id sid tid token lemma pos 5684 1 1 1780 1780 CD 5684 1 2 THE the DT 5684 1 3 METAPHYSICAL METAPHYSICAL NNP 5684 1 4 ELEMENTS element NNS 5684 1 5 OF of IN 5684 1 6 ETHICS ethic NNS 5684 1 7 by by IN 5684 1 8 Immanuel Immanuel NNP 5684 1 9 Kant Kant NNP 5684 1 10 translated translate VBN 5684 1 11 by by IN 5684 1 12 Thomas Thomas NNP 5684 1 13 Kingsmill Kingsmill NNP 5684 1 14 Abbott Abbott NNP 5684 1 15 PREFACE PREFACE NNP 5684 1 16 If if IN 5684 1 17 there there EX 5684 1 18 exists exist VBZ 5684 1 19 on on IN 5684 1 20 any any DT 5684 1 21 subject subject NN 5684 1 22 a a DT 5684 1 23 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 1 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 1 25 that that RB 5684 1 26 is is RB 5684 1 27 , , , 5684 1 28 a a DT 5684 1 29 system system NN 5684 1 30 of of IN 5684 1 31 rational rational JJ 5684 1 32 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 1 33 based base VBN 5684 1 34 on on IN 5684 1 35 concepts concept NNS 5684 1 36 ) ) -RRB- 5684 1 37 , , , 5684 1 38 then then RB 5684 1 39 there there EX 5684 1 40 must must MD 5684 1 41 also also RB 5684 1 42 be be VB 5684 1 43 for for IN 5684 1 44 this this DT 5684 1 45 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 1 46 a a DT 5684 1 47 system system NN 5684 1 48 of of IN 5684 1 49 pure pure JJ 5684 1 50 rational rational JJ 5684 1 51 concepts concept NNS 5684 1 52 , , , 5684 1 53 independent independent JJ 5684 1 54 of of IN 5684 1 55 any any DT 5684 1 56 condition condition NN 5684 1 57 of of IN 5684 1 58 intuition intuition NN 5684 1 59 , , , 5684 1 60 in in IN 5684 1 61 other other JJ 5684 1 62 words word NNS 5684 1 63 , , , 5684 1 64 a a DT 5684 1 65 metaphysic metaphysic NN 5684 1 66 . . . 5684 2 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 2 2 may may MD 5684 2 3 be be VB 5684 2 4 asked ask VBN 5684 2 5 whether whether IN 5684 2 6 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 5684 2 7 elements element NNS 5684 2 8 are be VBP 5684 2 9 required require VBN 5684 2 10 also also RB 5684 2 11 for for IN 5684 2 12 every every DT 5684 2 13 practical practical JJ 5684 2 14 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 2 15 , , , 5684 2 16 which which WDT 5684 2 17 is be VBZ 5684 2 18 the the DT 5684 2 19 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 2 20 of of IN 5684 2 21 duties duty NNS 5684 2 22 , , , 5684 2 23 and and CC 5684 2 24 therefore therefore RB 5684 2 25 also also RB 5684 2 26 for for IN 5684 2 27 Ethics ethic NNS 5684 2 28 , , , 5684 2 29 in in IN 5684 2 30 order order NN 5684 2 31 to to TO 5684 2 32 be be VB 5684 2 33 able able JJ 5684 2 34 to to TO 5684 2 35 present present VB 5684 2 36 it -PRON- PRP 5684 2 37 as as IN 5684 2 38 a a DT 5684 2 39 true true JJ 5684 2 40 science science NN 5684 2 41 ( ( -LRB- 5684 2 42 systematically systematically RB 5684 2 43 ) ) -RRB- 5684 2 44 , , , 5684 2 45 not not RB 5684 2 46 merely merely RB 5684 2 47 as as IN 5684 2 48 an an DT 5684 2 49 aggregate aggregate NN 5684 2 50 of of IN 5684 2 51 separate separate JJ 5684 2 52 doctrines doctrine NNS 5684 2 53 ( ( -LRB- 5684 2 54 fragmentarily fragmentarily RB 5684 2 55 ) ) -RRB- 5684 2 56 . . . 5684 3 1 As as IN 5684 3 2 regards regard VBZ 5684 3 3 pure pure JJ 5684 3 4 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 3 5 , , , 5684 3 6 no no DT 5684 3 7 one one NN 5684 3 8 will will MD 5684 3 9 question question VB 5684 3 10 this this DT 5684 3 11 requirement requirement NN 5684 3 12 ; ; : 5684 3 13 for for IN 5684 3 14 it -PRON- PRP 5684 3 15 concerns concern VBZ 5684 3 16 only only RB 5684 3 17 what what WP 5684 3 18 is be VBZ 5684 3 19 formal formal JJ 5684 3 20 in in IN 5684 3 21 the the DT 5684 3 22 elective elective NN 5684 3 23 will will NN 5684 3 24 , , , 5684 3 25 which which WDT 5684 3 26 has have VBZ 5684 3 27 to to TO 5684 3 28 be be VB 5684 3 29 limited limit VBN 5684 3 30 in in IN 5684 3 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 3 32 external external JJ 5684 3 33 relations relation NNS 5684 3 34 according accord VBG 5684 3 35 to to IN 5684 3 36 laws law NNS 5684 3 37 of of IN 5684 3 38 freedom freedom NN 5684 3 39 ; ; : 5684 3 40 without without IN 5684 3 41 regarding regard VBG 5684 3 42 any any DT 5684 3 43 end end NN 5684 3 44 which which WDT 5684 3 45 is be VBZ 5684 3 46 the the DT 5684 3 47 matter matter NN 5684 3 48 of of IN 5684 3 49 this this DT 5684 3 50 will will NN 5684 3 51 . . . 5684 4 1 Here here RB 5684 4 2 , , , 5684 4 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 4 4 , , , 5684 4 5 deontology deontology NN 5684 4 6 is be VBZ 5684 4 7 a a DT 5684 4 8 mere mere JJ 5684 4 9 scientific scientific JJ 5684 4 10 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 4 11 ( ( -LRB- 5684 4 12 doctrina doctrina NNP 5684 4 13 scientiae scientiae NNP 5684 4 14 ) ) -RRB- 5684 4 15 . . . 5684 5 1 * * NFP 5684 5 2 * * NFP 5684 5 3 One one NN 5684 5 4 who who WP 5684 5 5 is be VBZ 5684 5 6 acquainted acquaint VBN 5684 5 7 with with IN 5684 5 8 practical practical JJ 5684 5 9 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 5 10 is be VBZ 5684 5 11 not not RB 5684 5 12 , , , 5684 5 13 therefore therefore RB 5684 5 14 , , , 5684 5 15 a a DT 5684 5 16 practical practical JJ 5684 5 17 philosopher philosopher NN 5684 5 18 . . . 5684 6 1 The the DT 5684 6 2 latter latter JJ 5684 6 3 is be VBZ 5684 6 4 he -PRON- PRP 5684 6 5 who who WP 5684 6 6 makes make VBZ 5684 6 7 the the DT 5684 6 8 rational rational JJ 5684 6 9 end end NN 5684 6 10 the the DT 5684 6 11 principle principle NN 5684 6 12 of of IN 5684 6 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 6 14 actions action NNS 5684 6 15 , , , 5684 6 16 while while IN 5684 6 17 at at IN 5684 6 18 the the DT 5684 6 19 same same JJ 5684 6 20 time time NN 5684 6 21 he -PRON- PRP 5684 6 22 joins join VBZ 5684 6 23 with with IN 5684 6 24 this this DT 5684 6 25 the the DT 5684 6 26 necessary necessary JJ 5684 6 27 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 6 28 which which WDT 5684 6 29 , , , 5684 6 30 as as IN 5684 6 31 it -PRON- PRP 5684 6 32 aims aim VBZ 5684 6 33 at at IN 5684 6 34 action action NN 5684 6 35 , , , 5684 6 36 must must MD 5684 6 37 not not RB 5684 6 38 be be VB 5684 6 39 spun spin VBN 5684 6 40 out out RP 5684 6 41 into into IN 5684 6 42 the the DT 5684 6 43 most most JJS 5684 6 44 subtile subtile NN 5684 6 45 threads thread NNS 5684 6 46 of of IN 5684 6 47 metaphysic metaphysic NN 5684 6 48 , , , 5684 6 49 unless unless IN 5684 6 50 a a DT 5684 6 51 legal legal JJ 5684 6 52 duty duty NN 5684 6 53 is be VBZ 5684 6 54 in in IN 5684 6 55 question question NN 5684 6 56 ; ; : 5684 6 57 in in IN 5684 6 58 which which WDT 5684 6 59 case case NN 5684 6 60 meum meum NN 5684 6 61 and and CC 5684 6 62 tuum tuum NN 5684 6 63 must must MD 5684 6 64 be be VB 5684 6 65 accurately accurately RB 5684 6 66 determined determine VBN 5684 6 67 in in IN 5684 6 68 the the DT 5684 6 69 balance balance NN 5684 6 70 of of IN 5684 6 71 justice justice NN 5684 6 72 , , , 5684 6 73 on on IN 5684 6 74 the the DT 5684 6 75 principle principle NN 5684 6 76 of of IN 5684 6 77 equality equality NN 5684 6 78 of of IN 5684 6 79 action action NN 5684 6 80 and and CC 5684 6 81 action action NN 5684 6 82 , , , 5684 6 83 which which WDT 5684 6 84 requires require VBZ 5684 6 85 something something NN 5684 6 86 like like IN 5684 6 87 mathematical mathematical JJ 5684 6 88 proportion proportion NN 5684 6 89 , , , 5684 6 90 but but CC 5684 6 91 not not RB 5684 6 92 in in IN 5684 6 93 the the DT 5684 6 94 case case NN 5684 6 95 of of IN 5684 6 96 a a DT 5684 6 97 mere mere JJ 5684 6 98 ethical ethical JJ 5684 6 99 duty duty NN 5684 6 100 . . . 5684 7 1 For for IN 5684 7 2 in in IN 5684 7 3 this this DT 5684 7 4 case case NN 5684 7 5 the the DT 5684 7 6 question question NN 5684 7 7 is be VBZ 5684 7 8 not not RB 5684 7 9 only only RB 5684 7 10 to to TO 5684 7 11 know know VB 5684 7 12 what what WP 5684 7 13 it -PRON- PRP 5684 7 14 is be VBZ 5684 7 15 a a DT 5684 7 16 duty duty NN 5684 7 17 to to TO 5684 7 18 do do VB 5684 7 19 ( ( -LRB- 5684 7 20 a a DT 5684 7 21 thing thing NN 5684 7 22 which which WDT 5684 7 23 on on IN 5684 7 24 account account NN 5684 7 25 of of IN 5684 7 26 the the DT 5684 7 27 ends end NNS 5684 7 28 that that IN 5684 7 29 all all DT 5684 7 30 men man NNS 5684 7 31 naturally naturally RB 5684 7 32 have have VBP 5684 7 33 can can MD 5684 7 34 be be VB 5684 7 35 easily easily RB 5684 7 36 decided decide VBN 5684 7 37 ) ) -RRB- 5684 7 38 , , , 5684 7 39 but but CC 5684 7 40 the the DT 5684 7 41 chief chief JJ 5684 7 42 point point NN 5684 7 43 is be VBZ 5684 7 44 the the DT 5684 7 45 inner inner JJ 5684 7 46 principle principle NN 5684 7 47 of of IN 5684 7 48 the the DT 5684 7 49 will will MD 5684 7 50 namely namely RB 5684 7 51 that that IN 5684 7 52 the the DT 5684 7 53 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 7 54 of of IN 5684 7 55 this this DT 5684 7 56 duty duty NN 5684 7 57 be be VB 5684 7 58 also also RB 5684 7 59 the the DT 5684 7 60 spring spring NN 5684 7 61 of of IN 5684 7 62 action action NN 5684 7 63 , , , 5684 7 64 in in IN 5684 7 65 order order NN 5684 7 66 that that IN 5684 7 67 we -PRON- PRP 5684 7 68 may may MD 5684 7 69 be be VB 5684 7 70 able able JJ 5684 7 71 to to TO 5684 7 72 say say VB 5684 7 73 of of IN 5684 7 74 the the DT 5684 7 75 man man NN 5684 7 76 who who WP 5684 7 77 joins join VBZ 5684 7 78 to to IN 5684 7 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 7 80 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 7 81 this this DT 5684 7 82 principle principle NN 5684 7 83 of of IN 5684 7 84 wisdom wisdom NN 5684 7 85 that that WDT 5684 7 86 he -PRON- PRP 5684 7 87 is be VBZ 5684 7 88 a a DT 5684 7 89 practical practical JJ 5684 7 90 philosopher philosopher NN 5684 7 91 . . . 5684 8 1 Now now RB 5684 8 2 in in IN 5684 8 3 this this DT 5684 8 4 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 8 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 8 6 of of IN 5684 8 7 ethics ethic NNS 5684 8 8 ) ) -RRB- 5684 8 9 it -PRON- PRP 5684 8 10 seems seem VBZ 5684 8 11 contrary contrary JJ 5684 8 12 to to IN 5684 8 13 the the DT 5684 8 14 idea idea NN 5684 8 15 of of IN 5684 8 16 it -PRON- PRP 5684 8 17 that that IN 5684 8 18 we -PRON- PRP 5684 8 19 should should MD 5684 8 20 go go VB 5684 8 21 back back RB 5684 8 22 to to IN 5684 8 23 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 5684 8 24 elements element NNS 5684 8 25 in in IN 5684 8 26 order order NN 5684 8 27 to to TO 5684 8 28 make make VB 5684 8 29 the the DT 5684 8 30 notion notion NN 5684 8 31 of of IN 5684 8 32 duty duty NN 5684 8 33 purified purify VBN 5684 8 34 from from IN 5684 8 35 everything everything NN 5684 8 36 empirical empirical JJ 5684 8 37 ( ( -LRB- 5684 8 38 from from IN 5684 8 39 every every DT 5684 8 40 feeling feeling NN 5684 8 41 ) ) -RRB- 5684 8 42 a a DT 5684 8 43 motive motive NN 5684 8 44 of of IN 5684 8 45 action action NN 5684 8 46 . . . 5684 9 1 For for IN 5684 9 2 what what WP 5684 9 3 sort sort NN 5684 9 4 of of IN 5684 9 5 notion notion NN 5684 9 6 can can MD 5684 9 7 we -PRON- PRP 5684 9 8 form form VB 5684 9 9 of of IN 5684 9 10 the the DT 5684 9 11 mighty mighty JJ 5684 9 12 power power NN 5684 9 13 and and CC 5684 9 14 herculean herculean NN 5684 9 15 strength strength NN 5684 9 16 which which WDT 5684 9 17 would would MD 5684 9 18 be be VB 5684 9 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 5684 9 20 to to TO 5684 9 21 overcome overcome VB 5684 9 22 the the DT 5684 9 23 vice vice NN 5684 9 24 - - HYPH 5684 9 25 breeding breed VBG 5684 9 26 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 9 27 , , , 5684 9 28 if if IN 5684 9 29 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 9 30 is be VBZ 5684 9 31 to to TO 5684 9 32 borrow borrow VB 5684 9 33 her -PRON- PRP$ 5684 9 34 " " `` 5684 9 35 arms arm NNS 5684 9 36 from from IN 5684 9 37 the the DT 5684 9 38 armoury armoury NN 5684 9 39 of of IN 5684 9 40 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 5684 9 41 , , , 5684 9 42 " " '' 5684 9 43 which which WDT 5684 9 44 is be VBZ 5684 9 45 a a DT 5684 9 46 matter matter NN 5684 9 47 of of IN 5684 9 48 speculation speculation NN 5684 9 49 that that IN 5684 9 50 only only RB 5684 9 51 few few JJ 5684 9 52 men man NNS 5684 9 53 can can MD 5684 9 54 handle handle VB 5684 9 55 ? ? . 5684 10 1 Hence hence RB 5684 10 2 all all DT 5684 10 3 ethical ethical JJ 5684 10 4 teaching teaching NN 5684 10 5 in in IN 5684 10 6 lecture lecture NN 5684 10 7 rooms room NNS 5684 10 8 , , , 5684 10 9 pulpits pulpit NNS 5684 10 10 , , , 5684 10 11 and and CC 5684 10 12 popular popular JJ 5684 10 13 books book NNS 5684 10 14 , , , 5684 10 15 when when WRB 5684 10 16 it -PRON- PRP 5684 10 17 is be VBZ 5684 10 18 decked deck VBN 5684 10 19 out out RP 5684 10 20 with with IN 5684 10 21 fragments fragment NNS 5684 10 22 of of IN 5684 10 23 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 5684 10 24 , , , 5684 10 25 becomes become VBZ 5684 10 26 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 5684 10 27 . . . 5684 11 1 But but CC 5684 11 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 11 3 is be VBZ 5684 11 4 not not RB 5684 11 5 , , , 5684 11 6 therefore therefore RB 5684 11 7 , , , 5684 11 8 useless useless JJ 5684 11 9 , , , 5684 11 10 much much RB 5684 11 11 less less RBR 5684 11 12 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 5684 11 13 , , , 5684 11 14 to to TO 5684 11 15 trace trace VB 5684 11 16 in in IN 5684 11 17 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 5684 11 18 the the DT 5684 11 19 first first JJ 5684 11 20 principles principle NNS 5684 11 21 of of IN 5684 11 22 ethics ethic NNS 5684 11 23 ; ; : 5684 11 24 for for IN 5684 11 25 it -PRON- PRP 5684 11 26 is be VBZ 5684 11 27 only only RB 5684 11 28 as as IN 5684 11 29 a a DT 5684 11 30 philosopher philosopher NN 5684 11 31 that that IN 5684 11 32 anyone anyone NN 5684 11 33 can can MD 5684 11 34 reach reach VB 5684 11 35 the the DT 5684 11 36 first first JJ 5684 11 37 principles principle NNS 5684 11 38 of of IN 5684 11 39 this this DT 5684 11 40 conception conception NN 5684 11 41 of of IN 5684 11 42 duty duty NN 5684 11 43 , , , 5684 11 44 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 11 45 we -PRON- PRP 5684 11 46 could could MD 5684 11 47 not not RB 5684 11 48 look look VB 5684 11 49 for for IN 5684 11 50 either either DT 5684 11 51 certainty certainty NN 5684 11 52 or or CC 5684 11 53 purity purity NN 5684 11 54 in in IN 5684 11 55 the the DT 5684 11 56 ethical ethical JJ 5684 11 57 teaching teaching NN 5684 11 58 . . . 5684 12 1 To to TO 5684 12 2 rely rely VB 5684 12 3 for for IN 5684 12 4 this this DT 5684 12 5 reason reason NN 5684 12 6 on on IN 5684 12 7 a a DT 5684 12 8 certain certain JJ 5684 12 9 feeling feeling NN 5684 12 10 which which WDT 5684 12 11 , , , 5684 12 12 on on IN 5684 12 13 account account NN 5684 12 14 of of IN 5684 12 15 the the DT 5684 12 16 effect effect NN 5684 12 17 expected expect VBN 5684 12 18 from from IN 5684 12 19 it -PRON- PRP 5684 12 20 , , , 5684 12 21 is be VBZ 5684 12 22 called call VBN 5684 12 23 moral moral JJ 5684 12 24 , , , 5684 12 25 may may MD 5684 12 26 , , , 5684 12 27 perhaps perhaps RB 5684 12 28 , , , 5684 12 29 even even RB 5684 12 30 satisfy satisfy VB 5684 12 31 the the DT 5684 12 32 popular popular JJ 5684 12 33 teacher teacher NN 5684 12 34 , , , 5684 12 35 provided provide VBD 5684 12 36 he -PRON- PRP 5684 12 37 desires desire VBZ 5684 12 38 as as IN 5684 12 39 the the DT 5684 12 40 criterion criterion NN 5684 12 41 of of IN 5684 12 42 a a DT 5684 12 43 moral moral JJ 5684 12 44 duty duty NN 5684 12 45 to to TO 5684 12 46 consider consider VB 5684 12 47 the the DT 5684 12 48 problem problem NN 5684 12 49 : : : 5684 12 50 " " `` 5684 12 51 If if IN 5684 12 52 everyone everyone NN 5684 12 53 in in IN 5684 12 54 every every DT 5684 12 55 case case NN 5684 12 56 made make VBD 5684 12 57 your -PRON- PRP$ 5684 12 58 maxim maxim NN 5684 12 59 the the DT 5684 12 60 universal universal JJ 5684 12 61 law law NN 5684 12 62 , , , 5684 12 63 how how WRB 5684 12 64 could could MD 5684 12 65 this this DT 5684 12 66 law law NN 5684 12 67 be be VB 5684 12 68 consistent consistent JJ 5684 12 69 with with IN 5684 12 70 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 12 71 ? ? . 5684 12 72 " " '' 5684 13 1 But but CC 5684 13 2 if if IN 5684 13 3 it -PRON- PRP 5684 13 4 were be VBD 5684 13 5 merely merely RB 5684 13 6 feeling feel VBG 5684 13 7 that that WDT 5684 13 8 made make VBD 5684 13 9 it -PRON- PRP 5684 13 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 13 11 duty duty NN 5684 13 12 to to TO 5684 13 13 take take VB 5684 13 14 this this DT 5684 13 15 principle principle NN 5684 13 16 as as IN 5684 13 17 a a DT 5684 13 18 criterion criterion NN 5684 13 19 , , , 5684 13 20 then then RB 5684 13 21 this this DT 5684 13 22 would would MD 5684 13 23 not not RB 5684 13 24 be be VB 5684 13 25 dictated dictate VBN 5684 13 26 by by IN 5684 13 27 reason reason NN 5684 13 28 , , , 5684 13 29 but but CC 5684 13 30 only only RB 5684 13 31 adopted adopt VBN 5684 13 32 instinctively instinctively RB 5684 13 33 and and CC 5684 13 34 therefore therefore RB 5684 13 35 blindly blindly RB 5684 13 36 . . . 5684 14 1 { { -LRB- 5684 14 2 PREFACE PREFACE NNP 5684 14 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 14 4 5 5 CD 5684 14 5 } } -RRB- 5684 14 6 But but CC 5684 14 7 in in IN 5684 14 8 fact fact NN 5684 14 9 , , , 5684 14 10 whatever whatever WDT 5684 14 11 men man NNS 5684 14 12 imagine imagine VBP 5684 14 13 , , , 5684 14 14 no no DT 5684 14 15 moral moral JJ 5684 14 16 principle principle NN 5684 14 17 is be VBZ 5684 14 18 based base VBN 5684 14 19 on on IN 5684 14 20 any any DT 5684 14 21 feeling feeling NN 5684 14 22 , , , 5684 14 23 but but CC 5684 14 24 such such PDT 5684 14 25 a a DT 5684 14 26 principle principle NN 5684 14 27 is be VBZ 5684 14 28 really really RB 5684 14 29 nothing nothing NN 5684 14 30 else else RB 5684 14 31 than than IN 5684 14 32 an an DT 5684 14 33 obscurely obscurely RB 5684 14 34 conceived conceive VBN 5684 14 35 metaphysic metaphysic NN 5684 14 36 which which WDT 5684 14 37 inheres inhere VBZ 5684 14 38 in in IN 5684 14 39 every every DT 5684 14 40 man man NN 5684 14 41 's 's POS 5684 14 42 reasoning reasoning NN 5684 14 43 faculty faculty NN 5684 14 44 ; ; : 5684 14 45 as as IN 5684 14 46 the the DT 5684 14 47 teacher teacher NN 5684 14 48 will will MD 5684 14 49 easily easily RB 5684 14 50 find find VB 5684 14 51 who who WP 5684 14 52 tries try VBZ 5684 14 53 to to TO 5684 14 54 catechize catechize VB 5684 14 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 14 56 pupils pupil NNS 5684 14 57 in in IN 5684 14 58 the the DT 5684 14 59 Socratic socratic JJ 5684 14 60 method method NN 5684 14 61 about about IN 5684 14 62 the the DT 5684 14 63 imperative imperative NN 5684 14 64 of of IN 5684 14 65 duty duty NN 5684 14 66 and and CC 5684 14 67 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 14 68 application application NN 5684 14 69 to to IN 5684 14 70 the the DT 5684 14 71 moral moral JJ 5684 14 72 judgement judgement NN 5684 14 73 of of IN 5684 14 74 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 14 75 actions action NNS 5684 14 76 . . . 5684 15 1 The the DT 5684 15 2 mode mode NN 5684 15 3 of of IN 5684 15 4 stating state VBG 5684 15 5 it -PRON- PRP 5684 15 6 need nee MD 5684 15 7 not not RB 5684 15 8 be be VB 5684 15 9 always always RB 5684 15 10 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 5684 15 11 , , , 5684 15 12 and and CC 5684 15 13 the the DT 5684 15 14 language language NN 5684 15 15 need need VBP 5684 15 16 not not RB 5684 15 17 necessarily necessarily RB 5684 15 18 be be VB 5684 15 19 scholastic scholastic JJ 5684 15 20 , , , 5684 15 21 unless unless IN 5684 15 22 the the DT 5684 15 23 pupil pupil NN 5684 15 24 is be VBZ 5684 15 25 to to TO 5684 15 26 be be VB 5684 15 27 trained train VBN 5684 15 28 to to TO 5684 15 29 be be VB 5684 15 30 a a DT 5684 15 31 philosopher philosopher NN 5684 15 32 . . . 5684 16 1 But but CC 5684 16 2 the the DT 5684 16 3 thought thought NN 5684 16 4 must must MD 5684 16 5 go go VB 5684 16 6 back back RB 5684 16 7 to to IN 5684 16 8 the the DT 5684 16 9 elements element NNS 5684 16 10 of of IN 5684 16 11 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 5684 16 12 , , , 5684 16 13 without without IN 5684 16 14 which which WDT 5684 16 15 we -PRON- PRP 5684 16 16 can can MD 5684 16 17 not not RB 5684 16 18 expect expect VB 5684 16 19 any any DT 5684 16 20 certainty certainty NN 5684 16 21 or or CC 5684 16 22 purity purity NN 5684 16 23 , , , 5684 16 24 or or CC 5684 16 25 even even RB 5684 16 26 motive motive JJ 5684 16 27 power power NN 5684 16 28 in in IN 5684 16 29 ethics ethic NNS 5684 16 30 . . . 5684 17 1 If if IN 5684 17 2 we -PRON- PRP 5684 17 3 deviate deviate VBP 5684 17 4 from from IN 5684 17 5 this this DT 5684 17 6 principle principle NN 5684 17 7 and and CC 5684 17 8 begin begin VB 5684 17 9 from from IN 5684 17 10 pathological pathological JJ 5684 17 11 , , , 5684 17 12 or or CC 5684 17 13 purely purely RB 5684 17 14 sensitive sensitive JJ 5684 17 15 , , , 5684 17 16 or or CC 5684 17 17 even even RB 5684 17 18 moral moral JJ 5684 17 19 feeling feeling NN 5684 17 20 ( ( -LRB- 5684 17 21 from from IN 5684 17 22 what what WP 5684 17 23 is be VBZ 5684 17 24 subjectively subjectively RB 5684 17 25 practical practical JJ 5684 17 26 instead instead RB 5684 17 27 of of IN 5684 17 28 what what WP 5684 17 29 is be VBZ 5684 17 30 objective objective JJ 5684 17 31 ) ) -RRB- 5684 17 32 , , , 5684 17 33 that that RB 5684 17 34 is is RB 5684 17 35 , , , 5684 17 36 from from IN 5684 17 37 the the DT 5684 17 38 matter matter NN 5684 17 39 of of IN 5684 17 40 the the DT 5684 17 41 will will NN 5684 17 42 , , , 5684 17 43 the the DT 5684 17 44 end end NN 5684 17 45 , , , 5684 17 46 not not RB 5684 17 47 from from IN 5684 17 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 17 49 form form NN 5684 17 50 that that WDT 5684 17 51 is be VBZ 5684 17 52 the the DT 5684 17 53 law law NN 5684 17 54 , , , 5684 17 55 in in IN 5684 17 56 order order NN 5684 17 57 from from IN 5684 17 58 thence thence NN 5684 17 59 to to TO 5684 17 60 determine determine VB 5684 17 61 duties duty NNS 5684 17 62 ; ; : 5684 17 63 then then RB 5684 17 64 , , , 5684 17 65 certainly certainly RB 5684 17 66 , , , 5684 17 67 there there EX 5684 17 68 are be VBP 5684 17 69 no no DT 5684 17 70 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 5684 17 71 elements element NNS 5684 17 72 of of IN 5684 17 73 ethics ethic NNS 5684 17 74 , , , 5684 17 75 for for IN 5684 17 76 feeling feeling NN 5684 17 77 by by IN 5684 17 78 whatever whatever WDT 5684 17 79 it -PRON- PRP 5684 17 80 may may MD 5684 17 81 be be VB 5684 17 82 excited excited JJ 5684 17 83 is be VBZ 5684 17 84 always always RB 5684 17 85 physical physical JJ 5684 17 86 . . . 5684 18 1 But but CC 5684 18 2 then then RB 5684 18 3 ethical ethical JJ 5684 18 4 teaching teaching NN 5684 18 5 , , , 5684 18 6 whether whether IN 5684 18 7 in in IN 5684 18 8 schools school NNS 5684 18 9 , , , 5684 18 10 or or CC 5684 18 11 lecture lecture NN 5684 18 12 - - HYPH 5684 18 13 rooms room NNS 5684 18 14 , , , 5684 18 15 etc etc FW 5684 18 16 . . . 5684 18 17 , , , 5684 18 18 is be VBZ 5684 18 19 corrupted corrupt VBN 5684 18 20 in in IN 5684 18 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 18 22 source source NN 5684 18 23 . . . 5684 19 1 For for IN 5684 19 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 19 3 is be VBZ 5684 19 4 not not RB 5684 19 5 a a DT 5684 19 6 matter matter NN 5684 19 7 of of IN 5684 19 8 indifference indifference NN 5684 19 9 by by IN 5684 19 10 what what WDT 5684 19 11 motives motive NNS 5684 19 12 or or CC 5684 19 13 means mean VBZ 5684 19 14 one one CD 5684 19 15 is be VBZ 5684 19 16 led lead VBN 5684 19 17 to to IN 5684 19 18 a a DT 5684 19 19 good good JJ 5684 19 20 purpose purpose NN 5684 19 21 ( ( -LRB- 5684 19 22 the the DT 5684 19 23 obedience obedience NN 5684 19 24 to to IN 5684 19 25 duty duty NN 5684 19 26 ) ) -RRB- 5684 19 27 . . . 5684 20 1 However however RB 5684 20 2 disgusting disgusting JJ 5684 20 3 , , , 5684 20 4 then then RB 5684 20 5 , , , 5684 20 6 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 5684 20 7 may may MD 5684 20 8 appear appear VB 5684 20 9 to to IN 5684 20 10 those those DT 5684 20 11 pretended pretend VBN 5684 20 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 5684 20 13 who who WP 5684 20 14 dogmatize dogmatize VBP 5684 20 15 oracularly oracularly RB 5684 20 16 , , , 5684 20 17 or or CC 5684 20 18 even even RB 5684 20 19 brilliantly brilliantly RB 5684 20 20 , , , 5684 20 21 about about IN 5684 20 22 the the DT 5684 20 23 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 20 24 of of IN 5684 20 25 duty duty NN 5684 20 26 , , , 5684 20 27 it -PRON- PRP 5684 20 28 is be VBZ 5684 20 29 , , , 5684 20 30 nevertheless nevertheless RB 5684 20 31 , , , 5684 20 32 an an DT 5684 20 33 indispensable indispensable JJ 5684 20 34 duty duty NN 5684 20 35 for for IN 5684 20 36 those those DT 5684 20 37 who who WP 5684 20 38 oppose oppose VBP 5684 20 39 it -PRON- PRP 5684 20 40 to to TO 5684 20 41 go go VB 5684 20 42 back back RB 5684 20 43 to to IN 5684 20 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 20 45 principles principle NNS 5684 20 46 even even RB 5684 20 47 in in IN 5684 20 48 ethics ethic NNS 5684 20 49 , , , 5684 20 50 and and CC 5684 20 51 to to TO 5684 20 52 begin begin VB 5684 20 53 by by IN 5684 20 54 going go VBG 5684 20 55 to to IN 5684 20 56 school school NN 5684 20 57 on on IN 5684 20 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 20 59 benches bench NNS 5684 20 60 . . . 5684 21 1 We -PRON- PRP 5684 21 2 may may MD 5684 21 3 fairly fairly RB 5684 21 4 wonder wonder VB 5684 21 5 how how WRB 5684 21 6 , , , 5684 21 7 after after IN 5684 21 8 all all DT 5684 21 9 previous previous JJ 5684 21 10 explanations explanation NNS 5684 21 11 of of IN 5684 21 12 the the DT 5684 21 13 principles principle NNS 5684 21 14 of of IN 5684 21 15 duty duty NN 5684 21 16 , , , 5684 21 17 so so RB 5684 21 18 far far RB 5684 21 19 as as IN 5684 21 20 it -PRON- PRP 5684 21 21 is be VBZ 5684 21 22 derived derive VBN 5684 21 23 from from IN 5684 21 24 pure pure JJ 5684 21 25 reason reason NN 5684 21 26 , , , 5684 21 27 it -PRON- PRP 5684 21 28 was be VBD 5684 21 29 still still RB 5684 21 30 possible possible JJ 5684 21 31 to to TO 5684 21 32 reduce reduce VB 5684 21 33 it -PRON- PRP 5684 21 34 again again RB 5684 21 35 to to IN 5684 21 36 a a DT 5684 21 37 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 21 38 of of IN 5684 21 39 happiness happiness NN 5684 21 40 ; ; : 5684 21 41 in in IN 5684 21 42 such such PDT 5684 21 43 a a DT 5684 21 44 way way NN 5684 21 45 , , , 5684 21 46 however however RB 5684 21 47 , , , 5684 21 48 that that IN 5684 21 49 a a DT 5684 21 50 certain certain JJ 5684 21 51 moral moral JJ 5684 21 52 happiness happiness NN 5684 21 53 not not RB 5684 21 54 resting rest VBG 5684 21 55 on on IN 5684 21 56 empirical empirical JJ 5684 21 57 causes cause NNS 5684 21 58 was be VBD 5684 21 59 ultimately ultimately RB 5684 21 60 arrived arrive VBN 5684 21 61 at at IN 5684 21 62 , , , 5684 21 63 a a DT 5684 21 64 self self NN 5684 21 65 - - HYPH 5684 21 66 contradictory contradictory JJ 5684 21 67 nonentity nonentity NN 5684 21 68 . . . 5684 22 1 In in IN 5684 22 2 fact fact NN 5684 22 3 , , , 5684 22 4 when when WRB 5684 22 5 the the DT 5684 22 6 thinking thinking NN 5684 22 7 man man NN 5684 22 8 has have VBZ 5684 22 9 conquered conquer VBN 5684 22 10 the the DT 5684 22 11 temptations temptation NNS 5684 22 12 to to IN 5684 22 13 vice vice NN 5684 22 14 , , , 5684 22 15 and and CC 5684 22 16 is be VBZ 5684 22 17 conscious conscious JJ 5684 22 18 of of IN 5684 22 19 having have VBG 5684 22 20 done do VBN 5684 22 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 22 22 ( ( -LRB- 5684 22 23 often often RB 5684 22 24 hard hard JJ 5684 22 25 ) ) -RRB- 5684 22 26 duty duty NN 5684 22 27 , , , 5684 22 28 he -PRON- PRP 5684 22 29 finds find VBZ 5684 22 30 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 22 31 in in IN 5684 22 32 a a DT 5684 22 33 state state NN 5684 22 34 of of IN 5684 22 35 peace peace NN 5684 22 36 and and CC 5684 22 37 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 22 38 which which WDT 5684 22 39 may may MD 5684 22 40 well well RB 5684 22 41 be be VB 5684 22 42 called call VBN 5684 22 43 happiness happiness NN 5684 22 44 , , , 5684 22 45 in in IN 5684 22 46 which which WDT 5684 22 47 virtue virtue NN 5684 22 48 is be VBZ 5684 22 49 her -PRON- PRP$ 5684 22 50 own own JJ 5684 22 51 reward reward NN 5684 22 52 . . . 5684 23 1 Now now RB 5684 23 2 , , , 5684 23 3 says say VBZ 5684 23 4 the the DT 5684 23 5 eudaemonist eudaemonist NN 5684 23 6 , , , 5684 23 7 this this DT 5684 23 8 delight delight NN 5684 23 9 , , , 5684 23 10 this this DT 5684 23 11 happiness happiness NN 5684 23 12 , , , 5684 23 13 is be VBZ 5684 23 14 the the DT 5684 23 15 real real JJ 5684 23 16 motive motive NN 5684 23 17 of of IN 5684 23 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 23 19 acting act VBG 5684 23 20 virtuously virtuously RB 5684 23 21 . . . 5684 24 1 The the DT 5684 24 2 notion notion NN 5684 24 3 of of IN 5684 24 4 duty duty NN 5684 24 5 , , , 5684 24 6 says say VBZ 5684 24 7 be be VB 5684 24 8 , , , 5684 24 9 does do VBZ 5684 24 10 not not RB 5684 24 11 immediately immediately RB 5684 24 12 determine determine VB 5684 24 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 24 14 will will NN 5684 24 15 ; ; : 5684 24 16 it -PRON- PRP 5684 24 17 is be VBZ 5684 24 18 only only RB 5684 24 19 by by IN 5684 24 20 means mean NNS 5684 24 21 of of IN 5684 24 22 the the DT 5684 24 23 happiness happiness NN 5684 24 24 in in IN 5684 24 25 prospect prospect NN 5684 24 26 that that IN 5684 24 27 he -PRON- PRP 5684 24 28 is be VBZ 5684 24 29 moved move VBN 5684 24 30 to to IN 5684 24 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 24 32 duty duty NN 5684 24 33 . . . 5684 25 1 Now now RB 5684 25 2 , , , 5684 25 3 on on IN 5684 25 4 the the DT 5684 25 5 other other JJ 5684 25 6 hand hand NN 5684 25 7 , , , 5684 25 8 since since IN 5684 25 9 he -PRON- PRP 5684 25 10 can can MD 5684 25 11 promise promise VB 5684 25 12 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 25 13 this this DT 5684 25 14 reward reward NN 5684 25 15 of of IN 5684 25 16 virtue virtue NN 5684 25 17 only only RB 5684 25 18 from from IN 5684 25 19 the the DT 5684 25 20 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 25 21 of of IN 5684 25 22 having have VBG 5684 25 23 done do VBN 5684 25 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 25 25 duty duty NN 5684 25 26 , , , 5684 25 27 it -PRON- PRP 5684 25 28 is be VBZ 5684 25 29 clear clear JJ 5684 25 30 that that IN 5684 25 31 the the DT 5684 25 32 latter latter JJ 5684 25 33 must must MD 5684 25 34 have have VB 5684 25 35 preceded precede VBN 5684 25 36 : : : 5684 25 37 that that RB 5684 25 38 is is RB 5684 25 39 , , , 5684 25 40 he -PRON- PRP 5684 25 41 must must MD 5684 25 42 feel feel VB 5684 25 43 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 25 44 bound bind VBN 5684 25 45 to to TO 5684 25 46 do do VB 5684 25 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 25 48 duty duty NN 5684 25 49 before before IN 5684 25 50 he -PRON- PRP 5684 25 51 thinks think VBZ 5684 25 52 , , , 5684 25 53 and and CC 5684 25 54 without without IN 5684 25 55 thinking thinking NN 5684 25 56 , , , 5684 25 57 that that IN 5684 25 58 happiness happiness NN 5684 25 59 will will MD 5684 25 60 be be VB 5684 25 61 the the DT 5684 25 62 consequence consequence NN 5684 25 63 of of IN 5684 25 64 obedience obedience NN 5684 25 65 to to IN 5684 25 66 duty duty NN 5684 25 67 . . . 5684 26 1 He -PRON- PRP 5684 26 2 is be VBZ 5684 26 3 thus thus RB 5684 26 4 involved involve VBN 5684 26 5 in in IN 5684 26 6 a a DT 5684 26 7 circle circle NN 5684 26 8 in in IN 5684 26 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 26 10 assignment assignment NN 5684 26 11 of of IN 5684 26 12 cause cause NN 5684 26 13 and and CC 5684 26 14 effect effect NN 5684 26 15 . . . 5684 27 1 He -PRON- PRP 5684 27 2 can can MD 5684 27 3 only only RB 5684 27 4 hope hope VB 5684 27 5 to to TO 5684 27 6 be be VB 5684 27 7 happy happy JJ 5684 27 8 if if IN 5684 27 9 he -PRON- PRP 5684 27 10 is be VBZ 5684 27 11 conscious conscious JJ 5684 27 12 of of IN 5684 27 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 27 14 obedience obedience NN 5684 27 15 to to IN 5684 27 16 duty duty NN 5684 27 17 : : : 5684 27 18 and and CC 5684 27 19 he -PRON- PRP 5684 27 20 can can MD 5684 27 21 only only RB 5684 27 22 be be VB 5684 27 23 moved move VBN 5684 27 24 to to IN 5684 27 25 obedience obedience NN 5684 27 26 to to IN 5684 27 27 duty duty NN 5684 27 28 if if IN 5684 27 29 be be VB 5684 27 30 foresees foresee NNS 5684 27 31 that that IN 5684 27 32 he -PRON- PRP 5684 27 33 will will MD 5684 27 34 thereby thereby RB 5684 27 35 become become VB 5684 27 36 happy happy JJ 5684 27 37 . . . 5684 28 1 But but CC 5684 28 2 in in IN 5684 28 3 this this DT 5684 28 4 reasoning reasoning NN 5684 28 5 there there EX 5684 28 6 is be VBZ 5684 28 7 also also RB 5684 28 8 a a DT 5684 28 9 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 28 10 . . . 5684 29 1 For for IN 5684 29 2 , , , 5684 29 3 on on IN 5684 29 4 the the DT 5684 29 5 one one CD 5684 29 6 side side NN 5684 29 7 , , , 5684 29 8 he -PRON- PRP 5684 29 9 must must MD 5684 29 10 obey obey VB 5684 29 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 29 12 duty duty NN 5684 29 13 , , , 5684 29 14 without without IN 5684 29 15 asking ask VBG 5684 29 16 what what WDT 5684 29 17 effect effect NN 5684 29 18 this this DT 5684 29 19 will will MD 5684 29 20 have have VB 5684 29 21 on on IN 5684 29 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 29 23 happiness happiness NN 5684 29 24 , , , 5684 29 25 consequently consequently RB 5684 29 26 , , , 5684 29 27 from from IN 5684 29 28 a a DT 5684 29 29 moral moral JJ 5684 29 30 principle principle NN 5684 29 31 ; ; : 5684 29 32 on on IN 5684 29 33 the the DT 5684 29 34 other other JJ 5684 29 35 side side NN 5684 29 36 , , , 5684 29 37 he -PRON- PRP 5684 29 38 can can MD 5684 29 39 only only RB 5684 29 40 recognize recognize VB 5684 29 41 something something NN 5684 29 42 as as IN 5684 29 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 29 44 duty duty NN 5684 29 45 when when WRB 5684 29 46 he -PRON- PRP 5684 29 47 can can MD 5684 29 48 reckon reckon VB 5684 29 49 on on IN 5684 29 50 happiness happiness NN 5684 29 51 which which WDT 5684 29 52 will will MD 5684 29 53 accrue accrue VB 5684 29 54 to to IN 5684 29 55 him -PRON- PRP 5684 29 56 thereby thereby RB 5684 29 57 , , , 5684 29 58 and and CC 5684 29 59 consequently consequently RB 5684 29 60 on on IN 5684 29 61 a a DT 5684 29 62 pathological pathological JJ 5684 29 63 principle principle NN 5684 29 64 , , , 5684 29 65 which which WDT 5684 29 66 is be VBZ 5684 29 67 the the DT 5684 29 68 direct direct JJ 5684 29 69 opposite opposite NN 5684 29 70 of of IN 5684 29 71 the the DT 5684 29 72 former former JJ 5684 29 73 . . . 5684 30 1 I -PRON- PRP 5684 30 2 have have VBP 5684 30 3 in in IN 5684 30 4 another another DT 5684 30 5 place place NN 5684 30 6 ( ( -LRB- 5684 30 7 the the DT 5684 30 8 Berlin Berlin NNP 5684 30 9 Monatsschrift Monatsschrift NNP 5684 30 10 ) ) -RRB- 5684 30 11 , , , 5684 30 12 reduced reduce VBN 5684 30 13 , , , 5684 30 14 as as IN 5684 30 15 I -PRON- PRP 5684 30 16 believe believe VBP 5684 30 17 , , , 5684 30 18 to to IN 5684 30 19 the the DT 5684 30 20 simplest simple JJS 5684 30 21 expressions expression NNS 5684 30 22 the the DT 5684 30 23 distinction distinction NN 5684 30 24 between between IN 5684 30 25 pathological pathological JJ 5684 30 26 and and CC 5684 30 27 moral moral JJ 5684 30 28 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 30 29 . . . 5684 31 1 The the DT 5684 31 2 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 31 3 , , , 5684 31 4 namely namely RB 5684 31 5 , , , 5684 31 6 which which WDT 5684 31 7 must must MD 5684 31 8 precede precede VB 5684 31 9 the the DT 5684 31 10 obedience obedience NN 5684 31 11 to to IN 5684 31 12 the the DT 5684 31 13 law law NN 5684 31 14 in in IN 5684 31 15 order order NN 5684 31 16 that that IN 5684 31 17 one one PRP 5684 31 18 may may MD 5684 31 19 act act VB 5684 31 20 according accord VBG 5684 31 21 to to IN 5684 31 22 the the DT 5684 31 23 law law NN 5684 31 24 is be VBZ 5684 31 25 pathological pathological JJ 5684 31 26 , , , 5684 31 27 and and CC 5684 31 28 the the DT 5684 31 29 process process NN 5684 31 30 follows follow VBZ 5684 31 31 the the DT 5684 31 32 physical physical JJ 5684 31 33 order order NN 5684 31 34 of of IN 5684 31 35 nature nature NN 5684 31 36 ; ; : 5684 31 37 that that IN 5684 31 38 which which WDT 5684 31 39 must must MD 5684 31 40 be be VB 5684 31 41 preceded precede VBN 5684 31 42 by by IN 5684 31 43 the the DT 5684 31 44 law law NN 5684 31 45 in in IN 5684 31 46 order order NN 5684 31 47 that that IN 5684 31 48 it -PRON- PRP 5684 31 49 may may MD 5684 31 50 be be VB 5684 31 51 felt feel VBN 5684 31 52 is be VBZ 5684 31 53 in in IN 5684 31 54 the the DT 5684 31 55 moral moral JJ 5684 31 56 order order NN 5684 31 57 . . . 5684 32 1 If if IN 5684 32 2 this this DT 5684 32 3 distinction distinction NN 5684 32 4 is be VBZ 5684 32 5 not not RB 5684 32 6 observed observe VBN 5684 32 7 ; ; : 5684 32 8 if if IN 5684 32 9 eudaemonism eudaemonism NN 5684 32 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 32 11 the the DT 5684 32 12 principle principle NN 5684 32 13 of of IN 5684 32 14 happiness happiness NN 5684 32 15 ) ) -RRB- 5684 32 16 is be VBZ 5684 32 17 adopted adopt VBN 5684 32 18 as as IN 5684 32 19 the the DT 5684 32 20 principle principle NN 5684 32 21 instead instead RB 5684 32 22 of of IN 5684 32 23 eleutheronomy eleutheronomy NN 5684 32 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 32 25 the the DT 5684 32 26 principle principle NN 5684 32 27 of of IN 5684 32 28 freedom freedom NN 5684 32 29 of of IN 5684 32 30 the the DT 5684 32 31 inner inner JJ 5684 32 32 legislation legislation NN 5684 32 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 32 34 , , , 5684 32 35 the the DT 5684 32 36 consequence consequence NN 5684 32 37 is be VBZ 5684 32 38 the the DT 5684 32 39 euthanasia euthanasia NN 5684 32 40 ( ( -LRB- 5684 32 41 quiet quiet JJ 5684 32 42 death death NN 5684 32 43 ) ) -RRB- 5684 32 44 of of IN 5684 32 45 all all DT 5684 32 46 morality morality NN 5684 32 47 . . . 5684 33 1 { { -LRB- 5684 33 2 PREFACE PREFACE NNP 5684 33 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 33 4 10 10 CD 5684 33 5 } } -RRB- 5684 33 6 The the DT 5684 33 7 cause cause NN 5684 33 8 of of IN 5684 33 9 these these DT 5684 33 10 mistakes mistake NNS 5684 33 11 is be VBZ 5684 33 12 no no DT 5684 33 13 other other JJ 5684 33 14 than than IN 5684 33 15 the the DT 5684 33 16 following follow VBG 5684 33 17 : : : 5684 33 18 Those those DT 5684 33 19 who who WP 5684 33 20 are be VBP 5684 33 21 accustomed accustomed JJ 5684 33 22 only only RB 5684 33 23 to to IN 5684 33 24 physiological physiological JJ 5684 33 25 explanations explanation NNS 5684 33 26 will will MD 5684 33 27 not not RB 5684 33 28 admit admit VB 5684 33 29 into into IN 5684 33 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 33 31 heads head NNS 5684 33 32 the the DT 5684 33 33 categorical categorical JJ 5684 33 34 imperative imperative NN 5684 33 35 from from IN 5684 33 36 which which WDT 5684 33 37 these these DT 5684 33 38 laws law NNS 5684 33 39 dictatorially dictatorially RB 5684 33 40 proceed proceed VBP 5684 33 41 , , , 5684 33 42 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 5684 33 43 that that IN 5684 33 44 they -PRON- PRP 5684 33 45 feel feel VBP 5684 33 46 themselves -PRON- PRP 5684 33 47 irresistibly irresistibly RB 5684 33 48 forced force VBN 5684 33 49 by by IN 5684 33 50 it -PRON- PRP 5684 33 51 . . . 5684 34 1 Dissatisfied dissatisfy VBN 5684 34 2 at at IN 5684 34 3 not not RB 5684 34 4 being be VBG 5684 34 5 able able JJ 5684 34 6 to to TO 5684 34 7 explain explain VB 5684 34 8 what what WP 5684 34 9 lies lie VBZ 5684 34 10 wholly wholly RB 5684 34 11 beyond beyond IN 5684 34 12 that that DT 5684 34 13 sphere sphere NN 5684 34 14 , , , 5684 34 15 namely namely RB 5684 34 16 , , , 5684 34 17 freedom freedom NN 5684 34 18 of of IN 5684 34 19 the the DT 5684 34 20 elective elective NN 5684 34 21 will will MD 5684 34 22 , , , 5684 34 23 elevating elevate VBG 5684 34 24 as as IN 5684 34 25 is be VBZ 5684 34 26 this this DT 5684 34 27 privilege privilege NN 5684 34 28 , , , 5684 34 29 that that DT 5684 34 30 man man NN 5684 34 31 has have VBZ 5684 34 32 of of IN 5684 34 33 being be VBG 5684 34 34 capable capable JJ 5684 34 35 of of IN 5684 34 36 such such PDT 5684 34 37 an an DT 5684 34 38 idea idea NN 5684 34 39 , , , 5684 34 40 they -PRON- PRP 5684 34 41 are be VBP 5684 34 42 stirred stir VBN 5684 34 43 up up RP 5684 34 44 by by IN 5684 34 45 the the DT 5684 34 46 proud proud JJ 5684 34 47 claims claim NNS 5684 34 48 of of IN 5684 34 49 speculative speculative JJ 5684 34 50 reason reason NN 5684 34 51 , , , 5684 34 52 which which WDT 5684 34 53 feels feel VBZ 5684 34 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 34 55 power power NN 5684 34 56 so so RB 5684 34 57 strongly strongly RB 5684 34 58 in in IN 5684 34 59 the the DT 5684 34 60 fields field NNS 5684 34 61 , , , 5684 34 62 just just RB 5684 34 63 as as IN 5684 34 64 if if IN 5684 34 65 they -PRON- PRP 5684 34 66 were be VBD 5684 34 67 allies ally NNS 5684 34 68 leagued league VBN 5684 34 69 in in IN 5684 34 70 defence defence NN 5684 34 71 of of IN 5684 34 72 the the DT 5684 34 73 omnipotence omnipotence NN 5684 34 74 of of IN 5684 34 75 theoretical theoretical JJ 5684 34 76 reason reason NN 5684 34 77 and and CC 5684 34 78 roused rouse VBD 5684 34 79 by by IN 5684 34 80 a a DT 5684 34 81 general general JJ 5684 34 82 call call NN 5684 34 83 to to IN 5684 34 84 arms arm NNS 5684 34 85 to to TO 5684 34 86 resist resist VB 5684 34 87 that that DT 5684 34 88 idea idea NN 5684 34 89 ; ; : 5684 34 90 and and CC 5684 34 91 thus thus RB 5684 34 92 they -PRON- PRP 5684 34 93 are be VBP 5684 34 94 at at IN 5684 34 95 present present JJ 5684 34 96 , , , 5684 34 97 and and CC 5684 34 98 perhaps perhaps RB 5684 34 99 for for IN 5684 34 100 a a DT 5684 34 101 long long JJ 5684 34 102 time time NN 5684 34 103 to to TO 5684 34 104 come come VB 5684 34 105 , , , 5684 34 106 though though IN 5684 34 107 ultimately ultimately RB 5684 34 108 in in IN 5684 34 109 vain vain JJ 5684 34 110 , , , 5684 34 111 to to TO 5684 34 112 attack attack VB 5684 34 113 the the DT 5684 34 114 moral moral JJ 5684 34 115 concept concept NN 5684 34 116 of of IN 5684 34 117 freedom freedom NN 5684 34 118 and and CC 5684 34 119 if if IN 5684 34 120 possible possible JJ 5684 34 121 render render VBP 5684 34 122 it -PRON- PRP 5684 34 123 doubtful doubtful JJ 5684 34 124 . . . 5684 35 1 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 35 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION VBN 5684 35 3 TO to IN 5684 35 4 THE the DT 5684 35 5 METAPHYSICAL METAPHYSICAL NNP 5684 35 6 ELEMENTS element NNS 5684 35 7 OF of IN 5684 35 8 ETHICS ETHICS NNP 5684 35 9 Ethics ethic NNS 5684 35 10 in in IN 5684 35 11 ancient ancient JJ 5684 35 12 times time NNS 5684 35 13 signified signify VBD 5684 35 14 moral moral JJ 5684 35 15 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 35 16 ( ( -LRB- 5684 35 17 philosophia philosophia NNP 5684 35 18 moralis moralis NNP 5684 35 19 ) ) -RRB- 5684 35 20 generally generally RB 5684 35 21 , , , 5684 35 22 which which WDT 5684 35 23 was be VBD 5684 35 24 also also RB 5684 35 25 called call VBN 5684 35 26 the the DT 5684 35 27 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 35 28 of of IN 5684 35 29 duties duty NNS 5684 35 30 . . . 5684 36 1 Subsequently subsequently RB 5684 36 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 36 3 was be VBD 5684 36 4 found find VBN 5684 36 5 advisable advisable JJ 5684 36 6 to to TO 5684 36 7 confine confine VB 5684 36 8 this this DT 5684 36 9 name name NN 5684 36 10 to to IN 5684 36 11 a a DT 5684 36 12 part part NN 5684 36 13 of of IN 5684 36 14 moral moral JJ 5684 36 15 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 36 16 , , , 5684 36 17 namely namely RB 5684 36 18 , , , 5684 36 19 to to IN 5684 36 20 the the DT 5684 36 21 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 36 22 of of IN 5684 36 23 duties duty NNS 5684 36 24 which which WDT 5684 36 25 are be VBP 5684 36 26 not not RB 5684 36 27 subject subject JJ 5684 36 28 to to IN 5684 36 29 external external JJ 5684 36 30 laws law NNS 5684 36 31 ( ( -LRB- 5684 36 32 for for IN 5684 36 33 which which WDT 5684 36 34 in in IN 5684 36 35 German german JJ 5684 36 36 the the DT 5684 36 37 name name NN 5684 36 38 Tugendlehre Tugendlehre NNP 5684 36 39 was be VBD 5684 36 40 found find VBN 5684 36 41 suitable suitable JJ 5684 36 42 ) ) -RRB- 5684 36 43 . . . 5684 37 1 Thus thus RB 5684 37 2 the the DT 5684 37 3 system system NN 5684 37 4 of of IN 5684 37 5 general general JJ 5684 37 6 deontology deontology NN 5684 37 7 is be VBZ 5684 37 8 divided divide VBN 5684 37 9 into into IN 5684 37 10 that that DT 5684 37 11 of of IN 5684 37 12 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 37 13 ( ( -LRB- 5684 37 14 jurisprudentia jurisprudentia NNP 5684 37 15 ) ) -RRB- 5684 37 16 , , , 5684 37 17 which which WDT 5684 37 18 is be VBZ 5684 37 19 capable capable JJ 5684 37 20 of of IN 5684 37 21 external external JJ 5684 37 22 laws law NNS 5684 37 23 , , , 5684 37 24 and and CC 5684 37 25 of of IN 5684 37 26 ethics ethic NNS 5684 37 27 , , , 5684 37 28 which which WDT 5684 37 29 is be VBZ 5684 37 30 not not RB 5684 37 31 thus thus RB 5684 37 32 capable capable JJ 5684 37 33 , , , 5684 37 34 and and CC 5684 37 35 we -PRON- PRP 5684 37 36 may may MD 5684 37 37 let let VB 5684 37 38 this this DT 5684 37 39 division division NN 5684 37 40 stand stand VB 5684 37 41 . . . 5684 38 1 I. I. NNP 5684 38 2 Exposition Exposition NNP 5684 38 3 of of IN 5684 38 4 the the DT 5684 38 5 Conception Conception NNP 5684 38 6 of of IN 5684 38 7 Ethics Ethics NNP 5684 38 8 The the DT 5684 38 9 notion notion NN 5684 38 10 of of IN 5684 38 11 duty duty NN 5684 38 12 is be VBZ 5684 38 13 in in IN 5684 38 14 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 38 15 already already RB 5684 38 16 the the DT 5684 38 17 notion notion NN 5684 38 18 of of IN 5684 38 19 a a DT 5684 38 20 constraint constraint NN 5684 38 21 of of IN 5684 38 22 the the DT 5684 38 23 free free JJ 5684 38 24 elective elective NN 5684 38 25 will will MD 5684 38 26 by by IN 5684 38 27 the the DT 5684 38 28 law law NN 5684 38 29 ; ; : 5684 38 30 whether whether IN 5684 38 31 this this DT 5684 38 32 constraint constraint NN 5684 38 33 be be VB 5684 38 34 an an DT 5684 38 35 external external JJ 5684 38 36 one one NN 5684 38 37 or or CC 5684 38 38 be be VB 5684 38 39 self self NN 5684 38 40 - - HYPH 5684 38 41 constraint constraint JJ 5684 38 42 . . . 5684 39 1 The the DT 5684 39 2 moral moral JJ 5684 39 3 imperative imperative NN 5684 39 4 , , , 5684 39 5 by by IN 5684 39 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 39 7 categorical categorical JJ 5684 39 8 ( ( -LRB- 5684 39 9 the the DT 5684 39 10 unconditional unconditional JJ 5684 39 11 ought ought NN 5684 39 12 ) ) -RRB- 5684 39 13 announces announce VBZ 5684 39 14 this this DT 5684 39 15 constraint constraint NN 5684 39 16 , , , 5684 39 17 which which WDT 5684 39 18 therefore therefore RB 5684 39 19 does do VBZ 5684 39 20 not not RB 5684 39 21 apply apply VB 5684 39 22 to to IN 5684 39 23 all all DT 5684 39 24 rational rational JJ 5684 39 25 beings being NNS 5684 39 26 ( ( -LRB- 5684 39 27 for for IN 5684 39 28 there there EX 5684 39 29 may may MD 5684 39 30 also also RB 5684 39 31 be be VB 5684 39 32 holy holy JJ 5684 39 33 beings being NNS 5684 39 34 ) ) -RRB- 5684 39 35 , , , 5684 39 36 but but CC 5684 39 37 applies apply VBZ 5684 39 38 to to IN 5684 39 39 men man NNS 5684 39 40 as as IN 5684 39 41 rational rational JJ 5684 39 42 physical physical JJ 5684 39 43 beings being NNS 5684 39 44 who who WP 5684 39 45 are be VBP 5684 39 46 unholy unholy JJ 5684 39 47 enough enough RB 5684 39 48 to to TO 5684 39 49 be be VB 5684 39 50 seduced seduce VBN 5684 39 51 by by IN 5684 39 52 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 39 53 to to IN 5684 39 54 the the DT 5684 39 55 transgression transgression NN 5684 39 56 of of IN 5684 39 57 the the DT 5684 39 58 moral moral JJ 5684 39 59 law law NN 5684 39 60 , , , 5684 39 61 although although IN 5684 39 62 they -PRON- PRP 5684 39 63 themselves -PRON- PRP 5684 39 64 recognize recognize VBP 5684 39 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 39 66 authority authority NN 5684 39 67 ; ; : 5684 39 68 and and CC 5684 39 69 when when WRB 5684 39 70 they -PRON- PRP 5684 39 71 do do VBP 5684 39 72 obey obey VB 5684 39 73 it -PRON- PRP 5684 39 74 , , , 5684 39 75 to to TO 5684 39 76 obey obey VB 5684 39 77 it -PRON- PRP 5684 39 78 unwillingly unwillingly RB 5684 39 79 ( ( -LRB- 5684 39 80 with with IN 5684 39 81 resistance resistance NN 5684 39 82 of of IN 5684 39 83 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 39 84 inclination inclination NN 5684 39 85 ) ) -RRB- 5684 39 86 ; ; : 5684 39 87 and and CC 5684 39 88 it -PRON- PRP 5684 39 89 is be VBZ 5684 39 90 in in IN 5684 39 91 this this DT 5684 39 92 that that IN 5684 39 93 the the DT 5684 39 94 constraint constraint NN 5684 39 95 properly properly RB 5684 39 96 consists consist VBZ 5684 39 97 . . . 5684 40 1 * * NFP 5684 40 2 Now now RB 5684 40 3 , , , 5684 40 4 as as IN 5684 40 5 man man NN 5684 40 6 is be VBZ 5684 40 7 a a DT 5684 40 8 free free JJ 5684 40 9 ( ( -LRB- 5684 40 10 moral moral JJ 5684 40 11 ) ) -RRB- 5684 40 12 being be VBG 5684 40 13 , , , 5684 40 14 the the DT 5684 40 15 notion notion NN 5684 40 16 of of IN 5684 40 17 duty duty NN 5684 40 18 can can MD 5684 40 19 contain contain VB 5684 40 20 only only RB 5684 40 21 self self NN 5684 40 22 - - HYPH 5684 40 23 constraint constraint NN 5684 40 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 40 25 by by IN 5684 40 26 the the DT 5684 40 27 idea idea NN 5684 40 28 of of IN 5684 40 29 the the DT 5684 40 30 law law NN 5684 40 31 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 40 32 ) ) -RRB- 5684 40 33 , , , 5684 40 34 when when WRB 5684 40 35 we -PRON- PRP 5684 40 36 look look VBP 5684 40 37 to to IN 5684 40 38 the the DT 5684 40 39 internal internal JJ 5684 40 40 determination determination NN 5684 40 41 of of IN 5684 40 42 the the DT 5684 40 43 will will NN 5684 40 44 ( ( -LRB- 5684 40 45 the the DT 5684 40 46 spring spring NN 5684 40 47 ) ) -RRB- 5684 40 48 , , , 5684 40 49 for for IN 5684 40 50 thus thus RB 5684 40 51 only only RB 5684 40 52 is be VBZ 5684 40 53 it -PRON- PRP 5684 40 54 possible possible JJ 5684 40 55 to to TO 5684 40 56 combine combine VB 5684 40 57 that that DT 5684 40 58 constraint constraint NN 5684 40 59 ( ( -LRB- 5684 40 60 even even RB 5684 40 61 if if IN 5684 40 62 it -PRON- PRP 5684 40 63 were be VBD 5684 40 64 external external JJ 5684 40 65 ) ) -RRB- 5684 40 66 with with IN 5684 40 67 the the DT 5684 40 68 freedom freedom NN 5684 40 69 of of IN 5684 40 70 the the DT 5684 40 71 elective elective NN 5684 40 72 will will NN 5684 40 73 . . . 5684 41 1 The the DT 5684 41 2 notion notion NN 5684 41 3 of of IN 5684 41 4 duty duty NN 5684 41 5 then then RB 5684 41 6 must must MD 5684 41 7 be be VB 5684 41 8 an an DT 5684 41 9 ethical ethical JJ 5684 41 10 one one NN 5684 41 11 . . . 5684 42 1 { { -LRB- 5684 42 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 42 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 42 4 5 5 CD 5684 42 5 } } -RRB- 5684 42 6 * * NFP 5684 42 7 Man man UH 5684 42 8 , , , 5684 42 9 however however RB 5684 42 10 , , , 5684 42 11 as as IN 5684 42 12 at at IN 5684 42 13 the the DT 5684 42 14 same same JJ 5684 42 15 time time NN 5684 42 16 a a DT 5684 42 17 moral moral JJ 5684 42 18 being being NN 5684 42 19 , , , 5684 42 20 when when WRB 5684 42 21 he -PRON- PRP 5684 42 22 considers consider VBZ 5684 42 23 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 42 24 objectively objectively RB 5684 42 25 , , , 5684 42 26 which which WDT 5684 42 27 he -PRON- PRP 5684 42 28 is be VBZ 5684 42 29 qualified qualified JJ 5684 42 30 to to TO 5684 42 31 do do VB 5684 42 32 by by IN 5684 42 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 42 34 pure pure JJ 5684 42 35 practical practical JJ 5684 42 36 reason reason NN 5684 42 37 , , , 5684 42 38 ( ( -LRB- 5684 42 39 i.e. i.e. FW 5684 43 1 according accord VBG 5684 43 2 to to IN 5684 43 3 humanity humanity NN 5684 43 4 in in IN 5684 43 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 43 6 own own JJ 5684 43 7 person person NN 5684 43 8 ) ) -RRB- 5684 43 9 , , , 5684 43 10 finds find VBZ 5684 43 11 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 43 12 holy holy JJ 5684 43 13 enough enough RB 5684 43 14 to to TO 5684 43 15 transgress transgress VB 5684 43 16 the the DT 5684 43 17 law law NN 5684 43 18 only only RB 5684 43 19 unwillingly unwillingly RB 5684 43 20 ; ; : 5684 43 21 for for IN 5684 43 22 there there EX 5684 43 23 is be VBZ 5684 43 24 no no DT 5684 43 25 man man NN 5684 43 26 so so RB 5684 43 27 depraved depraved JJ 5684 43 28 who who WP 5684 43 29 in in IN 5684 43 30 this this DT 5684 43 31 transgression transgression NN 5684 43 32 would would MD 5684 43 33 not not RB 5684 43 34 feel feel VB 5684 43 35 a a DT 5684 43 36 resistance resistance NN 5684 43 37 and and CC 5684 43 38 an an DT 5684 43 39 abhorrence abhorrence NN 5684 43 40 of of IN 5684 43 41 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 43 42 , , , 5684 43 43 so so IN 5684 43 44 that that IN 5684 43 45 he -PRON- PRP 5684 43 46 must must MD 5684 43 47 put put VB 5684 43 48 a a DT 5684 43 49 force force NN 5684 43 50 on on IN 5684 43 51 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 43 52 . . . 5684 44 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 44 2 is be VBZ 5684 44 3 impossible impossible JJ 5684 44 4 to to TO 5684 44 5 explain explain VB 5684 44 6 the the DT 5684 44 7 phenomenon phenomenon NN 5684 44 8 that that IN 5684 44 9 at at IN 5684 44 10 this this DT 5684 44 11 parting parting NN 5684 44 12 of of IN 5684 44 13 the the DT 5684 44 14 ways way NNS 5684 44 15 ( ( -LRB- 5684 44 16 where where WRB 5684 44 17 the the DT 5684 44 18 beautiful beautiful JJ 5684 44 19 fable fable JJ 5684 44 20 places place VBZ 5684 44 21 Hercules Hercules NNP 5684 44 22 between between IN 5684 44 23 virtue virtue NN 5684 44 24 and and CC 5684 44 25 sensuality sensuality NN 5684 44 26 ) ) -RRB- 5684 44 27 man man NN 5684 44 28 shows show VBZ 5684 44 29 more more JJR 5684 44 30 propensity propensity NN 5684 44 31 to to TO 5684 44 32 obey obey VB 5684 44 33 inclination inclination NN 5684 44 34 than than IN 5684 44 35 the the DT 5684 44 36 law law NN 5684 44 37 . . . 5684 45 1 For for IN 5684 45 2 , , , 5684 45 3 we -PRON- PRP 5684 45 4 can can MD 5684 45 5 only only RB 5684 45 6 explain explain VB 5684 45 7 what what WP 5684 45 8 happens happen VBZ 5684 45 9 by by IN 5684 45 10 tracing trace VBG 5684 45 11 it -PRON- PRP 5684 45 12 to to IN 5684 45 13 a a DT 5684 45 14 cause cause NN 5684 45 15 according accord VBG 5684 45 16 to to IN 5684 45 17 physical physical JJ 5684 45 18 laws law NNS 5684 45 19 ; ; : 5684 45 20 but but CC 5684 45 21 then then RB 5684 45 22 we -PRON- PRP 5684 45 23 should should MD 5684 45 24 not not RB 5684 45 25 be be VB 5684 45 26 able able JJ 5684 45 27 to to TO 5684 45 28 conceive conceive VB 5684 45 29 the the DT 5684 45 30 elective elective NN 5684 45 31 will will MD 5684 45 32 as as RB 5684 45 33 free free JJ 5684 45 34 . . . 5684 46 1 Now now RB 5684 46 2 this this DT 5684 46 3 mutually mutually RB 5684 46 4 opposed oppose VBD 5684 46 5 self self NN 5684 46 6 - - HYPH 5684 46 7 constraint constraint NN 5684 46 8 and and CC 5684 46 9 the the DT 5684 46 10 inevitability inevitability NN 5684 46 11 of of IN 5684 46 12 it -PRON- PRP 5684 46 13 makes make VBZ 5684 46 14 us -PRON- PRP 5684 46 15 recognize recognize VB 5684 46 16 the the DT 5684 46 17 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 5684 46 18 property property NN 5684 46 19 of of IN 5684 46 20 freedom freedom NN 5684 46 21 . . . 5684 47 1 The the DT 5684 47 2 impulses impulse NNS 5684 47 3 of of IN 5684 47 4 nature nature NN 5684 47 5 , , , 5684 47 6 then then RB 5684 47 7 , , , 5684 47 8 contain contain VB 5684 47 9 hindrances hindrance NNS 5684 47 10 to to IN 5684 47 11 the the DT 5684 47 12 fulfilment fulfilment NN 5684 47 13 of of IN 5684 47 14 duty duty NN 5684 47 15 in in IN 5684 47 16 the the DT 5684 47 17 mind mind NN 5684 47 18 of of IN 5684 47 19 man man NN 5684 47 20 , , , 5684 47 21 and and CC 5684 47 22 resisting resist VBG 5684 47 23 forces force NNS 5684 47 24 , , , 5684 47 25 some some DT 5684 47 26 of of IN 5684 47 27 them -PRON- PRP 5684 47 28 powerful powerful JJ 5684 47 29 ; ; : 5684 47 30 and and CC 5684 47 31 he -PRON- PRP 5684 47 32 must must MD 5684 47 33 judge judge VB 5684 47 34 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 47 35 able able JJ 5684 47 36 to to TO 5684 47 37 combat combat VB 5684 47 38 these these DT 5684 47 39 and and CC 5684 47 40 to to TO 5684 47 41 conquer conquer VB 5684 47 42 them -PRON- PRP 5684 47 43 by by IN 5684 47 44 means mean NNS 5684 47 45 of of IN 5684 47 46 reason reason NN 5684 47 47 , , , 5684 47 48 not not RB 5684 47 49 in in IN 5684 47 50 the the DT 5684 47 51 future future NN 5684 47 52 , , , 5684 47 53 but but CC 5684 47 54 in in IN 5684 47 55 the the DT 5684 47 56 present present NN 5684 47 57 , , , 5684 47 58 simultaneously simultaneously RB 5684 47 59 with with IN 5684 47 60 the the DT 5684 47 61 thought thought NN 5684 47 62 ; ; : 5684 47 63 he -PRON- PRP 5684 47 64 must must MD 5684 47 65 judge judge VB 5684 47 66 that that IN 5684 47 67 he -PRON- PRP 5684 47 68 can can MD 5684 47 69 do do VB 5684 47 70 what what WP 5684 47 71 the the DT 5684 47 72 law law NN 5684 47 73 unconditionally unconditionally RB 5684 47 74 commands command VBZ 5684 47 75 that that IN 5684 47 76 he -PRON- PRP 5684 47 77 ought ought MD 5684 47 78 . . . 5684 48 1 Now now RB 5684 48 2 the the DT 5684 48 3 power power NN 5684 48 4 and and CC 5684 48 5 resolved resolve VBD 5684 48 6 purpose purpose NN 5684 48 7 to to TO 5684 48 8 resist resist VB 5684 48 9 a a DT 5684 48 10 strong strong JJ 5684 48 11 but but CC 5684 48 12 unjust unjust JJ 5684 48 13 opponent opponent NN 5684 48 14 is be VBZ 5684 48 15 called call VBN 5684 48 16 fortitude fortitude NN 5684 48 17 ( ( -LRB- 5684 48 18 fortitudo fortitudo NNP 5684 48 19 ) ) -RRB- 5684 48 20 , , , 5684 48 21 and and CC 5684 48 22 when when WRB 5684 48 23 concerned concern VBN 5684 48 24 with with IN 5684 48 25 the the DT 5684 48 26 opponent opponent NN 5684 48 27 of of IN 5684 48 28 the the DT 5684 48 29 moral moral JJ 5684 48 30 character character NN 5684 48 31 within within IN 5684 48 32 us -PRON- PRP 5684 48 33 , , , 5684 48 34 it -PRON- PRP 5684 48 35 is be VBZ 5684 48 36 virtue virtue NN 5684 48 37 ( ( -LRB- 5684 48 38 virtus virtus NNP 5684 48 39 , , , 5684 48 40 fortitudo fortitudo NNP 5684 48 41 moralis moralis NNP 5684 48 42 ) ) -RRB- 5684 48 43 . . . 5684 49 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 5684 49 2 , , , 5684 49 3 general general JJ 5684 49 4 deontology deontology NN 5684 49 5 , , , 5684 49 6 in in IN 5684 49 7 that that DT 5684 49 8 part part NN 5684 49 9 which which WDT 5684 49 10 brings bring VBZ 5684 49 11 not not RB 5684 49 12 external external JJ 5684 49 13 , , , 5684 49 14 but but CC 5684 49 15 internal internal JJ 5684 49 16 , , , 5684 49 17 freedom freedom NN 5684 49 18 under under IN 5684 49 19 laws law NNS 5684 49 20 is be VBZ 5684 49 21 the the DT 5684 49 22 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 49 23 of of IN 5684 49 24 virtue virtue NN 5684 49 25 . . . 5684 50 1 { { -LRB- 5684 50 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 50 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 50 4 10 10 CD 5684 50 5 } } -RRB- 5684 50 6 Jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 50 7 had have VBD 5684 50 8 to to TO 5684 50 9 do do VB 5684 50 10 only only RB 5684 50 11 with with IN 5684 50 12 the the DT 5684 50 13 formal formal JJ 5684 50 14 condition condition NN 5684 50 15 of of IN 5684 50 16 external external JJ 5684 50 17 freedom freedom NN 5684 50 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 50 19 the the DT 5684 50 20 condition condition NN 5684 50 21 of of IN 5684 50 22 consistency consistency NN 5684 50 23 with with IN 5684 50 24 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 50 25 , , , 5684 50 26 if if IN 5684 50 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 50 28 maxim maxim NN 5684 50 29 became become VBD 5684 50 30 a a DT 5684 50 31 universal universal JJ 5684 50 32 law law NN 5684 50 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 50 34 , , , 5684 50 35 that that RB 5684 50 36 is is RB 5684 50 37 , , , 5684 50 38 with with IN 5684 50 39 law law NN 5684 50 40 . . . 5684 51 1 Ethics ethic NNS 5684 51 2 , , , 5684 51 3 on on IN 5684 51 4 the the DT 5684 51 5 contrary contrary NN 5684 51 6 , , , 5684 51 7 supplies supply VBZ 5684 51 8 us -PRON- PRP 5684 51 9 with with IN 5684 51 10 a a DT 5684 51 11 matter matter NN 5684 51 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 51 13 an an DT 5684 51 14 object object NN 5684 51 15 of of IN 5684 51 16 the the DT 5684 51 17 free free JJ 5684 51 18 elective elective NN 5684 51 19 will will MD 5684 51 20 ) ) -RRB- 5684 51 21 , , , 5684 51 22 an an DT 5684 51 23 end end NN 5684 51 24 of of IN 5684 51 25 pure pure JJ 5684 51 26 reason reason NN 5684 51 27 which which WDT 5684 51 28 is be VBZ 5684 51 29 at at IN 5684 51 30 the the DT 5684 51 31 same same JJ 5684 51 32 time time NN 5684 51 33 conceived conceive VBD 5684 51 34 as as IN 5684 51 35 an an DT 5684 51 36 objectively objectively RB 5684 51 37 necessary necessary JJ 5684 51 38 end end NN 5684 51 39 , , , 5684 51 40 i.e. i.e. FW 5684 51 41 , , , 5684 51 42 as as IN 5684 51 43 duty duty NN 5684 51 44 for for IN 5684 51 45 all all DT 5684 51 46 men man NNS 5684 51 47 . . . 5684 52 1 For for IN 5684 52 2 , , , 5684 52 3 as as IN 5684 52 4 the the DT 5684 52 5 sensible sensible JJ 5684 52 6 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 52 7 mislead mislead VBP 5684 52 8 us -PRON- PRP 5684 52 9 to to IN 5684 52 10 ends ends NNP 5684 52 11 ( ( -LRB- 5684 52 12 which which WDT 5684 52 13 are be VBP 5684 52 14 the the DT 5684 52 15 matter matter NN 5684 52 16 of of IN 5684 52 17 the the DT 5684 52 18 elective elective NN 5684 52 19 will will MD 5684 52 20 ) ) -RRB- 5684 52 21 that that WDT 5684 52 22 may may MD 5684 52 23 contradict contradict VB 5684 52 24 duty duty NN 5684 52 25 , , , 5684 52 26 the the DT 5684 52 27 legislating legislating NN 5684 52 28 reason reason NN 5684 52 29 can can MD 5684 52 30 not not RB 5684 52 31 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 52 32 guard guard VB 5684 52 33 against against IN 5684 52 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 52 35 influence influence NN 5684 52 36 than than IN 5684 52 37 by by IN 5684 52 38 an an DT 5684 52 39 opposite opposite JJ 5684 52 40 moral moral JJ 5684 52 41 end end NN 5684 52 42 , , , 5684 52 43 which which WDT 5684 52 44 therefore therefore RB 5684 52 45 must must MD 5684 52 46 be be VB 5684 52 47 given give VBN 5684 52 48 a a DT 5684 52 49 priori priori FW 5684 52 50 independently independently RB 5684 52 51 on on IN 5684 52 52 inclination inclination NN 5684 52 53 . . . 5684 53 1 An an DT 5684 53 2 end end NN 5684 53 3 is be VBZ 5684 53 4 an an DT 5684 53 5 object object NN 5684 53 6 of of IN 5684 53 7 the the DT 5684 53 8 elective elective NN 5684 53 9 will will NN 5684 53 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 53 11 of of IN 5684 53 12 a a DT 5684 53 13 rational rational JJ 5684 53 14 being being NN 5684 53 15 ) ) -RRB- 5684 53 16 by by IN 5684 53 17 the the DT 5684 53 18 idea idea NN 5684 53 19 of of IN 5684 53 20 which which WDT 5684 53 21 this this DT 5684 53 22 will will MD 5684 53 23 is be VBZ 5684 53 24 determined determine VBN 5684 53 25 to to IN 5684 53 26 an an DT 5684 53 27 action action NN 5684 53 28 for for IN 5684 53 29 the the DT 5684 53 30 production production NN 5684 53 31 of of IN 5684 53 32 this this DT 5684 53 33 object object NN 5684 53 34 . . . 5684 54 1 Now now RB 5684 54 2 I -PRON- PRP 5684 54 3 may may MD 5684 54 4 be be VB 5684 54 5 forced force VBN 5684 54 6 by by IN 5684 54 7 others other NNS 5684 54 8 to to IN 5684 54 9 actions action NNS 5684 54 10 which which WDT 5684 54 11 are be VBP 5684 54 12 directed direct VBN 5684 54 13 to to IN 5684 54 14 an an DT 5684 54 15 end end NN 5684 54 16 as as IN 5684 54 17 means mean NNS 5684 54 18 , , , 5684 54 19 but but CC 5684 54 20 I -PRON- PRP 5684 54 21 can can MD 5684 54 22 not not RB 5684 54 23 be be VB 5684 54 24 forced force VBN 5684 54 25 to to TO 5684 54 26 have have VB 5684 54 27 an an DT 5684 54 28 end end NN 5684 54 29 ; ; : 5684 54 30 I -PRON- PRP 5684 54 31 can can MD 5684 54 32 only only RB 5684 54 33 make make VB 5684 54 34 something something NN 5684 54 35 an an DT 5684 54 36 end end NN 5684 54 37 to to IN 5684 54 38 myself -PRON- PRP 5684 54 39 . . . 5684 55 1 If if IN 5684 55 2 , , , 5684 55 3 however however RB 5684 55 4 , , , 5684 55 5 I -PRON- PRP 5684 55 6 am be VBP 5684 55 7 also also RB 5684 55 8 bound bind VBN 5684 55 9 to to TO 5684 55 10 make make VB 5684 55 11 something something NN 5684 55 12 which which WDT 5684 55 13 lies lie VBZ 5684 55 14 in in IN 5684 55 15 the the DT 5684 55 16 notions notion NNS 5684 55 17 of of IN 5684 55 18 practical practical JJ 5684 55 19 reason reason NN 5684 55 20 an an DT 5684 55 21 end end NN 5684 55 22 to to IN 5684 55 23 myself -PRON- PRP 5684 55 24 , , , 5684 55 25 and and CC 5684 55 26 therefore therefore RB 5684 55 27 besides besides IN 5684 55 28 the the DT 5684 55 29 formal formal JJ 5684 55 30 determining determine VBG 5684 55 31 principle principle NN 5684 55 32 of of IN 5684 55 33 the the DT 5684 55 34 elective elective NN 5684 55 35 will will NN 5684 55 36 ( ( -LRB- 5684 55 37 as as IN 5684 55 38 contained contain VBN 5684 55 39 in in IN 5684 55 40 law law NN 5684 55 41 ) ) -RRB- 5684 55 42 to to TO 5684 55 43 have have VB 5684 55 44 also also RB 5684 55 45 a a DT 5684 55 46 material material JJ 5684 55 47 principle principle NN 5684 55 48 , , , 5684 55 49 an an DT 5684 55 50 end end NN 5684 55 51 which which WDT 5684 55 52 can can MD 5684 55 53 be be VB 5684 55 54 opposed oppose VBN 5684 55 55 to to IN 5684 55 56 the the DT 5684 55 57 end end NN 5684 55 58 derived derive VBN 5684 55 59 from from IN 5684 55 60 sensible sensible JJ 5684 55 61 impulses impulse NNS 5684 55 62 ; ; : 5684 55 63 then then RB 5684 55 64 this this DT 5684 55 65 gives give VBZ 5684 55 66 the the DT 5684 55 67 notion notion NN 5684 55 68 of of IN 5684 55 69 an an DT 5684 55 70 end end NN 5684 55 71 which which WDT 5684 55 72 is be VBZ 5684 55 73 in in IN 5684 55 74 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 55 75 a a DT 5684 55 76 duty duty NN 5684 55 77 . . . 5684 56 1 The the DT 5684 56 2 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 56 3 of of IN 5684 56 4 this this DT 5684 56 5 can can MD 5684 56 6 not not RB 5684 56 7 belong belong VB 5684 56 8 to to IN 5684 56 9 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 56 10 , , , 5684 56 11 but but CC 5684 56 12 to to IN 5684 56 13 ethics ethic NNS 5684 56 14 , , , 5684 56 15 since since IN 5684 56 16 this this DT 5684 56 17 alone alone RB 5684 56 18 includes include VBZ 5684 56 19 in in IN 5684 56 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 56 21 conception conception NN 5684 56 22 self self NN 5684 56 23 - - HYPH 5684 56 24 constraint constraint NN 5684 56 25 according accord VBG 5684 56 26 to to IN 5684 56 27 moral moral JJ 5684 56 28 laws law NNS 5684 56 29 . . . 5684 57 1 For for IN 5684 57 2 this this DT 5684 57 3 reason reason NN 5684 57 4 , , , 5684 57 5 ethics ethic NNS 5684 57 6 may may MD 5684 57 7 also also RB 5684 57 8 be be VB 5684 57 9 defined define VBN 5684 57 10 as as IN 5684 57 11 the the DT 5684 57 12 system system NN 5684 57 13 of of IN 5684 57 14 the the DT 5684 57 15 ends end NNS 5684 57 16 of of IN 5684 57 17 the the DT 5684 57 18 pure pure JJ 5684 57 19 practical practical JJ 5684 57 20 reason reason NN 5684 57 21 . . . 5684 58 1 The the DT 5684 58 2 two two CD 5684 58 3 parts part NNS 5684 58 4 of of IN 5684 58 5 moral moral JJ 5684 58 6 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 58 7 are be VBP 5684 58 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 5684 58 9 as as IN 5684 58 10 treating treat VBG 5684 58 11 respectively respectively RB 5684 58 12 of of IN 5684 58 13 ends end NNS 5684 58 14 and and CC 5684 58 15 of of IN 5684 58 16 duties duty NNS 5684 58 17 of of IN 5684 58 18 constraint constraint NN 5684 58 19 . . . 5684 59 1 That that IN 5684 59 2 ethics ethic NNS 5684 59 3 contains contain VBZ 5684 59 4 duties duty NNS 5684 59 5 to to IN 5684 59 6 the the DT 5684 59 7 observance observance NN 5684 59 8 of of IN 5684 59 9 which which WDT 5684 59 10 one one PRP 5684 59 11 can can MD 5684 59 12 not not RB 5684 59 13 be be VB 5684 59 14 ( ( -LRB- 5684 59 15 physically physically RB 5684 59 16 ) ) -RRB- 5684 59 17 forced force VBN 5684 59 18 by by IN 5684 59 19 others other NNS 5684 59 20 , , , 5684 59 21 is be VBZ 5684 59 22 merely merely RB 5684 59 23 the the DT 5684 59 24 consequence consequence NN 5684 59 25 of of IN 5684 59 26 this this DT 5684 59 27 , , , 5684 59 28 that that IN 5684 59 29 it -PRON- PRP 5684 59 30 is be VBZ 5684 59 31 a a DT 5684 59 32 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 59 33 of of IN 5684 59 34 ends end NNS 5684 59 35 , , , 5684 59 36 since since IN 5684 59 37 to to TO 5684 59 38 be be VB 5684 59 39 forced force VBN 5684 59 40 to to TO 5684 59 41 have have VB 5684 59 42 ends end NNS 5684 59 43 or or CC 5684 59 44 to to TO 5684 59 45 set set VB 5684 59 46 them -PRON- PRP 5684 59 47 before before IN 5684 59 48 one one PRP 5684 59 49 's 's POS 5684 59 50 self self NN 5684 59 51 is be VBZ 5684 59 52 a a DT 5684 59 53 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 59 54 . . . 5684 60 1 Now now RB 5684 60 2 that that IN 5684 60 3 ethics ethic NNS 5684 60 4 is be VBZ 5684 60 5 a a DT 5684 60 6 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 60 7 of of IN 5684 60 8 virtue virtue NN 5684 60 9 ( ( -LRB- 5684 60 10 doctrina doctrina NNP 5684 60 11 officiorum officiorum NNP 5684 60 12 virtutis virtutis NN 5684 60 13 ) ) -RRB- 5684 60 14 follows follow VBZ 5684 60 15 from from IN 5684 60 16 the the DT 5684 60 17 definition definition NN 5684 60 18 of of IN 5684 60 19 virtue virtue NN 5684 60 20 given give VBN 5684 60 21 above above RB 5684 60 22 compared compare VBN 5684 60 23 with with IN 5684 60 24 the the DT 5684 60 25 obligation obligation NN 5684 60 26 , , , 5684 60 27 the the DT 5684 60 28 peculiarity peculiarity NN 5684 60 29 of of IN 5684 60 30 which which WDT 5684 60 31 has have VBZ 5684 60 32 just just RB 5684 60 33 been be VBN 5684 60 34 shown show VBN 5684 60 35 . . . 5684 61 1 There there EX 5684 61 2 is be VBZ 5684 61 3 in in IN 5684 61 4 fact fact NN 5684 61 5 no no DT 5684 61 6 other other JJ 5684 61 7 determination determination NN 5684 61 8 of of IN 5684 61 9 the the DT 5684 61 10 elective elective NN 5684 61 11 will will MD 5684 61 12 , , , 5684 61 13 except except IN 5684 61 14 that that IN 5684 61 15 to to IN 5684 61 16 an an DT 5684 61 17 end end NN 5684 61 18 , , , 5684 61 19 which which WDT 5684 61 20 in in IN 5684 61 21 the the DT 5684 61 22 very very JJ 5684 61 23 notion notion NN 5684 61 24 of of IN 5684 61 25 it -PRON- PRP 5684 61 26 implies imply VBZ 5684 61 27 that that IN 5684 61 28 I -PRON- PRP 5684 61 29 can can MD 5684 61 30 not not RB 5684 61 31 even even RB 5684 61 32 physically physically RB 5684 61 33 be be VB 5684 61 34 forced force VBN 5684 61 35 to to IN 5684 61 36 it -PRON- PRP 5684 61 37 by by IN 5684 61 38 the the DT 5684 61 39 elective elective NN 5684 61 40 will will NN 5684 61 41 of of IN 5684 61 42 others other NNS 5684 61 43 . . . 5684 62 1 Another another DT 5684 62 2 may may MD 5684 62 3 indeed indeed RB 5684 62 4 force force VB 5684 62 5 me -PRON- PRP 5684 62 6 to to TO 5684 62 7 do do VB 5684 62 8 something something NN 5684 62 9 which which WDT 5684 62 10 is be VBZ 5684 62 11 not not RB 5684 62 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 62 13 end end NN 5684 62 14 ( ( -LRB- 5684 62 15 but but CC 5684 62 16 only only RB 5684 62 17 means mean VBZ 5684 62 18 to to IN 5684 62 19 the the DT 5684 62 20 end end NN 5684 62 21 of of IN 5684 62 22 another another DT 5684 62 23 ) ) -RRB- 5684 62 24 , , , 5684 62 25 but but CC 5684 62 26 he -PRON- PRP 5684 62 27 can can MD 5684 62 28 not not RB 5684 62 29 force force VB 5684 62 30 me -PRON- PRP 5684 62 31 to to TO 5684 62 32 make make VB 5684 62 33 it -PRON- PRP 5684 62 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 62 35 own own JJ 5684 62 36 end end NN 5684 62 37 , , , 5684 62 38 and and CC 5684 62 39 yet yet RB 5684 62 40 I -PRON- PRP 5684 62 41 can can MD 5684 62 42 have have VB 5684 62 43 no no DT 5684 62 44 end end NN 5684 62 45 except except IN 5684 62 46 of of IN 5684 62 47 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 62 48 own own JJ 5684 62 49 making making NN 5684 62 50 . . . 5684 63 1 The the DT 5684 63 2 latter latter JJ 5684 63 3 supposition supposition NN 5684 63 4 would would MD 5684 63 5 be be VB 5684 63 6 a a DT 5684 63 7 contradiction- contradiction- NN 5684 63 8 an an DT 5684 63 9 act act NN 5684 63 10 of of IN 5684 63 11 freedom freedom NN 5684 63 12 which which WDT 5684 63 13 yet yet RB 5684 63 14 at at IN 5684 63 15 the the DT 5684 63 16 same same JJ 5684 63 17 time time NN 5684 63 18 would would MD 5684 63 19 not not RB 5684 63 20 be be VB 5684 63 21 free free JJ 5684 63 22 . . . 5684 64 1 But but CC 5684 64 2 there there EX 5684 64 3 is be VBZ 5684 64 4 no no DT 5684 64 5 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 64 6 in in IN 5684 64 7 setting set VBG 5684 64 8 before before IN 5684 64 9 one one PRP 5684 64 10 's 's POS 5684 64 11 self self NN 5684 64 12 an an DT 5684 64 13 end end NN 5684 64 14 which which WDT 5684 64 15 is be VBZ 5684 64 16 also also RB 5684 64 17 a a DT 5684 64 18 duty duty NN 5684 64 19 : : : 5684 64 20 for for IN 5684 64 21 in in IN 5684 64 22 this this DT 5684 64 23 case case NN 5684 64 24 I -PRON- PRP 5684 64 25 constrain constrain VBP 5684 64 26 myself -PRON- PRP 5684 64 27 , , , 5684 64 28 and and CC 5684 64 29 this this DT 5684 64 30 is be VBZ 5684 64 31 quite quite RB 5684 64 32 consistent consistent JJ 5684 64 33 with with IN 5684 64 34 freedom freedom NN 5684 64 35 . . . 5684 65 1 * * NFP 5684 65 2 But but CC 5684 65 3 how how WRB 5684 65 4 is be VBZ 5684 65 5 such such PDT 5684 65 6 an an DT 5684 65 7 end end NN 5684 65 8 possible possible JJ 5684 65 9 ? ? . 5684 66 1 That that DT 5684 66 2 is be VBZ 5684 66 3 now now RB 5684 66 4 the the DT 5684 66 5 question question NN 5684 66 6 . . . 5684 67 1 For for IN 5684 67 2 the the DT 5684 67 3 possibility possibility NN 5684 67 4 of of IN 5684 67 5 the the DT 5684 67 6 notion notion NN 5684 67 7 of of IN 5684 67 8 the the DT 5684 67 9 thing thing NN 5684 67 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 67 11 viz viz NNP 5684 67 12 . . NNP 5684 67 13 , , , 5684 67 14 that that IN 5684 67 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 67 16 is be VBZ 5684 67 17 not not RB 5684 67 18 self self NN 5684 67 19 - - HYPH 5684 67 20 contradictory contradictory JJ 5684 67 21 ) ) -RRB- 5684 67 22 is be VBZ 5684 67 23 not not RB 5684 67 24 enough enough JJ 5684 67 25 to to TO 5684 67 26 prove prove VB 5684 67 27 the the DT 5684 67 28 possibility possibility NN 5684 67 29 of of IN 5684 67 30 the the DT 5684 67 31 thing thing NN 5684 67 32 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 67 33 ( ( -LRB- 5684 67 34 the the DT 5684 67 35 objective objective JJ 5684 67 36 reality reality NN 5684 67 37 of of IN 5684 67 38 the the DT 5684 67 39 notion notion NN 5684 67 40 ) ) -RRB- 5684 67 41 . . . 5684 68 1 { { -LRB- 5684 68 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 68 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 68 4 15 15 CD 5684 68 5 } } -RRB- 5684 68 6 * * NFP 5684 68 7 The the DT 5684 68 8 less less RBR 5684 68 9 a a DT 5684 68 10 man man NN 5684 68 11 can can MD 5684 68 12 be be VB 5684 68 13 physically physically RB 5684 68 14 forced force VBN 5684 68 15 , , , 5684 68 16 and and CC 5684 68 17 the the DT 5684 68 18 more more JJR 5684 68 19 he -PRON- PRP 5684 68 20 can can MD 5684 68 21 be be VB 5684 68 22 morally morally RB 5684 68 23 forced force VBN 5684 68 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 68 25 by by IN 5684 68 26 the the DT 5684 68 27 mere mere JJ 5684 68 28 idea idea NN 5684 68 29 of of IN 5684 68 30 duty duty NN 5684 68 31 ) ) -RRB- 5684 68 32 , , , 5684 68 33 so so RB 5684 68 34 much much RB 5684 68 35 the the DT 5684 68 36 freer freer NN 5684 68 37 he -PRON- PRP 5684 68 38 is be VBZ 5684 68 39 . . . 5684 69 1 The the DT 5684 69 2 man man NN 5684 69 3 , , , 5684 69 4 for for IN 5684 69 5 example example NN 5684 69 6 , , , 5684 69 7 who who WP 5684 69 8 is be VBZ 5684 69 9 of of IN 5684 69 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 5684 69 11 firm firm JJ 5684 69 12 resolution resolution NN 5684 69 13 and and CC 5684 69 14 strong strong JJ 5684 69 15 mind mind NN 5684 69 16 not not RB 5684 69 17 to to TO 5684 69 18 give give VB 5684 69 19 up up RP 5684 69 20 an an DT 5684 69 21 enjoyment enjoyment NN 5684 69 22 which which WDT 5684 69 23 he -PRON- PRP 5684 69 24 has have VBZ 5684 69 25 resolved resolve VBN 5684 69 26 on on IN 5684 69 27 , , , 5684 69 28 however however RB 5684 69 29 much much JJ 5684 69 30 loss loss NN 5684 69 31 is be VBZ 5684 69 32 shown show VBN 5684 69 33 as as IN 5684 69 34 resulting result VBG 5684 69 35 therefrom therefrom NN 5684 69 36 , , , 5684 69 37 and and CC 5684 69 38 who who WP 5684 69 39 yet yet RB 5684 69 40 desists desist VBZ 5684 69 41 from from IN 5684 69 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 69 43 purpose purpose NN 5684 69 44 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 5684 69 45 , , , 5684 69 46 though though IN 5684 69 47 very very RB 5684 69 48 reluctantly reluctantly RB 5684 69 49 , , , 5684 69 50 when when WRB 5684 69 51 he -PRON- PRP 5684 69 52 finds find VBZ 5684 69 53 that that IN 5684 69 54 it -PRON- PRP 5684 69 55 would would MD 5684 69 56 cause cause VB 5684 69 57 him -PRON- PRP 5684 69 58 to to TO 5684 69 59 neglect neglect VB 5684 69 60 an an DT 5684 69 61 official official JJ 5684 69 62 duty duty NN 5684 69 63 or or CC 5684 69 64 a a DT 5684 69 65 sick sick JJ 5684 69 66 father father NN 5684 69 67 ; ; : 5684 69 68 this this DT 5684 69 69 man man NN 5684 69 70 proves prove VBZ 5684 69 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 69 72 freedom freedom NN 5684 69 73 in in IN 5684 69 74 the the DT 5684 69 75 highest high JJS 5684 69 76 degree degree NN 5684 69 77 by by IN 5684 69 78 this this DT 5684 69 79 very very JJ 5684 69 80 thing thing NN 5684 69 81 , , , 5684 69 82 that that IN 5684 69 83 he -PRON- PRP 5684 69 84 can can MD 5684 69 85 not not RB 5684 69 86 resist resist VB 5684 69 87 the the DT 5684 69 88 voice voice NN 5684 69 89 of of IN 5684 69 90 duty duty NN 5684 69 91 . . . 5684 70 1 II ii CD 5684 70 2 . . . 5684 71 1 Exposition exposition NN 5684 71 2 of of IN 5684 71 3 the the DT 5684 71 4 Notion Notion NNP 5684 71 5 of of IN 5684 71 6 an an DT 5684 71 7 End end NN 5684 71 8 which which WDT 5684 71 9 is be VBZ 5684 71 10 also also RB 5684 71 11 a a DT 5684 71 12 Duty duty NN 5684 71 13 We -PRON- PRP 5684 71 14 can can MD 5684 71 15 conceive conceive VB 5684 71 16 the the DT 5684 71 17 relation relation NN 5684 71 18 of of IN 5684 71 19 end end NN 5684 71 20 to to IN 5684 71 21 duty duty NN 5684 71 22 in in IN 5684 71 23 two two CD 5684 71 24 ways way NNS 5684 71 25 ; ; : 5684 71 26 either either CC 5684 71 27 starting start VBG 5684 71 28 from from IN 5684 71 29 the the DT 5684 71 30 end end NN 5684 71 31 to to TO 5684 71 32 find find VB 5684 71 33 the the DT 5684 71 34 maxim maxim NN 5684 71 35 of of IN 5684 71 36 the the DT 5684 71 37 dutiful dutiful JJ 5684 71 38 actions action NNS 5684 71 39 ; ; : 5684 71 40 or or CC 5684 71 41 conversely conversely RB 5684 71 42 , , , 5684 71 43 setting set VBG 5684 71 44 out out RP 5684 71 45 from from IN 5684 71 46 this this DT 5684 71 47 to to TO 5684 71 48 find find VB 5684 71 49 the the DT 5684 71 50 end end NN 5684 71 51 which which WDT 5684 71 52 is be VBZ 5684 71 53 also also RB 5684 71 54 duty duty NN 5684 71 55 . . . 5684 72 1 Jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 72 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 5684 72 3 in in IN 5684 72 4 the the DT 5684 72 5 former former JJ 5684 72 6 way way NN 5684 72 7 . . . 5684 73 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 73 2 is be VBZ 5684 73 3 left leave VBN 5684 73 4 to to IN 5684 73 5 everyone everyone NN 5684 73 6 's 's POS 5684 73 7 free free JJ 5684 73 8 elective elective NN 5684 73 9 will will MD 5684 73 10 what what WP 5684 73 11 end end VB 5684 73 12 he -PRON- PRP 5684 73 13 will will MD 5684 73 14 choose choose VB 5684 73 15 for for IN 5684 73 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 73 17 action action NN 5684 73 18 . . . 5684 74 1 But but CC 5684 74 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 74 3 maxim maxim NN 5684 74 4 is be VBZ 5684 74 5 determined determine VBN 5684 74 6 a a DT 5684 74 7 priori priori NN 5684 74 8 ; ; : 5684 74 9 namely namely RB 5684 74 10 , , , 5684 74 11 that that IN 5684 74 12 the the DT 5684 74 13 freedom freedom NN 5684 74 14 of of IN 5684 74 15 the the DT 5684 74 16 agent agent NN 5684 74 17 must must MD 5684 74 18 be be VB 5684 74 19 consistent consistent JJ 5684 74 20 with with IN 5684 74 21 the the DT 5684 74 22 freedom freedom NN 5684 74 23 of of IN 5684 74 24 every every DT 5684 74 25 other other JJ 5684 74 26 according accord VBG 5684 74 27 to to IN 5684 74 28 a a DT 5684 74 29 universal universal JJ 5684 74 30 law law NN 5684 74 31 . . . 5684 75 1 { { -LRB- 5684 75 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 75 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 75 4 20 20 CD 5684 75 5 } } -RRB- 5684 75 6 Ethics Ethics NNP 5684 75 7 , , , 5684 75 8 however however RB 5684 75 9 , , , 5684 75 10 proceeds proceed VBZ 5684 75 11 in in IN 5684 75 12 the the DT 5684 75 13 opposite opposite JJ 5684 75 14 way way NN 5684 75 15 . . . 5684 76 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 76 2 can can MD 5684 76 3 not not RB 5684 76 4 start start VB 5684 76 5 from from IN 5684 76 6 the the DT 5684 76 7 ends end NNS 5684 76 8 which which WDT 5684 76 9 the the DT 5684 76 10 man man NN 5684 76 11 may may MD 5684 76 12 propose propose VB 5684 76 13 to to IN 5684 76 14 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 76 15 , , , 5684 76 16 and and CC 5684 76 17 hence hence RB 5684 76 18 give give VB 5684 76 19 directions direction NNS 5684 76 20 as as IN 5684 76 21 to to IN 5684 76 22 the the DT 5684 76 23 maxims maxim NNS 5684 76 24 he -PRON- PRP 5684 76 25 should should MD 5684 76 26 adopt adopt VB 5684 76 27 , , , 5684 76 28 that that RB 5684 76 29 is is RB 5684 76 30 , , , 5684 76 31 as as IN 5684 76 32 to to IN 5684 76 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 76 34 duty duty NN 5684 76 35 ; ; : 5684 76 36 for for IN 5684 76 37 that that DT 5684 76 38 would would MD 5684 76 39 be be VB 5684 76 40 to to TO 5684 76 41 take take VB 5684 76 42 empirical empirical JJ 5684 76 43 principles principle NNS 5684 76 44 of of IN 5684 76 45 maxims maxim NNS 5684 76 46 , , , 5684 76 47 and and CC 5684 76 48 these these DT 5684 76 49 could could MD 5684 76 50 not not RB 5684 76 51 give give VB 5684 76 52 any any DT 5684 76 53 notion notion NN 5684 76 54 of of IN 5684 76 55 duty duty NN 5684 76 56 ; ; : 5684 76 57 since since IN 5684 76 58 this this DT 5684 76 59 , , , 5684 76 60 the the DT 5684 76 61 categorical categorical JJ 5684 76 62 ought ought NN 5684 76 63 , , , 5684 76 64 has have VBZ 5684 76 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 76 66 root root NN 5684 76 67 in in IN 5684 76 68 pure pure JJ 5684 76 69 reason reason NN 5684 76 70 alone alone RB 5684 76 71 . . . 5684 77 1 Indeed indeed RB 5684 77 2 , , , 5684 77 3 if if IN 5684 77 4 the the DT 5684 77 5 maxims maxim NNS 5684 77 6 were be VBD 5684 77 7 to to TO 5684 77 8 be be VB 5684 77 9 adopted adopt VBN 5684 77 10 in in IN 5684 77 11 accordance accordance NN 5684 77 12 with with IN 5684 77 13 those those DT 5684 77 14 ends end NNS 5684 77 15 ( ( -LRB- 5684 77 16 which which WDT 5684 77 17 are be VBP 5684 77 18 all all DT 5684 77 19 selfish selfish JJ 5684 77 20 ) ) -RRB- 5684 77 21 , , , 5684 77 22 we -PRON- PRP 5684 77 23 could could MD 5684 77 24 not not RB 5684 77 25 properly properly RB 5684 77 26 speak speak VB 5684 77 27 of of IN 5684 77 28 the the DT 5684 77 29 notion notion NN 5684 77 30 of of IN 5684 77 31 duty duty NN 5684 77 32 at at RB 5684 77 33 all all RB 5684 77 34 . . . 5684 78 1 Hence hence RB 5684 78 2 in in IN 5684 78 3 ethics ethic NNS 5684 78 4 the the DT 5684 78 5 notion notion NN 5684 78 6 of of IN 5684 78 7 duty duty NN 5684 78 8 must must MD 5684 78 9 lead lead VB 5684 78 10 to to IN 5684 78 11 ends end NNS 5684 78 12 , , , 5684 78 13 and and CC 5684 78 14 must must MD 5684 78 15 on on IN 5684 78 16 moral moral JJ 5684 78 17 principles principle NNS 5684 78 18 give give VBP 5684 78 19 the the DT 5684 78 20 foundation foundation NN 5684 78 21 of of IN 5684 78 22 maxims maxim NNS 5684 78 23 with with IN 5684 78 24 respect respect NN 5684 78 25 to to IN 5684 78 26 the the DT 5684 78 27 ends end NNS 5684 78 28 which which WDT 5684 78 29 we -PRON- PRP 5684 78 30 ought ought MD 5684 78 31 to to TO 5684 78 32 propose propose VB 5684 78 33 to to IN 5684 78 34 ourselves -PRON- PRP 5684 78 35 . . . 5684 79 1 Setting set VBG 5684 79 2 aside aside RP 5684 79 3 the the DT 5684 79 4 question question NN 5684 79 5 what what WDT 5684 79 6 sort sort NN 5684 79 7 of of IN 5684 79 8 end end NN 5684 79 9 that that WDT 5684 79 10 is be VBZ 5684 79 11 which which WDT 5684 79 12 is be VBZ 5684 79 13 in in IN 5684 79 14 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 79 15 a a DT 5684 79 16 duty duty NN 5684 79 17 , , , 5684 79 18 and and CC 5684 79 19 how how WRB 5684 79 20 such such PDT 5684 79 21 an an DT 5684 79 22 end end NN 5684 79 23 is be VBZ 5684 79 24 possible possible JJ 5684 79 25 , , , 5684 79 26 it -PRON- PRP 5684 79 27 is be VBZ 5684 79 28 here here RB 5684 79 29 only only RB 5684 79 30 necessary necessary JJ 5684 79 31 to to TO 5684 79 32 show show VB 5684 79 33 that that IN 5684 79 34 a a DT 5684 79 35 duty duty NN 5684 79 36 of of IN 5684 79 37 this this DT 5684 79 38 kind kind NN 5684 79 39 is be VBZ 5684 79 40 called call VBN 5684 79 41 a a DT 5684 79 42 duty duty NN 5684 79 43 of of IN 5684 79 44 virtue virtue NN 5684 79 45 , , , 5684 79 46 and and CC 5684 79 47 why why WRB 5684 79 48 it -PRON- PRP 5684 79 49 is be VBZ 5684 79 50 so so RB 5684 79 51 called call VBN 5684 79 52 . . . 5684 80 1 To to IN 5684 80 2 every every DT 5684 80 3 duty duty NN 5684 80 4 corresponds correspond VBZ 5684 80 5 a a DT 5684 80 6 right right NN 5684 80 7 of of IN 5684 80 8 action action NN 5684 80 9 ( ( -LRB- 5684 80 10 facultas facultas NNP 5684 80 11 moralis moralis NNP 5684 80 12 generatim generatim VBP 5684 80 13 ) ) -RRB- 5684 80 14 , , , 5684 80 15 but but CC 5684 80 16 all all DT 5684 80 17 duties duty NNS 5684 80 18 do do VBP 5684 80 19 not not RB 5684 80 20 imply imply VB 5684 80 21 a a DT 5684 80 22 corresponding corresponding JJ 5684 80 23 right right NN 5684 80 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 80 25 facultas facultas NNP 5684 80 26 juridica juridica NNP 5684 80 27 ) ) -RRB- 5684 80 28 of of IN 5684 80 29 another another DT 5684 80 30 to to TO 5684 80 31 compel compel VB 5684 80 32 anyone anyone NN 5684 80 33 , , , 5684 80 34 but but CC 5684 80 35 only only RB 5684 80 36 the the DT 5684 80 37 duties duty NNS 5684 80 38 called call VBD 5684 80 39 legal legal JJ 5684 80 40 duties duty NNS 5684 80 41 . . . 5684 81 1 Similarly similarly RB 5684 81 2 to to IN 5684 81 3 all all DT 5684 81 4 ethical ethical JJ 5684 81 5 obligation obligation NN 5684 81 6 corresponds correspond VBZ 5684 81 7 the the DT 5684 81 8 notion notion NN 5684 81 9 of of IN 5684 81 10 virtue virtue NN 5684 81 11 , , , 5684 81 12 but but CC 5684 81 13 it -PRON- PRP 5684 81 14 does do VBZ 5684 81 15 not not RB 5684 81 16 follow follow VB 5684 81 17 that that IN 5684 81 18 all all DT 5684 81 19 ethical ethical JJ 5684 81 20 duties duty NNS 5684 81 21 are be VBP 5684 81 22 duties duty NNS 5684 81 23 of of IN 5684 81 24 virtue virtue NN 5684 81 25 . . . 5684 82 1 Those those DT 5684 82 2 , , , 5684 82 3 in in IN 5684 82 4 fact fact NN 5684 82 5 , , , 5684 82 6 are be VBP 5684 82 7 not not RB 5684 82 8 so so RB 5684 82 9 which which WDT 5684 82 10 do do VBP 5684 82 11 not not RB 5684 82 12 concern concern VB 5684 82 13 so so RB 5684 82 14 much much RB 5684 82 15 a a DT 5684 82 16 certain certain JJ 5684 82 17 end end NN 5684 82 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 82 19 matter matter NN 5684 82 20 , , , 5684 82 21 object object NN 5684 82 22 of of IN 5684 82 23 the the DT 5684 82 24 elective elective NN 5684 82 25 will will NN 5684 82 26 ) ) -RRB- 5684 82 27 , , , 5684 82 28 but but CC 5684 82 29 merely merely RB 5684 82 30 that that DT 5684 82 31 which which WDT 5684 82 32 is be VBZ 5684 82 33 formal formal JJ 5684 82 34 in in IN 5684 82 35 the the DT 5684 82 36 moral moral JJ 5684 82 37 determination determination NN 5684 82 38 of of IN 5684 82 39 the the DT 5684 82 40 will will NN 5684 82 41 ( ( -LRB- 5684 82 42 e.g. e.g. RB 5684 82 43 , , , 5684 82 44 that that IN 5684 82 45 the the DT 5684 82 46 dutiful dutiful JJ 5684 82 47 action action NN 5684 82 48 must must MD 5684 82 49 also also RB 5684 82 50 be be VB 5684 82 51 done do VBN 5684 82 52 from from IN 5684 82 53 duty duty NN 5684 82 54 ) ) -RRB- 5684 82 55 . . . 5684 83 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 83 2 is be VBZ 5684 83 3 only only RB 5684 83 4 an an DT 5684 83 5 end end NN 5684 83 6 which which WDT 5684 83 7 is be VBZ 5684 83 8 also also RB 5684 83 9 duty duty NN 5684 83 10 that that WDT 5684 83 11 can can MD 5684 83 12 be be VB 5684 83 13 called call VBN 5684 83 14 a a DT 5684 83 15 duty duty NN 5684 83 16 of of IN 5684 83 17 virtue virtue NN 5684 83 18 . . . 5684 84 1 Hence hence RB 5684 84 2 there there EX 5684 84 3 are be VBP 5684 84 4 several several JJ 5684 84 5 of of IN 5684 84 6 the the DT 5684 84 7 latter latter JJ 5684 84 8 kind kind NN 5684 84 9 ( ( -LRB- 5684 84 10 and and CC 5684 84 11 thus thus RB 5684 84 12 there there EX 5684 84 13 are be VBP 5684 84 14 distinct distinct JJ 5684 84 15 virtues virtue NNS 5684 84 16 ) ) -RRB- 5684 84 17 ; ; : 5684 84 18 on on IN 5684 84 19 the the DT 5684 84 20 contrary contrary NN 5684 84 21 , , , 5684 84 22 there there EX 5684 84 23 is be VBZ 5684 84 24 only only RB 5684 84 25 one one CD 5684 84 26 duty duty NN 5684 84 27 of of IN 5684 84 28 the the DT 5684 84 29 former former JJ 5684 84 30 kind kind NN 5684 84 31 , , , 5684 84 32 but but CC 5684 84 33 it -PRON- PRP 5684 84 34 is be VBZ 5684 84 35 one one CD 5684 84 36 which which WDT 5684 84 37 is be VBZ 5684 84 38 valid valid JJ 5684 84 39 for for IN 5684 84 40 all all DT 5684 84 41 actions action NNS 5684 84 42 ( ( -LRB- 5684 84 43 only only RB 5684 84 44 one one CD 5684 84 45 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 84 46 disposition disposition NN 5684 84 47 ) ) -RRB- 5684 84 48 . . . 5684 85 1 The the DT 5684 85 2 duty duty NN 5684 85 3 of of IN 5684 85 4 virtue virtue NN 5684 85 5 is be VBZ 5684 85 6 essentially essentially RB 5684 85 7 distinguished distinguish VBN 5684 85 8 from from IN 5684 85 9 the the DT 5684 85 10 duty duty NN 5684 85 11 of of IN 5684 85 12 justice justice NN 5684 85 13 in in IN 5684 85 14 this this DT 5684 85 15 respect respect NN 5684 85 16 ; ; : 5684 85 17 that that IN 5684 85 18 it -PRON- PRP 5684 85 19 is be VBZ 5684 85 20 morally morally RB 5684 85 21 possible possible JJ 5684 85 22 to to TO 5684 85 23 be be VB 5684 85 24 externally externally RB 5684 85 25 compelled compel VBN 5684 85 26 to to IN 5684 85 27 the the DT 5684 85 28 latter latter JJ 5684 85 29 , , , 5684 85 30 whereas whereas IN 5684 85 31 the the DT 5684 85 32 former former JJ 5684 85 33 rests rest NNS 5684 85 34 on on IN 5684 85 35 free free JJ 5684 85 36 self self NN 5684 85 37 - - HYPH 5684 85 38 constraint constraint NN 5684 85 39 only only RB 5684 85 40 . . . 5684 86 1 For for IN 5684 86 2 finite finite JJ 5684 86 3 holy holy JJ 5684 86 4 beings being NNS 5684 86 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 86 6 which which WDT 5684 86 7 can can MD 5684 86 8 not not RB 5684 86 9 even even RB 5684 86 10 be be VB 5684 86 11 tempted tempt VBN 5684 86 12 to to IN 5684 86 13 the the DT 5684 86 14 violation violation NN 5684 86 15 of of IN 5684 86 16 duty duty NN 5684 86 17 ) ) -RRB- 5684 86 18 there there EX 5684 86 19 is be VBZ 5684 86 20 no no DT 5684 86 21 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 86 22 of of IN 5684 86 23 virtue virtue NN 5684 86 24 , , , 5684 86 25 but but CC 5684 86 26 only only RB 5684 86 27 moral moral JJ 5684 86 28 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 86 29 , , , 5684 86 30 the the DT 5684 86 31 latter latter NN 5684 86 32 being be VBG 5684 86 33 an an DT 5684 86 34 autonomy autonomy NN 5684 86 35 of of IN 5684 86 36 practical practical JJ 5684 86 37 reason reason NN 5684 86 38 , , , 5684 86 39 whereas whereas IN 5684 86 40 the the DT 5684 86 41 former former JJ 5684 86 42 is be VBZ 5684 86 43 also also RB 5684 86 44 an an DT 5684 86 45 autocracy autocracy NN 5684 86 46 of of IN 5684 86 47 it -PRON- PRP 5684 86 48 . . . 5684 87 1 That that RB 5684 87 2 is is RB 5684 87 3 , , , 5684 87 4 it -PRON- PRP 5684 87 5 includes include VBZ 5684 87 6 a a DT 5684 87 7 consciousness- consciousness- NN 5684 87 8 not not RB 5684 87 9 indeed indeed RB 5684 87 10 immediately immediately RB 5684 87 11 perceived perceive VBN 5684 87 12 , , , 5684 87 13 but but CC 5684 87 14 rightly rightly RB 5684 87 15 concluded conclude VBD 5684 87 16 , , , 5684 87 17 from from IN 5684 87 18 the the DT 5684 87 19 moral moral JJ 5684 87 20 categorical categorical JJ 5684 87 21 imperative- imperative- NN 5684 87 22 of of IN 5684 87 23 the the DT 5684 87 24 power power NN 5684 87 25 to to TO 5684 87 26 become become VB 5684 87 27 master master NN 5684 87 28 of of IN 5684 87 29 one one CD 5684 87 30 's 's POS 5684 87 31 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 87 32 which which WDT 5684 87 33 resist resist VBP 5684 87 34 the the DT 5684 87 35 law law NN 5684 87 36 ; ; : 5684 87 37 so so CC 5684 87 38 that that IN 5684 87 39 human human JJ 5684 87 40 morality morality NN 5684 87 41 in in IN 5684 87 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 87 43 highest high JJS 5684 87 44 stage stage NN 5684 87 45 can can MD 5684 87 46 yet yet RB 5684 87 47 be be VB 5684 87 48 nothing nothing NN 5684 87 49 more more JJR 5684 87 50 than than IN 5684 87 51 virtue virtue NN 5684 87 52 ; ; : 5684 87 53 even even RB 5684 87 54 if if IN 5684 87 55 it -PRON- PRP 5684 87 56 were be VBD 5684 87 57 quite quite RB 5684 87 58 pure pure JJ 5684 87 59 ( ( -LRB- 5684 87 60 perfectly perfectly RB 5684 87 61 free free JJ 5684 87 62 from from IN 5684 87 63 the the DT 5684 87 64 influence influence NN 5684 87 65 of of IN 5684 87 66 a a DT 5684 87 67 spring spring NN 5684 87 68 foreign foreign NN 5684 87 69 to to IN 5684 87 70 duty duty NN 5684 87 71 ) ) -RRB- 5684 87 72 , , , 5684 87 73 a a DT 5684 87 74 state state NN 5684 87 75 which which WDT 5684 87 76 is be VBZ 5684 87 77 poetically poetically RB 5684 87 78 personified personify VBN 5684 87 79 under under IN 5684 87 80 the the DT 5684 87 81 name name NN 5684 87 82 of of IN 5684 87 83 the the DT 5684 87 84 wise wise JJ 5684 87 85 man man NN 5684 87 86 ( ( -LRB- 5684 87 87 as as IN 5684 87 88 an an DT 5684 87 89 ideal ideal NN 5684 87 90 to to TO 5684 87 91 which which WDT 5684 87 92 one one PRP 5684 87 93 should should MD 5684 87 94 continually continually RB 5684 87 95 approximate approximate VB 5684 87 96 ) ) -RRB- 5684 87 97 . . . 5684 88 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 88 2 , , , 5684 88 3 however however RB 5684 88 4 , , , 5684 88 5 is be VBZ 5684 88 6 not not RB 5684 88 7 to to TO 5684 88 8 be be VB 5684 88 9 defined define VBN 5684 88 10 and and CC 5684 88 11 esteemed esteem VBN 5684 88 12 merely merely RB 5684 88 13 as as IN 5684 88 14 habit habit NN 5684 88 15 , , , 5684 88 16 and and CC 5684 88 17 ( ( -LRB- 5684 88 18 as as IN 5684 88 19 it -PRON- PRP 5684 88 20 is be VBZ 5684 88 21 expressed express VBN 5684 88 22 in in IN 5684 88 23 the the DT 5684 88 24 prize prize NN 5684 88 25 essay essay NN 5684 88 26 of of IN 5684 88 27 Cochius Cochius NNP 5684 88 28 ) ) -RRB- 5684 88 29 as as IN 5684 88 30 a a DT 5684 88 31 long long JJ 5684 88 32 custom custom NN 5684 88 33 acquired acquire VBN 5684 88 34 by by IN 5684 88 35 practice practice NN 5684 88 36 of of IN 5684 88 37 morally morally RB 5684 88 38 good good JJ 5684 88 39 actions action NNS 5684 88 40 . . . 5684 89 1 For for IN 5684 89 2 , , , 5684 89 3 if if IN 5684 89 4 this this DT 5684 89 5 is be VBZ 5684 89 6 not not RB 5684 89 7 an an DT 5684 89 8 effect effect NN 5684 89 9 of of IN 5684 89 10 well well RB 5684 89 11 - - HYPH 5684 89 12 resolved resolve VBN 5684 89 13 and and CC 5684 89 14 firm firm JJ 5684 89 15 principles principle NNS 5684 89 16 ever ever RB 5684 89 17 more more RBR 5684 89 18 and and CC 5684 89 19 more more RBR 5684 89 20 purified purify VBN 5684 89 21 , , , 5684 89 22 then then RB 5684 89 23 , , , 5684 89 24 like like IN 5684 89 25 any any DT 5684 89 26 other other JJ 5684 89 27 mechanical mechanical JJ 5684 89 28 arrangement arrangement NN 5684 89 29 brought bring VBN 5684 89 30 about about RP 5684 89 31 by by IN 5684 89 32 technical technical JJ 5684 89 33 practical practical JJ 5684 89 34 reason reason NN 5684 89 35 , , , 5684 89 36 it -PRON- PRP 5684 89 37 is be VBZ 5684 89 38 neither neither CC 5684 89 39 armed arm VBN 5684 89 40 for for IN 5684 89 41 all all DT 5684 89 42 circumstances circumstance NNS 5684 89 43 nor nor CC 5684 89 44 adequately adequately RB 5684 89 45 secured secure VBN 5684 89 46 against against IN 5684 89 47 the the DT 5684 89 48 change change NN 5684 89 49 that that WDT 5684 89 50 may may MD 5684 89 51 be be VB 5684 89 52 wrought work VBN 5684 89 53 by by IN 5684 89 54 new new JJ 5684 89 55 allurements allurement NNS 5684 89 56 . . . 5684 90 1 { { -LRB- 5684 90 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 90 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 90 4 25 25 CD 5684 90 5 } } -RRB- 5684 90 6 REMARK REMARK NNP 5684 90 7 To to TO 5684 90 8 virtue virtue VB 5684 90 9 = = NNS 5684 90 10 + + CC 5684 90 11 a a DT 5684 90 12 is be VBZ 5684 90 13 opposed oppose VBN 5684 90 14 as as IN 5684 90 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 90 16 logical logical JJ 5684 90 17 contradictory contradictory JJ 5684 90 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 90 19 contradictorie contradictorie NNP 5684 90 20 oppositum oppositum NN 5684 90 21 ) ) -RRB- 5684 90 22 the the DT 5684 90 23 negative negative JJ 5684 90 24 lack lack NN 5684 90 25 of of IN 5684 90 26 virtue virtue JJ 5684 90 27 ( ( -LRB- 5684 90 28 moral moral JJ 5684 90 29 weakness weakness NN 5684 90 30 ) ) -RRB- 5684 90 31 = = SYM 5684 90 32 0 0 CD 5684 90 33 ; ; : 5684 90 34 but but CC 5684 90 35 vice vice NN 5684 90 36 = = SYM 5684 90 37 - - : 5684 90 38 a a FW 5684 90 39 is be VBZ 5684 90 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 90 41 contrary contrary NN 5684 90 42 ( ( -LRB- 5684 90 43 contrarie contrarie NNP 5684 90 44 s. s. NNP 5684 90 45 realiter realit JJR 5684 90 46 oppositum oppositum NN 5684 90 47 ) ) -RRB- 5684 90 48 ; ; : 5684 90 49 and and CC 5684 90 50 it -PRON- PRP 5684 90 51 is be VBZ 5684 90 52 not not RB 5684 90 53 merely merely RB 5684 90 54 a a DT 5684 90 55 needless needless JJ 5684 90 56 question question NN 5684 90 57 but but CC 5684 90 58 an an DT 5684 90 59 offensive offensive JJ 5684 90 60 one one NN 5684 90 61 to to TO 5684 90 62 ask ask VB 5684 90 63 whether whether IN 5684 90 64 great great JJ 5684 90 65 crimes crime NNS 5684 90 66 do do VBP 5684 90 67 not not RB 5684 90 68 perhaps perhaps RB 5684 90 69 demand demand VB 5684 90 70 more more JJR 5684 90 71 strength strength NN 5684 90 72 of of IN 5684 90 73 mind mind NN 5684 90 74 than than IN 5684 90 75 great great JJ 5684 90 76 virtues virtue NNS 5684 90 77 . . . 5684 91 1 For for IN 5684 91 2 by by IN 5684 91 3 strength strength NN 5684 91 4 of of IN 5684 91 5 mind mind NN 5684 91 6 we -PRON- PRP 5684 91 7 understand understand VBP 5684 91 8 the the DT 5684 91 9 strength strength NN 5684 91 10 of of IN 5684 91 11 purpose purpose NN 5684 91 12 of of IN 5684 91 13 a a DT 5684 91 14 man man NN 5684 91 15 , , , 5684 91 16 as as IN 5684 91 17 a a DT 5684 91 18 being be VBG 5684 91 19 endowed endow VBN 5684 91 20 with with IN 5684 91 21 freedom freedom NN 5684 91 22 , , , 5684 91 23 and and CC 5684 91 24 consequently consequently RB 5684 91 25 so so RB 5684 91 26 far far RB 5684 91 27 as as IN 5684 91 28 he -PRON- PRP 5684 91 29 is be VBZ 5684 91 30 master master NN 5684 91 31 of of IN 5684 91 32 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 91 33 ( ( -LRB- 5684 91 34 in in IN 5684 91 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 91 36 senses sense NNS 5684 91 37 ) ) -RRB- 5684 91 38 and and CC 5684 91 39 therefore therefore RB 5684 91 40 in in IN 5684 91 41 a a DT 5684 91 42 healthy healthy JJ 5684 91 43 condition condition NN 5684 91 44 of of IN 5684 91 45 mind mind NN 5684 91 46 . . . 5684 92 1 But but CC 5684 92 2 great great JJ 5684 92 3 crimes crime NNS 5684 92 4 are be VBP 5684 92 5 paroxysms paroxysm NNS 5684 92 6 , , , 5684 92 7 the the DT 5684 92 8 very very JJ 5684 92 9 sight sight NN 5684 92 10 of of IN 5684 92 11 which which WDT 5684 92 12 makes make VBZ 5684 92 13 the the DT 5684 92 14 man man NN 5684 92 15 of of IN 5684 92 16 healthy healthy JJ 5684 92 17 mind mind NN 5684 92 18 shudder shudder NN 5684 92 19 . . . 5684 93 1 The the DT 5684 93 2 question question NN 5684 93 3 would would MD 5684 93 4 therefore therefore RB 5684 93 5 be be VB 5684 93 6 something something NN 5684 93 7 like like IN 5684 93 8 this this DT 5684 93 9 : : : 5684 93 10 whether whether IN 5684 93 11 a a DT 5684 93 12 man man NN 5684 93 13 in in IN 5684 93 14 a a DT 5684 93 15 fit fit NN 5684 93 16 of of IN 5684 93 17 madness madness NN 5684 93 18 can can MD 5684 93 19 have have VB 5684 93 20 more more JJR 5684 93 21 physical physical JJ 5684 93 22 strength strength NN 5684 93 23 than than IN 5684 93 24 if if IN 5684 93 25 he -PRON- PRP 5684 93 26 is be VBZ 5684 93 27 in in IN 5684 93 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 93 29 senses sense NNS 5684 93 30 ; ; : 5684 93 31 and and CC 5684 93 32 we -PRON- PRP 5684 93 33 may may MD 5684 93 34 admit admit VB 5684 93 35 this this DT 5684 93 36 without without IN 5684 93 37 on on IN 5684 93 38 that that DT 5684 93 39 account account NN 5684 93 40 ascribing ascribe VBG 5684 93 41 to to IN 5684 93 42 him -PRON- PRP 5684 93 43 more more JJR 5684 93 44 strength strength NN 5684 93 45 of of IN 5684 93 46 mind mind NN 5684 93 47 , , , 5684 93 48 if if IN 5684 93 49 by by IN 5684 93 50 mind mind NN 5684 93 51 we -PRON- PRP 5684 93 52 understand understand VBP 5684 93 53 the the DT 5684 93 54 vital vital JJ 5684 93 55 principle principle NN 5684 93 56 of of IN 5684 93 57 man man NN 5684 93 58 in in IN 5684 93 59 the the DT 5684 93 60 free free JJ 5684 93 61 use use NN 5684 93 62 of of IN 5684 93 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 93 64 powers power NNS 5684 93 65 . . . 5684 94 1 For for IN 5684 94 2 since since IN 5684 94 3 those those DT 5684 94 4 crimes crime NNS 5684 94 5 have have VBP 5684 94 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 94 7 ground ground NN 5684 94 8 merely merely RB 5684 94 9 in in IN 5684 94 10 the the DT 5684 94 11 power power NN 5684 94 12 of of IN 5684 94 13 the the DT 5684 94 14 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 94 15 that that WDT 5684 94 16 weaken weaken VBP 5684 94 17 reason reason NN 5684 94 18 , , , 5684 94 19 which which WDT 5684 94 20 does do VBZ 5684 94 21 not not RB 5684 94 22 prove prove VB 5684 94 23 strength strength NN 5684 94 24 of of IN 5684 94 25 mind mind NN 5684 94 26 , , , 5684 94 27 this this DT 5684 94 28 question question NN 5684 94 29 would would MD 5684 94 30 be be VB 5684 94 31 nearly nearly RB 5684 94 32 the the DT 5684 94 33 same same JJ 5684 94 34 as as IN 5684 94 35 the the DT 5684 94 36 question question NN 5684 94 37 whether whether IN 5684 94 38 a a DT 5684 94 39 man man NN 5684 94 40 in in IN 5684 94 41 a a DT 5684 94 42 fit fit NN 5684 94 43 of of IN 5684 94 44 illness illness NN 5684 94 45 can can MD 5684 94 46 show show VB 5684 94 47 more more JJR 5684 94 48 strength strength NN 5684 94 49 than than IN 5684 94 50 in in IN 5684 94 51 a a DT 5684 94 52 healthy healthy JJ 5684 94 53 condition condition NN 5684 94 54 ; ; : 5684 94 55 and and CC 5684 94 56 this this DT 5684 94 57 may may MD 5684 94 58 be be VB 5684 94 59 directly directly RB 5684 94 60 denied deny VBN 5684 94 61 , , , 5684 94 62 since since IN 5684 94 63 the the DT 5684 94 64 want want NN 5684 94 65 of of IN 5684 94 66 health health NN 5684 94 67 , , , 5684 94 68 which which WDT 5684 94 69 consists consist VBZ 5684 94 70 in in IN 5684 94 71 the the DT 5684 94 72 proper proper JJ 5684 94 73 balance balance NN 5684 94 74 of of IN 5684 94 75 all all PDT 5684 94 76 the the DT 5684 94 77 bodily bodily JJ 5684 94 78 forces force NNS 5684 94 79 of of IN 5684 94 80 the the DT 5684 94 81 man man NN 5684 94 82 , , , 5684 94 83 is be VBZ 5684 94 84 a a DT 5684 94 85 weakness weakness NN 5684 94 86 in in IN 5684 94 87 the the DT 5684 94 88 system system NN 5684 94 89 of of IN 5684 94 90 these these DT 5684 94 91 forces force NNS 5684 94 92 , , , 5684 94 93 by by IN 5684 94 94 which which WDT 5684 94 95 system system NN 5684 94 96 alone alone RB 5684 94 97 we -PRON- PRP 5684 94 98 can can MD 5684 94 99 estimate estimate VB 5684 94 100 absolute absolute JJ 5684 94 101 health health NN 5684 94 102 . . . 5684 95 1 { { -LRB- 5684 95 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 95 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 95 4 30 30 CD 5684 95 5 } } -RRB- 5684 95 6 III iii CD 5684 95 7 . . . 5684 96 1 Of of IN 5684 96 2 the the DT 5684 96 3 Reason Reason NNP 5684 96 4 for for IN 5684 96 5 conceiving conceive VBG 5684 96 6 an an DT 5684 96 7 End end NN 5684 96 8 which which WDT 5684 96 9 is be VBZ 5684 96 10 also also RB 5684 96 11 a a DT 5684 96 12 Duty Duty NNP 5684 96 13 An an DT 5684 96 14 end end NN 5684 96 15 is be VBZ 5684 96 16 an an DT 5684 96 17 object object NN 5684 96 18 of of IN 5684 96 19 the the DT 5684 96 20 free free JJ 5684 96 21 elective elective NN 5684 96 22 will will MD 5684 96 23 , , , 5684 96 24 the the DT 5684 96 25 idea idea NN 5684 96 26 of of IN 5684 96 27 which which WDT 5684 96 28 determines determine VBZ 5684 96 29 this this DT 5684 96 30 will will MD 5684 96 31 to to IN 5684 96 32 an an DT 5684 96 33 action action NN 5684 96 34 by by IN 5684 96 35 which which WDT 5684 96 36 the the DT 5684 96 37 object object NN 5684 96 38 is be VBZ 5684 96 39 produced produce VBN 5684 96 40 . . . 5684 97 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 5684 97 2 every every DT 5684 97 3 action action NN 5684 97 4 has have VBZ 5684 97 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 97 6 end end NN 5684 97 7 , , , 5684 97 8 and and CC 5684 97 9 as as IN 5684 97 10 no no DT 5684 97 11 one one NN 5684 97 12 can can MD 5684 97 13 have have VB 5684 97 14 an an DT 5684 97 15 end end NN 5684 97 16 without without IN 5684 97 17 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 97 18 making make VBG 5684 97 19 the the DT 5684 97 20 object object NN 5684 97 21 of of IN 5684 97 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 97 23 elective elective NN 5684 97 24 will will MD 5684 97 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 97 26 end end NN 5684 97 27 , , , 5684 97 28 hence hence RB 5684 97 29 to to TO 5684 97 30 have have VB 5684 97 31 some some DT 5684 97 32 end end NN 5684 97 33 of of IN 5684 97 34 actions action NNS 5684 97 35 is be VBZ 5684 97 36 an an DT 5684 97 37 act act NN 5684 97 38 of of IN 5684 97 39 the the DT 5684 97 40 freedom freedom NN 5684 97 41 of of IN 5684 97 42 the the DT 5684 97 43 agent agent NN 5684 97 44 , , , 5684 97 45 not not RB 5684 97 46 an an DT 5684 97 47 affect affect NN 5684 97 48 of of IN 5684 97 49 physical physical JJ 5684 97 50 nature nature NN 5684 97 51 . . . 5684 98 1 Now now RB 5684 98 2 , , , 5684 98 3 since since IN 5684 98 4 this this DT 5684 98 5 act act NN 5684 98 6 which which WDT 5684 98 7 determines determine VBZ 5684 98 8 an an DT 5684 98 9 end end NN 5684 98 10 is be VBZ 5684 98 11 a a DT 5684 98 12 practical practical JJ 5684 98 13 principle principle NN 5684 98 14 which which WDT 5684 98 15 commands command VBZ 5684 98 16 not not RB 5684 98 17 the the DT 5684 98 18 means mean NNS 5684 98 19 ( ( -LRB- 5684 98 20 therefore therefore RB 5684 98 21 not not RB 5684 98 22 conditionally conditionally JJ 5684 98 23 ) ) -RRB- 5684 98 24 but but CC 5684 98 25 the the DT 5684 98 26 end end NN 5684 98 27 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 98 28 ( ( -LRB- 5684 98 29 therefore therefore RB 5684 98 30 unconditionally unconditionally RB 5684 98 31 ) ) -RRB- 5684 98 32 , , , 5684 98 33 hence hence RB 5684 98 34 it -PRON- PRP 5684 98 35 is be VBZ 5684 98 36 a a DT 5684 98 37 categorical categorical JJ 5684 98 38 imperative imperative NN 5684 98 39 of of IN 5684 98 40 pure pure JJ 5684 98 41 practical practical JJ 5684 98 42 reason reason NN 5684 98 43 and and CC 5684 98 44 one one CD 5684 98 45 , , , 5684 98 46 therefore therefore RB 5684 98 47 , , , 5684 98 48 which which WDT 5684 98 49 combines combine VBZ 5684 98 50 a a DT 5684 98 51 concept concept NN 5684 98 52 of of IN 5684 98 53 duty duty NN 5684 98 54 with with IN 5684 98 55 that that DT 5684 98 56 of of IN 5684 98 57 an an DT 5684 98 58 end end NN 5684 98 59 in in IN 5684 98 60 general general NN 5684 98 61 . . . 5684 99 1 Now now RB 5684 99 2 there there EX 5684 99 3 must must MD 5684 99 4 be be VB 5684 99 5 such such PDT 5684 99 6 an an DT 5684 99 7 end end NN 5684 99 8 and and CC 5684 99 9 a a DT 5684 99 10 categorical categorical JJ 5684 99 11 imperative imperative NN 5684 99 12 corresponding correspond VBG 5684 99 13 to to IN 5684 99 14 it -PRON- PRP 5684 99 15 . . . 5684 100 1 For for IN 5684 100 2 since since IN 5684 100 3 there there EX 5684 100 4 are be VBP 5684 100 5 free free JJ 5684 100 6 actions action NNS 5684 100 7 , , , 5684 100 8 there there EX 5684 100 9 must must MD 5684 100 10 also also RB 5684 100 11 be be VB 5684 100 12 ends end NNS 5684 100 13 to to TO 5684 100 14 which which WDT 5684 100 15 as as IN 5684 100 16 an an DT 5684 100 17 object object NN 5684 100 18 those those DT 5684 100 19 actions action NNS 5684 100 20 are be VBP 5684 100 21 directed direct VBN 5684 100 22 . . . 5684 101 1 Amongst amongst IN 5684 101 2 these these DT 5684 101 3 ends end NNS 5684 101 4 there there EX 5684 101 5 must must MD 5684 101 6 also also RB 5684 101 7 be be VB 5684 101 8 some some DT 5684 101 9 which which WDT 5684 101 10 are be VBP 5684 101 11 at at IN 5684 101 12 the the DT 5684 101 13 same same JJ 5684 101 14 time time NN 5684 101 15 ( ( -LRB- 5684 101 16 that that RB 5684 101 17 is is RB 5684 101 18 , , , 5684 101 19 by by IN 5684 101 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 101 21 very very JJ 5684 101 22 notion notion NN 5684 101 23 ) ) -RRB- 5684 101 24 duties duty NNS 5684 101 25 . . . 5684 102 1 For for IN 5684 102 2 if if IN 5684 102 3 there there EX 5684 102 4 were be VBD 5684 102 5 none none NN 5684 102 6 such such JJ 5684 102 7 , , , 5684 102 8 then then RB 5684 102 9 since since IN 5684 102 10 no no DT 5684 102 11 actions action NNS 5684 102 12 can can MD 5684 102 13 be be VB 5684 102 14 without without IN 5684 102 15 an an DT 5684 102 16 end end NN 5684 102 17 , , , 5684 102 18 all all DT 5684 102 19 ends end VBZ 5684 102 20 which which WDT 5684 102 21 practical practical JJ 5684 102 22 reason reason NN 5684 102 23 might may MD 5684 102 24 have have VB 5684 102 25 would would MD 5684 102 26 be be VB 5684 102 27 valid valid JJ 5684 102 28 only only RB 5684 102 29 as as IN 5684 102 30 means mean VBZ 5684 102 31 to to IN 5684 102 32 other other JJ 5684 102 33 ends end NNS 5684 102 34 , , , 5684 102 35 and and CC 5684 102 36 a a DT 5684 102 37 categorical categorical JJ 5684 102 38 imperative imperative NN 5684 102 39 would would MD 5684 102 40 be be VB 5684 102 41 impossible impossible JJ 5684 102 42 ; ; : 5684 102 43 a a DT 5684 102 44 supposition supposition NN 5684 102 45 which which WDT 5684 102 46 destroys destroy VBZ 5684 102 47 all all DT 5684 102 48 moral moral JJ 5684 102 49 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 102 50 . . . 5684 103 1 Here here RB 5684 103 2 , , , 5684 103 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 103 4 , , , 5684 103 5 we -PRON- PRP 5684 103 6 treat treat VBP 5684 103 7 not not RB 5684 103 8 of of IN 5684 103 9 ends end NNS 5684 103 10 which which WDT 5684 103 11 man man NN 5684 103 12 actually actually RB 5684 103 13 makes make VBZ 5684 103 14 to to IN 5684 103 15 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 103 16 in in IN 5684 103 17 accordance accordance NN 5684 103 18 with with IN 5684 103 19 the the DT 5684 103 20 sensible sensible JJ 5684 103 21 impulses impulse NNS 5684 103 22 of of IN 5684 103 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 103 24 nature nature NN 5684 103 25 , , , 5684 103 26 but but CC 5684 103 27 of of IN 5684 103 28 objects object NNS 5684 103 29 of of IN 5684 103 30 the the DT 5684 103 31 free free JJ 5684 103 32 elective elective NN 5684 103 33 will will MD 5684 103 34 under under IN 5684 103 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 103 36 own own JJ 5684 103 37 laws- laws- NN 5684 103 38 objects object NNS 5684 103 39 which which WDT 5684 103 40 he -PRON- PRP 5684 103 41 ought ought MD 5684 103 42 to to TO 5684 103 43 make make VB 5684 103 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 103 45 end end NN 5684 103 46 . . . 5684 104 1 We -PRON- PRP 5684 104 2 may may MD 5684 104 3 call call VB 5684 104 4 the the DT 5684 104 5 former former JJ 5684 104 6 technical technical JJ 5684 104 7 ( ( -LRB- 5684 104 8 subjective subjective JJ 5684 104 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 104 10 , , , 5684 104 11 properly properly RB 5684 104 12 pragmatical pragmatical JJ 5684 104 13 , , , 5684 104 14 including include VBG 5684 104 15 the the DT 5684 104 16 rules rule NNS 5684 104 17 of of IN 5684 104 18 prudence prudence NN 5684 104 19 in in IN 5684 104 20 the the DT 5684 104 21 choice choice NN 5684 104 22 of of IN 5684 104 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 104 24 ends end NNS 5684 104 25 ; ; : 5684 104 26 but but CC 5684 104 27 the the DT 5684 104 28 latter latter JJ 5684 104 29 we -PRON- PRP 5684 104 30 must must MD 5684 104 31 call call VB 5684 104 32 the the DT 5684 104 33 moral moral JJ 5684 104 34 ( ( -LRB- 5684 104 35 objective objective JJ 5684 104 36 ) ) -RRB- 5684 104 37 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 104 38 of of IN 5684 104 39 ends end NNS 5684 104 40 . . . 5684 105 1 This this DT 5684 105 2 distinction distinction NN 5684 105 3 is be VBZ 5684 105 4 , , , 5684 105 5 however however RB 5684 105 6 , , , 5684 105 7 superfluous superfluous JJ 5684 105 8 here here RB 5684 105 9 , , , 5684 105 10 since since IN 5684 105 11 moral moral JJ 5684 105 12 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 105 13 already already RB 5684 105 14 by by IN 5684 105 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 105 16 very very JJ 5684 105 17 notion notion NN 5684 105 18 is be VBZ 5684 105 19 clearly clearly RB 5684 105 20 separated separate VBN 5684 105 21 from from IN 5684 105 22 the the DT 5684 105 23 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 105 24 of of IN 5684 105 25 physical physical JJ 5684 105 26 nature nature NN 5684 105 27 ( ( -LRB- 5684 105 28 in in IN 5684 105 29 the the DT 5684 105 30 present present JJ 5684 105 31 instance instance NN 5684 105 32 , , , 5684 105 33 anthropology anthropology NN 5684 105 34 ) ) -RRB- 5684 105 35 . . . 5684 106 1 The the DT 5684 106 2 latter latter JJ 5684 106 3 resting rest VBG 5684 106 4 on on IN 5684 106 5 empirical empirical JJ 5684 106 6 principles principle NNS 5684 106 7 , , , 5684 106 8 whereas whereas IN 5684 106 9 the the DT 5684 106 10 moral moral JJ 5684 106 11 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 106 12 of of IN 5684 106 13 ends end NNS 5684 106 14 which which WDT 5684 106 15 treats treat NNS 5684 106 16 of of IN 5684 106 17 duties duty NNS 5684 106 18 rests rest VBZ 5684 106 19 on on IN 5684 106 20 principles principle NNS 5684 106 21 given give VBN 5684 106 22 a a DT 5684 106 23 priori priori FW 5684 106 24 in in IN 5684 106 25 pure pure JJ 5684 106 26 practical practical JJ 5684 106 27 reason reason NN 5684 106 28 . . . 5684 107 1 { { -LRB- 5684 107 2 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 107 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 107 4 35 35 CD 5684 107 5 } } -RRB- 5684 107 6 IV IV NNP 5684 107 7 . . . 5684 108 1 What what WP 5684 108 2 are be VBP 5684 108 3 the the DT 5684 108 4 Ends Ends NNPS 5684 108 5 which which WDT 5684 108 6 are be VBP 5684 108 7 also also RB 5684 108 8 Duties Duties NNPS 5684 108 9 ? ? . 5684 109 1 They -PRON- PRP 5684 109 2 are be VBP 5684 109 3 : : : 5684 109 4 A. a. NN 5684 110 1 OUR our PRP$ 5684 110 2 OWN OWN NNP 5684 110 3 PERFECTION perfection NN 5684 110 4 , , , 5684 110 5 B. B. NNP 5684 110 6 HAPPINESS HAPPINESS NNP 5684 110 7 OF of IN 5684 110 8 OTHERS other NNS 5684 110 9 . . . 5684 111 1 We -PRON- PRP 5684 111 2 can can MD 5684 111 3 not not RB 5684 111 4 invert invert VB 5684 111 5 these these DT 5684 111 6 and and CC 5684 111 7 make make VB 5684 111 8 on on IN 5684 111 9 one one CD 5684 111 10 side side NN 5684 111 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 111 12 own own JJ 5684 111 13 happiness happiness NN 5684 111 14 , , , 5684 111 15 and and CC 5684 111 16 on on IN 5684 111 17 the the DT 5684 111 18 other other JJ 5684 111 19 the the DT 5684 111 20 perfection perfection NN 5684 111 21 of of IN 5684 111 22 others other NNS 5684 111 23 , , , 5684 111 24 ends end VBZ 5684 111 25 which which WDT 5684 111 26 should should MD 5684 111 27 be be VB 5684 111 28 in in IN 5684 111 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 5684 111 30 duties duty NNS 5684 111 31 for for IN 5684 111 32 the the DT 5684 111 33 same same JJ 5684 111 34 person person NN 5684 111 35 . . . 5684 112 1 { { -LRB- 5684 112 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 112 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 112 4 40 40 CD 5684 112 5 } } -RRB- 5684 112 6 For for IN 5684 112 7 one one PRP 5684 112 8 's 's POS 5684 112 9 own own JJ 5684 112 10 happiness happiness NN 5684 112 11 is be VBZ 5684 112 12 , , , 5684 112 13 no no RB 5684 112 14 doubt doubt RB 5684 112 15 , , , 5684 112 16 an an DT 5684 112 17 end end NN 5684 112 18 that that WDT 5684 112 19 all all DT 5684 112 20 men man NNS 5684 112 21 have have VBP 5684 112 22 ( ( -LRB- 5684 112 23 by by IN 5684 112 24 virtue virtue NN 5684 112 25 of of IN 5684 112 26 the the DT 5684 112 27 impulse impulse NN 5684 112 28 of of IN 5684 112 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 112 30 nature nature NN 5684 112 31 ) ) -RRB- 5684 112 32 , , , 5684 112 33 but but CC 5684 112 34 this this DT 5684 112 35 end end NN 5684 112 36 can can MD 5684 112 37 not not RB 5684 112 38 without without IN 5684 112 39 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 112 40 be be VB 5684 112 41 regarded regard VBN 5684 112 42 as as IN 5684 112 43 a a DT 5684 112 44 duty duty NN 5684 112 45 . . . 5684 113 1 What what WDT 5684 113 2 a a DT 5684 113 3 man man NN 5684 113 4 of of IN 5684 113 5 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 113 6 inevitably inevitably RB 5684 113 7 wills will VBZ 5684 113 8 does do VBZ 5684 113 9 not not RB 5684 113 10 come come VB 5684 113 11 under under IN 5684 113 12 the the DT 5684 113 13 notion notion NN 5684 113 14 of of IN 5684 113 15 duty duty NN 5684 113 16 , , , 5684 113 17 for for IN 5684 113 18 this this DT 5684 113 19 is be VBZ 5684 113 20 a a DT 5684 113 21 constraint constraint NN 5684 113 22 to to IN 5684 113 23 an an DT 5684 113 24 end end NN 5684 113 25 reluctantly reluctantly RB 5684 113 26 adopted adopt VBN 5684 113 27 . . . 5684 114 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 114 2 is be VBZ 5684 114 3 , , , 5684 114 4 therefore therefore RB 5684 114 5 , , , 5684 114 6 a a DT 5684 114 7 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 114 8 to to TO 5684 114 9 say say VB 5684 114 10 that that IN 5684 114 11 a a DT 5684 114 12 man man NN 5684 114 13 is be VBZ 5684 114 14 in in IN 5684 114 15 duty duty NN 5684 114 16 bound bind VBN 5684 114 17 to to TO 5684 114 18 advance advance VB 5684 114 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 114 20 own own JJ 5684 114 21 happiness happiness NN 5684 114 22 with with IN 5684 114 23 all all DT 5684 114 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 114 25 power power NN 5684 114 26 . . . 5684 115 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 115 2 is be VBZ 5684 115 3 likewise likewise RB 5684 115 4 a a DT 5684 115 5 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 115 6 to to TO 5684 115 7 make make VB 5684 115 8 the the DT 5684 115 9 perfection perfection NN 5684 115 10 of of IN 5684 115 11 another another DT 5684 115 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 115 13 end end NN 5684 115 14 , , , 5684 115 15 and and CC 5684 115 16 to to TO 5684 115 17 regard regard VB 5684 115 18 myself -PRON- PRP 5684 115 19 as as IN 5684 115 20 in in IN 5684 115 21 duty duty NN 5684 115 22 bound bind VBN 5684 115 23 to to TO 5684 115 24 promote promote VB 5684 115 25 it -PRON- PRP 5684 115 26 . . . 5684 116 1 For for IN 5684 116 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 116 3 is be VBZ 5684 116 4 just just RB 5684 116 5 in in IN 5684 116 6 this this DT 5684 116 7 that that IN 5684 116 8 the the DT 5684 116 9 perfection perfection NN 5684 116 10 of of IN 5684 116 11 another another DT 5684 116 12 man man NN 5684 116 13 as as IN 5684 116 14 a a DT 5684 116 15 person person NN 5684 116 16 consists consist VBZ 5684 116 17 , , , 5684 116 18 namely namely RB 5684 116 19 , , , 5684 116 20 that that IN 5684 116 21 he -PRON- PRP 5684 116 22 is be VBZ 5684 116 23 able able JJ 5684 116 24 of of IN 5684 116 25 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 116 26 to to TO 5684 116 27 set set VB 5684 116 28 before before IN 5684 116 29 him -PRON- PRP 5684 116 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 116 31 own own JJ 5684 116 32 end end NN 5684 116 33 according accord VBG 5684 116 34 to to IN 5684 116 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 116 36 own own JJ 5684 116 37 notions notion NNS 5684 116 38 of of IN 5684 116 39 duty duty NN 5684 116 40 ; ; : 5684 116 41 and and CC 5684 116 42 it -PRON- PRP 5684 116 43 is be VBZ 5684 116 44 a a DT 5684 116 45 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 116 46 to to TO 5684 116 47 require require VB 5684 116 48 ( ( -LRB- 5684 116 49 to to TO 5684 116 50 make make VB 5684 116 51 it -PRON- PRP 5684 116 52 a a DT 5684 116 53 duty duty NN 5684 116 54 for for IN 5684 116 55 me -PRON- PRP 5684 116 56 ) ) -RRB- 5684 116 57 that that IN 5684 116 58 I -PRON- PRP 5684 116 59 should should MD 5684 116 60 do do VB 5684 116 61 something something NN 5684 116 62 which which WDT 5684 116 63 no no DT 5684 116 64 other other JJ 5684 116 65 but but CC 5684 116 66 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 116 67 can can MD 5684 116 68 do do VB 5684 116 69 . . . 5684 117 1 V. V. NNP 5684 117 2 Explanation Explanation NNP 5684 117 3 of of IN 5684 117 4 these these DT 5684 117 5 two two CD 5684 117 6 Notions notion NNS 5684 117 7 { { -LRB- 5684 117 8 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 117 9 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 117 10 45 45 CD 5684 117 11 } } -RRB- 5684 117 12 A. a. NN 5684 118 1 OUR our PRP$ 5684 118 2 OWN own JJ 5684 118 3 PERFECTION perfection NN 5684 118 4 The the DT 5684 118 5 word word NN 5684 118 6 perfection perfection NN 5684 118 7 is be VBZ 5684 118 8 liable liable JJ 5684 118 9 to to IN 5684 118 10 many many JJ 5684 118 11 misconceptions misconception NNS 5684 118 12 . . . 5684 119 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 119 2 is be VBZ 5684 119 3 sometimes sometimes RB 5684 119 4 understood understand VBN 5684 119 5 as as IN 5684 119 6 a a DT 5684 119 7 notion notion NN 5684 119 8 belonging belong VBG 5684 119 9 to to IN 5684 119 10 transcendental transcendental JJ 5684 119 11 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 119 12 ; ; : 5684 119 13 viz viz NNP 5684 119 14 . . NNP 5684 119 15 , , , 5684 119 16 the the DT 5684 119 17 notion notion NN 5684 119 18 of of IN 5684 119 19 the the DT 5684 119 20 totality totality NN 5684 119 21 of of IN 5684 119 22 the the DT 5684 119 23 manifold manifold NN 5684 119 24 which which WDT 5684 119 25 taken take VBN 5684 119 26 together together RB 5684 119 27 constitutes constitute VBZ 5684 119 28 a a DT 5684 119 29 thing thing NN 5684 119 30 ; ; : 5684 119 31 sometimes sometimes RB 5684 119 32 , , , 5684 119 33 again again RB 5684 119 34 , , , 5684 119 35 it -PRON- PRP 5684 119 36 is be VBZ 5684 119 37 understood understand VBN 5684 119 38 as as IN 5684 119 39 belonging belong VBG 5684 119 40 to to IN 5684 119 41 teleology teleology NN 5684 119 42 , , , 5684 119 43 so so IN 5684 119 44 that that IN 5684 119 45 it -PRON- PRP 5684 119 46 signifies signify VBZ 5684 119 47 the the DT 5684 119 48 correspondence correspondence NN 5684 119 49 of of IN 5684 119 50 the the DT 5684 119 51 properties property NNS 5684 119 52 of of IN 5684 119 53 a a DT 5684 119 54 thing thing NN 5684 119 55 to to IN 5684 119 56 an an DT 5684 119 57 end end NN 5684 119 58 . . . 5684 120 1 Perfection perfection NN 5684 120 2 in in IN 5684 120 3 the the DT 5684 120 4 former former JJ 5684 120 5 sense sense NN 5684 120 6 might may MD 5684 120 7 be be VB 5684 120 8 called call VBN 5684 120 9 quantitative quantitative JJ 5684 120 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 120 11 material material NN 5684 120 12 ) ) -RRB- 5684 120 13 , , , 5684 120 14 in in IN 5684 120 15 the the DT 5684 120 16 latter latter JJ 5684 120 17 qualitative qualitative JJ 5684 120 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 120 19 formal formal JJ 5684 120 20 ) ) -RRB- 5684 120 21 perfection perfection NN 5684 120 22 . . . 5684 121 1 The the DT 5684 121 2 former former JJ 5684 121 3 can can MD 5684 121 4 be be VB 5684 121 5 one one CD 5684 121 6 only only RB 5684 121 7 , , , 5684 121 8 for for IN 5684 121 9 the the DT 5684 121 10 whole whole NN 5684 121 11 of of IN 5684 121 12 what what WP 5684 121 13 belongs belong VBZ 5684 121 14 to to IN 5684 121 15 the the DT 5684 121 16 one one CD 5684 121 17 thing thing NN 5684 121 18 is be VBZ 5684 121 19 one one CD 5684 121 20 . . . 5684 122 1 But but CC 5684 122 2 of of IN 5684 122 3 the the DT 5684 122 4 latter latter JJ 5684 122 5 there there EX 5684 122 6 may may MD 5684 122 7 be be VB 5684 122 8 several several JJ 5684 122 9 in in IN 5684 122 10 one one CD 5684 122 11 thing thing NN 5684 122 12 ; ; : 5684 122 13 and and CC 5684 122 14 it -PRON- PRP 5684 122 15 is be VBZ 5684 122 16 of of IN 5684 122 17 the the DT 5684 122 18 latter latter JJ 5684 122 19 property property NN 5684 122 20 that that WDT 5684 122 21 we -PRON- PRP 5684 122 22 here here RB 5684 122 23 treat treat VBP 5684 122 24 . . . 5684 123 1 When when WRB 5684 123 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 123 3 is be VBZ 5684 123 4 said say VBN 5684 123 5 of of IN 5684 123 6 the the DT 5684 123 7 perfection perfection NN 5684 123 8 that that WDT 5684 123 9 belongs belong VBZ 5684 123 10 to to TO 5684 123 11 man man VB 5684 123 12 generally generally RB 5684 123 13 ( ( -LRB- 5684 123 14 properly properly RB 5684 123 15 speaking speak VBG 5684 123 16 , , , 5684 123 17 to to IN 5684 123 18 humanity humanity NN 5684 123 19 ) ) -RRB- 5684 123 20 , , , 5684 123 21 that that IN 5684 123 22 it -PRON- PRP 5684 123 23 is be VBZ 5684 123 24 in in IN 5684 123 25 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 123 26 a a DT 5684 123 27 duty duty NN 5684 123 28 to to TO 5684 123 29 make make VB 5684 123 30 this this DT 5684 123 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 123 32 end end NN 5684 123 33 , , , 5684 123 34 it -PRON- PRP 5684 123 35 must must MD 5684 123 36 be be VB 5684 123 37 placed place VBN 5684 123 38 in in IN 5684 123 39 that that DT 5684 123 40 which which WDT 5684 123 41 may may MD 5684 123 42 be be VB 5684 123 43 the the DT 5684 123 44 effect effect NN 5684 123 45 of of IN 5684 123 46 one one PRP 5684 123 47 's 's POS 5684 123 48 deed deed NN 5684 123 49 , , , 5684 123 50 not not RB 5684 123 51 in in IN 5684 123 52 that that DT 5684 123 53 which which WDT 5684 123 54 is be VBZ 5684 123 55 merely merely RB 5684 123 56 an an DT 5684 123 57 endowment endowment NN 5684 123 58 for for IN 5684 123 59 which which WDT 5684 123 60 we -PRON- PRP 5684 123 61 have have VBP 5684 123 62 to to TO 5684 123 63 thank thank VB 5684 123 64 nature nature NN 5684 123 65 ; ; : 5684 123 66 for for IN 5684 123 67 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 123 68 it -PRON- PRP 5684 123 69 would would MD 5684 123 70 not not RB 5684 123 71 be be VB 5684 123 72 duty duty NN 5684 123 73 . . . 5684 124 1 Consequently consequently RB 5684 124 2 , , , 5684 124 3 it -PRON- PRP 5684 124 4 can can MD 5684 124 5 be be VB 5684 124 6 nothing nothing NN 5684 124 7 else else RB 5684 124 8 than than IN 5684 124 9 the the DT 5684 124 10 cultivation cultivation NN 5684 124 11 of of IN 5684 124 12 one one NN 5684 124 13 's 's POS 5684 124 14 power power NN 5684 124 15 ( ( -LRB- 5684 124 16 or or CC 5684 124 17 natural natural JJ 5684 124 18 capacity capacity NN 5684 124 19 ) ) -RRB- 5684 124 20 and and CC 5684 124 21 also also RB 5684 124 22 of of IN 5684 124 23 one one PRP 5684 124 24 's 's POS 5684 124 25 will will NN 5684 124 26 ( ( -LRB- 5684 124 27 moral moral JJ 5684 124 28 disposition disposition NN 5684 124 29 ) ) -RRB- 5684 124 30 to to TO 5684 124 31 satisfy satisfy VB 5684 124 32 the the DT 5684 124 33 requirement requirement NN 5684 124 34 of of IN 5684 124 35 duty duty NN 5684 124 36 in in IN 5684 124 37 general general JJ 5684 124 38 . . . 5684 125 1 The the DT 5684 125 2 supreme supreme JJ 5684 125 3 element element NN 5684 125 4 in in IN 5684 125 5 the the DT 5684 125 6 former former JJ 5684 125 7 ( ( -LRB- 5684 125 8 the the DT 5684 125 9 power power NN 5684 125 10 ) ) -RRB- 5684 125 11 is be VBZ 5684 125 12 the the DT 5684 125 13 understanding understanding NN 5684 125 14 , , , 5684 125 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 125 16 being be VBG 5684 125 17 the the DT 5684 125 18 faculty faculty NN 5684 125 19 of of IN 5684 125 20 concepts concept NNS 5684 125 21 , , , 5684 125 22 and and CC 5684 125 23 , , , 5684 125 24 therefore therefore RB 5684 125 25 , , , 5684 125 26 also also RB 5684 125 27 of of IN 5684 125 28 those those DT 5684 125 29 concepts concept NNS 5684 125 30 which which WDT 5684 125 31 refer refer VBP 5684 125 32 to to IN 5684 125 33 duty duty NN 5684 125 34 . . . 5684 126 1 First first RB 5684 126 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 126 3 is be VBZ 5684 126 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 5 duty duty NN 5684 126 6 to to IN 5684 126 7 labour labour NN 5684 126 8 to to TO 5684 126 9 raise raise VB 5684 126 10 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 126 11 out out IN 5684 126 12 of of IN 5684 126 13 the the DT 5684 126 14 rudeness rudeness NN 5684 126 15 of of IN 5684 126 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 17 nature nature NN 5684 126 18 , , , 5684 126 19 out out IN 5684 126 20 of of IN 5684 126 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 22 animal animal NN 5684 126 23 nature nature NN 5684 126 24 more more RBR 5684 126 25 and and CC 5684 126 26 more more RBR 5684 126 27 to to IN 5684 126 28 humanity humanity NN 5684 126 29 , , , 5684 126 30 by by IN 5684 126 31 which which WDT 5684 126 32 alone alone RB 5684 126 33 he -PRON- PRP 5684 126 34 is be VBZ 5684 126 35 capable capable JJ 5684 126 36 of of IN 5684 126 37 setting set VBG 5684 126 38 before before IN 5684 126 39 him -PRON- PRP 5684 126 40 ends end VBZ 5684 126 41 to to TO 5684 126 42 supply supply VB 5684 126 43 the the DT 5684 126 44 defects defect NNS 5684 126 45 of of IN 5684 126 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 47 ignorance ignorance NN 5684 126 48 by by IN 5684 126 49 instruction instruction NN 5684 126 50 , , , 5684 126 51 and and CC 5684 126 52 to to TO 5684 126 53 correct correct VB 5684 126 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 55 errors error NNS 5684 126 56 ; ; : 5684 126 57 he -PRON- PRP 5684 126 58 is be VBZ 5684 126 59 not not RB 5684 126 60 merely merely RB 5684 126 61 counselled counselled JJ 5684 126 62 to to TO 5684 126 63 do do VB 5684 126 64 this this DT 5684 126 65 by by IN 5684 126 66 reason reason NN 5684 126 67 as as IN 5684 126 68 technically technically RB 5684 126 69 practical practical JJ 5684 126 70 , , , 5684 126 71 with with IN 5684 126 72 a a DT 5684 126 73 view view NN 5684 126 74 to to IN 5684 126 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 76 purposes purpose NNS 5684 126 77 of of IN 5684 126 78 other other JJ 5684 126 79 kinds kind NNS 5684 126 80 ( ( -LRB- 5684 126 81 as as IN 5684 126 82 art art NN 5684 126 83 ) ) -RRB- 5684 126 84 , , , 5684 126 85 but but CC 5684 126 86 reason reason NN 5684 126 87 , , , 5684 126 88 as as IN 5684 126 89 morally morally RB 5684 126 90 practical practical JJ 5684 126 91 , , , 5684 126 92 absolutely absolutely RB 5684 126 93 commands command VBZ 5684 126 94 him -PRON- PRP 5684 126 95 to to TO 5684 126 96 do do VB 5684 126 97 it -PRON- PRP 5684 126 98 , , , 5684 126 99 and and CC 5684 126 100 makes make VBZ 5684 126 101 this this DT 5684 126 102 end end VB 5684 126 103 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 126 104 duty duty NN 5684 126 105 , , , 5684 126 106 in in IN 5684 126 107 order order NN 5684 126 108 that that IN 5684 126 109 he -PRON- PRP 5684 126 110 may may MD 5684 126 111 be be VB 5684 126 112 worthy worthy JJ 5684 126 113 of of IN 5684 126 114 the the DT 5684 126 115 humanity humanity NN 5684 126 116 that that WDT 5684 126 117 dwells dwell VBZ 5684 126 118 in in IN 5684 126 119 him -PRON- PRP 5684 126 120 . . . 5684 127 1 Secondly secondly RB 5684 127 2 , , , 5684 127 3 to to TO 5684 127 4 carry carry VB 5684 127 5 the the DT 5684 127 6 cultivation cultivation NN 5684 127 7 of of IN 5684 127 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 127 9 will will NN 5684 127 10 up up IN 5684 127 11 to to IN 5684 127 12 the the DT 5684 127 13 purest pure JJS 5684 127 14 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 127 15 disposition disposition NN 5684 127 16 , , , 5684 127 17 that that IN 5684 127 18 , , , 5684 127 19 namely namely RB 5684 127 20 , , , 5684 127 21 in in IN 5684 127 22 which which WDT 5684 127 23 the the DT 5684 127 24 law law NN 5684 127 25 is be VBZ 5684 127 26 also also RB 5684 127 27 the the DT 5684 127 28 spring spring NN 5684 127 29 of of IN 5684 127 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 127 31 dutiful dutiful JJ 5684 127 32 actions action NNS 5684 127 33 , , , 5684 127 34 and and CC 5684 127 35 to to TO 5684 127 36 obey obey VB 5684 127 37 it -PRON- PRP 5684 127 38 from from IN 5684 127 39 duty duty NN 5684 127 40 , , , 5684 127 41 for for IN 5684 127 42 this this DT 5684 127 43 is be VBZ 5684 127 44 internal internal JJ 5684 127 45 morally morally RB 5684 127 46 practical practical JJ 5684 127 47 perfection perfection NN 5684 127 48 . . . 5684 128 1 This this DT 5684 128 2 is be VBZ 5684 128 3 called call VBN 5684 128 4 the the DT 5684 128 5 moral moral JJ 5684 128 6 sense sense NN 5684 128 7 ( ( -LRB- 5684 128 8 as as IN 5684 128 9 it -PRON- PRP 5684 128 10 were be VBD 5684 128 11 a a DT 5684 128 12 special special JJ 5684 128 13 sense sense NN 5684 128 14 , , , 5684 128 15 sensus sensus NNP 5684 128 16 moralis moralis NNP 5684 128 17 ) ) -RRB- 5684 128 18 , , , 5684 128 19 because because IN 5684 128 20 it -PRON- PRP 5684 128 21 is be VBZ 5684 128 22 a a DT 5684 128 23 feeling feeling NN 5684 128 24 of of IN 5684 128 25 the the DT 5684 128 26 effect effect NN 5684 128 27 which which WDT 5684 128 28 the the DT 5684 128 29 legislative legislative JJ 5684 128 30 will will NN 5684 128 31 within within IN 5684 128 32 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 128 33 exercises exercise VBZ 5684 128 34 on on IN 5684 128 35 the the DT 5684 128 36 faculty faculty NN 5684 128 37 of of IN 5684 128 38 acting act VBG 5684 128 39 accordingly accordingly RB 5684 128 40 . . . 5684 129 1 This this DT 5684 129 2 is be VBZ 5684 129 3 , , , 5684 129 4 indeed indeed RB 5684 129 5 , , , 5684 129 6 often often RB 5684 129 7 misused misuse VBD 5684 129 8 fanatically fanatically RB 5684 129 9 , , , 5684 129 10 as as IN 5684 129 11 though though RB 5684 129 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 129 13 like like IN 5684 129 14 the the DT 5684 129 15 genius genius NN 5684 129 16 of of IN 5684 129 17 Socrates Socrates NNPS 5684 129 18 ) ) -RRB- 5684 129 19 it -PRON- PRP 5684 129 20 preceded precede VBD 5684 129 21 reason reason NN 5684 129 22 , , , 5684 129 23 or or CC 5684 129 24 even even RB 5684 129 25 could could MD 5684 129 26 dispense dispense VB 5684 129 27 with with IN 5684 129 28 judgement judgement NN 5684 129 29 of of IN 5684 129 30 reason reason NN 5684 129 31 ; ; : 5684 129 32 but but CC 5684 129 33 still still RB 5684 129 34 it -PRON- PRP 5684 129 35 is be VBZ 5684 129 36 a a DT 5684 129 37 moral moral JJ 5684 129 38 perfection perfection NN 5684 129 39 , , , 5684 129 40 making make VBG 5684 129 41 every every DT 5684 129 42 special special JJ 5684 129 43 end end NN 5684 129 44 , , , 5684 129 45 which which WDT 5684 129 46 is be VBZ 5684 129 47 also also RB 5684 129 48 a a DT 5684 129 49 duty duty NN 5684 129 50 , , , 5684 129 51 one one PRP 5684 129 52 's 's POS 5684 129 53 own own JJ 5684 129 54 end end NN 5684 129 55 . . . 5684 130 1 { { -LRB- 5684 130 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 130 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 130 4 50 50 CD 5684 130 5 } } -RRB- 5684 130 6 B. B. NNP 5684 130 7 HAPPINESS HAPPINESS NNP 5684 130 8 OF of IN 5684 130 9 OTHERS other NNS 5684 130 10 It -PRON- PRP 5684 130 11 is be VBZ 5684 130 12 inevitable inevitable JJ 5684 130 13 for for IN 5684 130 14 human human JJ 5684 130 15 nature nature NN 5684 130 16 that that WDT 5684 130 17 man man VBP 5684 130 18 a a DT 5684 130 19 should should MD 5684 130 20 wish wish VB 5684 130 21 and and CC 5684 130 22 seek seek VB 5684 130 23 for for IN 5684 130 24 happiness happiness NN 5684 130 25 , , , 5684 130 26 that that RB 5684 130 27 is is RB 5684 130 28 , , , 5684 130 29 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 130 30 with with IN 5684 130 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 130 32 condition condition NN 5684 130 33 , , , 5684 130 34 with with IN 5684 130 35 certainty certainty NN 5684 130 36 of of IN 5684 130 37 the the DT 5684 130 38 continuance continuance NN 5684 130 39 of of IN 5684 130 40 this this DT 5684 130 41 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 130 42 . . . 5684 131 1 But but CC 5684 131 2 for for IN 5684 131 3 this this DT 5684 131 4 very very JJ 5684 131 5 reason reason NN 5684 131 6 it -PRON- PRP 5684 131 7 is be VBZ 5684 131 8 not not RB 5684 131 9 an an DT 5684 131 10 end end NN 5684 131 11 that that WDT 5684 131 12 is be VBZ 5684 131 13 also also RB 5684 131 14 a a DT 5684 131 15 duty duty NN 5684 131 16 . . . 5684 132 1 Some some DT 5684 132 2 writers writer NNS 5684 132 3 still still RB 5684 132 4 make make VBP 5684 132 5 a a DT 5684 132 6 distinction distinction NN 5684 132 7 between between IN 5684 132 8 moral moral JJ 5684 132 9 and and CC 5684 132 10 physical physical JJ 5684 132 11 happiness happiness NN 5684 132 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 132 13 the the DT 5684 132 14 former former JJ 5684 132 15 consisting consisting NN 5684 132 16 in in IN 5684 132 17 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 132 18 with with IN 5684 132 19 one one PRP 5684 132 20 's 's POS 5684 132 21 person person NN 5684 132 22 and and CC 5684 132 23 moral moral JJ 5684 132 24 behaviour behaviour NN 5684 132 25 , , , 5684 132 26 that that RB 5684 132 27 is is RB 5684 132 28 , , , 5684 132 29 with with IN 5684 132 30 what what WP 5684 132 31 one one NN 5684 132 32 does do VBZ 5684 132 33 ; ; : 5684 132 34 the the DT 5684 132 35 other other JJ 5684 132 36 in in IN 5684 132 37 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 132 38 with with IN 5684 132 39 that that DT 5684 132 40 which which WDT 5684 132 41 nature nature NN 5684 132 42 confers confer NNS 5684 132 43 , , , 5684 132 44 consequently consequently RB 5684 132 45 with with IN 5684 132 46 what what WP 5684 132 47 one one NN 5684 132 48 enjoys enjoy VBZ 5684 132 49 as as IN 5684 132 50 a a DT 5684 132 51 foreign foreign JJ 5684 132 52 gift gift NN 5684 132 53 ) ) -RRB- 5684 132 54 . . . 5684 133 1 Without without IN 5684 133 2 at at IN 5684 133 3 present present NN 5684 133 4 censuring censure VBG 5684 133 5 the the DT 5684 133 6 misuse misuse NN 5684 133 7 of of IN 5684 133 8 the the DT 5684 133 9 word word NN 5684 133 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 133 11 which which WDT 5684 133 12 even even RB 5684 133 13 involves involve VBZ 5684 133 14 a a DT 5684 133 15 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 133 16 ) ) -RRB- 5684 133 17 , , , 5684 133 18 it -PRON- PRP 5684 133 19 must must MD 5684 133 20 be be VB 5684 133 21 observed observe VBN 5684 133 22 that that IN 5684 133 23 the the DT 5684 133 24 feeling feeling NN 5684 133 25 of of IN 5684 133 26 the the DT 5684 133 27 former former JJ 5684 133 28 belongs belong VBZ 5684 133 29 solely solely RB 5684 133 30 to to IN 5684 133 31 the the DT 5684 133 32 preceding precede VBG 5684 133 33 head head NN 5684 133 34 , , , 5684 133 35 namely namely RB 5684 133 36 , , , 5684 133 37 perfection perfection NN 5684 133 38 . . . 5684 134 1 For for IN 5684 134 2 he -PRON- PRP 5684 134 3 who who WP 5684 134 4 is be VBZ 5684 134 5 to to TO 5684 134 6 feel feel VB 5684 134 7 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 134 8 happy happy JJ 5684 134 9 in in IN 5684 134 10 the the DT 5684 134 11 mere mere JJ 5684 134 12 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 134 13 of of IN 5684 134 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 134 15 uprightness uprightness JJ 5684 134 16 already already RB 5684 134 17 possesses possess VBZ 5684 134 18 that that DT 5684 134 19 perfection perfection NN 5684 134 20 which which WDT 5684 134 21 in in IN 5684 134 22 the the DT 5684 134 23 previous previous JJ 5684 134 24 section section NN 5684 134 25 was be VBD 5684 134 26 defined define VBN 5684 134 27 as as IN 5684 134 28 that that DT 5684 134 29 end end NN 5684 134 30 which which WDT 5684 134 31 is be VBZ 5684 134 32 also also RB 5684 134 33 duty duty NN 5684 134 34 . . . 5684 135 1 If if IN 5684 135 2 happiness happiness NN 5684 135 3 , , , 5684 135 4 then then RB 5684 135 5 , , , 5684 135 6 is be VBZ 5684 135 7 in in IN 5684 135 8 question question NN 5684 135 9 , , , 5684 135 10 which which WDT 5684 135 11 it -PRON- PRP 5684 135 12 is be VBZ 5684 135 13 to to TO 5684 135 14 be be VB 5684 135 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 135 16 duty duty NN 5684 135 17 to to TO 5684 135 18 promote promote VB 5684 135 19 as as IN 5684 135 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 135 21 end end NN 5684 135 22 , , , 5684 135 23 it -PRON- PRP 5684 135 24 must must MD 5684 135 25 be be VB 5684 135 26 the the DT 5684 135 27 happiness happiness NN 5684 135 28 of of IN 5684 135 29 other other JJ 5684 135 30 men man NNS 5684 135 31 whose whose WP$ 5684 135 32 ( ( -LRB- 5684 135 33 permitted permit VBN 5684 135 34 ) ) -RRB- 5684 135 35 end end NN 5684 135 36 I -PRON- PRP 5684 135 37 hereby hereby RB 5684 135 38 make make VBP 5684 135 39 also also RB 5684 135 40 mine -PRON- PRP 5684 135 41 . . . 5684 136 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 136 2 still still RB 5684 136 3 remains remain VBZ 5684 136 4 left left JJ 5684 136 5 to to IN 5684 136 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 5684 136 7 to to TO 5684 136 8 decide decide VB 5684 136 9 what what WP 5684 136 10 they -PRON- PRP 5684 136 11 shall shall MD 5684 136 12 reckon reckon VB 5684 136 13 as as IN 5684 136 14 belonging belong VBG 5684 136 15 to to IN 5684 136 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 136 17 happiness happiness NN 5684 136 18 ; ; : 5684 136 19 only only RB 5684 136 20 that that IN 5684 136 21 it -PRON- PRP 5684 136 22 is be VBZ 5684 136 23 in in IN 5684 136 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 136 25 power power NN 5684 136 26 to to TO 5684 136 27 decline decline VB 5684 136 28 many many JJ 5684 136 29 things thing NNS 5684 136 30 which which WDT 5684 136 31 they -PRON- PRP 5684 136 32 so so RB 5684 136 33 reckon reckon VBP 5684 136 34 , , , 5684 136 35 but but CC 5684 136 36 which which WDT 5684 136 37 I -PRON- PRP 5684 136 38 do do VBP 5684 136 39 not not RB 5684 136 40 so so RB 5684 136 41 regard regard VB 5684 136 42 , , , 5684 136 43 supposing suppose VBG 5684 136 44 that that IN 5684 136 45 they -PRON- PRP 5684 136 46 have have VBP 5684 136 47 no no DT 5684 136 48 right right NN 5684 136 49 to to TO 5684 136 50 demand demand VB 5684 136 51 it -PRON- PRP 5684 136 52 from from IN 5684 136 53 me -PRON- PRP 5684 136 54 as as IN 5684 136 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 136 56 own own JJ 5684 136 57 . . . 5684 137 1 A a DT 5684 137 2 plausible plausible JJ 5684 137 3 objection objection NN 5684 137 4 often often RB 5684 137 5 advanced advance VBD 5684 137 6 against against IN 5684 137 7 the the DT 5684 137 8 division division NN 5684 137 9 of of IN 5684 137 10 duties duty NNS 5684 137 11 above above IN 5684 137 12 adopted adopt VBD 5684 137 13 consists consist NNS 5684 137 14 in in IN 5684 137 15 setting set VBG 5684 137 16 over over RP 5684 137 17 against against IN 5684 137 18 that that DT 5684 137 19 end end NN 5684 137 20 a a DT 5684 137 21 supposed suppose VBN 5684 137 22 obligation obligation NN 5684 137 23 to to TO 5684 137 24 study study VB 5684 137 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 137 26 own own JJ 5684 137 27 ( ( -LRB- 5684 137 28 physical physical JJ 5684 137 29 ) ) -RRB- 5684 137 30 happiness happiness NN 5684 137 31 , , , 5684 137 32 and and CC 5684 137 33 thus thus RB 5684 137 34 making make VBG 5684 137 35 this this DT 5684 137 36 , , , 5684 137 37 which which WDT 5684 137 38 is be VBZ 5684 137 39 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 137 40 natural natural JJ 5684 137 41 and and CC 5684 137 42 merely merely RB 5684 137 43 subjective subjective JJ 5684 137 44 end end NN 5684 137 45 , , , 5684 137 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 137 47 duty duty NN 5684 137 48 ( ( -LRB- 5684 137 49 and and CC 5684 137 50 objective objective JJ 5684 137 51 end end NN 5684 137 52 ) ) -RRB- 5684 137 53 . . . 5684 138 1 This this DT 5684 138 2 requires require VBZ 5684 138 3 to to TO 5684 138 4 be be VB 5684 138 5 cleared clear VBN 5684 138 6 up up RP 5684 138 7 . . . 5684 139 1 Adversity adversity NN 5684 139 2 , , , 5684 139 3 pain pain NN 5684 139 4 , , , 5684 139 5 and and CC 5684 139 6 want want VBP 5684 139 7 are be VBP 5684 139 8 great great JJ 5684 139 9 temptations temptation NNS 5684 139 10 to to IN 5684 139 11 transgression transgression NN 5684 139 12 of of IN 5684 139 13 one one NN 5684 139 14 's 's POS 5684 139 15 duty duty NN 5684 139 16 ; ; : 5684 139 17 accordingly accordingly RB 5684 139 18 it -PRON- PRP 5684 139 19 would would MD 5684 139 20 seem seem VB 5684 139 21 that that DT 5684 139 22 strength strength NN 5684 139 23 , , , 5684 139 24 health health NN 5684 139 25 , , , 5684 139 26 a a DT 5684 139 27 competence competence NN 5684 139 28 , , , 5684 139 29 and and CC 5684 139 30 welfare welfare NN 5684 139 31 generally generally RB 5684 139 32 , , , 5684 139 33 which which WDT 5684 139 34 are be VBP 5684 139 35 opposed opposed JJ 5684 139 36 to to IN 5684 139 37 that that DT 5684 139 38 influence influence NN 5684 139 39 , , , 5684 139 40 may may MD 5684 139 41 also also RB 5684 139 42 be be VB 5684 139 43 regarded regard VBN 5684 139 44 as as IN 5684 139 45 ends end NNS 5684 139 46 that that WDT 5684 139 47 are be VBP 5684 139 48 also also RB 5684 139 49 duties duty NNS 5684 139 50 ; ; : 5684 139 51 that that RB 5684 139 52 is is RB 5684 139 53 , , , 5684 139 54 that that IN 5684 139 55 it -PRON- PRP 5684 139 56 is be VBZ 5684 139 57 a a DT 5684 139 58 duty duty NN 5684 139 59 to to TO 5684 139 60 promote promote VB 5684 139 61 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 139 62 own own JJ 5684 139 63 happiness happiness NN 5684 139 64 not not RB 5684 139 65 merely merely RB 5684 139 66 to to TO 5684 139 67 make make VB 5684 139 68 that that DT 5684 139 69 of of IN 5684 139 70 others other NNS 5684 139 71 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 139 72 end end NN 5684 139 73 . . . 5684 140 1 But but CC 5684 140 2 in in IN 5684 140 3 that that DT 5684 140 4 case case NN 5684 140 5 the the DT 5684 140 6 end end NN 5684 140 7 is be VBZ 5684 140 8 not not RB 5684 140 9 happiness happiness NN 5684 140 10 but but CC 5684 140 11 the the DT 5684 140 12 morality morality NN 5684 140 13 of of IN 5684 140 14 the the DT 5684 140 15 agent agent NN 5684 140 16 ; ; : 5684 140 17 and and CC 5684 140 18 happiness happiness NN 5684 140 19 is be VBZ 5684 140 20 only only RB 5684 140 21 the the DT 5684 140 22 means mean NNS 5684 140 23 of of IN 5684 140 24 removing remove VBG 5684 140 25 the the DT 5684 140 26 hindrances hindrance NNS 5684 140 27 to to IN 5684 140 28 morality morality NN 5684 140 29 ; ; , 5684 140 30 permitted permitted JJ 5684 140 31 means mean NNS 5684 140 32 , , , 5684 140 33 since since IN 5684 140 34 no no DT 5684 140 35 one one NN 5684 140 36 has have VBZ 5684 140 37 a a DT 5684 140 38 right right NN 5684 140 39 to to TO 5684 140 40 demand demand VB 5684 140 41 from from IN 5684 140 42 me -PRON- PRP 5684 140 43 the the DT 5684 140 44 sacrifice sacrifice NN 5684 140 45 of of IN 5684 140 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 140 47 not not RB 5684 140 48 immoral immoral JJ 5684 140 49 ends end NNS 5684 140 50 . . . 5684 141 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 141 2 is be VBZ 5684 141 3 not not RB 5684 141 4 directly directly RB 5684 141 5 a a DT 5684 141 6 duty duty NN 5684 141 7 to to TO 5684 141 8 seek seek VB 5684 141 9 a a DT 5684 141 10 competence competence NN 5684 141 11 for for IN 5684 141 12 one one NN 5684 141 13 's 's POS 5684 141 14 self self NN 5684 141 15 ; ; : 5684 141 16 but but CC 5684 141 17 indirectly indirectly RB 5684 141 18 it -PRON- PRP 5684 141 19 may may MD 5684 141 20 be be VB 5684 141 21 so so RB 5684 141 22 ; ; : 5684 141 23 namely namely RB 5684 141 24 , , , 5684 141 25 in in IN 5684 141 26 order order NN 5684 141 27 to to TO 5684 141 28 guard guard VB 5684 141 29 against against IN 5684 141 30 poverty poverty NN 5684 141 31 which which WDT 5684 141 32 is be VBZ 5684 141 33 a a DT 5684 141 34 great great JJ 5684 141 35 temptation temptation NN 5684 141 36 to to IN 5684 141 37 vice vice NN 5684 141 38 . . . 5684 142 1 But but CC 5684 142 2 then then RB 5684 142 3 it -PRON- PRP 5684 142 4 is be VBZ 5684 142 5 not not RB 5684 142 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 142 7 happiness happiness NN 5684 142 8 but but CC 5684 142 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 142 10 morality morality NN 5684 142 11 , , , 5684 142 12 to to TO 5684 142 13 maintain maintain VB 5684 142 14 which which WDT 5684 142 15 in in IN 5684 142 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 142 17 integrity integrity NN 5684 142 18 is be VBZ 5684 142 19 at at IN 5684 142 20 once once IN 5684 142 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 142 22 end end NN 5684 142 23 and and CC 5684 142 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 142 25 duty duty NN 5684 142 26 . . . 5684 143 1 { { -LRB- 5684 143 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 143 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 143 4 55 55 CD 5684 143 5 } } -RRB- 5684 143 6 VI VI NNP 5684 143 7 . . . 5684 144 1 Ethics ethic NNS 5684 144 2 does do VBZ 5684 144 3 not not RB 5684 144 4 supply supply VB 5684 144 5 Laws law NNS 5684 144 6 for for IN 5684 144 7 Actions Actions NNPS 5684 144 8 ( ( -LRB- 5684 144 9 which which WDT 5684 144 10 is be VBZ 5684 144 11 done do VBN 5684 144 12 by by IN 5684 144 13 Jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 144 14 ) ) -RRB- 5684 144 15 , , , 5684 144 16 but but CC 5684 144 17 only only RB 5684 144 18 for for IN 5684 144 19 the the DT 5684 144 20 Maxims Maxims NNPS 5684 144 21 of of IN 5684 144 22 Action action NN 5684 144 23 The the DT 5684 144 24 notion notion NN 5684 144 25 of of IN 5684 144 26 duty duty NN 5684 144 27 stands stand VBZ 5684 144 28 in in IN 5684 144 29 immediate immediate JJ 5684 144 30 relation relation NN 5684 144 31 to to IN 5684 144 32 a a DT 5684 144 33 law law NN 5684 144 34 ( ( -LRB- 5684 144 35 even even RB 5684 144 36 though though IN 5684 144 37 I -PRON- PRP 5684 144 38 abstract abstract VBP 5684 144 39 from from IN 5684 144 40 every every DT 5684 144 41 end end NN 5684 144 42 which which WDT 5684 144 43 is be VBZ 5684 144 44 the the DT 5684 144 45 matter matter NN 5684 144 46 of of IN 5684 144 47 the the DT 5684 144 48 law law NN 5684 144 49 ) ) -RRB- 5684 144 50 ; ; : 5684 144 51 as as IN 5684 144 52 is be VBZ 5684 144 53 shown show VBN 5684 144 54 by by IN 5684 144 55 the the DT 5684 144 56 formal formal JJ 5684 144 57 principle principle NN 5684 144 58 of of IN 5684 144 59 duty duty NN 5684 144 60 in in IN 5684 144 61 the the DT 5684 144 62 categorical categorical JJ 5684 144 63 imperative imperative NN 5684 144 64 : : : 5684 144 65 " " `` 5684 144 66 Act act VB 5684 144 67 so so IN 5684 144 68 that that IN 5684 144 69 the the DT 5684 144 70 maxims maxim NNS 5684 144 71 of of IN 5684 144 72 thy thy PRP$ 5684 144 73 action action NN 5684 144 74 might may MD 5684 144 75 become become VB 5684 144 76 a a DT 5684 144 77 universal universal JJ 5684 144 78 law law NN 5684 144 79 . . . 5684 144 80 " " '' 5684 145 1 But but CC 5684 145 2 in in IN 5684 145 3 ethics ethic NNS 5684 145 4 this this DT 5684 145 5 is be VBZ 5684 145 6 conceived conceive VBN 5684 145 7 as as IN 5684 145 8 the the DT 5684 145 9 law law NN 5684 145 10 of of IN 5684 145 11 thy thy PRP$ 5684 145 12 own own JJ 5684 145 13 will will NN 5684 145 14 , , , 5684 145 15 not not RB 5684 145 16 of of IN 5684 145 17 will will NN 5684 145 18 in in IN 5684 145 19 general general JJ 5684 145 20 , , , 5684 145 21 which which WDT 5684 145 22 might may MD 5684 145 23 be be VB 5684 145 24 that that DT 5684 145 25 of of IN 5684 145 26 others other NNS 5684 145 27 ; ; : 5684 145 28 for for IN 5684 145 29 in in IN 5684 145 30 the the DT 5684 145 31 latter latter JJ 5684 145 32 case case NN 5684 145 33 it -PRON- PRP 5684 145 34 would would MD 5684 145 35 give give VB 5684 145 36 rise rise NN 5684 145 37 to to IN 5684 145 38 a a DT 5684 145 39 judicial judicial JJ 5684 145 40 duty duty NN 5684 145 41 which which WDT 5684 145 42 does do VBZ 5684 145 43 not not RB 5684 145 44 belong belong VB 5684 145 45 to to IN 5684 145 46 the the DT 5684 145 47 domain domain NN 5684 145 48 of of IN 5684 145 49 ethics ethic NNS 5684 145 50 . . . 5684 146 1 In in IN 5684 146 2 ethics ethic NNS 5684 146 3 , , , 5684 146 4 maxims maxim NNS 5684 146 5 are be VBP 5684 146 6 regarded regard VBN 5684 146 7 as as IN 5684 146 8 those those DT 5684 146 9 subjective subjective JJ 5684 146 10 laws law NNS 5684 146 11 which which WDT 5684 146 12 merely merely RB 5684 146 13 have have VBP 5684 146 14 the the DT 5684 146 15 specific specific JJ 5684 146 16 character character NN 5684 146 17 of of IN 5684 146 18 universal universal JJ 5684 146 19 legislation legislation NN 5684 146 20 , , , 5684 146 21 which which WDT 5684 146 22 is be VBZ 5684 146 23 only only RB 5684 146 24 a a DT 5684 146 25 negative negative JJ 5684 146 26 principle principle NN 5684 146 27 ( ( -LRB- 5684 146 28 not not RB 5684 146 29 to to TO 5684 146 30 contradict contradict VB 5684 146 31 a a DT 5684 146 32 law law NN 5684 146 33 in in IN 5684 146 34 general general NN 5684 146 35 ) ) -RRB- 5684 146 36 . . . 5684 147 1 How how WRB 5684 147 2 , , , 5684 147 3 then then RB 5684 147 4 , , , 5684 147 5 can can MD 5684 147 6 there there EX 5684 147 7 be be VB 5684 147 8 further further JJ 5684 147 9 a a DT 5684 147 10 law law NN 5684 147 11 for for IN 5684 147 12 the the DT 5684 147 13 maxims maxim NNS 5684 147 14 of of IN 5684 147 15 actions action NNS 5684 147 16 ? ? . 5684 148 1 { { -LRB- 5684 148 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 148 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 148 4 60 60 CD 5684 148 5 } } -RRB- 5684 148 6 It -PRON- PRP 5684 148 7 is be VBZ 5684 148 8 the the DT 5684 148 9 notion notion NN 5684 148 10 of of IN 5684 148 11 an an DT 5684 148 12 end end NN 5684 148 13 which which WDT 5684 148 14 is be VBZ 5684 148 15 also also RB 5684 148 16 a a DT 5684 148 17 duty duty NN 5684 148 18 , , , 5684 148 19 a a DT 5684 148 20 notion notion NN 5684 148 21 peculiar peculiar JJ 5684 148 22 to to IN 5684 148 23 ethics ethic NNS 5684 148 24 , , , 5684 148 25 that that IN 5684 148 26 alone alone RB 5684 148 27 is be VBZ 5684 148 28 the the DT 5684 148 29 foundation foundation NN 5684 148 30 of of IN 5684 148 31 a a DT 5684 148 32 law law NN 5684 148 33 for for IN 5684 148 34 the the DT 5684 148 35 maxims maxim NNS 5684 148 36 of of IN 5684 148 37 actions action NNS 5684 148 38 ; ; : 5684 148 39 by by IN 5684 148 40 making make VBG 5684 148 41 the the DT 5684 148 42 subjective subjective JJ 5684 148 43 end end NN 5684 148 44 ( ( -LRB- 5684 148 45 that that IN 5684 148 46 which which WDT 5684 148 47 every every DT 5684 148 48 one one NN 5684 148 49 has have VBZ 5684 148 50 ) ) -RRB- 5684 148 51 subordinate subordinate JJ 5684 148 52 to to IN 5684 148 53 the the DT 5684 148 54 objective objective JJ 5684 148 55 end end NN 5684 148 56 ( ( -LRB- 5684 148 57 that that IN 5684 148 58 which which WDT 5684 148 59 every every DT 5684 148 60 one one NN 5684 148 61 ought ought MD 5684 148 62 to to TO 5684 148 63 make make VB 5684 148 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 148 65 own own JJ 5684 148 66 ) ) -RRB- 5684 148 67 . . . 5684 149 1 The the DT 5684 149 2 imperative imperative NN 5684 149 3 : : : 5684 149 4 " " `` 5684 149 5 Thou Thou NNP 5684 149 6 shalt shalt NN 5684 149 7 make make VB 5684 149 8 this this DT 5684 149 9 or or CC 5684 149 10 that that IN 5684 149 11 thy thy PRP$ 5684 149 12 end end NN 5684 149 13 ( ( -LRB- 5684 149 14 e. e. NNP 5684 149 15 g. g. NNP 5684 149 16 , , , 5684 149 17 the the DT 5684 149 18 happiness happiness NN 5684 149 19 of of IN 5684 149 20 others other NNS 5684 149 21 ) ) -RRB- 5684 149 22 " " '' 5684 149 23 applies apply VBZ 5684 149 24 to to IN 5684 149 25 the the DT 5684 149 26 matter matter NN 5684 149 27 of of IN 5684 149 28 the the DT 5684 149 29 elective elective NN 5684 149 30 will will NN 5684 149 31 ( ( -LRB- 5684 149 32 an an DT 5684 149 33 object object NN 5684 149 34 ) ) -RRB- 5684 149 35 . . . 5684 150 1 Now now RB 5684 150 2 since since IN 5684 150 3 no no DT 5684 150 4 free free JJ 5684 150 5 action action NN 5684 150 6 is be VBZ 5684 150 7 possible possible JJ 5684 150 8 , , , 5684 150 9 without without IN 5684 150 10 the the DT 5684 150 11 agent agent NN 5684 150 12 having have VBG 5684 150 13 in in IN 5684 150 14 view view NN 5684 150 15 in in IN 5684 150 16 it -PRON- PRP 5684 150 17 some some DT 5684 150 18 end end NN 5684 150 19 ( ( -LRB- 5684 150 20 as as IN 5684 150 21 matter matter NN 5684 150 22 of of IN 5684 150 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 150 24 elective elective NN 5684 150 25 will will NN 5684 150 26 ) ) -RRB- 5684 150 27 , , , 5684 150 28 it -PRON- PRP 5684 150 29 follows follow VBZ 5684 150 30 that that IN 5684 150 31 , , , 5684 150 32 if if IN 5684 150 33 there there EX 5684 150 34 is be VBZ 5684 150 35 an an DT 5684 150 36 end end NN 5684 150 37 which which WDT 5684 150 38 is be VBZ 5684 150 39 also also RB 5684 150 40 a a DT 5684 150 41 duty duty NN 5684 150 42 , , , 5684 150 43 the the DT 5684 150 44 maxims maxim NNS 5684 150 45 of of IN 5684 150 46 actions action NNS 5684 150 47 which which WDT 5684 150 48 are be VBP 5684 150 49 means mean NNS 5684 150 50 to to IN 5684 150 51 ends end NNS 5684 150 52 must must MD 5684 150 53 contain contain VB 5684 150 54 only only RB 5684 150 55 the the DT 5684 150 56 condition condition NN 5684 150 57 of of IN 5684 150 58 fitness fitness NN 5684 150 59 for for IN 5684 150 60 a a DT 5684 150 61 possible possible JJ 5684 150 62 universal universal JJ 5684 150 63 legislation legislation NN 5684 150 64 : : : 5684 150 65 on on IN 5684 150 66 the the DT 5684 150 67 other other JJ 5684 150 68 hand hand NN 5684 150 69 , , , 5684 150 70 the the DT 5684 150 71 end end NN 5684 150 72 which which WDT 5684 150 73 is be VBZ 5684 150 74 also also RB 5684 150 75 a a DT 5684 150 76 duty duty NN 5684 150 77 can can MD 5684 150 78 make make VB 5684 150 79 it -PRON- PRP 5684 150 80 a a DT 5684 150 81 law law NN 5684 150 82 that that WDT 5684 150 83 we -PRON- PRP 5684 150 84 should should MD 5684 150 85 have have VB 5684 150 86 such such PDT 5684 150 87 a a DT 5684 150 88 maxim maxim NN 5684 150 89 , , , 5684 150 90 whilst whilst IN 5684 150 91 for for IN 5684 150 92 the the DT 5684 150 93 maxim maxim NN 5684 150 94 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 150 95 the the DT 5684 150 96 possibility possibility NN 5684 150 97 of of IN 5684 150 98 agreeing agree VBG 5684 150 99 with with IN 5684 150 100 a a DT 5684 150 101 universal universal JJ 5684 150 102 legislation legislation NN 5684 150 103 is be VBZ 5684 150 104 sufficient sufficient JJ 5684 150 105 . . . 5684 151 1 For for IN 5684 151 2 maxims maxim NNS 5684 151 3 of of IN 5684 151 4 actions action NNS 5684 151 5 may may MD 5684 151 6 be be VB 5684 151 7 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 5684 151 8 , , , 5684 151 9 and and CC 5684 151 10 are be VBP 5684 151 11 only only RB 5684 151 12 limited limit VBN 5684 151 13 by by IN 5684 151 14 the the DT 5684 151 15 condition condition NN 5684 151 16 of of IN 5684 151 17 fitness fitness NN 5684 151 18 for for IN 5684 151 19 a a DT 5684 151 20 universal universal JJ 5684 151 21 legislation legislation NN 5684 151 22 , , , 5684 151 23 which which WDT 5684 151 24 is be VBZ 5684 151 25 the the DT 5684 151 26 formal formal JJ 5684 151 27 principle principle NN 5684 151 28 of of IN 5684 151 29 actions action NNS 5684 151 30 . . . 5684 152 1 But but CC 5684 152 2 a a DT 5684 152 3 law law NN 5684 152 4 abolishes abolish VBZ 5684 152 5 the the DT 5684 152 6 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 5684 152 7 character character NN 5684 152 8 of of IN 5684 152 9 actions action NNS 5684 152 10 , , , 5684 152 11 and and CC 5684 152 12 is be VBZ 5684 152 13 by by IN 5684 152 14 this this DT 5684 152 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 5684 152 16 from from IN 5684 152 17 recommendation recommendation NN 5684 152 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 152 19 in in IN 5684 152 20 which which WDT 5684 152 21 one one CD 5684 152 22 only only RB 5684 152 23 desires desire VBZ 5684 152 24 to to TO 5684 152 25 know know VB 5684 152 26 the the DT 5684 152 27 best good JJS 5684 152 28 means mean NNS 5684 152 29 to to IN 5684 152 30 an an DT 5684 152 31 end end NN 5684 152 32 ) ) -RRB- 5684 152 33 . . . 5684 153 1 VII VII NNP 5684 153 2 . . . 5684 154 1 Ethical ethical JJ 5684 154 2 Duties Duties NNPS 5684 154 3 are be VBP 5684 154 4 of of IN 5684 154 5 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 154 6 , , , 5684 154 7 Juridical Juridical NNP 5684 154 8 Duties Duties NNPS 5684 154 9 of of IN 5684 154 10 strict strict JJ 5684 154 11 , , , 5684 154 12 Obligation obligation NN 5684 154 13 { { -LRB- 5684 154 14 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 154 15 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 154 16 65 65 CD 5684 154 17 } } -RRB- 5684 154 18 This this DT 5684 154 19 proposition proposition NN 5684 154 20 is be VBZ 5684 154 21 a a DT 5684 154 22 consequence consequence NN 5684 154 23 of of IN 5684 154 24 the the DT 5684 154 25 foregoing foregoing NN 5684 154 26 ; ; : 5684 154 27 for for IN 5684 154 28 if if IN 5684 154 29 the the DT 5684 154 30 law law NN 5684 154 31 can can MD 5684 154 32 only only RB 5684 154 33 command command VB 5684 154 34 the the DT 5684 154 35 maxim maxim NN 5684 154 36 of of IN 5684 154 37 the the DT 5684 154 38 actions action NNS 5684 154 39 , , , 5684 154 40 not not RB 5684 154 41 the the DT 5684 154 42 actions action NNS 5684 154 43 themselves -PRON- PRP 5684 154 44 , , , 5684 154 45 this this DT 5684 154 46 is be VBZ 5684 154 47 a a DT 5684 154 48 sign sign NN 5684 154 49 that that IN 5684 154 50 it -PRON- PRP 5684 154 51 leaves leave VBZ 5684 154 52 in in IN 5684 154 53 the the DT 5684 154 54 observance observance NN 5684 154 55 of of IN 5684 154 56 it -PRON- PRP 5684 154 57 a a DT 5684 154 58 latitude latitude NN 5684 154 59 ( ( -LRB- 5684 154 60 latitudo latitudo NN 5684 154 61 ) ) -RRB- 5684 154 62 for for IN 5684 154 63 the the DT 5684 154 64 elective elective NN 5684 154 65 will will MD 5684 154 66 ; ; : 5684 154 67 that that RB 5684 154 68 is is RB 5684 154 69 , , , 5684 154 70 it -PRON- PRP 5684 154 71 can can MD 5684 154 72 not not RB 5684 154 73 definitely definitely RB 5684 154 74 assign assign VB 5684 154 75 how how WRB 5684 154 76 and and CC 5684 154 77 how how WRB 5684 154 78 much much RB 5684 154 79 we -PRON- PRP 5684 154 80 should should MD 5684 154 81 do do VB 5684 154 82 by by IN 5684 154 83 the the DT 5684 154 84 action action NN 5684 154 85 towards towards IN 5684 154 86 the the DT 5684 154 87 end end NN 5684 154 88 which which WDT 5684 154 89 is be VBZ 5684 154 90 also also RB 5684 154 91 duty duty NN 5684 154 92 . . . 5684 155 1 But but CC 5684 155 2 by by IN 5684 155 3 an an DT 5684 155 4 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 155 5 duty duty NN 5684 155 6 is be VBZ 5684 155 7 not not RB 5684 155 8 meant mean VBN 5684 155 9 a a DT 5684 155 10 permission permission NN 5684 155 11 to to TO 5684 155 12 make make VB 5684 155 13 exceptions exception NNS 5684 155 14 from from IN 5684 155 15 the the DT 5684 155 16 maxim maxim NN 5684 155 17 of of IN 5684 155 18 the the DT 5684 155 19 actions action NNS 5684 155 20 , , , 5684 155 21 but but CC 5684 155 22 only only RB 5684 155 23 the the DT 5684 155 24 permission permission NN 5684 155 25 to to TO 5684 155 26 limit limit VB 5684 155 27 one one CD 5684 155 28 maxim maxim NN 5684 155 29 of of IN 5684 155 30 duty duty NN 5684 155 31 by by IN 5684 155 32 another another DT 5684 155 33 ( ( -LRB- 5684 155 34 e. e. NNP 5684 155 35 g. g. NNP 5684 155 36 , , , 5684 155 37 the the DT 5684 155 38 general general JJ 5684 155 39 love love NN 5684 155 40 of of IN 5684 155 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 155 42 neighbour neighbour NN 5684 155 43 by by IN 5684 155 44 the the DT 5684 155 45 love love NN 5684 155 46 of of IN 5684 155 47 parents parent NNS 5684 155 48 ) ) -RRB- 5684 155 49 ; ; : 5684 155 50 and and CC 5684 155 51 this this DT 5684 155 52 in in IN 5684 155 53 fact fact NN 5684 155 54 enlarges enlarge VBZ 5684 155 55 the the DT 5684 155 56 field field NN 5684 155 57 for for IN 5684 155 58 the the DT 5684 155 59 practice practice NN 5684 155 60 of of IN 5684 155 61 virtue virtue NN 5684 155 62 . . . 5684 156 1 The the DT 5684 156 2 more more RBR 5684 156 3 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 156 4 the the DT 5684 156 5 duty duty NN 5684 156 6 , , , 5684 156 7 and and CC 5684 156 8 the the DT 5684 156 9 more more RBR 5684 156 10 imperfect imperfect JJ 5684 156 11 accordingly accordingly RB 5684 156 12 the the DT 5684 156 13 obligation obligation NN 5684 156 14 of of IN 5684 156 15 the the DT 5684 156 16 man man NN 5684 156 17 to to IN 5684 156 18 the the DT 5684 156 19 action action NN 5684 156 20 , , , 5684 156 21 and and CC 5684 156 22 the the DT 5684 156 23 closer close RBR 5684 156 24 he -PRON- PRP 5684 156 25 nevertheless nevertheless RB 5684 156 26 brings bring VBZ 5684 156 27 this this DT 5684 156 28 maxim maxim NN 5684 156 29 of of IN 5684 156 30 obedience obedience NN 5684 156 31 thereto thereto NNP 5684 156 32 ( ( -LRB- 5684 156 33 in in IN 5684 156 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 156 35 own own JJ 5684 156 36 mind mind NN 5684 156 37 ) ) -RRB- 5684 156 38 to to IN 5684 156 39 the the DT 5684 156 40 strict strict JJ 5684 156 41 duty duty NN 5684 156 42 ( ( -LRB- 5684 156 43 of of IN 5684 156 44 justice justice NN 5684 156 45 ) ) -RRB- 5684 156 46 , , , 5684 156 47 so so RB 5684 156 48 much much RB 5684 156 49 the the DT 5684 156 50 more more RBR 5684 156 51 perfect perfect JJ 5684 156 52 is be VBZ 5684 156 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 156 54 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 156 55 action action NN 5684 156 56 . . . 5684 157 1 Hence hence RB 5684 157 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 157 3 is be VBZ 5684 157 4 only only RB 5684 157 5 imperfect imperfect JJ 5684 157 6 duties duty NNS 5684 157 7 that that WDT 5684 157 8 are be VBP 5684 157 9 duties duty NNS 5684 157 10 of of IN 5684 157 11 virtue virtue NN 5684 157 12 . . . 5684 158 1 The the DT 5684 158 2 fulfilment fulfilment NN 5684 158 3 of of IN 5684 158 4 them -PRON- PRP 5684 158 5 is be VBZ 5684 158 6 merit merit NN 5684 158 7 ( ( -LRB- 5684 158 8 meritum meritum NN 5684 158 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 158 10 = = NFP 5684 158 11 + + CC 5684 158 12 a a DT 5684 158 13 ; ; : 5684 158 14 but but CC 5684 158 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 158 16 transgression transgression NN 5684 158 17 is be VBZ 5684 158 18 not not RB 5684 158 19 necessarily necessarily RB 5684 158 20 demerit demerit NN 5684 158 21 ( ( -LRB- 5684 158 22 demeritum demeritum NN 5684 158 23 ) ) -RRB- 5684 158 24 = = NFP 5684 158 25 - - : 5684 158 26 a a LS 5684 158 27 , , , 5684 158 28 but but CC 5684 158 29 only only RB 5684 158 30 moral moral JJ 5684 158 31 unworth unworth NN 5684 158 32 = = SYM 5684 158 33 o o XX 5684 158 34 , , , 5684 158 35 unless unless IN 5684 158 36 the the DT 5684 158 37 agent agent NN 5684 158 38 made make VBD 5684 158 39 it -PRON- PRP 5684 158 40 a a DT 5684 158 41 principle principle NN 5684 158 42 not not RB 5684 158 43 to to TO 5684 158 44 conform conform VB 5684 158 45 to to IN 5684 158 46 those those DT 5684 158 47 duties duty NNS 5684 158 48 . . . 5684 159 1 The the DT 5684 159 2 strength strength NN 5684 159 3 of of IN 5684 159 4 purpose purpose NN 5684 159 5 in in IN 5684 159 6 the the DT 5684 159 7 former former JJ 5684 159 8 case case NN 5684 159 9 is be VBZ 5684 159 10 alone alone JJ 5684 159 11 properly properly RB 5684 159 12 called call VBN 5684 159 13 virtue virtue NN 5684 159 14 [ [ -LRB- 5684 159 15 Tugend tugend NN 5684 159 16 ] ] -RRB- 5684 159 17 ( ( -LRB- 5684 159 18 virtus virtus NNP 5684 159 19 ) ) -RRB- 5684 159 20 ; ; : 5684 159 21 the the DT 5684 159 22 weakness weakness NN 5684 159 23 in in IN 5684 159 24 the the DT 5684 159 25 latter latter JJ 5684 159 26 case case NN 5684 159 27 is be VBZ 5684 159 28 not not RB 5684 159 29 vice vice NN 5684 159 30 ( ( -LRB- 5684 159 31 vitium vitium NN 5684 159 32 ) ) -RRB- 5684 159 33 , , , 5684 159 34 but but CC 5684 159 35 rather rather RB 5684 159 36 only only RB 5684 159 37 lack lack NN 5684 159 38 of of IN 5684 159 39 virtue virtue NN 5684 159 40 [ [ -LRB- 5684 159 41 Untugend Untugend NNP 5684 159 42 ] ] -RRB- 5684 159 43 , , , 5684 159 44 a a DT 5684 159 45 want want NN 5684 159 46 of of IN 5684 159 47 moral moral JJ 5684 159 48 strength strength NN 5684 159 49 ( ( -LRB- 5684 159 50 defectus defectus NNP 5684 159 51 moralis moralis NNP 5684 159 52 ) ) -RRB- 5684 159 53 . . . 5684 160 1 ( ( -LRB- 5684 160 2 As as IN 5684 160 3 the the DT 5684 160 4 word word NN 5684 160 5 Tugend tugend NN 5684 160 6 is be VBZ 5684 160 7 derived derive VBN 5684 160 8 from from IN 5684 160 9 taugen taugen NN 5684 160 10 [ [ -LRB- 5684 160 11 to to TO 5684 160 12 be be VB 5684 160 13 good good JJ 5684 160 14 for for IN 5684 160 15 something something NN 5684 160 16 ] ] -RRB- 5684 160 17 , , , 5684 160 18 Untugend untugend NN 5684 160 19 by by IN 5684 160 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 160 21 etymology etymology NN 5684 160 22 signifies signifie NNS 5684 160 23 good good JJ 5684 160 24 for for IN 5684 160 25 nothing nothing NN 5684 160 26 . . . 5684 160 27 ) ) -RRB- 5684 161 1 Every every DT 5684 161 2 action action NN 5684 161 3 contrary contrary JJ 5684 161 4 to to IN 5684 161 5 duty duty NN 5684 161 6 is be VBZ 5684 161 7 called call VBN 5684 161 8 transgression transgression NN 5684 161 9 ( ( -LRB- 5684 161 10 peccatum peccatum NNP 5684 161 11 ) ) -RRB- 5684 161 12 . . . 5684 162 1 Deliberate deliberate JJ 5684 162 2 transgression transgression NN 5684 162 3 which which WDT 5684 162 4 has have VBZ 5684 162 5 become become VBN 5684 162 6 a a DT 5684 162 7 principle principle NN 5684 162 8 is be VBZ 5684 162 9 what what WP 5684 162 10 properly properly RB 5684 162 11 constitutes constitute VBZ 5684 162 12 what what WP 5684 162 13 is be VBZ 5684 162 14 called call VBN 5684 162 15 vice vice NN 5684 162 16 ( ( -LRB- 5684 162 17 vitium vitium NN 5684 162 18 ) ) -RRB- 5684 162 19 . . . 5684 163 1 Although although IN 5684 163 2 the the DT 5684 163 3 conformity conformity NN 5684 163 4 of of IN 5684 163 5 actions action NNS 5684 163 6 to to IN 5684 163 7 justice justice NN 5684 163 8 ( ( -LRB- 5684 163 9 i.e. i.e. FW 5684 163 10 , , , 5684 163 11 to to TO 5684 163 12 be be VB 5684 163 13 an an DT 5684 163 14 upright upright JJ 5684 163 15 man man NN 5684 163 16 ) ) -RRB- 5684 163 17 is be VBZ 5684 163 18 nothing nothing NN 5684 163 19 meritorious meritorious JJ 5684 163 20 , , , 5684 163 21 yet yet CC 5684 163 22 the the DT 5684 163 23 conformity conformity NN 5684 163 24 of of IN 5684 163 25 the the DT 5684 163 26 maxim maxim NN 5684 163 27 of of IN 5684 163 28 such such JJ 5684 163 29 actions action NNS 5684 163 30 regarded regard VBN 5684 163 31 as as IN 5684 163 32 duties duty NNS 5684 163 33 , , , 5684 163 34 that that RB 5684 163 35 is is RB 5684 163 36 , , , 5684 163 37 reverence reverence NN 5684 163 38 for for IN 5684 163 39 justice justice NN 5684 163 40 is be VBZ 5684 163 41 meritorious meritorious JJ 5684 163 42 . . . 5684 164 1 For for IN 5684 164 2 by by IN 5684 164 3 this this DT 5684 164 4 the the DT 5684 164 5 man man NN 5684 164 6 makes make VBZ 5684 164 7 the the DT 5684 164 8 right right NN 5684 164 9 of of IN 5684 164 10 humanity humanity NN 5684 164 11 or or CC 5684 164 12 of of IN 5684 164 13 men man NNS 5684 164 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 164 15 own own JJ 5684 164 16 end end NN 5684 164 17 , , , 5684 164 18 and and CC 5684 164 19 thereby thereby RB 5684 164 20 enlarges enlarge VBZ 5684 164 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 164 22 notion notion NN 5684 164 23 of of IN 5684 164 24 duty duty NN 5684 164 25 beyond beyond IN 5684 164 26 that that DT 5684 164 27 of of IN 5684 164 28 indebtedness indebtedness NN 5684 164 29 ( ( -LRB- 5684 164 30 officium officium NNP 5684 164 31 debiti debiti NNP 5684 164 32 ) ) -RRB- 5684 164 33 , , , 5684 164 34 since since IN 5684 164 35 although although IN 5684 164 36 another another DT 5684 164 37 man man NN 5684 164 38 by by IN 5684 164 39 virtue virtue NN 5684 164 40 of of IN 5684 164 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 164 42 rights right NNS 5684 164 43 can can MD 5684 164 44 demand demand VB 5684 164 45 that that IN 5684 164 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 164 47 actions action NNS 5684 164 48 shall shall MD 5684 164 49 conform conform VB 5684 164 50 to to IN 5684 164 51 the the DT 5684 164 52 law law NN 5684 164 53 , , , 5684 164 54 he -PRON- PRP 5684 164 55 can can MD 5684 164 56 not not RB 5684 164 57 demand demand VB 5684 164 58 that that IN 5684 164 59 the the DT 5684 164 60 law law NN 5684 164 61 shall shall MD 5684 164 62 also also RB 5684 164 63 contain contain VB 5684 164 64 the the DT 5684 164 65 spring spring NN 5684 164 66 of of IN 5684 164 67 these these DT 5684 164 68 actions action NNS 5684 164 69 . . . 5684 165 1 The the DT 5684 165 2 same same JJ 5684 165 3 thing thing NN 5684 165 4 is be VBZ 5684 165 5 true true JJ 5684 165 6 of of IN 5684 165 7 the the DT 5684 165 8 general general NNP 5684 165 9 ethical ethical JJ 5684 165 10 command command NNP 5684 165 11 , , , 5684 165 12 " " `` 5684 165 13 Act act VB 5684 165 14 dutifully dutifully RB 5684 165 15 from from IN 5684 165 16 a a DT 5684 165 17 sense sense NN 5684 165 18 of of IN 5684 165 19 duty duty NN 5684 165 20 . . . 5684 165 21 " " '' 5684 166 1 To to TO 5684 166 2 fix fix VB 5684 166 3 this this DT 5684 166 4 disposition disposition NN 5684 166 5 firmly firmly RB 5684 166 6 in in IN 5684 166 7 one one NN 5684 166 8 's 's POS 5684 166 9 mind mind NN 5684 166 10 and and CC 5684 166 11 to to TO 5684 166 12 quicken quicken VB 5684 166 13 it -PRON- PRP 5684 166 14 is be VBZ 5684 166 15 , , , 5684 166 16 as as IN 5684 166 17 in in IN 5684 166 18 the the DT 5684 166 19 former former JJ 5684 166 20 case case NN 5684 166 21 , , , 5684 166 22 meritorious meritorious JJ 5684 166 23 , , , 5684 166 24 because because IN 5684 166 25 it -PRON- PRP 5684 166 26 goes go VBZ 5684 166 27 beyond beyond IN 5684 166 28 the the DT 5684 166 29 law law NN 5684 166 30 of of IN 5684 166 31 duty duty NN 5684 166 32 in in IN 5684 166 33 actions action NNS 5684 166 34 and and CC 5684 166 35 makes make VBZ 5684 166 36 the the DT 5684 166 37 law law NN 5684 166 38 in in IN 5684 166 39 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 166 40 the the DT 5684 166 41 spring spring NN 5684 166 42 . . . 5684 167 1 But but CC 5684 167 2 just just RB 5684 167 3 for for IN 5684 167 4 or or CC 5684 167 5 reason reason NN 5684 167 6 , , , 5684 167 7 those those DT 5684 167 8 duties duty NNS 5684 167 9 also also RB 5684 167 10 must must MD 5684 167 11 be be VB 5684 167 12 reckoned reckon VBN 5684 167 13 as as IN 5684 167 14 of of IN 5684 167 15 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 167 16 obligation obligation NN 5684 167 17 , , , 5684 167 18 in in IN 5684 167 19 respect respect NN 5684 167 20 of of IN 5684 167 21 which which WDT 5684 167 22 there there EX 5684 167 23 exists exist VBZ 5684 167 24 a a DT 5684 167 25 subjective subjective JJ 5684 167 26 principle principle NN 5684 167 27 which which WDT 5684 167 28 ethically ethically RB 5684 167 29 rewards reward VBZ 5684 167 30 them -PRON- PRP 5684 167 31 ; ; : 5684 167 32 or or CC 5684 167 33 to to TO 5684 167 34 bring bring VB 5684 167 35 them -PRON- PRP 5684 167 36 as as RB 5684 167 37 near near RB 5684 167 38 as as IN 5684 167 39 possible possible JJ 5684 167 40 to to IN 5684 167 41 the the DT 5684 167 42 notion notion NN 5684 167 43 of of IN 5684 167 44 a a DT 5684 167 45 strict strict JJ 5684 167 46 obligation obligation NN 5684 167 47 , , , 5684 167 48 a a DT 5684 167 49 principle principle NN 5684 167 50 of of IN 5684 167 51 susceptibility susceptibility NN 5684 167 52 of of IN 5684 167 53 this this DT 5684 167 54 reward reward NN 5684 167 55 according accord VBG 5684 167 56 to to IN 5684 167 57 the the DT 5684 167 58 law law NN 5684 167 59 of of IN 5684 167 60 virtue virtue NN 5684 167 61 ; ; : 5684 167 62 namely namely RB 5684 167 63 , , , 5684 167 64 a a DT 5684 167 65 moral moral JJ 5684 167 66 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 167 67 which which WDT 5684 167 68 goes go VBZ 5684 167 69 beyond beyond IN 5684 167 70 mere mere JJ 5684 167 71 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 167 72 with with IN 5684 167 73 oneself oneself PRP 5684 167 74 ( ( -LRB- 5684 167 75 which which WDT 5684 167 76 may may MD 5684 167 77 be be VB 5684 167 78 merely merely RB 5684 167 79 negative negative JJ 5684 167 80 ) ) -RRB- 5684 167 81 , , , 5684 167 82 and and CC 5684 167 83 of of IN 5684 167 84 which which WDT 5684 167 85 it -PRON- PRP 5684 167 86 is be VBZ 5684 167 87 proudly proudly RB 5684 167 88 said say VBN 5684 167 89 that that IN 5684 167 90 in in IN 5684 167 91 this this DT 5684 167 92 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 167 93 virtue virtue NN 5684 167 94 is be VBZ 5684 167 95 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 167 96 own own JJ 5684 167 97 reward reward NN 5684 167 98 . . . 5684 168 1 { { -LRB- 5684 168 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 168 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 168 4 70 70 CD 5684 168 5 } } -RRB- 5684 168 6 When when WRB 5684 168 7 this this DT 5684 168 8 merit merit NN 5684 168 9 is be VBZ 5684 168 10 a a DT 5684 168 11 merit merit NN 5684 168 12 of of IN 5684 168 13 the the DT 5684 168 14 man man NN 5684 168 15 in in IN 5684 168 16 respect respect NN 5684 168 17 of of IN 5684 168 18 other other JJ 5684 168 19 men man NNS 5684 168 20 of of IN 5684 168 21 promoting promote VBG 5684 168 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 168 23 natural natural JJ 5684 168 24 ends end NNS 5684 168 25 , , , 5684 168 26 which which WDT 5684 168 27 are be VBP 5684 168 28 recognized recognize VBN 5684 168 29 as as IN 5684 168 30 such such JJ 5684 168 31 by by IN 5684 168 32 all all DT 5684 168 33 men man NNS 5684 168 34 ( ( -LRB- 5684 168 35 making make VBG 5684 168 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 168 37 happiness happiness NN 5684 168 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 168 39 own own JJ 5684 168 40 ) ) -RRB- 5684 168 41 , , , 5684 168 42 we -PRON- PRP 5684 168 43 might may MD 5684 168 44 call call VB 5684 168 45 it -PRON- PRP 5684 168 46 the the DT 5684 168 47 sweet sweet JJ 5684 168 48 merit merit NN 5684 168 49 , , , 5684 168 50 the the DT 5684 168 51 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 168 52 of of IN 5684 168 53 which which WDT 5684 168 54 creates create VBZ 5684 168 55 a a DT 5684 168 56 moral moral JJ 5684 168 57 enjoyment enjoyment NN 5684 168 58 in in IN 5684 168 59 which which WDT 5684 168 60 men man NNS 5684 168 61 are be VBP 5684 168 62 by by IN 5684 168 63 sympathy sympathy NN 5684 168 64 inclined incline VBN 5684 168 65 to to TO 5684 168 66 revel revel VB 5684 168 67 ; ; : 5684 168 68 whereas whereas IN 5684 168 69 the the DT 5684 168 70 bitter bitter JJ 5684 168 71 merit merit NN 5684 168 72 of of IN 5684 168 73 promoting promote VBG 5684 168 74 the the DT 5684 168 75 true true JJ 5684 168 76 welfare welfare NN 5684 168 77 of of IN 5684 168 78 other other JJ 5684 168 79 men man NNS 5684 168 80 , , , 5684 168 81 even even RB 5684 168 82 though though IN 5684 168 83 they -PRON- PRP 5684 168 84 should should MD 5684 168 85 not not RB 5684 168 86 recognize recognize VB 5684 168 87 it -PRON- PRP 5684 168 88 as as IN 5684 168 89 such such JJ 5684 168 90 ( ( -LRB- 5684 168 91 in in IN 5684 168 92 the the DT 5684 168 93 case case NN 5684 168 94 of of IN 5684 168 95 the the DT 5684 168 96 unthankful unthankful JJ 5684 168 97 and and CC 5684 168 98 ungrateful ungrateful JJ 5684 168 99 ) ) -RRB- 5684 168 100 , , , 5684 168 101 has have VBZ 5684 168 102 commonly commonly RB 5684 168 103 no no DT 5684 168 104 such such JJ 5684 168 105 reaction reaction NN 5684 168 106 , , , 5684 168 107 but but CC 5684 168 108 only only RB 5684 168 109 produces produce VBZ 5684 168 110 a a DT 5684 168 111 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 168 112 with with IN 5684 168 113 one one PRP 5684 168 114 's 's POS 5684 168 115 self self NN 5684 168 116 , , , 5684 168 117 although although IN 5684 168 118 in in IN 5684 168 119 the the DT 5684 168 120 latter latter JJ 5684 168 121 case case NN 5684 168 122 this this DT 5684 168 123 would would MD 5684 168 124 be be VB 5684 168 125 even even RB 5684 168 126 greater great JJR 5684 168 127 . . . 5684 169 1 VIII VIII NNP 5684 169 2 . . . 5684 170 1 Exposition exposition NN 5684 170 2 of of IN 5684 170 3 the the DT 5684 170 4 Duties Duties NNPS 5684 170 5 of of IN 5684 170 6 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 170 7 as as IN 5684 170 8 Intermediate Intermediate NNP 5684 170 9 Duties Duties NNPS 5684 170 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 170 11 1 1 LS 5684 170 12 ) ) -RRB- 5684 170 13 OUR our PRP$ 5684 170 14 OWN own JJ 5684 170 15 PERFECTION perfection NN 5684 170 16 as as IN 5684 170 17 an an DT 5684 170 18 end end NN 5684 170 19 which which WDT 5684 170 20 is be VBZ 5684 170 21 also also RB 5684 170 22 a a DT 5684 170 23 duty duty NN 5684 170 24 { { -LRB- 5684 170 25 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 170 26 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 170 27 75 75 CD 5684 170 28 } } -RRB- 5684 170 29 ( ( -LRB- 5684 170 30 a a DT 5684 170 31 ) ) -RRB- 5684 170 32 Physical physical JJ 5684 170 33 perfection perfection NN 5684 170 34 ; ; : 5684 170 35 that that RB 5684 170 36 is is RB 5684 170 37 , , , 5684 170 38 cultivation cultivation NN 5684 170 39 of of IN 5684 170 40 all all DT 5684 170 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 170 42 faculties faculty NNS 5684 170 43 generally generally RB 5684 170 44 for for IN 5684 170 45 the the DT 5684 170 46 promotion promotion NN 5684 170 47 of of IN 5684 170 48 the the DT 5684 170 49 ends end NNS 5684 170 50 set set VBN 5684 170 51 before before IN 5684 170 52 us -PRON- PRP 5684 170 53 by by IN 5684 170 54 reason reason NN 5684 170 55 . . . 5684 171 1 That that IN 5684 171 2 this this DT 5684 171 3 is be VBZ 5684 171 4 a a DT 5684 171 5 duty duty NN 5684 171 6 , , , 5684 171 7 and and CC 5684 171 8 therefore therefore RB 5684 171 9 an an DT 5684 171 10 end end NN 5684 171 11 in in IN 5684 171 12 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 171 13 , , , 5684 171 14 and and CC 5684 171 15 that that IN 5684 171 16 the the DT 5684 171 17 effort effort NN 5684 171 18 to to TO 5684 171 19 effect effect VB 5684 171 20 this this DT 5684 171 21 even even RB 5684 171 22 without without IN 5684 171 23 regard regard NN 5684 171 24 to to IN 5684 171 25 the the DT 5684 171 26 advantage advantage NN 5684 171 27 that that WDT 5684 171 28 it -PRON- PRP 5684 171 29 secures secure VBZ 5684 171 30 us -PRON- PRP 5684 171 31 , , , 5684 171 32 is be VBZ 5684 171 33 based base VBN 5684 171 34 , , , 5684 171 35 not not RB 5684 171 36 on on IN 5684 171 37 a a DT 5684 171 38 conditional conditional JJ 5684 171 39 ( ( -LRB- 5684 171 40 pragmatic pragmatic JJ 5684 171 41 ) ) -RRB- 5684 171 42 , , , 5684 171 43 but but CC 5684 171 44 an an DT 5684 171 45 unconditional unconditional JJ 5684 171 46 ( ( -LRB- 5684 171 47 moral moral JJ 5684 171 48 ) ) -RRB- 5684 171 49 imperative imperative NN 5684 171 50 , , , 5684 171 51 may may MD 5684 171 52 be be VB 5684 171 53 seen see VBN 5684 171 54 from from IN 5684 171 55 the the DT 5684 171 56 following follow VBG 5684 171 57 consideration consideration NN 5684 171 58 . . . 5684 172 1 The the DT 5684 172 2 power power NN 5684 172 3 of of IN 5684 172 4 proposing propose VBG 5684 172 5 to to IN 5684 172 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 5684 172 7 an an DT 5684 172 8 end end NN 5684 172 9 is be VBZ 5684 172 10 the the DT 5684 172 11 characteristic characteristic NN 5684 172 12 of of IN 5684 172 13 humanity humanity NN 5684 172 14 ( ( -LRB- 5684 172 15 as as IN 5684 172 16 distinguished distinguish VBN 5684 172 17 from from IN 5684 172 18 the the DT 5684 172 19 brutes brute NNS 5684 172 20 ) ) -RRB- 5684 172 21 . . . 5684 173 1 With with IN 5684 173 2 the the DT 5684 173 3 end end NN 5684 173 4 of of IN 5684 173 5 humanity humanity NN 5684 173 6 in in IN 5684 173 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 173 8 own own JJ 5684 173 9 person person NN 5684 173 10 is be VBZ 5684 173 11 therefore therefore RB 5684 173 12 combined combine VBN 5684 173 13 the the DT 5684 173 14 rational rational JJ 5684 173 15 will will NN 5684 173 16 , , , 5684 173 17 and and CC 5684 173 18 consequently consequently RB 5684 173 19 the the DT 5684 173 20 duty duty NN 5684 173 21 of of IN 5684 173 22 deserving deserve VBG 5684 173 23 well well RB 5684 173 24 of of IN 5684 173 25 humanity humanity NN 5684 173 26 by by IN 5684 173 27 culture culture NN 5684 173 28 generally generally RB 5684 173 29 , , , 5684 173 30 by by IN 5684 173 31 acquiring acquire VBG 5684 173 32 or or CC 5684 173 33 advancing advance VBG 5684 173 34 the the DT 5684 173 35 power power NN 5684 173 36 to to TO 5684 173 37 carry carry VB 5684 173 38 out out RP 5684 173 39 all all DT 5684 173 40 sorts sort NNS 5684 173 41 of of IN 5684 173 42 possible possible JJ 5684 173 43 ends end NNS 5684 173 44 , , , 5684 173 45 so so RB 5684 173 46 far far RB 5684 173 47 as as IN 5684 173 48 this this DT 5684 173 49 power power NN 5684 173 50 is be VBZ 5684 173 51 to to TO 5684 173 52 be be VB 5684 173 53 found find VBN 5684 173 54 in in IN 5684 173 55 man man NN 5684 173 56 ; ; : 5684 173 57 that that RB 5684 173 58 is is RB 5684 173 59 , , , 5684 173 60 it -PRON- PRP 5684 173 61 is be VBZ 5684 173 62 a a DT 5684 173 63 duty duty NN 5684 173 64 to to TO 5684 173 65 cultivate cultivate VB 5684 173 66 the the DT 5684 173 67 crude crude JJ 5684 173 68 capacities capacity NNS 5684 173 69 of of IN 5684 173 70 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 173 71 nature nature NN 5684 173 72 , , , 5684 173 73 since since IN 5684 173 74 it -PRON- PRP 5684 173 75 is be VBZ 5684 173 76 by by IN 5684 173 77 that that DT 5684 173 78 cultivation cultivation NN 5684 173 79 that that IN 5684 173 80 the the DT 5684 173 81 animal animal NN 5684 173 82 is be VBZ 5684 173 83 raised raise VBN 5684 173 84 to to IN 5684 173 85 man man NN 5684 173 86 , , , 5684 173 87 therefore therefore RB 5684 173 88 it -PRON- PRP 5684 173 89 is be VBZ 5684 173 90 a a DT 5684 173 91 duty duty NN 5684 173 92 in in IN 5684 173 93 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 173 94 . . . 5684 174 1 This this DT 5684 174 2 duty duty NN 5684 174 3 , , , 5684 174 4 however however RB 5684 174 5 , , , 5684 174 6 is be VBZ 5684 174 7 merely merely RB 5684 174 8 ethical ethical JJ 5684 174 9 , , , 5684 174 10 that that RB 5684 174 11 is is RB 5684 174 12 , , , 5684 174 13 of of IN 5684 174 14 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 174 15 obligation obligation NN 5684 174 16 . . . 5684 175 1 No no DT 5684 175 2 principle principle NN 5684 175 3 of of IN 5684 175 4 reason reason NN 5684 175 5 prescribes prescribe VBZ 5684 175 6 how how WRB 5684 175 7 far far RB 5684 175 8 one one PRP 5684 175 9 must must MD 5684 175 10 go go VB 5684 175 11 in in IN 5684 175 12 this this DT 5684 175 13 effort effort NN 5684 175 14 ( ( -LRB- 5684 175 15 in in IN 5684 175 16 enlarging enlarge VBG 5684 175 17 or or CC 5684 175 18 correcting correct VBG 5684 175 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 175 20 faculty faculty NN 5684 175 21 of of IN 5684 175 22 understanding understanding NN 5684 175 23 , , , 5684 175 24 that that RB 5684 175 25 is is RB 5684 175 26 , , , 5684 175 27 in in IN 5684 175 28 acquisition acquisition NN 5684 175 29 of of IN 5684 175 30 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 175 31 or or CC 5684 175 32 technical technical JJ 5684 175 33 capacity capacity NN 5684 175 34 ) ) -RRB- 5684 175 35 ; ; : 5684 175 36 and and CC 5684 175 37 besides besides IN 5684 175 38 the the DT 5684 175 39 difference difference NN 5684 175 40 in in IN 5684 175 41 the the DT 5684 175 42 circumstances circumstance NNS 5684 175 43 into into IN 5684 175 44 which which WDT 5684 175 45 men man NNS 5684 175 46 may may MD 5684 175 47 come come VB 5684 175 48 makes make VBZ 5684 175 49 the the DT 5684 175 50 choice choice NN 5684 175 51 of of IN 5684 175 52 the the DT 5684 175 53 kind kind NN 5684 175 54 of of IN 5684 175 55 employment employment NN 5684 175 56 for for IN 5684 175 57 which which WDT 5684 175 58 he -PRON- PRP 5684 175 59 should should MD 5684 175 60 cultivate cultivate VB 5684 175 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 175 62 talent talent NN 5684 175 63 very very RB 5684 175 64 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 5684 175 65 . . . 5684 176 1 Here here RB 5684 176 2 , , , 5684 176 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 176 4 , , , 5684 176 5 there there EX 5684 176 6 is be VBZ 5684 176 7 no no DT 5684 176 8 law law NN 5684 176 9 of of IN 5684 176 10 reason reason NN 5684 176 11 for for IN 5684 176 12 actions action NNS 5684 176 13 , , , 5684 176 14 but but CC 5684 176 15 only only RB 5684 176 16 for for IN 5684 176 17 the the DT 5684 176 18 maxim maxim NN 5684 176 19 of of IN 5684 176 20 actions action NNS 5684 176 21 , , , 5684 176 22 viz viz NN 5684 176 23 . . . 5684 177 1 : : : 5684 177 2 " " `` 5684 177 3 Cultivate cultivate VB 5684 177 4 thy thy PRP$ 5684 177 5 faculties faculty NNS 5684 177 6 of of IN 5684 177 7 mind mind NN 5684 177 8 and and CC 5684 177 9 body body NN 5684 177 10 so so IN 5684 177 11 as as IN 5684 177 12 to to TO 5684 177 13 be be VB 5684 177 14 effective effective JJ 5684 177 15 for for IN 5684 177 16 all all DT 5684 177 17 ends end NNS 5684 177 18 that that WDT 5684 177 19 may may MD 5684 177 20 come come VB 5684 177 21 in in IN 5684 177 22 thy thy PRP$ 5684 177 23 way way NN 5684 177 24 , , , 5684 177 25 uncertain uncertain JJ 5684 177 26 which which WDT 5684 177 27 of of IN 5684 177 28 them -PRON- PRP 5684 177 29 may may MD 5684 177 30 become become VB 5684 177 31 thy thy PRP$ 5684 177 32 own own JJ 5684 177 33 . . . 5684 177 34 " " '' 5684 178 1 ( ( -LRB- 5684 178 2 b b LS 5684 178 3 ) ) -RRB- 5684 178 4 Cultivation cultivation NN 5684 178 5 of of IN 5684 178 6 Morality morality NN 5684 178 7 in in IN 5684 178 8 ourselves -PRON- PRP 5684 178 9 . . . 5684 179 1 The the DT 5684 179 2 greatest great JJS 5684 179 3 moral moral JJ 5684 179 4 perfection perfection NN 5684 179 5 of of IN 5684 179 6 man man NN 5684 179 7 is be VBZ 5684 179 8 to to TO 5684 179 9 do do VB 5684 179 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 179 11 duty duty NN 5684 179 12 , , , 5684 179 13 and and CC 5684 179 14 that that IN 5684 179 15 from from IN 5684 179 16 duty duty NN 5684 179 17 ( ( -LRB- 5684 179 18 that that IN 5684 179 19 the the DT 5684 179 20 law law NN 5684 179 21 be be VB 5684 179 22 not not RB 5684 179 23 only only RB 5684 179 24 the the DT 5684 179 25 rule rule NN 5684 179 26 but but CC 5684 179 27 also also RB 5684 179 28 the the DT 5684 179 29 spring spring NN 5684 179 30 of of IN 5684 179 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 179 32 actions action NNS 5684 179 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 179 34 . . . 5684 180 1 Now now RB 5684 180 2 at at IN 5684 180 3 first first JJ 5684 180 4 sight sight NN 5684 180 5 this this DT 5684 180 6 seems seem VBZ 5684 180 7 to to TO 5684 180 8 be be VB 5684 180 9 a a DT 5684 180 10 strict strict JJ 5684 180 11 obligation obligation NN 5684 180 12 , , , 5684 180 13 and and CC 5684 180 14 as as IN 5684 180 15 if if IN 5684 180 16 the the DT 5684 180 17 principle principle NN 5684 180 18 of of IN 5684 180 19 duty duty NN 5684 180 20 commanded command VBD 5684 180 21 not not RB 5684 180 22 merely merely RB 5684 180 23 the the DT 5684 180 24 legality legality NN 5684 180 25 of of IN 5684 180 26 every every DT 5684 180 27 action action NN 5684 180 28 , , , 5684 180 29 but but CC 5684 180 30 also also RB 5684 180 31 the the DT 5684 180 32 morality morality NN 5684 180 33 , , , 5684 180 34 i.e. i.e. FW 5684 180 35 , , , 5684 180 36 the the DT 5684 180 37 mental mental JJ 5684 180 38 disposition disposition NN 5684 180 39 , , , 5684 180 40 with with IN 5684 180 41 the the DT 5684 180 42 exactness exactness NN 5684 180 43 and and CC 5684 180 44 strictness strictness NN 5684 180 45 of of IN 5684 180 46 a a DT 5684 180 47 law law NN 5684 180 48 ; ; : 5684 180 49 but but CC 5684 180 50 in in IN 5684 180 51 fact fact NN 5684 180 52 the the DT 5684 180 53 law law NN 5684 180 54 commands command VBZ 5684 180 55 even even RB 5684 180 56 here here RB 5684 180 57 only only RB 5684 180 58 the the DT 5684 180 59 maxim maxim NN 5684 180 60 of of IN 5684 180 61 the the DT 5684 180 62 action action NN 5684 180 63 , , , 5684 180 64 namely namely RB 5684 180 65 , , , 5684 180 66 that that IN 5684 180 67 we -PRON- PRP 5684 180 68 should should MD 5684 180 69 seek seek VB 5684 180 70 the the DT 5684 180 71 ground ground NN 5684 180 72 of of IN 5684 180 73 obligation obligation NN 5684 180 74 , , , 5684 180 75 not not RB 5684 180 76 in in IN 5684 180 77 the the DT 5684 180 78 sensible sensible JJ 5684 180 79 impulses impulse NNS 5684 180 80 ( ( -LRB- 5684 180 81 advantage advantage NN 5684 180 82 or or CC 5684 180 83 disadvantage disadvantage NN 5684 180 84 ) ) -RRB- 5684 180 85 , , , 5684 180 86 but but CC 5684 180 87 wholly wholly RB 5684 180 88 in in IN 5684 180 89 the the DT 5684 180 90 law law NN 5684 180 91 ; ; : 5684 180 92 so so IN 5684 180 93 that that IN 5684 180 94 the the DT 5684 180 95 action action NN 5684 180 96 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 180 97 is be VBZ 5684 180 98 not not RB 5684 180 99 commanded command VBN 5684 180 100 . . . 5684 181 1 For for IN 5684 181 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 181 3 is be VBZ 5684 181 4 not not RB 5684 181 5 possible possible JJ 5684 181 6 to to TO 5684 181 7 man man VB 5684 181 8 to to TO 5684 181 9 see see VB 5684 181 10 so so RB 5684 181 11 far far RB 5684 181 12 into into IN 5684 181 13 the the DT 5684 181 14 depth depth NN 5684 181 15 of of IN 5684 181 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 181 17 own own JJ 5684 181 18 heart heart NN 5684 181 19 that that IN 5684 181 20 he -PRON- PRP 5684 181 21 could could MD 5684 181 22 ever ever RB 5684 181 23 be be VB 5684 181 24 thoroughly thoroughly RB 5684 181 25 certain certain JJ 5684 181 26 of of IN 5684 181 27 the the DT 5684 181 28 purity purity NN 5684 181 29 of of IN 5684 181 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 181 31 moral moral JJ 5684 181 32 purpose purpose NN 5684 181 33 and and CC 5684 181 34 the the DT 5684 181 35 sincerity sincerity NN 5684 181 36 of of IN 5684 181 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 181 38 mind mind NN 5684 181 39 even even RB 5684 181 40 in in IN 5684 181 41 one one CD 5684 181 42 single single JJ 5684 181 43 action action NN 5684 181 44 , , , 5684 181 45 although although IN 5684 181 46 he -PRON- PRP 5684 181 47 has have VBZ 5684 181 48 no no DT 5684 181 49 doubt doubt NN 5684 181 50 about about IN 5684 181 51 the the DT 5684 181 52 legality legality NN 5684 181 53 of of IN 5684 181 54 it -PRON- PRP 5684 181 55 . . . 5684 182 1 Nay nay UH 5684 182 2 , , , 5684 182 3 often often RB 5684 182 4 the the DT 5684 182 5 weakness weakness NN 5684 182 6 which which WDT 5684 182 7 deters deter VBZ 5684 182 8 a a DT 5684 182 9 man man NN 5684 182 10 from from IN 5684 182 11 the the DT 5684 182 12 risk risk NN 5684 182 13 of of IN 5684 182 14 a a DT 5684 182 15 crime crime NN 5684 182 16 is be VBZ 5684 182 17 regarded regard VBN 5684 182 18 by by IN 5684 182 19 him -PRON- PRP 5684 182 20 as as IN 5684 182 21 virtue virtue NN 5684 182 22 ( ( -LRB- 5684 182 23 which which WDT 5684 182 24 gives give VBZ 5684 182 25 the the DT 5684 182 26 notion notion NN 5684 182 27 of of IN 5684 182 28 strength strength NN 5684 182 29 ) ) -RRB- 5684 182 30 . . . 5684 183 1 And and CC 5684 183 2 how how WRB 5684 183 3 many many JJ 5684 183 4 there there EX 5684 183 5 are be VBP 5684 183 6 who who WP 5684 183 7 may may MD 5684 183 8 have have VB 5684 183 9 led lead VBN 5684 183 10 a a DT 5684 183 11 long long JJ 5684 183 12 blameless blameless JJ 5684 183 13 life life NN 5684 183 14 , , , 5684 183 15 who who WP 5684 183 16 are be VBP 5684 183 17 only only RB 5684 183 18 fortunate fortunate JJ 5684 183 19 in in IN 5684 183 20 having have VBG 5684 183 21 escaped escape VBN 5684 183 22 so so RB 5684 183 23 many many JJ 5684 183 24 temptations temptation NNS 5684 183 25 . . . 5684 184 1 How how WRB 5684 184 2 much much JJ 5684 184 3 of of IN 5684 184 4 the the DT 5684 184 5 element element NN 5684 184 6 of of IN 5684 184 7 pure pure JJ 5684 184 8 morality morality NN 5684 184 9 in in IN 5684 184 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 184 11 mental mental JJ 5684 184 12 disposition disposition NN 5684 184 13 may may MD 5684 184 14 have have VB 5684 184 15 belonged belong VBN 5684 184 16 to to IN 5684 184 17 each each DT 5684 184 18 deed deed NN 5684 184 19 remains remain VBZ 5684 184 20 hidden hide VBN 5684 184 21 even even RB 5684 184 22 from from IN 5684 184 23 themselves -PRON- PRP 5684 184 24 . . . 5684 185 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 5684 185 2 , , , 5684 185 3 this this DT 5684 185 4 duty duty NN 5684 185 5 to to TO 5684 185 6 estimate estimate VB 5684 185 7 the the DT 5684 185 8 worth worth NN 5684 185 9 of of IN 5684 185 10 one one PRP 5684 185 11 's 's POS 5684 185 12 actions action NNS 5684 185 13 not not RB 5684 185 14 merely merely RB 5684 185 15 by by IN 5684 185 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 185 17 legality legality NN 5684 185 18 , , , 5684 185 19 but but CC 5684 185 20 also also RB 5684 185 21 by by IN 5684 185 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 185 23 morality morality NN 5684 185 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 185 25 mental mental JJ 5684 185 26 disposition disposition NN 5684 185 27 ) ) -RRB- 5684 185 28 , , , 5684 185 29 is be VBZ 5684 185 30 only only RB 5684 185 31 of of IN 5684 185 32 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 185 33 obligation obligation NN 5684 185 34 ; ; : 5684 185 35 the the DT 5684 185 36 law law NN 5684 185 37 does do VBZ 5684 185 38 not not RB 5684 185 39 command command VB 5684 185 40 this this DT 5684 185 41 internal internal JJ 5684 185 42 action action NN 5684 185 43 in in IN 5684 185 44 the the DT 5684 185 45 human human JJ 5684 185 46 mind mind NN 5684 185 47 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 185 48 , , , 5684 185 49 but but CC 5684 185 50 only only RB 5684 185 51 the the DT 5684 185 52 maxim maxim NN 5684 185 53 of of IN 5684 185 54 the the DT 5684 185 55 action action NN 5684 185 56 , , , 5684 185 57 namely namely RB 5684 185 58 , , , 5684 185 59 that that IN 5684 185 60 we -PRON- PRP 5684 185 61 should should MD 5684 185 62 strive strive VB 5684 185 63 with with IN 5684 185 64 all all DT 5684 185 65 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 185 66 power power NN 5684 185 67 that that IN 5684 185 68 for for IN 5684 185 69 all all DT 5684 185 70 dutiful dutiful JJ 5684 185 71 actions action NNS 5684 185 72 the the DT 5684 185 73 thought thought NN 5684 185 74 of of IN 5684 185 75 duty duty NN 5684 185 76 should should MD 5684 185 77 be be VB 5684 185 78 of of IN 5684 185 79 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 185 80 an an DT 5684 185 81 adequate adequate JJ 5684 185 82 spring spring NN 5684 185 83 . . . 5684 186 1 ( ( -LRB- 5684 186 2 2 2 LS 5684 186 3 ) ) -RRB- 5684 186 4 HAPPINESS happiness NN 5684 186 5 OF of IN 5684 186 6 OTHERS other NNS 5684 186 7 as as IN 5684 186 8 an an DT 5684 186 9 end end NN 5684 186 10 which which WDT 5684 186 11 is be VBZ 5684 186 12 also also RB 5684 186 13 a a DT 5684 186 14 duty duty NN 5684 186 15 { { -LRB- 5684 186 16 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION VBN 5684 186 17 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 186 18 80 80 CD 5684 186 19 } } -RRB- 5684 186 20 ( ( -LRB- 5684 186 21 a a DT 5684 186 22 ) ) -RRB- 5684 186 23 Physical Physical NNP 5684 186 24 Welfare Welfare NNP 5684 186 25 . . . 5684 187 1 Benevolent benevolent JJ 5684 187 2 wishes wish NNS 5684 187 3 may may MD 5684 187 4 be be VB 5684 187 5 unlimited unlimited JJ 5684 187 6 , , , 5684 187 7 for for IN 5684 187 8 they -PRON- PRP 5684 187 9 do do VBP 5684 187 10 not not RB 5684 187 11 imply imply VB 5684 187 12 doing do VBG 5684 187 13 anything anything NN 5684 187 14 . . . 5684 188 1 But but CC 5684 188 2 the the DT 5684 188 3 case case NN 5684 188 4 is be VBZ 5684 188 5 more more RBR 5684 188 6 difficult difficult JJ 5684 188 7 with with IN 5684 188 8 benevolent benevolent JJ 5684 188 9 action action NN 5684 188 10 , , , 5684 188 11 especially especially RB 5684 188 12 when when WRB 5684 188 13 this this DT 5684 188 14 is be VBZ 5684 188 15 to to TO 5684 188 16 be be VB 5684 188 17 done do VBN 5684 188 18 , , , 5684 188 19 not not RB 5684 188 20 from from IN 5684 188 21 friendly friendly JJ 5684 188 22 inclination inclination NN 5684 188 23 ( ( -LRB- 5684 188 24 love love NN 5684 188 25 ) ) -RRB- 5684 188 26 to to IN 5684 188 27 others other NNS 5684 188 28 , , , 5684 188 29 but but CC 5684 188 30 from from IN 5684 188 31 duty duty NN 5684 188 32 , , , 5684 188 33 at at IN 5684 188 34 the the DT 5684 188 35 expense expense NN 5684 188 36 of of IN 5684 188 37 the the DT 5684 188 38 sacrifice sacrifice NN 5684 188 39 and and CC 5684 188 40 mortification mortification NN 5684 188 41 of of IN 5684 188 42 many many JJ 5684 188 43 of of IN 5684 188 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 188 45 appetites appetite NNS 5684 188 46 . . . 5684 189 1 That that IN 5684 189 2 this this DT 5684 189 3 beneficence beneficence NN 5684 189 4 is be VBZ 5684 189 5 a a DT 5684 189 6 duty duty NN 5684 189 7 results result NNS 5684 189 8 from from IN 5684 189 9 this this DT 5684 189 10 : : : 5684 189 11 that that IN 5684 189 12 since since IN 5684 189 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 189 14 self self NN 5684 189 15 - - HYPH 5684 189 16 love love NN 5684 189 17 can can MD 5684 189 18 not not RB 5684 189 19 be be VB 5684 189 20 separated separate VBN 5684 189 21 from from IN 5684 189 22 the the DT 5684 189 23 need need NN 5684 189 24 to to TO 5684 189 25 be be VB 5684 189 26 loved love VBN 5684 189 27 by by IN 5684 189 28 others other NNS 5684 189 29 ( ( -LRB- 5684 189 30 to to TO 5684 189 31 obtain obtain VB 5684 189 32 help help NN 5684 189 33 from from IN 5684 189 34 them -PRON- PRP 5684 189 35 in in IN 5684 189 36 case case NN 5684 189 37 of of IN 5684 189 38 necessity necessity NN 5684 189 39 ) ) -RRB- 5684 189 40 , , , 5684 189 41 we -PRON- PRP 5684 189 42 therefore therefore RB 5684 189 43 make make VBP 5684 189 44 ourselves -PRON- PRP 5684 189 45 an an DT 5684 189 46 end end NN 5684 189 47 for for IN 5684 189 48 others other NNS 5684 189 49 ; ; : 5684 189 50 and and CC 5684 189 51 this this DT 5684 189 52 maxim maxim NN 5684 189 53 can can MD 5684 189 54 never never RB 5684 189 55 be be VB 5684 189 56 obligatory obligatory JJ 5684 189 57 except except IN 5684 189 58 by by IN 5684 189 59 having have VBG 5684 189 60 the the DT 5684 189 61 specific specific JJ 5684 189 62 character character NN 5684 189 63 of of IN 5684 189 64 a a DT 5684 189 65 universal universal JJ 5684 189 66 law law NN 5684 189 67 , , , 5684 189 68 and and CC 5684 189 69 consequently consequently RB 5684 189 70 by by IN 5684 189 71 means mean NNS 5684 189 72 of of IN 5684 189 73 a a DT 5684 189 74 will will NN 5684 189 75 that that IN 5684 189 76 we -PRON- PRP 5684 189 77 should should MD 5684 189 78 also also RB 5684 189 79 make make VB 5684 189 80 others other NNS 5684 189 81 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 189 82 ends end NNS 5684 189 83 . . . 5684 190 1 Hence hence RB 5684 190 2 the the DT 5684 190 3 happiness happiness NN 5684 190 4 of of IN 5684 190 5 others other NNS 5684 190 6 is be VBZ 5684 190 7 an an DT 5684 190 8 end end NN 5684 190 9 that that WDT 5684 190 10 is be VBZ 5684 190 11 also also RB 5684 190 12 a a DT 5684 190 13 duty duty NN 5684 190 14 . . . 5684 191 1 I -PRON- PRP 5684 191 2 am be VBP 5684 191 3 only only RB 5684 191 4 bound bind VBN 5684 191 5 then then RB 5684 191 6 to to TO 5684 191 7 sacrifice sacrifice VB 5684 191 8 to to IN 5684 191 9 others other NNS 5684 191 10 a a DT 5684 191 11 part part NN 5684 191 12 of of IN 5684 191 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 191 14 welfare welfare NN 5684 191 15 without without IN 5684 191 16 hope hope NN 5684 191 17 of of IN 5684 191 18 recompense recompense NN 5684 191 19 : : : 5684 191 20 because because IN 5684 191 21 it -PRON- PRP 5684 191 22 is be VBZ 5684 191 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 191 24 duty duty NN 5684 191 25 , , , 5684 191 26 and and CC 5684 191 27 it -PRON- PRP 5684 191 28 is be VBZ 5684 191 29 impossible impossible JJ 5684 191 30 to to TO 5684 191 31 assign assign VB 5684 191 32 definite definite JJ 5684 191 33 limits limit NNS 5684 191 34 how how WRB 5684 191 35 far far RB 5684 191 36 that that DT 5684 191 37 may may MD 5684 191 38 go go VB 5684 191 39 . . . 5684 192 1 Much much JJ 5684 192 2 depends depend VBZ 5684 192 3 on on IN 5684 192 4 what what WP 5684 192 5 would would MD 5684 192 6 be be VB 5684 192 7 the the DT 5684 192 8 true true JJ 5684 192 9 want want NN 5684 192 10 of of IN 5684 192 11 each each DT 5684 192 12 according accord VBG 5684 192 13 to to IN 5684 192 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 192 15 own own JJ 5684 192 16 feelings feeling NNS 5684 192 17 , , , 5684 192 18 and and CC 5684 192 19 it -PRON- PRP 5684 192 20 must must MD 5684 192 21 be be VB 5684 192 22 left leave VBN 5684 192 23 to to IN 5684 192 24 each each DT 5684 192 25 to to TO 5684 192 26 determine determine VB 5684 192 27 this this DT 5684 192 28 for for IN 5684 192 29 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 192 30 . . . 5684 193 1 For for IN 5684 193 2 that that DT 5684 193 3 one one PRP 5684 193 4 should should MD 5684 193 5 sacrifice sacrifice VB 5684 193 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 193 7 own own JJ 5684 193 8 happiness happiness NN 5684 193 9 , , , 5684 193 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 193 11 true true JJ 5684 193 12 wants want VBZ 5684 193 13 , , , 5684 193 14 in in IN 5684 193 15 order order NN 5684 193 16 to to TO 5684 193 17 promote promote VB 5684 193 18 that that DT 5684 193 19 of of IN 5684 193 20 others other NNS 5684 193 21 , , , 5684 193 22 would would MD 5684 193 23 be be VB 5684 193 24 a a DT 5684 193 25 self self NN 5684 193 26 - - HYPH 5684 193 27 contradictory contradictory JJ 5684 193 28 maxim maxim NN 5684 193 29 if if IN 5684 193 30 made make VBD 5684 193 31 a a DT 5684 193 32 universal universal JJ 5684 193 33 law law NN 5684 193 34 . . . 5684 194 1 This this DT 5684 194 2 duty duty NN 5684 194 3 , , , 5684 194 4 therefore therefore RB 5684 194 5 , , , 5684 194 6 is be VBZ 5684 194 7 only only RB 5684 194 8 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 194 9 ; ; : 5684 194 10 it -PRON- PRP 5684 194 11 has have VBZ 5684 194 12 a a DT 5684 194 13 certain certain JJ 5684 194 14 latitude latitude NN 5684 194 15 within within IN 5684 194 16 which which WDT 5684 194 17 one one PRP 5684 194 18 may may MD 5684 194 19 do do VB 5684 194 20 more more RBR 5684 194 21 or or CC 5684 194 22 less less RBR 5684 194 23 without without IN 5684 194 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 194 25 being be VBG 5684 194 26 able able JJ 5684 194 27 to to TO 5684 194 28 assign assign VB 5684 194 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 194 30 limits limit NNS 5684 194 31 definitely definitely RB 5684 194 32 . . . 5684 195 1 The the DT 5684 195 2 law law NN 5684 195 3 holds hold VBZ 5684 195 4 only only RB 5684 195 5 for for IN 5684 195 6 the the DT 5684 195 7 maxims maxim NNS 5684 195 8 , , , 5684 195 9 not not RB 5684 195 10 for for IN 5684 195 11 definite definite JJ 5684 195 12 actions action NNS 5684 195 13 . . . 5684 196 1 ( ( -LRB- 5684 196 2 b b LS 5684 196 3 ) ) -RRB- 5684 196 4 Moral moral JJ 5684 196 5 well well RB 5684 196 6 - - HYPH 5684 196 7 being being NN 5684 196 8 of of IN 5684 196 9 others other NNS 5684 196 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 196 11 salus salus NNP 5684 196 12 moralis moralis NNP 5684 196 13 ) ) -RRB- 5684 196 14 also also RB 5684 196 15 belongs belong VBZ 5684 196 16 to to IN 5684 196 17 the the DT 5684 196 18 happiness happiness NN 5684 196 19 of of IN 5684 196 20 others other NNS 5684 196 21 , , , 5684 196 22 which which WDT 5684 196 23 it -PRON- PRP 5684 196 24 is be VBZ 5684 196 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 196 26 duty duty NN 5684 196 27 to to TO 5684 196 28 promote promote VB 5684 196 29 , , , 5684 196 30 but but CC 5684 196 31 only only RB 5684 196 32 a a DT 5684 196 33 negative negative JJ 5684 196 34 duty duty NN 5684 196 35 . . . 5684 197 1 The the DT 5684 197 2 pain pain NN 5684 197 3 that that WDT 5684 197 4 a a DT 5684 197 5 man man NN 5684 197 6 feels feel VBZ 5684 197 7 from from IN 5684 197 8 remorse remorse NN 5684 197 9 of of IN 5684 197 10 conscience conscience NN 5684 197 11 , , , 5684 197 12 although although IN 5684 197 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 197 14 origin origin NN 5684 197 15 is be VBZ 5684 197 16 moral moral JJ 5684 197 17 , , , 5684 197 18 is be VBZ 5684 197 19 yet yet RB 5684 197 20 in in IN 5684 197 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 197 22 operation operation NN 5684 197 23 physical physical NN 5684 197 24 , , , 5684 197 25 like like IN 5684 197 26 grief grief NN 5684 197 27 , , , 5684 197 28 fear fear NN 5684 197 29 , , , 5684 197 30 and and CC 5684 197 31 every every DT 5684 197 32 other other JJ 5684 197 33 diseased diseased JJ 5684 197 34 condition condition NN 5684 197 35 . . . 5684 198 1 To to TO 5684 198 2 take take VB 5684 198 3 care care NN 5684 198 4 that that IN 5684 198 5 he -PRON- PRP 5684 198 6 should should MD 5684 198 7 not not RB 5684 198 8 be be VB 5684 198 9 deservedly deservedly RB 5684 198 10 smitten smite VBN 5684 198 11 by by IN 5684 198 12 this this DT 5684 198 13 inward inward JJ 5684 198 14 reproach reproach NN 5684 198 15 is be VBZ 5684 198 16 not not RB 5684 198 17 indeed indeed RB 5684 198 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 198 19 duty duty NN 5684 198 20 but but CC 5684 198 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 198 22 business business NN 5684 198 23 ; ; : 5684 198 24 nevertheless nevertheless RB 5684 198 25 , , , 5684 198 26 it -PRON- PRP 5684 198 27 is be VBZ 5684 198 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 198 29 duty duty NN 5684 198 30 to to TO 5684 198 31 do do VB 5684 198 32 nothing nothing NN 5684 198 33 which which WDT 5684 198 34 by by IN 5684 198 35 the the DT 5684 198 36 nature nature NN 5684 198 37 of of IN 5684 198 38 man man NN 5684 198 39 might may MD 5684 198 40 seduce seduce VB 5684 198 41 him -PRON- PRP 5684 198 42 to to IN 5684 198 43 that that DT 5684 198 44 for for IN 5684 198 45 which which WDT 5684 198 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 198 47 conscience conscience NN 5684 198 48 may may MD 5684 198 49 hereafter hereafter RB 5684 198 50 torment torment VB 5684 198 51 him -PRON- PRP 5684 198 52 , , , 5684 198 53 that that RB 5684 198 54 is is RB 5684 198 55 , , , 5684 198 56 it -PRON- PRP 5684 198 57 is be VBZ 5684 198 58 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 198 59 duty duty NN 5684 198 60 not not RB 5684 198 61 to to TO 5684 198 62 give give VB 5684 198 63 him -PRON- PRP 5684 198 64 occasion occasion NN 5684 198 65 of of IN 5684 198 66 stumbling stumble VBG 5684 198 67 . . . 5684 199 1 But but CC 5684 199 2 there there EX 5684 199 3 are be VBP 5684 199 4 no no DT 5684 199 5 definite definite JJ 5684 199 6 limits limit NNS 5684 199 7 within within IN 5684 199 8 which which WDT 5684 199 9 this this DT 5684 199 10 care care NN 5684 199 11 for for IN 5684 199 12 the the DT 5684 199 13 moral moral JJ 5684 199 14 satisfaction satisfaction NN 5684 199 15 of of IN 5684 199 16 others other NNS 5684 199 17 must must MD 5684 199 18 be be VB 5684 199 19 kept keep VBN 5684 199 20 ; ; : 5684 199 21 therefore therefore RB 5684 199 22 it -PRON- PRP 5684 199 23 involves involve VBZ 5684 199 24 only only RB 5684 199 25 an an DT 5684 199 26 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 199 27 obligation obligation NN 5684 199 28 . . . 5684 200 1 IX ix NN 5684 200 2 . . . 5684 201 1 What what WP 5684 201 2 is be VBZ 5684 201 3 a a DT 5684 201 4 Duty Duty NNP 5684 201 5 of of IN 5684 201 6 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 201 7 ? ? . 5684 202 1 { { -LRB- 5684 202 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 202 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 202 4 85 85 CD 5684 202 5 } } -RRB- 5684 202 6 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 202 7 is be VBZ 5684 202 8 the the DT 5684 202 9 strength strength NN 5684 202 10 of of IN 5684 202 11 the the DT 5684 202 12 man man NN 5684 202 13 's 's POS 5684 202 14 maxim maxim NN 5684 202 15 in in IN 5684 202 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 202 17 obedience obedience NN 5684 202 18 to to IN 5684 202 19 duty duty NN 5684 202 20 . . . 5684 203 1 All all DT 5684 203 2 strength strength NN 5684 203 3 is be VBZ 5684 203 4 known know VBN 5684 203 5 only only RB 5684 203 6 by by IN 5684 203 7 the the DT 5684 203 8 obstacles obstacle NNS 5684 203 9 that that WDT 5684 203 10 it -PRON- PRP 5684 203 11 can can MD 5684 203 12 overcome overcome VB 5684 203 13 ; ; : 5684 203 14 and and CC 5684 203 15 in in IN 5684 203 16 the the DT 5684 203 17 case case NN 5684 203 18 of of IN 5684 203 19 virtue virtue NN 5684 203 20 the the DT 5684 203 21 obstacles obstacle NNS 5684 203 22 are be VBP 5684 203 23 the the DT 5684 203 24 natural natural JJ 5684 203 25 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 203 26 which which WDT 5684 203 27 may may MD 5684 203 28 come come VB 5684 203 29 into into IN 5684 203 30 conflict conflict NN 5684 203 31 with with IN 5684 203 32 the the DT 5684 203 33 moral moral JJ 5684 203 34 purpose purpose NN 5684 203 35 ; ; , 5684 203 36 and and CC 5684 203 37 as as IN 5684 203 38 it -PRON- PRP 5684 203 39 is be VBZ 5684 203 40 the the DT 5684 203 41 man man NN 5684 203 42 who who WP 5684 203 43 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 203 44 puts put VBZ 5684 203 45 these these DT 5684 203 46 obstacles obstacle NNS 5684 203 47 in in IN 5684 203 48 the the DT 5684 203 49 way way NN 5684 203 50 of of IN 5684 203 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 203 52 maxims maxim NNS 5684 203 53 , , , 5684 203 54 hence hence RB 5684 203 55 virtue virtue NN 5684 203 56 is be VBZ 5684 203 57 not not RB 5684 203 58 merely merely RB 5684 203 59 a a DT 5684 203 60 self self NN 5684 203 61 - - HYPH 5684 203 62 constraint constraint NN 5684 203 63 ( ( -LRB- 5684 203 64 for for IN 5684 203 65 that that DT 5684 203 66 might may MD 5684 203 67 be be VB 5684 203 68 an an DT 5684 203 69 effort effort NN 5684 203 70 of of IN 5684 203 71 one one CD 5684 203 72 inclination inclination NN 5684 203 73 to to TO 5684 203 74 constrain constrain VB 5684 203 75 another another DT 5684 203 76 ) ) -RRB- 5684 203 77 , , , 5684 203 78 but but CC 5684 203 79 is be VBZ 5684 203 80 also also RB 5684 203 81 a a DT 5684 203 82 constraint constraint NN 5684 203 83 according accord VBG 5684 203 84 to to IN 5684 203 85 a a DT 5684 203 86 principle principle NN 5684 203 87 of of IN 5684 203 88 inward inward IN 5684 203 89 freedom freedom NN 5684 203 90 , , , 5684 203 91 and and CC 5684 203 92 therefore therefore RB 5684 203 93 by by IN 5684 203 94 the the DT 5684 203 95 mere mere JJ 5684 203 96 idea idea NN 5684 203 97 of of IN 5684 203 98 duty duty NN 5684 203 99 , , , 5684 203 100 according accord VBG 5684 203 101 to to IN 5684 203 102 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 203 103 formal formal JJ 5684 203 104 law law NN 5684 203 105 . . . 5684 204 1 All all DT 5684 204 2 duties duty NNS 5684 204 3 involve involve VBP 5684 204 4 a a DT 5684 204 5 notion notion NN 5684 204 6 of of IN 5684 204 7 necessitation necessitation NN 5684 204 8 by by IN 5684 204 9 the the DT 5684 204 10 law law NN 5684 204 11 , , , 5684 204 12 and and CC 5684 204 13 ethical ethical JJ 5684 204 14 duties duty NNS 5684 204 15 involve involve VBP 5684 204 16 a a DT 5684 204 17 necessitation necessitation NN 5684 204 18 for for IN 5684 204 19 which which WDT 5684 204 20 only only RB 5684 204 21 an an DT 5684 204 22 internal internal JJ 5684 204 23 legislation legislation NN 5684 204 24 is be VBZ 5684 204 25 possible possible JJ 5684 204 26 ; ; : 5684 204 27 juridical juridical JJ 5684 204 28 duties duty NNS 5684 204 29 , , , 5684 204 30 on on IN 5684 204 31 the the DT 5684 204 32 other other JJ 5684 204 33 hand hand NN 5684 204 34 , , , 5684 204 35 one one CD 5684 204 36 for for IN 5684 204 37 which which WDT 5684 204 38 external external JJ 5684 204 39 legislation legislation NN 5684 204 40 also also RB 5684 204 41 is be VBZ 5684 204 42 possible possible JJ 5684 204 43 . . . 5684 205 1 Both both DT 5684 205 2 , , , 5684 205 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 205 4 , , , 5684 205 5 include include VBP 5684 205 6 the the DT 5684 205 7 notion notion NN 5684 205 8 of of IN 5684 205 9 constraint constraint NN 5684 205 10 , , , 5684 205 11 either either CC 5684 205 12 self self NN 5684 205 13 - - HYPH 5684 205 14 constraint constraint NN 5684 205 15 or or CC 5684 205 16 constraint constraint NN 5684 205 17 by by IN 5684 205 18 others other NNS 5684 205 19 . . . 5684 206 1 The the DT 5684 206 2 moral moral JJ 5684 206 3 power power NN 5684 206 4 of of IN 5684 206 5 the the DT 5684 206 6 former former JJ 5684 206 7 is be VBZ 5684 206 8 virtue virtue NN 5684 206 9 , , , 5684 206 10 and and CC 5684 206 11 the the DT 5684 206 12 action action NN 5684 206 13 springing spring VBG 5684 206 14 from from IN 5684 206 15 such such PDT 5684 206 16 a a DT 5684 206 17 disposition disposition NN 5684 206 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 206 19 from from IN 5684 206 20 reverence reverence NN 5684 206 21 for for IN 5684 206 22 the the DT 5684 206 23 law law NN 5684 206 24 ) ) -RRB- 5684 206 25 may may MD 5684 206 26 be be VB 5684 206 27 called call VBN 5684 206 28 a a DT 5684 206 29 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 206 30 action action NN 5684 206 31 ( ( -LRB- 5684 206 32 ethical ethical JJ 5684 206 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 206 34 , , , 5684 206 35 although although IN 5684 206 36 the the DT 5684 206 37 law law NN 5684 206 38 expresses express VBZ 5684 206 39 a a DT 5684 206 40 juridical juridical JJ 5684 206 41 duty duty NN 5684 206 42 . . . 5684 207 1 For for IN 5684 207 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 207 3 is be VBZ 5684 207 4 the the DT 5684 207 5 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 207 6 of of IN 5684 207 7 virtue virtue NN 5684 207 8 that that WDT 5684 207 9 commands command VBZ 5684 207 10 us -PRON- PRP 5684 207 11 to to TO 5684 207 12 regard regard VB 5684 207 13 the the DT 5684 207 14 rights right NNS 5684 207 15 of of IN 5684 207 16 men man NNS 5684 207 17 as as IN 5684 207 18 holy holy JJ 5684 207 19 . . . 5684 208 1 But but CC 5684 208 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 208 3 does do VBZ 5684 208 4 not not RB 5684 208 5 follow follow VB 5684 208 6 that that IN 5684 208 7 everything everything NN 5684 208 8 the the DT 5684 208 9 doing doing NN 5684 208 10 of of IN 5684 208 11 which which WDT 5684 208 12 is be VBZ 5684 208 13 virtue virtue NN 5684 208 14 , , , 5684 208 15 is be VBZ 5684 208 16 , , , 5684 208 17 properly properly RB 5684 208 18 speaking speak VBG 5684 208 19 , , , 5684 208 20 a a DT 5684 208 21 duty duty NN 5684 208 22 of of IN 5684 208 23 virtue virtue NN 5684 208 24 . . . 5684 209 1 The the DT 5684 209 2 former former JJ 5684 209 3 may may NNP 5684 209 4 concern concern NN 5684 209 5 merely merely RB 5684 209 6 the the DT 5684 209 7 form form NN 5684 209 8 of of IN 5684 209 9 the the DT 5684 209 10 maxims maxim NNS 5684 209 11 ; ; : 5684 209 12 the the DT 5684 209 13 latter latter JJ 5684 209 14 applies apply VBZ 5684 209 15 to to IN 5684 209 16 the the DT 5684 209 17 matter matter NN 5684 209 18 of of IN 5684 209 19 them -PRON- PRP 5684 209 20 , , , 5684 209 21 namely namely RB 5684 209 22 , , , 5684 209 23 to to IN 5684 209 24 an an DT 5684 209 25 end end NN 5684 209 26 which which WDT 5684 209 27 is be VBZ 5684 209 28 also also RB 5684 209 29 conceived conceive VBN 5684 209 30 as as IN 5684 209 31 duty duty NN 5684 209 32 . . . 5684 210 1 Now now RB 5684 210 2 , , , 5684 210 3 as as IN 5684 210 4 the the DT 5684 210 5 ethical ethical JJ 5684 210 6 obligation obligation NN 5684 210 7 to to IN 5684 210 8 ends end NNS 5684 210 9 , , , 5684 210 10 of of IN 5684 210 11 which which WDT 5684 210 12 there there EX 5684 210 13 may may MD 5684 210 14 be be VB 5684 210 15 many many JJ 5684 210 16 , , , 5684 210 17 is be VBZ 5684 210 18 only only RB 5684 210 19 indeterminate indeterminate JJ 5684 210 20 , , , 5684 210 21 because because IN 5684 210 22 it -PRON- PRP 5684 210 23 contains contain VBZ 5684 210 24 only only RB 5684 210 25 a a DT 5684 210 26 law law NN 5684 210 27 for for IN 5684 210 28 the the DT 5684 210 29 maxim maxim NN 5684 210 30 of of IN 5684 210 31 actions action NNS 5684 210 32 , , , 5684 210 33 and and CC 5684 210 34 the the DT 5684 210 35 end end NN 5684 210 36 is be VBZ 5684 210 37 the the DT 5684 210 38 matter matter NN 5684 210 39 ( ( -LRB- 5684 210 40 object object NN 5684 210 41 ) ) -RRB- 5684 210 42 of of IN 5684 210 43 elective elective NN 5684 210 44 will will MD 5684 210 45 ; ; : 5684 210 46 hence hence RB 5684 210 47 there there EX 5684 210 48 are be VBP 5684 210 49 many many JJ 5684 210 50 duties duty NNS 5684 210 51 , , , 5684 210 52 differing differ VBG 5684 210 53 according accord VBG 5684 210 54 to to IN 5684 210 55 the the DT 5684 210 56 difference difference NN 5684 210 57 of of IN 5684 210 58 lawful lawful JJ 5684 210 59 ends end NNS 5684 210 60 , , , 5684 210 61 which which WDT 5684 210 62 may may MD 5684 210 63 be be VB 5684 210 64 called call VBN 5684 210 65 duties duty NNS 5684 210 66 of of IN 5684 210 67 virtue virtue NNP 5684 210 68 ( ( -LRB- 5684 210 69 officia officia NNP 5684 210 70 honestatis honestatis NNP 5684 210 71 ) ) -RRB- 5684 210 72 , , , 5684 210 73 just just RB 5684 210 74 because because IN 5684 210 75 they -PRON- PRP 5684 210 76 are be VBP 5684 210 77 subject subject JJ 5684 210 78 only only RB 5684 210 79 to to TO 5684 210 80 free free JJ 5684 210 81 self self NN 5684 210 82 - - HYPH 5684 210 83 constraint constraint NN 5684 210 84 , , , 5684 210 85 not not RB 5684 210 86 to to IN 5684 210 87 the the DT 5684 210 88 constraint constraint NN 5684 210 89 of of IN 5684 210 90 other other JJ 5684 210 91 men man NNS 5684 210 92 , , , 5684 210 93 and and CC 5684 210 94 determine determine VB 5684 210 95 the the DT 5684 210 96 end end NN 5684 210 97 which which WDT 5684 210 98 is be VBZ 5684 210 99 also also RB 5684 210 100 a a DT 5684 210 101 duty duty NN 5684 210 102 . . . 5684 211 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 211 2 , , , 5684 211 3 being be VBG 5684 211 4 a a DT 5684 211 5 coincidence coincidence NN 5684 211 6 of of IN 5684 211 7 the the DT 5684 211 8 rational rational JJ 5684 211 9 will will NN 5684 211 10 , , , 5684 211 11 with with IN 5684 211 12 every every DT 5684 211 13 duty duty NN 5684 211 14 firmly firmly RB 5684 211 15 settled settle VBN 5684 211 16 in in IN 5684 211 17 the the DT 5684 211 18 character character NN 5684 211 19 , , , 5684 211 20 is be VBZ 5684 211 21 , , , 5684 211 22 like like IN 5684 211 23 everything everything NN 5684 211 24 formal formal JJ 5684 211 25 , , , 5684 211 26 only only RB 5684 211 27 one one CD 5684 211 28 and and CC 5684 211 29 the the DT 5684 211 30 same same JJ 5684 211 31 . . . 5684 212 1 But but CC 5684 212 2 , , , 5684 212 3 as as IN 5684 212 4 regards regard VBZ 5684 212 5 the the DT 5684 212 6 end end NN 5684 212 7 of of IN 5684 212 8 actions action NNS 5684 212 9 , , , 5684 212 10 which which WDT 5684 212 11 is be VBZ 5684 212 12 also also RB 5684 212 13 duty duty NN 5684 212 14 , , , 5684 212 15 that that RB 5684 212 16 is is RB 5684 212 17 , , , 5684 212 18 as as IN 5684 212 19 regards regard VBZ 5684 212 20 the the DT 5684 212 21 matter matter NN 5684 212 22 which which WDT 5684 212 23 one one PRP 5684 212 24 ought ought MD 5684 212 25 to to TO 5684 212 26 make make VB 5684 212 27 an an DT 5684 212 28 end end NN 5684 212 29 , , , 5684 212 30 there there EX 5684 212 31 may may MD 5684 212 32 be be VB 5684 212 33 several several JJ 5684 212 34 virtues virtue NNS 5684 212 35 ; ; : 5684 212 36 and and CC 5684 212 37 as as IN 5684 212 38 the the DT 5684 212 39 obligation obligation NN 5684 212 40 to to IN 5684 212 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 212 42 maxim maxim NN 5684 212 43 is be VBZ 5684 212 44 called call VBN 5684 212 45 a a DT 5684 212 46 duty duty NN 5684 212 47 of of IN 5684 212 48 virtue virtue NN 5684 212 49 , , , 5684 212 50 it -PRON- PRP 5684 212 51 follows follow VBZ 5684 212 52 that that IN 5684 212 53 there there EX 5684 212 54 are be VBP 5684 212 55 also also RB 5684 212 56 several several JJ 5684 212 57 duties duty NNS 5684 212 58 of of IN 5684 212 59 virtue virtue NN 5684 212 60 . . . 5684 213 1 { { -LRB- 5684 213 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 213 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 213 4 90 90 CD 5684 213 5 } } -RRB- 5684 213 6 The the DT 5684 213 7 supreme supreme JJ 5684 213 8 principle principle NN 5684 213 9 of of IN 5684 213 10 ethics ethic NNS 5684 213 11 ( ( -LRB- 5684 213 12 the the DT 5684 213 13 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 213 14 of of IN 5684 213 15 virtue virtue NN 5684 213 16 ) ) -RRB- 5684 213 17 is be VBZ 5684 213 18 : : : 5684 213 19 " " `` 5684 213 20 Act act VB 5684 213 21 on on IN 5684 213 22 a a DT 5684 213 23 maxim maxim NN 5684 213 24 , , , 5684 213 25 the the DT 5684 213 26 ends end NNS 5684 213 27 of of IN 5684 213 28 which which WDT 5684 213 29 are be VBP 5684 213 30 such such JJ 5684 213 31 as as IN 5684 213 32 it -PRON- PRP 5684 213 33 might may MD 5684 213 34 be be VB 5684 213 35 a a DT 5684 213 36 universal universal JJ 5684 213 37 law law NN 5684 213 38 for for IN 5684 213 39 everyone everyone NN 5684 213 40 to to TO 5684 213 41 have have VB 5684 213 42 . . . 5684 213 43 " " '' 5684 214 1 On on IN 5684 214 2 this this DT 5684 214 3 principle principle NN 5684 214 4 a a DT 5684 214 5 man man NN 5684 214 6 is be VBZ 5684 214 7 an an DT 5684 214 8 end end NN 5684 214 9 to to IN 5684 214 10 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 214 11 as as RB 5684 214 12 well well RB 5684 214 13 as as IN 5684 214 14 others other NNS 5684 214 15 , , , 5684 214 16 and and CC 5684 214 17 it -PRON- PRP 5684 214 18 is be VBZ 5684 214 19 not not RB 5684 214 20 enough enough JJ 5684 214 21 that that IN 5684 214 22 he -PRON- PRP 5684 214 23 is be VBZ 5684 214 24 not not RB 5684 214 25 permitted permit VBN 5684 214 26 to to TO 5684 214 27 use use VB 5684 214 28 either either CC 5684 214 29 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 214 30 or or CC 5684 214 31 others other NNS 5684 214 32 merely merely RB 5684 214 33 as as IN 5684 214 34 means mean NNS 5684 214 35 ( ( -LRB- 5684 214 36 which which WDT 5684 214 37 would would MD 5684 214 38 imply imply VB 5684 214 39 that that DT 5684 214 40 be be VB 5684 214 41 might may MD 5684 214 42 be be VB 5684 214 43 indifferent indifferent JJ 5684 214 44 to to IN 5684 214 45 them -PRON- PRP 5684 214 46 ) ) -RRB- 5684 214 47 , , , 5684 214 48 but but CC 5684 214 49 it -PRON- PRP 5684 214 50 is be VBZ 5684 214 51 in in IN 5684 214 52 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 214 53 a a DT 5684 214 54 duty duty NN 5684 214 55 of of IN 5684 214 56 every every DT 5684 214 57 man man NN 5684 214 58 to to TO 5684 214 59 make make VB 5684 214 60 mankind mankind NN 5684 214 61 in in IN 5684 214 62 general general JJ 5684 214 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 214 64 end end NN 5684 214 65 . . . 5684 215 1 The the DT 5684 215 2 principle principle NN 5684 215 3 of of IN 5684 215 4 ethics ethic NNS 5684 215 5 being be VBG 5684 215 6 a a DT 5684 215 7 categorical categorical JJ 5684 215 8 imperative imperative NN 5684 215 9 does do VBZ 5684 215 10 not not RB 5684 215 11 admit admit VB 5684 215 12 of of IN 5684 215 13 proof proof NN 5684 215 14 , , , 5684 215 15 but but CC 5684 215 16 it -PRON- PRP 5684 215 17 admits admit VBZ 5684 215 18 of of IN 5684 215 19 a a DT 5684 215 20 justification justification NN 5684 215 21 from from IN 5684 215 22 principles principle NNS 5684 215 23 of of IN 5684 215 24 pure pure JJ 5684 215 25 practical practical JJ 5684 215 26 reason reason NN 5684 215 27 . . . 5684 216 1 Whatever whatever WDT 5684 216 2 in in IN 5684 216 3 relation relation NN 5684 216 4 to to IN 5684 216 5 mankind mankind NN 5684 216 6 , , , 5684 216 7 to to IN 5684 216 8 oneself oneself PRP 5684 216 9 , , , 5684 216 10 and and CC 5684 216 11 others other NNS 5684 216 12 , , , 5684 216 13 can can MD 5684 216 14 be be VB 5684 216 15 an an DT 5684 216 16 end end NN 5684 216 17 , , , 5684 216 18 that that DT 5684 216 19 is be VBZ 5684 216 20 an an DT 5684 216 21 end end NN 5684 216 22 for for IN 5684 216 23 pure pure JJ 5684 216 24 practical practical JJ 5684 216 25 reason reason NN 5684 216 26 : : : 5684 216 27 for for IN 5684 216 28 this this DT 5684 216 29 is be VBZ 5684 216 30 a a DT 5684 216 31 faculty faculty NN 5684 216 32 of of IN 5684 216 33 assigning assigning NN 5684 216 34 ends end NNS 5684 216 35 in in IN 5684 216 36 general general JJ 5684 216 37 ; ; : 5684 216 38 and and CC 5684 216 39 to to TO 5684 216 40 be be VB 5684 216 41 indifferent indifferent JJ 5684 216 42 to to IN 5684 216 43 them -PRON- PRP 5684 216 44 , , , 5684 216 45 that that RB 5684 216 46 is is RB 5684 216 47 , , , 5684 216 48 to to TO 5684 216 49 take take VB 5684 216 50 no no DT 5684 216 51 interest interest NN 5684 216 52 in in IN 5684 216 53 them -PRON- PRP 5684 216 54 , , , 5684 216 55 is be VBZ 5684 216 56 a a DT 5684 216 57 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 216 58 ; ; : 5684 216 59 since since IN 5684 216 60 in in IN 5684 216 61 that that DT 5684 216 62 case case NN 5684 216 63 it -PRON- PRP 5684 216 64 would would MD 5684 216 65 not not RB 5684 216 66 determine determine VB 5684 216 67 the the DT 5684 216 68 maxims maxim NNS 5684 216 69 of of IN 5684 216 70 actions action NNS 5684 216 71 ( ( -LRB- 5684 216 72 which which WDT 5684 216 73 always always RB 5684 216 74 involve involve VBP 5684 216 75 an an DT 5684 216 76 end end NN 5684 216 77 ) ) -RRB- 5684 216 78 , , , 5684 216 79 and and CC 5684 216 80 consequently consequently RB 5684 216 81 would would MD 5684 216 82 cease cease VB 5684 216 83 to to TO 5684 216 84 be be VB 5684 216 85 practical practical JJ 5684 216 86 reasons reason NNS 5684 216 87 . . . 5684 217 1 Pure pure JJ 5684 217 2 reason reason NN 5684 217 3 , , , 5684 217 4 however however RB 5684 217 5 , , , 5684 217 6 can can MD 5684 217 7 not not RB 5684 217 8 command command VB 5684 217 9 any any DT 5684 217 10 ends end NNS 5684 217 11 a a DT 5684 217 12 priori priori FW 5684 217 13 , , , 5684 217 14 except except IN 5684 217 15 so so RB 5684 217 16 far far RB 5684 217 17 as as IN 5684 217 18 it -PRON- PRP 5684 217 19 declares declare VBZ 5684 217 20 the the DT 5684 217 21 same same JJ 5684 217 22 to to TO 5684 217 23 be be VB 5684 217 24 also also RB 5684 217 25 a a DT 5684 217 26 duty duty NN 5684 217 27 , , , 5684 217 28 which which WDT 5684 217 29 duty duty NN 5684 217 30 is be VBZ 5684 217 31 then then RB 5684 217 32 called call VBN 5684 217 33 a a DT 5684 217 34 duty duty NN 5684 217 35 of of IN 5684 217 36 virtue virtue NN 5684 217 37 . . . 5684 218 1 X. X. NNP 5684 219 1 The the DT 5684 219 2 Supreme Supreme NNP 5684 219 3 Principle Principle NNP 5684 219 4 of of IN 5684 219 5 Jurisprudence Jurisprudence NNP 5684 219 6 was be VBD 5684 219 7 Analytical analytical JJ 5684 219 8 ; ; : 5684 219 9 that that DT 5684 219 10 of of IN 5684 219 11 Ethics Ethics NNP 5684 219 12 is be VBZ 5684 219 13 Synthetical Synthetical NNP 5684 219 14 { { -LRB- 5684 219 15 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 219 16 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 219 17 95 95 CD 5684 219 18 } } -RRB- 5684 219 19 That that DT 5684 219 20 external external JJ 5684 219 21 constraint constraint NN 5684 219 22 , , , 5684 219 23 so so RB 5684 219 24 far far RB 5684 219 25 as as IN 5684 219 26 it -PRON- PRP 5684 219 27 withstands withstand VBZ 5684 219 28 that that IN 5684 219 29 which which WDT 5684 219 30 hinders hinder VBZ 5684 219 31 the the DT 5684 219 32 external external JJ 5684 219 33 freedom freedom NN 5684 219 34 that that WDT 5684 219 35 agrees agree VBZ 5684 219 36 with with IN 5684 219 37 general general JJ 5684 219 38 laws law NNS 5684 219 39 ( ( -LRB- 5684 219 40 as as IN 5684 219 41 an an DT 5684 219 42 obstacle obstacle NN 5684 219 43 of of IN 5684 219 44 the the DT 5684 219 45 obstacle obstacle NN 5684 219 46 thereto thereto NN 5684 219 47 ) ) -RRB- 5684 219 48 , , , 5684 219 49 can can MD 5684 219 50 be be VB 5684 219 51 consistent consistent JJ 5684 219 52 with with IN 5684 219 53 ends end NNS 5684 219 54 generally generally RB 5684 219 55 , , , 5684 219 56 is be VBZ 5684 219 57 clear clear JJ 5684 219 58 on on IN 5684 219 59 the the DT 5684 219 60 principle principle NN 5684 219 61 of of IN 5684 219 62 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 219 63 , , , 5684 219 64 and and CC 5684 219 65 I -PRON- PRP 5684 219 66 need need VBP 5684 219 67 not not RB 5684 219 68 go go VB 5684 219 69 beyond beyond IN 5684 219 70 the the DT 5684 219 71 notion notion NN 5684 219 72 of of IN 5684 219 73 freedom freedom NN 5684 219 74 in in IN 5684 219 75 order order NN 5684 219 76 to to TO 5684 219 77 see see VB 5684 219 78 it -PRON- PRP 5684 219 79 , , , 5684 219 80 let let VB 5684 219 81 the the DT 5684 219 82 end end NN 5684 219 83 which which WDT 5684 219 84 each each DT 5684 219 85 may may MD 5684 219 86 be be VB 5684 219 87 what what WP 5684 219 88 he -PRON- PRP 5684 219 89 will will MD 5684 219 90 . . . 5684 220 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 5684 220 2 , , , 5684 220 3 the the DT 5684 220 4 supreme supreme NNP 5684 220 5 principle principle NN 5684 220 6 of of IN 5684 220 7 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 220 8 is be VBZ 5684 220 9 an an DT 5684 220 10 analytical analytical JJ 5684 220 11 principle principle NN 5684 220 12 . . . 5684 221 1 On on IN 5684 221 2 the the DT 5684 221 3 contrary contrary NN 5684 221 4 the the DT 5684 221 5 principle principle NN 5684 221 6 of of IN 5684 221 7 ethics ethic NNS 5684 221 8 goes go VBZ 5684 221 9 beyond beyond IN 5684 221 10 the the DT 5684 221 11 notion notion NN 5684 221 12 of of IN 5684 221 13 external external JJ 5684 221 14 freedom freedom NN 5684 221 15 and and CC 5684 221 16 , , , 5684 221 17 by by IN 5684 221 18 general general JJ 5684 221 19 laws law NNS 5684 221 20 , , , 5684 221 21 connects connect NNS 5684 221 22 further further RB 5684 221 23 with with IN 5684 221 24 it -PRON- PRP 5684 221 25 an an DT 5684 221 26 end end NN 5684 221 27 which which WDT 5684 221 28 it -PRON- PRP 5684 221 29 makes make VBZ 5684 221 30 a a DT 5684 221 31 duty duty NN 5684 221 32 . . . 5684 222 1 This this DT 5684 222 2 principle principle NN 5684 222 3 , , , 5684 222 4 therefore therefore RB 5684 222 5 , , , 5684 222 6 is be VBZ 5684 222 7 synthetic synthetic JJ 5684 222 8 . . . 5684 223 1 The the DT 5684 223 2 possibility possibility NN 5684 223 3 of of IN 5684 223 4 it -PRON- PRP 5684 223 5 is be VBZ 5684 223 6 contained contain VBN 5684 223 7 in in IN 5684 223 8 the the DT 5684 223 9 Deduction Deduction NNP 5684 223 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 223 11 Sec Sec NNP 5684 223 12 . . . 5684 224 1 ix ix NNP 5684 224 2 . . . 5684 224 3 ) ) -RRB- 5684 224 4 . . . 5684 225 1 This this DT 5684 225 2 enlargement enlargement NN 5684 225 3 of of IN 5684 225 4 the the DT 5684 225 5 notion notion NN 5684 225 6 of of IN 5684 225 7 duty duty NN 5684 225 8 beyond beyond IN 5684 225 9 that that DT 5684 225 10 of of IN 5684 225 11 external external JJ 5684 225 12 freedom freedom NN 5684 225 13 and and CC 5684 225 14 of of IN 5684 225 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 225 16 limitation limitation NN 5684 225 17 by by IN 5684 225 18 the the DT 5684 225 19 merely merely RB 5684 225 20 formal formal JJ 5684 225 21 condition condition NN 5684 225 22 of of IN 5684 225 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 225 24 constant constant JJ 5684 225 25 harmony harmony NN 5684 225 26 ; ; : 5684 225 27 this this DT 5684 225 28 , , , 5684 225 29 I -PRON- PRP 5684 225 30 say say VBP 5684 225 31 , , , 5684 225 32 in in IN 5684 225 33 which which WDT 5684 225 34 , , , 5684 225 35 instead instead RB 5684 225 36 of of IN 5684 225 37 constraint constraint NN 5684 225 38 from from IN 5684 225 39 without without RB 5684 225 40 , , , 5684 225 41 there there EX 5684 225 42 is be VBZ 5684 225 43 set set VBN 5684 225 44 up up RP 5684 225 45 freedom freedom NN 5684 225 46 within within IN 5684 225 47 , , , 5684 225 48 the the DT 5684 225 49 power power NN 5684 225 50 of of IN 5684 225 51 self self NN 5684 225 52 - - HYPH 5684 225 53 constraint constraint NN 5684 225 54 , , , 5684 225 55 and and CC 5684 225 56 that that IN 5684 225 57 not not RB 5684 225 58 by by IN 5684 225 59 the the DT 5684 225 60 help help NN 5684 225 61 of of IN 5684 225 62 other other JJ 5684 225 63 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 225 64 , , , 5684 225 65 but but CC 5684 225 66 by by IN 5684 225 67 pure pure JJ 5684 225 68 practical practical JJ 5684 225 69 reason reason NN 5684 225 70 ( ( -LRB- 5684 225 71 which which WDT 5684 225 72 scorns scorn VBZ 5684 225 73 all all DT 5684 225 74 such such JJ 5684 225 75 help help NN 5684 225 76 ) ) -RRB- 5684 225 77 , , , 5684 225 78 consists consist VBZ 5684 225 79 in in IN 5684 225 80 this this DT 5684 225 81 fact fact NN 5684 225 82 , , , 5684 225 83 which which WDT 5684 225 84 raises raise VBZ 5684 225 85 it -PRON- PRP 5684 225 86 above above IN 5684 225 87 juridical juridical JJ 5684 225 88 duty duty NN 5684 225 89 ; ; : 5684 225 90 that that IN 5684 225 91 by by IN 5684 225 92 it -PRON- PRP 5684 225 93 ends end VBZ 5684 225 94 are be VBP 5684 225 95 proposed propose VBN 5684 225 96 from from IN 5684 225 97 which which WDT 5684 225 98 jurisprudence jurisprudence NN 5684 225 99 altogether altogether RB 5684 225 100 abstracts abstract NNS 5684 225 101 . . . 5684 226 1 In in IN 5684 226 2 the the DT 5684 226 3 case case NN 5684 226 4 of of IN 5684 226 5 the the DT 5684 226 6 moral moral JJ 5684 226 7 imperative imperative NN 5684 226 8 , , , 5684 226 9 and and CC 5684 226 10 the the DT 5684 226 11 supposition supposition NN 5684 226 12 of of IN 5684 226 13 freedom freedom NN 5684 226 14 which which WDT 5684 226 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 226 16 necessarily necessarily RB 5684 226 17 involves involve VBZ 5684 226 18 , , , 5684 226 19 the the DT 5684 226 20 law law NN 5684 226 21 , , , 5684 226 22 the the DT 5684 226 23 power power NN 5684 226 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 226 25 to to TO 5684 226 26 fulfil fulfil VB 5684 226 27 it -PRON- PRP 5684 226 28 ) ) -RRB- 5684 226 29 and and CC 5684 226 30 the the DT 5684 226 31 rational rational JJ 5684 226 32 will will NN 5684 226 33 that that WDT 5684 226 34 determines determine VBZ 5684 226 35 the the DT 5684 226 36 maxim maxim NN 5684 226 37 , , , 5684 226 38 constitute constitute VB 5684 226 39 all all PDT 5684 226 40 the the DT 5684 226 41 elements element NNS 5684 226 42 that that WDT 5684 226 43 form form VBP 5684 226 44 the the DT 5684 226 45 notion notion NN 5684 226 46 of of IN 5684 226 47 juridical juridical JJ 5684 226 48 duty duty NN 5684 226 49 . . . 5684 227 1 But but CC 5684 227 2 in in IN 5684 227 3 the the DT 5684 227 4 imperative imperative NN 5684 227 5 , , , 5684 227 6 which which WDT 5684 227 7 commands command VBZ 5684 227 8 the the DT 5684 227 9 duty duty NN 5684 227 10 of of IN 5684 227 11 virtue virtue NN 5684 227 12 , , , 5684 227 13 there there EX 5684 227 14 is be VBZ 5684 227 15 added add VBN 5684 227 16 , , , 5684 227 17 besides besides IN 5684 227 18 the the DT 5684 227 19 notion notion NN 5684 227 20 of of IN 5684 227 21 self self NN 5684 227 22 - - HYPH 5684 227 23 constraint constraint NN 5684 227 24 , , , 5684 227 25 that that DT 5684 227 26 of of IN 5684 227 27 an an DT 5684 227 28 end end NN 5684 227 29 ; ; : 5684 227 30 not not RB 5684 227 31 one one CD 5684 227 32 that that WDT 5684 227 33 we -PRON- PRP 5684 227 34 have have VBP 5684 227 35 , , , 5684 227 36 but but CC 5684 227 37 that that IN 5684 227 38 we -PRON- PRP 5684 227 39 ought ought MD 5684 227 40 to to TO 5684 227 41 have have VB 5684 227 42 , , , 5684 227 43 which which WDT 5684 227 44 , , , 5684 227 45 therefore therefore RB 5684 227 46 , , , 5684 227 47 pure pure JJ 5684 227 48 practical practical JJ 5684 227 49 reason reason NN 5684 227 50 has have VBZ 5684 227 51 in in IN 5684 227 52 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 227 53 , , , 5684 227 54 whose whose WP$ 5684 227 55 highest high JJS 5684 227 56 , , , 5684 227 57 unconditional unconditional JJ 5684 227 58 end end NN 5684 227 59 ( ( -LRB- 5684 227 60 which which WDT 5684 227 61 , , , 5684 227 62 however however RB 5684 227 63 , , , 5684 227 64 continues continue VBZ 5684 227 65 to to TO 5684 227 66 be be VB 5684 227 67 duty duty NN 5684 227 68 ) ) -RRB- 5684 227 69 consists consist VBZ 5684 227 70 in in IN 5684 227 71 this this DT 5684 227 72 : : : 5684 227 73 that that DT 5684 227 74 virtue virtue NN 5684 227 75 is be VBZ 5684 227 76 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 227 77 own own JJ 5684 227 78 end end NN 5684 227 79 and and CC 5684 227 80 , , , 5684 227 81 by by IN 5684 227 82 deserving deserve VBG 5684 227 83 well well RB 5684 227 84 of of IN 5684 227 85 men man NNS 5684 227 86 , , , 5684 227 87 is be VBZ 5684 227 88 also also RB 5684 227 89 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 227 90 own own JJ 5684 227 91 reward reward NN 5684 227 92 . . . 5684 228 1 Herein Herein NNP 5684 228 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 228 3 shines shine VBZ 5684 228 4 so so RB 5684 228 5 brightly brightly RB 5684 228 6 as as IN 5684 228 7 an an DT 5684 228 8 ideal ideal NN 5684 228 9 to to IN 5684 228 10 human human JJ 5684 228 11 perceptions perception NNS 5684 228 12 , , , 5684 228 13 it -PRON- PRP 5684 228 14 seems seem VBZ 5684 228 15 to to TO 5684 228 16 cast cast VB 5684 228 17 in in IN 5684 228 18 the the DT 5684 228 19 shade shade NN 5684 228 20 even even RB 5684 228 21 holiness holiness VBP 5684 228 22 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 228 23 , , , 5684 228 24 which which WDT 5684 228 25 is be VBZ 5684 228 26 never never RB 5684 228 27 tempted tempt VBN 5684 228 28 to to IN 5684 228 29 transgression transgression NN 5684 228 30 . . . 5684 229 1 * * NFP 5684 229 2 This this DT 5684 229 3 , , , 5684 229 4 however however RB 5684 229 5 , , , 5684 229 6 is be VBZ 5684 229 7 an an DT 5684 229 8 illusion illusion NN 5684 229 9 arising arise VBG 5684 229 10 from from IN 5684 229 11 the the DT 5684 229 12 fact fact NN 5684 229 13 that that IN 5684 229 14 as as IN 5684 229 15 we -PRON- PRP 5684 229 16 have have VBP 5684 229 17 no no DT 5684 229 18 measure measure NN 5684 229 19 for for IN 5684 229 20 the the DT 5684 229 21 degree degree NN 5684 229 22 of of IN 5684 229 23 strength strength NN 5684 229 24 , , , 5684 229 25 except except IN 5684 229 26 the the DT 5684 229 27 greatness greatness NN 5684 229 28 of of IN 5684 229 29 the the DT 5684 229 30 obstacles obstacle NNS 5684 229 31 which which WDT 5684 229 32 might may MD 5684 229 33 have have VB 5684 229 34 been be VBN 5684 229 35 overcome overcome VBN 5684 229 36 ( ( -LRB- 5684 229 37 which which WDT 5684 229 38 in in IN 5684 229 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 229 40 case case NN 5684 229 41 are be VBP 5684 229 42 the the DT 5684 229 43 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 229 44 ) ) -RRB- 5684 229 45 , , , 5684 229 46 we -PRON- PRP 5684 229 47 are be VBP 5684 229 48 led lead VBN 5684 229 49 to to TO 5684 229 50 mistake mistake VB 5684 229 51 the the DT 5684 229 52 subjective subjective JJ 5684 229 53 conditions condition NNS 5684 229 54 of of IN 5684 229 55 estimation estimation NN 5684 229 56 of of IN 5684 229 57 a a DT 5684 229 58 magnitude magnitude NN 5684 229 59 for for IN 5684 229 60 the the DT 5684 229 61 objective objective JJ 5684 229 62 conditions condition NNS 5684 229 63 of of IN 5684 229 64 the the DT 5684 229 65 magnitude magnitude NN 5684 229 66 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 229 67 . . . 5684 230 1 But but CC 5684 230 2 when when WRB 5684 230 3 compared compare VBN 5684 230 4 with with IN 5684 230 5 human human JJ 5684 230 6 ends end NNS 5684 230 7 , , , 5684 230 8 all all DT 5684 230 9 of of IN 5684 230 10 which which WDT 5684 230 11 have have VBP 5684 230 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 230 13 obstacles obstacle NNS 5684 230 14 to to TO 5684 230 15 be be VB 5684 230 16 overcome overcome VBN 5684 230 17 , , , 5684 230 18 it -PRON- PRP 5684 230 19 is be VBZ 5684 230 20 true true JJ 5684 230 21 that that IN 5684 230 22 the the DT 5684 230 23 worth worth NN 5684 230 24 of of IN 5684 230 25 virtue virtue NN 5684 230 26 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 230 27 , , , 5684 230 28 which which WDT 5684 230 29 is be VBZ 5684 230 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 230 31 own own JJ 5684 230 32 end end NN 5684 230 33 , , , 5684 230 34 far far RB 5684 230 35 outweighs outweigh VBZ 5684 230 36 the the DT 5684 230 37 worth worth NN 5684 230 38 of of IN 5684 230 39 all all PDT 5684 230 40 the the DT 5684 230 41 utility utility NN 5684 230 42 and and CC 5684 230 43 all all PDT 5684 230 44 the the DT 5684 230 45 empirical empirical JJ 5684 230 46 ends end NNS 5684 230 47 and and CC 5684 230 48 advantages advantage NNS 5684 230 49 which which WDT 5684 230 50 it -PRON- PRP 5684 230 51 may may MD 5684 230 52 have have VB 5684 230 53 as as IN 5684 230 54 consequences consequence NNS 5684 230 55 . . . 5684 231 1 * * NFP 5684 231 2 So so IN 5684 231 3 that that IN 5684 231 4 one one PRP 5684 231 5 might may MD 5684 231 6 vary vary VB 5684 231 7 two two CD 5684 231 8 well well RB 5684 231 9 - - HYPH 5684 231 10 known know VBN 5684 231 11 lines line NNS 5684 231 12 of of IN 5684 231 13 Haller Haller NNP 5684 231 14 thus thus RB 5684 231 15 : : : 5684 231 16 { { -LRB- 5684 231 17 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 231 18 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 231 19 100 100 CD 5684 231 20 } } -RRB- 5684 231 21 With with IN 5684 231 22 all all PDT 5684 231 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 231 24 failings failing NNS 5684 231 25 , , , 5684 231 26 man man NN 5684 231 27 is be VBZ 5684 231 28 still still RB 5684 231 29 Better well JJR 5684 231 30 than than IN 5684 231 31 angels angel NNS 5684 231 32 void void JJ 5684 231 33 of of IN 5684 231 34 will will NNP 5684 231 35 . . . 5684 232 1 We -PRON- PRP 5684 232 2 may may MD 5684 232 3 , , , 5684 232 4 indeed indeed RB 5684 232 5 , , , 5684 232 6 say say VBP 5684 232 7 that that DT 5684 232 8 man man NN 5684 232 9 is be VBZ 5684 232 10 obliged oblige VBN 5684 232 11 to to TO 5684 232 12 virtue virtue VB 5684 232 13 ( ( -LRB- 5684 232 14 as as IN 5684 232 15 a a DT 5684 232 16 moral moral JJ 5684 232 17 strength strength NN 5684 232 18 ) ) -RRB- 5684 232 19 . . . 5684 233 1 For for IN 5684 233 2 although although IN 5684 233 3 the the DT 5684 233 4 power power NN 5684 233 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 233 6 facultas facultas NN 5684 233 7 ) ) -RRB- 5684 233 8 to to TO 5684 233 9 overcome overcome VB 5684 233 10 all all DT 5684 233 11 imposing impose VBG 5684 233 12 sensible sensible JJ 5684 233 13 impulses impulse NNS 5684 233 14 by by IN 5684 233 15 virtue virtue NN 5684 233 16 of of IN 5684 233 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 233 18 freedom freedom NN 5684 233 19 can can MD 5684 233 20 and and CC 5684 233 21 must must MD 5684 233 22 be be VB 5684 233 23 presupposed presuppose VBN 5684 233 24 , , , 5684 233 25 yet yet CC 5684 233 26 this this DT 5684 233 27 power power NN 5684 233 28 regarded regard VBD 5684 233 29 as as IN 5684 233 30 strength strength NN 5684 233 31 ( ( -LRB- 5684 233 32 robur robur NN 5684 233 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 233 34 is be VBZ 5684 233 35 something something NN 5684 233 36 that that WDT 5684 233 37 must must MD 5684 233 38 be be VB 5684 233 39 acquired acquire VBN 5684 233 40 by by IN 5684 233 41 the the DT 5684 233 42 moral moral JJ 5684 233 43 spring spring NN 5684 233 44 ( ( -LRB- 5684 233 45 the the DT 5684 233 46 idea idea NN 5684 233 47 of of IN 5684 233 48 the the DT 5684 233 49 law law NN 5684 233 50 ) ) -RRB- 5684 233 51 being be VBG 5684 233 52 elevated elevate VBN 5684 233 53 by by IN 5684 233 54 contemplation contemplation NN 5684 233 55 of of IN 5684 233 56 the the DT 5684 233 57 dignity dignity NN 5684 233 58 of of IN 5684 233 59 the the DT 5684 233 60 pure pure JJ 5684 233 61 law law NN 5684 233 62 of of IN 5684 233 63 reason reason NN 5684 233 64 in in IN 5684 233 65 us -PRON- PRP 5684 233 66 , , , 5684 233 67 and and CC 5684 233 68 at at IN 5684 233 69 the the DT 5684 233 70 same same JJ 5684 233 71 time time NN 5684 233 72 also also RB 5684 233 73 by by IN 5684 233 74 exercise exercise NN 5684 233 75 . . . 5684 234 1 { { -LRB- 5684 234 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 234 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 234 4 105 105 CD 5684 234 5 } } -RRB- 5684 234 6 XI XI NNP 5684 234 7 . . . 5684 235 1 According accord VBG 5684 235 2 to to IN 5684 235 3 the the DT 5684 235 4 preceding precede VBG 5684 235 5 Principles Principles NNPS 5684 235 6 , , , 5684 235 7 the the DT 5684 235 8 Scheme Scheme NNP 5684 235 9 of of IN 5684 235 10 Duties Duties NNPS 5684 235 11 of of IN 5684 235 12 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 235 13 may may MD 5684 235 14 be be VB 5684 235 15 thus thus RB 5684 235 16 exhibited exhibit VBN 5684 235 17 The the DT 5684 235 18 Material Material NNP 5684 235 19 Element Element NNP 5684 235 20 of of IN 5684 235 21 the the DT 5684 235 22 Duty Duty NNP 5684 235 23 of of IN 5684 235 24 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 235 25 { { -LRB- 5684 235 26 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 235 27 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 235 28 110 110 CD 5684 235 29 } } -RRB- 5684 235 30 1 1 CD 5684 235 31 2 2 CD 5684 235 32 Internal Internal NNP 5684 235 33 Duty Duty NNP 5684 235 34 of of IN 5684 235 35 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 235 36 External External NNP 5684 235 37 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 235 38 of of IN 5684 235 39 Duty Duty NNP 5684 235 40 My -PRON- PRP$ 5684 235 41 Own own JJ 5684 235 42 End end NN 5684 235 43 , , , 5684 235 44 The the DT 5684 235 45 End end NN 5684 235 46 of of IN 5684 235 47 Others Others NNPS 5684 235 48 , , , 5684 235 49 which which WDT 5684 235 50 is be VBZ 5684 235 51 also also RB 5684 235 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 235 53 the the DT 5684 235 54 promotion promotion NN 5684 235 55 of of IN 5684 235 56 { { -LRB- 5684 235 57 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 235 58 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 235 59 115 115 CD 5684 235 60 } } -RRB- 5684 235 61 Duty Duty NNP 5684 235 62 which which WDT 5684 235 63 is be VBZ 5684 235 64 also also RB 5684 235 65 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 235 66 Duty Duty NNP 5684 235 67 ( ( -LRB- 5684 235 68 My -PRON- PRP$ 5684 235 69 own own JJ 5684 235 70 ( ( -LRB- 5684 235 71 The the DT 5684 235 72 Happiness Happiness NNP 5684 235 73 Perfection Perfection NNP 5684 235 74 ) ) -RRB- 5684 235 75 of of IN 5684 235 76 Others other NNS 5684 235 77 ) ) -RRB- 5684 235 78 { { -LRB- 5684 235 79 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 235 80 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 235 81 120 120 CD 5684 235 82 } } -RRB- 5684 235 83 3 3 CD 5684 235 84 4 4 CD 5684 235 85 The the DT 5684 235 86 Law Law NNP 5684 235 87 which which WDT 5684 235 88 is be VBZ 5684 235 89 The the DT 5684 235 90 End end NN 5684 235 91 which which WDT 5684 235 92 is be VBZ 5684 235 93 also also RB 5684 235 94 Spring spring NN 5684 235 95 also also RB 5684 235 96 Spring spring VB 5684 235 97 { { -LRB- 5684 235 98 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 235 99 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 235 100 125 125 CD 5684 235 101 } } -RRB- 5684 235 102 On on IN 5684 235 103 which which WDT 5684 235 104 the the DT 5684 235 105 On on IN 5684 235 106 which which WDT 5684 235 107 the the DT 5684 235 108 Morality Morality NNP 5684 235 109 Legality Legality NNP 5684 235 110 of of IN 5684 235 111 every every DT 5684 235 112 free free JJ 5684 235 113 determination determination NN 5684 235 114 of of IN 5684 235 115 will will NN 5684 235 116 rests rest NNS 5684 235 117 { { -LRB- 5684 235 118 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 235 119 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 235 120 130 130 CD 5684 235 121 } } -RRB- 5684 235 122 The the DT 5684 235 123 Formal Formal NNP 5684 235 124 Element Element NNP 5684 235 125 of of IN 5684 235 126 the the DT 5684 235 127 Duty Duty NNP 5684 235 128 of of IN 5684 235 129 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 235 130 . . . 5684 236 1 XII XII NNP 5684 236 2 . . . 5684 237 1 Preliminary preliminary JJ 5684 237 2 Notions notion NNS 5684 237 3 of of IN 5684 237 4 the the DT 5684 237 5 Susceptibility susceptibility NN 5684 237 6 of of IN 5684 237 7 the the DT 5684 237 8 Mind mind NN 5684 237 9 for for IN 5684 237 10 Notions notion NNS 5684 237 11 of of IN 5684 237 12 Duty Duty NNP 5684 237 13 generally generally RB 5684 237 14 { { -LRB- 5684 237 15 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 237 16 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 237 17 135 135 CD 5684 237 18 } } -RRB- 5684 237 19 These these DT 5684 237 20 are be VBP 5684 237 21 such such JJ 5684 237 22 moral moral JJ 5684 237 23 qualities quality NNS 5684 237 24 as as IN 5684 237 25 , , , 5684 237 26 when when WRB 5684 237 27 a a DT 5684 237 28 man man NN 5684 237 29 does do VBZ 5684 237 30 not not RB 5684 237 31 possess possess VB 5684 237 32 them -PRON- PRP 5684 237 33 , , , 5684 237 34 he -PRON- PRP 5684 237 35 is be VBZ 5684 237 36 not not RB 5684 237 37 bound bind VBN 5684 237 38 to to TO 5684 237 39 acquire acquire VB 5684 237 40 them -PRON- PRP 5684 237 41 . . . 5684 238 1 They -PRON- PRP 5684 238 2 are be VBP 5684 238 3 : : : 5684 238 4 the the DT 5684 238 5 moral moral JJ 5684 238 6 feeling feeling NN 5684 238 7 , , , 5684 238 8 conscience conscience NN 5684 238 9 , , , 5684 238 10 love love NN 5684 238 11 of of IN 5684 238 12 one one NN 5684 238 13 's 's POS 5684 238 14 neighbour neighbour NN 5684 238 15 , , , 5684 238 16 and and CC 5684 238 17 respect respect NN 5684 238 18 for for IN 5684 238 19 ourselves -PRON- PRP 5684 238 20 ( ( -LRB- 5684 238 21 self self NN 5684 238 22 - - HYPH 5684 238 23 esteem esteem NN 5684 238 24 ) ) -RRB- 5684 238 25 . . . 5684 239 1 There there EX 5684 239 2 is be VBZ 5684 239 3 no no DT 5684 239 4 obligation obligation NN 5684 239 5 to to TO 5684 239 6 have have VB 5684 239 7 these these DT 5684 239 8 , , , 5684 239 9 since since IN 5684 239 10 they -PRON- PRP 5684 239 11 are be VBP 5684 239 12 subjective subjective JJ 5684 239 13 conditions condition NNS 5684 239 14 of of IN 5684 239 15 susceptibility susceptibility NN 5684 239 16 for for IN 5684 239 17 the the DT 5684 239 18 notion notion NN 5684 239 19 of of IN 5684 239 20 duty duty NN 5684 239 21 , , , 5684 239 22 not not RB 5684 239 23 objective objective JJ 5684 239 24 conditions condition NNS 5684 239 25 of of IN 5684 239 26 morality morality NN 5684 239 27 . . . 5684 240 1 They -PRON- PRP 5684 240 2 are be VBP 5684 240 3 all all RB 5684 240 4 sensitive sensitive JJ 5684 240 5 and and CC 5684 240 6 antecedent antecedent NN 5684 240 7 , , , 5684 240 8 but but CC 5684 240 9 natural natural JJ 5684 240 10 capacities capacity NNS 5684 240 11 of of IN 5684 240 12 mind mind NN 5684 240 13 ( ( -LRB- 5684 240 14 praedispositio praedispositio NN 5684 240 15 ) ) -RRB- 5684 240 16 to to TO 5684 240 17 be be VB 5684 240 18 affected affect VBN 5684 240 19 by by IN 5684 240 20 notions notion NNS 5684 240 21 of of IN 5684 240 22 duty duty NN 5684 240 23 ; ; : 5684 240 24 capacities capacity NNS 5684 240 25 which which WDT 5684 240 26 it -PRON- PRP 5684 240 27 can can MD 5684 240 28 not not RB 5684 240 29 be be VB 5684 240 30 regarded regard VBN 5684 240 31 as as IN 5684 240 32 a a DT 5684 240 33 duty duty NN 5684 240 34 to to TO 5684 240 35 have have VB 5684 240 36 , , , 5684 240 37 but but CC 5684 240 38 which which WDT 5684 240 39 every every DT 5684 240 40 man man NN 5684 240 41 has have VBZ 5684 240 42 , , , 5684 240 43 and and CC 5684 240 44 by by IN 5684 240 45 virtue virtue NN 5684 240 46 of of IN 5684 240 47 which which WDT 5684 240 48 he -PRON- PRP 5684 240 49 can can MD 5684 240 50 be be VB 5684 240 51 brought bring VBN 5684 240 52 under under IN 5684 240 53 obligation obligation NN 5684 240 54 . . . 5684 241 1 The the DT 5684 241 2 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 241 3 of of IN 5684 241 4 them -PRON- PRP 5684 241 5 is be VBZ 5684 241 6 not not RB 5684 241 7 of of IN 5684 241 8 empirical empirical JJ 5684 241 9 origin origin NN 5684 241 10 , , , 5684 241 11 but but CC 5684 241 12 can can MD 5684 241 13 only only RB 5684 241 14 follow follow VB 5684 241 15 on on IN 5684 241 16 that that DT 5684 241 17 of of IN 5684 241 18 a a DT 5684 241 19 moral moral JJ 5684 241 20 law law NN 5684 241 21 , , , 5684 241 22 as as IN 5684 241 23 an an DT 5684 241 24 effect effect NN 5684 241 25 of of IN 5684 241 26 the the DT 5684 241 27 same same JJ 5684 241 28 on on IN 5684 241 29 the the DT 5684 241 30 mind mind NN 5684 241 31 . . . 5684 242 1 A. A. NNP 5684 243 1 THE the DT 5684 243 2 MORAL moral JJ 5684 243 3 FEELING feel VBG 5684 243 4 This this DT 5684 243 5 is be VBZ 5684 243 6 the the DT 5684 243 7 susceptibility susceptibility NN 5684 243 8 for for IN 5684 243 9 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 243 10 or or CC 5684 243 11 displeasure displeasure NN 5684 243 12 , , , 5684 243 13 merely merely RB 5684 243 14 from from IN 5684 243 15 the the DT 5684 243 16 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 243 17 of of IN 5684 243 18 the the DT 5684 243 19 agreement agreement NN 5684 243 20 or or CC 5684 243 21 disagreement disagreement NN 5684 243 22 of of IN 5684 243 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 243 24 action action NN 5684 243 25 with with IN 5684 243 26 the the DT 5684 243 27 law law NN 5684 243 28 of of IN 5684 243 29 duty duty NN 5684 243 30 . . . 5684 244 1 Now now RB 5684 244 2 , , , 5684 244 3 every every DT 5684 244 4 determination determination NN 5684 244 5 of of IN 5684 244 6 the the DT 5684 244 7 elective elective NN 5684 244 8 will will MD 5684 244 9 proceeds proceed VBZ 5684 244 10 from from IN 5684 244 11 the the DT 5684 244 12 idea idea NN 5684 244 13 of of IN 5684 244 14 the the DT 5684 244 15 possible possible JJ 5684 244 16 action action NN 5684 244 17 through through IN 5684 244 18 the the DT 5684 244 19 feeling feeling NN 5684 244 20 of of IN 5684 244 21 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 244 22 or or CC 5684 244 23 displeasure displeasure NN 5684 244 24 in in IN 5684 244 25 taking take VBG 5684 244 26 an an DT 5684 244 27 interest interest NN 5684 244 28 in in IN 5684 244 29 it -PRON- PRP 5684 244 30 or or CC 5684 244 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 244 32 effect effect NN 5684 244 33 to to IN 5684 244 34 the the DT 5684 244 35 deed deed NN 5684 244 36 ; ; : 5684 244 37 and and CC 5684 244 38 here here RB 5684 244 39 the the DT 5684 244 40 sensitive sensitive JJ 5684 244 41 state state NN 5684 244 42 ( ( -LRB- 5684 244 43 the the DT 5684 244 44 affection affection NN 5684 244 45 of of IN 5684 244 46 the the DT 5684 244 47 internal internal JJ 5684 244 48 sense sense NN 5684 244 49 ) ) -RRB- 5684 244 50 is be VBZ 5684 244 51 either either CC 5684 244 52 a a DT 5684 244 53 pathological pathological JJ 5684 244 54 or or CC 5684 244 55 a a DT 5684 244 56 moral moral JJ 5684 244 57 feeling feeling NN 5684 244 58 . . . 5684 245 1 The the DT 5684 245 2 former former JJ 5684 245 3 is be VBZ 5684 245 4 the the DT 5684 245 5 feeling feeling NN 5684 245 6 that that WDT 5684 245 7 precedes precede VBZ 5684 245 8 the the DT 5684 245 9 idea idea NN 5684 245 10 of of IN 5684 245 11 the the DT 5684 245 12 law law NN 5684 245 13 , , , 5684 245 14 the the DT 5684 245 15 latter latter JJ 5684 245 16 that that WDT 5684 245 17 which which WDT 5684 245 18 may may MD 5684 245 19 follow follow VB 5684 245 20 it -PRON- PRP 5684 245 21 . . . 5684 246 1 { { -LRB- 5684 246 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 246 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 246 4 140 140 CD 5684 246 5 } } -RRB- 5684 246 6 Now now RB 5684 246 7 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 8 can can MD 5684 246 9 not not RB 5684 246 10 be be VB 5684 246 11 a a DT 5684 246 12 duty duty NN 5684 246 13 to to TO 5684 246 14 have have VB 5684 246 15 a a DT 5684 246 16 moral moral JJ 5684 246 17 feeling feeling NN 5684 246 18 , , , 5684 246 19 or or CC 5684 246 20 to to TO 5684 246 21 acquire acquire VB 5684 246 22 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 23 ; ; : 5684 246 24 for for IN 5684 246 25 all all DT 5684 246 26 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 246 27 of of IN 5684 246 28 obligation obligation NN 5684 246 29 supposes suppose VBZ 5684 246 30 this this DT 5684 246 31 feeling feeling NN 5684 246 32 in in IN 5684 246 33 order order NN 5684 246 34 that that IN 5684 246 35 one one PRP 5684 246 36 may may MD 5684 246 37 become become VB 5684 246 38 conscious conscious JJ 5684 246 39 of of IN 5684 246 40 the the DT 5684 246 41 necessitation necessitation NN 5684 246 42 that that WDT 5684 246 43 lies lie VBZ 5684 246 44 in in IN 5684 246 45 the the DT 5684 246 46 notion notion NN 5684 246 47 of of IN 5684 246 48 duty duty NN 5684 246 49 ; ; : 5684 246 50 but but CC 5684 246 51 every every DT 5684 246 52 man man NN 5684 246 53 ( ( -LRB- 5684 246 54 as as IN 5684 246 55 a a DT 5684 246 56 moral moral JJ 5684 246 57 being being NN 5684 246 58 ) ) -RRB- 5684 246 59 has have VBZ 5684 246 60 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 61 originally originally RB 5684 246 62 in in IN 5684 246 63 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 246 64 ; ; : 5684 246 65 the the DT 5684 246 66 obligation obligation NN 5684 246 67 , , , 5684 246 68 then then RB 5684 246 69 , , , 5684 246 70 can can MD 5684 246 71 only only RB 5684 246 72 extend extend VB 5684 246 73 to to IN 5684 246 74 the the DT 5684 246 75 cultivation cultivation NN 5684 246 76 of of IN 5684 246 77 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 78 and and CC 5684 246 79 the the DT 5684 246 80 strengthening strengthening NN 5684 246 81 of of IN 5684 246 82 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 83 even even RB 5684 246 84 by by IN 5684 246 85 admiration admiration NN 5684 246 86 of of IN 5684 246 87 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 246 88 inscrutable inscrutable JJ 5684 246 89 origin origin NN 5684 246 90 ; ; : 5684 246 91 and and CC 5684 246 92 this this DT 5684 246 93 is be VBZ 5684 246 94 effected effect VBN 5684 246 95 by by IN 5684 246 96 showing show VBG 5684 246 97 how how WRB 5684 246 98 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 99 is be VBZ 5684 246 100 just just RB 5684 246 101 , , , 5684 246 102 by by IN 5684 246 103 the the DT 5684 246 104 mere mere JJ 5684 246 105 conception conception NN 5684 246 106 of of IN 5684 246 107 reason reason NN 5684 246 108 , , , 5684 246 109 that that IN 5684 246 110 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 111 is be VBZ 5684 246 112 excited excited JJ 5684 246 113 most most RBS 5684 246 114 strongly strongly RB 5684 246 115 , , , 5684 246 116 in in IN 5684 246 117 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 246 118 own own JJ 5684 246 119 purity purity NN 5684 246 120 and and CC 5684 246 121 apart apart RB 5684 246 122 from from IN 5684 246 123 every every DT 5684 246 124 pathological pathological JJ 5684 246 125 stimulus stimulus NN 5684 246 126 ; ; : 5684 246 127 and and CC 5684 246 128 it -PRON- PRP 5684 246 129 is be VBZ 5684 246 130 improper improper JJ 5684 246 131 to to TO 5684 246 132 call call VB 5684 246 133 this this DT 5684 246 134 feeling feeling NN 5684 246 135 a a DT 5684 246 136 moral moral JJ 5684 246 137 sense sense NN 5684 246 138 ; ; : 5684 246 139 for for IN 5684 246 140 the the DT 5684 246 141 word word NN 5684 246 142 sense sense NN 5684 246 143 generally generally RB 5684 246 144 means mean VBZ 5684 246 145 a a DT 5684 246 146 theoretical theoretical JJ 5684 246 147 power power NN 5684 246 148 of of IN 5684 246 149 perception perception NN 5684 246 150 directed direct VBN 5684 246 151 to to IN 5684 246 152 an an DT 5684 246 153 object object NN 5684 246 154 ; ; : 5684 246 155 whereas whereas IN 5684 246 156 the the DT 5684 246 157 moral moral JJ 5684 246 158 feeling feeling NN 5684 246 159 ( ( -LRB- 5684 246 160 like like IN 5684 246 161 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 246 162 and and CC 5684 246 163 displeasure displeasure NN 5684 246 164 in in IN 5684 246 165 general general NN 5684 246 166 ) ) -RRB- 5684 246 167 is be VBZ 5684 246 168 something something NN 5684 246 169 merely merely RB 5684 246 170 subjective subjective JJ 5684 246 171 , , , 5684 246 172 which which WDT 5684 246 173 supplies supply VBZ 5684 246 174 no no DT 5684 246 175 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 246 176 . . . 5684 247 1 No no DT 5684 247 2 man man NN 5684 247 3 is be VBZ 5684 247 4 wholly wholly RB 5684 247 5 destitute destitute JJ 5684 247 6 of of IN 5684 247 7 moral moral JJ 5684 247 8 feeling feeling NN 5684 247 9 , , , 5684 247 10 for for CC 5684 247 11 if if IN 5684 247 12 he -PRON- PRP 5684 247 13 were be VBD 5684 247 14 totally totally RB 5684 247 15 unsusceptible unsusceptible JJ 5684 247 16 of of IN 5684 247 17 this this DT 5684 247 18 sensation sensation NN 5684 247 19 he -PRON- PRP 5684 247 20 would would MD 5684 247 21 be be VB 5684 247 22 morally morally RB 5684 247 23 dead dead JJ 5684 247 24 ; ; : 5684 247 25 and and CC 5684 247 26 , , , 5684 247 27 to to TO 5684 247 28 speak speak VB 5684 247 29 in in IN 5684 247 30 the the DT 5684 247 31 language language NN 5684 247 32 of of IN 5684 247 33 physicians physician NNS 5684 247 34 , , , 5684 247 35 if if IN 5684 247 36 the the DT 5684 247 37 moral moral JJ 5684 247 38 vital vital JJ 5684 247 39 force force NN 5684 247 40 could could MD 5684 247 41 no no RB 5684 247 42 longer longer RB 5684 247 43 produce produce VB 5684 247 44 any any DT 5684 247 45 effect effect NN 5684 247 46 on on IN 5684 247 47 this this DT 5684 247 48 feeling feeling NN 5684 247 49 , , , 5684 247 50 then then RB 5684 247 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 247 52 humanity humanity NN 5684 247 53 would would MD 5684 247 54 be be VB 5684 247 55 dissolved dissolve VBN 5684 247 56 ( ( -LRB- 5684 247 57 as as IN 5684 247 58 it -PRON- PRP 5684 247 59 were be VBD 5684 247 60 by by IN 5684 247 61 chemical chemical JJ 5684 247 62 laws law NNS 5684 247 63 ) ) -RRB- 5684 247 64 into into IN 5684 247 65 mere mere JJ 5684 247 66 animality animality NN 5684 247 67 and and CC 5684 247 68 be be VB 5684 247 69 irrevocably irrevocably RB 5684 247 70 confounded confound VBN 5684 247 71 with with IN 5684 247 72 the the DT 5684 247 73 mass mass NN 5684 247 74 of of IN 5684 247 75 other other JJ 5684 247 76 physical physical JJ 5684 247 77 beings being NNS 5684 247 78 . . . 5684 248 1 But but CC 5684 248 2 we -PRON- PRP 5684 248 3 have have VBP 5684 248 4 no no DT 5684 248 5 special special JJ 5684 248 6 sense sense NN 5684 248 7 for for IN 5684 248 8 ( ( -LRB- 5684 248 9 moral moral JJ 5684 248 10 ) ) -RRB- 5684 248 11 good good NN 5684 248 12 and and CC 5684 248 13 evil evil NN 5684 248 14 any any DT 5684 248 15 more more JJR 5684 248 16 than than IN 5684 248 17 for for IN 5684 248 18 truth truth NN 5684 248 19 , , , 5684 248 20 although although IN 5684 248 21 such such JJ 5684 248 22 expressions expression NNS 5684 248 23 are be VBP 5684 248 24 often often RB 5684 248 25 used use VBN 5684 248 26 ; ; : 5684 248 27 but but CC 5684 248 28 we -PRON- PRP 5684 248 29 have have VBP 5684 248 30 a a DT 5684 248 31 susceptibility susceptibility NN 5684 248 32 of of IN 5684 248 33 the the DT 5684 248 34 free free JJ 5684 248 35 elective elective NN 5684 248 36 will will NN 5684 248 37 for for IN 5684 248 38 being be VBG 5684 248 39 moved move VBN 5684 248 40 by by IN 5684 248 41 pure pure JJ 5684 248 42 practical practical JJ 5684 248 43 reason reason NN 5684 248 44 and and CC 5684 248 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 248 46 law law NN 5684 248 47 ; ; : 5684 248 48 and and CC 5684 248 49 it -PRON- PRP 5684 248 50 is be VBZ 5684 248 51 this this DT 5684 248 52 that that IN 5684 248 53 we -PRON- PRP 5684 248 54 call call VBP 5684 248 55 the the DT 5684 248 56 moral moral JJ 5684 248 57 feeling feeling NN 5684 248 58 . . . 5684 249 1 B. B. NNP 5684 250 1 OF OF NNP 5684 250 2 CONSCIENCE CONSCIENCE NNP 5684 250 3 Similarly similarly RB 5684 250 4 , , , 5684 250 5 conscience conscience NN 5684 250 6 is be VBZ 5684 250 7 not not RB 5684 250 8 a a DT 5684 250 9 thing thing NN 5684 250 10 to to TO 5684 250 11 be be VB 5684 250 12 acquired acquire VBN 5684 250 13 , , , 5684 250 14 and and CC 5684 250 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 250 16 is be VBZ 5684 250 17 not not RB 5684 250 18 a a DT 5684 250 19 duty duty NN 5684 250 20 to to TO 5684 250 21 acquire acquire VB 5684 250 22 it -PRON- PRP 5684 250 23 ; ; : 5684 250 24 but but CC 5684 250 25 every every DT 5684 250 26 man man NN 5684 250 27 , , , 5684 250 28 as as IN 5684 250 29 a a DT 5684 250 30 moral moral JJ 5684 250 31 being being NN 5684 250 32 , , , 5684 250 33 has have VBZ 5684 250 34 it -PRON- PRP 5684 250 35 originally originally RB 5684 250 36 within within IN 5684 250 37 him -PRON- PRP 5684 250 38 . . . 5684 251 1 To to TO 5684 251 2 be be VB 5684 251 3 bound bind VBN 5684 251 4 to to TO 5684 251 5 have have VB 5684 251 6 a a DT 5684 251 7 conscience conscience NN 5684 251 8 would would MD 5684 251 9 be be VB 5684 251 10 as as RB 5684 251 11 much much JJ 5684 251 12 as as IN 5684 251 13 to to TO 5684 251 14 say say VB 5684 251 15 to to TO 5684 251 16 be be VB 5684 251 17 under under IN 5684 251 18 a a DT 5684 251 19 duty duty NN 5684 251 20 to to TO 5684 251 21 recognize recognize VB 5684 251 22 duties duty NNS 5684 251 23 . . . 5684 252 1 For for IN 5684 252 2 conscience conscience NN 5684 252 3 is be VBZ 5684 252 4 practical practical JJ 5684 252 5 reason reason NN 5684 252 6 which which WDT 5684 252 7 , , , 5684 252 8 in in IN 5684 252 9 every every DT 5684 252 10 case case NN 5684 252 11 of of IN 5684 252 12 law law NN 5684 252 13 , , , 5684 252 14 holds hold VBZ 5684 252 15 before before IN 5684 252 16 a a DT 5684 252 17 man man NN 5684 252 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 252 19 duty duty NN 5684 252 20 for for IN 5684 252 21 acquittal acquittal NN 5684 252 22 or or CC 5684 252 23 condemnation condemnation NN 5684 252 24 ; ; : 5684 252 25 consequently consequently RB 5684 252 26 it -PRON- PRP 5684 252 27 does do VBZ 5684 252 28 not not RB 5684 252 29 refer refer VB 5684 252 30 to to IN 5684 252 31 an an DT 5684 252 32 object object NN 5684 252 33 , , , 5684 252 34 but but CC 5684 252 35 only only RB 5684 252 36 to to IN 5684 252 37 the the DT 5684 252 38 subject subject NN 5684 252 39 ( ( -LRB- 5684 252 40 affecting affect VBG 5684 252 41 the the DT 5684 252 42 moral moral JJ 5684 252 43 feeling feeling NN 5684 252 44 by by IN 5684 252 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 252 46 own own JJ 5684 252 47 act act NN 5684 252 48 ) ) -RRB- 5684 252 49 ; ; : 5684 252 50 so so IN 5684 252 51 that that IN 5684 252 52 it -PRON- PRP 5684 252 53 is be VBZ 5684 252 54 an an DT 5684 252 55 inevitable inevitable JJ 5684 252 56 fact fact NN 5684 252 57 , , , 5684 252 58 not not RB 5684 252 59 an an DT 5684 252 60 obligation obligation NN 5684 252 61 and and CC 5684 252 62 duty duty NN 5684 252 63 . . . 5684 253 1 When when WRB 5684 253 2 , , , 5684 253 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 253 4 , , , 5684 253 5 it -PRON- PRP 5684 253 6 is be VBZ 5684 253 7 said say VBN 5684 253 8 , , , 5684 253 9 " " `` 5684 253 10 This this DT 5684 253 11 man man NN 5684 253 12 has have VBZ 5684 253 13 no no DT 5684 253 14 conscience conscience NN 5684 253 15 , , , 5684 253 16 " " '' 5684 253 17 what what WP 5684 253 18 is be VBZ 5684 253 19 meant mean VBN 5684 253 20 is be VBZ 5684 253 21 that that IN 5684 253 22 he -PRON- PRP 5684 253 23 pays pay VBZ 5684 253 24 no no DT 5684 253 25 heed heed NN 5684 253 26 to to IN 5684 253 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 253 28 dictates dictate NNS 5684 253 29 . . . 5684 254 1 For for CC 5684 254 2 if if IN 5684 254 3 he -PRON- PRP 5684 254 4 really really RB 5684 254 5 had have VBD 5684 254 6 none none NN 5684 254 7 , , , 5684 254 8 he -PRON- PRP 5684 254 9 would would MD 5684 254 10 not not RB 5684 254 11 take take VB 5684 254 12 credit credit NN 5684 254 13 to to IN 5684 254 14 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 254 15 for for IN 5684 254 16 anything anything NN 5684 254 17 done do VBN 5684 254 18 according accord VBG 5684 254 19 to to IN 5684 254 20 duty duty NN 5684 254 21 , , , 5684 254 22 nor nor CC 5684 254 23 reproach reproach VB 5684 254 24 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 254 25 with with IN 5684 254 26 violation violation NN 5684 254 27 of of IN 5684 254 28 duty duty NN 5684 254 29 , , , 5684 254 30 and and CC 5684 254 31 therefore therefore RB 5684 254 32 he -PRON- PRP 5684 254 33 would would MD 5684 254 34 be be VB 5684 254 35 unable unable JJ 5684 254 36 even even RB 5684 254 37 to to TO 5684 254 38 conceive conceive VB 5684 254 39 the the DT 5684 254 40 duty duty NN 5684 254 41 of of IN 5684 254 42 having have VBG 5684 254 43 a a DT 5684 254 44 conscience conscience NN 5684 254 45 . . . 5684 255 1 { { -LRB- 5684 255 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 255 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 255 4 145 145 CD 5684 255 5 } } -RRB- 5684 255 6 I -PRON- PRP 5684 255 7 pass pass VBP 5684 255 8 by by IN 5684 255 9 the the DT 5684 255 10 manifold manifold JJ 5684 255 11 subdivisions subdivision NNS 5684 255 12 of of IN 5684 255 13 conscience conscience NN 5684 255 14 , , , 5684 255 15 and and CC 5684 255 16 only only RB 5684 255 17 observe observe VB 5684 255 18 what what WP 5684 255 19 follows follow VBZ 5684 255 20 from from IN 5684 255 21 what what WP 5684 255 22 has have VBZ 5684 255 23 just just RB 5684 255 24 been be VBN 5684 255 25 said say VBN 5684 255 26 , , , 5684 255 27 namely namely RB 5684 255 28 , , , 5684 255 29 that that IN 5684 255 30 there there EX 5684 255 31 is be VBZ 5684 255 32 no no DT 5684 255 33 such such JJ 5684 255 34 thing thing NN 5684 255 35 as as IN 5684 255 36 an an DT 5684 255 37 erring err VBG 5684 255 38 conscience conscience NN 5684 255 39 . . . 5684 256 1 No no RB 5684 256 2 doubt doubt RB 5684 256 3 it -PRON- PRP 5684 256 4 is be VBZ 5684 256 5 possible possible JJ 5684 256 6 sometimes sometimes RB 5684 256 7 to to TO 5684 256 8 err err VB 5684 256 9 in in IN 5684 256 10 the the DT 5684 256 11 objective objective JJ 5684 256 12 judgement judgement NN 5684 256 13 whether whether IN 5684 256 14 something something NN 5684 256 15 is be VBZ 5684 256 16 a a DT 5684 256 17 duty duty NN 5684 256 18 or or CC 5684 256 19 not not RB 5684 256 20 ; ; : 5684 256 21 but but CC 5684 256 22 I -PRON- PRP 5684 256 23 can can MD 5684 256 24 not not RB 5684 256 25 err err VB 5684 256 26 in in IN 5684 256 27 the the DT 5684 256 28 subjective subjective JJ 5684 256 29 whether whether IN 5684 256 30 I -PRON- PRP 5684 256 31 have have VBP 5684 256 32 compared compare VBN 5684 256 33 it -PRON- PRP 5684 256 34 with with IN 5684 256 35 my -PRON- PRP$ 5684 256 36 practical practical JJ 5684 256 37 ( ( -LRB- 5684 256 38 here here RB 5684 256 39 judicially judicially RB 5684 256 40 acting act VBG 5684 256 41 ) ) -RRB- 5684 256 42 reason reason NN 5684 256 43 for for IN 5684 256 44 the the DT 5684 256 45 purpose purpose NN 5684 256 46 of of IN 5684 256 47 that that DT 5684 256 48 judgement judgement NN 5684 256 49 : : : 5684 256 50 for for IN 5684 256 51 if if IN 5684 256 52 I -PRON- PRP 5684 256 53 erred err VBD 5684 256 54 I -PRON- PRP 5684 256 55 would would MD 5684 256 56 not not RB 5684 256 57 have have VB 5684 256 58 exercised exercise VBN 5684 256 59 practical practical JJ 5684 256 60 judgement judgement NN 5684 256 61 at at RB 5684 256 62 all all RB 5684 256 63 , , , 5684 256 64 and and CC 5684 256 65 in in IN 5684 256 66 that that DT 5684 256 67 case case NN 5684 256 68 there there EX 5684 256 69 is be VBZ 5684 256 70 neither neither CC 5684 256 71 truth truth NN 5684 256 72 nor nor CC 5684 256 73 error error NN 5684 256 74 . . . 5684 257 1 Unconscientiousness unconscientiousness NN 5684 257 2 is be VBZ 5684 257 3 not not RB 5684 257 4 want want NN 5684 257 5 of of IN 5684 257 6 conscience conscience NN 5684 257 7 , , , 5684 257 8 but but CC 5684 257 9 the the DT 5684 257 10 propensity propensity NN 5684 257 11 not not RB 5684 257 12 to to TO 5684 257 13 heed heed VB 5684 257 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 257 15 judgement judgement NN 5684 257 16 . . . 5684 258 1 But but CC 5684 258 2 when when WRB 5684 258 3 a a DT 5684 258 4 man man NN 5684 258 5 is be VBZ 5684 258 6 conscious conscious JJ 5684 258 7 of of IN 5684 258 8 having have VBG 5684 258 9 acted act VBN 5684 258 10 according accord VBG 5684 258 11 to to IN 5684 258 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 258 13 conscience conscience NN 5684 258 14 , , , 5684 258 15 then then RB 5684 258 16 , , , 5684 258 17 as as RB 5684 258 18 far far RB 5684 258 19 as as IN 5684 258 20 regards regard VBZ 5684 258 21 guilt guilt NN 5684 258 22 or or CC 5684 258 23 innocence innocence NN 5684 258 24 , , , 5684 258 25 nothing nothing NN 5684 258 26 more more JJR 5684 258 27 can can MD 5684 258 28 be be VB 5684 258 29 required require VBN 5684 258 30 of of IN 5684 258 31 him -PRON- PRP 5684 258 32 , , , 5684 258 33 only only RB 5684 258 34 he -PRON- PRP 5684 258 35 is be VBZ 5684 258 36 bound bind VBN 5684 258 37 to to TO 5684 258 38 enlighten enlighten VB 5684 258 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 258 40 understanding understanding NN 5684 258 41 as as IN 5684 258 42 to to IN 5684 258 43 what what WP 5684 258 44 is be VBZ 5684 258 45 duty duty NN 5684 258 46 or or CC 5684 258 47 not not RB 5684 258 48 ; ; : 5684 258 49 but but CC 5684 258 50 when when WRB 5684 258 51 it -PRON- PRP 5684 258 52 comes come VBZ 5684 258 53 or or CC 5684 258 54 has have VBZ 5684 258 55 come come VBN 5684 258 56 to to IN 5684 258 57 action action NN 5684 258 58 , , , 5684 258 59 then then RB 5684 258 60 conscience conscience NN 5684 258 61 speaks speak VBZ 5684 258 62 involuntarily involuntarily RB 5684 258 63 and and CC 5684 258 64 inevitably inevitably RB 5684 258 65 . . . 5684 259 1 To to TO 5684 259 2 act act VB 5684 259 3 conscientiously conscientiously RB 5684 259 4 can can MD 5684 259 5 , , , 5684 259 6 therefore therefore RB 5684 259 7 , , , 5684 259 8 not not RB 5684 259 9 be be VB 5684 259 10 a a DT 5684 259 11 duty duty NN 5684 259 12 , , , 5684 259 13 since since IN 5684 259 14 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 259 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 259 16 would would MD 5684 259 17 be be VB 5684 259 18 necessary necessary JJ 5684 259 19 to to TO 5684 259 20 have have VB 5684 259 21 a a DT 5684 259 22 second second JJ 5684 259 23 conscience conscience NN 5684 259 24 , , , 5684 259 25 in in IN 5684 259 26 order order NN 5684 259 27 to to TO 5684 259 28 be be VB 5684 259 29 conscious conscious JJ 5684 259 30 of of IN 5684 259 31 the the DT 5684 259 32 act act NN 5684 259 33 of of IN 5684 259 34 the the DT 5684 259 35 first first JJ 5684 259 36 . . . 5684 260 1 The the DT 5684 260 2 duty duty NN 5684 260 3 here here RB 5684 260 4 is be VBZ 5684 260 5 only only RB 5684 260 6 to to TO 5684 260 7 cultivate cultivate VB 5684 260 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 260 9 conscience conscience NN 5684 260 10 , , , 5684 260 11 to to TO 5684 260 12 quicken quicken VB 5684 260 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 260 14 attention attention NN 5684 260 15 to to IN 5684 260 16 the the DT 5684 260 17 voice voice NN 5684 260 18 of of IN 5684 260 19 the the DT 5684 260 20 internal internal JJ 5684 260 21 judge judge NN 5684 260 22 , , , 5684 260 23 and and CC 5684 260 24 to to TO 5684 260 25 use use VB 5684 260 26 all all DT 5684 260 27 means mean NNS 5684 260 28 to to TO 5684 260 29 secure secure VB 5684 260 30 obedience obedience NN 5684 260 31 to to IN 5684 260 32 it -PRON- PRP 5684 260 33 , , , 5684 260 34 and and CC 5684 260 35 is be VBZ 5684 260 36 thus thus RB 5684 260 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 260 38 indirect indirect JJ 5684 260 39 duty duty NN 5684 260 40 . . . 5684 261 1 C. C. NNP 5684 261 2 OF of IN 5684 261 3 LOVE LOVE NNP 5684 261 4 TO to IN 5684 261 5 MEN MEN NNP 5684 261 6 { { -LRB- 5684 261 7 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 5684 261 8 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 261 9 150 150 CD 5684 261 10 } } -RRB- 5684 261 11 Love Love NNP 5684 261 12 is be VBZ 5684 261 13 a a DT 5684 261 14 matter matter NN 5684 261 15 of of IN 5684 261 16 feeling feeling NN 5684 261 17 , , , 5684 261 18 not not RB 5684 261 19 of of IN 5684 261 20 will will NN 5684 261 21 or or CC 5684 261 22 volition volition VB 5684 261 23 , , , 5684 261 24 and and CC 5684 261 25 I -PRON- PRP 5684 261 26 can can MD 5684 261 27 not not RB 5684 261 28 love love VB 5684 261 29 because because IN 5684 261 30 I -PRON- PRP 5684 261 31 will will MD 5684 261 32 to to TO 5684 261 33 do do VB 5684 261 34 so so RB 5684 261 35 , , , 5684 261 36 still still RB 5684 261 37 less less JJR 5684 261 38 because because IN 5684 261 39 I -PRON- PRP 5684 261 40 ought ought MD 5684 261 41 ( ( -LRB- 5684 261 42 I -PRON- PRP 5684 261 43 can can MD 5684 261 44 not not RB 5684 261 45 be be VB 5684 261 46 necessitated necessitate VBN 5684 261 47 to to TO 5684 261 48 love love VB 5684 261 49 ) ) -RRB- 5684 261 50 ; ; : 5684 261 51 hence hence RB 5684 261 52 there there EX 5684 261 53 is be VBZ 5684 261 54 no no DT 5684 261 55 such such JJ 5684 261 56 thing thing NN 5684 261 57 as as IN 5684 261 58 a a DT 5684 261 59 duty duty NN 5684 261 60 to to TO 5684 261 61 love love VB 5684 261 62 . . . 5684 262 1 Benevolence benevolence NN 5684 262 2 , , , 5684 262 3 however however RB 5684 262 4 ( ( -LRB- 5684 262 5 amor amor NNP 5684 262 6 benevolentiae benevolentiae NNP 5684 262 7 ) ) -RRB- 5684 262 8 , , , 5684 262 9 as as IN 5684 262 10 a a DT 5684 262 11 mode mode NN 5684 262 12 of of IN 5684 262 13 action action NN 5684 262 14 , , , 5684 262 15 may may MD 5684 262 16 be be VB 5684 262 17 subject subject JJ 5684 262 18 to to IN 5684 262 19 a a DT 5684 262 20 law law NN 5684 262 21 of of IN 5684 262 22 duty duty NN 5684 262 23 . . . 5684 263 1 Disinterested disintereste VBN 5684 263 2 benevolence benevolence NN 5684 263 3 is be VBZ 5684 263 4 often often RB 5684 263 5 called call VBN 5684 263 6 ( ( -LRB- 5684 263 7 though though IN 5684 263 8 very very RB 5684 263 9 improperly improperly RB 5684 263 10 ) ) -RRB- 5684 263 11 love love NN 5684 263 12 ; ; : 5684 263 13 even even RB 5684 263 14 where where WRB 5684 263 15 the the DT 5684 263 16 happiness happiness NN 5684 263 17 of of IN 5684 263 18 the the DT 5684 263 19 other other JJ 5684 263 20 is be VBZ 5684 263 21 not not RB 5684 263 22 concerned concern VBN 5684 263 23 , , , 5684 263 24 but but CC 5684 263 25 the the DT 5684 263 26 complete complete JJ 5684 263 27 and and CC 5684 263 28 free free JJ 5684 263 29 surrender surrender NN 5684 263 30 of of IN 5684 263 31 all all DT 5684 263 32 one one NN 5684 263 33 's 's POS 5684 263 34 own own JJ 5684 263 35 ends end NNS 5684 263 36 to to IN 5684 263 37 the the DT 5684 263 38 ends end NNS 5684 263 39 of of IN 5684 263 40 another another DT 5684 263 41 ( ( -LRB- 5684 263 42 even even RB 5684 263 43 a a DT 5684 263 44 superhuman superhuman NN 5684 263 45 ) ) -RRB- 5684 263 46 being being NN 5684 263 47 , , , 5684 263 48 love love NN 5684 263 49 is be VBZ 5684 263 50 spoken speak VBN 5684 263 51 of of IN 5684 263 52 as as IN 5684 263 53 being be VBG 5684 263 54 also also RB 5684 263 55 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 263 56 duty duty NN 5684 263 57 . . . 5684 264 1 But but CC 5684 264 2 all all DT 5684 264 3 duty duty NN 5684 264 4 is be VBZ 5684 264 5 necessitation necessitation NN 5684 264 6 or or CC 5684 264 7 constraint constraint NN 5684 264 8 , , , 5684 264 9 although although IN 5684 264 10 it -PRON- PRP 5684 264 11 may may MD 5684 264 12 be be VB 5684 264 13 self self NN 5684 264 14 - - HYPH 5684 264 15 constraint constraint NN 5684 264 16 according accord VBG 5684 264 17 to to IN 5684 264 18 a a DT 5684 264 19 law law NN 5684 264 20 . . . 5684 265 1 But but CC 5684 265 2 what what WP 5684 265 3 is be VBZ 5684 265 4 done do VBN 5684 265 5 from from IN 5684 265 6 constraint constraint NN 5684 265 7 is be VBZ 5684 265 8 not not RB 5684 265 9 done do VBN 5684 265 10 from from IN 5684 265 11 love love NN 5684 265 12 . . . 5684 266 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 266 2 is be VBZ 5684 266 3 a a DT 5684 266 4 duty duty NN 5684 266 5 to to TO 5684 266 6 do do VB 5684 266 7 good good NN 5684 266 8 to to IN 5684 266 9 other other JJ 5684 266 10 men man NNS 5684 266 11 according accord VBG 5684 266 12 to to IN 5684 266 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 266 14 power power NN 5684 266 15 , , , 5684 266 16 whether whether IN 5684 266 17 we -PRON- PRP 5684 266 18 love love VBP 5684 266 19 them -PRON- PRP 5684 266 20 or or CC 5684 266 21 not not RB 5684 266 22 , , , 5684 266 23 and and CC 5684 266 24 this this DT 5684 266 25 duty duty NN 5684 266 26 loses lose VBZ 5684 266 27 nothing nothing NN 5684 266 28 of of IN 5684 266 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 266 30 weight weight NN 5684 266 31 , , , 5684 266 32 although although IN 5684 266 33 we -PRON- PRP 5684 266 34 must must MD 5684 266 35 make make VB 5684 266 36 the the DT 5684 266 37 sad sad JJ 5684 266 38 remark remark NN 5684 266 39 that that IN 5684 266 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 5684 266 41 species specie NNS 5684 266 42 , , , 5684 266 43 alas alas UH 5684 266 44 ! ! . 5684 267 1 is be VBZ 5684 267 2 not not RB 5684 267 3 such such JJ 5684 267 4 as as IN 5684 267 5 to to TO 5684 267 6 be be VB 5684 267 7 found find VBN 5684 267 8 particularly particularly RB 5684 267 9 worthy worthy JJ 5684 267 10 of of IN 5684 267 11 love love NN 5684 267 12 when when WRB 5684 267 13 we -PRON- PRP 5684 267 14 know know VBP 5684 267 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 267 16 more more RBR 5684 267 17 closely closely RB 5684 267 18 . . . 5684 268 1 Hatred hatred NN 5684 268 2 of of IN 5684 268 3 men man NNS 5684 268 4 , , , 5684 268 5 however however RB 5684 268 6 , , , 5684 268 7 is be VBZ 5684 268 8 always always RB 5684 268 9 hateful hateful JJ 5684 268 10 : : : 5684 268 11 even even RB 5684 268 12 though though IN 5684 268 13 without without IN 5684 268 14 any any DT 5684 268 15 active active JJ 5684 268 16 hostility hostility NN 5684 268 17 it -PRON- PRP 5684 268 18 consists consist VBZ 5684 268 19 only only RB 5684 268 20 in in IN 5684 268 21 complete complete JJ 5684 268 22 aversion aversion NN 5684 268 23 from from IN 5684 268 24 mankind mankind NN 5684 268 25 ( ( -LRB- 5684 268 26 the the DT 5684 268 27 solitary solitary JJ 5684 268 28 misanthropy misanthropy NN 5684 268 29 ) ) -RRB- 5684 268 30 . . . 5684 269 1 For for IN 5684 269 2 benevolence benevolence NN 5684 269 3 still still RB 5684 269 4 remains remain VBZ 5684 269 5 a a DT 5684 269 6 duty duty NN 5684 269 7 even even RB 5684 269 8 towards towards IN 5684 269 9 the the DT 5684 269 10 manhater manhater NN 5684 269 11 , , , 5684 269 12 whom whom WP 5684 269 13 one one PRP 5684 269 14 can can MD 5684 269 15 not not RB 5684 269 16 love love VB 5684 269 17 , , , 5684 269 18 but but CC 5684 269 19 to to IN 5684 269 20 whom whom WP 5684 269 21 we -PRON- PRP 5684 269 22 can can MD 5684 269 23 show show VB 5684 269 24 kindness kindness NN 5684 269 25 . . . 5684 270 1 To to TO 5684 270 2 hate hate VB 5684 270 3 vice vice NN 5684 270 4 in in IN 5684 270 5 men man NNS 5684 270 6 is be VBZ 5684 270 7 neither neither CC 5684 270 8 duty duty NN 5684 270 9 nor nor CC 5684 270 10 against against IN 5684 270 11 duty duty NN 5684 270 12 , , , 5684 270 13 but but CC 5684 270 14 a a DT 5684 270 15 mere mere JJ 5684 270 16 feeling feeling NN 5684 270 17 of of IN 5684 270 18 horror horror NN 5684 270 19 of of IN 5684 270 20 vice vice NN 5684 270 21 , , , 5684 270 22 the the DT 5684 270 23 will will NN 5684 270 24 having have VBG 5684 270 25 no no DT 5684 270 26 influence influence NN 5684 270 27 on on IN 5684 270 28 the the DT 5684 270 29 feeling feeling NN 5684 270 30 nor nor CC 5684 270 31 the the DT 5684 270 32 feeling feeling NN 5684 270 33 on on IN 5684 270 34 the the DT 5684 270 35 will will NN 5684 270 36 . . . 5684 271 1 Beneficence Beneficence NNP 5684 271 2 is be VBZ 5684 271 3 a a DT 5684 271 4 duty duty NN 5684 271 5 . . . 5684 272 1 He -PRON- PRP 5684 272 2 who who WP 5684 272 3 often often RB 5684 272 4 practises practise VBZ 5684 272 5 this this DT 5684 272 6 , , , 5684 272 7 and and CC 5684 272 8 sees see VBZ 5684 272 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 272 10 beneficent beneficent JJ 5684 272 11 purpose purpose NN 5684 272 12 succeed succeed NN 5684 272 13 , , , 5684 272 14 comes come VBZ 5684 272 15 at at IN 5684 272 16 last last RB 5684 272 17 really really RB 5684 272 18 to to TO 5684 272 19 love love VB 5684 272 20 him -PRON- PRP 5684 272 21 whom whom WP 5684 272 22 he -PRON- PRP 5684 272 23 has have VBZ 5684 272 24 benefited benefit VBN 5684 272 25 . . . 5684 273 1 When when WRB 5684 273 2 , , , 5684 273 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 273 4 , , , 5684 273 5 it -PRON- PRP 5684 273 6 is be VBZ 5684 273 7 said say VBN 5684 273 8 : : : 5684 273 9 " " `` 5684 273 10 Thou Thou NNP 5684 273 11 shalt shalt NN 5684 273 12 love love NN 5684 273 13 thy thy NN 5684 273 14 neighbour neighbour NN 5684 273 15 as as IN 5684 273 16 thyself thyself PRP 5684 273 17 , , , 5684 273 18 " " `` 5684 273 19 this this DT 5684 273 20 does do VBZ 5684 273 21 not not RB 5684 273 22 mean mean VB 5684 273 23 , , , 5684 273 24 " " '' 5684 273 25 Thou Thou NNP 5684 273 26 shalt shalt NN 5684 273 27 first first RB 5684 273 28 of of IN 5684 273 29 all all DT 5684 273 30 love love NN 5684 273 31 , , , 5684 273 32 and and CC 5684 273 33 by by IN 5684 273 34 means mean NNS 5684 273 35 of of IN 5684 273 36 this this DT 5684 273 37 love love NN 5684 273 38 ( ( -LRB- 5684 273 39 in in IN 5684 273 40 the the DT 5684 273 41 next next JJ 5684 273 42 place place NN 5684 273 43 ) ) -RRB- 5684 273 44 do do VBP 5684 273 45 him -PRON- PRP 5684 273 46 good good JJ 5684 273 47 " " '' 5684 273 48 ; ; : 5684 273 49 but but CC 5684 273 50 : : : 5684 273 51 " " `` 5684 273 52 Do do VB 5684 273 53 good good NN 5684 273 54 to to TO 5684 273 55 thy thy PRP$ 5684 273 56 neighbour neighbour NN 5684 273 57 , , , 5684 273 58 and and CC 5684 273 59 this this DT 5684 273 60 beneficence beneficence NN 5684 273 61 will will MD 5684 273 62 produce produce VB 5684 273 63 in in IN 5684 273 64 thee thee PRP 5684 273 65 the the DT 5684 273 66 love love NN 5684 273 67 of of IN 5684 273 68 men man NNS 5684 273 69 ( ( -LRB- 5684 273 70 as as IN 5684 273 71 a a DT 5684 273 72 settled settle VBN 5684 273 73 habit habit NN 5684 273 74 of of IN 5684 273 75 inclination inclination NN 5684 273 76 to to IN 5684 273 77 beneficence beneficence NN 5684 273 78 ) ) -RRB- 5684 273 79 . . . 5684 273 80 " " '' 5684 274 1 The the DT 5684 274 2 love love NN 5684 274 3 of of IN 5684 274 4 complacency complacency NN 5684 274 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 274 6 amor amor NNP 5684 274 7 complacentiae complacentiae NNS 5684 274 8 , , , 5684 274 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 274 10 would would MD 5684 274 11 therefore therefore RB 5684 274 12 alone alone RB 5684 274 13 be be VB 5684 274 14 direct direct JJ 5684 274 15 . . . 5684 275 1 This this DT 5684 275 2 is be VBZ 5684 275 3 a a DT 5684 275 4 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 275 5 immediately immediately RB 5684 275 6 connected connect VBN 5684 275 7 with with IN 5684 275 8 the the DT 5684 275 9 idea idea NN 5684 275 10 of of IN 5684 275 11 the the DT 5684 275 12 existence existence NN 5684 275 13 of of IN 5684 275 14 an an DT 5684 275 15 object object NN 5684 275 16 , , , 5684 275 17 and and CC 5684 275 18 to to TO 5684 275 19 have have VB 5684 275 20 a a DT 5684 275 21 duty duty NN 5684 275 22 to to IN 5684 275 23 this this DT 5684 275 24 , , , 5684 275 25 that that RB 5684 275 26 is is RB 5684 275 27 , , , 5684 275 28 to to TO 5684 275 29 be be VB 5684 275 30 necessitated necessitate VBN 5684 275 31 to to TO 5684 275 32 find find VB 5684 275 33 pleasure pleasure NN 5684 275 34 in in IN 5684 275 35 a a DT 5684 275 36 thing thing NN 5684 275 37 , , , 5684 275 38 is be VBZ 5684 275 39 a a DT 5684 275 40 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 275 41 . . . 5684 276 1 { { -LRB- 5684 276 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 276 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 276 4 155 155 CD 5684 276 5 } } -RRB- 5684 276 6 D. D. NNP 5684 276 7 OF of IN 5684 276 8 RESPECT RESPECT NNP 5684 276 9 Respect Respect NNP 5684 276 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 276 11 reverentia reverentia NN 5684 276 12 ) ) -RRB- 5684 276 13 is be VBZ 5684 276 14 likewise likewise RB 5684 276 15 something something NN 5684 276 16 merely merely RB 5684 276 17 subjective subjective JJ 5684 276 18 ; ; : 5684 276 19 a a DT 5684 276 20 feeling feeling NN 5684 276 21 of of IN 5684 276 22 a a DT 5684 276 23 peculiar peculiar JJ 5684 276 24 kind kind NN 5684 276 25 not not RB 5684 276 26 a a DT 5684 276 27 judgement judgement NN 5684 276 28 about about IN 5684 276 29 an an DT 5684 276 30 object object NN 5684 276 31 which which WDT 5684 276 32 it -PRON- PRP 5684 276 33 would would MD 5684 276 34 be be VB 5684 276 35 a a DT 5684 276 36 duty duty NN 5684 276 37 to to TO 5684 276 38 effect effect VB 5684 276 39 or or CC 5684 276 40 to to TO 5684 276 41 advance advance VB 5684 276 42 . . . 5684 277 1 For for IN 5684 277 2 if if IN 5684 277 3 considered consider VBN 5684 277 4 as as IN 5684 277 5 duty duty NN 5684 277 6 it -PRON- PRP 5684 277 7 could could MD 5684 277 8 only only RB 5684 277 9 be be VB 5684 277 10 conceived conceive VBN 5684 277 11 as as IN 5684 277 12 such such JJ 5684 277 13 by by IN 5684 277 14 means mean NNS 5684 277 15 of of IN 5684 277 16 the the DT 5684 277 17 respect respect NN 5684 277 18 which which WDT 5684 277 19 we -PRON- PRP 5684 277 20 have have VBP 5684 277 21 for for IN 5684 277 22 it -PRON- PRP 5684 277 23 . . . 5684 278 1 To to TO 5684 278 2 have have VB 5684 278 3 a a DT 5684 278 4 duty duty NN 5684 278 5 to to IN 5684 278 6 this this DT 5684 278 7 , , , 5684 278 8 therefore therefore RB 5684 278 9 , , , 5684 278 10 would would MD 5684 278 11 be be VB 5684 278 12 as as RB 5684 278 13 much much JJ 5684 278 14 as as IN 5684 278 15 to to TO 5684 278 16 say say VB 5684 278 17 to to TO 5684 278 18 be be VB 5684 278 19 bound bind VBN 5684 278 20 in in IN 5684 278 21 duty duty NN 5684 278 22 to to TO 5684 278 23 have have VB 5684 278 24 a a DT 5684 278 25 duty duty NN 5684 278 26 . . . 5684 279 1 When when WRB 5684 279 2 , , , 5684 279 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 279 4 , , , 5684 279 5 it -PRON- PRP 5684 279 6 is be VBZ 5684 279 7 said say VBN 5684 279 8 : : : 5684 279 9 " " `` 5684 279 10 Man man NN 5684 279 11 has have VBZ 5684 279 12 a a DT 5684 279 13 duty duty NN 5684 279 14 of of IN 5684 279 15 self self NN 5684 279 16 - - HYPH 5684 279 17 esteem esteem NN 5684 279 18 , , , 5684 279 19 " " '' 5684 279 20 this this DT 5684 279 21 is be VBZ 5684 279 22 improperly improperly RB 5684 279 23 stated state VBN 5684 279 24 , , , 5684 279 25 and and CC 5684 279 26 we -PRON- PRP 5684 279 27 ought ought MD 5684 279 28 rather rather RB 5684 279 29 to to TO 5684 279 30 say say VB 5684 279 31 : : : 5684 279 32 " " `` 5684 279 33 The the DT 5684 279 34 law law NN 5684 279 35 within within IN 5684 279 36 him -PRON- PRP 5684 279 37 inevitably inevitably RB 5684 279 38 forces force VBZ 5684 279 39 from from IN 5684 279 40 him -PRON- PRP 5684 279 41 respect respect NN 5684 279 42 for for IN 5684 279 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 279 44 own own JJ 5684 279 45 being being NN 5684 279 46 , , , 5684 279 47 and and CC 5684 279 48 this this DT 5684 279 49 feeling feeling NN 5684 279 50 ( ( -LRB- 5684 279 51 which which WDT 5684 279 52 is be VBZ 5684 279 53 of of IN 5684 279 54 a a DT 5684 279 55 peculiar peculiar JJ 5684 279 56 kind kind NN 5684 279 57 ) ) -RRB- 5684 279 58 is be VBZ 5684 279 59 a a DT 5684 279 60 basis basis NN 5684 279 61 of of IN 5684 279 62 certain certain JJ 5684 279 63 duties duty NNS 5684 279 64 , , , 5684 279 65 that that RB 5684 279 66 is is RB 5684 279 67 , , , 5684 279 68 of of IN 5684 279 69 certain certain JJ 5684 279 70 actions action NNS 5684 279 71 which which WDT 5684 279 72 may may MD 5684 279 73 be be VB 5684 279 74 consistent consistent JJ 5684 279 75 with with IN 5684 279 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 279 77 duty duty NN 5684 279 78 to to IN 5684 279 79 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 279 80 . . . 5684 279 81 " " '' 5684 280 1 But but CC 5684 280 2 we -PRON- PRP 5684 280 3 can can MD 5684 280 4 not not RB 5684 280 5 say say VB 5684 280 6 that that IN 5684 280 7 he -PRON- PRP 5684 280 8 has have VBZ 5684 280 9 a a DT 5684 280 10 duty duty NN 5684 280 11 of of IN 5684 280 12 respect respect NN 5684 280 13 for for IN 5684 280 14 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 280 15 ; ; : 5684 280 16 for for IN 5684 280 17 he -PRON- PRP 5684 280 18 must must MD 5684 280 19 have have VB 5684 280 20 respect respect NN 5684 280 21 for for IN 5684 280 22 the the DT 5684 280 23 law law NN 5684 280 24 within within IN 5684 280 25 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 280 26 , , , 5684 280 27 in in IN 5684 280 28 order order NN 5684 280 29 to to TO 5684 280 30 be be VB 5684 280 31 able able JJ 5684 280 32 to to TO 5684 280 33 conceive conceive VB 5684 280 34 duty duty NN 5684 280 35 at at RB 5684 280 36 all all RB 5684 280 37 . . . 5684 281 1 XIII XIII NNP 5684 281 2 . . . 5684 282 1 General General NNP 5684 282 2 Principles Principles NNPS 5684 282 3 of of IN 5684 282 4 the the DT 5684 282 5 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 5684 282 6 of of IN 5684 282 7 Morals Morals NNPS 5684 282 8 in in IN 5684 282 9 the the DT 5684 282 10 { { -LRB- 5684 282 11 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 282 12 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 282 13 160 160 CD 5684 282 14 } } -RRB- 5684 282 15 treatment treatment NN 5684 282 16 of of IN 5684 282 17 Pure Pure NNP 5684 282 18 Ethics Ethics NNP 5684 282 19 First first RB 5684 282 20 . . . 5684 283 1 A a DT 5684 283 2 duty duty NN 5684 283 3 can can MD 5684 283 4 have have VB 5684 283 5 only only RB 5684 283 6 a a DT 5684 283 7 single single JJ 5684 283 8 ground ground NN 5684 283 9 of of IN 5684 283 10 obligation obligation NN 5684 283 11 ; ; : 5684 283 12 and and CC 5684 283 13 if if IN 5684 283 14 two two CD 5684 283 15 or or CC 5684 283 16 more more JJR 5684 283 17 proof proof NN 5684 283 18 of of IN 5684 283 19 it -PRON- PRP 5684 283 20 are be VBP 5684 283 21 adduced adduced JJ 5684 283 22 , , , 5684 283 23 this this DT 5684 283 24 is be VBZ 5684 283 25 a a DT 5684 283 26 certain certain JJ 5684 283 27 mark mark NN 5684 283 28 that that WDT 5684 283 29 either either CC 5684 283 30 no no DT 5684 283 31 valid valid JJ 5684 283 32 proof proof NN 5684 283 33 has have VBZ 5684 283 34 yet yet RB 5684 283 35 been be VBN 5684 283 36 given give VBN 5684 283 37 , , , 5684 283 38 or or CC 5684 283 39 that that IN 5684 283 40 there there EX 5684 283 41 are be VBP 5684 283 42 several several JJ 5684 283 43 distinct distinct JJ 5684 283 44 duties duty NNS 5684 283 45 which which WDT 5684 283 46 have have VBP 5684 283 47 been be VBN 5684 283 48 regarded regard VBN 5684 283 49 as as IN 5684 283 50 one one CD 5684 283 51 . . . 5684 284 1 For for IN 5684 284 2 all all DT 5684 284 3 moral moral JJ 5684 284 4 proofs proof NNS 5684 284 5 , , , 5684 284 6 being be VBG 5684 284 7 philosophical philosophical JJ 5684 284 8 , , , 5684 284 9 can can MD 5684 284 10 only only RB 5684 284 11 be be VB 5684 284 12 drawn draw VBN 5684 284 13 by by IN 5684 284 14 means mean NNS 5684 284 15 of of IN 5684 284 16 rational rational JJ 5684 284 17 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 284 18 from from IN 5684 284 19 concepts concept NNS 5684 284 20 , , , 5684 284 21 not not RB 5684 284 22 like like IN 5684 284 23 mathematics mathematic NNS 5684 284 24 , , , 5684 284 25 through through IN 5684 284 26 the the DT 5684 284 27 construction construction NN 5684 284 28 of of IN 5684 284 29 concepts concept NNS 5684 284 30 . . . 5684 285 1 The the DT 5684 285 2 latter latter JJ 5684 285 3 science science NN 5684 285 4 admits admit VBZ 5684 285 5 a a DT 5684 285 6 variety variety NN 5684 285 7 of of IN 5684 285 8 proofs proof NNS 5684 285 9 of of IN 5684 285 10 one one CD 5684 285 11 and and CC 5684 285 12 the the DT 5684 285 13 same same JJ 5684 285 14 theorem theorem NN 5684 285 15 ; ; : 5684 285 16 because because IN 5684 285 17 in in IN 5684 285 18 intuition intuition NN 5684 285 19 a a DT 5684 285 20 priori priori NN 5684 285 21 there there EX 5684 285 22 may may MD 5684 285 23 be be VB 5684 285 24 several several JJ 5684 285 25 properties property NNS 5684 285 26 of of IN 5684 285 27 an an DT 5684 285 28 object object NN 5684 285 29 , , , 5684 285 30 all all DT 5684 285 31 of of IN 5684 285 32 which which WDT 5684 285 33 lead lead VBP 5684 285 34 back back RB 5684 285 35 to to IN 5684 285 36 the the DT 5684 285 37 very very RB 5684 285 38 same same JJ 5684 285 39 principle principle NN 5684 285 40 . . . 5684 286 1 If if IN 5684 286 2 , , , 5684 286 3 for for IN 5684 286 4 instance instance NN 5684 286 5 , , , 5684 286 6 to to TO 5684 286 7 prove prove VB 5684 286 8 the the DT 5684 286 9 duty duty NN 5684 286 10 of of IN 5684 286 11 veracity veracity NN 5684 286 12 , , , 5684 286 13 an an DT 5684 286 14 argument argument NN 5684 286 15 is be VBZ 5684 286 16 drawn draw VBN 5684 286 17 first first RB 5684 286 18 from from IN 5684 286 19 the the DT 5684 286 20 harm harm NN 5684 286 21 that that WDT 5684 286 22 a a DT 5684 286 23 lie lie NN 5684 286 24 causes cause VBZ 5684 286 25 to to IN 5684 286 26 other other JJ 5684 286 27 men man NNS 5684 286 28 ; ; : 5684 286 29 another another DT 5684 286 30 from from IN 5684 286 31 the the DT 5684 286 32 worthlessness worthlessness NN 5684 286 33 of of IN 5684 286 34 a a DT 5684 286 35 liar liar NN 5684 286 36 and and CC 5684 286 37 the the DT 5684 286 38 violation violation NN 5684 286 39 of of IN 5684 286 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 286 41 own own JJ 5684 286 42 self self NN 5684 286 43 - - HYPH 5684 286 44 respect respect NN 5684 286 45 , , , 5684 286 46 what what WP 5684 286 47 is be VBZ 5684 286 48 proved prove VBN 5684 286 49 in in IN 5684 286 50 the the DT 5684 286 51 former former JJ 5684 286 52 argument argument NN 5684 286 53 is be VBZ 5684 286 54 a a DT 5684 286 55 duty duty NN 5684 286 56 of of IN 5684 286 57 benevolence benevolence NN 5684 286 58 , , , 5684 286 59 not not RB 5684 286 60 of of IN 5684 286 61 veracity veracity NN 5684 286 62 , , , 5684 286 63 that that DT 5684 286 64 is be VBZ 5684 286 65 to to TO 5684 286 66 say say VB 5684 286 67 , , , 5684 286 68 not not RB 5684 286 69 the the DT 5684 286 70 duty duty NN 5684 286 71 which which WDT 5684 286 72 required require VBD 5684 286 73 to to TO 5684 286 74 be be VB 5684 286 75 proved prove VBN 5684 286 76 , , , 5684 286 77 but but CC 5684 286 78 a a DT 5684 286 79 different different JJ 5684 286 80 one one CD 5684 286 81 . . . 5684 287 1 Now now RB 5684 287 2 , , , 5684 287 3 if if IN 5684 287 4 , , , 5684 287 5 in in IN 5684 287 6 giving give VBG 5684 287 7 a a DT 5684 287 8 variety variety NN 5684 287 9 of of IN 5684 287 10 proof proof NN 5684 287 11 for for IN 5684 287 12 one one CD 5684 287 13 and and CC 5684 287 14 the the DT 5684 287 15 same same JJ 5684 287 16 theorem theorem NN 5684 287 17 , , , 5684 287 18 we -PRON- PRP 5684 287 19 flatter flatter VBP 5684 287 20 ourselves -PRON- PRP 5684 287 21 that that IN 5684 287 22 the the DT 5684 287 23 multitude multitude NN 5684 287 24 of of IN 5684 287 25 reasons reason NNS 5684 287 26 will will MD 5684 287 27 compensate compensate VB 5684 287 28 the the DT 5684 287 29 lack lack NN 5684 287 30 of of IN 5684 287 31 weight weight NN 5684 287 32 in in IN 5684 287 33 each each DT 5684 287 34 taken take VBN 5684 287 35 separately separately RB 5684 287 36 , , , 5684 287 37 this this DT 5684 287 38 is be VBZ 5684 287 39 a a DT 5684 287 40 very very RB 5684 287 41 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 5684 287 42 resource resource NN 5684 287 43 , , , 5684 287 44 since since IN 5684 287 45 it -PRON- PRP 5684 287 46 betrays betray VBZ 5684 287 47 trickery trickery NN 5684 287 48 and and CC 5684 287 49 dishonesty dishonesty NN 5684 287 50 ; ; : 5684 287 51 for for IN 5684 287 52 several several JJ 5684 287 53 insufficient insufficient JJ 5684 287 54 proofs proof NNS 5684 287 55 placed place VBN 5684 287 56 beside beside IN 5684 287 57 one one CD 5684 287 58 another another DT 5684 287 59 do do VBP 5684 287 60 not not RB 5684 287 61 produce produce VB 5684 287 62 certainty certainty NN 5684 287 63 , , , 5684 287 64 nor nor CC 5684 287 65 even even RB 5684 287 66 probability probability NN 5684 287 67 . . . 5684 288 1 They -PRON- PRP 5684 288 2 should should MD 5684 288 3 advance advance VB 5684 288 4 as as IN 5684 288 5 reason reason NN 5684 288 6 and and CC 5684 288 7 consequence consequence NN 5684 288 8 in in IN 5684 288 9 a a DT 5684 288 10 series series NN 5684 288 11 , , , 5684 288 12 up up IN 5684 288 13 to to IN 5684 288 14 the the DT 5684 288 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 5684 288 16 reason reason NN 5684 288 17 , , , 5684 288 18 and and CC 5684 288 19 it -PRON- PRP 5684 288 20 is be VBZ 5684 288 21 only only RB 5684 288 22 in in IN 5684 288 23 this this DT 5684 288 24 way way NN 5684 288 25 that that WDT 5684 288 26 they -PRON- PRP 5684 288 27 can can MD 5684 288 28 have have VB 5684 288 29 the the DT 5684 288 30 force force NN 5684 288 31 of of IN 5684 288 32 proof proof NN 5684 288 33 . . . 5684 289 1 Yet yet RB 5684 289 2 the the DT 5684 289 3 former former JJ 5684 289 4 is be VBZ 5684 289 5 the the DT 5684 289 6 usual usual JJ 5684 289 7 device device NN 5684 289 8 of of IN 5684 289 9 the the DT 5684 289 10 rhetorician rhetorician NN 5684 289 11 . . . 5684 290 1 Secondly secondly RB 5684 290 2 . . . 5684 291 1 The the DT 5684 291 2 difference difference NN 5684 291 3 between between IN 5684 291 4 virtue virtue NN 5684 291 5 and and CC 5684 291 6 vice vice NN 5684 291 7 can can MD 5684 291 8 not not RB 5684 291 9 be be VB 5684 291 10 sought seek VBN 5684 291 11 in in IN 5684 291 12 the the DT 5684 291 13 degree degree NN 5684 291 14 in in IN 5684 291 15 which which WDT 5684 291 16 certain certain JJ 5684 291 17 maxims maxim NNS 5684 291 18 are be VBP 5684 291 19 followed follow VBN 5684 291 20 , , , 5684 291 21 but but CC 5684 291 22 only only RB 5684 291 23 in in IN 5684 291 24 the the DT 5684 291 25 specific specific JJ 5684 291 26 quality quality NN 5684 291 27 of of IN 5684 291 28 the the DT 5684 291 29 maxims maxim NNS 5684 291 30 ( ( -LRB- 5684 291 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 291 32 relation relation NN 5684 291 33 to to IN 5684 291 34 the the DT 5684 291 35 law law NN 5684 291 36 ) ) -RRB- 5684 291 37 . . . 5684 292 1 In in IN 5684 292 2 other other JJ 5684 292 3 words word NNS 5684 292 4 , , , 5684 292 5 the the DT 5684 292 6 vaunted vaunted JJ 5684 292 7 principle principle NN 5684 292 8 of of IN 5684 292 9 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 5684 292 10 , , , 5684 292 11 that that DT 5684 292 12 virtue virtue NN 5684 292 13 is be VBZ 5684 292 14 the the DT 5684 292 15 mean mean NN 5684 292 16 between between IN 5684 292 17 two two CD 5684 292 18 vices vice NNS 5684 292 19 , , , 5684 292 20 is be VBZ 5684 292 21 false false JJ 5684 292 22 . . . 5684 293 1 * * NFP 5684 293 2 For for IN 5684 293 3 instance instance NN 5684 293 4 , , , 5684 293 5 suppose suppose VB 5684 293 6 that that IN 5684 293 7 good good JJ 5684 293 8 management management NN 5684 293 9 is be VBZ 5684 293 10 given give VBN 5684 293 11 as as IN 5684 293 12 the the DT 5684 293 13 mean mean NN 5684 293 14 between between IN 5684 293 15 two two CD 5684 293 16 vices vice NNS 5684 293 17 , , , 5684 293 18 prodigality prodigality NN 5684 293 19 and and CC 5684 293 20 avarice avarice NN 5684 293 21 ; ; : 5684 293 22 then then RB 5684 293 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 293 24 origin origin NN 5684 293 25 as as IN 5684 293 26 a a DT 5684 293 27 virtue virtue NN 5684 293 28 can can MD 5684 293 29 neither neither CC 5684 293 30 be be VB 5684 293 31 defined define VBN 5684 293 32 as as IN 5684 293 33 the the DT 5684 293 34 gradual gradual JJ 5684 293 35 diminution diminution NN 5684 293 36 of of IN 5684 293 37 the the DT 5684 293 38 former former JJ 5684 293 39 vice vice NN 5684 293 40 ( ( -LRB- 5684 293 41 by by IN 5684 293 42 saving save VBG 5684 293 43 ) ) -RRB- 5684 293 44 , , , 5684 293 45 nor nor CC 5684 293 46 as as IN 5684 293 47 the the DT 5684 293 48 increase increase NN 5684 293 49 of of IN 5684 293 50 the the DT 5684 293 51 expenses expense NNS 5684 293 52 of of IN 5684 293 53 the the DT 5684 293 54 miserly miserly JJ 5684 293 55 . . . 5684 294 1 These these DT 5684 294 2 vices vice NNS 5684 294 3 , , , 5684 294 4 in in IN 5684 294 5 fact fact NN 5684 294 6 , , , 5684 294 7 can can MD 5684 294 8 not not RB 5684 294 9 be be VB 5684 294 10 viewed view VBN 5684 294 11 as as IN 5684 294 12 if if IN 5684 294 13 they -PRON- PRP 5684 294 14 , , , 5684 294 15 proceeding proceed VBG 5684 294 16 as as IN 5684 294 17 it -PRON- PRP 5684 294 18 were be VBD 5684 294 19 in in IN 5684 294 20 opposite opposite JJ 5684 294 21 directions direction NNS 5684 294 22 , , , 5684 294 23 met meet VBD 5684 294 24 together together RB 5684 294 25 in in IN 5684 294 26 good good JJ 5684 294 27 management management NN 5684 294 28 ; ; : 5684 294 29 but but CC 5684 294 30 each each DT 5684 294 31 of of IN 5684 294 32 them -PRON- PRP 5684 294 33 has have VBZ 5684 294 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 294 35 own own JJ 5684 294 36 maxim maxim NN 5684 294 37 , , , 5684 294 38 which which WDT 5684 294 39 necessarily necessarily RB 5684 294 40 contradicts contradict VBZ 5684 294 41 that that DT 5684 294 42 of of IN 5684 294 43 the the DT 5684 294 44 other other JJ 5684 294 45 . . . 5684 295 1 { { -LRB- 5684 295 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 295 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 295 4 165 165 CD 5684 295 5 } } -RRB- 5684 295 6 * * NFP 5684 295 7 The the DT 5684 295 8 common common JJ 5684 295 9 classical classical JJ 5684 295 10 formulae formula NNS 5684 295 11 of of IN 5684 295 12 ethics- ethics- NNP 5684 295 13 medio medio NNP 5684 295 14 tutissimus tutissimus NNP 5684 295 15 ibis ibis NNP 5684 295 16 ; ; : 5684 295 17 omne omne NNP 5684 295 18 mimium mimium NNP 5684 295 19 vertitur vertitur NNP 5684 295 20 in in IN 5684 295 21 vitium vitium NN 5684 295 22 ; ; : 5684 295 23 est est NNP 5684 295 24 modus modus NNP 5684 295 25 in in IN 5684 295 26 rebus rebus NNP 5684 295 27 , , , 5684 295 28 etc etc FW 5684 295 29 . . FW 5684 295 30 , , , 5684 295 31 medium medium NNP 5684 295 32 tenuere tenuere NNP 5684 295 33 beati beati NNS 5684 295 34 ; ; : 5684 295 35 virtus virtus NNP 5684 295 36 est est NNP 5684 295 37 medium medium NNP 5684 295 38 vitiorum vitiorum NNP 5684 295 39 et et NNP 5684 295 40 utrinque utrinque NNP 5684 295 41 reductum- reductum- NNP 5684 295 42 [ [ -LRB- 5684 295 43 " " `` 5684 295 44 You -PRON- PRP 5684 295 45 will will MD 5684 295 46 go go VB 5684 295 47 most most RBS 5684 295 48 safely safely RB 5684 295 49 in in IN 5684 295 50 the the DT 5684 295 51 middle middle NN 5684 295 52 " " '' 5684 295 53 ( ( -LRB- 5684 295 54 Virgil Virgil NNP 5684 295 55 ) ) -RRB- 5684 295 56 ; ; : 5684 295 57 " " `` 5684 295 58 Every every DT 5684 295 59 excess excess JJ 5684 295 60 develops develop VBZ 5684 295 61 into into IN 5684 295 62 a a DT 5684 295 63 vice vice NN 5684 295 64 " " '' 5684 295 65 ; ; : 5684 295 66 " " `` 5684 295 67 There there EX 5684 295 68 is be VBZ 5684 295 69 a a DT 5684 295 70 mean mean NN 5684 295 71 in in IN 5684 295 72 all all DT 5684 295 73 things thing NNS 5684 295 74 , , , 5684 295 75 etc etc FW 5684 295 76 . . . 5684 295 77 " " '' 5684 296 1 ( ( -LRB- 5684 296 2 Horace horace NN 5684 296 3 ) ) -RRB- 5684 296 4 ; ; : 5684 296 5 " " `` 5684 296 6 Happy happy JJ 5684 296 7 they -PRON- PRP 5684 296 8 who who WP 5684 296 9 steadily steadily RB 5684 296 10 pursue pursue VBP 5684 296 11 a a DT 5684 296 12 middle middle JJ 5684 296 13 course course NN 5684 296 14 " " '' 5684 296 15 ; ; : 5684 296 16 " " `` 5684 296 17 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 296 18 is be VBZ 5684 296 19 the the DT 5684 296 20 mean mean NN 5684 296 21 between between IN 5684 296 22 two two CD 5684 296 23 vices vice NNS 5684 296 24 and and CC 5684 296 25 equally equally RB 5684 296 26 removed remove VBN 5684 296 27 from from IN 5684 296 28 either either DT 5684 296 29 " " `` 5684 296 30 ( ( -LRB- 5684 296 31 Horace Horace NNP 5684 296 32 ) ) -RRB- 5684 296 33 . . . 5684 297 1 ] ] -RRB- 5684 297 2 - - : 5684 297 3 contain contain VB 5684 297 4 a a DT 5684 297 5 poor poor JJ 5684 297 6 sort sort NN 5684 297 7 of of IN 5684 297 8 wisdom wisdom NN 5684 297 9 , , , 5684 297 10 which which WDT 5684 297 11 has have VBZ 5684 297 12 no no DT 5684 297 13 definite definite JJ 5684 297 14 principles principle NNS 5684 297 15 ; ; : 5684 297 16 for for IN 5684 297 17 this this DT 5684 297 18 mean mean NN 5684 297 19 between between IN 5684 297 20 two two CD 5684 297 21 extremes extreme NNS 5684 297 22 , , , 5684 297 23 who who WP 5684 297 24 will will MD 5684 297 25 assign assign VB 5684 297 26 it -PRON- PRP 5684 297 27 for for IN 5684 297 28 me -PRON- PRP 5684 297 29 ? ? . 5684 298 1 Avarice Avarice NNP 5684 298 2 ( ( -LRB- 5684 298 3 as as IN 5684 298 4 a a DT 5684 298 5 vice vice NN 5684 298 6 ) ) -RRB- 5684 298 7 is be VBZ 5684 298 8 not not RB 5684 298 9 distinguished distinguish VBN 5684 298 10 from from IN 5684 298 11 frugality frugality NN 5684 298 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 298 13 as as IN 5684 298 14 a a DT 5684 298 15 virtue virtue NN 5684 298 16 ) ) -RRB- 5684 298 17 by by IN 5684 298 18 merely merely RB 5684 298 19 being be VBG 5684 298 20 the the DT 5684 298 21 latter latter JJ 5684 298 22 pushed push VBN 5684 298 23 too too RB 5684 298 24 far far RB 5684 298 25 ; ; : 5684 298 26 but but CC 5684 298 27 has have VBZ 5684 298 28 a a DT 5684 298 29 quite quite RB 5684 298 30 different different JJ 5684 298 31 principle principle NN 5684 298 32 ( ( -LRB- 5684 298 33 maxim maxim NN 5684 298 34 ) ) -RRB- 5684 298 35 , , , 5684 298 36 namely namely RB 5684 298 37 placing place VBG 5684 298 38 the the DT 5684 298 39 end end NN 5684 298 40 of of IN 5684 298 41 economy economy NN 5684 298 42 not not RB 5684 298 43 in in IN 5684 298 44 the the DT 5684 298 45 enjoyment enjoyment NN 5684 298 46 of of IN 5684 298 47 one one PRP 5684 298 48 's 's POS 5684 298 49 means mean NNS 5684 298 50 , , , 5684 298 51 but but CC 5684 298 52 in in IN 5684 298 53 the the DT 5684 298 54 mere mere JJ 5684 298 55 possession possession NN 5684 298 56 of of IN 5684 298 57 them -PRON- PRP 5684 298 58 , , , 5684 298 59 renouncing renounce VBG 5684 298 60 enjoyment enjoyment NN 5684 298 61 ; ; : 5684 298 62 just just RB 5684 298 63 as as IN 5684 298 64 the the DT 5684 298 65 vice vice NN 5684 298 66 of of IN 5684 298 67 prodigality prodigality NN 5684 298 68 is be VBZ 5684 298 69 not not RB 5684 298 70 to to TO 5684 298 71 be be VB 5684 298 72 sought seek VBN 5684 298 73 in in IN 5684 298 74 the the DT 5684 298 75 excessive excessive JJ 5684 298 76 enjoyment enjoyment NN 5684 298 77 of of IN 5684 298 78 one one PRP 5684 298 79 's 's POS 5684 298 80 means mean NNS 5684 298 81 , , , 5684 298 82 but but CC 5684 298 83 in in IN 5684 298 84 the the DT 5684 298 85 bad bad JJ 5684 298 86 maxim maxim NN 5684 298 87 which which WDT 5684 298 88 makes make VBZ 5684 298 89 the the DT 5684 298 90 use use NN 5684 298 91 of of IN 5684 298 92 them -PRON- PRP 5684 298 93 , , , 5684 298 94 without without IN 5684 298 95 regard regard NN 5684 298 96 to to IN 5684 298 97 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 298 98 maintenance maintenance NN 5684 298 99 , , , 5684 298 100 the the DT 5684 298 101 sole sole JJ 5684 298 102 end end NN 5684 298 103 . . . 5684 299 1 For for IN 5684 299 2 the the DT 5684 299 3 same same JJ 5684 299 4 reason reason NN 5684 299 5 , , , 5684 299 6 no no DT 5684 299 7 vice vice NN 5684 299 8 can can MD 5684 299 9 be be VB 5684 299 10 defined define VBN 5684 299 11 as as IN 5684 299 12 an an DT 5684 299 13 excess excess NN 5684 299 14 in in IN 5684 299 15 the the DT 5684 299 16 practice practice NN 5684 299 17 of of IN 5684 299 18 certain certain JJ 5684 299 19 actions action NNS 5684 299 20 beyond beyond IN 5684 299 21 what what WP 5684 299 22 is be VBZ 5684 299 23 proper proper JJ 5684 299 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 299 25 e.g. e.g. RB 5684 299 26 , , , 5684 299 27 Prodigalitas Prodigalitas NNP 5684 299 28 est est VBD 5684 299 29 excessus excessus VBP 5684 299 30 in in IN 5684 299 31 consumendis consumendis NNP 5684 299 32 opibus opibus NNP 5684 299 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 299 34 ; ; : 5684 299 35 or or CC 5684 299 36 , , , 5684 299 37 as as IN 5684 299 38 a a DT 5684 299 39 less less JJR 5684 299 40 exercise exercise NN 5684 299 41 of of IN 5684 299 42 them -PRON- PRP 5684 299 43 than than IN 5684 299 44 is be VBZ 5684 299 45 fitting fitting JJ 5684 299 46 ( ( -LRB- 5684 299 47 Avaritia Avaritia NNP 5684 299 48 est est NNP 5684 299 49 defectus defectus NNP 5684 299 50 , , , 5684 299 51 etc etc FW 5684 299 52 . . . 5684 299 53 ) ) -RRB- 5684 299 54 . . . 5684 300 1 For for IN 5684 300 2 since since IN 5684 300 3 in in IN 5684 300 4 this this DT 5684 300 5 way way NN 5684 300 6 the the DT 5684 300 7 degree degree NN 5684 300 8 is be VBZ 5684 300 9 left leave VBN 5684 300 10 quite quite RB 5684 300 11 undefined undefined JJ 5684 300 12 , , , 5684 300 13 and and CC 5684 300 14 the the DT 5684 300 15 question question NN 5684 300 16 whether whether IN 5684 300 17 conduct conduct NN 5684 300 18 accords accord NNS 5684 300 19 with with IN 5684 300 20 duty duty NN 5684 300 21 or or CC 5684 300 22 not not RB 5684 300 23 , , , 5684 300 24 turns turn VBZ 5684 300 25 wholly wholly RB 5684 300 26 on on IN 5684 300 27 this this DT 5684 300 28 , , , 5684 300 29 such such PDT 5684 300 30 an an DT 5684 300 31 account account NN 5684 300 32 is be VBZ 5684 300 33 of of IN 5684 300 34 no no DT 5684 300 35 use use NN 5684 300 36 as as IN 5684 300 37 a a DT 5684 300 38 definition definition NN 5684 300 39 . . . 5684 301 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 5684 301 2 . . . 5684 302 1 Ethical ethical JJ 5684 302 2 virtue virtue NN 5684 302 3 must must MD 5684 302 4 not not RB 5684 302 5 be be VB 5684 302 6 estimated estimate VBN 5684 302 7 by by IN 5684 302 8 the the DT 5684 302 9 power power NN 5684 302 10 we -PRON- PRP 5684 302 11 attribute attribute VBP 5684 302 12 to to IN 5684 302 13 man man NN 5684 302 14 of of IN 5684 302 15 fulfilling fulfil VBG 5684 302 16 the the DT 5684 302 17 law law NN 5684 302 18 ; ; : 5684 302 19 but but CC 5684 302 20 , , , 5684 302 21 conversely conversely RB 5684 302 22 , , , 5684 302 23 the the DT 5684 302 24 moral moral JJ 5684 302 25 power power NN 5684 302 26 must must MD 5684 302 27 be be VB 5684 302 28 estimated estimate VBN 5684 302 29 by by IN 5684 302 30 the the DT 5684 302 31 law law NN 5684 302 32 , , , 5684 302 33 which which WDT 5684 302 34 commands command VBZ 5684 302 35 categorically categorically RB 5684 302 36 ; ; : 5684 302 37 not not RB 5684 302 38 , , , 5684 302 39 therefore therefore RB 5684 302 40 , , , 5684 302 41 by by IN 5684 302 42 the the DT 5684 302 43 empirical empirical JJ 5684 302 44 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 302 45 that that WDT 5684 302 46 we -PRON- PRP 5684 302 47 have have VBP 5684 302 48 of of IN 5684 302 49 men man NNS 5684 302 50 as as IN 5684 302 51 they -PRON- PRP 5684 302 52 are be VBP 5684 302 53 , , , 5684 302 54 but but CC 5684 302 55 by by IN 5684 302 56 the the DT 5684 302 57 rational rational JJ 5684 302 58 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 302 59 how how WRB 5684 302 60 , , , 5684 302 61 according accord VBG 5684 302 62 to to IN 5684 302 63 the the DT 5684 302 64 ideas idea NNS 5684 302 65 of of IN 5684 302 66 humanity humanity NN 5684 302 67 , , , 5684 302 68 they -PRON- PRP 5684 302 69 ought ought MD 5684 302 70 to to TO 5684 302 71 be be VB 5684 302 72 . . . 5684 303 1 These these DT 5684 303 2 three three CD 5684 303 3 maxims maxim NNS 5684 303 4 of of IN 5684 303 5 the the DT 5684 303 6 scientific scientific JJ 5684 303 7 treatment treatment NN 5684 303 8 of of IN 5684 303 9 ethics ethic NNS 5684 303 10 are be VBP 5684 303 11 opposed oppose VBN 5684 303 12 to to IN 5684 303 13 the the DT 5684 303 14 older old JJR 5684 303 15 apophthegms apophthegms NN 5684 303 16 : : : 5684 303 17 { { -LRB- 5684 303 18 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 303 19 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 303 20 170 170 CD 5684 303 21 } } -RRB- 5684 303 22 1 1 CD 5684 303 23 . . . 5684 304 1 There there EX 5684 304 2 is be VBZ 5684 304 3 only only RB 5684 304 4 one one CD 5684 304 5 virtue virtue NN 5684 304 6 and and CC 5684 304 7 only only RB 5684 304 8 one one CD 5684 304 9 vice vice NN 5684 304 10 . . . 5684 305 1 2 2 LS 5684 305 2 . . . 5684 306 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 306 2 is be VBZ 5684 306 3 the the DT 5684 306 4 observance observance NN 5684 306 5 of of IN 5684 306 6 the the DT 5684 306 7 mean mean JJ 5684 306 8 path path NN 5684 306 9 between between IN 5684 306 10 two two CD 5684 306 11 opposite opposite JJ 5684 306 12 vices vice NNS 5684 306 13 . . . 5684 307 1 3 3 LS 5684 307 2 . . . 5684 308 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 308 2 ( ( -LRB- 5684 308 3 like like IN 5684 308 4 prudence prudence NN 5684 308 5 ) ) -RRB- 5684 308 6 must must MD 5684 308 7 be be VB 5684 308 8 learned learn VBN 5684 308 9 from from IN 5684 308 10 experience experience NN 5684 308 11 . . . 5684 309 1 XIV XIV NNP 5684 309 2 . . . 5684 310 1 Of of IN 5684 310 2 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 310 3 in in IN 5684 310 4 General General NNP 5684 310 5 { { -LRB- 5684 310 6 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 310 7 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 310 8 175 175 CD 5684 310 9 } } -RRB- 5684 310 10 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 310 11 signifies signify VBZ 5684 310 12 a a DT 5684 310 13 moral moral JJ 5684 310 14 strength strength NN 5684 310 15 of of IN 5684 310 16 will will NN 5684 310 17 . . . 5684 311 1 But but CC 5684 311 2 this this DT 5684 311 3 does do VBZ 5684 311 4 not not RB 5684 311 5 exhaust exhaust VB 5684 311 6 the the DT 5684 311 7 notion notion NN 5684 311 8 ; ; : 5684 311 9 for for IN 5684 311 10 such such JJ 5684 311 11 strength strength NN 5684 311 12 might may MD 5684 311 13 also also RB 5684 311 14 belong belong VB 5684 311 15 to to IN 5684 311 16 a a DT 5684 311 17 holy holy JJ 5684 311 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 311 19 superhuman superhuman NN 5684 311 20 ) ) -RRB- 5684 311 21 being be VBG 5684 311 22 , , , 5684 311 23 in in IN 5684 311 24 whom whom WP 5684 311 25 no no DT 5684 311 26 opposing oppose VBG 5684 311 27 impulse impulse NN 5684 311 28 counteracts counteract NNS 5684 311 29 the the DT 5684 311 30 law law NN 5684 311 31 of of IN 5684 311 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 311 33 rational rational JJ 5684 311 34 will will NN 5684 311 35 ; ; : 5684 311 36 who who WP 5684 311 37 therefore therefore RB 5684 311 38 willingly willingly RB 5684 311 39 does do VBZ 5684 311 40 everything everything NN 5684 311 41 in in IN 5684 311 42 accordance accordance NN 5684 311 43 with with IN 5684 311 44 the the DT 5684 311 45 law law NN 5684 311 46 . . . 5684 312 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 312 2 then then RB 5684 312 3 is be VBZ 5684 312 4 the the DT 5684 312 5 moral moral JJ 5684 312 6 strength strength NN 5684 312 7 of of IN 5684 312 8 a a DT 5684 312 9 man man NN 5684 312 10 's 's POS 5684 312 11 will will NN 5684 312 12 in in IN 5684 312 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 312 14 obedience obedience NN 5684 312 15 to to IN 5684 312 16 duty duty NN 5684 312 17 ; ; : 5684 312 18 and and CC 5684 312 19 this this DT 5684 312 20 is be VBZ 5684 312 21 a a DT 5684 312 22 moral moral JJ 5684 312 23 necessitation necessitation NN 5684 312 24 by by IN 5684 312 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 312 26 own own JJ 5684 312 27 law law NN 5684 312 28 giving give VBG 5684 312 29 reason reason NN 5684 312 30 , , , 5684 312 31 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 5684 312 32 as as IN 5684 312 33 this this DT 5684 312 34 constitutes constitute VBZ 5684 312 35 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 312 36 a a DT 5684 312 37 power power NN 5684 312 38 executing execute VBG 5684 312 39 the the DT 5684 312 40 law law NN 5684 312 41 . . . 5684 313 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 313 2 is be VBZ 5684 313 3 not not RB 5684 313 4 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 313 5 a a DT 5684 313 6 duty duty NN 5684 313 7 , , , 5684 313 8 nor nor CC 5684 313 9 is be VBZ 5684 313 10 it -PRON- PRP 5684 313 11 a a DT 5684 313 12 duty duty NN 5684 313 13 to to TO 5684 313 14 possess possess VB 5684 313 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 313 16 ( ( -LRB- 5684 313 17 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 313 18 we -PRON- PRP 5684 313 19 should should MD 5684 313 20 be be VB 5684 313 21 in in IN 5684 313 22 duty duty NN 5684 313 23 bound bind VBN 5684 313 24 to to TO 5684 313 25 have have VB 5684 313 26 a a DT 5684 313 27 duty duty NN 5684 313 28 ) ) -RRB- 5684 313 29 , , , 5684 313 30 but but CC 5684 313 31 it -PRON- PRP 5684 313 32 commands command VBZ 5684 313 33 , , , 5684 313 34 and and CC 5684 313 35 accompanies accompany VBZ 5684 313 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 313 37 command command NN 5684 313 38 with with IN 5684 313 39 a a DT 5684 313 40 moral moral JJ 5684 313 41 constraint constraint NN 5684 313 42 ( ( -LRB- 5684 313 43 one one CD 5684 313 44 possible possible JJ 5684 313 45 by by IN 5684 313 46 laws law NNS 5684 313 47 of of IN 5684 313 48 internal internal JJ 5684 313 49 freedom freedom NN 5684 313 50 ) ) -RRB- 5684 313 51 . . . 5684 314 1 But but CC 5684 314 2 since since IN 5684 314 3 this this DT 5684 314 4 should should MD 5684 314 5 be be VB 5684 314 6 irresistible irresistible JJ 5684 314 7 , , , 5684 314 8 strength strength NN 5684 314 9 is be VBZ 5684 314 10 requisite requisite JJ 5684 314 11 , , , 5684 314 12 and and CC 5684 314 13 the the DT 5684 314 14 degree degree NN 5684 314 15 of of IN 5684 314 16 this this DT 5684 314 17 strength strength NN 5684 314 18 can can MD 5684 314 19 be be VB 5684 314 20 estimated estimate VBN 5684 314 21 only only RB 5684 314 22 by by IN 5684 314 23 the the DT 5684 314 24 magnitude magnitude NN 5684 314 25 of of IN 5684 314 26 the the DT 5684 314 27 hindrances hindrance NNS 5684 314 28 which which WDT 5684 314 29 man man NN 5684 314 30 creates create VBZ 5684 314 31 for for IN 5684 314 32 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 314 33 , , , 5684 314 34 by by IN 5684 314 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 314 36 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 314 37 . . . 5684 315 1 Vices vice NNS 5684 315 2 , , , 5684 315 3 the the DT 5684 315 4 brood brood NN 5684 315 5 of of IN 5684 315 6 unlawful unlawful JJ 5684 315 7 dispositions disposition NNS 5684 315 8 , , , 5684 315 9 are be VBP 5684 315 10 the the DT 5684 315 11 monsters monster NNS 5684 315 12 that that WDT 5684 315 13 he -PRON- PRP 5684 315 14 has have VBZ 5684 315 15 to to TO 5684 315 16 combat combat VB 5684 315 17 ; ; , 5684 315 18 wherefore wherefore VBD 5684 315 19 this this DT 5684 315 20 moral moral JJ 5684 315 21 strength strength NN 5684 315 22 as as IN 5684 315 23 fortitude fortitude NN 5684 315 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 315 25 fortitudo fortitudo NNP 5684 315 26 moralis moralis NNP 5684 315 27 ) ) -RRB- 5684 315 28 constitutes constitute VBZ 5684 315 29 the the DT 5684 315 30 greatest great JJS 5684 315 31 and and CC 5684 315 32 only only JJ 5684 315 33 true true JJ 5684 315 34 martial martial JJ 5684 315 35 glory glory NN 5684 315 36 of of IN 5684 315 37 man man NN 5684 315 38 ; ; : 5684 315 39 it -PRON- PRP 5684 315 40 is be VBZ 5684 315 41 also also RB 5684 315 42 called call VBN 5684 315 43 the the DT 5684 315 44 true true JJ 5684 315 45 wisdom wisdom NN 5684 315 46 , , , 5684 315 47 namely namely RB 5684 315 48 , , , 5684 315 49 the the DT 5684 315 50 practical practical JJ 5684 315 51 , , , 5684 315 52 because because IN 5684 315 53 it -PRON- PRP 5684 315 54 makes make VBZ 5684 315 55 the the DT 5684 315 56 ultimate ultimate JJ 5684 315 57 end end NN 5684 315 58 of of IN 5684 315 59 the the DT 5684 315 60 existence existence NN 5684 315 61 of of IN 5684 315 62 man man NN 5684 315 63 on on IN 5684 315 64 earth earth NN 5684 315 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 315 66 own own JJ 5684 315 67 end end NN 5684 315 68 . . . 5684 316 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 316 2 possession possession NN 5684 316 3 alone alone RB 5684 316 4 makes make VBZ 5684 316 5 man man NN 5684 316 6 free free JJ 5684 316 7 , , , 5684 316 8 healthy healthy JJ 5684 316 9 , , , 5684 316 10 rich rich JJ 5684 316 11 , , , 5684 316 12 a a DT 5684 316 13 king king NN 5684 316 14 , , , 5684 316 15 etc etc FW 5684 316 16 . . FW 5684 316 17 , , , 5684 316 18 nor nor CC 5684 316 19 either either DT 5684 316 20 chance chance NN 5684 316 21 or or CC 5684 316 22 fate fate NN 5684 316 23 deprive deprive VB 5684 316 24 him -PRON- PRP 5684 316 25 of of IN 5684 316 26 this this DT 5684 316 27 , , , 5684 316 28 since since IN 5684 316 29 he -PRON- PRP 5684 316 30 possesses possess VBZ 5684 316 31 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 316 32 , , , 5684 316 33 and and CC 5684 316 34 the the DT 5684 316 35 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 316 36 can can MD 5684 316 37 not not RB 5684 316 38 lose lose VB 5684 316 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 316 40 virtue virtue NN 5684 316 41 . . . 5684 317 1 All all PDT 5684 317 2 the the DT 5684 317 3 encomiums encomium NNS 5684 317 4 bestowed bestow VBN 5684 317 5 on on IN 5684 317 6 the the DT 5684 317 7 ideal ideal NN 5684 317 8 of of IN 5684 317 9 humanity humanity NN 5684 317 10 in in IN 5684 317 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 317 12 moral moral JJ 5684 317 13 perfection perfection NN 5684 317 14 can can MD 5684 317 15 lose lose VB 5684 317 16 nothing nothing NN 5684 317 17 of of IN 5684 317 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 317 19 practical practical JJ 5684 317 20 reality reality NN 5684 317 21 by by IN 5684 317 22 the the DT 5684 317 23 examples example NNS 5684 317 24 of of IN 5684 317 25 what what WP 5684 317 26 men man NNS 5684 317 27 now now RB 5684 317 28 are be VBP 5684 317 29 , , , 5684 317 30 have have VBP 5684 317 31 been be VBN 5684 317 32 , , , 5684 317 33 or or CC 5684 317 34 will will MD 5684 317 35 probably probably RB 5684 317 36 be be VB 5684 317 37 hereafter hereafter NN 5684 317 38 ; ; : 5684 317 39 anthropology anthropology NN 5684 317 40 which which WDT 5684 317 41 proceeds proceed VBZ 5684 317 42 from from IN 5684 317 43 mere mere JJ 5684 317 44 empirical empirical JJ 5684 317 45 knowledge knowledge NN 5684 317 46 can can MD 5684 317 47 not not RB 5684 317 48 impair impair VB 5684 317 49 anthroponomy anthroponomy NN 5684 317 50 which which WDT 5684 317 51 is be VBZ 5684 317 52 erected erect VBN 5684 317 53 by by IN 5684 317 54 the the DT 5684 317 55 unconditionally unconditionally RB 5684 317 56 legislating legislating NN 5684 317 57 reason reason NN 5684 317 58 ; ; : 5684 317 59 and and CC 5684 317 60 although although IN 5684 317 61 virtue virtue NN 5684 317 62 may may MD 5684 317 63 now now RB 5684 317 64 and and CC 5684 317 65 then then RB 5684 317 66 be be VB 5684 317 67 called call VBN 5684 317 68 meritorious meritorious JJ 5684 317 69 ( ( -LRB- 5684 317 70 in in IN 5684 317 71 relation relation NN 5684 317 72 to to IN 5684 317 73 men man NNS 5684 317 74 , , , 5684 317 75 not not RB 5684 317 76 to to IN 5684 317 77 the the DT 5684 317 78 law law NN 5684 317 79 ) ) -RRB- 5684 317 80 , , , 5684 317 81 and and CC 5684 317 82 be be VB 5684 317 83 worthy worthy JJ 5684 317 84 of of IN 5684 317 85 reward reward NN 5684 317 86 , , , 5684 317 87 yet yet CC 5684 317 88 in in IN 5684 317 89 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 317 90 , , , 5684 317 91 as as IN 5684 317 92 it -PRON- PRP 5684 317 93 is be VBZ 5684 317 94 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 317 95 own own JJ 5684 317 96 end end NN 5684 317 97 , , , 5684 317 98 so so RB 5684 317 99 also also RB 5684 317 100 it -PRON- PRP 5684 317 101 must must MD 5684 317 102 be be VB 5684 317 103 regarded regard VBN 5684 317 104 as as IN 5684 317 105 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 317 106 own own JJ 5684 317 107 reward reward NN 5684 317 108 . . . 5684 318 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 318 2 considered consider VBD 5684 318 3 in in IN 5684 318 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 318 5 complete complete JJ 5684 318 6 perfection perfection NN 5684 318 7 is be VBZ 5684 318 8 , , , 5684 318 9 therefore therefore RB 5684 318 10 , , , 5684 318 11 regarded regard VBD 5684 318 12 not not RB 5684 318 13 as as IN 5684 318 14 if if IN 5684 318 15 man man NN 5684 318 16 possessed possess VBD 5684 318 17 virtue virtue NNP 5684 318 18 , , , 5684 318 19 but but CC 5684 318 20 as as IN 5684 318 21 if if IN 5684 318 22 virtue virtue NN 5684 318 23 possessed possess VBD 5684 318 24 the the DT 5684 318 25 man man NN 5684 318 26 , , , 5684 318 27 since since IN 5684 318 28 in in IN 5684 318 29 the the DT 5684 318 30 former former JJ 5684 318 31 case case NN 5684 318 32 it -PRON- PRP 5684 318 33 would would MD 5684 318 34 appear appear VB 5684 318 35 as as IN 5684 318 36 though though IN 5684 318 37 he -PRON- PRP 5684 318 38 had have VBD 5684 318 39 still still RB 5684 318 40 had have VBN 5684 318 41 the the DT 5684 318 42 choice choice NN 5684 318 43 ( ( -LRB- 5684 318 44 for for IN 5684 318 45 which which WDT 5684 318 46 he -PRON- PRP 5684 318 47 would would MD 5684 318 48 then then RB 5684 318 49 require require VB 5684 318 50 another another DT 5684 318 51 virtue virtue NN 5684 318 52 , , , 5684 318 53 in in IN 5684 318 54 order order NN 5684 318 55 to to TO 5684 318 56 select select VB 5684 318 57 virtue virtue NN 5684 318 58 from from IN 5684 318 59 all all DT 5684 318 60 other other JJ 5684 318 61 wares ware NNS 5684 318 62 offered offer VBD 5684 318 63 to to IN 5684 318 64 him -PRON- PRP 5684 318 65 ) ) -RRB- 5684 318 66 . . . 5684 319 1 To to TO 5684 319 2 conceive conceive VB 5684 319 3 a a DT 5684 319 4 plurality plurality NN 5684 319 5 of of IN 5684 319 6 virtues virtue NNS 5684 319 7 ( ( -LRB- 5684 319 8 as as IN 5684 319 9 we -PRON- PRP 5684 319 10 unavoidably unavoidably RB 5684 319 11 must must MD 5684 319 12 ) ) -RRB- 5684 319 13 is be VBZ 5684 319 14 nothing nothing NN 5684 319 15 else else RB 5684 319 16 but but IN 5684 319 17 to to TO 5684 319 18 conceive conceive VB 5684 319 19 various various JJ 5684 319 20 moral moral JJ 5684 319 21 objects object NNS 5684 319 22 to to TO 5684 319 23 which which WDT 5684 319 24 the the DT 5684 319 25 ( ( -LRB- 5684 319 26 rational rational JJ 5684 319 27 ) ) -RRB- 5684 319 28 will will MD 5684 319 29 is be VBZ 5684 319 30 led lead VBN 5684 319 31 by by IN 5684 319 32 the the DT 5684 319 33 single single JJ 5684 319 34 principle principle NN 5684 319 35 of of IN 5684 319 36 virtue virtue NN 5684 319 37 ; ; : 5684 319 38 and and CC 5684 319 39 it -PRON- PRP 5684 319 40 is be VBZ 5684 319 41 the the DT 5684 319 42 same same JJ 5684 319 43 with with IN 5684 319 44 the the DT 5684 319 45 opposite opposite JJ 5684 319 46 vices vice NNS 5684 319 47 . . . 5684 320 1 The the DT 5684 320 2 expression expression NN 5684 320 3 which which WDT 5684 320 4 personifies personify VBZ 5684 320 5 both both DT 5684 320 6 is be VBZ 5684 320 7 a a DT 5684 320 8 contrivance contrivance NN 5684 320 9 for for IN 5684 320 10 affecting affect VBG 5684 320 11 the the DT 5684 320 12 sensibility sensibility NN 5684 320 13 , , , 5684 320 14 pointing pointing NN 5684 320 15 , , , 5684 320 16 however however RB 5684 320 17 , , , 5684 320 18 to to IN 5684 320 19 a a DT 5684 320 20 moral moral JJ 5684 320 21 sense sense NN 5684 320 22 . . . 5684 321 1 Hence hence RB 5684 321 2 it -PRON- PRP 5684 321 3 follows follow VBZ 5684 321 4 that that IN 5684 321 5 an an DT 5684 321 6 aesthetic aesthetic NN 5684 321 7 of of IN 5684 321 8 morals moral NNS 5684 321 9 is be VBZ 5684 321 10 not not RB 5684 321 11 a a DT 5684 321 12 part part NN 5684 321 13 , , , 5684 321 14 but but CC 5684 321 15 a a DT 5684 321 16 subjective subjective JJ 5684 321 17 exposition exposition NN 5684 321 18 of of IN 5684 321 19 the the DT 5684 321 20 Metaphysic Metaphysic NNP 5684 321 21 of of IN 5684 321 22 Morals Morals NNPS 5684 321 23 ; ; : 5684 321 24 in in IN 5684 321 25 which which WDT 5684 321 26 the the DT 5684 321 27 emotions emotion NNS 5684 321 28 that that WDT 5684 321 29 accompany accompany VBP 5684 321 30 the the DT 5684 321 31 force force NN 5684 321 32 of of IN 5684 321 33 the the DT 5684 321 34 moral moral JJ 5684 321 35 law law NN 5684 321 36 make make VBP 5684 321 37 the the DT 5684 321 38 that that DT 5684 321 39 force force NN 5684 321 40 to to TO 5684 321 41 be be VB 5684 321 42 felt feel VBN 5684 321 43 ; ; : 5684 321 44 for for IN 5684 321 45 example example NN 5684 321 46 : : : 5684 321 47 disgust disgust NN 5684 321 48 , , , 5684 321 49 horror horror NN 5684 321 50 , , , 5684 321 51 etc etc FW 5684 321 52 . . FW 5684 321 53 , , , 5684 321 54 which which WDT 5684 321 55 gives give VBZ 5684 321 56 a a DT 5684 321 57 sensible sensible JJ 5684 321 58 moral moral JJ 5684 321 59 aversion aversion NN 5684 321 60 in in IN 5684 321 61 order order NN 5684 321 62 to to TO 5684 321 63 gain gain VB 5684 321 64 the the DT 5684 321 65 precedence precedence NN 5684 321 66 from from IN 5684 321 67 the the DT 5684 321 68 merely merely RB 5684 321 69 sensible sensible JJ 5684 321 70 incitement incitement NN 5684 321 71 . . . 5684 322 1 { { -LRB- 5684 322 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 322 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 322 4 180 180 CD 5684 322 5 } } -RRB- 5684 322 6 XV XV NNP 5684 322 7 . . . 5684 323 1 Of of IN 5684 323 2 the the DT 5684 323 3 Principle Principle NNP 5684 323 4 on on IN 5684 323 5 which which WDT 5684 323 6 Ethics Ethics NNP 5684 323 7 is be VBZ 5684 323 8 separated separate VBN 5684 323 9 from from IN 5684 323 10 Jurisprudence Jurisprudence NNP 5684 323 11 This This NNP 5684 323 12 separation separation NN 5684 323 13 on on IN 5684 323 14 which which WDT 5684 323 15 the the DT 5684 323 16 subdivision subdivision NN 5684 323 17 of of IN 5684 323 18 moral moral JJ 5684 323 19 philosophy philosophy NN 5684 323 20 in in IN 5684 323 21 general general JJ 5684 323 22 rests rest NNS 5684 323 23 , , , 5684 323 24 is be VBZ 5684 323 25 founded found VBN 5684 323 26 on on IN 5684 323 27 this this DT 5684 323 28 : : : 5684 323 29 that that IN 5684 323 30 the the DT 5684 323 31 notion notion NN 5684 323 32 of of IN 5684 323 33 freedom freedom NN 5684 323 34 , , , 5684 323 35 which which WDT 5684 323 36 is be VBZ 5684 323 37 common common JJ 5684 323 38 to to IN 5684 323 39 both both DT 5684 323 40 , , , 5684 323 41 makes make VBZ 5684 323 42 it -PRON- PRP 5684 323 43 necessary necessary JJ 5684 323 44 to to TO 5684 323 45 divide divide VB 5684 323 46 duties duty NNS 5684 323 47 into into IN 5684 323 48 those those DT 5684 323 49 of of IN 5684 323 50 external external JJ 5684 323 51 and and CC 5684 323 52 those those DT 5684 323 53 of of IN 5684 323 54 internal internal JJ 5684 323 55 freedom freedom NN 5684 323 56 ; ; : 5684 323 57 the the DT 5684 323 58 latter latter NN 5684 323 59 of of IN 5684 323 60 which which WDT 5684 323 61 alone alone RB 5684 323 62 are be VBP 5684 323 63 ethical ethical JJ 5684 323 64 . . . 5684 324 1 Hence hence RB 5684 324 2 this this DT 5684 324 3 internal internal JJ 5684 324 4 freedom freedom NN 5684 324 5 which which WDT 5684 324 6 is be VBZ 5684 324 7 the the DT 5684 324 8 condition condition NN 5684 324 9 of of IN 5684 324 10 all all DT 5684 324 11 ethical ethical JJ 5684 324 12 duty duty NN 5684 324 13 must must MD 5684 324 14 be be VB 5684 324 15 discussed discuss VBN 5684 324 16 as as IN 5684 324 17 a a DT 5684 324 18 preliminary preliminary JJ 5684 324 19 ( ( -LRB- 5684 324 20 discursus discursus NNP 5684 324 21 praeliminaris praeliminaris NNP 5684 324 22 ) ) -RRB- 5684 324 23 , , , 5684 324 24 just just RB 5684 324 25 as as IN 5684 324 26 above above IN 5684 324 27 the the DT 5684 324 28 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 324 29 of of IN 5684 324 30 conscience conscience NN 5684 324 31 was be VBD 5684 324 32 discussed discuss VBN 5684 324 33 as as IN 5684 324 34 the the DT 5684 324 35 condition condition NN 5684 324 36 of of IN 5684 324 37 all all DT 5684 324 38 duty duty NN 5684 324 39 . . . 5684 325 1 { { -LRB- 5684 325 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 325 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 325 4 185 185 CD 5684 325 5 } } -RRB- 5684 325 6 REMARKS REMARKS NNP 5684 325 7 Of of IN 5684 325 8 the the DT 5684 325 9 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 5684 325 10 of of IN 5684 325 11 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 325 12 on on IN 5684 325 13 the the DT 5684 325 14 Principle Principle NNP 5684 325 15 Of of IN 5684 325 16 Internal Internal NNP 5684 325 17 Freedom Freedom NNP 5684 325 18 . . . 5684 326 1 Habit Habit NNP 5684 326 2 ( ( -LRB- 5684 326 3 habitus habitus NN 5684 326 4 ) ) -RRB- 5684 326 5 is be VBZ 5684 326 6 a a DT 5684 326 7 facility facility NN 5684 326 8 of of IN 5684 326 9 action action NN 5684 326 10 and and CC 5684 326 11 a a DT 5684 326 12 subjective subjective JJ 5684 326 13 perfection perfection NN 5684 326 14 of of IN 5684 326 15 the the DT 5684 326 16 elective elective NN 5684 326 17 will will NN 5684 326 18 . . . 5684 327 1 But but CC 5684 327 2 not not RB 5684 327 3 every every DT 5684 327 4 such such JJ 5684 327 5 facility facility NN 5684 327 6 is be VBZ 5684 327 7 a a DT 5684 327 8 free free JJ 5684 327 9 habit habit NN 5684 327 10 ( ( -LRB- 5684 327 11 habitus habitus NNP 5684 327 12 libertatis libertatis NNP 5684 327 13 ) ) -RRB- 5684 327 14 ; ; : 5684 327 15 for for IN 5684 327 16 if if IN 5684 327 17 it -PRON- PRP 5684 327 18 is be VBZ 5684 327 19 custom custom NN 5684 327 20 ( ( -LRB- 5684 327 21 assuetudo assuetudo NNP 5684 327 22 ) ) -RRB- 5684 327 23 , , , 5684 327 24 that that RB 5684 327 25 is is RB 5684 327 26 , , , 5684 327 27 a a DT 5684 327 28 uniformity uniformity NN 5684 327 29 of of IN 5684 327 30 action action NN 5684 327 31 which which WDT 5684 327 32 , , , 5684 327 33 by by IN 5684 327 34 frequent frequent JJ 5684 327 35 repetition repetition NN 5684 327 36 , , , 5684 327 37 has have VBZ 5684 327 38 become become VBN 5684 327 39 a a DT 5684 327 40 necessity necessity NN 5684 327 41 , , , 5684 327 42 then then RB 5684 327 43 it -PRON- PRP 5684 327 44 is be VBZ 5684 327 45 not not RB 5684 327 46 a a DT 5684 327 47 habit habit NN 5684 327 48 proceeding proceeding NN 5684 327 49 from from IN 5684 327 50 freedom freedom NN 5684 327 51 , , , 5684 327 52 and and CC 5684 327 53 therefore therefore RB 5684 327 54 not not RB 5684 327 55 a a DT 5684 327 56 moral moral JJ 5684 327 57 habit habit NN 5684 327 58 . . . 5684 328 1 Virtue virtue NN 5684 328 2 therefore therefore RB 5684 328 3 can can MD 5684 328 4 not not RB 5684 328 5 be be VB 5684 328 6 defined define VBN 5684 328 7 as as IN 5684 328 8 a a DT 5684 328 9 habit habit NN 5684 328 10 of of IN 5684 328 11 free free JJ 5684 328 12 law law NN 5684 328 13 - - HYPH 5684 328 14 abiding abide VBG 5684 328 15 actions action NNS 5684 328 16 , , , 5684 328 17 unless unless IN 5684 328 18 indeed indeed RB 5684 328 19 we -PRON- PRP 5684 328 20 add add VBP 5684 328 21 " " '' 5684 328 22 determining determine VBG 5684 328 23 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 328 24 in in IN 5684 328 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 328 26 action action NN 5684 328 27 by by IN 5684 328 28 the the DT 5684 328 29 idea idea NN 5684 328 30 of of IN 5684 328 31 the the DT 5684 328 32 law law NN 5684 328 33 " " '' 5684 328 34 ; ; : 5684 328 35 and and CC 5684 328 36 then then RB 5684 328 37 this this DT 5684 328 38 habit habit NN 5684 328 39 is be VBZ 5684 328 40 not not RB 5684 328 41 a a DT 5684 328 42 property property NN 5684 328 43 of of IN 5684 328 44 the the DT 5684 328 45 elective elective NN 5684 328 46 will will NN 5684 328 47 , , , 5684 328 48 but but CC 5684 328 49 of of IN 5684 328 50 the the DT 5684 328 51 rational rational JJ 5684 328 52 will will NN 5684 328 53 , , , 5684 328 54 which which WDT 5684 328 55 is be VBZ 5684 328 56 a a DT 5684 328 57 faculty faculty NN 5684 328 58 that that IN 5684 328 59 in in IN 5684 328 60 adopting adopt VBG 5684 328 61 a a DT 5684 328 62 rule rule NN 5684 328 63 also also RB 5684 328 64 declares declare VBZ 5684 328 65 it -PRON- PRP 5684 328 66 to to TO 5684 328 67 be be VB 5684 328 68 a a DT 5684 328 69 universal universal JJ 5684 328 70 law law NN 5684 328 71 , , , 5684 328 72 and and CC 5684 328 73 it -PRON- PRP 5684 328 74 is be VBZ 5684 328 75 only only RB 5684 328 76 such such PDT 5684 328 77 a a DT 5684 328 78 habit habit NN 5684 328 79 that that WDT 5684 328 80 can can MD 5684 328 81 be be VB 5684 328 82 reckoned reckon VBN 5684 328 83 as as IN 5684 328 84 virtue virtue NN 5684 328 85 . . . 5684 329 1 Two two CD 5684 329 2 things thing NNS 5684 329 3 are be VBP 5684 329 4 required require VBN 5684 329 5 for for IN 5684 329 6 internal internal JJ 5684 329 7 freedom freedom NN 5684 329 8 : : : 5684 329 9 to to TO 5684 329 10 be be VB 5684 329 11 master master NN 5684 329 12 of of IN 5684 329 13 oneself oneself PRP 5684 329 14 in in IN 5684 329 15 a a DT 5684 329 16 given give VBN 5684 329 17 case case NN 5684 329 18 ( ( -LRB- 5684 329 19 animus animus NNP 5684 329 20 sui sui NNP 5684 329 21 compos compos NNP 5684 329 22 ) ) -RRB- 5684 329 23 and and CC 5684 329 24 to to TO 5684 329 25 have have VB 5684 329 26 command command NN 5684 329 27 over over IN 5684 329 28 oneself oneself PRP 5684 329 29 ( ( -LRB- 5684 329 30 imperium imperium NN 5684 329 31 in in IN 5684 329 32 semetipsum semetipsum NN 5684 329 33 ) ) -RRB- 5684 329 34 , , , 5684 329 35 that that DT 5684 329 36 is be VBZ 5684 329 37 to to TO 5684 329 38 subdue subdue VB 5684 329 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 329 40 emotions emotion NNS 5684 329 41 and and CC 5684 329 42 to to TO 5684 329 43 govern govern VB 5684 329 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 329 45 passions passion NNS 5684 329 46 . . . 5684 330 1 With with IN 5684 330 2 these these DT 5684 330 3 conditions condition NNS 5684 330 4 , , , 5684 330 5 the the DT 5684 330 6 character character NN 5684 330 7 ( ( -LRB- 5684 330 8 indoles indoles NNP 5684 330 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 330 10 is be VBZ 5684 330 11 noble noble JJ 5684 330 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 330 13 erecta erecta NNP 5684 330 14 ) ) -RRB- 5684 330 15 ; ; : 5684 330 16 in in IN 5684 330 17 the the DT 5684 330 18 opposite opposite JJ 5684 330 19 case case NN 5684 330 20 , , , 5684 330 21 it -PRON- PRP 5684 330 22 is be VBZ 5684 330 23 ignoble ignoble JJ 5684 330 24 ( ( -LRB- 5684 330 25 indoles indole VBZ 5684 330 26 abjecta abjecta NNP 5684 330 27 serva serva NNP 5684 330 28 ) ) -RRB- 5684 330 29 . . . 5684 331 1 { { -LRB- 5684 331 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 331 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 331 4 190 190 CD 5684 331 5 } } -RRB- 5684 331 6 XVI XVI NNP 5684 331 7 . . . 5684 332 1 Virtue virtue NN 5684 332 2 requires require VBZ 5684 332 3 , , , 5684 332 4 first first RB 5684 332 5 of of IN 5684 332 6 all all DT 5684 332 7 , , , 5684 332 8 Command Command NNP 5684 332 9 over over IN 5684 332 10 Oneself Oneself NNP 5684 332 11 Emotions Emotions NNPS 5684 332 12 and and CC 5684 332 13 passions passion NNS 5684 332 14 are be VBP 5684 332 15 essentially essentially RB 5684 332 16 distinct distinct JJ 5684 332 17 ; ; : 5684 332 18 the the DT 5684 332 19 former former JJ 5684 332 20 belong belong NN 5684 332 21 to to IN 5684 332 22 feeling feel VBG 5684 332 23 in in RB 5684 332 24 so so RB 5684 332 25 far far RB 5684 332 26 as as IN 5684 332 27 this this DT 5684 332 28 coming come VBG 5684 332 29 before before IN 5684 332 30 reflection reflection NN 5684 332 31 makes make VBZ 5684 332 32 it -PRON- PRP 5684 332 33 more more RBR 5684 332 34 difficult difficult JJ 5684 332 35 or or CC 5684 332 36 even even RB 5684 332 37 impossible impossible JJ 5684 332 38 . . . 5684 333 1 Hence hence RB 5684 333 2 emotion emotion NN 5684 333 3 is be VBZ 5684 333 4 called call VBN 5684 333 5 hasty hasty NNP 5684 333 6 ( ( -LRB- 5684 333 7 animus animus NNP 5684 333 8 praeceps praeceps NNP 5684 333 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 333 10 . . . 5684 334 1 And and CC 5684 334 2 reason reason NN 5684 334 3 declares declare VBZ 5684 334 4 through through IN 5684 334 5 the the DT 5684 334 6 notion notion NN 5684 334 7 of of IN 5684 334 8 virtue virtue NN 5684 334 9 that that IN 5684 334 10 a a DT 5684 334 11 man man NN 5684 334 12 should should MD 5684 334 13 collect collect VB 5684 334 14 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 334 15 ; ; : 5684 334 16 but but CC 5684 334 17 this this DT 5684 334 18 weakness weakness NN 5684 334 19 in in IN 5684 334 20 the the DT 5684 334 21 life life NN 5684 334 22 of of IN 5684 334 23 one one NN 5684 334 24 's 's POS 5684 334 25 understanding understanding NN 5684 334 26 , , , 5684 334 27 joined join VBD 5684 334 28 with with IN 5684 334 29 the the DT 5684 334 30 strength strength NN 5684 334 31 of of IN 5684 334 32 a a DT 5684 334 33 mental mental JJ 5684 334 34 excitement excitement NN 5684 334 35 , , , 5684 334 36 is be VBZ 5684 334 37 only only RB 5684 334 38 a a DT 5684 334 39 lack lack NN 5684 334 40 of of IN 5684 334 41 virtue virtue NN 5684 334 42 ( ( -LRB- 5684 334 43 Untugend Untugend NNP 5684 334 44 ) ) -RRB- 5684 334 45 , , , 5684 334 46 and and CC 5684 334 47 as as IN 5684 334 48 it -PRON- PRP 5684 334 49 were be VBD 5684 334 50 a a DT 5684 334 51 weak weak JJ 5684 334 52 and and CC 5684 334 53 childish childish JJ 5684 334 54 thing thing NN 5684 334 55 , , , 5684 334 56 which which WDT 5684 334 57 may may MD 5684 334 58 very very RB 5684 334 59 well well RB 5684 334 60 consist consist VB 5684 334 61 with with IN 5684 334 62 the the DT 5684 334 63 best good JJS 5684 334 64 will will NN 5684 334 65 , , , 5684 334 66 and and CC 5684 334 67 has have VBZ 5684 334 68 further further RB 5684 334 69 this this DT 5684 334 70 one one CD 5684 334 71 good good JJ 5684 334 72 thing thing NN 5684 334 73 in in IN 5684 334 74 it -PRON- PRP 5684 334 75 , , , 5684 334 76 that that IN 5684 334 77 this this DT 5684 334 78 storm storm NN 5684 334 79 soon soon RB 5684 334 80 subsides subside NNS 5684 334 81 . . . 5684 335 1 A a DT 5684 335 2 propensity propensity NN 5684 335 3 to to IN 5684 335 4 emotion emotion NN 5684 335 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 335 6 e.g. e.g. RB 5684 335 7 , , , 5684 335 8 resentment resentment NN 5684 335 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 335 10 is be VBZ 5684 335 11 therefore therefore RB 5684 335 12 not not RB 5684 335 13 so so RB 5684 335 14 closely closely RB 5684 335 15 related related JJ 5684 335 16 to to IN 5684 335 17 vice vice NN 5684 335 18 as as IN 5684 335 19 passion passion NN 5684 335 20 is be VBZ 5684 335 21 . . . 5684 336 1 Passion passion NN 5684 336 2 , , , 5684 336 3 on on IN 5684 336 4 the the DT 5684 336 5 other other JJ 5684 336 6 hand hand NN 5684 336 7 , , , 5684 336 8 is be VBZ 5684 336 9 the the DT 5684 336 10 sensible sensible JJ 5684 336 11 appetite appetite NN 5684 336 12 grown grow VBN 5684 336 13 into into IN 5684 336 14 a a DT 5684 336 15 permanent permanent JJ 5684 336 16 inclination inclination NN 5684 336 17 ( ( -LRB- 5684 336 18 e. e. NNP 5684 336 19 g. g. NNP 5684 336 20 , , , 5684 336 21 hatred hatred NNP 5684 336 22 in in IN 5684 336 23 contrast contrast NN 5684 336 24 to to IN 5684 336 25 resentment resentment NN 5684 336 26 ) ) -RRB- 5684 336 27 . . . 5684 337 1 The the DT 5684 337 2 calmness calmness NN 5684 337 3 with with IN 5684 337 4 which which WDT 5684 337 5 one one NN 5684 337 6 indulges indulge VBZ 5684 337 7 it -PRON- PRP 5684 337 8 leaves leave VBZ 5684 337 9 room room NN 5684 337 10 for for IN 5684 337 11 reflection reflection NN 5684 337 12 and and CC 5684 337 13 allows allow VBZ 5684 337 14 the the DT 5684 337 15 mind mind NN 5684 337 16 to to TO 5684 337 17 frame frame VB 5684 337 18 principles principle NNS 5684 337 19 thereon thereon NN 5684 337 20 for for IN 5684 337 21 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 337 22 ; ; : 5684 337 23 and and CC 5684 337 24 thus thus RB 5684 337 25 when when WRB 5684 337 26 the the DT 5684 337 27 inclination inclination NN 5684 337 28 falls fall VBZ 5684 337 29 upon upon IN 5684 337 30 what what WP 5684 337 31 contradicts contradict VBZ 5684 337 32 the the DT 5684 337 33 law law NN 5684 337 34 , , , 5684 337 35 to to IN 5684 337 36 brood brood NN 5684 337 37 on on IN 5684 337 38 it -PRON- PRP 5684 337 39 , , , 5684 337 40 to to TO 5684 337 41 allow allow VB 5684 337 42 it -PRON- PRP 5684 337 43 to to TO 5684 337 44 root root VB 5684 337 45 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 337 46 deeply deeply RB 5684 337 47 , , , 5684 337 48 and and CC 5684 337 49 thereby thereby RB 5684 337 50 to to TO 5684 337 51 take take VB 5684 337 52 up up RP 5684 337 53 evil evil NN 5684 337 54 ( ( -LRB- 5684 337 55 as as IN 5684 337 56 of of IN 5684 337 57 set set VBN 5684 337 58 purpose purpose NN 5684 337 59 ) ) -RRB- 5684 337 60 into into IN 5684 337 61 one one PRP 5684 337 62 's 's POS 5684 337 63 maxim maxim NN 5684 337 64 ; ; : 5684 337 65 and and CC 5684 337 66 this this DT 5684 337 67 is be VBZ 5684 337 68 then then RB 5684 337 69 specifically specifically RB 5684 337 70 evil evil JJ 5684 337 71 , , , 5684 337 72 that that RB 5684 337 73 is is RB 5684 337 74 , , , 5684 337 75 it -PRON- PRP 5684 337 76 is be VBZ 5684 337 77 a a DT 5684 337 78 true true JJ 5684 337 79 vice vice NN 5684 337 80 . . . 5684 338 1 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 338 2 , , , 5684 338 3 therefore therefore RB 5684 338 4 , , , 5684 338 5 in in IN 5684 338 6 so so RB 5684 338 7 far far RB 5684 338 8 as as IN 5684 338 9 it -PRON- PRP 5684 338 10 is be VBZ 5684 338 11 based base VBN 5684 338 12 on on IN 5684 338 13 internal internal JJ 5684 338 14 freedom freedom NN 5684 338 15 , , , 5684 338 16 contains contain VBZ 5684 338 17 a a DT 5684 338 18 positive positive JJ 5684 338 19 command command NN 5684 338 20 for for IN 5684 338 21 man man NN 5684 338 22 , , , 5684 338 23 namely namely RB 5684 338 24 , , , 5684 338 25 that that IN 5684 338 26 he -PRON- PRP 5684 338 27 should should MD 5684 338 28 bring bring VB 5684 338 29 all all PDT 5684 338 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 338 31 powers power NNS 5684 338 32 and and CC 5684 338 33 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 338 34 under under IN 5684 338 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 338 36 rule rule NN 5684 338 37 ( ( -LRB- 5684 338 38 that that DT 5684 338 39 of of IN 5684 338 40 reason reason NN 5684 338 41 ) ) -RRB- 5684 338 42 ; ; : 5684 338 43 and and CC 5684 338 44 this this DT 5684 338 45 is be VBZ 5684 338 46 a a DT 5684 338 47 positive positive JJ 5684 338 48 precept precept NN 5684 338 49 of of IN 5684 338 50 command command NN 5684 338 51 over over IN 5684 338 52 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 338 53 which which WDT 5684 338 54 is be VBZ 5684 338 55 additional additional JJ 5684 338 56 to to IN 5684 338 57 the the DT 5684 338 58 prohibition prohibition NN 5684 338 59 , , , 5684 338 60 namely namely RB 5684 338 61 , , , 5684 338 62 that that IN 5684 338 63 he -PRON- PRP 5684 338 64 should should MD 5684 338 65 not not RB 5684 338 66 allow allow VB 5684 338 67 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 338 68 to to TO 5684 338 69 be be VB 5684 338 70 governed govern VBN 5684 338 71 by by IN 5684 338 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 338 73 feelings feeling NNS 5684 338 74 and and CC 5684 338 75 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 338 76 ( ( -LRB- 5684 338 77 the the DT 5684 338 78 duty duty NN 5684 338 79 of of IN 5684 338 80 apathy apathy NNP 5684 338 81 ) ) -RRB- 5684 338 82 ; ; : 5684 338 83 since since IN 5684 338 84 , , , 5684 338 85 unless unless IN 5684 338 86 reason reason NN 5684 338 87 takes take VBZ 5684 338 88 the the DT 5684 338 89 reins rein NNS 5684 338 90 of of IN 5684 338 91 government government NN 5684 338 92 into into IN 5684 338 93 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 338 94 own own JJ 5684 338 95 hands hand NNS 5684 338 96 , , , 5684 338 97 the the DT 5684 338 98 feelings feeling NNS 5684 338 99 and and CC 5684 338 100 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 338 101 play play VBP 5684 338 102 the the DT 5684 338 103 master master NN 5684 338 104 over over IN 5684 338 105 the the DT 5684 338 106 man man NN 5684 338 107 . . . 5684 339 1 { { -LRB- 5684 339 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 339 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 339 4 195 195 CD 5684 339 5 } } -RRB- 5684 339 6 XVII XVII NNP 5684 339 7 . . . 5684 340 1 Virtue virtue VB 5684 340 2 necessarily necessarily RB 5684 340 3 presupposes presuppose VBZ 5684 340 4 Apathy Apathy NNP 5684 340 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 340 6 considered consider VBN 5684 340 7 as as IN 5684 340 8 Strength Strength NNP 5684 340 9 ) ) -RRB- 5684 340 10 This this DT 5684 340 11 word word NN 5684 340 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 340 13 apathy apathy NNP 5684 340 14 ) ) -RRB- 5684 340 15 has have VBZ 5684 340 16 come come VBN 5684 340 17 into into IN 5684 340 18 bad bad JJ 5684 340 19 repute repute NN 5684 340 20 , , , 5684 340 21 just just RB 5684 340 22 as as IN 5684 340 23 if if IN 5684 340 24 it -PRON- PRP 5684 340 25 meant mean VBD 5684 340 26 want want NN 5684 340 27 of of IN 5684 340 28 feeling feeling NN 5684 340 29 , , , 5684 340 30 and and CC 5684 340 31 therefore therefore RB 5684 340 32 subjective subjective JJ 5684 340 33 indifference indifference NN 5684 340 34 with with IN 5684 340 35 respect respect NN 5684 340 36 to to IN 5684 340 37 the the DT 5684 340 38 objects object NNS 5684 340 39 of of IN 5684 340 40 the the DT 5684 340 41 elective elective NN 5684 340 42 will will MD 5684 340 43 ; ; : 5684 340 44 it -PRON- PRP 5684 340 45 is be VBZ 5684 340 46 supposed suppose VBN 5684 340 47 to to TO 5684 340 48 be be VB 5684 340 49 a a DT 5684 340 50 weakness weakness NN 5684 340 51 . . . 5684 341 1 This this DT 5684 341 2 misconception misconception NN 5684 341 3 may may MD 5684 341 4 be be VB 5684 341 5 avoided avoid VBN 5684 341 6 by by IN 5684 341 7 giving give VBG 5684 341 8 the the DT 5684 341 9 name name NN 5684 341 10 moral moral JJ 5684 341 11 apathy apathy NNP 5684 341 12 to to IN 5684 341 13 that that DT 5684 341 14 want want NN 5684 341 15 of of IN 5684 341 16 emotion emotion NN 5684 341 17 which which WDT 5684 341 18 is be VBZ 5684 341 19 to to TO 5684 341 20 be be VB 5684 341 21 distinguished distinguish VBN 5684 341 22 from from IN 5684 341 23 indifference indifference NN 5684 341 24 . . . 5684 342 1 In in IN 5684 342 2 the the DT 5684 342 3 former former JJ 5684 342 4 , , , 5684 342 5 the the DT 5684 342 6 feelings feeling NNS 5684 342 7 arising arise VBG 5684 342 8 from from IN 5684 342 9 sensible sensible JJ 5684 342 10 impressions impression NNS 5684 342 11 lose lose VBP 5684 342 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 342 13 influence influence NN 5684 342 14 on on IN 5684 342 15 the the DT 5684 342 16 moral moral JJ 5684 342 17 feeling feeling NN 5684 342 18 only only RB 5684 342 19 because because IN 5684 342 20 the the DT 5684 342 21 respect respect NN 5684 342 22 for for IN 5684 342 23 the the DT 5684 342 24 law law NN 5684 342 25 is be VBZ 5684 342 26 more more RBR 5684 342 27 powerful powerful JJ 5684 342 28 than than IN 5684 342 29 all all DT 5684 342 30 of of IN 5684 342 31 them -PRON- PRP 5684 342 32 together together RB 5684 342 33 . . . 5684 343 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 343 2 is be VBZ 5684 343 3 only only RB 5684 343 4 the the DT 5684 343 5 apparent apparent JJ 5684 343 6 strength strength NN 5684 343 7 of of IN 5684 343 8 a a DT 5684 343 9 fever fever NN 5684 343 10 patient patient NN 5684 343 11 that that WDT 5684 343 12 makes make VBZ 5684 343 13 even even RB 5684 343 14 the the DT 5684 343 15 lively lively JJ 5684 343 16 sympathy sympathy NN 5684 343 17 with with IN 5684 343 18 good good JJ 5684 343 19 rise rise NN 5684 343 20 to to IN 5684 343 21 an an DT 5684 343 22 emotion emotion NN 5684 343 23 , , , 5684 343 24 or or CC 5684 343 25 rather rather RB 5684 343 26 degenerate degenerate VB 5684 343 27 into into IN 5684 343 28 it -PRON- PRP 5684 343 29 . . . 5684 344 1 Such such PDT 5684 344 2 an an DT 5684 344 3 emotion emotion NN 5684 344 4 is be VBZ 5684 344 5 called call VBN 5684 344 6 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 5684 344 7 , , , 5684 344 8 and and CC 5684 344 9 it -PRON- PRP 5684 344 10 is be VBZ 5684 344 11 with with IN 5684 344 12 reference reference NN 5684 344 13 to to IN 5684 344 14 this this DT 5684 344 15 that that IN 5684 344 16 we -PRON- PRP 5684 344 17 are be VBP 5684 344 18 to to TO 5684 344 19 explain explain VB 5684 344 20 the the DT 5684 344 21 moderation moderation NN 5684 344 22 which which WDT 5684 344 23 is be VBZ 5684 344 24 usually usually RB 5684 344 25 recommended recommend VBN 5684 344 26 in in IN 5684 344 27 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 344 28 practices practice NNS 5684 344 29 : : : 5684 344 30 { { -LRB- 5684 344 31 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 344 32 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 344 33 200 200 CD 5684 344 34 } } -RRB- 5684 344 35 Insani Insani NNP 5684 344 36 sapiens sapiens VB 5684 344 37 nomen nomen NNP 5684 344 38 ferat ferat NNP 5684 344 39 , , , 5684 344 40 aequus aequus NNP 5684 344 41 uniqui uniqui NNP 5684 344 42 Ultra Ultra NNP 5684 344 43 quam quam NN 5684 344 44 satis satis NN 5684 344 45 est est NNP 5684 344 46 virtutem virtutem NNP 5684 344 47 si si NNP 5684 344 48 petat petat NNP 5684 344 49 ipsam ipsam NNP 5684 344 50 . . . 5684 345 1 * * NFP 5684 345 2 * * NFP 5684 345 3 Horace horace NN 5684 345 4 . . . 5684 346 1 [ [ -LRB- 5684 346 2 " " `` 5684 346 3 Let let VB 5684 346 4 the the DT 5684 346 5 wise wise JJ 5684 346 6 man man NN 5684 346 7 bear bear VB 5684 346 8 the the DT 5684 346 9 name name NN 5684 346 10 of of IN 5684 346 11 fool fool NN 5684 346 12 , , , 5684 346 13 and and CC 5684 346 14 the the DT 5684 346 15 just just RB 5684 346 16 of of IN 5684 346 17 unjust unjust JJ 5684 346 18 , , , 5684 346 19 if if IN 5684 346 20 he -PRON- PRP 5684 346 21 pursue pursue VB 5684 346 22 virtue virtue VB 5684 346 23 herself -PRON- PRP 5684 346 24 beyond beyond IN 5684 346 25 the the DT 5684 346 26 proper proper JJ 5684 346 27 bounds bound NNS 5684 346 28 . . . 5684 346 29 " " '' 5684 346 30 ] ] -RRB- 5684 347 1 { { -LRB- 5684 347 2 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 347 3 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 347 4 205 205 CD 5684 347 5 } } -RRB- 5684 347 6 For for IN 5684 347 7 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 347 8 it -PRON- PRP 5684 347 9 is be VBZ 5684 347 10 absurd absurd JJ 5684 347 11 to to TO 5684 347 12 imagine imagine VB 5684 347 13 that that IN 5684 347 14 one one PRP 5684 347 15 could could MD 5684 347 16 be be VB 5684 347 17 too too RB 5684 347 18 wise wise JJ 5684 347 19 or or CC 5684 347 20 too too RB 5684 347 21 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 347 22 . . . 5684 348 1 The the DT 5684 348 2 emotion emotion NN 5684 348 3 always always RB 5684 348 4 belongs belong VBZ 5684 348 5 to to IN 5684 348 6 the the DT 5684 348 7 sensibility sensibility NN 5684 348 8 , , , 5684 348 9 no no RB 5684 348 10 matter matter RB 5684 348 11 by by IN 5684 348 12 what what WDT 5684 348 13 sort sort NN 5684 348 14 of of IN 5684 348 15 object object NN 5684 348 16 it -PRON- PRP 5684 348 17 may may MD 5684 348 18 be be VB 5684 348 19 excited excite VBN 5684 348 20 . . . 5684 349 1 The the DT 5684 349 2 true true JJ 5684 349 3 strength strength NN 5684 349 4 of of IN 5684 349 5 virtue virtue NN 5684 349 6 is be VBZ 5684 349 7 the the DT 5684 349 8 mind mind NN 5684 349 9 at at IN 5684 349 10 rest rest NN 5684 349 11 , , , 5684 349 12 with with IN 5684 349 13 a a DT 5684 349 14 firm firm JJ 5684 349 15 , , , 5684 349 16 deliberate deliberate JJ 5684 349 17 resolution resolution NN 5684 349 18 to to TO 5684 349 19 bring bring VB 5684 349 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 349 21 law law NN 5684 349 22 into into IN 5684 349 23 practice practice NN 5684 349 24 . . . 5684 350 1 That that DT 5684 350 2 is be VBZ 5684 350 3 the the DT 5684 350 4 state state NN 5684 350 5 of of IN 5684 350 6 health health NN 5684 350 7 in in IN 5684 350 8 the the DT 5684 350 9 moral moral JJ 5684 350 10 life life NN 5684 350 11 ; ; , 5684 350 12 on on IN 5684 350 13 the the DT 5684 350 14 contrary contrary NN 5684 350 15 , , , 5684 350 16 the the DT 5684 350 17 emotion emotion NN 5684 350 18 , , , 5684 350 19 even even RB 5684 350 20 when when WRB 5684 350 21 it -PRON- PRP 5684 350 22 is be VBZ 5684 350 23 excited excite VBN 5684 350 24 by by IN 5684 350 25 the the DT 5684 350 26 idea idea NN 5684 350 27 of of IN 5684 350 28 the the DT 5684 350 29 good good JJ 5684 350 30 , , , 5684 350 31 is be VBZ 5684 350 32 a a DT 5684 350 33 momentary momentary JJ 5684 350 34 glitter glitter NN 5684 350 35 which which WDT 5684 350 36 leaves leave VBZ 5684 350 37 exhaustion exhaustion NN 5684 350 38 after after IN 5684 350 39 it -PRON- PRP 5684 350 40 . . . 5684 351 1 We -PRON- PRP 5684 351 2 may may MD 5684 351 3 apply apply VB 5684 351 4 the the DT 5684 351 5 term term NN 5684 351 6 fantastically fantastically RB 5684 351 7 virtuous virtuous JJ 5684 351 8 to to IN 5684 351 9 the the DT 5684 351 10 man man NN 5684 351 11 who who WP 5684 351 12 will will MD 5684 351 13 admit admit VB 5684 351 14 nothing nothing NN 5684 351 15 to to TO 5684 351 16 be be VB 5684 351 17 indifferent indifferent JJ 5684 351 18 in in IN 5684 351 19 respect respect NN 5684 351 20 of of IN 5684 351 21 morality morality NN 5684 351 22 ( ( -LRB- 5684 351 23 adiaphora adiaphora NNP 5684 351 24 ) ) -RRB- 5684 351 25 , , , 5684 351 26 and and CC 5684 351 27 who who WP 5684 351 28 strews strew VBZ 5684 351 29 all all PDT 5684 351 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 351 31 steps step NNS 5684 351 32 with with IN 5684 351 33 duties duty NNS 5684 351 34 , , , 5684 351 35 as as IN 5684 351 36 with with IN 5684 351 37 traps trap NNS 5684 351 38 , , , 5684 351 39 and and CC 5684 351 40 will will MD 5684 351 41 not not RB 5684 351 42 allow allow VB 5684 351 43 it -PRON- PRP 5684 351 44 to to TO 5684 351 45 be be VB 5684 351 46 indifferent indifferent JJ 5684 351 47 whether whether IN 5684 351 48 a a DT 5684 351 49 man man NN 5684 351 50 eats eat VBZ 5684 351 51 fish fish NN 5684 351 52 or or CC 5684 351 53 flesh flesh NN 5684 351 54 , , , 5684 351 55 drink drink VB 5684 351 56 beer beer NN 5684 351 57 or or CC 5684 351 58 wine wine NN 5684 351 59 , , , 5684 351 60 when when WRB 5684 351 61 both both DT 5684 351 62 agree agree VBP 5684 351 63 with with IN 5684 351 64 him -PRON- PRP 5684 351 65 ; ; : 5684 351 66 a a DT 5684 351 67 micrology micrology NN 5684 351 68 which which WDT 5684 351 69 , , , 5684 351 70 if if IN 5684 351 71 adopted adopt VBN 5684 351 72 into into IN 5684 351 73 the the DT 5684 351 74 doctrine doctrine NN 5684 351 75 of of IN 5684 351 76 virtue virtue NN 5684 351 77 , , , 5684 351 78 would would MD 5684 351 79 make make VB 5684 351 80 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 351 81 rule rule NN 5684 351 82 a a DT 5684 351 83 tyranny tyranny NN 5684 351 84 . . . 5684 352 1 REMARK REMARK NNP 5684 352 2 { { -LRB- 5684 352 3 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 5684 352 4 ^paragraph ^paragraph NNP 5684 352 5 210 210 CD 5684 352 6 } } -RRB- 5684 352 7 Virtue Virtue NNP 5684 352 8 is be VBZ 5684 352 9 always always RB 5684 352 10 in in IN 5684 352 11 progress progress NN 5684 352 12 , , , 5684 352 13 and and CC 5684 352 14 yet yet RB 5684 352 15 always always RB 5684 352 16 begins begin VBZ 5684 352 17 from from IN 5684 352 18 the the DT 5684 352 19 beginning beginning NN 5684 352 20 . . . 5684 353 1 The the DT 5684 353 2 former former JJ 5684 353 3 follows follow VBZ 5684 353 4 from from IN 5684 353 5 the the DT 5684 353 6 fact fact NN 5684 353 7 that that IN 5684 353 8 , , , 5684 353 9 objectively objectively RB 5684 353 10 considered consider VBN 5684 353 11 , , , 5684 353 12 it -PRON- PRP 5684 353 13 is be VBZ 5684 353 14 an an DT 5684 353 15 ideal ideal JJ 5684 353 16 and and CC 5684 353 17 unattainable unattainable JJ 5684 353 18 , , , 5684 353 19 and and CC 5684 353 20 yet yet RB 5684 353 21 it -PRON- PRP 5684 353 22 is be VBZ 5684 353 23 a a DT 5684 353 24 duty duty NN 5684 353 25 constantly constantly RB 5684 353 26 to to TO 5684 353 27 approximate approximate VB 5684 353 28 to to IN 5684 353 29 it -PRON- PRP 5684 353 30 . . . 5684 354 1 The the DT 5684 354 2 second second JJ 5684 354 3 is be VBZ 5684 354 4 founded found VBN 5684 354 5 subjectively subjectively RB 5684 354 6 on on IN 5684 354 7 the the DT 5684 354 8 nature nature NN 5684 354 9 of of IN 5684 354 10 man man NN 5684 354 11 which which WDT 5684 354 12 is be VBZ 5684 354 13 affected affect VBN 5684 354 14 by by IN 5684 354 15 inclinations inclination NNS 5684 354 16 , , , 5684 354 17 under under IN 5684 354 18 the the DT 5684 354 19 influence influence NN 5684 354 20 of of IN 5684 354 21 which which WDT 5684 354 22 virtue virtue NN 5684 354 23 , , , 5684 354 24 with with IN 5684 354 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 354 26 maxims maxim NNS 5684 354 27 adopted adopt VBN 5684 354 28 once once RB 5684 354 29 for for IN 5684 354 30 all all DT 5684 354 31 , , , 5684 354 32 can can MD 5684 354 33 never never RB 5684 354 34 settle settle VB 5684 354 35 in in IN 5684 354 36 a a DT 5684 354 37 position position NN 5684 354 38 of of IN 5684 354 39 rest rest NN 5684 354 40 ; ; : 5684 354 41 but but CC 5684 354 42 , , , 5684 354 43 if if IN 5684 354 44 it -PRON- PRP 5684 354 45 is be VBZ 5684 354 46 not not RB 5684 354 47 rising rise VBG 5684 354 48 , , , 5684 354 49 inevitably inevitably RB 5684 354 50 falls fall VBZ 5684 354 51 ; ; : 5684 354 52 because because IN 5684 354 53 moral moral JJ 5684 354 54 maxims maxim NNS 5684 354 55 can can MD 5684 354 56 not not RB 5684 354 57 , , , 5684 354 58 like like UH 5684 354 59 technical technical JJ 5684 354 60 , , , 5684 354 61 be be VB 5684 354 62 based base VBN 5684 354 63 on on IN 5684 354 64 custom custom NN 5684 354 65 ( ( -LRB- 5684 354 66 for for IN 5684 354 67 this this DT 5684 354 68 belongs belong VBZ 5684 354 69 to to IN 5684 354 70 the the DT 5684 354 71 physical physical JJ 5684 354 72 character character NN 5684 354 73 of of IN 5684 354 74 the the DT 5684 354 75 determination determination NN 5684 354 76 of of IN 5684 354 77 will will NN 5684 354 78 ) ) -RRB- 5684 354 79 ; ; : 5684 354 80 but but CC 5684 354 81 even even RB 5684 354 82 if if IN 5684 354 83 the the DT 5684 354 84 practice practice NN 5684 354 85 of of IN 5684 354 86 them -PRON- PRP 5684 354 87 become become VBP 5684 354 88 a a DT 5684 354 89 custom custom NN 5684 354 90 , , , 5684 354 91 the the DT 5684 354 92 agent agent NN 5684 354 93 would would MD 5684 354 94 thereby thereby RB 5684 354 95 lose lose VB 5684 354 96 the the DT 5684 354 97 freedom freedom NN 5684 354 98 in in IN 5684 354 99 the the DT 5684 354 100 choice choice NN 5684 354 101 of of IN 5684 354 102 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 354 103 maxims maxim NNS 5684 354 104 , , , 5684 354 105 which which WDT 5684 354 106 freedom freedom NN 5684 354 107 is be VBZ 5684 354 108 the the DT 5684 354 109 character character NN 5684 354 110 of of IN 5684 354 111 an an DT 5684 354 112 action action NN 5684 354 113 done do VBN 5684 354 114 from from IN 5684 354 115 duty duty NN 5684 354 116 . . . 5684 355 1 ON_CONSCIENCE on_conscience LS 5684 355 2 ON ON NNP 5684 355 3 CONSCIENCE conscience NN 5684 355 4 The the DT 5684 355 5 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 355 6 of of IN 5684 355 7 an an DT 5684 355 8 internal internal JJ 5684 355 9 tribunal tribunal NN 5684 355 10 in in IN 5684 355 11 man man NN 5684 355 12 ( ( -LRB- 5684 355 13 before before IN 5684 355 14 which which WDT 5684 355 15 " " `` 5684 355 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 355 17 thoughts thought NNS 5684 355 18 accuse accuse VBP 5684 355 19 or or CC 5684 355 20 excuse excuse VB 5684 355 21 one one CD 5684 355 22 another another DT 5684 355 23 " " '' 5684 355 24 ) ) -RRB- 5684 355 25 is be VBZ 5684 355 26 CONSCIENCE conscience NN 5684 355 27 . . . 5684 356 1 Every every DT 5684 356 2 man man NN 5684 356 3 has have VBZ 5684 356 4 a a DT 5684 356 5 conscience conscience NN 5684 356 6 , , , 5684 356 7 and and CC 5684 356 8 finds find VBZ 5684 356 9 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 356 10 observed observe VBN 5684 356 11 by by IN 5684 356 12 an an DT 5684 356 13 inward inward JJ 5684 356 14 judge judge NN 5684 356 15 which which WDT 5684 356 16 threatens threaten VBZ 5684 356 17 and and CC 5684 356 18 keeps keep VBZ 5684 356 19 him -PRON- PRP 5684 356 20 in in IN 5684 356 21 awe awe NN 5684 356 22 ( ( -LRB- 5684 356 23 reverence reverence NN 5684 356 24 combined combine VBN 5684 356 25 with with IN 5684 356 26 fear fear NN 5684 356 27 ) ) -RRB- 5684 356 28 ; ; : 5684 356 29 and and CC 5684 356 30 this this DT 5684 356 31 power power NN 5684 356 32 which which WDT 5684 356 33 watches watch VBZ 5684 356 34 over over IN 5684 356 35 the the DT 5684 356 36 laws law NNS 5684 356 37 within within IN 5684 356 38 him -PRON- PRP 5684 356 39 is be VBZ 5684 356 40 not not RB 5684 356 41 something something NN 5684 356 42 which which WDT 5684 356 43 he -PRON- PRP 5684 356 44 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 356 45 ( ( -LRB- 5684 356 46 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 5684 356 47 ) ) -RRB- 5684 356 48 makes make VBZ 5684 356 49 , , , 5684 356 50 but but CC 5684 356 51 it -PRON- PRP 5684 356 52 is be VBZ 5684 356 53 incorporated incorporate VBN 5684 356 54 in in IN 5684 356 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 356 56 being being NN 5684 356 57 . . . 5684 357 1 It -PRON- PRP 5684 357 2 follows follow VBZ 5684 357 3 him -PRON- PRP 5684 357 4 like like IN 5684 357 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 357 6 shadow shadow NN 5684 357 7 , , , 5684 357 8 when when WRB 5684 357 9 he -PRON- PRP 5684 357 10 thinks think VBZ 5684 357 11 to to TO 5684 357 12 escape escape VB 5684 357 13 . . . 5684 358 1 He -PRON- PRP 5684 358 2 may may MD 5684 358 3 indeed indeed RB 5684 358 4 stupefy stupefy VB 5684 358 5 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 358 6 with with IN 5684 358 7 pleasures pleasure NNS 5684 358 8 and and CC 5684 358 9 distractions distraction NNS 5684 358 10 , , , 5684 358 11 but but CC 5684 358 12 can can MD 5684 358 13 not not RB 5684 358 14 avoid avoid VB 5684 358 15 now now RB 5684 358 16 and and CC 5684 358 17 then then RB 5684 358 18 coming come VBG 5684 358 19 to to IN 5684 358 20 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 358 21 or or CC 5684 358 22 awaking awake VBG 5684 358 23 , , , 5684 358 24 and and CC 5684 358 25 then then RB 5684 358 26 he -PRON- PRP 5684 358 27 at at IN 5684 358 28 once once RB 5684 358 29 perceives perceive VBZ 5684 358 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 358 31 awful awful JJ 5684 358 32 voice voice NN 5684 358 33 . . . 5684 359 1 In in IN 5684 359 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 359 3 utmost utmost JJ 5684 359 4 depravity depravity NN 5684 359 5 , , , 5684 359 6 he -PRON- PRP 5684 359 7 may may MD 5684 359 8 , , , 5684 359 9 indeed indeed RB 5684 359 10 , , , 5684 359 11 pay pay VB 5684 359 12 no no DT 5684 359 13 attention attention NN 5684 359 14 to to IN 5684 359 15 it -PRON- PRP 5684 359 16 , , , 5684 359 17 but but CC 5684 359 18 he -PRON- PRP 5684 359 19 can can MD 5684 359 20 not not RB 5684 359 21 avoid avoid VB 5684 359 22 hearing hear VBG 5684 359 23 it -PRON- PRP 5684 359 24 . . . 5684 360 1 Now now RB 5684 360 2 this this DT 5684 360 3 original original JJ 5684 360 4 intellectual intellectual NN 5684 360 5 and and CC 5684 360 6 ( ( -LRB- 5684 360 7 as as IN 5684 360 8 a a DT 5684 360 9 conception conception NN 5684 360 10 of of IN 5684 360 11 duty duty NN 5684 360 12 ) ) -RRB- 5684 360 13 moral moral JJ 5684 360 14 capacity capacity NN 5684 360 15 , , , 5684 360 16 called call VBN 5684 360 17 conscience conscience NN 5684 360 18 , , , 5684 360 19 has have VBZ 5684 360 20 this this DT 5684 360 21 peculiarity peculiarity NN 5684 360 22 in in IN 5684 360 23 it -PRON- PRP 5684 360 24 , , , 5684 360 25 that that IN 5684 360 26 although although IN 5684 360 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 5684 360 28 business business NN 5684 360 29 is be VBZ 5684 360 30 a a DT 5684 360 31 business business NN 5684 360 32 of of IN 5684 360 33 man man NN 5684 360 34 with with IN 5684 360 35 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 360 36 , , , 5684 360 37 yet yet CC 5684 360 38 he -PRON- PRP 5684 360 39 finds find VBZ 5684 360 40 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 360 41 compelled compel VBN 5684 360 42 by by IN 5684 360 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 360 44 reason reason NN 5684 360 45 to to TO 5684 360 46 transact transact VB 5684 360 47 it -PRON- PRP 5684 360 48 as as IN 5684 360 49 if if IN 5684 360 50 at at IN 5684 360 51 the the DT 5684 360 52 command command NN 5684 360 53 of of IN 5684 360 54 another another DT 5684 360 55 person person NN 5684 360 56 . . . 5684 361 1 For for IN 5684 361 2 the the DT 5684 361 3 transaction transaction NN 5684 361 4 here here RB 5684 361 5 is be VBZ 5684 361 6 the the DT 5684 361 7 conduct conduct NN 5684 361 8 of of IN 5684 361 9 a a DT 5684 361 10 trial trial NN 5684 361 11 ( ( -LRB- 5684 361 12 causa causa JJ 5684 361 13 ) ) -RRB- 5684 361 14 before before IN 5684 361 15 a a DT 5684 361 16 tribunal tribunal NN 5684 361 17 . . . 5684 362 1 But but CC 5684 362 2 that that IN 5684 362 3 he -PRON- PRP 5684 362 4 who who WP 5684 362 5 is be VBZ 5684 362 6 accused accuse VBN 5684 362 7 by by IN 5684 362 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 362 9 conscience conscience NN 5684 362 10 should should MD 5684 362 11 be be VB 5684 362 12 conceived conceive VBN 5684 362 13 as as IN 5684 362 14 one one CD 5684 362 15 and and CC 5684 362 16 the the DT 5684 362 17 same same JJ 5684 362 18 person person NN 5684 362 19 with with IN 5684 362 20 the the DT 5684 362 21 judge judge NN 5684 362 22 is be VBZ 5684 362 23 an an DT 5684 362 24 absurd absurd JJ 5684 362 25 conception conception NN 5684 362 26 of of IN 5684 362 27 a a DT 5684 362 28 judicial judicial JJ 5684 362 29 court court NN 5684 362 30 ; ; : 5684 362 31 for for IN 5684 362 32 then then RB 5684 362 33 the the DT 5684 362 34 complainant complainant NN 5684 362 35 would would MD 5684 362 36 always always RB 5684 362 37 lose lose VB 5684 362 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 362 39 case case NN 5684 362 40 . . . 5684 363 1 Therefore therefore RB 5684 363 2 , , , 5684 363 3 in in IN 5684 363 4 all all DT 5684 363 5 duties duty NNS 5684 363 6 the the DT 5684 363 7 conscience conscience NN 5684 363 8 of of IN 5684 363 9 the the DT 5684 363 10 man man NN 5684 363 11 must must MD 5684 363 12 regard regard VB 5684 363 13 another another DT 5684 363 14 than than IN 5684 363 15 himself -PRON- PRP 5684 363 16 as as IN 5684 363 17 the the DT 5684 363 18 judge judge NN 5684 363 19 of of IN 5684 363 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 363 21 actions action NNS 5684 363 22 , , , 5684 363 23 if if IN 5684 363 24 it -PRON- PRP 5684 363 25 is be VBZ 5684 363 26 to to TO 5684 363 27 avoid avoid VB 5684 363 28 self self NN 5684 363 29 - - HYPH 5684 363 30 contradiction contradiction NN 5684 363 31 . . . 5684 364 1 Now now RB 5684 364 2 this this DT 5684 364 3 other other JJ 5684 364 4 may may MD 5684 364 5 be be VB 5684 364 6 an an DT 5684 364 7 actual actual JJ 5684 364 8 or or CC 5684 364 9 a a DT 5684 364 10 merely merely RB 5684 364 11 ideal ideal JJ 5684 364 12 person person NN 5684 364 13 which which WDT 5684 364 14 reason reason NN 5684 364 15 frames frame VBZ 5684 364 16 to to IN 5684 364 17 itself -PRON- PRP 5684 364 18 . . . 5684 365 1 Such such PDT 5684 365 2 an an DT 5684 365 3 idealized idealized JJ 5684 365 4 person person NN 5684 365 5 ( ( -LRB- 5684 365 6 the the DT 5684 365 7 authorized authorized JJ 5684 365 8 judge judge NN 5684 365 9 of of IN 5684 365 10 conscience conscience NN 5684 365 11 ) ) -RRB- 5684 365 12 must must MD 5684 365 13 be be VB 5684 365 14 one one CD 5684 365 15 who who WP 5684 365 16 knows know VBZ 5684 365 17 the the DT 5684 365 18 heart heart NN 5684 365 19 ; ; : 5684 365 20 for for IN 5684 365 21 the the DT 5684 365 22 tribunal tribunal NN 5684 365 23 is be VBZ 5684 365 24 set set VBN 5684 365 25 up up RP 5684 365 26 in in IN 5684 365 27 the the DT 5684 365 28 inward inward JJ 5684 365 29 part part NN 5684 365 30 of of IN 5684 365 31 man man NN 5684 365 32 ; ; : 5684 365 33 at at IN 5684 365 34 the the DT 5684 365 35 same same JJ 5684 365 36 time time NN 5684 365 37 he -PRON- PRP 5684 365 38 must must MD 5684 365 39 also also RB 5684 365 40 be be VB 5684 365 41 all all RB 5684 365 42 - - HYPH 5684 365 43 obliging obliging JJ 5684 365 44 , , , 5684 365 45 that that RB 5684 365 46 is is RB 5684 365 47 , , , 5684 365 48 must must MD 5684 365 49 be be VB 5684 365 50 or or CC 5684 365 51 be be VB 5684 365 52 conceived conceive VBN 5684 365 53 as as IN 5684 365 54 a a DT 5684 365 55 person person NN 5684 365 56 in in IN 5684 365 57 respect respect NN 5684 365 58 of of IN 5684 365 59 whom whom WP 5684 365 60 all all DT 5684 365 61 duties duty NNS 5684 365 62 are be VBP 5684 365 63 to to TO 5684 365 64 be be VB 5684 365 65 regarded regard VBN 5684 365 66 as as IN 5684 365 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 365 68 commands command NNS 5684 365 69 ; ; : 5684 365 70 since since IN 5684 365 71 conscience conscience NN 5684 365 72 is be VBZ 5684 365 73 the the DT 5684 365 74 inward inward JJ 5684 365 75 judge judge NN 5684 365 76 of of IN 5684 365 77 all all DT 5684 365 78 free free JJ 5684 365 79 actions action NNS 5684 365 80 . . . 5684 366 1 Now now RB 5684 366 2 , , , 5684 366 3 since since IN 5684 366 4 such such PDT 5684 366 5 a a DT 5684 366 6 moral moral JJ 5684 366 7 being being NN 5684 366 8 must must MD 5684 366 9 at at IN 5684 366 10 the the DT 5684 366 11 same same JJ 5684 366 12 time time NN 5684 366 13 possess possess VBP 5684 366 14 all all DT 5684 366 15 power power NN 5684 366 16 ( ( -LRB- 5684 366 17 in in IN 5684 366 18 heaven heaven NNP 5684 366 19 and and CC 5684 366 20 earth earth NN 5684 366 21 ) ) -RRB- 5684 366 22 , , , 5684 366 23 since since IN 5684 366 24 otherwise otherwise RB 5684 366 25 he -PRON- PRP 5684 366 26 could could MD 5684 366 27 not not RB 5684 366 28 give give VB 5684 366 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 5684 366 30 commands command NNS 5684 366 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 5684 366 32 proper proper JJ 5684 366 33 effect effect NN 5684 366 34 ( ( -LRB- 5684 366 35 which which WDT 5684 366 36 the the DT 5684 366 37 office office NN 5684 366 38 of of IN 5684 366 39 judge judge NNP 5684 366 40 necessarily necessarily RB 5684 366 41 requires require VBZ 5684 366 42 ) ) -RRB- 5684 366 43 , , , 5684 366 44 and and CC 5684 366 45 since since IN 5684 366 46 such such PDT 5684 366 47 a a DT 5684 366 48 moral moral JJ 5684 366 49 being be VBG 5684 366 50 possessing possess VBG 5684 366 51 power power NN 5684 366 52 over over IN 5684 366 53 all all DT 5684 366 54 is be VBZ 5684 366 55 called call VBN 5684 366 56 GOD GOD NNP 5684 366 57 , , , 5684 366 58 hence hence RB 5684 366 59 conscience conscience NN 5684 366 60 must must MD 5684 366 61 be be VB 5684 366 62 conceived conceive VBN 5684 366 63 as as IN 5684 366 64 the the DT 5684 366 65 subjective subjective JJ 5684 366 66 principle principle NN 5684 366 67 of of IN 5684 366 68 a a DT 5684 366 69 responsibility responsibility NN 5684 366 70 for for IN 5684 366 71 one one NN 5684 366 72 's 's POS 5684 366 73 deeds deed NNS 5684 366 74 before before IN 5684 366 75 God God NNP 5684 366 76 ; ; : 5684 366 77 nay nay NNP 5684 366 78 , , , 5684 366 79 this this DT 5684 366 80 latter latter JJ 5684 366 81 concept concept NN 5684 366 82 is be VBZ 5684 366 83 contained contain VBN 5684 366 84 ( ( -LRB- 5684 366 85 though though IN 5684 366 86 it -PRON- PRP 5684 366 87 be be VB 5684 366 88 only only RB 5684 366 89 obscurely obscurely JJ 5684 366 90 ) ) -RRB- 5684 366 91 in in IN 5684 366 92 every every DT 5684 366 93 moral moral JJ 5684 366 94 self self NN 5684 366 95 - - HYPH 5684 366 96 consciousness consciousness NN 5684 366 97 . . . 5684 367 1 THE the DT 5684 367 2 END END NNP