id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
22283	1	1	MIND	mind	NN
22283	1	2	AND	and	CC
22283	1	3	MOTION	MOTION	NNP
22283	1	4	AND	and	CC
22283	1	5	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	1	6	BY	by	IN
22283	1	7	THE	the	DT
22283	1	8	LATE	late	JJ
22283	1	9	GEORGE	GEORGE	NNP
22283	1	10	JOHN	JOHN	NNP
22283	1	11	ROMANES	ROMANES	NNP
22283	1	12	,	,	,
22283	1	13	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
22283	1	14	,	,	,
22283	1	15	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
22283	1	16	,	,	,
22283	1	17	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
22283	2	1	HONORARY	HONORARY	NNP
22283	2	2	FELLOW	FELLOW	NNP
22283	2	3	OF	of	IN
22283	2	4	GONVILLE	GONVILLE	NNP
22283	2	5	AND	and	CC
22283	2	6	CAIUS	CAIUS	NNP
22283	2	7	COLLEGE	COLLEGE	NNPS
22283	2	8	,	,	,
22283	2	9	CAMBRIDGE	CAMBRIDGE	NNP
22283	2	10	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
22283	2	11	LONGMANS	LONGMANS	NNP
22283	2	12	,	,	,
22283	2	13	GREEN	GREEN	NNP
22283	2	14	,	,	,
22283	2	15	AND	and	CC
22283	2	16	CO	CO	NNP
22283	2	17	.	.	NNP
22283	2	18	AND	and	CC
22283	2	19	NEW	NEW	NNP
22283	2	20	YORK	YORK	NNP
22283	2	21	1895	1895	CD
22283	2	22	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
22283	2	23	HORACE	HORACE	NNP
22283	2	24	HART	HART	NNP
22283	2	25	,	,	,
22283	2	26	PRINTER	PRINTER	NNP
22283	2	27	TO	to	IN
22283	2	28	THE	the	DT
22283	2	29	UNIVERSITY	UNIVERSITY	NNP
22283	2	30	WORKS	work	VBN
22283	2	31	BY	by	IN
22283	2	32	_	_	NNP
22283	2	33	GEORGE	GEORGE	NNP
22283	2	34	JOHN	JOHN	NNP
22283	2	35	ROMANES	ROMANES	NNP
22283	2	36	,	,	,
22283	2	37	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
22283	2	38	,	,	,
22283	2	39	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
22283	2	40	,	,	,
22283	2	41	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
22283	2	42	_	_	NNP
22283	2	43	=	=	SYM
22283	2	44	DARWIN	DARWIN	NNP
22283	2	45	,	,	,
22283	2	46	AND	and	CC
22283	2	47	AFTER	AFTER	NNP
22283	2	48	DARWIN=	DARWIN=	NNP
22283	2	49	:	:	:
22283	2	50	an	an	DT
22283	2	51	Exposition	Exposition	NNP
22283	2	52	of	of	IN
22283	2	53	the	the	DT
22283	2	54	Darwinian	Darwinian	NNP
22283	2	55	Theory	Theory	NNP
22283	2	56	,	,	,
22283	2	57	and	and	CC
22283	2	58	a	a	DT
22283	2	59	Discussion	Discussion	NNP
22283	2	60	on	on	IN
22283	2	61	Post	post	JJ
22283	2	62	-	-	JJ
22283	2	63	Darwinian	darwinian	JJ
22283	2	64	Questions	Questions	NNPS
22283	2	65	.	.	.
22283	3	1	PART	PART	NNP
22283	3	2	I.	I.	NNP
22283	4	1	THE	the	DT
22283	4	2	DARWINIAN	DARWINIAN	NNP
22283	4	3	THEORY	THEORY	NNP
22283	4	4	.	.	.
22283	5	1	With	with	IN
22283	5	2	Portrait	Portrait	NNP
22283	5	3	of	of	IN
22283	5	4	Darwin	Darwin	NNP
22283	5	5	and	and	CC
22283	5	6	125	125	CD
22283	5	7	Illustrations	Illustrations	NNPS
22283	5	8	.	.	.
22283	6	1	_	_	NNP
22283	6	2	Crown	Crown	NNP
22283	6	3	8vo	8vo	NNP
22283	6	4	_	_	NNP
22283	6	5	,	,	,
22283	6	6	10s	10s	NNP
22283	6	7	.	.	.
22283	7	1	6d	6d	NNP
22283	7	2	.	.	.
22283	8	1	PART	PART	NNP
22283	8	2	II	ii	CD
22283	8	3	.	.	.
22283	9	1	POST	post	JJ
22283	9	2	-	-	HYPH
22283	9	3	DARWINIAN	darwinian	JJ
22283	9	4	QUESTIONS	questions	NN
22283	9	5	:	:	:
22283	9	6	HEREDITY	heredity	NN
22283	9	7	AND	and	CC
22283	9	8	UTILITY	UTILITY	NNP
22283	9	9	.	.	.
22283	10	1	_	_	NNP
22283	10	2	Crown	Crown	NNP
22283	10	3	8vo	8vo	NNP
22283	10	4	_	_	NNP
22283	10	5	.	.	.
22283	11	1	=	=	NFP
22283	11	2	AN	an	DT
22283	11	3	EXAMINATION	examination	NN
22283	11	4	OF	of	IN
22283	11	5	WEISMANNISM.=	WEISMANNISM.=	:
22283	11	6	_	_	NNP
22283	11	7	Crown	Crown	NNP
22283	11	8	8vo	8vo	NNP
22283	11	9	_	_	NNP
22283	11	10	,	,	,
22283	11	11	6s	6s	NNP
22283	11	12	.	.	.
22283	12	1	=	=	NFP
22283	12	2	MIND	mind	NN
22283	12	3	AND	and	CC
22283	12	4	MOTION	MOTION	NNP
22283	12	5	AND	and	CC
22283	12	6	MONISM.=	MONISM.=	NNP
22283	12	7	_	_	NNP
22283	12	8	Crown	Crown	NNP
22283	12	9	8vo	8vo	NNP
22283	12	10	_	_	NNP
22283	12	11	.	.	.
22283	13	1	=	=	NFP
22283	13	2	THOUGHTS	THOUGHTS	NNP
22283	13	3	ON	on	IN
22283	13	4	RELIGION=.	RELIGION=.	NNP
22283	14	1	Edited	edit	VBN
22283	14	2	,	,	,
22283	14	3	with	with	IN
22283	14	4	a	a	DT
22283	14	5	Preface	Preface	NNP
22283	14	6	,	,	,
22283	14	7	by	by	IN
22283	14	8	CHARLES	CHARLES	NNP
22283	14	9	GORE	GORE	NNP
22283	14	10	,	,	,
22283	14	11	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
22283	14	12	,	,	,
22283	14	13	Canon	Canon	NNP
22283	14	14	of	of	IN
22283	14	15	Westminster	Westminster	NNP
22283	14	16	.	.	.
22283	15	1	_	_	NNP
22283	15	2	Crown	Crown	NNP
22283	15	3	8vo	8vo	NNP
22283	15	4	_	_	NNP
22283	15	5	,	,	,
22283	15	6	4s	4s	CD
22283	15	7	.	.	.
22283	16	1	6d	6d	NNP
22283	16	2	.	.	.
22283	17	1	London	London	NNP
22283	17	2	LONGMANS	LONGMANS	NNP
22283	17	3	,	,	,
22283	17	4	GREEN	GREEN	NNP
22283	17	5	&	&	CC
22283	17	6	CO	CO	NNP
22283	17	7	.	.	.
22283	18	1	PREFACE	preface	NN
22283	18	2	Of	of	IN
22283	18	3	the	the	DT
22283	18	4	contents	content	NNS
22283	18	5	of	of	IN
22283	18	6	this	this	DT
22283	18	7	little	little	JJ
22283	18	8	volume	volume	NN
22283	18	9	the	the	DT
22283	18	10	section	section	NN
22283	18	11	on	on	IN
22283	18	12	_	_	NNP
22283	18	13	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	18	14	and	and	CC
22283	18	15	Motion	Motion	NNP
22283	18	16	_	_	NNP
22283	18	17	which	which	WDT
22283	18	18	forms	form	VBZ
22283	18	19	,	,	,
22283	18	20	in	in	IN
22283	18	21	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	18	22	with	with	IN
22283	18	23	a	a	DT
22283	18	24	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	18	25	of	of	IN
22283	18	26	the	the	DT
22283	18	27	author	author	NN
22283	18	28	's	's	POS
22283	18	29	,	,	,
22283	18	30	a	a	DT
22283	18	31	general	general	JJ
22283	18	32	introduction	introduction	NN
22283	18	33	,	,	,
22283	18	34	was	be	VBD
22283	18	35	delivered	deliver	VBN
22283	18	36	at	at	IN
22283	18	37	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
22283	18	38	as	as	IN
22283	18	39	the	the	DT
22283	18	40	Rede	Rede	NNP
22283	18	41	Lecture	Lecture	NNP
22283	18	42	in	in	IN
22283	18	43	1885	1885	CD
22283	18	44	,	,	,
22283	18	45	and	and	CC
22283	18	46	was	be	VBD
22283	18	47	printed	print	VBN
22283	18	48	in	in	IN
22283	18	49	the	the	DT
22283	18	50	_	_	NNP
22283	18	51	Contemporary	Contemporary	NNP
22283	18	52	Review	Review	NNP
22283	18	53	_	_	NNP
22283	18	54	for	for	IN
22283	18	55	June	June	NNP
22283	18	56	in	in	IN
22283	18	57	that	that	DT
22283	18	58	year	year	NN
22283	18	59	.	.	.
22283	19	1	The	the	DT
22283	19	2	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	19	3	on	on	IN
22283	19	4	The	the	DT
22283	19	5	_	_	NNP
22283	19	6	World	World	NNP
22283	19	7	as	as	IN
22283	19	8	an	an	DT
22283	19	9	Eject	Eject	NNP
22283	19	10	_	_	NNP
22283	19	11	was	be	VBD
22283	19	12	published	publish	VBN
22283	19	13	,	,	,
22283	19	14	almost	almost	RB
22283	19	15	as	as	IN
22283	19	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	19	17	now	now	RB
22283	19	18	stands	stand	VBZ
22283	19	19	,	,	,
22283	19	20	in	in	IN
22283	19	21	the	the	DT
22283	19	22	_	_	NNP
22283	19	23	Contemporary	Contemporary	NNP
22283	19	24	Review	Review	NNP
22283	19	25	_	_	NNP
22283	19	26	for	for	IN
22283	19	27	July	July	NNP
22283	19	28	,	,	,
22283	19	29	1886	1886	CD
22283	19	30	.	.	.
22283	20	1	A	a	DT
22283	20	2	paper	paper	NN
22283	20	3	on	on	IN
22283	20	4	_	_	NNP
22283	20	5	The	the	DT
22283	20	6	Fallacy	Fallacy	NNP
22283	20	7	of	of	IN
22283	20	8	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	20	9	_	_	NNP
22283	20	10	,	,	,
22283	20	11	of	of	IN
22283	20	12	which	which	WDT
22283	20	13	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	20	14	Romanes	Romanes	NNP
22283	20	15	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
22283	20	16	the	the	DT
22283	20	17	more	more	RBR
22283	20	18	important	important	JJ
22283	20	19	parts	part	NNS
22283	20	20	in	in	IN
22283	20	21	the	the	DT
22283	20	22	Essay	Essay	NNP
22283	20	23	on	on	IN
22283	20	24	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	20	25	,	,	,
22283	20	26	was	be	VBD
22283	20	27	contributed	contribute	VBN
22283	20	28	to	to	IN
22283	20	29	the	the	DT
22283	20	30	_	_	NNP
22283	20	31	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
22283	20	32	Century	Century	NNP
22283	20	33	_	_	NNP
22283	20	34	for	for	IN
22283	20	35	December	December	NNP
22283	20	36	,	,	,
22283	20	37	1882	1882	CD
22283	20	38	.	.	.
22283	21	1	The	the	DT
22283	21	2	rest	rest	NN
22283	21	3	was	be	VBD
22283	21	4	left	leave	VBN
22283	21	5	in	in	IN
22283	21	6	MS	MS	NNP
22283	21	7	.	.	.
22283	21	8	and	and	CC
22283	21	9	was	be	VBD
22283	21	10	probably	probably	RB
22283	21	11	written	write	VBN
22283	21	12	in	in	IN
22283	21	13	1889	1889	CD
22283	21	14	or	or	CC
22283	21	15	1890	1890	CD
22283	21	16	.	.	.
22283	22	1	The	the	DT
22283	22	2	subjects	subject	NNS
22283	22	3	here	here	RB
22283	22	4	discussed	discuss	VBN
22283	22	5	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	22	6	occupied	occupy	VBD
22283	22	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	22	8	Romanes	Romanes	NNP
22283	22	9	'	'	POS
22283	22	10	keen	keen	JJ
22283	22	11	and	and	CC
22283	22	12	versatile	versatile	JJ
22283	22	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	22	14	.	.	.
22283	23	1	Had	have	VBD
22283	23	2	not	not	RB
22283	23	3	the	the	DT
22283	23	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	23	5	of	of	IN
22283	23	6	death	death	NN
22283	23	7	fallen	fall	VBN
22283	23	8	upon	upon	IN
22283	23	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	23	10	while	while	IN
22283	23	11	so	so	RB
22283	23	12	much	much	JJ
22283	23	13	of	of	IN
22283	23	14	the	the	DT
22283	23	15	ripening	ripening	JJ
22283	23	16	grain	grain	NN
22283	23	17	of	of	IN
22283	23	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	23	19	thought	thought	NN
22283	23	20	still	still	RB
22283	23	21	remained	remain	VBD
22283	23	22	to	to	TO
22283	23	23	be	be	VB
22283	23	24	finally	finally	RB
22283	23	25	garnered	garner	VBN
22283	23	26	,	,	,
22283	23	27	some	some	DT
22283	23	28	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	23	29	and	and	CC
22283	23	30	extensions	extension	NNS
22283	23	31	of	of	IN
22283	23	32	the	the	DT
22283	23	33	views	view	NNS
22283	23	34	set	set	VBN
22283	23	35	forth	forth	RP
22283	23	36	in	in	IN
22283	23	37	the	the	DT
22283	23	38	Essay	Essay	NNP
22283	23	39	on	on	IN
22283	23	40	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	23	41	would	would	MD
22283	23	42	probably	probably	RB
22283	23	43	have	have	VB
22283	23	44	been	be	VBN
22283	23	45	introduced	introduce	VBN
22283	23	46	.	.	.
22283	24	1	Attention	attention	NN
22283	24	2	may	may	MD
22283	24	3	be	be	VB
22283	24	4	drawn	draw	VBN
22283	24	5	,	,	,
22283	24	6	for	for	IN
22283	24	7	example	example	NN
22283	24	8	,	,	,
22283	24	9	to	to	IN
22283	24	10	the	the	DT
22283	24	11	sentence	sentence	NN
22283	24	12	on	on	IN
22283	24	13	p.	p.	NN
22283	24	14	139	139	CD
22283	24	15	,	,	,
22283	24	16	italicized	italicize	VBN
22283	24	17	by	by	IN
22283	24	18	the	the	DT
22283	24	19	author	author	NN
22283	24	20	himself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	24	21	,	,	,
22283	24	22	in	in	IN
22283	24	23	which	which	WDT
22283	24	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	24	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	24	26	contended	contend	VBN
22283	24	27	that	that	IN
22283	24	28	the	the	DT
22283	24	29	will	will	NN
22283	24	30	as	as	IN
22283	24	31	agent	agent	NN
22283	24	32	_	_	NNP
22283	24	33	must	must	MD
22283	24	34	be	be	VB
22283	24	35	identified	identify	VBN
22283	24	36	with	with	IN
22283	24	37	the	the	DT
22283	24	38	principle	principle	NN
22283	24	39	of	of	IN
22283	24	40	Causality	Causality	NNP
22283	24	41	_	_	NNP
22283	24	42	.	.	.
22283	25	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	25	2	have	have	VBP
22283	25	3	reason	reason	NN
22283	25	4	to	to	TO
22283	25	5	believe	believe	VB
22283	25	6	that	that	IN
22283	25	7	the	the	DT
22283	25	8	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	25	9	on	on	IN
22283	25	10	_	_	NNP
22283	25	11	The	the	DT
22283	25	12	World	World	NNP
22283	25	13	as	as	IN
22283	25	14	an	an	DT
22283	25	15	Eject	Eject	NNP
22283	25	16	_	_	NNP
22283	25	17	would	would	MD
22283	25	18	,	,	,
22283	25	19	in	in	IN
22283	25	20	a	a	DT
22283	25	21	final	final	JJ
22283	25	22	revision	revision	NN
22283	25	23	of	of	IN
22283	25	24	the	the	DT
22283	25	25	Essay	Essay	NNP
22283	25	26	as	as	IN
22283	25	27	a	a	DT
22283	25	28	whole	whole	NN
22283	25	29	,	,	,
22283	25	30	have	have	VBP
22283	25	31	been	be	VBN
22283	25	32	modified	modify	VBN
22283	25	33	so	so	IN
22283	25	34	as	as	IN
22283	25	35	to	to	TO
22283	25	36	lay	lay	VB
22283	25	37	stress	stress	NN
22283	25	38	on	on	IN
22283	25	39	this	this	DT
22283	25	40	identification	identification	NN
22283	25	41	of	of	IN
22283	25	42	the	the	DT
22283	25	43	human	human	NN
22283	25	44	will	will	NN
22283	25	45	with	with	IN
22283	25	46	the	the	DT
22283	25	47	principle	principle	NN
22283	25	48	of	of	IN
22283	25	49	Causality	Causality	NNP
22283	25	50	in	in	IN
22283	25	51	the	the	DT
22283	25	52	world	world	NN
22283	25	53	at	at	IN
22283	25	54	large	large	JJ
22283	25	55	--	--	:
22283	25	56	a	a	DT
22283	25	57	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	25	58	the	the	DT
22283	25	59	relation	relation	NN
22283	25	60	of	of	IN
22283	25	61	which	which	WDT
22283	25	62	to	to	IN
22283	25	63	the	the	DT
22283	25	64	teachings	teaching	NNS
22283	25	65	of	of	IN
22283	25	66	Schopenhauer	Schopenhauer	NNP
22283	25	67	will	will	MD
22283	25	68	be	be	VB
22283	25	69	evident	evident	JJ
22283	25	70	to	to	IN
22283	25	71	students	student	NNS
22283	25	72	of	of	IN
22283	25	73	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	25	74	.	.	.
22283	26	1	But	but	CC
22283	26	2	the	the	DT
22283	26	3	hand	hand	NN
22283	26	4	of	of	IN
22283	26	5	death	death	NN
22283	26	6	closed	close	VBN
22283	26	7	on	on	IN
22283	26	8	the	the	DT
22283	26	9	thinker	thinker	NN
22283	26	10	ere	ere	VBD
22283	26	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	26	12	thought	thought	NN
22283	26	13	had	have	VBD
22283	26	14	received	receive	VBN
22283	26	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	26	16	full	full	JJ
22283	26	17	and	and	CC
22283	26	18	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	26	19	expression	expression	NN
22283	26	20	.	.	.
22283	27	1	When	when	WRB
22283	27	2	in	in	IN
22283	27	3	July	July	NNP
22283	27	4	,	,	,
22283	27	5	1893	1893	CD
22283	27	6	,	,	,
22283	27	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	27	8	received	receive	VBD
22283	27	9	from	from	IN
22283	27	10	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	27	11	Romanes	Romanes	NNP
22283	27	12	instructions	instruction	NNS
22283	27	13	with	with	IN
22283	27	14	regard	regard	NN
22283	27	15	to	to	IN
22283	27	16	the	the	DT
22283	27	17	publication	publication	NN
22283	27	18	of	of	IN
22283	27	19	that	that	DT
22283	27	20	which	which	WDT
22283	27	21	now	now	RB
22283	27	22	goes	go	VBZ
22283	27	23	forth	forth	RB
22283	27	24	to	to	IN
22283	27	25	the	the	DT
22283	27	26	world	world	NN
22283	27	27	in	in	IN
22283	27	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	27	29	name	name	NN
22283	27	30	,	,	,
22283	27	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	27	32	end	end	NN
22283	27	33	seemed	seem	VBD
22283	27	34	very	very	RB
22283	27	35	near	near	RB
22283	27	36	;	;	:
22283	27	37	and	and	CC
22283	27	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	27	39	said	say	VBD
22283	27	40	with	with	IN
22283	27	41	faltering	falter	VBG
22283	27	42	voice	voice	NN
22283	27	43	,	,	,
22283	27	44	in	in	IN
22283	27	45	tones	tone	NNS
22283	27	46	the	the	DT
22283	27	47	pathos	pathos	NN
22283	27	48	of	of	IN
22283	27	49	which	which	WDT
22283	27	50	lingers	linger	VBZ
22283	27	51	with	with	IN
22283	27	52	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	27	53	still	still	RB
22283	27	54	,	,	,
22283	27	55	that	that	IN
22283	27	56	this	this	DT
22283	27	57	and	and	CC
22283	27	58	much	much	JJ
22283	27	59	besides	besides	IN
22283	27	60	must	must	MD
22283	27	61	,	,	,
22283	27	62	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	27	63	feared	fear	VBD
22283	27	64	,	,	,
22283	27	65	be	be	VB
22283	27	66	left	leave	VBN
22283	27	67	unfinished	unfinished	JJ
22283	27	68	.	.	.
22283	28	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	28	2	suggested	suggest	VBD
22283	28	3	that	that	IN
22283	28	4	perhaps	perhaps	RB
22283	28	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	28	6	might	may	MD
22283	28	7	revise	revise	VB
22283	28	8	the	the	DT
22283	28	9	parts	part	NNS
22283	28	10	in	in	IN
22283	28	11	the	the	DT
22283	28	12	light	light	NN
22283	28	13	of	of	IN
22283	28	14	the	the	DT
22283	28	15	whole	whole	NN
22283	28	16	.	.	.
22283	29	1	But	but	CC
22283	29	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	3	have	have	VBP
22283	29	4	thought	think	VBN
22283	29	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	6	best	well	RBS
22283	29	7	to	to	TO
22283	29	8	leave	leave	VB
22283	29	9	what	what	WP
22283	29	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	11	had	have	VBD
22283	29	12	written	write	VBN
22283	29	13	as	as	IN
22283	29	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	15	wrote	write	VBD
22283	29	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	17	,	,	,
22283	29	18	save	save	VB
22283	29	19	for	for	IN
22283	29	20	quite	quite	RB
22283	29	21	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
22283	29	22	emendations	emendation	NNS
22283	29	23	,	,	,
22283	29	24	lest	lest	IN
22283	29	25	in	in	IN
22283	29	26	revising	revise	VBG
22283	29	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	28	should	should	MD
22283	29	29	cast	cast	VB
22283	29	30	over	over	IN
22283	29	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	29	32	the	the	DT
22283	29	33	shadow	shadow	NN
22283	29	34	of	of	IN
22283	29	35	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	29	36	own	own	JJ
22283	29	37	opinions	opinion	NNS
22283	29	38	.	.	.
22283	30	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	30	2	only	only	RB
22283	30	3	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	30	4	to	to	TO
22283	30	5	add	add	VB
22283	30	6	that	that	IN
22283	30	7	the	the	DT
22283	30	8	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
22283	30	9	reached	reach	VBN
22283	30	10	in	in	IN
22283	30	11	this	this	DT
22283	30	12	Essay	Essay	NNP
22283	30	13	should	should	MD
22283	30	14	be	be	VB
22283	30	15	studied	study	VBN
22283	30	16	in	in	IN
22283	30	17	connection	connection	NN
22283	30	18	with	with	IN
22283	30	19	the	the	DT
22283	30	20	later	later	JJ
22283	30	21	_	_	NNP
22283	30	22	Thoughts	Thoughts	NNPS
22283	30	23	on	on	IN
22283	30	24	Religion	Religion	NNP
22283	30	25	_	_	NNP
22283	30	26	which	which	WDT
22283	30	27	Canon	Canon	NNP
22283	30	28	Gore	Gore	NNP
22283	30	29	has	have	VBZ
22283	30	30	recently	recently	RB
22283	30	31	edited	edit	VBN
22283	30	32	.	.	.
22283	31	1	C.	C.	NNP
22283	31	2	LL	LL	NNP
22283	31	3	.	.	.
22283	32	1	M.	M.	NNP
22283	32	2	BRISTOL	BRISTOL	NNP
22283	32	3	,	,	,
22283	32	4	_	_	NNP
22283	32	5	May	May	NNP
22283	32	6	,	,	,
22283	32	7	1895	1895	CD
22283	32	8	.	.	.
22283	32	9	_	_	NNP
22283	32	10	CONTENTS	CONTENTS	NNP
22283	32	11	PAGE	page	NN
22283	32	12	MIND	MIND	NNS
22283	32	13	AND	and	CC
22283	32	14	MOTION	motion	NN
22283	32	15	1	1	CD
22283	32	16	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	32	17	39	39	CD
22283	32	18	INTRODUCTION	introduction	NN
22283	32	19	41	41	CD
22283	32	20	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
22283	32	21	I.	I.	NNP
22283	32	22	SPIRITUALISM	SPIRITUALISM	NNP
22283	32	23	47	47	CD
22283	32	24	"	"	``
22283	32	25	II	ii	CD
22283	32	26	.	.	.
22283	33	1	MATERIALISM	MATERIALISM	NNP
22283	33	2	55	55	CD
22283	33	3	"	"	``
22283	33	4	III	iii	CD
22283	33	5	.	.	.
22283	34	1	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	34	2	79	79	CD
22283	34	3	"	"	``
22283	34	4	IV	IV	NNP
22283	34	5	.	.	.
22283	35	1	THE	the	DT
22283	35	2	WORLD	WORLD	NNP
22283	35	3	AS	as	IN
22283	35	4	AN	an	DT
22283	35	5	EJECT	EJECT	NNP
22283	35	6	88	88	CD
22283	35	7	"	"	``
22283	35	8	V.	V.	NNP
22283	35	9	THE	THE	NNP
22283	35	10	WILL	WILL	MD
22283	35	11	IN	in	IN
22283	35	12	RELATION	relation	NN
22283	35	13	TO	to	IN
22283	35	14	MATERIALISM	MATERIALISM	NNP
22283	35	15	AND	and	CC
22283	35	16	SPIRITUALISM	SPIRITUALISM	NNP
22283	35	17	119	119	CD
22283	35	18	"	"	``
22283	35	19	VI	VI	NNP
22283	35	20	.	.	.
22283	36	1	THE	the	DT
22283	36	2	WILL	WILL	MD
22283	36	3	IN	in	IN
22283	36	4	RELATION	relation	NN
22283	36	5	TO	to	IN
22283	36	6	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	36	7	129	129	CD
22283	36	8	MIND	MIND	NNS
22283	36	9	AND	and	CC
22283	36	10	MOTION	MOTION	NNP
22283	36	11	[	[	-LRB-
22283	36	12	REDE	REDE	NNP
22283	36	13	LECTURE	LECTURE	NNP
22283	36	14	,	,	,
22283	36	15	1885	1885	CD
22283	36	16	.	.	.
22283	36	17	]	]	-RRB-
22283	37	1	The	the	DT
22283	37	2	earliest	early	JJS
22283	37	3	writer	writer	NN
22283	37	4	who	who	WP
22283	37	5	deserves	deserve	VBZ
22283	37	6	to	to	TO
22283	37	7	be	be	VB
22283	37	8	called	call	VBN
22283	37	9	a	a	DT
22283	37	10	psychologist	psychologist	NN
22283	37	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	37	12	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNPS
22283	37	13	;	;	:
22283	37	14	and	and	CC
22283	37	15	if	if	IN
22283	37	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	37	17	consider	consider	VBP
22283	37	18	the	the	DT
22283	37	19	time	time	NN
22283	37	20	when	when	WRB
22283	37	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	37	22	wrote	write	VBD
22283	37	23	,	,	,
22283	37	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	37	25	can	can	MD
22283	37	26	not	not	RB
22283	37	27	fail	fail	VB
22283	37	28	to	to	TO
22283	37	29	be	be	VB
22283	37	30	surprised	surprised	JJ
22283	37	31	at	at	IN
22283	37	32	what	what	WP
22283	37	33	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	37	34	may	may	MD
22283	37	35	term	term	VB
22283	37	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	37	37	prevision	prevision	NN
22283	37	38	of	of	IN
22283	37	39	the	the	DT
22283	37	40	most	most	RBS
22283	37	41	important	important	JJ
22283	37	42	results	result	NNS
22283	37	43	which	which	WDT
22283	37	44	have	have	VBP
22283	37	45	now	now	RB
22283	37	46	been	be	VBN
22283	37	47	established	establish	VBN
22283	37	48	by	by	IN
22283	37	49	science	science	NN
22283	37	50	.	.	.
22283	38	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	38	2	was	be	VBD
22283	38	3	the	the	DT
22283	38	4	first	first	JJ
22283	38	5	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	38	6	to	to	TO
22283	38	7	sound	sound	VB
22283	38	8	the	the	DT
22283	38	9	note	note	NN
22283	38	10	which	which	WDT
22283	38	11	has	have	VBZ
22283	38	12	ever	ever	RB
22283	38	13	since	since	IN
22283	38	14	constituted	constitute	VBN
22283	38	15	the	the	DT
22283	38	16	bass	bass	NN
22283	38	17	,	,	,
22283	38	18	or	or	CC
22283	38	19	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	38	20	tone	tone	NN
22283	38	21	,	,	,
22283	38	22	of	of	IN
22283	38	23	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	38	24	thought	thought	NN
22283	38	25	.	.	.
22283	39	1	Let	let	VB
22283	39	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	39	3	listen	listen	VB
22283	39	4	to	to	IN
22283	39	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	39	6	through	through	IN
22283	39	7	the	the	DT
22283	39	8	clear	clear	JJ
22283	39	9	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
22283	39	10	of	of	IN
22283	39	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	39	12	own	own	JJ
22283	39	13	language:--	language:--	NN
22283	39	14	'	'	''
22283	39	15	All	all	PDT
22283	39	16	the	the	DT
22283	39	17	qualities	quality	NNS
22283	39	18	called	call	VBN
22283	39	19	sensible	sensible	JJ
22283	39	20	are	be	VBP
22283	39	21	,	,	,
22283	39	22	in	in	IN
22283	39	23	the	the	DT
22283	39	24	object	object	NN
22283	39	25	which	which	WDT
22283	39	26	causeth	causeth	VBP
22283	39	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	39	28	,	,	,
22283	39	29	but	but	CC
22283	39	30	so	so	RB
22283	39	31	many	many	JJ
22283	39	32	motions	motion	NNS
22283	39	33	of	of	IN
22283	39	34	the	the	DT
22283	39	35	matter	matter	NN
22283	39	36	by	by	IN
22283	39	37	which	which	WDT
22283	39	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	39	39	presseth	presseth	VBD
22283	39	40	on	on	IN
22283	39	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	39	42	organs	organ	NNS
22283	39	43	diversely	diversely	RB
22283	39	44	.	.	.
22283	40	1	Neither	neither	CC
22283	40	2	in	in	IN
22283	40	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	40	4	that	that	WDT
22283	40	5	are	be	VBP
22283	40	6	pressed	press	VBN
22283	40	7	are	be	VBP
22283	40	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	40	9	anything	anything	NN
22283	40	10	else	else	RB
22283	40	11	but	but	CC
22283	40	12	divers	diver	VBZ
22283	40	13	motions	motion	NNS
22283	40	14	;	;	,
22283	40	15	for	for	IN
22283	40	16	motion	motion	NNP
22283	40	17	produceth	produceth	NNP
22283	40	18	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	40	19	but	but	IN
22283	40	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	40	21	....	....	.
22283	41	1	The	the	DT
22283	41	2	cause	cause	NN
22283	41	3	of	of	IN
22283	41	4	sense	sense	NN
22283	41	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	41	6	the	the	DT
22283	41	7	external	external	JJ
22283	41	8	body	body	NN
22283	41	9	or	or	CC
22283	41	10	object	object	NN
22283	41	11	,	,	,
22283	41	12	which	which	WDT
22283	41	13	presseth	presseth	VBP
22283	41	14	the	the	DT
22283	41	15	organ	organ	NN
22283	41	16	proper	proper	JJ
22283	41	17	to	to	IN
22283	41	18	each	each	DT
22283	41	19	sense	sense	NN
22283	41	20	,	,	,
22283	41	21	either	either	CC
22283	41	22	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	41	23	,	,	,
22283	41	24	as	as	IN
22283	41	25	in	in	IN
22283	41	26	taste	taste	NN
22283	41	27	and	and	CC
22283	41	28	touch	touch	NN
22283	41	29	,	,	,
22283	41	30	or	or	CC
22283	41	31	mediately	mediately	RB
22283	41	32	,	,	,
22283	41	33	as	as	IN
22283	41	34	in	in	IN
22283	41	35	hearing	hearing	NN
22283	41	36	,	,	,
22283	41	37	seeing	see	VBG
22283	41	38	,	,	,
22283	41	39	and	and	CC
22283	41	40	smelling	smell	VBG
22283	41	41	;	;	:
22283	41	42	which	which	WDT
22283	41	43	pressure	pressure	NN
22283	41	44	,	,	,
22283	41	45	by	by	IN
22283	41	46	the	the	DT
22283	41	47	mediation	mediation	NN
22283	41	48	of	of	IN
22283	41	49	the	the	DT
22283	41	50	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	41	51	,	,	,
22283	41	52	and	and	CC
22283	41	53	other	other	JJ
22283	41	54	strings	string	NNS
22283	41	55	and	and	CC
22283	41	56	membranes	membrane	NNS
22283	41	57	of	of	IN
22283	41	58	the	the	DT
22283	41	59	body	body	NN
22283	41	60	,	,	,
22283	41	61	continued	continue	VBD
22283	41	62	inwards	inward	NNS
22283	41	63	to	to	IN
22283	41	64	the	the	DT
22283	41	65	brain	brain	NN
22283	41	66	and	and	CC
22283	41	67	heart	heart	NN
22283	41	68	,	,	,
22283	41	69	causeth	causeth	NNP
22283	41	70	there	there	RB
22283	41	71	a	a	DT
22283	41	72	resistance	resistance	NN
22283	41	73	,	,	,
22283	41	74	or	or	CC
22283	41	75	counter	counter	NN
22283	41	76	-	-	NN
22283	41	77	pressure	pressure	NN
22283	41	78	,	,	,
22283	41	79	or	or	CC
22283	41	80	endeavour	endeavour	NN
22283	41	81	....	....	NFP
22283	41	82	And	and	CC
22283	41	83	because	because	IN
22283	41	84	_	_	NNP
22283	41	85	going	go	VBG
22283	41	86	_	_	NNP
22283	41	87	,	,	,
22283	41	88	_	_	NNP
22283	41	89	speaking	speak	VBG
22283	41	90	_	_	NNP
22283	41	91	,	,	,
22283	41	92	and	and	CC
22283	41	93	the	the	DT
22283	41	94	like	like	IN
22283	41	95	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	41	96	motions	motion	NNS
22283	41	97	,	,	,
22283	41	98	depend	depend	VBP
22283	41	99	always	always	RB
22283	41	100	upon	upon	IN
22283	41	101	a	a	DT
22283	41	102	precedent	precedent	NN
22283	41	103	thought	thought	NN
22283	41	104	of	of	IN
22283	41	105	_	_	NNP
22283	41	106	whither	whither	NN
22283	41	107	_	_	NNP
22283	41	108	,	,	,
22283	41	109	_	_	NNP
22283	41	110	which	which	WDT
22283	41	111	way	way	NN
22283	41	112	_	_	NNP
22283	41	113	,	,	,
22283	41	114	and	and	CC
22283	41	115	_	_	NNP
22283	41	116	what	what	WP
22283	41	117	_	_	NNP
22283	41	118	;	;	:
22283	41	119	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	41	120	is	be	VBZ
22283	41	121	evident	evident	JJ
22283	41	122	that	that	IN
22283	41	123	the	the	DT
22283	41	124	imagination	imagination	NN
22283	41	125	[	[	-LRB-
22283	41	126	or	or	CC
22283	41	127	idea	idea	NN
22283	41	128	]	]	-RRB-
22283	41	129	is	be	VBZ
22283	41	130	the	the	DT
22283	41	131	first	first	JJ
22283	41	132	internal	internal	JJ
22283	41	133	beginning	beginning	NN
22283	41	134	of	of	IN
22283	41	135	all	all	DT
22283	41	136	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	41	137	motion	motion	NN
22283	41	138	.	.	.
22283	42	1	And	and	CC
22283	42	2	although	although	IN
22283	42	3	unstudied	unstudied	JJ
22283	42	4	men	man	NNS
22283	42	5	do	do	VBP
22283	42	6	not	not	RB
22283	42	7	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	42	8	any	any	DT
22283	42	9	motion	motion	NN
22283	42	10	at	at	RB
22283	42	11	all	all	RB
22283	42	12	to	to	TO
22283	42	13	be	be	VB
22283	42	14	there	there	RB
22283	42	15	,	,	,
22283	42	16	where	where	WRB
22283	42	17	the	the	DT
22283	42	18	thing	thing	NN
22283	42	19	moved	move	VBD
22283	42	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	42	21	invisible	invisible	JJ
22283	42	22	;	;	:
22283	42	23	or	or	CC
22283	42	24	the	the	DT
22283	42	25	space	space	NN
22283	42	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	42	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	42	28	moved	move	VBN
22283	42	29	in	in	IN
22283	42	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	42	31	,	,	,
22283	42	32	for	for	IN
22283	42	33	the	the	DT
22283	42	34	shortness	shortness	NN
22283	42	35	of	of	IN
22283	42	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	42	37	,	,	,
22283	42	38	insensible	insensible	JJ
22283	42	39	;	;	:
22283	42	40	yet	yet	CC
22283	42	41	that	that	DT
22283	42	42	doth	doth	NN
22283	42	43	not	not	RB
22283	42	44	hinder	hinder	JJ
22283	42	45	,	,	,
22283	42	46	but	but	CC
22283	42	47	that	that	IN
22283	42	48	such	such	JJ
22283	42	49	motions	motion	NNS
22283	42	50	are	be	VBP
22283	42	51	.	.	.
22283	43	1	These	these	DT
22283	43	2	small	small	JJ
22283	43	3	beginnings	beginning	NNS
22283	43	4	of	of	IN
22283	43	5	motion	motion	NN
22283	43	6	,	,	,
22283	43	7	within	within	IN
22283	43	8	the	the	DT
22283	43	9	body	body	NN
22283	43	10	of	of	IN
22283	43	11	man	man	NN
22283	43	12	,	,	,
22283	43	13	before	before	IN
22283	43	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	43	15	appear	appear	VBP
22283	43	16	in	in	IN
22283	43	17	walking	walk	VBG
22283	43	18	,	,	,
22283	43	19	speaking	speaking	NN
22283	43	20	,	,	,
22283	43	21	striking	strike	VBG
22283	43	22	,	,	,
22283	43	23	and	and	CC
22283	43	24	other	other	JJ
22283	43	25	visible	visible	JJ
22283	43	26	actions	action	NNS
22283	43	27	,	,	,
22283	43	28	are	be	VBP
22283	43	29	commonly	commonly	RB
22283	43	30	called	call	VBN
22283	43	31	ENDEAVOUR[1	endeavour[1	NN
22283	43	32	]	]	-RRB-
22283	43	33	.	.	.
22283	43	34	'	'	''
22283	44	1	These	these	DT
22283	44	2	quotations	quotation	NNS
22283	44	3	are	be	VBP
22283	44	4	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	44	5	to	to	TO
22283	44	6	show	show	VB
22283	44	7	that	that	IN
22283	44	8	the	the	DT
22283	44	9	system	system	NN
22283	44	10	of	of	IN
22283	44	11	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	44	12	was	be	VBD
22283	44	13	prophetic	prophetic	JJ
22283	44	14	of	of	IN
22283	44	15	a	a	DT
22283	44	16	revelation	revelation	NN
22283	44	17	afterwards	afterwards	RB
22283	44	18	declared	declare	VBN
22283	44	19	by	by	IN
22283	44	20	two	two	CD
22283	44	21	centuries	century	NNS
22283	44	22	of	of	IN
22283	44	23	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	44	24	research	research	NN
22283	44	25	.	.	.
22283	45	1	For	for	IN
22283	45	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	45	3	show	show	VBP
22283	45	4	how	how	WRB
22283	45	5	plainly	plainly	RB
22283	45	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	45	7	taught	teach	VBD
22283	45	8	that	that	IN
22283	45	9	all	all	PDT
22283	45	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	45	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	45	12	of	of	IN
22283	45	13	the	the	DT
22283	45	14	external	external	JJ
22283	45	15	world	world	NN
22283	45	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	45	17	a	a	DT
22283	45	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	45	19	of	of	IN
22283	45	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	45	21	;	;	:
22283	45	22	and	and	CC
22283	45	23	,	,	,
22283	45	24	again	again	RB
22283	45	25	,	,	,
22283	45	26	that	that	IN
22283	45	27	all	all	PDT
22283	45	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	45	29	acquisitions	acquisition	NNS
22283	45	30	of	of	IN
22283	45	31	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	45	32	and	and	CC
22283	45	33	other	other	JJ
22283	45	34	acts	act	NNS
22283	45	35	of	of	IN
22283	45	36	mind	mind	NN
22283	45	37	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	45	38	imply	imply	VBP
22283	45	39	,	,	,
22283	45	40	as	as	IN
22283	45	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	45	42	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	45	43	says	say	VBZ
22283	45	44	,	,	,
22283	45	45	some	some	DT
22283	45	46	kind	kind	NN
22283	45	47	of	of	IN
22283	45	48	'	'	``
22283	45	49	motion	motion	NN
22283	45	50	,	,	,
22283	45	51	agitation	agitation	NN
22283	45	52	,	,	,
22283	45	53	or	or	CC
22283	45	54	alteration	alteration	NN
22283	45	55	,	,	,
22283	45	56	which	which	WDT
22283	45	57	worketh	worketh	JJ
22283	45	58	in	in	IN
22283	45	59	the	the	DT
22283	45	60	brain	brain	NN
22283	45	61	.	.	.
22283	45	62	'	'	''
22283	46	1	That	that	IN
22283	46	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	46	3	conceived	conceive	VBD
22283	46	4	such	such	JJ
22283	46	5	motion	motion	NN
22283	46	6	,	,	,
22283	46	7	agitation	agitation	NN
22283	46	8	,	,	,
22283	46	9	or	or	CC
22283	46	10	alteration	alteration	NN
22283	46	11	to	to	TO
22283	46	12	be	be	VB
22283	46	13	,	,	,
22283	46	14	from	from	IN
22283	46	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	46	16	extreme	extreme	JJ
22283	46	17	minuteness	minuteness	NN
22283	46	18	,	,	,
22283	46	19	'	'	``
22283	46	20	invisible	invisible	JJ
22283	46	21	'	'	''
22283	46	22	and	and	CC
22283	46	23	'	'	``
22283	46	24	insensible	insensible	JJ
22283	46	25	,	,	,
22283	46	26	'	'	''
22283	46	27	or	or	CC
22283	46	28	,	,	,
22283	46	29	as	as	IN
22283	46	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	46	31	should	should	MD
22283	46	32	now	now	RB
22283	46	33	say	say	VB
22283	46	34	,	,	,
22283	46	35	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	46	36	,	,	,
22283	46	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	46	38	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	46	39	evident	evident	JJ
22283	46	40	.	.	.
22283	47	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	47	2	can	can	MD
22283	47	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	47	4	imagine	imagine	VB
22283	47	5	the	the	DT
22283	47	6	delight	delight	NN
22283	47	7	with	with	IN
22283	47	8	which	which	WDT
22283	47	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	47	10	would	would	MD
22283	47	11	hear	hear	VB
22283	47	12	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	47	13	speak	speak	VB
22283	47	14	when	when	WRB
22283	47	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	47	16	say	say	VBP
22283	47	17	,	,	,
22283	47	18	that	that	IN
22283	47	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	47	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	47	21	no	no	RB
22283	47	22	longer	long	RBR
22283	47	23	a	a	DT
22283	47	24	matter	matter	NN
22283	47	25	of	of	IN
22283	47	26	keen	keen	JJ
22283	47	27	-	-	HYPH
22283	47	28	sighted	sighted	JJ
22283	47	29	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	47	30	,	,	,
22283	47	31	but	but	CC
22283	47	32	a	a	DT
22283	47	33	matter	matter	NN
22283	47	34	of	of	IN
22283	47	35	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	47	36	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
22283	47	37	fact	fact	NN
22283	47	38	,	,	,
22283	47	39	that	that	IN
22283	47	40	all	all	PDT
22283	47	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	47	42	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	47	43	of	of	IN
22283	47	44	the	the	DT
22283	47	45	external	external	JJ
22283	47	46	world	world	NN
22283	47	47	is	be	VBZ
22283	47	48	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	47	49	more	more	JJR
22283	47	50	than	than	IN
22283	47	51	a	a	DT
22283	47	52	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	47	53	of	of	IN
22283	47	54	motion	motion	NN
22283	47	55	.	.	.
22283	48	1	For	for	IN
22283	48	2	all	all	PDT
22283	48	3	the	the	DT
22283	48	4	forms	form	NNS
22283	48	5	of	of	IN
22283	48	6	energy	energy	NN
22283	48	7	have	have	VBP
22283	48	8	now	now	RB
22283	48	9	been	be	VBN
22283	48	10	proved	prove	VBN
22283	48	11	to	to	TO
22283	48	12	be	be	VB
22283	48	13	but	but	CC
22283	48	14	modes	mode	NNS
22283	48	15	of	of	IN
22283	48	16	motion	motion	NN
22283	48	17	;	;	:
22283	48	18	and	and	CC
22283	48	19	even	even	RB
22283	48	20	matter	matter	RBR
22283	48	21	,	,	,
22283	48	22	if	if	IN
22283	48	23	not	not	RB
22283	48	24	in	in	IN
22283	48	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	48	26	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	48	27	constitution	constitution	NN
22283	48	28	vortical	vortical	JJ
22283	48	29	motion	motion	NN
22283	48	30	,	,	,
22283	48	31	at	at	IN
22283	48	32	all	all	DT
22283	48	33	events	event	NNS
22283	48	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	48	35	known	know	VBN
22283	48	36	to	to	IN
22283	48	37	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	48	38	only	only	RB
22283	48	39	as	as	IN
22283	48	40	changes	change	NNS
22283	48	41	of	of	IN
22283	48	42	motion	motion	NN
22283	48	43	:	:	:
22283	48	44	all	all	DT
22283	48	45	that	that	WDT
22283	48	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	48	47	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	48	48	in	in	IN
22283	48	49	what	what	WP
22283	48	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	48	51	call	call	VBP
22283	48	52	matter	matter	NN
22283	48	53	is	be	VBZ
22283	48	54	change	change	NN
22283	48	55	in	in	IN
22283	48	56	modes	mode	NNS
22283	48	57	of	of	IN
22283	48	58	motion	motion	NN
22283	48	59	.	.	.
22283	49	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	49	2	do	do	VBP
22283	49	3	not	not	RB
22283	49	4	even	even	RB
22283	49	5	know	know	VB
22283	49	6	what	what	WP
22283	49	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	49	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	49	9	that	that	IN
22283	49	10	moves	move	NNS
22283	49	11	;	;	:
22283	49	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	49	13	only	only	RB
22283	49	14	know	know	VBP
22283	49	15	that	that	IN
22283	49	16	when	when	WRB
22283	49	17	some	some	DT
22283	49	18	modes	mode	NNS
22283	49	19	of	of	IN
22283	49	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	49	21	pass	pass	VBP
22283	49	22	into	into	IN
22283	49	23	other	other	JJ
22283	49	24	modes	mode	NNS
22283	49	25	,	,	,
22283	49	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	49	27	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	49	28	what	what	WP
22283	49	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	49	30	understand	understand	VBP
22283	49	31	by	by	IN
22283	49	32	matter	matter	NN
22283	49	33	.	.	.
22283	50	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	50	2	would	would	MD
22283	50	3	take	take	VB
22283	50	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	50	5	too	too	RB
22283	50	6	long	long	JJ
22283	50	7	to	to	TO
22283	50	8	justify	justify	VB
22283	50	9	this	this	DT
22283	50	10	general	general	JJ
22283	50	11	statement	statement	NN
22283	50	12	so	so	IN
22283	50	13	that	that	IN
22283	50	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	50	15	should	should	MD
22283	50	16	be	be	VB
22283	50	17	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
22283	50	18	to	to	IN
22283	50	19	every	every	DT
22283	50	20	one	one	CD
22283	50	21	;	;	:
22283	50	22	but	but	CC
22283	50	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	50	24	am	be	VBP
22283	50	25	confident	confident	JJ
22283	50	26	that	that	IN
22283	50	27	all	all	DT
22283	50	28	persons	person	NNS
22283	50	29	who	who	WP
22283	50	30	understand	understand	VBP
22283	50	31	such	such	JJ
22283	50	32	subjects	subject	NNS
22283	50	33	will	will	MD
22283	50	34	,	,	,
22283	50	35	when	when	WRB
22283	50	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	50	37	think	think	VBP
22283	50	38	about	about	IN
22283	50	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	50	40	,	,	,
22283	50	41	accept	accept	VB
22283	50	42	this	this	DT
22283	50	43	general	general	JJ
22283	50	44	statement	statement	NN
22283	50	45	as	as	IN
22283	50	46	one	one	CD
22283	50	47	which	which	WDT
22283	50	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	50	49	universally	universally	RB
22283	50	50	true	true	JJ
22283	50	51	.	.	.
22283	51	1	And	and	CC
22283	51	2	,	,	,
22283	51	3	if	if	IN
22283	51	4	so	so	RB
22283	51	5	,	,	,
22283	51	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	51	7	will	will	MD
22283	51	8	agree	agree	VB
22283	51	9	with	with	IN
22283	51	10	Hobbes	hobbe	NNS
22283	51	11	that	that	IN
22283	51	12	all	all	PDT
22283	51	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	51	14	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	51	15	of	of	IN
22283	51	16	the	the	DT
22283	51	17	external	external	JJ
22283	51	18	world	world	NN
22283	51	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	51	20	a	a	DT
22283	51	21	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	51	22	of	of	IN
22283	51	23	motion	motion	NN
22283	51	24	.	.	.
22283	52	1	Now	now	RB
22283	52	2	,	,	,
22283	52	3	if	if	IN
22283	52	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	52	5	would	would	MD
22283	52	6	have	have	VB
22283	52	7	been	be	VBN
22283	52	8	thus	thus	RB
22283	52	9	a	a	DT
22283	52	10	joy	joy	NN
22283	52	11	to	to	IN
22283	52	12	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	52	13	to	to	TO
22283	52	14	have	have	VB
22283	52	15	heard	hear	VBN
22283	52	16	to	to	IN
22283	52	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	52	18	day	day	NN
22283	52	19	how	how	WRB
22283	52	20	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
22283	52	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	52	22	has	have	VBZ
22283	52	23	been	be	VBN
22283	52	24	justified	justify	VBN
22283	52	25	in	in	IN
22283	52	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	52	27	views	view	NNS
22283	52	28	touching	touch	VBG
22283	52	29	the	the	DT
22283	52	30	external	external	JJ
22283	52	31	world	world	NN
22283	52	32	,	,	,
22283	52	33	with	with	IN
22283	52	34	no	no	DT
22283	52	35	less	less	JJR
22283	52	36	joy	joy	NN
22283	52	37	would	would	MD
22283	52	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	52	39	have	have	VB
22283	52	40	heard	hear	VBN
22283	52	41	that	that	IN
22283	52	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	52	43	has	have	VBZ
22283	52	44	been	be	VBN
22283	52	45	equally	equally	RB
22283	52	46	justified	justify	VBN
22283	52	47	in	in	IN
22283	52	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	52	49	views	view	NNS
22283	52	50	touching	touch	VBG
22283	52	51	the	the	DT
22283	52	52	internal	internal	JJ
22283	52	53	world	world	NN
22283	52	54	.	.	.
22283	53	1	For	for	IN
22283	53	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	53	3	has	have	VBZ
22283	53	4	now	now	RB
22283	53	5	been	be	VBN
22283	53	6	proved	prove	VBN
22283	53	7	,	,	,
22283	53	8	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	53	9	the	the	DT
22283	53	10	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	53	11	of	of	IN
22283	53	12	dispute	dispute	NN
22283	53	13	,	,	,
22283	53	14	that	that	IN
22283	53	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	53	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	53	17	only	only	RB
22283	53	18	in	in	IN
22283	53	19	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	53	20	of	of	IN
22283	53	21	those	those	DT
22283	53	22	invisible	invisible	JJ
22283	53	23	movements	movement	NNS
22283	53	24	which	which	WDT
22283	53	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	53	26	inferred	infer	VBD
22283	53	27	that	that	IN
22283	53	28	the	the	DT
22283	53	29	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	53	30	system	system	NN
22283	53	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	53	32	enabled	enable	VBN
22283	53	33	to	to	TO
22283	53	34	perform	perform	VB
22283	53	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	53	36	varied	varied	JJ
22283	53	37	functions	function	NNS
22283	53	38	.	.	.
22283	54	1	To	to	IN
22283	54	2	many	many	JJ
22283	54	3	among	among	IN
22283	54	4	the	the	DT
22283	54	5	different	different	JJ
22283	54	6	kinds	kind	NNS
22283	54	7	of	of	IN
22283	54	8	movement	movement	NN
22283	54	9	going	go	VBG
22283	54	10	on	on	RP
22283	54	11	in	in	IN
22283	54	12	the	the	DT
22283	54	13	external	external	JJ
22283	54	14	world	world	NN
22283	54	15	,	,	,
22283	54	16	the	the	DT
22283	54	17	animal	animal	NN
22283	54	18	body	body	NN
22283	54	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	54	20	adapted	adapt	VBN
22283	54	21	to	to	TO
22283	54	22	respond	respond	VB
22283	54	23	by	by	IN
22283	54	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	54	25	own	own	JJ
22283	54	26	movements	movement	NNS
22283	54	27	as	as	IN
22283	54	28	best	good	JJS
22283	54	29	suits	suit	VBZ
22283	54	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	54	31	own	own	JJ
22283	54	32	welfare	welfare	NN
22283	54	33	;	;	:
22283	54	34	and	and	CC
22283	54	35	the	the	DT
22283	54	36	mechanism	mechanism	NN
22283	54	37	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	54	38	this	this	DT
22283	54	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	54	40	effected	effect	VBN
22283	54	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	54	42	the	the	DT
22283	54	43	neuro	neuro	NNP
22283	54	44	-	-	HYPH
22283	54	45	muscular	muscular	JJ
22283	54	46	system	system	NN
22283	54	47	.	.	.
22283	55	1	Those	those	DT
22283	55	2	kinds	kind	NNS
22283	55	3	of	of	IN
22283	55	4	movement	movement	NN
22283	55	5	going	go	VBG
22283	55	6	on	on	RP
22283	55	7	in	in	IN
22283	55	8	the	the	DT
22283	55	9	external	external	JJ
22283	55	10	world	world	NN
22283	55	11	which	which	WDT
22283	55	12	are	be	VBP
22283	55	13	competent	competent	JJ
22283	55	14	to	to	TO
22283	55	15	evoke	evoke	VB
22283	55	16	responsive	responsive	JJ
22283	55	17	movements	movement	NNS
22283	55	18	in	in	IN
22283	55	19	the	the	DT
22283	55	20	animal	animal	NN
22283	55	21	body	body	NN
22283	55	22	are	be	VBP
22283	55	23	called	call	VBN
22283	55	24	by	by	IN
22283	55	25	physiologists	physiologist	NNS
22283	55	26	stimuli	stimulus	NNS
22283	55	27	.	.	.
22283	56	1	When	when	WRB
22283	56	2	a	a	DT
22283	56	3	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	56	4	falls	fall	VBZ
22283	56	5	upon	upon	IN
22283	56	6	the	the	DT
22283	56	7	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
22283	56	8	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	56	9	surface	surface	NN
22283	56	10	,	,	,
22283	56	11	a	a	DT
22283	56	12	wave	wave	NN
22283	56	13	of	of	IN
22283	56	14	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	56	15	movement	movement	NN
22283	56	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	56	17	sent	send	VBN
22283	56	18	up	up	RP
22283	56	19	the	the	DT
22283	56	20	attached	attach	VBN
22283	56	21	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	56	22	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	56	23	to	to	IN
22283	56	24	a	a	DT
22283	56	25	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	56	26	-	-	HYPH
22283	56	27	centre	centre	NN
22283	56	28	,	,	,
22283	56	29	which	which	WDT
22283	56	30	thereupon	thereupon	VBD
22283	56	31	issues	issue	VBZ
22283	56	32	another	another	DT
22283	56	33	wave	wave	NN
22283	56	34	of	of	IN
22283	56	35	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	56	36	movement	movement	NN
22283	56	37	down	down	IN
22283	56	38	a	a	DT
22283	56	39	motor	motor	NN
22283	56	40	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	56	41	to	to	IN
22283	56	42	the	the	DT
22283	56	43	group	group	NN
22283	56	44	of	of	IN
22283	56	45	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	56	46	over	over	IN
22283	56	47	whose	whose	WP$
22283	56	48	action	action	NN
22283	56	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	56	50	presides	preside	VBZ
22283	56	51	;	;	:
22283	56	52	and	and	CC
22283	56	53	when	when	WRB
22283	56	54	the	the	DT
22283	56	55	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	56	56	receive	receive	VBP
22283	56	57	this	this	DT
22283	56	58	wave	wave	NN
22283	56	59	of	of	IN
22283	56	60	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	56	61	influence	influence	NN
22283	56	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	56	63	contract	contract	VBP
22283	56	64	.	.	.
22283	57	1	This	this	DT
22283	57	2	kind	kind	NN
22283	57	3	of	of	IN
22283	57	4	response	response	NN
22283	57	5	to	to	IN
22283	57	6	stimuli	stimulus	NNS
22283	57	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	57	8	purely	purely	RB
22283	57	9	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	57	10	,	,	,
22283	57	11	or	or	CC
22283	57	12	non	non	JJ
22283	57	13	-	-	JJ
22283	57	14	mental	mental	JJ
22283	57	15	,	,	,
22283	57	16	and	and	CC
22283	57	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	57	18	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
22283	57	19	termed	term	VBN
22283	57	20	reflex	reflex	JJ
22283	57	21	action	action	NN
22283	57	22	.	.	.
22283	58	1	The	the	DT
22283	58	2	whole	whole	NN
22283	58	3	of	of	IN
22283	58	4	the	the	DT
22283	58	5	spinal	spinal	JJ
22283	58	6	cord	cord	NN
22283	58	7	and	and	CC
22283	58	8	lower	low	JJR
22283	58	9	part	part	NN
22283	58	10	of	of	IN
22283	58	11	the	the	DT
22283	58	12	brain	brain	NN
22283	58	13	are	be	VBP
22283	58	14	made	make	VBN
22283	58	15	up	up	RP
22283	58	16	of	of	IN
22283	58	17	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	58	18	-	-	HYPH
22283	58	19	centres	centre	NNS
22283	58	20	of	of	IN
22283	58	21	reflex	reflex	JJ
22283	58	22	action	action	NN
22283	58	23	;	;	:
22283	58	24	and	and	CC
22283	58	25	,	,	,
22283	58	26	in	in	IN
22283	58	27	the	the	DT
22283	58	28	result	result	NN
22283	58	29	,	,	,
22283	58	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	58	31	have	have	VBP
22283	58	32	a	a	DT
22283	58	33	wonderfully	wonderfully	RB
22283	58	34	perfect	perfect	JJ
22283	58	35	machine	machine	NN
22283	58	36	in	in	IN
22283	58	37	the	the	DT
22283	58	38	animal	animal	NN
22283	58	39	body	body	NN
22283	58	40	considered	consider	VBN
22283	58	41	as	as	IN
22283	58	42	a	a	DT
22283	58	43	whole	whole	NN
22283	58	44	.	.	.
22283	59	1	For	for	CC
22283	59	2	while	while	IN
22283	59	3	the	the	DT
22283	59	4	various	various	JJ
22283	59	5	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	59	6	surfaces	surface	NNS
22283	59	7	are	be	VBP
22283	59	8	severally	severally	RB
22283	59	9	adapted	adapt	VBN
22283	59	10	to	to	TO
22283	59	11	respond	respond	VB
22283	59	12	to	to	IN
22283	59	13	different	different	JJ
22283	59	14	kinds	kind	NNS
22283	59	15	of	of	IN
22283	59	16	external	external	JJ
22283	59	17	movement	movement	NN
22283	59	18	--	--	:
22283	59	19	the	the	DT
22283	59	20	eye	eye	NN
22283	59	21	to	to	IN
22283	59	22	light	light	NN
22283	59	23	,	,	,
22283	59	24	the	the	DT
22283	59	25	ear	ear	NN
22283	59	26	to	to	TO
22283	59	27	sound	sound	VB
22283	59	28	,	,	,
22283	59	29	and	and	CC
22283	59	30	so	so	RB
22283	59	31	on	on	RB
22283	59	32	--	--	:
22283	59	33	any	any	DT
22283	59	34	of	of	IN
22283	59	35	these	these	DT
22283	59	36	surfaces	surface	NNS
22283	59	37	may	may	MD
22283	59	38	be	be	VB
22283	59	39	brought	bring	VBN
22283	59	40	into	into	IN
22283	59	41	suitable	suitable	JJ
22283	59	42	relation	relation	NN
22283	59	43	with	with	IN
22283	59	44	any	any	DT
22283	59	45	of	of	IN
22283	59	46	the	the	DT
22283	59	47	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	59	48	of	of	IN
22283	59	49	the	the	DT
22283	59	50	body	body	NN
22283	59	51	by	by	IN
22283	59	52	means	mean	NNS
22283	59	53	of	of	IN
22283	59	54	the	the	DT
22283	59	55	cerebro	cerebro	JJ
22283	59	56	-	-	HYPH
22283	59	57	spinal	spinal	JJ
22283	59	58	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	59	59	-	-	HYPH
22283	59	60	centres	centre	NNS
22283	59	61	and	and	CC
22283	59	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	59	63	intercommunications	intercommunication	NNS
22283	59	64	.	.	.
22283	60	1	So	so	RB
22283	60	2	much	much	RB
22283	60	3	,	,	,
22283	60	4	then	then	RB
22283	60	5	,	,	,
22283	60	6	for	for	IN
22283	60	7	the	the	DT
22283	60	8	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	60	9	of	of	IN
22283	60	10	the	the	DT
22283	60	11	body	body	NN
22283	60	12	.	.	.
22283	61	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	61	2	must	must	MD
22283	61	3	now	now	RB
22283	61	4	turn	turn	VB
22283	61	5	to	to	TO
22283	61	6	consider	consider	VB
22283	61	7	the	the	DT
22283	61	8	corporeal	corporeal	JJ
22283	61	9	seat	seat	NN
22283	61	10	of	of	IN
22283	61	11	the	the	DT
22283	61	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	61	13	,	,	,
22283	61	14	or	or	CC
22283	61	15	the	the	DT
22283	61	16	only	only	JJ
22283	61	17	part	part	NN
22283	61	18	of	of	IN
22283	61	19	the	the	DT
22283	61	20	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	61	21	system	system	NN
22283	61	22	wherein	wherein	WRB
22283	61	23	the	the	DT
22283	61	24	agitation	agitation	NN
22283	61	25	of	of	IN
22283	61	26	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	61	27	matter	matter	NN
22283	61	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	61	29	accompanied	accompany	VBN
22283	61	30	with	with	IN
22283	61	31	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	61	32	.	.	.
22283	62	1	This	this	DT
22283	62	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	62	3	composed	compose	VBN
22283	62	4	of	of	IN
22283	62	5	a	a	DT
22283	62	6	double	double	JJ
22283	62	7	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	62	8	-	-	HYPH
22283	62	9	centre	centre	NN
22283	62	10	,	,	,
22283	62	11	which	which	WDT
22283	62	12	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	62	13	in	in	IN
22283	62	14	all	all	DT
22283	62	15	vertebrated	vertebrate	VBN
22283	62	16	animals	animal	NNS
22283	62	17	,	,	,
22283	62	18	and	and	CC
22283	62	19	the	the	DT
22283	62	20	two	two	CD
22283	62	21	parts	part	NNS
22283	62	22	of	of	IN
22283	62	23	which	which	WDT
22283	62	24	are	be	VBP
22283	62	25	called	call	VBN
22283	62	26	the	the	DT
22283	62	27	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	62	28	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	62	29	.	.	.
22283	63	1	In	in	IN
22283	63	2	man	man	NN
22283	63	3	this	this	DT
22283	63	4	double	double	JJ
22283	63	5	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	63	6	-	-	HYPH
22283	63	7	centre	centre	NN
22283	63	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	63	9	so	so	RB
22283	63	10	large	large	JJ
22283	63	11	that	that	IN
22283	63	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	63	13	completely	completely	RB
22283	63	14	fills	fill	VBZ
22283	63	15	the	the	DT
22283	63	16	arch	arch	NN
22283	63	17	of	of	IN
22283	63	18	the	the	DT
22283	63	19	skull	skull	NN
22283	63	20	,	,	,
22283	63	21	as	as	RB
22283	63	22	far	far	RB
22283	63	23	down	down	RB
22283	63	24	as	as	IN
22283	63	25	the	the	DT
22283	63	26	level	level	NN
22283	63	27	of	of	IN
22283	63	28	the	the	DT
22283	63	29	eyebrows	eyebrow	NNS
22283	63	30	.	.	.
22283	64	1	The	the	DT
22283	64	2	two	two	CD
22283	64	3	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	64	4	of	of	IN
22283	64	5	which	which	WDT
22283	64	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	64	7	consists	consist	VBZ
22283	64	8	meet	meet	VBP
22283	64	9	face	face	NN
22283	64	10	to	to	IN
22283	64	11	face	face	NN
22283	64	12	in	in	IN
22283	64	13	the	the	DT
22283	64	14	middle	middle	JJ
22283	64	15	line	line	NN
22283	64	16	of	of	IN
22283	64	17	the	the	DT
22283	64	18	skull	skull	NN
22283	64	19	,	,	,
22283	64	20	from	from	IN
22283	64	21	the	the	DT
22283	64	22	top	top	NN
22283	64	23	of	of	IN
22283	64	24	the	the	DT
22283	64	25	nose	nose	NN
22283	64	26	backwards	backwards	RB
22283	64	27	.	.	.
22283	65	1	Each	each	DT
22283	65	2	hemisphere	hemisphere	NN
22283	65	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	65	4	composed	compose	VBN
22283	65	5	of	of	IN
22283	65	6	two	two	CD
22283	65	7	conspicuously	conspicuously	RB
22283	65	8	distinct	distinct	JJ
22283	65	9	parts	part	NNS
22283	65	10	,	,	,
22283	65	11	called	call	VBD
22283	65	12	respectively	respectively	RB
22283	65	13	the	the	DT
22283	65	14	grey	grey	JJ
22283	65	15	matter	matter	NN
22283	65	16	and	and	CC
22283	65	17	the	the	DT
22283	65	18	white	white	JJ
22283	65	19	matter	matter	NN
22283	65	20	.	.	.
22283	66	1	The	the	DT
22283	66	2	grey	grey	JJ
22283	66	3	matter	matter	NN
22283	66	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	66	5	external	external	JJ
22283	66	6	,	,	,
22283	66	7	enveloping	envelop	VBG
22283	66	8	the	the	DT
22283	66	9	white	white	JJ
22283	66	10	matter	matter	NN
22283	66	11	like	like	IN
22283	66	12	a	a	DT
22283	66	13	skull	skull	NN
22283	66	14	-	-	HYPH
22283	66	15	cap	cap	NN
22283	66	16	,	,	,
22283	66	17	and	and	CC
22283	66	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	66	19	composed	compose	VBN
22283	66	20	of	of	IN
22283	66	21	an	an	DT
22283	66	22	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	66	23	number	number	NN
22283	66	24	of	of	IN
22283	66	25	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	66	26	-	-	HYPH
22283	66	27	cells	cell	NNS
22283	66	28	connected	connect	VBN
22283	66	29	together	together	RB
22283	66	30	by	by	IN
22283	66	31	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	66	32	-	-	HYPH
22283	66	33	fibres	fibre	NNS
22283	66	34	.	.	.
22283	67	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	67	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	67	3	computed	compute	VBN
22283	67	4	that	that	IN
22283	67	5	in	in	IN
22283	67	6	a	a	DT
22283	67	7	human	human	JJ
22283	67	8	brain	brain	NN
22283	67	9	there	there	EX
22283	67	10	can	can	MD
22283	67	11	not	not	RB
22283	67	12	be	be	VB
22283	67	13	less	less	JJR
22283	67	14	than	than	IN
22283	67	15	a	a	DT
22283	67	16	thousand	thousand	CD
22283	67	17	millions	million	NNS
22283	67	18	of	of	IN
22283	67	19	cells	cell	NNS
22283	67	20	,	,	,
22283	67	21	and	and	CC
22283	67	22	five	five	CD
22283	67	23	thousand	thousand	CD
22283	67	24	millions	million	NNS
22283	67	25	of	of	IN
22283	67	26	fibres	fibre	NNS
22283	67	27	.	.	.
22283	68	1	The	the	DT
22283	68	2	white	white	JJ
22283	68	3	matter	matter	NN
22283	68	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	68	5	composed	compose	VBN
22283	68	6	only	only	RB
22283	68	7	of	of	IN
22283	68	8	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	68	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	68	10	fibres	fibre	NNS
22283	68	11	,	,	,
22283	68	12	which	which	WDT
22283	68	13	pass	pass	VBP
22283	68	14	downwards	downwards	RB
22283	68	15	in	in	IN
22283	68	16	great	great	JJ
22283	68	17	strands	strand	NNS
22283	68	18	of	of	IN
22283	68	19	conducting	conduct	VBG
22283	68	20	tissue	tissue	NN
22283	68	21	to	to	IN
22283	68	22	the	the	DT
22283	68	23	lower	low	JJR
22283	68	24	centres	centre	NNS
22283	68	25	of	of	IN
22283	68	26	the	the	DT
22283	68	27	brain	brain	NN
22283	68	28	and	and	CC
22283	68	29	spinal	spinal	JJ
22283	68	30	cord	cord	NN
22283	68	31	.	.	.
22283	69	1	So	so	RB
22283	69	2	that	that	IN
22283	69	3	the	the	DT
22283	69	4	whole	whole	NN
22283	69	5	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
22283	69	6	one	one	CD
22283	69	7	system	system	NN
22283	69	8	,	,	,
22283	69	9	with	with	IN
22283	69	10	the	the	DT
22283	69	11	grey	grey	JJ
22283	69	12	matter	matter	NN
22283	69	13	of	of	IN
22283	69	14	the	the	DT
22283	69	15	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	69	16	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	69	17	at	at	IN
22283	69	18	the	the	DT
22283	69	19	apex	apex	NNP
22283	69	20	or	or	CC
22283	69	21	crown	crown	NN
22283	69	22	.	.	.
22283	70	1	That	that	IN
22283	70	2	the	the	DT
22283	70	3	grey	grey	JJ
22283	70	4	matter	matter	NN
22283	70	5	of	of	IN
22283	70	6	the	the	DT
22283	70	7	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	70	8	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	70	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	70	10	the	the	DT
22283	70	11	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
22283	70	12	seat	seat	NN
22283	70	13	of	of	IN
22283	70	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	70	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	70	16	proved	prove	VBN
22283	70	17	in	in	IN
22283	70	18	two	two	CD
22283	70	19	ways	way	NNS
22283	70	20	.	.	.
22283	71	1	In	in	IN
22283	71	2	the	the	DT
22283	71	3	first	first	JJ
22283	71	4	place	place	NN
22283	71	5	,	,	,
22283	71	6	if	if	IN
22283	71	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	71	8	look	look	VBP
22283	71	9	to	to	IN
22283	71	10	the	the	DT
22283	71	11	animal	animal	NN
22283	71	12	kingdom	kingdom	NN
22283	71	13	as	as	IN
22283	71	14	a	a	DT
22283	71	15	whole	whole	NN
22283	71	16	,	,	,
22283	71	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	71	18	find	find	VBP
22283	71	19	that	that	IN
22283	71	20	,	,	,
22283	71	21	speaking	speak	VBG
22283	71	22	generally	generally	RB
22283	71	23	,	,	,
22283	71	24	the	the	DT
22283	71	25	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	71	26	of	of	IN
22283	71	27	species	specie	NNS
22283	71	28	varies	varie	NNS
22283	71	29	with	with	IN
22283	71	30	the	the	DT
22283	71	31	mass	mass	NN
22283	71	32	of	of	IN
22283	71	33	this	this	DT
22283	71	34	grey	grey	JJ
22283	71	35	matter	matter	NN
22283	71	36	.	.	.
22283	72	1	Or	or	CC
22283	72	2	,	,	,
22283	72	3	in	in	IN
22283	72	4	other	other	JJ
22283	72	5	words	word	NNS
22283	72	6	,	,	,
22283	72	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	72	8	find	find	VBP
22283	72	9	that	that	IN
22283	72	10	the	the	DT
22283	72	11	process	process	NN
22283	72	12	of	of	IN
22283	72	13	mental	mental	JJ
22283	72	14	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	72	15	,	,	,
22283	72	16	on	on	IN
22283	72	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	72	18	physical	physical	JJ
22283	72	19	side	side	NN
22283	72	20	,	,	,
22283	72	21	has	have	VBZ
22283	72	22	consisted	consist	VBN
22283	72	23	in	in	IN
22283	72	24	the	the	DT
22283	72	25	progressive	progressive	JJ
22283	72	26	development	development	NN
22283	72	27	of	of	IN
22283	72	28	this	this	DT
22283	72	29	grey	grey	JJ
22283	72	30	matter	matter	NN
22283	72	31	superimposed	superimpose	VBN
22283	72	32	upon	upon	IN
22283	72	33	the	the	DT
22283	72	34	pre	pre	JJ
22283	72	35	-	-	JJ
22283	72	36	existing	exist	VBG
22283	72	37	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	72	38	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	72	39	,	,	,
22283	72	40	until	until	IN
22283	72	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	72	42	has	have	VBZ
22283	72	43	attained	attain	VBN
22283	72	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	72	45	latest	late	JJS
22283	72	46	and	and	CC
22283	72	47	maximum	maximum	JJ
22283	72	48	growth	growth	NN
22283	72	49	in	in	IN
22283	72	50	man	man	NN
22283	72	51	.	.	.
22283	73	1	In	in	IN
22283	73	2	the	the	DT
22283	73	3	second	second	JJ
22283	73	4	place	place	NN
22283	73	5	,	,	,
22283	73	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	73	7	find	find	VBP
22283	73	8	that	that	IN
22283	73	9	when	when	WRB
22283	73	10	the	the	DT
22283	73	11	grey	grey	JJ
22283	73	12	matter	matter	NN
22283	73	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	73	14	experimentally	experimentally	RB
22283	73	15	removed	remove	VBN
22283	73	16	from	from	IN
22283	73	17	the	the	DT
22283	73	18	brain	brain	NN
22283	73	19	of	of	IN
22283	73	20	animals	animal	NNS
22283	73	21	,	,	,
22283	73	22	the	the	DT
22283	73	23	animals	animal	NNS
22283	73	24	continue	continue	VBP
22283	73	25	to	to	TO
22283	73	26	live	live	VB
22283	73	27	;	;	:
22283	73	28	but	but	CC
22283	73	29	are	be	VBP
22283	73	30	completely	completely	RB
22283	73	31	deprived	deprive	VBN
22283	73	32	of	of	IN
22283	73	33	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	73	34	.	.	.
22283	74	1	All	all	PDT
22283	74	2	the	the	DT
22283	74	3	lower	low	JJR
22283	74	4	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	74	5	-	-	HYPH
22283	74	6	centres	centre	NNS
22283	74	7	continue	continue	VBP
22283	74	8	to	to	TO
22283	74	9	perform	perform	VB
22283	74	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	74	11	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	74	12	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	74	13	in	in	IN
22283	74	14	response	response	NN
22283	74	15	to	to	IN
22283	74	16	suitable	suitable	JJ
22283	74	17	stimulation	stimulation	NN
22283	74	18	;	;	:
22283	74	19	but	but	CC
22283	74	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	74	21	are	be	VBP
22283	74	22	no	no	RB
22283	74	23	longer	longer	RB
22283	74	24	under	under	IN
22283	74	25	the	the	DT
22283	74	26	government	government	NN
22283	74	27	of	of	IN
22283	74	28	the	the	DT
22283	74	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	74	30	.	.	.
22283	75	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	75	2	,	,	,
22283	75	3	for	for	IN
22283	75	4	instance	instance	NN
22283	75	5	,	,	,
22283	75	6	when	when	WRB
22283	75	7	a	a	DT
22283	75	8	bird	bird	NN
22283	75	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	75	10	mutilated	mutilate	VBN
22283	75	11	in	in	IN
22283	75	12	this	this	DT
22283	75	13	way	way	NN
22283	75	14	,	,	,
22283	75	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	75	16	will	will	MD
22283	75	17	continue	continue	VB
22283	75	18	to	to	TO
22283	75	19	perform	perform	VB
22283	75	20	all	all	PDT
22283	75	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	75	22	reflex	reflex	JJ
22283	75	23	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	75	24	--	--	:
22283	75	25	such	such	JJ
22283	75	26	as	as	IN
22283	75	27	sitting	sit	VBG
22283	75	28	on	on	IN
22283	75	29	a	a	DT
22283	75	30	perch	perch	NN
22283	75	31	,	,	,
22283	75	32	using	use	VBG
22283	75	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	75	34	wings	wing	NNS
22283	75	35	when	when	WRB
22283	75	36	thrown	throw	VBN
22283	75	37	into	into	IN
22283	75	38	the	the	DT
22283	75	39	air	air	NN
22283	75	40	,	,	,
22283	75	41	and	and	CC
22283	75	42	so	so	RB
22283	75	43	forth	forth	RB
22283	75	44	;	;	:
22283	75	45	but	but	CC
22283	75	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	75	47	no	no	RB
22283	75	48	longer	long	RBR
22283	75	49	remembers	remember	VBZ
22283	75	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	75	51	nest	nest	NN
22283	75	52	or	or	CC
22283	75	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	75	54	young	young	JJ
22283	75	55	,	,	,
22283	75	56	and	and	CC
22283	75	57	will	will	MD
22283	75	58	starve	starve	VB
22283	75	59	to	to	IN
22283	75	60	death	death	NN
22283	75	61	in	in	IN
22283	75	62	the	the	DT
22283	75	63	midst	midst	NN
22283	75	64	of	of	IN
22283	75	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	75	66	food	food	NN
22283	75	67	,	,	,
22283	75	68	unless	unless	IN
22283	75	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	75	70	be	be	VB
22283	75	71	fed	feed	VBN
22283	75	72	artificially	artificially	RB
22283	75	73	.	.	.
22283	76	1	Again	again	RB
22283	76	2	,	,	,
22283	76	3	if	if	IN
22283	76	4	the	the	DT
22283	76	5	grey	grey	JJ
22283	76	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	76	7	of	of	IN
22283	76	8	only	only	RB
22283	76	9	one	one	CD
22283	76	10	hemisphere	hemisphere	NN
22283	76	11	be	be	VB
22283	76	12	removed	remove	VBN
22283	76	13	,	,	,
22283	76	14	the	the	DT
22283	76	15	mind	mind	NN
22283	76	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	76	17	taken	take	VBN
22283	76	18	away	away	RB
22283	76	19	from	from	IN
22283	76	20	the	the	DT
22283	76	21	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	76	22	(	(	-LRB-
22283	76	23	i.	i.	NNP
22283	76	24	e.	e.	NNP
22283	76	25	the	the	DT
22283	76	26	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	76	27	)	)	-RRB-
22283	76	28	side	side	NN
22283	76	29	of	of	IN
22283	76	30	the	the	DT
22283	76	31	body	body	NN
22283	76	32	,	,	,
22283	76	33	while	while	IN
22283	76	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	76	35	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	76	36	intact	intact	JJ
22283	76	37	on	on	IN
22283	76	38	the	the	DT
22283	76	39	other	other	JJ
22283	76	40	side	side	NN
22283	76	41	.	.	.
22283	77	1	For	for	IN
22283	77	2	example	example	NN
22283	77	3	,	,	,
22283	77	4	if	if	IN
22283	77	5	a	a	DT
22283	77	6	dog	dog	NN
22283	77	7	be	be	VB
22283	77	8	deprived	deprive	VBN
22283	77	9	of	of	IN
22283	77	10	one	one	CD
22283	77	11	hemisphere	hemisphere	NN
22283	77	12	,	,	,
22283	77	13	the	the	DT
22283	77	14	eye	eye	NN
22283	77	15	which	which	WDT
22283	77	16	was	be	VBD
22283	77	17	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	77	18	from	from	IN
22283	77	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	77	20	with	with	IN
22283	77	21	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	77	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	77	23	fibres	fibre	NNS
22283	77	24	continues	continue	VBZ
22283	77	25	able	able	JJ
22283	77	26	to	to	TO
22283	77	27	see	see	VB
22283	77	28	,	,	,
22283	77	29	or	or	CC
22283	77	30	to	to	TO
22283	77	31	transmit	transmit	VB
22283	77	32	impressions	impression	NNS
22283	77	33	to	to	IN
22283	77	34	the	the	DT
22283	77	35	lower	low	JJR
22283	77	36	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	77	37	-	-	HYPH
22283	77	38	centre	centre	NNP
22283	77	39	called	call	VBD
22283	77	40	the	the	DT
22283	77	41	optic	optic	JJ
22283	77	42	ganglion	ganglion	NN
22283	77	43	;	;	:
22283	77	44	for	for	IN
22283	77	45	this	this	DT
22283	77	46	eye	eye	NN
22283	77	47	will	will	MD
22283	77	48	then	then	RB
22283	77	49	mechanically	mechanically	RB
22283	77	50	follow	follow	VB
22283	77	51	the	the	DT
22283	77	52	hand	hand	NN
22283	77	53	waved	wave	VBD
22283	77	54	in	in	IN
22283	77	55	front	front	NN
22283	77	56	of	of	IN
22283	77	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	77	58	.	.	.
22283	78	1	But	but	CC
22283	78	2	if	if	IN
22283	78	3	the	the	DT
22283	78	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	78	5	should	should	MD
22283	78	6	hold	hold	VB
22283	78	7	a	a	DT
22283	78	8	piece	piece	NN
22283	78	9	of	of	IN
22283	78	10	meat	meat	NN
22283	78	11	,	,	,
22283	78	12	the	the	DT
22283	78	13	dog	dog	NN
22283	78	14	will	will	MD
22283	78	15	show	show	VB
22283	78	16	no	no	DT
22283	78	17	mental	mental	JJ
22283	78	18	recognition	recognition	NN
22283	78	19	of	of	IN
22283	78	20	the	the	DT
22283	78	21	meat	meat	NN
22283	78	22	,	,	,
22283	78	23	which	which	WDT
22283	78	24	of	of	IN
22283	78	25	course	course	NN
22283	78	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	78	27	will	will	MD
22283	78	28	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	78	29	seize	seize	VB
22283	78	30	if	if	IN
22283	78	31	exposed	expose	VBN
22283	78	32	to	to	IN
22283	78	33	the	the	DT
22283	78	34	view	view	NN
22283	78	35	of	of	IN
22283	78	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	78	37	other	other	JJ
22283	78	38	eye	eye	NN
22283	78	39	.	.	.
22283	79	1	The	the	DT
22283	79	2	same	same	JJ
22283	79	3	thing	thing	NN
22283	79	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	79	5	found	find	VBN
22283	79	6	to	to	TO
22283	79	7	happen	happen	VB
22283	79	8	in	in	IN
22283	79	9	the	the	DT
22283	79	10	case	case	NN
22283	79	11	of	of	IN
22283	79	12	birds	bird	NNS
22283	79	13	:	:	:
22283	79	14	on	on	IN
22283	79	15	the	the	DT
22283	79	16	injured	injured	JJ
22283	79	17	side	side	NN
22283	79	18	_	_	NNP
22283	79	19	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	79	20	_	_	NNP
22283	79	21	,	,	,
22283	79	22	or	or	CC
22283	79	23	the	the	DT
22283	79	24	power	power	NN
22283	79	25	of	of	IN
22283	79	26	responding	respond	VBG
22283	79	27	to	to	IN
22283	79	28	a	a	DT
22283	79	29	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	79	30	,	,	,
22283	79	31	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	79	32	intact	intact	JJ
22283	79	33	;	;	:
22283	79	34	while	while	IN
22283	79	35	_	_	NNP
22283	79	36	perception	perception	NN
22283	79	37	_	_	NNP
22283	79	38	,	,	,
22283	79	39	or	or	CC
22283	79	40	the	the	DT
22283	79	41	power	power	NN
22283	79	42	of	of	IN
22283	79	43	mental	mental	JJ
22283	79	44	recognition	recognition	NN
22283	79	45	,	,	,
22283	79	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	79	47	destroyed	destroy	VBN
22283	79	48	.	.	.
22283	80	1	This	this	DT
22283	80	2	description	description	NN
22283	80	3	applies	apply	VBZ
22283	80	4	to	to	IN
22283	80	5	the	the	DT
22283	80	6	grey	grey	JJ
22283	80	7	matter	matter	NN
22283	80	8	of	of	IN
22283	80	9	the	the	DT
22283	80	10	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	80	11	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	80	12	as	as	IN
22283	80	13	a	a	DT
22283	80	14	whole	whole	NN
22283	80	15	.	.	.
22283	81	1	But	but	CC
22283	81	2	of	of	IN
22283	81	3	course	course	NN
22283	81	4	the	the	DT
22283	81	5	question	question	NN
22283	81	6	next	next	JJ
22283	81	7	arises	arise	NNS
22283	81	8	whether	whether	IN
22283	81	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	81	10	only	only	RB
22283	81	11	acts	act	VBZ
22283	81	12	as	as	IN
22283	81	13	a	a	DT
22283	81	14	whole	whole	NN
22283	81	15	,	,	,
22283	81	16	or	or	CC
22283	81	17	whether	whether	IN
22283	81	18	there	there	EX
22283	81	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	81	20	any	any	DT
22283	81	21	localization	localization	NN
22283	81	22	of	of	IN
22283	81	23	different	different	JJ
22283	81	24	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
22283	81	25	faculties	faculty	NNS
22283	81	26	in	in	IN
22283	81	27	different	different	JJ
22283	81	28	parts	part	NNS
22283	81	29	of	of	IN
22283	81	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	81	31	.	.	.
22283	82	1	Now	now	RB
22283	82	2	,	,	,
22283	82	3	in	in	IN
22283	82	4	answer	answer	NN
22283	82	5	to	to	IN
22283	82	6	this	this	DT
22283	82	7	question	question	NN
22283	82	8	,	,	,
22283	82	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	82	10	has	have	VBZ
22283	82	11	long	long	RB
22283	82	12	been	be	VBN
22283	82	13	known	know	VBN
22283	82	14	that	that	IN
22283	82	15	the	the	DT
22283	82	16	faculty	faculty	NN
22283	82	17	of	of	IN
22283	82	18	speech	speech	NN
22283	82	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	82	20	definitely	definitely	RB
22283	82	21	localized	localize	VBN
22283	82	22	in	in	IN
22283	82	23	a	a	DT
22283	82	24	part	part	NN
22283	82	25	of	of	IN
22283	82	26	the	the	DT
22283	82	27	grey	grey	NNP
22283	82	28	matter	matter	NN
22283	82	29	lying	lie	VBG
22283	82	30	just	just	RB
22283	82	31	behind	behind	IN
22283	82	32	the	the	DT
22283	82	33	forehead	forehead	NN
22283	82	34	;	;	:
22283	82	35	for	for	IN
22283	82	36	,	,	,
22283	82	37	when	when	WRB
22283	82	38	this	this	DT
22283	82	39	part	part	NN
22283	82	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	82	41	injured	injure	VBN
22283	82	42	,	,	,
22283	82	43	a	a	DT
22283	82	44	man	man	NN
22283	82	45	loses	lose	VBZ
22283	82	46	all	all	DT
22283	82	47	power	power	NN
22283	82	48	of	of	IN
22283	82	49	expressing	express	VBG
22283	82	50	even	even	RB
22283	82	51	the	the	DT
22283	82	52	most	most	RBS
22283	82	53	simple	simple	JJ
22283	82	54	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	82	55	in	in	IN
22283	82	56	words	word	NNS
22283	82	57	,	,	,
22283	82	58	while	while	IN
22283	82	59	the	the	DT
22283	82	60	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	82	61	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	82	62	remain	remain	VBP
22283	82	63	as	as	RB
22283	82	64	clear	clear	JJ
22283	82	65	as	as	IN
22283	82	66	ever	ever	RB
22283	82	67	.	.	.
22283	83	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	83	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	83	3	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
22283	83	4	that	that	IN
22283	83	5	in	in	IN
22283	83	6	each	each	DT
22283	83	7	individual	individual	NN
22283	83	8	only	only	RB
22283	83	9	this	this	DT
22283	83	10	part	part	NN
22283	83	11	of	of	IN
22283	83	12	one	one	CD
22283	83	13	hemisphere	hemisphere	NN
22283	83	14	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	83	15	to	to	TO
22283	83	16	be	be	VB
22283	83	17	used	use	VBN
22283	83	18	;	;	:
22283	83	19	and	and	CC
22283	83	20	there	there	EX
22283	83	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	83	22	some	some	DT
22283	83	23	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	83	24	to	to	TO
22283	83	25	show	show	VB
22283	83	26	that	that	IN
22283	83	27	left	left	JJ
22283	83	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	83	29	handed	handed	JJ
22283	83	30	persons	person	NNS
22283	83	31	use	use	VBP
22283	83	32	the	the	DT
22283	83	33	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	83	34	side	side	NN
22283	83	35	from	from	IN
22283	83	36	right	right	JJ
22283	83	37	-	-	HYPH
22283	83	38	handed	handed	JJ
22283	83	39	.	.	.
22283	84	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
22283	84	2	,	,	,
22283	84	3	when	when	WRB
22283	84	4	the	the	DT
22283	84	5	side	side	NN
22283	84	6	which	which	WDT
22283	84	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	84	8	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	84	9	in	in	IN
22283	84	10	use	use	NN
22283	84	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	84	12	destroyed	destroy	VBN
22283	84	13	,	,	,
22283	84	14	the	the	DT
22283	84	15	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	84	16	part	part	NN
22283	84	17	of	of	IN
22283	84	18	the	the	DT
22283	84	19	other	other	JJ
22283	84	20	hemisphere	hemisphere	NN
22283	84	21	begins	begin	VBZ
22283	84	22	to	to	TO
22283	84	23	learn	learn	VB
22283	84	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	84	25	work	work	NN
22283	84	26	,	,	,
22283	84	27	so	so	IN
22283	84	28	that	that	IN
22283	84	29	the	the	DT
22283	84	30	patient	patient	NN
22283	84	31	may	may	MD
22283	84	32	in	in	IN
22283	84	33	time	time	NN
22283	84	34	recover	recover	VB
22283	84	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	84	36	use	use	NN
22283	84	37	of	of	IN
22283	84	38	language	language	NN
22283	84	39	.	.	.
22283	85	1	Within	within	IN
22283	85	2	the	the	DT
22283	85	3	last	last	JJ
22283	85	4	few	few	JJ
22283	85	5	years	year	NNS
22283	85	6	the	the	DT
22283	85	7	important	important	JJ
22283	85	8	discovery	discovery	NN
22283	85	9	has	have	VBZ
22283	85	10	been	be	VBN
22283	85	11	made	make	VBN
22283	85	12	,	,	,
22283	85	13	that	that	IN
22283	85	14	by	by	IN
22283	85	15	stimulating	stimulate	VBG
22283	85	16	with	with	IN
22283	85	17	electricity	electricity	NN
22283	85	18	the	the	DT
22283	85	19	surface	surface	NN
22283	85	20	of	of	IN
22283	85	21	the	the	DT
22283	85	22	grey	grey	JJ
22283	85	23	matter	matter	NN
22283	85	24	of	of	IN
22283	85	25	the	the	DT
22283	85	26	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	85	27	,	,	,
22283	85	28	muscular	muscular	JJ
22283	85	29	movements	movement	NNS
22283	85	30	are	be	VBP
22283	85	31	evoked	evoke	VBN
22283	85	32	;	;	:
22283	85	33	and	and	CC
22283	85	34	that	that	IN
22283	85	35	certain	certain	JJ
22283	85	36	patches	patch	NNS
22283	85	37	of	of	IN
22283	85	38	the	the	DT
22283	85	39	grey	grey	JJ
22283	85	40	matter	matter	NN
22283	85	41	,	,	,
22283	85	42	when	when	WRB
22283	85	43	thus	thus	RB
22283	85	44	stimulated	stimulate	VBD
22283	85	45	,	,	,
22283	85	46	always	always	RB
22283	85	47	throw	throw	VB
22283	85	48	into	into	IN
22283	85	49	action	action	NN
22283	85	50	the	the	DT
22283	85	51	same	same	JJ
22283	85	52	groups	group	NNS
22283	85	53	of	of	IN
22283	85	54	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	85	55	.	.	.
22283	86	1	In	in	IN
22283	86	2	other	other	JJ
22283	86	3	words	word	NNS
22283	86	4	,	,	,
22283	86	5	there	there	EX
22283	86	6	are	be	VBP
22283	86	7	definite	definite	JJ
22283	86	8	local	local	JJ
22283	86	9	areas	area	NNS
22283	86	10	of	of	IN
22283	86	11	grey	grey	NNP
22283	86	12	matter	matter	NNP
22283	86	13	,	,	,
22283	86	14	which	which	WDT
22283	86	15	,	,	,
22283	86	16	when	when	WRB
22283	86	17	stimulated	stimulate	VBN
22283	86	18	,	,	,
22283	86	19	throw	throw	VBP
22283	86	20	into	into	IN
22283	86	21	action	action	NN
22283	86	22	definite	definite	JJ
22283	86	23	groups	group	NNS
22283	86	24	of	of	IN
22283	86	25	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	86	26	.	.	.
22283	87	1	The	the	DT
22283	87	2	surface	surface	NN
22283	87	3	of	of	IN
22283	87	4	the	the	DT
22283	87	5	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	87	6	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	87	7	has	have	VBZ
22283	87	8	now	now	RB
22283	87	9	been	be	VBN
22283	87	10	in	in	IN
22283	87	11	large	large	JJ
22283	87	12	measure	measure	NN
22283	87	13	explored	explore	VBN
22283	87	14	and	and	CC
22283	87	15	mapped	map	VBN
22283	87	16	out	out	RP
22283	87	17	with	with	IN
22283	87	18	reference	reference	NN
22283	87	19	to	to	IN
22283	87	20	these	these	DT
22283	87	21	so	so	RB
22283	87	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	87	23	called	call	VBN
22283	87	24	motor	motor	NN
22283	87	25	-	-	HYPH
22283	87	26	centres	centre	NNS
22283	87	27	;	;	:
22283	87	28	and	and	CC
22283	87	29	thus	thus	RB
22283	87	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	87	31	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	87	32	of	of	IN
22283	87	33	the	the	DT
22283	87	34	neuro	neuro	NNP
22283	87	35	-	-	HYPH
22283	87	36	muscular	muscular	JJ
22283	87	37	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	87	38	of	of	IN
22283	87	39	the	the	DT
22283	87	40	higher	high	JJR
22283	87	41	animals	animal	NNS
22283	87	42	(	(	-LRB-
22283	87	43	including	include	VBG
22283	87	44	man	man	NN
22283	87	45	)	)	-RRB-
22283	87	46	has	have	VBZ
22283	87	47	been	be	VBN
22283	87	48	very	very	RB
22283	87	49	greatly	greatly	RB
22283	87	50	furthered	further	VBN
22283	87	51	.	.	.
22283	88	1	Here	here	RB
22283	88	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	88	3	may	may	MD
22283	88	4	observe	observe	VB
22283	88	5	parenthetically	parenthetically	RB
22283	88	6	that	that	DT
22283	88	7	,	,	,
22283	88	8	as	as	IN
22283	88	9	the	the	DT
22283	88	10	brain	brain	NN
22283	88	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	88	12	insentient	insentient	JJ
22283	88	13	to	to	IN
22283	88	14	injuries	injury	NNS
22283	88	15	inflicted	inflict	VBN
22283	88	16	upon	upon	IN
22283	88	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	88	18	own	own	JJ
22283	88	19	substance	substance	NN
22283	88	20	,	,	,
22283	88	21	none	none	NN
22283	88	22	of	of	IN
22283	88	23	the	the	DT
22283	88	24	experiments	experiment	NNS
22283	88	25	to	to	TO
22283	88	26	which	which	WDT
22283	88	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	88	28	have	have	VBP
22283	88	29	alluded	allude	VBN
22283	88	30	entail	entail	NN
22283	88	31	any	any	DT
22283	88	32	suffering	suffering	NN
22283	88	33	to	to	IN
22283	88	34	the	the	DT
22283	88	35	animals	animal	NNS
22283	88	36	experimented	experiment	VBN
22283	88	37	upon	upon	IN
22283	88	38	;	;	:
22283	88	39	and	and	CC
22283	88	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	88	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	88	42	evident	evident	JJ
22283	88	43	that	that	IN
22283	88	44	the	the	DT
22283	88	45	important	important	JJ
22283	88	46	information	information	NN
22283	88	47	which	which	WDT
22283	88	48	has	have	VBZ
22283	88	49	thus	thus	RB
22283	88	50	been	be	VBN
22283	88	51	gained	gain	VBN
22283	88	52	could	could	MD
22283	88	53	not	not	RB
22283	88	54	have	have	VB
22283	88	55	been	be	VBN
22283	88	56	gained	gain	VBN
22283	88	57	by	by	IN
22283	88	58	any	any	DT
22283	88	59	other	other	JJ
22283	88	60	method	method	NN
22283	88	61	.	.	.
22283	89	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	89	2	may	may	MD
22283	89	3	also	also	RB
22283	89	4	observe	observe	VB
22283	89	5	that	that	IN
22283	89	6	as	as	IN
22283	89	7	these	these	DT
22283	89	8	motor	motor	NN
22283	89	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	89	10	centres	centre	NNS
22283	89	11	occur	occur	VBP
22283	89	12	in	in	IN
22283	89	13	the	the	DT
22283	89	14	grey	grey	JJ
22283	89	15	matter	matter	NN
22283	89	16	of	of	IN
22283	89	17	the	the	DT
22283	89	18	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	89	19	,	,	,
22283	89	20	a	a	DT
22283	89	21	strong	strong	JJ
22283	89	22	probability	probability	NN
22283	89	23	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	89	24	that	that	IN
22283	89	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	89	26	are	be	VBP
22283	89	27	not	not	RB
22283	89	28	only	only	RB
22283	89	29	the	the	DT
22283	89	30	motor	motor	NN
22283	89	31	-	-	HYPH
22283	89	32	centres	centre	NNS
22283	89	33	,	,	,
22283	89	34	but	but	CC
22283	89	35	also	also	RB
22283	89	36	the	the	DT
22283	89	37	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	89	38	centres	centre	NNS
22283	89	39	which	which	WDT
22283	89	40	originate	originate	VBP
22283	89	41	the	the	DT
22283	89	42	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
22283	89	43	commands	command	NNS
22283	89	44	for	for	IN
22283	89	45	the	the	DT
22283	89	46	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	89	47	of	of	IN
22283	89	48	this	this	DT
22283	89	49	and	and	CC
22283	89	50	that	that	DT
22283	89	51	group	group	NN
22283	89	52	of	of	IN
22283	89	53	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	89	54	.	.	.
22283	90	1	Unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
22283	90	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	90	3	can	can	MD
22283	90	4	not	not	RB
22283	90	5	interrogate	interrogate	VB
22283	90	6	an	an	DT
22283	90	7	animal	animal	NN
22283	90	8	whether	whether	IN
22283	90	9	,	,	,
22283	90	10	when	when	WRB
22283	90	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	90	12	stimulate	stimulate	VBP
22283	90	13	a	a	DT
22283	90	14	motor	motor	NN
22283	90	15	-	-	HYPH
22283	90	16	centre	centre	NN
22283	90	17	,	,	,
22283	90	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	90	19	arouse	arouse	VBP
22283	90	20	in	in	IN
22283	90	21	the	the	DT
22283	90	22	animal	animal	NN
22283	90	23	's	's	POS
22283	90	24	mind	mind	NN
22283	90	25	an	an	DT
22283	90	26	act	act	NN
22283	90	27	of	of	IN
22283	90	28	will	will	NN
22283	90	29	to	to	TO
22283	90	30	throw	throw	VB
22283	90	31	the	the	DT
22283	90	32	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	90	33	group	group	NN
22283	90	34	of	of	IN
22283	90	35	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	90	36	into	into	IN
22283	90	37	action	action	NN
22283	90	38	;	;	:
22283	90	39	but	but	CC
22283	90	40	that	that	IN
22283	90	41	these	these	DT
22283	90	42	motor	motor	NN
22283	90	43	-	-	HYPH
22283	90	44	centres	centre	NNS
22283	90	45	are	be	VBP
22283	90	46	really	really	RB
22283	90	47	centres	centre	NNS
22283	90	48	of	of	IN
22283	90	49	volition	volition	NN
22283	90	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	90	51	pointed	point	VBN
22283	90	52	to	to	IN
22283	90	53	by	by	IN
22283	90	54	the	the	DT
22283	90	55	fact	fact	NN
22283	90	56	,	,	,
22283	90	57	that	that	IN
22283	90	58	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	90	59	stimuli	stimulus	NNS
22283	90	60	have	have	VBP
22283	90	61	no	no	RB
22283	90	62	longer	longer	RB
22283	90	63	any	any	DT
22283	90	64	effect	effect	NN
22283	90	65	upon	upon	IN
22283	90	66	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	90	67	when	when	WRB
22283	90	68	the	the	DT
22283	90	69	mental	mental	JJ
22283	90	70	faculties	faculty	NNS
22283	90	71	of	of	IN
22283	90	72	the	the	DT
22283	90	73	animal	animal	NN
22283	90	74	are	be	VBP
22283	90	75	suspended	suspend	VBN
22283	90	76	by	by	IN
22283	90	77	anæsthetics	anæsthetic	NNS
22283	90	78	,	,	,
22283	90	79	nor	nor	CC
22283	90	80	in	in	IN
22283	90	81	the	the	DT
22283	90	82	case	case	NN
22283	90	83	of	of	IN
22283	90	84	young	young	JJ
22283	90	85	animals	animal	NNS
22283	90	86	where	where	WRB
22283	90	87	the	the	DT
22283	90	88	mental	mental	JJ
22283	90	89	faculties	faculty	NNS
22283	90	90	have	have	VBP
22283	90	91	not	not	RB
22283	90	92	yet	yet	RB
22283	90	93	been	be	VBN
22283	90	94	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
22283	90	95	developed	develop	VBN
22283	90	96	to	to	TO
22283	90	97	admit	admit	VB
22283	90	98	of	of	IN
22283	90	99	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	90	100	co	co	NN
22283	90	101	-	-	NN
22283	90	102	ordination	ordination	NN
22283	90	103	among	among	IN
22283	90	104	the	the	DT
22283	90	105	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	90	106	which	which	WDT
22283	90	107	are	be	VBP
22283	90	108	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	90	109	.	.	.
22283	91	1	On	on	IN
22283	91	2	the	the	DT
22283	91	3	whole	whole	NN
22283	91	4	,	,	,
22283	91	5	then	then	RB
22283	91	6	,	,	,
22283	91	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	91	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	91	9	not	not	RB
22283	91	10	improbable	improbable	JJ
22283	91	11	that	that	IN
22283	91	12	on	on	IN
22283	91	13	stimulating	stimulate	VBG
22283	91	14	artificially	artificially	RB
22283	91	15	these	these	DT
22283	91	16	motor	motor	NN
22283	91	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	91	18	centres	centre	NNS
22283	91	19	of	of	IN
22283	91	20	the	the	DT
22283	91	21	brain	brain	NN
22283	91	22	,	,	,
22283	91	23	a	a	DT
22283	91	24	physiologist	physiologist	NN
22283	91	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	91	26	actually	actually	RB
22283	91	27	playing	play	VBG
22283	91	28	from	from	IN
22283	91	29	without	without	IN
22283	91	30	,	,	,
22283	91	31	and	and	CC
22283	91	32	at	at	IN
22283	91	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	91	34	own	own	JJ
22283	91	35	pleasure	pleasure	NN
22283	91	36	,	,	,
22283	91	37	upon	upon	IN
22283	91	38	the	the	DT
22283	91	39	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	91	40	of	of	IN
22283	91	41	the	the	DT
22283	91	42	animal	animal	NN
22283	91	43	.	.	.
22283	92	1	Turning	turn	VBG
22283	92	2	,	,	,
22283	92	3	now	now	RB
22283	92	4	,	,	,
22283	92	5	from	from	IN
22283	92	6	this	this	DT
22283	92	7	brief	brief	JJ
22283	92	8	description	description	NN
22283	92	9	of	of	IN
22283	92	10	the	the	DT
22283	92	11	structure	structure	NN
22283	92	12	and	and	CC
22283	92	13	leading	leading	JJ
22283	92	14	functions	function	NNS
22283	92	15	of	of	IN
22283	92	16	the	the	DT
22283	92	17	principal	principal	JJ
22283	92	18	parts	part	NNS
22283	92	19	of	of	IN
22283	92	20	the	the	DT
22283	92	21	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	92	22	system	system	NN
22283	92	23	,	,	,
22283	92	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	92	25	propose	propose	VBP
22283	92	26	to	to	TO
22283	92	27	consider	consider	VB
22283	92	28	what	what	WP
22283	92	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	92	30	know	know	VBP
22283	92	31	about	about	IN
22283	92	32	the	the	DT
22283	92	33	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	92	34	movements	movement	NNS
22283	92	35	which	which	WDT
22283	92	36	go	go	VBP
22283	92	37	on	on	RP
22283	92	38	in	in	IN
22283	92	39	different	different	JJ
22283	92	40	parts	part	NNS
22283	92	41	of	of	IN
22283	92	42	this	this	DT
22283	92	43	system	system	NN
22283	92	44	,	,	,
22283	92	45	and	and	CC
22283	92	46	which	which	WDT
22283	92	47	are	be	VBP
22283	92	48	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	92	49	in	in	IN
22283	92	50	all	all	PDT
22283	92	51	the	the	DT
22283	92	52	processes	process	NNS
22283	92	53	of	of	IN
22283	92	54	reflex	reflex	JJ
22283	92	55	adjustment	adjustment	NN
22283	92	56	,	,	,
22283	92	57	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	92	58	,	,	,
22283	92	59	perception	perception	NN
22283	92	60	,	,	,
22283	92	61	emotion	emotion	NN
22283	92	62	,	,	,
22283	92	63	instinct	instinct	NN
22283	92	64	,	,	,
22283	92	65	thought	think	VBD
22283	92	66	,	,	,
22283	92	67	and	and	CC
22283	92	68	volition	volition	NN
22283	92	69	.	.	.
22283	93	1	First	first	RB
22283	93	2	of	of	IN
22283	93	3	all	all	DT
22283	93	4	,	,	,
22283	93	5	the	the	DT
22283	93	6	rate	rate	NN
22283	93	7	at	at	IN
22283	93	8	which	which	WDT
22283	93	9	these	these	DT
22283	93	10	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	93	11	movements	movement	NNS
22283	93	12	travel	travel	VBP
22283	93	13	through	through	IN
22283	93	14	a	a	DT
22283	93	15	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	93	16	has	have	VBZ
22283	93	17	been	be	VBN
22283	93	18	measured	measure	VBN
22283	93	19	,	,	,
22283	93	20	and	and	CC
22283	93	21	found	find	VBN
22283	93	22	to	to	TO
22283	93	23	be	be	VB
22283	93	24	about	about	RB
22283	93	25	100	100	CD
22283	93	26	feet	foot	NNS
22283	93	27	per	per	IN
22283	93	28	second	second	NN
22283	93	29	,	,	,
22283	93	30	or	or	CC
22283	93	31	somewhat	somewhat	RB
22283	93	32	more	more	JJR
22283	93	33	than	than	IN
22283	93	34	a	a	DT
22283	93	35	mile	mile	NN
22283	93	36	a	a	DT
22283	93	37	minute	minute	NN
22283	93	38	,	,	,
22283	93	39	in	in	IN
22283	93	40	the	the	DT
22283	93	41	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	93	42	of	of	IN
22283	93	43	a	a	DT
22283	93	44	frog	frog	NN
22283	93	45	.	.	.
22283	94	1	In	in	IN
22283	94	2	the	the	DT
22283	94	3	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	94	4	of	of	IN
22283	94	5	a	a	DT
22283	94	6	mammal	mammal	NN
22283	94	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	94	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	94	9	just	just	RB
22283	94	10	about	about	RB
22283	94	11	twice	twice	RB
22283	94	12	as	as	RB
22283	94	13	fast	fast	RB
22283	94	14	;	;	:
22283	94	15	so	so	IN
22283	94	16	that	that	IN
22283	94	17	if	if	IN
22283	94	18	London	London	NNP
22283	94	19	were	be	VBD
22283	94	20	connected	connect	VBN
22283	94	21	with	with	IN
22283	94	22	New	New	NNP
22283	94	23	York	York	NNP
22283	94	24	by	by	IN
22283	94	25	means	mean	NNS
22283	94	26	of	of	IN
22283	94	27	a	a	DT
22283	94	28	mammalian	mammalian	JJ
22283	94	29	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	94	30	instead	instead	RB
22283	94	31	of	of	IN
22283	94	32	an	an	DT
22283	94	33	electric	electric	JJ
22283	94	34	cable	cable	NN
22283	94	35	,	,	,
22283	94	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	94	37	would	would	MD
22283	94	38	require	require	VB
22283	94	39	nearly	nearly	RB
22283	94	40	a	a	DT
22283	94	41	whole	whole	JJ
22283	94	42	day	day	NN
22283	94	43	for	for	IN
22283	94	44	a	a	DT
22283	94	45	message	message	NN
22283	94	46	to	to	TO
22283	94	47	pass	pass	VB
22283	94	48	.	.	.
22283	95	1	Next	next	RB
22283	95	2	,	,	,
22283	95	3	the	the	DT
22283	95	4	time	time	NN
22283	95	5	has	have	VBZ
22283	95	6	also	also	RB
22283	95	7	been	be	VBN
22283	95	8	measured	measure	VBN
22283	95	9	which	which	WDT
22283	95	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	95	11	required	require	VBN
22283	95	12	by	by	IN
22283	95	13	a	a	DT
22283	95	14	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	95	15	-	-	HYPH
22283	95	16	centre	centre	NN
22283	95	17	to	to	TO
22283	95	18	perform	perform	VB
22283	95	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	95	20	part	part	NN
22283	95	21	in	in	IN
22283	95	22	a	a	DT
22283	95	23	reflex	reflex	JJ
22283	95	24	action	action	NN
22283	95	25	,	,	,
22283	95	26	where	where	WRB
22283	95	27	no	no	DT
22283	95	28	thought	thought	NN
22283	95	29	or	or	CC
22283	95	30	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	95	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	95	32	involved	involve	VBN
22283	95	33	.	.	.
22283	96	1	This	this	DT
22283	96	2	time	time	NN
22283	96	3	,	,	,
22283	96	4	in	in	IN
22283	96	5	the	the	DT
22283	96	6	case	case	NN
22283	96	7	of	of	IN
22283	96	8	the	the	DT
22283	96	9	winking	wink	VBG
22283	96	10	reflex	reflex	NN
22283	96	11	,	,	,
22283	96	12	and	and	CC
22283	96	13	apart	apart	RB
22283	96	14	from	from	IN
22283	96	15	the	the	DT
22283	96	16	time	time	NN
22283	96	17	required	require	VBN
22283	96	18	for	for	IN
22283	96	19	the	the	DT
22283	96	20	passage	passage	NN
22283	96	21	of	of	IN
22283	96	22	the	the	DT
22283	96	23	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	96	24	waves	wave	NNS
22283	96	25	up	up	RP
22283	96	26	and	and	CC
22283	96	27	down	down	IN
22283	96	28	the	the	DT
22283	96	29	sensory	sensory	NN
22283	96	30	and	and	CC
22283	96	31	motor	motor	NN
22283	96	32	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	96	33	,	,	,
22283	96	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	96	35	about	about	IN
22283	96	36	1/20	1/20	CD
22283	96	37	of	of	IN
22283	96	38	a	a	DT
22283	96	39	second	second	NN
22283	96	40	.	.	.
22283	97	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	97	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	97	3	the	the	DT
22283	97	4	rate	rate	NN
22283	97	5	at	at	IN
22283	97	6	which	which	WDT
22283	97	7	a	a	DT
22283	97	8	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	97	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	97	10	centre	centre	NN
22283	97	11	conducts	conduct	VBZ
22283	97	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	97	13	operations	operation	NNS
22283	97	14	when	when	WRB
22283	97	15	no	no	DT
22283	97	16	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	97	17	or	or	CC
22283	97	18	volition	volition	NN
22283	97	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	97	20	involved	involve	VBN
22283	97	21	.	.	.
22283	98	1	But	but	CC
22283	98	2	when	when	WRB
22283	98	3	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	98	4	and	and	CC
22283	98	5	volition	volition	NN
22283	98	6	are	be	VBP
22283	98	7	involved	involve	VBN
22283	98	8	,	,	,
22283	98	9	or	or	CC
22283	98	10	when	when	WRB
22283	98	11	the	the	DT
22283	98	12	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	98	13	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	98	14	are	be	VBP
22283	98	15	called	call	VBN
22283	98	16	into	into	IN
22283	98	17	play	play	NN
22283	98	18	,	,	,
22283	98	19	the	the	DT
22283	98	20	time	time	NN
22283	98	21	required	require	VBN
22283	98	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	98	23	considerably	considerably	RB
22283	98	24	greater	great	JJR
22283	98	25	.	.	.
22283	99	1	For	for	IN
22283	99	2	the	the	DT
22283	99	3	operations	operation	NNS
22283	99	4	on	on	IN
22283	99	5	the	the	DT
22283	99	6	part	part	NN
22283	99	7	of	of	IN
22283	99	8	the	the	DT
22283	99	9	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	99	10	which	which	WDT
22283	99	11	are	be	VBP
22283	99	12	comprised	comprise	VBN
22283	99	13	in	in	IN
22283	99	14	perceiving	perceive	VBG
22283	99	15	a	a	DT
22283	99	16	simple	simple	JJ
22283	99	17	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	99	18	(	(	-LRB-
22283	99	19	such	such	JJ
22283	99	20	as	as	IN
22283	99	21	an	an	DT
22283	99	22	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	99	23	shock	shock	NN
22283	99	24	)	)	-RRB-
22283	99	25	and	and	CC
22283	99	26	the	the	DT
22283	99	27	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	99	28	act	act	NN
22283	99	29	of	of	IN
22283	99	30	signalling	signal	VBG
22283	99	31	the	the	DT
22283	99	32	perception	perception	NN
22283	99	33	,	,	,
22283	99	34	can	can	MD
22283	99	35	not	not	RB
22283	99	36	be	be	VB
22283	99	37	performed	perform	VBN
22283	99	38	in	in	IN
22283	99	39	less	less	JJR
22283	99	40	than	than	IN
22283	99	41	1/12	1/12	CD
22283	99	42	of	of	IN
22283	99	43	a	a	DT
22283	99	44	second	second	NN
22283	99	45	,	,	,
22283	99	46	which	which	WDT
22283	99	47	is	be	VBZ
22283	99	48	nearly	nearly	RB
22283	99	49	twice	twice	RB
22283	99	50	as	as	RB
22283	99	51	long	long	RB
22283	99	52	as	as	IN
22283	99	53	the	the	DT
22283	99	54	time	time	NN
22283	99	55	required	require	VBN
22283	99	56	by	by	IN
22283	99	57	the	the	DT
22283	99	58	lower	low	JJR
22283	99	59	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	99	60	-	-	HYPH
22283	99	61	centres	centre	NNS
22283	99	62	for	for	IN
22283	99	63	the	the	DT
22283	99	64	performance	performance	NN
22283	99	65	of	of	IN
22283	99	66	a	a	DT
22283	99	67	reflex	reflex	JJ
22283	99	68	action	action	NN
22283	99	69	.	.	.
22283	100	1	Other	other	JJ
22283	100	2	experiments	experiment	NNS
22283	100	3	prove	prove	VBP
22283	100	4	that	that	IN
22283	100	5	the	the	DT
22283	100	6	more	more	RBR
22283	100	7	complex	complex	JJ
22283	100	8	an	an	DT
22283	100	9	act	act	NN
22283	100	10	of	of	IN
22283	100	11	perception	perception	NN
22283	100	12	,	,	,
22283	100	13	the	the	DT
22283	100	14	more	more	JJR
22283	100	15	time	time	NN
22283	100	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	100	17	required	require	VBN
22283	100	18	for	for	IN
22283	100	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	100	20	performance	performance	NN
22283	100	21	.	.	.
22283	101	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	101	2	,	,	,
22283	101	3	when	when	WRB
22283	101	4	the	the	DT
22283	101	5	experiment	experiment	NN
22283	101	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	101	7	made	make	VBN
22283	101	8	to	to	TO
22283	101	9	consist	consist	VB
22283	101	10	,	,	,
22283	101	11	not	not	RB
22283	101	12	merely	merely	RB
22283	101	13	in	in	IN
22283	101	14	signalling	signal	VBG
22283	101	15	a	a	DT
22283	101	16	perception	perception	NN
22283	101	17	,	,	,
22283	101	18	but	but	CC
22283	101	19	in	in	IN
22283	101	20	signalling	signal	VBG
22283	101	21	one	one	CD
22283	101	22	of	of	IN
22283	101	23	two	two	CD
22283	101	24	or	or	CC
22283	101	25	more	more	JJR
22283	101	26	perceptions	perception	NNS
22283	101	27	(	(	-LRB-
22283	101	28	such	such	JJ
22283	101	29	as	as	IN
22283	101	30	an	an	DT
22283	101	31	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	101	32	shock	shock	NN
22283	101	33	on	on	IN
22283	101	34	one	one	CD
22283	101	35	or	or	CC
22283	101	36	other	other	JJ
22283	101	37	of	of	IN
22283	101	38	the	the	DT
22283	101	39	two	two	CD
22283	101	40	hands	hand	NNS
22283	101	41	,	,	,
22283	101	42	which	which	WDT
22283	101	43	of	of	IN
22283	101	44	five	five	CD
22283	101	45	letters	letter	NNS
22283	101	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	101	47	suddenly	suddenly	RB
22283	101	48	exposed	expose	VBN
22283	101	49	to	to	IN
22283	101	50	view	view	NN
22283	101	51	,	,	,
22283	101	52	&	&	CC
22283	101	53	c.	c.	NNP
22283	101	54	)	)	-RRB-
22283	101	55	,	,	,
22283	101	56	a	a	DT
22283	101	57	longer	long	JJR
22283	101	58	time	time	NN
22283	101	59	is	be	VBZ
22283	101	60	required	require	VBN
22283	101	61	for	for	IN
22283	101	62	the	the	DT
22283	101	63	more	more	RBR
22283	101	64	complex	complex	JJ
22283	101	65	process	process	NN
22283	101	66	of	of	IN
22283	101	67	distinguishing	distinguishing	NN
22283	101	68	which	which	WDT
22283	101	69	of	of	IN
22283	101	70	the	the	DT
22283	101	71	two	two	CD
22283	101	72	or	or	CC
22283	101	73	more	more	JJR
22283	101	74	expected	expected	JJ
22283	101	75	stimuli	stimulus	NNS
22283	101	76	is	be	VBZ
22283	101	77	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	101	78	,	,	,
22283	101	79	and	and	CC
22283	101	80	in	in	IN
22283	101	81	determining	determine	VBG
22283	101	82	which	which	WDT
22283	101	83	of	of	IN
22283	101	84	the	the	DT
22283	101	85	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
22283	101	86	signals	signal	NNS
22283	101	87	to	to	TO
22283	101	88	make	make	VB
22283	101	89	in	in	IN
22283	101	90	response	response	NN
22283	101	91	.	.	.
22283	102	1	The	the	DT
22283	102	2	time	time	NN
22283	102	3	consumed	consume	VBN
22283	102	4	by	by	IN
22283	102	5	the	the	DT
22283	102	6	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	102	7	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	102	8	in	in	IN
22283	102	9	meeting	meet	VBG
22283	102	10	a	a	DT
22283	102	11	'	'	``
22283	102	12	dilemma	dilemma	NN
22283	102	13	'	'	''
22283	102	14	of	of	IN
22283	102	15	this	this	DT
22283	102	16	kind	kind	NN
22283	102	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	102	18	from	from	IN
22283	102	19	1/5	1/5	CD
22283	102	20	to	to	IN
22283	102	21	1/20	1/20	CD
22283	102	22	of	of	IN
22283	102	23	a	a	DT
22283	102	24	second	second	NN
22283	102	25	longer	long	RBR
22283	102	26	than	than	IN
22283	102	27	that	that	DT
22283	102	28	which	which	WDT
22283	102	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	102	30	consume	consume	VBP
22283	102	31	in	in	IN
22283	102	32	the	the	DT
22283	102	33	case	case	NN
22283	102	34	of	of	IN
22283	102	35	a	a	DT
22283	102	36	simpler	simple	JJR
22283	102	37	perception	perception	NN
22283	102	38	.	.	.
22283	103	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	103	2	,	,	,
22283	103	3	whenever	whenever	WRB
22283	103	4	mental	mental	JJ
22283	103	5	operations	operation	NNS
22283	103	6	are	be	VBP
22283	103	7	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	103	8	,	,	,
22283	103	9	a	a	DT
22283	103	10	relatively	relatively	RB
22283	103	11	much	much	RB
22283	103	12	greater	great	JJR
22283	103	13	time	time	NN
22283	103	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	103	15	required	require	VBN
22283	103	16	for	for	IN
22283	103	17	a	a	DT
22283	103	18	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	103	19	-	-	HYPH
22283	103	20	centre	centre	NN
22283	103	21	to	to	TO
22283	103	22	perform	perform	VB
22283	103	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	103	24	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	103	25	than	than	IN
22283	103	26	when	when	WRB
22283	103	27	a	a	DT
22283	103	28	merely	merely	RB
22283	103	29	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	103	30	or	or	CC
22283	103	31	non	non	JJ
22283	103	32	-	-	JJ
22283	103	33	mental	mental	JJ
22283	103	34	response	response	NN
22283	103	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	103	36	needed	need	VBN
22283	103	37	;	;	:
22283	103	38	and	and	CC
22283	103	39	the	the	DT
22283	103	40	more	more	RBR
22283	103	41	complex	complex	JJ
22283	103	42	the	the	DT
22283	103	43	mental	mental	JJ
22283	103	44	operation	operation	NN
22283	103	45	the	the	DT
22283	103	46	more	more	JJR
22283	103	47	time	time	NN
22283	103	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	103	49	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	103	50	.	.	.
22283	104	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	104	2	may	may	MD
22283	104	3	be	be	VB
22283	104	4	termed	term	VBN
22283	104	5	the	the	DT
22283	104	6	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	104	7	of	of	IN
22283	104	8	deliberation	deliberation	NN
22283	104	9	.	.	.
22283	105	1	So	so	RB
22283	105	2	much	much	RB
22283	105	3	,	,	,
22283	105	4	then	then	RB
22283	105	5	,	,	,
22283	105	6	for	for	IN
22283	105	7	the	the	DT
22283	105	8	rate	rate	NN
22283	105	9	at	at	IN
22283	105	10	which	which	WDT
22283	105	11	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	105	12	movements	movement	NNS
22283	105	13	travel	travel	VBP
22283	105	14	through	through	IN
22283	105	15	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	105	16	,	,	,
22283	105	17	and	and	CC
22283	105	18	the	the	DT
22283	105	19	times	time	NNS
22283	105	20	which	which	WDT
22283	105	21	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	105	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	105	23	centres	centre	NNS
22283	105	24	consume	consume	VBP
22283	105	25	in	in	IN
22283	105	26	performing	perform	VBG
22283	105	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	105	28	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	105	29	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	105	30	.	.	.
22283	106	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	106	2	may	may	MD
22283	106	3	next	next	RB
22283	106	4	consider	consider	VB
22283	106	5	the	the	DT
22283	106	6	researches	research	NNS
22283	106	7	which	which	WDT
22283	106	8	have	have	VBP
22283	106	9	been	be	VBN
22283	106	10	made	make	VBN
22283	106	11	within	within	IN
22283	106	12	the	the	DT
22283	106	13	last	last	JJ
22283	106	14	few	few	JJ
22283	106	15	months	month	NNS
22283	106	16	upon	upon	IN
22283	106	17	the	the	DT
22283	106	18	rates	rate	NNS
22283	106	19	of	of	IN
22283	106	20	these	these	DT
22283	106	21	movements	movement	NNS
22283	106	22	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	106	23	,	,	,
22283	106	24	or	or	CC
22283	106	25	the	the	DT
22283	106	26	number	number	NN
22283	106	27	of	of	IN
22283	106	28	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	106	29	per	per	IN
22283	106	30	second	second	NN
22283	106	31	with	with	IN
22283	106	32	which	which	WDT
22283	106	33	the	the	DT
22283	106	34	particles	particle	NNS
22283	106	35	of	of	IN
22283	106	36	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	106	37	matter	matter	NN
22283	106	38	oscillate	oscillate	NN
22283	106	39	.	.	.
22283	107	1	If	if	IN
22283	107	2	,	,	,
22283	107	3	by	by	IN
22283	107	4	means	mean	NNS
22283	107	5	of	of	IN
22283	107	6	a	a	DT
22283	107	7	suitable	suitable	JJ
22283	107	8	apparatus	apparatus	NN
22283	107	9	,	,	,
22283	107	10	a	a	DT
22283	107	11	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	107	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	107	13	made	make	VBN
22283	107	14	to	to	TO
22283	107	15	record	record	VB
22283	107	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	107	17	own	own	JJ
22283	107	18	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	107	19	,	,	,
22283	107	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	107	21	find	find	VBP
22283	107	22	that	that	IN
22283	107	23	during	during	IN
22283	107	24	all	all	PDT
22283	107	25	the	the	DT
22283	107	26	time	time	NN
22283	107	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	107	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	107	29	in	in	IN
22283	107	30	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	107	31	,	,	,
22283	107	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	107	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	107	34	under	under	RB
22283	107	35	-	-	:
22283	107	36	going	go	VBG
22283	107	37	a	a	DT
22283	107	38	vibratory	vibratory	NN
22283	107	39	movement	movement	NN
22283	107	40	at	at	IN
22283	107	41	the	the	DT
22283	107	42	rate	rate	NN
22283	107	43	of	of	IN
22283	107	44	about	about	IN
22283	107	45	nine	nine	CD
22283	107	46	pulsations	pulsation	NNS
22283	107	47	per	per	IN
22283	107	48	second	second	NN
22283	107	49	.	.	.
22283	108	1	What	what	WP
22283	108	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	108	3	the	the	DT
22283	108	4	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	108	5	of	of	IN
22283	108	6	this	this	DT
22283	108	7	movement	movement	NN
22283	108	8	?	?	.
22283	109	1	The	the	DT
22283	109	2	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	109	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	109	4	that	that	IN
22283	109	5	the	the	DT
22283	109	6	act	act	NN
22283	109	7	of	of	IN
22283	109	8	will	will	NN
22283	109	9	in	in	IN
22283	109	10	the	the	DT
22283	109	11	brain	brain	NN
22283	109	12	,	,	,
22283	109	13	which	which	WDT
22283	109	14	serves	serve	VBZ
22283	109	15	as	as	IN
22283	109	16	a	a	DT
22283	109	17	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	109	18	to	to	IN
22283	109	19	the	the	DT
22283	109	20	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	109	21	of	of	IN
22283	109	22	the	the	DT
22283	109	23	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	109	24	,	,	,
22283	109	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	109	26	accompanied	accompany	VBN
22283	109	27	by	by	IN
22283	109	28	a	a	DT
22283	109	29	vibratory	vibratory	JJ
22283	109	30	movement	movement	NN
22283	109	31	in	in	IN
22283	109	32	the	the	DT
22283	109	33	grey	grey	JJ
22283	109	34	matter	matter	NN
22283	109	35	of	of	IN
22283	109	36	the	the	DT
22283	109	37	brain	brain	NN
22283	109	38	;	;	:
22283	109	39	that	that	IN
22283	109	40	this	this	DT
22283	109	41	movement	movement	NN
22283	109	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	109	43	going	go	VBG
22283	109	44	on	on	RP
22283	109	45	at	at	IN
22283	109	46	the	the	DT
22283	109	47	rate	rate	NN
22283	109	48	of	of	IN
22283	109	49	nine	nine	CD
22283	109	50	pulsations	pulsation	NNS
22283	109	51	per	per	IN
22283	109	52	second	second	NN
22283	109	53	;	;	:
22283	109	54	and	and	CC
22283	109	55	that	that	IN
22283	109	56	the	the	DT
22283	109	57	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	109	58	is	be	VBZ
22283	109	59	giving	give	VBG
22283	109	60	a	a	DT
22283	109	61	separate	separate	JJ
22283	109	62	or	or	CC
22283	109	63	distinct	distinct	JJ
22283	109	64	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	109	65	in	in	IN
22283	109	66	response	response	NN
22283	109	67	to	to	IN
22283	109	68	every	every	DT
22283	109	69	one	one	CD
22283	109	70	of	of	IN
22283	109	71	these	these	DT
22283	109	72	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	109	73	pulsations	pulsation	NNS
22283	109	74	.	.	.
22283	110	1	That	that	DT
22283	110	2	such	such	JJ
22283	110	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	110	4	the	the	DT
22283	110	5	true	true	JJ
22283	110	6	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	110	7	of	of	IN
22283	110	8	the	the	DT
22283	110	9	rhythm	rhythm	NN
22283	110	10	in	in	IN
22283	110	11	the	the	DT
22283	110	12	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	110	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	110	14	proved	prove	VBN
22283	110	15	by	by	IN
22283	110	16	the	the	DT
22283	110	17	fact	fact	NN
22283	110	18	that	that	IN
22283	110	19	if	if	IN
22283	110	20	,	,	,
22283	110	21	instead	instead	RB
22283	110	22	of	of	IN
22283	110	23	contracting	contract	VBG
22283	110	24	a	a	DT
22283	110	25	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	110	26	by	by	IN
22283	110	27	an	an	DT
22283	110	28	act	act	NN
22283	110	29	of	of	IN
22283	110	30	the	the	DT
22283	110	31	will	will	NN
22283	110	32	,	,	,
22283	110	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	110	34	be	be	VB
22283	110	35	contracted	contract	VBN
22283	110	36	by	by	IN
22283	110	37	means	mean	NNS
22283	110	38	of	of	IN
22283	110	39	a	a	DT
22283	110	40	rapid	rapid	JJ
22283	110	41	series	series	NN
22283	110	42	of	of	IN
22283	110	43	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	110	44	shocks	shock	NNS
22283	110	45	playing	play	VBG
22283	110	46	upon	upon	IN
22283	110	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	110	48	attached	attached	JJ
22283	110	49	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	110	50	,	,	,
22283	110	51	the	the	DT
22283	110	52	record	record	NN
22283	110	53	then	then	RB
22283	110	54	furnished	furnish	VBD
22283	110	55	shows	show	VBZ
22283	110	56	a	a	DT
22283	110	57	similar	similar	JJ
22283	110	58	trembling	trembling	NN
22283	110	59	going	go	VBG
22283	110	60	on	on	RP
22283	110	61	in	in	IN
22283	110	62	the	the	DT
22283	110	63	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	110	64	as	as	IN
22283	110	65	in	in	IN
22283	110	66	the	the	DT
22283	110	67	previous	previous	JJ
22283	110	68	case	case	NN
22283	110	69	;	;	:
22283	110	70	but	but	CC
22283	110	71	the	the	DT
22283	110	72	tremors	tremor	NNS
22283	110	73	of	of	IN
22283	110	74	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	110	75	are	be	VBP
22283	110	76	now	now	RB
22283	110	77	no	no	RB
22283	110	78	longer	long	RBR
22283	110	79	at	at	IN
22283	110	80	the	the	DT
22283	110	81	rate	rate	NN
22283	110	82	of	of	IN
22283	110	83	nine	nine	CD
22283	110	84	per	per	IN
22283	110	85	second	second	NN
22283	110	86	:	:	:
22283	110	87	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	110	88	correspond	correspond	VBP
22283	110	89	beat	beat	NN
22283	110	90	for	for	IN
22283	110	91	beat	beat	NN
22283	110	92	with	with	IN
22283	110	93	the	the	DT
22283	110	94	interruptions	interruption	NNS
22283	110	95	of	of	IN
22283	110	96	the	the	DT
22283	110	97	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	110	98	current	current	NN
22283	110	99	.	.	.
22283	111	1	That	that	DT
22283	111	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	111	3	to	to	TO
22283	111	4	say	say	VB
22283	111	5	,	,	,
22283	111	6	the	the	DT
22283	111	7	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	111	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	111	9	responding	respond	VBG
22283	111	10	separately	separately	RB
22283	111	11	to	to	IN
22283	111	12	every	every	DT
22283	111	13	separate	separate	JJ
22283	111	14	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	111	15	which	which	WDT
22283	111	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	111	17	receives	receive	VBZ
22283	111	18	through	through	IN
22283	111	19	the	the	DT
22283	111	20	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	111	21	;	;	:
22283	111	22	and	and	CC
22283	111	23	further	further	JJ
22283	111	24	experiment	experiment	NN
22283	111	25	shows	show	VBZ
22283	111	26	that	that	IN
22283	111	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	111	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	111	29	able	able	JJ
22283	111	30	thus	thus	RB
22283	111	31	to	to	TO
22283	111	32	keep	keep	VB
22283	111	33	time	time	NN
22283	111	34	with	with	IN
22283	111	35	the	the	DT
22283	111	36	separate	separate	JJ
22283	111	37	shocks	shock	NNS
22283	111	38	,	,	,
22283	111	39	even	even	RB
22283	111	40	though	though	IN
22283	111	41	these	these	DT
22283	111	42	be	be	VB
22283	111	43	made	make	VBN
22283	111	44	to	to	TO
22283	111	45	follow	follow	VB
22283	111	46	one	one	CD
22283	111	47	another	another	DT
22283	111	48	so	so	RB
22283	111	49	rapidly	rapidly	RB
22283	111	50	as	as	IN
22283	111	51	1,000	1,000	CD
22283	111	52	per	per	IN
22283	111	53	second	second	NN
22283	111	54	.	.	.
22283	112	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	112	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	112	3	can	can	MD
22283	112	4	have	have	VB
22283	112	5	no	no	DT
22283	112	6	doubt	doubt	NN
22283	112	7	that	that	IN
22283	112	8	the	the	DT
22283	112	9	slow	slow	JJ
22283	112	10	rhythm	rhythm	NN
22283	112	11	of	of	IN
22283	112	12	nine	nine	CD
22283	112	13	per	per	IN
22283	112	14	second	second	JJ
22283	112	15	under	under	IN
22283	112	16	the	the	DT
22283	112	17	influence	influence	NN
22283	112	18	of	of	IN
22283	112	19	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	112	20	stimulation	stimulation	NN
22283	112	21	,	,	,
22283	112	22	represents	represent	VBZ
22283	112	23	the	the	DT
22283	112	24	rate	rate	NN
22283	112	25	at	at	IN
22283	112	26	which	which	WDT
22283	112	27	the	the	DT
22283	112	28	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	112	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	112	30	receiving	receive	VBG
22283	112	31	so	so	RB
22283	112	32	many	many	JJ
22283	112	33	separate	separate	JJ
22283	112	34	impulses	impulse	NNS
22283	112	35	from	from	IN
22283	112	36	the	the	DT
22283	112	37	brain	brain	NN
22283	112	38	:	:	:
22283	112	39	the	the	DT
22283	112	40	muscle	muscle	NN
22283	112	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	112	42	keeping	keep	VBG
22283	112	43	time	time	NN
22283	112	44	with	with	IN
22283	112	45	the	the	DT
22283	112	46	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	112	47	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	112	48	going	go	VBG
22283	112	49	on	on	RP
22283	112	50	in	in	IN
22283	112	51	the	the	DT
22283	112	52	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	112	53	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	112	54	at	at	IN
22283	112	55	the	the	DT
22283	112	56	rate	rate	NN
22283	112	57	of	of	IN
22283	112	58	nine	nine	CD
22283	112	59	beats	beat	NNS
22283	112	60	per	per	IN
22283	112	61	second	second	NN
22283	112	62	.	.	.
22283	113	1	Careful	careful	JJ
22283	113	2	tracings	tracing	NNS
22283	113	3	show	show	VBP
22283	113	4	that	that	IN
22283	113	5	this	this	DT
22283	113	6	rate	rate	NN
22283	113	7	can	can	MD
22283	113	8	not	not	RB
22283	113	9	be	be	VB
22283	113	10	increased	increase	VBN
22283	113	11	by	by	IN
22283	113	12	increasing	increase	VBG
22283	113	13	the	the	DT
22283	113	14	strength	strength	NN
22283	113	15	of	of	IN
22283	113	16	the	the	DT
22283	113	17	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	113	18	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	113	19	;	;	:
22283	113	20	but	but	CC
22283	113	21	some	some	DT
22283	113	22	individuals	individual	NNS
22283	113	23	--	--	:
22283	113	24	and	and	CC
22283	113	25	those	those	DT
22283	113	26	usually	usually	RB
22283	113	27	who	who	WP
22283	113	28	are	be	VBP
22283	113	29	of	of	IN
22283	113	30	quickest	quick	JJS
22283	113	31	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	113	32	--	--	:
22283	113	33	display	display	VB
22283	113	34	a	a	DT
22283	113	35	somewhat	somewhat	RB
22283	113	36	quicker	quick	JJR
22283	113	37	rate	rate	NN
22283	113	38	of	of	IN
22283	113	39	rhythm	rhythm	NN
22283	113	40	,	,	,
22283	113	41	which	which	WDT
22283	113	42	may	may	MD
22283	113	43	be	be	VB
22283	113	44	as	as	RB
22283	113	45	high	high	JJ
22283	113	46	as	as	IN
22283	113	47	eleven	eleven	CD
22283	113	48	per	per	IN
22283	113	49	second	second	NN
22283	113	50	.	.	.
22283	114	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
22283	114	2	,	,	,
22283	114	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	114	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	114	5	found	find	VBN
22283	114	6	that	that	IN
22283	114	7	by	by	IN
22283	114	8	stimulating	stimulate	VBG
22283	114	9	with	with	IN
22283	114	10	strychnine	strychnine	NN
22283	114	11	any	any	DT
22283	114	12	of	of	IN
22283	114	13	the	the	DT
22283	114	14	centres	centre	NNS
22283	114	15	of	of	IN
22283	114	16	reflex	reflex	NNP
22283	114	17	action	action	NN
22283	114	18	,	,	,
22283	114	19	pretty	pretty	RB
22283	114	20	nearly	nearly	RB
22283	114	21	the	the	DT
22283	114	22	same	same	JJ
22283	114	23	rate	rate	NN
22283	114	24	of	of	IN
22283	114	25	rhythm	rhythm	NN
22283	114	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	114	27	exhibited	exhibit	VBN
22283	114	28	by	by	IN
22283	114	29	the	the	DT
22283	114	30	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	114	31	thus	thus	RB
22283	114	32	thrown	throw	VBN
22283	114	33	into	into	IN
22283	114	34	contraction	contraction	NN
22283	114	35	;	;	:
22283	114	36	so	so	CC
22283	114	37	that	that	IN
22283	114	38	all	all	PDT
22283	114	39	the	the	DT
22283	114	40	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	114	41	-	-	HYPH
22283	114	42	cells	cell	NNS
22283	114	43	in	in	IN
22283	114	44	the	the	DT
22283	114	45	body	body	NN
22283	114	46	are	be	VBP
22283	114	47	thus	thus	RB
22283	114	48	shown	show	VBN
22283	114	49	to	to	TO
22283	114	50	have	have	VB
22283	114	51	in	in	IN
22283	114	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	114	53	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	114	54	pretty	pretty	RB
22283	114	55	nearly	nearly	RB
22283	114	56	the	the	DT
22283	114	57	same	same	JJ
22283	114	58	period	period	NN
22283	114	59	,	,	,
22283	114	60	and	and	CC
22283	114	61	not	not	RB
22283	114	62	to	to	TO
22283	114	63	be	be	VB
22283	114	64	able	able	JJ
22283	114	65	to	to	TO
22283	114	66	vibrate	vibrate	VB
22283	114	67	with	with	IN
22283	114	68	any	any	DT
22283	114	69	other	other	JJ
22283	114	70	.	.	.
22283	115	1	For	for	IN
22283	115	2	no	no	DT
22283	115	3	matter	matter	NN
22283	115	4	how	how	WRB
22283	115	5	rapidly	rapidly	RB
22283	115	6	the	the	DT
22283	115	7	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	115	8	shocks	shock	NNS
22283	115	9	are	be	VBP
22283	115	10	allowed	allow	VBN
22283	115	11	to	to	TO
22283	115	12	play	play	VB
22283	115	13	upon	upon	IN
22283	115	14	the	the	DT
22283	115	15	grey	grey	JJ
22283	115	16	matter	matter	NN
22283	115	17	of	of	IN
22283	115	18	the	the	DT
22283	115	19	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	115	20	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	115	21	,	,	,
22283	115	22	as	as	IN
22283	115	23	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	115	24	from	from	IN
22283	115	25	the	the	DT
22283	115	26	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	115	27	-	-	HYPH
22283	115	28	trunks	trunk	NNS
22283	115	29	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	115	30	from	from	IN
22283	115	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	115	32	to	to	IN
22283	115	33	the	the	DT
22283	115	34	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	115	35	,	,	,
22283	115	36	the	the	DT
22283	115	37	muscles	muscle	NNS
22283	115	38	always	always	RB
22283	115	39	show	show	VBP
22283	115	40	the	the	DT
22283	115	41	same	same	JJ
22283	115	42	rhythm	rhythm	NN
22283	115	43	of	of	IN
22283	115	44	about	about	IN
22283	115	45	nine	nine	CD
22283	115	46	beats	beat	NNS
22283	115	47	per	per	IN
22283	115	48	second	second	NN
22283	115	49	:	:	:
22283	115	50	the	the	DT
22283	115	51	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	115	52	-	-	HYPH
22283	115	53	cells	cell	NNS
22283	115	54	,	,	,
22283	115	55	unlike	unlike	IN
22283	115	56	the	the	DT
22283	115	57	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	115	58	-	-	HYPH
22283	115	59	fibres	fibre	NNS
22283	115	60	,	,	,
22283	115	61	refuse	refuse	VBP
22283	115	62	to	to	TO
22283	115	63	keep	keep	VB
22283	115	64	time	time	NN
22283	115	65	with	with	IN
22283	115	66	the	the	DT
22283	115	67	electric	electric	JJ
22283	115	68	shocks	shock	NNS
22283	115	69	,	,	,
22283	115	70	and	and	CC
22283	115	71	will	will	MD
22283	115	72	only	only	RB
22283	115	73	respond	respond	VB
22283	115	74	to	to	IN
22283	115	75	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	115	76	by	by	IN
22283	115	77	vibrating	vibrate	VBG
22283	115	78	at	at	IN
22283	115	79	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	115	80	own	own	JJ
22283	115	81	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
22283	115	82	rate	rate	NN
22283	115	83	of	of	IN
22283	115	84	nine	nine	CD
22283	115	85	beats	beat	NNS
22283	115	86	per	per	IN
22283	115	87	second	second	NN
22283	115	88	.	.	.
22283	116	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	116	2	much	much	JJ
22283	116	3	,	,	,
22283	116	4	then	then	RB
22283	116	5	,	,	,
22283	116	6	for	for	IN
22283	116	7	the	the	DT
22283	116	8	rate	rate	NN
22283	116	9	of	of	IN
22283	116	10	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	116	11	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	116	12	which	which	WDT
22283	116	13	goes	go	VBZ
22283	116	14	on	on	RB
22283	116	15	in	in	IN
22283	116	16	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	116	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	116	18	centres	centre	NNS
22283	116	19	.	.	.
22283	117	1	But	but	CC
22283	117	2	the	the	DT
22283	117	3	rate	rate	NN
22283	117	4	of	of	IN
22283	117	5	such	such	JJ
22283	117	6	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	117	7	which	which	WDT
22283	117	8	goes	go	VBZ
22283	117	9	on	on	RB
22283	117	10	in	in	IN
22283	117	11	sensory	sensory	NN
22283	117	12	and	and	CC
22283	117	13	motor	motor	NN
22283	117	14	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	117	15	may	may	MD
22283	117	16	be	be	VB
22283	117	17	very	very	RB
22283	117	18	much	much	RB
22283	117	19	more	more	RBR
22283	117	20	rapid	rapid	JJ
22283	117	21	.	.	.
22283	118	1	For	for	IN
22283	118	2	while	while	IN
22283	118	3	a	a	DT
22283	118	4	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	118	5	-	-	HYPH
22283	118	6	centre	centre	NN
22283	118	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	118	8	only	only	RB
22283	118	9	able	able	JJ
22283	118	10	to	to	TO
22283	118	11	_	_	NNP
22283	118	12	originate	originate	NN
22283	118	13	_	_	NNP
22283	118	14	a	a	DT
22283	118	15	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	118	16	at	at	IN
22283	118	17	the	the	DT
22283	118	18	rate	rate	NN
22283	118	19	of	of	IN
22283	118	20	about	about	IN
22283	118	21	nine	nine	CD
22283	118	22	beats	beat	NNS
22283	118	23	per	per	IN
22283	118	24	second	second	NN
22283	118	25	,	,	,
22283	118	26	a	a	DT
22283	118	27	motor	motor	NN
22283	118	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	118	29	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	118	30	,	,	,
22283	118	31	as	as	IN
22283	118	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	118	33	have	have	VBP
22283	118	34	already	already	RB
22283	118	35	seen	see	VBN
22283	118	36	,	,	,
22283	118	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	118	38	able	able	JJ
22283	118	39	to	to	TO
22283	118	40	_	_	NNP
22283	118	41	transmit	transmit	NN
22283	118	42	_	_	NNP
22283	118	43	a	a	DT
22283	118	44	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	118	45	of	of	IN
22283	118	46	at	at	RB
22283	118	47	least	least	JJS
22283	118	48	1,000	1,000	CD
22283	118	49	beats	beat	NNS
22283	118	50	per	per	IN
22283	118	51	second	second	NN
22283	118	52	;	;	:
22283	118	53	and	and	CC
22283	118	54	a	a	DT
22283	118	55	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	118	56	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	118	57	which	which	WDT
22283	118	58	at	at	IN
22283	118	59	the	the	DT
22283	118	60	surface	surface	NN
22283	118	61	of	of	IN
22283	118	62	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	118	63	expansion	expansion	NN
22283	118	64	is	be	VBZ
22283	118	65	able	able	JJ
22283	118	66	to	to	TO
22283	118	67	respond	respond	VB
22283	118	68	differently	differently	RB
22283	118	69	to	to	IN
22283	118	70	differences	difference	NNS
22283	118	71	of	of	IN
22283	118	72	musical	musical	JJ
22283	118	73	pitch	pitch	NN
22283	118	74	,	,	,
22283	118	75	of	of	IN
22283	118	76	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	118	77	,	,	,
22283	118	78	and	and	CC
22283	118	79	even	even	RB
22283	118	80	of	of	IN
22283	118	81	colour	colour	NN
22283	118	82	,	,	,
22283	118	83	is	be	VBZ
22283	118	84	probably	probably	RB
22283	118	85	able	able	JJ
22283	118	86	to	to	TO
22283	118	87	vibrate	vibrate	VB
22283	118	88	very	very	RB
22283	118	89	much	much	RB
22283	118	90	more	more	RBR
22283	118	91	rapidly	rapidly	RB
22283	118	92	even	even	RB
22283	118	93	than	than	IN
22283	118	94	this	this	DT
22283	118	95	.	.	.
22283	119	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	2	are	be	VBP
22283	119	3	not	not	RB
22283	119	4	,	,	,
22283	119	5	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	119	6	,	,	,
22283	119	7	entitled	entitle	VBN
22283	119	8	to	to	TO
22283	119	9	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	119	10	that	that	IN
22283	119	11	the	the	DT
22283	119	12	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	119	13	of	of	IN
22283	119	14	special	special	JJ
22283	119	15	sense	sense	NN
22283	119	16	vibrate	vibrate	NN
22283	119	17	in	in	IN
22283	119	18	actual	actual	JJ
22283	119	19	unison	unison	NN
22283	119	20	,	,	,
22283	119	21	or	or	CC
22283	119	22	synchronize	synchronize	VB
22283	119	23	,	,	,
22283	119	24	with	with	IN
22283	119	25	these	these	DT
22283	119	26	external	external	JJ
22283	119	27	sources	source	NNS
22283	119	28	of	of	IN
22283	119	29	stimulation	stimulation	NN
22283	119	30	;	;	:
22283	119	31	but	but	CC
22283	119	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	33	are	be	VBP
22283	119	34	,	,	,
22283	119	35	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	36	think	think	VBP
22283	119	37	,	,	,
22283	119	38	bound	bind	VBN
22283	119	39	to	to	TO
22283	119	40	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	119	41	that	that	IN
22283	119	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	43	must	must	MD
22283	119	44	vibrate	vibrate	VB
22283	119	45	in	in	IN
22283	119	46	some	some	DT
22283	119	47	numerical	numerical	JJ
22283	119	48	proportion	proportion	NN
22283	119	49	to	to	IN
22283	119	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	51	(	(	-LRB-
22283	119	52	else	else	RB
22283	119	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	54	should	should	MD
22283	119	55	not	not	RB
22283	119	56	perceive	perceive	VB
22283	119	57	objective	objective	JJ
22283	119	58	differences	difference	NNS
22283	119	59	in	in	IN
22283	119	60	sound	sound	NN
22283	119	61	,	,	,
22283	119	62	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	119	63	,	,	,
22283	119	64	or	or	CC
22283	119	65	colour	colour	NN
22283	119	66	)	)	-RRB-
22283	119	67	;	;	:
22283	119	68	and	and	CC
22283	119	69	even	even	RB
22283	119	70	this	this	DT
22283	119	71	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	119	72	that	that	IN
22283	119	73	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	119	74	are	be	VBP
22283	119	75	probably	probably	RB
22283	119	76	able	able	JJ
22283	119	77	to	to	TO
22283	119	78	vibrate	vibrate	VB
22283	119	79	at	at	IN
22283	119	80	some	some	DT
22283	119	81	enormous	enormous	JJ
22283	119	82	rate	rate	NN
22283	119	83	.	.	.
22283	120	1	With	with	IN
22283	120	2	further	further	JJ
22283	120	3	reference	reference	NN
22283	120	4	to	to	IN
22283	120	5	these	these	DT
22283	120	6	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	120	7	movements	movement	NNS
22283	120	8	in	in	IN
22283	120	9	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	120	10	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	120	11	,	,	,
22283	120	12	the	the	DT
22283	120	13	following	follow	VBG
22283	120	14	important	important	JJ
22283	120	15	observation	observation	NN
22283	120	16	has	have	VBZ
22283	120	17	been	be	VBN
22283	120	18	made	make	VBN
22283	120	19	--	--	:
22283	120	20	viz	viz	NN
22283	120	21	.	.	.
22283	121	1	that	that	IN
22283	121	2	there	there	EX
22283	121	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	121	4	a	a	DT
22283	121	5	constant	constant	JJ
22283	121	6	ratio	ratio	NN
22283	121	7	between	between	IN
22283	121	8	the	the	DT
22283	121	9	amount	amount	NN
22283	121	10	of	of	IN
22283	121	11	agitation	agitation	NN
22283	121	12	produced	produce	VBN
22283	121	13	in	in	IN
22283	121	14	a	a	DT
22283	121	15	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	121	16	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	121	17	,	,	,
22283	121	18	and	and	CC
22283	121	19	the	the	DT
22283	121	20	intensity	intensity	NN
22283	121	21	of	of	IN
22283	121	22	the	the	DT
22283	121	23	corresponding	correspond	VBG
22283	121	24	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	121	25	.	.	.
22283	122	1	This	this	DT
22283	122	2	ratio	ratio	NN
22283	122	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	122	4	not	not	RB
22283	122	5	a	a	DT
22283	122	6	direct	direct	JJ
22283	122	7	one	one	NN
22283	122	8	.	.	.
22283	123	1	As	as	IN
22283	123	2	Fechner	Fechner	NNP
22283	123	3	states	state	VBZ
22283	123	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	123	5	,	,	,
22283	123	6	'	'	''
22283	123	7	Sensation	sensation	NN
22283	123	8	varies	vary	VBZ
22283	123	9	,	,	,
22283	123	10	not	not	RB
22283	123	11	as	as	IN
22283	123	12	the	the	DT
22283	123	13	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	123	14	,	,	,
22283	123	15	but	but	CC
22283	123	16	as	as	IN
22283	123	17	the	the	DT
22283	123	18	logarithm	logarithm	NN
22283	123	19	of	of	IN
22283	123	20	the	the	DT
22283	123	21	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	123	22	.	.	.
22283	123	23	'	'	''
22283	124	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	124	2	,	,	,
22283	124	3	for	for	IN
22283	124	4	instance	instance	NN
22283	124	5	,	,	,
22283	124	6	if	if	IN
22283	124	7	1,000	1,000	CD
22283	124	8	candles	candle	NNS
22283	124	9	are	be	VBP
22283	124	10	all	all	RB
22283	124	11	throwing	throw	VBG
22283	124	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	124	13	light	light	NN
22283	124	14	upon	upon	IN
22283	124	15	the	the	DT
22283	124	16	same	same	JJ
22283	124	17	screen	screen	NN
22283	124	18	,	,	,
22283	124	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	124	20	should	should	MD
22283	124	21	require	require	VB
22283	124	22	ten	ten	CD
22283	124	23	more	more	JJR
22283	124	24	candles	candle	NNS
22283	124	25	to	to	TO
22283	124	26	be	be	VB
22283	124	27	added	add	VBN
22283	124	28	before	before	IN
22283	124	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	124	30	eyes	eye	NNS
22283	124	31	could	could	MD
22283	124	32	perceive	perceive	VB
22283	124	33	any	any	DT
22283	124	34	difference	difference	NN
22283	124	35	in	in	IN
22283	124	36	the	the	DT
22283	124	37	amount	amount	NN
22283	124	38	of	of	IN
22283	124	39	illumination	illumination	NN
22283	124	40	.	.	.
22283	125	1	But	but	CC
22283	125	2	if	if	IN
22283	125	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	125	4	begin	begin	VBP
22283	125	5	with	with	IN
22283	125	6	only	only	RB
22283	125	7	100	100	CD
22283	125	8	candles	candle	NNS
22283	125	9	shining	shine	VBG
22283	125	10	upon	upon	IN
22283	125	11	the	the	DT
22283	125	12	screen	screen	NN
22283	125	13	,	,	,
22283	125	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	125	15	should	should	MD
22283	125	16	perceive	perceive	VB
22283	125	17	an	an	DT
22283	125	18	increase	increase	NN
22283	125	19	in	in	IN
22283	125	20	the	the	DT
22283	125	21	illumination	illumination	NN
22283	125	22	by	by	IN
22283	125	23	adding	add	VBG
22283	125	24	a	a	DT
22283	125	25	single	single	JJ
22283	125	26	candle	candle	NN
22283	125	27	.	.	.
22283	126	1	And	and	CC
22283	126	2	what	what	WP
22283	126	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	126	4	true	true	JJ
22283	126	5	of	of	IN
22283	126	6	sight	sight	NN
22283	126	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	126	8	equally	equally	RB
22283	126	9	true	true	JJ
22283	126	10	of	of	IN
22283	126	11	all	all	PDT
22283	126	12	the	the	DT
22283	126	13	other	other	JJ
22283	126	14	senses	sense	NNS
22283	126	15	:	:	:
22283	126	16	if	if	IN
22283	126	17	any	any	DT
22283	126	18	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	126	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	126	20	increased	increase	VBN
22283	126	21	,	,	,
22283	126	22	the	the	DT
22283	126	23	smallest	small	JJS
22283	126	24	increase	increase	NN
22283	126	25	of	of	IN
22283	126	26	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	126	27	first	first	RB
22283	126	28	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	126	29	when	when	WRB
22283	126	30	the	the	DT
22283	126	31	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	126	32	rises	rise	VBZ
22283	126	33	one	one	CD
22283	126	34	per	per	IN
22283	126	35	cent	cent	NN
22283	126	36	,	,	,
22283	126	37	above	above	IN
22283	126	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	126	39	original	original	JJ
22283	126	40	intensity	intensity	NN
22283	126	41	.	.	.
22283	127	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	127	2	being	be	VBG
22283	127	3	the	the	DT
22283	127	4	law	law	NN
22283	127	5	on	on	IN
22283	127	6	the	the	DT
22283	127	7	side	side	NN
22283	127	8	of	of	IN
22283	127	9	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	127	10	,	,	,
22283	127	11	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	127	12	that	that	IN
22283	127	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	127	14	place	place	VBP
22283	127	15	upon	upon	IN
22283	127	16	the	the	DT
22283	127	17	optic	optic	JJ
22283	127	18	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	127	19	of	of	IN
22283	127	20	an	an	DT
22283	127	21	animal	animal	NN
22283	127	22	the	the	DT
22283	127	23	wires	wire	NNS
22283	127	24	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	127	25	from	from	IN
22283	127	26	a	a	DT
22283	127	27	delicate	delicate	JJ
22283	127	28	galvanometer	galvanometer	NN
22283	127	29	,	,	,
22283	127	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	127	31	find	find	VBP
22283	127	32	that	that	IN
22283	127	33	every	every	DT
22283	127	34	time	time	NN
22283	127	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	127	36	stimulate	stimulate	VBP
22283	127	37	the	the	DT
22283	127	38	eye	eye	NN
22283	127	39	with	with	IN
22283	127	40	light	light	NN
22283	127	41	,	,	,
22283	127	42	the	the	DT
22283	127	43	needle	needle	NN
22283	127	44	of	of	IN
22283	127	45	the	the	DT
22283	127	46	galvanometer	galvanometer	NN
22283	127	47	moves	move	NNS
22283	127	48	,	,	,
22283	127	49	showing	show	VBG
22283	127	50	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	127	51	changes	change	NNS
22283	127	52	going	go	VBG
22283	127	53	on	on	RP
22283	127	54	in	in	IN
22283	127	55	the	the	DT
22283	127	56	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	127	57	,	,	,
22283	127	58	caused	cause	VBN
22283	127	59	by	by	IN
22283	127	60	the	the	DT
22283	127	61	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	127	62	agitations	agitation	NNS
22283	127	63	.	.	.
22283	128	1	Now	now	RB
22283	128	2	these	these	DT
22283	128	3	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	128	4	changes	change	NNS
22283	128	5	are	be	VBP
22283	128	6	found	find	VBN
22283	128	7	to	to	TO
22283	128	8	vary	vary	VB
22283	128	9	in	in	IN
22283	128	10	intensity	intensity	NN
22283	128	11	with	with	IN
22283	128	12	the	the	DT
22283	128	13	intensity	intensity	NN
22283	128	14	of	of	IN
22283	128	15	the	the	DT
22283	128	16	light	light	NN
22283	128	17	used	use	VBN
22283	128	18	as	as	IN
22283	128	19	a	a	DT
22283	128	20	stimulus	stimulus	NN
22283	128	21	,	,	,
22283	128	22	and	and	CC
22283	128	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	128	24	do	do	VBP
22283	128	25	so	so	RB
22283	128	26	very	very	RB
22283	128	27	nearly	nearly	RB
22283	128	28	in	in	IN
22283	128	29	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	128	30	with	with	IN
22283	128	31	the	the	DT
22283	128	32	law	law	NN
22283	128	33	of	of	IN
22283	128	34	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	128	35	just	just	RB
22283	128	36	mentioned	mention	VBN
22283	128	37	.	.	.
22283	129	1	So	so	RB
22283	129	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	129	3	say	say	VBP
22283	129	4	that	that	IN
22283	129	5	in	in	IN
22283	129	6	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	129	7	the	the	DT
22283	129	8	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	129	9	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	129	10	are	be	VBP
22283	129	11	,	,	,
22283	129	12	as	as	IN
22283	129	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	129	14	were	be	VBD
22283	129	15	,	,	,
22283	129	16	acting	act	VBG
22283	129	17	the	the	DT
22283	129	18	part	part	NN
22283	129	19	of	of	IN
22283	129	20	galvanometers	galvanometer	NNS
22283	129	21	in	in	IN
22283	129	22	appreciating	appreciate	VBG
22283	129	23	the	the	DT
22283	129	24	amount	amount	NN
22283	129	25	of	of	IN
22283	129	26	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	129	27	change	change	NN
22283	129	28	which	which	WDT
22283	129	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	129	30	going	go	VBG
22283	129	31	on	on	RP
22283	129	32	in	in	IN
22283	129	33	sensory	sensory	JJ
22283	129	34	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	129	35	;	;	:
22283	129	36	and	and	CC
22283	129	37	that	that	IN
22283	129	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	129	39	record	record	VBP
22283	129	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	129	41	readings	reading	NNS
22283	129	42	in	in	IN
22283	129	43	the	the	DT
22283	129	44	mind	mind	NN
22283	129	45	as	as	RB
22283	129	46	faithfully	faithfully	RB
22283	129	47	as	as	IN
22283	129	48	a	a	DT
22283	129	49	galvanometer	galvanometer	NN
22283	129	50	records	record	VBZ
22283	129	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	129	52	readings	reading	NNS
22283	129	53	on	on	IN
22283	129	54	the	the	DT
22283	129	55	dial	dial	NN
22283	129	56	.	.	.
22283	130	1	*	*	NFP
22283	130	2	*	*	NFP
22283	130	3	*	*	NFP
22283	130	4	*	*	NFP
22283	130	5	*	*	NFP
22283	130	6	Hitherto	Hitherto	NNP
22283	130	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	130	8	have	have	VBP
22283	130	9	been	be	VBN
22283	130	10	considering	consider	VBG
22283	130	11	certain	certain	JJ
22283	130	12	features	feature	NNS
22283	130	13	in	in	IN
22283	130	14	the	the	DT
22283	130	15	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	130	16	of	of	IN
22283	130	17	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	130	18	action	action	NN
22283	130	19	,	,	,
22283	130	20	so	so	RB
22283	130	21	far	far	RB
22283	130	22	as	as	IN
22283	130	23	this	this	DT
22283	130	24	can	can	MD
22283	130	25	be	be	VB
22283	130	26	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
22283	130	27	by	by	IN
22283	130	28	means	mean	NNS
22283	130	29	of	of	IN
22283	130	30	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	130	31	instruments	instrument	NNS
22283	130	32	.	.	.
22283	131	1	But	but	CC
22283	131	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	131	3	have	have	VBP
22283	131	4	just	just	RB
22283	131	5	seen	see	VBN
22283	131	6	that	that	IN
22283	131	7	the	the	DT
22283	131	8	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	131	9	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	131	10	may	may	MD
22283	131	11	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	131	12	be	be	VB
22283	131	13	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	131	14	as	as	IN
22283	131	15	such	such	JJ
22283	131	16	instruments	instrument	NNS
22283	131	17	,	,	,
22283	131	18	which	which	WDT
22283	131	19	record	record	NN
22283	131	20	in	in	IN
22283	131	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	131	22	minds	mind	NNS
22283	131	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	131	24	readings	reading	NNS
22283	131	25	of	of	IN
22283	131	26	changes	change	NNS
22283	131	27	going	go	VBG
22283	131	28	on	on	RP
22283	131	29	in	in	IN
22283	131	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	131	31	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	131	32	.	.	.
22283	132	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	132	2	,	,	,
22283	132	3	when	when	WRB
22283	132	4	other	other	JJ
22283	132	5	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	132	6	instruments	instrument	NNS
22283	132	7	fail	fail	VBP
22283	132	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	132	9	,	,	,
22283	132	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	132	11	may	may	MD
22283	132	12	gain	gain	VB
22283	132	13	much	much	JJ
22283	132	14	additional	additional	JJ
22283	132	15	insight	insight	NN
22283	132	16	touching	touch	VBG
22283	132	17	the	the	DT
22283	132	18	movements	movement	NNS
22283	132	19	of	of	IN
22283	132	20	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	132	21	matter	matter	NN
22283	132	22	by	by	IN
22283	132	23	attending	attend	VBG
22283	132	24	to	to	IN
22283	132	25	the	the	DT
22283	132	26	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	132	27	and	and	CC
22283	132	28	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	132	29	of	of	IN
22283	132	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	132	31	own	own	JJ
22283	132	32	minds	mind	NNS
22283	132	33	;	;	:
22283	132	34	for	for	IN
22283	132	35	these	these	DT
22283	132	36	are	be	VBP
22283	132	37	so	so	RB
22283	132	38	many	many	JJ
22283	132	39	indices	index	NNS
22283	132	40	of	of	IN
22283	132	41	what	what	WP
22283	132	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	132	43	going	go	VBG
22283	132	44	on	on	RP
22283	132	45	in	in	IN
22283	132	46	the	the	DT
22283	132	47	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	132	48	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	132	49	.	.	.
22283	133	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	133	2	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	133	3	propose	propose	VBP
22283	133	4	next	next	RB
22283	133	5	to	to	TO
22283	133	6	contemplate	contemplate	VB
22283	133	7	the	the	DT
22283	133	8	mind	mind	NN
22283	133	9	,	,	,
22283	133	10	considered	consider	VBN
22283	133	11	thus	thus	RB
22283	133	12	as	as	IN
22283	133	13	a	a	DT
22283	133	14	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	133	15	instrument	instrument	NN
22283	133	16	.	.	.
22283	134	1	The	the	DT
22283	134	2	same	same	JJ
22283	134	3	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	134	4	instinct	instinct	NN
22283	134	5	which	which	WDT
22283	134	6	led	lead	VBD
22283	134	7	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNPS
22283	134	8	so	so	RB
22283	134	9	truly	truly	RB
22283	134	10	to	to	TO
22283	134	11	anticipate	anticipate	VB
22283	134	12	the	the	DT
22283	134	13	progress	progress	NN
22283	134	14	of	of	IN
22283	134	15	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	134	16	,	,	,
22283	134	17	led	lead	VBD
22283	134	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	134	19	not	not	RB
22283	134	20	less	less	RBR
22283	134	21	truly	truly	RB
22283	134	22	to	to	TO
22283	134	23	anticipate	anticipate	VB
22283	134	24	the	the	DT
22283	134	25	progress	progress	NN
22283	134	26	of	of	IN
22283	134	27	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	134	28	.	.	.
22283	135	1	For	for	IN
22283	135	2	just	just	RB
22283	135	3	as	as	IN
22283	135	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	135	5	was	be	VBD
22283	135	6	the	the	DT
22283	135	7	first	first	JJ
22283	135	8	to	to	TO
22283	135	9	enunciate	enunciate	VB
22283	135	10	the	the	DT
22283	135	11	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	135	12	principle	principle	NN
22283	135	13	of	of	IN
22283	135	14	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	135	15	-	-	HYPH
22283	135	16	action	action	NN
22283	135	17	in	in	IN
22283	135	18	the	the	DT
22283	135	19	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	135	20	of	of	IN
22283	135	21	molecules	molecule	NNS
22283	135	22	,	,	,
22283	135	23	so	so	RB
22283	135	24	was	be	VBD
22283	135	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	135	26	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	135	27	the	the	DT
22283	135	28	first	first	JJ
22283	135	29	to	to	TO
22283	135	30	enunciate	enunciate	VB
22283	135	31	the	the	DT
22283	135	32	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	135	33	principle	principle	NN
22283	135	34	of	of	IN
22283	135	35	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	135	36	in	in	IN
22283	135	37	the	the	DT
22283	135	38	association	association	NNP
22283	135	39	of	of	IN
22283	135	40	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	135	41	.	.	.
22283	136	1	And	and	CC
22283	136	2	the	the	DT
22283	136	3	great	great	JJ
22283	136	4	advance	advance	NN
22283	136	5	of	of	IN
22283	136	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	136	7	which	which	WDT
22283	136	8	has	have	VBZ
22283	136	9	been	be	VBN
22283	136	10	made	make	VBN
22283	136	11	since	since	IN
22283	136	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	136	13	day	day	NN
22283	136	14	with	with	IN
22283	136	15	respect	respect	NN
22283	136	16	to	to	IN
22283	136	17	both	both	PDT
22283	136	18	these	these	DT
22283	136	19	principles	principle	NNS
22283	136	20	,	,	,
22283	136	21	entitles	entitle	VBZ
22283	136	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	136	23	to	to	TO
22283	136	24	be	be	VB
22283	136	25	much	much	RB
22283	136	26	more	more	RBR
22283	136	27	confident	confident	JJ
22283	136	28	than	than	IN
22283	136	29	even	even	RB
22283	136	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	136	31	was	be	VBD
22283	136	32	that	that	IN
22283	136	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	136	34	are	be	VBP
22283	136	35	in	in	IN
22283	136	36	some	some	DT
22283	136	37	way	way	NN
22283	136	38	intimately	intimately	RB
22283	136	39	united	unite	VBN
22283	136	40	.	.	.
22283	137	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
22283	137	2	,	,	,
22283	137	3	the	the	DT
22283	137	4	manner	manner	NN
22283	137	5	in	in	IN
22283	137	6	which	which	WDT
22283	137	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	137	8	are	be	VBP
22283	137	9	so	so	RB
22283	137	10	united	united	JJ
22283	137	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	137	12	have	have	VBP
22283	137	13	begun	begin	VBN
22283	137	14	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	137	15	to	to	TO
22283	137	16	understand	understand	VB
22283	137	17	.	.	.
22283	138	1	For	for	IN
22283	138	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	138	3	know	know	VBP
22283	138	4	from	from	IN
22283	138	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	138	6	study	study	NN
22283	138	7	of	of	IN
22283	138	8	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	138	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	138	10	action	action	NN
22283	138	11	in	in	IN
22283	138	12	general	general	JJ
22283	138	13	,	,	,
22283	138	14	that	that	IN
22283	138	15	when	when	WRB
22283	138	16	once	once	IN
22283	138	17	a	a	DT
22283	138	18	wave	wave	NN
22283	138	19	of	of	IN
22283	138	20	invisible	invisible	JJ
22283	138	21	or	or	CC
22283	138	22	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	138	23	movement	movement	NN
22283	138	24	passes	pass	VBZ
22283	138	25	through	through	IN
22283	138	26	any	any	DT
22283	138	27	line	line	NN
22283	138	28	of	of	IN
22283	138	29	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	138	30	-	-	HYPH
22283	138	31	structure	structure	NN
22283	138	32	,	,	,
22283	138	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	138	34	leaves	leave	VBZ
22283	138	35	behind	behind	IN
22283	138	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	138	37	a	a	DT
22283	138	38	change	change	NN
22283	138	39	in	in	IN
22283	138	40	the	the	DT
22283	138	41	structure	structure	NN
22283	138	42	such	such	JJ
22283	138	43	that	that	IN
22283	138	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	138	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	138	46	afterwards	afterwards	RB
22283	138	47	more	more	RBR
22283	138	48	easy	easy	JJ
22283	138	49	for	for	IN
22283	138	50	a	a	DT
22283	138	51	similar	similar	JJ
22283	138	52	wave	wave	NN
22283	138	53	,	,	,
22283	138	54	when	when	WRB
22283	138	55	started	start	VBD
22283	138	56	from	from	IN
22283	138	57	the	the	DT
22283	138	58	same	same	JJ
22283	138	59	point	point	NN
22283	138	60	,	,	,
22283	138	61	to	to	TO
22283	138	62	pursue	pursue	VB
22283	138	63	the	the	DT
22283	138	64	same	same	JJ
22283	138	65	course	course	NN
22283	138	66	.	.	.
22283	139	1	Or	or	CC
22283	139	2	,	,	,
22283	139	3	to	to	TO
22283	139	4	adopt	adopt	VB
22283	139	5	a	a	DT
22283	139	6	simile	simile	NN
22283	139	7	from	from	IN
22283	139	8	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	139	9	,	,	,
22283	139	10	just	just	RB
22283	139	11	as	as	IN
22283	139	12	water	water	NN
22283	139	13	upon	upon	IN
22283	139	14	a	a	DT
22283	139	15	table	table	NN
22283	139	16	flows	flow	VBZ
22283	139	17	most	most	RBS
22283	139	18	readily	readily	RB
22283	139	19	in	in	IN
22283	139	20	the	the	DT
22283	139	21	lines	line	NNS
22283	139	22	which	which	WDT
22283	139	23	have	have	VBP
22283	139	24	been	be	VBN
22283	139	25	wetted	wet	VBN
22283	139	26	by	by	IN
22283	139	27	a	a	DT
22283	139	28	previous	previous	JJ
22283	139	29	flow	flow	NN
22283	139	30	,	,	,
22283	139	31	so	so	CC
22283	139	32	the	the	DT
22283	139	33	invisible	invisible	JJ
22283	139	34	waves	wave	NNS
22283	139	35	of	of	IN
22283	139	36	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	139	37	-	-	HYPH
22283	139	38	action	action	NN
22283	139	39	pass	pass	NN
22283	139	40	most	most	RBS
22283	139	41	readily	readily	RB
22283	139	42	in	in	IN
22283	139	43	the	the	DT
22283	139	44	lines	line	NNS
22283	139	45	of	of	IN
22283	139	46	a	a	DT
22283	139	47	previous	previous	JJ
22283	139	48	passage	passage	NN
22283	139	49	.	.	.
22283	140	1	This	this	DT
22283	140	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	140	3	the	the	DT
22283	140	4	reason	reason	NN
22283	140	5	why	why	WRB
22283	140	6	in	in	IN
22283	140	7	any	any	DT
22283	140	8	exercise	exercise	NN
22283	140	9	requiring	require	VBG
22283	140	10	muscular	muscular	JJ
22283	140	11	co	co	NN
22283	140	12	-	-	NN
22283	140	13	ordination	ordination	NN
22283	140	14	,	,	,
22283	140	15	or	or	CC
22283	140	16	dexterity	dexterity	NN
22283	140	17	,	,	,
22283	140	18	'	'	''
22283	140	19	practice	practice	NN
22283	140	20	makes	make	VBZ
22283	140	21	perfect	perfect	JJ
22283	140	22	:	:	:
22283	140	23	'	'	''
22283	140	24	the	the	DT
22283	140	25	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	140	26	-	-	HYPH
22283	140	27	centres	centre	NNS
22283	140	28	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	140	29	learn	learn	VBP
22283	140	30	to	to	TO
22283	140	31	perform	perform	VB
22283	140	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	140	33	work	work	NN
22283	140	34	by	by	IN
22283	140	35	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	140	36	repeating	repeat	VBG
22283	140	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	140	38	,	,	,
22283	140	39	because	because	IN
22283	140	40	in	in	IN
22283	140	41	this	this	DT
22283	140	42	way	way	NN
22283	140	43	the	the	DT
22283	140	44	needful	needful	JJ
22283	140	45	lines	line	NNS
22283	140	46	of	of	IN
22283	140	47	wave	wave	NN
22283	140	48	-	-	HYPH
22283	140	49	movement	movement	NN
22283	140	50	in	in	IN
22283	140	51	the	the	DT
22283	140	52	structure	structure	NN
22283	140	53	of	of	IN
22283	140	54	the	the	DT
22283	140	55	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	140	56	-	-	HYPH
22283	140	57	centre	centre	NN
22283	140	58	are	be	VBP
22283	140	59	rendered	render	VBN
22283	140	60	more	more	JJR
22283	140	61	and	and	CC
22283	140	62	more	more	RBR
22283	140	63	permeable	permeable	JJ
22283	140	64	by	by	IN
22283	140	65	use	use	NN
22283	140	66	.	.	.
22283	141	1	Now	now	RB
22283	141	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	141	3	have	have	VBP
22283	141	4	seen	see	VBN
22283	141	5	that	that	IN
22283	141	6	in	in	IN
22283	141	7	the	the	DT
22283	141	8	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	141	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	141	10	centres	centre	NNS
22283	141	11	called	call	VBD
22283	141	12	the	the	DT
22283	141	13	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	141	14	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	141	15	,	,	,
22283	141	16	wave	wave	NN
22283	141	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	141	18	movement	movement	NN
22283	141	19	of	of	IN
22283	141	20	this	this	DT
22283	141	21	kind	kind	NN
22283	141	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	141	23	accompanied	accompany	VBN
22283	141	24	with	with	IN
22283	141	25	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	141	26	.	.	.
22283	142	1	Changes	change	NNS
22283	142	2	of	of	IN
22283	142	3	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	142	4	follow	follow	VBP
22283	142	5	step	step	NN
22283	142	6	by	by	IN
22283	142	7	step	step	NN
22283	142	8	these	these	DT
22283	142	9	waves	wave	NNS
22283	142	10	of	of	IN
22283	142	11	movement	movement	NN
22283	142	12	in	in	IN
22283	142	13	the	the	DT
22283	142	14	brain	brain	NN
22283	142	15	,	,	,
22283	142	16	and	and	CC
22283	142	17	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	142	18	when	when	WRB
22283	142	19	on	on	IN
22283	142	20	two	two	CD
22283	142	21	successive	successive	JJ
22283	142	22	occasions	occasion	NNS
22283	142	23	the	the	DT
22283	142	24	waves	wave	NNS
22283	142	25	of	of	IN
22283	142	26	movement	movement	NN
22283	142	27	pursue	pursue	VB
22283	142	28	the	the	DT
22283	142	29	same	same	JJ
22283	142	30	pathway	pathway	NN
22283	142	31	in	in	IN
22283	142	32	the	the	DT
22283	142	33	brain	brain	NN
22283	142	34	,	,	,
22283	142	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	142	36	are	be	VBP
22283	142	37	attended	attend	VBN
22283	142	38	with	with	IN
22283	142	39	a	a	DT
22283	142	40	succession	succession	NN
22283	142	41	of	of	IN
22283	142	42	the	the	DT
22283	142	43	same	same	JJ
22283	142	44	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	142	45	in	in	IN
22283	142	46	the	the	DT
22283	142	47	mind	mind	NN
22283	142	48	.	.	.
22283	143	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	143	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	143	3	see	see	VBP
22283	143	4	that	that	IN
22283	143	5	the	the	DT
22283	143	6	tendency	tendency	NN
22283	143	7	of	of	IN
22283	143	8	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	143	9	to	to	IN
22283	143	10	_	_	NNP
22283	143	11	re_cur	re_cur	ADD
22283	143	12	in	in	IN
22283	143	13	the	the	DT
22283	143	14	same	same	JJ
22283	143	15	order	order	NN
22283	143	16	as	as	IN
22283	143	17	that	that	DT
22283	143	18	in	in	IN
22283	143	19	which	which	WDT
22283	143	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	143	21	have	have	VBP
22283	143	22	previously	previously	RB
22283	143	23	_	_	IN
22283	143	24	oc_curred	oc_curred	NNP
22283	143	25	,	,	,
22283	143	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	143	27	merely	merely	RB
22283	143	28	an	an	DT
22283	143	29	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	143	30	expression	expression	NN
22283	143	31	of	of	IN
22283	143	32	the	the	DT
22283	143	33	fact	fact	NN
22283	143	34	that	that	IN
22283	143	35	lines	line	NNS
22283	143	36	of	of	IN
22283	143	37	wave	wave	NN
22283	143	38	-	-	HYPH
22283	143	39	movement	movement	NN
22283	143	40	in	in	IN
22283	143	41	the	the	DT
22283	143	42	brain	brain	NN
22283	143	43	become	become	VBP
22283	143	44	more	more	RBR
22283	143	45	and	and	CC
22283	143	46	more	more	RBR
22283	143	47	permeable	permeable	JJ
22283	143	48	by	by	IN
22283	143	49	use	use	NN
22283	143	50	.	.	.
22283	144	1	So	so	RB
22283	144	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	144	3	comes	come	VBZ
22283	144	4	that	that	IN
22283	144	5	a	a	DT
22283	144	6	child	child	NN
22283	144	7	can	can	MD
22283	144	8	learn	learn	VB
22283	144	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	144	10	lessons	lesson	NNS
22283	144	11	by	by	IN
22283	144	12	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	144	13	repeating	repeat	VBG
22283	144	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	144	15	;	;	:
22283	144	16	so	so	CC
22283	144	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	144	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	144	19	that	that	IN
22283	144	20	all	all	PDT
22283	144	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	144	22	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	144	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	144	24	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
22283	144	25	;	;	:
22283	144	26	and	and	CC
22283	144	27	so	so	RB
22283	144	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	144	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	144	30	that	that	IN
22283	144	31	all	all	PDT
22283	144	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	144	33	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	144	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	144	35	conducted	conduct	VBN
22283	144	36	.	.	.
22283	145	1	A	a	DT
22283	145	2	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	145	3	new	new	JJ
22283	145	4	field	field	NN
22283	145	5	of	of	IN
22283	145	6	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	145	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	145	8	thus	thus	RB
22283	145	9	opened	open	VBN
22283	145	10	up	up	RP
22283	145	11	.	.	.
22283	146	1	By	by	IN
22283	146	2	using	use	VBG
22283	146	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	146	4	own	own	JJ
22283	146	5	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	146	6	as	as	IN
22283	146	7	a	a	DT
22283	146	8	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	146	9	instrument	instrument	NN
22283	146	10	of	of	IN
22283	146	11	the	the	DT
22283	146	12	greatest	great	JJS
22283	146	13	delicacy	delicacy	NN
22283	146	14	,	,	,
22283	146	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	146	16	are	be	VBP
22283	146	17	able	able	JJ
22283	146	18	to	to	TO
22283	146	19	learn	learn	VB
22283	146	20	a	a	DT
22283	146	21	great	great	JJ
22283	146	22	deal	deal	NN
22283	146	23	about	about	IN
22283	146	24	the	the	DT
22283	146	25	dynamics	dynamic	NNS
22283	146	26	of	of	IN
22283	146	27	brain	brain	NN
22283	146	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	146	29	action	action	NN
22283	146	30	concerning	concern	VBG
22283	146	31	which	which	WDT
22283	146	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	146	33	should	should	MD
22283	146	34	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	146	35	remain	remain	VB
22283	146	36	in	in	IN
22283	146	37	total	total	JJ
22283	146	38	ignorance	ignorance	NN
22283	146	39	.	.	.
22283	147	1	But	but	CC
22283	147	2	the	the	DT
22283	147	3	field	field	NN
22283	147	4	of	of	IN
22283	147	5	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	147	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	147	7	opened	open	VBD
22283	147	8	up	up	RP
22283	147	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	147	10	too	too	RB
22283	147	11	large	large	JJ
22283	147	12	for	for	IN
22283	147	13	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	147	14	to	to	TO
22283	147	15	enter	enter	VB
22283	147	16	upon	upon	IN
22283	147	17	to	to	IN
22283	147	18	-	-	HYPH
22283	147	19	day	day	NN
22283	147	20	.	.	.
22283	148	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	148	2	will	will	MD
22283	148	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	148	4	merely	merely	RB
22283	148	5	observe	observe	VB
22283	148	6	,	,	,
22283	148	7	in	in	IN
22283	148	8	general	general	JJ
22283	148	9	terms	term	NNS
22283	148	10	,	,	,
22283	148	11	that	that	IN
22283	148	12	although	although	IN
22283	148	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	148	14	are	be	VBP
22283	148	15	still	still	RB
22283	148	16	very	very	RB
22283	148	17	far	far	RB
22283	148	18	from	from	IN
22283	148	19	understanding	understand	VBG
22283	148	20	the	the	DT
22283	148	21	operations	operation	NNS
22283	148	22	of	of	IN
22283	148	23	the	the	DT
22283	148	24	brain	brain	NN
22283	148	25	in	in	IN
22283	148	26	thought	thought	NN
22283	148	27	,	,	,
22283	148	28	there	there	EX
22283	148	29	can	can	MD
22283	148	30	be	be	VB
22283	148	31	no	no	RB
22283	148	32	longer	long	RBR
22283	148	33	any	any	DT
22283	148	34	question	question	NN
22283	148	35	that	that	IN
22283	148	36	in	in	IN
22283	148	37	these	these	DT
22283	148	38	operations	operation	NNS
22283	148	39	of	of	IN
22283	148	40	the	the	DT
22283	148	41	brain	brain	NN
22283	148	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	148	43	have	have	VBP
22283	148	44	what	what	WP
22283	148	45	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	148	46	may	may	MD
22283	148	47	term	term	VB
22283	148	48	the	the	DT
22283	148	49	objective	objective	JJ
22283	148	50	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	148	51	of	of	IN
22283	148	52	thought	thought	NN
22283	148	53	.	.	.
22283	149	1	'	'	``
22283	149	2	Not	not	RB
22283	149	3	every	every	DT
22283	149	4	thought	thought	NN
22283	149	5	to	to	IN
22283	149	6	every	every	DT
22283	149	7	thought	thought	NN
22283	149	8	succeeds	succeed	VBZ
22283	149	9	indifferently	indifferently	RB
22283	149	10	,	,	,
22283	149	11	'	'	''
22283	149	12	said	say	VBD
22283	149	13	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	149	14	.	.	.
22283	150	1	Starting	start	VBG
22283	150	2	from	from	IN
22283	150	3	this	this	DT
22283	150	4	fact	fact	NN
22283	150	5	,	,	,
22283	150	6	modern	modern	JJ
22283	150	7	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	150	8	has	have	VBZ
22283	150	9	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	150	10	shown	show	VBN
22283	150	11	why	why	WRB
22283	150	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	150	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	150	14	a	a	DT
22283	150	15	fact	fact	NN
22283	150	16	;	;	:
22283	150	17	and	and	CC
22283	150	18	looking	look	VBG
22283	150	19	to	to	IN
22283	150	20	the	the	DT
22283	150	21	astonishing	astonishing	JJ
22283	150	22	rate	rate	NN
22283	150	23	at	at	IN
22283	150	24	which	which	WDT
22283	150	25	the	the	DT
22283	150	26	science	science	NN
22283	150	27	of	of	IN
22283	150	28	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	150	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	150	30	now	now	RB
22283	150	31	advancing	advance	VBG
22283	150	32	,	,	,
22283	150	33	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	150	34	think	think	VBP
22283	150	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	150	36	may	may	MD
22283	150	37	fairly	fairly	RB
22283	150	38	expect	expect	VB
22283	150	39	that	that	IN
22283	150	40	within	within	IN
22283	150	41	a	a	DT
22283	150	42	time	time	NN
22283	150	43	less	less	RBR
22283	150	44	remote	remote	JJ
22283	150	45	than	than	IN
22283	150	46	the	the	DT
22283	150	47	two	two	CD
22283	150	48	centuries	century	NNS
22283	150	49	which	which	WDT
22283	150	50	now	now	RB
22283	150	51	separate	separate	VBP
22283	150	52	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	150	53	from	from	IN
22283	150	54	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	150	55	,	,	,
22283	150	56	the	the	DT
22283	150	57	course	course	NN
22283	150	58	of	of	IN
22283	150	59	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	150	60	in	in	IN
22283	150	61	a	a	DT
22283	150	62	given	give	VBN
22283	150	63	train	train	NN
22283	150	64	of	of	IN
22283	150	65	thought	thought	NN
22283	150	66	will	will	MD
22283	150	67	admit	admit	VB
22283	150	68	of	of	IN
22283	150	69	having	have	VBG
22283	150	70	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	150	71	footsteps	footstep	NNS
22283	150	72	tracked	track	VBN
22283	150	73	in	in	IN
22283	150	74	the	the	DT
22283	150	75	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	150	76	pathways	pathway	NNS
22283	150	77	of	of	IN
22283	150	78	the	the	DT
22283	150	79	brain	brain	NN
22283	150	80	.	.	.
22283	151	1	Be	be	VB
22283	151	2	this	this	DT
22283	151	3	,	,	,
22283	151	4	however	however	RB
22283	151	5	,	,	,
22283	151	6	as	as	IN
22283	151	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	151	8	may	may	MD
22283	151	9	,	,	,
22283	151	10	even	even	RB
22283	151	11	now	now	RB
22283	151	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	151	13	know	know	VBP
22283	151	14	enough	enough	RB
22283	151	15	to	to	TO
22283	151	16	say	say	VB
22283	151	17	that	that	IN
22283	151	18	,	,	,
22283	151	19	whether	whether	IN
22283	151	20	or	or	CC
22283	151	21	not	not	RB
22283	151	22	these	these	DT
22283	151	23	footsteps	footstep	NNS
22283	151	24	will	will	MD
22283	151	25	ever	ever	RB
22283	151	26	admit	admit	VB
22283	151	27	of	of	IN
22283	151	28	being	be	VBG
22283	151	29	thus	thus	RB
22283	151	30	tracked	track	VBN
22283	151	31	in	in	IN
22283	151	32	detail	detail	NN
22283	151	33	,	,	,
22283	151	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	151	35	are	be	VBP
22283	151	36	all	all	DT
22283	151	37	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	151	38	present	present	JJ
22283	151	39	in	in	IN
22283	151	40	the	the	DT
22283	151	41	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	151	42	structures	structure	NNS
22283	151	43	of	of	IN
22283	151	44	each	each	DT
22283	151	45	one	one	CD
22283	151	46	of	of	IN
22283	151	47	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	151	48	.	.	.
22283	152	1	What	what	WP
22283	152	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	152	3	know	know	VBP
22283	152	4	on	on	IN
22283	152	5	the	the	DT
22283	152	6	side	side	NN
22283	152	7	of	of	IN
22283	152	8	mind	mind	NN
22283	152	9	as	as	IN
22283	152	10	logical	logical	JJ
22283	152	11	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	152	12	,	,	,
22283	152	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	152	14	on	on	IN
22283	152	15	the	the	DT
22283	152	16	side	side	NN
22283	152	17	of	of	IN
22283	152	18	the	the	DT
22283	152	19	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	152	20	system	system	NN
22283	152	21	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	152	22	more	more	JJR
22283	152	23	than	than	IN
22283	152	24	a	a	DT
22283	152	25	passage	passage	NN
22283	152	26	of	of	IN
22283	152	27	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	152	28	energy	energy	NN
22283	152	29	through	through	IN
22283	152	30	one	one	CD
22283	152	31	series	series	NN
22283	152	32	of	of	IN
22283	152	33	cells	cell	NNS
22283	152	34	and	and	CC
22283	152	35	fibres	fibre	NNS
22283	152	36	rather	rather	RB
22283	152	37	than	than	IN
22283	152	38	through	through	IN
22283	152	39	another	another	DT
22283	152	40	:	:	:
22283	152	41	what	what	WP
22283	152	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	152	43	recognize	recognize	VBP
22283	152	44	as	as	IN
22283	152	45	truth	truth	NN
22283	152	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	152	47	merely	merely	RB
22283	152	48	the	the	DT
22283	152	49	fact	fact	NN
22283	152	50	of	of	IN
22283	152	51	the	the	DT
22283	152	52	brain	brain	NN
22283	152	53	vibrating	vibrate	VBG
22283	152	54	in	in	IN
22283	152	55	tune	tune	NN
22283	152	56	with	with	IN
22283	152	57	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	152	58	.	.	.
22283	153	1	*	*	NFP
22283	153	2	*	*	NFP
22283	153	3	*	*	NFP
22283	153	4	*	*	NFP
22283	153	5	*	*	NFP
22283	153	6	Such	such	JJ
22283	153	7	being	be	VBG
22283	153	8	the	the	DT
22283	153	9	intimate	intimate	JJ
22283	153	10	relation	relation	NN
22283	153	11	between	between	IN
22283	153	12	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	153	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	153	14	action	action	NN
22283	153	15	and	and	CC
22283	153	16	mind	mind	NN
22283	153	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	153	18	action	action	NN
22283	153	19	,	,	,
22283	153	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	153	21	has	have	VBZ
22283	153	22	become	become	VBN
22283	153	23	the	the	DT
22283	153	24	scientifically	scientifically	RB
22283	153	25	orthodox	orthodox	JJ
22283	153	26	teaching	teaching	NN
22283	153	27	that	that	IN
22283	153	28	the	the	DT
22283	153	29	two	two	CD
22283	153	30	stand	stand	NN
22283	153	31	to	to	IN
22283	153	32	one	one	CD
22283	153	33	another	another	DT
22283	153	34	in	in	IN
22283	153	35	the	the	DT
22283	153	36	relation	relation	NN
22283	153	37	of	of	IN
22283	153	38	cause	cause	NN
22283	153	39	to	to	TO
22283	153	40	effect	effect	NN
22283	153	41	.	.	.
22283	154	1	One	one	CD
22283	154	2	of	of	IN
22283	154	3	the	the	DT
22283	154	4	most	most	RBS
22283	154	5	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
22283	154	6	of	of	IN
22283	154	7	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	154	8	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
22283	154	9	in	in	IN
22283	154	10	this	this	DT
22283	154	11	place	place	NN
22283	154	12	,	,	,
22283	154	13	the	the	DT
22283	154	14	President	President	NNP
22283	154	15	of	of	IN
22283	154	16	the	the	DT
22283	154	17	Royal	Royal	NNP
22283	154	18	Society	Society	NNP
22283	154	19	,	,	,
22283	154	20	has	have	VBZ
22283	154	21	said	say	VBN
22283	154	22	in	in	IN
22283	154	23	one	one	CD
22283	154	24	of	of	IN
22283	154	25	the	the	DT
22283	154	26	most	most	RBS
22283	154	27	celebrated	celebrated	JJ
22283	154	28	of	of	IN
22283	154	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	154	30	lectures:--'We	lectures:--'we	CD
22283	154	31	have	have	VBP
22283	154	32	as	as	RB
22283	154	33	much	much	JJ
22283	154	34	reason	reason	NN
22283	154	35	for	for	IN
22283	154	36	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	154	37	the	the	DT
22283	154	38	mode	mode	NN
22283	154	39	of	of	IN
22283	154	40	motion	motion	NN
22283	154	41	of	of	IN
22283	154	42	the	the	DT
22283	154	43	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	154	44	system	system	NN
22283	154	45	as	as	IN
22283	154	46	the	the	DT
22283	154	47	cause	cause	NN
22283	154	48	of	of	IN
22283	154	49	the	the	DT
22283	154	50	state	state	NN
22283	154	51	of	of	IN
22283	154	52	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	154	53	,	,	,
22283	154	54	as	as	IN
22283	154	55	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	154	56	have	have	VBP
22283	154	57	for	for	IN
22283	154	58	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	154	59	any	any	DT
22283	154	60	event	event	NN
22283	154	61	as	as	IN
22283	154	62	the	the	DT
22283	154	63	cause	cause	NN
22283	154	64	of	of	IN
22283	154	65	another	another	DT
22283	154	66	.	.	.
22283	154	67	'	'	''
22283	155	1	And	and	CC
22283	155	2	,	,	,
22283	155	3	by	by	IN
22283	155	4	way	way	NN
22283	155	5	of	of	IN
22283	155	6	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	155	7	logical	logical	JJ
22283	155	8	deduction	deduction	NN
22283	155	9	from	from	IN
22283	155	10	this	this	DT
22283	155	11	statement	statement	NN
22283	155	12	,	,	,
22283	155	13	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	155	14	Huxley	Huxley	NNP
22283	155	15	argues	argue	VBZ
22283	155	16	that	that	DT
22283	155	17	thought	think	VBD
22283	155	18	and	and	CC
22283	155	19	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	155	20	have	have	VBP
22283	155	21	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	155	22	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	155	23	to	to	TO
22283	155	24	do	do	VB
22283	155	25	with	with	IN
22283	155	26	determining	determine	VBG
22283	155	27	action	action	NN
22283	155	28	:	:	:
22283	155	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	155	30	are	be	VBP
22283	155	31	merely	merely	RB
22283	155	32	the	the	DT
22283	155	33	bye	bye	NN
22283	155	34	-	-	HYPH
22283	155	35	products	product	NNS
22283	155	36	of	of	IN
22283	155	37	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	155	38	,	,	,
22283	155	39	or	or	CC
22283	155	40	,	,	,
22283	155	41	as	as	IN
22283	155	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	155	43	expresses	express	VBZ
22283	155	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	155	45	,	,	,
22283	155	46	the	the	DT
22283	155	47	indices	index	NNS
22283	155	48	of	of	IN
22283	155	49	changes	change	NNS
22283	155	50	which	which	WDT
22283	155	51	are	be	VBP
22283	155	52	going	go	VBG
22283	155	53	on	on	RP
22283	155	54	in	in	IN
22283	155	55	the	the	DT
22283	155	56	brain	brain	NN
22283	155	57	.	.	.
22283	156	1	Under	under	IN
22283	156	2	this	this	DT
22283	156	3	view	view	NN
22283	156	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	156	5	are	be	VBP
22283	156	6	all	all	DT
22283	156	7	what	what	WP
22283	156	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	156	9	terms	term	VBZ
22283	156	10	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	156	11	automata	automata	NN
22283	156	12	,	,	,
22283	156	13	or	or	CC
22283	156	14	machines	machine	NNS
22283	156	15	which	which	WDT
22283	156	16	happen	happen	VBP
22283	156	17	,	,	,
22283	156	18	as	as	IN
22283	156	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	156	20	were	be	VBD
22283	156	21	by	by	IN
22283	156	22	chance	chance	NN
22283	156	23	,	,	,
22283	156	24	to	to	TO
22283	156	25	be	be	VB
22283	156	26	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	156	27	of	of	IN
22283	156	28	some	some	DT
22283	156	29	of	of	IN
22283	156	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	156	31	own	own	JJ
22283	156	32	movements	movement	NNS
22283	156	33	.	.	.
22283	157	1	But	but	CC
22283	157	2	the	the	DT
22283	157	3	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	157	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	157	5	altogether	altogether	RB
22283	157	6	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	157	7	,	,	,
22283	157	8	and	and	CC
22283	157	9	bears	bear	VBZ
22283	157	10	the	the	DT
22283	157	11	same	same	JJ
22283	157	12	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
22283	157	13	relation	relation	NN
22283	157	14	to	to	IN
22283	157	15	the	the	DT
22283	157	16	activity	activity	NN
22283	157	17	of	of	IN
22283	157	18	the	the	DT
22283	157	19	brain	brain	NN
22283	157	20	as	as	IN
22283	157	21	a	a	DT
22283	157	22	steam	steam	NN
22283	157	23	-	-	HYPH
22283	157	24	whistle	whistle	NN
22283	157	25	bears	bear	NNS
22283	157	26	to	to	IN
22283	157	27	the	the	DT
22283	157	28	activity	activity	NN
22283	157	29	of	of	IN
22283	157	30	a	a	DT
22283	157	31	locomotive	locomotive	JJ
22283	157	32	,	,	,
22283	157	33	or	or	CC
22283	157	34	the	the	DT
22283	157	35	striking	striking	NN
22283	157	36	of	of	IN
22283	157	37	a	a	DT
22283	157	38	clock	clock	NN
22283	157	39	to	to	IN
22283	157	40	the	the	DT
22283	157	41	time	time	NN
22283	157	42	-	-	HYPH
22283	157	43	keeping	keep	VBG
22283	157	44	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	157	45	of	of	IN
22283	157	46	the	the	DT
22283	157	47	clock	clock	NN
22283	157	48	-	-	HYPH
22283	157	49	work	work	NN
22283	157	50	.	.	.
22283	158	1	Here	here	RB
22283	158	2	,	,	,
22283	158	3	again	again	RB
22283	158	4	,	,	,
22283	158	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	158	6	meet	meet	VBP
22283	158	7	with	with	IN
22283	158	8	an	an	DT
22283	158	9	echo	echo	NN
22283	158	10	of	of	IN
22283	158	11	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNPS
22283	158	12	,	,	,
22283	158	13	who	who	WP
22283	158	14	opens	open	VBZ
22283	158	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	158	16	work	work	NN
22283	158	17	on	on	IN
22283	158	18	the	the	DT
22283	158	19	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
22283	158	20	with	with	IN
22283	158	21	these	these	DT
22283	158	22	words:--	words:--	:
22283	158	23	'	'	''
22283	158	24	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	158	25	,	,	,
22283	158	26	the	the	DT
22283	158	27	art	art	NN
22283	158	28	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	158	29	God	God	NNP
22283	158	30	hath	hath	NNP
22283	158	31	made	make	VBD
22283	158	32	and	and	CC
22283	158	33	governs	govern	VBZ
22283	158	34	the	the	DT
22283	158	35	world	world	NN
22283	158	36	,	,	,
22283	158	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	158	38	by	by	IN
22283	158	39	the	the	DT
22283	158	40	_	_	NNP
22283	158	41	art	art	NN
22283	158	42	_	_	NNP
22283	158	43	of	of	IN
22283	158	44	man	man	NN
22283	158	45	,	,	,
22283	158	46	as	as	IN
22283	158	47	in	in	IN
22283	158	48	many	many	JJ
22283	158	49	other	other	JJ
22283	158	50	things	thing	NNS
22283	158	51	,	,	,
22283	158	52	in	in	IN
22283	158	53	this	this	DT
22283	158	54	also	also	RB
22283	158	55	imitated	imitate	VBD
22283	158	56	,	,	,
22283	158	57	that	that	IN
22283	158	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	158	59	can	can	MD
22283	158	60	make	make	VB
22283	158	61	an	an	DT
22283	158	62	artificial	artificial	JJ
22283	158	63	animal	animal	NN
22283	158	64	.	.	.
22283	159	1	For	for	IN
22283	159	2	seeing	see	VBG
22283	159	3	life	life	NN
22283	159	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	159	5	but	but	CC
22283	159	6	a	a	DT
22283	159	7	motion	motion	NN
22283	159	8	of	of	IN
22283	159	9	limbs	limb	NNS
22283	159	10	,	,	,
22283	159	11	the	the	DT
22283	159	12	beginning	beginning	NN
22283	159	13	whereof	whereof	NNP
22283	159	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	159	15	in	in	IN
22283	159	16	the	the	DT
22283	159	17	principal	principal	JJ
22283	159	18	part	part	NN
22283	159	19	within	within	IN
22283	159	20	;	;	:
22283	159	21	why	why	WRB
22283	159	22	may	may	MD
22283	159	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	159	24	not	not	RB
22283	159	25	say	say	VB
22283	159	26	,	,	,
22283	159	27	that	that	IN
22283	159	28	all	all	DT
22283	159	29	_	_	NNP
22283	159	30	automata	automata	NN
22283	159	31	_	_	NNP
22283	159	32	(	(	-LRB-
22283	159	33	engines	engine	NNS
22283	159	34	that	that	WDT
22283	159	35	move	move	VBP
22283	159	36	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	159	37	by	by	IN
22283	159	38	springs	spring	NNS
22283	159	39	and	and	CC
22283	159	40	wheels	wheel	NNS
22283	159	41	as	as	IN
22283	159	42	doth	doth	NNP
22283	159	43	a	a	DT
22283	159	44	watch	watch	NN
22283	159	45	)	)	-RRB-
22283	159	46	,	,	,
22283	159	47	have	have	VB
22283	159	48	an	an	DT
22283	159	49	artificial	artificial	JJ
22283	159	50	life	life	NN
22283	159	51	?	?	.
22283	160	1	For	for	IN
22283	160	2	what	what	WP
22283	160	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	160	4	the	the	DT
22283	160	5	_	_	NNP
22283	160	6	heart	heart	NN
22283	160	7	_	_	NNP
22283	160	8	,	,	,
22283	160	9	but	but	CC
22283	160	10	a	a	DT
22283	160	11	_	_	NNP
22283	160	12	spring	spring	NN
22283	160	13	_	_	NNP
22283	160	14	;	;	:
22283	160	15	and	and	CC
22283	160	16	the	the	DT
22283	160	17	_	_	NNP
22283	160	18	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	160	19	_	_	NNP
22283	160	20	,	,	,
22283	160	21	but	but	CC
22283	160	22	so	so	RB
22283	160	23	many	many	JJ
22283	160	24	_	_	NNP
22283	160	25	strings	string	NNS
22283	160	26	_	_	NNP
22283	160	27	;	;	:
22283	160	28	and	and	CC
22283	160	29	the	the	DT
22283	160	30	_	_	NNP
22283	160	31	joints	joint	NNS
22283	160	32	_	_	NNP
22283	160	33	,	,	,
22283	160	34	but	but	CC
22283	160	35	so	so	RB
22283	160	36	many	many	JJ
22283	160	37	_	_	NNP
22283	160	38	wheels	wheel	NNS
22283	160	39	_	_	NNP
22283	160	40	,	,	,
22283	160	41	giving	give	VBG
22283	160	42	motion	motion	NN
22283	160	43	to	to	IN
22283	160	44	the	the	DT
22283	160	45	whole	whole	JJ
22283	160	46	body	body	NN
22283	160	47	,	,	,
22283	160	48	such	such	JJ
22283	160	49	as	as	IN
22283	160	50	was	be	VBD
22283	160	51	intended	intend	VBN
22283	160	52	by	by	IN
22283	160	53	the	the	DT
22283	160	54	artificer[2	artificer[2	NNP
22283	160	55	]	]	-RRB-
22283	160	56	?	?	.
22283	160	57	'	'	''
22283	161	1	Now	now	RB
22283	161	2	,	,	,
22283	161	3	this	this	DT
22283	161	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	161	5	of	of	IN
22283	161	6	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	161	7	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	161	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	161	9	not	not	RB
22283	161	10	merely	merely	RB
22283	161	11	a	a	DT
22283	161	12	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
22283	161	13	outcome	outcome	NN
22283	161	14	of	of	IN
22283	161	15	the	the	DT
22283	161	16	theory	theory	NN
22283	161	17	that	that	IN
22283	161	18	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	161	19	changes	change	NNS
22283	161	20	are	be	VBP
22283	161	21	the	the	DT
22283	161	22	causes	cause	NNS
22283	161	23	of	of	IN
22283	161	24	mental	mental	JJ
22283	161	25	changes	change	NNS
22283	161	26	,	,	,
22283	161	27	but	but	CC
22283	161	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	161	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	161	30	logically	logically	RB
22283	161	31	the	the	DT
22283	161	32	only	only	JJ
22283	161	33	possible	possible	JJ
22283	161	34	outcome	outcome	NN
22283	161	35	.	.	.
22283	162	1	Nor	nor	CC
22283	162	2	do	do	VBP
22283	162	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	162	4	see	see	VB
22283	162	5	any	any	DT
22283	162	6	way	way	NN
22283	162	7	in	in	IN
22283	162	8	which	which	WDT
22283	162	9	this	this	DT
22283	162	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	162	11	can	can	MD
22283	162	12	be	be	VB
22283	162	13	fought	fight	VBN
22283	162	14	on	on	IN
22283	162	15	grounds	ground	NNS
22283	162	16	of	of	IN
22283	162	17	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	162	18	.	.	.
22283	163	1	If	if	IN
22283	163	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	163	3	persist	persist	VBP
22283	163	4	in	in	IN
22283	163	5	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	163	6	the	the	DT
22283	163	7	association	association	NN
22283	163	8	between	between	IN
22283	163	9	brain	brain	NN
22283	163	10	and	and	CC
22283	163	11	thought	think	VBD
22283	163	12	exclusively	exclusively	RB
22283	163	13	from	from	IN
22283	163	14	a	a	DT
22283	163	15	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	163	16	point	point	NN
22283	163	17	of	of	IN
22283	163	18	view	view	NN
22283	163	19	,	,	,
22283	163	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	163	21	must	must	MD
22283	163	22	of	of	IN
22283	163	23	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	163	24	be	be	VB
22283	163	25	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	163	26	.	.	.
22283	164	1	Further	further	RB
22283	164	2	,	,	,
22283	164	3	so	so	RB
22283	164	4	far	far	RB
22283	164	5	as	as	IN
22283	164	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	164	7	are	be	VBP
22283	164	8	physiologists	physiologist	NNS
22283	164	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	164	10	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	164	11	can	can	MD
22283	164	12	do	do	VB
22283	164	13	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	164	14	no	no	DT
22283	164	15	harm	harm	NN
22283	164	16	.	.	.
22283	165	1	On	on	IN
22283	165	2	the	the	DT
22283	165	3	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	165	4	,	,	,
22283	165	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	165	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	165	7	to	to	IN
22283	165	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	165	9	of	of	IN
22283	165	10	the	the	DT
22283	165	11	utmost	utmost	JJ
22283	165	12	service	service	NN
22283	165	13	,	,	,
22283	165	14	as	as	IN
22283	165	15	at	at	IN
22283	165	16	once	once	RB
22283	165	17	the	the	DT
22283	165	18	simplest	simple	JJS
22283	165	19	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	165	20	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	165	21	of	of	IN
22283	165	22	facts	fact	NNS
22283	165	23	already	already	RB
22283	165	24	known	know	VBN
22283	165	25	,	,	,
22283	165	26	and	and	CC
22283	165	27	the	the	DT
22283	165	28	best	good	JJS
22283	165	29	working	working	JJ
22283	165	30	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	165	31	to	to	TO
22283	165	32	guide	guide	VB
22283	165	33	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	165	34	in	in	IN
22283	165	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	165	36	further	further	JJ
22283	165	37	researches	research	NNS
22283	165	38	.	.	.
22283	166	1	But	but	CC
22283	166	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	166	3	does	do	VBZ
22283	166	4	not	not	RB
22283	166	5	follow	follow	VB
22283	166	6	from	from	IN
22283	166	7	this	this	DT
22283	166	8	that	that	IN
22283	166	9	the	the	DT
22283	166	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	166	11	of	of	IN
22283	166	12	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	166	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	166	14	true	true	JJ
22283	166	15	.	.	.
22283	167	1	The	the	DT
22283	167	2	bells	bell	NNS
22283	167	3	of	of	IN
22283	167	4	St.	St.	NNP
22283	167	5	Mary	Mary	NNP
22283	167	6	's	's	POS
22283	167	7	over	over	IN
22283	167	8	the	the	DT
22283	167	9	way	way	NN
22283	167	10	always	always	RB
22283	167	11	ring	re	VBG
22283	167	12	for	for	IN
22283	167	13	a	a	DT
22283	167	14	quarter	quarter	NN
22283	167	15	of	of	IN
22283	167	16	an	an	DT
22283	167	17	hour	hour	NN
22283	167	18	before	before	IN
22283	167	19	the	the	DT
22283	167	20	University	University	NNP
22283	167	21	sermon	sermon	NN
22283	167	22	;	;	:
22283	167	23	yet	yet	CC
22283	167	24	the	the	DT
22283	167	25	ringing	ringing	NN
22283	167	26	of	of	IN
22283	167	27	the	the	DT
22283	167	28	bells	bell	NNS
22283	167	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	167	30	not	not	RB
22283	167	31	the	the	DT
22283	167	32	cause	cause	NN
22283	167	33	of	of	IN
22283	167	34	the	the	DT
22283	167	35	sermon	sermon	JJ
22283	167	36	,	,	,
22283	167	37	although	although	IN
22283	167	38	,	,	,
22283	167	39	as	as	RB
22283	167	40	long	long	RB
22283	167	41	as	as	IN
22283	167	42	the	the	DT
22283	167	43	association	association	NN
22283	167	44	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	167	45	constant	constant	JJ
22283	167	46	,	,	,
22283	167	47	there	there	EX
22283	167	48	would	would	MD
22283	167	49	be	be	VB
22283	167	50	no	no	DT
22283	167	51	harm	harm	NN
22283	167	52	in	in	IN
22283	167	53	assuming	assume	VBG
22283	167	54	,	,	,
22283	167	55	for	for	IN
22283	167	56	any	any	DT
22283	167	57	practical	practical	JJ
22283	167	58	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	167	59	,	,	,
22283	167	60	that	that	IN
22283	167	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	167	62	is	be	VBZ
22283	167	63	so	so	RB
22283	167	64	.	.	.
22283	168	1	But	but	CC
22283	168	2	just	just	RB
22283	168	3	as	as	IN
22283	168	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	168	5	should	should	MD
22283	168	6	be	be	VB
22283	168	7	wrong	wrong	JJ
22283	168	8	in	in	IN
22283	168	9	concluding	conclude	VBG
22283	168	10	,	,	,
22283	168	11	if	if	IN
22283	168	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	168	13	did	do	VBD
22283	168	14	not	not	RB
22283	168	15	happen	happen	VB
22283	168	16	to	to	TO
22283	168	17	know	know	VB
22283	168	18	so	so	RB
22283	168	19	much	much	JJ
22283	168	20	about	about	IN
22283	168	21	the	the	DT
22283	168	22	matter	matter	NN
22283	168	23	as	as	IN
22283	168	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	168	25	do	do	VBP
22283	168	26	,	,	,
22283	168	27	that	that	IN
22283	168	28	the	the	DT
22283	168	29	University	University	NNP
22283	168	30	sermon	sermon	NN
22283	168	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	168	32	produced	produce	VBN
22283	168	33	by	by	IN
22283	168	34	the	the	DT
22283	168	35	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	168	36	of	of	IN
22283	168	37	bells	bell	NNS
22283	168	38	in	in	IN
22283	168	39	the	the	DT
22283	168	40	tower	tower	NN
22283	168	41	of	of	IN
22283	168	42	St.	St.	NNP
22283	168	43	Mary	Mary	NNP
22283	168	44	's	's	POS
22283	168	45	Church	Church	NNP
22283	168	46	,	,	,
22283	168	47	so	so	IN
22283	168	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	168	49	may	may	MD
22283	168	50	be	be	VB
22283	168	51	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	168	52	wrong	wrong	JJ
22283	168	53	if	if	IN
22283	168	54	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	168	55	were	be	VBD
22283	168	56	definitely	definitely	RB
22283	168	57	to	to	TO
22283	168	58	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	168	59	that	that	IN
22283	168	60	the	the	DT
22283	168	61	sermon	sermon	NN
22283	168	62	is	be	VBZ
22283	168	63	produced	produce	VBN
22283	168	64	by	by	IN
22283	168	65	the	the	DT
22283	168	66	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	168	67	of	of	IN
22283	168	68	a	a	DT
22283	168	69	number	number	NN
22283	168	70	of	of	IN
22283	168	71	little	little	JJ
22283	168	72	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	168	73	-	-	HYPH
22283	168	74	cells	cell	NNS
22283	168	75	in	in	IN
22283	168	76	the	the	DT
22283	168	77	brain	brain	NN
22283	168	78	of	of	IN
22283	168	79	the	the	DT
22283	168	80	preacher	preacher	NN
22283	168	81	.	.	.
22283	169	1	Now	now	RB
22283	169	2	,	,	,
22283	169	3	if	if	IN
22283	169	4	time	time	NN
22283	169	5	permitted	permit	VBD
22283	169	6	,	,	,
22283	169	7	and	and	CC
22283	169	8	if	if	IN
22283	169	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	169	10	supposed	suppose	VBD
22283	169	11	that	that	IN
22283	169	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	169	13	would	would	MD
22283	169	14	all	all	RB
22283	169	15	care	care	VB
22283	169	16	to	to	TO
22283	169	17	go	go	VB
22283	169	18	with	with	IN
22283	169	19	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	169	20	into	into	IN
22283	169	21	matters	matter	NNS
22283	169	22	of	of	IN
22283	169	23	some	some	DT
22283	169	24	abstruseness	abstruseness	NN
22283	169	25	,	,	,
22283	169	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	169	27	could	could	MD
22283	169	28	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	169	29	prove	prove	VB
22283	169	30	that	that	IN
22283	169	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	169	32	the	the	DT
22283	169	33	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	169	34	between	between	IN
22283	169	35	body	body	NN
22283	169	36	and	and	CC
22283	169	37	mind	mind	NN
22283	169	38	may	may	MD
22283	169	39	be	be	VB
22283	169	40	,	,	,
22283	169	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	169	42	have	have	VBP
22283	169	43	the	the	DT
22283	169	44	best	good	JJS
22283	169	45	possible	possible	JJ
22283	169	46	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	169	47	for	for	IN
22283	169	48	concluding	conclude	VBG
22283	169	49	that	that	IN
22283	169	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	169	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	169	52	not	not	RB
22283	169	53	a	a	DT
22283	169	54	causal	causal	JJ
22283	169	55	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	169	56	.	.	.
22283	170	1	These	these	DT
22283	170	2	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	170	3	are	be	VBP
22283	170	4	,	,	,
22283	170	5	of	of	IN
22283	170	6	course	course	NN
22283	170	7	,	,	,
22283	170	8	extra	extra	RB
22283	170	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	170	10	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	170	11	;	;	:
22283	170	12	but	but	CC
22283	170	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	170	14	are	be	VBP
22283	170	15	not	not	RB
22283	170	16	on	on	IN
22283	170	17	this	this	DT
22283	170	18	account	account	NN
22283	170	19	less	less	RBR
22283	170	20	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
22283	170	21	.	.	.
22283	171	1	Within	within	IN
22283	171	2	the	the	DT
22283	171	3	limits	limit	NNS
22283	171	4	of	of	IN
22283	171	5	a	a	DT
22283	171	6	lecture	lecture	NN
22283	171	7	,	,	,
22283	171	8	however	however	RB
22283	171	9	,	,	,
22283	171	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	171	11	can	can	MD
22283	171	12	only	only	RB
22283	171	13	undertake	undertake	VB
22283	171	14	to	to	TO
22283	171	15	give	give	VB
22283	171	16	an	an	DT
22283	171	17	outline	outline	JJ
22283	171	18	sketch	sketch	NN
22283	171	19	of	of	IN
22283	171	20	what	what	WP
22283	171	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	171	22	take	take	VBP
22283	171	23	to	to	TO
22283	171	24	be	be	VB
22283	171	25	the	the	DT
22283	171	26	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
22283	171	27	argument	argument	NN
22283	171	28	against	against	IN
22283	171	29	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	171	30	.	.	.
22283	172	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	172	2	have	have	VBP
22283	172	3	first	first	RB
22283	172	4	the	the	DT
22283	172	5	general	general	JJ
22283	172	6	fact	fact	NN
22283	172	7	that	that	IN
22283	172	8	all	all	PDT
22283	172	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	172	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	172	11	of	of	IN
22283	172	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	172	13	,	,	,
22283	172	14	and	and	CC
22283	172	15	so	so	RB
22283	172	16	of	of	IN
22283	172	17	matter	matter	NN
22283	172	18	,	,	,
22283	172	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	172	20	merely	merely	RB
22283	172	21	a	a	DT
22283	172	22	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	172	23	of	of	IN
22283	172	24	the	the	DT
22283	172	25	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	172	26	of	of	IN
22283	172	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	172	28	.	.	.
22283	173	1	That	that	DT
22283	173	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	173	3	to	to	TO
22283	173	4	say	say	VB
22283	173	5	,	,	,
22283	173	6	all	all	PDT
22283	173	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	173	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	173	9	of	of	IN
22283	173	10	the	the	DT
22283	173	11	external	external	JJ
22283	173	12	world	world	NN
22283	173	13	--	--	:
22283	173	14	including	include	VBG
22283	173	15	the	the	DT
22283	173	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	173	17	of	of	IN
22283	173	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	173	19	own	own	JJ
22283	173	20	brains	brain	NNS
22283	173	21	--	--	:
22283	173	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	173	23	merely	merely	RB
22283	173	24	a	a	DT
22283	173	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	173	26	of	of	IN
22283	173	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	173	28	own	own	JJ
22283	173	29	mental	mental	JJ
22283	173	30	states	state	NNS
22283	173	31	.	.	.
22283	174	1	Let	let	VB
22283	174	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	174	3	be	be	VB
22283	174	4	observed	observe	VBN
22283	174	5	that	that	IN
22283	174	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	174	7	do	do	VBP
22283	174	8	not	not	RB
22283	174	9	even	even	RB
22283	174	10	require	require	VB
22283	174	11	to	to	TO
22283	174	12	go	go	VB
22283	174	13	so	so	RB
22283	174	14	far	far	RB
22283	174	15	as	as	IN
22283	174	16	the	the	DT
22283	174	17	irrefutable	irrefutable	JJ
22283	174	18	position	position	NN
22283	174	19	of	of	IN
22283	174	20	Berkeley	Berkeley	NNP
22283	174	21	,	,	,
22283	174	22	that	that	IN
22283	174	23	the	the	DT
22283	174	24	existence	existence	NN
22283	174	25	of	of	IN
22283	174	26	an	an	DT
22283	174	27	external	external	JJ
22283	174	28	world	world	NN
22283	174	29	without	without	IN
22283	174	30	the	the	DT
22283	174	31	medium	medium	NN
22283	174	32	of	of	IN
22283	174	33	mind	mind	NN
22283	174	34	,	,	,
22283	174	35	or	or	CC
22283	174	36	of	of	IN
22283	174	37	being	be	VBG
22283	174	38	without	without	IN
22283	174	39	knowing	know	VBG
22283	174	40	,	,	,
22283	174	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	174	42	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	174	43	.	.	.
22283	175	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	175	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	175	3	enough	enough	JJ
22283	175	4	to	to	TO
22283	175	5	take	take	VB
22283	175	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	175	7	stand	stand	NN
22283	175	8	on	on	IN
22283	175	9	a	a	DT
22283	175	10	lower	low	JJR
22283	175	11	level	level	NN
22283	175	12	of	of	IN
22283	175	13	abstraction	abstraction	NN
22283	175	14	,	,	,
22283	175	15	and	and	CC
22283	175	16	to	to	TO
22283	175	17	say	say	VB
22283	175	18	that	that	IN
22283	175	19	whether	whether	IN
22283	175	20	or	or	CC
22283	175	21	not	not	RB
22283	175	22	an	an	DT
22283	175	23	external	external	JJ
22283	175	24	world	world	NN
22283	175	25	can	can	MD
22283	175	26	exist	exist	VB
22283	175	27	apart	apart	RB
22283	175	28	from	from	IN
22283	175	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	175	30	in	in	IN
22283	175	31	any	any	DT
22283	175	32	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	175	33	or	or	CC
22283	175	34	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	175	35	sense	sense	NN
22283	175	36	,	,	,
22283	175	37	at	at	IN
22283	175	38	any	any	DT
22283	175	39	rate	rate	NN
22283	175	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	175	41	can	can	MD
22283	175	42	not	not	RB
22283	175	43	do	do	VB
22283	175	44	so	so	RB
22283	175	45	_	_	NNP
22283	175	46	for	for	IN
22283	175	47	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	175	48	_	_	NNP
22283	175	49	.	.	.
22283	176	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	176	2	can	can	MD
22283	176	3	not	not	RB
22283	176	4	think	think	VB
22283	176	5	any	any	DT
22283	176	6	of	of	IN
22283	176	7	the	the	DT
22283	176	8	facts	fact	NNS
22283	176	9	of	of	IN
22283	176	10	external	external	JJ
22283	176	11	nature	nature	NN
22283	176	12	without	without	IN
22283	176	13	presupposing	presuppose	VBG
22283	176	14	the	the	DT
22283	176	15	existence	existence	NN
22283	176	16	of	of	IN
22283	176	17	a	a	DT
22283	176	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	176	19	which	which	WDT
22283	176	20	thinks	think	VBZ
22283	176	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	176	22	;	;	:
22283	176	23	and	and	CC
22283	176	24	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	176	25	,	,	,
22283	176	26	so	so	RB
22283	176	27	far	far	RB
22283	176	28	at	at	IN
22283	176	29	least	least	JJS
22283	176	30	as	as	IN
22283	176	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	176	32	are	be	VBP
22283	176	33	concerned	concerned	JJ
22283	176	34	,	,	,
22283	176	35	mind	mind	NN
22283	176	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	176	37	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	176	38	prior	prior	JJ
22283	176	39	to	to	IN
22283	176	40	everything	everything	NN
22283	176	41	else	else	RB
22283	176	42	.	.	.
22283	177	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	177	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	177	3	for	for	IN
22283	177	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	177	5	the	the	DT
22283	177	6	only	only	JJ
22283	177	7	mode	mode	NN
22283	177	8	of	of	IN
22283	177	9	existence	existence	NN
22283	177	10	which	which	WDT
22283	177	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	177	12	real	real	JJ
22283	177	13	in	in	IN
22283	177	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	177	15	own	own	JJ
22283	177	16	right	right	NN
22283	177	17	;	;	:
22283	177	18	and	and	CC
22283	177	19	to	to	IN
22283	177	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	177	21	,	,	,
22283	177	22	as	as	IN
22283	177	23	to	to	IN
22283	177	24	a	a	DT
22283	177	25	standard	standard	NN
22283	177	26	,	,	,
22283	177	27	all	all	DT
22283	177	28	other	other	JJ
22283	177	29	modes	mode	NNS
22283	177	30	of	of	IN
22283	177	31	existence	existence	NN
22283	177	32	which	which	WDT
22283	177	33	may	may	MD
22283	177	34	be	be	VB
22283	177	35	_	_	NNP
22283	177	36	in_ferred	in_ferred	NNP
22283	177	37	must	must	MD
22283	177	38	be	be	VB
22283	177	39	_	_	NNP
22283	177	40	re_ferred	re_ferred	NNP
22283	177	41	.	.	.
22283	178	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	178	2	,	,	,
22283	178	3	if	if	IN
22283	178	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	178	5	say	say	VBP
22283	178	6	that	that	DT
22283	178	7	mind	mind	NN
22283	178	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	178	9	a	a	DT
22283	178	10	function	function	NN
22283	178	11	of	of	IN
22283	178	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	178	13	,	,	,
22283	178	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	178	15	are	be	VBP
22283	178	16	only	only	RB
22283	178	17	saying	say	VBG
22283	178	18	,	,	,
22283	178	19	in	in	IN
22283	178	20	somewhat	somewhat	RB
22283	178	21	confused	confused	JJ
22283	178	22	terminology	terminology	NN
22283	178	23	,	,	,
22283	178	24	that	that	DT
22283	178	25	mind	mind	NN
22283	178	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	178	27	a	a	DT
22283	178	28	function	function	NN
22283	178	29	of	of	IN
22283	178	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	178	31	.	.	.
22283	179	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	179	2	,	,	,
22283	179	3	then	then	RB
22283	179	4	,	,	,
22283	179	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	179	6	take	take	VBP
22283	179	7	to	to	TO
22283	179	8	be	be	VB
22283	179	9	a	a	DT
22283	179	10	general	general	JJ
22283	179	11	refutation	refutation	NN
22283	179	12	of	of	IN
22283	179	13	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	179	14	.	.	.
22283	180	1	To	to	TO
22283	180	2	use	use	VB
22283	180	3	but	but	CC
22283	180	4	a	a	DT
22283	180	5	mild	mild	JJ
22283	180	6	epithet	epithet	NN
22283	180	7	,	,	,
22283	180	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	180	9	must	must	MD
22283	180	10	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	180	11	that	that	IN
22283	180	12	the	the	DT
22283	180	13	theory	theory	NN
22283	180	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	180	15	unphilosophical	unphilosophical	JJ
22283	180	16	,	,	,
22283	180	17	seeing	see	VBG
22283	180	18	that	that	IN
22283	180	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	180	20	assumes	assume	VBZ
22283	180	21	one	one	CD
22283	180	22	thing	thing	NN
22283	180	23	to	to	TO
22283	180	24	be	be	VB
22283	180	25	produced	produce	VBN
22283	180	26	by	by	IN
22283	180	27	another	another	DT
22283	180	28	thing	thing	NN
22283	180	29	,	,	,
22283	180	30	in	in	IN
22283	180	31	spite	spite	NN
22283	180	32	of	of	IN
22283	180	33	an	an	DT
22283	180	34	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	180	35	demonstration	demonstration	NN
22283	180	36	that	that	IN
22283	180	37	the	the	DT
22283	180	38	alleged	allege	VBN
22283	180	39	effect	effect	NN
22283	180	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	180	41	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	180	42	prior	prior	JJ
22283	180	43	to	to	IN
22283	180	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	180	45	cause	cause	NN
22283	180	46	.	.	.
22283	181	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	181	2	,	,	,
22283	181	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	181	4	say	say	VBP
22283	181	5	,	,	,
22283	181	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	181	7	a	a	DT
22283	181	8	general	general	JJ
22283	181	9	refutation	refutation	NN
22283	181	10	of	of	IN
22283	181	11	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	181	12	.	.	.
22283	182	1	But	but	CC
22283	182	2	this	this	DT
22283	182	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	182	4	far	far	RB
22283	182	5	from	from	IN
22283	182	6	being	be	VBG
22283	182	7	all	all	DT
22283	182	8	.	.	.
22283	183	1	'	'	``
22283	183	2	Motion	motion	NN
22283	183	3	,	,	,
22283	183	4	'	'	''
22283	183	5	says	say	VBZ
22283	183	6	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	183	7	,	,	,
22283	183	8	'	'	''
22283	183	9	produceth	produceth	JJ
22283	183	10	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	183	11	but	but	IN
22283	183	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	183	13	;	;	:
22283	183	14	'	'	''
22283	183	15	and	and	CC
22283	183	16	yet	yet	RB
22283	183	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	183	18	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	183	19	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
22283	183	20	to	to	TO
22283	183	21	assume	assume	VB
22283	183	22	that	that	IN
22283	183	23	in	in	IN
22283	183	24	the	the	DT
22283	183	25	case	case	NN
22283	183	26	of	of	IN
22283	183	27	the	the	DT
22283	183	28	brain	brain	NN
22283	183	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	183	30	produces	produce	VBZ
22283	183	31	,	,	,
22283	183	32	not	not	RB
22283	183	33	only	only	RB
22283	183	34	motion	motion	NN
22283	183	35	,	,	,
22283	183	36	but	but	CC
22283	183	37	mind	mind	NN
22283	183	38	.	.	.
22283	184	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	184	2	was	be	VBD
22283	184	3	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	184	4	right	right	JJ
22283	184	5	in	in	IN
22283	184	6	saying	say	VBG
22283	184	7	that	that	IN
22283	184	8	with	with	IN
22283	184	9	respect	respect	NN
22283	184	10	to	to	IN
22283	184	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	184	12	movements	movement	NNS
22283	184	13	the	the	DT
22283	184	14	animal	animal	NN
22283	184	15	body	body	NN
22283	184	16	resembles	resemble	VBZ
22283	184	17	an	an	DT
22283	184	18	engine	engine	NN
22283	184	19	or	or	CC
22283	184	20	a	a	DT
22283	184	21	watch	watch	NN
22283	184	22	;	;	:
22283	184	23	and	and	CC
22283	184	24	if	if	IN
22283	184	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	184	26	had	have	VBD
22283	184	27	been	be	VBN
22283	184	28	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
22283	184	29	with	with	IN
22283	184	30	the	the	DT
22283	184	31	products	product	NNS
22283	184	32	of	of	IN
22283	184	33	higher	high	JJR
22283	184	34	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	184	35	in	in	IN
22283	184	36	watch	watch	NN
22283	184	37	-	-	HYPH
22283	184	38	making	making	NN
22283	184	39	,	,	,
22283	184	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	184	41	might	may	MD
22283	184	42	with	with	IN
22283	184	43	full	full	JJ
22283	184	44	propriety	propriety	NN
22283	184	45	have	have	VBP
22283	184	46	argued	argue	VBN
22283	184	47	,	,	,
22283	184	48	for	for	IN
22283	184	49	instance	instance	NN
22283	184	50	,	,	,
22283	184	51	that	that	IN
22283	184	52	in	in	IN
22283	184	53	the	the	DT
22283	184	54	compensating	compensating	NN
22283	184	55	balance	balance	NN
22283	184	56	,	,	,
22283	184	57	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	184	58	a	a	DT
22283	184	59	watch	watch	NN
22283	184	60	adjusts	adjust	VBZ
22283	184	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	184	62	own	own	JJ
22283	184	63	movements	movement	NNS
22283	184	64	in	in	IN
22283	184	65	adaptation	adaptation	NN
22283	184	66	to	to	IN
22283	184	67	external	external	JJ
22283	184	68	changes	change	NNS
22283	184	69	of	of	IN
22283	184	70	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	184	71	,	,	,
22283	184	72	a	a	DT
22283	184	73	watch	watch	NN
22283	184	74	is	be	VBZ
22283	184	75	exhibiting	exhibit	VBG
22283	184	76	the	the	DT
22283	184	77	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	184	78	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	184	79	of	of	IN
22283	184	80	volition	volition	NN
22283	184	81	.	.	.
22283	185	1	And	and	CC
22283	185	2	,	,	,
22283	185	3	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	185	4	,	,	,
22283	185	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	185	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	185	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
22283	185	8	possible	possible	JJ
22283	185	9	to	to	TO
22283	185	10	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	185	11	that	that	IN
22283	185	12	the	the	DT
22283	185	13	principles	principle	NNS
22283	185	14	of	of	IN
22283	185	15	mechanism	mechanism	NN
22283	185	16	might	may	MD
22283	185	17	be	be	VB
22283	185	18	more	more	RBR
22283	185	19	and	and	CC
22283	185	20	more	more	RBR
22283	185	21	extended	extended	JJ
22283	185	22	in	in	IN
22283	185	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	185	24	effects	effect	NNS
22283	185	25	,	,	,
22283	185	26	until	until	IN
22283	185	27	,	,	,
22283	185	28	in	in	IN
22283	185	29	so	so	RB
22283	185	30	marvellously	marvellously	RB
22283	185	31	perfected	perfect	VBD
22283	185	32	a	a	DT
22283	185	33	structure	structure	NN
22283	185	34	as	as	IN
22283	185	35	the	the	DT
22283	185	36	human	human	JJ
22283	185	37	brain	brain	NN
22283	185	38	,	,	,
22283	185	39	all	all	PDT
22283	185	40	the	the	DT
22283	185	41	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	185	42	movements	movement	NNS
22283	185	43	of	of	IN
22283	185	44	the	the	DT
22283	185	45	body	body	NN
22283	185	46	might	may	MD
22283	185	47	be	be	VB
22283	185	48	originated	originate	VBN
22283	185	49	in	in	IN
22283	185	50	the	the	DT
22283	185	51	same	same	JJ
22283	185	52	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	185	53	manner	manner	NN
22283	185	54	as	as	IN
22283	185	55	are	be	VBP
22283	185	56	the	the	DT
22283	185	57	compensating	compensate	VBG
22283	185	58	movements	movement	NNS
22283	185	59	of	of	IN
22283	185	60	a	a	DT
22283	185	61	watch	watch	NN
22283	185	62	;	;	:
22283	185	63	for	for	IN
22283	185	64	this	this	DT
22283	185	65	,	,	,
22283	185	66	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	185	67	,	,	,
22283	185	68	as	as	IN
22283	185	69	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	185	70	have	have	VBP
22283	185	71	seen	see	VBN
22283	185	72	,	,	,
22283	185	73	is	be	VBZ
22283	185	74	no	no	DT
22283	185	75	more	more	JJR
22283	185	76	than	than	IN
22283	185	77	happens	happen	VBZ
22283	185	78	in	in	IN
22283	185	79	the	the	DT
22283	185	80	case	case	NN
22283	185	81	of	of	IN
22283	185	82	all	all	PDT
22283	185	83	the	the	DT
22283	185	84	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	185	85	-	-	HYPH
22283	185	86	centres	centre	NNS
22283	185	87	other	other	JJ
22283	185	88	than	than	IN
22283	185	89	the	the	DT
22283	185	90	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	185	91	hemispheres	hemisphere	NNS
22283	185	92	.	.	.
22283	186	1	If	if	IN
22283	186	2	this	this	DT
22283	186	3	were	be	VBD
22283	186	4	so	so	RB
22283	186	5	,	,	,
22283	186	6	motion	motion	NN
22283	186	7	would	would	MD
22283	186	8	be	be	VB
22283	186	9	producing	produce	VBG
22283	186	10	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	186	11	but	but	IN
22283	186	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	186	13	,	,	,
22283	186	14	and	and	CC
22283	186	15	upon	upon	IN
22283	186	16	the	the	DT
22283	186	17	subject	subject	NN
22283	186	18	of	of	IN
22283	186	19	brain	brain	NN
22283	186	20	-	-	HYPH
22283	186	21	action	action	NN
22283	186	22	there	there	EX
22283	186	23	would	would	MD
22283	186	24	be	be	VB
22283	186	25	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	186	26	further	further	RB
22283	186	27	to	to	TO
22283	186	28	say	say	VB
22283	186	29	.	.	.
22283	187	1	Without	without	IN
22283	187	2	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	187	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	187	4	should	should	MD
22283	187	5	be	be	VB
22283	187	6	delivering	deliver	VBG
22283	187	7	this	this	DT
22283	187	8	lecture	lecture	NN
22283	187	9	;	;	:
22283	187	10	without	without	IN
22283	187	11	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	187	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	187	13	would	would	MD
22283	187	14	be	be	VB
22283	187	15	hearing	hear	VBG
22283	187	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	187	17	;	;	:
22283	187	18	and	and	CC
22283	187	19	all	all	PDT
22283	187	20	the	the	DT
22283	187	21	busy	busy	JJ
22283	187	22	brains	brain	NNS
22283	187	23	in	in	IN
22283	187	24	this	this	DT
22283	187	25	University	University	NNP
22283	187	26	would	would	MD
22283	187	27	be	be	VB
22283	187	28	conducting	conduct	VBG
22283	187	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	187	30	researches	research	NNS
22283	187	31	,	,	,
22283	187	32	or	or	CC
22283	187	33	preparing	prepare	VBG
22283	187	34	for	for	IN
22283	187	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	187	36	examinations	examination	NNS
22283	187	37	,	,	,
22283	187	38	mindlessly	mindlessly	RB
22283	187	39	.	.	.
22283	188	1	Strange	strange	JJ
22283	188	2	as	as	IN
22283	188	3	such	such	PDT
22283	188	4	a	a	DT
22283	188	5	state	state	NN
22283	188	6	of	of	IN
22283	188	7	things	thing	NNS
22283	188	8	might	may	MD
22283	188	9	be	be	VB
22283	188	10	,	,	,
22283	188	11	still	still	RB
22283	188	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	188	13	would	would	MD
22283	188	14	be	be	VB
22283	188	15	producing	produce	VBG
22283	188	16	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	188	17	but	but	IN
22283	188	18	motion	motion	NN
22283	188	19	;	;	:
22283	188	20	and	and	CC
22283	188	21	,	,	,
22283	188	22	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	188	23	,	,	,
22283	188	24	if	if	IN
22283	188	25	there	there	EX
22283	188	26	were	be	VBD
22283	188	27	any	any	DT
22283	188	28	mind	mind	NN
22283	188	29	to	to	TO
22283	188	30	contemplate	contemplate	VB
22283	188	31	the	the	DT
22283	188	32	facts	fact	NNS
22283	188	33	,	,	,
22283	188	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	188	35	would	would	MD
22283	188	36	encounter	encounter	VB
22283	188	37	no	no	DT
22283	188	38	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	188	39	paradox	paradox	NN
22283	188	40	:	:	:
22283	188	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	188	42	would	would	MD
22283	188	43	merely	merely	RB
22283	188	44	have	have	VB
22283	188	45	to	to	TO
22283	188	46	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	188	47	that	that	IN
22283	188	48	such	such	JJ
22283	188	49	were	be	VBD
22283	188	50	the	the	DT
22283	188	51	astonishing	astonishing	JJ
22283	188	52	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	188	53	of	of	IN
22283	188	54	mechanism	mechanism	NN
22283	188	55	.	.	.
22283	189	1	But	but	CC
22283	189	2	,	,	,
22283	189	3	as	as	IN
22283	189	4	the	the	DT
22283	189	5	facts	fact	NNS
22283	189	6	actually	actually	RB
22283	189	7	stand	stand	VBP
22283	189	8	,	,	,
22283	189	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	189	10	find	find	VBP
22283	189	11	that	that	IN
22283	189	12	this	this	DT
22283	189	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	189	14	not	not	RB
22283	189	15	the	the	DT
22283	189	16	case	case	NN
22283	189	17	.	.	.
22283	190	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	190	2	find	find	VBP
22283	190	3	,	,	,
22283	190	4	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	190	5	,	,	,
22283	190	6	that	that	IN
22283	190	7	up	up	IN
22283	190	8	to	to	IN
22283	190	9	a	a	DT
22283	190	10	certain	certain	JJ
22283	190	11	level	level	NN
22283	190	12	of	of	IN
22283	190	13	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	190	14	mechanism	mechanism	NN
22283	190	15	alone	alone	RB
22283	190	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	190	17	able	able	JJ
22283	190	18	to	to	TO
22283	190	19	perform	perform	VB
22283	190	20	all	all	PDT
22283	190	21	the	the	DT
22283	190	22	compensations	compensation	NNS
22283	190	23	or	or	CC
22283	190	24	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	190	25	which	which	WDT
22283	190	26	are	be	VBP
22283	190	27	performed	perform	VBN
22283	190	28	by	by	IN
22283	190	29	the	the	DT
22283	190	30	animal	animal	NN
22283	190	31	body	body	NN
22283	190	32	;	;	:
22283	190	33	but	but	CC
22283	190	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	190	35	also	also	RB
22283	190	36	find	find	VBP
22283	190	37	that	that	IN
22283	190	38	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	190	39	this	this	DT
22283	190	40	level	level	NN
22283	190	41	such	such	JJ
22283	190	42	compensations	compensation	NNS
22283	190	43	or	or	CC
22283	190	44	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	190	45	are	be	VBP
22283	190	46	never	never	RB
22283	190	47	performed	perform	VBN
22283	190	48	without	without	IN
22283	190	49	the	the	DT
22283	190	50	intervention	intervention	NN
22283	190	51	of	of	IN
22283	190	52	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	190	53	.	.	.
22283	191	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	191	2	,	,	,
22283	191	3	the	the	DT
22283	191	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	191	5	of	of	IN
22283	191	6	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	191	7	has	have	VBZ
22283	191	8	to	to	TO
22283	191	9	meet	meet	VB
22283	191	10	the	the	DT
22283	191	11	unanswerable	unanswerable	JJ
22283	191	12	question	question	NN
22283	191	13	--	--	:
22283	191	14	How	how	WRB
22283	191	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	191	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	191	17	that	that	IN
22283	191	18	in	in	IN
22283	191	19	the	the	DT
22283	191	20	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	191	21	of	of	IN
22283	191	22	the	the	DT
22283	191	23	brain	brain	NN
22283	191	24	motion	motion	NN
22283	191	25	produces	produce	VBZ
22283	191	26	this	this	DT
22283	191	27	something	something	NN
22283	191	28	which	which	WDT
22283	191	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	191	30	not	not	RB
22283	191	31	motion	motion	NN
22283	191	32	?	?	.
22283	192	1	Science	science	NN
22283	192	2	has	have	VBZ
22283	192	3	now	now	RB
22283	192	4	definitely	definitely	RB
22283	192	5	proved	prove	VBN
22283	192	6	the	the	DT
22283	192	7	correlation	correlation	NN
22283	192	8	of	of	IN
22283	192	9	all	all	PDT
22283	192	10	the	the	DT
22283	192	11	forces	force	NNS
22283	192	12	;	;	:
22283	192	13	and	and	CC
22283	192	14	this	this	DT
22283	192	15	means	mean	VBZ
22283	192	16	that	that	IN
22283	192	17	if	if	IN
22283	192	18	any	any	DT
22283	192	19	kind	kind	NN
22283	192	20	of	of	IN
22283	192	21	motion	motion	NN
22283	192	22	could	could	MD
22283	192	23	produce	produce	VB
22283	192	24	anything	anything	NN
22283	192	25	else	else	RB
22283	192	26	that	that	WDT
22283	192	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	192	28	not	not	RB
22283	192	29	motion	motion	NN
22283	192	30	,	,	,
22283	192	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	192	32	would	would	MD
22283	192	33	be	be	VB
22283	192	34	producing	produce	VBG
22283	192	35	that	that	IN
22283	192	36	which	which	WDT
22283	192	37	science	science	NN
22283	192	38	would	would	MD
22283	192	39	be	be	VB
22283	192	40	bound	bind	VBN
22283	192	41	to	to	TO
22283	192	42	regard	regard	VB
22283	192	43	as	as	IN
22283	192	44	in	in	IN
22283	192	45	the	the	DT
22283	192	46	strictest	strict	JJS
22283	192	47	sense	sense	NN
22283	192	48	of	of	IN
22283	192	49	the	the	DT
22283	192	50	word	word	NN
22283	192	51	a	a	DT
22283	192	52	miracle	miracle	NN
22283	192	53	.	.	.
22283	193	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	193	2	,	,	,
22283	193	3	if	if	IN
22283	193	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	193	5	are	be	VBP
22283	193	6	to	to	TO
22283	193	7	take	take	VB
22283	193	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	193	9	stand	stand	NN
22283	193	10	upon	upon	IN
22283	193	11	science	science	NN
22283	193	12	--	--	:
22283	193	13	and	and	CC
22283	193	14	this	this	DT
22283	193	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	193	16	what	what	WP
22283	193	17	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	193	18	professes	profess	VBZ
22283	193	19	to	to	TO
22283	193	20	do	do	VB
22283	193	21	--	--	:
22283	193	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	193	23	are	be	VBP
22283	193	24	logically	logically	RB
22283	193	25	bound	bind	VBN
22283	193	26	to	to	TO
22283	193	27	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	193	28	,	,	,
22283	193	29	not	not	RB
22283	193	30	merely	merely	RB
22283	193	31	that	that	IN
22283	193	32	the	the	DT
22283	193	33	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	193	34	of	of	IN
22283	193	35	causation	causation	NN
22283	193	36	from	from	IN
22283	193	37	body	body	NN
22283	193	38	to	to	IN
22283	193	39	mind	mind	NN
22283	193	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	193	41	not	not	RB
22283	193	42	so	so	RB
22283	193	43	cogent	cogent	JJ
22283	193	44	as	as	IN
22283	193	45	that	that	DT
22283	193	46	of	of	IN
22283	193	47	causation	causation	NN
22283	193	48	in	in	IN
22283	193	49	any	any	DT
22283	193	50	other	other	JJ
22283	193	51	case	case	NN
22283	193	52	,	,	,
22283	193	53	but	but	CC
22283	193	54	that	that	IN
22283	193	55	in	in	IN
22283	193	56	this	this	DT
22283	193	57	particular	particular	JJ
22283	193	58	case	case	NN
22283	193	59	causation	causation	NN
22283	193	60	may	may	MD
22283	193	61	be	be	VB
22283	193	62	proved	prove	VBN
22283	193	63	,	,	,
22283	193	64	again	again	RB
22283	193	65	in	in	IN
22283	193	66	the	the	DT
22283	193	67	strictest	strict	JJS
22283	193	68	sense	sense	NN
22283	193	69	of	of	IN
22283	193	70	the	the	DT
22283	193	71	term	term	NN
22283	193	72	,	,	,
22283	193	73	a	a	DT
22283	193	74	physical	physical	JJ
22283	193	75	impossibility	impossibility	NN
22283	193	76	.	.	.
22283	194	1	To	to	TO
22283	194	2	adduce	adduce	VB
22283	194	3	only	only	RB
22283	194	4	one	one	CD
22283	194	5	other	other	JJ
22283	194	6	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	194	7	.	.	.
22283	195	1	Apart	apart	RB
22283	195	2	from	from	IN
22283	195	3	all	all	DT
22283	195	4	that	that	WDT
22283	195	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	195	6	have	have	VBP
22283	195	7	said	say	VBD
22283	195	8	,	,	,
22283	195	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	195	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	195	11	not	not	RB
22283	195	12	in	in	IN
22283	195	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	195	14	a	a	DT
22283	195	15	strikingly	strikingly	RB
22283	195	16	suggestive	suggestive	JJ
22283	195	17	fact	fact	NN
22283	195	18	that	that	IN
22283	195	19	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	195	20	only	only	RB
22283	195	21	,	,	,
22283	195	22	yet	yet	CC
22283	195	23	always	always	RB
22283	195	24	,	,	,
22283	195	25	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	195	26	upon	upon	IN
22283	195	27	the	the	DT
22283	195	28	scene	scene	NN
22283	195	29	when	when	WRB
22283	195	30	the	the	DT
22283	195	31	adjustive	adjustive	JJ
22283	195	32	actions	action	NNS
22283	195	33	of	of	IN
22283	195	34	any	any	DT
22283	195	35	animal	animal	NN
22283	195	36	body	body	NN
22283	195	37	rise	rise	NN
22283	195	38	above	above	IN
22283	195	39	the	the	DT
22283	195	40	certain	certain	JJ
22283	195	41	level	level	NN
22283	195	42	of	of	IN
22283	195	43	intricacy	intricacy	NN
22283	195	44	to	to	TO
22283	195	45	which	which	WDT
22283	195	46	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	195	47	have	have	VBP
22283	195	48	alluded	allude	VBN
22283	195	49	?	?	.
22283	196	1	Surely	surely	RB
22283	196	2	this	this	DT
22283	196	3	large	large	JJ
22283	196	4	and	and	CC
22283	196	5	general	general	JJ
22283	196	6	fact	fact	NN
22283	196	7	points	point	NNS
22283	196	8	with	with	IN
22283	196	9	irresistible	irresistible	JJ
22283	196	10	force	force	NN
22283	196	11	to	to	IN
22283	196	12	the	the	DT
22283	196	13	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	196	14	,	,	,
22283	196	15	that	that	IN
22283	196	16	in	in	IN
22283	196	17	the	the	DT
22283	196	18	performance	performance	NN
22283	196	19	of	of	IN
22283	196	20	these	these	DT
22283	196	21	more	more	RBR
22283	196	22	complex	complex	JJ
22283	196	23	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	196	24	,	,	,
22283	196	25	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	196	26	--	--	:
22283	196	27	or	or	CC
22283	196	28	the	the	DT
22283	196	29	power	power	NN
22283	196	30	of	of	IN
22283	196	31	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	196	32	and	and	CC
22283	196	33	the	the	DT
22283	196	34	power	power	NN
22283	196	35	of	of	IN
22283	196	36	willing	willing	JJ
22283	196	37	--	--	:
22283	196	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	196	39	of	of	IN
22283	196	40	some	some	DT
22283	196	41	_	_	NNP
22283	196	42	use	use	NN
22283	196	43	_	_	NNP
22283	196	44	.	.	.
22283	197	1	Assuredly	assuredly	RB
22283	197	2	on	on	IN
22283	197	3	the	the	DT
22283	197	4	principles	principle	NNS
22283	197	5	of	of	IN
22283	197	6	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	197	7	,	,	,
22283	197	8	which	which	WDT
22283	197	9	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	197	10	at	at	IN
22283	197	11	all	all	DT
22283	197	12	events	event	NNS
22283	197	13	can	can	MD
22283	197	14	not	not	RB
22283	197	15	afford	afford	VB
22283	197	16	to	to	TO
22283	197	17	disregard	disregard	VB
22283	197	18	,	,	,
22283	197	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	197	20	would	would	MD
22283	197	21	be	be	VB
22283	197	22	a	a	DT
22283	197	23	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	197	24	anomalous	anomalous	JJ
22283	197	25	fact	fact	NN
22283	197	26	that	that	IN
22283	197	27	so	so	RB
22283	197	28	wide	wide	JJ
22283	197	29	and	and	CC
22283	197	30	important	important	JJ
22283	197	31	a	a	DT
22283	197	32	class	class	NN
22283	197	33	of	of	IN
22283	197	34	faculties	faculty	NNS
22283	197	35	as	as	IN
22283	197	36	those	those	DT
22283	197	37	of	of	IN
22283	197	38	mind	mind	NN
22283	197	39	should	should	MD
22283	197	40	have	have	VB
22283	197	41	become	become	VBN
22283	197	42	developed	develop	VBN
22283	197	43	in	in	IN
22283	197	44	constantly	constantly	RB
22283	197	45	ascending	ascend	VBG
22283	197	46	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	197	47	throughout	throughout	IN
22283	197	48	the	the	DT
22283	197	49	animal	animal	NN
22283	197	50	kingdom	kingdom	NN
22283	197	51	,	,	,
22283	197	52	if	if	IN
22283	197	53	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	197	54	were	be	VBD
22283	197	55	entirely	entirely	RB
22283	197	56	without	without	IN
22283	197	57	use	use	NN
22283	197	58	to	to	IN
22283	197	59	animals	animal	NNS
22283	197	60	.	.	.
22283	198	1	And	and	CC
22283	198	2	,	,	,
22283	198	3	be	be	VB
22283	198	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	198	5	observed	observe	VBN
22283	198	6	,	,	,
22283	198	7	this	this	DT
22283	198	8	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	198	9	holds	hold	VBZ
22283	198	10	good	good	JJ
22283	198	11	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	198	12	views	view	NNS
22283	198	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	198	14	may	may	MD
22283	198	15	happen	happen	VB
22283	198	16	to	to	TO
22283	198	17	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	198	18	upon	upon	IN
22283	198	19	the	the	DT
22283	198	20	special	special	JJ
22283	198	21	theory	theory	NN
22283	198	22	of	of	IN
22283	198	23	natural	natural	JJ
22283	198	24	selection	selection	NN
22283	198	25	.	.	.
22283	199	1	For	for	IN
22283	199	2	the	the	DT
22283	199	3	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	199	4	stands	stand	VBZ
22283	199	5	upon	upon	IN
22283	199	6	the	the	DT
22283	199	7	general	general	JJ
22283	199	8	fact	fact	NN
22283	199	9	that	that	IN
22283	199	10	all	all	PDT
22283	199	11	the	the	DT
22283	199	12	organs	organ	NNS
22283	199	13	and	and	CC
22283	199	14	functions	function	NNS
22283	199	15	of	of	IN
22283	199	16	animals	animal	NNS
22283	199	17	are	be	VBP
22283	199	18	of	of	IN
22283	199	19	use	use	NN
22283	199	20	to	to	IN
22283	199	21	animals	animal	NNS
22283	199	22	:	:	:
22283	199	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	199	24	never	never	RB
22283	199	25	meet	meet	VBP
22283	199	26	,	,	,
22283	199	27	on	on	IN
22283	199	28	any	any	DT
22283	199	29	large	large	JJ
22283	199	30	or	or	CC
22283	199	31	general	general	JJ
22283	199	32	scale	scale	NN
22283	199	33	,	,	,
22283	199	34	with	with	IN
22283	199	35	organs	organ	NNS
22283	199	36	and	and	CC
22283	199	37	functions	function	NNS
22283	199	38	which	which	WDT
22283	199	39	are	be	VBP
22283	199	40	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	199	41	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	199	42	.	.	.
22283	200	1	Is	be	VBZ
22283	200	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	200	3	to	to	TO
22283	200	4	be	be	VB
22283	200	5	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	200	6	that	that	IN
22283	200	7	this	this	DT
22283	200	8	general	general	JJ
22283	200	9	principle	principle	NN
22283	200	10	fails	fail	VBZ
22283	200	11	just	just	RB
22283	200	12	where	where	WRB
22283	200	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	200	14	presence	presence	NN
22283	200	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	200	16	most	most	RBS
22283	200	17	required	required	JJ
22283	200	18	,	,	,
22283	200	19	and	and	CC
22283	200	20	that	that	IN
22283	200	21	the	the	DT
22283	200	22	highest	high	JJS
22283	200	23	functions	function	NNS
22283	200	24	of	of	IN
22283	200	25	the	the	DT
22283	200	26	highest	high	JJS
22283	200	27	organs	organ	NNS
22283	200	28	of	of	IN
22283	200	29	the	the	DT
22283	200	30	highest	high	JJS
22283	200	31	animals	animal	NNS
22283	200	32	stand	stand	VBP
22283	200	33	out	out	IN
22283	200	34	of	of	IN
22283	200	35	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	200	36	with	with	IN
22283	200	37	all	all	DT
22283	200	38	other	other	JJ
22283	200	39	functions	function	NNS
22283	200	40	in	in	IN
22283	200	41	being	be	VBG
22283	200	42	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	200	43	functionless	functionless	JJ
22283	200	44	?	?	.
22283	201	1	To	to	IN
22283	201	2	this	this	DT
22283	201	3	question	question	NN
22283	201	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	201	5	,	,	,
22283	201	6	for	for	IN
22283	201	7	one	one	CD
22283	201	8	,	,	,
22283	201	9	can	can	MD
22283	201	10	only	only	RB
22283	201	11	answer	answer	VB
22283	201	12	,	,	,
22283	201	13	and	and	CC
22283	201	14	answer	answer	VB
22283	201	15	unequivocally	unequivocally	RB
22283	201	16	,	,	,
22283	201	17	No	no	UH
22283	201	18	.	.	.
22283	202	1	As	as	IN
22283	202	2	a	a	DT
22283	202	3	rational	rational	JJ
22283	202	4	being	being	NN
22283	202	5	who	who	WP
22283	202	6	waits	wait	VBZ
22283	202	7	to	to	TO
22283	202	8	take	take	VB
22283	202	9	a	a	DT
22283	202	10	wider	wide	JJR
22283	202	11	view	view	NN
22283	202	12	of	of	IN
22283	202	13	the	the	DT
22283	202	14	facts	fact	NNS
22283	202	15	than	than	IN
22283	202	16	that	that	DT
22283	202	17	which	which	WDT
22283	202	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	202	19	open	open	JJ
22283	202	20	to	to	IN
22283	202	21	the	the	DT
22283	202	22	one	one	CD
22283	202	23	line	line	NN
22283	202	24	of	of	IN
22283	202	25	research	research	NN
22283	202	26	pursued	pursue	VBN
22283	202	27	by	by	IN
22283	202	28	the	the	DT
22283	202	29	physiologist	physiologist	NN
22283	202	30	,	,	,
22283	202	31	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	202	32	am	be	VBP
22283	202	33	forced	force	VBN
22283	202	34	to	to	TO
22283	202	35	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	202	36	that	that	IN
22283	202	37	not	not	RB
22283	202	38	without	without	IN
22283	202	39	a	a	DT
22283	202	40	reason	reason	NN
22283	202	41	does	do	VBZ
22283	202	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	202	43	exist	exist	VB
22283	202	44	in	in	IN
22283	202	45	the	the	DT
22283	202	46	frame	frame	NN
22283	202	47	of	of	IN
22283	202	48	things	thing	NNS
22283	202	49	;	;	:
22283	202	50	and	and	CC
22283	202	51	that	that	IN
22283	202	52	apart	apart	RB
22283	202	53	from	from	IN
22283	202	54	the	the	DT
22283	202	55	activity	activity	NN
22283	202	56	of	of	IN
22283	202	57	mind	mind	NN
22283	202	58	,	,	,
22283	202	59	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	202	60	motion	motion	NN
22283	202	61	is	be	VBZ
22283	202	62	related	relate	VBN
22283	202	63	to	to	IN
22283	202	64	that	that	DT
22283	202	65	which	which	WDT
22283	202	66	is	be	VBZ
22283	202	67	not	not	RB
22283	202	68	motion	motion	NN
22283	202	69	,	,	,
22283	202	70	this	this	DT
22283	202	71	planet	planet	NN
22283	202	72	could	could	MD
22283	202	73	never	never	RB
22283	202	74	have	have	VB
22283	202	75	held	hold	VBN
22283	202	76	the	the	DT
22283	202	77	wonderful	wonderful	JJ
22283	202	78	being	being	NN
22283	202	79	,	,	,
22283	202	80	who	who	WP
22283	202	81	in	in	IN
22283	202	82	multiplying	multiply	VBG
22283	202	83	has	have	VBZ
22283	202	84	replenished	replenish	VBN
22283	202	85	the	the	DT
22283	202	86	earth	earth	NN
22283	202	87	and	and	CC
22283	202	88	subdued	subdue	VBD
22283	202	89	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	202	90	--	--	:
22283	202	91	holding	hold	VBG
22283	202	92	dominion	dominion	NN
22283	202	93	over	over	IN
22283	202	94	the	the	DT
22283	202	95	fish	fish	NN
22283	202	96	of	of	IN
22283	202	97	the	the	DT
22283	202	98	sea	sea	NN
22283	202	99	,	,	,
22283	202	100	and	and	CC
22283	202	101	over	over	IN
22283	202	102	the	the	DT
22283	202	103	fowl	fowl	NN
22283	202	104	of	of	IN
22283	202	105	the	the	DT
22283	202	106	air	air	NN
22283	202	107	,	,	,
22283	202	108	and	and	CC
22283	202	109	over	over	IN
22283	202	110	every	every	DT
22283	202	111	living	living	NN
22283	202	112	thing	thing	NN
22283	202	113	that	that	WDT
22283	202	114	moveth	moveth	NNP
22283	202	115	.	.	.
22283	203	1	What	what	WP
22283	203	2	,	,	,
22283	203	3	then	then	RB
22283	203	4	,	,	,
22283	203	5	shall	shall	MD
22283	203	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	203	7	say	say	VB
22283	203	8	touching	touch	VBG
22283	203	9	this	this	DT
22283	203	10	mysterious	mysterious	JJ
22283	203	11	union	union	NN
22283	203	12	of	of	IN
22283	203	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	203	14	and	and	CC
22283	203	15	motion	motion	NN
22283	203	16	?	?	.
22283	204	1	Having	have	VBG
22283	204	2	found	find	VBN
22283	204	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	204	4	physically	physically	RB
22283	204	5	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	204	6	that	that	IN
22283	204	7	there	there	EX
22283	204	8	should	should	MD
22283	204	9	be	be	VB
22283	204	10	a	a	DT
22283	204	11	causal	causal	JJ
22283	204	12	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	204	13	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	204	14	from	from	IN
22283	204	15	motion	motion	NN
22283	204	16	to	to	IN
22283	204	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	204	18	,	,	,
22283	204	19	shall	shall	MD
22283	204	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	204	21	try	try	VB
22283	204	22	to	to	TO
22283	204	23	reverse	reverse	VB
22283	204	24	the	the	DT
22283	204	25	terms	term	NNS
22283	204	26	,	,	,
22283	204	27	and	and	CC
22283	204	28	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	204	29	a	a	DT
22283	204	30	causal	causal	JJ
22283	204	31	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	204	32	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	204	33	from	from	IN
22283	204	34	mind	mind	NN
22283	204	35	to	to	IN
22283	204	36	motion	motion	NN
22283	204	37	?	?	.
22283	205	1	This	this	DT
22283	205	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	205	3	the	the	DT
22283	205	4	oldest	old	JJS
22283	205	5	and	and	CC
22283	205	6	still	still	RB
22283	205	7	the	the	DT
22283	205	8	most	most	RBS
22283	205	9	popular	popular	JJ
22283	205	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	205	11	--	--	:
22283	205	12	the	the	DT
22283	205	13	theory	theory	NN
22283	205	14	of	of	IN
22283	205	15	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	205	16	.	.	.
22283	206	1	And	and	CC
22283	206	2	,	,	,
22283	206	3	no	no	RB
22283	206	4	doubt	doubt	RB
22283	206	5	,	,	,
22283	206	6	in	in	IN
22283	206	7	one	one	CD
22283	206	8	important	important	JJ
22283	206	9	respect	respect	NN
22283	206	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	206	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	206	12	less	less	RBR
22283	206	13	unphilosophical	unphilosophical	JJ
22283	206	14	than	than	IN
22283	206	15	the	the	DT
22283	206	16	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	206	17	theory	theory	NN
22283	206	18	of	of	IN
22283	206	19	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	206	20	.	.	.
22283	207	1	For	for	IN
22283	207	2	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	207	3	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	207	4	the	the	DT
22283	207	5	causation	causation	NN
22283	207	6	to	to	TO
22283	207	7	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	207	8	from	from	IN
22283	207	9	that	that	DT
22283	207	10	which	which	WDT
22283	207	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	207	12	the	the	DT
22283	207	13	source	source	NN
22283	207	14	of	of	IN
22283	207	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	207	16	idea	idea	NN
22283	207	17	of	of	IN
22283	207	18	causality	causality	NN
22283	207	19	--	--	:
22283	207	20	the	the	DT
22283	207	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	207	22	:	:	:
22283	207	23	not	not	RB
22283	207	24	from	from	IN
22283	207	25	that	that	DT
22283	207	26	into	into	IN
22283	207	27	which	which	WDT
22283	207	28	this	this	DT
22283	207	29	idea	idea	NN
22283	207	30	has	have	VBZ
22283	207	31	been	be	VBN
22283	207	32	read	read	VBN
22283	207	33	--	--	:
22283	207	34	the	the	DT
22283	207	35	brain	brain	NN
22283	207	36	.	.	.
22283	208	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	208	2	,	,	,
22283	208	3	if	if	IN
22283	208	4	causation	causation	NN
22283	208	5	were	be	VBD
22283	208	6	to	to	TO
22283	208	7	be	be	VB
22283	208	8	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	208	9	as	as	IN
22283	208	10	a	a	DT
22283	208	11	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	208	12	either	either	DT
22283	208	13	way	way	NN
22283	208	14	,	,	,
22283	208	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	208	16	would	would	MD
22283	208	17	be	be	VB
22283	208	18	less	less	RBR
22283	208	19	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
22283	208	20	to	to	TO
22283	208	21	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	208	22	mental	mental	JJ
22283	208	23	changes	change	NNS
22283	208	24	the	the	DT
22283	208	25	causes	cause	NNS
22283	208	26	of	of	IN
22283	208	27	material	material	NN
22283	208	28	changes	change	NNS
22283	208	29	than	than	IN
22283	208	30	_	_	NNP
22283	208	31	vice	vice	NNP
22283	208	32	versâ	versâ	NNP
22283	208	33	_	_	NNP
22283	208	34	;	;	:
22283	208	35	for	for	IN
22283	208	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	208	37	should	should	MD
22283	208	38	then	then	RB
22283	208	39	at	at	IN
22283	208	40	least	least	JJS
22283	208	41	be	be	VB
22283	208	42	starting	start	VBG
22283	208	43	from	from	IN
22283	208	44	the	the	DT
22283	208	45	basis	basis	NN
22283	208	46	of	of	IN
22283	208	47	immediate	immediate	JJ
22283	208	48	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	208	49	,	,	,
22283	208	50	instead	instead	RB
22283	208	51	of	of	IN
22283	208	52	from	from	IN
22283	208	53	the	the	DT
22283	208	54	reflection	reflection	NN
22283	208	55	of	of	IN
22283	208	56	that	that	DT
22283	208	57	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	208	58	in	in	IN
22283	208	59	what	what	WP
22283	208	60	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	208	61	call	call	VBP
22283	208	62	the	the	DT
22283	208	63	external	external	JJ
22283	208	64	world	world	NN
22283	208	65	.	.	.
22283	209	1	Seeing	see	VBG
22283	209	2	that	that	IN
22283	209	3	the	the	DT
22283	209	4	external	external	JJ
22283	209	5	world	world	NN
22283	209	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	209	7	known	know	VBN
22283	209	8	to	to	IN
22283	209	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	209	10	only	only	RB
22283	209	11	as	as	IN
22283	209	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	209	13	,	,	,
22283	209	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	209	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	209	16	logically	logically	RB
22283	209	17	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	209	18	for	for	IN
22283	209	19	the	the	DT
22283	209	20	mind	mind	NN
22283	209	21	to	to	TO
22283	209	22	infer	infer	VB
22283	209	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	209	24	own	own	JJ
22283	209	25	causation	causation	NN
22283	209	26	from	from	IN
22283	209	27	the	the	DT
22283	209	28	external	external	JJ
22283	209	29	world	world	NN
22283	209	30	;	;	,
22283	209	31	for	for	IN
22283	209	32	this	this	DT
22283	209	33	would	would	MD
22283	209	34	be	be	VB
22283	209	35	to	to	TO
22283	209	36	infer	infer	VB
22283	209	37	that	that	IN
22283	209	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	209	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	209	40	an	an	DT
22283	209	41	effect	effect	NN
22283	209	42	of	of	IN
22283	209	43	motion	motion	NN
22283	209	44	,	,	,
22283	209	45	which	which	WDT
22283	209	46	would	would	MD
22283	209	47	be	be	VB
22283	209	48	the	the	DT
22283	209	49	same	same	JJ
22283	209	50	as	as	IN
22283	209	51	saying	say	VBG
22283	209	52	that	that	IN
22283	209	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	209	54	is	be	VBZ
22283	209	55	an	an	DT
22283	209	56	effect	effect	NN
22283	209	57	of	of	IN
22283	209	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	209	59	own	own	JJ
22283	209	60	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	209	61	;	;	:
22283	209	62	and	and	CC
22283	209	63	this	this	DT
22283	209	64	would	would	MD
22283	209	65	be	be	VB
22283	209	66	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	209	67	.	.	.
22283	210	1	But	but	CC
22283	210	2	,	,	,
22283	210	3	on	on	IN
22283	210	4	the	the	DT
22283	210	5	other	other	JJ
22283	210	6	hand	hand	NN
22283	210	7	,	,	,
22283	210	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	210	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	210	10	not	not	RB
22283	210	11	thus	thus	RB
22283	210	12	logically	logically	RB
22283	210	13	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	210	14	for	for	IN
22283	210	15	the	the	DT
22283	210	16	mind	mind	NN
22283	210	17	to	to	TO
22283	210	18	infer	infer	VB
22283	210	19	that	that	IN
22283	210	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	210	21	may	may	MD
22283	210	22	be	be	VB
22283	210	23	the	the	DT
22283	210	24	cause	cause	NN
22283	210	25	of	of	IN
22283	210	26	some	some	DT
22283	210	27	of	of	IN
22283	210	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	210	29	own	own	JJ
22283	210	30	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	210	31	,	,	,
22283	210	32	or	or	CC
22283	210	33	,	,	,
22283	210	34	in	in	IN
22283	210	35	other	other	JJ
22283	210	36	words	word	NNS
22283	210	37	,	,	,
22283	210	38	that	that	IN
22283	210	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	210	40	may	may	MD
22283	210	41	have	have	VB
22283	210	42	in	in	IN
22283	210	43	some	some	DT
22283	210	44	measure	measure	NN
22283	210	45	the	the	DT
22283	210	46	power	power	NN
22283	210	47	of	of	IN
22283	210	48	producing	produce	VBG
22283	210	49	what	what	WP
22283	210	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	210	51	knows	know	VBZ
22283	210	52	as	as	IN
22283	210	53	motion	motion	NN
22283	210	54	.	.	.
22283	211	1	And	and	CC
22283	211	2	when	when	WRB
22283	211	3	the	the	DT
22283	211	4	mind	mind	NN
22283	211	5	does	do	VBZ
22283	211	6	infer	infer	VB
22283	211	7	this	this	DT
22283	211	8	,	,	,
22283	211	9	no	no	DT
22283	211	10	logic	logic	NN
22283	211	11	on	on	IN
22283	211	12	earth	earth	NN
22283	211	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	211	14	able	able	JJ
22283	211	15	to	to	TO
22283	211	16	touch	touch	VB
22283	211	17	the	the	DT
22283	211	18	inference	inference	NN
22283	211	19	;	;	:
22283	211	20	the	the	DT
22283	211	21	position	position	NN
22283	211	22	of	of	IN
22283	211	23	pure	pure	JJ
22283	211	24	idealism	idealism	NN
22283	211	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	211	26	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	211	27	the	the	DT
22283	211	28	reach	reach	NN
22283	211	29	of	of	IN
22283	211	30	argument	argument	NN
22283	211	31	.	.	.
22283	212	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	212	2	,	,	,
22283	212	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	212	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	212	5	opposed	opposed	JJ
22283	212	6	to	to	IN
22283	212	7	the	the	DT
22283	212	8	whole	whole	JJ
22283	212	9	momentum	momentum	NN
22283	212	10	of	of	IN
22283	212	11	science	science	NN
22283	212	12	.	.	.
22283	213	1	For	for	IN
22283	213	2	if	if	IN
22283	213	3	mind	mind	NN
22283	213	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	213	5	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	213	6	,	,	,
22283	213	7	on	on	IN
22283	213	8	no	no	DT
22283	213	9	matter	matter	RB
22283	213	10	how	how	WRB
22283	213	11	small	small	JJ
22283	213	12	a	a	DT
22283	213	13	scale	scale	NN
22283	213	14	,	,	,
22283	213	15	to	to	TO
22283	213	16	be	be	VB
22283	213	17	a	a	DT
22283	213	18	cause	cause	NN
22283	213	19	of	of	IN
22283	213	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	213	21	,	,	,
22283	213	22	the	the	DT
22283	213	23	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	213	24	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	213	25	of	of	IN
22283	213	26	science	science	NN
22283	213	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	213	28	impugned	impugn	VBN
22283	213	29	.	.	.
22283	214	1	This	this	DT
22283	214	2	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	214	3	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	214	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	214	5	that	that	IN
22283	214	6	energy	energy	NN
22283	214	7	can	can	MD
22283	214	8	neither	neither	CC
22283	214	9	be	be	VB
22283	214	10	created	create	VBN
22283	214	11	nor	nor	CC
22283	214	12	destroyed	destroy	VBN
22283	214	13	--	--	:
22283	214	14	that	that	IN
22283	214	15	just	just	RB
22283	214	16	as	as	IN
22283	214	17	motion	motion	NN
22283	214	18	can	can	MD
22283	214	19	produce	produce	VB
22283	214	20	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	214	21	but	but	IN
22283	214	22	motion	motion	NN
22283	214	23	,	,	,
22283	214	24	so	so	CC
22283	214	25	,	,	,
22283	214	26	conversely	conversely	RB
22283	214	27	,	,	,
22283	214	28	motion	motion	NN
22283	214	29	can	can	MD
22283	214	30	be	be	VB
22283	214	31	produced	produce	VBN
22283	214	32	by	by	IN
22283	214	33	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	214	34	but	but	IN
22283	214	35	motion	motion	NN
22283	214	36	.	.	.
22283	215	1	Regarded	regarded	JJ
22283	215	2	,	,	,
22283	215	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	215	4	,	,	,
22283	215	5	from	from	IN
22283	215	6	the	the	DT
22283	215	7	stand	stand	NN
22283	215	8	-	-	HYPH
22283	215	9	point	point	NN
22283	215	10	of	of	IN
22283	215	11	physical	physical	JJ
22283	215	12	science	science	NN
22283	215	13	,	,	,
22283	215	14	the	the	DT
22283	215	15	theory	theory	NN
22283	215	16	of	of	IN
22283	215	17	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	215	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	215	19	in	in	IN
22283	215	20	precisely	precisely	RB
22283	215	21	the	the	DT
22283	215	22	same	same	JJ
22283	215	23	case	case	NN
22283	215	24	as	as	IN
22283	215	25	the	the	DT
22283	215	26	theory	theory	NN
22283	215	27	of	of	IN
22283	215	28	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	215	29	:	:	:
22283	215	30	that	that	DT
22283	215	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	215	32	to	to	TO
22283	215	33	say	say	VB
22283	215	34	,	,	,
22283	215	35	if	if	IN
22283	215	36	the	the	DT
22283	215	37	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	215	38	causation	causation	NN
22283	215	39	takes	take	VBZ
22283	215	40	place	place	NN
22283	215	41	,	,	,
22283	215	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	215	43	can	can	MD
22283	215	44	only	only	RB
22283	215	45	be	be	VB
22283	215	46	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	215	47	to	to	TO
22283	215	48	do	do	VB
22283	215	49	so	so	RB
22283	215	50	by	by	IN
22283	215	51	way	way	NN
22283	215	52	of	of	IN
22283	215	53	miracle	miracle	NN
22283	215	54	.	.	.
22283	216	1	And	and	CC
22283	216	2	this	this	DT
22283	216	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	216	4	a	a	DT
22283	216	5	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	216	6	which	which	WDT
22283	216	7	the	the	DT
22283	216	8	more	more	RBR
22283	216	9	clear	clear	JJ
22283	216	10	-	-	HYPH
22283	216	11	sighted	sighted	JJ
22283	216	12	of	of	IN
22283	216	13	the	the	DT
22283	216	14	idealists	idealist	NNS
22283	216	15	have	have	VBP
22283	216	16	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	216	17	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	216	18	.	.	.
22283	217	1	That	that	DT
22283	217	2	subtle	subtle	JJ
22283	217	3	and	and	CC
22283	217	4	most	most	RBS
22283	217	5	entertaining	entertaining	JJ
22283	217	6	thinker	thinker	NN
22283	217	7	,	,	,
22283	217	8	for	for	IN
22283	217	9	example	example	NN
22283	217	10	,	,	,
22283	217	11	the	the	DT
22283	217	12	late	late	JJ
22283	217	13	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	217	14	Green	Green	NNP
22283	217	15	of	of	IN
22283	217	16	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
22283	217	17	,	,	,
22283	217	18	has	have	VBZ
22283	217	19	said	say	VBN
22283	217	20	that	that	IN
22283	217	21	the	the	DT
22283	217	22	self	self	NN
22283	217	23	-	-	HYPH
22283	217	24	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	217	25	volition	volition	NN
22283	217	26	of	of	IN
22283	217	27	man	man	NN
22283	217	28	'	'	''
22283	217	29	does	do	VBZ
22283	217	30	not	not	RB
22283	217	31	consist	consist	VB
22283	217	32	in	in	IN
22283	217	33	a	a	DT
22283	217	34	series	series	NN
22283	217	35	of	of	IN
22283	217	36	natural	natural	JJ
22283	217	37	events	event	NNS
22283	217	38	,	,	,
22283	217	39	...	...	:
22283	217	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	217	41	not	not	RB
22283	217	42	natural	natural	JJ
22283	217	43	in	in	IN
22283	217	44	the	the	DT
22283	217	45	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
22283	217	46	sense	sense	NN
22283	217	47	of	of	IN
22283	217	48	that	that	DT
22283	217	49	term	term	NN
22283	217	50	;	;	:
22283	217	51	not	not	RB
22283	217	52	natural	natural	JJ
22283	217	53	at	at	IN
22283	217	54	any	any	DT
22283	217	55	rate	rate	NN
22283	217	56	in	in	IN
22283	217	57	any	any	DT
22283	217	58	sense	sense	NN
22283	217	59	in	in	IN
22283	217	60	which	which	WDT
22283	217	61	naturalness	naturalness	NN
22283	217	62	would	would	MD
22283	217	63	imply	imply	VB
22283	217	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	217	65	determination	determination	NN
22283	217	66	by	by	IN
22283	217	67	antecedent	antecedent	NN
22283	217	68	events	event	NNS
22283	217	69	,	,	,
22283	217	70	or	or	CC
22283	217	71	by	by	IN
22283	217	72	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	217	73	of	of	IN
22283	217	74	which	which	WDT
22283	217	75	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	217	76	is	be	VBZ
22283	217	77	not	not	RB
22283	217	78	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	217	79	the	the	DT
22283	217	80	source	source	NN
22283	217	81	.	.	.
22283	217	82	'	'	''
22283	218	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	218	2	the	the	DT
22283	218	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	218	4	of	of	IN
22283	218	5	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	218	6	,	,	,
22283	218	7	although	although	IN
22283	218	8	not	not	RB
22283	218	9	directly	directly	RB
22283	218	10	refutable	refutable	JJ
22283	218	11	by	by	IN
22283	218	12	any	any	DT
22283	218	13	process	process	NN
22283	218	14	of	of	IN
22283	218	15	logic	logic	NN
22283	218	16	,	,	,
22283	218	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	218	18	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	218	19	enfeebled	enfeeble	VBN
22283	218	20	by	by	IN
22283	218	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	218	22	collision	collision	NN
22283	218	23	with	with	IN
22283	218	24	the	the	DT
22283	218	25	instincts	instinct	NNS
22283	218	26	of	of	IN
22283	218	27	physical	physical	JJ
22283	218	28	science	science	NN
22283	218	29	.	.	.
22283	219	1	In	in	IN
22283	219	2	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	219	3	holding	hold	VBG
22283	219	4	the	the	DT
22283	219	5	facts	fact	NNS
22283	219	6	of	of	IN
22283	219	7	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	219	8	and	and	CC
22283	219	9	volition	volition	NN
22283	219	10	super	super	JJ
22283	219	11	-	-	JJ
22283	219	12	natural	natural	JJ
22283	219	13	,	,	,
22283	219	14	extra	extra	JJ
22283	219	15	-	-	HYPH
22283	219	16	natural	natural	JJ
22283	219	17	,	,	,
22283	219	18	or	or	CC
22283	219	19	non	non	JJ
22283	219	20	-	-	JJ
22283	219	21	natural	natural	JJ
22283	219	22	,	,	,
22283	219	23	the	the	DT
22283	219	24	theory	theory	NN
22283	219	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	219	26	opposed	oppose	VBN
22283	219	27	to	to	IN
22283	219	28	the	the	DT
22283	219	29	principle	principle	NN
22283	219	30	of	of	IN
22283	219	31	continuity	continuity	NN
22283	219	32	.	.	.
22283	220	1	Spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	220	2	being	be	VBG
22283	220	3	thus	thus	RB
22283	220	4	unsatisfactory	unsatisfactory	JJ
22283	220	5	,	,	,
22283	220	6	and	and	CC
22283	220	7	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	220	8	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	220	9	,	,	,
22283	220	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	220	11	there	there	EX
22283	220	12	yet	yet	RB
22283	220	13	any	any	DT
22283	220	14	third	third	JJ
22283	220	15	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	220	16	in	in	IN
22283	220	17	which	which	WDT
22283	220	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	220	19	may	may	MD
22283	220	20	hope	hope	VB
22283	220	21	to	to	TO
22283	220	22	find	find	VB
22283	220	23	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
22283	220	24	rest	rest	NN
22283	220	25	?	?	.
22283	221	1	In	in	IN
22283	221	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	221	3	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	221	4	there	there	EX
22283	221	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	221	6	.	.	.
22283	222	1	If	if	IN
22283	222	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	222	3	unite	unite	VBP
22283	222	4	in	in	IN
22283	222	5	a	a	DT
22283	222	6	higher	high	JJR
22283	222	7	synthesis	synthesis	NN
22283	222	8	the	the	DT
22283	222	9	elements	element	NNS
22283	222	10	both	both	DT
22283	222	11	of	of	IN
22283	222	12	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	222	13	and	and	CC
22283	222	14	of	of	IN
22283	222	15	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	222	16	,	,	,
22283	222	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	222	18	obtain	obtain	VBP
22283	222	19	a	a	DT
22283	222	20	product	product	NN
22283	222	21	which	which	WDT
22283	222	22	satisfies	satisfy	VBZ
22283	222	23	every	every	DT
22283	222	24	fact	fact	NN
22283	222	25	of	of	IN
22283	222	26	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	222	27	on	on	IN
22283	222	28	the	the	DT
22283	222	29	one	one	CD
22283	222	30	hand	hand	NN
22283	222	31	,	,	,
22283	222	32	and	and	CC
22283	222	33	of	of	IN
22283	222	34	observation	observation	NN
22283	222	35	on	on	IN
22283	222	36	the	the	DT
22283	222	37	other	other	JJ
22283	222	38	.	.	.
22283	223	1	The	the	DT
22283	223	2	manner	manner	NN
22283	223	3	in	in	IN
22283	223	4	which	which	WDT
22283	223	5	this	this	DT
22283	223	6	synthesis	synthesis	NN
22283	223	7	may	may	MD
22283	223	8	be	be	VB
22283	223	9	effected	effect	VBN
22283	223	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	223	11	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	223	12	simple	simple	JJ
22283	223	13	.	.	.
22283	224	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	224	2	have	have	VBP
22283	224	3	only	only	RB
22283	224	4	to	to	TO
22283	224	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	224	6	that	that	IN
22283	224	7	the	the	DT
22283	224	8	antithesis	antithesis	NN
22283	224	9	between	between	IN
22283	224	10	mind	mind	NN
22283	224	11	and	and	CC
22283	224	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	224	13	--	--	:
22283	224	14	subject	subject	NN
22283	224	15	and	and	CC
22283	224	16	object	object	NN
22283	224	17	--	--	:
22283	224	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	224	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	224	20	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	224	21	or	or	CC
22283	224	22	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	224	23	:	:	:
22283	224	24	not	not	RB
22283	224	25	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	224	26	or	or	CC
22283	224	27	real	real	JJ
22283	224	28	.	.	.
22283	225	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	225	2	have	have	VBP
22283	225	3	only	only	RB
22283	225	4	to	to	TO
22283	225	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	225	6	that	that	IN
22283	225	7	the	the	DT
22283	225	8	seeming	seeming	JJ
22283	225	9	duality	duality	NN
22283	225	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	225	11	relative	relative	JJ
22283	225	12	to	to	IN
22283	225	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	225	14	modes	mode	NNS
22283	225	15	of	of	IN
22283	225	16	apprehension	apprehension	NN
22283	225	17	;	;	:
22283	225	18	and	and	CC
22283	225	19	,	,	,
22283	225	20	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	225	21	,	,	,
22283	225	22	that	that	IN
22283	225	23	any	any	DT
22283	225	24	change	change	NN
22283	225	25	taking	take	VBG
22283	225	26	place	place	NN
22283	225	27	in	in	IN
22283	225	28	the	the	DT
22283	225	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	225	30	,	,	,
22283	225	31	and	and	CC
22283	225	32	any	any	DT
22283	225	33	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	225	34	change	change	NN
22283	225	35	taking	take	VBG
22283	225	36	place	place	NN
22283	225	37	in	in	IN
22283	225	38	the	the	DT
22283	225	39	brain	brain	NN
22283	225	40	,	,	,
22283	225	41	are	be	VBP
22283	225	42	really	really	RB
22283	225	43	not	not	RB
22283	225	44	two	two	CD
22283	225	45	changes	change	NNS
22283	225	46	,	,	,
22283	225	47	but	but	CC
22283	225	48	one	one	CD
22283	225	49	change	change	NN
22283	225	50	.	.	.
22283	226	1	When	when	WRB
22283	226	2	a	a	DT
22283	226	3	violin	violin	NN
22283	226	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	226	5	played	play	VBN
22283	226	6	upon	upon	IN
22283	226	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	226	8	hear	hear	VBP
22283	226	9	a	a	DT
22283	226	10	musical	musical	JJ
22283	226	11	sound	sound	NN
22283	226	12	,	,	,
22283	226	13	and	and	CC
22283	226	14	at	at	IN
22283	226	15	the	the	DT
22283	226	16	same	same	JJ
22283	226	17	time	time	NN
22283	226	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	226	19	see	see	VBP
22283	226	20	a	a	DT
22283	226	21	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	226	22	of	of	IN
22283	226	23	the	the	DT
22283	226	24	strings	string	NNS
22283	226	25	.	.	.
22283	227	1	Relatively	relatively	RB
22283	227	2	to	to	IN
22283	227	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	227	4	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	227	5	,	,	,
22283	227	6	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	227	7	,	,	,
22283	227	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	227	9	have	have	VBP
22283	227	10	here	here	RB
22283	227	11	two	two	CD
22283	227	12	sets	set	NNS
22283	227	13	of	of	IN
22283	227	14	changes	change	NNS
22283	227	15	,	,	,
22283	227	16	which	which	WDT
22283	227	17	appear	appear	VBP
22283	227	18	to	to	TO
22283	227	19	be	be	VB
22283	227	20	very	very	RB
22283	227	21	different	different	JJ
22283	227	22	in	in	IN
22283	227	23	kind	kind	NN
22283	227	24	;	;	:
22283	227	25	yet	yet	CC
22283	227	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	227	27	know	know	VBP
22283	227	28	that	that	IN
22283	227	29	in	in	IN
22283	227	30	an	an	DT
22283	227	31	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	227	32	sense	sense	NN
22283	227	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	227	34	are	be	VBP
22283	227	35	one	one	CD
22283	227	36	and	and	CC
22283	227	37	the	the	DT
22283	227	38	same	same	JJ
22283	227	39	:	:	:
22283	227	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	227	41	know	know	VBP
22283	227	42	that	that	IN
22283	227	43	the	the	DT
22283	227	44	diversity	diversity	NN
22283	227	45	in	in	IN
22283	227	46	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	227	47	is	be	VBZ
22283	227	48	created	create	VBN
22283	227	49	only	only	RB
22283	227	50	by	by	IN
22283	227	51	the	the	DT
22283	227	52	difference	difference	NN
22283	227	53	in	in	IN
22283	227	54	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	227	55	modes	mode	NNS
22283	227	56	of	of	IN
22283	227	57	perceiving	perceive	VBG
22283	227	58	the	the	DT
22283	227	59	same	same	JJ
22283	227	60	event	event	NN
22283	227	61	--	--	:
22283	227	62	whether	whether	IN
22283	227	63	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	227	64	see	see	VBP
22283	227	65	or	or	CC
22283	227	66	whether	whether	IN
22283	227	67	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	227	68	hear	hear	VBP
22283	227	69	the	the	DT
22283	227	70	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	227	71	of	of	IN
22283	227	72	the	the	DT
22283	227	73	strings	string	NNS
22283	227	74	.	.	.
22283	228	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
22283	228	2	,	,	,
22283	228	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	228	4	may	may	MD
22283	228	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	228	6	that	that	IN
22283	228	7	a	a	DT
22283	228	8	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	228	9	of	of	IN
22283	228	10	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	228	11	-	-	HYPH
22283	228	12	strings	string	NNS
22283	228	13	and	and	CC
22283	228	14	a	a	DT
22283	228	15	process	process	NN
22283	228	16	of	of	IN
22283	228	17	thought	thought	NN
22283	228	18	are	be	VBP
22283	228	19	really	really	RB
22283	228	20	one	one	CD
22283	228	21	and	and	CC
22283	228	22	the	the	DT
22283	228	23	same	same	JJ
22283	228	24	event	event	NN
22283	228	25	,	,	,
22283	228	26	which	which	WDT
22283	228	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	228	28	dual	dual	JJ
22283	228	29	or	or	CC
22283	228	30	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	228	31	only	only	RB
22283	228	32	in	in	IN
22283	228	33	relation	relation	NN
22283	228	34	to	to	IN
22283	228	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	228	36	modes	mode	NNS
22283	228	37	of	of	IN
22283	228	38	perceiving	perceive	VBG
22283	228	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	228	40	.	.	.
22283	229	1	The	the	DT
22283	229	2	great	great	JJ
22283	229	3	advantage	advantage	NN
22283	229	4	of	of	IN
22283	229	5	this	this	DT
22283	229	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	229	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	229	8	that	that	IN
22283	229	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	229	10	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	229	11	only	only	RB
22283	229	12	one	one	CD
22283	229	13	stream	stream	NN
22283	229	14	of	of	IN
22283	229	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	229	16	,	,	,
22283	229	17	in	in	IN
22283	229	18	which	which	WDT
22283	229	19	both	both	DT
22283	229	20	mind	mind	NN
22283	229	21	and	and	CC
22283	229	22	motion	motion	NN
22283	229	23	are	be	VBP
22283	229	24	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
22283	229	25	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	229	26	.	.	.
22283	230	1	The	the	DT
22283	230	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	230	3	,	,	,
22283	230	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	230	5	,	,	,
22283	230	6	escapes	escape	VBZ
22283	230	7	all	all	PDT
22283	230	8	the	the	DT
22283	230	9	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	230	10	and	and	CC
22283	230	11	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
22283	230	12	with	with	IN
22283	230	13	which	which	WDT
22283	230	14	both	both	DT
22283	230	15	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	230	16	and	and	CC
22283	230	17	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	230	18	are	be	VBP
22283	230	19	beset	beset	NN
22283	230	20	.	.	.
22283	231	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	231	2	,	,	,
22283	231	3	motion	motion	NN
22283	231	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	231	5	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	231	6	to	to	TO
22283	231	7	be	be	VB
22283	231	8	producing	produce	VBG
22283	231	9	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	231	10	but	but	IN
22283	231	11	motion	motion	NN
22283	231	12	;	;	:
22283	231	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	231	14	-	-	HYPH
22283	231	15	changes	change	VBZ
22283	231	16	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	231	17	but	but	IN
22283	231	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	231	19	-	-	HYPH
22283	231	20	changes	change	NNS
22283	231	21	:	:	:
22283	231	22	both	both	DT
22283	231	23	producing	produce	VBG
22283	231	24	both	both	DT
22283	231	25	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
22283	231	26	,	,	,
22283	231	27	neither	neither	DT
22283	231	28	could	could	MD
22283	231	29	be	be	VB
22283	231	30	what	what	WP
22283	231	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	231	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	231	33	without	without	IN
22283	231	34	the	the	DT
22283	231	35	other	other	JJ
22283	231	36	,	,	,
22283	231	37	because	because	IN
22283	231	38	without	without	IN
22283	231	39	the	the	DT
22283	231	40	other	other	JJ
22283	231	41	neither	neither	CC
22283	231	42	could	could	MD
22283	231	43	be	be	VB
22283	231	44	the	the	DT
22283	231	45	cause	cause	NN
22283	231	46	which	which	WDT
22283	231	47	in	in	IN
22283	231	48	fact	fact	NN
22283	231	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	231	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	231	51	.	.	.
22283	232	1	Impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	232	2	,	,	,
22283	232	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	232	4	,	,	,
22283	232	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	232	6	the	the	DT
22283	232	7	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	232	8	of	of	IN
22283	232	9	the	the	DT
22283	232	10	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	232	11	that	that	WDT
22283	232	12	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	232	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	232	14	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	232	15	,	,	,
22283	232	16	or	or	CC
22283	232	17	that	that	IN
22283	232	18	in	in	IN
22283	232	19	the	the	DT
22283	232	20	absence	absence	NN
22283	232	21	of	of	IN
22283	232	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	232	23	changes	change	NNS
22283	232	24	of	of	IN
22283	232	25	brain	brain	NN
22283	232	26	could	could	MD
22283	232	27	be	be	VB
22283	232	28	what	what	WP
22283	232	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	232	30	are	be	VBP
22283	232	31	;	;	:
22283	232	32	for	for	IN
22283	232	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	232	34	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	232	35	to	to	IN
22283	232	36	the	the	DT
22283	232	37	very	very	JJ
22283	232	38	causation	causation	NN
22283	232	39	of	of	IN
22283	232	40	these	these	DT
22283	232	41	changes	change	NNS
22283	232	42	that	that	IN
22283	232	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	232	44	should	should	MD
22283	232	45	have	have	VB
22283	232	46	a	a	DT
22283	232	47	mental	mental	JJ
22283	232	48	side	side	NN
22283	232	49	.	.	.
22283	233	1	The	the	DT
22283	233	2	use	use	NN
22283	233	3	of	of	IN
22283	233	4	mind	mind	NN
22283	233	5	to	to	IN
22283	233	6	animals	animal	NNS
22283	233	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	233	8	thus	thus	RB
22283	233	9	rendered	render	VBN
22283	233	10	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	233	11	;	;	:
22283	233	12	for	for	IN
22283	233	13	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
22283	233	14	volition	volition	NN
22283	233	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	233	16	thus	thus	RB
22283	233	17	shown	show	VBN
22283	233	18	to	to	TO
22283	233	19	be	be	VB
22283	233	20	a	a	DT
22283	233	21	true	true	JJ
22283	233	22	cause	cause	NN
22283	233	23	of	of	IN
22283	233	24	adjustive	adjustive	JJ
22283	233	25	movement	movement	NN
22283	233	26	,	,	,
22283	233	27	in	in	IN
22283	233	28	that	that	IN
22283	233	29	the	the	DT
22283	233	30	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	233	31	which	which	WDT
22283	233	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	233	33	involves	involve	VBZ
22283	233	34	could	could	MD
22283	233	35	not	not	RB
22283	233	36	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	233	37	be	be	VB
22283	233	38	possible	possible	JJ
22283	233	39	:	:	:
22283	233	40	the	the	DT
22283	233	41	causation	causation	NN
22283	233	42	would	would	MD
22283	233	43	not	not	RB
22283	233	44	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	233	45	be	be	VB
22283	233	46	complete	complete	JJ
22283	233	47	.	.	.
22283	234	1	A	a	DT
22283	234	2	simple	simple	JJ
22283	234	3	illustration	illustration	NN
22283	234	4	may	may	MD
22283	234	5	serve	serve	VB
22283	234	6	at	at	IN
22283	234	7	once	once	RB
22283	234	8	to	to	TO
22283	234	9	render	render	VB
22283	234	10	this	this	DT
22283	234	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	234	12	more	more	RBR
22283	234	13	easily	easily	RB
22283	234	14	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
22283	234	15	,	,	,
22283	234	16	and	and	CC
22283	234	17	to	to	TO
22283	234	18	show	show	VB
22283	234	19	that	that	IN
22283	234	20	,	,	,
22283	234	21	if	if	IN
22283	234	22	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	234	23	,	,	,
22283	234	24	the	the	DT
22283	234	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	234	26	,	,	,
22283	234	27	as	as	IN
22283	234	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	234	29	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	234	30	to	to	IN
22283	234	31	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	234	32	,	,	,
22283	234	33	terminates	terminate	VBZ
22283	234	34	the	the	DT
22283	234	35	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	234	36	interminable	interminable	JJ
22283	234	37	controversy	controversy	NN
22283	234	38	on	on	IN
22283	234	39	the	the	DT
22283	234	40	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	234	41	of	of	IN
22283	234	42	the	the	DT
22283	234	43	will	will	NN
22283	234	44	.	.	.
22283	235	1	In	in	IN
22283	235	2	an	an	DT
22283	235	3	Edison	Edison	NNP
22283	235	4	lamp	lamp	NN
22283	235	5	the	the	DT
22283	235	6	light	light	NN
22283	235	7	which	which	WDT
22283	235	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	235	9	emitted	emit	VBN
22283	235	10	from	from	IN
22283	235	11	the	the	DT
22283	235	12	burner	burner	NN
22283	235	13	may	may	MD
22283	235	14	be	be	VB
22283	235	15	said	say	VBN
22283	235	16	indifferently	indifferently	RB
22283	235	17	to	to	TO
22283	235	18	be	be	VB
22283	235	19	caused	cause	VBN
22283	235	20	by	by	IN
22283	235	21	the	the	DT
22283	235	22	number	number	NN
22283	235	23	of	of	IN
22283	235	24	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	235	25	per	per	IN
22283	235	26	second	second	NN
22283	235	27	going	go	VBG
22283	235	28	on	on	RP
22283	235	29	in	in	IN
22283	235	30	the	the	DT
22283	235	31	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	235	32	,	,	,
22283	235	33	or	or	CC
22283	235	34	by	by	IN
22283	235	35	the	the	DT
22283	235	36	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	235	37	of	of	IN
22283	235	38	the	the	DT
22283	235	39	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	235	40	;	;	:
22283	235	41	for	for	IN
22283	235	42	this	this	DT
22283	235	43	rate	rate	NN
22283	235	44	of	of	IN
22283	235	45	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	235	46	could	could	MD
22283	235	47	not	not	RB
22283	235	48	take	take	VB
22283	235	49	place	place	NN
22283	235	50	in	in	IN
22283	235	51	the	the	DT
22283	235	52	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	235	53	without	without	IN
22283	235	54	constituting	constitute	VBG
22283	235	55	that	that	DT
22283	235	56	degree	degree	NN
22283	235	57	of	of	IN
22283	235	58	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	235	59	which	which	WDT
22283	235	60	affects	affect	VBZ
22283	235	61	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	235	62	eyes	eye	NNS
22283	235	63	as	as	IN
22283	235	64	luminous	luminous	JJ
22283	235	65	.	.	.
22283	236	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
22283	236	2	,	,	,
22283	236	3	a	a	DT
22283	236	4	train	train	NN
22283	236	5	of	of	IN
22283	236	6	thought	thought	NN
22283	236	7	may	may	MD
22283	236	8	be	be	VB
22283	236	9	said	say	VBN
22283	236	10	indifferently	indifferently	RB
22283	236	11	to	to	TO
22283	236	12	be	be	VB
22283	236	13	caused	cause	VBN
22283	236	14	by	by	IN
22283	236	15	brain	brain	NN
22283	236	16	-	-	HYPH
22283	236	17	action	action	NN
22283	236	18	or	or	CC
22283	236	19	by	by	IN
22283	236	20	mind	mind	NN
22283	236	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	236	22	action	action	NN
22283	236	23	;	;	:
22283	236	24	for	for	IN
22283	236	25	,	,	,
22283	236	26	_	_	NNP
22283	236	27	ex	ex	NNP
22283	236	28	hypothesi	hypothesi	NNP
22283	236	29	_	_	NNP
22283	236	30	,	,	,
22283	236	31	the	the	DT
22283	236	32	one	one	NN
22283	236	33	could	could	MD
22283	236	34	not	not	RB
22283	236	35	take	take	VB
22283	236	36	place	place	NN
22283	236	37	without	without	IN
22283	236	38	the	the	DT
22283	236	39	other	other	JJ
22283	236	40	.	.	.
22283	237	1	Now	now	RB
22283	237	2	,	,	,
22283	237	3	when	when	WRB
22283	237	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	237	5	contemplate	contemplate	VBP
22283	237	6	the	the	DT
22283	237	7	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	237	8	of	of	IN
22283	237	9	volition	volition	NN
22283	237	10	by	by	IN
22283	237	11	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	237	12	,	,	,
22283	237	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	237	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	237	15	as	as	IN
22283	237	16	though	though	IN
22283	237	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	237	18	were	be	VBD
22283	237	19	contemplating	contemplate	VBG
22283	237	20	the	the	DT
22283	237	21	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	237	22	of	of	IN
22283	237	23	light	light	NN
22283	237	24	by	by	IN
22283	237	25	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	237	26	:	:	:
22283	237	27	volition	volition	NN
22283	237	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	237	29	produced	produce	VBN
22283	237	30	by	by	IN
22283	237	31	mind	mind	NN
22283	237	32	in	in	IN
22283	237	33	brain	brain	NN
22283	237	34	,	,	,
22283	237	35	just	just	RB
22283	237	36	as	as	IN
22283	237	37	light	light	NN
22283	237	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	237	39	produced	produce	VBN
22283	237	40	by	by	IN
22283	237	41	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	237	42	in	in	IN
22283	237	43	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	237	44	.	.	.
22283	238	1	And	and	CC
22283	238	2	just	just	RB
22283	238	3	as	as	IN
22283	238	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	238	5	may	may	MD
22283	238	6	correctly	correctly	RB
22283	238	7	speak	speak	VB
22283	238	8	of	of	IN
22283	238	9	light	light	NN
22283	238	10	as	as	IN
22283	238	11	the	the	DT
22283	238	12	cause	cause	NN
22283	238	13	,	,	,
22283	238	14	say	say	UH
22283	238	15	,	,	,
22283	238	16	of	of	IN
22283	238	17	a	a	DT
22283	238	18	photograph	photograph	NN
22283	238	19	,	,	,
22283	238	20	so	so	IN
22283	238	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	238	22	may	may	MD
22283	238	23	correctly	correctly	RB
22283	238	24	speak	speak	VB
22283	238	25	of	of	IN
22283	238	26	volition	volition	NN
22283	238	27	as	as	IN
22283	238	28	the	the	DT
22283	238	29	cause	cause	NN
22283	238	30	of	of	IN
22283	238	31	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	238	32	movement	movement	NN
22283	238	33	.	.	.
22283	239	1	That	that	DT
22283	239	2	particular	particular	JJ
22283	239	3	kind	kind	NN
22283	239	4	of	of	IN
22283	239	5	physical	physical	JJ
22283	239	6	activity	activity	NN
22283	239	7	which	which	WDT
22283	239	8	takes	take	VBZ
22283	239	9	place	place	NN
22283	239	10	in	in	IN
22283	239	11	the	the	DT
22283	239	12	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	239	13	could	could	MD
22283	239	14	not	not	RB
22283	239	15	take	take	VB
22283	239	16	place	place	NN
22283	239	17	without	without	IN
22283	239	18	the	the	DT
22283	239	19	light	light	NN
22283	239	20	which	which	WDT
22283	239	21	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	239	22	a	a	DT
22283	239	23	photograph	photograph	NN
22283	239	24	;	;	:
22283	239	25	and	and	CC
22283	239	26	,	,	,
22283	239	27	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	239	28	,	,	,
22283	239	29	that	that	IN
22283	239	30	particular	particular	JJ
22283	239	31	kind	kind	NN
22283	239	32	of	of	IN
22283	239	33	physical	physical	JJ
22283	239	34	activity	activity	NN
22283	239	35	which	which	WDT
22283	239	36	takes	take	VBZ
22283	239	37	place	place	NN
22283	239	38	in	in	IN
22283	239	39	the	the	DT
22283	239	40	brain	brain	NN
22283	239	41	could	could	MD
22283	239	42	not	not	RB
22283	239	43	take	take	VB
22283	239	44	place	place	NN
22283	239	45	without	without	IN
22283	239	46	the	the	DT
22283	239	47	volition	volition	NN
22283	239	48	which	which	WDT
22283	239	49	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	239	50	a	a	DT
22283	239	51	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	239	52	movement	movement	NN
22283	239	53	.	.	.
22283	240	1	So	so	RB
22283	240	2	that	that	IN
22283	240	3	volition	volition	NN
22283	240	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	240	5	as	as	RB
22283	240	6	truly	truly	RB
22283	240	7	a	a	DT
22283	240	8	cause	cause	NN
22283	240	9	of	of	IN
22283	240	10	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	240	11	movement	movement	NN
22283	240	12	as	as	IN
22283	240	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	240	14	the	the	DT
22283	240	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	240	16	activity	activity	NN
22283	240	17	of	of	IN
22283	240	18	the	the	DT
22283	240	19	brain	brain	NN
22283	240	20	;	;	:
22283	240	21	seeing	see	VBG
22283	240	22	that	that	IN
22283	240	23	,	,	,
22283	240	24	in	in	IN
22283	240	25	an	an	DT
22283	240	26	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	240	27	sense	sense	NN
22283	240	28	,	,	,
22283	240	29	the	the	DT
22283	240	30	cause	cause	NN
22283	240	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	240	32	one	one	CD
22283	240	33	and	and	CC
22283	240	34	the	the	DT
22283	240	35	same	same	JJ
22283	240	36	.	.	.
22283	241	1	But	but	CC
22283	241	2	if	if	IN
22283	241	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	241	4	once	once	RB
22283	241	5	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	241	6	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	241	7	that	that	IN
22283	241	8	what	what	WP
22283	241	9	in	in	IN
22283	241	10	a	a	DT
22283	241	11	relative	relative	JJ
22283	241	12	sense	sense	NN
22283	241	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	241	14	know	know	VBP
22283	241	15	as	as	IN
22283	241	16	volition	volition	NN
22283	241	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	241	18	,	,	,
22283	241	19	in	in	IN
22283	241	20	a	a	DT
22283	241	21	similar	similar	JJ
22283	241	22	sense	sense	NN
22283	241	23	,	,	,
22283	241	24	the	the	DT
22283	241	25	cause	cause	NN
22283	241	26	of	of	IN
22283	241	27	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	241	28	movement	movement	NN
22283	241	29	,	,	,
22283	241	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	241	31	terminate	terminate	VBP
22283	241	32	the	the	DT
22283	241	33	question	question	NN
22283	241	34	touching	touch	VBG
22283	241	35	the	the	DT
22283	241	36	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	241	37	of	of	IN
22283	241	38	the	the	DT
22283	241	39	will	will	NN
22283	241	40	.	.	.
22283	242	1	For	for	IN
22283	242	2	this	this	DT
22283	242	3	question	question	NN
22283	242	4	in	in	IN
22283	242	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	242	6	last	last	JJ
22283	242	7	resort	resort	NN
22283	242	8	--	--	:
22283	242	9	and	and	CC
22283	242	10	apart	apart	RB
22283	242	11	from	from	IN
22283	242	12	the	the	DT
22283	242	13	ambiguity	ambiguity	NN
22283	242	14	which	which	WDT
22283	242	15	has	have	VBZ
22283	242	16	been	be	VBN
22283	242	17	thrown	throw	VBN
22283	242	18	around	around	IN
22283	242	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	242	20	by	by	IN
22283	242	21	some	some	DT
22283	242	22	of	of	IN
22283	242	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	242	24	metaphysicians	metaphysician	NNS
22283	242	25	--	--	:
22283	242	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	242	27	merely	merely	RB
22283	242	28	the	the	DT
22283	242	29	question	question	NN
22283	242	30	whether	whether	IN
22283	242	31	the	the	DT
22283	242	32	will	will	NN
22283	242	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	242	34	to	to	TO
22283	242	35	be	be	VB
22283	242	36	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	242	37	as	as	IN
22283	242	38	a	a	DT
22283	242	39	cause	cause	NN
22283	242	40	of	of	IN
22283	242	41	Nature	nature	NN
22283	242	42	.	.	.
22283	243	1	And	and	CC
22283	243	2	the	the	DT
22283	243	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	243	4	which	which	WDT
22283	243	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	243	6	have	have	VBP
22283	243	7	now	now	RB
22283	243	8	before	before	IN
22283	243	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	243	10	sanctions	sanction	VBZ
22283	243	11	the	the	DT
22283	243	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	243	13	that	that	IN
22283	243	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	243	15	may	may	MD
22283	243	16	be	be	VB
22283	243	17	so	so	RB
22283	243	18	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	243	19	,	,	,
22283	243	20	if	if	IN
22283	243	21	only	only	RB
22283	243	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	243	23	remember	remember	VBP
22283	243	24	that	that	IN
22283	243	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	243	26	causal	causal	JJ
22283	243	27	activity	activity	NN
22283	243	28	depends	depend	VBZ
22283	243	29	upon	upon	IN
22283	243	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	243	31	identity	identity	NN
22283	243	32	with	with	IN
22283	243	33	the	the	DT
22283	243	34	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	243	35	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	243	36	known	know	VBN
22283	243	37	as	as	IN
22283	243	38	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	243	39	,	,	,
22283	243	40	without	without	IN
22283	243	41	which	which	WDT
22283	243	42	identity	identity	NN
22283	243	43	in	in	IN
22283	243	44	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	243	45	duality	duality	NN
22283	243	46	neither	neither	CC
22283	243	47	volition	volition	NN
22283	243	48	nor	nor	CC
22283	243	49	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	243	50	could	could	MD
22283	243	51	be	be	VB
22283	243	52	the	the	DT
22283	243	53	cause	cause	NN
22283	243	54	which	which	WDT
22283	243	55	in	in	IN
22283	243	56	fact	fact	NN
22283	243	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	243	58	are	be	VBP
22283	243	59	.	.	.
22283	244	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	244	2	thus	thus	RB
22283	244	3	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	244	4	a	a	DT
22283	244	5	mere	mere	JJ
22283	244	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	244	7	of	of	IN
22283	244	8	phraseology	phraseology	NN
22283	244	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	244	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	244	11	speak	speak	VBP
22283	244	12	of	of	IN
22283	244	13	the	the	DT
22283	244	14	will	will	NN
22283	244	15	determining	determine	VBG
22283	244	16	,	,	,
22283	244	17	or	or	CC
22283	244	18	being	be	VBG
22283	244	19	determined	determine	VBN
22283	244	20	by	by	RB
22283	244	21	,	,	,
22283	244	22	changes	change	NNS
22283	244	23	going	go	VBG
22283	244	24	on	on	RP
22283	244	25	in	in	IN
22283	244	26	the	the	DT
22283	244	27	external	external	JJ
22283	244	28	world	world	NN
22283	244	29	;	;	:
22283	244	30	just	just	RB
22283	244	31	as	as	IN
22283	244	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	244	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	244	34	but	but	CC
22283	244	35	a	a	DT
22283	244	36	matter	matter	NN
22283	244	37	of	of	IN
22283	244	38	phraseology	phraseology	NN
22283	244	39	whether	whether	IN
22283	244	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	244	41	speak	speak	VBP
22283	244	42	of	of	IN
22283	244	43	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	244	44	determining	determine	VBG
22283	244	45	,	,	,
22283	244	46	or	or	CC
22283	244	47	being	be	VBG
22283	244	48	determined	determine	VBN
22283	244	49	by	by	IN
22283	244	50	,	,	,
22283	244	51	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	244	52	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	244	53	.	.	.
22283	245	1	All	all	PDT
22283	245	2	the	the	DT
22283	245	3	requirements	requirement	NNS
22283	245	4	alike	alike	RB
22283	245	5	of	of	IN
22283	245	6	the	the	DT
22283	245	7	free	free	JJ
22283	245	8	-	-	HYPH
22283	245	9	will	will	NN
22283	245	10	and	and	CC
22283	245	11	of	of	IN
22283	245	12	the	the	DT
22283	245	13	bond	bond	NN
22283	245	14	-	-	:
22283	245	15	will	will	MD
22283	245	16	hypotheses	hypothesis	NNS
22283	245	17	are	be	VBP
22283	245	18	thus	thus	RB
22283	245	19	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
22283	245	20	by	by	IN
22283	245	21	a	a	DT
22283	245	22	synthesis	synthesis	NN
22283	245	23	which	which	WDT
22283	245	24	comprises	comprise	VBZ
22283	245	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	245	26	both	both	DT
22283	245	27	.	.	.
22283	246	1	On	on	IN
22283	246	2	the	the	DT
22283	246	3	one	one	CD
22283	246	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	246	5	,	,	,
22283	246	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	246	7	would	would	MD
22283	246	8	be	be	VB
22283	246	9	as	as	RB
22283	246	10	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	246	11	for	for	IN
22283	246	12	an	an	DT
22283	246	13	_	_	NNP
22283	246	14	un_conscious	un_conscious	NNP
22283	246	15	automaton	automaton	NN
22283	246	16	to	to	TO
22283	246	17	do	do	VB
22283	246	18	the	the	DT
22283	246	19	work	work	NN
22283	246	20	or	or	CC
22283	246	21	to	to	TO
22283	246	22	perform	perform	VB
22283	246	23	the	the	DT
22283	246	24	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	246	25	of	of	IN
22283	246	26	a	a	DT
22283	246	27	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	246	28	agent	agent	NN
22283	246	29	,	,	,
22283	246	30	as	as	IN
22283	246	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	246	32	would	would	MD
22283	246	33	be	be	VB
22283	246	34	for	for	IN
22283	246	35	an	an	DT
22283	246	36	Edison	Edison	NNP
22283	246	37	lamp	lamp	NN
22283	246	38	to	to	TO
22283	246	39	give	give	VB
22283	246	40	out	out	RP
22283	246	41	light	light	NN
22283	246	42	and	and	CC
22283	246	43	cause	cause	VB
22283	246	44	a	a	DT
22283	246	45	photograph	photograph	NN
22283	246	46	when	when	WRB
22283	246	47	not	not	RB
22283	246	48	heated	heat	VBN
22283	246	49	by	by	IN
22283	246	50	an	an	DT
22283	246	51	electric	electric	JJ
22283	246	52	current	current	NN
22283	246	53	.	.	.
22283	247	1	On	on	IN
22283	247	2	the	the	DT
22283	247	3	other	other	JJ
22283	247	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	247	5	,	,	,
22283	247	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	247	7	would	would	MD
22283	247	8	be	be	VB
22283	247	9	as	as	RB
22283	247	10	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	247	11	for	for	IN
22283	247	12	the	the	DT
22283	247	13	will	will	NN
22283	247	14	to	to	TO
22283	247	15	originate	originate	VB
22283	247	16	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	247	17	movement	movement	NN
22283	247	18	without	without	IN
22283	247	19	the	the	DT
22283	247	20	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	247	21	of	of	IN
22283	247	22	a	a	DT
22283	247	23	strictly	strictly	RB
22283	247	24	physical	physical	JJ
22283	247	25	process	process	NN
22283	247	26	of	of	IN
22283	247	27	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	247	28	,	,	,
22283	247	29	as	as	IN
22283	247	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	247	31	would	would	MD
22283	247	32	be	be	VB
22283	247	33	for	for	IN
22283	247	34	light	light	NN
22283	247	35	to	to	TO
22283	247	36	shine	shine	VB
22283	247	37	in	in	IN
22283	247	38	an	an	DT
22283	247	39	Edison	Edison	NNP
22283	247	40	lamp	lamp	NN
22283	247	41	which	which	WDT
22283	247	42	had	have	VBD
22283	247	43	been	be	VBN
22283	247	44	deprived	deprive	VBN
22283	247	45	of	of	IN
22283	247	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	247	47	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	247	48	-	-	HYPH
22283	247	49	burner	burner	NN
22283	247	50	.	.	.
22283	248	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	248	2	may	may	MD
22283	248	3	be	be	VB
22283	248	4	said	say	VBN
22283	248	5	of	of	IN
22283	248	6	this	this	DT
22283	248	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	248	8	that	that	IN
22283	248	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	248	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	248	11	highly	highly	RB
22283	248	12	speculative	speculative	JJ
22283	248	13	,	,	,
22283	248	14	not	not	RB
22283	248	15	verifiable	verifiable	JJ
22283	248	16	by	by	IN
22283	248	17	any	any	DT
22283	248	18	possible	possible	JJ
22283	248	19	experiment	experiment	NN
22283	248	20	,	,	,
22283	248	21	and	and	CC
22283	248	22	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	248	23	at	at	IN
22283	248	24	best	good	JJS
22283	248	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	248	26	but	but	IN
22283	248	27	a	a	DT
22283	248	28	mere	mere	JJ
22283	248	29	guess	guess	NN
22283	248	30	.	.	.
22283	249	1	All	all	DT
22283	249	2	which	which	WDT
22283	249	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	249	4	,	,	,
22283	249	5	no	no	RB
22283	249	6	doubt	doubt	RB
22283	249	7	,	,	,
22283	249	8	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	249	9	true	true	JJ
22283	249	10	;	;	:
22283	249	11	but	but	CC
22283	249	12	,	,	,
22283	249	13	on	on	IN
22283	249	14	the	the	DT
22283	249	15	other	other	JJ
22283	249	16	hand	hand	NN
22283	249	17	,	,	,
22283	249	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	249	19	must	must	MD
22283	249	20	remember	remember	VB
22283	249	21	that	that	IN
22283	249	22	this	this	DT
22283	249	23	theory	theory	NN
22283	249	24	comes	come	VBZ
22283	249	25	to	to	IN
22283	249	26	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	249	27	as	as	IN
22283	249	28	the	the	DT
22283	249	29	only	only	JJ
22283	249	30	one	one	CD
22283	249	31	which	which	WDT
22283	249	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	249	33	logically	logically	RB
22283	249	34	possible	possible	JJ
22283	249	35	,	,	,
22283	249	36	and	and	CC
22283	249	37	at	at	IN
22283	249	38	the	the	DT
22283	249	39	same	same	JJ
22283	249	40	time	time	NN
22283	249	41	competent	competent	JJ
22283	249	42	to	to	TO
22283	249	43	satisfy	satisfy	VB
22283	249	44	the	the	DT
22283	249	45	facts	fact	NNS
22283	249	46	alike	alike	RB
22283	249	47	of	of	IN
22283	249	48	the	the	DT
22283	249	49	outer	outer	JJ
22283	249	50	and	and	CC
22283	249	51	of	of	IN
22283	249	52	the	the	DT
22283	249	53	inner	inner	JJ
22283	249	54	world	world	NN
22283	249	55	.	.	.
22283	250	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	250	3	a	a	DT
22283	250	4	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	250	5	in	in	IN
22283	250	6	the	the	DT
22283	250	7	sense	sense	NN
22283	250	8	of	of	IN
22283	250	9	not	not	RB
22283	250	10	being	be	VBG
22283	250	11	verifiable	verifiable	JJ
22283	250	12	by	by	IN
22283	250	13	experiment	experiment	NN
22283	250	14	;	;	:
22283	250	15	but	but	CC
22283	250	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	17	has	have	VBZ
22283	250	18	much	much	RB
22283	250	19	more	more	JJR
22283	250	20	value	value	NN
22283	250	21	than	than	IN
22283	250	22	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
22283	250	23	attaches	attach	VBZ
22283	250	24	to	to	IN
22283	250	25	an	an	DT
22283	250	26	unverifiable	unverifiable	JJ
22283	250	27	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	250	28	,	,	,
22283	250	29	in	in	IN
22283	250	30	that	that	IN
22283	250	31	there	there	EX
22283	250	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	250	33	really	really	RB
22283	250	34	no	no	DT
22283	250	35	alternative	alternative	JJ
22283	250	36	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	250	37	to	to	TO
22283	250	38	be	be	VB
22283	250	39	considered	consider	VBN
22283	250	40	:	:	:
22283	250	41	if	if	IN
22283	250	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	43	choose	choose	VBP
22283	250	44	to	to	TO
22283	250	45	call	call	VB
22283	250	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	47	a	a	DT
22283	250	48	guess	guess	NN
22283	250	49	,	,	,
22283	250	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	51	must	must	MD
22283	250	52	at	at	IN
22283	250	53	the	the	DT
22283	250	54	same	same	JJ
22283	250	55	time	time	NN
22283	250	56	remember	remember	VB
22283	250	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	58	is	be	VBZ
22283	250	59	a	a	DT
22283	250	60	guess	guess	NN
22283	250	61	where	where	WRB
22283	250	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	250	63	does	do	VBZ
22283	250	64	not	not	RB
22283	250	65	appear	appear	VB
22283	250	66	that	that	IN
22283	250	67	any	any	DT
22283	250	68	other	other	JJ
22283	250	69	is	be	VBZ
22283	250	70	open	open	JJ
22283	250	71	.	.	.
22283	251	1	Once	once	RB
22283	251	2	more	more	JJR
22283	251	3	to	to	TO
22283	251	4	quote	quote	VB
22283	251	5	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	251	6	,	,	,
22283	251	7	who	who	WP
22283	251	8	,	,	,
22283	251	9	as	as	IN
22283	251	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	251	11	have	have	VBP
22283	251	12	seen	see	VBN
22283	251	13	,	,	,
22283	251	14	was	be	VBD
22283	251	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	251	16	a	a	DT
22283	251	17	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
22283	251	18	instance	instance	NN
22283	251	19	of	of	IN
22283	251	20	what	what	WP
22283	251	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	251	22	here	here	RB
22283	251	23	says	say	VBZ
22283	251	24	:	:	:
22283	251	25	'	'	``
22283	251	26	The	the	DT
22283	251	27	best	good	JJS
22283	251	28	prophet	prophet	NN
22283	251	29	naturally	naturally	RB
22283	251	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	251	31	the	the	DT
22283	251	32	best	good	JJS
22283	251	33	guesser	guesser	NN
22283	251	34	;	;	:
22283	251	35	and	and	CC
22283	251	36	the	the	DT
22283	251	37	best	good	JJS
22283	251	38	guesser	guesser	NN
22283	251	39	,	,	,
22283	251	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	251	41	that	that	DT
22283	251	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	251	43	most	most	RBS
22283	251	44	versed	versed	JJ
22283	251	45	and	and	CC
22283	251	46	studied	study	VBN
22283	251	47	in	in	IN
22283	251	48	the	the	DT
22283	251	49	matters	matter	NNS
22283	251	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	251	51	guesses	guess	VBZ
22283	251	52	at	at	IN
22283	251	53	.	.	.
22283	251	54	'	'	''
22283	252	1	In	in	IN
22283	252	2	this	this	DT
22283	252	3	case	case	NN
22283	252	4	,	,	,
22283	252	5	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	252	6	,	,	,
22283	252	7	the	the	DT
22283	252	8	best	good	JJS
22283	252	9	prophet	prophet	NN
22283	252	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	252	11	not	not	RB
22283	252	12	the	the	DT
22283	252	13	physiologist	physiologist	NN
22283	252	14	,	,	,
22283	252	15	whose	whose	WP$
22283	252	16	guess	guess	NN
22283	252	17	ends	end	NNS
22283	252	18	in	in	IN
22283	252	19	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	252	20	;	;	,
22283	252	21	nor	nor	CC
22283	252	22	the	the	DT
22283	252	23	purely	purely	RB
22283	252	24	mental	mental	JJ
22283	252	25	philosopher	philosopher	NN
22283	252	26	,	,	,
22283	252	27	whose	whose	WP$
22283	252	28	guess	guess	NN
22283	252	29	ends	end	NNS
22283	252	30	in	in	IN
22283	252	31	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	252	32	;	;	:
22283	252	33	but	but	CC
22283	252	34	rather	rather	RB
22283	252	35	the	the	DT
22283	252	36	man	man	NN
22283	252	37	who	who	WP
22283	252	38	,	,	,
22283	252	39	being	be	VBG
22283	252	40	'	'	''
22283	252	41	versed	verse	VBN
22283	252	42	and	and	CC
22283	252	43	studied	study	VBN
22283	252	44	'	'	''
22283	252	45	in	in	IN
22283	252	46	all	all	PDT
22283	252	47	the	the	DT
22283	252	48	facts	fact	NNS
22283	252	49	appertaining	appertain	VBG
22283	252	50	to	to	IN
22283	252	51	both	both	DT
22283	252	52	sides	side	NNS
22283	252	53	of	of	IN
22283	252	54	the	the	DT
22283	252	55	matter	matter	NN
22283	252	56	,	,	,
22283	252	57	ends	end	VBZ
22283	252	58	in	in	IN
22283	252	59	the	the	DT
22283	252	60	only	only	JJ
22283	252	61	alternative	alternative	JJ
22283	252	62	guess	guess	NN
22283	252	63	which	which	WDT
22283	252	64	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	252	65	open	open	JJ
22283	252	66	.	.	.
22283	253	1	And	and	CC
22283	253	2	if	if	IN
22283	253	3	that	that	DT
22283	253	4	most	most	RBS
22283	253	5	troublesome	troublesome	JJ
22283	253	6	individual	individual	NN
22283	253	7	,	,	,
22283	253	8	the	the	DT
22283	253	9	'	'	``
22283	253	10	plain	plain	JJ
22283	253	11	man	man	NN
22283	253	12	'	'	''
22283	253	13	of	of	IN
22283	253	14	Locke	Locke	NNP
22283	253	15	,	,	,
22283	253	16	should	should	MD
22283	253	17	say	say	VB
22283	253	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	253	19	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	253	20	at	at	IN
22283	253	21	least	least	RBS
22283	253	22	opposed	opposed	JJ
22283	253	23	to	to	IN
22283	253	24	common	common	JJ
22283	253	25	sense	sense	NN
22283	253	26	to	to	TO
22283	253	27	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	253	28	that	that	IN
22283	253	29	there	there	EX
22283	253	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	253	31	anything	anything	NN
22283	253	32	in	in	IN
22283	253	33	a	a	DT
22283	253	34	burning	burn	VBG
22283	253	35	candle	candle	NN
22283	253	36	or	or	CC
22283	253	37	a	a	DT
22283	253	38	rolling	roll	VBG
22283	253	39	billiard	billiard	NN
22283	253	40	-	-	HYPH
22283	253	41	ball	ball	NN
22283	253	42	substantially	substantially	RB
22283	253	43	the	the	DT
22283	253	44	same	same	JJ
22283	253	45	as	as	IN
22283	253	46	mind	mind	NN
22283	253	47	,	,	,
22283	253	48	the	the	DT
22283	253	49	answer	answer	NN
22283	253	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	253	51	that	that	IN
22283	253	52	if	if	IN
22283	253	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	253	54	could	could	MD
22283	253	55	look	look	VB
22283	253	56	into	into	IN
22283	253	57	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	253	58	brain	brain	NN
22283	253	59	at	at	IN
22283	253	60	this	this	DT
22283	253	61	moment	moment	NN
22283	253	62	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	253	63	would	would	MD
22283	253	64	see	see	VB
22283	253	65	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	253	66	there	there	RB
22283	253	67	but	but	CC
22283	253	68	motion	motion	NN
22283	253	69	of	of	IN
22283	253	70	molecules	molecule	NNS
22283	253	71	,	,	,
22283	253	72	or	or	CC
22283	253	73	motion	motion	NN
22283	253	74	of	of	IN
22283	253	75	masses	masse	NNS
22283	253	76	;	;	:
22283	253	77	and	and	CC
22283	253	78	apart	apart	RB
22283	253	79	from	from	IN
22283	253	80	the	the	DT
22283	253	81	accident	accident	NN
22283	253	82	of	of	IN
22283	253	83	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	253	84	being	be	VBG
22283	253	85	able	able	JJ
22283	253	86	to	to	TO
22283	253	87	tell	tell	VB
22283	253	88	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	253	89	so	so	RB
22283	253	90	,	,	,
22283	253	91	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	253	92	'	'	``
22283	253	93	common	common	JJ
22283	253	94	sense	sense	NN
22283	253	95	'	'	''
22283	253	96	could	could	MD
22283	253	97	never	never	RB
22283	253	98	have	have	VB
22283	253	99	divined	divine	VBN
22283	253	100	that	that	IN
22283	253	101	these	these	DT
22283	253	102	motions	motion	NNS
22283	253	103	in	in	IN
22283	253	104	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	253	105	brain	brain	NN
22283	253	106	are	be	VBP
22283	253	107	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	253	108	in	in	IN
22283	253	109	the	the	DT
22283	253	110	genesis	genesis	NN
22283	253	111	of	of	IN
22283	253	112	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	253	113	spoken	speak	VBN
22283	253	114	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	253	115	.	.	.
22283	254	1	*	*	NFP
22283	254	2	*	*	NFP
22283	254	3	*	*	NFP
22283	254	4	*	*	NFP
22283	254	5	*	*	NFP
22283	254	6	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	254	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	254	8	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	254	9	that	that	IN
22283	254	10	from	from	IN
22283	254	11	this	this	DT
22283	254	12	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	254	13	as	as	IN
22283	254	14	to	to	IN
22283	254	15	the	the	DT
22283	254	16	substantial	substantial	JJ
22283	254	17	identity	identity	NN
22283	254	18	of	of	IN
22283	254	19	mind	mind	NN
22283	254	20	and	and	CC
22283	254	21	motion	motion	NN
22283	254	22	,	,	,
22283	254	23	two	two	CD
22283	254	24	important	important	JJ
22283	254	25	questions	question	NNS
22283	254	26	arise	arise	VBP
22283	254	27	;	;	:
22283	254	28	and	and	CC
22283	254	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	254	30	feel	feel	VBP
22283	254	31	that	that	IN
22283	254	32	some	some	DT
22283	254	33	reference	reference	NN
22283	254	34	to	to	IN
22283	254	35	these	these	DT
22283	254	36	questions	question	NNS
22283	254	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	254	38	in	in	IN
22283	254	39	present	present	JJ
22283	254	40	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
22283	254	41	forced	force	VBN
22283	254	42	upon	upon	IN
22283	254	43	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	254	44	,	,	,
22283	254	45	because	because	IN
22283	254	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	254	47	have	have	VBP
22283	254	48	both	both	DT
22283	254	49	been	be	VBN
22283	254	50	considered	consider	VBN
22283	254	51	in	in	IN
22283	254	52	precisely	precisely	RB
22283	254	53	the	the	DT
22283	254	54	same	same	JJ
22283	254	55	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	254	56	by	by	IN
22283	254	57	one	one	CD
22283	254	58	of	of	IN
22283	254	59	the	the	DT
22283	254	60	most	most	RBS
22283	254	61	powerful	powerful	JJ
22283	254	62	intellects	intellect	NNS
22283	254	63	that	that	WDT
22283	254	64	was	be	VBD
22283	254	65	ever	ever	RB
22283	254	66	sent	send	VBN
22283	254	67	out	out	RP
22283	254	68	into	into	IN
22283	254	69	the	the	DT
22283	254	70	world	world	NN
22283	254	71	by	by	IN
22283	254	72	this	this	DT
22283	254	73	University	University	NNP
22283	254	74	.	.	.
22283	255	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	255	2	mean	mean	VBP
22283	255	3	the	the	DT
22283	255	4	late	late	JJ
22283	255	5	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	255	6	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	255	7	.	.	.
22283	256	1	As	as	IN
22283	256	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	256	3	intimate	intimate	JJ
22283	256	4	and	and	CC
22283	256	5	valued	valued	JJ
22283	256	6	friend	friend	NN
22283	256	7	,	,	,
22283	256	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	9	desire	desire	VBP
22283	256	10	to	to	TO
22283	256	11	mention	mention	VB
22283	256	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	256	13	name	name	NN
22283	256	14	in	in	IN
22283	256	15	this	this	DT
22283	256	16	place	place	NN
22283	256	17	with	with	IN
22283	256	18	all	all	PDT
22283	256	19	the	the	DT
22283	256	20	affection	affection	NN
22283	256	21	,	,	,
22283	256	22	as	as	RB
22283	256	23	well	well	RB
22283	256	24	as	as	IN
22283	256	25	with	with	IN
22283	256	26	all	all	PDT
22283	256	27	the	the	DT
22283	256	28	admiration	admiration	NN
22283	256	29	,	,	,
22283	256	30	to	to	TO
22283	256	31	which	which	WDT
22283	256	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	33	well	well	RB
22283	256	34	know	know	VBP
22283	256	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	256	37	so	so	RB
22283	256	38	fully	fully	RB
22283	256	39	entitled	entitle	VBN
22283	256	40	;	;	:
22283	256	41	and	and	CC
22283	256	42	if	if	IN
22283	256	43	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	44	appear	appear	VBP
22283	256	45	to	to	TO
22283	256	46	mention	mention	VB
22283	256	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	48	only	only	RB
22283	256	49	in	in	IN
22283	256	50	order	order	NN
22283	256	51	to	to	TO
22283	256	52	disagree	disagree	VB
22283	256	53	with	with	IN
22283	256	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	55	,	,	,
22283	256	56	this	this	DT
22283	256	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	256	58	only	only	RB
22283	256	59	because	because	IN
22283	256	60	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	256	61	know	know	VBP
22283	256	62	equally	equally	RB
22283	256	63	well	well	RB
22283	256	64	that	that	IN
22283	256	65	in	in	IN
22283	256	66	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	256	67	large	large	JJ
22283	256	68	and	and	CC
22283	256	69	magnanimous	magnanimous	JJ
22283	256	70	thought	thought	NN
22283	256	71	differences	difference	NNS
22283	256	72	of	of	IN
22283	256	73	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	256	74	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	256	75	were	be	VBD
22283	256	76	never	never	RB
22283	256	77	felt	feel	VBN
22283	256	78	to	to	TO
22283	256	79	weaken	weaken	VB
22283	256	80	the	the	DT
22283	256	81	bonds	bond	NNS
22283	256	82	of	of	IN
22283	256	83	friendship	friendship	NN
22283	256	84	.	.	.
22283	257	1	In	in	IN
22283	257	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	257	3	well	well	RB
22283	257	4	-	-	HYPH
22283	257	5	known	know	VBN
22283	257	6	lecture	lecture	NN
22283	257	7	on	on	IN
22283	257	8	Body	Body	NNP
22283	257	9	and	and	CC
22283	257	10	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	257	11	,	,	,
22283	257	12	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	257	13	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	257	14	adopted	adopt	VBD
22283	257	15	the	the	DT
22283	257	16	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	257	17	of	of	IN
22283	257	18	identity	identity	NN
22283	257	19	which	which	WDT
22283	257	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	257	21	are	be	VBP
22283	257	22	now	now	RB
22283	257	23	considering	consider	VBG
22283	257	24	,	,	,
22283	257	25	and	and	CC
22283	257	26	from	from	IN
22283	257	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	257	28	was	be	VBD
22283	257	29	led	lead	VBN
22283	257	30	to	to	IN
22283	257	31	the	the	DT
22283	257	32	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	257	33	that	that	IN
22283	257	34	if	if	IN
22283	257	35	in	in	IN
22283	257	36	the	the	DT
22283	257	37	case	case	NN
22283	257	38	of	of	IN
22283	257	39	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	257	40	processes	process	NNS
22283	257	41	motion	motion	NN
22283	257	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	257	43	one	one	CD
22283	257	44	with	with	IN
22283	257	45	mind	mind	NN
22283	257	46	,	,	,
22283	257	47	the	the	DT
22283	257	48	same	same	JJ
22283	257	49	must	must	MD
22283	257	50	be	be	VB
22283	257	51	true	true	JJ
22283	257	52	of	of	IN
22283	257	53	motion	motion	NN
22283	257	54	wherever	wherever	WRB
22283	257	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	257	56	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	257	57	;	;	:
22283	257	58	or	or	CC
22283	257	59	,	,	,
22283	257	60	as	as	IN
22283	257	61	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	257	62	expressed	express	VBD
22283	257	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	257	64	subsequently	subsequently	RB
22283	257	65	,	,	,
22283	257	66	the	the	DT
22283	257	67	whole	whole	JJ
22283	257	68	universe	universe	NN
22283	257	69	must	must	MD
22283	257	70	be	be	VB
22283	257	71	made	make	VBN
22283	257	72	of	of	IN
22283	257	73	mind	mind	NN
22283	257	74	-	-	HYPH
22283	257	75	stuff	stuff	NN
22283	257	76	.	.	.
22283	258	1	But	but	CC
22283	258	2	in	in	IN
22283	258	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	258	4	view	view	NN
22283	258	5	,	,	,
22283	258	6	although	although	IN
22283	258	7	matter	matter	NN
22283	258	8	in	in	IN
22283	258	9	motion	motion	NN
22283	258	10	presents	present	NNS
22283	258	11	what	what	WP
22283	258	12	may	may	MD
22283	258	13	be	be	VB
22283	258	14	termed	term	VBN
22283	258	15	the	the	DT
22283	258	16	raw	raw	JJ
22283	258	17	material	material	NN
22283	258	18	of	of	IN
22283	258	19	mind	mind	NN
22283	258	20	,	,	,
22283	258	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	258	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	258	23	only	only	RB
22283	258	24	in	in	IN
22283	258	25	the	the	DT
22283	258	26	highly	highly	RB
22283	258	27	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
22283	258	28	constitution	constitution	NN
22283	258	29	of	of	IN
22283	258	30	the	the	DT
22283	258	31	human	human	JJ
22283	258	32	brain	brain	NN
22283	258	33	that	that	WDT
22283	258	34	this	this	DT
22283	258	35	raw	raw	JJ
22283	258	36	material	material	NN
22283	258	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	258	38	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
22283	258	39	wrought	work	VBN
22283	258	40	up	up	RP
22283	258	41	to	to	TO
22283	258	42	yield	yield	VB
22283	258	43	a	a	DT
22283	258	44	self	self	NN
22283	258	45	-	-	HYPH
22283	258	46	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	258	47	personality	personality	NN
22283	258	48	.	.	.
22283	259	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	259	2	the	the	DT
22283	259	3	dissolution	dissolution	NN
22283	259	4	of	of	IN
22283	259	5	a	a	DT
22283	259	6	human	human	JJ
22283	259	7	brain	brain	NN
22283	259	8	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	259	9	the	the	DT
22283	259	10	dissolution	dissolution	NN
22283	259	11	of	of	IN
22283	259	12	a	a	DT
22283	259	13	human	human	JJ
22283	259	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	259	15	;	;	,
22283	259	16	and	and	CC
22283	259	17	hence	hence	RB
22283	259	18	also	also	RB
22283	259	19	the	the	DT
22283	259	20	universe	universe	NN
22283	259	21	,	,	,
22283	259	22	although	although	IN
22283	259	23	entirely	entirely	RB
22283	259	24	composed	compose	VBN
22283	259	25	of	of	IN
22283	259	26	mind	mind	NN
22283	259	27	-	-	HYPH
22283	259	28	stuff	stuff	NN
22283	259	29	,	,	,
22283	259	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	259	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	259	32	mindless	mindless	JJ
22283	259	33	.	.	.
22283	260	1	Now	now	RB
22283	260	2	,	,	,
22283	260	3	all	all	DT
22283	260	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	260	5	have	have	VBP
22283	260	6	to	to	TO
22283	260	7	say	say	VB
22283	260	8	about	about	IN
22283	260	9	these	these	DT
22283	260	10	two	two	CD
22283	260	11	deductions	deduction	NNS
22283	260	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	260	13	this	this	DT
22283	260	14	--	--	:
22283	260	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	260	16	do	do	VBP
22283	260	17	not	not	RB
22283	260	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	260	19	follow	follow	VB
22283	260	20	from	from	IN
22283	260	21	the	the	DT
22283	260	22	theory	theory	NN
22283	260	23	which	which	WDT
22283	260	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	260	25	before	before	IN
22283	260	26	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	260	27	.	.	.
22283	261	1	In	in	IN
22283	261	2	holding	hold	VBG
22283	261	3	that	that	IN
22283	261	4	the	the	DT
22283	261	5	mind	mind	NN
22283	261	6	of	of	IN
22283	261	7	man	man	NN
22283	261	8	perishes	perish	VBZ
22283	261	9	with	with	IN
22283	261	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	261	11	body	body	NN
22283	261	12	,	,	,
22283	261	13	and	and	CC
22283	261	14	that	that	IN
22283	261	15	above	above	IN
22283	261	16	the	the	DT
22283	261	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	261	18	of	of	IN
22283	261	19	man	man	NN
22283	261	20	there	there	EX
22283	261	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	261	22	no	no	DT
22283	261	23	other	other	JJ
22283	261	24	,	,	,
22283	261	25	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	261	26	may	may	MD
22283	261	27	have	have	VB
22283	261	28	been	be	VBN
22283	261	29	right	right	JJ
22283	261	30	,	,	,
22283	261	31	or	or	CC
22283	261	32	may	may	MD
22283	261	33	have	have	VB
22283	261	34	been	be	VBN
22283	261	35	wrong	wrong	JJ
22283	261	36	.	.	.
22283	262	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	262	2	am	be	VBP
22283	262	3	not	not	RB
22283	262	4	here	here	RB
22283	262	5	to	to	TO
22283	262	6	discuss	discuss	VB
22283	262	7	at	at	IN
22283	262	8	length	length	NN
22283	262	9	any	any	DT
22283	262	10	questions	question	NNS
22283	262	11	of	of	IN
22283	262	12	such	such	JJ
22283	262	13	supreme	supreme	JJ
22283	262	14	importance	importance	NN
22283	262	15	.	.	.
22283	263	1	But	but	CC
22283	263	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	263	3	feel	feel	VBP
22283	263	4	that	that	IN
22283	263	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	263	6	am	be	VBP
22283	263	7	here	here	RB
22283	263	8	to	to	TO
22283	263	9	insist	insist	VB
22283	263	10	upon	upon	IN
22283	263	11	the	the	DT
22283	263	12	one	one	CD
22283	263	13	point	point	NN
22283	263	14	which	which	WDT
22283	263	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	263	16	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	263	17	connected	connect	VBN
22283	263	18	with	with	IN
22283	263	19	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	263	20	subject	subject	NN
22283	263	21	;	;	:
22283	263	22	and	and	CC
22283	263	23	this	this	DT
22283	263	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	263	25	,	,	,
22283	263	26	that	that	IN
22283	263	27	whether	whether	IN
22283	263	28	or	or	CC
22283	263	29	not	not	RB
22283	263	30	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	263	31	was	be	VBD
22283	263	32	right	right	JJ
22283	263	33	in	in	IN
22283	263	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	263	35	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
22283	263	36	,	,	,
22283	263	37	these	these	DT
22283	263	38	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
22283	263	39	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	263	40	did	do	VBD
22283	263	41	not	not	RB
22283	263	42	follow	follow	VB
22283	263	43	by	by	IN
22283	263	44	way	way	NN
22283	263	45	of	of	IN
22283	263	46	any	any	DT
22283	263	47	logical	logical	JJ
22283	263	48	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	263	49	from	from	IN
22283	263	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	263	51	premises	premise	NNS
22283	263	52	.	.	.
22283	264	1	Because	because	IN
22283	264	2	within	within	IN
22283	264	3	the	the	DT
22283	264	4	limits	limit	NNS
22283	264	5	of	of	IN
22283	264	6	human	human	JJ
22283	264	7	experience	experience	NN
22283	264	8	mind	mind	NN
22283	264	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	264	10	only	only	RB
22283	264	11	known	know	VBN
22283	264	12	as	as	IN
22283	264	13	associated	associate	VBN
22283	264	14	with	with	IN
22283	264	15	brain	brain	NN
22283	264	16	,	,	,
22283	264	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	264	18	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	264	19	does	do	VBZ
22283	264	20	not	not	RB
22283	264	21	follow	follow	VB
22283	264	22	that	that	DT
22283	264	23	mind	mind	NN
22283	264	24	can	can	MD
22283	264	25	not	not	RB
22283	264	26	exist	exist	VB
22283	264	27	in	in	IN
22283	264	28	any	any	DT
22283	264	29	other	other	JJ
22283	264	30	mode	mode	NN
22283	264	31	.	.	.
22283	265	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	265	2	does	do	VBZ
22283	265	3	not	not	RB
22283	265	4	even	even	RB
22283	265	5	follow	follow	VB
22283	265	6	that	that	IN
22283	265	7	any	any	DT
22283	265	8	probability	probability	NN
22283	265	9	upon	upon	IN
22283	265	10	this	this	DT
22283	265	11	matter	matter	NN
22283	265	12	can	can	MD
22283	265	13	be	be	VB
22283	265	14	thus	thus	RB
22283	265	15	established	establish	VBN
22283	265	16	.	.	.
22283	266	1	The	the	DT
22283	266	2	basis	basis	NN
22283	266	3	of	of	IN
22283	266	4	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	266	5	on	on	IN
22283	266	6	which	which	WDT
22283	266	7	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	266	8	sought	seek	VBD
22283	266	9	to	to	TO
22283	266	10	rear	rear	VB
22283	266	11	an	an	DT
22283	266	12	inference	inference	NN
22283	266	13	of	of	IN
22283	266	14	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
22283	266	15	extent	extent	NN
22283	266	16	,	,	,
22283	266	17	was	be	VBD
22283	266	18	restricted	restrict	VBN
22283	266	19	to	to	IN
22283	266	20	the	the	DT
22283	266	21	one	one	CD
22283	266	22	instance	instance	NN
22283	266	23	of	of	IN
22283	266	24	mind	mind	NN
22283	266	25	as	as	IN
22283	266	26	known	know	VBN
22283	266	27	upon	upon	IN
22283	266	28	one	one	CD
22283	266	29	planet	planet	NN
22283	266	30	;	;	:
22283	266	31	and	and	CC
22283	266	32	,	,	,
22283	266	33	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	266	34	,	,	,
22283	266	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	266	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	266	37	hard	hard	JJ
22283	266	38	to	to	TO
22283	266	39	imagine	imagine	VB
22283	266	40	a	a	DT
22283	266	41	more	more	RBR
22283	266	42	precarious	precarious	JJ
22283	266	43	use	use	NN
22283	266	44	of	of	IN
22283	266	45	that	that	DT
22283	266	46	precarious	precarious	JJ
22283	266	47	method	method	NN
22283	266	48	which	which	WDT
22283	266	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	266	50	called	call	VBN
22283	266	51	by	by	IN
22283	266	52	logicians	logicians	NNPS
22283	266	53	simple	simple	JJ
22283	266	54	enumeration	enumeration	NN
22283	266	55	.	.	.
22283	267	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
22283	267	2	,	,	,
22283	267	3	even	even	RB
22283	267	4	for	for	IN
22283	267	5	what	what	WP
22283	267	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	267	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	267	8	worth	worth	JJ
22283	267	9	,	,	,
22283	267	10	the	the	DT
22283	267	11	inference	inference	NN
22283	267	12	may	may	MD
22283	267	13	be	be	VB
22283	267	14	pointed	point	VBN
22283	267	15	with	with	IN
22283	267	16	quite	quite	RB
22283	267	17	as	as	RB
22283	267	18	much	much	JJ
22283	267	19	effect	effect	NN
22283	267	20	in	in	IN
22283	267	21	precisely	precisely	RB
22283	267	22	the	the	DT
22283	267	23	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	267	24	direction	direction	NN
22283	267	25	.	.	.
22283	268	1	For	for	IN
22283	268	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	268	3	have	have	VBP
22283	268	4	seen	see	VBN
22283	268	5	how	how	WRB
22283	268	6	little	little	JJ
22283	268	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	268	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	268	9	that	that	IN
22283	268	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	268	11	understand	understand	VBP
22283	268	12	of	of	IN
22283	268	13	the	the	DT
22283	268	14	one	one	CD
22283	268	15	mode	mode	NN
22283	268	16	in	in	IN
22283	268	17	which	which	WDT
22283	268	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	268	19	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	268	20	know	know	VBP
22283	268	21	that	that	DT
22283	268	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	268	23	does	do	VBZ
22283	268	24	exist	exist	VB
22283	268	25	;	;	:
22283	268	26	and	and	CC
22283	268	27	if	if	IN
22283	268	28	from	from	IN
22283	268	29	this	this	DT
22283	268	30	little	little	JJ
22283	268	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	268	32	feel	feel	VBP
22283	268	33	impelled	impel	VBN
22283	268	34	to	to	TO
22283	268	35	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	268	36	that	that	IN
22283	268	37	there	there	EX
22283	268	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	268	39	a	a	DT
22283	268	40	mode	mode	NN
22283	268	41	of	of	IN
22283	268	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	268	43	which	which	WDT
22283	268	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	268	45	not	not	RB
22283	268	46	restricted	restrict	VBN
22283	268	47	to	to	IN
22283	268	48	brain	brain	NN
22283	268	49	,	,	,
22283	268	50	but	but	CC
22283	268	51	co	co	JJ
22283	268	52	-	-	JJ
22283	268	53	extensive	extensive	JJ
22283	268	54	with	with	IN
22283	268	55	motion	motion	NN
22283	268	56	,	,	,
22283	268	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	268	58	consubstantial	consubstantial	JJ
22283	268	59	and	and	CC
22283	268	60	co	co	JJ
22283	268	61	-	-	JJ
22283	268	62	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	268	63	with	with	IN
22283	268	64	all	all	DT
22283	268	65	that	that	WDT
22283	268	66	was	be	VBD
22283	268	67	,	,	,
22283	268	68	and	and	CC
22283	268	69	is	be	VBZ
22283	268	70	,	,	,
22283	268	71	and	and	CC
22283	268	72	is	be	VBZ
22283	268	73	to	to	TO
22283	268	74	come	come	VB
22283	268	75	;	;	:
22283	268	76	have	have	VBP
22283	268	77	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	268	78	not	not	RB
22283	268	79	at	at	IN
22283	268	80	least	least	JJS
22283	268	81	a	a	DT
22283	268	82	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	268	83	,	,	,
22283	268	84	that	that	RB
22283	268	85	high	high	JJ
22283	268	86	as	as	IN
22283	268	87	the	the	DT
22283	268	88	heavens	heaven	NNS
22283	268	89	are	be	VBP
22283	268	90	above	above	IN
22283	268	91	the	the	DT
22283	268	92	earth	earth	NN
22283	268	93	,	,	,
22283	268	94	so	so	RB
22283	268	95	high	high	JJ
22283	268	96	above	above	IN
22283	268	97	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	268	98	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	268	99	may	may	MD
22283	268	100	be	be	VB
22283	268	101	the	the	DT
22283	268	102	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	268	103	of	of	IN
22283	268	104	such	such	PDT
22283	268	105	a	a	DT
22283	268	106	mind	mind	NN
22283	268	107	as	as	IN
22283	268	108	this	this	DT
22283	268	109	?	?	.
22283	269	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	269	2	offer	offer	VBP
22283	269	3	no	no	DT
22283	269	4	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	269	5	upon	upon	IN
22283	269	6	the	the	DT
22283	269	7	question	question	NN
22283	269	8	whether	whether	IN
22283	269	9	the	the	DT
22283	269	10	general	general	JJ
22283	269	11	order	order	NN
22283	269	12	of	of	IN
22283	269	13	Nature	nature	NN
22283	269	14	does	do	VBZ
22283	269	15	not	not	RB
22283	269	16	require	require	VB
22283	269	17	some	some	DT
22283	269	18	one	one	CD
22283	269	19	explanatory	explanatory	JJ
22283	269	20	cause	cause	NN
22283	269	21	;	;	:
22283	269	22	nor	nor	CC
22283	269	23	upon	upon	IN
22283	269	24	the	the	DT
22283	269	25	question	question	NN
22283	269	26	whether	whether	IN
22283	269	27	the	the	DT
22283	269	28	mind	mind	NN
22283	269	29	of	of	IN
22283	269	30	man	man	NN
22283	269	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	269	32	does	do	VBZ
22283	269	33	not	not	RB
22283	269	34	point	point	VB
22283	269	35	to	to	IN
22283	269	36	something	something	NN
22283	269	37	kindred	kindred	JJ
22283	269	38	in	in	IN
22283	269	39	the	the	DT
22283	269	40	self	self	NN
22283	269	41	-	-	HYPH
22283	269	42	existing	exist	VBG
22283	269	43	origin	origin	NN
22283	269	44	of	of	IN
22283	269	45	things	thing	NNS
22283	269	46	.	.	.
22283	270	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	270	2	am	be	VBP
22283	270	3	not	not	RB
22283	270	4	concerned	concerned	JJ
22283	270	5	to	to	TO
22283	270	6	argue	argue	VB
22283	270	7	any	any	DT
22283	270	8	point	point	NN
22283	270	9	upon	upon	IN
22283	270	10	which	which	WDT
22283	270	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	270	12	feel	feel	VBP
22283	270	13	that	that	IN
22283	270	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
22283	270	15	may	may	MD
22283	270	16	legitimately	legitimately	RB
22283	270	17	differ	differ	VB
22283	270	18	.	.	.
22283	271	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	271	2	am	be	VBP
22283	271	3	only	only	RB
22283	271	4	concerned	concerned	JJ
22283	271	5	to	to	TO
22283	271	6	show	show	VB
22283	271	7	that	that	IN
22283	271	8	,	,	,
22283	271	9	in	in	IN
22283	271	10	so	so	RB
22283	271	11	far	far	RB
22283	271	12	as	as	IN
22283	271	13	any	any	DT
22283	271	14	deductions	deduction	NNS
22283	271	15	can	can	MD
22283	271	16	be	be	VB
22283	271	17	drawn	draw	VBN
22283	271	18	from	from	IN
22283	271	19	the	the	DT
22283	271	20	theory	theory	NN
22283	271	21	which	which	WDT
22283	271	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	271	23	before	before	IN
22283	271	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	271	25	,	,	,
22283	271	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	271	27	make	make	VBP
22283	271	28	at	at	IN
22283	271	29	least	least	JJS
22283	271	30	as	as	RB
22283	271	31	much	much	RB
22283	271	32	against	against	IN
22283	271	33	as	as	IN
22283	271	34	in	in	IN
22283	271	35	favour	favour	NN
22283	271	36	of	of	IN
22283	271	37	the	the	DT
22283	271	38	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
22283	271	39	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
22283	271	40	arrived	arrive	VBD
22283	271	41	at	at	IN
22283	271	42	by	by	IN
22283	271	43	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	271	44	.	.	.
22283	272	1	On	on	IN
22283	272	2	February	February	NNP
22283	272	3	17	17	CD
22283	272	4	,	,	,
22283	272	5	in	in	IN
22283	272	6	the	the	DT
22283	272	7	year	year	NN
22283	272	8	1600	1600	CD
22283	272	9	,	,	,
22283	272	10	when	when	WRB
22283	272	11	the	the	DT
22283	272	12	streets	street	NNS
22283	272	13	of	of	IN
22283	272	14	Rome	Rome	NNP
22283	272	15	were	be	VBD
22283	272	16	thronged	throng	VBN
22283	272	17	with	with	IN
22283	272	18	pilgrims	pilgrim	NNS
22283	272	19	from	from	IN
22283	272	20	all	all	PDT
22283	272	21	the	the	DT
22283	272	22	quarters	quarter	NNS
22283	272	23	of	of	IN
22283	272	24	Christendom	Christendom	NNP
22283	272	25	,	,	,
22283	272	26	while	while	IN
22283	272	27	no	no	DT
22283	272	28	less	less	JJR
22283	272	29	than	than	IN
22283	272	30	fifty	fifty	CD
22283	272	31	cardinals	cardinal	NNS
22283	272	32	were	be	VBD
22283	272	33	congregated	congregate	VBN
22283	272	34	for	for	IN
22283	272	35	the	the	DT
22283	272	36	Jubilee	Jubilee	NNP
22283	272	37	;	;	:
22283	272	38	into	into	IN
22283	272	39	the	the	DT
22283	272	40	densely	densely	RB
22283	272	41	crowded	crowd	VBN
22283	272	42	Campo	Campo	NNP
22283	272	43	di	di	NNP
22283	272	44	Fiori	Fiori	NNP
22283	272	45	a	a	DT
22283	272	46	man	man	NN
22283	272	47	was	be	VBD
22283	272	48	led	lead	VBN
22283	272	49	to	to	IN
22283	272	50	the	the	DT
22283	272	51	stake	stake	NN
22283	272	52	,	,	,
22283	272	53	where	where	WRB
22283	272	54	,	,	,
22283	272	55	'	'	``
22283	272	56	silent	silent	JJ
22283	272	57	and	and	CC
22283	272	58	self	self	NN
22283	272	59	-	-	HYPH
22283	272	60	sustained	sustained	JJ
22283	272	61	,	,	,
22283	272	62	'	'	''
22283	272	63	before	before	IN
22283	272	64	the	the	DT
22283	272	65	eyes	eye	NNS
22283	272	66	of	of	IN
22283	272	67	all	all	DT
22283	272	68	nations	nation	NNS
22283	272	69	,	,	,
22283	272	70	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	272	71	perished	perish	VBD
22283	272	72	in	in	IN
22283	272	73	the	the	DT
22283	272	74	flames	flame	NNS
22283	272	75	.	.	.
22283	273	1	That	that	DT
22283	273	2	death	death	NN
22283	273	3	was	be	VBD
22283	273	4	the	the	DT
22283	273	5	death	death	NN
22283	273	6	of	of	IN
22283	273	7	a	a	DT
22283	273	8	martyr	martyr	NN
22283	273	9	:	:	:
22283	273	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	273	11	was	be	VBD
22283	273	12	met	meet	VBN
22283	273	13	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
22283	273	14	in	in	IN
22283	273	15	attestation	attestation	NN
22283	273	16	of	of	IN
22283	273	17	truth	truth	NN
22283	273	18	.	.	.
22283	274	1	But	but	CC
22283	274	2	most	most	RBS
22283	274	3	noble	noble	JJ
22283	274	4	of	of	IN
22283	274	5	all	all	PDT
22283	274	6	the	the	DT
22283	274	7	noble	noble	JJ
22283	274	8	army	army	NN
22283	274	9	to	to	TO
22283	274	10	which	which	WDT
22283	274	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	274	12	belonged	belong	VBD
22283	274	13	,	,	,
22283	274	14	the	the	DT
22283	274	15	name	name	NN
22283	274	16	of	of	IN
22283	274	17	that	that	DT
22283	274	18	man	man	NN
22283	274	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	274	20	written	write	VBN
22283	274	21	large	large	JJ
22283	274	22	in	in	IN
22283	274	23	history	history	NN
22283	274	24	,	,	,
22283	274	25	as	as	IN
22283	274	26	the	the	DT
22283	274	27	name	name	NN
22283	274	28	of	of	IN
22283	274	29	one	one	NN
22283	274	30	who	who	WP
22283	274	31	had	have	VBD
22283	274	32	fortitude	fortitude	NN
22283	274	33	to	to	TO
22283	274	34	die	die	VB
22283	274	35	,	,	,
22283	274	36	not	not	RB
22283	274	37	in	in	IN
22283	274	38	the	the	DT
22283	274	39	cause	cause	NN
22283	274	40	of	of	IN
22283	274	41	religious	religious	JJ
22283	274	42	belief	belief	NN
22283	274	43	,	,	,
22283	274	44	but	but	CC
22283	274	45	in	in	IN
22283	274	46	that	that	DT
22283	274	47	of	of	IN
22283	274	48	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	274	49	conviction	conviction	NN
22283	274	50	.	.	.
22283	275	1	For	for	IN
22283	275	2	why	why	WRB
22283	275	3	did	do	VBD
22283	275	4	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
22283	275	5	suffer	suffer	VB
22283	275	6	?	?	.
22283	276	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	276	2	suffered	suffer	VBD
22283	276	3	,	,	,
22283	276	4	as	as	IN
22283	276	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	276	6	all	all	DT
22283	276	7	know	know	VBP
22283	276	8	,	,	,
22283	276	9	because	because	IN
22283	276	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	276	11	refused	refuse	VBD
22283	276	12	to	to	TO
22283	276	13	recant	recant	VB
22283	276	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	276	15	persuasion	persuasion	NN
22283	276	16	of	of	IN
22283	276	17	the	the	DT
22283	276	18	truth	truth	NN
22283	276	19	of	of	IN
22283	276	20	the	the	DT
22283	276	21	Copernican	copernican	JJ
22283	276	22	theory	theory	NN
22283	276	23	.	.	.
22283	277	1	Why	why	WRB
22283	277	2	,	,	,
22283	277	3	then	then	RB
22283	277	4	,	,	,
22283	277	5	do	do	VBP
22283	277	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	277	7	adduce	adduce	VB
22283	277	8	the	the	DT
22283	277	9	name	name	NN
22283	277	10	of	of	IN
22283	277	11	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
22283	277	12	at	at	IN
22283	277	13	the	the	DT
22283	277	14	close	close	NN
22283	277	15	of	of	IN
22283	277	16	this	this	DT
22283	277	17	lecture	lecture	NN
22283	277	18	?	?	.
22283	278	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	278	2	do	do	VBP
22283	278	3	so	so	RB
22283	278	4	because	because	IN
22283	278	5	,	,	,
22283	278	6	as	as	RB
22283	278	7	far	far	RB
22283	278	8	as	as	IN
22283	278	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	278	10	have	have	VBP
22283	278	11	been	be	VBN
22283	278	12	able	able	JJ
22283	278	13	to	to	TO
22283	278	14	ascertain	ascertain	VB
22283	278	15	,	,	,
22283	278	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	278	17	was	be	VBD
22283	278	18	the	the	DT
22283	278	19	first	first	JJ
22283	278	20	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	278	21	to	to	TO
22283	278	22	enunciate	enunciate	VB
22283	278	23	the	the	DT
22283	278	24	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	278	25	theory	theory	NN
22283	278	26	of	of	IN
22283	278	27	things	thing	NNS
22283	278	28	to	to	TO
22283	278	29	which	which	WDT
22283	278	30	the	the	DT
22283	278	31	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	278	32	of	of	IN
22283	278	33	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	278	34	subject	subject	NN
22283	278	35	has	have	VBZ
22283	278	36	conducted	conduct	VBN
22283	278	37	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	278	38	.	.	.
22283	279	1	This	this	DT
22283	279	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	279	3	--	--	:
22283	279	4	or	or	CC
22283	279	5	that	that	IN
22283	279	6	as	as	IN
22283	279	7	to	to	IN
22283	279	8	the	the	DT
22283	279	9	substantial	substantial	JJ
22283	279	10	identity	identity	NN
22283	279	11	of	of	IN
22283	279	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	279	13	and	and	CC
22283	279	14	motion	motion	NN
22283	279	15	--	--	:
22283	279	16	was	be	VBD
22283	279	17	afterwards	afterwards	RB
22283	279	18	espoused	espouse	VBN
22283	279	19	,	,	,
22283	279	20	in	in	IN
22283	279	21	different	different	JJ
22283	279	22	guises	guise	NNS
22283	279	23	,	,	,
22283	279	24	by	by	IN
22283	279	25	sundry	sundry	JJ
22283	279	26	other	other	JJ
22283	279	27	writers	writer	NNS
22283	279	28	;	;	:
22283	279	29	but	but	CC
22283	279	30	to	to	IN
22283	279	31	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
22283	279	32	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	279	33	the	the	DT
22283	279	34	merit	merit	NN
22283	279	35	of	of	IN
22283	279	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	279	37	original	original	JJ
22283	279	38	publication	publication	NN
22283	279	39	,	,	,
22283	279	40	and	and	CC
22283	279	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	279	42	was	be	VBD
22283	279	43	partly	partly	RB
22283	279	44	for	for	IN
22283	279	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	279	46	adherence	adherence	NN
22283	279	47	to	to	IN
22283	279	48	this	this	DT
22283	279	49	publication	publication	NN
22283	279	50	that	that	IN
22283	279	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	279	52	died	die	VBD
22283	279	53	.	.	.
22283	280	1	To	to	IN
22283	280	2	this	this	DT
22283	280	3	day	day	NN
22283	280	4	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
22283	280	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	280	6	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
22283	280	7	termed	term	VBN
22283	280	8	a	a	DT
22283	280	9	pantheist	pantheist	NN
22283	280	10	,	,	,
22283	280	11	and	and	CC
22283	280	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	280	13	theory	theory	NN
22283	280	14	,	,	,
22283	280	15	which	which	WDT
22283	280	16	in	in	IN
22283	280	17	the	the	DT
22283	280	18	light	light	NN
22283	280	19	of	of	IN
22283	280	20	much	much	JJ
22283	280	21	fuller	full	JJR
22283	280	22	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	280	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	280	24	am	be	VBP
22283	280	25	advocating	advocate	VBG
22283	280	26	,	,	,
22283	280	27	Pantheism	pantheism	NN
22283	280	28	.	.	.
22283	281	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	281	2	do	do	VBP
22283	281	3	not	not	RB
22283	281	4	care	care	VB
22283	281	5	to	to	TO
22283	281	6	consider	consider	VB
22283	281	7	a	a	DT
22283	281	8	difference	difference	NN
22283	281	9	of	of	IN
22283	281	10	terms	term	NNS
22283	281	11	,	,	,
22283	281	12	where	where	WRB
22283	281	13	the	the	DT
22283	281	14	only	only	JJ
22283	281	15	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	281	16	resides	reside	VBZ
22283	281	17	in	in	RB
22283	281	18	so	so	RB
22283	281	19	unintelligible	unintelligible	VB
22283	281	20	an	an	DT
22283	281	21	idea	idea	NN
22283	281	22	as	as	IN
22283	281	23	that	that	DT
22283	281	24	of	of	IN
22283	281	25	the	the	DT
22283	281	26	creation	creation	NN
22283	281	27	of	of	IN
22283	281	28	substance	substance	NN
22283	281	29	.	.	.
22283	282	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	282	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	282	3	more	more	JJR
22283	282	4	to	to	IN
22283	282	5	the	the	DT
22283	282	6	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	282	7	to	to	TO
22283	282	8	observe	observe	VB
22283	282	9	that	that	IN
22283	282	10	in	in	IN
22283	282	11	the	the	DT
22283	282	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	282	13	of	of	IN
22283	282	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	282	15	first	first	JJ
22283	282	16	originator	originator	NN
22283	282	17	--	--	:
22283	282	18	and	and	CC
22283	282	19	this	this	DT
22283	282	20	a	a	DT
22283	282	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	282	22	which	which	WDT
22283	282	23	was	be	VBD
22283	282	24	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
22283	282	25	clear	clear	JJ
22283	282	26	in	in	IN
22283	282	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	282	28	thought	thought	NN
22283	282	29	to	to	TO
22283	282	30	die	die	VB
22283	282	31	for	for	IN
22283	282	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	282	33	perception	perception	NN
22283	282	34	of	of	IN
22283	282	35	astronomical	astronomical	JJ
22283	282	36	truth	truth	NN
22283	282	37	--	--	:
22283	282	38	the	the	DT
22283	282	39	theory	theory	NN
22283	282	40	of	of	IN
22283	282	41	Pantheism	Pantheism	NNP
22283	282	42	was	be	VBD
22283	282	43	but	but	CC
22283	282	44	a	a	DT
22283	282	45	sublime	sublime	JJ
22283	282	46	extension	extension	NN
22283	282	47	of	of	IN
22283	282	48	the	the	DT
22283	282	49	then	then	RB
22283	282	50	contracted	contract	VBN
22283	282	51	views	view	NNS
22283	282	52	of	of	IN
22283	282	53	Theism	theism	NN
22283	282	54	.	.	.
22283	283	1	And	and	CC
22283	283	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	283	3	think	think	VBP
22283	283	4	that	that	IN
22283	283	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	283	6	of	of	IN
22283	283	7	to	to	IN
22283	283	8	-	-	HYPH
22283	283	9	day	day	NN
22283	283	10	,	,	,
22283	283	11	when	when	WRB
22283	283	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	283	13	look	look	VBP
22283	283	14	to	to	IN
22283	283	15	the	the	DT
22283	283	16	teaching	teaching	NN
22283	283	17	of	of	IN
22283	283	18	this	this	DT
22283	283	19	martyr	martyr	NN
22283	283	20	of	of	IN
22283	283	21	science	science	NN
22283	283	22	,	,	,
22283	283	23	will	will	MD
22283	283	24	find	find	VB
22283	283	25	that	that	IN
22283	283	26	in	in	IN
22283	283	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	283	28	theory	theory	NN
22283	283	29	alone	alone	RB
22283	283	30	do	do	VBP
22283	283	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	283	32	meet	meet	VB
22283	283	33	with	with	IN
22283	283	34	what	what	WP
22283	283	35	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	283	36	may	may	MD
22283	283	37	term	term	VB
22283	283	38	a	a	DT
22283	283	39	philosophically	philosophically	RB
22283	283	40	adequate	adequate	JJ
22283	283	41	conception	conception	NN
22283	283	42	of	of	IN
22283	283	43	Deity	deity	NN
22283	283	44	.	.	.
22283	284	1	If	if	IN
22283	284	2	the	the	DT
22283	284	3	advance	advance	NN
22283	284	4	of	of	IN
22283	284	5	natural	natural	JJ
22283	284	6	science	science	NN
22283	284	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	284	8	now	now	RB
22283	284	9	steadily	steadily	RB
22283	284	10	leading	lead	VBG
22283	284	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	284	12	to	to	IN
22283	284	13	the	the	DT
22283	284	14	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	284	15	that	that	IN
22283	284	16	there	there	EX
22283	284	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	284	18	no	no	DT
22283	284	19	motion	motion	NN
22283	284	20	without	without	IN
22283	284	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	284	22	,	,	,
22283	284	23	must	must	MD
22283	284	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	284	25	not	not	RB
22283	284	26	see	see	VB
22283	284	27	how	how	WRB
22283	284	28	the	the	DT
22283	284	29	independent	independent	JJ
22283	284	30	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	284	31	of	of	IN
22283	284	32	mental	mental	JJ
22283	284	33	science	science	NN
22283	284	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	284	35	thus	thus	RB
22283	284	36	independently	independently	RB
22283	284	37	confirmed	confirm	VBN
22283	284	38	--	--	:
22283	284	39	the	the	DT
22283	284	40	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	284	41	,	,	,
22283	284	42	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	284	43	mean	mean	VBP
22283	284	44	,	,	,
22283	284	45	that	that	IN
22283	284	46	there	there	EX
22283	284	47	is	be	VBZ
22283	284	48	no	no	DT
22283	284	49	being	be	VBG
22283	284	50	without	without	IN
22283	284	51	knowing	know	VBG
22283	284	52	?	?	.
22283	285	1	To	to	IN
22283	285	2	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	285	3	,	,	,
22283	285	4	at	at	IN
22283	285	5	least	least	JJS
22283	285	6	,	,	,
22283	285	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	285	8	does	do	VBZ
22283	285	9	appear	appear	VB
22283	285	10	that	that	IN
22283	285	11	the	the	DT
22283	285	12	time	time	NN
22283	285	13	has	have	VBZ
22283	285	14	come	come	VBN
22283	285	15	when	when	WRB
22283	285	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	285	17	may	may	MD
22283	285	18	begin	begin	VB
22283	285	19	,	,	,
22283	285	20	as	as	IN
22283	285	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	285	22	were	be	VBD
22283	285	23	in	in	IN
22283	285	24	a	a	DT
22283	285	25	dawning	dawn	VBG
22283	285	26	light	light	NN
22283	285	27	,	,	,
22283	285	28	to	to	TO
22283	285	29	see	see	VB
22283	285	30	that	that	IN
22283	285	31	the	the	DT
22283	285	32	study	study	NN
22283	285	33	of	of	IN
22283	285	34	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	285	35	and	and	CC
22283	285	36	the	the	DT
22283	285	37	study	study	NN
22283	285	38	of	of	IN
22283	285	39	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	285	40	are	be	VBP
22283	285	41	meeting	meet	VBG
22283	285	42	upon	upon	IN
22283	285	43	this	this	DT
22283	285	44	greatest	great	JJS
22283	285	45	of	of	IN
22283	285	46	possible	possible	JJ
22283	285	47	truths	truth	NNS
22283	285	48	.	.	.
22283	286	1	And	and	CC
22283	286	2	if	if	IN
22283	286	3	this	this	DT
22283	286	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	286	5	the	the	DT
22283	286	6	case	case	NN
22283	286	7	--	--	:
22283	286	8	if	if	IN
22283	286	9	there	there	EX
22283	286	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	286	11	no	no	DT
22283	286	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	286	13	without	without	IN
22283	286	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	286	15	,	,	,
22283	286	16	no	no	DT
22283	286	17	being	be	VBG
22283	286	18	without	without	IN
22283	286	19	knowing	know	VBG
22283	286	20	--	--	:
22283	286	21	shall	shall	MD
22283	286	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	286	23	infer	infer	VB
22283	286	24	,	,	,
22283	286	25	with	with	IN
22283	286	26	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	286	27	,	,	,
22283	286	28	that	that	IN
22283	286	29	universal	universal	JJ
22283	286	30	being	being	NN
22283	286	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	286	32	mindless	mindless	JJ
22283	286	33	,	,	,
22283	286	34	or	or	CC
22283	286	35	answer	answer	VB
22283	286	36	with	with	IN
22283	286	37	a	a	DT
22283	286	38	dogmatic	dogmatic	JJ
22283	286	39	negative	negative	JJ
22283	286	40	that	that	IN
22283	286	41	most	most	RBS
22283	286	42	stupendous	stupendous	JJ
22283	286	43	of	of	IN
22283	286	44	questions	question	NNS
22283	286	45	--	--	:
22283	286	46	Is	be	VBZ
22283	286	47	there	there	EX
22283	286	48	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	286	49	with	with	IN
22283	286	50	the	the	DT
22283	286	51	Most	most	RBS
22283	286	52	High	high	JJ
22283	286	53	?	?	.
22283	287	1	If	if	IN
22283	287	2	there	there	EX
22283	287	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	287	4	no	no	DT
22283	287	5	motion	motion	NN
22283	287	6	without	without	IN
22283	287	7	mind	mind	NN
22283	287	8	,	,	,
22283	287	9	no	no	DT
22283	287	10	being	be	VBG
22283	287	11	without	without	IN
22283	287	12	knowing	know	VBG
22283	287	13	,	,	,
22283	287	14	may	may	MD
22283	287	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	287	16	not	not	RB
22283	287	17	rather	rather	RB
22283	287	18	infer	infer	JJ
22283	287	19	,	,	,
22283	287	20	with	with	IN
22283	287	21	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
22283	287	22	,	,	,
22283	287	23	that	that	IN
22283	287	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	287	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	287	26	in	in	IN
22283	287	27	the	the	DT
22283	287	28	medium	medium	NN
22283	287	29	of	of	IN
22283	287	30	mind	mind	NN
22283	287	31	,	,	,
22283	287	32	and	and	CC
22283	287	33	in	in	IN
22283	287	34	the	the	DT
22283	287	35	medium	medium	NN
22283	287	36	of	of	IN
22283	287	37	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	287	38	,	,	,
22283	287	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	287	40	live	live	VBP
22283	287	41	,	,	,
22283	287	42	and	and	CC
22283	287	43	move	move	VB
22283	287	44	,	,	,
22283	287	45	and	and	CC
22283	287	46	have	have	VBP
22283	287	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	287	48	being	being	NN
22283	287	49	?	?	.
22283	288	1	This	this	DT
22283	288	2	,	,	,
22283	288	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	288	4	think	think	VBP
22283	288	5	,	,	,
22283	288	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	288	7	the	the	DT
22283	288	8	direction	direction	NN
22283	288	9	in	in	IN
22283	288	10	which	which	WDT
22283	288	11	the	the	DT
22283	288	12	inference	inference	NN
22283	288	13	points	point	VBZ
22283	288	14	,	,	,
22283	288	15	if	if	IN
22283	288	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	288	17	are	be	VBP
22283	288	18	careful	careful	JJ
22283	288	19	to	to	TO
22283	288	20	set	set	VB
22283	288	21	the	the	DT
22283	288	22	logical	logical	JJ
22283	288	23	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	288	24	with	with	IN
22283	288	25	complete	complete	JJ
22283	288	26	impartiality	impartiality	NN
22283	288	27	.	.	.
22283	289	1	But	but	CC
22283	289	2	the	the	DT
22283	289	3	ulterior	ulterior	JJ
22283	289	4	question	question	NN
22283	289	5	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	289	6	,	,	,
22283	289	7	whether	whether	IN
22283	289	8	,	,	,
22283	289	9	so	so	RB
22283	289	10	far	far	RB
22283	289	11	as	as	IN
22283	289	12	science	science	NN
22283	289	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	289	14	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	289	15	,	,	,
22283	289	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	289	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	289	18	here	here	RB
22283	289	19	possible	possible	JJ
22283	289	20	to	to	TO
22283	289	21	point	point	VB
22283	289	22	any	any	DT
22283	289	23	inference	inference	NN
22283	289	24	at	at	RB
22283	289	25	all	all	RB
22283	289	26	:	:	:
22283	289	27	the	the	DT
22283	289	28	whole	whole	JJ
22283	289	29	orbit	orbit	NN
22283	289	30	of	of	IN
22283	289	31	human	human	JJ
22283	289	32	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	289	33	may	may	MD
22283	289	34	be	be	VB
22283	289	35	too	too	RB
22283	289	36	narrow	narrow	JJ
22283	289	37	to	to	TO
22283	289	38	afford	afford	VB
22283	289	39	a	a	DT
22283	289	40	parallax	parallax	NN
22283	289	41	for	for	IN
22283	289	42	measurements	measurement	NNS
22283	289	43	so	so	RB
22283	289	44	vast	vast	JJ
22283	289	45	.	.	.
22283	290	1	Yet	yet	RB
22283	290	2	even	even	RB
22283	290	3	here	here	RB
22283	290	4	,	,	,
22283	290	5	if	if	IN
22283	290	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	290	7	be	be	VB
22283	290	8	true	true	JJ
22283	290	9	that	that	IN
22283	290	10	the	the	DT
22283	290	11	voice	voice	NN
22283	290	12	of	of	IN
22283	290	13	science	science	NNP
22283	290	14	must	must	MD
22283	290	15	thus	thus	RB
22283	290	16	of	of	IN
22283	290	17	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	290	18	speak	speak	VB
22283	290	19	the	the	DT
22283	290	20	language	language	NN
22283	290	21	of	of	IN
22283	290	22	agnosticism	agnosticism	NN
22283	290	23	,	,	,
22283	290	24	at	at	IN
22283	290	25	least	least	JJS
22283	290	26	let	let	VB
22283	290	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	290	28	see	see	VB
22283	290	29	to	to	IN
22283	290	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	290	31	that	that	IN
22283	290	32	the	the	DT
22283	290	33	language	language	NN
22283	290	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	290	35	pure	pure	JJ
22283	290	36	;	;	:
22283	290	37	let	let	VB
22283	290	38	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	290	39	not	not	RB
22283	290	40	tolerate	tolerate	VB
22283	290	41	any	any	DT
22283	290	42	barbarisms	barbarism	NNS
22283	290	43	introduced	introduce	VBN
22283	290	44	from	from	IN
22283	290	45	the	the	DT
22283	290	46	side	side	NN
22283	290	47	of	of	IN
22283	290	48	aggressive	aggressive	JJ
22283	290	49	dogma	dogma	NN
22283	290	50	.	.	.
22283	291	1	So	so	CC
22283	291	2	shall	shall	MD
22283	291	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	291	4	find	find	VB
22283	291	5	that	that	IN
22283	291	6	this	this	DT
22283	291	7	new	new	JJ
22283	291	8	grammar	grammar	NN
22283	291	9	of	of	IN
22283	291	10	thought	thought	NN
22283	291	11	does	do	VBZ
22283	291	12	not	not	RB
22283	291	13	admit	admit	VB
22283	291	14	of	of	IN
22283	291	15	any	any	DT
22283	291	16	constructions	construction	NNS
22283	291	17	radically	radically	RB
22283	291	18	opposed	oppose	VBN
22283	291	19	to	to	IN
22283	291	20	more	more	RBR
22283	291	21	venerable	venerable	JJ
22283	291	22	ways	way	NNS
22283	291	23	of	of	IN
22283	291	24	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	291	25	;	;	:
22283	291	26	even	even	RB
22283	291	27	if	if	IN
22283	291	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	291	29	do	do	VBP
22283	291	30	not	not	RB
22283	291	31	find	find	VB
22283	291	32	that	that	IN
22283	291	33	the	the	DT
22283	291	34	often	often	RB
22283	291	35	-	-	HYPH
22283	291	36	quoted	quote	VBN
22283	291	37	words	word	NNS
22283	291	38	of	of	IN
22283	291	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	291	40	earliest	early	JJS
22283	291	41	formulator	formulator	NN
22283	291	42	apply	apply	VBP
22283	291	43	with	with	IN
22283	291	44	special	special	JJ
22283	291	45	force	force	NN
22283	291	46	to	to	IN
22283	291	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	291	48	latest	late	JJS
22283	291	49	dialects	dialect	NNS
22283	291	50	--	--	:
22283	291	51	that	that	IN
22283	291	52	if	if	IN
22283	291	53	a	a	DT
22283	291	54	little	little	JJ
22283	291	55	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	291	56	of	of	IN
22283	291	57	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	291	58	and	and	CC
22283	291	59	a	a	DT
22283	291	60	little	little	JJ
22283	291	61	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	291	62	of	of	IN
22283	291	63	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	291	64	dispose	dispose	VBP
22283	291	65	men	man	NNS
22283	291	66	to	to	IN
22283	291	67	atheism	atheism	NN
22283	291	68	,	,	,
22283	291	69	a	a	DT
22283	291	70	deeper	deep	JJR
22283	291	71	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	291	72	of	of	IN
22283	291	73	both	both	DT
22283	291	74	,	,	,
22283	291	75	and	and	CC
22283	291	76	,	,	,
22283	291	77	still	still	RB
22283	291	78	more	more	JJR
22283	291	79	,	,	,
22283	291	80	a	a	DT
22283	291	81	deeper	deep	JJR
22283	291	82	thought	think	VBN
22283	291	83	upon	upon	IN
22283	291	84	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	291	85	relations	relation	NNS
22283	291	86	to	to	IN
22283	291	87	one	one	CD
22283	291	88	another	another	DT
22283	291	89	,	,	,
22283	291	90	will	will	MD
22283	291	91	lead	lead	VB
22283	291	92	men	man	NNS
22283	291	93	back	back	RB
22283	291	94	to	to	IN
22283	291	95	some	some	DT
22283	291	96	form	form	NN
22283	291	97	of	of	IN
22283	291	98	religion	religion	NN
22283	291	99	,	,	,
22283	291	100	which	which	WDT
22283	291	101	,	,	,
22283	291	102	if	if	IN
22283	291	103	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	291	104	be	be	VBP
22283	291	105	more	more	RBR
22283	291	106	vague	vague	JJ
22283	291	107	,	,	,
22283	291	108	may	may	MD
22283	291	109	also	also	RB
22283	291	110	be	be	VB
22283	291	111	more	more	RBR
22283	291	112	worthy	worthy	JJ
22283	291	113	than	than	IN
22283	291	114	that	that	DT
22283	291	115	of	of	IN
22283	291	116	earlier	early	JJR
22283	291	117	days	day	NNS
22283	291	118	.	.	.
22283	292	1	'	'	``
22283	292	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	292	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	292	4	a	a	DT
22283	292	5	beauteous	beauteous	JJ
22283	292	6	evening	evening	NN
22283	292	7	,	,	,
22283	292	8	calm	calm	JJ
22283	292	9	and	and	CC
22283	292	10	free	free	JJ
22283	292	11	;	;	:
22283	292	12	The	the	DT
22283	292	13	holy	holy	JJ
22283	292	14	time	time	NN
22283	292	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	292	16	quiet	quiet	JJ
22283	292	17	as	as	IN
22283	292	18	a	a	DT
22283	292	19	nun	nun	NN
22283	292	20	,	,	,
22283	292	21	Breathless	breathless	NN
22283	292	22	with	with	IN
22283	292	23	adoration	adoration	NN
22283	292	24	;	;	:
22283	292	25	the	the	DT
22283	292	26	broad	broad	JJ
22283	292	27	sun	sun	NN
22283	292	28	Is	be	VBZ
22283	292	29	sinking	sink	VBG
22283	292	30	down	down	RP
22283	292	31	in	in	IN
22283	292	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	292	33	tranquillity	tranquillity	NN
22283	292	34	;	;	.
22283	292	35	The	the	DT
22283	292	36	gentleness	gentleness	NN
22283	292	37	of	of	IN
22283	292	38	heaven	heaven	NNP
22283	292	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	292	40	on	on	IN
22283	292	41	the	the	DT
22283	292	42	sea	sea	NN
22283	292	43	:	:	:
22283	292	44	Listen	listen	VB
22283	292	45	!	!	.
22283	293	1	the	the	DT
22283	293	2	mighty	mighty	JJ
22283	293	3	being	being	NN
22283	293	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	293	5	awake	awake	JJ
22283	293	6	,	,	,
22283	293	7	And	and	CC
22283	293	8	doth	doth	VB
22283	293	9	with	with	IN
22283	293	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	293	11	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	293	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	293	13	make	make	VBP
22283	293	14	A	a	DT
22283	293	15	sound	sound	NN
22283	293	16	like	like	IN
22283	293	17	thunder	thunder	NN
22283	293	18	,	,	,
22283	293	19	everlastingly	everlastingly	RB
22283	293	20	.	.	.
22283	293	21	'	'	''
22283	294	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
22283	294	2	:	:	:
22283	294	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	294	4	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	294	5	1	1	CD
22283	294	6	:	:	:
22283	294	7	_	_	NNP
22283	294	8	Leviathan	Leviathan	NNP
22283	294	9	_	_	NNP
22283	294	10	,	,	,
22283	294	11	pt	pt	NN
22283	294	12	.	.	.
22283	295	1	i.	i.	NNP
22283	295	2	chaps	chaps	NNP
22283	295	3	,	,	,
22283	295	4	i.	i.	NNP
22283	295	5	and	and	CC
22283	295	6	vi	vi	NNP
22283	295	7	.	.	.
22283	295	8	]	]	-RRB-
22283	296	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	296	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	296	3	2	2	CD
22283	296	4	:	:	:
22283	296	5	_	_	NNP
22283	296	6	Leviathan	Leviathan	NNP
22283	296	7	_	_	NNP
22283	296	8	,	,	,
22283	296	9	Introduction	Introduction	NNP
22283	296	10	.	.	.
22283	296	11	]	]	-RRB-
22283	297	1	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	297	2	'	'	``
22283	297	3	Das	Das	NNP
22283	297	4	Ich	Ich	NNP
22283	297	5	ist	ist	NN
22283	297	6	nicht	nicht	NN
22283	297	7	aus	aus	NNP
22283	297	8	Leib	Leib	NNP
22283	297	9	und	und	NN
22283	297	10	Seele	Seele	NNP
22283	297	11	zusammengesetzt	zusammengesetzt	NNP
22283	297	12	,	,	,
22283	297	13	sondern	sondern	NNP
22283	297	14	es	es	XX
22283	297	15	ist	ist	NNP
22283	297	16	eine	eine	NNP
22283	297	17	bestimmte	bestimmte	NNP
22283	297	18	Entwicklungsstufe	Entwicklungsstufe	NNP
22283	297	19	des	des	FW
22283	297	20	Wesens	Wesens	NNP
22283	297	21	,	,	,
22283	297	22	das	das	NNP
22283	297	23	von	von	NNP
22283	297	24	verschiedenem	verschiedenem	NNP
22283	297	25	Standpunkt	Standpunkt	NNP
22283	297	26	betrachtet	betrachtet	VBD
22283	297	27	in	in	IN
22283	297	28	körperliches	körperliche	NNS
22283	297	29	und	und	NNP
22283	297	30	geistiges	geistiges	NNP
22283	297	31	Dasein	Dasein	NNP
22283	297	32	auseinanderfällt	auseinanderfällt	VBZ
22283	297	33	.	.	.
22283	297	34	'	'	''
22283	298	1	--Wundt	--Wundt	:
22283	298	2	,	,	,
22283	298	3	_	_	NNP
22283	298	4	Vorlesungen	Vorlesungen	NNP
22283	298	5	über	über	NN
22283	298	6	die	die	VBP
22283	298	7	Menschen	Menschen	NNP
22283	298	8	-	-	HYPH
22283	298	9	und	und	NNP
22283	298	10	Thierseele	Thierseele	NNP
22283	298	11	_	_	NNP
22283	298	12	,	,	,
22283	298	13	i.	i.	NNP
22283	299	1	293	293	CD
22283	299	2	.	.	.
22283	300	1	INTRODUCTION	INTRODUCTION	NNP
22283	300	2	.	.	.
22283	301	1	In	in	IN
22283	301	2	no	no	DT
22283	301	3	respect	respect	NN
22283	301	4	has	have	VBZ
22283	301	5	the	the	DT
22283	301	6	progress	progress	NN
22283	301	7	of	of	IN
22283	301	8	physical	physical	JJ
22283	301	9	science	science	NN
22283	301	10	exercised	exercise	VBD
22283	301	11	a	a	DT
22283	301	12	more	more	RBR
22283	301	13	profound	profound	JJ
22283	301	14	influence	influence	NN
22283	301	15	upon	upon	IN
22283	301	16	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	301	17	thought	thought	NN
22283	301	18	than	than	IN
22283	301	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	301	20	has	have	VBZ
22283	301	21	by	by	IN
22283	301	22	proving	prove	VBG
22283	301	23	an	an	DT
22283	301	24	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	301	25	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
22283	301	26	relation	relation	NN
22283	301	27	between	between	IN
22283	301	28	material	material	NN
22283	301	29	changes	change	NNS
22283	301	30	and	and	CC
22283	301	31	mental	mental	JJ
22283	301	32	changes	change	NNS
22283	301	33	.	.	.
22283	302	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	302	2	has	have	VBZ
22283	302	3	always	always	RB
22283	302	4	been	be	VBN
22283	302	5	known	know	VBN
22283	302	6	that	that	IN
22283	302	7	there	there	EX
22283	302	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	302	9	qualitative	qualitative	JJ
22283	302	10	relation	relation	NN
22283	302	11	.	.	.
22283	303	1	Even	even	RB
22283	303	2	long	long	RB
22283	303	3	before	before	IN
22283	303	4	mankind	mankind	NN
22283	303	5	suspected	suspect	VBD
22283	303	6	that	that	IN
22283	303	7	the	the	DT
22283	303	8	brain	brain	NN
22283	303	9	was	be	VBD
22283	303	10	in	in	IN
22283	303	11	any	any	DT
22283	303	12	way	way	NN
22283	303	13	connected	connect	VBN
22283	303	14	with	with	IN
22283	303	15	thought	thought	NN
22283	303	16	,	,	,
22283	303	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	303	18	was	be	VBD
22283	303	19	well	well	RB
22283	303	20	understood	understand	VBN
22283	303	21	that	that	IN
22283	303	22	alcohol	alcohol	NN
22283	303	23	and	and	CC
22283	303	24	other	other	JJ
22283	303	25	poisons	poison	NNS
22283	303	26	exercised	exercise	VBD
22283	303	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	303	28	sundry	sundry	JJ
22283	303	29	influences	influence	NNS
22283	303	30	on	on	IN
22283	303	31	the	the	DT
22283	303	32	mind	mind	NN
22283	303	33	in	in	IN
22283	303	34	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	303	35	of	of	IN
22283	303	36	influences	influence	NNS
22283	303	37	which	which	WDT
22283	303	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	303	39	exercised	exercise	VBD
22283	303	40	upon	upon	IN
22283	303	41	the	the	DT
22283	303	42	body	body	NN
22283	303	43	;	;	:
22283	303	44	and	and	CC
22283	303	45	even	even	RB
22283	303	46	the	the	DT
22283	303	47	lowest	low	JJS
22283	303	48	savages	savage	NNS
22283	303	49	must	must	MD
22283	303	50	always	always	RB
22283	303	51	have	have	VB
22283	303	52	been	be	VBN
22283	303	53	aware	aware	JJ
22283	303	54	that	that	IN
22283	303	55	a	a	DT
22283	303	56	blow	blow	NN
22283	303	57	on	on	IN
22283	303	58	the	the	DT
22283	303	59	head	head	NN
22283	303	60	is	be	VBZ
22283	303	61	followed	follow	VBN
22283	303	62	by	by	IN
22283	303	63	insensibility	insensibility	NN
22283	303	64	.	.	.
22283	304	1	But	but	CC
22283	304	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	304	3	was	be	VBD
22283	304	4	not	not	RB
22283	304	5	until	until	IN
22283	304	6	the	the	DT
22283	304	7	rise	rise	NN
22283	304	8	of	of	IN
22283	304	9	Physiology	Physiology	NNP
22283	304	10	that	that	IN
22283	304	11	this	this	DT
22283	304	12	qualitative	qualitative	JJ
22283	304	13	relation	relation	NN
22283	304	14	between	between	IN
22283	304	15	corporeal	corporeal	JJ
22283	304	16	changes	change	NNS
22283	304	17	and	and	CC
22283	304	18	mental	mental	JJ
22283	304	19	changes	change	NNS
22283	304	20	was	be	VBD
22283	304	21	gradually	gradually	RB
22283	304	22	found	find	VBN
22283	304	23	to	to	TO
22283	304	24	be	be	VB
22283	304	25	a	a	DT
22283	304	26	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
22283	304	27	one	one	CD
22283	304	28	--	--	:
22283	304	29	or	or	CC
22283	304	30	that	that	IN
22283	304	31	every	every	DT
22283	304	32	particular	particular	JJ
22283	304	33	change	change	NN
22283	304	34	of	of	IN
22283	304	35	mind	mind	NN
22283	304	36	had	have	VBD
22283	304	37	an	an	DT
22283	304	38	exact	exact	JJ
22283	304	39	and	and	CC
22283	304	40	invariable	invariable	JJ
22283	304	41	counterpart	counterpart	NN
22283	304	42	in	in	IN
22283	304	43	some	some	DT
22283	304	44	particular	particular	JJ
22283	304	45	change	change	NN
22283	304	46	of	of	IN
22283	304	47	body	body	NN
22283	304	48	.	.	.
22283	305	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	305	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	305	3	needless	needless	JJ
22283	305	4	for	for	IN
22283	305	5	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	305	6	to	to	TO
22283	305	7	detail	detail	VB
22283	305	8	the	the	DT
22283	305	9	successive	successive	JJ
22283	305	10	steps	step	NNS
22283	305	11	in	in	IN
22283	305	12	the	the	DT
22283	305	13	long	long	JJ
22283	305	14	course	course	NN
22283	305	15	of	of	IN
22283	305	16	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	305	17	discovery	discovery	NN
22283	305	18	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	305	19	this	this	DT
22283	305	20	great	great	JJ
22283	305	21	fact	fact	NN
22283	305	22	has	have	VBZ
22283	305	23	been	be	VBN
22283	305	24	established	establish	VBN
22283	305	25	;	;	:
22283	305	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	305	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	305	28	enough	enough	JJ
22283	305	29	to	to	TO
22283	305	30	say	say	VB
22283	305	31	that	that	IN
22283	305	32	the	the	DT
22283	305	33	fact	fact	NN
22283	305	34	_	_	NNP
22283	305	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	305	36	_	_	NNP
22283	305	37	established	establish	VBN
22283	305	38	to	to	IN
22283	305	39	the	the	DT
22283	305	40	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
22283	305	41	of	of	IN
22283	305	42	every	every	DT
22283	305	43	physiologist	physiologist	NN
22283	305	44	.	.	.
22283	306	1	Now	now	RB
22283	306	2	,	,	,
22283	306	3	when	when	WRB
22283	306	4	once	once	IN
22283	306	5	the	the	DT
22283	306	6	relation	relation	NN
22283	306	7	between	between	IN
22283	306	8	material	material	JJ
22283	306	9	changes	change	NNS
22283	306	10	and	and	CC
22283	306	11	mental	mental	JJ
22283	306	12	changes	change	NNS
22283	306	13	has	have	VBZ
22283	306	14	been	be	VBN
22283	306	15	thus	thus	RB
22283	306	16	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	306	17	as	as	IN
22283	306	18	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
22283	306	19	--	--	:
22283	306	20	or	or	CC
22283	306	21	,	,	,
22283	306	22	which	which	WDT
22283	306	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	306	24	the	the	DT
22283	306	25	same	same	JJ
22283	306	26	thing	thing	NN
22283	306	27	,	,	,
22283	306	28	when	when	WRB
22283	306	29	once	once	IN
22283	306	30	the	the	DT
22283	306	31	association	association	NN
22283	306	32	has	have	VBZ
22283	306	33	been	be	VBN
22283	306	34	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	306	35	as	as	IN
22283	306	36	both	both	DT
22283	306	37	invariable	invariable	JJ
22283	306	38	and	and	CC
22283	306	39	exact	exact	JJ
22283	306	40	--	--	:
22283	306	41	there	there	EX
22283	306	42	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	306	43	the	the	DT
22283	306	44	question	question	NN
22283	306	45	as	as	IN
22283	306	46	to	to	IN
22283	306	47	how	how	WRB
22283	306	48	this	this	DT
22283	306	49	relation	relation	NN
22283	306	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	306	51	to	to	TO
22283	306	52	be	be	VB
22283	306	53	explained	explain	VBN
22283	306	54	.	.	.
22283	307	1	Formally	formally	RB
22283	307	2	considered	consider	VBN
22283	307	3	--	--	:
22283	307	4	or	or	CC
22283	307	5	considered	consider	VBN
22283	307	6	as	as	IN
22283	307	7	a	a	DT
22283	307	8	matter	matter	NN
22283	307	9	of	of	IN
22283	307	10	logical	logical	JJ
22283	307	11	statement	statement	NN
22283	307	12	irrespective	irrespective	RB
22283	307	13	of	of	IN
22283	307	14	the	the	DT
22283	307	15	relative	relative	JJ
22283	307	16	probabilities	probability	NNS
22283	307	17	which	which	WDT
22283	307	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	307	19	may	may	MD
22283	307	20	present	present	VB
22283	307	21	,	,	,
22283	307	22	either	either	CC
22283	307	23	to	to	IN
22283	307	24	the	the	DT
22283	307	25	minds	mind	NNS
22283	307	26	of	of	IN
22283	307	27	different	different	JJ
22283	307	28	individuals	individual	NNS
22283	307	29	or	or	CC
22283	307	30	to	to	IN
22283	307	31	the	the	DT
22283	307	32	general	general	JJ
22283	307	33	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	307	34	of	of	IN
22283	307	35	the	the	DT
22283	307	36	race	race	NN
22283	307	37	--	--	:
22283	307	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	307	39	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	307	40	to	to	IN
22283	307	41	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	307	42	that	that	IN
22283	307	43	the	the	DT
22283	307	44	possible	possible	JJ
22283	307	45	hypotheses	hypothesis	NNS
22283	307	46	are	be	VBP
22283	307	47	here	here	RB
22283	307	48	seven	seven	CD
22283	307	49	in	in	IN
22283	307	50	number	number	NN
22283	307	51	.	.	.
22283	308	1	I.	I.	NNP
22283	309	1	The	the	DT
22283	309	2	mental	mental	JJ
22283	309	3	changes	change	NNS
22283	309	4	may	may	MD
22283	309	5	cause	cause	VB
22283	309	6	the	the	DT
22283	309	7	material	material	NN
22283	309	8	changes	change	NNS
22283	309	9	.	.	.
22283	310	1	II	ii	CD
22283	310	2	.	.	.
22283	311	1	The	the	DT
22283	311	2	material	material	NN
22283	311	3	changes	change	NNS
22283	311	4	may	may	MD
22283	311	5	cause	cause	VB
22283	311	6	the	the	DT
22283	311	7	mental	mental	JJ
22283	311	8	changes	change	NNS
22283	311	9	.	.	.
22283	312	1	III	iii	CD
22283	312	2	.	.	.
22283	313	1	There	there	EX
22283	313	2	may	may	MD
22283	313	3	be	be	VB
22283	313	4	no	no	DT
22283	313	5	causation	causation	NN
22283	313	6	either	either	DT
22283	313	7	way	way	NN
22283	313	8	,	,	,
22283	313	9	because	because	IN
22283	313	10	the	the	DT
22283	313	11	association	association	NN
22283	313	12	may	may	MD
22283	313	13	be	be	VB
22283	313	14	only	only	RB
22283	313	15	a	a	DT
22283	313	16	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	313	17	association	association	NN
22283	313	18	--	--	:
22283	313	19	the	the	DT
22283	313	20	two	two	CD
22283	313	21	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	313	22	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	313	23	classes	class	NNS
22283	313	24	of	of	IN
22283	313	25	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	313	26	being	be	VBG
22283	313	27	really	really	RB
22283	313	28	one	one	CD
22283	313	29	and	and	CC
22283	313	30	the	the	DT
22283	313	31	same	same	JJ
22283	313	32	.	.	.
22283	314	1	IV	IV	NNP
22283	314	2	.	.	.
22283	315	1	There	there	EX
22283	315	2	may	may	MD
22283	315	3	be	be	VB
22283	315	4	no	no	DT
22283	315	5	causation	causation	NN
22283	315	6	either	either	DT
22283	315	7	way	way	NN
22283	315	8	,	,	,
22283	315	9	because	because	IN
22283	315	10	the	the	DT
22283	315	11	association	association	NN
22283	315	12	may	may	MD
22283	315	13	be	be	VB
22283	315	14	due	due	IN
22283	315	15	to	to	IN
22283	315	16	a	a	DT
22283	315	17	harmony	harmony	NN
22283	315	18	pre	pre	VBN
22283	315	19	-	-	VBN
22283	315	20	established	establish	VBN
22283	315	21	by	by	IN
22283	315	22	a	a	DT
22283	315	23	superior	superior	JJ
22283	315	24	mind	mind	NN
22283	315	25	.	.	.
22283	316	1	V.	V.	NNP
22283	316	2	There	there	EX
22283	316	3	may	may	MD
22283	316	4	be	be	VB
22283	316	5	no	no	DT
22283	316	6	causation	causation	NN
22283	316	7	either	either	DT
22283	316	8	way	way	NN
22283	316	9	,	,	,
22283	316	10	because	because	IN
22283	316	11	the	the	DT
22283	316	12	association	association	NN
22283	316	13	may	may	MD
22283	316	14	always	always	RB
22283	316	15	be	be	VB
22283	316	16	due	due	JJ
22283	316	17	to	to	IN
22283	316	18	chance	chance	NN
22283	316	19	.	.	.
22283	317	1	VI	VI	NNP
22283	317	2	.	.	.
22283	318	1	There	there	EX
22283	318	2	may	may	MD
22283	318	3	be	be	VB
22283	318	4	no	no	DT
22283	318	5	causation	causation	NN
22283	318	6	either	either	DT
22283	318	7	way	way	NN
22283	318	8	,	,	,
22283	318	9	because	because	IN
22283	318	10	the	the	DT
22283	318	11	material	material	JJ
22283	318	12	order	order	NN
22283	318	13	may	may	MD
22283	318	14	not	not	RB
22283	318	15	have	have	VB
22283	318	16	any	any	DT
22283	318	17	real	real	JJ
22283	318	18	existence	existence	NN
22283	318	19	at	at	RB
22283	318	20	all	all	RB
22283	318	21	,	,	,
22283	318	22	being	be	VBG
22283	318	23	merely	merely	RB
22283	318	24	an	an	DT
22283	318	25	ideal	ideal	JJ
22283	318	26	creation	creation	NN
22283	318	27	of	of	IN
22283	318	28	the	the	DT
22283	318	29	mental	mental	JJ
22283	318	30	order	order	NN
22283	318	31	.	.	.
22283	319	1	VII	VII	NNP
22283	319	2	.	.	.
22283	320	1	Whether	whether	IN
22283	320	2	or	or	CC
22283	320	3	not	not	RB
22283	320	4	there	there	EX
22283	320	5	be	be	VB
22283	320	6	any	any	DT
22283	320	7	causation	causation	NN
22283	320	8	either	either	DT
22283	320	9	way	way	NN
22283	320	10	,	,	,
22283	320	11	the	the	DT
22283	320	12	association	association	NN
22283	320	13	may	may	MD
22283	320	14	be	be	VB
22283	320	15	one	one	CD
22283	320	16	which	which	WDT
22283	320	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	320	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	320	19	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	320	20	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	320	21	the	the	DT
22283	320	22	power	power	NN
22283	320	23	of	of	IN
22283	320	24	the	the	DT
22283	320	25	human	human	JJ
22283	320	26	mind	mind	NN
22283	320	27	to	to	TO
22283	320	28	explain	explain	VB
22283	320	29	.	.	.
22283	321	1	So	so	RB
22283	321	2	far	far	RB
22283	321	3	as	as	IN
22283	321	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	321	5	can	can	MD
22283	321	6	see	see	VB
22283	321	7	,	,	,
22283	321	8	this	this	DT
22283	321	9	list	list	NN
22283	321	10	of	of	IN
22283	321	11	possible	possible	JJ
22283	321	12	answers	answer	NNS
22283	321	13	to	to	IN
22283	321	14	the	the	DT
22283	321	15	question	question	NN
22283	321	16	before	before	IN
22283	321	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	321	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	321	19	exhaustive	exhaustive	JJ
22283	321	20	.	.	.
22283	322	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	322	2	will	will	MD
22283	322	3	next	next	RB
22283	322	4	show	show	VB
22283	322	5	why	why	WRB
22283	322	6	,	,	,
22283	322	7	in	in	IN
22283	322	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	322	9	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	322	10	,	,	,
22283	322	11	the	the	DT
22283	322	12	last	last	JJ
22283	322	13	four	four	CD
22283	322	14	of	of	IN
22283	322	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	322	16	may	may	MD
22283	322	17	be	be	VB
22283	322	18	excluded	exclude	VBN
22283	322	19	_	_	NNP
22283	322	20	in	in	IN
22283	322	21	limine	limine	NNP
22283	322	22	_	_	NNP
22283	322	23	.	.	.
22283	323	1	The	the	DT
22283	323	2	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	323	3	of	of	IN
22283	323	4	pre	pre	JJ
22283	323	5	-	-	JJ
22283	323	6	established	established	JJ
22283	323	7	harmony	harmony	NN
22283	323	8	(	(	-LRB-
22283	323	9	IV	IV	NNP
22283	323	10	)	)	-RRB-
22283	323	11	merely	merely	RB
22283	323	12	postpones	postpone	VBZ
22283	323	13	the	the	DT
22283	323	14	question	question	NN
22283	323	15	:	:	:
22283	323	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	323	17	_	_	NNP
22283	323	18	assumes	assume	VBZ
22283	323	19	_	_	NNP
22283	323	20	a	a	DT
22283	323	21	higher	high	JJR
22283	323	22	_	_	NNP
22283	323	23	mind	mind	NN
22283	323	24	_	_	NNP
22283	323	25	as	as	IN
22283	323	26	adjusting	adjust	VBG
22283	323	27	correspondencies	correspondencie	NNS
22283	323	28	between	between	IN
22283	323	29	known	known	JJ
22283	323	30	minds	mind	NNS
22283	323	31	and	and	CC
22283	323	32	animal	animal	NN
22283	323	33	bodies	body	NNS
22283	323	34	with	with	IN
22283	323	35	respect	respect	NN
22283	323	36	to	to	IN
22283	323	37	the	the	DT
22283	323	38	activities	activity	NNS
22283	323	39	of	of	IN
22283	323	40	each	each	DT
22283	323	41	;	;	:
22283	323	42	and	and	CC
22283	323	43	,	,	,
22283	323	44	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	323	45	,	,	,
22283	323	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	323	47	either	either	CC
22283	323	48	leaves	leave	NNS
22283	323	49	untouched	untouche	VBD
22283	323	50	the	the	DT
22283	323	51	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	323	52	question	question	NN
22283	323	53	concerning	concern	VBG
22283	323	54	the	the	DT
22283	323	55	relation	relation	NN
22283	323	56	of	of	IN
22283	323	57	mind	mind	NN
22283	323	58	(	(	-LRB-
22283	323	59	as	as	IN
22283	323	60	such	such	JJ
22283	323	61	)	)	-RRB-
22283	323	62	to	to	TO
22283	323	63	matter	matter	VB
22283	323	64	,	,	,
22283	323	65	or	or	CC
22283	323	66	else	else	RB
22283	323	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	323	68	answers	answer	VBZ
22283	323	69	this	this	DT
22283	323	70	question	question	NN
22283	323	71	in	in	IN
22283	323	72	terms	term	NNS
22283	323	73	of	of	IN
22283	323	74	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	323	75	(	(	-LRB-
22283	323	76	I	i	NN
22283	323	77	)	)	-RRB-
22283	323	78	.	.	.
22283	324	1	The	the	DT
22283	324	2	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	324	3	of	of	IN
22283	324	4	chance	chance	NN
22283	324	5	(	(	-LRB-
22283	324	6	V	v	NN
22283	324	7	)	)	-RRB-
22283	324	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	324	9	effectually	effectually	RB
22283	324	10	excluded	exclude	VBN
22283	324	11	by	by	IN
22283	324	12	the	the	DT
22283	324	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	324	14	of	of	IN
22283	324	15	chances	chance	NNS
22283	324	16	:	:	:
22283	324	17	even	even	RB
22283	324	18	in	in	IN
22283	324	19	any	any	DT
22283	324	20	one	one	CD
22283	324	21	individual	individual	JJ
22283	324	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	324	23	,	,	,
22283	324	24	the	the	DT
22283	324	25	association	association	NN
22283	324	26	between	between	IN
22283	324	27	mental	mental	JJ
22283	324	28	changes	change	NNS
22283	324	29	and	and	CC
22283	324	30	material	material	NN
22283	324	31	changes	change	NNS
22283	324	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	324	33	much	much	RB
22283	324	34	too	too	RB
22283	324	35	intimate	intimate	JJ
22283	324	36	,	,	,
22283	324	37	constant	constant	JJ
22283	324	38	,	,	,
22283	324	39	and	and	CC
22283	324	40	detailed	detail	VBN
22283	324	41	to	to	TO
22283	324	42	admit	admit	VB
22283	324	43	of	of	IN
22283	324	44	any	any	DT
22283	324	45	one	one	NN
22283	324	46	reasonably	reasonably	RB
22283	324	47	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	324	48	that	that	IN
22283	324	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	324	50	can	can	MD
22283	324	51	be	be	VB
22283	324	52	due	due	JJ
22283	324	53	only	only	RB
22283	324	54	to	to	TO
22283	324	55	chance	chance	NN
22283	324	56	.	.	.
22283	325	1	The	the	DT
22283	325	2	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	325	3	of	of	IN
22283	325	4	pure	pure	JJ
22283	325	5	idealism	idealism	NN
22283	325	6	(	(	-LRB-
22283	325	7	VI	VI	NNP
22283	325	8	)	)	-RRB-
22283	325	9	ultimately	ultimately	RB
22283	325	10	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	325	11	that	that	IN
22283	325	12	the	the	DT
22283	325	13	thinking	think	VBG
22283	325	14	Ego	ego	NN
22283	325	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	325	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	325	17	the	the	DT
22283	325	18	sole	sole	JJ
22283	325	19	existence	existence	NN
22283	325	20	--	--	:
22283	325	21	a	a	DT
22283	325	22	position	position	NN
22283	325	23	which	which	WDT
22283	325	24	can	can	MD
22283	325	25	not	not	RB
22283	325	26	,	,	,
22283	325	27	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	325	28	,	,	,
22283	325	29	be	be	VB
22283	325	30	turned	turn	VBN
22283	325	31	by	by	IN
22283	325	32	any	any	DT
22283	325	33	assault	assault	NN
22283	325	34	of	of	IN
22283	325	35	logic	logic	NN
22283	325	36	;	;	:
22283	325	37	but	but	CC
22283	325	38	one	one	CD
22283	325	39	which	which	WDT
22283	325	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	325	41	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	325	42	too	too	RB
22283	325	43	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	325	44	opposed	opposed	JJ
22283	325	45	to	to	IN
22283	325	46	common	common	JJ
22283	325	47	sense	sense	NN
22283	325	48	to	to	TO
22283	325	49	admit	admit	VB
22283	325	50	of	of	IN
22283	325	51	any	any	DT
22283	325	52	serious	serious	JJ
22283	325	53	defence	defence	NN
22283	325	54	;	;	:
22283	325	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	325	56	immunity	immunity	NN
22283	325	57	from	from	IN
22283	325	58	direct	direct	JJ
22283	325	59	attack	attack	NN
22283	325	60	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	325	61	only	only	RB
22283	325	62	from	from	IN
22283	325	63	the	the	DT
22283	325	64	gratuitous	gratuitous	JJ
22283	325	65	nature	nature	NN
22283	325	66	of	of	IN
22283	325	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	325	68	challenge	challenge	NN
22283	325	69	to	to	TO
22283	325	70	prove	prove	VB
22283	325	71	a	a	DT
22283	325	72	negative	negative	JJ
22283	325	73	(	(	-LRB-
22283	325	74	namely	namely	RB
22283	325	75	,	,	,
22283	325	76	that	that	IN
22283	325	77	the	the	DT
22283	325	78	thinking	think	VBG
22283	325	79	Ego	ego	NN
22283	325	80	is	be	VBZ
22283	325	81	_	_	NNP
22283	325	82	not	not	RB
22283	325	83	_	_	NNP
22283	325	84	the	the	DT
22283	325	85	sole	sole	JJ
22283	325	86	existence	existence	NN
22283	325	87	)	)	-RRB-
22283	325	88	,	,	,
22283	325	89	and	and	CC
22283	325	90	this	this	DT
22283	325	91	a	a	DT
22283	325	92	negative	negative	JJ
22283	325	93	which	which	WDT
22283	325	94	is	be	VBZ
22283	325	95	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	325	96	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	325	97	the	the	DT
22283	325	98	region	region	NN
22283	325	99	of	of	IN
22283	325	100	proof	proof	NN
22283	325	101	.	.	.
22283	326	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	326	2	,	,	,
22283	326	3	the	the	DT
22283	326	4	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	326	5	that	that	IN
22283	326	6	the	the	DT
22283	326	7	problem	problem	NN
22283	326	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	326	9	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	326	10	insoluble	insoluble	JJ
22283	326	11	(	(	-LRB-
22283	326	12	VII	VII	NNP
22283	326	13	)	)	-RRB-
22283	326	14	does	do	VBZ
22283	326	15	not	not	RB
22283	326	16	deserve	deserve	VB
22283	326	17	to	to	TO
22283	326	18	be	be	VB
22283	326	19	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	326	20	as	as	IN
22283	326	21	an	an	DT
22283	326	22	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	326	23	at	at	RB
22283	326	24	all	all	RB
22283	326	25	;	;	:
22283	326	26	for	for	IN
22283	326	27	to	to	TO
22283	326	28	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	326	29	that	that	IN
22283	326	30	the	the	DT
22283	326	31	problem	problem	NN
22283	326	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	326	33	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	326	34	insoluble	insoluble	JJ
22283	326	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	326	36	merely	merely	RB
22283	326	37	to	to	TO
22283	326	38	exclude	exclude	VB
22283	326	39	the	the	DT
22283	326	40	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	326	41	of	of	IN
22283	326	42	there	there	EX
22283	326	43	being	be	VBG
22283	326	44	any	any	DT
22283	326	45	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	326	46	available	available	JJ
22283	326	47	.	.	.
22283	327	1	In	in	IN
22283	327	2	view	view	NN
22283	327	3	of	of	IN
22283	327	4	these	these	DT
22283	327	5	several	several	JJ
22283	327	6	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	327	7	,	,	,
22283	327	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	327	9	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	327	10	to	to	IN
22283	327	11	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	327	12	that	that	IN
22283	327	13	,	,	,
22283	327	14	although	although	IN
22283	327	15	in	in	IN
22283	327	16	a	a	DT
22283	327	17	formal	formal	JJ
22283	327	18	sense	sense	NN
22283	327	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	327	20	may	may	MD
22283	327	21	say	say	VB
22283	327	22	there	there	EX
22283	327	23	are	be	VBP
22283	327	24	altogether	altogether	RB
22283	327	25	seven	seven	CD
22283	327	26	possible	possible	JJ
22283	327	27	answers	answer	NNS
22283	327	28	to	to	IN
22283	327	29	the	the	DT
22283	327	30	question	question	NN
22283	327	31	before	before	IN
22283	327	32	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	327	33	,	,	,
22283	327	34	in	in	IN
22283	327	35	reality	reality	NN
22283	327	36	,	,	,
22283	327	37	or	or	CC
22283	327	38	for	for	IN
22283	327	39	the	the	DT
22283	327	40	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	327	41	of	of	IN
22283	327	42	practical	practical	JJ
22283	327	43	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	327	44	,	,	,
22283	327	45	there	there	EX
22283	327	46	are	be	VBP
22283	327	47	nowadays	nowadays	RB
22283	327	48	but	but	CC
22283	327	49	three	three	CD
22283	327	50	--	--	:
22283	327	51	namely	namely	RB
22283	327	52	those	those	DT
22283	327	53	which	which	WDT
22283	327	54	head	head	VBP
22283	327	55	the	the	DT
22283	327	56	above	above	JJ
22283	327	57	list	list	NN
22283	327	58	,	,	,
22283	327	59	and	and	CC
22283	327	60	which	which	WDT
22283	327	61	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	327	62	will	will	MD
22283	327	63	now	now	RB
22283	327	64	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	327	65	to	to	TO
22283	327	66	consider	consider	VB
22283	327	67	.	.	.
22283	328	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	328	2	have	have	VBP
22283	328	3	named	name	VBN
22283	328	4	these	these	DT
22283	328	5	three	three	CD
22283	328	6	hypotheses	hypothesis	NNS
22283	328	7	in	in	IN
22283	328	8	the	the	DT
22283	328	9	order	order	NN
22283	328	10	of	of	IN
22283	328	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	328	12	appearance	appearance	NN
22283	328	13	during	during	IN
22283	328	14	the	the	DT
22283	328	15	history	history	NN
22283	328	16	of	of	IN
22283	328	17	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	328	18	thought	thought	NN
22283	328	19	.	.	.
22283	329	1	The	the	DT
22283	329	2	earliest	early	JJS
22283	329	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	329	4	the	the	DT
22283	329	5	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	329	6	.	.	.
22283	330	1	As	as	IN
22283	330	2	far	far	RB
22283	330	3	back	back	RB
22283	330	4	as	as	IN
22283	330	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	330	6	can	can	MD
22283	330	7	trace	trace	VB
22283	330	8	the	the	DT
22283	330	9	conceptions	conception	NNS
22283	330	10	of	of	IN
22283	330	11	primitive	primitive	JJ
22283	330	12	man	man	NN
22283	330	13	,	,	,
22283	330	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	330	15	meet	meet	VBP
22283	330	16	with	with	IN
22283	330	17	an	an	DT
22283	330	18	unquestioning	unquestioning	JJ
22283	330	19	belief	belief	NN
22283	330	20	that	that	IN
22283	330	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	330	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	330	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	330	24	spirit	spirit	NN
22283	330	25	which	which	WDT
22283	330	26	_	_	NNP
22283	330	27	animates	animate	VBZ
22283	330	28	_	_	IN
22283	330	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	330	30	body	body	NN
22283	330	31	;	;	:
22283	330	32	and	and	CC
22283	330	33	,	,	,
22283	330	34	starting	start	VBG
22283	330	35	from	from	IN
22283	330	36	this	this	DT
22283	330	37	belief	belief	NN
22283	330	38	as	as	IN
22283	330	39	explanatory	explanatory	JJ
22283	330	40	of	of	IN
22283	330	41	the	the	DT
22283	330	42	movements	movement	NNS
22283	330	43	of	of	IN
22283	330	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	330	45	own	own	JJ
22283	330	46	body	body	NN
22283	330	47	,	,	,
22283	330	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	330	49	readily	readily	RB
22283	330	50	attributes	attribute	VBZ
22283	330	51	movements	movement	NNS
22283	330	52	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	330	53	to	to	IN
22283	330	54	analogous	analogous	JJ
22283	330	55	agencies	agency	NNS
22283	330	56	--	--	:
22283	330	57	the	the	DT
22283	330	58	theory	theory	NN
22283	330	59	of	of	IN
22283	330	60	_	_	NNP
22283	330	61	animism	animism	NN
22283	330	62	_	_	NNP
22283	330	63	in	in	IN
22283	330	64	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	330	65	thus	thus	RB
22283	330	66	becoming	become	VBG
22283	330	67	the	the	DT
22283	330	68	universal	universal	JJ
22283	330	69	theory	theory	NN
22283	330	70	in	in	IN
22283	330	71	all	all	DT
22283	330	72	early	early	JJ
22283	330	73	stages	stage	NNS
22283	330	74	of	of	IN
22283	330	75	culture	culture	NN
22283	330	76	.	.	.
22283	331	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	331	2	also	also	RB
22283	331	3	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	331	4	to	to	TO
22283	331	5	be	be	VB
22283	331	6	the	the	DT
22283	331	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	331	8	most	most	RBS
22283	331	9	natural	natural	JJ
22283	331	10	to	to	IN
22283	331	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	331	12	own	own	JJ
22283	331	13	children	child	NNS
22283	331	14	during	during	IN
22283	331	15	the	the	DT
22283	331	16	early	early	JJ
22283	331	17	years	year	NNS
22283	331	18	of	of	IN
22283	331	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	331	20	dawning	dawn	VBG
22283	331	21	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	331	22	,	,	,
22283	331	23	and	and	CC
22283	331	24	would	would	MD
22283	331	25	doubtless	doubtless	RB
22283	331	26	continue	continue	VB
22283	331	27	through	through	IN
22283	331	28	life	life	NN
22283	331	29	in	in	IN
22283	331	30	the	the	DT
22283	331	31	case	case	NN
22283	331	32	of	of	IN
22283	331	33	every	every	DT
22283	331	34	individual	individual	JJ
22283	331	35	human	human	JJ
22283	331	36	being	being	NN
22283	331	37	,	,	,
22283	331	38	were	be	VBD
22283	331	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	331	40	not	not	RB
22283	331	41	subsequently	subsequently	RB
22283	331	42	instructed	instruct	VBN
22283	331	43	in	in	IN
22283	331	44	the	the	DT
22283	331	45	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	331	46	which	which	WDT
22283	331	47	have	have	VBP
22283	331	48	led	lead	VBN
22283	331	49	to	to	IN
22283	331	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	331	51	rejection	rejection	NN
22283	331	52	by	by	IN
22283	331	53	many	many	JJ
22283	331	54	other	other	JJ
22283	331	55	members	member	NNS
22283	331	56	of	of	IN
22283	331	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	331	58	race	race	NN
22283	331	59	.	.	.
22283	332	1	These	these	DT
22283	332	2	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	332	3	,	,	,
22283	332	4	as	as	IN
22283	332	5	already	already	RB
22283	332	6	observed	observe	VBN
22283	332	7	,	,	,
22283	332	8	have	have	VBP
22283	332	9	been	be	VBN
22283	332	10	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	332	11	in	in	IN
22283	332	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	332	13	entirety	entirety	NN
22283	332	14	only	only	RB
22283	332	15	within	within	IN
22283	332	16	comparatively	comparatively	RB
22283	332	17	recent	recent	JJ
22283	332	18	times	time	NNS
22283	332	19	;	;	:
22283	332	20	not	not	RB
22283	332	21	until	until	IN
22283	332	22	Physiology	Physiology	NNP
22283	332	23	was	be	VBD
22283	332	24	able	able	JJ
22283	332	25	to	to	TO
22283	332	26	prove	prove	VB
22283	332	27	how	how	WRB
22283	332	28	intimate	intimate	JJ
22283	332	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	332	30	the	the	DT
22283	332	31	association	association	NN
22283	332	32	between	between	IN
22283	332	33	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	332	34	processes	process	NNS
22283	332	35	and	and	CC
22283	332	36	mental	mental	JJ
22283	332	37	processes	process	NNS
22283	332	38	did	do	VBD
22283	332	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	332	40	become	become	VB
22283	332	41	possible	possible	JJ
22283	332	42	for	for	IN
22283	332	43	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	332	44	to	to	TO
22283	332	45	turn	turn	VB
22283	332	46	the	the	DT
22283	332	47	tables	table	NNS
22283	332	48	upon	upon	IN
22283	332	49	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	332	50	,	,	,
22283	332	51	by	by	IN
22283	332	52	simply	simply	RB
22283	332	53	inverting	invert	VBG
22283	332	54	the	the	DT
22283	332	55	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	332	56	.	.	.
22283	333	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	333	2	,	,	,
22283	333	3	although	although	IN
22283	333	4	the	the	DT
22283	333	5	theory	theory	NN
22283	333	6	of	of	IN
22283	333	7	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	333	8	(	(	-LRB-
22283	333	9	III	III	NNP
22283	333	10	)	)	-RRB-
22283	333	11	may	may	MD
22283	333	12	be	be	VB
22283	333	13	traced	trace	VBN
22283	333	14	back	back	RP
22283	333	15	at	at	RB
22283	333	16	least	least	JJS
22283	333	17	as	as	RB
22283	333	18	far	far	RB
22283	333	19	as	as	IN
22283	333	20	the	the	DT
22283	333	21	pantheistic	pantheistic	JJ
22283	333	22	thought	thought	NN
22283	333	23	of	of	IN
22283	333	24	Buddhism	Buddhism	NNP
22283	333	25	,	,	,
22283	333	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	333	27	there	there	EX
22283	333	28	had	have	VBD
22283	333	29	reference	reference	NN
22283	333	30	to	to	TO
22283	333	31	theology	theology	VB
22283	333	32	as	as	RB
22283	333	33	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	333	34	from	from	IN
22283	333	35	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	333	36	.	.	.
22283	334	1	And	and	CC
22283	334	2	even	even	RB
22283	334	3	as	as	IN
22283	334	4	presented	present	VBN
22283	334	5	in	in	IN
22283	334	6	the	the	DT
22283	334	7	writings	writing	NNS
22283	334	8	of	of	IN
22283	334	9	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
22283	334	10	,	,	,
22283	334	11	Spinoza	Spinoza	NNP
22283	334	12	,	,	,
22283	334	13	and	and	CC
22283	334	14	other	other	JJ
22283	334	15	so	so	RB
22283	334	16	-	-	HYPH
22283	334	17	called	call	VBN
22283	334	18	monists	monist	NNS
22283	334	19	prior	prior	RB
22283	334	20	to	to	IN
22283	334	21	the	the	DT
22283	334	22	present	present	JJ
22283	334	23	century	century	NN
22283	334	24	,	,	,
22283	334	25	the	the	DT
22283	334	26	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	334	27	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	334	28	lacked	lack	VBD
22283	334	29	completeness	completeness	NN
22283	334	30	on	on	IN
22283	334	31	account	account	NN
22283	334	32	of	of	IN
22283	334	33	the	the	DT
22283	334	34	absence	absence	NN
22283	334	35	of	of	IN
22283	334	36	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	334	37	afterwards	afterwards	RB
22283	334	38	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	334	39	by	by	IN
22283	334	40	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	334	41	.	.	.
22283	335	1	For	for	IN
22283	335	2	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	335	3	,	,	,
22283	335	4	in	in	IN
22283	335	5	the	the	DT
22283	335	6	sense	sense	NN
22283	335	7	of	of	IN
22283	335	8	this	this	DT
22283	335	9	term	term	NN
22283	335	10	as	as	IN
22283	335	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	335	12	shall	shall	MD
22283	335	13	use	use	VB
22283	335	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	335	15	,	,	,
22283	335	16	may	may	MD
22283	335	17	be	be	VB
22283	335	18	metaphorically	metaphorically	RB
22283	335	19	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	335	20	as	as	IN
22283	335	21	the	the	DT
22283	335	22	child	child	NN
22283	335	23	of	of	IN
22283	335	24	the	the	DT
22283	335	25	two	two	CD
22283	335	26	pre	pre	JJ
22283	335	27	-	-	JJ
22283	335	28	existing	existing	JJ
22283	335	29	theories	theory	NNS
22283	335	30	,	,	,
22283	335	31	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	335	32	and	and	CC
22283	335	33	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	335	34	.	.	.
22283	336	1	The	the	DT
22283	336	2	birth	birth	NN
22283	336	3	of	of	IN
22283	336	4	this	this	DT
22283	336	5	child	child	NN
22283	336	6	was	be	VBD
22283	336	7	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	336	8	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	336	9	before	before	IN
22283	336	10	both	both	CC
22283	336	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	336	12	parents	parent	NNS
22283	336	13	had	have	VBD
22283	336	14	reached	reach	VBN
22283	336	15	mature	mature	JJ
22283	336	16	age	age	NN
22283	336	17	.	.	.
22283	337	1	On	on	IN
22283	337	2	the	the	DT
22283	337	3	one	one	CD
22283	337	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	337	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	337	6	was	be	VBD
22283	337	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	337	8	that	that	IN
22283	337	9	the	the	DT
22283	337	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	337	11	of	of	IN
22283	337	12	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	337	13	should	should	MD
22283	337	14	have	have	VB
22283	337	15	outgrown	outgrow	VBN
22283	337	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	337	17	infancy	infancy	NN
22283	337	18	as	as	IN
22283	337	19	Animism	Animism	NNP
22283	337	20	,	,	,
22283	337	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	337	22	childhood	childhood	NN
22283	337	23	as	as	IN
22283	337	24	Polytheism	Polytheism	NNP
22283	337	25	,	,	,
22283	337	26	before	before	IN
22283	337	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	337	28	entered	enter	VBD
22283	337	29	upon	upon	IN
22283	337	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	337	31	youth	youth	NN
22283	337	32	as	as	IN
22283	337	33	Monotheism	Monotheism	NNP
22283	337	34	--	--	:
22283	337	35	or	or	CC
22283	337	36	before	before	IN
22283	337	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	337	38	was	be	VBD
22283	337	39	able	able	JJ
22283	337	40	to	to	TO
22283	337	41	supply	supply	VB
22283	337	42	material	material	NN
22283	337	43	for	for	IN
22283	337	44	the	the	DT
22283	337	45	conception	conception	NN
22283	337	46	of	of	IN
22283	337	47	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	337	48	as	as	IN
22283	337	49	a	a	DT
22283	337	50	theory	theory	NN
22283	337	51	of	of	IN
22283	337	52	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
22283	337	53	extent	extent	NN
22283	337	54	.	.	.
22283	338	1	On	on	IN
22283	338	2	the	the	DT
22283	338	3	other	other	JJ
22283	338	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	338	5	,	,	,
22283	338	6	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	338	7	required	require	VBD
22283	338	8	to	to	TO
22283	338	9	grow	grow	VB
22283	338	10	into	into	IN
22283	338	11	the	the	DT
22283	338	12	fullness	fullness	NN
22283	338	13	of	of	IN
22283	338	14	manhood	manhood	NN
22283	338	15	,	,	,
22283	338	16	under	under	IN
22283	338	17	the	the	DT
22283	338	18	nursing	nursing	NN
22283	338	19	influence	influence	NN
22283	338	20	of	of	IN
22283	338	21	Science	Science	NNP
22283	338	22	,	,	,
22283	338	23	before	before	IN
22283	338	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	338	25	was	be	VBD
22283	338	26	possible	possible	JJ
22283	338	27	to	to	TO
22283	338	28	engender	engender	VB
22283	338	29	this	this	DT
22283	338	30	new	new	RB
22283	338	31	-	-	HYPH
22283	338	32	born	bear	VBN
22283	338	33	offspring	offspring	NN
22283	338	34	;	;	:
22283	338	35	for	for	IN
22283	338	36	this	this	DT
22283	338	37	offspring	offspring	NN
22283	338	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	338	39	new	new	RB
22283	338	40	-	-	HYPH
22283	338	41	born	bear	VBN
22283	338	42	.	.	.
22283	339	1	The	the	DT
22283	339	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	339	3	of	of	IN
22283	339	4	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	339	5	,	,	,
22283	339	6	as	as	IN
22283	339	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	339	8	are	be	VBP
22283	339	9	about	about	JJ
22283	339	10	to	to	TO
22283	339	11	consider	consider	VB
22283	339	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	339	13	,	,	,
22283	339	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	339	15	a	a	DT
22283	339	16	creature	creature	NN
22283	339	17	of	of	IN
22283	339	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	339	19	own	own	JJ
22283	339	20	generation	generation	NN
22283	339	21	;	;	,
22283	339	22	and	and	CC
22283	339	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	339	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	339	25	only	only	RB
22283	339	26	as	as	RB
22283	339	27	such	such	JJ
22283	339	28	that	that	WDT
22283	339	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	339	30	desire	desire	VBP
22283	339	31	to	to	TO
22283	339	32	call	call	VB
22283	339	33	attention	attention	NN
22283	339	34	to	to	IN
22283	339	35	the	the	DT
22283	339	36	child	child	NN
22283	339	37	.	.	.
22283	340	1	In	in	IN
22283	340	2	order	order	NN
22283	340	3	,	,	,
22283	340	4	however	however	RB
22283	340	5	,	,	,
22283	340	6	to	to	TO
22283	340	7	do	do	VB
22283	340	8	this	this	DT
22283	340	9	,	,	,
22283	340	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	340	11	must	must	MD
22283	340	12	follow	follow	VB
22283	340	13	the	the	DT
22283	340	14	example	example	NN
22283	340	15	of	of	IN
22283	340	16	biographers	biographer	NNS
22283	340	17	in	in	IN
22283	340	18	general	general	JJ
22283	340	19	,	,	,
22283	340	20	and	and	CC
22283	340	21	begin	begin	VB
22283	340	22	by	by	IN
22283	340	23	giving	give	VBG
22283	340	24	a	a	DT
22283	340	25	brief	brief	JJ
22283	340	26	sketch	sketch	NN
22283	340	27	of	of	IN
22283	340	28	both	both	CC
22283	340	29	the	the	DT
22283	340	30	parents	parent	NNS
22283	340	31	.	.	.
22283	341	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
22283	341	2	I.	I.	NNP
22283	341	3	SPIRITUALISM	SPIRITUALISM	NNP
22283	341	4	.	.	.
22283	342	1	In	in	IN
22283	342	2	proceeding	proceeding	NN
22283	342	3	to	to	TO
22283	342	4	consider	consider	VB
22283	342	5	the	the	DT
22283	342	6	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	342	7	theories	theory	NNS
22283	342	8	of	of	IN
22283	342	9	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	342	10	and	and	CC
22283	342	11	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	342	12	,	,	,
22283	342	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	342	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	342	15	before	before	RB
22283	342	16	all	all	DT
22283	342	17	else	else	RB
22283	342	18	desirable	desirable	JJ
22283	342	19	to	to	TO
22283	342	20	be	be	VB
22283	342	21	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	342	22	clear	clear	JJ
22283	342	23	upon	upon	IN
22283	342	24	the	the	DT
22283	342	25	point	point	NN
22283	342	26	of	of	IN
22283	342	27	theory	theory	NN
22283	342	28	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	342	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	342	30	are	be	VBP
22283	342	31	essentially	essentially	RB
22283	342	32	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	342	33	.	.	.
22283	343	1	This	this	DT
22283	343	2	point	point	NN
22283	343	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	343	4	that	that	DT
22283	343	5	which	which	WDT
22283	343	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	343	7	raised	raise	VBN
22283	343	8	by	by	IN
22283	343	9	the	the	DT
22283	343	10	question	question	NN
22283	343	11	whether	whether	IN
22283	343	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	343	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	343	14	the	the	DT
22283	343	15	cause	cause	NN
22283	343	16	or	or	CC
22283	343	17	the	the	DT
22283	343	18	effect	effect	NN
22283	343	19	of	of	IN
22283	343	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	343	21	.	.	.
22283	344	1	Both	both	DT
22283	344	2	theories	theory	NNS
22283	344	3	are	be	VBP
22283	344	4	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	344	5	,	,	,
22283	344	6	and	and	CC
22283	344	7	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	344	8	agree	agree	VBP
22283	344	9	in	in	IN
22283	344	10	holding	hold	VBG
22283	344	11	that	that	IN
22283	344	12	there	there	EX
22283	344	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	344	14	causation	causation	NN
22283	344	15	as	as	IN
22283	344	16	between	between	IN
22283	344	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	344	18	and	and	CC
22283	344	19	motion	motion	NN
22283	344	20	:	:	:
22283	344	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	344	22	differ	differ	VBP
22283	344	23	only	only	RB
22283	344	24	in	in	IN
22283	344	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	344	26	teaching	teaching	NN
22283	344	27	as	as	IN
22283	344	28	to	to	IN
22283	344	29	the	the	DT
22283	344	30	direction	direction	NN
22283	344	31	in	in	IN
22283	344	32	which	which	WDT
22283	344	33	the	the	DT
22283	344	34	causation	causation	NN
22283	344	35	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
22283	344	36	.	.	.
22283	345	1	Of	of	RB
22283	345	2	course	course	RB
22283	345	3	,	,	,
22283	345	4	out	out	IN
22283	345	5	of	of	IN
22283	345	6	this	this	DT
22283	345	7	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	345	8	difference	difference	NN
22283	345	9	there	there	RB
22283	345	10	arise	arise	VBP
22283	345	11	many	many	JJ
22283	345	12	secondary	secondary	JJ
22283	345	13	differences	difference	NNS
22283	345	14	.	.	.
22283	346	1	The	the	DT
22283	346	2	most	most	RBS
22283	346	3	important	important	JJ
22283	346	4	of	of	IN
22283	346	5	these	these	DT
22283	346	6	secondary	secondary	JJ
22283	346	7	differences	difference	NNS
22283	346	8	has	have	VBZ
22283	346	9	reference	reference	NN
22283	346	10	to	to	IN
22283	346	11	the	the	DT
22283	346	12	nature	nature	NN
22283	346	13	of	of	IN
22283	346	14	the	the	DT
22283	346	15	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	346	16	or	or	CC
22283	346	17	self	self	NN
22283	346	18	-	-	HYPH
22283	346	19	existing	exist	VBG
22283	346	20	substance	substance	NN
22283	346	21	.	.	.
22283	347	1	Both	both	DT
22283	347	2	theories	theory	NNS
22283	347	3	agree	agree	VBP
22283	347	4	that	that	IN
22283	347	5	there	there	EX
22283	347	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	347	7	such	such	PDT
22283	347	8	a	a	DT
22283	347	9	substance	substance	NN
22283	347	10	;	;	:
22283	347	11	but	but	CC
22283	347	12	on	on	IN
22283	347	13	the	the	DT
22283	347	14	question	question	NN
22283	347	15	whether	whether	IN
22283	347	16	this	this	DT
22283	347	17	substance	substance	NN
22283	347	18	be	be	VB
22283	347	19	mental	mental	JJ
22283	347	20	or	or	CC
22283	347	21	material	material	JJ
22283	347	22	,	,	,
22283	347	23	the	the	DT
22283	347	24	two	two	CD
22283	347	25	theories	theory	NNS
22283	347	26	give	give	VBP
22283	347	27	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
22283	347	28	answers	answer	NNS
22283	347	29	,	,	,
22283	347	30	and	and	CC
22283	347	31	logically	logically	RB
22283	347	32	so	so	RB
22283	347	33	.	.	.
22283	348	1	For	for	IN
22283	348	2	,	,	,
22283	348	3	if	if	IN
22283	348	4	mind	mind	NN
22283	348	5	as	as	IN
22283	348	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	348	7	directly	directly	RB
22283	348	8	know	know	VBP
22283	348	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	348	10	(	(	-LRB-
22283	348	11	namely	namely	RB
22283	348	12	,	,	,
22283	348	13	in	in	IN
22283	348	14	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	348	15	)	)	-RRB-
22283	348	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	348	17	taken	take	VBN
22283	348	18	to	to	TO
22283	348	19	be	be	VB
22283	348	20	a	a	DT
22283	348	21	cause	cause	NN
22283	348	22	of	of	IN
22283	348	23	motion	motion	NN
22283	348	24	,	,	,
22283	348	25	within	within	IN
22283	348	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	348	27	experience	experience	NN
22283	348	28	mind	mind	NN
22283	348	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	348	30	accredited	accredit	VBN
22283	348	31	with	with	IN
22283	348	32	priority	priority	NN
22283	348	33	;	;	:
22283	348	34	and	and	CC
22283	348	35	hence	hence	RB
22283	348	36	the	the	DT
22283	348	37	inference	inference	NN
22283	348	38	that	that	IN
22283	348	39	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	348	40	,	,	,
22283	348	41	or	or	CC
22283	348	42	universally	universally	RB
22283	348	43	,	,	,
22283	348	44	mind	mind	NN
22283	348	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	348	46	prior	prior	RB
22283	348	47	to	to	IN
22283	348	48	motion	motion	NN
22283	348	49	.	.	.
22283	349	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
22283	349	2	,	,	,
22283	349	3	as	as	IN
22283	349	4	motion	motion	NN
22283	349	5	can	can	MD
22283	349	6	not	not	RB
22283	349	7	take	take	VB
22283	349	8	place	place	NN
22283	349	9	without	without	IN
22283	349	10	something	something	NN
22283	349	11	which	which	WDT
22283	349	12	moves	move	VBZ
22283	349	13	,	,	,
22283	349	14	this	this	DT
22283	349	15	something	something	NN
22283	349	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	349	17	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	349	18	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	349	19	to	to	TO
22283	349	20	have	have	VB
22283	349	21	been	be	VBN
22283	349	22	the	the	DT
22283	349	23	result	result	NN
22283	349	24	of	of	IN
22283	349	25	mind	mind	NN
22283	349	26	:	:	:
22283	349	27	hence	hence	RB
22283	349	28	the	the	DT
22283	349	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	349	30	of	of	IN
22283	349	31	the	the	DT
22283	349	32	creation	creation	NN
22283	349	33	by	by	IN
22283	349	34	mind	mind	NN
22283	349	35	both	both	DT
22283	349	36	of	of	IN
22283	349	37	matter	matter	NN
22283	349	38	and	and	CC
22283	349	39	of	of	IN
22283	349	40	energy	energy	NN
22283	349	41	.	.	.
22283	350	1	On	on	IN
22283	350	2	the	the	DT
22283	350	3	other	other	JJ
22283	350	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	350	5	,	,	,
22283	350	6	the	the	DT
22283	350	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	350	8	of	of	IN
22283	350	9	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	350	10	,	,	,
22283	350	11	by	by	IN
22283	350	12	refusing	refuse	VBG
22283	350	13	to	to	TO
22283	350	14	assign	assign	VB
22283	350	15	priority	priority	NN
22283	350	16	to	to	IN
22283	350	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	350	18	as	as	IN
22283	350	19	known	know	VBN
22283	350	20	directly	directly	RB
22283	350	21	in	in	IN
22283	350	22	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	350	23	,	,	,
22283	350	24	naturally	naturally	RB
22283	350	25	concludes	conclude	VBZ
22283	350	26	that	that	DT
22283	350	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	350	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	350	29	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	350	30	,	,	,
22283	350	31	or	or	CC
22283	350	32	universally	universally	RB
22283	350	33	,	,	,
22283	350	34	the	the	DT
22283	350	35	result	result	NN
22283	350	36	of	of	IN
22283	350	37	matter	matter	NN
22283	350	38	in	in	IN
22283	350	39	motion	motion	NN
22283	350	40	--	--	:
22283	350	41	in	in	IN
22283	350	42	other	other	JJ
22283	350	43	words	word	NNS
22283	350	44	,	,	,
22283	350	45	that	that	DT
22283	350	46	matter	matter	NN
22283	350	47	in	in	IN
22283	350	48	motion	motion	NN
22283	350	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	350	50	the	the	DT
22283	350	51	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	350	52	or	or	CC
22283	350	53	self	self	NN
22283	350	54	-	-	HYPH
22283	350	55	existing	exist	VBG
22283	350	56	substance	substance	NN
22283	350	57	,	,	,
22283	350	58	and	and	CC
22283	350	59	,	,	,
22283	350	60	as	as	IN
22283	350	61	such	such	JJ
22283	350	62	,	,	,
22283	350	63	the	the	DT
22283	350	64	cause	cause	NN
22283	350	65	of	of	IN
22283	350	66	mind	mind	NN
22283	350	67	wherever	wherever	WRB
22283	350	68	mind	mind	NN
22283	350	69	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	350	70	.	.	.
22283	351	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	351	2	may	may	MD
22283	351	3	observe	observe	VB
22283	351	4	,	,	,
22283	351	5	in	in	IN
22283	351	6	passing	pass	VBG
22283	351	7	,	,	,
22283	351	8	that	that	IN
22283	351	9	although	although	IN
22283	351	10	this	this	DT
22283	351	11	cosmical	cosmical	JJ
22283	351	12	deduction	deduction	NN
22283	351	13	from	from	IN
22283	351	14	the	the	DT
22283	351	15	theory	theory	NN
22283	351	16	of	of	IN
22283	351	17	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	351	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	351	19	,	,	,
22283	351	20	as	as	IN
22283	351	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	351	22	have	have	VBP
22283	351	23	said	say	VBD
22283	351	24	,	,	,
22283	351	25	natural	natural	JJ
22283	351	26	,	,	,
22283	351	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	351	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	351	29	not	not	RB
22283	351	30	(	(	-LRB-
22283	351	31	as	as	IN
22283	351	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	351	33	the	the	DT
22283	351	34	case	case	NN
22283	351	35	with	with	IN
22283	351	36	the	the	DT
22283	351	37	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	351	38	deduction	deduction	NN
22283	351	39	from	from	IN
22283	351	40	the	the	DT
22283	351	41	theory	theory	NN
22283	351	42	of	of	IN
22283	351	43	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	351	44	)	)	-RRB-
22283	351	45	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
22283	351	46	.	.	.
22283	352	1	For	for	IN
22283	352	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	352	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	352	4	logically	logically	RB
22283	352	5	possible	possible	JJ
22283	352	6	that	that	IN
22283	352	7	even	even	RB
22283	352	8	though	though	IN
22283	352	9	all	all	DT
22283	352	10	known	know	VBN
22283	352	11	minds	mind	NNS
22283	352	12	be	be	VB
22283	352	13	the	the	DT
22283	352	14	results	result	NNS
22283	352	15	of	of	IN
22283	352	16	matter	matter	NN
22283	352	17	in	in	IN
22283	352	18	motion	motion	NN
22283	352	19	,	,	,
22283	352	20	matter	matter	NN
22283	352	21	in	in	IN
22283	352	22	motion	motion	NN
22283	352	23	may	may	MD
22283	352	24	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	352	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	352	26	be	be	VB
22283	352	27	the	the	DT
22283	352	28	result	result	NN
22283	352	29	of	of	IN
22283	352	30	an	an	DT
22283	352	31	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	352	32	mind	mind	NN
22283	352	33	.	.	.
22283	353	1	This	this	DT
22283	353	2	,	,	,
22283	353	3	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	353	4	,	,	,
22283	353	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	353	6	the	the	DT
22283	353	7	position	position	NN
22283	353	8	virtually	virtually	RB
22283	353	9	adopted	adopt	VBN
22283	353	10	by	by	IN
22283	353	11	Locke	Locke	NNP
22283	353	12	in	in	IN
22283	353	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	353	14	celebrated	celebrated	JJ
22283	353	15	controversy	controversy	NN
22283	353	16	with	with	IN
22283	353	17	the	the	DT
22283	353	18	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
22283	353	19	of	of	IN
22283	353	20	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
22283	353	21	.	.	.
22283	354	1	Having	have	VBG
22283	354	2	been	be	VBN
22283	354	3	taken	take	VBN
22283	354	4	to	to	IN
22283	354	5	task	task	NN
22283	354	6	by	by	IN
22283	354	7	this	this	DT
22283	354	8	divine	divine	JJ
22283	354	9	for	for	IN
22283	354	10	the	the	DT
22283	354	11	materialistic	materialistic	JJ
22283	354	12	tendency	tendency	NN
22283	354	13	of	of	IN
22283	354	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	354	15	writings	writing	NNS
22283	354	16	,	,	,
22283	354	17	Locke	Locke	NNP
22283	354	18	defends	defend	VBZ
22283	354	19	himself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	354	20	by	by	IN
22283	354	21	denying	deny	VBG
22283	354	22	the	the	DT
22283	354	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	354	24	character	character	NN
22283	354	25	of	of	IN
22283	354	26	the	the	DT
22283	354	27	deduction	deduction	NN
22283	354	28	which	which	WDT
22283	354	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	354	30	are	be	VBP
22283	354	31	now	now	RB
22283	354	32	considering	consider	VBG
22283	354	33	.	.	.
22283	355	1	For	for	IN
22283	355	2	example	example	NN
22283	355	3	,	,	,
22283	355	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	5	insists	insist	VBZ
22283	355	6	,	,	,
22283	355	7	'	'	''
22283	355	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	9	see	see	VBP
22283	355	10	no	no	DT
22283	355	11	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	355	12	in	in	IN
22283	355	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	14	that	that	WDT
22283	355	15	the	the	DT
22283	355	16	first	first	JJ
22283	355	17	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	355	18	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	355	19	being	be	VBG
22283	355	20	should	should	MD
22283	355	21	,	,	,
22283	355	22	if	if	IN
22283	355	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	24	pleased	please	VBD
22283	355	25	,	,	,
22283	355	26	give	give	VB
22283	355	27	to	to	IN
22283	355	28	certain	certain	JJ
22283	355	29	systems	system	NNS
22283	355	30	of	of	IN
22283	355	31	created	create	VBN
22283	355	32	senseless	senseless	JJ
22283	355	33	matter	matter	NN
22283	355	34	,	,	,
22283	355	35	put	put	VBN
22283	355	36	together	together	RB
22283	355	37	as	as	IN
22283	355	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	39	thinks	think	VBZ
22283	355	40	fit	fit	JJ
22283	355	41	,	,	,
22283	355	42	some	some	DT
22283	355	43	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	355	44	of	of	IN
22283	355	45	sense	sense	NN
22283	355	46	,	,	,
22283	355	47	perception	perception	NN
22283	355	48	,	,	,
22283	355	49	and	and	CC
22283	355	50	thought	think	VBD
22283	355	51	:	:	:
22283	355	52	though	though	IN
22283	355	53	,	,	,
22283	355	54	as	as	IN
22283	355	55	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	56	think	think	VBP
22283	355	57	,	,	,
22283	355	58	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	355	59	have	have	VBP
22283	355	60	proved	prove	VBN
22283	355	61	(	(	-LRB-
22283	355	62	lib	lib	NNP
22283	355	63	.	.	.
22283	356	1	IV	IV	NNP
22283	356	2	,	,	,
22283	356	3	ch	ch	NN
22283	356	4	.	.	.
22283	357	1	10	10	CD
22283	357	2	and	and	CC
22283	357	3	14	14	CD
22283	357	4	&	&	CC
22283	357	5	c.	c.	NNP
22283	357	6	)	)	-RRB-
22283	357	7	,	,	,
22283	357	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	357	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	357	10	no	no	RB
22283	357	11	less	less	JJR
22283	357	12	than	than	IN
22283	357	13	a	a	DT
22283	357	14	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	357	15	to	to	TO
22283	357	16	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	357	17	matter	matter	NN
22283	357	18	(	(	-LRB-
22283	357	19	which	which	WDT
22283	357	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	357	21	evidently	evidently	RB
22283	357	22	in	in	IN
22283	357	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	357	24	own	own	JJ
22283	357	25	nature	nature	NN
22283	357	26	void	void	NN
22283	357	27	of	of	IN
22283	357	28	sense	sense	NN
22283	357	29	and	and	CC
22283	357	30	thought	thought	NN
22283	357	31	)	)	-RRB-
22283	357	32	should	should	MD
22283	357	33	be	be	VB
22283	357	34	that	that	RB
22283	357	35	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	357	36	first	first	JJ
22283	357	37	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	357	38	being	being	NN
22283	357	39	.	.	.
22283	357	40	'	'	''
22283	358	1	Under	under	IN
22283	358	2	this	this	DT
22283	358	3	view	view	NN
22283	358	4	,	,	,
22283	358	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	358	6	will	will	MD
22283	358	7	be	be	VB
22283	358	8	observed	observe	VBN
22283	358	9	,	,	,
22283	358	10	mind	mind	NN
22283	358	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	358	12	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	358	13	to	to	TO
22283	358	14	have	have	VB
22283	358	15	the	the	DT
22283	358	16	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	358	17	priority	priority	NN
22283	358	18	,	,	,
22283	358	19	and	and	CC
22283	358	20	thus	thus	RB
22283	358	21	to	to	TO
22283	358	22	have	have	VB
22283	358	23	been	be	VBN
22283	358	24	the	the	DT
22283	358	25	original	original	JJ
22283	358	26	or	or	CC
22283	358	27	creating	create	VBG
22283	358	28	cause	cause	NN
22283	358	29	of	of	IN
22283	358	30	matter	matter	NN
22283	358	31	in	in	IN
22283	358	32	motion	motion	NN
22283	358	33	,	,	,
22283	358	34	which	which	WDT
22283	358	35	,	,	,
22283	358	36	in	in	IN
22283	358	37	turn	turn	NN
22283	358	38	,	,	,
22283	358	39	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	358	40	the	the	DT
22283	358	41	cause	cause	NN
22283	358	42	(	(	-LRB-
22283	358	43	or	or	CC
22283	358	44	,	,	,
22283	358	45	at	at	IN
22283	358	46	least	least	JJS
22283	358	47	,	,	,
22283	358	48	the	the	DT
22283	358	49	conditional	conditional	JJ
22283	358	50	condition	condition	NN
22283	358	51	)	)	-RRB-
22283	358	52	of	of	IN
22283	358	53	mind	mind	NN
22283	358	54	of	of	IN
22283	358	55	a	a	DT
22283	358	56	lower	low	JJR
22283	358	57	order	order	NN
22283	358	58	.	.	.
22283	359	1	This	this	DT
22283	359	2	view	view	NN
22283	359	3	,	,	,
22283	359	4	however	however	RB
22283	359	5	,	,	,
22283	359	6	need	nee	MD
22283	359	7	not	not	RB
22283	359	8	detain	detain	VB
22283	359	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	359	10	,	,	,
22283	359	11	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
22283	359	12	as	as	IN
22283	359	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	359	14	can	can	MD
22283	359	15	only	only	RB
22283	359	16	be	be	VB
22283	359	17	held	hold	VBN
22283	359	18	by	by	IN
22283	359	19	those	those	DT
22283	359	20	who	who	WP
22283	359	21	,	,	,
22283	359	22	on	on	IN
22283	359	23	grounds	ground	NNS
22283	359	24	independent	independent	JJ
22283	359	25	of	of	IN
22283	359	26	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	359	27	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	359	28	,	,	,
22283	359	29	already	already	RB
22283	359	30	believe	believe	VB
22283	359	31	in	in	IN
22283	359	32	mind	mind	NN
22283	359	33	as	as	IN
22283	359	34	the	the	DT
22283	359	35	First	first	JJ
22283	359	36	Cause	Cause	NNP
22283	359	37	or	or	CC
22283	359	38	Eternal	Eternal	NNP
22283	359	39	Being	Being	NNP
22283	359	40	:	:	:
22283	359	41	this	this	DT
22283	359	42	belief	belief	NN
22283	359	43	granted	grant	VBD
22283	359	44	,	,	,
22283	359	45	there	there	EX
22283	359	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	359	47	,	,	,
22283	359	48	of	of	IN
22283	359	49	course	course	NN
22283	359	50	,	,	,
22283	359	51	an	an	DT
22283	359	52	end	end	NN
22283	359	53	of	of	IN
22283	359	54	any	any	DT
22283	359	55	question	question	NN
22283	359	56	as	as	IN
22283	359	57	between	between	IN
22283	359	58	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	359	59	and	and	CC
22283	359	60	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	359	61	.	.	.
22283	360	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	360	2	have	have	VBP
22283	360	3	,	,	,
22283	360	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	360	5	,	,	,
22283	360	6	only	only	RB
22283	360	7	mentioned	mention	VBD
22283	360	8	this	this	DT
22283	360	9	possible	possible	JJ
22283	360	10	phase	phase	NN
22283	360	11	of	of	IN
22283	360	12	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	360	13	theory	theory	NN
22283	360	14	,	,	,
22283	360	15	in	in	IN
22283	360	16	order	order	NN
22283	360	17	to	to	TO
22283	360	18	show	show	VB
22283	360	19	that	that	IN
22283	360	20	the	the	DT
22283	360	21	theory	theory	NN
22283	360	22	of	of	IN
22283	360	23	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	360	24	as	as	IN
22283	360	25	applied	apply	VBN
22283	360	26	to	to	IN
22283	360	27	a	a	DT
22283	360	28	human	human	JJ
22283	360	29	being	being	NN
22283	360	30	does	do	VBZ
22283	360	31	not	not	RB
22283	360	32	_	_	VB
22283	360	33	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	360	34	_	_	NNP
22283	360	35	involve	involve	VBP
22283	360	36	an	an	DT
22283	360	37	extension	extension	NN
22283	360	38	of	of	IN
22283	360	39	that	that	DT
22283	360	40	theory	theory	NN
22283	360	41	to	to	IN
22283	360	42	the	the	DT
22283	360	43	cosmos	cosmo	NNS
22283	360	44	.	.	.
22283	361	1	But	but	CC
22283	361	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	361	3	hold	hold	VBP
22283	361	4	this	this	DT
22283	361	5	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	361	6	as	as	IN
22283	361	7	of	of	IN
22283	361	8	no	no	DT
22283	361	9	practical	practical	JJ
22283	361	10	value	value	NN
22283	361	11	:	:	:
22283	361	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	361	13	merely	merely	RB
22283	361	14	indicates	indicate	VBZ
22283	361	15	a	a	DT
22283	361	16	logical	logical	JJ
22283	361	17	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	361	18	which	which	WDT
22283	361	19	no	no	DT
22283	361	20	one	one	PRP
22283	361	21	would	would	MD
22283	361	22	be	be	VB
22283	361	23	likely	likely	JJ
22283	361	24	to	to	TO
22283	361	25	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	361	26	except	except	IN
22283	361	27	on	on	IN
22283	361	28	grounds	ground	NNS
22283	361	29	independent	independent	JJ
22283	361	30	of	of	IN
22283	361	31	those	those	DT
22283	361	32	upon	upon	IN
22283	361	33	which	which	WDT
22283	361	34	the	the	DT
22283	361	35	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	361	36	dispute	dispute	NN
22283	361	37	between	between	IN
22283	361	38	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	361	39	and	and	CC
22283	361	40	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	361	41	must	must	MD
22283	361	42	be	be	VB
22283	361	43	confined	confine	VBN
22283	361	44	.	.	.
22283	362	1	Of	of	IN
22283	362	2	more	more	JJR
22283	362	3	practical	practical	JJ
22283	362	4	importance	importance	NN
22283	362	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	362	6	the	the	DT
22283	362	7	remark	remark	NN
22283	362	8	already	already	RB
22283	362	9	made	make	VBN
22283	362	10	,	,	,
22283	362	11	namely	namely	RB
22283	362	12	,	,	,
22283	362	13	that	that	IN
22283	362	14	the	the	DT
22283	362	15	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	362	16	or	or	CC
22283	362	17	diagnostic	diagnostic	JJ
22283	362	18	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	362	19	between	between	IN
22283	362	20	these	these	DT
22283	362	21	two	two	CD
22283	362	22	species	specie	NNS
22283	362	23	of	of	IN
22283	362	24	theory	theory	NN
22283	362	25	consists	consist	VBZ
22283	362	26	_	_	NNP
22283	362	27	only	only	RB
22283	362	28	_	_	NNP
22283	362	29	in	in	IN
22283	362	30	the	the	DT
22283	362	31	views	view	NNS
22283	362	32	which	which	WDT
22283	362	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	362	34	severally	severally	RB
22283	362	35	take	take	VBP
22283	362	36	on	on	RP
22283	362	37	the	the	DT
22283	362	38	question	question	NN
22283	362	39	of	of	IN
22283	362	40	causality	causality	NN
22283	362	41	.	.	.
22283	363	1	This	this	DT
22283	363	2	remark	remark	NN
22283	363	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	363	4	of	of	IN
22283	363	5	practical	practical	JJ
22283	363	6	importance	importance	NN
22283	363	7	,	,	,
22283	363	8	because	because	IN
22283	363	9	in	in	IN
22283	363	10	the	the	DT
22283	363	11	debate	debate	NN
22283	363	12	between	between	IN
22283	363	13	spiritualists	spiritualist	NNS
22283	363	14	and	and	CC
22283	363	15	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	363	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	363	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	363	18	often	often	RB
22283	363	19	lost	lose	VBN
22283	363	20	sight	sight	NN
22283	363	21	of	of	IN
22283	363	22	:	:	:
22283	363	23	nay	nay	NNP
22283	363	24	,	,	,
22283	363	25	in	in	IN
22283	363	26	some	some	DT
22283	363	27	cases	case	NNS
22283	363	28	,	,	,
22283	363	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	363	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	363	31	even	even	RB
22283	363	32	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	363	33	ignored	ignore	VBN
22283	363	34	.	.	.
22283	364	1	Obviously	obviously	RB
22283	364	2	,	,	,
22283	364	3	when	when	WRB
22283	364	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	364	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	364	6	either	either	CC
22283	364	7	intentionally	intentionally	RB
22283	364	8	or	or	CC
22283	364	9	unintentionally	unintentionally	RB
22283	364	10	disregarded	disregard	VBN
22283	364	11	,	,	,
22283	364	12	the	the	DT
22283	364	13	debate	debate	NN
22283	364	14	ceases	cease	VBZ
22283	364	15	to	to	TO
22283	364	16	be	be	VB
22283	364	17	directed	direct	VBN
22283	364	18	to	to	IN
22283	364	19	the	the	DT
22283	364	20	question	question	NN
22283	364	21	under	under	IN
22283	364	22	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	364	23	,	,	,
22283	364	24	and	and	CC
22283	364	25	may	may	MD
22283	364	26	then	then	RB
22283	364	27	wander	wander	VB
22283	364	28	aimlessly	aimlessly	RB
22283	364	29	over	over	IN
22283	364	30	the	the	DT
22283	364	31	whole	whole	JJ
22283	364	32	field	field	NN
22283	364	33	of	of	IN
22283	364	34	collateral	collateral	JJ
22283	364	35	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	364	36	.	.	.
22283	365	1	Throughout	throughout	IN
22283	365	2	the	the	DT
22283	365	3	present	present	JJ
22283	365	4	essay	essay	NN
22283	365	5	,	,	,
22283	365	6	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	365	7	,	,	,
22283	365	8	the	the	DT
22283	365	9	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	365	10	will	will	MD
22283	365	11	be	be	VB
22283	365	12	restricted	restrict	VBN
22283	365	13	to	to	IN
22283	365	14	the	the	DT
22283	365	15	only	only	JJ
22283	365	16	topic	topic	NN
22283	365	17	which	which	WDT
22283	365	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	365	19	have	have	VBP
22283	365	20	to	to	TO
22283	365	21	discuss	discuss	VB
22283	365	22	--	--	:
22283	365	23	namely	namely	RB
22283	365	24	,	,	,
22283	365	25	whether	whether	IN
22283	365	26	mind	mind	NN
22283	365	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	365	28	the	the	DT
22283	365	29	cause	cause	NN
22283	365	30	of	of	IN
22283	365	31	motion	motion	NN
22283	365	32	,	,	,
22283	365	33	motion	motion	NN
22283	365	34	the	the	DT
22283	365	35	cause	cause	NN
22283	365	36	of	of	IN
22283	365	37	mind	mind	NN
22283	365	38	,	,	,
22283	365	39	or	or	CC
22283	365	40	neither	neither	CC
22283	365	41	the	the	DT
22283	365	42	cause	cause	NN
22283	365	43	of	of	IN
22283	365	44	the	the	DT
22283	365	45	other	other	JJ
22283	365	46	.	.	.
22283	366	1	The	the	DT
22283	366	2	view	view	NN
22283	366	3	to	to	TO
22283	366	4	be	be	VB
22283	366	5	first	first	RB
22283	366	6	considered	consider	VBN
22283	366	7	--	--	:
22283	366	8	namely	namely	RB
22283	366	9	,	,	,
22283	366	10	that	that	DT
22283	366	11	mind	mind	NN
22283	366	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	366	13	the	the	DT
22283	366	14	cause	cause	NN
22283	366	15	of	of	IN
22283	366	16	motion	motion	NN
22283	366	17	--	--	:
22283	366	18	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	366	19	has	have	VBZ
22283	366	20	one	one	CD
22283	366	21	great	great	JJ
22283	366	22	advantage	advantage	NN
22283	366	23	over	over	IN
22283	366	24	the	the	DT
22283	366	25	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	366	26	view	view	NN
22283	366	27	:	:	:
22283	366	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	366	29	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	366	30	the	the	DT
22283	366	31	causality	causality	NN
22283	366	32	to	to	TO
22283	366	33	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	366	34	from	from	IN
22283	366	35	that	that	DT
22283	366	36	which	which	WDT
22283	366	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	366	38	the	the	DT
22283	366	39	source	source	NN
22283	366	40	of	of	IN
22283	366	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	366	42	idea	idea	NN
22283	366	43	of	of	IN
22283	366	44	causality	causality	NN
22283	366	45	(	(	-LRB-
22283	366	46	the	the	DT
22283	366	47	mind	mind	NN
22283	366	48	)	)	-RRB-
22283	366	49	;	;	:
22283	366	50	not	not	RB
22283	366	51	from	from	IN
22283	366	52	that	that	DT
22283	366	53	into	into	IN
22283	366	54	which	which	WDT
22283	366	55	this	this	DT
22283	366	56	idea	idea	NN
22283	366	57	has	have	VBZ
22283	366	58	been	be	VBN
22283	366	59	read	read	VBN
22283	366	60	by	by	IN
22283	366	61	the	the	DT
22283	366	62	mind	mind	NN
22283	366	63	.	.	.
22283	367	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	367	2	,	,	,
22283	367	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	367	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	367	5	so	so	RB
22283	367	6	far	far	RB
22283	367	7	less	less	RBR
22283	367	8	difficult	difficult	JJ
22283	367	9	to	to	TO
22283	367	10	imagine	imagine	VB
22283	367	11	that	that	IN
22283	367	12	mental	mental	JJ
22283	367	13	changes	change	NNS
22283	367	14	are	be	VBP
22283	367	15	the	the	DT
22283	367	16	cause	cause	NN
22283	367	17	of	of	IN
22283	367	18	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	367	19	changes	change	NNS
22283	367	20	than	than	IN
22283	367	21	_	_	NNP
22283	367	22	vice	vice	NN
22283	367	23	versa	versa	IN
22283	367	24	_	_	NNP
22283	367	25	;	;	:
22283	367	26	for	for	IN
22283	367	27	upon	upon	IN
22283	367	28	this	this	DT
22283	367	29	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	367	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	367	31	are	be	VBP
22283	367	32	starting	start	VBG
22283	367	33	at	at	IN
22283	367	34	least	least	JJS
22283	367	35	from	from	IN
22283	367	36	the	the	DT
22283	367	37	substance	substance	NN
22283	367	38	of	of	IN
22283	367	39	immediate	immediate	JJ
22283	367	40	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	367	41	,	,	,
22283	367	42	and	and	CC
22283	367	43	not	not	RB
22283	367	44	from	from	IN
22283	367	45	the	the	DT
22283	367	46	reflection	reflection	NN
22283	367	47	of	of	IN
22283	367	48	that	that	DT
22283	367	49	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	367	50	in	in	IN
22283	367	51	what	what	WP
22283	367	52	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	367	53	call	call	VBP
22283	367	54	the	the	DT
22283	367	55	external	external	JJ
22283	367	56	world	world	NN
22283	367	57	.	.	.
22283	368	1	On	on	IN
22283	368	2	the	the	DT
22283	368	3	other	other	JJ
22283	368	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	368	5	,	,	,
22283	368	6	the	the	DT
22283	368	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	368	8	of	of	IN
22283	368	9	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	368	10	labours	labour	VBZ
22283	368	11	under	under	IN
22283	368	12	certain	certain	JJ
22283	368	13	speculative	speculative	JJ
22283	368	14	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	368	15	which	which	WDT
22283	368	16	appear	appear	VBP
22283	368	17	to	to	IN
22283	368	18	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	368	19	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
22283	368	20	.	.	.
22283	369	1	The	the	DT
22283	369	2	most	most	RBS
22283	369	3	formidable	formidable	JJ
22283	369	4	of	of	IN
22283	369	5	these	these	DT
22283	369	6	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	369	7	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	369	8	from	from	IN
22283	369	9	the	the	DT
22283	369	10	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
22283	369	11	collision	collision	NN
22283	369	12	of	of	IN
22283	369	13	the	the	DT
22283	369	14	theory	theory	NN
22283	369	15	with	with	IN
22283	369	16	the	the	DT
22283	369	17	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	369	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	369	19	of	of	IN
22283	369	20	the	the	DT
22283	369	21	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	369	22	of	of	IN
22283	369	23	energy	energy	NN
22283	369	24	.	.	.
22283	370	1	Whether	whether	IN
22283	370	2	or	or	CC
22283	370	3	not	not	RB
22283	370	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	370	5	adopt	adopt	VBP
22283	370	6	the	the	DT
22283	370	7	view	view	NN
22283	370	8	that	that	IN
22283	370	9	all	all	DT
22283	370	10	causation	causation	NN
22283	370	11	of	of	IN
22283	370	12	a	a	DT
22283	370	13	physical	physical	JJ
22283	370	14	kind	kind	NN
22283	370	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	370	16	ultimately	ultimately	RB
22283	370	17	an	an	DT
22283	370	18	expression	expression	NN
22283	370	19	of	of	IN
22283	370	20	the	the	DT
22283	370	21	fact	fact	NN
22283	370	22	that	that	IN
22283	370	23	matter	matter	NN
22283	370	24	and	and	CC
22283	370	25	energy	energy	NN
22283	370	26	are	be	VBP
22283	370	27	indestructible[3	indestructible[3	NNPS
22283	370	28	]	]	-RRB-
22283	370	29	,	,	,
22283	370	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	370	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	370	32	equally	equally	RB
22283	370	33	certain	certain	JJ
22283	370	34	that	that	IN
22283	370	35	this	this	DT
22283	370	36	indestructibility	indestructibility	NN
22283	370	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	370	38	a	a	DT
22283	370	39	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	370	40	condition	condition	NN
22283	370	41	to	to	IN
22283	370	42	the	the	DT
22283	370	43	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	370	44	of	of	IN
22283	370	45	causation	causation	NN
22283	370	46	as	as	IN
22283	370	47	natural	natural	JJ
22283	370	48	.	.	.
22283	371	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	371	2	,	,	,
22283	371	3	if	if	IN
22283	371	4	the	the	DT
22283	371	5	mind	mind	NN
22283	371	6	of	of	IN
22283	371	7	man	man	NN
22283	371	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	371	9	capable	capable	JJ
22283	371	10	of	of	IN
22283	371	11	breaking	break	VBG
22283	371	12	in	in	RP
22283	371	13	as	as	IN
22283	371	14	an	an	DT
22283	371	15	independent	independent	JJ
22283	371	16	cause	cause	NN
22283	371	17	upon	upon	IN
22283	371	18	the	the	DT
22283	371	19	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	371	20	uniform	uniform	JJ
22283	371	21	system	system	NN
22283	371	22	of	of	IN
22283	371	23	natural	natural	JJ
22283	371	24	causation	causation	NN
22283	371	25	,	,	,
22283	371	26	the	the	DT
22283	371	27	only	only	JJ
22283	371	28	way	way	NN
22283	371	29	in	in	IN
22283	371	30	which	which	WDT
22283	371	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	371	32	could	could	MD
22283	371	33	do	do	VB
22283	371	34	so	so	RB
22283	371	35	would	would	MD
22283	371	36	be	be	VB
22283	371	37	by	by	IN
22283	371	38	either	either	CC
22283	371	39	destroying	destroy	VBG
22283	371	40	or	or	CC
22283	371	41	creating	create	VBG
22283	371	42	certain	certain	JJ
22283	371	43	_	_	NNP
22283	371	44	quanta	quanta	NNP
22283	371	45	_	_	NNP
22283	371	46	of	of	IN
22283	371	47	either	either	DT
22283	371	48	matter	matter	NN
22283	371	49	or	or	CC
22283	371	50	energy	energy	NN
22283	371	51	or	or	CC
22283	371	52	both	both	DT
22283	371	53	.	.	.
22283	372	1	But	but	CC
22283	372	2	to	to	TO
22283	372	3	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	372	4	the	the	DT
22283	372	5	mind	mind	NN
22283	372	6	capable	capable	JJ
22283	372	7	of	of	IN
22283	372	8	doing	do	VBG
22283	372	9	any	any	DT
22283	372	10	of	of	IN
22283	372	11	these	these	DT
22283	372	12	things	thing	NNS
22283	372	13	would	would	MD
22283	372	14	be	be	VB
22283	372	15	to	to	TO
22283	372	16	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	372	17	that	that	IN
22283	372	18	the	the	DT
22283	372	19	mind	mind	NN
22283	372	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	372	21	a	a	DT
22283	372	22	cause	cause	NN
22283	372	23	in	in	IN
22283	372	24	some	some	DT
22283	372	25	other	other	JJ
22283	372	26	sense	sense	NN
22283	372	27	than	than	IN
22283	372	28	a	a	DT
22283	372	29	physical	physical	NN
22283	372	30	or	or	CC
22283	372	31	a	a	DT
22283	372	32	natural	natural	JJ
22283	372	33	cause	cause	NN
22283	372	34	;	;	:
22283	372	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	372	36	would	would	MD
22283	372	37	be	be	VB
22283	372	38	to	to	TO
22283	372	39	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	372	40	that	that	IN
22283	372	41	the	the	DT
22283	372	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	372	43	is	be	VBZ
22283	372	44	a	a	DT
22283	372	45	super	super	JJ
22283	372	46	-	-	JJ
22283	372	47	natural	natural	JJ
22283	372	48	cause	cause	NN
22283	372	49	,	,	,
22283	372	50	or	or	CC
22283	372	51	,	,	,
22283	372	52	more	more	RBR
22283	372	53	plainly	plainly	RB
22283	372	54	,	,	,
22283	372	55	that	that	IN
22283	372	56	all	all	DT
22283	372	57	mental	mental	JJ
22283	372	58	activity	activity	NN
22283	372	59	,	,	,
22283	372	60	so	so	RB
22283	372	61	far	far	RB
22283	372	62	as	as	IN
22283	372	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	372	64	is	be	VBZ
22283	372	65	an	an	DT
22283	372	66	efficient	efficient	JJ
22283	372	67	cause	cause	NN
22283	372	68	of	of	IN
22283	372	69	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	372	70	movement	movement	NN
22283	372	71	,	,	,
22283	372	72	is	be	VBZ
22283	372	73	of	of	IN
22283	372	74	the	the	DT
22283	372	75	nature	nature	NN
22283	372	76	of	of	IN
22283	372	77	a	a	DT
22283	372	78	miracle	miracle	NN
22283	372	79	.	.	.
22283	373	1	This	this	DT
22283	373	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	373	3	,	,	,
22283	373	4	which	which	WDT
22283	373	5	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	373	6	to	to	IN
22283	373	7	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	373	8	unavoidably	unavoidably	RB
22283	373	9	implicated	implicate	VBN
22283	373	10	in	in	IN
22283	373	11	the	the	DT
22283	373	12	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	373	13	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	373	14	,	,	,
22283	373	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	373	16	not	not	RB
22283	373	17	merely	merely	RB
22283	373	18	improbable	improbable	JJ
22283	373	19	_	_	NNP
22283	373	20	per	per	FW
22283	373	21	se	se	FW
22283	373	22	_	_	NNP
22283	373	23	,	,	,
22283	373	24	but	but	CC
22283	373	25	admits	admit	NNS
22283	373	26	of	of	IN
22283	373	27	being	be	VBG
22283	373	28	shown	show	VBN
22283	373	29	virtually	virtually	RB
22283	373	30	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	373	31	if	if	IN
22283	373	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	373	33	proceed	proceed	VBP
22283	373	34	to	to	TO
22283	373	35	consider	consider	VB
22283	373	36	the	the	DT
22283	373	37	consequences	consequence	NNS
22283	373	38	to	to	TO
22283	373	39	which	which	WDT
22283	373	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	373	41	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	373	42	leads	lead	VBZ
22283	373	43	.	.	.
22283	374	1	A	a	DT
22283	374	2	sportsman	sportsman	NN
22283	374	3	,	,	,
22283	374	4	for	for	IN
22283	374	5	example	example	NN
22283	374	6	,	,	,
22283	374	7	pulls	pull	VBZ
22283	374	8	the	the	DT
22283	374	9	trigger	trigger	NN
22283	374	10	of	of	IN
22283	374	11	a	a	DT
22283	374	12	gun	gun	NN
22283	374	13	,	,	,
22283	374	14	thereby	thereby	RB
22283	374	15	initiating	initiate	VBG
22283	374	16	a	a	DT
22283	374	17	long	long	JJ
22283	374	18	train	train	NN
22283	374	19	of	of	IN
22283	374	20	physical	physical	JJ
22283	374	21	causes	cause	NNS
22283	374	22	,	,	,
22283	374	23	which	which	WDT
22283	374	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	374	25	may	may	MD
22283	374	26	take	take	VB
22283	374	27	up	up	RP
22283	374	28	at	at	IN
22283	374	29	the	the	DT
22283	374	30	point	point	NN
22283	374	31	where	where	WRB
22283	374	32	the	the	DT
22283	374	33	powder	powder	NN
22283	374	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	374	35	discharged	discharge	VBN
22283	374	36	,	,	,
22283	374	37	the	the	DT
22283	374	38	shot	shot	NN
22283	374	39	propelled	propel	VBD
22283	374	40	,	,	,
22283	374	41	and	and	CC
22283	374	42	the	the	DT
22283	374	43	bird	bird	NN
22283	374	44	dropped	drop	VBD
22283	374	45	.	.	.
22283	375	1	Here	here	RB
22283	375	2	the	the	DT
22283	375	3	man	man	NN
22283	375	4	's	's	POS
22283	375	5	volition	volition	NN
22283	375	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	375	7	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	375	8	to	to	TO
22283	375	9	have	have	VB
22283	375	10	broken	break	VBN
22283	375	11	in	in	RP
22283	375	12	upon	upon	IN
22283	375	13	the	the	DT
22283	375	14	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	375	15	continuous	continuous	JJ
22283	375	16	stream	stream	NN
22283	375	17	of	of	IN
22283	375	18	physical	physical	JJ
22283	375	19	causes	cause	NNS
22283	375	20	--	--	:
22283	375	21	first	first	RB
22283	375	22	by	by	IN
22283	375	23	modifying	modify	VBG
22283	375	24	the	the	DT
22283	375	25	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	375	26	movements	movement	NNS
22283	375	27	of	of	IN
22283	375	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	375	29	brain	brain	NN
22283	375	30	,	,	,
22283	375	31	so	so	IN
22283	375	32	as	as	IN
22283	375	33	to	to	TO
22283	375	34	produce	produce	VB
22283	375	35	the	the	DT
22283	375	36	particular	particular	JJ
22283	375	37	co	co	NN
22283	375	38	-	-	NN
22283	375	39	ordination	ordination	NN
22283	375	40	of	of	IN
22283	375	41	neuro	neuro	NNP
22283	375	42	-	-	HYPH
22283	375	43	muscular	muscular	JJ
22283	375	44	movement	movement	NN
22283	375	45	required	require	VBN
22283	375	46	to	to	TO
22283	375	47	take	take	VB
22283	375	48	accurate	accurate	JJ
22283	375	49	aim	aim	NN
22283	375	50	and	and	CC
22283	375	51	to	to	TO
22283	375	52	fire	fire	VB
22283	375	53	at	at	IN
22283	375	54	the	the	DT
22283	375	55	right	right	JJ
22283	375	56	moment	moment	NN
22283	375	57	;	;	:
22283	375	58	next	next	RB
22283	375	59	by	by	IN
22283	375	60	converting	convert	VBG
22283	375	61	a	a	DT
22283	375	62	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	375	63	of	of	IN
22283	375	64	gunpowder	gunpowder	NN
22283	375	65	into	into	IN
22283	375	66	gas	gas	NN
22283	375	67	,	,	,
22283	375	68	propelling	propel	VBG
22283	375	69	a	a	DT
22283	375	70	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	375	71	of	of	IN
22283	375	72	lead	lead	NN
22283	375	73	through	through	IN
22283	375	74	the	the	DT
22283	375	75	air	air	NN
22283	375	76	;	;	,
22283	375	77	and	and	CC
22283	375	78	finally	finally	RB
22283	375	79	,	,	,
22283	375	80	by	by	IN
22283	375	81	killing	kill	VBG
22283	375	82	a	a	DT
22283	375	83	bird	bird	NN
22283	375	84	.	.	.
22283	376	1	Now	now	RB
22283	376	2	,	,	,
22283	376	3	without	without	IN
22283	376	4	tracing	trace	VBG
22283	376	5	the	the	DT
22283	376	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	376	7	further	further	RB
22283	376	8	than	than	IN
22283	376	9	this	this	DT
22283	376	10	,	,	,
22283	376	11	let	let	VB
22283	376	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	376	13	consider	consider	VB
22283	376	14	how	how	WRB
22283	376	15	enormous	enormous	JJ
22283	376	16	a	a	DT
22283	376	17	change	change	NN
22283	376	18	the	the	DT
22283	376	19	will	will	NN
22283	376	20	of	of	IN
22283	376	21	the	the	DT
22283	376	22	man	man	NN
22283	376	23	has	have	VBZ
22283	376	24	introduced	introduce	VBN
22283	376	25	,	,	,
22283	376	26	even	even	RB
22283	376	27	by	by	IN
22283	376	28	so	so	RB
22283	376	29	trivial	trivial	JJ
22283	376	30	an	an	DT
22283	376	31	exercise	exercise	NN
22283	376	32	of	of	IN
22283	376	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	376	34	activity	activity	NN
22283	376	35	.	.	.
22283	377	1	No	no	RB
22283	377	2	doubt	doubt	RB
22283	377	3	the	the	DT
22283	377	4	first	first	JJ
22283	377	5	change	change	NN
22283	377	6	in	in	IN
22283	377	7	the	the	DT
22283	377	8	material	material	NN
22283	377	9	world	world	NN
22283	377	10	was	be	VBD
22283	377	11	exceedingly	exceedingly	RB
22283	377	12	slight	slight	JJ
22283	377	13	:	:	:
22283	377	14	the	the	DT
22283	377	15	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	377	16	movement	movement	NN
22283	377	17	in	in	IN
22283	377	18	the	the	DT
22283	377	19	cortex	cortex	NN
22283	377	20	of	of	IN
22283	377	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	377	22	brain	brain	NN
22283	377	23	was	be	VBD
22283	377	24	probably	probably	RB
22283	377	25	not	not	RB
22283	377	26	more	more	JJR
22283	377	27	than	than	IN
22283	377	28	might	may	MD
22283	377	29	be	be	VB
22283	377	30	dynamically	dynamically	RB
22283	377	31	represented	represent	VBN
22283	377	32	by	by	IN
22283	377	33	some	some	DT
22283	377	34	small	small	JJ
22283	377	35	fraction	fraction	NN
22283	377	36	of	of	IN
22283	377	37	a	a	DT
22283	377	38	foot	foot	NN
22283	377	39	-	-	HYPH
22283	377	40	pound	pound	NN
22283	377	41	.	.	.
22283	378	1	But	but	CC
22283	378	2	so	so	RB
22283	378	3	intricate	intricate	JJ
22283	378	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	378	5	the	the	DT
22283	378	6	_	_	NNP
22283	378	7	nexus	nexus	NN
22283	378	8	_	_	NNP
22283	378	9	of	of	IN
22283	378	10	physical	physical	JJ
22283	378	11	causality	causality	NN
22283	378	12	throughout	throughout	IN
22283	378	13	the	the	DT
22283	378	14	whole	whole	JJ
22283	378	15	domain	domain	NN
22283	378	16	of	of	IN
22283	378	17	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	378	18	,	,	,
22283	378	19	that	that	IN
22283	378	20	the	the	DT
22283	378	21	intervention	intervention	NN
22283	378	22	of	of	IN
22283	378	23	even	even	RB
22283	378	24	so	so	RB
22283	378	25	minute	minute	VB
22283	378	26	a	a	DT
22283	378	27	disturbance	disturbance	NN
22283	378	28	_	_	NNP
22283	378	29	ab	ab	NNP
22283	378	30	extra	extra	JJ
22283	378	31	_	_	NNP
22283	378	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	378	33	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	378	34	bound	bind	VBN
22283	378	35	to	to	TO
22283	378	36	continue	continue	VB
22283	378	37	to	to	TO
22283	378	38	assert	assert	VB
22283	378	39	an	an	DT
22283	378	40	influence	influence	NN
22283	378	41	of	of	IN
22283	378	42	ever	ever	RB
22283	378	43	-	-	HYPH
22283	378	44	widening	widen	VBG
22283	378	45	extent	extent	NN
22283	378	46	as	as	RB
22283	378	47	well	well	RB
22283	378	48	as	as	IN
22283	378	49	of	of	IN
22283	378	50	everlasting	everlasting	JJ
22283	378	51	duration	duration	NN
22283	378	52	.	.	.
22283	379	1	The	the	DT
22283	379	2	heat	heat	NN
22283	379	3	generated	generate	VBN
22283	379	4	by	by	IN
22283	379	5	the	the	DT
22283	379	6	explosion	explosion	NN
22283	379	7	of	of	IN
22283	379	8	the	the	DT
22283	379	9	powder	powder	NN
22283	379	10	,	,	,
22283	379	11	the	the	DT
22283	379	12	changed	change	VBN
22283	379	13	disposition	disposition	NN
22283	379	14	of	of	IN
22283	379	15	the	the	DT
22283	379	16	shot	shot	NN
22283	379	17	,	,	,
22283	379	18	the	the	DT
22283	379	19	death	death	NN
22283	379	20	of	of	IN
22283	379	21	the	the	DT
22283	379	22	bird	bird	NN
22283	379	23	--	--	:
22283	379	24	leading	lead	VBG
22283	379	25	to	to	IN
22283	379	26	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
22283	379	27	physical	physical	JJ
22283	379	28	changes	change	NNS
22283	379	29	as	as	IN
22283	379	30	to	to	IN
22283	379	31	stoppage	stoppage	NN
22283	379	32	of	of	IN
22283	379	33	many	many	JJ
22283	379	34	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	379	35	processes	process	NNS
22283	379	36	previously	previously	RB
22283	379	37	going	go	VBG
22283	379	38	on	on	RP
22283	379	39	in	in	IN
22283	379	40	the	the	DT
22283	379	41	bird	bird	NN
22283	379	42	's	's	POS
22283	379	43	body	body	NN
22283	379	44	,	,	,
22283	379	45	loss	loss	NN
22283	379	46	of	of	IN
22283	379	47	animal	animal	NN
22283	379	48	heat	heat	NN
22283	379	49	,	,	,
22283	379	50	&	&	CC
22283	379	51	c.	c.	NNP
22283	379	52	,	,	,
22283	379	53	and	and	CC
22283	379	54	also	also	RB
22283	379	55	to	to	TO
22283	379	56	innumerable	innumerable	VB
22283	379	57	vital	vital	JJ
22283	379	58	changes	change	NNS
22283	379	59	,	,	,
22283	379	60	leading	lead	VBG
22283	379	61	to	to	IN
22283	379	62	a	a	DT
22283	379	63	stoppage	stoppage	NN
22283	379	64	of	of	IN
22283	379	65	all	all	PDT
22283	379	66	the	the	DT
22283	379	67	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	379	68	changes	change	NNS
22283	379	69	which	which	WDT
22283	379	70	the	the	DT
22283	379	71	bird	bird	NN
22283	379	72	would	would	MD
22283	379	73	have	have	VB
22283	379	74	helped	help	VBN
22283	379	75	to	to	IN
22283	379	76	condition	condition	NN
22283	379	77	had	have	VBD
22283	379	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	379	79	lived	live	VBN
22283	379	80	to	to	TO
22283	379	81	die	die	VB
22283	379	82	some	some	DT
22283	379	83	other	other	JJ
22283	379	84	death	death	NN
22283	379	85	,	,	,
22283	379	86	to	to	TO
22283	379	87	propagate	propagate	VB
22283	379	88	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	379	89	kind	kind	NN
22283	379	90	,	,	,
22283	379	91	and	and	CC
22283	379	92	thus	thus	RB
22283	379	93	indirectly	indirectly	RB
22283	379	94	condition	condition	VBP
22283	379	95	an	an	DT
22283	379	96	incalculable	incalculable	JJ
22283	379	97	number	number	NN
22283	379	98	of	of	IN
22283	379	99	future	future	JJ
22283	379	100	changes	change	NNS
22283	379	101	that	that	WDT
22283	379	102	would	would	MD
22283	379	103	have	have	VB
22283	379	104	been	be	VBN
22283	379	105	brought	bring	VBN
22283	379	106	about	about	RP
22283	379	107	by	by	IN
22283	379	108	the	the	DT
22283	379	109	ever	ever	RB
22283	379	110	increasing	increase	VBG
22283	379	111	number	number	NN
22283	379	112	of	of	IN
22283	379	113	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	379	114	descendants	descendant	NNS
22283	379	115	--	--	:
22283	379	116	these	these	DT
22283	379	117	and	and	CC
22283	379	118	an	an	DT
22283	379	119	indefinite	indefinite	JJ
22283	379	120	number	number	NN
22283	379	121	of	of	IN
22283	379	122	other	other	JJ
22283	379	123	physical	physical	JJ
22283	379	124	changes	change	NNS
22283	379	125	must	must	MD
22283	379	126	all	all	RB
22283	379	127	be	be	VB
22283	379	128	held	hold	VBN
22283	379	129	to	to	TO
22283	379	130	have	have	VB
22283	379	131	followed	follow	VBN
22283	379	132	as	as	IN
22283	379	133	a	a	DT
22283	379	134	direct	direct	JJ
22283	379	135	consequence	consequence	NN
22283	379	136	of	of	IN
22283	379	137	the	the	DT
22283	379	138	man	man	NN
22283	379	139	's	's	POS
22283	379	140	volition	volition	NN
22283	379	141	thus	thus	RB
22283	379	142	suddenly	suddenly	RB
22283	379	143	breaking	break	VBG
22283	379	144	in	in	RP
22283	379	145	as	as	IN
22283	379	146	an	an	DT
22283	379	147	independent	independent	JJ
22283	379	148	cause	cause	NN
22283	379	149	upon	upon	IN
22283	379	150	the	the	DT
22283	379	151	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	379	152	uniform	uniform	JJ
22283	379	153	course	course	NN
22283	379	154	of	of	IN
22283	379	155	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	379	156	.	.	.
22283	380	1	Now	now	RB
22283	380	2	,	,	,
22283	380	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	380	4	say	say	VBP
22283	380	5	that	that	IN
22283	380	6	,	,	,
22283	380	7	apart	apart	RB
22283	380	8	from	from	IN
22283	380	9	some	some	DT
22283	380	10	system	system	NN
22283	380	11	of	of	IN
22283	380	12	pre	pre	JJ
22283	380	13	-	-	JJ
22283	380	14	established	established	JJ
22283	380	15	harmony	harmony	NN
22283	380	16	,	,	,
22283	380	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	380	18	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	380	19	simply	simply	RB
22283	380	20	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	380	21	that	that	IN
22283	380	22	the	the	DT
22283	380	23	order	order	NN
22283	380	24	of	of	IN
22283	380	25	Nature	nature	NN
22283	380	26	could	could	MD
22283	380	27	be	be	VB
22283	380	28	maintained	maintain	VBN
22283	380	29	at	at	RB
22283	380	30	all	all	RB
22283	380	31	,	,	,
22283	380	32	if	if	IN
22283	380	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	380	34	were	be	VBD
22283	380	35	thus	thus	RB
22283	380	36	liable	liable	JJ
22283	380	37	to	to	TO
22283	380	38	be	be	VB
22283	380	39	interfered	interfere	VBN
22283	380	40	with	with	IN
22283	380	41	at	at	IN
22283	380	42	any	any	DT
22283	380	43	moment	moment	NN
22283	380	44	in	in	IN
22283	380	45	any	any	DT
22283	380	46	number	number	NN
22283	380	47	of	of	IN
22283	380	48	points	point	NNS
22283	380	49	.	.	.
22283	381	1	And	and	CC
22283	381	2	if	if	IN
22283	381	3	the	the	DT
22283	381	4	spiritualist	spiritualist	NN
22283	381	5	takes	take	VBZ
22283	381	6	refuge	refuge	NN
22283	381	7	in	in	IN
22283	381	8	the	the	DT
22283	381	9	further	further	JJ
22283	381	10	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	381	11	of	of	IN
22283	381	12	a	a	DT
22283	381	13	pre	pre	JJ
22283	381	14	-	-	JJ
22283	381	15	established	established	JJ
22283	381	16	harmony	harmony	NN
22283	381	17	between	between	IN
22283	381	18	acts	act	NNS
22283	381	19	of	of	IN
22283	381	20	human	human	NN
22283	381	21	(	(	-LRB-
22283	381	22	not	not	RB
22283	381	23	to	to	TO
22283	381	24	add	add	VB
22283	381	25	brute	brute	JJ
22283	381	26	)	)	-RRB-
22283	381	27	volition	volition	NN
22283	381	28	and	and	CC
22283	381	29	causes	cause	NNS
22283	381	30	of	of	IN
22283	381	31	a	a	DT
22283	381	32	natural	natural	JJ
22283	381	33	kind	kind	NN
22283	381	34	,	,	,
22283	381	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	381	36	have	have	VBP
22283	381	37	only	only	RB
22283	381	38	to	to	TO
22283	381	39	observe	observe	VB
22283	381	40	that	that	IN
22283	381	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	381	42	thus	thus	RB
22283	381	43	lands	land	VBZ
22283	381	44	himself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	381	45	in	in	IN
22283	381	46	a	a	DT
22283	381	47	speculative	speculative	JJ
22283	381	48	position	position	NN
22283	381	49	which	which	WDT
22283	381	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	381	51	practically	practically	RB
22283	381	52	identical	identical	JJ
22283	381	53	with	with	IN
22283	381	54	that	that	DT
22283	381	55	occupied	occupy	VBN
22283	381	56	by	by	IN
22283	381	57	the	the	DT
22283	381	58	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	381	59	.	.	.
22283	382	1	For	for	IN
22283	382	2	the	the	DT
22283	382	3	only	only	JJ
22283	382	4	difference	difference	NN
22283	382	5	between	between	IN
22283	382	6	the	the	DT
22283	382	7	two	two	CD
22283	382	8	positions	position	NNS
22283	382	9	then	then	RB
22283	382	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	382	11	that	that	IN
22283	382	12	the	the	DT
22283	382	13	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	382	14	which	which	WDT
22283	382	15	the	the	DT
22283	382	16	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	382	17	takes	take	VBZ
22283	382	18	to	to	TO
22283	382	19	be	be	VB
22283	382	20	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	382	21	on	on	IN
22283	382	22	human	human	JJ
22283	382	23	volition	volition	NN
22283	382	24	by	by	IN
22283	382	25	the	the	DT
22283	382	26	system	system	NN
22283	382	27	of	of	IN
22283	382	28	natural	natural	JJ
22283	382	29	causation	causation	NN
22283	382	30	,	,	,
22283	382	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	382	32	now	now	RB
22283	382	33	taken	take	VBN
22283	382	34	by	by	IN
22283	382	35	the	the	DT
22283	382	36	spiritualist	spiritualist	NN
22283	382	37	to	to	TO
22283	382	38	be	be	VB
22283	382	39	equally	equally	RB
22283	382	40	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	382	41	by	by	IN
22283	382	42	a	a	DT
22283	382	43	super	super	JJ
22283	382	44	-	-	JJ
22283	382	45	natural	natural	JJ
22283	382	46	volition	volition	NN
22283	382	47	.	.	.
22283	383	1	The	the	DT
22283	383	2	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	383	3	which	which	WDT
22283	383	4	binds	bind	VBZ
22283	383	5	the	the	DT
22283	383	6	human	human	JJ
22283	383	7	volition	volition	NN
22283	383	8	must	must	MD
22283	383	9	be	be	VB
22283	383	10	equally	equally	RB
22283	383	11	rigid	rigid	JJ
22283	383	12	in	in	IN
22283	383	13	either	either	DT
22283	383	14	case	case	NN
22283	383	15	;	;	:
22283	383	16	and	and	CC
22283	383	17	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	383	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	383	19	can	can	MD
22283	383	20	make	make	VB
22283	383	21	no	no	DT
22283	383	22	practical	practical	JJ
22283	383	23	difference	difference	NN
22283	383	24	whether	whether	IN
22283	383	25	the	the	DT
22283	383	26	source	source	NN
22283	383	27	of	of	IN
22283	383	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	383	29	be	be	VB
22283	383	30	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	383	31	as	as	IN
22283	383	32	natural	natural	JJ
22283	383	33	or	or	CC
22283	383	34	super	super	JJ
22283	383	35	-	-	JJ
22283	383	36	natural	natural	JJ
22283	383	37	,	,	,
22283	383	38	material	material	NN
22283	383	39	or	or	CC
22283	383	40	mental	mental	JJ
22283	383	41	:	:	:
22283	383	42	so	so	IN
22283	383	43	that	that	IN
22283	383	44	a	a	DT
22283	383	45	man	man	NN
22283	383	46	be	be	VB
22283	383	47	fated	fate	VBN
22283	383	48	to	to	IN
22283	383	49	will	will	VB
22283	383	50	only	only	RB
22283	383	51	in	in	IN
22283	383	52	certain	certain	JJ
22283	383	53	ways	way	NNS
22283	383	54	--	--	:
22283	383	55	and	and	CC
22283	383	56	this	this	DT
22283	383	57	with	with	IN
22283	383	58	all	all	PDT
22283	383	59	the	the	DT
22283	383	60	rigour	rigour	NN
22283	383	61	which	which	WDT
22283	383	62	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	383	63	to	to	TO
22283	383	64	causation	causation	NN
22283	383	65	as	as	IN
22283	383	66	physical	physical	JJ
22283	383	67	--	--	:
22283	383	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	383	69	is	be	VBZ
22283	383	70	scarcely	scarcely	RB
22283	383	71	worth	worth	JJ
22283	383	72	while	while	IN
22283	383	73	to	to	TO
22283	383	74	dispute	dispute	VB
22283	383	75	whether	whether	IN
22283	383	76	the	the	DT
22283	383	77	predestination	predestination	NN
22283	383	78	is	be	VBZ
22283	383	79	of	of	IN
22283	383	80	God	God	NNP
22283	383	81	or	or	CC
22283	383	82	of	of	IN
22283	383	83	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	383	84	.	.	.
22283	384	1	There	there	EX
22283	384	2	can	can	MD
22283	384	3	be	be	VB
22283	384	4	no	no	DT
22283	384	5	question	question	NN
22283	384	6	,	,	,
22283	384	7	however	however	RB
22283	384	8	,	,	,
22283	384	9	that	that	IN
22283	384	10	in	in	IN
22283	384	11	this	this	DT
22283	384	12	matter	matter	NN
22283	384	13	the	the	DT
22283	384	14	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	384	15	which	which	WDT
22283	384	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	384	17	have	have	VBP
22283	384	18	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	384	19	to	to	TO
22283	384	20	be	be	VB
22283	384	21	suggested	suggest	VBN
22283	384	22	by	by	IN
22283	384	23	the	the	DT
22283	384	24	spiritualist	spiritualist	NN
22283	384	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	384	26	more	more	RBR
22283	384	27	far	far	RB
22283	384	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	384	29	fetched	fetched	JJ
22283	384	30	than	than	IN
22283	384	31	that	that	DT
22283	384	32	which	which	WDT
22283	384	33	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	384	34	lies	lie	VBZ
22283	384	35	to	to	IN
22283	384	36	the	the	DT
22283	384	37	hand	hand	NN
22283	384	38	of	of	IN
22283	384	39	the	the	DT
22283	384	40	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	384	41	;	;	:
22283	384	42	and	and	CC
22283	384	43	,	,	,
22283	384	44	moreover	moreover	RB
22283	384	45	,	,	,
22283	384	46	that	that	IN
22283	384	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	384	48	too	too	RB
22283	384	49	plainly	plainly	RB
22283	384	50	wears	wear	VBZ
22283	384	51	the	the	DT
22283	384	52	appearance	appearance	NN
22283	384	53	of	of	IN
22283	384	54	a	a	DT
22283	384	55	desperate	desperate	JJ
22283	384	56	device	device	NN
22283	384	57	to	to	TO
22283	384	58	save	save	VB
22283	384	59	a	a	DT
22283	384	60	hollow	hollow	JJ
22283	384	61	theory	theory	NN
22283	384	62	.	.	.
22283	385	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	385	2	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	385	3	to	to	TO
22283	385	4	add	add	VB
22283	385	5	that	that	IN
22283	385	6	this	this	DT
22283	385	7	great	great	JJ
22283	385	8	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	385	9	against	against	IN
22283	385	10	the	the	DT
22283	385	11	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	385	12	theory	theory	NN
22283	385	13	has	have	VBZ
22283	385	14	been	be	VBN
22283	385	15	revealed	reveal	VBN
22283	385	16	in	in	IN
22283	385	17	all	all	DT
22283	385	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	385	19	force	force	NN
22283	385	20	only	only	RB
22283	385	21	during	during	IN
22283	385	22	the	the	DT
22283	385	23	present	present	JJ
22283	385	24	generation	generation	NN
22283	385	25	.	.	.
22283	386	1	Since	since	IN
22283	386	2	the	the	DT
22283	386	3	days	day	NNS
22283	386	4	of	of	IN
22283	386	5	fetishism	fetishism	NN
22283	386	6	,	,	,
22283	386	7	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	386	8	,	,	,
22283	386	9	the	the	DT
22283	386	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	386	11	has	have	VBZ
22283	386	12	always	always	RB
22283	386	13	been	be	VBN
22283	386	14	an	an	DT
22283	386	15	increasing	increase	VBG
22283	386	16	one	one	CD
22283	386	17	--	--	:
22283	386	18	growing	grow	VBG
22283	386	19	with	with	IN
22283	386	20	the	the	DT
22283	386	21	growth	growth	NN
22283	386	22	of	of	IN
22283	386	23	the	the	DT
22283	386	24	perception	perception	NN
22283	386	25	of	of	IN
22283	386	26	uniformity	uniformity	NN
22283	386	27	on	on	IN
22283	386	28	the	the	DT
22283	386	29	one	one	CD
22283	386	30	hand	hand	NN
22283	386	31	,	,	,
22283	386	32	and	and	CC
22283	386	33	of	of	IN
22283	386	34	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	386	35	as	as	IN
22283	386	36	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	386	37	from	from	IN
22283	386	38	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	386	39	agency	agency	NN
22283	386	40	on	on	IN
22283	386	41	the	the	DT
22283	386	42	other	other	JJ
22283	386	43	.	.	.
22283	387	1	But	but	CC
22283	387	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	387	3	was	be	VBD
22283	387	4	not	not	RB
22283	387	5	until	until	IN
22283	387	6	the	the	DT
22283	387	7	correlation	correlation	NN
22283	387	8	of	of	IN
22283	387	9	all	all	PDT
22283	387	10	the	the	DT
22283	387	11	physical	physical	JJ
22283	387	12	forces	force	NNS
22283	387	13	had	have	VBD
22283	387	14	been	be	VBN
22283	387	15	proved	prove	VBN
22283	387	16	by	by	IN
22283	387	17	actual	actual	JJ
22283	387	18	experiment	experiment	NN
22283	387	19	,	,	,
22283	387	20	and	and	CC
22283	387	21	the	the	DT
22283	387	22	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	387	23	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	387	24	of	of	IN
22283	387	25	the	the	DT
22283	387	26	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	387	27	of	of	IN
22283	387	28	energy	energy	NN
22283	387	29	became	become	VBD
22283	387	30	as	as	IN
22283	387	31	a	a	DT
22283	387	32	consequence	consequence	NN
22283	387	33	firmly	firmly	RB
22283	387	34	established	establish	VBD
22283	387	35	,	,	,
22283	387	36	that	that	IN
22283	387	37	the	the	DT
22283	387	38	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	387	39	in	in	IN
22283	387	40	question	question	NN
22283	387	41	assumed	assume	VBD
22283	387	42	the	the	DT
22283	387	43	importance	importance	NN
22283	387	44	of	of	IN
22283	387	45	a	a	DT
22283	387	46	logical	logical	JJ
22283	387	47	barrier	barrier	NN
22283	387	48	to	to	IN
22283	387	49	the	the	DT
22283	387	50	theory	theory	NN
22283	387	51	of	of	IN
22283	387	52	mental	mental	JJ
22283	387	53	changes	change	NNS
22283	387	54	acting	act	VBG
22283	387	55	as	as	IN
22283	387	56	efficient	efficient	JJ
22283	387	57	causes	cause	NNS
22283	387	58	of	of	IN
22283	387	59	material	material	NN
22283	387	60	changes	change	NNS
22283	387	61	.	.	.
22283	388	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
22283	388	2	:	:	:
22283	388	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	388	4	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	388	5	3	3	CD
22283	388	6	:	:	:
22283	388	7	In	in	IN
22283	388	8	the	the	DT
22283	388	9	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	388	10	of	of	IN
22283	388	11	some	some	DT
22283	388	12	modern	modern	JJ
22283	388	13	writers	writer	NNS
22283	388	14	the	the	DT
22283	388	15	indestructibility	indestructibility	NN
22283	388	16	of	of	IN
22283	388	17	matter	matter	NN
22283	388	18	and	and	CC
22283	388	19	the	the	DT
22283	388	20	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	388	21	of	of	IN
22283	388	22	energy	energy	NN
22283	388	23	are	be	VBP
22283	388	24	alone	alone	RB
22283	388	25	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	388	26	to	to	TO
22283	388	27	explain	explain	VB
22283	388	28	all	all	PDT
22283	388	29	the	the	DT
22283	388	30	facts	fact	NNS
22283	388	31	of	of	IN
22283	388	32	natural	natural	JJ
22283	388	33	causation	causation	NN
22283	388	34	.	.	.
22283	389	1	'	'	``
22283	389	2	For	for	IN
22283	389	3	,	,	,
22283	389	4	'	'	''
22283	389	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	389	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	389	7	urged	urge	VBN
22283	389	8	,	,	,
22283	389	9	'	'	''
22283	389	10	if	if	IN
22283	389	11	in	in	IN
22283	389	12	any	any	DT
22283	389	13	case	case	NN
22283	389	14	similar	similar	JJ
22283	389	15	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
22283	389	16	did	do	VBD
22283	389	17	not	not	RB
22283	389	18	determine	determine	VB
22283	389	19	similar	similar	JJ
22283	389	20	consequents	consequent	NNS
22283	389	21	,	,	,
22283	389	22	on	on	IN
22283	389	23	one	one	CD
22283	389	24	or	or	CC
22283	389	25	other	other	JJ
22283	389	26	of	of	IN
22283	389	27	these	these	DT
22283	389	28	occasions	occasion	NNS
22283	389	29	some	some	DT
22283	389	30	_	_	NNP
22283	389	31	quantum	quantum	NN
22283	389	32	_	_	NNP
22283	389	33	of	of	IN
22283	389	34	force	force	NN
22283	389	35	,	,	,
22283	389	36	or	or	CC
22283	389	37	of	of	IN
22283	389	38	matter	matter	NN
22283	389	39	,	,	,
22283	389	40	or	or	CC
22283	389	41	of	of	IN
22283	389	42	both	both	DT
22283	389	43	,	,	,
22283	389	44	must	must	MD
22283	389	45	have	have	VB
22283	389	46	disappeared	disappear	VBN
22283	389	47	--	--	:
22283	389	48	or	or	CC
22283	389	49	,	,	,
22283	389	50	which	which	WDT
22283	389	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	389	52	the	the	DT
22283	389	53	same	same	JJ
22283	389	54	thing	thing	NN
22283	389	55	,	,	,
22283	389	56	the	the	DT
22283	389	57	law	law	NN
22283	389	58	of	of	IN
22283	389	59	causation	causation	NN
22283	389	60	can	can	MD
22283	389	61	not	not	RB
22283	389	62	have	have	VB
22283	389	63	been	be	VBN
22283	389	64	constant	constant	JJ
22283	389	65	.	.	.
22283	389	66	'	'	''
22283	390	1	In	in	IN
22283	390	2	a	a	DT
22283	390	3	future	future	JJ
22283	390	4	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	390	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	390	6	shall	shall	MD
22283	390	7	have	have	VB
22283	390	8	to	to	TO
22283	390	9	recur	recur	VB
22283	390	10	to	to	IN
22283	390	11	this	this	DT
22283	390	12	view	view	NN
22283	390	13	.	.	.
22283	391	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
22283	391	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	391	3	have	have	VBP
22283	391	4	only	only	RB
22283	391	5	to	to	TO
22283	391	6	observe	observe	VB
22283	391	7	that	that	IN
22283	391	8	whether	whether	IN
22283	391	9	or	or	CC
22283	391	10	not	not	RB
22283	391	11	the	the	DT
22283	391	12	law	law	NN
22283	391	13	of	of	IN
22283	391	14	causation	causation	NN
22283	391	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	391	16	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	391	17	more	more	JJR
22283	391	18	than	than	IN
22283	391	19	a	a	DT
22283	391	20	re	re	NN
22283	391	21	-	-	NN
22283	391	22	statement	statement	NN
22283	391	23	of	of	IN
22283	391	24	the	the	DT
22283	391	25	fact	fact	NN
22283	391	26	that	that	IN
22283	391	27	matter	matter	NN
22283	391	28	and	and	CC
22283	391	29	energy	energy	NN
22283	391	30	are	be	VBP
22283	391	31	indestructible	indestructible	JJ
22283	391	32	,	,	,
22283	391	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	391	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	391	35	equally	equally	RB
22283	391	36	true	true	JJ
22283	391	37	that	that	IN
22283	391	38	this	this	DT
22283	391	39	fact	fact	NN
22283	391	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	391	41	at	at	IN
22283	391	42	least	least	JJS
22283	391	43	a	a	DT
22283	391	44	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	391	45	_	_	NNP
22283	391	46	condition	condition	NN
22283	391	47	_	_	NNP
22283	391	48	to	to	IN
22283	391	49	the	the	DT
22283	391	50	operation	operation	NN
22283	391	51	of	of	IN
22283	391	52	that	that	DT
22283	391	53	law	law	NN
22283	391	54	.	.	.
22283	391	55	]	]	-RRB-
22283	392	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
22283	392	2	II	II	NNP
22283	392	3	.	.	.
22283	393	1	MATERIALISM	MATERIALISM	NNP
22283	393	2	.	.	.
22283	394	1	This	this	DT
22283	394	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	394	3	the	the	DT
22283	394	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	394	5	which	which	WDT
22283	394	6	presents	present	VBZ
22283	394	7	great	great	JJ
22283	394	8	fascination	fascination	NN
22283	394	9	to	to	IN
22283	394	10	the	the	DT
22283	394	11	student	student	NN
22283	394	12	of	of	IN
22283	394	13	physical	physical	JJ
22283	394	14	science	science	NN
22283	394	15	.	.	.
22283	395	1	By	by	IN
22283	395	2	laborious	laborious	JJ
22283	395	3	investigation	investigation	NN
22283	395	4	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	395	5	has	have	VBZ
22283	395	6	established	establish	VBN
22283	395	7	the	the	DT
22283	395	8	fact	fact	NN
22283	395	9	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	395	10	the	the	DT
22283	395	11	reach	reach	NN
22283	395	12	of	of	IN
22283	395	13	rational	rational	JJ
22283	395	14	dispute	dispute	NN
22283	395	15	,	,	,
22283	395	16	that	that	IN
22283	395	17	there	there	EX
22283	395	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	395	19	a	a	DT
22283	395	20	constant	constant	JJ
22283	395	21	relation	relation	NN
22283	395	22	of	of	IN
22283	395	23	concomitancy	concomitancy	NN
22283	395	24	between	between	IN
22283	395	25	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	395	26	action	action	NN
22283	395	27	and	and	CC
22283	395	28	thought	thought	NN
22283	395	29	.	.	.
22283	396	1	Within	within	IN
22283	396	2	experience	experience	NN
22283	396	3	mind	mind	NN
22283	396	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	396	5	found	find	VBN
22283	396	6	in	in	IN
22283	396	7	constant	constant	JJ
22283	396	8	and	and	CC
22283	396	9	definite	definite	JJ
22283	396	10	association	association	NN
22283	396	11	with	with	IN
22283	396	12	that	that	DT
22283	396	13	highly	highly	RB
22283	396	14	complex	complex	JJ
22283	396	15	and	and	CC
22283	396	16	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
22283	396	17	disposition	disposition	NN
22283	396	18	of	of	IN
22283	396	19	matter	matter	NNP
22283	396	20	called	call	VBD
22283	396	21	a	a	DT
22283	396	22	living	live	VBG
22283	396	23	brain	brain	NN
22283	396	24	.	.	.
22283	397	1	The	the	DT
22283	397	2	size	size	NN
22283	397	3	and	and	CC
22283	397	4	elaboration	elaboration	NN
22283	397	5	of	of	IN
22283	397	6	this	this	DT
22283	397	7	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
22283	397	8	structure	structure	NN
22283	397	9	throughout	throughout	IN
22283	397	10	the	the	DT
22283	397	11	animal	animal	NN
22283	397	12	kingdom	kingdom	NN
22283	397	13	stand	stand	VBP
22283	397	14	in	in	IN
22283	397	15	conspicuous	conspicuous	JJ
22283	397	16	proportion	proportion	NN
22283	397	17	to	to	IN
22283	397	18	the	the	DT
22283	397	19	degree	degree	NN
22283	397	20	of	of	IN
22283	397	21	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	397	22	displayed	display	VBN
22283	397	23	;	;	:
22283	397	24	while	while	IN
22283	397	25	the	the	DT
22283	397	26	impairment	impairment	NN
22283	397	27	of	of	IN
22283	397	28	this	this	DT
22283	397	29	structure	structure	NN
22283	397	30	,	,	,
22283	397	31	whether	whether	IN
22283	397	32	by	by	IN
22283	397	33	congenital	congenital	JJ
22283	397	34	defect	defect	NN
22283	397	35	,	,	,
22283	397	36	mutilation	mutilation	NN
22283	397	37	,	,	,
22283	397	38	anaemia	anaemia	NN
22283	397	39	,	,	,
22283	397	40	decay	decay	NN
22283	397	41	,	,	,
22283	397	42	or	or	CC
22283	397	43	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
22283	397	44	poison	poison	NN
22283	397	45	,	,	,
22283	397	46	entails	entail	VBZ
22283	397	47	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	397	48	impairment	impairment	NN
22283	397	49	of	of	IN
22283	397	50	mental	mental	JJ
22283	397	51	processes	process	NNS
22283	397	52	.	.	.
22283	398	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	398	2	much	much	JJ
22283	398	3	being	be	VBG
22283	398	4	established	establish	VBN
22283	398	5	,	,	,
22283	398	6	no	no	DT
22283	398	7	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
22283	398	8	man	man	NN
22283	398	9	can	can	MD
22283	398	10	hesitate	hesitate	VB
22283	398	11	in	in	IN
22283	398	12	believing	believe	VBG
22283	398	13	the	the	DT
22283	398	14	relation	relation	NN
22283	398	15	between	between	IN
22283	398	16	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	398	17	and	and	CC
22283	398	18	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	398	19	to	to	TO
22283	398	20	be	be	VB
22283	398	21	a	a	DT
22283	398	22	constant	constant	JJ
22283	398	23	and	and	CC
22283	398	24	concomitant	concomitant	JJ
22283	398	25	relation	relation	NN
22283	398	26	,	,	,
22283	398	27	so	so	IN
22283	398	28	that	that	IN
22283	398	29	the	the	DT
22283	398	30	step	step	NN
22283	398	31	between	between	IN
22283	398	32	this	this	DT
22283	398	33	,	,	,
22283	398	34	and	and	CC
22283	398	35	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	398	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	398	37	as	as	IN
22283	398	38	a	a	DT
22283	398	39	causal	causal	JJ
22283	398	40	relation	relation	NN
22283	398	41	,	,	,
22283	398	42	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	398	43	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	398	44	a	a	DT
22283	398	45	small	small	JJ
22283	398	46	one	one	CD
22283	398	47	.	.	.
22283	399	1	For	for	IN
22283	399	2	,	,	,
22283	399	3	in	in	IN
22283	399	4	all	all	DT
22283	399	5	matters	matter	NNS
22283	399	6	of	of	IN
22283	399	7	physical	physical	JJ
22283	399	8	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	399	9	,	,	,
22283	399	10	whenever	whenever	WRB
22283	399	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	399	12	have	have	VBP
22283	399	13	proved	prove	VBN
22283	399	14	a	a	DT
22283	399	15	constant	constant	JJ
22283	399	16	relation	relation	NN
22283	399	17	of	of	IN
22283	399	18	concomitancy	concomitancy	NN
22283	399	19	in	in	IN
22283	399	20	a	a	DT
22283	399	21	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	399	22	_	_	NNP
22283	399	23	A	A	NNP
22283	399	24	B	B	NNP
22283	399	25	_	_	NNP
22283	399	26	,	,	,
22283	399	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	399	28	call	call	VBP
22283	399	29	_	_	NNP
22283	399	30	A	A	NNP
22283	399	31	_	_	NNP
22283	399	32	the	the	DT
22283	399	33	cause	cause	NN
22283	399	34	of	of	IN
22283	399	35	_	_	NNP
22283	399	36	B	B	NNP
22283	399	37	_	_	NNP
22283	399	38	;	;	:
22283	399	39	and	and	CC
22283	399	40	,	,	,
22283	399	41	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	399	42	,	,	,
22283	399	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	399	44	has	have	VBZ
22283	399	45	been	be	VBN
22283	399	46	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	399	47	said	say	VBN
22283	399	48	that	that	IN
22283	399	49	the	the	DT
22283	399	50	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	399	51	of	of	IN
22283	399	52	causation	causation	NN
22283	399	53	between	between	IN
22283	399	54	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	399	55	and	and	CC
22283	399	56	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	399	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	399	58	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	399	59	causation	causation	NN
22283	399	60	.	.	.
22283	400	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	400	2	,	,	,
22283	400	3	to	to	TO
22283	400	4	fortify	fortify	VB
22283	400	5	this	this	DT
22283	400	6	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	400	7	,	,	,
22283	400	8	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	400	9	point	point	VBP
22283	400	10	to	to	IN
22283	400	11	the	the	DT
22283	400	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	400	13	of	of	IN
22283	400	14	the	the	DT
22283	400	15	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	400	16	of	of	IN
22283	400	17	energy	energy	NN
22283	400	18	,	,	,
22283	400	19	which	which	WDT
22283	400	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	400	21	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	400	22	by	by	IN
22283	400	23	the	the	DT
22283	400	24	science	science	NN
22283	400	25	of	of	IN
22283	400	26	physics	physics	NN
22283	400	27	as	as	IN
22283	400	28	a	a	DT
22283	400	29	sort	sort	NN
22283	400	30	of	of	IN
22283	400	31	buttress	buttress	NN
22283	400	32	in	in	IN
22283	400	33	this	this	DT
22283	400	34	matter	matter	NN
22283	400	35	to	to	IN
22283	400	36	the	the	DT
22283	400	37	teachings	teaching	NNS
22283	400	38	of	of	IN
22283	400	39	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	400	40	.	.	.
22283	401	1	For	for	IN
22283	401	2	,	,	,
22283	401	3	as	as	IN
22283	401	4	this	this	DT
22283	401	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	401	6	compels	compel	VBZ
22283	401	7	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	401	8	to	to	TO
22283	401	9	believe	believe	VB
22283	401	10	that	that	IN
22283	401	11	the	the	DT
22283	401	12	chain	chain	NN
22283	401	13	of	of	IN
22283	401	14	physical	physical	JJ
22283	401	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	401	16	involved	involve	VBN
22283	401	17	in	in	IN
22283	401	18	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	401	19	processes	process	NNS
22283	401	20	can	can	MD
22283	401	21	nowhere	nowhere	RB
22283	401	22	be	be	VB
22283	401	23	broken	break	VBN
22283	401	24	or	or	CC
22283	401	25	deflected	deflect	VBN
22283	401	26	_	_	NNP
22283	401	27	ab	ab	NNP
22283	401	28	extra	extra	JJ
22283	401	29	_	_	NNP
22283	401	30	,	,	,
22283	401	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	401	32	are	be	VBP
22283	401	33	compelled	compel	VBN
22283	401	34	to	to	TO
22283	401	35	believe	believe	VB
22283	401	36	that	that	IN
22283	401	37	the	the	DT
22283	401	38	mental	mental	JJ
22283	401	39	processes	process	NNS
22283	401	40	,	,	,
22283	401	41	which	which	WDT
22283	401	42	are	be	VBP
22283	401	43	correlatively	correlatively	RB
22283	401	44	associated	associate	VBN
22283	401	45	with	with	IN
22283	401	46	these	these	DT
22283	401	47	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	401	48	processes	process	NNS
22283	401	49	,	,	,
22283	401	50	can	can	MD
22283	401	51	nowhere	nowhere	RB
22283	401	52	escape	escape	VB
22283	401	53	from	from	IN
22283	401	54	'	'	''
22283	401	55	the	the	DT
22283	401	56	charmed	charm	VBN
22283	401	57	circle	circle	NN
22283	401	58	of	of	IN
22283	401	59	the	the	DT
22283	401	60	forces	force	NNS
22283	401	61	,	,	,
22283	401	62	'	'	''
22283	401	63	so	so	IN
22283	401	64	that	that	IN
22283	401	65	whether	whether	IN
22283	401	66	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	401	67	look	look	VBP
22283	401	68	to	to	IN
22283	401	69	the	the	DT
22283	401	70	detailed	detailed	JJ
22283	401	71	teachings	teaching	NNS
22283	401	72	of	of	IN
22283	401	73	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	401	74	,	,	,
22283	401	75	or	or	CC
22283	401	76	to	to	IN
22283	401	77	the	the	DT
22283	401	78	more	more	RBR
22283	401	79	general	general	JJ
22283	401	80	teachings	teaching	NNS
22283	401	81	of	of	IN
22283	401	82	physics	physics	NN
22283	401	83	,	,	,
22283	401	84	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	401	85	alike	alike	RB
22283	401	86	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	401	87	that	that	IN
22283	401	88	natural	natural	JJ
22283	401	89	science	science	NN
22283	401	90	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	401	91	to	to	TO
22283	401	92	leave	leave	VB
22283	401	93	no	no	DT
22283	401	94	locus	locus	NN
22283	401	95	for	for	IN
22283	401	96	mind	mind	NN
22283	401	97	other	other	JJ
22283	401	98	than	than	IN
22283	401	99	as	as	IN
22283	401	100	a	a	DT
22283	401	101	something	something	NN
22283	401	102	which	which	WDT
22283	401	103	is	be	VBZ
22283	401	104	in	in	IN
22283	401	105	some	some	DT
22283	401	106	way	way	NN
22283	401	107	a	a	DT
22283	401	108	result	result	NN
22283	401	109	of	of	IN
22283	401	110	motion	motion	NN
22283	401	111	.	.	.
22283	402	1	The	the	DT
22283	402	2	position	position	NN
22283	402	3	of	of	IN
22283	402	4	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	402	5	being	be	VBG
22283	402	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	402	7	at	at	IN
22283	402	8	first	first	JJ
22283	402	9	sight	sight	NN
22283	402	10	so	so	RB
22283	402	11	naturally	naturally	RB
22283	402	12	strong	strong	JJ
22283	402	13	,	,	,
22283	402	14	and	and	CC
22283	402	15	having	have	VBG
22283	402	16	been	be	VBN
22283	402	17	in	in	IN
22283	402	18	recent	recent	JJ
22283	402	19	years	year	NNS
22283	402	20	so	so	RB
22283	402	21	fortified	fortify	VBN
22283	402	22	by	by	IN
22283	402	23	the	the	DT
22283	402	24	labours	labour	NNS
22283	402	25	of	of	IN
22283	402	26	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	402	27	,	,	,
22283	402	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	402	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	402	30	not	not	RB
22283	402	31	surprising	surprising	JJ
22283	402	32	that	that	IN
22283	402	33	in	in	IN
22283	402	34	the	the	DT
22283	402	35	present	present	JJ
22283	402	36	generation	generation	NN
22283	402	37	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	402	38	should	should	MD
22283	402	39	be	be	VB
22283	402	40	in	in	IN
22283	402	41	the	the	DT
22283	402	42	ascendant	ascendant	NN
22283	402	43	.	.	.
22283	403	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	403	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	403	3	the	the	DT
22283	403	4	simple	simple	JJ
22283	403	5	truth	truth	NN
22283	403	6	,	,	,
22283	403	7	as	as	IN
22283	403	8	a	a	DT
22283	403	9	learned	learn	VBN
22283	403	10	and	and	CC
22283	403	11	temperate	temperate	NN
22283	403	12	author	author	NN
22283	403	13	,	,	,
22283	403	14	speaking	speak	VBG
22283	403	15	from	from	IN
22283	403	16	the	the	DT
22283	403	17	side	side	NN
22283	403	18	of	of	IN
22283	403	19	theology	theology	NN
22283	403	20	,	,	,
22283	403	21	has	have	VBZ
22283	403	22	recently	recently	RB
22283	403	23	said	say	VBN
22283	403	24	,	,	,
22283	403	25	that	that	IN
22283	403	26	'	'	``
22283	403	27	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	403	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	403	29	a	a	DT
22283	403	30	danger	danger	NN
22283	403	31	to	to	TO
22283	403	32	which	which	WDT
22283	403	33	individuals	individual	NNS
22283	403	34	and	and	CC
22283	403	35	societies	society	NNS
22283	403	36	will	will	MD
22283	403	37	always	always	RB
22283	403	38	be	be	VB
22283	403	39	more	more	RBR
22283	403	40	or	or	CC
22283	403	41	less	less	RBR
22283	403	42	exposed	exposed	JJ
22283	403	43	.	.	.
22283	404	1	The	the	DT
22283	404	2	present	present	JJ
22283	404	3	generation	generation	NN
22283	404	4	,	,	,
22283	404	5	however	however	RB
22283	404	6	,	,	,
22283	404	7	and	and	CC
22283	404	8	especially	especially	RB
22283	404	9	the	the	DT
22283	404	10	generation	generation	NN
22283	404	11	which	which	WDT
22283	404	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	404	13	growing	grow	VBG
22283	404	14	up	up	RP
22283	404	15	,	,	,
22283	404	16	will	will	MD
22283	404	17	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	404	18	be	be	VB
22283	404	19	very	very	RB
22283	404	20	especially	especially	RB
22283	404	21	exposed	expose	VBN
22283	404	22	to	to	IN
22283	404	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	404	24	;	;	:
22283	404	25	as	as	RB
22283	404	26	much	much	RB
22283	404	27	so	so	RB
22283	404	28	,	,	,
22283	404	29	perhaps	perhaps	RB
22283	404	30	,	,	,
22283	404	31	as	as	IN
22283	404	32	any	any	DT
22283	404	33	generation	generation	NN
22283	404	34	in	in	IN
22283	404	35	the	the	DT
22283	404	36	history	history	NN
22283	404	37	of	of	IN
22283	404	38	the	the	DT
22283	404	39	world	world	NN
22283	404	40	.	.	.
22283	405	1	Within	within	IN
22283	405	2	the	the	DT
22283	405	3	last	last	JJ
22283	405	4	thirty	thirty	CD
22283	405	5	years	year	NNS
22283	405	6	the	the	DT
22283	405	7	great	great	JJ
22283	405	8	wave	wave	NN
22283	405	9	of	of	IN
22283	405	10	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	405	11	or	or	CC
22283	405	12	idealistic	idealistic	JJ
22283	405	13	thought	thought	NN
22283	405	14	...	...	:
22283	405	15	has	have	VBZ
22283	405	16	been	be	VBN
22283	405	17	receding	recede	VBG
22283	405	18	and	and	CC
22283	405	19	decreasing	decrease	VBG
22283	405	20	;	;	:
22283	405	21	and	and	CC
22283	405	22	another	another	DT
22283	405	23	,	,	,
22283	405	24	which	which	WDT
22283	405	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	405	26	in	in	IN
22283	405	27	the	the	DT
22283	405	28	main	main	JJ
22283	405	29	driven	drive	VBN
22283	405	30	by	by	IN
22283	405	31	materialistic	materialistic	JJ
22283	405	32	forces	force	NNS
22283	405	33	,	,	,
22283	405	34	has	have	VBZ
22283	405	35	been	be	VBN
22283	405	36	gradually	gradually	RB
22283	405	37	rising	rise	VBG
22283	405	38	behind	behind	RB
22283	405	39	,	,	,
22283	405	40	vast	vast	JJ
22283	405	41	and	and	CC
22283	405	42	threatening	threatening	JJ
22283	405	43	.	.	.
22283	406	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	406	3	but	but	CC
22283	406	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	406	5	crest	crest	NN
22283	406	6	that	that	IN
22283	406	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	8	at	at	IN
22283	406	9	present	present	NN
22283	406	10	see	see	VB
22283	406	11	;	;	:
22283	406	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	406	14	but	but	CC
22283	406	15	a	a	DT
22283	406	16	certain	certain	JJ
22283	406	17	vague	vague	JJ
22283	406	18	shaking	shaking	NN
22283	406	19	produced	produce	VBN
22283	406	20	by	by	IN
22283	406	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	22	that	that	IN
22283	406	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	24	at	at	IN
22283	406	25	present	present	JJ
22283	406	26	feel	feel	NN
22283	406	27	;	;	:
22283	406	28	but	but	CC
22283	406	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	30	shall	shall	MD
22283	406	31	probably	probably	RB
22283	406	32	soon	soon	RB
22283	406	33	enough	enough	RB
22283	406	34	fail	fail	VBP
22283	406	35	not	not	RB
22283	406	36	both	both	DT
22283	406	37	to	to	TO
22283	406	38	see	see	VB
22283	406	39	and	and	CC
22283	406	40	feel	feel	VB
22283	406	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	406	42	fully	fully	RB
22283	406	43	and	and	CC
22283	406	44	distinctly[4	distinctly[4	NNP
22283	406	45	]	]	-RRB-
22283	406	46	.	.	.
22283	406	47	'	'	''
22283	407	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	407	2	being	be	VBG
22283	407	3	the	the	DT
22283	407	4	present	present	JJ
22283	407	5	importance	importance	NN
22283	407	6	of	of	IN
22283	407	7	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	407	8	,	,	,
22283	407	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	407	10	shall	shall	MD
22283	407	11	devote	devote	VB
22283	407	12	the	the	DT
22283	407	13	present	present	JJ
22283	407	14	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	407	15	to	to	IN
22283	407	16	a	a	DT
22283	407	17	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	407	18	of	of	IN
22283	407	19	this	this	DT
22283	407	20	theory	theory	NN
22283	407	21	.	.	.
22283	408	1	Each	each	DT
22283	408	2	of	of	IN
22283	408	3	the	the	DT
22283	408	4	points	point	NNS
22283	408	5	in	in	IN
22283	408	6	the	the	DT
22283	408	7	argument	argument	NN
22283	408	8	for	for	IN
22283	408	9	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	408	10	which	which	WDT
22283	408	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	408	12	have	have	VBP
22283	408	13	mentioned	mention	VBN
22283	408	14	above	above	IN
22283	408	15	admits	admit	NNS
22283	408	16	,	,	,
22283	408	17	of	of	IN
22283	408	18	course	course	NN
22283	408	19	,	,	,
22283	408	20	of	of	IN
22283	408	21	elaboration	elaboration	NN
22283	408	22	;	;	:
22283	408	23	but	but	CC
22283	408	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	408	25	think	think	VBP
22283	408	26	that	that	IN
22283	408	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	408	28	enumeration	enumeration	NN
22283	408	29	contains	contain	VBZ
22283	408	30	all	all	DT
22283	408	31	that	that	WDT
22283	408	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	408	33	essential	essential	JJ
22283	408	34	to	to	IN
22283	408	35	the	the	DT
22283	408	36	theory	theory	NN
22283	408	37	in	in	IN
22283	408	38	question	question	NN
22283	408	39	.	.	.
22283	409	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	409	2	now	now	RB
22283	409	3	devolves	devolve	VBZ
22283	409	4	upon	upon	IN
22283	409	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	409	6	to	to	TO
22283	409	7	inquire	inquire	VB
22283	409	8	whether	whether	IN
22283	409	9	this	this	DT
22283	409	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	409	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	409	12	adequate	adequate	JJ
22283	409	13	to	to	TO
22283	409	14	meet	meet	VB
22283	409	15	the	the	DT
22283	409	16	facts	fact	NNS
22283	409	17	.	.	.
22283	410	1	And	and	CC
22283	410	2	here	here	RB
22283	410	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	410	4	may	may	MD
22283	410	5	as	as	RB
22283	410	6	well	well	RB
22283	410	7	at	at	IN
22283	410	8	once	once	RB
22283	410	9	give	give	VB
22283	410	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	410	11	as	as	IN
22283	410	12	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	410	13	own	own	JJ
22283	410	14	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	410	15	that	that	IN
22283	410	16	,	,	,
22283	410	17	of	of	IN
22283	410	18	however	however	RB
22283	410	19	much	much	JJ
22283	410	20	service	service	NN
22283	410	21	the	the	DT
22283	410	22	theory	theory	NN
22283	410	23	of	of	IN
22283	410	24	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	410	25	may	may	MD
22283	410	26	be	be	VB
22283	410	27	,	,	,
22283	410	28	up	up	IN
22283	410	29	to	to	IN
22283	410	30	a	a	DT
22283	410	31	certain	certain	JJ
22283	410	32	point	point	NN
22283	410	33	,	,	,
22283	410	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	410	35	can	can	MD
22283	410	36	never	never	RB
22283	410	37	be	be	VB
22283	410	38	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	410	39	by	by	IN
22283	410	40	any	any	DT
22283	410	41	competent	competent	JJ
22283	410	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	410	43	as	as	IN
22283	410	44	a	a	DT
22283	410	45	final	final	JJ
22283	410	46	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	410	47	of	of	IN
22283	410	48	the	the	DT
22283	410	49	facts	fact	NNS
22283	410	50	with	with	IN
22283	410	51	which	which	WDT
22283	410	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	410	53	has	have	VBZ
22283	410	54	to	to	TO
22283	410	55	deal	deal	VB
22283	410	56	.	.	.
22283	411	1	Unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
22283	411	2	as	as	IN
22283	411	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	411	4	use	use	NN
22283	411	5	may	may	MD
22283	411	6	be	be	VB
22283	411	7	as	as	IN
22283	411	8	a	a	DT
22283	411	9	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	411	10	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	411	11	in	in	IN
22283	411	12	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	411	13	and	and	CC
22283	411	14	medicine	medicine	NN
22283	411	15	,	,	,
22283	411	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	411	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	411	18	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	411	19	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
22283	411	20	as	as	IN
22283	411	21	a	a	DT
22283	411	22	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	411	23	in	in	IN
22283	411	24	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	411	25	.	.	.
22283	412	1	That	that	DT
22283	412	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	412	3	to	to	TO
22283	412	4	say	say	VB
22283	412	5	,	,	,
22283	412	6	so	so	RB
22283	412	7	long	long	RB
22283	412	8	as	as	IN
22283	412	9	there	there	EX
22283	412	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	412	11	a	a	DT
22283	412	12	constant	constant	JJ
22283	412	13	relation	relation	NN
22283	412	14	of	of	IN
22283	412	15	concomitancy	concomitancy	NN
22283	412	16	found	find	VBN
22283	412	17	by	by	IN
22283	412	18	experience	experience	NN
22283	412	19	to	to	TO
22283	412	20	obtain	obtain	VB
22283	412	21	between	between	IN
22283	412	22	neural	neural	JJ
22283	412	23	processes	process	NNS
22283	412	24	and	and	CC
22283	412	25	mental	mental	JJ
22283	412	26	processes	process	NNS
22283	412	27	,	,	,
22283	412	28	so	so	CC
22283	412	29	long	long	RB
22283	412	30	no	no	DT
22283	412	31	harm	harm	NN
22283	412	32	can	can	MD
22283	412	33	accrue	accrue	VB
22283	412	34	to	to	IN
22283	412	35	physical	physical	JJ
22283	412	36	science	science	NN
22283	412	37	by	by	IN
22283	412	38	assuming	assume	VBG
22283	412	39	,	,	,
22283	412	40	for	for	IN
22283	412	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	412	42	own	own	JJ
22283	412	43	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	412	44	,	,	,
22283	412	45	that	that	IN
22283	412	46	this	this	DT
22283	412	47	relation	relation	NN
22283	412	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	412	49	a	a	DT
22283	412	50	causal	causal	JJ
22283	412	51	one	one	NN
22283	412	52	.	.	.
22283	413	1	But	but	CC
22283	413	2	as	as	RB
22283	413	3	soon	soon	RB
22283	413	4	as	as	IN
22283	413	5	the	the	DT
22283	413	6	question	question	NN
22283	413	7	concerning	concern	VBG
22283	413	8	the	the	DT
22283	413	9	validity	validity	NN
22283	413	10	of	of	IN
22283	413	11	this	this	DT
22283	413	12	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	413	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	413	14	raised	raise	VBN
22283	413	15	into	into	IN
22283	413	16	the	the	DT
22283	413	17	region	region	NN
22283	413	18	of	of	IN
22283	413	19	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	413	20	,	,	,
22283	413	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	413	22	receives	receive	VBZ
22283	413	23	the	the	DT
22283	413	24	answer	answer	NN
22283	413	25	that	that	IN
22283	413	26	the	the	DT
22283	413	27	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	413	28	can	can	MD
22283	413	29	not	not	RB
22283	413	30	be	be	VB
22283	413	31	allowed	allow	VBN
22283	413	32	to	to	TO
22283	413	33	pass	pass	VB
22283	413	34	.	.	.
22283	414	1	For	for	IN
22283	414	2	where	where	WRB
22283	414	3	the	the	DT
22283	414	4	question	question	NN
22283	414	5	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	414	6	one	one	PRP
22283	414	7	not	not	RB
22283	414	8	as	as	IN
22283	414	9	to	to	IN
22283	414	10	the	the	DT
22283	414	11	_	_	NNP
22283	414	12	fact	fact	NN
22283	414	13	_	_	NNP
22283	414	14	of	of	IN
22283	414	15	the	the	DT
22283	414	16	association	association	NN
22283	414	17	but	but	CC
22283	414	18	as	as	IN
22283	414	19	to	to	IN
22283	414	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	414	21	_	_	NNP
22283	414	22	nature	nature	NN
22283	414	23	_	_	NNP
22283	414	24	,	,	,
22283	414	25	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	414	26	,	,	,
22283	414	27	which	which	WDT
22283	414	28	must	must	MD
22283	414	29	have	have	VB
22283	414	30	regard	regard	NN
22283	414	31	to	to	IN
22283	414	32	the	the	DT
22283	414	33	facts	fact	NNS
22283	414	34	of	of	IN
22283	414	35	mind	mind	NN
22283	414	36	no	no	UH
22283	414	37	less	less	JJR
22283	414	38	than	than	IN
22283	414	39	to	to	IN
22283	414	40	those	those	DT
22283	414	41	of	of	IN
22283	414	42	matter	matter	NN
22283	414	43	,	,	,
22283	414	44	must	must	MD
22283	414	45	pronounce	pronounce	VB
22283	414	46	that	that	IN
22283	414	47	the	the	DT
22283	414	48	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	414	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	414	50	untenable	untenable	JJ
22283	414	51	;	;	:
22283	414	52	for	for	IN
22283	414	53	the	the	DT
22283	414	54	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	414	55	of	of	IN
22283	414	56	this	this	DT
22283	414	57	association	association	NN
22283	414	58	being	be	VBG
22283	414	59	one	one	CD
22283	414	60	of	of	IN
22283	414	61	causality	causality	NN
22283	414	62	acting	act	VBG
22283	414	63	from	from	IN
22283	414	64	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	414	65	to	to	IN
22283	414	66	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	414	67	,	,	,
22283	414	68	can	can	MD
22283	414	69	not	not	RB
22283	414	70	be	be	VB
22283	414	71	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	414	72	without	without	IN
22283	414	73	doing	do	VBG
22283	414	74	violence	violence	NN
22283	414	75	,	,	,
22283	414	76	not	not	RB
22283	414	77	merely	merely	RB
22283	414	78	to	to	IN
22283	414	79	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	414	80	faculty	faculty	NN
22283	414	81	of	of	IN
22283	414	82	reason	reason	NN
22283	414	83	,	,	,
22283	414	84	but	but	CC
22283	414	85	to	to	IN
22283	414	86	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	414	87	very	very	JJ
22283	414	88	idea	idea	NN
22283	414	89	of	of	IN
22283	414	90	causation	causation	NN
22283	414	91	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	414	92	.	.	.
22283	415	1	A	a	DT
22283	415	2	very	very	RB
22283	415	3	small	small	JJ
22283	415	4	amount	amount	NN
22283	415	5	of	of	IN
22283	415	6	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	415	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	415	8	enough	enough	JJ
22283	415	9	to	to	TO
22283	415	10	show	show	VB
22283	415	11	that	that	IN
22283	415	12	what	what	WP
22283	415	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	415	14	call	call	VBP
22283	415	15	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	415	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	415	17	of	of	IN
22283	415	18	the	the	DT
22283	415	19	external	external	JJ
22283	415	20	world	world	NN
22283	415	21	,	,	,
22283	415	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	415	23	merely	merely	RB
22283	415	24	a	a	DT
22283	415	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	415	26	of	of	IN
22283	415	27	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	415	28	own	own	JJ
22283	415	29	mental	mental	JJ
22283	415	30	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	415	31	.	.	.
22283	416	1	A	a	DT
22283	416	2	step	step	NN
22283	416	3	further	far	RBR
22283	416	4	and	and	CC
22283	416	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	416	6	find	find	VBP
22283	416	7	that	that	IN
22283	416	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	416	9	idea	idea	NN
22283	416	10	of	of	IN
22283	416	11	causation	causation	NN
22283	416	12	as	as	IN
22283	416	13	a	a	DT
22283	416	14	principle	principle	NN
22283	416	15	in	in	IN
22283	416	16	the	the	DT
22283	416	17	external	external	JJ
22283	416	18	world	world	NN
22283	416	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	416	20	derived	derive	VBN
22283	416	21	from	from	IN
22283	416	22	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	416	23	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	416	24	of	of	IN
22283	416	25	this	this	DT
22283	416	26	principle	principle	NN
22283	416	27	in	in	IN
22283	416	28	the	the	DT
22283	416	29	internal	internal	JJ
22283	416	30	world	world	NN
22283	416	31	.	.	.
22283	417	1	For	for	IN
22283	417	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	417	3	find	find	VBP
22283	417	4	that	that	IN
22283	417	5	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	417	6	idea	idea	NN
22283	417	7	of	of	IN
22283	417	8	force	force	NN
22283	417	9	and	and	CC
22283	417	10	energy	energy	NN
22283	417	11	in	in	IN
22283	417	12	the	the	DT
22283	417	13	external	external	JJ
22283	417	14	world	world	NN
22283	417	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	417	16	a	a	DT
22283	417	17	mere	mere	JJ
22283	417	18	projection	projection	NN
22283	417	19	of	of	IN
22283	417	20	the	the	DT
22283	417	21	idea	idea	NN
22283	417	22	which	which	WDT
22283	417	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	417	24	have	have	VBP
22283	417	25	of	of	IN
22283	417	26	effort	effort	NN
22283	417	27	within	within	IN
22283	417	28	the	the	DT
22283	417	29	region	region	NN
22283	417	30	of	of	IN
22283	417	31	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	417	32	own	own	JJ
22283	417	33	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	417	34	;	;	:
22283	417	35	and	and	CC
22283	417	36	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	417	37	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	417	38	only	only	JJ
22283	417	39	idea	idea	NN
22283	417	40	of	of	IN
22283	417	41	causation	causation	NN
22283	417	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	417	43	that	that	DT
22283	417	44	which	which	WDT
22283	417	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	417	46	originally	originally	RB
22283	417	47	derived	derive	VBN
22283	417	48	from	from	IN
22283	417	49	the	the	DT
22283	417	50	experience	experience	NN
22283	417	51	which	which	WDT
22283	417	52	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	417	53	have	have	VBP
22283	417	54	of	of	IN
22283	417	55	this	this	DT
22283	417	56	principle	principle	NN
22283	417	57	as	as	IN
22283	417	58	obtaining	obtain	VBG
22283	417	59	among	among	IN
22283	417	60	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	417	61	own	own	JJ
22283	417	62	mental	mental	JJ
22283	417	63	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	417	64	.	.	.
22283	418	1	If	if	IN
22283	418	2	once	once	IN
22283	418	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	418	4	see	see	VBP
22283	418	5	plainly	plainly	RB
22283	418	6	that	that	IN
22283	418	7	the	the	DT
22283	418	8	idea	idea	NN
22283	418	9	of	of	IN
22283	418	10	causation	causation	NN
22283	418	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	418	12	derived	derive	VBN
22283	418	13	from	from	IN
22283	418	14	within	within	IN
22283	418	15	,	,	,
22283	418	16	and	and	CC
22283	418	17	that	that	IN
22283	418	18	what	what	WP
22283	418	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	418	20	call	call	VBP
22283	418	21	the	the	DT
22283	418	22	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	418	23	of	of	IN
22283	418	24	physical	physical	JJ
22283	418	25	causation	causation	NN
22283	418	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	418	27	really	really	RB
22283	418	28	the	the	DT
22283	418	29	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	418	30	of	of	IN
22283	418	31	mental	mental	JJ
22283	418	32	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	418	33	following	follow	VBG
22283	418	34	one	one	CD
22283	418	35	another	another	DT
22283	418	36	in	in	IN
22283	418	37	a	a	DT
22283	418	38	definite	definite	JJ
22283	418	39	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	418	40	,	,	,
22283	418	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	418	42	shall	shall	MD
22283	418	43	then	then	RB
22283	418	44	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	418	45	see	see	VB
22283	418	46	,	,	,
22283	418	47	not	not	RB
22283	418	48	merely	merely	RB
22283	418	49	that	that	IN
22283	418	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	418	51	have	have	VBP
22283	418	52	no	no	DT
22283	418	53	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	418	54	,	,	,
22283	418	55	but	but	CC
22283	418	56	that	that	IN
22283	418	57	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	418	58	_	_	NNP
22283	418	59	can	can	MD
22283	418	60	have	have	VB
22283	418	61	_	_	NNP
22283	418	62	no	no	DT
22283	418	63	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	418	64	of	of	IN
22283	418	65	causation	causation	NN
22283	418	66	as	as	IN
22283	418	67	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	418	68	from	from	IN
22283	418	69	object	object	NN
22283	418	70	to	to	IN
22283	418	71	subject	subject	VB
22283	418	72	.	.	.
22283	419	1	However	however	WRB
22283	419	2	cogent	cogent	JJ
22283	419	3	the	the	DT
22283	419	4	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	419	5	may	may	MD
22283	419	6	appear	appear	VB
22283	419	7	at	at	IN
22283	419	8	first	first	JJ
22283	419	9	sight	sight	NN
22283	419	10	to	to	TO
22283	419	11	be	be	VB
22283	419	12	,	,	,
22283	419	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	419	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	419	15	found	find	VBN
22283	419	16	to	to	TO
22283	419	17	vanish	vanish	VB
22283	419	18	like	like	IN
22283	419	19	a	a	DT
22283	419	20	cloud	cloud	NN
22283	419	21	as	as	RB
22283	419	22	soon	soon	RB
22283	419	23	as	as	IN
22283	419	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	419	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	419	26	exposed	expose	VBN
22283	419	27	to	to	IN
22283	419	28	the	the	DT
22283	419	29	light	light	NN
22283	419	30	of	of	IN
22283	419	31	adequate	adequate	JJ
22283	419	32	contemplation	contemplation	NN
22283	419	33	.	.	.
22283	420	1	In	in	IN
22283	420	2	the	the	DT
22283	420	3	very	very	JJ
22283	420	4	act	act	NN
22283	420	5	of	of	IN
22283	420	6	thinking	think	VBG
22283	420	7	the	the	DT
22283	420	8	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	420	9	,	,	,
22283	420	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	420	11	are	be	VBP
22283	420	12	virtually	virtually	RB
22283	420	13	denying	deny	VBG
22283	420	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	420	15	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	420	16	as	as	IN
22283	420	17	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	420	18	;	;	,
22283	420	19	for	for	IN
22283	420	20	as	as	IN
22283	420	21	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	420	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	420	23	appeals	appeal	VBZ
22283	420	24	only	only	RB
22283	420	25	to	to	IN
22283	420	26	the	the	DT
22283	420	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	420	28	,	,	,
22283	420	29	and	and	CC
22283	420	30	since	since	IN
22283	420	31	the	the	DT
22283	420	32	mind	mind	NN
22283	420	33	can	can	MD
22283	420	34	only	only	RB
22283	420	35	know	know	VB
22283	420	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	420	37	own	own	JJ
22283	420	38	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	420	39	,	,	,
22283	420	40	the	the	DT
22283	420	41	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	420	42	must	must	MD
22283	420	43	be	be	VB
22283	420	44	presenting	present	VBG
22283	420	45	to	to	IN
22283	420	46	the	the	DT
22283	420	47	mind	mind	NN
22283	420	48	an	an	DT
22283	420	49	account	account	NN
22283	420	50	of	of	IN
22283	420	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	420	52	own	own	JJ
22283	420	53	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	420	54	;	;	:
22283	420	55	from	from	IN
22283	420	56	the	the	DT
22283	420	57	mere	mere	JJ
22283	420	58	fact	fact	NN
22283	420	59	,	,	,
22283	420	60	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	420	61	,	,	,
22283	420	62	of	of	IN
22283	420	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	420	64	being	be	VBG
22283	420	65	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	420	66	as	as	IN
22283	420	67	thinkable	thinkable	JJ
22283	420	68	,	,	,
22283	420	69	the	the	DT
22283	420	70	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	420	71	is	be	VBZ
22283	420	72	proved	prove	VBN
22283	420	73	to	to	TO
22283	420	74	be	be	VB
22283	420	75	illusory	illusory	JJ
22283	420	76	.	.	.
22283	421	1	To	to	IN
22283	421	2	uneducated	uneducated	JJ
22283	421	3	men	man	NNS
22283	421	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	421	5	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	421	6	an	an	DT
22283	421	7	indisputable	indisputable	JJ
22283	421	8	fact	fact	NN
22283	421	9	of	of	IN
22283	421	10	'	'	``
22283	421	11	common	common	JJ
22283	421	12	sense	sense	NN
22283	421	13	'	'	''
22283	421	14	that	that	IN
22283	421	15	the	the	DT
22283	421	16	colour	colour	NN
22283	421	17	of	of	IN
22283	421	18	a	a	DT
22283	421	19	flower	flower	NN
22283	421	20	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	421	21	as	as	IN
22283	421	22	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	421	23	in	in	IN
22283	421	24	the	the	DT
22283	421	25	flower	flower	NN
22283	421	26	,	,	,
22283	421	27	apart	apart	RB
22283	421	28	from	from	IN
22283	421	29	any	any	DT
22283	421	30	relation	relation	NN
22283	421	31	to	to	IN
22283	421	32	the	the	DT
22283	421	33	percipient	percipient	JJ
22283	421	34	mind	mind	NN
22283	421	35	.	.	.
22283	422	1	A	a	DT
22283	422	2	physiologist	physiologist	NN
22283	422	3	has	have	VBZ
22283	422	4	gone	go	VBN
22283	422	5	further	further	RB
22283	422	6	into	into	IN
22283	422	7	the	the	DT
22283	422	8	thicket	thicket	NN
22283	422	9	of	of	IN
22283	422	10	things	thing	NNS
22283	422	11	,	,	,
22283	422	12	and	and	CC
22283	422	13	finds	find	VBZ
22283	422	14	that	that	IN
22283	422	15	the	the	DT
22283	422	16	way	way	NN
22283	422	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	422	18	not	not	RB
22283	422	19	so	so	RB
22283	422	20	simple	simple	JJ
22283	422	21	as	as	IN
22283	422	22	this	this	DT
22283	422	23	.	.	.
22283	423	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	423	2	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	423	3	the	the	DT
22283	423	4	quality	quality	NN
22283	423	5	of	of	IN
22283	423	6	colour	colour	NN
22283	423	7	as	as	IN
22283	423	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	423	9	related	relate	VBN
22283	423	10	to	to	IN
22283	423	11	the	the	DT
22283	423	12	faculty	faculty	NN
22283	423	13	of	of	IN
22283	423	14	visual	visual	JJ
22283	423	15	perception	perception	NN
22283	423	16	;	;	:
22283	423	17	does	do	VBZ
22283	423	18	not	not	RB
22283	423	19	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	423	20	that	that	IN
22283	423	21	the	the	DT
22283	423	22	colour	colour	NN
22283	423	23	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	423	24	_	_	NNP
22283	423	25	as	as	RB
22283	423	26	such	such	JJ
22283	423	27	_	_	NNP
22283	423	28	in	in	IN
22283	423	29	the	the	DT
22283	423	30	flower	flower	NN
22283	423	31	,	,	,
22283	423	32	but	but	CC
22283	423	33	thinks	think	VBZ
22283	423	34	of	of	IN
22283	423	35	the	the	DT
22283	423	36	something	something	NN
22283	423	37	there	there	RB
22283	423	38	as	as	IN
22283	423	39	a	a	DT
22283	423	40	certain	certain	JJ
22283	423	41	order	order	NN
22283	423	42	of	of	IN
22283	423	43	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	423	44	which	which	WDT
22283	423	45	,	,	,
22283	423	46	when	when	WRB
22283	423	47	brought	bring	VBN
22283	423	48	into	into	IN
22283	423	49	relation	relation	NN
22283	423	50	with	with	IN
22283	423	51	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	423	52	through	through	IN
22283	423	53	the	the	DT
22283	423	54	medium	medium	NN
22283	423	55	of	of	IN
22283	423	56	certain	certain	JJ
22283	423	57	nerves	nerve	NNS
22283	423	58	,	,	,
22283	423	59	gives	give	VBZ
22283	423	60	rise	rise	NN
22283	423	61	to	to	IN
22283	423	62	the	the	DT
22283	423	63	perception	perception	NN
22283	423	64	experienced	experience	VBD
22283	423	65	;	;	:
22283	423	66	and	and	CC
22283	423	67	in	in	IN
22283	423	68	order	order	NN
22283	423	69	to	to	TO
22283	423	70	account	account	VB
22283	423	71	for	for	IN
22283	423	72	the	the	DT
22283	423	73	translation	translation	NN
22283	423	74	into	into	IN
22283	423	75	visual	visual	JJ
22283	423	76	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	423	77	of	of	IN
22283	423	78	an	an	DT
22283	423	79	event	event	NN
22283	423	80	so	so	RB
22283	423	81	unlike	unlike	IN
22283	423	82	that	that	DT
22283	423	83	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	423	84	as	as	IN
22283	423	85	is	be	VBZ
22283	423	86	the	the	DT
22283	423	87	process	process	NN
22283	423	88	taking	take	VBG
22283	423	89	place	place	NN
22283	423	90	in	in	IN
22283	423	91	the	the	DT
22283	423	92	flower	flower	NN
22283	423	93	,	,	,
22283	423	94	physiologists	physiologist	NNS
22283	423	95	have	have	VBP
22283	423	96	recourse	recourse	VBN
22283	423	97	to	to	IN
22283	423	98	an	an	DT
22283	423	99	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
22283	423	100	theory	theory	NN
22283	423	101	,	,	,
22283	423	102	such	such	JJ
22283	423	103	as	as	IN
22283	423	104	that	that	DT
22283	423	105	of	of	IN
22283	423	106	Helmholtz	Helmholtz	NNP
22283	423	107	or	or	CC
22283	423	108	Hering	Hering	NNP
22283	423	109	.	.	.
22283	424	1	In	in	IN
22283	424	2	other	other	JJ
22283	424	3	words	word	NNS
22283	424	4	,	,	,
22283	424	5	physiologists	physiologist	NNS
22283	424	6	here	here	RB
22283	424	7	fully	fully	RB
22283	424	8	recognize	recognize	VBP
22283	424	9	that	that	DT
22283	424	10	colour	colour	NN
22283	424	11	,	,	,
22283	424	12	or	or	CC
22283	424	13	any	any	DT
22283	424	14	other	other	JJ
22283	424	15	thing	thing	NN
22283	424	16	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	424	17	,	,	,
22283	424	18	only	only	RB
22283	424	19	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	424	20	_	_	NNP
22283	424	21	as	as	IN
22283	424	22	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	424	23	_	_	NNP
22283	424	24	in	in	IN
22283	424	25	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	424	26	of	of	IN
22283	424	27	a	a	DT
22283	424	28	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	424	29	element	element	NN
22283	424	30	blending	blending	NN
22283	424	31	with	with	IN
22283	424	32	an	an	DT
22283	424	33	objective	objective	NN
22283	424	34	;	;	:
22283	424	35	the	the	DT
22283	424	36	thing	thing	NN
22283	424	37	_	_	NNP
22283	424	38	as	as	IN
22283	424	39	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	424	40	_	_	NNP
22283	424	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	424	42	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	424	43	as	as	IN
22283	424	44	having	have	VBG
22283	424	45	no	no	DT
22283	424	46	existence	existence	NN
22283	424	47	apart	apart	RB
22283	424	48	from	from	IN
22283	424	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	424	50	relation	relation	NN
22283	424	51	to	to	IN
22283	424	52	a	a	DT
22283	424	53	percipient	percipient	JJ
22283	424	54	mind	mind	NN
22283	424	55	.	.	.
22283	425	1	Now	now	RB
22283	425	2	,	,	,
22283	425	3	although	although	IN
22283	425	4	physiologists	physiologist	NNS
22283	425	5	are	be	VBP
22283	425	6	at	at	IN
22283	425	7	one	one	CD
22283	425	8	with	with	IN
22283	425	9	the	the	DT
22283	425	10	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
22283	425	11	thus	thus	RB
22283	425	12	far	far	RB
22283	425	13	,	,	,
22283	425	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	425	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	425	16	to	to	TO
22283	425	17	be	be	VB
22283	425	18	feared	fear	VBN
22283	425	19	that	that	IN
22283	425	20	very	very	RB
22283	425	21	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	425	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	425	23	are	be	VBP
22283	425	24	in	in	IN
22283	425	25	the	the	DT
22283	425	26	same	same	JJ
22283	425	27	position	position	NN
22283	425	28	as	as	IN
22283	425	29	the	the	DT
22283	425	30	above	above	RB
22283	425	31	-	-	HYPH
22283	425	32	mentioned	mention	VBN
22283	425	33	'	'	''
22283	425	34	uneducated	uneducated	JJ
22283	425	35	men	man	NNS
22283	425	36	,	,	,
22283	425	37	'	'	''
22283	425	38	when	when	WRB
22283	425	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	425	40	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	425	41	needful	needful	JJ
22283	425	42	to	to	TO
22283	425	43	press	press	VB
22283	425	44	still	still	RB
22283	425	45	further	further	RB
22283	425	46	into	into	IN
22283	425	47	the	the	DT
22283	425	48	thicket	thicket	NN
22283	425	49	.	.	.
22283	426	1	For	for	IN
22283	426	2	after	after	IN
22283	426	3	having	have	VBG
22283	426	4	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	426	5	the	the	DT
22283	426	6	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	426	7	of	of	IN
22283	426	8	recognizing	recognize	VBG
22283	426	9	a	a	DT
22283	426	10	mind	mind	NN
22283	426	11	-	-	HYPH
22283	426	12	element	element	NN
22283	426	13	in	in	IN
22283	426	14	any	any	DT
22283	426	15	possible	possible	JJ
22283	426	16	theory	theory	NN
22283	426	17	of	of	IN
22283	426	18	perception	perception	NN
22283	426	19	,	,	,
22283	426	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	426	21	forthwith	forthwith	VBP
22283	426	22	proceed	proceed	VBP
22283	426	23	to	to	TO
22283	426	24	disregard	disregard	VB
22283	426	25	this	this	DT
22283	426	26	element	element	NN
22283	426	27	when	when	WRB
22283	426	28	passing	pass	VBG
22283	426	29	from	from	IN
22283	426	30	the	the	DT
22283	426	31	ground	ground	NN
22283	426	32	of	of	IN
22283	426	33	perception	perception	NN
22283	426	34	to	to	IN
22283	426	35	that	that	DT
22283	426	36	of	of	IN
22283	426	37	thought	thought	NN
22283	426	38	.	.	.
22283	427	1	Although	although	IN
22283	427	2	the	the	DT
22283	427	3	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	427	4	of	of	IN
22283	427	5	matter	matter	NN
22283	427	6	,	,	,
22283	427	7	motion	motion	NN
22283	427	8	,	,	,
22283	427	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	427	10	,	,	,
22283	427	11	and	and	CC
22283	427	12	so	so	RB
22283	427	13	on	on	RB
22283	427	14	,	,	,
22283	427	15	are	be	VBP
22283	427	16	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	427	17	as	as	RB
22283	427	18	much	much	RB
22283	427	19	the	the	DT
22283	427	20	offspring	offspring	NN
22283	427	21	of	of	IN
22283	427	22	a	a	DT
22283	427	23	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	427	24	mind	mind	NN
22283	427	25	,	,	,
22283	427	26	with	with	IN
22283	427	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	427	28	environment	environment	NN
22283	427	29	,	,	,
22283	427	30	as	as	IN
22283	427	31	the	the	DT
22283	427	32	perception	perception	NN
22283	427	33	of	of	IN
22283	427	34	colour	colour	NN
22283	427	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	427	36	a	a	DT
22283	427	37	conceiving	conceiving	NN
22283	427	38	of	of	IN
22283	427	39	the	the	DT
22283	427	40	percipient	percipient	JJ
22283	427	41	mind	mind	NN
22283	427	42	,	,	,
22283	427	43	with	with	IN
22283	427	44	_	_	NNP
22283	427	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	427	46	_	_	NNP
22283	427	47	environment	environment	NN
22283	427	48	,	,	,
22283	427	49	these	these	DT
22283	427	50	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	427	51	are	be	VBP
22283	427	52	inconsistently	inconsistently	RB
22283	427	53	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	427	54	to	to	TO
22283	427	55	stand	stand	VB
22283	427	56	for	for	IN
22283	427	57	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
22283	427	58	realities	reality	NNS
22283	427	59	of	of	IN
22283	427	60	the	the	DT
22283	427	61	external	external	JJ
22283	427	62	world	world	NN
22283	427	63	--	--	:
22283	427	64	to	to	TO
22283	427	65	truly	truly	RB
22283	427	66	represent	represent	VB
22283	427	67	things	thing	NNS
22283	427	68	that	that	WDT
22283	427	69	are	be	VBP
22283	427	70	virtually	virtually	RB
22283	427	71	independent	independent	JJ
22283	427	72	of	of	IN
22283	427	73	any	any	DT
22283	427	74	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	427	75	relation	relation	NN
22283	427	76	to	to	IN
22283	427	77	mind	mind	NN
22283	427	78	.	.	.
22283	428	1	Or	or	CC
22283	428	2	,	,	,
22283	428	3	as	as	IN
22283	428	4	the	the	DT
22283	428	5	case	case	NN
22283	428	6	has	have	VBZ
22283	428	7	recently	recently	RB
22283	428	8	been	be	VBN
22283	428	9	well	well	RB
22283	428	10	put	put	VBN
22283	428	11	by	by	IN
22283	428	12	Principal	Principal	NNP
22283	428	13	Caird	Caird	NNP
22283	428	14	:	:	:
22283	428	15	'	'	''
22283	428	16	You	-PRON-	PRP
22283	428	17	can	can	MD
22283	428	18	not	not	RB
22283	428	19	get	get	VB
22283	428	20	mind	mind	NN
22283	428	21	as	as	IN
22283	428	22	an	an	DT
22283	428	23	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	428	24	product	product	NN
22283	428	25	of	of	IN
22283	428	26	matter	matter	NN
22283	428	27	,	,	,
22283	428	28	for	for	IN
22283	428	29	in	in	IN
22283	428	30	the	the	DT
22283	428	31	very	very	JJ
22283	428	32	attempt	attempt	NN
22283	428	33	to	to	TO
22283	428	34	do	do	VB
22283	428	35	so	so	RB
22283	428	36	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	428	37	have	have	VBP
22283	428	38	already	already	RB
22283	428	39	begun	begin	VBN
22283	428	40	with	with	IN
22283	428	41	mind	mind	NN
22283	428	42	.	.	.
22283	429	1	The	the	DT
22283	429	2	easiest	easy	JJS
22283	429	3	step	step	NN
22283	429	4	of	of	IN
22283	429	5	any	any	DT
22283	429	6	such	such	JJ
22283	429	7	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	429	8	involves	involve	VBZ
22283	429	9	categories	category	NNS
22283	429	10	of	of	IN
22283	429	11	thought	thought	NN
22283	429	12	,	,	,
22283	429	13	and	and	CC
22283	429	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	429	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	429	16	in	in	IN
22283	429	17	terms	term	NNS
22283	429	18	of	of	IN
22283	429	19	thought	thought	NN
22283	429	20	that	that	IN
22283	429	21	the	the	DT
22283	429	22	very	very	JJ
22283	429	23	problem	problem	NN
22283	429	24	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	429	25	are	be	VBP
22283	429	26	investigating	investigate	VBG
22283	429	27	can	can	MD
22283	429	28	be	be	VB
22283	429	29	so	so	RB
22283	429	30	much	much	RB
22283	429	31	as	as	IN
22283	429	32	stated	state	VBN
22283	429	33	.	.	.
22283	430	1	You	-PRON-	PRP
22283	430	2	can	can	MD
22283	430	3	not	not	RB
22283	430	4	start	start	VB
22283	430	5	in	in	IN
22283	430	6	your	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	430	7	investigations	investigation	NNS
22283	430	8	with	with	IN
22283	430	9	a	a	DT
22283	430	10	bare	bare	JJ
22283	430	11	,	,	,
22283	430	12	self	self	NN
22283	430	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	430	14	identical	identical	JJ
22283	430	15	,	,	,
22283	430	16	objective	objective	JJ
22283	430	17	fact	fact	NN
22283	430	18	,	,	,
22283	430	19	stripped	strip	VBN
22283	430	20	of	of	IN
22283	430	21	every	every	DT
22283	430	22	ideal	ideal	JJ
22283	430	23	element	element	NN
22283	430	24	or	or	CC
22283	430	25	contribution	contribution	NN
22283	430	26	from	from	IN
22283	430	27	thought	thought	NN
22283	430	28	.	.	.
22283	431	1	The	the	DT
22283	431	2	least	least	JJS
22283	431	3	and	and	CC
22283	431	4	lowest	low	JJS
22283	431	5	part	part	NN
22283	431	6	of	of	IN
22283	431	7	outward	outward	JJ
22283	431	8	observation	observation	NN
22283	431	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	431	10	not	not	RB
22283	431	11	an	an	DT
22283	431	12	independent	independent	JJ
22283	431	13	entity	entity	NN
22283	431	14	--	--	:
22283	431	15	fact	fact	NN
22283	431	16	_	_	NNP
22283	431	17	minus	minus	NN
22283	431	18	_	_	NNP
22283	431	19	mind	mind	NN
22283	431	20	,	,	,
22283	431	21	and	and	CC
22283	431	22	out	out	IN
22283	431	23	of	of	IN
22283	431	24	which	which	WDT
22283	431	25	mind	mind	NN
22283	431	26	may	may	MD
22283	431	27	,	,	,
22283	431	28	somewhere	somewhere	RB
22283	431	29	or	or	CC
22283	431	30	other	other	JJ
22283	431	31	,	,	,
22283	431	32	be	be	VB
22283	431	33	seen	see	VBN
22283	431	34	to	to	TO
22283	431	35	emerge	emerge	VB
22283	431	36	;	;	:
22283	431	37	but	but	CC
22283	431	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	431	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	431	40	fact	fact	NN
22283	431	41	or	or	CC
22283	431	42	object	object	NN
22283	431	43	as	as	IN
22283	431	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	431	45	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	431	46	to	to	IN
22283	431	47	an	an	DT
22283	431	48	observing	observing	JJ
22283	431	49	mind	mind	NN
22283	431	50	,	,	,
22283	431	51	in	in	IN
22283	431	52	the	the	DT
22283	431	53	medium	medium	NN
22283	431	54	of	of	IN
22283	431	55	thought	thought	NN
22283	431	56	,	,	,
22283	431	57	having	have	VBG
22283	431	58	mind	mind	NN
22283	431	59	or	or	CC
22283	431	60	thought	think	VBD
22283	431	61	as	as	IN
22283	431	62	an	an	DT
22283	431	63	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
22283	431	64	factor	factor	NN
22283	431	65	of	of	IN
22283	431	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	431	67	.	.	.
22283	432	1	Whether	whether	IN
22283	432	2	there	there	EX
22283	432	3	be	be	VBP
22283	432	4	such	such	PDT
22283	432	5	a	a	DT
22283	432	6	thing	thing	NN
22283	432	7	as	as	IN
22283	432	8	an	an	DT
22283	432	9	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	432	10	world	world	NN
22283	432	11	outside	outside	IN
22283	432	12	of	of	IN
22283	432	13	thought	thought	NN
22283	432	14	,	,	,
22283	432	15	whether	whether	IN
22283	432	16	there	there	EX
22283	432	17	be	be	VB
22283	432	18	such	such	JJ
22283	432	19	things	thing	NNS
22283	432	20	as	as	IN
22283	432	21	matter	matter	NN
22283	432	22	and	and	CC
22283	432	23	material	material	NN
22283	432	24	atoms	atom	NNS
22283	432	25	existing	exist	VBG
22283	432	26	in	in	IN
22283	432	27	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	432	28	before	before	IN
22283	432	29	any	any	DT
22283	432	30	mind	mind	NN
22283	432	31	begins	begin	VBZ
22283	432	32	to	to	TO
22283	432	33	perceive	perceive	VB
22283	432	34	or	or	CC
22283	432	35	think	think	VB
22283	432	36	about	about	IN
22283	432	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	432	38	,	,	,
22283	432	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	432	40	not	not	RB
22283	432	41	the	the	DT
22283	432	42	question	question	NN
22283	432	43	before	before	IN
22283	432	44	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	432	45	.	.	.
22283	433	1	If	if	IN
22283	433	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	433	3	were	be	VBD
22283	433	4	possible	possible	JJ
22283	433	5	to	to	TO
22283	433	6	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	433	7	of	of	IN
22283	433	8	such	such	JJ
22283	433	9	atoms	atom	NNS
22283	433	10	,	,	,
22283	433	11	at	at	IN
22283	433	12	any	any	DT
22283	433	13	rate	rate	NN
22283	433	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	433	15	,	,	,
22283	433	16	before	before	IN
22283	433	17	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	433	18	begin	begin	VBP
22283	433	19	to	to	TO
22283	433	20	make	make	VB
22283	433	21	anything	anything	NN
22283	433	22	of	of	IN
22283	433	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	433	24	,	,	,
22283	433	25	must	must	MD
22283	433	26	think	think	VB
22283	433	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	433	28	;	;	:
22283	433	29	and	and	CC
22283	433	30	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	433	31	can	can	MD
22283	433	32	never	never	RB
22283	433	33	,	,	,
22283	433	34	by	by	IN
22283	433	35	thinking	think	VBG
22283	433	36	about	about	IN
22283	433	37	atoms	atom	NNS
22283	433	38	,	,	,
22283	433	39	prove	prove	VBP
22283	433	40	that	that	IN
22283	433	41	there	there	EX
22283	433	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	433	43	no	no	DT
22283	433	44	such	such	JJ
22283	433	45	thing	thing	NN
22283	433	46	as	as	IN
22283	433	47	thought	thought	NN
22283	433	48	other	other	JJ
22283	433	49	than	than	IN
22283	433	50	as	as	IN
22283	433	51	an	an	DT
22283	433	52	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	433	53	product	product	NN
22283	433	54	of	of	IN
22283	433	55	atoms	atom	NNS
22283	433	56	.	.	.
22283	434	1	Before	before	IN
22283	434	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	434	3	could	could	MD
22283	434	4	reach	reach	VB
22283	434	5	thought	thought	NN
22283	434	6	or	or	CC
22283	434	7	mind	mind	NN
22283	434	8	as	as	IN
22283	434	9	a	a	DT
22283	434	10	last	last	JJ
22283	434	11	result	result	NN
22283	434	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	434	13	must	must	MD
22283	434	14	needs	needs	VB
22283	434	15	eliminate	eliminate	VB
22283	434	16	from	from	IN
22283	434	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	434	18	the	the	DT
22283	434	19	data	datum	NNS
22283	434	20	of	of	IN
22283	434	21	the	the	DT
22283	434	22	problem	problem	NN
22283	434	23	with	with	IN
22283	434	24	which	which	WDT
22283	434	25	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	434	26	start	start	VBP
22283	434	27	,	,	,
22283	434	28	and	and	CC
22283	434	29	that	that	IN
22283	434	30	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	434	31	can	can	MD
22283	434	32	never	never	RB
22283	434	33	do	do	VB
22283	434	34	,	,	,
22283	434	35	any	any	DT
22283	434	36	more	more	JJR
22283	434	37	than	than	IN
22283	434	38	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	434	39	can	can	MD
22283	434	40	stand	stand	VB
22283	434	41	on	on	IN
22283	434	42	your	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	434	43	own	own	JJ
22283	434	44	shoulders	shoulder	NNS
22283	434	45	or	or	CC
22283	434	46	outstrip	outstrip	VB
22283	434	47	your	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	434	48	own	own	JJ
22283	434	49	shadow	shadow	NN
22283	434	50	....	....	.
22283	435	1	In	in	IN
22283	435	2	one	one	CD
22283	435	3	word	word	NN
22283	435	4	,	,	,
22283	435	5	to	to	TO
22283	435	6	constitute	constitute	VB
22283	435	7	the	the	DT
22283	435	8	reality	reality	NN
22283	435	9	of	of	IN
22283	435	10	the	the	DT
22283	435	11	outward	outward	JJ
22283	435	12	world	world	NN
22283	435	13	--	--	:
22283	435	14	to	to	TO
22283	435	15	make	make	VB
22283	435	16	possible	possible	JJ
22283	435	17	the	the	DT
22283	435	18	minimum	minimum	NN
22283	435	19	of	of	IN
22283	435	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	435	21	,	,	,
22283	435	22	nay	nay	NN
22283	435	23	,	,	,
22283	435	24	the	the	DT
22283	435	25	very	very	JJ
22283	435	26	existence	existence	NN
22283	435	27	for	for	IN
22283	435	28	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	435	29	of	of	IN
22283	435	30	molecules	molecule	NNS
22283	435	31	and	and	CC
22283	435	32	atoms	atom	NNS
22283	435	33	--	--	:
22283	435	34	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	435	35	must	must	MD
22283	435	36	needs	needs	VB
22283	435	37	presuppose	presuppose	JJ
22283	435	38	that	that	WDT
22283	435	39	thought	thought	NN
22283	435	40	or	or	CC
22283	435	41	thinking	think	VBG
22283	435	42	self	self	NN
22283	435	43	,	,	,
22283	435	44	which	which	WDT
22283	435	45	some	some	DT
22283	435	46	would	would	MD
22283	435	47	persuade	persuade	VB
22283	435	48	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	435	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	435	50	to	to	TO
22283	435	51	be	be	VB
22283	435	52	educed	educe	VBN
22283	435	53	or	or	CC
22283	435	54	evolved	evolve	VBN
22283	435	55	from	from	IN
22283	435	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	435	57	....	....	.
22283	435	58	To	to	TO
22283	435	59	make	make	VB
22283	435	60	thought	think	VBN
22283	435	61	a	a	DT
22283	435	62	function	function	NN
22283	435	63	of	of	IN
22283	435	64	matter	matter	NN
22283	435	65	is	be	VBZ
22283	435	66	thus	thus	RB
22283	435	67	,	,	,
22283	435	68	simply	simply	RB
22283	435	69	,	,	,
22283	435	70	to	to	TO
22283	435	71	make	make	VB
22283	435	72	thought	think	VBN
22283	435	73	a	a	DT
22283	435	74	function	function	NN
22283	435	75	of	of	IN
22283	435	76	itself[5	itself[5	NNP
22283	435	77	]	]	-RRB-
22283	435	78	.	.	.
22283	435	79	'	'	''
22283	436	1	From	from	IN
22283	436	2	this	this	DT
22283	436	3	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	436	4	there	there	EX
22283	436	5	can	can	MD
22283	436	6	be	be	VB
22283	436	7	no	no	DT
22283	436	8	escape	escape	NN
22283	436	9	;	;	:
22283	436	10	and	and	CC
22283	436	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	436	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	436	13	more	more	RBR
22283	436	14	rational	rational	JJ
22283	436	15	for	for	IN
22283	436	16	a	a	DT
22283	436	17	man	man	NN
22283	436	18	to	to	TO
22283	436	19	believe	believe	VB
22283	436	20	that	that	IN
22283	436	21	colour	colour	NN
22283	436	22	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	436	23	as	as	IN
22283	436	24	such	such	JJ
22283	436	25	in	in	IN
22283	436	26	a	a	DT
22283	436	27	flower	flower	NN
22283	436	28	than	than	IN
22283	436	29	,	,	,
22283	436	30	after	after	IN
22283	436	31	having	have	VBG
22283	436	32	plainly	plainly	RB
22283	436	33	seen	see	VBN
22283	436	34	that	that	IN
22283	436	35	such	such	JJ
22283	436	36	can	can	MD
22283	436	37	not	not	RB
22283	436	38	be	be	VB
22283	436	39	the	the	DT
22283	436	40	case	case	NN
22283	436	41	,	,	,
22283	436	42	forthwith	forthwith	NNP
22283	436	43	to	to	TO
22283	436	44	disregard	disregard	VB
22283	436	45	the	the	DT
22283	436	46	teaching	teaching	NN
22283	436	47	of	of	IN
22283	436	48	this	this	DT
22283	436	49	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	436	50	,	,	,
22283	436	51	and	and	CC
22283	436	52	to	to	TO
22283	436	53	imagine	imagine	VB
22283	436	54	that	that	IN
22283	436	55	any	any	DT
22283	436	56	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	436	57	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	436	58	of	of	IN
22283	436	59	mind	mind	NN
22283	436	60	as	as	IN
22283	436	61	a	a	DT
22283	436	62	result	result	NN
22283	436	63	of	of	IN
22283	436	64	matter	matter	NN
22283	436	65	or	or	CC
22283	436	66	motion	motion	NN
22283	436	67	can	can	MD
22283	436	68	possibly	possibly	RB
22283	436	69	be	be	VB
22283	436	70	entertained	entertain	VBN
22283	436	71	as	as	IN
22283	436	72	real	real	JJ
22283	436	73	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	436	74	.	.	.
22283	437	1	Remembering	remembering	NN
22283	437	2	,	,	,
22283	437	3	then	then	RB
22283	437	4	,	,	,
22283	437	5	that	that	IN
22283	437	6	from	from	IN
22283	437	7	the	the	DT
22283	437	8	nature	nature	NN
22283	437	9	of	of	IN
22283	437	10	this	this	DT
22283	437	11	particular	particular	JJ
22283	437	12	case	case	NN
22283	437	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	437	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	437	15	as	as	RB
22283	437	16	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	437	17	for	for	IN
22283	437	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	437	19	to	to	TO
22283	437	20	prove	prove	VB
22283	437	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	437	22	own	own	JJ
22283	437	23	causation	causation	NN
22283	437	24	as	as	IN
22283	437	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	437	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	437	27	for	for	IN
22283	437	28	water	water	NN
22283	437	29	to	to	TO
22283	437	30	rise	rise	VB
22283	437	31	above	above	IN
22283	437	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	437	33	source	source	NN
22283	437	34	,	,	,
22283	437	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	437	36	may	may	MD
22283	437	37	still	still	RB
22283	437	38	be	be	VB
22283	437	39	well	well	JJ
22283	437	40	,	,	,
22283	437	41	for	for	IN
22283	437	42	the	the	DT
22283	437	43	sake	sake	NN
22283	437	44	of	of	IN
22283	437	45	further	further	JJ
22283	437	46	argument	argument	NN
22283	437	47	,	,	,
22283	437	48	to	to	TO
22283	437	49	sink	sink	VB
22283	437	50	this	this	DT
22283	437	51	general	general	JJ
22283	437	52	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	437	53	,	,	,
22283	437	54	and	and	CC
22283	437	55	to	to	TO
22283	437	56	regard	regard	VB
22283	437	57	such	such	JJ
22283	437	58	spurious	spurious	JJ
22283	437	59	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	437	60	of	of	IN
22283	437	61	causation	causation	NN
22283	437	62	as	as	IN
22283	437	63	is	be	VBZ
22283	437	64	presented	present	VBN
22283	437	65	by	by	IN
22283	437	66	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	437	67	,	,	,
22283	437	68	without	without	IN
22283	437	69	prejudice	prejudice	NN
22283	437	70	arising	arise	VBG
22283	437	71	from	from	IN
22283	437	72	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	437	73	being	be	VBG
22283	437	74	_	_	NNP
22283	437	75	primâ	primâ	NN
22283	437	76	facie	facie	NN
22283	437	77	_	_	NNP
22283	437	78	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
22283	437	79	.	.	.
22283	438	1	Materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	438	2	,	,	,
22283	438	3	as	as	IN
22283	438	4	already	already	RB
22283	438	5	observed	observe	VBN
22283	438	6	,	,	,
22283	438	7	are	be	VBP
22283	438	8	fond	fond	JJ
22283	438	9	of	of	IN
22283	438	10	saying	say	VBG
22283	438	11	that	that	IN
22283	438	12	the	the	DT
22283	438	13	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	438	14	of	of	IN
22283	438	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	438	16	from	from	IN
22283	438	17	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	438	18	to	to	IN
22283	438	19	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	438	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	438	21	as	as	RB
22283	438	22	good	good	JJ
22283	438	23	as	as	IN
22283	438	24	such	such	JJ
22283	438	25	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	438	26	can	can	MD
22283	438	27	be	be	VB
22283	438	28	proved	prove	VBN
22283	438	29	to	to	TO
22283	438	30	be	be	VB
22283	438	31	in	in	IN
22283	438	32	any	any	DT
22283	438	33	other	other	JJ
22283	438	34	case	case	NN
22283	438	35	.	.	.
22283	439	1	Now	now	RB
22283	439	2	,	,	,
22283	439	3	quite	quite	RB
22283	439	4	apart	apart	RB
22283	439	5	from	from	IN
22283	439	6	the	the	DT
22283	439	7	general	general	JJ
22283	439	8	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	439	9	just	just	RB
22283	439	10	adduced	adduce	VBD
22283	439	11	to	to	TO
22283	439	12	show	show	VB
22283	439	13	that	that	IN
22283	439	14	from	from	IN
22283	439	15	the	the	DT
22283	439	16	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
22283	439	17	nature	nature	NN
22283	439	18	of	of	IN
22283	439	19	this	this	DT
22283	439	20	case	case	NN
22283	439	21	there	there	EX
22283	439	22	can	can	MD
22283	439	23	here	here	RB
22283	439	24	be	be	VB
22283	439	25	no	no	DT
22283	439	26	such	such	JJ
22283	439	27	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	439	28	at	at	RB
22283	439	29	all	all	RB
22283	439	30	--	--	:
22283	439	31	quite	quite	RB
22283	439	32	apart	apart	RB
22283	439	33	from	from	IN
22283	439	34	this	this	DT
22283	439	35	,	,	,
22283	439	36	and	and	CC
22283	439	37	treating	treat	VBG
22283	439	38	the	the	DT
22283	439	39	problem	problem	NN
22283	439	40	on	on	IN
22283	439	41	the	the	DT
22283	439	42	lower	low	JJR
22283	439	43	ground	ground	NN
22283	439	44	of	of	IN
22283	439	45	the	the	DT
22283	439	46	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	439	47	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	439	48	,	,	,
22283	439	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	439	50	may	may	MD
22283	439	51	be	be	VB
22283	439	52	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	439	53	shown	show	VBN
22283	439	54	that	that	IN
22283	439	55	the	the	DT
22283	439	56	statement	statement	NN
22283	439	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	439	58	untrue	untrue	JJ
22283	439	59	.	.	.
22283	440	1	For	for	IN
22283	440	2	a	a	DT
22283	440	3	little	little	JJ
22283	440	4	thought	thought	NN
22283	440	5	will	will	MD
22283	440	6	show	show	VB
22283	440	7	that	that	IN
22283	440	8	in	in	IN
22283	440	9	point	point	NN
22283	440	10	of	of	IN
22283	440	11	fact	fact	NN
22283	440	12	the	the	DT
22283	440	13	only	only	JJ
22283	440	14	resemblance	resemblance	NN
22283	440	15	between	between	IN
22283	440	16	this	this	DT
22283	440	17	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	440	18	case	case	NN
22283	440	19	of	of	IN
22283	440	20	causation	causation	NN
22283	440	21	and	and	CC
22283	440	22	all	all	DT
22283	440	23	other	other	JJ
22283	440	24	cases	case	NNS
22283	440	25	of	of	IN
22283	440	26	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	440	27	causation	causation	NN
22283	440	28	,	,	,
22283	440	29	consists	consist	VBZ
22283	440	30	in	in	IN
22283	440	31	the	the	DT
22283	440	32	invariability	invariability	NN
22283	440	33	of	of	IN
22283	440	34	the	the	DT
22283	440	35	correlation	correlation	NN
22283	440	36	between	between	IN
22283	440	37	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	440	38	processes	process	NNS
22283	440	39	and	and	CC
22283	440	40	mental	mental	JJ
22283	440	41	processes	process	NNS
22283	440	42	;	;	:
22283	440	43	in	in	IN
22283	440	44	all	all	DT
22283	440	45	other	other	JJ
22283	440	46	points	point	NNS
22283	440	47	the	the	DT
22283	440	48	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	440	49	fails	fail	VBZ
22283	440	50	.	.	.
22283	441	1	For	for	IN
22283	441	2	in	in	IN
22283	441	3	all	all	DT
22283	441	4	cases	case	NNS
22283	441	5	of	of	IN
22283	441	6	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	441	7	causation	causation	NN
22283	441	8	there	there	EX
22283	441	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	441	10	a	a	DT
22283	441	11	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	441	12	_	_	NNP
22283	441	13	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	441	14	_	_	NNP
22283	441	15	between	between	IN
22283	441	16	the	the	DT
22283	441	17	cause	cause	NN
22283	441	18	and	and	CC
22283	441	19	the	the	DT
22283	441	20	effect	effect	NN
22283	441	21	;	;	:
22283	441	22	the	the	DT
22283	441	23	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
22283	441	24	are	be	VBP
22283	441	25	physical	physical	JJ
22283	441	26	,	,	,
22283	441	27	and	and	CC
22283	441	28	the	the	DT
22283	441	29	consequents	consequent	NNS
22283	441	30	are	be	VBP
22283	441	31	physical	physical	JJ
22283	441	32	.	.	.
22283	442	1	But	but	CC
22283	442	2	in	in	IN
22283	442	3	the	the	DT
22283	442	4	case	case	NN
22283	442	5	before	before	IN
22283	442	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	442	7	there	there	EX
22283	442	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	442	9	no	no	DT
22283	442	10	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	442	11	,	,	,
22283	442	12	or	or	CC
22283	442	13	even	even	RB
22283	442	14	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	442	15	,	,	,
22283	442	16	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	442	17	between	between	IN
22283	442	18	the	the	DT
22283	442	19	cause	cause	NN
22283	442	20	and	and	CC
22283	442	21	the	the	DT
22283	442	22	effect	effect	NN
22283	442	23	;	;	:
22283	442	24	for	for	IN
22283	442	25	the	the	DT
22283	442	26	causes	cause	NNS
22283	442	27	are	be	VBP
22283	442	28	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	442	29	to	to	TO
22283	442	30	be	be	VB
22283	442	31	physical	physical	JJ
22283	442	32	and	and	CC
22283	442	33	the	the	DT
22283	442	34	effects	effect	NNS
22283	442	35	mental	mental	JJ
22283	442	36	.	.	.
22283	443	1	And	and	CC
22283	443	2	the	the	DT
22283	443	3	antithesis	antithesis	NN
22283	443	4	thus	thus	RB
22283	443	5	posited	posit	VBD
22283	443	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	443	7	alone	alone	RB
22283	443	8	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	443	9	to	to	TO
22283	443	10	separate	separate	VB
22283	443	11	_	_	NNP
22283	443	12	toto	toto	NN
22283	443	13	coelo	coelo	NNP
22283	443	14	_	_	NNP
22283	443	15	the	the	DT
22283	443	16	case	case	NN
22283	443	17	of	of	IN
22283	443	18	causation	causation	NN
22283	443	19	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	443	20	from	from	IN
22283	443	21	that	that	DT
22283	443	22	of	of	IN
22283	443	23	all	all	DT
22283	443	24	cases	case	NNS
22283	443	25	of	of	IN
22283	443	26	causation	causation	NN
22283	443	27	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	443	28	.	.	.
22283	444	1	From	from	IN
22283	444	2	the	the	DT
22283	444	3	singularly	singularly	RB
22283	444	4	clear	clear	JJ
22283	444	5	and	and	CC
22283	444	6	well	well	RB
22283	444	7	-	-	HYPH
22283	444	8	balanced	balance	VBN
22283	444	9	statement	statement	NN
22283	444	10	of	of	IN
22283	444	11	this	this	DT
22283	444	12	subject	subject	NN
22283	444	13	given	give	VBN
22283	444	14	by	by	IN
22283	444	15	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	444	16	Allman	Allman	NNP
22283	444	17	in	in	IN
22283	444	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	444	19	Presidential	Presidential	NNP
22283	444	20	Address	Address	NNP
22283	444	21	before	before	IN
22283	444	22	the	the	DT
22283	444	23	British	British	NNP
22283	444	24	Association	Association	NNP
22283	444	25	,	,	,
22283	444	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	444	27	may	may	MD
22283	444	28	here	here	RB
22283	444	29	fitly	fitly	RB
22283	444	30	quote	quote	VB
22283	444	31	the	the	DT
22283	444	32	following:--	following:--	NN
22283	444	33	'	'	''
22283	444	34	If	if	IN
22283	444	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	444	36	could	could	MD
22283	444	37	see	see	VB
22283	444	38	any	any	DT
22283	444	39	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	444	40	between	between	IN
22283	444	41	thought	thought	NN
22283	444	42	and	and	CC
22283	444	43	any	any	DT
22283	444	44	one	one	CD
22283	444	45	of	of	IN
22283	444	46	the	the	DT
22283	444	47	admitted	admit	VBN
22283	444	48	phenomena	phenomena	NN
22283	444	49	of	of	IN
22283	444	50	matter	matter	NN
22283	444	51	,	,	,
22283	444	52	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	444	53	should	should	MD
22283	444	54	be	be	VB
22283	444	55	justified	justify	VBN
22283	444	56	in	in	IN
22283	444	57	the	the	DT
22283	444	58	first	first	JJ
22283	444	59	of	of	IN
22283	444	60	these	these	DT
22283	444	61	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
22283	444	62	(	(	-LRB-
22283	444	63	i.	i.	NNP
22283	444	64	e.	e.	NNP
22283	444	65	that	that	DT
22283	444	66	of	of	IN
22283	444	67	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	444	68	)	)	-RRB-
22283	444	69	as	as	IN
22283	444	70	the	the	DT
22283	444	71	simplest	simple	JJS
22283	444	72	,	,	,
22283	444	73	and	and	CC
22283	444	74	as	as	IN
22283	444	75	affording	afford	VBG
22283	444	76	a	a	DT
22283	444	77	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	444	78	most	most	RBS
22283	444	79	in	in	IN
22283	444	80	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	444	81	with	with	IN
22283	444	82	the	the	DT
22283	444	83	comprehensiveness	comprehensiveness	NN
22283	444	84	of	of	IN
22283	444	85	natural	natural	JJ
22283	444	86	laws	law	NNS
22283	444	87	;	;	:
22283	444	88	but	but	CC
22283	444	89	between	between	IN
22283	444	90	thought	thought	NN
22283	444	91	and	and	CC
22283	444	92	the	the	DT
22283	444	93	physical	physical	JJ
22283	444	94	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	444	95	of	of	IN
22283	444	96	matter	matter	NN
22283	444	97	there	there	EX
22283	444	98	is	be	VBZ
22283	444	99	not	not	RB
22283	444	100	only	only	RB
22283	444	101	no	no	DT
22283	444	102	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	444	103	,	,	,
22283	444	104	but	but	CC
22283	444	105	no	no	DT
22283	444	106	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	444	107	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	444	108	;	;	:
22283	444	109	and	and	CC
22283	444	110	the	the	DT
22283	444	111	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	444	112	and	and	CC
22283	444	113	continuous	continuous	JJ
22283	444	114	path	path	NN
22283	444	115	which	which	WDT
22283	444	116	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	444	117	have	have	VBP
22283	444	118	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
22283	444	119	followed	follow	VBN
22283	444	120	up	up	RP
22283	444	121	in	in	IN
22283	444	122	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	444	123	reasonings	reasoning	NNS
22283	444	124	from	from	IN
22283	444	125	the	the	DT
22283	444	126	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	444	127	of	of	IN
22283	444	128	lifeless	lifeless	JJ
22283	444	129	matter	matter	NN
22283	444	130	through	through	IN
22283	444	131	those	those	DT
22283	444	132	of	of	IN
22283	444	133	living	living	NN
22283	444	134	matter	matter	NN
22283	444	135	here	here	RB
22283	444	136	comes	come	VBZ
22283	444	137	suddenly	suddenly	RB
22283	444	138	to	to	IN
22283	444	139	an	an	DT
22283	444	140	end	end	NN
22283	444	141	.	.	.
22283	445	1	The	the	DT
22283	445	2	chasm	chasm	NN
22283	445	3	between	between	IN
22283	445	4	unconscious	unconscious	JJ
22283	445	5	life	life	NN
22283	445	6	and	and	CC
22283	445	7	thought	thought	NN
22283	445	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	445	9	deep	deep	JJ
22283	445	10	and	and	CC
22283	445	11	impassable	impassable	JJ
22283	445	12	,	,	,
22283	445	13	and	and	CC
22283	445	14	no	no	DT
22283	445	15	transitional	transitional	JJ
22283	445	16	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	445	17	can	can	MD
22283	445	18	be	be	VB
22283	445	19	found	find	VBN
22283	445	20	by	by	IN
22283	445	21	which	which	WDT
22283	445	22	,	,	,
22283	445	23	as	as	IN
22283	445	24	by	by	IN
22283	445	25	a	a	DT
22283	445	26	bridge	bridge	NN
22283	445	27	,	,	,
22283	445	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	445	29	may	may	MD
22283	445	30	span	span	VB
22283	445	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	445	32	over[6	over[6	.
22283	445	33	]	]	-RRB-
22283	445	34	.	.	.
22283	445	35	'	'	''
22283	446	1	And	and	CC
22283	446	2	,	,	,
22283	446	3	not	not	RB
22283	446	4	unduly	unduly	RB
22283	446	5	to	to	TO
22283	446	6	multiply	multiply	VB
22283	446	7	quotations	quotation	NNS
22283	446	8	,	,	,
22283	446	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	446	10	shall	shall	MD
22283	446	11	only	only	RB
22283	446	12	adduce	adduce	VB
22283	446	13	one	one	CD
22283	446	14	more	more	JJR
22283	446	15	from	from	IN
22283	446	16	another	another	DT
22283	446	17	of	of	IN
22283	446	18	the	the	DT
22283	446	19	few	few	JJ
22283	446	20	eminent	eminent	JJ
22283	446	21	men	man	NNS
22283	446	22	of	of	IN
22283	446	23	science	science	NN
22283	446	24	who	who	WP
22283	446	25	have	have	VBP
22283	446	26	seen	see	VBN
22283	446	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	446	28	way	way	NN
22283	446	29	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	446	30	in	in	IN
22283	446	31	this	this	DT
22283	446	32	matter	matter	NN
22283	446	33	,	,	,
22283	446	34	and	and	CC
22283	446	35	have	have	VBP
22283	446	36	expressed	express	VBN
22283	446	37	what	what	WP
22283	446	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	446	39	have	have	VBP
22283	446	40	seen	see	VBN
22283	446	41	in	in	IN
22283	446	42	language	language	NN
22283	446	43	as	as	RB
22283	446	44	clear	clear	JJ
22283	446	45	as	as	IN
22283	446	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	446	47	vision	vision	NN
22283	446	48	.	.	.
22283	447	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	447	2	Tyndall	Tyndall	NNP
22283	447	3	writes:--	writes:--	NNP
22283	447	4	'	'	''
22283	447	5	The	the	DT
22283	447	6	passage	passage	NN
22283	447	7	from	from	IN
22283	447	8	the	the	DT
22283	447	9	physics	physics	NN
22283	447	10	of	of	IN
22283	447	11	the	the	DT
22283	447	12	brain	brain	NN
22283	447	13	to	to	IN
22283	447	14	the	the	DT
22283	447	15	corresponding	correspond	VBG
22283	447	16	facts	fact	NNS
22283	447	17	of	of	IN
22283	447	18	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	447	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	447	20	unthinkable	unthinkable	JJ
22283	447	21	.	.	.
22283	448	1	Granted	grant	VBN
22283	448	2	that	that	IN
22283	448	3	a	a	DT
22283	448	4	definite	definite	JJ
22283	448	5	thought	thought	NN
22283	448	6	and	and	CC
22283	448	7	a	a	DT
22283	448	8	definite	definite	JJ
22283	448	9	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	448	10	action	action	NN
22283	448	11	in	in	IN
22283	448	12	the	the	DT
22283	448	13	brain	brain	NN
22283	448	14	occur	occur	VBP
22283	448	15	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
22283	448	16	,	,	,
22283	448	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	448	18	do	do	VBP
22283	448	19	not	not	RB
22283	448	20	possess	possess	VB
22283	448	21	the	the	DT
22283	448	22	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
22283	448	23	organ	organ	NN
22283	448	24	,	,	,
22283	448	25	nor	nor	CC
22283	448	26	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	448	27	any	any	DT
22283	448	28	rudiment	rudiment	NN
22283	448	29	of	of	IN
22283	448	30	the	the	DT
22283	448	31	organ	organ	NN
22283	448	32	,	,	,
22283	448	33	which	which	WDT
22283	448	34	would	would	MD
22283	448	35	enable	enable	VB
22283	448	36	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	448	37	to	to	TO
22283	448	38	pass	pass	VB
22283	448	39	,	,	,
22283	448	40	by	by	IN
22283	448	41	a	a	DT
22283	448	42	process	process	NN
22283	448	43	of	of	IN
22283	448	44	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	448	45	,	,	,
22283	448	46	from	from	IN
22283	448	47	the	the	DT
22283	448	48	one	one	CD
22283	448	49	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
22283	448	50	to	to	IN
22283	448	51	the	the	DT
22283	448	52	other	other	JJ
22283	448	53	.	.	.
22283	449	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
22283	449	2	appear	appear	VBP
22283	449	3	together	together	RB
22283	449	4	but	but	CC
22283	449	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	449	6	do	do	VBP
22283	449	7	not	not	RB
22283	449	8	know	know	VB
22283	449	9	why	why	WRB
22283	449	10	.	.	.
22283	450	1	Were	be	VBD
22283	450	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	450	3	minds	mind	NNS
22283	450	4	and	and	CC
22283	450	5	senses	sense	NNS
22283	450	6	so	so	RB
22283	450	7	expanded	expanded	JJ
22283	450	8	,	,	,
22283	450	9	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
22283	450	10	,	,	,
22283	450	11	and	and	CC
22283	450	12	illuminated	illuminate	VBN
22283	450	13	,	,	,
22283	450	14	as	as	IN
22283	450	15	to	to	TO
22283	450	16	enable	enable	VB
22283	450	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	450	18	to	to	TO
22283	450	19	see	see	VB
22283	450	20	and	and	CC
22283	450	21	feel	feel	VB
22283	450	22	the	the	DT
22283	450	23	very	very	JJ
22283	450	24	molecules	molecule	NNS
22283	450	25	of	of	IN
22283	450	26	the	the	DT
22283	450	27	brain	brain	NN
22283	450	28	;	;	:
22283	450	29	were	be	VBD
22283	450	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	450	31	capable	capable	JJ
22283	450	32	of	of	IN
22283	450	33	following	follow	VBG
22283	450	34	all	all	PDT
22283	450	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	450	36	motions	motion	NNS
22283	450	37	,	,	,
22283	450	38	all	all	DT
22283	450	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	450	40	groupings	grouping	NNS
22283	450	41	,	,	,
22283	450	42	all	all	DT
22283	450	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	450	44	electrical	electrical	JJ
22283	450	45	discharges	discharge	NNS
22283	450	46	,	,	,
22283	450	47	if	if	IN
22283	450	48	such	such	JJ
22283	450	49	there	there	EX
22283	450	50	be	be	VB
22283	450	51	;	;	:
22283	450	52	and	and	CC
22283	450	53	were	be	VBD
22283	450	54	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	450	55	intimately	intimately	RB
22283	450	56	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
22283	450	57	with	with	IN
22283	450	58	the	the	DT
22283	450	59	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	450	60	states	state	NNS
22283	450	61	of	of	IN
22283	450	62	thought	thought	NN
22283	450	63	and	and	CC
22283	450	64	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	450	65	,	,	,
22283	450	66	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	450	67	should	should	MD
22283	450	68	be	be	VB
22283	450	69	as	as	RB
22283	450	70	far	far	RB
22283	450	71	as	as	IN
22283	450	72	ever	ever	RB
22283	450	73	from	from	IN
22283	450	74	the	the	DT
22283	450	75	solution	solution	NN
22283	450	76	of	of	IN
22283	450	77	the	the	DT
22283	450	78	problem	problem	NN
22283	450	79	.	.	.
22283	451	1	How	how	WRB
22283	451	2	are	be	VBP
22283	451	3	these	these	DT
22283	451	4	physical	physical	JJ
22283	451	5	processes	process	NNS
22283	451	6	connected	connect	VBN
22283	451	7	with	with	IN
22283	451	8	the	the	DT
22283	451	9	facts	fact	NNS
22283	451	10	of	of	IN
22283	451	11	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	451	12	?	?	.
22283	452	1	The	the	DT
22283	452	2	chasm	chasm	NN
22283	452	3	between	between	IN
22283	452	4	the	the	DT
22283	452	5	two	two	CD
22283	452	6	classes	class	NNS
22283	452	7	of	of	IN
22283	452	8	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	452	9	would	would	MD
22283	452	10	still	still	RB
22283	452	11	remain	remain	VB
22283	452	12	intellectually	intellectually	RB
22283	452	13	impassable[7	impassable[7	NNP
22283	452	14	]	]	-RRB-
22283	452	15	.	.	.
22283	452	16	'	'	''
22283	453	1	Next	next	RB
22283	453	2	,	,	,
22283	453	3	in	in	IN
22283	453	4	all	all	DT
22283	453	5	cases	case	NNS
22283	453	6	of	of	IN
22283	453	7	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	453	8	causation	causation	NN
22283	453	9	there	there	EX
22283	453	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	453	11	a	a	DT
22283	453	12	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	453	13	_	_	NNP
22283	453	14	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	453	15	_	_	NNP
22283	453	16	between	between	IN
22283	453	17	cause	cause	NN
22283	453	18	and	and	CC
22283	453	19	effect	effect	NN
22283	453	20	,	,	,
22283	453	21	such	such	JJ
22283	453	22	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	453	23	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	453	24	to	to	IN
22283	453	25	the	the	DT
22283	453	26	very	very	JJ
22283	453	27	essence	essence	NN
22283	453	28	of	of	IN
22283	453	29	that	that	DT
22283	453	30	in	in	IN
22283	453	31	which	which	WDT
22283	453	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	453	33	conceive	conceive	VBP
22283	453	34	causation	causation	NN
22283	453	35	to	to	TO
22283	453	36	consist	consist	VB
22283	453	37	.	.	.
22283	454	1	But	but	CC
22283	454	2	as	as	IN
22283	454	3	between	between	IN
22283	454	4	matter	matter	NN
22283	454	5	and	and	CC
22283	454	6	motion	motion	NN
22283	454	7	on	on	IN
22283	454	8	the	the	DT
22283	454	9	one	one	CD
22283	454	10	side	side	NN
22283	454	11	,	,	,
22283	454	12	and	and	CC
22283	454	13	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	454	14	and	and	CC
22283	454	15	thought	think	VBD
22283	454	16	on	on	IN
22283	454	17	the	the	DT
22283	454	18	other	other	JJ
22283	454	19	,	,	,
22283	454	20	there	there	EX
22283	454	21	can	can	MD
22283	454	22	be	be	VB
22283	454	23	no	no	DT
22283	454	24	such	such	JJ
22283	454	25	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	454	26	conceivable	conceivable	NN
22283	454	27	.	.	.
22283	455	1	That	that	IN
22283	455	2	no	no	DT
22283	455	3	such	such	JJ
22283	455	4	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	455	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	455	6	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	455	7	may	may	MD
22283	455	8	be	be	VB
22283	455	9	rendered	render	VBN
22283	455	10	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	455	11	on	on	IN
22283	455	12	grounds	ground	NNS
22283	455	13	of	of	IN
22283	455	14	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	455	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	455	16	.	.	.
22283	456	1	For	for	IN
22283	456	2	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	456	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	456	4	bound	bind	VBN
22283	456	5	to	to	TO
22283	456	6	accept	accept	VB
22283	456	7	the	the	DT
22283	456	8	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	456	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	456	10	of	of	IN
22283	456	11	modern	modern	JJ
22283	456	12	physics	physics	NN
22283	456	13	--	--	:
22283	456	14	that	that	IN
22283	456	15	,	,	,
22283	456	16	viz	viz	NN
22283	456	17	.	.	.
22283	457	1	as	as	IN
22283	457	2	to	to	IN
22283	457	3	the	the	DT
22283	457	4	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	457	5	of	of	IN
22283	457	6	energy	energy	NN
22283	457	7	--	--	:
22283	457	8	and	and	CC
22283	457	9	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	457	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	457	11	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	457	12	evident	evident	JJ
22283	457	13	that	that	IN
22283	457	14	unless	unless	IN
22283	457	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	457	16	assimilate	assimilate	VBP
22283	457	17	thought	think	VBD
22283	457	18	with	with	IN
22283	457	19	energy	energy	NN
22283	457	20	,	,	,
22283	457	21	there	there	EX
22283	457	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	457	23	no	no	DT
22283	457	24	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	457	25	of	of	IN
22283	457	26	a	a	DT
22283	457	27	causal	causal	JJ
22283	457	28	relation	relation	NN
22283	457	29	,	,	,
22283	457	30	or	or	CC
22283	457	31	a	a	DT
22283	457	32	relation	relation	NN
22283	457	33	of	of	IN
22283	457	34	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	457	35	,	,	,
22283	457	36	as	as	IN
22283	457	37	obtaining	obtain	VBG
22283	457	38	between	between	IN
22283	457	39	the	the	DT
22283	457	40	one	one	NN
22283	457	41	and	and	CC
22283	457	42	the	the	DT
22283	457	43	other	other	JJ
22283	457	44	.	.	.
22283	458	1	For	for	IN
22283	458	2	however	however	RB
22283	458	3	little	little	JJ
22283	458	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	458	5	may	may	MD
22283	458	6	know	know	VB
22283	458	7	about	about	IN
22283	458	8	brain	brain	NN
22283	458	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	458	10	dynamics	dynamic	NNS
22283	458	11	,	,	,
22283	458	12	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	458	13	,	,	,
22283	458	14	at	at	IN
22283	458	15	least	least	JJS
22283	458	16	,	,	,
22283	458	17	must	must	MD
22283	458	18	take	take	VB
22283	458	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	458	20	for	for	IN
22283	458	21	granted	grant	VBN
22283	458	22	that	that	IN
22283	458	23	in	in	IN
22283	458	24	every	every	DT
22283	458	25	process	process	NN
22283	458	26	of	of	IN
22283	458	27	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	458	28	the	the	DT
22283	458	29	matter	matter	NN
22283	458	30	and	and	CC
22283	458	31	force	force	NN
22283	458	32	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	458	33	are	be	VBP
22283	458	34	indestructible	indestructible	JJ
22283	458	35	quantities	quantity	NNS
22283	458	36	,	,	,
22283	458	37	and	and	CC
22283	458	38	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	458	39	that	that	IN
22283	458	40	all	all	PDT
22283	458	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	458	42	possible	possible	JJ
22283	458	43	equations	equation	NNS
22283	458	44	are	be	VBP
22283	458	45	fully	fully	RB
22283	458	46	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
22283	458	47	,	,	,
22283	458	48	could	could	MD
22283	458	49	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	458	50	but	but	CC
22283	458	51	follow	follow	VB
22283	458	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	458	53	out	out	RP
22283	458	54	.	.	.
22283	459	1	Howsoever	howsoever	NN
22283	459	2	complex	complex	NN
22283	459	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	459	4	may	may	MD
22283	459	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	459	6	the	the	DT
22283	459	7	flux	flux	NN
22283	459	8	and	and	CC
22283	459	9	reflux	reflux	NN
22283	459	10	of	of	IN
22283	459	11	forces	force	NNS
22283	459	12	to	to	TO
22283	459	13	be	be	VB
22283	459	14	within	within	IN
22283	459	15	the	the	DT
22283	459	16	structure	structure	NN
22283	459	17	of	of	IN
22283	459	18	a	a	DT
22283	459	19	living	live	VBG
22283	459	20	brain	brain	NN
22283	459	21	,	,	,
22283	459	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	459	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	459	24	no	no	DT
22283	459	25	more	more	RBR
22283	459	26	possible	possible	JJ
22283	459	27	for	for	IN
22283	459	28	any	any	DT
22283	459	29	one	one	CD
22283	459	30	of	of	IN
22283	459	31	the	the	DT
22283	459	32	forces	force	NNS
22283	459	33	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	459	34	to	to	TO
22283	459	35	escape	escape	VB
22283	459	36	from	from	IN
22283	459	37	brain	brain	NN
22283	459	38	to	to	IN
22283	459	39	mind	mind	NN
22283	459	40	,	,	,
22283	459	41	than	than	IN
22283	459	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	459	43	would	would	MD
22283	459	44	be	be	VB
22283	459	45	for	for	IN
22283	459	46	such	such	PDT
22283	459	47	an	an	DT
22283	459	48	escape	escape	NN
22283	459	49	to	to	TO
22283	459	50	occur	occur	VB
22283	459	51	in	in	IN
22283	459	52	a	a	DT
22283	459	53	steam	steam	NN
22283	459	54	-	-	HYPH
22283	459	55	engine	engine	NN
22283	459	56	or	or	CC
22283	459	57	a	a	DT
22283	459	58	watch	watch	NN
22283	459	59	;	;	:
22283	459	60	the	the	DT
22283	459	61	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	459	62	of	of	IN
22283	459	63	the	the	DT
22283	459	64	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	459	65	of	of	IN
22283	459	66	energy	energy	NN
22283	459	67	forms	form	NNS
22283	459	68	an	an	DT
22283	459	69	insuperable	insuperable	JJ
22283	459	70	bar	bar	NN
22283	459	71	to	to	IN
22283	459	72	the	the	DT
22283	459	73	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	459	74	that	that	IN
22283	459	75	any	any	DT
22283	459	76	equation	equation	NN
22283	459	77	in	in	IN
22283	459	78	the	the	DT
22283	459	79	region	region	NN
22283	459	80	of	of	IN
22283	459	81	physics	physics	NN
22283	459	82	can	can	MD
22283	459	83	be	be	VB
22283	459	84	left	leave	VBN
22283	459	85	unsatisfied	unsatisfied	JJ
22283	459	86	,	,	,
22283	459	87	in	in	IN
22283	459	88	order	order	NN
22283	459	89	to	to	TO
22283	459	90	pass	pass	VB
22283	459	91	over	over	RP
22283	459	92	and	and	CC
22283	459	93	satisfy	satisfy	VB
22283	459	94	some	some	DT
22283	459	95	other	other	JJ
22283	459	96	equation	equation	NN
22283	459	97	in	in	IN
22283	459	98	the	the	DT
22283	459	99	region	region	NN
22283	459	100	of	of	IN
22283	459	101	psychics	psychic	NNS
22283	459	102	.	.	.
22283	460	1	Of	of	RB
22283	460	2	course	course	RB
22283	460	3	in	in	IN
22283	460	4	saying	say	VBG
22283	460	5	this	this	DT
22283	460	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	460	7	am	be	VBP
22283	460	8	aware	aware	JJ
22283	460	9	that	that	IN
22283	460	10	some	some	DT
22283	460	11	of	of	IN
22283	460	12	the	the	DT
22283	460	13	more	more	RBR
22283	460	14	clear	clear	JJ
22283	460	15	-	-	HYPH
22283	460	16	sighted	sighted	JJ
22283	460	17	of	of	IN
22283	460	18	the	the	DT
22283	460	19	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	460	20	have	have	VBP
22283	460	21	plainly	plainly	RB
22283	460	22	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	460	23	this	this	DT
22283	460	24	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	460	25	in	in	IN
22283	460	26	all	all	DT
22283	460	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	460	28	magnitude	magnitude	NN
22283	460	29	,	,	,
22283	460	30	and	and	CC
22283	460	31	so	so	RB
22283	460	32	have	have	VBP
22283	460	33	felt	feel	VBN
22283	460	34	that	that	IN
22283	460	35	unless	unless	IN
22283	460	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	460	37	can	can	MD
22283	460	38	be	be	VB
22283	460	39	met	meet	VBN
22283	460	40	,	,	,
22283	460	41	any	any	DT
22283	460	42	theory	theory	NN
22283	460	43	of	of	IN
22283	460	44	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	460	45	must	must	MD
22283	460	46	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	460	47	contain	contain	VB
22283	460	48	a	a	DT
22283	460	49	radical	radical	JJ
22283	460	50	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	460	51	of	of	IN
22283	460	52	principles	principle	NNS
22283	460	53	.	.	.
22283	461	1	Some	some	DT
22283	461	2	few	few	JJ
22283	461	3	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	461	4	have	have	VBP
22283	461	5	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	461	6	sought	seek	VBN
22283	461	7	to	to	TO
22283	461	8	meet	meet	VB
22283	461	9	the	the	DT
22283	461	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	461	11	in	in	IN
22283	461	12	the	the	DT
22283	461	13	only	only	JJ
22283	461	14	way	way	NN
22283	461	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	461	16	can	can	MD
22283	461	17	be	be	VB
22283	461	18	met	meet	VBN
22283	461	19	,	,	,
22283	461	20	viz	viz	NN
22283	461	21	.	.	.
22283	462	1	by	by	IN
22283	462	2	boldly	boldly	RB
22283	462	3	asserting	assert	VBG
22283	462	4	the	the	DT
22283	462	5	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	462	6	of	of	IN
22283	462	7	thought	thought	NN
22283	462	8	and	and	CC
22283	462	9	energy	energy	NN
22283	462	10	being	be	VBG
22283	462	11	transmutable	transmutable	JJ
22283	462	12	.	.	.
22283	463	1	On	on	IN
22283	463	2	this	this	DT
22283	463	3	view	view	NN
22283	463	4	thought	think	VBD
22283	463	5	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	463	6	a	a	DT
22283	463	7	mode	mode	NN
22283	463	8	of	of	IN
22283	463	9	motion	motion	NN
22283	463	10	,	,	,
22283	463	11	and	and	CC
22283	463	12	takes	take	VBZ
22283	463	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	463	14	rank	rank	NN
22283	463	15	among	among	IN
22283	463	16	the	the	DT
22283	463	17	forces	force	NNS
22283	463	18	as	as	IN
22283	463	19	identical	identical	JJ
22283	463	20	in	in	IN
22283	463	21	nature	nature	NN
22283	463	22	with	with	IN
22283	463	23	heat	heat	NN
22283	463	24	,	,	,
22283	463	25	light	light	NN
22283	463	26	,	,	,
22283	463	27	electricity	electricity	NN
22283	463	28	,	,	,
22283	463	29	and	and	CC
22283	463	30	the	the	DT
22283	463	31	rest	rest	NN
22283	463	32	.	.	.
22283	464	1	But	but	CC
22283	464	2	this	this	DT
22283	464	3	view	view	NN
22283	464	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	464	5	also	also	RB
22283	464	6	inherently	inherently	RB
22283	464	7	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	464	8	.	.	.
22283	465	1	For	for	IN
22283	465	2	suppose	suppose	NN
22283	465	3	,	,	,
22283	465	4	as	as	IN
22283	465	5	a	a	DT
22283	465	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	465	7	of	of	IN
22283	465	8	argument	argument	NN
22283	465	9	,	,	,
22283	465	10	that	that	IN
22283	465	11	physiologists	physiologist	NNS
22283	465	12	should	should	MD
22283	465	13	discover	discover	VB
22283	465	14	a	a	DT
22283	465	15	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	465	16	equivalent	equivalent	NN
22283	465	17	of	of	IN
22283	465	18	thought	thought	NN
22283	465	19	,	,	,
22283	465	20	so	so	IN
22283	465	21	that	that	IN
22283	465	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	465	23	might	may	MD
22283	465	24	estimate	estimate	VB
22283	465	25	the	the	DT
22283	465	26	value	value	NN
22283	465	27	of	of	IN
22283	465	28	a	a	DT
22283	465	29	calculation	calculation	NN
22283	465	30	in	in	IN
22283	465	31	thermal	thermal	JJ
22283	465	32	units	unit	NNS
22283	465	33	,	,	,
22283	465	34	or	or	CC
22283	465	35	the	the	DT
22283	465	36	'	'	``
22283	465	37	labour	labour	NN
22283	465	38	of	of	IN
22283	465	39	love	love	NN
22283	465	40	'	'	''
22283	465	41	in	in	IN
22283	465	42	foot	foot	NN
22283	465	43	-	-	HYPH
22283	465	44	pounds	pound	NNS
22283	465	45	:	:	:
22283	465	46	still	still	RB
22283	465	47	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	465	48	should	should	MD
22283	465	49	not	not	RB
22283	465	50	be	be	VB
22283	465	51	out	out	IN
22283	465	52	of	of	IN
22283	465	53	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	465	54	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	465	55	;	;	:
22283	465	56	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	465	57	should	should	MD
22283	465	58	only	only	RB
22283	465	59	have	have	VB
22283	465	60	to	to	TO
22283	465	61	cut	cut	VB
22283	465	62	a	a	DT
22283	465	63	twist	twist	NN
22283	465	64	of	of	IN
22283	465	65	flax	flax	NN
22283	465	66	to	to	TO
22283	465	67	find	find	VB
22283	465	68	a	a	DT
22283	465	69	lock	lock	NN
22283	465	70	of	of	IN
22283	465	71	iron	iron	NN
22283	465	72	.	.	.
22283	466	1	For	for	IN
22283	466	2	by	by	IN
22283	466	3	thus	thus	RB
22283	466	4	assimilating	assimilate	VBG
22283	466	5	thought	think	VBN
22283	466	6	with	with	IN
22283	466	7	energy	energy	NN
22283	466	8	,	,	,
22283	466	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	466	10	should	should	MD
22283	466	11	in	in	IN
22283	466	12	no	no	DT
22283	466	13	wise	wise	JJ
22283	466	14	have	have	VBP
22283	466	15	explained	explain	VBN
22283	466	16	the	the	DT
22283	466	17	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	466	18	antithesis	antithesis	NN
22283	466	19	between	between	IN
22283	466	20	subject	subject	NN
22283	466	21	and	and	CC
22283	466	22	object	object	NN
22283	466	23	.	.	.
22283	467	1	The	the	DT
22283	467	2	fact	fact	NN
22283	467	3	would	would	MD
22283	467	4	remain	remain	VB
22283	467	5	,	,	,
22283	467	6	if	if	IN
22283	467	7	possible	possible	JJ
22283	467	8	,	,	,
22283	467	9	more	more	RBR
22283	467	10	unaccountable	unaccountable	JJ
22283	467	11	than	than	IN
22283	467	12	ever	ever	RB
22283	467	13	,	,	,
22283	467	14	that	that	DT
22283	467	15	mind	mind	NN
22283	467	16	should	should	MD
22283	467	17	present	present	VB
22283	467	18	absolutely	absolutely	RB
22283	467	19	no	no	DT
22283	467	20	point	point	NN
22283	467	21	of	of	IN
22283	467	22	real	real	JJ
22283	467	23	analogy	analogy	NN
22283	467	24	with	with	IN
22283	467	25	motion	motion	NN
22283	467	26	.	.	.
22283	468	1	Involved	involve	VBN
22283	468	2	with	with	IN
22283	468	3	the	the	DT
22283	468	4	essential	essential	JJ
22283	468	5	idea	idea	NN
22283	468	6	of	of	IN
22283	468	7	motion	motion	NN
22283	468	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	468	9	the	the	DT
22283	468	10	idea	idea	NN
22283	468	11	of	of	IN
22283	468	12	extension	extension	NN
22283	468	13	;	;	:
22283	468	14	suppress	suppress	VB
22283	468	15	the	the	DT
22283	468	16	latter	latter	JJ
22283	468	17	and	and	CC
22283	468	18	the	the	DT
22283	468	19	former	former	JJ
22283	468	20	must	must	MD
22283	468	21	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	468	22	vanish	vanish	VB
22283	468	23	,	,	,
22283	468	24	for	for	IN
22283	468	25	motion	motion	NN
22283	468	26	only	only	RB
22283	468	27	means	mean	VBZ
22283	468	28	transition	transition	NN
22283	468	29	in	in	IN
22283	468	30	space	space	NN
22283	468	31	of	of	IN
22283	468	32	something	something	NN
22283	468	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	468	34	extended	extend	VBD
22283	468	35	.	.	.
22283	469	1	But	but	CC
22283	469	2	thought	think	VBD
22283	469	3	,	,	,
22283	469	4	as	as	RB
22283	469	5	far	far	RB
22283	469	6	as	as	IN
22283	469	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	469	8	can	can	MD
22283	469	9	possibly	possibly	RB
22283	469	10	know	know	VB
22283	469	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	469	12	,	,	,
22283	469	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	469	14	known	know	VBN
22283	469	15	and	and	CC
22283	469	16	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	469	17	by	by	IN
22283	469	18	the	the	DT
22283	469	19	very	very	JJ
22283	469	20	peculiarity	peculiarity	NN
22283	469	21	of	of	IN
22283	469	22	not	not	RB
22283	469	23	having	have	VBG
22283	469	24	extension	extension	NN
22283	469	25	.	.	.
22283	470	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	470	2	,	,	,
22283	470	3	even	even	RB
22283	470	4	if	if	IN
22283	470	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	470	6	were	be	VBD
22283	470	7	to	to	TO
22283	470	8	find	find	VB
22283	470	9	a	a	DT
22283	470	10	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	470	11	equivalent	equivalent	NN
22283	470	12	of	of	IN
22283	470	13	thought	thought	NN
22283	470	14	,	,	,
22283	470	15	thought	thought	NN
22283	470	16	would	would	MD
22283	470	17	still	still	RB
22283	470	18	not	not	RB
22283	470	19	be	be	VB
22283	470	20	proved	prove	VBN
22283	470	21	a	a	DT
22283	470	22	mode	mode	NN
22283	470	23	of	of	IN
22283	470	24	motion	motion	NN
22283	470	25	.	.	.
22283	471	1	On	on	IN
22283	471	2	the	the	DT
22283	471	3	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	471	4	,	,	,
22283	471	5	what	what	WP
22283	471	6	would	would	MD
22283	471	7	be	be	VB
22283	471	8	proved	prove	VBN
22283	471	9	would	would	MD
22283	471	10	be	be	VB
22283	471	11	that	that	IN
22283	471	12	,	,	,
22283	471	13	in	in	IN
22283	471	14	becoming	become	VBG
22283	471	15	transformed	transform	VBN
22283	471	16	into	into	IN
22283	471	17	thought	thought	NN
22283	471	18	,	,	,
22283	471	19	energy	energy	NN
22283	471	20	had	have	VBD
22283	471	21	ceased	cease	VBN
22283	471	22	to	to	TO
22283	471	23	be	be	VB
22283	471	24	energy	energy	NN
22283	471	25	;	;	:
22283	471	26	in	in	IN
22283	471	27	passing	pass	VBG
22283	471	28	out	out	IN
22283	471	29	of	of	IN
22283	471	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	471	31	relation	relation	NN
22283	471	32	to	to	IN
22283	471	33	space	space	NN
22283	471	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	471	35	would	would	MD
22283	471	36	cease	cease	VB
22283	471	37	to	to	TO
22283	471	38	exist	exist	VB
22283	471	39	as	as	IN
22283	471	40	energy	energy	NN
22283	471	41	,	,	,
22283	471	42	and	and	CC
22283	471	43	if	if	IN
22283	471	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	471	45	again	again	RB
22283	471	46	passed	pass	VBD
22283	471	47	into	into	IN
22283	471	48	that	that	DT
22283	471	49	relation	relation	NN
22283	471	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	471	51	would	would	MD
22283	471	52	only	only	RB
22283	471	53	be	be	VB
22283	471	54	by	by	IN
22283	471	55	starting	start	VBG
22283	471	56	_	_	NNP
22283	471	57	de	de	NNP
22283	471	58	novo	novo	NNP
22283	471	59	_	_	NNP
22283	471	60	on	on	IN
22283	471	61	a	a	DT
22283	471	62	new	new	JJ
22283	471	63	course	course	NN
22283	471	64	of	of	IN
22283	471	65	history	history	NN
22283	471	66	.	.	.
22283	472	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	472	2	the	the	DT
22283	472	3	proof	proof	NN
22283	472	4	that	that	WDT
22283	472	5	thought	think	VBD
22283	472	6	has	have	VBZ
22283	472	7	a	a	DT
22283	472	8	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	472	9	equivalent	equivalent	NN
22283	472	10	would	would	MD
22283	472	11	simply	simply	RB
22283	472	12	amount	amount	VB
22283	472	13	to	to	IN
22283	472	14	the	the	DT
22283	472	15	proof	proof	NN
22283	472	16	,	,	,
22283	472	17	not	not	RB
22283	472	18	that	that	DT
22283	472	19	thought	think	VBD
22283	472	20	_	_	NNP
22283	472	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	472	22	_	_	NNP
22283	472	23	energy	energy	NN
22283	472	24	,	,	,
22283	472	25	but	but	CC
22283	472	26	that	that	DT
22283	472	27	thought	think	VBD
22283	472	28	_	_	NNP
22283	472	29	destroys	destroy	NNS
22283	472	30	_	_	NNP
22283	472	31	energy	energy	NN
22283	472	32	.	.	.
22283	473	1	And	and	CC
22283	473	2	if	if	IN
22283	473	3	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	473	4	were	be	VBD
22283	473	5	to	to	TO
22283	473	6	prove	prove	VB
22283	473	7	this	this	DT
22283	473	8	,	,	,
22283	473	9	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	473	10	would	would	MD
22283	473	11	commit	commit	VB
22283	473	12	suicide	suicide	NN
22283	473	13	.	.	.
22283	474	1	For	for	IN
22283	474	2	if	if	IN
22283	474	3	once	once	IN
22283	474	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	474	5	were	be	VBD
22283	474	6	proved	prove	VBN
22283	474	7	that	that	IN
22283	474	8	the	the	DT
22283	474	9	relation	relation	NN
22283	474	10	of	of	IN
22283	474	11	energy	energy	NN
22283	474	12	to	to	IN
22283	474	13	thought	thought	NN
22283	474	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	474	15	such	such	JJ
22283	474	16	that	that	DT
22283	474	17	thought	thought	NN
22283	474	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	474	19	able	able	JJ
22283	474	20	to	to	TO
22283	474	21	absorb	absorb	VB
22283	474	22	or	or	CC
22283	474	23	temporarily	temporarily	RB
22283	474	24	to	to	TO
22283	474	25	annihilate	annihilate	VB
22283	474	26	energy	energy	NN
22283	474	27	,	,	,
22283	474	28	the	the	DT
22283	474	29	whole	whole	JJ
22283	474	30	argument	argument	NN
22283	474	31	of	of	IN
22283	474	32	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	474	33	would	would	MD
22283	474	34	be	be	VB
22283	474	35	inverted	invert	VBN
22283	474	36	,	,	,
22283	474	37	and	and	CC
22283	474	38	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	474	39	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	474	40	there	there	EX
22283	474	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	474	42	of	of	IN
22283	474	43	causation	causation	NN
22283	474	44	as	as	IN
22283	474	45	between	between	IN
22283	474	46	mind	mind	NN
22283	474	47	and	and	CC
22283	474	48	matter	matter	NN
22283	474	49	would	would	MD
22283	474	50	become	become	VB
22283	474	51	available	available	JJ
22283	474	52	in	in	IN
22283	474	53	all	all	DT
22283	474	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	474	55	force	force	NN
22283	474	56	on	on	IN
22283	474	57	the	the	DT
22283	474	58	side	side	NN
22283	474	59	of	of	IN
22283	474	60	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	474	61	.	.	.
22283	475	1	This	this	DT
22283	475	2	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	475	3	plain	plain	JJ
22283	475	4	,	,	,
22283	475	5	for	for	IN
22283	475	6	if	if	IN
22283	475	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	475	8	even	even	RB
22283	475	9	were	be	VBD
22283	475	10	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	475	11	--	--	:
22283	475	12	which	which	WDT
22283	475	13	most	most	RBS
22283	475	14	distinctly	distinctly	RB
22283	475	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	475	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	475	17	not	not	RB
22283	475	18	--	--	:
22283	475	19	that	that	IN
22283	475	20	a	a	DT
22283	475	21	motor	motor	NN
22283	475	22	could	could	MD
22283	475	23	ever	ever	RB
22283	475	24	become	become	VB
22283	475	25	a	a	DT
22283	475	26	motive	motive	NN
22283	475	27	,	,	,
22283	475	28	and	and	CC
22283	475	29	so	so	RB
22283	475	30	pass	pass	VB
22283	475	31	from	from	IN
22283	475	32	the	the	DT
22283	475	33	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	475	34	of	of	IN
22283	475	35	dynamics	dynamic	NNS
22283	475	36	into	into	IN
22283	475	37	the	the	DT
22283	475	38	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	475	39	of	of	IN
22283	475	40	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	475	41	,	,	,
22283	475	42	the	the	DT
22283	475	43	fact	fact	NN
22283	475	44	would	would	MD
22283	475	45	go	go	VB
22283	475	46	to	to	TO
22283	475	47	prove	prove	VB
22283	475	48	,	,	,
22283	475	49	not	not	RB
22283	475	50	that	that	IN
22283	475	51	the	the	DT
22283	475	52	motor	motor	NN
22283	475	53	was	be	VBD
22283	475	54	the	the	DT
22283	475	55	cause	cause	NN
22283	475	56	of	of	IN
22283	475	57	the	the	DT
22283	475	58	motive	motive	NN
22283	475	59	,	,	,
22283	475	60	but	but	CC
22283	475	61	rather	rather	RB
22283	475	62	that	that	IN
22283	475	63	the	the	DT
22283	475	64	motive	motive	NN
22283	475	65	was	be	VBD
22283	475	66	the	the	DT
22283	475	67	cause	cause	NN
22283	475	68	of	of	IN
22283	475	69	destroying	destroy	VBG
22283	475	70	the	the	DT
22283	475	71	motor	motor	NN
22283	475	72	;	;	:
22283	475	73	so	so	IN
22283	475	74	that	that	IN
22283	475	75	at	at	IN
22283	475	76	that	that	DT
22283	475	77	point	point	NN
22283	475	78	the	the	DT
22283	475	79	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	475	80	unbroken	unbroken	JJ
22283	475	81	chain	chain	NN
22283	475	82	of	of	IN
22283	475	83	physical	physical	JJ
22283	475	84	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	475	85	was	be	VBD
22283	475	86	interrupted	interrupt	VBN
22283	475	87	by	by	IN
22283	475	88	the	the	DT
22283	475	89	motive	motive	NN
22283	475	90	striking	strike	VBG
22283	475	91	in	in	RP
22283	475	92	upon	upon	IN
22283	475	93	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	475	94	,	,	,
22283	475	95	and	and	CC
22283	475	96	in	in	IN
22283	475	97	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	475	98	of	of	IN
22283	475	99	the	the	DT
22283	475	100	mysterious	mysterious	JJ
22283	475	101	power	power	NN
22283	475	102	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	475	103	to	to	TO
22283	475	104	have	have	VB
22283	475	105	been	be	VBN
22283	475	106	proved	prove	VBN
22283	475	107	by	by	IN
22283	475	108	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	475	109	,	,	,
22283	475	110	cancelling	cancel	VBG
22283	475	111	the	the	DT
22283	475	112	motor	motor	NN
22283	475	113	,	,	,
22283	475	114	so	so	RB
22283	475	115	allowing	allow	VBG
22283	475	116	the	the	DT
22283	475	117	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	475	118	-	-	HYPH
22283	475	119	centre	centre	NN
22283	475	120	to	to	TO
22283	475	121	act	act	VB
22283	475	122	as	as	IN
22283	475	123	determined	determine	VBN
22283	475	124	by	by	IN
22283	475	125	the	the	DT
22283	475	126	motive	motive	NN
22283	475	127	.	.	.
22283	476	1	Of	of	RB
22283	476	2	course	course	RB
22283	476	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	476	4	wish	wish	VBP
22283	476	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	476	6	to	to	TO
22283	476	7	be	be	VB
22283	476	8	understood	understand	VBN
22283	476	9	that	that	IN
22283	476	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	476	11	believe	believe	VBP
22283	476	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	476	13	are	be	VBP
22283	476	14	here	here	RB
22283	476	15	dealing	deal	VBG
22283	476	16	with	with	IN
22283	476	17	what	what	WP
22283	476	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	476	19	may	may	MD
22283	476	20	call	call	VB
22283	476	21	,	,	,
22283	476	22	in	in	IN
22283	476	23	perhaps	perhaps	RB
22283	476	24	suitably	suitably	RB
22283	476	25	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
22283	476	26	terms	term	NNS
22283	476	27	,	,	,
22283	476	28	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	476	29	conceptions	conception	NNS
22283	476	30	.	.	.
22283	477	1	But	but	CC
22283	477	2	let	let	VB
22283	477	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	477	4	be	be	VB
22283	477	5	remembered	remember	VBN
22283	477	6	that	that	IN
22283	477	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	477	8	am	be	VBP
22283	477	9	not	not	RB
22283	477	10	responsible	responsible	JJ
22283	477	11	for	for	IN
22283	477	12	this	this	DT
22283	477	13	ambiguity	ambiguity	NN
22283	477	14	;	;	:
22283	477	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	477	16	am	be	VBP
22283	477	17	only	only	RB
22283	477	18	showing	show	VBG
22283	477	19	what	what	WP
22283	477	20	must	must	MD
22283	477	21	be	be	VB
22283	477	22	the	the	DT
22283	477	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	477	24	outcome	outcome	NN
22283	477	25	of	of	IN
22283	477	26	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	477	27	if	if	IN
22283	477	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	477	29	begin	begin	VBP
22283	477	30	by	by	IN
22283	477	31	endeavouring	endeavour	VBG
22283	477	32	phenomenally	phenomenally	RB
22283	477	33	to	to	TO
22283	477	34	unite	unite	VB
22283	477	35	the	the	DT
22283	477	36	most	most	RBS
22283	477	37	antithetical	antithetical	JJ
22283	477	38	of	of	IN
22283	477	39	elements	element	NNS
22283	477	40	--	--	:
22283	477	41	mind	mind	NN
22283	477	42	and	and	CC
22283	477	43	motion	motion	NN
22283	477	44	.	.	.
22283	478	1	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	478	2	,	,	,
22283	478	3	at	at	IN
22283	478	4	least	least	JJS
22283	478	5	,	,	,
22283	478	6	will	will	MD
22283	478	7	not	not	RB
22283	478	8	be	be	VB
22283	478	9	the	the	DT
22283	478	10	gainer	gainer	NN
22283	478	11	should	should	MD
22283	478	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	478	13	ever	ever	RB
22283	478	14	be	be	VB
22283	478	15	proved	prove	VBN
22283	478	16	that	that	IN
22283	478	17	in	in	IN
22283	478	18	the	the	DT
22283	478	19	complex	complex	JJ
22283	478	20	operations	operation	NNS
22283	478	21	of	of	IN
22283	478	22	the	the	DT
22283	478	23	brain	brain	NN
22283	478	24	a	a	DT
22283	478	25	unique	unique	JJ
22283	478	26	exception	exception	NN
22283	478	27	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	478	28	to	to	IN
22283	478	29	the	the	DT
22283	478	30	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	478	31	universal	universal	JJ
22283	478	32	law	law	NN
22283	478	33	of	of	IN
22283	478	34	the	the	DT
22283	478	35	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	478	36	of	of	IN
22283	478	37	energy	energy	NN
22283	478	38	in	in	IN
22283	478	39	space	space	NN
22283	478	40	.	.	.
22283	479	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	479	2	may	may	MD
22283	479	3	,	,	,
22283	479	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	479	5	,	,	,
22283	479	6	quit	quit	VBD
22283	479	7	the	the	DT
22283	479	8	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	479	9	that	that	IN
22283	479	10	the	the	DT
22283	479	11	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	479	12	experienced	experience	VBN
22283	479	13	by	by	IN
22283	479	14	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	479	15	of	of	IN
22283	479	16	showing	show	VBG
22283	479	17	an	an	DT
22283	479	18	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	479	19	between	between	IN
22283	479	20	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	479	21	and	and	CC
22283	479	22	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	479	23	can	can	MD
22283	479	24	ever	ever	RB
22283	479	25	be	be	VB
22283	479	26	met	meet	VBN
22283	479	27	by	by	IN
22283	479	28	assuming	assume	VBG
22283	479	29	that	that	IN
22283	479	30	some	some	DT
22283	479	31	day	day	NN
22283	479	32	mental	mental	JJ
22283	479	33	processes	process	NNS
22283	479	34	may	may	MD
22283	479	35	admit	admit	VB
22283	479	36	of	of	IN
22283	479	37	being	be	VBG
22283	479	38	expressed	express	VBN
22283	479	39	in	in	IN
22283	479	40	terms	term	NNS
22283	479	41	of	of	IN
22283	479	42	physical	physical	NN
22283	479	43	.	.	.
22283	480	1	But	but	CC
22283	480	2	before	before	IN
22283	480	3	leaving	leave	VBG
22283	480	4	this	this	DT
22283	480	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	480	6	with	with	IN
22283	480	7	regard	regard	NN
22283	480	8	to	to	IN
22283	480	9	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	480	10	,	,	,
22283	480	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	480	12	may	may	MD
22283	480	13	mention	mention	VB
22283	480	14	one	one	CD
22283	480	15	other	other	JJ
22283	480	16	point	point	NN
22283	480	17	that	that	WDT
22283	480	18	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	480	19	to	to	IN
22283	480	20	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	480	21	of	of	IN
22283	480	22	importance	importance	NN
22283	480	23	in	in	IN
22283	480	24	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	480	25	with	with	IN
22283	480	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	480	27	.	.	.
22283	481	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	481	2	have	have	VBP
22283	481	3	already	already	RB
22283	481	4	said	say	VBN
22283	481	5	that	that	IN
22283	481	6	if	if	IN
22283	481	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	481	8	suppose	suppose	VBP
22283	481	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	481	10	to	to	TO
22283	481	11	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	481	12	from	from	IN
22283	481	13	brain	brain	NN
22283	481	14	to	to	IN
22283	481	15	mind	mind	NN
22283	481	16	,	,	,
22283	481	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	481	18	must	must	MD
22283	481	19	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	481	20	this	this	DT
22283	481	21	essential	essential	JJ
22283	481	22	requirement	requirement	NN
22283	481	23	of	of	IN
22283	481	24	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	481	25	between	between	IN
22283	481	26	the	the	DT
22283	481	27	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	481	28	causes	cause	NNS
22283	481	29	and	and	CC
22283	481	30	the	the	DT
22283	481	31	mental	mental	JJ
22283	481	32	effects	effect	NNS
22283	481	33	to	to	TO
22283	481	34	be	be	VB
22283	481	35	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
22283	481	36	somewhere	somewhere	RB
22283	481	37	.	.	.
22283	482	1	But	but	CC
22283	482	2	where	where	WRB
22283	482	3	are	be	VBP
22283	482	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	482	5	to	to	TO
22283	482	6	say	say	VB
22283	482	7	that	that	IN
22283	482	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	482	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	482	10	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
22283	482	11	?	?	.
22283	483	1	Even	even	RB
22283	483	2	if	if	IN
22283	483	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	483	4	suppose	suppose	VBP
22283	483	5	that	that	DT
22283	483	6	thought	thought	NN
22283	483	7	has	have	VBZ
22283	483	8	a	a	DT
22283	483	9	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	483	10	equivalent	equivalent	NN
22283	483	11	,	,	,
22283	483	12	and	and	CC
22283	483	13	that	that	IN
22283	483	14	causation	causation	NN
22283	483	15	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
22283	483	16	in	in	IN
22283	483	17	the	the	DT
22283	483	18	direction	direction	NN
22283	483	19	from	from	IN
22283	483	20	energy	energy	NN
22283	483	21	to	to	IN
22283	483	22	thought	thought	NN
22283	483	23	,	,	,
22283	483	24	still	still	RB
22283	483	25	,	,	,
22283	483	26	when	when	WRB
22283	483	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	483	28	have	have	VBP
22283	483	29	regard	regard	NN
22283	483	30	to	to	IN
22283	483	31	the	the	DT
22283	483	32	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	483	33	effects	effect	NNS
22283	483	34	,	,	,
22283	483	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	483	36	find	find	VBP
22283	483	37	that	that	IN
22283	483	38	even	even	RB
22283	483	39	yet	yet	RB
22283	483	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	483	41	bear	bear	VBP
22283	483	42	no	no	DT
22283	483	43	kind	kind	NN
22283	483	44	of	of	IN
22283	483	45	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	483	46	to	to	IN
22283	483	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	483	48	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	483	49	causes	cause	NNS
22283	483	50	.	.	.
22283	484	1	The	the	DT
22283	484	2	brain	brain	NN
22283	484	3	of	of	IN
22283	484	4	a	a	DT
22283	484	5	Shakespeare	Shakespeare	NNP
22283	484	6	probably	probably	RB
22283	484	7	did	do	VBD
22283	484	8	not	not	RB
22283	484	9	,	,	,
22283	484	10	as	as	IN
22283	484	11	a	a	DT
22283	484	12	system	system	NN
22283	484	13	,	,	,
22283	484	14	exhibit	exhibit	NN
22283	484	15	so	so	RB
22283	484	16	much	much	JJ
22283	484	17	energy	energy	NN
22283	484	18	as	as	IN
22283	484	19	does	do	VBZ
22283	484	20	the	the	DT
22283	484	21	brain	brain	NN
22283	484	22	of	of	IN
22283	484	23	an	an	DT
22283	484	24	elephant	elephant	NN
22283	484	25	;	;	:
22283	484	26	and	and	CC
22283	484	27	the	the	DT
22283	484	28	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	484	29	operations	operation	NNS
22283	484	30	of	of	IN
22283	484	31	a	a	DT
22283	484	32	Darwin	Darwin	NNP
22283	484	33	may	may	MD
22283	484	34	not	not	RB
22283	484	35	have	have	VB
22283	484	36	had	have	VBN
22283	484	37	a	a	DT
22283	484	38	very	very	RB
22283	484	39	perceptibly	perceptibly	RB
22283	484	40	larger	large	JJR
22283	484	41	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	484	42	equivalent	equivalent	NN
22283	484	43	than	than	IN
22283	484	44	those	those	DT
22283	484	45	of	of	IN
22283	484	46	a	a	DT
22283	484	47	banker	banker	NN
22283	484	48	's	's	POS
22283	484	49	clerk	clerk	NN
22283	484	50	.	.	.
22283	485	1	Yet	yet	CC
22283	485	2	in	in	IN
22283	485	3	the	the	DT
22283	485	4	world	world	NN
22283	485	5	of	of	IN
22283	485	6	thought	thought	NN
22283	485	7	the	the	DT
22283	485	8	difference	difference	NN
22283	485	9	between	between	IN
22283	485	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	485	11	estimate	estimate	NN
22283	485	12	of	of	IN
22283	485	13	the	the	DT
22283	485	14	results	result	NNS
22283	485	15	,	,	,
22283	485	16	or	or	CC
22283	485	17	'	'	``
22283	485	18	work	work	NN
22283	485	19	done	do	VBN
22283	485	20	,	,	,
22283	485	21	'	'	''
22283	485	22	in	in	IN
22283	485	23	these	these	DT
22283	485	24	cases	case	NNS
22283	485	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	485	26	such	such	JJ
22283	485	27	as	as	IN
22283	485	28	to	to	TO
22283	485	29	drive	drive	VB
22283	485	30	all	all	DT
22283	485	31	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	485	32	of	of	IN
22283	485	33	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	485	34	to	to	IN
22283	485	35	the	the	DT
22283	485	36	winds	wind	NNS
22283	485	37	.	.	.
22283	486	1	Doubtless	doubtless	RB
22283	486	2	,	,	,
22283	486	3	a	a	DT
22283	486	4	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	486	5	will	will	MD
22283	486	6	answer	answer	VB
22283	486	7	that	that	IN
22283	486	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	486	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	486	10	not	not	RB
22283	486	11	fair	fair	JJ
22283	486	12	to	to	TO
22283	486	13	take	take	VB
22283	486	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	486	15	estimate	estimate	NN
22283	486	16	of	of	IN
22283	486	17	'	'	``
22283	486	18	work	work	NN
22283	486	19	done	do	VBN
22283	486	20	'	'	''
22283	486	21	in	in	IN
22283	486	22	the	the	DT
22283	486	23	world	world	NN
22283	486	24	of	of	IN
22283	486	25	mind	mind	NN
22283	486	26	as	as	IN
22283	486	27	the	the	DT
22283	486	28	real	real	JJ
22283	486	29	equivalent	equivalent	NN
22283	486	30	of	of	IN
22283	486	31	the	the	DT
22283	486	32	energy	energy	NN
22283	486	33	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	486	34	to	to	TO
22283	486	35	have	have	VB
22283	486	36	passed	pass	VBN
22283	486	37	over	over	RP
22283	486	38	from	from	IN
22283	486	39	the	the	DT
22283	486	40	world	world	NN
22283	486	41	of	of	IN
22283	486	42	motion	motion	NN
22283	486	43	,	,	,
22283	486	44	seeing	see	VBG
22283	486	45	that	that	IN
22283	486	46	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	486	47	estimate	estimate	NN
22283	486	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	486	49	based	base	VBN
22283	486	50	,	,	,
22283	486	51	not	not	RB
22283	486	52	on	on	IN
22283	486	53	the	the	DT
22283	486	54	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
22283	486	55	amount	amount	NN
22283	486	56	of	of	IN
22283	486	57	thought	thought	NN
22283	486	58	produced	produce	VBN
22283	486	59	,	,	,
22283	486	60	but	but	CC
22283	486	61	rather	rather	RB
22283	486	62	on	on	IN
22283	486	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	486	64	qualitative	qualitative	JJ
22283	486	65	character	character	NN
22283	486	66	with	with	IN
22283	486	67	reference	reference	NN
22283	486	68	to	to	IN
22283	486	69	the	the	DT
22283	486	70	social	social	JJ
22283	486	71	requirements	requirement	NNS
22283	486	72	of	of	IN
22283	486	73	the	the	DT
22283	486	74	race	race	NN
22283	486	75	.	.	.
22283	487	1	But	but	CC
22283	487	2	to	to	IN
22283	487	3	this	this	DT
22283	487	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	487	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	487	6	enough	enough	JJ
22283	487	7	to	to	TO
22283	487	8	answer	answer	VB
22283	487	9	that	that	IN
22283	487	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	487	11	have	have	VBP
22283	487	12	no	no	DT
22283	487	13	means	means	NN
22283	487	14	of	of	IN
22283	487	15	gauging	gauge	VBG
22283	487	16	the	the	DT
22283	487	17	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	487	18	of	of	IN
22283	487	19	thought	thought	NN
22283	487	20	produced	produce	VBN
22283	487	21	other	other	JJ
22283	487	22	than	than	IN
22283	487	23	by	by	IN
22283	487	24	having	have	VBG
22283	487	25	regard	regard	NN
22283	487	26	to	to	IN
22283	487	27	_	_	NNP
22283	487	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	487	29	_	_	NNP
22283	487	30	effects	effect	NNS
22283	487	31	in	in	IN
22283	487	32	the	the	DT
22283	487	33	world	world	NN
22283	487	34	of	of	IN
22283	487	35	mind	mind	NN
22283	487	36	,	,	,
22283	487	37	and	and	CC
22283	487	38	this	this	DT
22283	487	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	487	40	can	can	MD
22283	487	41	not	not	RB
22283	487	42	do	do	VB
22283	487	43	except	except	IN
22283	487	44	by	by	IN
22283	487	45	having	have	VBG
22283	487	46	regard	regard	NN
22283	487	47	to	to	IN
22283	487	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	487	49	qualitative	qualitative	JJ
22283	487	50	character	character	NN
22283	487	51	.	.	.
22283	488	1	Many	many	JJ
22283	488	2	a	a	DT
22283	488	3	man	man	NN
22283	488	4	,	,	,
22283	488	5	for	for	IN
22283	488	6	instance	instance	NN
22283	488	7	,	,	,
22283	488	8	must	must	MD
22283	488	9	have	have	VB
22283	488	10	consumed	consume	VBN
22283	488	11	more	more	JJR
22283	488	12	than	than	IN
22283	488	13	a	a	DT
22283	488	14	thousand	thousand	CD
22283	488	15	times	time	NNS
22283	488	16	the	the	DT
22283	488	17	brain	brain	NN
22283	488	18	-	-	HYPH
22283	488	19	substance	substance	NN
22283	488	20	and	and	CC
22283	488	21	brain	brain	NN
22283	488	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	488	23	energy	energy	NN
22283	488	24	that	that	WDT
22283	488	25	Shelley	Shelley	NNP
22283	488	26	expended	expend	VBD
22283	488	27	over	over	IN
22283	488	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	488	29	'	'	``
22283	488	30	Ode	ode	NN
22283	488	31	to	to	IN
22283	488	32	a	a	DT
22283	488	33	Skylark	Skylark	NNP
22283	488	34	,	,	,
22283	488	35	'	'	''
22283	488	36	and	and	CC
22283	488	37	yet	yet	RB
22283	488	38	as	as	IN
22283	488	39	a	a	DT
22283	488	40	result	result	NN
22283	488	41	have	have	VBP
22283	488	42	produced	produce	VBN
22283	488	43	an	an	DT
22283	488	44	utterly	utterly	RB
22283	488	45	worthless	worthless	JJ
22283	488	46	poem	poem	NN
22283	488	47	.	.	.
22283	489	1	Now	now	RB
22283	489	2	,	,	,
22283	489	3	in	in	IN
22283	489	4	what	what	WDT
22283	489	5	way	way	NN
22283	489	6	are	be	VBP
22283	489	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	489	8	to	to	TO
22283	489	9	estimate	estimate	VB
22283	489	10	the	the	DT
22283	489	11	'	'	``
22283	489	12	work	work	NN
22283	489	13	done	do	VBN
22283	489	14	'	'	''
22283	489	15	in	in	IN
22283	489	16	two	two	CD
22283	489	17	such	such	JJ
22283	489	18	cases	case	NNS
22283	489	19	,	,	,
22283	489	20	except	except	IN
22283	489	21	by	by	IN
22283	489	22	looking	look	VBG
22283	489	23	to	to	IN
22283	489	24	the	the	DT
22283	489	25	relative	relative	JJ
22283	489	26	effects	effect	NNS
22283	489	27	produced	produce	VBN
22283	489	28	in	in	IN
22283	489	29	the	the	DT
22283	489	30	only	only	JJ
22283	489	31	region	region	NN
22283	489	32	where	where	WRB
22283	489	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	489	34	are	be	VBP
22283	489	35	produced	produce	VBN
22283	489	36	,	,	,
22283	489	37	viz	viz	NN
22283	489	38	.	.	.
22283	490	1	in	in	IN
22283	490	2	the	the	DT
22283	490	3	region	region	NN
22283	490	4	of	of	IN
22283	490	5	mind	mind	NN
22283	490	6	?	?	.
22283	491	1	Yet	yet	CC
22283	491	2	,	,	,
22283	491	3	when	when	WRB
22283	491	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	491	5	do	do	VBP
22283	491	6	so	so	RB
22283	491	7	estimate	estimate	VB
22283	491	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	491	9	,	,	,
22283	491	10	what	what	WP
22283	491	11	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	491	12	of	of	IN
22283	491	13	the	the	DT
22283	491	14	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	491	15	of	of	IN
22283	491	16	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	491	17	between	between	IN
22283	491	18	the	the	DT
22283	491	19	physical	physical	JJ
22283	491	20	causes	cause	NNS
22283	491	21	and	and	CC
22283	491	22	the	the	DT
22283	491	23	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	491	24	effects	effect	NNS
22283	491	25	?	?	.
22283	492	1	Now	now	RB
22283	492	2	if	if	IN
22283	492	3	thus	thus	RB
22283	492	4	,	,	,
22283	492	5	whether	whether	IN
22283	492	6	or	or	CC
22283	492	7	not	not	RB
22283	492	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	492	9	try	try	VBP
22283	492	10	to	to	TO
22283	492	11	form	form	VB
22283	492	12	an	an	DT
22283	492	13	estimate	estimate	NN
22283	492	14	,	,	,
22283	492	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	492	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	492	17	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	492	18	to	to	TO
22283	492	19	show	show	VB
22283	492	20	any	any	DT
22283	492	21	semblance	semblance	NN
22283	492	22	of	of	IN
22283	492	23	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	492	24	between	between	IN
22283	492	25	the	the	DT
22283	492	26	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	492	27	causes	cause	NNS
22283	492	28	and	and	CC
22283	492	29	the	the	DT
22283	492	30	alleged	allege	VBN
22283	492	31	effects	effect	NNS
22283	492	32	,	,	,
22283	492	33	how	how	WRB
22283	492	34	can	can	MD
22283	492	35	any	any	DT
22283	492	36	one	one	NN
22283	492	37	be	be	VB
22283	492	38	found	find	VBN
22283	492	39	to	to	TO
22283	492	40	say	say	VB
22283	492	41	that	that	IN
22283	492	42	the	the	DT
22283	492	43	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	492	44	of	of	IN
22283	492	45	causation	causation	NN
22283	492	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	492	47	here	here	RB
22283	492	48	as	as	RB
22283	492	49	valid	valid	JJ
22283	492	50	as	as	IN
22283	492	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	492	52	is	be	VBZ
22283	492	53	in	in	IN
22283	492	54	any	any	DT
22283	492	55	other	other	JJ
22283	492	56	case	case	NN
22283	492	57	?	?	.
22283	493	1	The	the	DT
22283	493	2	truth	truth	NN
22283	493	3	rather	rather	RB
22283	493	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	493	5	that	that	IN
22283	493	6	the	the	DT
22283	493	7	alleged	allege	VBN
22283	493	8	effects	effect	NNS
22283	493	9	stand	stand	VBP
22283	493	10	out	out	IN
22283	493	11	of	of	IN
22283	493	12	every	every	DT
22283	493	13	relation	relation	NN
22283	493	14	to	to	IN
22283	493	15	the	the	DT
22283	493	16	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	493	17	causes	cause	NNS
22283	493	18	,	,	,
22283	493	19	with	with	IN
22283	493	20	the	the	DT
22283	493	21	exception	exception	NN
22283	493	22	only	only	RB
22283	493	23	of	of	IN
22283	493	24	being	be	VBG
22283	493	25	associated	associate	VBN
22283	493	26	in	in	IN
22283	493	27	time	time	NN
22283	493	28	.	.	.
22283	494	1	There	there	EX
22283	494	2	still	still	RB
22283	494	3	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	494	4	one	one	CD
22283	494	5	other	other	JJ
22283	494	6	enormous	enormous	JJ
22283	494	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	494	8	in	in	IN
22283	494	9	the	the	DT
22283	494	10	way	way	NN
22283	494	11	of	of	IN
22283	494	12	the	the	DT
22283	494	13	theory	theory	NN
22283	494	14	of	of	IN
22283	494	15	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	494	16	;	;	:
22283	494	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	494	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	494	19	embodies	embody	VBZ
22283	494	20	the	the	DT
22283	494	21	theory	theory	NN
22283	494	22	of	of	IN
22283	494	23	_	_	NNP
22283	494	24	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	494	25	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	494	26	_	_	NNP
22283	494	27	,	,	,
22283	494	28	and	and	CC
22283	494	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	494	30	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	494	31	called	call	VBN
22283	494	32	upon	upon	IN
22283	494	33	to	to	TO
22283	494	34	explain	explain	VB
22283	494	35	why	why	WRB
22283	494	36	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	494	37	and	and	CC
22283	494	38	thought	thought	NN
22283	494	39	have	have	VBP
22283	494	40	ever	ever	RB
22283	494	41	appeared	appear	VBN
22283	494	42	upon	upon	IN
22283	494	43	the	the	DT
22283	494	44	scene	scene	NN
22283	494	45	of	of	IN
22283	494	46	things	thing	NNS
22283	494	47	at	at	RB
22283	494	48	all	all	RB
22283	494	49	.	.	.
22283	495	1	That	that	IN
22283	495	2	this	this	DT
22283	495	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	495	4	the	the	DT
22283	495	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	495	6	position	position	NN
22283	495	7	of	of	IN
22283	495	8	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	495	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	495	10	easily	easily	RB
22283	495	11	proved	prove	VBN
22283	495	12	as	as	IN
22283	495	13	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	495	14	.	.	.
22283	496	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	496	2	have	have	VBP
22283	496	3	already	already	RB
22283	496	4	seen	see	VBN
22283	496	5	that	that	IN
22283	496	6	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	496	7	would	would	MD
22283	496	8	commit	commit	VB
22283	496	9	suicide	suicide	NN
22283	496	10	by	by	IN
22283	496	11	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	496	12	that	that	DT
22283	496	13	energy	energy	NN
22283	496	14	could	could	MD
22283	496	15	be	be	VB
22283	496	16	transmuted	transmute	VBN
22283	496	17	into	into	IN
22283	496	18	thought	thought	NN
22283	496	19	,	,	,
22283	496	20	for	for	IN
22283	496	21	this	this	DT
22283	496	22	would	would	MD
22283	496	23	amount	amount	VB
22283	496	24	to	to	IN
22283	496	25	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	496	26	short	short	RB
22283	496	27	of	of	IN
22283	496	28	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	496	29	the	the	DT
22283	496	30	destruction	destruction	NN
22283	496	31	of	of	IN
22283	496	32	energy	energy	NN
22283	496	33	as	as	IN
22283	496	34	such	such	JJ
22283	496	35	;	;	:
22283	496	36	and	and	CC
22283	496	37	to	to	TO
22283	496	38	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	496	39	energy	energy	NN
22283	496	40	thus	thus	RB
22283	496	41	destructible	destructible	JJ
22283	496	42	would	would	MD
22283	496	43	be	be	VB
22283	496	44	to	to	TO
22283	496	45	open	open	VB
22283	496	46	wide	wide	JJ
22283	496	47	the	the	DT
22283	496	48	door	door	NN
22283	496	49	of	of	IN
22283	496	50	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	496	51	.	.	.
22283	497	1	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	497	2	,	,	,
22283	497	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	497	4	,	,	,
22283	497	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	497	6	logically	logically	RB
22283	497	7	bound	bind	VBN
22283	497	8	to	to	TO
22283	497	9	argue	argue	VB
22283	497	10	in	in	IN
22283	497	11	this	this	DT
22283	497	12	way	way	NN
22283	497	13	:	:	:
22283	497	14	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	497	15	can	can	MD
22283	497	16	not	not	RB
22283	497	17	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	497	18	of	of	IN
22283	497	19	a	a	DT
22283	497	20	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	497	21	idea	idea	NN
22283	497	22	,	,	,
22283	497	23	or	or	CC
22283	497	24	mental	mental	JJ
22283	497	25	change	change	NN
22283	497	26	,	,	,
22283	497	27	as	as	IN
22283	497	28	in	in	IN
22283	497	29	any	any	DT
22283	497	30	way	way	NN
22283	497	31	affecting	affect	VBG
22283	497	32	the	the	DT
22283	497	33	course	course	NN
22283	497	34	of	of	IN
22283	497	35	a	a	DT
22283	497	36	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	497	37	reflex	reflex	NN
22283	497	38	,	,	,
22283	497	39	or	or	CC
22283	497	40	material	material	NN
22283	497	41	change	change	NN
22283	497	42	;	;	:
22283	497	43	while	while	IN
22283	497	44	,	,	,
22283	497	45	on	on	IN
22283	497	46	the	the	DT
22283	497	47	other	other	JJ
22283	497	48	hand	hand	NN
22283	497	49	,	,	,
22283	497	50	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	497	51	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	497	52	of	of	IN
22283	497	53	the	the	DT
22283	497	54	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	497	55	of	of	IN
22283	497	56	energy	energy	NN
22283	497	57	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	497	58	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	497	59	as	as	IN
22283	497	60	an	an	DT
22283	497	61	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	497	62	that	that	IN
22283	497	63	the	the	DT
22283	497	64	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	497	65	changes	change	NNS
22283	497	66	must	must	MD
22283	497	67	determine	determine	VB
22283	497	68	each	each	DT
22283	497	69	other	other	JJ
22283	497	70	in	in	IN
22283	497	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	497	72	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	497	73	as	as	IN
22283	497	74	in	in	IN
22283	497	75	a	a	DT
22283	497	76	continuous	continuous	JJ
22283	497	77	series	series	NN
22283	497	78	.	.	.
22283	498	1	Nowhere	nowhere	RB
22283	498	2	can	can	MD
22283	498	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	498	4	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	498	5	the	the	DT
22283	498	6	physical	physical	JJ
22283	498	7	process	process	NN
22283	498	8	to	to	TO
22283	498	9	be	be	VB
22283	498	10	interrupted	interrupt	VBN
22283	498	11	or	or	CC
22283	498	12	diverted	divert	VBN
22283	498	13	by	by	IN
22283	498	14	the	the	DT
22283	498	15	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	498	16	process	process	NN
22283	498	17	;	;	:
22283	498	18	and	and	CC
22283	498	19	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	498	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	498	21	must	must	MD
22283	498	22	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	498	23	that	that	DT
22283	498	24	thought	thought	NN
22283	498	25	and	and	CC
22283	498	26	volition	volition	NN
22283	498	27	really	really	RB
22283	498	28	play	play	VBP
22283	498	29	no	no	DT
22283	498	30	part	part	NN
22283	498	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	498	32	in	in	IN
22283	498	33	determining	determine	VBG
22283	498	34	action	action	NN
22283	498	35	.	.	.
22283	499	1	Thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	499	2	and	and	CC
22283	499	3	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	499	4	are	be	VBP
22283	499	5	but	but	CC
22283	499	6	indices	index	NNS
22283	499	7	which	which	WDT
22283	499	8	show	show	VBP
22283	499	9	in	in	IN
22283	499	10	the	the	DT
22283	499	11	mirror	mirror	NN
22283	499	12	of	of	IN
22283	499	13	the	the	DT
22283	499	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	499	15	certain	certain	JJ
22283	499	16	changes	change	NNS
22283	499	17	that	that	WDT
22283	499	18	are	be	VBP
22283	499	19	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	499	20	in	in	IN
22283	499	21	the	the	DT
22283	499	22	matter	matter	NN
22283	499	23	of	of	IN
22283	499	24	the	the	DT
22283	499	25	brain	brain	NN
22283	499	26	,	,	,
22283	499	27	and	and	CC
22283	499	28	are	be	VBP
22283	499	29	as	as	RB
22283	499	30	inefficient	inefficient	JJ
22283	499	31	in	in	IN
22283	499	32	influencing	influence	VBG
22283	499	33	those	those	DT
22283	499	34	changes	change	NNS
22283	499	35	as	as	IN
22283	499	36	the	the	DT
22283	499	37	shadow	shadow	NN
22283	499	38	of	of	IN
22283	499	39	a	a	DT
22283	499	40	cloud	cloud	NN
22283	499	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	499	42	powerless	powerless	JJ
22283	499	43	to	to	TO
22283	499	44	direct	direct	VB
22283	499	45	the	the	DT
22283	499	46	movements	movement	NNS
22283	499	47	of	of	IN
22283	499	48	that	that	DT
22283	499	49	of	of	IN
22283	499	50	which	which	WDT
22283	499	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	499	52	is	be	VBZ
22283	499	53	the	the	DT
22283	499	54	shadow	shadow	NN
22283	499	55	.	.	.
22283	500	1	But	but	CC
22283	500	2	when	when	WRB
22283	500	3	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	500	4	reaches	reach	VBZ
22283	500	5	,	,	,
22283	500	6	in	in	IN
22283	500	7	a	a	DT
22283	500	8	clear	clear	JJ
22283	500	9	and	and	CC
22283	500	10	articulate	articulate	JJ
22283	500	11	manner	manner	NN
22283	500	12	,	,	,
22283	500	13	this	this	DT
22283	500	14	inference	inference	NN
22283	500	15	as	as	IN
22283	500	16	a	a	DT
22283	500	17	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	500	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	500	19	from	from	IN
22283	500	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	500	21	premises	premise	NNS
22283	500	22	,	,	,
22283	500	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	500	24	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	500	25	opposed	opposed	JJ
22283	500	26	at	at	IN
22283	500	27	once	once	RB
22283	500	28	to	to	IN
22283	500	29	common	common	JJ
22283	500	30	sense	sense	NN
22283	500	31	and	and	CC
22283	500	32	to	to	IN
22283	500	33	the	the	DT
22283	500	34	requirements	requirement	NNS
22283	500	35	of	of	IN
22283	500	36	methodical	methodical	JJ
22283	500	37	reason	reason	NN
22283	500	38	.	.	.
22283	501	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	501	2	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	501	3	opposed	opposed	JJ
22283	501	4	to	to	IN
22283	501	5	common	common	JJ
22283	501	6	sense	sense	NN
22283	501	7	because	because	IN
22283	501	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	501	9	all	all	DT
22283	501	10	feel	feel	VBP
22283	501	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	501	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	501	13	practically	practically	RB
22283	501	14	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	501	15	to	to	TO
22283	501	16	believe	believe	VB
22283	501	17	that	that	IN
22283	501	18	the	the	DT
22283	501	19	world	world	NN
22283	501	20	would	would	MD
22283	501	21	now	now	RB
22283	501	22	have	have	VB
22283	501	23	been	be	VBN
22283	501	24	exactly	exactly	RB
22283	501	25	what	what	WP
22283	501	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	501	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	501	28	even	even	RB
22283	501	29	if	if	IN
22283	501	30	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	501	31	,	,	,
22283	501	32	thought	think	VBD
22283	501	33	,	,	,
22283	501	34	and	and	CC
22283	501	35	volition	volition	NN
22283	501	36	had	have	VBD
22283	501	37	never	never	RB
22283	501	38	appeared	appear	VBN
22283	501	39	upon	upon	IN
22283	501	40	the	the	DT
22283	501	41	scene	scene	NN
22283	501	42	--	--	:
22283	501	43	that	that	IN
22283	501	44	railway	railway	NN
22283	501	45	trains	train	NNS
22283	501	46	would	would	MD
22283	501	47	have	have	VB
22283	501	48	been	be	VBN
22283	501	49	running	run	VBG
22283	501	50	filled	fill	VBN
22283	501	51	with	with	IN
22283	501	52	mindless	mindless	JJ
22283	501	53	passengers	passenger	NNS
22283	501	54	,	,	,
22283	501	55	or	or	CC
22283	501	56	that	that	IN
22283	501	57	telephones	telephone	NNS
22283	501	58	would	would	MD
22283	501	59	have	have	VB
22283	501	60	been	be	VBN
22283	501	61	invented	invent	VBN
22283	501	62	by	by	IN
22283	501	63	brains	brain	NNS
22283	501	64	that	that	WDT
22283	501	65	could	could	MD
22283	501	66	not	not	RB
22283	501	67	think	think	VB
22283	501	68	to	to	TO
22283	501	69	speak	speak	VB
22283	501	70	to	to	IN
22283	501	71	ears	ear	NNS
22283	501	72	that	that	WDT
22283	501	73	could	could	MD
22283	501	74	not	not	RB
22283	501	75	hear	hear	VB
22283	501	76	.	.	.
22283	502	1	And	and	CC
22283	502	2	the	the	DT
22283	502	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	502	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	502	5	opposed	oppose	VBN
22283	502	6	to	to	IN
22283	502	7	the	the	DT
22283	502	8	requirements	requirement	NNS
22283	502	9	of	of	IN
22283	502	10	methodical	methodical	JJ
22283	502	11	reason	reason	NN
22283	502	12	,	,	,
22283	502	13	because	because	IN
22283	502	14	reason	reason	NN
22283	502	15	to	to	TO
22283	502	16	be	be	VB
22283	502	17	methodical	methodical	JJ
22283	502	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	502	19	bound	bind	VBN
22283	502	20	to	to	TO
22283	502	21	have	have	VB
22283	502	22	an	an	DT
22283	502	23	answer	answer	NN
22283	502	24	to	to	IN
22283	502	25	the	the	DT
22283	502	26	question	question	NN
22283	502	27	that	that	WDT
22283	502	28	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	502	29	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	502	30	from	from	IN
22283	502	31	the	the	DT
22283	502	32	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	502	33	.	.	.
22283	503	1	This	this	DT
22283	503	2	question	question	NN
22283	503	3	simply	simply	RB
22283	503	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	503	5	,	,	,
22283	503	6	Why	why	WRB
22283	503	7	have	have	VBP
22283	503	8	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	503	9	,	,	,
22283	503	10	thought	think	VBD
22283	503	11	,	,	,
22283	503	12	and	and	CC
22283	503	13	volition	volition	NN
22283	503	14	ever	ever	RB
22283	503	15	been	be	VBN
22283	503	16	called	call	VBN
22283	503	17	into	into	IN
22283	503	18	existence	existence	NN
22283	503	19	;	;	,
22283	503	20	and	and	CC
22283	503	21	why	why	WRB
22283	503	22	are	be	VBP
22283	503	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	503	24	related	relate	VBN
22283	503	25	,	,	,
22283	503	26	as	as	IN
22283	503	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	503	28	are	be	VBP
22283	503	29	related	related	JJ
22283	503	30	,	,	,
22283	503	31	to	to	IN
22283	503	32	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	503	33	action	action	NN
22283	503	34	?	?	.
22283	504	1	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	504	2	,	,	,
22283	504	3	by	by	IN
22283	504	4	here	here	RB
22283	504	5	undertaking	undertake	VBG
22283	504	6	to	to	TO
22283	504	7	prove	prove	VB
22283	504	8	that	that	IN
22283	504	9	these	these	DT
22283	504	10	things	thing	NNS
22283	504	11	stand	stand	VBP
22283	504	12	uselessly	uselessly	RB
22283	504	13	isolated	isolate	VBN
22283	504	14	from	from	IN
22283	504	15	all	all	DT
22283	504	16	other	other	JJ
22283	504	17	things	thing	NNS
22283	504	18	,	,	,
22283	504	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	504	20	bound	bind	VBN
22283	504	21	to	to	TO
22283	504	22	show	show	VB
22283	504	23	some	some	DT
22283	504	24	reason	reason	NN
22283	504	25	why	why	WRB
22283	504	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	504	27	ever	ever	RB
22283	504	28	came	come	VBD
22283	504	29	to	to	TO
22283	504	30	be	be	VB
22283	504	31	,	,	,
22283	504	32	and	and	CC
22283	504	33	to	to	TO
22283	504	34	be	be	VB
22283	504	35	what	what	WP
22283	504	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	504	37	are	be	VBP
22283	504	38	.	.	.
22283	505	1	For	for	IN
22283	505	2	observe	observe	NN
22283	505	3	,	,	,
22283	505	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	505	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	505	6	not	not	RB
22283	505	7	merely	merely	RB
22283	505	8	that	that	IN
22283	505	9	these	these	DT
22283	505	10	things	thing	NNS
22283	505	11	exist	exist	VBP
22283	505	12	in	in	IN
22283	505	13	a	a	DT
22283	505	14	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	505	15	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
22283	505	16	relation	relation	NN
22283	505	17	to	to	IN
22283	505	18	all	all	DT
22283	505	19	other	other	JJ
22283	505	20	things	thing	NNS
22283	505	21	;	;	:
22283	505	22	the	the	DT
22283	505	23	fact	fact	NN
22283	505	24	to	to	TO
22283	505	25	be	be	VB
22283	505	26	explained	explain	VBN
22283	505	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	505	28	that	that	IN
22283	505	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	505	30	exist	exist	VBP
22283	505	31	in	in	IN
22283	505	32	a	a	DT
22283	505	33	most	most	RBS
22283	505	34	intimately	intimately	RB
22283	505	35	woven	weave	VBN
22283	505	36	and	and	CC
22283	505	37	invariable	invariable	JJ
22283	505	38	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	505	39	with	with	IN
22283	505	40	certain	certain	JJ
22283	505	41	highly	highly	RB
22283	505	42	complex	complex	JJ
22283	505	43	forms	form	NNS
22283	505	44	of	of	IN
22283	505	45	organic	organic	JJ
22283	505	46	structure	structure	NN
22283	505	47	and	and	CC
22283	505	48	certain	certain	JJ
22283	505	49	highly	highly	RB
22283	505	50	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
22283	505	51	distributions	distribution	NNS
22283	505	52	of	of	IN
22283	505	53	physical	physical	JJ
22283	505	54	force	force	NN
22283	505	55	.	.	.
22283	506	1	Yet	yet	RB
22283	506	2	these	these	DT
22283	506	3	unique	unique	JJ
22283	506	4	and	and	CC
22283	506	5	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
22283	506	6	things	thing	NNS
22283	506	7	are	be	VBP
22283	506	8	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	506	9	by	by	IN
22283	506	10	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	506	11	to	to	TO
22283	506	12	be	be	VB
22283	506	13	always	always	RB
22283	506	14	results	result	NNS
22283	506	15	and	and	CC
22283	506	16	never	never	RB
22283	506	17	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	506	18	;	;	:
22283	506	19	in	in	IN
22283	506	20	the	the	DT
22283	506	21	theatre	theatre	NN
22283	506	22	of	of	IN
22283	506	23	things	thing	NNS
22283	506	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	506	25	are	be	VBP
22283	506	26	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	506	27	to	to	TO
22283	506	28	be	be	VB
22283	506	29	always	always	RB
22283	506	30	spectators	spectator	NNS
22283	506	31	and	and	CC
22283	506	32	never	never	RB
22283	506	33	actors	actor	NNS
22283	506	34	;	;	:
22283	506	35	in	in	IN
22283	506	36	the	the	DT
22283	506	37	laboratory	laboratory	NN
22283	506	38	of	of	IN
22283	506	39	life	life	NN
22283	506	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	506	41	are	be	VBP
22283	506	42	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	506	43	to	to	TO
22283	506	44	be	be	VB
22283	506	45	always	always	RB
22283	506	46	by	by	IN
22283	506	47	-	-	HYPH
22283	506	48	products	product	NNS
22283	506	49	;	;	,
22283	506	50	and	and	CC
22283	506	51	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	506	52	in	in	IN
22283	506	53	the	the	DT
22283	506	54	order	order	NN
22283	506	55	of	of	IN
22283	506	56	nature	nature	NN
22283	506	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	506	58	are	be	VBP
22283	506	59	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	506	60	to	to	TO
22283	506	61	have	have	VB
22283	506	62	no	no	DT
22283	506	63	_	_	NNP
22283	506	64	raison	raison	NNP
22283	506	65	d'être	d'être	NNP
22283	506	66	_	_	NNP
22283	506	67	.	.	.
22283	507	1	Such	such	PDT
22283	507	2	a	a	DT
22283	507	3	state	state	NN
22283	507	4	of	of	IN
22283	507	5	matters	matter	NNS
22283	507	6	would	would	MD
22283	507	7	be	be	VB
22283	507	8	accountable	accountable	JJ
22283	507	9	enough	enough	RB
22283	507	10	if	if	IN
22283	507	11	the	the	DT
22283	507	12	stream	stream	NN
22283	507	13	of	of	IN
22283	507	14	mental	mental	JJ
22283	507	15	changes	change	NNS
22283	507	16	were	be	VBD
22283	507	17	but	but	CC
22283	507	18	partly	partly	RB
22283	507	19	,	,	,
22283	507	20	occasionally	occasionally	RB
22283	507	21	,	,	,
22283	507	22	and	and	CC
22283	507	23	imperfectly	imperfectly	RB
22283	507	24	associated	associate	VBN
22283	507	25	with	with	IN
22283	507	26	the	the	DT
22283	507	27	stream	stream	NN
22283	507	28	of	of	IN
22283	507	29	material	material	NN
22283	507	30	changes	change	NNS
22283	507	31	;	;	:
22283	507	32	but	but	CC
22283	507	33	as	as	IN
22283	507	34	the	the	DT
22283	507	35	association	association	NN
22283	507	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	507	37	so	so	RB
22283	507	38	minute	minute	JJ
22283	507	39	,	,	,
22283	507	40	invariable	invariable	JJ
22283	507	41	,	,	,
22283	507	42	and	and	CC
22283	507	43	precise	precise	JJ
22283	507	44	,	,	,
22283	507	45	the	the	DT
22283	507	46	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	507	47	of	of	IN
22283	507	48	the	the	DT
22283	507	49	association	association	NN
22283	507	50	being	be	VBG
22283	507	51	merely	merely	RB
22283	507	52	accidental	accidental	JJ
22283	507	53	,	,	,
22283	507	54	or	or	CC
22283	507	55	_	_	NNP
22283	507	56	not	not	RB
22283	507	57	requiring	require	VBG
22283	507	58	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	507	59	_	_	NNP
22283	507	60	,	,	,
22283	507	61	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	507	62	,	,	,
22283	507	63	at	at	IN
22283	507	64	the	the	DT
22283	507	65	bar	bar	NN
22283	507	66	of	of	IN
22283	507	67	methodical	methodical	JJ
22283	507	68	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	507	69	,	,	,
22283	507	70	self	self	NN
22283	507	71	-	-	HYPH
22283	507	72	convicted	convict	VBN
22283	507	73	of	of	IN
22283	507	74	absurdity	absurdity	NN
22283	507	75	.	.	.
22283	508	1	The	the	DT
22283	508	2	state	state	NN
22283	508	3	of	of	IN
22283	508	4	the	the	DT
22283	508	5	case	case	NN
22283	508	6	,	,	,
22283	508	7	then	then	RB
22283	508	8	,	,	,
22283	508	9	simply	simply	RB
22283	508	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	508	11	that	that	IN
22283	508	12	two	two	CD
22283	508	13	distinct	distinct	JJ
22283	508	14	facts	fact	NNS
22283	508	15	stand	stand	VBP
22283	508	16	to	to	TO
22283	508	17	be	be	VB
22283	508	18	explained	explain	VBN
22283	508	19	by	by	IN
22283	508	20	the	the	DT
22283	508	21	theory	theory	NN
22283	508	22	of	of	IN
22283	508	23	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	508	24	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	508	25	--	--	:
22283	508	26	first	first	RB
22283	508	27	,	,	,
22283	508	28	why	why	WRB
22283	508	29	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	508	30	should	should	MD
22283	508	31	ever	ever	RB
22283	508	32	have	have	VB
22283	508	33	been	be	VBN
22283	508	34	developed	develop	VBN
22283	508	35	as	as	IN
22283	508	36	a	a	DT
22283	508	37	mysterious	mysterious	JJ
22283	508	38	appendage	appendage	NN
22283	508	39	to	to	IN
22283	508	40	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	508	41	;	;	:
22283	508	42	and	and	CC
22283	508	43	,	,	,
22283	508	44	secondly	secondly	RB
22283	508	45	,	,	,
22283	508	46	why	why	WRB
22283	508	47	the	the	DT
22283	508	48	association	association	NN
22283	508	49	between	between	IN
22283	508	50	these	these	DT
22283	508	51	things	thing	NNS
22283	508	52	should	should	MD
22283	508	53	be	be	VB
22283	508	54	so	so	RB
22283	508	55	intimate	intimate	JJ
22283	508	56	and	and	CC
22283	508	57	precise	precise	JJ
22283	508	58	.	.	.
22283	509	1	Assuredly	assuredly	RB
22283	509	2	,	,	,
22283	509	3	on	on	IN
22283	509	4	the	the	DT
22283	509	5	principles	principle	NNS
22283	509	6	of	of	IN
22283	509	7	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	509	8	,	,	,
22283	509	9	which	which	WDT
22283	509	10	materialists	materialist	VBZ
22283	509	11	at	at	RB
22283	509	12	least	least	JJS
22283	509	13	can	can	MD
22283	509	14	not	not	RB
22283	509	15	afford	afford	VB
22283	509	16	to	to	TO
22283	509	17	disregard	disregard	VB
22283	509	18	,	,	,
22283	509	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	509	20	would	would	MD
22283	509	21	be	be	VB
22283	509	22	a	a	DT
22283	509	23	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	509	24	anomalous	anomalous	JJ
22283	509	25	fact	fact	NN
22283	509	26	that	that	IN
22283	509	27	so	so	RB
22283	509	28	wide	wide	JJ
22283	509	29	and	and	CC
22283	509	30	general	general	JJ
22283	509	31	a	a	DT
22283	509	32	class	class	NN
22283	509	33	of	of	IN
22283	509	34	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	509	35	as	as	IN
22283	509	36	those	those	DT
22283	509	37	of	of	IN
22283	509	38	mind	mind	NN
22283	509	39	should	should	MD
22283	509	40	have	have	VB
22283	509	41	become	become	VBN
22283	509	42	developed	develop	VBN
22283	509	43	in	in	IN
22283	509	44	constantly	constantly	RB
22283	509	45	ascending	ascend	VBG
22283	509	46	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	509	47	throughout	throughout	IN
22283	509	48	the	the	DT
22283	509	49	animal	animal	NN
22283	509	50	kingdom	kingdom	NN
22283	509	51	,	,	,
22283	509	52	if	if	IN
22283	509	53	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	509	54	are	be	VBP
22283	509	55	entirely	entirely	RB
22283	509	56	without	without	IN
22283	509	57	use	use	NN
22283	509	58	to	to	IN
22283	509	59	animals	animal	NNS
22283	509	60	.	.	.
22283	510	1	If	if	IN
22283	510	2	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	510	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	510	4	,	,	,
22283	510	5	as	as	IN
22283	510	6	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	510	7	,	,	,
22283	510	8	a	a	DT
22283	510	9	function	function	NN
22283	510	10	of	of	IN
22283	510	11	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	510	12	,	,	,
22283	510	13	the	the	DT
22283	510	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	510	15	of	of	IN
22283	510	16	natural	natural	JJ
22283	510	17	selection	selection	NN
22283	510	18	alone	alone	RB
22283	510	19	would	would	MD
22283	510	20	forbid	forbid	VB
22283	510	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	510	22	to	to	TO
22283	510	23	imagine	imagine	VB
22283	510	24	that	that	IN
22283	510	25	this	this	DT
22283	510	26	function	function	NN
22283	510	27	differs	differ	VBZ
22283	510	28	from	from	IN
22283	510	29	all	all	DT
22283	510	30	other	other	JJ
22283	510	31	functions	function	NNS
22283	510	32	in	in	IN
22283	510	33	being	be	VBG
22283	510	34	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	510	35	functionless	functionless	JJ
22283	510	36	.	.	.
22283	511	1	If	if	IN
22283	511	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	511	3	would	would	MD
22283	511	4	be	be	VB
22283	511	5	detrimental	detrimental	JJ
22283	511	6	to	to	IN
22283	511	7	the	the	DT
22283	511	8	theory	theory	NN
22283	511	9	of	of	IN
22283	511	10	natural	natural	JJ
22283	511	11	selection	selection	NN
22283	511	12	that	that	IN
22283	511	13	any	any	DT
22283	511	14	one	one	CD
22283	511	15	isolated	isolate	VBN
22283	511	16	structure	structure	NN
22283	511	17	--	--	:
22283	511	18	such	such	JJ
22283	511	19	as	as	IN
22283	511	20	the	the	DT
22283	511	21	tail	tail	NN
22283	511	22	of	of	IN
22283	511	23	a	a	DT
22283	511	24	rattlesnake	rattlesnake	NN
22283	511	25	--	--	:
22283	511	26	should	should	MD
22283	511	27	be	be	VB
22283	511	28	adapted	adapt	VBN
22283	511	29	to	to	TO
22283	511	30	perform	perform	VB
22283	511	31	a	a	DT
22283	511	32	function	function	NN
22283	511	33	useless	useless	JJ
22283	511	34	to	to	IN
22283	511	35	the	the	DT
22283	511	36	animal	animal	NN
22283	511	37	possessing	possess	VBG
22283	511	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	511	39	,	,	,
22283	511	40	how	how	WRB
22283	511	41	utterly	utterly	RB
22283	511	42	destructive	destructive	JJ
22283	511	43	of	of	IN
22283	511	44	that	that	DT
22283	511	45	theory	theory	NN
22283	511	46	would	would	MD
22283	511	47	be	be	VB
22283	511	48	the	the	DT
22283	511	49	fact	fact	NN
22283	511	50	that	that	IN
22283	511	51	all	all	PDT
22283	511	52	the	the	DT
22283	511	53	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	511	54	of	of	IN
22283	511	55	mind	mind	NN
22283	511	56	have	have	VBP
22283	511	57	been	be	VBN
22283	511	58	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
22283	511	59	as	as	IN
22283	511	60	functions	function	NNS
22283	511	61	of	of	IN
22283	511	62	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	511	63	-	-	HYPH
22283	511	64	tissue	tissue	NN
22283	511	65	without	without	IN
22283	511	66	any	any	DT
22283	511	67	one	one	CD
22283	511	68	of	of	IN
22283	511	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	511	70	ever	ever	RB
22283	511	71	having	have	VBG
22283	511	72	been	be	VBN
22283	511	73	of	of	IN
22283	511	74	any	any	DT
22283	511	75	use	use	NN
22283	511	76	either	either	CC
22283	511	77	to	to	IN
22283	511	78	the	the	DT
22283	511	79	individual	individual	NN
22283	511	80	or	or	CC
22283	511	81	to	to	IN
22283	511	82	the	the	DT
22283	511	83	species	specie	NNS
22283	511	84	.	.	.
22283	512	1	And	and	CC
22283	512	2	the	the	DT
22283	512	3	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	512	4	that	that	WDT
22283	512	5	thus	thus	RB
22283	512	6	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	512	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	512	8	magnified	magnify	VBN
22283	512	9	without	without	IN
22283	512	10	limit	limit	NN
22283	512	11	when	when	WRB
22283	512	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	512	13	remember	remember	VBP
22283	512	14	that	that	IN
22283	512	15	the	the	DT
22283	512	16	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	512	17	of	of	IN
22283	512	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	512	19	are	be	VBP
22283	512	20	invariable	invariable	JJ
22283	512	21	in	in	IN
22283	512	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	512	23	association	association	NN
22283	512	24	with	with	IN
22283	512	25	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	512	26	structure	structure	NN
22283	512	27	,	,	,
22283	512	28	grade	grade	NN
22283	512	29	for	for	IN
22283	512	30	grade	grade	NN
22283	512	31	,	,	,
22283	512	32	and	and	CC
22283	512	33	process	process	NN
22283	512	34	for	for	IN
22283	512	35	process	process	NN
22283	512	36	.	.	.
22283	513	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	513	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	513	3	of	of	IN
22283	513	4	no	no	DT
22283	513	5	argumentative	argumentative	JJ
22283	513	6	use	use	NN
22283	513	7	to	to	TO
22283	513	8	point	point	VB
22283	513	9	to	to	IN
22283	513	10	the	the	DT
22283	513	11	fact	fact	NN
22283	513	12	that	that	IN
22283	513	13	many	many	JJ
22283	513	14	adaptive	adaptive	JJ
22283	513	15	movements	movement	NNS
22283	513	16	in	in	IN
22283	513	17	animals	animal	NNS
22283	513	18	are	be	VBP
22283	513	19	performed	perform	VBN
22283	513	20	by	by	IN
22283	513	21	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	513	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	513	23	centres	centre	NNS
22283	513	24	apart	apart	RB
22283	513	25	from	from	IN
22283	513	26	any	any	DT
22283	513	27	association	association	NN
22283	513	28	with	with	IN
22283	513	29	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	513	30	or	or	CC
22283	513	31	volition	volition	NN
22283	513	32	,	,	,
22283	513	33	because	because	IN
22283	513	34	all	all	PDT
22283	513	35	the	the	DT
22283	513	36	facts	fact	NNS
22283	513	37	on	on	IN
22283	513	38	this	this	DT
22283	513	39	head	head	NN
22283	513	40	go	go	VB
22283	513	41	to	to	TO
22283	513	42	prove	prove	VB
22283	513	43	that	that	DT
22283	513	44	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	513	45	and	and	CC
22283	513	46	volition	volition	NN
22283	513	47	come	come	VBP
22283	513	48	in	in	RP
22283	513	49	most	most	RBS
22283	513	50	suggestively	suggestively	RB
22283	513	51	just	just	RB
22283	513	52	where	where	WRB
22283	513	53	adaptive	adaptive	JJ
22283	513	54	movements	movement	NNS
22283	513	55	begin	begin	VBP
22283	513	56	to	to	TO
22283	513	57	grow	grow	VB
22283	513	58	varied	varied	JJ
22283	513	59	and	and	CC
22283	513	60	complex	complex	JJ
22283	513	61	,	,	,
22283	513	62	and	and	CC
22283	513	63	then	then	RB
22283	513	64	continue	continue	VB
22283	513	65	to	to	TO
22283	513	66	develop	develop	VB
22283	513	67	with	with	IN
22283	513	68	a	a	DT
22283	513	69	proportional	proportional	JJ
22283	513	70	reference	reference	NN
22283	513	71	to	to	IN
22283	513	72	the	the	DT
22283	513	73	growing	grow	VBG
22283	513	74	variety	variety	NN
22283	513	75	and	and	CC
22283	513	76	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	513	77	of	of	IN
22283	513	78	these	these	DT
22283	513	79	movements	movement	NNS
22283	513	80	.	.	.
22283	514	1	The	the	DT
22283	514	2	facts	fact	NNS
22283	514	3	,	,	,
22283	514	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	514	5	,	,	,
22283	514	6	irresistibly	irresistibly	RB
22283	514	7	lead	lead	VB
22283	514	8	to	to	IN
22283	514	9	the	the	DT
22283	514	10	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	514	11	(	(	-LRB-
22283	514	12	if	if	IN
22283	514	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	514	14	argue	argue	VBP
22283	514	15	here	here	RB
22283	514	16	as	as	IN
22283	514	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	514	18	should	should	MD
22283	514	19	in	in	IN
22283	514	20	the	the	DT
22283	514	21	case	case	NN
22283	514	22	of	of	IN
22283	514	23	any	any	DT
22283	514	24	other	other	JJ
22283	514	25	function	function	NN
22283	514	26	)	)	-RRB-
22283	514	27	that	that	WDT
22283	514	28	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	514	29	and	and	CC
22283	514	30	volition	volition	NN
22283	514	31	are	be	VBP
22283	514	32	functions	function	NNS
22283	514	33	of	of	IN
22283	514	34	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	514	35	-	-	HYPH
22283	514	36	tissue	tissue	NN
22283	514	37	super	super	RB
22283	514	38	-	-	VBN
22283	514	39	added	add	VBN
22283	514	40	to	to	IN
22283	514	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	514	42	previous	previous	JJ
22283	514	43	functions	function	NNS
22283	514	44	,	,	,
22283	514	45	in	in	IN
22283	514	46	order	order	NN
22283	514	47	to	to	TO
22283	514	48	meet	meet	VB
22283	514	49	new	new	JJ
22283	514	50	and	and	CC
22283	514	51	more	more	RBR
22283	514	52	complex	complex	JJ
22283	514	53	demands	demand	NNS
22283	514	54	on	on	IN
22283	514	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	514	56	powers	power	NNS
22283	514	57	of	of	IN
22283	514	58	adaptation	adaptation	NN
22283	514	59	.	.	.
22283	515	1	Neither	neither	DT
22283	515	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	515	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	515	4	of	of	IN
22283	515	5	any	any	DT
22283	515	6	argumentative	argumentative	JJ
22283	515	7	use	use	NN
22283	515	8	to	to	TO
22283	515	9	point	point	VB
22283	515	10	to	to	IN
22283	515	11	the	the	DT
22283	515	12	fact	fact	NN
22283	515	13	that	that	IN
22283	515	14	adaptive	adaptive	JJ
22283	515	15	actions	action	NNS
22283	515	16	which	which	WDT
22283	515	17	originally	originally	RB
22283	515	18	are	be	VBP
22283	515	19	performed	perform	VBN
22283	515	20	with	with	IN
22283	515	21	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	515	22	volition	volition	NN
22283	515	23	may	may	MD
22283	515	24	by	by	IN
22283	515	25	practice	practice	NN
22283	515	26	come	come	VB
22283	515	27	to	to	TO
22283	515	28	be	be	VB
22283	515	29	performed	perform	VBN
22283	515	30	without	without	IN
22283	515	31	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	515	32	volition	volition	NN
22283	515	33	.	.	.
22283	516	1	For	for	IN
22283	516	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	516	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	516	4	certain	certain	JJ
22283	516	5	that	that	IN
22283	516	6	no	no	DT
22283	516	7	adaptive	adaptive	JJ
22283	516	8	action	action	NN
22283	516	9	of	of	IN
22283	516	10	quite	quite	PDT
22283	516	11	a	a	DT
22283	516	12	novel	novel	JJ
22283	516	13	kind	kind	NN
22283	516	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	516	15	ever	ever	RB
22283	516	16	performed	perform	VBN
22283	516	17	from	from	IN
22283	516	18	the	the	DT
22283	516	19	first	first	JJ
22283	516	20	without	without	IN
22283	516	21	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	516	22	of	of	IN
22283	516	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	516	24	performance	performance	NN
22283	516	25	,	,	,
22283	516	26	and	and	CC
22283	516	27	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	516	28	,	,	,
22283	516	29	although	although	IN
22283	516	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	516	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	516	32	true	true	JJ
22283	516	33	that	that	IN
22283	516	34	by	by	IN
22283	516	35	repetition	repetition	NN
22283	516	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	516	37	performance	performance	NN
22283	516	38	may	may	MD
22283	516	39	become	become	VB
22283	516	40	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	516	41	or	or	CC
22283	516	42	unconscious	unconscious	JJ
22283	516	43	,	,	,
22283	516	44	this	this	DT
22283	516	45	does	do	VBZ
22283	516	46	not	not	RB
22283	516	47	prove	prove	VB
22283	516	48	that	that	DT
22283	516	49	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	516	50	was	be	VBD
22283	516	51	without	without	IN
22283	516	52	use	use	NN
22283	516	53	in	in	IN
22283	516	54	producing	produce	VBG
22283	516	55	the	the	DT
22283	516	56	adaptive	adaptive	JJ
22283	516	57	action	action	NN
22283	516	58	.	.	.
22283	517	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	517	2	only	only	RB
22283	517	3	proves	prove	VBZ
22283	517	4	that	that	IN
22283	517	5	after	after	IN
22283	517	6	a	a	DT
22283	517	7	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	517	8	mechanism	mechanism	NN
22283	517	9	has	have	VBZ
22283	517	10	been	be	VBN
22283	517	11	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
22283	517	12	by	by	IN
22283	517	13	the	the	DT
22283	517	14	help	help	NN
22283	517	15	of	of	IN
22283	517	16	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	517	17	,	,	,
22283	517	18	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	517	19	may	may	MD
22283	517	20	be	be	VB
22283	517	21	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
22283	517	22	and	and	CC
22283	517	23	leave	leave	VB
22283	517	24	the	the	DT
22283	517	25	finished	finished	JJ
22283	517	26	mechanism	mechanism	NN
22283	517	27	to	to	TO
22283	517	28	work	work	VB
22283	517	29	alone	alone	RB
22283	517	30	;	;	:
22283	517	31	the	the	DT
22283	517	32	structure	structure	NN
22283	517	33	having	have	VBG
22283	517	34	been	be	VBN
22283	517	35	completed	complete	VBN
22283	517	36	,	,	,
22283	517	37	the	the	DT
22283	517	38	scaffolding	scaffolding	NN
22283	517	39	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	517	40	to	to	IN
22283	517	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	517	42	completion	completion	NN
22283	517	43	may	may	MD
22283	517	44	be	be	VB
22283	517	45	removed	remove	VBN
22283	517	46	.	.	.
22283	518	1	But	but	CC
22283	518	2	passing	pass	VBG
22283	518	3	over	over	RP
22283	518	4	this	this	DT
22283	518	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	518	6	which	which	WDT
22283	518	7	the	the	DT
22283	518	8	theory	theory	NN
22283	518	9	of	of	IN
22283	518	10	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	518	11	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	518	12	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	518	13	bound	bind	VBN
22283	518	14	to	to	TO
22283	518	15	encounter	encounter	VB
22283	518	16	in	in	IN
22283	518	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	518	18	collision	collision	NN
22283	518	19	with	with	IN
22283	518	20	the	the	DT
22283	518	21	theory	theory	NN
22283	518	22	of	of	IN
22283	518	23	natural	natural	JJ
22283	518	24	selection	selection	NN
22283	518	25	,	,	,
22283	518	26	the	the	DT
22283	518	27	most	most	RBS
22283	518	28	insuperable	insuperable	JJ
22283	518	29	of	of	IN
22283	518	30	all	all	DT
22283	518	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	518	32	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	518	33	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	518	34	from	from	IN
22283	518	35	the	the	DT
22283	518	36	bare	bare	JJ
22283	518	37	fact	fact	NN
22283	518	38	,	,	,
22283	518	39	which	which	WDT
22283	518	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	518	41	can	can	MD
22283	518	42	not	not	RB
22283	518	43	explain	explain	VB
22283	518	44	,	,	,
22283	518	45	that	that	DT
22283	518	46	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	518	47	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	518	48	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	518	49	,	,	,
22283	518	50	and	and	CC
22283	518	51	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	518	52	in	in	IN
22283	518	53	the	the	DT
22283	518	54	most	most	RBS
22283	518	55	intimate	intimate	JJ
22283	518	56	relation	relation	NN
22283	518	57	with	with	IN
22283	518	58	one	one	CD
22283	518	59	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
22283	518	60	kind	kind	NN
22283	518	61	of	of	IN
22283	518	62	material	material	JJ
22283	518	63	structure	structure	NN
22283	518	64	.	.	.
22283	519	1	For	for	IN
22283	519	2	automatists	automatist	NNS
22283	519	3	must	must	MD
22283	519	4	concede	concede	VB
22283	519	5	that	that	IN
22283	519	6	the	the	DT
22283	519	7	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	519	8	of	of	IN
22283	519	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	519	10	in	in	IN
22283	519	11	the	the	DT
22283	519	12	region	region	NN
22283	519	13	of	of	IN
22283	519	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	519	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	519	16	at	at	IN
22283	519	17	least	least	JJS
22283	519	18	as	as	RB
22283	519	19	cogent	cogent	JJ
22283	519	20	as	as	IN
22283	519	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	519	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	519	23	in	in	IN
22283	519	24	the	the	DT
22283	519	25	region	region	NN
22283	519	26	of	of	IN
22283	519	27	matter	matter	NN
22283	519	28	,	,	,
22283	519	29	seeing	see	VBG
22283	519	30	that	that	IN
22283	519	31	the	the	DT
22283	519	32	whole	whole	JJ
22283	519	33	science	science	NN
22283	519	34	of	of	IN
22283	519	35	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	519	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	519	37	only	only	RB
22283	519	38	rendered	render	VBN
22283	519	39	possible	possible	JJ
22283	519	40	as	as	IN
22283	519	41	a	a	DT
22283	519	42	science	science	NN
22283	519	43	by	by	IN
22283	519	44	the	the	DT
22283	519	45	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	519	46	fact	fact	NN
22283	519	47	of	of	IN
22283	519	48	observation	observation	NN
22283	519	49	that	that	IN
22283	519	50	mental	mental	JJ
22283	519	51	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
22283	519	52	determine	determine	VBP
22283	519	53	mental	mental	JJ
22283	519	54	consequents	consequent	NNS
22283	519	55	.	.	.
22283	520	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	520	2	,	,	,
22283	520	3	if	if	IN
22283	520	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	520	5	call	call	VBP
22283	520	6	a	a	DT
22283	520	7	physical	physical	JJ
22283	520	8	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	520	9	_	_	NNP
22283	520	10	A	A	NNP
22283	520	11	,	,	,
22283	520	12	B	B	NNP
22283	520	13	,	,	,
22283	520	14	C	C	NNP
22283	520	15	_	_	NNP
22283	520	16	,	,	,
22283	520	17	and	and	CC
22283	520	18	a	a	DT
22283	520	19	mental	mental	JJ
22283	520	20	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	520	21	_	_	NNP
22283	520	22	a	a	NNP
22283	520	23	,	,	,
22283	520	24	b	b	NN
22283	520	25	,	,	,
22283	520	26	c	c	NNP
22283	520	27	_	_	NNP
22283	520	28	automatists	automatist	NNS
22283	520	29	have	have	VBP
22283	520	30	to	to	TO
22283	520	31	explain	explain	VB
22283	520	32	,	,	,
22283	520	33	not	not	RB
22283	520	34	merely	merely	RB
22283	520	35	why	why	WRB
22283	520	36	there	there	EX
22283	520	37	should	should	MD
22283	520	38	be	be	VB
22283	520	39	such	such	PDT
22283	520	40	a	a	DT
22283	520	41	thing	thing	NN
22283	520	42	as	as	IN
22283	520	43	a	a	DT
22283	520	44	mental	mental	JJ
22283	520	45	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	520	46	at	at	RB
22283	520	47	all	all	RB
22283	520	48	,	,	,
22283	520	49	but	but	CC
22283	520	50	also	also	RB
22283	520	51	why	why	WRB
22283	520	52	the	the	DT
22283	520	53	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	520	54	_	_	NNP
22283	520	55	a	a	NNP
22283	520	56	,	,	,
22283	520	57	b	b	NN
22283	520	58	,	,	,
22283	520	59	c	c	NNP
22283	520	60	_	_	NNP
22283	520	61	should	should	MD
22283	520	62	always	always	RB
22283	520	63	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	520	64	,	,	,
22283	520	65	link	link	VB
22283	520	66	for	for	IN
22283	520	67	link	link	NN
22283	520	68	,	,	,
22283	520	69	with	with	IN
22283	520	70	the	the	DT
22283	520	71	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	520	72	_	_	NNP
22283	520	73	A	A	NNP
22283	520	74	,	,	,
22283	520	75	B	B	NNP
22283	520	76	,	,	,
22283	520	77	C	C	NNP
22283	520	78	_	_	NNP
22283	520	79	.	.	.
22283	521	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	521	2	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	521	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	521	4	no	no	DT
22283	521	5	answer	answer	NN
22283	521	6	to	to	TO
22283	521	7	say	say	VB
22283	521	8	that	that	IN
22283	521	9	the	the	DT
22283	521	10	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	521	11	_	_	NNP
22283	521	12	A	A	NNP
22283	521	13	,	,	,
22283	521	14	B	B	NNP
22283	521	15	,	,	,
22283	521	16	C	C	NNP
22283	521	17	_	_	NNP
22283	521	18	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	521	19	the	the	DT
22283	521	20	successive	successive	JJ
22283	521	21	activity	activity	NN
22283	521	22	of	of	IN
22283	521	23	certain	certain	JJ
22283	521	24	definite	definite	JJ
22283	521	25	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	521	26	-	-	HYPH
22283	521	27	centres	centre	NNS
22283	521	28	_	_	NNP
22283	521	29	A	A	NNP
22283	521	30	'	'	''
22283	521	31	,	,	,
22283	521	32	B	b	NN
22283	521	33	'	'	''
22283	521	34	,	,	,
22283	521	35	C	C	NNP
22283	521	36	'	'	''
22283	521	37	_	_	NN
22283	521	38	which	which	WDT
22283	521	39	have	have	VBP
22283	521	40	for	for	IN
22283	521	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	521	42	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	521	43	effects	effect	NNS
22283	521	44	the	the	DT
22283	521	45	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	521	46	_	_	NNP
22283	521	47	a	a	NNP
22283	521	48	,	,	,
22283	521	49	b	b	NN
22283	521	50	,	,	,
22283	521	51	c	c	NNP
22283	521	52	_	_	NNP
22283	521	53	so	so	IN
22283	521	54	that	that	IN
22283	521	55	whenever	whenever	WRB
22283	521	56	the	the	DT
22283	521	57	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	521	58	_	_	NNP
22283	521	59	A	A	NNP
22283	521	60	,	,	,
22283	521	61	B	B	NNP
22283	521	62	,	,	,
22283	521	63	C	C	NNP
22283	521	64	_	_	NNP
22283	521	65	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	521	66	the	the	DT
22283	521	67	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	521	68	_	_	NNP
22283	521	69	a	a	NNP
22283	521	70	,	,	,
22283	521	71	b	b	NN
22283	521	72	,	,	,
22283	521	73	c	c	NNP
22283	521	74	_	_	NNP
22283	521	75	must	must	MD
22283	521	76	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	521	77	occur	occur	VB
22283	521	78	.	.	.
22283	522	1	This	this	DT
22283	522	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	522	3	no	no	DT
22283	522	4	answer	answer	NN
22283	522	5	,	,	,
22283	522	6	because	because	IN
22283	522	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	522	8	merely	merely	RB
22283	522	9	restates	restate	VBZ
22283	522	10	the	the	DT
22283	522	11	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	522	12	of	of	IN
22283	522	13	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	522	14	,	,	,
22283	522	15	and	and	CC
22283	522	16	begs	beg	VBZ
22283	522	17	the	the	DT
22283	522	18	whole	whole	JJ
22283	522	19	question	question	NN
22283	522	20	to	to	TO
22283	522	21	be	be	VB
22283	522	22	discussed	discuss	VBN
22283	522	23	.	.	.
22283	523	1	What	what	WDT
22283	523	2	methodical	methodical	JJ
22283	523	3	reason	reason	NN
22283	523	4	demands	demand	VBZ
22283	523	5	as	as	IN
22283	523	6	an	an	DT
22283	523	7	answer	answer	NN
22283	523	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	523	9	simply	simply	RB
22283	523	10	why	why	WRB
22283	523	11	the	the	DT
22283	523	12	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	523	13	_	_	NNP
22283	523	14	A	A	NNP
22283	523	15	,	,	,
22283	523	16	B	B	NNP
22283	523	17	,	,	,
22283	523	18	C	C	NNP
22283	523	19	_	_	NNP
22283	523	20	even	even	RB
22283	523	21	though	though	IN
22283	523	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	523	23	freely	freely	RB
22283	523	24	grant	grant	VBP
22283	523	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	523	26	due	due	IN
22283	523	27	to	to	IN
22283	523	28	the	the	DT
22283	523	29	successive	successive	JJ
22283	523	30	activity	activity	NN
22283	523	31	of	of	IN
22283	523	32	certain	certain	JJ
22283	523	33	definite	definite	JJ
22283	523	34	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	523	35	-	-	HYPH
22283	523	36	centres	centre	NNS
22283	523	37	,	,	,
22283	523	38	should	should	MD
22283	523	39	be	be	VB
22283	523	40	attended	attend	VBN
22283	523	41	by	by	IN
22283	523	42	the	the	DT
22283	523	43	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	523	44	_	_	NNP
22283	523	45	a	a	NNP
22283	523	46	,	,	,
22283	523	47	b	b	NN
22283	523	48	,	,	,
22283	523	49	c	c	NNP
22283	523	50	_	_	NNP
22283	523	51	.	.	.
22283	524	1	Reason	reason	NN
22283	524	2	perceives	perceive	VBZ
22283	524	3	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	524	4	enough	enough	RB
22283	524	5	that	that	IN
22283	524	6	the	the	DT
22283	524	7	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	524	8	_	_	NNP
22283	524	9	a	a	NNP
22283	524	10	,	,	,
22283	524	11	b	b	NN
22283	524	12	,	,	,
22283	524	13	c	c	NNP
22283	524	14	_	_	NNP
22283	524	15	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	524	16	to	to	IN
22283	524	17	a	a	DT
22283	524	18	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	524	19	different	different	JJ
22283	524	20	category	category	NN
22283	524	21	from	from	IN
22283	524	22	the	the	DT
22283	524	23	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	524	24	_	_	NNP
22283	524	25	A	A	NNP
22283	524	26	,	,	,
22283	524	27	B	B	NNP
22283	524	28	,	,	,
22283	524	29	C	C	NNP
22283	524	30	_	_	NNP
22283	524	31	the	the	DT
22283	524	32	one	one	NN
22283	524	33	being	be	VBG
22283	524	34	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	524	35	known	know	VBN
22283	524	36	as	as	IN
22283	524	37	a	a	DT
22283	524	38	process	process	NN
22283	524	39	taking	take	VBG
22283	524	40	place	place	NN
22283	524	41	in	in	IN
22283	524	42	a	a	DT
22283	524	43	something	something	NN
22283	524	44	which	which	WDT
22283	524	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	524	46	without	without	IN
22283	524	47	extension	extension	NN
22283	524	48	or	or	CC
22283	524	49	physical	physical	JJ
22283	524	50	properties	property	NNS
22283	524	51	of	of	IN
22283	524	52	any	any	DT
22283	524	53	kind	kind	NN
22283	524	54	,	,	,
22283	524	55	and	and	CC
22283	524	56	the	the	DT
22283	524	57	other	other	JJ
22283	524	58	taking	take	VBG
22283	524	59	place	place	NN
22283	524	60	in	in	IN
22283	524	61	a	a	DT
22283	524	62	something	something	NN
22283	524	63	which	which	WDT
22283	524	64	when	when	WRB
22283	524	65	,	,	,
22283	524	66	translated	translate	VBN
22283	524	67	by	by	IN
22283	524	68	the	the	DT
22283	524	69	previous	previous	JJ
22283	524	70	something	something	NN
22283	524	71	,	,	,
22283	524	72	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	524	73	recognize	recognize	VBP
22283	524	74	as	as	IN
22283	524	75	having	have	VBG
22283	524	76	extension	extension	NN
22283	524	77	and	and	CC
22283	524	78	the	the	DT
22283	524	79	other	other	JJ
22283	524	80	antithetical	antithetical	JJ
22283	524	81	properties	property	NNS
22283	524	82	which	which	WDT
22283	524	83	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	524	84	class	class	VBP
22283	524	85	together	together	RB
22283	524	86	as	as	IN
22283	524	87	physical	physical	JJ
22283	524	88	.	.	.
22283	525	1	There	there	EX
22283	525	2	would	would	MD
22283	525	3	of	of	IN
22283	525	4	course	course	NN
22283	525	5	be	be	VB
22283	525	6	no	no	DT
22283	525	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	525	8	if	if	IN
22283	525	9	the	the	DT
22283	525	10	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	525	11	_	_	NNP
22283	525	12	A	A	NNP
22283	525	13	,	,	,
22283	525	14	B	B	NNP
22283	525	15	,	,	,
22283	525	16	C	C	NNP
22283	525	17	_	_	NNP
22283	525	18	continued	continue	VBD
22283	525	19	through	through	IN
22283	525	20	any	any	DT
22283	525	21	amount	amount	NN
22283	525	22	of	of	IN
22283	525	23	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	525	24	in	in	IN
22283	525	25	the	the	DT
22283	525	26	same	same	JJ
22283	525	27	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	525	28	category	category	NN
22283	525	29	of	of	IN
22283	525	30	being	be	VBG
22283	525	31	;	;	:
22283	525	32	so	so	IN
22283	525	33	that	that	IN
22283	525	34	there	there	EX
22283	525	35	would	would	MD
22283	525	36	be	be	VB
22283	525	37	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	525	38	actually	actually	RB
22283	525	39	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	525	40	in	in	IN
22283	525	41	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	525	42	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	525	43	--	--	:
22283	525	44	changes	change	VBZ
22283	525	45	running	run	VBG
22283	525	46	through	through	IN
22283	525	47	_	_	NNP
22283	525	48	D	D	NNP
22283	525	49	,	,	,
22283	525	50	E	e	NN
22283	525	51	,	,	,
22283	525	52	F	F	NNP
22283	525	53	_	_	NNP
22283	525	54	,	,	,
22283	525	55	&	&	CC
22283	525	56	c.	c.	NNP
22283	525	57	,	,	,
22283	525	58	to	to	IN
22283	525	59	an	an	DT
22283	525	60	extent	extent	NN
22283	525	61	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	525	62	to	to	TO
22283	525	63	cause	cause	VB
22283	525	64	unconscious	unconscious	JJ
22283	525	65	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	525	66	of	of	IN
22283	525	67	any	any	DT
22283	525	68	degree	degree	NN
22283	525	69	of	of	IN
22283	525	70	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	525	71	.	.	.
22283	526	1	But	but	CC
22283	526	2	that	that	DT
22283	526	3	which	which	WDT
22283	526	4	does	do	VBZ
22283	526	5	require	require	VB
22283	526	6	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	526	7	from	from	IN
22283	526	8	automatists	automatist	NNS
22283	526	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	526	10	why	why	WRB
22283	526	11	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	526	12	should	should	MD
22283	526	13	have	have	VB
22283	526	14	become	become	VBN
22283	526	15	associated	associate	VBN
22283	526	16	with	with	IN
22283	526	17	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	526	18	,	,	,
22283	526	19	and	and	CC
22283	526	20	this	this	DT
22283	526	21	so	so	RB
22283	526	22	intimately	intimately	RB
22283	526	23	that	that	IN
22283	526	24	every	every	DT
22283	526	25	change	change	NN
22283	526	26	in	in	IN
22283	526	27	the	the	DT
22283	526	28	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	526	29	_	_	NNP
22283	526	30	A	A	NNP
22283	526	31	,	,	,
22283	526	32	B	B	NNP
22283	526	33	,	,	,
22283	526	34	C	C	NNP
22283	526	35	_	_	NNP
22283	526	36	,	,	,
22283	526	37	&	&	CC
22283	526	38	c.	c.	NNP
22283	526	39	,	,	,
22283	526	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	526	41	accompanied	accompany	VBN
22283	526	42	by	by	IN
22283	526	43	a	a	DT
22283	526	44	particular	particular	JJ
22283	526	45	and	and	CC
22283	526	46	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	526	47	change	change	NN
22283	526	48	in	in	IN
22283	526	49	the	the	DT
22283	526	50	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	526	51	_	_	NNP
22283	526	52	a	a	NNP
22283	526	53	,	,	,
22283	526	54	b	b	NN
22283	526	55	,	,	,
22283	526	56	c	c	NNP
22283	526	57	_	_	NNP
22283	526	58	,	,	,
22283	526	59	&	&	CC
22283	526	60	c.	c.	NNP
22283	526	61	Thus	thus	RB
22283	526	62	,	,	,
22283	526	63	to	to	TO
22283	526	64	take	take	VB
22283	526	65	a	a	DT
22283	526	66	definite	definite	JJ
22283	526	67	illustration	illustration	NN
22283	526	68	,	,	,
22283	526	69	if	if	IN
22283	526	70	on	on	IN
22283	526	71	seeing	see	VBG
22283	526	72	the	the	DT
22283	526	73	sun	sun	NN
22283	526	74	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	526	75	think	think	VBP
22283	526	76	of	of	IN
22283	526	77	a	a	DT
22283	526	78	paper	paper	NN
22283	526	79	on	on	IN
22283	526	80	solar	solar	JJ
22283	526	81	physics	physics	NN
22283	526	82	,	,	,
22283	526	83	and	and	CC
22283	526	84	from	from	IN
22283	526	85	this	this	DT
22283	526	86	pass	pass	NN
22283	526	87	to	to	IN
22283	526	88	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	526	89	of	of	IN
22283	526	90	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	526	91	Norman	Norman	NNP
22283	526	92	Lockyer	Lockyer	NNP
22283	526	93	,	,	,
22283	526	94	and	and	CC
22283	526	95	from	from	IN
22283	526	96	this	this	DT
22283	526	97	to	to	IN
22283	526	98	speculating	speculate	VBG
22283	526	99	on	on	IN
22283	526	100	the	the	DT
22283	526	101	probability	probability	NN
22283	526	102	of	of	IN
22283	526	103	certain	certain	JJ
22283	526	104	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	526	105	elements	element	NNS
22283	526	106	being	be	VBG
22283	526	107	really	really	RB
22283	526	108	compounds	compound	NNS
22283	526	109	,	,	,
22283	526	110	there	there	EX
22283	526	111	is	be	VBZ
22283	526	112	here	here	RB
22283	526	113	a	a	DT
22283	526	114	definite	definite	JJ
22283	526	115	causal	causal	JJ
22283	526	116	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	526	117	in	in	IN
22283	526	118	the	the	DT
22283	526	119	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	526	120	of	of	IN
22283	526	121	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	526	122	_	_	NNP
22283	526	123	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	526	124	_	_	NNP
22283	526	125	.	.	.
22283	527	1	But	but	CC
22283	527	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	527	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	527	4	the	the	DT
22283	527	5	last	last	JJ
22283	527	6	extravagance	extravagance	NN
22283	527	7	of	of	IN
22283	527	8	absurdity	absurdity	NN
22283	527	9	to	to	TO
22283	527	10	tell	tell	VB
22283	527	11	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	527	12	that	that	IN
22283	527	13	the	the	DT
22283	527	14	accompanying	accompany	VBG
22283	527	15	causal	causal	JJ
22283	527	16	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	527	17	going	go	VBG
22283	527	18	on	on	RP
22283	527	19	in	in	IN
22283	527	20	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	527	21	brain	brain	NN
22283	527	22	happen	happen	VB
22283	527	23	to	to	TO
22283	527	24	have	have	VB
22283	527	25	exactly	exactly	RB
22283	527	26	corresponded	correspond	VBN
22283	527	27	to	to	IN
22283	527	28	the	the	DT
22283	527	29	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	527	30	which	which	WDT
22283	527	31	were	be	VBD
22283	527	32	taking	take	VBG
22283	527	33	place	place	NN
22283	527	34	in	in	IN
22283	527	35	the	the	DT
22283	527	36	mind	mind	NN
22283	527	37	,	,	,
22283	527	38	the	the	DT
22283	527	39	two	two	CD
22283	527	40	trains	train	NNS
22283	527	41	of	of	IN
22283	527	42	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	527	43	being	be	VBG
22283	527	44	each	each	DT
22283	527	45	definite	definite	JJ
22283	527	46	and	and	CC
22283	527	47	coherent	coherent	JJ
22283	527	48	in	in	IN
22283	527	49	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	527	50	,	,	,
22283	527	51	and	and	CC
22283	527	52	yet	yet	RB
22283	527	53	each	each	DT
22283	527	54	proceeding	proceeding	NN
22283	527	55	link	link	NN
22283	527	56	for	for	IN
22283	527	57	link	link	NN
22283	527	58	in	in	IN
22283	527	59	lines	line	NNS
22283	527	60	parallel	parallel	JJ
22283	527	61	with	with	IN
22283	527	62	the	the	DT
22283	527	63	other	other	JJ
22283	527	64	.	.	.
22283	528	1	Without	without	IN
22283	528	2	some	some	DT
22283	528	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	528	4	of	of	IN
22283	528	5	pre	pre	JJ
22283	528	6	-	-	JJ
22283	528	7	established	established	JJ
22283	528	8	harmony	harmony	NN
22283	528	9	--	--	:
22283	528	10	which	which	WDT
22283	528	11	,	,	,
22283	528	12	of	of	IN
22283	528	13	course	course	NN
22283	528	14	,	,	,
22283	528	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	528	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	528	17	no	no	DT
22283	528	18	part	part	NN
22283	528	19	of	of	IN
22283	528	20	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	528	21	to	to	TO
22283	528	22	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	528	23	--	--	:
22283	528	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	528	25	would	would	MD
22283	528	26	,	,	,
22283	528	27	on	on	IN
22283	528	28	the	the	DT
22283	528	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	528	30	of	of	IN
22283	528	31	chances	chance	NNS
22283	528	32	alone	alone	RB
22283	528	33	,	,	,
22283	528	34	be	be	VB
22283	528	35	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	528	36	to	to	TO
22283	528	37	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	528	38	that	that	IN
22283	528	39	the	the	DT
22283	528	40	causal	causal	JJ
22283	528	41	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	528	42	in	in	IN
22283	528	43	the	the	DT
22283	528	44	brain	brain	NN
22283	528	45	always	always	RB
22283	528	46	happen	happen	VBP
22283	528	47	to	to	TO
22283	528	48	be	be	VB
22283	528	49	just	just	RB
22283	528	50	those	those	DT
22283	528	51	which	which	WDT
22283	528	52	,	,	,
22283	528	53	by	by	IN
22283	528	54	running	running	NN
22283	528	55	link	link	NN
22283	528	56	for	for	IN
22283	528	57	link	link	NN
22283	528	58	with	with	IN
22283	528	59	another	another	DT
22283	528	60	set	set	NN
22283	528	61	of	of	IN
22283	528	62	causal	causal	JJ
22283	528	63	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	528	64	taking	take	VBG
22283	528	65	place	place	NN
22283	528	66	in	in	IN
22283	528	67	the	the	DT
22283	528	68	mind	mind	NN
22283	528	69	,	,	,
22283	528	70	enable	enable	VB
22283	528	71	both	both	CC
22283	528	72	the	the	DT
22283	528	73	series	series	NN
22283	528	74	to	to	TO
22283	528	75	be	be	VB
22283	528	76	definite	definite	JJ
22283	528	77	and	and	CC
22283	528	78	coherent	coherent	JJ
22283	528	79	in	in	IN
22283	528	80	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	528	81	.	.	.
22283	529	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	529	2	,	,	,
22283	529	3	before	before	IN
22283	529	4	reason	reason	NN
22283	529	5	can	can	MD
22283	529	6	allow	allow	VB
22283	529	7	the	the	DT
22283	529	8	theory	theory	NN
22283	529	9	of	of	IN
22283	529	10	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	529	11	to	to	TO
22283	529	12	pass	pass	VB
22283	529	13	,	,	,
22283	529	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	529	15	must	must	MD
22283	529	16	be	be	VB
22283	529	17	told	tell	VBN
22283	529	18	how	how	WRB
22283	529	19	this	this	DT
22283	529	20	wonderful	wonderful	JJ
22283	529	21	fact	fact	NN
22283	529	22	of	of	IN
22283	529	23	parallelism	parallelism	NN
22283	529	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	529	25	to	to	TO
22283	529	26	be	be	VB
22283	529	27	explained	explain	VBN
22283	529	28	.	.	.
22283	530	1	There	there	EX
22283	530	2	must	must	MD
22283	530	3	be	be	VB
22283	530	4	_	_	NNP
22283	530	5	some	some	DT
22283	530	6	_	_	NNP
22283	530	7	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	530	8	between	between	IN
22283	530	9	the	the	DT
22283	530	10	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
22283	530	11	coherent	coherent	JJ
22283	530	12	series	series	NN
22283	530	13	_	_	NNP
22283	530	14	A	A	NNP
22283	530	15	,	,	,
22283	530	16	B	B	NNP
22283	530	17	,	,	,
22283	530	18	C	C	NNP
22283	530	19	_	_	NNP
22283	530	20	and	and	CC
22283	530	21	the	the	DT
22283	530	22	no	no	RB
22283	530	23	less	less	RBR
22283	530	24	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
22283	530	25	coherent	coherent	JJ
22283	530	26	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	530	27	_	_	NNP
22283	530	28	a	a	NNP
22283	530	29	,	,	,
22283	530	30	b	b	NN
22283	530	31	,	,	,
22283	530	32	c	c	NNP
22283	530	33	_	_	NNP
22283	530	34	,	,	,
22283	530	35	which	which	WDT
22283	530	36	may	may	MD
22283	530	37	be	be	VB
22283	530	38	taken	take	VBN
22283	530	39	as	as	IN
22283	530	40	an	an	DT
22283	530	41	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	530	42	why	why	WRB
22283	530	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	530	44	coincide	coincide	VBP
22283	530	45	each	each	DT
22283	530	46	to	to	IN
22283	530	47	each	each	DT
22283	530	48	.	.	.
22283	531	1	What	what	WP
22283	531	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	531	3	this	this	DT
22283	531	4	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	531	5	?	?	.
22283	532	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	2	do	do	VBP
22283	532	3	not	not	RB
22283	532	4	know	know	VB
22283	532	5	;	;	:
22283	532	6	but	but	CC
22283	532	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	8	have	have	VBP
22283	532	9	now	now	RB
22283	532	10	seen	see	VBN
22283	532	11	that	that	IN
22283	532	12	,	,	,
22283	532	13	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	532	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	532	16	,	,	,
22283	532	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	18	can	can	MD
22283	532	19	not	not	RB
22283	532	20	be	be	VB
22283	532	21	an	an	DT
22283	532	22	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
22283	532	23	causal	causal	JJ
22283	532	24	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	532	25	--	--	:
22283	532	26	first	first	RB
22283	532	27	,	,	,
22283	532	28	because	because	IN
22283	532	29	the	the	DT
22283	532	30	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	532	31	of	of	IN
22283	532	32	the	the	DT
22283	532	33	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	532	34	of	of	IN
22283	532	35	energy	energy	NN
22283	532	36	makes	make	VBZ
22283	532	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	38	incumbent	incumbent	JJ
22283	532	39	on	on	IN
22283	532	40	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	41	to	to	TO
22283	532	42	believe	believe	VB
22283	532	43	that	that	IN
22283	532	44	the	the	DT
22283	532	45	procession	procession	NN
22283	532	46	of	of	IN
22283	532	47	physical	physical	JJ
22283	532	48	cause	cause	NN
22283	532	49	and	and	CC
22283	532	50	effect	effect	NN
22283	532	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	532	52	complete	complete	JJ
22283	532	53	within	within	IN
22283	532	54	the	the	DT
22283	532	55	region	region	NN
22283	532	56	of	of	IN
22283	532	57	brain	brain	NN
22283	532	58	--	--	:
22283	532	59	a	a	DT
22283	532	60	closed	close	VBN
22283	532	61	circle	circle	NN
22283	532	62	,	,	,
22283	532	63	as	as	IN
22283	532	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	65	were	be	VBD
22283	532	66	,	,	,
22283	532	67	from	from	IN
22283	532	68	which	which	WDT
22283	532	69	no	no	DT
22283	532	70	energy	energy	NN
22283	532	71	can	can	MD
22283	532	72	,	,	,
22283	532	73	without	without	IN
22283	532	74	argumentative	argumentative	JJ
22283	532	75	suicide	suicide	NN
22283	532	76	,	,	,
22283	532	77	be	be	VB
22283	532	78	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	532	79	to	to	TO
22283	532	80	escape	escape	VB
22283	532	81	into	into	IN
22283	532	82	the	the	DT
22283	532	83	region	region	NN
22283	532	84	of	of	IN
22283	532	85	mind	mind	NN
22283	532	86	;	;	,
22283	532	87	and	and	CC
22283	532	88	next	next	RB
22283	532	89	,	,	,
22283	532	90	because	because	IN
22283	532	91	,	,	,
22283	532	92	even	even	RB
22283	532	93	were	be	VBD
22283	532	94	this	this	DT
22283	532	95	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	532	96	disregarded	disregard	VBD
22283	532	97	,	,	,
22283	532	98	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	99	is	be	VBZ
22283	532	100	unaccountable	unaccountable	JJ
22283	532	101	that	that	IN
22283	532	102	the	the	DT
22283	532	103	causative	causative	JJ
22283	532	104	influence	influence	NN
22283	532	105	(	(	-LRB-
22283	532	106	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	532	107	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	108	is	be	VBZ
22283	532	109	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	532	110	to	to	TO
22283	532	111	be	be	VB
22283	532	112	)	)	-RRB-
22283	532	113	,	,	,
22283	532	114	which	which	WDT
22283	532	115	passes	pass	VBZ
22283	532	116	over	over	RP
22283	532	117	from	from	IN
22283	532	118	the	the	DT
22283	532	119	region	region	NN
22283	532	120	of	of	IN
22283	532	121	physics	physics	NN
22283	532	122	into	into	IN
22283	532	123	that	that	DT
22283	532	124	of	of	IN
22283	532	125	psychics	psychic	NNS
22283	532	126	,	,	,
22283	532	127	should	should	MD
22283	532	128	be	be	VB
22283	532	129	such	such	JJ
22283	532	130	as	as	IN
22283	532	131	to	to	TO
22283	532	132	render	render	VB
22283	532	133	the	the	DT
22283	532	134	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	532	135	series	series	NN
22283	532	136	coherent	coherent	NN
22283	532	137	in	in	IN
22283	532	138	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	532	139	,	,	,
22283	532	140	when	when	WRB
22283	532	141	on	on	IN
22283	532	142	the	the	DT
22283	532	143	physical	physical	JJ
22283	532	144	side	side	NN
22283	532	145	the	the	DT
22283	532	146	series	series	NN
22283	532	147	must	must	MD
22283	532	148	be	be	VB
22283	532	149	determined	determine	VBN
22283	532	150	by	by	IN
22283	532	151	purely	purely	RB
22283	532	152	physical	physical	JJ
22283	532	153	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	532	154	,	,	,
22283	532	155	having	have	VBG
22283	532	156	no	no	DT
22283	532	157	reference	reference	NN
22283	532	158	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
22283	532	159	to	to	IN
22283	532	160	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	532	161	requirements	requirement	NNS
22283	532	162	.	.	.
22283	533	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	533	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	533	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	533	4	argumentatively	argumentatively	RB
22283	533	5	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	533	6	for	for	IN
22283	533	7	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	533	8	to	to	TO
22283	533	9	elude	elude	VB
22283	533	10	the	the	DT
22283	533	11	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	533	12	of	of	IN
22283	533	13	explaining	explain	VBG
22283	533	14	the	the	DT
22283	533	15	kind	kind	NN
22283	533	16	of	of	IN
22283	533	17	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	533	18	which	which	WDT
22283	533	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	533	20	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	533	21	to	to	TO
22283	533	22	subsist	subsist	VB
22283	533	23	between	between	IN
22283	533	24	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	533	25	and	and	CC
22283	533	26	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	533	27	;	;	,
22283	533	28	and	and	CC
22283	533	29	forasmuch	forasmuch	VBP
22283	533	30	as	as	IN
22283	533	31	the	the	DT
22283	533	32	above	above	JJ
22283	533	33	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	533	34	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	533	35	show	show	VBP
22283	533	36	this	this	DT
22283	533	37	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	533	38	can	can	MD
22283	533	39	not	not	RB
22283	533	40	be	be	VB
22283	533	41	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	533	42	as	as	IN
22283	533	43	one	one	CD
22283	533	44	of	of	IN
22283	533	45	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
22283	533	46	causality	causality	NN
22283	533	47	without	without	IN
22283	533	48	some	some	DT
22283	533	49	answer	answer	NN
22283	533	50	being	be	VBG
22283	533	51	given	give	VBN
22283	533	52	to	to	IN
22283	533	53	the	the	DT
22283	533	54	questions	question	NNS
22283	533	55	which	which	WDT
22283	533	56	reason	reason	NN
22283	533	57	has	have	VBZ
22283	533	58	to	to	TO
22283	533	59	ask	ask	VB
22283	533	60	,	,	,
22283	533	61	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	533	62	must	must	MD
22283	533	63	be	be	VB
22283	533	64	ruled	rule	VBN
22283	533	65	out	out	IN
22283	533	66	of	of	IN
22283	533	67	court	court	NN
22283	533	68	if	if	IN
22283	533	69	she	-PRON-	PRP
22283	533	70	fails	fail	VBZ
22283	533	71	to	to	TO
22283	533	72	respond	respond	VB
22283	533	73	to	to	IN
22283	533	74	the	the	DT
22283	533	75	demand	demand	NN
22283	533	76	.	.	.
22283	534	1	But	but	CC
22283	534	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	534	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	534	4	no	no	RB
22283	534	5	less	less	RBR
22283	534	6	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	534	7	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	534	8	that	that	IN
22283	534	9	she	-PRON-	PRP
22283	534	10	can	can	MD
22283	534	11	respond	respond	VB
22283	534	12	to	to	IN
22283	534	13	the	the	DT
22283	534	14	demand	demand	NN
22283	534	15	,	,	,
22283	534	16	and	and	CC
22283	534	17	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	534	18	at	at	IN
22283	534	19	the	the	DT
22283	534	20	bar	bar	NN
22283	534	21	of	of	IN
22283	534	22	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
22283	534	23	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	534	24	must	must	MD
22283	534	25	be	be	VB
22283	534	26	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
22283	534	27	,	,	,
22283	534	28	for	for	IN
22283	534	29	this	this	DT
22283	534	30	as	as	RB
22283	534	31	well	well	RB
22283	534	32	as	as	IN
22283	534	33	for	for	IN
22283	534	34	the	the	DT
22283	534	35	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	534	36	previously	previously	RB
22283	534	37	cited	cite	VBN
22283	534	38	,	,	,
22283	534	39	conspicuously	conspicuously	RB
22283	534	40	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
22283	534	41	to	to	TO
22283	534	42	account	account	VB
22283	534	43	for	for	IN
22283	534	44	the	the	DT
22283	534	45	facts	fact	NNS
22283	534	46	.	.	.
22283	535	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
22283	535	2	:	:	:
22283	535	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	535	4	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	535	5	4	4	CD
22283	535	6	:	:	:
22283	535	7	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	535	8	Flint	Flint	NNP
22283	535	9	,	,	,
22283	535	10	_	_	NNP
22283	535	11	Antitheistic	Antitheistic	NNP
22283	535	12	Theories	Theories	NNPS
22283	535	13	_	_	NNP
22283	535	14	,	,	,
22283	535	15	p.	p.	NN
22283	536	1	99	99	CD
22283	536	2	.	.	.
22283	536	3	]	]	-RRB-
22283	537	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	537	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
22283	537	3	5	5	CD
22283	537	4	:	:	:
22283	537	5	_	_	NNP
22283	537	6	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
22283	537	7	of	of	IN
22283	537	8	Religion	Religion	NNP
22283	537	9	_	_	NNP
22283	537	10	,	,	,
22283	537	11	pp	pp	NNP
22283	537	12	.	.	.
22283	538	1	95	95	CD
22283	538	2	,	,	,
22283	538	3	99	99	CD
22283	538	4	,	,	,
22283	538	5	and	and	CC
22283	538	6	101	101	CD
22283	538	7	.	.	.
22283	538	8	]	]	-RRB-
22283	539	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	539	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
22283	539	3	6	6	CD
22283	539	4	:	:	:
22283	539	5	British	British	NNP
22283	539	6	Association	Association	NNP
22283	539	7	Report	Report	NNP
22283	539	8	,	,	,
22283	539	9	1879	1879	CD
22283	539	10	,	,	,
22283	539	11	p.	p.	NN
22283	540	1	28	28	CD
22283	540	2	.	.	.
22283	540	3	]	]	-RRB-
22283	541	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	541	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
22283	541	3	7	7	CD
22283	541	4	:	:	:
22283	541	5	British	British	NNP
22283	541	6	Association	Association	NNP
22283	541	7	Report	Report	NNP
22283	541	8	,	,	,
22283	541	9	1868	1868	CD
22283	541	10	.	.	.
22283	542	1	Trans	tran	NNS
22283	542	2	.	.	.
22283	543	1	of	of	IN
22283	543	2	Sections	section	NNS
22283	543	3	,	,	,
22283	543	4	p.	p.	NN
22283	544	1	5	5	CD
22283	544	2	.	.	.
22283	544	3	]	]	-RRB-
22283	545	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
22283	545	2	III	III	NNP
22283	545	3	.	.	.
22283	546	1	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	546	2	.	.	.
22283	547	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	547	2	have	have	VBP
22283	547	3	seen	see	VBN
22283	547	4	,	,	,
22283	547	5	then	then	RB
22283	547	6	,	,	,
22283	547	7	that	that	IN
22283	547	8	both	both	CC
22283	547	9	the	the	DT
22283	547	10	alternative	alternative	JJ
22283	547	11	theories	theory	NNS
22283	547	12	of	of	IN
22283	547	13	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	547	14	and	and	CC
22283	547	15	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	547	16	are	be	VBP
22283	547	17	found	find	VBN
22283	547	18	,	,	,
22283	547	19	when	when	WRB
22283	547	20	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	547	21	examined	examine	VBN
22283	547	22	,	,	,
22283	547	23	to	to	TO
22283	547	24	be	be	VB
22283	547	25	so	so	RB
22283	547	26	beset	beset	VB
22283	547	27	with	with	IN
22283	547	28	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	547	29	of	of	IN
22283	547	30	a	a	DT
22283	547	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	547	32	and	and	CC
22283	547	33	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	547	34	kind	kind	NN
22283	547	35	,	,	,
22283	547	36	that	that	IN
22283	547	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	547	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	547	39	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	547	40	to	to	TO
22283	547	41	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	547	42	either	either	CC
22283	547	43	without	without	IN
22283	547	44	closing	close	VBG
22283	547	45	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	547	46	eyes	eye	NNS
22283	547	47	to	to	IN
22283	547	48	certain	certain	JJ
22283	547	49	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
22283	547	50	which	which	WDT
22283	547	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	547	52	severally	severally	RB
22283	547	53	and	and	CC
22283	547	54	inherently	inherently	RB
22283	547	55	present	present	JJ
22283	547	56	.	.	.
22283	548	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	548	2	may	may	MD
22283	548	3	,	,	,
22283	548	4	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	548	5	,	,	,
22283	548	6	go	go	VB
22283	548	7	even	even	RB
22283	548	8	further	far	RBR
22283	548	9	than	than	IN
22283	548	10	this	this	DT
22283	548	11	,	,	,
22283	548	12	and	and	CC
22283	548	13	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	548	14	that	that	DT
22283	548	15	to	to	TO
22283	548	16	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	548	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	548	18	the	the	DT
22283	548	19	cause	cause	NN
22283	548	20	of	of	IN
22283	548	21	motion	motion	NN
22283	548	22	or	or	CC
22283	548	23	motion	motion	NN
22283	548	24	the	the	DT
22283	548	25	cause	cause	NN
22283	548	26	of	of	IN
22283	548	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	548	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	548	29	equally	equally	RB
22283	548	30	to	to	TO
22283	548	31	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	548	32	that	that	IN
22283	548	33	which	which	WDT
22283	548	34	in	in	IN
22283	548	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	548	36	very	very	JJ
22283	548	37	nature	nature	NN
22283	548	38	as	as	IN
22283	548	39	a	a	DT
22283	548	40	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	548	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	548	42	neither	neither	CC
22283	548	43	true	true	JJ
22283	548	44	nor	nor	CC
22283	548	45	untrue	untrue	JJ
22283	548	46	,	,	,
22283	548	47	but	but	CC
22283	548	48	nonsensical	nonsensical	JJ
22283	548	49	.	.	.
22283	549	1	For	for	IN
22283	549	2	,	,	,
22283	549	3	as	as	IN
22283	549	4	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
22283	549	5	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	549	6	has	have	VBZ
22283	549	7	said	say	VBN
22283	549	8	in	in	IN
22283	549	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	549	10	essay	essay	NN
22283	549	11	on	on	IN
22283	549	12	_	_	NNP
22283	549	13	Body	Body	NNP
22283	549	14	and	and	CC
22283	549	15	Mind_,--	Mind_,--	.
22283	549	16	'	'	''
22283	549	17	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	549	18	may	may	MD
22283	549	19	be	be	VB
22283	549	20	conceived	conceive	VBN
22283	549	21	that	that	IN
22283	549	22	,	,	,
22283	549	23	at	at	IN
22283	549	24	the	the	DT
22283	549	25	same	same	JJ
22283	549	26	time	time	NN
22283	549	27	with	with	IN
22283	549	28	every	every	DT
22283	549	29	exercise	exercise	NN
22283	549	30	of	of	IN
22283	549	31	volition	volition	NN
22283	549	32	,	,	,
22283	549	33	there	there	EX
22283	549	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	549	35	a	a	DT
22283	549	36	disturbance	disturbance	NN
22283	549	37	of	of	IN
22283	549	38	the	the	DT
22283	549	39	physical	physical	JJ
22283	549	40	laws	law	NNS
22283	549	41	;	;	:
22283	549	42	but	but	CC
22283	549	43	this	this	DT
22283	549	44	disturbance	disturbance	NN
22283	549	45	,	,	,
22283	549	46	being	be	VBG
22283	549	47	perceptible	perceptible	JJ
22283	549	48	to	to	IN
22283	549	49	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	549	50	,	,	,
22283	549	51	would	would	MD
22283	549	52	be	be	VB
22283	549	53	a	a	DT
22283	549	54	physical	physical	JJ
22283	549	55	fact	fact	NN
22283	549	56	accompanying	accompany	VBG
22283	549	57	the	the	DT
22283	549	58	volition	volition	NN
22283	549	59	,	,	,
22283	549	60	and	and	CC
22283	549	61	could	could	MD
22283	549	62	not	not	RB
22283	549	63	be	be	VB
22283	549	64	volition	volition	NN
22283	549	65	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	549	66	,	,	,
22283	549	67	which	which	WDT
22283	549	68	is	be	VBZ
22283	549	69	not	not	RB
22283	549	70	perceptible	perceptible	JJ
22283	549	71	to	to	IN
22283	549	72	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	549	73	.	.	.
22283	550	1	Whether	whether	IN
22283	550	2	there	there	EX
22283	550	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	550	4	such	such	PDT
22283	550	5	a	a	DT
22283	550	6	disturbance	disturbance	NN
22283	550	7	of	of	IN
22283	550	8	the	the	DT
22283	550	9	physical	physical	JJ
22283	550	10	laws	law	NNS
22283	550	11	or	or	CC
22283	550	12	no	no	DT
22283	550	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	550	14	a	a	DT
22283	550	15	question	question	NN
22283	550	16	of	of	IN
22283	550	17	fact	fact	NN
22283	550	18	to	to	TO
22283	550	19	which	which	WDT
22283	550	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	550	21	have	have	VBP
22283	550	22	the	the	DT
22283	550	23	best	good	JJS
22283	550	24	of	of	IN
22283	550	25	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	550	26	for	for	IN
22283	550	27	giving	give	VBG
22283	550	28	a	a	DT
22283	550	29	negative	negative	JJ
22283	550	30	answer	answer	NN
22283	550	31	;	;	:
22283	550	32	but	but	CC
22283	550	33	the	the	DT
22283	550	34	assertion	assertion	NN
22283	550	35	that	that	IN
22283	550	36	another	another	DT
22283	550	37	man	man	NN
22283	550	38	's	's	POS
22283	550	39	volition	volition	NN
22283	550	40	,	,	,
22283	550	41	a	a	DT
22283	550	42	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	550	43	in	in	IN
22283	550	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	550	45	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	550	46	which	which	WDT
22283	550	47	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	550	48	can	can	MD
22283	550	49	not	not	RB
22283	550	50	perceive	perceive	VB
22283	550	51	,	,	,
22283	550	52	is	be	VBZ
22283	550	53	part	part	NN
22283	550	54	of	of	IN
22283	550	55	the	the	DT
22283	550	56	train	train	NN
22283	550	57	of	of	IN
22283	550	58	physical	physical	JJ
22283	550	59	facts	fact	NNS
22283	550	60	which	which	WDT
22283	550	61	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	550	62	may	may	MD
22283	550	63	perceive,--this	perceive,--this	NNP
22283	550	64	is	be	VBZ
22283	550	65	neither	neither	CC
22283	550	66	true	true	JJ
22283	550	67	nor	nor	CC
22283	550	68	untrue	untrue	JJ
22283	550	69	,	,	,
22283	550	70	but	but	CC
22283	550	71	nonsense	nonsense	NN
22283	550	72	;	;	:
22283	550	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	550	74	is	be	VBZ
22283	550	75	a	a	DT
22283	550	76	combination	combination	NN
22283	550	77	of	of	IN
22283	550	78	words	word	NNS
22283	550	79	whose	whose	WP$
22283	550	80	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	550	81	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	550	82	will	will	MD
22283	550	83	not	not	RB
22283	550	84	go	go	VB
22283	550	85	together[8	together[8	.
22283	550	86	]	]	-RRB-
22283	550	87	.	.	.
22283	550	88	'	'	''
22283	551	1	And	and	CC
22283	551	2	seeing	see	VBG
22283	551	3	that	that	IN
22283	551	4	the	the	DT
22283	551	5	correlatives	correlative	NNS
22283	551	6	are	be	VBP
22283	551	7	in	in	IN
22283	551	8	each	each	DT
22283	551	9	case	case	NN
22283	551	10	the	the	DT
22283	551	11	same	same	JJ
22283	551	12	,	,	,
22283	551	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	551	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	551	15	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	551	16	'	'	``
22283	551	17	nonsense	nonsense	NN
22283	551	18	'	'	''
22283	551	19	to	to	TO
22283	551	20	assert	assert	VB
22283	551	21	the	the	DT
22283	551	22	converse	converse	NN
22283	551	23	proposition	proposition	NN
22283	551	24	:	:	:
22283	551	25	or	or	CC
22283	551	26	,	,	,
22283	551	27	in	in	IN
22283	551	28	other	other	JJ
22283	551	29	words	word	NNS
22283	551	30	,	,	,
22283	551	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	551	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	551	33	equally	equally	RB
22283	551	34	nonsense	nonsense	JJ
22283	551	35	to	to	TO
22283	551	36	speak	speak	VB
22283	551	37	of	of	IN
22283	551	38	mental	mental	JJ
22283	551	39	action	action	NN
22283	551	40	causing	cause	VBG
22283	551	41	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	551	42	action	action	NN
22283	551	43	,	,	,
22283	551	44	or	or	CC
22283	551	45	of	of	IN
22283	551	46	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	551	47	action	action	NN
22283	551	48	causing	cause	VBG
22283	551	49	mental	mental	JJ
22283	551	50	action	action	NN
22283	551	51	--	--	:
22283	551	52	nonsense	nonsense	NN
22283	551	53	of	of	IN
22283	551	54	the	the	DT
22283	551	55	same	same	JJ
22283	551	56	kind	kind	NN
22283	551	57	as	as	IN
22283	551	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	551	59	would	would	MD
22283	551	60	be	be	VB
22283	551	61	to	to	TO
22283	551	62	speak	speak	VB
22283	551	63	of	of	IN
22283	551	64	the	the	DT
22283	551	65	_	_	NNP
22283	551	66	Pickwick	Pickwick	NNP
22283	551	67	Papers	Papers	NNPS
22283	551	68	_	_	NNP
22283	551	69	causing	cause	VBG
22283	551	70	a	a	DT
22283	551	71	storm	storm	NN
22283	551	72	at	at	IN
22283	551	73	sea	sea	NN
22283	551	74	,	,	,
22283	551	75	or	or	CC
22283	551	76	the	the	DT
22283	551	77	eruption	eruption	NN
22283	551	78	of	of	IN
22283	551	79	a	a	DT
22283	551	80	volcano	volcano	NN
22283	551	81	causing	cause	VBG
22283	551	82	the	the	DT
22283	551	83	forty	forty	CD
22283	551	84	-	-	HYPH
22283	551	85	seventh	seventh	JJ
22283	551	86	proposition	proposition	NN
22283	551	87	in	in	IN
22283	551	88	the	the	DT
22283	551	89	first	first	JJ
22283	551	90	book	book	NN
22283	551	91	of	of	IN
22283	551	92	Euclid	Euclid	NNP
22283	551	93	.	.	.
22283	552	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	552	2	see	see	VBP
22283	552	3	,	,	,
22283	552	4	then	then	RB
22283	552	5	,	,	,
22283	552	6	that	that	IN
22283	552	7	two	two	CD
22283	552	8	of	of	IN
22283	552	9	the	the	DT
22283	552	10	three	three	CD
22283	552	11	possible	possible	JJ
22283	552	12	theories	theory	NNS
22283	552	13	of	of	IN
22283	552	14	things	thing	NNS
22283	552	15	contain	contain	VBP
22283	552	16	the	the	DT
22283	552	17	elements	element	NNS
22283	552	18	of	of	IN
22283	552	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	552	20	own	own	JJ
22283	552	21	destruction	destruction	NN
22283	552	22	:	:	:
22283	552	23	when	when	WRB
22283	552	24	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	552	25	analyzed	analyze	VBN
22283	552	26	,	,	,
22283	552	27	both	both	PDT
22283	552	28	these	these	DT
22283	552	29	theories	theory	NNS
22283	552	30	are	be	VBP
22283	552	31	found	find	VBN
22283	552	32	to	to	TO
22283	552	33	present	present	VB
22283	552	34	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	552	35	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
22283	552	36	.	.	.
22283	553	1	On	on	IN
22283	553	2	this	this	DT
22283	553	3	account	account	NN
22283	553	4	the	the	DT
22283	553	5	third	third	JJ
22283	553	6	,	,	,
22283	553	7	or	or	CC
22283	553	8	only	only	RB
22283	553	9	alternative	alternative	JJ
22283	553	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	553	11	,	,	,
22283	553	12	comes	come	VBZ
22283	553	13	to	to	IN
22283	553	14	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	553	15	with	with	IN
22283	553	16	a	a	DT
22283	553	17	large	large	JJ
22283	553	18	antecedent	antecedent	NN
22283	553	19	presumption	presumption	NN
22283	553	20	in	in	IN
22283	553	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	553	22	favour	favour	NN
22283	553	23	.	.	.
22283	554	1	For	for	IN
22283	554	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	554	3	comes	come	VBZ
22283	554	4	to	to	IN
22283	554	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	554	6	,	,	,
22283	554	7	as	as	IN
22283	554	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	554	9	were	be	VBD
22283	554	10	,	,	,
22283	554	11	on	on	IN
22283	554	12	a	a	DT
22283	554	13	clear	clear	JJ
22283	554	14	field	field	NN
22283	554	15	,	,	,
22283	554	16	or	or	CC
22283	554	17	with	with	IN
22283	554	18	the	the	DT
22283	554	19	negative	negative	JJ
22283	554	20	advantage	advantage	NN
22283	554	21	of	of	IN
22283	554	22	having	have	VBG
22283	554	23	no	no	DT
22283	554	24	logical	logical	JJ
22283	554	25	rivals	rival	NNS
22283	554	26	to	to	TO
22283	554	27	contend	contend	VB
22283	554	28	with	with	IN
22283	554	29	.	.	.
22283	555	1	The	the	DT
22283	555	2	other	other	JJ
22283	555	3	two	two	CD
22283	555	4	suggestions	suggestion	NNS
22283	555	5	having	have	VBG
22283	555	6	been	be	VBN
22283	555	7	weighed	weigh	VBN
22283	555	8	in	in	IN
22283	555	9	the	the	DT
22283	555	10	balance	balance	NN
22283	555	11	and	and	CC
22283	555	12	found	find	VBD
22283	555	13	wanting	wanting	NN
22283	555	14	,	,	,
22283	555	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	555	16	are	be	VBP
22283	555	17	free	free	JJ
22283	555	18	to	to	TO
22283	555	19	look	look	VB
22283	555	20	to	to	IN
22283	555	21	the	the	DT
22283	555	22	new	new	JJ
22283	555	23	-	-	HYPH
22283	555	24	comer	comer	NN
22283	555	25	as	as	RB
22283	555	26	quite	quite	RB
22283	555	27	unopposed	unopposed	JJ
22283	555	28	.	.	.
22283	556	1	This	this	DT
22283	556	2	new	new	JJ
22283	556	3	-	-	HYPH
22283	556	4	comer	comer	NN
22283	556	5	must	must	MD
22283	556	6	,	,	,
22283	556	7	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	556	8	,	,	,
22283	556	9	be	be	VB
22283	556	10	interrogated	interrogate	VBN
22283	556	11	as	as	RB
22283	556	12	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	556	13	as	as	IN
22283	556	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	556	15	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
22283	556	16	,	,	,
22283	556	17	and	and	CC
22283	556	18	,	,	,
22283	556	19	like	like	IN
22283	556	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	556	21	,	,	,
22283	556	22	must	must	MD
22283	556	23	be	be	VB
22283	556	24	judged	judge	VBN
22283	556	25	upon	upon	IN
22283	556	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	556	27	own	own	JJ
22283	556	28	merits	merit	NNS
22283	556	29	.	.	.
22283	557	1	But	but	CC
22283	557	2	as	as	IN
22283	557	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	557	4	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
22283	557	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	557	6	last	last	JJ
22283	557	7	possible	possible	JJ
22283	557	8	hope	hope	NN
22283	557	9	of	of	IN
22283	557	10	solving	solve	VBG
22283	557	11	the	the	DT
22283	557	12	question	question	NN
22283	557	13	which	which	WDT
22283	557	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	557	15	professes	profess	VBZ
22283	557	16	himself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	557	17	able	able	JJ
22283	557	18	to	to	TO
22283	557	19	solve	solve	VB
22283	557	20	,	,	,
22283	557	21	the	the	DT
22283	557	22	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	557	23	failure	failure	NN
22283	557	24	of	of	IN
22283	557	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	557	26	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
22283	557	27	entitles	entitle	VBZ
22283	557	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	557	29	to	to	IN
22283	557	30	a	a	DT
22283	557	31	patient	patient	JJ
22283	557	32	hearing	hearing	NN
22283	557	33	.	.	.
22283	558	1	By	by	IN
22283	558	2	the	the	DT
22283	558	3	method	method	NN
22283	558	4	of	of	IN
22283	558	5	exclusion	exclusion	NN
22283	558	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	558	7	voice	voice	NN
22283	558	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	558	9	now	now	RB
22283	558	10	the	the	DT
22283	558	11	only	only	JJ
22283	558	12	voice	voice	NN
22283	558	13	that	that	WDT
22283	558	14	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	558	15	to	to	TO
22283	558	16	be	be	VB
22283	558	17	heard	hear	VBN
22283	558	18	,	,	,
22283	558	19	and	and	CC
22283	558	20	unless	unless	IN
22283	558	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	558	22	can	can	MD
22283	558	23	speak	speak	VB
22283	558	24	to	to	IN
22283	558	25	better	well	JJR
22283	558	26	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	558	27	than	than	IN
22283	558	28	the	the	DT
22283	558	29	others	other	NNS
22283	558	30	,	,	,
22283	558	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	558	32	shall	shall	MD
22283	558	33	have	have	VB
22283	558	34	no	no	DT
22283	558	35	alternative	alternative	NN
22283	558	36	but	but	IN
22283	558	37	to	to	TO
22283	558	38	abandon	abandon	VB
22283	558	39	the	the	DT
22283	558	40	facts	fact	NNS
22283	558	41	as	as	IN
22283	558	42	inexplicable	inexplicable	JJ
22283	558	43	,	,	,
22283	558	44	or	or	CC
22283	558	45	to	to	TO
22283	558	46	confess	confess	VB
22283	558	47	that	that	IN
22283	558	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	558	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	558	50	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	558	51	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	558	52	for	for	IN
22283	558	53	the	the	DT
22283	558	54	human	human	JJ
22283	558	55	mind	mind	NN
22283	558	56	ever	ever	RB
22283	558	57	to	to	TO
22283	558	58	arrive	arrive	VB
22283	558	59	at	at	IN
22283	558	60	any	any	DT
22283	558	61	theory	theory	NN
22283	558	62	of	of	IN
22283	558	63	things	thing	NNS
22283	558	64	.	.	.
22283	559	1	Before	before	IN
22283	559	2	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	559	3	to	to	IN
22283	559	4	state	state	NN
22283	559	5	or	or	CC
22283	559	6	to	to	TO
22283	559	7	examine	examine	VB
22283	559	8	this	this	DT
22283	559	9	third	third	JJ
22283	559	10	and	and	CC
22283	559	11	last	last	JJ
22283	559	12	of	of	IN
22283	559	13	the	the	DT
22283	559	14	suggested	suggest	VBN
22283	559	15	theories	theory	NNS
22283	559	16	,	,	,
22283	559	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	559	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	559	19	desirable	desirable	JJ
22283	559	20	--	--	:
22283	559	21	in	in	IN
22283	559	22	order	order	NN
22283	559	23	still	still	RB
22283	559	24	further	further	RB
22283	559	25	to	to	TO
22283	559	26	define	define	VB
22283	559	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	559	28	_	_	NNP
22283	559	29	status	status	NN
22283	559	30	a	a	DT
22283	559	31	priori_--that	priori_--that	NN
22283	559	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	559	33	should	should	MD
22283	559	34	exhibit	exhibit	VB
22283	559	35	the	the	DT
22283	559	36	reason	reason	NN
22283	559	37	why	why	WRB
22283	559	38	the	the	DT
22283	559	39	two	two	CD
22283	559	40	other	other	JJ
22283	559	41	suggestions	suggestion	NNS
22283	559	42	have	have	VBP
22283	559	43	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	559	44	failed	fail	VBN
22283	559	45	.	.	.
22283	560	1	For	for	IN
22283	560	2	to	to	IN
22283	560	3	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	560	4	mind	mind	NN
22283	560	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	560	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	560	7	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	560	8	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	560	9	that	that	IN
22283	560	10	this	this	DT
22283	560	11	reason	reason	NN
22283	560	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	560	13	to	to	TO
22283	560	14	be	be	VB
22283	560	15	found	find	VBN
22283	560	16	,	,	,
22283	560	17	and	and	CC
22283	560	18	found	find	VBD
22283	560	19	only	only	RB
22283	560	20	,	,	,
22283	560	21	in	in	IN
22283	560	22	the	the	DT
22283	560	23	fact	fact	NN
22283	560	24	that	that	IN
22283	560	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	560	26	are	be	VBP
22283	560	27	both	both	RB
22283	560	28	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	560	29	.	.	.
22283	561	1	The	the	DT
22283	561	2	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	561	3	,	,	,
22283	561	4	the	the	DT
22283	561	5	fatal	fatal	JJ
22283	561	6	,	,	,
22283	561	7	and	and	CC
22283	561	8	the	the	DT
22283	561	9	closely	closely	RB
22283	561	10	similar	similar	JJ
22283	561	11	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	561	12	which	which	WDT
22283	561	13	attach	attach	VBP
22283	561	14	to	to	IN
22283	561	15	both	both	DT
22283	561	16	the	the	DT
22283	561	17	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	561	18	theories	theory	NNS
22283	561	19	,	,	,
22283	561	20	attach	attach	VBP
22283	561	21	to	to	IN
22283	561	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	561	23	merely	merely	RB
22283	561	24	because	because	IN
22283	561	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	561	26	_	_	NNP
22283	561	27	are	be	VBP
22283	561	28	_	_	NNP
22283	561	29	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	561	30	.	.	.
22283	562	1	The	the	DT
22283	562	2	'	'	``
22283	562	3	nonsense	nonsense	NN
22283	562	4	'	'	''
22283	562	5	of	of	IN
22283	562	6	each	each	DT
22283	562	7	of	of	IN
22283	562	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	562	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	562	10	really	really	RB
22283	562	11	identical	identical	JJ
22283	562	12	,	,	,
22283	562	13	and	and	CC
22283	562	14	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	562	15	only	only	RB
22283	562	16	because	because	IN
22283	562	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	562	18	both	both	DT
22283	562	19	make	make	VBP
22283	562	20	the	the	DT
22283	562	21	same	same	JJ
22283	562	22	irrational	irrational	JJ
22283	562	23	attempt	attempt	NN
22283	562	24	to	to	TO
22283	562	25	find	find	VB
22283	562	26	more	more	JJR
22283	562	27	in	in	IN
22283	562	28	the	the	DT
22283	562	29	effect	effect	NN
22283	562	30	than	than	IN
22283	562	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	562	32	have	have	VBP
22283	562	33	put	put	VBN
22283	562	34	into	into	IN
22283	562	35	the	the	DT
22283	562	36	cause	cause	NN
22283	562	37	.	.	.
22283	563	1	In	in	IN
22283	563	2	other	other	JJ
22283	563	3	words	word	NNS
22283	563	4	,	,	,
22283	563	5	both	both	CC
22283	563	6	the	the	DT
22283	563	7	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	563	8	theories	theory	NNS
22283	563	9	suppose	suppose	VBP
22283	563	10	that	that	IN
22283	563	11	the	the	DT
22283	563	12	physical	physical	JJ
22283	563	13	chains	chain	NNS
22283	563	14	of	of	IN
22283	563	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	563	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	563	17	complete	complete	JJ
22283	563	18	within	within	IN
22283	563	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	563	20	,	,	,
22283	563	21	and	and	CC
22283	563	22	that	that	IN
22283	563	23	the	the	DT
22283	563	24	mental	mental	JJ
22283	563	25	chain	chain	NN
22283	563	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	563	27	also	also	RB
22283	563	28	complete	complete	JJ
22283	563	29	within	within	IN
22283	563	30	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	563	31	:	:	:
22283	563	32	yet	yet	CC
22283	563	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	563	34	both	both	DT
22283	563	35	proceed	proceed	VBP
22283	563	36	to	to	IN
22283	563	37	the	the	DT
22283	563	38	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	563	39	that	that	IN
22283	563	40	one	one	CD
22283	563	41	of	of	IN
22283	563	42	these	these	DT
22283	563	43	chains	chain	NNS
22283	563	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	563	45	able	able	JJ
22283	563	46	to	to	TO
22283	563	47	allow	allow	VB
22283	563	48	some	some	DT
22283	563	49	of	of	IN
22283	563	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	563	51	causal	causal	JJ
22283	563	52	influence	influence	NN
22283	563	53	to	to	TO
22283	563	54	escape	escape	VB
22283	563	55	,	,	,
22283	563	56	as	as	IN
22283	563	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	563	58	were	be	VBD
22283	563	59	,	,	,
22283	563	60	in	in	IN
22283	563	61	order	order	NN
22283	563	62	to	to	TO
22283	563	63	constitute	constitute	VB
22283	563	64	the	the	DT
22283	563	65	other	other	JJ
22283	563	66	chain	chain	NN
22283	563	67	.	.	.
22283	564	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	564	2	makes	make	VBZ
22283	564	3	no	no	DT
22283	564	4	difference	difference	NN
22283	564	5	,	,	,
22283	564	6	in	in	IN
22283	564	7	point	point	NN
22283	564	8	of	of	IN
22283	564	9	logic	logic	NN
22283	564	10	,	,	,
22283	564	11	whether	whether	IN
22283	564	12	such	such	PDT
22283	564	13	an	an	DT
22283	564	14	escape	escape	NN
22283	564	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	564	16	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	564	17	to	to	TO
22283	564	18	take	take	VB
22283	564	19	place	place	NN
22283	564	20	from	from	IN
22283	564	21	the	the	DT
22283	564	22	physical	physical	JJ
22283	564	23	chain	chain	NN
22283	564	24	(	(	-LRB-
22283	564	25	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	564	26	)	)	-RRB-
22283	564	27	or	or	CC
22283	564	28	from	from	IN
22283	564	29	the	the	DT
22283	564	30	mental	mental	JJ
22283	564	31	chain	chain	NN
22283	564	32	(	(	-LRB-
22283	564	33	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	564	34	)	)	-RRB-
22283	564	35	:	:	:
22283	564	36	in	in	IN
22283	564	37	either	either	DT
22283	564	38	case	case	NN
22283	564	39	the	the	DT
22283	564	40	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	564	41	principle	principle	NN
22283	564	42	of	of	IN
22283	564	43	causality	causality	NN
22283	564	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	564	45	alike	alike	RB
22283	564	46	impugned	impugn	VBN
22283	564	47	--	--	:
22283	564	48	the	the	DT
22283	564	49	principle	principle	NN
22283	564	50	,	,	,
22283	564	51	that	that	RB
22283	564	52	is	is	RB
22283	564	53	,	,	,
22283	564	54	of	of	IN
22283	564	55	there	there	EX
22283	564	56	being	be	VBG
22283	564	57	an	an	DT
22283	564	58	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	564	59	between	between	IN
22283	564	60	cause	cause	NN
22283	564	61	and	and	CC
22283	564	62	effect	effect	NN
22283	564	63	,	,	,
22283	564	64	such	such	JJ
22283	564	65	that	that	IN
22283	564	66	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	564	67	can	can	MD
22283	564	68	not	not	RB
22283	564	69	get	get	VB
22283	564	70	more	more	JJR
22283	564	71	out	out	IN
22283	564	72	of	of	IN
22283	564	73	your	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	564	74	effect	effect	NN
22283	564	75	than	than	IN
22283	564	76	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	564	77	have	have	VBP
22283	564	78	put	put	VBN
22283	564	79	into	into	IN
22283	564	80	your	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	564	81	cause	cause	NN
22283	564	82	.	.	.
22283	565	1	Both	both	DT
22283	565	2	these	these	DT
22283	565	3	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	565	4	theories	theory	NNS
22283	565	5	,	,	,
22283	565	6	although	although	IN
22283	565	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	565	8	take	take	VBP
22283	565	9	opposite	opposite	JJ
22283	565	10	views	view	NNS
22283	565	11	as	as	IN
22283	565	12	to	to	IN
22283	565	13	which	which	WDT
22283	565	14	of	of	IN
22283	565	15	the	the	DT
22283	565	16	two	two	CD
22283	565	17	chains	chain	NNS
22283	565	18	of	of	IN
22283	565	19	causation	causation	NN
22283	565	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	565	21	the	the	DT
22283	565	22	cause	cause	NN
22283	565	23	of	of	IN
22283	565	24	the	the	DT
22283	565	25	other	other	JJ
22283	565	26	,	,	,
22283	565	27	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	565	28	agree	agree	VBP
22283	565	29	in	in	IN
22283	565	30	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	565	31	that	that	IN
22283	565	32	there	there	EX
22283	565	33	_	_	NNP
22283	565	34	are	be	VBP
22283	565	35	_	_	NNP
22283	565	36	two	two	CD
22283	565	37	chains	chain	NNS
22283	565	38	of	of	IN
22283	565	39	causation	causation	NN
22283	565	40	,	,	,
22283	565	41	and	and	CC
22283	565	42	that	that	IN
22283	565	43	one	one	CD
22283	565	44	of	of	IN
22283	565	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	565	46	_	_	NNP
22283	565	47	does	do	VBZ
22283	565	48	_	_	NNP
22283	565	49	act	act	VB
22283	565	50	causally	causally	RB
22283	565	51	upon	upon	IN
22283	565	52	the	the	DT
22283	565	53	other	other	JJ
22283	565	54	:	:	:
22283	565	55	and	and	CC
22283	565	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	565	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	565	58	in	in	IN
22283	565	59	this	this	DT
22283	565	60	matter	matter	NN
22283	565	61	of	of	IN
22283	565	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	565	63	common	common	JJ
22283	565	64	consent	consent	NN
22283	565	65	that	that	WDT
22283	565	66	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	565	67	both	both	DT
22283	565	68	commit	commit	VBP
22283	565	69	suicide	suicide	NN
22283	565	70	.	.	.
22283	566	1	Every	every	DT
22283	566	2	process	process	NN
22283	566	3	in	in	IN
22283	566	4	the	the	DT
22283	566	5	physical	physical	JJ
22283	566	6	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	566	7	must	must	MD
22283	566	8	be	be	VB
22283	566	9	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	566	10	to	to	TO
22283	566	11	have	have	VB
22283	566	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	566	13	equations	equation	NNS
22283	566	14	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
22283	566	15	within	within	IN
22283	566	16	that	that	DT
22283	566	17	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	566	18	:	:	:
22283	566	19	else	else	RB
22283	566	20	the	the	DT
22283	566	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	566	22	of	of	IN
22283	566	23	the	the	DT
22283	566	24	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	566	25	of	of	IN
22283	566	26	energy	energy	NN
22283	566	27	would	would	MD
22283	566	28	be	be	VB
22283	566	29	contravened	contravene	VBN
22283	566	30	,	,	,
22283	566	31	and	and	CC
22283	566	32	thus	thus	RB
22283	566	33	the	the	DT
22283	566	34	causation	causation	NN
22283	566	35	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
22283	566	36	could	could	MD
22283	566	37	no	no	RB
22283	566	38	longer	longer	RB
22283	566	39	be	be	VB
22283	566	40	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
22283	566	41	as	as	IN
22283	566	42	physical	physical	JJ
22283	566	43	.	.	.
22283	567	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
22283	567	2	,	,	,
22283	567	3	every	every	DT
22283	567	4	process	process	NN
22283	567	5	in	in	IN
22283	567	6	the	the	DT
22283	567	7	mental	mental	JJ
22283	567	8	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	567	9	must	must	MD
22283	567	10	be	be	VB
22283	567	11	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	567	12	to	to	TO
22283	567	13	have	have	VB
22283	567	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	567	15	equations	equation	NNS
22283	567	16	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
22283	567	17	within	within	IN
22283	567	18	that	that	DT
22283	567	19	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	567	20	:	:	:
22283	567	21	else	else	RB
22283	567	22	the	the	DT
22283	567	23	causation	causation	NN
22283	567	24	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
22283	567	25	could	could	MD
22283	567	26	no	no	RB
22283	567	27	longer	longer	RB
22283	567	28	be	be	VB
22283	567	29	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
22283	567	30	as	as	IN
22283	567	31	mental	mental	JJ
22283	567	32	:	:	:
22283	567	33	some	some	DT
22283	567	34	of	of	IN
22283	567	35	the	the	DT
22283	567	36	equations	equation	NNS
22283	567	37	must	must	MD
22283	567	38	be	be	VB
22283	567	39	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	567	40	not	not	RB
22283	567	41	to	to	TO
22283	567	42	have	have	VB
22283	567	43	been	be	VBN
22283	567	44	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
22283	567	45	within	within	IN
22283	567	46	the	the	DT
22283	567	47	mental	mental	JJ
22283	567	48	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	567	49	,	,	,
22283	567	50	but	but	CC
22283	567	51	to	to	TO
22283	567	52	have	have	VB
22283	567	53	been	be	VBN
22283	567	54	carried	carry	VBN
22283	567	55	over	over	RP
22283	567	56	into	into	IN
22283	567	57	the	the	DT
22283	567	58	physical	physical	JJ
22283	567	59	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	567	60	--	--	:
22283	567	61	thus	thus	RB
22283	567	62	to	to	TO
22283	567	63	have	have	VB
22283	567	64	either	either	CC
22283	567	65	created	create	VBN
22283	567	66	or	or	CC
22283	567	67	destroyed	destroy	VBN
22283	567	68	certain	certain	JJ
22283	567	69	quantities	quantity	NNS
22283	567	70	of	of	IN
22283	567	71	energy	energy	NN
22283	567	72	within	within	IN
22283	567	73	that	that	DT
22283	567	74	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	567	75	,	,	,
22283	567	76	and	and	CC
22283	567	77	thus	thus	RB
22283	567	78	,	,	,
22283	567	79	also	also	RB
22283	567	80	,	,	,
22283	567	81	to	to	TO
22283	567	82	have	have	VB
22283	567	83	introduced	introduce	VBN
22283	567	84	elements	element	NNS
22283	567	85	of	of	IN
22283	567	86	endless	endless	JJ
22283	567	87	confusion	confusion	NN
22283	567	88	into	into	IN
22283	567	89	the	the	DT
22283	567	90	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	567	91	orderly	orderly	JJ
22283	567	92	system	system	NN
22283	567	93	of	of	IN
22283	567	94	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	567	95	.	.	.
22283	568	1	From	from	IN
22283	568	2	this	this	DT
22283	568	3	vice	vice	NN
22283	568	4	of	of	IN
22283	568	5	radical	radical	JJ
22283	568	6	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	568	7	,	,	,
22283	568	8	to	to	TO
22283	568	9	which	which	WDT
22283	568	10	both	both	CC
22283	568	11	the	the	DT
22283	568	12	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	568	13	theories	theory	NNS
22283	568	14	are	be	VBP
22283	568	15	committed	commit	VBN
22283	568	16	,	,	,
22283	568	17	the	the	DT
22283	568	18	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	568	19	theory	theory	NN
22283	568	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	568	21	free	free	JJ
22283	568	22	.	.	.
22283	569	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
22283	569	2	,	,	,
22283	569	3	as	as	IN
22283	569	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	569	5	shall	shall	MD
22283	569	6	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	569	7	find	find	VB
22283	569	8	,	,	,
22283	569	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	569	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	569	11	free	free	JJ
22283	569	12	to	to	TO
22283	569	13	combine	combine	VB
22283	569	14	the	the	DT
22283	569	15	elements	element	NNS
22283	569	16	of	of	IN
22283	569	17	truth	truth	NN
22283	569	18	which	which	WDT
22283	569	19	severally	severally	RB
22283	569	20	belong	belong	VBP
22283	569	21	to	to	IN
22283	569	22	both	both	DT
22283	569	23	the	the	DT
22283	569	24	other	other	JJ
22283	569	25	theories	theory	NNS
22283	569	26	.	.	.
22283	570	1	These	these	DT
22283	570	2	other	other	JJ
22283	570	3	theories	theory	NNS
22283	570	4	are	be	VBP
22283	570	5	each	each	DT
22283	570	6	concerned	concerned	JJ
22283	570	7	with	with	IN
22283	570	8	what	what	WP
22283	570	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	570	10	see	see	VBP
22283	570	11	upon	upon	IN
22283	570	12	different	different	JJ
22283	570	13	sides	side	NNS
22283	570	14	of	of	IN
22283	570	15	the	the	DT
22283	570	16	same	same	JJ
22283	570	17	shield	shield	NN
22283	570	18	.	.	.
22283	571	1	The	the	DT
22283	571	2	facts	fact	NNS
22283	571	3	which	which	WDT
22283	571	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	571	5	severally	severally	RB
22283	571	6	receive	receive	VBP
22283	571	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	571	8	severally	severally	RB
22283	571	9	report	report	VBP
22283	571	10	,	,	,
22283	571	11	and	and	CC
22283	571	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	571	13	reports	report	NNS
22283	571	14	appear	appear	VBP
22283	571	15	to	to	TO
22283	571	16	contradict	contradict	VB
22283	571	17	each	each	DT
22283	571	18	other	other	JJ
22283	571	19	.	.	.
22283	572	1	But	but	CC
22283	572	2	truth	truth	NN
22283	572	3	can	can	MD
22283	572	4	never	never	RB
22283	572	5	be	be	VB
22283	572	6	really	really	RB
22283	572	7	in	in	IN
22283	572	8	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	572	9	with	with	IN
22283	572	10	other	other	JJ
22283	572	11	truth	truth	NN
22283	572	12	;	;	,
22283	572	13	and	and	CC
22283	572	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	572	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	572	16	reserved	reserve	VBN
22283	572	17	for	for	IN
22283	572	18	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	572	19	,	,	,
22283	572	20	by	by	IN
22283	572	21	taking	take	VBG
22283	572	22	a	a	DT
22283	572	23	simultaneous	simultaneous	JJ
22283	572	24	view	view	NN
22283	572	25	of	of	IN
22283	572	26	both	both	DT
22283	572	27	sides	side	NNS
22283	572	28	,	,	,
22283	572	29	to	to	TO
22283	572	30	reconcile	reconcile	VB
22283	572	31	the	the	DT
22283	572	32	previously	previously	RB
22283	572	33	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	572	34	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
22283	572	35	.	.	.
22283	573	1	For	for	IN
22283	573	2	these	these	DT
22283	573	3	and	and	CC
22283	573	4	other	other	JJ
22283	573	5	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	573	6	,	,	,
22283	573	7	which	which	WDT
22283	573	8	will	will	MD
22283	573	9	unfold	unfold	VB
22283	573	10	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	573	11	as	as	IN
22283	573	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	573	13	proceed	proceed	VBP
22283	573	14	,	,	,
22283	573	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	573	16	fully	fully	RB
22283	573	17	agree	agree	VBP
22283	573	18	with	with	IN
22283	573	19	the	the	DT
22283	573	20	late	late	JJ
22283	573	21	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	573	22	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	573	23	where	where	WRB
22283	573	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	573	25	says	say	VBZ
22283	573	26	of	of	IN
22283	573	27	this	this	DT
22283	573	28	theory--'It	theory--'it	NN
22283	573	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	573	30	not	not	RB
22283	573	31	merely	merely	RB
22283	573	32	a	a	DT
22283	573	33	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	573	34	,	,	,
22283	573	35	but	but	CC
22283	573	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	573	37	a	a	DT
22283	573	38	result	result	NN
22283	573	39	to	to	IN
22283	573	40	which	which	WDT
22283	573	41	all	all	PDT
22283	573	42	the	the	DT
22283	573	43	greatest	great	JJS
22283	573	44	minds	mind	NNS
22283	573	45	that	that	WDT
22283	573	46	have	have	VBP
22283	573	47	studied	study	VBN
22283	573	48	this	this	DT
22283	573	49	question	question	NN
22283	573	50	(	(	-LRB-
22283	573	51	the	the	DT
22283	573	52	relation	relation	NN
22283	573	53	between	between	IN
22283	573	54	body	body	NN
22283	573	55	and	and	CC
22283	573	56	mind	mind	NN
22283	573	57	)	)	-RRB-
22283	573	58	in	in	IN
22283	573	59	the	the	DT
22283	573	60	right	right	JJ
22283	573	61	way	way	NN
22283	573	62	have	have	VBP
22283	573	63	gradually	gradually	RB
22283	573	64	been	be	VBN
22283	573	65	approximating	approximate	VBG
22283	573	66	for	for	IN
22283	573	67	a	a	DT
22283	573	68	long	long	JJ
22283	573	69	time	time	NN
22283	573	70	.	.	.
22283	573	71	'	'	''
22283	574	1	This	this	DT
22283	574	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	574	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	574	4	,	,	,
22283	574	5	as	as	IN
22283	574	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	574	7	have	have	VBP
22283	574	8	already	already	RB
22283	574	9	seen	see	VBN
22283	574	10	,	,	,
22283	574	11	that	that	IN
22283	574	12	mental	mental	JJ
22283	574	13	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	574	14	and	and	CC
22283	574	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	574	16	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	574	17	,	,	,
22283	574	18	although	although	IN
22283	574	19	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	574	20	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	574	21	,	,	,
22283	574	22	are	be	VBP
22283	574	23	really	really	RB
22283	574	24	identical	identical	JJ
22283	574	25	.	.	.
22283	575	1	If	if	IN
22283	575	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	575	3	thus	thus	RB
22283	575	4	unite	unite	VBP
22283	575	5	in	in	IN
22283	575	6	a	a	DT
22283	575	7	higher	high	JJR
22283	575	8	synthesis	synthesis	NN
22283	575	9	the	the	DT
22283	575	10	elements	element	NNS
22283	575	11	both	both	DT
22283	575	12	of	of	IN
22283	575	13	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	575	14	and	and	CC
22283	575	15	of	of	IN
22283	575	16	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	575	17	,	,	,
22283	575	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	575	19	obtain	obtain	VBP
22283	575	20	a	a	DT
22283	575	21	product	product	NN
22283	575	22	which	which	WDT
22283	575	23	satisfies	satisfy	VBZ
22283	575	24	every	every	DT
22283	575	25	fact	fact	NN
22283	575	26	of	of	IN
22283	575	27	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	575	28	on	on	IN
22283	575	29	the	the	DT
22283	575	30	one	one	CD
22283	575	31	hand	hand	NN
22283	575	32	,	,	,
22283	575	33	and	and	CC
22283	575	34	of	of	IN
22283	575	35	observation	observation	NN
22283	575	36	on	on	IN
22283	575	37	the	the	DT
22283	575	38	other	other	JJ
22283	575	39	.	.	.
22283	576	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	576	2	have	have	VBP
22283	576	3	only	only	RB
22283	576	4	to	to	TO
22283	576	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	576	6	that	that	IN
22283	576	7	the	the	DT
22283	576	8	antithesis	antithesis	NN
22283	576	9	between	between	IN
22283	576	10	mind	mind	NN
22283	576	11	and	and	CC
22283	576	12	motion	motion	NN
22283	576	13	--	--	:
22283	576	14	subject	subject	NN
22283	576	15	and	and	CC
22283	576	16	object	object	NN
22283	576	17	--	--	:
22283	576	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	576	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	576	20	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	576	21	or	or	CC
22283	576	22	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	576	23	:	:	:
22283	576	24	not	not	RB
22283	576	25	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	576	26	or	or	CC
22283	576	27	real	real	JJ
22283	576	28	.	.	.
22283	577	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	577	2	have	have	VBP
22283	577	3	only	only	RB
22283	577	4	to	to	TO
22283	577	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	577	6	that	that	IN
22283	577	7	the	the	DT
22283	577	8	seeming	seeming	JJ
22283	577	9	duality	duality	NN
22283	577	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	577	11	relative	relative	JJ
22283	577	12	to	to	IN
22283	577	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	577	14	modes	mode	NNS
22283	577	15	of	of	IN
22283	577	16	apprehension	apprehension	NN
22283	577	17	:	:	:
22283	577	18	and	and	CC
22283	577	19	,	,	,
22283	577	20	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	577	21	,	,	,
22283	577	22	that	that	IN
22283	577	23	any	any	DT
22283	577	24	change	change	NN
22283	577	25	taking	take	VBG
22283	577	26	place	place	NN
22283	577	27	in	in	IN
22283	577	28	the	the	DT
22283	577	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	577	30	,	,	,
22283	577	31	and	and	CC
22283	577	32	any	any	DT
22283	577	33	corresponding	corresponding	JJ
22283	577	34	change	change	NN
22283	577	35	taking	take	VBG
22283	577	36	place	place	NN
22283	577	37	in	in	IN
22283	577	38	the	the	DT
22283	577	39	brain	brain	NN
22283	577	40	,	,	,
22283	577	41	are	be	VBP
22283	577	42	really	really	RB
22283	577	43	not	not	RB
22283	577	44	two	two	CD
22283	577	45	changes	change	NNS
22283	577	46	,	,	,
22283	577	47	but	but	CC
22283	577	48	one	one	CD
22283	577	49	change	change	NN
22283	577	50	.	.	.
22283	578	1	When	when	WRB
22283	578	2	a	a	DT
22283	578	3	violin	violin	NN
22283	578	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	578	5	played	play	VBN
22283	578	6	upon	upon	IN
22283	578	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	578	8	hear	hear	VBP
22283	578	9	a	a	DT
22283	578	10	musical	musical	JJ
22283	578	11	sound	sound	NN
22283	578	12	,	,	,
22283	578	13	and	and	CC
22283	578	14	at	at	IN
22283	578	15	the	the	DT
22283	578	16	same	same	JJ
22283	578	17	time	time	NN
22283	578	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	578	19	see	see	VBP
22283	578	20	a	a	DT
22283	578	21	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	578	22	of	of	IN
22283	578	23	the	the	DT
22283	578	24	strings	string	NNS
22283	578	25	.	.	.
22283	579	1	Relatively	relatively	RB
22283	579	2	to	to	IN
22283	579	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	579	4	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	579	5	,	,	,
22283	579	6	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	579	7	,	,	,
22283	579	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	579	9	have	have	VBP
22283	579	10	here	here	RB
22283	579	11	two	two	CD
22283	579	12	sets	set	NNS
22283	579	13	of	of	IN
22283	579	14	changes	change	NNS
22283	579	15	,	,	,
22283	579	16	which	which	WDT
22283	579	17	appear	appear	VBP
22283	579	18	to	to	TO
22283	579	19	be	be	VB
22283	579	20	very	very	RB
22283	579	21	different	different	JJ
22283	579	22	in	in	IN
22283	579	23	kind	kind	NN
22283	579	24	;	;	:
22283	579	25	yet	yet	CC
22283	579	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	579	27	know	know	VBP
22283	579	28	that	that	IN
22283	579	29	in	in	IN
22283	579	30	an	an	DT
22283	579	31	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	579	32	sense	sense	NN
22283	579	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	579	34	are	be	VBP
22283	579	35	one	one	CD
22283	579	36	and	and	CC
22283	579	37	the	the	DT
22283	579	38	same	same	JJ
22283	579	39	:	:	:
22283	579	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	579	41	know	know	VBP
22283	579	42	that	that	IN
22283	579	43	the	the	DT
22283	579	44	diversity	diversity	NN
22283	579	45	in	in	IN
22283	579	46	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	579	47	is	be	VBZ
22283	579	48	created	create	VBN
22283	579	49	only	only	RB
22283	579	50	by	by	IN
22283	579	51	the	the	DT
22283	579	52	difference	difference	NN
22283	579	53	in	in	IN
22283	579	54	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	579	55	mode	mode	NN
22283	579	56	of	of	IN
22283	579	57	perceiving	perceive	VBG
22283	579	58	the	the	DT
22283	579	59	same	same	JJ
22283	579	60	events	event	NNS
22283	579	61	--	--	:
22283	579	62	whether	whether	IN
22283	579	63	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	579	64	see	see	VBP
22283	579	65	or	or	CC
22283	579	66	whether	whether	IN
22283	579	67	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	579	68	hear	hear	VBP
22283	579	69	the	the	DT
22283	579	70	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	579	71	of	of	IN
22283	579	72	the	the	DT
22283	579	73	strings	string	NNS
22283	579	74	.	.	.
22283	580	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
22283	580	2	,	,	,
22283	580	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	580	4	may	may	MD
22283	580	5	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	580	6	that	that	IN
22283	580	7	a	a	DT
22283	580	8	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	580	9	of	of	IN
22283	580	10	nerve	nerve	NN
22283	580	11	-	-	HYPH
22283	580	12	strings	string	NNS
22283	580	13	and	and	CC
22283	580	14	a	a	DT
22283	580	15	process	process	NN
22283	580	16	of	of	IN
22283	580	17	thought	thought	NN
22283	580	18	are	be	VBP
22283	580	19	really	really	RB
22283	580	20	one	one	CD
22283	580	21	and	and	CC
22283	580	22	the	the	DT
22283	580	23	same	same	JJ
22283	580	24	event	event	NN
22283	580	25	,	,	,
22283	580	26	which	which	WDT
22283	580	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	580	28	dual	dual	JJ
22283	580	29	or	or	CC
22283	580	30	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	580	31	only	only	RB
22283	580	32	in	in	IN
22283	580	33	relation	relation	NN
22283	580	34	to	to	IN
22283	580	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	580	36	modes	mode	NNS
22283	580	37	of	of	IN
22283	580	38	perceiving	perceive	VBG
22283	580	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	580	40	.	.	.
22283	581	1	Or	or	CC
22283	581	2	,	,	,
22283	581	3	to	to	TO
22283	581	4	take	take	VB
22283	581	5	another	another	DT
22283	581	6	and	and	CC
22283	581	7	a	a	DT
22283	581	8	better	well	JJR
22283	581	9	illustration	illustration	NN
22283	581	10	,	,	,
22283	581	11	in	in	IN
22283	581	12	an	an	DT
22283	581	13	Edison	Edison	NNP
22283	581	14	lamp	lamp	NN
22283	581	15	the	the	DT
22283	581	16	light	light	NN
22283	581	17	which	which	WDT
22283	581	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	581	19	emitted	emit	VBN
22283	581	20	from	from	IN
22283	581	21	the	the	DT
22283	581	22	burner	burner	NN
22283	581	23	may	may	MD
22283	581	24	be	be	VB
22283	581	25	said	say	VBN
22283	581	26	indifferently	indifferently	RB
22283	581	27	to	to	TO
22283	581	28	be	be	VB
22283	581	29	caused	cause	VBN
22283	581	30	by	by	IN
22283	581	31	the	the	DT
22283	581	32	number	number	NN
22283	581	33	of	of	IN
22283	581	34	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	581	35	per	per	IN
22283	581	36	second	second	NN
22283	581	37	going	go	VBG
22283	581	38	on	on	RP
22283	581	39	in	in	IN
22283	581	40	the	the	DT
22283	581	41	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	581	42	,	,	,
22283	581	43	or	or	CC
22283	581	44	by	by	IN
22283	581	45	the	the	DT
22283	581	46	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	581	47	of	of	IN
22283	581	48	the	the	DT
22283	581	49	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	581	50	;	;	:
22283	581	51	for	for	IN
22283	581	52	this	this	DT
22283	581	53	rate	rate	NN
22283	581	54	of	of	IN
22283	581	55	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	581	56	could	could	MD
22283	581	57	not	not	RB
22283	581	58	take	take	VB
22283	581	59	place	place	NN
22283	581	60	in	in	IN
22283	581	61	the	the	DT
22283	581	62	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	581	63	without	without	IN
22283	581	64	constituting	constitute	VBG
22283	581	65	that	that	DT
22283	581	66	degree	degree	NN
22283	581	67	of	of	IN
22283	581	68	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	581	69	which	which	WDT
22283	581	70	affects	affect	VBZ
22283	581	71	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	581	72	eyes	eye	NNS
22283	581	73	as	as	IN
22283	581	74	luminous	luminous	JJ
22283	581	75	.	.	.
22283	582	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
22283	582	2	,	,	,
22283	582	3	a	a	DT
22283	582	4	train	train	NN
22283	582	5	of	of	IN
22283	582	6	thought	thought	NN
22283	582	7	may	may	MD
22283	582	8	be	be	VB
22283	582	9	said	say	VBN
22283	582	10	indifferently	indifferently	RB
22283	582	11	to	to	TO
22283	582	12	be	be	VB
22283	582	13	caused	cause	VBN
22283	582	14	by	by	IN
22283	582	15	brain	brain	NN
22283	582	16	-	-	HYPH
22283	582	17	action	action	NN
22283	582	18	or	or	CC
22283	582	19	by	by	IN
22283	582	20	mind	mind	NN
22283	582	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	582	22	action	action	NN
22283	582	23	;	;	:
22283	582	24	for	for	IN
22283	582	25	,	,	,
22283	582	26	_	_	NNP
22283	582	27	ex	ex	NNP
22283	582	28	hypothesi	hypothesi	NNP
22283	582	29	_	_	NNP
22283	582	30	,	,	,
22283	582	31	the	the	DT
22283	582	32	one	one	NN
22283	582	33	could	could	MD
22283	582	34	not	not	RB
22283	582	35	take	take	VB
22283	582	36	place	place	NN
22283	582	37	without	without	IN
22283	582	38	the	the	DT
22283	582	39	other	other	JJ
22283	582	40	.	.	.
22283	583	1	Now	now	RB
22283	583	2	when	when	WRB
22283	583	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	583	4	contemplate	contemplate	VBP
22283	583	5	the	the	DT
22283	583	6	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	583	7	of	of	IN
22283	583	8	volition	volition	NN
22283	583	9	by	by	IN
22283	583	10	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	583	11	,	,	,
22283	583	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	583	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	583	14	as	as	IN
22283	583	15	though	though	IN
22283	583	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	583	17	were	be	VBD
22283	583	18	contemplating	contemplate	VBG
22283	583	19	the	the	DT
22283	583	20	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	583	21	of	of	IN
22283	583	22	light	light	NN
22283	583	23	by	by	IN
22283	583	24	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	583	25	:	:	:
22283	583	26	volition	volition	NN
22283	583	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	583	28	produced	produce	VBN
22283	583	29	by	by	IN
22283	583	30	mind	mind	NN
22283	583	31	in	in	IN
22283	583	32	brain	brain	NN
22283	583	33	,	,	,
22283	583	34	just	just	RB
22283	583	35	as	as	IN
22283	583	36	light	light	NN
22283	583	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	583	38	produced	produce	VBN
22283	583	39	by	by	IN
22283	583	40	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	583	41	in	in	IN
22283	583	42	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	583	43	.	.	.
22283	584	1	And	and	CC
22283	584	2	just	just	RB
22283	584	3	as	as	IN
22283	584	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	584	5	may	may	MD
22283	584	6	correctly	correctly	RB
22283	584	7	speak	speak	VB
22283	584	8	of	of	IN
22283	584	9	light	light	NN
22283	584	10	as	as	IN
22283	584	11	the	the	DT
22283	584	12	cause	cause	NN
22283	584	13	,	,	,
22283	584	14	say	say	UH
22283	584	15	,	,	,
22283	584	16	of	of	IN
22283	584	17	a	a	DT
22283	584	18	photograph	photograph	NN
22283	584	19	,	,	,
22283	584	20	so	so	IN
22283	584	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	584	22	may	may	MD
22283	584	23	correctly	correctly	RB
22283	584	24	speak	speak	VB
22283	584	25	of	of	IN
22283	584	26	volition	volition	NN
22283	584	27	as	as	IN
22283	584	28	the	the	DT
22283	584	29	cause	cause	NN
22283	584	30	of	of	IN
22283	584	31	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	584	32	movement	movement	NN
22283	584	33	.	.	.
22283	585	1	That	that	DT
22283	585	2	particular	particular	JJ
22283	585	3	kind	kind	NN
22283	585	4	of	of	IN
22283	585	5	physical	physical	JJ
22283	585	6	activity	activity	NN
22283	585	7	which	which	WDT
22283	585	8	takes	take	VBZ
22283	585	9	place	place	NN
22283	585	10	in	in	IN
22283	585	11	the	the	DT
22283	585	12	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	585	13	could	could	MD
22283	585	14	not	not	RB
22283	585	15	take	take	VB
22283	585	16	place	place	NN
22283	585	17	without	without	IN
22283	585	18	the	the	DT
22283	585	19	light	light	NN
22283	585	20	which	which	WDT
22283	585	21	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	585	22	a	a	DT
22283	585	23	photograph	photograph	NN
22283	585	24	;	;	:
22283	585	25	and	and	CC
22283	585	26	,	,	,
22283	585	27	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	585	28	,	,	,
22283	585	29	that	that	IN
22283	585	30	particular	particular	JJ
22283	585	31	kind	kind	NN
22283	585	32	of	of	IN
22283	585	33	physical	physical	JJ
22283	585	34	activity	activity	NN
22283	585	35	which	which	WDT
22283	585	36	takes	take	VBZ
22283	585	37	place	place	NN
22283	585	38	in	in	IN
22283	585	39	the	the	DT
22283	585	40	brain	brain	NN
22283	585	41	could	could	MD
22283	585	42	not	not	RB
22283	585	43	take	take	VB
22283	585	44	place	place	NN
22283	585	45	without	without	IN
22283	585	46	the	the	DT
22283	585	47	volition	volition	NN
22283	585	48	which	which	WDT
22283	585	49	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	585	50	a	a	DT
22283	585	51	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	585	52	movement	movement	NN
22283	585	53	.	.	.
22283	586	1	So	so	RB
22283	586	2	that	that	IN
22283	586	3	volition	volition	NN
22283	586	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	586	5	as	as	RB
22283	586	6	truly	truly	RB
22283	586	7	a	a	DT
22283	586	8	cause	cause	NN
22283	586	9	of	of	IN
22283	586	10	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	586	11	movement	movement	NN
22283	586	12	as	as	IN
22283	586	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	586	14	the	the	DT
22283	586	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	586	16	activity	activity	NN
22283	586	17	of	of	IN
22283	586	18	the	the	DT
22283	586	19	brain	brain	NN
22283	586	20	;	;	:
22283	586	21	seeing	see	VBG
22283	586	22	that	that	IN
22283	586	23	,	,	,
22283	586	24	in	in	IN
22283	586	25	an	an	DT
22283	586	26	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	586	27	sense	sense	NN
22283	586	28	,	,	,
22283	586	29	the	the	DT
22283	586	30	cause	cause	NN
22283	586	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	586	32	one	one	CD
22283	586	33	and	and	CC
22283	586	34	the	the	DT
22283	586	35	same	same	JJ
22283	586	36	.	.	.
22283	587	1	But	but	CC
22283	587	2	if	if	IN
22283	587	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	587	4	once	once	RB
22283	587	5	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	587	6	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	587	7	that	that	IN
22283	587	8	what	what	WP
22283	587	9	in	in	IN
22283	587	10	a	a	DT
22283	587	11	relative	relative	JJ
22283	587	12	sense	sense	NN
22283	587	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	587	14	know	know	VBP
22283	587	15	as	as	IN
22283	587	16	volition	volition	NN
22283	587	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	587	18	,	,	,
22283	587	19	in	in	IN
22283	587	20	a	a	DT
22283	587	21	similar	similar	JJ
22283	587	22	sense	sense	NN
22283	587	23	,	,	,
22283	587	24	the	the	DT
22283	587	25	cause	cause	NN
22283	587	26	of	of	IN
22283	587	27	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	587	28	movement	movement	NN
22283	587	29	,	,	,
22283	587	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	587	31	terminate	terminate	VBP
22283	587	32	the	the	DT
22283	587	33	question	question	NN
22283	587	34	touching	touch	VBG
22283	587	35	the	the	DT
22283	587	36	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	587	37	of	of	IN
22283	587	38	the	the	DT
22283	587	39	will	will	NN
22283	587	40	.	.	.
22283	588	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	588	2	thus	thus	RB
22283	588	3	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	588	4	a	a	DT
22283	588	5	mere	mere	JJ
22283	588	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	588	7	of	of	IN
22283	588	8	phraseology	phraseology	NN
22283	588	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	588	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	588	11	speak	speak	VBP
22283	588	12	of	of	IN
22283	588	13	the	the	DT
22283	588	14	will	will	NN
22283	588	15	determining	determine	VBG
22283	588	16	,	,	,
22283	588	17	or	or	CC
22283	588	18	being	be	VBG
22283	588	19	determined	determine	VBN
22283	588	20	by	by	RB
22283	588	21	,	,	,
22283	588	22	changes	change	NNS
22283	588	23	going	go	VBG
22283	588	24	on	on	RP
22283	588	25	in	in	IN
22283	588	26	the	the	DT
22283	588	27	external	external	JJ
22283	588	28	world	world	NN
22283	588	29	;	;	:
22283	588	30	just	just	RB
22283	588	31	as	as	IN
22283	588	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	588	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	588	34	but	but	CC
22283	588	35	a	a	DT
22283	588	36	matter	matter	NN
22283	588	37	of	of	IN
22283	588	38	phraseology	phraseology	NN
22283	588	39	whether	whether	IN
22283	588	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	588	41	speak	speak	VBP
22283	588	42	of	of	IN
22283	588	43	temperature	temperature	NN
22283	588	44	determining	determine	VBG
22283	588	45	,	,	,
22283	588	46	or	or	CC
22283	588	47	being	be	VBG
22283	588	48	determined	determine	VBN
22283	588	49	by	by	IN
22283	588	50	,	,	,
22283	588	51	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	588	52	vibration	vibration	NN
22283	588	53	.	.	.
22283	589	1	All	all	PDT
22283	589	2	the	the	DT
22283	589	3	requirements	requirement	NNS
22283	589	4	alike	alike	RB
22283	589	5	of	of	IN
22283	589	6	the	the	DT
22283	589	7	free	free	JJ
22283	589	8	-	-	HYPH
22283	589	9	will	will	NN
22283	589	10	and	and	CC
22283	589	11	of	of	IN
22283	589	12	the	the	DT
22283	589	13	bond	bond	NN
22283	589	14	-	-	:
22283	589	15	will	will	MD
22283	589	16	hypotheses	hypothesis	NNS
22283	589	17	are	be	VBP
22283	589	18	thus	thus	RB
22283	589	19	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
22283	589	20	by	by	IN
22283	589	21	a	a	DT
22283	589	22	synthesis	synthesis	NN
22283	589	23	which	which	WDT
22283	589	24	comprises	comprise	VBZ
22283	589	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	589	26	both	both	DT
22283	589	27	.	.	.
22283	590	1	On	on	IN
22283	590	2	the	the	DT
22283	590	3	one	one	CD
22283	590	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	590	5	,	,	,
22283	590	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	590	7	would	would	MD
22283	590	8	be	be	VB
22283	590	9	as	as	RB
22283	590	10	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	590	11	for	for	IN
22283	590	12	an	an	DT
22283	590	13	_	_	NNP
22283	590	14	un_conscious	un_conscious	NNP
22283	590	15	automaton	automaton	NN
22283	590	16	to	to	TO
22283	590	17	do	do	VB
22283	590	18	the	the	DT
22283	590	19	work	work	NN
22283	590	20	or	or	CC
22283	590	21	to	to	TO
22283	590	22	perform	perform	VB
22283	590	23	the	the	DT
22283	590	24	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	590	25	of	of	IN
22283	590	26	a	a	DT
22283	590	27	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	590	28	agent	agent	NN
22283	590	29	,	,	,
22283	590	30	as	as	IN
22283	590	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	590	32	would	would	MD
22283	590	33	be	be	VB
22283	590	34	for	for	IN
22283	590	35	an	an	DT
22283	590	36	Edison	Edison	NNP
22283	590	37	lamp	lamp	NN
22283	590	38	to	to	TO
22283	590	39	give	give	VB
22283	590	40	out	out	RP
22283	590	41	light	light	NN
22283	590	42	and	and	CC
22283	590	43	cause	cause	VB
22283	590	44	a	a	DT
22283	590	45	photograph	photograph	NN
22283	590	46	when	when	WRB
22283	590	47	not	not	RB
22283	590	48	heated	heat	VBN
22283	590	49	by	by	IN
22283	590	50	an	an	DT
22283	590	51	electric	electric	JJ
22283	590	52	current	current	NN
22283	590	53	.	.	.
22283	591	1	On	on	IN
22283	591	2	the	the	DT
22283	591	3	other	other	JJ
22283	591	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	591	5	,	,	,
22283	591	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	591	7	would	would	MD
22283	591	8	be	be	VB
22283	591	9	as	as	RB
22283	591	10	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	591	11	for	for	IN
22283	591	12	the	the	DT
22283	591	13	will	will	NN
22283	591	14	to	to	TO
22283	591	15	originate	originate	VB
22283	591	16	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	591	17	motion	motion	NN
22283	591	18	without	without	IN
22283	591	19	the	the	DT
22283	591	20	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	591	21	of	of	IN
22283	591	22	a	a	DT
22283	591	23	strictly	strictly	RB
22283	591	24	physical	physical	JJ
22283	591	25	process	process	NN
22283	591	26	of	of	IN
22283	591	27	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	591	28	,	,	,
22283	591	29	as	as	IN
22283	591	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	591	31	would	would	MD
22283	591	32	be	be	VB
22283	591	33	for	for	IN
22283	591	34	light	light	NN
22283	591	35	to	to	TO
22283	591	36	shine	shine	VB
22283	591	37	in	in	IN
22283	591	38	an	an	DT
22283	591	39	Edison	Edison	NNP
22283	591	40	lamp	lamp	NN
22283	591	41	which	which	WDT
22283	591	42	had	have	VBD
22283	591	43	been	be	VBN
22283	591	44	deprived	deprive	VBN
22283	591	45	of	of	IN
22283	591	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	591	47	carbon	carbon	NN
22283	591	48	-	-	HYPH
22283	591	49	burner	burner	NN
22283	591	50	.	.	.
22283	592	1	The	the	DT
22283	592	2	great	great	JJ
22283	592	3	advantage	advantage	NN
22283	592	4	of	of	IN
22283	592	5	this	this	DT
22283	592	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	592	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	592	8	,	,	,
22283	592	9	that	that	IN
22283	592	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	592	11	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	592	12	only	only	RB
22283	592	13	one	one	CD
22283	592	14	stream	stream	NN
22283	592	15	of	of	IN
22283	592	16	causation	causation	NN
22283	592	17	,	,	,
22283	592	18	in	in	IN
22283	592	19	which	which	WDT
22283	592	20	both	both	DT
22283	592	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	592	22	and	and	CC
22283	592	23	motion	motion	NN
22283	592	24	are	be	VBP
22283	592	25	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
22283	592	26	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	592	27	.	.	.
22283	593	1	The	the	DT
22283	593	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	593	3	,	,	,
22283	593	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	593	5	,	,	,
22283	593	6	escapes	escape	VBZ
22283	593	7	all	all	PDT
22283	593	8	the	the	DT
22283	593	9	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
22283	593	10	and	and	CC
22283	593	11	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
22283	593	12	with	with	IN
22283	593	13	which	which	WDT
22283	593	14	both	both	DT
22283	593	15	spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	593	16	and	and	CC
22283	593	17	materialism	materialism	NN
22283	593	18	are	be	VBP
22283	593	19	beset	beset	NN
22283	593	20	.	.	.
22283	594	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	594	2	,	,	,
22283	594	3	motion	motion	NN
22283	594	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	594	5	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	594	6	to	to	TO
22283	594	7	be	be	VB
22283	594	8	producing	produce	VBG
22283	594	9	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	594	10	but	but	IN
22283	594	11	motion	motion	NN
22283	594	12	;	;	:
22283	594	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	594	14	-	-	HYPH
22283	594	15	changes	change	VBZ
22283	594	16	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	594	17	but	but	IN
22283	594	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	594	19	-	-	HYPH
22283	594	20	changes	change	NNS
22283	594	21	--	--	:
22283	594	22	both	both	DT
22283	594	23	producing	produce	VBG
22283	594	24	both	both	DT
22283	594	25	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
22283	594	26	:	:	:
22283	594	27	neither	neither	DT
22283	594	28	could	could	MD
22283	594	29	be	be	VB
22283	594	30	what	what	WP
22283	594	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	594	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	594	33	without	without	IN
22283	594	34	the	the	DT
22283	594	35	other	other	JJ
22283	594	36	,	,	,
22283	594	37	because	because	IN
22283	594	38	without	without	IN
22283	594	39	the	the	DT
22283	594	40	other	other	JJ
22283	594	41	neither	neither	CC
22283	594	42	could	could	MD
22283	594	43	be	be	VB
22283	594	44	the	the	DT
22283	594	45	cause	cause	NN
22283	594	46	which	which	WDT
22283	594	47	in	in	IN
22283	594	48	fact	fact	NN
22283	594	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	594	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	594	51	.	.	.
22283	595	1	Impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	595	2	,	,	,
22283	595	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	595	4	,	,	,
22283	595	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	595	6	the	the	DT
22283	595	7	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	595	8	of	of	IN
22283	595	9	the	the	DT
22283	595	10	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	595	11	that	that	WDT
22283	595	12	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	595	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	595	14	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	595	15	,	,	,
22283	595	16	or	or	CC
22283	595	17	that	that	IN
22283	595	18	in	in	IN
22283	595	19	the	the	DT
22283	595	20	absence	absence	NN
22283	595	21	of	of	IN
22283	595	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	595	23	the	the	DT
22283	595	24	changes	change	NNS
22283	595	25	of	of	IN
22283	595	26	the	the	DT
22283	595	27	brain	brain	NN
22283	595	28	could	could	MD
22283	595	29	be	be	VB
22283	595	30	what	what	WP
22283	595	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	595	32	are	be	VBP
22283	595	33	;	;	:
22283	595	34	for	for	IN
22283	595	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	595	36	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	595	37	to	to	IN
22283	595	38	the	the	DT
22283	595	39	very	very	JJ
22283	595	40	causation	causation	NN
22283	595	41	of	of	IN
22283	595	42	these	these	DT
22283	595	43	movements	movement	NNS
22283	595	44	that	that	IN
22283	595	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	595	46	should	should	MD
22283	595	47	have	have	VB
22283	595	48	a	a	DT
22283	595	49	mental	mental	JJ
22283	595	50	side	side	NN
22283	595	51	.	.	.
22283	596	1	And	and	CC
22283	596	2	equally	equally	RB
22283	596	3	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	596	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	596	5	the	the	DT
22283	596	6	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	596	7	of	of	IN
22283	596	8	the	the	DT
22283	596	9	spiritualist	spiritualist	NN
22283	596	10	that	that	WDT
22283	596	11	the	the	DT
22283	596	12	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	596	13	processes	process	NNS
22283	596	14	are	be	VBP
22283	596	15	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	596	16	,	,	,
22283	596	17	or	or	CC
22283	596	18	that	that	IN
22283	596	19	in	in	IN
22283	596	20	the	the	DT
22283	596	21	absence	absence	NN
22283	596	22	of	of	IN
22283	596	23	brain	brain	NN
22283	596	24	the	the	DT
22283	596	25	changes	change	NNS
22283	596	26	of	of	IN
22283	596	27	the	the	DT
22283	596	28	mind	mind	NN
22283	596	29	could	could	MD
22283	596	30	be	be	VB
22283	596	31	what	what	WP
22283	596	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	596	33	are	be	VBP
22283	596	34	;	;	:
22283	596	35	for	for	IN
22283	596	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	596	37	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	596	38	to	to	IN
22283	596	39	the	the	DT
22283	596	40	very	very	JJ
22283	596	41	causation	causation	NN
22283	596	42	of	of	IN
22283	596	43	these	these	DT
22283	596	44	changes	change	NNS
22283	596	45	that	that	IN
22283	596	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	596	47	should	should	MD
22283	596	48	have	have	VB
22283	596	49	a	a	DT
22283	596	50	material	material	JJ
22283	596	51	side	side	NN
22283	596	52	.	.	.
22283	597	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
22283	597	2	,	,	,
22283	597	3	the	the	DT
22283	597	4	use	use	NN
22283	597	5	of	of	IN
22283	597	6	mind	mind	NN
22283	597	7	to	to	IN
22283	597	8	animals	animal	NNS
22283	597	9	and	and	CC
22283	597	10	to	to	IN
22283	597	11	men	man	NNS
22283	597	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	597	13	thus	thus	RB
22283	597	14	rendered	render	VBN
22283	597	15	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	597	16	;	;	:
22283	597	17	for	for	IN
22283	597	18	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
22283	597	19	volition	volition	NN
22283	597	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	597	21	thus	thus	RB
22283	597	22	shown	show	VBN
22283	597	23	to	to	TO
22283	597	24	be	be	VB
22283	597	25	a	a	DT
22283	597	26	true	true	JJ
22283	597	27	cause	cause	NN
22283	597	28	of	of	IN
22283	597	29	adjustive	adjustive	JJ
22283	597	30	movement	movement	NN
22283	597	31	,	,	,
22283	597	32	in	in	IN
22283	597	33	that	that	IN
22283	597	34	the	the	DT
22283	597	35	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	597	36	which	which	WDT
22283	597	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	597	38	involves	involve	VBZ
22283	597	39	could	could	MD
22283	597	40	not	not	RB
22283	597	41	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	597	42	be	be	VB
22283	597	43	possible	possible	JJ
22283	597	44	:	:	:
22283	597	45	the	the	DT
22283	597	46	causation	causation	NN
22283	597	47	would	would	MD
22283	597	48	not	not	RB
22283	597	49	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	597	50	be	be	VB
22283	597	51	complete	complete	JJ
22283	597	52	.	.	.
22283	598	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
22283	598	2	:	:	:
22283	598	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	598	4	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	598	5	8	8	CD
22283	598	6	:	:	:
22283	598	7	_	_	NNP
22283	598	8	Lectures	Lectures	NNPS
22283	598	9	and	and	CC
22283	598	10	Essays	Essays	NNPS
22283	598	11	_	_	NNP
22283	598	12	,	,	,
22283	598	13	vol	vol	NNP
22283	598	14	.	.	.
22283	599	1	ii	ii	LS
22283	599	2	.	.	.
22283	600	1	pp	pp	NNP
22283	600	2	.	.	.
22283	601	1	56	56	CD
22283	601	2	-	-	SYM
22283	601	3	7	7	CD
22283	601	4	.	.	.
22283	601	5	]	]	-RRB-
22283	602	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
22283	602	2	IV	IV	NNP
22283	602	3	.	.	.
22283	603	1	THE	the	DT
22283	603	2	WORLD	WORLD	NNP
22283	603	3	AS	as	IN
22283	603	4	AN	an	DT
22283	603	5	EJECT	eject	NN
22283	603	6	.	.	.
22283	604	1	In	in	IN
22283	604	2	the	the	DT
22283	604	3	Introduction	introduction	NN
22283	604	4	to	to	IN
22283	604	5	this	this	DT
22283	604	6	essay	essay	NN
22283	604	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	604	8	have	have	VBP
22283	604	9	sought	seek	VBN
22283	604	10	to	to	TO
22283	604	11	show	show	VB
22283	604	12	that	that	IN
22283	604	13	there	there	EX
22283	604	14	are	be	VBP
22283	604	15	,	,	,
22283	604	16	for	for	IN
22283	604	17	the	the	DT
22283	604	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	604	19	of	of	IN
22283	604	20	practical	practical	JJ
22283	604	21	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	604	22	,	,	,
22283	604	23	but	but	CC
22283	604	24	three	three	CD
22283	604	25	theories	theory	NNS
22283	604	26	of	of	IN
22283	604	27	the	the	DT
22283	604	28	World	World	NNP
22283	604	29	of	of	IN
22283	604	30	Being	be	VBG
22283	604	31	.	.	.
22283	605	1	There	there	EX
22283	605	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	605	3	,	,	,
22283	605	4	first	first	RB
22283	605	5	,	,	,
22283	605	6	the	the	DT
22283	605	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	605	8	of	of	IN
22283	605	9	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	605	10	,	,	,
22283	605	11	which	which	WDT
22283	605	12	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	605	13	matter	matter	NN
22283	605	14	in	in	IN
22283	605	15	motion	motion	NN
22283	605	16	to	to	TO
22283	605	17	be	be	VB
22283	605	18	the	the	DT
22283	605	19	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	605	20	or	or	CC
22283	605	21	self	self	NN
22283	605	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	605	23	existing	exist	VBG
22283	605	24	Reality	reality	NN
22283	605	25	,	,	,
22283	605	26	and	and	CC
22283	605	27	,	,	,
22283	605	28	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	605	29	,	,	,
22283	605	30	the	the	DT
22283	605	31	cause	cause	NN
22283	605	32	of	of	IN
22283	605	33	mind	mind	NN
22283	605	34	.	.	.
22283	606	1	Next	next	RB
22283	606	2	,	,	,
22283	606	3	there	there	EX
22283	606	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	606	5	the	the	DT
22283	606	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	606	7	of	of	IN
22283	606	8	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	606	9	,	,	,
22283	606	10	which	which	WDT
22283	606	11	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	606	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	606	13	to	to	TO
22283	606	14	be	be	VB
22283	606	15	the	the	DT
22283	606	16	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	606	17	Reality	reality	NN
22283	606	18	,	,	,
22283	606	19	and	and	CC
22283	606	20	,	,	,
22283	606	21	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	606	22	,	,	,
22283	606	23	the	the	DT
22283	606	24	cause	cause	NN
22283	606	25	of	of	IN
22283	606	26	matter	matter	NN
22283	606	27	in	in	IN
22283	606	28	motion	motion	NN
22283	606	29	.	.	.
22283	607	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	607	2	,	,	,
22283	607	3	there	there	EX
22283	607	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	607	5	the	the	DT
22283	607	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	607	7	of	of	IN
22283	607	8	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	607	9	which	which	WDT
22283	607	10	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	607	11	matter	matter	NN
22283	607	12	in	in	IN
22283	607	13	motion	motion	NN
22283	607	14	to	to	TO
22283	607	15	be	be	VB
22283	607	16	substantially	substantially	RB
22283	607	17	identical	identical	JJ
22283	607	18	with	with	IN
22283	607	19	mind	mind	NN
22283	607	20	,	,	,
22283	607	21	and	and	CC
22283	607	22	,	,	,
22283	607	23	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	607	24	,	,	,
22283	607	25	that	that	IN
22283	607	26	as	as	IN
22283	607	27	between	between	IN
22283	607	28	mind	mind	NN
22283	607	29	and	and	CC
22283	607	30	matter	matter	NN
22283	607	31	in	in	IN
22283	607	32	motion	motion	NN
22283	607	33	there	there	EX
22283	607	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	607	35	no	no	DT
22283	607	36	causal	causal	JJ
22283	607	37	relation	relation	NN
22283	607	38	either	either	DT
22283	607	39	way	way	NN
22283	607	40	.	.	.
22283	608	1	In	in	IN
22283	608	2	the	the	DT
22283	608	3	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
22283	608	4	chapters	chapter	NNS
22283	608	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	608	6	have	have	VBP
22283	608	7	considered	consider	VBN
22283	608	8	these	these	DT
22283	608	9	three	three	CD
22283	608	10	theories	theory	NNS
22283	608	11	,	,	,
22283	608	12	and	and	CC
22283	608	13	argued	argue	VBD
22283	608	14	that	that	DT
22283	608	15	of	of	IN
22283	608	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	608	17	the	the	DT
22283	608	18	last	last	RB
22283	608	19	-	-	HYPH
22283	608	20	mentioned	mention	VBN
22283	608	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	608	22	the	the	DT
22283	608	23	only	only	JJ
22283	608	24	one	one	CD
22283	608	25	which	which	WDT
22283	608	26	satisfies	satisfy	VBZ
22283	608	27	all	all	PDT
22283	608	28	the	the	DT
22283	608	29	facts	fact	NNS
22283	608	30	of	of	IN
22283	608	31	feeling	feel	VBG
22283	608	32	on	on	IN
22283	608	33	the	the	DT
22283	608	34	one	one	CD
22283	608	35	hand	hand	NN
22283	608	36	,	,	,
22283	608	37	and	and	CC
22283	608	38	of	of	IN
22283	608	39	observation	observation	NN
22283	608	40	on	on	IN
22283	608	41	the	the	DT
22283	608	42	other	other	JJ
22283	608	43	.	.	.
22283	609	1	The	the	DT
22283	609	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	609	3	of	of	IN
22283	609	4	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	609	5	alone	alone	RB
22283	609	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	609	7	able	able	JJ
22283	609	8	to	to	TO
22283	609	9	explain	explain	VB
22283	609	10	,	,	,
22283	609	11	without	without	IN
22283	609	12	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	609	13	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	609	14	,	,	,
22283	609	15	the	the	DT
22283	609	16	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	609	17	both	both	DT
22283	609	18	of	of	IN
22283	609	19	the	the	DT
22283	609	20	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	609	21	and	and	CC
22283	609	22	objective	objective	JJ
22283	609	23	spheres	sphere	NNS
22283	609	24	.	.	.
22283	610	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	610	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	610	3	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	610	4	present	present	JJ
22283	610	5	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	610	6	to	to	TO
22283	610	7	extend	extend	VB
22283	610	8	the	the	DT
22283	610	9	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	610	10	already	already	RB
22283	610	11	presented	present	VBN
22283	610	12	.	.	.
22283	611	1	Assuming	assume	VBG
22283	611	2	the	the	DT
22283	611	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	611	4	of	of	IN
22283	611	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	611	6	,	,	,
22283	611	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	611	8	desire	desire	VBP
22283	611	9	to	to	TO
22283	611	10	ascertain	ascertain	VB
22283	611	11	the	the	DT
22283	611	12	result	result	NN
22283	611	13	to	to	TO
22283	611	14	which	which	WDT
22283	611	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	611	16	will	will	MD
22283	611	17	lead	lead	VB
22283	611	18	when	when	WRB
22283	611	19	applied	apply	VBN
22283	611	20	to	to	IN
22283	611	21	the	the	DT
22283	611	22	question	question	NN
22283	611	23	whether	whether	IN
22283	611	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	611	25	ought	ought	MD
22283	611	26	to	to	TO
22283	611	27	regard	regard	VB
22283	611	28	the	the	DT
22283	611	29	external	external	JJ
22283	611	30	world	world	NN
22283	611	31	as	as	IN
22283	611	32	of	of	IN
22283	611	33	a	a	DT
22283	611	34	character	character	NN
22283	611	35	mental	mental	JJ
22283	611	36	or	or	CC
22283	611	37	non	non	JJ
22283	611	38	-	-	JJ
22283	611	39	mental	mental	JJ
22283	611	40	.	.	.
22283	612	1	As	as	IN
22283	612	2	observed	observe	VBN
22283	612	3	in	in	IN
22283	612	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	612	5	Rede	Rede	NNP
22283	612	6	Lecture	Lecture	NNP
22283	612	7	(	(	-LRB-
22283	612	8	_	_	NNP
22283	612	9	supra	supra	NNP
22283	612	10	_	_	NNP
22283	612	11	,	,	,
22283	612	12	p.	p.	NN
22283	612	13	33	33	CD
22283	612	14	)	)	-RRB-
22283	612	15	,	,	,
22283	612	16	this	this	DT
22283	612	17	question	question	NN
22283	612	18	has	have	VBZ
22283	612	19	already	already	RB
22283	612	20	been	be	VBN
22283	612	21	considered	consider	VBN
22283	612	22	by	by	IN
22283	612	23	the	the	DT
22283	612	24	late	late	JJ
22283	612	25	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	612	26	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	612	27	,	,	,
22283	612	28	who	who	WP
22283	612	29	decided	decide	VBD
22283	612	30	that	that	IN
22283	612	31	on	on	IN
22283	612	32	the	the	DT
22283	612	33	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	612	34	theory	theory	NN
22283	612	35	the	the	DT
22283	612	36	probability	probability	NN
22283	612	37	pointed	point	VBD
22283	612	38	towards	towards	IN
22283	612	39	the	the	DT
22283	612	40	external	external	JJ
22283	612	41	world	world	NN
22283	612	42	being	be	VBG
22283	612	43	of	of	IN
22283	612	44	a	a	DT
22283	612	45	character	character	NN
22283	612	46	non	non	JJ
22283	612	47	-	-	JJ
22283	612	48	mental	mental	JJ
22283	612	49	;	;	:
22283	612	50	that	that	IN
22283	612	51	,	,	,
22283	612	52	although	although	IN
22283	612	53	the	the	DT
22283	612	54	whole	whole	JJ
22283	612	55	universe	universe	NN
22283	612	56	is	be	VBZ
22283	612	57	composed	compose	VBN
22283	612	58	of	of	IN
22283	612	59	'	'	``
22283	612	60	mind	mind	NN
22283	612	61	-	-	HYPH
22283	612	62	stuff	stuff	NN
22283	612	63	,	,	,
22283	612	64	'	'	''
22283	612	65	the	the	DT
22283	612	66	universe	universe	NN
22283	612	67	as	as	IN
22283	612	68	a	a	DT
22283	612	69	whole	whole	NN
22283	612	70	is	be	VBZ
22283	612	71	mindless	mindless	JJ
22283	612	72	.	.	.
22283	613	1	This	this	DT
22283	613	2	decision	decision	NN
22283	613	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	613	4	then	then	RB
22283	613	5	briefly	briefly	RB
22283	613	6	criticized	criticize	VBD
22283	613	7	;	;	:
22283	613	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	613	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	613	10	now	now	RB
22283	613	11	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	613	12	object	object	NN
22283	613	13	to	to	TO
22283	613	14	contemplate	contemplate	VB
22283	613	15	the	the	DT
22283	613	16	matter	matter	NN
22283	613	17	somewhat	somewhat	RB
22283	613	18	more	more	RBR
22283	613	19	in	in	IN
22283	613	20	detail	detail	NN
22283	613	21	.	.	.
22283	614	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	2	will	will	MD
22283	614	3	assume	assume	VB
22283	614	4	,	,	,
22283	614	5	on	on	IN
22283	614	6	account	account	NN
22283	614	7	of	of	IN
22283	614	8	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	614	9	previously	previously	RB
22283	614	10	given	give	VBN
22283	614	11	,	,	,
22283	614	12	that	that	IN
22283	614	13	when	when	WRB
22283	614	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	15	speak	speak	VBP
22283	614	16	of	of	IN
22283	614	17	matter	matter	NN
22283	614	18	in	in	IN
22283	614	19	motion	motion	NN
22283	614	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	21	do	do	VBP
22283	614	22	not	not	RB
22283	614	23	at	at	RB
22283	614	24	all	all	RB
22283	614	25	know	know	VB
22283	614	26	what	what	WP
22283	614	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	614	29	that	that	IN
22283	614	30	moves	move	NNS
22283	614	31	,	,	,
22283	614	32	nor	nor	CC
22283	614	33	do	do	VBP
22283	614	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	35	know	know	VB
22283	614	36	at	at	RB
22283	614	37	all	all	RB
22283	614	38	what	what	WP
22283	614	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	614	41	that	that	IN
22283	614	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	614	43	mean	mean	VBP
22283	614	44	by	by	IN
22283	614	45	motion	motion	NN
22283	614	46	.	.	.
22283	615	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	615	2	if	if	IN
22283	615	3	,	,	,
22283	615	4	as	as	IN
22283	615	5	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	615	6	quantities	quantity	NNS
22283	615	7	,	,	,
22283	615	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	615	9	call	call	VBP
22283	615	10	matter	matter	NN
22283	615	11	_	_	NNP
22283	615	12	a	a	DT
22283	615	13	_	_	NNP
22283	615	14	and	and	CC
22283	615	15	motion	motion	NN
22283	615	16	_	_	NNP
22283	615	17	b	b	NNP
22283	615	18	_	_	NNP
22283	615	19	,	,	,
22283	615	20	all	all	DT
22283	615	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	615	22	are	be	VBP
22283	615	23	entitled	entitle	VBN
22283	615	24	to	to	TO
22283	615	25	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	615	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	615	27	that	that	IN
22283	615	28	_	_	NNP
22283	615	29	a	a	NN
22283	615	30	+	+	SYM
22283	615	31	b	b	NN
22283	615	32	=	=	SYM
22283	615	33	z	z	NNP
22283	615	34	_	_	NNP
22283	615	35	,	,	,
22283	615	36	where	where	WRB
22283	615	37	_	_	NNP
22283	615	38	z	z	NNP
22283	615	39	_	_	NNP
22283	615	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	615	41	a	a	DT
22283	615	42	known	know	VBN
22283	615	43	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	615	44	,	,	,
22283	615	45	or	or	CC
22283	615	46	mind	mind	NN
22283	615	47	.	.	.
22283	616	1	Obversely	obversely	RB
22283	616	2	stated	stated	JJ
22283	616	3	,	,	,
22283	616	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	616	5	may	may	MD
22283	616	6	say	say	VB
22283	616	7	that	that	IN
22283	616	8	the	the	DT
22283	616	9	known	know	VBN
22283	616	10	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	616	11	_	_	NNP
22283	616	12	z	z	NNP
22283	616	13	_	_	NNP
22283	616	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	616	15	capable	capable	JJ
22283	616	16	of	of	IN
22283	616	17	being	be	VBG
22283	616	18	resolved	resolve	VBN
22283	616	19	into	into	IN
22283	616	20	the	the	DT
22283	616	21	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	616	22	_	_	NNP
22283	616	23	a	a	DT
22283	616	24	+	+	SYM
22283	616	25	b	b	NN
22283	616	26	_	_	NN
22283	616	27	.	.	.
22283	617	1	But	but	CC
22283	617	2	,	,	,
22283	617	3	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
22283	617	4	as	as	IN
22283	617	5	both	both	DT
22283	617	6	_	_	NNP
22283	617	7	a	a	DT
22283	617	8	_	_	NNP
22283	617	9	and	and	CC
22283	617	10	_	_	NNP
22283	617	11	b	b	NNP
22283	617	12	_	_	NNP
22283	617	13	are	be	VBP
22283	617	14	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	617	15	,	,	,
22283	617	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	617	17	may	may	MD
22283	617	18	simplify	simplify	VB
22283	617	19	matters	matter	NNS
22283	617	20	by	by	IN
22283	617	21	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	617	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	617	23	sum	sum	NN
22283	617	24	as	as	IN
22283	617	25	a	a	DT
22283	617	26	single	single	JJ
22283	617	27	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	617	28	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	617	29	_	_	NNP
22283	617	30	x	x	NNP
22283	617	31	_	_	NNP
22283	617	32	,	,	,
22283	617	33	which	which	WDT
22283	617	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	617	35	take	take	VBP
22283	617	36	to	to	TO
22283	617	37	be	be	VB
22283	617	38	substantially	substantially	RB
22283	617	39	identical	identical	JJ
22283	617	40	with	with	IN
22283	617	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	617	42	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	617	43	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	617	44	known	know	VBN
22283	617	45	as	as	IN
22283	617	46	_	_	NNP
22283	617	47	z	z	NNP
22283	617	48	_	_	NNP
22283	617	49	.	.	.
22283	618	1	Here	here	RB
22283	618	2	,	,	,
22283	618	3	then	then	RB
22283	618	4	,	,	,
22283	618	5	are	be	VBP
22283	618	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	618	7	data	datum	NNS
22283	618	8	.	.	.
22283	619	1	The	the	DT
22283	619	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	619	3	of	of	IN
22283	619	4	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	619	5	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	619	6	that	that	IN
22283	619	7	what	what	WP
22283	619	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	619	9	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	619	10	as	as	IN
22283	619	11	matter	matter	NN
22283	619	12	in	in	IN
22283	619	13	motion	motion	NN
22283	619	14	,	,	,
22283	619	15	_	_	NNP
22283	619	16	x	x	NNP
22283	619	17	_	_	NNP
22283	619	18	,	,	,
22283	619	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	619	20	the	the	DT
22283	619	21	obverse	obverse	NN
22283	619	22	of	of	IN
22283	619	23	what	what	WP
22283	619	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	619	25	know	know	VBP
22283	619	26	as	as	IN
22283	619	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	619	28	,	,	,
22283	619	29	_	_	NNP
22283	619	30	z	z	NNP
22283	619	31	_	_	NNP
22283	619	32	.	.	.
22283	620	1	What	what	WP
22283	620	2	,	,	,
22283	620	3	then	then	RB
22283	620	4	,	,	,
22283	620	5	do	do	VBP
22283	620	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	620	7	know	know	VB
22283	620	8	of	of	IN
22283	620	9	_	_	NNP
22283	620	10	z	z	NNP
22283	620	11	_	_	NNP
22283	620	12	?	?	.
22283	621	1	In	in	IN
22283	621	2	the	the	DT
22283	621	3	first	first	JJ
22283	621	4	place	place	NN
22283	621	5	,	,	,
22283	621	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	621	7	well	well	RB
22283	621	8	know	know	VBP
22283	621	9	that	that	IN
22283	621	10	this	this	DT
22283	621	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	621	12	the	the	DT
22283	621	13	only	only	JJ
22283	621	14	entity	entity	NN
22283	621	15	with	with	IN
22283	621	16	which	which	WDT
22283	621	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	621	18	are	be	VBP
22283	621	19	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
22283	621	20	,	,	,
22283	621	21	so	so	RB
22283	621	22	to	to	TO
22283	621	23	speak	speak	VB
22283	621	24	,	,	,
22283	621	25	at	at	IN
22283	621	26	first	first	JJ
22283	621	27	hand	hand	NN
22283	621	28	;	;	:
22283	621	29	all	all	DT
22283	621	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	621	31	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	621	32	of	of	IN
22283	621	33	_	_	NNP
22283	621	34	x	x	SYM
22283	621	35	_	_	NNP
22283	621	36	(	(	-LRB-
22283	621	37	which	which	WDT
22283	621	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	621	39	the	the	DT
22283	621	40	only	only	JJ
22283	621	41	other	other	JJ
22283	621	42	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	621	43	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	621	44	possess	possess	VBP
22283	621	45	)	)	-RRB-
22283	621	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	621	47	possible	possible	JJ
22283	621	48	only	only	RB
22283	621	49	in	in	IN
22283	621	50	so	so	RB
22283	621	51	far	far	RB
22283	621	52	as	as	IN
22283	621	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	621	54	are	be	VBP
22283	621	55	able	able	JJ
22283	621	56	to	to	TO
22283	621	57	translate	translate	VB
22283	621	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	621	59	into	into	IN
22283	621	60	terms	term	NNS
22283	621	61	of	of	IN
22283	621	62	_	_	NNP
22283	621	63	z	z	NNP
22283	621	64	_	_	NNP
22283	621	65	.	.	.
22283	622	1	In	in	IN
22283	622	2	the	the	DT
22283	622	3	next	next	JJ
22283	622	4	place	place	NN
22283	622	5	,	,	,
22283	622	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	622	7	know	know	VBP
22283	622	8	that	that	IN
22283	622	9	_	_	NNP
22283	622	10	z	z	NNP
22283	622	11	_	_	NNP
22283	622	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	622	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	622	14	an	an	DT
22283	622	15	entity	entity	NN
22283	622	16	of	of	IN
22283	622	17	the	the	DT
22283	622	18	most	most	RBS
22283	622	19	enormous	enormous	JJ
22283	622	20	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	622	21	.	.	.
22283	623	1	Standing	stand	VBG
22283	623	2	as	as	IN
22283	623	3	a	a	DT
22283	623	4	symbol	symbol	NN
22283	623	5	of	of	IN
22283	623	6	the	the	DT
22283	623	7	whole	whole	JJ
22283	623	8	range	range	NN
22283	623	9	of	of	IN
22283	623	10	individual	individual	JJ
22283	623	11	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	623	12	,	,	,
22283	623	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	623	14	may	may	MD
22283	623	15	be	be	VB
22283	623	16	said	say	VBN
22283	623	17	to	to	TO
22283	623	18	constitute	constitute	VB
22283	623	19	for	for	IN
22283	623	20	each	each	DT
22283	623	21	individual	individual	NN
22283	623	22	the	the	DT
22283	623	23	symbol	symbol	NN
22283	623	24	of	of	IN
22283	623	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	623	26	own	own	JJ
22283	623	27	personality	personality	NN
22283	623	28	--	--	:
22283	623	29	or	or	CC
22283	623	30	the	the	DT
22283	623	31	sum	sum	NN
22283	623	32	total	total	NN
22283	623	33	of	of	IN
22283	623	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	623	35	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	623	36	life	life	NN
22283	623	37	.	.	.
22283	624	1	Now	now	RB
22283	624	2	each	each	DT
22283	624	3	individual	individual	NN
22283	624	4	knows	know	VBZ
22283	624	5	by	by	IN
22283	624	6	direct	direct	JJ
22283	624	7	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	624	8	that	that	IN
22283	624	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	624	10	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	624	11	life	life	NN
22283	624	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	624	13	,	,	,
22283	624	14	as	as	IN
22283	624	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	624	16	have	have	VBP
22283	624	17	said	say	VBD
22283	624	18	,	,	,
22283	624	19	of	of	IN
22283	624	20	enormous	enormous	JJ
22283	624	21	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	624	22	,	,	,
22283	624	23	and	and	CC
22283	624	24	that	that	IN
22283	624	25	numberless	numberless	JJ
22283	624	26	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
22283	624	27	of	of	IN
22283	624	28	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	624	29	,	,	,
22283	624	30	thought	thought	NN
22283	624	31	,	,	,
22283	624	32	and	and	CC
22283	624	33	volition	volition	NN
22283	624	34	are	be	VBP
22283	624	35	therein	therein	RB
22283	624	36	combined	combine	VBN
22283	624	37	in	in	IN
22283	624	38	numberless	numberless	JJ
22283	624	39	ways	way	NNS
22283	624	40	.	.	.
22283	625	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	625	2	the	the	DT
22283	625	3	symbol	symbol	NN
22283	625	4	_	_	NNP
22283	625	5	z	z	NNP
22283	625	6	_	_	NNP
22283	625	7	may	may	MD
22283	625	8	be	be	VB
22283	625	9	considered	consider	VBN
22283	625	10	as	as	IN
22283	625	11	the	the	DT
22283	625	12	sum	sum	NN
22283	625	13	of	of	IN
22283	625	14	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
22283	625	15	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	625	16	parts	part	NNS
22283	625	17	,	,	,
22283	625	18	grouped	group	VBD
22283	625	19	_	_	NNP
22283	625	20	inter	inter	NN
22283	625	21	se	se	NNP
22283	625	22	_	_	NNP
22283	625	23	in	in	IN
22283	625	24	numberless	numberless	JJ
22283	625	25	systems	system	NNS
22283	625	26	of	of	IN
22283	625	27	more	more	RBR
22283	625	28	or	or	CC
22283	625	29	less	less	JJR
22283	625	30	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	625	31	.	.	.
22283	626	1	From	from	IN
22283	626	2	these	these	DT
22283	626	3	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	626	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	626	5	arrive	arrive	VBP
22283	626	6	at	at	IN
22283	626	7	the	the	DT
22283	626	8	following	follow	VBG
22283	626	9	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
22283	626	10	.	.	.
22283	627	1	The	the	DT
22283	627	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	627	3	of	of	IN
22283	627	4	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	627	5	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	627	6	that	that	IN
22283	627	7	all	all	DT
22283	627	8	_	_	NNP
22283	627	9	z	z	NNP
22283	627	10	_	_	NNP
22283	627	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	627	12	_	_	NNP
22283	627	13	x	x	NNP
22283	627	14	_	_	NNP
22283	627	15	;	;	:
22283	627	16	but	but	CC
22283	627	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	627	18	does	do	VBZ
22283	627	19	not	not	RB
22283	627	20	,	,	,
22283	627	21	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	627	22	,	,	,
22283	627	23	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	627	24	teach	teach	VBP
22283	627	25	that	that	IN
22283	627	26	all	all	DT
22283	627	27	_	_	NNP
22283	627	28	x	x	NNP
22283	627	29	_	_	NNP
22283	627	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	627	31	_	_	NNP
22283	627	32	z	z	NNP
22283	627	33	_	_	NNP
22283	627	34	.	.	.
22283	628	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	628	2	,	,	,
22283	628	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	628	4	does	do	VBZ
22283	628	5	teach	teach	VB
22283	628	6	that	that	IN
22283	628	7	if	if	IN
22283	628	8	all	all	DT
22283	628	9	_	_	NNP
22283	628	10	x	x	NNP
22283	628	11	_	_	NNP
22283	628	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	628	13	not	not	RB
22283	628	14	_	_	NNP
22283	628	15	z	z	NNP
22283	628	16	_	_	NNP
22283	628	17	,	,	,
22283	628	18	this	this	DT
22283	628	19	must	must	MD
22283	628	20	be	be	VB
22283	628	21	because	because	IN
22283	628	22	_	_	NNP
22283	628	23	x	x	NNP
22283	628	24	_	_	NNP
22283	628	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	628	26	_	_	NNP
22283	628	27	z	z	NNP
22283	628	28	_	_	NNP
22283	628	29	,	,	,
22283	628	30	_	_	NNP
22283	628	31	plus	plus	CC
22283	628	32	_	_	NNP
22283	628	33	something	something	NN
22283	628	34	more	more	JJR
22283	628	35	than	than	IN
22283	628	36	_	_	NNP
22283	628	37	z	z	NNP
22283	628	38	_	_	NNP
22283	628	39	,	,	,
22283	628	40	as	as	IN
22283	628	41	a	a	DT
22283	628	42	little	little	JJ
22283	628	43	thought	thought	NN
22283	628	44	will	will	MD
22283	628	45	be	be	VB
22283	628	46	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	628	47	to	to	TO
22283	628	48	show	show	VB
22283	628	49	.	.	.
22283	629	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	629	2	,	,	,
22283	629	3	the	the	DT
22283	629	4	four	four	CD
22283	629	5	annexed	annex	VBN
22283	629	6	diagrams	diagram	NNS
22283	629	7	exhaust	exhaust	VBP
22283	629	8	the	the	DT
22283	629	9	logical	logical	JJ
22283	629	10	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	629	11	of	of	IN
22283	629	12	any	any	DT
22283	629	13	case	case	NN
22283	629	14	,	,	,
22283	629	15	where	where	WRB
22283	629	16	the	the	DT
22283	629	17	question	question	NN
22283	629	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	629	19	as	as	IN
22283	629	20	to	to	IN
22283	629	21	the	the	DT
22283	629	22	inclusion	inclusion	NN
22283	629	23	or	or	CC
22283	629	24	exclusion	exclusion	NN
22283	629	25	of	of	IN
22283	629	26	one	one	CD
22283	629	27	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	629	28	by	by	IN
22283	629	29	another	another	DT
22283	629	30	.	.	.
22283	630	1	In	in	IN
22283	630	2	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	630	3	.	.	.
22283	631	1	1	1	CD
22283	631	2	the	the	DT
22283	631	3	two	two	CD
22283	631	4	quantities	quantity	NNS
22283	631	5	are	be	VBP
22283	631	6	coincident	coincident	JJ
22283	631	7	;	;	:
22283	631	8	in	in	IN
22283	631	9	Fig	fig	NN
22283	631	10	2	2	CD
22283	631	11	the	the	DT
22283	631	12	one	one	NN
22283	631	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	631	14	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	631	15	included	include	VBN
22283	631	16	by	by	IN
22283	631	17	the	the	DT
22283	631	18	other	other	JJ
22283	631	19	;	;	:
22283	631	20	in	in	IN
22283	631	21	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	631	22	.	.	.
22283	632	1	3	3	LS
22283	632	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	632	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	632	4	partially	partially	RB
22283	632	5	included	include	VBN
22283	632	6	;	;	:
22283	632	7	and	and	CC
22283	632	8	in	in	IN
22283	632	9	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	632	10	.	.	.
22283	633	1	4	4	CD
22283	633	2	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	633	3	excluded	exclude	VBN
22283	633	4	.	.	.
22283	634	1	Now	now	RB
22283	634	2	in	in	IN
22283	634	3	the	the	DT
22283	634	4	present	present	JJ
22283	634	5	case	case	NN
22283	634	6	,	,	,
22283	634	7	and	and	CC
22283	634	8	upon	upon	IN
22283	634	9	the	the	DT
22283	634	10	data	datum	NNS
22283	634	11	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	634	12	,	,	,
22283	634	13	the	the	DT
22283	634	14	logical	logical	JJ
22283	634	15	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	634	16	are	be	VBP
22283	634	17	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
22283	634	18	by	by	IN
22283	634	19	Figs	fig	NNS
22283	634	20	.	.	.
22283	635	1	1	1	CD
22283	635	2	and	and	CC
22283	635	3	2	2	CD
22283	635	4	.	.	.
22283	636	1	For	for	IN
22283	636	2	,	,	,
22283	636	3	upon	upon	IN
22283	636	4	these	these	DT
22283	636	5	data	datum	NNS
22283	636	6	,	,	,
22283	636	7	Figs	fig	NNS
22283	636	8	.	.	.
22283	637	1	3	3	CD
22283	637	2	and	and	CC
22283	637	3	4	4	CD
22283	637	4	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	637	5	represent	represent	VB
22283	637	6	logical	logical	JJ
22283	637	7	impossibilities	impossibility	NNS
22283	637	8	;	;	:
22283	637	9	no	no	DT
22283	637	10	part	part	NN
22283	637	11	of	of	IN
22283	637	12	Mind	mind	NN
22283	637	13	can	can	MD
22283	637	14	,	,	,
22283	637	15	according	accord	VBG
22283	637	16	to	to	IN
22283	637	17	these	these	DT
22283	637	18	data	datum	NNS
22283	637	19	,	,	,
22283	637	20	stand	stand	VB
22283	637	21	outside	outside	IN
22283	637	22	the	the	DT
22283	637	23	limits	limit	NNS
22283	637	24	of	of	IN
22283	637	25	Matter	Matter	NNP
22283	637	26	and	and	CC
22283	637	27	Motion	Motion	NNP
22283	637	28	.	.	.
22283	638	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	638	2	,	,	,
22283	638	3	if	if	IN
22283	638	4	the	the	DT
22283	638	5	Ego	Ego	NNP
22283	638	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	638	7	not	not	RB
22283	638	8	coincident	coincident	JJ
22283	638	9	with	with	IN
22283	638	10	the	the	DT
22283	638	11	Non	Non	NNP
22283	638	12	-	-	JJ
22283	638	13	ego	ego	JJ
22283	638	14	(	(	-LRB-
22283	638	15	or	or	CC
22283	638	16	if	if	IN
22283	638	17	all	all	DT
22283	638	18	_	_	NNP
22283	638	19	x	x	NNP
22283	638	20	_	_	NNP
22283	638	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	638	22	not	not	RB
22283	638	23	_	_	NNP
22283	638	24	z	z	NNP
22283	638	25	_	_	NNP
22283	638	26	,	,	,
22283	638	27	as	as	IN
22283	638	28	in	in	IN
22283	638	29	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	638	30	.	.	.
22283	639	1	1	1	LS
22283	639	2	)	)	-RRB-
22283	639	3	,	,	,
22283	639	4	this	this	DT
22283	639	5	can	can	MD
22283	639	6	only	only	RB
22283	639	7	be	be	VB
22283	639	8	because	because	IN
22283	639	9	the	the	DT
22283	639	10	Ego	Ego	NNP
22283	639	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	639	12	less	less	RBR
22283	639	13	extensive	extensive	JJ
22283	639	14	than	than	IN
22283	639	15	the	the	DT
22283	639	16	Non	Non	NNP
22283	639	17	-	-	JJ
22283	639	18	ego	ego	JJ
22283	639	19	(	(	-LRB-
22283	639	20	or	or	CC
22283	639	21	because	because	IN
22283	639	22	_	_	NNP
22283	639	23	x	x	NNP
22283	639	24	_	_	NNP
22283	639	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	639	26	_	_	NNP
22283	639	27	z	z	NNP
22283	639	28	plus	plus	CC
22283	639	29	_	_	NNP
22283	639	30	something	something	NN
22283	639	31	more	more	JJR
22283	639	32	than	than	IN
22283	639	33	_	_	NNP
22283	639	34	z	z	NNP
22283	639	35	_	_	NNP
22283	639	36	,	,	,
22283	639	37	as	as	IN
22283	639	38	in	in	IN
22283	639	39	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	639	40	.	.	.
22283	640	1	2	2	LS
22283	640	2	)	)	-RRB-
22283	640	3	.	.	.
22283	641	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	641	2	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	641	3	:	:	:
22283	641	4	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	641	5	.	.	.
22283	642	1	1	1	LS
22283	642	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	642	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	642	4	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	642	5	:	:	:
22283	642	6	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	642	7	.	.	.
22283	643	1	2	2	LS
22283	643	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	643	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	643	4	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	643	5	:	:	:
22283	643	6	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	643	7	.	.	.
22283	644	1	3	3	LS
22283	644	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	644	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	644	4	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	644	5	:	:	:
22283	644	6	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	644	7	.	.	.
22283	645	1	4	4	LS
22283	645	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	645	3	Of	of	IN
22283	645	4	these	these	DT
22283	645	5	two	two	CD
22283	645	6	logical	logical	JJ
22283	645	7	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	645	8	Idealism	Idealism	NNP
22283	645	9	,	,	,
22283	645	10	in	in	IN
22283	645	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	645	12	most	most	RBS
22283	645	13	extreme	extreme	JJ
22283	645	14	form	form	NN
22283	645	15	,	,	,
22283	645	16	may	may	MD
22283	645	17	adopt	adopt	VB
22283	645	18	the	the	DT
22283	645	19	first	first	JJ
22283	645	20	.	.	.
22283	646	1	For	for	IN
22283	646	2	Idealism	idealism	NN
22283	646	3	in	in	IN
22283	646	4	this	this	DT
22283	646	5	form	form	NN
22283	646	6	may	may	MD
22283	646	7	hold	hold	VB
22283	646	8	that	that	IN
22283	646	9	apart	apart	RB
22283	646	10	from	from	IN
22283	646	11	the	the	DT
22283	646	12	Ego	Ego	NNP
22283	646	13	there	there	EX
22283	646	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	646	15	no	no	DT
22283	646	16	external	external	JJ
22283	646	17	world	world	NN
22283	646	18	;	;	:
22283	646	19	that	that	IN
22283	646	20	outside	outside	IN
22283	646	21	of	of	IN
22283	646	22	_	_	NNP
22283	646	23	z	z	NNP
22283	646	24	_	_	NNP
22283	646	25	there	there	EX
22283	646	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	646	27	no	no	DT
22283	646	28	_	_	NNP
22283	646	29	x	x	NNP
22283	646	30	_	_	NNP
22283	646	31	;	;	:
22283	646	32	that	that	IN
22283	646	33	the	the	DT
22283	646	34	only	only	JJ
22283	646	35	_	_	NNP
22283	646	36	esse	esse	NNP
22283	646	37	_	_	NNP
22283	646	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	646	39	the	the	DT
22283	646	40	_	_	NNP
22283	646	41	percipi	percipi	NN
22283	646	42	_	_	NNP
22283	646	43	.	.	.
22283	647	1	But	but	CC
22283	647	2	,	,	,
22283	647	3	as	as	IN
22283	647	4	very	very	RB
22283	647	5	few	few	JJ
22283	647	6	persons	person	NNS
22283	647	7	nowadays	nowadays	RB
22283	647	8	are	be	VBP
22283	647	9	prepared	prepared	JJ
22283	647	10	to	to	TO
22283	647	11	go	go	VB
22283	647	12	the	the	DT
22283	647	13	length	length	NN
22283	647	14	of	of	IN
22283	647	15	seriously	seriously	RB
22283	647	16	maintaining	maintain	VBG
22283	647	17	that	that	DT
22283	647	18	in	in	IN
22283	647	19	actual	actual	JJ
22283	647	20	fact	fact	NN
22283	647	21	there	there	EX
22283	647	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	647	23	no	no	DT
22283	647	24	external	external	JJ
22283	647	25	world	world	NN
22283	647	26	save	save	VB
22283	647	27	in	in	IN
22283	647	28	so	so	RB
22283	647	29	far	far	RB
22283	647	30	as	as	IN
22283	647	31	this	this	DT
22283	647	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	647	33	perceived	perceive	VBN
22283	647	34	by	by	IN
22283	647	35	the	the	DT
22283	647	36	individual	individual	JJ
22283	647	37	mind	mind	NN
22283	647	38	,	,	,
22283	647	39	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	647	40	need	need	VBP
22283	647	41	not	not	RB
22283	647	42	wait	wait	VB
22283	647	43	to	to	TO
22283	647	44	consider	consider	VB
22283	647	45	this	this	DT
22283	647	46	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	647	47	.	.	.
22283	648	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	648	2	are	be	VBP
22283	648	3	thus	thus	RB
22283	648	4	practically	practically	RB
22283	648	5	shut	shut	VBN
22283	648	6	up	up	RP
22283	648	7	to	to	IN
22283	648	8	a	a	DT
22283	648	9	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	648	10	of	of	IN
22283	648	11	the	the	DT
22283	648	12	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	648	13	marked	mark	VBD
22283	648	14	2	2	CD
22283	648	15	.	.	.
22283	649	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	649	2	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	649	3	:	:	:
22283	649	4	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	649	5	.	.	.
22283	650	1	5	5	LS
22283	650	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	650	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	650	4	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	650	5	:	:	:
22283	650	6	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	650	7	.	.	.
22283	651	1	6	6	LS
22283	651	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	651	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	651	4	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	651	5	:	:	:
22283	651	6	Fig	Fig	NNP
22283	651	7	.	.	.
22283	652	1	7	7	LS
22283	652	2	]	]	-RRB-
22283	652	3	The	the	DT
22283	652	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	652	5	of	of	IN
22283	652	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	652	7	,	,	,
22283	652	8	then	then	RB
22283	652	9	,	,	,
22283	652	10	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	652	11	that	that	IN
22283	652	12	_	_	NNP
22283	652	13	x	x	NNP
22283	652	14	_	_	NNP
22283	652	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	652	16	_	_	NNP
22283	652	17	z	z	NNP
22283	652	18	_	_	NNP
22283	652	19	_	_	NNP
22283	652	20	plus	plus	CC
22283	652	21	_	_	NNP
22283	652	22	something	something	NN
22283	652	23	more	more	JJR
22283	652	24	than	than	IN
22283	652	25	_	_	NNP
22283	652	26	z	z	NNP
22283	652	27	_	_	NNP
22283	652	28	;	;	:
22283	652	29	and	and	CC
22283	652	30	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	652	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	652	32	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	652	33	a	a	DT
22283	652	34	matter	matter	NN
22283	652	35	of	of	IN
22283	652	36	great	great	JJ
22283	652	37	moment	moment	NN
22283	652	38	to	to	TO
22283	652	39	consider	consider	VB
22283	652	40	the	the	DT
22283	652	41	probable	probable	JJ
22283	652	42	nature	nature	NN
22283	652	43	of	of	IN
22283	652	44	the	the	DT
22283	652	45	overplus	overplus	NN
22283	652	46	.	.	.
22283	653	1	For	for	IN
22283	653	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	653	3	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	653	4	does	do	VBZ
22283	653	5	not	not	RB
22283	653	6	follow	follow	VB
22283	653	7	that	that	DT
22283	653	8	because	because	IN
22283	653	9	_	_	NNP
22283	653	10	x	x	NNP
22283	653	11	_	_	NNP
22283	653	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	653	13	greater	great	JJR
22283	653	14	than	than	IN
22283	653	15	_	_	NNP
22283	653	16	z	z	NNP
22283	653	17	_	_	NNP
22283	653	18	in	in	IN
22283	653	19	a	a	DT
22283	653	20	logical	logical	JJ
22283	653	21	sense	sense	NN
22283	653	22	,	,	,
22283	653	23	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	653	24	_	_	NNP
22283	653	25	x	x	NNP
22283	653	26	_	_	NNP
22283	653	27	must	must	MD
22283	653	28	be	be	VB
22283	653	29	greater	great	JJR
22283	653	30	than	than	IN
22283	653	31	_	_	NNP
22283	653	32	z	z	NNP
22283	653	33	_	_	NNP
22283	653	34	in	in	IN
22283	653	35	a	a	DT
22283	653	36	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	653	37	sense	sense	NN
22283	653	38	.	.	.
22283	654	1	Save	save	VB
22283	654	2	upon	upon	IN
22283	654	3	the	the	DT
22283	654	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	654	5	of	of	IN
22283	654	6	Idealism	Idealism	NNP
22283	654	7	(	(	-LRB-
22283	654	8	with	with	IN
22283	654	9	which	which	WDT
22283	654	10	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	654	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	654	12	not	not	RB
22283	654	13	specially	specially	RB
22283	654	14	concerned	concerned	JJ
22283	654	15	)	)	-RRB-
22283	654	16	the	the	DT
22283	654	17	amount	amount	NN
22283	654	18	(	(	-LRB-
22283	654	19	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	654	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	654	21	may	may	MD
22283	654	22	be	be	VB
22283	654	23	)	)	-RRB-
22283	654	24	wherein	wherein	WRB
22283	654	25	_	_	NNP
22283	654	26	x	x	NNP
22283	654	27	_	_	NNP
22283	654	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	654	29	greater	great	JJR
22283	654	30	than	than	IN
22283	654	31	_	_	NNP
22283	654	32	z	z	NNP
22283	654	33	_	_	NNP
22283	654	34	,	,	,
22283	654	35	may	may	MD
22283	654	36	not	not	RB
22283	654	37	present	present	VB
22283	654	38	any	any	DT
22283	654	39	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	654	40	signification	signification	NN
22283	654	41	at	at	RB
22283	654	42	all	all	RB
22283	654	43	.	.	.
22283	655	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	655	2	may	may	MD
22283	655	3	find	find	VB
22283	655	4	that	that	IN
22283	655	5	the	the	DT
22283	655	6	surface	surface	NN
22283	655	7	of	of	IN
22283	655	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	655	9	globe	globe	NN
22283	655	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	655	11	considerably	considerably	RB
22283	655	12	larger	large	JJR
22283	655	13	than	than	IN
22283	655	14	that	that	DT
22283	655	15	of	of	IN
22283	655	16	the	the	DT
22283	655	17	dry	dry	JJ
22283	655	18	land	land	NN
22283	655	19	,	,	,
22283	655	20	and	and	CC
22283	655	21	yet	yet	RB
22283	655	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	655	23	may	may	MD
22283	655	24	not	not	RB
22283	655	25	follow	follow	VB
22283	655	26	that	that	IN
22283	655	27	the	the	DT
22283	655	28	mental	mental	JJ
22283	655	29	-	-	HYPH
22283	655	30	life	life	NN
22283	655	31	to	to	TO
22283	655	32	be	be	VB
22283	655	33	met	meet	VBN
22283	655	34	with	with	IN
22283	655	35	in	in	IN
22283	655	36	the	the	DT
22283	655	37	sea	sea	NN
22283	655	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	655	39	psychologically	psychologically	RB
22283	655	40	superior	superior	JJ
22283	655	41	to	to	IN
22283	655	42	that	that	DT
22283	655	43	which	which	WDT
22283	655	44	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	655	45	on	on	IN
22283	655	46	dry	dry	JJ
22283	655	47	land	land	NN
22283	655	48	.	.	.
22283	656	1	If	if	IN
22283	656	2	,	,	,
22283	656	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	656	4	,	,	,
22283	656	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	656	6	represent	represent	VBP
22283	656	7	by	by	IN
22283	656	8	comparative	comparative	JJ
22283	656	9	shading	shade	VBG
22283	656	10	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	656	11	of	of	IN
22283	656	12	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	656	13	excellence	excellence	NN
22283	656	14	,	,	,
22283	656	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	656	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	656	17	evident	evident	JJ
22283	656	18	that	that	IN
22283	656	19	the	the	DT
22283	656	20	theory	theory	NN
22283	656	21	of	of	IN
22283	656	22	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	656	23	must	must	MD
22283	656	24	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	656	25	the	the	DT
22283	656	26	three	three	CD
22283	656	27	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	656	28	indicated	indicate	VBD
22283	656	29	diagrammatically	diagrammatically	RB
22283	656	30	in	in	IN
22283	656	31	Figs	Figs	NNP
22283	656	32	.	.	.
22283	657	1	5	5	CD
22283	657	2	,	,	,
22283	657	3	6	6	CD
22283	657	4	,	,	,
22283	657	5	and	and	CC
22283	657	6	7	7	CD
22283	657	7	.	.	.
22283	658	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	658	2	makes	make	VBZ
22283	658	3	no	no	DT
22283	658	4	difference	difference	NN
22283	658	5	what	what	WP
22283	658	6	the	the	DT
22283	658	7	comparative	comparative	JJ
22283	658	8	areas	area	NNS
22283	658	9	of	of	IN
22283	658	10	_	_	NNP
22283	658	11	x	x	NNP
22283	658	12	_	_	NNP
22283	658	13	and	and	CC
22283	658	14	_	_	NNP
22283	658	15	z	z	NNP
22283	658	16	_	_	NNP
22283	658	17	may	may	MD
22283	658	18	be	be	VB
22283	658	19	,	,	,
22283	658	20	or	or	CC
22283	658	21	whether	whether	IN
22283	658	22	_	_	NNP
22283	658	23	x	x	NNP
22283	658	24	_	_	NNP
22283	658	25	be	be	VB
22283	658	26	uniformly	uniformly	RB
22283	658	27	shaded	shade	VBN
22283	658	28	throughout	throughout	IN
22283	658	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	658	30	extent	extent	NN
22283	658	31	.	.	.
22283	659	1	All	all	DT
22283	659	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	659	3	have	have	VBP
22283	659	4	so	so	RB
22283	659	5	far	far	RB
22283	659	6	to	to	TO
22283	659	7	notice	notice	VB
22283	659	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	659	9	that	that	IN
22283	659	10	the	the	DT
22283	659	11	fact	fact	NN
22283	659	12	of	of	IN
22283	659	13	logical	logical	JJ
22283	659	14	inclusion	inclusion	NN
22283	659	15	does	do	VBZ
22283	659	16	not	not	RB
22283	659	17	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	659	18	carry	carry	VB
22283	659	19	with	with	IN
22283	659	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	659	21	the	the	DT
22283	659	22	implication	implication	NN
22283	659	23	of	of	IN
22283	659	24	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	659	25	superiority	superiority	NN
22283	659	26	.	.	.
22283	660	1	Next	next	RB
22283	660	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	660	3	must	must	MD
22283	660	4	notice	notice	VB
22283	660	5	that	that	IN
22283	660	6	besides	besides	IN
22283	660	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	660	8	own	own	JJ
22283	660	9	subjectivities	subjectivity	NNS
22283	660	10	,	,	,
22283	660	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	660	12	have	have	VBP
22283	660	13	cognizance	cognizance	NN
22283	660	14	of	of	IN
22283	660	15	being	be	VBG
22283	660	16	surrounded	surround	VBN
22283	660	17	by	by	IN
22283	660	18	many	many	JJ
22283	660	19	other	other	JJ
22283	660	20	inferred	inferred	JJ
22283	660	21	subjectivities	subjectivity	NNS
22283	660	22	more	more	RBR
22283	660	23	or	or	CC
22283	660	24	less	less	RBR
22283	660	25	like	like	UH
22283	660	26	in	in	IN
22283	660	27	kind	kind	NN
22283	660	28	(	(	-LRB-
22283	660	29	i.	i.	NNP
22283	660	30	e.	e.	NNP
22283	660	31	other	other	JJ
22283	660	32	human	human	JJ
22283	660	33	minds	mind	NNS
22283	660	34	)	)	-RRB-
22283	660	35	;	;	:
22283	660	36	and	and	CC
22283	660	37	also	also	RB
22283	660	38	yet	yet	RB
22283	660	39	many	many	JJ
22283	660	40	other	other	JJ
22283	660	41	inferred	inferred	JJ
22283	660	42	subjectivities	subjectivity	NNS
22283	660	43	more	more	RBR
22283	660	44	or	or	CC
22283	660	45	less	less	RBR
22283	660	46	unlike	unlike	JJ
22283	660	47	,	,	,
22283	660	48	but	but	CC
22283	660	49	all	all	DT
22283	660	50	inferior	inferior	JJ
22283	660	51	(	(	-LRB-
22283	660	52	i.	i.	NNP
22283	660	53	e.	e.	NNP
22283	660	54	the	the	DT
22283	660	55	minds	mind	NNS
22283	660	56	of	of	IN
22283	660	57	lower	low	JJR
22283	660	58	animals	animal	NNS
22283	660	59	,	,	,
22283	660	60	young	young	JJ
22283	660	61	children	child	NNS
22283	660	62	,	,	,
22283	660	63	and	and	CC
22283	660	64	idiots	idiot	NNS
22283	660	65	)	)	-RRB-
22283	660	66	.	.	.
22283	661	1	Following	follow	VBG
22283	661	2	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	661	3	,	,	,
22283	661	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	661	5	will	will	MD
22283	661	6	call	call	VB
22283	661	7	these	these	DT
22283	661	8	inferred	infer	VBN
22283	661	9	subjectivities	subjectivity	NNS
22283	661	10	by	by	IN
22283	661	11	the	the	DT
22283	661	12	name	name	NN
22283	661	13	of	of	IN
22283	661	14	ejects	eject	NNS
22283	661	15	,	,	,
22283	661	16	and	and	CC
22283	661	17	assign	assign	VB
22283	661	18	to	to	IN
22283	661	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	661	20	the	the	DT
22283	661	21	symbol	symbol	NN
22283	661	22	_	_	NNP
22283	661	23	y	y	NNP
22283	661	24	_	_	NNP
22283	661	25	.	.	.
22283	662	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	662	2	,	,	,
22283	662	3	in	in	IN
22283	662	4	the	the	DT
22283	662	5	following	follow	VBG
22283	662	6	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	662	7	,	,	,
22283	662	8	_	_	NNP
22283	662	9	x	x	NNP
22283	662	10	_	_	NNP
22283	662	11	=	=	SYM
22283	662	12	the	the	DT
22283	662	13	objective	objective	JJ
22283	662	14	world	world	NN
22283	662	15	,	,	,
22283	662	16	_	_	NNP
22283	662	17	y	y	NNP
22283	662	18	_	_	NNP
22283	662	19	=	=	SYM
22283	662	20	the	the	DT
22283	662	21	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	662	22	world	world	NN
22283	662	23	,	,	,
22283	662	24	and	and	CC
22283	662	25	_	_	NNP
22283	662	26	z	z	NNP
22283	662	27	_	_	NNP
22283	662	28	=	=	SYM
22283	662	29	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	662	30	world	world	NN
22283	662	31	.	.	.
22283	663	1	Now	now	RB
22283	663	2	,	,	,
22283	663	3	the	the	DT
22283	663	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	663	5	of	of	IN
22283	663	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	663	7	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	663	8	that	that	IN
22283	663	9	_	_	NNP
22283	663	10	x	x	NNP
22283	663	11	_	_	NNP
22283	663	12	,	,	,
22283	663	13	_	_	NNP
22283	663	14	y	y	NNP
22283	663	15	_	_	NNP
22283	663	16	,	,	,
22283	663	17	and	and	CC
22283	663	18	_	_	NNP
22283	663	19	z	z	NNP
22283	663	20	_	_	NNP
22283	663	21	are	be	VBP
22283	663	22	all	all	RB
22283	663	23	alike	alike	RB
22283	663	24	in	in	IN
22283	663	25	kind	kind	NN
22283	663	26	,	,	,
22283	663	27	but	but	CC
22283	663	28	present	present	VB
22283	663	29	no	no	DT
22283	663	30	definite	definite	JJ
22283	663	31	teaching	teaching	NN
22283	663	32	as	as	IN
22283	663	33	to	to	IN
22283	663	34	how	how	WRB
22283	663	35	far	far	RB
22283	663	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	663	37	may	may	MD
22283	663	38	differ	differ	VB
22283	663	39	in	in	IN
22283	663	40	degree	degree	NN
22283	663	41	.	.	.
22283	664	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	664	2	may	may	MD
22283	664	3	,	,	,
22283	664	4	however	however	RB
22283	664	5	,	,	,
22283	664	6	at	at	IN
22283	664	7	once	once	RB
22283	664	8	allow	allow	VB
22283	664	9	that	that	IN
22283	664	10	between	between	IN
22283	664	11	the	the	DT
22283	664	12	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	664	13	value	value	NN
22283	664	14	of	of	IN
22283	664	15	_	_	NNP
22283	664	16	z	z	NNP
22283	664	17	_	_	NNP
22283	664	18	and	and	CC
22283	664	19	that	that	DT
22283	664	20	of	of	IN
22283	664	21	_	_	NNP
22283	664	22	y	y	NNP
22283	664	23	_	_	NNP
22283	664	24	there	there	EX
22283	664	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	664	26	a	a	DT
22283	664	27	wide	wide	JJ
22283	664	28	difference	difference	NN
22283	664	29	of	of	IN
22283	664	30	degree	degree	NN
22283	664	31	;	;	:
22283	664	32	and	and	CC
22283	664	33	also	also	RB
22283	664	34	that	that	IN
22283	664	35	,	,	,
22283	664	36	while	while	IN
22283	664	37	the	the	DT
22283	664	38	value	value	NN
22283	664	39	of	of	IN
22283	664	40	_	_	NNP
22283	664	41	z	z	NNP
22283	664	42	_	_	NNP
22283	664	43	is	be	VBZ
22283	664	44	a	a	DT
22283	664	45	fixed	fix	VBN
22283	664	46	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	664	47	,	,	,
22283	664	48	that	that	DT
22283	664	49	of	of	IN
22283	664	50	_	_	NNP
22283	664	51	y	y	NNP
22283	664	52	_	_	NNP
22283	664	53	varies	vary	VBZ
22283	664	54	greatly	greatly	RB
22283	664	55	in	in	IN
22283	664	56	the	the	DT
22283	664	57	different	different	JJ
22283	664	58	parts	part	NNS
22283	664	59	of	of	IN
22283	664	60	the	the	DT
22283	664	61	area	area	NN
22283	664	62	_	_	NNP
22283	664	63	y	y	NNP
22283	664	64	_	_	NNP
22283	664	65	.	.	.
22283	665	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	665	2	scheme	scheme	NN
22283	665	3	,	,	,
22283	665	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	665	5	,	,	,
22283	665	6	will	will	MD
22283	665	7	now	now	RB
22283	665	8	adopt	adopt	VB
22283	665	9	this	this	DT
22283	665	10	form--	form--	JJ
22283	665	11	[	[	-LRB-
22283	665	12	Illustration	illustration	NN
22283	665	13	]	]	-RRB-
22283	665	14	But	but	CC
22283	665	15	the	the	DT
22283	665	16	important	important	JJ
22283	665	17	question	question	NN
22283	665	18	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	665	19	how	how	WRB
22283	665	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	665	21	ought	ought	MD
22283	665	22	to	to	TO
22283	665	23	shade	shade	VB
22283	665	24	_	_	NNP
22283	665	25	x	x	NNP
22283	665	26	_	_	NNP
22283	665	27	.	.	.
22283	666	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	666	2	to	to	IN
22283	666	3	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	666	4	,	,	,
22283	666	5	this	this	DT
22283	666	6	ought	ought	MD
22283	666	7	scarcely	scarcely	RB
22283	666	8	to	to	TO
22283	666	9	be	be	VB
22283	666	10	shaded	shade	VBN
22283	666	11	at	at	RB
22283	666	12	all	all	RB
22283	666	13	,	,	,
22283	666	14	while	while	IN
22283	666	15	according	accord	VBG
22283	666	16	to	to	IN
22283	666	17	theologians	theologian	NNS
22283	666	18	(	(	-LRB-
22283	666	19	and	and	CC
22283	666	20	theists	theist	NNS
22283	666	21	generally	generally	RB
22283	666	22	)	)	-RRB-
22283	666	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	666	24	ought	ought	MD
22283	666	25	to	to	TO
22283	666	26	be	be	VB
22283	666	27	shaded	shade	VBN
22283	666	28	so	so	RB
22283	666	29	much	much	RB
22283	666	30	more	more	RBR
22283	666	31	deeply	deeply	RB
22283	666	32	than	than	IN
22283	666	33	either	either	CC
22283	666	34	_	_	NNP
22283	666	35	y	y	NNP
22283	666	36	_	_	NNP
22283	666	37	or	or	CC
22283	666	38	_	_	NNP
22283	666	39	z	z	NNP
22283	666	40	_	_	NNP
22283	666	41	,	,	,
22283	666	42	that	that	IN
22283	666	43	the	the	DT
22283	666	44	joint	joint	JJ
22283	666	45	representation	representation	NN
22283	666	46	in	in	IN
22283	666	47	one	one	CD
22283	666	48	diagram	diagram	NN
22283	666	49	would	would	MD
22283	666	50	only	only	RB
22283	666	51	be	be	VB
22283	666	52	possible	possible	JJ
22283	666	53	by	by	IN
22283	666	54	choosing	choose	VBG
22283	666	55	for	for	IN
22283	666	56	the	the	DT
22283	666	57	shading	shading	NN
22283	666	58	of	of	IN
22283	666	59	_	_	NNP
22283	666	60	x	x	SYM
22283	666	61	_	_	NNP
22283	666	62	a	a	DT
22283	666	63	colour	colour	NN
22283	666	64	different	different	JJ
22283	666	65	from	from	IN
22283	666	66	that	that	DT
22283	666	67	employed	employ	VBN
22283	666	68	for	for	IN
22283	666	69	_	_	NNP
22283	666	70	y	y	NNP
22283	666	71	_	_	NNP
22283	666	72	and	and	CC
22283	666	73	_	_	NNP
22283	666	74	z	z	NNP
22283	666	75	_	_	NNP
22283	666	76	,	,	,
22283	666	77	and	and	CC
22283	666	78	assigning	assigning	NN
22283	666	79	to	to	IN
22283	666	80	that	that	DT
22283	666	81	colour	colour	NN
22283	666	82	a	a	DT
22283	666	83	representative	representative	JJ
22283	666	84	value	value	NN
22283	666	85	higher	high	JJR
22283	666	86	than	than	IN
22283	666	87	that	that	DT
22283	666	88	assigned	assign	VBN
22283	666	89	to	to	IN
22283	666	90	the	the	DT
22283	666	91	other	other	JJ
22283	666	92	in	in	IN
22283	666	93	the	the	DT
22283	666	94	ratio	ratio	NN
22283	666	95	of	of	IN
22283	666	96	one	one	CD
22283	666	97	to	to	IN
22283	666	98	infinity	infinity	NN
22283	666	99	.	.	.
22283	667	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	667	2	will	will	MD
22283	667	3	be	be	VB
22283	667	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	667	5	object	object	NN
22283	667	6	to	to	TO
22283	667	7	estimate	estimate	VB
22283	667	8	the	the	DT
22283	667	9	relative	relative	JJ
22283	667	10	probability	probability	NN
22283	667	11	of	of	IN
22283	667	12	these	these	DT
22283	667	13	rival	rival	JJ
22283	667	14	estimates	estimate	NNS
22283	667	15	of	of	IN
22283	667	16	the	the	DT
22283	667	17	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	667	18	value	value	NN
22283	667	19	of	of	IN
22283	667	20	_	_	NNP
22283	667	21	x	x	NNP
22283	667	22	_	_	NNP
22283	667	23	.	.	.
22283	668	1	Starting	start	VBG
22283	668	2	from	from	IN
22283	668	3	_	_	NNP
22283	668	4	z	z	NNP
22283	668	5	_	_	NNP
22283	668	6	as	as	IN
22283	668	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	668	8	centre	centre	NN
22283	668	9	,	,	,
22283	668	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	668	11	know	know	VBP
22283	668	12	that	that	IN
22283	668	13	this	this	DT
22283	668	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	668	15	an	an	DT
22283	668	16	isolated	isolated	JJ
22283	668	17	system	system	NN
22283	668	18	of	of	IN
22283	668	19	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	668	20	,	,	,
22283	668	21	and	and	CC
22283	668	22	hence	hence	RB
22283	668	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	668	24	infer	infer	VBP
22283	668	25	that	that	IN
22283	668	26	all	all	DT
22283	668	27	_	_	NNP
22283	668	28	y	y	NNP
22283	668	29	_	_	NNP
22283	668	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	668	31	composed	compose	VBN
22283	668	32	of	of	IN
22283	668	33	analogous	analogous	JJ
22283	668	34	systems	system	NNS
22283	668	35	,	,	,
22283	668	36	resembling	resemble	VBG
22283	668	37	one	one	CD
22283	668	38	another	another	DT
22283	668	39	as	as	IN
22283	668	40	to	to	IN
22283	668	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	668	42	isolation	isolation	NN
22283	668	43	,	,	,
22283	668	44	and	and	CC
22283	668	45	differing	differ	VBG
22283	668	46	only	only	RB
22283	668	47	in	in	IN
22283	668	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	668	49	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	668	50	of	of	IN
22283	668	51	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	668	52	value	value	NN
22283	668	53	.	.	.
22283	669	1	Now	now	RB
22283	669	2	this	this	DT
22283	669	3	,	,	,
22283	669	4	translated	translate	VBN
22283	669	5	into	into	IN
22283	669	6	terms	term	NNS
22283	669	7	of	of	IN
22283	669	8	_	_	NNP
22283	669	9	x	x	SYM
22283	669	10	_	_	NNP
22283	669	11	(	(	-LRB-
22283	669	12	or	or	CC
22283	669	13	into	into	IN
22283	669	14	terms	term	NNS
22283	669	15	of	of	IN
22283	669	16	objectivity	objectivity	NN
22283	669	17	)	)	-RRB-
22283	669	18	means	mean	VBZ
22283	669	19	that	that	IN
22283	669	20	_	_	NNP
22283	669	21	z	z	NNP
22283	669	22	_	_	NNP
22283	669	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	669	24	an	an	DT
22283	669	25	isolated	isolated	JJ
22283	669	26	system	system	NN
22283	669	27	of	of	IN
22283	669	28	matter	matter	NN
22283	669	29	in	in	IN
22283	669	30	motion	motion	NN
22283	669	31	,	,	,
22283	669	32	and	and	CC
22283	669	33	that	that	IN
22283	669	34	the	the	DT
22283	669	35	same	same	JJ
22283	669	36	has	have	VBZ
22283	669	37	to	to	TO
22283	669	38	be	be	VB
22283	669	39	said	say	VBN
22283	669	40	of	of	IN
22283	669	41	all	all	PDT
22283	669	42	the	the	DT
22283	669	43	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	669	44	parts	part	NNS
22283	669	45	of	of	IN
22283	669	46	_	_	NNP
22283	669	47	y	y	NNP
22283	669	48	_	_	NNP
22283	669	49	.	.	.
22283	670	1	In	in	IN
22283	670	2	other	other	JJ
22283	670	3	words	word	NNS
22283	670	4	,	,	,
22283	670	5	both	both	DT
22283	670	6	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	670	7	and	and	CC
22283	670	8	ejectivity	ejectivity	NN
22283	670	9	are	be	VBP
22283	670	10	only	only	RB
22283	670	11	known	know	VBN
22283	670	12	under	under	IN
22283	670	13	the	the	DT
22283	670	14	condition	condition	NN
22283	670	15	of	of	IN
22283	670	16	being	be	VBG
22283	670	17	isolated	isolate	VBN
22283	670	18	from	from	IN
22283	670	19	objectivity	objectivity	NN
22283	670	20	;	;	:
22283	670	21	which	which	WDT
22283	670	22	,	,	,
22283	670	23	obversely	obversely	RB
22283	670	24	considered	consider	VBN
22283	670	25	,	,	,
22283	670	26	means	mean	VBZ
22283	670	27	that	that	IN
22283	670	28	the	the	DT
22283	670	29	matter	matter	NN
22283	670	30	in	in	IN
22283	670	31	motion	motion	NN
22283	670	32	here	here	RB
22283	670	33	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	670	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	670	35	temporarily	temporarily	RB
22283	670	36	separated	separate	VBN
22283	670	37	off	off	RP
22283	670	38	from	from	IN
22283	670	39	the	the	DT
22283	670	40	rest	rest	NN
22283	670	41	of	of	IN
22283	670	42	the	the	DT
22283	670	43	objective	objective	JJ
22283	670	44	world	world	NN
22283	670	45	,	,	,
22283	670	46	in	in	IN
22283	670	47	such	such	JJ
22283	670	48	wise	wise	JJ
22283	670	49	that	that	IN
22283	670	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	670	51	forms	form	VBZ
22283	670	52	a	a	DT
22283	670	53	distinct	distinct	JJ
22283	670	54	system	system	NN
22283	670	55	of	of	IN
22283	670	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	670	57	own	own	JJ
22283	670	58	.	.	.
22283	671	1	If	if	IN
22283	671	2	any	any	DT
22283	671	3	part	part	NN
22283	671	4	of	of	IN
22283	671	5	the	the	DT
22283	671	6	objective	objective	JJ
22283	671	7	world	world	NN
22283	671	8	rudely	rudely	RB
22283	671	9	forces	force	VBZ
22283	671	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	671	11	way	way	NN
22283	671	12	within	within	IN
22283	671	13	the	the	DT
22283	671	14	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	671	15	of	of	IN
22283	671	16	that	that	DT
22283	671	17	system	system	NN
22283	671	18	,	,	,
22283	671	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	671	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	671	21	at	at	IN
22283	671	22	the	the	DT
22283	671	23	risk	risk	NN
22283	671	24	of	of	IN
22283	671	25	disarranging	disarrange	VBG
22283	671	26	the	the	DT
22283	671	27	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	671	28	and	and	CC
22283	671	29	stopping	stop	VBG
22283	671	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	671	31	work	work	NN
22283	671	32	--	--	:
22283	671	33	as	as	IN
22283	671	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	671	35	the	the	DT
22283	671	36	case	case	NN
22283	671	37	when	when	WRB
22283	671	38	a	a	DT
22283	671	39	bullet	bullet	NN
22283	671	40	enters	enter	VBZ
22283	671	41	the	the	DT
22283	671	42	brain	brain	NN
22283	671	43	.	.	.
22283	672	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	672	2	converse	converse	NN
22283	672	3	as	as	IN
22283	672	4	the	the	DT
22283	672	5	brain	brain	NN
22283	672	6	normally	normally	RB
22283	672	7	holds	hold	VBZ
22283	672	8	with	with	IN
22283	672	9	the	the	DT
22283	672	10	external	external	JJ
22283	672	11	world	world	NN
22283	672	12	,	,	,
22283	672	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	672	14	held	hold	VBN
22283	672	15	through	through	IN
22283	672	16	the	the	DT
22283	672	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
22283	672	18	channels	channel	NNS
22283	672	19	of	of	IN
22283	672	20	the	the	DT
22283	672	21	senses	sense	NNS
22283	672	22	,	,	,
22283	672	23	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	672	24	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
22283	672	25	causation	causation	NN
22283	672	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	672	27	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	672	28	to	to	TO
22283	672	29	keep	keep	VB
22283	672	30	the	the	DT
22283	672	31	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	672	32	isolated	isolated	JJ
22283	672	33	system	system	NN
22283	672	34	at	at	IN
22283	672	35	work	work	NN
22283	672	36	.	.	.
22283	673	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	673	2	know	know	VBP
22283	673	3	,	,	,
22283	673	4	from	from	IN
22283	673	5	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	673	6	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	673	7	,	,	,
22283	673	8	that	that	IN
22283	673	9	when	when	WRB
22283	673	10	such	such	JJ
22283	673	11	external	external	JJ
22283	673	12	causation	causation	NN
22283	673	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	673	14	withheld	withhold	VBN
22283	673	15	,	,	,
22283	673	16	the	the	DT
22283	673	17	isolated	isolated	JJ
22283	673	18	system	system	NN
22283	673	19	ceases	cease	VBZ
22283	673	20	to	to	TO
22283	673	21	work	work	VB
22283	673	22	;	;	:
22283	673	23	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	673	24	,	,	,
22283	673	25	the	the	DT
22283	673	26	isolation	isolation	NN
22283	673	27	,	,	,
22283	673	28	although	although	IN
22283	673	29	complete	complete	JJ
22283	673	30	under	under	IN
22283	673	31	one	one	CD
22283	673	32	point	point	NN
22283	673	33	of	of	IN
22283	673	34	view	view	NN
22283	673	35	,	,	,
22283	673	36	under	under	IN
22283	673	37	another	another	DT
22283	673	38	point	point	NN
22283	673	39	of	of	IN
22283	673	40	view	view	NN
22283	673	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	673	42	incomplete	incomplete	JJ
22283	673	43	.	.	.
22283	674	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	674	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	674	3	complete	complete	JJ
22283	674	4	only	only	RB
22283	674	5	in	in	IN
22283	674	6	the	the	DT
22283	674	7	sense	sense	NN
22283	674	8	in	in	IN
22283	674	9	which	which	WDT
22283	674	10	the	the	DT
22283	674	11	isolation	isolation	NN
22283	674	12	of	of	IN
22283	674	13	a	a	DT
22283	674	14	machine	machine	NN
22283	674	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	674	16	complete	complete	JJ
22283	674	17	--	--	:
22283	674	18	i	i	PRP
22283	674	19	.	.	.
22283	674	20	e.	e.	NNP
22283	674	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	674	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	674	23	in	in	IN
22283	674	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	674	25	a	a	DT
22283	674	26	working	work	VBG
22283	674	27	system	system	NN
22283	674	28	,	,	,
22283	674	29	yet	yet	CC
22283	674	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	674	31	working	working	NN
22283	674	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	674	33	ultimately	ultimately	RB
22283	674	34	dependent	dependent	JJ
22283	674	35	upon	upon	IN
22283	674	36	causation	causation	NN
22283	674	37	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	674	38	from	from	IN
22283	674	39	without	without	IN
22283	674	40	in	in	IN
22283	674	41	certain	certain	JJ
22283	674	42	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
22283	674	43	ways	way	NNS
22283	674	44	.	.	.
22283	675	1	This	this	DT
22283	675	2	truth	truth	NN
22283	675	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	675	4	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	675	5	testified	testify	VBN
22283	675	6	to	to	IN
22283	675	7	on	on	IN
22283	675	8	the	the	DT
22283	675	9	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	675	10	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	675	11	of	of	IN
22283	675	12	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	675	13	.	.	.
22283	676	1	For	for	IN
22283	676	2	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	676	3	shows	show	VBZ
22283	676	4	that	that	IN
22283	676	5	all	all	DT
22283	676	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	676	7	mental	mental	JJ
22283	676	8	processes	process	NNS
22283	676	9	(	(	-LRB-
22283	676	10	however	however	RB
22283	676	11	complex	complex	JJ
22283	676	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	676	13	may	may	MD
22283	676	14	be	be	VB
22283	676	15	internally	internally	RB
22283	676	16	)	)	-RRB-
22283	676	17	are	be	VBP
22283	676	18	ultimately	ultimately	RB
22283	676	19	dependent	dependent	JJ
22283	676	20	on	on	IN
22283	676	21	impressions	impression	NNS
22283	676	22	of	of	IN
22283	676	23	the	the	DT
22283	676	24	external	external	JJ
22283	676	25	world	world	NN
22283	676	26	gained	gain	VBN
22283	676	27	through	through	IN
22283	676	28	the	the	DT
22283	676	29	senses	sense	NNS
22283	676	30	.	.	.
22283	677	1	Whether	whether	IN
22283	677	2	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	677	3	objectively	objectively	RB
22283	677	4	or	or	CC
22283	677	5	subjectively	subjectively	RB
22283	677	6	,	,	,
22283	677	7	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	677	8	,	,	,
22283	677	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	677	10	find	find	VBP
22283	677	11	that	that	IN
22283	677	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	677	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	677	14	the	the	DT
22283	677	15	business	business	NN
22283	677	16	of	of	IN
22283	677	17	the	the	DT
22283	677	18	isolated	isolated	JJ
22283	677	19	system	system	NN
22283	677	20	to	to	TO
22283	677	21	elaborate	elaborate	VB
22283	677	22	,	,	,
22283	677	23	by	by	IN
22283	677	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	677	25	internal	internal	JJ
22283	677	26	processes	process	NNS
22283	677	27	,	,	,
22283	677	28	the	the	DT
22283	677	29	raw	raw	JJ
22283	677	30	materials	material	NNS
22283	677	31	which	which	WDT
22283	677	32	are	be	VBP
22283	677	33	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	677	34	to	to	IN
22283	677	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	677	36	from	from	IN
22283	677	37	without	without	IN
22283	677	38	.	.	.
22283	678	1	Seeing	seeing	NN
22283	678	2	,	,	,
22283	678	3	then	then	RB
22283	678	4	,	,	,
22283	678	5	that	that	IN
22283	678	6	the	the	DT
22283	678	7	isolation	isolation	NN
22283	678	8	of	of	IN
22283	678	9	the	the	DT
22283	678	10	system	system	NN
22283	678	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	678	12	thus	thus	RB
22283	678	13	only	only	RB
22283	678	14	partial	partial	JJ
22283	678	15	,	,	,
22283	678	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	678	17	may	may	MD
22283	678	18	best	best	RB
22283	678	19	apply	apply	VB
22283	678	20	to	to	IN
22283	678	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	678	22	the	the	DT
22283	678	23	term	term	NN
22283	678	24	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	678	25	.	.	.
22283	679	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	679	2	partial	partial	JJ
22283	679	3	isolation	isolation	NN
22283	679	4	or	or	CC
22283	679	5	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	679	6	of	of	IN
22283	679	7	matter	matter	NN
22283	679	8	in	in	IN
22283	679	9	motion	motion	NN
22283	679	10	--	--	:
22283	679	11	so	so	IN
22283	679	12	that	that	IN
22283	679	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	679	14	shall	shall	MD
22283	679	15	in	in	IN
22283	679	16	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	679	17	constitute	constitute	VBP
22283	679	18	a	a	DT
22283	679	19	little	little	JJ
22283	679	20	working	working	JJ
22283	679	21	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	679	22	--	--	:
22283	679	23	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	679	24	to	to	TO
22283	679	25	be	be	VB
22283	679	26	the	the	DT
22283	679	27	first	first	JJ
22283	679	28	condition	condition	NN
22283	679	29	to	to	IN
22283	679	30	the	the	DT
22283	679	31	being	being	NN
22283	679	32	of	of	IN
22283	679	33	a	a	DT
22283	679	34	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	679	35	personality	personality	NN
22283	679	36	.	.	.
22283	680	1	Why	why	WRB
22283	680	2	,	,	,
22283	680	3	then	then	RB
22283	680	4	,	,	,
22283	680	5	does	do	VBZ
22283	680	6	not	not	RB
22283	680	7	the	the	DT
22283	680	8	working	working	NN
22283	680	9	of	of	IN
22283	680	10	a	a	DT
22283	680	11	machine	machine	NN
22283	680	12	present	present	VB
22283	680	13	a	a	DT
22283	680	14	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	680	15	side	side	NN
22283	680	16	?	?	.
22283	681	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	681	2	answer	answer	NN
22283	681	3	to	to	IN
22283	681	4	this	this	DT
22283	681	5	question	question	NN
22283	681	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	681	7	to	to	TO
22283	681	8	be	be	VB
22283	681	9	found	find	VBN
22283	681	10	in	in	IN
22283	681	11	the	the	DT
22283	681	12	following	follow	VBG
22283	681	13	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	681	14	.	.	.
22283	682	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	682	2	are	be	VBP
22283	682	3	going	go	VBG
22283	682	4	upon	upon	IN
22283	682	5	the	the	DT
22283	682	6	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	682	7	that	that	WDT
22283	682	8	all	all	DT
22283	682	9	mind	mind	NN
22283	682	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	682	11	matter	matter	NN
22283	682	12	in	in	IN
22283	682	13	motion	motion	NN
22283	682	14	,	,	,
22283	682	15	and	and	CC
22283	682	16	that	that	IN
22283	682	17	all	all	DT
22283	682	18	matter	matter	NN
22283	682	19	in	in	IN
22283	682	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	682	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	682	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	682	23	--	--	:
22283	682	24	or	or	CC
22283	682	25	,	,	,
22283	682	26	as	as	IN
22283	682	27	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	682	28	phrased	phrase	VBD
22283	682	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	682	30	,	,	,
22283	682	31	that	that	IN
22283	682	32	all	all	PDT
22283	682	33	the	the	DT
22283	682	34	external	external	JJ
22283	682	35	world	world	NN
22283	682	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	682	37	composed	compose	VBN
22283	682	38	of	of	IN
22283	682	39	mind	mind	NN
22283	682	40	-	-	HYPH
22283	682	41	stuff	stuff	NN
22283	682	42	.	.	.
22283	683	1	No	no	RB
22283	683	2	matter	matter	RB
22283	683	3	how	how	WRB
22283	683	4	lightly	lightly	RB
22283	683	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	683	6	may	may	MD
22283	683	7	shade	shade	VB
22283	683	8	_	_	NNP
22283	683	9	x	x	NNP
22283	683	10	_	_	NNP
22283	683	11	,	,	,
22283	683	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	683	13	are	be	VBP
22283	683	14	assuming	assume	VBG
22283	683	15	that	that	IN
22283	683	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	683	17	must	must	MD
22283	683	18	be	be	VB
22283	683	19	shaded	shade	VBN
22283	683	20	,	,	,
22283	683	21	and	and	CC
22283	683	22	not	not	RB
22283	683	23	left	leave	VBN
22283	683	24	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	683	25	white	white	JJ
22283	683	26	.	.	.
22283	684	1	Now	now	RB
22283	684	2	,	,	,
22283	684	3	both	both	DT
22283	684	4	mind	mind	NN
22283	684	5	and	and	CC
22283	684	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	684	7	in	in	IN
22283	684	8	motion	motion	NN
22283	684	9	admit	admit	NN
22283	684	10	of	of	IN
22283	684	11	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	684	12	:	:	:
22283	684	13	first	first	RB
22283	684	14	as	as	IN
22283	684	15	to	to	IN
22283	684	16	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	684	17	,	,	,
22283	684	18	next	next	JJ
22283	684	19	as	as	IN
22283	684	20	to	to	IN
22283	684	21	velocity	velocity	NN
22283	684	22	,	,	,
22283	684	23	and	and	CC
22283	684	24	lastly	lastly	RB
22283	684	25	as	as	IN
22283	684	26	to	to	IN
22283	684	27	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	684	28	.	.	.
22283	685	1	But	but	CC
22283	685	2	the	the	DT
22283	685	3	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	685	4	of	of	IN
22283	685	5	matter	matter	NN
22283	685	6	in	in	IN
22283	685	7	motion	motion	NN
22283	685	8	are	be	VBP
22283	685	9	found	find	VBN
22283	685	10	,	,	,
22283	685	11	in	in	IN
22283	685	12	point	point	NN
22283	685	13	of	of	IN
22283	685	14	observable	observable	JJ
22283	685	15	fact	fact	NN
22283	685	16	,	,	,
22283	685	17	not	not	RB
22283	685	18	to	to	TO
22283	685	19	correspond	correspond	VB
22283	685	20	with	with	IN
22283	685	21	those	those	DT
22283	685	22	of	of	IN
22283	685	23	mind	mind	NN
22283	685	24	,	,	,
22283	685	25	save	save	IN
22283	685	26	in	in	IN
22283	685	27	the	the	DT
22283	685	28	last	last	JJ
22283	685	29	particular	particular	NN
22283	685	30	of	of	IN
22283	685	31	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	685	32	,	,	,
22283	685	33	where	where	WRB
22283	685	34	there	there	EX
22283	685	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	685	36	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
22283	685	37	an	an	DT
22283	685	38	evident	evident	JJ
22283	685	39	correspondence	correspondence	NN
22283	685	40	.	.	.
22283	686	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	686	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	686	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	686	4	that	that	IN
22283	686	5	a	a	DT
22283	686	6	machine	machine	NN
22283	686	7	,	,	,
22283	686	8	although	although	IN
22283	686	9	conforming	conform	VBG
22283	686	10	to	to	IN
22283	686	11	the	the	DT
22283	686	12	prime	prime	JJ
22283	686	13	condition	condition	NN
22283	686	14	of	of	IN
22283	686	15	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	686	16	in	in	IN
22283	686	17	being	be	VBG
22283	686	18	a	a	DT
22283	686	19	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	686	20	system	system	NN
22283	686	21	of	of	IN
22283	686	22	matter	matter	NN
22283	686	23	in	in	IN
22283	686	24	motion	motion	NN
22283	686	25	,	,	,
22283	686	26	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	686	27	does	do	VBZ
22283	686	28	not	not	RB
22283	686	29	attain	attain	VB
22283	686	30	to	to	IN
22283	686	31	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	686	32	:	:	:
22283	686	33	the	the	DT
22283	686	34	_	_	NNP
22283	686	35	x	x	NNP
22283	686	36	_	_	NNP
22283	686	37	does	do	VBZ
22283	686	38	not	not	RB
22283	686	39	rise	rise	VB
22283	686	40	to	to	IN
22283	686	41	_	_	NNP
22283	686	42	z	z	NNP
22283	686	43	_	_	NNP
22283	686	44	because	because	IN
22283	686	45	the	the	DT
22283	686	46	internal	internal	JJ
22283	686	47	processes	process	NNS
22283	686	48	of	of	IN
22283	686	49	_	_	NNP
22283	686	50	x	x	NNP
22283	686	51	_	_	NNP
22283	686	52	are	be	VBP
22283	686	53	not	not	RB
22283	686	54	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
22283	686	55	intricate	intricate	JJ
22283	686	56	,	,	,
22283	686	57	or	or	CC
22283	686	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	686	59	intricacy	intricacy	NN
22283	686	60	is	be	VBZ
22283	686	61	not	not	RB
22283	686	62	of	of	IN
22283	686	63	the	the	DT
22283	686	64	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
22283	686	65	kind	kind	NN
22283	686	66	.	.	.
22283	687	1	From	from	IN
22283	687	2	which	which	WDT
22283	687	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	687	4	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	687	5	that	that	IN
22283	687	6	although	although	IN
22283	687	7	,	,	,
22283	687	8	as	as	IN
22283	687	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	687	10	have	have	VBP
22283	687	11	said	say	VBD
22283	687	12	,	,	,
22283	687	13	all	all	DT
22283	687	14	matter	matter	NN
22283	687	15	in	in	IN
22283	687	16	motion	motion	NN
22283	687	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	687	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	687	19	,	,	,
22283	687	20	merely	merely	RB
22283	687	21	as	as	IN
22283	687	22	matter	matter	NN
22283	687	23	in	in	IN
22283	687	24	motion	motion	NN
22283	687	25	(	(	-LRB-
22283	687	26	or	or	CC
22283	687	27	irrespective	irrespective	RB
22283	687	28	of	of	IN
22283	687	29	the	the	DT
22283	687	30	kinds	kind	NNS
22283	687	31	and	and	CC
22283	687	32	degrees	degree	NNS
22283	687	33	of	of	IN
22283	687	34	both	both	DT
22283	687	35	)	)	-RRB-
22283	687	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	687	37	may	may	MD
22283	687	38	not	not	RB
22283	687	39	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	687	40	be	be	VB
22283	687	41	mind	mind	NN
22283	687	42	in	in	IN
22283	687	43	the	the	DT
22283	687	44	elaborated	elaborate	VBN
22283	687	45	form	form	NN
22283	687	46	of	of	IN
22283	687	47	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	687	48	:	:	:
22283	687	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	687	50	may	may	MD
22283	687	51	only	only	RB
22283	687	52	be	be	VB
22283	687	53	the	the	DT
22283	687	54	raw	raw	JJ
22283	687	55	material	material	NN
22283	687	56	of	of	IN
22283	687	57	mind	mind	NN
22283	687	58	--	--	:
22283	687	59	or	or	CC
22283	687	60	,	,	,
22283	687	61	as	as	IN
22283	687	62	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	687	63	called	call	VBD
22283	687	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	687	65	,	,	,
22283	687	66	mind	mind	NN
22283	687	67	-	-	HYPH
22283	687	68	stuff	stuff	NN
22283	687	69	.	.	.
22283	688	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	688	2	,	,	,
22283	688	3	although	although	IN
22283	688	4	all	all	DT
22283	688	5	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	688	6	volition	volition	NN
22283	688	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	688	8	matter	matter	NN
22283	688	9	in	in	IN
22283	688	10	motion	motion	NN
22283	688	11	,	,	,
22283	688	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	688	13	does	do	VBZ
22283	688	14	not	not	RB
22283	688	15	follow	follow	VB
22283	688	16	that	that	IN
22283	688	17	all	all	DT
22283	688	18	matter	matter	NN
22283	688	19	in	in	IN
22283	688	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	688	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	688	22	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	688	23	volition	volition	NN
22283	688	24	.	.	.
22283	689	1	Which	which	WDT
22283	689	2	serves	serve	VBZ
22283	689	3	to	to	TO
22283	689	4	restate	restate	VB
22283	689	5	the	the	DT
22283	689	6	question	question	NN
22283	689	7	as	as	IN
22283	689	8	to	to	IN
22283	689	9	how	how	WRB
22283	689	10	far	far	RB
22283	689	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	689	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	689	13	probable	probable	JJ
22283	689	14	,	,	,
22283	689	15	or	or	CC
22283	689	16	improbable	improbable	JJ
22283	689	17	,	,	,
22283	689	18	that	that	IN
22283	689	19	all	all	DT
22283	689	20	matter	matter	NN
22283	689	21	in	in	IN
22283	689	22	motion	motion	NN
22283	689	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	689	24	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	689	25	volition	volition	NN
22283	689	26	--	--	:
22283	689	27	i.e	i.e	NNP
22283	689	28	.	.	.
22283	690	1	how	how	WRB
22283	690	2	deeply	deeply	RB
22283	690	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	690	4	ought	ought	MD
22283	690	5	to	to	TO
22283	690	6	shade	shade	VB
22283	690	7	_	_	NNP
22283	690	8	x	x	NNP
22283	690	9	_	_	NNP
22283	690	10	.	.	.
22283	691	1	Well	well	UH
22283	691	2	,	,	,
22283	691	3	the	the	DT
22283	691	4	first	first	JJ
22283	691	5	thing	thing	NN
22283	691	6	to	to	TO
22283	691	7	be	be	VB
22283	691	8	considered	consider	VBN
22283	691	9	in	in	IN
22283	691	10	answering	answer	VBG
22283	691	11	this	this	DT
22283	691	12	question	question	NN
22283	691	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	691	14	that	that	IN
22283	691	15	,	,	,
22283	691	16	according	accord	VBG
22283	691	17	to	to	IN
22283	691	18	the	the	DT
22283	691	19	theory	theory	NN
22283	691	20	of	of	IN
22283	691	21	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	691	22	,	,	,
22283	691	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	691	24	_	_	NNP
22283	691	25	know	know	VBP
22283	691	26	_	_	NNP
22283	691	27	that	that	IN
22283	691	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	691	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	691	30	within	within	IN
22283	691	31	the	the	DT
22283	691	32	range	range	NN
22283	691	33	of	of	IN
22283	691	34	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	691	35	for	for	IN
22283	691	36	matter	matter	NN
22283	691	37	in	in	IN
22283	691	38	motion	motion	NN
22283	691	39	to	to	TO
22283	691	40	reach	reach	VB
22283	691	41	a	a	DT
22283	691	42	level	level	NN
22283	691	43	of	of	IN
22283	691	44	intricacy	intricacy	NN
22283	691	45	which	which	WDT
22283	691	46	shall	shall	MD
22283	691	47	yield	yield	VB
22283	691	48	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	691	49	volition	volition	NN
22283	691	50	,	,	,
22283	691	51	and	and	CC
22283	691	52	even	even	RB
22283	691	53	self	self	NN
22283	691	54	-	-	HYPH
22283	691	55	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	691	56	thought	thought	NN
22283	691	57	of	of	IN
22283	691	58	an	an	DT
22283	691	59	extremely	extremely	RB
22283	691	60	high	high	JJ
22283	691	61	order	order	NN
22283	691	62	of	of	IN
22283	691	63	development	development	NN
22283	691	64	.	.	.
22283	692	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	692	2	,	,	,
22283	692	3	the	the	DT
22283	692	4	only	only	JJ
22283	692	5	question	question	NN
22283	692	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	692	7	as	as	IN
22283	692	8	to	to	IN
22283	692	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	692	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	692	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	692	12	possible	possible	JJ
22283	692	13	,	,	,
22283	692	14	or	or	CC
22283	692	15	in	in	IN
22283	692	16	any	any	DT
22283	692	17	way	way	NN
22283	692	18	probable	probable	JJ
22283	692	19	,	,	,
22283	692	20	that	that	DT
22283	692	21	matter	matter	NN
22283	692	22	in	in	IN
22283	692	23	motion	motion	NN
22283	692	24	as	as	IN
22283	692	25	occurring	occur	VBG
22283	692	26	in	in	IN
22283	692	27	_	_	NNP
22283	692	28	x	x	NNP
22283	692	29	_	_	NNP
22283	692	30	resembles	resemble	NNS
22283	692	31	,	,	,
22283	692	32	in	in	IN
22283	692	33	point	point	NN
22283	692	34	of	of	IN
22283	692	35	intricacy	intricacy	NN
22283	692	36	,	,	,
22283	692	37	matter	matter	NN
22283	692	38	in	in	IN
22283	692	39	motion	motion	NN
22283	692	40	as	as	IN
22283	692	41	occurring	occur	VBG
22283	692	42	in	in	IN
22283	692	43	_	_	NNP
22283	692	44	z	z	NNP
22283	692	45	_	_	NNP
22283	692	46	.	.	.
22283	693	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	693	2	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	693	3	perceived	perceive	VBD
22283	693	4	that	that	IN
22283	693	5	this	this	DT
22283	693	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	693	7	the	the	DT
22283	693	8	core	core	NN
22283	693	9	of	of	IN
22283	693	10	the	the	DT
22283	693	11	question	question	NN
22283	693	12	,	,	,
22283	693	13	and	and	CC
22283	693	14	staked	stake	VBD
22283	693	15	the	the	DT
22283	693	16	whole	whole	JJ
22283	693	17	answer	answer	NN
22283	693	18	to	to	IN
22283	693	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	693	20	on	on	IN
22283	693	21	an	an	DT
22283	693	22	extremely	extremely	RB
22283	693	23	simple	simple	JJ
22283	693	24	issue	issue	NN
22283	693	25	.	.	.
22283	694	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	694	2	said	say	VBD
22283	694	3	that	that	IN
22283	694	4	unless	unless	IN
22283	694	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	694	6	can	can	MD
22283	694	7	show	show	VB
22283	694	8	in	in	IN
22283	694	9	the	the	DT
22283	694	10	disposition	disposition	NN
22283	694	11	of	of	IN
22283	694	12	heavenly	heavenly	JJ
22283	694	13	bodies	body	NNS
22283	694	14	some	some	DT
22283	694	15	morphological	morphological	JJ
22283	694	16	resemblance	resemblance	NN
22283	694	17	to	to	IN
22283	694	18	the	the	DT
22283	694	19	structure	structure	NN
22283	694	20	of	of	IN
22283	694	21	a	a	DT
22283	694	22	human	human	JJ
22283	694	23	brain	brain	NN
22283	694	24	,	,	,
22283	694	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	694	26	are	be	VBP
22283	694	27	precluded	preclude	VBN
22283	694	28	from	from	IN
22283	694	29	rationally	rationally	RB
22283	694	30	entertaining	entertain	VBG
22283	694	31	any	any	DT
22283	694	32	probability	probability	NN
22283	694	33	that	that	IN
22283	694	34	self	self	NN
22283	694	35	-	-	HYPH
22283	694	36	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	694	37	volition	volition	NN
22283	694	38	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	694	39	to	to	IN
22283	694	40	the	the	DT
22283	694	41	universe	universe	NN
22283	694	42	.	.	.
22283	695	1	Obviously	obviously	RB
22283	695	2	,	,	,
22283	695	3	this	this	DT
22283	695	4	way	way	NN
22283	695	5	of	of	IN
22283	695	6	presenting	present	VBG
22283	695	7	the	the	DT
22283	695	8	case	case	NN
22283	695	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	695	10	so	so	RB
22283	695	11	grossly	grossly	RB
22283	695	12	illogical	illogical	JJ
22283	695	13	that	that	IN
22283	695	14	even	even	RB
22283	695	15	the	the	DT
22283	695	16	exigencies	exigency	NNS
22283	695	17	of	of	IN
22283	695	18	popular	popular	JJ
22283	695	19	exposition	exposition	NN
22283	695	20	can	can	MD
22283	695	21	not	not	RB
22283	695	22	be	be	VB
22283	695	23	held	hold	VBN
22283	695	24	to	to	TO
22283	695	25	justify	justify	VB
22283	695	26	the	the	DT
22283	695	27	presentation	presentation	NN
22283	695	28	.	.	.
22283	696	1	For	for	IN
22283	696	2	aught	aught	JJ
22283	696	3	that	that	IN
22283	696	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	696	5	can	can	MD
22283	696	6	know	know	VB
22283	696	7	to	to	IN
22283	696	8	the	the	DT
22283	696	9	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	696	10	,	,	,
22283	696	11	not	not	RB
22283	696	12	merely	merely	RB
22283	696	13	the	the	DT
22283	696	14	highly	highly	RB
22283	696	15	specialized	specialized	JJ
22283	696	16	structure	structure	NN
22283	696	17	of	of	IN
22283	696	18	the	the	DT
22283	696	19	human	human	JJ
22283	696	20	brain	brain	NN
22283	696	21	,	,	,
22283	696	22	but	but	CC
22283	696	23	even	even	RB
22283	696	24	that	that	DT
22283	696	25	of	of	IN
22283	696	26	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	696	27	matter	matter	NN
22283	696	28	in	in	IN
22283	696	29	general	general	JJ
22283	696	30	,	,	,
22283	696	31	may	may	MD
22283	696	32	only	only	RB
22283	696	33	be	be	VB
22283	696	34	one	one	CD
22283	696	35	of	of	IN
22283	696	36	a	a	DT
22283	696	37	thousand	thousand	CD
22283	696	38	possible	possible	JJ
22283	696	39	ways	way	NNS
22283	696	40	in	in	IN
22283	696	41	which	which	WDT
22283	696	42	the	the	DT
22283	696	43	material	material	JJ
22283	696	44	and	and	CC
22283	696	45	dynamical	dynamical	JJ
22283	696	46	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	696	47	required	require	VBN
22283	696	48	for	for	IN
22283	696	49	the	the	DT
22283	696	50	apparition	apparition	NN
22283	696	51	of	of	IN
22283	696	52	self	self	NN
22283	696	53	-	-	HYPH
22283	696	54	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	696	55	can	can	MD
22283	696	56	be	be	VB
22283	696	57	secured	secure	VBN
22283	696	58	.	.	.
22283	697	1	To	to	TO
22283	697	2	imagine	imagine	VB
22283	697	3	that	that	IN
22283	697	4	the	the	DT
22283	697	5	human	human	JJ
22283	697	6	brain	brain	NN
22283	697	7	of	of	IN
22283	697	8	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	697	9	exhausts	exhaust	VBZ
22283	697	10	these	these	DT
22283	697	11	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	697	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	697	13	in	in	IN
22283	697	14	the	the	DT
22283	697	15	last	last	JJ
22283	697	16	degree	degree	NN
22283	697	17	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	697	18	.	.	.
22283	698	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	698	2	,	,	,
22283	698	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	698	4	may	may	MD
22283	698	5	suggest	suggest	VB
22283	698	6	the	the	DT
22283	698	7	following	follow	VBG
22283	698	8	presentation	presentation	NN
22283	698	9	of	of	IN
22283	698	10	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	698	11	's	's	POS
22283	698	12	case	case	NN
22283	698	13	as	as	IN
22283	698	14	one	one	NN
22283	698	15	that	that	WDT
22283	698	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	698	17	less	less	RBR
22283	698	18	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	698	19	inadequate:--if	inadequate:--if	VB
22283	698	20	any	any	DT
22283	698	21	resemblance	resemblance	NN
22283	698	22	to	to	IN
22283	698	23	the	the	DT
22283	698	24	material	material	JJ
22283	698	25	and	and	CC
22283	698	26	dynamical	dynamical	JJ
22283	698	27	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	698	28	of	of	IN
22283	698	29	the	the	DT
22283	698	30	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	698	31	can	can	MD
22283	698	32	be	be	VB
22283	698	33	detected	detect	VBN
22283	698	34	in	in	IN
22283	698	35	the	the	DT
22283	698	36	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	698	37	,	,	,
22283	698	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	698	39	should	should	MD
22283	698	40	have	have	VB
22283	698	41	good	good	JJ
22283	698	42	reason	reason	NN
22283	698	43	to	to	TO
22283	698	44	ascribe	ascribe	VB
22283	698	45	to	to	IN
22283	698	46	the	the	DT
22283	698	47	latter	latter	JJ
22283	698	48	those	those	DT
22283	698	49	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	698	50	of	of	IN
22283	698	51	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	698	52	which	which	WDT
22283	698	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	698	54	know	know	VBP
22283	698	55	as	as	IN
22283	698	56	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	698	57	to	to	IN
22283	698	58	the	the	DT
22283	698	59	former	former	JJ
22283	698	60	;	;	:
22283	698	61	but	but	CC
22283	698	62	if	if	IN
22283	698	63	no	no	DT
22283	698	64	such	such	JJ
22283	698	65	resemblance	resemblance	NN
22283	698	66	can	can	MD
22283	698	67	be	be	VB
22283	698	68	traced	trace	VBN
22283	698	69	,	,	,
22283	698	70	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	698	71	shall	shall	MD
22283	698	72	have	have	VB
22283	698	73	some	some	DT
22283	698	74	reason	reason	NN
22283	698	75	to	to	TO
22283	698	76	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	698	77	that	that	IN
22283	698	78	these	these	DT
22283	698	79	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	698	80	do	do	VBP
22283	698	81	not	not	RB
22283	698	82	belong	belong	VB
22283	698	83	to	to	IN
22283	698	84	the	the	DT
22283	698	85	universe	universe	NN
22283	698	86	.	.	.
22283	699	1	Even	even	RB
22283	699	2	this	this	DT
22283	699	3	,	,	,
22283	699	4	however	however	RB
22283	699	5	,	,	,
22283	699	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	699	7	should	should	MD
22283	699	8	regard	regard	VB
22283	699	9	as	as	RB
22283	699	10	much	much	RB
22283	699	11	too	too	RB
22283	699	12	wide	wide	JJ
22283	699	13	a	a	DT
22283	699	14	statement	statement	NN
22283	699	15	of	of	IN
22283	699	16	the	the	DT
22283	699	17	case	case	NN
22283	699	18	.	.	.
22283	700	1	To	to	TO
22283	700	2	take	take	VB
22283	700	3	the	the	DT
22283	700	4	particular	particular	JJ
22283	700	5	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	700	6	under	under	IN
22283	700	7	which	which	WDT
22283	700	8	alone	alone	JJ
22283	700	9	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	700	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	700	11	known	know	VBN
22283	700	12	to	to	TO
22283	700	13	occur	occur	VB
22283	700	14	upon	upon	IN
22283	700	15	a	a	DT
22283	700	16	single	single	JJ
22283	700	17	planet	planet	NN
22283	700	18	as	as	IN
22283	700	19	exhausting	exhaust	VBG
22283	700	20	the	the	DT
22283	700	21	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	700	22	of	of	IN
22283	700	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	700	24	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	700	25	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	700	26	,	,	,
22283	700	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	700	28	too	too	RB
22283	700	29	flagrant	flagrant	JJ
22283	700	30	a	a	DT
22283	700	31	use	use	NN
22283	700	32	of	of	IN
22283	700	33	the	the	DT
22283	700	34	method	method	NN
22283	700	35	of	of	IN
22283	700	36	simple	simple	JJ
22283	700	37	enumeration	enumeration	NN
22283	700	38	to	to	TO
22283	700	39	admit	admit	VB
22283	700	40	of	of	IN
22283	700	41	a	a	DT
22283	700	42	moment	moment	NN
22283	700	43	's	's	POS
22283	700	44	countenance	countenance	NN
22283	700	45	.	.	.
22283	701	1	Even	even	RB
22283	701	2	the	the	DT
22283	701	3	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	701	4	that	that	WDT
22283	701	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	701	6	have	have	VBP
22283	701	7	of	of	IN
22283	701	8	the	the	DT
22283	701	9	two	two	CD
22283	701	10	great	great	JJ
22283	701	11	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	701	12	under	under	IN
22283	701	13	which	which	WDT
22283	701	14	terrestrial	terrestrial	JJ
22283	701	15	subjectivities	subjectivity	NNS
22283	701	16	occur	occur	VBP
22283	701	17	--	--	:
22283	701	18	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	701	19	and	and	CC
22283	701	20	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	701	21	--	--	:
22283	701	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	701	23	only	only	RB
22283	701	24	empirical	empirical	JJ
22283	701	25	.	.	.
22283	702	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	702	2	may	may	MD
22283	702	3	well	well	RB
22283	702	4	be	be	VB
22283	702	5	that	that	IN
22283	702	6	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	702	7	(	(	-LRB-
22283	702	8	or	or	CC
22283	702	9	apart	apart	RB
22283	702	10	from	from	IN
22283	702	11	the	the	DT
22283	702	12	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	702	13	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	702	14	by	by	IN
22283	702	15	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	702	16	tissue	tissue	NN
22283	702	17	)	)	-RRB-
22283	702	18	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	702	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	702	20	possible	possible	JJ
22283	702	21	irrespective	irrespective	RB
22283	702	22	both	both	DT
22283	702	23	of	of	IN
22283	702	24	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	702	25	and	and	CC
22283	702	26	of	of	IN
22283	702	27	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	702	28	.	.	.
22283	703	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	703	2	,	,	,
22283	703	3	properly	properly	RB
22283	703	4	or	or	CC
22283	703	5	logically	logically	RB
22283	703	6	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	703	7	,	,	,
22283	703	8	the	the	DT
22283	703	9	great	great	JJ
22283	703	10	use	use	NN
22283	703	11	of	of	IN
22283	703	12	the	the	DT
22283	703	13	one	one	CD
22283	703	14	exhibition	exhibition	NN
22283	703	15	of	of	IN
22283	703	16	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	703	17	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	703	18	to	to	IN
22283	703	19	human	human	JJ
22283	703	20	experience	experience	NN
22283	703	21	,	,	,
22283	703	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	703	23	the	the	DT
22283	703	24	proof	proof	NN
22283	703	25	thus	thus	RB
22283	703	26	furnished	furnish	VBD
22283	703	27	that	that	IN
22283	703	28	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	703	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	703	30	possible	possible	JJ
22283	703	31	under	under	IN
22283	703	32	_	_	NNP
22283	703	33	some	some	DT
22283	703	34	_	_	NNP
22283	703	35	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	703	36	;	;	:
22283	703	37	and	and	CC
22283	703	38	the	the	DT
22283	703	39	utmost	utmost	JJ
22283	703	40	which	which	WDT
22283	703	41	on	on	IN
22283	703	42	the	the	DT
22283	703	43	grounds	ground	NNS
22283	703	44	of	of	IN
22283	703	45	such	such	JJ
22283	703	46	proof	proof	JJ
22283	703	47	human	human	JJ
22283	703	48	experience	experience	NN
22283	703	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	703	50	entitled	entitle	VBN
22283	703	51	to	to	TO
22283	703	52	argue	argue	VB
22283	703	53	is	be	VBZ
22283	703	54	,	,	,
22283	703	55	that	that	IN
22283	703	56	_	_	NNP
22283	703	57	probably	probably	RB
22283	703	58	_	_	NNP
22283	703	59	,	,	,
22283	703	60	if	if	IN
22283	703	61	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	703	62	is	be	VBZ
22283	703	63	possible	possible	JJ
22283	703	64	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	703	65	,	,	,
22283	703	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	703	67	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	703	68	is	be	VBZ
22283	703	69	given	give	VBN
22283	703	70	by	by	IN
22283	703	71	those	those	DT
22283	703	72	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	703	73	of	of	IN
22283	703	74	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	703	75	and	and	CC
22283	703	76	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	703	77	in	in	IN
22283	703	78	the	the	DT
22283	703	79	material	material	JJ
22283	703	80	and	and	CC
22283	703	81	dynamical	dynamical	JJ
22283	703	82	relations	relation	NNS
22283	703	83	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	703	84	,	,	,
22283	703	85	which	which	WDT
22283	703	86	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	703	87	find	find	VBP
22283	703	88	to	to	TO
22283	703	89	be	be	VB
22283	703	90	the	the	DT
22283	703	91	invariable	invariable	JJ
22283	703	92	and	and	CC
22283	703	93	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
22283	703	94	concomitants	concomitant	NNS
22283	703	95	of	of	IN
22283	703	96	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	703	97	within	within	IN
22283	703	98	experience	experience	NN
22283	703	99	.	.	.
22283	704	1	But	but	CC
22283	704	2	this	this	DT
22283	704	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	704	4	a	a	DT
22283	704	5	widely	widely	RB
22283	704	6	different	different	JJ
22283	704	7	thing	thing	NN
22283	704	8	from	from	IN
22283	704	9	saying	say	VBG
22283	704	10	that	that	IN
22283	704	11	the	the	DT
22283	704	12	only	only	JJ
22283	704	13	kind	kind	NN
22283	704	14	of	of	IN
22283	704	15	such	such	JJ
22283	704	16	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	704	17	and	and	CC
22283	704	18	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	704	19	--	--	:
22283	704	20	or	or	CC
22283	704	21	the	the	DT
22283	704	22	only	only	JJ
22283	704	23	disposition	disposition	NN
22283	704	24	of	of	IN
22283	704	25	these	these	DT
22283	704	26	relations	relation	NNS
22283	704	27	--	--	:
22283	704	28	which	which	WDT
22283	704	29	can	can	MD
22283	704	30	present	present	VB
22283	704	31	a	a	DT
22283	704	32	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	704	33	side	side	NN
22283	704	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	704	35	that	that	DT
22283	704	36	which	which	WDT
22283	704	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	704	38	found	find	VBN
22283	704	39	in	in	IN
22283	704	40	the	the	DT
22283	704	41	structures	structure	NNS
22283	704	42	and	and	CC
22283	704	43	functions	function	NNS
22283	704	44	of	of	IN
22283	704	45	a	a	DT
22283	704	46	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	704	47	system	system	NN
22283	704	48	.	.	.
22283	705	1	Now	now	RB
22283	705	2	,	,	,
22283	705	3	if	if	IN
22283	705	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	705	5	fix	fix	VBP
22283	705	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	705	7	attention	attention	NN
22283	705	8	merely	merely	RB
22283	705	9	on	on	IN
22283	705	10	this	this	DT
22283	705	11	matter	matter	NN
22283	705	12	of	of	IN
22283	705	13	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	705	14	,	,	,
22283	705	15	and	and	CC
22283	705	16	refuse	refuse	VBP
22283	705	17	to	to	TO
22283	705	18	be	be	VB
22283	705	19	led	lead	VBN
22283	705	20	astray	astray	RB
22283	705	21	by	by	IN
22283	705	22	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	705	23	false	false	JJ
22283	705	24	analogies	analogy	NNS
22283	705	25	of	of	IN
22283	705	26	a	a	DT
22283	705	27	more	more	RBR
22283	705	28	special	special	JJ
22283	705	29	kind	kind	NN
22283	705	30	,	,	,
22283	705	31	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	705	32	think	think	VBP
22283	705	33	there	there	EX
22283	705	34	can	can	MD
22283	705	35	be	be	VB
22283	705	36	no	no	DT
22283	705	37	question	question	NN
22283	705	38	that	that	IN
22283	705	39	the	the	DT
22283	705	40	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	705	41	does	do	VBZ
22283	705	42	furnish	furnish	VB
22283	705	43	amply	amply	JJ
22283	705	44	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	705	45	opportunity	opportunity	NN
22283	705	46	,	,	,
22283	705	47	as	as	IN
22283	705	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	705	49	were	be	VBD
22283	705	50	,	,	,
22283	705	51	for	for	IN
22283	705	52	the	the	DT
22283	705	53	presence	presence	NN
22283	705	54	of	of	IN
22283	705	55	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	705	56	,	,	,
22283	705	57	even	even	RB
22283	705	58	if	if	IN
22283	705	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	705	60	be	be	VBP
22283	705	61	assumed	assume	VBN
22283	705	62	that	that	IN
22283	705	63	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	705	64	can	can	MD
22283	705	65	only	only	RB
22283	705	66	be	be	VB
22283	705	67	yielded	yield	VBN
22283	705	68	by	by	IN
22283	705	69	an	an	DT
22283	705	70	order	order	NN
22283	705	71	of	of	IN
22283	705	72	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	705	73	analogous	analogous	JJ
22283	705	74	to	to	IN
22283	705	75	that	that	DT
22283	705	76	of	of	IN
22283	705	77	a	a	DT
22283	705	78	nervous	nervous	JJ
22283	705	79	system	system	NN
22283	705	80	.	.	.
22283	706	1	For	for	IN
22283	706	2	,	,	,
22283	706	3	considering	consider	VBG
22283	706	4	the	the	DT
22283	706	5	material	material	JJ
22283	706	6	and	and	CC
22283	706	7	dynamical	dynamical	JJ
22283	706	8	system	system	NN
22283	706	9	of	of	IN
22283	706	10	the	the	DT
22283	706	11	universe	universe	NN
22283	706	12	as	as	IN
22283	706	13	a	a	DT
22283	706	14	whole	whole	NN
22283	706	15	,	,	,
22283	706	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	706	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	706	18	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	706	19	that	that	IN
22283	706	20	the	the	DT
22283	706	21	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	706	22	presented	present	VBN
22283	706	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	706	24	greater	great	JJR
22283	706	25	than	than	IN
22283	706	26	that	that	DT
22283	706	27	of	of	IN
22283	706	28	any	any	DT
22283	706	29	of	of	IN
22283	706	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	706	31	parts	part	NNS
22283	706	32	.	.	.
22283	707	1	Not	not	RB
22283	707	2	only	only	RB
22283	707	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	707	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	707	5	true	true	JJ
22283	707	6	that	that	IN
22283	707	7	all	all	PDT
22283	707	8	these	these	DT
22283	707	9	parts	part	NNS
22283	707	10	are	be	VBP
22283	707	11	included	include	VBN
22283	707	12	in	in	IN
22283	707	13	the	the	DT
22283	707	14	whole	whole	NN
22283	707	15	,	,	,
22283	707	16	and	and	CC
22283	707	17	that	that	IN
22283	707	18	even	even	RB
22283	707	19	the	the	DT
22283	707	20	visible	visible	JJ
22283	707	21	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
22283	707	22	system	system	NN
22283	707	23	alone	alone	RB
22283	707	24	presents	present	VBZ
22283	707	25	movements	movement	NNS
22283	707	26	of	of	IN
22283	707	27	enormous	enormous	JJ
22283	707	28	intricacy[9	intricacy[9	NNP
22283	707	29	]	]	-RRB-
22283	707	30	,	,	,
22283	707	31	but	but	CC
22283	707	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	707	33	find	find	VBP
22283	707	34	,	,	,
22283	707	35	for	for	IN
22283	707	36	instance	instance	NN
22283	707	37	,	,	,
22283	707	38	that	that	IN
22283	707	39	even	even	RB
22283	707	40	within	within	IN
22283	707	41	the	the	DT
22283	707	42	limits	limit	NNS
22283	707	43	of	of	IN
22283	707	44	this	this	DT
22283	707	45	small	small	JJ
22283	707	46	planet	planet	NN
22283	707	47	there	there	EX
22283	707	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	707	49	presented	present	VBN
22283	707	50	to	to	IN
22283	707	51	actual	actual	JJ
22283	707	52	observation	observation	NN
22283	707	53	a	a	DT
22283	707	54	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
22283	707	55	form	form	NN
22283	707	56	of	of	IN
22283	707	57	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	707	58	complex	complex	JJ
22283	707	59	,	,	,
22283	707	60	fully	fully	RB
22283	707	61	comparable	comparable	JJ
22283	707	62	with	with	IN
22283	707	63	that	that	DT
22283	707	64	of	of	IN
22283	707	65	the	the	DT
22283	707	66	individual	individual	JJ
22283	707	67	brain	brain	NN
22283	707	68	,	,	,
22283	707	69	and	and	CC
22283	707	70	yet	yet	RB
22283	707	71	external	external	JJ
22283	707	72	to	to	IN
22283	707	73	each	each	DT
22283	707	74	individual	individual	JJ
22283	707	75	brain	brain	NN
22283	707	76	.	.	.
22283	708	1	For	for	IN
22283	708	2	the	the	DT
22283	708	3	so	so	RB
22283	708	4	-	-	HYPH
22283	708	5	called	call	VBN
22283	708	6	'	'	``
22283	708	7	social	social	JJ
22283	708	8	organism	organism	NN
22283	708	9	,	,	,
22283	708	10	'	'	''
22283	708	11	although	although	IN
22283	708	12	composed	compose	VBN
22283	708	13	of	of	IN
22283	708	14	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
22283	708	15	individual	individual	JJ
22283	708	16	personalities	personality	NNS
22283	708	17	,	,	,
22283	708	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	708	19	,	,	,
22283	708	20	with	with	IN
22283	708	21	regard	regard	NN
22283	708	22	to	to	IN
22283	708	23	each	each	DT
22283	708	24	of	of	IN
22283	708	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	708	26	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	708	27	units	unit	NNS
22283	708	28	,	,	,
22283	708	29	a	a	DT
22283	708	30	part	part	NN
22283	708	31	of	of	IN
22283	708	32	the	the	DT
22283	708	33	objective	objective	JJ
22283	708	34	world	world	NN
22283	708	35	--	--	:
22283	708	36	just	just	RB
22283	708	37	as	as	IN
22283	708	38	the	the	DT
22283	708	39	human	human	JJ
22283	708	40	brain	brain	NN
22283	708	41	would	would	MD
22283	708	42	be	be	VB
22283	708	43	,	,	,
22283	708	44	were	be	VBD
22283	708	45	each	each	DT
22283	708	46	of	of	IN
22283	708	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	708	48	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	708	49	cells	cell	NNS
22283	708	50	of	of	IN
22283	708	51	a	a	DT
22283	708	52	construction	construction	NN
22283	708	53	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
22283	708	54	complex	complex	JJ
22283	708	55	to	to	TO
22283	708	56	yield	yield	VB
22283	708	57	a	a	DT
22283	708	58	separate	separate	JJ
22283	708	59	personality	personality	NN
22283	708	60	.	.	.
22283	709	1	If	if	IN
22283	709	2	to	to	IN
22283	709	3	this	this	DT
22283	709	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	709	5	be	be	VB
22283	709	6	objected	object	VBN
22283	709	7	that	that	IN
22283	709	8	,	,	,
22283	709	9	as	as	IN
22283	709	10	a	a	DT
22283	709	11	matter	matter	NN
22283	709	12	of	of	IN
22283	709	13	fact	fact	NN
22283	709	14	,	,	,
22283	709	15	the	the	DT
22283	709	16	social	social	JJ
22283	709	17	organism	organism	NN
22283	709	18	does	do	VBZ
22283	709	19	not	not	RB
22283	709	20	possess	possess	VB
22283	709	21	a	a	DT
22283	709	22	self	self	NN
22283	709	23	-	-	HYPH
22283	709	24	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	709	25	personality	personality	NN
22283	709	26	,	,	,
22283	709	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	709	28	will	will	MD
22283	709	29	give	give	VB
22283	709	30	a	a	DT
22283	709	31	twofold	twofold	JJ
22283	709	32	answer	answer	NN
22283	709	33	.	.	.
22283	710	1	In	in	IN
22283	710	2	the	the	DT
22283	710	3	first	first	JJ
22283	710	4	place	place	NN
22283	710	5	,	,	,
22283	710	6	Who	who	WP
22283	710	7	told	tell	VBD
22283	710	8	the	the	DT
22283	710	9	objector	objector	NN
22283	710	10	that	that	WDT
22283	710	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	710	12	has	have	VBZ
22283	710	13	not	not	RB
22283	710	14	?	?	.
22283	711	1	For	for	IN
22283	711	2	aught	aught	VBN
22283	711	3	that	that	IN
22283	711	4	any	any	DT
22283	711	5	one	one	CD
22283	711	6	of	of	IN
22283	711	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	711	8	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	711	9	personalities	personality	NNS
22283	711	10	can	can	MD
22283	711	11	prove	prove	VB
22283	711	12	to	to	IN
22283	711	13	the	the	DT
22283	711	14	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	711	15	,	,	,
22283	711	16	this	this	DT
22283	711	17	social	social	JJ
22283	711	18	organism	organism	NN
22283	711	19	may	may	MD
22283	711	20	possess	possess	VB
22283	711	21	self	self	NN
22283	711	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	711	23	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	711	24	personality	personality	NN
22283	711	25	of	of	IN
22283	711	26	the	the	DT
22283	711	27	most	most	RBS
22283	711	28	vivid	vivid	JJ
22283	711	29	character	character	NN
22283	711	30	:	:	:
22283	711	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	711	32	constituent	constituent	JJ
22283	711	33	human	human	JJ
22283	711	34	minds	mind	NNS
22283	711	35	may	may	MD
22283	711	36	be	be	VB
22283	711	37	born	bear	VBN
22283	711	38	into	into	IN
22283	711	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	711	40	and	and	CC
22283	711	41	die	die	VB
22283	711	42	out	out	IN
22283	711	43	of	of	IN
22283	711	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	711	45	as	as	IN
22283	711	46	do	do	VBP
22283	711	47	the	the	DT
22283	711	48	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	711	49	cells	cell	NNS
22283	711	50	of	of	IN
22283	711	51	the	the	DT
22283	711	52	human	human	JJ
22283	711	53	body	body	NN
22283	711	54	:	:	:
22283	711	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	711	56	may	may	MD
22283	711	57	feel	feel	VB
22283	711	58	the	the	DT
22283	711	59	throes	throe	NNS
22283	711	60	of	of	IN
22283	711	61	war	war	NN
22283	711	62	and	and	CC
22283	711	63	famine	famine	NN
22283	711	64	,	,	,
22283	711	65	rejoice	rejoice	VB
22283	711	66	in	in	IN
22283	711	67	the	the	DT
22283	711	68	comforts	comfort	NNS
22283	711	69	of	of	IN
22283	711	70	peace	peace	NN
22283	711	71	and	and	CC
22283	711	72	plenty	plenty	NN
22283	711	73	:	:	:
22283	711	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	711	75	may	may	MD
22283	711	76	appreciate	appreciate	VB
22283	711	77	the	the	DT
22283	711	78	growth	growth	NN
22283	711	79	of	of	IN
22283	711	80	civilization	civilization	NN
22283	711	81	as	as	IN
22283	711	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	711	83	passage	passage	NN
22283	711	84	from	from	IN
22283	711	85	childhood	childhood	NN
22283	711	86	to	to	IN
22283	711	87	maturity	maturity	NN
22283	711	88	.	.	.
22283	712	1	If	if	IN
22283	712	2	this	this	DT
22283	712	3	at	at	IN
22283	712	4	first	first	JJ
22283	712	5	sight	sight	NN
22283	712	6	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	712	7	a	a	DT
22283	712	8	grotesque	grotesque	JJ
22283	712	9	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	712	10	,	,	,
22283	712	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	712	12	must	must	MD
22283	712	13	remember	remember	VB
22283	712	14	that	that	IN
22283	712	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	712	16	would	would	MD
22283	712	17	appear	appear	VB
22283	712	18	equally	equally	RB
22283	712	19	so	so	RB
22283	712	20	to	to	TO
22283	712	21	ascribe	ascribe	VB
22283	712	22	such	such	JJ
22283	712	23	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	712	24	to	to	IN
22283	712	25	the	the	DT
22283	712	26	individual	individual	JJ
22283	712	27	brain	brain	NN
22283	712	28	,	,	,
22283	712	29	were	be	VBD
22283	712	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	712	31	not	not	RB
22283	712	32	for	for	IN
22283	712	33	the	the	DT
22283	712	34	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
22283	712	35	accident	accident	NN
22283	712	36	of	of	IN
22283	712	37	this	this	DT
22283	712	38	particular	particular	JJ
22283	712	39	form	form	NN
22283	712	40	of	of	IN
22283	712	41	complex	complex	JJ
22283	712	42	standing	standing	NN
22283	712	43	in	in	IN
22283	712	44	such	such	JJ
22283	712	45	relation	relation	NN
22283	712	46	to	to	IN
22283	712	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	712	48	own	own	JJ
22283	712	49	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	712	50	that	that	IN
22283	712	51	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	712	52	are	be	VBP
22283	712	53	able	able	JJ
22283	712	54	to	to	TO
22283	712	55	verify	verify	VB
22283	712	56	the	the	DT
22283	712	57	fact	fact	NN
22283	712	58	of	of	IN
22283	712	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	712	60	ejectivity	ejectivity	NN
22283	712	61	.	.	.
22283	713	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	713	2	,	,	,
22283	713	3	for	for	IN
22283	713	4	aught	aught	JJ
22283	713	5	that	that	IN
22283	713	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	713	7	can	can	MD
22283	713	8	tell	tell	VB
22283	713	9	to	to	IN
22283	713	10	the	the	DT
22283	713	11	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	713	12	,	,	,
22283	713	13	Comte	Comte	NNP
22283	713	14	may	may	MD
22283	713	15	have	have	VB
22283	713	16	been	be	VBN
22283	713	17	even	even	RB
22283	713	18	more	more	RBR
22283	713	19	justified	justified	JJ
22283	713	20	than	than	IN
22283	713	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	713	22	followers	follower	NNS
22283	713	23	suppose	suppose	VBP
22283	713	24	,	,	,
22283	713	25	in	in	IN
22283	713	26	teaching	teach	VBG
22283	713	27	the	the	DT
22283	713	28	personification	personification	NN
22283	713	29	of	of	IN
22283	713	30	Humanity	Humanity	NNP
22283	713	31	.	.	.
22283	714	1	But	but	CC
22283	714	2	,	,	,
22283	714	3	in	in	IN
22283	714	4	the	the	DT
22283	714	5	next	next	JJ
22283	714	6	place	place	NN
22283	714	7	,	,	,
22283	714	8	if	if	IN
22283	714	9	the	the	DT
22283	714	10	social	social	JJ
22283	714	11	organism	organism	NN
22283	714	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	714	13	not	not	RB
22283	714	14	endowed	endow	VBN
22283	714	15	with	with	IN
22283	714	16	personality	personality	NN
22283	714	17	,	,	,
22283	714	18	this	this	DT
22283	714	19	may	may	MD
22283	714	20	be	be	VB
22283	714	21	for	for	IN
22283	714	22	either	either	DT
22283	714	23	one	one	CD
22283	714	24	of	of	IN
22283	714	25	two	two	CD
22283	714	26	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	714	27	.	.	.
22283	715	1	All	all	PDT
22283	715	2	the	the	DT
22283	715	3	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	715	4	required	require	VBN
22283	715	5	for	for	IN
22283	715	6	attaining	attain	VBG
22283	715	7	so	so	RB
22283	715	8	high	high	JJ
22283	715	9	a	a	DT
22283	715	10	level	level	NN
22283	715	11	of	of	IN
22283	715	12	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	715	13	perfection	perfection	NN
22283	715	14	may	may	MD
22283	715	15	not	not	RB
22283	715	16	be	be	VB
22283	715	17	here	here	RB
22283	715	18	present	present	JJ
22283	715	19	;	;	:
22283	715	20	or	or	CC
22283	715	21	else	else	RB
22283	715	22	the	the	DT
22283	715	23	level	level	NN
22283	715	24	of	of	IN
22283	715	25	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	715	26	perfection	perfection	NN
22283	715	27	may	may	MD
22283	715	28	be	be	VB
22283	715	29	higher	high	JJR
22283	715	30	than	than	IN
22283	715	31	that	that	DT
22283	715	32	which	which	WDT
22283	715	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	715	34	know	know	VBP
22283	715	35	as	as	IN
22283	715	36	personality	personality	NN
22283	715	37	.	.	.
22283	716	1	This	this	DT
22283	716	2	latter	latter	JJ
22283	716	3	alternative	alternative	NN
22283	716	4	will	will	MD
22283	716	5	be	be	VB
22283	716	6	considered	consider	VBN
22283	716	7	in	in	IN
22283	716	8	another	another	DT
22283	716	9	relation	relation	NN
22283	716	10	by	by	IN
22283	716	11	-	-	HYPH
22283	716	12	and	and	CC
22283	716	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	716	14	by	by	RB
22283	716	15	,	,	,
22283	716	16	so	so	CC
22283	716	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	716	18	will	will	MD
22283	716	19	not	not	RB
22283	716	20	dwell	dwell	VB
22283	716	21	upon	upon	IN
22283	716	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	716	23	now	now	RB
22283	716	24	.	.	.
22283	717	1	But	but	CC
22283	717	2	with	with	IN
22283	717	3	reference	reference	NN
22283	717	4	to	to	IN
22283	717	5	all	all	PDT
22283	717	6	these	these	DT
22283	717	7	possible	possible	JJ
22283	717	8	contingencies	contingency	NNS
22283	717	9	,	,	,
22283	717	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	717	11	may	may	MD
22283	717	12	observe	observe	VB
22283	717	13	that	that	IN
22283	717	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	717	15	are	be	VBP
22283	717	16	not	not	RB
22283	717	17	without	without	IN
22283	717	18	clear	clear	JJ
22283	717	19	indications	indication	NNS
22283	717	20	of	of	IN
22283	717	21	the	the	DT
22283	717	22	great	great	JJ
22283	717	23	fact	fact	NN
22283	717	24	that	that	IN
22283	717	25	the	the	DT
22283	717	26	high	high	JJ
22283	717	27	order	order	NN
22283	717	28	of	of	IN
22283	717	29	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	717	30	which	which	WDT
22283	717	31	has	have	VBZ
22283	717	32	been	be	VBN
22283	717	33	reached	reach	VBN
22283	717	34	by	by	IN
22283	717	35	the	the	DT
22283	717	36	social	social	JJ
22283	717	37	organism	organism	NN
22283	717	38	_	_	NNP
22283	717	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	717	40	_	_	NNP
22283	717	41	accompanied	accompany	VBN
22283	717	42	by	by	IN
22283	717	43	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	717	44	of	of	IN
22283	717	45	something	something	NN
22283	717	46	which	which	WDT
22283	717	47	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	717	48	may	may	MD
22283	717	49	least	least	RBS
22283	717	50	dimly	dimly	RB
22283	717	51	define	define	VB
22283	717	52	as	as	IN
22283	717	53	resembling	resemble	VBG
22283	717	54	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	717	55	.	.	.
22283	718	1	In	in	IN
22283	718	2	numberless	numberless	JJ
22283	718	3	ways	way	NNS
22283	718	4	,	,	,
22283	718	5	which	which	WDT
22283	718	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	718	7	need	need	VBP
22283	718	8	not	not	RB
22283	718	9	wait	wait	VB
22283	718	10	to	to	TO
22283	718	11	enumerate	enumerate	VB
22283	718	12	,	,	,
22283	718	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	718	14	perceive	perceive	VBP
22283	718	15	that	that	IN
22283	718	16	society	society	NN
22283	718	17	exhibits	exhibit	VBZ
22283	718	18	the	the	DT
22283	718	19	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	718	20	both	both	DT
22283	718	21	of	of	IN
22283	718	22	thought	thought	NN
22283	718	23	and	and	CC
22283	718	24	conduct	conduct	NN
22283	718	25	.	.	.
22283	719	1	And	and	CC
22283	719	2	these	these	DT
22283	719	3	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	719	4	can	can	MD
22283	719	5	not	not	RB
22283	719	6	always	always	RB
22283	719	7	be	be	VB
22283	719	8	explained	explain	VBN
22283	719	9	by	by	IN
22283	719	10	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	719	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	719	12	as	as	IN
22283	719	13	the	the	DT
22283	719	14	sum	sum	NN
22283	719	15	of	of	IN
22283	719	16	the	the	DT
22283	719	17	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	719	18	and	and	CC
22283	719	19	actions	action	NNS
22283	719	20	of	of	IN
22283	719	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	719	22	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	719	23	individuals	individual	NNS
22283	719	24	--	--	:
22283	719	25	or	or	CC
22283	719	26	,	,	,
22283	719	27	at	at	IN
22283	719	28	least	least	JJS
22283	719	29	,	,	,
22283	719	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	719	31	can	can	MD
22283	719	32	only	only	RB
22283	719	33	be	be	VB
22283	719	34	so	so	RB
22283	719	35	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	719	36	by	by	IN
22283	719	37	conceding	concede	VBG
22283	719	38	that	that	IN
22283	719	39	the	the	DT
22283	719	40	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	719	41	and	and	CC
22283	719	42	actions	action	NNS
22283	719	43	of	of	IN
22283	719	44	the	the	DT
22283	719	45	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	719	46	individuals	individual	NNS
22283	719	47	,	,	,
22283	719	48	when	when	WRB
22283	719	49	thus	thus	RB
22283	719	50	_	_	NNP
22283	719	51	summated	summate	VBD
22283	719	52	_	_	NNP
22283	719	53	,	,	,
22283	719	54	yield	yield	VB
22283	719	55	a	a	DT
22283	719	56	different	different	JJ
22283	719	57	product	product	NN
22283	719	58	from	from	IN
22283	719	59	that	that	DT
22283	719	60	which	which	WDT
22283	719	61	would	would	MD
22283	719	62	be	be	VB
22283	719	63	obtained	obtain	VBN
22283	719	64	by	by	IN
22283	719	65	a	a	DT
22283	719	66	merely	merely	RB
22283	719	67	arithmetical	arithmetical	JJ
22283	719	68	computation	computation	NN
22283	719	69	of	of	IN
22283	719	70	the	the	DT
22283	719	71	constituent	constituent	NN
22283	719	72	parts	part	NNS
22283	719	73	:	:	:
22283	719	74	the	the	DT
22283	719	75	composite	composite	JJ
22283	719	76	product	product	NN
22283	719	77	differs	differ	VBZ
22283	719	78	from	from	IN
22283	719	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	719	80	component	component	NN
22283	719	81	elements	element	NNS
22283	719	82	,	,	,
22283	719	83	as	as	IN
22283	719	84	H_2O	h_2o	CD
22283	719	85	differs	differ	NNS
22283	719	86	from	from	IN
22283	719	87	2H	2h	CD
22283	719	88	+	+	SYM
22283	719	89	O.	o.	NN
22283	720	1	The	the	DT
22283	720	2	general	general	JJ
22283	720	3	truth	truth	NN
22283	720	4	of	of	IN
22283	720	5	this	this	DT
22283	720	6	remark	remark	NN
22283	720	7	will	will	MD
22283	720	8	,	,	,
22283	720	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	720	10	believe	believe	VBP
22283	720	11	,	,	,
22283	720	12	be	be	VB
22283	720	13	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
22283	720	14	by	by	IN
22283	720	15	all	all	DT
22283	720	16	historians	historian	NNS
22283	720	17	.	.	.
22283	721	1	Seeing	see	VBG
22283	721	2	that	that	IN
22283	721	3	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	721	4	are	be	VBP
22283	721	5	often	often	RB
22283	721	6	,	,	,
22283	721	7	as	as	IN
22283	721	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	721	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	721	10	said	say	VBN
22283	721	11	,	,	,
22283	721	12	'	'	''
22283	721	13	in	in	IN
22283	721	14	the	the	DT
22283	721	15	air	air	NN
22283	721	16	'	'	''
22283	721	17	before	before	IN
22283	721	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	721	19	are	be	VBP
22283	721	20	condensed	condense	VBN
22283	721	21	in	in	IN
22283	721	22	the	the	DT
22283	721	23	mind	mind	NN
22283	721	24	of	of	IN
22283	721	25	individual	individual	JJ
22283	721	26	genius	genius	NN
22283	721	27	,	,	,
22283	721	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	721	29	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	721	30	speak	speak	VBP
22283	721	31	of	of	IN
22283	721	32	the	the	DT
22283	721	33	'	'	``
22283	721	34	Zeit	Zeit	NNP
22283	721	35	-	-	HYPH
22283	721	36	geist	geist	NN
22283	721	37	'	'	''
22283	721	38	as	as	IN
22283	721	39	the	the	DT
22283	721	40	product	product	NN
22283	721	41	of	of	IN
22283	721	42	a	a	DT
22283	721	43	kind	kind	NN
22283	721	44	of	of	IN
22283	721	45	collective	collective	JJ
22283	721	46	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	721	47	,	,	,
22283	721	48	which	which	WDT
22283	721	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	721	50	something	something	NN
22283	721	51	other	other	JJ
22283	721	52	than	than	IN
22283	721	53	the	the	DT
22283	721	54	mere	mere	JJ
22283	721	55	sum	sum	NN
22283	721	56	of	of	IN
22283	721	57	all	all	PDT
22283	721	58	the	the	DT
22283	721	59	individual	individual	JJ
22283	721	60	minds	mind	NNS
22283	721	61	of	of	IN
22283	721	62	a	a	DT
22283	721	63	generation	generation	NN
22283	721	64	.	.	.
22283	722	1	That	that	DT
22283	722	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	722	3	to	to	TO
22283	722	4	say	say	VB
22283	722	5	,	,	,
22283	722	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	722	7	regard	regard	VBP
22283	722	8	society	society	NN
22283	722	9	as	as	IN
22283	722	10	an	an	DT
22283	722	11	eject	eject	NN
22283	722	12	,	,	,
22283	722	13	and	and	CC
22283	722	14	the	the	DT
22283	722	15	more	more	JJR
22283	722	16	that	that	IN
22283	722	17	a	a	DT
22283	722	18	man	man	NN
22283	722	19	studies	study	VBZ
22283	722	20	the	the	DT
22283	722	21	thought	thought	NN
22283	722	22	and	and	CC
22283	722	23	conduct	conduct	NN
22283	722	24	of	of	IN
22283	722	25	society	society	NN
22283	722	26	,	,	,
22283	722	27	the	the	DT
22283	722	28	more	more	RBR
22283	722	29	does	do	VBZ
22283	722	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	722	31	become	become	VB
22283	722	32	convinced	convinced	JJ
22283	722	33	that	that	IN
22283	722	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	722	35	are	be	VBP
22283	722	36	right	right	JJ
22283	722	37	in	in	IN
22283	722	38	so	so	RB
22283	722	39	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	722	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	722	41	.	.	.
22283	723	1	Of	of	RB
22283	723	2	course	course	RB
22283	723	3	this	this	DT
22283	723	4	eject	eject	NN
22283	723	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	723	6	manifestly	manifestly	RB
22283	723	7	unlike	unlike	IN
22283	723	8	that	that	DT
22283	723	9	which	which	WDT
22283	723	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	723	11	form	form	VBP
22283	723	12	of	of	IN
22283	723	13	another	another	DT
22283	723	14	individual	individual	JJ
22283	723	15	mind	mind	NN
22283	723	16	:	:	:
22283	723	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	723	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	723	19	much	much	RB
22283	723	20	more	more	RBR
22283	723	21	general	general	JJ
22283	723	22	,	,	,
22283	723	23	vague	vague	JJ
22283	723	24	,	,	,
22283	723	25	and	and	CC
22283	723	26	so	so	RB
22283	723	27	far	far	RB
22283	723	28	unlike	unlike	IN
22283	723	29	the	the	DT
22283	723	30	pattern	pattern	NN
22283	723	31	of	of	IN
22283	723	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	723	33	own	own	JJ
22283	723	34	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	723	35	that	that	IN
22283	723	36	even	even	RB
22283	723	37	to	to	TO
22283	723	38	ascribe	ascribe	VB
22283	723	39	to	to	IN
22283	723	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	723	41	the	the	DT
22283	723	42	important	important	JJ
22283	723	43	attribute	attribute	NN
22283	723	44	of	of	IN
22283	723	45	personality	personality	NN
22283	723	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	723	47	felt	feel	VBN
22283	723	48	,	,	,
22283	723	49	as	as	IN
22283	723	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	723	51	have	have	VBP
22283	723	52	just	just	RB
22283	723	53	seen	see	VBN
22283	723	54	,	,	,
22283	723	55	to	to	TO
22283	723	56	approach	approach	VB
22283	723	57	the	the	DT
22283	723	58	grotesque	grotesque	NN
22283	723	59	.	.	.
22283	724	1	Still	still	RB
22283	724	2	,	,	,
22283	724	3	in	in	IN
22283	724	4	this	this	DT
22283	724	5	vague	vague	JJ
22283	724	6	and	and	CC
22283	724	7	general	general	JJ
22283	724	8	way	way	NN
22283	724	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	724	10	do	do	VBP
22283	724	11	ascribe	ascribe	VB
22283	724	12	to	to	IN
22283	724	13	society	society	NN
22283	724	14	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	724	15	existence	existence	NN
22283	724	16	:	:	:
22283	724	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	724	18	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	724	19	think	think	VBP
22283	724	20	of	of	IN
22283	724	21	the	the	DT
22283	724	22	whole	whole	JJ
22283	724	23	world	world	NN
22283	724	24	of	of	IN
22283	724	25	human	human	JJ
22283	724	26	thought	thought	NN
22283	724	27	and	and	CC
22283	724	28	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	724	29	as	as	IN
22283	724	30	a	a	DT
22283	724	31	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	724	32	complex	complex	NN
22283	724	33	,	,	,
22283	724	34	which	which	WDT
22283	724	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	724	36	other	other	JJ
22283	724	37	than	than	IN
22283	724	38	,	,	,
22283	724	39	and	and	CC
22283	724	40	more	more	JJR
22283	724	41	than	than	IN
22283	724	42	,	,	,
22283	724	43	a	a	DT
22283	724	44	mere	mere	JJ
22283	724	45	shorthand	shorthand	NN
22283	724	46	enumeration	enumeration	NN
22283	724	47	of	of	IN
22283	724	48	all	all	PDT
22283	724	49	the	the	DT
22283	724	50	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	724	51	and	and	CC
22283	724	52	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	724	53	of	of	IN
22283	724	54	all	all	DT
22283	724	55	individual	individual	JJ
22283	724	56	human	human	JJ
22283	724	57	beings	being	NNS
22283	724	58	.	.	.
22283	725	1	The	the	DT
22283	725	2	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	725	3	existence	existence	NN
22283	725	4	thus	thus	RB
22283	725	5	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
22283	725	6	to	to	IN
22283	725	7	society	society	NN
22283	725	8	serves	serve	VBZ
22283	725	9	as	as	IN
22283	725	10	a	a	DT
22283	725	11	stepping	stepping	JJ
22283	725	12	-	-	HYPH
22283	725	13	stone	stone	NN
22283	725	14	to	to	IN
22283	725	15	the	the	DT
22283	725	16	yet	yet	RB
22283	725	17	more	more	RBR
22283	725	18	vague	vague	JJ
22283	725	19	and	and	CC
22283	725	20	general	general	JJ
22283	725	21	ascription	ascription	NN
22283	725	22	of	of	IN
22283	725	23	such	such	JJ
22283	725	24	existence	existence	NN
22283	725	25	to	to	IN
22283	725	26	the	the	DT
22283	725	27	Cosmos	Cosmos	NNP
22283	725	28	.	.	.
22283	726	1	At	at	IN
22283	726	2	first	first	RB
22283	726	3	,	,	,
22283	726	4	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	726	5	,	,	,
22283	726	6	or	or	CC
22283	726	7	during	during	IN
22283	726	8	the	the	DT
22283	726	9	earliest	early	JJS
22283	726	10	stages	stage	NNS
22283	726	11	of	of	IN
22283	726	12	culture	culture	NN
22283	726	13	,	,	,
22283	726	14	the	the	DT
22283	726	15	ascription	ascription	NN
22283	726	16	of	of	IN
22283	726	17	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	726	18	existence	existence	NN
22283	726	19	to	to	IN
22283	726	20	the	the	DT
22283	726	21	external	external	JJ
22283	726	22	world	world	NN
22283	726	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	726	24	neither	neither	CC
22283	726	25	vague	vague	JJ
22283	726	26	nor	nor	CC
22283	726	27	general	general	JJ
22283	726	28	:	:	:
22283	726	29	on	on	IN
22283	726	30	the	the	DT
22283	726	31	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	726	32	,	,	,
22283	726	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	726	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	726	35	most	most	RBS
22283	726	36	distinct	distinct	JJ
22283	726	37	and	and	CC
22283	726	38	specific	specific	JJ
22283	726	39	.	.	.
22283	727	1	Beginning	begin	VBG
22283	727	2	in	in	IN
22283	727	3	the	the	DT
22283	727	4	rudest	rude	JJS
22283	727	5	forms	form	NNS
22283	727	6	of	of	IN
22283	727	7	animism	animism	NN
22283	727	8	,	,	,
22283	727	9	where	where	WRB
22283	727	10	every	every	DT
22283	727	11	natural	natural	JJ
22283	727	12	process	process	NN
22283	727	13	admits	admit	NNS
22283	727	14	of	of	IN
22283	727	15	being	be	VBG
22283	727	16	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	727	17	attributed	attribute	VBN
22283	727	18	to	to	IN
22283	727	19	the	the	DT
22283	727	20	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	727	21	agency	agency	NN
22283	727	22	of	of	IN
22283	727	23	an	an	DT
22283	727	24	unseen	unseen	JJ
22283	727	25	spirit	spirit	NN
22283	727	26	,	,	,
22283	727	27	anthropomorphism	anthropomorphism	NN
22283	727	28	sets	set	VBZ
22283	727	29	out	out	RP
22283	727	30	upon	upon	IN
22283	727	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	727	32	long	long	JJ
22283	727	33	course	course	NN
22283	727	34	of	of	IN
22283	727	35	development	development	NN
22283	727	36	,	,	,
22283	727	37	which	which	WDT
22283	727	38	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
22283	727	39	_	_	NNP
22283	727	40	pari	pari	JJ
22283	727	41	passu	passu	NN
22283	727	42	_	_	NNP
22283	727	43	with	with	IN
22283	727	44	the	the	DT
22283	727	45	development	development	NN
22283	727	46	of	of	IN
22283	727	47	abstract	abstract	JJ
22283	727	48	thought	thought	NN
22283	727	49	.	.	.
22283	728	1	Man	man	UH
22283	728	2	,	,	,
22283	728	3	as	as	IN
22283	728	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	728	5	has	have	VBZ
22283	728	6	been	be	VBN
22283	728	7	truly	truly	RB
22283	728	8	said	say	VBN
22283	728	9	,	,	,
22283	728	10	universally	universally	RB
22283	728	11	makes	make	VBZ
22283	728	12	God	God	NNP
22283	728	13	in	in	IN
22283	728	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	728	15	own	own	JJ
22283	728	16	image	image	NN
22283	728	17	;	;	:
22283	728	18	and	and	CC
22283	728	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	728	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	728	21	difficult	difficult	JJ
22283	728	22	to	to	TO
22283	728	23	see	see	VB
22283	728	24	how	how	WRB
22283	728	25	the	the	DT
22283	728	26	case	case	NN
22283	728	27	could	could	MD
22283	728	28	be	be	VB
22283	728	29	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	728	30	.	.	.
22283	729	1	Universally	universally	RB
22283	729	2	the	the	DT
22283	729	3	eject	eject	NN
22283	729	4	must	must	MD
22283	729	5	assume	assume	VB
22283	729	6	the	the	DT
22283	729	7	pattern	pattern	NN
22283	729	8	of	of	IN
22283	729	9	the	the	DT
22283	729	10	subject	subject	NN
22283	729	11	,	,	,
22283	729	12	and	and	CC
22283	729	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	729	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	729	15	only	only	RB
22283	729	16	in	in	IN
22283	729	17	the	the	DT
22283	729	18	proportion	proportion	NN
22283	729	19	that	that	WDT
22283	729	20	this	this	DT
22283	729	21	pattern	pattern	NN
22283	729	22	presents	present	VBZ
22283	729	23	the	the	DT
22283	729	24	features	feature	NNS
22283	729	25	of	of	IN
22283	729	26	abstract	abstract	JJ
22283	729	27	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	729	28	that	that	IN
22283	729	29	the	the	DT
22283	729	30	image	image	NN
22283	729	31	which	which	WDT
22283	729	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	729	33	throws	throw	VBZ
22283	729	34	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	729	35	less	less	JJR
22283	729	36	and	and	CC
22283	729	37	less	less	JJR
22283	729	38	man	man	NN
22283	729	39	-	-	HYPH
22283	729	40	like	like	JJ
22283	729	41	.	.	.
22283	730	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	730	2	,	,	,
22283	730	3	as	as	IN
22283	730	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	730	5	Fiske	Fiske	NNP
22283	730	6	has	have	VBZ
22283	730	7	shown	show	VBN
22283	730	8	in	in	IN
22283	730	9	detail	detail	NN
22283	730	10	,	,	,
22283	730	11	so	so	RB
22283	730	12	soon	soon	RB
22283	730	13	as	as	IN
22283	730	14	anthropomorphism	anthropomorphism	NN
22283	730	15	has	have	VBZ
22283	730	16	assumed	assume	VBN
22283	730	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	730	18	highest	high	JJS
22283	730	19	state	state	NN
22283	730	20	of	of	IN
22283	730	21	development	development	NN
22283	730	22	,	,	,
22283	730	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	730	24	begins	begin	VBZ
22283	730	25	to	to	TO
22283	730	26	be	be	VB
22283	730	27	replaced	replace	VBN
22283	730	28	by	by	IN
22283	730	29	a	a	DT
22283	730	30	continuous	continuous	JJ
22283	730	31	growth	growth	NN
22283	730	32	of	of	IN
22283	730	33	'	'	``
22283	730	34	deanthropomorphism	deanthropomorphism	NN
22283	730	35	,	,	,
22283	730	36	'	'	''
22283	730	37	which	which	WDT
22283	730	38	,	,	,
22283	730	39	passing	pass	VBG
22283	730	40	through	through	IN
22283	730	41	polytheism	polytheism	NN
22283	730	42	into	into	IN
22283	730	43	monotheism	monotheism	NN
22283	730	44	,	,	,
22283	730	45	eventually	eventually	RB
22283	730	46	ends	end	VBZ
22283	730	47	in	in	IN
22283	730	48	a	a	DT
22283	730	49	progressive	progressive	JJ
22283	730	50	'	'	``
22283	730	51	purification	purification	NN
22283	730	52	'	'	''
22283	730	53	of	of	IN
22283	730	54	theism	theism	NN
22283	730	55	--	--	:
22283	730	56	by	by	IN
22283	730	57	which	which	WDT
22283	730	58	is	be	VBZ
22283	730	59	meant	mean	VBN
22283	730	60	a	a	DT
22283	730	61	progressive	progressive	JJ
22283	730	62	metamorphosis	metamorphosis	NN
22283	730	63	of	of	IN
22283	730	64	the	the	DT
22283	730	65	theistic	theistic	JJ
22283	730	66	conception	conception	NN
22283	730	67	,	,	,
22283	730	68	tending	tend	VBG
22283	730	69	to	to	TO
22283	730	70	remove	remove	VB
22283	730	71	from	from	IN
22283	730	72	Deity	Deity	NNP
22283	730	73	the	the	DT
22283	730	74	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	730	75	of	of	IN
22283	730	76	Humanity	Humanity	NNP
22283	730	77	.	.	.
22283	731	1	The	the	DT
22283	731	2	last	last	JJ
22283	731	3	of	of	IN
22283	731	4	these	these	DT
22283	731	5	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	731	6	to	to	TO
22283	731	7	disappear	disappear	VB
22283	731	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	731	9	that	that	DT
22283	731	10	of	of	IN
22283	731	11	personality	personality	NN
22283	731	12	,	,	,
22283	731	13	and	and	CC
22283	731	14	when	when	WRB
22283	731	15	this	this	DT
22283	731	16	final	final	JJ
22283	731	17	ecdysis	ecdysis	NN
22283	731	18	has	have	VBZ
22283	731	19	been	be	VBN
22283	731	20	performed	perform	VBN
22283	731	21	,	,	,
22283	731	22	the	the	DT
22283	731	23	eject	eject	NN
22283	731	24	which	which	WDT
22283	731	25	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	731	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	731	27	so	so	RB
22283	731	28	unlike	unlike	IN
22283	731	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	731	30	original	original	JJ
22283	731	31	subject	subject	NN
22283	731	32	,	,	,
22283	731	33	that	that	IN
22283	731	34	,	,	,
22283	731	35	as	as	IN
22283	731	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	731	37	shall	shall	MD
22283	731	38	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	731	39	find	find	VB
22283	731	40	,	,	,
22283	731	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	731	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	731	43	extremely	extremely	RB
22283	731	44	difficult	difficult	JJ
22283	731	45	to	to	TO
22283	731	46	trace	trace	VB
22283	731	47	any	any	DT
22283	731	48	points	point	NNS
22283	731	49	of	of	IN
22283	731	50	resemblance	resemblance	NN
22283	731	51	between	between	IN
22283	731	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	731	53	.	.	.
22283	732	1	Now	now	RB
22283	732	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	732	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	732	4	with	with	IN
22283	732	5	this	this	DT
22283	732	6	perfect	perfect	JJ
22283	732	7	,	,	,
22283	732	8	or	or	CC
22283	732	9	imago	imago	JJ
22283	732	10	condition	condition	NN
22283	732	11	of	of	IN
22283	732	12	the	the	DT
22283	732	13	world	world	NN
22283	732	14	-	-	HYPH
22283	732	15	eject	eject	NN
22283	732	16	,	,	,
22283	732	17	that	that	IN
22283	732	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	732	19	have	have	VBP
22283	732	20	to	to	TO
22283	732	21	do	do	VB
22283	732	22	.	.	.
22283	733	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	733	2	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
22283	733	3	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	733	4	,	,	,
22283	733	5	in	in	IN
22283	733	6	what	what	WP
22283	733	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	733	8	consider	consider	VBP
22283	733	9	the	the	DT
22283	733	10	profoundest	profoundest	NN
22283	733	11	reaches	reach	NNS
22283	733	12	of	of	IN
22283	733	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	733	14	philosophic	philosophic	JJ
22283	733	15	thought	thought	NN
22283	733	16	,	,	,
22283	733	17	has	have	VBZ
22283	733	18	well	well	RB
22283	733	19	shown	show	VBN
22283	733	20	,	,	,
22283	733	21	on	on	IN
22283	733	22	the	the	DT
22283	733	23	one	one	CD
22283	733	24	hand	hand	NN
22283	733	25	,	,	,
22283	733	26	how	how	WRB
22283	733	27	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	733	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	733	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	733	30	to	to	TO
22283	733	31	attribute	attribute	VB
22283	733	32	to	to	IN
22283	733	33	Deity	Deity	NNP
22283	733	34	any	any	DT
22283	733	35	of	of	IN
22283	733	36	the	the	DT
22283	733	37	specific	specific	JJ
22283	733	38	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	733	39	of	of	IN
22283	733	40	mind	mind	NN
22283	733	41	as	as	IN
22283	733	42	known	know	VBN
22283	733	43	to	to	IN
22283	733	44	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	733	45	subjectively	subjectively	RB
22283	733	46	;	;	:
22283	733	47	and	and	CC
22283	733	48	,	,	,
22283	733	49	on	on	IN
22283	733	50	the	the	DT
22283	733	51	other	other	JJ
22283	733	52	hand	hand	NN
22283	733	53	,	,	,
22283	733	54	how	how	WRB
22283	733	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	733	56	is	be	VBZ
22283	733	57	possible	possible	JJ
22283	733	58	to	to	TO
22283	733	59	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	733	60	'	'	``
22283	733	61	symbolically	symbolically	RB
22283	733	62	'	'	''
22283	733	63	that	that	IN
22283	733	64	the	the	DT
22283	733	65	universe	universe	NN
22283	733	66	may	may	MD
22283	733	67	be	be	VB
22283	733	68	instinct	instinct	NN
22283	733	69	with	with	IN
22283	733	70	a	a	DT
22283	733	71	'	'	``
22283	733	72	quasi	quasi	JJ
22283	733	73	-	-	JJ
22283	733	74	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	733	75	'	'	''
22283	733	76	principle	principle	NN
22283	733	77	,	,	,
22283	733	78	as	as	IN
22283	733	79	greatly	greatly	RB
22283	733	80	transcending	transcend	VBG
22283	733	81	personality	personality	NN
22283	733	82	as	as	IN
22283	733	83	personality	personality	NN
22283	733	84	transcends	transcend	VBZ
22283	733	85	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	733	86	motion[10	motion[10	NNP
22283	733	87	]	]	-RRB-
22283	733	88	.	.	.
22283	734	1	Accepting	accept	VBG
22283	734	2	,	,	,
22283	734	3	then	then	RB
22283	734	4	,	,	,
22283	734	5	the	the	DT
22283	734	6	world	world	NN
22283	734	7	-	-	HYPH
22283	734	8	eject	eject	NN
22283	734	9	in	in	IN
22283	734	10	this	this	DT
22283	734	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	734	12	highest	highest	RBS
22283	734	13	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	734	14	stage	stage	NN
22283	734	15	of	of	IN
22283	734	16	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	734	17	,	,	,
22283	734	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	734	19	desire	desire	VBP
22283	734	20	to	to	TO
22283	734	21	contemplate	contemplate	VB
22283	734	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	734	23	under	under	IN
22283	734	24	the	the	DT
22283	734	25	light	light	NN
22283	734	26	of	of	IN
22283	734	27	the	the	DT
22283	734	28	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	734	29	theory	theory	NN
22283	734	30	.	.	.
22283	735	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	735	2	have	have	VBP
22283	735	3	seen	see	VBN
22283	735	4	that	that	IN
22283	735	5	,	,	,
22283	735	6	whether	whether	IN
22283	735	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	735	8	look	look	VBP
22283	735	9	upon	upon	IN
22283	735	10	the	the	DT
22283	735	11	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	735	12	or	or	CC
22283	735	13	objective	objective	JJ
22283	735	14	face	face	NN
22283	735	15	of	of	IN
22283	735	16	personality	personality	NN
22283	735	17	,	,	,
22283	735	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	735	19	find	find	VBP
22283	735	20	that	that	IN
22283	735	21	personality	personality	NN
22283	735	22	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	735	23	from	from	IN
22283	735	24	limitation	limitation	NN
22283	735	25	--	--	:
22283	735	26	or	or	CC
22283	735	27	,	,	,
22283	735	28	as	as	IN
22283	735	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	735	30	have	have	VBP
22283	735	31	previously	previously	RB
22283	735	32	termed	term	VBN
22283	735	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	735	34	,	,	,
22283	735	35	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	735	36	.	.	.
22283	736	1	Now	now	RB
22283	736	2	,	,	,
22283	736	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	736	4	have	have	VBP
22283	736	5	no	no	DT
22283	736	6	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	736	7	,	,	,
22283	736	8	nor	nor	CC
22283	736	9	are	be	VBP
22283	736	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	736	11	able	able	JJ
22283	736	12	to	to	TO
22283	736	13	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	736	14	,	,	,
22283	736	15	of	of	IN
22283	736	16	the	the	DT
22283	736	17	external	external	JJ
22283	736	18	world	world	NN
22283	736	19	as	as	IN
22283	736	20	limited	limit	VBN
22283	736	21	;	;	:
22283	736	22	consequently	consequently	RB
22283	736	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	736	24	are	be	VBP
22283	736	25	not	not	RB
22283	736	26	able	able	JJ
22283	736	27	to	to	TO
22283	736	28	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	736	29	,	,	,
22283	736	30	of	of	IN
22283	736	31	the	the	DT
22283	736	32	world	world	NN
22283	736	33	-	-	HYPH
22283	736	34	eject	eject	NN
22283	736	35	as	as	IN
22283	736	36	personal	personal	JJ
22283	736	37	.	.	.
22283	737	1	But	but	CC
22283	737	2	,	,	,
22283	737	3	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
22283	737	4	as	as	IN
22283	737	5	personality	personality	NN
22283	737	6	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	737	7	only	only	RB
22283	737	8	from	from	IN
22283	737	9	limitation	limitation	NN
22283	737	10	,	,	,
22283	737	11	the	the	DT
22283	737	12	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	737	13	that	that	IN
22283	737	14	the	the	DT
22283	737	15	world	world	NN
22283	737	16	-	-	HYPH
22283	737	17	eject	eject	NN
22283	737	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	737	19	impersonal	impersonal	JJ
22283	737	20	does	do	VBZ
22283	737	21	not	not	RB
22283	737	22	tend	tend	VB
22283	737	23	to	to	TO
22283	737	24	show	show	VB
22283	737	25	that	that	IN
22283	737	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	737	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	737	28	of	of	IN
22283	737	29	lower	low	JJR
22283	737	30	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	737	31	value	value	NN
22283	737	32	than	than	IN
22283	737	33	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	737	34	personality	personality	NN
22283	737	35	:	:	:
22283	737	36	on	on	IN
22283	737	37	the	the	DT
22283	737	38	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	737	39	,	,	,
22283	737	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	737	41	tends	tend	VBZ
22283	737	42	to	to	TO
22283	737	43	show	show	VB
22283	737	44	that	that	IN
22283	737	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	737	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	737	47	probably	probably	RB
22283	737	48	of	of	IN
22283	737	49	higher	high	JJR
22283	737	50	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	737	51	value	value	NN
22283	737	52	.	.	.
22283	738	1	True	true	JJ
22283	738	2	,	,	,
22283	738	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	738	4	are	be	VBP
22283	738	5	not	not	RB
22283	738	6	able	able	JJ
22283	738	7	to	to	TO
22283	738	8	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	738	9	actually	actually	RB
22283	738	10	of	of	IN
22283	738	11	mind	mind	NN
22283	738	12	as	as	IN
22283	738	13	impersonal	impersonal	JJ
22283	738	14	;	;	:
22283	738	15	but	but	CC
22283	738	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	738	17	can	can	MD
22283	738	18	see	see	VB
22283	738	19	that	that	IN
22283	738	20	this	this	DT
22283	738	21	merely	merely	RB
22283	738	22	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	738	23	from	from	IN
22283	738	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	738	25	only	only	JJ
22283	738	26	experience	experience	NN
22283	738	27	of	of	IN
22283	738	28	mind	mind	NN
22283	738	29	being	be	VBG
22283	738	30	given	give	VBN
22283	738	31	under	under	IN
22283	738	32	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	738	33	of	of	IN
22283	738	34	personality	personality	NN
22283	738	35	;	;	,
22283	738	36	and	and	CC
22283	738	37	,	,	,
22283	738	38	as	as	RB
22283	738	39	just	just	RB
22283	738	40	observed	observe	VBN
22283	738	41	,	,	,
22283	738	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	738	43	is	be	VBZ
22283	738	44	possible	possible	JJ
22283	738	45	to	to	TO
22283	738	46	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	738	47	symbolically	symbolically	RB
22283	738	48	that	that	IN
22283	738	49	there	there	EX
22283	738	50	may	may	MD
22283	738	51	be	be	VB
22283	738	52	a	a	DT
22283	738	53	form	form	NN
22283	738	54	of	of	IN
22283	738	55	mind	mind	NN
22283	738	56	as	as	IN
22283	738	57	greatly	greatly	RB
22283	738	58	transcending	transcend	VBG
22283	738	59	personality	personality	NN
22283	738	60	as	as	IN
22283	738	61	personality	personality	NN
22283	738	62	transcends	transcend	VBZ
22283	738	63	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	738	64	motion	motion	NN
22283	738	65	.	.	.
22283	739	1	Now	now	RB
22283	739	2	,	,	,
22283	739	3	although	although	IN
22283	739	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	739	5	can	can	MD
22283	739	6	not	not	RB
22283	739	7	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	739	8	of	of	IN
22283	739	9	such	such	PDT
22283	739	10	a	a	DT
22283	739	11	mind	mind	NN
22283	739	12	actually	actually	RB
22283	739	13	,	,	,
22283	739	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	739	15	may	may	MD
22283	739	16	most	most	RBS
22283	739	17	probably	probably	RB
22283	739	18	make	make	VB
22283	739	19	the	the	DT
22283	739	20	nearest	near	JJS
22283	739	21	approach	approach	NN
22283	739	22	to	to	IN
22283	739	23	conceiving	conceiving	NN
22283	739	24	of	of	IN
22283	739	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	739	26	truly	truly	RB
22283	739	27	,	,	,
22283	739	28	by	by	IN
22283	739	29	_	_	NNP
22283	739	30	provisionally	provisionally	RB
22283	739	31	_	_	NNP
22283	739	32	ascribing	ascribe	VBG
22283	739	33	to	to	IN
22283	739	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	739	35	the	the	DT
22283	739	36	highest	high	JJS
22283	739	37	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	739	38	of	of	IN
22283	739	39	mind	mind	NN
22283	739	40	as	as	IN
22283	739	41	known	know	VBN
22283	739	42	to	to	IN
22283	739	43	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	739	44	,	,	,
22283	739	45	or	or	CC
22283	739	46	the	the	DT
22283	739	47	attributes	attribute	NNS
22283	739	48	which	which	WDT
22283	739	49	belong	belong	VBP
22283	739	50	to	to	IN
22283	739	51	human	human	JJ
22283	739	52	personality	personality	NN
22283	739	53	.	.	.
22283	740	1	Just	just	RB
22283	740	2	as	as	IN
22283	740	3	a	a	DT
22283	740	4	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	740	5	insect	insect	NN
22283	740	6	would	would	MD
22283	740	7	derive	derive	VB
22283	740	8	a	a	DT
22283	740	9	better	well	JJR
22283	740	10	,	,	,
22283	740	11	or	or	CC
22283	740	12	more	more	RBR
22283	740	13	true	true	JJ
22283	740	14	,	,	,
22283	740	15	conception	conception	NN
22283	740	16	of	of	IN
22283	740	17	human	human	JJ
22283	740	18	personality	personality	NN
22283	740	19	by	by	IN
22283	740	20	considering	consider	VBG
22283	740	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	740	22	ejectively	ejectively	RB
22283	740	23	than	than	IN
22283	740	24	by	by	IN
22283	740	25	considering	consider	VBG
22283	740	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	740	27	objectively	objectively	RB
22283	740	28	(	(	-LRB-
22283	740	29	or	or	CC
22283	740	30	by	by	IN
22283	740	31	considering	consider	VBG
22283	740	32	the	the	DT
22283	740	33	mind	mind	NN
22283	740	34	-	-	HYPH
22283	740	35	processes	process	NNS
22283	740	36	as	as	IN
22283	740	37	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	740	38	from	from	IN
22283	740	39	the	the	DT
22283	740	40	brain	brain	NN
22283	740	41	-	-	HYPH
22283	740	42	processes	process	NNS
22283	740	43	)	)	-RRB-
22283	740	44	,	,	,
22283	740	45	so	so	CC
22283	740	46	,	,	,
22283	740	47	if	if	IN
22283	740	48	there	there	EX
22283	740	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	740	50	a	a	DT
22283	740	51	form	form	NN
22283	740	52	of	of	IN
22283	740	53	mind	mind	NN
22283	740	54	immeasurably	immeasurably	RB
22283	740	55	superior	superior	JJ
22283	740	56	to	to	IN
22283	740	57	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	740	58	own	own	JJ
22283	740	59	,	,	,
22283	740	60	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	740	61	may	may	MD
22283	740	62	probably	probably	RB
22283	740	63	gain	gain	VB
22283	740	64	a	a	DT
22283	740	65	more	more	RBR
22283	740	66	faithful	faithful	JJ
22283	740	67	--	--	:
22283	740	68	howsoever	howsoever	RB
22283	740	69	still	still	RB
22283	740	70	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
22283	740	71	--	--	:
22283	740	72	conception	conception	NN
22283	740	73	of	of	IN
22283	740	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	740	75	by	by	IN
22283	740	76	contemplating	contemplate	VBG
22283	740	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	740	78	operations	operation	NNS
22283	740	79	ejectively	ejectively	RB
22283	740	80	than	than	IN
22283	740	81	by	by	IN
22283	740	82	doing	do	VBG
22283	740	83	so	so	RB
22283	740	84	objectively	objectively	RB
22283	740	85	.	.	.
22283	741	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	741	2	will	will	MD
22283	741	3	,	,	,
22283	741	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	741	5	,	,	,
22283	741	6	speak	speak	VB
22283	741	7	of	of	IN
22283	741	8	the	the	DT
22283	741	9	world	world	NN
22283	741	10	-	-	HYPH
22283	741	11	eject	eject	NN
22283	741	12	as	as	IN
22283	741	13	presenting	present	VBG
22283	741	14	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	741	15	volition	volition	NN
22283	741	16	,	,	,
22283	741	17	on	on	IN
22283	741	18	the	the	DT
22283	741	19	understanding	understanding	NN
22283	741	20	that	that	IN
22283	741	21	if	if	IN
22283	741	22	_	_	NNP
22283	741	23	x	x	NNP
22283	741	24	_	_	NNP
22283	741	25	does	do	VBZ
22283	741	26	not	not	RB
22283	741	27	present	present	VB
22283	741	28	either	either	DT
22283	741	29	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	741	30	or	or	CC
22283	741	31	volition	volition	NN
22283	741	32	,	,	,
22283	741	33	this	this	DT
22283	741	34	must	must	MD
22283	741	35	be	be	VB
22283	741	36	--	--	:
22283	741	37	according	accord	VBG
22283	741	38	to	to	IN
22283	741	39	the	the	DT
22283	741	40	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	741	41	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	741	42	of	of	IN
22283	741	43	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	741	44	on	on	IN
22283	741	45	which	which	WDT
22283	741	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	741	47	are	be	VBP
22283	741	48	now	now	RB
22283	741	49	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	741	50	--	--	:
22283	741	51	because	because	IN
22283	741	52	_	_	NNP
22283	741	53	x	x	NNP
22283	741	54	_	_	NNP
22283	741	55	presents	present	VBZ
22283	741	56	attributes	attribute	VBZ
22283	741	57	at	at	IN
22283	741	58	least	least	JJS
22283	741	59	as	as	RB
22283	741	60	much	much	RB
22283	741	61	higher	high	JJR
22283	741	62	than	than	IN
22283	741	63	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	741	64	or	or	CC
22283	741	65	volition	volition	NN
22283	741	66	as	as	IN
22283	741	67	these	these	DT
22283	741	68	are	be	VBP
22283	741	69	higher	high	JJR
22283	741	70	than	than	IN
22283	741	71	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	741	72	motion	motion	NN
22283	741	73	.	.	.
22283	742	1	For	for	IN
22283	742	2	when	when	WRB
22283	742	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	742	4	consider	consider	VBP
22283	742	5	the	the	DT
22283	742	6	utmost	utmost	NN
22283	742	7	that	that	WDT
22283	742	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	742	9	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	742	10	volition	volition	NN
22283	742	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	742	12	able	able	JJ
22283	742	13	to	to	TO
22283	742	14	accomplish	accomplish	VB
22283	742	15	in	in	IN
22283	742	16	the	the	DT
22283	742	17	way	way	NN
22283	742	18	of	of	IN
22283	742	19	contrivance	contrivance	NN
22283	742	20	--	--	:
22283	742	21	how	how	WRB
22283	742	22	limited	limited	JJ
22283	742	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	742	24	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	742	25	,	,	,
22283	742	26	how	how	WRB
22283	742	27	short	short	JJ
22283	742	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	742	29	duration	duration	NN
22283	742	30	,	,	,
22283	742	31	how	how	WRB
22283	742	32	restricted	restrict	VBN
22283	742	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	742	34	range	range	NN
22283	742	35	,	,	,
22283	742	36	and	and	CC
22283	742	37	how	how	WRB
22283	742	38	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
22283	742	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	742	40	adaptations	adaptation	NNS
22283	742	41	--	--	:
22283	742	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	742	43	can	can	MD
22283	742	44	only	only	RB
22283	742	45	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	742	46	that	that	IN
22283	742	47	_	_	NNP
22283	742	48	if	if	IN
22283	742	49	_	_	NNP
22283	742	50	the	the	DT
22283	742	51	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	742	52	constitution	constitution	NN
22283	742	53	of	of	IN
22283	742	54	all	all	DT
22283	742	55	things	thing	NNS
22283	742	56	is	be	VBZ
22283	742	57	pyschical	pyschical	JJ
22283	742	58	,	,	,
22283	742	59	the	the	DT
22283	742	60	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	742	61	of	of	IN
22283	742	62	the	the	DT
22283	742	63	Cosmos	Cosmos	NNP
22283	742	64	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	742	65	a	a	DT
22283	742	66	'	'	``
22283	742	67	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	742	68	of	of	IN
22283	742	69	the	the	DT
22283	742	70	Unconscious	unconscious	JJ
22283	742	71	'	'	''
22283	742	72	only	only	RB
22283	742	73	because	because	IN
22283	742	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	742	75	is	be	VBZ
22283	742	76	a	a	DT
22283	742	77	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	742	78	of	of	IN
22283	742	79	the	the	DT
22283	742	80	Superconscious	Superconscious	NNP
22283	742	81	.	.	.
22283	743	1	Now	now	RB
22283	743	2	,	,	,
22283	743	3	if	if	IN
22283	743	4	once	once	IN
22283	743	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	743	6	feel	feel	VBP
22283	743	7	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	743	8	able	able	JJ
22283	743	9	to	to	TO
22283	743	10	transcend	transcend	VB
22283	743	11	the	the	DT
22283	743	12	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
22283	743	13	--	--	:
22283	743	14	and	and	CC
22283	743	15	doubtless	doubtless	RB
22283	743	16	very	very	RB
22283	743	17	considerable	considerable	JJ
22283	743	18	--	--	:
22283	743	19	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	743	20	of	of	IN
22283	743	21	symbolically	symbolically	RB
22283	743	22	conceiving	conceive	VBG
22283	743	23	the	the	DT
22283	743	24	world	world	NN
22283	743	25	-	-	HYPH
22283	743	26	eject	eject	NN
22283	743	27	as	as	IN
22283	743	28	super	super	JJ
22283	743	29	-	-	JJ
22283	743	30	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	743	31	,	,	,
22283	743	32	and	and	CC
22283	743	33	(	(	-LRB-
22283	743	34	because	because	IN
22283	743	35	not	not	RB
22283	743	36	limited	limited	JJ
22283	743	37	)	)	-RRB-
22283	743	38	also	also	RB
22283	743	39	super	super	JJ
22283	743	40	-	-	JJ
22283	743	41	personal	personal	JJ
22283	743	42	,	,	,
22283	743	43	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	743	44	think	think	VBP
22283	743	45	there	there	EX
22283	743	46	can	can	MD
22283	743	47	be	be	VB
22283	743	48	no	no	DT
22283	743	49	question	question	NN
22283	743	50	that	that	IN
22283	743	51	the	the	DT
22283	743	52	world	world	NN
22283	743	53	-	-	HYPH
22283	743	54	object	object	NN
22283	743	55	furnishes	furnishe	NNS
22283	743	56	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
22283	743	57	proof	proof	NN
22283	743	58	of	of	IN
22283	743	59	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	743	60	.	.	.
22283	744	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	744	2	candidly	candidly	RB
22283	744	3	confess	confess	VBP
22283	744	4	that	that	IN
22283	744	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	744	6	am	be	VBP
22283	744	7	not	not	RB
22283	744	8	myself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	744	9	able	able	JJ
22283	744	10	to	to	TO
22283	744	11	overcome	overcome	VB
22283	744	12	the	the	DT
22283	744	13	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
22283	744	14	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	744	15	in	in	IN
22283	744	16	question	question	NN
22283	744	17	.	.	.
22283	745	1	By	by	IN
22283	745	2	discharging	discharge	VBG
22283	745	3	the	the	DT
22283	745	4	elements	element	NNS
22283	745	5	of	of	IN
22283	745	6	personality	personality	NN
22283	745	7	and	and	CC
22283	745	8	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	745	9	volition	volition	NN
22283	745	10	from	from	IN
22283	745	11	the	the	DT
22283	745	12	world	world	NN
22283	745	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	745	14	eject	eject	NN
22283	745	15	,	,	,
22283	745	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	745	17	appear	appear	VBP
22283	745	18	to	to	TO
22283	745	19	be	be	VB
22283	745	20	discharging	discharge	VBG
22283	745	21	from	from	IN
22283	745	22	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	745	23	conception	conception	NN
22283	745	24	of	of	IN
22283	745	25	mind	mind	NN
22283	745	26	all	all	PDT
22283	745	27	that	that	WDT
22283	745	28	most	most	RBS
22283	745	29	distinctively	distinctively	RB
22283	745	30	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	745	31	to	to	IN
22283	745	32	that	that	DT
22283	745	33	conception	conception	NN
22283	745	34	;	;	:
22283	745	35	and	and	CC
22283	745	36	thus	thus	RB
22283	745	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	745	38	seem	seem	VBP
22283	745	39	to	to	TO
22283	745	40	be	be	VB
22283	745	41	brought	bring	VBN
22283	745	42	back	back	RB
22283	745	43	again	again	RB
22283	745	44	to	to	IN
22283	745	45	the	the	DT
22283	745	46	point	point	NN
22283	745	47	from	from	IN
22283	745	48	which	which	WDT
22283	745	49	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	745	50	started	start	VBD
22283	745	51	:	:	:
22283	745	52	the	the	DT
22283	745	53	world	world	NN
22283	745	54	-	-	HYPH
22283	745	55	eject	eject	NN
22283	745	56	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	745	57	to	to	TO
22283	745	58	have	have	VB
22283	745	59	again	again	RB
22283	745	60	resolved	resolve	VBN
22283	745	61	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	745	62	into	into	IN
22283	745	63	the	the	DT
22283	745	64	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	745	65	quantity	quantity	NN
22283	745	66	_	_	NNP
22283	745	67	x	x	NNP
22283	745	68	_	_	NNP
22283	745	69	.	.	.
22283	746	1	But	but	CC
22283	746	2	here	here	RB
22283	746	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	746	4	must	must	MD
22283	746	5	distinguish	distinguish	VB
22283	746	6	between	between	IN
22283	746	7	actual	actual	JJ
22283	746	8	conception	conception	NN
22283	746	9	and	and	CC
22283	746	10	symbolical	symbolical	JJ
22283	746	11	conception	conception	NN
22283	746	12	.	.	.
22283	747	1	Although	although	IN
22283	747	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	747	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	747	4	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
22283	747	5	true	true	JJ
22283	747	6	that	that	IN
22283	747	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	747	8	can	can	MD
22283	747	9	form	form	VB
22283	747	10	no	no	DT
22283	747	11	actual	actual	JJ
22283	747	12	conception	conception	NN
22283	747	13	of	of	IN
22283	747	14	Mind	mind	NN
22283	747	15	save	save	VB
22283	747	16	as	as	IN
22283	747	17	an	an	DT
22283	747	18	eject	eject	NN
22283	747	19	of	of	IN
22283	747	20	personality	personality	NN
22283	747	21	and	and	CC
22283	747	22	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	747	23	volition	volition	NN
22283	747	24	,	,	,
22283	747	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	747	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	747	27	a	a	DT
22283	747	28	question	question	NN
22283	747	29	whether	whether	IN
22283	747	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	747	31	am	be	VBP
22283	747	32	not	not	RB
22283	747	33	able	able	JJ
22283	747	34	to	to	TO
22283	747	35	form	form	VB
22283	747	36	a	a	DT
22283	747	37	symbolical	symbolical	JJ
22283	747	38	conception	conception	NN
22283	747	39	of	of	IN
22283	747	40	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	747	41	as	as	RB
22283	747	42	thus	thus	RB
22283	747	43	extended	extend	VBN
22283	747	44	.	.	.
22283	748	1	For	for	IN
22283	748	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	748	3	know	know	VBP
22283	748	4	that	that	DT
22283	748	5	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	748	6	,	,	,
22283	748	7	implying	imply	VBG
22283	748	8	as	as	IN
22283	748	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	748	10	does	do	VBZ
22283	748	11	continual	continual	JJ
22283	748	12	change	change	NN
22283	748	13	in	in	IN
22283	748	14	serial	serial	JJ
22283	748	15	order	order	NN
22283	748	16	of	of	IN
22283	748	17	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	748	18	mental	mental	JJ
22283	748	19	processes	process	NNS
22283	748	20	,	,	,
22283	748	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	748	22	not	not	RB
22283	748	23	(	(	-LRB-
22283	748	24	symbolically	symbolically	RB
22283	748	25	considered	consider	VBN
22283	748	26	)	)	-RRB-
22283	748	27	the	the	DT
22283	748	28	highest	highest	RBS
22283	748	29	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
22283	748	30	exhibition	exhibition	NN
22283	748	31	of	of	IN
22283	748	32	Mind	mind	NN
22283	748	33	;	;	:
22283	748	34	and	and	CC
22283	748	35	just	just	RB
22283	748	36	as	as	IN
22283	748	37	a	a	DT
22283	748	38	mathematician	mathematician	NN
22283	748	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	748	40	able	able	JJ
22283	748	41	to	to	TO
22283	748	42	deal	deal	VB
22283	748	43	symbolically	symbolically	RB
22283	748	44	with	with	IN
22283	748	45	space	space	NN
22283	748	46	of	of	IN
22283	748	47	_	_	NNP
22283	748	48	n	n	CC
22283	748	49	_	_	NNP
22283	748	50	dimensions	dimension	NNS
22283	748	51	,	,	,
22283	748	52	while	while	IN
22283	748	53	only	only	RB
22283	748	54	able	able	JJ
22283	748	55	really	really	RB
22283	748	56	to	to	TO
22283	748	57	conceive	conceive	VB
22283	748	58	of	of	IN
22283	748	59	space	space	NN
22283	748	60	as	as	IN
22283	748	61	limited	limit	VBN
22283	748	62	to	to	IN
22283	748	63	three	three	CD
22283	748	64	dimensions	dimension	NNS
22283	748	65	,	,	,
22283	748	66	so	so	CC
22283	748	67	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	748	68	feel	feel	VBP
22283	748	69	that	that	IN
22283	748	70	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	748	71	ought	ought	MD
22283	748	72	not	not	RB
22283	748	73	to	to	TO
22283	748	74	limit	limit	VB
22283	748	75	the	the	DT
22283	748	76	abstract	abstract	JJ
22283	748	77	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	748	78	of	of	IN
22283	748	79	mental	mental	JJ
22283	748	80	being	being	NN
22283	748	81	by	by	IN
22283	748	82	what	what	WP
22283	748	83	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	748	84	may	may	MD
22283	748	85	term	term	VB
22283	748	86	the	the	DT
22283	748	87	accidental	accidental	JJ
22283	748	88	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	748	89	of	of	IN
22283	748	90	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	748	91	own	own	JJ
22283	748	92	being	being	NN
22283	748	93	.	.	.
22283	749	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	749	2	need	need	VBP
22283	749	3	scarcely	scarcely	RB
22283	749	4	wait	wait	VB
22283	749	5	to	to	TO
22283	749	6	show	show	VB
22283	749	7	why	why	WRB
22283	749	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	749	9	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	749	10	to	to	IN
22283	749	11	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	749	12	that	that	IN
22283	749	13	if	if	IN
22283	749	14	this	this	DT
22283	749	15	position	position	NN
22283	749	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	749	17	granted	grant	VBN
22283	749	18	,	,	,
22283	749	19	the	the	DT
22283	749	20	world	world	NN
22283	749	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	749	22	object	object	NN
22283	749	23	furnishes	furnishe	NNS
22283	749	24	,	,	,
22283	749	25	as	as	IN
22283	749	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	749	27	have	have	VBP
22283	749	28	said	say	VBD
22283	749	29	,	,	,
22283	749	30	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
22283	749	31	proof	proof	NN
22283	749	32	of	of	IN
22283	749	33	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	749	34	;	;	,
22283	749	35	for	for	IN
22283	749	36	this	this	DT
22283	749	37	proof	proof	NN
22283	749	38	has	have	VBZ
22283	749	39	been	be	VBN
22283	749	40	ably	ably	RB
22283	749	41	presented	present	VBN
22283	749	42	by	by	IN
22283	749	43	many	many	JJ
22283	749	44	other	other	JJ
22283	749	45	writers	writer	NNS
22283	749	46	.	.	.
22283	750	1	There	there	EX
22283	750	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	750	3	first	first	RB
22283	750	4	the	the	DT
22283	750	5	antecedent	antecedent	NN
22283	750	6	improbability	improbability	NN
22283	750	7	that	that	IN
22283	750	8	the	the	DT
22283	750	9	human	human	JJ
22283	750	10	mind	mind	NN
22283	750	11	should	should	MD
22283	750	12	be	be	VB
22283	750	13	the	the	DT
22283	750	14	highest	high	JJS
22283	750	15	manifestation	manifestation	NN
22283	750	16	of	of	IN
22283	750	17	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	750	18	in	in	IN
22283	750	19	this	this	DT
22283	750	20	universe	universe	NN
22283	750	21	of	of	IN
22283	750	22	infinite	infinite	JJ
22283	750	23	objectivity	objectivity	NN
22283	750	24	.	.	.
22283	751	1	There	there	EX
22283	751	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	751	3	next	next	JJ
22283	751	4	the	the	DT
22283	751	5	fact	fact	NN
22283	751	6	that	that	IN
22283	751	7	throughout	throughout	IN
22283	751	8	this	this	DT
22283	751	9	universe	universe	NN
22283	751	10	of	of	IN
22283	751	11	infinite	infinite	JJ
22283	751	12	objectivity	objectivity	NN
22283	751	13	--	--	:
22283	751	14	so	so	RB
22283	751	15	far	far	RB
22283	751	16	,	,	,
22283	751	17	at	at	IN
22283	751	18	least	least	JJS
22283	751	19	,	,	,
22283	751	20	as	as	IN
22283	751	21	human	human	JJ
22283	751	22	observation	observation	NN
22283	751	23	can	can	MD
22283	751	24	extend	extend	VB
22283	751	25	--	--	:
22283	751	26	there	there	EX
22283	751	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	751	28	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
22283	751	29	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	751	30	of	of	IN
22283	751	31	some	some	DT
22283	751	32	one	one	CD
22283	751	33	integrating	integrate	VBG
22283	751	34	principle	principle	NN
22283	751	35	,	,	,
22283	751	36	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	751	37	all	all	PDT
22283	751	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	751	39	many	many	JJ
22283	751	40	and	and	CC
22283	751	41	complex	complex	JJ
22283	751	42	parts	part	NNS
22283	751	43	are	be	VBP
22283	751	44	correlated	correlate	VBN
22283	751	45	with	with	IN
22283	751	46	one	one	CD
22283	751	47	another	another	DT
22283	751	48	in	in	IN
22283	751	49	such	such	JJ
22283	751	50	wise	wise	JJ
22283	751	51	that	that	IN
22283	751	52	the	the	DT
22283	751	53	result	result	NN
22283	751	54	is	be	VBZ
22283	751	55	universal	universal	JJ
22283	751	56	order	order	NN
22283	751	57	.	.	.
22283	752	1	And	and	CC
22283	752	2	if	if	IN
22283	752	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	752	4	take	take	VBP
22283	752	5	any	any	DT
22283	752	6	part	part	NN
22283	752	7	of	of	IN
22283	752	8	the	the	DT
22283	752	9	whole	whole	JJ
22283	752	10	system	system	NN
22283	752	11	--	--	:
22283	752	12	such	such	JJ
22283	752	13	as	as	IN
22283	752	14	that	that	DT
22283	752	15	of	of	IN
22283	752	16	organic	organic	JJ
22283	752	17	nature	nature	NN
22283	752	18	on	on	IN
22283	752	19	this	this	DT
22283	752	20	planet	planet	NN
22283	752	21	--	--	:
22283	752	22	to	to	TO
22283	752	23	examine	examine	VB
22283	752	24	in	in	IN
22283	752	25	more	more	JJR
22283	752	26	detail	detail	NN
22283	752	27	,	,	,
22283	752	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	752	29	find	find	VBP
22283	752	30	that	that	IN
22283	752	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	752	32	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	752	33	to	to	TO
22283	752	34	be	be	VB
22283	752	35	instinct	instinct	NN
22283	752	36	with	with	IN
22283	752	37	contrivance	contrivance	NN
22283	752	38	.	.	.
22283	753	1	So	so	RB
22283	753	2	to	to	TO
22283	753	3	speak	speak	VB
22283	753	4	,	,	,
22283	753	5	wherever	wherever	WRB
22283	753	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	753	7	tap	tap	VBP
22283	753	8	organic	organic	JJ
22283	753	9	nature	nature	NN
22283	753	10	,	,	,
22283	753	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	753	12	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	753	13	to	to	TO
22283	753	14	flow	flow	VB
22283	753	15	with	with	IN
22283	753	16	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	753	17	;	;	:
22283	753	18	and	and	CC
22283	753	19	,	,	,
22283	753	20	as	as	IN
22283	753	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	753	22	shall	shall	MD
22283	753	23	presently	presently	RB
22283	753	24	see	see	VB
22283	753	25	,	,	,
22283	753	26	upon	upon	IN
22283	753	27	the	the	DT
22283	753	28	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	753	29	theory	theory	NN
22283	753	30	the	the	DT
22283	753	31	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	753	32	of	of	IN
22283	753	33	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	753	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	753	35	here	here	RB
22283	753	36	in	in	IN
22283	753	37	no	no	DT
22283	753	38	way	way	NN
22283	753	39	attenuated	attenuate	VBN
22283	753	40	by	by	IN
22283	753	41	a	a	DT
22283	753	42	full	full	JJ
22283	753	43	acceptance	acceptance	NN
22283	753	44	of	of	IN
22283	753	45	any	any	DT
22283	753	46	of	of	IN
22283	753	47	the	the	DT
22283	753	48	'	'	``
22283	753	49	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	753	50	'	'	POS
22283	753	51	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	753	52	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	753	53	by	by	IN
22283	753	54	science	science	NN
22283	753	55	.	.	.
22283	754	1	Now	now	RB
22283	754	2	,	,	,
22283	754	3	these	these	DT
22283	754	4	large	large	JJ
22283	754	5	and	and	CC
22283	754	6	important	important	JJ
22283	754	7	facts	fact	NNS
22283	754	8	of	of	IN
22283	754	9	observation	observation	NN
22283	754	10	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
22283	754	11	point	point	NN
22283	754	12	,	,	,
22283	754	13	as	as	RB
22283	754	14	just	just	RB
22283	754	15	observed	observe	VBN
22283	754	16	,	,	,
22283	754	17	to	to	IN
22283	754	18	some	some	DT
22283	754	19	one	one	CD
22283	754	20	integrating	integrate	VBG
22283	754	21	principle	principle	NN
22283	754	22	as	as	IN
22283	754	23	pervading	pervade	VBG
22283	754	24	the	the	DT
22283	754	25	Cosmos	Cosmos	NNP
22283	754	26	;	;	:
22283	754	27	and	and	CC
22283	754	28	,	,	,
22283	754	29	if	if	IN
22283	754	30	so	so	RB
22283	754	31	,	,	,
22283	754	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	754	33	can	can	MD
22283	754	34	scarcely	scarcely	RB
22283	754	35	be	be	VB
22283	754	36	wrong	wrong	JJ
22283	754	37	in	in	IN
22283	754	38	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	754	39	that	that	IN
22283	754	40	among	among	IN
22283	754	41	all	all	DT
22283	754	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	754	43	conceptions	conception	NNS
22283	754	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	754	45	must	must	MD
22283	754	46	hold	hold	VB
22283	754	47	nearest	near	JJS
22283	754	48	kinship	kinship	NN
22283	754	49	to	to	IN
22283	754	50	that	that	DT
22283	754	51	which	which	WDT
22283	754	52	is	be	VBZ
22283	754	53	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	754	54	highest	high	JJS
22283	754	55	conception	conception	NN
22283	754	56	of	of	IN
22283	754	57	an	an	DT
22283	754	58	integrating	integrating	NN
22283	754	59	cause	cause	NN
22283	754	60	--	--	:
22283	754	61	viz	viz	NNP
22283	754	62	.	.	NNP
22283	754	63	,	,	,
22283	754	64	the	the	DT
22283	754	65	conception	conception	NN
22283	754	66	of	of	IN
22283	754	67	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	754	68	.	.	.
22283	755	1	Assuredly	assuredly	RB
22283	755	2	no	no	DT
22283	755	3	human	human	JJ
22283	755	4	mind	mind	NN
22283	755	5	could	could	MD
22283	755	6	either	either	CC
22283	755	7	have	have	VB
22283	755	8	devised	devise	VBN
22283	755	9	or	or	CC
22283	755	10	maintained	maintain	VBN
22283	755	11	the	the	DT
22283	755	12	working	working	NN
22283	755	13	of	of	IN
22283	755	14	even	even	RB
22283	755	15	a	a	DT
22283	755	16	fragment	fragment	NN
22283	755	17	of	of	IN
22283	755	18	Nature	nature	NN
22283	755	19	;	;	:
22283	755	20	and	and	CC
22283	755	21	,	,	,
22283	755	22	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	755	23	,	,	,
22283	755	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	755	25	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	755	26	but	but	CC
22283	755	27	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
22283	755	28	to	to	TO
22283	755	29	conclude	conclude	VB
22283	755	30	that	that	IN
22283	755	31	the	the	DT
22283	755	32	integrating	integrate	VBG
22283	755	33	principle	principle	NN
22283	755	34	of	of	IN
22283	755	35	the	the	DT
22283	755	36	whole	whole	NN
22283	755	37	--	--	:
22283	755	38	the	the	DT
22283	755	39	Spirit	Spirit	NNP
22283	755	40	,	,	,
22283	755	41	as	as	IN
22283	755	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	755	43	were	be	VBD
22283	755	44	,	,	,
22283	755	45	of	of	IN
22283	755	46	the	the	DT
22283	755	47	Universe	Universe	NNP
22283	755	48	--	--	:
22283	755	49	must	must	MD
22283	755	50	be	be	VB
22283	755	51	something	something	NN
22283	755	52	which	which	WDT
22283	755	53	,	,	,
22283	755	54	while	while	IN
22283	755	55	as	as	IN
22283	755	56	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	755	57	have	have	VBP
22283	755	58	said	say	VBD
22283	755	59	holding	hold	VBG
22283	755	60	nearest	near	JJS
22283	755	61	kinship	kinship	NN
22283	755	62	with	with	IN
22283	755	63	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	755	64	highest	high	JJS
22283	755	65	conception	conception	NN
22283	755	66	of	of	IN
22283	755	67	disposing	dispose	VBG
22283	755	68	power	power	NN
22283	755	69	,	,	,
22283	755	70	must	must	MD
22283	755	71	yet	yet	RB
22283	755	72	be	be	VB
22283	755	73	immeasurably	immeasurably	RB
22283	755	74	superior	superior	JJ
22283	755	75	to	to	IN
22283	755	76	the	the	DT
22283	755	77	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	755	78	of	of	IN
22283	755	79	man	man	NN
22283	755	80	.	.	.
22283	756	1	The	the	DT
22283	756	2	world	world	NN
22283	756	3	-	-	HYPH
22283	756	4	eject	eject	NN
22283	756	5	thus	thus	RB
22283	756	6	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	756	7	invested	invest	VBN
22283	756	8	with	with	IN
22283	756	9	a	a	DT
22283	756	10	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	756	11	value	value	NN
22283	756	12	as	as	IN
22283	756	13	greatly	greatly	RB
22283	756	14	transcending	transcend	VBG
22283	756	15	in	in	IN
22283	756	16	magnitude	magnitude	NN
22283	756	17	that	that	DT
22283	756	18	of	of	IN
22283	756	19	the	the	DT
22283	756	20	human	human	JJ
22283	756	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	756	22	,	,	,
22283	756	23	as	as	IN
22283	756	24	the	the	DT
22283	756	25	material	material	NN
22283	756	26	frame	frame	NN
22283	756	27	of	of	IN
22283	756	28	the	the	DT
22283	756	29	universe	universe	NNP
22283	756	30	transcends	transcend	VBZ
22283	756	31	in	in	IN
22283	756	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	756	33	magnitude	magnitude	NN
22283	756	34	the	the	DT
22283	756	35	material	material	NN
22283	756	36	frame	frame	NN
22283	756	37	of	of	IN
22283	756	38	the	the	DT
22283	756	39	human	human	JJ
22283	756	40	body	body	NN
22283	756	41	.	.	.
22283	757	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	757	2	,	,	,
22283	757	3	without	without	IN
22283	757	4	in	in	IN
22283	757	5	any	any	DT
22283	757	6	way	way	NN
22283	757	7	straining	strain	VBG
22283	757	8	the	the	DT
22283	757	9	theory	theory	NN
22283	757	10	of	of	IN
22283	757	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	757	12	,	,	,
22283	757	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	757	14	may	may	MD
22283	757	15	provisionally	provisionally	RB
22283	757	16	shade	shade	VB
22283	757	17	_	_	NNP
22283	757	18	x	x	NNP
22283	757	19	_	_	NNP
22283	757	20	more	more	RBR
22283	757	21	deeply	deeply	RB
22283	757	22	than	than	IN
22283	757	23	_	_	NNP
22283	757	24	z	z	NNP
22283	757	25	_	_	NNP
22283	757	26	,	,	,
22283	757	27	and	and	CC
22283	757	28	this	this	DT
22283	757	29	in	in	IN
22283	757	30	some	some	DT
22283	757	31	immeasurable	immeasurable	JJ
22283	757	32	degree	degree	NN
22283	757	33	.	.	.
22283	758	1	*	*	NFP
22283	758	2	*	*	NFP
22283	758	3	*	*	NFP
22283	758	4	*	*	NFP
22283	758	5	*	*	NFP
22283	758	6	One	one	CD
22283	758	7	other	other	JJ
22283	758	8	matter	matter	NN
22283	758	9	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	758	10	to	to	TO
22283	758	11	be	be	VB
22283	758	12	considered	consider	VBN
22283	758	13	with	with	IN
22283	758	14	reference	reference	NN
22283	758	15	to	to	IN
22283	758	16	this	this	DT
22283	758	17	world	world	NN
22283	758	18	-	-	HYPH
22283	758	19	eject	eject	NN
22283	758	20	as	as	IN
22283	758	21	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
22283	758	22	by	by	IN
22283	758	23	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	758	24	.	.	.
22283	759	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	759	2	leaves	leave	VBZ
22283	759	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	759	4	free	free	JJ
22283	759	5	to	to	TO
22283	759	6	regard	regard	VB
22283	759	7	all	all	DT
22283	759	8	natural	natural	JJ
22283	759	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	759	10	as	as	IN
22283	759	11	a	a	DT
22283	759	12	direct	direct	JJ
22283	759	13	exhibition	exhibition	NN
22283	759	14	of	of	IN
22283	759	15	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	759	16	.	.	.
22283	760	1	The	the	DT
22283	760	2	prejudice	prejudice	NN
22283	760	3	against	against	IN
22283	760	4	anything	anything	NN
22283	760	5	approaching	approach	VBG
22283	760	6	a	a	DT
22283	760	7	theistic	theistic	JJ
22283	760	8	interpretation	interpretation	NN
22283	760	9	of	of	IN
22283	760	10	the	the	DT
22283	760	11	Universe	Universe	NNP
22283	760	12	nowadays	nowadays	RB
22283	760	13	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	760	14	chiefly	chiefly	RB
22283	760	15	from	from	IN
22283	760	16	the	the	DT
22283	760	17	advance	advance	NN
22283	760	18	of	of	IN
22283	760	19	physical	physical	JJ
22283	760	20	science	science	NN
22283	760	21	having	have	VBG
22283	760	22	practically	practically	RB
22283	760	23	revealed	reveal	VBN
22283	760	24	the	the	DT
22283	760	25	ubiquity	ubiquity	NN
22283	760	26	of	of	IN
22283	760	27	natural	natural	JJ
22283	760	28	causes	cause	NNS
22283	760	29	.	.	.
22283	761	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	761	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	761	3	felt	feel	VBN
22283	761	4	that	that	IN
22283	761	5	when	when	WRB
22283	761	6	a	a	DT
22283	761	7	complete	complete	JJ
22283	761	8	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	761	9	of	of	IN
22283	761	10	any	any	DT
22283	761	11	given	give	VBN
22283	761	12	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
22283	761	13	has	have	VBZ
22283	761	14	been	be	VBN
22283	761	15	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	761	16	in	in	IN
22283	761	17	terms	term	NNS
22283	761	18	of	of	IN
22283	761	19	these	these	DT
22283	761	20	causes	cause	NNS
22283	761	21	,	,	,
22283	761	22	there	there	EX
22283	761	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	761	24	no	no	DT
22283	761	25	need	need	NN
22283	761	26	to	to	TO
22283	761	27	go	go	VB
22283	761	28	further	further	RB
22283	761	29	;	;	:
22283	761	30	the	the	DT
22283	761	31	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
22283	761	32	has	have	VBZ
22283	761	33	been	be	VBN
22283	761	34	rendered	render	VBN
22283	761	35	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
22283	761	36	on	on	IN
22283	761	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	761	38	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	761	39	side	side	NN
22283	761	40	,	,	,
22283	761	41	and	and	CC
22283	761	42	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	761	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	761	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	761	45	felt	feel	VBN
22283	761	46	that	that	IN
22283	761	47	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	761	48	have	have	VBP
22283	761	49	no	no	DT
22283	761	50	reason	reason	NN
22283	761	51	to	to	TO
22283	761	52	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	761	53	that	that	IN
22283	761	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	761	55	presents	present	VBZ
22283	761	56	a	a	DT
22283	761	57	mental	mental	JJ
22283	761	58	side	side	NN
22283	761	59	--	--	:
22283	761	60	any	any	DT
22283	761	61	supplementary	supplementary	JJ
22283	761	62	causation	causation	NN
22283	761	63	of	of	IN
22283	761	64	a	a	DT
22283	761	65	mental	mental	JJ
22283	761	66	kind	kind	NN
22283	761	67	being	being	NN
22283	761	68	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	761	69	as	as	RB
22283	761	70	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
22283	761	71	.	.	.
22283	762	1	Even	even	RB
22283	762	2	writers	writer	NNS
22283	762	3	who	who	WP
22283	762	4	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	762	5	repudiate	repudiate	VBP
22283	762	6	this	this	DT
22283	762	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	762	8	prove	prove	VBP
22283	762	9	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	762	10	to	to	TO
22283	762	11	be	be	VB
22283	762	12	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	762	13	under	under	IN
22283	762	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	762	15	influence	influence	NN
22283	762	16	;	;	:
22283	762	17	for	for	IN
22283	762	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	762	19	constantly	constantly	RB
22283	762	20	find	find	VBP
22283	762	21	that	that	IN
22283	762	22	such	such	JJ
22283	762	23	writers	writer	NNS
22283	762	24	,	,	,
22283	762	25	after	after	IN
22283	762	26	conceding	concede	VBG
22283	762	27	the	the	DT
22283	762	28	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	762	29	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	762	30	as	as	RB
22283	762	31	far	far	RB
22283	762	32	as	as	IN
22283	762	33	these	these	DT
22283	762	34	have	have	VBP
22283	762	35	been	be	VBN
22283	762	36	_	_	NNP
22283	762	37	proved	prove	VBN
22283	762	38	_	_	NNP
22283	762	39	,	,	,
22283	762	40	take	take	VB
22283	762	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	762	42	stand	stand	NN
22283	762	43	upon	upon	IN
22283	762	44	the	the	DT
22283	762	45	more	more	RBR
22283	762	46	intricate	intricate	JJ
22283	762	47	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	762	48	of	of	IN
22283	762	49	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	762	50	where	where	WRB
22283	762	51	,	,	,
22283	762	52	as	as	RB
22283	762	53	yet	yet	RB
22283	762	54	,	,	,
22283	762	55	the	the	DT
22283	762	56	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	762	57	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	762	58	are	be	VBP
22283	762	59	not	not	RB
22283	762	60	forthcoming	forthcoming	JJ
22283	762	61	.	.	.
22283	763	1	Whether	whether	IN
22283	763	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	763	3	be	be	VBP
22283	763	4	at	at	IN
22283	763	5	the	the	DT
22283	763	6	origin	origin	NN
22283	763	7	of	of	IN
22283	763	8	life	life	NN
22283	763	9	,	,	,
22283	763	10	the	the	DT
22283	763	11	origin	origin	NN
22283	763	12	of	of	IN
22283	763	13	sentiency	sentiency	NN
22283	763	14	,	,	,
22283	763	15	of	of	IN
22283	763	16	instinct	instinct	NN
22283	763	17	,	,	,
22283	763	18	of	of	IN
22283	763	19	rationality	rationality	NN
22283	763	20	,	,	,
22283	763	21	of	of	IN
22283	763	22	morality	morality	NN
22283	763	23	,	,	,
22283	763	24	or	or	CC
22283	763	25	of	of	IN
22283	763	26	religion	religion	NN
22283	763	27	,	,	,
22283	763	28	these	these	DT
22283	763	29	writers	writer	NNS
22283	763	30	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	763	31	argue	argue	VBP
22283	763	32	that	that	IN
22283	763	33	here	here	RB
22283	763	34	,	,	,
22283	763	35	at	at	IN
22283	763	36	least	least	JJS
22283	763	37	,	,	,
22283	763	38	the	the	DT
22283	763	39	purely	purely	RB
22283	763	40	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	763	41	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
22283	763	42	fail	fail	VBP
22283	763	43	;	;	:
22283	763	44	and	and	CC
22283	763	45	that	that	IN
22283	763	46	here	here	RB
22283	763	47	,	,	,
22283	763	48	consequently	consequently	RB
22283	763	49	,	,	,
22283	763	50	there	there	EX
22283	763	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	763	52	still	still	RB
22283	763	53	room	room	NN
22283	763	54	left	leave	VBN
22283	763	55	for	for	IN
22283	763	56	a	a	DT
22283	763	57	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	763	58	interpretation	interpretation	NN
22283	763	59	.	.	.
22283	764	1	Of	of	RB
22283	764	2	course	course	RB
22283	764	3	the	the	DT
22283	764	4	pleading	pleading	NN
22283	764	5	for	for	IN
22283	764	6	theism	theism	NN
22283	764	7	thus	thus	RB
22283	764	8	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	764	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	764	10	seen	see	VBN
22283	764	11	by	by	IN
22283	764	12	others	other	NNS
22283	764	13	to	to	TO
22283	764	14	be	be	VB
22283	764	15	of	of	IN
22283	764	16	an	an	DT
22283	764	17	extremely	extremely	RB
22283	764	18	feeble	feeble	JJ
22283	764	19	quality	quality	NN
22283	764	20	;	;	:
22283	764	21	for	for	IN
22283	764	22	while	while	IN
22283	764	23	,	,	,
22283	764	24	on	on	IN
22283	764	25	the	the	DT
22283	764	26	one	one	CD
22283	764	27	hand	hand	NN
22283	764	28	,	,	,
22283	764	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	764	30	rests	rest	VBZ
22283	764	31	only	only	RB
22283	764	32	upon	upon	IN
22283	764	33	ignorance	ignorance	NN
22283	764	34	of	of	IN
22283	764	35	natural	natural	JJ
22283	764	36	causation	causation	NN
22283	764	37	(	(	-LRB-
22283	764	38	as	as	IN
22283	764	39	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	764	40	from	from	IN
22283	764	41	any	any	DT
22283	764	42	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	764	43	of	of	IN
22283	764	44	super	super	JJ
22283	764	45	-	-	JJ
22283	764	46	natural	natural	JJ
22283	764	47	causation	causation	NN
22283	764	48	)	)	-RRB-
22283	764	49	,	,	,
22283	764	50	on	on	IN
22283	764	51	the	the	DT
22283	764	52	other	other	JJ
22283	764	53	hand	hand	NN
22283	764	54	,	,	,
22283	764	55	abundant	abundant	JJ
22283	764	56	historical	historical	JJ
22283	764	57	analogies	analogy	NNS
22283	764	58	are	be	VBP
22283	764	59	available	available	JJ
22283	764	60	to	to	TO
22283	764	61	show	show	VB
22283	764	62	that	that	IN
22283	764	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	764	64	is	be	VBZ
22283	764	65	only	only	RB
22283	764	66	a	a	DT
22283	764	67	question	question	NN
22283	764	68	of	of	IN
22283	764	69	time	time	NN
22283	764	70	when	when	WRB
22283	764	71	pleading	plead	VBG
22283	764	72	of	of	IN
22283	764	73	this	this	DT
22283	764	74	kind	kind	NN
22283	764	75	will	will	MD
22283	764	76	become	become	VB
22283	764	77	more	more	RBR
22283	764	78	and	and	CC
22283	764	79	more	more	RBR
22283	764	80	restricted	restricted	JJ
22283	764	81	in	in	IN
22283	764	82	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	764	83	subject	subject	JJ
22283	764	84	-	-	HYPH
22283	764	85	matter	matter	NN
22283	764	86	,	,	,
22283	764	87	till	till	IN
22283	764	88	eventually	eventually	RB
22283	764	89	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	764	90	be	be	VB
22283	764	91	altogether	altogether	RB
22283	764	92	silenced	silence	VBN
22283	764	93	.	.	.
22283	765	1	But	but	CC
22283	765	2	the	the	DT
22283	765	3	pleading	pleading	NN
22283	765	4	which	which	WDT
22283	765	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	765	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	765	7	here	here	RB
22283	765	8	able	able	JJ
22283	765	9	to	to	TO
22283	765	10	supply	supply	VB
22283	765	11	can	can	MD
22283	765	12	never	never	RB
22283	765	13	be	be	VB
22283	765	14	silenced	silence	VBN
22283	765	15	.	.	.
22283	766	1	For	for	IN
22283	766	2	,	,	,
22283	766	3	according	accord	VBG
22283	766	4	to	to	IN
22283	766	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	766	6	,	,	,
22283	766	7	all	all	DT
22283	766	8	matter	matter	RB
22283	766	9	in	in	IN
22283	766	10	motion	motion	NN
22283	766	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	766	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	766	13	;	;	,
22283	766	14	and	and	CC
22283	766	15	,	,	,
22283	766	16	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	766	17	,	,	,
22283	766	18	matter	matter	NN
22283	766	19	in	in	IN
22283	766	20	motion	motion	NN
22283	766	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	766	22	merely	merely	RB
22283	766	23	the	the	DT
22283	766	24	objective	objective	JJ
22283	766	25	revelation	revelation	NN
22283	766	26	,	,	,
22283	766	27	_	_	NNP
22283	766	28	to	to	IN
22283	766	29	_	_	NNP
22283	766	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	766	31	and	and	CC
22283	766	32	_	_	NNP
22283	766	33	for	for	IN
22283	766	34	_	_	NNP
22283	766	35	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	766	36	,	,	,
22283	766	37	of	of	IN
22283	766	38	that	that	DT
22283	766	39	which	which	WDT
22283	766	40	in	in	IN
22283	766	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	766	42	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	766	43	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	766	44	--	--	:
22283	766	45	or	or	CC
22283	766	46	in	in	IN
22283	766	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	766	48	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	766	49	reality	reality	NN
22283	766	50	--	--	:
22283	766	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	766	52	mind	mind	NN
22283	766	53	.	.	.
22283	767	1	Just	just	RB
22283	767	2	as	as	IN
22283	767	3	the	the	DT
22283	767	4	operations	operation	NNS
22283	767	5	of	of	IN
22283	767	6	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	767	7	friend	friend	NN
22283	767	8	's	's	POS
22283	767	9	mind	mind	NN
22283	767	10	can	can	MD
22283	767	11	only	only	RB
22283	767	12	be	be	VB
22283	767	13	revealed	reveal	VBN
22283	767	14	to	to	IN
22283	767	15	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	767	16	through	through	IN
22283	767	17	the	the	DT
22283	767	18	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	767	19	operations	operation	NNS
22283	767	20	of	of	IN
22283	767	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	767	22	body	body	NN
22283	767	23	,	,	,
22283	767	24	so	so	IN
22283	767	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	767	26	may	may	MD
22283	767	27	very	very	RB
22283	767	28	well	well	RB
22283	767	29	be	be	VB
22283	767	30	that	that	IN
22283	767	31	the	the	DT
22283	767	32	operations	operation	NNS
22283	767	33	of	of	IN
22283	767	34	the	the	DT
22283	767	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
22283	767	36	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	767	37	(	(	-LRB-
22283	767	38	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	767	39	such	such	JJ
22283	767	40	to	to	TO
22283	767	41	exist	exist	VB
22283	767	42	)	)	-RRB-
22283	767	43	can	can	MD
22283	767	44	only	only	RB
22283	767	45	be	be	VB
22283	767	46	revealed	reveal	VBN
22283	767	47	to	to	IN
22283	767	48	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	767	49	through	through	IN
22283	767	50	the	the	DT
22283	767	51	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	767	52	operations	operation	NNS
22283	767	53	of	of	IN
22283	767	54	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	767	55	.	.	.
22283	768	1	The	the	DT
22283	768	2	only	only	JJ
22283	768	3	difference	difference	NN
22283	768	4	between	between	IN
22283	768	5	the	the	DT
22283	768	6	two	two	CD
22283	768	7	cases	case	NNS
22283	768	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	768	9	that	that	IN
22283	768	10	while	while	IN
22283	768	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	768	12	am	be	VBP
22283	768	13	able	able	JJ
22283	768	14	,	,	,
22283	768	15	in	in	IN
22283	768	16	the	the	DT
22283	768	17	case	case	NN
22283	768	18	of	of	IN
22283	768	19	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	768	20	friend	friend	NN
22283	768	21	's	's	POS
22283	768	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	768	23	,	,	,
22283	768	24	to	to	TO
22283	768	25	elicit	elicit	VB
22283	768	26	responses	response	NNS
22283	768	27	of	of	IN
22283	768	28	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	768	29	movement	movement	NN
22283	768	30	having	have	VBG
22283	768	31	a	a	DT
22283	768	32	definite	definite	JJ
22283	768	33	and	and	CC
22283	768	34	intended	intended	JJ
22283	768	35	relation	relation	NN
22283	768	36	to	to	IN
22283	768	37	the	the	DT
22283	768	38	operations	operation	NNS
22283	768	39	of	of	IN
22283	768	40	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	768	41	own	own	JJ
22283	768	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	768	43	,	,	,
22283	768	44	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	768	45	expressed	express	VBD
22283	768	46	to	to	IN
22283	768	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	768	48	;	;	:
22283	768	49	such	such	JJ
22283	768	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	768	51	not	not	RB
22283	768	52	the	the	DT
22283	768	53	case	case	NN
22283	768	54	with	with	IN
22283	768	55	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	768	56	.	.	.
22283	769	1	With	with	IN
22283	769	2	the	the	DT
22283	769	3	friend	friend	NN
22283	769	4	-	-	HYPH
22283	769	5	eject	eject	NN
22283	769	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	769	7	am	be	VBP
22283	769	8	able	able	JJ
22283	769	9	to	to	TO
22283	769	10	_	_	NNP
22283	769	11	converse	converse	RB
22283	769	12	_	_	NNP
22283	769	13	;	;	:
22283	769	14	but	but	CC
22283	769	15	not	not	RB
22283	769	16	so	so	RB
22283	769	17	with	with	IN
22283	769	18	the	the	DT
22283	769	19	world	world	NN
22283	769	20	-	-	HYPH
22283	769	21	eject[11	eject[11	NNP
22283	769	22	]	]	-RRB-
22283	769	23	.	.	.
22283	770	1	This	this	DT
22283	770	2	great	great	JJ
22283	770	3	difference	difference	NN
22283	770	4	,	,	,
22283	770	5	however	however	RB
22283	770	6	,	,	,
22283	770	7	although	although	IN
22283	770	8	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	770	9	depriving	deprive	VBG
22283	770	10	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	770	11	of	of	IN
22283	770	12	any	any	DT
22283	770	13	such	such	JJ
22283	770	14	direct	direct	JJ
22283	770	15	corroboration	corroboration	NN
22283	770	16	of	of	IN
22283	770	17	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	770	18	in	in	IN
22283	770	19	the	the	DT
22283	770	20	world	world	NN
22283	770	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	770	22	eject	eject	NN
22283	770	23	as	as	IN
22283	770	24	that	that	DT
22283	770	25	which	which	WDT
22283	770	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	770	27	thus	thus	RB
22283	770	28	derive	derive	VBP
22283	770	29	of	of	IN
22283	770	30	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	770	31	in	in	IN
22283	770	32	the	the	DT
22283	770	33	friend	friend	NN
22283	770	34	-	-	HYPH
22283	770	35	eject	eject	NN
22283	770	36	,	,	,
22283	770	37	ought	ought	MD
22283	770	38	not	not	RB
22283	770	39	to	to	TO
22283	770	40	be	be	VB
22283	770	41	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	770	42	by	by	IN
22283	770	43	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	770	44	as	as	IN
22283	770	45	amounting	amount	VBG
22283	770	46	,	,	,
22283	770	47	in	in	IN
22283	770	48	the	the	DT
22283	770	49	smallest	small	JJS
22283	770	50	degree	degree	NN
22283	770	51	,	,	,
22283	770	52	to	to	IN
22283	770	53	_	_	NNP
22283	770	54	disproof	disproof	JJ
22283	770	55	_	_	NNP
22283	770	56	of	of	IN
22283	770	57	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	770	58	in	in	IN
22283	770	59	the	the	DT
22283	770	60	world	world	NN
22283	770	61	-	-	HYPH
22283	770	62	eject	eject	NN
22283	770	63	.	.	.
22283	771	1	The	the	DT
22283	771	2	fact	fact	NN
22283	771	3	that	that	IN
22283	771	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	771	5	am	be	VBP
22283	771	6	not	not	RB
22283	771	7	able	able	JJ
22283	771	8	to	to	TO
22283	771	9	converse	converse	VB
22283	771	10	with	with	IN
22283	771	11	the	the	DT
22283	771	12	world	world	NN
22283	771	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	771	14	eject	eject	NN
22283	771	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	771	16	merely	merely	RB
22283	771	17	a	a	DT
22283	771	18	negative	negative	JJ
22283	771	19	fact	fact	NN
22283	771	20	,	,	,
22283	771	21	and	and	CC
22283	771	22	should	should	MD
22283	771	23	not	not	RB
22283	771	24	be	be	VB
22283	771	25	allowed	allow	VBN
22283	771	26	to	to	TO
22283	771	27	tell	tell	VB
22283	771	28	against	against	IN
22283	771	29	any	any	DT
22283	771	30	probability	probability	NN
22283	771	31	(	(	-LRB-
22283	771	32	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	771	33	derived	derive	VBN
22283	771	34	)	)	-RRB-
22283	771	35	in	in	IN
22283	771	36	favour	favour	NN
22283	771	37	of	of	IN
22283	771	38	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	771	39	as	as	IN
22283	771	40	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	771	41	to	to	IN
22283	771	42	that	that	DT
22283	771	43	eject	eject	NN
22283	771	44	.	.	.
22283	772	1	There	there	EX
22283	772	2	may	may	MD
22283	772	3	be	be	VB
22283	772	4	a	a	DT
22283	772	5	thousand	thousand	CD
22283	772	6	very	very	RB
22283	772	7	good	good	JJ
22283	772	8	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	772	9	why	why	WRB
22283	772	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	772	11	should	should	MD
22283	772	12	be	be	VB
22283	772	13	precluded	preclude	VBN
22283	772	14	from	from	IN
22283	772	15	such	such	JJ
22283	772	16	converse	converse	NN
22283	772	17	--	--	:
22283	772	18	some	some	DT
22283	772	19	of	of	IN
22283	772	20	which	which	WDT
22283	772	21	,	,	,
22283	772	22	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	772	23	,	,	,
22283	772	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	772	25	can	can	MD
22283	772	26	myself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	772	27	very	very	RB
22283	772	28	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	772	29	perceive	perceive	JJ
22283	772	30	.	.	.
22283	773	1	The	the	DT
22283	773	2	importance	importance	NN
22283	773	3	of	of	IN
22283	773	4	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	773	5	in	in	IN
22283	773	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	773	7	enabling	enable	VBG
22283	773	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	773	9	rationally	rationally	RB
22283	773	10	to	to	TO
22283	773	11	contemplate	contemplate	VB
22283	773	12	all	all	DT
22283	773	13	processes	process	NNS
22283	773	14	of	of	IN
22283	773	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	773	16	causation	causation	NN
22283	773	17	as	as	IN
22283	773	18	possibly	possibly	RB
22283	773	19	immediate	immediate	JJ
22283	773	20	exhibitions	exhibition	NNS
22283	773	21	of	of	IN
22283	773	22	psychism	psychism	NN
22283	773	23	,	,	,
22283	773	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	773	25	difficult	difficult	JJ
22283	773	26	to	to	TO
22283	773	27	overrate	overrate	VB
22283	773	28	.	.	.
22283	774	1	For	for	IN
22283	774	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	774	3	entirely	entirely	RB
22283	774	4	discharges	discharge	VBZ
22283	774	5	all	all	DT
22283	774	6	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	774	7	between	between	IN
22283	774	8	the	the	DT
22283	774	9	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	774	10	and	and	CC
22283	774	11	the	the	DT
22283	774	12	mental	mental	JJ
22283	774	13	;	;	:
22283	774	14	so	so	IN
22283	774	15	that	that	IN
22283	774	16	if	if	IN
22283	774	17	physical	physical	JJ
22283	774	18	science	science	NN
22283	774	19	were	be	VBD
22283	774	20	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
22283	774	21	advanced	advance	VBN
22283	774	22	to	to	TO
22283	774	23	yield	yield	VB
22283	774	24	a	a	DT
22283	774	25	full	full	JJ
22283	774	26	natural	natural	JJ
22283	774	27	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	774	28	of	of	IN
22283	774	29	all	all	PDT
22283	774	30	the	the	DT
22283	774	31	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	774	32	within	within	IN
22283	774	33	human	human	JJ
22283	774	34	experience	experience	NN
22283	774	35	,	,	,
22283	774	36	mankind	mankind	NN
22283	774	37	would	would	MD
22283	774	38	be	be	VB
22283	774	39	in	in	IN
22283	774	40	a	a	DT
22283	774	41	position	position	NN
22283	774	42	to	to	TO
22283	774	43	gain	gain	VB
22283	774	44	as	as	IN
22283	774	45	complete	complete	JJ
22283	774	46	a	a	DT
22283	774	47	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	774	48	as	as	IN
22283	774	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	774	50	theoretically	theoretically	RB
22283	774	51	possible	possible	JJ
22283	774	52	of	of	IN
22283	774	53	the	the	DT
22283	774	54	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	774	55	character	character	NN
22283	774	56	of	of	IN
22283	774	57	the	the	DT
22283	774	58	world	world	NN
22283	774	59	-	-	HYPH
22283	774	60	eject	eject	NN
22283	774	61	.	.	.
22283	775	1	Already	already	RB
22283	775	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	775	3	are	be	VBP
22283	775	4	able	able	JJ
22283	775	5	to	to	TO
22283	775	6	perceive	perceive	VB
22283	775	7	the	the	DT
22283	775	8	immense	immense	JJ
22283	775	9	significance	significance	NN
22283	775	10	of	of	IN
22283	775	11	being	be	VBG
22283	775	12	able	able	JJ
22283	775	13	to	to	TO
22283	775	14	regard	regard	VB
22283	775	15	any	any	DT
22283	775	16	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	775	17	of	of	IN
22283	775	18	natural	natural	JJ
22283	775	19	causation	causation	NN
22283	775	20	as	as	IN
22283	775	21	the	the	DT
22283	775	22	merely	merely	RB
22283	775	23	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	775	24	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	775	25	of	of	IN
22283	775	26	the	the	DT
22283	775	27	ontological	ontological	JJ
22283	775	28	reality	reality	NN
22283	775	29	--	--	:
22283	775	30	the	the	DT
22283	775	31	merely	merely	RB
22283	775	32	outward	outward	JJ
22283	775	33	manifestation	manifestation	NN
22283	775	34	of	of	IN
22283	775	35	an	an	DT
22283	775	36	inward	inward	JJ
22283	775	37	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	775	38	.	.	.
22283	776	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	776	2	,	,	,
22283	776	3	for	for	IN
22283	776	4	example	example	NN
22283	776	5	,	,	,
22283	776	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	776	7	am	be	VBP
22283	776	8	listening	listen	VBG
22283	776	9	to	to	IN
22283	776	10	a	a	DT
22283	776	11	sonata	sonata	NN
22283	776	12	of	of	IN
22283	776	13	Beethoven	Beethoven	NNP
22283	776	14	's	's	POS
22283	776	15	played	play	VBN
22283	776	16	by	by	IN
22283	776	17	Madame	Madame	NNP
22283	776	18	Schumann	Schumann	NNP
22283	776	19	.	.	.
22283	777	1	Helmholtz	Helmholtz	NNP
22283	777	2	tells	tell	VBZ
22283	777	3	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	777	4	all	all	DT
22283	777	5	that	that	WDT
22283	777	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	777	7	knows	know	VBZ
22283	777	8	about	about	IN
22283	777	9	the	the	DT
22283	777	10	physics	physics	NN
22283	777	11	and	and	CC
22283	777	12	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	777	13	of	of	IN
22283	777	14	the	the	DT
22283	777	15	process	process	NN
22283	777	16	,	,	,
22283	777	17	both	both	CC
22283	777	18	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	777	19	and	and	CC
22283	777	20	within	within	IN
22283	777	21	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	777	22	brain	brain	NN
22283	777	23	.	.	.
22283	778	1	But	but	CC
22283	778	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	778	3	feel	feel	VBP
22283	778	4	that	that	IN
22283	778	5	,	,	,
22283	778	6	even	even	RB
22283	778	7	if	if	IN
22283	778	8	Helmholtz	Helmholtz	NNP
22283	778	9	were	be	VBD
22283	778	10	able	able	JJ
22283	778	11	to	to	TO
22283	778	12	tell	tell	VB
22283	778	13	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	778	14	very	very	RB
22283	778	15	much	much	RB
22283	778	16	more	more	JJR
22283	778	17	than	than	IN
22283	778	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	778	19	can	can	MD
22283	778	20	,	,	,
22283	778	21	so	so	RB
22283	778	22	long	long	RB
22283	778	23	as	as	IN
22283	778	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	778	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	778	26	dealing	deal	VBG
22283	778	27	with	with	IN
22283	778	28	these	these	DT
22283	778	29	objective	objective	JJ
22283	778	30	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	778	31	,	,	,
22283	778	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	778	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	778	34	at	at	IN
22283	778	35	work	work	NN
22283	778	36	only	only	RB
22283	778	37	upon	upon	IN
22283	778	38	the	the	DT
22283	778	39	outer	outer	JJ
22283	778	40	skin	skin	NN
22283	778	41	of	of	IN
22283	778	42	the	the	DT
22283	778	43	whole	whole	JJ
22283	778	44	matter	matter	NN
22283	778	45	.	.	.
22283	779	1	The	the	DT
22283	779	2	great	great	JJ
22283	779	3	reality	reality	NN
22283	779	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	779	5	the	the	DT
22283	779	6	mind	mind	NN
22283	779	7	of	of	IN
22283	779	8	Beethoven	Beethoven	NNP
22283	779	9	communicating	communicate	VBG
22283	779	10	to	to	IN
22283	779	11	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	779	12	mind	mind	NN
22283	779	13	through	through	IN
22283	779	14	the	the	DT
22283	779	15	complex	complex	JJ
22283	779	16	intervention	intervention	NN
22283	779	17	of	of	IN
22283	779	18	three	three	CD
22283	779	19	different	different	JJ
22283	779	20	brains	brain	NNS
22283	779	21	with	with	IN
22283	779	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	779	23	neuro	neuro	NNP
22283	779	24	-	-	HYPH
22283	779	25	muscular	muscular	JJ
22283	779	26	systems	system	NNS
22283	779	27	,	,	,
22283	779	28	and	and	CC
22283	779	29	an	an	DT
22283	779	30	endless	endless	JJ
22283	779	31	variety	variety	NN
22283	779	32	of	of	IN
22283	779	33	aërial	aërial	JJ
22283	779	34	vibrations	vibration	NNS
22283	779	35	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	779	36	from	from	IN
22283	779	37	a	a	DT
22283	779	38	pianoforte	pianoforte	NN
22283	779	39	.	.	.
22283	780	1	The	the	DT
22283	780	2	method	method	NN
22283	780	3	of	of	IN
22283	780	4	communication	communication	NN
22283	780	5	has	have	VBZ
22283	780	6	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	780	7	more	more	JJR
22283	780	8	to	to	TO
22283	780	9	do	do	VB
22283	780	10	with	with	IN
22283	780	11	the	the	DT
22283	780	12	reality	reality	NN
22283	780	13	communicated	communicate	VBN
22283	780	14	than	than	IN
22283	780	15	have	have	VB
22283	780	16	the	the	DT
22283	780	17	paper	paper	NN
22283	780	18	and	and	CC
22283	780	19	ink	ink	NN
22283	780	20	of	of	IN
22283	780	21	this	this	DT
22283	780	22	essay	essay	NN
22283	780	23	to	to	TO
22283	780	24	do	do	VB
22283	780	25	with	with	IN
22283	780	26	the	the	DT
22283	780	27	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	780	28	which	which	WDT
22283	780	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	780	30	serve	serve	VBP
22283	780	31	to	to	TO
22283	780	32	convey	convey	VB
22283	780	33	.	.	.
22283	781	1	In	in	IN
22283	781	2	each	each	DT
22283	781	3	case	case	NN
22283	781	4	a	a	DT
22283	781	5	vehicle	vehicle	NN
22283	781	6	of	of	IN
22283	781	7	symbols	symbol	NNS
22283	781	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	781	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	781	10	in	in	IN
22283	781	11	order	order	NN
22283	781	12	that	that	IN
22283	781	13	one	one	CD
22283	781	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	781	15	should	should	MD
22283	781	16	communicate	communicate	VB
22283	781	17	with	with	IN
22283	781	18	another	another	DT
22283	781	19	;	;	:
22283	781	20	but	but	CC
22283	781	21	in	in	IN
22283	781	22	both	both	DT
22283	781	23	cases	case	NNS
22283	781	24	this	this	DT
22283	781	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	781	26	a	a	DT
22283	781	27	vehicle	vehicle	NN
22283	781	28	of	of	IN
22283	781	29	_	_	NNP
22283	781	30	symbols	symbol	NNS
22283	781	31	_	_	NNP
22283	781	32	,	,	,
22283	781	33	and	and	CC
22283	781	34	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	781	35	more	more	JJR
22283	781	36	.	.	.
22283	782	1	Everywhere	everywhere	RB
22283	782	2	,	,	,
22283	782	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	782	4	,	,	,
22283	782	5	the	the	DT
22283	782	6	reality	reality	NN
22283	782	7	may	may	MD
22283	782	8	be	be	VB
22283	782	9	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	782	10	,	,	,
22283	782	11	and	and	CC
22283	782	12	the	the	DT
22283	782	13	physical	physical	JJ
22283	782	14	symbolic	symbolic	NN
22283	782	15	;	;	:
22283	782	16	everywhere	everywhere	RB
22283	782	17	matter	matter	NN
22283	782	18	in	in	IN
22283	782	19	motion	motion	NN
22283	782	20	may	may	MD
22283	782	21	be	be	VB
22283	782	22	the	the	DT
22283	782	23	outward	outward	JJ
22283	782	24	and	and	CC
22283	782	25	visible	visible	JJ
22283	782	26	sign	sign	NN
22283	782	27	of	of	IN
22283	782	28	an	an	DT
22283	782	29	inward	inward	JJ
22283	782	30	and	and	CC
22283	782	31	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
22283	782	32	grace	grace	NN
22283	782	33	.	.	.
22283	783	1	Take	take	VB
22283	783	2	again	again	RB
22283	783	3	the	the	DT
22283	783	4	case	case	NN
22283	783	5	of	of	IN
22283	783	6	morality	morality	NN
22283	783	7	and	and	CC
22283	783	8	religion	religion	NN
22283	783	9	.	.	.
22283	784	1	Because	because	IN
22283	784	2	science	science	NN
22283	784	3	,	,	,
22283	784	4	by	by	IN
22283	784	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	784	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	784	7	of	of	IN
22283	784	8	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	784	9	,	,	,
22283	784	10	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	784	11	to	to	TO
22283	784	12	be	be	VB
22283	784	13	in	in	IN
22283	784	14	a	a	DT
22283	784	15	fair	fair	JJ
22283	784	16	way	way	NN
22283	784	17	of	of	IN
22283	784	18	explaining	explain	VBG
22283	784	19	the	the	DT
22283	784	20	genesis	genesis	NN
22283	784	21	of	of	IN
22283	784	22	these	these	DT
22283	784	23	things	thing	NNS
22283	784	24	by	by	IN
22283	784	25	natural	natural	JJ
22283	784	26	causes	cause	NNS
22283	784	27	,	,	,
22283	784	28	theists	theist	NNS
22283	784	29	are	be	VBP
22283	784	30	taking	take	VBG
22283	784	31	alarm	alarm	NN
22283	784	32	;	;	:
22283	784	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	784	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	784	35	felt	feel	VBN
22283	784	36	by	by	IN
22283	784	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	784	38	that	that	IN
22283	784	39	if	if	IN
22283	784	40	morality	morality	NN
22283	784	41	can	can	MD
22283	784	42	be	be	VB
22283	784	43	fully	fully	RB
22283	784	44	explained	explain	VBN
22283	784	45	by	by	IN
22283	784	46	utility	utility	NN
22283	784	47	,	,	,
22283	784	48	and	and	CC
22283	784	49	religion	religion	NN
22283	784	50	by	by	IN
22283	784	51	superstition	superstition	NN
22283	784	52	,	,	,
22283	784	53	the	the	DT
22283	784	54	reality	reality	NN
22283	784	55	of	of	IN
22283	784	56	both	both	DT
22283	784	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	784	58	destroyed	destroy	VBN
22283	784	59	.	.	.
22283	785	1	But	but	CC
22283	785	2	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	785	3	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	785	4	that	that	IN
22283	785	5	such	such	PDT
22283	785	6	a	a	DT
22283	785	7	view	view	NN
22283	785	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	785	9	entirely	entirely	RB
22283	785	10	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
22283	785	11	.	.	.
22283	786	1	For	for	IN
22283	786	2	,	,	,
22283	786	3	according	accord	VBG
22283	786	4	to	to	IN
22283	786	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	786	6	,	,	,
22283	786	7	the	the	DT
22283	786	8	natural	natural	JJ
22283	786	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	786	10	of	of	IN
22283	786	11	morality	morality	NN
22283	786	12	and	and	CC
22283	786	13	religion	religion	NN
22283	786	14	has	have	VBZ
22283	786	15	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	786	16	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	786	17	to	to	TO
22283	786	18	do	do	VB
22283	786	19	with	with	IN
22283	786	20	the	the	DT
22283	786	21	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	786	22	truth	truth	NN
22283	786	23	of	of	IN
22283	786	24	either	either	DT
22283	786	25	.	.	.
22283	787	1	The	the	DT
22283	787	2	natural	natural	JJ
22283	787	3	causation	causation	NN
22283	787	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	787	5	merely	merely	RB
22283	787	6	a	a	DT
22283	787	7	record	record	NN
22283	787	8	of	of	IN
22283	787	9	physical	physical	JJ
22283	787	10	processes	process	NNS
22283	787	11	,	,	,
22283	787	12	serving	serve	VBG
22283	787	13	to	to	TO
22283	787	14	manifest	manifest	VB
22283	787	15	the	the	DT
22283	787	16	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	787	17	processes	process	NNS
22283	787	18	.	.	.
22283	788	1	Nor	nor	CC
22283	788	2	can	can	MD
22283	788	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	788	4	make	make	VB
22283	788	5	any	any	DT
22283	788	6	difference	difference	NN
22283	788	7	,	,	,
22283	788	8	as	as	IN
22283	788	9	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	788	10	the	the	DT
22283	788	11	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	788	12	veracity	veracity	NN
22283	788	13	of	of	IN
22283	788	14	the	the	DT
22283	788	15	moral	moral	JJ
22283	788	16	and	and	CC
22283	788	17	religious	religious	JJ
22283	788	18	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	788	19	,	,	,
22283	788	20	that	that	IN
22283	788	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	788	22	have	have	VBP
22283	788	23	been	be	VBN
22283	788	24	developed	develop	VBN
22283	788	25	slowly	slowly	RB
22283	788	26	by	by	IN
22283	788	27	natural	natural	JJ
22283	788	28	causes	cause	NNS
22283	788	29	;	;	:
22283	788	30	that	that	IN
22283	788	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	788	32	were	be	VBD
22283	788	33	at	at	IN
22283	788	34	first	first	RB
22283	788	35	grossly	grossly	RB
22283	788	36	selfish	selfish	JJ
22283	788	37	on	on	IN
22283	788	38	the	the	DT
22283	788	39	one	one	CD
22283	788	40	hand	hand	NN
22283	788	41	,	,	,
22283	788	42	and	and	CC
22283	788	43	hideously	hideously	RB
22283	788	44	superstitious	superstitious	JJ
22283	788	45	on	on	IN
22283	788	46	the	the	DT
22283	788	47	other	other	JJ
22283	788	48	;	;	:
22283	788	49	that	that	IN
22283	788	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	788	51	afterwards	afterwards	RB
22283	788	52	went	go	VBD
22283	788	53	through	through	IN
22283	788	54	a	a	DT
22283	788	55	long	long	JJ
22283	788	56	series	series	NN
22283	788	57	of	of	IN
22283	788	58	changes	change	NNS
22283	788	59	,	,	,
22283	788	60	none	none	NN
22283	788	61	of	of	IN
22283	788	62	which	which	WDT
22283	788	63	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	788	64	can	can	MD
22283	788	65	have	have	VB
22283	788	66	fully	fully	RB
22283	788	67	corresponded	correspond	VBN
22283	788	68	with	with	IN
22283	788	69	external	external	JJ
22283	788	70	truth	truth	NN
22283	788	71	;	;	,
22283	788	72	or	or	CC
22283	788	73	that	that	IN
22283	788	74	even	even	RB
22283	788	75	now	now	RB
22283	788	76	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	788	77	may	may	MD
22283	788	78	be	be	VB
22283	788	79	both	both	DT
22283	788	80	extremely	extremely	RB
22283	788	81	far	far	RB
22283	788	82	from	from	IN
22283	788	83	any	any	DT
22283	788	84	such	such	JJ
22283	788	85	correspondence	correspondence	NN
22283	788	86	.	.	.
22283	789	1	All	all	DT
22283	789	2	that	that	DT
22283	789	3	such	such	JJ
22283	789	4	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	789	5	go	go	VBP
22283	789	6	to	to	TO
22283	789	7	prove	prove	VB
22283	789	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	789	9	,	,	,
22283	789	10	that	that	IN
22283	789	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	789	12	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	789	13	to	to	IN
22283	789	14	the	the	DT
22283	789	15	natural	natural	JJ
22283	789	16	method	method	NN
22283	789	17	of	of	IN
22283	789	18	mental	mental	JJ
22283	789	19	evolution	evolution	NN
22283	789	20	in	in	IN
22283	789	21	man	man	NN
22283	789	22	that	that	IN
22283	789	23	with	with	IN
22283	789	24	advancing	advance	VBG
22283	789	25	culture	culture	NN
22283	789	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	789	27	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	789	28	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
22283	789	29	of	of	IN
22283	789	30	Nature	nature	NN
22283	789	31	should	should	MD
22283	789	32	more	more	RBR
22283	789	33	and	and	CC
22283	789	34	more	more	RBR
22283	789	35	nearly	nearly	RB
22283	789	36	_	_	NNP
22283	789	37	approximate	approximate	JJ
22283	789	38	_	_	NNP
22283	789	39	the	the	DT
22283	789	40	truth	truth	NN
22283	789	41	.	.	.
22283	790	1	The	the	DT
22283	790	2	world	world	NN
22283	790	3	-	-	HYPH
22283	790	4	eject	eject	NN
22283	790	5	must	must	MD
22283	790	6	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	790	7	vary	vary	VB
22283	790	8	with	with	IN
22283	790	9	the	the	DT
22283	790	10	character	character	NN
22283	790	11	of	of	IN
22283	790	12	the	the	DT
22283	790	13	human	human	JJ
22283	790	14	subject	subject	NN
22283	790	15	;	;	:
22283	790	16	but	but	CC
22283	790	17	this	this	DT
22283	790	18	does	do	VBZ
22283	790	19	not	not	RB
22283	790	20	prove	prove	VB
22283	790	21	that	that	IN
22283	790	22	the	the	DT
22283	790	23	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	790	24	interpretation	interpretation	NN
22283	790	25	has	have	VBZ
22283	790	26	throughout	throughout	RB
22283	790	27	been	be	VBN
22283	790	28	wrong	wrong	JJ
22283	790	29	in	in	IN
22283	790	30	_	_	NNP
22283	790	31	method	method	NN
22283	790	32	_	_	NNP
22283	790	33	:	:	:
22283	790	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	790	35	only	only	RB
22283	790	36	proves	prove	VBZ
22283	790	37	that	that	IN
22283	790	38	such	such	JJ
22283	790	39	interpretation	interpretation	NN
22283	790	40	has	have	VBZ
22283	790	41	been	be	VBN
22283	790	42	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
22283	790	43	--	--	:
22283	790	44	and	and	CC
22283	790	45	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	790	46	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
22283	790	47	--	--	:
22283	790	48	in	in	IN
22283	790	49	_	_	NNP
22283	790	50	application	application	NN
22283	790	51	_	_	NNP
22283	790	52	.	.	.
22283	791	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	791	2	,	,	,
22283	791	3	then	then	RB
22283	791	4	,	,	,
22283	791	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	791	6	conceive	conceive	VBP
22283	791	7	to	to	TO
22283	791	8	be	be	VB
22283	791	9	one	one	CD
22283	791	10	of	of	IN
22283	791	11	the	the	DT
22283	791	12	most	most	RBS
22283	791	13	important	important	JJ
22283	791	14	consequences	consequence	NNS
22283	791	15	of	of	IN
22283	791	16	the	the	DT
22283	791	17	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	791	18	theory	theory	NN
22283	791	19	.	.	.
22283	792	1	Namely	namely	RB
22283	792	2	,	,	,
22283	792	3	that	that	IN
22283	792	4	by	by	IN
22283	792	5	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	792	6	physical	physical	JJ
22283	792	7	causation	causation	NN
22283	792	8	as	as	RB
22283	792	9	everywhere	everywhere	RB
22283	792	10	but	but	CC
22283	792	11	the	the	DT
22283	792	12	objective	objective	JJ
22283	792	13	or	or	CC
22283	792	14	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	792	15	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	792	16	of	of	IN
22283	792	17	an	an	DT
22283	792	18	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	792	19	or	or	CC
22283	792	20	ontological	ontological	JJ
22283	792	21	reality	reality	NN
22283	792	22	,	,	,
22283	792	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	792	24	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
22283	792	25	a	a	DT
22283	792	26	logical	logical	JJ
22283	792	27	basis	basis	NN
22283	792	28	for	for	IN
22283	792	29	a	a	DT
22283	792	30	theory	theory	NN
22283	792	31	of	of	IN
22283	792	32	things	thing	NNS
22283	792	33	which	which	WDT
22283	792	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	792	35	at	at	IN
22283	792	36	the	the	DT
22283	792	37	same	same	JJ
22283	792	38	time	time	NN
22283	792	39	natural	natural	JJ
22283	792	40	and	and	CC
22283	792	41	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
22283	792	42	.	.	.
22283	793	1	On	on	IN
22283	793	2	the	the	DT
22283	793	3	objective	objective	JJ
22283	793	4	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	793	5	,	,	,
22283	793	6	the	the	DT
22283	793	7	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	793	8	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	793	9	by	by	IN
22283	793	10	reason	reason	NN
22283	793	11	are	be	VBP
22283	793	12	of	of	IN
22283	793	13	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	793	14	physical	physical	JJ
22283	793	15	,	,	,
22283	793	16	while	while	IN
22283	793	17	,	,	,
22283	793	18	on	on	IN
22283	793	19	the	the	DT
22283	793	20	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	793	21	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	793	22	,	,	,
22283	793	23	such	such	JJ
22283	793	24	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	793	25	are	be	VBP
22283	793	26	of	of	IN
22283	793	27	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	793	28	metaphysical	metaphysical	JJ
22283	793	29	--	--	:
22283	793	30	or	or	CC
22283	793	31	rather	rather	RB
22283	793	32	,	,	,
22283	793	33	let	let	VB
22283	793	34	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	793	35	say	say	VB
22283	793	36	,	,	,
22283	793	37	hyper	hyper	JJ
22283	793	38	-	-	NN
22283	793	39	physical	physical	JJ
22283	793	40	.	.	.
22283	794	1	But	but	CC
22283	794	2	these	these	DT
22283	794	3	two	two	CD
22283	794	4	orders	order	NNS
22283	794	5	of	of	IN
22283	794	6	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	794	7	are	be	VBP
22283	794	8	different	different	JJ
22283	794	9	only	only	RB
22283	794	10	because	because	IN
22283	794	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	794	12	modes	mode	NNS
22283	794	13	of	of	IN
22283	794	14	interpreting	interpret	VBG
22283	794	15	the	the	DT
22283	794	16	same	same	JJ
22283	794	17	events	event	NNS
22283	794	18	are	be	VBP
22283	794	19	different	different	JJ
22283	794	20	.	.	.
22283	795	1	The	the	DT
22283	795	2	objective	objective	JJ
22283	795	3	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	795	4	which	which	WDT
22283	795	5	was	be	VBD
22283	795	6	given	give	VBN
22283	795	7	(	(	-LRB-
22283	795	8	as	as	IN
22283	795	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	795	10	supposed	suppose	VBD
22283	795	11	)	)	-RRB-
22283	795	12	by	by	IN
22283	795	13	Helmholtz	Helmholtz	NNP
22283	795	14	of	of	IN
22283	795	15	the	the	DT
22283	795	16	effects	effect	NNS
22283	795	17	produced	produce	VBN
22283	795	18	on	on	IN
22283	795	19	the	the	DT
22283	795	20	human	human	JJ
22283	795	21	brain	brain	NN
22283	795	22	by	by	IN
22283	795	23	hearing	hear	VBG
22283	795	24	a	a	DT
22283	795	25	sonata	sonata	NN
22283	795	26	,	,	,
22283	795	27	was	be	VBD
22283	795	28	no	no	RB
22283	795	29	doubt	doubt	RB
22283	795	30	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	795	31	sound	sound	JJ
22283	795	32	within	within	IN
22283	795	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	795	34	own	own	JJ
22283	795	35	category	category	NN
22283	795	36	;	;	:
22283	795	37	but	but	CC
22283	795	38	the	the	DT
22283	795	39	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	795	40	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	795	41	of	of	IN
22283	795	42	these	these	DT
22283	795	43	same	same	JJ
22283	795	44	effects	effect	NNS
22283	795	45	which	which	WDT
22283	795	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	795	47	given	give	VBN
22283	795	48	by	by	IN
22283	795	49	a	a	DT
22283	795	50	musician	musician	NN
22283	795	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	795	52	equally	equally	RB
22283	795	53	sound	sound	JJ
22283	795	54	within	within	IN
22283	795	55	_	_	NNP
22283	795	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	795	57	_	_	NNP
22283	795	58	category	category	NN
22283	795	59	.	.	.
22283	796	1	And	and	CC
22283	796	2	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	796	3	,	,	,
22283	796	4	if	if	IN
22283	796	5	instead	instead	RB
22283	796	6	of	of	IN
22283	796	7	the	the	DT
22283	796	8	man	man	NN
22283	796	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	796	10	object	object	NN
22283	796	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	796	12	contemplate	contemplate	VBP
22283	796	13	the	the	DT
22283	796	14	world	world	NN
22283	796	15	-	-	HYPH
22283	796	16	object	object	NN
22283	796	17	physical	physical	JJ
22283	796	18	causation	causation	NN
22283	796	19	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	796	20	but	but	CC
22283	796	21	the	the	DT
22283	796	22	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	796	23	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	796	24	of	of	IN
22283	796	25	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	796	26	causation	causation	NN
22283	796	27	;	;	:
22283	796	28	the	the	DT
22283	796	29	invariability	invariability	NN
22283	796	30	of	of	IN
22283	796	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	796	32	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	796	33	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	796	34	but	but	CC
22283	796	35	the	the	DT
22283	796	36	expression	expression	NN
22283	796	37	of	of	IN
22283	796	38	intentional	intentional	JJ
22283	796	39	order	order	NN
22283	796	40	;	;	:
22283	796	41	the	the	DT
22283	796	42	iron	iron	NN
22283	796	43	rigidity	rigidity	NN
22283	796	44	of	of	IN
22283	796	45	natural	natural	JJ
22283	796	46	law	law	NN
22283	796	47	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	796	48	the	the	DT
22283	796	49	sensuous	sensuous	JJ
22283	796	50	manifestation	manifestation	NN
22283	796	51	of	of	IN
22283	796	52	an	an	DT
22283	796	53	unalterable	unalterable	JJ
22283	796	54	consistency	consistency	NN
22283	796	55	as	as	IN
22283	796	56	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	796	57	to	to	IN
22283	796	58	the	the	DT
22283	796	59	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
22283	796	60	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	796	61	.	.	.
22283	797	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	797	2	object	object	NN
22283	797	3	in	in	IN
22283	797	4	this	this	DT
22283	797	5	paper	paper	NN
22283	797	6	has	have	VBZ
22283	797	7	been	be	VBN
22283	797	8	to	to	TO
22283	797	9	show	show	VB
22283	797	10	that	that	IN
22283	797	11	the	the	DT
22283	797	12	views	view	NNS
22283	797	13	of	of	IN
22283	797	14	the	the	DT
22283	797	15	late	late	JJ
22283	797	16	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	797	17	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	797	18	concerning	concern	VBG
22283	797	19	the	the	DT
22283	797	20	influence	influence	NN
22283	797	21	of	of	IN
22283	797	22	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	797	23	on	on	IN
22283	797	24	Theism	theism	NN
22283	797	25	are	be	VBP
22283	797	26	unsound	unsound	JJ
22283	797	27	.	.	.
22283	798	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	798	2	am	be	VBP
22283	798	3	in	in	IN
22283	798	4	full	full	JJ
22283	798	5	agreement	agreement	NN
22283	798	6	with	with	IN
22283	798	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	798	8	in	in	IN
22283	798	9	believing	believe	VBG
22283	798	10	that	that	IN
22283	798	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	798	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	798	13	destined	destine	VBN
22283	798	14	to	to	TO
22283	798	15	become	become	VB
22283	798	16	the	the	DT
22283	798	17	generally	generally	RB
22283	798	18	accepted	accept	VBN
22283	798	19	theory	theory	NN
22283	798	20	of	of	IN
22283	798	21	things	thing	NNS
22283	798	22	,	,	,
22283	798	23	seeing	see	VBG
22283	798	24	that	that	IN
22283	798	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	798	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	798	27	the	the	DT
22283	798	28	only	only	JJ
22283	798	29	theory	theory	NN
22283	798	30	of	of	IN
22283	798	31	things	thing	NNS
22283	798	32	which	which	WDT
22283	798	33	can	can	MD
22283	798	34	receive	receive	VB
22283	798	35	the	the	DT
22283	798	36	sanction	sanction	NN
22283	798	37	of	of	IN
22283	798	38	science	science	NN
22283	798	39	on	on	IN
22283	798	40	the	the	DT
22283	798	41	one	one	CD
22283	798	42	hand	hand	NN
22283	798	43	and	and	CC
22283	798	44	of	of	IN
22283	798	45	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	798	46	on	on	IN
22283	798	47	the	the	DT
22283	798	48	other	other	JJ
22283	798	49	.	.	.
22283	799	1	But	but	CC
22283	799	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	799	3	disagree	disagree	VBP
22283	799	4	with	with	IN
22283	799	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	799	6	in	in	IN
22283	799	7	holding	hold	VBG
22283	799	8	that	that	IN
22283	799	9	this	this	DT
22283	799	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	799	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	799	12	fraught	fraught	JJ
22283	799	13	with	with	IN
22283	799	14	implications	implication	NNS
22283	799	15	of	of	IN
22283	799	16	an	an	DT
22283	799	17	anti	anti	JJ
22283	799	18	-	-	JJ
22283	799	19	theistic	theistic	JJ
22283	799	20	kind	kind	NN
22283	799	21	.	.	.
22283	800	1	In	in	IN
22283	800	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	800	3	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	800	4	this	this	DT
22283	800	5	theory	theory	NN
22283	800	6	leaves	leave	VBZ
22283	800	7	the	the	DT
22283	800	8	question	question	NN
22283	800	9	of	of	IN
22283	800	10	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	800	11	very	very	RB
22283	800	12	much	much	RB
22283	800	13	where	where	WRB
22283	800	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	800	15	was	be	VBD
22283	800	16	before	before	RB
22283	800	17	.	.	.
22283	801	1	That	that	DT
22283	801	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	801	3	to	to	TO
22283	801	4	say	say	VB
22283	801	5	,	,	,
22283	801	6	while	while	IN
22283	801	7	not	not	RB
22283	801	8	furnishing	furnish	VBG
22283	801	9	any	any	DT
22283	801	10	independent	independent	JJ
22283	801	11	proof	proof	NN
22283	801	12	of	of	IN
22283	801	13	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	801	14	,	,	,
22283	801	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	801	16	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	801	17	fails	fail	VBZ
22283	801	18	to	to	TO
22283	801	19	furnish	furnish	VB
22283	801	20	any	any	DT
22283	801	21	independent	independent	JJ
22283	801	22	disproof	disproof	NN
22283	801	23	.	.	.
22283	802	1	The	the	DT
22283	802	2	reason	reason	NN
22283	802	3	why	why	WRB
22283	802	4	in	in	IN
22283	802	5	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	802	6	's	's	POS
22283	802	7	hands	hand	NNS
22283	802	8	this	this	DT
22283	802	9	theory	theory	NN
22283	802	10	appeared	appear	VBD
22283	802	11	to	to	TO
22283	802	12	furnish	furnish	VB
22283	802	13	independent	independent	JJ
22283	802	14	disproof	disproof	NNP
22283	802	15	,	,	,
22283	802	16	was	be	VBD
22283	802	17	because	because	IN
22283	802	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	802	19	persisted	persist	VBD
22283	802	20	in	in	IN
22283	802	21	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	802	22	the	the	DT
22283	802	23	world	world	NN
22283	802	24	only	only	RB
22283	802	25	as	as	IN
22283	802	26	an	an	DT
22283	802	27	object	object	NN
22283	802	28	:	:	:
22283	802	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	802	30	did	do	VBD
22283	802	31	not	not	RB
22283	802	32	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	802	33	the	the	DT
22283	802	34	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	802	35	that	that	IN
22283	802	36	the	the	DT
22283	802	37	world	world	NN
22283	802	38	might	may	MD
22283	802	39	also	also	RB
22283	802	40	be	be	VB
22283	802	41	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	802	42	as	as	IN
22283	802	43	an	an	DT
22283	802	44	eject	eject	NN
22283	802	45	.	.	.
22283	803	1	Yet	yet	RB
22283	803	2	,	,	,
22283	803	3	that	that	IN
22283	803	4	the	the	DT
22283	803	5	world	world	NN
22283	803	6	,	,	,
22283	803	7	under	under	IN
22283	803	8	the	the	DT
22283	803	9	theory	theory	NN
22283	803	10	of	of	IN
22283	803	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	803	12	,	,	,
22283	803	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	803	14	at	at	IN
22283	803	15	least	least	JJS
22283	803	16	as	as	IN
22283	803	17	susceptible	susceptible	JJ
22283	803	18	of	of	IN
22283	803	19	an	an	DT
22283	803	20	ejective	ejective	NN
22283	803	21	as	as	IN
22283	803	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	803	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	803	24	of	of	IN
22283	803	25	an	an	DT
22283	803	26	objective	objective	JJ
22283	803	27	interpretation	interpretation	NN
22283	803	28	,	,	,
22283	803	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	803	30	trust	trust	VBP
22283	803	31	that	that	IN
22283	803	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	803	33	have	have	VBP
22283	803	34	now	now	RB
22283	803	35	been	be	VBN
22283	803	36	able	able	JJ
22283	803	37	to	to	TO
22283	803	38	show	show	VB
22283	803	39	.	.	.
22283	804	1	And	and	CC
22283	804	2	this	this	DT
22283	804	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	804	4	all	all	DT
22283	804	5	that	that	WDT
22283	804	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	804	7	have	have	VBP
22283	804	8	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
22283	804	9	to	to	TO
22283	804	10	show	show	VB
22283	804	11	.	.	.
22283	805	1	As	as	IN
22283	805	2	a	a	DT
22283	805	3	matter	matter	NN
22283	805	4	of	of	IN
22283	805	5	methodical	methodical	JJ
22283	805	6	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	805	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	805	8	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	805	9	to	to	IN
22283	805	10	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	805	11	that	that	IN
22283	805	12	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	805	13	alone	alone	RB
22283	805	14	can	can	MD
22283	805	15	only	only	RB
22283	805	16	lead	lead	VB
22283	805	17	to	to	IN
22283	805	18	Agnosticism	Agnosticism	NNP
22283	805	19	.	.	.
22283	806	1	That	that	DT
22283	806	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	806	3	to	to	TO
22283	806	4	say	say	VB
22283	806	5	,	,	,
22283	806	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	806	7	leaves	leave	VBZ
22283	806	8	a	a	DT
22283	806	9	clear	clear	JJ
22283	806	10	field	field	NN
22283	806	11	of	of	IN
22283	806	12	choice	choice	NN
22283	806	13	as	as	IN
22283	806	14	between	between	IN
22283	806	15	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	806	16	and	and	CC
22283	806	17	Atheism	Atheism	NNP
22283	806	18	;	;	:
22283	806	19	and	and	CC
22283	806	20	,	,	,
22283	806	21	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	806	22	,	,	,
22283	806	23	to	to	IN
22283	806	24	a	a	DT
22283	806	25	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	806	26	reasoning	reason	VBG
22283	806	27	Monist	Monist	NNP
22283	806	28	,	,	,
22283	806	29	there	there	EX
22283	806	30	are	be	VBP
22283	806	31	three	three	CD
22283	806	32	alternatives	alternative	NNS
22283	806	33	open	open	JJ
22283	806	34	.	.	.
22283	807	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	807	2	may	may	MD
22283	807	3	remain	remain	VB
22283	807	4	a	a	DT
22283	807	5	Monist	Monist	NNP
22283	807	6	,	,	,
22283	807	7	and	and	CC
22283	807	8	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	807	9	more	more	JJR
22283	807	10	;	;	:
22283	807	11	in	in	IN
22283	807	12	which	which	WDT
22283	807	13	case	case	NN
22283	807	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	807	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	807	16	an	an	DT
22283	807	17	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
22283	807	18	.	.	.
22283	808	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	808	2	may	may	MD
22283	808	3	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	808	4	what	what	WP
22283	808	5	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	808	6	to	to	IN
22283	808	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	808	8	independent	independent	JJ
22283	808	9	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	808	10	in	in	IN
22283	808	11	favour	favour	NN
22283	808	12	of	of	IN
22283	808	13	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	808	14	,	,	,
22283	808	15	and	and	CC
22283	808	16	thus	thus	RB
22283	808	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	808	18	may	may	MD
22283	808	19	become	become	VB
22283	808	20	a	a	DT
22283	808	21	theist	theist	NN
22283	808	22	.	.	.
22283	809	1	Or	or	CC
22283	809	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	809	3	may	may	MD
22283	809	4	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	809	5	what	what	WP
22283	809	6	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	809	7	to	to	IN
22283	809	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	809	9	independent	independent	JJ
22283	809	10	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	809	11	in	in	IN
22283	809	12	favour	favour	NN
22283	809	13	of	of	IN
22283	809	14	Atheism	Atheism	NNP
22283	809	15	,	,	,
22283	809	16	and	and	CC
22283	809	17	thus	thus	RB
22283	809	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	809	19	may	may	MD
22283	809	20	become	become	VB
22283	809	21	an	an	DT
22283	809	22	atheist	atheist	NN
22283	809	23	.	.	.
22283	810	1	But	but	CC
22283	810	2	,	,	,
22283	810	3	in	in	IN
22283	810	4	any	any	DT
22283	810	5	case	case	NN
22283	810	6	,	,	,
22283	810	7	so	so	RB
22283	810	8	far	far	RB
22283	810	9	as	as	IN
22283	810	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	810	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	810	12	can	can	MD
22283	810	13	carry	carry	VB
22283	810	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	810	15	,	,	,
22283	810	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	810	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	810	18	left	leave	VBN
22283	810	19	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	810	20	free	free	JJ
22283	810	21	either	either	CC
22283	810	22	to	to	TO
22283	810	23	regard	regard	VB
22283	810	24	the	the	DT
22283	810	25	world	world	NN
22283	810	26	as	as	IN
22283	810	27	an	an	DT
22283	810	28	object	object	NN
22283	810	29	alone	alone	RB
22283	810	30	,	,	,
22283	810	31	or	or	CC
22283	810	32	to	to	TO
22283	810	33	regard	regard	VB
22283	810	34	the	the	DT
22283	810	35	world	world	NN
22283	810	36	as	as	RB
22283	810	37	also	also	RB
22283	810	38	an	an	DT
22283	810	39	eject[12	eject[12	NN
22283	810	40	]	]	-RRB-
22283	810	41	.	.	.
22283	811	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
22283	811	2	:	:	:
22283	811	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	811	4	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	811	5	9	9	CD
22283	811	6	:	:	:
22283	811	7	If	if	IN
22283	811	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	811	9	imagine	imagine	VBP
22283	811	10	the	the	DT
22283	811	11	visible	visible	JJ
22283	811	12	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
22283	811	13	system	system	NN
22283	811	14	compressed	compress	VBN
22283	811	15	within	within	IN
22283	811	16	the	the	DT
22283	811	17	limits	limit	NNS
22283	811	18	of	of	IN
22283	811	19	a	a	DT
22283	811	20	human	human	JJ
22283	811	21	skull	skull	NN
22283	811	22	,	,	,
22283	811	23	so	so	IN
22283	811	24	that	that	IN
22283	811	25	all	all	PDT
22283	811	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	811	27	movements	movement	NNS
22283	811	28	which	which	WDT
22283	811	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	811	30	now	now	RB
22283	811	31	recognize	recognize	VBP
22283	811	32	as	as	IN
22283	811	33	molar	molar	JJ
22283	811	34	should	should	MD
22283	811	35	become	become	VB
22283	811	36	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	811	37	,	,	,
22283	811	38	the	the	DT
22283	811	39	complexity	complexity	NN
22283	811	40	of	of	IN
22283	811	41	such	such	JJ
22283	811	42	movement	movement	NN
22283	811	43	would	would	MD
22283	811	44	probably	probably	RB
22283	811	45	be	be	VB
22283	811	46	as	as	RB
22283	811	47	great	great	JJ
22283	811	48	as	as	IN
22283	811	49	that	that	DT
22283	811	50	which	which	WDT
22283	811	51	takes	take	VBZ
22283	811	52	place	place	NN
22283	811	53	in	in	IN
22283	811	54	a	a	DT
22283	811	55	human	human	JJ
22283	811	56	brain	brain	NN
22283	811	57	.	.	.
22283	812	1	Yet	yet	CC
22283	812	2	to	to	IN
22283	812	3	this	this	DT
22283	812	4	must	must	MD
22283	812	5	be	be	VB
22283	812	6	added	add	VBN
22283	812	7	all	all	PDT
22283	812	8	the	the	DT
22283	812	9	molecular	molecular	JJ
22283	812	10	movements	movement	NNS
22283	812	11	which	which	WDT
22283	812	12	are	be	VBP
22283	812	13	now	now	RB
22283	812	14	going	go	VBG
22283	812	15	on	on	RP
22283	812	16	in	in	IN
22283	812	17	the	the	DT
22283	812	18	sidereal	sidereal	JJ
22283	812	19	system	system	NN
22283	812	20	,	,	,
22283	812	21	visible	visible	JJ
22283	812	22	and	and	CC
22283	812	23	invisible	invisible	JJ
22283	812	24	.	.	.
22283	812	25	]	]	-RRB-
22283	813	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	813	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
22283	813	3	10	10	CD
22283	813	4	:	:	:
22283	813	5	_	_	NNP
22283	813	6	Principles	Principles	NNPS
22283	813	7	of	of	IN
22283	813	8	Psychology	Psychology	NNP
22283	813	9	_	_	NNP
22283	813	10	,	,	,
22283	813	11	vol	vol	NNP
22283	813	12	.	.	.
22283	814	1	i.	i.	NNP
22283	814	2	pp	pp	NNP
22283	814	3	.	.	.
22283	815	1	159	159	CD
22283	815	2	-	-	SYM
22283	815	3	61	61	CD
22283	815	4	;	;	:
22283	815	5	_	_	NNP
22283	815	6	Essays	Essays	NNP
22283	815	7	_	_	NNP
22283	815	8	,	,	,
22283	815	9	vol	vol	NNP
22283	815	10	.	.	.
22283	816	1	iii	iii	NNP
22283	816	2	.	.	.
22283	817	1	pp	pp	NNP
22283	817	2	.	.	.
22283	818	1	246	246	CD
22283	818	2	-	-	SYM
22283	818	3	9	9	CD
22283	818	4	;	;	:
22283	818	5	and	and	CC
22283	818	6	_	_	NNP
22283	818	7	First	First	NNP
22283	818	8	Principles	Principles	NNPS
22283	818	9	_	_	NNP
22283	818	10	,	,	,
22283	818	11	p.	p.	NN
22283	819	1	26	26	CD
22283	819	2	.	.	.
22283	819	3	]	]	-RRB-
22283	820	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	820	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	820	3	11	11	CD
22283	820	4	:	:	:
22283	820	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	820	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	820	7	,	,	,
22283	820	8	however	however	RB
22283	820	9	,	,	,
22283	820	10	the	the	DT
22283	820	11	belief	belief	NN
22283	820	12	of	of	IN
22283	820	13	all	all	DT
22283	820	14	religious	religious	JJ
22283	820	15	persons	person	NNS
22283	820	16	that	that	IN
22283	820	17	even	even	RB
22283	820	18	this	this	DT
22283	820	19	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	820	20	does	do	VBZ
22283	820	21	not	not	RB
22283	820	22	hold	hold	VB
22283	820	23	.	.	.
22283	821	1	If	if	IN
22283	821	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	821	3	are	be	VBP
22283	821	4	right	right	JJ
22283	821	5	in	in	IN
22283	821	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	821	7	belief	belief	NN
22283	821	8	,	,	,
22283	821	9	the	the	DT
22283	821	10	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	821	11	would	would	MD
22283	821	12	then	then	RB
22283	821	13	become	become	VB
22283	821	14	one	one	CD
22283	821	15	as	as	IN
22283	821	16	to	to	IN
22283	821	17	the	the	DT
22283	821	18	mode	mode	NN
22283	821	19	of	of	IN
22283	821	20	converse	converse	NN
22283	821	21	.	.	.
22283	822	1	In	in	IN
22283	822	2	this	this	DT
22283	822	3	case	case	NN
22283	822	4	what	what	WP
22283	822	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	822	6	called	call	VBN
22283	822	7	communion	communion	NN
22283	822	8	with	with	IN
22283	822	9	the	the	DT
22283	822	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
22283	822	11	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	822	12	must	must	MD
22283	822	13	be	be	VB
22283	822	14	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	822	15	to	to	TO
22283	822	16	be	be	VB
22283	822	17	a	a	DT
22283	822	18	communion	communion	NN
22283	822	19	_	_	NNP
22283	822	20	sui	sui	NNP
22283	822	21	generis	generis	NNP
22283	822	22	_	_	NNP
22283	822	23	:	:	:
22283	822	24	the	the	DT
22283	822	25	converse	converse	NN
22283	822	26	of	of	IN
22283	822	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	822	28	with	with	IN
22283	822	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	822	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	822	31	here	here	RB
22283	822	32	_	_	NNP
22283	822	33	direct	direct	JJ
22283	822	34	_	_	NNP
22283	822	35	,	,	,
22283	822	36	or	or	CC
22283	822	37	does	do	VBZ
22283	822	38	not	not	RB
22283	822	39	require	require	VB
22283	822	40	to	to	TO
22283	822	41	be	be	VB
22283	822	42	translated	translate	VBN
22283	822	43	into	into	IN
22283	822	44	the	the	DT
22283	822	45	language	language	NN
22283	822	46	of	of	IN
22283	822	47	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
22283	822	48	signs	sign	NNS
22283	822	49	:	:	:
22283	822	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	822	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	822	52	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	822	53	,	,	,
22283	822	54	not	not	RB
22283	822	55	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	822	56	.	.	.
22283	823	1	Still	still	RB
22283	823	2	,	,	,
22283	823	3	even	even	RB
22283	823	4	here	here	RB
22283	823	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	823	6	must	must	MD
22283	823	7	believe	believe	VB
22283	823	8	that	that	IN
22283	823	9	the	the	DT
22283	823	10	physical	physical	JJ
22283	823	11	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	823	12	accompanies	accompany	VBZ
22283	823	13	the	the	DT
22283	823	14	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	823	15	,	,	,
22283	823	16	although	although	IN
22283	823	17	not	not	RB
22283	823	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	823	19	observed	observe	VBN
22283	823	20	.	.	.
22283	824	1	An	an	DT
22283	824	2	act	act	NN
22283	824	3	of	of	IN
22283	824	4	prayer	prayer	NN
22283	824	5	,	,	,
22283	824	6	for	for	IN
22283	824	7	example	example	NN
22283	824	8	,	,	,
22283	824	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	824	10	,	,	,
22283	824	11	on	on	IN
22283	824	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	824	13	physical	physical	JJ
22283	824	14	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	824	15	,	,	,
22283	824	16	an	an	DT
22283	824	17	act	act	NN
22283	824	18	of	of	IN
22283	824	19	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	824	20	:	:	:
22283	824	21	so	so	RB
22283	824	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	824	23	the	the	DT
22283	824	24	answer	answer	NN
22283	824	25	(	(	-LRB-
22283	824	26	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	824	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	824	28	genuine	genuine	JJ
22283	824	29	)	)	-RRB-
22283	824	30	,	,	,
22283	824	31	in	in	IN
22283	824	32	as	as	RB
22283	824	33	far	far	RB
22283	824	34	as	as	IN
22283	824	35	the	the	DT
22283	824	36	worshipper	worshipper	NN
22283	824	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	824	38	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	824	39	.	.	.
22283	825	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	825	2	prayer	prayer	NN
22283	825	3	and	and	CC
22283	825	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	825	5	answer	answer	NN
22283	825	6	(	(	-LRB-
22283	825	7	according	accord	VBG
22283	825	8	to	to	IN
22283	825	9	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	825	10	)	)	-RRB-
22283	825	11	resemble	resemble	VBP
22283	825	12	all	all	PDT
22283	825	13	the	the	DT
22283	825	14	other	other	JJ
22283	825	15	processes	process	NNS
22283	825	16	of	of	IN
22283	825	17	Nature	nature	NN
22283	825	18	in	in	IN
22283	825	19	presenting	present	VBG
22283	825	20	an	an	DT
22283	825	21	objective	objective	JJ
22283	825	22	side	side	NN
22283	825	23	of	of	IN
22283	825	24	strictly	strictly	RB
22283	825	25	physical	physical	JJ
22283	825	26	causation	causation	NN
22283	825	27	.	.	.
22283	826	1	Nor	nor	CC
22283	826	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	826	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	826	4	possible	possible	JJ
22283	826	5	that	that	IN
22283	826	6	the	the	DT
22283	826	7	case	case	NN
22283	826	8	could	could	MD
22283	826	9	be	be	VB
22283	826	10	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	826	11	,	,	,
22283	826	12	if	if	IN
22283	826	13	_	_	NNP
22283	826	14	all	all	DT
22283	826	15	_	_	NNP
22283	826	16	mental	mental	JJ
22283	826	17	processes	process	NNS
22283	826	18	consist	consist	VBP
22283	826	19	in	in	IN
22283	826	20	physical	physical	JJ
22283	826	21	process	process	NN
22283	826	22	,	,	,
22283	826	23	and	and	CC
22283	826	24	vice	vice	NN
22283	826	25	versa	versa	RB
22283	826	26	.	.	.
22283	827	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	827	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	827	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	827	4	that	that	IN
22283	827	5	this	this	DT
22283	827	6	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	827	7	has	have	VBZ
22283	827	8	important	important	JJ
22283	827	9	bearings	bearing	NNS
22283	827	10	on	on	IN
22283	827	11	the	the	DT
22283	827	12	question	question	NN
22283	827	13	as	as	IN
22283	827	14	to	to	IN
22283	827	15	the	the	DT
22283	827	16	physical	physical	JJ
22283	827	17	efficacy	efficacy	NN
22283	827	18	of	of	IN
22283	827	19	prayer	prayer	NN
22283	827	20	.	.	.
22283	828	1	From	from	IN
22283	828	2	a	a	DT
22283	828	3	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	828	4	point	point	NN
22283	828	5	of	of	IN
22283	828	6	view	view	NN
22283	828	7	both	both	DT
22283	828	8	those	those	DT
22283	828	9	who	who	WP
22283	828	10	affirm	affirm	VBP
22283	828	11	and	and	CC
22283	828	12	those	those	DT
22283	828	13	who	who	WP
22283	828	14	deny	deny	VBP
22283	828	15	such	such	JJ
22283	828	16	efficacy	efficacy	NN
22283	828	17	are	be	VBP
22283	828	18	equally	equally	RB
22283	828	19	in	in	IN
22283	828	20	the	the	DT
22283	828	21	right	right	NN
22283	828	22	,	,	,
22283	828	23	and	and	CC
22283	828	24	equally	equally	RB
22283	828	25	in	in	IN
22283	828	26	the	the	DT
22283	828	27	wrong	wrong	NN
22283	828	28	;	;	:
22283	828	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	828	30	are	be	VBP
22283	828	31	merely	merely	RB
22283	828	32	quarrelling	quarrel	VBG
22283	828	33	upon	upon	IN
22283	828	34	different	different	JJ
22283	828	35	sides	side	NNS
22283	828	36	of	of	IN
22283	828	37	the	the	DT
22283	828	38	same	same	JJ
22283	828	39	shield	shield	NN
22283	828	40	.	.	.
22283	829	1	For	for	IN
22283	829	2	,	,	,
22283	829	3	according	accord	VBG
22283	829	4	to	to	IN
22283	829	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	829	6	,	,	,
22283	829	7	if	if	IN
22283	829	8	the	the	DT
22283	829	9	theologians	theologian	NNS
22283	829	10	are	be	VBP
22283	829	11	right	right	JJ
22283	829	12	in	in	IN
22283	829	13	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	829	14	that	that	IN
22283	829	15	the	the	DT
22283	829	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
22283	829	17	Mind	Mind	NNP
22283	829	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	829	19	the	the	DT
22283	829	20	hearer	hearer	NN
22283	829	21	of	of	IN
22283	829	22	prayer	prayer	NN
22283	829	23	in	in	IN
22283	829	24	any	any	DT
22283	829	25	case	case	NN
22283	829	26	,	,	,
22283	829	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	829	28	are	be	VBP
22283	829	29	also	also	RB
22283	829	30	right	right	JJ
22283	829	31	in	in	IN
22283	829	32	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	829	33	that	that	IN
22283	829	34	the	the	DT
22283	829	35	Mind	mind	NN
22283	829	36	must	must	MD
22283	829	37	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	829	38	be	be	VB
22283	829	39	able	able	JJ
22283	829	40	to	to	TO
22283	829	41	grant	grant	VB
22283	829	42	what	what	WP
22283	829	43	is	be	VBZ
22283	829	44	called	call	VBN
22283	829	45	physical	physical	JJ
22283	829	46	answers	answer	NNS
22283	829	47	,	,	,
22283	829	48	seeing	see	VBG
22283	829	49	that	that	IN
22283	829	50	in	in	IN
22283	829	51	order	order	NN
22283	829	52	to	to	TO
22283	829	53	grant	grant	VB
22283	829	54	_	_	NNP
22283	829	55	any	any	DT
22283	829	56	_	_	NNP
22283	829	57	answer	answer	NN
22283	829	58	(	(	-LRB-
22283	829	59	even	even	RB
22283	829	60	of	of	IN
22283	829	61	the	the	DT
22283	829	62	most	most	RBS
22283	829	63	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	829	64	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
22283	829	65	kind	kind	NN
22283	829	66	)	)	-RRB-
22283	829	67	some	some	DT
22283	829	68	physical	physical	JJ
22283	829	69	change	change	NN
22283	829	70	must	must	MD
22283	829	71	be	be	VB
22283	829	72	produced	produce	VBN
22283	829	73	,	,	,
22283	829	74	if	if	IN
22283	829	75	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	829	76	be	be	VB
22283	829	77	only	only	RB
22283	829	78	in	in	IN
22283	829	79	the	the	DT
22283	829	80	brain	brain	NN
22283	829	81	of	of	IN
22283	829	82	the	the	DT
22283	829	83	petitioner	petitioner	NN
22283	829	84	.	.	.
22283	830	1	On	on	IN
22283	830	2	the	the	DT
22283	830	3	other	other	JJ
22283	830	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	830	5	,	,	,
22283	830	6	the	the	DT
22283	830	7	scientists	scientist	NNS
22283	830	8	are	be	VBP
22283	830	9	equally	equally	RB
22283	830	10	right	right	JJ
22283	830	11	in	in	IN
22283	830	12	maintaining	maintain	VBG
22283	830	13	that	that	IN
22283	830	14	no	no	DT
22283	830	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	830	16	answer	answer	NN
22283	830	17	to	to	IN
22283	830	18	prayer	prayer	NN
22283	830	19	can	can	MD
22283	830	20	be	be	VB
22283	830	21	of	of	IN
22283	830	22	the	the	DT
22283	830	23	nature	nature	NN
22283	830	24	of	of	IN
22283	830	25	a	a	DT
22283	830	26	miracle	miracle	NN
22283	830	27	,	,	,
22283	830	28	or	or	CC
22283	830	29	produced	produce	VBN
22283	830	30	independently	independently	RB
22283	830	31	of	of	IN
22283	830	32	strictly	strictly	RB
22283	830	33	physical	physical	JJ
22283	830	34	causation	causation	NN
22283	830	35	;	;	:
22283	830	36	for	for	IN
22283	830	37	,	,	,
22283	830	38	if	if	IN
22283	830	39	so	so	RB
22283	830	40	,	,	,
22283	830	41	the	the	DT
22283	830	42	physical	physical	NN
22283	830	43	and	and	CC
22283	830	44	the	the	DT
22283	830	45	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	830	46	would	would	MD
22283	830	47	no	no	RB
22283	830	48	longer	longer	RB
22283	830	49	be	be	VB
22283	830	50	coincident	coincident	JJ
22283	830	51	.	.	.
22283	831	1	But	but	CC
22283	831	2	,	,	,
22283	831	3	until	until	IN
22283	831	4	the	the	DT
22283	831	5	scientists	scientist	NNS
22283	831	6	are	be	VBP
22283	831	7	able	able	JJ
22283	831	8	to	to	TO
22283	831	9	perform	perform	VB
22283	831	10	the	the	DT
22283	831	11	hopeless	hopeless	JJ
22283	831	12	task	task	NN
22283	831	13	of	of	IN
22283	831	14	proving	prove	VBG
22283	831	15	where	where	WRB
22283	831	16	the	the	DT
22283	831	17	possibilities	possibility	NNS
22283	831	18	of	of	IN
22283	831	19	physical	physical	JJ
22283	831	20	causation	causation	NN
22283	831	21	end	end	NN
22283	831	22	,	,	,
22283	831	23	as	as	IN
22283	831	24	a	a	DT
22283	831	25	mere	mere	JJ
22283	831	26	matter	matter	NN
22283	831	27	of	of	IN
22283	831	28	abstract	abstract	JJ
22283	831	29	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	831	30	and	and	CC
22283	831	31	going	go	VBG
22283	831	32	upon	upon	IN
22283	831	33	the	the	DT
22283	831	34	theory	theory	NN
22283	831	35	of	of	IN
22283	831	36	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	831	37	,	,	,
22283	831	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	831	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	831	40	evident	evident	JJ
22283	831	41	that	that	IN
22283	831	42	the	the	DT
22283	831	43	theologians	theologian	NNS
22283	831	44	may	may	MD
22283	831	45	have	have	VB
22283	831	46	any	any	DT
22283	831	47	latitude	latitude	NN
22283	831	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	831	49	choose	choose	VBP
22283	831	50	to	to	TO
22283	831	51	claim	claim	VB
22283	831	52	,	,	,
22283	831	53	both	both	CC
22283	831	54	as	as	IN
22283	831	55	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	831	56	this	this	DT
22283	831	57	matter	matter	NN
22283	831	58	and	and	CC
22283	831	59	that	that	DT
22283	831	60	of	of	IN
22283	831	61	so	so	RB
22283	831	62	-	-	HYPH
22283	831	63	called	call	VBN
22283	831	64	miracles	miracle	NNS
22283	831	65	.	.	.
22283	831	66	]	]	-RRB-
22283	832	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	832	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
22283	832	3	12	12	CD
22283	832	4	:	:	:
22283	832	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	832	6	may	may	MD
22283	832	7	be	be	VB
22283	832	8	explained	explain	VBN
22283	832	9	that	that	IN
22283	832	10	by	by	IN
22283	832	11	Agnosticism	Agnosticism	NNP
22283	832	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	832	13	understand	understand	VBP
22283	832	14	a	a	DT
22283	832	15	theory	theory	NN
22283	832	16	of	of	IN
22283	832	17	things	thing	NNS
22283	832	18	which	which	WDT
22283	832	19	abstains	abstain	VBZ
22283	832	20	from	from	IN
22283	832	21	either	either	CC
22283	832	22	affirming	affirming	NN
22283	832	23	or	or	CC
22283	832	24	denying	deny	VBG
22283	832	25	the	the	DT
22283	832	26	existence	existence	NN
22283	832	27	of	of	IN
22283	832	28	God	God	NNP
22283	832	29	.	.	.
22283	833	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	833	2	thus	thus	RB
22283	833	3	represents	represent	VBZ
22283	833	4	,	,	,
22283	833	5	with	with	IN
22283	833	6	regard	regard	NN
22283	833	7	to	to	IN
22283	833	8	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	833	9	,	,	,
22283	833	10	a	a	DT
22283	833	11	state	state	NN
22283	833	12	of	of	IN
22283	833	13	suspended	suspend	VBN
22283	833	14	judgement	judgement	NN
22283	833	15	;	;	:
22283	833	16	and	and	CC
22283	833	17	all	all	DT
22283	833	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	833	19	undertakes	undertake	VBZ
22283	833	20	to	to	TO
22283	833	21	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	833	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	833	23	,	,	,
22283	833	24	that	that	IN
22283	833	25	,	,	,
22283	833	26	upon	upon	IN
22283	833	27	existing	exist	VBG
22283	833	28	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	833	29	,	,	,
22283	833	30	the	the	DT
22283	833	31	being	being	NN
22283	833	32	of	of	IN
22283	833	33	God	God	NNP
22283	833	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	833	35	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	833	36	.	.	.
22283	834	1	But	but	CC
22283	834	2	the	the	DT
22283	834	3	term	term	NN
22283	834	4	Agnosticism	Agnosticism	NNP
22283	834	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	834	6	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	834	7	used	use	VBN
22283	834	8	in	in	IN
22283	834	9	a	a	DT
22283	834	10	widely	widely	RB
22283	834	11	different	different	JJ
22283	834	12	sense	sense	NN
22283	834	13	,	,	,
22283	834	14	as	as	IN
22283	834	15	implying	implying	JJ
22283	834	16	belief	belief	NN
22283	834	17	that	that	IN
22283	834	18	the	the	DT
22283	834	19	being	being	NN
22283	834	20	of	of	IN
22283	834	21	God	God	NNP
22283	834	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	834	23	not	not	RB
22283	834	24	merely	merely	RB
22283	834	25	now	now	RB
22283	834	26	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	834	27	,	,	,
22283	834	28	but	but	CC
22283	834	29	must	must	MD
22283	834	30	always	always	RB
22283	834	31	remain	remain	VB
22283	834	32	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
22283	834	33	.	.	.
22283	835	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	835	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	835	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	835	4	often	often	RB
22283	835	5	represented	represent	VBN
22283	835	6	that	that	IN
22283	835	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	835	8	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
22283	835	9	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	835	10	,	,	,
22283	835	11	in	in	IN
22283	835	12	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	835	13	of	of	IN
22283	835	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	835	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	835	16	of	of	IN
22283	835	17	the	the	DT
22283	835	18	Unknowable	Unknowable	NNP
22283	835	19	,	,	,
22283	835	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	835	21	a	a	DT
22283	835	22	kind	kind	NN
22283	835	23	of	of	IN
22283	835	24	apostle	apostle	NN
22283	835	25	of	of	IN
22283	835	26	Agnosticism	Agnosticism	NNP
22283	835	27	.	.	.
22283	836	1	This	this	DT
22283	836	2	,	,	,
22283	836	3	however	however	RB
22283	836	4	,	,	,
22283	836	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	836	6	conceive	conceive	VBP
22283	836	7	to	to	TO
22283	836	8	be	be	VB
22283	836	9	a	a	DT
22283	836	10	great	great	JJ
22283	836	11	mistake	mistake	NN
22283	836	12	.	.	.
22283	837	1	The	the	DT
22283	837	2	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
22283	837	3	features	feature	NNS
22283	837	4	of	of	IN
22283	837	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	837	6	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	837	7	's	's	POS
22283	837	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	837	9	of	of	IN
22283	837	10	the	the	DT
22283	837	11	Unknowable	Unknowable	NNP
22283	837	12	are	be	VBP
22283	837	13	not	not	RB
22283	837	14	merely	merely	RB
22283	837	15	non	non	JJ
22283	837	16	-	-	JJ
22283	837	17	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
22283	837	18	,	,	,
22283	837	19	but	but	CC
22283	837	20	anti	anti	JJ
22283	837	21	-	-	JJ
22283	837	22	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
22283	837	23	.	.	.
22283	838	1	For	for	IN
22283	838	2	the	the	DT
22283	838	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	838	4	affirms	affirm	VBZ
22283	838	5	that	that	IN
22283	838	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	838	7	have	have	VBP
22283	838	8	this	this	DT
22283	838	9	much	much	JJ
22283	838	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	838	11	of	of	IN
22283	838	12	God	God	NNP
22283	838	13	--	--	:
22283	838	14	namely	namely	RB
22283	838	15	,	,	,
22283	838	16	that	that	IN
22283	838	17	if	if	IN
22283	838	18	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	838	19	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	838	20	,	,	,
22283	838	21	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	838	22	must	must	MD
22283	838	23	for	for	IN
22283	838	24	ever	ever	RB
22283	838	25	be	be	VB
22283	838	26	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	838	27	.	.	.
22283	839	1	Without	without	IN
22283	839	2	question	question	NN
22283	839	3	,	,	,
22283	839	4	this	this	DT
22283	839	5	would	would	MD
22283	839	6	be	be	VB
22283	839	7	a	a	DT
22283	839	8	most	most	RBS
22283	839	9	important	important	JJ
22283	839	10	piece	piece	NN
22283	839	11	of	of	IN
22283	839	12	definite	definite	JJ
22283	839	13	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	839	14	with	with	IN
22283	839	15	regard	regard	NN
22283	839	16	to	to	IN
22283	839	17	Deity	Deity	NNP
22283	839	18	,	,	,
22283	839	19	negative	negative	JJ
22283	839	20	though	though	IN
22283	839	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	839	22	be	be	VBP
22283	839	23	;	;	:
22283	839	24	and	and	CC
22283	839	25	,	,	,
22283	839	26	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	839	27	,	,	,
22283	839	28	any	any	DT
22283	839	29	man	man	NN
22283	839	30	who	who	WP
22283	839	31	holds	hold	VBZ
22283	839	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	839	33	has	have	VBZ
22283	839	34	no	no	DT
22283	839	35	right	right	NN
22283	839	36	to	to	TO
22283	839	37	be	be	VB
22283	839	38	called	call	VBN
22283	839	39	an	an	DT
22283	839	40	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
22283	839	41	.	.	.
22283	840	1	To	to	IN
22283	840	2	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	840	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	840	4	has	have	VBZ
22283	840	5	always	always	RB
22283	840	6	seemed	seem	VBN
22283	840	7	that	that	IN
22283	840	8	the	the	DT
22283	840	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	840	10	of	of	IN
22283	840	11	the	the	DT
22283	840	12	Unknowable	Unknowable	NNP
22283	840	13	,	,	,
22283	840	14	in	in	IN
22283	840	15	so	so	RB
22283	840	16	far	far	RB
22283	840	17	as	as	IN
22283	840	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	840	19	differs	differ	VBZ
22283	840	20	from	from	IN
22283	840	21	the	the	DT
22283	840	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	840	23	of	of	IN
22283	840	24	the	the	DT
22283	840	25	Unknown	Unknown	NNP
22283	840	26	,	,	,
22283	840	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	840	28	highly	highly	RB
22283	840	29	unphilosophical	unphilosophical	JJ
22283	840	30	.	.	.
22283	841	1	By	by	IN
22283	841	2	what	what	WDT
22283	841	3	right	right	RB
22283	841	4	can	can	MD
22283	841	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	841	6	be	be	VB
22283	841	7	affirmed	affirm	VBN
22283	841	8	that	that	IN
22283	841	9	Deity	Deity	NNP
22283	841	10	,	,	,
22283	841	11	if	if	IN
22283	841	12	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	841	13	exists	exist	VBZ
22283	841	14	,	,	,
22283	841	15	may	may	MD
22283	841	16	not	not	RB
22283	841	17	reveal	reveal	VB
22283	841	18	the	the	DT
22283	841	19	fact	fact	NN
22283	841	20	of	of	IN
22283	841	21	His	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	841	22	existence	existence	NN
22283	841	23	to	to	IN
22283	841	24	-	-	HYPH
22283	841	25	morrow	morrow	NN
22283	841	26	--	--	:
22283	841	27	and	and	CC
22283	841	28	this	this	DT
22283	841	29	to	to	IN
22283	841	30	the	the	DT
22283	841	31	whole	whole	JJ
22283	841	32	human	human	JJ
22283	841	33	race	race	NN
22283	841	34	without	without	IN
22283	841	35	the	the	DT
22283	841	36	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	841	37	of	of	IN
22283	841	38	doubt	doubt	NN
22283	841	39	?	?	.
22283	842	1	Or	or	CC
22283	842	2	,	,	,
22283	842	3	if	if	IN
22283	842	4	there	there	EX
22283	842	5	be	be	VB
22283	842	6	a	a	DT
22283	842	7	God	God	NNP
22283	842	8	,	,	,
22283	842	9	who	who	WP
22283	842	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	842	11	to	to	TO
22283	842	12	say	say	VB
22283	842	13	that	that	IN
22283	842	14	there	there	EX
22283	842	15	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	842	16	can	can	MD
22283	842	17	not	not	RB
22283	842	18	be	be	VB
22283	842	19	a	a	DT
22283	842	20	future	future	JJ
22283	842	21	life	life	NN
22283	842	22	,	,	,
22283	842	23	in	in	IN
22283	842	24	which	which	WDT
22283	842	25	each	each	DT
22283	842	26	individual	individual	JJ
22283	842	27	man	man	NN
22283	842	28	may	may	MD
22283	842	29	have	have	VB
22283	842	30	unquestionable	unquestionable	JJ
22283	842	31	proof	proof	NN
22283	842	32	of	of	IN
22283	842	33	Theism	theism	NN
22283	842	34	?	?	.
22283	843	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	843	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	843	3	a	a	DT
22283	843	4	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	843	5	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	843	6	statement	statement	NN
22283	843	7	for	for	IN
22283	843	8	any	any	DT
22283	843	9	one	one	NN
22283	843	10	to	to	TO
22283	843	11	make	make	VB
22283	843	12	that	that	DT
22283	843	13	,	,	,
22283	843	14	as	as	IN
22283	843	15	matters	matter	NNS
22283	843	16	now	now	RB
22283	843	17	stand	stand	VBP
22283	843	18	,	,	,
22283	843	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	843	20	can	can	MD
22283	843	21	see	see	VB
22283	843	22	no	no	DT
22283	843	23	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	843	24	of	of	IN
22283	843	25	Theism	theism	NN
22283	843	26	;	;	:
22283	843	27	but	but	CC
22283	843	28	to	to	TO
22283	843	29	say	say	VB
22283	843	30	that	that	IN
22283	843	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	843	32	knows	know	VBZ
22283	843	33	the	the	DT
22283	843	34	human	human	JJ
22283	843	35	race	race	NN
22283	843	36	never	never	RB
22283	843	37	can	can	MD
22283	843	38	have	have	VB
22283	843	39	such	such	JJ
22283	843	40	evidence	evidence	NN
22283	843	41	,	,	,
22283	843	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	843	43	a	a	DT
22283	843	44	most	most	RBS
22283	843	45	unphilosophical	unphilosophical	JJ
22283	843	46	statement	statement	NN
22283	843	47	,	,	,
22283	843	48	seeing	see	VBG
22283	843	49	that	that	IN
22283	843	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	843	51	could	could	MD
22283	843	52	only	only	RB
22283	843	53	be	be	VB
22283	843	54	justified	justify	VBN
22283	843	55	by	by	IN
22283	843	56	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	843	57	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	843	58	.	.	.
22283	844	1	And	and	CC
22283	844	2	,	,	,
22283	844	3	on	on	IN
22283	844	4	this	this	DT
22283	844	5	account	account	NN
22283	844	6	,	,	,
22283	844	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	844	8	say	say	VBP
22283	844	9	that	that	IN
22283	844	10	the	the	DT
22283	844	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	844	12	of	of	IN
22283	844	13	the	the	DT
22283	844	14	Unknowable	Unknowable	NNP
22283	844	15	,	,	,
22283	844	16	in	in	IN
22283	844	17	so	so	RB
22283	844	18	far	far	RB
22283	844	19	as	as	IN
22283	844	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	844	21	differs	differ	VBZ
22283	844	22	from	from	IN
22283	844	23	the	the	DT
22283	844	24	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	844	25	of	of	IN
22283	844	26	the	the	DT
22283	844	27	Unknown	Unknown	NNP
22283	844	28	,	,	,
22283	844	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	844	30	the	the	DT
22283	844	31	very	very	RB
22283	844	32	reverse	reverse	NN
22283	844	33	of	of	IN
22283	844	34	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
22283	844	35	.	.	.
22283	845	1	Now	now	RB
22283	845	2	,	,	,
22283	845	3	the	the	DT
22283	845	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	845	5	of	of	IN
22283	845	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	845	7	alone	alone	RB
22283	845	8	,	,	,
22283	845	9	as	as	IN
22283	845	10	observed	observe	VBN
22283	845	11	in	in	IN
22283	845	12	the	the	DT
22283	845	13	text	text	NN
22283	845	14	,	,	,
22283	845	15	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	845	16	to	to	TO
22283	845	17	be	be	VB
22283	845	18	purely	purely	RB
22283	845	19	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
22283	845	20	in	in	IN
22283	845	21	the	the	DT
22283	845	22	sense	sense	NN
22283	845	23	just	just	RB
22283	845	24	explained	explain	VBD
22283	845	25	.	.	.
22283	846	1	If	if	IN
22283	846	2	in	in	IN
22283	846	3	some	some	DT
22283	846	4	parts	part	NNS
22283	846	5	of	of	IN
22283	846	6	the	the	DT
22283	846	7	foregoing	foregoing	NN
22283	846	8	essay	essay	NN
22283	846	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	846	10	appear	appear	VBP
22283	846	11	to	to	TO
22283	846	12	have	have	VB
22283	846	13	been	be	VBN
22283	846	14	arguing	argue	VBG
22283	846	15	in	in	IN
22283	846	16	favour	favour	NN
22283	846	17	of	of	IN
22283	846	18	theistic	theistic	JJ
22283	846	19	implications	implication	NNS
22283	846	20	,	,	,
22283	846	21	this	this	DT
22283	846	22	has	have	VBZ
22283	846	23	only	only	RB
22283	846	24	been	be	VBN
22283	846	25	in	in	IN
22283	846	26	order	order	NN
22283	846	27	to	to	TO
22283	846	28	show	show	VB
22283	846	29	(	(	-LRB-
22283	846	30	as	as	IN
22283	846	31	against	against	IN
22283	846	32	Clifford	Clifford	NNP
22283	846	33	)	)	-RRB-
22283	846	34	that	that	IN
22283	846	35	the	the	DT
22283	846	36	world	world	NN
22283	846	37	does	do	VBZ
22283	846	38	admit	admit	VB
22283	846	39	of	of	IN
22283	846	40	being	be	VBG
22283	846	41	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	846	42	as	as	IN
22283	846	43	an	an	DT
22283	846	44	eject	eject	NN
22283	846	45	.	.	.
22283	847	1	But	but	CC
22283	847	2	inasmuch	inasmuch	VB
22283	847	3	as	as	IN
22283	847	4	--	--	:
22283	847	5	religious	religious	JJ
22283	847	6	faith	faith	NN
22283	847	7	apart	apart	RB
22283	847	8	--	--	:
22283	847	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	847	10	are	be	VBP
22283	847	11	not	not	RB
22283	847	12	able	able	JJ
22283	847	13	to	to	TO
22283	847	14	verify	verify	VB
22283	847	15	any	any	DT
22283	847	16	such	such	JJ
22283	847	17	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	847	18	interpretation	interpretation	NN
22283	847	19	,	,	,
22283	847	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	847	21	are	be	VBP
22283	847	22	not	not	RB
22283	847	23	able	able	JJ
22283	847	24	to	to	TO
22283	847	25	estimate	estimate	VB
22283	847	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	847	27	value	value	NN
22283	847	28	.	.	.
22283	848	1	Monism	monism	NN
22283	848	2	sanctions	sanction	VBZ
22283	848	3	the	the	DT
22283	848	4	shading	shading	NN
22283	848	5	of	of	IN
22283	848	6	_	_	NNP
22283	848	7	x	x	NNP
22283	848	8	_	_	NNP
22283	848	9	as	as	RB
22283	848	10	deeply	deeply	RB
22283	848	11	as	as	IN
22283	848	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	848	13	choose	choose	VBP
22283	848	14	;	;	:
22283	848	15	but	but	CC
22283	848	16	the	the	DT
22283	848	17	shading	shading	NN
22283	848	18	which	which	WDT
22283	848	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	848	20	sanctions	sanction	VBZ
22283	848	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	848	22	only	only	RB
22283	848	23	provisional	provisional	JJ
22283	848	24	.	.	.
22283	848	25	]	]	-RRB-
22283	849	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
22283	849	2	V.	V.	NNP
22283	849	3	THE	THE	NNP
22283	849	4	WILL	WILL	MD
22283	849	5	IN	in	IN
22283	849	6	RELATION	relation	NN
22283	849	7	TO	to	IN
22283	849	8	MATERIALISM	MATERIALISM	NNP
22283	849	9	AND	and	CC
22283	849	10	SPIRITUALISM	SPIRITUALISM	NNP
22283	849	11	.	.	.
22283	850	1	In	in	IN
22283	850	2	the	the	DT
22283	850	3	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
22283	850	4	chapters	chapter	NNS
22283	850	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	850	6	have	have	VBP
22283	850	7	considered	consider	VBN
22283	850	8	the	the	DT
22283	850	9	theory	theory	NN
22283	850	10	of	of	IN
22283	850	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	850	12	,	,	,
22283	850	13	first	first	RB
22283	850	14	in	in	IN
22283	850	15	contrast	contrast	NN
22283	850	16	with	with	IN
22283	850	17	the	the	DT
22283	850	18	theories	theory	NNS
22283	850	19	of	of	IN
22283	850	20	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	850	21	and	and	CC
22283	850	22	of	of	IN
22283	850	23	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	850	24	,	,	,
22283	850	25	and	and	CC
22283	850	26	next	next	RB
22283	850	27	in	in	IN
22283	850	28	relation	relation	NN
22283	850	29	to	to	IN
22283	850	30	the	the	DT
22283	850	31	theory	theory	NN
22283	850	32	of	of	IN
22283	850	33	Theism	theism	NN
22283	850	34	.	.	.
22283	851	1	In	in	IN
22283	851	2	this	this	DT
22283	851	3	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	851	4	and	and	CC
22283	851	5	that	that	DT
22283	851	6	which	which	WDT
22283	851	7	succeeds	succeed	VBZ
22283	851	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	851	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	851	10	propose	propose	VBP
22283	851	11	to	to	TO
22283	851	12	consider	consider	VB
22283	851	13	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	851	14	in	in	IN
22283	851	15	relation	relation	NN
22283	851	16	to	to	IN
22283	851	17	the	the	DT
22283	851	18	Will	Will	NNP
22283	851	19	.	.	.
22283	852	1	To	to	TO
22283	852	2	do	do	VB
22283	852	3	this	this	DT
22283	852	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	852	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	852	6	needful	needful	JJ
22283	852	7	to	to	TO
22283	852	8	begin	begin	VB
22283	852	9	by	by	IN
22283	852	10	considering	consider	VBG
22283	852	11	the	the	DT
22283	852	12	problems	problem	NNS
22283	852	13	which	which	WDT
22283	852	14	are	be	VBP
22283	852	15	presented	present	VBN
22283	852	16	by	by	IN
22283	852	17	the	the	DT
22283	852	18	Will	Will	NNP
22283	852	19	in	in	IN
22283	852	20	relation	relation	NN
22283	852	21	to	to	IN
22283	852	22	the	the	DT
22283	852	23	older	old	JJR
22283	852	24	theories	theory	NNS
22283	852	25	of	of	IN
22283	852	26	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	852	27	on	on	IN
22283	852	28	the	the	DT
22283	852	29	one	one	CD
22283	852	30	hand	hand	NN
22283	852	31	and	and	CC
22283	852	32	of	of	IN
22283	852	33	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	852	34	on	on	IN
22283	852	35	the	the	DT
22283	852	36	other	other	JJ
22283	852	37	.	.	.
22283	853	1	Although	although	IN
22283	853	2	the	the	DT
22283	853	3	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	853	4	of	of	IN
22283	853	5	volition	volition	NN
22283	853	6	have	have	VBP
22283	853	7	occupied	occupy	VBN
22283	853	8	so	so	RB
22283	853	9	large	large	JJ
22283	853	10	a	a	DT
22283	853	11	province	province	NN
22283	853	12	of	of	IN
22283	853	13	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	853	14	literature	literature	NN
22283	853	15	,	,	,
22283	853	16	the	the	DT
22283	853	17	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	853	18	problems	problem	NNS
22283	853	19	which	which	WDT
22283	853	20	arise	arise	VBP
22283	853	21	in	in	IN
22283	853	22	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	853	23	with	with	IN
22283	853	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	853	25	are	be	VBP
22283	853	26	only	only	RB
22283	853	27	two	two	CD
22283	853	28	in	in	IN
22283	853	29	number	number	NN
22283	853	30	,	,	,
22283	853	31	and	and	CC
22283	853	32	both	both	DT
22283	853	33	admit	admit	VBP
22283	853	34	of	of	IN
22283	853	35	being	be	VBG
22283	853	36	stated	state	VBN
22283	853	37	in	in	IN
22283	853	38	extremely	extremely	RB
22283	853	39	simple	simple	JJ
22283	853	40	terms	term	NNS
22283	853	41	.	.	.
22283	854	1	The	the	DT
22283	854	2	historical	historical	JJ
22283	854	3	order	order	NN
22283	854	4	in	in	IN
22283	854	5	which	which	WDT
22283	854	6	these	these	DT
22283	854	7	two	two	CD
22283	854	8	problems	problem	NNS
22283	854	9	have	have	VBP
22283	854	10	arisen	arise	VBN
22283	854	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	854	12	the	the	DT
22283	854	13	inverse	inverse	NN
22283	854	14	of	of	IN
22283	854	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	854	16	logical	logical	JJ
22283	854	17	order	order	NN
22283	854	18	.	.	.
22283	855	1	For	for	IN
22283	855	2	while	while	IN
22283	855	3	in	in	IN
22283	855	4	logical	logical	JJ
22283	855	5	order	order	NN
22283	855	6	the	the	DT
22283	855	7	two	two	CD
22283	855	8	problems	problem	NNS
22283	855	9	would	would	MD
22283	855	10	stand	stand	VB
22283	855	11	thus	thus	RB
22283	855	12	--	--	:
22283	855	13	Is	be	VBZ
22283	855	14	the	the	DT
22283	855	15	Will	Will	NNP
22283	855	16	an	an	DT
22283	855	17	agent	agent	NN
22283	855	18	?	?	.
22283	856	1	If	if	IN
22283	856	2	so	so	RB
22283	856	3	,	,	,
22283	856	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	856	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	856	6	a	a	DT
22283	856	7	free	free	JJ
22283	856	8	agent?--in	agent?--in	NNP
22283	856	9	actual	actual	JJ
22283	856	10	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	856	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	856	12	was	be	VBD
22283	856	13	long	long	RB
22283	856	14	taken	take	VBN
22283	856	15	for	for	IN
22283	856	16	granted	grant	VBN
22283	856	17	that	that	IN
22283	856	18	the	the	DT
22283	856	19	Will	Will	NNP
22283	856	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	856	21	an	an	DT
22283	856	22	agent	agent	NN
22283	856	23	,	,	,
22283	856	24	and	and	CC
22283	856	25	hence	hence	RB
22283	856	26	the	the	DT
22283	856	27	only	only	JJ
22283	856	28	controversy	controversy	NN
22283	856	29	gathered	gather	VBD
22283	856	30	round	round	IN
22283	856	31	the	the	DT
22283	856	32	question	question	NN
22283	856	33	whether	whether	IN
22283	856	34	the	the	DT
22283	856	35	Will	Will	NNP
22283	856	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	856	37	a	a	DT
22283	856	38	free	free	JJ
22283	856	39	agent	agent	NN
22283	856	40	.	.	.
22283	857	1	Descartes	descarte	NNS
22283	857	2	,	,	,
22283	857	3	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	857	4	,	,	,
22283	857	5	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	857	6	to	to	TO
22283	857	7	have	have	VB
22283	857	8	entertained	entertain	VBN
22283	857	9	the	the	DT
22283	857	10	prior	prior	JJ
22283	857	11	question	question	NN
22283	857	12	with	with	IN
22283	857	13	regard	regard	NN
22283	857	14	to	to	IN
22283	857	15	animals	animal	NNS
22283	857	16	,	,	,
22283	857	17	and	and	CC
22283	857	18	there	there	EX
22283	857	19	are	be	VBP
22283	857	20	passages	passage	NNS
22283	857	21	in	in	IN
22283	857	22	the	the	DT
22283	857	23	_	_	NNP
22283	857	24	Leviathan	Leviathan	NNP
22283	857	25	_	_	NNP
22283	857	26	which	which	WDT
22283	857	27	may	may	MD
22283	857	28	be	be	VB
22283	857	29	taken	take	VBN
22283	857	30	to	to	TO
22283	857	31	imply	imply	VB
22283	857	32	that	that	IN
22283	857	33	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNPS
22283	857	34	entertained	entertain	VBD
22283	857	35	this	this	DT
22283	857	36	question	question	NN
22283	857	37	with	with	IN
22283	857	38	regard	regard	NN
22283	857	39	to	to	IN
22283	857	40	man	man	NN
22283	857	41	.	.	.
22283	858	1	But	but	CC
22283	858	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	858	3	was	be	VBD
22283	858	4	not	not	RB
22283	858	5	until	until	IN
22283	858	6	recent	recent	JJ
22283	858	7	years	year	NNS
22283	858	8	that	that	IN
22283	858	9	any	any	DT
22283	858	10	such	such	JJ
22283	858	11	question	question	NN
22283	858	12	could	could	MD
22283	858	13	stand	stand	VB
22283	858	14	upon	upon	IN
22283	858	15	a	a	DT
22283	858	16	basis	basis	NN
22283	858	17	of	of	IN
22283	858	18	science	science	NN
22283	858	19	as	as	IN
22283	858	20	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	858	21	from	from	IN
22283	858	22	speculation	speculation	NN
22283	858	23	;	;	:
22283	858	24	the	the	DT
22283	858	25	question	question	NN
22283	858	26	did	do	VBD
22283	858	27	not	not	RB
22283	858	28	admit	admit	VB
22283	858	29	of	of	IN
22283	858	30	being	be	VBG
22283	858	31	so	so	RB
22283	858	32	much	much	RB
22283	858	33	as	as	IN
22283	858	34	stated	state	VBN
22283	858	35	in	in	IN
22283	858	36	terms	term	NNS
22283	858	37	of	of	IN
22283	858	38	science	science	NN
22283	858	39	until	until	IN
22283	858	40	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	858	41	was	be	VBD
22283	858	42	in	in	IN
22283	858	43	a	a	DT
22283	858	44	position	position	NN
22283	858	45	openly	openly	RB
22283	858	46	to	to	TO
22283	858	47	challenge	challenge	VB
22283	858	48	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	858	49	right	right	NN
22283	858	50	to	to	TO
22283	858	51	assume	assume	VB
22283	858	52	that	that	IN
22283	858	53	the	the	DT
22283	858	54	Will	Will	NNP
22283	858	55	is	be	VBZ
22283	858	56	an	an	DT
22283	858	57	agent	agent	NN
22283	858	58	.	.	.
22283	859	1	Such	such	PDT
22283	859	2	a	a	DT
22283	859	3	challenge	challenge	NN
22283	859	4	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	859	5	has	have	VBZ
22283	859	6	now	now	RB
22283	859	7	given	give	VBN
22283	859	8	,	,	,
22283	859	9	and	and	CC
22283	859	10	even	even	RB
22283	859	11	declared	declare	VBD
22283	859	12	that	that	IN
22283	859	13	any	any	DT
22283	859	14	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	859	15	of	of	IN
22283	859	16	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	859	17	agency	agency	NN
22283	859	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	859	19	,	,	,
22283	859	20	in	in	IN
22283	859	21	the	the	DT
22283	859	22	presence	presence	NN
22283	859	23	of	of	IN
22283	859	24	adequate	adequate	JJ
22283	859	25	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	859	26	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	859	27	,	,	,
22283	859	28	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	859	29	.	.	.
22283	860	1	The	the	DT
22283	860	2	two	two	CD
22283	860	3	problems	problem	NNS
22283	860	4	which	which	WDT
22283	860	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	860	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	860	7	state	state	VBP
22283	860	8	separately	separately	RB
22283	860	9	are	be	VBP
22283	860	10	often	often	RB
22283	860	11	,	,	,
22283	860	12	and	and	CC
22283	860	13	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	860	14	generally	generally	RB
22283	860	15	,	,	,
22283	860	16	confused	confuse	VBD
22283	860	17	together	together	RB
22283	860	18	;	;	:
22283	860	19	but	but	CC
22283	860	20	for	for	IN
22283	860	21	the	the	DT
22283	860	22	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	860	23	of	of	IN
22283	860	24	clear	clear	JJ
22283	860	25	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	860	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	860	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	860	28	of	of	IN
22283	860	29	the	the	DT
22283	860	30	first	first	JJ
22283	860	31	importance	importance	NN
22283	860	32	that	that	IN
22283	860	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	860	34	should	should	MD
22283	860	35	be	be	VB
22283	860	36	kept	keep	VBN
22283	860	37	apart	apart	RB
22283	860	38	.	.	.
22283	861	1	In	in	IN
22283	861	2	order	order	NN
22283	861	3	to	to	TO
22283	861	4	show	show	VB
22283	861	5	the	the	DT
22283	861	6	wide	wide	JJ
22283	861	7	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	861	8	between	between	IN
22283	861	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	861	10	,	,	,
22283	861	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	861	12	may	may	MD
22283	861	13	best	well	RBS
22283	861	14	begin	begin	VB
22283	861	15	with	with	IN
22283	861	16	a	a	DT
22283	861	17	brief	brief	JJ
22283	861	18	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	861	19	of	of	IN
22283	861	20	what	what	WP
22283	861	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	861	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	861	23	that	that	IN
22283	861	24	the	the	DT
22283	861	25	two	two	CD
22283	861	26	problems	problem	NNS
22283	861	27	severally	severally	RB
22283	861	28	involve	involve	VBP
22283	861	29	;	;	:
22283	861	30	and	and	CC
22283	861	31	to	to	TO
22283	861	32	do	do	VB
22283	861	33	this	this	DT
22283	861	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	861	35	may	may	MD
22283	861	36	best	best	RB
22283	861	37	take	take	VB
22283	861	38	the	the	DT
22283	861	39	problems	problem	NNS
22283	861	40	in	in	IN
22283	861	41	what	what	WP
22283	861	42	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	861	43	have	have	VBP
22283	861	44	called	call	VBN
22283	861	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	861	46	logical	logical	JJ
22283	861	47	order	order	NN
22283	861	48	.	.	.
22283	862	1	First	first	RB
22283	862	2	,	,	,
22283	862	3	then	then	RB
22283	862	4	,	,	,
22283	862	5	as	as	IN
22283	862	6	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	862	7	the	the	DT
22283	862	8	question	question	NN
22283	862	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	862	10	the	the	DT
22283	862	11	Will	Will	NNP
22283	862	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	862	13	an	an	DT
22283	862	14	agent	agent	NN
22283	862	15	,	,	,
22283	862	16	the	the	DT
22283	862	17	rival	rival	JJ
22283	862	18	theories	theory	NNS
22283	862	19	of	of	IN
22283	862	20	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	862	21	and	and	CC
22283	862	22	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	862	23	stand	stand	VB
22283	862	24	to	to	IN
22283	862	25	one	one	CD
22283	862	26	another	another	DT
22283	862	27	in	in	IN
22283	862	28	a	a	DT
22283	862	29	relation	relation	NN
22283	862	30	of	of	IN
22283	862	31	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	862	32	.	.	.
22283	863	1	For	for	IN
22283	863	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	863	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	863	4	of	of	IN
22283	863	5	the	the	DT
22283	863	6	essence	essence	NN
22283	863	7	of	of	IN
22283	863	8	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	863	9	to	to	TO
22283	863	10	regard	regard	VB
22283	863	11	the	the	DT
22283	863	12	Will	Will	NNP
22283	863	13	as	as	IN
22283	863	14	an	an	DT
22283	863	15	agent	agent	NN
22283	863	16	,	,	,
22283	863	17	or	or	CC
22283	863	18	as	as	IN
22283	863	19	an	an	DT
22283	863	20	original	original	JJ
22283	863	21	cause	cause	NN
22283	863	22	of	of	IN
22283	863	23	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	863	24	movement	movement	NN
22283	863	25	,	,	,
22283	863	26	and	and	CC
22283	863	27	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	863	28	as	as	IN
22283	863	29	a	a	DT
22283	863	30	true	true	JJ
22283	863	31	cause	cause	NN
22283	863	32	in	in	IN
22283	863	33	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	863	34	.	.	.
22283	864	1	On	on	IN
22283	864	2	the	the	DT
22283	864	3	other	other	JJ
22283	864	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	864	5	,	,	,
22283	864	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	864	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	864	8	of	of	IN
22283	864	9	the	the	DT
22283	864	10	essence	essence	NN
22283	864	11	of	of	IN
22283	864	12	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	864	13	to	to	TO
22283	864	14	deny	deny	VB
22283	864	15	that	that	IN
22283	864	16	the	the	DT
22283	864	17	Will	Will	NNP
22283	864	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	864	19	an	an	DT
22283	864	20	agent	agent	NN
22283	864	21	.	.	.
22283	865	1	Hitherto	Hitherto	NNP
22283	865	2	,	,	,
22283	865	3	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	865	4	,	,	,
22283	865	5	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	865	6	as	as	IN
22283	865	7	a	a	DT
22283	865	8	body	body	NN
22283	865	9	have	have	VBP
22283	865	10	not	not	RB
22283	865	11	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	865	12	recognized	recognize	VBN
22283	865	13	this	this	DT
22283	865	14	implication	implication	NN
22283	865	15	as	as	IN
22283	865	16	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	865	17	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	865	18	to	to	IN
22283	865	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	865	20	theory	theory	NN
22283	865	21	;	;	:
22283	865	22	but	but	CC
22283	865	23	that	that	IN
22283	865	24	this	this	DT
22283	865	25	implication	implication	NN
22283	865	26	does	do	VBZ
22283	865	27	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	865	28	belong	belong	VB
22283	865	29	to	to	IN
22283	865	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	865	31	theory	theory	NN
22283	865	32	--	--	:
22283	865	33	or	or	CC
22283	865	34	rather	rather	RB
22283	865	35	,	,	,
22283	865	36	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	865	37	should	should	MD
22283	865	38	say	say	VB
22283	865	39	,	,	,
22283	865	40	really	really	RB
22283	865	41	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
22283	865	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	865	43	most	most	RBS
22283	865	44	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
22283	865	45	feature	feature	NN
22283	865	46	--	--	:
22283	865	47	admits	admit	NNS
22283	865	48	of	of	IN
22283	865	49	being	be	VBG
22283	865	50	easily	easily	RB
22283	865	51	shown	show	VBN
22283	865	52	.	.	.
22283	866	1	For	for	IN
22283	866	2	the	the	DT
22283	866	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	866	4	that	that	IN
22283	866	5	material	material	NN
22283	866	6	changes	change	NNS
22283	866	7	are	be	VBP
22283	866	8	the	the	DT
22283	866	9	causes	cause	NNS
22283	866	10	of	of	IN
22283	866	11	mental	mental	JJ
22283	866	12	changes	change	NNS
22283	866	13	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	866	14	terminates	terminate	NNS
22283	866	15	in	in	IN
22283	866	16	the	the	DT
22283	866	17	so	so	RB
22283	866	18	-	-	HYPH
22283	866	19	called	call	VBN
22283	866	20	theory	theory	NN
22283	866	21	of	of	IN
22283	866	22	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	866	23	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	866	24	--	--	:
22283	866	25	or	or	CC
22283	866	26	the	the	DT
22283	866	27	theory	theory	NN
22283	866	28	that	that	WDT
22283	866	29	so	so	RB
22283	866	30	far	far	RB
22283	866	31	as	as	IN
22283	866	32	the	the	DT
22283	866	33	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	866	34	to	to	TO
22283	866	35	bodily	bodily	RB
22283	866	36	action	action	NN
22283	866	37	are	be	VBP
22283	866	38	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	866	39	,	,	,
22283	866	40	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	866	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	866	42	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	866	43	,	,	,
22283	866	44	bearing	bear	VBG
22283	866	45	the	the	DT
22283	866	46	same	same	JJ
22283	866	47	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
22283	866	48	relation	relation	NN
22283	866	49	to	to	IN
22283	866	50	the	the	DT
22283	866	51	activity	activity	NN
22283	866	52	of	of	IN
22283	866	53	the	the	DT
22283	866	54	brain	brain	NN
22283	866	55	as	as	IN
22283	866	56	the	the	DT
22283	866	57	striking	striking	NN
22283	866	58	of	of	IN
22283	866	59	a	a	DT
22283	866	60	clock	clock	NN
22283	866	61	bears	bear	NNS
22283	866	62	to	to	IN
22283	866	63	the	the	DT
22283	866	64	time	time	NN
22283	866	65	-	-	HYPH
22283	866	66	keeping	keep	VBG
22283	866	67	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	866	68	of	of	IN
22283	866	69	the	the	DT
22283	866	70	clock	clock	NN
22283	866	71	-	-	HYPH
22283	866	72	work	work	NN
22283	866	73	.	.	.
22283	867	1	From	from	IN
22283	867	2	this	this	DT
22283	867	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	867	4	there	there	EX
22283	867	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	867	6	no	no	DT
22283	867	7	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	867	8	of	of	IN
22283	867	9	escape	escape	NN
22283	867	10	,	,	,
22283	867	11	if	if	IN
22283	867	12	once	once	IN
22283	867	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	867	14	accept	accept	VBP
22283	867	15	the	the	DT
22283	867	16	premises	premise	NNS
22283	867	17	of	of	IN
22283	867	18	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	867	19	;	;	,
22283	867	20	and	and	CC
22283	867	21	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	867	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	867	23	say	say	VBP
22283	867	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	867	25	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	867	26	to	to	IN
22283	867	27	the	the	DT
22283	867	28	essence	essence	NN
22283	867	29	of	of	IN
22283	867	30	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	867	31	to	to	TO
22283	867	32	deny	deny	VB
22283	867	33	the	the	DT
22283	867	34	agency	agency	NN
22283	867	35	of	of	IN
22283	867	36	Will	Will	NNP
22283	867	37	.	.	.
22283	868	1	Just	just	RB
22283	868	2	as	as	IN
22283	868	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	868	4	does	do	VBZ
22283	868	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	868	6	belong	belong	VB
22283	868	7	to	to	IN
22283	868	8	the	the	DT
22283	868	9	essence	essence	NN
22283	868	10	of	of	IN
22283	868	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	868	12	to	to	TO
22283	868	13	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	868	14	the	the	DT
22283	868	15	agency	agency	NN
22283	868	16	of	of	IN
22283	868	17	Will	Will	NNP
22283	868	18	.	.	.
22283	869	1	For	for	IN
22283	869	2	,	,	,
22283	869	3	according	accord	VBG
22283	869	4	to	to	IN
22283	869	5	this	this	DT
22283	869	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	869	7	,	,	,
22283	869	8	while	while	IN
22283	869	9	motion	motion	NN
22283	869	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	869	11	producing	produce	VBG
22283	869	12	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	869	13	but	but	IN
22283	869	14	motion	motion	NN
22283	869	15	,	,	,
22283	869	16	mind	mind	NN
22283	869	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	869	18	change	change	VB
22283	869	19	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	869	20	but	but	IN
22283	869	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	869	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	869	23	change	change	NN
22283	869	24	,	,	,
22283	869	25	both	both	DT
22283	869	26	are	be	VBP
22283	869	27	producing	produce	VBG
22283	869	28	both	both	DT
22283	869	29	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
22283	869	30	;	;	:
22283	869	31	neither	neither	DT
22283	869	32	could	could	MD
22283	869	33	be	be	VB
22283	869	34	what	what	WP
22283	869	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	869	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	869	37	without	without	IN
22283	869	38	the	the	DT
22283	869	39	other	other	JJ
22283	869	40	,	,	,
22283	869	41	for	for	IN
22283	869	42	each	each	DT
22283	869	43	is	be	VBZ
22283	869	44	to	to	IN
22283	869	45	the	the	DT
22283	869	46	other	other	JJ
22283	869	47	a	a	DT
22283	869	48	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	869	49	counterpart	counterpart	NN
22283	869	50	or	or	CC
22283	869	51	supplement	supplement	NN
22283	869	52	,	,	,
22283	869	53	in	in	IN
22283	869	54	the	the	DT
22283	869	55	absence	absence	NN
22283	869	56	of	of	IN
22283	869	57	which	which	WDT
22283	869	58	the	the	DT
22283	869	59	whole	whole	JJ
22283	869	60	causation	causation	NN
22283	869	61	(	(	-LRB-
22283	869	62	whether	whether	IN
22283	869	63	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	869	64	from	from	IN
22283	869	65	the	the	DT
22283	869	66	physical	physical	JJ
22283	869	67	or	or	CC
22283	869	68	mental	mental	JJ
22283	869	69	side	side	NN
22283	869	70	)	)	-RRB-
22283	869	71	would	would	MD
22283	869	72	not	not	RB
22283	869	73	be	be	VB
22283	869	74	complete	complete	JJ
22283	869	75	.	.	.
22283	870	1	Now	now	RB
22283	870	2	,	,	,
22283	870	3	in	in	IN
22283	870	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	870	5	opinion	opinion	NN
22283	870	6	the	the	DT
22283	870	7	importance	importance	NN
22283	870	8	of	of	IN
22283	870	9	the	the	DT
22283	870	10	view	view	NN
22283	870	11	thus	thus	RB
22283	870	12	presented	present	VBN
22283	870	13	by	by	IN
22283	870	14	the	the	DT
22283	870	15	theory	theory	NN
22283	870	16	of	of	IN
22283	870	17	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	870	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	870	19	,	,	,
22283	870	20	for	for	IN
22283	870	21	all	all	DT
22283	870	22	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	870	23	of	of	IN
22283	870	24	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	870	25	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	870	26	,	,	,
22283	870	27	inestimable	inestimable	JJ
22283	870	28	.	.	.
22283	871	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	871	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	871	3	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	871	4	nowadays	nowadays	RB
22283	871	5	that	that	IN
22283	871	6	such	such	JJ
22283	871	7	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	871	8	can	can	MD
22283	871	9	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	871	10	very	very	RB
22283	871	11	far	far	RB
22283	871	12	in	in	IN
22283	871	13	any	any	DT
22283	871	14	direction	direction	NN
22283	871	15	without	without	IN
22283	871	16	confronting	confront	VBG
22283	871	17	the	the	DT
22283	871	18	facts	fact	NNS
22283	871	19	presented	present	VBN
22283	871	20	by	by	IN
22283	871	21	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	871	22	:	:	:
22283	871	23	hence	hence	RB
22283	871	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	871	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	871	26	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	871	27	for	for	IN
22283	871	28	such	such	JJ
22283	871	29	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	871	30	to	to	TO
22283	871	31	confine	confine	VB
22283	871	32	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	871	33	exclusively	exclusively	RB
22283	871	34	to	to	IN
22283	871	35	the	the	DT
22283	871	36	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
22283	871	37	or	or	CC
22283	871	38	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	871	39	side	side	NN
22283	871	40	of	of	IN
22283	871	41	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	871	42	.	.	.
22283	872	1	On	on	IN
22283	872	2	the	the	DT
22283	872	3	other	other	JJ
22283	872	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	872	5	,	,	,
22283	872	6	in	in	IN
22283	872	7	so	so	RB
22283	872	8	far	far	RB
22283	872	9	as	as	IN
22283	872	10	such	such	JJ
22283	872	11	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	872	12	has	have	VBZ
22283	872	13	regard	regard	NN
22283	872	14	to	to	IN
22283	872	15	the	the	DT
22283	872	16	material	material	NN
22283	872	17	or	or	CC
22283	872	18	objective	objective	JJ
22283	872	19	side	side	NN
22283	872	20	,	,	,
22283	872	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	872	22	has	have	VBZ
22283	872	23	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
22283	872	24	appeared	appear	VBN
22283	872	25	to	to	TO
22283	872	26	countenance	countenance	VB
22283	872	27	--	--	:
22283	872	28	in	in	IN
22283	872	29	however	however	RB
22283	872	30	disguised	disguise	VBN
22283	872	31	a	a	DT
22283	872	32	form	form	NN
22283	872	33	--	--	:
22283	872	34	the	the	DT
22283	872	35	dogmatic	dogmatic	JJ
22283	872	36	denial	denial	NN
22283	872	37	of	of	IN
22283	872	38	the	the	DT
22283	872	39	Will	Will	NNP
22283	872	40	as	as	IN
22283	872	41	an	an	DT
22283	872	42	agent	agent	NN
22283	872	43	.	.	.
22283	873	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	873	2	the	the	DT
22283	873	3	supreme	supreme	JJ
22283	873	4	importance	importance	NN
22283	873	5	to	to	IN
22283	873	6	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	873	7	of	of	IN
22283	873	8	reconciling	reconcile	VBG
22283	873	9	the	the	DT
22283	873	10	hitherto	hitherto	JJ
22283	873	11	rival	rival	JJ
22283	873	12	theories	theory	NNS
22283	873	13	of	of	IN
22283	873	14	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	873	15	and	and	CC
22283	873	16	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	873	17	in	in	IN
22283	873	18	the	the	DT
22283	873	19	higher	high	JJR
22283	873	20	synthesis	synthesis	NN
22283	873	21	which	which	WDT
22283	873	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	873	23	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	873	24	by	by	IN
22283	873	25	the	the	DT
22283	873	26	theory	theory	NN
22283	873	27	of	of	IN
22283	873	28	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	873	29	.	.	.
22283	874	1	For	for	IN
22283	874	2	,	,	,
22283	874	3	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	874	4	,	,	,
22283	874	5	in	in	IN
22283	874	6	the	the	DT
22283	874	7	absence	absence	NN
22283	874	8	of	of	IN
22283	874	9	any	any	DT
22283	874	10	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	874	11	justification	justification	NN
22283	874	12	of	of	IN
22283	874	13	the	the	DT
22283	874	14	Will	Will	NNP
22283	874	15	as	as	IN
22283	874	16	an	an	DT
22283	874	17	agent	agent	NN
22283	874	18	,	,	,
22283	874	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	874	20	are	be	VBP
22283	874	21	without	without	IN
22283	874	22	any	any	DT
22283	874	23	guarantee	guarantee	NN
22283	874	24	that	that	IN
22283	874	25	all	all	DT
22283	874	26	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	874	27	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	874	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	874	29	not	not	RB
22283	874	30	a	a	DT
22283	874	31	vain	vain	JJ
22283	874	32	beating	beating	NN
22283	874	33	of	of	IN
22283	874	34	the	the	DT
22283	874	35	air	air	NN
22283	874	36	.	.	.
22283	875	1	If	if	IN
22283	875	2	,	,	,
22283	875	3	as	as	IN
22283	875	4	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	875	5	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	875	6	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	875	7	,	,	,
22283	875	8	the	the	DT
22283	875	9	Will	Will	NNP
22283	875	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	875	11	not	not	RB
22283	875	12	a	a	DT
22283	875	13	cause	cause	NN
22283	875	14	in	in	IN
22283	875	15	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	875	16	,	,	,
22283	875	17	there	there	EX
22283	875	18	would	would	MD
22283	875	19	be	be	VB
22283	875	20	no	no	DT
22283	875	21	reason	reason	NN
22283	875	22	in	in	IN
22283	875	23	Nature	nature	NN
22283	875	24	for	for	IN
22283	875	25	the	the	DT
22283	875	26	agency	agency	NN
22283	875	27	either	either	CC
22283	875	28	of	of	IN
22283	875	29	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	875	30	or	or	CC
22283	875	31	of	of	IN
22283	875	32	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	875	33	.	.	.
22283	876	1	Feeling	feeling	NN
22283	876	2	and	and	CC
22283	876	3	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	876	4	would	would	MD
22283	876	5	,	,	,
22283	876	6	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	876	7	,	,	,
22283	876	8	stand	stand	VB
22283	876	9	as	as	IN
22283	876	10	ciphers	cipher	NNS
22283	876	11	in	in	IN
22283	876	12	the	the	DT
22283	876	13	general	general	JJ
22283	876	14	constitution	constitution	NN
22283	876	15	of	of	IN
22283	876	16	things	thing	NNS
22283	876	17	;	;	:
22283	876	18	and	and	CC
22283	876	19	any	any	DT
22283	876	20	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	876	21	touching	touch	VBG
22283	876	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	876	23	internal	internal	JJ
22283	876	24	system	system	NN
22283	876	25	of	of	IN
22283	876	26	causation	causation	NN
22283	876	27	could	could	MD
22283	876	28	have	have	VB
22283	876	29	no	no	DT
22283	876	30	reference	reference	NN
22283	876	31	to	to	IN
22283	876	32	any	any	DT
22283	876	33	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	876	34	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	876	35	touching	touch	VBG
22283	876	36	causation	causation	NN
22283	876	37	in	in	IN
22283	876	38	general	general	JJ
22283	876	39	.	.	.
22283	877	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	877	2	am	be	VBP
22283	877	3	aware	aware	JJ
22283	877	4	that	that	IN
22283	877	5	this	this	DT
22283	877	6	truth	truth	NN
22283	877	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	877	8	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	877	9	overlooked	overlook	VBN
22283	877	10	by	by	IN
22283	877	11	psychologists	psychologist	NNS
22283	877	12	;	;	:
22283	877	13	but	but	CC
22283	877	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	877	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	877	16	none	none	NN
22283	877	17	the	the	DT
22283	877	18	less	less	RBR
22283	877	19	a	a	DT
22283	877	20	truth	truth	NN
22283	877	21	of	of	IN
22283	877	22	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	877	23	importance	importance	NN
22283	877	24	to	to	IN
22283	877	25	the	the	DT
22283	877	26	whole	whole	JJ
22283	877	27	superstructure	superstructure	NN
22283	877	28	of	of	IN
22283	877	29	this	this	DT
22283	877	30	science	science	NN
22283	877	31	.	.	.
22283	878	1	Or	or	CC
22283	878	2	,	,	,
22283	878	3	in	in	IN
22283	878	4	other	other	JJ
22283	878	5	words	word	NNS
22283	878	6	,	,	,
22283	878	7	unless	unless	IN
22283	878	8	psychologists	psychologist	NNS
22283	878	9	will	will	MD
22283	878	10	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	878	11	consent	consent	VB
22283	878	12	to	to	TO
22283	878	13	rear	rear	VB
22283	878	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	878	15	science	science	NN
22283	878	16	on	on	IN
22283	878	17	the	the	DT
22283	878	18	basis	basis	NN
22283	878	19	provided	provide	VBN
22283	878	20	by	by	IN
22283	878	21	the	the	DT
22283	878	22	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	878	23	theory	theory	NN
22283	878	24	of	of	IN
22283	878	25	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	878	26	,	,	,
22283	878	27	there	there	EX
22283	878	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	878	29	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	878	30	to	to	TO
22283	878	31	save	save	VB
22283	878	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	878	33	from	from	IN
22283	878	34	logical	logical	JJ
22283	878	35	disintegration	disintegration	NN
22283	878	36	;	;	,
22283	878	37	apart	apart	RB
22283	878	38	from	from	IN
22283	878	39	this	this	DT
22283	878	40	basis	basis	NN
22283	878	41	,	,	,
22283	878	42	the	the	DT
22283	878	43	whole	whole	JJ
22283	878	44	science	science	NN
22283	878	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	878	46	,	,	,
22283	878	47	so	so	RB
22283	878	48	to	to	TO
22283	878	49	speak	speak	VB
22283	878	50	,	,	,
22283	878	51	built	build	VBN
22283	878	52	in	in	IN
22283	878	53	the	the	DT
22283	878	54	air	air	NN
22283	878	55	,	,	,
22283	878	56	like	like	IN
22283	878	57	an	an	DT
22283	878	58	unsubstantial	unsubstantial	JJ
22283	878	59	structure	structure	NN
22283	878	60	of	of	IN
22283	878	61	clouds	cloud	NNS
22283	878	62	.	.	.
22283	879	1	Psychologists	psychologist	NNS
22283	879	2	,	,	,
22283	879	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	879	4	repeat	repeat	VBP
22283	879	5	,	,	,
22283	879	6	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	879	7	ignore	ignore	VBP
22283	879	8	this	this	DT
22283	879	9	fact	fact	NN
22283	879	10	,	,	,
22283	879	11	and	and	CC
22283	879	12	constantly	constantly	RB
22283	879	13	speak	speak	VB
22283	879	14	of	of	IN
22283	879	15	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	879	16	and	and	CC
22283	879	17	intelligence	intelligence	NN
22283	879	18	as	as	IN
22283	879	19	true	true	JJ
22283	879	20	causes	cause	NNS
22283	879	21	of	of	IN
22283	879	22	adjustive	adjustive	JJ
22283	879	23	action	action	NN
22283	879	24	;	;	:
22283	879	25	but	but	CC
22283	879	26	by	by	IN
22283	879	27	so	so	RB
22283	879	28	doing	do	VBG
22283	879	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	879	30	merely	merely	RB
22283	879	31	beg	beg	VBP
22283	879	32	from	from	IN
22283	879	33	this	this	DT
22283	879	34	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
22283	879	35	theory	theory	NN
22283	879	36	of	of	IN
22283	879	37	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	879	38	a	a	DT
22283	879	39	flat	flat	JJ
22283	879	40	denial	denial	NN
22283	879	41	of	of	IN
22283	879	42	the	the	DT
22283	879	43	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	879	44	postulate	postulate	NN
22283	879	45	on	on	IN
22283	879	46	which	which	WDT
22283	879	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	879	48	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	879	49	proceed	proceed	VBP
22283	879	50	--	--	:
22283	879	51	the	the	DT
22283	879	52	postulate	postulate	NN
22283	879	53	,	,	,
22283	879	54	namely	namely	RB
22283	879	55	,	,	,
22283	879	56	that	that	IN
22283	879	57	mental	mental	JJ
22283	879	58	changes	change	NNS
22283	879	59	are	be	VBP
22283	879	60	determined	determine	VBN
22283	879	61	by	by	IN
22283	879	62	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	879	63	changes	change	NNS
22283	879	64	.	.	.
22283	880	1	Consider	consider	VB
22283	880	2	,	,	,
22283	880	3	for	for	IN
22283	880	4	example	example	NN
22283	880	5	,	,	,
22283	880	6	the	the	DT
22283	880	7	following	follow	VBG
22283	880	8	passage	passage	NN
22283	880	9	from	from	IN
22283	880	10	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	880	11	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	880	12	's	's	POS
22283	880	13	_	_	NNP
22283	880	14	Principles	Principles	NNPS
22283	880	15	of	of	IN
22283	880	16	Psychology	Psychology	NNP
22283	880	17	_	_	NNP
22283	880	18	(	(	-LRB-
22283	880	19	§	§	CD
22283	880	20	125	125	CD
22283	880	21	)	)	-RRB-
22283	880	22	,	,	,
22283	880	23	which	which	WDT
22283	880	24	serves	serve	VBZ
22283	880	25	to	to	TO
22283	880	26	show	show	VB
22283	880	27	in	in	IN
22283	880	28	brief	brief	JJ
22283	880	29	compass	compass	NN
22283	880	30	the	the	DT
22283	880	31	logical	logical	JJ
22283	880	32	incoherency	incoherency	NN
22283	880	33	which	which	WDT
22283	880	34	in	in	IN
22283	880	35	this	this	DT
22283	880	36	matter	matter	NN
22283	880	37	runs	run	VBZ
22283	880	38	through	through	IN
22283	880	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	880	40	whole	whole	JJ
22283	880	41	work:--	work:--	FW
22283	880	42	'	'	``
22283	880	43	Those	those	DT
22283	880	44	races	race	NNS
22283	880	45	of	of	IN
22283	880	46	beings	being	NNS
22283	880	47	only	only	RB
22283	880	48	can	can	MD
22283	880	49	have	have	VB
22283	880	50	survived	survive	VBN
22283	880	51	in	in	IN
22283	880	52	which	which	WDT
22283	880	53	,	,	,
22283	880	54	on	on	IN
22283	880	55	the	the	DT
22283	880	56	average	average	JJ
22283	880	57	,	,	,
22283	880	58	agreeable	agreeable	JJ
22283	880	59	or	or	CC
22283	880	60	desired	desire	VBN
22283	880	61	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	880	62	went	go	VBD
22283	880	63	along	along	RB
22283	880	64	with	with	IN
22283	880	65	activities	activity	NNS
22283	880	66	conducive	conducive	JJ
22283	880	67	to	to	IN
22283	880	68	the	the	DT
22283	880	69	maintenance	maintenance	NN
22283	880	70	of	of	IN
22283	880	71	life	life	NN
22283	880	72	,	,	,
22283	880	73	while	while	IN
22283	880	74	disagreeable	disagreeable	JJ
22283	880	75	and	and	CC
22283	880	76	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	880	77	-	-	HYPH
22283	880	78	avoided	avoid	VBN
22283	880	79	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	880	80	went	go	VBD
22283	880	81	along	along	RB
22283	880	82	with	with	IN
22283	880	83	activities	activity	NNS
22283	880	84	directly	directly	RB
22283	880	85	or	or	CC
22283	880	86	indirectly	indirectly	RB
22283	880	87	destructive	destructive	JJ
22283	880	88	of	of	IN
22283	880	89	life	life	NN
22283	880	90	;	;	:
22283	880	91	and	and	CC
22283	880	92	there	there	EX
22283	880	93	must	must	MD
22283	880	94	ever	ever	RB
22283	880	95	have	have	VB
22283	880	96	been	be	VBN
22283	880	97	,	,	,
22283	880	98	other	other	JJ
22283	880	99	things	thing	NNS
22283	880	100	equal	equal	JJ
22283	880	101	,	,	,
22283	880	102	the	the	DT
22283	880	103	most	most	RBS
22283	880	104	numerous	numerous	JJ
22283	880	105	and	and	CC
22283	880	106	long	long	JJ
22283	880	107	-	-	HYPH
22283	880	108	continued	continue	VBN
22283	880	109	survivals	survival	NNS
22283	880	110	among	among	IN
22283	880	111	races	race	NNS
22283	880	112	in	in	IN
22283	880	113	which	which	WDT
22283	880	114	these	these	DT
22283	880	115	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	880	116	of	of	IN
22283	880	117	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	880	118	to	to	IN
22283	880	119	actions	action	NNS
22283	880	120	were	be	VBD
22283	880	121	the	the	DT
22283	880	122	best	good	JJS
22283	880	123	,	,	,
22283	880	124	tending	tend	VBG
22283	880	125	ever	ever	RB
22283	880	126	to	to	TO
22283	880	127	bring	bring	VB
22283	880	128	about	about	RP
22283	880	129	perfect	perfect	JJ
22283	880	130	adjustment	adjustment	NN
22283	880	131	.	.	.
22283	880	132	'	'	''
22283	881	1	The	the	DT
22283	881	2	argument	argument	NN
22283	881	3	here	here	RB
22283	881	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	881	5	that	that	IN
22283	881	6	the	the	DT
22283	881	7	'	'	``
22283	881	8	adjustments	adjustment	NNS
22283	881	9	of	of	IN
22283	881	10	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	881	11	to	to	IN
22283	881	12	actions	action	NNS
22283	881	13	,	,	,
22283	881	14	'	'	''
22283	881	15	when	when	WRB
22283	881	16	once	once	RB
22283	881	17	attained	attain	VBD
22283	881	18	,	,	,
22283	881	19	leads	lead	VBZ
22283	881	20	in	in	IN
22283	881	21	turn	turn	NN
22283	881	22	to	to	IN
22283	881	23	an	an	DT
22283	881	24	adjustment	adjustment	NN
22283	881	25	of	of	IN
22283	881	26	actions	action	NNS
22283	881	27	to	to	IN
22283	881	28	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	881	29	--	--	:
22283	881	30	or	or	CC
22283	881	31	,	,	,
22283	881	32	as	as	IN
22283	881	33	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	881	34	have	have	VBP
22283	881	35	myself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	881	36	stated	state	VBN
22283	881	37	the	the	DT
22283	881	38	argument	argument	NN
22283	881	39	in	in	IN
22283	881	40	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	881	41	_	_	NNP
22283	881	42	Mental	Mental	NNP
22283	881	43	Evolution	Evolution	NNP
22283	881	44	in	in	IN
22283	881	45	Animals	Animals	NNPS
22283	881	46	_	_	NNP
22283	881	47	,	,	,
22283	881	48	'	'	''
22283	881	49	the	the	DT
22283	881	50	_	_	NNP
22283	881	51	raison	raison	NNP
22283	881	52	d'étre	d'étre	NNP
22283	881	53	_	_	NNP
22283	881	54	of	of	IN
22283	881	55	Pleasure	Pleasure	NNP
22283	881	56	and	and	CC
22283	881	57	Pain	Pain	NNP
22283	881	58	has	have	VBZ
22283	881	59	been	be	VBN
22283	881	60	that	that	DT
22283	881	61	of	of	IN
22283	881	62	furnishing	furnish	VBG
22283	881	63	organisms	organism	NNS
22283	881	64	with	with	IN
22283	881	65	guides	guide	NNS
22283	881	66	to	to	TO
22283	881	67	adjustive	adjustive	JJ
22283	881	68	action	action	NN
22283	881	69	:	:	:
22283	881	70	moreover	moreover	RB
22283	881	71	,	,	,
22283	881	72	as	as	IN
22283	881	73	in	in	IN
22283	881	74	the	the	DT
22283	881	75	case	case	NN
22283	881	76	of	of	IN
22283	881	77	direct	direct	JJ
22283	881	78	sensation	sensation	NN
22283	881	79	dictating	dictate	VBG
22283	881	80	any	any	DT
22283	881	81	simple	simple	JJ
22283	881	82	adjustment	adjustment	NN
22283	881	83	for	for	IN
22283	881	84	the	the	DT
22283	881	85	sake	sake	NN
22283	881	86	of	of	IN
22283	881	87	securing	secure	VBG
22283	881	88	an	an	DT
22283	881	89	immediate	immediate	JJ
22283	881	90	good	good	NN
22283	881	91	,	,	,
22283	881	92	so	so	RB
22283	881	93	in	in	IN
22283	881	94	the	the	DT
22283	881	95	case	case	NN
22283	881	96	of	of	IN
22283	881	97	instinct	instinct	NN
22283	881	98	dictating	dictate	VBG
22283	881	99	a	a	DT
22283	881	100	more	more	RBR
22283	881	101	intricate	intricate	JJ
22283	881	102	action	action	NN
22283	881	103	for	for	IN
22283	881	104	the	the	DT
22283	881	105	sake	sake	NN
22283	881	106	of	of	IN
22283	881	107	eventually	eventually	RB
22283	881	108	securing	secure	VBG
22283	881	109	a	a	DT
22283	881	110	more	more	RBR
22283	881	111	remote	remote	JJ
22283	881	112	good	good	NN
22283	881	113	(	(	-LRB-
22283	881	114	whether	whether	IN
22283	881	115	for	for	IN
22283	881	116	self	self	NN
22283	881	117	,	,	,
22283	881	118	progeny	progeny	VB
22283	881	119	,	,	,
22283	881	120	or	or	CC
22283	881	121	community	community	NN
22283	881	122	)	)	-RRB-
22283	881	123	;	;	:
22283	881	124	and	and	CC
22283	881	125	so	so	RB
22283	881	126	,	,	,
22283	881	127	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	881	128	,	,	,
22283	881	129	in	in	IN
22283	881	130	the	the	DT
22283	881	131	case	case	NN
22283	881	132	of	of	IN
22283	881	133	reason	reason	NN
22283	881	134	dictating	dictate	VBG
22283	881	135	a	a	DT
22283	881	136	still	still	RB
22283	881	137	more	more	RBR
22283	881	138	intricate	intricate	JJ
22283	881	139	adjustment	adjustment	NN
22283	881	140	for	for	IN
22283	881	141	the	the	DT
22283	881	142	sake	sake	NN
22283	881	143	of	of	IN
22283	881	144	securing	secure	VBG
22283	881	145	a	a	DT
22283	881	146	good	good	JJ
22283	881	147	still	still	RB
22283	881	148	more	more	RBR
22283	881	149	remote	remote	JJ
22283	881	150	--	--	:
22283	881	151	in	in	IN
22283	881	152	all	all	DT
22283	881	153	cases	case	NNS
22283	881	154	,	,	,
22283	881	155	that	that	RB
22283	881	156	is	is	RB
22283	881	157	,	,	,
22283	881	158	where	where	WRB
22283	881	159	volition	volition	NN
22283	881	160	is	be	VBZ
22283	881	161	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	881	162	,	,	,
22283	881	163	pleasures	pleasure	NNS
22283	881	164	and	and	CC
22283	881	165	pains	pain	NNS
22283	881	166	are	be	VBP
22283	881	167	the	the	DT
22283	881	168	guides	guide	NNS
22283	881	169	of	of	IN
22283	881	170	action	action	NN
22283	881	171	.	.	.
22283	881	172	'	'	''
22283	882	1	But	but	CC
22283	882	2	thus	thus	RB
22283	882	3	to	to	TO
22283	882	4	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	882	5	that	that	IN
22283	882	6	pleasures	pleasure	NNS
22283	882	7	and	and	CC
22283	882	8	pains	pain	NNS
22283	882	9	are	be	VBP
22283	882	10	the	the	DT
22283	882	11	guides	guide	NNS
22283	882	12	of	of	IN
22283	882	13	action	action	NN
22283	882	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	882	15	merely	merely	RB
22283	882	16	another	another	DT
22283	882	17	way	way	NN
22283	882	18	of	of	IN
22283	882	19	affirming	affirming	NN
22283	882	20	that	that	IN
22283	882	21	the	the	DT
22283	882	22	Will	Will	NNP
22283	882	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	882	24	an	an	DT
22283	882	25	agent	agent	NN
22283	882	26	--	--	:
22283	882	27	a	a	DT
22283	882	28	cause	cause	NN
22283	882	29	of	of	IN
22283	882	30	bodily	bodily	NNP
22283	882	31	movement	movement	NN
22283	882	32	,	,	,
22283	882	33	and	and	CC
22283	882	34	,	,	,
22283	882	35	as	as	IN
22283	882	36	such	such	JJ
22283	882	37	,	,	,
22283	882	38	a	a	DT
22283	882	39	cause	cause	NN
22283	882	40	in	in	IN
22283	882	41	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	882	42	.	.	.
22283	883	1	Now	now	RB
22283	883	2	,	,	,
22283	883	3	as	as	IN
22283	883	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	883	5	have	have	VBP
22283	883	6	seen	see	VBN
22283	883	7	,	,	,
22283	883	8	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	883	9	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	883	10	not	not	RB
22283	883	11	only	only	RB
22283	883	12	affirms	affirm	VBZ
22283	883	13	this	this	DT
22283	883	14	--	--	:
22283	883	15	or	or	CC
22283	883	16	rather	rather	RB
22283	883	17	assumes	assume	VBZ
22283	883	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	883	19	--	--	:
22283	883	20	but	but	CC
22283	883	21	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
22283	883	22	to	to	TO
22283	883	23	render	render	VB
22283	883	24	an	an	DT
22283	883	25	_	_	NNP
22283	883	26	a	a	DT
22283	883	27	priori	priori	FW
22283	883	28	_	_	NNP
22283	883	29	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	883	30	of	of	IN
22283	883	31	the	the	DT
22283	883	32	accuracy	accuracy	NN
22283	883	33	of	of	IN
22283	883	34	the	the	DT
22283	883	35	guidance	guidance	NN
22283	883	36	.	.	.
22283	884	1	Yet	yet	CC
22283	884	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	884	3	nowhere	nowhere	RB
22283	884	4	considers	consider	VBZ
22283	884	5	the	the	DT
22283	884	6	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	884	7	question	question	NN
22283	884	8	--	--	:
22283	884	9	Why	why	WRB
22283	884	10	should	should	MD
22283	884	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	884	12	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	884	13	that	that	IN
22283	884	14	the	the	DT
22283	884	15	Will	Will	NNP
22283	884	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	884	17	an	an	DT
22283	884	18	agent	agent	NN
22283	884	19	at	at	RB
22283	884	20	all	all	RB
22283	884	21	?	?	.
22283	885	1	Assuredly	assuredly	RB
22283	885	2	the	the	DT
22283	885	3	answer	answer	NN
22283	885	4	given	give	VBN
22283	885	5	by	by	IN
22283	885	6	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	885	7	to	to	IN
22283	885	8	this	this	DT
22283	885	9	question	question	NN
22283	885	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	885	11	a	a	DT
22283	885	12	simple	simple	JJ
22283	885	13	denial	denial	NN
22283	885	14	that	that	WDT
22283	885	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	885	16	have	have	VBP
22283	885	17	any	any	DT
22283	885	18	justification	justification	NN
22283	885	19	so	so	RB
22283	885	20	to	to	TO
22283	885	21	regard	regard	VB
22283	885	22	the	the	DT
22283	885	23	Will	Will	NNP
22283	885	24	:	:	:
22283	885	25	in	in	IN
22283	885	26	view	view	NN
22283	885	27	of	of	IN
22283	885	28	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	885	29	demonstration	demonstration	NN
22283	885	30	of	of	IN
22283	885	31	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	885	32	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	885	33	,	,	,
22283	885	34	she	-PRON-	PRP
22283	885	35	can	can	MD
22283	885	36	see	see	VB
22283	885	37	no	no	DT
22283	885	38	reason	reason	NN
22283	885	39	why	why	WRB
22283	885	40	there	there	EX
22283	885	41	should	should	MD
22283	885	42	be	be	VB
22283	885	43	any	any	DT
22283	885	44	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	885	45	at	at	RB
22283	885	46	all	all	RB
22283	885	47	between	between	IN
22283	885	48	a	a	DT
22283	885	49	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	885	50	feeling	feeling	NN
22283	885	51	of	of	IN
22283	885	52	pleasure	pleasure	NN
22283	885	53	or	or	CC
22283	885	54	pain	pain	NN
22283	885	55	and	and	CC
22283	885	56	an	an	DT
22283	885	57	objective	objective	JJ
22283	885	58	fact	fact	NN
22283	885	59	of	of	IN
22283	885	60	'	'	``
22283	885	61	agreement	agreement	NN
22283	885	62	or	or	CC
22283	885	63	disagreement	disagreement	NN
22283	885	64	with	with	IN
22283	885	65	the	the	DT
22283	885	66	environment'--nay	environment'--nay	NN
22283	885	67	,	,	,
22283	885	68	one	one	CD
22283	885	69	of	of	IN
22283	885	70	the	the	DT
22283	885	71	most	most	RBS
22283	885	72	eminent	eminent	JJ
22283	885	73	of	of	IN
22283	885	74	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	885	75	priesthood	priesthood	NN
22283	885	76	has	have	VBZ
22283	885	77	declared	declare	VBN
22283	885	78	that	that	IN
22283	885	79	there	there	EX
22283	885	80	_	_	NNP
22283	885	81	is	be	VBZ
22283	885	82	_	_	NNP
22283	885	83	no	no	DT
22283	885	84	more	more	JJR
22283	885	85	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	885	86	between	between	IN
22283	885	87	the	the	DT
22283	885	88	ambition	ambition	NN
22283	885	89	of	of	IN
22283	885	90	a	a	DT
22283	885	91	Napoleon	Napoleon	NNP
22283	885	92	and	and	CC
22283	885	93	a	a	DT
22283	885	94	general	general	JJ
22283	885	95	commotion	commotion	NN
22283	885	96	of	of	IN
22283	885	97	Europe	Europe	NNP
22283	885	98	,	,	,
22283	885	99	than	than	IN
22283	885	100	there	there	EX
22283	885	101	is	be	VBZ
22283	885	102	between	between	IN
22283	885	103	the	the	DT
22283	885	104	puff	puff	NN
22283	885	105	of	of	IN
22283	885	106	a	a	DT
22283	885	107	steam	steam	NN
22283	885	108	-	-	HYPH
22283	885	109	whistle	whistle	NN
22283	885	110	and	and	CC
22283	885	111	the	the	DT
22283	885	112	locomotion	locomotion	NN
22283	885	113	of	of	IN
22283	885	114	a	a	DT
22283	885	115	train	train	NN
22283	885	116	.	.	.
22283	886	1	And	and	CC
22283	886	2	,	,	,
22283	886	3	as	as	IN
22283	886	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	886	5	have	have	VBP
22283	886	6	now	now	RB
22283	886	7	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
22283	886	8	insisted	insist	VBN
22283	886	9	,	,	,
22283	886	10	on	on	IN
22283	886	11	grounds	ground	NNS
22283	886	12	of	of	IN
22283	886	13	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	886	14	alone	alone	RB
22283	886	15	this	this	DT
22283	886	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	886	17	the	the	DT
22283	886	18	only	only	JJ
22283	886	19	logical	logical	JJ
22283	886	20	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	886	21	at	at	IN
22283	886	22	which	which	WDT
22283	886	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	886	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	886	25	possible	possible	JJ
22283	886	26	to	to	TO
22283	886	27	arrive	arrive	VB
22283	886	28	.	.	.
22283	887	1	Yet	yet	CC
22283	887	2	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	887	3	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	887	4	,	,	,
22283	887	5	while	while	IN
22283	887	6	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
22283	887	7	proceeding	proceed	VBG
22283	887	8	on	on	IN
22283	887	9	the	the	DT
22283	887	10	lines	line	NNS
22283	887	11	of	of	IN
22283	887	12	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	887	13	,	,	,
22283	887	14	whenever	whenever	WRB
22283	887	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	887	16	encounters	encounter	VBZ
22283	887	17	the	the	DT
22283	887	18	question	question	NN
22283	887	19	of	of	IN
22283	887	20	the	the	DT
22283	887	21	agency	agency	NN
22283	887	22	of	of	IN
22283	887	23	Will	Will	NNP
22283	887	24	,	,	,
22283	887	25	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	887	26	jumps	jump	VBZ
22283	887	27	the	the	DT
22283	887	28	whole	whole	JJ
22283	887	29	gulf	gulf	NN
22283	887	30	that	that	WDT
22283	887	31	separates	separate	VBZ
22283	887	32	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	887	33	from	from	IN
22283	887	34	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	887	35	.	.	.
22283	888	1	And	and	CC
22283	888	2	this	this	DT
22283	888	3	wonderful	wonderful	JJ
22283	888	4	feat	feat	NN
22283	888	5	of	of	IN
22283	888	6	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
22283	888	7	athletics	athletic	NNS
22283	888	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	888	9	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	888	10	performed	perform	VBN
22283	888	11	,	,	,
22283	888	12	so	so	RB
22283	888	13	far	far	RB
22283	888	14	at	at	IN
22283	888	15	least	least	JJS
22283	888	16	as	as	IN
22283	888	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	888	18	am	be	VBP
22283	888	19	aware	aware	JJ
22283	888	20	,	,	,
22283	888	21	by	by	IN
22283	888	22	every	every	DT
22283	888	23	other	other	JJ
22283	888	24	psychologist	psychologist	NN
22283	888	25	who	who	WP
22283	888	26	has	have	VBZ
22283	888	27	proceeded	proceed	VBN
22283	888	28	on	on	IN
22283	888	29	the	the	DT
22283	888	30	lines	line	NNS
22283	888	31	of	of	IN
22283	888	32	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	888	33	.	.	.
22283	889	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
22283	889	2	,	,	,
22283	889	3	the	the	DT
22283	889	4	logical	logical	JJ
22283	889	5	incoherency	incoherency	NN
22283	889	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	889	7	not	not	RB
22283	889	8	so	so	RB
22283	889	9	serious	serious	JJ
22283	889	10	in	in	IN
22283	889	11	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	889	12	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	889	13	's	's	POS
22283	889	14	case	case	NN
22283	889	15	as	as	IN
22283	889	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	889	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	889	18	in	in	IN
22283	889	19	that	that	DT
22283	889	20	of	of	IN
22283	889	21	many	many	JJ
22283	889	22	other	other	JJ
22283	889	23	writers	writer	NNS
22283	889	24	whom	whom	WP
22283	889	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	889	26	need	need	VBP
22283	889	27	not	not	RB
22283	889	28	wait	wait	VB
22283	889	29	to	to	TO
22283	889	30	name	name	VB
22283	889	31	.	.	.
22283	890	1	For	for	IN
22283	890	2	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	890	3	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	890	4	does	do	VBZ
22283	890	5	not	not	RB
22283	890	6	seek	seek	VB
22283	890	7	to	to	TO
22283	890	8	found	find	VBN
22283	890	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	890	10	system	system	NN
22283	890	11	on	on	IN
22283	890	12	a	a	DT
22283	890	13	basis	basis	NN
22283	890	14	of	of	IN
22283	890	15	avowed	avowed	JJ
22283	890	16	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	890	17	,	,	,
22283	890	18	and	and	CC
22283	890	19	,	,	,
22283	890	20	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	890	21	,	,	,
22283	890	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	890	23	may	may	MD
22283	890	24	be	be	VB
22283	890	25	said	say	VBN
22283	890	26	to	to	TO
22283	890	27	have	have	VB
22283	890	28	left	leave	VBN
22283	890	29	this	this	DT
22283	890	30	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	890	31	question	question	NN
22283	890	32	of	of	IN
22283	890	33	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	890	34	agency	agency	NN
22283	890	35	in	in	IN
22283	890	36	abeyance	abeyance	NN
22283	890	37	.	.	.
22283	891	1	But	but	CC
22283	891	2	all	all	PDT
22283	891	3	those	those	DT
22283	891	4	writers	writer	NNS
22283	891	5	who	who	WP
22283	891	6	have	have	VBP
22283	891	7	reared	rear	VBN
22283	891	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	891	9	systems	system	NNS
22283	891	10	of	of	IN
22283	891	11	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	891	12	on	on	IN
22283	891	13	a	a	DT
22283	891	14	basis	basis	NN
22283	891	15	of	of	IN
22283	891	16	avowed	avowed	JJ
22283	891	17	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	891	18	--	--	:
22283	891	19	or	or	CC
22283	891	20	,	,	,
22283	891	21	which	which	WDT
22283	891	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	891	23	the	the	DT
22283	891	24	same	same	JJ
22283	891	25	thing	thing	NN
22283	891	26	,	,	,
22283	891	27	on	on	IN
22283	891	28	a	a	DT
22283	891	29	basis	basis	NN
22283	891	30	of	of	IN
22283	891	31	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	891	32	alone	alone	RB
22283	891	33	--	--	:
22283	891	34	lay	lay	VB
22283	891	35	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	891	36	open	open	JJ
22283	891	37	to	to	IN
22283	891	38	the	the	DT
22283	891	39	charge	charge	NN
22283	891	40	of	of	IN
22283	891	41	grossest	gross	JJS
22283	891	42	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
22283	891	43	when	when	WRB
22283	891	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	891	45	thus	thus	RB
22283	891	46	assume	assume	VBP
22283	891	47	that	that	IN
22283	891	48	the	the	DT
22283	891	49	Will	Will	NNP
22283	891	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	891	51	an	an	DT
22283	891	52	agent	agent	NN
22283	891	53	.	.	.
22283	892	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	892	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	892	3	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	892	4	that	that	IN
22283	892	5	these	these	DT
22283	892	6	writers	writer	NNS
22283	892	7	can	can	MD
22283	892	8	both	both	DT
22283	892	9	have	have	VB
22283	892	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	892	11	cake	cake	NN
22283	892	12	and	and	CC
22283	892	13	eat	eat	VB
22283	892	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	892	15	.	.	.
22283	893	1	Either	either	CC
22283	893	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	893	3	must	must	MD
22283	893	4	forego	forego	VB
22283	893	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	893	6	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	893	7	,	,	,
22283	893	8	or	or	CC
22283	893	9	else	else	RB
22283	893	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	893	11	must	must	MD
22283	893	12	cease	cease	VB
22283	893	13	to	to	TO
22283	893	14	speak	speak	VB
22283	893	15	of	of	IN
22283	893	16	'	'	``
22283	893	17	motives	motive	NNS
22283	893	18	determining	determine	VBG
22283	893	19	action	action	NN
22283	893	20	,	,	,
22283	893	21	'	'	''
22283	893	22	'	'	''
22283	893	23	conduct	conduct	NN
22283	893	24	being	be	VBG
22283	893	25	governed	govern	VBN
22283	893	26	by	by	IN
22283	893	27	pleasures	pleasure	NNS
22283	893	28	and	and	CC
22283	893	29	pains	pain	NNS
22283	893	30	,	,	,
22283	893	31	'	'	''
22283	893	32	'	'	''
22283	893	33	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	893	34	movements	movement	NNS
22283	893	35	in	in	IN
22283	893	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	893	37	last	last	JJ
22283	893	38	resort	resort	NN
22283	893	39	being	be	VBG
22283	893	40	all	all	DT
22283	893	41	due	due	IN
22283	893	42	to	to	IN
22283	893	43	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	893	44	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	893	45	,	,	,
22283	893	46	'	'	''
22283	893	47	'	'	''
22283	893	48	the	the	DT
22283	893	49	highest	high	JJS
22283	893	50	morality	morality	NN
22283	893	51	and	and	CC
22283	893	52	the	the	DT
22283	893	53	lowest	low	JJS
22283	893	54	vice	vice	NN
22283	893	55	being	be	VBG
22283	893	56	alike	alike	RB
22283	893	57	the	the	DT
22283	893	58	result	result	NN
22283	893	59	of	of	IN
22283	893	60	a	a	DT
22283	893	61	pursuit	pursuit	NN
22283	893	62	of	of	IN
22283	893	63	happiness	happiness	NN
22283	893	64	,	,	,
22283	893	65	'	'	''
22283	893	66	&	&	CC
22283	893	67	c.	c.	NNP
22283	893	68	&	&	CC
22283	893	69	c.	c.	NNP
22283	893	70	And	and	CC
22283	893	71	,	,	,
22283	893	72	so	so	RB
22283	893	73	far	far	RB
22283	893	74	as	as	IN
22283	893	75	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	893	76	can	can	MD
22283	893	77	see	see	VB
22283	893	78	,	,	,
22283	893	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	893	80	is	be	VBZ
22283	893	81	only	only	RB
22283	893	82	in	in	IN
22283	893	83	the	the	DT
22283	893	84	way	way	NN
22283	893	85	above	above	IN
22283	893	86	indicated	indicate	VBN
22283	893	87	,	,	,
22283	893	88	or	or	CC
22283	893	89	on	on	IN
22283	893	90	the	the	DT
22283	893	91	theory	theory	NN
22283	893	92	of	of	IN
22283	893	93	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	893	94	,	,	,
22283	893	95	that	that	IN
22283	893	96	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	893	97	is	be	VBZ
22283	893	98	possible	possible	JJ
22283	893	99	,	,	,
22283	893	100	without	without	IN
22283	893	101	ignoring	ignore	VBG
22283	893	102	the	the	DT
22283	893	103	facts	fact	NNS
22283	893	104	of	of	IN
22283	893	105	physiology	physiology	NN
22283	893	106	on	on	IN
22283	893	107	the	the	DT
22283	893	108	one	one	CD
22283	893	109	hand	hand	NN
22283	893	110	or	or	CC
22283	893	111	those	those	DT
22283	893	112	of	of	IN
22283	893	113	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	893	114	on	on	IN
22283	893	115	the	the	DT
22283	893	116	other	other	JJ
22283	893	117	,	,	,
22283	893	118	philosophically	philosophically	RB
22283	893	119	to	to	TO
22283	893	120	save	save	VB
22283	893	121	the	the	DT
22283	893	122	agency	agency	NN
22283	893	123	of	of	IN
22283	893	124	Will	Will	NNP
22283	893	125	.	.	.
22283	894	1	From	from	IN
22283	894	2	this	this	DT
22283	894	3	brief	brief	JJ
22283	894	4	exposition	exposition	NN
22283	894	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	894	6	may	may	MD
22283	894	7	be	be	VB
22283	894	8	gathered	gather	VBN
22283	894	9	that	that	IN
22283	894	10	on	on	IN
22283	894	11	the	the	DT
22283	894	12	materialistic	materialistic	JJ
22283	894	13	theory	theory	NN
22283	894	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	894	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	894	16	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	894	17	that	that	IN
22283	894	18	the	the	DT
22283	894	19	Will	Will	MD
22283	894	20	can	can	MD
22283	894	21	be	be	VB
22283	894	22	,	,	,
22283	894	23	in	in	IN
22283	894	24	any	any	DT
22283	894	25	sense	sense	NN
22283	894	26	of	of	IN
22283	894	27	the	the	DT
22283	894	28	term	term	NN
22283	894	29	,	,	,
22283	894	30	an	an	DT
22283	894	31	agent	agent	NN
22283	894	32	;	;	:
22283	894	33	that	that	DT
22283	894	34	on	on	IN
22283	894	35	the	the	DT
22283	894	36	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	894	37	theory	theory	NN
22283	894	38	the	the	DT
22283	894	39	Will	Will	NNP
22283	894	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	894	41	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	894	42	as	as	IN
22283	894	43	an	an	DT
22283	894	44	agent	agent	NN
22283	894	45	,	,	,
22283	894	46	but	but	CC
22283	894	47	only	only	RB
22283	894	48	in	in	IN
22283	894	49	the	the	DT
22283	894	50	sense	sense	NN
22283	894	51	of	of	IN
22283	894	52	a	a	DT
22283	894	53	non	non	JJ
22283	894	54	-	-	JJ
22283	894	55	natural	natural	JJ
22283	894	56	or	or	CC
22283	894	57	miraculous	miraculous	JJ
22283	894	58	cause	cause	NN
22283	894	59	;	;	:
22283	894	60	and	and	CC
22283	894	61	,	,	,
22283	894	62	lastly	lastly	RB
22283	894	63	,	,	,
22283	894	64	that	that	IN
22283	894	65	on	on	IN
22283	894	66	the	the	DT
22283	894	67	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	894	68	theory	theory	NN
22283	894	69	the	the	DT
22283	894	70	Will	Will	NNP
22283	894	71	is	be	VBZ
22283	894	72	saved	save	VBN
22283	894	73	as	as	IN
22283	894	74	an	an	DT
22283	894	75	agent	agent	NN
22283	894	76	,	,	,
22283	894	77	or	or	CC
22283	894	78	may	may	MD
22283	894	79	be	be	VB
22283	894	80	properly	properly	RB
22283	894	81	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	894	82	and	and	CC
22283	894	83	as	as	RB
22283	894	84	properly	properly	RB
22283	894	85	denominated	denominate	VBN
22283	894	86	a	a	DT
22283	894	87	true	true	JJ
22283	894	88	cause	cause	NN
22283	894	89	,	,	,
22283	894	90	in	in	IN
22283	894	91	the	the	DT
22283	894	92	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
22283	894	93	sense	sense	NN
22283	894	94	of	of	IN
22283	894	95	that	that	DT
22283	894	96	term	term	NN
22283	894	97	.	.	.
22283	895	1	For	for	IN
22283	895	2	this	this	DT
22283	895	3	,	,	,
22283	895	4	as	as	RB
22283	895	5	well	well	RB
22283	895	6	as	as	IN
22283	895	7	for	for	IN
22283	895	8	other	other	JJ
22283	895	9	reasons	reason	NNS
22283	895	10	which	which	WDT
22283	895	11	need	need	VBP
22283	895	12	not	not	RB
22283	895	13	here	here	RB
22283	895	14	be	be	VB
22283	895	15	specified	specify	VBN
22283	895	16	,	,	,
22283	895	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	895	18	accept	accept	VBP
22283	895	19	in	in	IN
22283	895	20	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	895	21	the	the	DT
22283	895	22	theory	theory	NN
22283	895	23	of	of	IN
22283	895	24	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	895	25	;	;	,
22283	895	26	and	and	CC
22283	895	27	am	be	VBP
22283	895	28	thus	thus	RB
22283	895	29	entitled	entitle	VBN
22283	895	30	in	in	IN
22283	895	31	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	895	32	to	to	TO
22283	895	33	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	895	34	upon	upon	IN
22283	895	35	the	the	DT
22283	895	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	895	37	that	that	IN
22283	895	38	the	the	DT
22283	895	39	Will	Will	NNP
22283	895	40	is	be	VBZ
22283	895	41	an	an	DT
22283	895	42	agent	agent	NN
22283	895	43	.	.	.
22283	896	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	896	2	have	have	VBP
22283	896	3	next	next	JJ
22283	896	4	to	to	TO
22283	896	5	consider	consider	VB
22283	896	6	the	the	DT
22283	896	7	ulterior	ulterior	JJ
22283	896	8	question	question	NN
22283	896	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	896	10	upon	upon	IN
22283	896	11	this	this	DT
22283	896	12	theory	theory	NN
22283	896	13	the	the	DT
22283	896	14	Will	Will	NNP
22283	896	15	may	may	MD
22283	896	16	be	be	VB
22283	896	17	properly	properly	RB
22283	896	18	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	896	19	as	as	IN
22283	896	20	a	a	DT
22283	896	21	free	free	JJ
22283	896	22	agent	agent	NN
22283	896	23	.	.	.
22283	897	1	By	by	IN
22283	897	2	a	a	DT
22283	897	3	free	free	JJ
22283	897	4	agent	agent	NN
22283	897	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	897	6	understood	understand	VBN
22283	897	7	an	an	DT
22283	897	8	agent	agent	NN
22283	897	9	that	that	WDT
22283	897	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	897	11	able	able	JJ
22283	897	12	to	to	TO
22283	897	13	act	act	VB
22283	897	14	without	without	IN
22283	897	15	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	897	16	,	,	,
22283	897	17	or	or	CC
22283	897	18	spontaneously	spontaneously	RB
22283	897	19	.	.	.
22283	898	1	The	the	DT
22283	898	2	word	word	NN
22283	898	3	'	'	``
22283	898	4	free	free	JJ
22283	898	5	,	,	,
22283	898	6	'	'	''
22283	898	7	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	898	8	,	,	,
22283	898	9	bears	bear	VBZ
22283	898	10	a	a	DT
22283	898	11	very	very	RB
22283	898	12	different	different	JJ
22283	898	13	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	898	14	when	when	WRB
22283	898	15	applied	apply	VBD
22283	898	16	exclusively	exclusively	RB
22283	898	17	to	to	IN
22283	898	18	the	the	DT
22283	898	19	Will	Will	NNP
22283	898	20	,	,	,
22283	898	21	and	and	CC
22283	898	22	when	when	WRB
22283	898	23	applied	apply	VBN
22283	898	24	more	more	RBR
22283	898	25	generally	generally	RB
22283	898	26	to	to	IN
22283	898	27	the	the	DT
22283	898	28	living	live	VBG
22283	898	29	organism	organism	NN
22283	898	30	.	.	.
22283	899	1	For	for	IN
22283	899	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	899	3	may	may	MD
22283	899	4	properly	properly	RB
22283	899	5	say	say	VB
22283	899	6	that	that	IN
22283	899	7	a	a	DT
22283	899	8	man	man	NN
22283	899	9	,	,	,
22283	899	10	or	or	CC
22283	899	11	an	an	DT
22283	899	12	animal	animal	NN
22283	899	13	,	,	,
22283	899	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	899	15	free	free	JJ
22283	899	16	when	when	WRB
22283	899	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	899	18	,	,	,
22283	899	19	or	or	CC
22283	899	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	899	21	,	,	,
22283	899	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	899	23	at	at	IN
22283	899	24	liberty	liberty	NN
22283	899	25	to	to	TO
22283	899	26	act	act	VB
22283	899	27	in	in	IN
22283	899	28	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	899	29	with	with	IN
22283	899	30	desire	desire	NN
22283	899	31	.	.	.
22283	900	1	Touching	touch	VBG
22283	900	2	the	the	DT
22283	900	3	fact	fact	NN
22283	900	4	of	of	IN
22283	900	5	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	900	6	in	in	IN
22283	900	7	this	this	DT
22283	900	8	sense	sense	NN
22283	900	9	there	there	EX
22283	900	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	900	11	,	,	,
22283	900	12	of	of	IN
22283	900	13	course	course	NN
22283	900	14	,	,	,
22283	900	15	no	no	DT
22283	900	16	question	question	NN
22283	900	17	.	.	.
22283	901	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	901	2	have	have	VBP
22283	901	3	not	not	RB
22283	901	4	to	to	TO
22283	901	5	consider	consider	VB
22283	901	6	the	the	DT
22283	901	7	possible	possible	JJ
22283	901	8	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	901	9	of	of	IN
22283	901	10	man	man	NN
22283	901	11	,	,	,
22283	901	12	but	but	CC
22283	901	13	the	the	DT
22283	901	14	possible	possible	JJ
22283	901	15	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	901	16	of	of	IN
22283	901	17	Will	Will	NNP
22283	901	18	;	;	:
22283	901	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	901	20	have	have	VBP
22283	901	21	not	not	RB
22283	901	22	to	to	TO
22283	901	23	contemplate	contemplate	VB
22283	901	24	whether	whether	IN
22283	901	25	a	a	DT
22283	901	26	man	man	NN
22283	901	27	may	may	MD
22283	901	28	be	be	VB
22283	901	29	free	free	JJ
22283	901	30	to	to	TO
22283	901	31	do	do	VB
22283	901	32	what	what	WP
22283	901	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	901	34	wills	will	VBZ
22283	901	35	,	,	,
22283	901	36	but	but	CC
22283	901	37	whether	whether	IN
22283	901	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	901	39	can	can	MD
22283	901	40	be	be	VB
22283	901	41	free	free	JJ
22283	901	42	to	to	TO
22283	901	43	will	will	VB
22283	901	44	what	what	WP
22283	901	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	901	46	wills	will	VBZ
22283	901	47	.	.	.
22283	902	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	902	2	being	be	VBG
22283	902	3	the	the	DT
22283	902	4	question	question	NN
22283	902	5	,	,	,
22283	902	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	902	7	have	have	VBP
22283	902	8	to	to	TO
22283	902	9	consider	consider	VB
22283	902	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	902	11	in	in	IN
22283	902	12	relation	relation	NN
22283	902	13	to	to	IN
22283	902	14	the	the	DT
22283	902	15	three	three	CD
22283	902	16	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	902	17	theories	theory	NNS
22283	902	18	already	already	RB
22283	902	19	stated	state	VBN
22283	902	20	--	--	:
22283	902	21	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	902	22	,	,	,
22283	902	23	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	902	24	,	,	,
22283	902	25	and	and	CC
22283	902	26	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	902	27	.	.	.
22283	903	1	For	for	IN
22283	903	2	the	the	DT
22283	903	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	903	4	of	of	IN
22283	903	5	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	903	6	the	the	DT
22283	903	7	present	present	JJ
22283	903	8	question	question	NN
22283	903	9	has	have	VBZ
22283	903	10	no	no	DT
22283	903	11	existence	existence	NN
22283	903	12	.	.	.
22283	904	1	If	if	IN
22283	904	2	this	this	DT
22283	904	3	announcement	announcement	NN
22283	904	4	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	904	5	startling	startling	JJ
22283	904	6	,	,	,
22283	904	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	904	8	can	can	MD
22283	904	9	only	only	RB
22283	904	10	be	be	VB
22283	904	11	because	because	IN
22283	904	12	no	no	DT
22283	904	13	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	904	14	has	have	VBZ
22283	904	15	ever	ever	RB
22283	904	16	taken	take	VBN
22283	904	17	the	the	DT
22283	904	18	trouble	trouble	NN
22283	904	19	to	to	TO
22283	904	20	formulate	formulate	VB
22283	904	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	904	22	own	own	JJ
22283	904	23	theory	theory	NN
22283	904	24	with	with	IN
22283	904	25	distinctness	distinctness	NN
22283	904	26	.	.	.
22283	905	1	For	for	IN
22283	905	2	,	,	,
22283	905	3	as	as	IN
22283	905	4	previously	previously	RB
22283	905	5	shown	show	VBN
22283	905	6	,	,	,
22283	905	7	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	905	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	905	9	involves	involve	VBZ
22283	905	10	the	the	DT
22283	905	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	905	12	of	of	IN
22283	905	13	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	905	14	automatism	automatism	NN
22283	905	15	;	;	:
22283	905	16	but	but	CC
22283	905	17	,	,	,
22283	905	18	if	if	IN
22283	905	19	so	so	RB
22283	905	20	,	,	,
22283	905	21	the	the	DT
22283	905	22	Will	Will	NNP
22283	905	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	905	24	concluded	conclude	VBN
22283	905	25	not	not	RB
22283	905	26	to	to	TO
22283	905	27	be	be	VB
22283	905	28	an	an	DT
22283	905	29	agent	agent	NN
22283	905	30	at	at	RB
22283	905	31	all	all	RB
22283	905	32	,	,	,
22283	905	33	and	and	CC
22283	905	34	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	905	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	905	36	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	905	37	idle	idle	JJ
22283	905	38	to	to	TO
22283	905	39	discuss	discuss	VB
22283	905	40	whether	whether	IN
22283	905	41	,	,	,
22283	905	42	in	in	IN
22283	905	43	any	any	DT
22283	905	44	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	905	45	exercise	exercise	NN
22283	905	46	of	of	IN
22283	905	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	905	48	agency	agency	NN
22283	905	49	,	,	,
22283	905	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	905	51	is	be	VBZ
22283	905	52	free	free	JJ
22283	905	53	or	or	CC
22283	905	54	subject	subject	JJ
22283	905	55	to	to	IN
22283	905	56	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	905	57	.	.	.
22283	906	1	The	the	DT
22283	906	2	most	most	JJS
22283	906	3	that	that	WDT
22283	906	4	in	in	IN
22283	906	5	this	this	DT
22283	906	6	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	906	7	could	could	MD
22283	906	8	logically	logically	RB
22283	906	9	stand	stand	VB
22283	906	10	to	to	TO
22283	906	11	be	be	VB
22283	906	12	considered	consider	VBN
22283	906	13	by	by	IN
22283	906	14	the	the	DT
22283	906	15	advocates	advocate	NNS
22283	906	16	of	of	IN
22283	906	17	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	906	18	would	would	MD
22283	906	19	be	be	VB
22283	906	20	whether	whether	IN
22283	906	21	or	or	CC
22283	906	22	not	not	RB
22283	906	23	the	the	DT
22283	906	24	adventitious	adventitious	JJ
22283	906	25	and	and	CC
22283	906	26	inefficacious	inefficacious	JJ
22283	906	27	feelings	feeling	NNS
22283	906	28	of	of	IN
22283	906	29	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	906	30	which	which	WDT
22283	906	31	are	be	VBP
22283	906	32	associated	associate	VBN
22283	906	33	with	with	IN
22283	906	34	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	906	35	activity	activity	NN
22283	906	36	are	be	VBP
22283	906	37	determinate	determinate	JJ
22283	906	38	or	or	CC
22283	906	39	free	free	JJ
22283	906	40	;	;	:
22283	906	41	but	but	CC
22283	906	42	this	this	DT
22283	906	43	would	would	MD
22283	906	44	probably	probably	RB
22283	906	45	be	be	VB
22283	906	46	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	906	47	on	on	IN
22283	906	48	all	all	DT
22283	906	49	hands	hand	NNS
22283	906	50	as	as	IN
22283	906	51	a	a	DT
22283	906	52	somewhat	somewhat	RB
22283	906	53	useless	useless	JJ
22283	906	54	topic	topic	NN
22283	906	55	of	of	IN
22283	906	56	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	906	57	,	,	,
22283	906	58	and	and	CC
22283	906	59	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	906	60	in	in	IN
22283	906	61	any	any	DT
22283	906	62	case	case	NN
22283	906	63	would	would	MD
22283	906	64	have	have	VB
22283	906	65	no	no	DT
22283	906	66	reference	reference	NN
22283	906	67	to	to	IN
22283	906	68	the	the	DT
22283	906	69	question	question	NN
22283	906	70	of	of	IN
22283	906	71	free	free	JJ
22283	906	72	_	_	NNP
22283	906	73	agency	agency	NN
22283	906	74	_	_	NNP
22283	906	75	.	.	.
22283	907	1	The	the	DT
22283	907	2	point	point	NN
22283	907	3	to	to	TO
22283	907	4	be	be	VB
22283	907	5	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	907	6	understood	understand	VBN
22283	907	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	907	8	that	that	IN
22283	907	9	,	,	,
22283	907	10	according	accord	VBG
22283	907	11	to	to	IN
22283	907	12	the	the	DT
22283	907	13	materialistic	materialistic	JJ
22283	907	14	theory	theory	NN
22283	907	15	,	,	,
22283	907	16	a	a	DT
22283	907	17	motor	motor	NN
22283	907	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	907	19	distinct	distinct	JJ
22283	907	20	from	from	IN
22283	907	21	a	a	DT
22283	907	22	motive	motive	NN
22283	907	23	,	,	,
22283	907	24	although	although	IN
22283	907	25	in	in	IN
22283	907	26	some	some	DT
22283	907	27	unaccountable	unaccountable	JJ
22283	907	28	manner	manner	NN
22283	907	29	the	the	DT
22283	907	30	motor	motor	NN
22283	907	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	907	32	able	able	JJ
22283	907	33	to	to	TO
22283	907	34	cause	cause	VB
22283	907	35	the	the	DT
22283	907	36	motive	motive	NN
22283	907	37	.	.	.
22283	908	1	But	but	CC
22283	908	2	the	the	DT
22283	908	3	motive	motive	NN
22283	908	4	,	,	,
22283	908	5	when	when	WRB
22283	908	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	908	7	caused	cause	VBN
22283	908	8	,	,	,
22283	908	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	908	10	not	not	RB
22283	908	11	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	908	12	to	to	TO
22283	908	13	exert	exert	VB
22283	908	14	any	any	DT
22283	908	15	causal	causal	JJ
22283	908	16	influence	influence	NN
22283	908	17	on	on	IN
22283	908	18	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	908	19	action	action	NN
22283	908	20	;	;	:
22283	908	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	908	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	908	23	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	908	24	to	to	TO
22283	908	25	begin	begin	VB
22283	908	26	and	and	CC
22283	908	27	end	end	VB
22283	908	28	as	as	IN
22283	908	29	a	a	DT
22283	908	30	motive	motive	NN
22283	908	31	,	,	,
22283	908	32	or	or	CC
22283	908	33	never	never	RB
22283	908	34	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	908	35	to	to	TO
22283	908	36	become	become	VB
22283	908	37	a	a	DT
22283	908	38	motor	motor	NN
22283	908	39	.	.	.
22283	909	1	In	in	IN
22283	909	2	other	other	JJ
22283	909	3	words	word	NNS
22283	909	4	,	,	,
22283	909	5	as	as	IN
22283	909	6	before	before	IN
22283	909	7	stated	state	VBN
22283	909	8	,	,	,
22283	909	9	the	the	DT
22283	909	10	Will	Will	NNP
22283	909	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	909	12	not	not	RB
22283	909	13	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	909	14	to	to	TO
22283	909	15	be	be	VB
22283	909	16	an	an	DT
22283	909	17	agent	agent	NN
22283	909	18	;	;	:
22283	909	19	and	and	CC
22283	909	20	,	,	,
22283	909	21	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	909	22	,	,	,
22283	909	23	to	to	IN
22283	909	24	this	this	DT
22283	909	25	theory	theory	NN
22283	909	26	the	the	DT
22283	909	27	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	909	28	of	of	IN
22283	909	29	free	free	JJ
22283	909	30	-	-	HYPH
22283	909	31	will	will	NN
22283	909	32	and	and	CC
22283	909	33	of	of	IN
22283	909	34	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	909	35	are	be	VBP
22283	909	36	alike	alike	RB
22283	909	37	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
22283	909	38	.	.	.
22283	910	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	910	2	need	nee	MD
22283	910	3	not	not	RB
22283	910	4	wait	wait	VB
22283	910	5	to	to	TO
22283	910	6	prove	prove	VB
22283	910	7	that	that	IN
22283	910	8	this	this	DT
22283	910	9	important	important	JJ
22283	910	10	fact	fact	NN
22283	910	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	910	12	habitually	habitually	RB
22283	910	13	overlooked	overlook	VBN
22283	910	14	by	by	IN
22283	910	15	materialists	materialist	NNS
22283	910	16	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	910	17	,	,	,
22283	910	18	or	or	CC
22283	910	19	that	that	IN
22283	910	20	whenever	whenever	WRB
22283	910	21	a	a	DT
22283	910	22	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	910	23	espouses	espouse	VBZ
22283	910	24	the	the	DT
22283	910	25	cause	cause	NN
22283	910	26	of	of	IN
22283	910	27	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	910	28	,	,	,
22283	910	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	910	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	910	31	thereby	thereby	RB
22283	910	32	and	and	CC
22283	910	33	for	for	IN
22283	910	34	the	the	DT
22283	910	35	time	time	NN
22283	910	36	being	be	VBG
22283	910	37	vacating	vacate	VBG
22283	910	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	910	39	position	position	NN
22283	910	40	as	as	IN
22283	910	41	a	a	DT
22283	910	42	materialist	materialist	NN
22283	910	43	;	;	:
22283	910	44	for	for	IN
22283	910	45	if	if	IN
22283	910	46	,	,	,
22283	910	47	according	accord	VBG
22283	910	48	to	to	IN
22283	910	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	910	50	theory	theory	NN
22283	910	51	,	,	,
22283	910	52	the	the	DT
22283	910	53	Will	Will	NNP
22283	910	54	is	be	VBZ
22283	910	55	not	not	RB
22283	910	56	an	an	DT
22283	910	57	agent	agent	NN
22283	910	58	,	,	,
22283	910	59	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	910	60	is	be	VBZ
22283	910	61	merely	merely	RB
22283	910	62	impugning	impugn	VBG
22283	910	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	910	64	own	own	JJ
22283	910	65	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
22283	910	66	by	by	IN
22283	910	67	consenting	consent	VBG
22283	910	68	to	to	TO
22283	910	69	discuss	discuss	VB
22283	910	70	the	the	DT
22283	910	71	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	910	72	of	of	IN
22283	910	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	910	74	agency	agency	NN
22283	910	75	.	.	.
22283	911	1	The	the	DT
22283	911	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	911	3	of	of	IN
22283	911	4	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	911	5	and	and	CC
22283	911	6	the	the	DT
22283	911	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	911	8	of	of	IN
22283	911	9	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	911	10	agree	agree	VBP
22283	911	11	in	in	IN
22283	911	12	holding	hold	VBG
22283	911	13	that	that	IN
22283	911	14	the	the	DT
22283	911	15	Will	Will	NNP
22283	911	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	911	17	an	an	DT
22283	911	18	agent	agent	NN
22283	911	19	;	;	:
22283	911	20	and	and	CC
22283	911	21	,	,	,
22283	911	22	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	911	23	,	,	,
22283	911	24	to	to	IN
22283	911	25	both	both	DT
22283	911	26	of	of	IN
22283	911	27	these	these	DT
22283	911	28	theories	theory	NNS
22283	911	29	the	the	DT
22283	911	30	question	question	NN
22283	911	31	whether	whether	IN
22283	911	32	the	the	DT
22283	911	33	Will	Will	NNP
22283	911	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	911	35	a	a	DT
22283	911	36	free	free	JJ
22283	911	37	agent	agent	NN
22283	911	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	911	39	a	a	DT
22283	911	40	real	real	JJ
22283	911	41	question	question	NN
22283	911	42	.	.	.
22283	912	1	Here	here	RB
22283	912	2	,	,	,
22283	912	3	then	then	RB
22283	912	4	,	,	,
22283	912	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	912	6	devolves	devolve	VBZ
22283	912	7	upon	upon	IN
22283	912	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	912	9	to	to	TO
22283	912	10	consider	consider	VB
22283	912	11	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	912	12	the	the	DT
22283	912	13	logical	logical	JJ
22283	912	14	status	status	NN
22283	912	15	of	of	IN
22283	912	16	the	the	DT
22283	912	17	rival	rival	JJ
22283	912	18	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
22283	912	19	of	of	IN
22283	912	20	so	so	RB
22283	912	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	912	22	called	call	VBN
22283	912	23	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	912	24	and	and	CC
22283	912	25	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
22283	912	26	.	.	.
22283	913	1	For	for	IN
22283	913	2	convenience	convenience	NN
22283	913	3	of	of	IN
22283	913	4	arrangement	arrangement	NN
22283	913	5	in	in	IN
22283	913	6	what	what	WP
22283	913	7	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	913	8	,	,	,
22283	913	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	913	10	may	may	MD
22283	913	11	best	well	RBS
22283	913	12	begin	begin	VB
22283	913	13	with	with	IN
22283	913	14	the	the	DT
22283	913	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	913	16	of	of	IN
22283	913	17	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
22283	913	18	,	,	,
22283	913	19	or	or	CC
22283	913	20	Determinism	Determinism	NNP
22283	913	21	.	.	.
22283	914	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
22283	914	2	VI	VI	NNP
22283	914	3	.	.	.
22283	915	1	THE	the	DT
22283	915	2	WILL	WILL	MD
22283	915	3	IN	in	IN
22283	915	4	RELATION	relation	NN
22283	915	5	TO	to	IN
22283	915	6	MONISM	MONISM	NNP
22283	915	7	.	.	.
22283	916	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	916	2	have	have	VBP
22283	916	3	now	now	RB
22283	916	4	seen	see	VBN
22283	916	5	that	that	IN
22283	916	6	,	,	,
22283	916	7	according	accord	VBG
22283	916	8	to	to	IN
22283	916	9	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	916	10	,	,	,
22283	916	11	the	the	DT
22283	916	12	Will	Will	NNP
22283	916	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	916	14	not	not	RB
22283	916	15	an	an	DT
22283	916	16	agent	agent	NN
22283	916	17	,	,	,
22283	916	18	while	while	IN
22283	916	19	according	accord	VBG
22283	916	20	both	both	CC
22283	916	21	to	to	IN
22283	916	22	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	916	23	and	and	CC
22283	916	24	to	to	IN
22283	916	25	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	916	26	the	the	DT
22283	916	27	Will	Will	NNP
22283	916	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	916	29	an	an	DT
22283	916	30	agent	agent	NN
22283	916	31	.	.	.
22283	917	1	Touching	touch	VBG
22283	917	2	the	the	DT
22283	917	3	further	further	JJ
22283	917	4	question	question	NN
22283	917	5	,	,	,
22283	917	6	whether	whether	IN
22283	917	7	the	the	DT
22283	917	8	Will	Will	NNP
22283	917	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	917	10	a	a	DT
22283	917	11	free	free	JJ
22283	917	12	agent	agent	NN
22283	917	13	,	,	,
22283	917	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	917	15	have	have	VBP
22283	917	16	seen	see	VBN
22283	917	17	that	that	IN
22283	917	18	while	while	IN
22283	917	19	the	the	DT
22283	917	20	question	question	NN
22283	917	21	does	do	VBZ
22283	917	22	not	not	RB
22283	917	23	exist	exist	VB
22283	917	24	for	for	IN
22283	917	25	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	917	26	,	,	,
22283	917	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	917	28	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	917	29	to	to	TO
22283	917	30	require	require	VB
22283	917	31	a	a	DT
22283	917	32	negative	negative	JJ
22283	917	33	answer	answer	NN
22283	917	34	both	both	CC
22283	917	35	from	from	IN
22283	917	36	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	917	37	and	and	CC
22283	917	38	from	from	IN
22283	917	39	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	917	40	.	.	.
22283	918	1	For	for	IN
22283	918	2	,	,	,
22283	918	3	as	as	IN
22283	918	4	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	918	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	918	6	relation	relation	NN
22283	918	7	to	to	IN
22283	918	8	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	918	9	,	,	,
22283	918	10	when	when	WRB
22283	918	11	once	once	IN
22283	918	12	the	the	DT
22283	918	13	ground	ground	NN
22283	918	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	918	15	cleared	clear	VBN
22283	918	16	of	of	IN
22283	918	17	certain	certain	JJ
22283	918	18	errors	error	NNS
22283	918	19	of	of	IN
22283	918	20	statement	statement	NN
22283	918	21	and	and	CC
22283	918	22	fallacies	fallacy	NNS
22283	918	23	of	of	IN
22283	918	24	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	918	25	,	,	,
22283	918	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	918	27	appear	appear	VBP
22283	918	28	to	to	TO
22283	918	29	find	find	VB
22283	918	30	that	that	IN
22283	918	31	unless	unless	IN
22283	918	32	the	the	DT
22283	918	33	will	will	NN
22283	918	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	918	35	held	hold	VBN
22283	918	36	to	to	TO
22283	918	37	be	be	VB
22283	918	38	motiveless	motiveless	NN
22283	918	39	--	--	:
22283	918	40	which	which	WDT
22283	918	41	would	would	MD
22283	918	42	be	be	VB
22283	918	43	to	to	TO
22283	918	44	destroy	destroy	VB
22283	918	45	not	not	RB
22283	918	46	only	only	RB
22283	918	47	the	the	DT
22283	918	48	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	918	49	of	of	IN
22283	918	50	moral	moral	JJ
22283	918	51	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	918	52	,	,	,
22283	918	53	but	but	CC
22283	918	54	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	918	55	that	that	DT
22283	918	56	of	of	IN
22283	918	57	universal	universal	JJ
22283	918	58	causation	causation	NN
22283	918	59	--	--	:
22283	918	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	918	61	must	must	MD
22283	918	62	be	be	VB
22283	918	63	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	918	64	as	as	IN
22283	918	65	subject	subject	JJ
22283	918	66	to	to	IN
22283	918	67	law	law	NN
22283	918	68	,	,	,
22283	918	69	or	or	CC
22283	918	70	as	as	IN
22283	918	71	determined	determine	VBN
22283	918	72	in	in	IN
22283	918	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	918	74	action	action	NN
22283	918	75	by	by	IN
22283	918	76	the	the	DT
22283	918	77	nature	nature	NN
22283	918	78	of	of	IN
22283	918	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	918	80	past	past	JJ
22283	918	81	history	history	NN
22283	918	82	and	and	CC
22283	918	83	present	present	JJ
22283	918	84	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
22283	918	85	.	.	.
22283	919	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	919	2	,	,	,
22283	919	3	the	the	DT
22283	919	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	919	5	of	of	IN
22283	919	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	919	7	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	919	8	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	919	9	to	to	TO
22283	919	10	deny	deny	VB
22283	919	11	the	the	DT
22283	919	12	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	919	13	of	of	IN
22283	919	14	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	919	15	as	as	IN
22283	919	16	an	an	DT
22283	919	17	attribute	attribute	NN
22283	919	18	of	of	IN
22283	919	19	Will	Will	NNP
22283	919	20	;	;	:
22283	919	21	for	for	IN
22283	919	22	,	,	,
22283	919	23	according	accord	VBG
22283	919	24	to	to	IN
22283	919	25	this	this	DT
22283	919	26	theory	theory	NN
22283	919	27	,	,	,
22283	919	28	mental	mental	JJ
22283	919	29	processes	process	NNS
22283	919	30	are	be	VBP
22283	919	31	one	one	CD
22283	919	32	and	and	CC
22283	919	33	the	the	DT
22283	919	34	same	same	JJ
22283	919	35	with	with	IN
22283	919	36	physical	physical	JJ
22283	919	37	processes	process	NNS
22283	919	38	,	,	,
22283	919	39	and	and	CC
22283	919	40	hence	hence	RB
22283	919	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	919	42	does	do	VBZ
22283	919	43	not	not	RB
22283	919	44	appear	appear	VB
22283	919	45	that	that	IN
22283	919	46	the	the	DT
22283	919	47	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	919	48	of	of	IN
22283	919	49	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	919	50	could	could	MD
22283	919	51	well	well	RB
22283	919	52	be	be	VB
22283	919	53	taught	teach	VBN
22283	919	54	in	in	IN
22283	919	55	a	a	DT
22283	919	56	manner	manner	NN
22283	919	57	more	more	RBR
22283	919	58	emphatic	emphatic	JJ
22283	919	59	.	.	.
22283	920	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	920	2	far	far	RB
22283	920	3	,	,	,
22283	920	4	then	then	RB
22283	920	5	,	,	,
22283	920	6	the	the	DT
22283	920	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	920	8	of	of	IN
22283	920	9	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	920	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	920	11	seen	see	VBN
22283	920	12	to	to	TO
22283	920	13	be	be	VB
22283	920	14	victorious	victorious	JJ
22283	920	15	over	over	IN
22283	920	16	the	the	DT
22283	920	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	920	18	of	of	IN
22283	920	19	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	920	20	all	all	RB
22283	920	21	along	along	IN
22283	920	22	the	the	DT
22283	920	23	line	line	NN
22283	920	24	.	.	.
22283	921	1	By	by	IN
22283	921	2	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	921	3	the	the	DT
22283	921	4	question	question	NN
22283	921	5	of	of	IN
22283	921	6	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	921	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	921	8	excluded	exclude	VBN
22283	921	9	_	_	NNP
22283	921	10	ab	ab	NNP
22283	921	11	initio	initio	NNP
22283	921	12	_	_	NNP
22283	921	13	;	;	:
22283	921	14	by	by	IN
22283	921	15	Spiritualism	spiritualism	NN
22283	921	16	and	and	CC
22283	921	17	by	by	IN
22283	921	18	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	921	19	,	,	,
22283	921	20	so	so	RB
22283	921	21	far	far	RB
22283	921	22	as	as	IN
22283	921	23	yet	yet	RB
22283	921	24	seen	see	VBN
22283	921	25	,	,	,
22283	921	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	921	27	can	can	MD
22283	921	28	be	be	VB
22283	921	29	logically	logically	RB
22283	921	30	answered	answer	VBN
22283	921	31	only	only	RB
22283	921	32	in	in	IN
22283	921	33	the	the	DT
22283	921	34	negative	negative	NN
22283	921	35	.	.	.
22283	922	1	From	from	IN
22283	922	2	which	which	WDT
22283	922	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	922	4	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	922	5	that	that	IN
22283	922	6	the	the	DT
22283	922	7	sense	sense	NN
22283	922	8	of	of	IN
22283	922	9	moral	moral	JJ
22283	922	10	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	922	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	922	12	of	of	IN
22283	922	13	the	the	DT
22283	922	14	nature	nature	NN
22283	922	15	of	of	IN
22283	922	16	a	a	DT
22283	922	17	vast	vast	JJ
22283	922	18	illusion	illusion	NN
22283	922	19	,	,	,
22283	922	20	the	the	DT
22283	922	21	historical	historical	JJ
22283	922	22	genesis	genesis	NN
22283	922	23	of	of	IN
22283	922	24	which	which	WDT
22283	922	25	admits	admit	NNS
22283	922	26	of	of	IN
22283	922	27	being	be	VBG
22283	922	28	easily	easily	RB
22283	922	29	traced	trace	VBN
22283	922	30	,	,	,
22283	922	31	and	and	CC
22283	922	32	the	the	DT
22283	922	33	authority	authority	NN
22283	922	34	of	of	IN
22283	922	35	which	which	WDT
22283	922	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	922	37	thus	thus	RB
22283	922	38	destroyed	destroy	VBN
22283	922	39	.	.	.
22283	923	1	Although	although	IN
22283	923	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	923	3	may	may	MD
22283	923	4	still	still	RB
22283	923	5	serve	serve	VB
22283	923	6	to	to	TO
22283	923	7	supply	supply	VB
22283	923	8	motives	motive	NNS
22283	923	9	to	to	TO
22283	923	10	conduct	conduct	VB
22283	923	11	,	,	,
22283	923	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	923	13	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	923	14	that	that	IN
22283	923	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	923	16	can	can	MD
22283	923	17	do	do	VB
22283	923	18	so	so	RB
22283	923	19	only	only	RB
22283	923	20	in	in	IN
22283	923	21	the	the	DT
22283	923	22	way	way	NN
22283	923	23	that	that	WDT
22283	923	24	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	923	25	to	to	TO
22283	923	26	superstition	superstition	NN
22283	923	27	--	--	:
22283	923	28	that	that	IN
22283	923	29	Conscience	Conscience	NNP
22283	923	30	,	,	,
22283	923	31	as	as	IN
22283	923	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	923	33	have	have	VBP
22283	923	34	before	before	RB
22283	923	35	said	say	VBN
22283	923	36	,	,	,
22283	923	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	923	38	the	the	DT
22283	923	39	bogey	bogey	NN
22283	923	40	of	of	IN
22283	923	41	mankind	mankind	NN
22283	923	42	,	,	,
22283	923	43	and	and	CC
22283	923	44	that	that	DT
22283	923	45	belief	belief	NN
22283	923	46	in	in	IN
22283	923	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	923	48	authority	authority	NN
22283	923	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	923	50	like	like	IN
22283	923	51	belief	belief	NN
22283	923	52	in	in	IN
22283	923	53	witchcraft	witchcraft	NN
22283	923	54	,	,	,
22283	923	55	destined	destine	VBN
22283	923	56	to	to	TO
22283	923	57	dwindle	dwindle	VB
22283	923	58	and	and	CC
22283	923	59	to	to	TO
22283	923	60	fade	fade	VB
22283	923	61	before	before	IN
22283	923	62	the	the	DT
22283	923	63	advance	advance	NN
22283	923	64	of	of	IN
22283	923	65	a	a	DT
22283	923	66	better	well	JJR
22283	923	67	or	or	CC
22283	923	68	more	more	RBR
22283	923	69	complete	complete	JJ
22283	923	70	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	923	71	of	of	IN
22283	923	72	natural	natural	JJ
22283	923	73	causation	causation	NN
22283	923	74	.	.	.
22283	924	1	But	but	CC
22283	924	2	the	the	DT
22283	924	3	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	924	4	must	must	MD
22283	924	5	not	not	RB
22283	924	6	end	end	VB
22283	924	7	here	here	RB
22283	924	8	.	.	.
22283	925	1	Hitherto	Hitherto	NNP
22283	925	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	925	3	have	have	VBP
22283	925	4	presented	present	VBN
22283	925	5	the	the	DT
22283	925	6	case	case	NN
22283	925	7	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	925	8	_	_	NNP
22283	925	9	versus	versus	IN
22283	925	10	_	_	NNP
22283	925	11	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
22283	925	12	with	with	IN
22283	925	13	all	all	PDT
22283	925	14	the	the	DT
22283	925	15	impartiality	impartiality	NN
22283	925	16	of	of	IN
22283	925	17	which	which	WDT
22283	925	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	925	19	am	be	VBP
22283	925	20	capable	capable	JJ
22283	925	21	;	;	:
22283	925	22	but	but	CC
22283	925	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	925	24	have	have	VBP
22283	925	25	done	do	VBN
22283	925	26	so	so	RB
22283	925	27	without	without	IN
22283	925	28	travelling	travel	VBG
22283	925	29	an	an	DT
22283	925	30	inch	inch	NN
22283	925	31	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	925	32	those	those	DT
22283	925	33	limits	limit	NNS
22283	925	34	of	of	IN
22283	925	35	discussion	discussion	NN
22283	925	36	within	within	IN
22283	925	37	which	which	WDT
22283	925	38	the	the	DT
22283	925	39	question	question	NN
22283	925	40	has	have	VBZ
22283	925	41	been	be	VBN
22283	925	42	debated	debate	VBN
22283	925	43	by	by	IN
22283	925	44	previous	previous	JJ
22283	925	45	writers	writer	NNS
22283	925	46	.	.	.
22283	926	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	926	2	believe	believe	VBP
22283	926	3	,	,	,
22283	926	4	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	926	5	,	,	,
22283	926	6	that	that	IN
22283	926	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	926	8	have	have	VBP
22283	926	9	pointed	point	VBN
22283	926	10	out	out	RP
22283	926	11	several	several	JJ
22283	926	12	important	important	JJ
22283	926	13	oversights	oversight	NNS
22283	926	14	which	which	WDT
22283	926	15	have	have	VBP
22283	926	16	been	be	VBN
22283	926	17	made	make	VBN
22283	926	18	on	on	IN
22283	926	19	both	both	DT
22283	926	20	sides	side	NNS
22283	926	21	of	of	IN
22283	926	22	the	the	DT
22283	926	23	question	question	NN
22283	926	24	;	;	:
22283	926	25	but	but	CC
22283	926	26	in	in	IN
22283	926	27	doing	do	VBG
22283	926	28	this	this	DT
22283	926	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	926	30	have	have	VBP
22283	926	31	not	not	RB
22283	926	32	gone	go	VBN
22283	926	33	further	further	RB
22283	926	34	than	than	IN
22283	926	35	the	the	DT
22283	926	36	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	926	37	basis	basis	NN
22283	926	38	upon	upon	IN
22283	926	39	which	which	WDT
22283	926	40	the	the	DT
22283	926	41	question	question	NN
22283	926	42	has	have	VBZ
22283	926	43	been	be	VBN
22283	926	44	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
22283	926	45	argued	argue	VBN
22283	926	46	.	.	.
22283	927	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	927	2	object	object	NN
22283	927	3	,	,	,
22283	927	4	however	however	RB
22283	927	5	,	,	,
22283	927	6	in	in	IN
22283	927	7	publishing	publish	VBG
22283	927	8	these	these	DT
22283	927	9	papers	paper	NNS
22283	927	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	927	11	not	not	RB
22283	927	12	that	that	DT
22283	927	13	of	of	IN
22283	927	14	destructive	destructive	JJ
22283	927	15	criticism	criticism	NN
22283	927	16	;	;	:
22283	927	17	and	and	CC
22283	927	18	what	what	WP
22283	927	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	927	20	have	have	VBP
22283	927	21	done	do	VBN
22283	927	22	in	in	IN
22283	927	23	this	this	DT
22283	927	24	direction	direction	NN
22283	927	25	has	have	VBZ
22283	927	26	been	be	VBN
22283	927	27	done	do	VBN
22283	927	28	only	only	RB
22283	927	29	in	in	IN
22283	927	30	order	order	NN
22283	927	31	to	to	TO
22283	927	32	prepare	prepare	VB
22283	927	33	the	the	DT
22283	927	34	way	way	NN
22283	927	35	for	for	IN
22283	927	36	what	what	WP
22283	927	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	927	38	now	now	RB
22283	927	39	to	to	TO
22283	927	40	follow	follow	VB
22283	927	41	.	.	.
22283	928	1	Having	have	VBG
22283	928	2	shown	show	VBN
22283	928	3	,	,	,
22283	928	4	as	as	IN
22283	928	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	928	6	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	928	7	to	to	IN
22283	928	8	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	928	9	conclusively	conclusively	RB
22283	928	10	,	,	,
22283	928	11	that	that	IN
22283	928	12	upon	upon	IN
22283	928	13	both	both	CC
22283	928	14	the	the	DT
22283	928	15	rival	rival	JJ
22283	928	16	theories	theory	NNS
22283	928	17	of	of	IN
22283	928	18	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	928	19	and	and	CC
22283	928	20	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	928	21	--	--	:
22283	928	22	the	the	DT
22283	928	23	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	928	24	of	of	IN
22283	928	25	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	928	26	,	,	,
22283	928	27	and	and	CC
22283	928	28	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	928	29	of	of	IN
22283	928	30	Moral	Moral	NNP
22283	928	31	Responsibility	Responsibility	NNP
22283	928	32	--	--	:
22283	928	33	must	must	MD
22283	928	34	logically	logically	RB
22283	928	35	fall	fall	VB
22283	928	36	,	,	,
22283	928	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	928	38	now	now	RB
22283	928	39	hope	hope	VBP
22283	928	40	to	to	TO
22283	928	41	show	show	VB
22283	928	42	that	that	IN
22283	928	43	this	this	DT
22283	928	44	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	928	45	admits	admit	NNS
22283	928	46	of	of	IN
22283	928	47	being	be	VBG
22283	928	48	re	re	VBN
22283	928	49	-	-	VBN
22283	928	50	established	establish	VBN
22283	928	51	on	on	IN
22283	928	52	a	a	DT
22283	928	53	basis	basis	NN
22283	928	54	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	928	55	by	by	IN
22283	928	56	the	the	DT
22283	928	57	theory	theory	NN
22283	928	58	of	of	IN
22283	928	59	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	928	60	.	.	.
22283	929	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	929	2	often	often	RB
22283	929	3	happens	happen	VBZ
22283	929	4	that	that	IN
22283	929	5	an	an	DT
22283	929	6	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
22283	929	7	structure	structure	NN
22283	929	8	of	of	IN
22283	929	9	argument	argument	NN
22283	929	10	,	,	,
22283	929	11	which	which	WDT
22283	929	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	929	13	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	929	14	sound	sound	JJ
22283	929	15	and	and	CC
22283	929	16	complete	complete	JJ
22283	929	17	upon	upon	IN
22283	929	18	the	the	DT
22283	929	19	basis	basis	NN
22283	929	20	furnished	furnish	VBN
22283	929	21	by	by	IN
22283	929	22	a	a	DT
22283	929	23	given	give	VBN
22283	929	24	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	929	25	,	,	,
22283	929	26	admits	admit	NNS
22283	929	27	of	of	IN
22283	929	28	being	be	VBG
22283	929	29	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	929	30	disintegrated	disintegrate	VBN
22283	929	31	when	when	WRB
22283	929	32	the	the	DT
22283	929	33	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	929	34	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	929	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	929	36	shown	show	VBN
22283	929	37	to	to	TO
22283	929	38	be	be	VB
22283	929	39	either	either	CC
22283	929	40	provisional	provisional	JJ
22283	929	41	or	or	CC
22283	929	42	untrue	untrue	JJ
22283	929	43	.	.	.
22283	930	1	And	and	CC
22283	930	2	such	such	JJ
22283	930	3	,	,	,
22283	930	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	930	5	believe	believe	VBP
22283	930	6	,	,	,
22283	930	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	930	8	the	the	DT
22283	930	9	case	case	NN
22283	930	10	with	with	IN
22283	930	11	the	the	DT
22283	930	12	issue	issue	NN
22283	930	13	now	now	RB
22283	930	14	before	before	IN
22283	930	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	930	16	.	.	.
22283	931	1	For	for	IN
22283	931	2	the	the	DT
22283	931	3	issue	issue	NN
22283	931	4	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	931	5	_	_	NNP
22283	931	6	versus	versus	IN
22283	931	7	_	_	NNP
22283	931	8	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
22283	931	9	has	have	VBZ
22283	931	10	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
22283	931	11	been	be	VBN
22283	931	12	argued	argue	VBN
22283	931	13	on	on	IN
22283	931	14	the	the	DT
22283	931	15	common	common	JJ
22283	931	16	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	931	17	that	that	IN
22283	931	18	natural	natural	JJ
22283	931	19	causation	causation	NN
22283	931	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	931	21	not	not	RB
22283	931	22	merely	merely	RB
22283	931	23	the	the	DT
22283	931	24	most	most	RBS
22283	931	25	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	931	26	principle	principle	NN
22283	931	27	which	which	WDT
22283	931	28	the	the	DT
22283	931	29	human	human	JJ
22283	931	30	mind	mind	NN
22283	931	31	can	can	MD
22283	931	32	reach	reach	VB
22283	931	33	;	;	:
22283	931	34	but	but	CC
22283	931	35	also	also	RB
22283	931	36	a	a	DT
22283	931	37	principle	principle	NN
22283	931	38	which	which	WDT
22283	931	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	931	40	,	,	,
22283	931	41	in	in	IN
22283	931	42	some	some	DT
22283	931	43	way	way	NN
22283	931	44	or	or	CC
22283	931	45	another	another	DT
22283	931	46	,	,	,
22283	931	47	external	external	JJ
22283	931	48	to	to	IN
22283	931	49	that	that	DT
22283	931	50	mind	mind	NN
22283	931	51	.	.	.
22283	932	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	932	2	has	have	VBZ
22283	932	3	been	be	VBN
22283	932	4	taken	take	VBN
22283	932	5	for	for	IN
22283	932	6	granted	grant	VBN
22283	932	7	by	by	IN
22283	932	8	both	both	DT
22283	932	9	sides	side	NNS
22283	932	10	in	in	IN
22283	932	11	the	the	DT
22283	932	12	controversy	controversy	NN
22283	932	13	that	that	IN
22283	932	14	if	if	IN
22283	932	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	932	16	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	932	17	can	can	MD
22283	932	18	be	be	VB
22283	932	19	proved	prove	VBN
22283	932	20	to	to	TO
22283	932	21	depend	depend	VB
22283	932	22	upon	upon	IN
22283	932	23	natural	natural	JJ
22283	932	24	causation	causation	NN
22283	932	25	,	,	,
22283	932	26	as	as	IN
22283	932	27	rigid	rigid	JJ
22283	932	28	in	in	IN
22283	932	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	932	30	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	932	31	within	within	IN
22283	932	32	the	the	DT
22283	932	33	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	932	34	of	of	IN
22283	932	35	a	a	DT
22283	932	36	human	human	JJ
22283	932	37	mind	mind	NN
22283	932	38	as	as	IN
22283	932	39	within	within	IN
22283	932	40	that	that	DT
22283	932	41	of	of	IN
22283	932	42	a	a	DT
22283	932	43	calculating	calculate	VBG
22283	932	44	machine	machine	NN
22283	932	45	,	,	,
22283	932	46	there	there	EX
22283	932	47	must	must	MD
22283	932	48	be	be	VB
22283	932	49	an	an	DT
22283	932	50	end	end	NN
22283	932	51	of	of	IN
22283	932	52	the	the	DT
22283	932	53	controversy	controversy	NN
22283	932	54	;	;	,
22283	932	55	seeing	see	VBG
22283	932	56	that	that	IN
22283	932	57	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	932	58	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	932	59	would	would	MD
22283	932	60	be	be	VB
22283	932	61	thus	thus	RB
22283	932	62	proved	prove	VBN
22283	932	63	to	to	TO
22283	932	64	be	be	VB
22283	932	65	rigidly	rigidly	RB
22283	932	66	determined	determine	VBN
22283	932	67	by	by	IN
22283	932	68	those	those	DT
22283	932	69	same	same	JJ
22283	932	70	principles	principle	NNS
22283	932	71	of	of	IN
22283	932	72	fixed	fix	VBN
22283	932	73	order	order	NN
22283	932	74	,	,	,
22283	932	75	or	or	CC
22283	932	76	'	'	``
22283	932	77	natural	natural	JJ
22283	932	78	law	law	NN
22283	932	79	,	,	,
22283	932	80	'	'	''
22283	932	81	which	which	WDT
22283	932	82	are	be	VBP
22283	932	83	external	external	JJ
22283	932	84	to	to	IN
22283	932	85	,	,	,
22283	932	86	or	or	CC
22283	932	87	independent	independent	JJ
22283	932	88	of	of	IN
22283	932	89	,	,	,
22283	932	90	the	the	DT
22283	932	91	human	human	JJ
22283	932	92	mind	mind	NN
22283	932	93	--	--	:
22283	932	94	quite	quite	RB
22283	932	95	as	as	RB
22283	932	96	much	much	RB
22283	932	97	as	as	IN
22283	932	98	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	932	99	are	be	VBP
22283	932	100	external	external	JJ
22283	932	101	to	to	IN
22283	932	102	,	,	,
22283	932	103	or	or	CC
22283	932	104	independent	independent	JJ
22283	932	105	of	of	IN
22283	932	106	,	,	,
22283	932	107	the	the	DT
22283	932	108	calculating	calculate	VBG
22283	932	109	machine	machine	NN
22283	932	110	.	.	.
22283	933	1	Now	now	RB
22283	933	2	,	,	,
22283	933	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	933	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	933	5	this	this	DT
22283	933	6	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	933	7	which	which	WDT
22283	933	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	933	9	challenge	challenge	VBP
22283	933	10	.	.	.
22283	934	1	The	the	DT
22283	934	2	theory	theory	NN
22283	934	3	of	of	IN
22283	934	4	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	934	5	entitles	entitle	VBZ
22283	934	6	one	one	NN
22283	934	7	to	to	TO
22283	934	8	deny	deny	VB
22283	934	9	that	that	IN
22283	934	10	when	when	WRB
22283	934	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	934	12	have	have	VBP
22283	934	13	driven	drive	VBN
22283	934	14	the	the	DT
22283	934	15	question	question	NN
22283	934	16	down	down	RP
22283	934	17	to	to	IN
22283	934	18	the	the	DT
22283	934	19	granite	granite	NN
22283	934	20	bed	bed	NN
22283	934	21	of	of	IN
22283	934	22	natural	natural	JJ
22283	934	23	causation	causation	NN
22283	934	24	,	,	,
22283	934	25	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	934	26	more	more	JJR
22283	934	27	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	934	28	to	to	TO
22283	934	29	be	be	VB
22283	934	30	done	do	VBN
22283	934	31	;	;	:
22283	934	32	according	accord	VBG
22283	934	33	to	to	IN
22283	934	34	this	this	DT
22283	934	35	theory	theory	NN
22283	934	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	934	37	still	still	RB
22283	934	38	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	934	39	to	to	TO
22283	934	40	be	be	VB
22283	934	41	asked	ask	VBN
22283	934	42	,	,	,
22283	934	43	What	what	WP
22283	934	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	934	45	the	the	DT
22283	934	46	nature	nature	NN
22283	934	47	of	of	IN
22283	934	48	this	this	DT
22283	934	49	natural	natural	JJ
22283	934	50	causation	causation	NN
22283	934	51	?	?	.
22283	935	1	Is	be	VBZ
22283	935	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	935	3	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	935	4	the	the	DT
22283	935	5	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	935	6	datum	datum	NN
22283	935	7	of	of	IN
22283	935	8	experience	experience	NN
22283	935	9	,	,	,
22283	935	10	below	below	IN
22283	935	11	which	which	WDT
22283	935	12	the	the	DT
22283	935	13	human	human	JJ
22283	935	14	mind	mind	NN
22283	935	15	can	can	MD
22283	935	16	not	not	RB
22283	935	17	go	go	VB
22283	935	18	?	?	.
22283	936	1	And	and	CC
22283	936	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	936	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	936	4	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	936	5	so	so	RB
22283	936	6	far	far	RB
22283	936	7	external	external	JJ
22283	936	8	to	to	IN
22283	936	9	,	,	,
22283	936	10	or	or	CC
22283	936	11	independent	independent	JJ
22283	936	12	of	of	IN
22283	936	13	,	,	,
22283	936	14	the	the	DT
22283	936	15	human	human	JJ
22283	936	16	mind	mind	NN
22283	936	17	,	,	,
22283	936	18	that	that	IN
22283	936	19	the	the	DT
22283	936	20	latter	latter	JJ
22283	936	21	stands	stand	VBZ
22283	936	22	to	to	IN
22283	936	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	936	24	in	in	IN
22283	936	25	the	the	DT
22283	936	26	relation	relation	NN
22283	936	27	of	of	IN
22283	936	28	a	a	DT
22283	936	29	slave	slave	NN
22283	936	30	to	to	IN
22283	936	31	a	a	DT
22283	936	32	master	master	NN
22283	936	33	--	--	:
22283	936	34	coerced	coerce	VBD
22283	936	35	as	as	IN
22283	936	36	to	to	IN
22283	936	37	action	action	NN
22283	936	38	by	by	IN
22283	936	39	the	the	DT
22283	936	40	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	936	41	which	which	WDT
22283	936	42	that	that	DT
22283	936	43	master	master	NN
22283	936	44	has	have	VBZ
22283	936	45	laid	lay	VBN
22283	936	46	down	down	RP
22283	936	47	?	?	.
22283	937	1	Now	now	RB
22283	937	2	these	these	DT
22283	937	3	questions	question	NNS
22283	937	4	are	be	VBP
22283	937	5	all	all	DT
22283	937	6	virtually	virtually	RB
22283	937	7	answered	answer	VBN
22283	937	8	in	in	IN
22283	937	9	the	the	DT
22283	937	10	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
22283	937	11	by	by	IN
22283	937	12	the	the	DT
22283	937	13	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	937	14	theory	theory	NN
22283	937	15	of	of	IN
22283	937	16	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	937	17	.	.	.
22283	938	1	For	for	IN
22283	938	2	the	the	DT
22283	938	3	Will	Will	NNP
22283	938	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	938	5	here	here	RB
22283	938	6	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	938	7	as	as	IN
22283	938	8	an	an	DT
22283	938	9	agent	agent	NN
22283	938	10	bound	bind	VBN
22283	938	11	to	to	TO
22283	938	12	act	act	VB
22283	938	13	in	in	IN
22283	938	14	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	938	15	with	with	IN
22283	938	16	those	those	DT
22283	938	17	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	938	18	of	of	IN
22283	938	19	external	external	JJ
22283	938	20	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	938	21	which	which	WDT
22283	938	22	dualism	dualism	NN
22283	938	23	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
22283	938	24	as	as	IN
22283	938	25	natural	natural	JJ
22283	938	26	causation	causation	NN
22283	938	27	.	.	.
22283	939	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	939	2	internal	internal	JJ
22283	939	3	causation	causation	NN
22283	939	4	thus	thus	RB
22283	939	5	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	939	6	but	but	CC
22283	939	7	the	the	DT
22283	939	8	reflex	reflex	NN
22283	939	9	of	of	IN
22283	939	10	external	external	JJ
22283	939	11	;	;	:
22283	939	12	and	and	CC
22283	939	13	the	the	DT
22283	939	14	reflection	reflection	NN
22283	939	15	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	939	16	known	know	VBN
22283	939	17	internally	internally	RB
22283	939	18	as	as	IN
22283	939	19	the	the	DT
22283	939	20	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	939	21	of	of	IN
22283	939	22	motive	motive	NN
22283	939	23	.	.	.
22283	940	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	940	2	,	,	,
22283	940	3	the	the	DT
22283	940	4	Will	Will	NNP
22283	940	5	can	can	MD
22283	940	6	not	not	RB
22283	940	7	be	be	VB
22283	940	8	philosophically	philosophically	RB
22283	940	9	liberated	liberate	VBN
22283	940	10	from	from	IN
22283	940	11	the	the	DT
22283	940	12	toils	toil	NNS
22283	940	13	of	of	IN
22283	940	14	this	this	DT
22283	940	15	external	external	JJ
22283	940	16	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	940	17	,	,	,
22283	940	18	so	so	RB
22283	940	19	long	long	RB
22283	940	20	as	as	IN
22283	940	21	dualism	dualism	NN
22283	940	22	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
22283	940	23	that	that	IN
22283	940	24	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	940	25	as	as	IN
22283	940	26	existing	exist	VBG
22283	940	27	independently	independently	RB
22283	940	28	of	of	IN
22283	940	29	the	the	DT
22283	940	30	Will	Will	NNP
22283	940	31	,	,	,
22283	940	32	and	and	CC
22283	940	33	thus	thus	RB
22283	940	34	imposing	impose	VBG
22283	940	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	940	36	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	940	37	on	on	IN
22283	940	38	volitional	volitional	JJ
22283	940	39	activity	activity	NN
22283	940	40	.	.	.
22283	941	1	But	but	CC
22283	941	2	the	the	DT
22283	941	3	theory	theory	NN
22283	941	4	of	of	IN
22283	941	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	941	6	,	,	,
22283	941	7	by	by	IN
22283	941	8	identifying	identify	VBG
22283	941	9	external	external	JJ
22283	941	10	with	with	IN
22283	941	11	internal	internal	JJ
22283	941	12	causation	causation	NN
22283	941	13	--	--	:
22283	941	14	or	or	CC
22283	941	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	941	16	processes	process	NNS
22283	941	17	with	with	IN
22283	941	18	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	941	19	processes	process	NNS
22283	941	20	--	--	:
22283	941	21	philosophically	philosophically	RB
22283	941	22	saves	save	VBZ
22283	941	23	the	the	DT
22283	941	24	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	941	25	of	of	IN
22283	941	26	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	941	27	,	,	,
22283	941	28	and	and	CC
22283	941	29	with	with	IN
22283	941	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	941	31	the	the	DT
22283	941	32	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	941	33	of	of	IN
22283	941	34	moral	moral	JJ
22283	941	35	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	941	36	.	.	.
22283	942	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
22283	942	2	,	,	,
22283	942	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	942	4	does	do	VBZ
22283	942	5	so	so	RB
22283	942	6	without	without	IN
22283	942	7	relying	rely	VBG
22283	942	8	upon	upon	IN
22283	942	9	any	any	DT
22283	942	10	precarious	precarious	JJ
22283	942	11	appeal	appeal	NN
22283	942	12	to	to	IN
22283	942	13	the	the	DT
22283	942	14	direct	direct	JJ
22283	942	15	testimony	testimony	NN
22283	942	16	of	of	IN
22283	942	17	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	942	18	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	942	19	.	.	.
22283	943	1	As	as	IN
22283	943	2	this	this	DT
22283	943	3	view	view	NN
22283	943	4	of	of	IN
22283	943	5	the	the	DT
22283	943	6	subject	subject	NN
22283	943	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	943	8	one	one	CD
22283	943	9	by	by	IN
22283	943	10	no	no	DT
22283	943	11	means	means	NN
22283	943	12	easy	easy	JJ
22283	943	13	of	of	IN
22283	943	14	apprehension	apprehension	NN
22283	943	15	,	,	,
22283	943	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	943	17	will	will	MD
22283	943	18	endeavour	endeavour	VB
22283	943	19	to	to	TO
22283	943	20	unfold	unfold	VB
22283	943	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	943	22	part	part	NN
22283	943	23	by	by	IN
22283	943	24	part	part	NN
22283	943	25	.	.	.
22283	944	1	To	to	TO
22283	944	2	begin	begin	VB
22283	944	3	with	with	IN
22283	944	4	,	,	,
22283	944	5	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	944	6	excludes	exclude	VBZ
22283	944	7	the	the	DT
22283	944	8	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	944	9	of	of	IN
22283	944	10	volition	volition	NN
22283	944	11	being	be	VBG
22283	944	12	determined	determine	VBN
22283	944	13	by	by	IN
22283	944	14	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	944	15	.	.	.
22283	945	1	Let	let	VB
22283	945	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	945	3	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	945	4	,	,	,
22283	945	5	for	for	IN
22283	945	6	example	example	NN
22283	945	7	,	,	,
22283	945	8	that	that	IN
22283	945	9	a	a	DT
22283	945	10	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	945	11	of	of	IN
22283	945	12	ideas	idea	NNS
22283	945	13	,	,	,
22283	945	14	_	_	NNP
22283	945	15	A	A	NNP
22283	945	16	,	,	,
22283	945	17	B	B	NNP
22283	945	18	,	,	,
22283	945	19	C	C	NNP
22283	945	20	,	,	,
22283	945	21	D	D	NNP
22283	945	22	_	_	NNP
22283	945	23	,	,	,
22283	945	24	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	945	25	in	in	IN
22283	945	26	the	the	DT
22283	945	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	945	28	,	,	,
22283	945	29	which	which	WDT
22283	945	30	on	on	IN
22283	945	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	945	32	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	945	33	or	or	CC
22283	945	34	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	945	35	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	945	36	may	may	MD
22283	945	37	be	be	VB
22283	945	38	represented	represent	VBN
22283	945	39	by	by	IN
22283	945	40	the	the	DT
22283	945	41	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	945	42	_	_	NNP
22283	945	43	a	a	NNP
22283	945	44	,	,	,
22283	945	45	b	b	NN
22283	945	46	,	,	,
22283	945	47	c	c	NNP
22283	945	48	,	,	,
22283	945	49	d	d	NNP
22283	945	50	_	_	NNP
22283	945	51	.	.	.
22283	946	1	Here	here	RB
22283	946	2	the	the	DT
22283	946	3	parallelism	parallelism	NN
22283	946	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	946	5	not	not	RB
22283	946	6	due	due	JJ
22283	946	7	,	,	,
22283	946	8	as	as	IN
22283	946	9	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	946	10	by	by	IN
22283	946	11	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	946	12	,	,	,
22283	946	13	to	to	IN
22283	946	14	_	_	NNP
22283	946	15	a	a	DT
22283	946	16	_	_	NNP
22283	946	17	determining	determine	VBG
22283	946	18	_	_	NNP
22283	946	19	Ab	Ab	NNP
22283	946	20	_	_	NNP
22283	946	21	,	,	,
22283	946	22	_	_	NNP
22283	946	23	b	b	NNP
22283	946	24	_	_	NNP
22283	946	25	determining	determine	VBG
22283	946	26	_	_	NNP
22283	946	27	Bc	Bc	NNP
22283	946	28	_	_	NNP
22283	946	29	,	,	,
22283	946	30	&	&	CC
22283	946	31	c.	c.	NNP
22283	946	32	;	;	:
22283	946	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	946	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	946	35	due	due	JJ
22283	946	36	to	to	IN
22283	946	37	_	_	NNP
22283	946	38	Aa	Aa	NNP
22283	946	39	_	_	NNP
22283	946	40	determining	determine	VBG
22283	946	41	_	_	NNP
22283	946	42	Bb	Bb	NNP
22283	946	43	_	_	NNP
22283	946	44	,	,	,
22283	946	45	_	_	NNP
22283	946	46	Bb	Bb	NNP
22283	946	47	_	_	NNP
22283	946	48	determining	determine	VBG
22283	946	49	_	_	NNP
22283	946	50	Cc	Cc	NNP
22283	946	51	_	_	NNP
22283	946	52	,	,	,
22283	946	53	&	&	CC
22283	946	54	c.--the	c.--the	NNP
22283	946	55	two	two	CD
22283	946	56	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	946	57	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	946	58	causal	causal	JJ
22283	946	59	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	946	60	being	be	VBG
22283	946	61	really	really	RB
22283	946	62	but	but	CC
22283	946	63	one	one	CD
22283	946	64	causal	causal	JJ
22283	946	65	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	946	66	.	.	.
22283	947	1	If	if	IN
22283	947	2	the	the	DT
22283	947	3	determinist	determinist	NN
22283	947	4	should	should	MD
22283	947	5	rejoin	rejoin	VB
22283	947	6	that	that	IN
22283	947	7	a	a	DT
22283	947	8	causal	causal	JJ
22283	947	9	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	947	10	of	of	IN
22283	947	11	some	some	DT
22283	947	12	kind	kind	NN
22283	947	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	947	14	all	all	DT
22283	947	15	that	that	WDT
22283	947	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	947	17	demands	demand	VBZ
22283	947	18	--	--	:
22283	947	19	that	that	IN
22283	947	20	the	the	DT
22283	947	21	Will	Will	NNP
22283	947	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	947	23	equally	equally	RB
22283	947	24	proved	prove	VBN
22283	947	25	to	to	TO
22283	947	26	be	be	VB
22283	947	27	unfree	unfree	CD
22283	947	28	,	,	,
22283	947	29	whether	whether	IN
22283	947	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	947	31	be	be	VB
22283	947	32	bound	bind	VBN
22283	947	33	by	by	IN
22283	947	34	the	the	DT
22283	947	35	causal	causal	JJ
22283	947	36	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	947	37	_	_	NNP
22283	947	38	a	a	NNP
22283	947	39	,	,	,
22283	947	40	b	b	NN
22283	947	41	,	,	,
22283	947	42	c	c	NNP
22283	947	43	,	,	,
22283	947	44	d	d	NNP
22283	947	45	_	_	NNP
22283	947	46	,	,	,
22283	947	47	or	or	CC
22283	947	48	by	by	IN
22283	947	49	the	the	DT
22283	947	50	causal	causal	JJ
22283	947	51	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	947	52	_	_	NNP
22283	947	53	Aa	Aa	NNP
22283	947	54	,	,	,
22283	947	55	Bb	Bb	NNP
22283	947	56	,	,	,
22283	947	57	Cc	Cc	NNP
22283	947	58	,	,	,
22283	947	59	Dd_--I	Dd_--I	,
22283	947	60	answer	answer	VBP
22283	947	61	that	that	IN
22283	947	62	this	this	DT
22283	947	63	is	be	VBZ
22283	947	64	a	a	DT
22283	947	65	point	point	NN
22283	947	66	which	which	WDT
22283	947	67	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	947	68	have	have	VBP
22283	947	69	to	to	TO
22283	947	70	consider	consider	VB
22283	947	71	by	by	IN
22283	947	72	-	-	HYPH
22283	947	73	and	and	CC
22283	947	74	-	-	HYPH
22283	947	75	by	by	RB
22283	947	76	.	.	.
22283	948	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
22283	948	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	948	3	am	be	VBP
22283	948	4	only	only	RB
22283	948	5	endeavouring	endeavour	VBG
22283	948	6	to	to	TO
22283	948	7	make	make	VB
22283	948	8	clear	clear	JJ
22283	948	9	the	the	DT
22283	948	10	essential	essential	JJ
22283	948	11	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	948	12	between	between	IN
22283	948	13	the	the	DT
22283	948	14	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	948	15	theories	theory	NNS
22283	948	16	of	of	IN
22283	948	17	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	948	18	and	and	CC
22283	948	19	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	948	20	.	.	.
22283	949	1	And	and	CC
22283	949	2	the	the	DT
22283	949	3	effect	effect	NN
22283	949	4	of	of	IN
22283	949	5	this	this	DT
22283	949	6	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	949	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	949	8	to	to	TO
22283	949	9	show	show	VB
22283	949	10	that	that	IN
22283	949	11	,	,	,
22283	949	12	for	for	IN
22283	949	13	the	the	DT
22283	949	14	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	949	15	of	of	IN
22283	949	16	clear	clear	JJ
22283	949	17	analysis	analysis	NN
22283	949	18	,	,	,
22283	949	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	949	20	may	may	MD
22283	949	21	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	949	22	neglect	neglect	VB
22283	949	23	either	either	DT
22283	949	24	side	side	NN
22283	949	25	of	of	IN
22283	949	26	the	the	DT
22283	949	27	double	double	JJ
22283	949	28	reality	reality	NN
22283	949	29	.	.	.
22283	950	1	If	if	IN
22283	950	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	950	3	happen	happen	VBP
22283	950	4	to	to	TO
22283	950	5	be	be	VB
22283	950	6	engaged	engage	VBN
22283	950	7	on	on	IN
22283	950	8	any	any	DT
22283	950	9	physiological	physiological	JJ
22283	950	10	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	950	11	,	,	,
22283	950	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	950	13	may	may	MD
22283	950	14	altogether	altogether	RB
22283	950	15	neglect	neglect	VB
22283	950	16	the	the	DT
22283	950	17	processes	process	NNS
22283	950	18	of	of	IN
22283	950	19	ideation	ideation	NN
22283	950	20	with	with	IN
22283	950	21	which	which	WDT
22283	950	22	any	any	DT
22283	950	23	process	process	NN
22283	950	24	of	of	IN
22283	950	25	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	950	26	may	may	MD
22283	950	27	be	be	VB
22283	950	28	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	950	29	;	;	:
22283	950	30	while	while	IN
22283	950	31	,	,	,
22283	950	32	if	if	IN
22283	950	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	950	34	happen	happen	VBP
22283	950	35	to	to	TO
22283	950	36	be	be	VB
22283	950	37	engaged	engage	VBN
22283	950	38	upon	upon	IN
22283	950	39	any	any	DT
22283	950	40	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	950	41	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	950	42	,	,	,
22283	950	43	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	950	44	may	may	MD
22283	950	45	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	950	46	neglect	neglect	VB
22283	950	47	the	the	DT
22283	950	48	processes	process	NNS
22283	950	49	of	of	IN
22283	950	50	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	950	51	with	with	IN
22283	950	52	which	which	WDT
22283	950	53	any	any	DT
22283	950	54	process	process	NN
22283	950	55	of	of	IN
22283	950	56	ideation	ideation	NN
22283	950	57	may	may	MD
22283	950	58	be	be	VB
22283	950	59	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	950	60	.	.	.
22283	951	1	Seeing	see	VBG
22283	951	2	that	that	IN
22283	951	3	each	each	DT
22283	951	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	951	5	equally	equally	RB
22283	951	6	an	an	DT
22283	951	7	index	index	NN
22283	951	8	of	of	IN
22283	951	9	a	a	DT
22283	951	10	common	common	JJ
22283	951	11	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	951	12	,	,	,
22283	951	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	951	14	can	can	MD
22283	951	15	make	make	VB
22283	951	16	no	no	DT
22283	951	17	difference	difference	NN
22283	951	18	which	which	WDT
22283	951	19	of	of	IN
22283	951	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	951	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	951	22	take	take	VBP
22283	951	23	as	as	IN
22283	951	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	951	25	guide	guide	NN
22283	951	26	,	,	,
22283	951	27	although	although	IN
22283	951	28	for	for	IN
22283	951	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
22283	951	30	of	of	IN
22283	951	31	practical	practical	JJ
22283	951	32	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	951	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	951	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	951	35	of	of	IN
22283	951	36	course	course	NN
22283	951	37	expedient	expedient	NN
22283	951	38	to	to	TO
22283	951	39	take	take	VB
22283	951	40	the	the	DT
22283	951	41	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	951	42	index	index	NN
22283	951	43	when	when	WRB
22283	951	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	951	45	are	be	VBP
22283	951	46	dealing	deal	VBG
22283	951	47	with	with	IN
22283	951	48	the	the	DT
22283	951	49	objective	objective	JJ
22283	951	50	side	side	NN
22283	951	51	of	of	IN
22283	951	52	the	the	DT
22283	951	53	problem	problem	NN
22283	951	54	,	,	,
22283	951	55	and	and	CC
22283	951	56	the	the	DT
22283	951	57	mental	mental	JJ
22283	951	58	index	index	NN
22283	951	59	when	when	WRB
22283	951	60	dealing	deal	VBG
22283	951	61	with	with	IN
22283	951	62	the	the	DT
22283	951	63	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	951	64	.	.	.
22283	952	1	In	in	IN
22283	952	2	the	the	DT
22283	952	3	following	follow	VBG
22283	952	4	pages	page	NNS
22283	952	5	,	,	,
22283	952	6	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	952	7	,	,	,
22283	952	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	952	9	shall	shall	MD
22283	952	10	altogether	altogether	RB
22283	952	11	neglect	neglect	VB
22283	952	12	the	the	DT
22283	952	13	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	952	14	index	index	NN
22283	952	15	.	.	.
22283	953	1	The	the	DT
22283	953	2	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	953	3	on	on	IN
22283	953	4	which	which	WDT
22283	953	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	953	6	are	be	VBP
22283	953	7	engaged	engage	VBN
22283	953	8	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	953	9	to	to	IN
22283	953	10	the	the	DT
22283	953	11	region	region	NN
22283	953	12	of	of	IN
22283	953	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	953	14	,	,	,
22283	953	15	and	and	CC
22283	953	16	,	,	,
22283	953	17	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	953	18	,	,	,
22283	953	19	after	after	IN
22283	953	20	what	what	WP
22283	953	21	has	have	VBZ
22283	953	22	just	just	RB
22283	953	23	been	be	VBN
22283	953	24	said	say	VBN
22283	953	25	,	,	,
22283	953	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	953	27	will	will	MD
22283	953	28	be	be	VB
22283	953	29	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	953	30	that	that	IN
22283	953	31	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	953	32	am	be	VBP
22283	953	33	entitled	entitle	VBN
22283	953	34	to	to	TO
22283	953	35	adopt	adopt	VB
22283	953	36	the	the	DT
22283	953	37	standpoint	standpoint	NN
22283	953	38	of	of	IN
22283	953	39	a	a	DT
22283	953	40	spiritualist	spiritualist	NN
22283	953	41	,	,	,
22283	953	42	to	to	IN
22283	953	43	the	the	DT
22283	953	44	extent	extent	NN
22283	953	45	of	of	IN
22283	953	46	fastening	fasten	VBG
22283	953	47	attention	attention	NN
22283	953	48	only	only	RB
22283	953	49	upon	upon	IN
22283	953	50	the	the	DT
22283	953	51	mental	mental	JJ
22283	953	52	side	side	NN
22283	953	53	of	of	IN
22283	953	54	the	the	DT
22283	953	55	problem	problem	NN
22283	953	56	.	.	.
22283	954	1	For	for	IN
22283	954	2	although	although	IN
22283	954	3	the	the	DT
22283	954	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	954	5	of	of	IN
22283	954	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	954	7	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	954	8	,	,	,
22283	954	9	as	as	IN
22283	954	10	against	against	IN
22283	954	11	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	954	12	,	,	,
22283	954	13	that	that	IN
22283	954	14	no	no	DT
22283	954	15	one	one	CD
22283	954	16	of	of	IN
22283	954	17	the	the	DT
22283	954	18	mental	mental	JJ
22283	954	19	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	954	20	could	could	MD
22283	954	21	take	take	VB
22283	954	22	place	place	NN
22283	954	23	without	without	IN
22283	954	24	a	a	DT
22283	954	25	corresponding	correspond	VBG
22283	954	26	physical	physical	JJ
22283	954	27	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	954	28	,	,	,
22283	954	29	the	the	DT
22283	954	30	theory	theory	NN
22283	954	31	also	also	RB
22283	954	32	teaches	teach	VBZ
22283	954	33	the	the	DT
22283	954	34	converse	converse	NN
22283	954	35	proposition	proposition	NN
22283	954	36	;	;	:
22283	954	37	and	and	CC
22283	954	38	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	954	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	954	40	makes	make	VBZ
22283	954	41	no	no	DT
22283	954	42	difference	difference	NN
22283	954	43	which	which	WDT
22283	954	44	of	of	IN
22283	954	45	the	the	DT
22283	954	46	two	two	CD
22283	954	47	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	954	48	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	954	49	is	be	VBZ
22283	954	50	taken	take	VBN
22283	954	51	as	as	IN
22283	954	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	954	53	index	index	NN
22283	954	54	of	of	IN
22283	954	55	the	the	DT
22283	954	56	ontological	ontological	JJ
22283	954	57	.	.	.
22283	955	1	Now	now	RB
22283	955	2	,	,	,
22283	955	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	955	4	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	955	5	makes	make	VBZ
22283	955	6	a	a	DT
22283	955	7	great	great	JJ
22283	955	8	difference	difference	NN
22283	955	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	955	10	the	the	DT
22283	955	11	mental	mental	JJ
22283	955	12	changes	change	NNS
22283	955	13	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	955	14	in	in	IN
22283	955	15	volition	volition	NN
22283	955	16	are	be	VBP
22283	955	17	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	955	18	as	as	IN
22283	955	19	effects	effect	NNS
22283	955	20	or	or	CC
22283	955	21	as	as	IN
22283	955	22	causes	cause	NNS
22283	955	23	.	.	.
22283	956	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	956	2	to	to	IN
22283	956	3	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	956	4	,	,	,
22283	956	5	the	the	DT
22283	956	6	mental	mental	JJ
22283	956	7	changes	change	NNS
22283	956	8	are	be	VBP
22283	956	9	the	the	DT
22283	956	10	effects	effect	NNS
22283	956	11	of	of	IN
22283	956	12	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	956	13	changes	change	NNS
22283	956	14	,	,	,
22283	956	15	which	which	WDT
22283	956	16	were	be	VBD
22283	956	17	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	956	18	the	the	DT
22283	956	19	effects	effect	NNS
22283	956	20	of	of	IN
22283	956	21	precedent	precedent	NN
22283	956	22	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	956	23	changes	change	NNS
22283	956	24	.	.	.
22283	957	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	957	2	to	to	IN
22283	957	3	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	957	4	,	,	,
22283	957	5	these	these	DT
22283	957	6	mental	mental	JJ
22283	957	7	changes	change	NNS
22283	957	8	are	be	VBP
22283	957	9	the	the	DT
22283	957	10	causes	cause	NNS
22283	957	11	,	,	,
22283	957	12	not	not	RB
22283	957	13	only	only	RB
22283	957	14	of	of	IN
22283	957	15	the	the	DT
22283	957	16	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	957	17	changes	change	NNS
22283	957	18	,	,	,
22283	957	19	but	but	CC
22283	957	20	also	also	RB
22283	957	21	of	of	IN
22283	957	22	one	one	CD
22283	957	23	another	another	DT
22283	957	24	.	.	.
22283	958	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	958	2	to	to	IN
22283	958	3	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	958	4	,	,	,
22283	958	5	the	the	DT
22283	958	6	mental	mental	JJ
22283	958	7	changes	change	NNS
22283	958	8	may	may	MD
22283	958	9	be	be	VB
22283	958	10	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	958	11	as	as	IN
22283	958	12	the	the	DT
22283	958	13	causes	cause	NNS
22283	958	14	of	of	IN
22283	958	15	the	the	DT
22283	958	16	cerebral	cerebral	NN
22283	958	17	,	,	,
22283	958	18	or	or	CC
22283	958	19	_	_	NNP
22283	958	20	vice	vice	NN
22283	958	21	versa	versa	IN
22283	958	22	_	_	NNP
22283	958	23	,	,	,
22283	958	24	seeing	see	VBG
22283	958	25	that	that	IN
22283	958	26	in	in	IN
22283	958	27	neither	neither	DT
22283	958	28	case	case	NN
22283	958	29	are	be	VBP
22283	958	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	958	31	stating	state	VBG
22283	958	32	a	a	DT
22283	958	33	real	real	JJ
22283	958	34	truth	truth	NN
22283	958	35	--	--	:
22283	958	36	the	the	DT
22283	958	37	real	real	JJ
22283	958	38	truth	truth	NN
22283	958	39	being	be	VBG
22283	958	40	that	that	IN
22283	958	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	958	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	958	43	only	only	RB
22283	958	44	a	a	DT
22283	958	45	cerebro	cerebro	NN
22283	958	46	-	-	HYPH
22283	958	47	mental	mental	JJ
22283	958	48	change	change	NN
22283	958	49	which	which	WDT
22283	958	50	can	can	MD
22283	958	51	cause	cause	VB
22283	958	52	any	any	DT
22283	958	53	change	change	NN
22283	958	54	either	either	CC
22283	958	55	of	of	IN
22283	958	56	cerebration	cerebration	NN
22283	958	57	or	or	CC
22283	958	58	of	of	IN
22283	958	59	mentation	mentation	NN
22283	958	60	.	.	.
22283	959	1	Now	now	RB
22283	959	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	959	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	959	4	evident	evident	JJ
22283	959	5	that	that	IN
22283	959	6	if	if	IN
22283	959	7	the	the	DT
22283	959	8	mental	mental	JJ
22283	959	9	processes	process	NNS
22283	959	10	were	be	VBD
22283	959	11	always	always	RB
22283	959	12	the	the	DT
22283	959	13	effects	effect	NNS
22283	959	14	of	of	IN
22283	959	15	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	959	16	processes	process	NNS
22283	959	17	(	(	-LRB-
22283	959	18	Materialism	Materialism	NNP
22283	959	19	)	)	-RRB-
22283	959	20	,	,	,
22283	959	21	there	there	EX
22283	959	22	could	could	MD
22283	959	23	be	be	VB
22283	959	24	no	no	DT
22283	959	25	further	further	JJ
22283	959	26	question	question	NN
22283	959	27	with	with	IN
22283	959	28	regard	regard	NN
22283	959	29	to	to	IN
22283	959	30	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	959	31	and	and	CC
22283	959	32	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
22283	959	33	;	;	:
22283	959	34	while	while	IN
22283	959	35	,	,	,
22283	959	36	if	if	IN
22283	959	37	the	the	DT
22283	959	38	mental	mental	JJ
22283	959	39	processes	process	NNS
22283	959	40	are	be	VBP
22283	959	41	the	the	DT
22283	959	42	causes	cause	NNS
22283	959	43	both	both	DT
22283	959	44	of	of	IN
22283	959	45	the	the	DT
22283	959	46	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	959	47	processes	process	NNS
22283	959	48	and	and	CC
22283	959	49	of	of	IN
22283	959	50	one	one	CD
22283	959	51	another	another	DT
22283	959	52	(	(	-LRB-
22283	959	53	Spiritualism	Spiritualism	NNP
22283	959	54	)	)	-RRB-
22283	959	55	,	,	,
22283	959	56	the	the	DT
22283	959	57	question	question	NN
22283	959	58	before	before	IN
22283	959	59	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	959	60	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	959	61	raised	raise	VBN
22283	959	62	to	to	IN
22283	959	63	a	a	DT
22283	959	64	higher	high	JJR
22283	959	65	level	level	NN
22283	959	66	.	.	.
22283	960	1	The	the	DT
22283	960	2	causality	causality	NN
22283	960	3	in	in	IN
22283	960	4	question	question	NN
22283	960	5	being	be	VBG
22283	960	6	now	now	RB
22283	960	7	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	960	8	as	as	IN
22283	960	9	purely	purely	RB
22283	960	10	mental	mental	JJ
22283	960	11	,	,	,
22283	960	12	the	the	DT
22283	960	13	will	will	NN
22283	960	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	960	15	no	no	RB
22283	960	16	longer	long	RBR
22283	960	17	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	960	18	as	as	IN
22283	960	19	a	a	DT
22283	960	20	passive	passive	JJ
22283	960	21	slave	slave	NN
22283	960	22	of	of	IN
22283	960	23	the	the	DT
22283	960	24	brain	brain	NN
22283	960	25	,	,	,
22283	960	26	and	and	CC
22283	960	27	the	the	DT
22283	960	28	only	only	JJ
22283	960	29	thing	thing	NN
22283	960	30	to	to	TO
22283	960	31	be	be	VB
22283	960	32	considered	consider	VBN
22283	960	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	960	34	whether	whether	IN
22283	960	35	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	960	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	960	37	compatible	compatible	JJ
22283	960	38	with	with	IN
22283	960	39	causation	causation	NN
22283	960	40	of	of	IN
22283	960	41	a	a	DT
22283	960	42	purely	purely	RB
22283	960	43	mental	mental	JJ
22283	960	44	kind	kind	NN
22283	960	45	.	.	.
22283	961	1	Now	now	RB
22283	961	2	,	,	,
22283	961	3	at	at	IN
22283	961	4	an	an	DT
22283	961	5	earlier	early	JJR
22283	961	6	stage	stage	NN
22283	961	7	of	of	IN
22283	961	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	961	9	enquiry	enquiry	NN
22283	961	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	961	11	have	have	VBP
22283	961	12	argued	argue	VBN
22283	961	13	that	that	IN
22283	961	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	961	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	961	16	not	not	RB
22283	961	17	;	;	:
22283	961	18	but	but	CC
22283	961	19	this	this	DT
22283	961	20	argument	argument	NN
22283	961	21	was	be	VBD
22283	961	22	based	base	VBN
22283	961	23	entirely	entirely	RB
22283	961	24	upon	upon	IN
22283	961	25	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	961	26	premises	premise	NNS
22283	961	27	,	,	,
22283	961	28	or	or	CC
22283	961	29	upon	upon	IN
22283	961	30	the	the	DT
22283	961	31	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	961	32	that	that	IN
22283	961	33	the	the	DT
22283	961	34	principle	principle	NN
22283	961	35	of	of	IN
22283	961	36	causality	causality	NN
22283	961	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	961	38	everywhere	everywhere	RB
22283	961	39	external	external	JJ
22283	961	40	to	to	IN
22283	961	41	,	,	,
22283	961	42	or	or	CC
22283	961	43	independent	independent	JJ
22283	961	44	of	of	IN
22283	961	45	,	,	,
22283	961	46	the	the	DT
22283	961	47	human	human	JJ
22283	961	48	mind	mind	NN
22283	961	49	--	--	:
22283	961	50	under	under	IN
22283	961	51	which	which	WDT
22283	961	52	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	961	53	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	961	54	can	can	MD
22283	961	55	not	not	RB
22283	961	56	see	see	VB
22283	961	57	that	that	IN
22283	961	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	961	59	makes	make	VBZ
22283	961	60	much	much	JJ
22283	961	61	difference	difference	NN
22283	961	62	whether	whether	IN
22283	961	63	the	the	DT
22283	961	64	coercion	coercion	NN
22283	961	65	comes	come	VBZ
22283	961	66	from	from	IN
22283	961	67	the	the	DT
22283	961	68	brain	brain	NN
22283	961	69	alone	alone	RB
22283	961	70	,	,	,
22283	961	71	or	or	CC
22283	961	72	from	from	IN
22283	961	73	the	the	DT
22283	961	74	whole	whole	JJ
22283	961	75	general	general	JJ
22283	961	76	system	system	NN
22283	961	77	of	of	IN
22283	961	78	things	thing	NNS
22283	961	79	external	external	JJ
22283	961	80	to	to	IN
22283	961	81	the	the	DT
22283	961	82	human	human	JJ
22283	961	83	mind	mind	NN
22283	961	84	.	.	.
22283	962	1	And	and	CC
22283	962	2	here	here	RB
22283	962	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	962	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	962	5	that	that	IN
22283	962	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	962	7	think	think	VBP
22283	962	8	the	the	DT
22283	962	9	theory	theory	NN
22283	962	10	of	of	IN
22283	962	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	962	12	comes	come	VBZ
22283	962	13	to	to	IN
22283	962	14	the	the	DT
22283	962	15	rescue	rescue	NN
22283	962	16	.	.	.
22283	963	1	For	for	IN
22283	963	2	,	,	,
22283	963	3	if	if	IN
22283	963	4	physical	physical	JJ
22283	963	5	and	and	CC
22283	963	6	mental	mental	JJ
22283	963	7	processes	process	NNS
22283	963	8	are	be	VBP
22283	963	9	everywhere	everywhere	RB
22283	963	10	consubstantial	consubstantial	JJ
22283	963	11	,	,	,
22283	963	12	or	or	CC
22283	963	13	identical	identical	JJ
22283	963	14	in	in	IN
22283	963	15	kind	kind	NN
22283	963	16	,	,	,
22283	963	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	963	18	can	can	MD
22283	963	19	make	make	VB
22283	963	20	no	no	DT
22283	963	21	difference	difference	NN
22283	963	22	whether	whether	IN
22283	963	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	963	24	regard	regard	VBP
22283	963	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	963	26	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	963	27	as	as	IN
22283	963	28	objective	objective	JJ
22283	963	29	or	or	CC
22283	963	30	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	963	31	,	,	,
22283	963	32	physical	physical	JJ
22283	963	33	or	or	CC
22283	963	34	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
22283	963	35	.	.	.
22283	964	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	964	2	,	,	,
22283	964	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	964	4	are	be	VBP
22283	964	5	free	free	JJ
22283	964	6	to	to	TO
22283	964	7	regard	regard	VB
22283	964	8	all	all	DT
22283	964	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	964	10	as	as	IN
22283	964	11	of	of	IN
22283	964	12	a	a	DT
22283	964	13	character	character	NN
22283	964	14	essentially	essentially	RB
22283	964	15	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	964	16	.	.	.
22283	965	1	But	but	CC
22283	965	2	,	,	,
22283	965	3	if	if	IN
22283	965	4	so	so	RB
22283	965	5	,	,	,
22283	965	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	965	7	must	must	MD
22283	965	8	be	be	VB
22283	965	9	self	self	NN
22283	965	10	-	-	HYPH
22283	965	11	contained	contain	VBN
22283	965	12	as	as	IN
22283	965	13	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	965	14	;	;	:
22283	965	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	965	16	can	can	MD
22283	965	17	not	not	RB
22283	965	18	be	be	VB
22283	965	19	in	in	IN
22283	965	20	any	any	DT
22283	965	21	way	way	NN
22283	965	22	determined	determine	VBN
22283	965	23	by	by	IN
22283	965	24	anything	anything	NN
22283	965	25	from	from	IN
22283	965	26	without	without	RB
22283	965	27	,	,	,
22283	965	28	seeing	see	VBG
22283	965	29	that	that	IN
22283	965	30	outside	outside	IN
22283	965	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	965	32	there	there	EX
22283	965	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	965	34	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	965	35	in	in	IN
22283	965	36	the	the	DT
22283	965	37	Universe	Universe	NNP
22283	965	38	.	.	.
22283	966	1	Now	now	RB
22283	966	2	,	,	,
22283	966	3	if	if	IN
22283	966	4	this	this	DT
22283	966	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	966	6	true	true	JJ
22283	966	7	of	of	IN
22283	966	8	the	the	DT
22283	966	9	World	World	NNP
22283	966	10	-	-	HYPH
22283	966	11	eject	eject	NN
22283	966	12	,	,	,
22283	966	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	966	14	must	must	MD
22283	966	15	also	also	RB
22283	966	16	be	be	VB
22283	966	17	true	true	JJ
22283	966	18	of	of	IN
22283	966	19	the	the	DT
22283	966	20	Man	man	NN
22283	966	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	966	22	eject	eject	NN
22283	966	23	,	,	,
22283	966	24	as	as	RB
22283	966	25	well	well	RB
22283	966	26	as	as	IN
22283	966	27	of	of	IN
22283	966	28	the	the	DT
22283	966	29	Man	Man	NNP
22283	966	30	-	-	HYPH
22283	966	31	subject	subject	NN
22283	966	32	,	,	,
22283	966	33	or	or	CC
22283	966	34	Ego	ego	NN
22283	966	35	.	.	.
22283	967	1	If	if	IN
22283	967	2	all	all	DT
22283	967	3	causation	causation	NN
22283	967	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	967	5	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	967	6	,	,	,
22283	967	7	that	that	DT
22283	967	8	portion	portion	NN
22283	967	9	of	of	IN
22283	967	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	967	11	which	which	WDT
22283	967	12	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	967	13	to	to	IN
22283	967	14	,	,	,
22283	967	15	or	or	CC
22283	967	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	967	17	manifested	manifest	VBN
22283	967	18	by	by	IN
22283	967	19	,	,	,
22283	967	20	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	967	21	own	own	JJ
22283	967	22	personality	personality	NN
22283	967	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	967	24	not	not	RB
22283	967	25	laid	lay	VBN
22283	967	26	upon	upon	IN
22283	967	27	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	967	28	by	by	IN
22283	967	29	anything	anything	NN
22283	967	30	from	from	IN
22283	967	31	without	without	IN
22283	967	32	;	;	:
22283	967	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	967	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	967	35	merely	merely	RB
22283	967	36	the	the	DT
22283	967	37	expression	expression	NN
22283	967	38	of	of	IN
22283	967	39	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	967	40	own	own	JJ
22283	967	41	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	967	42	activity	activity	NN
22283	967	43	,	,	,
22283	967	44	as	as	IN
22283	967	45	this	this	DT
22283	967	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	967	47	taking	take	VBG
22283	967	48	place	place	NN
22283	967	49	within	within	IN
22283	967	50	the	the	DT
22283	967	51	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	967	52	area	area	NN
22283	967	53	of	of	IN
22283	967	54	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	967	55	own	own	JJ
22283	967	56	personality	personality	NN
22283	967	57	.	.	.
22283	968	1	And	and	CC
22283	968	2	this	this	DT
22283	968	3	activity	activity	NN
22283	968	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	968	5	spontaneous	spontaneous	JJ
22283	968	6	,	,	,
22283	968	7	in	in	IN
22283	968	8	the	the	DT
22283	968	9	sense	sense	NN
22283	968	10	that	that	IN
22283	968	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	968	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	968	13	not	not	RB
22283	968	14	coerced	coerce	VBN
22283	968	15	from	from	IN
22283	968	16	without	without	IN
22283	968	17	.	.	.
22283	969	1	All	all	PDT
22283	969	2	the	the	DT
22283	969	3	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	969	4	which	which	WDT
22283	969	5	that	that	IN
22283	969	6	activity	activity	NN
22283	969	7	displays	display	VBZ
22283	969	8	within	within	IN
22283	969	9	this	this	DT
22283	969	10	region	region	NN
22283	969	11	are	be	VBP
22283	969	12	self	self	NN
22283	969	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	969	14	determined	determine	VBN
22283	969	15	,	,	,
22283	969	16	in	in	IN
22283	969	17	the	the	DT
22283	969	18	sense	sense	NN
22283	969	19	that	that	IN
22283	969	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	969	21	are	be	VBP
22283	969	22	determined	determine	VBN
22283	969	23	by	by	IN
22283	969	24	the	the	DT
22283	969	25	self	self	NN
22283	969	26	,	,	,
22283	969	27	and	and	CC
22283	969	28	not	not	RB
22283	969	29	by	by	IN
22283	969	30	any	any	DT
22283	969	31	agency	agency	NN
22283	969	32	external	external	JJ
22283	969	33	to	to	IN
22283	969	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	969	35	.	.	.
22283	970	1	The	the	DT
22283	970	2	only	only	JJ
22283	970	3	influence	influence	NN
22283	970	4	which	which	WDT
22283	970	5	any	any	DT
22283	970	6	external	external	JJ
22283	970	7	agency	agency	NN
22283	970	8	can	can	MD
22283	970	9	here	here	RB
22283	970	10	exert	exert	VB
22283	970	11	,	,	,
22283	970	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	970	13	that	that	DT
22283	970	14	of	of	IN
22283	970	15	insisting	insist	VBG
22283	970	16	that	that	IN
22283	970	17	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	970	18	action	action	NN
22283	970	19	--	--	:
22283	970	20	the	the	DT
22283	970	21	physical	physical	JJ
22283	970	22	outcome	outcome	NN
22283	970	23	of	of	IN
22283	970	24	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	970	25	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	970	26	processes	process	NNS
22283	970	27	--	--	:
22283	970	28	shall	shall	MD
22283	970	29	be	be	VB
22283	970	30	in	in	IN
22283	970	31	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	970	32	with	with	IN
22283	970	33	the	the	DT
22283	970	34	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	970	35	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	970	36	by	by	IN
22283	970	37	the	the	DT
22283	970	38	internal	internal	JJ
22283	970	39	system	system	NN
22283	970	40	of	of	IN
22283	970	41	causation	causation	NN
22283	970	42	;	;	:
22283	970	43	but	but	CC
22283	970	44	this	this	DT
22283	970	45	does	do	VBZ
22283	970	46	not	not	RB
22283	970	47	influence	influence	VB
22283	970	48	in	in	IN
22283	970	49	any	any	DT
22283	970	50	degree	degree	NN
22283	970	51	those	those	DT
22283	970	52	mental	mental	JJ
22283	970	53	processes	process	NNS
22283	970	54	which	which	WDT
22283	970	55	do	do	VBP
22283	970	56	not	not	RB
22283	970	57	express	express	VB
22283	970	58	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	970	59	in	in	IN
22283	970	60	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	970	61	action	action	NN
22283	970	62	.	.	.
22283	971	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	971	2	,	,	,
22283	971	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	971	4	may	may	MD
22283	971	5	be	be	VB
22283	971	6	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	971	7	true	true	JJ
22283	971	8	that	that	IN
22283	971	9	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	971	10	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	971	11	action	action	NN
22283	971	12	in	in	IN
22283	971	13	the	the	DT
22283	971	14	past	past	NN
22283	971	15	might	may	MD
22283	971	16	have	have	VB
22283	971	17	been	be	VBN
22283	971	18	different	different	JJ
22283	971	19	from	from	IN
22283	971	20	what	what	WP
22283	971	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	971	22	actually	actually	RB
22283	971	23	was	be	VBD
22283	971	24	;	;	:
22283	971	25	for	for	IN
22283	971	26	as	as	IN
22283	971	27	this	this	DT
22283	971	28	action	action	NN
22283	971	29	was	be	VBD
22283	971	30	the	the	DT
22283	971	31	outcome	outcome	NN
22283	971	32	of	of	IN
22283	971	33	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	971	34	mentation	mentation	NN
22283	971	35	at	at	IN
22283	971	36	the	the	DT
22283	971	37	time	time	NN
22283	971	38	(	(	-LRB-
22283	971	39	according	accord	VBG
22283	971	40	to	to	IN
22283	971	41	the	the	DT
22283	971	42	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
22283	971	43	index	index	NN
22283	971	44	,	,	,
22283	971	45	which	which	WDT
22283	971	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	971	47	now	now	RB
22283	971	48	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	971	49	guide	guide	NN
22283	971	50	)	)	-RRB-
22283	971	51	,	,	,
22283	971	52	and	and	CC
22283	971	53	as	as	IN
22283	971	54	this	this	DT
22283	971	55	mentation	mentation	NN
22283	971	56	was	be	VBD
22283	971	57	not	not	RB
22283	971	58	coerced	coerce	VBN
22283	971	59	from	from	IN
22283	971	60	without	without	IN
22283	971	61	,	,	,
22283	971	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	971	63	might	may	MD
22283	971	64	very	very	RB
22283	971	65	well	well	RB
22283	971	66	have	have	VB
22283	971	67	been	be	VBN
22283	971	68	different	different	JJ
22283	971	69	from	from	IN
22283	971	70	what	what	WP
22283	971	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	971	72	was	be	VBD
22283	971	73	.	.	.
22283	972	1	Each	each	DT
22283	972	2	of	of	IN
22283	972	3	the	the	DT
22283	972	4	mental	mental	JJ
22283	972	5	sequences	sequence	NNS
22283	972	6	at	at	IN
22283	972	7	that	that	DT
22283	972	8	time	time	NN
22283	972	9	was	be	VBD
22283	972	10	a	a	DT
22283	972	11	result	result	NN
22283	972	12	of	of	IN
22283	972	13	those	those	DT
22283	972	14	preceding	precede	VBG
22283	972	15	and	and	CC
22283	972	16	a	a	DT
22283	972	17	cause	cause	NN
22283	972	18	of	of	IN
22283	972	19	those	those	DT
22283	972	20	succeeding	succeed	VBG
22283	972	21	;	;	:
22283	972	22	but	but	CC
22283	972	23	behind	behind	IN
22283	972	24	all	all	PDT
22283	972	25	this	this	DT
22283	972	26	play	play	NN
22283	972	27	of	of	IN
22283	972	28	mental	mental	JJ
22283	972	29	causation	causation	NN
22283	972	30	there	there	RB
22283	972	31	all	all	PDT
22283	972	32	the	the	DT
22283	972	33	while	while	NN
22283	972	34	stood	stand	VBD
22283	972	35	that	that	IN
22283	972	36	Self	Self	NNP
22283	972	37	,	,	,
22283	972	38	which	which	WDT
22283	972	39	was	be	VBD
22283	972	40	at	at	IN
22283	972	41	once	once	RB
22283	972	42	the	the	DT
22283	972	43	condition	condition	NN
22283	972	44	of	of	IN
22283	972	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	972	46	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	972	47	,	,	,
22283	972	48	and	and	CC
22283	972	49	the	the	DT
22283	972	50	_	_	NNP
22283	972	51	First	First	NNP
22283	972	52	Cause	Cause	NNP
22283	972	53	_	_	NNP
22283	972	54	of	of	IN
22283	972	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	972	56	action	action	NN
22283	972	57	.	.	.
22283	973	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	973	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	973	3	not	not	RB
22283	973	4	true	true	JJ
22283	973	5	that	that	IN
22283	973	6	that	that	IN
22283	973	7	Self	self	NN
22283	973	8	was	be	VBD
22283	973	9	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	973	10	more	more	JJR
22283	973	11	than	than	IN
22283	973	12	the	the	DT
22283	973	13	result	result	NN
22283	973	14	of	of	IN
22283	973	15	all	all	PDT
22283	973	16	this	this	DT
22283	973	17	play	play	NN
22283	973	18	of	of	IN
22283	973	19	mental	mental	JJ
22283	973	20	causation	causation	NN
22283	973	21	;	;	:
22283	973	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	973	23	can	can	MD
22283	973	24	only	only	RB
22283	973	25	have	have	VB
22283	973	26	been	be	VBN
22283	973	27	the	the	DT
22283	973	28	First	first	JJ
22283	973	29	Cause	cause	NN
22283	973	30	of	of	IN
22283	973	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	973	32	.	.	.
22283	974	1	For	for	IN
22283	974	2	,	,	,
22283	974	3	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	974	4	,	,	,
22283	974	5	the	the	DT
22283	974	6	mental	mental	JJ
22283	974	7	causation	causation	NN
22283	974	8	must	must	MD
22283	974	9	have	have	VB
22283	974	10	been	be	VBN
22283	974	11	the	the	DT
22283	974	12	cause	cause	NN
22283	974	13	of	of	IN
22283	974	14	that	that	DT
22283	974	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	974	16	,	,	,
22283	974	17	which	which	WDT
22283	974	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	974	19	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	974	20	.	.	.
22283	975	1	Who	who	WP
22283	975	2	or	or	CC
22283	975	3	What	what	WP
22283	975	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	975	5	was	be	VBD
22283	975	6	that	that	DT
22283	975	7	originally	originally	RB
22283	975	8	caused	cause	VBD
22283	975	9	this	this	DT
22283	975	10	First	First	NNP
22283	975	11	Cause	Cause	NNP
22283	975	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	975	13	,	,	,
22283	975	14	of	of	IN
22283	975	15	course	course	NN
22283	975	16	,	,	,
22283	975	17	another	another	DT
22283	975	18	question	question	NN
22283	975	19	,	,	,
22283	975	20	which	which	WDT
22283	975	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	975	22	shall	shall	MD
22283	975	23	presently	presently	RB
22283	975	24	hope	hope	VB
22283	975	25	to	to	TO
22283	975	26	show	show	VB
22283	975	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	975	28	not	not	RB
22283	975	29	merely	merely	RB
22283	975	30	unanswerable	unanswerable	JJ
22283	975	31	,	,	,
22283	975	32	but	but	CC
22283	975	33	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
22283	975	34	.	.	.
22283	976	1	As	as	IN
22283	976	2	a	a	DT
22283	976	3	matter	matter	NN
22283	976	4	of	of	IN
22283	976	5	fact	fact	NN
22283	976	6	,	,	,
22283	976	7	however	however	RB
22283	976	8	,	,	,
22283	976	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	976	10	know	know	VBP
22283	976	11	that	that	IN
22283	976	12	this	this	DT
22283	976	13	Self	self	NN
22283	976	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	976	15	here	here	RB
22283	976	16	,	,	,
22283	976	17	and	and	CC
22283	976	18	that	that	IN
22283	976	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	976	20	can	can	MD
22283	976	21	thus	thus	RB
22283	976	22	be	be	VB
22283	976	23	proved	prove	VBN
22283	976	24	to	to	TO
22283	976	25	be	be	VB
22283	976	26	a	a	DT
22283	976	27	substance	substance	NN
22283	976	28	,	,	,
22283	976	29	_	_	NNP
22283	976	30	standing	stand	VBG
22283	976	31	under	under	IN
22283	976	32	_	_	NNP
22283	976	33	the	the	DT
22283	976	34	whole	whole	NN
22283	976	35	of	of	IN
22283	976	36	that	that	DT
22283	976	37	more	more	RBR
22283	976	38	superficial	superficial	JJ
22283	976	39	display	display	NN
22283	976	40	of	of	IN
22283	976	41	mental	mental	JJ
22283	976	42	causation	causation	NN
22283	976	43	which	which	WDT
22283	976	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	976	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	976	46	able	able	JJ
22283	976	47	to	to	TO
22283	976	48	look	look	VB
22283	976	49	upon	upon	IN
22283	976	50	introspectively	introspectively	RB
22283	976	51	--	--	:
22283	976	52	and	and	CC
22283	976	53	this	this	DT
22283	976	54	almost	almost	RB
22283	976	55	as	as	IN
22283	976	56	_	_	NNP
22283	976	57	impersonally	impersonally	RB
22283	976	58	_	_	NNP
22283	976	59	as	as	IN
22283	976	60	if	if	IN
22283	976	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	976	62	were	be	VBD
22283	976	63	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	976	64	the	the	DT
22283	976	65	display	display	NN
22283	976	66	as	as	IN
22283	976	67	narrated	narrate	VBN
22283	976	68	by	by	IN
22283	976	69	another	another	DT
22283	976	70	mind	mind	NN
22283	976	71	.	.	.
22283	977	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	977	2	say	say	VBP
22283	977	3	,	,	,
22283	977	4	then	then	RB
22283	977	5	,	,	,
22283	977	6	that	that	IN
22283	977	7	the	the	DT
22283	977	8	theory	theory	NN
22283	977	9	of	of	IN
22283	977	10	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	977	11	entitles	entitle	VBZ
22283	977	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	977	13	to	to	TO
22283	977	14	regard	regard	VB
22283	977	15	this	this	DT
22283	977	16	Self	Self	NNP
22283	977	17	as	as	IN
22283	977	18	the	the	DT
22283	977	19	_	_	NNP
22283	977	20	fons	fon	NNS
22283	977	21	et	et	NNP
22283	977	22	origo	origo	NNP
22283	977	23	_	_	NNP
22283	977	24	of	of	IN
22283	977	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	977	26	mental	mental	JJ
22283	977	27	causation	causation	NN
22283	977	28	,	,	,
22283	977	29	and	and	CC
22283	977	30	thus	thus	RB
22283	977	31	restores	restore	VBZ
22283	977	32	to	to	IN
22283	977	33	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	977	34	the	the	DT
22283	977	35	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	977	36	of	of	IN
22283	977	37	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	977	38	with	with	IN
22283	977	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	977	40	attendant	attendant	JJ
22283	977	41	consequence	consequence	NN
22283	977	42	of	of	IN
22283	977	43	Moral	Moral	NNP
22283	977	44	Responsibility	Responsibility	NNP
22283	977	45	.	.	.
22283	978	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	978	2	may	may	MD
22283	978	3	help	help	VB
22283	978	4	to	to	TO
22283	978	5	elucidate	elucidate	VB
22283	978	6	this	this	DT
22283	978	7	matter	matter	NN
22283	978	8	if	if	IN
22283	978	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	978	10	regard	regard	VBP
22283	978	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	978	12	from	from	IN
22283	978	13	another	another	DT
22283	978	14	point	point	NN
22283	978	15	of	of	IN
22283	978	16	view	view	NN
22283	978	17	.	.	.
22283	979	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	979	2	to	to	IN
22283	979	3	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	979	4	,	,	,
22283	979	5	'	'	''
22283	979	6	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	979	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	979	8	the	the	DT
22283	979	9	absence	absence	NN
22283	979	10	of	of	IN
22283	979	11	all	all	DT
22283	979	12	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	979	13	to	to	IN
22283	979	14	action	action	NN
22283	979	15	that	that	WDT
22283	979	16	are	be	VBP
22283	979	17	not	not	RB
22283	979	18	contained	contain	VBN
22283	979	19	in	in	IN
22283	979	20	the	the	DT
22283	979	21	nature	nature	NN
22283	979	22	and	and	CC
22283	979	23	intrinsical	intrinsical	JJ
22283	979	24	qualities	quality	NNS
22283	979	25	of	of	IN
22283	979	26	the	the	DT
22283	979	27	agent	agent	NN
22283	979	28	.	.	.
22283	979	29	'	'	''
22283	980	1	Now	now	RB
22283	980	2	,	,	,
22283	980	3	if	if	IN
22283	980	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	980	5	accept	accept	VBP
22283	980	6	this	this	DT
22283	980	7	definition	definition	NN
22283	980	8	,	,	,
22283	980	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	980	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	980	11	easy	easy	JJ
22283	980	12	to	to	TO
22283	980	13	show	show	VB
22283	980	14	that	that	IN
22283	980	15	the	the	DT
22283	980	16	theory	theory	NN
22283	980	17	of	of	IN
22283	980	18	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	980	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	980	20	really	really	RB
22283	980	21	at	at	IN
22283	980	22	one	one	CD
22283	980	23	with	with	IN
22283	980	24	the	the	DT
22283	980	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	980	26	of	of	IN
22283	980	27	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
22283	980	28	.	.	.
22283	981	1	For	for	IN
22283	981	2	,	,	,
22283	981	3	in	in	IN
22283	981	4	the	the	DT
22283	981	5	first	first	JJ
22283	981	6	place	place	NN
22283	981	7	,	,	,
22283	981	8	according	accord	VBG
22283	981	9	to	to	IN
22283	981	10	the	the	DT
22283	981	11	theory	theory	NN
22283	981	12	of	of	IN
22283	981	13	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	981	14	,	,	,
22283	981	15	the	the	DT
22283	981	16	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	981	17	of	of	IN
22283	981	18	the	the	DT
22283	981	19	brain	brain	NN
22283	981	20	could	could	MD
22283	981	21	not	not	RB
22283	981	22	be	be	VB
22283	981	23	what	what	WP
22283	981	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	981	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	981	26	without	without	IN
22283	981	27	the	the	DT
22283	981	28	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	981	29	of	of	IN
22283	981	30	the	the	DT
22283	981	31	mind	mind	NN
22283	981	32	.	.	.
22283	982	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
22283	982	2	,	,	,
22283	982	3	as	as	IN
22283	982	4	above	above	IN
22283	982	5	shown	show	VBN
22283	982	6	,	,	,
22283	982	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	982	8	would	would	MD
22283	982	9	be	be	VB
22283	982	10	equally	equally	RB
22283	982	11	incorrect	incorrect	JJ
22283	982	12	to	to	TO
22283	982	13	say	say	VB
22283	982	14	that	that	IN
22283	982	15	the	the	DT
22283	982	16	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	982	17	governs	govern	VBZ
22283	982	18	the	the	DT
22283	982	19	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	982	20	,	,	,
22283	982	21	as	as	IN
22283	982	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	982	23	would	would	MD
22283	982	24	be	be	VB
22283	982	25	to	to	TO
22283	982	26	say	say	VB
22283	982	27	that	that	IN
22283	982	28	the	the	DT
22283	982	29	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	982	30	governs	govern	VBZ
22283	982	31	the	the	DT
22283	982	32	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	982	33	.	.	.
22283	983	1	But	but	CC
22283	983	2	,	,	,
22283	983	3	if	if	IN
22283	983	4	so	so	RB
22283	983	5	,	,	,
22283	983	6	the	the	DT
22283	983	7	Will	Will	NNP
22283	983	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	983	9	free	free	JJ
22283	983	10	in	in	IN
22283	983	11	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	983	12	with	with	IN
22283	983	13	Hobbes	hobbe	NNS
22283	983	14	'	'	POS
22283	983	15	definition	definition	NN
22283	983	16	of	of	IN
22283	983	17	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	983	18	.	.	.
22283	984	1	Suppose	suppose	VB
22283	984	2	,	,	,
22283	984	3	for	for	IN
22283	984	4	example	example	NN
22283	984	5	,	,	,
22283	984	6	that	that	IN
22283	984	7	on	on	IN
22283	984	8	seeing	see	VBG
22283	984	9	a	a	DT
22283	984	10	bone	bone	NN
22283	984	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	984	12	think	think	VBP
22283	984	13	of	of	IN
22283	984	14	Professor	Professor	NNP
22283	984	15	Flower	Flower	NNP
22283	984	16	,	,	,
22283	984	17	then	then	RB
22283	984	18	remember	remember	VB
22283	984	19	that	that	IN
22283	984	20	a	a	DT
22283	984	21	long	long	JJ
22283	984	22	time	time	NN
22283	984	23	ago	ago	RB
22283	984	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	984	25	lent	lend	VBD
22283	984	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	984	27	book	book	NN
22283	984	28	on	on	IN
22283	984	29	Osteology	Osteology	NNP
22283	984	30	to	to	IN
22283	984	31	a	a	DT
22283	984	32	friend	friend	NN
22283	984	33	,	,	,
22283	984	34	and	and	CC
22283	984	35	forthwith	forthwith	NNP
22283	984	36	resolve	resolve	VB
22283	984	37	to	to	TO
22283	984	38	ask	ask	VB
22283	984	39	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	984	40	friend	friend	NN
22283	984	41	what	what	WP
22283	984	42	has	have	VBZ
22283	984	43	become	become	VBN
22283	984	44	of	of	IN
22283	984	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	984	46	;	;	:
22283	984	47	here	here	RB
22283	984	48	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	984	49	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	984	50	volition	volition	NN
22283	984	51	would	would	MD
22283	984	52	be	be	VB
22283	984	53	unfree	unfree	CD
22283	984	54	if	if	IN
22283	984	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	984	56	were	be	VBD
22283	984	57	the	the	DT
22283	984	58	effect	effect	NN
22283	984	59	of	of	IN
22283	984	60	physical	physical	JJ
22283	984	61	processes	process	NNS
22283	984	62	going	go	VBG
22283	984	63	on	on	RP
22283	984	64	in	in	IN
22283	984	65	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	984	66	brain	brain	NN
22283	984	67	.	.	.
22283	985	1	But	but	CC
22283	985	2	the	the	DT
22283	985	3	volition	volition	NN
22283	985	4	might	may	MD
22283	985	5	be	be	VB
22283	985	6	free	free	JJ
22283	985	7	if	if	IN
22283	985	8	each	each	DT
22283	985	9	of	of	IN
22283	985	10	these	these	DT
22283	985	11	mental	mental	JJ
22283	985	12	processes	process	NNS
22283	985	13	were	be	VBD
22283	985	14	the	the	DT
22283	985	15	result	result	NN
22283	985	16	of	of	IN
22283	985	17	the	the	DT
22283	985	18	preceding	precede	VBG
22283	985	19	one	one	CD
22283	985	20	,	,	,
22283	985	21	seeing	see	VBG
22283	985	22	that	that	IN
22283	985	23	there	there	EX
22283	985	24	may	may	MD
22283	985	25	then	then	RB
22283	985	26	have	have	VB
22283	985	27	been	be	VBN
22283	985	28	'	'	''
22283	985	29	an	an	DT
22283	985	30	absence	absence	NN
22283	985	31	of	of	IN
22283	985	32	all	all	DT
22283	985	33	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	985	34	'	'	POS
22283	985	35	to	to	IN
22283	985	36	the	the	DT
22283	985	37	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	985	38	of	of	IN
22283	985	39	these	these	DT
22283	985	40	processes	process	NNS
22283	985	41	.	.	.
22283	986	1	Of	of	RB
22283	986	2	course	course	RB
22283	986	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	986	4	will	will	MD
22283	986	5	be	be	VB
22283	986	6	objected	object	VBN
22283	986	7	--	--	:
22283	986	8	as	as	IN
22283	986	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	986	10	have	have	VBP
22283	986	11	myself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	986	12	urged	urge	VBN
22283	986	13	in	in	IN
22283	986	14	the	the	DT
22283	986	15	preceding	precede	VBG
22283	986	16	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	986	17	--	--	:
22283	986	18	that	that	IN
22283	986	19	causal	causal	JJ
22283	986	20	action	action	NN
22283	986	21	of	of	IN
22283	986	22	any	any	DT
22283	986	23	kind	kind	NN
22283	986	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	986	25	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
22283	986	26	with	with	IN
22283	986	27	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	986	28	of	of	IN
22283	986	29	volition	volition	NN
22283	986	30	--	--	:
22283	986	31	that	that	IN
22283	986	32	if	if	IN
22283	986	33	there	there	EX
22283	986	34	be	be	VB
22283	986	35	any	any	DT
22283	986	36	such	such	JJ
22283	986	37	causal	causal	JJ
22283	986	38	action	action	NN
22283	986	39	,	,	,
22283	986	40	even	even	RB
22283	986	41	though	though	IN
22283	986	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	986	43	be	be	VB
22283	986	44	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	986	45	restricted	restrict	VBN
22283	986	46	within	within	IN
22283	986	47	the	the	DT
22283	986	48	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	986	49	of	of	IN
22283	986	50	mind	mind	NN
22283	986	51	,	,	,
22283	986	52	the	the	DT
22283	986	53	Will	Will	NNP
22283	986	54	is	be	VBZ
22283	986	55	really	really	RB
22283	986	56	compelled	compel	VBN
22283	986	57	to	to	TO
22283	986	58	will	will	VB
22283	986	59	as	as	IN
22283	986	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	986	61	does	do	VBZ
22283	986	62	will	will	MD
22283	986	63	,	,	,
22283	986	64	is	be	VBZ
22283	986	65	determined	determine	VBN
22283	986	66	to	to	TO
22283	986	67	determine	determine	VB
22283	986	68	as	as	IN
22283	986	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	986	70	does	do	VBZ
22283	986	71	determine	determine	VB
22283	986	72	,	,	,
22283	986	73	and	and	CC
22283	986	74	hence	hence	RB
22283	986	75	that	that	IN
22283	986	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	986	77	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	986	78	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	986	79	is	be	VBZ
22283	986	80	illusory	illusory	JJ
22283	986	81	.	.	.
22283	987	1	Hobbes	hobbe	NNS
22283	987	2	'	'	POS
22283	987	3	definition	definition	NN
22283	987	4	,	,	,
22283	987	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	987	6	may	may	MD
22283	987	7	be	be	VB
22283	987	8	urged	urge	VBN
22283	987	9	,	,	,
22283	987	10	when	when	WRB
22283	987	11	applied	apply	VBN
22283	987	12	to	to	IN
22283	987	13	the	the	DT
22283	987	14	case	case	NN
22283	987	15	of	of	IN
22283	987	16	the	the	DT
22283	987	17	Will	Will	NNP
22283	987	18	,	,	,
22283	987	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	987	20	equivocal	equivocal	JJ
22283	987	21	.	.	.
22283	988	1	No	no	RB
22283	988	2	doubt	doubt	RB
22283	988	3	a	a	DT
22283	988	4	man	man	NN
22283	988	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	988	6	free	free	JJ
22283	988	7	as	as	IN
22283	988	8	to	to	IN
22283	988	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	988	10	_	_	NNP
22283	988	11	action	action	NN
22283	988	12	_	_	NNP
22283	988	13	,	,	,
22283	988	14	if	if	IN
22283	988	15	there	there	EX
22283	988	16	be	be	VB
22283	988	17	an	an	DT
22283	988	18	'	'	``
22283	988	19	absence	absence	NN
22283	988	20	of	of	IN
22283	988	21	all	all	DT
22283	988	22	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	988	23	'	'	POS
22283	988	24	to	to	IN
22283	988	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	988	26	action	action	NN
22283	988	27	--	--	:
22283	988	28	or	or	CC
22283	988	29	,	,	,
22283	988	30	in	in	IN
22283	988	31	other	other	JJ
22283	988	32	words	word	NNS
22283	988	33	,	,	,
22283	988	34	if	if	IN
22283	988	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	988	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	988	37	able	able	JJ
22283	988	38	to	to	TO
22283	988	39	act	act	VB
22283	988	40	as	as	IN
22283	988	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	988	42	wills	will	VBZ
22283	988	43	to	to	TO
22283	988	44	act	act	VB
22283	988	45	.	.	.
22283	989	1	But	but	CC
22283	989	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	989	3	does	do	VBZ
22283	989	4	not	not	RB
22283	989	5	follow	follow	VB
22283	989	6	that	that	IN
22283	989	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	989	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	989	9	free	free	JJ
22283	989	10	as	as	IN
22283	989	11	to	to	IN
22283	989	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	989	13	_	_	NNP
22283	989	14	will	will	MD
22283	989	15	_	_	NNP
22283	989	16	,	,	,
22283	989	17	even	even	RB
22283	989	18	though	though	IN
22283	989	19	there	there	EX
22283	989	20	be	be	VB
22283	989	21	an	an	DT
22283	989	22	absence	absence	NN
22283	989	23	of	of	IN
22283	989	24	all	all	DT
22283	989	25	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	989	26	to	to	IN
22283	989	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	989	28	willing	willing	JJ
22283	989	29	as	as	IN
22283	989	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	989	31	wills	will	VBZ
22283	989	32	to	to	TO
22283	989	33	will	will	VB
22283	989	34	.	.	.
22283	990	1	For	for	IN
22283	990	2	here	here	RB
22283	990	3	the	the	DT
22283	990	4	very	very	JJ
22283	990	5	question	question	NN
22283	990	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	990	7	as	as	IN
22283	990	8	to	to	IN
22283	990	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	990	10	there	there	EX
22283	990	11	are	be	VBP
22283	990	12	any	any	DT
22283	990	13	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	990	14	to	to	IN
22283	990	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	990	16	willing	willing	JJ
22283	990	17	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	990	18	than	than	IN
22283	990	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	990	20	does	do	VBZ
22283	990	21	will	will	MD
22283	990	22	.	.	.
22283	991	1	The	the	DT
22283	991	2	fact	fact	NN
22283	991	3	that	that	IN
22283	991	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	991	5	wills	will	VBZ
22283	991	6	to	to	TO
22283	991	7	will	will	VB
22283	991	8	as	as	IN
22283	991	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	991	10	does	do	VBZ
22283	991	11	will	will	MD
22283	991	12	proves	prove	VBZ
22283	991	13	that	that	IN
22283	991	14	there	there	EX
22283	991	15	are	be	VBP
22283	991	16	no	no	DT
22283	991	17	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	991	18	to	to	IN
22283	991	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	991	20	willing	willing	NN
22283	991	21	in	in	IN
22283	991	22	that	that	DT
22283	991	23	direction	direction	NN
22283	991	24	;	;	:
22283	991	25	but	but	CC
22283	991	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	991	27	there	there	EX
22283	991	28	a	a	DT
22283	991	29	similar	similar	JJ
22283	991	30	absence	absence	NN
22283	991	31	of	of	IN
22283	991	32	impediments	impediment	NNS
22283	991	33	to	to	IN
22283	991	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	991	35	willing	willing	NN
22283	991	36	to	to	TO
22283	991	37	will	will	VB
22283	991	38	in	in	IN
22283	991	39	any	any	DT
22283	991	40	other	other	JJ
22283	991	41	direction	direction	NN
22283	991	42	?	?	.
22283	992	1	If	if	IN
22283	992	2	so	so	RB
22283	992	3	,	,	,
22283	992	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	992	5	are	be	VBP
22283	992	6	still	still	RB
22283	992	7	within	within	IN
22283	992	8	the	the	DT
22283	992	9	lines	line	NNS
22283	992	10	of	of	IN
22283	992	11	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	992	12	.	.	.
22283	993	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	993	2	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
22283	993	3	'	'	POS
22283	993	4	definition	definition	NN
22283	993	5	of	of	IN
22283	993	6	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	993	7	really	really	RB
22283	993	8	applies	apply	VBZ
22283	993	9	only	only	RB
22283	993	10	to	to	IN
22283	993	11	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	993	12	of	of	IN
22283	993	13	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	993	14	action	action	NN
22283	993	15	;	;	:
22283	993	16	not	not	RB
22283	993	17	to	to	IN
22283	993	18	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	993	19	of	of	IN
22283	993	20	volition	volition	NN
22283	993	21	,	,	,
22283	993	22	seeing	see	VBG
22283	993	23	that	that	IN
22283	993	24	if	if	IN
22283	993	25	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	993	26	will	will	NN
22283	993	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	993	28	caused	cause	VBN
22283	993	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	993	30	could	could	MD
22283	993	31	not	not	RB
22283	993	32	have	have	VB
22283	993	33	willed	will	VBN
22283	993	34	to	to	TO
22283	993	35	will	will	MD
22283	993	36	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	993	37	than	than	IN
22283	993	38	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	993	39	did	do	VBD
22283	993	40	will	will	VB
22283	993	41	.	.	.
22283	994	1	Now	now	RB
22283	994	2	,	,	,
22283	994	3	the	the	DT
22283	994	4	answer	answer	NN
22283	994	5	which	which	WDT
22283	994	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	994	7	supplies	supply	VBZ
22283	994	8	to	to	IN
22283	994	9	this	this	DT
22283	994	10	objection	objection	NN
22283	994	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	994	12	that	that	IN
22283	994	13	the	the	DT
22283	994	14	will	will	NN
22283	994	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	994	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	994	17	here	here	RB
22283	994	18	the	the	DT
22283	994	19	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	994	20	agent	agent	NN
22283	994	21	,	,	,
22283	994	22	and	and	CC
22283	994	23	_	_	NNP
22283	994	24	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	994	25	an	an	DT
22283	994	26	agent	agent	NN
22283	994	27	which	which	WDT
22283	994	28	must	must	MD
22283	994	29	be	be	VB
22283	994	30	identified	identify	VBN
22283	994	31	with	with	IN
22283	994	32	the	the	DT
22283	994	33	principle	principle	NN
22283	994	34	of	of	IN
22283	994	35	causality	causality	NN
22283	994	36	_	_	NNP
22283	994	37	.	.	.
22283	995	1	In	in	IN
22283	995	2	other	other	JJ
22283	995	3	words	word	NNS
22283	995	4	,	,	,
22283	995	5	the	the	DT
22283	995	6	very	very	JJ
22283	995	7	reason	reason	NN
22283	995	8	why	why	WRB
22283	995	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	995	10	feel	feel	VBP
22283	995	11	that	that	IN
22283	995	12	Hobbes	hobbe	NNS
22283	995	13	'	'	POS
22283	995	14	definition	definition	NN
22283	995	15	of	of	IN
22283	995	16	liberty	liberty	NN
22283	995	17	,	,	,
22283	995	18	while	while	IN
22283	995	19	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	995	20	valid	valid	JJ
22283	995	21	as	as	IN
22283	995	22	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	995	23	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	995	24	action	action	NN
22283	995	25	,	,	,
22283	995	26	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	995	27	to	to	TO
22283	995	28	lack	lack	VB
22283	995	29	something	something	NN
22283	995	30	when	when	WRB
22283	995	31	applied	apply	VBN
22283	995	32	to	to	IN
22283	995	33	volition	volition	NN
22283	995	34	,	,	,
22283	995	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	995	36	because	because	IN
22283	995	37	volition	volition	NN
22283	995	38	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	995	39	to	to	IN
22283	995	40	the	the	DT
22283	995	41	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	995	42	of	of	IN
22283	995	43	mind	mind	NN
22283	995	44	--	--	:
22283	995	45	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	995	46	,	,	,
22283	995	47	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	995	48	,	,	,
22283	995	49	to	to	IN
22283	995	50	that	that	DT
22283	995	51	sphere	sphere	NN
22283	995	52	which	which	WDT
22283	995	53	the	the	DT
22283	995	54	theory	theory	NN
22283	995	55	of	of	IN
22283	995	56	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	995	57	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	995	58	as	as	RB
22283	995	59	identical	identical	JJ
22283	995	60	with	with	IN
22283	995	61	causality	causality	NN
22283	995	62	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	995	63	.	.	.
22283	996	1	Although	although	IN
22283	996	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	996	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	996	4	true	true	JJ
22283	996	5	that	that	IN
22283	996	6	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	996	7	are	be	VBP
22283	996	8	caused	cause	VBN
22283	996	9	by	by	IN
22283	996	10	motives	motive	NNS
22283	996	11	,	,	,
22283	996	12	yet	yet	CC
22283	996	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	996	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	996	15	the	the	DT
22283	996	16	mind	mind	NN
22283	996	17	which	which	WDT
22283	996	18	conditions	condition	VBZ
22283	996	19	the	the	DT
22283	996	20	motives	motive	NNS
22283	996	21	,	,	,
22283	996	22	and	and	CC
22283	996	23	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	996	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	996	25	own	own	JJ
22283	996	26	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	996	27	.	.	.
22283	997	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	997	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	997	3	not	not	RB
22283	997	4	true	true	JJ
22283	997	5	that	that	IN
22283	997	6	the	the	DT
22283	997	7	mind	mind	NN
22283	997	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	997	9	always	always	RB
22283	997	10	the	the	DT
22283	997	11	passive	passive	JJ
22283	997	12	slave	slave	NN
22283	997	13	of	of	IN
22283	997	14	causes	cause	NNS
22283	997	15	,	,	,
22283	997	16	known	know	VBN
22283	997	17	to	to	IN
22283	997	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	997	19	as	as	IN
22283	997	20	motives	motive	NNS
22283	997	21	.	.	.
22283	998	1	The	the	DT
22283	998	2	human	human	JJ
22283	998	3	mind	mind	NN
22283	998	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	998	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	998	6	a	a	DT
22283	998	7	causal	causal	JJ
22283	998	8	agent	agent	NN
22283	998	9	,	,	,
22283	998	10	having	have	VBG
22283	998	11	the	the	DT
22283	998	12	same	same	JJ
22283	998	13	kind	kind	NN
22283	998	14	of	of	IN
22283	998	15	priority	priority	NN
22283	998	16	within	within	IN
22283	998	17	the	the	DT
22283	998	18	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	998	19	as	as	IN
22283	998	20	the	the	DT
22283	998	21	World	World	NNP
22283	998	22	-	-	HYPH
22283	998	23	eject	eject	NN
22283	998	24	has	have	VBZ
22283	998	25	in	in	IN
22283	998	26	the	the	DT
22283	998	27	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	998	28	.	.	.
22283	999	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	999	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	999	3	motives	motive	NNS
22283	999	4	are	be	VBP
22283	999	5	in	in	IN
22283	999	6	large	large	JJ
22283	999	7	part	part	NN
22283	999	8	matters	matter	NNS
22283	999	9	of	of	IN
22283	999	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	999	11	own	own	JJ
22283	999	12	creation	creation	NN
22283	999	13	.	.	.
22283	1000	1	In	in	IN
22283	1000	2	the	the	DT
22283	1000	3	intricate	intricate	JJ
22283	1000	4	workings	working	NNS
22283	1000	5	of	of	IN
22283	1000	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1000	7	own	own	JJ
22283	1000	8	internal	internal	JJ
22283	1000	9	machinery	machinery	NN
22283	1000	10	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
22283	1000	11	patterns	pattern	NNS
22283	1000	12	of	of	IN
22283	1000	13	thought	thought	NN
22283	1000	14	are	be	VBP
22283	1000	15	turned	turn	VBN
22283	1000	16	out	out	RP
22283	1000	17	,	,	,
22283	1000	18	some	some	DT
22283	1000	19	of	of	IN
22283	1000	20	which	which	WDT
22283	1000	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1000	22	selects	select	VBZ
22283	1000	23	as	as	IN
22283	1000	24	good	good	JJ
22283	1000	25	,	,	,
22283	1000	26	while	while	IN
22283	1000	27	others	other	NNS
22283	1000	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1000	29	rejects	reject	VBZ
22283	1000	30	as	as	RB
22283	1000	31	bad	bad	JJ
22283	1000	32	;	;	:
22283	1000	33	but	but	CC
22283	1000	34	no	no	DT
22283	1000	35	one	one	NN
22283	1000	36	of	of	IN
22283	1000	37	which	which	WDT
22283	1000	38	could	could	MD
22283	1000	39	have	have	VB
22283	1000	40	come	come	VBN
22283	1000	41	into	into	IN
22283	1000	42	being	being	NN
22283	1000	43	at	at	RB
22283	1000	44	all	all	RB
22283	1000	45	without	without	IN
22283	1000	46	this	this	DT
22283	1000	47	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1000	48	agency	agency	NN
22283	1000	49	of	of	IN
22283	1000	50	the	the	DT
22283	1000	51	mind	mind	NN
22283	1000	52	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1000	53	.	.	.
22283	1001	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1001	2	will	will	MD
22283	1001	3	probably	probably	RB
22283	1001	4	be	be	VB
22283	1001	5	objected	object	VBN
22283	1001	6	that	that	IN
22283	1001	7	even	even	RB
22283	1001	8	though	though	IN
22283	1001	9	all	all	PDT
22283	1001	10	this	this	DT
22283	1001	11	were	be	VBD
22283	1001	12	granted	grant	VBN
22283	1001	13	,	,	,
22283	1001	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1001	15	can	can	MD
22283	1001	16	not	not	RB
22283	1001	17	thus	thus	RB
22283	1001	18	save	save	VB
22283	1001	19	the	the	DT
22283	1001	20	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	1001	21	of	of	IN
22283	1001	22	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1001	23	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1001	24	.	.	.
22283	1002	1	For	for	IN
22283	1002	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1002	3	may	may	MD
22283	1002	4	appear	appear	VB
22283	1002	5	that	that	IN
22283	1002	6	the	the	DT
22283	1002	7	liberty	liberty	NN
22283	1002	8	which	which	WDT
22283	1002	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1002	10	thus	thus	RB
22283	1002	11	accorded	accord	VBN
22283	1002	12	to	to	IN
22283	1002	13	the	the	DT
22283	1002	14	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1002	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	1002	16	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1002	17	better	well	JJR
22283	1002	18	than	than	IN
22283	1002	19	liberty	liberty	NN
22283	1002	20	to	to	TO
22283	1002	21	will	will	NN
22283	1002	22	at	at	IN
22283	1002	23	random	random	JJ
22283	1002	24	,	,	,
22283	1002	25	as	as	IN
22283	1002	26	argued	argue	VBN
22283	1002	27	in	in	IN
22283	1002	28	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1002	29	previous	previous	JJ
22283	1002	30	essay	essay	NN
22283	1002	31	.	.	.
22283	1003	1	But	but	CC
22283	1003	2	here	here	RB
22283	1003	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1003	4	must	must	MD
22283	1003	5	observe	observe	VB
22283	1003	6	that	that	IN
22283	1003	7	although	although	IN
22283	1003	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1003	9	are	be	VBP
22283	1003	10	thus	thus	RB
22283	1003	11	shown	show	VBN
22283	1003	12	free	free	JJ
22283	1003	13	to	to	TO
22283	1003	14	will	will	VB
22283	1003	15	at	at	IN
22283	1003	16	random	random	JJ
22283	1003	17	,	,	,
22283	1003	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1003	19	does	do	VBZ
22283	1003	20	not	not	RB
22283	1003	21	follow	follow	VB
22283	1003	22	that	that	IN
22283	1003	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1003	24	are	be	VBP
22283	1003	25	likewise	likewise	RB
22283	1003	26	free	free	JJ
22283	1003	27	to	to	TO
22283	1003	28	act	act	VB
22283	1003	29	in	in	IN
22283	1003	30	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	1003	31	with	with	IN
22283	1003	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1003	33	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1003	34	.	.	.
22283	1004	1	And	and	CC
22283	1004	2	this	this	DT
22283	1004	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	1004	4	a	a	DT
22283	1004	5	most	most	RBS
22283	1004	6	important	important	JJ
22283	1004	7	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1004	8	,	,	,
22283	1004	9	which	which	WDT
22283	1004	10	libertarians	libertarian	NNS
22283	1004	11	have	have	VBP
22283	1004	12	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
22283	1004	13	failed	fail	VBN
22283	1004	14	to	to	TO
22283	1004	15	notice	notice	VB
22283	1004	16	.	.	.
22283	1005	1	If	if	IN
22283	1005	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1005	3	are	be	VBP
22283	1005	4	free	free	JJ
22283	1005	5	to	to	TO
22283	1005	6	will	will	VB
22283	1005	7	in	in	IN
22283	1005	8	any	any	DT
22283	1005	9	direction	direction	NN
22283	1005	10	,	,	,
22283	1005	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1005	12	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1005	13	,	,	,
22283	1005	14	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	1005	15	,	,	,
22283	1005	16	that	that	IN
22283	1005	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1005	18	are	be	VBP
22283	1005	19	free	free	JJ
22283	1005	20	to	to	TO
22283	1005	21	will	will	VB
22283	1005	22	at	at	IN
22283	1005	23	random	random	JJ
22283	1005	24	;	;	:
22283	1005	25	but	but	CC
22283	1005	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1005	27	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1005	28	also	also	RB
22283	1005	29	,	,	,
22283	1005	30	and	and	CC
22283	1005	31	for	for	IN
22283	1005	32	this	this	DT
22283	1005	33	very	very	JJ
22283	1005	34	reason	reason	NN
22283	1005	35	,	,	,
22283	1005	36	that	that	IN
22283	1005	37	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1005	38	are	be	VBP
22283	1005	39	free	free	JJ
22283	1005	40	to	to	TO
22283	1005	41	will	will	VB
22283	1005	42	the	the	DT
22283	1005	43	_	_	NNP
22283	1005	44	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1005	45	_	_	NNP
22283	1005	46	.	.	.
22283	1006	1	True	true	JJ
22283	1006	2	,	,	,
22283	1006	3	when	when	WRB
22283	1006	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1006	5	will	will	MD
22283	1006	6	what	what	WP
22283	1006	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1006	8	known	know	VBN
22283	1006	9	to	to	TO
22283	1006	10	be	be	VB
22283	1006	11	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1006	12	of	of	IN
22283	1006	13	execution	execution	NN
22283	1006	14	,	,	,
22283	1006	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1006	16	call	call	VBP
22283	1006	17	the	the	DT
22283	1006	18	act	act	NN
22283	1006	19	an	an	DT
22283	1006	20	act	act	NN
22283	1006	21	of	of	IN
22283	1006	22	desire	desire	NN
22283	1006	23	;	;	:
22283	1006	24	but	but	CC
22283	1006	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1006	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	1006	27	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	1006	28	the	the	DT
22283	1006	29	same	same	JJ
22283	1006	30	in	in	IN
22283	1006	31	kind	kind	NN
22283	1006	32	as	as	IN
22283	1006	33	an	an	DT
22283	1006	34	act	act	NN
22283	1006	35	of	of	IN
22283	1006	36	will	will	NN
22283	1006	37	,	,	,
22283	1006	38	and	and	CC
22283	1006	39	differs	differ	VBZ
22283	1006	40	only	only	RB
22283	1006	41	in	in	IN
22283	1006	42	not	not	RB
22283	1006	43	admitting	admit	VBG
22283	1006	44	of	of	IN
22283	1006	45	being	be	VBG
22283	1006	46	translated	translate	VBN
22283	1006	47	into	into	IN
22283	1006	48	an	an	DT
22283	1006	49	act	act	NN
22283	1006	50	of	of	IN
22283	1006	51	body	body	NN
22283	1006	52	.	.	.
22283	1007	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1007	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1007	3	say	say	VBP
22283	1007	4	that	that	IN
22283	1007	5	the	the	DT
22283	1007	6	restriction	restriction	NN
22283	1007	7	which	which	WDT
22283	1007	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1007	9	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	1007	10	upon	upon	IN
22283	1007	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1007	12	by	by	IN
22283	1007	13	the	the	DT
22283	1007	14	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1007	15	of	of	IN
22283	1007	16	causality	causality	NN
22283	1007	17	,	,	,
22283	1007	18	whether	whether	IN
22283	1007	19	external	external	JJ
22283	1007	20	or	or	CC
22283	1007	21	internal	internal	JJ
22283	1007	22	,	,	,
22283	1007	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	1007	24	not	not	RB
22283	1007	25	any	any	DT
22283	1007	26	restriction	restriction	NN
22283	1007	27	as	as	IN
22283	1007	28	to	to	IN
22283	1007	29	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1007	30	,	,	,
22283	1007	31	but	but	CC
22283	1007	32	merely	merely	RB
22283	1007	33	as	as	IN
22283	1007	34	to	to	IN
22283	1007	35	doing	do	VBG
22283	1007	36	.	.	.
22283	1008	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1008	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1008	3	not	not	RB
22283	1008	4	in	in	IN
22283	1008	5	the	the	DT
22283	1008	6	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	1008	7	,	,	,
22283	1008	8	but	but	CC
22283	1008	9	in	in	IN
22283	1008	10	the	the	DT
22283	1008	11	objective	objective	JJ
22283	1008	12	world	world	NN
22283	1008	13	that	that	WDT
22283	1008	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1008	15	encounter	encounter	VBP
22283	1008	16	the	the	DT
22283	1008	17	'	'	''
22283	1008	18	bondage	bondage	NN
22283	1008	19	of	of	IN
22283	1008	20	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1008	21	.	.	.
22283	1008	22	'	'	''
22283	1009	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1009	2	,	,	,
22283	1009	3	the	the	DT
22283	1009	4	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	1009	5	that	that	WDT
22283	1009	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1009	7	are	be	VBP
22283	1009	8	thus	thus	RB
22283	1009	9	restricted	restrict	VBN
22283	1009	10	as	as	IN
22283	1009	11	to	to	IN
22283	1009	12	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	1009	13	action	action	NN
22283	1009	14	imposes	impose	NNS
22283	1009	15	that	that	DT
22283	1009	16	kind	kind	NN
22283	1009	17	of	of	IN
22283	1009	18	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1009	19	upon	upon	IN
22283	1009	20	volition	volition	NN
22283	1009	21	which	which	WDT
22283	1009	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1009	23	termed	term	VBN
22283	1009	24	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1009	25	.	.	.
22283	1010	1	There	there	EX
22283	1010	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1010	3	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1010	4	in	in	IN
22283	1010	5	the	the	DT
22283	1010	6	nature	nature	NN
22283	1010	7	of	of	IN
22283	1010	8	things	thing	NNS
22283	1010	9	to	to	TO
22283	1010	10	prevent	prevent	VB
22283	1010	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1010	12	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1010	13	anything	anything	NN
22283	1010	14	that	that	WDT
22283	1010	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1010	16	wish	wish	VBP
22283	1010	17	;	;	:
22283	1010	18	but	but	CC
22283	1010	19	there	there	EX
22283	1010	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	1010	21	something	something	NN
22283	1010	22	in	in	IN
22283	1010	23	the	the	DT
22283	1010	24	nature	nature	NN
22283	1010	25	of	of	IN
22283	1010	26	things	thing	NNS
22283	1010	27	to	to	TO
22283	1010	28	prevent	prevent	VB
22283	1010	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1010	30	doing	do	VBG
22283	1010	31	everything	everything	NN
22283	1010	32	that	that	WDT
22283	1010	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1010	34	will	will	MD
22283	1010	35	;	;	:
22283	1010	36	and	and	CC
22283	1010	37	as	as	IN
22283	1010	38	the	the	DT
22283	1010	39	practical	practical	JJ
22283	1010	40	object	object	NN
22283	1010	41	of	of	IN
22283	1010	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1010	43	volition	volition	NN
22283	1010	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	1010	45	that	that	DT
22283	1010	46	of	of	IN
22283	1010	47	determining	determine	VBG
22283	1010	48	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	1010	49	action	action	NN
22283	1010	50	,	,	,
22283	1010	51	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1010	52	find	find	VBP
22283	1010	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1010	54	expedient	expedient	JJ
22283	1010	55	to	to	TO
22283	1010	56	will	will	VB
22283	1010	57	only	only	RB
22283	1010	58	such	such	JJ
22283	1010	59	things	thing	NNS
22283	1010	60	as	as	IN
22283	1010	61	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1010	62	believe	believe	VBP
22283	1010	63	that	that	IN
22283	1010	64	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1010	65	can	can	MD
22283	1010	66	do	do	VB
22283	1010	67	.	.	.
22283	1011	1	To	to	IN
22283	1011	2	this	this	DT
22283	1011	3	extent	extent	NN
22283	1011	4	,	,	,
22283	1011	5	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1011	6	,	,	,
22283	1011	7	the	the	DT
22283	1011	8	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1011	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1011	10	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1011	11	--	--	:
22283	1011	12	namely	namely	RB
22283	1011	13	,	,	,
22283	1011	14	by	by	IN
22283	1011	15	the	the	DT
22283	1011	16	executive	executive	JJ
22283	1011	17	capacity	capacity	NN
22283	1011	18	of	of	IN
22283	1011	19	the	the	DT
22283	1011	20	body	body	NN
22283	1011	21	.	.	.
22283	1012	1	But	but	CC
22283	1012	2	,	,	,
22283	1012	3	strictly	strictly	RB
22283	1012	4	speaking	speak	VBG
22283	1012	5	,	,	,
22283	1012	6	this	this	DT
22283	1012	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1012	8	not	not	RB
22283	1012	9	a	a	DT
22283	1012	10	binding	binding	NN
22283	1012	11	of	of	IN
22283	1012	12	the	the	DT
22283	1012	13	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1012	14	_	_	NNP
22283	1012	15	qua	qua	NNP
22283	1012	16	_	_	NNP
22283	1012	17	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1012	18	.	.	.
22283	1013	1	Even	even	RB
22283	1013	2	in	in	IN
22283	1013	3	such	such	JJ
22283	1013	4	cases	case	NNS
22283	1013	5	,	,	,
22283	1013	6	as	as	IN
22283	1013	7	St.	St.	NNP
22283	1013	8	Paul	Paul	NNP
22283	1013	9	says	say	VBZ
22283	1013	10	,	,	,
22283	1013	11	to	to	TO
22283	1013	12	will	will	MD
22283	1013	13	may	may	MD
22283	1013	14	be	be	VB
22283	1013	15	present	present	JJ
22283	1013	16	with	with	IN
22283	1013	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1013	18	,	,	,
22283	1013	19	but	but	CC
22283	1013	20	how	how	WRB
22283	1013	21	to	to	TO
22283	1013	22	perform	perform	VB
22283	1013	23	that	that	IN
22283	1013	24	which	which	WDT
22283	1013	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	1013	26	good	good	JJ
22283	1013	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1013	28	find	find	VBP
22283	1013	29	not	not	RB
22283	1013	30	.	.	.
22283	1014	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1014	2	say	say	VBP
22283	1014	3	then	then	RB
22283	1014	4	that	that	IN
22283	1014	5	although	although	IN
22283	1014	6	the	the	DT
22283	1014	7	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1014	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1014	9	free	free	JJ
22283	1014	10	to	to	TO
22283	1014	11	will	will	VB
22283	1014	12	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	1014	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1014	14	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1014	15	,	,	,
22283	1014	16	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	1014	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1014	18	would	would	MD
22283	1014	19	fail	fail	VB
22283	1014	20	in	in	IN
22283	1014	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1014	22	essential	essential	JJ
22283	1014	23	use	use	NN
22283	1014	24	or	or	CC
22283	1014	25	object	object	NN
22283	1014	26	did	do	VBD
22283	1014	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1014	28	refuse	refuse	VB
22283	1014	29	to	to	TO
22283	1014	30	will	will	VB
22283	1014	31	in	in	IN
22283	1014	32	accordance	accordance	NN
22283	1014	33	with	with	IN
22283	1014	34	the	the	DT
22283	1014	35	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1014	36	which	which	WDT
22283	1014	37	are	be	VBP
22283	1014	38	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	1014	39	upon	upon	IN
22283	1014	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1014	41	executive	executive	JJ
22283	1014	42	capacity	capacity	NN
22283	1014	43	.	.	.
22283	1015	1	Again	again	RB
22283	1015	2	,	,	,
22283	1015	3	to	to	TO
22283	1015	4	quote	quote	VB
22283	1015	5	St.	St.	NNP
22283	1015	6	Paul	Paul	NNP
22283	1015	7	,	,	,
22283	1015	8	the	the	DT
22283	1015	9	Will	Will	MD
22283	1015	10	might	may	MD
22283	1015	11	say	say	VB
22283	1015	12	,	,	,
22283	1015	13	All	all	DT
22283	1015	14	things	thing	NNS
22283	1015	15	for	for	IN
22283	1015	16	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1015	17	are	be	VBP
22283	1015	18	lawful	lawful	JJ
22283	1015	19	;	;	:
22283	1015	20	but	but	CC
22283	1015	21	all	all	DT
22283	1015	22	things	thing	NNS
22283	1015	23	are	be	VBP
22283	1015	24	not	not	RB
22283	1015	25	expedient	expedient	JJ
22283	1015	26	.	.	.
22283	1016	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1016	2	,	,	,
22283	1016	3	this	this	DT
22283	1016	4	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	1016	5	of	of	IN
22283	1016	6	expediency	expediency	NN
22283	1016	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1016	8	one	one	CD
22283	1016	9	of	of	IN
22283	1016	10	constant	constant	JJ
22283	1016	11	and	and	CC
22283	1016	12	far	far	RB
22283	1016	13	-	-	HYPH
22283	1016	14	reaching	reach	VBG
22283	1016	15	importance	importance	NN
22283	1016	16	.	.	.
22283	1017	1	For	for	IN
22283	1017	2	not	not	RB
22283	1017	3	only	only	RB
22283	1017	4	,	,	,
22283	1017	5	as	as	RB
22283	1017	6	already	already	RB
22283	1017	7	observed	observe	VBN
22283	1017	8	,	,	,
22283	1017	9	does	do	VBZ
22283	1017	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1017	11	lead	lead	VB
22283	1017	12	to	to	IN
22283	1017	13	volition	volition	NN
22283	1017	14	on	on	IN
22283	1017	15	the	the	DT
22283	1017	16	one	one	CD
22283	1017	17	hand	hand	NN
22283	1017	18	as	as	IN
22283	1017	19	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1017	20	;	;	:
22283	1017	21	but	but	CC
22283	1017	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1017	23	also	also	RB
22283	1017	24	leads	lead	VBZ
22283	1017	25	to	to	IN
22283	1017	26	volition	volition	NN
22283	1017	27	on	on	IN
22283	1017	28	the	the	DT
22283	1017	29	other	other	JJ
22283	1017	30	hand	hand	NN
22283	1017	31	as	as	IN
22283	1017	32	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1017	33	.	.	.
22283	1018	1	Let	let	VB
22283	1018	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1018	3	take	take	VB
22283	1018	4	the	the	DT
22283	1018	5	two	two	CD
22283	1018	6	points	point	NNS
22283	1018	7	separately	separately	RB
22283	1018	8	.	.	.
22283	1019	1	Do	do	VBP
22283	1019	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1019	3	say	say	VB
22283	1019	4	that	that	IN
22283	1019	5	a	a	DT
22283	1019	6	man	man	NN
22283	1019	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1019	8	not	not	RB
22283	1019	9	free	free	JJ
22283	1019	10	to	to	TO
22283	1019	11	conduct	conduct	VB
22283	1019	12	a	a	DT
22283	1019	13	scientific	scientific	JJ
22283	1019	14	research	research	NN
22283	1019	15	,	,	,
22283	1019	16	because	because	IN
22283	1019	17	in	in	IN
22283	1019	18	conducting	conduct	VBG
22283	1019	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1019	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1019	21	must	must	MD
22283	1019	22	employ	employ	VB
22283	1019	23	the	the	DT
22283	1019	24	needful	needful	JJ
22283	1019	25	apparatus	apparatus	NN
22283	1019	26	?	?	.
22283	1020	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1020	2	do	do	VB
22283	1020	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1020	4	say	say	VB
22283	1020	5	that	that	IN
22283	1020	6	a	a	DT
22283	1020	7	man	man	NN
22283	1020	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1020	9	not	not	RB
22283	1020	10	free	free	JJ
22283	1020	11	to	to	TO
22283	1020	12	marry	marry	VB
22283	1020	13	,	,	,
22283	1020	14	because	because	IN
22283	1020	15	in	in	IN
22283	1020	16	order	order	NN
22283	1020	17	to	to	TO
22283	1020	18	do	do	VB
22283	1020	19	so	so	RB
22283	1020	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1020	21	must	must	MD
22283	1020	22	go	go	VB
22283	1020	23	through	through	IN
22283	1020	24	a	a	DT
22283	1020	25	marriage	marriage	NN
22283	1020	26	ceremony	ceremony	NN
22283	1020	27	?	?	.
22283	1021	1	Obviously	obviously	RB
22283	1021	2	,	,	,
22283	1021	3	to	to	TO
22283	1021	4	say	say	VB
22283	1021	5	such	such	JJ
22283	1021	6	things	thing	NNS
22283	1021	7	would	would	MD
22283	1021	8	sound	sound	VB
22283	1021	9	very	very	RB
22283	1021	10	like	like	IN
22283	1021	11	talking	talk	VBG
22283	1021	12	nonsense	nonsense	NN
22283	1021	13	.	.	.
22283	1022	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1022	3	true	true	JJ
22283	1022	4	that	that	IN
22283	1022	5	in	in	IN
22283	1022	6	neither	neither	DT
22283	1022	7	case	case	NN
22283	1022	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1022	9	a	a	DT
22283	1022	10	man	man	NN
22283	1022	11	free	free	JJ
22283	1022	12	to	to	TO
22283	1022	13	gain	gain	VB
22283	1022	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1022	15	object	object	NN
22283	1022	16	without	without	IN
22283	1022	17	adopting	adopt	VBG
22283	1022	18	the	the	DT
22283	1022	19	means	mean	NNS
22283	1022	20	which	which	WDT
22283	1022	21	are	be	VBP
22283	1022	22	seen	see	VBN
22283	1022	23	to	to	TO
22283	1022	24	be	be	VB
22283	1022	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	1022	26	under	under	IN
22283	1022	27	the	the	DT
22283	1022	28	system	system	NN
22283	1022	29	of	of	IN
22283	1022	30	external	external	JJ
22283	1022	31	causation	causation	NN
22283	1022	32	in	in	IN
22283	1022	33	which	which	WDT
22283	1022	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	35	finds	find	VBZ
22283	1022	36	himself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	37	;	;	:
22283	1022	38	but	but	CC
22283	1022	39	this	this	DT
22283	1022	40	does	do	VBZ
22283	1022	41	not	not	RB
22283	1022	42	mean	mean	VB
22283	1022	43	that	that	IN
22283	1022	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	1022	46	not	not	RB
22283	1022	47	free	free	JJ
22283	1022	48	to	to	TO
22283	1022	49	do	do	VB
22283	1022	50	as	as	IN
22283	1022	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	52	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1022	53	,	,	,
22283	1022	54	unless	unless	IN
22283	1022	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	56	so	so	RB
22283	1022	57	happens	happen	VBZ
22283	1022	58	that	that	IN
22283	1022	59	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1022	60	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1022	61	to	to	TO
22283	1022	62	do	do	VB
22283	1022	63	the	the	DT
22283	1022	64	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1022	65	.	.	.
22283	1023	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	1023	2	,	,	,
22283	1023	3	within	within	IN
22283	1023	4	the	the	DT
22283	1023	5	limits	limit	NNS
22283	1023	6	that	that	WDT
22283	1023	7	are	be	VBP
22283	1023	8	set	set	VBN
22283	1023	9	by	by	IN
22283	1023	10	the	the	DT
22283	1023	11	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1023	12	of	of	IN
22283	1023	13	causation	causation	NN
22283	1023	14	,	,	,
22283	1023	15	a	a	DT
22283	1023	16	man	man	NN
22283	1023	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	1023	18	understood	understand	VBN
22283	1023	19	to	to	TO
22283	1023	20	be	be	VB
22283	1023	21	free	free	JJ
22283	1023	22	to	to	TO
22283	1023	23	act	act	VB
22283	1023	24	as	as	IN
22283	1023	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1023	26	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1023	27	so	so	RB
22283	1023	28	long	long	RB
22283	1023	29	as	as	IN
22283	1023	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1023	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1023	32	not	not	RB
22283	1023	33	'	'	``
22283	1023	34	impeded	impede	VBN
22283	1023	35	'	'	''
22283	1023	36	by	by	IN
22283	1023	37	some	some	DT
22283	1023	38	of	of	IN
22283	1023	39	those	those	DT
22283	1023	40	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1023	41	.	.	.
22283	1024	1	To	to	TO
22283	1024	2	say	say	VB
22283	1024	3	that	that	IN
22283	1024	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1024	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	1024	6	not	not	RB
22283	1024	7	free	free	JJ
22283	1024	8	because	because	IN
22283	1024	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1024	10	can	can	MD
22283	1024	11	not	not	RB
22283	1024	12	get	get	VB
22283	1024	13	beyond	beyond	IN
22283	1024	14	those	those	DT
22283	1024	15	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1024	16	would	would	MD
22283	1024	17	be	be	VB
22283	1024	18	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	1024	19	,	,	,
22283	1024	20	since	since	IN
22283	1024	21	,	,	,
22283	1024	22	apart	apart	RB
22283	1024	23	from	from	IN
22283	1024	24	these	these	DT
22283	1024	25	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1024	26	,	,	,
22283	1024	27	action	action	NN
22283	1024	28	of	of	IN
22283	1024	29	any	any	DT
22283	1024	30	kind	kind	NN
22283	1024	31	would	would	MD
22283	1024	32	be	be	VB
22283	1024	33	_	_	NNP
22283	1024	34	a	a	DT
22283	1024	35	priori	priori	FW
22283	1024	36	_	_	NNP
22283	1024	37	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1024	38	,	,	,
22283	1024	39	and	and	CC
22283	1024	40	the	the	DT
22283	1024	41	man	man	NN
22283	1024	42	would	would	MD
22283	1024	43	have	have	VB
22283	1024	44	,	,	,
22283	1024	45	as	as	IN
22283	1024	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1024	47	only	only	JJ
22283	1024	48	alternative	alternative	NN
22283	1024	49	,	,	,
22283	1024	50	no	no	DT
22283	1024	51	-	-	HYPH
22283	1024	52	action	action	NN
22283	1024	53	.	.	.
22283	1025	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	1025	2	,	,	,
22283	1025	3	in	in	IN
22283	1025	4	doing	do	VBG
22283	1025	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1025	6	must	must	MD
22283	1025	7	conform	conform	VB
22283	1025	8	to	to	IN
22283	1025	9	the	the	DT
22283	1025	10	law	law	NN
22283	1025	11	of	of	IN
22283	1025	12	causation	causation	NN
22283	1025	13	--	--	:
22283	1025	14	which	which	WDT
22283	1025	15	,	,	,
22283	1025	16	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	1025	17	,	,	,
22283	1025	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	1025	19	all	all	DT
22283	1025	20	that	that	WDT
22283	1025	21	can	can	MD
22283	1025	22	be	be	VB
22283	1025	23	meant	mean	VBN
22283	1025	24	by	by	IN
22283	1025	25	doing	do	VBG
22283	1025	26	--	--	:
22283	1025	27	and	and	CC
22283	1025	28	if	if	IN
22283	1025	29	in	in	IN
22283	1025	30	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1025	31	what	what	WP
22283	1025	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1025	33	do	do	VBP
22283	1025	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1025	35	must	must	MD
22283	1025	36	also	also	RB
22283	1025	37	conform	conform	VB
22283	1025	38	to	to	IN
22283	1025	39	the	the	DT
22283	1025	40	law	law	NN
22283	1025	41	of	of	IN
22283	1025	42	causation	causation	NN
22283	1025	43	,	,	,
22283	1025	44	where	where	WRB
22283	1025	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	1025	46	the	the	DT
22283	1025	47	difference	difference	NN
22283	1025	48	with	with	IN
22283	1025	49	respect	respect	NN
22283	1025	50	to	to	IN
22283	1025	51	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	1025	52	?	?	.
22283	1026	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	1026	2	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1026	3	as	as	IN
22283	1026	4	there	there	EX
22283	1026	5	may	may	MD
22283	1026	6	be	be	VB
22283	1026	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1026	8	here	here	RB
22283	1026	9	a	a	DT
22283	1026	10	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1026	11	upon	upon	IN
22283	1026	12	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	1026	13	action	action	NN
22283	1026	14	;	;	:
22283	1026	15	not	not	RB
22283	1026	16	at	at	RB
22283	1026	17	all	all	RB
22283	1026	18	upon	upon	IN
22283	1026	19	the	the	DT
22283	1026	20	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1026	21	action	action	NN
22283	1026	22	which	which	WDT
22283	1026	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1026	24	call	call	VBP
22283	1026	25	volition	volition	NN
22283	1026	26	.	.	.
22283	1027	1	The	the	DT
22283	1027	2	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1027	3	may	may	MD
22283	1027	4	will	will	VB
22283	1027	5	in	in	IN
22283	1027	6	any	any	DT
22283	1027	7	way	way	NN
22283	1027	8	that	that	WDT
22283	1027	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1027	10	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1027	11	to	to	TO
22283	1027	12	will	will	VB
22283	1027	13	;	;	:
22283	1027	14	but	but	CC
22283	1027	15	the	the	DT
22283	1027	16	body	body	NN
22283	1027	17	can	can	MD
22283	1027	18	not	not	RB
22283	1027	19	act	act	VB
22283	1027	20	in	in	IN
22283	1027	21	every	every	DT
22283	1027	22	way	way	NN
22283	1027	23	that	that	WDT
22283	1027	24	the	the	DT
22283	1027	25	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1027	26	may	may	MD
22283	1027	27	will	will	VB
22283	1027	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1027	29	to	to	TO
22283	1027	30	act	act	VB
22283	1027	31	;	;	:
22283	1027	32	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1027	33	the	the	DT
22283	1027	34	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1027	35	finds	find	VBZ
22283	1027	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1027	37	expedient	expedient	JJ
22283	1027	38	to	to	TO
22283	1027	39	will	will	VB
22283	1027	40	only	only	RB
22283	1027	41	in	in	IN
22283	1027	42	such	such	JJ
22283	1027	43	ways	way	NNS
22283	1027	44	as	as	IN
22283	1027	45	the	the	DT
22283	1027	46	body	body	NN
22283	1027	47	can	can	MD
22283	1027	48	act	act	VB
22283	1027	49	--	--	:
22283	1027	50	i	i	PRP
22283	1027	51	.	.	.
22283	1027	52	e.	e.	NNP
22283	1027	53	to	to	TO
22283	1027	54	conform	conform	VB
22283	1027	55	in	in	IN
22283	1027	56	_	_	NNP
22283	1027	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1027	58	_	_	NNP
22283	1027	59	action	action	NN
22283	1027	60	to	to	IN
22283	1027	61	the	the	DT
22283	1027	62	external	external	JJ
22283	1027	63	system	system	NN
22283	1027	64	of	of	IN
22283	1027	65	causation	causation	NN
22283	1027	66	.	.	.
22283	1028	1	If	if	IN
22283	1028	2	this	this	DT
22283	1028	3	condition	condition	NN
22283	1028	4	of	of	IN
22283	1028	5	all	all	DT
22283	1028	6	action	action	NN
22283	1028	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1028	8	held	hold	VBN
22283	1028	9	to	to	TO
22283	1028	10	be	be	VB
22283	1028	11	compatible	compatible	JJ
22283	1028	12	with	with	IN
22283	1028	13	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	1028	14	in	in	IN
22283	1028	15	the	the	DT
22283	1028	16	one	one	CD
22283	1028	17	case	case	NN
22283	1028	18	,	,	,
22283	1028	19	so	so	RB
22283	1028	20	in	in	IN
22283	1028	21	consistency	consistency	NN
22283	1028	22	must	must	MD
22283	1028	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1028	24	be	be	VB
22283	1028	25	held	hold	VBN
22283	1028	26	in	in	IN
22283	1028	27	the	the	DT
22283	1028	28	other	other	JJ
22283	1028	29	.	.	.
22283	1029	1	Equally	equally	RB
22283	1029	2	in	in	IN
22283	1029	3	either	either	DT
22283	1029	4	case	case	NN
22283	1029	5	the	the	DT
22283	1029	6	agent	agent	NN
22283	1029	7	can	can	MD
22283	1029	8	only	only	RB
22283	1029	9	be	be	VB
22283	1029	10	properly	properly	RB
22283	1029	11	said	say	VBN
22283	1029	12	to	to	TO
22283	1029	13	be	be	VB
22283	1029	14	unfree	unfree	CD
22283	1029	15	,	,	,
22283	1029	16	if	if	IN
22283	1029	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1029	18	be	be	VB
22283	1029	19	subject	subject	JJ
22283	1029	20	to	to	IN
22283	1029	21	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1029	22	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1029	23	from	from	IN
22283	1029	24	without	without	IN
22283	1029	25	.	.	.
22283	1030	1	And	and	CC
22283	1030	2	in	in	IN
22283	1030	3	neither	neither	DT
22283	1030	4	case	case	NN
22283	1030	5	does	do	VBZ
22283	1030	6	the	the	DT
22283	1030	7	universal	universal	JJ
22283	1030	8	condition	condition	NN
22283	1030	9	of	of	IN
22283	1030	10	acting	act	VBG
22283	1030	11	under	under	IN
22283	1030	12	the	the	DT
22283	1030	13	law	law	NN
22283	1030	14	of	of	IN
22283	1030	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	1030	16	constitute	constitute	NN
22283	1030	17	bondage	bondage	VB
22283	1030	18	,	,	,
22283	1030	19	in	in	IN
22283	1030	20	any	any	DT
22283	1030	21	other	other	JJ
22283	1030	22	sense	sense	NN
22283	1030	23	than	than	IN
22283	1030	24	that	that	DT
22283	1030	25	of	of	IN
22283	1030	26	furnishing	furnish	VBG
22283	1030	27	the	the	DT
22283	1030	28	agent	agent	NN
22283	1030	29	with	with	IN
22283	1030	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1030	31	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1030	32	to	to	IN
22283	1030	33	acting	act	VBG
22283	1030	34	in	in	IN
22283	1030	35	any	any	DT
22283	1030	36	way	way	NN
22283	1030	37	at	at	RB
22283	1030	38	all	all	RB
22283	1030	39	.	.	.
22283	1031	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1031	2	,	,	,
22283	1031	3	unless	unless	IN
22283	1031	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	5	be	be	VB
22283	1031	6	said	say	VBN
22283	1031	7	that	that	IN
22283	1031	8	a	a	DT
22283	1031	9	man	man	NN
22283	1031	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1031	11	not	not	RB
22283	1031	12	free	free	JJ
22283	1031	13	to	to	TO
22283	1031	14	do	do	VB
22283	1031	15	as	as	IN
22283	1031	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	17	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1031	18	because	because	IN
22283	1031	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	20	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1031	21	to	to	TO
22283	1031	22	do	do	VB
22283	1031	23	the	the	DT
22283	1031	24	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1031	25	,	,	,
22283	1031	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	27	can	can	MD
22283	1031	28	not	not	RB
22283	1031	29	be	be	VB
22283	1031	30	denied	deny	VBN
22283	1031	31	that	that	IN
22283	1031	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	1031	34	free	free	JJ
22283	1031	35	to	to	TO
22283	1031	36	will	will	VB
22283	1031	37	as	as	IN
22283	1031	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	39	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1031	40	because	because	IN
22283	1031	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1031	42	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1031	43	according	accord	VBG
22283	1031	44	to	to	IN
22283	1031	45	law	law	NN
22283	1031	46	.	.	.
22283	1032	1	For	for	IN
22283	1032	2	no	no	DT
22283	1032	3	action	action	NN
22283	1032	4	of	of	IN
22283	1032	5	any	any	DT
22283	1032	6	kind	kind	NN
22283	1032	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1032	8	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1032	9	contrary	contrary	JJ
22283	1032	10	to	to	IN
22283	1032	11	law	law	NN
22283	1032	12	--	--	:
22283	1032	13	a	a	DT
22283	1032	14	general	general	JJ
22283	1032	15	fact	fact	NN
22283	1032	16	which	which	WDT
22283	1032	17	goes	go	VBZ
22283	1032	18	to	to	TO
22283	1032	19	constitute	constitute	VB
22283	1032	20	an	an	DT
22283	1032	21	argument	argument	NN
22283	1032	22	_	_	NNP
22283	1032	23	a	a	DT
22283	1032	24	posteriori	posteriori	NN
22283	1032	25	_	_	NNP
22283	1032	26	for	for	IN
22283	1032	27	the	the	DT
22283	1032	28	rationality	rationality	NN
22283	1032	29	of	of	IN
22283	1032	30	the	the	DT
22283	1032	31	World	World	NNP
22283	1032	32	-	-	HYPH
22283	1032	33	eject	eject	NN
22283	1032	34	--	--	:
22283	1032	35	and	and	CC
22283	1032	36	if	if	IN
22283	1032	37	volition	volition	NN
22283	1032	38	constituted	constitute	VBD
22283	1032	39	an	an	DT
22283	1032	40	exception	exception	NN
22283	1032	41	to	to	IN
22283	1032	42	this	this	DT
22283	1032	43	general	general	JJ
22283	1032	44	statement	statement	NN
22283	1032	45	,	,	,
22283	1032	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1032	47	could	could	MD
22283	1032	48	only	only	RB
22283	1032	49	do	do	VB
22283	1032	50	so	so	RB
22283	1032	51	by	by	IN
22283	1032	52	becoming	become	VBG
22283	1032	53	no	no	DT
22283	1032	54	-	-	HYPH
22283	1032	55	action	action	NN
22283	1032	56	.	.	.
22283	1033	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1033	2	,	,	,
22283	1033	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1033	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1033	5	by	by	IN
22283	1033	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	1033	7	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1033	8	according	accord	VBG
22283	1033	9	to	to	IN
22283	1033	10	law	law	NN
22283	1033	11	--	--	:
22283	1033	12	or	or	CC
22283	1033	13	with	with	IN
22283	1033	14	due	due	JJ
22283	1033	15	reference	reference	NN
22283	1033	16	to	to	IN
22283	1033	17	those	those	DT
22283	1033	18	external	external	JJ
22283	1033	19	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1033	20	of	of	IN
22283	1033	21	causality	causality	NN
22283	1033	22	with	with	IN
22283	1033	23	which	which	WDT
22283	1033	24	the	the	DT
22283	1033	25	executive	executive	NN
22283	1033	26	capacity	capacity	NN
22283	1033	27	has	have	VBZ
22283	1033	28	to	to	TO
22283	1033	29	do	do	VB
22283	1033	30	--	--	:
22283	1033	31	that	that	IN
22283	1033	32	volition	volition	NN
22283	1033	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	1033	34	rendered	render	VBN
22283	1033	35	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1033	36	.	.	.
22283	1034	1	The	the	DT
22283	1034	2	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1034	3	laid	lay	VBN
22283	1034	4	upon	upon	IN
22283	1034	5	volition	volition	NN
22283	1034	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1034	7	not	not	RB
22283	1034	8	laid	lay	VBN
22283	1034	9	upon	upon	IN
22283	1034	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1034	11	_	_	NNP
22283	1034	12	as	as	IN
22283	1034	13	_	_	NNP
22283	1034	14	volition	volition	NN
22283	1034	15	,	,	,
22283	1034	16	but	but	CC
22283	1034	17	only	only	RB
22283	1034	18	in	in	IN
22283	1034	19	respect	respect	NN
22283	1034	20	of	of	IN
22283	1034	21	execution	execution	NN
22283	1034	22	.	.	.
22283	1035	1	A	a	DT
22283	1035	2	man	man	NN
22283	1035	3	may	may	MD
22283	1035	4	will	will	VB
22283	1035	5	to	to	TO
22283	1035	6	marry	marry	VB
22283	1035	7	as	as	RB
22283	1035	8	long	long	RB
22283	1035	9	and	and	CC
22283	1035	10	as	as	RB
22283	1035	11	hard	hard	RB
22283	1035	12	as	as	IN
22283	1035	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1035	14	chooses	choose	VBZ
22283	1035	15	;	;	:
22283	1035	16	but	but	CC
22283	1035	17	only	only	RB
22283	1035	18	if	if	IN
22283	1035	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1035	20	further	further	RB
22283	1035	21	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1035	22	to	to	TO
22283	1035	23	take	take	VB
22283	1035	24	the	the	DT
22283	1035	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	1035	26	means	mean	NNS
22283	1035	27	can	can	MD
22283	1035	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1035	29	volition	volition	NN
22283	1035	30	become	become	VB
22283	1035	31	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1035	32	;	;	:
22283	1035	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1035	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	1035	35	irrational	irrational	JJ
22283	1035	36	if	if	IN
22283	1035	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1035	38	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1035	39	to	to	TO
22283	1035	40	marry	marry	VB
22283	1035	41	,	,	,
22283	1035	42	and	and	CC
22283	1035	43	at	at	IN
22283	1035	44	the	the	DT
22283	1035	45	same	same	JJ
22283	1035	46	time	time	NN
22283	1035	47	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1035	48	not	not	RB
22283	1035	49	to	to	TO
22283	1035	50	go	go	VB
22283	1035	51	through	through	IN
22283	1035	52	the	the	DT
22283	1035	53	marriage	marriage	NN
22283	1035	54	ceremony	ceremony	NN
22283	1035	55	.	.	.
22283	1036	1	But	but	CC
22283	1036	2	although	although	IN
22283	1036	3	irrational	irrational	JJ
22283	1036	4	,	,	,
22283	1036	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1036	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1036	7	none	none	NN
22283	1036	8	the	the	DT
22283	1036	9	less	less	RBR
22283	1036	10	free	free	JJ
22283	1036	11	.	.	.
22283	1037	1	Considered	consider	VBN
22283	1037	2	merely	merely	RB
22283	1037	3	as	as	IN
22283	1037	4	an	an	DT
22283	1037	5	act	act	NN
22283	1037	6	of	of	IN
22283	1037	7	volition	volition	NN
22283	1037	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1037	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1037	10	equally	equally	RB
22283	1037	11	free	free	JJ
22283	1037	12	,	,	,
22283	1037	13	whether	whether	IN
22283	1037	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1037	15	be	be	VB
22283	1037	16	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1037	17	or	or	CC
22283	1037	18	irrational	irrational	JJ
22283	1037	19	.	.	.
22283	1038	1	And	and	CC
22283	1038	2	,	,	,
22283	1038	3	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	1038	4	,	,	,
22283	1038	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1038	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1038	7	equally	equally	RB
22283	1038	8	free	free	JJ
22283	1038	9	whether	whether	IN
22283	1038	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1038	11	be	be	VB
22283	1038	12	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1038	13	or	or	CC
22283	1038	14	immoral	immoral	JJ
22283	1038	15	.	.	.
22283	1039	1	The	the	DT
22283	1039	2	objection	objection	NN
22283	1039	3	that	that	IN
22283	1039	4	an	an	DT
22283	1039	5	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1039	6	volition	volition	NN
22283	1039	7	can	can	MD
22283	1039	8	not	not	RB
22283	1039	9	be	be	VB
22283	1039	10	a	a	DT
22283	1039	11	responsible	responsible	JJ
22283	1039	12	volition	volition	NN
22283	1039	13	depends	depend	VBZ
22283	1039	14	for	for	IN
22283	1039	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1039	16	validity	validity	NN
22283	1039	17	on	on	IN
22283	1039	18	the	the	DT
22283	1039	19	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	1039	20	which	which	WDT
22283	1039	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1039	22	attach	attach	VBP
22283	1039	23	to	to	IN
22283	1039	24	the	the	DT
22283	1039	25	term	term	NN
22283	1039	26	'	'	``
22283	1039	27	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1039	28	.	.	.
22283	1039	29	'	'	''
22283	1040	1	If	if	IN
22283	1040	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1040	3	be	be	VB
22283	1040	4	meant	mean	VBN
22283	1040	5	that	that	IN
22283	1040	6	the	the	DT
22283	1040	7	volition	volition	NN
22283	1040	8	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1040	9	without	without	IN
22283	1040	10	any	any	DT
22283	1040	11	regard	regard	NN
22283	1040	12	at	at	RB
22283	1040	13	all	all	RB
22283	1040	14	to	to	IN
22283	1040	15	the	the	DT
22283	1040	16	surrounding	surround	VBG
22283	1040	17	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1040	18	of	of	IN
22283	1040	19	life	life	NN
22283	1040	20	,	,	,
22283	1040	21	and	and	CC
22283	1040	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1040	23	carried	carry	VBN
22283	1040	24	into	into	IN
22283	1040	25	effect	effect	NN
22283	1040	26	without	without	IN
22283	1040	27	the	the	DT
22283	1040	28	agent	agent	NN
22283	1040	29	being	be	VBG
22283	1040	30	able	able	JJ
22283	1040	31	to	to	TO
22283	1040	32	control	control	VB
22283	1040	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1040	34	by	by	IN
22283	1040	35	means	mean	NNS
22283	1040	36	of	of	IN
22283	1040	37	any	any	DT
22283	1040	38	other	other	JJ
22283	1040	39	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	1040	40	act	act	NN
22283	1040	41	;	;	:
22283	1040	42	then	then	RB
22283	1040	43	,	,	,
22283	1040	44	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	1040	45	,	,	,
22283	1040	46	whatever	whatever	WDT
22283	1040	47	else	else	RB
22283	1040	48	such	such	PDT
22283	1040	49	an	an	DT
22283	1040	50	agent	agent	NN
22283	1040	51	may	may	MD
22283	1040	52	be	be	VB
22283	1040	53	,	,	,
22283	1040	54	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1040	55	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	1040	56	is	be	VBZ
22283	1040	57	not	not	RB
22283	1040	58	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1040	59	.	.	.
22283	1041	1	But	but	CC
22283	1041	2	if	if	IN
22283	1041	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1041	4	be	be	VB
22283	1041	5	meant	mean	VBN
22283	1041	6	that	that	IN
22283	1041	7	among	among	IN
22283	1041	8	a	a	DT
22283	1041	9	number	number	NN
22283	1041	10	of	of	IN
22283	1041	11	uncompleted	uncompleted	JJ
22283	1041	12	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1041	13	drawing	draw	VBG
22283	1041	14	in	in	IN
22283	1041	15	different	different	JJ
22283	1041	16	directions	direction	NNS
22283	1041	17	--	--	:
22283	1041	18	and	and	CC
22283	1041	19	all	all	DT
22283	1041	20	'	'	``
22283	1041	21	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1041	22	'	'	''
22283	1041	23	in	in	IN
22283	1041	24	the	the	DT
22283	1041	25	sense	sense	NN
22283	1041	26	of	of	IN
22283	1041	27	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	1041	28	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	1041	29	to	to	IN
22283	1041	30	the	the	DT
22283	1041	31	Ego	ego	NN
22283	1041	32	--	--	:
22283	1041	33	one	one	CD
22283	1041	34	of	of	IN
22283	1041	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1041	36	gains	gain	VBZ
22283	1041	37	an	an	DT
22283	1041	38	advantage	advantage	NN
22283	1041	39	by	by	IN
22283	1041	40	a	a	DT
22283	1041	41	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	1041	42	reference	reference	NN
22283	1041	43	of	of	IN
22283	1041	44	the	the	DT
22283	1041	45	mind	mind	NN
22283	1041	46	to	to	IN
22283	1041	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1041	48	as	as	IN
22283	1041	49	good	good	JJ
22283	1041	50	or	or	CC
22283	1041	51	evil	evil	JJ
22283	1041	52	,	,	,
22283	1041	53	then	then	RB
22283	1041	54	the	the	DT
22283	1041	55	agent	agent	NN
22283	1041	56	who	who	WP
22283	1041	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	1041	58	capable	capable	JJ
22283	1041	59	of	of	IN
22283	1041	60	giving	give	VBG
22283	1041	61	this	this	DT
22283	1041	62	advantage	advantage	NN
22283	1041	63	to	to	IN
22283	1041	64	that	that	DT
22283	1041	65	member	member	NN
22283	1041	66	of	of	IN
22283	1041	67	the	the	DT
22283	1041	68	system	system	NN
22283	1041	69	may	may	MD
22283	1041	70	properly	properly	RB
22283	1041	71	be	be	VB
22283	1041	72	called	call	VBN
22283	1041	73	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1041	74	.	.	.
22283	1042	1	The	the	DT
22283	1042	2	man	man	NN
22283	1042	3	who	who	WP
22283	1042	4	willed	will	VBD
22283	1042	5	to	to	TO
22283	1042	6	marry	marry	VB
22283	1042	7	,	,	,
22283	1042	8	and	and	CC
22283	1042	9	yet	yet	RB
22283	1042	10	willed	will	VBD
22283	1042	11	not	not	RB
22283	1042	12	to	to	TO
22283	1042	13	go	go	VB
22283	1042	14	through	through	IN
22283	1042	15	the	the	DT
22283	1042	16	marriage	marriage	NN
22283	1042	17	ceremony	ceremony	NN
22283	1042	18	,	,	,
22283	1042	19	was	be	VBD
22283	1042	20	,	,	,
22283	1042	21	as	as	IN
22283	1042	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1042	23	have	have	VBP
22283	1042	24	seen	see	VBN
22283	1042	25	,	,	,
22283	1042	26	irrational	irrational	JJ
22283	1042	27	.	.	.
22283	1043	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
22283	1043	2	,	,	,
22283	1043	3	if	if	IN
22283	1043	4	any	any	DT
22283	1043	5	agent	agent	NN
22283	1043	6	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1043	7	an	an	DT
22283	1043	8	action	action	NN
22283	1043	9	without	without	IN
22283	1043	10	being	be	VBG
22283	1043	11	able	able	JJ
22283	1043	12	to	to	TO
22283	1043	13	consider	consider	VB
22283	1043	14	any	any	DT
22283	1043	15	of	of	IN
22283	1043	16	the	the	DT
22283	1043	17	consequences	consequence	NNS
22283	1043	18	which	which	WDT
22283	1043	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1043	20	may	may	MD
22283	1043	21	involve	involve	VB
22283	1043	22	as	as	IN
22283	1043	23	either	either	DT
22283	1043	24	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1043	25	or	or	CC
22283	1043	26	immoral	immoral	JJ
22283	1043	27	,	,	,
22283	1043	28	such	such	PDT
22283	1043	29	an	an	DT
22283	1043	30	agent	agent	NN
22283	1043	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1043	32	what	what	WP
22283	1043	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1043	34	must	must	MD
22283	1043	35	properly	properly	RB
22283	1043	36	call	call	VB
22283	1043	37	unmoral	unmoral	JJ
22283	1043	38	.	.	.
22283	1044	1	Even	even	RB
22283	1044	2	in	in	IN
22283	1044	3	such	such	PDT
22283	1044	4	an	an	DT
22283	1044	5	agent	agent	NN
22283	1044	6	,	,	,
22283	1044	7	however	however	RB
22283	1044	8	,	,	,
22283	1044	9	the	the	DT
22283	1044	10	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1044	11	may	may	MD
22283	1044	12	be	be	VB
22283	1044	13	free	free	JJ
22283	1044	14	;	;	:
22283	1044	15	only	only	RB
22283	1044	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1044	17	would	would	MD
22283	1044	18	act	act	VB
22283	1044	19	without	without	IN
22283	1044	20	reference	reference	NN
22283	1044	21	to	to	IN
22283	1044	22	any	any	DT
22283	1044	23	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1044	24	environment	environment	NN
22283	1044	25	,	,	,
22283	1044	26	just	just	RB
22283	1044	27	as	as	IN
22283	1044	28	the	the	DT
22283	1044	29	lunatic	lunatic	JJ
22283	1044	30	above	above	RB
22283	1044	31	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	1044	32	might	may	MD
22283	1044	33	endeavour	endeavour	VB
22283	1044	34	to	to	TO
22283	1044	35	act	act	VB
22283	1044	36	without	without	IN
22283	1044	37	reference	reference	NN
22283	1044	38	to	to	IN
22283	1044	39	any	any	DT
22283	1044	40	social	social	JJ
22283	1044	41	environment	environment	NN
22283	1044	42	.	.	.
22283	1045	1	Let	let	VB
22283	1045	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1045	3	look	look	VB
22283	1045	4	at	at	IN
22283	1045	5	the	the	DT
22283	1045	6	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1045	7	matter	matter	NN
22283	1045	8	in	in	IN
22283	1045	9	yet	yet	RB
22283	1045	10	another	another	DT
22283	1045	11	light	light	NN
22283	1045	12	.	.	.
22283	1046	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1046	2	have	have	VBP
22283	1046	3	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
22283	1046	4	seen	see	VBN
22283	1046	5	that	that	IN
22283	1046	6	the	the	DT
22283	1046	7	question	question	NN
22283	1046	8	of	of	IN
22283	1046	9	free	free	RB
22283	1046	10	-	-	HYPH
22283	1046	11	will	will	NN
22283	1046	12	,	,	,
22283	1046	13	and	and	CC
22283	1046	14	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1046	15	of	of	IN
22283	1046	16	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1046	17	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1046	18	,	,	,
22283	1046	19	depends	depend	VBZ
22283	1046	20	upon	upon	IN
22283	1046	21	the	the	DT
22283	1046	22	question	question	NN
22283	1046	23	as	as	IN
22283	1046	24	to	to	IN
22283	1046	25	whether	whether	IN
22283	1046	26	a	a	DT
22283	1046	27	man	man	NN
22283	1046	28	's	's	POS
22283	1046	29	action	action	NN
22283	1046	30	in	in	IN
22283	1046	31	the	the	DT
22283	1046	32	past	past	NN
22283	1046	33	might	may	MD
22283	1046	34	have	have	VB
22283	1046	35	been	be	VBN
22283	1046	36	other	other	JJ
22283	1046	37	than	than	IN
22283	1046	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1046	39	was	be	VBD
22283	1046	40	,	,	,
22283	1046	41	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
22283	1046	42	that	that	IN
22283	1046	43	all	all	PDT
22283	1046	44	the	the	DT
22283	1046	45	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1046	46	under	under	IN
22283	1046	47	which	which	WDT
22283	1046	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1046	49	was	be	VBD
22283	1046	50	placed	place	VBN
22283	1046	51	remained	remain	VBD
22283	1046	52	the	the	DT
22283	1046	53	same	same	JJ
22283	1046	54	.	.	.
22283	1047	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1047	2	,	,	,
22283	1047	3	to	to	IN
22283	1047	4	this	this	DT
22283	1047	5	question	question	NN
22283	1047	6	only	only	RB
22283	1047	7	one	one	CD
22283	1047	8	answer	answer	NN
22283	1047	9	can	can	MD
22283	1047	10	be	be	VB
22283	1047	11	given	give	VBN
22283	1047	12	by	by	IN
22283	1047	13	a	a	DT
22283	1047	14	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	1047	15	theory	theory	NN
22283	1047	16	of	of	IN
22283	1047	17	things	thing	NNS
22283	1047	18	,	,	,
22283	1047	19	whether	whether	IN
22283	1047	20	materialistic	materialistic	JJ
22283	1047	21	or	or	CC
22283	1047	22	spiritualistic	spiritualistic	JJ
22283	1047	23	.	.	.
22283	1048	1	For	for	IN
22283	1048	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1048	3	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	1048	4	to	to	IN
22283	1048	5	the	the	DT
22283	1048	6	essence	essence	NN
22283	1048	7	of	of	IN
22283	1048	8	a	a	DT
22283	1048	9	dualistic	dualistic	JJ
22283	1048	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	1048	11	to	to	TO
22283	1048	12	regard	regard	VB
22283	1048	13	the	the	DT
22283	1048	14	principle	principle	NN
22283	1048	15	of	of	IN
22283	1048	16	causation	causation	NN
22283	1048	17	as	as	IN
22283	1048	18	a	a	DT
22283	1048	19	principle	principle	JJ
22283	1048	20	external	external	JJ
22283	1048	21	to	to	IN
22283	1048	22	,	,	,
22283	1048	23	and	and	CC
22283	1048	24	independent	independent	JJ
22283	1048	25	of	of	IN
22283	1048	26	,	,	,
22283	1048	27	the	the	DT
22283	1048	28	human	human	JJ
22283	1048	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	1048	30	;	;	,
22283	1048	31	consequently	consequently	RB
22283	1048	32	,	,	,
22283	1048	33	all	all	PDT
22283	1048	34	the	the	DT
22283	1048	35	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1048	36	of	of	IN
22283	1048	37	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1048	38	causation	causation	NN
22283	1048	39	being	be	VBG
22283	1048	40	given	give	VBN
22283	1048	41	,	,	,
22283	1048	42	a	a	DT
22283	1048	43	certain	certain	JJ
22283	1048	44	result	result	NN
22283	1048	45	in	in	IN
22283	1048	46	the	the	DT
22283	1048	47	way	way	NN
22283	1048	48	of	of	IN
22283	1048	49	volition	volition	NN
22283	1048	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	1048	51	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1048	52	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1048	53	to	to	TO
22283	1048	54	ensue	ensue	VB
22283	1048	55	--	--	:
22283	1048	56	or	or	CC
22283	1048	57	,	,	,
22283	1048	58	in	in	IN
22283	1048	59	other	other	JJ
22283	1048	60	words	word	NNS
22283	1048	61	,	,	,
22283	1048	62	at	at	IN
22283	1048	63	any	any	DT
22283	1048	64	given	give	VBN
22283	1048	65	time	time	NN
22283	1048	66	in	in	IN
22283	1048	67	a	a	DT
22283	1048	68	man	man	NN
22283	1048	69	's	's	POS
22283	1048	70	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1048	71	history	history	NN
22283	1048	72	,	,	,
22283	1048	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1048	74	action	action	NN
22283	1048	75	can	can	MD
22283	1048	76	not	not	RB
22283	1048	77	have	have	VB
22283	1048	78	been	be	VBN
22283	1048	79	other	other	JJ
22283	1048	80	than	than	IN
22283	1048	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1048	82	was	be	VBD
22283	1048	83	.	.	.
22283	1049	1	But	but	CC
22283	1049	2	now	now	RB
22283	1049	3	,	,	,
22283	1049	4	according	accord	VBG
22283	1049	5	to	to	IN
22283	1049	6	the	the	DT
22283	1049	7	monistic	monistic	JJ
22283	1049	8	theory	theory	NN
22283	1049	9	,	,	,
22283	1049	10	all	all	DT
22283	1049	11	causation	causation	NN
22283	1049	12	has	have	VBZ
22283	1049	13	a	a	DT
22283	1049	14	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1049	15	basis	basis	NN
22283	1049	16	--	--	:
22283	1049	17	being	be	VBG
22283	1049	18	but	but	CC
22283	1049	19	the	the	DT
22283	1049	20	objective	objective	JJ
22283	1049	21	expression	expression	NN
22283	1049	22	to	to	IN
22283	1049	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1049	24	of	of	IN
22283	1049	25	the	the	DT
22283	1049	26	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1049	27	activity	activity	NN
22283	1049	28	of	of	IN
22283	1049	29	the	the	DT
22283	1049	30	World	World	NNP
22283	1049	31	-	-	HYPH
22283	1049	32	eject	eject	NN
22283	1049	33	.	.	.
22283	1050	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
22283	1050	2	,	,	,
22283	1050	3	according	accord	VBG
22283	1050	4	to	to	IN
22283	1050	5	this	this	DT
22283	1050	6	theory	theory	NN
22283	1050	7	,	,	,
22283	1050	8	the	the	DT
22283	1050	9	course	course	NN
22283	1050	10	of	of	IN
22283	1050	11	even	even	RB
22283	1050	12	strictly	strictly	RB
22283	1050	13	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1050	14	causation	causation	NN
22283	1050	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	1050	16	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
22283	1050	17	or	or	CC
22283	1050	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	1050	19	only	only	RB
22283	1050	20	in	in	IN
22283	1050	21	so	so	RB
22283	1050	22	far	far	RB
22283	1050	23	as	as	IN
22283	1050	24	the	the	DT
22283	1050	25	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1050	26	activity	activity	NN
22283	1050	27	of	of	IN
22283	1050	28	the	the	DT
22283	1050	29	World	World	NNP
22283	1050	30	-	-	HYPH
22283	1050	31	eject	eject	NN
22283	1050	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	1050	33	held	hold	VBN
22283	1050	34	to	to	TO
22283	1050	35	be	be	VB
22283	1050	36	uniform	uniform	JJ
22283	1050	37	,	,	,
22283	1050	38	or	or	CC
22283	1050	39	consistent	consistent	JJ
22283	1050	40	within	within	IN
22283	1050	41	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1050	42	.	.	.
22283	1051	1	And	and	CC
22283	1051	2	forasmuch	forasmuch	VB
22283	1051	3	as	as	IN
22283	1051	4	all	all	DT
22283	1051	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1051	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	1051	7	of	of	IN
22283	1051	8	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1051	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	1051	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1051	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1051	12	empirical	empirical	JJ
22283	1051	13	,	,	,
22283	1051	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1051	15	have	have	VBP
22283	1051	16	but	but	CC
22283	1051	17	very	very	RB
22283	1051	18	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
22283	1051	19	means	mean	NNS
22283	1051	20	of	of	IN
22283	1051	21	judging	judge	VBG
22283	1051	22	how	how	WRB
22283	1051	23	far	far	RB
22283	1051	24	this	this	DT
22283	1051	25	empirical	empirical	JJ
22283	1051	26	index	index	NN
22283	1051	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	1051	28	a	a	DT
22283	1051	29	true	true	JJ
22283	1051	30	gauge	gauge	NN
22283	1051	31	of	of	IN
22283	1051	32	the	the	DT
22283	1051	33	reality	reality	NN
22283	1051	34	.	.	.
22283	1052	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1052	2	can	can	MD
22283	1052	3	,	,	,
22283	1052	4	indeed	indeed	RB
22283	1052	5	,	,	,
22283	1052	6	predict	predict	VB
22283	1052	7	an	an	DT
22283	1052	8	eclipse	eclipse	NN
22283	1052	9	centuries	century	NNS
22283	1052	10	in	in	IN
22283	1052	11	advance	advance	NN
22283	1052	12	;	;	:
22283	1052	13	but	but	CC
22283	1052	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1052	15	can	can	MD
22283	1052	16	only	only	RB
22283	1052	17	do	do	VB
22283	1052	18	so	so	RB
22283	1052	19	on	on	IN
22283	1052	20	the	the	DT
22283	1052	21	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	1052	22	that	that	IN
22283	1052	23	such	such	JJ
22283	1052	24	and	and	CC
22283	1052	25	such	such	JJ
22283	1052	26	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1052	27	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1052	28	remain	remain	VBP
22283	1052	29	constant	constant	JJ
22283	1052	30	,	,	,
22283	1052	31	and	and	CC
22283	1052	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1052	33	have	have	VBP
22283	1052	34	no	no	DT
22283	1052	35	right	right	NN
22283	1052	36	to	to	TO
22283	1052	37	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	1052	38	that	that	IN
22283	1052	39	such	such	JJ
22283	1052	40	must	must	MD
22283	1052	41	be	be	VB
22283	1052	42	the	the	DT
22283	1052	43	case	case	NN
22283	1052	44	.	.	.
22283	1053	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1053	2	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	1053	3	of	of	IN
22283	1053	4	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1053	5	causation	causation	NN
22283	1053	6	,	,	,
22283	1053	7	being	being	NN
22283	1053	8	but	but	CC
22283	1053	9	empirical	empirical	JJ
22283	1053	10	,	,	,
22283	1053	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	1053	12	probably	probably	RB
22283	1053	13	but	but	CC
22283	1053	14	a	a	DT
22283	1053	15	very	very	RB
22283	1053	16	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
22283	1053	17	translation	translation	NN
22283	1053	18	of	of	IN
22283	1053	19	the	the	DT
22283	1053	20	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1053	21	activity	activity	NN
22283	1053	22	of	of	IN
22283	1053	23	the	the	DT
22283	1053	24	World	World	NNP
22283	1053	25	-	-	HYPH
22283	1053	26	eject	eject	NN
22283	1053	27	;	;	:
22283	1053	28	and	and	CC
22283	1053	29	hence	hence	RB
22283	1053	30	,	,	,
22283	1053	31	not	not	RB
22283	1053	32	only	only	RB
22283	1053	33	have	have	VBP
22283	1053	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1053	35	no	no	UH
22283	1053	36	right	right	NN
22283	1053	37	to	to	TO
22283	1053	38	predict	predict	VB
22283	1053	39	a	a	DT
22283	1053	40	future	future	JJ
22283	1053	41	eclipse	eclipse	NN
22283	1053	42	with	with	IN
22283	1053	43	certainty	certainty	NN
22283	1053	44	,	,	,
22283	1053	45	but	but	CC
22283	1053	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1053	47	have	have	VBP
22283	1053	48	not	not	RB
22283	1053	49	so	so	RB
22283	1053	50	much	much	JJ
22283	1053	51	as	as	IN
22283	1053	52	the	the	DT
22283	1053	53	right	right	NN
22283	1053	54	to	to	TO
22283	1053	55	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	1053	56	that	that	IN
22283	1053	57	even	even	RB
22283	1053	58	a	a	DT
22283	1053	59	past	past	JJ
22283	1053	60	eclipse	eclipse	NN
22283	1053	61	must	must	MD
22283	1053	62	have	have	VB
22283	1053	63	taken	take	VBN
22283	1053	64	place	place	NN
22283	1053	65	of	of	IN
22283	1053	66	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1053	67	.	.	.
22283	1054	1	For	for	IN
22283	1054	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1054	3	have	have	VBP
22283	1054	4	no	no	DT
22283	1054	5	right	right	NN
22283	1054	6	to	to	TO
22283	1054	7	affirm	affirm	VB
22283	1054	8	that	that	IN
22283	1054	9	at	at	IN
22283	1054	10	any	any	DT
22283	1054	11	one	one	CD
22283	1054	12	period	period	NN
22283	1054	13	of	of	IN
22283	1054	14	cosmic	cosmic	JJ
22283	1054	15	history	history	NN
22283	1054	16	the	the	DT
22283	1054	17	action	action	NN
22283	1054	18	of	of	IN
22283	1054	19	the	the	DT
22283	1054	20	World	World	NNP
22283	1054	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	1054	22	eject	eject	NN
22283	1054	23	must	must	MD
22283	1054	24	have	have	VB
22283	1054	25	been	be	VBN
22283	1054	26	what	what	WP
22283	1054	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1054	28	was	be	VBD
22283	1054	29	,	,	,
22283	1054	30	or	or	CC
22283	1054	31	could	could	MD
22283	1054	32	not	not	RB
22283	1054	33	have	have	VB
22283	1054	34	been	be	VBN
22283	1054	35	other	other	JJ
22283	1054	36	than	than	IN
22283	1054	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1054	38	was	be	VBD
22283	1054	39	.	.	.
22283	1055	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1055	2	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	1055	3	of	of	IN
22283	1055	4	the	the	DT
22283	1055	5	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	1055	6	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	1055	7	of	of	IN
22283	1055	8	this	this	DT
22283	1055	9	action	action	NN
22283	1055	10	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1055	11	in	in	IN
22283	1055	12	the	the	DT
22283	1055	13	course	course	NN
22283	1055	14	of	of	IN
22283	1055	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1055	16	causation	causation	NN
22283	1055	17	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1055	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	1055	19	,	,	,
22283	1055	20	as	as	IN
22283	1055	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1055	22	have	have	VBP
22283	1055	23	said	say	VBD
22283	1055	24	,	,	,
22283	1055	25	purely	purely	RB
22283	1055	26	empirical	empirical	JJ
22283	1055	27	;	;	:
22283	1055	28	and	and	CC
22283	1055	29	this	this	DT
22283	1055	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1055	31	merely	merely	RB
22283	1055	32	another	another	DT
22283	1055	33	way	way	NN
22283	1055	34	of	of	IN
22283	1055	35	saying	say	VBG
22283	1055	36	that	that	IN
22283	1055	37	although	although	IN
22283	1055	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1055	39	do	do	VBP
22283	1055	40	know	know	VB
22283	1055	41	what	what	WP
22283	1055	42	the	the	DT
22283	1055	43	action	action	NN
22283	1055	44	of	of	IN
22283	1055	45	the	the	DT
22283	1055	46	World	World	NNP
22283	1055	47	-	-	HYPH
22283	1055	48	eject	eject	NN
22283	1055	49	has	have	VBZ
22283	1055	50	been	be	VBN
22283	1055	51	at	at	IN
22283	1055	52	such	such	JJ
22283	1055	53	and	and	CC
22283	1055	54	such	such	JJ
22283	1055	55	a	a	DT
22283	1055	56	period	period	NN
22283	1055	57	of	of	IN
22283	1055	58	cosmic	cosmic	JJ
22283	1055	59	history	history	NN
22283	1055	60	,	,	,
22283	1055	61	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1055	62	can	can	MD
22283	1055	63	have	have	VB
22283	1055	64	no	no	DT
22283	1055	65	means	means	NN
22283	1055	66	of	of	IN
22283	1055	67	knowing	know	VBG
22283	1055	68	what	what	WP
22283	1055	69	else	else	RB
22283	1055	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1055	71	might	may	MD
22283	1055	72	have	have	VB
22283	1055	73	been	be	VBN
22283	1055	74	.	.	.
22283	1056	1	For	for	IN
22283	1056	2	anything	anything	NN
22283	1056	3	that	that	WDT
22283	1056	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1056	5	can	can	MD
22283	1056	6	tell	tell	VB
22283	1056	7	to	to	IN
22283	1056	8	the	the	DT
22283	1056	9	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	1056	10	,	,	,
22283	1056	11	the	the	DT
22283	1056	12	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1056	13	history	history	NN
22283	1056	14	of	of	IN
22283	1056	15	the	the	DT
22283	1056	16	solar	solar	JJ
22283	1056	17	system	system	NN
22283	1056	18	,	,	,
22283	1056	19	for	for	IN
22283	1056	20	example	example	NN
22283	1056	21	,	,	,
22283	1056	22	might	may	MD
22283	1056	23	have	have	VB
22283	1056	24	been	be	VBN
22283	1056	25	quite	quite	RB
22283	1056	26	different	different	JJ
22283	1056	27	from	from	IN
22283	1056	28	what	what	WP
22283	1056	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1056	30	has	have	VBZ
22283	1056	31	been	be	VBN
22283	1056	32	;	;	:
22283	1056	33	the	the	DT
22283	1056	34	course	course	NN
22283	1056	35	which	which	WDT
22283	1056	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1056	37	actually	actually	RB
22283	1056	38	has	have	VBZ
22283	1056	39	run	run	VBN
22283	1056	40	may	may	MD
22283	1056	41	have	have	VB
22283	1056	42	been	be	VBN
22283	1056	43	but	but	CC
22283	1056	44	one	one	CD
22283	1056	45	out	out	IN
22283	1056	46	of	of	IN
22283	1056	47	an	an	DT
22283	1056	48	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
22283	1056	49	number	number	NN
22283	1056	50	of	of	IN
22283	1056	51	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1056	52	alternatives	alternative	NNS
22283	1056	53	,	,	,
22283	1056	54	any	any	DT
22283	1056	55	other	other	JJ
22283	1056	56	of	of	IN
22283	1056	57	which	which	WDT
22283	1056	58	might	may	MD
22283	1056	59	just	just	RB
22283	1056	60	as	as	RB
22283	1056	61	well	well	RB
22283	1056	62	have	have	VBP
22283	1056	63	been	be	VBN
22283	1056	64	adopted	adopt	VBN
22283	1056	65	by	by	IN
22283	1056	66	the	the	DT
22283	1056	67	World	World	NNP
22283	1056	68	-	-	HYPH
22283	1056	69	eject	eject	NN
22283	1056	70	.	.	.
22283	1057	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1057	2	,	,	,
22283	1057	3	if	if	IN
22283	1057	4	this	this	DT
22283	1057	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	1057	6	true	true	JJ
22283	1057	7	of	of	IN
22283	1057	8	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1057	9	causation	causation	NN
22283	1057	10	in	in	IN
22283	1057	11	the	the	DT
22283	1057	12	case	case	NN
22283	1057	13	of	of	IN
22283	1057	14	the	the	DT
22283	1057	15	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	1057	16	,	,	,
22283	1057	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1057	18	would	would	MD
22283	1057	19	appear	appear	VB
22283	1057	20	to	to	TO
22283	1057	21	be	be	VB
22283	1057	22	equally	equally	RB
22283	1057	23	so	so	RB
22283	1057	24	of	of	IN
22283	1057	25	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1057	26	causation	causation	NN
22283	1057	27	in	in	IN
22283	1057	28	the	the	DT
22283	1057	29	case	case	NN
22283	1057	30	of	of	IN
22283	1057	31	the	the	DT
22283	1057	32	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	1057	33	.	.	.
22283	1058	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
22283	1058	2	,	,	,
22283	1058	3	prediction	prediction	NN
22283	1058	4	in	in	IN
22283	1058	5	the	the	DT
22283	1058	6	case	case	NN
22283	1058	7	of	of	IN
22283	1058	8	human	human	JJ
22283	1058	9	activity	activity	NN
22283	1058	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1058	11	so	so	RB
22283	1058	12	much	much	RB
22283	1058	13	less	less	RBR
22283	1058	14	certain	certain	JJ
22283	1058	15	than	than	IN
22283	1058	16	in	in	IN
22283	1058	17	the	the	DT
22283	1058	18	case	case	NN
22283	1058	19	of	of	IN
22283	1058	20	cosmic	cosmic	JJ
22283	1058	21	activity	activity	NN
22283	1058	22	,	,	,
22283	1058	23	that	that	IN
22283	1058	24	the	the	DT
22283	1058	25	attribute	attribute	NN
22283	1058	26	of	of	IN
22283	1058	27	free	free	JJ
22283	1058	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	1058	29	will	will	NN
22283	1058	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1058	31	generally	generally	RB
22283	1058	32	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
22283	1058	33	to	to	IN
22283	1058	34	the	the	DT
22283	1058	35	former	former	JJ
22283	1058	36	,	,	,
22283	1058	37	while	while	IN
22283	1058	38	rarely	rarely	RB
22283	1058	39	suggested	suggest	VBD
22283	1058	40	as	as	IN
22283	1058	41	possibly	possibly	RB
22283	1058	42	belonging	belong	VBG
22283	1058	43	to	to	IN
22283	1058	44	the	the	DT
22283	1058	45	latter	latter	JJ
22283	1058	46	.	.	.
22283	1059	1	And	and	CC
22283	1059	2	similarly	similarly	RB
22283	1059	3	as	as	IN
22283	1059	4	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	1059	5	past	past	JJ
22283	1059	6	action	action	NN
22283	1059	7	.	.	.
22283	1060	1	If	if	IN
22283	1060	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1060	3	are	be	VBP
22283	1060	4	unable	unable	JJ
22283	1060	5	to	to	TO
22283	1060	6	say	say	VB
22283	1060	7	that	that	IN
22283	1060	8	at	at	IN
22283	1060	9	any	any	DT
22283	1060	10	period	period	NN
22283	1060	11	in	in	IN
22283	1060	12	the	the	DT
22283	1060	13	past	past	JJ
22283	1060	14	history	history	NN
22283	1060	15	of	of	IN
22283	1060	16	the	the	DT
22283	1060	17	solar	solar	JJ
22283	1060	18	system	system	NN
22283	1060	19	the	the	DT
22283	1060	20	World	World	NNP
22283	1060	21	-	-	HYPH
22283	1060	22	eject	eject	NN
22283	1060	23	might	may	MD
22283	1060	24	not	not	RB
22283	1060	25	have	have	VB
22283	1060	26	deflected	deflect	VBN
22283	1060	27	the	the	DT
22283	1060	28	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1060	29	stream	stream	NN
22283	1060	30	of	of	IN
22283	1060	31	events	event	NNS
22283	1060	32	into	into	IN
22283	1060	33	some	some	DT
22283	1060	34	other	other	JJ
22283	1060	35	channel	channel	NN
22283	1060	36	,	,	,
22283	1060	37	how	how	WRB
22283	1060	38	can	can	MD
22283	1060	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1060	40	be	be	VB
22283	1060	41	able	able	JJ
22283	1060	42	to	to	TO
22283	1060	43	say	say	VB
22283	1060	44	that	that	IN
22283	1060	45	at	at	IN
22283	1060	46	any	any	DT
22283	1060	47	given	give	VBN
22283	1060	48	period	period	NN
22283	1060	49	of	of	IN
22283	1060	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1060	51	past	past	JJ
22283	1060	52	history	history	NN
22283	1060	53	the	the	DT
22283	1060	54	Man	Man	NNP
22283	1060	55	-	-	HYPH
22283	1060	56	eject	eject	NN
22283	1060	57	could	could	MD
22283	1060	58	not	not	RB
22283	1060	59	have	have	VB
22283	1060	60	performed	perform	VBN
22283	1060	61	an	an	DT
22283	1060	62	analogous	analogous	JJ
22283	1060	63	act	act	NN
22283	1060	64	?	?	.
22283	1061	1	Obviously	obviously	RB
22283	1061	2	,	,	,
22283	1061	3	the	the	DT
22283	1061	4	only	only	JJ
22283	1061	5	reason	reason	NN
22283	1061	6	why	why	WRB
22283	1061	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1061	8	are	be	VBP
22283	1061	9	not	not	RB
22283	1061	10	accustomed	accustomed	JJ
22283	1061	11	to	to	TO
22283	1061	12	entertain	entertain	VB
22283	1061	13	this	this	DT
22283	1061	14	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	1061	15	in	in	IN
22283	1061	16	either	either	DT
22283	1061	17	case	case	NN
22283	1061	18	,	,	,
22283	1061	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	1061	20	because	because	IN
22283	1061	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1061	22	judgements	judgement	NNS
22283	1061	23	are	be	VBP
22283	1061	24	beset	beset	VBN
22283	1061	25	with	with	IN
22283	1061	26	the	the	DT
22283	1061	27	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	1061	28	that	that	IN
22283	1061	29	the	the	DT
22283	1061	30	principle	principle	NN
22283	1061	31	of	of	IN
22283	1061	32	causality	causality	NN
22283	1061	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	1061	34	prior	prior	JJ
22283	1061	35	to	to	IN
22283	1061	36	that	that	DT
22283	1061	37	of	of	IN
22283	1061	38	mind	mind	NN
22283	1061	39	--	--	:
22283	1061	40	something	something	NN
22283	1061	41	of	of	IN
22283	1061	42	the	the	DT
22283	1061	43	nature	nature	NN
22283	1061	44	of	of	IN
22283	1061	45	Fate	Fate	NNP
22283	1061	46	superior	superior	JJ
22283	1061	47	even	even	RB
22283	1061	48	to	to	IN
22283	1061	49	the	the	DT
22283	1061	50	gods	god	NNS
22283	1061	51	.	.	.
22283	1062	1	And	and	CC
22283	1062	2	,	,	,
22283	1062	3	no	no	RB
22283	1062	4	less	less	RBR
22283	1062	5	obviously	obviously	RB
22283	1062	6	,	,	,
22283	1062	7	if	if	IN
22283	1062	8	once	once	IN
22283	1062	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1062	10	see	see	VBP
22283	1062	11	any	any	DT
22283	1062	12	reason	reason	NN
22283	1062	13	to	to	TO
22283	1062	14	regard	regard	VB
22283	1062	15	the	the	DT
22283	1062	16	principle	principle	NN
22283	1062	17	of	of	IN
22283	1062	18	causality	causality	NN
22283	1062	19	as	as	IN
22283	1062	20	merely	merely	RB
22283	1062	21	co	co	JJ
22283	1062	22	-	-	JJ
22283	1062	23	extensive	extensive	JJ
22283	1062	24	with	with	IN
22283	1062	25	that	that	DT
22283	1062	26	of	of	IN
22283	1062	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	1062	28	,	,	,
22283	1062	29	the	the	DT
22283	1062	30	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1062	31	question	question	NN
22283	1062	32	as	as	IN
22283	1062	33	between	between	IN
22283	1062	34	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
22283	1062	35	and	and	CC
22283	1062	36	Free	Free	NNP
22283	1062	37	-	-	HYPH
22283	1062	38	will	will	NN
22283	1062	39	lapses	lapse	NNS
22283	1062	40	;	;	:
22283	1062	41	there	there	EX
22283	1062	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	1062	43	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1062	44	to	to	TO
22283	1062	45	show	show	VB
22283	1062	46	that	that	IN
22283	1062	47	a	a	DT
22283	1062	48	man	man	NN
22283	1062	49	's	's	POS
22283	1062	50	action	action	NN
22283	1062	51	in	in	IN
22283	1062	52	the	the	DT
22283	1062	53	past	past	NN
22283	1062	54	might	may	MD
22283	1062	55	not	not	RB
22283	1062	56	have	have	VB
22283	1062	57	been	be	VBN
22283	1062	58	other	other	JJ
22283	1062	59	than	than	IN
22283	1062	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1062	61	was	be	VBD
22283	1062	62	.	.	.
22283	1063	1	The	the	DT
22283	1063	2	only	only	JJ
22283	1063	3	outward	outward	JJ
22283	1063	4	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1063	5	placed	place	VBN
22283	1063	6	upon	upon	IN
22283	1063	7	the	the	DT
22283	1063	8	exercise	exercise	NN
22283	1063	9	of	of	IN
22283	1063	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1063	11	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1063	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1063	13	then	then	RB
22283	1063	14	seen	see	VBN
22283	1063	15	to	to	TO
22283	1063	16	be	be	VB
22283	1063	17	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	1063	18	by	by	IN
22283	1063	19	the	the	DT
22283	1063	20	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1063	21	of	of	IN
22283	1063	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1063	23	executive	executive	JJ
22283	1063	24	capacity	capacity	NN
22283	1063	25	,	,	,
22283	1063	26	and	and	CC
22283	1063	27	this	this	DT
22283	1063	28	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1063	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1063	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1063	31	that	that	DT
22283	1063	32	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
22283	1063	33	man	man	NN
22283	1063	34	a	a	DT
22283	1063	35	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1063	36	agent	agent	NN
22283	1063	37	.	.	.
22283	1064	1	On	on	IN
22283	1064	2	the	the	DT
22283	1064	3	other	other	JJ
22283	1064	4	hand	hand	NN
22283	1064	5	,	,	,
22283	1064	6	the	the	DT
22283	1064	7	structure	structure	NN
22283	1064	8	of	of	IN
22283	1064	9	conscience	conscience	NN
22283	1064	10	--	--	:
22283	1064	11	however	however	RB
22283	1064	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1064	13	may	may	MD
22283	1064	14	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	1064	15	this	this	DT
22283	1064	16	to	to	TO
22283	1064	17	have	have	VB
22283	1064	18	been	be	VBN
22283	1064	19	formed	form	VBN
22283	1064	20	--	--	:
22283	1064	21	imposes	impose	VBZ
22283	1064	22	that	that	IN
22283	1064	23	further	further	RB
22283	1064	24	and	and	CC
22283	1064	25	inward	inward	JJ
22283	1064	26	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1064	27	upon	upon	IN
22283	1064	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1064	29	Will	will	NN
22283	1064	30	,	,	,
22283	1064	31	which	which	WDT
22283	1064	32	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
22283	1064	33	man	man	NN
22283	1064	34	a	a	DT
22283	1064	35	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1064	36	agent	agent	NN
22283	1064	37	.	.	.
22283	1065	1	But	but	CC
22283	1065	2	neither	neither	DT
22283	1065	3	of	of	IN
22283	1065	4	these	these	DT
22283	1065	5	restraints	restraint	NNS
22283	1065	6	can	can	MD
22283	1065	7	properly	properly	RB
22283	1065	8	be	be	VB
22283	1065	9	said	say	VBN
22283	1065	10	to	to	TO
22283	1065	11	constitute	constitute	VB
22283	1065	12	bondage	bondage	VB
22283	1065	13	in	in	IN
22283	1065	14	the	the	DT
22283	1065	15	sense	sense	NN
22283	1065	16	required	require	VBN
22283	1065	17	by	by	IN
22283	1065	18	Necessitarianism	Necessitarianism	NNP
22283	1065	19	,	,	,
22283	1065	20	because	because	IN
22283	1065	21	neither	neither	DT
22283	1065	22	of	of	IN
22283	1065	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1065	24	requires	require	VBZ
22283	1065	25	that	that	IN
22283	1065	26	the	the	DT
22283	1065	27	man	man	NN
22283	1065	28	's	's	POS
22283	1065	29	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1065	30	must	must	MD
22283	1065	31	will	will	VB
22283	1065	32	as	as	IN
22283	1065	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1065	34	does	do	VBZ
22283	1065	35	will	will	MD
22283	1065	36	;	;	:
22283	1065	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1065	38	require	require	VBP
22283	1065	39	merely	merely	RB
22283	1065	40	that	that	IN
22283	1065	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1065	42	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1065	43	should	should	MD
22283	1065	44	act	act	VB
22283	1065	45	in	in	IN
22283	1065	46	certain	certain	JJ
22283	1065	47	ways	way	NNS
22283	1065	48	if	if	IN
22283	1065	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1065	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	1065	51	to	to	TO
22283	1065	52	accomplish	accomplish	VB
22283	1065	53	certain	certain	JJ
22283	1065	54	results	result	NNS
22283	1065	55	;	;	:
22283	1065	56	and	and	CC
22283	1065	57	to	to	IN
22283	1065	58	this	this	DT
22283	1065	59	extent	extent	NN
22283	1065	60	only	only	RB
22283	1065	61	is	be	VBZ
22283	1065	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1065	63	subject	subject	JJ
22283	1065	64	to	to	IN
22283	1065	65	law	law	NN
22283	1065	66	,	,	,
22283	1065	67	or	or	CC
22283	1065	68	to	to	IN
22283	1065	69	the	the	DT
22283	1065	70	incidence	incidence	NN
22283	1065	71	of	of	IN
22283	1065	72	those	those	DT
22283	1065	73	external	external	JJ
22283	1065	74	influences	influence	NNS
22283	1065	75	which	which	WDT
22283	1065	76	help	help	VBP
22283	1065	77	to	to	TO
22283	1065	78	shape	shape	VB
22283	1065	79	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1065	80	motives	motive	NNS
22283	1065	81	.	.	.
22283	1066	1	But	but	CC
22283	1066	2	if	if	IN
22283	1066	3	this	this	DT
22283	1066	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1066	5	so	so	RB
22283	1066	6	,	,	,
22283	1066	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1066	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1066	9	not	not	RB
22283	1066	10	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	1066	11	that	that	IN
22283	1066	12	the	the	DT
22283	1066	13	sense	sense	NN
22283	1066	14	of	of	IN
22283	1066	15	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1066	16	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1066	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	1066	18	rationally	rationally	RB
22283	1066	19	justified	justify	VBN
22283	1066	20	?	?	.
22283	1067	1	This	this	DT
22283	1067	2	sense	sense	NN
22283	1067	3	goes	go	VBZ
22283	1067	4	upon	upon	IN
22283	1067	5	the	the	DT
22283	1067	6	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	1067	7	that	that	IN
22283	1067	8	a	a	DT
22283	1067	9	man	man	NN
22283	1067	10	's	's	POS
22283	1067	11	conduct	conduct	NN
22283	1067	12	in	in	IN
22283	1067	13	the	the	DT
22283	1067	14	past	past	NN
22283	1067	15	might	may	MD
22283	1067	16	have	have	VB
22283	1067	17	been	be	VBN
22283	1067	18	different	different	JJ
22283	1067	19	from	from	IN
22283	1067	20	what	what	WP
22283	1067	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1067	22	was	be	VBD
22283	1067	23	.	.	.
22283	1068	1	Clearly	clearly	RB
22283	1068	2	,	,	,
22283	1068	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1068	4	,	,	,
22283	1068	5	no	no	DT
22283	1068	6	question	question	NN
22283	1068	7	of	of	IN
22283	1068	8	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1068	9	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1068	10	can	can	MD
22283	1068	11	ever	ever	RB
22283	1068	12	obtain	obtain	VB
22283	1068	13	in	in	IN
22283	1068	14	cases	case	NNS
22283	1068	15	where	where	WRB
22283	1068	16	the	the	DT
22283	1068	17	general	general	JJ
22283	1068	18	system	system	NN
22283	1068	19	of	of	IN
22283	1068	20	external	external	JJ
22283	1068	21	causation	causation	NN
22283	1068	22	,	,	,
22283	1068	23	or	or	CC
22283	1068	24	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1068	25	law	law	NN
22283	1068	26	,	,	,
22283	1068	27	rendered	render	VBD
22283	1068	28	an	an	DT
22283	1068	29	alternative	alternative	JJ
22283	1068	30	line	line	NN
22283	1068	31	of	of	IN
22283	1068	32	action	action	NN
22283	1068	33	physically	physically	RB
22283	1068	34	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1068	35	.	.	.
22283	1069	1	_	_	NNP
22283	1069	2	The	the	DT
22283	1069	3	question	question	NN
22283	1069	4	of	of	IN
22283	1069	5	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1069	6	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1069	7	can	can	MD
22283	1069	8	only	only	RB
22283	1069	9	obtain	obtain	VB
22283	1069	10	in	in	IN
22283	1069	11	cases	case	NNS
22283	1069	12	where	where	WRB
22283	1069	13	two	two	CD
22283	1069	14	or	or	CC
22283	1069	15	more	more	JJR
22283	1069	16	lines	line	NNS
22283	1069	17	of	of	IN
22283	1069	18	conduct	conduct	NN
22283	1069	19	were	be	VBD
22283	1069	20	alike	alike	RB
22283	1069	21	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1069	22	,	,	,
22283	1069	23	so	so	RB
22283	1069	24	far	far	RB
22283	1069	25	as	as	IN
22283	1069	26	the	the	DT
22283	1069	27	external	external	JJ
22283	1069	28	system	system	NN
22283	1069	29	of	of	IN
22283	1069	30	causation	causation	NN
22283	1069	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1069	32	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	1069	33	--	--	:
22283	1069	34	or	or	CC
22283	1069	35	where	where	WRB
22283	1069	36	the	the	DT
22283	1069	37	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1069	38	was	be	VBD
22283	1069	39	equally	equally	RB
22283	1069	40	free	free	JJ
22283	1069	41	to	to	TO
22283	1069	42	choose	choose	VB
22283	1069	43	between	between	IN
22283	1069	44	two	two	CD
22283	1069	45	or	or	CC
22283	1069	46	more	more	JJR
22283	1069	47	courses	course	NNS
22283	1069	48	of	of	IN
22283	1069	49	bodily	bodily	JJ
22283	1069	50	action	action	NN
22283	1069	51	.	.	.
22283	1069	52	_	_	NNP
22283	1069	53	In	in	IN
22283	1069	54	other	other	JJ
22283	1069	55	words	word	NNS
22283	1069	56	,	,	,
22283	1069	57	the	the	DT
22283	1069	58	question	question	NN
22283	1069	59	of	of	IN
22283	1069	60	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1069	61	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1069	62	has	have	VBZ
22283	1069	63	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1069	64	to	to	TO
22283	1069	65	do	do	VB
22283	1069	66	with	with	IN
22283	1069	67	the	the	DT
22283	1069	68	only	only	JJ
22283	1069	69	kind	kind	NN
22283	1069	70	of	of	RB
22283	1069	71	bondage	bondage	NN
22283	1069	72	to	to	IN
22283	1069	73	which	which	WDT
22283	1069	74	,	,	,
22283	1069	75	according	accord	VBG
22283	1069	76	to	to	IN
22283	1069	77	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1069	78	present	present	JJ
22283	1069	79	point	point	NN
22283	1069	80	of	of	IN
22283	1069	81	view	view	NN
22283	1069	82	,	,	,
22283	1069	83	the	the	DT
22283	1069	84	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1069	85	is	be	VBZ
22283	1069	86	subject	subject	JJ
22283	1069	87	--	--	:
22283	1069	88	namely	namely	RB
22283	1069	89	the	the	DT
22283	1069	90	bondage	bondage	NN
22283	1069	91	of	of	IN
22283	1069	92	being	be	VBG
22283	1069	93	rationally	rationally	RB
22283	1069	94	obliged	oblige	VBN
22283	1069	95	to	to	TO
22283	1069	96	will	will	VB
22283	1069	97	only	only	RB
22283	1069	98	what	what	WP
22283	1069	99	is	be	VBZ
22283	1069	100	capable	capable	JJ
22283	1069	101	of	of	IN
22283	1069	102	performance	performance	NN
22283	1069	103	.	.	.
22283	1070	1	The	the	DT
22283	1070	2	question	question	NN
22283	1070	3	of	of	IN
22283	1070	4	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1070	5	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1070	6	has	have	VBZ
22283	1070	7	only	only	RB
22283	1070	8	to	to	TO
22283	1070	9	do	do	VB
22283	1070	10	with	with	IN
22283	1070	11	the	the	DT
22283	1070	12	system	system	NN
22283	1070	13	of	of	IN
22283	1070	14	causation	causation	NN
22283	1070	15	which	which	WDT
22283	1070	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	1070	17	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	1070	18	in	in	IN
22283	1070	19	the	the	DT
22283	1070	20	mind	mind	NN
22283	1070	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1070	22	;	;	:
22283	1070	23	not	not	RB
22283	1070	24	with	with	IN
22283	1070	25	the	the	DT
22283	1070	26	system	system	NN
22283	1070	27	that	that	WDT
22283	1070	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	1070	29	external	external	JJ
22283	1070	30	to	to	IN
22283	1070	31	the	the	DT
22283	1070	32	mind	mind	NN
22283	1070	33	.	.	.
22283	1071	1	And	and	CC
22283	1071	2	as	as	IN
22283	1071	3	the	the	DT
22283	1071	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	1071	5	of	of	IN
22283	1071	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1071	7	identifies	identify	VBZ
22283	1071	8	the	the	DT
22283	1071	9	mind	mind	NN
22283	1071	10	with	with	IN
22283	1071	11	this	this	DT
22283	1071	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1071	13	own	own	JJ
22283	1071	14	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	1071	15	system	system	NN
22283	1071	16	of	of	IN
22283	1071	17	causation	causation	NN
22283	1071	18	--	--	:
22283	1071	19	or	or	CC
22283	1071	20	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	1071	21	a	a	DT
22283	1071	22	man	man	NN
22283	1071	23	's	's	POS
22283	1071	24	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1071	25	as	as	IN
22283	1071	26	the	the	DT
22283	1071	27	originator	originator	NN
22283	1071	28	of	of	IN
22283	1071	29	a	a	DT
22283	1071	30	particular	particular	JJ
22283	1071	31	portion	portion	NN
22283	1071	32	of	of	IN
22283	1071	33	general	general	JJ
22283	1071	34	causality	causality	NN
22283	1071	35	--	--	:
22283	1071	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1071	37	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1071	38	from	from	IN
22283	1071	39	the	the	DT
22283	1071	40	theory	theory	NN
22283	1071	41	that	that	IN
22283	1071	42	a	a	DT
22283	1071	43	man	man	NN
22283	1071	44	is	be	VBZ
22283	1071	45	justly	justly	RB
22283	1071	46	liable	liable	JJ
22283	1071	47	to	to	IN
22283	1071	48	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1071	49	praise	praise	NN
22283	1071	50	or	or	CC
22283	1071	51	blame	blame	NN
22283	1071	52	as	as	IN
22283	1071	53	the	the	DT
22283	1071	54	case	case	NN
22283	1071	55	may	may	MD
22283	1071	56	be	be	VB
22283	1071	57	:	:	:
22283	1071	58	the	the	DT
22283	1071	59	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1071	60	sense	sense	NN
22283	1071	61	no	no	RB
22283	1071	62	longer	long	RBR
22283	1071	63	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1071	64	as	as	IN
22283	1071	65	a	a	DT
22283	1071	66	gigantic	gigantic	JJ
22283	1071	67	illusion	illusion	NN
22283	1071	68	:	:	:
22283	1071	69	conscience	conscience	NN
22283	1071	70	is	be	VBZ
22283	1071	71	justified	justify	VBN
22283	1071	72	at	at	IN
22283	1071	73	the	the	DT
22283	1071	74	bar	bar	NN
22283	1071	75	of	of	IN
22283	1071	76	reason	reason	NN
22283	1071	77	.	.	.
22283	1072	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1072	2	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1072	3	to	to	IN
22283	1072	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1072	5	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1072	6	that	that	IN
22283	1072	7	any	any	DT
22283	1072	8	valid	valid	JJ
22283	1072	9	exception	exception	NN
22283	1072	10	can	can	MD
22283	1072	11	be	be	VB
22283	1072	12	taken	take	VBN
22283	1072	13	to	to	IN
22283	1072	14	the	the	DT
22283	1072	15	above	above	JJ
22283	1072	16	reasoning	reasoning	NN
22283	1072	17	,	,	,
22283	1072	18	if	if	IN
22283	1072	19	once	once	IN
22283	1072	20	the	the	DT
22283	1072	21	premiss	premiss	NNP
22283	1072	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1072	23	granted	grant	VBN
22283	1072	24	--	--	:
22283	1072	25	namely	namely	RB
22283	1072	26	,	,	,
22283	1072	27	that	that	IN
22283	1072	28	the	the	DT
22283	1072	29	principle	principle	NN
22283	1072	30	of	of	IN
22283	1072	31	Causality	Causality	NNP
22283	1072	32	admits	admit	NNS
22283	1072	33	of	of	IN
22283	1072	34	being	be	VBG
22283	1072	35	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1072	36	as	as	RB
22283	1072	37	identical	identical	JJ
22283	1072	38	with	with	IN
22283	1072	39	that	that	DT
22283	1072	40	of	of	IN
22283	1072	41	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1072	42	.	.	.
22283	1073	1	For	for	IN
22283	1073	2	if	if	IN
22283	1073	3	Cause	Cause	NNP
22283	1073	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1073	5	but	but	CC
22283	1073	6	another	another	DT
22283	1073	7	name	name	NN
22283	1073	8	for	for	IN
22283	1073	9	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1073	10	--	--	:
22283	1073	11	whether	whether	IN
22283	1073	12	the	the	DT
22283	1073	13	Will	Will	MD
22283	1073	14	be	be	VB
22283	1073	15	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	1073	16	or	or	CC
22283	1073	17	ejective	ejective	JJ
22283	1073	18	--	--	:
22283	1073	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1073	20	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1073	21	that	that	IN
22283	1073	22	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1073	23	will	will	NN
22283	1073	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	1073	25	a	a	DT
22283	1073	26	first	first	JJ
22283	1073	27	cause	cause	NN
22283	1073	28	,	,	,
22283	1073	29	which	which	WDT
22283	1073	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1073	31	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1073	32	by	by	IN
22283	1073	33	other	other	JJ
22283	1073	34	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1073	35	only	only	RB
22283	1073	36	in	in	IN
22283	1073	37	so	so	RB
22283	1073	38	far	far	RB
22283	1073	39	as	as	IN
22283	1073	40	the	the	DT
22283	1073	41	executive	executive	JJ
22283	1073	42	capacity	capacity	NN
22283	1073	43	of	of	IN
22283	1073	44	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1073	45	body	body	NN
22283	1073	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	1073	47	so	so	RB
22283	1073	48	determined	determined	JJ
22283	1073	49	.	.	.
22283	1074	1	As	as	IN
22283	1074	2	the	the	DT
22283	1074	3	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1074	4	stress	stress	NN
22283	1074	5	of	of	IN
22283	1074	6	any	any	DT
22283	1074	7	objection	objection	NN
22283	1074	8	to	to	IN
22283	1074	9	the	the	DT
22283	1074	10	present	present	JJ
22283	1074	11	argument	argument	NN
22283	1074	12	must	must	MD
22283	1074	13	thus	thus	RB
22283	1074	14	be	be	VB
22283	1074	15	brought	bring	VBN
22283	1074	16	to	to	TO
22283	1074	17	bear	bear	VB
22283	1074	18	upon	upon	IN
22283	1074	19	the	the	DT
22283	1074	20	validity	validity	NN
22283	1074	21	of	of	IN
22283	1074	22	this	this	DT
22283	1074	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1074	24	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	1074	25	premiss	premiss	NN
22283	1074	26	,	,	,
22283	1074	27	a	a	DT
22283	1074	28	few	few	JJ
22283	1074	29	words	word	NNS
22283	1074	30	may	may	MD
22283	1074	31	now	now	RB
22283	1074	32	be	be	VB
22283	1074	33	said	say	VBN
22283	1074	34	to	to	TO
22283	1074	35	show	show	VB
22283	1074	36	that	that	IN
22283	1074	37	the	the	DT
22283	1074	38	premiss	premiss	NNP
22283	1074	39	is	be	VBZ
22283	1074	40	not	not	RB
22283	1074	41	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	1074	42	gratuitous	gratuitous	JJ
22283	1074	43	.	.	.
22283	1075	1	Of	of	RB
22283	1075	2	course	course	RB
22283	1075	3	the	the	DT
22283	1075	4	reason	reason	NN
22283	1075	5	why	why	WRB
22283	1075	6	at	at	IN
22283	1075	7	first	first	JJ
22283	1075	8	sight	sight	NN
22283	1075	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1075	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1075	11	apt	apt	JJ
22283	1075	12	to	to	TO
22283	1075	13	appear	appear	VB
22283	1075	14	,	,	,
22283	1075	15	not	not	RB
22283	1075	16	only	only	RB
22283	1075	17	gratuitous	gratuitous	JJ
22283	1075	18	,	,	,
22283	1075	19	but	but	CC
22283	1075	20	even	even	RB
22283	1075	21	grotesque	grotesque	NN
22283	1075	22	,	,	,
22283	1075	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	1075	24	because	because	IN
22283	1075	25	in	in	IN
22283	1075	26	these	these	DT
22283	1075	27	days	day	NNS
22283	1075	28	of	of	IN
22283	1075	29	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1075	30	science	science	NN
22283	1075	31	the	the	DT
22283	1075	32	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1075	33	of	of	IN
22283	1075	34	most	most	JJS
22283	1075	35	of	of	IN
22283	1075	36	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1075	37	are	be	VBP
22283	1075	38	dominated	dominate	VBN
22283	1075	39	by	by	IN
22283	1075	40	the	the	DT
22283	1075	41	unthinking	unthinking	JJ
22283	1075	42	persuasion	persuasion	NN
22283	1075	43	that	that	IN
22283	1075	44	the	the	DT
22283	1075	45	principle	principle	NN
22283	1075	46	of	of	IN
22283	1075	47	causality	causality	NN
22283	1075	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	1075	49	the	the	DT
22283	1075	50	most	most	RBS
22283	1075	51	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1075	52	principle	principle	NN
22283	1075	53	which	which	WDT
22283	1075	54	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1075	55	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1075	56	can	can	MD
22283	1075	57	reach	reach	VB
22283	1075	58	.	.	.
22283	1076	1	Most	Most	JJS
22283	1076	2	of	of	IN
22283	1076	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1076	4	accept	accept	VBP
22283	1076	5	this	this	DT
22283	1076	6	persuasion	persuasion	NN
22283	1076	7	as	as	IN
22283	1076	8	almost	almost	RB
22283	1076	9	of	of	IN
22283	1076	10	the	the	DT
22283	1076	11	nature	nature	NN
22283	1076	12	of	of	IN
22283	1076	13	an	an	DT
22283	1076	14	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	1076	15	,	,	,
22283	1076	16	and	and	CC
22283	1076	17	hence	hence	RB
22283	1076	18	the	the	DT
22283	1076	19	mere	mere	JJ
22283	1076	20	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	1076	21	that	that	IN
22283	1076	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1076	23	own	own	JJ
22283	1076	24	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1076	25	are	be	VBP
22283	1076	26	really	really	RB
22283	1076	27	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1076	28	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1076	29	to	to	IN
22283	1076	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1076	31	of	of	IN
22283	1076	32	the	the	DT
22283	1076	33	nature	nature	NN
22283	1076	34	of	of	IN
22283	1076	35	a	a	DT
22283	1076	36	self	self	NN
22283	1076	37	-	-	HYPH
22283	1076	38	evident	evident	JJ
22283	1076	39	absurdity	absurdity	NN
22283	1076	40	.	.	.
22283	1077	1	A	a	DT
22283	1077	2	little	little	JJ
22283	1077	3	thought	thought	NN
22283	1077	4	,	,	,
22283	1077	5	however	however	RB
22283	1077	6	,	,	,
22283	1077	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1077	8	enough	enough	JJ
22283	1077	9	to	to	TO
22283	1077	10	show	show	VB
22283	1077	11	that	that	IN
22283	1077	12	the	the	DT
22283	1077	13	only	only	JJ
22283	1077	14	ground	ground	NN
22283	1077	15	of	of	IN
22283	1077	16	reason	reason	NN
22283	1077	17	which	which	WDT
22283	1077	18	this	this	DT
22283	1077	19	strong	strong	JJ
22283	1077	20	prepossession	prepossession	NN
22283	1077	21	can	can	MD
22283	1077	22	rest	rest	VB
22283	1077	23	upon	upon	IN
22283	1077	24	,	,	,
22283	1077	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	1077	26	the	the	DT
22283	1077	27	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	1077	28	that	that	IN
22283	1077	29	the	the	DT
22283	1077	30	principle	principle	NN
22283	1077	31	of	of	IN
22283	1077	32	causality	causality	NN
22283	1077	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	1077	34	logically	logically	RB
22283	1077	35	prior	prior	RB
22283	1077	36	to	to	IN
22283	1077	37	that	that	DT
22283	1077	38	of	of	IN
22283	1077	39	mind	mind	NN
22283	1077	40	.	.	.
22283	1078	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1078	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1078	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	1078	4	the	the	DT
22283	1078	5	validity	validity	NN
22283	1078	6	of	of	IN
22283	1078	7	this	this	DT
22283	1078	8	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	1078	9	that	that	IN
22283	1078	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1078	11	have	have	VBP
22283	1078	12	here	here	RB
22283	1078	13	to	to	TO
22283	1078	14	investigate	investigate	VB
22283	1078	15	.	.	.
22283	1079	1	In	in	IN
22283	1079	2	the	the	DT
22283	1079	3	first	first	JJ
22283	1079	4	place	place	NN
22283	1079	5	,	,	,
22283	1079	6	then	then	RB
22283	1079	7	,	,	,
22283	1079	8	the	the	DT
22283	1079	9	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	1079	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1079	11	_	_	NNP
22283	1079	12	ipso	ipso	FW
22283	1079	13	facto	facto	FW
22283	1079	14	_	_	NNP
22283	1079	15	irrational	irrational	NN
22283	1079	16	.	.	.
22283	1080	1	For	for	IN
22283	1080	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1080	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	1080	4	evident	evident	JJ
22283	1080	5	that	that	IN
22283	1080	6	in	in	IN
22283	1080	7	order	order	NN
22283	1080	8	to	to	TO
22283	1080	9	make	make	VB
22283	1080	10	the	the	DT
22283	1080	11	assumption	assumption	NN
22283	1080	12	there	there	EX
22283	1080	13	must	must	MD
22283	1080	14	already	already	RB
22283	1080	15	be	be	VB
22283	1080	16	a	a	DT
22283	1080	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	1080	18	to	to	TO
22283	1080	19	make	make	VB
22283	1080	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1080	21	.	.	.
22283	1081	1	In	in	IN
22283	1081	2	other	other	JJ
22283	1081	3	words	word	NNS
22283	1081	4	,	,	,
22283	1081	5	the	the	DT
22283	1081	6	very	very	JJ
22283	1081	7	conception	conception	NN
22283	1081	8	of	of	IN
22283	1081	9	the	the	DT
22283	1081	10	principle	principle	NN
22283	1081	11	of	of	IN
22283	1081	12	causality	causality	NN
22283	1081	13	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	1081	14	a	a	DT
22283	1081	15	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	1081	16	substance	substance	NN
22283	1081	17	wherein	wherein	WRB
22283	1081	18	that	that	IN
22283	1081	19	conception	conception	NN
22283	1081	20	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1081	21	,	,	,
22283	1081	22	and	and	CC
22283	1081	23	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1081	24	,	,	,
22283	1081	25	as	as	IN
22283	1081	26	a	a	DT
22283	1081	27	mere	mere	JJ
22283	1081	28	matter	matter	NN
22283	1081	29	of	of	IN
22283	1081	30	formal	formal	JJ
22283	1081	31	statement	statement	NN
22283	1081	32	,	,	,
22283	1081	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1081	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	1081	35	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1081	36	to	to	TO
22283	1081	37	assign	assign	VB
22283	1081	38	logical	logical	JJ
22283	1081	39	priority	priority	NN
22283	1081	40	to	to	IN
22283	1081	41	this	this	DT
22283	1081	42	conception	conception	NN
22283	1081	43	over	over	IN
22283	1081	44	the	the	DT
22283	1081	45	thing	thing	NN
22283	1081	46	whereby	whereby	WRB
22283	1081	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1081	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	1081	49	conceived	conceive	VBN
22283	1081	50	.	.	.
22283	1082	1	In	in	IN
22283	1082	2	the	the	DT
22283	1082	3	next	next	JJ
22283	1082	4	place	place	NN
22283	1082	5	,	,	,
22283	1082	6	when	when	WRB
22283	1082	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1082	8	carefully	carefully	RB
22283	1082	9	analyze	analyze	VBP
22283	1082	10	the	the	DT
22283	1082	11	nature	nature	NN
22283	1082	12	of	of	IN
22283	1082	13	this	this	DT
22283	1082	14	conception	conception	NN
22283	1082	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1082	16	,	,	,
22283	1082	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1082	18	find	find	VBP
22283	1082	19	that	that	IN
22283	1082	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1082	21	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1082	22	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	1082	23	out	out	IN
22283	1082	24	of	of	IN
22283	1082	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1082	26	conception	conception	NN
22283	1082	27	of	of	IN
22283	1082	28	Being	be	VBG
22283	1082	29	as	as	IN
22283	1082	30	Being	be	VBG
22283	1082	31	.	.	.
22283	1083	1	This	this	DT
22283	1083	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1083	3	shown	show	VBN
22283	1083	4	by	by	IN
22283	1083	5	the	the	DT
22283	1083	6	idea	idea	NN
22283	1083	7	of	of	IN
22283	1083	8	_	_	NNP
22283	1083	9	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	1083	10	_	_	NNP
22283	1083	11	between	between	IN
22283	1083	12	cause	cause	NN
22283	1083	13	and	and	CC
22283	1083	14	effect	effect	NN
22283	1083	15	,	,	,
22283	1083	16	which	which	WDT
22283	1083	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	1083	18	an	an	DT
22283	1083	19	essential	essential	JJ
22283	1083	20	feature	feature	NN
22283	1083	21	of	of	IN
22283	1083	22	the	the	DT
22283	1083	23	conception	conception	NN
22283	1083	24	of	of	IN
22283	1083	25	causality	causality	NN
22283	1083	26	as	as	IN
22283	1083	27	such	such	JJ
22283	1083	28	.	.	.
22283	1084	1	In	in	IN
22283	1084	2	other	other	JJ
22283	1084	3	words	word	NNS
22283	1084	4	,	,	,
22283	1084	5	the	the	DT
22283	1084	6	statement	statement	NN
22283	1084	7	of	of	IN
22283	1084	8	any	any	DT
22283	1084	9	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1084	10	relation	relation	NN
22283	1084	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	1084	12	merely	merely	RB
22283	1084	13	a	a	DT
22283	1084	14	statement	statement	NN
22283	1084	15	of	of	IN
22283	1084	16	the	the	DT
22283	1084	17	fact	fact	NN
22283	1084	18	that	that	IN
22283	1084	19	both	both	CC
22283	1084	20	the	the	DT
22283	1084	21	matter	matter	NN
22283	1084	22	and	and	CC
22283	1084	23	the	the	DT
22283	1084	24	energy	energy	NN
22283	1084	25	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	1084	26	in	in	IN
22283	1084	27	the	the	DT
22283	1084	28	event	event	NN
22283	1084	29	were	be	VBD
22283	1084	30	of	of	IN
22283	1084	31	a	a	DT
22283	1084	32	permanent	permanent	JJ
22283	1084	33	nature	nature	NN
22283	1084	34	and	and	CC
22283	1084	35	unalterable	unalterable	JJ
22283	1084	36	amount	amount	NN
22283	1084	37	.	.	.
22283	1085	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1085	2	,	,	,
22283	1085	3	_	_	NNP
22283	1085	4	if	if	IN
22283	1085	5	_	_	NNP
22283	1085	6	the	the	DT
22283	1085	7	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1085	8	Reality	reality	NN
22283	1085	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1085	10	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1085	11	,	,	,
22283	1085	12	Causation	Causation	NNP
22283	1085	13	_	_	NNP
22283	1085	14	must	must	MD
22283	1085	15	_	_	NNP
22283	1085	16	be	be	VB
22283	1085	17	ontologically	ontologically	RB
22283	1085	18	identical	identical	JJ
22283	1085	19	with	with	IN
22283	1085	20	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1085	21	.	.	.
22283	1086	1	And	and	CC
22283	1086	2	that	that	IN
22283	1086	3	the	the	DT
22283	1086	4	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1086	5	Reality	reality	NN
22283	1086	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1086	7	either	either	CC
22283	1086	8	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1086	9	,	,	,
22283	1086	10	or	or	CC
22283	1086	11	something	something	NN
22283	1086	12	greater	great	JJR
22283	1086	13	,	,	,
22283	1086	14	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	1086	15	to	to	TO
22283	1086	16	be	be	VB
22283	1086	17	proved	prove	VBN
22283	1086	18	by	by	IN
22283	1086	19	the	the	DT
22283	1086	20	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	1086	21	that	that	IN
22283	1086	22	if	if	IN
22283	1086	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1086	24	be	be	VB
22283	1086	25	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	1086	26	anything	anything	NN
22283	1086	27	_	_	NNP
22283	1086	28	less	less	RBR
22283	1086	29	_	_	NNP
22283	1086	30	,	,	,
22283	1086	31	there	there	EX
22283	1086	32	must	must	MD
22283	1086	33	be	be	VB
22283	1086	34	an	an	DT
22283	1086	35	end	end	NN
22283	1086	36	of	of	IN
22283	1086	37	the	the	DT
22283	1086	38	conception	conception	NN
22283	1086	39	of	of	IN
22283	1086	40	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	1086	41	as	as	IN
22283	1086	42	between	between	IN
22283	1086	43	cause	cause	NN
22283	1086	44	and	and	CC
22283	1086	45	effect	effect	NN
22283	1086	46	,	,	,
22283	1086	47	and	and	CC
22283	1086	48	so	so	RB
22283	1086	49	of	of	IN
22283	1086	50	the	the	DT
22283	1086	51	conception	conception	NN
22283	1086	52	of	of	IN
22283	1086	53	causality	causality	NN
22283	1086	54	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1086	55	;	;	:
22283	1086	56	for	for	IN
22283	1086	57	,	,	,
22283	1086	58	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	1086	59	,	,	,
22283	1086	60	if	if	IN
22283	1086	61	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1086	62	mind	mind	NN
22283	1086	63	has	have	VBZ
22283	1086	64	been	be	VBN
22283	1086	65	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1086	66	by	by	IN
22283	1086	67	anything	anything	NN
22283	1086	68	less	less	JJR
22283	1086	69	than	than	IN
22283	1086	70	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1086	71	,	,	,
22283	1086	72	there	there	EX
22283	1086	73	is	be	VBZ
22283	1086	74	an	an	DT
22283	1086	75	end	end	NN
22283	1086	76	of	of	IN
22283	1086	77	any	any	DT
22283	1086	78	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1086	79	equivalency	equivalency	NN
22283	1086	80	between	between	IN
22283	1086	81	the	the	DT
22283	1086	82	activity	activity	NN
22283	1086	83	of	of	IN
22283	1086	84	that	that	DT
22283	1086	85	thing	thing	NN
22283	1086	86	as	as	IN
22283	1086	87	a	a	DT
22283	1086	88	cause	cause	NN
22283	1086	89	,	,	,
22283	1086	90	and	and	CC
22283	1086	91	the	the	DT
22283	1086	92	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	1086	93	of	of	IN
22283	1086	94	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1086	95	mind	mind	NN
22283	1086	96	as	as	IN
22283	1086	97	an	an	DT
22283	1086	98	effect[13	effect[13	NN
22283	1086	99	]	]	-RRB-
22283	1086	100	.	.	.
22283	1087	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	1087	2	,	,	,
22283	1087	3	the	the	DT
22283	1087	4	conception	conception	NN
22283	1087	5	of	of	IN
22283	1087	6	causality	causality	NN
22283	1087	7	essentially	essentially	RB
22283	1087	8	involves	involve	VBZ
22283	1087	9	the	the	DT
22283	1087	10	idea	idea	NN
22283	1087	11	of	of	IN
22283	1087	12	finality	finality	NN
22283	1087	13	as	as	IN
22283	1087	14	existing	exist	VBG
22283	1087	15	somewhere	somewhere	RB
22283	1087	16	.	.	.
22283	1088	1	Here	here	RB
22283	1088	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1088	3	can	can	MD
22283	1088	4	not	not	RB
22283	1088	5	do	do	VB
22283	1088	6	better	well	RBR
22283	1088	7	than	than	IN
22283	1088	8	quote	quote	VB
22283	1088	9	some	some	DT
22283	1088	10	extracts	extract	NNS
22283	1088	11	from	from	IN
22283	1088	12	Canon	Canon	NNP
22283	1088	13	Mozley	Mozley	NNP
22283	1088	14	's	's	POS
22283	1088	15	essay	essay	NN
22283	1088	16	on	on	IN
22283	1088	17	'	'	''
22283	1088	18	The	the	DT
22283	1088	19	Principle	Principle	NNP
22283	1088	20	of	of	IN
22283	1088	21	Causation	Causation	NNP
22283	1088	22	,	,	,
22283	1088	23	'	'	''
22283	1088	24	as	as	IN
22283	1088	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1088	26	manages	manage	VBZ
22283	1088	27	very	very	RB
22283	1088	28	tersely	tersely	RB
22283	1088	29	to	to	TO
22283	1088	30	convey	convey	VB
22283	1088	31	the	the	DT
22283	1088	32	gist	gist	NN
22283	1088	33	of	of	IN
22283	1088	34	previous	previous	JJ
22283	1088	35	philosophizing	philosophizing	NN
22283	1088	36	upon	upon	IN
22283	1088	37	this	this	DT
22283	1088	38	subject	subject	NN
22283	1088	39	.	.	.
22283	1089	1	'	'	``
22283	1089	2	He	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1089	3	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1089	4	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
22283	1089	5	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1089	6	brings	bring	VBZ
22283	1089	7	out	out	RP
22283	1089	8	simply	simply	RB
22283	1089	9	at	at	IN
22283	1089	10	bottom	bottom	NN
22283	1089	11	the	the	DT
22283	1089	12	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	1089	13	and	and	CC
22283	1089	14	significance	significance	NN
22283	1089	15	of	of	IN
22283	1089	16	an	an	DT
22283	1089	17	idea	idea	NN
22283	1089	18	in	in	IN
22283	1089	19	the	the	DT
22283	1089	20	human	human	JJ
22283	1089	21	mind	mind	NN
22283	1089	22	,	,	,
22283	1089	23	that	that	IN
22283	1089	24	there	there	EX
22283	1089	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	1089	26	implied	imply	VBN
22283	1089	27	in	in	IN
22283	1089	28	the	the	DT
22283	1089	29	very	very	JJ
22283	1089	30	idea	idea	NN
22283	1089	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1089	32	of	of	IN
22283	1089	33	cause	cause	NN
22283	1089	34	,	,	,
22283	1089	35	firstly	firstly	RB
22283	1089	36	,	,	,
22283	1089	37	that	that	IN
22283	1089	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1089	39	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	1089	40	something	something	NN
22283	1089	41	else	else	RB
22283	1089	42	;	;	:
22283	1089	43	and	and	CC
22283	1089	44	secondly	secondly	RB
22283	1089	45	,	,	,
22283	1089	46	that	that	IN
22283	1089	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1089	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	1089	49	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1089	50	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1089	51	....	....	.
22283	1089	52	An	an	DT
22283	1089	53	infinite	infinite	JJ
22283	1089	54	series	series	NN
22283	1089	55	of	of	IN
22283	1089	56	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1089	57	does	do	VBZ
22283	1089	58	not	not	RB
22283	1089	59	make	make	VB
22283	1089	60	a	a	DT
22283	1089	61	cause	cause	NN
22283	1089	62	;	;	:
22283	1089	63	...	...	:
22283	1089	64	an	an	DT
22283	1089	65	infinite	infinite	JJ
22283	1089	66	succession	succession	NN
22283	1089	67	of	of	IN
22283	1089	68	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1089	69	rests	rest	NNS
22283	1089	70	,	,	,
22283	1089	71	by	by	IN
22283	1089	72	the	the	DT
22283	1089	73	very	very	JJ
22283	1089	74	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	1089	75	,	,	,
22283	1089	76	upon	upon	IN
22283	1089	77	no	no	DT
22283	1089	78	cause	cause	NN
22283	1089	79	;	;	:
22283	1089	80	each	each	DT
22283	1089	81	particular	particular	JJ
22283	1089	82	one	one	NN
22283	1089	83	rests	rest	VBZ
22283	1089	84	on	on	IN
22283	1089	85	the	the	DT
22283	1089	86	one	one	NN
22283	1089	87	which	which	WDT
22283	1089	88	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1089	89	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1089	90	,	,	,
22283	1089	91	but	but	CC
22283	1089	92	the	the	DT
22283	1089	93	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1089	94	rests	rest	VBZ
22283	1089	95	upon	upon	IN
22283	1089	96	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1089	97	....	....	.
22283	1090	1	If	if	IN
22283	1090	2	from	from	IN
22283	1090	3	one	one	CD
22283	1090	4	cause	cause	IN
22283	1090	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1090	6	have	have	VBP
22283	1090	7	to	to	TO
22283	1090	8	go	go	VB
22283	1090	9	back	back	RB
22283	1090	10	to	to	IN
22283	1090	11	another	another	DT
22283	1090	12	,	,	,
22283	1090	13	that	that	IN
22283	1090	14	which	which	WDT
22283	1090	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1090	16	go	go	VBP
22283	1090	17	back	back	RB
22283	1090	18	from	from	IN
22283	1090	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	1090	20	not	not	RB
22283	1090	21	the	the	DT
22283	1090	22	cause	cause	NN
22283	1090	23	,	,	,
22283	1090	24	but	but	CC
22283	1090	25	that	that	IN
22283	1090	26	which	which	WDT
22283	1090	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1090	28	go	go	VBP
22283	1090	29	back	back	RB
22283	1090	30	to	to	IN
22283	1090	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1090	32	.	.	.
22283	1091	1	The	the	DT
22283	1091	2	very	very	JJ
22283	1091	3	idea	idea	NN
22283	1091	4	of	of	IN
22283	1091	5	cause	cause	NN
22283	1091	6	,	,	,
22283	1091	7	as	as	IN
22283	1091	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1091	9	have	have	VBP
22283	1091	10	said	say	VBD
22283	1091	11	,	,	,
22283	1091	12	implies	imply	VBZ
22283	1091	13	a	a	DT
22283	1091	14	stop	stop	NN
22283	1091	15	;	;	:
22283	1091	16	and	and	CC
22283	1091	17	wherever	wherever	WRB
22283	1091	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1091	19	stop	stop	VBP
22283	1091	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	1091	21	the	the	DT
22283	1091	22	cause	cause	NN
22283	1091	23	....	....	.
22283	1091	24	A	a	DT
22283	1091	25	true	true	JJ
22283	1091	26	cause	cause	NN
22283	1091	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	1091	28	a	a	DT
22283	1091	29	First	first	JJ
22283	1091	30	Cause	Cause	NNP
22283	1091	31	....	....	.
22283	1092	1	The	the	DT
22283	1092	2	atheistic	atheistic	JJ
22283	1092	3	idea	idea	NN
22283	1092	4	thus	thus	RB
22283	1092	5	does	do	VBZ
22283	1092	6	not	not	RB
22283	1092	7	correspond	correspond	VB
22283	1092	8	to	to	IN
22283	1092	9	the	the	DT
22283	1092	10	idea	idea	NN
22283	1092	11	of	of	IN
22283	1092	12	reason	reason	NN
22283	1092	13	.	.	.
22283	1093	1	The	the	DT
22283	1093	2	atheist	atheist	NN
22283	1093	3	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1093	4	to	to	TO
22283	1093	5	acknowledge	acknowledge	VB
22283	1093	6	the	the	DT
22283	1093	7	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1093	8	of	of	IN
22283	1093	9	a	a	DT
22283	1093	10	cause	cause	NN
22283	1093	11	,	,	,
22283	1093	12	and	and	CC
22283	1093	13	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1093	14	to	to	TO
22283	1093	15	provide	provide	VB
22283	1093	16	for	for	IN
22283	1093	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	18	;	;	:
22283	1093	19	but	but	CC
22283	1093	20	when	when	WRB
22283	1093	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	22	come	come	VBP
22283	1093	23	to	to	IN
22283	1093	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1093	25	scheme	scheme	NN
22283	1093	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	27	fails	fail	VBZ
22283	1093	28	exactly	exactly	RB
22283	1093	29	in	in	IN
22283	1093	30	that	that	DT
22283	1093	31	part	part	NN
22283	1093	32	of	of	IN
22283	1093	33	the	the	DT
22283	1093	34	idea	idea	NN
22283	1093	35	which	which	WDT
22283	1093	36	clenches	clench	VBZ
22283	1093	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	38	,	,	,
22283	1093	39	and	and	CC
22283	1093	40	which	which	WDT
22283	1093	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	1093	42	essential	essential	JJ
22283	1093	43	to	to	IN
22283	1093	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1093	45	integrity	integrity	NN
22283	1093	46	;	;	:
22283	1093	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	48	fails	fail	VBZ
22283	1093	49	in	in	IN
22283	1093	50	providing	provide	VBG
22283	1093	51	a	a	DT
22283	1093	52	stop	stop	NN
22283	1093	53	;	;	:
22283	1093	54	...	...	:
22283	1093	55	One	one	PRP
22283	1093	56	might	may	MD
22283	1093	57	say	say	VB
22283	1093	58	to	to	IN
22283	1093	59	him	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	60	,	,	,
22283	1093	61	Why	why	WRB
22283	1093	62	do	do	VBP
22283	1093	63	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	64	give	give	VB
22283	1093	65	yourself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1093	66	the	the	DT
22283	1093	67	trouble	trouble	NN
22283	1093	68	to	to	TO
22283	1093	69	supply	supply	VB
22283	1093	70	causation	causation	NN
22283	1093	71	at	at	RB
22283	1093	72	all	all	RB
22283	1093	73	?	?	.
22283	1094	1	You	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1094	2	do	do	VBP
22283	1094	3	so	so	RB
22283	1094	4	because	because	IN
22283	1094	5	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1094	6	consider	consider	VBP
22283	1094	7	yourself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1094	8	obliged	oblige	VBN
22283	1094	9	in	in	IN
22283	1094	10	reason	reason	NN
22283	1094	11	to	to	TO
22283	1094	12	do	do	VB
22283	1094	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1094	14	,	,	,
22283	1094	15	but	but	CC
22283	1094	16	if	if	IN
22283	1094	17	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1094	18	supply	supply	VBP
22283	1094	19	causation	causation	NN
22283	1094	20	at	at	RB
22283	1094	21	all	all	RB
22283	1094	22	,	,	,
22283	1094	23	why	why	WRB
22283	1094	24	not	not	RB
22283	1094	25	furnish	furnish	VB
22283	1094	26	such	such	PDT
22283	1094	27	a	a	DT
22283	1094	28	cause	cause	NN
22283	1094	29	as	as	IN
22283	1094	30	reason	reason	NN
22283	1094	31	has	have	VBZ
22283	1094	32	impressed	impress	VBN
22283	1094	33	upon	upon	IN
22283	1094	34	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1094	35	,	,	,
22283	1094	36	and	and	CC
22283	1094	37	which	which	WDT
22283	1094	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	1094	39	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	1094	40	in	in	IN
22283	1094	41	your	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1094	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	1094	43	--	--	:
22283	1094	44	a	a	DT
22283	1094	45	cause	cause	NN
22283	1094	46	which	which	WDT
22283	1094	47	stands	stand	VBZ
22283	1094	48	still	still	RB
22283	1094	49	,	,	,
22283	1094	50	an	an	DT
22283	1094	51	original	original	JJ
22283	1094	52	cause	cause	NN
22283	1094	53	?	?	.
22283	1095	1	If	if	IN
22283	1095	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1095	3	never	never	RB
22283	1095	4	intended	intend	VBD
22283	1095	5	to	to	TO
22283	1095	6	supply	supply	VB
22283	1095	7	this	this	DT
22283	1095	8	,	,	,
22283	1095	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1095	10	must	must	MD
22283	1095	11	have	have	VB
22283	1095	12	been	be	VBN
22283	1095	13	because	because	IN
22283	1095	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1095	15	thought	think	VBD
22283	1095	16	a	a	DT
22283	1095	17	real	real	JJ
22283	1095	18	cause	cause	NN
22283	1095	19	was	be	VBD
22283	1095	20	not	not	RB
22283	1095	21	wanted	want	VBN
22283	1095	22	;	;	:
22283	1095	23	but	but	CC
22283	1095	24	if	if	IN
22283	1095	25	you	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1095	26	thought	think	VBD
22283	1095	27	a	a	DT
22283	1095	28	cause	cause	NN
22283	1095	29	not	not	RB
22283	1095	30	wanted	want	VBN
22283	1095	31	,	,	,
22283	1095	32	why	why	WRB
22283	1095	33	not	not	RB
22283	1095	34	have	have	VBP
22283	1095	35	said	say	VBN
22283	1095	36	from	from	IN
22283	1095	37	the	the	DT
22283	1095	38	first	first	JJ
22283	1095	39	that	that	WDT
22283	1095	40	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1095	41	were	be	VBD
22283	1095	42	not	not	RB
22283	1095	43	wanted	want	VBN
22283	1095	44	,	,	,
22283	1095	45	and	and	CC
22283	1095	46	said	say	VBD
22283	1095	47	from	from	IN
22283	1095	48	the	the	DT
22283	1095	49	first	first	JJ
22283	1095	50	that	that	IN
22283	1095	51	events	event	NNS
22283	1095	52	could	could	MD
22283	1095	53	take	take	VB
22283	1095	54	place	place	NN
22283	1095	55	without	without	IN
22283	1095	56	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1095	57	?	?	.
22283	1095	58	'	'	''
22283	1096	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1096	2	,	,	,
22283	1096	3	to	to	TO
22283	1096	4	quote	quote	VB
22283	1096	5	a	a	DT
22283	1096	6	more	more	RBR
22283	1096	7	recent	recent	JJ
22283	1096	8	authority	authority	NN
22283	1096	9	,	,	,
22283	1096	10	and	and	CC
22283	1096	11	one	one	CD
22283	1096	12	speaking	speak	VBG
22283	1096	13	from	from	IN
22283	1096	14	the	the	DT
22283	1096	15	side	side	NN
22283	1096	16	of	of	IN
22283	1096	17	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1096	18	science	science	NN
22283	1096	19	,	,	,
22283	1096	20	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
22283	1096	21	Huxley	Huxley	NNP
22283	1096	22	writes:--	writes:--	VBD
22283	1096	23	'	'	''
22283	1096	24	The	the	DT
22283	1096	25	student	student	NN
22283	1096	26	of	of	IN
22283	1096	27	nature	nature	NN
22283	1096	28	who	who	WP
22283	1096	29	starts	start	VBZ
22283	1096	30	from	from	IN
22283	1096	31	the	the	DT
22283	1096	32	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	1096	33	of	of	IN
22283	1096	34	the	the	DT
22283	1096	35	universality	universality	NN
22283	1096	36	of	of	IN
22283	1096	37	the	the	DT
22283	1096	38	law	law	NN
22283	1096	39	of	of	IN
22283	1096	40	causation	causation	NN
22283	1096	41	,	,	,
22283	1096	42	can	can	MD
22283	1096	43	not	not	RB
22283	1096	44	refuse	refuse	VB
22283	1096	45	to	to	TO
22283	1096	46	admit	admit	VB
22283	1096	47	an	an	DT
22283	1096	48	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	1096	49	existence	existence	NN
22283	1096	50	;	;	:
22283	1096	51	if	if	IN
22283	1096	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1096	53	admits	admit	VBZ
22283	1096	54	the	the	DT
22283	1096	55	conservation	conservation	NN
22283	1096	56	of	of	IN
22283	1096	57	energy	energy	NN
22283	1096	58	,	,	,
22283	1096	59	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1096	60	can	can	MD
22283	1096	61	not	not	RB
22283	1096	62	deny	deny	VB
22283	1096	63	the	the	DT
22283	1096	64	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	1096	65	of	of	IN
22283	1096	66	an	an	DT
22283	1096	67	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	1096	68	energy	energy	NN
22283	1096	69	;	;	:
22283	1096	70	if	if	IN
22283	1096	71	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1096	72	admits	admit	VBZ
22283	1096	73	the	the	DT
22283	1096	74	existence	existence	NN
22283	1096	75	of	of	IN
22283	1096	76	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
22283	1096	77	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	1096	78	in	in	IN
22283	1096	79	the	the	DT
22283	1096	80	form	form	NN
22283	1096	81	of	of	IN
22283	1096	82	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	1096	83	,	,	,
22283	1096	84	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1096	85	must	must	MD
22283	1096	86	admit	admit	VB
22283	1096	87	the	the	DT
22283	1096	88	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	1096	89	,	,	,
22283	1096	90	at	at	IN
22283	1096	91	any	any	DT
22283	1096	92	rate	rate	NN
22283	1096	93	,	,	,
22283	1096	94	of	of	IN
22283	1096	95	an	an	DT
22283	1096	96	eternal	eternal	JJ
22283	1096	97	series	series	NN
22283	1096	98	of	of	IN
22283	1096	99	such	such	JJ
22283	1096	100	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
22283	1096	101	;	;	:
22283	1096	102	and	and	CC
22283	1096	103	,	,	,
22283	1096	104	if	if	IN
22283	1096	105	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1096	106	studies	study	NNS
22283	1096	107	have	have	VBP
22283	1096	108	not	not	RB
22283	1096	109	been	be	VBN
22283	1096	110	barren	barren	JJ
22283	1096	111	of	of	IN
22283	1096	112	the	the	DT
22283	1096	113	best	good	JJS
22283	1096	114	fruit	fruit	NN
22283	1096	115	of	of	IN
22283	1096	116	the	the	DT
22283	1096	117	investigation	investigation	NN
22283	1096	118	of	of	IN
22283	1096	119	nature	nature	NN
22283	1096	120	,	,	,
22283	1096	121	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1096	122	will	will	MD
22283	1096	123	have	have	VB
22283	1096	124	enough	enough	JJ
22283	1096	125	sense	sense	NN
22283	1096	126	to	to	TO
22283	1096	127	see	see	VB
22283	1096	128	that	that	DT
22283	1096	129	,	,	,
22283	1096	130	when	when	WRB
22283	1096	131	Spinoza	Spinoza	NNP
22283	1096	132	says	say	VBZ
22283	1096	133	,	,	,
22283	1096	134	"	"	``
22283	1096	135	Per	per	IN
22283	1096	136	Deum	Deum	NNP
22283	1096	137	intelligo	intelligo	VBZ
22283	1096	138	ens	ens	NNP
22283	1096	139	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	1096	140	infinitum	infinitum	NNP
22283	1096	141	,	,	,
22283	1096	142	hoc	hoc	FW
22283	1096	143	est	est	NNP
22283	1096	144	substantiam	substantiam	NNP
22283	1096	145	constantem	constantem	NNP
22283	1096	146	infinitis	infinitis	NNP
22283	1096	147	attributis	attributis	NNP
22283	1096	148	,	,	,
22283	1096	149	"	"	''
22283	1096	150	the	the	DT
22283	1096	151	God	God	NNP
22283	1096	152	so	so	RB
22283	1096	153	conceived	conceive	VBD
22283	1096	154	is	be	VBZ
22283	1096	155	one	one	NN
22283	1096	156	that	that	WDT
22283	1096	157	only	only	RB
22283	1096	158	a	a	DT
22283	1096	159	very	very	RB
22283	1096	160	great	great	JJ
22283	1096	161	fool	fool	NN
22283	1096	162	would	would	MD
22283	1096	163	deny	deny	VB
22283	1096	164	,	,	,
22283	1096	165	even	even	RB
22283	1096	166	in	in	IN
22283	1096	167	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1096	168	heart	heart	NN
22283	1096	169	.	.	.
22283	1097	1	Physical	physical	JJ
22283	1097	2	science	science	NN
22283	1097	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	1097	4	as	as	RB
22283	1097	5	little	little	JJ
22283	1097	6	Atheistic	atheistic	JJ
22283	1097	7	as	as	IN
22283	1097	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1097	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1097	10	Materialistic[14	materialistic[14	ADD
22283	1097	11	]	]	-RRB-
22283	1097	12	.	.	.
22283	1097	13	'	'	''
22283	1098	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1098	2	,	,	,
22283	1098	3	if	if	IN
22283	1098	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1098	5	thus	thus	RB
22283	1098	6	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	1098	7	to	to	IN
22283	1098	8	the	the	DT
22283	1098	9	essence	essence	NN
22283	1098	10	of	of	IN
22283	1098	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1098	12	idea	idea	NN
22283	1098	13	of	of	IN
22283	1098	14	causation	causation	NN
22283	1098	15	that	that	DT
22283	1098	16	finality	finality	NN
22283	1098	17	must	must	MD
22283	1098	18	be	be	VB
22283	1098	19	reached	reach	VBN
22283	1098	20	somewhere	somewhere	RB
22283	1098	21	,	,	,
22283	1098	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1098	23	do	do	VBP
22283	1098	24	not	not	RB
22283	1098	25	know	know	VB
22283	1098	26	where	where	WRB
22283	1098	27	this	this	DT
22283	1098	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	1098	29	so	so	RB
22283	1098	30	likely	likely	JJ
22283	1098	31	to	to	TO
22283	1098	32	be	be	VB
22283	1098	33	reached	reach	VBN
22283	1098	34	as	as	IN
22283	1098	35	at	at	IN
22283	1098	36	that	that	DT
22283	1098	37	principle	principle	NN
22283	1098	38	wherein	wherein	WRB
22283	1098	39	the	the	DT
22283	1098	40	idea	idea	NN
22283	1098	41	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1098	42	takes	take	VBZ
22283	1098	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1098	44	rise	rise	NN
22283	1098	45	--	--	:
22283	1098	46	viz	viz	NN
22283	1098	47	.	.	.
22283	1099	1	Mind	mind	NN
22283	1099	2	.	.	.
22283	1100	1	But	but	CC
22283	1100	2	,	,	,
22283	1100	3	if	if	IN
22283	1100	4	so	so	RB
22283	1100	5	,	,	,
22283	1100	6	the	the	DT
22283	1100	7	statement	statement	NN
22283	1100	8	that	that	IN
22283	1100	9	any	any	DT
22283	1100	10	particular	particular	JJ
22283	1100	11	acts	act	NNS
22283	1100	12	of	of	IN
22283	1100	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	1100	14	are	be	VBP
22283	1100	15	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1100	16	ceases	cease	NNS
22283	1100	17	to	to	TO
22283	1100	18	present	present	VB
22283	1100	19	any	any	DT
22283	1100	20	character	character	NN
22283	1100	21	of	of	IN
22283	1100	22	self	self	NN
22283	1100	23	-	-	HYPH
22283	1100	24	evident	evident	JJ
22283	1100	25	absurdity	absurdity	NN
22283	1100	26	.	.	.
22283	1101	1	And	and	CC
22283	1101	2	the	the	DT
22283	1101	3	argument	argument	NN
22283	1101	4	need	nee	MD
22283	1101	5	not	not	RB
22283	1101	6	end	end	VB
22283	1101	7	here	here	RB
22283	1101	8	.	.	.
22283	1102	1	For	for	IN
22283	1102	2	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
22283	1102	3	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
22283	1102	4	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
22283	1102	5	has	have	VBZ
22283	1102	6	shown	show	VBN
22283	1102	7	that	that	IN
22283	1102	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1102	9	idea	idea	NN
22283	1102	10	of	of	IN
22283	1102	11	causation	causation	NN
22283	1102	12	,	,	,
22283	1102	13	not	not	RB
22283	1102	14	merely	merely	RB
22283	1102	15	requires	require	VBZ
22283	1102	16	a	a	DT
22283	1102	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	1102	18	for	for	IN
22283	1102	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1102	20	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	1102	21	,	,	,
22283	1102	22	but	but	CC
22283	1102	23	that	that	IN
22283	1102	24	in	in	IN
22283	1102	25	every	every	DT
22283	1102	26	mind	mind	NN
22283	1102	27	where	where	WRB
22283	1102	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1102	29	does	do	VBZ
22283	1102	30	occur	occur	VB
22283	1102	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1102	32	has	have	VBZ
22283	1102	33	been	be	VBN
22283	1102	34	directly	directly	RB
22283	1102	35	formed	form	VBN
22283	1102	36	out	out	IN
22283	1102	37	of	of	IN
22283	1102	38	experiences	experience	NNS
22283	1102	39	of	of	IN
22283	1102	40	effort	effort	NN
22283	1102	41	in	in	IN
22283	1102	42	acts	act	NNS
22283	1102	43	of	of	IN
22283	1102	44	volition	volition	NN
22283	1102	45	.	.	.
22283	1103	1	So	so	IN
22283	1103	2	that	that	IN
22283	1103	3	whether	whether	IN
22283	1103	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1103	5	analyze	analyze	VBP
22283	1103	6	the	the	DT
22283	1103	7	idea	idea	NN
22283	1103	8	of	of	IN
22283	1103	9	cause	cause	NN
22283	1103	10	as	as	IN
22283	1103	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1103	12	actually	actually	RB
22283	1103	13	discover	discover	VBP
22283	1103	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1103	15	in	in	IN
22283	1103	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1103	17	own	own	JJ
22283	1103	18	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1103	19	,	,	,
22283	1103	20	or	or	CC
22283	1103	21	investigate	investigate	VBP
22283	1103	22	the	the	DT
22283	1103	23	history	history	NN
22283	1103	24	of	of	IN
22283	1103	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1103	26	genesis	genesis	NN
22283	1103	27	,	,	,
22283	1103	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1103	29	alike	alike	RB
22283	1103	30	find	find	VBP
22283	1103	31	,	,	,
22283	1103	32	as	as	IN
22283	1103	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1103	34	might	may	MD
22283	1103	35	have	have	VB
22283	1103	36	antecedently	antecedently	RB
22283	1103	37	expected	expect	VBN
22283	1103	38	,	,	,
22283	1103	39	that	that	IN
22283	1103	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1103	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	1103	42	dependent	dependent	JJ
22283	1103	43	on	on	IN
22283	1103	44	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1103	45	more	more	RBR
22283	1103	46	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1103	47	idea	idea	NN
22283	1103	48	of	of	IN
22283	1103	49	mind	mind	NN
22283	1103	50	as	as	IN
22283	1103	51	mind	mind	NN
22283	1103	52	;	;	:
22283	1103	53	the	the	DT
22283	1103	54	conception	conception	NN
22283	1103	55	of	of	IN
22283	1103	56	causality	causality	NN
22283	1103	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	1103	58	not	not	RB
22283	1103	59	,	,	,
22283	1103	60	as	as	IN
22283	1103	61	a	a	DT
22283	1103	62	matter	matter	NN
22283	1103	63	of	of	IN
22283	1103	64	fact	fact	NN
22283	1103	65	,	,	,
22283	1103	66	original	original	JJ
22283	1103	67	or	or	CC
22283	1103	68	primal	primal	JJ
22283	1103	69	,	,	,
22283	1103	70	but	but	CC
22283	1103	71	derivative	derivative	JJ
22283	1103	72	or	or	CC
22283	1103	73	secondary	secondary	JJ
22283	1103	74	.	.	.
22283	1104	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1104	2	,	,	,
22283	1104	3	if	if	IN
22283	1104	4	this	this	DT
22283	1104	5	conception	conception	NN
22283	1104	6	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1104	7	involves	involve	VBZ
22283	1104	8	the	the	DT
22283	1104	9	postulation	postulation	NN
22283	1104	10	of	of	IN
22283	1104	11	a	a	DT
22283	1104	12	first	first	JJ
22283	1104	13	cause	cause	NN
22283	1104	14	,	,	,
22283	1104	15	there	there	EX
22283	1104	16	can	can	MD
22283	1104	17	be	be	VB
22283	1104	18	no	no	DT
22283	1104	19	doubt	doubt	NN
22283	1104	20	that	that	IN
22283	1104	21	such	such	PDT
22283	1104	22	a	a	DT
22283	1104	23	cause	cause	NN
22283	1104	24	can	can	MD
22283	1104	25	only	only	RB
22283	1104	26	be	be	VB
22283	1104	27	conceived	conceive	VBN
22283	1104	28	as	as	IN
22283	1104	29	of	of	IN
22283	1104	30	the	the	DT
22283	1104	31	nature	nature	NN
22283	1104	32	of	of	IN
22283	1104	33	mind	mind	NN
22283	1104	34	.	.	.
22283	1105	1	From	from	IN
22283	1105	2	which	which	WDT
22283	1105	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1105	4	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1105	5	that	that	IN
22283	1105	6	each	each	DT
22283	1105	7	individual	individual	JJ
22283	1105	8	mind	mind	NN
22283	1105	9	requires	require	VBZ
22283	1105	10	to	to	TO
22283	1105	11	be	be	VB
22283	1105	12	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1105	13	--	--	:
22283	1105	14	if	if	IN
22283	1105	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1105	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	1105	17	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1105	18	at	at	RB
22283	1105	19	all	all	RB
22283	1105	20	--	--	:
22283	1105	21	as	as	IN
22283	1105	22	of	of	IN
22283	1105	23	the	the	DT
22283	1105	24	nature	nature	NN
22283	1105	25	of	of	IN
22283	1105	26	a	a	DT
22283	1105	27	first	first	JJ
22283	1105	28	cause	cause	NN
22283	1105	29	.	.	.
22283	1106	1	From	from	IN
22283	1106	2	this	this	DT
22283	1106	3	,	,	,
22283	1106	4	however	however	RB
22283	1106	5	,	,	,
22283	1106	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1106	7	does	do	VBZ
22283	1106	8	not	not	RB
22283	1106	9	follow	follow	VB
22283	1106	10	that	that	IN
22283	1106	11	each	each	DT
22283	1106	12	individual	individual	JJ
22283	1106	13	mind	mind	NN
22283	1106	14	requires	require	VBZ
22283	1106	15	to	to	TO
22283	1106	16	be	be	VB
22283	1106	17	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1106	18	as	as	IN
22283	1106	19	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	1106	20	independent	independent	JJ
22283	1106	21	of	of	IN
22283	1106	22	all	all	DT
22283	1106	23	other	other	JJ
22283	1106	24	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1106	25	,	,	,
22283	1106	26	or	or	CC
22283	1106	27	as	as	IN
22283	1106	28	never	never	RB
22283	1106	29	subject	subject	JJ
22283	1106	30	to	to	IN
22283	1106	31	any	any	DT
22283	1106	32	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1106	33	influence	influence	NN
22283	1106	34	which	which	WDT
22283	1106	35	may	may	MD
22283	1106	36	be	be	VB
22283	1106	37	exercised	exercise	VBN
22283	1106	38	by	by	IN
22283	1106	39	other	other	JJ
22283	1106	40	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1106	41	.	.	.
22283	1107	1	Although	although	IN
22283	1107	2	each	each	DT
22283	1107	3	mind	mind	NN
22283	1107	4	presents	present	VBZ
22283	1107	5	the	the	DT
22283	1107	6	feature	feature	NN
22283	1107	7	of	of	IN
22283	1107	8	finality	finality	NN
22283	1107	9	or	or	CC
22283	1107	10	spontaneity	spontaneity	NN
22283	1107	11	,	,	,
22283	1107	12	this	this	DT
22283	1107	13	does	do	VBZ
22283	1107	14	not	not	RB
22283	1107	15	hinder	hinder	VB
22283	1107	16	that	that	IN
22283	1107	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1107	18	also	also	RB
22283	1107	19	presents	present	VBZ
22283	1107	20	the	the	DT
22283	1107	21	feature	feature	NN
22283	1107	22	of	of	IN
22283	1107	23	relation	relation	NN
22283	1107	24	to	to	IN
22283	1107	25	other	other	JJ
22283	1107	26	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1107	27	,	,	,
22283	1107	28	which	which	WDT
22283	1107	29	,	,	,
22283	1107	30	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1107	31	,	,	,
22283	1107	32	are	be	VBP
22283	1107	33	able	able	JJ
22283	1107	34	to	to	TO
22283	1107	35	act	act	VB
22283	1107	36	upon	upon	IN
22283	1107	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1107	38	in	in	IN
22283	1107	39	numberless	numberless	JJ
22283	1107	40	ways	way	NNS
22283	1107	41	.	.	.
22283	1108	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1108	2	,	,	,
22283	1108	3	whether	whether	IN
22283	1108	4	these	these	DT
22283	1108	5	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1108	6	are	be	VBP
22283	1108	7	the	the	DT
22283	1108	8	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1108	9	of	of	IN
22283	1108	10	other	other	JJ
22283	1108	11	men	man	NNS
22283	1108	12	,	,	,
22283	1108	13	of	of	IN
22283	1108	14	other	other	JJ
22283	1108	15	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
22283	1108	16	beings	being	NNS
22283	1108	17	,	,	,
22283	1108	18	or	or	CC
22283	1108	19	of	of	IN
22283	1108	20	the	the	DT
22283	1108	21	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1108	22	World	world	NN
22283	1108	23	-	-	HYPH
22283	1108	24	eject	eject	NN
22283	1108	25	,	,	,
22283	1108	26	the	the	DT
22283	1108	27	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1108	28	activity	activity	NN
22283	1108	29	which	which	WDT
22283	1108	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1108	31	exerted	exert	VBN
22283	1108	32	upon	upon	IN
22283	1108	33	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1108	34	mind	mind	NN
22283	1108	35	expresses	express	VBZ
22283	1108	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1108	37	in	in	IN
22283	1108	38	that	that	DT
22283	1108	39	mind	mind	NN
22283	1108	40	as	as	IN
22283	1108	41	a	a	DT
22283	1108	42	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	1108	43	of	of	IN
22283	1108	44	motives	motive	NNS
22283	1108	45	.	.	.
22283	1109	1	But	but	CC
22283	1109	2	although	although	IN
22283	1109	3	these	these	DT
22283	1109	4	motives	motive	NNS
22283	1109	5	may	may	MD
22283	1109	6	help	help	VB
22283	1109	7	to	to	TO
22283	1109	8	determine	determine	VB
22283	1109	9	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1109	10	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1109	11	,	,	,
22283	1109	12	there	there	EX
22283	1109	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	1109	14	no	no	DT
22283	1109	15	reason	reason	NN
22283	1109	16	to	to	TO
22283	1109	17	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	1109	18	that	that	IN
22283	1109	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1109	20	are	be	VBP
22283	1109	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1109	22	the	the	DT
22283	1109	23	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1109	24	,	,	,
22283	1109	25	or	or	CC
22283	1109	26	that	that	IN
22283	1109	27	without	without	IN
22283	1109	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1109	29	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1109	30	mind	mind	NN
22283	1109	31	would	would	MD
22283	1109	32	cease	cease	VB
22283	1109	33	to	to	TO
22283	1109	34	be	be	VB
22283	1109	35	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1109	36	a	a	DT
22283	1109	37	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1109	38	agent	agent	NN
22283	1109	39	.	.	.
22283	1110	1	On	on	IN
22283	1110	2	the	the	DT
22283	1110	3	contrary	contrary	NN
22283	1110	4	,	,	,
22283	1110	5	if	if	IN
22283	1110	6	this	this	DT
22283	1110	7	were	be	VBD
22283	1110	8	supposed	suppose	VBN
22283	1110	9	,	,	,
22283	1110	10	the	the	DT
22283	1110	11	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	1110	12	would	would	MD
22283	1110	13	amount	amount	VB
22283	1110	14	to	to	IN
22283	1110	15	destroying	destroy	VBG
22283	1110	16	the	the	DT
22283	1110	17	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1110	18	agency	agency	NN
22283	1110	19	of	of	IN
22283	1110	20	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1110	21	own	own	JJ
22283	1110	22	mind	mind	NN
22283	1110	23	,	,	,
22283	1110	24	which	which	WDT
22283	1110	25	,	,	,
22283	1110	26	as	as	IN
22283	1110	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1110	28	have	have	VBP
22283	1110	29	just	just	RB
22283	1110	30	seen	see	VBN
22283	1110	31	,	,	,
22283	1110	32	must	must	MD
22283	1110	33	either	either	CC
22283	1110	34	be	be	VB
22283	1110	35	original	original	JJ
22283	1110	36	or	or	CC
22283	1110	37	not	not	RB
22283	1110	38	at	at	RB
22283	1110	39	all	all	RB
22283	1110	40	.	.	.
22283	1111	1	The	the	DT
22283	1111	2	way	way	NN
22283	1111	3	,	,	,
22283	1111	4	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1111	5	,	,	,
22283	1111	6	that	that	IN
22283	1111	7	the	the	DT
22283	1111	8	matter	matter	NN
22283	1111	9	stands	stand	VBZ
22283	1111	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1111	11	this	this	DT
22283	1111	12	.	.	.
22283	1112	1	In	in	IN
22283	1112	2	so	so	RB
22283	1112	3	far	far	RB
22283	1112	4	as	as	IN
22283	1112	5	the	the	DT
22283	1112	6	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	1112	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1112	8	a	a	DT
22283	1112	9	circumscribed	circumscribed	JJ
22283	1112	10	system	system	NN
22283	1112	11	of	of	IN
22283	1112	12	being	be	VBG
22283	1112	13	--	--	:
22283	1112	14	a	a	DT
22283	1112	15	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	1112	16	substance	substance	NN
22283	1112	17	,	,	,
22283	1112	18	a	a	DT
22283	1112	19	personality	personality	NN
22283	1112	20	--	--	:
22283	1112	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1112	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1112	23	of	of	IN
22283	1112	24	the	the	DT
22283	1112	25	nature	nature	NN
22283	1112	26	of	of	IN
22283	1112	27	a	a	DT
22283	1112	28	first	first	JJ
22283	1112	29	cause	cause	NN
22283	1112	30	,	,	,
22283	1112	31	free	free	JJ
22283	1112	32	to	to	TO
22283	1112	33	act	act	VB
22283	1112	34	in	in	IN
22283	1112	35	any	any	DT
22283	1112	36	direction	direction	NN
22283	1112	37	as	as	IN
22283	1112	38	to	to	IN
22283	1112	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1112	40	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	1112	41	and	and	CC
22283	1112	42	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1112	43	,	,	,
22283	1112	44	even	even	RB
22283	1112	45	though	though	IN
22283	1112	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1112	47	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	1112	48	should	should	MD
22283	1112	49	be	be	VB
22283	1112	50	irrational	irrational	JJ
22283	1112	51	as	as	IN
22283	1112	52	to	to	IN
22283	1112	53	truth	truth	NN
22283	1112	54	,	,	,
22283	1112	55	and	and	CC
22283	1112	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1112	57	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1112	58	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1112	59	as	as	IN
22283	1112	60	to	to	IN
22283	1112	61	execution	execution	NN
22283	1112	62	.	.	.
22283	1113	1	But	but	CC
22283	1113	2	in	in	IN
22283	1113	3	so	so	RB
22283	1113	4	far	far	RB
22283	1113	5	as	as	IN
22283	1113	6	the	the	DT
22283	1113	7	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	1113	8	enters	enter	VBZ
22283	1113	9	into	into	IN
22283	1113	10	relation	relation	NN
22283	1113	11	with	with	IN
22283	1113	12	the	the	DT
22283	1113	13	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	1113	14	,	,	,
22283	1113	15	the	the	DT
22283	1113	16	system	system	NN
22283	1113	17	of	of	IN
22283	1113	18	external	external	JJ
22283	1113	19	causation	causation	NN
22283	1113	20	which	which	WDT
22283	1113	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1113	22	encounters	encounter	VBZ
22283	1113	23	determines	determine	VBZ
22283	1113	24	the	the	DT
22283	1113	25	character	character	NN
22283	1113	26	of	of	IN
22283	1113	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1113	28	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1113	29	.	.	.
22283	1114	1	For	for	IN
22283	1114	2	although	although	IN
22283	1114	3	these	these	DT
22283	1114	4	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1114	5	are	be	VBP
22283	1114	6	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1114	7	of	of	IN
22283	1114	8	the	the	DT
22283	1114	9	nature	nature	NN
22283	1114	10	of	of	IN
22283	1114	11	first	first	JJ
22283	1114	12	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1114	13	,	,	,
22283	1114	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1114	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	1114	16	no	no	DT
22283	1114	17	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	1114	18	to	to	TO
22283	1114	19	say	say	VB
22283	1114	20	that	that	IN
22283	1114	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1114	22	are	be	VBP
22283	1114	23	--	--	:
22283	1114	24	at	at	IN
22283	1114	25	all	all	DT
22283	1114	26	events	event	NNS
22283	1114	27	in	in	IN
22283	1114	28	large	large	JJ
22283	1114	29	measure	measure	NN
22283	1114	30	--	--	:
22283	1114	31	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1114	32	by	by	IN
22283	1114	33	other	other	JJ
22283	1114	34	and	and	CC
22283	1114	35	external	external	JJ
22283	1114	36	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1114	37	.	.	.
22283	1115	1	This	this	DT
22283	1115	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1115	3	no	no	DT
22283	1115	4	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	1115	5	because	because	IN
22283	1115	6	,	,	,
22283	1115	7	although	although	IN
22283	1115	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1115	9	are	be	VBP
22283	1115	10	thus	thus	RB
22283	1115	11	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1115	12	,	,	,
22283	1115	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1115	14	does	do	VBZ
22283	1115	15	not	not	RB
22283	1115	16	follow	follow	VB
22283	1115	17	that	that	IN
22283	1115	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1115	19	are	be	VBP
22283	1115	20	thus	thus	RB
22283	1115	21	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1115	22	_	_	NNP
22283	1115	23	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1115	24	_	_	NNP
22283	1115	25	,	,	,
22283	1115	26	and	and	CC
22283	1115	27	this	this	DT
22283	1115	28	makes	make	VBZ
22283	1115	29	all	all	PDT
22283	1115	30	the	the	DT
22283	1115	31	difference	difference	NN
22283	1115	32	between	between	IN
22283	1115	33	the	the	DT
22283	1115	34	theory	theory	NN
22283	1115	35	of	of	IN
22283	1115	36	will	will	NN
22283	1115	37	as	as	RB
22283	1115	38	bond	bond	NN
22283	1115	39	or	or	CC
22283	1115	40	free	free	JJ
22283	1115	41	.	.	.
22283	1116	1	In	in	IN
22283	1116	2	any	any	DT
22283	1116	3	stream	stream	NN
22283	1116	4	of	of	IN
22283	1116	5	secondary	secondary	JJ
22283	1116	6	causation	causation	NN
22283	1116	7	each	each	DT
22283	1116	8	member	member	NN
22283	1116	9	of	of	IN
22283	1116	10	the	the	DT
22283	1116	11	series	series	NN
22283	1116	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1116	13	understood	understand	VBN
22283	1116	14	to	to	TO
22283	1116	15	determine	determine	VB
22283	1116	16	the	the	DT
22283	1116	17	next	next	JJ
22283	1116	18	member	member	NN
22283	1116	19	of	of	IN
22283	1116	20	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1116	21	;	;	:
22283	1116	22	and	and	CC
22283	1116	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1116	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	1116	25	because	because	IN
22283	1116	26	this	this	DT
22283	1116	27	notion	notion	NN
22283	1116	28	is	be	VBZ
22283	1116	29	imported	import	VBN
22283	1116	30	into	into	IN
22283	1116	31	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	1116	32	that	that	IN
22283	1116	33	the	the	DT
22283	1116	34	theory	theory	NN
22283	1116	35	of	of	IN
22283	1116	36	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	1116	37	regards	regard	VBZ
22283	1116	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1116	39	as	as	IN
22283	1116	40	axiomatic	axiomatic	JJ
22283	1116	41	that	that	IN
22283	1116	42	,	,	,
22283	1116	43	if	if	IN
22283	1116	44	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1116	45	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1116	46	are	be	VBP
22283	1116	47	in	in	IN
22283	1116	48	any	any	DT
22283	1116	49	way	way	NN
22283	1116	50	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1116	51	at	at	RB
22283	1116	52	all	all	RB
22283	1116	53	,	,	,
22283	1116	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1116	55	can	can	MD
22283	1116	56	only	only	RB
22283	1116	57	be	be	VB
22283	1116	58	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1116	59	by	by	IN
22283	1116	60	way	way	NN
22283	1116	61	of	of	IN
22283	1116	62	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1116	63	;	;	:
22283	1116	64	and	and	CC
22283	1116	65	hence	hence	RB
22283	1116	66	that	that	IN
22283	1116	67	under	under	IN
22283	1116	68	the	the	DT
22283	1116	69	operation	operation	NN
22283	1116	70	of	of	IN
22283	1116	71	any	any	DT
22283	1116	72	given	give	VBN
22283	1116	73	set	set	NN
22283	1116	74	of	of	IN
22283	1116	75	motives	motive	NNS
22283	1116	76	the	the	DT
22283	1116	77	action	action	NN
22283	1116	78	of	of	IN
22283	1116	79	the	the	DT
22283	1116	80	will	will	NN
22283	1116	81	can	can	MD
22283	1116	82	only	only	RB
22283	1116	83	take	take	VB
22283	1116	84	place	place	NN
22283	1116	85	in	in	IN
22283	1116	86	the	the	DT
22283	1116	87	direction	direction	NN
22283	1116	88	of	of	IN
22283	1116	89	the	the	DT
22283	1116	90	resultant	resultant	NN
22283	1116	91	.	.	.
22283	1117	1	But	but	CC
22283	1117	2	any	any	DT
22283	1117	3	such	such	JJ
22283	1117	4	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	1117	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	1117	6	valid	valid	JJ
22283	1117	7	only	only	RB
22283	1117	8	within	within	IN
22283	1117	9	the	the	DT
22283	1117	10	region	region	NN
22283	1117	11	of	of	IN
22283	1117	12	second	second	JJ
22283	1117	13	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1117	14	.	.	.
22283	1118	1	On	on	IN
22283	1118	2	the	the	DT
22283	1118	3	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	1118	4	that	that	IN
22283	1118	5	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1118	6	are	be	VBP
22283	1118	7	first	first	JJ
22283	1118	8	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1118	9	,	,	,
22283	1118	10	the	the	DT
22283	1118	11	axiom	axiom	NN
22283	1118	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1118	13	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
22283	1118	14	to	to	IN
22283	1118	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	16	;	;	:
22283	1118	17	for	for	IN
22283	1118	18	although	although	IN
22283	1118	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	20	may	may	MD
22283	1118	21	be	be	VB
22283	1118	22	true	true	JJ
22283	1118	23	that	that	IN
22283	1118	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	25	are	be	VBP
22283	1118	26	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1118	27	by	by	IN
22283	1118	28	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1118	29	from	from	IN
22283	1118	30	without	without	IN
22283	1118	31	,	,	,
22283	1118	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	33	may	may	MD
22283	1118	34	not	not	RB
22283	1118	35	be	be	VB
22283	1118	36	true	true	JJ
22283	1118	37	that	that	IN
22283	1118	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	39	are	be	VBP
22283	1118	40	thus	thus	RB
22283	1118	41	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1118	42	of	of	IN
22283	1118	43	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1118	44	:	:	:
22283	1118	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1118	46	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
22283	1118	47	character	character	NN
22283	1118	48	as	as	IN
22283	1118	49	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	50	first	first	JJ
22283	1118	51	causes	cause	VBZ
22283	1118	52	,	,	,
22283	1118	53	although	although	IN
22283	1118	54	not	not	RB
22283	1118	55	isolating	isolate	VBG
22283	1118	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	57	from	from	IN
22283	1118	58	any	any	DT
22283	1118	59	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1118	60	contact	contact	NN
22283	1118	61	with	with	IN
22283	1118	62	other	other	JJ
22283	1118	63	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1118	64	,	,	,
22283	1118	65	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	1118	66	does	do	VBZ
22283	1118	67	protect	protect	VB
22283	1118	68	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	69	from	from	IN
22283	1118	70	being	be	VBG
22283	1118	71	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1118	72	coerced	coerce	VBN
22283	1118	73	by	by	IN
22283	1118	74	these	these	DT
22283	1118	75	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1118	76	,	,	,
22283	1118	77	and	and	CC
22283	1118	78	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1118	79	from	from	IN
22283	1118	80	becoming	become	VBG
22283	1118	81	but	but	CC
22283	1118	82	the	the	DT
22283	1118	83	mere	mere	JJ
22283	1118	84	effects	effect	NNS
22283	1118	85	of	of	IN
22283	1118	86	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1118	87	.	.	.
22283	1119	1	Such	such	JJ
22283	1119	2	influence	influence	NN
22283	1119	3	,	,	,
22283	1119	4	or	or	CC
22283	1119	5	determination	determination	NN
22283	1119	6	,	,	,
22283	1119	7	as	as	IN
22283	1119	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1119	9	exerted	exert	VBN
22283	1119	10	upon	upon	IN
22283	1119	11	the	the	DT
22283	1119	12	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1119	13	by	by	IN
22283	1119	14	these	these	DT
22283	1119	15	external	external	JJ
22283	1119	16	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1119	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	1119	18	exerted	exert	VBN
22283	1119	19	only	only	RB
22283	1119	20	because	because	IN
22283	1119	21	any	any	DT
22283	1119	22	individual	individual	JJ
22283	1119	23	mind	mind	NN
22283	1119	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	1119	25	not	not	RB
22283	1119	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1119	27	a	a	DT
22283	1119	28	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	1119	29	,	,	,
22283	1119	30	but	but	CC
22283	1119	31	a	a	DT
22283	1119	32	microcosm	microcosm	NN
22283	1119	33	in	in	IN
22283	1119	34	relation	relation	NN
22283	1119	35	to	to	IN
22283	1119	36	a	a	DT
22283	1119	37	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	1119	38	.	.	.
22283	1120	1	If	if	IN
22283	1120	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1120	3	were	be	VBD
22283	1120	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1120	5	a	a	DT
22283	1120	6	macrocosm	macrocosm	NN
22283	1120	7	,	,	,
22283	1120	8	standing	stand	VBG
22283	1120	9	out	out	IN
22283	1120	10	of	of	IN
22283	1120	11	relation	relation	NN
22283	1120	12	to	to	IN
22283	1120	13	all	all	DT
22283	1120	14	other	other	JJ
22283	1120	15	being	being	NN
22283	1120	16	,	,	,
22283	1120	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1120	18	prime	prime	JJ
22283	1120	19	causation	causation	NN
22283	1120	20	would	would	MD
22283	1120	21	,	,	,
22283	1120	22	of	of	IN
22283	1120	23	course	course	NN
22283	1120	24	,	,	,
22283	1120	25	be	be	VB
22283	1120	26	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	1120	27	uninfluenced	uninfluenced	JJ
22283	1120	28	by	by	IN
22283	1120	29	any	any	DT
22283	1120	30	other	other	JJ
22283	1120	31	causation	causation	NN
22283	1120	32	;	;	:
22283	1120	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1120	34	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1120	35	would	would	MD
22283	1120	36	then	then	RB
22283	1120	37	be	be	VB
22283	1120	38	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	1120	39	only	only	RB
22283	1120	40	with	with	IN
22283	1120	41	the	the	DT
22283	1120	42	determination	determination	NN
22283	1120	43	of	of	IN
22283	1120	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1120	45	own	own	JJ
22283	1120	46	thoughts	thought	NNS
22283	1120	47	in	in	IN
22283	1120	48	a	a	DT
22283	1120	49	constant	constant	JJ
22283	1120	50	stream	stream	NN
22283	1120	51	of	of	IN
22283	1120	52	purely	purely	RB
22283	1120	53	subjective	subjective	JJ
22283	1120	54	contemplation	contemplation	NN
22283	1120	55	,	,	,
22283	1120	56	such	such	JJ
22283	1120	57	as	as	IN
22283	1120	58	that	that	DT
22283	1120	59	which	which	WDT
22283	1120	60	the	the	DT
22283	1120	61	Hindoo	Hindoo	NNP
22283	1120	62	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	1120	63	attributes	attribute	VBZ
22283	1120	64	to	to	IN
22283	1120	65	God	God	NNP
22283	1120	66	.	.	.
22283	1121	1	But	but	CC
22283	1121	2	as	as	IN
22283	1121	3	the	the	DT
22283	1121	4	human	human	JJ
22283	1121	5	mind	mind	NN
22283	1121	6	discovers	discover	VBZ
22283	1121	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1121	8	as	as	IN
22283	1121	9	existing	exist	VBG
22283	1121	10	in	in	IN
22283	1121	11	close	close	JJ
22283	1121	12	and	and	CC
22283	1121	13	complex	complex	JJ
22283	1121	14	relations	relation	NNS
22283	1121	15	with	with	IN
22283	1121	16	an	an	DT
22283	1121	17	external	external	JJ
22283	1121	18	world	world	NN
22283	1121	19	of	of	IN
22283	1121	20	an	an	DT
22283	1121	21	orderly	orderly	JJ
22283	1121	22	character	character	NN
22283	1121	23	,	,	,
22283	1121	24	the	the	DT
22283	1121	25	human	human	JJ
22283	1121	26	mind	mind	NN
22283	1121	27	finds	find	VBZ
22283	1121	28	that	that	IN
22283	1121	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1121	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1121	31	,	,	,
22283	1121	32	as	as	IN
22283	1121	33	before	before	IN
22283	1121	34	said	say	VBD
22283	1121	35	,	,	,
22283	1121	36	_	_	NNP
22283	1121	37	expedient	expedient	NN
22283	1121	38	_	_	NNP
22283	1121	39	to	to	TO
22283	1121	40	adapt	adapt	VB
22283	1121	41	the	the	DT
22283	1121	42	course	course	NN
22283	1121	43	of	of	IN
22283	1121	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1121	45	own	own	JJ
22283	1121	46	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1121	47	activity	activity	NN
22283	1121	48	so	so	IN
22283	1121	49	as	as	IN
22283	1121	50	to	to	TO
22283	1121	51	bring	bring	VB
22283	1121	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1121	53	into	into	IN
22283	1121	54	harmony	harmony	NN
22283	1121	55	with	with	IN
22283	1121	56	the	the	DT
22283	1121	57	external	external	JJ
22283	1121	58	order	order	NN
22283	1121	59	.	.	.
22283	1122	1	For	for	IN
22283	1122	2	,	,	,
22283	1122	3	although	although	IN
22283	1122	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1122	5	own	own	JJ
22283	1122	6	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1122	7	activity	activity	NN
22283	1122	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1122	9	primal	primal	JJ
22283	1122	10	,	,	,
22283	1122	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1122	12	by	by	IN
22283	1122	13	no	no	DT
22283	1122	14	means	means	NN
22283	1122	15	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1122	16	that	that	IN
22283	1122	17	on	on	IN
22283	1122	18	this	this	DT
22283	1122	19	account	account	NN
22283	1122	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1122	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	1122	22	almighty	almighty	JJ
22283	1122	23	;	;	:
22283	1122	24	hence	hence	RB
22283	1122	25	,	,	,
22283	1122	26	even	even	RB
22283	1122	27	although	although	IN
22283	1122	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1122	29	be	be	VBP
22283	1122	30	primal	primal	JJ
22283	1122	31	,	,	,
22283	1122	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1122	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	1122	34	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
22283	1122	35	under	under	IN
22283	1122	36	the	the	DT
22283	1122	37	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1122	38	of	of	IN
22283	1122	39	adopting	adopt	VBG
22283	1122	40	means	mean	NNS
22283	1122	41	in	in	IN
22283	1122	42	order	order	NN
22283	1122	43	to	to	TO
22283	1122	44	secure	secure	VB
22283	1122	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1122	46	ends	end	NNS
22283	1122	47	--	--	:
22283	1122	48	or	or	CC
22283	1122	49	,	,	,
22283	1122	50	in	in	IN
22283	1122	51	other	other	JJ
22283	1122	52	words	word	NNS
22283	1122	53	,	,	,
22283	1122	54	of	of	IN
22283	1122	55	adjusting	adjust	VBG
22283	1122	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1122	57	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1122	58	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1122	59	if	if	IN
22283	1122	60	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1122	61	are	be	VBP
22283	1122	62	to	to	TO
22283	1122	63	be	be	VB
22283	1122	64	practically	practically	RB
22283	1122	65	efficient	efficient	JJ
22283	1122	66	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1122	67	to	to	IN
22283	1122	68	the	the	DT
22283	1122	69	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1122	70	which	which	WDT
22283	1122	71	are	be	VBP
22283	1122	72	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	1122	73	upon	upon	IN
22283	1122	74	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1122	75	activity	activity	NN
22283	1122	76	by	by	IN
22283	1122	77	the	the	DT
22283	1122	78	orderly	orderly	JJ
22283	1122	79	system	system	NN
22283	1122	80	of	of	IN
22283	1122	81	the	the	DT
22283	1122	82	external	external	JJ
22283	1122	83	world	world	NN
22283	1122	84	.	.	.
22283	1123	1	Which	which	WDT
22283	1123	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1123	3	merely	merely	RB
22283	1123	4	another	another	DT
22283	1123	5	way	way	NN
22283	1123	6	of	of	IN
22283	1123	7	stating	state	VBG
22283	1123	8	the	the	DT
22283	1123	9	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	1123	10	previously	previously	RB
22283	1123	11	reached	reach	VBN
22283	1123	12	--	--	:
22283	1123	13	viz	viz	NN
22283	1123	14	.	.	.
22283	1124	1	that	that	IN
22283	1124	2	the	the	DT
22283	1124	3	only	only	JJ
22283	1124	4	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1124	5	which	which	WDT
22283	1124	6	can	can	MD
22283	1124	7	be	be	VB
22283	1124	8	proved	prove	VBN
22283	1124	9	to	to	TO
22283	1124	10	govern	govern	VB
22283	1124	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1124	12	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1124	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	1124	14	the	the	DT
22283	1124	15	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1124	16	which	which	WDT
22283	1124	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	1124	18	imposed	impose	VBN
22283	1124	19	by	by	IN
22283	1124	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1124	21	own	own	JJ
22283	1124	22	considerations	consideration	NNS
22283	1124	23	of	of	IN
22283	1124	24	reason	reason	NN
22283	1124	25	and	and	CC
22283	1124	26	morality	morality	NN
22283	1124	27	.	.	.
22283	1125	1	Although	although	IN
22283	1125	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	3	find	find	VBP
22283	1125	4	that	that	IN
22283	1125	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1125	7	expedient	expedient	JJ
22283	1125	8	to	to	TO
22283	1125	9	adapt	adapt	VB
22283	1125	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1125	11	own	own	JJ
22283	1125	12	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1125	13	activity	activity	NN
22283	1125	14	to	to	IN
22283	1125	15	that	that	DT
22283	1125	16	larger	large	JJR
22283	1125	17	system	system	NN
22283	1125	18	of	of	IN
22283	1125	19	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1125	20	activity	activity	NN
22283	1125	21	by	by	IN
22283	1125	22	which	which	WDT
22283	1125	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	24	are	be	VBP
22283	1125	25	surrounded	surround	VBN
22283	1125	26	--	--	:
22283	1125	27	seeing	see	VBG
22283	1125	28	that	that	IN
22283	1125	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	30	must	must	MD
22283	1125	31	do	do	VB
22283	1125	32	so	so	RB
22283	1125	33	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1125	34	if	if	IN
22283	1125	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	36	are	be	VBP
22283	1125	37	to	to	TO
22283	1125	38	act	act	VB
22283	1125	39	at	at	RB
22283	1125	40	all	all	RB
22283	1125	41	--	--	:
22283	1125	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	43	by	by	IN
22283	1125	44	no	no	DT
22283	1125	45	means	means	NN
22283	1125	46	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1125	47	that	that	IN
22283	1125	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1125	49	are	be	VBP
22283	1125	50	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1125	51	to	to	TO
22283	1125	52	will	will	VB
22283	1125	53	what	what	WP
22283	1125	54	is	be	VBZ
22283	1125	55	expedient	expedient	NN
22283	1125	56	.	.	.
22283	1126	1	In	in	IN
22283	1126	2	other	other	JJ
22283	1126	3	words	word	NNS
22283	1126	4	,	,	,
22283	1126	5	the	the	DT
22283	1126	6	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1126	7	laid	lay	VBN
22283	1126	8	upon	upon	IN
22283	1126	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1126	10	by	by	IN
22283	1126	11	the	the	DT
22283	1126	12	system	system	NN
22283	1126	13	of	of	IN
22283	1126	14	external	external	JJ
22283	1126	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	1126	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	1126	17	a	a	DT
22283	1126	18	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1126	19	to	to	TO
22283	1126	20	adopt	adopt	VB
22283	1126	21	means	mean	VBZ
22283	1126	22	for	for	IN
22283	1126	23	the	the	DT
22283	1126	24	attainment	attainment	NN
22283	1126	25	of	of	IN
22283	1126	26	ends	end	NNS
22283	1126	27	;	;	:
22283	1126	28	not	not	RB
22283	1126	29	a	a	DT
22283	1126	30	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1126	31	to	to	TO
22283	1126	32	will	will	VB
22283	1126	33	the	the	DT
22283	1126	34	ends	end	NNS
22283	1126	35	.	.	.
22283	1127	1	And	and	CC
22283	1127	2	although	although	IN
22283	1127	3	in	in	IN
22283	1127	4	many	many	JJ
22283	1127	5	cases	case	NNS
22283	1127	6	this	this	DT
22283	1127	7	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1127	8	may	may	MD
22283	1127	9	appear	appear	VB
22283	1127	10	to	to	TO
22283	1127	11	be	be	VB
22283	1127	12	practically	practically	RB
22283	1127	13	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
22283	1127	14	--	--	:
22283	1127	15	seeing	see	VBG
22283	1127	16	that	that	IN
22283	1127	17	no	no	DT
22283	1127	18	man	man	NN
22283	1127	19	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1127	20	what	what	WP
22283	1127	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1127	22	knows	know	VBZ
22283	1127	23	to	to	TO
22283	1127	24	be	be	VB
22283	1127	25	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1127	26	of	of	IN
22283	1127	27	execution	execution	NN
22283	1127	28	,	,	,
22283	1127	29	and	and	CC
22283	1127	30	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1127	31	that	that	DT
22283	1127	32	to	to	TO
22283	1127	33	say	say	VB
22283	1127	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1127	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	1127	36	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1127	37	prevented	prevent	VBN
22283	1127	38	from	from	IN
22283	1127	39	doing	do	VBG
22283	1127	40	a	a	DT
22283	1127	41	certain	certain	JJ
22283	1127	42	thing	thing	NN
22283	1127	43	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	1127	44	practically	practically	RB
22283	1127	45	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
22283	1127	46	to	to	IN
22283	1127	47	saying	say	VBG
22283	1127	48	that	that	IN
22283	1127	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1127	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	1127	51	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1127	52	prevented	prevent	VBN
22283	1127	53	from	from	IN
22283	1127	54	willing	willing	JJ
22283	1127	55	that	that	IN
22283	1127	56	thing	thing	NN
22283	1127	57	--	--	:
22283	1127	58	in	in	IN
22283	1127	59	all	all	DT
22283	1127	60	cases	case	NNS
22283	1127	61	where	where	WRB
22283	1127	62	any	any	DT
22283	1127	63	question	question	NN
22283	1127	64	of	of	IN
22283	1127	65	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1127	66	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1127	67	can	can	MD
22283	1127	68	possibly	possibly	RB
22283	1127	69	obtain	obtain	VB
22283	1127	70	,	,	,
22283	1127	71	the	the	DT
22283	1127	72	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1127	73	is	be	VBZ
22283	1127	74	one	one	CD
22283	1127	75	of	of	IN
22283	1127	76	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	1127	77	importance	importance	NN
22283	1127	78	.	.	.
22283	1128	1	For	for	IN
22283	1128	2	,	,	,
22283	1128	3	as	as	IN
22283	1128	4	already	already	RB
22283	1128	5	shown	show	VBN
22283	1128	6	,	,	,
22283	1128	7	any	any	DT
22283	1128	8	question	question	NN
22283	1128	9	of	of	IN
22283	1128	10	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1128	11	responsibility	responsibility	NN
22283	1128	12	can	can	MD
22283	1128	13	only	only	RB
22283	1128	14	obtain	obtain	VB
22283	1128	15	where	where	WRB
22283	1128	16	two	two	CD
22283	1128	17	or	or	CC
22283	1128	18	more	more	JJR
22283	1128	19	lines	line	NNS
22283	1128	20	of	of	IN
22283	1128	21	action	action	NN
22283	1128	22	are	be	VBP
22283	1128	23	alike	alike	RB
22283	1128	24	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1128	25	,	,	,
22283	1128	26	and	and	CC
22283	1128	27	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1128	28	where	where	WRB
22283	1128	29	no	no	DT
22283	1128	30	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1128	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1128	32	laid	lay	VBN
22283	1128	33	upon	upon	IN
22283	1128	34	the	the	DT
22283	1128	35	man	man	NN
22283	1128	36	in	in	IN
22283	1128	37	respect	respect	NN
22283	1128	38	of	of	IN
22283	1128	39	carrying	carry	VBG
22283	1128	40	out	out	RP
22283	1128	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1128	42	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1128	43	,	,	,
22283	1128	44	in	in	IN
22283	1128	45	whichever	whichever	WDT
22283	1128	46	direction	direction	NN
22283	1128	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1128	48	may	may	MD
22283	1128	49	eventually	eventually	RB
22283	1128	50	proceed	proceed	VB
22283	1128	51	.	.	.
22283	1129	1	Although	although	IN
22283	1129	2	in	in	IN
22283	1129	3	any	any	DT
22283	1129	4	event	event	NN
22283	1129	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1129	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1129	7	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1129	8	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1129	9	to	to	TO
22283	1129	10	adopt	adopt	VB
22283	1129	11	means	mean	NNS
22283	1129	12	in	in	IN
22283	1129	13	order	order	NN
22283	1129	14	to	to	TO
22283	1129	15	secure	secure	VB
22283	1129	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1129	17	ends	end	NNS
22283	1129	18	,	,	,
22283	1129	19	the	the	DT
22283	1129	20	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1129	21	quality	quality	NN
22283	1129	22	of	of	IN
22283	1129	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1129	24	choice	choice	NN
22283	1129	25	has	have	VBZ
22283	1129	26	reference	reference	NN
22283	1129	27	only	only	RB
22283	1129	28	to	to	IN
22283	1129	29	the	the	DT
22283	1129	30	ends	end	NNS
22283	1129	31	which	which	WDT
22283	1129	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1129	33	chooses	choose	VBZ
22283	1129	34	;	;	:
22283	1129	35	not	not	RB
22283	1129	36	at	at	RB
22283	1129	37	all	all	RB
22283	1129	38	to	to	IN
22283	1129	39	the	the	DT
22283	1129	40	fact	fact	NN
22283	1129	41	that	that	IN
22283	1129	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1129	43	has	have	VBZ
22283	1129	44	to	to	TO
22283	1129	45	employ	employ	VB
22283	1129	46	means	mean	NNS
22283	1129	47	for	for	IN
22283	1129	48	the	the	DT
22283	1129	49	purpose	purpose	NN
22283	1129	50	of	of	IN
22283	1129	51	attaining	attain	VBG
22283	1129	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1129	53	.	.	.
22283	1130	1	And	and	CC
22283	1130	2	even	even	RB
22283	1130	3	though	though	IN
22283	1130	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1130	5	choice	choice	NN
22283	1130	6	be	be	VB
22283	1130	7	influenced	influence	VBN
22283	1130	8	by	by	IN
22283	1130	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1130	10	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1130	11	and	and	CC
22283	1130	12	social	social	JJ
22283	1130	13	environment	environment	NN
22283	1130	14	--	--	:
22283	1130	15	as	as	IN
22283	1130	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1130	17	must	must	MD
22283	1130	18	be	be	VB
22283	1130	19	if	if	IN
22283	1130	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1130	21	be	be	VB
22283	1130	22	either	either	CC
22283	1130	23	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1130	24	on	on	IN
22283	1130	25	the	the	DT
22283	1130	26	one	one	CD
22283	1130	27	hand	hand	NN
22283	1130	28	or	or	CC
22283	1130	29	moral	moral	NN
22283	1130	30	on	on	IN
22283	1130	31	the	the	DT
22283	1130	32	other	other	JJ
22283	1130	33	--	--	:
22283	1130	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1130	35	does	do	VBZ
22283	1130	36	not	not	RB
22283	1130	37	follow	follow	VB
22283	1130	38	that	that	IN
22283	1130	39	this	this	DT
22283	1130	40	influence	influence	NN
22283	1130	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	1130	42	of	of	IN
22283	1130	43	a	a	DT
22283	1130	44	kind	kind	NN
22283	1130	45	to	to	TO
22283	1130	46	neutralize	neutralize	VB
22283	1130	47	or	or	CC
22283	1130	48	destroy	destroy	VB
22283	1130	49	the	the	DT
22283	1130	50	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1130	51	nature	nature	NN
22283	1130	52	of	of	IN
22283	1130	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1130	54	own	own	JJ
22283	1130	55	volition	volition	NN
22283	1130	56	.	.	.
22283	1131	1	For	for	IN
22283	1131	2	the	the	DT
22283	1131	3	influence	influence	NN
22283	1131	4	which	which	WDT
22283	1131	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	1131	6	thus	thus	RB
22283	1131	7	exerted	exert	VBN
22283	1131	8	can	can	MD
22283	1131	9	not	not	RB
22283	1131	10	be	be	VB
22283	1131	11	exerted	exert	VBN
22283	1131	12	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1131	13	,	,	,
22283	1131	14	unless	unless	IN
22283	1131	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1131	16	suppose	suppose	VBP
22283	1131	17	that	that	IN
22283	1131	18	the	the	DT
22283	1131	19	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1131	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	1131	21	not	not	RB
22283	1131	22	a	a	DT
22283	1131	23	first	first	JJ
22283	1131	24	cause	cause	NN
22283	1131	25	,	,	,
22283	1131	26	which	which	WDT
22283	1131	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	1131	28	the	the	DT
22283	1131	29	possibility	possibility	NN
22283	1131	30	now	now	RB
22283	1131	31	under	under	IN
22283	1131	32	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	1131	33	.	.	.
22283	1132	1	If	if	IN
22283	1132	2	the	the	DT
22283	1132	3	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1132	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1132	5	a	a	DT
22283	1132	6	first	first	JJ
22283	1132	7	cause	cause	NN
22283	1132	8	,	,	,
22283	1132	9	the	the	DT
22283	1132	10	influences	influence	NNS
22283	1132	11	brought	bring	VBN
22283	1132	12	to	to	TO
22283	1132	13	bear	bear	VB
22283	1132	14	upon	upon	IN
22283	1132	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1132	16	by	by	IN
22283	1132	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1132	18	relation	relation	NN
22283	1132	19	to	to	IN
22283	1132	20	other	other	JJ
22283	1132	21	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1132	22	--	--	:
22283	1132	23	and	and	CC
22283	1132	24	in	in	IN
22283	1132	25	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	1132	26	of	of	IN
22283	1132	27	which	which	WDT
22283	1132	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1132	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	1132	30	constituted	constituted	JJ
22283	1132	31	,	,	,
22283	1132	32	not	not	RB
22283	1132	33	only	only	RB
22283	1132	34	a	a	DT
22283	1132	35	cause	cause	NN
22283	1132	36	primal	primal	JJ
22283	1132	37	,	,	,
22283	1132	38	but	but	CC
22283	1132	39	also	also	RB
22283	1132	40	a	a	DT
22283	1132	41	cause	cause	NN
22283	1132	42	rational	rational	JJ
22283	1132	43	and	and	CC
22283	1132	44	moral	moral	JJ
22283	1132	45	--	--	:
22283	1132	46	these	these	DT
22283	1132	47	influences	influence	NNS
22283	1132	48	differ	differ	VBP
22283	1132	49	_	_	NNP
22283	1132	50	toto	toto	NN
22283	1132	51	coelo	coelo	NNP
22283	1132	52	_	_	NNP
22283	1132	53	from	from	IN
22283	1132	54	those	those	DT
22283	1132	55	which	which	WDT
22283	1132	56	are	be	VBP
22283	1132	57	exercised	exercise	VBN
22283	1132	58	by	by	IN
22283	1132	59	any	any	DT
22283	1132	60	members	member	NNS
22283	1132	61	in	in	IN
22283	1132	62	a	a	DT
22283	1132	63	series	series	NN
22283	1132	64	of	of	IN
22283	1132	65	secondary	secondary	JJ
22283	1132	66	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1132	67	upon	upon	IN
22283	1132	68	the	the	DT
22283	1132	69	next	next	JJ
22283	1132	70	succeeding	succeed	VBG
22283	1132	71	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1132	72	.	.	.
22283	1133	1	And	and	CC
22283	1133	2	the	the	DT
22283	1133	3	difference	difference	NN
22283	1133	4	consists	consist	VBZ
22283	1133	5	in	in	IN
22283	1133	6	the	the	DT
22283	1133	7	absence	absence	NN
22283	1133	8	of	of	IN
22283	1133	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	1133	10	or	or	CC
22283	1133	11	unconditional	unconditional	JJ
22283	1133	12	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	1133	13	in	in	IN
22283	1133	14	the	the	DT
22283	1133	15	one	one	CD
22283	1133	16	case	case	NN
22283	1133	17	,	,	,
22283	1133	18	and	and	CC
22283	1133	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1133	20	presence	presence	NN
22283	1133	21	in	in	IN
22283	1133	22	the	the	DT
22283	1133	23	other	other	JJ
22283	1133	24	.	.	.
22283	1134	1	However	however	RB
22283	1134	2	strong	strong	JJ
22283	1134	3	the	the	DT
22283	1134	4	determining	determine	VBG
22283	1134	5	influence	influence	NN
22283	1134	6	of	of	IN
22283	1134	7	a	a	DT
22283	1134	8	motive	motive	NN
22283	1134	9	may	may	MD
22283	1134	10	be	be	VB
22283	1134	11	,	,	,
22283	1134	12	if	if	IN
22283	1134	13	the	the	DT
22283	1134	14	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1134	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	1134	16	a	a	DT
22283	1134	17	first	first	JJ
22283	1134	18	cause	cause	NN
22283	1134	19	,	,	,
22283	1134	20	the	the	DT
22283	1134	21	motive	motive	NN
22283	1134	22	must	must	MD
22283	1134	23	belong	belong	VB
22283	1134	24	to	to	IN
22283	1134	25	a	a	DT
22283	1134	26	different	different	JJ
22283	1134	27	order	order	NN
22283	1134	28	of	of	IN
22283	1134	29	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1134	30	relation	relation	NN
22283	1134	31	from	from	IN
22283	1134	32	a	a	DT
22283	1134	33	motor	motor	NN
22283	1134	34	;	;	:
22283	1134	35	for	for	IN
22283	1134	36	,	,	,
22283	1134	37	no	no	RB
22283	1134	38	matter	matter	RB
22283	1134	39	how	how	WRB
22283	1134	40	strong	strong	JJ
22283	1134	41	the	the	DT
22283	1134	42	determining	determine	VBG
22283	1134	43	influence	influence	NN
22283	1134	44	may	may	MD
22283	1134	45	be	be	VB
22283	1134	46	,	,	,
22283	1134	47	_	_	NNP
22283	1134	48	ex	ex	NNP
22283	1134	49	hypothesi	hypothesi	NNP
22283	1134	50	_	_	NNP
22283	1134	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1134	52	can	can	MD
22283	1134	53	never	never	RB
22283	1134	54	attain	attain	VB
22283	1134	55	to	to	IN
22283	1134	56	the	the	DT
22283	1134	57	strength	strength	NN
22283	1134	58	of	of	IN
22283	1134	59	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1134	60	;	;	:
22283	1134	61	the	the	DT
22283	1134	62	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1134	63	must	must	MD
22283	1134	64	ever	ever	RB
22283	1134	65	remain	remain	VB
22283	1134	66	free	free	JJ
22283	1134	67	to	to	TO
22283	1134	68	overcome	overcome	VB
22283	1134	69	such	such	JJ
22283	1134	70	influence	influence	NN
22283	1134	71	by	by	IN
22283	1134	72	an	an	DT
22283	1134	73	adequate	adequate	JJ
22283	1134	74	exercise	exercise	NN
22283	1134	75	of	of	IN
22283	1134	76	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1134	77	own	own	JJ
22283	1134	78	power	power	NN
22283	1134	79	of	of	IN
22283	1134	80	spontaneous	spontaneous	JJ
22283	1134	81	action	action	NN
22283	1134	82	,	,	,
22283	1134	83	or	or	CC
22283	1134	84	of	of	IN
22283	1134	85	supplying	supply	VBG
22283	1134	86	_	_	NNP
22283	1134	87	de	de	NNP
22283	1134	88	novo	novo	NNP
22283	1134	89	_	_	NNP
22283	1134	90	an	an	DT
22283	1134	91	additional	additional	JJ
22283	1134	92	access	access	NN
22283	1134	93	of	of	IN
22283	1134	94	strength	strength	NN
22283	1134	95	to	to	IN
22283	1134	96	some	some	DT
22283	1134	97	other	other	JJ
22283	1134	98	motive	motive	NN
22283	1134	99	.	.	.
22283	1135	1	Of	of	RB
22283	1135	2	course	course	RB
22283	1135	3	,	,	,
22283	1135	4	as	as	IN
22283	1135	5	a	a	DT
22283	1135	6	general	general	JJ
22283	1135	7	rule	rule	NN
22283	1135	8	,	,	,
22283	1135	9	the	the	DT
22283	1135	10	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1135	11	allows	allow	VBZ
22283	1135	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1135	13	to	to	TO
22283	1135	14	be	be	VB
22283	1135	15	influenced	influence	VBN
22283	1135	16	by	by	IN
22283	1135	17	motives	motive	NNS
22283	1135	18	supplied	supply	VBN
22283	1135	19	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	1135	20	by	by	IN
22283	1135	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1135	22	relations	relation	NNS
22283	1135	23	with	with	IN
22283	1135	24	the	the	DT
22283	1135	25	external	external	JJ
22283	1135	26	world	world	NN
22283	1135	27	;	;	,
22283	1135	28	but	but	CC
22283	1135	29	this	this	DT
22283	1135	30	is	be	VBZ
22283	1135	31	so	so	RB
22283	1135	32	only	only	RB
22283	1135	33	because	because	IN
22283	1135	34	the	the	DT
22283	1135	35	thinking	thinking	NN
22283	1135	36	substance	substance	NN
22283	1135	37	well	well	RB
22283	1135	38	knows	know	VBZ
22283	1135	39	that	that	IN
22283	1135	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1135	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	1135	42	expedient	expedient	NN
22283	1135	43	so	so	RB
22283	1135	44	to	to	TO
22283	1135	45	fall	fall	VB
22283	1135	46	in	in	RP
22283	1135	47	with	with	IN
22283	1135	48	the	the	DT
22283	1135	49	general	general	JJ
22283	1135	50	stream	stream	NN
22283	1135	51	of	of	IN
22283	1135	52	external	external	JJ
22283	1135	53	causation	causation	NN
22283	1135	54	.	.	.
22283	1136	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	1136	2	,	,	,
22283	1136	3	as	as	IN
22283	1136	4	a	a	DT
22283	1136	5	general	general	JJ
22283	1136	6	rule	rule	NN
22283	1136	7	,	,	,
22283	1136	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1136	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1136	10	only	only	RB
22283	1136	11	in	in	IN
22283	1136	12	cases	case	NNS
22283	1136	13	where	where	WRB
22283	1136	14	the	the	DT
22283	1136	15	stream	stream	NN
22283	1136	16	of	of	IN
22283	1136	17	external	external	JJ
22283	1136	18	causation	causation	NN
22283	1136	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	1136	20	drawing	draw	VBG
22283	1136	21	the	the	DT
22283	1136	22	will	will	NN
22283	1136	23	in	in	IN
22283	1136	24	different	different	JJ
22283	1136	25	directions	direction	NNS
22283	1136	26	that	that	WDT
22283	1136	27	the	the	DT
22283	1136	28	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1136	29	activity	activity	NN
22283	1136	30	of	of	IN
22283	1136	31	the	the	DT
22283	1136	32	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1136	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1136	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	1136	35	called	call	VBN
22283	1136	36	into	into	IN
22283	1136	37	play	play	NN
22283	1136	38	.	.	.
22283	1137	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1137	2	rather	rather	RB
22283	1137	3	,	,	,
22283	1137	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1137	5	should	should	MD
22283	1137	6	say	say	VB
22283	1137	7	,	,	,
22283	1137	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1137	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1137	10	only	only	RB
22283	1137	11	in	in	IN
22283	1137	12	such	such	JJ
22283	1137	13	cases	case	NNS
22283	1137	14	that	that	WDT
22283	1137	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1137	16	become	become	VBP
22283	1137	17	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	1137	18	of	of	IN
22283	1137	19	the	the	DT
22283	1137	20	fact	fact	NN
22283	1137	21	.	.	.
22283	1138	1	In	in	IN
22283	1138	2	the	the	DT
22283	1138	3	case	case	NN
22283	1138	4	of	of	IN
22283	1138	5	every	every	DT
22283	1138	6	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
22283	1138	7	movement	movement	NN
22283	1138	8	the	the	DT
22283	1138	9	primal	primal	JJ
22283	1138	10	activity	activity	NN
22283	1138	11	of	of	IN
22283	1138	12	Will	Will	MD
22283	1138	13	must	must	MD
22283	1138	14	be	be	VB
22283	1138	15	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	1138	16	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1138	17	and	and	CC
22283	1138	18	this	this	DT
22283	1138	19	even	even	RB
22283	1138	20	in	in	IN
22283	1138	21	the	the	DT
22283	1138	22	case	case	NN
22283	1138	23	of	of	IN
22283	1138	24	the	the	DT
22283	1138	25	lower	low	JJR
22283	1138	26	animals	animal	NNS
22283	1138	27	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1138	28	;	;	:
22283	1138	29	but	but	CC
22283	1138	30	as	as	IN
22283	1138	31	the	the	DT
22283	1138	32	vast	vast	JJ
22283	1138	33	majority	majority	NN
22283	1138	34	of	of	IN
22283	1138	35	such	such	JJ
22283	1138	36	movements	movement	NNS
22283	1138	37	are	be	VBP
22283	1138	38	performed	perform	VBN
22283	1138	39	by	by	IN
22283	1138	40	way	way	NN
22283	1138	41	of	of	IN
22283	1138	42	response	response	NN
22283	1138	43	to	to	IN
22283	1138	44	frequently	frequently	RB
22283	1138	45	recurring	recur	VBG
22283	1138	46	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
22283	1138	47	,	,	,
22283	1138	48	the	the	DT
22283	1138	49	response	response	NN
22283	1138	50	which	which	WDT
22283	1138	51	experience	experience	NN
22283	1138	52	has	have	VBZ
22283	1138	53	shown	show	VBN
22283	1138	54	to	to	TO
22283	1138	55	be	be	VB
22283	1138	56	most	most	RBS
22283	1138	57	expedient	expedient	JJ
22283	1138	58	is	be	VBZ
22283	1138	59	given	give	VBN
22283	1138	60	,	,	,
22283	1138	61	as	as	IN
22283	1138	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1138	63	were	be	VBD
22283	1138	64	,	,	,
22283	1138	65	automatically	automatically	RB
22283	1138	66	,	,	,
22283	1138	67	or	or	CC
22283	1138	68	without	without	IN
22283	1138	69	the	the	DT
22283	1138	70	occurrence	occurrence	NN
22283	1138	71	of	of	IN
22283	1138	72	any	any	DT
22283	1138	73	adverse	adverse	JJ
22283	1138	74	motive	motive	NN
22283	1138	75	.	.	.
22283	1139	1	But	but	CC
22283	1139	2	in	in	IN
22283	1139	3	cases	case	NNS
22283	1139	4	where	where	WRB
22283	1139	5	motives	motive	NNS
22283	1139	6	are	be	VBP
22283	1139	7	drawing	draw	VBG
22283	1139	8	in	in	IN
22283	1139	9	different	different	JJ
22283	1139	10	directions	direction	NNS
22283	1139	11	,	,	,
22283	1139	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1139	13	become	become	VBP
22283	1139	14	conscious	conscious	JJ
22283	1139	15	of	of	IN
22283	1139	16	an	an	DT
22283	1139	17	effort	effort	NN
22283	1139	18	of	of	IN
22283	1139	19	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1139	20	in	in	IN
22283	1139	21	choosing	choose	VBG
22283	1139	22	one	one	CD
22283	1139	23	or	or	CC
22283	1139	24	other	other	JJ
22283	1139	25	line	line	NN
22283	1139	26	of	of	IN
22283	1139	27	conduct	conduct	NN
22283	1139	28	,	,	,
22283	1139	29	and	and	CC
22283	1139	30	,	,	,
22283	1139	31	according	accord	VBG
22283	1139	32	to	to	IN
22283	1139	33	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1139	34	present	present	JJ
22283	1139	35	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
22283	1139	36	,	,	,
22283	1139	37	this	this	DT
22283	1139	38	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	1139	39	of	of	IN
22283	1139	40	effort	effort	NN
22283	1139	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	1139	42	an	an	DT
22283	1139	43	expression	expression	NN
22283	1139	44	of	of	IN
22283	1139	45	the	the	DT
22283	1139	46	work	work	NN
22283	1139	47	which	which	WDT
22283	1139	48	the	the	DT
22283	1139	49	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1139	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	1139	51	doing	do	VBG
22283	1139	52	in	in	IN
22283	1139	53	the	the	DT
22283	1139	54	way	way	NN
22283	1139	55	of	of	IN
22283	1139	56	spontaneous	spontaneous	JJ
22283	1139	57	causation	causation	NN
22283	1139	58	.	.	.
22283	1140	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	1140	2	,	,	,
22283	1140	3	upon	upon	IN
22283	1140	4	the	the	DT
22283	1140	5	whole	whole	NN
22283	1140	6	,	,	,
22283	1140	7	if	if	IN
22283	1140	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1140	9	identify	identify	VBP
22283	1140	10	the	the	DT
22283	1140	11	principle	principle	NN
22283	1140	12	of	of	IN
22283	1140	13	causation	causation	NN
22283	1140	14	with	with	IN
22283	1140	15	the	the	DT
22283	1140	16	principle	principle	NN
22283	1140	17	of	of	IN
22283	1140	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	1140	19	--	--	:
22283	1140	20	as	as	IN
22283	1140	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1140	22	are	be	VBP
22283	1140	23	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1140	24	to	to	TO
22283	1140	25	do	do	VB
22283	1140	26	by	by	IN
22283	1140	27	the	the	DT
22283	1140	28	theory	theory	NN
22283	1140	29	of	of	IN
22283	1140	30	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1140	31	--	--	:
22283	1140	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1140	33	thereby	thereby	RB
22283	1140	34	draw	draw	VBP
22283	1140	35	a	a	DT
22283	1140	36	great	great	JJ
22283	1140	37	and	and	CC
22283	1140	38	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	1140	39	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1140	40	between	between	IN
22283	1140	41	causation	causation	NN
22283	1140	42	as	as	IN
22283	1140	43	this	this	DT
22283	1140	44	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	1140	45	in	in	IN
22283	1140	46	the	the	DT
22283	1140	47	external	external	JJ
22283	1140	48	world	world	NN
22283	1140	49	,	,	,
22283	1140	50	and	and	CC
22283	1140	51	as	as	IN
22283	1140	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1140	53	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	1140	54	within	within	IN
22283	1140	55	the	the	DT
22283	1140	56	limits	limit	NNS
22283	1140	57	of	of	IN
22283	1140	58	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1140	59	own	own	JJ
22283	1140	60	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	1140	61	.	.	.
22283	1141	1	And	and	CC
22283	1141	2	the	the	DT
22283	1141	3	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1141	4	consists	consist	VBZ
22283	1141	5	in	in	IN
22283	1141	6	the	the	DT
22283	1141	7	unconditional	unconditional	JJ
22283	1141	8	nature	nature	NN
22283	1141	9	of	of	IN
22283	1141	10	a	a	DT
22283	1141	11	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1141	12	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	1141	13	in	in	IN
22283	1141	14	the	the	DT
22283	1141	15	external	external	JJ
22283	1141	16	world	world	NN
22283	1141	17	,	,	,
22283	1141	18	as	as	IN
22283	1141	19	against	against	IN
22283	1141	20	the	the	DT
22283	1141	21	conditional	conditional	JJ
22283	1141	22	nature	nature	NN
22283	1141	23	of	of	IN
22283	1141	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1141	25	in	in	IN
22283	1141	26	the	the	DT
22283	1141	27	other	other	JJ
22283	1141	28	case	case	NN
22283	1141	29	;	;	:
22283	1141	30	the	the	DT
22283	1141	31	condition	condition	NN
22283	1141	32	to	to	IN
22283	1141	33	the	the	DT
22283	1141	34	effective	effective	JJ
22283	1141	35	operation	operation	NN
22283	1141	36	of	of	IN
22283	1141	37	a	a	DT
22283	1141	38	motive	motive	NN
22283	1141	39	--	--	:
22283	1141	40	as	as	IN
22283	1141	41	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
22283	1141	42	from	from	IN
22283	1141	43	a	a	DT
22283	1141	44	motor	motor	NN
22283	1141	45	--	--	:
22283	1141	46	is	be	VBZ
22283	1141	47	the	the	DT
22283	1141	48	acquiescence	acquiescence	NN
22283	1141	49	of	of	IN
22283	1141	50	the	the	DT
22283	1141	51	first	first	JJ
22283	1141	52	cause	cause	NN
22283	1141	53	upon	upon	IN
22283	1141	54	which	which	WDT
22283	1141	55	that	that	DT
22283	1141	56	motive	motive	NN
22283	1141	57	is	be	VBZ
22283	1141	58	operating	operate	VBG
22283	1141	59	.	.	.
22283	1142	1	To	to	IN
22283	1142	2	the	the	DT
22283	1142	3	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
22283	1142	4	argument	argument	NN
22283	1142	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1142	6	may	may	MD
22283	1142	7	be	be	VB
22283	1142	8	objected	object	VBN
22283	1142	9	that	that	IN
22283	1142	10	by	by	IN
22283	1142	11	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	1142	12	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	1142	13	the	the	DT
22283	1142	14	human	human	JJ
22283	1142	15	mind	mind	NN
22283	1142	16	as	as	IN
22283	1142	17	a	a	DT
22283	1142	18	first	first	JJ
22283	1142	19	cause	cause	NN
22283	1142	20	of	of	IN
22283	1142	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1142	22	own	own	JJ
22283	1142	23	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1142	24	,	,	,
22283	1142	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1142	26	imply	imply	VBP
22283	1142	27	that	that	IN
22283	1142	28	that	that	DT
22283	1142	29	mind	mind	NN
22283	1142	30	can	can	MD
22283	1142	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1142	32	have	have	VB
22283	1142	33	had	have	VBN
22283	1142	34	no	no	DT
22283	1142	35	cause	cause	NN
22283	1142	36	,	,	,
22283	1142	37	which	which	WDT
22283	1142	38	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1142	39	to	to	TO
22283	1142	40	be	be	VB
22283	1142	41	self	self	NN
22283	1142	42	-	-	HYPH
22283	1142	43	evidently	evidently	RB
22283	1142	44	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	1142	45	.	.	.
22283	1143	1	But	but	CC
22283	1143	2	here	here	RB
22283	1143	3	again	again	RB
22283	1143	4	the	the	DT
22283	1143	5	absurdity	absurdity	NN
22283	1143	6	only	only	RB
22283	1143	7	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1143	8	from	from	IN
22283	1143	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1143	10	inveterate	inveterate	JJ
22283	1143	11	habit	habit	NN
22283	1143	12	of	of	IN
22283	1143	13	regarding	regard	VBG
22283	1143	14	the	the	DT
22283	1143	15	principle	principle	NN
22283	1143	16	of	of	IN
22283	1143	17	causation	causation	NN
22283	1143	18	as	as	IN
22283	1143	19	logically	logically	RB
22283	1143	20	prior	prior	RB
22283	1143	21	to	to	IN
22283	1143	22	that	that	DT
22283	1143	23	of	of	IN
22283	1143	24	mind	mind	NN
22283	1143	25	.	.	.
22283	1144	1	If	if	IN
22283	1144	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1144	3	expressly	expressly	RB
22283	1144	4	refuse	refuse	VBP
22283	1144	5	to	to	TO
22283	1144	6	do	do	VB
22283	1144	7	this	this	DT
22283	1144	8	,	,	,
22283	1144	9	there	there	EX
22283	1144	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1144	11	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1144	12	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	1144	13	in	in	IN
22283	1144	14	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	1144	15	the	the	DT
22283	1144	16	principle	principle	NN
22283	1144	17	of	of	IN
22283	1144	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	1144	19	wherever	wherever	WRB
22283	1144	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1144	21	occurs	occur	VBZ
22283	1144	22	,	,	,
22283	1144	23	as	as	IN
22283	1144	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1144	25	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1144	26	.	.	.
22283	1145	1	For	for	IN
22283	1145	2	if	if	IN
22283	1145	3	,	,	,
22283	1145	4	as	as	IN
22283	1145	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1145	6	are	be	VBP
22283	1145	7	now	now	RB
22283	1145	8	supposing	suppose	VBG
22283	1145	9	,	,	,
22283	1145	10	this	this	DT
22283	1145	11	principle	principle	NN
22283	1145	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1145	13	identical	identical	JJ
22283	1145	14	with	with	IN
22283	1145	15	that	that	DT
22283	1145	16	of	of	IN
22283	1145	17	causation	causation	NN
22283	1145	18	,	,	,
22283	1145	19	to	to	TO
22283	1145	20	say	say	VB
22283	1145	21	that	that	IN
22283	1145	22	any	any	DT
22283	1145	23	mind	mind	NN
22283	1145	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	1145	25	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1145	26	would	would	MD
22283	1145	27	be	be	VB
22283	1145	28	to	to	TO
22283	1145	29	say	say	VB
22283	1145	30	that	that	IN
22283	1145	31	a	a	DT
22283	1145	32	cause	cause	NN
22283	1145	33	is	be	VBZ
22283	1145	34	the	the	DT
22283	1145	35	cause	cause	NN
22283	1145	36	of	of	IN
22283	1145	37	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1145	38	,	,	,
22283	1145	39	which	which	WDT
22283	1145	40	would	would	MD
22283	1145	41	be	be	VB
22283	1145	42	really	really	RB
22283	1145	43	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	1145	44	.	.	.
22283	1146	1	Under	under	IN
22283	1146	2	the	the	DT
22283	1146	3	present	present	JJ
22283	1146	4	point	point	NN
22283	1146	5	of	of	IN
22283	1146	6	view	view	NN
22283	1146	7	,	,	,
22283	1146	8	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1146	9	,	,	,
22283	1146	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1146	11	would	would	MD
22283	1146	12	be	be	VB
22283	1146	13	a	a	DT
22283	1146	14	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
22283	1146	15	question	question	NN
22283	1146	16	to	to	TO
22283	1146	17	ask	ask	VB
22283	1146	18	for	for	IN
22283	1146	19	the	the	DT
22283	1146	20	cause	cause	NN
22283	1146	21	of	of	IN
22283	1146	22	a	a	DT
22283	1146	23	human	human	JJ
22283	1146	24	mind	mind	NN
22283	1146	25	,	,	,
22283	1146	26	since	since	IN
22283	1146	27	,	,	,
22283	1146	28	_	_	NNP
22283	1146	29	ex	ex	NNP
22283	1146	30	hypothesi	hypothesi	NNP
22283	1146	31	_	_	NNP
22283	1146	32	,	,	,
22283	1146	33	a	a	DT
22283	1146	34	human	human	JJ
22283	1146	35	mind	mind	NN
22283	1146	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	1146	37	a	a	DT
22283	1146	38	part	part	NN
22283	1146	39	of	of	IN
22283	1146	40	the	the	DT
22283	1146	41	self	self	NN
22283	1146	42	-	-	HYPH
22283	1146	43	existing	exist	VBG
22283	1146	44	substance	substance	NN
22283	1146	45	,	,	,
22283	1146	46	although	although	IN
22283	1146	47	not	not	RB
22283	1146	48	on	on	IN
22283	1146	49	this	this	DT
22283	1146	50	account	account	NN
22283	1146	51	self	self	NN
22283	1146	52	-	-	HYPH
22283	1146	53	existing	exist	VBG
22283	1146	54	as	as	IN
22283	1146	55	to	to	IN
22283	1146	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1146	57	individual	individual	JJ
22283	1146	58	personality	personality	NN
22283	1146	59	.	.	.
22283	1147	1	As	as	IN
22283	1147	2	argued	argue	VBN
22283	1147	3	in	in	IN
22283	1147	4	a	a	DT
22283	1147	5	previous	previous	JJ
22283	1147	6	chapter	chapter	NN
22283	1147	7	,	,	,
22283	1147	8	the	the	DT
22283	1147	9	personality	personality	NN
22283	1147	10	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1147	11	to	to	TO
22283	1147	12	arise	arise	VB
22283	1147	13	on	on	IN
22283	1147	14	account	account	NN
22283	1147	15	of	of	IN
22283	1147	16	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	1147	17	,	,	,
22283	1147	18	or	or	CC
22283	1147	19	the	the	DT
22283	1147	20	isolation	isolation	NN
22283	1147	21	of	of	IN
22283	1147	22	a	a	DT
22283	1147	23	constituent	constituent	JJ
22283	1147	24	part	part	NN
22283	1147	25	of	of	IN
22283	1147	26	the	the	DT
22283	1147	27	World	World	NNP
22283	1147	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	1147	29	eject	eject	NN
22283	1147	30	.	.	.
22283	1148	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1148	2	,	,	,
22283	1148	3	although	although	IN
22283	1148	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1148	5	may	may	MD
22283	1148	6	be	be	VB
22283	1148	7	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
22283	1148	8	to	to	TO
22283	1148	9	ask	ask	VB
22283	1148	10	for	for	IN
22283	1148	11	a	a	DT
22283	1148	12	cause	cause	NN
22283	1148	13	of	of	IN
22283	1148	14	this	this	DT
22283	1148	15	circumscription	circumscription	NN
22283	1148	16	--	--	:
22283	1148	17	or	or	CC
22283	1148	18	of	of	IN
22283	1148	19	the	the	DT
22283	1148	20	personality	personality	NN
22283	1148	21	--	--	:
22283	1148	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1148	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	1148	24	not	not	RB
22283	1148	25	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
22283	1148	26	to	to	TO
22283	1148	27	ask	ask	VB
22283	1148	28	for	for	IN
22283	1148	29	a	a	DT
22283	1148	30	cause	cause	NN
22283	1148	31	of	of	IN
22283	1148	32	the	the	DT
22283	1148	33	substance	substance	NN
22283	1148	34	which	which	WDT
22283	1148	35	is	be	VBZ
22283	1148	36	thus	thus	RB
22283	1148	37	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	1148	38	,	,	,
22283	1148	39	or	or	CC
22283	1148	40	of	of	IN
22283	1148	41	the	the	DT
22283	1148	42	quality	quality	NN
22283	1148	43	of	of	IN
22283	1148	44	spontaneity	spontaneity	NN
22283	1148	45	which	which	WDT
22283	1148	46	that	that	IN
22283	1148	47	substance	substance	NN
22283	1148	48	exhibits	exhibit	VBZ
22283	1148	49	.	.	.
22283	1149	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1149	2	will	will	MD
22283	1149	3	now	now	RB
22283	1149	4	state	state	VB
22283	1149	5	the	the	DT
22283	1149	6	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1149	7	case	case	NN
22283	1149	8	in	in	IN
22283	1149	9	another	another	DT
22283	1149	10	way	way	NN
22283	1149	11	.	.	.
22283	1150	1	When	when	WRB
22283	1150	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1150	3	regard	regard	VBP
22283	1150	4	the	the	DT
22283	1150	5	facts	fact	NNS
22283	1150	6	of	of	IN
22283	1150	7	volition	volition	NN
22283	1150	8	from	from	IN
22283	1150	9	the	the	DT
22283	1150	10	stand	stand	NN
22283	1150	11	-	-	HYPH
22283	1150	12	point	point	NN
22283	1150	13	of	of	IN
22283	1150	14	psychology	psychology	NN
22283	1150	15	,	,	,
22283	1150	16	the	the	DT
22283	1150	17	only	only	JJ
22283	1150	18	theory	theory	NN
22283	1150	19	of	of	IN
22283	1150	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1150	21	which	which	WDT
22283	1150	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1150	23	open	open	JJ
22283	1150	24	to	to	IN
22283	1150	25	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1150	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	1150	27	,	,	,
22283	1150	28	as	as	IN
22283	1150	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1150	30	have	have	VBP
22283	1150	31	before	before	RB
22283	1150	32	seen	see	VBN
22283	1150	33	,	,	,
22283	1150	34	that	that	DT
22283	1150	35	of	of	IN
22283	1150	36	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	1150	37	.	.	.
22283	1151	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
22283	1151	2	,	,	,
22283	1151	3	within	within	IN
22283	1151	4	these	these	DT
22283	1151	5	limits	limit	NNS
22283	1151	6	that	that	WDT
22283	1151	7	theory	theory	NN
22283	1151	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1151	9	perfectly	perfectly	RB
22283	1151	10	true	true	JJ
22283	1151	11	.	.	.
22283	1152	1	Psychology	psychology	NN
22283	1152	2	,	,	,
22283	1152	3	as	as	IN
22283	1152	4	such	such	JJ
22283	1152	5	,	,	,
22283	1152	6	can	can	MD
22283	1152	7	not	not	RB
22283	1152	8	recognize	recognize	VB
22283	1152	9	any	any	DT
22283	1152	10	principle	principle	NN
22283	1152	11	more	more	RBR
22283	1152	12	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1152	13	than	than	IN
22283	1152	14	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1152	15	causation	causation	NN
22283	1152	16	,	,	,
22283	1152	17	seeing	see	VBG
22283	1152	18	that	that	DT
22283	1152	19	,	,	,
22283	1152	20	like	like	IN
22283	1152	21	any	any	DT
22283	1152	22	other	other	JJ
22283	1152	23	of	of	IN
22283	1152	24	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1152	25	sisters	sister	NNS
22283	1152	26	in	in	IN
22283	1152	27	the	the	DT
22283	1152	28	family	family	NN
22283	1152	29	of	of	IN
22283	1152	30	sciences	sciences	NNPS
22283	1152	31	,	,	,
22283	1152	32	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1152	33	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1152	34	work	work	NN
22283	1152	35	and	and	CC
22283	1152	36	duty	duty	NN
22283	1152	37	are	be	VBP
22283	1152	38	confined	confine	VBN
22283	1152	39	to	to	IN
22283	1152	40	the	the	DT
22283	1152	41	investigation	investigation	NN
22283	1152	42	of	of	IN
22283	1152	43	this	this	DT
22283	1152	44	principle	principle	NN
22283	1152	45	.	.	.
22283	1153	1	But	but	CC
22283	1153	2	,	,	,
22283	1153	3	just	just	RB
22283	1153	4	as	as	IN
22283	1153	5	in	in	IN
22283	1153	6	the	the	DT
22283	1153	7	case	case	NN
22283	1153	8	of	of	IN
22283	1153	9	all	all	PDT
22283	1153	10	the	the	DT
22283	1153	11	other	other	JJ
22283	1153	12	sciences	science	NNS
22283	1153	13	,	,	,
22283	1153	14	when	when	WRB
22283	1153	15	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1153	16	investigations	investigation	NNS
22283	1153	17	have	have	VBP
22283	1153	18	been	be	VBN
22283	1153	19	pushed	push	VBN
22283	1153	20	to	to	IN
22283	1153	21	the	the	DT
22283	1153	22	point	point	NN
22283	1153	23	where	where	WRB
22283	1153	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1153	25	encounter	encounter	VBP
22283	1153	26	the	the	DT
22283	1153	27	problem	problem	NN
22283	1153	28	of	of	IN
22283	1153	29	explaining	explain	VBG
22283	1153	30	this	this	DT
22283	1153	31	principle	principle	NN
22283	1153	32	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1153	33	,	,	,
22283	1153	34	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1153	35	investigations	investigation	NNS
22283	1153	36	must	must	MD
22283	1153	37	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1153	38	cease	cease	VB
22283	1153	39	;	;	:
22283	1153	40	this	this	DT
22283	1153	41	principle	principle	NN
22283	1153	42	is	be	VBZ
22283	1153	43	for	for	IN
22283	1153	44	all	all	PDT
22283	1153	45	the	the	DT
22283	1153	46	sciences	science	NNS
22283	1153	47	the	the	DT
22283	1153	48	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1153	49	datum	datum	NN
22283	1153	50	,	,	,
22283	1153	51	behind	behind	IN
22283	1153	52	which	which	WDT
22283	1153	53	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1153	54	can	can	MD
22283	1153	55	not	not	RB
22283	1153	56	go	go	VB
22283	1153	57	without	without	IN
22283	1153	58	ceasing	cease	VBG
22283	1153	59	to	to	TO
22283	1153	60	be	be	VB
22283	1153	61	sciences	science	NNS
22283	1153	62	.	.	.
22283	1154	1	But	but	CC
22283	1154	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1154	3	does	do	VBZ
22283	1154	4	not	not	RB
22283	1154	5	follow	follow	VB
22283	1154	6	that	that	DT
22283	1154	7	because	because	IN
22283	1154	8	the	the	DT
22283	1154	9	area	area	NN
22283	1154	10	of	of	IN
22283	1154	11	science	science	NN
22283	1154	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1154	13	limited	limit	VBN
22283	1154	14	by	by	IN
22283	1154	15	that	that	DT
22283	1154	16	of	of	IN
22283	1154	17	causation	causation	NN
22283	1154	18	,	,	,
22283	1154	19	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1154	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1154	21	are	be	VBP
22283	1154	22	precluded	preclude	VBN
22283	1154	23	from	from	IN
22283	1154	24	asking	ask	VBG
22283	1154	25	any	any	DT
22283	1154	26	questions	question	NNS
22283	1154	27	as	as	IN
22283	1154	28	to	to	IN
22283	1154	29	the	the	DT
22283	1154	30	nature	nature	NN
22283	1154	31	of	of	IN
22283	1154	32	this	this	DT
22283	1154	33	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1154	34	datum	datum	NN
22283	1154	35	.	.	.
22283	1155	1	Of	of	RB
22283	1155	2	course	course	RB
22283	1155	3	any	any	DT
22283	1155	4	questions	question	NNS
22283	1155	5	which	which	WDT
22283	1155	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1155	7	may	may	MD
22283	1155	8	thus	thus	RB
22283	1155	9	ask	ask	VB
22283	1155	10	can	can	MD
22283	1155	11	not	not	RB
22283	1155	12	possibly	possibly	RB
22283	1155	13	be	be	VB
22283	1155	14	answered	answer	VBN
22283	1155	15	by	by	IN
22283	1155	16	science	science	NN
22283	1155	17	;	;	:
22283	1155	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1155	19	are	be	VBP
22283	1155	20	questions	question	NNS
22283	1155	21	of	of	IN
22283	1155	22	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	1155	23	,	,	,
22283	1155	24	in	in	IN
22283	1155	25	the	the	DT
22283	1155	26	consideration	consideration	NN
22283	1155	27	of	of	IN
22283	1155	28	which	which	WDT
22283	1155	29	science	science	NN
22283	1155	30	,	,	,
22283	1155	31	from	from	IN
22283	1155	32	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1155	33	very	very	JJ
22283	1155	34	nature	nature	NN
22283	1155	35	and	and	CC
22283	1155	36	essential	essential	JJ
22283	1155	37	limitation	limitation	NN
22283	1155	38	of	of	IN
22283	1155	39	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1155	40	office	office	NN
22283	1155	41	,	,	,
22283	1155	42	can	can	MD
22283	1155	43	have	have	VB
22283	1155	44	no	no	DT
22283	1155	45	voice	voice	NN
22283	1155	46	.	.	.
22283	1156	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1156	2	,	,	,
22283	1156	3	if	if	IN
22283	1156	4	on	on	IN
22283	1156	5	taking	take	VBG
22283	1156	6	up	up	RP
22283	1156	7	the	the	DT
22283	1156	8	principle	principle	NN
22283	1156	9	of	of	IN
22283	1156	10	causation	causation	NN
22283	1156	11	where	where	WRB
22283	1156	12	this	this	DT
22283	1156	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	1156	14	left	leave	VBN
22283	1156	15	by	by	IN
22283	1156	16	science	science	NN
22283	1156	17	--	--	:
22283	1156	18	viz	viz	NN
22283	1156	19	.	.	.
22283	1157	1	as	as	IN
22283	1157	2	the	the	DT
22283	1157	3	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1157	4	or	or	CC
22283	1157	5	unanalyzable	unanalyzable	JJ
22283	1157	6	_	_	NNP
22283	1157	7	datum	datum	NN
22283	1157	8	_	_	NNP
22283	1157	9	of	of	IN
22283	1157	10	experience	experience	NN
22283	1157	11	,	,	,
22283	1157	12	upon	upon	IN
22283	1157	13	which	which	WDT
22283	1157	14	all	all	DT
22283	1157	15	her	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1157	16	investigations	investigation	NNS
22283	1157	17	are	be	VBP
22283	1157	18	founded	found	VBN
22283	1157	19	,	,	,
22283	1157	20	and	and	CC
22283	1157	21	by	by	IN
22283	1157	22	which	which	WDT
22283	1157	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1157	24	are	be	VBP
22283	1157	25	all	all	RB
22283	1157	26	limited	limited	JJ
22283	1157	27	--	--	:
22283	1157	28	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	1157	29	finds	find	VBZ
22283	1157	30	any	any	DT
22283	1157	31	reason	reason	NN
22283	1157	32	to	to	TO
22283	1157	33	surmise	surmise	VB
22283	1157	34	that	that	IN
22283	1157	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1157	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	1157	37	resolvable	resolvable	JJ
22283	1157	38	into	into	IN
22283	1157	39	the	the	DT
22283	1157	40	principle	principle	NN
22283	1157	41	of	of	IN
22283	1157	42	mind	mind	NN
22283	1157	43	,	,	,
22283	1157	44	philosophy	philosophy	NN
22283	1157	45	is	be	VBZ
22283	1157	46	thus	thus	RB
22283	1157	47	able	able	JJ
22283	1157	48	to	to	TO
22283	1157	49	suggest	suggest	VB
22283	1157	50	that	that	IN
22283	1157	51	any	any	DT
22283	1157	52	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1157	53	between	between	IN
22283	1157	54	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1157	55	processes	process	NNS
22283	1157	56	as	as	IN
22283	1157	57	determinate	determinate	NN
22283	1157	58	or	or	CC
22283	1157	59	free	free	JJ
22283	1157	60	,	,	,
22283	1157	61	is	be	VBZ
22283	1157	62	really	really	RB
22283	1157	63	a	a	DT
22283	1157	64	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
22283	1157	65	distinction	distinction	NN
22283	1157	66	.	.	.
22283	1158	1	For	for	IN
22283	1158	2	,	,	,
22283	1158	3	according	accord	VBG
22283	1158	4	to	to	IN
22283	1158	5	this	this	DT
22283	1158	6	suggestion	suggestion	NN
22283	1158	7	,	,	,
22283	1158	8	the	the	DT
22283	1158	9	issue	issue	NN
22283	1158	10	is	be	VBZ
22283	1158	11	no	no	RB
22283	1158	12	longer	long	RBR
22283	1158	13	as	as	IN
22283	1158	14	to	to	IN
22283	1158	15	whether	whether	IN
22283	1158	16	these	these	DT
22283	1158	17	processes	process	NNS
22283	1158	18	are	be	VBP
22283	1158	19	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1158	20	or	or	CC
22283	1158	21	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1158	22	;	;	:
22283	1158	23	the	the	DT
22283	1158	24	very	very	JJ
22283	1158	25	idea	idea	NN
22283	1158	26	of	of	IN
22283	1158	27	cause	cause	NN
22283	1158	28	has	have	VBZ
22283	1158	29	been	be	VBN
22283	1158	30	abolished	abolish	VBN
22283	1158	31	as	as	IN
22283	1158	32	one	one	CD
22283	1158	33	which	which	WDT
22283	1158	34	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	1158	35	only	only	RB
22283	1158	36	to	to	IN
22283	1158	37	that	that	DT
22283	1158	38	lower	low	JJR
22283	1158	39	level	level	NN
22283	1158	40	of	of	IN
22283	1158	41	inquiry	inquiry	NN
22283	1158	42	with	with	IN
22283	1158	43	which	which	WDT
22283	1158	44	science	science	NN
22283	1158	45	,	,	,
22283	1158	46	or	or	CC
22283	1158	47	sensuous	sensuous	JJ
22283	1158	48	experience	experience	NN
22283	1158	49	,	,	,
22283	1158	50	is	be	VBZ
22283	1158	51	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	1158	52	.	.	.
22283	1159	1	Here	here	RB
22283	1159	2	,	,	,
22283	1159	3	no	no	RB
22283	1159	4	doubt	doubt	RB
22283	1159	5	,	,	,
22283	1159	6	the	the	DT
22283	1159	7	question	question	NN
22283	1159	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1159	9	a	a	DT
22283	1159	10	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
22283	1159	11	real	real	JJ
22283	1159	12	one	one	CD
22283	1159	13	,	,	,
22283	1159	14	and	and	CC
22283	1159	15	,	,	,
22283	1159	16	as	as	IN
22283	1159	17	shown	show	VBN
22283	1159	18	in	in	IN
22283	1159	19	previous	previous	JJ
22283	1159	20	chapters	chapter	NNS
22283	1159	21	,	,	,
22283	1159	22	can	can	MD
22283	1159	23	only	only	RB
22283	1159	24	be	be	VB
22283	1159	25	answered	answer	VBN
22283	1159	26	in	in	IN
22283	1159	27	the	the	DT
22283	1159	28	way	way	NN
22283	1159	29	of	of	IN
22283	1159	30	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	1159	31	.	.	.
22283	1160	1	But	but	CC
22283	1160	2	so	so	RB
22283	1160	3	soon	soon	RB
22283	1160	4	as	as	IN
22283	1160	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1160	6	ascend	ascend	VBP
22283	1160	7	to	to	IN
22283	1160	8	the	the	DT
22283	1160	9	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	1160	10	theory	theory	NN
22283	1160	11	of	of	IN
22283	1160	12	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1160	13	,	,	,
22283	1160	14	and	and	CC
22283	1160	15	so	so	RB
22283	1160	16	transcend	transcend	VB
22283	1160	17	the	the	DT
22283	1160	18	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1160	19	of	of	IN
22283	1160	20	sensuous	sensuous	JJ
22283	1160	21	experience	experience	NN
22283	1160	22	,	,	,
22283	1160	23	the	the	DT
22283	1160	24	question	question	NN
22283	1160	25	whether	whether	IN
22283	1160	26	volitions	volition	NNS
22283	1160	27	are	be	VBP
22283	1160	28	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1160	29	or	or	CC
22283	1160	30	uncaused	uncaused	JJ
22283	1160	31	becomes	become	NNS
22283	1160	32	,	,	,
22283	1160	33	as	as	IN
22283	1160	34	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1160	35	have	have	VBP
22283	1160	36	said	say	VBD
22283	1160	37	,	,	,
22283	1160	38	a	a	DT
22283	1160	39	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
22283	1160	40	question	question	NN
22283	1160	41	,	,	,
22283	1160	42	or	or	CC
22283	1160	43	a	a	DT
22283	1160	44	question	question	NN
22283	1160	45	the	the	DT
22283	1160	46	terms	term	NNS
22283	1160	47	of	of	IN
22283	1160	48	which	which	WDT
22283	1160	49	are	be	VBP
22283	1160	50	not	not	RB
22283	1160	51	correctly	correctly	RB
22283	1160	52	stated	state	VBN
22283	1160	53	.	.	.
22283	1161	1	If	if	IN
22283	1161	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1161	3	be	be	VBP
22283	1161	4	the	the	DT
22283	1161	5	case	case	NN
22283	1161	6	that	that	WDT
22283	1161	7	all	all	DT
22283	1161	8	causality	causality	NN
22283	1161	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1161	10	of	of	IN
22283	1161	11	a	a	DT
22283	1161	12	nature	nature	NN
22283	1161	13	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1161	14	,	,	,
22283	1161	15	volition	volition	NN
22283	1161	16	and	and	CC
22283	1161	17	causation	causation	NN
22283	1161	18	are	be	VBP
22283	1161	19	one	one	CD
22283	1161	20	and	and	CC
22283	1161	21	the	the	DT
22283	1161	22	same	same	JJ
22283	1161	23	thing	thing	NN
22283	1161	24	,	,	,
22283	1161	25	differing	differ	VBG
22283	1161	26	only	only	RB
22283	1161	27	in	in	IN
22283	1161	28	relation	relation	NN
22283	1161	29	to	to	IN
22283	1161	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1161	31	modes	mode	NNS
22283	1161	32	of	of	IN
22283	1161	33	apprehension	apprehension	NN
22283	1161	34	.	.	.
22283	1162	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1162	2	would	would	MD
22283	1162	3	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1162	4	be	be	VB
22283	1162	5	equally	equally	RB
22283	1162	6	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
22283	1162	7	to	to	TO
22283	1162	8	say	say	VB
22283	1162	9	that	that	IN
22283	1162	10	either	either	DT
22283	1162	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	1162	12	the	the	DT
22283	1162	13	cause	cause	NN
22283	1162	14	of	of	IN
22283	1162	15	the	the	DT
22283	1162	16	other	other	JJ
22283	1162	17	--	--	:
22283	1162	18	just	just	RB
22283	1162	19	as	as	IN
22283	1162	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1162	21	would	would	MD
22283	1162	22	be	be	VB
22283	1162	23	equally	equally	RB
22283	1162	24	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
22283	1162	25	to	to	TO
22283	1162	26	say	say	VB
22283	1162	27	that	that	IN
22283	1162	28	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	1162	29	is	be	VBZ
22283	1162	30	the	the	DT
22283	1162	31	cause	cause	NN
22283	1162	32	of	of	IN
22283	1162	33	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	1162	34	,	,	,
22283	1162	35	or	or	CC
22283	1162	36	that	that	DT
22283	1162	37	psychosis	psychosis	NN
22283	1162	38	is	be	VBZ
22283	1162	39	the	the	DT
22283	1162	40	cause	cause	NN
22283	1162	41	of	of	IN
22283	1162	42	neurosis	neurosis	NN
22283	1162	43	.	.	.
22283	1163	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1163	2	thus	thus	RB
22283	1163	3	,	,	,
22283	1163	4	if	if	IN
22283	1163	5	volition	volition	NN
22283	1163	6	and	and	CC
22283	1163	7	causation	causation	NN
22283	1163	8	are	be	VBP
22283	1163	9	one	one	CD
22283	1163	10	and	and	CC
22283	1163	11	the	the	DT
22283	1163	12	same	same	JJ
22283	1163	13	thing	thing	NN
22283	1163	14	,	,	,
22283	1163	15	the	the	DT
22283	1163	16	only	only	JJ
22283	1163	17	reason	reason	NN
22283	1163	18	why	why	WRB
22283	1163	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1163	20	ever	ever	RB
22283	1163	21	appear	appear	VBP
22283	1163	22	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	1163	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	1163	24	because	because	IN
22283	1163	25	the	the	DT
22283	1163	26	one	one	NN
22283	1163	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	1163	28	known	know	VBN
22283	1163	29	ontologically	ontologically	RB
22283	1163	30	,	,	,
22283	1163	31	while	while	IN
22283	1163	32	the	the	DT
22283	1163	33	other	other	JJ
22283	1163	34	is	be	VBZ
22283	1163	35	known	know	VBN
22283	1163	36	phenomenally	phenomenally	RB
22283	1163	37	.	.	.
22283	1164	1	Were	be	VBD
22283	1164	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1164	3	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1164	4	that	that	IN
22283	1164	5	the	the	DT
22283	1164	6	orbit	orbit	NN
22283	1164	7	of	of	IN
22283	1164	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1164	9	own	own	JJ
22283	1164	10	personality	personality	NN
22283	1164	11	could	could	MD
22283	1164	12	be	be	VB
22283	1164	13	widened	widen	VBN
22283	1164	14	so	so	IN
22283	1164	15	as	as	IN
22283	1164	16	to	to	TO
22283	1164	17	include	include	VB
22283	1164	18	within	within	IN
22283	1164	19	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1164	20	own	own	JJ
22283	1164	21	subjectivity	subjectivity	NN
22283	1164	22	the	the	DT
22283	1164	23	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1164	24	universe	universe	NN
22283	1164	25	of	of	IN
22283	1164	26	causality	causality	NN
22283	1164	27	,	,	,
22283	1164	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1164	29	should	should	MD
22283	1164	30	find	find	VB
22283	1164	31	--	--	:
22283	1164	32	according	accord	VBG
22283	1164	33	to	to	IN
22283	1164	34	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1164	35	--	--	:
22283	1164	36	that	that	IN
22283	1164	37	all	all	DT
22283	1164	38	causation	causation	NN
22283	1164	39	would	would	MD
22283	1164	40	become	become	VB
22283	1164	41	transformed	transform	VBN
22283	1164	42	into	into	IN
22283	1164	43	volition	volition	NN
22283	1164	44	.	.	.
22283	1165	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	1165	2	,	,	,
22283	1165	3	the	the	DT
22283	1165	4	only	only	JJ
22283	1165	5	reason	reason	NN
22283	1165	6	why	why	WRB
22283	1165	7	there	there	RB
22283	1165	8	now	now	RB
22283	1165	9	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1165	10	to	to	TO
22283	1165	11	be	be	VB
22283	1165	12	so	so	RB
22283	1165	13	great	great	JJ
22283	1165	14	an	an	DT
22283	1165	15	antithesis	antithesis	NN
22283	1165	16	between	between	IN
22283	1165	17	these	these	DT
22283	1165	18	two	two	CD
22283	1165	19	principles	principle	NNS
22283	1165	20	,	,	,
22283	1165	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	1165	22	because	because	IN
22283	1165	23	the	the	DT
22283	1165	24	volition	volition	NN
22283	1165	25	which	which	WDT
22283	1165	26	is	be	VBZ
22283	1165	27	going	go	VBG
22283	1165	28	on	on	RP
22283	1165	29	outside	outside	RB
22283	1165	30	of	of	IN
22283	1165	31	my	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1165	32	own	own	JJ
22283	1165	33	consciousness	consciousness	NN
22283	1165	34	can	can	MD
22283	1165	35	only	only	RB
22283	1165	36	be	be	VB
22283	1165	37	known	know	VBN
22283	1165	38	to	to	IN
22283	1165	39	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1165	40	objectively,--or	objectively,--or	NNP
22283	1165	41	at	at	IN
22283	1165	42	most	most	JJS
22283	1165	43	ejectively,--on	ejectively,--on	NN
22283	1165	44	which	which	WDT
22283	1165	45	account	account	VBP
22283	1165	46	the	the	DT
22283	1165	47	principle	principle	NN
22283	1165	48	of	of	IN
22283	1165	49	causality	causality	NN
22283	1165	50	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1165	51	to	to	IN
22283	1165	52	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1165	53	phenomenally	phenomenally	RB
22283	1165	54	as	as	IN
22283	1165	55	the	the	DT
22283	1165	56	most	most	RBS
22283	1165	57	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1165	58	,	,	,
22283	1165	59	or	or	CC
22283	1165	60	most	most	RBS
22283	1165	61	unanalyzable	unanalyzable	JJ
22283	1165	62	,	,	,
22283	1165	63	principle	principle	NN
22283	1165	64	in	in	IN
22283	1165	65	the	the	DT
22283	1165	66	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	1165	67	universe	universe	NN
22283	1165	68	.	.	.
22283	1166	1	Upon	upon	IN
22283	1166	2	the	the	DT
22283	1166	3	whole	whole	NN
22283	1166	4	,	,	,
22283	1166	5	then	then	RB
22283	1166	6	,	,	,
22283	1166	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1166	8	conclude	conclude	VBP
22283	1166	9	that	that	IN
22283	1166	10	this	this	DT
22283	1166	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	1166	12	the	the	DT
22283	1166	13	teaching	teaching	NN
22283	1166	14	of	of	IN
22283	1166	15	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1166	16	.	.	.
22283	1167	1	If	if	IN
22283	1167	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1167	3	view	view	VBP
22283	1167	4	the	the	DT
22283	1167	5	facts	fact	NNS
22283	1167	6	of	of	IN
22283	1167	7	human	human	JJ
22283	1167	8	volition	volition	NN
22283	1167	9	relatively	relatively	RB
22283	1167	10	,	,	,
22283	1167	11	or	or	CC
22283	1167	12	within	within	IN
22283	1167	13	the	the	DT
22283	1167	14	four	four	CD
22283	1167	15	corners	corner	NNS
22283	1167	16	of	of	IN
22283	1167	17	psychological	psychological	JJ
22283	1167	18	science	science	NN
22283	1167	19	,	,	,
22283	1167	20	there	there	EX
22283	1167	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	1167	22	no	no	DT
22283	1167	23	escape	escape	NN
22283	1167	24	from	from	IN
22283	1167	25	the	the	DT
22283	1167	26	conclusion	conclusion	NN
22283	1167	27	that	that	IN
22283	1167	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1167	29	are	be	VBP
22283	1167	30	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1167	31	with	with	IN
22283	1167	32	all	all	PDT
22283	1167	33	the	the	DT
22283	1167	34	rigour	rigour	NN
22283	1167	35	which	which	WDT
22283	1167	36	belongs	belong	VBZ
22283	1167	37	to	to	IN
22283	1167	38	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1167	39	causation	causation	NN
22283	1167	40	in	in	IN
22283	1167	41	general	general	JJ
22283	1167	42	.	.	.
22283	1168	1	For	for	IN
22283	1168	2	every	every	DT
22283	1168	3	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	1168	4	of	of	IN
22283	1168	5	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1168	6	changes	change	NNS
22283	1168	7	and	and	CC
22283	1168	8	every	every	DT
22283	1168	9	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	1168	10	of	of	IN
22283	1168	11	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	1168	12	changes	change	NNS
22283	1168	13	,	,	,
22283	1168	14	although	although	IN
22283	1168	15	phenomenally	phenomenally	RB
22283	1168	16	so	so	RB
22283	1168	17	diverse	diverse	JJ
22283	1168	18	,	,	,
22283	1168	19	are	be	VBP
22283	1168	20	taken	take	VBN
22283	1168	21	by	by	IN
22283	1168	22	this	this	DT
22283	1168	23	theory	theory	NN
22283	1168	24	to	to	TO
22283	1168	25	be	be	VB
22283	1168	26	ontologically	ontologically	RB
22283	1168	27	identical	identical	JJ
22283	1168	28	;	;	:
22283	1168	29	and	and	CC
22283	1168	30	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1168	31	the	the	DT
22283	1168	32	sequence	sequence	NN
22283	1168	33	of	of	IN
22283	1168	34	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1168	35	changes	change	NNS
22283	1168	36	must	must	MD
22283	1168	37	be	be	VB
22283	1168	38	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1168	39	with	with	IN
22283	1168	40	the	the	DT
22283	1168	41	same	same	JJ
22283	1168	42	degree	degree	NN
22283	1168	43	of	of	IN
22283	1168	44	'	'	``
22283	1168	45	necessity	necessity	NN
22283	1168	46	'	'	''
22283	1168	47	as	as	IN
22283	1168	48	is	be	VBZ
22283	1168	49	that	that	DT
22283	1168	50	of	of	IN
22283	1168	51	the	the	DT
22283	1168	52	cerebral	cerebral	JJ
22283	1168	53	changes	change	NNS
22283	1168	54	.	.	.
22283	1169	1	In	in	IN
22283	1169	2	short	short	JJ
22283	1169	3	,	,	,
22283	1169	4	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1169	5	causation	causation	NN
22283	1169	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1169	7	taken	take	VBN
22283	1169	8	to	to	TO
22283	1169	9	be	be	VB
22283	1169	10	but	but	CC
22283	1169	11	the	the	DT
22283	1169	12	obverse	obverse	JJ
22283	1169	13	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	1169	14	of	of	IN
22283	1169	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1169	16	causation	causation	NN
22283	1169	17	,	,	,
22283	1169	18	and	and	CC
22283	1169	19	,	,	,
22283	1169	20	as	as	IN
22283	1169	21	previously	previously	RB
22283	1169	22	remarked	remark	VBN
22283	1169	23	,	,	,
22283	1169	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1169	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	1169	26	impossible	impossible	JJ
22283	1169	27	that	that	IN
22283	1169	28	the	the	DT
22283	1169	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
22283	1169	30	of	of	IN
22283	1169	31	determinism	determinism	NN
22283	1169	32	could	could	MD
22283	1169	33	be	be	VB
22283	1169	34	taught	teach	VBN
22283	1169	35	in	in	IN
22283	1169	36	a	a	DT
22283	1169	37	manner	manner	NN
22283	1169	38	more	more	RBR
22283	1169	39	emphatic	emphatic	JJ
22283	1169	40	.	.	.
22283	1170	1	But	but	CC
22283	1170	2	,	,	,
22283	1170	3	on	on	IN
22283	1170	4	the	the	DT
22283	1170	5	other	other	JJ
22283	1170	6	hand	hand	NN
22283	1170	7	,	,	,
22283	1170	8	the	the	DT
22283	1170	9	theory	theory	NN
22283	1170	10	of	of	IN
22283	1170	11	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1170	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1170	13	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1170	14	to	to	TO
22283	1170	15	go	go	VB
22283	1170	16	further	far	RBR
22283	1170	17	than	than	IN
22283	1170	18	this	this	DT
22283	1170	19	.	.	.
22283	1171	1	From	from	IN
22283	1171	2	the	the	DT
22283	1171	3	very	very	JJ
22283	1171	4	fact	fact	NN
22283	1171	5	of	of	IN
22283	1171	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1171	7	having	have	VBG
22283	1171	8	gone	go	VBN
22283	1171	9	so	so	RB
22283	1171	10	far	far	RB
22283	1171	11	as	as	IN
22283	1171	12	to	to	TO
22283	1171	13	identify	identify	VB
22283	1171	14	all	all	DT
22283	1171	15	physical	physical	JJ
22283	1171	16	processes	process	NNS
22283	1171	17	with	with	IN
22283	1171	18	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1171	19	processes	process	NNS
22283	1171	20	,	,	,
22283	1171	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1171	22	can	can	MD
22283	1171	23	not	not	RB
22283	1171	24	refuse	refuse	VB
22283	1171	25	to	to	TO
22283	1171	26	take	take	VB
22283	1171	27	the	the	DT
22283	1171	28	further	further	JJ
22283	1171	29	and	and	CC
22283	1171	30	final	final	JJ
22283	1171	31	step	step	NN
22283	1171	32	of	of	IN
22283	1171	33	identifying	identify	VBG
22283	1171	34	the	the	DT
22283	1171	35	most	most	RBS
22283	1171	36	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1171	37	known	known	JJ
22283	1171	38	principle	principle	NN
22283	1171	39	of	of	IN
22283	1171	40	the	the	DT
22283	1171	41	one	one	NN
22283	1171	42	with	with	IN
22283	1171	43	the	the	DT
22283	1171	44	most	most	RBS
22283	1171	45	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1171	46	known	known	JJ
22283	1171	47	principle	principle	NN
22283	1171	48	of	of	IN
22283	1171	49	the	the	DT
22283	1171	50	other	other	JJ
22283	1171	51	;	;	:
22283	1171	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1171	53	is	be	VBZ
22283	1171	54	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1171	55	to	to	TO
22283	1171	56	recognize	recognize	VB
22283	1171	57	in	in	IN
22283	1171	58	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1171	59	causation	causation	NN
22283	1171	60	the	the	DT
22283	1171	61	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	1171	62	aspect	aspect	NN
22283	1171	63	of	of	IN
22283	1171	64	that	that	DT
22283	1171	65	which	which	WDT
22283	1171	66	is	be	VBZ
22283	1171	67	known	know	VBN
22283	1171	68	ontologically	ontologically	RB
22283	1171	69	as	as	IN
22283	1171	70	volition	volition	NN
22283	1171	71	.	.	.
22283	1172	1	But	but	CC
22283	1172	2	if	if	IN
22283	1172	3	these	these	DT
22283	1172	4	two	two	CD
22283	1172	5	principles	principle	NNS
22283	1172	6	are	be	VBP
22283	1172	7	thus	thus	RB
22283	1172	8	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1172	9	as	as	IN
22283	1172	10	identical	identical	JJ
22283	1172	11	,	,	,
22283	1172	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1172	13	clearly	clearly	RB
22283	1172	14	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	1172	15	as	as	IN
22283	1172	16	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
22283	1172	17	to	to	TO
22283	1172	18	ask	ask	VB
22283	1172	19	whether	whether	IN
22283	1172	20	the	the	DT
22283	1172	21	one	one	NN
22283	1172	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1172	23	the	the	DT
22283	1172	24	cause	cause	NN
22283	1172	25	of	of	IN
22283	1172	26	the	the	DT
22283	1172	27	other	other	JJ
22283	1172	28	,	,	,
22283	1172	29	as	as	IN
22283	1172	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1172	31	would	would	MD
22283	1172	32	be	be	VB
22283	1172	33	to	to	TO
22283	1172	34	ask	ask	VB
22283	1172	35	whether	whether	IN
22283	1172	36	the	the	DT
22283	1172	37	one	one	NN
22283	1172	38	wills	will	VBZ
22283	1172	39	the	the	DT
22283	1172	40	other	other	JJ
22283	1172	41	.	.	.
22283	1173	1	For	for	IN
22283	1173	2	,	,	,
22283	1173	3	_	_	NNP
22283	1173	4	ex	ex	NNP
22283	1173	5	hypothesi	hypothesi	NNP
22283	1173	6	_	_	NNP
22283	1173	7	,	,	,
22283	1173	8	the	the	DT
22283	1173	9	two	two	CD
22283	1173	10	things	thing	NNS
22283	1173	11	being	be	VBG
22283	1173	12	one	one	CD
22283	1173	13	thing	thing	NN
22283	1173	14	,	,	,
22283	1173	15	or	or	CC
22283	1173	16	but	but	CC
22283	1173	17	different	different	JJ
22283	1173	18	modes	mode	NNS
22283	1173	19	of	of	IN
22283	1173	20	viewing	view	VBG
22283	1173	21	the	the	DT
22283	1173	22	same	same	JJ
22283	1173	23	thing	thing	NN
22283	1173	24	,	,	,
22283	1173	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1173	26	becomes	become	VBZ
22283	1173	27	mere	mere	JJ
22283	1173	28	nonsense	nonsense	NN
22283	1173	29	to	to	TO
22283	1173	30	speak	speak	VB
22283	1173	31	of	of	IN
22283	1173	32	either	either	CC
22283	1173	33	determining	determine	VBG
22283	1173	34	the	the	DT
22283	1173	35	other	other	JJ
22283	1173	36	;	;	:
22283	1173	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1173	38	are	be	VBP
22283	1173	39	both	both	DT
22283	1173	40	but	but	CC
22283	1173	41	different	different	JJ
22283	1173	42	expressions	expression	NNS
22283	1173	43	of	of	IN
22283	1173	44	the	the	DT
22283	1173	45	same	same	JJ
22283	1173	46	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1173	47	fact	fact	NN
22283	1173	48	,	,	,
22283	1173	49	namely	namely	RB
22283	1173	50	the	the	DT
22283	1173	51	fact	fact	NN
22283	1173	52	of	of	IN
22283	1173	53	Being	be	VBG
22283	1173	54	as	as	IN
22283	1173	55	Being	be	VBG
22283	1173	56	.	.	.
22283	1174	1	If	if	IN
22283	1174	2	this	this	DT
22283	1174	3	result	result	NN
22283	1174	4	should	should	MD
22283	1174	5	be	be	VB
22283	1174	6	deemed	deem	VBN
22283	1174	7	unsatisfactory	unsatisfactory	JJ
22283	1174	8	on	on	IN
22283	1174	9	account	account	NN
22283	1174	10	of	of	IN
22283	1174	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1174	12	vagueness	vagueness	NN
22283	1174	13	,	,	,
22283	1174	14	let	let	VB
22283	1174	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1174	16	be	be	VB
22283	1174	17	remembered	remember	VBN
22283	1174	18	that	that	IN
22283	1174	19	nothing	nothing	NN
22283	1174	20	is	be	VBZ
22283	1174	21	gained	gain	VBN
22283	1174	22	on	on	IN
22283	1174	23	the	the	DT
22283	1174	24	side	side	NN
22283	1174	25	of	of	IN
22283	1174	26	clearness	clearness	NN
22283	1174	27	by	by	IN
22283	1174	28	the	the	DT
22283	1174	29	converse	converse	NN
22283	1174	30	supposition	supposition	NN
22283	1174	31	--	--	:
22283	1174	32	viz	viz	NN
22283	1174	33	.	.	.
22283	1175	1	that	that	DT
22283	1175	2	priority	priority	NN
22283	1175	3	should	should	MD
22283	1175	4	be	be	VB
22283	1175	5	assigned	assign	VBN
22283	1175	6	to	to	IN
22283	1175	7	the	the	DT
22283	1175	8	principle	principle	NN
22283	1175	9	of	of	IN
22283	1175	10	causality	causality	NN
22283	1175	11	.	.	.
22283	1176	1	For	for	IN
22283	1176	2	,	,	,
22283	1176	3	if	if	IN
22283	1176	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1176	5	say	say	VBP
22283	1176	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1176	7	is	be	VBZ
22283	1176	8	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
22283	1176	9	that	that	IN
22283	1176	10	anything	anything	NN
22283	1176	11	should	should	MD
22283	1176	12	come	come	VB
22283	1176	13	into	into	IN
22283	1176	14	existence	existence	NN
22283	1176	15	without	without	IN
22283	1176	16	a	a	DT
22283	1176	17	cause	cause	NN
22283	1176	18	--	--	:
22283	1176	19	not	not	RB
22283	1176	20	even	even	RB
22283	1176	21	excepting	except	VBG
22283	1176	22	the	the	DT
22283	1176	23	principle	principle	NN
22283	1176	24	of	of	IN
22283	1176	25	mind	mind	NN
22283	1176	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1176	27	--	--	:
22283	1176	28	then	then	RB
22283	1176	29	the	the	DT
22283	1176	30	question	question	NN
22283	1176	31	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	1176	32	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1176	33	--	--	:
22283	1176	34	If	if	IN
22283	1176	35	all	all	DT
22283	1176	36	volition	volition	NN
22283	1176	37	is	be	VBZ
22283	1176	38	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1176	39	,	,	,
22283	1176	40	what	what	WP
22283	1176	41	is	be	VBZ
22283	1176	42	the	the	DT
22283	1176	43	cause	cause	NN
22283	1176	44	of	of	IN
22283	1176	45	volition	volition	NN
22283	1176	46	?	?	.
22283	1177	1	What	what	WP
22283	1177	2	caused	cause	VBD
22283	1177	3	this	this	DT
22283	1177	4	cause	cause	NN
22283	1177	5	?	?	.
22283	1178	1	And	and	CC
22283	1178	2	so	so	RB
22283	1178	3	on	on	RB
22283	1178	4	till	till	IN
22283	1178	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1178	6	arrive	arrive	VBP
22283	1178	7	at	at	IN
22283	1178	8	the	the	DT
22283	1178	9	question	question	NN
22283	1178	10	,	,	,
22283	1178	11	What	what	WP
22283	1178	12	caused	cause	VBD
22283	1178	13	the	the	DT
22283	1178	14	principle	principle	NN
22283	1178	15	of	of	IN
22283	1178	16	causality	causality	NN
22283	1178	17	?	?	.
22283	1179	1	which	which	WDT
22283	1179	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1179	3	absurd	absurd	JJ
22283	1179	4	.	.	.
22283	1180	1	So	so	IN
22283	1180	2	that	that	IN
22283	1180	3	whether	whether	IN
22283	1180	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1180	5	regard	regard	VBP
22283	1180	6	mind	mind	NN
22283	1180	7	as	as	IN
22283	1180	8	prior	prior	RB
22283	1180	9	to	to	TO
22283	1180	10	cause	cause	VB
22283	1180	11	,	,	,
22283	1180	12	or	or	CC
22283	1180	13	cause	cause	VB
22283	1180	14	as	as	IN
22283	1180	15	prior	prior	RB
22283	1180	16	to	to	IN
22283	1180	17	mind	mind	NN
22283	1180	18	,	,	,
22283	1180	19	or	or	CC
22283	1180	20	neither	neither	CC
22283	1180	21	as	as	RB
22283	1180	22	prior	prior	RB
22283	1180	23	to	to	IN
22283	1180	24	the	the	DT
22283	1180	25	other	other	JJ
22283	1180	26	,	,	,
22283	1180	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1180	28	arrive	arrive	VBP
22283	1180	29	at	at	IN
22283	1180	30	precisely	precisely	RB
22283	1180	31	the	the	DT
22283	1180	32	same	same	JJ
22283	1180	33	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	1180	34	.	.	.
22283	1181	1	And	and	CC
22283	1181	2	the	the	DT
22283	1181	3	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	1181	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1181	5	a	a	DT
22283	1181	6	hopeless	hopeless	JJ
22283	1181	7	one	one	NN
22283	1181	8	,	,	,
22283	1181	9	because	because	IN
22283	1181	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1181	11	concerns	concern	VBZ
22283	1181	12	the	the	DT
22283	1181	13	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1181	14	question	question	NN
22283	1181	15	of	of	IN
22283	1181	16	Being	be	VBG
22283	1181	17	as	as	IN
22283	1181	18	Being	be	VBG
22283	1181	19	,	,	,
22283	1181	20	or	or	CC
22283	1181	21	the	the	DT
22283	1181	22	final	final	JJ
22283	1181	23	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1181	24	of	of	IN
22283	1181	25	things	thing	NNS
22283	1181	26	.	.	.
22283	1182	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1182	2	,	,	,
22283	1182	3	to	to	TO
22283	1182	4	state	state	VB
22283	1182	5	the	the	DT
22283	1182	6	matter	matter	NN
22283	1182	7	in	in	IN
22283	1182	8	another	another	DT
22283	1182	9	way	way	NN
22283	1182	10	.	.	.
22283	1183	1	An	an	DT
22283	1183	2	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	1183	3	means	mean	VBZ
22283	1183	4	the	the	DT
22283	1183	5	reference	reference	NN
22283	1183	6	of	of	IN
22283	1183	7	observed	observed	JJ
22283	1183	8	effects	effect	NNS
22283	1183	9	to	to	IN
22283	1183	10	known	know	VBN
22283	1183	11	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1183	12	,	,	,
22283	1183	13	or	or	CC
22283	1183	14	the	the	DT
22283	1183	15	inclusion	inclusion	NN
22283	1183	16	of	of	IN
22283	1183	17	previously	previously	RB
22283	1183	18	unknown	unknown	JJ
22283	1183	19	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1183	20	among	among	IN
22283	1183	21	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1183	22	better	well	RBR
22283	1183	23	known	know	VBN
22283	1183	24	.	.	.
22283	1184	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	1184	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1184	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	1184	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
22283	1184	5	,	,	,
22283	1184	6	from	from	IN
22283	1184	7	the	the	DT
22283	1184	8	very	very	JJ
22283	1184	9	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	1184	10	of	of	IN
22283	1184	11	what	what	WP
22283	1184	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1184	13	call	call	VBP
22283	1184	14	an	an	DT
22283	1184	15	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	1184	16	,	,	,
22283	1184	17	that	that	IN
22283	1184	18	at	at	IN
22283	1184	19	the	the	DT
22283	1184	20	base	base	NN
22283	1184	21	of	of	IN
22283	1184	22	all	all	DT
22283	1184	23	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1184	24	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	1184	25	there	there	EX
22283	1184	26	must	must	MD
22283	1184	27	lie	lie	VB
22283	1184	28	a	a	DT
22283	1184	29	great	great	JJ
22283	1184	30	Inexplicable	inexplicable	JJ
22283	1184	31	,	,	,
22283	1184	32	which	which	WDT
22283	1184	33	,	,	,
22283	1184	34	just	just	RB
22283	1184	35	because	because	IN
22283	1184	36	more	more	RBR
22283	1184	37	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1184	38	than	than	IN
22283	1184	39	any	any	DT
22283	1184	40	of	of	IN
22283	1184	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1184	42	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1184	43	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	1184	44	,	,	,
22283	1184	45	does	do	VBZ
22283	1184	46	not	not	RB
22283	1184	47	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1184	48	require	require	VB
22283	1184	49	to	to	TO
22283	1184	50	be	be	VB
22283	1184	51	explained	explain	VBN
22283	1184	52	.	.	.
22283	1185	1	To	to	TO
22283	1185	2	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	1185	3	that	that	IN
22283	1185	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1185	5	does	do	VBZ
22283	1185	6	require	require	VB
22283	1185	7	to	to	TO
22283	1185	8	be	be	VB
22283	1185	9	explained	explain	VBN
22283	1185	10	,	,	,
22283	1185	11	would	would	MD
22283	1185	12	be	be	VB
22283	1185	13	to	to	TO
22283	1185	14	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	1185	15	,	,	,
22283	1185	16	that	that	IN
22283	1185	17	there	there	EX
22283	1185	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	1185	19	something	something	NN
22283	1185	20	still	still	RB
22283	1185	21	more	more	RBR
22283	1185	22	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1185	23	into	into	IN
22283	1185	24	which	which	WDT
22283	1185	25	,	,	,
22283	1185	26	if	if	IN
22283	1185	27	known	know	VBN
22283	1185	28	,	,	,
22283	1185	29	this	this	DT
22283	1185	30	Inexplicable	inexplicable	JJ
22283	1185	31	could	could	MD
22283	1185	32	be	be	VB
22283	1185	33	merged	merge	VBN
22283	1185	34	.	.	.
22283	1186	1	Hence	hence	RB
22283	1186	2	,	,	,
22283	1186	3	unless	unless	IN
22283	1186	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1186	5	postulate	postulate	VBP
22283	1186	6	an	an	DT
22283	1186	7	infinite	infinite	JJ
22283	1186	8	series	series	NN
22283	1186	9	of	of	IN
22283	1186	10	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1186	11	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	1186	12	,	,	,
22283	1186	13	there	there	EX
22283	1186	14	must	must	MD
22283	1186	15	be	be	VB
22283	1186	16	a	a	DT
22283	1186	17	basal	basal	NN
22283	1186	18	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1186	19	somewhere	somewhere	RB
22283	1186	20	,	,	,
22283	1186	21	which	which	WDT
22283	1186	22	,	,	,
22283	1186	23	in	in	IN
22283	1186	24	virtue	virtue	NN
22283	1186	25	of	of	IN
22283	1186	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1186	27	constituting	constitute	VBG
22283	1186	28	the	the	DT
22283	1186	29	ground	ground	NN
22283	1186	30	of	of	IN
22283	1186	31	all	all	DT
22283	1186	32	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1186	33	explanations	explanation	NNS
22283	1186	34	,	,	,
22283	1186	35	can	can	MD
22283	1186	36	not	not	RB
22283	1186	37	be	be	VB
22283	1186	38	,	,	,
22283	1186	39	and	and	CC
22283	1186	40	does	do	VBZ
22283	1186	41	not	not	RB
22283	1186	42	require	require	VB
22283	1186	43	to	to	TO
22283	1186	44	be	be	VB
22283	1186	45	,	,	,
22283	1186	46	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1186	47	explained	explain	VBD
22283	1186	48	.	.	.
22283	1187	1	What	what	WP
22283	1187	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1187	3	this	this	DT
22283	1187	4	basal	basal	NN
22283	1187	5	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1187	6	?	?	.
22283	1188	1	Materialism	materialism	NN
22283	1188	2	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	1188	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1188	4	to	to	TO
22283	1188	5	be	be	VB
22283	1188	6	lodged	lodge	VBN
22283	1188	7	in	in	IN
22283	1188	8	Matter	Matter	NNP
22283	1188	9	to	to	IN
22283	1188	10	the	the	DT
22283	1188	11	exclusion	exclusion	NN
22283	1188	12	of	of	IN
22283	1188	13	Mind	mind	NN
22283	1188	14	,	,	,
22283	1188	15	while	while	IN
22283	1188	16	Idealism	idealism	NN
22283	1188	17	in	in	IN
22283	1188	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1188	19	extreme	extreme	JJ
22283	1188	20	forms	form	NNS
22283	1188	21	takes	take	VBZ
22283	1188	22	the	the	DT
22283	1188	23	converse	converse	NN
22283	1188	24	view	view	NN
22283	1188	25	.	.	.
22283	1189	1	Theism	theism	NN
22283	1189	2	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	1189	3	that	that	IN
22283	1189	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1189	5	is	be	VBZ
22283	1189	6	an	an	DT
22283	1189	7	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
22283	1189	8	Person	person	NN
22283	1189	9	,	,	,
22283	1189	10	who	who	WP
22283	1189	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	1189	12	held	hold	VBN
22283	1189	13	--	--	:
22283	1189	14	and	and	CC
22283	1189	15	logically	logically	RB
22283	1189	16	enough	enough	RB
22283	1189	17	--	--	:
22283	1189	18	not	not	RB
22283	1189	19	to	to	TO
22283	1189	20	be	be	VB
22283	1189	21	able	able	JJ
22283	1189	22	to	to	TO
22283	1189	23	give	give	VB
22283	1189	24	any	any	DT
22283	1189	25	explanation	explanation	NN
22283	1189	26	of	of	IN
22283	1189	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1189	28	own	own	JJ
22283	1189	29	existence	existence	NN
22283	1189	30	;	;	:
22283	1189	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1189	32	is	be	VBZ
22283	1189	33	,	,	,
22283	1189	34	as	as	IN
22283	1189	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1189	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	1189	37	said	say	VBN
22283	1189	38	,	,	,
22283	1189	39	self	self	NN
22283	1189	40	-	-	HYPH
22283	1189	41	existent	existent	NN
22283	1189	42	,	,	,
22283	1189	43	and	and	CC
22283	1189	44	,	,	,
22283	1189	45	if	if	IN
22283	1189	46	asked	ask	VBN
22283	1189	47	to	to	TO
22283	1189	48	give	give	VB
22283	1189	49	any	any	DT
22283	1189	50	account	account	NN
22283	1189	51	of	of	IN
22283	1189	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1189	53	being	being	NN
22283	1189	54	,	,	,
22283	1189	55	would	would	MD
22283	1189	56	only	only	RB
22283	1189	57	be	be	VB
22283	1189	58	able	able	JJ
22283	1189	59	to	to	TO
22283	1189	60	restate	restate	VB
22283	1189	61	the	the	DT
22283	1189	62	fact	fact	NN
22283	1189	63	of	of	IN
22283	1189	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1189	65	being	being	NN
22283	1189	66	in	in	IN
22283	1189	67	the	the	DT
22283	1189	68	words	word	NNS
22283	1189	69	,	,	,
22283	1189	70	'	'	''
22283	1189	71	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1189	72	am	be	VBP
22283	1189	73	that	that	IN
22283	1189	74	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1189	75	am	be	VBP
22283	1189	76	.	.	.
22283	1189	77	'	'	''
22283	1190	1	Lastly	lastly	RB
22283	1190	2	,	,	,
22283	1190	3	Pantheism	pantheism	NN
22283	1190	4	,	,	,
22283	1190	5	or	or	CC
22283	1190	6	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1190	7	,	,	,
22283	1190	8	supposes	suppose	VBZ
22283	1190	9	the	the	DT
22283	1190	10	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1190	11	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1190	12	to	to	TO
22283	1190	13	be	be	VB
22283	1190	14	lodged	lodge	VBN
22283	1190	15	in	in	IN
22283	1190	16	the	the	DT
22283	1190	17	universe	universe	NN
22283	1190	18	as	as	IN
22283	1190	19	a	a	DT
22283	1190	20	whole	whole	NN
22283	1190	21	.	.	.
22283	1191	1	Now	now	RB
22283	1191	2	,	,	,
22283	1191	3	in	in	IN
22283	1191	4	the	the	DT
22283	1191	5	present	present	JJ
22283	1191	6	connexion	connexion	NN
22283	1191	7	the	the	DT
22283	1191	8	question	question	NN
22283	1191	9	before	before	IN
22283	1191	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1191	11	is	be	VBZ
22283	1191	12	simply	simply	RB
22283	1191	13	this	this	DT
22283	1191	14	--	--	:
22283	1191	15	Are	be	VBP
22283	1191	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1191	17	to	to	TO
22283	1191	18	regard	regard	VB
22283	1191	19	the	the	DT
22283	1191	20	principle	principle	NN
22283	1191	21	of	of	IN
22283	1191	22	causality	causality	NN
22283	1191	23	or	or	CC
22283	1191	24	the	the	DT
22283	1191	25	principle	principle	NN
22283	1191	26	of	of	IN
22283	1191	27	mind	mind	NN
22283	1191	28	as	as	IN
22283	1191	29	the	the	DT
22283	1191	30	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1191	31	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1191	32	?	?	.
22283	1192	1	And	and	CC
22283	1192	2	to	to	IN
22283	1192	3	this	this	DT
22283	1192	4	question	question	NN
22283	1192	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1192	6	answer	answer	VBP
22283	1192	7	that	that	DT
22283	1192	8	to	to	IN
22283	1192	9	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1192	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1192	11	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1192	12	most	most	RBS
22283	1192	13	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
22283	1192	14	to	to	TO
22283	1192	15	assign	assign	VB
22283	1192	16	priority	priority	NN
22283	1192	17	to	to	IN
22283	1192	18	mind	mind	NN
22283	1192	19	.	.	.
22283	1193	1	For	for	IN
22283	1193	2	,	,	,
22283	1193	3	on	on	IN
22283	1193	4	the	the	DT
22283	1193	5	one	one	CD
22283	1193	6	hand	hand	NN
22283	1193	7	,	,	,
22283	1193	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1193	9	only	only	JJ
22283	1193	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	1193	11	of	of	IN
22283	1193	12	causation	causation	NN
22283	1193	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	1193	14	empirical	empirical	JJ
22283	1193	15	,	,	,
22283	1193	16	while	while	IN
22283	1193	17	even	even	RB
22283	1193	18	as	as	IN
22283	1193	19	such	such	JJ
22283	1193	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1193	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	1193	22	only	only	RB
22283	1193	23	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1193	24	in	in	IN
22283	1193	25	the	the	DT
22283	1193	26	same	same	JJ
22283	1193	27	way	way	NN
22283	1193	28	as	as	IN
22283	1193	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1193	30	knowledge	knowledge	NN
22283	1193	31	of	of	IN
22283	1193	32	objective	objective	JJ
22283	1193	33	existence	existence	NN
22283	1193	34	in	in	IN
22283	1193	35	general	general	JJ
22283	1193	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	1193	37	possible	possible	JJ
22283	1193	38	--	--	:
22283	1193	39	namely	namely	RB
22283	1193	40	,	,	,
22283	1193	41	by	by	IN
22283	1193	42	way	way	NN
22283	1193	43	of	of	IN
22283	1193	44	inference	inference	NN
22283	1193	45	from	from	IN
22283	1193	46	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1193	47	own	own	JJ
22283	1193	48	mental	mental	JJ
22283	1193	49	modifications	modification	NNS
22283	1193	50	,	,	,
22283	1193	51	which	which	WDT
22283	1193	52	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1193	53	must	must	MD
22283	1193	54	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1193	55	have	have	VB
22283	1193	56	priority	priority	NN
22283	1193	57	so	so	RB
22283	1193	58	far	far	RB
22283	1193	59	as	as	IN
22283	1193	60	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1193	61	are	be	VBP
22283	1193	62	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1193	63	concerned	concern	VBN
22283	1193	64	.	.	.
22283	1194	1	Next	next	RB
22283	1194	2	,	,	,
22283	1194	3	on	on	IN
22283	1194	4	the	the	DT
22283	1194	5	other	other	JJ
22283	1194	6	hand	hand	NN
22283	1194	7	,	,	,
22283	1194	8	even	even	RB
22283	1194	9	if	if	IN
22283	1194	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1194	11	were	be	VBD
22283	1194	12	to	to	TO
22283	1194	13	grant	grant	VB
22283	1194	14	that	that	IN
22283	1194	15	the	the	DT
22283	1194	16	principle	principle	NN
22283	1194	17	of	of	IN
22283	1194	18	causality	causality	NN
22283	1194	19	is	be	VBZ
22283	1194	20	the	the	DT
22283	1194	21	prius	prius	NN
22283	1194	22	,	,	,
22283	1194	23	or	or	CC
22283	1194	24	the	the	DT
22283	1194	25	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1194	26	and	and	CC
22283	1194	27	inexplicable	inexplicable	JJ
22283	1194	28	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1194	29	,	,	,
22283	1194	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1194	31	can	can	MD
22283	1194	32	not	not	RB
22283	1194	33	see	see	VB
22283	1194	34	that	that	IN
22283	1194	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1194	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	1194	37	really	really	RB
22283	1194	38	available	available	JJ
22283	1194	39	to	to	TO
22283	1194	40	explain	explain	VB
22283	1194	41	the	the	DT
22283	1194	42	fact	fact	NN
22283	1194	43	of	of	IN
22283	1194	44	personality	personality	NN
22283	1194	45	.	.	.
22283	1195	1	To	to	IN
22283	1195	2	me	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1195	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1195	4	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1195	5	that	that	IN
22283	1195	6	,	,	,
22283	1195	7	within	within	IN
22283	1195	8	the	the	DT
22283	1195	9	range	range	NN
22283	1195	10	of	of	IN
22283	1195	11	human	human	JJ
22283	1195	12	observation	observation	NN
22283	1195	13	,	,	,
22283	1195	14	this	this	DT
22283	1195	15	is	be	VBZ
22283	1195	16	the	the	DT
22283	1195	17	fact	fact	NN
22283	1195	18	that	that	IN
22283	1195	19	most	most	JJS
22283	1195	20	wears	wear	VBZ
22283	1195	21	the	the	DT
22283	1195	22	appearance	appearance	NN
22283	1195	23	of	of	IN
22283	1195	24	finality	finality	NN
22283	1195	25	,	,	,
22283	1195	26	or	or	CC
22283	1195	27	of	of	IN
22283	1195	28	that	that	DT
22283	1195	29	unanalyzable	unanalyzable	JJ
22283	1195	30	and	and	CC
22283	1195	31	inexplicable	inexplicable	JJ
22283	1195	32	nature	nature	NN
22283	1195	33	which	which	WDT
22283	1195	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1195	35	are	be	VBP
22283	1195	36	bound	bind	VBN
22283	1195	37	to	to	TO
22283	1195	38	believe	believe	VB
22283	1195	39	must	must	MD
22283	1195	40	belong	belong	VB
22283	1195	41	to	to	IN
22283	1195	42	the	the	DT
22283	1195	43	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
22283	1195	44	mystery	mystery	NN
22283	1195	45	of	of	IN
22283	1195	46	Being	be	VBG
22283	1195	47	.	.	.
22283	1196	1	But	but	CC
22283	1196	2	,	,	,
22283	1196	3	be	be	VB
22283	1196	4	this	this	DT
22283	1196	5	as	as	IN
22283	1196	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1196	7	may	may	MD
22283	1196	8	,	,	,
22283	1196	9	the	the	DT
22283	1196	10	speculative	speculative	JJ
22283	1196	11	difficulty	difficulty	NN
22283	1196	12	of	of	IN
22283	1196	13	assigning	assigning	NN
22283	1196	14	priority	priority	NN
22283	1196	15	to	to	IN
22283	1196	16	mind	mind	NN
22283	1196	17	is	be	VBZ
22283	1196	18	certainly	certainly	RB
22283	1196	19	no	no	RB
22283	1196	20	greater	great	JJR
22283	1196	21	than	than	IN
22283	1196	22	that	that	DT
22283	1196	23	of	of	IN
22283	1196	24	assigning	assign	VBG
22283	1196	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1196	26	to	to	IN
22283	1196	27	causality	causality	NN
22283	1196	28	;	;	:
22283	1196	29	and	and	CC
22283	1196	30	this	this	DT
22283	1196	31	,	,	,
22283	1196	32	as	as	IN
22283	1196	33	above	above	IN
22283	1196	34	remarked	remark	VBN
22283	1196	35	,	,	,
22283	1196	36	is	be	VBZ
22283	1196	37	a	a	DT
22283	1196	38	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
22283	1196	39	answer	answer	NN
22283	1196	40	to	to	IN
22283	1196	41	the	the	DT
22283	1196	42	question	question	NN
22283	1196	43	before	before	IN
22283	1196	44	us	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1196	45	.	.	.
22283	1197	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	1197	2	to	to	IN
22283	1197	3	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1197	4	,	,	,
22283	1197	5	however	however	RB
22283	1197	6	,	,	,
22283	1197	7	there	there	EX
22283	1197	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1197	9	no	no	DT
22283	1197	10	need	need	NN
22283	1197	11	to	to	TO
22283	1197	12	assign	assign	VB
22283	1197	13	priority	priority	NN
22283	1197	14	to	to	IN
22283	1197	15	either	either	CC
22283	1197	16	principle	principle	NN
22283	1197	17	,	,	,
22283	1197	18	seeing	see	VBG
22283	1197	19	that	that	IN
22283	1197	20	one	one	NN
22283	1197	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	1197	22	but	but	CC
22283	1197	23	a	a	DT
22283	1197	24	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
22283	1197	25	expression	expression	NN
22283	1197	26	of	of	IN
22283	1197	27	the	the	DT
22283	1197	28	other	other	JJ
22283	1197	29	.	.	.
22283	1198	1	Only	only	RB
22283	1198	2	one	one	CD
22283	1198	3	further	further	JJ
22283	1198	4	question	question	NN
22283	1198	5	remains	remain	VBZ
22283	1198	6	to	to	TO
22283	1198	7	be	be	VB
22283	1198	8	considered	consider	VBN
22283	1198	9	.	.	.
22283	1199	1	From	from	IN
22283	1199	2	what	what	WP
22283	1199	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1199	4	have	have	VBP
22283	1199	5	just	just	RB
22283	1199	6	said	say	VBN
22283	1199	7	on	on	IN
22283	1199	8	the	the	DT
22283	1199	9	subject	subject	NN
22283	1199	10	of	of	IN
22283	1199	11	Personality	Personality	NNP
22283	1199	12	,	,	,
22283	1199	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1199	14	will	will	MD
22283	1199	15	be	be	VB
22283	1199	16	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	1199	17	that	that	IN
22283	1199	18	the	the	DT
22283	1199	19	theory	theory	NN
22283	1199	20	of	of	IN
22283	1199	21	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1199	22	is	be	VBZ
22283	1199	23	in	in	IN
22283	1199	24	conflict	conflict	NN
22283	1199	25	with	with	IN
22283	1199	26	that	that	DT
22283	1199	27	of	of	IN
22283	1199	28	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	1199	29	only	only	RB
22283	1199	30	in	in	IN
22283	1199	31	so	so	RB
22283	1199	32	far	far	RB
22283	1199	33	as	as	IN
22283	1199	34	personality	personality	NN
22283	1199	35	appears	appear	VBZ
22283	1199	36	to	to	TO
22283	1199	37	imply	imply	VB
22283	1199	38	limitation	limitation	NN
22283	1199	39	.	.	.
22283	1200	1	This	this	DT
22283	1200	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1200	3	a	a	DT
22283	1200	4	point	point	NN
22283	1200	5	which	which	WDT
22283	1200	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1200	7	have	have	VBP
22283	1200	8	previously	previously	RB
22283	1200	9	considered	consider	VBN
22283	1200	10	in	in	IN
22283	1200	11	these	these	DT
22283	1200	12	pages	page	NNS
22283	1200	13	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1200	14	Chapter	Chapter	NNP
22283	1200	15	iv	iv	NNP
22283	1200	16	,	,	,
22283	1200	17	p.	p.	NN
22283	1200	18	109	109	CD
22283	1200	19	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1200	20	,	,	,
22283	1200	21	with	with	IN
22283	1200	22	the	the	DT
22283	1200	23	result	result	NN
22283	1200	24	of	of	IN
22283	1200	25	appearing	appear	VBG
22283	1200	26	to	to	TO
22283	1200	27	show	show	VB
22283	1200	28	that	that	IN
22283	1200	29	the	the	DT
22283	1200	30	conflict	conflict	NN
22283	1200	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1200	32	one	one	CD
22283	1200	33	which	which	WDT
22283	1200	34	would	would	MD
22283	1200	35	probably	probably	RB
22283	1200	36	vanish	vanish	VB
22283	1200	37	could	could	MD
22283	1200	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1200	39	rise	rise	VB
22283	1200	40	above	above	IN
22283	1200	41	the	the	DT
22283	1200	42	necessary	necessary	JJ
22283	1200	43	limitations	limitation	NNS
22283	1200	44	of	of	IN
22283	1200	45	human	human	JJ
22283	1200	46	thought	thought	NN
22283	1200	47	.	.	.
22283	1201	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1201	2	,	,	,
22283	1201	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1201	4	here	here	RB
22283	1201	5	seems	seem	VBZ
22283	1201	6	worth	worth	JJ
22283	1201	7	while	while	IN
22283	1201	8	to	to	TO
22283	1201	9	ask	ask	VB
22283	1201	10	,	,	,
22283	1201	11	What	what	WP
22283	1201	12	can	can	MD
22283	1201	13	be	be	VB
22283	1201	14	said	say	VBN
22283	1201	15	by	by	IN
22283	1201	16	the	the	DT
22283	1201	17	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
22283	1201	18	theory	theory	NN
22283	1201	19	of	of	IN
22283	1201	20	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1201	21	to	to	IN
22283	1201	22	the	the	DT
22283	1201	23	old	old	JJ
22283	1201	24	theological	theological	JJ
22283	1201	25	dilemma	dilemma	NN
22283	1201	26	touching	touch	VBG
22283	1201	27	free	free	RB
22283	1201	28	-	-	HYPH
22283	1201	29	will	will	NN
22283	1201	30	and	and	CC
22283	1201	31	predestination	predestination	NN
22283	1201	32	?	?	.
22283	1202	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1202	2	,	,	,
22283	1202	3	even	even	RB
22283	1202	4	apart	apart	RB
22283	1202	5	from	from	IN
22283	1202	6	any	any	DT
22283	1202	7	question	question	NN
22283	1202	8	of	of	IN
22283	1202	9	Theism	theism	NN
22283	1202	10	,	,	,
22283	1202	11	what	what	WDT
22283	1202	12	position	position	NN
22283	1202	13	does	do	VBZ
22283	1202	14	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1202	15	suppose	suppose	VB
22283	1202	16	the	the	DT
22283	1202	17	psychical	psychical	JJ
22283	1202	18	activity	activity	NN
22283	1202	19	of	of	IN
22283	1202	20	man	man	NN
22283	1202	21	to	to	TO
22283	1202	22	hold	hold	VB
22283	1202	23	in	in	RP
22283	1202	24	relation	relation	NN
22283	1202	25	to	to	IN
22283	1202	26	that	that	DT
22283	1202	27	of	of	IN
22283	1202	28	the	the	DT
22283	1202	29	universe	universe	NN
22283	1202	30	?	?	.
22283	1203	1	Of	of	RB
22283	1203	2	course	course	RB
22283	1203	3	the	the	DT
22283	1203	4	latter	latter	JJ
22283	1203	5	statement	statement	NN
22283	1203	6	of	of	IN
22283	1203	7	the	the	DT
22283	1203	8	question	question	NN
22283	1203	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1203	10	included	include	VBN
22283	1203	11	in	in	IN
22283	1203	12	the	the	DT
22283	1203	13	former	former	JJ
22283	1203	14	;	;	:
22283	1203	15	and	and	CC
22283	1203	16	,	,	,
22283	1203	17	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1203	18	,	,	,
22283	1203	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1203	20	may	may	MD
22283	1203	21	present	present	VB
22283	1203	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1203	23	thus;--If	thus;--If	NNP
22283	1203	24	the	the	DT
22283	1203	25	human	human	NN
22283	1203	26	will	will	NN
22283	1203	27	is	be	VBZ
22283	1203	28	free	free	JJ
22283	1203	29	,	,	,
22283	1203	30	and	and	CC
22283	1203	31	the	the	DT
22283	1203	32	theory	theory	NN
22283	1203	33	of	of	IN
22283	1203	34	Theism	Theism	NNP
22283	1203	35	substantially	substantially	RB
22283	1203	36	true	true	JJ
22283	1203	37	,	,	,
22283	1203	38	how	how	WRB
22283	1203	39	are	be	VBP
22283	1203	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1203	41	to	to	TO
22283	1203	42	reconcile	reconcile	VB
22283	1203	43	the	the	DT
22283	1203	44	fact	fact	NN
22283	1203	45	with	with	IN
22283	1203	46	the	the	DT
22283	1203	47	theory	theory	NN
22283	1203	48	?	?	.
22283	1204	1	According	accord	VBG
22283	1204	2	to	to	IN
22283	1204	3	the	the	DT
22283	1204	4	theory	theory	NN
22283	1204	5	of	of	IN
22283	1204	6	Theism	theism	NN
22283	1204	7	as	as	IN
22283	1204	8	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
22283	1204	9	by	by	IN
22283	1204	10	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1204	11	,	,	,
22283	1204	12	what	what	WP
22283	1204	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1204	14	apprehend	apprehend	VBP
22283	1204	15	as	as	IN
22283	1204	16	natural	natural	JJ
22283	1204	17	causation	causation	NN
22283	1204	18	is	be	VBZ
22283	1204	19	the	the	DT
22283	1204	20	obverse	obverse	NN
22283	1204	21	of	of	IN
22283	1204	22	a	a	DT
22283	1204	23	part	part	NN
22283	1204	24	of	of	IN
22283	1204	25	a	a	DT
22283	1204	26	_	_	NNP
22283	1204	27	summum	summum	JJ
22283	1204	28	genus_--i.e	genus_--i.e	NNP
22283	1204	29	.	.	.
22283	1205	1	the	the	DT
22283	1205	2	part	part	NN
22283	1205	3	falling	fall	VBG
22283	1205	4	within	within	IN
22283	1205	5	human	human	JJ
22283	1205	6	observation	observation	NN
22283	1205	7	whose	whose	WP$
22283	1205	8	whole	whole	NN
22283	1205	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1205	10	the	the	DT
22283	1205	11	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1205	12	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1205	13	.	.	.
22283	1206	1	This	this	DT
22283	1206	2	Volition	volition	NN
22283	1206	3	,	,	,
22283	1206	4	being	be	VBG
22283	1206	5	absolute	absolute	JJ
22283	1206	6	,	,	,
22283	1206	7	can	can	MD
22283	1206	8	nowhere	nowhere	RB
22283	1206	9	meet	meet	VB
22283	1206	10	with	with	IN
22283	1206	11	restraint	restraint	NN
22283	1206	12	;	;	:
22283	1206	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1206	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	1206	15	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1206	16	absolutely	absolutely	RB
22283	1206	17	free	free	JJ
22283	1206	18	,	,	,
22283	1206	19	and	and	CC
22283	1206	20	can	can	MD
22283	1206	21	never	never	RB
22283	1206	22	contradict	contradict	VB
22283	1206	23	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1206	24	.	.	.
22283	1207	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	1207	2	,	,	,
22283	1207	3	those	those	DT
22283	1207	4	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	1207	5	portions	portion	NNS
22283	1207	6	of	of	IN
22283	1207	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1207	8	which	which	WDT
22283	1207	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1207	10	know	know	VBP
22283	1207	11	as	as	IN
22283	1207	12	human	human	JJ
22283	1207	13	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1207	14	--	--	:
22283	1207	15	and	and	CC
22283	1207	16	which	which	WDT
22283	1207	17	,	,	,
22283	1207	18	on	on	IN
22283	1207	19	account	account	NN
22283	1207	20	of	of	IN
22283	1207	21	being	be	VBG
22283	1207	22	so	so	RB
22283	1207	23	circumscribed	circumscribe	VBN
22283	1207	24	,	,	,
22283	1207	25	are	be	VBP
22283	1207	26	free	free	JJ
22283	1207	27	within	within	IN
22283	1207	28	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1207	29	--	--	:
22283	1207	30	do	do	VB
22283	1207	31	not	not	RB
22283	1207	32	in	in	IN
22283	1207	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1207	34	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	1207	35	conflict	conflict	NN
22283	1207	36	with	with	IN
22283	1207	37	the	the	DT
22283	1207	38	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1207	39	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1207	40	.	.	.
22283	1208	1	The	the	DT
22283	1208	2	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1208	3	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1208	4	and	and	CC
22283	1208	5	the	the	DT
22283	1208	6	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1208	7	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1208	8	are	be	VBP
22283	1208	9	always	always	RB
22283	1208	10	in	in	IN
22283	1208	11	unison	unison	NNP
22283	1208	12	.	.	.
22283	1209	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1209	2	is	be	VBZ
22283	1209	3	not	not	RB
22283	1209	4	that	that	IN
22283	1209	5	the	the	DT
22283	1209	6	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1209	7	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1209	8	unconditionally	unconditionally	RB
22283	1209	9	determines	determine	VBZ
22283	1209	10	the	the	DT
22283	1209	11	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1209	12	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1209	13	--	--	:
22283	1209	14	else	else	RB
22283	1209	15	the	the	DT
22283	1209	16	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1209	17	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1209	18	would	would	MD
22283	1209	19	not	not	RB
22283	1209	20	be	be	VB
22283	1209	21	free	free	JJ
22283	1209	22	;	;	:
22283	1209	23	but	but	CC
22283	1209	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1209	25	is	be	VBZ
22283	1209	26	that	that	IN
22283	1209	27	the	the	DT
22283	1209	28	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1209	29	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1209	30	invariably	invariably	RB
22283	1209	31	assents	assent	VBZ
22283	1209	32	to	to	IN
22283	1209	33	the	the	DT
22283	1209	34	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1209	35	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1209	36	as	as	IN
22283	1209	37	to	to	IN
22283	1209	38	the	the	DT
22283	1209	39	activity	activity	NN
22283	1209	40	of	of	IN
22283	1209	41	an	an	DT
22283	1209	42	integral	integral	JJ
22283	1209	43	part	part	NN
22283	1209	44	of	of	IN
22283	1209	45	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1209	46	.	.	.
22283	1210	1	This	this	DT
22283	1210	2	will	will	MD
22283	1210	3	be	be	VB
22283	1210	4	at	at	RB
22283	1210	5	once	once	RB
22283	1210	6	evident	evident	JJ
22283	1210	7	if	if	IN
22283	1210	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1210	9	consider	consider	VBP
22283	1210	10	that	that	IN
22283	1210	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1210	12	only	only	JJ
22283	1210	13	idea	idea	NN
22283	1210	14	of	of	IN
22283	1210	15	determination	determination	NN
22283	1210	16	--	--	:
22283	1210	17	i.e	i.e	NNP
22283	1210	18	.	.	.
22283	1211	1	causation	causation	NN
22283	1211	2	--	--	:
22283	1211	3	is	be	VBZ
22283	1211	4	,	,	,
22283	1211	5	upon	upon	IN
22283	1211	6	the	the	DT
22283	1211	7	theistic	theistic	JJ
22283	1211	8	theory	theory	NN
22283	1211	9	,	,	,
22283	1211	10	derived	derive	VBN
22283	1211	11	from	from	IN
22283	1211	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1211	13	observing	observe	VBG
22283	1211	14	the	the	DT
22283	1211	15	consistency	consistency	NN
22283	1211	16	of	of	IN
22283	1211	17	the	the	DT
22283	1211	18	Divine	Divine	NNP
22283	1211	19	Will	Will	NNP
22283	1211	20	,	,	,
22283	1211	21	whether	whether	IN
22283	1211	22	as	as	IN
22283	1211	23	revealed	reveal	VBN
22283	1211	24	subjectively	subjectively	RB
22283	1211	25	in	in	IN
22283	1211	26	the	the	DT
22283	1211	27	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1211	28	operations	operation	NNS
22283	1211	29	of	of	IN
22283	1211	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1211	31	own	own	JJ
22283	1211	32	minds	mind	NNS
22283	1211	33	,	,	,
22283	1211	34	or	or	CC
22283	1211	35	objectively	objectively	RB
22283	1211	36	in	in	IN
22283	1211	37	the	the	DT
22283	1211	38	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1211	39	operations	operation	NNS
22283	1211	40	of	of	IN
22283	1211	41	Nature	Nature	NNP
22283	1211	42	.	.	.
22283	1212	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1212	2	,	,	,
22283	1212	3	the	the	DT
22283	1212	4	idea	idea	NN
22283	1212	5	of	of	IN
22283	1212	6	causation	causation	NN
22283	1212	7	as	as	IN
22283	1212	8	between	between	IN
22283	1212	9	the	the	DT
22283	1212	10	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1212	11	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1212	12	and	and	CC
22283	1212	13	the	the	DT
22283	1212	14	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1212	15	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1212	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	1212	17	an	an	DT
22283	1212	18	idea	idea	NN
22283	1212	19	destitute	destitute	NN
22283	1212	20	of	of	IN
22283	1212	21	meaning	meaning	NN
22283	1212	22	.	.	.
22283	1213	1	One	one	CD
22283	1213	2	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1213	3	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1213	4	may	may	MD
22283	1213	5	act	act	VB
22283	1213	6	causally	causally	RB
22283	1213	7	on	on	IN
22283	1213	8	another	another	DT
22283	1213	9	.	.	.
22283	1214	1	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1214	2	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1214	3	,	,	,
22283	1214	4	because	because	IN
22283	1214	5	each	each	DT
22283	1214	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1214	7	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	1214	8	external	external	JJ
22283	1214	9	to	to	IN
22283	1214	10	each	each	DT
22283	1214	11	.	.	.
22283	1215	1	But	but	CC
22283	1215	2	all	all	DT
22283	1215	3	Relative	relative	JJ
22283	1215	4	Volitions	Volitions	NNPS
22283	1215	5	are	be	VBP
22283	1215	6	constituent	constituent	JJ
22283	1215	7	parts	part	NNS
22283	1215	8	of	of	IN
22283	1215	9	the	the	DT
22283	1215	10	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1215	11	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1215	12	,	,	,
22283	1215	13	which	which	WDT
22283	1215	14	,	,	,
22283	1215	15	therefore	therefore	RB
22283	1215	16	,	,	,
22283	1215	17	can	can	MD
22283	1215	18	not	not	RB
22283	1215	19	act	act	VB
22283	1215	20	causally	causally	RB
22283	1215	21	_	_	NNP
22283	1215	22	on	on	IN
22283	1215	23	_	_	NNP
22283	1215	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1215	25	,	,	,
22283	1215	26	though	though	IN
22283	1215	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1215	28	always	always	RB
22283	1215	29	acts	act	VBZ
22283	1215	30	substantially	substantially	RB
22283	1215	31	_	_	NNP
22283	1215	32	with	with	IN
22283	1215	33	_	_	NNP
22283	1215	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1215	35	.	.	.
22283	1216	1	Or	or	CC
22283	1216	2	,	,	,
22283	1216	3	otherwise	otherwise	RB
22283	1216	4	phrased	phrase	VBN
22283	1216	5	,	,	,
22283	1216	6	if	if	IN
22283	1216	7	the	the	DT
22283	1216	8	subject	subject	NN
22283	1216	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1216	10	a	a	DT
22283	1216	11	constituent	constituent	JJ
22283	1216	12	part	part	NN
22283	1216	13	of	of	IN
22283	1216	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1216	15	own	own	JJ
22283	1216	16	World	world	NN
22283	1216	17	-	-	HYPH
22283	1216	18	eject	eject	NN
22283	1216	19	--	--	:
22283	1216	20	the	the	DT
22283	1216	21	volition	volition	NN
22283	1216	22	of	of	IN
22283	1216	23	which	which	WDT
22283	1216	24	is	be	VBZ
22283	1216	25	always	always	RB
22283	1216	26	self	self	NN
22283	1216	27	-	-	HYPH
22283	1216	28	consistent	consistent	JJ
22283	1216	29	--	--	:
22283	1216	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1216	31	follows	follow	VBZ
22283	1216	32	that	that	IN
22283	1216	33	the	the	DT
22283	1216	34	volition	volition	NN
22283	1216	35	of	of	IN
22283	1216	36	the	the	DT
22283	1216	37	subject	subject	NN
22283	1216	38	must	must	MD
22283	1216	39	always	always	RB
22283	1216	40	be	be	VB
22283	1216	41	coincident	coincident	JJ
22283	1216	42	with	with	IN
22283	1216	43	that	that	DT
22283	1216	44	of	of	IN
22283	1216	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1216	46	World	World	NNP
22283	1216	47	-	-	HYPH
22283	1216	48	eject	eject	NN
22283	1216	49	;	;	:
22283	1216	50	and	and	CC
22283	1216	51	this	this	DT
22283	1216	52	without	without	IN
22283	1216	53	being	be	VBG
22283	1216	54	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1216	55	in	in	IN
22283	1216	56	any	any	DT
22283	1216	57	other	other	JJ
22283	1216	58	sense	sense	NN
22283	1216	59	than	than	IN
22283	1216	60	the	the	DT
22283	1216	61	smaller	small	JJR
22283	1216	62	size	size	NN
22283	1216	63	of	of	IN
22283	1216	64	a	a	DT
22283	1216	65	part	part	NN
22283	1216	66	can	can	MD
22283	1216	67	be	be	VB
22283	1216	68	said	say	VBN
22283	1216	69	to	to	TO
22283	1216	70	be	be	VB
22283	1216	71	determined	determine	VBN
22283	1216	72	by	by	IN
22283	1216	73	the	the	DT
22283	1216	74	larger	large	JJR
22283	1216	75	size	size	NN
22283	1216	76	of	of	IN
22283	1216	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1216	78	whole	whole	NN
22283	1216	79	:	:	:
22283	1216	80	i.e.	i.e.	FW
22283	1217	1	the	the	DT
22283	1217	2	determination	determination	NN
22283	1217	3	--	--	:
22283	1217	4	if	if	IN
22283	1217	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1217	6	choose	choose	VBP
22283	1217	7	so	so	RB
22283	1217	8	to	to	TO
22283	1217	9	call	call	VB
22283	1217	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1217	11	--	--	:
22283	1217	12	is	be	VBZ
22283	1217	13	not	not	RB
22283	1217	14	a	a	DT
22283	1217	15	causal	causal	JJ
22283	1217	16	one	one	NN
22283	1217	17	,	,	,
22283	1217	18	but	but	CC
22283	1217	19	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1217	20	immediately	immediately	RB
22283	1217	21	from	from	IN
22283	1217	22	the	the	DT
22283	1217	23	inherent	inherent	JJ
22283	1217	24	nature	nature	NN
22283	1217	25	of	of	IN
22283	1217	26	the	the	DT
22283	1217	27	case	case	NN
22283	1217	28	.	.	.
22283	1218	1	The	the	DT
22283	1218	2	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1218	3	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1218	4	within	within	IN
22283	1218	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1218	6	is	be	VBZ
22283	1218	7	free	free	JJ
22283	1218	8	;	;	:
22283	1218	9	the	the	DT
22283	1218	10	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1218	11	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1218	12	within	within	IN
22283	1218	13	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1218	14	is	be	VBZ
22283	1218	15	free	free	JJ
22283	1218	16	;	;	:
22283	1218	17	but	but	CC
22283	1218	18	there	there	EX
22283	1218	19	can	can	MD
22283	1218	20	be	be	VB
22283	1218	21	no	no	DT
22283	1218	22	conflict	conflict	NN
22283	1218	23	between	between	IN
22283	1218	24	these	these	DT
22283	1218	25	two	two	CD
22283	1218	26	freedoms	freedom	NNS
22283	1218	27	.	.	.
22283	1219	1	For	for	IN
22283	1219	2	,	,	,
22283	1219	3	if	if	IN
22283	1219	4	there	there	EX
22283	1219	5	were	be	VBD
22283	1219	6	a	a	DT
22283	1219	7	conflict	conflict	NN
22283	1219	8	,	,	,
22283	1219	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1219	10	must	must	MD
22283	1219	11	be	be	VB
22283	1219	12	caused	cause	VBN
22283	1219	13	;	;	:
22283	1219	14	but	but	CC
22283	1219	15	where	where	WRB
22283	1219	16	is	be	VBZ
22283	1219	17	the	the	DT
22283	1219	18	cause	cause	NN
22283	1219	19	of	of	IN
22283	1219	20	this	this	DT
22283	1219	21	conflict	conflict	NN
22283	1219	22	to	to	TO
22283	1219	23	come	come	VB
22283	1219	24	from	from	IN
22283	1219	25	?	?	.
22283	1220	1	Not	not	RB
22283	1220	2	from	from	IN
22283	1220	3	the	the	DT
22283	1220	4	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1220	5	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1220	6	,	,	,
22283	1220	7	which	which	WDT
22283	1220	8	is	be	VBZ
22283	1220	9	everywhere	everywhere	RB
22283	1220	10	self	self	NN
22283	1220	11	-	-	HYPH
22283	1220	12	consistent	consistent	JJ
22283	1220	13	;	;	:
22283	1220	14	not	not	RB
22283	1220	15	from	from	IN
22283	1220	16	the	the	DT
22283	1220	17	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1220	18	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1220	19	,	,	,
22283	1220	20	which	which	WDT
22283	1220	21	is	be	VBZ
22283	1220	22	wholly	wholly	RB
22283	1220	23	contained	contain	VBN
22283	1220	24	within	within	IN
22283	1220	25	the	the	DT
22283	1220	26	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
22283	1220	27	.	.	.
22283	1221	1	Thus	thus	RB
22283	1221	2	,	,	,
22283	1221	3	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1221	4	from	from	IN
22283	1221	5	within	within	IN
22283	1221	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1221	7	own	own	JJ
22283	1221	8	system	system	NN
22283	1221	9	,	,	,
22283	1221	10	the	the	DT
22283	1221	11	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1221	12	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1221	13	is	be	VBZ
22283	1221	14	free	free	JJ
22283	1221	15	;	;	:
22283	1221	16	while	while	IN
22283	1221	17	,	,	,
22283	1221	18	regarded	regard	VBN
22283	1221	19	from	from	IN
22283	1221	20	the	the	DT
22283	1221	21	system	system	NN
22283	1221	22	of	of	IN
22283	1221	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
22283	1221	24	World	World	NNP
22283	1221	25	-	-	HYPH
22283	1221	26	eject	eject	NN
22283	1221	27	,	,	,
22283	1221	28	the	the	DT
22283	1221	29	Relative	Relative	NNP
22283	1221	30	Volition	Volition	NNP
22283	1221	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1221	32	predestined	predestine	VBN
22283	1221	33	.	.	.
22283	1222	1	But	but	CC
22283	1222	2	the	the	DT
22283	1222	3	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	1222	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1222	5	not	not	RB
22283	1222	6	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
22283	1222	7	with	with	IN
22283	1222	8	the	the	DT
22283	1222	9	predestination	predestination	NN
22283	1222	10	,	,	,
22283	1222	11	nor	nor	CC
22283	1222	12	the	the	DT
22283	1222	13	predestination	predestination	NN
22283	1222	14	with	with	IN
22283	1222	15	the	the	DT
22283	1222	16	freedom	freedom	NN
22283	1222	17	.	.	.
22283	1223	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1223	2	stand	stand	VBP
22283	1223	3	to	to	IN
22283	1223	4	each	each	DT
22283	1223	5	other	other	JJ
22283	1223	6	in	in	IN
22283	1223	7	the	the	DT
22283	1223	8	relation	relation	NN
22283	1223	9	of	of	IN
22283	1223	10	complementary	complementary	JJ
22283	1223	11	truths	truth	NNS
22283	1223	12	,	,	,
22283	1223	13	the	the	DT
22283	1223	14	apparent	apparent	JJ
22283	1223	15	contradiction	contradiction	NN
22283	1223	16	of	of	IN
22283	1223	17	which	which	WDT
22283	1223	18	arises	arise	VBZ
22283	1223	19	only	only	RB
22283	1223	20	from	from	IN
22283	1223	21	the	the	DT
22283	1223	22	apparently	apparently	RB
22283	1223	23	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
22283	1223	24	antithesis	antithesis	NN
22283	1223	25	between	between	IN
22283	1223	26	mind	mind	NN
22283	1223	27	and	and	CC
22283	1223	28	cause	cause	VB
22283	1223	29	which	which	WDT
22283	1223	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1223	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1223	32	the	the	DT
22283	1223	33	privilege	privilege	NN
22283	1223	34	of	of	IN
22283	1223	35	Monism	Monism	NNP
22283	1223	36	to	to	TO
22283	1223	37	abolish	abolish	VB
22283	1223	38	.	.	.
22283	1224	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
22283	1224	2	:	:	:
22283	1224	3	[	[	-LRB-
22283	1224	4	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
22283	1224	5	13	13	CD
22283	1224	6	:	:	:
22283	1224	7	'	'	''
22283	1224	8	Whatsoever	whatsoever	WP
22283	1224	9	is	be	VBZ
22283	1224	10	first	first	JJ
22283	1224	11	of	of	IN
22283	1224	12	all	all	DT
22283	1224	13	things	thing	NNS
22283	1224	14	must	must	MD
22283	1224	15	necessarily	necessarily	RB
22283	1224	16	contain	contain	VB
22283	1224	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1224	18	,	,	,
22283	1224	19	and	and	CC
22283	1224	20	actually	actually	RB
22283	1224	21	have	have	VBP
22283	1224	22	,	,	,
22283	1224	23	at	at	IN
22283	1224	24	least	least	JJS
22283	1224	25	,	,	,
22283	1224	26	all	all	PDT
22283	1224	27	the	the	DT
22283	1224	28	perfections	perfection	NNS
22283	1224	29	that	that	WDT
22283	1224	30	can	can	MD
22283	1224	31	ever	ever	RB
22283	1224	32	after	after	RB
22283	1224	33	exist	exist	VB
22283	1224	34	;	;	:
22283	1224	35	nor	nor	CC
22283	1224	36	can	can	MD
22283	1224	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1224	38	ever	ever	RB
22283	1224	39	give	give	VB
22283	1224	40	to	to	IN
22283	1224	41	another	another	DT
22283	1224	42	any	any	DT
22283	1224	43	perfection	perfection	NN
22283	1224	44	that	that	IN
22283	1224	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1224	46	hath	hath	VBP
22283	1224	47	not	not	RB
22283	1224	48	actually	actually	RB
22283	1224	49	in	in	IN
22283	1224	50	itself	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1224	51	,	,	,
22283	1224	52	or	or	CC
22283	1224	53	at	at	IN
22283	1224	54	least	least	JJS
22283	1224	55	in	in	IN
22283	1224	56	a	a	DT
22283	1224	57	higher	high	JJR
22283	1224	58	degree	degree	NN
22283	1224	59	'	'	''
22283	1224	60	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1224	61	Locke	Locke	NNP
22283	1224	62	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1224	63	.	.	.
22283	1225	1	To	to	IN
22283	1225	2	this	this	DT
22283	1225	3	argument	argument	NN
22283	1225	4	Mill	Mill	NNP
22283	1225	5	answers	answer	VBZ
22283	1225	6	,	,	,
22283	1225	7	'	'	``
22283	1225	8	How	how	WRB
22283	1225	9	vastly	vastly	RB
22283	1225	10	nobler	noble	JJR
22283	1225	11	and	and	CC
22283	1225	12	more	more	RBR
22283	1225	13	precious	precious	JJ
22283	1225	14	,	,	,
22283	1225	15	for	for	IN
22283	1225	16	instance	instance	NN
22283	1225	17	,	,	,
22283	1225	18	are	be	VBP
22283	1225	19	the	the	DT
22283	1225	20	vegetables	vegetable	NNS
22283	1225	21	and	and	CC
22283	1225	22	animals	animal	NNS
22283	1225	23	than	than	IN
22283	1225	24	the	the	DT
22283	1225	25	soil	soil	NN
22283	1225	26	and	and	CC
22283	1225	27	manure	manure	NN
22283	1225	28	out	out	IN
22283	1225	29	of	of	IN
22283	1225	30	which	which	WDT
22283	1225	31	,	,	,
22283	1225	32	and	and	CC
22283	1225	33	by	by	IN
22283	1225	34	the	the	DT
22283	1225	35	properties	property	NNS
22283	1225	36	of	of	IN
22283	1225	37	which	which	WDT
22283	1225	38	,	,	,
22283	1225	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1225	40	are	be	VBP
22283	1225	41	raised	raise	VBN
22283	1225	42	up	up	RP
22283	1225	43	!	!	.
22283	1226	1	But	but	CC
22283	1226	2	this	this	DT
22283	1226	3	stricture	stricture	NN
22283	1226	4	is	be	VBZ
22283	1226	5	not	not	RB
22283	1226	6	worthy	worthy	JJ
22283	1226	7	of	of	IN
22283	1226	8	Mill	Mill	NNP
22283	1226	9	.	.	.
22283	1227	1	The	the	DT
22283	1227	2	soil	soil	NN
22283	1227	3	and	and	CC
22283	1227	4	manure	manure	NN
22283	1227	5	do	do	VBP
22283	1227	6	not	not	RB
22283	1227	7	constitute	constitute	VB
22283	1227	8	the	the	DT
22283	1227	9	whole	whole	JJ
22283	1227	10	cause	cause	NN
22283	1227	11	of	of	IN
22283	1227	12	the	the	DT
22283	1227	13	plants	plant	NNS
22283	1227	14	and	and	CC
22283	1227	15	animals	animal	NNS
22283	1227	16	.	.	.
22283	1228	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1228	2	must	must	MD
22283	1228	3	trace	trace	VB
22283	1228	4	these	these	DT
22283	1228	5	and	and	CC
22283	1228	6	many	many	JJ
22283	1228	7	other	other	JJ
22283	1228	8	con	con	NN
22283	1228	9	-	-	HYPH
22283	1228	10	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1228	11	(	(	-LRB-
22283	1228	12	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1228	13	)	)	-RRB-
22283	1228	14	back	back	RB
22283	1228	15	and	and	CC
22283	1228	16	back	back	RB
22283	1228	17	till	till	IN
22283	1228	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1228	19	come	come	VBP
22283	1228	20	to	to	IN
22283	1228	21	'	'	''
22283	1228	22	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
22283	1228	23	is	be	VBZ
22283	1228	24	first	first	JJ
22283	1228	25	of	of	IN
22283	1228	26	all	all	DT
22283	1228	27	things	thing	NNS
22283	1228	28	'	'	POS
22283	1228	29	:	:	:
22283	1228	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1228	31	is	be	VBZ
22283	1228	32	merely	merely	RB
22283	1228	33	childish	childish	JJ
22283	1228	34	to	to	TO
22283	1228	35	choose	choose	VB
22283	1228	36	some	some	DT
22283	1228	37	few	few	JJ
22283	1228	38	of	of	IN
22283	1228	39	the	the	DT
22283	1228	40	conditions	condition	NNS
22283	1228	41	,	,	,
22283	1228	42	and	and	CC
22283	1228	43	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	RB
22283	1228	44	to	to	TO
22283	1228	45	regard	regard	VB
22283	1228	46	them	-PRON-	PRP
22283	1228	47	as	as	RB
22283	1228	48	alone	alone	RB
22283	1228	49	the	the	DT
22283	1228	50	efficient	efficient	JJ
22283	1228	51	causes	cause	NNS
22283	1228	52	.	.	.
22283	1228	53	]	]	-RRB-
22283	1229	1	[	[	-LRB-
22283	1229	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
22283	1229	3	14	14	CD
22283	1229	4	:	:	:
22283	1229	5	_	_	NNP
22283	1229	6	Collected	Collected	NNP
22283	1229	7	Essays	Essays	NNPS
22283	1229	8	_	_	NNP
22283	1229	9	,	,	,
22283	1229	10	vol	vol	NNP
22283	1229	11	.	.	.
22283	1230	1	ix	ix	IN
22283	1230	2	.	.	.
22283	1231	1	'	'	``
22283	1231	2	Evolution	Evolution	NNP
22283	1231	3	and	and	CC
22283	1231	4	Ethics	Ethics	NNP
22283	1231	5	,	,	,
22283	1231	6	'	'	''
22283	1231	7	p.	p.	NN
22283	1232	1	140	140	CD
22283	1232	2	.	.	.
22283	1232	3	]	]	-RRB-
22283	1233	1	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	2	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	3	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	4	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	5	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	6	+	+	SYM
22283	1233	7	-------------------------------------------------------------------+	-------------------------------------------------------------------+	NN
22283	1233	8	|Transcriber	|Transcriber	NNP
22283	1233	9	's	's	POS
22283	1233	10	note	note	NN
22283	1233	11	:	:	:
22283	1233	12	In	in	IN
22283	1233	13	this	this	DT
22283	1233	14	text	text	NN
22283	1233	15	this	this	DT
22283	1233	16	H_2O	h_2o	NN
22283	1233	17	represents	represent	VBZ
22283	1233	18	a	a	DT
22283	1233	19	subscript	subscript	NN
22283	1233	20	2|	2|	CD
22283	1233	21	+	+	SYM
22283	1233	22	-------------------------------------------------------------------+	-------------------------------------------------------------------+	NFP
22283	1233	23	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	24	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	25	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	26	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	27	*	*	NFP
22283	1233	28	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
22283	1233	29	HORACE	HORACE	NNP
22283	1233	30	HART	HART	NNP
22283	1233	31	,	,	,
22283	1233	32	PRINTER	PRINTER	NNP
22283	1233	33	TO	to	IN
22283	1233	34	THE	the	DT
22283	1233	35	UNIVERSITY	UNIVERSITY	NNP