerning all the Parts and Particulars of our Liberty . 2. He hath furnished us with the most potent Means , for the gaining of it . 3. He hath purchased a rich supply of Grace and Strength , to enable us to use these Means successfully . 4. He hath laid before us the most powerful Motives and Arguments to prevail on our Wills to make use of this Strength , and comply with this Grace . HAving , I hope , sufficiently cleared the truth of this Proposition , that our Christian Liberty ( both mainly and wholly ) consisteth in Freedom to holy Obedience , and deliverance from Sin , I now come to shew , Secondly , How Christ instates men in this Liberty , or what Course he hath taken for the effecting hereof . By the way , we are to take notice that the Method our Lord hath made choice of , for the setting us free from our Corrupt Affections , is such as is most Suitable to the Nature of those that are to be delivered , and such as is most suitable to the Nature of that Bondage and Slavery from which he delivers . Those who are to be delivered being Reasonable Creatures , Voluntary and therefore Free Agents , who act not by mere Necessity of Nature , or Blind instincts , and much less from External Force and Compulsion , he dealeth with them , in Setting them free , as with such a sort of Creatures . Again the Slavery ( as also the Confinement ) from which he delivers being Spiritual not Corporal ; I mean , being Originally in the Mind , Will and Affections , and not in the Outward man , he hath accordingly applied himself to the effecting our deliverance . So that our Deliverer hath not done all for us that is to be done , and left nothing for us to do , in order to our being set free . Nor can this be said of any other who designs to deliver out of Bondage or Prison persons arrived at years of discretion , and that are able to use their hands and legs . Such a one accounts that he hath done abundantly enough , when he hath paid the Slaves Ransom , and removed the necessity he was under of continuing in servitude ; If afterward he will not stir a foot , he doth not think himself obliged to hale him by main force out of the Gallies or House of bondage . He also looks upon his work as done , when he hath set the Prison doors wide open , and hath cleared the Prisoner's passage out , and put the Key into his hand for the unlocking his Fetters , and offered to assist him if he cannot do it by his own strength : But when all this is done , if the Prisoner will do nothing towards his own escape , he , who hath done thus much in his behalf , will think it great pity but that there he should lie . There is no Prince but will be satisfied that he hath quitted himself bravely , and fully performed the part of a Deliverer , when he hath put Weapons into the hands of a Conquered People , and furnished them with sufficient aids for the rescuing themselves from the Tyranny of their Oppressors ; but if after all , they will not be perswaded to use their Weapons , and are so dastardly as not to joyn with those Forces that are sent for their help , he nevertheless deserves the Title of a Deliverer . In like manner , it is not our Blessed Saviour's Method to drag men with irresistible force out of their Spiritual Vassallage and Slavery : He doth not deliver us against our Wills , nor in such a manner as if we were Creatures that have no Wills ; nor doth so overpower our Wills ( at least ordinarily ) as that they shall have left them no power of resistance , but be necessitated to give their Consent . But this is the Course he hath taken , which is the most wise , and in its own nature the most admirably effectual . First , He hath fully informed us concerning all the Parts and Particulars of our Liberty . Secondly , He hath Directed us to the most potent Means for the gaining thereof . Thirdly , He hath purchased a rich supply of Grace and Strength to enable us to use these Means successfully . Fourthly , He hath laid before us the most powerful Motives and Arguments imaginable to prevail with our Wills to use this Strength , to comply with this Grace . First , He hath fully informed us concerning all the Parts and Particulars of our Liberty : I mean , he hath instructed us in all those Rules of Righteousness and Goodness , in the Observance of which consists our best and most desirable Liberty . This he hath done by the Precepts he hath given us , as also by the Example he hath set before us . In Matthew 11. 28 , 29. he proposeth both these , the one to be obeyed , the other to be followed , in order to the possessing our selves of this Liberty : Come unto me ( saith he ) all ye that labour and are heavy laden , and I will give you rest . And what he meaneth by Coming unto him he tells us in the next words , Take my Yoke upon you , or obey my Precepts , and Learn of me , or follow my Example , for I am meek and lowly in heart , and ye shall find Rest unto your Souls : Rest from the Slavish drudgery of sinful Affections . As to our Saviours Precepts , whatsoever he hath required of us , it is either a Part of our Liberty , or a Means for the gaining and maintenance thereof . Now as to the Christian Precepts which oblige us to those things in the doing of which our Liberty consisteth , as they incomparably excel the Precepts of whatsoever Religion was before or since the coming of our Saviour , so there is nothing defective or wanting in them . There is not any thing left out of them that is necessary to the completing of the freedom and happiness of our Souls . All the defects of the Mosaical Law , and of the Law of Nature , are supplied and made up by them . As our Lord came not to destroy the Law , so he came to fulfil it : To perfect it and fill it up , as he himself hath told us , Matth. 5. 17. There is nothing that conduceth to the restoring humane nature to its Primitive Perfection , to the bringing every thing in man into due order , to the effecting a complete Harmony and Agreement between his various disagreeing Powers and Faculties , to the putting him into that state wherein every thing would be with him as his own heart could wish to have it , or ( in one word ) to the making him partaker of the God-like Nature , and consequently of the God-like Liberty , Freedom and Blessedness ; There is nothing , I say , conduceable to these excellent purposes , but our Saviour hath in his own Person , when he was on Earth , and by his Apostles since he left the World , acquainted us with it , over and over inculcated it , again and again minded us of it , and urged it upon our practice . To speak in the words of the Apostle S. Paul , Phil. 4. 8. Whatsoever things are true , or remote from insincerity and hypocrisie ; Whatsoever things are honest , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , venerable and grave ; Whatsoever things are just , or exactly agreeable to the Rule of doing as we would be done unto ; Whatsoever things are pure , or far from all shew and appearance of unchastity ; Whatsoever things are lovely , or which tend to secure to us love among men , such as all works of benignity , mercy and Charity ; Whatsoever things are of good report , or which are apt to procure a good name , and therefore to prevent all the causes of shame , and to give us the greatest freedom and confidence , as before God , so before Men too ; If there be any virtue , if there be any thing that is by Good men reckoned in the number of Virtues ; And if there be any praise , or any thing laudable and praise-worthy : All these things , as the Apostle in the general here enjoyneth us to think upon them , so they are very particularly , and as clearly and perspicuously , recommended to us to be carefully observed by us , in the New Testament . There is nothing which it becometh us to Do or Forbear , whether in reference to God , our Great Creator , Governour and Benefactor , or to our Fellow-creatures , or to our own Souls and Bodies , but here we find it . Again , we may observe all these in our Saviour's Life also , wherein He set us an Example , that we should follow his steps . And it is a most admirable Example of Piety towards God ( of Love to him , Trust in him , and Submission to his Will ) of Charity to all men , even his greatest Enemies ; and of Humility , Meekness , Temperance , Purity , Contempt of the World , and Heavenly-mindedness . He that shall observe how our Blessed Saviour Lived , cannot be ignorant of any of those Laws of Righteousness and Goodness , which , before his coming , the World was so lamentably , in not a few instances , to seek in the knowledge of , through that blindness which by the customary gratifying their vile Affections men had generally contracted . I say , he that is acquainted with the Life of our Saviour cannot easily be ignorant of any of those Laws , although he never understood what particular Commands or Prohibitions his Precepts consist of . So that this is the First thing Christ Iesus hath done for us in order to our being made Free : He hath given us fully to understand what it is to be Free , what are those several Rules of Righteousness and Goodness , in compliance with which consists our Liberty . Secondly , Our Saviour hath also prescribed most Effectual Means , by making use of which we shall most certainly obtain and maintain this Liberty , that is , obey those Laws of Liberty which he hath given us . These Means are especially : Believing himself to be the Son of God , and consequently the Truth and Divinity of his Doctrine . Hearing his Word , and Receiving it into honest hearts , or Pondering it in our minds , and Meditating upon it , with the Design of conforming our selves to it . Prayer to God in his Name , together with Faith in his Bloud for the Remission of our Sins , and in his Power and Goodness , for the Subduing our Lusts , and the making us Obedient to his Precepts : That is , for the blessing our Endeavours to that End. Setting his Example before our Eyes , which is an Excellent Means to beget in us a likeness to him , and to our partaking of his Spirit and Temper . Watching over our own Hearts , and against Temptations . Denying our selves , and not indulging our Sensitive Part. Advising in all Cases of doubt and difficulty with our Pastors and Spiritual Guides ; whom Christ hath given to his Church , For the perfecting of the Saints , for the work of the Ministery , for the Edifying of the Body of Christ , Ephes. 4. 12. And obeying them which have the Rule over us in the Lord , they watching for our Souls , as those that must give an Account , Heb. 13. 17. Which Duties were never more neglected , than in this Age , to the great scandal of our Reformed Religion . Keeping in the Communion of the Church : And not forsaking the Assembling our selves together ( or our publick Assemblies ) as the manner of some is , Heb. 10. 25. And now is the manner of vast numbers of us , ( though no Terms of Communion are required that contradict any one Text of Scripture ) which Separation we are too like ere long to pay dear for . The Religious observation of the Lords Day , both in Publick and Private , is another singular Help and Advantage ; Though few Professors of Christianity seem now to have any great sense of it , to the great prejudice of their own Souls , and the Souls of those who are under their charge . And to these add in the last place ( because 't is most convenient to place them here ) The Sacraments of Baptism and the Lord's Supper . By Baptism we are admitted into the Church of Christ , and brought into a New State : We are baptized into the name of the Father , Son and Holy Ghost , or devoted to their service . And the Father , in this Sacrament , takes us into his special care , and into the Relation of his Children , whereas before we were only the Children of Adam . The Son receives us as members of his Body the Church : We are baptized into one Body ( as the Apostle speaks , 1 Cor. 12. 13. ) that Body whereof Christ is the Head. And the Holy Ghost , who is the Author of Grace and Spiritual Life , taketh us for his Temples . We are said to Receive the Holy Ghost in Baptism , to receive that power and strength from him , which will enable us to Mortifie the deeds of the Body , and to acquire the Divine Graces and Virtues ; which we shall certainly do , if we refuse not to Exert and Improve it , when we come to years of Discretion , and our Faculties are ripe enough for that purpose . In Baptism the Holy Spirit communicates to us the Beginnings of a new life , which may afterwards be improved to large measures of Virtue and Goodness , if we be not wilfully wanting to our selves in the other Means . And in the Lords Supper , as we renew the Covenant we made in Baptism , to renounce the Devil and all his works , &c. So all worthy Receivers of that Sacrament receive great additions of Grace and Spiritual Strength , are fed with the spiritual food of the most Precious Body and Bloud of Christ. And of all the Means prescribed for the Subduing our Lusts , and Growing in Grace , the Frequent Receiving the Lord's Supper is very deservedly accounted the Principal . Certainly there is not any Ordinance wherein sincere Souls do so experiment the Communications of the Holy Spirit , by which they are so Strengthened with strength in their Souls . Nor are there any such Strong and Spriteful Christians , any so confirmed and rooted in Goodness , in the love of God and their Neighbour , and all the Christian Virtues , as those who take all occasions to attend upon it , with a thankful sense of the infinite love of God and Christ to them , and sincerely design in so doing a fuller participation of the Divine nature . But this intimation that these two Sacraments are conveyances of Grace and Strength leads me to shew , that , Thirdly , Our Saviour hath moreover purchased for us a rich supply of Grace , to enable us to use the forementioned Means with happy success . He hath obtained from his Father by his Perfect Obedience , both Active and Passive , Authority to send the Holy Ghost powerfully to assist us ; and hath assured us that those who ask him shall have him , in those most excellent , and most comfortable words , Luke 11. 11 , 12 , 13. If a Son shall ask bread of any that is a Father , will he give him a stone ? Or if he ask a fish , will he for a fish give him a Serpent ? Or if he shall ask an Egge , will he offer him a Scorpion ? If ye then being evil , know how to give good gifts unto your Children , how much more shall your Heavenly Father give his holy Spirit unto them that ask him ? And if any of us want the Holy Spirit 's Assistance , it is certainly because we either pray not at all for it , or not with a sincere and earnest desire that he should root up and destroy every Evil Affection in our Souls ; Because we are secretly unwilling to let go some beloved lust or other ; And because we are false to God and our own Souls in those things which he hath put into our Power . For 't is certain , that not to put forth the power we have already received , and yet complain for want of strength , is to play the Hypocrities ; and no wonder if the Holy Spirit of God doth estrange himself , and withhold or withdraw his blessed Influences from such persons . But as for those who are faithful so far as those Talents reach , which they are at present intrusted with , our Lord hath promised them that more shall be given them . That is the meaning of those words , Mark 4. 25. He that hath , to him shall be given : That is , that useth what he hath ; for no man properly hath or possesseth what he makes no use of , 't would be the same thing to him to be without it . Nay , our Lord doth not only promise to him that hath , that more shall be given him , but also that he shall have abundantly more , Matth. 13. 12. For whosoever hath , to him shall be given , and he shall have more abundance : And he repeats this , Chap. 25. 29. And if we were not through wilfulness and carelesness wanting to our selves , in putting forth that measure of strength we have , as sure as Iesus is the Christ we should fully experiment the truth of this promise : We should then feel the Divine Spirit working in us mightily , as the Apostle S. Paul saith he did , Col. 1. 29. The great things that are spoken concerning the Spirit , and of what he shall do in the hearts of men , would be then punctually fulfilled in us , and we should be satisfied by happy experience , that they are not mere words ; the Holy Ghost would not fail to do all that for us , he was sent by our Lord to do . It is to be acknowledged with great sadness , that both Fleshly and Spiritual Lusts are exceedingly strong and vigorous even in the generality of those that profess Christianity , as well as in others , and no less than in others , that are Strangers to our Religion : But this never to be enough lamented Evil doth not proceed from hence , that grace is denied to the generality , but 't is wholly to be imputed to their Receiving the grace of God in vain , and wilfully refusing to comply therewith . It is not at all to be ascribed to the Spirits refusing to perform his Office in them , or to do in their behalf what doth belong to him , but to their refusing to do their part ▪ This we are as fully assured of from abundance of Texts of Scripture as we can desire to be . The same is to be said of mens so ordinarily falling again and again into those sins which they frequently Pray and Resolve and Vow against : This is far from being the account of it , that God is not willing to hear their prayers ; For ( as S. Iohn speaks , 1 Epist. 5. 14. ) This is the confidence that we have in him , that if we ask any thing according to his will , he heareth us ; and to ask victory over our Lusts is of all Petitions most agreeable to his will. This cannot be the reason of it , that the Holy Spirit refuseth to inforce his Preventing ( or Prevenient ) with his Assisting Grace , that he will not assist some persons in the performance of those good Resolutions which his Preventing Grace hath excited in their Souls . But this is the true account hereof , viz. Such Persons are undoubtedly wanting in the use of some Necessary Means or other for the subduing their Lusts ; they do not use all the means our Lord hath appointed , and are especially faulty in neglecting particularly the great duty of Consideration , They pray , it may be , very frequently and earnestly too , that God would give them strength against this or that Corruption , and they add Vows to their Prayers , but they add not Consideration to their Prayers and Vows , they watch not over themselves , disregard the first motions of their Wills , and inclinations of their Souls towards the sins or sin they so Pray , Resolve and Vow against , and are not careful to avoid Temptations . And as inconsideration is the chiefest cause of unsuccessfulness in the use of means for the subduing of Corrupt Affections , so the gross neglect of that grand Means the Lords Supper , but now discoursed of ( which I hope in no Age , nor among any people professing Christianity , was ever so common , as to our great shame it is in this Age and this Nation ) this gross neglect , I say , is questionless a very great cause of so much Non-proficiency in attendance on other Ordinances as is complained of . Which Nonproficiency may well be , notwithstanding the Promises of the plentiful Effusion of the Spirit , and our Saviour's purchasing so rich a supply of Grace for us . For our Saviour is no such Friend to Negligence and Carelesness , as to dispense his Grace in such a way and manner , as that it must necessarily be a motive and encouragement to do nothing , or but little our selves : But on the contrary , he so communicates his Grace and Strength , as to make it a great Exciter and Quickner of Endeavours . Of this S. Paul assures us , in making God's working in us to will and to do , or his readiness so to do , an argument to perswade us to work out our own salvation with fear and trembling , Phil. 2. 12. Lastly , As our Saviour hath purchased for us a rich supply of Grace for the Enabling us to use the Means of our Deliverance with happy success , so he hath given us the most powerful Motives and Arguments that can be imagined , to prevail upon our Wills to comply and cooperate with this Grace . And these Arguments are not only proposed outwardly to us in his Gospel , but they are also inforced inwardly upon our hearts ( as appears by what hath been now said ) by his Holy Spirit . That is , they are inforced upon the hearts of all those who will take the pains seriously to consider them . To which consideration likewise the Spirit fails not to Excite men , till by long Grieving him , and very frequent rejecting his good ▪ Motions and Suggestions , he is , as it were , forced to desist , and depart from them . CHAP. VII . Wherein is discoursed the First of those Motives and Arguments which are offered in the Gospel , to perswade us to use the Means prescribed for our deliverance from the Power of Sin. Namely , The love of God in sending his Son upon the errand of our Redemption . And two most powerful Motives implied in this . NOW the chiefest of those Motives and Arguments are these that follow . First , The unconceivable Love of God expressed in sending his only and Eternal begotten Son , ultimately upon this errand of Redeeming us from the Power of Sin : And the never to be sufficiently admired Love of Christ , in so readily taking our Nature upon him , condescending to such extremely low circumstances here in the World , and at last submitting to so Vile and Ignominious , so Cruel and Tormenting a Death , and all this , ultimately I say , for this very End , that of Sins and Satans Slaves we might become his and his Fathers Free Subjects ; For he died , the just for the unjust , that he might bring us to God , 1 Pet. 3. 18. Here we have a two-fold most exciting and wonderfully powerful motive to comply most heartily with the Method our Saviour hath taken for the setting us free . First , God's sending his own Son to be a Sacrifice for our Sins , without the interposition of which he would not propose Terms of Reconciliation to Sinners , sheweth his infinite hatred of Sin , and consequently , that it is a most deadly Evil , and hath excessive Malignity in it . This is expressed in the most Emphatical manner by our Saviour's shedding his most precious Bloud upon the Cross for the expiating of it . And can we have a more constraining Motive to do our utmost to be delivered from the Dominion of Sin , than this , that it is thus demonstrated to be an unspeakable Evil ? It hath been shewed , that the Death of Christ was designed to set us free from the Power as well as Punishment of Sin , and it is apt to effect that end , partly as its extreme hatefulness is thereby discovered and made manifest . By this Sacrifice for Sin , is it condemned in the flesh , as the Apostle saith , Rom. 8. 3. It is condemned as the Vilest and most Intolerable thing . The immediate end of Christs sufferings was to make Atonement for Sin , but this way of Atonement is a means , a most effectual means , to this farther End , the making us out of love with Sin , and perswading us to Abandon it as the worst of all Evils . Of which , I say , we cannot desire greater evidence than this , that no meaner Sacrifice might be accepted for the making expiation for Sin , than that of the only begotten Son of God. Secondly , This is as wonderful an Expression of the Divine love to Sinners , as of the Divine displeasure against Sin. God commendeth his love towards us , in that when we were yet Sinners Christ died for us , Rom. 5. 8. And herein did he commend his love in the most wonderful manner that it was possible to commend it . He shewed the exceeding riches of his grace , in his Kindness towards us through Iesus Christ , as we read Ephes. 2. 7. Was that an ordinary Love in God the Father think we , that moved him to send no less a person upon the business of our Redemption , than him who was the Brightness of his own Glory , and the express Image of his Person , by whom also he made the Worlds ? Was that an Ordinary Love in God the Son , that prevailed with him to take the Humane nature , and to humble himself in that Astonishing manner , and to undergo such direful Sufferings for our sake ? Or was it not such a Love as passeth knowledge ? So S. Paul saith it was , and it can be no less . This is such a love indeed , as is rather to be silently Admired , than much discoursed of . How hard must needs be that heart which will not be broken by the force of such love as this ! Nothing can be imagined to be of such irresistible power over Persons not forsaken of all ingenuity , as the consideration of this Love. This is the Other way whereby the Death of Christ was designed for the Destroying of Sin. And in respect of either of these ways , but much more of both , our Saviour had good ground for the uttering those words , Iohn 12. 32. When I am lifted up from the Earth , I shall draw all men unto me : He spake of his dying on the Cross for Mankind , as it follows , This he said signifying what-death he should die . And he here supposeth this his Death to contain such Forcible Arguments to perswade men to cast off the Drudgery of sin , and exchange it for his Free service , that it must necessarily be happily successful to this End , wheresoever it is seriously thought on , and laid to heart . CHAP. VIII . A Seasonable Digression concerning the Doctrine of Vniversal Redemption . The Antiquity and Catholicalness of this Doctrine . Large Citations out of Bishop Latimer and Bishop Hooper , expressing their sense of it . And full proof thereof presented out of the H. Scriptures . BY the way : It is of great importance to be fully satisfied , that no man in the World is excluded from having his share in this Propitiatory Sacrifice , and that the Redemption designed by the Death of Christ is Universal . For if each individual Person cannot be assured that he is his Saviour , and that he died for him ; if he died not for all , nay , but for a few comparatively ( as those say who deny that he died for all ) then what influence can the consideration of his Death have upon the Wills of men ? Surely the weakest influence that can be , if any at all . Indeed how it can rationally have any , seems unintelligible , since those who assert that Christ died but for a few comparatively , assert also that those few shall be infallibly at one time or other drawn to him , and Christ will not lose any one of them . If this be so , what inducement can we have either from the Death of Christ , or any other Consideration , to concern our selves at all about leaving our Sins , and using the means prescribed for our deliverance from the power of them ? For if it so happen that I am one of those few for whom Christ died , what need is there of my being concerned about that which is so effectually secured ? What is this but to take Christ's work out of his hand ? But if Christ died not for me ( as 't is very many to one he did not , if he died for so few ) then all my care is to no purpose . I say , if every one of us cannot be certain that Christ died for him , and consequently for all , what motive to obedience can his Death be to us ? And if he died but for some , and those some but a very small number compared with those for whom he did not die , and those for whom he died shall be undoubtedly saved , and those for whom he died not shall be undoubtedly damned , then I cannot see how the wisest man on Earth can answer this Plea of a wicked man for persisting impenitently in his wickedness , viz. If Christ died for me I shall be saved , and he will most assuredly at his own time , which to be sure is the best , bring me over to the obedience of his Precepts by his Omnipotent grace , if that be necessary , in order to my Salvation : But if he died not for me , then let me do what I can , it will signifie nothing , my state is unalterable . So that I run no hazard in being careless and neglectful of the concerns of my Soul , on supposition of my having an interest in the death of Christ ; nor is my case one jot the better for my diligence in using the means of Salvation according to my power , on supposition of the contrary . Now how can we think , that the Gospel doth contain such mighty Arguments to perswade us to work out our own Salvation , whilest it leaves us utterly unable to answer this Plea , that Careless People may , and do many of them , make for their Carelesness ? And therefore it highly concerns us to beware of that Doctrine , which makes Christ to die but for some Certain Persons , as not only most false , but as very dangerous . The truth is , this Doctrine could never gain any considerable Credit , in any Church in the World , for the first fifteen hundred years : 'T was broached ( with the other concomitant Doctrines ) by one Lucidus a Presbyter in France , about the year of our Lord 500 , of which the Pelagian Heresie was the occasion , but quickly condemned by two Councils , one at Arles , the other at Lions . About 300 years after , it was ( with the other ) revived by Godscalcus , a person of ill Fame , but condemned again by a Council at Mentz . But the Doctrine we are defending was Asserted , as a Point never doubted of , by the Fathers of the first 300 years : And is as expresly Asserted in the most Ancient Confessions of the Reformed Churches beyond Sea , and also in the Articles , Homilies and Catechism of our own Church . And those three Holy Martyrs , Arch-Bishop Cranmer , Bishop Latimer and Bishop Hooper ( who will be acknowledged by our Adversaries in this Point , to be most Orthodox men ) have as plainly and fully given their testimony thereunto as we can desire . Arch-Bishop Cranmer , in the Preface to his Book against Gardiner hath these words , that Christ made a Sacrifice and Oblation of his body upon the Cross , which was a full Redemption , Satisfaction and Propitiation for the Sins of the whole World. Bishop Latimer , in his Sermon on the first Sunday after the Epiphany , tells us , that Iesus is an Hebrew word , which signifieth in our English Tongue , a Saviour and Redeemer of all Mankind born into the World. And he hath this passage in his Sermon on the Gospel for the twenty first Sunday after Trinity , P. 2. of Fol. 208. which would be horribly offensive to many now adays , viz. That Christ shed as much bloud for Judas , as he did for Peter ; Peter believed it and therefore was saved , Judas would not believe , and therefore he was condemned ; the fault being in him only , and in no body else . Bishop Hooper , in his Preface to his Exposition of the Ten Commandments , saith , That as the Sin of Adam , without priviledge or exemption , extended and appertained unto all and every of Adams Posterity ; so did this promise of Grace generally appertain as well to every and singular of Adams posterity as to Adam : As it is more plainly expressed , where God promiseth to bless , in the seed of Abraham , all the people of the World. And that these Good men did not hold Contradictions , but , as they undoubtedly believed that Christ died for all , so they also rejected that Doctrine of the Divine Decrees which is inconsistent therewith , is plain from the following passages . Bishop Latimer saith , in his Fourth Sermon on the Third Sunday after the Epiphany , That if the most part be damned , the fault is not in God , but in themselves ; for , Deus vult omnes homines salvos fieri , God would that all men should be saved , but they themselves procure their own damnation , and despise the Passion of Christ by their own wicked and inordinate living . Here we may learn to keep us from all curious and dangerous Questions ; when we hear that some be chosen and some be damned : Let us have good hope that we shall be among the chosen , and live after this hope , &c. Think that God hath chosen those that believe in Christ , and that Christ is the Book of life , &c. So we need not to go about to trouble our selves with curious questions of the Predestination of God. But let us rather endeavour our selves that we may be in Christ , for when we be in him , then are we well , and then we may be sure that we are ordained to everlasting life . But you will say , how shall I know that I am in the Book of life ? How shall I try my self to be elect of God to everlasting life ? I answer , First we may know , that we may one time be in the book , and another time come out again , as it appeareth by David . See more that follows to the same purpose , Fol. 310. Again , in his Sermon on Septuag . Fol. 214. saith he , God's Salvation is sufficient to save all Mankind ; But we are so wicked of our selves , that we refuse the same , and we will not take it when 't is offered to us , and therefore he saith , Pauci verò electi , Few are chosen ; that is , few have pleasure and delight in it , for the most part are weary of it , cannot abide it ; for there are some that hear it , but they will abide no danger , &c. Such men are cause of their own Damnation ; for God would have them saved , but they refuse it : like Judas the Traitor , whom Christ would have had to be saved , but he refused his Salvation , he refused to follow the Doctrine of his Master Christ. And Bishop Hooper is very full and particular to this purpose in his forecited Preface . Saith he , Cain was no more excluded from the promise of Christ , till he excluded himself , than Abel ; Saul than David ; Judas than Peter ; Esau than Jacob : Concerning which two Brethren , in the sentence of God given to Rebecca , there was no mention at all , that Esau should be disinherited of Eternal Life , but that he should be inferior to his Brother Jacob in this world , which Prophecy was fulfilled in their Posterity , and not the Persons themselves . God is said by the Prophet to have hated Esau , not because he was disinherited of Eternal Life , but in laying his mountains and his heritage waste for the Dragons of the Wilderness , Mal. 1. 3. That Threatning of God against Esau ( if he had not of wilful malice excluded himself from the Promise of Grace ) should no more have hindred his Salvation , than God's Threatning against Nineveh : The cause of Rejection or Damnation is Sin in man , which will not hear , neither receive the promise of the Gospel , &c. It is not a Christian man's part to attribute his Salvation to his own Free-will , with the Pelagian , and extenuate Original Sin , nor to make God the Author of ill and damnation , with the Manichee ; nor yet to say , that God hath written Fatal Laws , and with necessity of Destiny , violently pulleth the one by the hair into Heaven , and thrusteth the other head-long into Hell. I have thus at large transcribed the words of these two Holy Bishops and Martyrs for the Reformed Religion , because the Books are not easie to be met with , and Bishop Hooper's not to be light on without great difficulty . And , I say , by these Citations ( to which we might have added others ) it is very apparent , not only that they undoubtedly believed the Doctrine of Christ's dying for all men , ( and were zealous Assertors of it too ) but also , that they rejected that Doctrine of Fatal Decrees , which is the Foundation of the contrary Opinion . I cannot but take notice , by the way , how Unreasonable and Uncharitable those men are , who clamour at such a rate against their Brethren , as Innovators and Apostates from the Church of England , for their asserting no worse Doctrine , than we have now seen was heartily approved by these Ancient and Eminent Fathers of our Church . The Doctrine of which Church , I presume , they 'l have the Modesty to acknowledge , they were as fit judges of as themselves . But I must hasten to that which is much more to our present purpose ; viz. That no Doctrine is more clearly or fully asserted in the Holy Scriptures than this of Vniversal Redemption . And that there may remain no longer the least doubt or scruple in any of our breasts concerning it , let us take notice of these following particulars . First , How those that have a share in Christ's Redemption are expressed by our Saviour and his Apostles . They are expressed by the words SINNERS indefinitely , the WORLD , ALL , the WHOLE WORLD , EVERY MAN. And can the Wisdom of man invent more plain , significant and full words , by which to express the Universality of Mankind ? 1. Those whom Christ came , and died to save , that is , to put into a Salvable state , so that it will be wholly long of themselves if they perish , are expressed by the word Sinners indefinitely . S. Paul saith , 1 Tim. 1. 15. This is a faithful saying , and worthy of all acceptation , that Iesus Christ came into the world to save Sinners , of which I am chief . Now 't is a known Maxim , that An indefinite Proposition is equivalent to an Vniversal one . And our Saviour himself saith , that He came to call sinners to repentance , Luke 5. 32. And to seek and save that which was lost , Chap. 19. 10. He makes no exception of Sinners or Lost persons , and therefore what can they be less than All Mankind ? But if this be not satisfactory , 2. They are expressed by the word World. Our Saviour saith , Iohn 3. 16 , 17. God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son , that whosoever believeth in him should not perish , but have everlasting life . For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world , but that the world through him might be saved . I could not disparage any ones understanding more , than by endeavouring to satisfie him , that 't is a most pitiful and senseless shift , to say , that by the World is meant all the Elect in the world , that is , some exceeding few of the world in comparison of the rest . For , besides that this is to make nonsence of the former Verse , as must needs be obvious to every body , so by taking the same Liberty in interpreting other Texts , the Bible would be made the most insignificant Book in the world . The Generality of men is ordinarily called the World , and Bad men are sometimes so called in Scripture , because they are the Generality ; but to express the incomparably lesser part of men by the word World , is such a Figure as was never heard of . 3. They are expressed by the word All , to put us more out of doubt , 2 Cor. 5. 14 , 15. The love of Christ constraineth us , because we thus judge , that if one died for all , then were all dead , and that he died for all , that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves , but unto him that died for them , and rose again . Now did ever the word All signifie a few ? And that by All is to be understood the Universality is plain from the former of these Verses , where the Apostle proves that all were dead , or obnoxious to death , by this Argument that Christ died for all . But we will not question whether all in the largest sence were obnoxious to death , and therefore all must be understood in the same extent , when it is said that Christ died for all , or we shall make the Apostle a very sad Arguer . For how could it follow from hence , that Christ died for some , that therefore all without exception were dead ? Again , 1 Tim. 2. 6. we read that Christ gave himself a Ransom for all : And ver . 4. that He will have all to be saved , and come to the knowledge ( or Acknowledgment ) of the truth . And once more , 1 Tim. 4. 10. that He is the Saviour of all men , but especially of those that believe : So that those that believe are not the all he is the Saviour of , the all being distinguished from them . And the meaning of the words is sufficiently obvious , viz. He is so the Saviour of all , as to put them into a capacity of Salvation , but he is so the Saviour of those that believe , as that they shall be actually saved . Those that so believe as to obey the Gospel are at present in a state of Salvation , and if they persevere shall be undoubtedly saved . 4. Those whom Christ died for and came to save ( to make it still more out of doubt if it be possible ) are expressed by the Whole World , 1 John 2. 6. If any man sin , we have an Advocate with the Father , Iesus Christ the Righteous , who is the Propitiation for our sins , and not only for ours , but also for the sins of the whole World. Nay , 5. They are expressed by Every man , Heb. 2. 9. But we see Iesus , who was made a little ( or for a little while ) lower than the Angels , for the suffering of death crowned with glory and honour , that he by the grace of God should taste death , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , for every man. And this is the fullest and most Comprehensive Expression that can be imagined . If after all these most express Affirmations , in such variety of the plainest words , it shall still be asserted , that the Doctrine of Universal Redemption is Heretical or false , there needs no other Reply but this : Let Christ be true and his Holy Apostles , and everyman a Liar that dares to contradict them . Secondly , As our Saviour and his Apostles do so express the Persons for whom he died , as that they must necessarily be the Universality of Mankind , so we learn from S. Paul , that the Remedy by Christ is of equal extent with the mischief occasioned by Adam : That the Sore is not so broad but the Plaister is every whit as broad : Rom. 5. 18. Therefore as by the offence of one judgment came upon all men to condemnation , even so by the Righteousness of one the free gift came upon all men to justification of life . Can anything be said plainer than this is , in these words , viz. That as many as fell by the Transgression of Adam , were designed to be recovered by the Righteousness of Christ ? But it is Objected that it follows in the 19. ver . that , By the obedience of one shall Many he made Righteous ; As our Saviour himself saith , This is the New Testament in my bloud , which was shed for Many for the Remission of Sins . But that this is a Strange objection , will appear by comparing the latter part of that 19. ver . with the former : For as by one mans disobedience Many were made sinners . So that , as many were put into a possibility of being justified by the Righteousness of Christ ( and we do not desire that more should ) as were made Sinners ( or made liable to condemnation ) by the Disobedience of Adam . And by this means , the Reign of Grace to Eternal life was designed to be no more limited , than was the Reign of Sin to death : As it follows in the 21. ver . That as Sin hath reigned unto death , even so might Grace reign through Righteousness unto Eternal life , by Iesus Christ our Lord. And it is not to be wondered at , that the word Many should signifie All , for it is well known , that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , Many , or the Many , is used in other Greek Authors to signifie all , as well as in the New Testament . So that these Texts do most necessarily and plainly speak thus much , That none that hear the Gospel shall fall short of Salvation , but through their Unbelief and Disobedience , their wilful rejecting the Remedy offered them : Nor any neither that never heard the Gospel , merely for the Transgression of their first Parents , but only for their own Sins , I mean , their wilful disobedience to that light they have . And that none to whom the Gospel is preached are excluded from Salvation by Christ , is manifestly implied in those words of our Saviour , Iohn 3. 14. As Moses lifted up the Serpent in the Wilderness , even so must the Son of man be lifted up , that whosoever believeth in him should not perish , but have everlasting life . As the Brazen Serpent was erected for the Cure of all that were stung by the Fiery Serpent , none excepted but such as would not look up to it , for that end : So none shall be shut out from the benefit designed by the Son of man's being lifted up upon the Cross , but such as will not believe , that is , apply themselves to him in that way , which he hath appointed for the obtaining of it . And though our Saviour saith , ver . 19. of that Chapter , that This is the condemnation , that a light is come into the World : Yet he immediately explains himself in the following words , and men loved darkness rather than light , because their deeds are evil . Or Mens being condemned by the occasion of his coming is to be imputed to their Rejecting him , and so refusing to comply with the most reasonable terms of his New Gracious Covenant , not to his or his Father's design in his Coming . For he saith , Iohn 12. 47. I came not to judge the World , but to save the World. Thirdly , We are assured that Christ died even for those that perish . The Apostle saith , 1 Cor. 8. 11. If any man see thee which hast knowledge sit at meat in the Idols Temple , shall not the Conscience of him that is weak be imboldened to eat those things which are offered to Idols , and through thy knowledge shall the weak Brother perish , for whom Christ died ? Here it is supposed that a man may perish , for whom Christ died : And consequently , that he died for Reprobates themselves ; that is , those that have made themselves so , for if Christ died for all , there can be no other Reprobates . Again , Rom. 14. 15. Destroy not him with thy meat , for whom Christ died . And the Author to the Hebrews expresly preacheth this Doctrine , Chap. 10. 29. Of how much sorer punishment , suppose ye , shall he be thought worthy , who hath trodden under foot the Son of God , and hath counted the bloud of the Covenant , wherewith he was Sanctified ( or Consecrated ) an unholy thing ? S. Peter likewise asserts the same , 2 Epist. 2. 1. But there were false Prophets also among the People , even as there will be false Teachers among you , who privily will bring in damnable Heresies , even denying the Lord that bought them , and bring upon themselves swift destruction . So that these vile wretches were not destroyed because Christ did not redeem them , for they are said to be bought or redeemed by him as well as others , but they brought upon themselves swift destruction . Lastly , If this Doctrine be false , that Christ died for all , then none are or can be condemned for not Believing in him , notwithstanding that the condemnation of men is so continually ascribed thereunto . For 't is a plain case , that those for whom Christ did not die , can be no more obliged to believe in him , than the Devils are . And to say that any are condemned for not doing that which it was not their duty to do , will , I hope , be acknowledged the grossest absurdity . This little in comparison of what might be said , to demonstrate the truth of this Great Article of our Faith , is much more than barely sufficient to give us an undoubted assurance of it . The truth is , the Sun doth not shine more bright in the Firmament , than doth this Doctrine in the New Testament : And I know nothing we can be assured of upon Scripture Authority , if this be False or Uncertain . I verily believe that there are few of the Greatest Points of our Christian Faith , but may as plausibly be objected against as this Doctrine , from Scripture . 'T is said indeed by our Saviour , Iohn 10. 5. I lay down my life for my sheep : But did he ever say , I lay down my life for none but my sheep ? If he had , we must have concluded , either that the whole World are his Sheep , or that which is far worse , that he said and unsaid , and contradicted himself , and so destroyed the Foundation of our Faith and Hope . But in saying He laid down his life for his sheep , his meaning was , that those who obeyed his voice should receive the benefit of his death ; and such Sheep he would have all to be . For ( as we have seen in 1 Tim. 2. 4. ) He would have all men to be saved , and to come to the acknowledgment of the truth . Again our Saviour saith , that He prayed not for the World , Iohn 17. 9. From whence some would infer , that surely he would not shed his Precious bloud for those on whom he would not vouchsafe to bestow a Prayer . But 't is apparent his meaning was , that at that time he peculiarly prayed for his Disciples : They only ( as appears by the Context ) are meant , by those that his Father had given him out of the World. But afterwards , ver . 20. He proceeds to pray for all that should believe on him through their word : And at his death , he prayed for his very Crucifiers . And that he could not refuse to pray for the World , is apparent from ver . 21. where he prayeth that Believers might be one in him and his Father , for this reason , That the World may believe that He had sent him : or might be converted to the Faith of the Gospel . These two Objections , as weak as they are , are the chief ones that are taken out of Scripture , against the most Ancient and Catholick Doctrine we have been asserting . But I must needs say , I have often wondred at their Boldness , who have used their utmost endeavours to run down a Doctrine , that not only for so many Ages together hath stood unshaken , but is also so Abundantly , and in the Clearest manner imaginable asserted by Truth it self , and those who were Guided into all truth : And how they are able not to perceive , how grosly they wrest the Holy Scriptures ; so that , if they should use the same Artifice in interpreting all other Texts , they would make the Bible to look like a thing that is contrived for the service of every Humour and every Phancy , and for both the proving and disproving every thing . Certainly , if we should take the same liberty in understanding our own and other mens sayings , that they take in Expounding the forementioned and the like sayings of our Blessed Saviour and his Apostles , Speech would signifie nothing , nay , be of very pernicious consequence , and serve only to abuse and put tricks upon one another . If so many plain Texts as can be , to all Appearance , should require so much labour and pains to be rightly understood , 't will be impossible to defend the Holy Scriptures from that Obscurity which the Papists most injuriously charge them with ; and to preserve the Bible from that Contempt , which ( the higher to advance the Authority of Holy Church ) it suffers from their prophane Tongues and Pens , and wicked Practices . But this Doctrine of Vniversal Redemption , being so strongly fortified , could never have been assaulted , were it reconcileable with that of Absolute Reprobation , either in the Supra or Sublapsarian way ( as it is impossible it should be ) which the too great Admirers of the otherwise very judicious and pious Calvin , are so exceedingly tenacious and fond of . But 't is much to be wondred at , what these men should see in this Doctrine ( which is so severe in it self , and horrid in its necessary Consequences ) that they should be contented to buy it at so dear a Rate , as the Parting with that other most Comfortable Doctrine . Especially since this hath no Antiquity to commend it , and is not so much as seemingly befriended , but by a very few Texts of Scripture , and those very fairly capable of quite another sence , than at first sight may seem to belong to them ; but is contradicted by innumerable plain Texts , and the concurrent strain both of the New and Old Testament . But I must not forget that this Chapter is a Digression from our Main Business ; And I have thus long insisted upon this Argument , that the great Motives contained in the Death of Christ to exchange the Slavery of Sin for his Free service might have their full weight and cogency : which would be in danger , not only of being weakned , but even quite lost , by limiting the Design of Christ's Death to some particular persons , where the Consequences of such a Limitation are apprehended . And I appeal to every Considerative Person , whether it be not a mighty Motive and Encouragement to the engaging all the powers of our Souls in this great work of using the Means prescribed for the subduing our Lusts , to be assured that every individual person of us is one of those , for whom Christ gave himself to redeem them from all iniquity . CHAP. IX . Wherein are contained Five more Evangelical Motives , which are of wonderful Power to excite us to diligence in using the Means of our Deliverance from the Dominion of Sin , viz. Our Saviours excellent Example . The assurance he hath given us , that he will not take such advantage of our Frailties and Weaknesses , as to cast us off for them . Our Saviours Mediation and Intercession . The Glorious Reward he hath purchased for , and promised to those , who , by the Assistance of his Grace , overcome their Lusts. And the most dismal Threatnings he hath pronounced against those who receive that Grace in vain , and will not be delivered from the Dominion of Sin. HAving presented you with the First powerful Motive to diligence , in using the Means of our Deliverance from the Dominion of Sin , namely , The unconceivable Love of God in sending his only Begotten Son upon this Errand of Delivering us ; and of Christ in so readily taking our Nature upon him , and dying a cursed Death for that End : And having also fully Demonstrated , that no man in the World is excluded from the Benefit designed by the Death of Christ , in order to our giving that Motive its full force and strength : I proceed to shew , that Secondly , Another singular Motive is our Saviour's Example . As we are by his Example Directed in the several parts of our Duty , as hath been shewed ; And as the frequent Eyeing thereof is a Means ( as hath been intimated ) whereby we may be more and more transformed into his Likeness ; so is it to be considered as a Wonderfully Exciting Motive to comply with those Rules of Righteousness and Goodness , which we have naturally the greatest Aversation of Will towards . As particularly , those which oblige us to the Meek bearing of Indignities , the Forgiving the greatest and most Provoking Injuries , the Loving our Enemies ; whereby we shall be set free from the Cruel Tyrants of Revenge and Malice . Those also that oblige us to Humility , Patience and intire Resignation to the Will of God , under the severest Dispensations of his Providence ; and Contentation with a mean Fortune , and low Circumstances in the World ; which will free us from the inslaving Passions of Pride , Anger , immoderate Grief , Covetousness , &c. When we consider with what Admirable Evenness of Mind , this Great Prince of the Kings of the Earth indured the Contradiction of Sinners against himself ; How , when he was reviled , he reviled not again , when he suffered he threatned not , but committed himself to him who judgeth righteously : When we consider with what strange Sedateness of Spirit he bore the Mockings , Buffettings , and most Contumelious and insolent Behaviour of vile Creatures towards himself : It is then hardly Possible that We despicable Worms should Rage and be inflamed upon the account of such Disgrace , Contempt and ill usage from Rude People , as is not to be compared with that which He underwent . When we consider how our Blessed Saviour Forgave those who Thirsted after his Bloud , and were never satisfied till they had put him to the most shameful and most cruel Death ; and not only Forgave them himself , but Entreated his Father , and that even in the midst of his Torments ( when his Spirit one would think should be most highly exasperated ) to forgive them too : I say , when we consider this , how can it be difficult to disswade our selves from Meditating Revenge upon any Provocations whatsoever ? Surely we must needs be very powerfully inclined to forgive our Enemies . When we call to mind how He exprest his love to his very Murderers , even so as to design the greatest good to them by the means of that , whereby they designed the greatest evil to him , can we be averse to the bearing Good will to those who are ill affected towards us , to the Blessing of those that Curse us , and Praying for those that despightfully use us ? When we consider how this Mighty Person humbled himself , even to the washing his Disciples Feet , and declared that He came not to be ministred unto , but to minister , can We contemptible Wretches cherish the least spark of Pride in our Souls ? Can We despise the meanest of our Fellow-creatures , or think our selves too Great or too Good to condescend to the lowest Offices of Love whereby we may serve our Brethren ? When we consider with what submission to the Divine Will our Blessed Lord indured the most exquisite Pains both of Soul and Body , though He never deserved them by the least offence , but was always most perfectly obedient to his Father , can this be other than a most forcible motive to us , who have Merited so ill at the Hands of God , quietly to submit to his good Pleasure in Afflicting us , whenas in so doing he doth always punish us far less than our iniquities deserve ? When we consider how well satisfied our Saviour was to be in poor low Circumstances , and not to have so much as a Cottage of his own to put his Head in , though he was Lord of all : Is it imaginable that We should aspire at High and Great things , and having Food and Raiment , not be Content , who are less than the least of all God's mercies ? And lastly , Will not the Consideration of our Saviour's being such a Man of sorrows , and so acquainted with griefs , exceedingly deaden our desires after Sensual Pleasures ? Surely it must necessarily so do . Thus we see how greatly exciting the Example of our Saviour is to the perfect Mortifying of those Lusts which are most strong and vigorous , to the loathing and abominating those , which are naturally very dear to us , and to the most restless endeavours , to get our Souls possessed of those Virtues and Graces which are most supernatural . Thirdly , Another very prevalent Motive is , the Assurance our Lord hath given us , that He will not take such Advantage of our Frailties and Weaknesses , or Sins we fall into by mere surprize and want of due Watchfulness , as to cast us off for them ; so long as we allow not our selves in any evil way , and it is the principal design of our lives , to be conformed in all things to the Laws of Righteousness . There is a Prophecy concerning the Messiah , Isaiah 42. 3. which our Saviour applieth to himself , Matth. 12. 20. A bruised reed shall he not break , and smoaking flax shall he not quench , &c. He will not crush under foot those who fall through weakness , but whatsoever good he seeth in them , he will still cherish . My little children ( saith S. Iohn ) these things I write unto you , that ye sin not : But what if , through the weakness of their Flesh , they should at any time be overtaken , is their state then desperate ? No , by no means , for it follows , And if any man sin , we have an Advocate with the Father Iesus Christ the Righteous , &c. 1 Epist. 2. 1. As there are Sins unto Death , so there are Sins not unto Death , according to that of the same Apostle , 1 Epist. 5. 17. All unrighteousness is sin , and there is a sin not unto death . Though all Unrighteousness be sin , and the deserved wages of sin be Death , yet such is the Goodness of God through Christ , that all Sins shall not be unto Death , but only Wilful and Presumptuous Sins . And I add , not these neither , if not persevered in , but throughly forsaken . If we were liable to Eternal Ruine for such Faults , as considering all our Circumstances in this state , it is scarcely to be hoped we shall constantly avoid , we should necessarily live in great Bondage , through continual fear , anxiety and disquieting thoughtfulness : But on the other hand , it conduceth exceedingly to the chearful pursuing our Great Work , to be satisfied that it is not every Failure that shall endanger our final miscarrying . And it is no small inducement to ingenuous Tempers , to be so much the more solicitous to avoid Deliberate and Wilful sins , because God through Christ is so ready to forgive , and graciously pass by those that are not such : Because he is pleased in his infinite Goodness to grant a pardon of course for these , upon condition of their being in the general and habituals repented of . And it is a great Motive also to such Tempers , to be the more vigilant and watchful against all sins whatsoever ; against sins of daily incursion and infirmity , as well as those which waste the Conscience . And those are very ill natured and obdurate Sinners , who can find in their hearts to Encourage themselves by this indulgence to sin the more freely . Fourthly , Another wonderful Encouragement to the careful use of the Means , we are directed to for the subduing of our Lusts , is our Saviours Mediation and Intercession . There is one God and one Mediator between God and men , the man Christ Iesus . His oblation was begun on Earth , but perfected in Heaven ; where He appears in the presence of God for us , Heb. 9. 24. Those Prayers we put up in His name , for things Agreeable to the Divine Will , with honest and sincere hearts , our Saviour inforceth with his own Intercession . He ever lives to make intercession for us , Heb. 7. 25. And for this reason ( as the Apostle saith in the former part of that Verse ) He is able to save them to the uttermost that come unto God by him : That is , to give them a full and complete Deliverance from the Slavery of sin , and all the evil Consequents thereof . Now we know that we ask what is according to the Will of God , when we pray for his Grace to Mortifie our Corruptions , and to set us more and more Free from their Dominion : This is the Will of God , even our Sanctification , &c. 1 Thess. 4. 3. There are many Temporal good things , which God in his infinite Wisdom may see not to be good for us ; but He knows that whatsoever hath a necessary influence into our Soul's welfare , and the making us partakers of his own image and likeness , can by no Circumstances whatsoever become unfit to be bestowed on those that heartily and sincerely seek it . And therefore we are assured that those prayers that are put up for such things , with a true heart and full assurance of faith in his Power and Goodness , are seconded in Heaven by our Blessed Lord : And him the Father heareth always , John 11. 42. We have shewed that our Saviour hath purchased a Rich supply of Grace to help our Weakness , and that his Holy Spirit is promised to those that ask him ; who will not fail to assist them , whilest they carefully exert that power they are already in possession of : But the most Honest Souls have so frequent experience of Heaviness , Dulness and Distractions in their Addresses to God , that they would be in great danger of despairing of the Success of their Prayers , but for this Consideration , that they have a no Less Friend in Heaven , than the Only Begotten Son of God ; who is most powerful with his Father , and supplies all the Defects of their Prayers by his own Intercession in their behalf . I need not say , what a marvellous incouragement this is of our Faith and Hope in the Divine Goodness ; which are so necessary to Animate us , and to put Spirit and Life into all our Endeavours . And the Mediation and Intercession of our Blessed Saviour conduceth exceedingly to the overcoming those inslaving Passions of Fearfulness and Shame , which arise from Guilt ; and do naturally cause a great Averseness in Sinners from going into the Presence of God , and disable them , when they are there , to behave themselves as they ought before him . S. Paul tells the Ephesians , that In Christ Iesus they have boldness and access with confidence , by the faith of him . That is , through Christ's Mediation those Believing Gentiles ( of whose Calling he was discoursing ) as great Sinners as they had been , even dead in Trespasses and Sins , have liberty of Approach to God , with Confidence of a kind Reception and a Gracious Acceptance . And the Author to the Hebrews , Chap. 10. 19 , &c. doth thus encourage Sincere Souls to draw near to God. Having therefore , Brethren , boldness ( or Liberty , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ) to enter into the holiest by the bloud of Iesus , by a new and living way , which he hath consecrated for us , ( in opposition to the dead shadows under the Law ) through the veil , that is to say , his Flesh : ( Breaking through the veil of his Flesh , being fain to die before he ascended into Heaven ) And having an High Priest over the House of God : Let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of Faith ; Having our Hearts sprinkled from an evil Conscience , and our Bodies washed with pure Water . That is , being sincerely resolved against all sins both of Heart and Life : As none that had touched any unclean thing under the Law , till the Priest had sprinkled them with pure Water , had Liberty to enter into the Congregation . Fifthly , The Reward , which our Saviour hath purchased for and promised to those that shall get free from the power of their Lusts , is another Motive , than which a more Powerful one is not to be imagined . He hath promised that such shall be with him where he is . That because he lives , they shall live also . Hath assured them , that He is gone to Heaven before , to prepare a place for them : That He is entered thither as their Forerunner : That they shall behold the Glory there which his Father hath given him ; and that they shall be sharers also with him in that Glory : That they shall sit with Him upon his Throne , Rev. 3. 21. To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me upon my Throne , even as I also overcame , and am set down with my Father on his Throne . That the Righteous shall shine forth as the Sun in the Kingdom of the Father , Matth. 13. 43. That their dead Bodies also , being raised again , shall be fashioned like to his own most Glorious Body , according to the Mighty working whereby he is able even to subdue all things unto himself , Phil. 3. 21. Of this Glory it is impossible we should speak much in this state worthily of it ; it far surpasseth our most Elevated Con●eptions , and therefore our highest Expressions must needs fall excessively short of it . It doth not yet appear what we shall be , saith S. Iohn , 1 Epist. 3. 2. only we know so much of the Heavenly Bliss , as to be assured that it is astonishingly Great ; for , as it follows , this we know , that when he appears we shall be like him ( like Him the infinitely Holy and Happy Being , in his Holiness and Happiness ) for we shall see him as he is . Which implieth such a clear , distinct and vigorous knowledge of his most Glorious Perfections , as will transform the Soul into His own Nature , and fill it with His own Blessedness , to the utmost extent of its capacity . Could we now apprehend this Blessedness in any proportion to its transcendent Greatness and Excellency , we should have no more Spirit left in us ; as it is said of the Queen of Sheba , when she beheld the Magnificence of Solomons Court. Indeed there is such an Account given us of the Happiness prepared for Good men , that we should find it impossible to believe it , but that God which cannot lye hath promised it , and that it is the purchase of a most inestimable price , the Bloud of his Eternally Begotten Son. And we have so great Evidence of its being promised by his Father , and purchased by Himself , given us by our Blessed Lord , that our own Hearts can't wish for greater ; nay , such as we could not have asked any comparable to it , might we have had our own choice of Evidence , viz. His innumerable Miraculous works , His Resurrection from the Dead , His Ascension into Heaven ; And afterwards ( exactly according to his promise ) His sending the Holy Ghost . We have not more Evidence that Iesus is the Son of God , than we have that All his sincere Disciples shall live with him , in unspeakable and Eternal Blessedness ; for we have the self - same for both . The same Arguments which have abundantly demonstrated the truth of the former Proposition , do equally prove the latter , for they depend mutually upon each other ; As S. Paul hath shewed in 1 Cor. 5. 13 , 14. If there be no Resurrection of the Dead , then is Christ not risen : And if Christ be not risen , then is our Preaching vain , and your Faith is also vain . That is , there will be no Resurrection of the Dead . Now of what mighty force and efficacy are the exceeding great and precious promises of such a Glorious state as this , to engage all the Powers of our Souls in the pursuance of that Holiness which is not only an indispensable Condition to precede the obtaining of it , but like a necessary Qualification for it . The Happiness which will naturally , by proper , Efficiency and necessary Consequence , result from our Deliverance from the Dominion of Sin , and our being instated in the Freedom we have discoursed of , would be a mighty Motive to the doing our utmost to be set at Liberty : What a Motive then is this Vast Additional Happiness which our Lord hath given us the most unquestionable Assurance of ? We can never be sufficiently affected with those words of the Apostle , Rom. 6. 21 , 22. What fruit had ye then of those things , whereof ye are now ashamed ; for the end of those things is death . But now being made free from sin , and become servants to God , ye have your fruit unto Holiness , an● the end everlasting life . Can we have such a Hope as this , such a Blessed Hope ( as the Apostle calls it ) and not heartily endeavour to purifie our selves as God is pure ? S. Iohn tells us , that he who hath this hope will do so . Hath our most Gracious Lord made to his Free Servants such a promise as this of entering into his Rest , his Glorious and Eternal Rest , how should we fear , lest by continuing in subjection to our vile Affections , we should at last fall short of it ? Good Lord ! . That such a prize as this should be set before us , and we not press hard forward towards it . That such Blessedness should be Purchased for , and Offered to those , who have no esteem or value for it . But had much rather be wretched Bondslaves and Vassals to the Devil and their Lusts , than Reign with Christ in his Everlasting Kingdom . How many shall lament this inexpressible Folly in a sad Eternity ! And this brings me to the Last Motive I shall speak to , viz. Sixthly , If it be possible , that this with the foregoing Motives should not prevail , there is another behind , which is suited to the most Disingenuous , Stubborn and Inflexible Tempers , and must needs subdue them , if any thing will : Namely , The most Dismal Threatnings our Saviour hath pronounced against those , who will not Accept the Liberty he offereth them , and become his Freemen . As such will be necessarily exceedingly miserable , beyond what they are here , when they leave this world , through the Fury of their Corrupt Appetites ( there being no objects in the other state to appease it , or to afford them the least satisfaction or gratification ) so our Lord hath declared , that , They shall be cast into outer Darkness , where shall be weeping , and wailing , and gnashing of teeth , Matth. 8. 12. That , they shall be cast into a Furnace of Fire , Matth. 13. 42. That , He will say unto them at the last Day , Depart from me ye cursed into Everlasting Fire , prepared for the Devil and his Angels , Matth. 25. 41. And his Apostle S. Paul hath told such , what their Doom shall be , in 2 Thess. 1. 7 , 8 , 9. viz. That the Lord Iesus shall be revealed from Heaven , with his Mighty Angels , in flaming Fire , taking vengeance on them that know not God , and obey not the Gospel of our Lord Iesus Christ : Who shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord , and from the Glory of his power : When he shall come to be glorified in his Saints , and to be admired of all them that believe . Then shall we discern the vastest difference imaginable between the states of the Righteous and the Wicked , of those who have through the Spirit mortified the deeds of the body , and those who have lived after the flesh . The Former sort of men , as the same Apostle saith , shall live ; that is , a most inexpressibly Happy and Glorious life : The Latter shall die ; that is , the Second death , or be Eternally Miserable . One shall be taken , and the other left : One shall be saved , the Other damned : One shall be received into the Blessed Mansions above , and crowned with Immortal Bliss and Glory ; the other shall be tumbled down into Hell , and have his portion in the lake that burneth with Fire and Brimstone . Did I say , that these Fearful Threatnings are designed to awaken the most Disingenuous , Stupid and Obdurate Souls ? I fear there are Few who do not find , that they have need sometimes of seriously considering them , and laying them to heart . And when we feel the principle of ingenuity most unactive , as also that those Motives that excite our Hope have but a weak influence ( as it is possible we may , at certain times , be in so dull and heavy a Temper , as that we may be but very little affected with them ) then should we rouse up our selves out of our Lethargick stupidity , by employing our Thoughts upon the Terrors of the Lord , the most Terrible Threatnings of the Gospel . And now what think we ? Hath not our Blessed Lord done Abundantly enough to make us Free indeed ; To set us at Liberty from Sin and to Righteousness ? In that he hath not only shewn us What it is to be made Free , and wherein our Liberty consisteth ; And given us the best Means , by the use of which , as we ought , we shall be set at Liberty ; And purchased such Grace for us as whereby we may be successful in the use of those Means , if we will not neglect them ; But also hath given us such Motives , as those we have now discoursed of , to prevail with our Wills not to receive that Grace in vain . And as for these Motives , can the Heart of Man conceive any more powerful ? No surely , nor could it , unassisted by Divine Revelation , conceive any that are the thousandth part so powerful . But besides all this ( as hath been intimated ) the Blessed Spirit of God is ready so to inforce these Motives upon us , if we will endeavour to think seriously upon them , as that they shall effectually do what they are designed for : And not only so , but he also begins with us , and by his secret suggestions excites us to the due Consideration of them , and the use of whatsoever Means we are directed to , for the pulling down of strong holds , and casting down every imagination , and every high thing , that advanceth it self against the Scepter and Government of Christ in our Souls , and the bringing every thought , and all that is within us , to the obedience of Christ. And thus doth he work in us both to will and to do , as to Do so to Will , of his own good pleasure : or , of his free and undeserved mercy to us . And therefore what encouragement have we to put the Apostles inference from that Doctrine into Practice , namely , To work out our own Salvation with fear and trembling ? That is , to work out our own Deliverance from the Dominion of Sin , and our Slavish subjection thereunto , with great Diligence and Solicitude . SECT . III. Containing the Inferences from each of the Arguments of the foregoing Sections . CHAP. X. Which treats of the First Inference from the First Proposition , [ That the most Excellent Liberty doth consist in an Intire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness ; Or in Freedom from the Dominion of Sinful Affections . ] Namely , That those are most Vnreasonable and Depraved People , who complain of the Divine Laws as intolerable Intrenchments upon their Liberty . Where it is shewed , First , That upon supposition our Liberty were restrained by the Laws of God , it would nevertheless be most unreasonable to complain upon that account . Secondly , That the Laws which oblige Christians do not restrain their Liberty . I AM come now to the Last Head of Discourse , viz. To draw distinctly from each of the Arguments of the foregoing Sections several very useful Inferences : Such as , if they be duly considered , will farther improve us in our Knowledge of the true Nature and Design of the Christian Religion ; and ( with the assistance of the Divine Grace ) Advance us higher in the true Evangelical Spirit and Temper . To begin with the Former of those Arguments , viz. That the most Excellent Liberty consisteth in an Intire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness ; or in Freedom from the Dominion of Corrupt and Sinful Assections . From hence , and what hath been discoursed thereupon , we Infer , First , That those are most Unreasonable , and very sadly Depraved who complain of , and quarrel with the Divine Laws as great Intrenchments upon their Liberty ; And therefore , in regard of the high value they set upon Liberty , cry out upon them as intolerable . For , First , Suppose it were true , that our Liberty is much restrained by the Laws of God , yet would it be the most unreasonable thing in the World to cavil at them upon that account , or to think our selves too unkindly dealt with : And that for these three Reasons . 1. We know by Experience , that it is Absolutely necessary to the Well being ( nay to the very Being ) of Societies , that particular Persons be obliged to part with not a little of their Natural Liberty . It is utterly inconsistent with the Wellfare of the Whole , for each Particular to insist so severely on his own Right , as to refuse to submit to the being deprived of that Liberty , in several instances , in which the Primary Laws of Nature have instated him : And consequently this is as inconsistent with the Wellfare of Particulars ; the Well-being of each Part depending upon the Well-being of the Whole . There can be no Leagues , Compacts or Agreements between Men and Men , but there must be yielding , and quitting of Liberty ; and that on both sides too ordinarily , if not always . All the Laws of Men do suppose the Necessity of this ; Nor is there any one merely Humane Law but doth Restrain Natural Liberty . He therefore who is resolved not to let go any part of that Liberty , must resolve upon another thing too , viz. To live under no Government ; To forsake all Society with his own kind , and live alone in a Desart . But by so doing he will quickly be satisfied , that he pays infinitely too dear for so stiffly infilling upon his beloved Liberty , and that he hath sold for it all the Comfort of his Life , and whatsoever would make it desirable to him . In a word , There can be no such thing as Property without parting with several points of Liberty ; without this no Meum or ●uum ( I mean as to any thing without our selves , or that can happen to come within the reach of Anothers Power ) can be secured , as every Body will grant . And therefore can it be thought a grievous thing that God himself should restrain our Liberty ? 2. As it will be Universally Acknowledged , that it is Absolutely necessary , that Particular Persons be abridged of their Natural Liberty in abundance of instances , so all that have a right Notion of the Deity must needs believe , that we are abridged of it in no instances by God Almighty , but such as wherein it is most fit we should be abridged . The Holy Scriptures assure us of nothing more , nor doth Natural Light neither , than that Infinite Wisdom , Righteousness and Goodness are necessary Perfections of the Divine Nature ; Than that Wilfulness and Arbitrariness , Austerity and Sourness , Envy and Ill will , are as far removed from God as is Hell from Heaven . And consequently , though several of His Laws should seem to our thinking never so Unreasonable , yet while we adhere to the Scriptural and Natural Notion of the Deity , we our selves would be most Unreasonable , in not Concluding them to be really most contrary to what they may seemingly be to us ; in not believing them to be as Wise , as Righteous , and as Good , as any can fancy them Weak , Unrighteous , or Unkind . 3. As from the Consideration of the Nature of God we are as certain as we are capable of being of any thing , that all the Abatements and Limitations of our Liberty , He is the Author of , are most Wise , Just and Good ; that they are founded in great Reason , Equity and Kindness also to us , so we that live under the Gospel Dispensation are assured from the Consideration of the particular Observances and Forbearances He hath by Christ Iesus obliged us to , that they are no other , than such as are infinitely Worthy of such a God. They are all of that nature , that they carry their own Reason most visibly and apparently along with them : And such as we are easily able to give account to our selves , upon what particular Designs , it was the pleasure of our Creator to impose them upon us . 'T is the easiest thing in the World to demonstrate , that they are not only all of them Consistent with Infinite Goodness , but also great Instances and Expressions thereof : That God is not only most Righteous in enjoyning each of them , but most Good and Gracious . All but some two or three of the Precepts of the Gospel are no other than what Right Reason , and the Law of our Creation did , and must necessarily , always oblige us to , as will presently be seen . And those very few purely Evangelical ones are designed for our better Observation of those Natural Laws . And thus I have shewed in short , that , granting Gods Laws do put restraints ( and those many too ) upon our Liberty , we have no cause to complain upon that account : They restraining it only in such particulars , as wherein it is incomparably better for us to be restrained than otherwise . But Secondly , It is utterly to be denied , that the Laws we Christians are under the Obligation of , do any of them restrain our Liberty . They restrain Licentiousness indeed , but not Liberty . This doth sufficiently appear from what hath been discoursed . That cannot be true Liberty which is injurious to our Chiefest Liberty , but our Chiefest Liberty we have shewed doth consist in being free to Good ; in having all impediments taken out of our way to the free exercise of those Virtues which are ( as I may say ) the very Soul of our Souls , the Life of our Souls , as our Souls are of our Bodies : Without which we are dead even whilest we live ; without which we are in an utter incapacity of enjoying our selves , of being in the least measure truly Happy , or of Living like Men , and discharging the Functions of that Life which is proper to Reasonable Creatures : And by the absence of which we degenerate into the Brutish , nay into the Devilish Nature . You may as well say , that He is abridged of his Liberty , who is kept from running his Head into the fire , or from Cutting his own Throat , as that He is so , who is forbidden to be Unjust and Unrighteous in any kind , or to be Malicious , or Uncharitable , or Intemperate , or Lascivious : That is , who is forbidden to play the Beast or the Devil . Or who is Commanded to Love God above all , to Fear Him , to Trust in Him , to be Thankful to Him , in all his ways to Acknowledge Him ; and to Love his Neighbour as himself . But , if we will believe the Great S. Paul , in these particulars is comprehended all that for Substance , which the Grace of God that bringeth Salvation reacheth men to forbear or practise . To summ up all in short that needs to be said about this matter , There is nothing required of us , but it is either an Essential part of our Liberty , of our Highest and most Excellent Liberty , to be Free to it , or is a Means to the obtaining and Maintenance of it . What an Unreasonable Brutish Creature therefore art Thou , whosoever thou art , that darest repine at the Restraints which thy Creator and Redeemer have laid upon thee , whenas these Restraints ( if they may be called so ) are necessary to thy greatest Enlargement . And let me tell thee , thou that thinkest much of being held within the Limits which the Gospel hath set thee , thou affectest a Liberty which God himself hath not , and Abhors to have . CHAP. XI . The Second Inference , viz. That such a Freedom of Will as consists in an Indifferency to good or evil is no Perfection , but the Contrary . SEcondly , We may observe from the abovesaid Discourse , That such a Freedom of Will as consists in an Indifferency to Good or Evil , as much as it is magnified by some for a great Perfection of the Humane Nature , is indeed no better than a Diminution and Disparagement : Nor is it otherwise Commendable than as a less Evil. This must necessarily be so , if the most Excellent Liberty consisteth in an entire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness , as it hath been fully proved it doth . Seneca hath somewhere a most Impudent and Blasphemous saying , to this purpose : That a Wise , or Virtuous , man is in some respect Superior to God himself ; because God is Good by necessity of Nature , but he by his own free choice . 'T is to be confessed , that , comparing this indifferency to Good or Evil with the Determination of the Will to Evil , so it is desirable ; but then it is so only as 't is a less Evil than the other , as was said . But comparing it with the Determination of the Will to Good , from an inward Principle , viz. from a quick , Vigorous Sense of the infinite Loveliness of Virtue , and monstrous Deformity and Ugliness of Vice , so on the other hand , 't is a great imperfection , and consequently by no means desirable . The Divine Nature will be acknowledged to be the Great Standard and Measure of Perfections : We cannot question but that , the more like to God any one is , the more perfect he will be ; and the more unlike to God , the more imperfect : But the being Free to Evil and Undetermined to Good , makes a man less like God , because God is ( as hath been shewn ) necessarily , from his own Nature Determined to Good , and from Evil ; And his Infinite Wisdom , Holiness , Righteousness and Goodness cannot consist with Peccability , or a Possibility of doing or approving the least Evil. And therefore the more any one is from within himself , from a good Temper of mind , determined to that which is Good , the more like must he needs be to the Best of Beings , and the more he partakes of a Divine Nature . That saying of S. Ierome doth need a Paraphrase , viz. God is the only Being , that is uncapable of sinning ; but all Creatures , having Free Will in them , may turn their Will to Good or Evil. Namely , that God alone is Absolutely Im●eccable ; not but that by the Divine Grace Creatures may be made so ; as , without doubt , the Angels and Saints in Heaven are . And , whereas the Father seems to exclude Free Will from God , and to give it to all Reasonable Creatures , he must mean such a Free Will as consisteth in Indifferency to Good or Evil , or Undeterminedness from within to Good and against Evil , and so on the contrary . This kind of Freedom cannot belong to God , because it speaks great imperfection : For it supposeth him who hath it , to be without such a Sense of the Excellency and Loveliness of Goodness , and the Hatefulness and Intolerableness of Wickedness , as he ought to have . He that can in the least Deliberate ▪ whether it be more Eligible to be Just or Unjust , Chaste or Impure , Intemperate or Sober , to speak Truth or to Lye , to Love God or the World , to Forgive or Revenge , to be Pitiful or Cruel , to be Niggardly or Charitable , &c. He , I say , that can perswade himself to Deliberate about these things , doth manifestly declare , that he understands neither the one nor the other , as he ought to do . I mean , that he hath nothing so lively a Sense of the Goodness of the one , or the Evil of the other , as it becomes him to have . If we had such a Sense , it would be as impossible to perswade us to any Vile Action , as it would be to prevail with a man in his right Mind , to pour melted Lead down his own Throat , to pluck out his Eyes , or to dash out his Brains . You cannot deliberate whether it be better for you to be Healthy or Sick , to be at Ease or in Torment , to have a Good Name or a Bad , to be Beggarly or in Plentiful Circumstances , to be a Wise man or a Fool , to be a Mad-man or in your Wits , to be a Slave or a Freeman , &c. You will say that Bedlam is the fittest place for him , that shall in the least consider which of these he shall chuse . Now if we had as great a Sense of the Evil of the infinitely worst of Evils Sin , as we have of those Evils , it would be as impossible , that our Wills should incline to the Commission of a known Sin , as that they should prefer Sickness before Health , and refuse Ease and embrace Torment . As for those that contend that , It is more Praise-worthy to do Good and forbear Evil , having a Power to do otherwise , than to be under a necessity of so doing ▪ Supposing they mean by necessity , such as is not from without , or from an inward blind instinct , but from an Understanding Principle and Perfection of Nature , I must needs tell them there is no Proposition in the World more false or absurd . For is God Almighty the less to be Admired , Loved or Praised for his Goodness , because his Nature is so Good , as that He cannot but be ever doing good ? Surely He is much the more to be Loved , Adored , Admired and Praised upon this account . I will not therefore stick to say , that to have the Will necessarily determined to all Good , and from all Evil , from an Overpowering Sense of the Becomingness and Excellency of the one , and the Vileness and Odiousness of the other , is the very Perfection of Liberty . And this is so far from being impossible to be obtained by Creatures or by our Selves , that , by the help of God's Grace , it is in a large measure even in this life Attainable . I mean such a Sense of Good and Evil , as shall certainly determine us to Good and against Evil in most of the instances of each . There are some immoralities and wicked Actions , that they who have attained to but very mean and ordinary degrees of Goodness , cannot perswade themselves so much as to endeavour to reconcile their Minds to . Nay , there are some that no man can easily be supposed able to consent to , but an extraordinarily Depraved and Wicked Wretch , let the Motives that are used to perswade him be what they will. Such as Blaspheming of God : Contriving the Murther of our Parents , or of a most obliging Friend : Torturing of innocent Babes , and the like Horrid Villanies . Surely then , a man is capable of such a Vivid sense of the Hatefulness of Sin in general , as will ( whilest it lasts ) render it impossible for him to Will deliberately to commit any known Sin whatsoever . 'T is confessed that we cannot hope to get past all danger of sudden Surprizals , so long as we inhabit these Bodies , and remain in our present Unhappy Circumstances ; but , I say , so powerful a Sense of the Infinite Unrighteousness , Disingenuity , Unreasonableness , Folly and Madness of opposing the Holy Will of our Great Creator and Blessed Redeemer may , by the Divine Assistance , be acquired even on this side Heaven , as shall Determine us effectually against all Deliberate and Wilful Violations of the Divine Laws . For this we have the Authority of a Great Apostle : S. Iohn saith in his 1 Epist. 3. 9. Whosoever is Born of God doth not commit Sin , for his Seed remaineth in him , neither can he Sin , because he is Born of God. He here affirms , not only that those who have attained to extraordinary Measures of Goodness cannot Sin , that is , cannot will to sin deliberately , but likewise that no Regenerate or truly Good man can . He cannot thus Sin , because he is born of God ; because he is a Child of God by the inward Renewing of his Holy Spirit : And because his Seed remaineth in him , that is , the Divine Seed . Which Divine Seed I take to be the same thing with the several times mentioned Quick , Powerful and Pungent Sense of the Horrid Nature , and most dreadful Effects and Consequents of Wilful Sinning . It is more than Morally impossible , that whilest this Sense abideth in its Strength and Vigour , the Good man should lapse into such Sins . Have we not such a Sense of the Vileness of some Actions , as to say frequently , I could not for all the world find in mine heart ( that is , in my Will ) to do so or so ? And if we had the same Sense of all Sins , which it is unreasonable not to have , considering them as Sins , or Transgressions of the Everlasting Rules of Righteousness ( for considering them under that notion , all sins are alike ) I say had we the same Sense of all Sins , we should as truly say concerning each , I cannot find in mine heart , I cannot will , to consent unto it . CHAP. XII . Which Treats of one Branch of the First Inference from the Argument of the Second Section , [ That in Freedom from the Dominion of Corrupt Affections doth that Liberty Principally or rather Wholly Consist , which Christ hath purchased for us . ] Namely , that several Notions of Christian Liberty , which have too much prevailed , are false and of dangerous Consequence . The First of which is , That which makes it to consist , wholly or in part , in Freedom from the Obligation of the Moral Law. Certain Texts , urged by the Antinomians in favour of it , vindicated from the sence they put upon them . And the extreme wildness and wickedness of it exposed in Five Particulars . WE proceed now to the Inferences from the latter Argument , viz. That in Freedom from the Dominion of Corrupt Affections , and all the sad Consequents thereof our Christian Liberty doth Eminently consist , and wholly too the Liberty which Christ hath purchased for us Gentiles . And First , We infer from hence , that several Notions of Christian Liberty , that have too much prevailed , are False and of dangerous Consequence . We will speak to , First , That which makes it to consist in Freedom from the Obligation of the Moral Law. Secondly , That which makes it to consist in Freedom from those Laws of Men , which Enjoyn or Forbid indifferent things . Thirdly , That which makes Liberty of Conscience a Branch of Christian Liberty . First , For that Notion of Christian Liberty , which makes it to consist , either wholly or in part , in Freedom from the Obligation of the Moral Law : This is extremely Wild and Wicked , as will appear from what hath been discoursed . It is the Doctrine of the Antinomians , and they produce in favour of it all those Texts wherein we are said to be delivered from the Law. As particularly Rom. 7. 6. Now we are delivered from the Law , that being dead wherein we were held , &c. Gal. 2. 19. I through the Law am dead to the Law , &c. Rom. 6. 14. Ye are not under the Law , but under Grace . Gal. 4. 4 , 5. When the fulness of time was come , God sent forth his Son , made of a Woman , made under the Law , to Redeem them that were under the Law , &c. To this it is Answered , That there are indeed many Texts which Assert our being freed from the Law , but the Question is , What Law they mean ? Or rather 't is out of Question , that they mean not the Moral Law. For there is no need of doing more than reading throughout the forementioned Verses , to satisfie us , that the Apostle understood , in each of them , nothing less than that Law. Nay , we need do no more to be assured , that he Abominated this Notion of Christian Liberty . For whereas he saith , Rom. 7. 6. Now we are delivered from the Law , that being dead wherein we were held ; it follows , that we should serve in Newness of Spirit , and not in the Oldness of the Letter . That is , That we should no longer be merely Externally Obedient , but also , Inwardly and Spiritually . Whereas he saith , Gal. 2. 19. I through the Law am dead to the Law , he immediately adds this as the reason why he was so , that I might live unto God : Or be in all things conformed to the Rules of Righteousness and Goodness , which He hath prescribed ; all which are comprehended in the Moral Law. Again , whereas he tells the Romans , Chap. 6. 14. Ye are not under the Law but under Grace : This comes in as a proof of what he said immediately before in the same Verse , viz. Sin shall not have dominion over you . Lastly , In saying , Gal. 4. 5. That Christ was made of a Woman , made under the Law , to redeem them that were under the Law , he gives this in the next words as the reason or design hereof , that we might receive the Adoption of Sons . But doth not the Relation of a Son necessarily infer Obligation to Obedience ? It doth so no less than that of a Servant . For where God saith , If I am a Master , where is my Fear ? he saith also , If I am a Father where is mine Honour ? The Law therefore which is to be understood in these and the like places is the purely Iewish Law , the mere External and Drudging Observances of the Mosaical Dispensation , which the Iewish Believers thought themselves to be still under the Obligation of , and Condemned the Gentile Converts for not submitting their Necks to the same Yoke . And the Apostle takes a great deal of pains , in his Epistles to the Romans and Galatians , to confute that mistake ; and to convince the Iews , that that Law was made by Christ null and void ; that He had Cancelled it , and taken away its Obliging power . And in each of those places the Apostle as plainly affirms this to be the Law they were delivered from , as that it is not the Moral Law. We will therefore a third time go them over again . Rom. 7. 6. Now we are delivered from the Law , that being dead wherein we were held , that we should serve in Newness of Spirit , and not in the Oldness of the Letter . That is , We are delivered from that Law , that considered literally , required nothing but a company of Bodily Washings , Outward Services , and Carnal Performances , which the Iews generally rested in , and thought no more was to be done to render them Acceptable in the sight of God ; And the reason why we are delivered from this Law is , that so we may be the more intent upon the Great Substantial Duties , and the Purification of our Hearts , Souls and Spirits . Gal. 2. 19. I through the Law am dead to the Law , that I might live unto God. Or , I by virtue of the Law of Christ , am dead to the Law of Moses , that I may have all impediments taken out of my way to the being intirely devoted , as to the Inward as well as Outward man , to the Service of God. And it hath been shewed how injurious this Law did Accidentally become to the great Design of the Gospel , viz. The making us Spiritually Obedient ; the enduing us with Inward , Real , Substantial Righteousness ; or the Divine Likeness . Rom. 6. 14. Sin shall not have dominion over you , for ye are not under the Law , but under Grace . That is , There is no necessity of your continuing under the power and dominion of Sin , because you are not under the weak Dispensation of Moses , which made nothing perfect , and gave no strength to mortifie Lust , but under the Gospel Dispensation , which is accompanied with Promises of Plentiful Supplies of Grace and Strength . Gal. 4. 5. God sent forth his Son , made of a Woman , made under the Law , to Redeem them that were under the Law , that we might receive the Adoption of Sons . Or , That we might no longer drudge like Servants of the inferior Sort , in such Employments as are mean and low , having no Internal Goodness in them ; and that from the hope only of some sleight Reward , from the hope of some mere Earthly good things , such as are Gratifications only of the Animal and Sensual life ; and from the Fear of mere Temporal Evils , and the present Lash , ( that Law containing no other express Promises or Threatnings but Temporal , as was shewed ) but may be dealt with as Sons , be Honourably employed , viz. in such services as are of the most Excellent nature , and do recommend themselves by their own Goodness , and Agreeableness to our Rational and Intellectual Faculty . And be acted also by a more Noble Principle , viz. Love , and encouraged by an Infinitely more Noble Reward , which consisteth in a perfect Likeness to God , and an Everlasting Enjoyment of him . And thus we see , these very Texts that are made use of by the Antinomians , to prove this mad Notion of Christian Liberty from the Obligation of the Moral Law , are so far from signifying any thing to this purpose , that they give manifest and clear proof of the Contrary . As they are far from asserting , that any such Liberty as this belongs to Christians , so they assure us that no such Liberty belongeth to them . Tertullian hath a good saying to our present purpose : The Yokes of Works ( meaning the Drudgeries of the Ceremonial Law ) are cast off , not those of Rules to walk by . Liberty in Christ is not injurious to innocence . The intire Law of Piety , Holiness , Humanity , V●rity , Chastity , Righteousness , Mercy , B●n●volence , Purity is still of force . And indeed should we find this Doctrine in those Texts , that our Saviour hath procured for us Freedom from this Law , then , First , The Blessed Apostle would have most expresly contradicted his Great Master , and so have proved himself no Apostle ; For our Saviour plainly saith , Matth. 5. 17. Think not , let not such a wild fancy enter into your Heads , that I am come to destroy the Law and the Prophets , I am not come to destroy , but to fulfil : 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , to fill it up , or Preach it fully . I am so far from such a Design , as that of destroying or Abolishing the Moral Law , that , on the contrary , I am come to Preach it more fully and perfectly , than ever it was before my Coming . And this he presently sets upon doing , Vers. 21 , 22 , 27 , 28 , &c. Ye have heard that it hath been said by them of old time , thou shalt not Kill , and whosoever shall Kill shall be in danger of the judgment ; but I say unto you , that whoso●v●r is Angry with his Brother without a cause , shall be in danger of the judgment , &c. Ye have heard , that it was said by them of old time , Thou shalt not commit Adultery : but I say unto you , that whosoev●r shall look upon a Woman , to lust after h●r , hath committed Adultery already with her in his heart . And so He goes on to Perfect and Fill up Law , in the following Verses . Again our Saviour saith , vers . 18. Verily I say unto you , that till Heaven and Earth pass , one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the Law , till all be fulfilled : 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , till all be done , or till all things come to an End , according to Doctor Hammond . He hath not here respect to the Universal Conflagration , saith Grotius upon the place , but it is a Proverbial speech , as if it were said in Latine , Vsque dum Coelum ruat : Till the Heavens fall . Which is thus expressed , Luke 16. 17. And it is easier for Heaven and Earth to pass , than one tittle of the Law to fail . In which manner of speaking , as saith the same Learned Expositor , He hath respect to the Order of Nature , and not to the Power of God. But according to Nature it seems impossible that Heaven and Earth should pass away or perish . So that the meaning of these Texts is plainly this , viz. The Obligation of the Law can neither cease , nor be diminished or relaxed in the least , to all Eternity . And then our Saviour adds , Vers. 19. of this Fifth of S. Matthew , Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least Commandments , and shall teach men so , he shall be called the least in the Kingdom of Heaven : That is , saith Grotius , Minimi erit pretii , eum minimi habitum iri , he shall be contemned , and treated as a most despicable wretch at the Day of Iudgment . Then it follows , But whosoever shall do and teach them , the same shall be called Great in the Kingdom of Heaven . He shall be highly Honoured , and signally Rewarded . When the young Man came to our Saviour to ask him , What good thing he should do , that he might have Eternal life , we know what his Answer was , If thou wilt enter into life , keep the Commandments , S. Matth. 19. 17. And whereas He meant all , yet ( knowing how apt Hypocrites are to flatter themselves with an opinion of the goodness of their state , upon the account of their External Conformity to the First Table Precepts , though they live in the gross Transgression of those of the Second Table ) He only expressed those which enjoyn Duties relating to our Neighbour . For the young Man asking which Commandments ? Iesus said , Thou shalt do no Murder , Thou shalt not commit Adultery , Thou shalt not Steal , Thou shalt not bear false Witness , Honour thy Father and thy Mother : And thou shalt love thy Neighbour as thyself , Ver. 18 , 19. Secondly , The Apostle would have Contradicted himself most Egregiously , as well as his Master , should he , in the above-cited Places , or any where else , teach this Notion of Christian Liberty . For 't was He that said , Do we make void the Law through Faith , God forbid , yea we establish the Law , Rom. 3. 31. He here includes even the Ceremonial Law , as appears by ver . 28. ( which gave occasion to these words ) Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by Faith , without the deeds of the Law : That is , that a Gentile is justified without Circumcision , or Sacrifices , or any other of the Iewish Rites and Services , which they still laid so great weight upon ; as appears by the two following Verses , Is he the God of the Iews only ? Is he not also of the Gentiles ? Yes of the Gentiles also . Seeing it is one God , which shall justifie the Circumcision by Faith , and Vncircumcision through Faith. Now saith the Apostle , God forbid we should affirm that the Gospel Dispensation should make void the Law ; should make useless so much as the Ceremonial Law , therefore much less the Moral , yea we assert it establisheth the Law. In some sence it even establisheth or perfects that Law , as it brings in the substance of that , whereof that Law had the shadow ; and requireth purity of Heart , which was the spiritual meaning of Circumcision . Again , 't was the same S. Paul that said , Not the Hearers of the Law are just before God ; but the Doers of the Law shall be justified , Rom. 2. 13. And it is He who makes it to be the design of Christ's Expiating our Sins upon the Cross , That the Righteousness of the Law might be fulfilled in us , who walk not after the Flesh , but after the Spirit . And it is this same Apostle that saith , Though I speak with the Tongues of Men and of Angels , and have not Charity ( a Moral Virtue ) I am become as sounding Brass , or a tinkling Cymbal . And though I have the gift of Prophecy , and understand all Mysteries , and all Knowledge : And though I have all Faith , so that I could remove Mountains , and have no Charity , I am nothing , &c. 1 Cor. 13. 1 , 2. And in the last Verse , doth not only Equalize Charity with Faith and Hope ( which many now adays are so far from doing , that they are angry with those who do so ) but also Advanceth it above those Graces . And now abideth Faith , Hope , Charity , these three , but the greatest of these is Charity . Thirdly , Whosoever teacheth this Doctrine , of Christ's having set us free from the Moral Law , contradicteth the whole strain of the New Testament : Our Saviours Sermon on the Mount throughout , all his Injunctions and even all his Discourses , and all the Precepts and Exhortations contained in the Epistles of the Apostles . They are all so many instances of the Obligations that the First and Second Tables lay upon us , as understood in the most Spiritual , Sublime and Comprehensive Sence : And none are more so than those of S. Paul , so intolerably is he abused in being made the Great , and I think , Onely Patron of that most licentious and wicked Doctrine . And even that Precept of Believing in the Name of the Son of God , is a First-Table Precept , not Positive but Moral , in its own Nature necessarily obliging , and a Dictate of Natural Light , to all those who are acquainted with the Evidence of his being the Messiah , and Son of God. Upon our understanding how He is demonstrated so to be , we should have known that Faith in Him is an indispensable Duty , though we could not have produced one Text to prove it . Moreover Believing in Christ , together with the Institutions of Baptism and the Lord's Supper are designed as Means to the great End of making us intirely Obedient to the Moral Law , or the Everlasting Rules of Righteousness . Fourthly , Whosoever teacheth this Doctrine , teacheth a most manifest contradiction to the Essential Principles and Make of Mankind . It is impossible that Reasonable Creatures should be disobliged from Loving God above all , from being Just and Charitable , Sober and Temperate , Humble and Submissive to the Divine Will , and the like . It is impossible that any Power whatsoever should discharge them from such duties as these . Their Obligation to them doth Naturally arise from their being such Creatures . There is not a greater contradiction than this imaginable , that Creatures made capable of understanding what God is , and their Relation and Obligations to him , may not be Eternally bound to behave themselves towards him , as the Moral Law requires they should . Infinite Power it self cannot set such Creatures free from their Obligation to love God with the highest degree of love their Souls will admit of . Now as the Apostle tells us , that Love is the fulfilling of the Law , so 't is easie to shew , that all Moral Duties whatsoever , whether relating to God , our Neighbour , or our Selves , are the necessary results and consequents of the Love of God ; so that we cannot once suppose , that these should cease at any time to be the Duties of Men and Women , but we must also suppose them then deprived of their Essential Form , and to be changed into another sort of Beings . Fifthly , This Doctrine also is as apparent a contradiction to the Happiness and Welfare of Mankind . We cannot be in a Happy or tolerably Good state , but by conforming our selves to the Precepts of this Law. We have already shewed , that those must necessarily be deplorably Miserable , who live in subjection to any corrupt Appetite , any Fleshly or Spiritual Lust. To which purpose , I will add this passage of Clemens Alexandrinus , To submit and give place to evil Affections is extreme Slavery , as to overcome them is the only Liberty . Nor can the best place in the World , not Heaven it self , or the most Glorious outward circumstances , make that person Happy , or not Miserable , within whom all is amiss and out of order , and who is indued with no good Habit or Temper of Mind . A diseased Body will be uneasie , do what you can to it , and so will diseased Souls . These things considered , 't is the most Amazing thing , that any who call themselves Christians can entertain such a Notion as this of Christian Liberty ; the directly contrary being the whole Design and Business of Christianity . And yet for all that we find it as Ancient as the Apostles days ; there were those so early that did not only Teach it but Practised upon it ; that used their Liberty for a cloak of Maliciousness , and turned the Grace of God into lasciviousness . But 't is no over-bold saying , that if this could be really proved to be a Liberty of Christ's bringing into the World , there is no Good man but would abhor the Christian Religion . But the Antinomians ( not to make worse of them than they are ) tell us , that they do not deny the Obligation of Christians to the performance of the Duties required by the Moral Law , but 't is only Love , Gratitude and ingenuity that can oblige them . Which is as much as to say , that they are not obliged to them in strict Justice , or as they are the Matter of a Law. But alas , they very little mend the matter by this Salvo , nay their Doctrine is of the same dangerous consequence with it , that it is without it . For , First , It destroys all the Gospel Precepts , makes them insignificant and idle things ; They being all Moral , either in themselves or in their Design . Secondly , It takes off all Obligation to Love , Ingenuity and Gratitude . You say you are not bound to be Righteous , Charitable , Temperate , &c. by any other Law than that of Love and Gratitude : But by what Law are you obliged to the Love of God and Christ , to be Grateful to them , and to have an Ingenuous , Thankful Sense of the Great things they have done for you ? You must say by no Law at all , seeing you make these the only Law of Christians . And , if you are obliged to these things by no Law , how are they Duties ? And perswade a man once , that they are not Duties , and 't will be very strange if he make any Conscience of Love and Gratitude : And then there is nothing left to hold him in from committing all manner of wickedness with greediness , whensoever the Tempter or his Lusts solicite him , and opportunities are offered to him . But besides , they have another Doctrine , and 't is that upon which this strange wild Notion is founded , which takes away all necessity of being Grateful and Ingenuous , viz. That the Righteousness of Christ is Formally ( and not only in its Fruits and Effects ) a Believers ; so that He hath done all that the Law requires in the Believers stead , or as Personating him . This is their Sence of those words lately cited , I came not to destroy the Law , but to fulfil it ; so that Christ having fulfilled the Law as the Believers Representative , he hath fulfilled it himself in Christ. And Christs Active and Passive Obedience is his , both as to Matter and Principle , and therefore Christs Love and Gratitude are his Love and Gratitude , and all those Graces which so shined forth in Christ are the Believers , in their very Formality and Essential nature . Now what should ail those that can down with this strange stuff , to boggle at believing that they have no need at all of any other Love , Ingenuity or Gratitude , than what is thus imputed to them ? And therefore you see that their talking of the Law of Love and Gratitude is but a pitiful shift , and will do nothing towards the deliverance of their Doctrine of Freedom from the Moral Law , from the necessary tendency it is charged with , to the letting the Reins loose , and opening the Flood-gates to all Ungodliness . I exceedingly wonder how it is possible , for People that have not first lost their Wits , to embrace an Opinion so apparently Destructive of Christianity and of all Religion , and all this while profess themselves Christians , and the onely Christians too . But I have bestowed too much time in the Confutation of this Hateful Notion of Christian Liberty ; it being as ridiculously silly as it is wicked : And it being as evident to him that knows any thing of the Gospel , that it is Antichristian Licentiousness , as that there is any such thing as Christian Liberty . Poor Souls ! They little understand what Liberty meaneth , who are able to talk or think at this rate . In short , He that believes that true Christians are delivered by the Sufferings of Christ from the Curse due to the Transgressors of this Law , believes most truly ; but whosoever believes they are delivered from the Power it had to oblige to the Duties thereof , or that any man can be so delivered , thinks most wickedly , and thinks most madly . CHAP. XIII . A Second False Notion of Christian Liberty , viz. That which makes it to consist in Freedom from the Obligation of those Laws of Men , which enjoyn or forbid indifferent things . This Notion differently managed by the Defenders of it . First , Some extend it so far as to make it to reach to all Humane Laws , the matter of which are things indifferent . Secondly , Others limit it to those which relate to Religion and the Worship of God. The 23. Vers. of the 7. Chap. of the 1 Epist. to the Corinthians cleared from giving any Countenance to either of these Opinions . The Former of them Confuted by three Arguments : And the Latter by four . Vnder the Second of which , several Texts of Scripture which are much insisted upon in the defence thereof , are taken into Consideration . An unjust Reflection upon the Church of England briefly replied to . And this Principle , that the imposing of things indifferent in Divine Worship is no Violation of Christian Liberty , proved to be no ways Serviceable to Popery , by considering what the Popish Impositions are in Three Particulars . SEcondly , We are next to speak to that Notion of Christian Liberty , which makes it to consist in Freedom from those Laws of Men , that command or forbid Indifferent things : ( i. e. ) Things neither good nor evil in their own nature , nor required or prohibited by any Law of God. This Notion is differently managed by the Defenders of it . First , Some extend it to all Humane laws , the Matter of which are things Indifferent . Secondly , Others limit it to those which relate to Religion onely , and the Worship of God. But what proof is there of Christ's having purchased such a Liberty as this ? Or that Christians are made Free from such Laws in either of these Sences ? There is one Text insisted on by both of these Parties for each of their Sentiments about this matter ; viz. that of S. Paul , 1 Cor. 7. 23. Ye are bought with a price , be not ye the Servants of Men. That is , say the former party , Ye are Redeemed by the precious Bloud of Christ from the Obligation of all merely Humane Laws : From all such Observances as are only of Mens imposing , which neither Natural Light , nor any Divine Law hath made Necessary , but have left us Free to . And the latter Party say , The meaning is , Ye are Redeemed by Christ's Bloud from all merely Humane Impositions which respect Religion and Divine Worship , as being aware that the other Exposition is too too extravagant . But these two Parties are equally Out in their Application of this Text to their several purposes , nor will it do the least service to either of them . And they may as well conclude from that of our Saviour , Matth. 23. 9. Call no man your Father upon Earth , for one is your Father which is in Heaven , that it is forbidden them to acknowledge any such Relation upon Earth , as that of Father , as raise either of those Doctrines from those words of S. Paul. And , as it is manifest , that by this Prohibition of our Saviour , no more is to be understood , than that we ought not to give up our selves Universally and Absolutely to be Guided and Governed by any Man on Earth ; as the Pharisees ( of whom He is there discoursing , and against the imitation of whose proud practices he there cautions his Disciples ) did expect their Proselytes should be by them ; as young Children who are wholly ruled by the Will of their Parents : I say , as , by considering the Context , it is most evident that our Saviour there only speaks against an Vnlimited subjection to Men , as being that which is due to God only , so it is exceedingly Unreasonable to make that Prohibition of the Apostle to speak any more than thus much , Put not your selves so under the power of any Man or Men whatsoever , as to be in all things without exception , at their Devotion . As to subject your selves to their Lusts , in doing those things at their Command which God hath forbidden . And thus to do , 't is acknowledged most freely , is with a Witness opposite to our Christian Liberty , according to that Notion of it , which in this Discourse hath been laid down and defended by us . But it is , I think , a plain case , that this Place hath been not only by these men , but generally mistaken ; and that Doctor Hammond is in the right , in reading the words otherwise than they are translated , viz. thus : Are ye bought with a price ? be not ye the Servants of Men. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 may as well be rendred , Are ye ? as Ye are bought with a price . So that the meaning of these words according to this Reading is this , Have you bought out your Liberty , and obtained Manumission ( having been formerly Servants to Heathens ) sell not your selves again . Return not to that condition of Servitude , but prefer Liberty . The immediately foregoing Verses do greatly favour this Reading , viz. Ver. 21 , 22. Art thou called being a Servant ? care not for it , think it not a disparagement to Christianity for a Bondman to be a Christian , but if thou mayest be made Free , use it rather : Prefer Freedom , if thou canst lawfully obtain it . For he that is called in the Lord , being a Servant , is the Lord's Free-man : Likewise also he that is called being Free , is Christ's Servant . So that the 23. Ver. follows these two very fitly and pertinently , as we now read it , Are ye bought with a price ? that is , out of your Servile condition , ( and it was ordinary in those days , for Christians to buy themselves from their Heathen Masters ) be not ye , or be not ye made [ 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ] the Servants of Men. Or return not any more to your former condition . Now , First , For that Doctrine which makes it a part of Christian Liberty to be freed from all Laws that are merely Humane ; ( which the minds of some Professors of Christianity were leavened with , as I might shew , even in the Apostles time , and all theirs must needs have been , who then held themselves disobliged from the Moral Law ) I say , as for that Doctine , the Wildness thereof will be sufficiently exposed , by that time we have considered these following Particulars . First , There is no intimation in Scripture of any such Liberty as this . I cannot think of any Text that so much seemeth to look that way , as this we have now spoken to : And this , read it how you will , cannot to any sober man , at his second thought upon it , seem so to do . But Secondly , Nothing is more slatly contradicted by the Holy Scriptures than this Doctrine . For , Servants are not only commanded to be Obedient to them that are their Masters according to the Flesh , with fear and trembling , in singleness of heart , as unto Christ , without any such limitation as this , If they command nothing but what God hath required ; But they are expresly commanded , in all things to obey their Masters according to the Flesh , Col. 3. 22. That is , all things not Evil in themselves , or not forbidden by any Law of God. The All things must be so limited , because else S. Paul would have contradicted two other Apostles , S. Peter and S. Iohn , who said to their Rulers , upon their Commanding them not to teach any more in the Name of Iesus , Whether it be right in the sight of God , to hearken unto you more than unto God , judge ye , Acts 4. 19. This limitation needed not to be expressed , because nothing is better known from Scripture , nor from Natural Light neither , than that no Laws of the greatest Kings on Earth are of any force that are contrary to any Law of the King of Kings . According to that saying of Tertullian , if I mistake not , Obediendum est Principibus , sed intra limites disciplinae . Princes are to be obeyed , but no farther than our Religion will give us leave . I see not how he can be better than a down-right Atheist , let him pretend what he will , whosoever patronizeth the Leviathan Doctrine , that Absolute Subjection , Active no less than Passive , is due to Governours . But to return to our present Business : S. Peter is still more express , 1 Epist. 2. 18. saith he there to Servants , Be subject to your Masters with all fear , not only to the Good and Gentle , but also to the Froward . Or , though they require Unreasonable things of you , if they be not forbidden by a Higher Power , do you obey them . But I presume the greatest Zealots for this wild Notion who have Servants , are well content that they should have no plea from their Christianity to disobey themselves in any of their Commands ; but are onely concerned to have their Notion of Christian Liberty true in reference to the Laws of the Magistrate . As if a Master of a Family hath more Power over his Servants , than a King hath over his Subjects . Let us see therefore what Doctrine we find concerning Obedience to Kings and the Higher Powers . S. Peter saith , 1 Epist. 2. 13. Submit your selves to every Ordinance of Man for the Lords sake ; whether it be to the King as Supreme , or unto Governours , as unto them that are sent by him , &c. Again , Every Soul is commanded to be Subject to the Higher Powers , because there is no Power but of God , the Powers that be are ordained of God , Rom. 13. 1 , 2 , &c. And Ver. 5. 't is said , We must needs be Subject , and that not onely for Wrath , but also for Conscience sake . But there is not the least syllable , either in these or any other places , of such a limitation as might Reconcile these Injunctions with this Notion of Christian Liberty . And we may be confident , that if , by virtue of that Liberty , Christians were disobliged from Obedience to their Governours , whensoever they required things indifferent , ( though very unreasonably enjoyned , yet in their own nature not Evil , and no where forbidden by God to be done ) the Apostle would have put in this Exception in the last mentioned place : The Emperor being a great Tyrant , and rather a Monster than a Man , that then Reigned . Thirdly , If Governours can oblige us to nothing , but what Antecedently to their Laws we ought to do , there is no formal Obedience at all due to them . I am then no more bound in Conscience to obey them , than those who have no power over me , that are invested by God with no Authority . For if such say to me , Do not Kill , Do not Steal , Do not commit Adultery , &c. I shall greatly sin in not hearkening to them . And whereas it will be replied , that though such Injunctions of Persons not placed in Power ought to be observed , yet not as theirs , but as Divine Injunctions , I must needs profess that I do not believe it neither to be at all my Duty to obey such Laws of our Governours under the n●tion of theirs : My obligation to obey all the Laws of God being as strong and indispensable every whit , by virtue of His immediate Authority , as if they were backt and inforced by never so many , and never so severe Laws of his Vicegerents . Nor can any of their Laws make what God Almighty hath obliged me either to or from , one iot a greater Duty or Sin than it was before ; For the Divine Authority hath made whatsoever it hath commanded or prohibited , as great a Duty or Sin , as it is capable of being made , that is , considered in it self . It is so evident , that we are not obliged to obey a Law of the Land as such , which onely requires or forbids what is required or forbidden by an express Law of God , that the less respect any one hath to Humane Laws in such things , in doing Iustly , in being Temperate and Chaste , in attending upon the solemn Worship of God , and the like , supposing he makes Conscience of them upon the account of the Divine Laws , the better Man is he , and the more sincere Christian. And therefore such Laws of Men , as are Enacted against what God's Law hath forbidden , or do enjoyn what was before commanded by God , are not made for a Righteous man ( as the Apostle speaks , even of the Law of Moses ) but for such Wretches as live under no Sense of the Divine Sovereignty , and would not have any regard to God's Laws , were they not inforced with Men's , having severe penalties annexed to them . So that , if I am disobliged by my Christian Liberty from Doing or Forbearing any thing in Obedience to Humane Laws , but what I ought to Do or Forbear , though there were no Laws of Men about it , that which I now said is very easie to be believed , viz. That no Formal Obedience is due to Magistrates ; and they have no Power to make any New Laws of their own , but onely to take the best care that the Old ones , viz. the Laws of God , be observed . And if it be so , what becomes of all those Texts wherein Obedience to Governours is with such strictness required of Christians ? This Opinion that Rulers have no Power over us in regard of our Christian Liberty in matters of an Indifferent Nature , doth make the Fifth Commandment , and all those Injunctions perfectly insignificant . And the Apostle might well have spared his charge to Titus , To put those under his care in mind , to be subject to Principalities and Powers , to obey Magistrates , &c. Tit. 3. 1. This Monstrously wild Notion of Christian Liberty , I should not have taken thus much notice of , as little as I have said , but that of late days Multitudes by their behaviour would make us suspect they are infected with it , who yet will not professedly own it . It is come to that sad pass , that preaching Obedience to Authority is become as unacceptable Doctrine as can be to even many great Pretenders to Christianity , although it be done never so prudently and agreeably to the express Doctrine of our Saviour and his Apostles : And the Notion of Obedience for Conscience-sake seems almost lost among not a few . Which is one of the great Sins for which we have too good reason to fear , there 's a Heavy Scourge near us . Secondly , As for that Doctrine which limits our disobligation , by the means of Christian Liberty , from the Laws of Men that impose indifferent things , to those that onely relate to Religion and the Worship of God : That this is Wild too , though more Sober than the other , will appear by these Considerations . First , This Notion of Christian Liberty tends to introduce sad Disorder and Confusion into the Churches of Christ , and will certainly do it if practised upon . I need not go about to prove , that the Order of Ecclesiastical as well as Civil Societies consisteth principally in the due Regulation of things in their own Nature Indifferent . S. Paul hath enjoyned that in the Church , All things be done decently , and in order , 1 Cor. 14. 40. But how shall they be so done , if it be a Violation of our Christian Liberty to have any thing imposed upon us by our Governours for Decencies and Orders sake ? Particular Rules being not given us in Scripture about this matter ; which to be sure would have been , were they not left to the Determination of the Governours of each Church , upon supposition that 't is possible to give such as would well suit all Churches . Calvin , upon those words of S. Paul , 1 Cor. 11. 2. Now I praise you Brethren , that you remember me in all things , and keep the Ordinances as I delivered them to you , doth thus express his Sense about this matter : Saith he , We know that every Church is left free to appoint a Form of Polity for it self , because our Lord hath prescribed nothing certain : And he speaks this you see , not as his own sense onely , but as the sense , and that undoubted too , of his other Brethren of the Reformation : Whose judgment , were it needful , we might largely produce to the same purpose . But there is no need of it , those very Persons , who have been most zealous for the contrary opinion being forced to contradict it in their practice ; And , for Orders sake , to determine such things in their several Church-Administrations as are left perfectly undetermined in Scripture ( of which might be given very many instances ) notwithstanding their clamors against the Church of England upon this account , as modest as she is in her Impositions . Secondly , This Notion of Christian Liberty is so great an infringment of the Liberty Christ hath left to Ecclesiastical Governours , as not to leave them so much , as it is certain the Governours of the Iewish Church was invested with , who yet were bound up and determined in a very great number of Particulars . Over and above the Multitude of Rites and Ceremonies which God himself did annex to the Substance of his Worship , we read of not a few others that were added by Men. We have a large account of such in Maimonides , in his Book De Cultu Divino , and the Holy Scriptures themselves present us with diverse such , without the least intimation of God's dislike of them ; a Summary of which is to be seen in several late Treatises . I will onely instance in some few of the chief of them , viz. King Solomon's Hallowing the middle part of the Temple for Sacrifices , 1 Kings 8. 64. The celebrating of the Passover for fourteen days by King Hezekiahs order , although God had commanded no more than half that number , 2 Chron. 30. 23. The Yearly Feast of Purim , Esther 9. 27. The set Hours of Prayer in the Temple , Acts 3. 1. The Feast of Dedication , ordained by the Iews , 1 Maccab. 4. 29. in commemoration of the new Consecrating the Altar , after Antiochus had prophaned it . This Feast , though God did not prescribe it , was Honoured by Christ's own presence at it , Iohn 10. 22 , 23. Several Alterations , and particularly that of the Gesture , in Eating the Passover ; The which Christ declared his Approbation of by his Conformity to them , Matth. 26. 20. To these I shall only add those two known Rites of the Iews not commanded in the Law , viz. That of joyning Baptism with Circumcision in admitting Proselytes ; and that of the Post-coenium , or Feast after the Passover . And these two our Saviour was so far from condemning , upon the score of their being of Humane Institution , that his two Great Sacraments received their rise from them . The Texts which are chiefly urged , to prove the Unlawfulness of bringing any thing into the Worship of God , but what He hath himself prescribed , are those in the Old Testament , wherein God declareth his displeasure against some of the Israelites , for doing those things which he commanded them not : And one in the New , but cited out of the Old , where our Saviour reprehendeth the Pharisees for Teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of men . Those Texts in the Old Testament are Lev. 10. 1. Deut. 17. 3. Ier. 7. 31. Chap. 19. 5. Chap. 32. 35. But I wonder that those who produce these Texts for such a purpose , could not see without our shewing it to them , that they all speak of such things as God did not onely not Command , but had strictly forbid . In Lev. 10. 1. The thing which God saith He Commanded them not , was Nadab and Abihu's offering strange fire before the Lord. Which was an Act of Disobedience to a most express Law , Chap. 6. 12 , 13. That , in Deut. 17. 3. not commanded by God , was a most hainous Sin , and a flat Transgression of the First Commandment , viz. Serving other Gods , and Worshipping of them , the Sun , the Moon and the Host of Heaven . That not Commanded , Ier. 7. 31. was not onely contrary to the Law of God , but a horrible wickedness condemned by the Light of Nature , viz. The burning of their Sons and their Daughters in the Fire , in the Valley of Hinnom . That which God saith , He Commanded not , neither came it into his Mind , Jer. 19. 5. was the same Vnnatural wickedness , viz. The burning their Sons with Fire for Burnt-offerings to Baal . And that in Ier. 32. 35. was the causing of their Sons and Daughters to pass through the Fire unte Molech . But what doth Gods condemning such Abominable practices as these signifie , towards the proving it unlawful to use or impose certain innocent Rites and Circumstances in Divine worship , which are not expresly and particularly required by God ? But may be truly said to be in the general required by him , as such are necessary to the decorous management of his Worship , and agreeable to the forementioned Rule , of Doing all things decently , and in order . And whereas the Urgers of these Texts for the foresaid purpose do reply to us , that though they cannot deny but the instances of the things not Commanded mentioned in each of them , are things also Prohibited , yet they are pertinently insisted upon by them , because it is tacitly implied in God's expressing them as things onely not Commanded , that things not Commanded in His Worship offend him , as well as things Prohibited . To this I briefly Answer , that this is subtil Arguing indeed , except it can be shewed that God doth any where condemn the doing in his Worship what is lawful in its own Nature , and no where forbidden by him , under the notion of a thing not Commanded . Which I dare affirm cannot be shewed . And I add , that nothing is more absurd , than to build Doctrines upon Idioms of the Sacred Language ; but this is too commonly done by the men we are now dealing with , as I am able to shew in too many Instances . And if we should turn the Scales , and argue thus , such and such things are not Forbidden by God , therefore they are Commanded , we should not be guilty of a grosser absurdity than they are in inferring from God's not having Commanded them , that he hath therefore Forbidden them . If it be said ( as it is by these men ) that there is a general Precept , Deut. 4. 2. that makes it as evident , that things not commanded in Divine Worship may not be done , though they ben't forbidden , as if there were particular instances of that nature condemned , viz. Ye shall not add unto the word which I command you , neither shall you diminish ought from it , that ye may keep the Commandments of the Lord your God which I command you . I Reply , that if they be not mistaken in the sence of these words , they will prove more than is intended to be proved , or than they would have true : Namely , that nothing is to be done out of as well as in the Worship of God , but what is expresly and particularly Commanded . But Episcopius ( who may be listened to in this matter because no Episcopalian ) hath shewed that these words , Ye shall 〈◊〉 add unto the word which I command you , neither shall you diminish ought from it , are no new Precept ; but onely signifie , Ye shall not transgress the Commandments of God , by doing any thing contrary to them , which is to Add ; or by omitting any thing Required by them , which is to Diminish . And as to that Text in the New Testament , Matth. 15. 9. But in vain do they Worship me , teaching for Doctrines , the Commandments of men . It is manifest , that that which is condemned in the Pharisees here is the setting up of their own Constitutions in stead or in the place of God's , and those too contrary to God's Commandments . This is evident from the Context . Our Saviour saith Vers. 3. Why do you transgress the Commandments of God by your Traditions ? That is , saith Irenaeus upon these words , They did not onely frustrate the Law of God by prevarication , mixing Wine with Water ; but they also set their Law in opposition , or contradiction to the Law of God , &c. And that so they did appears by what follows , Vers. 4 , 5 , 6. For God commanded , saying , Honour thy Father and Mother , &c. But ye say , Whosoever shall say to his Father or his Mother , it is gift by whatsoever thou mightest be profited by me ; And Honour not his Father or Mother , he shall be free . Thus have ye made the Commandment of God of none effect by your Tradition . And then next follows a Citation out of Esay 29. 13. according to the Septuagint , whereof these words are part , viz. Ye Hypocrites , well did Esaias prophesie of you , saying , This people draweth nigh unto me with their mouth , and honoureth me with their lips : But their heart is far from me . But in vain do they worship me , teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of men . We will also consider these words as they are recited by S. Mark , Chap. 7. 7. with the Verse following . Howbeit in vain do they Worship me , teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of men . For laying aside the Commandment of God , ye hold the Tradition of men , as the washing of Pots and Cups , &c. That is , according to Doctor Hammond 's Paraphrase upon the place , You are those Hypocrites that profess great strictness in performances towards God , and practise in some external things more than God commands you , and impose these on others as the commands of God , when they are only Humane Ordinances . As for the inward purity of the heart and actions , to which all God's Laws of washings did refer , you take no care of them , transgress against this substantial part of Religion in the foulest manner , and spend all your time in these External superfluities , ●●shing of Pots , &c. The Ordinances of your Rabbins onely . But what are the Hypocritical and wicked doings here condemned , to Governours determining of External Circumstances of Administration in the Worship of God , which are not onely innocent in themselves , but also not set up in the place of , or justling out , any thing commanded by God , nor yet imposed as the commands of God. But who can have the Forehead to fasten such high Presumptions as these upon our Church ? But I proceed , Thirdly , As this Notion of Christian Liberty is an infringment of the Liberty which is left to Governours , so is it also greatly injurious to the Peoples Liberty . For it is a very highly to be prized instance of the Peoples Liberty , that they may without giving God an offence conform to such Laws as oblige them onely to indifferent things . And it will be an intolerable straitning and confining of our Liberty , it will be a very grievous Bondage to us , to be always obnoxious to the Penalties which are the Sanctions of such Laws , and to other manifold inconveniences that follow upon disobeying them . Christian Liberty , according to this Notion , is so far from being worthy of our Saviour's purchasing , that 't is infinitely more desirable to be without it , in regard of the extremely mischievous consequences which follow upon quarrelling with Authority about harmless matters , which have not the least ill influence upon our Souls ; whereby not onely those who refuse Obedience are exposed in their own Persons and Families to great Evils , both Temporal and Spiritual , but also the whole Community , the Church and State too , by their means . This we all know , at this day , by very sad experience . This , I say , is such a Liberty as is the occasion of lamentable Mischiefs both publick and private , but I am wholly to seek what Good can possibly accrue thereby ; and therefore we may safely warrant it , to be no Liberty of our Blessed Saviour's procurement , but the contrary . If we were well instructed in the Nature of the Gospel Dispensation , we should be very certain that whatsoever doth no way tend to the Depraving of our Souls , and the bringing us into Bondage to Sin ( Which we have proved to be the onely Opposite to our Grand Christian Liberty ) cannot be unlawful to us Christians ; because not prejudicial to the Ultimate Design of the Gospel , which is the making us Free from the Dominion of Sin. To which Design we have shewed all the Precepts of our Saviour , the Promises and Threatnings ( and I may add Doctrines too ) are subservient . And on the contrary , we may be as sure , that whatsoever is apt to hinder the promoting of this Design must needs be Unlawful lawful under the Gospel : As all that are not blind , or do not shut their Eyes , may easily see this same pretended Christian Liberty most sadly doth . And there is nothing more apparent , than that Obedience to Authority , in all things not forbidden by the Divine Laws , doth mightily conduce to the promoting of Peace , Love , Humility , Self-denial , and the like great Christian Virtues : But Disobedience in such matters doth as much occasion the gratifying of those Devilish Lusts , Pride , Uncharitableness , Contention , Wrath , Sedition , &c. Fourthly , Those that pretend it to be such a Violation of Christian Liberty to be obliged by Mens Laws to things indifferent , if they will be true to themselves and their own Principles , must not onely refuse Obedience to the Injunctions of such things , but to the Prohibitions also of such things : As they must not do such as are commanded to be done , so they must do such as are commanded to be forborn . For it is as great an Infringment of our Liberty to have indifferent things Forbidden us , as to have them Imposed upon us ; 'T is a no less intrenchment upon it , to be tied up from what we may antecedently to the Magistrates Authority do , as to be commanded what we may omit . So that if the things which the Dissenters now Refuse to do because Commanded , should hereafter be Forbidden by Authority , they would be obliged , in order to the Maintenance of their Christian Liberty , to be every whit as zealous for them as now they are against them : Nor were they so honest as they should have been , but false to this their Principle , and shamefully betrayed their Liberty , in so patiently Submitting , when time was , to the severe Prohibition of the same things , though it was by an Usurped Power too . What a strange Liberty is this , which , in its natural consequences , tends to make people so Humoursom , Cross-grain'd , and Opposite to Government ! Surely it can't be Christian , but the most Vnchristian Liberty . If this Free Dealing should offend any , I shall be sorry for it , but must withal take leave to tell the offended , that it is an Evidence of exceeding great Weakness , not to say worse , to be Angry with those who endeavour in the Spirit of Meekness , to convince us of our Dangerous Mistakes . But such is the Fate of Conscientious opposing Popular and Prevailing Errors , that it seldom meeteth with better success , than kindling the Passions , and sharpening the Tongues ( and Pens too ) of those , who are most obliged to be thankful for it : But Wisdom is justified of her Children . But however it be taken , it was never more seasonable , nor ever scarcely so Necessary , to do our utmost towards the rectifying of Peoples Apprehensions about matters of this nature ; when our Contentions and Animosities about little things mostly , ( things very little in themselves ) and so great a Defection from our Church , merely upon the account of such things as are no where condemned by the Law of God , nor are opposed by any express or plain Text , but by exceedingly laboured and far fetch'd Consequences , have given our Adversaries such Advantage against us , and do them far greater service , than all their open Attempts , or secret wicked Plots and Conspiracies , through the infinite Goodness of God to us , have hitherto done . God Almighty grant that that saying be not to be applied to us ere long , which was used of our Predecessors the Britains , when their intestine Quarrels had occasioned their being Vanquish'd by the Romans , viz. Dum singuli pugnant , Vniversi vincuntur . While they severally contend and quarrel with one another , they are all overcome by a Common Enemy . I must confess , when I consider what Excellent Treatises have of late been published , fraught with Unanswerable and the most convincing and affecting Arguments , to perswade our Brethren of the Separation to ease us in a great measure of our Fears of Popery or Confusion , by Returning to the Communion of that Church wherein most of them were Baptized ; and when withal I observe what little Success those Treatises have had , I have as faint hopes as can be that so small an endeavour as this should do any Service . But however , it is some satisfaction to my Mind to express my Good Will. But we are told by some , that we may thank the Church of England if ever the Pope be again our Master , and particularly that Principle of Hers we have been now defending , viz. that Imposing of Indifferent things in the Worship of God is no Violation of Christian Liberty : And that this Principle will open a door to Popish Conformity , if we should be once more so unhappy as to be brought into Subjection to the Roman Yoke . To these I Reply , in the First place , That 't is unconceiveable how any thing but Malice or the thickest Ignorance can charge the Church of England with serving the Interest of the Popish Religion : For is any thing more Notorious , than that almost all the opposition that hath either heretofore or of late been made against Popery hath been by the Bishops and the other Clergy of this Church ? To say nothing of what the Separating Party have done ( though not upon that Design ) to promote Popery , which would be as large as unpleasant a Theme to insist on ; what have they done in defence of the Reformed Religion against Popery ? Have they all of them put together done the half quarter part of that Service in this kind , that One Excellent Dean of our Church hath done ? Truly I much doubt it . And I think I may adventure to say , that all the Reformed Churches together can hardly shew of their own so many Learned and Judicious Treatises against the Body and the several Parts of Popery , as our single Church can shew of Hers. Again , Is any thing better known than that the Priests and Jesuits , and Popish Faction do at this time spit all their Venome and bend all their Force against the Church of England , and indeed always have done ? This sheweth that they are well aware , though so many among our selves will not acknowledge it , but would have the World think the directly contrary , that our Church is the most Formidable of all their Adversaries . In short , Who needs Arguments to convince him , that the Church of England is at present our onely Bulwark against Popery ? As , ever since the Reformation , she hath been acknowledged by our Brethren beyond Sea , to be the strongest and most impregnable upon several accounts . But Secondly , as to this Principle of our Church , that Imposing of Indifferent things in the Worship of God is no Violation of Christian Liberty , it is a most weak and ignorant furmise , that it should in the least befriend Popery . Those little understand what Popery means that think thus : For , First , There is nothing more plainly demonstrable than that many of those things which are imposed by the Roman Church are far from being Indifferent in their own nature , but the grossest Corruptions , as contrary to the Doctrine and Practice of the first Ages of the Church ; and , which is far more , as contrary to the Laws of God and our Saviour Christ , as is Darkness to Light. I have given a Catalogue in the Design of Christianity of the chief of these , with Remarks upon them , and thither I refer the Reader that needs satisfaction . Secondly , Other of Her Impositions , which are Indifferent in themselves , are made to change their Nature by the Notion under which they are enjoyned by her . That Church enjoyns no Indifferent things as such ( as ours doth all she imposeth , as appears by her 34 th Article ) but as made necessary by Divine Authority ; She pretending to the Infallible Guidance of the Holy Ghost in all Her Decrees and Constitutions : And therefore expects your Receiving them , as you do the Holy Scriptures , with a Divine Faith , and the self-same awful Regard and Reverence . I might add too , that several of her Rites and Ceremonies are imposed under a most Superstitious notion , either as Sacraments conveying Grace , or as having some special Virtue in them , to atone the Divine Majesty , or to scare away the Devil , &c. Thirdly , It is my opinion too , that though their Ceremonies were never so innocent in themselves , yet the Multitude of them doth make them in the lump to cease to be Indifferent . My reason is , because it is unconceiveable to me , but that so great a Number must needs so employ the Mind in the Worship of God , as that it is not possible to be intent thereupon , and consequently must frustrate ( at least in a great measure ) the Design of Worship . But this is no Reason to a Papist , who cannot be thoroughly so , and acknowledge the necessity of exercising the Mind in Divine Worship : For his Holy Mother hath taught him this mad and impious Doctrine , That the Sacraments confer Grace , ex opere operato , from the work Done , and so are differenced from those of the Old Testament , they conferring Grace , ex opere operantis , from the work of the Doer ; as also that a mere general Attention in saying their Prayers and numbering them over , is as much as is necessary . And if we can believe that we need not mind our Prayers , we have no reason to blame those of them , who do not desire to understand them ; Nor yet their Church for enjoyning the saying them in a Language which the Generality of Her Children are ignorant of ; as if She designed in so doing to put an Affront upon S. Paul , who hath taught us in the most express terms the quite contrary Doctrine , in the 14 Chapter of the First to the Corinthians . To conclude this Chapter : Our Notion of Christian Liberty is so very far from befriending Popery , that 't is not possible it should have a greater Enemy ; in that it so highly conduceth to the advancing of the true Spirit and Power of Religion , and to the perfect ridding our Minds of those two as Great Friends to Popery , as Pests to Religion , and even Humane Society , viz. Superstition and fanaticism . I mean by these two a Base Unworthy Apprehension of the Deity , and a Blind , Irrational , Heady Zeal . If it be said after all , that supposing the two Notions of Christian Liberty , which we have now declared our Sense 〈◊〉 be never so false , yet we are notwithstanding too confined in Our Notion ; in ●hat Christian Liberty doth not onely ●onsist in Freedom from the Dominion of 〈◊〉 and the other sad Consequents of it , ●ut also in our Freedom as to all things ●fan Indifferent nature , to or from which ●e are not determined as by any Divine , 〈◊〉 neither by any Humane Law : If this , ●say , be objected , our Answer in one ●ord is this . This is not Christian , but ●his is Natural Liberty . That of S. Paul ●ving been in All Ages , and in refe●ence to all sorts of People , as Great a Truth , as it hath been since our Saviours ●ime and in reference to Christians , viz. Where no Law is there is no Transgression . CHAP. XIV . An Answer to this Question , Whether the Prescribing of Forms of Prayer , for the Publick Worship of God , be not an Encroachment upon Christian Liberty ? Wherein it is shewed , that this is not a Stifling of the Spirit , or Restraining the exercise of his Gift . And what in Prayer is not , as also what is the Gift of the Spirit . Whereby is occasioned an Answer to another Question , viz. Whether an Ability for Preaching be properly a Gift of the Spirit . WHat hath been last discoursed gives me occasion to Enquire , Whether the Imposing of a Liturgy , or Forms of Prayer for the Publick Worship of God , be not an Encroachment upon Christian Liberty ? I answer it is , if that Principle taken up by very many among us be a true one , viz. That this is a Stifling of the Spirit , and a Restraining of the Exercise of one of his Gifts . If this be so , I say , it can be no better than a very great invasion of Christian Liberty , and a far greater than the mere obliging men to things Indifferent . For , as S. Paul saith , 1 Cor. 12. 7. The Mani●estation of the Spirit is given to every man to profit withal ; and therefore for Christians to be limited in doing good by a Gift of the Spirit , must needs be a robbing them of that Liberty , which Christ in sending Him design'd to give them . By the way , it shall be no part of my Reply to say , that onely the Ministers are here concerned , not at all the People : For although a Conceived Prayer of the Minister be of the nature of a prescribed Form to those that joyn with him , as to the confining their Spirits , yet the People must needs be sufferers by means of their Ministers being stinted in the exercise of a Gift of the Spirit , since it was designed for their profit ; and therefore upon this account , and moreover in regard of the Countenance they will thereby give to Authority in such a kind of Sacrilegious Usurpation of power over Ministers , it cannot be justifiable in them to Attend willingly upon such Forms . But in order to the undeceiving of those , who are so tenacious of this conceit , that a prescribed Liturgy is a hinderance to the Free Exercise of a Gift of the Spirit , I must freely profess , that I know of no Gifts of the Spirit which we have warrant from Scripture to believe are continued to the Church at this day , besides those which S. Paul calls the Fruits of the Spirit , Gal. 5. 22. Where he saith , The fruit of the Spirit is Love , Ioy , Peace , Long-suffering , Gentleness , Goodness , Faith , Meekness , Temperance . These and the like Christian Graces , are Gifts which the Spirit still bestows , and therefore called Graces . They are supernatural Gifts as no man by his mere Natural power can obtain them , but only by the Spirit 's blessing of our Endeavours ; and to the sincere use of the Gospel-means the Spirit is always ready to give his blessing . And the reason why in these latter Ages , these blessed Gifts are bestowed upon no more Professors of Christianity than they are , is because the generality of such are miserably wanting to themselves , and to the Holy Spirit , in refusing to do their part , and to cooperate with Him : Because they will not attend to the evidence the Spirit hath given to the Truth of the Gospel , and therefore have too weak and ineffectual a belief thereof : Because they will not consider the Doctrine of the Gospel ; they will not weigh well , and lay to heart its Precepts , with the infinitely powerful motives wherewith they are inforced . Because they will not listen to the Spirits good motions and suggestions , whereby he works in men to Will , and begets in them good Resolutions , but do truly ●●ench the Spirit ( though that phrase is ●sed in reference to his miraculous Gifts ) and resist the Holy Ghost ; and because they will not make a believing Application to Him for his powerful Assistance . I say it is upon these , and such like accounts , that the forementioned Gifts of the Spirit are so rare , and that the generality of those who are honoured with the Title of Christians are so destitute of them as we see they are . Nay , multitudes are so befooled by the enemy of their Souls , as to expect that the Spirit should do all in them , without their doing any thing ; that He should make them Temperate , Righteous , Charitable , Meek , Humble and Submissive to God's Will , Heavenly-minded , and the like , without their due attendance upon those Ordinances of the Word , Sacrament and Prayer , and serious Consideration and Watchfulness over themselves , wherein alone we have ground to expect the powerful working of the Divine Grace in our Souls . But , I say , though these Gifts are observable in so very few comparatively , ( the account whereof I have briefly touched upon , and shewed that 't is mens own fault that they are not very common ) yet we have no warrant from Scripture that I know of , to call those which are much more common , though they are by many so reputed , Gifts of the Spirit ; notwithstanding the Prophecies and Promises of so plentiful a pouring of Him out in the times of the Gospel . There were indeed common as well as more special Gifts of the Spirit in the First Ages ; For the miraculous ones of speaking all manner of Tongues , Prophesying , Healing all sorts of Diseases , Casting out Devils , &c. which were the great Witnesses to the truth of Christianity , were very common . They were not only conferred upon the Apostles , but the private Believers : These signs , said our Saviour , shall follow them that believe in my name , &c. Mark 16. 17. And not onely on those Believers who were sincere Christians , but those also whose Lives were not at all answerable to their Christian profession , as appears by those words of our Saviour , Mat. 7. 22. And several of these miraculous Gifts , we have full assurance from Antiquity , did continue in the Church , though in nothing so plentiful a measure , particularly those of Healing , Prophesying and Casting out Devils , till about the beginning of the Fourth Century , when Providence blessed her with a Christian Emperor , and she came to be protected by his Sword and Laws ; and consequently stood not in such need of those Gifts for the keeping her in Heart , and the upholding her Credit and Reputation in the World. But as these have ceased for many Ages , so the abovesaid Fruits of the Spirit are the onely Endowments now remaining , which may in a more peculiar manner be ascribed to Him ; that is , they are the onely Supernatural Endowments . As to that therefore which is commonly called the Gift of Prayer , we have these things to say , First , That we have not the least reason to believe , that the expressions of the very best mens Prayers are now dictated by the Holy Ghost , or that they pray by the Inspiration of the Spirit as to Words or Matter . I know not that any sober men do pretend to such a Gift as this in Prayer , and too many of those that do pretend to it do manifestly declare by the management of their Gift , that either they juggle and are gross Cheats , or are sadly deluded . What slovenly , what ridiculous , what bold and impudent expressions are ordinarily heard from them ? And what a deal of nauseating stuff , that hath brought a vile scandal upon Religion , and furnished Atheistical and Prophane people with matter of derision ? Even such stuff as that it is no better than a Blaspheming the Holy Ghost to father it upon Him. But I delight not to insist upon this Argument . It is objected , that S. Paul saith , Rom. 8. 26. We know not what we should pray for as we ought , but the Spirit it self maketh Intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered . I answer , that this Text makes not at all for the purpose of those who in this sence pretend to an ability of praying by the Spirit . For , as for the Apostle's saying , that We know not what to pray for as we ought , it is to be limited to Temporal things , and wholly to them : For we do know that all those things which are necessary to our Eternal Felicity , viz. all spiritual Blessings , are to be prayed for . And we do or may know what all those are without inspiration . But we do not know whether worldly Prosperity or Affliction may be best for us , or what measure of temporal good things , or what particulars of such good things ; and therefore in reference to these things , we are not to pray Absolutely but Conditionally , and with a Willingness to be denied if God sees it not good to grant them to us . And the following words shew , that it is not therefore to be concluded , that the Spirit will put it into Good peoples hearts , what temporal things they should pray for , for they tell us that He will back their Petitions in Heaven by interceding for them , with unutterable Groanings ; not that He will put words into their mouths , or suggest matter of Prayer to them . I dare not say , the Spirit never does thus , I should be then too bold ; but we have no ground to expect or hope He should , at least , in ordinary cases . In short , whosoever pretends that his Prayers are dictated by the Holy Ghost , must have the very same opinion of them that he hath of the Divinely inspired Writings . Secondly , I say consequently , That an ability of uttering our Minds to Almighty God in great variety of words and phrases , is as much a Natural Gift , or a Gift acquired in an ordinary way , that is , by study and frequent practising and exercising , as any Art or Ability whatsoever . Very bad men have been often known to have a notable Faculty this way ; and so miserably weak and silly are abundance of people as to admire those for excellent Christians in whom they perceive it , though they know them guilty of very great immoralities , and they have nothing to commend them but this Faculty . But there is no man , if he will set himself to it , and he be made for it , that is , prepared with a sufficient measure of Boldness and Confidence , with a glib Tongue and a warm Head , but may be excellent at it . Therefore , I say , how shamefully ignorant and childish are the Vulgar sort ( I fear the much greater part ) that this dexterity at pouring forth words to the King of Heaven without fear or wit , with a mighty voice , great earnestness , and abundance of action , shall gain to a man a greater repute with them for a precious Christian , than all the above-mentioned real fruits of the Spirit put together ? Although any Hypocrite that is qualified as we now said , may with the greatest ease attain to it . Such a brave man as this shall lead multitudes by the Nose , work his base designs upon them , and infuse what Principles he listeth into them . Such Babies are the common People too generally in the affairs of Religion , and their Spiritual concerns . But , Si populus vult decipi , decipiatur , If Folk will be thus cheated and made a prey of , who can help it ? It may grieve us at the Hearts to think , what work the Popish Priests and Jesuits may hereafter make ( as we know that in Disguises they have already made sad work ) among these silly Sheep : No men in the World having a rarer knack at Extemporary performances , and at Feigning and Raising of Passions than many of them have . But , Thirdly , The true Spirit of Prayer consisteth in a deep sense of the Incomprehensible Majesty of the great God , of the infinite distance that is between Him and us , of our unspeakable Obligations to Him , and necessary dependance upon Him : In an affecting sense of our own Wretchedness and Sinfulness , which makes us altogether unworthy to appear in His presence , or to receive the least Favour at His hands : In a sense of His infinite Goodness , Wisdom and Power , and an undoubted Belief that whatsoever is really needful for us , He knoweth so to be , and is both Able and Willing to confer it upon us , when we ask it as we ought in the Name of Iesus . Add hereunto entire Resignation of our Wills to the Will of God , to have Granted or Denied to us , as shall seem most agreeable to His infinite Wisdom , the Good things of this present Life ; and hungering and thirsting desires after Righteousness , after those Divine Dispositions and Qualifications which are necessary to our being made meet for the Kingdom of Heaven . In such things as these doth consist the Soul and Spirit of Prayer : These are the Absolutely necessary and Essential ingredients thereof . But , Fourthly , As for Words , they are but a circumstantial part of Prayer , and no farther necessary than as they tend to the more quickening our Affections , exciting our Desires , inlivening our Sense of the forementioned Objects , and keeping our Minds fixed and intent ; And in publick Prayer , or Prayer with others , they are necessary to enable others to joyn with us . But the Omniscient God understands the sense of our Souls , the temper of our Spirits , and the desires of our Hearts , though no words be used for the expressing of them ; And always measures our Prayers by those , not at all by these . I say not at all by Words , because if they flow from an honest Heart , and a good disposition of Mind , they cannot be so faulty as to make a Prayer unacceptable . And therefore it is the same thing to God whether a good Sense and good Desires be from time to time expressed by the same , or by variety of Words and Phrases : And he who is affected as he ought to be in the use of a Form , who hath such Desires and such a Sense as he ought to have ( as thousands of good Christians have ) hath as much the true Spirit of Prayer , and as much of it too , as he can have who hath the most notable Faculty at varying his Expressions . And he who hath this Faculty but wants that Sense and those good Dispositions , is notwithstanding utterly destitute of the Spirit of Prayer . But it is incomparably most fit , that there should be a Liturgy , or Forms prescribed for the publick Worship of God , for Prayer and Praising of God in the Church , and for the celebration of the Holy Sacraments , with the other Offices ; because the publick Worship of God ought always to be performed with the greatest Gravity and Solemnity possible . But such a performance of Divine Worship can never be secured , where Ministers are wholly left to their own Liberty , and permitted to put up all the Confessions , Petitions and Thanksgivings of the Congregation , and to perform all the Offices , in their own Arbitrary and Extemporary Expressions . For though some Ministers who take this Liberty may pray excellently well when their heads are clear , and they are in a good Temper , yet I doubt there are very few who have always that Presence of Mind , that Composedness of Thoughts , and Constancy of Temper as not to be forced sometimes to use many Tautologies and indecent expressions . But however the Church is never like to be provided with such Ministers as shall be able , for the most part of them , to keep themselves from great confusion in their conceived Prayers , from bald and absurd phrases , and from Nauseating their Auditory with repetitions of the same things , ful●om sayings , or lamentable misapplications of Texts of Scripture ; through over-much modesty or other infelicities of Temper in some , and in others through ignorance , or weakness of Natural parts , either slowness of Invention or want of Judgment . And besides , there is this necessity of having a Liturgy , that without one there is no rational way of perswading strangers to hold Communion with us : Except we can shew them something which is acknowledged by common Agreement for a Form and Method of Divine Worship , we cannot satisfie them what publick Service we perform to God , it will then be so various , that is , as not alike in all places , so neither at all times in the same places . But to complete my Answer to the Question in hand . Fifthly , The affecting us with a profound Sense of the Majesty and Glorious perfections of the God we pray to , and of our own Vileness and Unworthiness ; And a Submissive frame of Mind to the Divine Will ; Ardent Breathings after more of the Divine Image and Likeness ; And a lively Faith in the Power , Wisdom and Goodness of God , which are , as I said , the Substantial and Essential parts of Prayer ; all these we heartily and thankfully acknowledge to be the Gifts of the Spirit . We own them to be so otherwise than all other good things which are every of them expressions of the Divine Bounty , and consequently Gifts of the Spirit as He is one of the Persons of the Blessed Trinity : But we profess to owe them to the more special operations and influences of the Holy Ghost ; And for the working and encrease of these , all good Christians do daily crave the Spirits assistance . Now I need not say , that to endeavour to put a restraint upon the exercise of such Gifts as these is a most wicked invasion and violation of our Christian Liberty , according to our own Notion of it . But what we have discoursed concerning Prayer , gives me occasion to add something of Preaching too , and to shew also how far an ability for that performance is to be ascribed to the Holy Spirit , or called one of his Gifts . And consequently we may from hence be satisfied , whether a Preacher of the Gospel is in●●tled to such a Liberty in reference to Preaching as may not be limited by Au●hority , or upon no accounts taken whol● from him , without putting an affront upon the Holy Spirit . First , It is out of doubt , that no man 〈◊〉 hath the Gift of Preaching in the demonstration of the Spirit and of Power , in the sence that S. Paul and his fellow-Apostles had it . For by the demonstration of the Spirit and of Power is meant those extraordinary Gifts of Speaking with Tongues , Prophecy and Miracles accompanying their Preaching , whereby they demonstrated the truth of the Doctrine preached by them . And so Origen understands it , in his Book against Cel●us . Secondly , There is not the least ground to believe that any man hath now the Gift of Preaching by Inspiration , or from the immediate Revelation of the Spirit . Nor do any seriously pretend to it , but wild Enthusiasts , Brain-sick , Melancholy and Hot-headed people , who take their own Fancies and Whims , and the products of an ungoverned imagination for Inspirations . I say none but those who plainly discover themselves to be such do seriously pretend to this Gift , because there have been and still are a company of Knaves in the World ( as is manifest by their actings ) who , for the carrying on their corrupt and naughty designs , pretend to that which they are conscious to themselves they have nothing of . But sober and honest Preachers of the Gospel do profess to deliver nothing to their people , but what they conceive to be long ago revealed ; But what they acknowledge they have with study and pains gathered from the Holy Scriptures , either immediately , or by plain consequence ; wherein are contained all things necessary to be believed and practised by us in order to Salvation ; and which , without any Additions , are able to make us wise to Salvation ( as S. Paul assures us ) and are a complete Rule of Faith and Practice . And that Preacher who shall offer to require his Auditors assent to any thing not delivered , either in express terms or by plain consequence , in the Writings of the Old or New Testament , doth impudently impose upon their belief , except he be able to work real Miracles for the convincing of them . He takes more upon him , than either the Apostles , or our Saviour himself , who did still appeal to the works , the Supernatural works he did , to attest the truth of the Doctrine he delivered . I would such impudent imposers were onely to be found among the Romanists ( who are all so , and the most impudent that ever appeared upon the stage of the World ) but alas , they are too too common also among professed haters of Popery . Thirdly , And as to the sence of the more difficult places of Scripture , no sober Preacher pretends to come to the knowledge thereof by the immediate illumination of the Spirit , but such a one acknowledgeth he doth it in the general by the exercise of his Reason : And particularly by considering the proper signification of Words and Phrases in the Original Languages ; by comparing Scripture with Scripture ; by searching into the Ancient Customs , which give great light to a great number of Texts , and without the knowledge of which they are not to be understood ; by enquiring after the judgment of those who lived nearest to the Times of the Apostles , &c. And after all , they submit their Expositions of such Texts to the judgments of their Hearers , I mean such of them as are capable of judging . As for others , Oportet discentes credere , It becomes Learners to give credit to their Teachers . And Credendum est peritis in suâ Arte. But , Fourthly , We do piously , and by the Authority of Scripture believe , that the Spirit is ready to assist us in our Reasonings and Enquiries , and whatsoever particular good means we use for the understanding of Scripture , when He is humbly and devoutly sought to by us ; and when without the least prejudice , partiality , ill design , or sinister respect , but for the best of Ends , and from the pure love of Truth , we make Enquiry . Thus even Private Christians are assisted in the searches and enquiries which they are able to make : For God hath promised that The Meek he will guide in judgment , and the Meek he will teach his way . Fifthly , In composing also of profitable Discourses , as we implore , so we have the Divine Assistance , but we see no ground to believe that we have it in any other manner , than in other good works of what nature soever . But as for the ready Faculty of Discoursing from a Pulpit , and popular speaking to a Congregation , we have no reason to believe it a Gift of the Spirit , any more than the Lawyers strange readiness in pleading at the Bar. And a volubility of speech upon any subject whatsoever , heat of Fancy , and nimbleness of Wit and Invention , are as much to be attributed to the Holy Spirit as such a Faculty . And hence we may gather , that a Preacher of the Gospel can plead no such Liberty as is wholly exempted from Restraints by Authority . But one that is known to have never so good a Talent at Preaching may be forbidden the exercise of it , till he hath submitted to a lawful Ordination , such as was in use in the Churches of Christ for Fifteen hundred years together . And when Ordained , he may lawfully have bounds set him as to the places where he shall exercise his Ministry in publick , and as to the times when . And he may be forbidden to meddle with such Arguments as are above the reach of his Peoples Understandings , or are not like to conduce to their Edification , and much more to broach dangerous Doctrines , that is , such as are so in the judgment of his Governours . And for his Disobedience , and other Misdemeanours , he is as liable to be suspended or totally deprived of his Ministerial Office , as are any other Officers . I do but touch upon and give light glances at these things , because my present subject will not give me leave to discourse largely upon them , which would be too great a digression from its proper business . CHAP. XV. A Third False Notion of Christian Liberty , viz. that which makes Liberty of Conscience a Branch of it . Two things premised , 1. That Conscience is not so sacred a thing as to be uncapable of being obliged by Humane Laws . 2. That no man can properly be deprived of the true Liberty of his Conscience by any Power on Earth . That what is contended for , is more properly Liberty of Practice than of Conscience . The Author's Opinion in reference to this Liberty delivered in Ten Propositions . That whatsoever Liberty of this nature may be insisted on as our Right , it is not Christian Liberty but Natural Liberty . THirdly and Lastly , I proceed to that Notion of Christian Liberty , which makes Liberty of Conscience a Branch of it . But before I deliver my Opinion about this weighty point , which hath occasioned as great Feuds and sharp Contests as any whatsoever , I shall premise two things : First , That Conscience is not so Sacred a thing as to be uncapable of being Obliged by Humane Laws . Secondly , That no man can properly be deprived of the true Liberty of his Conscience by any Power on Earth . First , That Conscience is not so Sacred a thing , as to be uncapable of being Obliged by Humane Laws . This is sufficiently clear from what is discoursed in the Thirteenth Chapter . But it is said by many that God is the onely Lord of Conscience , and therefore it is the highest presumption for Men to go about to bind it by their Laws . It is the sole Prerogative of the Deity to search the Heart , and try the Reins of the Children of men ; Conscience is too inward and secret a thing to fall under Mans cognizance , and therefore what have any of our Fellow-Creatures to do to give Laws to our Consciences ? In Answer hereunto , We have already seen what S. Paul's sense is about this matter , that he saith , We must needs be Subject , or Obedient , and that not only for wrath , but also for Conscience sake . So that the Apostle was far from thinking , that the obligation of Humane Authority is founded in mere Prudence , not at all in Conscience . But no man in his Wits will say , that the Laws of Men do oblige Conscience as the Laws of God do . Those cannot do it immediately as these do , but onely by virtue of the Divine Authority . S. Paul saith , Rom. 13. 1. Let every Soul be subject to the Higher Powers : I think I shall not be over-critical in saying , that is every Conscience , for what follows proves the obligation of Conscience to subjection , and is an Answer to the foresaid Objection against it , viz. For there is no Power but of God , the Powers that be are ordained of God , whosoever therefore Resisteth the Power Resisteth the Ordinance of God , &c. So that all we assert is this , that we are bound to obey our lawful Governours for God's sake , who hath invested them with the Authority they have over us , and commanded us to obey those Laws of theirs which are not contradictory to any of His. Nor do we say that Humane Authority can make more Duties or Sins than God hath made , or to speak properly and strictly , can make any thing to be a Duty or Sin ; for it can only Command or Forbid , and what it Commands , if lawful , the Divine Authority makes it a Duty , and what it Forbids , if not a Duty , the Divine Authority makes it a Sin. Or to speak in the words of the Learned Bishop Taylor : Humane Authority doth not make the action of disobedience to be a Sin. It makes that the not compliance of the Subject is Disobedience ; but it is the Authority of God which makes Disobedience to be a Sin. And what immediately follows deserves also to be transcribed in this place , viz. And though no Humane Power can give or take Grace away , yet we may remember , that we our selves throw away God's Grace , or abuse it or neglect it , when we will not make use of it to the purposes of Humility , Charity and Obedience , all which are concerned in our Subordination to the Laws . There is also this difference between the Obligations of Divine and Humane Laws , viz. The Divine Laws bind our Thoughts and the Sense of our Minds , they bind us not onely to obey them , but to think them also Wise and Good Laws . But so do not Humane Laws , they oblige onely to Obedience , but not to the thinking them such as ought , or are fit , to be imposed . A man may think a Humane Law imprudent or unreasonable , and be guilty of no Transgression , if notwithstanding he complies with it ; I mean , provided he keeps his thoughts to himself , or does not make them publick . The forementioned Worthy Prelate layeth down no sewer than Ten or Eleven differences of Divine and Humane Laws in their obligation , in his Ductor Dubitantium : Whether they will all hold or no , or may not be reduced to a smaller number , I will not take upon me to say ; but thither I refer the Reader . And thus much may serve to be spoken to the First thing premised , viz. That Conscience is not so Sacred a thing as to be uncapable of being bound by Humane Laws . Secondly , I premise also , that no man can be deprived properly of the true Liberty of his Conscience by any Power on Earth , I mean without his own consent ; no Mortal nor any Creature is able to invade it . This will appear by considering what that is , which is called Conscience . Conscience is The Mind of a man considered as possessed with certain practical principles , and comparing his own actions with those principles , doth , according as he finds them agreeing or disagreeing with them , judge of himself ; either absolve or condemn himself . So that there are three Offices of Conscience : The first is , That of assenting to and embracing certain practical principles as Laws for the governing a man's self . The second is , That of comparing ones self , or actions , with those Rules or Principles . The third , That of passing judgment of ones self accordingly . Now that is properly Liberty of Conscience , and that onely , which relates to the execution of these three Offices . But the Acts of Conscience in executing these Offices being all Internal , and within a mans Soul , how can its Liberty in exerting those Acts be infringed by any Humane Power ? What Earthly Power can make me Assent to or believe what it pleaseth ? Can so give Laws to my Conscience , as to necessitate me to receive them for such , and to think them good Laws , and safe to steer my Actions by ? Again , how can any such Power deprive me of my Liberty to compare my Actions with such Rules as I think I am obliged to be governed by ? And , having reflected upon my self and actions , and made this comparison , how can any such Power abridge me of Liberty to Absolve my self , if I find my actions agreeing with those Rules , or to Condemn my self , if I find the contrary ? Can make me Condemn when I ought to Acquit my self , or Acquit when I see reason to Condemn my self ? So that the Liberty which is with so much heat contended for by some , and inveighed against by others , under the name of Liberty of Conscience , is truly and properly Liberty of Practice , not of Conscience . And the great thing in contest is , Whether a Liberty of doing what a man's Conscience tells him he ought to do , and of forbearing what it tells him he ought to forbear , be an inviolable Right , and not to be invaded by Humane Authority ? This being the true state of the Question , I shall endeavour an Answer thereunto in these following Propositions . Prop. 1. That there are two Extremes about this matter to be carefully avoided . First , That of Asserting an unlimited Liberty of practising according to a mans Conscience . Secondly , That of over-great severity in Restraining this Liberty . First , As to the Extreme of Asserting an unlimited Liberty of practising according to a man's Conscience : This will appear to be an Extreme indeed , and a very wild and mad one , if we consider that there is scarcely any thing so extravagant or wicked , but the Consciences of some or other may urge them to it . Nay , it is certain that men have pretended Conscience for some of the most impious and most villanous actions in the World. So the Papists have done among our selves we all know ; And another sort of People too , whose principles , though very bad , were better than theirs . And it is not possible for us to know that their pretences of Conscience were m●re pretences . Nor is it hard for us to perswade our selves , that through the just judgment of God for past provocations , the Spirit of delusion may be permitted to have such power over some mens Consciences , as that they shall call evil good and good evil , put darkness for light and light for darkness , and bitter for sweet and sweet for bitter ; for we find a Woe pronounced against such as do so , Esay 5. 20. which there would not have been , if there were no such men , nor could be . And it is said of some , 2 Thess. 2. 10 , 11 , 12. that , Because they received not the love of the truth that they might be saved , God shall send them ( or permit to be sent them ) strong delusions ( 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , strength of delusion ) that they should believe a lie : That they all might be damned , who believed not the truth , but had pleasure in unrighteousness . Our Saviour foretold his Disciples , Iohn 16. 2. that The time cometh that whosoever killeth you will think that he doth God service . That is , the time is coming , when men shall kill you out of Conscience . As no doubt the Papists have done many thousands of good Christians : And it is well known that their principles are such , as that they cannot be true to them , and not think themselves bound in Conscience to Stab and Poison , Burn and Massacre all without exception whom they call Hereticks , whensoever an opportunity is put into their hands . S. Paul , as cruel a persecutor of Christians as he was before his Conversion , did then think not onely that he did what was lawful , but that he did his duty too . For , saith he , Acts 26. 9. I verily thought with my self ( or I was verily perswaded in my Conscience ) that I ought to do many things contrary the Name of Jesus of Nazareth . Among which things he reckoneth in the two following verses , Shutting up many of the Saints in Prison , and giving his voice against them to be put to death , and compelling them to Blaspheme . No man is able to imagine what dismal Effects Superstition and Enthusiasm may have upon the Mind and Conscience . So that this will be easily granted me by men of any Sobriety , that that which they call Liberty of Conscience must be limited by Governours , if they will have any concern for the Honour of God , the Welfare of Religion , the Safety of the Community , and the Preservation of Government ; it being impossible that there should be any such thing as Government , if all shall be exempt from Punishment who shall plead Conscience for their Disobedience ; nay , though they should be known to plead it never so truly . Now it being so evident that Conscience may and must be restrained in its Liberty , we clearly gain one point by it , and that no small one , viz. That Liberty of Conscience is not to be necessarily allowed under the notion of Liberty of Conscience : For this Liberty as such is not an inviolable Right , if it be not to be claimed in all cases without exception . Secondly , As to that which we call the other Extreme of over-great Severity in Restraining this Liberty , no man surely will question but that there may be an erring on this hand also . But how to steer betwixt Scylla and Charybdis , these two extremes , is , I think , one of the greatest difficulties : And requires a conjunction of the greatest Prudence with as great Goodness . But as to what measures in the general are to be taken , we will adventure modestly to suggest our Thoughts in the Propositions that follow . Prop. 2. No such Liberty of Conscience ( for so for fashions-sake wee 'l call it ) is by any means to be allowed , as is apparently injurious to the Community , and such a Liberty as can have no ill publick influence in the Church or State , both may and ought to be granted . The welfare of the Community with respect to both its Civil and Spiritual Interests is the business and design of Government , and the welfare of particular persons , as they are parts of the Community . Therefore not to grant to particular persons as much Liberty of what nature soever , as is consistent with the general Good or Well-being of the Whole , is to hold the Reins too strait , and to be over-severe and Arbitrary . But it must be left to the iudgment of our Governours , what measure and proportion of Liberty may be safely vouchsafed , with respect to the Interest of the Community , both because they are to be presumed the fittest Judges of this affair , and because it is wholly inconsistent with Government for every private person to be his own Judge . But ( as I need not add ) Governours are obliged as they will answer it to their Judge , not to be hasty in making a judgment , but to do it with the greatest wariness and deliberation , because their being mistaken in this point may happen to be of very evil and mischievous consequence . Prop. 3. It is a very plain case that men ought to have the Liberty of enjoying their Opinions to themselves , without their being extorted by penalties from them . This follows from the foregoing proposition , and if that be true this can't be false . For if such a Liberty ought to be granted as hath no ill Aspect upon the Community , then no Body should be compelled to discover his Opinions , because whilest they are kept within a mans own Breast , they can do no hurt to other Folk , and if they discover themselves by Overt-Acts ( as the Lawyers speak ) there is no need of using violent means for the Extorting of them . Which is the cruel practice of the Roman Church , and our own Nation knew it by sad experience in the Reign of Queen Mary . How many excellently good Christians were then Sentenced to the Stake for their mere Refusing to Subscribe to their as wicked as false Doctrine of the Sacrifice of the Altar ? Prop. 4. To make Sanguinary Laws against mere Dissenting from the publick Establishment , that is , when Dissenting from it is not accompanied with a Factious , Schismatical and Seditious opposition to it , is without controversie Antichristian Tyranny . Of all the indefensible practices of the now mentioned Church , there is none that makes the Title of Antichrist more due to her , than her prosecuting with Fire and Faggot , and all manner of Cruelties , men who are guilty of no other crime but that of renouncing Communion with her in her gross Corruptions . But suppose her Terms of Communion were as agreeable as they are contrary to the Word of God , yet would her putting men to death for their bare not submitting to those terms , speak her to be utterly destitute of the true Christian Spirit : And to deserve that Reprehension which her mild and gentle Master gave to his Disciples for desiring him to call for Fire from Heaven to destroy the Samaritans for refusing to receive him , viz. Ye know not what manner of Spirit ye are of ; for the Son of man came not to destroy mens lives , but to save them . And if our Saviour was so offended with those Disciples for making that motion , though He knew 't was not made deliberately , but in a sudden fit of passion , and that kindled too by the quick resentment they had of an high affront that was put upon his Sacred person , how highly must it needs provoke him to see Christians destroying their Brethren in cool bloud , and that not for so hainous a crime as Renouncing his Religion , but for not being Christians of their Mode and Form : Which possibly considering all their circumstances ( particularly their Education , the prejudices of which it is the most difficult thing in the world one of them to overcome , their Parts , Complexions , &c. ) may be more their misfortune than their fault . Besides Sanguinary Penalties , or the using of extreme Rigour of any kind to compel men to come over to our way of Religion , are the most improper means to effect that end ; that of Lactantius being as great a Truth in all Ages as it was in his and the two foregoing , when the Church was subject to the Heathen Persecutors , viz. Religion is a thing to which no man can be forced , the Will is perswaded by Words not by Blows . And the Arguments used by the most Ancient Fathers against persecuting people for mere dissenting in matters of Religion are as strong against the persecuting practices of Rome Christian , as they were against those of Rome Pagan . And this means hath proved always as unsuccessful as it is improper , the best success it hath ever had hath been to make some Hypocrites , and the rest more averse and obstinate than they were before . That way of Religion they before disliked , they now hate , and oppression making even wise men mad ( as King Solomon observeth ) multitudes from modest Dissenters in their own defence turn Factious and Seditious , and down-right opposers . And nothing hath been more ordinarily observed , than that Persecution doth mightily encrease instead of diminishing the number of Dissenters . As it is grown into a Maxim , Sanguis Martyrum est semen Ecclesiae , The bloud of Martyrs is the seed of the Church , so nothing makes any party so considerable , nor any thing gains them so many Proselytes , as their bearing Death or Torment or any cruel usage like Martyrs ; which we need not be informed the very worst of men have frequently done . Thanks be to God the Church of England is as far departed from that of Rome in this point of merciless Severity , as in the rest of her Abominations . Which hath made me stand amazed at the Tragical out-cries of one or two of late against our Church , as if the Inquisition it self could hardly match her in her savage cruelty towards sober Dissenters . Such Libellers as these have as little Wit as Christianity or Common Honesty ; for can they more expose their Reputation than by publishing to the World such things as every body can confute from his own knowledge . These people cannot but believe in their Consciences ; that modest Dissenters ( nor immodest neither as themselves know by experience ) cannot hope to have fairer quarter in any part of the Christian world , where there is any Establishment , than they have in this Church . Nay , that there is hardly any one Party of the Dissenters that would be half so favourable to the rest , should they get into Power , as our Constitution is to all of them . The principal of our divided Parties 't is well known have been tried in England , Scotland and New-England , and how exemplary they have been for their Moderation towards men of a different perswasion is too well understood to be quickly forgotten . But old sores shall not bleed afresh by my rubbing them , as great provocation as is given by some at the most unseasonable time imaginable . Prop. 5. But , notwithstanding what we have now ▪ Asserted , there is a necessity of making it more mens interest to comply with the publick Establishment , than not to comply with it : Which cannot be done , so long as those who are conformable thereunto , and those which dissent from it , are both put into the self-same circumstances . It is as good , nay better , to have no legal Establishment at all , than not to back it with motives of Temporal Interest , to disswade from Disobedience to it ; it is so , so long as this sort of interest hath so great a power over the generality of men , nay of professors of Religion too , as we see it hath ; and so few comparatively are governed by pure Reason and Conscience , as great pretences as there are to both . Penalties of one nature or other are necessary Sanctions of Laws , and were it not for the annexing of them , Laws would be so far from being generally obeyed , that they would be generally despised and contemned . Nay , the perverse natures of men do so incline them niti in vetitum , to do what 's prohibited , through their excessive fondness for Liberty , that I am perswaded the way to have this or that done by the far greater part , would be for Authority to forbid it without a Penalty . And as for that Objection , that Civil penalties make men Hypocrites ; how is it possible that those who make it should not at the same time see , that it is as much levelled at all Laws , as at those which relate to matters of Religion ? Then men ought not to be prohibited Murther , Adultery or Theft under Civil penalties , because they will be apt to make them Hypocrites ; as 't is certain those are no better , who abstain from those crimes from the mere fear of the lash of the Law. But it is better for the Publick that men should be Hypocrites in their Obedience , than that they should live in Disobedience , and somewhat better for themselves too . And no man will be made a Hypocrite by penalties , but such a one as would disobey and be an open sinner were it not for them . I add , that this Objection is also levelled at leaving it to every bodies Liberty to comply or not comply with the legal Establishment . What a Temptation would this be to those to plead scruples of Conscience against some condition of Communion , who are only swayed by some motive of Interest ( to get better trading , to please their Wives or the like ) to leave the Church , and joyn themselves to separate Congregations . Prop. 6. We must distinguish between a Liberty of serving God according to our Consciences , and a Liberty of making others to be of our perswasion . There is a wide difference between these two . It is inconsistent with Government for this latter Liberty to be Allowed . Nothing can come of Authorities giving licence to Dissenters to make Proselytes to their several Parties , but downright Confusion . I appeal to themselves , whether if any of them now sate at the Helm , and were in the chair of Government , they could endure to have their Authority publickly confronted ; they know they could not , and much less give Liberty , that is Encouragement , to those to confront it who have a mind to it . But what is it to put an affront upon Authority , if publick Endeavours to withdraw People from Obedience be not so ? It is the greatest immodesty to desire of Governours such a Liberty as this , and supposeth them either not to understand or to have no concern for their own interest as Governours . And those that dissent from the legal Establishment ought to think themselves most kindly dealt with , and to be very thankful , may they enjoy upon tolerable terms their own way of Religion , without free licence to do all they can to encrease their Party . How happy would our good Ancestors in the Reign of Queen Mary have thought themselves , had Her Majesty vouchsafed them such a Liberty as that ! They would hardly have thought they could pay too dear for 't . It may be objected , what if a man be immediately commissionated by the King of Kings , as the Apostles were , publickly to withdraw men from Obedience to those Laws which require of them unlawful things , and withal he prove his Commission by working of Miracles , is not Authority obliged to give Liberty so to do in that case ? Surely it is . I answer , surely it is not , but 't is obliged to do that which is much better than giving this Liberty , and which will prevent all need of it , namely , to Repeal those Laws as soon as ever it appears they are displeasing to God ; and so to make the doing contrary to them no Disobedience . But if this be not done , the Commissionated person ought not to expect that Authority should give him this Liberty , but he ought to take it , and to be confident that God will stand by him in so doing . Prop. 7. Those Laws that enjoyn or forbid things in their own nature Indifferent , ought not to be inforced with as severe Penalties , as those which are made for or against those things which are good or evil in themselves , which are commanded or prohibited by the Divine Laws . Or the Transgressors of the Majora jura , the Laws of Heaven should be more severely punisht , than the Transgressors of mere Humane Laws . 'T is certain that the former sort of offenders do deserve worse than the latter do . Their crimes are of an higher nature and more intolerable , and therefore it is highly fit that they should be greater sufferers than the other offenders , for the more effectual scaring of others from following their Example , or doing like them . All offences against the State are not alike punished , neither should all those which are against the Church . No good man will question , but that 't is a greater Sin to be a Separatist than a mere Dissenter in some things ; and also not to worship God at all than to worship him in an illegal way . To make no Conscience of Receiving the Lord's Supper , than to scruple the Gesture he is obliged to receive it in . Or , that Profaneness is more hateful than unaffected Scrupulosity or Superstition . And therefore I think the self-same or equal Penalties should not belong to both . Common Equity requires this ; and according to this Rule our Judge hath foretold us He will at the last day proceed with the Disobedient . And by this means will no pretence be left to those , who take all occasions to censure their Governours , for the reproaching of them , as laying too great weight upon things little in themselves , as placing Religion in them , and equalizing their own Traditions with ( and much less preferring them , Pharisee like , before ) the Commandments of God ; and as having less Zeal for Gods Glory than for keeping up the Reputation of their own Authority . And for the same as well as an higher reason it is necessary , that as great care at least should be taken to bring the open immediate Transgressors of God's Laws to condign punishment , as those who only are Transgressors of mere Humane Laws . But there is one thing more that I would not have forgotten , that the dreadful Censure of Excommunication ought not to be past upon any but the greatest offenders ; among which ( that I may not be mistaken ) I account ( as the Primitive Church did ) all Schismaticks as well as Prophane persons . To make the smaller offenders liable to it , be it done upon what pretence it will , is the readiest way to make it contemptible . And nothing is more contrary to the practice of the Apostles or the first Ages than so to do . Prop. 8. Most favour may be reasonably expected by such Dissenters as give the greatest reason to judge that they are really Conscientious in their Dissenting . If any Liberty be left by Law to the Magistrate to shew favour in pitiable circumstances , whatsoever it is , such Dissenters ought to have the benefit of it . And those may be presumed to be Conscientious in reality as well as pretence , who First , Are observed to make Conscience of the great and indisputable duties of Religion . And Secondly , Who comply with the Establishment as far as they can , for ought that appeareth to the contrary . These we are bound in charity to believe are sincerely Conscientious in stopping where they do . This proposition needs no proving ; and this other is as clear , viz. Those who give greatest evidence of their being Conscientious have most right to favour . But although it be not an indisputable case , that he makes no Conscience in some smaller things who makes none in certain great ones ; or that he who goes not as far as he declares he can , is a mere pretender to Conscience in what he saith he cannot do , yet there is no injury done him if his Governours have a strong suspicion of him , and he fare the worse upon that account . He must then thank himself for it , and not blame them . Prop. 9. Those have least reason to ask or look for Liberty of Conscience or any thing of Indulgence , who are for no bodies having it besides themselves , and give great reason to presume by their behaviour in their present circumstances , that were they in Authority they would give none to those from whom they now expect it . Such are all those who are not contented to Disobey the present Laws , nor to draw others to their Party as much as in them lies , but cannot forbear Railing at , and passing the severest and most uncharitable Censures , in their Common discourse , and in the Pulpit and Press too , upon their Spiritual Governours especially , and those who are Conformable to the Constitution . 'T is not at all to be questioned but such People would Persecute otherwise than with their Tongues or Pens , if ever they should be furnisht with more dangerous Weapons . He who shews his teeth at me , I have reason to suspect would make them meet , were he able to bite ; in so doing he shews his good will and what he would gladly be at , had he an opportunity . I wish the Papists were the onely people I could now reflect upon . Such too are all our peremptory Dogmatizers in Disputable points of Religion , who cannot bear to be contradicted , though never so modestly , as if they had gotten the Popes chair from him , and their judgments were the standard of Orthodoxy . From whose Sentiments you may not depart scarcely one hairs breadth , but you immediately fall under suspicion of Heresie , or some dangerous error . I should be very loth these Stiff and Supercilious men should ever live to be my Masters ; if they should , I doubt not ●ut I should soon feel that they have Cru●●ty answerable to their Pride , as much ●s some of them now cry out for Liberty ●f Conscience . The men I have now in my thoughts ●re not onely ( as I said of the other ) ●he Roman Gentlemen , but certain pro●●ssed Protestants ( as like Papists as they ●ook ) and those of more than one Mode and Form. Such again are those , who , as impa●ent as themselves are of all Restraints , ●re very angry that the Conformable Clergy are no more restrained , that is , ●n Doctrinals . Who would have the ●hirty Nine Articles more than Nine ●nd Forty , and are not a little grieved that several Points are so expressed , as to admit of a latitude of Interpretation . Who can believe but that these men would be far more severe Restrainers of Liberty , than those whom they so complain of ? I say far more severe , for there is no Considerative Ingenuous and Free-minded man but had rather have twenty harmless Rites imposed on his Practice , than two disputable and uncertain Doctrines upon his Belief . And such lastly are those Parties , who , whensoever they have had opportunity , have been Rigidly severe to Dissenters from themselves . What security can we possibly have , that those who for the time past have been Persecutors , whenever they had Power in their hands , will never be so for the time to come , if they should have Power ? Especially if they still retain those principles which naturally tend to make men Cruel . Here if I expatiated I would have onely to do with the Popish Faction , and spare others , who though they have been too guilty in this respect , yet not comparably to them . What is better known throughout the Christian World , than the Horrible Tyranny of the Romish Church , than her most Barbarous and Savage Cruelties towards those who would not Worship that Beast and his Image , and would not receive the mark of his Name ? What an Ocean of Bloud hath this Ravenous Beast shed of the Saints and of the Prophets of God ? The History of Pagan Rome's cruelties towards the Christians in the ten Famous Persecutions is far out-done by that of Rome Christian ( I had rather say Rome Antichristian ) towards poor Protestants . Guess we what a prodigiously vast number have fallen as Sacrifices to her Devilish Fury by two or three Instances . It is computed that in the Massacre in Paris , and other parts of France , were Butchered about an Hundred thousand . That of the Albigenses and Waldenses were Murthered no fewer than a Thousand thousand . That within the space of Forty years from the Founding of the Blessed Order of the Iesuits , were Murthered about Nine hundred thousand . That the Holy Inquisition in the space of Thirty years destroyed with an infinite number of cruelties an Hundred and Fifty thousand . That in the Low Countries Duke Alva , that Bloudy Bigot of Rome , caused to be executed about Six thousand . And what great numbers did suffer here in England purely upon the score of Religion in the Reigns of King Henry the Eighth and Queen Mar● ? And what work the Priests and Jesuits and other of the Sons of Rome had ere this time been employed in again among us , if their ●ate Horrid Conspiracy had taken effect , we very well know . Those know no more of the Principles or Spirit of Popery than a sucking Infant , who can give the least credit to their most solemn promises of a Toleration of , or Indulgence towards Protestants , although they should back them with never so many Sacred Oaths upon the Holy Bible , and pawn their Souls upon their fulfilling them with never so tremendous and direful Execrations . And yet these men are so void of all shame , that ever since the Reformation they have turned every stone to obtain a Toleration of their Religion among us : And that notwithstanding the plainest Demonstrations which from time to time they have given us , that they seek it for no other End , but that by the means of it they may do that by Fraud against our Religion and all that 's dear to us , which ( thanks be to God ) they are not strong enough to do by force , nor by any other methods of Fraud neither . Though they could never yet obtain a legal Toleration , yet they have not wanted for indulgence and kind usage , but this hath been so far from melting them into good nature , that they have still taken Advantage from thence to lay Designs for our Ruine . At that very time ( and for some time before ) when their Gunpowder Conspiracy , not to be thought of without the greatest Horror , was projected and almost effected by them , did King Iames treat them with not onely extraordinary Clemency , but also Friendship and Bounty . At the Trial of the Traitors , his Majestie 's Attorny General observed , that that Treason was hatched at a time , when the King used the greatest Lenity towards the Papists , whom he honoured with Advancement and Favour as well as others , and by the space of a whole Year and four Months took no Penalties by Statute of them . And this likewise the King himself remembred them of , the more to convince them of their prodigious Ingratitude . And to pass by their Conspiring the Death of King Charles the First of most Happy Memory , and afterwards effecting it by the hands of the Fanaticks ( whose instruments they were , not onely in the not to be parallel'd Murder of that excellently pious Prince , all circumstances of it considered , but also in the long Civil War preceding it , as Doctor Peter Du-Moulin hath discovered in his Answer to Philanax Anglicus ) I say to pass by all that , to which nothing could provoke them except the most Gentle , Gracious and Kind usage , 't is known to every body , that nothing neither except the like usage could provoke them to this last most Inhumane and Hellish Conspiracy . And yet , notwithstanding they have always been to us like the Philistines to the Israelites , sharp Thorns in our Sides , and Pricks in our Eyes , are they still so impudent as to insist upon it as their Right to have Liberty of Conscience ; and hope with the Assistance of their old tried Tools at last to obtain it . And 't is matter of Grief and Astonishment to us , that these will not yet see , though it be as visible as the Light , that if with their help they do obtain it , the best Recompence they shall receive for their good service will be the Inslaving of themselves , and the Ruine of their Religion . I thought not of so far enlarging upon this Proposition , but considering into what a large Field I was entered , I found it somewhat difficult to break off so soon . Prop. 10. In the last place , Governours ought not to impose any thing but for weighty Reasons ; but what upon the maturest deliberation they judge to be necessary , or ( upon one account or other ) very highly Expedient . To make little and insignificant things the matter of Laws is the readiest course to beget in the People a sleighting of Authority , and to lessen the Veneration that is due to Laws ; And also gives ill-minded persons a great advantage , and puts plausible objections into their mouths against the Government . But , having taken leave to say what becomes Governours , I am obliged to add , that private Persons are no competent judges of the Necessity or Expediency of Laws . And that it very ill becomes them to be forward to Censure those as needless , the reason of which is unknown to them . 'T is an Argument of great immodesty and pride to think , that we who stand upon the lower ground can see as far as those who are so much above us : And a very little Prudence and Humility will serve to convince us , that those much better understand the Methods of Government than we do , and what is fit to be imposed , whose whole Business and Employment it is to Govern. We have certain Rules whereby to judge of the Lawfulness of things imposed , but we may be easily mistaken when we undertake to determine of the Fitness of them . Thus having with submission to my Superiors offered my Opinion about this weighty Argument in the foregoing Propositions , I hope I shan't be censured as immodest if I also add , that I do not see but Governours might avoid the two Extremes in reference to Liberty of Conscience , as it is called , by having a constant regard to such like Rules . And that the Governed , on the other hand , by doing the like , might understand without much difficulty , within what bounds they ought to confine themselves , in Craving of their Governours or Expecting from them this kind of Liberty . But I think it seasonable to suggest this one thing more to these , that they would so behave themselves , that those who have Power to grant it as far as is sitting , might not be tempted to think it a thing onely adapted to the serving of Interest , and by that means be the more inclined to a total Refusing of any such Liberty . I mean , that there be no Occasion given to what is so Commonly , not without ground , said , viz. When 't is mens Temporal Interest to plead for Liberty of Conscience , then they are Zealous for it , but the Tables are no sooner turned , but who like them against it . Were we as honest as we should be , we should be more fixed and constant , and not so vary in our Principles as our Circumstances vary . We should not in one Circumstance build what before we destroyed , and in another destroy what we before built : And so declare amidst all our Stir and Noise about Liberty of Conscience , that we have either none at all , or but very little Conscience . But in the Conclusion of all , I must not forget that which hath occasioned all this Discourse about Liberty of Conscience , viz. that whatever that Liberty of this kind is which we have a Right to , it is not a Branch of Christian but of mere Natural Liberty . There is no Text of Scripture that mentioneth this as a Liberty of our Saviour's Purchasing , and therefore no Christian may claim it as a Christian. 'T is due to men of all Religions , who may be supposed to make Conscience of what they do , and not only to the Professors of the Christian Religion . And 't was always and in all places as much mens Right , as it hath been since our Saviour's Appearance in the World , and is in those Parts of it where his Gospel is received . CHAP. XVI . The Third Inference from our Notion of Christian Liberty , viz. That Popery is the greatest Enemy in the World thereunto . Where it is shewed , First , That the Church of Rome Robs those who are subject to her of that Natural Liberty which necessarily belongs to them as they are Men , viz. That which consists in the free use of their Vnderstandings in matters of Religion . That She will not permit men to Examine either her Doctrines or Practices by the Holy Scriptures ; nor yet to receive the Holy Scriptures themselves otherwise than upon her Authority . The Wickedness of this exposed in two Particulars . The alledging of Scripture for it , shewed to be the grossest Absurdity . Their great Text 1 Tim. 3. 15. spoken to . Her Tyranny over mens Minds further shewed . HAving now spoken to all the False Notions of Christian Liberty that I know of , and discovered the intolerable Mischievousness of them as well as Falsity ; I proceed to another Inference from our Notion thereof , namely ; Thirdly , That Popery is a Religion ( if I honour it not too much in calling it so ) that is the greatest Enemy in the whole World to Christian Liberty . Should all the wicked Wits in the World meet together to Consult and Complot how to Banish out of it this Liberty , they could not devise more effectual means for the doing of it than those which are pitch'd upon by the Church of Rome . And here we will shew , First , That She Robs those who Subject themselves to her , of that Natural Liberty which necessarily belongs to them as they are Men , or Reasonable Creatures . And much more , Secondly , That She Robs them of that Liberty , which it was the Design of our Saviour's Coming into the World , and of all he did and suffered here to instate us in . First , That She Robs those , who Subject themselves to her , of that Natural Liberty , which necessarily belongs to them as Men , or Reasonable Creatures . There is no Liberty so Essential to Humane Nature , or so much its Inviolable Right , as that which consists in the free use of our Understandings : But a Papist is miserably tied up and inslaved here ; and that in those matters wherein it is of Infinitely the greatest Importance and Concernment to him , that his Mind should be free , namely in matters of Religion ; which have such a necessary influence into the Welfare of our Souls and our Eternal Happiness . But , notwithstanding that Injunction of S. Paul , 1 Thes. 5. 21. Prove all things , hold fast that which is good . And that of S. Iohn , 1 Epist. 4. 1. Beloved believe not every Spirit , but try the Spirits whether they be of God , &c. This Church denieth to her Children all judgment of Discretion in Points of Religion ; at least except in this one Point , the choice of the Church for their Guide , which having Chosen , they must follow her blind-fold all their lives after . They must be Implicit Believers , and Implicit Chusers , She will 〈◊〉 and believe for them : All their ●●dgment and Faith must be resolved into h●rs ; as being , if you will believe her , 〈◊〉 and Uncapable of being either deceiv●● 〈◊〉 self , or of deceiving others . And therefore , to take our Saviour's 〈◊〉 to 〈◊〉 th● Scriptures , except for the forementioned one thing , ( nay , for that too , as we shall see anon ) is to put an Affront upon Her Authority ; and the Bereans , who were so highly commended for so doing , were guilty of great Sauciness and high Presumption . And She takes the most successful course that can be thought of , that you shall not Search the Scriptures , by locking them up as She does , and making the Bible so scarce a Book to be light upon , where she hath Power enough to do it ; and in those places where her Power is Clipt , by using a many wicked Artifices to keep the Vulgar from looking into it ; who are so miserably imposed upon by their wretched Priests , as to think it a lighter sin to be Drunk or to commit Fornication , and transgress many an express Law of God , than to cast their Eyes upon the Holy Scriptures . So well aware is this Church , that a great part of her Religion is neither to be found there , nor agreeable with them , but as expresly , as it can be done by words , contradicted by them . And as you may not Examine any of her Doctrines or Practices by comparing them with the Rule of Faith and Practice , the Scriptures , so neither ( which is but a necessary consequence from thence ) may you have any other Foundation for your Belief of the Books of Scripture themselves , besides her Authority . She will have your Assent to their being of Divine Authority to depend wholly upon her Testimony ; Notwithstanding that God Almighty hath vouchsafed to the World marvellously full and plentiful Evidence thereof , and such as is adapted to the capacities of all those who have the use of Reason , but never once mentioned this as a part of that Evidence , and therefore much less can it be thought the Whole . How infinitely ill hath this Corrupt Church deserved at the hands of all Christians , although this were the onely Abuse she had put upon them ! For ( to say nothing of her Horrible Pride and Uncharitableness in making the truth of the Scriptures dependent on her Testimony , that her Pretence supposing her making her self the onely true Church ) this is the greatest injury imaginable to Christianity ; nor can she take a surer course than this to make all men Infidels . And that upon these two Accounts . First , This Pretence of hers is immediately founded upon a Precarious and most Evidently false Principle , viz. That of her Infallibility . I dare appeal to those of her own Sons who have studied the Controversie , whether there was ever a more shamefully baffled Cause in the World than this is : Whether by their Infallible Church they mean with the Iesuits the Pope alone , or with others the Pope with his General Council , that is , a pack of Bishops and Priests of his own Faction . As the Psalmist saith , If the Foundations be destroyed , what shall the Righteous do ? So if this be the Foundation of our Christian Faith , and that be proved to be a Rotten Foundation ( as nothing was ever proved if this be not ) then what shall we Christians do ? We must then acknowledge our selves a Generation of most Credulous Fools , and that our Faith is vain . If the Foundation be tottering , the whole Superstructure must fall to the Ground . But so fond is this Unsatiably Covetous and Ambitious Church of her Great Diana Infallibility , by the Pretence whereof she hath raised her self to such a Height and Grandeur , that she is well content , if that must fall , that our Saviour and his Apostles , both the Old and New Testament should fall with it . And she hath done all that lies in her to make it necessary , that those who shall have the wisdom to reject her Ridiculous Doctrine of Infallibility , should at the self-same time renounce Christianity . If Popery were Chargeable with no other Crime ( as it is with innumerable others , and many of them intolerable ) I say were it Chargeable with no other Crime , but the making our Belief of the Authority of the Books of Scripture to be founded on the Infallibility of the Romish Faction , we ought to be as zealous for the Preventing its Reestablishment in this Nation ( from whence it hath happily been twice Expelled ) as we are desirous to Preserve the Christian Religion . Secondly , The Romish Churche's making her Authority the sole Foundation of our Belief of the Scriptures makes the Testimony of the Spirit to the Truth of Christianity , in our Saviour when on ●arth , and in the Apostles and others in the Primitive Ages , to be now perfectly Insignificant . I think it makes them to be so as to the Church Representative , for she pretends to her Infallibility ( and consequently to her Infallible Assurance of the Truth of Christianity ) as an immedi●te Gift of the Holy Ghost , therefore what need hath she of the Testimony of Miracles ? But as to Private Christians I can by no means understand in what stead they stand them ; for if the Churches Authority be necessary to their believing the truth of the Scriptures , and therefore to their believing that there were those Miracles really wrought , which the Writings of the Apostles tell us of , then why may they not without any more ado make her Authority the immediate ground of their Assent to the truth of Christianity ? It is said that the truth of the Matters of Fact are not knowable at this distance , ( such as whether there were such Persons as our Saviour and his Apostles , whether they performed such Miracles , and the Apostles wrote such Books , &c. ) but by the Tradition of the Church , because no such Matters are to be known at any considerable distance , but by Tradition . To this it is Answered , that it is one thing to believe the Matters of Fact upon the Churche's Tradition , and another to believe them upon her Authority founded upon her Infallibility . Now this latter we reject , but adhere to the former , as a Ground of our belief of those things . But then by the Tradition of the Church we are far from meaning that of Rome onely . We mean the Catholick Church , or the whole Collective Body of Christians throughout the World , from the Apostles times down to this present Age ; of which the Roman Church is but a Part ( and therefore does Impudently in appropriating Catholicism to her self ) and that a very Vitiated Part too , and that Church Representative an exceedingly small Part. And we receive the Tradition of the Catholick Church as a Ground ( as I said ) of believing these Matters , not as t●e Ground , because we take in another Tradition , viz. that of those who are out of the Church , and Enemies to Christianity , the Iews especially . In short , we believe those and the like matters of Fact , upon the same ground that we believe all other wherein Religion is not concerned ; but there are Circumstances which give the Tradition of Christian matters of Fact a mighty Advantage above other Traditions , as unquestionable Assurance as these give men , when they are General and Uninterrupted . But 't is well known to all who are not strangers to the Popish Writers , what lamentable work they make in proving the Testimony of the Church to be the foundation of our Faith concerning the Authority of the Scriptures . This Proof they fetch out of the Scriptures themselves ; and their main Text for this purpose , and for the Infallibility of their Church is those words of S. Paul , 1 Tim. 3. 15. where he calls the Church the Pillar and Ground of Truth . But what a manifest Circle is this ? We ask them , how it appears that the Scriptures are the Word of God ? They answer , it appears from the Testimony of the Church . We ask again , how it appears that the Testimony of the Church is true ? They reply , it appears from the Scriptures . And so they prove the Authority of the Scriptures by the Testimony of the Church , and then wheel about again , and prove the Authority of the Church by the Testimony of the Scriptures . But again , We can either be certain of the truth of these words of S. Paul , setting aside the Authority of the Church , or we cannot be Certain . If we can be Certain , why then not of the truth of the whole Scripture as well as of this single Text ? If we cannot be certain of the truth of this Text without the consideration of the Churche's Authority , what Folly or rather Knavery is it to make this Text an Argument to prove the thing in Controversie by , when the truth of this Text is questionable upon the same grounds that the truth of the Scriptures in general is ? Again , When they say that the Testimony of the Church is the Ground of this our Faith , they tell us , that by the Church they mean the Church of Rome , and that She onely is the True Church . We reply , that there are a many Societies of Christians in the World , that hold no Communion with the Church of Rome , and Each of these calls it self a True Church , and therefore how shall we know that they are none of them so , but that the Church of Rome alone is ? They tell us , that this Church alone hath the Notes and Characters of the True Church . We ask again , how it doth appear that those Notes and Characters they give are true and genuine , and , if they are , that their Church onely hath them ? Here they are forced to fly again to the Scriptures , and produce us some which they would have us believe are very pertinent to the purpose ; though none but those who see by their Light are able to discern any such matter . But whether they be to the purpose or no , is no part now of our Enquiry , but this is that which we shew from hence , how still they are intangled in their own Net , and Run round in a Circle . Yet once again , these People would perswade us that there is no knowing the Scriptures to be of Divine Authority , but by the Testimony of their Church , whenas 't is impossible to know that there is any such thing in being as a Church , but by the Scriptures . And thus you see what prime Christians these Romanists are , what Worthy Catholicks . If there were no better Champions than these for the Authority of the Scriptures , or the Truth of Christianity , Atheists and Infidels long since would have filled all Places : As it is well known how they abound in the Popish Countries , and most of all in Italy , and of all Italy most in Rome . And but for Old Mother Ignorance , whom they have a marvellous Fondness for , as well they may , their Holy Mother the Church would by this time have had but a very small number of Children or Friends . But I would this had been the worst on 't , as alas it is not : For Multitudes among them being well aware that they are merely imposed on ; and being Acquainted with no better than an Implicit Faith , and thinking that no more is to be said for Christianity than they learn from them , shake off both their Popish and Christian Faith together . But we must not let that forementioned Text wholly pass on which is laid such mighty Stress for the proving of the Infallibility of the Roman Church ; which gives her such a plausible Pretence for the Enslaving of Mens Minds and Understandings . The whole Verse runs thus , with the Verse foregoing : Th●●e things write I unto thee , hoping to come unto thee shortly . But if I tarry long , that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thy self in the House of God , which is the Church of the living God , the Pillar and Ground of Truth . According to Episcopius his reading of these latter words , it is not the Church that is here called the Pillar and Ground of Truth ; but God manifested in the flesh , justified in the Spirit , &c. in the next Verse . For he makes that 15. Verse to conclude with living God , ( Verses and Pointings being arbitrary ) and The Pillar and Ground of Truth to begin the next Verse thus , The Pillar and Ground of Truth , and without controversie the great Mystery of Godliness , is God manifested in the flesh , &c. But there is no need of using any artifice to make these words unserviceable to the design of proving the Infallibility of the Church of Rome ; for all that can be gathered from them is no more than this ; That the Church is the support of that Truth which is necessary to Salvation , viz. the Doctrine of the Gospel . That which preserveth it in the world is the Churches constant profession of it , and standing up for it . That is , this is the External and Visible means whereby this Truth is kept from perishing and being lost . Or according to Grotius , The Church doth uphold and lift up the Truth , it causeth it not to slip out of mens minds , and also to be beheld far and near . For the Testimony of many good men , who all say that they received these Doctrines and Precepts from the Apostles , must needs have great force and efficacy upon those who are not obstinate and contumacious . So that , First , This Great man seems to understand by the Church in this place onely that which was most Ancient . But , Secondly , There is no reason at all to understand by the Church here onely the Church Representative , but the whole Body of Christians must necessarily be meant ; It being called the House of God , but the Apostles , Bishops and Pastors are called the Builders of the House , and Governours never the House it self . And besides , the Church which is here called the Pillar and Ground of Truth is that over part of which Timothy presided . That thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thy self in the House of God , &c. that is , as a Bishop and Pastor in it . Thirdly , If it should be understood of the Church Representative , 't is however intolerable impudence to make it onely the Roman . But , Fourthly , This Text makes nothing to the purpose of Infallibility in the Church of Rome's sence , understand by the Church of the living God which Church you please ; especially if you do not limit it to the First Age : As is plain from what hath been said , and it needs no more words to make it plainer . Now how can we have greater assurance that the Church of Rome is an Arrant Impostor than this one thing gives us , viz. That She will not allow us the Liberty of judging for our selves ? The Great Apostle S. Paul allowed this Liberty to the Corinthians in those words : I speak as unto wise men , judge ●e what I say , 1 Cor. 10. 15. And dare they say , that he overshot himself in that saying , or passed a mere Complement upon the Corinthians ? 'T will not be at all strange if they do , considering how many worse things several of them have said of this Apostle . But , I say , this Church will not permit us to see with our own Eyes , but we must take the whole of our Religion upon trust , that is , upon her bare word , pin our whole Faith upon her Sleeve , and receive the most Fundamental Articles upon her Warrant and Authority . Nay , though she would seem to give us leave to use our Reason in the choice of our Church , yet neither doth she this really ; but what she gives with one hand takes away again with the other , in that she will not suffer us to judge of the sence of Scripture , and consequently not of those Texts whereby she pretends to prove her self the onely true Church . For if we be acknowledged to be Competent judges of the true meaning of some Scriptures , why not of all that are as easily intelligible as those are ? Those must be very Charitable , who can put a fairer Interpretation upon this her Severity than this , that it is designed to make us swallow without Chewing , receive without Examining the Doctrines which are of her own invention ; and obey blindfold those Decrees of hers , which she is Conscious to her Self , have not onely no Countenance from the Holy Scriptures , but are as apparently Contradictory to them , as any one Proposition can be to another ; and are framed for no other purpose , but the serving of a worldly and most corrupt Interest , and the gratifying of those Appetites which it is the Business of Christianity to Subdue and Mortifie , viz. Unsatiable Covetousness , Luciferian Pride and Ambition , and Diabolical Revenge and Malice . Again , what greater Tyranny can be Exercised over a mans Mind , than to impose upon his Faith , and that upon pain of Damnation , not onely the strangest Absurdities and greatest Fooleries , but the grossest , most manifest and palpable Contradictions ? But the Romish Church requireth your Belief of Innumerable of these in that her one Doctrine of Transubstantiation . Nay , in imposing this mad Doctrine upon you , she also tieth you up from giving Credit to your very Senses , no fewer than four of five ; and so would deprive you not onely of the Liberty of Men , but of all Animals . CHAP. XVII . Where it is shewed , Secondly , That Popery is as great an Enemy as can be to Christian Liberty . And First , To that Liberty which our Saviour hath purchased for the World in general . As 1. That it tendeth as much as is possible to the Corrupting of mens Souls by subjecting them to vile Affections . This shewed in the general , viz. in that it is apt to beget false Notions of God ; and more particularly , in that it brings men under the Power of the Lusts of Malice , Revenge , Cruelty ; Pride and Ambition ; Covetousness ; Uncleanness ; Intemperance ; and the greatest Injustice and Unrighteousness . 2. That it no less tendeth to Disqui●● m●ns M●nds with certain troublesome Passions . SEcondly , As Popery deprives men of that Natural Liberty which doth necessarily belong to them as men , so it is as grea● an Enemy as can be to Christian Liberty . Both to that Liberty which our Saviour hath purchased for the World in general , and to that which He purchased for the Iews in particular . First , It is as opposite and injurious as can be to that Liberty which our Saviour hath purchased for the World in general . This Liberty we have abundantly proved doth consist in Freedom from the Dominion of Corrupt Affections , and an entire Compliance with the Laws of Righteousness . Upon which follow Freedom from the Power of Troublesom and Disquieting Passions , and Sweet Satisfaction and Self-Enjoyment . Now it will fully appear , that the Popish Religion is as opposite as can be to the Liberty which consisteth in these things , by that time we have dispatched these following particulars ; whereon should I give my self leave to be as large as I might , I should write a large Volume instead of a Chapter . First , Popery in its own nature tendeth , as much as is possible , to the Corrupting and Debauching our Souls by bringing them into Subjection to Vile Affections . Secondly , It no less tendeth to Disquiet our Minds with Troublesom and Tormenting Passions . Thirdly , It makes the Admirable Method , which we have shewed our Lord hath taken for our Deliverance from both , and the making of us Holy and Happy , perfectly Ineffectual . First , It in its own nature tendeth as much as is possible , to the Corrupting and Debauching of our Souls , by bringing them into subjection to Vile Affections . This shall be shewed in the general , and more particularly . 1. In the general , it doth this as it is apt to beget false Notions , and very unworthy Conceptions of the Divine Nature : Whereas a true Idea of God is necessary to the Reforming of our Lives , and Rectifying of our Natures , which cannot be done , without a due Awe and Reverence for Him , nor without Conforming our selves to his Image and Likeness . Among the several Instances of Popish Idolatry ( from the guilt of which high and provoking Impiety the Heathens may as easily purge themselves , as the Church of Rome ) their Picturing of God the Father and the Holy Trinity ( Allowed by the Council of Trent ) and Worshipping their Pictures is a very great one . But who seeth not how this tends to beget in mens Minds a most Low and Undervaluing , Gross and Impure Conception of the Deity ? Can he easily conceive of God as a most pure Spirit , that useth to feed his Eyes , and foul his Fancy with bodily Representations of Him ? That useth to Worship the Trinity under the Figure of an Old man , with a long Grey Beard , with a Crucifix between his Knees and a Dove in his Breast ? Or under the ugly Figure of a Man-Cerberus , or a Man with three Heads upon his shoulders ? But 't is well known that these are the Abominable Forms by which the Papists Represent the Glorious Trinity ; of which the former is much the more Common . I do not see how any Man who venerates the Divine Majesty as he ought , and hath according to his Capacity a worthy Idea of the unspeakable purity of his Nature and incomprehensible Perfections , can endure the sight of such Pictures : But whosoever can fall in love with them , whatsoever becoming sense of God he had before , must needs soon lose it . That other Instance also of Popish Idolatry , viz. The Addressing themselves to the Saints , whether by Images or otherwise with all the Reverence and Solemnity of Devotion which is used to the Great God , must necessarily have much the same influence upon their Minds . And their multitude of little trifling things , and many of them most ridiculous Fopperies , in which they place so much Religion , and seek to obtain Pardon by them even for great immoralities , speaks them to have no true sense of his Wisdom or Holiness , to have a base and sordid notion of Him , and doth more and more confirm them therein . Nor can they have any true Sense of the Infinite Equity and Goodness of the Divine Nature , who are able to think that there is no Salvation out of the Church of Rome ; and that God will damn to Eternal Torments all Persons that are not of her Communion , that is , the much greater part of Christendom , let them be never so good and pious people otherwise : But no man can be truly a Papist who believes more Charitably . And 't is no wonder that they should be Bloudy Wretches who are able to conceive such a thing of God ; when according to their Notion of Him the more Arbitrary , Tyrannical and Cruel they are , the more are they like that Being , which to Resemble is their Glory and Happiness . 2. This brings me to shew more Particularly that Popery doth naturally tend to bring mens Souls into Slavish Subjection to the Vile Affections of Malice , Revenge and Cruelty ; Pride and Ambition ; Covetousness ; Uncleanness ; Intemperance ; and the greatest Injustice and Unrighteousness . As for Malice and Cruelty ( as now we intimated ) they are the Natural and Genuine Off-spring of that most Horrible Uncharitableness that is proper to Popery . When men have once conceived such an opinion of any of their Fellow-Creatures , as that they are hated of God , and damned Reprobates , they think themselves obliged to Hate them too , and Hatred and Cruelty are never separated . We have already given Instances of Popish Cruelty in Butchering Protestants , and shewed what a vast Sea of Bloud hath been shed by the Papists ; which hath been at the command of their Holy Father , and the instigation of his cursed instruments the Iesuits . And I now add , that they have not satisfied themselves with the mere shedding of Bloud , but have devised the most exquisitely tormenting Methods of doing it ; such as can hardly be recited without great Horror and Consternation of mind . To pass over the inexpressible Tortures of the Holy Inquisition , what say you to long protracting the torments of those whose Bodies have been committed to the merciless Flames , by letting them down by degrees with Pullies , that the lower parts might be consumed before the Fire could reach the Vitals ? What say you to Roasting alive ; To Flaying off mens skins alive ; To Boiling of the Young Children of Hereticks alive , and casting them alive to be devoured by Swine ? What say you to Ripping up the Bellies of Women Great with Child , their hands and feet being first nailed down ; To Hanging men at their own doors by their privy Members ; To Burying men alive , and young Children , making holes in the Ground out of which they have put their hands , and made sad moan for their Mothers ? What Heart is so hard as not to bleed at the mere Reading or Hearing such things as these ? But these and innumerable such like , nay far more horrible things we might shew are Instances of Popish Cruelty ; And those in●licted upon the account of no greater Offences , than Refusing to be Idolaters , and not daring to be partakers of Rome's Sins lest they receive of her Plagues . But how should those think that these Devilish Barbarities do not well become them , who presume the poor Wretches they so torture to be Accursed of God , Devoted to destruction , and to far more grievous and intolerable Torments ; and that the Hatred God bears to them doth cause him to accept it as an Excellent piece of Service at their hands to be their Destroyers and Tormenters , that is , the Executioners of His Wrath ? Moreover , the Absolute Obedience they owe to Christ's Vicar imposeth a Necessity upon them not to boggle at the greatest Cruelties , whensoever his Holiness shall please to imploy them in such Services : which his Pride and Malice will never permit him to fail to do , whensoever he thinks it consistent with his interest . And that a power to employ his Vassals in such work as this , was conferred by Christ upon S. Peter and his Successors , Pope Pius the Fifth tells you , in the beginning of his Bull against Queen Elizabeth . Saith he , Regnans in excelsis , &c. He that Reigneth on High , to whom is given all Power in H●●●en and in Earth , hath committed the one Holy , Catholick and Apostolick Church , to one alone on Earth , viz. Peter Prince of the Apostles , and to his Successor the Bishop of Rome , to be governed with a plenitude of Power . This one hath he constituted Prince over all Nations and Kingdoms , ( but what to do ? The next words tell us ) Qui evellat , destruat , dissipet , disperdat , plantet & aedificet . That he may pluck up , destroy , break in pieces , waste , ( Blessed work ! ) plant and build ( i. e. ) upon those Ruines . And Pope Innocent the Third applieth to the Popes in a literal sence those words in the Prophecy of Ieremy : See , I have set thee over the Nations , and over the Kingdoms , to root out , and to pull down , and to destroy , and to throw down , to build and to plant . And it would be a most tedious piece of work to shew , what use the Popes have made of this their pretended power ; and how they have menaced with Excommunication those good-natured or prudent Princes , whom they have not found forward to obey their Commands in destroying Hereticks . So necessary is it that a Papist , if he will be true to his principles , should be either actually Cruel , or in a ready preparation to be so . And where is the Lust of Pride and Ambition so gratified to the height as in the Church of Rome ? As for the Head of this Church , can there be a prouder or so proud a Creature upon Gods Earth ? Who claims as Universal and Unbounded an Empire over Mankind , as the Father hath invested his Son Iesus withal . Who pretendeth his Authority to exceed as much the Royal Power as the Sun doth the Moon . Which are the words of the now mentioned Pope Innocent in the place cited . Who assumes to himself as great a Power over Kings and Emperors as over the meanest of Peasants , and Authority to dispose of their Crowns and Kingdoms at his own pleasure : And , whensoever he hath been strong enough , hath made them feel it . Who claims as great a power over Mens very Consciences , their Minds and Understandings ( as we have seen ) in matters of Religion , as God himself can . Nay , usurpeth such a Power as God himself abhors to have , as shall be shewn anon . So that if the Man of Sin , who sitteth in the Temple of God , and Exalteth himself above all that is called God , be not to be found in Rome , no part of the World ever was or will be able to shew him . And how is it possible that such prodigious Pride in the Head should not affect and influence the Members , both Clergy and Laity ; and that there should be none or little contagion in such an Example ? Surely the Example of the profoundly Humble Iesus cannot have a more powerful influence upon his Disciples , than that of his Diabolically proud and haughty pretended Vicars must needs have upon their Proselytes ; especially considering the great propensity of Humane Nature to this Sin of Pride . But as for the Popish Clergie , they have infinite temptations to the gratifying to the height this Lust , and as great Opportunities for it . To pass by the Cardinals and Bishops , the former of which have the stile and go in the Equipage of Princes , and are co-partners with their High and Mighty Lord in his forementioned vast Rule and Government : And the latter not inferior to the greatest of the Nobility , and have been Censured for going too much out of their way to meet Princes ; I say to pass by these , their Common Priests , Monks and Friers have the greatest incentives to Pride , haughtiness and Contempt of others , that the most Ambitious of them all can well wish to have . As for the Priests , I need not say how much their pretended Power of Transubstantiating the Elements in the Eucharist , which is no less than making a God Almighty with pronouncing five words , must needs Conciliate Veneration from the People to them . And also what a mighty Awe and Reverence their taking of Auricular Confession from People of all Ranks lying prostrate before them must necessarily beget in their minds towards them . And to other Instigations to pride , too many to be now instanced in , may be added their priviledge of taking the Sacrament in both kinds , whereas the greatest men of the Laity may not presume to touch the Cup. And then for the Monks and Friers ▪ what a Gratification of Pharisaical Pride is the Opinion that the Silly Vulgar have of their Extraordinary Sanctity , by means of the many Ceremonies , of which some are peculiar to one , and some to another Order , which are devised for no other purpose , but to make up a Mock-shew of wonderful Humility , Contempt of the World , and Mortification ? And to the Lust of Pride we next add that of Covetousness , this is no less gratified by the Popish Religion than the other : And no wonder , for Covetousness is a Pander and Pimp to Pride . Indeed , the whole Systeme of Popery is mainly contrived for the heaping up of Wealth . This is manifestly designed in their Doctrine of Purgatory ; Of the Merit of good Works ; The Popes Indulgences , and his prodigious Grants of Pardons ; The prohibition of Marriage to Priests ; Their many Spiritual Fraternities , &c. But I must not take liberty to enlarge here ; for innumerable are the Ways and Methods of the Papacy , and that are interwoven with the Popish Religion , for scraping together the Wealth of the World : So notoriously guilty is that Church of the crime which S. Paul charged the Seducers with , Tit. I. II. viz. Teaching things that they ought not , for filthy lucres sake . She hath infinitely out-done all Societies and Bodies of men that ever were in the World in the Politick Trade of Grasping and Accumulating Riches ; and that ( which makes it far the more abominable ) varnisht over with a Form and mighty shew of Godliness ; though in the mean time She sticks at no means , though never so unrighteous and abominably wicked , to accomplish her End. The Sect of the Pharisees , her famous Predecessors , Who made long Prayers to devour Widows houses , were in comparison of Her very silly Novices at this Artifice , and sorry Bunglers . Which should I make out by proceeding to Enumerate the rest of the Particulars ( as hath been now intimated ) I should hardly know where to make an End. Then , for the Lust of Vncleanness , what greater encouragement can a Beastly Creature have to give it its full Swinge and Liberty , than Holy Church gives him ? As also what dangerous and next to unavoidable snares doth she lay in the way of those mens Chastity , who would be glad to live honestly ? As to the Encouragement she gives to the satisfaction of this Lust , what can be greater than to make simple Fornication a Venial Sin ? That is , in the Popish sence of that phrase , a mere Peccadillo ; all of which kind put together , Bellarmin will tell you , cannot equal one Mortal Sin , nor destroy Charity : Nor deprive us of Gods favour , etiamsi nullum pactum esset de Remissione , although there were no Covenant of Grace . And whereas it will be replied , that though such sins expose not to the torments of Hell , yet they do to those of Purgatory , which are sufficient to scare a man from them , and particularly from this of Fornication : I add this as another great Encouragement to the commission of it , viz. The exceeding light Penances that are ordinarily imposed for it , such as going a little way bare●●●● ; A little piece of Money ; So often Repeating so many Prayers , &c. But can there be greater Encouragement given , than his Holiness his not bare Connivence at , but Toleration of publick Stews or Bawdy-houses even at his own door , and Sharing with them in their wicked Gains ? Nay , Chemnitius tells us ( for which he quotes the Authority of Sleidan ) that the Popes Legat himself had lately in a publick Writing , both defended in his own behalf , and commended to others that horrid Wickedness for which Sodom with the neighbouring Cities was destroyed by Fire . In short , there is a thousand times greater discouragement given in and by the Church of Rome to Holy Wedlock ( the special means appointed by God for the preservation of Chastity ) than to Vncleanness of what kind soever , and even the most Vnnatural , as might largely be shewed . The Holy Fathers of the Council of Trent have the impudence to oppose Chastity to Matrimony , in their Ninth Canon of the Eighth Session . Which leads me to shew likewise what Snares are laid by that Church , and what next to invincible Temptations to the sin of Uncleanness she exposeth innumerable People to . As imposing Vows of perpetual single Life upon all Priests , Monks , Friers and Nuns , most of which live idly and fare plentifully ; And giving the Priests the most inviting Opportunities for the commission of Fornication and Adultery that can be : There being not a Female of ripe years but is obliged once a year at least to be alone with a Priest for Auricular Confession . And whensoever they please to apply themselves to them upon that pretence , 't is a Sin for Parents , Husbands , &c. to prohibit them : By which means there is no sort of men scarcely in all Christendom so infamous for Filthiness as the Popish Priests : And what a snare their Example must necessarily be to the Laity , I need not say . I might instance in other high provocations to Lust and Wantonness which the Clergy and Laity of that Church must thank her for . As her excessive number of Holy days , whereon the Laity at least must be idle whether they will or no. And which , considering how they are observed as well within the Church as out of it , do generally not at all serve the purposes of Religion ; and , considering the Liberty that is allowed , are only opportunities for making provision for the flesh to fulfil it in the Lusts thereof . And as for the Carnivals , the business of them is to commit all manner of Wickedness with greediness , and with the greatest Secrecy and Security . And therefore I need not distinctly shew what Liberty that Church gives to the Sin of Intemperance , the highest provocative to Lasciviousness . Lastly , For that of the grossest Injustice and Vnrighteousness , no men in the world have such Encouragement to make no bones of it as have the Children of the Church of Rome : Diverse of whose Practices and Principles are exactly fitted for so Execrable a Design , as the extirpating out of mens Minds all sense of Justice or Common Honesty . As particularly , the Pope's claiming a Power to dispense with the most Solemn Oaths , and frequent exercise of that Power in Absolving Subjects from their Allegiance to Heretical Princes , and otherwise : That truly Catholick principle , that Faith is not to be kept with Hereticks ; which a Council of Constance put in practice upon poor Iohn Husse : The Doctrine of Equivocation and Mental Reservation , which takes away all Security and Confidence in one anothers words , and tends to the destruction of Humane Society . This Doctrine is not proper to the Iesuits , but ( as Father Parsons saith in his Treatise tending to Mitigation ) hath been received in the Roman Church for Four hundred years . And if you take in the professed Principles of that their most Renowned Order , which improve that Doctrine so far , as in some cases , but especially in those wherein their Religion is concerned , to make it Lawful or at least Venial , to back Equivocations with Sacred Oaths , and horrible Imprecations ; and that before a Court of Judicature ( at least if it consists of Hereticks ) of the practising upon which we have had among our selves of late most Amazing Instances : If , I say , you take in these principles ( which are now collected out of their Books into Pamphlets , and exposed to the View of every Body ) as also those very many other , which are to be seen in the Iesuits Morals , you will say that should we rake Hell for Doctrines to make men Devils , there can none be found more Effectual for the purpose than those wherewith we are furnished by the Church of Rome . And so much shall suffice to be spoken to the First Particular , viz. That Popery tendeth as much as is possible to the debauching our Souls , by bringing them into subjection to Vile Affections ; in discoursing on which we have studied to be as brief as can be . Secondly , Popery no less tendeth to Disquiet mens Minds with certain troublesom and tormenting Passions . We have shewed in the First Section , that all Corrupt Affections ( and therefore the forementioned , to which all may be reduced ) are of a very tormenting nature : In saying therefore now that Popery tends to disquiet men with certain troublesom Passions , I design a distinct head of Discourse , viz. That the better and wiser any man of that Religion is , the more will his Mind be disturbed by a many Points thereof ; particularly with Fear , Shame , Anxiety and Solicitude : And First , For the Passion of Fear , what can so excite this , or make a man so much a Slave to it , as the Popish Doctrine of Purgatory ? Whosoever doth really believe that there is a life after this , must needs be more or less solicitous about his state in that life ; and according to the degrees of that his Faith , will his solicitude be greater or less . Now the belief of that Doctrine must necessarily be accompanied with great fear of Death ; which , as the Apostle saith , makes those who are under the power of it all their life-time subject to Bondage . For , as the pains of Purgatory are taught to be so dreadful and terrible as to equallize those of Hell , except onely in the duration of them ( and how long each particular person may lie there before he be released , whether scores or hundreds of years , as also what degrees of Torment shall be allotted to him , is the greatest uncertainty ) so no man can have any rational assurance , let him lead never so strictly holy a life , of escaping this place of Torment ; No nor the least hope neither from such a life , if it be short of absolute Perfection , as whose is not ? And as for the Efficacy of Penances and Indulgences , it is impossible for any one who ever thinks seriously about the concerns of his Soul , and understands any thing of Religion , at least not to be full of diffidence what it may amount to . Those are such monstrous Cheats , the former for the most part of them , and the latter all of them , that such as are not much short of Brutes for Folly , or of Devils for Wickedness , can never be so blinded as to promise to themselves the least benefit or advantage from them , and much less that which is promised by the Pope and the Priests . Again , what a Slavish Fear and Dread of God , as a Revengeful Being , must needs possess the Minds of those who have imbibed the Church of Rome's Doctrine concerning Whippings and Scourgings , and other severe Penances ? viz. That they are necessary not onely for Mortification , but likewise for Satisfaction , in the Popish sence of that word . But what a Spirit of Bondage are they under then from Dread of God's Vengeance , in believing ( as they are bound ) that God will not Remit the punishment of Sin where the Guilt of it is washed away with the Bloud of Christ , upon the performance of the conditions of the New Covenant ( which is as Nonsensical as False ) that he will not Remit it , I say , to such , so far as to excuse them from intolerable Temporary Torments in the other World , except he hath other satisfaction given him in this life by themselves ; nor from Torments of a Vastly long duration , except it be given him by others after their decease ? Their Church is so well aware , with what horrible Dread and Fear this Doctrine must necessarily affect poor credulous Fools , that she hath invented it for that very reason ; because by this means she brings them into the most Slavish subjection , makes her self Mistress of their Purses , and is enabled to have her fill of Tyranny over their Consciences , their Souls and Bodies . What tongue can express the Devilishness of such Practices ! Next for the Passion of Shame ; The necessity of all People's of both Sexes Confessing to the Priest , which is enjoyned by the Council of Trent to be done once a year at least , and that of all their Actual sins , and not onely so , but also of all their purposes and desires to commit them , nay , and inclinations too ; what violence is hereby done to the Modesty of all such as have not arrived to the height of impudence ? This is ( to use the words of the Learned Doctor More ) as if all the modest Maids and grave Matrons in the Parish should strip themselves stark naked , and in that manner humble themselves before their Priest once a year : Which would look like a piece of unsupportable Tyranny . And yet ( as he proceeds ) this extorted Confession upon pain of Damnation not to conceal any thing , is not the stripping of a man to his naked body , but the stripping him of his body , that they may see his naked Heart , and so by the force of this Superstition break into those secrets , which it is onely the due priviledge of God Almighty to be acquainted with , &c. And Lastly , What Anxiety and Solicitude must those Papists minds needs be tormented with , who are at all concerned about their Eternal State , by reason of these following Doctrines , viz. That of the Dependence of the Efficacy of Sacraments upon the Priests intention : That of Confession now mentioned , decreed in the Trent Canons , viz. That the Penitent must not onely confess every Mortal sin , which after the strictest search he can call to mind , but even his particular sinful thoughts , his secret desires , and every circumstance which changeth the nature of the sin : And that of their distinction of sins into Mortal and Venial ; to pass by many others . As for the First of these , That known Doctrine of the Dependence of the Efficacy of Sacraments upon the Priests intention : Such as Baptism ; the Lords Supper ; Absolution , which is a grand Popish Sacrament , &c. Can it be other than a great disturbance and distraction to a considering person , whether there be any dash of Melancholy in his Temper or no , to think with himself thus : What if after all my care and all my expence , the Priest should either from a principle of Malice or non-advertency not direct his Intention as he ought to do ? Then , if I am not remedilesly damned , I am at least in eminent danger of damnation . But then as to the Second relating to Confession ; This ushers in this perplexing difficulty , viz. How shall I in enquiring after my particular sins , in deed , word and thought , assure my self that I have used my utmost diligence ? Which if I have not done , my Absolution will signifie nothing to me . And as to Confessing the Circumstances of sins , the Questions and Scruples which naturally arise from thence are too many to be recited . But I 'le transcribe some passages of the Learned Bishop Taylor ' s , concerning Auricular Confession , which are greatly to our present purpose . Saith he in his Disswasive from Popery , the First Part , How this can be safely done , and who is sufficient for these things , and who can tell his Circumstances without tempting his Confessor , or betraying and defaming another person ( which is forbidden ) and in what cases it may be done , and in what cases omitted ; and whether the Confession be valid upon infinite other Considerations , and whether it be to be repeated in whole or in part , and how often , and how much ? These things are so uncertain , casual and contingent , and so many cases are multiplied upon every one of these ; and these so disputed by their greatest Doctors , by Thomas and Scotus , and all the School-men , and by the Casuists ; that , as Beatus Rhenanus complains , it was truly observed by the famous John Geilerius , that according to their Cases , Enquiries and Conclusions , it is impossible for any man to make a right Confession . And thus he concludes that Section : So that although the shame of private Confession be very tolerable and easie , yet the Cases and Scruples which they have introduced , are neither easie nor tolerable . And though , as it is now used , there be but little in it to restrain sin , yet there is very much danger of encreasing it , and of receiving no benefit by it . But yet for all this , the Trent Gentlemen in the fore-cited Session and Chapter , call it an impious thing to say that this their Auricular Confession is Carnificina Conscientiarum , a Racking and Torturing of Peoples Consciences . But it would be a wonder if the greatest Wickedness should be unaccompanied with the most shameless impudence . As for the Third Doctrine I named , viz. That of their distinction of Sins into Mortal and Venial ( that is , in their own nature so ) the intanglements it brings men into are inextricable . For they cannot be satisfied from their Casuists what Sins are Venial and what are not so , in very many instances . And much less can they distinguish between the greatest Venial Sins and the least Mortal ones . Now , considering this little that hath been said , as the Apostle saith , 2 Cor. 3. 17. Where the Spirit of the Lord is ( or the true Spirit of Christianity ) there is Liberty , so may we say , Where the Spirit of Popery is , there is Slavery ; much worse than Egyptian Slavery . No Papist who is disposed to be Devout and Religious can be better than a poor Superstitious Creature : Nor can scarcely serve God after a better sort than a Turkish Slave doth his cruel Patron ; or than the poor Indians Worship the Devil . But that those of them who make Conscience of their ways , and are Religiously inclined are not beholden to their Popery for being so , will be fully made to appear in the next Chapter . CHAP. XVIII . The Third Particular discoursed on , viz. That the Admirable Method our Lord hath taken to Instate us in our Christian Liberty , is made lamentably Ineffectual by Popery . This shewed as to each of those four Particulars that Method consists of . The Second Head briefly spoken to , viz. That Popery is also the greatest Enemy to that Liberty Christ purchased for the Jews in Particular . A Pathetical Exhortation to a higher valuing of the Priviledges we enjoy in the Church of England concludes the Chapter . THirdly , The Admirable course and Method which our Lord hath taken to instate us in our Christian Liberty is made lamentably Ineffectual by Popery , For , First , Whereas we have shewed , that He hath fully informed us concerning all the parts and particulars of our Liberty , what can the Romish Church do more than she doth to keep men in Ignorance of them ? The Holy Scriptures ( as hath been said ) She hath locked up : And though ( as that excellent Gentleman Sir Edwyn Sandys saith ) as well to beat back the irksome out-cries of their Adversaries , as to give some content and satisfaction to their own , that they might not think them so terribly afraid of the Bible , they were content to let it be translated by some of their Favourers into the Vulgar , as also some number of Copies to be saleable a-while at the beginning ; yet since , having hushed that former clamour , and made better provision for the Establishment of their Kingdom , they have called all Vulgar Bibles straitly in again , yea the very Psalms of David , which their famous Preacher , Bishop Panigarola translated , as doubting else the unavoidableness of those former inconveniences . And such base , blasphemous Reflections upon the Holy Scriptures have been published , both from their Pulpits and Presses , as speak them exceedingly dangerous by reason of their extreme obscurity , even in points necessary to Salvation ( though the Apostle saith , If our Gospel be hid , it is hid to them that are lost ) as well as not worth the reading , as being fitted to serve all turns , a dead letter , and at best an insufficient Rule , and not signifying any thing unaccompanied with their paltry Traditions ; though S. Paul saith , The Scriptures are able to make us wise to Salvation . Nor do their Preachers make any great amends for this intolerable abuse ; for , as they are too generally most sottishly ignorant , and know little more of the Scriptures than the poor people , so the most Knowing of them for the most part stuff their Sermons with Legends and Idle tales , make as little use of Scripture as they can , and feed their Flocks with sorry Trash , nay , with rank Poison mingled with the sincere milk of the Word , and the Saving Doctrines of the Gospel . Secondly , Whereas we have shewn , that our Lord hath furnisht us with the most potent Means for the gaining of our Christian Liberty , this Church hath also taken a course to make these unsuccessful We will instance in some of them . As for that of Believing himself to be the Son of God , &c. we need add nothing to what hath been said to shew how little she befriends it , in that she makes her own Authority the onely foundation of that Belief . That of Hearing his Word , we have now seen how Ineffectual she makes it . That of Prayer she makes so as much as she can , both by her foresaid Doctrine of the Non-necessity of imploying the Mind therein , and her suitable Practice of enjoyning the Reading of Prayers in an unknown Tongue : As also by defiling them with Superstitious Rites , and even gross Idolatry : And by joyning many Mediators with Iesus Christ. That of the Observation of the Lords day , for which we have uninterrupted Tradition from the Apostles times , she hath made as effectual to the business 't is designed for , as the rest of her Holy-days . That of Denying our sensitive Appetites , she is a wonderful Friend to , as appears by the foresaid Doctrine concerning simple Fornication , and the forementioned Liberty she allows , and the Indulgences her Popes have granted . And lastly , Those of the Sacraments , how unserviceable hath she made them to their intended End , by her Doctrines of opus operatum , and of making their Efficacy dependent on the Priests Intention : And that of the Lords Supper , by Robbing the People of half , and converting the whole by her prodigious Doctrine of Transubstantiation into the most Shameful Idolatry ; and by her , Doctrine of the Sacrifice of the Mass into a daily Crucifying our Lord afresh , and putting him again to an open shame . Thirdly , Whereas we have shewed that our Lord hath purchased for us a rich supply of Grace , to enable us to use these and the like Means with happy success , I need not say what an Enemy Popery is to this Grace and the Efficaciousness thereof , having now shewn what an Enemy it is to these Means . Fourthly , Whereas we have likewise presented several most powerful Motives , which our Lord hath given us to prevail with our Wills to comply with this Grace , Popery is apt greatly to weaken and deaden every one of them to all its Proselytes . As for instance , 1. That of the Vnconceiveable Love of God , expressed in sending his onely Begotten Son upon the Errand of our Deliverance , &c. Wherein we said are implied two wonderfully exciting Motives to comply heartily with the Method Christ hath taken to set us free from the Dominion of Sin , viz. First , Gods extremest Hatred of Sin , in that he would not propose Terms of Reconciliation to Sinners without the intervention of such a Sacrifice as that of his Dear Son. Secondly , His as wonderful love to Sinners . Now as to the former of these two Motives , what influence can it have upon those who are made to believe that a company of little sleight Penances will satisfie for great and enormous Crimes ? Can they think that God doth account Sin so heinous and intolerable an evil , when they presume Him so willing to be reconciled to great Sinners upon the most easie terms and conditions ? The foresaid Gentleman , who was conversant among them , tells us , that their Penance doth ordinarily consist but in Ave Maries and Pater Nosters , with some easie Alms to them that are able , and some little Fasting to such as are willing . And that he himself hath known , when the Penance for Horrible Blasphemy , and that frequent too , besides much other lewdness , hath been but the bare saying of their Beads thrice over ; which in Italy ( such good Husbands are they ) hinders no business , but ( as he also observes ) they dispatch their Beads as they walk the Streets , or rid business at home , making it two lips and one fingers work . But were the Penance imposed by the Priests never so sharp , he shews that the Fathers plenary Pardon sweeps all away at a blow . And that of these they have granted ( especially the Pope that lived in his time ) so huge a number , that he believed there were few Churches of note in Italy , which had not purchased or procured a perpetual plenary Indulgence , by virtue whereof whosoever at certain days being Confessed , and , having Communicated , pours out his Devotions at some Altar in that Church , or gives Alms to the behoof thereof , had forthwith free Remission of all sin and punishment . Which , I say , is the most effectual course that can be devised to make people think , that the greatest sins are no greater evil in God's than they are in their own account . And then as to the latter Motive , how is the Love of God to sinners lessened by this Doctrine of theirs , viz. That by the Sufferings of Christ true Penitents are indeed delivered from Hell , but not from the direful pains of Purgatory , which ( as was said ) may be equal in all respects to those of Hell , except in the duration of them ; which yet may endure too for many Ages , but that they have invented means to shorten them . And their eaking out the satisfaction which Christ hath made to the Divine Justice for sinners , with satisfactions of their own making , doth also not a little disparage his and his Fathers love in what he hath suffered in their behalf . 2. As to the Motive of Christ's Admirable Example , we have shewed of what little Efficacy this is made by the Vile Examples of his Vicars and Vicegerents , and their Spiritual Guides . Whereunto I will add this passage of the said Sir Edwin's , That the Iniquity of their Chief See hath been so exorbitant , as to have raised amidst themselves this Proverb or saying , That the worst Christians of Italy are the Romans , of the Romans the Priests are Wickedest , the Lewdest Priests are preferred to be Cardinals , and the baddest Man among the Cardinals is preferred to be Pope . 3. As for this Motive , viz. The assurance Christ hath given us , that he will not take such advantage of our Frailties as to cast us off for them . it is even quite taken away by their Doctrine of even Venial Sins being so severely punisht in Purgatory . 4. For that of our Saviour's Mediation and Intercession , what a little Motive have they made it , by making so many Co-Mediators with Iesus Christ , as if his Mediation were far from sufficient . And nothing hath been more observed than that for one Pater Noster , they say very many Ave Maries . And the Virgin Mother of God ( as they call her ) is Caressed after that rate by them , that 't is scarcely uncharitable to suspect that they lay far more stress upon her's than upon her Son's Merits . Lastly , To joyn together the Motives of the Glorious Reward promised to the subduing of Corrupt Affections , and the most Dismal Punishment those are threatned with who gratisie them , it appears abundantly from what hath been already said , that they have made these exceedingly weak and insignificant . But that one Doctrine is enough to do it alone , which we find backt with the Authority of the Council of Trent , viz. That Imperfect Contrition , or Attrition , although by it self it cannot bring a sinner to Iustification , without the Sacrament of Penance ; nevertheless it disposeth him for the obtaining of the Grace of God in that Sacrament . Now they tell you immediately before what they mean by Attrition , viz. A sorrow for Sin , arising either from the consideration of its turpitude , or from the fear of Hell , ( not from both together , but from either ) excluding a will to Sin for the future , and accompanied with the hope of Pardon . Now who can find it difficult to be affected with sorrow for his Sins , for fear of Hell , and to be willing to leave off to sin , when he sees Death approaching , and he can sin no longer ? And then a Priest being at hand to apply the Sacrament of Penance , according to this sweet Doctrine , the most profligate sinners work is done for the other World. And therefore what need any man put himself to the trouble of subduing his Lusts , and a holy life , seeing all that 's necessary to Eternal Salvation may be dispatcht on the Death-bed ? If it be said , that no man can be certain that he shall have any time of sickness before death , or that he shall not be cut off in a Moment , as many are , or that he shall be compos mentis , and have the use of Reason in his Sickness , and therefore 't is a mad thing to put off the great work of Saving a man's Soul to the very last : I say , if this be said , the Answer is easie , that seeing there 's scarcely one in some hundreds but hath at some time or other the use of his Intellectuals upon his Death-bed , and so very few comparatively die without some warning , there is no doubt of it , but a hardned sinner will put those things to the Venture , when once he hath drunk down the comfortable Cordial which is prepared for him by his Spiritual Physicians , and that by a General Council of them too , which never fails of being Infallible . And thus we have seen how wofully mischievous Popery is in making as ineffectual as can be the most admirable Method our Lord hath pitcht upon for the setting us Free from the Power of Sin. Which Argument I have been the more brief upon , because I have already discoursed upon it in the Design of Christianity . Secondly , It remains to be shewn what an Enemy Popery is to that Liberty which our Saviour purchased for the Iews particularly . The Church of Rome hath laid on a far more intolerable Burden of Ceremonies and Ritual Observances than that which our Saviour took off their shoulders . Which , as they fall not short of the Iewish ones in number , ( nay I may say do much exceed them ) so they are ( to say nothing how grosly Superstitious many of them are , and some as Idolatrous ) for the most part so odd and uncouth , so childish and ridiculous , so vain and garish , as that it is not conceivable how truly Devout and Serious people should stoop so low as to give their Minds to them , and not lose their Seriousness and Devoutness . The ill influence which the Mosaical Ordinances had by accident , and through their own default upon the Minds of the Iews , these must naturally have , and a far worse , upon the Minds of Papists . It would be an endless piece of work to discourse of them particularly , and I shall onely refer the Reader to the Seventeenth , Eighteenth , and Nineteenth Chapters of the several times quoted Mystery of Iniquity . Nor will I add any thing farther of mine own upon this Unpleasant subject , but set down what Sir Edwyn Sandys hath acquainted us with from his own Observation . Saith he , To omit the endless multitude of Superstitions and Ceremonies of the Church of Rome , enough to take up a great part of a mans life to gaze on and to peruse ; being neither Vniform in all places , as some would pretend , but different in divers Countries : An huge sort of them are so childish also and unsavoury , that , as they argue great silliness and rawness in their Inventors , so can they naturally bring no other than disgrace and contempt to those exercises of Religion wherein they are stirring . Nor can I forbear to add the following large Citation from the same Author , in the Conclusion of this Discourse , of the infinite injury that is done by Popery to Christian Liberty : Viz. The particular ways they hold to Ravish all Affections and to fit each Humour , are well nigh infinite : There being not any thing either Sacred or Prophane , no Virtue nor Vice almost , nothing of how contrary condition soever , which they make not in some sort to serve that turn ; that each Fancy may be satisfied , and each Appetite find what to feed on . Whatsoever either Wealth can sway with the Lovers , or Voluntary Poverty with the Despisers of the World ; What Honour with the Ambitious , what Obedience with the Humble ; What great Employment with Stirring and metall'd Spirits ; What perpetual Quiet with Heavy and Restive Bodies ; What Content the Pleasant Nature can take in Pastimes and Iollity ; What contrariwise the Austere Mind in Discipline and Rigour ; What Love either Chastity can raise in the Pure , or Voluptuousness in the Dissolute , &c. What with the Hopeful Prerogative of Reward can work ; What Errors , Doubts and Dangers with the Fearful , &c. What Pardons with the Faulty , or Supplies with the Defective ; What Miracles with the Credulous ; What Visions with the Fantastical ; What Gorgiousness of Shews with the Vulgar and Simple ; What multitude of Ceremonies with the Superstitious and Ignorant ; What Prayer with the Devout ; What with the Charitable works of Piety ; What Rules of higher Perfection with Elevated Affections ; What Dispensing with Breach of all Rules with men of Lawless Conditions : In summ , what thing soever can prevail with any man , either for himself to pursue , or at leastwise to love , reverence or honour in another , the same is found with them , not as in other places of the World by Casualty blended without Order , and of necessity ; but sorted in great part into several Professions , &c. What Pomp , what Riot to that of their Cardinals ? What Severity of life comparable to their Hermits and Capuchins ? Who wealthier than their Prelates ? Who poorer by Vow and Profession than their Mendicants ? On the one side of the Street a Cloister of Virgins , on the other a Stye of Courtizans with publick Toleration . This day all in Masks with all looseness and foolery , to morrow all in Processions , whipping themselves till the bloud follows . On one door an Excommunication throwing to Hell all Transgressors , on another a Iubilee or full Discharge from all Transgressions , &c. What Pride equal to the Pope's , making Kings to kiss his Pantafle ? What Humility greater than his , shriving himself daily on his knees to an ordinary Priest ? &c. Where greater Rigour in the World in acting the Observation of the Church Laws ? Where less care or Conscience of the Commandments of God ? To taste Flesh on a Friday , where suspicion might fasten , were a matter for the Inquisition ; Whereas on the other side the Sunday is one of their greatest Market-days . To conclude , never State , never Government in the World so strangely compacted of infinite Contrarieties , all tending to entertain the several Humours of all men , and to work what kind of Effects soever they shall desire , &c. So that where is mad Licentiousness more countenanced in the whole World than it is by this Church ? And where are poor Mortals made such miserable Slaves as She makes them ? And consequently , how can there be a greater Enemy than the Romish Church is , to that which we have proved to be the true , and most Excellent Liberty ? And now is it possible , that after the reading of the foregoing Account of the unsupportably Tyranny , the intolerably Corrupt Principles and most Abominable Practices of the Church of Rome , we should not be very greatly affected with the Priviledges we enjoy in the Church of England ? And with the infinite Goodness of God to us in giving us our Birth and Education in a Church which affords us all the Advantages of which that Church , like a cruel Step-Mother , robs her Children ? We live in a Church which lays before us the Scripture Arguments for our Confirmati●n in the Christian Faith ; which obligeth us to receive the Faith of Christ upon the self-same Grounds and Motives that are proposed by our Saviour and his Apostles , and upon no other . We live in a Church which not onely gives us free leave , but likewise enjoyns us to read the Holy Scriptures , and deprives us of no part of them . We live in a Church which requires us to receive nothing as an Article of Faith upon her bare Authority ; that assumes nothing of In●allibility to her self , but freely gives us the Liberty of trying all things : That imposeth nothing upon our Belief or Practice as necessary to Salvation , but what is in the plainest and most express terms to be found in the Bible : That makes the Scriptures a complete Rule of Faith , and adds not one syllable of her own to supply their defect : That takes no Liberty in her Constitutions , but such as she believes to be agreeable to the General Apostolical Rules of doing all things decently and in order , and to Edification ; and imposeth these not as of Divine Institution , or as necessary in their own nature , but onely as Expedient for the more solemn , grave and decorous Management of the Publick Worship of God : This being left by Christ and his Apostles to the Prudence of the Governours of each particular Church . We live in a Church which Abominates the Worship of God by Images , allows no Prayers to Saints or Angels , but onely to the true God by the alone Mediation of our Lord Iesus Christ. We live in a Church which renounceth all Merit of good Works , and teacheth us to expect Salvation onely for the sake of Iesus Christ , and through his Righteousness ; but gives not the least countenance to Licentious practices , or Remissness in good Works ; and teacheth the absolute necessity of purging our selves by the Assistance of the Divine Grace from all Filthiness both of Flesh and Spirit , in order to our being made capable of God's Complacential love here , and Glory hereafter . Lastly , ( whereas I might be exceedingly large upon this subject ) we live in a Church wherein we want no necessary help for the building us up in our most holy Faith , or our having the Design of our Saviour's Religion happily effected in us ; namely , the Reformation of our Lives , and our being Renewed after the Image of God , which consisteth in Righteousness and true Holiness . O that at length we could become more eflectually sensible of the blessed priviledges the Divine Goodness vouchsafeth to us of the Church of England , lest we be made to Prize them by the Loss of them : Lest our general monstrous Ingratitude , and lamentable Unprofitableness under them ; and the Wantonness , Peevishness , and Causless Separation of Multitudes from the Communion of this Church , provoke the Divine Majesty to put our Necks once more under the Iron Yoke of those Tyrants , which made such Vassals of our Fore-fathers . If that dismal day should again come ( as God grant it may not ) with what Sorrow and Grief of Soul shall we reflect upon our neglecting and despising such happy Opportunities as we now enjoy ? What would we not then gladly part with to regain them , when we are deprived of them ? And O that our several divided Parties were capable of being perswaded to consider Sedately and Seriously before it be too late , what their Gain will be by the Fall of our Chuch , when themselves and their Religion lie buried together in her Ruines . CHAP. XIX . The Fourth Inference , That he onely is a true Christian , that looks upon himself as obliged to be no less Watchful over his Heart and the frame and temper of his Mind , than over his Life and Conversation . I Shall now return to more immediately practical discourse , for what remains of this Treatise , which is far more pleasing to my self than that I have been employed in for several of the past Chapters ; as necessary and seasonable as that is also . Fourthly , From our Notion of Christian Liberty this is another manifest Inference , viz. That a true Christian is one that looks upon himself as obliged to be no less watchful over his Heart , than over his Life and Conversation ; to take as great care to cleanse the inside of the Cup and Platter ( to use our Saviour's expression ) as the outside ; to be as vigilant over his Affections , as over his outward Behaviour ; to be as Solicitous about purging himself from all immoderate Love of the things of this World , as about procuring them by warrantable and lawful means . The true Christian makes as much Conscience of Lusting after a Woman and cherishing impure thoughts , as he doth of Lascivious and Wanton Practices ; Of harbouring Revenge in his Breast , and bearing ill will to any , as of repaying Injury with injury . He needs not to be made sensible that 't is no less his duty to forgive and love his Enemies , than to forbear reviling them or doing evil to them ; that 't is as indispensably necessary to be low in his own Eyes , and to think meanly of himself , as to beware of a haughty and supercilious carriage towards others ; that he cannot more safely Covet than he can Steal his Neighbours goods ; that he is as much bound to bring his Will into subjection to the Will of God , under the severest Providences , as to forbear Murmuring , Repining and Charging of God foolishly . He who is a Christian in deed as well as in name placeth Religion in Governing his own Spirit , no less than in any External performances or forbearances of what nature soever ; in putting away from himself all Wrath , Bitterness and Sourness , no less than in abstaining from uncivil deportment towards his Brethren . This man doth not think it more necessary to do good works than to do them from a good principle : And he is as much concerned about Loving of God , as about Doing what he hath commanded him , and Forbearing what he hath forbidden him . He no less endeavours to Hate sin , than not to Commit it ; and to be in love with his duty , than to do his duty . Nay , the sincere Christian looks upon that as his greatest and most important work and business which is least in sight , which is to be done within himself ; as well knowing that if the Tree be good , its Fruit will be so also : That ( as our Saviour saith ) a corrupt tree cannot bring forth good fruit , nor a good tree evil fruit ; and that all must needs be well without him , if all be well within him : And that no outward Temptations can be forceably enough to draw him to sin , so long as there is entertained within him no treacherous Lust , that is ready to take part with them . That he to whom this Character doth not belong is no genuine Christian , is apparent , in that such a person is no Freeman . And as a great number of Texts do plainly speak the former Proposition to be true , so is it to be concluded from what hath been discoursed of the nature of Christian Liberty ; from our having demonstrated that it consisteth in deliverance from all Inslaving Lusts , and in having all obstacles taken out of the way to our complete complying with the Laws of Righteousness and Goodness . CHAP. XX. The Last Inference . Viz. That the most Proper and Genuine Christian Obedience is that which hath most of Liberty in it ; namely , that which proceeds from the Principle of Love to God and Goodness . FIfthly and Lastly , I infer from our discourse of Christian Liberty what is the most Proper and Genuine Christian Obedience ; Surely that which hath most of Liberty in it ; that Obedience which is most free and least forced : That which springs from an Inward Living Principle , and is not merely occasioned by the consideration of External Motives and Arguments . And then doth a man act from an Inward Principle of Life , when he acts from the love of God and Goodness . There is scarcely any distinction betwixt these two , for to love God , that is , as God , is to be inamoured primarily with his most Beautiful and Amiable Perfections of Righteousness , Purity , Beneficence and Mercy ; all which may properly be expressed by that one Excellent word GOODNESS . I say to love God as God is to be in love with these Perfections primarily , and to love His Person upon the account of them , if it be lawful to distinguish them , and abstract His Person from His Perfections . But those do most truly conceive of that Incomprehensible Being , who make no such Abstraction , but describe Him by calling Him Infinite Righteousness and Purity , Bounty and Mercy , Wisdom and Power , &c. rather than a Being in whom are all these Perfections : For they are not so properly said to be in God , as to be God Himself . Thus limited that Maxim of the Schools is indisputably true , viz. Quicquid est in Deo est ipse Deus : Whatsoever is in God is God himself . So that I say , to love God and to love Goodness as such do amount to the same thing : To love God not because Good in himself , but because Good and Kind to me , is more self-love than a love of God. A Wicked man may thus love God , for as the Wise man observes , that every man is a friend to him that giveth gifts , so is he especially to him that bestoweth gifts upon himself ; the very Brutes are so , and he is more a Devil than a Man that is not so . Publicans and Sinners , our Saviour saith , do love those who love them , and the more a man loves himself the more will he be inclined to love his Benefactors and best Friends as such . Now ( as I said ) that is the most Free , and consequently the most Christian Obedience which ariseth from an Inward lively sense of the Beauty and Amiableness of Goodness , of the Christian Virtues and Graces , which are all so many Rays of and Emanations from the Divine Goodness , and therefore those who are indued with them are said to be partakers of a Divine nature : And when we act from this Principle we act from a New nature , and I need not say that no actions are so free as natural actions . Thus to do good is to do like God himself , the Freest of all Agents ; for he doth good not from External Motives , but from the Infinite Complacency he takes in Goodness it self . I am the Lord who exercise Loving kindness , Iudgment and Righteousness in the Earth , for in these things do I d●light saith the Lord , Ier. 9. 24. Which is as much as to say , therefore I am exercised in these things , because I delight in them : or , my delight in these things is the Principle whereby I am acted in the Exercise of them . Thou art Good ( saith the Psalmist ) and dost good , Psal. 119. 68. Or , because thou art Good thou dost good , and God's being Good is his Delighting in Goodness . Righteousness and Goodness are too Excellent things to be made mere means to a farther End. Who is a God like unto thee , that pardoneth Iniquity , and passeth by the Transgression of the Remnant of his Heritage , he retaineth not his anger for ever ( and why he doth not , the next words tell us ) because he Delighteth in Mercy , Mic. 7. 18. And our imitating of God and being like to him is the great design and business of our Saviour's Religion . But I would not be understood as if I affirmed that that Obedience which springs from Hope or Fear , or is excited by the consideration of Rewards and Punishments is an Obedience not becoming and unworthy of Christians : If so , I should condemn our Saviour and his Apostles for proposing such Motives . But I say , First , That the most genuinely Christian Obedience is that which proceeds from Love , from the Love of God and Goodness ; Not that Christianity doth exclude all other Motives , but this is the Chief and Principal , because it makes our Obedience most Free , and makes us most like to God in doing Good. Secondly , I say also that to do good from a Principle of love to God and Goodness , and to do it from the hope of Heaven and the fear of Hell are one and the same thing , if we have a true notion of Heaven and Hell : That is , if we conceive of the Heavenly State as that which consists in a perfect likeness to God ( as perfect as our Natures are capable of ) and a full and complete enjoyment of him ; and of the Hellish State as that which is directly opposite to the Heavenly , according to this Notion of it . Now I need not spend one minute in shewing , that to do good from the hope of such a Happiness , and from the fear of such a Misery , is to be acted by the foresaid principle of Love in so doing . Thirdly , I add , that to be acted by mere External Motives , Motives wholly Extrinsical to God and Goodness , by the ●●ar of Hell onely considered as a place of Torment , and the hope of Heaven onely considered as a place of great Pleasure and Joy , without considering the nature of that torment and the nature of that Joy , this is a low and mean Obedience , as having nothing but Self-love in it , and Self-love of the lower kind too ; and this is a forced not a free Obedience . It is a certain truth , that he who hath no sense of the inward Pulchritude and Loveliness of Virtue , and of the Deformity and Ugliness of Vice , and the Eligibleness of the former before the latter considered in themselves , and therefore would be a Wicked wretch if he were not held in by the mere hope of a Reward and fear of Punishment , though he be never so Conformable outwardly to the Laws of Christ , this man is no Christian. He is much nearer to the Kingdom of God , than he on whom Hope and Fear have no Influence to make him better , but he hath not attained to a due qualification and meetness for it . I appeal to any Father , whether he would account such a one a good Child who is mightily observant of him , if he were assured that his Obedience proceeded from no more generous Principles ; and that he would be a Rogue and a Villain but for fear of the Lash , and that he hopes for his Estate . As little reason hath our Saviour to account such Disciples of his good Christians , as we have to account such Sons of ours good Children . And from what hath now been said we learn what to think of the Principle of Gratitude ; Whether this makes that Obedience which ariseth from thence the most genuinely Christian Obedience , as it is ordinarily said it doth . If our Gratitude proceeds merely from the consideration of the Divine Bounty to our selves , taking no notice of that expressed to our Fellow-Creatures , it hath nothing but Self-love in it , and therefore is more Animal than Christian Gratitude . And consequently , I need not ask what we are to think of that Gratitude which is founded onely or chiefly upon the Peculiarity of God's love to our selves ; that wherein the Sweetest and most Indearing Consideration is this , that the Generality of Mankind are excluded from it : Truly this is a worse than mere Animal Gratitude , and speaks a Mind exceedingly destitute of that Divine ( and therefore Christian ) temper , which exerts it self in Universal good will. And I am certain that the more a Christian any man is , the higher will the Consideration of other's having a share with him in the Blessings of God advance his Gratitude . And that which doth most become us springs more from a lovely sense of the Divine Beneficence considered as largely extended , than from the Consideration of its being terminated on our own Persons or Families , or some few people besides our selves . I do not say , that the peculiarity of a Favour ought not to affect us , when it is not in our Fancy onely but in reality : But , I say , there is nothing but what is natural , ( it is impossible we should not be affected with it when we consider it ) there is nothing proper to a Christian in such a Gratitude ; and I say also , that though this Consideration , I have such a Mercy conferred upon me , which not one in a thousand is blessed with besides my self , must needs the more affect me with Joy and Gratitude ; because it makes me sensible that it was more than a thousand to one I might have missed of it too , supposing it was no fruit of my extraordinary diligence , and I did no more than others for it who went without it : Yet it would be a very Uncharitable , and therefore Wicked , thing in me to be so much the more thankful for that Mercy , because it is denied to most others . There is a Vast difference between being the more grateful for a Blessing , because , since so small a number are partakers of it , I am one of those that are ; and being so , because so small a number are partakers of it . And the more will our Gratitude have of the truly Christian Spirit , the less we abstract our selves from others in the Consideration of those obligations God hath laid upon us together with others ; and by consequence that Obedience will be most Christian-like which flows from such a Gratitude . THE CONCLUSION . NOW then , after all that hath been said upon this weighty Argument , shall we continue as negligent and cold as ever in Asserting our Liberty ? That Liberty which is infinitely most Valuable , that Liberty which sets free from the Vilest and most Intolerable Slavery , the Liberty of our Souls , and the truly Divine Liberty ? Shall that Liberty which deserves not to be named on the same day with this , be so highly set by , and can we tamely give up this ? Do men think Freedom from Bodily Slavery to be worth the Price of all they have , their Lives and all , and are we able to imagine that Freedom from Spiritual Slavery can be bought too dear ; or think much of using our most Serious Endeavours for the regaining of it ? Had the Laconick Boy , when taken Captive by a Souldier of Antigonus , so brave a Spirit as to refuse to be employed by him , in any of that drudgery which was proper to Slaves , and to prefer a Violent death before a Slavish Life , when he despaired of Redemption ? Did those Dardan Women esteem Slavery 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the most loathsom of all Evils , and so extremely Vile and Shameful a thing , as to take their dear Children and drown them in the River to prevent their being made Slaves of ? And are we of so much a baser Make than that poor Lad , and these silly Women , as Sheepishly to subject our selves to the incomparably most Vile and dishonourable Slavery ? Nay , are we so void of all Sense as to be unconcerned at the unsupportable Misery which first or last will be the unavoidable consequent thereof ? Are we Nati ad Servitutem , is Slavery so natural to us , as that we can endure to be domineered over by the most Tyrannical and Unreasonable Masters , as we have shewed our Lusts and the Devil are ? Are we so in love with the house of Bondage as to be well satisfied to make it the place of our perpetual Residence ? Are we so like Apes as to hug our Clogs , and so like Bedlams as to be fond of our Shackles ? The King of Heaven , we have heard , hath sent his onely Begotten Son upon this very Errand of Knocking off our Fetters , of proclaiming Liberty to us Captives , and opening the Prison doors unto them that are bound ; of delivering us from our Thraldom and Vassalage , and making us Free indeed , Free with the most Excellent and Noble Freedom ; and recovering those out of the snare of the Devil who are taken Captive by him at his Will ; and will we not be made Free ? Will we not exchange this worse than Egyptian Slavery for the Glorious Liberty of the Sons of God ? As God said of old to Ierusalem , Wilt thou not be made clean , when shall it once be ? So let me say to every Soul that lyeth under the Dominion of Corrupt Affections , Wilt thou not be set at Liberty , when shall it once be ? Did the Grecians when set at Liberty by Flaminius ( as Plutarch reports ) sound out , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , SAVIOVR , SAVIOVR , with such a Courage , that the Birds which flew over them fell Astonisht to the Ground ? And can we be so little Affected with what our Saviour hath done for us in order to our being rescued from that Slavery which is so much worse than theirs , as not to accept Deliverance at his hands ? Can we be so unconcerned at what King IESVS hath done for our Redemption , as to refuse to embrace his offers of it ? Have we conceived so low an opinion of the Service of God , and his Blessed Son , as to chuse to be Drudges and Vassals to most Cruel Pharaohs , rather than to be their Free-men ? Had we rather still toil in the Brick-Kilns of Egypt than inherit and possess the good Land ; the Land of Peace and Rest , Liberty and Joy ? God forbid . O that therefore we would at length be perswaded , first to accept of , and then to stand fast in the Liberty , wherewith Christ would make us free , and no more be intangled with the yoke of Bondage . Hath Christ Iesus taken such an admirable course in order to our being set free from the power of Sin , and its dismal Effects ? Then let us no longer cry out , O wretched men that we are , who shall deliver us from the body of this death ? as if we knew of no Deliverer ; but let us thank God through Iesus Christ our Lord. It hath been shewed that Christ is not so our Deliverer as to leave us nothing to do , as to bid us stand still ( as Moses did the Israelites at the Red-Sea ) and see the Salvation of God , and see what himself will do for us ; but that he doth expect we should do our part in order to our being set Free. But he hath done as much as we can reasonably desire he should do for that end , and abundantly more than could ever have entered into our hearts to imagine he would have done ; and so much that it must be now wholly long of our selves , our own inexcusable negligence , if what he hath done prove at last unsuccessful . We are too weak to deliver our selves by our own strength , by our own natural power we are utterly unable to rescue our selves from under the dominion of our Spiritual Adversaries ; but Christ hath purchased that Grace which shall be sufficient for us , if we will make a believing Application to him for it , so that we may , if it be not our own fault , be strong in the Lord and in the power of his Might ; and therefore our weakness can be no excuse . It is to be acknowledged also that we are naturally very listless and averse to the using of the means of our Deliverance , but what would we desire our Saviour to do more than he hath done to excite our Wills and quicken our Endeavours ? Nor can we plead Ignorance of the Means to be used , for we have understood how fully our Saviour and his Apostles have instructed us in these . Now hath Christ been so wonderfully concerned for our Deliverance , and can we our selves be unconcerned ? Did he pay such a Ransom and Price for us , and not think much of coming down from Heaven , of taking our Nature , of parting with his precious Bloud , and suffering inexpressible Torments in order to this great End , and can we think it unworthy of our serious Care ? What is this but to tread under foot the Son of God , and that Bloud whereby we are Redeemed ? Was ever any miserable Slave heard of that might if he would be set at Liberty , and yet refused ? Or is it imaginable that such a one could listen to any temptation whatsoever to continue in Slavery ? especially if he were promised by a Person able to make good his word , that he should exchange his Prison for a Palace , and his House of Bondage for a Kingdom ? But we have seen that no less a Motive than this is presented to us by one who cannot lie , and who is as Able as Faithful . We have the greatest Security in the World given us of a Crown of Glory , and an Everlasting Kingdom ; which infinitely surpasseth all the Crowns and Kingdoms upon Earth to perswade us to comply with that Rare , most Powerful and most Wise Method which our Lord hath taken to make us Free. What a wonderful thing is this , that our Lord should hire us to accept of Liberty , and that at such a Rate as this ! That he should have such Compassion and Love for our Souls , as , that so we may be perswaded to do that which is onely our own Interest , and infinitely our greatest Interest to do , that so we may be won upon to cease from the vilest , most filthy and most miserable Drudgery , and to Engage in his most Free and Blessed Service , he should think that he cannot make us too large Offers . That he should so strangely out-bid the Devil and our Lusts , and , that we may no longer be be●ooled by their pitiful Promises of Vanishing , Empty and False Pleasures , should proffer us such Joys , such Bliss , as to which those Pleasures , were they truly so , and never so durable , cannot bear the least proportion ▪ And , that we might no longer suffer our selves to be Insulted and Tyrannized over by them , and to be , as it were , their Footstool , he should assure us of his willingness , nay , of his great desire to advance us to his own Throne . For , as hath been said , he hath promised To grant unto him that overcometh that he shall sit with him upon his Throne , even as he also overcame , and is set down with his Father upon his Throne . He applieth himself to that Principle which is most predominant in our natures , so that if the love of himself cannot , yet the love of our own selves may even compel us to come in to his Service . But one would think we should find it no less impossible to be so Disingenuous towards our dear Lord , than to be so cruel to our selves as to slight such promises , or that his most gracious and endearing Invitation , Come unto me all ye that labour and are heavy laden , and I will give you Rest. Take my yoke upon you , and learn of me , for I am meek and lowly in heart , and ye shall find Rest to your Souls . For my yoke is easie , and my burden is light , Matth. 11. 28 , 29 , 30. But then are we able to think of it with any Patience , that Christ should Do and Suffer in our behalf so much in vain ; that we should frustrate the Design of his Astonishing Condescension in assuming our Nature , and of all he did and suffered for us ? Hath he paid so Excessively dear for us , and can we be content that after all he should lose his Purchase ? Especially since he purchased us , not because he stood in the least need of our Service , but that we might serve our selves in serving him , and be made thereby unconceivably and Everlastingly Happy . Do we not look upon the Iews as a very strange Generation of Pople , and as no less Ill-natured than Foolish , that they would not be prevailed with to accept of Deliverance from the Burdensom Services of Moses his Law ; that they should be so fond of that Servile Dispensation they were under , as to refuse to be Released from it ? Whenas the Abolishing thereof was evidenced in as full and convincing a manner as its Divine Authority before was : Nay , when that of the Gospel set up in the room of it was demonstrated in a far more glorious manner to be of God , by Christ himself before his death , by his Resurrection from the dead , and Ascension into Heaven , and by the Spirit in the Apostles and others afterward . And shall we refuse to be set at Liberty by our Saviour from the Bondage of Sin , which is infinitely more heavy and unsufferable , and the consequences of which are so sad and intolerable ? While we so do , let us never blame the Iews , and much less accuse them of being so perverse , hard-hearted and stiff-neckt a People ; for then , wherein we judge them we condemn our selves , for we that judge them do not onely the same , but a far more unaccountable thing . And think we this that so judge them that have done such a thing , and do the same and so much worse , that we shall escape the judgment of God ? Nay , are we able not to think that it shall be much more intolerable for us at the day of Judgment than for them , if we persist in so doing . We are apt to believe that no People ever deserved so ill of our Saviour as those Pharisees who ascribed his casting out Devils to the Assistance of Beelzebub the Prince of the Devils : But how much better do we think those deserve of him who will not obey him , after they have had far greater Evidence of his being the Son of God than they at that time were in a possibility of having ? And if our Saviour did accuse those of despising both Himself and his Father that sent him , who would not be perswaded by his Mighty WORKS to believe in him while he was on Earth , what a high Affront then do those put upon both , who will not give up themselves to be ruled by him , and quit the service of Satan for his service ( which is the same thing with not believing in him ) now he is in Heaven , and in all his Glory ? This he must needs take far more unkindly and hainously at our hands . And be we assured ( for nothing is more Evident ) that , as he is a most unreasonable Creature , who after such marvellous Evidence of Iesus his being the Son of God , and now sate down on the Right Hand of the Majesty on High , will not give credit to these Doctrines ; so he is much more Unreasonable who doth give credit to them , and yet behave himself as if he believed no such matter . O that therefore we would ( those of us who have hitherto neglected to do it ) before it be too late and without farther delay , Consider these things , and shew our selves Men ; and then we shall with great Courage and Resolution make use of those Weapons which the Captain of our Salvation hath put into our hands , for the Vanquishing the Enemies of our Souls ; which Weapons are not Carnal , but Mighty through God. And if we persevere in so doing , then shall those who have held such a severe hand over us fly before us ; then shall those Lords who so subjected us , and kept us under , be brought under by us , be our Subjects . Then shall our Prison-doors fly open , we shall be no longer under Restraint and Confinement . We shall be our own Men , and walk at Liberty ; We shall run and not be weary , walk and not faint , until we appear before God in Sion ; Until we are delivered from all Molestation from , as well as Dominion of Sin and Satan ; Being made by Iesus Christ , who hath loved us and washed us from our sins in his own Bloud , Kings and Priests unto God and his Father : To whom be Glory and Dominion for ever and ever . Amen . THE END . Books sold by Richard Royston , at the Sign of the Angel in Amen-Corner . THE Principles and Practices of Certain Divines of the Church of England truly Represented and Defended , &c. In a Free Discourse between two intimate Friends , viz. Theophilus and Philalethes . The Design of Christianity ; or , A plain Demonstration and Improvement of this ▪ Proposition , That the Enduing men with Inward Real Righteousness was the Ultimate End of our Saviour's Coming , &c. The Second Edition . Both of them by the Author of this Treatise . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A40082-e3390 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . Refranet prius libidines , spernat voluptates , iracundiam teneat , co●recat avaritiam , cateras animi labes repellat [ imperator ] tum incipiat aliis imperare cùm ipse improbissi●is dominis , dedecori ac turpitudini parere desicrit , dum quidem his ob●di●t . Imperator non modò , sed liber habendus omninò non erit . Si servitus sit , sicut est , obedientia fracti animi & abjecti , & arbitri● carentis suo , quis neget omnes leves , omnes cupidos , omnes denique improbos esse servos ? In his St●ical Paradoxes . Cùm Cupiditatum dominatus excessit , & alius est Dominus exortus , ex Conscientiâ Peccatorum Timor , quàm illa miscra , quam dura scrvitus ! in Stoic . Paradox ▪ Pudor nec in pessimos nec in optimos cadit . Nam qui sibi conscius est se libero suo arbitrio constanter uti ad ca quae optima sunt , novit se non debere contemni , ac proinde , omni contemptu superior , ipsumme● contemnit contemptum ; quae magna pars est Generositatis , in improbis vero summum improbitatis fastigium . Enclur . Eth. lib. 1. cap. 2. Dr. Patrick's . O Vitae Philosophiae Dux O Virtutum indagatrix , expultrixque Vitiorum ! Vnus dies benè & ex praeceptis tuis actus , peccanti immortalitati est anteponendus . Mr. Iohn Smith . Deut. 32. 4 Heb. 6. 18. Ezek. 18. 29. Rom. 2. 2. Iob 34. 23 Habak . 1. 13. Psal. 145. 17. I●m . 11● Psal. 145. 9. Ver. 8. Ezek. 33. 11. Notes for div A40082-e8710 Luke 4. 18. Eph. 6. 16. Acts 15. 9. 1 Ioh. 5. 4. The Design of Christianity . Ier. 7. 4. Iohn 17. 24. Chap. 14. 19. ver . 3. Heb. 6. 20. Iohn 17. 24. Notes for div A40082-e19780 Solus Deus est , in quem Peec●tum non cadit ; C●et●ra , cùm sint liberi Arbitrii , possunt in utramque partem suam flectere Voluntatem . Operum juga rejecta ●unt . non disciplinarum . Libertas in Christo , non fecit Innocentie Injuriam . Mannt ●extota Pictatis , Sanctitatis , Humanitatis , Veritatis , Castitatis , Iustitiae , Mi●●ricordiae , Benevolentiae , Pudicitiae . Lib. de Pudi●itia . 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . Strom. Lib. 2. p. 424. Eph. 6. 5. Instit. Theol . Lib. 3. cap. 8. p. 97. Non solùm autem per praevaricationem frustrati sunt Legem Dei , miscentes Vinum Aquâ ; sed & suam Legem è contrario statuerunt , quae usque adhuc Pharisaica vocatur . Advers . Haeres . Lib. 4. Cap. 25. p. 342. Chap. 17. Vid. Iust. Mart. Dial . cum Trypho . p. 247. Tertul . ad Scap. p. 69 : Rig. Orig. cont . C●ls . lib. 1. p. 34. 1 Cor. 2. 4. Contra Cels. lib. 1. p. 4. Edit . Spenceri . Icr. 17. 10. Rom. 13. 5. Ductor Dubitantium , Book 3 chap. 1. p 21. Edit . 1. Book 3. chap. 1. p. 23. Aquatenùs ad omne valet consequentia . Religio cogt non potest ; verbis potiùs quàm verberibus res agenda est , ut sit voluntas , lib. 5. cap. 20. See the Learned Dean of Canterburies judicious Discourse on Josh. 24. 15. Instit. Th●ol . Cap. 8. p. 241. See Doctor More 's Modest Enquiry into the Mystery of Iniquity , Book● 2. Chap. 15 , & 16. In D●●ret . Greg. Lib. 1. tit . 33. cap. 6. Bellarm. d● Amis . Grat. cap. 13. Et d● Sacram. Euchar. l. 4. c. 19 ▪ Exam. C●n. Tri● . Ses. 8. cap. 1 Vid. Chem. Exam. Con. Trid. Ses. 8. cap. ● . Chap. ● . Sess. 14. 〈◊〉 . ● . Mystery of Iniquity , p. 78. Polemical Discourses in fol. p. 316. Europe Speculum , p. 126. Edit . 1673 Europae Speculum , p. 13. Europe Speculum . p. 136 , 137 Quamv● sine Sacramento Poenitentiae [ Attritio ] per se ad Iustificationem perducere Peccatorem ●equeat ; tamen cum ad Dei gratian in Sacramento Paeniten●● impetrandum disponit . Sess. 14. Cap. 4. Chap. 17. Europ●e Speculum . p. 3. Pag. 〈◊〉 . Notes for div A40082-e41250 Phil. Iud. p. 682. Ibid. Rev. 1. 6.