Black Lives Do Matter COMMENTARY Black Lives Do Matter Bradley A. Boucher, PharmD,a Marie Chisholm-Burns, PharmD, MPH, MBAa,b a University of Tennessee Health Science Center (UTHSC) College of Pharmacy, Memphis, Tennessee b University of Tennessee Health Science Center College of Medicine, Memphis, Tennessee Submitted July 24, 2020; accepted September 17, 2020; published November 2020. Recent Black deaths at the hands of law enforcement officers has heightened awareness of racism within the United States. The consequences of this racism are not only differential policing practices toward Black people, but also inequities related to numerous other sectors, including housing, educa- tion, economics, and overt health care disparities between White and non-White Americans. Health care practitioners, including pharmacists, are extremely well positioned to be leaders in addressing long-standing inequities, thereby saving lives and improving access to and quality of care. The views of two senior faculty administrators are outlined: one, a White faculty member of privilege, the other, a Black CEO Dean. Despite having very different life experiences, they partner to foster unity and an antiracist culture within their institution and among their many stakeholders, with the ultimate goal of creating a culture of equity regardless of skin color. Keywords: Black Lives Matter, racism, antiracism The Black Lives Matter movement originated with a Facebook post by Alicia Garza following the death of Trayvon Martin and the subsequent acquittal of his killer, George Zimmerman.1 The words “Black lives matter,” which have permeated our lives in recent months, are not merely a slogan, but a declaration and affirmation that Black lives do matter. At a time when racial polarity is gripping our nation after the deaths of Ahmaud Arbury, Breonna Taylor, George Floyd, Rayshard Brooks, Daniel Prude, and countless other unnamed Black Americans, it is important for each of us to think about our personal perspective on racism in the United States. Only then can we begin to achieve the ideals of a nation for all citizens, not merely those of privilege. This commentary offers two unique perspectives on racism by senior administra- tors at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center (UTHSC) College of Pharmacy. One is offered by a White, male, clinical pharmacist and educator whose career spans over 40 years. The other is rendered by a Black, female, seasoned faculty member, former depart- ment head, researcher, executive director, and CEO (Chief Executive Officer) dean with more than 25 years of academic experience. The goal of sharing these per- spectives is to provide context for their partnership and efforts to achieve racial awareness, literacy, unity, and eventually equity at their academic institution. If indi- viduals can identify to some degree with the views of either one of these two professionals whose social expe- riences represent opposite ends of the spectrum, an en- vironment of inclusivity, equity, and diversity may be achieved among us all. Perspective of Bradley A. Boucher, PharmD I grew up in a predominantly White, blue-collar community on the northside of Minneapolis, where I attended public schools. During these years (1960s- 1970s), it was evident to me that Minneapolis did indeed have segregation. The inner-city neighborhoods to the north and south of downtown Minneapolis clearly had a higher degree of poverty than the neighborhood I resided in, as well as a very different demographic make-up, ie, one of predominantly Black residents. What I did not know until recently, however, was that racial residential covenants existed in many communities within Minne- apolis and its adjacent suburbs throughout much of the 20th century.2 These covenants de facto created racial boundaries, and this segregation, supported by the courts until the 1960s, continues to have a ripple effect even today. The overall intended effect was to enrich White homeowners while impoverishing Black communities. This, in turn, undoubtedly has affected the quality of ed- ucation and health care available to the citizens living in these communities. Nevertheless, I gave little thought to how advantaged I was by being able to attend the pre- dominantly White schools in my neighborhood vs the Corresponding Author: Marie Chisholm-Burns, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, 881 Madison Ave., Ste. 264, Memphis, TN 38103. Tel: 901-448-6036. Email: mchisho3@uthsc.edu American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2020; 84 (11) Article 8306. 1449 b y gu es t on A pr il 5 , 2 02 1. © 2 02 0 A m er ic an A ss oc ia ti on o f C ol le ge s of P ha rm ac y ht tp :/ /w w w .a jp e. or g D ow nl oa de d fr om mailto:mchisho3@uthsc.edu http://www.ajpe.org inner-city Minneapolis schools that the majority of Black students attended. I do not recall thinking about the privileges afforded by my “Whiteness” (also known as white privilege, which is defined as “the unearned, mostly unacknowledged social advantage White people have over other racial groups simply because they are white”).3 In contrast, I believed strongly in the myth of American meritocracy for all at that time, firmly believing it was only one’s work ethic and discipline that stood in the way of future success. Eventually my efforts facilitated com- pletion of my professional pharmacy training at the University of Minnesota College of Pharmacy. Thereaf- ter, I began my academic career at the UTHSC College of Pharmacy in 1984, and moved to Memphis, a city with a majority Black population. While Memphis demograph- ics were very different than those of my home city of Minneapolis, the ability of privileged White citizens to orchestrate neighborhood segregation was virtually in- distinguishable. 4 As in Minneapolis, the segregation of Black citizens into neighborhoods with subquality hous- ing had spawned poverty and diminished their access to quality health care and education.4 This tactic was and continues to be the norm across the United States. On an individual level, the question I now ask myself as a relatively successful senior faculty member is: did I achieve this success as a result of good fortune, hard work, the color of my skin, or a combination of these and other factors? In other words, would I have had the same suc- cess if I had been a Black man and not enjoyed a life of privilege? I certainly had more advantages because of my skin color. Furthermore, my three sons who are all health care professionals have also enjoyed White privilege. While I have never thought of myself as a “racist,” neither have I consciously acted to reverse the system of advan- tage based on race that exists in our society, past and present. Therefore, depending on one’s definition, I may have to accept the “racist” label along with all other White Americans who actively or passively enjoy lives of privilege. 1 While I have no guilt or shame regarding the privi- lege being White has provided me and my offspring, I have committed myself to becoming immersed into a heighted awareness of racism in the United States. The sentinel events leading to this commitment are the two Black deaths in or near my hometown of Minneapolis, a city I love. The first was the shooting of Philando Castile during a routine traffic stop in 2016. The other was the killing of George Floyd at the hands of a White police officer in May 2020. How could either of these deaths occur in the city that I grew up in? The answer is that structuralracism continuesto thrivethereand in citieslike it across America. These tragedies, and many others, are at the forefront of the Black Lives Matter movement. Furthermore, countless Black Americans lose their lives because of health care disparities tied to racism. Because these Black lives do matter, it is time that we as phar- macists serve as advocates and agents of change to eliminate health disparities and health care disparities and promotea culture ofequityfor Black Americans and other persons of color. Perspective of Marie Chisholm-Burns, PharmD, MPH, MBA I grew up in a city in New York where the high school graduation rate was less than 30%, my parents never earned more than $20,000 a year, and neither graduated from high school. My parents worked hard but also en- dured unimaginable prejudice in their efforts to make a better life for themselves and me. I vividly remember being with my father on repeated occasions when his gas station was set on fire and vandalized, with racial slurs scrawled on the walls. My parents instilled in me the will to focus on the business of survival and staying clear of any signs of trouble, including “good trouble” (which refers to acting as an agent for social change and justice, even if it causes disruption or defies authority). 5 Although my parents were the best parents anyone could ask for, their moralcharacter wasunimpeachable,and my focused approach to better my circumstances was immensely valuable and life changing, over the years I have learned that I must address inequities (defined simply as injustice or unfairness 6), which may challenge boundaries. With the disturbing events of this year, whenever I hear stories of racism, oppression, and brutality, I am haunted by a gas station on fire and the story of devastation and loss written on my father’s face. So today, as my dear colleague, Dr. Boucher, reflects on his life journey, I must in order to survive and move forward, reflect on the sunrise. The morning after Congressman John Lewis and Reverend C.T. Vivian died, I watched the newscast reflecting on their lives, tears streaming down my face as I realized two icons had left us. However, their legacy of “keeping your eye on the prize” 7 will continue, just as the sunrise continues. This year served as a watershed mo- ment in which the eyes of the public have been opened, not only to the existence of racial inequities, but also to the pervasiveness and depth of racism in the United States. The country is struggling with crises on multiple fronts: the COVID-19 pandemic and the strain and pain it has caused our health systems and personal lives; health disparities, particularly among Black and Hispanic Americans, tragically exposed by the onslaught of the pandemic; and underrecognized, uncorrected, and un- treated racial traumas experienced by Black Americans. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2020; 84 (11) Article 8306. 1450 b y gu es t on A pr il 5 , 2 02 1. © 2 02 0 A m er ic an A ss oc ia ti on o f C ol le ge s of P ha rm ac y ht tp :/ /w w w .a jp e. or g D ow nl oa de d fr om http://www.ajpe.org These racial traumas have existed since the birth of this country, accumulated over the decades, and include (but are not limited to): slavery, Jim Crow laws, the practice of “redlining,” mass incarceration, police bru- tality, food apartheid, educational disparities, economic gaps, microaggression, and additional traumas extending beyond the scope of this commentary, but experienced in mine and other African Americans’ daily reality. 8-12 Racism exists in many forms, and includes biologi- cal racism (the belief the races are biologically different and that White people are superior), ethnic racism (the belief that the origins of various ethnic groups are dif- ferent from one another and that one group has greater ability than other groups because of their ethnic origin), bodily racism (the belief that Black people are more physically dominant, violent, and threatening), and cul- tural racism (the belief that the Black culture is inferior to other cultures). 13 Furthermore, the term structural racism is commonly used today, breeding the formation of ill-formed stereotypes and racist behaviors toward an individual ascribed to a certain group as a whole and, in reciprocal, the group or the “system” is responsible for the behavior of the individual.13 Structural racism perpetu- ates discrimination with little energy from individuals as it is inherently built into daily operations across govern- ment agencies, institutions, health systems, educational systems, and other myriad structures, and driven by cul- ture, environment, practice, and policies of the system, organization, and/or program. Additionally, I also believe that structural racism or institutional racism masks the core of the problem and reduces racists’ ownership of creating, implementing, facilitating, and capitalizing on racist practices. It exonerates the individual of responsi- bility to change, preserves power, and even perpetuates further racist behaviors. Moreover, it relieves all indi- viduals, including racists, of the responsibility for cor- recting the inequity. No doubt structural racism exists and should be eradicated. As Ibram X. Kendi declares and as Dr. Boucher appreciates, if you are not practicing anti- racism (defined as the belief that all people are equal and fighting to deconstruct racism), you are racist. 13 Martin Luther King, Jr., suggested decades ago that the greateststumblingblock toward liberation ismoderates who prefer a negative peace that is free of any tension, including uncomfortable conversations, and absent of real actions leading to racial equity.14 Just as Dr. Boucher re- flectson hisinternal dilemma ofWhiteprivilege, I toohave reflected on my own “dueling consciousness”13 in order to both embrace my heritage and conform to the society that I want to be accepted in, and wonder if I could do more to fight inequities. As founder and director of the Medication Access Program, I help to increase medication access among those who have limited access to needed medica- tions, and the majority of my patients are persons of color. Is there more I can and should do in this area? Although I have some degree of privilege as a CEO Dean, my skin color continues to be one of the first things people notice about me, before they ever think about checking my cre- dentials (if they check my credentials at all). Even as a well-educated Black woman, aggressions occur, not as open attacks like my father’s burning gas station, but as the more common microaggressions often experienced by Black Americans today. I often wonder what I would have been if I had all the privileges of a White male. However, wasting energy on wondering “what if” is not a fruitful exercise.Instead,Ichoose tomove forwardusing whatever privilege I have in my circle of influence including my institution, UTHSC College of Pharmacy. Our minority student population has certainly grown during my tenure and is now greater than 40%. Dr. Boucher and I are clearly different, but for almost a decade we have worked together at UTHSC, along with many others, to help forge a path for our college to uphold a culture of diversity, and now we must commit to do more to resolve inequities. Recently, I published a commentary in the American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy where I framed racism as a disease not dissimilar to COVID-19. 15 To effectively treat a disease in a patient, the first step is to diagnose orrecognizethe problem.Likewise, thefirst step to changing the culture within a society regarding racism is to acknowledge the problem, regardless of one’s life journey and where one falls presently on the continuum from racist to antiracist. Thereafter, one needs to be in- tentional and committed to attitudinal change on an in- dividual level. This is based on the assumption that one can grow toward development of antiracist behaviors, which in turn can lead to institutional initiatives focused on promoting inclusiveness, diversity, and equity.13 What treatment (medicine, if you will) can we start working on today to treat racism? A few proposed strat- egies include: Identify the problem and call it out. What symptoms are being displayed? What behaviors are adversa- rial? What behaviors are producing the inequities and promoting racism? Have the uncomfortable conversations that lead to reflection and a treatment plan. We must approach treatment from multiple perspectives or symptoms, including treatment plans to eliminate micro- aggressions and disparities/inequities concerning health care, education, socioeconomic, employ- ment, law enforcement, and housing, to name a few. Get to know people who are not like you. Push yourself out of your comfort zone. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2020; 84 (11) Article 8306. 1451 b y gu es t on A pr il 5 , 2 02 1. © 2 02 0 A m er ic an A ss oc ia ti on o f C ol le ge s of P ha rm ac y ht tp :/ /w w w .a jp e. or g D ow nl oa de d fr om http://www.ajpe.org Extend radical empathy, defined as “actively striving to better understand and share the feelings of others. To fundamentally change our perspectives from judgmental to accepting, in an attempt to more au- thentically connect with ourselves and others.”16 Learn as much as possible about racial inequities and how to be an antiracist. In particular, White and non- White Americans must be intentional about being allies and advocates related to achieving equity and justice within communities across the United States. Also, we must never take for granted the importance of leadership because leadership does matter. Treat people as you want to be treated, and once learning more about the individual, treat them as they want to be treated (which may be different than how you want to be treated).15 Strive toward reducing disparities within your spheres of influence, including calling attention to policies, practices, and systems facilitating inequities. Promote resilience as we strive toward equity. This is a marathon, and engagement is long-term. One major initiative at our college has been the recent creation of the Equity, Inclusivity, and Diversity Advisory Board (comprised of faculty, staff, and student pharmacists) to swiftly identify goals and action items to promote an em- pathetic, attentive, and healing environment. Some early successes are several curricular changes related to health care disparities, diversity, and inclusion; virtual social gathering and “listening sessions” with approximately 150 and 125 college participants in the first two offerings, respectively; and requiring all faculty and staff members to complete for- mal diversity training programs. While the majority of the action items of the Board are inwardly focused on the envi- ronment at the UTHSC College of Pharmacy and our many stakeholders, such as our student pharmacists, faculty, staff, and alumni, the overarching goal is to affect the patients we serve and society as a whole. In doing so, we support that “Black lives do matter” in addition to upholding the well- beingofallpersonslessprivileged.Thesunhasrisen,anditis a new day with a better tomorrow ahead. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS TheauthorswouldliketothankDrs.ChristinaSpiveyand Jenny Johnson for their assistance in manuscript preparation. Marie Chisholm-Burns serves on the board of direc- tors for the Accreditation Council of Pharmacy Education (ACPE); however, this manuscript does not represent ACPE or the boards’ opinions or views. REFERENCES 1. Tatum BD. Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria? And Other Conversations About Race. New York, NY: Basic Books; 2017. 2. Twin Cities PBS [TPT Originals]. Jim Crow of the North – full- length documentary [Video]. https://www.youtube.com/watch? v5XWQfDbbQv9E. Published February 25, 2019. Accessed November 3, 2020. 3. Dictionary.com. White privilege. https://www.dictionary.com/e/ pop-culture/white-privilege/. Accessed November 3, 2020. 4. Lauterbach P. Memphis burning. Places Journal. 2016. doi: 10.22269/160307. https://placesjournal.org/article/memphis- burning/. Accessed November 3, 2020. 5. Ray R. Five things John Lewis taught us about getting in “good trouble.” Brookings Institute; July 23, 2020. https:// www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2020/07/23/five-things-john- lewis-taught-us-about-getting-in-good-trouble/. Accessed November 3, 2020. 6. Merriam Webster. Inequity. https://www.merriam-webster.com/ dictionary/inequity. Accessed November 3, 2020. 7. @repjohnlewis. Never give up, never give in, never give out. Keep the faith, and keep your eyes on the prize. Together, we can redeem the soul of America. #goodtrouble. https://twitter.com/repjohnlewis/ status/1017417974687227906. Posted July 12, 2018. Accessed November 3, 2020. 8. Kendi IA. Stamped from the Beginning. New York: Bold Type Books; 2016. 9. Alexander M. The New Jim Crow. New York: New Press 2012. 10. Rothstein R. The Color of Law. New York: W.W. Norton & Company; 2017. 11. Guernica A. Food apartheid: the root of the problem with America’s groceries. The Guardian. May 15, 2018. https:// www.theguardian.com/society/2018/may/15/food-apartheid-food- deserts-racism-inequality-america-karen-washington-interview. Accessed November 3, 2020. 12. Sue DW. Racial microaggressions in everyday life. Psychology Today. 2010. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/ microaggressions-in-everyday-life/201010/racial-microaggressions- in-everyday-life. Accessed November 3, 2020. 13. Kendi IX. How to Be an Antiracist. New York, NY: One World; 2019. 14. King Jr ML. Letter from Birmingham Jail. London: Penguin Books; 2018. 15. Chisholm-Burns MA. The disease of racism. Am J Health Syst Pharm. 2020;77(18):1537-1538. doi:10.1093/ajhp/zxaa254. 16. Schott J. What is radical empathy? Camp Stomping Ground Blog. https://campstompingground.org/blog/2017/2/16/what-is- radical-empathy. Published February 16, 2017. Accessed November 3, 2020. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2020; 84 (11) Article 8306. 1452 b y gu es t on A pr il 5 , 2 02 1. © 2 02 0 A m er ic an A ss oc ia ti on o f C ol le ge s of P ha rm ac y ht tp :/ /w w w .a jp e. or g D ow nl oa de d fr om https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWQfDbbQv9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWQfDbbQv9E https://www.dictionary.com/e/pop-culture/white-privilege/ https://www.dictionary.com/e/pop-culture/white-privilege/ https://placesjournal.org/article/memphis-burning/ https://placesjournal.org/article/memphis-burning/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2020/07/23/five-things-john-lewis-taught-us-about-getting-in-good-trouble/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2020/07/23/five-things-john-lewis-taught-us-about-getting-in-good-trouble/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2020/07/23/five-things-john-lewis-taught-us-about-getting-in-good-trouble/ https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/inequity https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/inequity https://twitter.com/repjohnlewis/status/1017417974687227906 https://twitter.com/repjohnlewis/status/1017417974687227906 https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/may/15/food-apartheid-food-deserts-racism-inequality-america-karen-washington-interview https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/may/15/food-apartheid-food-deserts-racism-inequality-america-karen-washington-interview https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/may/15/food-apartheid-food-deserts-racism-inequality-america-karen-washington-interview https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/microaggressions-in-everyday-life/201010/racial-microaggressions-in-everyday-life https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/microaggressions-in-everyday-life/201010/racial-microaggressions-in-everyday-life https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/microaggressions-in-everyday-life/201010/racial-microaggressions-in-everyday-life https://campstompingground.org/blog/2017/2/16/what-is-radical-empathy https://campstompingground.org/blog/2017/2/16/what-is-radical-empathy http://www.ajpe.org