Fermentvm Pharisæorvm, or, The leaven of pharisaicall wil-worship: declared in a sermon on Matth. 15.9 Novemb. 24. 1641. at Lemster in Herefordshire. / By Iohn Tombes, B.D. Tombes, John, 1603?-1676. This text is an enriched version of the TCP digital transcription A94735 of text R20645 in the English Short Title Catalog (Thomason E56_16). Textual changes and metadata enrichments aim at making the text more computationally tractable, easier to read, and suitable for network-based collaborative curation by amateur and professional end users from many walks of life. The text has been tokenized and linguistically annotated with MorphAdorner. The annotation includes standard spellings that support the display of a text in a standardized format that preserves archaic forms ('loveth', 'seekest'). Textual changes aim at restoring the text the author or stationer meant to publish. This text has not been fully proofread Approx. 56 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 12 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. EarlyPrint Project Evanston,IL, Notre Dame, IN, St. Louis, MO 2017 A94735 Wing T1808 Thomason E56_16 ESTC R20645 99865608 99865608 155274 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A94735) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 155274) Images scanned from microfilm: (Thomason Tracts ; 10:E56[16]) Fermentvm Pharisæorvm, or, The leaven of pharisaicall wil-worship: declared in a sermon on Matth. 15.9 Novemb. 24. 1641. at Lemster in Herefordshire. / By Iohn Tombes, B.D. Tombes, John, 1603?-1676. England and Wales. Parliament. House of Commons. [4], 18 p. Printed by Richard Cotes for Andrew Crooke, and are to be sold at his shop at the signe of the Greene Dragon in Pauls Church-yard, London : 1643. Annotation on Thomason copy: "July ist". "It is this nineteenth day of Aprill Anno Dom. 1643. Ordered by the committee of the House of Commons in Parliament, concerning printing, that this book intituled (the leaven of Pharisaicall Wil-worship) be printed. John White." Reproduction of the original in the British Library. eng Bible. -- N.T. -- Matthew XV, 9 -- Sermons -- Early works to 1800. A94735 R20645 (Thomason E56_16). civilwar no Fermentvm Pharisæorvm, or, The leaven of pharisaicall wil-worship:: declared in a sermon on Matth. 15.9 Novemb. 24. 1641. at Lemster in Her Tombes, John 1643 9780 22 15 0 0 0 0 38 D The rate of 38 defects per 10,000 words puts this text in the D category of texts with between 35 and 100 defects per 10,000 words. 2007-05 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2007-05 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2007-09 Elspeth Healey Sampled and proofread 2007-09 Elspeth Healey Text and markup reviewed and edited 2008-02 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion FERMENTVM PHARISAEORVM , OR , The Leaven of Pharisaicall WIL-WORSHIP : Declared in A SERMON On Matth. 15. 9. Novemb. 24. 1641. at Lemster in Herefordshire . By IOHN TOMBES , B. D. It is this nineteenth day of Aprill Anno Dom. 1643. Ordered by the Committee of the House of Commons in Parliament , concerning Printing , that this Book intituled ( The Leaven of Pharisaicall Wil-Worship ) be Printed . John White . LONDON , Printed by Richard Cotes , for Andrew Crooke , and are to be sold at his shop at the signe of the Greene Dragon in Pauls Church-yard . 1643. TO THE RIGHT WORSHIPFVLL Richard Aldworth Esquire , Mayor , the Aldermen , Sheriffes , and the rest of the Inhabitants of the City of BRISTOLL . HOw tenacious the heart of man is of superstition , as former ages , so the present generation doe abundantly declare . No age can yeeld a more horrid instance of a people taught so much as this Nation hath beene concerning the true Worship of God , admonished so often ▪ that God is not pleased by humane rites , and yet still place their Religion in them , oppugne the representative Body of the Commonwealth , for seeking to remove them , fight for them tanquam pro aris & focis , spoyle their owne Countrey , with such cruell despight drive away their faithfull teachers , and unspotted neighbours from their dwellings , wives and children , and thinke it a good worke to destroy them for not yeelding to practise things never appointed by God and notoriously tending to superstition , and for their faithfull dealing with their soules in labouring to draw them from their vaine confidence in the flesh to worship God in the spirit , and to rejoyce in Christ Jesus . Hope somewhat to abate this fire of rage , moved me at first to cast this bucket of water to quench it . But as it happens often , that when water quencheth not a fire , it flames out the more by casting water on it : so it be fell me : the barbarous rage and impetuous violence of people so increased , that I could have no safety in my proper station , but was enforced to remove my selfe , Wife and Children , and since have suffered the spoyling of my goods , of my dwelling house , with many other injuries . After much tossing up and downe , J have in Your City cast anchor , till either a greater storme enforce me to commit my selfe to the Maine againe , or a favourable gale bring me into a Harbour . And that J may testifie my love to this City , and gratitude for my present entertainment , and withall aiming at your edification , J have presumed in publishing this Sermon , to prefixe your Names , to whom J humbly present it for your use and acceptance , and doe professe my selfe Yours , in the service of Christ Iesus , JOHN TOMBES . The Leaven of Pharisaicall Wil-worship . Matthew 15. 9. But in vaine they doe worship me , teaching for doctrines the Commandements of men . OF all the opposers of Christ none were more malicious , nor more dangerous then the Scribes & Pharisees : None more malicious , because none did so clearely apprehend the glory of Christ , as they that saw the rayes of his divinity shining in his miracles , the evidence of his acquaintance with God in his divine doctrine ; yet they hated him extreamely as shadowing and eclipsing their repute , and power with the people , whose praise they sought more then the praise of God : Now as no poyson is stronger then that of the hottest Countries , so no malice greater then that of the most enlightned breasts ; Nor any more dangerous , because none covered their enmity with such shewes of gravity and devotion as they did , whereby their example and perswasions tooke with many to the great hinderance of the efficacy of Christs Preaching : For formall hypocrisie is more mischievous to mens soules , then open ungodlinesse , in as much as it is lesse discernible , even as a viper lurking under greene leaves is more dangerous , then a dogge that runnes on a man with open mouth . Fallit vitium specie virtutis et umbra : which thing caused our Lord Christ to have more encounters with this generation of vipers , then with all other adversaries . Among which , that which is related in this Chapter is remarkeable : For it may seeme that they came downe from Jerusalem of purpose to quarrell with Christ , and therefore our Saviour deales with them most plainely and sharpely in his reply . The occasion they take was his disciples omission of their antient Custome of washing afore meales , the neglect of which they conceived a great crime , as violating the tradition of the Elders : Concerning which they expostulate with Christ for his disciples supposed fault : v. 2. Why doe thy disciples transgresse the tradition of the Elders ? Had the people of this generation beene to make answer to this question , they would have fallen on Christs disciples , and checked them for their indiscretion at least in giving offence in a matter indifferent , of novelty in not observing old customes . They should have heard , What harme is it to wash ones hands before meales ? why should not men for peace sake doe as others doe ? Are you wiser then the Rabbines ? then your Elders ? will you be singular and different from all others ? Smooth words should have beene given to the Pharisees , to entreat them to be contented , order should be taken to teach the disciples better manners ; But our Saviour carries the businesse in another way , what his disciples neglected to doe , he himselfe gave them example to neglect , Luk. 11. 38. And when the Pharisees excepted against them , he doth in plaine words endite them of hypocrisie , and chargeth them home by a proofe from the Prophet Esaias , which he applies to them as forespoken of them . vers. 7 , 8 ▪ 9. So that the words of my text are a passage cited out of the prophesie of Isaiah 29. 13. wherein our Saviour makes use of the Septuagints translation , which is somewhat different in words , though not in sense , from the Hebrew , for whereas in the Hebrew the words are , And their feare towards me is taught from , or by the precepts of men , the Septuagint reade , But in vaine doe they worship me , teaching for doctrines the Commandements of men . In which there is a sinne charged upon these Pharises , to wit , the teaching doctrines the commandements of men , that is , as Piscator in his Scholies paraphraseth the words , tales doctrinas , quae nihil aliud sunt quam mandata hominum , such doctrines as are nothing else but mens commandements , which being taught by those that were to be teachers of the law , and seemed to be such in stead of Gods precepts , were therefore accounted as Gods worship , or his feare . 2. There is a censure passed on this practice [ In vaine doe they worship me ] which words are not in the Hebrew , yet may be collected from the woe threatned to such teachers , Isa. 29. 14. whereby God disclaimes such teaching and practice as being no service of his , though the teachers and practisers of such Commands of men , imagined they honored God thereby . So that the plaine truth that this enunciation of our Lord Christ affords is this : That however they thinke of their actions they doe is vaine worship God , who teach for doctrines mens precepts . The selfe same truth is seconded by Saint Paul , who in his Epistle to the Colassians ch. 2. v. 20 , 21 , 23. speakes thus ; why as though living in the world are ye subject to ordinances ; after the commandements and doctrines of men ? which things have indeed a shew of wisedome in will-worship . In which you may clearely see that the Apostle condemnes dogmatizing , that is , either teaching ▪ urging , or submitting to {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} , orders and rites , as the word signifies , Col. 2. 14. Ephes. 2. 15. Luk. 2. 1. which are after the commandements and doctrines of men , which he sayes have a shew of wisedome in wil-worship , which hath no true wisedome , nor pleaseth God . That I may the more clearely and fully open the truth in this point , I shall distinctly endeavour to declare , what these doctrines commandements of men were , and how the Pharisees taught them . 2. How they did worship God in vaine . 3. Why they did in vaine worship God . Concerning the first of these , It is plaine that these Pharisees and Scribes did many wayes teach contrary to the Law of God , to wit , in expounding the lawes of God as if they did onely prohibit the grosse externall act , Matth. 5. 21 , 27 , 33 , 38 , 43. they urged the smaller matters of the law , as tithing of mint , and neglected the greater , Matth. 23. 23. But in this place that which our Saviour objects to them is that they sought to establish the traditions of men , though Gods commands were thereby rejected , or neglected . Particularly that a man was not to regard the honouring of his father and mother , if he had taken on him the rash and impious vow of Corban , which was directly contra legem , against the law , to allow men for an unjust oathes sake to breake Gods plaine precept . But chiefely that they taught men to observe things praeter legem , besides the law , instead of Gods law , as the washing hands afore meales , the washing of cups and pots , brazen vessells and tables , with many such like traditions invented by men : These things they strictly urged on the people , excepting much at the omission of them , conniving at , yea countenancing the transgression of God precepts : They ascribed so much authority to the traditions of the Elders that they made it a great crime to transgresse them ; they conceived and taught that the not observing of them made men unholy and uncleane , else they would not have been offended with Christ , when he taught that the eating with unwashen hands defileth not a man ; they conceived their observation of them did please God as if he were thereby honoured . Now this teaching for doctrines mens precepts is worshipping God in vaine , because it doth not please God . Frusta fit quod non attingit finem , That is done in vaine which attaines not its end , wherefore sith such commandements of men are observed that God may be pleased , and God is not thereby pleased , they must needes be in vaine . And indeed God is not pleased with such service , sith he counts it no service to him , yea he is much displeased with it , as appeares by the threatning , Isa. 29. 14. Because their feare towards me is taught by the precepts of men , therefore behold I will proceede to doe a marvellous worke among this people , even a marvailous worke and a wonder , for the wisedome of their wise men shall perish , and the understanding of their prudent men shall be hid . All which came to passe when the Pharisees and Scribes who were accounted the onely {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} or wise men , Doctors of the Lawes , Rabbins and Masters in Israel , by reason of their placing religion in traditions of men , washings , long robes , phylacteries and such like , were delivered over to such blindnesse and sottishnesse of spirit as to be ignorant of their Messiah , and his Kingdome , the true righteousnesse of the Gospell , spirituall new-birth , and other heavenly truths of Gods profound Counsell in Christ . A most heavy , but most just judgement of God , that like as when the heathens knowing God by his workes they held the truth in unrighteousnesse , so these knowing him by his law , but loving unrighteousnesse , should become vaine in their imaginations , and their foolish heart be darkened , professing themselves to be wise they should become fooles , Rom. 1. 21 , 22. For what more foolish then to thinke that the onely wise God who is an immortall Spirit should be pleased with such toyes , as washings , phylacteries and such like observances , when there is no Philosopher that is given to contemplation , but thinkes such things to be rather babies for children to play with , then bookes for men to reade ? Of this censure and judgement there may be many reasons given . As first , It is vaine to worship or to thinke to please God by the doctrines which are Commandements of men : for God is not pleased with mans devices , what is devised by man comes from a corrupt and foolish heart , and such a corrupt fountaine must needs send forth but puddle water . And this is true of the best of men in the things of God : The Lord knoweth the thoughts of the wise that they are vaine , 1 Cor. 3. 20. Whence the Apostle , Col. 2. 23. when he speakes of the things devised by men who introduced {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} {non-Roman} , a wil-worship , sayes of them that they had a shew of wisedome , they seemed to be wise inventions to beget reverence to God , and humility in mens spirits , but it was farre otherwise in truth . For as children doe count many things wise which understanding men doe laugh at : so carnall hearts of men esteemed as wise among men doe count many things to be wise , as duckings , bowings , washings , whippings , creepings , pilgrimages , and such like gestures , usages , and rites invented by men to expresse humility , devotion and reverence to God , which the Almighty , who is a most holy Spirit , contemnes as childish , apish , theatrical and ridiculous : Besides ; we may consider the vanity of such inventions for Gods worship by the event . For whereas many things have beene invented and used by men out of a supposed good intent to further devotion experience hath sufficiently proved that they have corrupted the Church with superstition and Idolatry . Thus Images thought fit by Gregory to bee made Laymens bookes became in time Laymens and Clergy mens , Gods too , the signe of the Crosse invented to testifie their faith in Christ before heathens , became the object of faith and adoration instead of Christ among Christians , the praying at the Tombes of Martyrs proceeded to the invocation of Martyrs , monasticall orders and vowes highly commended for the promoting of chastity and piety became the chiefest meanes to further superstition , ignorance , sensuality and uncleannesse , that ever the devill invented : The like might be said of reserving the Eucharist , keeping of festivals , of fasting dayes , preserving of reliques , pilgrimages , and innumerable other devices , which in processe of time , though at first invented for a good use , turned to the great detriment of religion , and corrupting of the Gospell : I thinke an instance cannot be given of a device of man pretending to advance piety , and to edifie the Church , when God hath provided other meanes to that end , which hath not in the conclusion hindered piety ; and more or lesse , destroyed the purity of Religion . So sottish and blinde is the wisedome of man in appointing and directing the service of God . Secondly , in vaine is Gods feare taught by mens precepts , because God is not pleased with Carnall observances and bodily exercises : Bodily exercise , saith the Apostle 1 Tim. 4. 8. profiteth little , but godlinesse is profitable to all things , where the Apostle opposeth godlinesse to bodily exercise , and thereby sheweth that bodily exercise is not godlinesse , and therefore profits but a little , to wit among men , getting esteeme with them , but nothing with God , whose promises onely are made to true Godlinesse which is a spirituall exercise . For God is a Spirit , and they that worship him , must worship him in Spirit and in truth , saith our Saviour , John . 4. 23 , 24. Now mens precepts are altogether about bodily things , as washings , gestures , garments , fastings , feastings , processions , buildings , and such like ; All which reach no further then the body , cannot rectifie or amend the Soule : and make it more like to God . Thirdly , this teaching for doctrines mens precepts displeaseth God , as being injurious to him , and that in a double respect : first , teaching and urging mens commands in stead of doctrines , whereby Gods worship should be taught , intrencheth on Gods Prerogative , who is the onely Lawgiver to his Church , Jam. 4. 12. for his worship . For as it is a prerogative of a King to appoint the wayes of his owne service and honour , and he should be taken to be very presumptuous and arrogant that should take upon him to prescribe a fashion of attendance , suite , and service to his Prince without his consent , when he hath otherwise declared his will ; so is it much more intolerable pride , and presumption in a mortall man , to appoint a way of service to God , which he never consented to , but hath otherwise directed his owne service . And for the same reason it is a transferring of Gods prerogative on a man , when he doth servilly consent by subjecting his conscience to such usurpation . Secondly , God is injured by the thoughts that such superstitious persons have of God , when they conceive God to be such a one as will be pleased with humane Ceremonies , to be so childish or simple as to be affected with pompes , and shewes , and gestures , and carnall rites , which he never appointed . I remember the saying of a man of great wit to this effect : That superstition alike injures God , as Atheisme . For as Plutarch sayes , I had as liefe men should say there is no such man as Plutarch , as to say Plutarch is a foole ; so saith the Author it is as injurious to God to say he is so childish , as to be taken with superstition , as to deny his being . Fourthly , this teaching for doctrines mens precepts produceth many other evill effects . First , it opposeth Gods word , his Law , his Gospell sundry wayes . First , Because it brings in another rule of worship then Gods Law , to wit tradition of Elders , custome , example , or opinion of seeming grave , wise and pious men , of affected teachers . For these are the rules by which superstitious persons are guided , not by Gods word . Now it is a high crime against God to follow any other rule of our worship and obedience to him , sith he hath injoyned Deut. 4. 2. Ye shall not adde unto the word which I command you , neither shall you diminish ought from it , that ye may keepe the commandements of the Lord your God , which I command you . Prov. 30. 6. Adde not thou unto his words , lest he reprove thee and thou bee found a lier . Secondly , Because it opposeth the manifestation of the cleare light of the Gospell . As shadowes darken the light of the Sunne that shines in the aire , so carnall rites invented by men obscure the spirituall beauty , and splendour of the Gospell , so that by reason of such rites the Gospell is either not considered , or understood carnally : Thus the Ceremonies of Moses law were as a vaile before the eyes of the Jewes , that they could not looke to the end of that which is abolished , 2 Cor. 3. 13. And the popish ceremonies darkned the true light of the Gospell . And let any man looke into those places in which there is so much preaching of ceremonies , and Church orders , and such a regular observation of them , as in places where the Cathedrall and Canonicall Preachers , and officiating Priests doe beare sway , he shall finde little spirituall understanding , and lively feeling of the doctrine and grace of Christ ; the highest pitch that they bring men to , ( and there are but few that are brought by them so farre ) is some morall civility , some outward regularity in the outward formes of devotion , which yet is accompanyed , as it was in the Pharisees , with bitter and virulent enmity against holy and ardent zeale for Christ , and shewes it selfe to be but Pharisaicall hypocrisie when it is brought to triall . It is usually alledged that such Ceremonies are appointed for edification , and that the text 1 Cor. 14. 26. Let all things be done unto edifying , allowes men , specially Prelates in a Synod , to ordaine what they conceive may be for edifying . But the occasion of these words plainly shewes that the Apostle meanes not every arbitrary devise which is conceited by men , though the wisest , most grave and pious , to bee for edifying , must be done , for then the text would impose a necessity of subjection to such humane devices . But the text is plainly meant of such things as are necessary to edification , as speaking in a knowne tongue , and without confusion . And although I know Ceremonies invented by men are pretented to serve for edification , yet I must professe that I never found in my reading , or experience , that ever any person by such rites , or observances was wonne to the profession of Christ , or brought to any spirituall knowledge of Christ , any true faith or sincere obedience to him . Possibly they may beget some kinde of raptures of carnall delight , through melodious soundes or pleasant sights , some kinde of womanish pity , and teares , such as the acting of a stage play will draw from some persons : but that ever they begat sanctifying knowledge , sound repentance , holy mortification of sinne , lively faith , fruitfull living to God , I assure my selfe cannot be shewed : But it is certaine on the contrary that the teaching for doctrines commandements of men hath occasioned men to oppose the principall point of the Gospell of Chri●t , to wit , justification by faith in him , and contrary to the covenant of grace in Christ to conceive a righteousnesse in themselves by the observation of mens commands , as in the Pharisees and Papists , and al sorts of superstitious persons it doth abundantly appeare . Thirdly , because the teachers of precepts of men for doctrines doe still oppose the fruitfull and faithfull Preaching of Gods word . Thus it was in the Pharisees , thus in Papists , and thus it appeares still by experience . They that urge or affect humane religious rites are disaffected and adversaries to Godly Preaching : where the one is set up , the other goes downe . And this shewes a malignity in them when they are so inconsistent with that , of which our Saviour said , One thing is necessary , Luk. 10. 42. Even as weedes though never so pleasant to the eyes are judged to be hurtfull when they destroy good Corne , which should preserve mens lives . And for this reason should be weeded out when they have this effect , what ever pretence of antiquity or esteeme they have . Lastly , It opposeth Gods word in that it introduceth an obedience , which alwayes diminisheth or annihilates the obedience due to Gods Law : were there no more instances to prove this , then what we finde of the Pharisees charged upon them by our Lord Christ , Mark . 7. 8. that laying aside the Commandement of God they held the tradition of men , v. 9. ye reject the Commandement of God that ye may keep your owne tradition , ver. 13. making the word of God of none effect through your tradition , this were enough to make it appeare that as Pharaohs leane kine devoured the fat ones , so this superstitious devotion to mens precepts devoures the true obedience that is due to Gods Commands : But it is also manifest that such is the effect of observing humane traditions by the practises of Papists , and ignorant superstitious people in all Countries : For as for Papists it is notorious how zealous they are for the traditions , as they call them , of the Church , but how carelesse they are of Gods commands : I had rather expresse it in the words of another then mine owne . What Papist in all Christendome hath ever beene heard to pray dayly with his family , or sing but a Psalme at home ? Looke into the universall course of the Catholike life , there you shall finde the Decalogue professedly broken , besides the ordinary practice of Idolatry , and frequency of oathes : Who ever saw Gods day duely kept in any City , village or houshold under the Jurisdiction of Rome ? Every obscure holy day takes the wall of it and thrusts it into the Channel : Who sees not obedience to authority so slighted , that it stands onely to the mercy of humane dispensation ? And in the rest of Gods Lawes who sees not how foule sins passe for veniall ? and how easily veniall sins passe their satisfaction : for which a crosse or drop of holy water is sufficient amends ? Who sees not how no place can be left for truth , where there is full roome given to equivocation ? And how true the like is of the late prelaticall party , and their superstitious adherents , who have so zealously and industriously promoted humane Ceremonies , it is abundantly manifest , by their opening a gap for licentiousnesse in prophaning the Lords day , by their discountenancing and suppressing the diligent preaching of Gods word , by their countenancing drinking of healths , common swearing , gaming and other practises of sensuality , either practising them or not reproving them , but speaking favourably of such as use them , and by their continuall disquieting of those that have sought to promote the knowledge and worship of God by praying in their families , repeating Gods word , and praising of God together , and chiefly by their devillish practises whereby they endeavour to hinder the reformation of the ignorance , ungodlinesse , and prophanenesse that hath overspread the Land by reason of an unworthy ministery and corrupt discipline . And indeed this is the genuine effect that followes this sinne , that it makes men averse from , and negligent of Gods Commands . Saint Augustines observation in his 119. Epistle to Januarius of the men of his time is well knowne , that those who made conscience to touch the ground with their bare feete in their Octaves , made no scruple of conscience to be drunken . And the like is still found true , that those that are scrupulous to omit a Church order , an old tradition , an humane rite , scarse ever make scruple of being drunke ; of officious , and jesting lies , of charming , or going to such as say prayers to helpe Cattell , of entertaining people in riotous manner , of hearing and spreading lies of Godly persons , of faithfull preachers : but are rather so besotted as to thinke some of these to be good workes , or at least that there is no harme in them . In a word , there is such a venome in this practice of teaching and observing of doctrines mens precepts , that it strangeth the mindes of people and Ministers from learning , and studying Gods word , and inclines them to heede and invent and be led by tales and legends of lies framed to get credit to superstitious usages that have no strength of them selves . Another evill effect by this sinne is against Gods worship bringing men to an hypocriticall image of devotion without life , a forme of godlinesse without power : This might easily be verified by instancing in the Pharisees and Papists praying and fasting , being but a meere semblance and shell of those duties . And thus it is with those people among our selves that place their Religion in their rites , and thinke they shall have a new Religion when any old custome or rite is left ; they thinke they have kept a fast well , if they have forborne eating , though there have beene no examination of Conscience , humiliation of soule , or repentance from sinne : they thinke they pray well if they be present when the Service booke is read , and say after the Minister , though without knowledge , attention of minde , faith in Gods promises , or fervency of desire : they thinke they receive the Lords supper well , if without any godly preparation , spirituall meditation , they doe with empty stomacks and faire deportment eate the bread and drinke the wine of solemne seasons : they thinke they use baptisme well , if they get some to stand at the font as sureties , for the Childs faith , ( which I thinke to be proper to Christ , Heb. 7. 22. ) the Childe to be sprinckled with water , & crossed on the fore-head , though there be no sense of the guilt and defilement of sinne , utter ignorance of the excellency and necessity of spirituall new birth . And the like is their carriage in hearing the word read and preached , in singing of Psalmes , &c. In all there is the Popish conceit of apus operatum , that the worke done pleaseth God , that if they have faire service and their rites they are well , though they are no whit changed , enlightned , awakened in their consciences , or altered and quickned in their conversation . Adde hereunto that this wil-worship puffs men up with spirituall pride ; Thus the Pharisees were proud of their often fastings , and the Friers are lifted up in great conceits of their holinesse by their observing the rules of their orders , and formall Protestants in the observatition of there customes and traditions . True Religion humbles men : but empty ▪ Ceremonies like winde in a bladder puffe up the soule . Finally , this wil-worship and teaching for doctrines mens precepts , is opposite to true charity , in that it begets hatred against true and zealous worshippers of God , and this hatred shewes it selfe not onely in evill thoughts , and beleeving all false reports , and hard censures of them , but also in bitter invectives against them for not affecting and liking their superstitious and virulent persecution of those that conforme not to their practice , though it be onely because of tendernesse of conscience . Hence it was that the Pharisees could better comply with such wicked men as Caiaphas , Pilate , Herod , then with Christ , his Disciples , and John Baptist ; the Papists with Jewes , Turkes , Sodomits , then with the godly Divines of the reformed Churches ; the formal Prelatists among Prote●tants with the most prophane Libertines , or Idolatrous Papists , then with a zealous preacher of the Gospell ; yea the most strict Pharisees have beene still the most incessant persecutors of Christ , the most devout Friers , the most eager and bloody inquisitors , the most zealous for Church Canons and Rites , the most heavy and unrelenting deprivers , censurers and vexers of reverend Ministers and unspotted Christians , whom they have confessed to agree with them in the same faith , and to dissent onely from them in discipline and Ceremonies . Secondly , It causeth contentions , Schismes , and divisions in the Church , witnesse the great contentions betweene the Easterne and Westerne , Saxon and Brittish Churches , about Easter , Monkes and Friers , about the rules of their orders conformists & non-conformists , about Ceremonies , which the defenders acknowledge but trifles , yet promote with as much bitter zeale , as if Salus eccles ae verteretur in istis , the safety of the Church , faith and Religion depended on them . Thirdly , By it Christian liberty is impaired , which being a precious thing to a Christian soule cannot be taken away without injury ; All wil-worship at first conception hath pretence of order and decency ▪ perhaps the things in which it is placed are taken but as indifferent , which yet in processe of time gaine opinion of holinesse and necessity to that end , and so bring the conscience into bondage . Fourthly , To conclude , this evill tends to the detriment of mens goods , the pillaging of their purses , for no benefit to the owners , much hinderance to the poore , labouring Ministers , and Common-wealth on which it should be bestowed . Many a pound is given in Legacies and Contributions , is extorted by Courts , for maintaining vestments , organs , processions , windowes , buildings , and other things unnecessary , when the poore want , painefull Preachers live on a small stipend , the Common-wealth is brought to straights : For superstition is costly , and supers●●tious persons are either lavishly profuse , or slavisbly ready to bestow their goods for very vanities which doe them no good , when by a right bestowing of their goods they might make them friends of the unrighteous Mammon and be re●eived into everlasting habitations . For application of this truth . That which hath beene said may helpe us to take the right dimensions of this sinne : as in all other things pertaining to God , mans reason judgeth very corruptly , so in particular about censuring of sinnes : sinnes which injure men , and harme them in their bodies , goods or name , are accounted hainous , and the acting of them stirres up mens Spirits to rage and fury against the Authors . But sinnes against Gods excellency and glory , though they be indeed Camells , yet are swallowed downe as gnats . They that cry out against theft , and murther , and slander , are very favourable in censuring Idolatry , blasphemy and prophanenesse . Hence it is that superstition is conceived harmelesse , and superstitious persons , though most injurious to God , yet counted harmelesse by men ; it is hard to convince men that this is a sinne , or to bring them to any serious repentance for it . But would men seriously lay to heart that which hath beene said , and judge righteous judgement , it would be found that wil-worship is a sinne of a deepe dye , estranging the heart farre from God , and stirring up his soule against men , wherefore it concernes especially two sorts of persons to lay this to heart . First , the Papists , both Clergy and people , who are horribly guilty of this point of Pharisaisme in teaching & observing innumerable doctrines & usages of rites , customes , ceremonies after the Commandement of men without Gods word . It were an infinite businesse to reckon up all their humane religious devices in their fastings , Sacraments , burialls , festivalls , Churches , religious orders , and the like . They pretend that the Churches orders are Gods orders , and for that purpose alledge , Luk. 10. 16. Hee that heareth you , heareth mee : and bee that despiseth you , despiseth mee . But this is absurdly alledged . For this extends not to every thing that the seventy disciples ( to whom those words were spoken ) should devise of themselves : but onely to what they should teach according to that injunction Matth. 28. 20. given to the Apostles , that they should teach all nations to observe al things whatsoever he commanded them . And in this limitation he that heareth the least minister of the Gospell heareth Christ , as well as he that heareth the Pope or a Synod of Prelates , whom they ridiculously call the Church . They tell us that their traditions are not contra legem , against the law , but praeter legem , besides the law . To which we reply . The same might have been said for the Pharisees washings , for which neverthelesse our Saviour chargeth them with hypocris●e . And indeed though the things themselves were not plainely contra legem against Gods Law , yet the practice of teaching & n●…ng such things for or instead of Gods feare is directly against Gods Law , which forbids us to adde or diminish from Gods commandements . Secondly , The late Prelaticall prevailing party of this Kingdome may be charged as guilty of the same sinne of which our Saviour indited these Pharisees in whose steps they tread , I say the late Prelaticall party , that I may not be thought to lay this imputation on the first reformers , and their reverend successors , who were constant and zealous Preachers of the Gospell of Christ , and many of them confirmed it by their sufferings . I say the late prevailing Prelaticall party , because I conceive that some of the Prelates of this Land have beenemore considerate then to urge and teach Commandements of men in that manner that the prevailing party hath done . I mean in their teaching and practise about Images , Crucifixes , Altars , Rayles , Tapers , bowing to or towards Altars , praying towards the East , bowing at the naming of the word Jesus , consecrating Churches , Confirmation , Copes , Organes , Surplisses , Crossing at the solemnity of Baptisme , and the like . All which have beene urged and used of late with a Pharisaicall and Popish Spirit as if by the using them men were made more holy , God served , and the not conforming to them a crime of want of devotion and reverence to God . And yet the same party shew themselves adversaries to the constant and fruitfull preaching of Gods word , sanctifying of the Lords day , exercising of the duties of Religion in private houses , as prayer , repeating of Gods word , praysing of God , Godly conference of Scripture , reformation of prophane swearing , excessive drinking , gaming , sporting , and the like palpable sinnes ; they inveigh much against the Sacriledge of keeping back tithes , and other Ecclesiasticall dues from Ministers , and yet winke at it as if it were no sacriledge in Ministers to pervert holy things to maintaine pompe and riot , without doing the worke for which the wages is due , to wit the laborious preaching of the Gospell : turning the Ministry of the word into an officiating Priest-hood to observe rites injoyned by Canons of men . The exception I conceive may be taken to this charge is , That they are not urged as if they were necessary , but as things indifferent , for order and decency . Whereto I reply . First , That for some of them it cannot be conceived that they are indifferent , but plainely evill , as the setting up of Images in Temples , Crucifixes , &c. For some of them it is not denyed but that they are indifferent in se , of themselves , and of their owne nature : For my part I conceive that it is indifferent in it selfe to weare a white linnen garment or a blacke gowne , to pray with the face toward the East or the West : If any say they are simply in themselves unlawfull , I cannot excuse them from negative superstition , in denying the use of that to be lawfull , which God hath not forbidden to be used . For most of them there can hardly be a colour of appointing them in their use prescribed and urged for order and decency onely , sith any man may easily perceive that they tend onely to bring in a gay sense affecting spendour in Gods service , and serve to breed Jewish and Popish conceits in the mindes of people . It is granted that many things are left to the disposing of the governours of the Church pertaining to order and decencie , 1 Cor. 14. 40. though it is to be considered that how farre that permission extends , it is not without difficulty to determine , and oftentimes under pretext of that speech many things are appointed that pertaine not to meere order and decency . I adde further , that some of them were intended in their institution by the reformers to be used onely for decency and orders sake , though perhaps erroneously . But as for the late urging and practising of them , by the late prevailing Prelaticall party , they have beene urged for a further end then order and decency , yea with a Pharisaicall minde , as hath beene said : And this may appeare from their writings , sayings , and actions . From their writings , which tell us , that those Church Ceremonies are the great witnesse to the world , that men may see our devotion and glorifie our Father which is in heaven ; that the promoting them is the settlement of Gods externall worship ; that this businesse of promoting Church Ceremonies is the piety of the times , the good worke in hand : which speake excessively of the authority of the Church , that with like reverence men are to obey the conmands of Bishops as Gods , when they command not things contrary to God , that what is decreed in the holy Councells of Bishops is all to bee attributed to Gods will : that Church orders are to be obeyed without examining the reasons : in which writings wee finde that text , Phil. 2. 10. brought to binde Christians to a Ceremony of bowing at the naming of Jesus , in the Church here , which is most clearely meant of universall subjection of all persons to Christ , wil they nill they , at the day of Judgement , as appeares by comparing it with the text , Rom. 14 10 , 11 , 12. And that text Heb. 13. 10. is produced for a materiall Altar , which the whole context shewes to be meant metaphorically . From their sayings , as that frequent speech , No Ceremony no Bishop , and yet Bishops avouched to be jure divino , these impious yet frequent speeches , wherein to their owne inexcusable shame , they sticke not to professe that they love a Papist though an Idolater , better then a Puritane , whom they acknowledge not to differ from them in matters of faith and religion , but onely in discipline and Ceremonies , that they had rather joyne with the former then the latter . From their doings , as their conniving at , yea and favouring of Popery , but extreame severity to those that conformed not to their Ceremonies , their censuring men for the meere omission of them , suspending , depriving , excommunicating , imprisoning , fining those that could or yeeld to them though charged with no other crime , when al sort of erroneous teachers , and licentious livers , were tolerated and greatly favoured , from their discountenancing preaching of the Gospell , and promoting a bare officiating ministry without preaching : from their violent endeavours to obtrude on Scotland their rites , from their practises in contriving the oath of the late Synod , and in a word , from the whole course of their proceedings tending to superstition , formality and Popery , as the Remonstrance of the State of the Kingdome by the House of Commons in this present Parliament doth declare . Secondly , From hence some Apology may be framed for defence of them that of late have disused those Ceremonies which heretofore they used : Great outcries are made in some places against such , as refractary to Government , changeable with the times . The former imputation is easily answered , if the conscience conceive upon reason that the continuing of the use of them would be sinfull . For no man will say that in the use of unnecessary Ceremonies , which the conscience thinkes upon probable grounds out of Gods word to bee unlawfull , a Christian is bound to doe that which authority commands . As for the oth●r imputation , although it cannot be called a fault for a man to change his minde upon reasons not knowne or not considered so well before , specially in such disputable points ; ( For what judicious Divine is there who hath not in some things altered his opinion ? or what meere man is he that may not by after thoughts correct the former ? ) Yet the truth is , in point of Ceremony , and things indifferent , that some things may be unlawfull at one time , which are not unlawfull at another : For in such things the differing circumstances , intentions and ends in using and imposing them , may make them lawfull at one time and unlawfull at another , without any lightnesse or inconstancy in the judgement : Who knowes not that Saint Paul one while used the Ceremonies of Moses Law , which he would by no meanes suffer to be used at another time ? And in this present matter I conceive they who have changed their opinion and practice may be justified by foure reasons . First , Because as hath beene proved the Ceremonies heretofore declared and appointed as indifferent for order and decency onely , have beene urged of late as needefull offices of holinesse , as if they were necessary evidences and meanes of devotion , of more moment then the preaching of Gods word . Now it is the plaine doctrine of the Apostle Col. 2. 20. when Ceremonies are obtruded as necessary , we are not to submit to them . If ye be dead with Christ , saith the Apostle , from the rudiments of the world , why as though living in the world are ye subject to ordinances . Peccant igitur saith Bishop Davenant on those words , non modo qui nova decreta fabricantur in religione , sed qui iisdem se subj●ciunt , & libertatem Christi sanguine partam patiuntur sibi eripi : Quid ritibus oneramini ? inquit Apostolus : quasi diceret , vestrum est hoc jugum recusare , & in li●erate quâ Christus vos liberavit perstare , ut Paulus m●net , Gal. 5. 1. That is , they therefore sinne not onely who make new decrees in Religion , but who subject themselves to the same , and suffer the liberty gotten by the blood of Christ to be taken from them . Why are yee burdened with rites ? saith the Apostle , as if he should say , It belongs to you to refuse this yoke , and to persist in the liberty in which Christ hath freed you , as Paul admonisheth , Gal. 5. 1. Secondly , Because it is apparent by many proofes , and declared in the Remonstrance of the State of the Kingdome , that they have beene urged and used for the reduction of Superstition and Popery , and for the hindering of true godlinesse . Papists themselves boasted of it that we were comming neare to them , and they gathered it from the outward face of this Church , as was of late in the urging and use of Ceremonies . Besides they began to corrupt the doctrine of Religion , specially that point of the free grace of God , as the booke called the Cumerb●rtant selfe - Conviction proves from their writings . And it is the rule of Master Francis Mason in his booke of the authority of the Church on 1 Cor. 14. 40. that when the Doctrine declineth , the Ceremony is perverted . Now the Apostles practice is a sure rule , who having circumcised Timothy would not yeeld to have Titus circumcised , when he saw that by yeelding , the preservation of Christian liberty and of the truth of the Gospell , was endangered : Gal. 2. 3 , 4 , 5. Thirdly , Because they are found to foment Ignorance and superstition in the people . And this by innumerable experiments is manifest , that by reason of the constant continuance of them Religion is placed in them , yea the omitting of a Ceremony is conceived an alteration of Religion , they are zealous for them as if all their Religion were placed in them . Nor is this onely in places where there hath beene no Preacher to shew their errour : but also where they have been often and fully taught the contrary . And indeed where humane Ceremonies are p●ecisely used , the word of God is little minded : Now in this case though the things be indifferent in themselves , yet are they not to be used to the scandall of mens soules . It is the speech of the second part of the Sermon of fasting in the second Tome of Homilies , that Gods Church ought not , neither may it be so tyed to that or any other order now made or hereafter to be made and devised by the authority of man , but that it may lawfully and for just causes , alter , change or mitigate those ecclesiasticall decrees and orders , yea recede wholly from them and breake them , when they tend either to superstition , or to impiety , when they draw the people from God , rather then worke any edisication in them . Fourthly , Because they have found them to increase more and more , and the yeelding to some gives encouragement to adde more . Now it is a rule agreed that Ceremonies if many are an intolerable burthen . It makes the case of the Church Christian worse then that of the Jewes , if as Saint Augustine observes Epist. 119. ad Januarium , the Christian Church being freed from legall ordinances of God be burthened with humane presumptions . Now as he that will beare a little burthen , will throw off all if more bee added to over burthen him , so may that man that would beare a few Ceremonies ▪ justly throw off all when the burthen is increased without measure : especially sith multitude of Ceremonies shadow the Gospell , making the Religion rather carnall , like the Jewish , then spirituall , like the Christian ; & hindering the fruit thereof from ripening , as too many leaves doe a few grapes that are covered by them . Thirdly , from hence we may take occasion to admonish ministers that they avoid the way of these Pharisees , who taught for doctrines mens precepts . Con●ider I beseech you whereto you are called , to be Ministers of Christ and Stewards of the mysteries of God , 1 Cor. 4. 1. not observers of Ceremonies and teachers of Church orders : Give me leave to expostulate with you . Are ye called to maintaine mens traditions ? or Gods word ? the Ceremonies of men ? or the Gospell of Christ ? How will you then give your account to Christ when you are so zealous for mens traditions , so cold for his Gospell ? When ye exclaime against them that omit an humane Ceremony , favour and commend them that teach not the way of salvation ? When yee foment the hatred of the people against those that disuse Ceremonies of men , favour them that neglect the Commands of God ? when ye cherish the ignorance and superstition of the common people which ye should labour to weede out of their hearts ? Is it not enough for you to worship God in vaine but that ye teach men so to doe ? I beseech you consider that threatning before alledged , Isa. 29. 14. that for this cause the wisedome of the wise men shall perish , and the understanding of the prudent shall be hid . Remember the threatning , Mal. 2. 9. Therefore have I also made you contemptible and base before all the people , according as yee have not kept my wayes , but have beene partiall in the law . Fourthly , From hence we may take occasion to admonish the people to take heed of such Pharisaicall teachers , as teach for Doctrines Commandements of men : our Saviour Christ having manifested the hypocrisie of the Scribes and Pharisees in this thing , bids his Disciples let them alone , telling them that they were blinde leaders of the blinde ; and if the blinde lead the blinde , both fall into the ditch , Matth. 15. 14. And elsewhere , Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees , which is hypocrisie , Luk. 12. 1. And surely people have neede to take heede of such teachers , sith superstition , as it is a pernitious evill , so it easily insinuates into peoples mindes , and sticks fast in them under shew of antiquity , decency and gravity . I know this will bee interpreted as if it were a hainous thing to perswade people to withdraw themselves from the Ministers of their Parish though never so negligent or corrupt . But let Bishop Bilson answer for me , Imo populus ipse deficiente Magistratu Christiano deserere falsos & improbos pastores jure Divino potest , coercere vero minime . Declinare & derelinquere eos possunt , cogere aut punire non possunt . Vis et vindicta gladio alligatae , extra privatorum sortem ac caetum collocatae sunt . Vnde Paulus Rom. 16. Observate eos qui dissidia & scandala contra doctrinam quam edocti estis faciunt , et declinate ab iis . Oves meae , inquit Dominus noster Johan . 10. vocem meam audiunt , & sequuntur me . Alienum autem nequaquam sequentur , sed fugient ab eo . Idem Cyprianus et reliqui Episcopi consulti rescripserunt Epist. Lib. 1. Ep. 4. Separemini , inquit Dominus , a tabernaculis hominum istorum durissimorum , et nolite tangere ea quae ad eos pertinent , ne simul pereatis in peccatis eorum ▪ Propter quod plebs obsequens praeceptis Domini , et Deum metuens , a peccatore praeposito separare se debet , nec se ad sacrilegi Sacerdotis sacrificia miscere : quando ipsa ( defectu fidelis magistratus ) maxim● habeat potestatem vel eligendi dignos sacerdotes , vel recusandi indignos . FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A94735e-330 Sect. 1. Sect. 2. Sect. 3. Sect. 4. Sect. 5. Sect. 6. Sect. 7. Sir Fran. Bacons essayes of superstition . Sect. 8. Dr. Hall quo vadis or censure of travaile . Sect. 20. Sect. 9. Sect. 10. Sect. 11. Sect. 12. Archbishop . Laud Epist. Dedic. before the relat ▪ of his conference with Fisher Heylin coale from the Altar . Bishop White Answer to Burton of the Sab. p. 20. Reeve in his expos. of the Cat . Bishop Andrewes Sermon in locum : Widdowes Lawles kneeles puritan . Bishop Andrews Answer to the 18. ch of Cardinall Perrouns reply . Heylin Antid . Lincoln . Sect. 13. Sect. 14. Sect. 15. Libro de perp . eul . gubernat . c. 10.