The way and manner of the Reformation of the Church of England declared and justified against the clamors and objections of the opposite parties / by Peter Heylyn ... Heylyn, Peter, 1600-1662. This text is an enriched version of the TCP digital transcription A43559 of text R202431 in the English Short Title Catalog (Wing H1746). Textual changes and metadata enrichments aim at making the text more computationally tractable, easier to read, and suitable for network-based collaborative curation by amateur and professional end users from many walks of life. The text has been tokenized and linguistically annotated with MorphAdorner. The annotation includes standard spellings that support the display of a text in a standardized format that preserves archaic forms ('loveth', 'seekest'). Textual changes aim at restoring the text the author or stationer meant to publish. This text has not been fully proofread Approx. 237 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 50 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. EarlyPrint Project Evanston,IL, Notre Dame, IN, St. Louis, MO 2017 A43559 Wing H1746 ESTC R202431 12417622 ocm 12417622 61736 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A43559) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 61736) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 941:28) The way and manner of the Reformation of the Church of England declared and justified against the clamors and objections of the opposite parties / by Peter Heylyn ... Heylyn, Peter, 1600-1662. [8], 90 p. Printed by E. Cotes for Henry Seile ..., London : 1657. Reproduction of original in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York. Table of contents: p. [6]-[7] Errata: p. [8] eng Church of England -- Parties and movements. A43559 R202431 (Wing H1746). civilwar no Ecclesia vindicata: or, The Church of England justified: I. In the way and manner of her Reformation. II. In officiating by a publick liturg Heylyn, Peter 1657 41956 1259 15 0 0 0 0 304 F The rate of 304 defects per 10,000 words puts this text in the F category of texts with 100 or more defects per 10,000 words. 2002-08 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2002-10 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2002-11 Rina Kor Sampled and proofread 2002-11 Rina Kor Text and markup reviewed and edited 2002-12 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion THE WAY and MANNER OF THE REFORMATION OF THE Church of England DECLARED and JUSTIFIED : Against the Clamors and Objections of the Opposite Parties . By PETER HEYLYN , D. D. MALACH. 2. 7. Lab●a Sacerdotis custodient Sapientiam , & legem requirent ex ore ejus : quia Angelus Domini Exercituum est . Heb. 13. 17. Obey them that rule over you , and submit your selves ; for they watch for your souls , as they that must give account , that they may do it with joy and not grief . LONDON , Printed by E. Cotes for Henry Seile over against St. Dunstans Church in Fleetstreet , M.DC.LVII . TO THE READER . THe occasion which induc'd me to the writing of this Discourse hath been already touched at in our general Preface , and shall be shewn thee more at large in the following Preamble or Introduction . Let it suffice thee now to know , that it was done on an occasion really given , and not in supposition only , the better to bring in the Design which I have in hand ; and that it gave such satisfaction to the Party for whose sake it was undertaken , that it was thought fit by some to have it publisht for the Use of others . But being published by a faulty and imperfect Copy , I caus'd it presently to be call'd ●in ; not willing it should goe abroad ( though without my Name ) till it were able in some measure to defend it self , if not to justifie the Authour . Being now set upon a resolution , which God bless me me in , of vindicating this poor Church ( as far at least as in me is ) in her Forms of Worship , her Government and establisht Patrimony , together with the Times and Places destinate to her Sacred Offices ; I have thought good to place this Tractate in the Front , as a Praecognitum or necessary Manuduction unto all the rest . The way and manner of the Reformation of the Church of England declared and justified , cannot but give a good Relish unto all that follows , being no other then the Essentiall parts and branches of that Reformation . If thou art satisfied in this , it will be a faire Omen to me , that the rest may not prove unwelcome . And that thou mayst peruse it with the greater chearfulness ; I will not keep thee longer in the Entrance of it ; it being no good Husbandry to waste that Friend in petit Matters , whom we endeavour to preserve for nobler favours . And so fare thee well . The Contents of the Chapters ▪ SECT. I. THe Introduction sh●wing the Occasion , Method , and Design of the whole Discourse . pag 1. 1. Of Calling or Assembling the Convocation of the Clergie , and the Authority thereof when convened together . 3. 2. Of the Ejection of the Pope , and vesting the Supremacy in the Regal Crown . 10. 3. Of the translation of the Scriptures , and permitting them to be read in the English tongue . 13. 4. Of the Reformation of Religion in the points of Doctrine . 19. 5. Of the Reformation of the Church of England in the forms of Worship ; and the times appointed thereunto . 28. 6. Of the power of making Canons , for the well ordering of the Clergy , and the directing of the people in the publick duties of Religion . 34. 7. An Answ●● to the main Objections of either Party . 38. SECT. II. 1. That the Church of England did not innovate in the Ejection of the Pope , and setling the Supremacy in the Regal Crown . pag. 46. 2. That the Church of England might proceed to a Reformation●ithout the approbation of the Pope or the Church of Rome . 52. 3. That the Church of England might lawfully proceed to a Reformation without the help of a General Councell , or calling in the aid of the Protestant Church . 62. 4. That the Church did not innovate in translating the Scriptures and the publick Liturgie in to vulgar Tongues , and of the Consequents thereof to the Church it self . 70. 5. That the proceedings of this Church in setting out the English Liturgie were not meerly Regal ; and of the power of Soveraign Princes in Ecclesiastical affaires . 79. 6. That the Clergie lost not any of their just Rights by the Act of submission , and that the power of calling and confirming Councels did antiently bel●ng to the Christian Princes . 86. The Errata of the First Part to be thus Corrected . Pape 1. for New read Your , p. 8. r. conv●ni●ntly , p. 9. r. p●iviledged , p. 9. r. ejection , p. 11. l. 10. r. enact , p. 12. l. 22. r. final , p. 13. l. 16. to Phil. and Mary , add , yet were they all revived in the 1. of Elazabeth , p. 19. l. 19. r. Sacraments , p. 25. l. 17. r. not on it , p 30. r. Holbeck , p. 34. r. Warham . p. 56. l. 11. r. four , p. 58. l. 7. r. Canon Law , p 63. l. 27 r. come , p. 76. l. 6. dele to the Popes authority on the one side , or the other side , p. 72. l. 7. r. of it into the , p. 84. l. 22. r. formerly , p. 93. l. 23. r. continued , p. 95. l. 7. r. humble , p. 181. l. 1. r. we shall see hereafter , p. 194. l. 6. r. one new body , p. 251. l. 20. r. Nicomedia , p. 254. l. 2. r. derived , p. 258. l. 1. r. Sabbath , p. 292. l. 10. r. hint , p. 296. l. 21. r. praefantes , p. 300. l. 23. r. cure . p. 342. l. 3. dele Greek and . The Way of the Reformation of the Church of England Declared and Justified , &c. The Introduction . Shewing the Occasion , Method , and Design of the whole Discourse . My dear Hierophilus , _ 〈◊〉 company is alwaies very pleasing to me ; but you are never better welcome then when you bring your doubts and scruples along with you , for by that means you put me to the studying of some point or other , whereby I benefit my self , if not profit you . And I remember at the time of your last being with me , you seemed much scandalized for the Church of England , telling me you were well assured that her Doctrine was most true and orthodox , her Government conform to the Word of God and the best ages of the Church ; and that her publick Liturgie was an extract of the primitive Formes ; nothing in all the whole Composure but what did tend to edification and increase of piety . But for all this , you were unsatisfied ( as you said ) in the waies and means by which this Church proceeded in her Reformation , alledging , that you had heard it many times objected by some Partisans of the Church of Rome , that our Religion was meer Parliamentarian , not regulated by Synodical Meetings , or the Authority of Councels , as in elder Times ; or as Dr. Harding said long since in his Answer unto B. Iewel , That we had a Parliament Religion , a Parliament Faith , and a Parliament Gospel : To which Scultingius and some others after added , that we had none but Parliament Bishops , and a Parliament Clergy ; that you were apt enough to think that the Papists made not all this noise without some ground for it , in regard you have observed some Parliaments in these latter daies so mainly bent to catch at all occasions , whereby to manifest their power in Ecclesiastical matters , especially in constituting the new Assembly o● Divines and others . And finally , that you were heartily ashamed , that being so often choaked with these Objections , you neither knew how to traverse the Indictment , nor plead Not guilty to the Bill . Some other doubts you said you had , relating to the King ▪ the Pope , and the Protestant Churches , either too little or too much look'd after in our Reformation , but you were loth to trouble me with too much at once . And thereupon you did intreat me to bethink my self of some ●it Plaster for the Sore which did oft afflict you , religiously affirming that your desires proceeded not from curiosity , or an itch of knowledge , or out of any disaffection to the Power of Parliaments ; but me●rly ▪ from an honest zeal to the Church of England , whose credit and prosperity you did far prefer before your life , or wha●soever in this world could be dear unto you ; Adding withall , that if I would take this pains for your satisfaction , and help you out of these perplexities which you were involved in , I should not only do good service to the Church it self , but to many a wavering member of it , whom these objections had much staggered in their Resolutions . In fine , that you desired also to be in●ormed how far the Parliaments had been interessed in these alterations of Religion , which hapned in the Reign● of K. Hen. the 8. K. Edw. the 6. and Q●een Elizabeth ? what ground there was for all all this clamour of the Papists ? and whether the Houses , or either of them , have exercised of old any such Authority in matters of Ecclesiastical or Spiritual nature , as some of late have ascribed unto them ? Which though it be a dangerous and invidious subject ( as the times now are ) yet for your sake , and for the Truths , and for the honour of Parliaments , which seem to suffer much in that Popish calumny , I shall undertake it ; premising first , that I intend not to say any thing to the point of Right , whether or not the Parliament may lawfully meddle in such matters as concern Religion ; but shall apply my self wholly unto matters of Fact , a● they relate unto the Reformation here by Law established . And for my method in this businesse , I shall first lay down by way of preamble , the form of calling of the C●nvocation of the Clergy here in England , that we may see by what Authority they proceed in their Constitutions , and then declare what was acted by the Clergy in that Reformation : In which , I shall begin with the ejection of the Pope , and setling the Supremacy in the Crown Imperial of this Realm ; descending next to the Translation of the Scriptures into the English Tongue , the Reformation of the Church in Doctrinals and Formes of Worship , and to proceed unto the Power of making Canons for the well ordering of the Clergy , and the direction of the people in the Exercise of their Religion ; concluding with an An●wer to all such Objections ( by what party soever they be made ) as are most mate●ial . And in the canvassing of these points , I doubt not but it will appear unto you , that till these late busie and unfortunate Times , in which every man intrudeth on the Priestly Function , the Parliaments did nothing at all either in making Canons , or in matters Doctrinall , or in Translation of the Scriptures : next that that lit●le which they did in reference to the Formes and Times of Worship , was no more then the inflicting of some Temporal or legal penalties on such as did neglect the one , or not conform unto the other , having been first digested and agreed upon in the Clergy way : and finally that those Kings and Princes before remembred , by whose Authority the Parliaments did that little in those Formes and Times , did not act any thing in that kinde themselves , but what was warranted unto them by the word of God and the example of such godly and religious Emperors and other Christian Kings and Princes , as flourished in the happiest times of Christianity . This is the sum of my design , which I shall follow in the order before laid down : assuring you that when you shall acquaint me with your other scruples , I will endevour what I can for your satisfaction . 1. Of calling or assembling the Convocation of the Clergy , and the Authority thereof when conveen'd together . ANd in this we are first to know , that anciently the Archbishop of the several Provinces of Canterbury and York were vested with a power of Convocating the Clergy of their several and respective Provinces , when , and as often as they thought it necessary for the Churches peace . And of this power they did make use upon all extraordinary and emergent cases , either as Metropoli●ans and Primates in their several Provinces , or as Legati nati to the Popes of Rome : but ordinarily , and of common course especially after the first passing of the Acts or Statutes of Praemuniri , they did r●strain that power to the good pleasure of the Kings under whom they lived , and used it not but as the necessities and occasions of these Kings , or the distresses of the Church did require it of them ; and when it was required of them , the Writ or Pr●cept of the King was in this form following . R●x , &c. Reverendissimo in Christo Patri N. Cantuariensi Archiepiscopo totius Angliae Primati & A●ostolicae sedis L●gato salutem . Quibusdam arduis & urgentibus negotiis d●f●nsionem & securitatem Eccle●ae Anglicanae , ac pacem , tranquillitatem , & ●onum publi●um , & defensionem Regni nostri , & subditorum nostrorum ejusd● m concernentibus , Vobis in Fide & dilectione , quibus nobis tenemini , rogando mandamus , quatenus praemissis debito intuitu attentis & ponderatis universos & singul●s Episcopos vestrae Provinciae , ac Decanos & Priores 〈…〉 & non exemptos , nec non Archidiaconos , Conventus , Capitula , & Collegia totumque Clerum ●ujuslibet Dioceseos ejusdem Provinciae , ad c●nveniendum coram vobis in Ecclesia Sancti Pauli London . vel alibi , prout melius expedire videritis , cumomni celeritate accommoda modo debito Convocari faciatis ; Ad tractandum , consentiendum & conclud●ndum super praemissis & aliis quae sibi clarius proponentur , tunc & ibidem ex parte nostra . Et hoc si●ut nos & statum Regni nostri , ac honorem & utilitatem Ecclesiae praedictae diligitis , nullatenus omittatis . Teste meipso , &c. These are the very words o● the antient Writs , and are still retained in these of later Times ; but that the Ti●le of Legatus sedis Apost●licae , then used in the Archbishops stile was laid aside together with the Pope himself ; and that there is no mention in them of Abbots , Priors , and Conven●s , as being now not extant in the Church of England . And in this Writ you may observe ; first , that the calling of the Bishops and Clergy of the Province of Canterbury to a Synodical ▪ Assembly , belonged to the Arch bishop of that Province only ( the like to him of York also within the Sphere or Verge of his Jurisdiction . ) Secondly , that the nominating of the time and place for this Assembly was left to the Arch Bishops pleasure , as seemed ▪ best unto him ; though for the most part , and with reference unto themselves & the other P●elates , who were bound to attend the service of the King in Parliament , they caused these Meetings to be held at the time and place , at , and to which the Parliament was or had been called by the Kings Authority . Thirdly , That from the word Convocari used in the Writ , the Synodical meetings of the Clergy were named Convocations . And fourthly , That the Clergy thus assembled in Convocation had not only a power of treating on and consenting unto such things as should be there propounded on the Kings behalf , but a power also of concluding or not concluding on the same as they saw occasion : Not that they were restrained only to such points as the King propounded , or were proposed in his behalf to their c●nsideration ; b●t that they were to handle to his businesse with their own , wherein they had full power when once met together . In the next place we must behold what the Archbishop did in pursuance of the Kings command for calling of the Clergy of his Province to a Conv●cation , who on the receipt of the Kings Writ presently issued out his Mandate to the B●sh●p of London ( D●an by his plac● of the whole Colledge of Bishops of that Province ) ●equiring him immediately on the sight hereof ( and of the 〈…〉 and included in it ) to cite and summon all the Bishops , and other Prelates , Deans , Arch-Deacons , and capitular Bodies , with the whole Clergy of that Province , that they the said Bishops , Deans , Arch-Deacons , in their own persons , the Capitular Bodies by one Procurator , and the Clergy of each Diocess by two , do appear before him at the time and place by him appointed , and that those Procurators should be furnished with sufficient powers by those which sent them , not only to treat upon such points as 〈…〉 England , and to give their counsel in the same : sed ad consentiendum ●is quae ibidem ex com●un● delibe●a●ione ad honorem Dei & Ecclesiae in praemissis contigerint concorditer ordinari ; but also to consent both in their own names , and in the names of those who sent them , unto all such things , as by mature deliberation and consent should be there ordained . Which Mandate being received by the Bishop of London , the several Bishops cited accordingly , and intima●ion given by those Bishops u●to their Arch-Deacons for summoning the Clergy to make choice of their Procurators , as also the Chapters , or capitular Bodies , to do the like : The next work is to proceed to the choice of those Procurators . Which choice being made , the said Chapters under their common seals , and the said Clergy in a publick Writing subscribed by them , do bind themselves sub Hypotheca omnium bonorum suorum , under the pawn and forfeiture of all their goods moveable and immoveable ( I speak the very words of these publick Instruments ) se ratum , gra●um & accep●um habere quicquid dicti Procuratores sui nomine & vice suis fecerint , &c. To stand to and perform whatsoever their said Procurators , in their name and stead , shall do , determine and consent to . The like is also done in the Province of York ; but that the Arch-B. thereof sends out the summons in his own name to the suffragan Bish●ps , the Province being small , and the Suffragans not above three in number . Finally , as the Convocations of the Clergy in their several Provinces were called by the Arch-Bishops only , the Kings Writ thereunto requiring and authorizing ; so by the same powers were they also dissolved again , when they had done the business they were called about , or did desire to be dismissed to their own affairs . At which time by special Writ or Mandates to the said Arch-Bishops , expressing the calling and assembling of the Convocation by ve●tue of the former Prec●pt , it is declared , That on certain urgent causes and considerations moving his Majesty thereunto , he thought fit with the advice of his privie Councel , that the same should be again dissolved : Et ideo vobis mandamus quod eandem praesentem Convocationem hac instanti die debito mod● sine ulla dilatione dissolvatis , sive dissolvi faciatis , prout convenit ; and therefore did command them to dissolve it , or cause the same to be dissolved in the accustomed manner without delay . Which Writ received , and not before , the Convocation was dissolved accordingly : and so it holds in Law and practise to this very day . I have the longer staid on these publick Formes , partly because not obvious unto every eye ; but specially to let you see by what Authority the Clergy are to be assembled in their Convocations , and what it is which makes their Canons and Conclusions binding , unto all those which send them thither , or intrust them there . Their calling by the Kings Authority makes their meeting lawful , which else were liable to exceptions and disputes in Law , and possibly might render them obnoxious to some grievous penalties ; and so would their continuance too after the writ was issued for their Dissolution . As on the contrary their breaking or dissolving of their own accord , would make them guilty of contempt , and consequently subject to the Kings displeasure ; for being called by the Kings Writ , they are to continue till dissolved by the Kings Writ also , notwithstanding the dissolving of the Parliament , with which sometimes it might be summoned . And so it was resolved in terminis , by the chief ●udges of the Realm and others of his M●jesties Counsel learned , May 10. anno 1640. at such time as the Convocations did continue sitting , the Parliament being most unhappily dissolved on the Tuesday before , subscribed by Finch Lord Keeper of the Great Seal , Manchester then Lord privy Seal , Littleton chief ●ustice of the Common-plea● , Ban●es Atturney General , Whitfield and Heath his Majesties Sergeants , Authority enough for the poor Clergy to proceed on , though much condemned and maligned for obedience to it . [ Now as they have the Kings Authority not only for their Meeting , but continuance also ; so also have they all the power of the whole National Clergy of England , to make good whatsoever they conclude upon : the Arch-Bishops , Deans , Arch-Deacons , acting in their own capacities , the Procurators in the na●e and by the power committed to them , both by the Chapters or capitular Bodies , and the Dioces●n Clergy of both Provinces . And this they did by vertue of that power and trust alone , without any ratification or confirmation from King of Parliament , untill the 25 year of King Henry the 8. At which time they bound themselves by a Synodical Act ( whereof more hereafter ) not to enact , promulge , or ●xecute any Canons , Constitutions , or Ordinances Provincial in their C●nvocations for time coming , unlesse the King● Highness by his Royal Assent command them to make promulge , and execute the same accordingly . Before this time they acted absolutely in their Convocations of their own Authority , the King● Assent neither concurring nor required ; and by this sole Authority which they had in themselves , they did not only make Canons , declare Heresie , convict and censure persons suspected of Heresie , in which the subjects of all sorts ( whose Votes were tacitely included in the suffrages of their Pastors & spi●itual Fathers ) were concerned alike . But also to conclude , the Clergy whom they represented in the point of Property , imposing on them what they pleased , and levying it by Canons of their own enacting . And they enjoyed this power to the very day in which they tendred the submission , which before we spake of . For by this self-authority ( if I may so call it ) they imposed and levied that great Subsidie of 120000 l. ( an infinite sum as the Standard of the Times then was ) granted unto King Henry the 8. anno 1530. to free them from the fear and danger of the Praemuni●i . By this Benefit of the Chapter called Similiter in the old Provincial , extended formerly to the University of Oxon only , was made communicable the same year unto Cambridge also . By this Crome , Latimer , Bilney , and divers others , were in the year next following impeached of Heresie . By this the Will and Testament of William Tracie of Toddington was condemned as scandalous and heretical , and his body taken up and burnt not many daies before the passing of the Act of Submission , anno 1532. But this power being thought too great or inconsistent at least with the Kings Design touching his divorce , the Clergy were reduced unto such a straight by the degrees and steps which you find in the following Section , as to submit their power unto that of the King , and to promise in verbo sacerdotii , that they would do and enact nothing in their Convocations without his consent . And to the gaining of this point , he was pressed the rather , in regard of a Remonstrance then presented to Him by the House of Commons , in which they shewed themselves aggrieved , that the Clergy of this Realm should act Authoritatively , and supremely in the Convocations , and they in Parliament do nothing , but as it was confirmed and ratified by the Royal Assent . Which notwithstanding , though this Submission brought down the Convocation to the same Level with the Houses of Parliament ; yet being made unto the King in his single person , and not as in conjunction with his Houses of Parliament , it neither brought the Convocation under the command of Parliaments , nor rendred them obnoxious to the power thereof . That which they did in former times of their self-authority ( in matters which concerned the Church ) without the Kings consent co-operating and concurring with them , the same they did and might do in the Times succeeding , the Kings Authority and Consent being superadded , without the help and midwifery of an Act of Parliament , though sometimes that Authority was made use of also , for binding of the subject under Temporal and Legal penalties , to yeeld obedience and conformity to the Churches Orders . Which being the true state of the present businesse , it makes the clamour of the Papists the more unreasonable ; but then withall it makes it the more easily answered . Temporal punishments inflicted on the refractory and disobedient in ●Temporal Court , may adde some strength unto the Decrees and Constitutions of the Church , but they take none from it : Or if they did the Religion of the Church of Rome , the whole Mass of Popery , as it was received and setled h●●e in Qu. Marios Reign , would have a sor●y c●utch ●o stand upon , and might as justly bear the name of a Parliament Faith , as the reformed Religion of the Church of England . It is true indeed , that had those Convocations which were active in that Reformation , being either call'd or summoned by the King in Parliament , or by the Houses separately , or 〈◊〉 without the King ; or had the Members of the same been nominated and impo●●ered by the Hous alone , and intermixt with a considerable number of the Lord● and Commons ; ( which being by the way , the Case of this New Assembly , I do not see how any thing which they agree on 〈…〉 the Clergy , otherwise then imposed by a strong hand , and against their priviledge● ) Or finally , had the conclusions or results thereof been o● no effect , but as reported to 〈◊〉 confirmed in Parliament , the Papists might have had some ground for so gross a c●u●nny , in calling the Religion which is now est b●ith●d by the name of a Parliament Religion , and a Parliament G●spel . But so it is not in the C●se which is now before us , the said ●ubmissi●n notwithst●nding . For being the Convocation is still called by the same Authority as before it was , the Members of that Body 〈◊〉 stil● the s●me priviledge . with the same freedom of debate and determination ▪ and which is more , the P●ocurdtors of the Clergy invested with the same power and trust which before they had : there was no alteration made by the said 〈◊〉 , in the whole constitution and composure of it , but onely the addition of a greater and more excellent power . Nor was there any thing done here in that Reformation , but either by the Clergy in their Convocations , and in their Convocations rightly c●lled and canonically constituted , or with the councel and advice o● the Heads thereof in more private conferences ; the Parliaments of these Times contributing very little towards i● , but acquie●cing in the Wi●dome of the Sovereign Prince , and in the piety and zeal of the Ghostly Fathers . This is the Ground work or Found●●ion of the following building . It is now time I should proceed to the Superstructures beginning first with the Election of the Pope , and vesting the Supremacie in the Regal Crown . 2 Of the Ejection of the Pope , and vesting the Supremacy in the Regall Crown . ANd first , beginning with the Ejection of the Pope and his Authority that led the way unto the Reformation of Religion which did after follow : It was first voted and decreed in the Convocation , before ever it became the subject of an Act of Parliament . For in the Year 1530. 22 Hen. 8. the Clergy being caught in a premunire , were willing to redee● their danger by a sum of money ; and to that end , the Clergy of the Province of Canterbury bestowed upon the King the sum of 100000 l● . to be paid by equal portions in the same Year following ; but the King would not so be satisfied , unless they would acknowledge him for the supream Head on earth for the Church of England ; which , though it was hard meat , and would not easily down amongst them , yet it passed at last . For , being throughly debated in a Synodical way , both in the upper and lower Houses of Convocation , they did , in fine , agree upon this expression . Cujus ( Ecclesi●e 〈…〉 To this they al consented and subscribed their hands , and afterwards incorporated it into the publike Act or Instrument , which was presented to the King in the Name of his Clergy , for the redeeming of their errour , and the grant of their money , which as it doth at large appear in the Records and Acts of the Convocation , so it is touched upon in a Historical way in the Antiq. Britan. Mason de Minist. Anglic. and other Authors ; by whom it also doth appear , that what was thus concluded on by the Clergy of the Province of Canterbury , was also ratified and confirmed by the Convocation of the Province of York ( according to the usual custom ) save that they did not buy their pardon , at so dear a r●te . This was the Leading Card to the Game that followed . For on this ground were built the Statutes , prohibiting all Appeales to Rome , and for determining all Ecclesiastical suits and controversies within the Kingdoms , 24 H. 8. c 12. That for the manner of electing and conse●rating of Arch-Bishops , and Bishops , 25 H. 8. c. 2● . and the prohibiting the payment of all Impositions to the Court of Rome ; and for obtaining all such dispensations from the See of Canterbury , which formerly were procured from the Popes of Rome , 25. H. 8. c. 21. Which last is built expresly upon this foundations . That the King is the onely supream Head of the Church of England , and was so recognized by the Prelates and Clergy , representing the said Church in their Convocation . And on the ve●y same foundation was the Statute raised , 26 H. 8. c. 1. wherein the King is declared to be the supream Head of the Church of England , and to have 〈…〉 which were annexed unto that Title , as by the Act it self doth at full appear : Which Act being made ( I speak it from the Act it self ) onely for corroboration and confirmation of that which had been done in the Convocation did afterwards draw on the Statute for the Tenths and first frui●s , as the point incident to the Headship or supream Authority , ●6 H. 8. c. 3. The second step to the Ejection of the Pope , was the submission of the Clergy to the said King Henry , whom they had recognizanced for their supream Head . And this was first concluded on in the Convocation , before it was proposed or agitated in the Houses of Parliament , and was commended onely to the care of the Parliament , that it might have the force of a Law by a civil Sanction . The whole deba●e , with all the traverses and emergent difficulties which appeared therein , are specified at large in the Records of 〈◊〉 , Anno 1532. But being you have not opportunity to consult those Records . I shall prove it by the Act of Parliament , called commonly The Act of submission of the Clergy ; but bearing this Title in the Abridgment of the Statutes set out by Poulton ; That the Cler●y in their Convocations shall enact no constitutions without the Kings assent . In which it is premised for granted , that the Clergy of the Realm of England , had not onely acknowledged , according to the Truth , that the Convocation of the same Clergy , is , alwayes hath been , and ought to be assembled alwayes by the Kings Writ ; but also submitting themselves to the Kings Majesty , had pr●mised , in verbo Sace●dotis , That they would never from henceforth presum : to attempt , allcadge , claim , or put in ure , enact promulge , or execute , any new Canons Constitutions , Ordinances provincial , or other ; or by whatsoever other name they shall be called in the Convocation , unless the Kings most Royal Assent may to them be had , to make , promulge , and execute the same ; and that his Majesty do give his most Royall Assent and Authority in that behalf . Upon which ground-work of the Clergies , the Parliament shortly after built this superstructure , to the same effect , viz. That none of the said Clergy from thenceforth should presume to attempt , alleadge , cla●m , or put in●ure , any Constitutions , or Ordinances Provincial , or Synodals , or any other Canons ; nor shall enact , promulge , or execute any such Canon● , Constitutions , or Ordinances Provinc●s● , ( by whatsoever name or names they may be called ) in their Convocations in time coming ( which alwayes shall be assembled by the Kings Writ ) unless the same Clergy may have the Kings in st Royal Assent and Licence to make , promulge , and execute such Canons , Constitutions , and Ordinances Provincial , or Synodical , upon pain of every one of the said Clergy doing the contrary to this Act , and thereof convicted , to suffer imprisonment , and make fine at the Kings Will , 25 H. 8. c. 19. So that the statute , in effect , is no more then this , an Act to binde the Clergy to perform their promise , to keep them fast unto their word for the time to come , that no new Canon should be made in the times succeeding in the favour of the Pope , or by his Authority , or to the diminution of the Kings R●yal Pre●ogative , or contrary to the Iuwes and statutes of this Realm of England , at many Papal Constitutions were in the former Ages : Which statute I desire you to take notice of , because it is the Rule and Measure of the Churches power in making Canons , Constitutions , or whatsoever else you shall please to call them in their Convocations . The third and small Act , conducing to the Popes Ejection , was an Act of Parliament , 28. H. 8. c. 10. entit●led , An Act ex●inguishing the 〈◊〉 of the Bishop of Rome . By which it was enacted , That if any person should extoll the Authority of the Bishop of Rome , he should incur the penalty of a praeminire ; that every Officer both Ecclesiastical and Lay should be sworn to renounce the said Bishop and his Authority , and to resist it to his power , and to repute any Oath formerly taken in maintenance of the said Bishop , or his Authority , to be void , and finally , that the refusal of the said Oath should bejudged High Treason . But this was also usher'd in , by the determination first , and after by the practice of all the Clergy . For in the year 1534 , which was two yeares before the passing of this Act , the King had sent this Proposition to be agitated in both Vniversities , and in the greatest and most famous Monasteries of the kingdom , that is to say , 〈…〉 Romans , dejure competat plusquam alii cujamque Episco●o extero ? By whom it was determined Negatively , that the Bishop of Rome had no more power of right in the Kingdom of England , than any other forreign Bishop . Which being testified and returned , under the hands and seales respectively ( the Originals whereof are still remaining in the Library of Sr Robert Cotton ) was a good preamble to the Bishops , and the rest of the Clergy , assembled in their Convocation , to conclude the like . And so accordingly they did , and made an Instrument thereof subscribed by the hands of all the Bishops , and others of the Clergy , and afterwards confirmed the same by their corporal Oaths . The copies of which Oaths and Instrument you shal finde in Foxes Acts and Monuments , Vol. 2. fol. 1203. and fol. 1210 , 1211. of the Edition of Iohn Day Anno 1570. And this was semblably the ground of a following statute , 35 H. 8. c. 1. wherein another Oath was devised and ratified , to be imposed upon the Subject , for the more cleer asserting of the Kings Supremacy , and the utter exclusion of the Popes for ever ; which statutes , though they were all repealed by an Act of Parliament , 1 and 2d of Phil. and Mary , c. 1. save that the name of supream Head was changed unto that of the supream Governour , and certain clauses altered in the Oath of Supremacy . Where ( by the way ) you must take notice , that the statutes which concerns the Kings Supremacy , are not introductory of any new Right , that was not in the Crown before ; but onely declaratory of an old , as our best Lawyers tell us , and the statute of the 26 of H. 8. c 1. doth clearly intimate . So that in the Ejection of the Pope of Rome , which was the first and greatest step towards the Work of Reformation , the Parliament did nothing , for ought it appeares , but what was done before in the Convocation , and did no more than fortifie the Results of Hely Church , by the addition and corroboration of the Secular Power . 3 Of the Translation of the Scriptures , and permitting them to be read in the English Tongue . THE second step towards the Work of Reformation ( and indeed one of the most especial parts the●eof ) was the Translation of the Bible into the English Tongue , and the permitting all sorts of people to peruse the same , as that which visibly did tend to the discovery of the errours and corruptions in the Church of Rome ; and the intollerable pride and tyranny of the Romane Prelates , upon which grounds it had been formerly translated into English by the hand of Wi●kliff , and after on the spreading of Luthers Doctrine , by the paines of Tindal , a stou● and active man in King Henries dayes , but not so well bef●iended as the work deserved : especially considering ●●at it hapned in such a time when many printed Pamphlets did disturb the State ( and some of them of T●●dals making ) which seemed to ●end unto sedition , and the change of Government . Which being remonstrated to the King , he caused divers of his Bishops , tog●ther with sundry of the learn d'st and most eminent Divines of all the Kingdom to come before him : Whom he required freely and plainly to declare , a●wel what their opinion was of the foresaid Pamphl●● , as what they did think fit to be done concerning the Translation of the Bible into the English Tongue ; And they upon mature advise and deliberation unanimously conden ned the aforesaid B●oks of H●r●sie and Blasphemy ( no smaler crime : ) then for translating of the Scriptures into the English Tongue , they agreed all with one assent , that it depended wholly on the will and pleasure of the Soveraign P●ince , who might do th●rein as he conceived to be most agreeable to his occasions ▪ but that with reference to the present estate of things , it was more expedient to explain the Scripture to the people by the way of Sermons , then to permit it to be read promiscuou●● by all sorts of men : yet so that hopes were to be given unto the Laity , that if they did renounce their errours , and presently deliver to the hands of his Majesties Officers all such Bookes and Bibles ( which they conceived to be translated with great fraud and falshood ) as any of them had in keeping ; his Majesty would cause a true and catholike Translation of it to be published in convenient time , for the use of his Subjects . This was the sum and substance of the present Con●erence , which you shal finde laid down at large in the Registers of Arch-Bishop Warham . And according to this advice the King sets out a Proclamation , not onely prohibiting the buying , reading , or translating of any the aforesaid Book●s , but straitly charging all his Subjects which had any of the Bookes of Scripture , either of the Old Testament , or of the New , in the English Tongue , to bring them in without delay . But for the other part● of giving hopes unto the people of a true Translation , if they delivered in the false ( ● or that at leas● which was pretended to be false ) I finde no word at all in the Proclamation . That was a work reserved unto better times , or left to be solicited by the Bishops themselves , and other Learned men who had given the counsel ; by whom ( indeed ) the people were kept up in hope that all should be accomplished unto their desires . And so indeed it proved at last . For in the Convocation of the year 1536. the authority of the Pope being abrogated , and Cranmer fully setled in the See of Canterbury , the Clergy did agree upon a form of Petition to be presented to the King , That he would graciously indulge unto his subjects of the Laity the reading of the Bible in the English Tongue , and that a new Translation of it might be forthwith made for that end and purpose . According to which godly motion , his Majesty did not onely give Order for a new Translation , which afterwards He authorized to be read both in publique and private ; but in the interim he permitted CROMWEL , his Vicar-General , to set out an Injunction for providing the whole Bible both in Latine and English , after the Translation then in use , ( which was called commonly by the name of Matthewes Bible , but was no other then that of Tindal somewhat altered ) to be kept in every Parish Church throughout the Kingdom , for every one that would repair unto , and caused this mark or character of Authority to be set upon them in red Letters , Set forth with the Kings most gracious Licence ; which you may see in Fox his Acts and Monum. p. 1248. and 1363. Afterwards when the new Translation so often promised , and so long expected , was compleat and finished ; printed at London by the Kings Authority , and countenanced by a grave and pious Preface of Arch Bishop Cranmer ; the King sets out a Proclamation dated May 6. Anno 1541. Commanding all the Curates and Parishioners throughout the Kingdom , who were not already furnished with Bibles so authorized and translated , as is before said , to provide themselves before Al. hallowtide next following , and to cause the Bibles , so provided , to be placed conveniently in their several and respective Churches , straitly requiring all his Bishops , and other Or●inaries , to take special care to see his said commands put in execution . And therewithal came out Instructions from the King to be published by the Clergy in their several Parishes , the better to possesse the people with the Kings good affection towards them in suffering them to have the ben●fi● of such Heavenly Treasure ; and to direct hem in a course by which they might enjoy the same to their greater comfort , the reformation of their lives , and the peace and quiet of the Church . Which Proclamation and Instructions are stil preserved in that most admirable 〈◊〉 of Sr Robert Cotten . and unto these Commands of so great a Prince , both Bishops , Priests , and People , did apply themselves with such cheerful reverence , that Bonner ( even tha● b●oud● 〈◊〉 as he after proved ) caused six of them to be chained in several places of St Pauls Church in London , for all that 〈◊〉 so 〈…〉 inclined to resort unto , for their edification and instruction , 〈◊〉 Book being very chargable , because very la●ge , and therefore called commonly ( for distinctions sake ) The Bible of the greater 〈◊〉 . Thus have we seen the Scriptures faithfull translated into the English Tongue , the 〈…〉 Churches , that every one which would , ●igh pe●use the same , and leave permitted to all people to buy them for ●hen private use , and re●de them to themselves , or before th●i Families ; and all the brought about by no other meanes then by 〈◊〉 Kings Authority onely , grounded on the advice and judgment of the 〈◊〉 . But long it was not ( I confess ) before the Parliament put in for a share , and claimed some interest in the Work ; but whether for the better , or he worse , I leave you to iudge . For in the year 1542. the King being then in agitation of a League with Charles the Emperou● , He caused a complaint to be made un●o him in this Court of Parliament , That the 〈◊〉 ●ranted to the people in having in their hands the Bookes of the Old and New Testament , had been much abused by many false glosse● and 〈◊〉 which were made upon them , tending to the seducing of the people especially of the younger sort , and the raising of sedition within the Realm . And thereupon it was enacted by the Authority of the Parliament ( on whom He was content to cast the envy of an Act so contrary to ●is former gracious Proclamations ) That all manner of Bookes of the Old and New Testament , of the cr●●●ty , false and untrue Translation of Tind●● , be forthwith abolished , and forbidden to be used and ke●t . As also , that all other B●bles not being of Tindals Translation , in which were sound any Preambles or Annotations , other then the Quotations or Summaries of of the Chapters should be purged of the said Preambles and Annotatious , either by cutting them out , or blotting them in such wise , that they might not be perceived or read . And finally , That the Bible be not read ●penly in any Church , but by the leave of the King , or of the Ordinary of the place ; nor privately by any Women , Artificers , Apprentices , Iourney-men , Husband-men , 〈◊〉 , or by any of the Servants of Yoomen , or under , with several pains to those who should do the con●trary . This is the substance of the statute of the 34 and 35 H●● . 8. c. 1. Which though i● shewes that there was somewhat done in Parliament , in a matter which concern'd Religion , ( which howsoever if you mark it , was rather the adding of the penalties , than giving any resolution or decision of the points in question ) yet I presume the Papists wil not use this for an Argument , that we have either a Parliament Religion , or a Parliament Gospel ; or that we stand indebted to the Parliament for the use of the Scriptures in the English Tongue , which is so principal a part of the Reformation . Nor did the Parliament speed so prosperously in the undertaking ( which the wise King permitted them to have a hand in , for the foresaid ends , ) or found so general an obedience in it from the common people , as would have been expected in these Times , on the like occasion ; but that the King was fain to quicken and give life to the Acts thereof , by his Proclamation , Anno 1546. which you shal finde in Fox his book , fo● 1437. To drive this Nail a little further : The terrour of this statute dying with H. 8. or being repealed by that of K. Ed. 6. c. 22. the Bible was again made publique ; and not onely suffered to be read by particular persons , either privatly , or in the Church ; but ordered to be read over yearly in the Congregation , as a part of the Liturgie , or Divine Service : Which how far it relates to the Court of Parliament we shal see anon ; But for the publishing thereof in Print for the use of the people , for the comfort and edification of private persons , that was done onely by the King , at least in his Name , and by His Authority . And so it also stood in Q Elizabeths time , the translation of the Bible being again reviewed by some of the most learned Bishops , appointed thereunto by the Queens Commission ( from whence is had the name of the Bishops Bible ) and upon that review , re●printed by her sole Commandement , and by her sole Authority left free and open to the use of her wel-affected and religious subjects . Nor did the Parliament do any thing in all Her Reign with reference to the Scriptures in the English Tongue , otherwise then at the reading of them ▪ in that Tongue , in the Congregation , is to be reckoned for a part of the English Liturgy , whereof more hereafter . In the translation of them into Welch , or British , somwhat indeed was done which doth look this way . It being ordered in the Parliament , 5. Eliz. c. 28. That the B. B. of Hereford , St Davids , Bangor , Landaff , and St Asaph , should take care amongst them for translating the whole Bible , with the book of Common Prayer , into the Welch or Brittish Tongue , on pain of forseiting 40 l. a piece in default hereof . And to incourage them thereunto , it was enacted that one book of either sort being so translated and imprinted should be provided and bought for every Cathedral Church , as also for all Parish Churches and Chappels of Ease , where the said tongue is commonly used ; the Ministers to pay the one half of the price , and the Parishioners the other . But then you must observe withal , that it had been before determined in the Convocation of the self-same year , Anno 1562. That the Common-Prayer of the Church ought to be celebrated in a tongue which was under stood by the people ( as you may see in the book of Articles of Religion , Art. 24. which came out that year ) and consequently , aswel in the Welch or Brittish , as in any other . Which care , had it been taken for Ireland also as it was for Wales , no question but that people had been more generally civiliz'd , and made conformable in all points to the English Government long before this time . And for the new Translation of K. Iames his time , to shew that the Translation of Scripture is no work of Parliament , as it was principally occasioned by some passages in the Conference at Hampton Court , without recourse unto the Parliament , so was it done onely by such men as the King appointed , and by His Authority alone imprinted , published and imposed , care being taken by the Canon of the year , 1603. That one of them should be provided for each several at Church , at the charge of the Parish . No flying in this case to an Act of Parliament , either to authorize the doing of it , or to impose it being done . 4 Of the Reformation of Religion in points of Doctrine . NExt let us look upon the method used in former Times in the reforming of the Church , whether in points of Doctrine , or in formes of Worship , and we shal find it stil the same . The Clergy did the work as to them seemed best , never advising with the Parliament , but upon the post-fact , and in most cases not at all . And first for Doctrinals , there was but little done in K. Henries time , but that which was acted by the Clergy onely in their Convocation , and so commended to the people by the Kings sole Authority , the matter being never brought within the cognizance of the two Houses of Parliament . For in the year 1536. being the year in which the Popes Authority was for ever banished , there were some Articles agreed on in the Convocation , and represented to the King , under the hands of the Bishops , Abbots , Priors , and inferior Clergy usually called unto those Meetings ; the Original whereof being in Sr Robert Cotton's Library I have often seen : Which being approved of by the King , were forthwith published under the Title of Articles devised by the Kings Highness , to stable Christian quietness and unity amongst the people . In which it is to be observed : First , that those Articles make mention of Sacraments onely , that is to say , of Baptisme , Penance , and the Sacrament of the Altar . And secondly , That in the Declaration of the Doctrine of Iustification , Images , honouring of the Saiuts departed ; as also concerning many of the Ceremonies , and the fire of Purgatory , they differ'd very much from those Opinions which had been formerly received in the Church of Rome ; as you may partly see by that Extract of them , which occurs in Fox his Acts and Monuments , Vol. 2. fol. 1246. For the confirming of which book , and recommending it to the use of the people , His Majesty was pleased in the Injunctions of the year , 1536. to give command to all Deans , Parsons , Vicars , and Curates , so to open and declare in their Sermons , and other Collacions , the said Articles unto them which be under their Cure , that they might plainly know and discern , which of them be necessary to be believed and observed for their salvation , and which d● onely concern the decent and politique Order of the Church . And this he did upon this ground , that the said Articles had been concluded and condescended upon by the Prelates and Clergy of the Realm in their Convocation ; as appeareth in the very words of the Injunction : For which , see Fox his Acts and Monuments , fol. 1247. I find not any thing in Parliament which relates to this , either to countenance the work , or to require obedience and conformity from the hand of the people . And to say truth , neither the King nor Clergy did account it necessary , but thought their own Authority sufficient to go through with it ; though certainly it was more necessary at that time , then in any since : The power and reputation of the Clergy being under foot , the King scarce setled in the Supremacy so lately recognized unto him ; and therefore the Authority of the Parliament of more use then afterward , in Times well ballanced and established . 'T is true , that in some other year of that Princes Reign , we finde some use and mention of an Act of Parliament in matters which concerned Religion ; but it was onely in such Times when the hopes of Reformation were in the Wane , and the Work went retro●●● For in the year 1539. being the 31. H. 8. When the Lord 〈◊〉 power began to decline , and the King was in a necessity of complyance with His Neighbouring Princes , there passed an Act of Parliament commonly called the statute of the six Articles ( or the Whip with six strings . ) In which it was enacted , That whosoever by word or writing should preach , teach , or publish , that in the blessed Sacraments of the Altar , under form of Bread and Wine , there is not really the naturall body and bloud of our Saviour Iesus Christ , conceived of the Virgin Mary , ( or affirm otherwise thereof then was maintained and taught in the Church of Rome ) should be adjudged an Heretick , and suffer death , by burning , and forfeit all his Lands and Goods , as in case of High Treason . Secondly , That whosoever should teach or preach , that the Communion of the blessed Sacrament ( in both kindes ) is necessary for the health of mans soul , and ought to be maintained . Thirdly , Or that any man after the Order of Priesthood received , might marry , or contract Matrimony . Fourthly , Or that any woman which had vowed and professed chastity , might contract Marriage . Fifthly , Or that private Masses were not lawful and laudable , or agreeable to the Word of God . Or sixthly , That curicular Confession was not necessary and expedient to be used in the Church of God , should suffer death , and forfeit Lands and goods as a Fellon , 31 H. 8. c. 14. The rigour of which terrible statute was shortly after mittigated in the said Kings Reign , 32 H. 8. c. 10. and 35 H. 8. c. 5. and the whole statute absolutely repealed by Act of Parliament , 1 E. 6. c. 12. But then it is to be observed first , that this Parliament of K. H. 8. did not determine any thing in those six points of Doctrine which are therein recited ; but onely took upon them to devise a course for the suppressing of the contrary Opinions , by adding by the secular Power , the punishment of Death , and forfeiture of Lands & Goods , unto the censures of the Church , which were grown weak , if not unvalid ; and consequently , by degrees became neglected ever since the said K. Henry took the Headship on Him , and exercised the same by a Lay Vicar General . And secondly , you must observe , that it appeareth evidently by the Act it self , that at the same time the King had called a Synod and Convocation of all the Archbishops , Bishops , and other learned men of the Clergy , that the Articles were first deliberately and advisedly debated , argued and reasoned , by the said Archbishops , Bishops , and other learned men of the Clergy , and their opinions in the same declared and made known , before the matter came in Parliament . And finally , That being brought into the Parliament , there was not any thing declared and passed as doctrinall , but by the assent of the Lords Spiritual , and other learned men of the Clergy , as by the Act it self doth at large appear . Finally , Whatsoever , may be drawn from thence , can be only this , That K. H●n . did make use of his Court of Parliament for the establishing and confirming of some points of Popery , which seemed to be in danger of a Reformation . And this compared with the statute of the 34 and 35 , prohibiting the reading of the Bible by most sorts of people , doth cleerly shew that the Parliaments of those times did rather hinder and retard the work of Reformation , in some especial parts thereof , than give any furtherance to the same . But to proceed : There was another point of Reformation begun in the Lord C●●mwels time , but not produced , nor brought to perfection till after his decease ; and then too , not without the Midwifery of an Act of Parliament . For in the year 1537. the Bishops and others of the Clergy of the Convocation , had composed a Book , entituled , The Institution of a Christian Man ; which being subscribed by all their hands , was by them presented to the King , by His most excellent judgment to be allowed of , or condemned . This book , containing the chief heads of Christian Religion , was forthwith printed , and exposed to publike view . But some things not being cleerly explicated , or otherwise subject to exception , he caused it to be reviewed and to that end , as Supream Head on Earth of the Church of England ( I speak the very words of the Act of Parl. 32. H. 8. c. 26. ) appointed the Archbishops and Bishops of both Provinces , and also a great number of the best , learned , honestest , and most vertuous sort of the Doctors of Divinity , men of discretion , judgment , and good disposition , to be called together ; to the intent , that according to the very Gospel and Law of God , without any partial respect or affection to the Papistical sort , or any other sect or sects whatsoever , they sh●●ld declare by writing , & publish , as well the principal Articles and points of our Faith and Belief ; with the Declaration , true understanding an● observation of such other expedi●nt points , as by them , with his Grace ; advice , councel , and consent , shall be thought needful and expedient ; as also for the lawful Rights , Ceremonies , and observation of Gods service within this Realm . This was in the year , 1540. at what time the Parliament was also sitting ; of which the King was pleased to make this especial use , That whereas the work which was in hand ( I use again the words of the statute ) required ripe and mature deliberation , and was not rashly to be defined and set forth , and so not fit to be restrained to the present Session , an Act was passed to this effect , That all Determitions , Declarations , Decrees , Definitions , and Ordinances , as according to Gods Word , and Christs Gospel , should at any time hereafter be set forth by the said Archbishops and Bishops , and Doctors in Divinity , now appointed , or hereafter to be appointed by his Royal Majesty , or else by the whole Clergy of England , in , and upon the matter of Christs Religion , and the Christian Faith , and the lawful Rights Ceremonies , and Observations of the same , by his Majesties advice and confirmation under the great Seal of England , shall be by all his Graces subjects fully believed , obeyed , observed , and performed to all purposes and intents , upon the paines and penalties therein to be comprized , as if the same had been in 〈◊〉 and 〈…〉 and fully made , set forth , declared , and contained in the said Act , 32. H. 8. c. 26. where note , That the two House of Parliament were so far from ●edling in the matter which was then in hand , that they did not so much as require to see the Determinations and Decrees of those learned men whom His Majesty had then assembled , before they passed the present Act , to bind the Subject fully to believe , observe , and perform the same ; but left it wholly to the judgment and discretion of the King and Clergy , and trusted them besides , with the ordaining and inflicting of such paines and penalties on disobedient and unconformable persons as to them seemed meet . This ground-work laid , the work went forwards in good order , and at last being brought unto as much perfection as the said Arch-Bishops , Bishops , and other learned men would give it , without the co-operation and concurrence of the Royal assent ; it was presented once again to the Kings consideration ▪ who very carefully perused it , and altered many things with his own hand ; as appeares by the book it self ●●ll extant in the famous Library of Sr Robert Cotton ; and having so altered and corrected it in some passages , returned it to the Archbishop of Canterbury , who bestowed some further paines upon it ; to the end , that being to come forth in the Kings Name , and by his Authority , there might be nothing in the same which might be justly reprehended . The business being in this forwardnesse , the King declares in Parliament , Anno 1544. being the 34 year of his Reign , his zeal and care , not onely to suppress all such Bookes and Writings as were noysome and pestilent , and tended to the seducing of his subjects ; but also to ordain and establish a certain form of pure and sincere Teaching agreeable to Gods Word , and the true Doctrine of the Catholick and Apostolick Church , whereunto men may have recourse for the decision of some such controversies , as have in Times past , and yet do happen to arise . And for a preparatory thereunto , that so it might come forth with the greater credit , he caused an Act to pass in Parliament for the abolishing of all Bookes and Writings , comprizing any matters of Christian Religion , contrary to that Doctrine , which since the year 1540. is , or any time during the Kings life , shall be , set forth by his Highnesse , and for the punishment of all such ( and that too , with most grievous 〈◊〉 ) which should preach , teach , maintain , or defend any matter or thing contrary to the book of Doctrine , which was then in readiness , 34 , 35 H. 8. c. 1. Which done , He can●ed the said book to be imprinted in the year next following , under the Title of Anecessdry Doctrine for all sorts of people ; prefixing a Preface thereto in his Royal Name , to all his faithful and loving Subjects , that they might know the better in those dangerous Times , what to believe in point of Doctrine , and how they were to carry and behave themselves in points of practice . Which Statute , as it is the greatest Evidence which those Times afford to shew , that both , or either of the Houses of Parliament had any thing to do in matters which concerned Religion ; so it entitles them to no more ( if at all to any thing ) then that th●y did make way to a book of Doctrine , which was before digested by the Clergy onely , revised after , and corrected by the Kings own hand ; and finally , perused and perfected by the Metr●politan . And more then so ( besides , that being but one Swallow , it can make no Summer ) it is acknowledged and confessed in the Act it self ( if Poulton understand it rightly in his Abridgment ) That recourse must be had to the Catholick and Apostolick Church , for the decision of Controversies . Which as it gives the Clergy the decisive power , so it left nothing to the Houses but to assist and aid them with the Temporal Sword , when the Spiritual Word could not do the deed , the point thereof being blunted , and the edge abated . Next , let us look upon the time of K. Ed. 6. and we shall finde the Articles and Doctrine of the Church ( excepting such as were contained in the book of Common-Prayer ) to be composed , confirmed , and setled in no other way , then by the C●ergy onely in their Convocation , the Kings Authority co-operating and concur●ing with them . For , in the Synod held in London , Anno 1552. the Clergy did compose and agree upon a book of Articles , containing the chief heads of the Christian Faith ; especially , with reference to such points of Controversie , as were in difference between the Reformators of the Church of England , and the Church of Rome , and other Opponents whatsoever which after were approved , and published by the Kings Authority . They were in number 41. and were published by this following Title ; that is to say , Articuli d● quibus in Syno● London . Anno 1552. 〈…〉 Religion is firmandum , inter Episcopos & alios & Eruditis 〈◊〉 Convenerat , Regia authoritate in lucem Editi . And , it is worth our observation , that though the Parliament was held at the very time , and that the Parliament passed several Acts which concerned Church-matters ; as , viz. An Act for Vniformity of Divine Service , and for the confirmation of the book of Ordination , 5 and 6 Edw. 6. c. 1. All Act declaring which dayes onely shall be kept for Holy dayes ; and which for Fasting dayes , C. 3. against striking or drawing weapon , either in the Church or Church-yard , C. 4. And finally , another Act for the legitimating of the Marriages of Priests and Ministers , C. 12. Yet neither in this Parliament , nor in that which followed , is there so much as the least syllable which reflecteth this way , or medleth any thing at all with the book of Articles . Where , by the way , if you behold the lawfulnesse of Priests Marriages as a matter Doctrinal ; or think we owe that point of Doctrine , & the indulgence granted to the Clergy in it , to the care and goodness of the Parl. you may please to know , that the point had been before determined in the Convocation , & stands determined by and for the Clergy in the 31 of those Articles , and that the Parliament looked on it as a point of Doctrine ; but as it was a matter practical , conducing to the benefit and improvement of the Common-wealth . Or if it did , yet was the statute built on no other ground-work , than the Resolution of the Clergy , the Marriage of Priests being before determined to be most lawfull ( I use the very words of the Act it self ) and according to the Word of God , by the learned Clergy of this Realm in their Convocations , as well by the common assent , as by subscriptions of their hands , 5 , 6. Edw. 6. chap. 12. And for the time of Queen Elizabeth , it is most manifest , that they had no other body of Doctrine in the first part of her Reign , then onely the said Articles of K. Edwards book ; and that which was delivered in the book of Homilies of the said Kings time : in which the Parliament had as little to do , as you have seen they had in the book of Articles . But in the Convocation of the year , 1562. being the fifth of the Qu. Reign , the Bishops and Clergy taking into consideration the said book of Articles , and altering what they thought most fitting , to make it more conducible to the use of the Church , and the edification of the people , presented it unto the Queen , who caused it to be published with this Name and Title , viz. Articles whereupon it was agreed by the Arch-Bishops , and Bishops of both Provinces , and the whole Clergy in the Convocation holden at London , Anno 1562 , for the avoiding of diversity of Opinions , and for the establishing of Consent touching true Religion ; put forth by the Queens authority . Of any thing done , or pretended to be done , by the power of the Parliament , either in the way of approbation , or of confirmation , ●ot one word occurs either in any of the printed books , or the publique Registers . At last , indeed in the 13th of the said Queens Reign ( which was 8 years full after the passing of those Articles ) comes out a statute for the redressing of disorders in the Ministers of holy Church : In which it was enacted , That all such as were ordained Priests or Ministers of Gods Word and Sacraments , after any other form then that appointed to be used in the Church of England ; all such as were to be ordained , or permitted to preach , or to be instituted into any Benefi●e with ●ure of soules , should publikely subscribe to the said Articles , and testifie their assent unto them Which shews ( if you observe it well ) that though the Parliament did well allow of , and approve the said book of Articles , yet the said book owes neither confirmation , nor authority , to the Act of Parliament . So that the wonder is the greater , that that most insolent scoff which is put upon us by the Church of Rome , in calling our Religion by the name Parliamentaria Religi● , should pass so long without controle ; unlesse , perhaps , it was in reference to our Formes of Worship , of which I am to speak in the next place . But first we must make answer unto some Objections which are made against us , both from Law and Practice . For Practice ; first , it is alleadged by some out of Bishop Iewel , in his Answer to the cavil of Dr Harding , to be no strange matter to see Ecclesiastical Causes debated in Parliament ; and that it is apparent by the Lawes of King Inas , King Alfred , King Edward , &c. That our godly fore-fathers , the Princes and Peers of this Realm , never vouchsafed to treat of matters touching the common State , before all controversies of Religion , and Causes Ecclesiastical had been concluded , Def. of the Apol. part 6 chap. 2. sect. 1. But the answer unto this is ea●●e : For first , if our Religion may be called Parliamentarian , because it hath received confirmation and debate in Parliament , then the Religion of our Fore-fathers , even Papistry it self ( concerning which so many Acts of Parliament were made in K. Hen. 8. and Q. Maries time ) must be called Parliamentarian also . And secondly , it is most certain , that in the Parliaments or Common-Councels ( call them which you will ) both of King Inas time , and the rest of the Saxon Kings which B. Iewel speaks of ; not onely Bishops , Abbots , and the higher part of the Clergy , but the whole Body of the Clergy generally had their votes and suffrages , either in person , or by proxie . Concerning which , take this for the leading Case ; That in the Parliament or Common-councel in K. Ethelberts time , who first of all the Saxon Kings , received the Gospel , the Clergy were convened in as full a manner , as the Lay-Subjects of that Prince : Convo●ati communi Concilio tam Cleri , quam Populi , saith Sr H. Spelman in his Collection of the Councels , Ann. 605. p. 118. And for the Parliament of King Ina , which leades the way in Bishop Iewel , it was , ( saith the same Sr H. Spelman , p. 630. Communi Concilium Episcoporum , Procerum , Comitum , nec non omnium Sapientum , Seniorum , populorumque totius Regni ; Where , doubtless , Sapientes and Seniores ( and you know what Seniores signifieth in the Ecclesiastical notion ) must be some body else then those which after are expressed by the name of Populi , which shews the falshood and absurdity of the collection made by Mr Pryn , in the Epistle to his book against Dr Cousins , viz. That the Parliament ( as it is now constituted ) hath an ancient genuine , just and lawful Prerogative , to establish true Religion in our Church , and to abolish and suppress all false , new , and counterfeit Doctrines whatsoever . Unlesse he meanes upon the post-fact , after the Church hath done her part , in determining what was true , what false , what new , what ancient ; and finally , what Doctrines might be counted counterfeit , and what sincere . And as for Law , 't is true indeed , that by the Statute , 1 Eliz. cap. 1. The Court of Parliament hath power to determine and judge of Heresie ; which at first sight seems somewhat strange ; but on the second view , you will easily finde that this relates onely to new and emergent Heresies , not formerly declared for such in any of the first four General Councels , nor in any other General Councel , adjudging by express words of holy Scripture ; as also that in such new Heresies , the following words restrain this power to the Assent of the Clergy in their Convocation , as being best able to instruct the Parliament what they are to do , and where they are to make use of the secular sword for cutting off a desperate H●retick from the Church of CHRIST , or rather from the body of all Christian people . 5 Of the Reformation of the church of England in the Formes of Worship ; and the Times appointed thereunto . THis rub removed , we now proceed unto a view of such Formes of Worship as have been setled in this Church , since the first dawning of the day of Reformation , in which our Parliaments have indeed done somewhat , though it be not much . The first point which was altered in the publike Liturgies , was that the Creed , the Pater-●●ster , and the Ten Commandements , were ordered to be said in the English Tongue ; to the intent , the people might be perfect in them , and learn them without book , as our phrase is . The next , the setting forth and using of the English Letany , on such dayes and times , in which it was accustomably to be read , as a part of the service . But neither of these two was done by Parliament ; nay , ( to say truth ) the Parliament did nothing in them . All which was done in either of them , was onely by the Kings Authority , by vertue of the Headship or Supremacy , which by way of recognition was vested in him by the Clergy , either co-operating and concurring with them in their Convocations , or else directed and assisted by such learned Prelates , with whom he did advise in matters which concerned the Church , and did relate to Reformation . By vertue of which Headship or Supremacy he ordained the first ; and to that end , caused certain Articles or Injunctions to be published by the Lord Cromwel , then his Vicar General , Anno 1536. And by the same did he give order for the second , I mean , for the saying of the Letany in the English Tongue , by his own Royal Proclamation , Anno 1545. For which , consult the Acts and Monuments , fol. 1248 , 1312. But these were only preparations to a greater work which was reserved unto the times of K. Edw. 6. In the beginning of whose Reign there passed a statute for the administring the Sacrament in both kindes to any person that should devoutly and humbly desire the same , 1. E. 6. c. 1. In which it is to be observed , that though the statute do declare , that the ministring of the same in both kinds to the people was more agreeable to the first I●stitution of the said Sacrament , and to the common usage of the primitive Times . Yet Mr. F●x assures us ( and we may take his word ) that they did build that Declaration , and consequently the Act which was raised upon it , upon the judgment and opinion of the best learned men , whose resolution and advice they followed in it , fol. 1489. And for the Form by which the said most blessed Sacrament was to be delivered to the common people , it was commended to the care of the most grave and learned Bishops , and others , assembled by the King at His C●stle of Windsor ; who upon long , wise , learned , and deliberate advice did finally agree ( saith Fox ) upon one godly and uniform Order for receiving of the same , according to the right rule of Scriptures , and the first use of the primitive Church , fol. 1491. Which Order , as it was set forth in print , Anno 1548. with a Proclamation in the name of the King , to give authority thereunto amongst the people so was it recommended by especial Letters 〈◊〉 unto every Bishop , severally from the Lords of the Councel to see the same put in execution ; A copy of which Letters you may finde in Fox , fol. 1491. as afore is said . Hitherto nothing done by Parliament in the Formes of Worship , but in the following year there was For the Protector and the rest of the Kings Councel being fully bent for a Reformation , thought it expedient that one uniform , quiet and godly Order should be had thoroughout the Realm , for Officiating Gods divine Service . And to that end ( I use the words of the Act it self ) appointed the Archbishop of Canterbury , and certain of the most learned and discreet Bishops , and other learned men of the Realm to meet together , requiring them , that having aswel eye and respect to the most pure and sincere Christian Religion , taught in Scriptures , as to the usages in the Primitive Church , they should draw and make one convenient and meet O●der , ●ite and fashion of Common Prayer , and Administration of Sacraments , to be had and used in this his Majesties Realm of England . Well , what did they being thus assembled ? that the Statute tels us : Where it is said , that by the aid of the Holy Ghost ( I pray you mark this well ) and with one uniform agreement they did conclude upon and set forth an Order , which they delivered to the Kings Higness , in a Book entituled , The Book of Common Prayer and Administration of the Sacraments , and other ●ites and Ceremonies of the Church , after the use of the Church of England . All this was done before the Parliament did any thing . But what was done by them at last ? Why first , considering the most godly travail of the Kings Highness , and the Lord Protector and others of his Highness Councel , in gathering together the said B. and learned men . Secondly , the Godly prayers , Orders , Rites and Ceremonies in the said Book mentioned . Thirdly , the motives and inducements which inclined the aforesaid learned men to alter those things which were altered , and to retain those things which were retained ; And finally , taking into consideration the honour of God , and the great quietness which by the grace of God would ensue upon it ; they gave his Majesty most hearty and lowely thanks for the same , and most humbly prayed him , that it might be ordained by his Majesty , with the assent of the Lords and Commons assembled in Parliament , and by authority of the same , that the said Form of Common-prayer and another , after the Feast of Pentecost next following , should be used in all his Majesties Dominions with several penalties to such , as either should deprave or neglect the same . 2. and 3. E. 6. cap. 1. So farre the very words of the Act it self . By which it evidently appeareth , that the two Houses of Parliament did nothing in the present business , but impose that Form upon the people : which by the learned & religious Clergy-men ( whom the K. appointed thereunto ) was agreed upon , and made it penal unto such as either should deprave the same , or neglect to use it . And thus doth Poulton ( no mean Lawyer ) understand the Statute , who therfore gives no other title to it in his Abridgement published in the year 1612 than this , The penalty for not using uniformity of Service , and Ministration of the Sacrament . So then the making of one uniform Order of celebrating divine Service , was the work of the Clergy , the making of the Penalties , was the work of the Parliament . Where let me tell you by the way , that the men who were employed in this weighty business ( whose names deserve to be continued in perpetual memory ) were Thomas Cranmer Archbishop of Canterbury , George Day Bishop of Chichester , Thomas Goodrich B. of Ely and Lord Chancellour , Iohn Ship Bishop of Hereford , Henry Holb●rt Bishop of Lincoln , Nichol●s Ridley Bishop of Rochester , translated afterwards to London , Thomas Thirleby B. of Westminster , Doctor May D●an of S. Pauls , Dr Taylor ( then Dean afterwards ) Bp of Lincoln , Dr Haines Dean of Exeter , Dr Robertson afterwards Dean of Durham , Dr Redman Master of Trinity Colledge in Cambridge , and Dr Coke then Al●ner to the King , afterward Dean of Westminster , and at last Bp of Ely ; men famous in their generations , and the honour of the Age they lived in : And so much for the first Liturgy of King Edwards Reign ; in which you see how little was done by authority or power of Parliament , so little , that if it had been less , it had been just nothing . But some exceptions being taken against the Liturgy by some of the preciser sort at home , and by Calvin abroad , the book was brought under a review : and though it had been framed at first ( if the Parliament which said so erred not ) by the ●yd of the Holy Ghost himself ; yet to comply with the curiosity of the Ministers and mistakes of the people , rather then for any other weighty cause , As the Statute 5 and 6 Ed. 6. cap. 1. it was thought expedient by the King , with the assent of the Lords and Commons in Parliament assembled , that the said Order of Common Service should be faithfully and godly perused , explained , and made fully perfect . Perused and explained ; by whom ? Why , questionless by those who made it ; or else , by those ( if they were not the same men ) who were appointed by the King to draw up , and compose a Form of Ordination for the use of the Church . And this Assent of theirs ( for it was no more ) was the onely part that was ever acted by the Parliament , in matter of this present nature ; save that a Statute passed in the former Parliament 3 and 4 Ed. 6. c. 12. unto this effect , that such form and manner of making and consecrating Archb. Bi-shops , Priests , Deacons , and other Ministers of the Church ( which before I spake of ) as by sixe Prelates and sixe other men of this Realm , learned in Gods lawes , by the King to be appointed and assigned , shall be devised to that purpose , and set forth under the great Seal , shall be lawfully used and exercised , and none other . Where note , that the King onely was to nominate and appoint the men , the Bishops and other learned men were to make the Book ; and that the Parliament in a blinde obedience , or at the least upon a charitable confidence in the integrity of the men so nominated , did confirm that Book , before any of their Members had ever seen it , though afterwards indeed , in the following Parliament , this Book , together with the book of Common-prayer , so printed and explained , obtained a more formal confirmation , as to the use thereof throughout the Kingdom , but in no other respect ; for which see the Statute 5 and 6 Ed. 6. c. 1. ( As for the time of Qu. Elizabeth , when the Common prayer book now in use ( being the same almost with the last of King Edward ) was to be brought again into the Church , from whence it was cast out in Queen Maries Reign ; it was commited to the care of some learned men ; that is to say , to M Whitehead ( once Chaplain to Queen Anne Bullen ) Dr Parker , after Archbishop of Canterbury , Dr Grindal , after bishop of London , Dr Cox , after Bishop of Ely , Dr Pilkington , after Bishop of Durham , Dr May , Dean of Saint Pauls , Dr Bill , Provost of Eaton , after Dean of Westminster , and Sr Tho : Smith . By whom being altered in some few passages which the Statute points to , 1 Eliz. c. 21. it was presented to the Parliament , and by the Parliament received and established without more 〈…〉 troubling any Committee of both or ●ither Houses to consider of it , for ought appears in their Records . All that the Parliament did in it , being to put it into the condition in which it stood before in King Edwards Reign , partly by repealing the Repeal of King Edw. Statute● , made in the first of Q. Mary , c. 2. and partly by the adding of some farther penalties on such as did deprave the book , or neglect to use it , or wilfully did absent themselves from their Parish-Churches . And for the Alterations made in King Iames his time , b●ing small in the Rubrick onely ; and for the additions of the Thanksgivings at the end of the Letany , the Prayer for the Queen and the Royal Issue , and the Doctrine of the Sacraments at the end of the Catechisi●e , which were not in the book before , they were never referred unto the Parliament , but were done onely by a●thority of the Kings Commission , and stand in force by vertue onely of His Proclamation , which you may finde before the book ; the charge of buying the said book so explained and altered , being laid upon the several and respective Parishes , by no other Authority than that of the eightieth Canon , made in Convocation , Anno 1603. The like may also be affirmed of the Fo●mes of prayer for the Inauguration day of our Kings and Queens , the Prayer-books for the fifth of November , and the fifth of August , and those which have been used in all publike Fasts : All which , without the help of Pa●liaments , have been composed by the Bishops , and imposed by the King . Now unto this discourse of the Forms of Worship , I shall subjoyn a word or two of the times of Worship , that is to say , the Holy dayes observed in the Church of England ; and so observed , that they do owe that observation chiefly to the Church ● power . For whereas it was found in the former times , that the number ●f the holy dayes was grown so great , that they became a burthen to the common people , and a great hinderance to the thrist and manufactures of the Kingdom ; there was a Canon made in the Convocation , An. 1536. for cutting off of many superstitious and supe●fluous Holy dayes , and the reducing them into the number in which they now st●nd ( save that St G●orge's day , and Ma●y Magdalens day , and all the Festivals of the blessed Virgin had their place amongst them ) according to which Can●n , there went out a M●nitory from the A●chbp of Ca●terbury , to all the Suffrag●ns of hi● P●ovince , 〈…〉 , which is still extant on Record . But being the authority of the Church was then in the wane , it was thought necessary to confirm their Acts , and see execution done upon it by the Kings Injunction : which did accordin●ly come forth with this Form or preamble ; That the abolishing of the said holy dayes , was decreed ordained and established by the Kings Highness Authority , as sup●eam Head in earth of the Church of England , with the common consent and assent of the Prelates and Clergy of this ●is Realm in Conv●cation lawfully assembled and congregate . Of which see Foxe his Acts and M●numents , fol. 1246 , 1247. Afterwards in the year 1541 , the King perceiving with what difficulty the people were induced to leave off those Holy days , to which they had been so long ac●ustomed , published his Proclamation of the twenty third of Iuly , for the abolishing of such Holy days ( amongst other things ) as were prohibited before by his Injunctions : both built upon the same foundation , namely , the resolution of the Clergy in their Convocation . And so it stood until the Reign of King E. 6. at which time the Reformation of the publick Liturgie drew after it by consequence an alteration in the present businesse , no days being to be kept or accounted holy , but those for which the Church had set apart a peculiar office , and not all those neither : For , whereas there are several and peculiar offices for the day of the Conversion of Saint Paul , and the day of Saint Barnabas the Apostles ; neither of these are kept as holy days , nor reckoned or esteemed as such in the Act of Parliament wherein the names and number of the holy days is precisely specified , which makes some think the Act of Parliament to have had an over-ruling power on the Common prayer Book ; but it is not so , there being a specification of the holy days in the book it self , with this direction , These to be ●bs●rved for Hol● days , and non● other ; in which the Feasts of the Conversion of St , Paul , and the Apostle Barnabas are omitt●d plainly , and upon which specification the Stat. 5 & 6 Ed. 6. cap. 3. which concerns the holy days ▪ seems most expresly to be built . And for the Off●ces on tho●e days in the Common-prayer Booke , you may plea●e to know that every holy day consisteth of two special parts , that is to say , r●st or cessati●n from bodily labour , and celebration of Di●ine or Rel●gious du●ies ; and that the day●s before remembred a●e so far kept holy , as to have s●ill their proper and peculiar Off●ces , which is observed in all the Cathedrals of this Kingdome , and the Chappels Royall , where the Service is read every day ; and in most Parish Churches also , as oft as either of them falls upon a Sunday , though the people be not in those days injoined to rest from bodily labour , no more then on the Coronation day , or the fi●th of November , which yet are reckoned by the people for a kind of holy days . Put all which hath been said together , and the ●umme is this ; That the proceedings of this Church in the Reformation were not meerly Regall ( as it is objected by some Puritans ) much les●e that they were Parliamentarian in so great a wo●k , as the Papists falsly charge upon us ▪ the Parliaments for the most part doing li●tle in it , but that they were directed in a justifiable way , the work being done Synodically ▪ by the Clergy onely , according to the usage of the Primi●ive●imes , the King concurring with them , and corroborating what they had ●esolved on , either by his own single Act in his letters Pa●ent . Proclamations and I●junctions or by some publick Act of State , as in 〈◊〉 , and by Acts of Parliament . 6. Of the power of making Canons , for the well ordering of the Clergy , and the directing of the people in the publick Duties of Religion . WE are now come to the last part of this design , unto the power of making Canons , in which the Parliament of England have had lesse to do then in either of the other which are gone before . Concerning which , I must d●sire you to remember , that the Clergie , who had power before to make such Canons and Constitut●ons in their Convocation as to them seemed meet ▪ promised the King in verbo Sacerd●tij , not to Enact or Ex●cute any new Ca●ons , but by his Majesties Royal Assent , and by his authority first obtained in tha● behalf : which is thus bri●fly touched upon in the Ant. Brit. in the l●fe of William Marham Arch Bp of Canterbury , Cler●● in verbo Sacerdotij fidem Regid●dit , ne ulla● deinceps in Synodo ferrent Eccles●asticas leges , nisi e● Synodas auth●ritate R●gia con● gregata , et constitutiones in Synodis publicata● eadem au●●oritate ratae essent . Upon which ground I doubt not but I might securely raise this proposition , That whatso●ver the Clergy did , or might do lawfully before the act of Submission in their Convocation of their own power , without the Kings authority and consent concurring , the same they can , and may do still , since the act of their Submission ; the Kings autho●●ty and consent co-operating with them in their counsels , and giving confirmation to their Constitutions , as was said before . Further , i● doth appear by the aforesaid Act. 25. H. 8. c. 19. ●hat all such Canons , Constitutions , Ordinances , and Synodals Prouincial , as were made be●ore the said Submission , which be not contrary or repugnant to the Laws , Statutes and Customes of this Realm , nor to the damage or hurt of the Ki●gs Prerogative Royal , were to be used and executed as in former times . And by the Statute 26. H. 8. c. 1. of the Kings Supr●macy , that according to the Recognition made in Convocation ) ou● said Soveraign Lord , his heirs and succes●ors , Kings of this Realm , shall have full power and authority from time to time to visit , repress , reform , order , correct , &c. all such Errours , heresies , abuses , offences , contemp●s , and enormities whatsoever they be , &c. as may be most to the pleasure of Almighty God , the increase of vir●●e in Christs Religion , and for the peace , unity , and tranquillity of this Realm , and the confirmation of the same . So that you see these several ways of ordering matters for the Publick weal and governance of the Church ; First by such ancient Canons and Constitutions , as being made in former times , are still in force ; Secondly , by such n●w Canons as are , or shall be made in Convocation , with , and by the Kings Consen● ; And Thirdly , by the authority of the Soveraign Prince , according to the Precedent● laid down in the book 〈…〉 , and the best ag●s of the Church . Concerning which you must remember what was said before , viz. That the Statutes which concern the Kings Supremacy are Declaratory of an old power onely , not Introd●ctory of a new ; which said , we shall the better see whether the Parliament have had any thing to do either in making Canons , or prescribing Orders for the regulating of Spiritual and Ecclesiastical matters , and unto whom the same doth of right belong according to the Laws of the Realm of England . And first , King Henry being restored to his Headship or Supremacy ( call it which you will ) did not conceive himself so absolute in it ( though at the first much enamoured of it ) as not sometimes to take his Convocation with him , but at all ●imes to be advised by his Prelates , when he had any thing to do that concerned the Church ; for which there had been no provision made by the a●cient Canons , grounding most times , his Edicts and ●njuncti●ns Royal , upon their advise and re●●lution . For on this groun● ▪ I mean the judgement and conclusions of his Convocation , did he set out the 〈◊〉 of the yea● 1536. for the abo●●shing of superstitious Holy days , the ex●erminating o● the Popes authority , the publishing of the book o● Articles , which before we spake of ●um . 8. by all Parsons , Vica●s and Curates ; for preaching down the use of Im●ges , Reliques , Pilgrimag●s and supe●stitious Miracles ; for rehea●sing o●enly in the Church , in the English ●ongue ; the Creed , the Pater noster , and the ten Commandements ; for the due and r●verend minist●i●g of the Sacraments and Sacramentals ; for providing English Bible● to be set in every Church for the use of the people ; for the regular and sober life of Clergy men , and the relief of the poor . And on the other side , the King proceeded sometimes onely by the advise of his Prelates , as in the Injunctions of the year 1538. for quarte●ly Sermons in e●ch Parish ; for admitting non● to preach but men sufficien●ly Licenced ; for keeping a Register book of Christnings , Weddings , and Burials ; for the due paying of T●thes , as had been acc●stomed ; for the abolishing of the commemoration of S● . Thomas Becket ; For singing a Parce nobis Domine , in stead of Ora pr●nobis , and the like to these . And of this sort were the Injunctions which came o●t in some years succeeding , for the taking away of Images and Reliques , with all the Ornaments of the same ; and all the Monum●n●s and writings of feigned Miracles , and for restraint of of●●ring or setting up Lights in any Churches , but onely to the Blessed Sacrament of the Altar , in which he was directed chiefly by Archb●shop Cra●●er ; a● also those for eating of white meats in the 〈◊〉 of Lent , the abolishing the Fast on St ▪ Marks day ▪ and the ridiculous ( but supe●stitious sports accustomably used on the days of St. Cl●ment , St. Catherine and St. Ni●holas . All which and more was d●ne in the said Kings Reign without help of Parliament . For which I shall re●er you to the Acts and Mon. fol. 1385 , 1425 1441. The like may also be af●irmed of the Inju●ctions published in the name of K. E. 6. An. 1547. and printed also then for the use of the Subjects ▪ And of the several Letters missive which went forth in his Name , prohibiting the bearing of Candles one Candlemas day : of Ashes in Lent , and of Palms on Palm-sunday ; for the taking down of all the Images throughout the Kingdom ; for administring the Communion in both kinds , dated March 13. 1548. for abrogating of p●ivate Mas●es , Iune 24 ▪ 1549. for bri●ging in all Miss●ls , Graduals , Processionals , Legends and Ordinals about the latter end o●December of the same year : ●or taking down of Altars , and setting up Tables in stead the●eof , An. 1550. and the like to these : All which part●cu●ars you have in 〈◊〉 book of Act● and Mon. in King Edwards life , which whether they were done of the Kings meer motion , or by advice of his Counc●l , or by co●sultation with his Bishops ( ●or there is little left upon R●cord of the Convoca●ions of that time , more then the Articles of the year 1552 ) ce●tain I am that there was nothing done , nor yet p●e●ended to be done in all these particulars by the authority o●Parliament . Thus also in Qu. Elizabe●hs time , before the new B●shops were well setled , and the Q●een as●ured of the af●ections of her Clerg● , she went that way to work in the Reformation , which not onely her two Predeces●ors , 〈◊〉 all the Godly Kings and Princes in the Jewish State , and many o● th●Christian Emperours in the Primitive times had done before her , in the well ordering o● the Church and peop●e committed to their care and government by Almighty God ; and to that end she published her Injunctions , An. 1559. A book of Orde●s ▪ An. 1561. Another of Advertisements , An. 1562. All tending unto Reformation , unto the building up of the new Ierusalem , with the advise and counsel of the Metropolitan ▪ and some other godly Prela●es , who were then ab●ut her , by whom they were agreed on and subscribed unto , before they were presented to her , without the least concurrence of her Court of Parli●ment . But when the times were better se●led , and the first di●●icul●ies of her Reign passed over , she left Church work to the disposing of Church-men , who by their place and calling were most proper for i● ; and they being met in C●●vocation , and thereto authorised as the laws required , did make and publish several books of Canons , as viz. 1571. An. 1584. An. 1597. Which being confirmed by the Queen und●r the broad seal of England ▪ were in force of Laws to all intents and purposes which they were first made ; but being confirmed without those formal words , Her Heirs and Successors , are not binding now , but expired together with the Queen . No Act of Pa●liame●t required to confirm them then , nor never required ever since , on the like occasion . A fuller evidence whereof w● cannot have , then in the Canons of the year , 1603. being the first year of King Iames , made by the Clergie , onely in the C●nvo●●tion , and confirmed onely by the King ▪ for though the old Canons were in force , which had been made before the submis●ion of the Clergie , as before I shewed you , which served in all these wavering and un●etled t●mes , for the perpetu●l standing rule of the Churches govenment ; yet many new emergent c●se● did require new ●ules , and whilest th●re is a possibility of Mali mores ; there will be a necessity of bona Leges . Now in the confirmation of these Canons we shall find it thus , That the Cl●rgy being met in their Convocatio● , according to the Tenour and effect of his Majesties Writ , his M●j●sty was pleased by virtue of his Prerogativ● Royal and Supream authori●y in causes Ecclesiastical , to give and grant un●o them by his Letters Patents dated Apr. 12. and Iun. 25. full , free , and lawfu●l liberty , licence , power and authority , to convene , treat , debate , consider , consult , and agree upon such Canons , Or●ders , Ordinances , and Constitutions , as they should think neces●ary , fit and convenient for the honor and service of Almighty God , the good and quiet of the Church , and the better government thereof from time to time , &c. to be kept by all perso●s within this Realm , as far as lawfully , being members o● the Church it may concern them , which being agreed on by the Cl●rgie , and by them presented to the King , humbly requiring him to give his royal as●ent unto them , according to the Statute made in the 25 of K. H. 8 , and by his Majesties Prerogative and Supream authority in Ecclesiastical causes to ratifie and confirm the same , his Majesty was graciously pleased to confirm and ratifie them by his Letters Patents , for himself , his heirs , and lawfull successours , straightly commanding and requiring all his loving Subj●cts , dilig●ntly to observe , execute , and keep the same in all points , wherein they do or may concern all or any of them . No running to the Parliament to confirm these Canons , nor any question made till this present by temperate and knowing men , that there wanted any act for their confirmation which the law could give them . 7. An Answer to the main Objections of either Party . BUt against this , all which hath been said before , it will be objected , ●hat being the Bishops of the Church are fully and wholly Parliamentarian , and have no more authority and jurisdiction , nisi a Parliamentis derivatum , but that which is con●erred upon them by the power of Parliam●nts , as both Sanders and Schultingius do expresly say , whatsoever they shall do o● conclude upon , either in Convocation , or in more private conferences may be called P●rli●men●arian also . And this last calumny they build on the sev●ral St●tutes 24. H 8. c. 12. touching the manner of e●ecting and consecrating Arch-Bishops and Bishops , that of the 1 E. 6. c. 2. appointing how they shall be chosen , and what sea●s they sha●l u●e ; th●se of 3 and 4 Ed. 6. c. 12. & 5 ▪ & 6. E. 6. ●or authorizing of the book of Ordination . But ch●●fly that of the 8 Eliz. c. 1. for making good all Acts since ▪ 1 Eliz. in co●s●crating , any Arch Bishop or Bishop within this Rea●m . ●o give a general answer to each several cavil , you may please to know ; that the Bishops as they now stand in the Church of England , derive their calling together with their authority and power in Spiritual mat●ers , from no other hands , then those of Christ and his Apostles , their Temporal honors and pos●●●●ions , from the bounty and affection onely of our Kings & Princes , their Ecclesiastical juri●diction in ca●ses Matrimonial , Testamentary and the like , for which no action lieth at the common Law , from continuall usage and prescription ; and ratified and continued unto them in the Magna Charta of this Realm , and 〈◊〉 more unto the Parliament than all sort of subjects do besid●s , whose fortunes and estates have been occasionally and collaterally confirmed in Parliament . And as for the particular Statutes which are touched upon , that of the 24 H. 8. do●h only constitute and ordain a way by which they might be chose and con●ecrated , without recourse to Rome for a con●irmation ▪ which formerly had put the Pr●lates to great charge and trouble ; but for the form and ma●ner of their consecration , the Sta●u●e leaves it to those Rites and Ceremonies wherewith before it was perfo●●ed , and therefore Sanders doth not stick to affirm , that all the Bishops which were made in King Henries days were lawfully and Canonically ordained and cons●crated , the Bishops of that time , not on●ly being acknowledged in Queen Maries days for lawfull and Canonical Bishops , but called on to assist at the consecration of such other Bishops ( Car●inal Pool himself for one ) as were promoted in her Reign , whereof see Masons book de Minist. Ang. l. c. 〈◊〉 Next for the Statute 1 E. 6. cap. 2. besides that it is satisfied in part by the former Answer as it relates to their Canon●cal Consecrations , it was repeaeld to T●rminis in the first of Queene Maries Reigne , and never stood in ●orce nor practise to this day ▪ That of the authorizing of the booke of Ordination in two severall Parliaments of that King , the one a parte ante , and the other a parte post , as before I told you , m●ght indeed seeme somewhat to the purpose , if any thing were wan●ing in it which had beene used i● the formula's of the Primitive times , or if the book had be●n composed in Pa●liament , or by Parliament men , or otherwise received more authority from them , then that i● might be lawfully used and exerc●sed th●oughou● the Kingdome . But it is pl●in , that none of these things were o●jected 〈◊〉 Queen Maries day●● , when the P●pists stood m●st upon their points ▪ 〈◊〉 Ordinal being not ●a●led in , because it had too much of the Parliament , bu● becau●e it had too l●ttle of the Pope , and re●sh●d too strongly of the P●imitive piety . And for the S●atute o● 8 of Qu. Eliz●beth , which is chiefly stood on , all that was done therein was no more then thi● , and on this occasion . A question had been m●de by captiou● and unquiet men , and amongst the rest by Doctor B●nner , sometimes Bishop of London , whether the Bishops of those times were law●ully ordained or not ; the reason of the doub● being this ( which I marvell Mason did not s●e ) because the ●ook of Ordination which was annulled and ab●ogated in the 〈◊〉 of Queen Mary ▪ had not been yet restored , and revived by any legal Act o● Qu. Elizabeths time ; which Cau●e being brought before the P●rliamen● in the 8 year of her Reign , th●P●rli●ment took notice first , that their not restoring of tha● booke 〈…〉 fo●mer power in ter●s significant and expresse , was but 〈…〉 , and then declare , that by the Stature 5 and 6 E. 6. it had been 〈◊〉 to the book of Common-pr●yer and Administration of the Sacram●nss , as a member of it , at least as an App●●dant to it , and therefore by the Sta●u●e 1 Eliz. c. ● . was restored again together with the s●id boo● 〈◊〉 Common-prayer , intentionally at the least , if not in Terminis . But 〈…〉 words in the said Statute were not clear enough to remove all doub●s they therefore did revive now , and did accordingly enact , That whatso●ve● had been done by vertue of that Ordination , should be good in Law , 〈…〉 the total of the Statute , and this shews rather in my judgement , tha● the Bishops of the Queens first times had too little of the Parliament in them , then that they were conceived to have had too much . And so I come to your la●t Objection , which concerns the Parliament , whose entertaining all occasions to manifest their power in Ecclesiasticall mat●●●● , doth seeme to you to make that groundlesse sl●nder of the P●pists the more fair and pla●sible . 'T is true , indeed , that many Members of both Houses in these latter Times , have been ●een very ready to embrace all businesses which are offered to them , out of a probable hope of drawing the managery of all Affairs , as well Ecclesiastical as Civil , into their own hands . And some there are , who being they cannot hope to have their fancies authorized in a regular way , do put them upon such designs , as neither can consist with the nature of Parliaments , nor the authority of the King , nor with the priviledges of the Clergy ; nor , to say truth , with the esteem and reputation of the Church of Christ . And this hath been a practice even as old as Wicklisse , who in the time of K. R. 2. addressed his Petition to the Parliament ( as we read in Walsingham ) for the reformation of the Clergy , the rooting out of many false and erroneous Tenents , and for establishing of his own Doctrines ( who though he had some Wheat , had more Tares by ods ) in the Church of England . And lest he might be thought to have gone a way , as dangerous and unjustifiable , as it was strange and new , he laid it down for a position , That the Parliament , or Temporal Lords ( where by the way this ascribes no authority or power at all to the House of Commons ) might lawfully examine and reform the Disorders and Corruptions of the Church , and a discovery of the errors and corruptions of it , devest her of all Tithes and Temporal endowments , till she were reformed . But for all this , and ( more then this ) for all he was so strongly back●d by the Duke of Lancaster , neither his Petition nor his Position found any welcome in the Parliament , further then that it made them cast many a longing eye on the Churches pa●rimony ; or produced any other effect towards the work of reformation , which he chiefly aimed at , then that it hath since served for a precedent to Penry , Pry● , and such like troublesome and unquiet spirits , to disturb the Church , and set on foot those dreams and dotages , which otherwise they du●st not publish . And to say truth , as long as the Clergy were in power , and had authority in Convocation to do what th●y would in matters which concerned Religion ; those of the Parliament conceived it neither safe nor fitting to intermeddle in such business as concerned the Clergy , for fear of being questioned for it at the Churches Bar. But when that Power was lessened ( though it were not lost ) by the submission of the Clergy to K. H. 8. and by the Act of the Supremacy which ensued upon it ; then did the Parliaments begin to intrench upon the Churches Rights , to offer at , and entertain such businesses , as formerly were held peculiar to the Clergy only ; next , to dispute their charters and reverse their priviledges ; and finally , to impose some hard Lawes upon them . And of these notable incroachments , Matthew Parker thus complains in the life of Cranmer , Qua Ecclesiasticarum legum potestate abdicata , populus in Parliamento coepit de rebus divinis inconsulto Clero Sancire , tum al s●ntis C●eri privileg●a sensim de●rahere , ju●a●● duriora quibus Cl●rus invitus teneretur , Constituere . But these were only tentamenta , offers and undertakings only , and no more then so . Neither the Parliaments of K Edward , or Q. Elizabeths time knew what it was to make Committees for Religion , or thought it fit that Vzzah should support the A●k ▪ though he saw it tottering . That was a work belonging to the Levites only , none of the other Tribes were to meddle with it . But as the ●uritan Faction grew more strong and active , so they applyed themselves more openly to the Houses of Parliament , but specially to the House of Commons ; p●tting all power into their hands , as well in Ecclesiastical and spiritual Causes , as in matt●rs Temporal . This , amongst others , confidently affirmed by Mr. Pryn , in the Epistle to his book called Anti-Arminianism , where he a●ers , That all our Bishops , our Ministers , our Sacraments , our Consecration , our Articles of Religion , our Homilies , Common-prayer Book , yea , and all the Religion of the Church , is no other way publiquely received , supported , or established amongst us , but by Acts of Parliament . And this not only since the time of the Reformation , but that Religion and Church affairs were determined , ratified , declared , and ordered by Act of Parliament , and no waies else , even then when Popery and Church-men had the grea●●● 〈◊〉 . Which strange assertion falling from the pen of so great a 〈◊〉 , was forthwith cheerfully received amongst our Pharisces , who hoped to have the highest places , not only in the Synagogue , but the Court of Sanhedrim , advancing the Authority of Parliaments to so high a pitch , that by degrees they fastened on them , both an infallibility of judgement , and an ●mnipotency of power . Nor can it be denied ( to deal truly with you ) but that they met with many apt scholars in that House , who either out of a desire to bring all the grist to their own Mill , or willing to enlarge the great power of Parliaments , by making new precedents for Posterity , or out of faction , or affection , or what else you please , began to put their Rules in practise , and draw all matters whatsoever within the cognizance of that Court ; In which their embracements were at last so general , and that humour in the House so prevalent ; that one being once demanded , what they did amongst them , returned this answer , That they were making a new Creed : Another being heard to say , That he could not be quiet in his conscience , till the holy Text should be confirmed by an Act of theirs : Which passages , if they be not true and real , ( as I have them from an honest hand ) I assure you they are bitter jests . But this , although indeed it be the sicknesse and disease of the present Times , and little to the honour of the Court of Parliament , can be no prejudice at all to the way and means of the Reformation ; amongst sober and discerning men , the Doctrine of the Church being setled , the Liturgy published and confirmed , the Can●ns authorized and executed , when no such humour was predominant , nor no such power pretended to , by both or either of the Houses of Parliament . But here perhaps it will be said that we are fallen into Charyb●is by avoiding S●yl●a , and that endevouring to stop the mouth of this Popish Calumny , we have set open a wide gap to another no lesse scandalous of the Presbyterians ; who being as professed enemies of the Kings as the Popes Supremacy , and noting that strong influence which the King h●●h had in Ecclesiastical affairs since the first attempts for Reformation , have charg'd it as reproachfully on the Church of England , and the Religion here est●blished , 〈…〉 and a Regal-Gospel . But the Answer unto this is 〈◊〉 For first the Kings intended by the Objectors , did not act much in order to the Reformation ( as appears by that which hath been said ) but either by the advice and cooperation of the whole Clergy of the Realm in their Convocations , or by the Counsel and consent of the Bishops and most eminent Church-men in particular Conferences : which made it properly the work of the Clergy only , the Kings no otherwise then as it was propounded by him , or finally confirmed by the Civil S●nction . And secondly , had they done more in it then they did , they had been warranted so to do by the Word of God ; who hath committed unto Kings and soveraign Princes a Supreme or supereminent power , not only in all matters of a Temporal , or secular nature , but in such a● do concern Religion and the Church of Christ . And so S ▪ Augustine hath resolved it in his thi●d Book against Cres●onius . In hoc Reges sicut iis divinitus praecipitur : ( pray you note that well ) Deo serviunt in quantum Reges sunt , si in suo Regno bona jubeant , mala prohibeant , non solum quae p●rtinent ad humanam societatem , verum etiam ad Divinam Religionem . Which words of his ●●emed so significant and convincing unto Hart the Iesuite , that being shewed the Tractate writ by Dr. Nowell against Dorman the Priest in the beginning of Q Elizabeths time , and finding how the case was stated by that reverend person , he did ingenu●usly confesse , that there was no authority ascribed to the Kings of England in Ecclesiastical affaire , but what was warranted unto them by that place of Augustine . The like affirmed by him that calleth himself Francis●us de S. Cl●ra , though a Iesuite too ( that you may see how much more candid and ingenuous the Iesuites are in this point then the Presbyterians ) in his Examen of the Articles of the Church of England . But hereof you may give me opportunity to speak more hereafter , when you propose the Doubts which you say you have , relating to the King , the Pope , and the Churches Protestant , and therefore I shall say no more of it at the present time . SECT. II. The manner of the Reformation of the Church of England declared and justified . HItherto I had gone in order to your satisfaction and communicated my conceptions in writing to you , when I received your letter of the 4. of Ianuary , in which you signified the high contentment I had given you , in cond●scending to your weaknesse , ( as you pleased to call it ) and freeing you from those doubts which lay heaviest on you . And therewithall you did request me to give you leave to propound those other Scruples which were yet behinde , relating to the King , the Pope and the Protestant Churches , either too little or too much looked after in the Reformation . And first you say it is complained of by some Zelots of the Church of Rome , that the Pope was very hardly and unjustly dealt with in being deprived of the Supremacy so long enjoyed and exercised by his predecessors , and that it was an innovation no lesse strange then dangerous to settle it upon the King. 2. That the Church of England ought not to have proceeded to a Reformation without the Pope , considered either as the Patriarch of the Western world , or the Apostle in particular of the English Nation . 3. That if a Reformation had been found so necessary , it ought to have been done by a General Councel , at least with the consent and co-operation of the Sister-Churches , especially of those who were engaged at the same time in the same designs . 4. That in the carrying on of the Reformation the Church proceeded very unadvisedly , in letting the people have the Scriptures and the publique Liturgie in the ●ulgar tongue , the dangerous consequents whereof are now grown too visible . 5. That the proceedings in the point of the Common-prayer Book were meerly Regall , the body of the Clergy not consulted with , or consenting to it ; and consequently not so Regular as we fain would have it . And 6. That in the power of making Canons and determining matters of the Faith , the Clergy have so ●ettered and in●angled themselves by the Act of Submission , that they can neither meet , deliberate , concl●de nor ●x●cute , but as they are enabled by the Kings authority , which is a Vassallage inconsistent with their native Libertie● , and not agreeable to the usage of the Primitive times . These are the points in which you now desire to have satisfaction , and you shall have it in the best way I am able to do it , that so you may be freed hereafter from such ●roubles and Disputants , as I perceive have laboured to perplex your thoughts , and make you lesse affectionate then formerly to the Church your Mother . 1. That the Church of England did not innova●e in the Ej●ction of the Pope , and setling the Supremacy in the Regal Crown . And in this point you are to know that it hath been and still is the general and constant judgement of the greatest Lawyers of this Kingdome , that the vesting of the Supremacy in the Crown Imperial of this Realm , was not Introductory of any new Right or Power which was not in the Crown before , but Declaratory of an old , which had been anciently and original●y inherent in it , though of late Times usurped by the Popes of Rome , and in Abeyance at that time , as our Lawyers phrase it . And they have so resolved it upon very good 〈◊〉 ●●he principal manag●ry of 〈◊〉 which conce●n Religion being a flower inseparably annexed to the ●egal Diadem , not proper and peculiar only to the Kings of England , but to all Kings and Princes in the Church of God , and by them exercised and enjoyed accordingly in their times and places . For who , I pray you , we●e the men in the Iewish Church who destroy●d the Idols of that people , cut down the Groves , demolished the high places , and brake in pi●ces the Brazen Serpent , when abused to Idolatry ? Were they not the godly King● and Prince● only which sw●y●● 〈◊〉 Scepter of that Kingdom● ? And though ' ●is possible 〈◊〉 that they might do it by the counsel and advice of the High Priests of that Nation , or of some of the more godly Priests and Levites ( who had a zeal unto the L●w of the most high God ) yet we finde nothing of it in the holy Scripture ; the merit of these Reformations which were made occasionally in that faulty Church , being ascribed unto their Kings , and none but them . Had they done any thing in this which belonged not to their place and calling , or by so doing had intrenched on the Office of the Pri●sts and Levites , that God who punished Vzzah for attempting to support the Arke when he saw it tot●ering , and smote Osias with a Leprosie for burning incense in the Temple ( things which the Priests and Levites only were to meddle in ) would not have suffered those good Kings to have gone unpunished , or at least uncensured , how good so●ver their intentions and 〈◊〉 we●e . Nay , on the contrary , when any thing was amis●e in the Church of Iewry , the King● , and not the 〈◊〉 were admonished of it , and reproved for it by the Prophets ; which sheweth that they were trusted with the Reformation , and none else but they . Is it not also said of David , that he distributed the Priests and Levites into several Classes , alot●e● to them the particular times of their Ministration , and designed them unto several Offices in the Publick Service ? Iosephus adding to these passages of the Holy Writ , That he c●mposed Hymns and Songs to the Lord his God , and made them to be sung in the Congregation , as an especial part of the publick Liturgy . Of which , although it may be said that he composed those Songs and Hymns by vertue of his Prophetical Spirit , yet he imposed them on the Church , appointed singing-men to sing them , and prescribed Vestments also to thes●singing-men , by no other power then the regal only : None of the Pri●sts consulted in i● , for ought yet appears . The like authority was ●xercised and enjoyed by the Christian Emperors , not only in their calling Councels , and many times assisting at them , or presiding in them by themselves , or their Deputies , or Commissioners ; but also in confirming the Acts thereof . He that consults the C●de and 〈◊〉 in the Civil Lawes , will finde the best Princes to have been most active in things which did concern Religion , in regulating matters of the Church , and setting out their Imperial Edicts for suppressing of Hereticks . Quid Im●eratori cum Ecclesia ? What hath the Emperor to d● in matters which concern the Church ? is one of the chief Brand marks which Optatus sets upon the Donatists . And though some Christians of the East have in the way of scorn had the name of Melchites ( men of the Kings Religion , as the word doth intimate ) b●cause they adhered unto those Doctrines which the Emperors , agreeable to former Councels , had confirmed and ratified : yet the best was , that none but Sectaries and Hereticks put that name upon them . Neither the men , nor the Religion was a ●ot the worse . Nor did they only deal in matters of Exterior Order , but even in Doctrinals , matters intrinsecal to the Faith ; for which their Enoticon set out by the Emperor Zeno for setling differences in Religion , may be proof suffici●n●● The like authority was exercised and enjoyed by Charles the Great , when he attained the Western Empire , as the Capitula●s published in hi● Name , and in the names of his Successors , do most clearly evidence ; and not much lesse enjoyed and practis●d by the Kings of England in the elder Times , though more obnoxious to the power of the Pope of Rome , by reason of his Apostleship ( if I may so call it ) : the Christian Faith being first preached unto the English Saxons , by such as he employed in that holy Work . The instance● whereof dispersed in several places of our English Histories , and other Monuments and Records which concern this Church , are handsomely summed up together by Sir Edward Coke in the fift part of his Reports , if I well remember ▪ but I am sure in Cawd●ies Case , entituled , De Iure Regis Ecclesiastico . And though Parsons ( the Iesuite ) in his Answer unto that Report , hath took much pains to vindicate the Popes Supremacy in this Kingdome , from the first planting of the Gospel among the Saxons ; yet all he hath effected by it , proves no more th●n this , That the Popes , by permission of some weak Princes , did exercise a kinde of concurrent jurisdiction here with the Kings themselves , but came not to the full and entire Supremacy , till they had brought all other Kings and Princes of the Western Empire ; nay ▪ even the Emperors themselves under their command . So that when the Supremacy was recognized by the Clergy in their Convocation●o K. H. 8. it was only the restoring of him to his proper and original power , invaded by the Popes of these later Ages ; though possi●ly the Title of Supreme Head seemed to have somewhat in it of an 〈◊〉 . At which Title , when the Papists generally and Calvin in his Comment on the Prophet Amos , did seem to be much scandaliz●d , it was with much wisdome changed by Q. Elizabeth into that of Supreme Governour , which is still in use . And when that also would not down with some queasie stomachs , the Queen her self by her Injunctions , published in the first year of her Reign , and the Clergy in their Book of Articles agreed upon in Convocation about five years a●ter , did declare and signifie , That there was no authority in s●cred matters contained under that Title , but that only Prerogative which had b●en given alwaies to all godly Princes in holy Scriptu●es by God himself ; that i● , That they should rule all Estates and degrees committ●d to their change by God , whether they be Ecclesiastical or Temporal , and to restrain , with the Civil Sword , the stubborn and evil d●ers ; as also to exclude thereby the Bishop of Rome from having any jurisdiction in the Realm of England , Artic. 37. Lay this unto the rest before , and tell me ( if you c●n ) what hath been acted by the Kings of England in the Reformation of Religion , but what is warranted unto them by the practise and example of the most godly Kings of Iewry , seconded by the most godly Emperor● in the Christian Church , and by the usage also of their own Predecessors in this Kingdome , till Papal Usurpation carried all before it . And being that all the Popes pretended to in this Realm was but Usurpation , it was no wrong to take that from him which he had no right to , and to restore it at the last to the proper Owner . Neither Prescription on the one side , nor discontinuance on the other , change the case at all : that noted Maxim of our Lawyers that no prescription●indes the King ( or Nullum tempus occurrit Regi , as their own words are ) being as good against the Pope , as against the Subject . This leads me to the second part of this Dispute , the dispossessing of the Pope of that supreme Power , so long enjoyed and exercised in this Realm by his Predecessors . To which we say that though the pretensions of the Pope were antient , yet they were not Primitive : and therefore we may answer in our Saviours words , Ab initio non ●uit sic , it was not so from the beginning . For it is evident enough in the course of story , that the Pope neither claimed nor exercised any such Supermacy within this Kingdome in the first Ages of this Church , nor in many after ; till by gaining from the King the 〈◊〉 of Bishops under Henry the ● . the exemption of the Clergy from the Courts of Justice ●nder Henry the 2. and the submission of King Iohn to the See of Rome , they found themselves of strength sufficient to make good their Plea . And though by the like artifices , seconded by some Texts of Scripture , which the ignorance of those times incouraged them to abuse as they pleased , they had attained the like Supremacy in France , Spain , and Germany , and all the Churches of the West : yet his incroachm●nts wer● opposed , and his authority disputed upon all occasions , especially a● the light of Letters did begin to shine . Insomuch as it was not only determined essentially in the Councel of Constance ( one of the Imperial Cities of High Germany ) that the Councel was above the Pope ; and his Authority much 〈◊〉 by the Pragmatick Sanction , which thence took beginning : but Gerson the learned Chancellor of Paris wrote a full discourse , entituled , De auferibilitate Papae , ●ouching the totall abrogating of the Papall Office ; which certainly he had never done in case the Papall Office had been found ●ssential and of intrinsecal concernment to the Church of Christ . According to the Position of that learned man the greatest Princes in these times did look upon the Pope and the Papall power as an Exc●escence at the best in the body mystical ; subject and fit to be pared off as occasion served : though on self-ends , Reasons of State , and to serve their several turn● by him as their needs required , they did and do permit him to continue in his former greatnesse . For Lewis the 11. King of France in a Councel of his own Bishops held at Lions , cited Pope Iulius the 2. to appear before him : and La●strech Governour of Millaine under Francis the 1. conceived the Popes authority to be so unnecessary ( yea even in Italy it self ) that taking a displeasure against Leo the 10. he outed him of all his jurisdiction within that Dukedome , anno 1528. and so disposed of all Ecclesiasticall affairs ; ut praefecto sacris Bigorrano Episc●po omnia sine Romani Pontificis autoritate admin●strarentur , as Thuanu● hath it , that the Church there was supremely governed by the Bishop of Bigorre ( a Bishop of the Church of France ) without the intermedling of the Pope at all . The like we finde to have been done about six years after , by Charle● the fift Emperor and King of Spain , who being no lesse displeased with Pope Clement the 7. abolished the Papall power and jurisdiction out of all the Churches of his Kingdomes in Spain . Which though it held but for a while , ( till the breach was closed ) yet left he an example by it ( as my A●thor noteth ) Ecclesiasticam disciplinam citra Romani nominis autoritatem posse conservari , that there was no necessity of a Pope at all . And when K ▪ Henry the 8. following these examples , had banished the Popes authority out of his Dominions , Religion still rema●ning here as before it did ( he Pope●Supremacy not being at that time an Article of the Christian Faith , as it ha●h since been made by Pope Pius the 4. ) that Act of his was much commended by most knowing men , in that without more alteration in the face of the Church Romanae sedis exuisset obsequium ( saith the Author of the Tridentine History ) he had ●reed himself and all his subjects from so great a Vassa●lage . Now as K. Henry the 8. was not the first Christian P●ince , who did de facto abrogate the Popes authority : so was he not the last that thought it might be abrogated if occasion were . For to say nothing of King Edward the 6. and Queen Elizabeth two of hi● Successo●s , who followed his example in it : we finde it to have been resolved on by K. Henry the 4. of France ▪ who questionlesse had made the Archbishop of Bou●ges the Patriarch of the Gallicane Church , and totally with●rawn it from acknowledging of the authority of the See of Rome , had not Pope Clement the 8. ( much against his will ) by the continual solicitations of Cardinal D' Ossat , admitt●d him to a formal Reconciliation , on his last falling off to popery . How nee● the Signeury of Venice was to have done the like , anno 1608. the History of the Interdict , or of the Quarrel● betwixt that State and Pope Paul the 5. doth most plainly shew . This makes it evident , that in the judgement and esteem of most Christian P●inces ( in other things of the Religion of the Church of Rome ) the Popes Supremacy was looked upon as an incroachment ; and therefore might be abrogated upon bet●●● 〈…〉 been admitted in their several Kingdome● . By cons●quence the doing of it here in England , neither so injurious or unjust as your Zelots make it . 2. That the Church of England might proceed to a Reformation without the Approbation of the Pop● or Church of Rome . But here you say it will be replied , that though the Pope 〈◊〉 not con●id●re● a● the 〈…〉 of the Church ; with reference wher●unto his super eminent jurisdiction was disputed in the former times : yet it cannot be denied with reason , but that he is the Patriarch of these W●stern Churches , and the Apostle in particular of the English Nation . In these respects no Reformation of the Church to be made without him : especially , considering that the Church of England at that time was a Member of the Church of Rome , and therefore to act nothing in that kinde but by consent of the whole ; according to that known Maxim of the Schools , Turpis est pars ea qu●e toti su● non cohaere●t . This though it be a Triple Cord , will be easily broken . For first the P●pe is not the Patriarch of the West . One of the Patri●●●● of the W●st we shall easily grant him ; but that he is the Patriarch we will by no means yeeld . To tell you why we dare not yeeld it , I must put you in minde of these particulars : 1. That all Bishops in respect of their Office or Episcopality are of equall power , whether they be of Rome or Rhegium , of Constantinople or Engubium , of Alexa●dria or of Tanais , as S. Hierom hath it , Potn●ia divitiarum & paupertatis humilitas vel sublimiorem vel in●eriorem ●piscopum non faci● . A plentiful Revenue and a sorry Competency makes not ( saith he ) one Bishop higher then another in regard of his office , though possibly of more esteem and reputation in the eyes of men . 2. That in respect to Polity and external order , the Bishops antien●ly were disposed of into Sub et supra , according to the Platform of the Roman Empire , agreeable to the good old Rule which we finde mentioned , though not made in the general Councel of Chalc●don , that is to say , {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} &c. The 〈…〉 Civil State . 3. That the Rom●n Empire was divided an●iently into 14 Juridical Circuit● , which they called Diocesses , reckoning the Praefecture o●Rome for one of the number : six of the which , that is to say the Diocess●s of Italie , Africk , Spain Britain , Gaul , and Illyricum occidentale , besides the P●aefecture of the City , were under the command of the Western Empero●s , after the Empire was divided into East and West . 4. That in the P●aefecture of the City of Rome were contained no more than the Provinces of Latium , Tuscia , Picenum 〈…〉 and Lucania , in the main land of Italy , t●gether with the Islands of Sicilie , Corsica and Sardinia . 5. That every Province having s●veral Cities , there was ( agreeable to this model ) a Bishop plac●d in every City , a Metropolitan in the chief City of each Province , who had a superintendence over all the Bishops ; and in each Diocesse , a Primate ruling in chief over the Metropolitans of the several Provinces . And 6. though at fi●st only the three Primates or Arch-bishops of Rome , Antioch , and Al●xandria , commonly and in vulgar speech had the name of Patriarchs , by reason of the wealth and greatn●sse of those Cities ( the greatest of the Roman E●pire , and the chief of Europe , Asia , and Africa ) to which the Bishops of Hierusalem and 〈◊〉 were after added : yet were they all of ●qual power am●ng themselve● , and shined with as full a splendor in their proper Orbes as any of the Popes then did in the Sphere of Rome , receiving all their light from the Sun of righteousnesse , not borrowing it from one another ; for which the so much celebrated Canon of the N●cene Councel may may be pro●f su●●icient . If not the Edicts of Ius●inian shall come in to help , by which it was decreed that all Appeals in point of grievance should lie from the Bishop to the Metropolitan , and from the Metropolitans unto the Primates ( the Patriarchs as he cals them ) of the several Diocess●s . By which accompt it doth appear that the Patriarch●te of Rome was an●iently confined within the Praefecture of that City : in which respect as the Provinces subject to the Pope were by Ruffinus called Regiones Suburbicariae , or the City Provinces ; so was the Pope himself called Vrbicus , or the City-Bishop by Optatus A●er . To prove this point more pl●inly by particular instances ▪ I shall take leave to travel over the Western Diocesses , to se● what marks of Independence we can finde among them : such as dissenting in opinion from the Church of Rome , or adhering unto different ceremonies and formes of worship , or otherwise standing in defence of their own authority . And first the Diocesse of Italy , though under the Popes nose ( as we use to say ) was under the command of the Archbishop of Millaine , as the Primate of it : which City is therefore called by Athanasius {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} the Metropolis or chief City o●Italy . The Saturdaies fast observed at Rome and not at Millaine , ( Quando Romae sum jejuno Sabbato , quum hic sum non jejuno Sabbato , as S. Ambrose hath it ) shewes clearly that the one had no d●pendence upon the other . And yet the diff●rence of Divine Offices or Formes of worship is a more pregnant proof then this : the Churches of Millain officiating for many ages by a Liturgie which S. Ambrose had a special hand in ; they of the Patriarchate of Rome following the old Roman Missals , not fully finished and compleated till the time of Pope Gregory . Whence the distinction of Ecclesiae Ambrosianae & Ecclesiae Gregorianae , extant in Bonaventure and others of the writers of the later times . Crosse we the Seas unto the Diocesse of Africk , governed in chief by the P●imate or Archbishop of Carthage : and there we finde S. Cyprian determining against Pope Stephen in the then controverted case of Rebaptization ; and calling him ( in his Epistle of Pompeius ) an obstinate and presumptuous man , and a fauter of Hereticks : no very great tokens of subjection , if you mark it well . The error of his judgement in the point debated I regard not here ; but I am sure that in defence of his authority and jurisdiction , he was right enough : and therein strongly seconded by the African Church , opposing the incroachments of Zosimus , Boniface , and Celestine , succeeding one another in the Roman Patr●archa●e ; prohibiting all appeals to Rome in the Councels of Milevis and Carthage ; and finally ●xcommunicating Lupicinus for appealing to Pope Leo the first , contrary to the rites and liberties of the African Church . Next for the Diocesse of Spain , I look upon the Musarabick Liturgie composed by Isidore , Archbishop of Sevil , and universally received in all the Churches of that Continent 〈…〉 as the Am●rosian Office was in the Church of M●llain ; the Roman or Gregorian Missal not being used in all this Countrey till the year 1083. At which time one Bernard a Frenchman and a great stickler in behalf of the Roman Ceremonies , being made Archbishop of Toledo , by practising with Alfonso the then King of Castile , first introduced the Roman Missall into some of the Churches of that City , and after by degrees into all the rest of those Kingdomes : soon after the Chu●ches of France , the greatest and most noble part of the Gallick Diocesse , they were originally under the authority of the Bishop of Lions , as their proper Primate , not owing any sui● of s●rvice to the Court of Rome ; but standing on their own Basis , and acting all 〈…〉 did . The freedome wherewith I●enaeu● the renowned 〈◊〉 of that City reproved the rashnesse of Pope Victor ( in the Case of Easter ) not well becoming an inferi●r Bishop to the Supreme Pastor : shewes plainly that they stood on even ground , and had no advantage of each other in respect of sub & supra , as Logicians say : notwithstanding that more powerful Principality ( potentior principalitas , as the Latin : hath it ) which Irenaeus did allow him over those at home . But a more evident proof of this there can hardly be then those large lib●rties and freedomes which the Church Gallican doth at this time enjoy ; the remainders past all doubt of those antient rights which under their own Patriarch they were first possessed of : not suffering the Decrees of the Councel of Trent ( that great supporter of the Pop●dome ) to take place amongst them , but as insensi●ly and by the practises of some Bishop● they were introduced ; cu●bing the Popes exorbitant power by the pragmatick Sanction , and by the frequent Judgements and Arrests of Parliament : insomuch ●s a Book of Cardinal 〈◊〉 tending to the advancement of the Papall Monarchy , and another writ by Becanus the Iesuite●nti●uled Controv●rsia Anglicana in maintenance of the Popes supremacy , we●e supp●essed and cen●u●ed , anno 1612. Another writ by ●asp●r Schioppius to the same effect ( but with ●ar lesse modesty ) being at the same time burnt by the hands of the Hangman . Finally , for the Churches of the Diocesse of Britain ( those of Illyricum lying too far off to be brought in here ) they had their own Primate also the Archbishop of York , and under him two Metropolit●n● , the Bishops of London and Caer-leon . And for a character of their Freedome or self subsistence , they had four different customes from the Church of Rome , as in the Tonsure , and the keeping of the Feast of Easter , wherein they followed the Tradition of the Eastern Churches : So firm withall in their obedience to their own Primate , the Archbishop of Ca●r-leon on Vsh ( the only Archbishop of three which before they had ) that they would by no means yeeld sub●ection unto Augustine the Monk , the first Archbishop of the English , though he came armed amongst them with the Popes authority . Nor would they afterwards submit unto his successors , though backed by the authority of the Kings of England , acknowledging no other Primate but the Bishop of St. Davids ( to which the Metropolitan See was then translated ) untill the time of Henry the 2. when the greatest part of South Wales and the City of S. Davids it self was in possession of the English . These were the Patriarchs or Primates of the Western Churches , and by these Primates the Church was either governed singly ( but withall supremely ) in their several Diocesses , ( taking the word Diocese in the former notion ) or in conjunction each with other by their letters of advice and intercourse , which they called Literas Formatas and Communicatorias . You see by this that though the Pope was one of the Western Patriarchs , yet was he not originally and by primitive Insti●ution , either the Patriarch of the West , ( that is to say not the only one ) nor could pretend unto their Rights , as any of their Sees were ruined by the barbarous Nations : and consequently his consent not necessary to a Reformation beyond the bounds of his own Patriarchate , under that pretence . Let us next see what power he can lay claim unto , as the Apostle in particular of the English Nation . Which memorable title I shall never grudge him . I know well not only that the wife of Ethelbert King of Kent , a Christian and a daughter of France had both her Chappel and her Chappellane in the Palace Royal , before the first preaching of Austin the Monk ; but that the Britains living intermixt with the Saxons for so long a time , may be supposed in probability and reason to have gained some of them to the Faith . But let the Pope enjoy this honour , let Gregory the Great be the Apostle of the English Saxons , by whom that Augustine was sent hither : yet this en●i●uleth his Successors to no higher Prerogatives then the Lords own Apostles did think fit to claim in Countreys which they had converted . For neither were the English Saxons Baptized in the name of the Pope ( they had been then Gregoriani and not Christiani ) ; or looked upon him as the Lord of this part of Gods 〈…〉 S. Paul the Apostle of the Gentiles did disclaim the one ; S. Peter the Apostle of the Iewes did disswade the other . The Anglican Church was absolute and Independent from the first beginning , not tyed so much as to the Ceremonies of the Church of Rome : it being left by Gregory to the discretion of Augustine , out of the Rites and Rubricks of such Churches as he met with in his journey hither ( these of Italie and France he means ) to constitute a form of worship for the Church of England . And for a further proof hereof , he that consults the Saxon Councels collected by that learned and ind●striou● Gentleman Sir H ▪ Spelman , will finde how little there was in them of a Papall influence , from the first planting of the Gospel to the Norman Conquest . If we look lower we shall finde , that the Popes Legat a Latere whensoever sent , durst not set foot on English ground , till he was licensed and indemnified by the Kings Authority : but all Ap●eals in case of grievance were to be made ( by a Decree of Henry the 2. ) from the Archdeacon to the Bishop , from the Bishop to the Metropolita● , Et si Archiepiscopus defecerit in justitia exhibenda , ad Dominum Regem deveniendum est postremo , and last of all from the Metropolitan to the King himself ; no Appeal hence unto the Pope as in other places , that the Clergy of this land had a self-authority of treating and concluding in any businesse which concerned their own peace and happinesse , without resorting ●o the Pope for a confirmation . Out of which Canons and Determinations made amongst our s●lve● , Lindwood composed his Provincial ( though framed according to the method of the Roman D●cretal ) to be the standing body of ou●Common-Law : that on the other side neither the Canons of that Church , or Decretals of the Popes were c●ncluding here , but either by a voluntary submission of some ●●●ning and ambitiou● P●●lates , or as they were received Synodically by the English Cle●gy ; of which the con●●itutions made by O●he and Otheb●n Leg●ts a l●tere from the Pope may be proof sufficient : a●d finally that Ans●●m the A●chbish●p of Canterbury , was welcomed by Pope V●ban the 2. to the Councel of B●ri in Apulia , tanquam alterius orbis Papa , as in William of Malmesbury ; tanquam Patriarcham & Apostolicum , as Iohn Capgrave hath it ▪ as the Pope , Patriarch , and Apostolick P●●●or of another World ( Divisos orbe Brita●●os , as you know who said ) . Which ti●les questionlesse the Pope would n●ver have con●●●red upon him , had he not been as ●bsolute and supreme in his own jurisdiction ( succeeding in the Patriarchal Rights of the British Diocesse ) as the Pope was within the Churches ●ubject unto his Au●●ority . And this perh●ps might be the reason why Innocent the 2. bestow●d on Theobald ( the third from Ans●lm ) and on his Su●cesso●s in that S●e , the Title of Legati n●ti ; that they might seem to act rather in the time to come as Servants and Ministers to the Pope , then as the Primates●nd chief Pastors of the Church of England . And by all this it may appear that the Popes Apostleship was never looked on here as a matter of so great concernment , that the Church might not lawfully proceed to a R●formation without his allowance and consent . Were that plea good , the Germans might not lawfully have reformed themselves , without the allowance of the English : it being evident in story that not only Boniface Archbishop of Men●z , called generally the Apostle of Germany , was an Engglish man ; but that Willibald the first Bishop of Eystel , Willibad●he first Bishop of Bremen , Willibrod the first Bishop of Vtreoht , Swibert the first Bishop of Vir●●em , and the fi●st converter● of those parts were of England also men instigated to this great work ( all except the first ) not so much by the Pope● zeal as their own great piety . By this that hath been said it is clear enough that the Church of England at the time of the Reformation , was not indeed a Member of the Church of Rome , under the Pope a● the chief Pastor and Supreme Head of the Church of CHRIST : but a Fellow-member with it of that Body Mystical whereof CHRIST only is the Head , part of that ●●ock whereof he only i● the Sheph●rd : a sister Church to that of Rome , though with relation to the time of her last conversion , but a younger Sister . And if a Fellow-member and a Sister-Church , she might make use of that authority which naturally and originally was vested in her , to reform her self , without the leave of the particular Church of Rome , or any other whatsoever of the Sister-Churches . The Church is likened to a City in the Book of God , a City at unity in it self , as the Psalmist cals it ; and as a City it consisteth of many houses , and in each house a several and particular Family . Suppose this City visi●ed with some general sicknesse , may no● each family take care to preserve it self , advise with the Physitian , and apply the Remedy , without consulting with the rest ? Or if consulting with the rest , must they needs ask leave also of the Maior or principal Magistrate , take counsel with no other Doctors , and follow no other course of Physick then such as he commends unto them , or imposeth on them ? Or must the lesser languish irremediably under the calamity , because the greater and more potent Families do not like the cure ? Assuredly it was not so in the primitive times , whe● it was held a commendable and lawfull thing for National and particular Churches to reform such errors and corruptions as they found amongst them ; nor in the Church of Iudah n●ither , when the Idolatries of their N●ighbours had got ground upon them ▪ Though Isra●l transgress● , 〈◊〉 not Judah sin , saith the Prophet Hosea chap. 4. Yet Israel was the greater and more numerous people . Ten Tribes to two ; two of the ten the eld●st sons of their Father Iacob , all of them older then Benjamin the last begotten ▪ being the second of the two : which notwithstanding the Kings of Iudah might and did proceed to a Reformation , though those of Israel did refuse to co-operate with them . The like was also done de facto and de jure too in the best and happiest-times of Christianity : there b●ing many errors and un●ound opinions condemned in the Councels of G●ngra , Aquilia , Cart●age ▪ Mil●vis ; and not a ●ew cor●up●ions in the practical part of Religion reformed in the Synods of ●liberis , Laodic●a , Arles , and others in the fourth Century of the Church : without advising or consul●ing with the R●man Oracle , or running to the Church of Rome for a confirmation of their Acts and doings ▪ though at that time invested with a greater and more powerful princi●ality then the others were . No such regard had in those ti●es to the Church of Rome , though the elder Sister , but that another National Church might reform without her : nor any such consideration had of the younger S●sters , that one should ●arry for another till they all agreed , though possibly they might all be sensible of the inconvenience , and all alike desirous of a speedy Remedy . But of this more anon in Answer to the next Objections . Proceed we now a little ●urther , and let us grant for once that the Church of England was a Member at that time of the Church of Rome , acknowledging the Pope for the Head thereof : yet this could be no hindrance to a Reformation ▪ when the pre●ended Head would not yeeld unto it , or that the Members could not meet to consult about it . T●e whole Body of the Church was in ill condition , every part unsound , but the disease lay chiefly in the head it self , grown monstrously too great for the rest of the Members . And should the whole body pine and languish without hope of ease , because the Head ( I mean still the pretended Head ) would not be purged of some supe●fl●ous and noxious humours occasioning giddinesse in the brain , dimnesse in the eye , deafn●sse in the ear , and in a word , a general and sad distemper unto all the Members ? The Pop● was grown to an exorbitant height both of pride and power ; the Court of Rome wallowing ( as in a course of prosperous fortunes ) in all volup●uousnesse and sensuality . Nothing so feared amongst them as a Reformation ▪ wher●by they knew that an abatement must be made of their pomp and pleasure . Of these corrup●ions and abuses as of many others complaint had formerly been made , by Armachanus ▪ Grosthead Bishop of Lincoln , S. Bernard , Nic● de Clemangis , an● other conscientious men in their several Count●eys : 〈…〉 noted and informed against by Wic●l●sse , Iohn 〈…〉 , &c. Bu● they complained 〈…〉 who was resolv●d not to hear the voice of those 〈◊〉 , c●armed they never so wis●ly . The C●urch mean while was in a very ill condi●i●n , wh●n he that should prescribe the cure , was beco●e the si●kn●sse . Co●●●dering therefore that a Reformation could not be obtained by the Popes consent , there was no r●medy but that it must be made without it . The Molten Calf mod●lled by the Egyptian Apis , and the Altar patte●ned from Dam●s●us , had made the Israelites ( in all probability ) a● great idolaters as their 〈◊〉 , if the High priests that set them up might have ha● their Wil● . Nor had it been much better with the Chu●ch of CHRIST , if Arianism could not have been suppressed in particul●r Churches , because Liberius Pope of Rome , ( supposing him to be the Head of the Church in g●neral ) had subscribed unto it , and that no error and corruption could have been reformed , which any of the Popes ( whose Graves I am very lo●h to open ) had been guilty of , but by their permission . The Church now were in worse estate under Christian Princes , then when it s●ffered under the power and tyranny of the Heathen Emperors , if it were not lawf●l for particular Churches to provide for their own safety and salvation , without resorting to the Pope : who cannot every day be spoke with , and may ( when spoken with ) be pressed with so many inconveniences nearer hand , as not to be at leisure to attend such businesses as lie furth●r off . And therefore it was well said by Danet the French Ambass●dor when he communic●ted to the Pope his Ma●●ers purpose of Reforming the Ga●●●can Church by a National Councel : Is ( said he ) Paris were on fire , would you not count the Citizens either Fools , or Mad-men , if they should send so far as ●iber for some water to quench it ▪ the River of S●ine running through the City , and the Marno so near it ? 3. That the Church of England might lawfully pr●ceed to a Reformation with●ut the help of a General Councel , or calling in the aid of the Protestant Churches . But here you say it is object●d , that if a Reformation were so necessary as we seem to make it , and that the Pope wa● never like to yeeld unto it , as the case then stood ; it ought to have been done by a General Councel , according to the usage of the Primitive times . I know indeed that General Councels ( such as are commonly so called ) are of excellent use , and that the name thereof is sacred and of high esteem . But yet I prize them not so highly as Pope Gregory did , who ranked the ●our first General C●uncels with the four Evangelists : nor am I o● opinion that they are so necessary to a Reformation either in point of Faith or corruption of manners , but that the business of the Church may be done without them . Nay , might I be so bold as to lay my naked thoughts before you ( as I think I may ) you would there finde it to be some part of my Belief that there never was , and never can be such a thing as a General Councel truly and properly so called : th●t is to say , such a General Councel to which all the Bishops of the Church ( admiting none but such to the power of vo●ing ) have bin or can be called together by themselves or their Proxies . These which are commonly so called , as those of Nice , Constant●nople ▪ 〈◊〉 , Chal●●don , were only of the 〈◊〉 of the Roman E●pire . Chri●tian Churches ●xisting at that time in Ethiopia and the Kingdome of Persia ( which made up no small p●rt of the Church of Christ ) were neither present at them , nor invi●●d to them . And yet not all the P●elates n●ither of the Roman Empire , nor some from ●very Province of it did attend that service : those Councels only being the Assemblies of s●me Eastern Bishop● , such as could most conveniently be drawn together : few of the Wes●e●n Churches ( none at all in some ) having or list or leisure ●or so long a journey : For in the so much celebra●●d Councel of Nice , there were but nine Bishops s●nt from France , but two from Africk , one alone from Spain , none ●rom the 〈◊〉 of 〈◊〉 , and out of It●ly , which ●ay nearest to it , none but two Priests appeared at all , and those as Legat● from the Pope , not authorised to represent the Italian Churches ; so that of 318 Bishops which were there assembled , there were but twelve in all , ( besides the L●gats of the P●pe ) for the Western Churches : too great a dispropor●ion to entitle it 〈◊〉 the name of General . And yet this was more General then the rest that followed : there being no Bishops of the W●st at all in the second and third , but the Popes themselves : and in the 4 none but the Legats of the P●pe to supply his place . So that ●hese 〈◊〉 were called General , not that they were so in thems●lves , but that there was a grea●e● c●nc●urse to them fr●m the n●●ghbouring Provinces , then was o● had b●en to som● o●●ers on the like occasions . Which if it be enough to 〈◊〉 a General 〈◊〉 , I s●e no 〈…〉 call●d so too , summoned in the case of 〈…〉 the Patriarch at that time of that ●amous City . For the condemning of whose Heresie there conveen●d not the Bishops of that Province only , but the Pa●ria●ch o●Hi●rus●lem , the Bish●p of Caesarea in Palestine , B●zra in Arabia , Tarsus in Cili●●a , Caesarea in Cappadocia , of Iconium in Ly●a●ni● , o●Neo-Caesare● in Pontus , besides many others from all places , of the 〈◊〉 rank and qu●lity , but of lesser fame : not ●o say any thing 〈◊〉 Dionysius P●triarch of Alexand●ia , 〈◊〉 bu● not 〈◊〉 in regard of sicknesse , which d●f●ct he recompens●d 〈…〉 and int●rcourse ▪ or of Dion●sius Pope o●Rome , so 〈◊〉 by the Puritan or 〈…〉 that he could not shine . So that if the present of two of the fou● Pat●iarchs , and the invi●ing of the others , with the Bishops of so many distant N●tions as were there assembled , ●uffice to make a General Councel ; the Councel of Antioch might as well hav● the name of General , as almost any of the rest which are so entituled . But laying by th●se thoughts as too strong of th●Paradox , and looking on a General Councel in the common noti●n , ●or an Assembly of the Prelates of the East and West , ●o which the four Patriarchs are invited , and from which no Bishop is excluded that comes commissionated and instructed to at●●nd the 〈◊〉 . I cannot think them of such co●sequence to the Church of God , but that it may proceed without them to a Reformation . For certainly that saying of S. Augu●tine in his 4. Book against the two Epistles of the Pelagians , cap. 12. is ●xceeding true , Paucas fuisse haereses ad quas superandas necessarium fuerit Concilium plenarium occidentis & orientis , that very few Heresies have been crushed in such General C●uncels . And so far we may say with the learned Cardinal , that for seven Heresies suppressed in seven General Councel● ( though by hi● leave the seventh did not so much suppress as advance an Heresie ) an hundred have been quashed in National and Provincial Synods : whether confirmed or not confirmed by the P●pes authority , we regard not here . Some instances here●f in the Synods of Aquileia , Carthage , Gangra , Milevis , we have seen before , and might adde many others now , did we think it necessary . The Church had been in ill condition , if it had been otherwise , especially under the power of Heathen Emperors , when such a confluence of the Prelates from all parts of the world would have been construed a Conspiracie against the State , and drawn destruction on the Church and the Persons both . Or granting that they might assemble without any such danger , yet being great bodies , moving sl●wly , and not without long time and many difficulties and disputes , to be rightly constituted : the Church would suffer more under such delay by the spreading of Heresie , then receive benefit by their care to suppress the same . Had the same course been taken at Alexandria for suppressing Arius , as was before at Antioch for condemning Paulus ; we never had heard newes of the Councel of Nice ; the calling and assembling whereof took up so long time , that Arianism was diffused over all the world before the Fathers met together ; and could not be suppress●d ( though it were condemned ) in many ages following after . The plague of Heresie , and leprosie of sin would quickly over-run the whole face of the Church , if capable of no other cure then a General Councel . The case of Arius , and the universal spreading of his Heresie compared with the quick rooting out of so many others , makes this clear enough . To go a little further yet , we will suppose a General Councel to be the best and safest Physick that the Church can take , on all occasions of Epidemical distemper ; but then we must suppose it at such times and in such cas●s only , when it may conveniently be had . For where it is not to be had or not had conveniently , it will either prove to be no Physick , or not worth the taking . But so it was , that at the time of the Reformation , a General Councel could not conveniently be assembled , and more then so it was impossible that any such Councel should assemble ; I mean a General Councel rightly called and constituted , according to the Rul●● laid down by our Controversors . For first they say it must be called by such as have power to do it . 2. That it must be intimated to all Christian Churches , that so no Church nor people may plead ignorance of it . 3. The Pope and the four chief Patriarchs must be present at it , either in person or by Proxie . And lastly , that no Bishop is to be excluded , if he be known to be a Bishop and not excommunicated . According to which Rules , it was impossible I say , that any General Councel should be assembled at the time of the Reformation of the Church of England . It was not then as when the greatest part of the Christian world wa● under the command of the Roman Emperors ; whose Edict for a Gen●ral Councel●igh● speedily be posted over all the Provinces . The Messengers who should now be sent on such an errand unto the Countreys of the Turk , the Persian , the Tartarian , and the great Mogul ( in which are many Christian Churches , and more perhaps then in all the rest of the world besides ) would finde but sorry entertainment . Nor was it then , as when the four chief Patriarchs , together with their Metropolitans and Suffragan Bishops , were under the protection of the Christian Emperors , and might without danger to themselves or unto their Churches , obey the intimation and attend the service : those Patriarchs with their Metropolitans and Suffragans , both then and now langu●shing under the tyranny and power of the Turk , to whom so general a confluence of Christian Bishops , must n●eds give matter of suspicion , of just fears and jealousies , and therefore not to be permitted ( as far as he can possibly hind●r it ) on good Reason of State . For who knowes better the● themselve● how long and dangerous a war was raised against their Predecessors by the Western Christians for recovery of the Holy Land , on a resolution taken up at the Councel of Cle●mont ; and that ●●●ing war against the Turks is still ●steemed a cause sufficient ●or a General Councel . And then besides it would be known by whom this General Councel was to be assembl●d ▪ if by the Pope , as generally the Papists say , he and his Court were looked on as the greatest grievance of the Christian Church : and 't was not probable that he would call a Councell against himself , unlesse he might have leave to pack it , to govern it by his own Legats , fill it with Titular Bishops of his own creating , and send the Holy Ghost to them in a Clok●bag as he did to Trent . If joyntly by all Christian Princes ( which is the common Tenet of the Protestant Schools ) what hopes could any man conceive ( as the times then were ) that they should lay aside their particul●r interesses , to center all together upon one design ? or if they had agreed about it , what power had they to call the Prelates of the East to att●nd the business , or to protect them for so doing at their going home ? So that I look upon the hopes of a General Councel , I mean a General Councel rightly called and constit●ted , as an empty 〈◊〉 . The m●st that was to be expected was but a meeting of some Bishops of the West of Europe , and those but of 〈◊〉 party only : such as were excommunicated , ( and th●● might be as many as the Pope should please ) being to be excluded by the Cardinals Rule . Which how it may be call●●●n Oecumenial or General Councell , unlesse it be a Topical Oecumenical , a Particular-general ( as great an absurdity in Grammar , as a Roman Catholick ) I can hardly see . Which being so , and so no question but it was , either the Church must continue withou●●eformati●n , or el●e it must be lawfull for National pa●ticular Churches to reform themselves . In such a case the Church ●ay be reformed per partes , Part after part , Province after Province , as is said by Gerson . But I do not me●● 〈◊〉 trouble you with this Dis●●●● . 〈…〉 may reform themselves by National or Provincial Coun●●ls , 〈…〉 Church generall will not do it , or that it cannot be effected by a General Councel , hath been so fully proved by my Lord of Canterbury in his learned and elaborate discourse against Fisher the Iesuite , tha● nothing can be added unto so great diligence . But if it be objected , as you say it is , that National Councels have a power of Promulgation only , not of 〈◊〉 also : I answer first , that this runs crosse to all the current of Antiquity , in which not only National but Provincial Councels did usually determine in the poin●● of Faith , and these too of the greatest moment , as did that of Anti●ch ; which if it were somewhat more then a National , was notwithstanding never reckoned for a General Councel . I answer secondly as before , that for one Heresie suppress●d in a General Councel , there have been ten at least suppressed in National and Provincial Synods ; wich could not be in case they had no power of Determination . And thirdly , That the Articles or Confession of the Church of England are only Declaratory of such Catholick Doctrines as were received of old in the Church of CHRIST , not Introductory of new ones of their own devising ; as might be evidenced in particular , were this place fit for it . But what needs any proof at all , when we have Confession ? For the Archbishop of Spalato ( a man as well studied in the Fathers , as the best amongst them ) ingenuously acknowledged at the High Commission , that the Articles of this Church were profitable , none of them Heretical ; and that he would defend the honour of the Church of England against all the world . And this he said at the very time of his departure , when his soul was gone before to Rome , and nothing but his carkasse left behinde in England . The like avowed by Davenport , or Franciscus a Sancta Clara ( call him which you will ) who makes the Articles of this Church rightly understood according to the literal meaning , and not perverted to the ends of particular Factions , to be capable of a Catholick and Orthodox sense : which is as much as could be looked for from the mouth of an Adversary . So much as cost one of them his life ( though perhaps it will be said that he died in prison ) and the burning of his body after his death ; though he endevoured to save both by a Retractation . So that in thi● case 〈◊〉 we have omni● bene , 〈◊〉 amisse in the proceedings of this Church , with reference to the Pope or a General Councel . But you will say , that though we could not stay the calling of a General Councel , which would have justified ●ur proceedings in the eyes of our Adversaries ▪ it had been requisite even in the way of civil Prudence to have taken the advice of the Sister-Churches , especially of those which were ●ngaged at the same time in the same designs : which would have add●d r●putation to us in the eyes of our Friends . As for the taking counsel of the Sister-Churches , it hath been t●uch●d upon ●lready , and there●ore we shall say no more as t● that particular : unlesse the Sister-Churches of these later tim●● had b●en like the Believers in the infancy of the Ch●istian Faith , when they were all of one heart and one soul , as the Scripture hath it , Act. 4. their couns●ls had been 〈◊〉 , if not destructive . 'T is true inde●d , united Councel● are the stronger and of greater weight , and not to be neglected wh●re they may be had ; but where they are not to be had , we ●ust act without them . And if we look into the time of our Reformation , we shall finde those that were engaged in the same design , divided into obstinate parties ; and holding the names of Luther and Zuinglius in an higher estimate then either the truth of the Opinion in which they differed , or the common happinesse of the Church so disturbed between them . The breath not lessened , but made wider by the rise of Calvin , succeeding not long after in the fame of Zuinglius : besides , that living under the command of several Princes , and those Prince● driving on to their several ends ; it had been very difficult , if not impossible to draw them unto such an Harmony of affections , and consent in judgement , as so g●eat a businesse did require . So that the Church of England was necessitated in that conjuncture of affairs to proceed as it did , and to act that single by it self , which could not be effected by the common Councels , and joynt concurrence of the others . 'T is true , Melanchthon was once coming over in King Henries daies , but st●id his journey on the death of Q●een Anne Bullen , and that he was after sent f●r by King Edward the sixth ( Regis Literi● in Angliam vocor ) as he affirms in an Epistle unto Camerarius , anno 1553. But he was staid at that time also on some other occasion , though had he come at that time he had come too late to have had any hand in the Reformation , the Articles of the Church being passed , the Liturgie reviewed and setled in the year befor● . And 't is as true that Calvin offered his assistance to Archbishop Cranmer , for the reforming of this Church ; Si quis mei usus esset , as his own words are , i● his assistance were thought n●edfull to advance the work . But Cranmer knew the man ▪ and refused the offer ; and he did very wisely in it . For seeing it impossible to unite all parties , it had been an imprudent thing to have closed with any . I grant indeed th●t Martin Bucer and P●ter Martyr ( men of great learning and esteem , but of different judgements ) were brought over hither , about the beginning of the reign of K Edward 6. the one of them being placed in Oxford , the other in Cambridge ; but they were rather entertained as private Doctors to m●derate in the Chairs of those . Universities , then any waies made use of in the Reformation . For as the ●i●st Liturgie which was the main key unto the work , was framed and setled before either of them were come over ; so Bucer died , before the compiling of the Book of Articles , which was the acc●mplishment thereof : nor do I finde that Peter Martyr was made use of otherwise in this weighty businesse , then to make th●t good by disputation , which by the Clergy in their Synods or Convocations was agreed upon . By means whereof the Church proceeding without reference to the different interesses of the neighbouring . Churches , kept a conformity in all such points of Government and publ●q●e order with the Church of Rome , in which that Church had not forsaken the clear Tract of the primitive Times : retaining not only the Episcopall Government , with all the concomitants and adjuncts of it , which had been utterly abolished in the Zuinglian Churches , and much impaired in power and jurisdiction by the Luth●rans also : and keeping up a Liturgie or set form of worship , according to the rites and usages of the primitive times , which those of the 〈◊〉 congreg●●io●s would not hearken to . God certainly h●d so disposed it in his heavenly wisdome , that so this Church without respect unto the names and Dictate● of particular Doctors , might found its Reformation on the Prophets and Apostles only , according to the Explications and Traditions of the ancient Fathers : and being so founded in it self , without respect to any of the differing parties , might in succeeding Ages sit as Judge between th●m ; as being more inclinable by her constitution to mediate a peace amongst them then to espouse the quarrel of ei●her side , to the Popes authority on the one side , or on the other side . And though Spal●to in the Book of his Retractations , which he cals Consilium re●eundi , objects against u● : That besides the publick Articles and confession authorised by the Churches , we had embraced some Lutheran and Calvinian Fancies ( multa Lutheri & 〈◊〉 dog●ata , so his own words run ) yet this was but the 〈◊〉 of particular men , not to be charged upon the Church as maintaining either . The Church is constant to her safe and her first conclusions , though many private men take liberty to imbrace new Doctrines . 4. That the Ch●rch did not innovate in translating the Scripture● and the publick Liturgie into vulgar tongues ; and of the consequents thereof in the Church of England . The next thing faulted ( as you say ) in the Reformation , i● the committing so much heavenly treasure to such rotten vessels , the trusting so much excellent Wine to such musty bottles : I mean the versions of the Scriptures and the publick Liturgies into the usual Languages of the common people , and the promiscuous liberty indulged them in it . And this they charge not as an Innovation simply , but as an Innovation of a dangerous consequence ; the sad effects whereof we now see so clearly . A charge wich doth alike concern all the Pr●testant and Reformed Churches , so that I should have passed it over at the present time , but that it is made our● more specially in the application ; the sad effects which the enemy doth so much insult in being said to be more visible in the Church of England , then in other place● . This makes it our● , and therefore here to be considered , as the former were . First then they charge it on the Church as an Innovation , it being affirmed by Bellarmine in his 2. Book De verbo Dei , cap. 15. ( whether with lesse truth or modesty , it is hard to say ) Vniversam Ecclesiam semper his tantum linguis , &c. that in the Universal Church in all times foregoing the Scriptures were not commonly and publickly read in any other language but in the Hebrew , Greek , and Latine : this is ( you se● ) a two-edged sword , and strikes not only against all Transla●i●ns of the Scriptures into vulgar languages for comm●n use , but against reading those Translation● publickly 〈…〉 part o● the Liturgie , in which are many things as the Cardinal tel● u●quae secreta esse debent , which are not fit to be made known to the common people . This is the substance of the charge , and herein we joyn issu● in the usual Form with Absque hoc , sans ceo , no such matter really ; the constant current of Antiquity doth affi●m the contrary : by which it will appear most plainly that the Church did neither innovate in this act of hers , nor d●via●e therein f●om the Word of God , or from the usage of the best and happiest times of the Church of CHRIST . Not from the Word of God , there 's no doubt of that , which was committed unto writing that it ●ight be read , and read by all that were to be directed and guided by it . The Scriptures of the Old Testament fi●st writ in Hebrew , the Vulgar language of that people , and read unto them publickly on the Sabbath dai●s , as appears clearly Act. 13. 15. & 15. 21. translated afterwards ( by the cost and care of Ptolemy Philadelphus King of Egypt ) into the Greek tongue , the most known and studied language of the E●stern world . The N●w Testament first w●it in Gr●ek for the self-same reason , ( but that St. Matthew'● Gospel i●●ffirmed by some learned men to have been written in th●Hebrew ) and written to thi● end and purpose , that men might believe t●●t IESVS is the CHRIST t●e Son of GOD , and that believing t●ey might have use in his Name , Joh. 20. vers. ult. But being that all the Faithfull did not understand these Languages , and that the light of h●ly Scripture might not be likened to a Candl● hidden under ●●ushel : it wa● thought good by many ●odly men in the P●i●itive tim●s to translate the same into the ●an●uag●s of the Countreys in which th●● lived , or of the which th●● had been Na●ives . In which respect S Chrysostome then banished in●o Armenia , translated the New Testament , and the P●alms of David , into the Language of that people ; S. Hierom a Pannonian born , translated the whole Bible into the Dalmatick tongue , as Vulphilas Bishop of the Go●hes did into the G●thick ▪ all which we finde together without fu●ther search , in the Bibliotheque of Sixtus Senensis , a learned and ingenu●us man but a Pontifician , and so lesse partial in this cause . The like done h●re in England by the care of Athelstan causing a Translation of the Saxon Tongue ; the like done by Method●us , the Apostle Gen●r●l of the Sclaves , translating it into the Sclavonian for the use of those Nations : not to say any thing of the Syriack , Aethiopick , Arabick , the Pe●sian , and Chaldaean Versions , of which the times and Authors are not so well known . And what I pray you , is the vulgar or old Latine Edition , ( of late times made Authentick by the Popes of Rome ) but a Translation of the Scriptures out of Greek and Hebrew for the ins●ruction of the Roman and Italian Nations , to whom the Latine at that time was the Vulgar Tongue ? And when that Tongue by reason of the breaking in of the barbarous Nations was worn out of knowledge , ( I mean as to the common people ) did not God stir up Iames , Archbishop of Genoa , when the times were darkest ( that is to say , anno●290 . or the●eabouts ) to give some light to them by translating the whole Bible into the Italian , the modern Lan●u●ge of that Countrey ? As he did Wi●lef not long after , to translate the same into the English of those times , ( the Saxon Tongue not being then commonly underst●od ) a copy of whose Version in a fair Velom Manuscript I have now here by me , by the gift of my noble Friend Charles Dymoke , Hereditary Champion to the Kings of England . So then it is no innovation to translate the Scriptures ; and lesse to suffer these Translations to be promiscuously read by all sorts of people : the Scripture being as well MILK for Babes , as strong Meat for the man of more able judgement . Why else doth the Apostle note it as a commend●ble thing in Timothy , that he knew the Scriptures from his childhood ? and why else doth S. Hierom speak it to the honour of the Lady Paula , that she made her maids learn somewhat daily of the holy Scriptures ? Why else does Chrysostome call so earnestly on all sorts of men to provide themselves of the holy Bibles , {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} , the only Physick for the Soul , as he cals it there : inviting to the reading thereof not only men of learning and publick businesse ; but even the poor Artificer also , as is acknowledged by Senensis whom before we mentioned . And why else doth S. Augustine inform his Auditors , that it sufficeth not to hear the Scriptures read in the Congregation , unlesse they read also in their private Ho●ses . Assuredly if Boyes and Girles , if Servants and Artificers are called upon so earnestly to consult the Scriptures , t● have them in a Tongue intelligible to them in their private Fa●ilies ; and are commended for so doing as we see they are : I know no rank of men that can be excluded . Let us next see whether it be an Innovation in the Church of CHRIST , to have the Li●urgies or Comm●n-prayers of the Chu●ch in the Tongue generally understood by the comm●n People , which make the greatest number of all Church Assemblies . And first we finde by the Apostle not only that the publick Praye●s of the Church of C●rinth , were celebrated in a language which they understood ; but that it ought to be so also in all other Churches , Except ( saith he ) ye utter by the voice words easie to be understood , how shall it be known what is spoken ? How shall he that occupieth the room of the unlearned say Ame●to thy giving of thanks ( and consequently to thy Prayers also ) if he understand not what thou sayest ? 1 Cor. 14. 9. 16. What say the Papists unto this ? Do not both Lyra and Aquinas expresly grant in their Commentaries on this place of Scripture , that the common Service of the Church in the Primitive times was in the common vulgar language ? Is not the like affirmed by Harding in his Answer to Bishop Iewels challenge , Art. 3. Sect. 28. Adding withall , that it was necessary in the Primitive times that it should be so ; and granting that it were still better that the people had their Service in their own vulgar Tongue for their better understanding of it ? Sect. 33. Having thus Confitentes reos , we need seek no further , and yet a further search will not be unprofitable . And on that search it will be found that the converted Iewes did celebrate their divin● Offices ( ●ractatus & oblationes , as the Father hath it ) most commonly in the Syriack , and sometimes in the Hebrew tongue ; the natural ●anguages of that people : as is affirmed by S. Ambr●se in 1. ad Cor. cap. 14. and out of him by Durand in his R●ti●n●le Divinorum . Eckius a great stickler of the Popes , affirmeth in his Common places , that the Indians have their Service in the Indian tongue ; and that S. Hierome having translated the whole Bible into the D●lmatick , procured that the Service sh●uld be celebrated in that Language also . The like S. H●erome himself in his Epistle to Heliodorus , hath told us 〈◊〉 the Bessi a Sarmation people : the like S. Basil in his Epistle to the Ne● caesareans , assures us for the Aegyptians , Libyans , Palestinians , Phenicians , Arabians , Syrians , and such as dwell about the B●nks of the River Euphrates . The Aethiopians had their M●ssal , the Chaldeans theirs ; each in the language of their Countryes , which they still retain : So had the M●scovites of old , and all the scattered Churches of the Eastern parts , which they continue to this day . But nothing is more memorable in this kinde then that which Aenaeas Silvius tels of the Sclavonians , who being converted to the Faith made suite unto the Pope to have the publick Service in their natural Tongue : but some delay being made therein by the Pope and Cardinals , a voice was heard , seeming to have come from Heaven , praying , Omnis Spiritus laudet Dominum , & omnis lingua con●iteatur ei : whereupon their desires were granted without more dispute . Touching which Grant there is extant an Epistle from Pope Iohn the 8. to Sfentopulcher King of the Moravian Selaves , anno 888. at what time both the Latine Service and the Popes authority were generally received in those parts of Europe . Which Letter of Pope I●hn the 8. together with the Story above mentioned , might probably be a chief inducement to Innocent the 3. to set out a Decree in the Lateran Councel , importing that in all such Cities in which there was a concourse of divers Nations , and consequently of different Languages , ( as in most Towns of Trade there doth use to be ) the Servi●e should be said , and Sacraments administred , Secundum diversitates nationum & linguarum , according to the difference of their Tongues and Nations ▪ And though Pope Gregory the 7. a turbulent and violent man , about 200 years af●er the Concession made by Iohn the S. in his Letter to Vratislaus King of Bohemia , laboured the cancelling of th●t priviledge , and possibly might prevail therein as the ●imes then were : yet the Liburnians , and Dalmatians , two Sclavonian Nations , and bordering on Italy ( the Popes proper seat ) do still enjoy the benefit of that indulgence , and celebrate their Liturgie in their own Language to this very day . So that the wonder is the greater that those of Rome should stand so stifly in defence of the Latine Service , which the common people understand not , and therefore cannot knowingly , and with faith say Amen unto it . For though the Latine Tongue was Vulgar in a manner to those Western Nations , amongst whom the Latine Service was first received , and for that cause received because Vulgar to them : yet when upon the inundation of the barbarous nation , the Latine tongue degenerated into other Languages , as in France , Italy , and Spain ; or else was quite worn out of knowledge as in Britain , Belgium , and some parts of the modern Germany , in which before it had been commonly understood ; it was both consonant to piety and Christian Prudence ▪ that the Language of the common Liturgies should be altered also . The people otherwise either in singing David's Psalmes , or repeating any parts of the daily Office , must needs be like those Romans or Italians which S. Ambrose speaks of ; who loved to sing Greek songs by rote ( as we use to say ) out of a meer delight which they had to the sound of the words ; nescientes tamen quid dicant , not understanding one word which they said or sung . The blame and guilt of Innovation being taken off , we must next examine the effects and dangerous consequents ; more visibly discerned at this time in the Church of England , then was or could have been believed when they were first intimated . Amongst these they reckon in the first place the increase of Heresies , occasioned by the mistaking of the true sense and meaning of the Holy Scripture ; and to that end it is said by Bellarmine , that the people would not only receive no good by having the Scripture read publickly unto them in their national Languages , Sed etiam caperet detrimentum , but on the contrary are like to receive much hurt . However , acciperet facillime occasionem errandi : because thereby they would most easily be led into errors : which gave occasion unto some ( as he tels as there ) to call the Scripture Librum Haereticorum , the Hereticks Book . So he in his 2. Book and 15. chapter , De verbo Dei . The like saith Harding in his Answer to Bishop Iewel's Challenge , Art 3. sect. 31. The Nations ( saith he ) that have ever had thei Service in the vulgar Tongue ( where note that some Nations never had it otherwi●e ) have continued still in Errors , Schisms , and certain Judaical Ceremonies , &c. In the next place they ●eckon this , that by permitting Scripture and the publick Liturgies to be extant in the Vulgar Tongues , all men would think themselves Divines , and 〈◊〉 authority of the Prelates would be disesteemed ; So Harding in his Answer to Iewels Apologie . l 5. fol. 460. that the people not content with hearing or 〈◊〉 the holy Scripture , would first take upon them to be Expositors , and at last to be Preachers also , which in effect is that which is charged by Bellarmine . And for this last , the present Distempers and consusions in the Church of England ( out of which they suck no small advantage ) gives them great rejoycing , as seeing their predictions so exactly verified . In answer to the first we need say no more , then that there have been Sects and Heresies in all times and Ages : never so many as in the first ages of the Church ( witnesse the Catalogue of S. Augustine , Philastrius , and Epiphanius ) in which the Scripture was translated into fewer Languages then it is at the present . 2. That this is no necessary effect of such Translations ( for we see few new Heresies started up of late in France or Germany , where such Translations are allowed of ) but a meer possible Contingency , which 〈◊〉 may be or may not be , as it pleaseth God to give or to withdraw his grace from a State or Nation . And 3. That as according to the Divine Rule of the Apostle , we must not do a thing positively evil , in hope that any good , how great soever , may come of it : so by Analogie thereunto , we must not debar the people of God from any thing positively good , for fear that any contingent mischief may ensue upon it . But of this I shall not say more now , as being loth to travel on a common place . The point hath been so canvassed by our Controversors , that you may there finde Answers unto all Objections . That which doth most concern me to consider of , is the second consequent , because it doth relate more specially then the other did to the present condition and estate of the Church of England . Although the Charge be general and equally concerning all the Protestant and Reformed Churches : yet the Application makes it ours , as before I said , and as ours , properly within the compasse of my present design . And though I will not take upon me to Advocate for the present distempers and confusions of this w●etched Church ( which no man can lament with a greater tendernesse , or look on with more indignation then I do , and I think you know it ) : yet I must tell you that it is neither Novum crimen C. Caesar , nor ante haec tempora inauditum , for those of the inferiour sort to take upon them the inquiry into sacred matters , to turn Expositors 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , as the spirit of delusion moves them . The people have had an itch this way , i● all times and Ages . The Satyrist thus complained of it amongst the Heathens ; — Ecce inter pocula quaerunt Romulides satu●i , quid dia Poema●a narrant . That is to say , The wel-●ed Romans in their Cups , do sit And judge of things contain'd in holy Writ . And the Apostle doth complain of it among the Christians , where he informes us of some ignorant and unstable men , which wrested some ha●d places of S. Pauls Epistles , as they also did the other Scriptures , to their own destruction , 2 Pet. 3. 26 and wrest them so they could not ( I am sure of that ) did they not take the liberty of expounding also . Look lower to S. Basils time , when learning did most flourish in the Church of CHRIST , and we shall finde the Emperors Cook ( or the Clerk of his Kitchen at the best ) as busily dishing out the Scriptures , as if it were no more then serving up his Masters diet from the Kitchin-hatch : paid home by that good father for his over-great sawcinesse , with this handsome scoffe , Tuum est de pulmento cogitare , non Divind decoquere , that it belonged unto his office to provide good pottage for the Court , not to Cook the Scriptures . But this was not the folly only of this Master Cook , who perhaps ( though better fed then taught ) might now and then have carried up the Chaplains Messe , and having heard their learned conferences and discourses , was apt enough to think himself no small fool at a joynt of Divinity . That whole age was extremely tainted with the self-same p●●cancy ; of which S. Hierome in his Epistle to Paulinus makes this sad complaint . Whereas ( saith he ) all other Sciences and Trades have their several and distinct professors , Sola Scripturarum ars est quam omnes passim sibi vendicant ; only the Art of opening or rather of undoing a Text of Scripture , ( as the phrase is now ) was usurped by all : Hanc garrula anus , hanc delirus senex , &c. The pratling Gossip and the doting Sire , the windy Sophister , and in a word , all sorts of people do presume upon , dismembring the body of the Scriptures , and teaching others before they have learnt any thing that is worth the teaching . Some with a supercilious look , speaking big words discourse of holy Scripture amongst silly women : others ( the more the shame ) learn that of women which afterwards they may teach to men , and some with no small volubility of tongue , and confidence , teach that to others which they never understood themselves : Not to say any thing of those who having a smack of humane learning , and coming so prepared to handle the Holy Scriptures , do with ent●c●ng words feed the ears of the people , bearing their Auditors in hand quicquid dixerint legem Dei esse , that whatsoever they deliver is the Word of God , nor will vouchsafe to learn what the Prophets and Apostles do conceive of the matter , but very incongruously produce some Testimoni●s out of holy Writ to make good their corrupt imaginations ; as if it were an excellent , not a pernicious way of teaching , to wrest the sense of holy Scripture , and thereby to accommodate it to their present purposes ! Hath not the Father given us in this place and passage a most excellent Mirrour , wherein to see the ill complexion of the present times ? doth not he set them forth in such likely colours , as if he rather did delineate the confusions of the present Age , then lament the miseries of his own ? May not both Factions see by this , what a condition the poor Church of England is involved in by them ? The sight whereof although it justifie them not in their several courses , as being not without example in their present practises ) : yet it may serve to let you know that as the distractions and confusions under which we suffer , are not the consequents of our translating of the Scriptures and publick Liturgies into the common vulgar Tongues , so ●t is neither ●ew no● stran●e that such confusions and distractions should befall the Church . 5. That the proceedings of this Church in setting out the English Liturgie , were not meerly Regal ; and of the power of Soveraign Princes in Ecclesiastical affairs . Having thus proved that nothing hath been done amisse by the Church of England , with reference to God● Word , the testimonies of godly Fathers , and the usage of the primitive times , in leaving off the Latine Service , and celebrating all Divine Offices in the English Tongue : I am to justifie it next , in order to the carrying on of that weighty businesse , whether so Regular or not , as we fain would have it . I see you are not scrupled at the subject-matter of the Common-prayer-Book , which being translated into Greek , Latine , French , and Spanish , hath found a general applause in most parts of Christendome ; no where so little set by as it is at home . All scruples in that kinde have been already fully satisfied by our learned Hooker , who hath examined it per partes , and justified it in each part and particular Office . But for the greater honour of it take this with you also , which is alledged in the Conference of Hampton Court , touching the Marquesse of Rhosny ( after Duke of Sally and Lord High Treasurer of France ) who coming Ambassador to King Iames from Henry the 4. and having seen the solemn celebration of our Service at Cante●bury , and in his Majesties Royall Chappels , did often and publickly affirm , that if the Reformed Churches in France ●ad 〈◊〉 the same Orders as were here in E●gland , he was assured there would ha●e been many thousand Protestants in that Kingdome more then were at that time . That which you seem to stick at only is in the way and manner of proceeding in it : which though you finde by perusal of the papers which I sent first unto you , not to have been so Parliamentarian as the Papists made it ; yet still you doubt whether it were so Regular and Canonical as it might have been . And this you stumble at the rather , in regard that the whole Body of the Clergy in their Convocation , had no hand therein , either as to decree the doing of it , or to approve it being done ; but that it was resolved on by the King ( or rather by the Lord Protector in the Kings Minority ) with some few of the Bishops ; by which Bishops and as small a number of learned Church-men , being framed and fashioned , it was allowed of by the King , confirmed or imposed rather by an Act of Parliament . Your question hereupon is this , Whether the King ( for his acting it by a Protector doth not change the Case ) consulting with a less●r part of his Bishops and Clergy , and having their consent therein , may conclude any thing in the way of a Reformation , the residue and greatest part not advised withall , nor yeelding their consent unto it in a formal way . This seems to have some reference to the Scottish Liturgie ( for by your Letter I perceive that one of the chief of your Objectors is a Divine of that Nation ) and therefore it concerns me to be very punctual in my Answer to it . And that my Answer may be built on the surer Ground , it is to be consid●red , first wh●ther the Reformation be in corruption of manners , or abuses in Government , whether in matters pr●ctical , or in points of Doctrine . 2. If in matters practical , whether such practise have the character of Antiquity , Vni●ersality , and Consent , imprinted on it ; or that it be the practise of particular Churchs , and of some times only . And 3. if in points of Doctrine , whether such points have been determined of before in a General Councel , or in particular Councels universally received and countenanced ; or are to be defined de novo on emergent controversies . And these Disti●ctions being laid , I shall answer briefly . First , if the things to be reformed be either corruptions in manners , or neglect of publick duties to Almighty God , abuses either in Government or the parties governing : the King may do it of himself by his sole authority . The Clergy are beholding to him , if he takes any of them along with him when he goeth about it . And if the times should be so bad , that either the whole body of the Clergy or any ( though the greatest ) part thereof should oppose him in it ; he may go forwards notwithstanding , punishing such as shall gainsay him in so good a work , and compelling others . And thi● I look on as a Power annexed to the Regal Diadem , and so inseparably annexed , that Kings could be no longer Kings if it were denied them . But hereof we have spoke already in the first of this Section , and shall speak more hereof in the next that followes . And on the other side , if the Reformation be in points of Doctrine , and in such points of doctrine as have not been before defined , or not defined in form , and manner as before laid down : the King only with a few of his Bishops and learned Clergy ( though never so well studied in the point disputed ) can do nothing in it . That belongs only to the whole Body of the Clergy in their Convocation rightly called and constituted ; whose Acts being ratified by the King , binde not alone the rest of the Clergy in whose names they Voted , but all the residue of the subjects of what sort soever , who are to acquiesce in their Resolutions . The constant practise of the Church , and that which we have said before touching the calling and authority of the Convocation , makes this clear enough . But if the thing to be Reformed be a matter practical , we are to look into the usage of the primitive times . And if the practise prove to have been both ancient and universally received over all the Church , though intermitted for a time and by time corrupted : the King consulting with so many of his Bishops and others of his most able Clergy , as he thinks fit to call unto him , and having their consent and direction in it ; may in the case of intermission revive such practise , and in the case of corruption and degeneration restore it to its Primitive and original lustre , whether he do it of himself , of his own meer motion , or that he follow the advice of his Councel in it ; whether he be of age to inform himself , or that he doth relie on those to whom he hath committed the publick Government ; it comes all to one : so they restrain themselves to the ancient patterns . The Reformation which was made under Iosias , though in his Minority and acting by the Counsel of the Elders as Iosephus telleth us , Antiqu ▪ Iud 1. cap. was no lesse pleasi●g unto God , nor lesse valid in the eyes of all his subjects ; then those of Ieh●saphat and H●zekiah in their riper years , and perhaps acting ●i●gly on the str●ngth of their own judgements only with●ut any advice . Now that there should be Liturgies for the use of the Church , that those Liturgies sh●uld be celebrated in a language understood by the people : that in those Liturgi●s there should be some prescribed Formes for giving the Communion in both kindes , for Baptizing Infants , for the reverent celebration of Marriage , performing the last office to the sick and the decent burial of the Dead , as also for set Feasts and appointed Festivals ; hath been a thing of primitive and general practise in the Christian Church . And being such , though intermitted or corrupted , as before is said , the King advising with his Bishops and other Church●men ( though not in a Synodical way ) may cause the same to be revised and revived : and having fitted them to edification and increase of piety either commend them to the Church by his sole authority , or else impose them on the people under certain penalties by his power in Parliament . Saepe Coeleste Regnum per Terrenum proficit . The Kingdome of Heaven ( said Reverend Isidore of Sevil ) doth many times receive increase from these earthly kingdomes ; in nothing more then by the regulating and well ordering of Gods publick worship . We saw before what David did in this particular allotting to the Priest the Courses of their Ministration , appointing Hymns and Songs for the Iewish Festivals , ordaining singing-men to sing , and finally prescribing Vestments for the Celebration . Which what else was it but a Regulating of the worship of God , the putting it into a sol●mn course and order , to be observed from time to time in succeeding ages ? Sufficient ground for Christian Princes to proceed on in the like occasions : especially when all they do is rather the reviving of the Ancient Formes then the Introduction of a new . Which as the King did here in England by his own Authority , the Body of the Clergy not consulted in it ; so possibly there might be good reason , why those who had the conduct of the Kings affairs , thought it not safe to put the managing of the businesse to a Convocation . The ignorance and superstition of the common people was at that time exceeding profitable to the Clergy , who by their frequent Masses for the quick and dead rais●d as great advantage , as Demetrius and the Silver-Smith by Dianas shrines . It hapned also in a time when many of the inferiour Clergy had not much more learning then what was taught them in the Missals and other Rituals , and well might fear that if the Service were once extant in the English tongue , the Laity would prove in time as great Clerks as themselves . So that as well in point of Reputation , as in point of P●ofit , ( besides the love which many of them had to their former Mumps●mus ) it was most probable that such an hard piece of Reformation would not easily down , had it been put into the power of a Convocation : especially under a Prince in Nonage , and a state unsetled . And yet it was not so carryed without them neither , but that the Bishops generally did concur to the Confirmation of the Book ( or the approbation of it rather ) when it passed in Parliament : the Bishops in that time and after , ( till the late vast and most improvident increase of the Lay-nobility ) making the most considerable , if not the greatest part of the House of Peers ; and so the Book not likely to be there allowed of , without their consent . And I the rather am inclined unto that Opinion , because I finde that none but Tunstall , Gardiner and Bonner were displaced from their Bishopricks , for not submitting in this case to the Kings appointments ; which seems to me a very strong and convincing argument , that none but they dissented or refused conformity . Adde here , that though the whole body of the Clergy in their Convocation were not consulted with at first ( for the Reasons formerly recited ) yet when they found the benefit and comfort which redounded by it to good Christian people , and had by little and little wean●d themselves from their private interesses , they all confirmed it on the Post-fact : passing an Article in the Convocation of the year 1552. with this Head or Title , viz. Agendum esse in Ecclesia lingua quae sit Populo nota , which is the 25. Article in King Edwards Book . Lay all that hath been said together , and the result of all will be briefly this , that being the setting out of the Liturgie in the English●ongue was a matter practical agreeable to the Word of God and the Primitive tim●s ; that the King with so many of his Bishops and others o● the Clergy as he pleased to call to Counsel in it , resolved 〈◊〉 on the doing of it ; that the Bishops generally confirmed it when it came before them , and that the whole body of the Clergy in their Convocation ( the Book being then under a review ) did avow and justifie it : The result of all I say is this , that as the work it self I say was good , so it was done not in a Regal but a Regular way , Kings were not Kings if regulating the external parts of Gods publick worship according to the Platformes of the Primitive times , should not be allowed them . But yet the Kings of England had a further right as to this particular , which is a power conferred upon them by the Clergy ( whether by way of Recognition or Concession , I regard not h●re ) by which they did invest the King with a Supreme Au●hority not only of confirming their Synodical Acts not to be put in ex●cution without his consent ; but in effect to devolve on him all that power , which firmly they enjoyed in their own capacity . And to this we have a paralled Case in the Roman Empire , in which there had b●●n once a time when the Supreme Majesty of the S●ate was vested in the Senate and people of Rome , till by the Law which they called Lex Regia , they transferred all their Power on Caesar , and the following Emperors . Which Law being passed , the Edicts of the Prince or Emperor was as strong and binding as the Senatus Consulta and the Pl●bis●ita had been before . Whence came that memorable Maxim in Iustinians Iustitutes ; that is to say , Quod Principi placuerit legis habet vig●rem . The like may be affirm●d of the Church of England , immediately before , and in the reign of K. Henry 8. The Clergy of this Realm had a Self-authority in all matters which concerned Religion , and by their Canons and Determinations did binde all the subjects of what rank soever , till by acknowledging that King for their supreme Head , and by the Act of submission not long after foll●wing , they transferred that power upon the King , and on his Successo●s : By do●ng wher●of they did not only di●able themselves from concluding any thing in their Convocations , or pu●ting ●heir results into execution without his con●ent ; but put him into the actual p●ssession of that Authori●y which properly be●onged to the supremacy , or the supreme Head , in as ●ull manner as 〈◊〉 the P●pe of Rome , or any d●l●gated by and under him did before enjoy it . After which 〈◊〉 , whatsoever the King or his Successors did in the R●form●tion , as it had vertually the power of the Convocations ; so was it as effectual and go●d in law , as if the Clergy in their C●nvocation particularly , and in terminis , had agreed upon it . Not that the King or his Successors were hereby enabled to exercise the K●i●s , and determine Heresies , much lesse to 〈◊〉 the Word ●nd administer the Sacrament● , as the Papists ●alsly gave it out ; but as the Heads of the Ecclesiastical Body of this Realm , to see that all the members of that Body 〈◊〉 perform their duties , to rectifie what was found amisse amongst them , to preserve peace between them on emergent differences , to reform such errors and corruptions as are expresly contrary to the word of God ; and finally , to give strength and motions to their Councels and Determinations , tending to Edification and increase of Piety . And though in most of their proceeding● toward Reformation , the Ki●gs advised with such Bishops as they had about them , or could ass●mble without any great trouble or inconvenience , to advise wit●all ; yet was there no nec●ssity , that all or the greatest part● of the Bishops should be drawn together for that purpose , no more then it was anciently in the Primitive Times for the godly Emperors to c●ll together the most part of the Bishops in the Roman Empire , for the ●st●blishing of the matters which com●erned the Church , or for the godly Kings of Iudah to call together the greatest part of the Priests and Levites , before they acted any thing in the Reformation of those corruptions and abuses which were cr●pt in amongst them . Which being so ; and then with●●l considering as we ought to do , that there was nothing a●tered here in the state of R●ligion , till either the whole Clergy in their 〈…〉 the B●shops and most eminent Church-men had resolved upon it ; our Religion is no more to be called a Regal then a Parliament-Gospel . 6 ▪ That the Clergy lost not any of their just Rights by the Act of Submission , and the p●wer of calling and confirming Councels did anciently belong to the Christian Princes . If you conceive that by ascribing to the King the Supreme Authority , taking him for their Supreme Head , and by the Act of Submission which ensued upon it , the Clergy did unwittingly ensnare themselves , and drew a Vas●allage on these of the times succeeding , inconsistent with their native Rights , and contrary to the usage of the Primitive Church : I hope it will be no hard matter to remove that scruple . It 's true the Clergy in their Convocation can do nothing now , but as their doings are confirmed by the Kings authority , and I conceive it stands with reason ( as well as point of State ) that it should be so . For since the two Houses of Parliament , though called by the Kings Writ , can conclude nothing which may binde either King or Subject , in their Civil Rights , untill it be made good by the Royal Assent ; so neither is it ●it nor safe , that the Clergy should be able by their Constitutions and Synodical Acts , to conclude both Prince and People in spiritual matters , untill the stamp of Royal Authority be imprinted on them . The Kings concurrence in this case devesteth not the Clergy of any lawful power which they ought to have , but restrains them only in the exercise of some part thereof , to make it more agreeable to Monarchical Government , & to accommodate it to the benefit both of Prince and People . It 's true the Clergy of this Realm can neither meet in Convocation , nor conclude any thing therein , nor put in execution any thing which they have concluded , but as they are enabled by the Kings authority . But then it is as true withall , that this is neither inconsistent with their native Rights , nor contrary unto the usage of the Primitive Times . And first it is not inconsistent with their native Rights , it being a peculiar happinesse of the Church of England to be alwaies under the protection of Christian Kings ; by whose encouragement and example , the Gospel was received in all parts of this Kingdome . And i● you look into Sir Henry Spleman's Collection of the Saxon Councels , I believe that you will hardly finde any Ecclesiastical Canons for the Government of the Church of England , which were not either originally promulgated , or after approved and allowed of either by the Supreme Monarch of all the Saxons , or by some King or other of the several 〈◊〉 , directing in their National or Provincial Synods . And they enjoyed this Prerogative without any dispute after the Norman Conquest also , till by degrees the Pope ingrossed it to himself ( as before was shewn ) and then conferred it upon such as were to exercise the same under his authority : which plainly manifests that the Act of Su●mission so much spoke of , was but a changing of their dependance from the Pope to the King , from an usurped to a lawful power , from one to whom they had made themselves a kinde of voluntary slaves , to him who justly challenged a natural dominion over them ; and secondly , that that submission of theirs to their natural Prince , is not to be considered as a new Concessi●n , but as the R●cognition only of a former power . In the next place I do not finde it to be contra●y to the usage of the primitive times . I grant indeed that when the Church was under the command of the Heathen Emperor● , the Clergy did assemble in their National and Provincial Synods of their own Authority : which Councels being summoned by the Metropolitans , and subscribed by the Clergy , were of sufficient power to binde all good Christians who lived within the Verge of their Jurisdiction . They could not else assemble upon any exigence of affai●s but by such authority . But it was otherwise when the Church came under the protection of Christian Princes : all Emperors and Kings from Constantine the Great ( till the Pope carried all before him in the darker times ) accompting it one of the principal flowers , ( as indeed it was ) which adorned their D●adems . I am not willing to beat ●n a common place . But if you please to look into the Acts of ancient Councels , you will finde that all the General Councels ( all which deserve to be so called , if any of them do deserve it ) to have been summoned and confirmed by the Christian Emperors , that the C●uncel of Arles was called and confirmed by the Emperor Constantine , that of Sardis by Constans , that of Lampsacus by Valentinian , that of Aqui●eia by Theodosius , that of The●●al●nica ( National or Provincial all ) by the Emperor Gratian : that when the Western Empire fell into the hands of the French , the Councels of A●on , Ment● , Meld●n , Wormes , and Colen received both life and motion ●●om Charles the Great and his Successors in that Emp●re ; it being evident in the Records of the Gallican Church , that the opening and confirming of all their Councels not only under the Caroline but under the Merovignean Family , was alwaies by the power , & sometimes with the Presidence of their Kings and Princes , as you may finde in the Collections of Lindebrogius , and Sirmondus the Iesuite : and finally that in Spain it self ( though now so much obnoxious to the Papal power ) the two at Bracara , and the ten first holden at Toledo , were summoned by the Writ and Mandate of the Kings thereof . Or if you be not willing to take this pains , I shall put you to a shorter and an easier search ; referring you for your better information in this particular to the learned Sermon preached by Bishop Andrewes at Hampton Court , anno 1606. touching the Right and power of calling Assemblies , or the right use of the Trumpets . A Sermon preached purposely at that time and place for giving satisfaction in that point to Melvin and some leading men of the Scotish Puritans , who of late times had arrogated to themselves an unlimited power of calling and constituting their Assemblies without the Kings cons●nt and against his will . As for the Vassallage which the Clergy are supposed to have drawn upon themselves by this Submission , I see no fear or danger of it as long as the two Houses of Parliament are in like condition ; and that the Kings of England are so tender of their own Prerogative , as not to suffer any one Body of the Subjects to give a Law unto the other without his consent . That which is most insisted on for the proof hereof , is the delegating of this power by King Henry the 8. to Sir Thomas Cromwell ( afterwards Earl of Essex and Lord high Chamberlain ) by the name of his Vicar General in Ecclesiastical matters : who by that name p●esided in the Convocation , anno 1536. and acted other things of like nature in the years next following . And this ( especially his presiding in the Convocation ) is looked on both by Sanders and some Protestant Doctors , not only as a great debasing of the English Clergie ( men very learned for those times ) but as deforme satis Spectacu●um , a k●nde of Monstrosity in nature . But certainly those men forget ( though I do not think my self bound to justifie all King Harr●es actions ) that in the Councell of Cha●●●don ▪ the Emperor apointed certain Noble-men to ●it as Judges , whose names occurre in the first Action of that Councell . The like we finde exemplified in the Ephesine Councell , in which by the appointment of Theod●sius and Valentinian then Roman Emp●rours , Candidianus , a Count Imperiall , ●ate as Judge o● President ; who in the managing of that trust over acted any thing that Cromwell did , or is objected to have been done by him as the Kings Commissioner . For that he was to have the first place in those publick meetings as the Kings Commissioner , or his Vicar-General , which you will , ( for I will neither trouble my self nor you with disputing Titles ) the very Scottish Presbyters , the most rigid sticklers for their own pretended ( and but pretended ) Rights which the world affords , do not stick to yeeld . No va●●allage of the Clergy to be ●ound in this , as little to be feared by their submission to the King as their Supreme Governour . Thus Sir according to my promise , and your expectation have I collected my Remembrances , and represented them unto you in as good a fashion as my other troublesome affairs , and the distractions of the time would give me leave ▪ and therein made you see , 〈◊〉 my judgement fail not , that neither our King or Parliaments have done more in matters which concern'd Religion and the Reformation of this Church , then what hath formerly been done by the secular Powers , in the best and happiest times of Christianity ; and consequently , that the clamours of the Papists and Puritans both , which have disturbed you , are both false and groundlesse . Which if it may be serviceable to your self , or others , whom the like doubts and prejudices have possessed or scrupled , It is all I wish : my studies and endevours aiming at no other end , then to do all , the service I can possibly to the Church of God ; to whose Graces and divine Protection you are most heartily commended in our Lord and Saviour Iesus Christ , By Sir , Your most affectionate friend to serve you , Peter Heylyn .