id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
47658	1	1	THE	the	DT
47658	1	2	PROBLEM	problem	NN
47658	1	3	OF	of	IN
47658	1	4	TRUTH	truth	NN
47658	1	5	BY	by	IN
47658	1	6	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1	7	WILDON	WILDON	NNP
47658	1	8	CARR	CARR	NNP
47658	1	9	HONORARY	HONORARY	NNP
47658	1	10	D.LITT	D.LITT	NNP
47658	1	11	.	.	NNP
47658	1	12	,	,	,
47658	1	13	DURHAM	DURHAM	NNP
47658	1	14	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
47658	1	15	:	:	:
47658	1	16	T.	T.	NNP
47658	1	17	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1	18	&	&	CC
47658	1	19	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1	20	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1	21	JACK	JACK	NNP
47658	1	22	67	67	CD
47658	1	23	LONG	LONG	NNP
47658	1	24	ACRE	ACRE	NNP
47658	1	25	,	,	,
47658	1	26	W.C.	W.C.	NNP
47658	1	27	,	,	,
47658	1	28	AND	and	CC
47658	1	29	EDINBURGH	EDINBURGH	NNP
47658	1	30	NEW	NEW	NNP
47658	1	31	YORK	YORK	NNP
47658	1	32	:	:	:
47658	1	33	DODGE	DODGE	NNP
47658	1	34	PUBLISHING	PUBLISHING	NNP
47658	1	35	CO	CO	NNP
47658	1	36	.	.	.
47658	1	37	{	{	-LRB-
47658	1	38	v	v	NN
47658	1	39	}	}	-RRB-
47658	1	40	PREFACE	PREFACE	NNP
47658	1	41	A	a	DT
47658	1	42	problem	problem	NN
47658	1	43	of	of	IN
47658	1	44	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	1	45	is	be	VBZ
47658	1	46	completely	completely	RB
47658	1	47	different	different	JJ
47658	1	48	from	from	IN
47658	1	49	a	a	DT
47658	1	50	problem	problem	NN
47658	1	51	of	of	IN
47658	1	52	science	science	NN
47658	1	53	.	.	.
47658	2	1	In	in	IN
47658	2	2	science	science	NN
47658	2	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	2	4	accept	accept	VBP
47658	2	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	2	6	subject	subject	JJ
47658	2	7	-	-	HYPH
47658	2	8	matter	matter	NN
47658	2	9	as	as	IN
47658	2	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	2	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	2	12	presented	present	VBN
47658	2	13	in	in	IN
47658	2	14	unanalysed	unanalysed	JJ
47658	2	15	experience	experience	NN
47658	2	16	;	;	:
47658	2	17	in	in	IN
47658	2	18	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	2	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	2	20	examine	examine	VBP
47658	2	21	the	the	DT
47658	2	22	first	first	JJ
47658	2	23	principles	principle	NNS
47658	2	24	and	and	CC
47658	2	25	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	2	26	questions	question	NNS
47658	2	27	that	that	WDT
47658	2	28	concern	concern	VBP
47658	2	29	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	2	30	experience	experience	NN
47658	2	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	2	32	.	.	.
47658	3	1	The	the	DT
47658	3	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	3	3	of	of	IN
47658	3	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	3	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	3	6	a	a	DT
47658	3	7	problem	problem	NN
47658	3	8	of	of	IN
47658	3	9	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	3	10	.	.	.
47658	4	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	4	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	4	3	not	not	RB
47658	4	4	a	a	DT
47658	4	5	problem	problem	NN
47658	4	6	of	of	IN
47658	4	7	merely	merely	RB
47658	4	8	historical	historical	JJ
47658	4	9	interest	interest	NN
47658	4	10	,	,	,
47658	4	11	but	but	CC
47658	4	12	a	a	DT
47658	4	13	present	present	JJ
47658	4	14	problem	problem	NN
47658	4	15	--	--	:
47658	4	16	a	a	DT
47658	4	17	living	live	VBG
47658	4	18	controversy	controversy	NN
47658	4	19	,	,	,
47658	4	20	the	the	DT
47658	4	21	issue	issue	NN
47658	4	22	of	of	IN
47658	4	23	which	which	WDT
47658	4	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	4	25	undecided	undecided	JJ
47658	4	26	.	.	.
47658	5	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	5	2	present	present	JJ
47658	5	3	interest	interest	NN
47658	5	4	may	may	MD
47658	5	5	be	be	VB
47658	5	6	said	say	VBN
47658	5	7	to	to	IN
47658	5	8	centre	centre	NN
47658	5	9	round	round	IN
47658	5	10	the	the	DT
47658	5	11	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	5	12	of	of	IN
47658	5	13	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	5	14	,	,	,
47658	5	15	which	which	WDT
47658	5	16	some	some	DT
47658	5	17	fifteen	fifteen	CD
47658	5	18	years	year	NNS
47658	5	19	ago	ago	RB
47658	5	20	began	begin	VBD
47658	5	21	to	to	TO
47658	5	22	challenge	challenge	VB
47658	5	23	the	the	DT
47658	5	24	generally	generally	RB
47658	5	25	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	5	26	principles	principle	NNS
47658	5	27	of	of	IN
47658	5	28	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	5	29	.	.	.
47658	6	1	In	in	IN
47658	6	2	expounding	expound	VBG
47658	6	3	this	this	DT
47658	6	4	problem	problem	NN
47658	6	5	of	of	IN
47658	6	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	6	7	,	,	,
47658	6	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	6	9	main	main	JJ
47658	6	10	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	6	11	has	have	VBZ
47658	6	12	been	be	VBN
47658	6	13	to	to	TO
47658	6	14	make	make	VB
47658	6	15	clear	clear	JJ
47658	6	16	to	to	IN
47658	6	17	the	the	DT
47658	6	18	reader	reader	NN
47658	6	19	the	the	DT
47658	6	20	nature	nature	NN
47658	6	21	of	of	IN
47658	6	22	a	a	DT
47658	6	23	problem	problem	NN
47658	6	24	of	of	IN
47658	6	25	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	6	26	and	and	CC
47658	6	27	to	to	TO
47658	6	28	disclose	disclose	VB
47658	6	29	the	the	DT
47658	6	30	secret	secret	NN
47658	6	31	of	of	IN
47658	6	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	6	33	interest	interest	NN
47658	6	34	.	.	.
47658	7	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	7	2	book	book	NN
47658	7	3	presumes	presume	VBZ
47658	7	4	no	no	DT
47658	7	5	previous	previous	JJ
47658	7	6	study	study	NN
47658	7	7	of	of	IN
47658	7	8	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	7	9	nor	nor	CC
47658	7	10	special	special	JJ
47658	7	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	7	12	of	of	IN
47658	7	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	7	14	problems	problem	NNS
47658	7	15	.	.	.
47658	8	1	The	the	DT
47658	8	2	theories	theory	NNS
47658	8	3	that	that	WDT
47658	8	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	8	5	have	have	VBP
47658	8	6	shown	show	VBN
47658	8	7	in	in	IN
47658	8	8	conflict	conflict	NN
47658	8	9	on	on	IN
47658	8	10	this	this	DT
47658	8	11	question	question	NN
47658	8	12	are	be	VBP
47658	8	13	,	,	,
47658	8	14	each	each	DT
47658	8	15	of	of	IN
47658	8	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	8	17	,	,	,
47658	8	18	held	hold	VBN
47658	8	19	by	by	IN
47658	8	20	some	some	DT
47658	8	21	of	of	IN
47658	8	22	the	the	DT
47658	8	23	leaders	leader	NNS
47658	8	24	of	of	IN
47658	8	25	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	8	26	.	.	.
47658	9	1	In	in	IN
47658	9	2	presenting	present	VBG
47658	9	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	9	4	,	,	,
47658	9	5	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	9	6	,	,	,
47658	9	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	9	8	have	have	VBP
47658	9	9	tried	try	VBN
47658	9	10	to	to	TO
47658	9	11	let	let	VB
47658	9	12	the	the	DT
47658	9	13	full	full	JJ
47658	9	14	dialectical	dialectical	JJ
47658	9	15	force	force	NN
47658	9	16	of	of	IN
47658	9	17	the	the	DT
47658	9	18	argument	argument	NN
47658	9	19	appear	appear	VBP
47658	9	20	.	.	.
47658	10	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	10	2	have	have	VBP
47658	10	3	indicated	indicate	VBN
47658	10	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	10	5	own	own	JJ
47658	10	6	view	view	NN
47658	10	7	,	,	,
47658	10	8	that	that	IN
47658	10	9	the	the	DT
47658	10	10	direction	direction	NN
47658	10	11	in	in	IN
47658	10	12	which	which	WDT
47658	10	13	the	the	DT
47658	10	14	solution	solution	NN
47658	10	15	lies	lie	VBZ
47658	10	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	10	17	in	in	IN
47658	10	18	the	the	DT
47658	10	19	new	new	JJ
47658	10	20	conception	conception	NN
47658	10	21	of	of	IN
47658	10	22	life	life	NN
47658	10	23	and	and	CC
47658	10	24	the	the	DT
47658	10	25	theory	theory	NN
47658	10	26	of	of	IN
47658	10	27	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	10	28	given	give	VBN
47658	10	29	to	to	IN
47658	10	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	10	31	in	in	IN
47658	10	32	the	the	DT
47658	10	33	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	10	34	of	of	IN
47658	10	35	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	10	36	.	.	.
47658	11	1	If	if	IN
47658	11	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	11	3	am	be	VBP
47658	11	4	right	right	JJ
47658	11	5	,	,	,
47658	11	6	the	the	DT
47658	11	7	solution	solution	NN
47658	11	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	11	9	not	not	RB
47658	11	10	,	,	,
47658	11	11	like	like	IN
47658	11	12	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	11	13	,	,	,
47658	11	14	a	a	DT
47658	11	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	11	16	of	of	IN
47658	11	17	the	the	DT
47658	11	18	nature	nature	NN
47658	11	19	of	of	IN
47658	11	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	11	21	,	,	,
47658	11	22	but	but	CC
47658	11	23	a	a	DT
47658	11	24	theory	theory	NN
47658	11	25	of	of	IN
47658	11	26	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	11	27	in	in	IN
47658	11	28	which	which	WDT
47658	11	29	{	{	-LRB-
47658	11	30	vi	vi	NNP
47658	11	31	}	}	-RRB-
47658	11	32	the	the	DT
47658	11	33	dilemma	dilemma	NN
47658	11	34	in	in	IN
47658	11	35	regard	regard	NN
47658	11	36	to	to	IN
47658	11	37	truth	truth	NN
47658	11	38	does	do	VBZ
47658	11	39	not	not	RB
47658	11	40	arise	arise	VB
47658	11	41	.	.	.
47658	12	1	But	but	CC
47658	12	2	,	,	,
47658	12	3	as	as	IN
47658	12	4	always	always	RB
47658	12	5	in	in	IN
47658	12	6	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	12	7	,	,	,
47658	12	8	the	the	DT
47658	12	9	solution	solution	NN
47658	12	10	of	of	IN
47658	12	11	one	one	CD
47658	12	12	problem	problem	NN
47658	12	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	12	14	the	the	DT
47658	12	15	emergence	emergence	NN
47658	12	16	of	of	IN
47658	12	17	another	another	DT
47658	12	18	.	.	.
47658	13	1	There	there	EX
47658	13	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	13	3	no	no	DT
47658	13	4	finality	finality	NN
47658	13	5	.	.	.
47658	14	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	14	2	grateful	grateful	JJ
47658	14	3	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
47658	14	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	14	5	due	due	JJ
47658	14	6	to	to	IN
47658	14	7	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	14	8	friend	friend	NN
47658	14	9	Professor	Professor	NNP
47658	14	10	S.	S.	NNP
47658	14	11	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
47658	14	12	,	,	,
47658	14	13	who	who	WP
47658	14	14	kindly	kindly	RB
47658	14	15	read	read	VBD
47658	14	16	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	14	17	manuscript	manuscript	NN
47658	14	18	and	and	CC
47658	14	19	assisted	assist	VBD
47658	14	20	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	14	21	with	with	IN
47658	14	22	most	most	JJS
47658	14	23	valuable	valuable	JJ
47658	14	24	suggestions	suggestion	NNS
47658	14	25	,	,	,
47658	14	26	and	and	CC
47658	14	27	also	also	RB
47658	14	28	to	to	IN
47658	14	29	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	14	30	friend	friend	NN
47658	14	31	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	14	32	T.	T.	NNP
47658	14	33	Percy	Percy	NNP
47658	14	34	Nunn	Nunn	NNP
47658	14	35	for	for	IN
47658	14	36	a	a	DT
47658	14	37	similar	similar	JJ
47658	14	38	service	service	NN
47658	14	39	.	.	.
47658	15	1	H.	H.	NNP
47658	15	2	WILDON	WILDON	NNP
47658	15	3	CARR	CARR	NNP
47658	15	4	.	.	.
47658	16	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	16	2	vii	vii	NN
47658	16	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	16	4	CONTENTS	content	NNS
47658	16	5	CHAP	CHAP	NNP
47658	16	6	.	.	.
47658	17	1	I.	I.	NNP
47658	18	1	PHYSICS	PHYSICS	NNP
47658	18	2	AND	and	CC
47658	18	3	METAPHYSICS	metaphysic	NNS
47658	18	4	II	II	NNP
47658	18	5	.	.	.
47658	19	1	APPEARANCE	APPEARANCE	NNP
47658	19	2	AND	and	CC
47658	19	3	REALITY	reality	NN
47658	19	4	III	iii	CD
47658	19	5	.	.	.
47658	20	1	THE	the	DT
47658	20	2	LOGICAL	LOGICAL	NNP
47658	20	3	THEORIES	THEORIES	NNP
47658	20	4	IV	IV	NNP
47658	20	5	.	.	.
47658	21	1	THE	the	DT
47658	21	2	ABSOLUTE	ABSOLUTE	NNP
47658	21	3	V.	V.	NNP
47658	21	4	PRAGMATISM	PRAGMATISM	NNP
47658	21	5	VI	VI	NNP
47658	21	6	.	.	.
47658	22	1	UTILITY	UTILITY	NNP
47658	22	2	VII	vii	NN
47658	22	3	.	.	.
47658	23	1	ILLUSION	illusion	JJ
47658	23	2	VIII	viii	NN
47658	23	3	.	.	.
47658	24	1	THE	the	DT
47658	24	2	PROBLEM	problem	NN
47658	24	3	OF	of	IN
47658	24	4	ERROR	ERROR	NNP
47658	24	5	IX	IX	NNP
47658	24	6	.	.	.
47658	25	1	CONCLUSION	CONCLUSION	NNP
47658	25	2	BIBLIOGRAPHY	BIBLIOGRAPHY	NNP
47658	25	3	INDEX	INDEX	NNP
47658	25	4	{	{	-LRB-
47658	25	5	9	9	CD
47658	25	6	}	}	-RRB-
47658	25	7	THE	the	DT
47658	25	8	PROBLEM	problem	NN
47658	25	9	OF	of	IN
47658	25	10	TRUTH	truth	NN
47658	25	11	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
47658	25	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	25	13	PHYSICS	physics	VBP
47658	25	14	AND	and	CC
47658	25	15	METAPHYSICS	metaphysic	NNS
47658	25	16	The	the	DT
47658	25	17	progress	progress	NN
47658	25	18	of	of	IN
47658	25	19	physical	physical	JJ
47658	25	20	science	science	NN
47658	25	21	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	25	22	to	to	IN
47658	25	23	the	the	DT
47658	25	24	continual	continual	JJ
47658	25	25	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	25	26	of	of	IN
47658	25	27	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	25	28	in	in	IN
47658	25	29	what	what	WP
47658	25	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	25	31	first	first	RB
47658	25	32	apprehended	apprehend	VBN
47658	25	33	as	as	IN
47658	25	34	simple	simple	JJ
47658	25	35	.	.	.
47658	26	1	The	the	DT
47658	26	2	atom	atom	NN
47658	26	3	of	of	IN
47658	26	4	hydrogen	hydrogen	NN
47658	26	5	,	,	,
47658	26	6	so	so	RB
47658	26	7	long	long	RB
47658	26	8	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	26	9	as	as	IN
47658	26	10	the	the	DT
47658	26	11	ideal	ideal	JJ
47658	26	12	limit	limit	NN
47658	26	13	of	of	IN
47658	26	14	simplicity	simplicity	NN
47658	26	15	,	,	,
47658	26	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	26	17	now	now	RB
47658	26	18	suspected	suspect	VBN
47658	26	19	to	to	TO
47658	26	20	be	be	VB
47658	26	21	not	not	RB
47658	26	22	the	the	DT
47658	26	23	lowest	low	JJS
47658	26	24	unit	unit	NN
47658	26	25	in	in	IN
47658	26	26	the	the	DT
47658	26	27	scale	scale	NN
47658	26	28	of	of	IN
47658	26	29	elements	element	NNS
47658	26	30	,	,	,
47658	26	31	and	and	CC
47658	26	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	26	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	26	34	no	no	RB
47658	26	35	longer	long	RBR
47658	26	36	conceived	conceive	VBN
47658	26	37	,	,	,
47658	26	38	as	as	IN
47658	26	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	26	40	used	use	VBD
47658	26	41	to	to	TO
47658	26	42	be	be	VB
47658	26	43	,	,	,
47658	26	44	as	as	IN
47658	26	45	structureless	structureless	NN
47658	26	46	,	,	,
47658	26	47	but	but	CC
47658	26	48	as	as	IN
47658	26	49	an	an	DT
47658	26	50	individual	individual	JJ
47658	26	51	system	system	NN
47658	26	52	,	,	,
47658	26	53	comparable	comparable	JJ
47658	26	54	to	to	IN
47658	26	55	a	a	DT
47658	26	56	solar	solar	JJ
47658	26	57	system	system	NN
47658	26	58	,	,	,
47658	26	59	of	of	IN
47658	26	60	electrical	electrical	JJ
47658	26	61	components	component	NNS
47658	26	62	preserving	preserve	VBG
47658	26	63	an	an	DT
47658	26	64	equilibrium	equilibrium	NN
47658	26	65	probably	probably	RB
47658	26	66	only	only	RB
47658	26	67	temporary	temporary	JJ
47658	26	68	.	.	.
47658	27	1	The	the	DT
47658	27	2	same	same	JJ
47658	27	3	tendency	tendency	NN
47658	27	4	to	to	TO
47658	27	5	discover	discover	VB
47658	27	6	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	27	7	in	in	IN
47658	27	8	what	what	WP
47658	27	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	27	10	first	first	RB
47658	27	11	apprehended	apprehend	VBN
47658	27	12	as	as	IN
47658	27	13	simple	simple	JJ
47658	27	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	27	15	evident	evident	JJ
47658	27	16	in	in	IN
47658	27	17	the	the	DT
47658	27	18	study	study	NN
47658	27	19	of	of	IN
47658	27	20	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	27	21	.	.	.
47658	28	1	The	the	DT
47658	28	2	more	more	RBR
47658	28	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	28	4	simple	simple	JJ
47658	28	5	and	and	CC
47658	28	6	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	28	7	notions	notion	NNS
47658	28	8	are	be	VBP
47658	28	9	submitted	submit	VBN
47658	28	10	to	to	IN
47658	28	11	analysis	analysis	NN
47658	28	12	,	,	,
47658	28	13	the	the	DT
47658	28	14	more	more	JJR
47658	28	15	are	be	VBP
47658	28	16	profound	profound	JJ
47658	28	17	problems	problem	NNS
47658	28	18	brought	bring	VBN
47658	28	19	to	to	IN
47658	28	20	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	28	21	.	.	.
47658	29	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	29	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	29	3	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	29	4	to	to	TO
47658	29	5	think	think	VB
47658	29	6	that	that	IN
47658	29	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	29	8	do	do	VBP
47658	29	9	not	not	RB
47658	29	10	know	know	VB
47658	29	11	what	what	WP
47658	29	12	such	such	PDT
47658	29	13	an	an	DT
47658	29	14	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	29	15	,	,	,
47658	29	16	simple	simple	JJ
47658	29	17	notion	notion	NN
47658	29	18	as	as	IN
47658	29	19	that	that	DT
47658	29	20	of	of	IN
47658	29	21	truth	truth	NN
47658	29	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	29	23	;	;	:
47658	29	24	yet	yet	CC
47658	29	25	the	the	DT
47658	29	26	attempt	attempt	NN
47658	29	27	to	to	TO
47658	29	28	give	give	VB
47658	29	29	a	a	DT
47658	29	30	definition	definition	NN
47658	29	31	of	of	IN
47658	29	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	29	33	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	29	34	brings	bring	VBZ
47658	29	35	quite	quite	RB
47658	29	36	unexpected	unexpected	JJ
47658	29	37	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
47658	29	38	to	to	IN
47658	29	39	light	light	NN
47658	29	40	,	,	,
47658	29	41	and	and	CC
47658	29	42	the	the	DT
47658	29	43	widest	wide	JJS
47658	29	44	divergence	divergence	NN
47658	29	45	at	at	IN
47658	29	46	the	the	DT
47658	29	47	present	present	JJ
47658	29	48	time	time	NN
47658	29	49	between	between	IN
47658	29	50	rival	rival	JJ
47658	29	51	principles	principle	NNS
47658	29	52	of	of	IN
47658	29	53	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	29	54	interpretation	interpretation	NN
47658	29	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	29	56	in	in	IN
47658	29	57	regard	regard	NN
47658	29	58	to	to	IN
47658	29	59	a	a	DT
47658	29	60	theory	theory	NN
47658	29	61	of	of	IN
47658	29	62	the	the	DT
47658	29	63	nature	nature	NN
47658	29	64	of	of	IN
47658	29	65	truth	truth	NN
47658	29	66	.	.	.
47658	30	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	30	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	30	3	not	not	RB
47658	30	4	a	a	DT
47658	30	5	problem	problem	NN
47658	30	6	that	that	WDT
47658	30	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	30	8	pressed	press	VBN
47658	30	9	on	on	IN
47658	30	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	30	11	by	by	IN
47658	30	12	any	any	DT
47658	30	13	felt	feel	VBN
47658	30	14	need	need	NN
47658	30	15	,	,	,
47658	30	16	nor	nor	CC
47658	30	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	30	18	anyone	anyone	NN
47658	30	19	who	who	WP
47658	30	20	does	do	VBZ
47658	30	21	not	not	RB
47658	30	22	feel	feel	VB
47658	30	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	30	24	interest	interest	NN
47658	30	25	called	call	VBN
47658	30	26	upon	upon	IN
47658	30	27	to	to	TO
47658	30	28	occupy	occupy	VB
47658	30	29	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	30	30	with	with	IN
47658	30	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	30	32	.	.	.
47658	31	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	31	2	speak	speak	VBP
47658	31	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	31	4	language	language	NN
47658	31	5	before	before	IN
47658	31	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	31	7	know	know	VBP
47658	31	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	31	9	{	{	-LRB-
47658	31	10	10	10	CD
47658	31	11	}	}	-RRB-
47658	31	12	grammar	grammar	NN
47658	31	13	,	,	,
47658	31	14	and	and	CC
47658	31	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	31	16	reason	reason	VBP
47658	31	17	just	just	RB
47658	31	18	as	as	RB
47658	31	19	well	well	RB
47658	31	20	whether	whether	IN
47658	31	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	31	22	have	have	VBP
47658	31	23	learnt	learn	VBN
47658	31	24	the	the	DT
47658	31	25	science	science	NN
47658	31	26	of	of	IN
47658	31	27	logic	logic	NN
47658	31	28	or	or	CC
47658	31	29	not	not	RB
47658	31	30	.	.	.
47658	32	1	This	this	DT
47658	32	2	science	science	NN
47658	32	3	of	of	IN
47658	32	4	Logic	logic	NN
47658	32	5	,	,	,
47658	32	6	or	or	CC
47658	32	7	,	,	,
47658	32	8	as	as	IN
47658	32	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	32	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	32	11	sometimes	sometimes	RB
47658	32	12	called	call	VBN
47658	32	13	,	,	,
47658	32	14	of	of	IN
47658	32	15	Formal	Formal	NNP
47658	32	16	Logic	Logic	NNP
47658	32	17	,	,	,
47658	32	18	was	be	VBD
47658	32	19	,	,	,
47658	32	20	until	until	IN
47658	32	21	modern	modern	JJ
47658	32	22	times	time	NNS
47658	32	23	,	,	,
47658	32	24	regarded	regard	VBD
47658	32	25	as	as	IN
47658	32	26	a	a	DT
47658	32	27	quite	quite	RB
47658	32	28	simple	simple	JJ
47658	32	29	account	account	NN
47658	32	30	of	of	IN
47658	32	31	the	the	DT
47658	32	32	principles	principle	NNS
47658	32	33	that	that	WDT
47658	32	34	govern	govern	VBP
47658	32	35	the	the	DT
47658	32	36	exercise	exercise	NN
47658	32	37	of	of	IN
47658	32	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	32	39	reasoning	reasoning	NN
47658	32	40	faculty	faculty	NN
47658	32	41	,	,	,
47658	32	42	and	and	CC
47658	32	43	of	of	IN
47658	32	44	the	the	DT
47658	32	45	rules	rule	NNS
47658	32	46	founded	found	VBN
47658	32	47	on	on	IN
47658	32	48	those	those	DT
47658	32	49	principles	principle	NNS
47658	32	50	by	by	IN
47658	32	51	following	follow	VBG
47658	32	52	which	which	WDT
47658	32	53	truth	truth	NN
47658	32	54	was	be	VBD
47658	32	55	attained	attain	VBN
47658	32	56	and	and	CC
47658	32	57	false	false	JJ
47658	32	58	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	32	59	or	or	CC
47658	32	60	error	error	NN
47658	32	61	avoided	avoid	VBD
47658	32	62	.	.	.
47658	33	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	33	2	was	be	VBD
47658	33	3	called	call	VBN
47658	33	4	formal	formal	JJ
47658	33	5	because	because	IN
47658	33	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	33	7	was	be	VBD
47658	33	8	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	33	9	to	to	TO
47658	33	10	have	have	VB
47658	33	11	no	no	DT
47658	33	12	relation	relation	NN
47658	33	13	to	to	IN
47658	33	14	the	the	DT
47658	33	15	matter	matter	NN
47658	33	16	of	of	IN
47658	33	17	the	the	DT
47658	33	18	subject	subject	NN
47658	33	19	reasoned	reason	VBN
47658	33	20	about	about	IN
47658	33	21	,	,	,
47658	33	22	but	but	CC
47658	33	23	only	only	RB
47658	33	24	to	to	IN
47658	33	25	the	the	DT
47658	33	26	form	form	NN
47658	33	27	which	which	WDT
47658	33	28	the	the	DT
47658	33	29	reasoning	reasoning	NN
47658	33	30	must	must	MD
47658	33	31	take	take	VB
47658	33	32	.	.	.
47658	34	1	A	a	DT
47658	34	2	complete	complete	JJ
47658	34	3	account	account	NN
47658	34	4	of	of	IN
47658	34	5	this	this	DT
47658	34	6	formal	formal	JJ
47658	34	7	science	science	NN
47658	34	8	,	,	,
47658	34	9	as	as	IN
47658	34	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	34	11	was	be	VBD
47658	34	12	recognised	recognise	VBN
47658	34	13	and	and	CC
47658	34	14	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	34	15	for	for	IN
47658	34	16	many	many	JJ
47658	34	17	ages	age	NNS
47658	34	18	,	,	,
47658	34	19	might	may	MD
47658	34	20	easily	easily	RB
47658	34	21	have	have	VB
47658	34	22	been	be	VBN
47658	34	23	set	set	VBN
47658	34	24	forth	forth	RB
47658	34	25	within	within	IN
47658	34	26	the	the	DT
47658	34	27	limits	limit	NNS
47658	34	28	of	of	IN
47658	34	29	a	a	DT
47658	34	30	small	small	JJ
47658	34	31	volume	volume	NN
47658	34	32	such	such	JJ
47658	34	33	as	as	IN
47658	34	34	this	this	DT
47658	34	35	.	.	.
47658	35	1	But	but	CC
47658	35	2	the	the	DT
47658	35	3	development	development	NN
47658	35	4	of	of	IN
47658	35	5	modern	modern	JJ
47658	35	6	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	35	7	has	have	VBZ
47658	35	8	wrought	work	VBN
47658	35	9	an	an	DT
47658	35	10	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
47658	35	11	change	change	NN
47658	35	12	.	.	.
47658	36	1	Anyone	anyone	NN
47658	36	2	now	now	RB
47658	36	3	who	who	WP
47658	36	4	will	will	MD
47658	36	5	set	set	VB
47658	36	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	36	7	the	the	DT
47658	36	8	task	task	NN
47658	36	9	of	of	IN
47658	36	10	mastering	master	VBG
47658	36	11	all	all	PDT
47658	36	12	the	the	DT
47658	36	13	problems	problem	NNS
47658	36	14	that	that	WDT
47658	36	15	have	have	VBP
47658	36	16	been	be	VBN
47658	36	17	raised	raise	VBN
47658	36	18	round	round	IN
47658	36	19	the	the	DT
47658	36	20	question	question	NN
47658	36	21	of	of	IN
47658	36	22	the	the	DT
47658	36	23	nature	nature	NN
47658	36	24	of	of	IN
47658	36	25	logical	logical	JJ
47658	36	26	process	process	NN
47658	36	27	,	,	,
47658	36	28	will	will	MD
47658	36	29	find	find	VB
47658	36	30	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	36	31	confronted	confront	VBN
47658	36	32	with	with	IN
47658	36	33	a	a	DT
47658	36	34	vast	vast	JJ
47658	36	35	library	library	NN
47658	36	36	of	of	IN
47658	36	37	special	special	JJ
47658	36	38	treatises	treatise	NNS
47658	36	39	,	,	,
47658	36	40	and	and	CC
47658	36	41	involved	involve	VBN
47658	36	42	in	in	IN
47658	36	43	discussions	discussion	NNS
47658	36	44	that	that	WDT
47658	36	45	embrace	embrace	VBP
47658	36	46	the	the	DT
47658	36	47	whole	whole	NN
47658	36	48	of	of	IN
47658	36	49	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	36	50	.	.	.
47658	37	1	The	the	DT
47658	37	2	special	special	JJ
47658	37	3	problem	problem	NN
47658	37	4	of	of	IN
47658	37	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	37	6	that	that	IN
47658	37	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	37	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	37	9	the	the	DT
47658	37	10	object	object	NN
47658	37	11	of	of	IN
47658	37	12	this	this	DT
47658	37	13	little	little	JJ
47658	37	14	volume	volume	NN
47658	37	15	to	to	TO
47658	37	16	explain	explain	VB
47658	37	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	37	18	a	a	DT
47658	37	19	quite	quite	RB
47658	37	20	modern	modern	JJ
47658	37	21	question	question	NN
47658	37	22	.	.	.
47658	38	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	38	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	38	3	been	be	VBN
47658	38	4	raised	raise	VBN
47658	38	5	within	within	IN
47658	38	6	the	the	DT
47658	38	7	present	present	JJ
47658	38	8	generation	generation	NN
47658	38	9	of	of	IN
47658	38	10	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	38	11	writers	writer	NNS
47658	38	12	,	,	,
47658	38	13	and	and	CC
47658	38	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	38	15	to	to	IN
47658	38	16	-	-	HYPH
47658	38	17	day	day	NN
47658	38	18	,	,	,
47658	38	19	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	38	20	,	,	,
47658	38	21	the	the	DT
47658	38	22	chief	chief	JJ
47658	38	23	controversy	controversy	NN
47658	38	24	in	in	IN
47658	38	25	which	which	WDT
47658	38	26	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	38	27	are	be	VBP
47658	38	28	engaged	engage	VBN
47658	38	29	.	.	.
47658	39	1	But	but	CC
47658	39	2	although	although	IN
47658	39	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	39	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	39	5	only	only	RB
47658	39	6	in	in	IN
47658	39	7	the	the	DT
47658	39	8	last	last	JJ
47658	39	9	few	few	JJ
47658	39	10	years	year	NNS
47658	39	11	that	that	WDT
47658	39	12	controversy	controversy	NN
47658	39	13	has	have	VBZ
47658	39	14	been	be	VBN
47658	39	15	aroused	arouse	VBN
47658	39	16	on	on	IN
47658	39	17	this	this	DT
47658	39	18	question	question	NN
47658	39	19	,	,	,
47658	39	20	the	the	DT
47658	39	21	problem	problem	NN
47658	39	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	39	23	not	not	RB
47658	39	24	new	new	JJ
47658	39	25	--	--	:
47658	39	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	39	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	39	28	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	39	29	as	as	RB
47658	39	30	old	old	JJ
47658	39	31	as	as	IN
47658	39	32	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	39	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	39	34	.	.	.
47658	40	1	In	in	IN
47658	40	2	the	the	DT
47658	40	3	fifth	fifth	JJ
47658	40	4	century	century	NN
47658	40	5	before	before	IN
47658	40	6	Christ	Christ	NNP
47658	40	7	,	,	,
47658	40	8	and	and	CC
47658	40	9	in	in	IN
47658	40	10	the	the	DT
47658	40	11	generation	generation	NN
47658	40	12	that	that	WDT
47658	40	13	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	40	14	preceded	precede	VBD
47658	40	15	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
47658	40	16	,	,	,
47658	40	17	a	a	DT
47658	40	18	famous	famous	JJ
47658	40	19	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	40	20	,	,	,
47658	40	21	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	40	22	(	(	-LRB-
47658	40	23	481	481	CD
47658	40	24	-	-	CD
47658	40	25	411	411	CD
47658	40	26	B.C.	B.C.	NNP
47658	40	27	)	)	-RRB-
47658	41	1	published	publish	VBN
47658	41	2	a	a	DT
47658	41	3	book	book	NN
47658	41	4	with	with	IN
47658	41	5	the	the	DT
47658	41	6	title	title	NN
47658	41	7	_	_	NNP
47658	41	8	The	the	DT
47658	41	9	Truth	Truth	NNP
47658	41	10	_	_	NNP
47658	41	11	.	.	.
47658	42	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	42	2	had	have	VBD
47658	42	3	the	the	DT
47658	42	4	misfortune	misfortune	NN
47658	42	5	,	,	,
47658	42	6	common	common	JJ
47658	42	7	at	at	IN
47658	42	8	that	that	DT
47658	42	9	time	time	NN
47658	42	10	,	,	,
47658	42	11	to	to	TO
47658	42	12	offend	offend	VB
47658	42	13	the	the	DT
47658	42	14	religious	religious	JJ
47658	42	15	Athenians	Athenians	NNPS
47658	42	16	,	,	,
47658	42	17	{	{	-LRB-
47658	42	18	11	11	CD
47658	42	19	}	}	-RRB-
47658	42	20	for	for	IN
47658	42	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	42	22	spoke	speak	VBD
47658	42	23	slightingly	slightingly	RB
47658	42	24	of	of	IN
47658	42	25	the	the	DT
47658	42	26	gods	god	NNS
47658	42	27	,	,	,
47658	42	28	proposing	propose	VBG
47658	42	29	to	to	TO
47658	42	30	"	"	``
47658	42	31	banish	banish	VB
47658	42	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	42	33	existence	existence	NN
47658	42	34	or	or	CC
47658	42	35	non	non	NN
47658	42	36	-	-	JJ
47658	42	37	existence	existence	NN
47658	42	38	from	from	IN
47658	42	39	writing	writing	NN
47658	42	40	and	and	CC
47658	42	41	speech	speech	NN
47658	42	42	.	.	.
47658	42	43	"	"	''
47658	43	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	43	2	was	be	VBD
47658	43	3	convicted	convict	VBN
47658	43	4	of	of	IN
47658	43	5	atheism	atheism	NN
47658	43	6	,	,	,
47658	43	7	and	and	CC
47658	43	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	43	9	books	book	NNS
47658	43	10	were	be	VBD
47658	43	11	publicly	publicly	RB
47658	43	12	burnt	burn	VBN
47658	43	13	,	,	,
47658	43	14	and	and	CC
47658	43	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	43	16	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	43	17	,	,	,
47658	43	18	then	then	RB
47658	43	19	seventy	seventy	CD
47658	43	20	years	year	NNS
47658	43	21	of	of	IN
47658	43	22	age	age	NN
47658	43	23	,	,	,
47658	43	24	was	be	VBD
47658	43	25	either	either	CC
47658	43	26	banished	banish	VBN
47658	43	27	or	or	CC
47658	43	28	at	at	IN
47658	43	29	least	least	JJS
47658	43	30	was	be	VBD
47658	43	31	obliged	oblige	VBN
47658	43	32	to	to	TO
47658	43	33	flee	flee	VB
47658	43	34	from	from	IN
47658	43	35	Athens	Athens	NNP
47658	43	36	,	,	,
47658	43	37	and	and	CC
47658	43	38	on	on	IN
47658	43	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	43	40	way	way	NN
47658	43	41	to	to	IN
47658	43	42	Sicily	Sicily	NNP
47658	43	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	43	44	lost	lose	VBD
47658	43	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	43	46	life	life	NN
47658	43	47	in	in	IN
47658	43	48	a	a	DT
47658	43	49	shipwreck	shipwreck	NN
47658	43	50	.	.	.
47658	44	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	44	2	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	44	3	of	of	IN
47658	44	4	this	this	DT
47658	44	5	book	book	NN
47658	44	6	of	of	IN
47658	44	7	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	44	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	44	9	due	due	JJ
47658	44	10	to	to	IN
47658	44	11	the	the	DT
47658	44	12	preservation	preservation	NN
47658	44	13	of	of	IN
47658	44	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	44	15	argument	argument	NN
47658	44	16	by	by	IN
47658	44	17	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	44	18	in	in	IN
47658	44	19	the	the	DT
47658	44	20	dialogue	dialogue	NN
47658	44	21	"	"	``
47658	44	22	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	44	23	.	.	.
47658	44	24	"	"	''
47658	45	1	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	45	2	,	,	,
47658	45	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	45	4	are	be	VBP
47658	45	5	there	there	RB
47658	45	6	told	tell	VBN
47658	45	7	,	,	,
47658	45	8	taught	teach	VBD
47658	45	9	that	that	IN
47658	45	10	"	"	``
47658	45	11	man	man	NN
47658	45	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	45	13	the	the	DT
47658	45	14	measure	measure	NN
47658	45	15	of	of	IN
47658	45	16	all	all	DT
47658	45	17	things	thing	NNS
47658	45	18	--	--	:
47658	45	19	of	of	IN
47658	45	20	the	the	DT
47658	45	21	existence	existence	NN
47658	45	22	of	of	IN
47658	45	23	things	thing	NNS
47658	45	24	that	that	WDT
47658	45	25	are	be	VBP
47658	45	26	,	,	,
47658	45	27	and	and	CC
47658	45	28	of	of	IN
47658	45	29	the	the	DT
47658	45	30	non	non	JJ
47658	45	31	-	-	NN
47658	45	32	existence	existence	NN
47658	45	33	of	of	IN
47658	45	34	things	thing	NNS
47658	45	35	that	that	WDT
47658	45	36	are	be	VBP
47658	45	37	not	not	RB
47658	45	38	.	.	.
47658	45	39	"	"	''
47658	46	1	"	"	``
47658	46	2	You	-PRON-	PRP
47658	46	3	have	have	VBP
47658	46	4	read	read	VBN
47658	46	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	46	6	?	?	.
47658	46	7	"	"	''
47658	47	1	asks	ask	VBZ
47658	47	2	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
47658	47	3	,	,	,
47658	47	4	addressing	address	VBG
47658	47	5	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	47	6	.	.	.
47658	48	1	"	"	``
47658	48	2	Oh	oh	UH
47658	48	3	yes	yes	UH
47658	48	4	,	,	,
47658	48	5	again	again	RB
47658	48	6	and	and	CC
47658	48	7	again	again	RB
47658	48	8	,	,	,
47658	48	9	"	"	''
47658	48	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	48	11	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	48	12	'	'	POS
47658	48	13	reply	reply	NN
47658	48	14	.	.	.
47658	49	1	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	49	2	was	be	VBD
47658	49	3	entirely	entirely	RB
47658	49	4	opposed	oppose	VBN
47658	49	5	to	to	IN
47658	49	6	the	the	DT
47658	49	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	49	8	that	that	IN
47658	49	9	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	49	10	taught	teach	VBD
47658	49	11	.	.	.
47658	50	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	50	2	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	50	3	to	to	IN
47658	50	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	50	5	to	to	TO
47658	50	6	bring	bring	VB
47658	50	7	gods	god	NNS
47658	50	8	and	and	CC
47658	50	9	men	man	NNS
47658	50	10	and	and	CC
47658	50	11	tadpoles	tadpole	NNS
47658	50	12	to	to	IN
47658	50	13	one	one	CD
47658	50	14	level	level	NN
47658	50	15	as	as	RB
47658	50	16	far	far	RB
47658	50	17	as	as	IN
47658	50	18	truth	truth	NN
47658	50	19	was	be	VBD
47658	50	20	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	50	21	;	;	:
47658	50	22	for	for	IN
47658	50	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	50	24	drew	draw	VBD
47658	50	25	the	the	DT
47658	50	26	deduction	deduction	NN
47658	50	27	that	that	IN
47658	50	28	if	if	IN
47658	50	29	man	man	NN
47658	50	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	50	31	the	the	DT
47658	50	32	measure	measure	NN
47658	50	33	of	of	IN
47658	50	34	all	all	DT
47658	50	35	things	thing	NNS
47658	50	36	,	,	,
47658	50	37	then	then	RB
47658	50	38	to	to	IN
47658	50	39	each	each	DT
47658	50	40	man	man	NN
47658	50	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	50	42	own	own	JJ
47658	50	43	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	50	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	50	45	right	right	JJ
47658	50	46	.	.	.
47658	51	1	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	51	2	opposed	oppose	VBD
47658	51	3	to	to	IN
47658	51	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	51	5	the	the	DT
47658	51	6	theory	theory	NN
47658	51	7	that	that	IN
47658	51	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	51	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	51	10	the	the	DT
47658	51	11	vision	vision	NN
47658	51	12	of	of	IN
47658	51	13	a	a	DT
47658	51	14	pure	pure	JJ
47658	51	15	objective	objective	JJ
47658	51	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	51	17	.	.	.
47658	52	1	This	this	DT
47658	52	2	same	same	JJ
47658	52	3	problem	problem	NN
47658	52	4	that	that	WDT
47658	52	5	exercised	exercise	VBD
47658	52	6	the	the	DT
47658	52	7	ancient	ancient	JJ
47658	52	8	world	world	NN
47658	52	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	52	10	now	now	RB
47658	52	11	again	again	RB
47658	52	12	a	a	DT
47658	52	13	chief	chief	JJ
47658	52	14	centre	centre	NN
47658	52	15	of	of	IN
47658	52	16	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	52	17	interest	interest	NN
47658	52	18	,	,	,
47658	52	19	and	and	CC
47658	52	20	the	the	DT
47658	52	21	aim	aim	NN
47658	52	22	of	of	IN
47658	52	23	this	this	DT
47658	52	24	little	little	JJ
47658	52	25	book	book	NN
47658	52	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	52	27	not	not	RB
47658	52	28	to	to	TO
47658	52	29	decide	decide	VB
47658	52	30	that	that	DT
47658	52	31	question	question	NN
47658	52	32	,	,	,
47658	52	33	but	but	CC
47658	52	34	to	to	TO
47658	52	35	serve	serve	VB
47658	52	36	as	as	IN
47658	52	37	a	a	DT
47658	52	38	guide	guide	NN
47658	52	39	and	and	CC
47658	52	40	introduction	introduction	NN
47658	52	41	to	to	IN
47658	52	42	those	those	DT
47658	52	43	who	who	WP
47658	52	44	desire	desire	VBP
47658	52	45	to	to	TO
47658	52	46	know	know	VB
47658	52	47	what	what	WP
47658	52	48	the	the	DT
47658	52	49	question	question	NN
47658	52	50	is	be	VBZ
47658	52	51	that	that	IN
47658	52	52	divides	divide	VBZ
47658	52	53	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	52	54	to	to	IN
47658	52	55	-	-	HYPH
47658	52	56	day	day	NN
47658	52	57	into	into	IN
47658	52	58	the	the	DT
47658	52	59	hostile	hostile	JJ
47658	52	60	camps	camp	NNS
47658	52	61	of	of	IN
47658	52	62	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	52	63	and	and	CC
47658	52	64	intellectualism	intellectualism	NN
47658	52	65	.	.	.
47658	53	1	The	the	DT
47658	53	2	subject	subject	NN
47658	53	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	53	4	not	not	RB
47658	53	5	likely	likely	JJ
47658	53	6	to	to	TO
47658	53	7	interest	interest	VB
47658	53	8	anyone	anyone	NN
47658	53	9	who	who	WP
47658	53	10	does	do	VBZ
47658	53	11	not	not	RB
47658	53	12	care	care	VB
47658	53	13	for	for	IN
47658	53	14	the	the	DT
47658	53	15	study	study	NN
47658	53	16	of	of	IN
47658	53	17	the	the	DT
47658	53	18	exact	exact	JJ
47658	53	19	definitions	definition	NNS
47658	53	20	and	and	CC
47658	53	21	abstract	abstract	JJ
47658	53	22	principles	principle	NNS
47658	53	23	that	that	WDT
47658	53	24	lie	lie	VBP
47658	53	25	at	at	IN
47658	53	26	the	the	DT
47658	53	27	basis	basis	NN
47658	53	28	of	of	IN
47658	53	29	science	science	NN
47658	53	30	and	and	CC
47658	53	31	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	53	32	.	.	.
47658	54	1	There	there	EX
47658	54	2	are	be	VBP
47658	54	3	many	many	JJ
47658	54	4	who	who	WP
47658	54	5	are	be	VBP
47658	54	6	engaged	engage	VBN
47658	54	7	in	in	IN
47658	54	8	the	the	DT
47658	54	9	study	study	NN
47658	54	10	of	of	IN
47658	54	11	the	the	DT
47658	54	12	physical	physical	JJ
47658	54	13	and	and	CC
47658	54	14	natural	natural	JJ
47658	54	15	sciences	science	NNS
47658	54	16	,	,	,
47658	54	17	and	and	CC
47658	54	18	also	also	RB
47658	54	19	many	many	JJ
47658	54	20	who	who	WP
47658	54	21	devote	devote	VBP
47658	54	22	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	54	23	to	to	IN
47658	54	24	the	the	DT
47658	54	25	social	social	JJ
47658	54	26	and	and	CC
47658	54	27	political	political	JJ
47658	54	28	{	{	-LRB-
47658	54	29	12	12	CD
47658	54	30	}	}	-RRB-
47658	54	31	sciences	science	NNS
47658	54	32	,	,	,
47658	54	33	who	who	WP
47658	54	34	hold	hold	VBP
47658	54	35	in	in	RP
47658	54	36	profound	profound	JJ
47658	54	37	contempt	contempt	NN
47658	54	38	the	the	DT
47658	54	39	fine	fine	JJ
47658	54	40	distinctions	distinction	NNS
47658	54	41	and	and	CC
47658	54	42	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	54	43	subtleties	subtlety	NNS
47658	54	44	that	that	WDT
47658	54	45	seem	seem	VBP
47658	54	46	to	to	IN
47658	54	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	54	48	the	the	DT
47658	54	49	whole	whole	JJ
47658	54	50	content	content	NN
47658	54	51	of	of	IN
47658	54	52	logic	logic	NN
47658	54	53	and	and	CC
47658	54	54	metaphysic	metaphysic	NN
47658	54	55	.	.	.
47658	55	1	The	the	DT
47658	55	2	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	55	3	of	of	IN
47658	55	4	the	the	DT
47658	55	5	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	55	6	mind	mind	NN
47658	55	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	55	8	not	not	RB
47658	55	9	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	55	10	to	to	TO
47658	55	11	understand	understand	VB
47658	55	12	.	.	.
47658	56	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	56	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	56	3	recently	recently	RB
47658	56	4	been	be	VBN
47658	56	5	rather	rather	RB
47658	56	6	graphically	graphically	RB
47658	56	7	expressed	express	VBN
47658	56	8	by	by	IN
47658	56	9	a	a	DT
47658	56	10	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
47658	56	11	and	and	CC
47658	56	12	popular	popular	JJ
47658	56	13	exponent	exponent	NN
47658	56	14	of	of	IN
47658	56	15	the	the	DT
47658	56	16	principles	principle	NNS
47658	56	17	of	of	IN
47658	56	18	natural	natural	JJ
47658	56	19	science	science	NN
47658	56	20	.	.	.
47658	57	1	"	"	``
47658	57	2	One	one	PRP
47658	57	3	may	may	MD
47658	57	4	regard	regard	VB
47658	57	5	the	the	DT
47658	57	6	utmost	utmost	JJ
47658	57	7	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	57	8	of	of	IN
47658	57	9	the	the	DT
47658	57	10	results	result	NNS
47658	57	11	of	of	IN
47658	57	12	human	human	JJ
47658	57	13	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	57	14	as	as	IN
47658	57	15	the	the	DT
47658	57	16	contents	content	NNS
47658	57	17	of	of	IN
47658	57	18	a	a	DT
47658	57	19	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	57	20	,	,	,
47658	57	21	and	and	CC
47658	57	22	place	place	NN
47658	57	23	outside	outside	IN
47658	57	24	the	the	DT
47658	57	25	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	57	26	the	the	DT
47658	57	27	factor	factor	NN
47658	57	28	_	_	NNP
47658	57	29	x	x	NNP
47658	57	30	_	_	NNP
47658	57	31	to	to	TO
47658	57	32	represent	represent	VB
47658	57	33	those	those	DT
47658	57	34	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	57	35	and	and	CC
47658	57	36	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	57	37	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	57	38	which	which	WDT
47658	57	39	the	the	DT
47658	57	40	imagination	imagination	NN
47658	57	41	of	of	IN
47658	57	42	man	man	NN
47658	57	43	is	be	VBZ
47658	57	44	never	never	RB
47658	57	45	wearied	weary	VBN
47658	57	46	of	of	IN
47658	57	47	suggesting	suggest	VBG
47658	57	48	.	.	.
47658	58	1	This	this	DT
47658	58	2	factor	factor	NN
47658	58	3	_	_	NNP
47658	58	4	x	x	NNP
47658	58	5	_	_	NNP
47658	58	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	58	7	the	the	DT
47658	58	8	plaything	plaything	NN
47658	58	9	of	of	IN
47658	58	10	the	the	DT
47658	58	11	metaphysician	metaphysician	NN
47658	58	12	.	.	.
47658	59	1	"	"	``
47658	59	2	[	[	-LRB-
47658	59	3	1	1	LS
47658	59	4	]	]	-RRB-
47658	59	5	This	this	DT
47658	59	6	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
47658	59	7	symbol	symbol	NN
47658	59	8	of	of	IN
47658	59	9	the	the	DT
47658	59	10	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	59	11	,	,	,
47658	59	12	multiplied	multiply	VBN
47658	59	13	by	by	IN
47658	59	14	_	_	NNP
47658	59	15	x	x	NNP
47658	59	16	_	_	NNP
47658	59	17	to	to	TO
47658	59	18	represent	represent	VB
47658	59	19	the	the	DT
47658	59	20	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	59	21	and	and	CC
47658	59	22	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	59	23	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	59	24	beyond	beyond	IN
47658	59	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	59	26	,	,	,
47658	59	27	will	will	MD
47658	59	28	serve	serve	VB
47658	59	29	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	59	30	to	to	TO
47658	59	31	indicate	indicate	VB
47658	59	32	with	with	IN
47658	59	33	some	some	DT
47658	59	34	exactness	exactness	NN
47658	59	35	the	the	DT
47658	59	36	problem	problem	NN
47658	59	37	with	with	IN
47658	59	38	which	which	WDT
47658	59	39	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	59	40	am	be	VBP
47658	59	41	going	go	VBG
47658	59	42	to	to	TO
47658	59	43	deal	deal	VB
47658	59	44	.	.	.
47658	60	1	The	the	DT
47658	60	2	symbol	symbol	NN
47658	60	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	60	4	an	an	DT
47658	60	5	expression	expression	NN
47658	60	6	of	of	IN
47658	60	7	the	the	DT
47658	60	8	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
47658	60	9	position	position	NN
47658	60	10	.	.	.
47658	61	1	The	the	DT
47658	61	2	popular	popular	JJ
47658	61	3	caricature	caricature	NN
47658	61	4	of	of	IN
47658	61	5	the	the	DT
47658	61	6	metaphysician	metaphysician	NN
47658	61	7	and	and	CC
47658	61	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	61	9	"	"	``
47658	61	10	plaything	playthe	VBG
47658	61	11	"	"	''
47658	61	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	61	13	may	may	MD
47658	61	14	disregard	disregard	VB
47658	61	15	as	as	IN
47658	61	16	a	a	DT
47658	61	17	pure	pure	JJ
47658	61	18	fiction	fiction	NN
47658	61	19	.	.	.
47658	62	1	The	the	DT
47658	62	2	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	62	3	_	_	NNP
47658	62	4	x	x	NNP
47658	62	5	_	_	NNP
47658	62	6	of	of	IN
47658	62	7	the	the	DT
47658	62	8	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
47658	62	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	62	10	not	not	RB
47658	62	11	the	the	DT
47658	62	12	"	"	``
47658	62	13	meta	meta	JJ
47658	62	14	"	"	''
47658	62	15	or	or	CC
47658	62	16	"	"	``
47658	62	17	beyond	beyond	IN
47658	62	18	"	"	''
47658	62	19	of	of	IN
47658	62	20	physics	physics	NN
47658	62	21	which	which	WDT
47658	62	22	the	the	DT
47658	62	23	metaphysician	metaphysician	NN
47658	62	24	vainly	vainly	RB
47658	62	25	seeks	seek	VBZ
47658	62	26	to	to	TO
47658	62	27	know	know	VB
47658	62	28	.	.	.
47658	63	1	The	the	DT
47658	63	2	only	only	JJ
47658	63	3	"	"	''
47658	63	4	beyond	beyond	IN
47658	63	5	"	"	''
47658	63	6	of	of	IN
47658	63	7	physics	physics	NN
47658	63	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	63	9	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	63	10	or	or	CC
47658	63	11	experience	experience	VBP
47658	63	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	63	13	,	,	,
47658	63	14	and	and	CC
47658	63	15	this	this	DT
47658	63	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	63	17	the	the	DT
47658	63	18	subject	subject	NN
47658	63	19	-	-	HYPH
47658	63	20	matter	matter	NN
47658	63	21	of	of	IN
47658	63	22	metaphysics	metaphysic	NNS
47658	63	23	.	.	.
47658	64	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	64	2	present	present	JJ
47658	64	3	problem	problem	NN
47658	64	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	64	5	that	that	DT
47658	64	6	of	of	IN
47658	64	7	the	the	DT
47658	64	8	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	64	9	,	,	,
47658	64	10	not	not	RB
47658	64	11	that	that	DT
47658	64	12	of	of	IN
47658	64	13	the	the	DT
47658	64	14	factor	factor	NN
47658	64	15	outside	outside	RB
47658	64	16	,	,	,
47658	64	17	if	if	IN
47658	64	18	there	there	EX
47658	64	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	64	20	any	any	DT
47658	64	21	such	such	JJ
47658	64	22	factor	factor	NN
47658	64	23	,	,	,
47658	64	24	nor	nor	CC
47658	64	25	yet	yet	RB
47658	64	26	the	the	DT
47658	64	27	particular	particular	JJ
47658	64	28	nature	nature	NN
47658	64	29	of	of	IN
47658	64	30	the	the	DT
47658	64	31	contents	content	NNS
47658	64	32	within	within	RB
47658	64	33	.	.	.
47658	65	1	There	there	EX
47658	65	2	are	be	VBP
47658	65	3	,	,	,
47658	65	4	as	as	IN
47658	65	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	65	6	shall	shall	MD
47658	65	7	see	see	VB
47658	65	8	,	,	,
47658	65	9	three	three	CD
47658	65	10	views	view	NNS
47658	65	11	that	that	WDT
47658	65	12	are	be	VBP
47658	65	13	possible	possible	JJ
47658	65	14	of	of	IN
47658	65	15	the	the	DT
47658	65	16	nature	nature	NN
47658	65	17	of	of	IN
47658	65	18	the	the	DT
47658	65	19	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	65	20	.	.	.
47658	66	1	In	in	IN
47658	66	2	one	one	CD
47658	66	3	view	view	NN
47658	66	4	,	,	,
47658	66	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	66	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	66	7	merely	merely	RB
47658	66	8	the	the	DT
47658	66	9	conception	conception	NN
47658	66	10	of	of	IN
47658	66	11	the	the	DT
47658	66	12	extent	extent	NN
47658	66	13	which	which	WDT
47658	66	14	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	66	15	has	have	VBZ
47658	66	16	attained	attain	VBN
47658	66	17	or	or	CC
47658	66	18	can	can	MD
47658	66	19	attain	attain	VB
47658	66	20	;	;	:
47658	66	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	66	22	has	have	VBZ
47658	66	23	no	no	DT
47658	66	24	intimate	intimate	JJ
47658	66	25	relation	relation	NN
47658	66	26	to	to	IN
47658	66	27	the	the	DT
47658	66	28	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	66	29	,	,	,
47658	66	30	but	but	CC
47658	66	31	marks	mark	NNS
47658	66	32	externally	externally	RB
47658	66	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	66	34	limit	limit	NN
47658	66	35	.	.	.
47658	67	1	This	this	DT
47658	67	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	67	3	the	the	DT
47658	67	4	view	view	NN
47658	67	5	of	of	IN
47658	67	6	the	the	DT
47658	67	7	realist	realist	NN
47658	67	8	.	.	.
47658	68	1	In	in	IN
47658	68	2	another	another	DT
47658	68	3	view	view	NN
47658	68	4	,	,	,
47658	68	5	the	the	DT
47658	68	6	whole	whole	NN
47658	68	7	of	of	IN
47658	68	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	68	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	68	10	intimately	intimately	RB
47658	68	11	related	relate	VBN
47658	68	12	{	{	-LRB-
47658	68	13	13	13	CD
47658	68	14	}	}	-RRB-
47658	68	15	to	to	IN
47658	68	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	68	17	particular	particular	JJ
47658	68	18	parts	part	NNS
47658	68	19	;	;	:
47658	68	20	the	the	DT
47658	68	21	things	thing	NNS
47658	68	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	68	23	know	know	VBP
47658	68	24	are	be	VBP
47658	68	25	not	not	RB
47658	68	26	a	a	DT
47658	68	27	mere	mere	JJ
47658	68	28	collection	collection	NN
47658	68	29	or	or	CC
47658	68	30	aggregate	aggregate	NN
47658	68	31	of	of	IN
47658	68	32	independent	independent	JJ
47658	68	33	facts	fact	NNS
47658	68	34	that	that	WDT
47658	68	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	68	36	have	have	VBP
47658	68	37	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	68	38	;	;	:
47658	68	39	the	the	DT
47658	68	40	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	68	41	which	which	WDT
47658	68	42	contains	contain	VBZ
47658	68	43	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	68	44	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	68	45	gives	give	VBZ
47658	68	46	form	form	NN
47658	68	47	to	to	IN
47658	68	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	68	49	,	,	,
47658	68	50	and	and	CC
47658	68	51	relates	relate	VBZ
47658	68	52	organically	organically	RB
47658	68	53	the	the	DT
47658	68	54	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	68	55	parts	part	NNS
47658	68	56	to	to	IN
47658	68	57	the	the	DT
47658	68	58	whole	whole	NN
47658	68	59	in	in	IN
47658	68	60	one	one	CD
47658	68	61	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
47658	68	62	individual	individual	JJ
47658	68	63	system	system	NN
47658	68	64	.	.	.
47658	69	1	This	this	DT
47658	69	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	69	3	the	the	DT
47658	69	4	view	view	NN
47658	69	5	of	of	IN
47658	69	6	the	the	DT
47658	69	7	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	69	8	.	.	.
47658	70	1	There	there	EX
47658	70	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	3	yet	yet	RB
47658	70	4	another	another	DT
47658	70	5	view	view	NN
47658	70	6	:	:	:
47658	70	7	human	human	JJ
47658	70	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	70	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	10	relative	relative	JJ
47658	70	11	to	to	IN
47658	70	12	human	human	JJ
47658	70	13	activity	activity	NN
47658	70	14	and	and	CC
47658	70	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	70	16	needs	need	NNS
47658	70	17	;	;	:
47658	70	18	the	the	DT
47658	70	19	bracket	bracket	NN
47658	70	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	21	the	the	DT
47658	70	22	ever	ever	RB
47658	70	23	-	-	HYPH
47658	70	24	changing	change	VBG
47658	70	25	limit	limit	NN
47658	70	26	of	of	IN
47658	70	27	that	that	DT
47658	70	28	activity	activity	NN
47658	70	29	--	--	:
47658	70	30	within	within	IN
47658	70	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	70	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	33	all	all	DT
47658	70	34	that	that	WDT
47658	70	35	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	36	relevant	relevant	JJ
47658	70	37	to	to	IN
47658	70	38	human	human	JJ
47658	70	39	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	70	40	and	and	CC
47658	70	41	personality	personality	NN
47658	70	42	without	without	IN
47658	70	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	70	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	45	all	all	DT
47658	70	46	that	that	WDT
47658	70	47	is	be	VBZ
47658	70	48	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	70	49	.	.	.
47658	71	1	This	this	DT
47658	71	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	71	3	the	the	DT
47658	71	4	view	view	NN
47658	71	5	of	of	IN
47658	71	6	the	the	DT
47658	71	7	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	71	8	.	.	.
47658	72	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	72	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	72	3	not	not	RB
47658	72	4	only	only	RB
47658	72	5	the	the	DT
47658	72	6	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	72	7	mind	mind	NN
47658	72	8	,	,	,
47658	72	9	but	but	CC
47658	72	10	also	also	RB
47658	72	11	the	the	DT
47658	72	12	ethical	ethical	JJ
47658	72	13	and	and	CC
47658	72	14	religious	religious	JJ
47658	72	15	mind	mind	NN
47658	72	16	,	,	,
47658	72	17	that	that	DT
47658	72	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	72	19	likely	likely	JJ
47658	72	20	to	to	TO
47658	72	21	be	be	VB
47658	72	22	at	at	IN
47658	72	23	least	least	JJS
47658	72	24	impatient	impatient	JJ
47658	72	25	,	,	,
47658	72	26	if	if	IN
47658	72	27	not	not	RB
47658	72	28	contemptuous	contemptuous	JJ
47658	72	29	,	,	,
47658	72	30	of	of	IN
47658	72	31	this	this	DT
47658	72	32	inquiry	inquiry	NN
47658	72	33	.	.	.
47658	73	1	The	the	DT
47658	73	2	question	question	NN
47658	73	3	What	what	WP
47658	73	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	73	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	73	6	?	?	.
47658	74	1	will	will	MD
47658	74	2	probably	probably	RB
47658	74	3	bring	bring	VB
47658	74	4	to	to	IN
47658	74	5	everyone	everyone	NN
47658	74	6	's	's	POS
47658	74	7	mind	mind	NN
47658	74	8	the	the	DT
47658	74	9	words	word	NNS
47658	74	10	uttered	utter	VBN
47658	74	11	by	by	IN
47658	74	12	a	a	DT
47658	74	13	Roman	Roman	NNP
47658	74	14	Procurator	Procurator	NNP
47658	74	15	at	at	IN
47658	74	16	the	the	DT
47658	74	17	supreme	supreme	JJ
47658	74	18	moment	moment	NN
47658	74	19	of	of	IN
47658	74	20	a	a	DT
47658	74	21	great	great	JJ
47658	74	22	world	world	NN
47658	74	23	-	-	HYPH
47658	74	24	tragedy	tragedy	NN
47658	74	25	.	.	.
47658	75	1	Pilate	Pilate	NNP
47658	75	2	's	's	POS
47658	75	3	question	question	NN
47658	75	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	75	5	usually	usually	RB
47658	75	6	interpreted	interpret	VBN
47658	75	7	as	as	IN
47658	75	8	the	the	DT
47658	75	9	cynical	cynical	JJ
47658	75	10	jest	jest	NN
47658	75	11	of	of	IN
47658	75	12	a	a	DT
47658	75	13	judge	judge	NN
47658	75	14	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
47658	75	15	to	to	IN
47658	75	16	the	the	DT
47658	75	17	significance	significance	NN
47658	75	18	of	of	IN
47658	75	19	the	the	DT
47658	75	20	great	great	JJ
47658	75	21	cause	cause	NN
47658	75	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	75	23	was	be	VBD
47658	75	24	trying	try	VBG
47658	75	25	--	--	:
47658	75	26	the	the	DT
47658	75	27	expression	expression	NN
47658	75	28	of	of	IN
47658	75	29	the	the	DT
47658	75	30	belief	belief	NN
47658	75	31	that	that	IN
47658	75	32	there	there	EX
47658	75	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	75	34	no	no	DT
47658	75	35	revelation	revelation	NN
47658	75	36	of	of	IN
47658	75	37	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
47658	75	38	truth	truth	NN
47658	75	39	of	of	IN
47658	75	40	the	the	DT
47658	75	41	highest	high	JJS
47658	75	42	importance	importance	NN
47658	75	43	for	for	IN
47658	75	44	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	75	45	human	human	JJ
47658	75	46	nature	nature	NN
47658	75	47	,	,	,
47658	75	48	or	or	CC
47658	75	49	at	at	IN
47658	75	50	least	least	JJS
47658	75	51	that	that	IN
47658	75	52	there	there	EX
47658	75	53	is	be	VBZ
47658	75	54	no	no	DT
47658	75	55	infallible	infallible	JJ
47658	75	56	test	test	NN
47658	75	57	by	by	IN
47658	75	58	which	which	WDT
47658	75	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	75	60	can	can	MD
47658	75	61	be	be	VB
47658	75	62	known	know	VBN
47658	75	63	.	.	.
47658	76	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	76	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	76	3	not	not	RB
47658	76	4	this	this	DT
47658	76	5	problem	problem	NN
47658	76	6	of	of	IN
47658	76	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	76	8	that	that	WDT
47658	76	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	76	10	are	be	VBP
47658	76	11	now	now	RB
47658	76	12	to	to	TO
47658	76	13	discuss	discuss	VB
47658	76	14	.	.	.
47658	77	1	There	there	EX
47658	77	2	are	be	VBP
47658	77	3	,	,	,
47658	77	4	on	on	IN
47658	77	5	the	the	DT
47658	77	6	other	other	JJ
47658	77	7	hand	hand	NN
47658	77	8	,	,	,
47658	77	9	many	many	JJ
47658	77	10	minds	mind	NNS
47658	77	11	that	that	WDT
47658	77	12	can	can	MD
47658	77	13	never	never	RB
47658	77	14	rest	rest	VB
47658	77	15	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
47658	77	16	while	while	IN
47658	77	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	77	18	have	have	VBP
47658	77	19	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	77	20	only	only	RB
47658	77	21	,	,	,
47658	77	22	and	and	CC
47658	77	23	not	not	RB
47658	77	24	examined	examine	VBN
47658	77	25	,	,	,
47658	77	26	the	the	DT
47658	77	27	assumptions	assumption	NNS
47658	77	28	of	of	IN
47658	77	29	science	science	NN
47658	77	30	and	and	CC
47658	77	31	the	the	DT
47658	77	32	values	value	NNS
47658	77	33	of	of	IN
47658	77	34	social	social	JJ
47658	77	35	and	and	CC
47658	77	36	political	political	JJ
47658	77	37	and	and	CC
47658	77	38	religious	religious	JJ
47658	77	39	ideals	ideal	NNS
47658	77	40	.	.	.
47658	78	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	78	2	quest	quest	NN
47658	78	3	of	of	IN
47658	78	4	first	first	JJ
47658	78	5	principles	principle	NNS
47658	78	6	may	may	MD
47658	78	7	appear	appear	VB
47658	78	8	to	to	IN
47658	78	9	more	more	JJR
47658	78	10	practical	practical	JJ
47658	78	11	natures	nature	NNS
47658	78	12	a	a	DT
47658	78	13	harmless	harmless	JJ
47658	78	14	amusement	amusement	NN
47658	78	15	or	or	CC
47658	78	16	a	a	DT
47658	78	17	useless	useless	JJ
47658	78	18	waste	waste	NN
47658	78	19	of	of	IN
47658	78	20	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	78	21	energy	energy	NN
47658	78	22	;	;	:
47658	78	23	but	but	CC
47658	78	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	78	25	are	be	VBP
47658	78	26	responding	respond	VBG
47658	78	27	to	to	IN
47658	78	28	a	a	DT
47658	78	29	deep	deep	JJ
47658	78	30	need	need	NN
47658	78	31	of	of	IN
47658	78	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	78	33	human	human	JJ
47658	78	34	nature	nature	NN
47658	78	35	,	,	,
47658	78	36	a	a	DT
47658	78	37	need	need	NN
47658	78	38	that	that	WDT
47658	78	39	,	,	,
47658	78	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	78	41	may	may	MD
47658	78	42	be	be	VB
47658	78	43	,	,	,
47658	78	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	78	45	in	in	IN
47658	78	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	78	47	very	very	JJ
47658	78	48	nature	nature	NN
47658	78	49	insatiable	insatiable	JJ
47658	78	50	--	--	:
47658	78	51	the	the	DT
47658	78	52	need	need	NN
47658	78	53	of	of	IN
47658	78	54	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	78	55	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
47658	78	56	.	.	.
47658	79	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	79	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	79	3	{	{	-LRB-
47658	79	4	14	14	CD
47658	79	5	}	}	-RRB-
47658	79	6	the	the	DT
47658	79	7	nature	nature	NN
47658	79	8	of	of	IN
47658	79	9	this	this	DT
47658	79	10	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	79	11	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
47658	79	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	79	13	that	that	WDT
47658	79	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	79	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	79	16	problem	problem	NN
47658	79	17	of	of	IN
47658	79	18	truth	truth	NN
47658	79	19	.	.	.
47658	80	1	There	there	EX
47658	80	2	are	be	VBP
47658	80	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	80	4	two	two	CD
47658	80	5	attitudes	attitude	NNS
47658	80	6	towards	towards	IN
47658	80	7	the	the	DT
47658	80	8	problem	problem	NN
47658	80	9	of	of	IN
47658	80	10	truth	truth	NN
47658	80	11	and	and	CC
47658	80	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	80	13	--	--	:
47658	80	14	that	that	DT
47658	80	15	of	of	IN
47658	80	16	the	the	DT
47658	80	17	mind	mind	NN
47658	80	18	which	which	WDT
47658	80	19	brings	bring	VBZ
47658	80	20	a	a	DT
47658	80	21	practical	practical	JJ
47658	80	22	test	test	NN
47658	80	23	to	to	IN
47658	80	24	every	every	DT
47658	80	25	question	question	NN
47658	80	26	,	,	,
47658	80	27	and	and	CC
47658	80	28	that	that	DT
47658	80	29	of	of	IN
47658	80	30	the	the	DT
47658	80	31	mind	mind	NN
47658	80	32	restless	restless	JJ
47658	80	33	to	to	TO
47658	80	34	gain	gain	VB
47658	80	35	by	by	IN
47658	80	36	insight	insight	NN
47658	80	37	or	or	CC
47658	80	38	by	by	IN
47658	80	39	speculation	speculation	NN
47658	80	40	a	a	DT
47658	80	41	clue	clue	NN
47658	80	42	to	to	IN
47658	80	43	the	the	DT
47658	80	44	mystery	mystery	NN
47658	80	45	that	that	WDT
47658	80	46	enshrouds	enshroud	VBZ
47658	80	47	the	the	DT
47658	80	48	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	80	49	of	of	IN
47658	80	50	existence	existence	NN
47658	80	51	.	.	.
47658	81	1	The	the	DT
47658	81	2	first	first	JJ
47658	81	3	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	81	4	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	81	5	peculiarly	peculiarly	JJ
47658	81	6	to	to	TO
47658	81	7	characterise	characterise	VB
47658	81	8	the	the	DT
47658	81	9	man	man	NN
47658	81	10	of	of	IN
47658	81	11	science	science	NNP
47658	81	12	,	,	,
47658	81	13	who	who	WP
47658	81	14	delights	delight	VBZ
47658	81	15	to	to	TO
47658	81	16	think	think	VB
47658	81	17	that	that	IN
47658	81	18	the	the	DT
47658	81	19	problem	problem	NN
47658	81	20	of	of	IN
47658	81	21	reality	reality	NN
47658	81	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	81	23	simple	simple	JJ
47658	81	24	and	and	CC
47658	81	25	open	open	JJ
47658	81	26	to	to	IN
47658	81	27	the	the	DT
47658	81	28	meanest	mean	JJS
47658	81	29	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	81	30	.	.	.
47658	82	1	Between	between	IN
47658	82	2	the	the	DT
47658	82	3	plain	plain	JJ
47658	82	4	man	man	NN
47658	82	5	's	's	POS
47658	82	6	view	view	NN
47658	82	7	and	and	CC
47658	82	8	that	that	DT
47658	82	9	of	of	IN
47658	82	10	the	the	DT
47658	82	11	man	man	NN
47658	82	12	of	of	IN
47658	82	13	high	high	JJ
47658	82	14	attainment	attainment	JJ
47658	82	15	in	in	IN
47658	82	16	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	82	17	research	research	NN
47658	82	18	there	there	EX
47658	82	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	82	20	for	for	IN
47658	82	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	82	22	only	only	RB
47658	82	23	a	a	DT
47658	82	24	difference	difference	NN
47658	82	25	of	of	IN
47658	82	26	degree	degree	NN
47658	82	27	,	,	,
47658	82	28	and	and	CC
47658	82	29	science	science	NN
47658	82	30	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	82	31	almost	almost	RB
47658	82	32	to	to	TO
47658	82	33	require	require	VB
47658	82	34	an	an	DT
47658	82	35	apology	apology	NN
47658	82	36	if	if	IN
47658	82	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	82	38	does	do	VBZ
47658	82	39	not	not	RB
47658	82	40	directly	directly	RB
47658	82	41	enlarge	enlarge	VB
47658	82	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	82	43	command	command	NN
47658	82	44	over	over	IN
47658	82	45	nature	nature	NN
47658	82	46	.	.	.
47658	83	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	83	2	would	would	MD
47658	83	3	explain	explain	VB
47658	83	4	life	life	NN
47658	83	5	and	and	CC
47658	83	6	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	83	7	as	as	IN
47658	83	8	the	the	DT
47658	83	9	result	result	NN
47658	83	10	of	of	IN
47658	83	11	chemical	chemical	JJ
47658	83	12	combination	combination	NN
47658	83	13	of	of	IN
47658	83	14	material	material	NN
47658	83	15	elements	element	NNS
47658	83	16	.	.	.
47658	84	1	Philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	84	2	,	,	,
47658	84	3	on	on	IN
47658	84	4	the	the	DT
47658	84	5	other	other	JJ
47658	84	6	hand	hand	NN
47658	84	7	,	,	,
47658	84	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	84	9	the	the	DT
47658	84	10	instinctive	instinctive	JJ
47658	84	11	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	84	12	that	that	IN
47658	84	13	the	the	DT
47658	84	14	secret	secret	NN
47658	84	15	of	of	IN
47658	84	16	the	the	DT
47658	84	17	universe	universe	NN
47658	84	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	84	19	not	not	RB
47658	84	20	open	open	JJ
47658	84	21	and	and	CC
47658	84	22	revealed	reveal	VBN
47658	84	23	to	to	IN
47658	84	24	the	the	DT
47658	84	25	plain	plain	JJ
47658	84	26	man	man	NN
47658	84	27	guided	guide	VBN
47658	84	28	by	by	IN
47658	84	29	common	common	JJ
47658	84	30	-	-	HYPH
47658	84	31	sense	sense	NN
47658	84	32	experience	experience	NN
47658	84	33	alone	alone	RB
47658	84	34	,	,	,
47658	84	35	even	even	RB
47658	84	36	if	if	IN
47658	84	37	to	to	IN
47658	84	38	this	this	DT
47658	84	39	experience	experience	NN
47658	84	40	be	be	VB
47658	84	41	added	add	VBN
47658	84	42	the	the	DT
47658	84	43	highest	high	JJS
47658	84	44	attainments	attainment	NNS
47658	84	45	of	of	IN
47658	84	46	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	84	47	research	research	NN
47658	84	48	.	.	.
47658	85	1	Either	either	CC
47658	85	2	there	there	EX
47658	85	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	85	4	far	far	RB
47658	85	5	more	more	JJR
47658	85	6	in	in	IN
47658	85	7	matter	matter	NN
47658	85	8	than	than	IN
47658	85	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	85	10	contained	contain	VBN
47658	85	11	in	in	IN
47658	85	12	the	the	DT
47658	85	13	three	three	CD
47658	85	14	-	-	HYPH
47658	85	15	dimensional	dimensional	JJ
47658	85	16	space	space	NN
47658	85	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	85	18	occupies	occupy	VBZ
47658	85	19	,	,	,
47658	85	20	or	or	CC
47658	85	21	else	else	RB
47658	85	22	the	the	DT
47658	85	23	universe	universe	NN
47658	85	24	must	must	MD
47658	85	25	owe	owe	VB
47658	85	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	85	27	development	development	NN
47658	85	28	to	to	IN
47658	85	29	something	something	NN
47658	85	30	beyond	beyond	IN
47658	85	31	matter	matter	NN
47658	85	32	.	.	.
47658	86	1	The	the	DT
47658	86	2	universe	universe	NN
47658	86	3	must	must	MD
47658	86	4	seem	seem	VB
47658	86	5	a	a	DT
47658	86	6	poor	poor	JJ
47658	86	7	thing	thing	NN
47658	86	8	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	86	9	to	to	IN
47658	86	10	a	a	DT
47658	86	11	man	man	NN
47658	86	12	who	who	WP
47658	86	13	can	can	MD
47658	86	14	think	think	VB
47658	86	15	that	that	IN
47658	86	16	physical	physical	JJ
47658	86	17	science	science	NN
47658	86	18	does	do	VBZ
47658	86	19	or	or	CC
47658	86	20	can	can	MD
47658	86	21	lay	lay	VB
47658	86	22	bare	bare	JJ
47658	86	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	86	24	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	86	25	.	.	.
47658	87	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	87	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	87	3	the	the	DT
47658	87	4	intense	intense	JJ
47658	87	5	desire	desire	NN
47658	87	6	to	to	TO
47658	87	7	catch	catch	VB
47658	87	8	some	some	DT
47658	87	9	glimpse	glimpse	NN
47658	87	10	of	of	IN
47658	87	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	87	12	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	87	13	that	that	WDT
47658	87	14	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	87	15	the	the	DT
47658	87	16	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	87	17	to	to	TO
47658	87	18	strive	strive	VB
47658	87	19	to	to	TO
47658	87	20	transcend	transcend	VB
47658	87	21	the	the	DT
47658	87	22	actual	actual	JJ
47658	87	23	world	world	NN
47658	87	24	by	by	IN
47658	87	25	following	follow	VBG
47658	87	26	the	the	DT
47658	87	27	speculative	speculative	JJ
47658	87	28	bent	bent	NN
47658	87	29	of	of	IN
47658	87	30	the	the	DT
47658	87	31	reasoning	reasoning	NN
47658	87	32	power	power	NN
47658	87	33	that	that	IN
47658	87	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	87	35	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	87	36	nature	nature	NN
47658	87	37	makes	make	VBZ
47658	87	38	possible	possible	JJ
47658	87	39	.	.	.
47658	88	1	[	[	-LRB-
47658	88	2	1	1	CD
47658	88	3	]	]	-RRB-
47658	88	4	Sir	Sir	NNP
47658	88	5	Kay	Kay	NNP
47658	88	6	Lankester	Lankester	NNP
47658	88	7	.	.	.
47658	89	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	89	2	15	15	CD
47658	89	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	89	4	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
47658	89	5	II	II	NNP
47658	89	6	APPEARANCE	APPEARANCE	NNS
47658	89	7	AND	and	CC
47658	89	8	REALITY	reality	VB
47658	89	9	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	89	10	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	89	11	life	life	NN
47658	89	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	89	13	one	one	CD
47658	89	14	unceasing	unceasing	NN
47658	89	15	change	change	NN
47658	89	16	.	.	.
47658	90	1	From	from	IN
47658	90	2	the	the	DT
47658	90	3	first	first	JJ
47658	90	4	awakening	awakening	NN
47658	90	5	of	of	IN
47658	90	6	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	90	7	to	to	IN
47658	90	8	the	the	DT
47658	90	9	actual	actual	JJ
47658	90	10	present	present	NN
47658	90	11	,	,	,
47658	90	12	no	no	DT
47658	90	13	one	one	CD
47658	90	14	moment	moment	NN
47658	90	15	has	have	VBZ
47658	90	16	been	be	VBN
47658	90	17	the	the	DT
47658	90	18	mere	mere	JJ
47658	90	19	repetition	repetition	NN
47658	90	20	of	of	IN
47658	90	21	another	another	DT
47658	90	22	,	,	,
47658	90	23	and	and	CC
47658	90	24	the	the	DT
47658	90	25	moments	moment	NNS
47658	90	26	which	which	WDT
47658	90	27	as	as	IN
47658	90	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	90	29	look	look	VBP
47658	90	30	back	back	RB
47658	90	31	seem	seem	VBP
47658	90	32	to	to	TO
47658	90	33	have	have	VB
47658	90	34	made	make	VBN
47658	90	35	up	up	RP
47658	90	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	90	37	life	life	NN
47658	90	38	are	be	VBP
47658	90	39	not	not	RB
47658	90	40	separable	separable	JJ
47658	90	41	elements	element	NNS
47658	90	42	of	of	IN
47658	90	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	90	44	but	but	CC
47658	90	45	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	90	46	own	own	JJ
47658	90	47	divisions	division	NNS
47658	90	48	of	of	IN
47658	90	49	a	a	DT
47658	90	50	change	change	NN
47658	90	51	that	that	WDT
47658	90	52	has	have	VBZ
47658	90	53	been	be	VBN
47658	90	54	continuous	continuous	JJ
47658	90	55	.	.	.
47658	91	1	And	and	CC
47658	91	2	as	as	IN
47658	91	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	91	4	has	have	VBZ
47658	91	5	been	be	VBN
47658	91	6	,	,	,
47658	91	7	so	so	RB
47658	91	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	91	9	know	know	VBP
47658	91	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	91	11	will	will	MD
47658	91	12	be	be	VB
47658	91	13	until	until	IN
47658	91	14	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	91	15	ceases	cease	VBZ
47658	91	16	with	with	IN
47658	91	17	death	death	NN
47658	91	18	.	.	.
47658	92	1	Consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	92	2	and	and	CC
47658	92	3	life	life	NN
47658	92	4	are	be	VBP
47658	92	5	in	in	IN
47658	92	6	this	this	DT
47658	92	7	respect	respect	NN
47658	92	8	one	one	CD
47658	92	9	and	and	CC
47658	92	10	the	the	DT
47658	92	11	same	same	JJ
47658	92	12	,	,	,
47658	92	13	although	although	IN
47658	92	14	when	when	WRB
47658	92	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	92	16	speak	speak	VBP
47658	92	17	of	of	IN
47658	92	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	92	19	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	92	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	92	21	think	think	VBP
47658	92	22	chiefly	chiefly	RB
47658	92	23	of	of	IN
47658	92	24	a	a	DT
47658	92	25	passive	passive	JJ
47658	92	26	receptivity	receptivity	NN
47658	92	27	,	,	,
47658	92	28	and	and	CC
47658	92	29	when	when	WRB
47658	92	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	92	31	speak	speak	VBP
47658	92	32	of	of	IN
47658	92	33	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	92	34	life	life	NN
47658	92	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	92	36	think	think	VBP
47658	92	37	of	of	IN
47658	92	38	an	an	DT
47658	92	39	activity	activity	NN
47658	92	40	.	.	.
47658	93	1	Consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	93	2	as	as	IN
47658	93	3	the	the	DT
47658	93	4	unity	unity	NN
47658	93	5	of	of	IN
47658	93	6	knowing	know	VBG
47658	93	7	and	and	CC
47658	93	8	acting	acting	NN
47658	93	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	93	10	a	a	DT
47658	93	11	becoming	becoming	NN
47658	93	12	.	.	.
47658	94	1	The	the	DT
47658	94	2	past	past	NN
47658	94	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	94	4	not	not	RB
47658	94	5	left	leave	VBN
47658	94	6	behind	behind	RB
47658	94	7	,	,	,
47658	94	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	94	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	94	10	with	with	IN
47658	94	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	94	12	in	in	IN
47658	94	13	the	the	DT
47658	94	14	form	form	NN
47658	94	15	of	of	IN
47658	94	16	memory	memory	NN
47658	94	17	;	;	:
47658	94	18	the	the	DT
47658	94	19	future	future	NN
47658	94	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	94	21	not	not	RB
47658	94	22	a	a	DT
47658	94	23	predetermined	predetermined	JJ
47658	94	24	order	order	NN
47658	94	25	which	which	WDT
47658	94	26	only	only	RB
47658	94	27	a	a	DT
47658	94	28	natural	natural	JJ
47658	94	29	disability	disability	NN
47658	94	30	prevents	prevent	VBZ
47658	94	31	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	94	32	from	from	IN
47658	94	33	knowing	know	VBG
47658	94	34	,	,	,
47658	94	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	94	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	94	37	yet	yet	RB
47658	94	38	uncreated	uncreated	JJ
47658	94	39	;	;	:
47658	94	40	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	94	41	life	life	NN
47658	94	42	is	be	VBZ
47658	94	43	the	the	DT
47658	94	44	enduring	endure	VBG
47658	94	45	present	present	NN
47658	94	46	which	which	WDT
47658	94	47	grows	grow	VBZ
47658	94	48	with	with	IN
47658	94	49	the	the	DT
47658	94	50	past	past	NN
47658	94	51	and	and	CC
47658	94	52	makes	make	VBZ
47658	94	53	the	the	DT
47658	94	54	future	future	NN
47658	94	55	.	.	.
47658	95	1	This	this	DT
47658	95	2	reality	reality	NN
47658	95	3	of	of	IN
47658	95	4	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	95	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	95	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	95	7	continually	continually	RB
47658	95	8	changing	change	VBG
47658	95	9	experience	experience	NN
47658	95	10	.	.	.
47658	96	1	But	but	CC
47658	96	2	there	there	EX
47658	96	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	96	4	also	also	RB
47658	96	5	another	another	DT
47658	96	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	96	7	with	with	IN
47658	96	8	which	which	WDT
47658	96	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	96	10	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	96	11	to	to	TO
47658	96	12	be	be	VB
47658	96	13	in	in	IN
47658	96	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	96	15	relation	relation	NN
47658	96	16	and	and	CC
47658	96	17	also	also	RB
47658	96	18	in	in	IN
47658	96	19	complete	complete	JJ
47658	96	20	contrast	contrast	NN
47658	96	21	--	--	:
47658	96	22	this	this	DT
47658	96	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	96	24	the	the	DT
47658	96	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	96	26	of	of	IN
47658	96	27	the	the	DT
47658	96	28	material	material	NN
47658	96	29	or	or	CC
47658	96	30	physical	physical	JJ
47658	96	31	universe	universe	NN
47658	96	32	.	.	.
47658	97	1	The	the	DT
47658	97	2	world	world	NN
47658	97	3	of	of	IN
47658	97	4	physical	physical	JJ
47658	97	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	97	6	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	97	7	to	to	TO
47658	97	8	be	be	VB
47658	97	9	composed	compose	VBN
47658	97	10	of	of	IN
47658	97	11	a	a	DT
47658	97	12	matter	matter	NN
47658	97	13	that	that	WDT
47658	97	14	can	can	MD
47658	97	15	not	not	RB
47658	97	16	change	change	VB
47658	97	17	in	in	IN
47658	97	18	a	a	DT
47658	97	19	space	space	NN
47658	97	20	that	that	WDT
47658	97	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	97	22	absolutely	absolutely	RB
47658	97	23	unchangeable	unchangeable	JJ
47658	97	24	.	.	.
47658	98	1	This	this	DT
47658	98	2	physical	physical	JJ
47658	98	3	world	world	NN
47658	98	4	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	98	5	made	make	VBN
47658	98	6	up	up	RP
47658	98	7	of	of	IN
47658	98	8	solid	solid	JJ
47658	98	9	things	thing	NNS
47658	98	10	,	,	,
47658	98	11	formed	form	VBN
47658	98	12	out	out	IN
47658	98	13	of	of	IN
47658	98	14	matter	matter	NN
47658	98	15	.	.	.
47658	99	1	Change	change	VB
47658	99	2	in	in	IN
47658	99	3	physical	physical	JJ
47658	99	4	science	science	NN
47658	99	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	99	6	only	only	RB
47658	99	7	a	a	DT
47658	99	8	rearrangement	rearrangement	NN
47658	99	9	of	of	IN
47658	99	10	matter	matter	NN
47658	99	11	or	or	CC
47658	99	12	an	an	DT
47658	99	13	alteration	alteration	NN
47658	99	14	of	of	IN
47658	99	15	position	position	NN
47658	99	16	in	in	IN
47658	99	17	space	space	NN
47658	99	18	.	.	.
47658	100	1	This	this	DT
47658	100	2	physical	physical	JJ
47658	100	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	100	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	100	5	not	not	RB
47658	100	6	,	,	,
47658	100	7	as	as	IN
47658	100	8	psychical	psychical	JJ
47658	100	9	reality	reality	NN
47658	100	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	100	11	,	,	,
47658	100	12	{	{	-LRB-
47658	100	13	16	16	CD
47658	100	14	}	}	-RRB-
47658	100	15	known	know	VBN
47658	100	16	to	to	IN
47658	100	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	100	18	directly	directly	RB
47658	100	19	;	;	:
47658	100	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	100	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	100	22	an	an	DT
47658	100	23	interpretation	interpretation	NN
47658	100	24	of	of	IN
47658	100	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	100	26	sense	sense	NN
47658	100	27	experience	experience	NN
47658	100	28	.	.	.
47658	101	1	Immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	101	2	experience	experience	NN
47658	101	3	has	have	VBZ
47658	101	4	objects	object	NNS
47658	101	5	,	,	,
47658	101	6	generally	generally	RB
47658	101	7	called	call	VBN
47658	101	8	sense	sense	NN
47658	101	9	data	datum	NNS
47658	101	10	.	.	.
47658	102	1	These	these	DT
47658	102	2	objects	object	NNS
47658	102	3	are	be	VBP
47658	102	4	what	what	WP
47658	102	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	102	6	actually	actually	RB
47658	102	7	see	see	VBP
47658	102	8	in	in	IN
47658	102	9	sensations	sensation	NNS
47658	102	10	of	of	IN
47658	102	11	sight	sight	NN
47658	102	12	,	,	,
47658	102	13	what	what	WP
47658	102	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	102	15	actually	actually	RB
47658	102	16	hear	hear	VBP
47658	102	17	in	in	IN
47658	102	18	sensations	sensation	NNS
47658	102	19	of	of	IN
47658	102	20	sound	sound	NN
47658	102	21	,	,	,
47658	102	22	and	and	CC
47658	102	23	so	so	RB
47658	102	24	on	on	RB
47658	102	25	;	;	:
47658	102	26	and	and	CC
47658	102	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	102	28	lead	lead	VBP
47658	102	29	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	102	30	to	to	TO
47658	102	31	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	102	32	or	or	CC
47658	102	33	infer	infer	VB
47658	102	34	physical	physical	JJ
47658	102	35	objects	object	NNS
47658	102	36	--	--	:
47658	102	37	that	that	RB
47658	102	38	is	is	RB
47658	102	39	,	,	,
47658	102	40	objects	object	NNS
47658	102	41	that	that	WDT
47658	102	42	do	do	VBP
47658	102	43	not	not	RB
47658	102	44	depend	depend	VB
47658	102	45	upon	upon	IN
47658	102	46	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	102	47	experience	experience	NN
47658	102	48	for	for	IN
47658	102	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	102	50	existence	existence	NN
47658	102	51	,	,	,
47658	102	52	but	but	CC
47658	102	53	whose	whose	WP$
47658	102	54	existence	existence	NN
47658	102	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	102	56	the	the	DT
47658	102	57	cause	cause	NN
47658	102	58	of	of	IN
47658	102	59	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	102	60	having	have	VBG
47658	102	61	the	the	DT
47658	102	62	experience	experience	NN
47658	102	63	.	.	.
47658	103	1	The	the	DT
47658	103	2	process	process	NN
47658	103	3	by	by	IN
47658	103	4	which	which	WDT
47658	103	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	103	6	infer	infer	VBP
47658	103	7	the	the	DT
47658	103	8	nature	nature	NN
47658	103	9	of	of	IN
47658	103	10	the	the	DT
47658	103	11	external	external	JJ
47658	103	12	world	world	NN
47658	103	13	from	from	IN
47658	103	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	103	15	felt	felt	JJ
47658	103	16	experience	experience	NN
47658	103	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	103	18	logical	logical	JJ
47658	103	19	.	.	.
47658	104	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	104	2	includes	include	VBZ
47658	104	3	perceiving	perceiving	NN
47658	104	4	,	,	,
47658	104	5	conceiving	conceive	VBG
47658	104	6	,	,	,
47658	104	7	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	104	8	or	or	CC
47658	104	9	reasoning	reasoning	NN
47658	104	10	.	.	.
47658	105	1	The	the	DT
47658	105	2	object	object	NN
47658	105	3	of	of	IN
47658	105	4	the	the	DT
47658	105	5	logical	logical	JJ
47658	105	6	process	process	NN
47658	105	7	,	,	,
47658	105	8	the	the	DT
47658	105	9	aim	aim	NN
47658	105	10	or	or	CC
47658	105	11	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	105	12	to	to	TO
47658	105	13	which	which	WDT
47658	105	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	105	15	seeks	seek	VBZ
47658	105	16	to	to	TO
47658	105	17	attain	attain	VB
47658	105	18	,	,	,
47658	105	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	105	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	105	21	.	.	.
47658	106	1	Knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	106	2	of	of	IN
47658	106	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	106	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	106	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	106	6	.	.	.
47658	107	1	There	there	EX
47658	107	2	are	be	VBP
47658	107	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	107	4	two	two	CD
47658	107	5	realities	reality	NNS
47658	107	6	,	,	,
47658	107	7	the	the	DT
47658	107	8	reality	reality	NN
47658	107	9	of	of	IN
47658	107	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	107	11	felt	felt	JJ
47658	107	12	experience	experience	NN
47658	107	13	from	from	IN
47658	107	14	which	which	WDT
47658	107	15	all	all	DT
47658	107	16	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	107	17	sets	set	VBZ
47658	107	18	out	out	RP
47658	107	19	,	,	,
47658	107	20	and	and	CC
47658	107	21	the	the	DT
47658	107	22	reality	reality	NN
47658	107	23	which	which	WDT
47658	107	24	in	in	IN
47658	107	25	thinking	think	VBG
47658	107	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	107	27	seek	seek	VBP
47658	107	28	to	to	TO
47658	107	29	know	know	VB
47658	107	30	.	.	.
47658	108	1	The	the	DT
47658	108	2	one	one	CD
47658	108	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	108	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	108	5	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	108	6	;	;	:
47658	108	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	108	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	108	9	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	108	10	experience	experience	NN
47658	108	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	108	12	.	.	.
47658	109	1	The	the	DT
47658	109	2	other	other	JJ
47658	109	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	109	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	109	5	that	that	IN
47658	109	6	which	which	WDT
47658	109	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	109	8	infer	infer	VBP
47658	109	9	from	from	IN
47658	109	10	the	the	DT
47658	109	11	fact	fact	NN
47658	109	12	of	of	IN
47658	109	13	experience	experience	NN
47658	109	14	,	,	,
47658	109	15	that	that	IN
47658	109	16	by	by	IN
47658	109	17	which	which	WDT
47658	109	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	109	19	seek	seek	VBP
47658	109	20	to	to	TO
47658	109	21	explain	explain	VB
47658	109	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	109	23	existence	existence	NN
47658	109	24	.	.	.
47658	110	1	The	the	DT
47658	110	2	one	one	NN
47658	110	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	110	4	feel	feel	VBP
47658	110	5	,	,	,
47658	110	6	the	the	DT
47658	110	7	other	other	JJ
47658	110	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	110	9	think	think	VBP
47658	110	10	.	.	.
47658	111	1	If	if	IN
47658	111	2	the	the	DT
47658	111	3	difference	difference	NN
47658	111	4	between	between	IN
47658	111	5	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	111	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	111	7	and	and	CC
47658	111	8	mediate	mediate	VB
47658	111	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	111	10	or	or	CC
47658	111	11	inference	inference	NN
47658	111	12	lay	lie	VBD
47658	111	13	in	in	IN
47658	111	14	the	the	DT
47658	111	15	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	111	16	of	of	IN
47658	111	17	certainty	certainty	NN
47658	111	18	alone	alone	JJ
47658	111	19	or	or	CC
47658	111	20	in	in	IN
47658	111	21	the	the	DT
47658	111	22	nature	nature	NN
47658	111	23	of	of	IN
47658	111	24	belief	belief	NN
47658	111	25	,	,	,
47658	111	26	the	the	DT
47658	111	27	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	111	28	would	would	MD
47658	111	29	not	not	RB
47658	111	30	be	be	VB
47658	111	31	the	the	DT
47658	111	32	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	111	33	one	one	NN
47658	111	34	that	that	WDT
47658	111	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	111	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	111	37	.	.	.
47658	112	1	The	the	DT
47658	112	2	theories	theory	NNS
47658	112	3	of	of	IN
47658	112	4	idealism	idealism	NN
47658	112	5	and	and	CC
47658	112	6	realism	realism	NN
47658	112	7	show	show	VBP
47658	112	8	how	how	WRB
47658	112	9	widely	widely	RB
47658	112	10	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	112	11	are	be	VBP
47658	112	12	divided	divide	VBN
47658	112	13	on	on	IN
47658	112	14	the	the	DT
47658	112	15	subject	subject	NN
47658	112	16	.	.	.
47658	113	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	113	2	are	be	VBP
47658	113	3	quite	quite	RB
47658	113	4	as	as	RB
47658	113	5	certain	certain	JJ
47658	113	6	of	of	IN
47658	113	7	some	some	DT
47658	113	8	of	of	IN
47658	113	9	the	the	DT
47658	113	10	things	thing	NNS
47658	113	11	that	that	WDT
47658	113	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	113	13	can	can	MD
47658	113	14	only	only	RB
47658	113	15	infer	infer	VB
47658	113	16	as	as	IN
47658	113	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	113	18	are	be	VBP
47658	113	19	of	of	IN
47658	113	20	the	the	DT
47658	113	21	things	thing	NNS
47658	113	22	of	of	IN
47658	113	23	which	which	WDT
47658	113	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	113	25	are	be	VBP
47658	113	26	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	113	27	aware	aware	JJ
47658	113	28	.	.	.
47658	114	1	Wd	wd	PRP
47658	114	2	can	can	MD
47658	114	3	not	not	RB
47658	114	4	doubt	doubt	VB
47658	114	5	,	,	,
47658	114	6	for	for	IN
47658	114	7	instance	instance	NN
47658	114	8	,	,	,
47658	114	9	that	that	IN
47658	114	10	there	there	EX
47658	114	11	are	be	VBP
47658	114	12	other	other	JJ
47658	114	13	persons	person	NNS
47658	114	14	besides	besides	IN
47658	114	15	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	114	16	,	,	,
47658	114	17	yet	yet	CC
47658	114	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	114	19	can	can	MD
47658	114	20	have	have	VB
47658	114	21	no	no	DT
47658	114	22	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	114	23	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	114	24	of	of	IN
47658	114	25	any	any	DT
47658	114	26	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	114	27	but	but	CC
47658	114	28	one	one	CD
47658	114	29	--	--	:
47658	114	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	114	31	own	own	JJ
47658	114	32	.	.	.
47658	115	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	115	2	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	115	3	that	that	IN
47658	115	4	there	there	EX
47658	115	5	are	be	VBP
47658	115	6	other	other	JJ
47658	115	7	minds	mind	NNS
47658	115	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	115	9	an	an	DT
47658	115	10	inference	inference	NN
47658	115	11	from	from	IN
47658	115	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	115	13	observation	observation	NN
47658	115	14	of	of	IN
47658	115	15	the	the	DT
47658	115	16	behaviour	behaviour	NN
47658	115	17	of	of	IN
47658	115	18	some	some	DT
47658	115	19	of	of	IN
47658	115	20	the	the	DT
47658	115	21	things	thing	NNS
47658	115	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	115	23	{	{	-LRB-
47658	115	24	17	17	CD
47658	115	25	}	}	-RRB-
47658	115	26	directly	directly	RB
47658	115	27	experience	experience	NN
47658	115	28	,	,	,
47658	115	29	and	and	CC
47658	115	30	from	from	IN
47658	115	31	the	the	DT
47658	115	32	experience	experience	NN
47658	115	33	of	of	IN
47658	115	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	115	35	own	own	JJ
47658	115	36	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	115	37	.	.	.
47658	116	1	And	and	CC
47658	116	2	even	even	RB
47658	116	3	those	those	DT
47658	116	4	things	thing	NNS
47658	116	5	which	which	WDT
47658	116	6	seem	seem	VBP
47658	116	7	in	in	IN
47658	116	8	direct	direct	JJ
47658	116	9	relation	relation	NN
47658	116	10	to	to	IN
47658	116	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	116	12	--	--	:
47658	116	13	the	the	DT
47658	116	14	things	thing	NNS
47658	116	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	116	16	see	see	VBP
47658	116	17	,	,	,
47658	116	18	or	or	CC
47658	116	19	hear	hear	VB
47658	116	20	,	,	,
47658	116	21	or	or	CC
47658	116	22	touch	touch	NN
47658	116	23	--	--	:
47658	116	24	are	be	VBP
47658	116	25	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	116	26	present	present	JJ
47658	116	27	in	in	IN
47658	116	28	only	only	RB
47658	116	29	a	a	DT
47658	116	30	very	very	RB
47658	116	31	small	small	JJ
47658	116	32	,	,	,
47658	116	33	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	116	34	an	an	DT
47658	116	35	infinitesimal	infinitesimal	NN
47658	116	36	,	,	,
47658	116	37	part	part	NN
47658	116	38	of	of	IN
47658	116	39	what	what	WP
47658	116	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	116	41	know	know	VBP
47658	116	42	and	and	CC
47658	116	43	think	think	VBP
47658	116	44	of	of	IN
47658	116	45	as	as	IN
47658	116	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	116	47	full	full	JJ
47658	116	48	reality	reality	NN
47658	116	49	;	;	:
47658	116	50	all	all	DT
47658	116	51	but	but	IN
47658	116	52	this	this	DT
47658	116	53	small	small	JJ
47658	116	54	part	part	NN
47658	116	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	116	56	inferred	infer	VBN
47658	116	57	.	.	.
47658	117	1	From	from	IN
47658	117	2	a	a	DT
47658	117	3	momentary	momentary	JJ
47658	117	4	sensation	sensation	NN
47658	117	5	of	of	IN
47658	117	6	sight	sight	NN
47658	117	7	,	,	,
47658	117	8	or	or	CC
47658	117	9	sound	sound	JJ
47658	117	10	,	,	,
47658	117	11	or	or	CC
47658	117	12	touch	touch	VB
47658	117	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	117	14	infer	infer	VBP
47658	117	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	117	16	that	that	WDT
47658	117	17	far	far	RB
47658	117	18	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
47658	117	19	anything	anything	NN
47658	117	20	actually	actually	RB
47658	117	21	given	give	VBN
47658	117	22	to	to	IN
47658	117	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	117	24	by	by	IN
47658	117	25	the	the	DT
47658	117	26	sensation	sensation	NN
47658	117	27	.	.	.
47658	118	1	Thinking	thinking	NN
47658	118	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	118	3	questioning	question	VBG
47658	118	4	experience	experience	NN
47658	118	5	.	.	.
47658	119	1	When	when	WRB
47658	119	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	119	3	attention	attention	NN
47658	119	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	119	5	suddenly	suddenly	RB
47658	119	6	attracted	attract	VBN
47658	119	7	by	by	IN
47658	119	8	something	something	NN
47658	119	9	--	--	:
47658	119	10	a	a	DT
47658	119	11	flash	flash	NN
47658	119	12	of	of	IN
47658	119	13	light	light	NN
47658	119	14	,	,	,
47658	119	15	or	or	CC
47658	119	16	a	a	DT
47658	119	17	sound	sound	NN
47658	119	18	,	,	,
47658	119	19	or	or	CC
47658	119	20	a	a	DT
47658	119	21	twinge	twinge	NN
47658	119	22	of	of	IN
47658	119	23	pain	pain	NN
47658	119	24	--	--	:
47658	119	25	consciously	consciously	RB
47658	119	26	or	or	CC
47658	119	27	unconsciously	unconsciously	RB
47658	119	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	119	29	say	say	VBP
47658	119	30	to	to	TO
47658	119	31	ourself	ourself	VB
47658	119	32	,	,	,
47658	119	33	What	what	WP
47658	119	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	119	35	that	that	DT
47658	119	36	?	?	.
47658	120	1	The	the	DT
47658	120	2	_	_	NNP
47658	120	3	that_--a	that_--a	NNP
47658	120	4	simple	simple	JJ
47658	120	5	felt	feel	VBD
47658	120	6	experience	experience	NN
47658	120	7	--	--	:
47658	120	8	contains	contain	VBZ
47658	120	9	a	a	DT
47658	120	10	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	120	11	,	,	,
47658	120	12	brings	bring	VBZ
47658	120	13	a	a	DT
47658	120	14	message	message	NN
47658	120	15	,	,	,
47658	120	16	and	and	CC
47658	120	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	120	18	ask	ask	VBP
47658	120	19	_	_	NNP
47658	120	20	what	what	WP
47658	120	21	_	_	NNP
47658	120	22	?	?	.
47658	121	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	121	2	distinguish	distinguish	VBP
47658	121	3	the	the	DT
47658	121	4	existence	existence	NN
47658	121	5	as	as	IN
47658	121	6	an	an	DT
47658	121	7	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	121	8	,	,	,
47658	121	9	and	and	CC
47658	121	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	121	11	seek	seek	VBP
47658	121	12	to	to	TO
47658	121	13	know	know	VB
47658	121	14	the	the	DT
47658	121	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	121	16	.	.	.
47658	122	1	The	the	DT
47658	122	2	quest	quest	NN
47658	122	3	of	of	IN
47658	122	4	the	the	DT
47658	122	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	122	6	which	which	WDT
47658	122	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	122	8	made	make	VBN
47658	122	9	known	known	JJ
47658	122	10	to	to	IN
47658	122	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	122	12	by	by	IN
47658	122	13	the	the	DT
47658	122	14	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	122	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	122	16	the	the	DT
47658	122	17	logical	logical	JJ
47658	122	18	process	process	NN
47658	122	19	of	of	IN
47658	122	20	thought	thought	NN
47658	122	21	.	.	.
47658	123	1	The	the	DT
47658	123	2	end	end	NN
47658	123	3	or	or	CC
47658	123	4	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	123	5	of	of	IN
47658	123	6	this	this	DT
47658	123	7	logical	logical	JJ
47658	123	8	process	process	NN
47658	123	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	123	10	to	to	TO
47658	123	11	replace	replace	VB
47658	123	12	the	the	DT
47658	123	13	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	123	14	reality	reality	NN
47658	123	15	of	of	IN
47658	123	16	the	the	DT
47658	123	17	felt	felt	JJ
47658	123	18	experience	experience	NN
47658	123	19	with	with	IN
47658	123	20	a	a	DT
47658	123	21	mediated	mediate	VBN
47658	123	22	-	-	HYPH
47658	123	23	reality	reality	NN
47658	123	24	--	--	:
47658	123	25	that	that	RB
47658	123	26	is	is	RB
47658	123	27	,	,	,
47658	123	28	a	a	DT
47658	123	29	reality	reality	NN
47658	123	30	made	make	VBN
47658	123	31	known	known	JJ
47658	123	32	to	to	IN
47658	123	33	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	123	34	.	.	.
47658	124	1	Directly	directly	RB
47658	124	2	,	,	,
47658	124	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	124	4	,	,	,
47658	124	5	that	that	IN
47658	124	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	124	7	begin	begin	VBP
47658	124	8	to	to	TO
47658	124	9	think	think	VB
47658	124	10	,	,	,
47658	124	11	the	the	DT
47658	124	12	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	124	13	present	present	JJ
47658	124	14	existence	existence	NN
47658	124	15	becomes	become	VBZ
47658	124	16	an	an	DT
47658	124	17	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	124	18	,	,	,
47658	124	19	and	and	CC
47658	124	20	throughout	throughout	IN
47658	124	21	the	the	DT
47658	124	22	development	development	NN
47658	124	23	of	of	IN
47658	124	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	124	25	thought	thought	NN
47658	124	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	124	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	124	28	taken	take	VBN
47658	124	29	to	to	TO
47658	124	30	be	be	VB
47658	124	31	something	something	NN
47658	124	32	that	that	WDT
47658	124	33	requires	require	VBZ
47658	124	34	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	124	35	.	.	.
47658	125	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	125	2	seek	seek	VBP
47658	125	3	to	to	TO
47658	125	4	discover	discover	VB
47658	125	5	the	the	DT
47658	125	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	125	7	which	which	WDT
47658	125	8	will	will	MD
47658	125	9	explain	explain	VB
47658	125	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	125	11	.	.	.
47658	126	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	126	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	126	3	in	in	IN
47658	126	4	this	this	DT
47658	126	5	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	126	6	of	of	IN
47658	126	7	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	126	8	and	and	CC
47658	126	9	reality	reality	NN
47658	126	10	that	that	IN
47658	126	11	the	the	DT
47658	126	12	problem	problem	NN
47658	126	13	of	of	IN
47658	126	14	truth	truth	NN
47658	126	15	arises	arise	VBZ
47658	126	16	.	.	.
47658	127	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	127	2	does	do	VBZ
47658	127	3	not	not	RB
47658	127	4	depend	depend	VB
47658	127	5	upon	upon	IN
47658	127	6	any	any	DT
47658	127	7	particular	particular	JJ
47658	127	8	theory	theory	NN
47658	127	9	of	of	IN
47658	127	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	127	11	.	.	.
47658	128	1	The	the	DT
47658	128	2	same	same	JJ
47658	128	3	fact	fact	NN
47658	128	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	128	5	recognised	recognise	VBN
47658	128	6	by	by	IN
47658	128	7	idealists	idealist	NNS
47658	128	8	and	and	CC
47658	128	9	by	by	IN
47658	128	10	realists	realist	NNS
47658	128	11	.	.	.
47658	129	1	Idealism	idealism	NN
47658	129	2	may	may	MD
47658	129	3	deny	deny	VB
47658	129	4	that	that	IN
47658	129	5	the	the	DT
47658	129	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	129	7	of	of	IN
47658	129	8	independent	independent	JJ
47658	129	9	reality	reality	NN
47658	129	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	129	11	possible	possible	JJ
47658	129	12	;	;	:
47658	129	13	realism	realism	NN
47658	129	14	may	may	MD
47658	129	15	insist	insist	VB
47658	129	16	that	that	IN
47658	129	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	129	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	129	19	implied	imply	VBN
47658	129	20	in	in	IN
47658	129	21	the	the	DT
47658	129	22	very	very	JJ
47658	129	23	fact	fact	NN
47658	129	24	of	of	IN
47658	129	25	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	129	26	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	129	27	--	--	:
47658	129	28	whichever	whichever	WDT
47658	129	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	129	30	right	right	JJ
47658	129	31	,	,	,
47658	129	32	the	the	DT
47658	129	33	reality	reality	NN
47658	129	34	which	which	WDT
47658	129	35	thinking	think	VBG
47658	129	36	brings	bring	VBZ
47658	129	37	before	before	IN
47658	129	38	the	the	DT
47658	129	39	mind	mind	NN
47658	129	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	129	41	quite	quite	RB
47658	129	42	{	{	-LRB-
47658	129	43	18	18	CD
47658	129	44	}	}	-RRB-
47658	129	45	unlike	unlike	IN
47658	129	46	and	and	CC
47658	129	47	of	of	IN
47658	129	48	a	a	DT
47658	129	49	different	different	JJ
47658	129	50	order	order	NN
47658	129	51	to	to	IN
47658	129	52	that	that	DT
47658	129	53	which	which	WDT
47658	129	54	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	129	55	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	129	56	experience	experience	VBP
47658	129	57	in	in	IN
47658	129	58	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	129	59	.	.	.
47658	130	1	And	and	CC
47658	130	2	even	even	RB
47658	130	3	if	if	IN
47658	130	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	130	5	know	know	VBP
47658	130	6	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	130	7	of	of	IN
47658	130	8	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	130	9	,	,	,
47658	130	10	if	if	IN
47658	130	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	130	12	are	be	VBP
47658	130	13	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
47658	130	14	of	of	IN
47658	130	15	all	all	DT
47658	130	16	theories	theory	NNS
47658	130	17	of	of	IN
47658	130	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	130	19	and	and	CC
47658	130	20	think	think	VBP
47658	130	21	of	of	IN
47658	130	22	the	the	DT
47658	130	23	nature	nature	NN
47658	130	24	of	of	IN
47658	130	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	130	26	simply	simply	RB
47658	130	27	from	from	IN
47658	130	28	the	the	DT
47658	130	29	standpoint	standpoint	NN
47658	130	30	of	of	IN
47658	130	31	the	the	DT
47658	130	32	natural	natural	JJ
47658	130	33	man	man	NN
47658	130	34	,	,	,
47658	130	35	the	the	DT
47658	130	36	fact	fact	NN
47658	130	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	130	38	essentially	essentially	RB
47658	130	39	the	the	DT
47658	130	40	same	same	JJ
47658	130	41	--	--	:
47658	130	42	the	the	DT
47658	130	43	true	true	JJ
47658	130	44	reality	reality	NN
47658	130	45	of	of	IN
47658	130	46	things	thing	NNS
47658	130	47	is	be	VBZ
47658	130	48	something	something	NN
47658	130	49	concealed	conceal	VBD
47658	130	50	from	from	IN
47658	130	51	outward	outward	JJ
47658	130	52	view	view	NN
47658	130	53	,	,	,
47658	130	54	something	something	NN
47658	130	55	to	to	TO
47658	130	56	be	be	VB
47658	130	57	found	find	VBN
47658	130	58	out	out	RP
47658	130	59	by	by	IN
47658	130	60	science	science	NN
47658	130	61	or	or	CC
47658	130	62	by	by	IN
47658	130	63	practical	practical	JJ
47658	130	64	wisdom	wisdom	NN
47658	130	65	.	.	.
47658	131	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	131	2	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	131	3	of	of	IN
47658	131	4	this	this	DT
47658	131	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	131	6	may	may	MD
47658	131	7	be	be	VB
47658	131	8	true	true	JJ
47658	131	9	,	,	,
47658	131	10	in	in	IN
47658	131	11	this	this	DT
47658	131	12	case	case	NN
47658	131	13	only	only	RB
47658	131	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	131	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	131	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	131	17	;	;	:
47658	131	18	or	or	CC
47658	131	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	131	20	may	may	MD
47658	131	21	be	be	VB
47658	131	22	false	false	JJ
47658	131	23	,	,	,
47658	131	24	in	in	IN
47658	131	25	which	which	WDT
47658	131	26	case	case	NN
47658	131	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	131	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	131	29	not	not	RB
47658	131	30	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	131	31	but	but	CC
47658	131	32	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	131	33	or	or	CC
47658	131	34	error	error	NN
47658	131	35	.	.	.
47658	132	1	The	the	DT
47658	132	2	reality	reality	NN
47658	132	3	then	then	RB
47658	132	4	,	,	,
47658	132	5	the	the	DT
47658	132	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	132	7	of	of	IN
47658	132	8	which	which	WDT
47658	132	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	132	10	truth	truth	NN
47658	132	11	,	,	,
47658	132	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	132	13	not	not	RB
47658	132	14	the	the	DT
47658	132	15	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	132	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	132	17	of	of	IN
47658	132	18	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	132	19	but	but	CC
47658	132	20	the	the	DT
47658	132	21	inferred	infer	VBN
47658	132	22	reality	reality	NN
47658	132	23	of	of	IN
47658	132	24	thought	thought	NN
47658	132	25	.	.	.
47658	133	1	To	to	TO
47658	133	2	have	have	VB
47658	133	3	any	any	DT
47658	133	4	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
47658	133	5	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	133	6	,	,	,
47658	133	7	the	the	DT
47658	133	8	affirmation	affirmation	NN
47658	133	9	that	that	IN
47658	133	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	133	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	133	12	true	true	JJ
47658	133	13	supposes	suppose	NNS
47658	133	14	that	that	IN
47658	133	15	there	there	EX
47658	133	16	already	already	RB
47658	133	17	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	133	18	a	a	DT
47658	133	19	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	133	20	between	between	IN
47658	133	21	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	133	22	and	and	CC
47658	133	23	the	the	DT
47658	133	24	reality	reality	NN
47658	133	25	known	know	VBN
47658	133	26	,	,	,
47658	133	27	between	between	IN
47658	133	28	the	the	DT
47658	133	29	being	being	NN
47658	133	30	and	and	CC
47658	133	31	the	the	DT
47658	133	32	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	133	33	of	of	IN
47658	133	34	that	that	DT
47658	133	35	which	which	WDT
47658	133	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	133	37	known	know	VBN
47658	133	38	.	.	.
47658	134	1	In	in	IN
47658	134	2	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	134	3	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	134	4	,	,	,
47658	134	5	in	in	IN
47658	134	6	actual	actual	JJ
47658	134	7	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	134	8	felt	felt	NN
47658	134	9	experience	experience	NN
47658	134	10	there	there	EX
47658	134	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	134	12	no	no	DT
47658	134	13	such	such	JJ
47658	134	14	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	134	15	,	,	,
47658	134	16	and	and	CC
47658	134	17	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	134	18	to	to	TO
47658	134	19	affirm	affirm	VB
47658	134	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	134	21	or	or	CC
47658	134	22	error	error	NN
47658	134	23	of	of	IN
47658	134	24	such	such	JJ
47658	134	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	134	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	134	27	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
47658	134	28	.	.	.
47658	135	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	135	2	can	can	MD
47658	135	3	not	not	RB
47658	135	4	have	have	VB
47658	135	5	a	a	DT
47658	135	6	toothache	toothache	NN
47658	135	7	without	without	IN
47658	135	8	knowing	know	VBG
47658	135	9	that	that	IN
47658	135	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	135	11	have	have	VBP
47658	135	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	135	13	.	.	.
47658	136	1	In	in	IN
47658	136	2	the	the	DT
47658	136	3	actual	actual	JJ
47658	136	4	felt	feel	VBN
47658	136	5	toothache	toothache	NN
47658	136	6	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	136	7	and	and	CC
47658	136	8	being	being	NN
47658	136	9	are	be	VBP
47658	136	10	not	not	RB
47658	136	11	only	only	RB
47658	136	12	inseparable	inseparable	JJ
47658	136	13	--	--	:
47658	136	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	136	15	are	be	VBP
47658	136	16	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	JJ
47658	136	17	.	.	.
47658	137	1	If	if	IN
47658	137	2	,	,	,
47658	137	3	however	however	RB
47658	137	4	,	,	,
47658	137	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	137	6	think	think	VBP
47658	137	7	of	of	IN
47658	137	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	137	9	toothache	toothache	NN
47658	137	10	as	as	IN
47658	137	11	part	part	NN
47658	137	12	of	of	IN
47658	137	13	an	an	DT
47658	137	14	independent	independent	JJ
47658	137	15	order	order	NN
47658	137	16	of	of	IN
47658	137	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	137	18	,	,	,
47658	137	19	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	137	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	137	21	of	of	IN
47658	137	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	137	23	may	may	MD
47658	137	24	be	be	VB
47658	137	25	true	true	JJ
47658	137	26	or	or	CC
47658	137	27	false	false	JJ
47658	137	28	.	.	.
47658	138	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	138	2	am	be	VBP
47658	138	3	then	then	RB
47658	138	4	thinking	think	VBG
47658	138	5	of	of	IN
47658	138	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	138	7	as	as	IN
47658	138	8	the	the	DT
47658	138	9	effect	effect	NN
47658	138	10	of	of	IN
47658	138	11	an	an	DT
47658	138	12	exposed	expose	VBN
47658	138	13	nerve	nerve	NN
47658	138	14	,	,	,
47658	138	15	or	or	CC
47658	138	16	of	of	IN
47658	138	17	an	an	DT
47658	138	18	abscess	abscess	NN
47658	138	19	or	or	CC
47658	138	20	of	of	IN
47658	138	21	an	an	DT
47658	138	22	inflammation	inflammation	NN
47658	138	23	--	--	:
47658	138	24	as	as	IN
47658	138	25	something	something	NN
47658	138	26	,	,	,
47658	138	27	that	that	DT
47658	138	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	138	29	to	to	TO
47658	138	30	say	say	VB
47658	138	31	,	,	,
47658	138	32	that	that	WDT
47658	138	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	138	34	conditioned	condition	VBN
47658	138	35	independently	independently	RB
47658	138	36	of	of	IN
47658	138	37	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	138	38	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	138	39	and	and	CC
47658	138	40	that	that	WDT
47658	138	41	will	will	MD
47658	138	42	cease	cease	VB
47658	138	43	to	to	TO
47658	138	44	exist	exist	VB
47658	138	45	when	when	WRB
47658	138	46	the	the	DT
47658	138	47	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	138	48	are	be	VBP
47658	138	49	altered	alter	VBN
47658	138	50	.	.	.
47658	139	1	In	in	IN
47658	139	2	the	the	DT
47658	139	3	same	same	JJ
47658	139	4	way	way	NN
47658	139	5	,	,	,
47658	139	6	when	when	WRB
47658	139	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	139	8	behold	behold	VBP
47658	139	9	a	a	DT
47658	139	10	landscape	landscape	NN
47658	139	11	,	,	,
47658	139	12	the	the	DT
47658	139	13	blue	blue	JJ
47658	139	14	expanse	expanse	NN
47658	139	15	of	of	IN
47658	139	16	sky	sky	NN
47658	139	17	and	and	CC
47658	139	18	variegated	variegate	VBD
47658	139	19	colour	colour	NN
47658	139	20	of	of	IN
47658	139	21	the	the	DT
47658	139	22	land	land	NN
47658	139	23	which	which	WDT
47658	139	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	139	25	actually	actually	RB
47658	139	26	experience	experience	VBP
47658	139	27	are	be	VBP
47658	139	28	not	not	RB
47658	139	29	either	either	CC
47658	139	30	true	true	JJ
47658	139	31	or	or	CC
47658	139	32	false	false	JJ
47658	139	33	,	,	,
47658	139	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	139	35	are	be	VBP
47658	139	36	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	139	37	experience	experience	NN
47658	139	38	in	in	IN
47658	139	39	{	{	-LRB-
47658	139	40	19	19	CD
47658	139	41	}	}	-RRB-
47658	139	42	which	which	WDT
47658	139	43	knowing	know	VBG
47658	139	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	139	45	being	be	VBG
47658	139	46	and	and	CC
47658	139	47	being	be	VBG
47658	139	48	is	be	VBZ
47658	139	49	knowing	know	VBG
47658	139	50	.	.	.
47658	140	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	140	2	and	and	CC
47658	140	3	error	error	NN
47658	140	4	only	only	RB
47658	140	5	apply	apply	VB
47658	140	6	to	to	IN
47658	140	7	the	the	DT
47658	140	8	interpretation	interpretation	NN
47658	140	9	of	of	IN
47658	140	10	that	that	DT
47658	140	11	experience	experience	NN
47658	140	12	,	,	,
47658	140	13	to	to	IN
47658	140	14	the	the	DT
47658	140	15	independent	independent	JJ
47658	140	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	140	17	that	that	WDT
47658	140	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	140	19	infer	infer	VBP
47658	140	20	from	from	IN
47658	140	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	140	22	.	.	.
47658	141	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	141	2	can	can	MD
47658	141	3	,	,	,
47658	141	4	then	then	RB
47658	141	5	,	,	,
47658	141	6	distinguish	distinguish	VB
47658	141	7	two	two	CD
47658	141	8	kinds	kind	NNS
47658	141	9	of	of	IN
47658	141	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	141	11	which	which	WDT
47658	141	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	141	13	may	may	MD
47658	141	14	call	call	VB
47658	141	15	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	141	16	and	and	CC
47658	141	17	mediate	mediate	JJ
47658	141	18	,	,	,
47658	141	19	or	or	CC
47658	141	20	,	,	,
47658	141	21	better	well	JJR
47658	141	22	still	still	RB
47658	141	23	,	,	,
47658	141	24	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	141	25	and	and	CC
47658	141	26	description	description	NN
47658	141	27	.	.	.
47658	142	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
47658	142	2	,	,	,
47658	142	3	when	when	WRB
47658	142	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	142	5	say	say	VBP
47658	142	6	that	that	IN
47658	142	7	something	something	NN
47658	142	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	142	9	,	,	,
47658	142	10	or	or	CC
47658	142	11	when	when	WRB
47658	142	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	142	13	say	say	VBP
47658	142	14	of	of	IN
47658	142	15	anything	anything	NN
47658	142	16	that	that	WDT
47658	142	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	142	18	if	if	IN
47658	142	19	real	real	JJ
47658	142	20	,	,	,
47658	142	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	142	22	may	may	MD
47658	142	23	mean	mean	VB
47658	142	24	either	either	CC
47658	142	25	of	of	IN
47658	142	26	two	two	CD
47658	142	27	things	thing	NNS
47658	142	28	.	.	.
47658	143	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	2	may	may	MD
47658	143	3	mean	mean	VB
47658	143	4	that	that	IN
47658	143	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	143	7	part	part	NN
47658	143	8	of	of	IN
47658	143	9	the	the	DT
47658	143	10	changing	change	VBG
47658	143	11	existence	existence	NN
47658	143	12	that	that	IN
47658	143	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	14	actually	actually	RB
47658	143	15	feel	feel	VBP
47658	143	16	and	and	CC
47658	143	17	that	that	IN
47658	143	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	19	call	call	VBP
47658	143	20	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	143	21	or	or	CC
47658	143	22	life	life	NN
47658	143	23	,	,	,
47658	143	24	or	or	CC
47658	143	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	26	may	may	MD
47658	143	27	mean	mean	VB
47658	143	28	that	that	IN
47658	143	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	143	31	part	part	NN
47658	143	32	of	of	IN
47658	143	33	an	an	DT
47658	143	34	independent	independent	JJ
47658	143	35	order	order	NN
47658	143	36	of	of	IN
47658	143	37	things	thing	NNS
47658	143	38	whose	whose	WP$
47658	143	39	existence	existence	NN
47658	143	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	41	think	think	VBP
47658	143	42	about	about	IN
47658	143	43	in	in	IN
47658	143	44	order	order	NN
47658	143	45	to	to	TO
47658	143	46	explain	explain	VB
47658	143	47	,	,	,
47658	143	48	not	not	RB
47658	143	49	what	what	WP
47658	143	50	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	143	51	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	143	52	is	be	VBZ
47658	143	53	(	(	-LRB-
47658	143	54	there	there	EX
47658	143	55	can	can	MD
47658	143	56	be	be	VB
47658	143	57	no	no	DT
47658	143	58	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	143	59	of	of	IN
47658	143	60	this	this	DT
47658	143	61	)	)	-RRB-
47658	143	62	,	,	,
47658	143	63	but	but	CC
47658	143	64	how	how	WRB
47658	143	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	143	66	comes	come	VBZ
47658	143	67	to	to	TO
47658	143	68	exist	exist	VB
47658	143	69	.	.	.
47658	144	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	144	2	know	know	VBP
47658	144	3	by	by	IN
47658	144	4	description	description	NN
47658	144	5	a	a	DT
47658	144	6	vast	vast	JJ
47658	144	7	number	number	NN
47658	144	8	of	of	IN
47658	144	9	things	thing	NNS
47658	144	10	with	with	IN
47658	144	11	which	which	WDT
47658	144	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	144	13	never	never	RB
47658	144	14	can	can	MD
47658	144	15	be	be	VB
47658	144	16	actually	actually	RB
47658	144	17	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	144	18	.	.	.
47658	145	1	Such	such	JJ
47658	145	2	,	,	,
47658	145	3	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	145	4	,	,	,
47658	145	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	145	6	the	the	DT
47658	145	7	case	case	NN
47658	145	8	with	with	IN
47658	145	9	all	all	PDT
47658	145	10	the	the	DT
47658	145	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	145	12	by	by	IN
47658	145	13	which	which	WDT
47658	145	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	145	15	rule	rule	VBP
47658	145	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	145	17	lives	life	NNS
47658	145	18	and	and	CC
47658	145	19	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	145	20	the	the	DT
47658	145	21	reality	reality	NN
47658	145	22	which	which	WDT
47658	145	23	environs	environ	VBZ
47658	145	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	145	25	.	.	.
47658	146	1	Yet	yet	CC
47658	146	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	146	3	are	be	VBP
47658	146	4	absolutely	absolutely	RB
47658	146	5	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	146	6	on	on	IN
47658	146	7	the	the	DT
47658	146	8	reality	reality	NN
47658	146	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	146	10	know	know	VBP
47658	146	11	by	by	IN
47658	146	12	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	146	13	for	for	IN
47658	146	14	all	all	DT
47658	146	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	146	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	146	17	of	of	IN
47658	146	18	these	these	DT
47658	146	19	things	thing	NNS
47658	146	20	.	.	.
47658	147	1	Not	not	RB
47658	147	2	only	only	RB
47658	147	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	147	4	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	147	5	sense	sense	NN
47658	147	6	experience	experience	NN
47658	147	7	and	and	CC
47658	147	8	the	the	DT
47658	147	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	147	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	11	gives	give	VBZ
47658	147	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	13	by	by	IN
47658	147	14	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	147	15	the	the	DT
47658	147	16	only	only	JJ
47658	147	17	evidence	evidence	NN
47658	147	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	19	have	have	VBP
47658	147	20	of	of	IN
47658	147	21	the	the	DT
47658	147	22	greater	great	JJR
47658	147	23	and	and	CC
47658	147	24	wider	wide	JJR
47658	147	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	147	26	,	,	,
47658	147	27	but	but	CC
47658	147	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	29	are	be	VBP
47658	147	30	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	147	31	on	on	IN
47658	147	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	33	for	for	IN
47658	147	34	the	the	DT
47658	147	35	terms	term	NNS
47658	147	36	wherewith	wherewith	VBG
47658	147	37	to	to	TO
47658	147	38	describe	describe	VB
47658	147	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	40	,	,	,
47658	147	41	for	for	IN
47658	147	42	the	the	DT
47658	147	43	form	form	NN
47658	147	44	in	in	IN
47658	147	45	which	which	WDT
47658	147	46	to	to	TO
47658	147	47	present	present	VB
47658	147	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	49	,	,	,
47658	147	50	for	for	IN
47658	147	51	the	the	DT
47658	147	52	matter	matter	NN
47658	147	53	with	with	IN
47658	147	54	which	which	WDT
47658	147	55	to	to	TO
47658	147	56	compose	compose	VB
47658	147	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	147	58	.	.	.
47658	148	1	And	and	CC
47658	148	2	this	this	DT
47658	148	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	148	4	the	the	DT
47658	148	5	real	real	JJ
47658	148	6	ground	ground	NN
47658	148	7	of	of	IN
47658	148	8	the	the	DT
47658	148	9	study	study	NN
47658	148	10	of	of	IN
47658	148	11	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	148	12	,	,	,
47658	148	13	the	the	DT
47658	148	14	justification	justification	NN
47658	148	15	of	of	IN
47658	148	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	148	17	standpoint	standpoint	NN
47658	148	18	.	.	.
47658	149	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	149	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	149	3	this	this	DT
47658	149	4	fact	fact	NN
47658	149	5	--	--	:
47658	149	6	this	this	DT
47658	149	7	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	149	8	undeniable	undeniable	JJ
47658	149	9	fact	fact	NN
47658	149	10	--	--	:
47658	149	11	that	that	IN
47658	149	12	all	all	DT
47658	149	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	149	14	of	of	IN
47658	149	15	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	149	16	kind	kind	NN
47658	149	17	and	and	CC
47658	149	18	in	in	IN
47658	149	19	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	149	20	way	way	NN
47658	149	21	known	know	VBN
47658	149	22	,	,	,
47658	149	23	whether	whether	IN
47658	149	24	by	by	IN
47658	149	25	thought	thought	NN
47658	149	26	or	or	CC
47658	149	27	by	by	IN
47658	149	28	feeling	feel	VBG
47658	149	29	,	,	,
47658	149	30	whether	whether	IN
47658	149	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	149	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	149	33	perceived	perceive	VBN
47658	149	34	or	or	CC
47658	149	35	conceived	conceive	VBN
47658	149	36	,	,	,
47658	149	37	remembered	remember	VBD
47658	149	38	or	or	CC
47658	149	39	imagined	imagine	VBN
47658	149	40	,	,	,
47658	149	41	is	be	VBZ
47658	149	42	in	in	IN
47658	149	43	the	the	DT
47658	149	44	end	end	NN
47658	149	45	composed	compose	VBN
47658	149	46	of	of	IN
47658	149	47	sense	sense	NN
47658	149	48	experience	experience	NN
47658	149	49	:	:	:
47658	149	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	149	51	is	be	VBZ
47658	149	52	this	this	DT
47658	149	53	fact	fact	NN
47658	149	54	from	from	IN
47658	149	55	which	which	WDT
47658	149	56	all	all	PDT
47658	149	57	the	the	DT
47658	149	58	problems	problem	NNS
47658	149	59	of	of	IN
47658	149	60	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	149	61	arise	arise	NN
47658	149	62	.	.	.
47658	150	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	150	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	150	3	this	this	DT
47658	150	4	fact	fact	NN
47658	150	5	that	that	IN
47658	150	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	150	7	utilitarian	utilitarian	JJ
47658	150	8	men	man	NNS
47658	150	9	of	of	IN
47658	150	10	science	science	NN
47658	150	11	find	find	VBP
47658	150	12	{	{	-LRB-
47658	150	13	20	20	CD
47658	150	14	}	}	-RRB-
47658	150	15	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	150	16	forced	force	VBN
47658	150	17	to	to	TO
47658	150	18	recognise	recognise	VB
47658	150	19	,	,	,
47658	150	20	however	however	RB
47658	150	21	scornful	scornful	JJ
47658	150	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	150	23	may	may	MD
47658	150	24	be	be	VB
47658	150	25	of	of	IN
47658	150	26	metaphysical	metaphysical	JJ
47658	150	27	methods	method	NNS
47658	150	28	and	and	CC
47658	150	29	results	result	NNS
47658	150	30	.	.	.
47658	151	1	The	the	DT
47658	151	2	special	special	JJ
47658	151	3	problem	problem	NN
47658	151	4	of	of	IN
47658	151	5	the	the	DT
47658	151	6	nature	nature	NN
47658	151	7	of	of	IN
47658	151	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	151	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	151	10	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	151	11	,	,	,
47658	151	12	then	then	RB
47658	151	13	,	,	,
47658	151	14	with	with	IN
47658	151	15	the	the	DT
47658	151	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	151	17	that	that	WDT
47658	151	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	151	19	have	have	VBP
47658	151	20	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
47658	151	21	as	as	IN
47658	151	22	known	know	VBN
47658	151	23	by	by	IN
47658	151	24	description	description	NN
47658	151	25	,	,	,
47658	151	26	and	and	CC
47658	151	27	conceived	conceive	VBN
47658	151	28	by	by	IN
47658	151	29	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	151	30	as	as	IN
47658	151	31	independent	independent	JJ
47658	151	32	in	in	IN
47658	151	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	151	34	existence	existence	NN
47658	151	35	of	of	IN
47658	151	36	the	the	DT
47658	151	37	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	151	38	by	by	IN
47658	151	39	which	which	WDT
47658	151	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	151	41	know	know	VBP
47658	151	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	151	43	.	.	.
47658	152	1	What	what	WP
47658	152	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	152	3	the	the	DT
47658	152	4	nature	nature	NN
47658	152	5	of	of	IN
47658	152	6	the	the	DT
47658	152	7	seal	seal	NN
47658	152	8	by	by	IN
47658	152	9	which	which	WDT
47658	152	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	152	11	stamp	stamp	VBP
47658	152	12	this	this	DT
47658	152	13	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	152	14	true	true	JJ
47658	152	15	?	?	.
47658	153	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
47658	153	2	III	III	NNP
47658	153	3	THE	the	DT
47658	153	4	LOGICAL	LOGICAL	NNP
47658	153	5	THEORIES	theory	NNS
47658	153	6	Whoever	whoever	WP
47658	153	7	cares	care	VBZ
47658	153	8	to	to	TO
47658	153	9	become	become	VB
47658	153	10	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	153	11	with	with	IN
47658	153	12	the	the	DT
47658	153	13	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	153	14	of	of	IN
47658	153	15	the	the	DT
47658	153	16	problem	problem	NN
47658	153	17	of	of	IN
47658	153	18	truth	truth	NN
47658	153	19	must	must	MD
47658	153	20	not	not	RB
47658	153	21	be	be	VB
47658	153	22	impatient	impatient	JJ
47658	153	23	of	of	IN
47658	153	24	dialectical	dialectical	JJ
47658	153	25	subtleties	subtlety	NNS
47658	153	26	.	.	.
47658	154	1	There	there	EX
47658	154	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	154	3	a	a	DT
47658	154	4	well	well	RB
47658	154	5	-	-	HYPH
47658	154	6	known	know	VBN
47658	154	7	story	story	NN
47658	154	8	in	in	IN
47658	154	9	Boswell	Boswell	NNP
47658	154	10	's	's	POS
47658	154	11	_	_	NNP
47658	154	12	Life	Life	NNP
47658	154	13	of	of	IN
47658	154	14	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	154	15	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
47658	154	16	_	_	NNP
47658	154	17	which	which	WDT
47658	154	18	relates	relate	VBZ
47658	154	19	how	how	WRB
47658	154	20	the	the	DT
47658	154	21	Doctor	Doctor	NNP
47658	154	22	refuted	refute	VBD
47658	154	23	Berkeley	Berkeley	NNP
47658	154	24	's	's	POS
47658	154	25	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	154	26	which	which	WDT
47658	154	27	affirmed	affirm	VBD
47658	154	28	the	the	DT
47658	154	29	non	non	JJ
47658	154	30	-	-	NN
47658	154	31	existence	existence	NN
47658	154	32	of	of	IN
47658	154	33	matter	matter	NN
47658	154	34	.	.	.
47658	155	1	"	"	``
47658	155	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	155	3	observed	observe	VBD
47658	155	4	,	,	,
47658	155	5	"	"	''
47658	155	6	says	say	VBZ
47658	155	7	Boswell	Boswell	NNP
47658	155	8	,	,	,
47658	155	9	"	"	``
47658	155	10	that	that	IN
47658	155	11	though	though	IN
47658	155	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	155	13	are	be	VBP
47658	155	14	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
47658	155	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	155	16	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	155	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	155	18	not	not	RB
47658	155	19	true	true	JJ
47658	155	20	,	,	,
47658	155	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	155	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	155	23	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	155	24	to	to	TO
47658	155	25	refute	refute	VB
47658	155	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	155	27	.	.	.
47658	156	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	156	2	shall	shall	MD
47658	156	3	never	never	RB
47658	156	4	forget	forget	VB
47658	156	5	the	the	DT
47658	156	6	alacrity	alacrity	NN
47658	156	7	with	with	IN
47658	156	8	which	which	WDT
47658	156	9	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
47658	156	10	answered	answer	VBD
47658	156	11	,	,	,
47658	156	12	striking	strike	VBG
47658	156	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	156	14	foot	foot	NN
47658	156	15	with	with	IN
47658	156	16	mighty	mighty	JJ
47658	156	17	force	force	NN
47658	156	18	against	against	IN
47658	156	19	a	a	DT
47658	156	20	large	large	JJ
47658	156	21	stone	stone	NN
47658	156	22	,	,	,
47658	156	23	till	till	IN
47658	156	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	156	25	rebounded	rebound	VBD
47658	156	26	from	from	IN
47658	156	27	it--'I	it--'I	:
47658	156	28	refute	refute	VB
47658	156	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	156	30	_	_	NNP
47658	156	31	thus	thus	RB
47658	156	32	_	_	NNP
47658	156	33	.	.	.
47658	156	34	'	'	''
47658	156	35	"	"	''
47658	157	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	157	2	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
47658	157	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	157	4	the	the	DT
47658	157	5	representative	representative	NN
47658	157	6	of	of	IN
47658	157	7	robust	robust	JJ
47658	157	8	common	common	JJ
47658	157	9	sense	sense	NN
47658	157	10	.	.	.
47658	158	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	158	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	158	3	very	very	RB
47658	158	4	often	often	RB
47658	158	5	turned	turn	VBN
47658	158	6	out	out	RP
47658	158	7	in	in	IN
47658	158	8	metaphysical	metaphysical	JJ
47658	158	9	disputes	dispute	NNS
47658	158	10	that	that	IN
47658	158	11	the	the	DT
47658	158	12	common	common	JJ
47658	158	13	-	-	HYPH
47658	158	14	sense	sense	NN
47658	158	15	answer	answer	NN
47658	158	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	158	17	the	the	DT
47658	158	18	one	one	NN
47658	158	19	that	that	WDT
47658	158	20	has	have	VBZ
47658	158	21	been	be	VBN
47658	158	22	justified	justify	VBN
47658	158	23	in	in	IN
47658	158	24	the	the	DT
47658	158	25	end	end	NN
47658	158	26	.	.	.
47658	159	1	Those	those	DT
47658	159	2	who	who	WP
47658	159	3	are	be	VBP
47658	159	4	impatient	impatient	JJ
47658	159	5	of	of	IN
47658	159	6	metaphysics	metaphysic	NNS
47658	159	7	are	be	VBP
47658	159	8	,	,	,
47658	159	9	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	159	10	,	,	,
47658	159	11	not	not	RB
47658	159	12	without	without	IN
47658	159	13	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
47658	159	14	ground	ground	NN
47658	159	15	;	;	:
47658	159	16	and	and	CC
47658	159	17	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	159	18	the	the	DT
47658	159	19	strong	strong	JJ
47658	159	20	belief	belief	NN
47658	159	21	that	that	IN
47658	159	22	the	the	DT
47658	159	23	common	common	JJ
47658	159	24	-	-	HYPH
47658	159	25	sense	sense	NN
47658	159	26	view	view	NN
47658	159	27	will	will	MD
47658	159	28	be	be	VB
47658	159	29	justified	justify	VBN
47658	159	30	in	in	IN
47658	159	31	the	the	DT
47658	159	32	end	end	NN
47658	159	33	,	,	,
47658	159	34	however	however	RB
47658	159	35	powerful	powerful	JJ
47658	159	36	the	the	DT
47658	159	37	sceptical	sceptical	JJ
47658	159	38	doubt	doubt	NN
47658	159	39	that	that	WDT
47658	159	40	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	159	41	to	to	TO
47658	159	42	contradict	contradict	VB
47658	159	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	159	44	,	,	,
47658	159	45	however	however	RB
47658	159	46	startling	startle	VBG
47658	159	47	the	the	DT
47658	159	48	paradox	paradox	NN
47658	159	49	that	that	WDT
47658	159	50	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	159	51	to	to	TO
47658	159	52	be	be	VB
47658	159	53	involved	involve	VBN
47658	159	54	in	in	IN
47658	159	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	159	56	,	,	,
47658	159	57	is	be	VBZ
47658	159	58	a	a	DT
47658	159	59	possession	possession	NN
47658	159	60	of	of	IN
47658	159	61	the	the	DT
47658	159	62	human	human	JJ
47658	159	63	mind	mind	NN
47658	159	64	without	without	IN
47658	159	65	which	which	WDT
47658	159	66	the	the	DT
47658	159	67	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	159	68	{	{	-LRB-
47658	159	69	21	21	CD
47658	159	70	}	}	-RRB-
47658	159	71	practical	practical	JJ
47658	159	72	conduct	conduct	NN
47658	159	73	of	of	IN
47658	159	74	life	life	NN
47658	159	75	would	would	MD
47658	159	76	be	be	VB
47658	159	77	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	159	78	.	.	.
47658	160	1	When	when	WRB
47658	160	2	,	,	,
47658	160	3	then	then	RB
47658	160	4	,	,	,
47658	160	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	160	6	ask	ask	VBP
47658	160	7	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	160	8	,	,	,
47658	160	9	What	what	WP
47658	160	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	160	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	160	12	?	?	.
47658	161	1	the	the	DT
47658	161	2	answer	answer	NN
47658	161	3	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	161	4	to	to	TO
47658	161	5	be	be	VB
47658	161	6	simple	simple	JJ
47658	161	7	and	and	CC
47658	161	8	obvious	obvious	JJ
47658	161	9	.	.	.
47658	162	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	162	2	,	,	,
47658	162	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	162	4	reply	reply	VBP
47658	162	5	,	,	,
47658	162	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	162	7	a	a	DT
47658	162	8	property	property	NN
47658	162	9	of	of	IN
47658	162	10	certain	certain	JJ
47658	162	11	of	of	IN
47658	162	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	162	13	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	162	14	;	;	:
47658	162	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	162	16	means	mean	VBZ
47658	162	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	162	18	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	162	19	,	,	,
47658	162	20	as	as	IN
47658	162	21	falsity	falsity	NN
47658	162	22	means	mean	VBZ
47658	162	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	162	24	disagreement	disagreement	NN
47658	162	25	,	,	,
47658	162	26	with	with	IN
47658	162	27	reality	reality	NN
47658	162	28	.	.	.
47658	163	1	If	if	IN
47658	163	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	163	3	say	say	VBP
47658	163	4	of	of	IN
47658	163	5	anything	anything	NN
47658	163	6	that	that	WDT
47658	163	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	163	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	163	9	so	so	RB
47658	163	10	,	,	,
47658	163	11	then	then	RB
47658	163	12	,	,	,
47658	163	13	if	if	IN
47658	163	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	163	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	163	16	so	so	RB
47658	163	17	,	,	,
47658	163	18	what	what	WP
47658	163	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	163	20	say	say	VBP
47658	163	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	163	22	true	true	JJ
47658	163	23	;	;	:
47658	163	24	if	if	IN
47658	163	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	163	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	163	27	not	not	RB
47658	163	28	so	so	RB
47658	163	29	,	,	,
47658	163	30	then	then	RB
47658	163	31	what	what	WP
47658	163	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	163	33	say	say	VBP
47658	163	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	163	35	false	false	JJ
47658	163	36	.	.	.
47658	164	1	This	this	DT
47658	164	2	simple	simple	JJ
47658	164	3	definition	definition	NN
47658	164	4	of	of	IN
47658	164	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	164	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	164	7	one	one	NN
47658	164	8	that	that	WDT
47658	164	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	164	10	universally	universally	RB
47658	164	11	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	164	12	.	.	.
47658	165	1	No	no	DT
47658	165	2	one	one	NN
47658	165	3	really	really	RB
47658	165	4	can	can	MD
47658	165	5	deny	deny	VB
47658	165	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	165	7	,	,	,
47658	165	8	for	for	IN
47658	165	9	if	if	IN
47658	165	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	165	11	did	do	VBD
47658	165	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	165	13	would	would	MD
47658	165	14	have	have	VB
47658	165	15	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	165	16	to	to	TO
47658	165	17	appeal	appeal	VB
47658	165	18	to	to	IN
47658	165	19	to	to	TO
47658	165	20	justify	justify	VB
47658	165	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	165	22	own	own	JJ
47658	165	23	theory	theory	NN
47658	165	24	or	or	CC
47658	165	25	condemn	condemn	VB
47658	165	26	another	another	DT
47658	165	27	.	.	.
47658	166	1	The	the	DT
47658	166	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	166	3	of	of	IN
47658	166	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	166	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	166	6	only	only	RB
47658	166	7	raised	raise	VBN
47658	166	8	when	when	WRB
47658	166	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	166	10	ask	ask	VBP
47658	166	11	,	,	,
47658	166	12	What	what	WP
47658	166	13	does	do	VBZ
47658	166	14	the	the	DT
47658	166	15	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	166	16	of	of	IN
47658	166	17	an	an	DT
47658	166	18	idea	idea	NN
47658	166	19	with	with	IN
47658	166	20	reality	reality	NN
47658	166	21	mean	mean	VB
47658	166	22	?	?	.
47658	167	1	If	if	IN
47658	167	2	the	the	DT
47658	167	3	reader	reader	NN
47658	167	4	will	will	MD
47658	167	5	ask	ask	VB
47658	167	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	167	7	that	that	IN
47658	167	8	question	question	NN
47658	167	9	,	,	,
47658	167	10	and	and	CC
47658	167	11	carefully	carefully	RB
47658	167	12	ponder	ponder	VB
47658	167	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	167	14	,	,	,
47658	167	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	167	16	will	will	MD
47658	167	17	see	see	VB
47658	167	18	that	that	IN
47658	167	19	there	there	EX
47658	167	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	167	21	some	some	DT
47658	167	22	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	167	23	in	in	IN
47658	167	24	the	the	DT
47658	167	25	answer	answer	NN
47658	167	26	to	to	IN
47658	167	27	the	the	DT
47658	167	28	simple	simple	JJ
47658	167	29	question	question	NN
47658	167	30	,	,	,
47658	167	31	What	what	WP
47658	167	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	167	33	truth	truth	NN
47658	167	34	?	?	.
47658	168	1	The	the	DT
47658	168	2	answer	answer	NN
47658	168	3	that	that	WDT
47658	168	4	will	will	MD
47658	168	5	probably	probably	RB
47658	168	6	first	first	RB
47658	168	7	of	of	IN
47658	168	8	all	all	DT
47658	168	9	suggest	suggest	VBP
47658	168	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	168	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	168	12	that	that	IN
47658	168	13	the	the	DT
47658	168	14	idea	idea	NN
47658	168	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	168	16	a	a	DT
47658	168	17	copy	copy	NN
47658	168	18	of	of	IN
47658	168	19	the	the	DT
47658	168	20	reality	reality	NN
47658	168	21	.	.	.
47658	169	1	And	and	CC
47658	169	2	at	at	IN
47658	169	3	once	once	RB
47658	169	4	many	many	JJ
47658	169	5	experiences	experience	NNS
47658	169	6	will	will	MD
47658	169	7	seem	seem	VB
47658	169	8	to	to	TO
47658	169	9	confirm	confirm	VB
47658	169	10	this	this	DT
47658	169	11	view	view	NN
47658	169	12	.	.	.
47658	170	1	Thus	thus	RB
47658	170	2	when	when	WRB
47658	170	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	170	4	look	look	VBP
47658	170	5	at	at	IN
47658	170	6	a	a	DT
47658	170	7	landscape	landscape	NN
47658	170	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	170	9	know	know	VBP
47658	170	10	that	that	IN
47658	170	11	the	the	DT
47658	170	12	lines	line	NNS
47658	170	13	of	of	IN
47658	170	14	light	light	NN
47658	170	15	which	which	WDT
47658	170	16	radiate	radiate	VBP
47658	170	17	from	from	IN
47658	170	18	every	every	DT
47658	170	19	point	point	NN
47658	170	20	of	of	IN
47658	170	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	170	22	pass	pass	VB
47658	170	23	through	through	IN
47658	170	24	the	the	DT
47658	170	25	lens	lens	NN
47658	170	26	of	of	IN
47658	170	27	each	each	DT
47658	170	28	of	of	IN
47658	170	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	170	30	eyes	eye	NNS
47658	170	31	to	to	TO
47658	170	32	be	be	VB
47658	170	33	focussed	focusse	VBN
47658	170	34	on	on	IN
47658	170	35	the	the	DT
47658	170	36	retina	retina	NNP
47658	170	37	,	,	,
47658	170	38	forming	form	VBG
47658	170	39	there	there	RB
47658	170	40	a	a	DT
47658	170	41	small	small	JJ
47658	170	42	picture	picture	NN
47658	170	43	which	which	WDT
47658	170	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	170	45	the	the	DT
47658	170	46	exact	exact	JJ
47658	170	47	counterpart	counterpart	NN
47658	170	48	of	of	IN
47658	170	49	the	the	DT
47658	170	50	reality	reality	NN
47658	170	51	.	.	.
47658	171	1	If	if	IN
47658	171	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	171	3	look	look	VBP
47658	171	4	into	into	IN
47658	171	5	another	another	DT
47658	171	6	person	person	NN
47658	171	7	's	's	POS
47658	171	8	eye	eye	NN
47658	171	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	171	10	may	may	MD
47658	171	11	see	see	VB
47658	171	12	there	there	RB
47658	171	13	a	a	DT
47658	171	14	picture	picture	NN
47658	171	15	of	of	IN
47658	171	16	the	the	DT
47658	171	17	whole	whole	JJ
47658	171	18	field	field	NN
47658	171	19	of	of	IN
47658	171	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	171	21	vision	vision	NN
47658	171	22	reflected	reflect	VBD
47658	171	23	from	from	IN
47658	171	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	171	25	lens	lens	NN
47658	171	26	.	.	.
47658	172	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	172	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	172	3	true	true	JJ
47658	172	4	that	that	IN
47658	172	5	what	what	WP
47658	172	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	172	7	see	see	VBP
47658	172	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	172	9	not	not	RB
47658	172	10	what	what	WP
47658	172	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	172	12	sees	see	VBZ
47658	172	13	,	,	,
47658	172	14	for	for	IN
47658	172	15	that	that	DT
47658	172	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	172	17	on	on	IN
47658	172	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	172	19	retina	retina	NN
47658	172	20	,	,	,
47658	172	21	but	but	CC
47658	172	22	the	the	DT
47658	172	23	analogy	analogy	NN
47658	172	24	of	of	IN
47658	172	25	this	this	DT
47658	172	26	with	with	IN
47658	172	27	a	a	DT
47658	172	28	photographic	photographic	JJ
47658	172	29	camera	camera	NN
47658	172	30	,	,	,
47658	172	31	where	where	WRB
47658	172	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	172	33	see	see	VBP
47658	172	34	the	the	DT
47658	172	35	picture	picture	NN
47658	172	36	on	on	IN
47658	172	37	the	the	DT
47658	172	38	ground	ground	NN
47658	172	39	glass	glass	NN
47658	172	40	,	,	,
47658	172	41	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	172	42	obvious	obvious	JJ
47658	172	43	and	and	CC
47658	172	44	natural	natural	JJ
47658	172	45	;	;	:
47658	172	46	and	and	CC
47658	172	47	so	so	RB
47658	172	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	172	49	think	think	VBP
47658	172	50	of	of	IN
47658	172	51	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	172	52	,	,	,
47658	172	53	so	so	RB
47658	172	54	far	far	RB
47658	172	55	as	as	IN
47658	172	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	172	57	depends	depend	VBZ
47658	172	58	on	on	IN
47658	172	59	the	the	DT
47658	172	60	sense	sense	NN
47658	172	61	of	of	IN
47658	172	62	vision	vision	NN
47658	172	63	,	,	,
47658	172	64	as	as	IN
47658	172	65	consisting	consist	VBG
47658	172	66	in	in	IN
47658	172	67	more	more	RBR
47658	172	68	or	or	CC
47658	172	69	less	less	RBR
47658	172	70	vivid	vivid	JJ
47658	172	71	,	,	,
47658	172	72	more	more	RBR
47658	172	73	or	or	CC
47658	172	74	less	less	RBR
47658	172	75	faded	faded	JJ
47658	172	76	,	,	,
47658	172	77	copies	copy	NNS
47658	172	78	of	of	IN
47658	172	79	real	real	JJ
47658	172	80	things	thing	NNS
47658	172	81	stored	store	VBN
47658	172	82	up	up	RP
47658	172	83	by	by	IN
47658	172	84	the	the	DT
47658	172	85	memory	memory	NN
47658	172	86	.	.	.
47658	173	1	But	but	CC
47658	173	2	a	a	DT
47658	173	3	very	very	RB
47658	173	4	little	little	JJ
47658	173	5	reflection	reflection	NN
47658	173	6	will	will	MD
47658	173	7	convince	convince	VB
47658	173	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	173	9	that	that	IN
47658	173	10	the	the	DT
47658	173	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	173	12	of	of	IN
47658	173	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	173	14	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	173	15	can	can	MD
47658	173	16	not	not	RB
47658	173	17	consist	consist	VB
47658	173	18	in	in	IN
47658	173	19	the	the	DT
47658	173	20	fact	fact	NN
47658	173	21	{	{	-LRB-
47658	173	22	22	22	CD
47658	173	23	}	}	-RRB-
47658	173	24	that	that	IN
47658	173	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	173	26	are	be	VBP
47658	173	27	copies	copy	NNS
47658	173	28	of	of	IN
47658	173	29	realities	reality	NNS
47658	173	30	,	,	,
47658	173	31	for	for	IN
47658	173	32	clearly	clearly	RB
47658	173	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	173	34	are	be	VBP
47658	173	35	not	not	RB
47658	173	36	copies	copy	NNS
47658	173	37	in	in	IN
47658	173	38	any	any	DT
47658	173	39	possible	possible	JJ
47658	173	40	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	173	41	of	of	IN
47658	173	42	the	the	DT
47658	173	43	term	term	NN
47658	173	44	.	.	.
47658	174	1	Take	take	VB
47658	174	2	,	,	,
47658	174	3	for	for	IN
47658	174	4	example	example	NN
47658	174	5	,	,	,
47658	174	6	this	this	DT
47658	174	7	very	very	JJ
47658	174	8	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	174	9	of	of	IN
47658	174	10	seeing	see	VBG
47658	174	11	a	a	DT
47658	174	12	landscape	landscape	NN
47658	174	13	:	:	:
47658	174	14	what	what	WP
47658	174	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	174	16	see	see	VBP
47658	174	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	174	18	not	not	RB
47658	174	19	a	a	DT
47658	174	20	picture	picture	NN
47658	174	21	or	or	CC
47658	174	22	copy	copy	NN
47658	174	23	of	of	IN
47658	174	24	the	the	DT
47658	174	25	landscape	landscape	NN
47658	174	26	,	,	,
47658	174	27	but	but	CC
47658	174	28	the	the	DT
47658	174	29	real	real	JJ
47658	174	30	landscape	landscape	NN
47658	174	31	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	174	32	.	.	.
47658	175	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	175	2	feel	feel	VBP
47658	175	3	quite	quite	RB
47658	175	4	sure	sure	JJ
47658	175	5	of	of	IN
47658	175	6	this	this	DT
47658	175	7	,	,	,
47658	175	8	and	and	CC
47658	175	9	with	with	IN
47658	175	10	regard	regard	NN
47658	175	11	to	to	IN
47658	175	12	the	the	DT
47658	175	13	other	other	JJ
47658	175	14	sensations	sensation	NNS
47658	175	15	,	,	,
47658	175	16	those	those	DT
47658	175	17	that	that	WDT
47658	175	18	come	come	VBP
47658	175	19	to	to	IN
47658	175	20	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	175	21	by	by	IN
47658	175	22	hearing	hear	VBG
47658	175	23	,	,	,
47658	175	24	taste	taste	NN
47658	175	25	,	,	,
47658	175	26	smell	smell	NN
47658	175	27	,	,	,
47658	175	28	touch	touch	NN
47658	175	29	,	,	,
47658	175	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	175	31	would	would	MD
47658	175	32	seem	seem	VB
47658	175	33	highly	highly	RB
47658	175	34	absurd	absurd	JJ
47658	175	35	to	to	TO
47658	175	36	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	175	37	that	that	IN
47658	175	38	the	the	DT
47658	175	39	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	175	40	these	these	DT
47658	175	41	sensations	sensation	NNS
47658	175	42	produce	produce	VBP
47658	175	43	in	in	IN
47658	175	44	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	175	45	are	be	VBP
47658	175	46	copies	copy	NNS
47658	175	47	of	of	IN
47658	175	48	real	real	JJ
47658	175	49	things	thing	NNS
47658	175	50	.	.	.
47658	176	1	The	the	DT
47658	176	2	pain	pain	NN
47658	176	3	of	of	IN
47658	176	4	burning	burning	NN
47658	176	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	176	6	not	not	RB
47658	176	7	a	a	DT
47658	176	8	copy	copy	NN
47658	176	9	of	of	IN
47658	176	10	real	real	JJ
47658	176	11	fire	fire	NN
47658	176	12	,	,	,
47658	176	13	and	and	CC
47658	176	14	the	the	DT
47658	176	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	176	16	of	of	IN
47658	176	17	the	the	DT
47658	176	18	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	176	19	,	,	,
47658	176	20	Fire	Fire	NNP
47658	176	21	burns	burn	NNS
47658	176	22	,	,	,
47658	176	23	does	do	VBZ
47658	176	24	not	not	RB
47658	176	25	consist	consist	VB
47658	176	26	in	in	IN
47658	176	27	the	the	DT
47658	176	28	fact	fact	NN
47658	176	29	that	that	IN
47658	176	30	the	the	DT
47658	176	31	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	176	32	denoted	denote	VBN
47658	176	33	by	by	IN
47658	176	34	the	the	DT
47658	176	35	words	word	NNS
47658	176	36	"	"	``
47658	176	37	fire	fire	NN
47658	176	38	,	,	,
47658	176	39	"	"	''
47658	176	40	"	"	``
47658	176	41	burns	burn	NNS
47658	176	42	,	,	,
47658	176	43	"	"	''
47658	176	44	faithfully	faithfully	RB
47658	176	45	copy	copy	VBP
47658	176	46	certain	certain	JJ
47658	176	47	real	real	JJ
47658	176	48	things	thing	NNS
47658	176	49	which	which	WDT
47658	176	50	are	be	VBP
47658	176	51	not	not	RB
47658	176	52	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	176	53	.	.	.
47658	177	1	And	and	CC
47658	177	2	the	the	DT
47658	177	3	whole	whole	JJ
47658	177	4	notion	notion	NN
47658	177	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	177	6	seen	see	VBN
47658	177	7	to	to	TO
47658	177	8	be	be	VB
47658	177	9	absurd	absurd	JJ
47658	177	10	if	if	IN
47658	177	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	12	consider	consider	VBP
47658	177	13	that	that	DT
47658	177	14	,	,	,
47658	177	15	were	be	VBD
47658	177	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	17	a	a	DT
47658	177	18	fact	fact	NN
47658	177	19	that	that	IN
47658	177	20	real	real	JJ
47658	177	21	things	thing	NNS
47658	177	22	produce	produce	VBP
47658	177	23	copies	copy	NNS
47658	177	24	of	of	IN
47658	177	25	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	26	in	in	IN
47658	177	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	177	28	mind	mind	NN
47658	177	29	,	,	,
47658	177	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	31	could	could	MD
47658	177	32	never	never	RB
47658	177	33	know	know	VB
47658	177	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	35	was	be	VBD
47658	177	36	so	so	RB
47658	177	37	--	--	:
47658	177	38	all	all	DT
47658	177	39	that	that	WDT
47658	177	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	41	should	should	MD
47658	177	42	have	have	VB
47658	177	43	any	any	DT
47658	177	44	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	177	45	of	of	IN
47658	177	46	would	would	MD
47658	177	47	be	be	VB
47658	177	48	the	the	DT
47658	177	49	copies	copy	NNS
47658	177	50	,	,	,
47658	177	51	and	and	CC
47658	177	52	whether	whether	IN
47658	177	53	these	these	DT
47658	177	54	were	be	VBD
47658	177	55	like	like	IN
47658	177	56	or	or	CC
47658	177	57	unlike	unlike	IN
47658	177	58	the	the	DT
47658	177	59	reality	reality	NN
47658	177	60	,	,	,
47658	177	61	or	or	CC
47658	177	62	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	177	63	whether	whether	IN
47658	177	64	there	there	EX
47658	177	65	was	be	VBD
47658	177	66	any	any	DT
47658	177	67	reality	reality	NN
47658	177	68	for	for	IN
47658	177	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	70	to	to	TO
47658	177	71	be	be	VB
47658	177	72	like	like	IN
47658	177	73	would	would	MD
47658	177	74	,	,	,
47658	177	75	in	in	IN
47658	177	76	the	the	DT
47658	177	77	nature	nature	NN
47658	177	78	of	of	IN
47658	177	79	the	the	DT
47658	177	80	case	case	NN
47658	177	81	,	,	,
47658	177	82	be	be	VB
47658	177	83	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	177	84	,	,	,
47658	177	85	and	and	CC
47658	177	86	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	177	87	could	could	MD
47658	177	88	never	never	RB
47658	177	89	ask	ask	VB
47658	177	90	the	the	DT
47658	177	91	question	question	NN
47658	177	92	.	.	.
47658	178	1	If	if	IN
47658	178	2	,	,	,
47658	178	3	then	then	RB
47658	178	4	,	,	,
47658	178	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	178	6	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	178	7	are	be	VBP
47658	178	8	not	not	RB
47658	178	9	copies	copy	NNS
47658	178	10	of	of	IN
47658	178	11	things	thing	NNS
47658	178	12	,	,	,
47658	178	13	and	and	CC
47658	178	14	if	if	IN
47658	178	15	there	there	EX
47658	178	16	are	be	VBP
47658	178	17	things	thing	NNS
47658	178	18	as	as	RB
47658	178	19	well	well	RB
47658	178	20	as	as	IN
47658	178	21	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	178	22	about	about	IN
47658	178	23	things	thing	NNS
47658	178	24	,	,	,
47658	178	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	178	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	178	27	quite	quite	RB
47658	178	28	clear	clear	JJ
47658	178	29	that	that	IN
47658	178	30	the	the	DT
47658	178	31	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	178	32	must	must	MD
47658	178	33	correspond	correspond	VB
47658	178	34	to	to	IN
47658	178	35	the	the	DT
47658	178	36	things	thing	NNS
47658	178	37	in	in	IN
47658	178	38	some	some	DT
47658	178	39	way	way	NN
47658	178	40	that	that	WDT
47658	178	41	does	do	VBZ
47658	178	42	not	not	RB
47658	178	43	make	make	VB
47658	178	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	178	45	copies	copy	NNS
47658	178	46	of	of	IN
47658	178	47	the	the	DT
47658	178	48	things	thing	NNS
47658	178	49	.	.	.
47658	179	1	The	the	DT
47658	179	2	most	most	RBS
47658	179	3	familiar	familiar	JJ
47658	179	4	instance	instance	NN
47658	179	5	of	of	IN
47658	179	6	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	179	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	179	8	the	the	DT
47658	179	9	symbolism	symbolism	NN
47658	179	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	179	11	use	use	VBP
47658	179	12	in	in	IN
47658	179	13	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
47658	179	14	.	.	.
47658	180	1	Are	be	VBP
47658	180	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	180	3	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	180	4	of	of	IN
47658	180	5	this	this	DT
47658	180	6	nature	nature	NN
47658	180	7	?	?	.
47658	181	1	And	and	CC
47658	181	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	181	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	181	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	181	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	181	6	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	181	7	?	?	.
47658	182	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	182	2	a	a	DT
47658	182	3	perfectly	perfectly	RB
47658	182	4	true	true	JJ
47658	182	5	idea	idea	NN
47658	182	6	one	one	CD
47658	182	7	in	in	IN
47658	182	8	which	which	WDT
47658	182	9	there	there	EX
47658	182	10	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	182	11	a	a	DT
47658	182	12	point	point	NN
47658	182	13	to	to	TO
47658	182	14	point	point	VB
47658	182	15	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	182	16	to	to	IN
47658	182	17	the	the	DT
47658	182	18	reality	reality	NN
47658	182	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	182	20	represents	represent	VBZ
47658	182	21	?	?	.
47658	183	1	At	at	IN
47658	183	2	once	once	RB
47658	183	3	there	there	EX
47658	183	4	will	will	MD
47658	183	5	occur	occur	VB
47658	183	6	to	to	IN
47658	183	7	the	the	DT
47658	183	8	mind	mind	NN
47658	183	9	a	a	DT
47658	183	10	great	great	JJ
47658	183	11	number	number	NN
47658	183	12	of	of	IN
47658	183	13	instances	instance	NNS
47658	183	14	where	where	WRB
47658	183	15	this	this	DT
47658	183	16	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	183	17	to	to	TO
47658	183	18	be	be	VB
47658	183	19	the	the	DT
47658	183	20	case	case	NN
47658	183	21	.	.	.
47658	184	1	A	a	DT
47658	184	2	map	map	NN
47658	184	3	of	of	IN
47658	184	4	England	England	NNP
47658	184	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	184	6	not	not	RB
47658	184	7	a	a	DT
47658	184	8	copy	copy	NN
47658	184	9	of	of	IN
47658	184	10	England	England	NNP
47658	184	11	such	such	JJ
47658	184	12	as	as	IN
47658	184	13	,	,	,
47658	184	14	for	for	IN
47658	184	15	example	example	NN
47658	184	16	,	,	,
47658	184	17	a	a	DT
47658	184	18	photograph	photograph	NN
47658	184	19	might	may	MD
47658	184	20	be	be	VB
47658	184	21	if	if	IN
47658	184	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	184	23	were	be	VBD
47658	184	24	to	to	TO
47658	184	25	imagine	imagine	VB
47658	184	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	184	27	taken	take	VBN
47658	184	28	{	{	-LRB-
47658	184	29	23	23	CD
47658	184	30	}	}	-RRB-
47658	184	31	from	from	IN
47658	184	32	the	the	DT
47658	184	33	moon	moon	NN
47658	184	34	.	.	.
47658	185	1	The	the	DT
47658	185	2	correctness	correctness	NN
47658	185	3	or	or	CC
47658	185	4	the	the	DT
47658	185	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	185	6	of	of	IN
47658	185	7	a	a	DT
47658	185	8	map	map	NN
47658	185	9	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	185	10	in	in	IN
47658	185	11	the	the	DT
47658	185	12	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	185	13	between	between	IN
47658	185	14	the	the	DT
47658	185	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	185	16	and	and	CC
47658	185	17	the	the	DT
47658	185	18	diagram	diagram	NN
47658	185	19	,	,	,
47658	185	20	which	which	WDT
47658	185	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	185	22	an	an	DT
47658	185	23	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
47658	185	24	sign	sign	NN
47658	185	25	of	of	IN
47658	185	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	185	27	.	.	.
47658	186	1	Throughout	throughout	IN
47658	186	2	the	the	DT
47658	186	3	whole	whole	NN
47658	186	4	of	of	IN
47658	186	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	186	6	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	186	7	life	life	NN
47658	186	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	186	9	find	find	VBP
47658	186	10	that	that	IN
47658	186	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	186	12	make	make	VBP
47658	186	13	use	use	NN
47658	186	14	of	of	IN
47658	186	15	symbols	symbol	NNS
47658	186	16	and	and	CC
47658	186	17	signs	sign	NNS
47658	186	18	that	that	WDT
47658	186	19	are	be	VBP
47658	186	20	not	not	RB
47658	186	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	186	22	either	either	CC
47658	186	23	parts	part	NNS
47658	186	24	of	of	IN
47658	186	25	or	or	CC
47658	186	26	copies	copy	NNS
47658	186	27	of	of	IN
47658	186	28	the	the	DT
47658	186	29	things	thing	NNS
47658	186	30	for	for	IN
47658	186	31	which	which	WDT
47658	186	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	186	33	stand	stand	VBP
47658	186	34	.	.	.
47658	187	1	Language	language	NN
47658	187	2	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	187	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	187	4	of	of	IN
47658	187	5	this	this	DT
47658	187	6	nature	nature	NN
47658	187	7	,	,	,
47658	187	8	and	and	CC
47658	187	9	there	there	EX
47658	187	10	may	may	MD
47658	187	11	be	be	VB
47658	187	12	symbols	symbol	NNS
47658	187	13	of	of	IN
47658	187	14	symbols	symbol	NNS
47658	187	15	of	of	IN
47658	187	16	symbols	symbol	NNS
47658	187	17	of	of	IN
47658	187	18	real	real	JJ
47658	187	19	things	thing	NNS
47658	187	20	.	.	.
47658	188	1	Written	written	JJ
47658	188	2	language	language	NN
47658	188	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	188	4	the	the	DT
47658	188	5	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
47658	188	6	visual	visual	JJ
47658	188	7	sign	sign	NN
47658	188	8	of	of	IN
47658	188	9	spoken	spoken	JJ
47658	188	10	language	language	NN
47658	188	11	,	,	,
47658	188	12	and	and	CC
47658	188	13	spoken	spoken	JJ
47658	188	14	language	language	NN
47658	188	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	188	16	the	the	DT
47658	188	17	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
47658	188	18	sign	sign	NN
47658	188	19	,	,	,
47658	188	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	188	21	may	may	MD
47658	188	22	be	be	VB
47658	188	23	,	,	,
47658	188	24	of	of	IN
47658	188	25	an	an	DT
47658	188	26	experienced	experienced	JJ
47658	188	27	thing	thing	NN
47658	188	28	or	or	CC
47658	188	29	of	of	IN
47658	188	30	an	an	DT
47658	188	31	abstract	abstract	JJ
47658	188	32	idea	idea	NN
47658	188	33	.	.	.
47658	189	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	189	2	,	,	,
47658	189	3	then	then	RB
47658	189	4	,	,	,
47658	189	5	this	this	DT
47658	189	6	property	property	NN
47658	189	7	of	of	IN
47658	189	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	189	9	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	189	10	which	which	WDT
47658	189	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	189	12	call	call	VBP
47658	189	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	189	14	the	the	DT
47658	189	15	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	189	16	of	of	IN
47658	189	17	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	189	18	with	with	IN
47658	189	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	189	20	objects	object	NNS
47658	189	21	,	,	,
47658	189	22	and	and	CC
47658	189	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	189	24	falsity	falsity	NN
47658	189	25	the	the	DT
47658	189	26	absence	absence	NN
47658	189	27	of	of	IN
47658	189	28	this	this	DT
47658	189	29	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	189	30	?	?	.
47658	190	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	190	2	can	can	MD
47658	190	3	not	not	RB
47658	190	4	be	be	VB
47658	190	5	so	so	RB
47658	190	6	.	.	.
47658	191	1	To	to	TO
47658	191	2	imagine	imagine	VB
47658	191	3	that	that	IN
47658	191	4	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	191	5	can	can	MD
47658	191	6	correspond	correspond	VB
47658	191	7	with	with	IN
47658	191	8	realities	reality	NNS
47658	191	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	191	10	to	to	TO
47658	191	11	forget	forget	VB
47658	191	12	that	that	IN
47658	191	13	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	191	14	simply	simply	RB
47658	191	15	are	be	VBP
47658	191	16	the	the	DT
47658	191	17	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	191	18	of	of	IN
47658	191	19	realities	reality	NNS
47658	191	20	;	;	:
47658	191	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	191	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	191	23	to	to	TO
47658	191	24	slip	slip	VB
47658	191	25	into	into	IN
47658	191	26	the	the	DT
47658	191	27	notion	notion	NN
47658	191	28	that	that	IN
47658	191	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	191	30	know	know	VBP
47658	191	31	two	two	CD
47658	191	32	kinds	kind	NNS
47658	191	33	of	of	IN
47658	191	34	different	different	JJ
47658	191	35	things	thing	NNS
47658	191	36	,	,	,
47658	191	37	first	first	JJ
47658	191	38	realities	reality	NNS
47658	191	39	and	and	CC
47658	191	40	secondly	secondly	RB
47658	191	41	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	191	42	,	,	,
47658	191	43	and	and	CC
47658	191	44	that	that	IN
47658	191	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	191	46	can	can	MD
47658	191	47	compare	compare	VB
47658	191	48	together	together	RB
47658	191	49	these	these	DT
47658	191	50	two	two	CD
47658	191	51	sorts	sort	NNS
47658	191	52	of	of	IN
47658	191	53	things	thing	NNS
47658	191	54	.	.	.
47658	192	1	But	but	CC
47658	192	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	192	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	192	4	at	at	IN
47658	192	5	once	once	RB
47658	192	6	evident	evident	JJ
47658	192	7	that	that	IN
47658	192	8	if	if	IN
47658	192	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	192	10	could	could	MD
47658	192	11	know	know	VB
47658	192	12	realities	reality	NNS
47658	192	13	without	without	IN
47658	192	14	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	192	15	,	,	,
47658	192	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	192	17	should	should	MD
47658	192	18	never	never	RB
47658	192	19	need	need	VB
47658	192	20	to	to	TO
47658	192	21	have	have	VB
47658	192	22	recourse	recourse	VBN
47658	192	23	to	to	IN
47658	192	24	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	192	25	.	.	.
47658	193	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	193	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	193	3	simply	simply	RB
47658	193	4	ridiculous	ridiculous	JJ
47658	193	5	to	to	TO
47658	193	6	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	193	7	that	that	IN
47658	193	8	the	the	DT
47658	193	9	relation	relation	NN
47658	193	10	between	between	IN
47658	193	11	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	193	12	and	and	CC
47658	193	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	193	14	which	which	WDT
47658	193	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	193	16	call	call	VBP
47658	193	17	knowing	know	VBG
47658	193	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	193	19	the	the	DT
47658	193	20	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	193	21	of	of	IN
47658	193	22	a	a	DT
47658	193	23	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	193	24	between	between	IN
47658	193	25	mental	mental	JJ
47658	193	26	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	193	27	and	and	CC
47658	193	28	real	real	JJ
47658	193	29	things	thing	NNS
47658	193	30	.	.	.
47658	194	1	The	the	DT
47658	194	2	two	two	CD
47658	194	3	things	thing	NNS
47658	194	4	that	that	WDT
47658	194	5	are	be	VBP
47658	194	6	related	relate	VBN
47658	194	7	together	together	RB
47658	194	8	in	in	IN
47658	194	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	194	10	are	be	VBP
47658	194	11	not	not	RB
47658	194	12	the	the	DT
47658	194	13	idea	idea	NN
47658	194	14	and	and	CC
47658	194	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	194	16	object	object	NN
47658	194	17	,	,	,
47658	194	18	but	but	CC
47658	194	19	the	the	DT
47658	194	20	mind	mind	NN
47658	194	21	and	and	CC
47658	194	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	194	23	object	object	NN
47658	194	24	.	.	.
47658	195	1	The	the	DT
47658	195	2	idea	idea	NN
47658	195	3	of	of	IN
47658	195	4	the	the	DT
47658	195	5	object	object	NN
47658	195	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	195	7	the	the	DT
47658	195	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	195	9	of	of	IN
47658	195	10	the	the	DT
47658	195	11	object	object	NN
47658	195	12	.	.	.
47658	196	1	There	there	EX
47658	196	2	may	may	MD
47658	196	3	be	be	VB
47658	196	4	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	196	5	between	between	IN
47658	196	6	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	196	7	,	,	,
47658	196	8	but	but	CC
47658	196	9	not	not	RB
47658	196	10	between	between	IN
47658	196	11	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	196	12	and	and	CC
47658	196	13	independent	independent	JJ
47658	196	14	things	thing	NNS
47658	196	15	,	,	,
47658	196	16	for	for	IN
47658	196	17	that	that	DT
47658	196	18	supposes	suppose	VBZ
47658	196	19	that	that	IN
47658	196	20	the	the	DT
47658	196	21	mind	mind	NN
47658	196	22	knows	know	VBZ
47658	196	23	the	the	DT
47658	196	24	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	196	25	and	and	CC
47658	196	26	also	also	RB
47658	196	27	knows	know	VBZ
47658	196	28	the	the	DT
47658	196	29	things	thing	NNS
47658	196	30	and	and	CC
47658	196	31	observes	observe	VBZ
47658	196	32	the	the	DT
47658	196	33	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	196	34	between	between	IN
47658	196	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	196	36	.	.	.
47658	197	1	And	and	CC
47658	197	2	even	even	RB
47658	197	3	if	if	IN
47658	197	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	197	5	suppose	suppose	VBP
47658	197	6	that	that	IN
47658	197	7	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	197	8	are	be	VBP
47658	197	9	an	an	DT
47658	197	10	independent	independent	JJ
47658	197	11	kind	kind	NN
47658	197	12	of	of	IN
47658	197	13	entity	entity	NN
47658	197	14	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
47658	197	15	and	and	CC
47658	197	16	separable	separable	JJ
47658	197	17	from	from	IN
47658	197	18	another	another	DT
47658	197	19	kind	kind	NN
47658	197	20	{	{	-LRB-
47658	197	21	24	24	CD
47658	197	22	}	}	-RRB-
47658	197	23	of	of	IN
47658	197	24	entity	entity	NN
47658	197	25	that	that	WDT
47658	197	26	forms	form	VBZ
47658	197	27	the	the	DT
47658	197	28	real	real	JJ
47658	197	29	world	world	NN
47658	197	30	,	,	,
47658	197	31	how	how	WRB
47658	197	32	could	could	MD
47658	197	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	197	34	know	know	VB
47658	197	35	that	that	IN
47658	197	36	the	the	DT
47658	197	37	two	two	CD
47658	197	38	corresponded	correspond	VBD
47658	197	39	,	,	,
47658	197	40	for	for	IN
47658	197	41	the	the	DT
47658	197	42	one	one	NN
47658	197	43	would	would	MD
47658	197	44	only	only	RB
47658	197	45	be	be	VB
47658	197	46	inferred	infer	VBN
47658	197	47	from	from	IN
47658	197	48	the	the	DT
47658	197	49	other	other	JJ
47658	197	50	?	?	.
47658	198	1	There	there	EX
47658	198	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	198	3	,	,	,
47658	198	4	however	however	RB
47658	198	5	,	,	,
47658	198	6	a	a	DT
47658	198	7	form	form	NN
47658	198	8	of	of	IN
47658	198	9	the	the	DT
47658	198	10	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	198	11	theory	theory	NN
47658	198	12	of	of	IN
47658	198	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	198	14	that	that	WDT
47658	198	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	198	16	presented	present	VBN
47658	198	17	in	in	IN
47658	198	18	a	a	DT
47658	198	19	way	way	NN
47658	198	20	which	which	WDT
47658	198	21	avoids	avoid	VBZ
47658	198	22	this	this	DT
47658	198	23	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	198	24	.	.	.
47658	199	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	199	2	,	,	,
47658	199	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	199	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	199	5	said	say	VBN
47658	199	6	,	,	,
47658	199	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	199	8	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	199	9	not	not	RB
47658	199	10	with	with	IN
47658	199	11	the	the	DT
47658	199	12	nature	nature	NN
47658	199	13	of	of	IN
47658	199	14	things	thing	NNS
47658	199	15	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	199	16	but	but	CC
47658	199	17	with	with	IN
47658	199	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	199	19	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	199	20	about	about	IN
47658	199	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	199	22	.	.	.
47658	200	1	Judgment	judgment	NN
47658	200	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	200	3	not	not	RB
47658	200	4	concerned	concerned	JJ
47658	200	5	with	with	IN
47658	200	6	the	the	DT
47658	200	7	terms	term	NNS
47658	200	8	that	that	WDT
47658	200	9	enter	enter	VBP
47658	200	10	into	into	IN
47658	200	11	relation	relation	NN
47658	200	12	--	--	:
47658	200	13	these	these	DT
47658	200	14	are	be	VBP
47658	200	15	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	200	16	experienced	experienced	JJ
47658	200	17	and	and	CC
47658	200	18	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	200	19	--	--	:
47658	200	20	but	but	CC
47658	200	21	with	with	IN
47658	200	22	the	the	DT
47658	200	23	relations	relation	NNS
47658	200	24	in	in	IN
47658	200	25	which	which	WDT
47658	200	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	200	27	stand	stand	VBP
47658	200	28	to	to	IN
47658	200	29	one	one	CD
47658	200	30	another	another	DT
47658	200	31	.	.	.
47658	201	1	Thus	thus	RB
47658	201	2	,	,	,
47658	201	3	when	when	WRB
47658	201	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	201	5	say	say	VBP
47658	201	6	John	John	NNP
47658	201	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	201	8	the	the	DT
47658	201	9	father	father	NN
47658	201	10	of	of	IN
47658	201	11	James	James	NNP
47658	201	12	,	,	,
47658	201	13	the	the	DT
47658	201	14	truth	truth	NN
47658	201	15	of	of	IN
47658	201	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	201	17	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	201	18	does	do	VBZ
47658	201	19	not	not	RB
47658	201	20	consist	consist	VB
47658	201	21	in	in	IN
47658	201	22	the	the	DT
47658	201	23	adequacy	adequacy	NN
47658	201	24	of	of	IN
47658	201	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	201	26	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	201	27	of	of	IN
47658	201	28	John	John	NNP
47658	201	29	and	and	CC
47658	201	30	James	James	NNP
47658	201	31	,	,	,
47658	201	32	nor	nor	CC
47658	201	33	in	in	IN
47658	201	34	the	the	DT
47658	201	35	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	201	36	of	of	IN
47658	201	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	201	38	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	201	39	with	with	IN
47658	201	40	the	the	DT
47658	201	41	realities	reality	NNS
47658	201	42	,	,	,
47658	201	43	but	but	CC
47658	201	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	201	45	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	201	46	only	only	RB
47658	201	47	with	with	IN
47658	201	48	the	the	DT
47658	201	49	relation	relation	NN
47658	201	50	that	that	WDT
47658	201	51	is	be	VBZ
47658	201	52	affirmed	affirm	VBN
47658	201	53	to	to	TO
47658	201	54	exist	exist	VB
47658	201	55	between	between	IN
47658	201	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	201	57	.	.	.
47658	202	1	This	this	DT
47658	202	2	relation	relation	NN
47658	202	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	202	4	declared	declare	VBN
47658	202	5	to	to	TO
47658	202	6	be	be	VB
47658	202	7	independent	independent	JJ
47658	202	8	of	of	IN
47658	202	9	or	or	CC
47658	202	10	at	at	IN
47658	202	11	least	least	JJS
47658	202	12	external	external	JJ
47658	202	13	to	to	IN
47658	202	14	the	the	DT
47658	202	15	terms	term	NNS
47658	202	16	,	,	,
47658	202	17	and	and	CC
47658	202	18	,	,	,
47658	202	19	so	so	RB
47658	202	20	far	far	RB
47658	202	21	as	as	IN
47658	202	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	202	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	202	24	expressed	express	VBN
47658	202	25	in	in	IN
47658	202	26	a	a	DT
47658	202	27	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	202	28	,	,	,
47658	202	29	truth	truth	NN
47658	202	30	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	202	31	in	in	IN
47658	202	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	202	33	actual	actual	JJ
47658	202	34	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	202	35	with	with	IN
47658	202	36	fact	fact	NN
47658	202	37	.	.	.
47658	203	1	So	so	CC
47658	203	2	if	if	IN
47658	203	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	203	4	say	say	VBP
47658	203	5	John	John	NNP
47658	203	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	7	the	the	DT
47658	203	8	father	father	NN
47658	203	9	of	of	IN
47658	203	10	James	James	NNP
47658	203	11	,	,	,
47658	203	12	then	then	RB
47658	203	13	,	,	,
47658	203	14	if	if	IN
47658	203	15	John	John	NNP
47658	203	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	17	the	the	DT
47658	203	18	father	father	NN
47658	203	19	of	of	IN
47658	203	20	James	James	NNP
47658	203	21	,	,	,
47658	203	22	the	the	DT
47658	203	23	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	203	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	25	true	true	JJ
47658	203	26	,	,	,
47658	203	27	the	the	DT
47658	203	28	affirmation	affirmation	NN
47658	203	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	30	a	a	DT
47658	203	31	truth	truth	NN
47658	203	32	;	;	:
47658	203	33	if	if	IN
47658	203	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	203	35	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	36	not	not	RB
47658	203	37	,	,	,
47658	203	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	203	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	40	false	false	JJ
47658	203	41	,	,	,
47658	203	42	the	the	DT
47658	203	43	affirmation	affirmation	NN
47658	203	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	203	45	a	a	DT
47658	203	46	falsehood	falsehood	NN
47658	203	47	.	.	.
47658	204	1	This	this	DT
47658	204	2	view	view	NN
47658	204	3	has	have	VBZ
47658	204	4	the	the	DT
47658	204	5	merit	merit	NN
47658	204	6	of	of	IN
47658	204	7	simplicity	simplicity	NN
47658	204	8	,	,	,
47658	204	9	and	and	CC
47658	204	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	204	11	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
47658	204	12	obvious	obvious	JJ
47658	204	13	almost	almost	RB
47658	204	14	to	to	TO
47658	204	15	disarm	disarm	VB
47658	204	16	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	204	17	.	.	.
47658	205	1	There	there	EX
47658	205	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	205	3	,	,	,
47658	205	4	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	205	5	,	,	,
47658	205	6	little	little	JJ
47658	205	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	205	8	in	in	IN
47658	205	9	accepting	accept	VBG
47658	205	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	205	11	if	if	IN
47658	205	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	205	13	are	be	VBP
47658	205	14	able	able	JJ
47658	205	15	to	to	TO
47658	205	16	take	take	VB
47658	205	17	the	the	DT
47658	205	18	view	view	NN
47658	205	19	of	of	IN
47658	205	20	the	the	DT
47658	205	21	nature	nature	NN
47658	205	22	of	of	IN
47658	205	23	the	the	DT
47658	205	24	real	real	JJ
47658	205	25	universe	universe	NN
47658	205	26	which	which	WDT
47658	205	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	205	28	assumes	assume	VBZ
47658	205	29	.	.	.
47658	206	1	The	the	DT
47658	206	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	206	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	206	4	best	well	RBS
47658	206	5	described	describe	VBN
47658	206	6	as	as	IN
47658	206	7	pluralistic	pluralistic	JJ
47658	206	8	realism	realism	NN
47658	206	9	.	.	.
47658	207	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	207	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	207	3	the	the	DT
47658	207	4	view	view	NN
47658	207	5	that	that	IN
47658	207	6	the	the	DT
47658	207	7	universe	universe	NN
47658	207	8	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	207	9	of	of	IN
47658	207	10	or	or	CC
47658	207	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	207	12	composed	compose	VBN
47658	207	13	of	of	IN
47658	207	14	an	an	DT
47658	207	15	aggregate	aggregate	NN
47658	207	16	of	of	IN
47658	207	17	an	an	DT
47658	207	18	infinite	infinite	JJ
47658	207	19	number	number	NN
47658	207	20	of	of	IN
47658	207	21	entities	entity	NNS
47658	207	22	.	.	.
47658	208	1	Some	some	DT
47658	208	2	of	of	IN
47658	208	3	these	these	DT
47658	208	4	have	have	VBP
47658	208	5	a	a	DT
47658	208	6	place	place	NN
47658	208	7	in	in	IN
47658	208	8	the	the	DT
47658	208	9	space	space	NN
47658	208	10	and	and	CC
47658	208	11	time	time	NN
47658	208	12	series	series	NN
47658	208	13	,	,	,
47658	208	14	and	and	CC
47658	208	15	these	these	DT
47658	208	16	exist	exist	VBP
47658	208	17	.	.	.
47658	209	1	Some	some	DT
47658	209	2	,	,	,
47658	209	3	on	on	IN
47658	209	4	the	the	DT
47658	209	5	other	other	JJ
47658	209	6	hand	hand	NN
47658	209	7	,	,	,
47658	209	8	are	be	VBP
47658	209	9	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	209	10	which	which	WDT
47658	209	11	have	have	VBP
47658	209	12	not	not	RB
47658	209	13	and	and	CC
47658	209	14	may	may	MD
47658	209	15	never	never	RB
47658	209	16	have	have	VB
47658	209	17	any	any	DT
47658	209	18	actual	actual	JJ
47658	209	19	existence	existence	NN
47658	209	20	.	.	.
47658	210	1	Entities	entity	NNS
47658	210	2	that	that	WDT
47658	210	3	have	have	VBP
47658	210	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	210	5	place	place	NN
47658	210	6	in	in	IN
47658	210	7	the	the	DT
47658	210	8	perceptual	perceptual	JJ
47658	210	9	order	order	NN
47658	210	10	of	of	IN
47658	210	11	experience	experience	NN
47658	210	12	exist	exist	VBP
47658	210	13	,	,	,
47658	210	14	{	{	-LRB-
47658	210	15	25	25	CD
47658	210	16	}	}	-RRB-
47658	210	17	or	or	CC
47658	210	18	have	have	VB
47658	210	19	existed	exist	VBN
47658	210	20	,	,	,
47658	210	21	or	or	CC
47658	210	22	will	will	MD
47658	210	23	exist	exist	VB
47658	210	24	;	;	:
47658	210	25	but	but	CC
47658	210	26	entities	entity	NNS
47658	210	27	that	that	WDT
47658	210	28	are	be	VBP
47658	210	29	concepts	concept	NNS
47658	210	30	,	,	,
47658	210	31	such	such	JJ
47658	210	32	as	as	IN
47658	210	33	goodness	goodness	NN
47658	210	34	,	,	,
47658	210	35	beauty	beauty	NN
47658	210	36	,	,	,
47658	210	37	truth	truth	NN
47658	210	38	,	,	,
47658	210	39	or	or	CC
47658	210	40	that	that	WDT
47658	210	41	are	be	VBP
47658	210	42	abstract	abstract	JJ
47658	210	43	symbols	symbol	NNS
47658	210	44	like	like	IN
47658	210	45	numbers	number	NNS
47658	210	46	,	,	,
47658	210	47	geometrical	geometrical	JJ
47658	210	48	figures	figure	NNS
47658	210	49	,	,	,
47658	210	50	pure	pure	JJ
47658	210	51	forms	form	NNS
47658	210	52	,	,	,
47658	210	53	do	do	VBP
47658	210	54	not	not	RB
47658	210	55	exist	exist	VB
47658	210	56	,	,	,
47658	210	57	but	but	CC
47658	210	58	are	be	VBP
47658	210	59	none	none	NN
47658	210	60	the	the	DT
47658	210	61	less	less	RBR
47658	210	62	just	just	RB
47658	210	63	as	as	RB
47658	210	64	real	real	JJ
47658	210	65	as	as	IN
47658	210	66	the	the	DT
47658	210	67	entities	entity	NNS
47658	210	68	that	that	WDT
47658	210	69	do	do	VBP
47658	210	70	exist	exist	VB
47658	210	71	.	.	.
47658	211	1	These	these	DT
47658	211	2	entities	entity	NNS
47658	211	3	are	be	VBP
47658	211	4	the	the	DT
47658	211	5	subject	subject	NN
47658	211	6	-	-	HYPH
47658	211	7	matter	matter	NN
47658	211	8	of	of	IN
47658	211	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	211	10	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	211	11	,	,	,
47658	211	12	and	and	CC
47658	211	13	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	211	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	211	15	discovering	discover	VBG
47658	211	16	the	the	DT
47658	211	17	relations	relation	NNS
47658	211	18	in	in	IN
47658	211	19	which	which	WDT
47658	211	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	211	21	stand	stand	VBP
47658	211	22	to	to	IN
47658	211	23	one	one	CD
47658	211	24	another	another	DT
47658	211	25	.	.	.
47658	212	1	The	the	DT
47658	212	2	whole	whole	JJ
47658	212	3	significance	significance	NN
47658	212	4	of	of	IN
47658	212	5	this	this	DT
47658	212	6	view	view	NN
47658	212	7	lies	lie	VBZ
47658	212	8	in	in	IN
47658	212	9	the	the	DT
47658	212	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	212	11	that	that	IN
47658	212	12	relations	relation	NNS
47658	212	13	are	be	VBP
47658	212	14	external	external	JJ
47658	212	15	to	to	IN
47658	212	16	the	the	DT
47658	212	17	entities	entity	NNS
47658	212	18	that	that	WDT
47658	212	19	are	be	VBP
47658	212	20	related	relate	VBN
47658	212	21	--	--	:
47658	212	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	212	23	do	do	VBP
47658	212	24	not	not	RB
47658	212	25	enter	enter	VB
47658	212	26	into	into	IN
47658	212	27	and	and	CC
47658	212	28	form	form	VB
47658	212	29	part	part	NN
47658	212	30	of	of	IN
47658	212	31	the	the	DT
47658	212	32	nature	nature	NN
47658	212	33	of	of	IN
47658	212	34	the	the	DT
47658	212	35	entities	entity	NNS
47658	212	36	.	.	.
47658	213	1	The	the	DT
47658	213	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	213	3	of	of	IN
47658	213	4	this	this	DT
47658	213	5	view	view	NN
47658	213	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	213	7	just	just	RB
47658	213	8	this	this	DT
47658	213	9	externality	externality	NN
47658	213	10	of	of	IN
47658	213	11	the	the	DT
47658	213	12	relation	relation	NN
47658	213	13	.	.	.
47658	214	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	214	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	214	3	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	214	4	to	to	TO
47658	214	5	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	214	6	what	what	WDT
47658	214	7	nature	nature	NN
47658	214	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	214	9	left	leave	VBN
47658	214	10	in	in	IN
47658	214	11	any	any	DT
47658	214	12	entity	entity	NN
47658	214	13	deprived	deprive	VBN
47658	214	14	of	of	IN
47658	214	15	all	all	DT
47658	214	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	214	17	relations	relation	NNS
47658	214	18	.	.	.
47658	215	1	The	the	DT
47658	215	2	relation	relation	NN
47658	215	3	of	of	IN
47658	215	4	father	father	NN
47658	215	5	and	and	CC
47658	215	6	son	son	NN
47658	215	7	in	in	IN
47658	215	8	the	the	DT
47658	215	9	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	215	10	,	,	,
47658	215	11	John	John	NNP
47658	215	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	215	13	the	the	DT
47658	215	14	father	father	NN
47658	215	15	of	of	IN
47658	215	16	James	James	NNP
47658	215	17	,	,	,
47658	215	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	215	19	so	so	RB
47658	215	20	far	far	RB
47658	215	21	part	part	NN
47658	215	22	of	of	IN
47658	215	23	the	the	DT
47658	215	24	nature	nature	NN
47658	215	25	of	of	IN
47658	215	26	the	the	DT
47658	215	27	persons	person	NNS
47658	215	28	John	John	NNP
47658	215	29	and	and	CC
47658	215	30	James	James	NNP
47658	215	31	,	,	,
47658	215	32	that	that	IN
47658	215	33	if	if	IN
47658	215	34	the	the	DT
47658	215	35	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	215	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	215	37	false	false	JJ
47658	215	38	then	then	RB
47658	215	39	to	to	IN
47658	215	40	that	that	DT
47658	215	41	extent	extent	NN
47658	215	42	John	John	NNP
47658	215	43	and	and	CC
47658	215	44	James	James	NNP
47658	215	45	are	be	VBP
47658	215	46	not	not	RB
47658	215	47	the	the	DT
47658	215	48	actual	actual	JJ
47658	215	49	persons	person	NNS
47658	215	50	John	John	NNP
47658	215	51	and	and	CC
47658	215	52	James	James	NNP
47658	215	53	that	that	IN
47658	215	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	215	55	are	be	VBP
47658	215	56	thought	think	VBN
47658	215	57	to	to	TO
47658	215	58	be	be	VB
47658	215	59	.	.	.
47658	216	1	And	and	CC
47658	216	2	this	this	DT
47658	216	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	216	4	the	the	DT
47658	216	5	case	case	NN
47658	216	6	even	even	RB
47658	216	7	in	in	IN
47658	216	8	so	so	RB
47658	216	9	purely	purely	RB
47658	216	10	external	external	JJ
47658	216	11	a	a	DT
47658	216	12	relation	relation	NN
47658	216	13	as	as	IN
47658	216	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	216	15	expressed	express	VBN
47658	216	16	,	,	,
47658	216	17	say	say	VB
47658	216	18	,	,	,
47658	216	19	in	in	IN
47658	216	20	the	the	DT
47658	216	21	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	216	22	,	,	,
47658	216	23	Edinburgh	Edinburgh	NNP
47658	216	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	216	25	East	East	NNP
47658	216	26	of	of	IN
47658	216	27	Glasgow	Glasgow	NNP
47658	216	28	.	.	.
47658	217	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	217	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	217	3	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	217	4	to	to	TO
47658	217	5	discuss	discuss	VB
47658	217	6	any	any	DT
47658	217	7	relation	relation	NN
47658	217	8	which	which	WDT
47658	217	9	can	can	MD
47658	217	10	be	be	VB
47658	217	11	said	say	VBN
47658	217	12	to	to	TO
47658	217	13	be	be	VB
47658	217	14	entirely	entirely	RB
47658	217	15	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
47658	217	16	to	to	IN
47658	217	17	the	the	DT
47658	217	18	nature	nature	NN
47658	217	19	of	of	IN
47658	217	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	217	21	terms	term	NNS
47658	217	22	,	,	,
47658	217	23	and	and	CC
47658	217	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	217	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	217	26	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
47658	217	27	if	if	IN
47658	217	28	anything	anything	NN
47658	217	29	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	217	30	would	would	MD
47658	217	31	be	be	VB
47658	217	32	left	leave	VBN
47658	217	33	of	of	IN
47658	217	34	a	a	DT
47658	217	35	term	term	NN
47658	217	36	abstracted	abstract	VBN
47658	217	37	from	from	IN
47658	217	38	all	all	DT
47658	217	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	217	40	relations	relation	NNS
47658	217	41	.	.	.
47658	218	1	These	these	DT
47658	218	2	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
47658	218	3	have	have	VBP
47658	218	4	led	lead	VBN
47658	218	5	to	to	IN
47658	218	6	the	the	DT
47658	218	7	formulation	formulation	NN
47658	218	8	of	of	IN
47658	218	9	an	an	DT
47658	218	10	altogether	altogether	RB
47658	218	11	different	different	JJ
47658	218	12	theory	theory	NN
47658	218	13	,	,	,
47658	218	14	namely	namely	RB
47658	218	15	,	,	,
47658	218	16	the	the	DT
47658	218	17	theory	theory	NN
47658	218	18	that	that	IN
47658	218	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	218	20	does	do	VBZ
47658	218	21	not	not	RB
47658	218	22	consist	consist	VB
47658	218	23	in	in	IN
47658	218	24	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	218	25	between	between	IN
47658	218	26	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	218	27	and	and	CC
47658	218	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	218	29	real	real	JJ
47658	218	30	counterparts	counterpart	NNS
47658	218	31	,	,	,
47658	218	32	but	but	CC
47658	218	33	in	in	IN
47658	218	34	the	the	DT
47658	218	35	consistence	consistence	NN
47658	218	36	and	and	CC
47658	218	37	internal	internal	JJ
47658	218	38	harmony	harmony	NN
47658	218	39	of	of	IN
47658	218	40	the	the	DT
47658	218	41	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	218	42	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	218	43	.	.	.
47658	219	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	219	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	219	3	named	name	VBN
47658	219	4	the	the	DT
47658	219	5	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	219	6	theory	theory	NN
47658	219	7	.	.	.
47658	220	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	220	2	will	will	MD
47658	220	3	be	be	VB
47658	220	4	recognised	recognise	VBN
47658	220	5	at	at	IN
47658	220	6	once	once	RB
47658	220	7	that	that	IN
47658	220	8	there	there	EX
47658	220	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	220	10	very	very	RB
47658	220	11	much	much	RB
47658	220	12	in	in	IN
47658	220	13	common	common	JJ
47658	220	14	experience	experience	NN
47658	220	15	to	to	TO
47658	220	16	support	support	VB
47658	220	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	220	18	.	.	.
47658	221	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	221	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	221	3	by	by	IN
47658	221	4	the	the	DT
47658	221	5	test	test	NN
47658	221	6	of	of	IN
47658	221	7	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	221	8	and	and	CC
47658	221	9	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	221	10	that	that	WDT
47658	221	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	221	12	invariably	invariably	RB
47658	221	13	judge	judge	VBP
47658	221	14	the	the	DT
47658	221	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	221	16	of	of	IN
47658	221	17	evidence	evidence	NN
47658	221	18	.	.	.
47658	222	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	222	2	26	26	CD
47658	222	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	222	4	Also	also	RB
47658	222	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	222	6	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	222	7	a	a	DT
47658	222	8	very	very	RB
47658	222	9	essential	essential	JJ
47658	222	10	part	part	NN
47658	222	11	of	of	IN
47658	222	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	222	13	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	222	14	nature	nature	NN
47658	222	15	to	to	TO
47658	222	16	reject	reject	VB
47658	222	17	as	as	RB
47658	222	18	untrue	untrue	JJ
47658	222	19	and	and	CC
47658	222	20	false	false	JJ
47658	222	21	any	any	DT
47658	222	22	statement	statement	NN
47658	222	23	or	or	CC
47658	222	24	any	any	DT
47658	222	25	idea	idea	NN
47658	222	26	that	that	WDT
47658	222	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	222	28	self	self	NN
47658	222	29	-	-	HYPH
47658	222	30	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	222	31	or	or	CC
47658	222	32	irreconcilable	irreconcilable	JJ
47658	222	33	with	with	IN
47658	222	34	the	the	DT
47658	222	35	world	world	NN
47658	222	36	of	of	IN
47658	222	37	living	living	NN
47658	222	38	experience	experience	NN
47658	222	39	.	.	.
47658	223	1	But	but	CC
47658	223	2	then	then	RB
47658	223	3	,	,	,
47658	223	4	on	on	IN
47658	223	5	the	the	DT
47658	223	6	other	other	JJ
47658	223	7	hand	hand	NN
47658	223	8	,	,	,
47658	223	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	223	10	by	by	IN
47658	223	11	no	no	DT
47658	223	12	means	means	NN
47658	223	13	allow	allow	VB
47658	223	14	that	that	IN
47658	223	15	that	that	DT
47658	223	16	must	must	MD
47658	223	17	be	be	VB
47658	223	18	true	true	JJ
47658	223	19	which	which	WDT
47658	223	20	does	do	VBZ
47658	223	21	not	not	RB
47658	223	22	exhibit	exhibit	VB
47658	223	23	logical	logical	JJ
47658	223	24	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	223	25	and	and	CC
47658	223	26	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
47658	223	27	.	.	.
47658	224	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	224	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	224	3	a	a	DT
47658	224	4	common	common	JJ
47658	224	5	enough	enough	JJ
47658	224	6	experience	experience	NN
47658	224	7	that	that	IN
47658	224	8	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	224	9	prove	prove	VBP
47658	224	10	false	false	JJ
47658	224	11	though	though	IN
47658	224	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	224	13	have	have	VBP
47658	224	14	exhibited	exhibit	VBN
47658	224	15	no	no	DT
47658	224	16	inherent	inherent	JJ
47658	224	17	failure	failure	NN
47658	224	18	to	to	TO
47658	224	19	harmonise	harmonise	VB
47658	224	20	with	with	IN
47658	224	21	surrounding	surround	VBG
47658	224	22	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
47658	224	23	nor	nor	CC
47658	224	24	any	any	DT
47658	224	25	self	self	NN
47658	224	26	-	-	HYPH
47658	224	27	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	224	28	.	.	.
47658	225	1	The	the	DT
47658	225	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	225	3	,	,	,
47658	225	4	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	225	5	,	,	,
47658	225	6	requires	require	VBZ
47658	225	7	more	more	JJR
47658	225	8	than	than	IN
47658	225	9	a	a	DT
47658	225	10	cursory	cursory	JJ
47658	225	11	examination	examination	NN
47658	225	12	.	.	.
47658	226	1	Thinking	think	VBG
47658	226	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	226	3	the	the	DT
47658	226	4	activity	activity	NN
47658	226	5	of	of	IN
47658	226	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	226	7	mind	mind	NN
47658	226	8	which	which	WDT
47658	226	9	discovers	discover	VBZ
47658	226	10	the	the	DT
47658	226	11	order	order	NN
47658	226	12	,	,	,
47658	226	13	arrangement	arrangement	NN
47658	226	14	,	,	,
47658	226	15	and	and	CC
47658	226	16	system	system	NN
47658	226	17	in	in	IN
47658	226	18	the	the	DT
47658	226	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	226	20	that	that	IN
47658	226	21	the	the	DT
47658	226	22	senses	sense	NNS
47658	226	23	reveal	reveal	VBP
47658	226	24	.	.	.
47658	227	1	Without	without	IN
47658	227	2	thought	thought	NN
47658	227	3	,	,	,
47658	227	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	227	5	felt	felt	JJ
47658	227	6	experience	experience	NN
47658	227	7	would	would	MD
47658	227	8	be	be	VB
47658	227	9	a	a	DT
47658	227	10	chaos	chaos	NN
47658	227	11	and	and	CC
47658	227	12	not	not	RB
47658	227	13	a	a	DT
47658	227	14	world	world	NN
47658	227	15	.	.	.
47658	228	1	The	the	DT
47658	228	2	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	228	3	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	228	4	expressed	express	VBD
47658	228	5	this	this	DT
47658	228	6	by	by	IN
47658	228	7	saying	say	VBG
47658	228	8	that	that	IN
47658	228	9	the	the	DT
47658	228	10	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	228	11	gives	give	VBZ
47658	228	12	unity	unity	NN
47658	228	13	to	to	IN
47658	228	14	the	the	DT
47658	228	15	manifold	manifold	NN
47658	228	16	of	of	IN
47658	228	17	sense	sense	NN
47658	228	18	.	.	.
47658	229	1	The	the	DT
47658	229	2	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	229	3	,	,	,
47658	229	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	229	5	said	say	VBD
47658	229	6	,	,	,
47658	229	7	makes	make	VBZ
47658	229	8	nature	nature	NN
47658	229	9	.	.	.
47658	230	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	230	2	does	do	VBZ
47658	230	3	this	this	DT
47658	230	4	by	by	IN
47658	230	5	giving	give	VBG
47658	230	6	form	form	NN
47658	230	7	to	to	IN
47658	230	8	the	the	DT
47658	230	9	matter	matter	NN
47658	230	10	which	which	WDT
47658	230	11	comes	come	VBZ
47658	230	12	to	to	IN
47658	230	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	230	14	by	by	IN
47658	230	15	the	the	DT
47658	230	16	senses	sense	NNS
47658	230	17	.	.	.
47658	231	1	The	the	DT
47658	231	2	mind	mind	NN
47658	231	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	231	4	not	not	RB
47658	231	5	a	a	DT
47658	231	6	_	_	NNP
47658	231	7	tabula	tabula	NN
47658	231	8	rasa	rasa	NN
47658	231	9	_	_	NNP
47658	231	10	upon	upon	IN
47658	231	11	which	which	WDT
47658	231	12	the	the	DT
47658	231	13	external	external	JJ
47658	231	14	world	world	NN
47658	231	15	makes	make	VBZ
47658	231	16	and	and	CC
47658	231	17	leaves	leave	VBZ
47658	231	18	impressions	impression	NNS
47658	231	19	,	,	,
47658	231	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	231	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	231	22	a	a	DT
47658	231	23	relating	relate	VBG
47658	231	24	activity	activity	NN
47658	231	25	which	which	WDT
47658	231	26	arranges	arrange	VBZ
47658	231	27	the	the	DT
47658	231	28	matter	matter	NN
47658	231	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	231	30	receives	receive	VBZ
47658	231	31	in	in	IN
47658	231	32	forms	form	NNS
47658	231	33	.	.	.
47658	232	1	First	first	RB
47658	232	2	of	of	IN
47658	232	3	all	all	DT
47658	232	4	there	there	EX
47658	232	5	are	be	VBP
47658	232	6	space	space	NN
47658	232	7	and	and	CC
47658	232	8	time	time	NN
47658	232	9	,	,	,
47658	232	10	which	which	WDT
47658	232	11	are	be	VBP
47658	232	12	forms	form	NNS
47658	232	13	in	in	IN
47658	232	14	which	which	WDT
47658	232	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	232	16	receive	receive	VBP
47658	232	17	all	all	DT
47658	232	18	perceptual	perceptual	JJ
47658	232	19	experience	experience	NN
47658	232	20	,	,	,
47658	232	21	and	and	CC
47658	232	22	then	then	RB
47658	232	23	there	there	EX
47658	232	24	are	be	VBP
47658	232	25	categories	category	NNS
47658	232	26	that	that	WDT
47658	232	27	are	be	VBP
47658	232	28	conceptual	conceptual	JJ
47658	232	29	frames	frame	NNS
47658	232	30	or	or	CC
47658	232	31	moulds	mould	NNS
47658	232	32	by	by	IN
47658	232	33	which	which	WDT
47658	232	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	232	35	think	think	VBP
47658	232	36	of	of	IN
47658	232	37	everything	everything	NN
47658	232	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	232	39	experience	experience	VBP
47658	232	40	as	as	IN
47658	232	41	having	have	VBG
47658	232	42	definite	definite	JJ
47658	232	43	relations	relation	NNS
47658	232	44	and	and	CC
47658	232	45	belonging	belong	VBG
47658	232	46	to	to	IN
47658	232	47	a	a	DT
47658	232	48	real	real	JJ
47658	232	49	order	order	NN
47658	232	50	of	of	IN
47658	232	51	existence	existence	NN
47658	232	52	.	.	.
47658	233	1	Substance	substance	NN
47658	233	2	,	,	,
47658	233	3	causality	causality	NN
47658	233	4	,	,	,
47658	233	5	quality	quality	NN
47658	233	6	,	,	,
47658	233	7	and	and	CC
47658	233	8	quantity	quantity	NN
47658	233	9	are	be	VBP
47658	233	10	categories	category	NNS
47658	233	11	;	;	:
47658	233	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	233	13	are	be	VBP
47658	233	14	universal	universal	JJ
47658	233	15	forms	form	NNS
47658	233	16	in	in	IN
47658	233	17	which	which	WDT
47658	233	18	the	the	DT
47658	233	19	mind	mind	NN
47658	233	20	arranges	arrange	VBZ
47658	233	21	sense	sense	VBP
47658	233	22	experience	experience	NN
47658	233	23	,	,	,
47658	233	24	and	and	CC
47658	233	25	which	which	WDT
47658	233	26	constitute	constitute	VBP
47658	233	27	the	the	DT
47658	233	28	laws	law	NNS
47658	233	29	of	of	IN
47658	233	30	nature	nature	NN
47658	233	31	,	,	,
47658	233	32	the	the	DT
47658	233	33	order	order	NN
47658	233	34	of	of	IN
47658	233	35	the	the	DT
47658	233	36	world	world	NN
47658	233	37	.	.	.
47658	234	1	Space	space	NN
47658	234	2	and	and	CC
47658	234	3	time	time	NN
47658	234	4	,	,	,
47658	234	5	and	and	CC
47658	234	6	the	the	DT
47658	234	7	categories	category	NNS
47658	234	8	of	of	IN
47658	234	9	the	the	DT
47658	234	10	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	234	11	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	234	12	declared	declare	VBD
47658	234	13	to	to	TO
47658	234	14	be	be	VB
47658	234	15	transcendental	transcendental	JJ
47658	234	16	--	--	:
47658	234	17	that	that	DT
47658	234	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	234	19	to	to	TO
47658	234	20	say	say	VB
47658	234	21	,	,	,
47658	234	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	234	23	are	be	VBP
47658	234	24	the	the	DT
47658	234	25	elements	element	NNS
47658	234	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	234	27	to	to	TO
47658	234	28	experience	experience	VB
47658	234	29	which	which	WDT
47658	234	30	are	be	VBP
47658	234	31	not	not	RB
47658	234	32	{	{	-LRB-
47658	234	33	27	27	CD
47658	234	34	}	}	-RRB-
47658	234	35	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	234	36	derived	derive	VBD
47658	234	37	from	from	IN
47658	234	38	experience	experience	NN
47658	234	39	,	,	,
47658	234	40	as	as	IN
47658	234	41	,	,	,
47658	234	42	for	for	IN
47658	234	43	example	example	NN
47658	234	44	,	,	,
47658	234	45	that	that	IN
47658	234	46	every	every	DT
47658	234	47	event	event	NN
47658	234	48	has	have	VBZ
47658	234	49	a	a	DT
47658	234	50	cause	cause	NN
47658	234	51	.	.	.
47658	235	1	There	there	EX
47658	235	2	are	be	VBP
47658	235	3	,	,	,
47658	235	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	235	5	declared	declare	VBD
47658	235	6	,	,	,
47658	235	7	synthetic	synthetic	JJ
47658	235	8	_	_	NNP
47658	235	9	a	a	DT
47658	235	10	priori	priori	FW
47658	235	11	_	_	NNP
47658	235	12	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	235	13	--	--	:
47658	235	14	that	that	RB
47658	235	15	is	is	RB
47658	235	16	,	,	,
47658	235	17	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	235	18	about	about	IN
47658	235	19	experience	experience	NN
47658	235	20	which	which	WDT
47658	235	21	are	be	VBP
47658	235	22	not	not	RB
47658	235	23	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	235	24	derived	derive	VBN
47658	235	25	from	from	IN
47658	235	26	experience	experience	NN
47658	235	27	,	,	,
47658	235	28	but	but	CC
47658	235	29	,	,	,
47658	235	30	on	on	IN
47658	235	31	the	the	DT
47658	235	32	contrary	contrary	NN
47658	235	33	,	,	,
47658	235	34	the	the	DT
47658	235	35	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	235	36	that	that	WDT
47658	235	37	make	make	VBP
47658	235	38	experience	experience	NN
47658	235	39	possible	possible	JJ
47658	235	40	.	.	.
47658	236	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	236	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	236	3	from	from	IN
47658	236	4	this	this	DT
47658	236	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	236	6	of	of	IN
47658	236	7	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	236	8	that	that	IN
47658	236	9	the	the	DT
47658	236	10	whole	whole	NN
47658	236	11	of	of	IN
47658	236	12	modern	modern	JJ
47658	236	13	idealism	idealism	NN
47658	236	14	takes	take	VBZ
47658	236	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	236	16	rise	rise	NN
47658	236	17	.	.	.
47658	237	1	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	237	2	,	,	,
47658	237	3	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	237	4	,	,	,
47658	237	5	held	hold	VBD
47658	237	6	that	that	IN
47658	237	7	there	there	EX
47658	237	8	are	be	VBP
47658	237	9	things	thing	NNS
47658	237	10	-	-	HYPH
47658	237	11	in	in	IN
47658	237	12	-	-	HYPH
47658	237	13	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	237	14	,	,	,
47658	237	15	and	and	CC
47658	237	16	to	to	IN
47658	237	17	this	this	DT
47658	237	18	extent	extent	NN
47658	237	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	237	20	was	be	VBD
47658	237	21	not	not	RB
47658	237	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	237	23	an	an	DT
47658	237	24	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	237	25	,	,	,
47658	237	26	but	but	CC
47658	237	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	237	28	also	also	RB
47658	237	29	held	hold	VBD
47658	237	30	that	that	IN
47658	237	31	things	thing	NNS
47658	237	32	-	-	HYPH
47658	237	33	in	in	IN
47658	237	34	-	-	HYPH
47658	237	35	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	237	36	are	be	VBP
47658	237	37	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	237	38	,	,	,
47658	237	39	and	and	CC
47658	237	40	this	this	DT
47658	237	41	is	be	VBZ
47658	237	42	essentially	essentially	RB
47658	237	43	the	the	DT
47658	237	44	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	237	45	position	position	NN
47658	237	46	.	.	.
47658	238	1	Clearly	clearly	RB
47658	238	2	,	,	,
47658	238	3	if	if	IN
47658	238	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	238	5	hold	hold	VBP
47658	238	6	the	the	DT
47658	238	7	view	view	NN
47658	238	8	that	that	IN
47658	238	9	things	thing	NNS
47658	238	10	-	-	HYPH
47658	238	11	in	in	IN
47658	238	12	-	-	HYPH
47658	238	13	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	238	14	are	be	VBP
47658	238	15	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	238	16	,	,	,
47658	238	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	238	18	can	can	MD
47658	238	19	not	not	RB
47658	238	20	be	be	VB
47658	238	21	a	a	DT
47658	238	22	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	238	23	between	between	IN
47658	238	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	238	25	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	238	26	and	and	CC
47658	238	27	these	these	DT
47658	238	28	things	thing	NNS
47658	238	29	-	-	HYPH
47658	238	30	in	in	IN
47658	238	31	-	-	HYPH
47658	238	32	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	238	33	.	.	.
47658	239	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	239	2	must	must	MD
47658	239	3	be	be	VB
47658	239	4	some	some	DT
47658	239	5	quality	quality	NN
47658	239	6	of	of	IN
47658	239	7	the	the	DT
47658	239	8	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	239	9	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	239	10	,	,	,
47658	239	11	and	and	CC
47658	239	12	this	this	DT
47658	239	13	can	can	MD
47658	239	14	only	only	RB
47658	239	15	be	be	VB
47658	239	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	239	17	logical	logical	JJ
47658	239	18	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	239	19	.	.	.
47658	240	1	Consistency	consistency	NN
47658	240	2	,	,	,
47658	240	3	because	because	IN
47658	240	4	the	the	DT
47658	240	5	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	240	6	must	must	MD
47658	240	7	be	be	VB
47658	240	8	in	in	IN
47658	240	9	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	240	10	with	with	IN
47658	240	11	one	one	CD
47658	240	12	another	another	DT
47658	240	13	;	;	:
47658	240	14	and	and	CC
47658	240	15	logical	logical	JJ
47658	240	16	,	,	,
47658	240	17	because	because	IN
47658	240	18	this	this	DT
47658	240	19	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	240	20	belongs	belong	VBZ
47658	240	21	to	to	IN
47658	240	22	the	the	DT
47658	240	23	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	240	24	,	,	,
47658	240	25	and	and	CC
47658	240	26	logic	logic	NN
47658	240	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	240	28	the	the	DT
47658	240	29	science	science	NN
47658	240	30	of	of	IN
47658	240	31	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	240	32	.	.	.
47658	241	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	241	2	,	,	,
47658	241	3	in	in	IN
47658	241	4	effect	effect	NN
47658	241	5	,	,	,
47658	241	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	241	7	the	the	DT
47658	241	8	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	241	9	of	of	IN
47658	241	10	logical	logical	JJ
47658	241	11	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	241	12	.	.	.
47658	242	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	242	2	experience	experience	VBP
47658	242	3	in	in	IN
47658	242	4	thinking	think	VBG
47658	242	5	an	an	DT
47658	242	6	activity	activity	NN
47658	242	7	striving	strive	VBG
47658	242	8	to	to	TO
47658	242	9	attain	attain	VB
47658	242	10	the	the	DT
47658	242	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	242	12	of	of	IN
47658	242	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	242	14	,	,	,
47658	242	15	and	and	CC
47658	242	16	the	the	DT
47658	242	17	belief	belief	NN
47658	242	18	,	,	,
47658	242	19	the	the	DT
47658	242	20	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	242	21	of	of	IN
47658	242	22	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
47658	242	23	that	that	WDT
47658	242	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	242	25	experience	experience	VBP
47658	242	26	when	when	WRB
47658	242	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	242	28	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	242	29	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	242	30	to	to	TO
47658	242	31	attain	attain	VB
47658	242	32	the	the	DT
47658	242	33	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	242	34	of	of	IN
47658	242	35	reality	reality	NN
47658	242	36	,	,	,
47658	242	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	242	38	the	the	DT
47658	242	39	harmony	harmony	NN
47658	242	40	,	,	,
47658	242	41	the	the	DT
47658	242	42	absence	absence	NN
47658	242	43	of	of	IN
47658	242	44	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	242	45	,	,	,
47658	242	46	the	the	DT
47658	242	47	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	242	48	,	,	,
47658	242	49	of	of	IN
47658	242	50	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	242	51	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	242	52	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	242	53	.	.	.
47658	243	1	This	this	DT
47658	243	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	243	3	the	the	DT
47658	243	4	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	243	5	theory	theory	NN
47658	243	6	.	.	.
47658	244	1	Let	let	VB
47658	244	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	244	3	see	see	VB
47658	244	4	what	what	WP
47658	244	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	244	6	implies	imply	VBZ
47658	244	7	as	as	IN
47658	244	8	to	to	IN
47658	244	9	the	the	DT
47658	244	10	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	244	11	nature	nature	NN
47658	244	12	of	of	IN
47658	244	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	244	14	and	and	CC
47658	244	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	244	16	.	.	.
47658	245	1	In	in	IN
47658	245	2	both	both	PDT
47658	245	3	the	the	DT
47658	245	4	theories	theory	NNS
47658	245	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	245	6	have	have	VBP
47658	245	7	now	now	RB
47658	245	8	examined	examine	VBN
47658	245	9	,	,	,
47658	245	10	truth	truth	NN
47658	245	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	245	12	a	a	DT
47658	245	13	logical	logical	JJ
47658	245	14	character	character	NN
47658	245	15	of	of	IN
47658	245	16	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	245	17	.	.	.
47658	246	1	In	in	IN
47658	246	2	the	the	DT
47658	246	3	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	246	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	246	5	there	there	EX
47658	246	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	246	7	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	246	8	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	246	9	a	a	DT
47658	246	10	non	non	JJ
47658	246	11	-	-	JJ
47658	246	12	logical	logical	JJ
47658	246	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	246	14	,	,	,
47658	246	15	but	but	CC
47658	246	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	246	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	246	18	only	only	RB
47658	246	19	in	in	IN
47658	246	20	the	the	DT
47658	246	21	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	246	22	that	that	IN
47658	246	23	there	there	EX
47658	246	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	246	25	the	the	DT
47658	246	26	conformity	conformity	NN
47658	246	27	or	or	CC
47658	246	28	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	246	29	which	which	WDT
47658	246	30	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
47658	246	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	246	32	truth	truth	NN
47658	246	33	.	.	.
47658	247	1	In	in	IN
47658	247	2	the	the	DT
47658	247	3	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	247	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	247	5	,	,	,
47658	247	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	247	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	247	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	247	9	ideal	ideal	JJ
47658	247	10	,	,	,
47658	247	11	and	and	CC
47658	247	12	the	the	DT
47658	247	13	{	{	-LRB-
47658	247	14	28	28	CD
47658	247	15	}	}	-RRB-
47658	247	16	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	247	17	ground	ground	NN
47658	247	18	of	of	IN
47658	247	19	everything	everything	NN
47658	247	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	247	21	logical	logical	JJ
47658	247	22	.	.	.
47658	248	1	This	this	DT
47658	248	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	248	3	the	the	DT
47658	248	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	248	5	of	of	IN
47658	248	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	248	7	that	that	WDT
47658	248	8	accords	accord	NNS
47658	248	9	with	with	IN
47658	248	10	the	the	DT
47658	248	11	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	248	12	view	view	NN
47658	248	13	,	,	,
47658	248	14	and	and	CC
47658	248	15	this	this	DT
47658	248	16	view	view	NN
47658	248	17	finds	find	VBZ
47658	248	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	248	19	most	most	RBS
47658	248	20	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	248	21	expression	expression	NN
47658	248	22	in	in	IN
47658	248	23	the	the	DT
47658	248	24	theory	theory	NN
47658	248	25	of	of	IN
47658	248	26	the	the	DT
47658	248	27	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	248	28	.	.	.
47658	249	1	The	the	DT
47658	249	2	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	249	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	249	4	the	the	DT
47658	249	5	idea	idea	NN
47658	249	6	of	of	IN
47658	249	7	an	an	DT
47658	249	8	object	object	NN
47658	249	9	that	that	WDT
47658	249	10	realises	realise	VBZ
47658	249	11	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	249	12	logical	logical	JJ
47658	249	13	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	249	14	.	.	.
47658	250	1	This	this	DT
47658	250	2	object	object	NN
47658	250	3	logic	logic	NN
47658	250	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	250	5	creates	create	VBZ
47658	250	6	;	;	:
47658	250	7	if	if	IN
47658	250	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	250	9	be	be	VB
47658	250	10	a	a	DT
47658	250	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	250	12	existence	existence	NN
47658	250	13	,	,	,
47658	250	14	then	then	RB
47658	250	15	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	250	16	of	of	IN
47658	250	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	250	18	can	can	MD
47658	250	19	not	not	RB
47658	250	20	be	be	VB
47658	250	21	other	other	JJ
47658	250	22	than	than	IN
47658	250	23	truth	truth	NN
47658	250	24	.	.	.
47658	251	1	This	this	DT
47658	251	2	view	view	NN
47658	251	3	,	,	,
47658	251	4	on	on	IN
47658	251	5	account	account	NN
47658	251	6	of	of	IN
47658	251	7	the	the	DT
47658	251	8	supreme	supreme	JJ
47658	251	9	position	position	NN
47658	251	10	that	that	WDT
47658	251	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	251	12	assigns	assign	VBZ
47658	251	13	to	to	IN
47658	251	14	the	the	DT
47658	251	15	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	251	16	,	,	,
47658	251	17	and	and	CC
47658	251	18	of	of	IN
47658	251	19	the	the	DT
47658	251	20	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	251	21	character	character	NN
47658	251	22	with	with	IN
47658	251	23	which	which	WDT
47658	251	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	251	25	invests	invest	VBZ
47658	251	26	the	the	DT
47658	251	27	logical	logical	JJ
47658	251	28	categories	category	NNS
47658	251	29	,	,	,
47658	251	30	has	have	VBZ
47658	251	31	been	be	VBN
47658	251	32	named	name	VBN
47658	251	33	by	by	IN
47658	251	34	those	those	DT
47658	251	35	who	who	WP
47658	251	36	oppose	oppose	VBP
47658	251	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	251	38	Intellectualism	Intellectualism	NNP
47658	251	39	.	.	.
47658	252	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	252	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	252	3	important	important	JJ
47658	252	4	that	that	IN
47658	252	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	252	6	should	should	MD
47658	252	7	be	be	VB
47658	252	8	clearly	clearly	RB
47658	252	9	understood	understand	VBN
47658	252	10	,	,	,
47658	252	11	and	and	CC
47658	252	12	the	the	DT
47658	252	13	next	next	JJ
47658	252	14	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	252	15	will	will	MD
47658	252	16	be	be	VB
47658	252	17	devoted	devoted	JJ
47658	252	18	to	to	IN
47658	252	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	252	20	exposition	exposition	NN
47658	252	21	.	.	.
47658	253	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
47658	253	2	IV	IV	NNP
47658	253	3	THE	the	DT
47658	253	4	ABSOLUTE	ABSOLUTE	NNP
47658	253	5	A	a	DT
47658	253	6	comparison	comparison	NN
47658	253	7	of	of	IN
47658	253	8	the	the	DT
47658	253	9	two	two	CD
47658	253	10	theories	theory	NNS
47658	253	11	of	of	IN
47658	253	12	truth	truth	NN
47658	253	13	examined	examine	VBN
47658	253	14	in	in	IN
47658	253	15	the	the	DT
47658	253	16	last	last	JJ
47658	253	17	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	253	18	will	will	MD
47658	253	19	show	show	VB
47658	253	20	that	that	IN
47658	253	21	,	,	,
47658	253	22	whereas	whereas	IN
47658	253	23	both	both	DT
47658	253	24	rest	rest	VB
47658	253	25	on	on	IN
47658	253	26	a	a	DT
47658	253	27	logical	logical	JJ
47658	253	28	quality	quality	NN
47658	253	29	in	in	IN
47658	253	30	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	253	31	,	,	,
47658	253	32	the	the	DT
47658	253	33	first	first	JJ
47658	253	34	depends	depend	VBZ
47658	253	35	on	on	IN
47658	253	36	an	an	DT
47658	253	37	external	external	JJ
47658	253	38	view	view	NN
47658	253	39	taken	take	VBN
47658	253	40	by	by	IN
47658	253	41	the	the	DT
47658	253	42	mind	mind	NN
47658	253	43	of	of	IN
47658	253	44	an	an	DT
47658	253	45	independent	independent	JJ
47658	253	46	non	non	JJ
47658	253	47	-	-	JJ
47658	253	48	mental	mental	JJ
47658	253	49	reality	reality	NN
47658	253	50	,	,	,
47658	253	51	whereas	whereas	IN
47658	253	52	the	the	DT
47658	253	53	second	second	JJ
47658	253	54	depends	depend	VBZ
47658	253	55	on	on	IN
47658	253	56	the	the	DT
47658	253	57	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	253	58	of	of	IN
47658	253	59	an	an	DT
47658	253	60	inner	inner	JJ
47658	253	61	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	253	62	in	in	IN
47658	253	63	experience	experience	NN
47658	253	64	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	253	65	.	.	.
47658	254	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	254	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	254	3	this	this	DT
47658	254	4	inner	inner	JJ
47658	254	5	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	254	6	of	of	IN
47658	254	7	experience	experience	NN
47658	254	8	that	that	WDT
47658	254	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	254	10	seek	seek	VBP
47658	254	11	to	to	TO
47658	254	12	know	know	VB
47658	254	13	when	when	WRB
47658	254	14	asking	ask	VBG
47658	254	15	any	any	DT
47658	254	16	question	question	NN
47658	254	17	concerning	concern	VBG
47658	254	18	reality	reality	NN
47658	254	19	.	.	.
47658	255	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	255	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	255	3	the	the	DT
47658	255	4	development	development	NN
47658	255	5	of	of	IN
47658	255	6	this	this	DT
47658	255	7	view	view	NN
47658	255	8	,	,	,
47658	255	9	and	and	CC
47658	255	10	what	what	WP
47658	255	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	255	12	implies	imply	VBZ
47658	255	13	as	as	IN
47658	255	14	to	to	IN
47658	255	15	the	the	DT
47658	255	16	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	255	17	nature	nature	NN
47658	255	18	of	of	IN
47658	255	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	255	20	and	and	CC
47658	255	21	truth	truth	NN
47658	255	22	,	,	,
47658	255	23	that	that	IN
47658	255	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	255	25	are	be	VBP
47658	255	26	now	now	RB
47658	255	27	to	to	TO
47658	255	28	examine	examine	VB
47658	255	29	.	.	.
47658	256	1	When	when	WRB
47658	256	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	256	3	ask	ask	VBP
47658	256	4	questions	question	NNS
47658	256	5	about	about	IN
47658	256	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	256	7	,	,	,
47658	256	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	256	9	assume	assume	VBP
47658	256	10	in	in	IN
47658	256	11	the	the	DT
47658	256	12	very	very	JJ
47658	256	13	inquiry	inquiry	NN
47658	256	14	that	that	IN
47658	256	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	256	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	256	17	of	of	IN
47658	256	18	a	a	DT
47658	256	19	nature	nature	NN
47658	256	20	that	that	WDT
47658	256	21	experience	experience	NN
47658	256	22	reveals	reveal	VBZ
47658	256	23	.	.	.
47658	257	1	Reality	reality	NN
47658	257	2	in	in	IN
47658	257	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	257	4	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	257	5	nature	nature	NN
47658	257	6	may	may	MD
47658	257	7	be	be	VB
47658	257	8	logical	logical	JJ
47658	257	9	--	--	:
47658	257	10	that	that	DT
47658	257	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	257	12	to	to	TO
47658	257	13	say	say	VB
47658	257	14	,	,	,
47658	257	15	of	of	IN
47658	257	16	the	the	DT
47658	257	17	nature	nature	NN
47658	257	18	of	of	IN
47658	257	19	reason	reason	NN
47658	257	20	,	,	,
47658	257	21	or	or	CC
47658	257	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	257	23	may	may	MD
47658	257	24	{	{	-LRB-
47658	257	25	29	29	CD
47658	257	26	}	}	-RRB-
47658	257	27	be	be	VB
47658	257	28	non	non	JJ
47658	257	29	-	-	JJ
47658	257	30	logical	logical	JJ
47658	257	31	--	--	:
47658	257	32	that	that	DT
47658	257	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	257	34	to	to	TO
47658	257	35	say	say	VB
47658	257	36	,	,	,
47658	257	37	of	of	IN
47658	257	38	the	the	DT
47658	257	39	nature	nature	NN
47658	257	40	of	of	IN
47658	257	41	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	257	42	or	or	CC
47658	257	43	will	will	MD
47658	257	44	;	;	:
47658	257	45	but	but	CC
47658	257	46	in	in	IN
47658	257	47	either	either	DT
47658	257	48	case	case	NN
47658	257	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	257	50	must	must	MD
47658	257	51	be	be	VB
47658	257	52	a	a	DT
47658	257	53	nature	nature	NN
47658	257	54	of	of	IN
47658	257	55	which	which	WDT
47658	257	56	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	257	57	experience	experience	NN
47658	257	58	can	can	MD
47658	257	59	give	give	VB
47658	257	60	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	257	61	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	257	62	.	.	.
47658	258	1	If	if	IN
47658	258	2	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	258	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	258	4	hold	hold	VBP
47658	258	5	the	the	DT
47658	258	6	view	view	NN
47658	258	7	which	which	WDT
47658	258	8	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	258	9	have	have	VBP
47658	258	10	often	often	RB
47658	258	11	endeavoured	endeavour	VBN
47658	258	12	to	to	TO
47658	258	13	formulate	formulate	VB
47658	258	14	,	,	,
47658	258	15	that	that	DT
47658	258	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	258	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	258	18	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	258	19	,	,	,
47658	258	20	then	then	RB
47658	258	21	there	there	EX
47658	258	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	258	23	no	no	DT
47658	258	24	more	more	JJR
47658	258	25	to	to	TO
47658	258	26	be	be	VB
47658	258	27	said	say	VBN
47658	258	28	;	;	:
47658	258	29	for	for	IN
47658	258	30	,	,	,
47658	258	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	258	32	the	the	DT
47658	258	33	picture	picture	NN
47658	258	34	or	or	CC
47658	258	35	the	the	DT
47658	258	36	blank	blank	NN
47658	258	37	for	for	IN
47658	258	38	a	a	DT
47658	258	39	picture	picture	NN
47658	258	40	by	by	IN
47658	258	41	which	which	WDT
47658	258	42	the	the	DT
47658	258	43	mind	mind	NN
47658	258	44	tries	try	VBZ
47658	258	45	to	to	TO
47658	258	46	present	present	VB
47658	258	47	this	this	DT
47658	258	48	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	258	49	reality	reality	NN
47658	258	50	,	,	,
47658	258	51	there	there	EX
47658	258	52	can	can	MD
47658	258	53	be	be	VB
47658	258	54	no	no	DT
47658	258	55	question	question	NN
47658	258	56	in	in	IN
47658	258	57	relation	relation	NN
47658	258	58	to	to	IN
47658	258	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	258	60	of	of	IN
47658	258	61	the	the	DT
47658	258	62	nature	nature	NN
47658	258	63	and	and	CC
47658	258	64	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	258	65	of	of	IN
47658	258	66	truth	truth	NN
47658	258	67	.	.	.
47658	259	1	An	an	DT
47658	259	2	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	259	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	259	4	,	,	,
47658	259	5	as	as	IN
47658	259	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	259	7	shall	shall	MD
47658	259	8	show	show	VB
47658	259	9	later	later	RB
47658	259	10	on	on	RB
47658	259	11	,	,	,
47658	259	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	259	13	to	to	IN
47658	259	14	all	all	DT
47658	259	15	intents	intent	NNS
47658	259	16	and	and	CC
47658	259	17	purposes	purpose	VBZ
47658	259	18	non	non	JJ
47658	259	19	-	-	JJ
47658	259	20	existent	existent	JJ
47658	259	21	reality	reality	NN
47658	259	22	.	.	.
47658	260	1	On	on	IN
47658	260	2	the	the	DT
47658	260	3	other	other	JJ
47658	260	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	260	5	,	,	,
47658	260	6	if	if	IN
47658	260	7	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	260	8	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	260	9	to	to	IN
47658	260	10	the	the	DT
47658	260	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	260	12	of	of	IN
47658	260	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	260	14	that	that	WDT
47658	260	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	260	16	call	call	VBP
47658	260	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	260	18	,	,	,
47658	260	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	260	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	260	21	because	because	IN
47658	260	22	being	be	VBG
47658	260	23	and	and	CC
47658	260	24	knowing	know	VBG
47658	260	25	are	be	VBP
47658	260	26	ultimately	ultimately	RB
47658	260	27	one	one	CD
47658	260	28	,	,	,
47658	260	29	and	and	CC
47658	260	30	this	this	DT
47658	260	31	unity	unity	NN
47658	260	32	can	can	MD
47658	260	33	only	only	RB
47658	260	34	be	be	VB
47658	260	35	in	in	IN
47658	260	36	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	260	37	experience	experience	NN
47658	260	38	.	.	.
47658	261	1	This	this	DT
47658	261	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	261	3	the	the	DT
47658	261	4	axiom	axiom	NN
47658	261	5	on	on	IN
47658	261	6	which	which	WDT
47658	261	7	the	the	DT
47658	261	8	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	261	9	argument	argument	NN
47658	261	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	261	11	based	base	VBN
47658	261	12	.	.	.
47658	262	1	The	the	DT
47658	262	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	262	3	of	of	IN
47658	262	4	the	the	DT
47658	262	5	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	262	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	262	7	a	a	DT
47658	262	8	logical	logical	JJ
47658	262	9	argument	argument	NN
47658	262	10	of	of	IN
47658	262	11	great	great	JJ
47658	262	12	dialectical	dialectical	JJ
47658	262	13	force	force	NN
47658	262	14	.	.	.
47658	263	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	263	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	263	3	not	not	RB
47658	263	4	an	an	DT
47658	263	5	exaggeration	exaggeration	NN
47658	263	6	to	to	TO
47658	263	7	say	say	VB
47658	263	8	that	that	IN
47658	263	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	263	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	263	11	the	the	DT
47658	263	12	greatest	great	JJS
47658	263	13	dialectical	dialectical	JJ
47658	263	14	triumph	triumph	NN
47658	263	15	of	of	IN
47658	263	16	modern	modern	JJ
47658	263	17	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	263	18	.	.	.
47658	264	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	264	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	264	3	the	the	DT
47658	264	4	most	most	RBS
47658	264	5	successful	successful	JJ
47658	264	6	expression	expression	NN
47658	264	7	of	of	IN
47658	264	8	idealism	idealism	NN
47658	264	9	.	.	.
47658	265	1	That	that	IN
47658	265	2	this	this	DT
47658	265	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	265	4	not	not	RB
47658	265	5	an	an	DT
47658	265	6	extravagant	extravagant	JJ
47658	265	7	estimate	estimate	NN
47658	265	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	265	9	shown	show	VBN
47658	265	10	,	,	,
47658	265	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	265	12	think	think	VBP
47658	265	13	,	,	,
47658	265	14	by	by	IN
47658	265	15	the	the	DT
47658	265	16	fact	fact	NN
47658	265	17	that	that	IN
47658	265	18	,	,	,
47658	265	19	widespread	widespread	JJ
47658	265	20	and	and	CC
47658	265	21	determined	determined	JJ
47658	265	22	as	as	IN
47658	265	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	265	24	the	the	DT
47658	265	25	opposition	opposition	NN
47658	265	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	265	27	has	have	VBZ
47658	265	28	had	have	VBN
47658	265	29	to	to	TO
47658	265	30	encounter	encounter	VB
47658	265	31	,	,	,
47658	265	32	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	265	33	has	have	VBZ
47658	265	34	been	be	VBN
47658	265	35	directed	direct	VBN
47658	265	36	not	not	RB
47658	265	37	so	so	RB
47658	265	38	much	much	JJ
47658	265	39	against	against	IN
47658	265	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	265	41	logic	logic	NN
47658	265	42	as	as	IN
47658	265	43	against	against	IN
47658	265	44	the	the	DT
47658	265	45	basis	basis	NN
47658	265	46	of	of	IN
47658	265	47	intellectualism	intellectualism	NN
47658	265	48	on	on	IN
47658	265	49	which	which	WDT
47658	265	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	265	51	rests	rest	VBZ
47658	265	52	.	.	.
47658	266	1	The	the	DT
47658	266	2	very	very	JJ
47658	266	3	boldness	boldness	NN
47658	266	4	of	of	IN
47658	266	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	266	6	claim	claim	NN
47658	266	7	and	and	CC
47658	266	8	brilliance	brilliance	NN
47658	266	9	of	of	IN
47658	266	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	266	11	triumph	triumph	NN
47658	266	12	lead	lead	VBP
47658	266	13	to	to	IN
47658	266	14	the	the	DT
47658	266	15	suspicion	suspicion	NN
47658	266	16	that	that	IN
47658	266	17	the	the	DT
47658	266	18	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	266	19	can	can	MD
47658	266	20	not	not	RB
47658	266	21	be	be	VB
47658	266	22	the	the	DT
47658	266	23	sole	sole	JJ
47658	266	24	determining	determine	VBG
47658	266	25	factor	factor	NN
47658	266	26	of	of	IN
47658	266	27	the	the	DT
47658	266	28	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	266	29	nature	nature	NN
47658	266	30	of	of	IN
47658	266	31	reality	reality	NN
47658	266	32	.	.	.
47658	267	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	267	2	will	will	MD
47658	267	3	be	be	VB
47658	267	4	easier	easy	JJR
47658	267	5	to	to	TO
47658	267	6	understand	understand	VB
47658	267	7	the	the	DT
47658	267	8	theory	theory	NN
47658	267	9	of	of	IN
47658	267	10	the	the	DT
47658	267	11	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	267	12	if	if	IN
47658	267	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	267	14	first	first	RB
47658	267	15	of	of	IN
47658	267	16	all	all	DT
47658	267	17	notice	notice	NN
47658	267	18	,	,	,
47658	267	19	for	for	IN
47658	267	20	the	the	DT
47658	267	21	sake	sake	NN
47658	267	22	of	of	IN
47658	267	23	afterwards	afterwards	RB
47658	267	24	comparing	compare	VBG
47658	267	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	267	26	,	,	,
47658	267	27	another	another	DT
47658	267	28	argument	argument	NN
47658	267	29	very	very	RB
47658	267	30	famous	famous	JJ
47658	267	31	in	in	IN
47658	267	32	the	the	DT
47658	267	33	history	history	NN
47658	267	34	of	of	IN
47658	267	35	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	267	36	--	--	:
47658	267	37	the	the	DT
47658	267	38	argument	argument	NN
47658	267	39	to	to	TO
47658	267	40	prove	prove	VB
47658	267	41	the	the	DT
47658	267	42	existence	existence	NN
47658	267	43	of	of	IN
47658	267	44	God	God	NNP
47658	267	45	named	name	VBN
47658	267	46	after	after	IN
47658	267	47	St.	St.	NNP
47658	267	48	Anselm	Anselm	NNP
47658	267	49	of	of	IN
47658	267	50	Canterbury	Canterbury	NNP
47658	267	51	.	.	.
47658	268	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	268	2	30	30	CD
47658	268	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	268	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	268	5	runs	run	VBZ
47658	268	6	thus	thus	RB
47658	268	7	:	:	:
47658	268	8	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	268	9	have	have	VBP
47658	268	10	in	in	IN
47658	268	11	God	God	NNP
47658	268	12	the	the	DT
47658	268	13	idea	idea	NN
47658	268	14	of	of	IN
47658	268	15	a	a	DT
47658	268	16	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	268	17	being	being	NN
47658	268	18	;	;	:
47658	268	19	the	the	DT
47658	268	20	idea	idea	NN
47658	268	21	of	of	IN
47658	268	22	a	a	DT
47658	268	23	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	268	24	being	being	NN
47658	268	25	includes	include	VBZ
47658	268	26	the	the	DT
47658	268	27	existence	existence	NN
47658	268	28	of	of	IN
47658	268	29	that	that	DT
47658	268	30	being	be	VBG
47658	268	31	,	,	,
47658	268	32	for	for	IN
47658	268	33	not	not	RB
47658	268	34	to	to	TO
47658	268	35	exist	exist	VB
47658	268	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	268	37	to	to	TO
47658	268	38	fall	fall	VB
47658	268	39	short	short	RB
47658	268	40	of	of	IN
47658	268	41	perfection	perfection	NN
47658	268	42	;	;	:
47658	268	43	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	268	44	God	God	NNP
47658	268	45	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	268	46	.	.	.
47658	269	1	The	the	DT
47658	269	2	theological	theological	JJ
47658	269	3	form	form	NN
47658	269	4	of	of	IN
47658	269	5	this	this	DT
47658	269	6	argument	argument	NN
47658	269	7	need	nee	MD
47658	269	8	raise	raise	VB
47658	269	9	no	no	DT
47658	269	10	prejudice	prejudice	NN
47658	269	11	against	against	IN
47658	269	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	269	13	.	.	.
47658	270	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	270	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	270	3	of	of	IN
47658	270	4	very	very	RB
47658	270	5	great	great	JJ
47658	270	6	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
47658	270	7	importance	importance	NN
47658	270	8	,	,	,
47658	270	9	and	and	CC
47658	270	10	if	if	IN
47658	270	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	270	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	270	13	wrong	wrong	JJ
47658	270	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	270	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	270	16	not	not	RB
47658	270	17	easy	easy	JJ
47658	270	18	to	to	TO
47658	270	19	point	point	VB
47658	270	20	out	out	RP
47658	270	21	wherein	wherein	WRB
47658	270	22	the	the	DT
47658	270	23	fallacy	fallacy	NN
47658	270	24	lies	lie	VBZ
47658	270	25	.	.	.
47658	271	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	271	2	may	may	MD
47658	271	3	,	,	,
47658	271	4	of	of	IN
47658	271	5	course	course	NN
47658	271	6	,	,	,
47658	271	7	be	be	VB
47658	271	8	denied	deny	VBN
47658	271	9	that	that	IN
47658	271	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	271	11	have	have	VBP
47658	271	12	or	or	CC
47658	271	13	can	can	MD
47658	271	14	have	have	VB
47658	271	15	the	the	DT
47658	271	16	idea	idea	NN
47658	271	17	of	of	IN
47658	271	18	a	a	DT
47658	271	19	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	271	20	being	being	NN
47658	271	21	--	--	:
47658	271	22	that	that	DT
47658	271	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	271	24	to	to	TO
47658	271	25	say	say	VB
47658	271	26	,	,	,
47658	271	27	that	that	IN
47658	271	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	271	29	can	can	MD
47658	271	30	present	present	VB
47658	271	31	that	that	DT
47658	271	32	idea	idea	NN
47658	271	33	to	to	IN
47658	271	34	the	the	DT
47658	271	35	mind	mind	NN
47658	271	36	with	with	IN
47658	271	37	a	a	DT
47658	271	38	positive	positive	JJ
47658	271	39	content	content	NN
47658	271	40	or	or	CC
47658	271	41	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	271	42	as	as	RB
47658	271	43	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	271	44	from	from	IN
47658	271	45	a	a	DT
47658	271	46	merely	merely	RB
47658	271	47	negative	negative	JJ
47658	271	48	or	or	CC
47658	271	49	limiting	limiting	JJ
47658	271	50	idea	idea	NN
47658	271	51	.	.	.
47658	272	1	But	but	CC
47658	272	2	this	this	DT
47658	272	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	272	4	practically	practically	RB
47658	272	5	to	to	TO
47658	272	6	admit	admit	VB
47658	272	7	the	the	DT
47658	272	8	driving	drive	VBG
47658	272	9	force	force	NN
47658	272	10	of	of	IN
47658	272	11	the	the	DT
47658	272	12	argument	argument	NN
47658	272	13	,	,	,
47658	272	14	namely	namely	RB
47658	272	15	,	,	,
47658	272	16	that	that	IN
47658	272	17	there	there	EX
47658	272	18	may	may	MD
47658	272	19	be	be	VB
47658	272	20	an	an	DT
47658	272	21	idea	idea	NN
47658	272	22	of	of	IN
47658	272	23	whose	whose	WP$
47658	272	24	content	content	NN
47658	272	25	or	or	CC
47658	272	26	meaning	mean	VBG
47658	272	27	existence	existence	NN
47658	272	28	forms	form	VBZ
47658	272	29	part	part	NN
47658	272	30	.	.	.
47658	273	1	With	with	IN
47658	273	2	regard	regard	NN
47658	273	3	to	to	IN
47658	273	4	everything	everything	NN
47658	273	5	else	else	RB
47658	273	6	the	the	DT
47658	273	7	idea	idea	NN
47658	273	8	of	of	IN
47658	273	9	existing	exist	VBG
47658	273	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	273	11	not	not	RB
47658	273	12	existence	existence	NN
47658	273	13	.	.	.
47658	274	1	There	there	EX
47658	274	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	274	3	absolutely	absolutely	RB
47658	274	4	no	no	DT
47658	274	5	difference	difference	NN
47658	274	6	between	between	IN
47658	274	7	the	the	DT
47658	274	8	idea	idea	NN
47658	274	9	of	of	IN
47658	274	10	a	a	DT
47658	274	11	hundred	hundred	CD
47658	274	12	dollars	dollar	NNS
47658	274	13	and	and	CC
47658	274	14	the	the	DT
47658	274	15	idea	idea	NN
47658	274	16	of	of	IN
47658	274	17	a	a	DT
47658	274	18	hundred	hundred	CD
47658	274	19	dollars	dollar	NNS
47658	274	20	existing	exist	VBG
47658	274	21	,	,	,
47658	274	22	but	but	CC
47658	274	23	there	there	EX
47658	274	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	274	25	the	the	DT
47658	274	26	whole	whole	JJ
47658	274	27	difference	difference	NN
47658	274	28	between	between	IN
47658	274	29	thought	thought	NN
47658	274	30	and	and	CC
47658	274	31	reality	reality	NN
47658	274	32	in	in	IN
47658	274	33	the	the	DT
47658	274	34	idea	idea	NN
47658	274	35	of	of	IN
47658	274	36	the	the	DT
47658	274	37	hundred	hundred	CD
47658	274	38	dollars	dollar	NNS
47658	274	39	existing	exist	VBG
47658	274	40	and	and	CC
47658	274	41	the	the	DT
47658	274	42	existence	existence	NN
47658	274	43	of	of	IN
47658	274	44	the	the	DT
47658	274	45	hundred	hundred	CD
47658	274	46	dollars	dollar	NNS
47658	274	47	.	.	.
47658	275	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	275	2	actual	actual	JJ
47658	275	3	existence	existence	NN
47658	275	4	in	in	IN
47658	275	5	no	no	DT
47658	275	6	way	way	NN
47658	275	7	depends	depend	VBZ
47658	275	8	on	on	IN
47658	275	9	the	the	DT
47658	275	10	perfection	perfection	NN
47658	275	11	or	or	CC
47658	275	12	imperfection	imperfection	NN
47658	275	13	of	of	IN
47658	275	14	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	275	15	idea	idea	NN
47658	275	16	,	,	,
47658	275	17	nor	nor	CC
47658	275	18	in	in	IN
47658	275	19	the	the	DT
47658	275	20	inclusion	inclusion	NN
47658	275	21	of	of	IN
47658	275	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	275	23	existence	existence	NN
47658	275	24	in	in	IN
47658	275	25	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	275	26	idea	idea	NN
47658	275	27	.	.	.
47658	276	1	This	this	DT
47658	276	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	276	3	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
47658	276	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
47658	276	5	in	in	IN
47658	276	6	every	every	DT
47658	276	7	case	case	NN
47658	276	8	in	in	IN
47658	276	9	which	which	WDT
47658	276	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	276	11	are	be	VBP
47658	276	12	dealing	deal	VBG
47658	276	13	with	with	IN
47658	276	14	perceptual	perceptual	JJ
47658	276	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	276	16	,	,	,
47658	276	17	and	and	CC
47658	276	18	in	in	IN
47658	276	19	which	which	WDT
47658	276	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	276	21	can	can	MD
47658	276	22	,	,	,
47658	276	23	in	in	IN
47658	276	24	the	the	DT
47658	276	25	words	word	NNS
47658	276	26	of	of	IN
47658	276	27	the	the	DT
47658	276	28	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	276	29	Hume	Hume	NNP
47658	276	30	,	,	,
47658	276	31	produce	produce	VB
47658	276	32	the	the	DT
47658	276	33	impression	impression	NN
47658	276	34	which	which	WDT
47658	276	35	gives	give	VBZ
47658	276	36	rise	rise	NN
47658	276	37	to	to	IN
47658	276	38	the	the	DT
47658	276	39	idea	idea	NN
47658	276	40	.	.	.
47658	277	1	But	but	CC
47658	277	2	there	there	EX
47658	277	3	are	be	VBP
47658	277	4	some	some	DT
47658	277	5	objects	object	NNS
47658	277	6	which	which	WDT
47658	277	7	by	by	IN
47658	277	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	277	9	very	very	JJ
47658	277	10	nature	nature	NN
47658	277	11	will	will	MD
47658	277	12	not	not	RB
47658	277	13	submit	submit	VB
47658	277	14	to	to	IN
47658	277	15	this	this	DT
47658	277	16	test	test	NN
47658	277	17	.	.	.
47658	278	1	No	no	DT
47658	278	2	man	man	NN
47658	278	3	hath	hath	NN
47658	278	4	seen	see	VBN
47658	278	5	God	God	NNP
47658	278	6	at	at	IN
47658	278	7	any	any	DT
47658	278	8	time	time	NN
47658	278	9	,	,	,
47658	278	10	not	not	RB
47658	278	11	because	because	IN
47658	278	12	God	God	NNP
47658	278	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	278	14	an	an	DT
47658	278	15	object	object	NN
47658	278	16	existing	exist	VBG
47658	278	17	under	under	IN
47658	278	18	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	278	19	and	and	CC
47658	278	20	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
47658	278	21	of	of	IN
47658	278	22	place	place	NN
47658	278	23	and	and	CC
47658	278	24	time	time	NN
47658	278	25	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	278	26	for	for	IN
47658	278	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	278	28	to	to	TO
47658	278	29	realise	realise	VB
47658	278	30	by	by	IN
47658	278	31	reason	reason	NN
47658	278	32	of	of	IN
47658	278	33	the	the	DT
47658	278	34	limitations	limitation	NNS
47658	278	35	of	of	IN
47658	278	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	278	37	finite	finite	JJ
47658	278	38	existence	existence	NN
47658	278	39	,	,	,
47658	278	40	but	but	CC
47658	278	41	because	because	IN
47658	278	42	God	God	NNP
47658	278	43	is	be	VBZ
47658	278	44	an	an	DT
47658	278	45	object	object	NN
47658	278	46	in	in	IN
47658	278	47	a	a	DT
47658	278	48	different	different	JJ
47658	278	49	sense	sense	NN
47658	278	50	from	from	IN
47658	278	51	that	that	DT
47658	278	52	which	which	WDT
47658	278	53	has	have	VBZ
47658	278	54	a	a	DT
47658	278	55	place	place	NN
47658	278	56	in	in	IN
47658	278	57	the	the	DT
47658	278	58	perceptual	perceptual	JJ
47658	278	59	order	order	NN
47658	278	60	,	,	,
47658	278	61	and	and	CC
47658	278	62	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	278	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	278	64	is	be	VBZ
47658	278	65	affirmed	affirm	VBN
47658	278	66	of	of	IN
47658	278	67	God	God	NNP
47658	278	68	that	that	WDT
47658	278	69	the	the	DT
47658	278	70	{	{	-LRB-
47658	278	71	31	31	CD
47658	278	72	}	}	-RRB-
47658	278	73	idea	idea	NN
47658	278	74	involves	involve	VBZ
47658	278	75	existence	existence	NN
47658	278	76	.	.	.
47658	279	1	God	God	NNP
47658	279	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	279	3	not	not	RB
47658	279	4	an	an	DT
47658	279	5	object	object	NN
47658	279	6	of	of	IN
47658	279	7	perception	perception	NN
47658	279	8	,	,	,
47658	279	9	either	either	CC
47658	279	10	actual	actual	JJ
47658	279	11	or	or	CC
47658	279	12	possible	possible	JJ
47658	279	13	;	;	,
47658	279	14	nor	nor	CC
47658	279	15	in	in	IN
47658	279	16	the	the	DT
47658	279	17	strict	strict	JJ
47658	279	18	sense	sense	NN
47658	279	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	279	20	God	God	NNP
47658	279	21	a	a	DT
47658	279	22	concept	concept	NN
47658	279	23	--	--	:
47658	279	24	that	that	DT
47658	279	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	279	26	to	to	TO
47658	279	27	say	say	VB
47658	279	28	,	,	,
47658	279	29	a	a	DT
47658	279	30	universal	universal	NN
47658	279	31	of	of	IN
47658	279	32	which	which	WDT
47658	279	33	there	there	EX
47658	279	34	may	may	MD
47658	279	35	be	be	VB
47658	279	36	particulars	particular	NNS
47658	279	37	.	.	.
47658	280	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	280	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	280	3	in	in	IN
47658	280	4	a	a	DT
47658	280	5	special	special	JJ
47658	280	6	sense	sense	NN
47658	280	7	the	the	DT
47658	280	8	object	object	NN
47658	280	9	of	of	IN
47658	280	10	reason	reason	NN
47658	280	11	.	.	.
47658	281	1	If	if	IN
47658	281	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	281	3	believe	believe	VBP
47658	281	4	that	that	IN
47658	281	5	there	there	EX
47658	281	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	281	7	a	a	DT
47658	281	8	God	God	NNP
47658	281	9	,	,	,
47658	281	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	281	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	281	12	because	because	IN
47658	281	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	281	14	reason	reason	NN
47658	281	15	tells	tell	VBZ
47658	281	16	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	281	17	that	that	IN
47658	281	18	there	there	EX
47658	281	19	must	must	MD
47658	281	20	be	be	VB
47658	281	21	.	.	.
47658	282	1	God	God	NNP
47658	282	2	,	,	,
47658	282	3	in	in	IN
47658	282	4	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	282	5	,	,	,
47658	282	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	282	7	the	the	DT
47658	282	8	idea	idea	NN
47658	282	9	of	of	IN
47658	282	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	282	11	existence	existence	NN
47658	282	12	,	,	,
47658	282	13	and	and	CC
47658	282	14	the	the	DT
47658	282	15	argument	argument	NN
47658	282	16	runs	run	VBZ
47658	282	17	:	:	:
47658	282	18	God	God	NNP
47658	282	19	must	must	MD
47658	282	20	be	be	VB
47658	282	21	,	,	,
47658	282	22	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	282	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	282	24	.	.	.
47658	283	1	If	if	IN
47658	283	2	,	,	,
47658	283	3	then	then	RB
47658	283	4	,	,	,
47658	283	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	283	6	exclude	exclude	VBP
47658	283	7	from	from	IN
47658	283	8	the	the	DT
47658	283	9	idea	idea	NN
47658	283	10	of	of	IN
47658	283	11	God	God	NNP
47658	283	12	every	every	DT
47658	283	13	mythological	mythological	JJ
47658	283	14	and	and	CC
47658	283	15	theological	theological	JJ
47658	283	16	element	element	NN
47658	283	17	--	--	:
47658	283	18	if	if	IN
47658	283	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	283	20	mean	mean	VBP
47658	283	21	not	not	RB
47658	283	22	Zeus	Zeus	NNP
47658	283	23	nor	nor	CC
47658	283	24	Jehovah	Jehovah	NNP
47658	283	25	nor	nor	CC
47658	283	26	Brahma	Brahma	NNP
47658	283	27	,	,	,
47658	283	28	but	but	CC
47658	283	29	the	the	DT
47658	283	30	first	first	JJ
47658	283	31	principle	principle	NN
47658	283	32	of	of	IN
47658	283	33	existence	existence	NN
47658	283	34	--	--	:
47658	283	35	then	then	RB
47658	283	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	283	37	may	may	MD
47658	283	38	find	find	VB
47658	283	39	in	in	IN
47658	283	40	the	the	DT
47658	283	41	St.	St.	NNP
47658	283	42	Anselm	Anselm	NNP
47658	283	43	argument	argument	NN
47658	283	44	the	the	DT
47658	283	45	very	very	JJ
47658	283	46	ground	ground	NN
47658	283	47	of	of	IN
47658	283	48	theism	theism	NN
47658	283	49	.	.	.
47658	284	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	284	2	have	have	VBP
47658	284	3	explained	explain	VBN
47658	284	4	this	this	DT
47658	284	5	argument	argument	NN
47658	284	6	,	,	,
47658	284	7	which	which	WDT
47658	284	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	284	9	of	of	IN
47658	284	10	the	the	DT
47658	284	11	class	class	NN
47658	284	12	called	call	VBN
47658	284	13	ontological	ontological	RB
47658	284	14	because	because	IN
47658	284	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	284	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	284	17	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	284	18	with	with	IN
47658	284	19	the	the	DT
47658	284	20	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	284	21	question	question	NN
47658	284	22	of	of	IN
47658	284	23	being	be	VBG
47658	284	24	,	,	,
47658	284	25	in	in	IN
47658	284	26	order	order	NN
47658	284	27	to	to	TO
47658	284	28	give	give	VB
47658	284	29	an	an	DT
47658	284	30	instance	instance	NN
47658	284	31	of	of	IN
47658	284	32	the	the	DT
47658	284	33	kind	kind	NN
47658	284	34	of	of	IN
47658	284	35	argument	argument	NN
47658	284	36	that	that	WDT
47658	284	37	has	have	VBZ
47658	284	38	given	give	VBN
47658	284	39	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	284	40	the	the	DT
47658	284	41	theory	theory	NN
47658	284	42	of	of	IN
47658	284	43	the	the	DT
47658	284	44	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	284	45	.	.	.
47658	285	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	285	2	will	will	MD
47658	285	3	now	now	RB
47658	285	4	try	try	VB
47658	285	5	to	to	TO
47658	285	6	set	set	VB
47658	285	7	that	that	DT
47658	285	8	theory	theory	NN
47658	285	9	before	before	IN
47658	285	10	the	the	DT
47658	285	11	reader	reader	NN
47658	285	12	,	,	,
47658	285	13	asking	ask	VBG
47658	285	14	only	only	RB
47658	285	15	that	that	IN
47658	285	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	285	17	will	will	MD
47658	285	18	put	put	VB
47658	285	19	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	285	20	into	into	IN
47658	285	21	the	the	DT
47658	285	22	position	position	NN
47658	285	23	of	of	IN
47658	285	24	a	a	DT
47658	285	25	plain	plain	JJ
47658	285	26	man	man	NN
47658	285	27	with	with	IN
47658	285	28	no	no	DT
47658	285	29	special	special	JJ
47658	285	30	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	285	31	with	with	IN
47658	285	32	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	285	33	,	,	,
47658	285	34	but	but	CC
47658	285	35	reflective	reflective	JJ
47658	285	36	and	and	CC
47658	285	37	anxious	anxious	JJ
47658	285	38	to	to	TO
47658	285	39	interpret	interpret	VB
47658	285	40	the	the	DT
47658	285	41	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	285	42	of	of	IN
47658	285	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	285	44	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	285	45	experience	experience	NN
47658	285	46	.	.	.
47658	286	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	286	2	have	have	VBP
47658	286	3	already	already	RB
47658	286	4	seen	see	VBN
47658	286	5	that	that	IN
47658	286	6	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	286	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	286	8	the	the	DT
47658	286	9	questioning	questioning	NN
47658	286	10	of	of	IN
47658	286	11	experience	experience	NN
47658	286	12	,	,	,
47658	286	13	and	and	CC
47658	286	14	that	that	IN
47658	286	15	the	the	DT
47658	286	16	moment	moment	NN
47658	286	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	286	18	begins	begin	VBZ
47658	286	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	286	20	gives	give	VBZ
47658	286	21	rise	rise	NN
47658	286	22	to	to	IN
47658	286	23	a	a	DT
47658	286	24	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	286	25	between	between	IN
47658	286	26	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	286	27	and	and	CC
47658	286	28	reality	reality	NN
47658	286	29	.	.	.
47658	287	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	287	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	287	3	the	the	DT
47658	287	4	asking	ask	VBG
47658	287	5	_	_	NN
47658	287	6	what	what	WP
47658	287	7	?	?	.
47658	287	8	_	_	NNP
47658	287	9	of	of	IN
47658	287	10	every	every	DT
47658	287	11	_	_	NNP
47658	287	12	that	that	WDT
47658	287	13	_	_	NNP
47658	287	14	of	of	IN
47658	287	15	felt	felt	JJ
47658	287	16	experience	experience	NN
47658	287	17	to	to	TO
47658	287	18	which	which	WDT
47658	287	19	the	the	DT
47658	287	20	mind	mind	NN
47658	287	21	attends	attend	VBZ
47658	287	22	.	.	.
47658	288	1	The	the	DT
47658	288	2	world	world	NN
47658	288	3	in	in	IN
47658	288	4	which	which	WDT
47658	288	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	6	find	find	VBP
47658	288	7	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	288	9	extended	extend	VBN
47658	288	10	all	all	RB
47658	288	11	around	around	IN
47658	288	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	13	in	in	IN
47658	288	14	space	space	NN
47658	288	15	and	and	CC
47658	288	16	full	full	JJ
47658	288	17	of	of	IN
47658	288	18	things	thing	NNS
47658	288	19	which	which	WDT
47658	288	20	affect	affect	VBP
47658	288	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	22	in	in	IN
47658	288	23	various	various	JJ
47658	288	24	ways	way	NNS
47658	288	25	:	:	:
47658	288	26	some	some	DT
47658	288	27	give	give	VBP
47658	288	28	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	29	pleasure	pleasure	NN
47658	288	30	,	,	,
47658	288	31	others	other	NNS
47658	288	32	give	give	VBP
47658	288	33	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	34	pain	pain	NN
47658	288	35	,	,	,
47658	288	36	and	and	CC
47658	288	37	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	38	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	39	are	be	VBP
47658	288	40	things	thing	NNS
47658	288	41	that	that	WDT
47658	288	42	affect	affect	VBP
47658	288	43	other	other	JJ
47658	288	44	things	thing	NNS
47658	288	45	as	as	RB
47658	288	46	well	well	RB
47658	288	47	as	as	IN
47658	288	48	being	be	VBG
47658	288	49	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	50	affected	affect	VBN
47658	288	51	by	by	IN
47658	288	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	288	53	.	.	.
47658	289	1	When	when	WRB
47658	289	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	289	3	think	think	VBP
47658	289	4	about	about	IN
47658	289	5	the	the	DT
47658	289	6	things	thing	NNS
47658	289	7	in	in	IN
47658	289	8	the	the	DT
47658	289	9	world	world	NN
47658	289	10	in	in	IN
47658	289	11	order	order	NN
47658	289	12	to	to	TO
47658	289	13	discover	discover	VB
47658	289	14	_	_	NNP
47658	289	15	what	what	WP
47658	289	16	_	_	NNP
47658	289	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	289	18	really	really	RB
47658	289	19	are	be	VBP
47658	289	20	,	,	,
47658	289	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	289	22	very	very	RB
47658	289	23	soon	soon	RB
47658	289	24	find	find	VBP
47658	289	25	that	that	IN
47658	289	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	289	27	are	be	VBP
47658	289	28	liable	liable	JJ
47658	289	29	to	to	IN
47658	289	30	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	289	31	and	and	CC
47658	289	32	error	error	NN
47658	289	33	.	.	.
47658	290	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	290	2	32	32	CD
47658	290	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	290	4	Things	thing	NNS
47658	290	5	turn	turn	VBP
47658	290	6	out	out	RP
47658	290	7	on	on	IN
47658	290	8	examination	examination	NN
47658	290	9	to	to	TO
47658	290	10	be	be	VB
47658	290	11	very	very	RB
47658	290	12	different	different	JJ
47658	290	13	to	to	IN
47658	290	14	what	what	WP
47658	290	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	290	16	first	first	RB
47658	290	17	imagined	imagine	VBD
47658	290	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	290	19	to	to	TO
47658	290	20	be	be	VB
47658	290	21	.	.	.
47658	291	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	291	2	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	291	3	,	,	,
47658	291	4	by	by	IN
47658	291	5	which	which	WDT
47658	291	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	291	7	try	try	VBP
47658	291	8	to	to	TO
47658	291	9	understand	understand	VB
47658	291	10	the	the	DT
47658	291	11	reality	reality	NN
47658	291	12	of	of	IN
47658	291	13	things	thing	NNS
47658	291	14	are	be	VBP
47658	291	15	just	just	RB
47658	291	16	so	so	RB
47658	291	17	many	many	JJ
47658	291	18	attempts	attempt	NNS
47658	291	19	to	to	TO
47658	291	20	correct	correct	VB
47658	291	21	and	and	CC
47658	291	22	set	set	VB
47658	291	23	right	right	RB
47658	291	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	291	25	illusions	illusion	NNS
47658	291	26	and	and	CC
47658	291	27	errors	error	NNS
47658	291	28	.	.	.
47658	292	1	And	and	CC
47658	292	2	so	so	RB
47658	292	3	the	the	DT
47658	292	4	question	question	NN
47658	292	5	arises	arise	VBZ
47658	292	6	,	,	,
47658	292	7	how	how	WRB
47658	292	8	far	far	RB
47658	292	9	are	be	VBP
47658	292	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	292	11	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	292	12	about	about	IN
47658	292	13	things	thing	NNS
47658	292	14	truths	truth	NNS
47658	292	15	about	about	IN
47658	292	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	292	17	?	?	.
47658	293	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	293	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	293	3	very	very	RB
47658	293	4	soon	soon	RB
47658	293	5	evident	evident	JJ
47658	293	6	that	that	IN
47658	293	7	there	there	EX
47658	293	8	are	be	VBP
47658	293	9	some	some	DT
47658	293	10	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	293	11	of	of	IN
47658	293	12	things	thing	NNS
47658	293	13	that	that	WDT
47658	293	14	give	give	VBP
47658	293	15	rise	rise	NN
47658	293	16	to	to	IN
47658	293	17	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	293	18	and	and	CC
47658	293	19	error	error	VB
47658	293	20	much	much	RB
47658	293	21	more	more	RBR
47658	293	22	readily	readily	RB
47658	293	23	than	than	IN
47658	293	24	others	other	NNS
47658	293	25	.	.	.
47658	294	1	The	the	DT
47658	294	2	spatial	spatial	JJ
47658	294	3	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	294	4	of	of	IN
47658	294	5	things	thing	NNS
47658	294	6	,	,	,
47658	294	7	solidity	solidity	NN
47658	294	8	,	,	,
47658	294	9	shape	shape	NN
47658	294	10	,	,	,
47658	294	11	size	size	NN
47658	294	12	,	,	,
47658	294	13	seem	seem	VBP
47658	294	14	to	to	TO
47658	294	15	be	be	VB
47658	294	16	real	real	JJ
47658	294	17	in	in	IN
47658	294	18	a	a	DT
47658	294	19	way	way	NN
47658	294	20	that	that	WDT
47658	294	21	does	do	VBZ
47658	294	22	not	not	RB
47658	294	23	admit	admit	VB
47658	294	24	of	of	IN
47658	294	25	doubt	doubt	NN
47658	294	26	.	.	.
47658	295	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	295	2	seem	seem	VBP
47658	295	3	able	able	JJ
47658	295	4	to	to	TO
47658	295	5	apply	apply	VB
47658	295	6	to	to	IN
47658	295	7	these	these	DT
47658	295	8	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	295	9	a	a	DT
47658	295	10	test	test	NN
47658	295	11	that	that	WDT
47658	295	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	295	13	definite	definite	JJ
47658	295	14	and	and	CC
47658	295	15	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	295	16	.	.	.
47658	296	1	On	on	IN
47658	296	2	the	the	DT
47658	296	3	other	other	JJ
47658	296	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	296	5	,	,	,
47658	296	6	there	there	EX
47658	296	7	seem	seem	VBP
47658	296	8	to	to	TO
47658	296	9	be	be	VB
47658	296	10	effects	effect	NNS
47658	296	11	of	of	IN
47658	296	12	these	these	DT
47658	296	13	things	thing	NNS
47658	296	14	in	in	IN
47658	296	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	296	16	such	such	JJ
47658	296	17	as	as	IN
47658	296	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	296	19	colour	colour	NN
47658	296	20	,	,	,
47658	296	21	taste	taste	NN
47658	296	22	,	,	,
47658	296	23	odour	odour	NN
47658	296	24	,	,	,
47658	296	25	sound	sound	NN
47658	296	26	,	,	,
47658	296	27	coldness	coldness	NN
47658	296	28	,	,	,
47658	296	29	or	or	CC
47658	296	30	heat	heat	NN
47658	296	31	,	,	,
47658	296	32	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	296	33	that	that	WDT
47658	296	34	are	be	VBP
47658	296	35	incessantly	incessantly	RB
47658	296	36	changing	change	VBG
47658	296	37	and	and	CC
47658	296	38	a	a	DT
47658	296	39	fruitful	fruitful	JJ
47658	296	40	source	source	NN
47658	296	41	of	of	IN
47658	296	42	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	296	43	and	and	CC
47658	296	44	error	error	NN
47658	296	45	.	.	.
47658	297	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	297	2	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	297	3	distinguish	distinguish	VBP
47658	297	4	the	the	DT
47658	297	5	spatial	spatial	JJ
47658	297	6	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	297	7	as	as	IN
47658	297	8	primary	primary	JJ
47658	297	9	,	,	,
47658	297	10	and	and	CC
47658	297	11	consider	consider	VB
47658	297	12	that	that	IN
47658	297	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	297	14	are	be	VBP
47658	297	15	the	the	DT
47658	297	16	real	real	JJ
47658	297	17	things	thing	NNS
47658	297	18	and	and	CC
47658	297	19	different	different	JJ
47658	297	20	from	from	IN
47658	297	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	297	22	effects	effect	NNS
47658	297	23	,	,	,
47658	297	24	which	which	WDT
47658	297	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	297	26	call	call	VBP
47658	297	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	297	28	secondary	secondary	JJ
47658	297	29	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	297	30	.	.	.
47658	298	1	And	and	CC
47658	298	2	this	this	DT
47658	298	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	298	4	,	,	,
47658	298	5	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	298	6	,	,	,
47658	298	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	298	8	most	most	RBS
47658	298	9	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	298	10	test	test	NN
47658	298	11	of	of	IN
47658	298	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	298	13	.	.	.
47658	299	1	If	if	IN
47658	299	2	,	,	,
47658	299	3	for	for	IN
47658	299	4	example	example	NN
47658	299	5	,	,	,
47658	299	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	299	7	should	should	MD
47658	299	8	think	think	VB
47658	299	9	that	that	IN
47658	299	10	something	something	NN
47658	299	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	299	12	see	see	VBP
47658	299	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	299	14	an	an	DT
47658	299	15	unreal	unreal	JJ
47658	299	16	phantom	phantom	NN
47658	299	17	,	,	,
47658	299	18	or	or	CC
47658	299	19	a	a	DT
47658	299	20	ghost	ghost	NN
47658	299	21	,	,	,
47658	299	22	or	or	CC
47658	299	23	some	some	DT
47658	299	24	kind	kind	NN
47658	299	25	of	of	IN
47658	299	26	hallucination	hallucination	NN
47658	299	27	,	,	,
47658	299	28	and	and	CC
47658	299	29	on	on	IN
47658	299	30	going	go	VBG
47658	299	31	up	up	RP
47658	299	32	to	to	IN
47658	299	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	299	34	find	find	VBP
47658	299	35	that	that	IN
47658	299	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	299	37	does	do	VBZ
47658	299	38	actually	actually	RB
47658	299	39	occupy	occupy	VB
47658	299	40	space	space	NN
47658	299	41	,	,	,
47658	299	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	299	43	correct	correct	VBP
47658	299	44	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	299	45	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	299	46	and	and	CC
47658	299	47	say	say	VB
47658	299	48	the	the	DT
47658	299	49	thing	thing	NN
47658	299	50	is	be	VBZ
47658	299	51	real	real	JJ
47658	299	52	.	.	.
47658	300	1	But	but	CC
47658	300	2	the	the	DT
47658	300	3	spatial	spatial	JJ
47658	300	4	or	or	CC
47658	300	5	primary	primary	JJ
47658	300	6	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	300	7	of	of	IN
47658	300	8	a	a	DT
47658	300	9	thing	thing	NN
47658	300	10	,	,	,
47658	300	11	although	although	IN
47658	300	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	300	13	may	may	MD
47658	300	14	seem	seem	VB
47658	300	15	more	more	RBR
47658	300	16	permanent	permanent	JJ
47658	300	17	and	and	CC
47658	300	18	more	more	RBR
47658	300	19	essential	essential	JJ
47658	300	20	to	to	IN
47658	300	21	the	the	DT
47658	300	22	reality	reality	NN
47658	300	23	of	of	IN
47658	300	24	the	the	DT
47658	300	25	thing	thing	NN
47658	300	26	than	than	IN
47658	300	27	the	the	DT
47658	300	28	secondary	secondary	JJ
47658	300	29	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	300	30	,	,	,
47658	300	31	are	be	VBP
47658	300	32	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
47658	300	33	only	only	JJ
47658	300	34	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	300	35	.	.	.
47658	301	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
47658	301	2	are	be	VBP
47658	301	3	not	not	RB
47658	301	4	the	the	DT
47658	301	5	thing	thing	NN
47658	301	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	301	7	,	,	,
47658	301	8	but	but	CC
47658	301	9	ways	way	NNS
47658	301	10	in	in	IN
47658	301	11	which	which	WDT
47658	301	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	301	13	affects	affect	VBZ
47658	301	14	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	301	15	.	.	.
47658	302	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	302	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	302	3	to	to	IN
47658	302	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	302	5	that	that	IN
47658	302	6	these	these	DT
47658	302	7	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	302	8	must	must	MD
47658	302	9	inhere	inhere	VB
47658	302	10	in	in	RB
47658	302	11	or	or	CC
47658	302	12	belong	belong	VB
47658	302	13	to	to	IN
47658	302	14	the	the	DT
47658	302	15	thing	thing	NN
47658	302	16	,	,	,
47658	302	17	and	and	CC
47658	302	18	so	so	RB
47658	302	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	302	20	try	try	VBP
47658	302	21	to	to	TO
47658	302	22	form	form	VB
47658	302	23	the	the	DT
47658	302	24	idea	idea	NN
47658	302	25	of	of	IN
47658	302	26	the	the	DT
47658	302	27	real	real	JJ
47658	302	28	thing	thing	NN
47658	302	29	as	as	IN
47658	302	30	a	a	DT
47658	302	31	substance	substance	NN
47658	302	32	or	or	CC
47658	302	33	substratum	substratum	NN
47658	302	34	which	which	WDT
47658	302	35	has	have	VBZ
47658	302	36	the	the	DT
47658	302	37	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	302	38	.	.	.
47658	303	1	This	this	DT
47658	303	2	was	be	VBD
47658	303	3	a	a	DT
47658	303	4	generally	generally	RB
47658	303	5	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	303	6	notion	notion	NN
47658	303	7	until	until	IN
47658	303	8	Berkeley	Berkeley	NNP
47658	303	9	(	(	-LRB-
47658	303	10	1685	1685	CD
47658	303	11	-	-	SYM
47658	303	12	1763	1763	CD
47658	303	13	)	)	-RRB-
47658	303	14	showed	show	VBD
47658	303	15	how	how	WRB
47658	303	16	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	303	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	303	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	303	19	.	.	.
47658	304	1	So	so	RB
47658	304	2	{	{	-LRB-
47658	304	3	33	33	CD
47658	304	4	}	}	-RRB-
47658	304	5	simple	simple	JJ
47658	304	6	and	and	CC
47658	304	7	convincing	convincing	JJ
47658	304	8	was	be	VBD
47658	304	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	304	10	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	304	11	of	of	IN
47658	304	12	the	the	DT
47658	304	13	notion	notion	NN
47658	304	14	,	,	,
47658	304	15	that	that	WDT
47658	304	16	never	never	RB
47658	304	17	since	since	IN
47658	304	18	has	have	VBZ
47658	304	19	material	material	NN
47658	304	20	substance	substance	NN
47658	304	21	been	be	VBN
47658	304	22	put	put	VBN
47658	304	23	forward	forward	RB
47658	304	24	as	as	IN
47658	304	25	an	an	DT
47658	304	26	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	304	27	of	of	IN
47658	304	28	the	the	DT
47658	304	29	reality	reality	NN
47658	304	30	of	of	IN
47658	304	31	the	the	DT
47658	304	32	things	thing	NNS
47658	304	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	304	34	perceive	perceive	VBP
47658	304	35	.	.	.
47658	305	1	All	all	DT
47658	305	2	that	that	WDT
47658	305	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	305	4	did	do	VBD
47658	305	5	was	be	VBD
47658	305	6	to	to	TO
47658	305	7	show	show	VB
47658	305	8	how	how	WRB
47658	305	9	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	305	10	and	and	CC
47658	305	11	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	305	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	305	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	305	14	to	to	TO
47658	305	15	think	think	VB
47658	305	16	that	that	IN
47658	305	17	the	the	DT
47658	305	18	reality	reality	NN
47658	305	19	of	of	IN
47658	305	20	that	that	DT
47658	305	21	which	which	WDT
47658	305	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	305	23	perceive	perceive	VBP
47658	305	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	305	25	something	something	NN
47658	305	26	in	in	IN
47658	305	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	305	28	nature	nature	NN
47658	305	29	imperceptible	imperceptible	JJ
47658	305	30	,	,	,
47658	305	31	for	for	IN
47658	305	32	such	such	JJ
47658	305	33	must	must	MD
47658	305	34	material	material	NN
47658	305	35	substance	substance	NN
47658	305	36	be	be	VB
47658	305	37	apart	apart	RB
47658	305	38	from	from	IN
47658	305	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	305	40	sense	sense	NN
47658	305	41	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	305	42	.	.	.
47658	306	1	How	how	WRB
47658	306	2	can	can	MD
47658	306	3	that	that	IN
47658	306	4	which	which	WDT
47658	306	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	306	6	perceive	perceive	VBP
47658	306	7	be	be	VBP
47658	306	8	something	something	NN
47658	306	9	imperceptible	imperceptible	JJ
47658	306	10	?	?	.
47658	307	1	And	and	CC
47658	307	2	if	if	IN
47658	307	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	307	4	reflect	reflect	VBP
47658	307	5	on	on	IN
47658	307	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	307	7	,	,	,
47658	307	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	307	9	shall	shall	MD
47658	307	10	surely	surely	RB
47658	307	11	agree	agree	VB
47658	307	12	that	that	IN
47658	307	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	307	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	307	15	so	so	RB
47658	307	16	--	--	:
47658	307	17	by	by	IN
47658	307	18	the	the	DT
47658	307	19	thing	thing	NN
47658	307	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	307	21	mean	mean	VBP
47658	307	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	307	23	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	307	24	,	,	,
47658	307	25	and	and	CC
47658	307	26	apart	apart	RB
47658	307	27	from	from	IN
47658	307	28	the	the	DT
47658	307	29	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	307	30	there	there	EX
47658	307	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	307	32	no	no	DT
47658	307	33	thing	thing	NN
47658	307	34	.	.	.
47658	308	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	308	2	must	must	MD
47658	308	3	try	try	VB
47658	308	4	,	,	,
47658	308	5	then	then	RB
47658	308	6	,	,	,
47658	308	7	in	in	IN
47658	308	8	some	some	DT
47658	308	9	other	other	JJ
47658	308	10	way	way	NN
47658	308	11	to	to	TO
47658	308	12	reach	reach	VB
47658	308	13	the	the	DT
47658	308	14	reality	reality	NN
47658	308	15	.	.	.
47658	309	1	What	what	WP
47658	309	2	,	,	,
47658	309	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	309	4	shall	shall	MD
47658	309	5	now	now	RB
47658	309	6	ask	ask	VB
47658	309	7	,	,	,
47658	309	8	can	can	MD
47658	309	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	309	10	be	be	VB
47658	309	11	that	that	IN
47658	309	12	binds	bind	NNS
47658	309	13	together	together	RB
47658	309	14	these	these	DT
47658	309	15	sense	sense	NN
47658	309	16	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	309	17	so	so	IN
47658	309	18	that	that	IN
47658	309	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	309	20	speak	speak	VBP
47658	309	21	of	of	IN
47658	309	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	309	23	as	as	IN
47658	309	24	a	a	DT
47658	309	25	thing	thing	NN
47658	309	26	?	?	.
47658	310	1	There	there	EX
47658	310	2	are	be	VBP
47658	310	3	two	two	CD
47658	310	4	elements	element	NNS
47658	310	5	that	that	WDT
47658	310	6	seem	seem	VBP
47658	310	7	to	to	TO
47658	310	8	enter	enter	VB
47658	310	9	into	into	IN
47658	310	10	everything	everything	NN
47658	310	11	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	310	12	that	that	WDT
47658	310	13	comes	come	VBZ
47658	310	14	into	into	IN
47658	310	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	310	16	experience	experience	NN
47658	310	17	,	,	,
47658	310	18	and	and	CC
47658	310	19	which	which	WDT
47658	310	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	310	21	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	310	22	to	to	IN
47658	310	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	310	24	would	would	MD
47658	310	25	remain	remain	VB
47658	310	26	if	if	IN
47658	310	27	everything	everything	NN
47658	310	28	in	in	IN
47658	310	29	the	the	DT
47658	310	30	universe	universe	NN
47658	310	31	were	be	VBD
47658	310	32	annihilated	annihilate	VBN
47658	310	33	.	.	.
47658	311	1	These	these	DT
47658	311	2	are	be	VBP
47658	311	3	space	space	NN
47658	311	4	and	and	CC
47658	311	5	time	time	NN
47658	311	6	.	.	.
47658	312	1	Are	be	VBP
47658	312	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	312	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	312	4	?	?	.
47658	313	1	Here	here	RB
47658	313	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	313	3	are	be	VBP
47658	313	4	met	meet	VBN
47658	313	5	with	with	IN
47658	313	6	a	a	DT
47658	313	7	new	new	JJ
47658	313	8	kind	kind	NN
47658	313	9	of	of	IN
47658	313	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	313	11	.	.	.
47658	314	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	314	2	was	be	VBD
47658	314	3	possible	possible	JJ
47658	314	4	to	to	TO
47658	314	5	dismiss	dismiss	VB
47658	314	6	material	material	NN
47658	314	7	substance	substance	NN
47658	314	8	as	as	IN
47658	314	9	a	a	DT
47658	314	10	false	false	JJ
47658	314	11	idea	idea	NN
47658	314	12	,	,	,
47658	314	13	an	an	DT
47658	314	14	idea	idea	NN
47658	314	15	of	of	IN
47658	314	16	something	something	NN
47658	314	17	whose	whose	WP$
47658	314	18	existence	existence	NN
47658	314	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	314	20	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	314	21	;	;	:
47658	314	22	but	but	CC
47658	314	23	space	space	NN
47658	314	24	and	and	CC
47658	314	25	time	time	NN
47658	314	26	are	be	VBP
47658	314	27	certainly	certainly	RB
47658	314	28	not	not	RB
47658	314	29	false	false	JJ
47658	314	30	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	314	31	.	.	.
47658	315	1	The	the	DT
47658	315	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	315	3	about	about	IN
47658	315	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	315	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	315	6	that	that	IN
47658	315	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	315	8	can	can	MD
47658	315	9	not	not	RB
47658	315	10	make	make	VB
47658	315	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	315	12	thought	thought	NN
47658	315	13	of	of	IN
47658	315	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	315	15	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	315	16	--	--	:
47658	315	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	315	18	are	be	VBP
47658	315	19	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	315	20	that	that	WDT
47658	315	21	contain	contain	VBP
47658	315	22	a	a	DT
47658	315	23	self	self	NN
47658	315	24	-	-	HYPH
47658	315	25	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	315	26	,	,	,
47658	315	27	or	or	CC
47658	315	28	at	at	IN
47658	315	29	least	least	JJS
47658	315	30	that	that	WDT
47658	315	31	lead	lead	VBP
47658	315	32	to	to	IN
47658	315	33	a	a	DT
47658	315	34	self	self	NN
47658	315	35	-	-	HYPH
47658	315	36	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	315	37	when	when	WRB
47658	315	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	315	39	affirm	affirm	VBP
47658	315	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	315	41	of	of	IN
47658	315	42	reality	reality	NN
47658	315	43	.	.	.
47658	316	1	With	with	IN
47658	316	2	the	the	DT
47658	316	3	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	316	4	of	of	IN
47658	316	5	space	space	NN
47658	316	6	and	and	CC
47658	316	7	time	time	NN
47658	316	8	are	be	VBP
47658	316	9	closely	closely	RB
47658	316	10	linked	link	VBN
47658	316	11	the	the	DT
47658	316	12	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	316	13	of	of	IN
47658	316	14	change	change	NN
47658	316	15	,	,	,
47658	316	16	of	of	IN
47658	316	17	movement	movement	NN
47658	316	18	,	,	,
47658	316	19	of	of	IN
47658	316	20	causation	causation	NN
47658	316	21	,	,	,
47658	316	22	of	of	IN
47658	316	23	quality	quality	NN
47658	316	24	and	and	CC
47658	316	25	quantity	quantity	NN
47658	316	26	,	,	,
47658	316	27	and	and	CC
47658	316	28	all	all	DT
47658	316	29	of	of	IN
47658	316	30	these	these	DT
47658	316	31	exhibit	exhibit	NN
47658	316	32	this	this	DT
47658	316	33	same	same	JJ
47658	316	34	puzzling	puzzling	JJ
47658	316	35	characteristic	characteristic	NN
47658	316	36	,	,	,
47658	316	37	that	that	IN
47658	316	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	316	39	seem	seem	VBP
47658	316	40	to	to	TO
47658	316	41	make	make	VB
47658	316	42	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	316	43	affirm	affirm	VB
47658	316	44	what	what	WP
47658	316	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	316	46	deny	deny	VBP
47658	316	47	and	and	CC
47658	316	48	deny	deny	VBP
47658	316	49	what	what	WP
47658	316	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	316	51	affirm	affirm	VBP
47658	316	52	.	.	.
47658	317	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	317	2	might	may	MD
47658	317	3	fill	fill	VB
47658	317	4	this	this	DT
47658	317	5	little	little	JJ
47658	317	6	book	book	NN
47658	317	7	with	with	IN
47658	317	8	illustrations	illustration	NNS
47658	317	9	of	of	IN
47658	317	10	the	the	DT
47658	317	11	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
47658	317	12	that	that	WDT
47658	317	13	are	be	VBP
47658	317	14	involved	involve	VBN
47658	317	15	in	in	IN
47658	317	16	these	these	DT
47658	317	17	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	317	18	working	work	VBG
47658	317	19	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	317	20	.	.	.
47658	318	1	Everyone	everyone	NN
47658	318	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	318	3	familiar	familiar	JJ
47658	318	4	with	with	IN
47658	318	5	the	the	DT
47658	318	6	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	318	7	involved	involve	VBN
47658	318	8	in	in	IN
47658	318	9	the	the	DT
47658	318	10	{	{	-LRB-
47658	318	11	34	34	CD
47658	318	12	}	}	-RRB-
47658	318	13	idea	idea	NN
47658	318	14	of	of	IN
47658	318	15	time	time	NN
47658	318	16	.	.	.
47658	319	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	319	2	must	must	MD
47658	319	3	think	think	VB
47658	319	4	there	there	EX
47658	319	5	was	be	VBD
47658	319	6	a	a	DT
47658	319	7	beginning	beginning	NN
47658	319	8	,	,	,
47658	319	9	and	and	CC
47658	319	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	319	11	can	can	MD
47658	319	12	not	not	RB
47658	319	13	think	think	VB
47658	319	14	that	that	IN
47658	319	15	there	there	EX
47658	319	16	was	be	VBD
47658	319	17	any	any	DT
47658	319	18	moment	moment	NN
47658	319	19	to	to	TO
47658	319	20	which	which	WDT
47658	319	21	there	there	EX
47658	319	22	was	be	VBD
47658	319	23	no	no	DT
47658	319	24	before	before	RB
47658	319	25	.	.	.
47658	320	1	So	so	RB
47658	320	2	also	also	RB
47658	320	3	with	with	IN
47658	320	4	space	space	NN
47658	320	5	,	,	,
47658	320	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	320	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	320	8	an	an	DT
47658	320	9	infinite	infinite	JJ
47658	320	10	extension	extension	NN
47658	320	11	which	which	WDT
47658	320	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	320	13	can	can	MD
47658	320	14	only	only	RB
47658	320	15	think	think	VB
47658	320	16	of	of	IN
47658	320	17	as	as	IN
47658	320	18	a	a	DT
47658	320	19	beyond	beyond	NN
47658	320	20	to	to	IN
47658	320	21	every	every	DT
47658	320	22	limit	limit	NN
47658	320	23	.	.	.
47658	321	1	This	this	DT
47658	321	2	receding	recede	VBG
47658	321	3	limit	limit	NN
47658	321	4	of	of	IN
47658	321	5	the	the	DT
47658	321	6	infinitely	infinitely	RB
47658	321	7	extensible	extensible	JJ
47658	321	8	space	space	NN
47658	321	9	involves	involve	VBZ
47658	321	10	the	the	DT
47658	321	11	character	character	NN
47658	321	12	of	of	IN
47658	321	13	infinite	infinite	JJ
47658	321	14	divisibility	divisibility	NN
47658	321	15	,	,	,
47658	321	16	for	for	IN
47658	321	17	if	if	IN
47658	321	18	there	there	EX
47658	321	19	are	be	VBP
47658	321	20	an	an	DT
47658	321	21	infinite	infinite	JJ
47658	321	22	number	number	NN
47658	321	23	of	of	IN
47658	321	24	points	point	NNS
47658	321	25	from	from	IN
47658	321	26	which	which	WDT
47658	321	27	straight	straight	JJ
47658	321	28	lines	line	NNS
47658	321	29	can	can	MD
47658	321	30	be	be	VB
47658	321	31	drawn	draw	VBN
47658	321	32	without	without	IN
47658	321	33	intersecting	intersect	VBG
47658	321	34	one	one	CD
47658	321	35	another	another	DT
47658	321	36	to	to	IN
47658	321	37	any	any	DT
47658	321	38	fixed	fixed	JJ
47658	321	39	point	point	NN
47658	321	40	there	there	EX
47658	321	41	is	be	VBZ
47658	321	42	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	321	43	no	no	DT
47658	321	44	smallest	small	JJS
47658	321	45	space	space	NN
47658	321	46	that	that	WDT
47658	321	47	can	can	MD
47658	321	48	not	not	RB
47658	321	49	be	be	VB
47658	321	50	further	further	RB
47658	321	51	divided	divide	VBN
47658	321	52	.	.	.
47658	322	1	The	the	DT
47658	322	2	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
47658	322	3	that	that	WDT
47658	322	4	follow	follow	VBP
47658	322	5	from	from	IN
47658	322	6	these	these	DT
47658	322	7	demonstrable	demonstrable	JJ
47658	322	8	contents	content	NNS
47658	322	9	of	of	IN
47658	322	10	the	the	DT
47658	322	11	idea	idea	NN
47658	322	12	of	of	IN
47658	322	13	space	space	NN
47658	322	14	are	be	VBP
47658	322	15	endless	endless	JJ
47658	322	16	.	.	.
47658	323	1	The	the	DT
47658	323	2	relation	relation	NN
47658	323	3	of	of	IN
47658	323	4	time	time	NN
47658	323	5	to	to	IN
47658	323	6	space	space	NN
47658	323	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	323	8	another	another	DT
47658	323	9	source	source	NN
47658	323	10	of	of	IN
47658	323	11	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	323	12	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	323	13	.	.	.
47658	324	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	324	2	shall	shall	MD
47658	324	3	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	324	4	,	,	,
47658	324	5	however	however	RB
47658	324	6	,	,	,
47658	324	7	best	well	RBS
47658	324	8	make	make	VB
47658	324	9	the	the	DT
47658	324	10	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	324	11	of	of	IN
47658	324	12	this	this	DT
47658	324	13	self	self	NN
47658	324	14	-	-	HYPH
47658	324	15	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	324	16	character	character	NN
47658	324	17	of	of	IN
47658	324	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	324	19	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	324	20	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	324	21	clear	clear	JJ
47658	324	22	by	by	IN
47658	324	23	following	follow	VBG
47658	324	24	out	out	RP
47658	324	25	a	a	DT
47658	324	26	definite	definite	JJ
47658	324	27	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	324	28	.	.	.
47658	325	1	What	what	WP
47658	325	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	325	3	known	know	VBN
47658	325	4	as	as	IN
47658	325	5	the	the	DT
47658	325	6	antinomy	antinomy	NN
47658	325	7	of	of	IN
47658	325	8	motion	motion	NN
47658	325	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	325	10	probably	probably	RB
47658	325	11	familiar	familiar	JJ
47658	325	12	to	to	IN
47658	325	13	everyone	everyone	NN
47658	325	14	from	from	IN
47658	325	15	the	the	DT
47658	325	16	well	well	RB
47658	325	17	-	-	HYPH
47658	325	18	known	know	VBN
47658	325	19	paradox	paradox	NN
47658	325	20	of	of	IN
47658	325	21	the	the	DT
47658	325	22	Greek	greek	JJ
47658	325	23	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	325	24	Zeno	Zeno	NNP
47658	325	25	.	.	.
47658	326	1	The	the	DT
47658	326	2	flying	fly	VBG
47658	326	3	arrow	arrow	NN
47658	326	4	,	,	,
47658	326	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	326	6	said	say	VBD
47658	326	7	,	,	,
47658	326	8	does	do	VBZ
47658	326	9	not	not	RB
47658	326	10	move	move	VB
47658	326	11	,	,	,
47658	326	12	because	because	IN
47658	326	13	if	if	IN
47658	326	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	326	15	did	do	VBD
47658	326	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	326	17	would	would	MD
47658	326	18	be	be	VB
47658	326	19	in	in	IN
47658	326	20	two	two	CD
47658	326	21	places	place	NNS
47658	326	22	at	at	IN
47658	326	23	one	one	CD
47658	326	24	and	and	CC
47658	326	25	the	the	DT
47658	326	26	same	same	JJ
47658	326	27	time	time	NN
47658	326	28	,	,	,
47658	326	29	and	and	CC
47658	326	30	that	that	DT
47658	326	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	326	32	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	326	33	.	.	.
47658	327	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	327	2	will	will	MD
47658	327	3	now	now	RB
47658	327	4	put	put	VB
47658	327	5	this	this	DT
47658	327	6	same	same	JJ
47658	327	7	paradox	paradox	NN
47658	327	8	of	of	IN
47658	327	9	movement	movement	NN
47658	327	10	in	in	IN
47658	327	11	a	a	DT
47658	327	12	form	form	NN
47658	327	13	which	which	WDT
47658	327	14	,	,	,
47658	327	15	so	so	RB
47658	327	16	far	far	RB
47658	327	17	as	as	IN
47658	327	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	327	19	know	know	VBP
47658	327	20	,	,	,
47658	327	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	327	22	has	have	VBZ
47658	327	23	not	not	RB
47658	327	24	been	be	VBN
47658	327	25	presented	present	VBN
47658	327	26	before	before	RB
47658	327	27	.	.	.
47658	328	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	328	2	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	328	3	will	will	MD
47658	328	4	involve	involve	VB
47658	328	5	the	the	DT
47658	328	6	idea	idea	NN
47658	328	7	of	of	IN
47658	328	8	causation	causation	NN
47658	328	9	as	as	RB
47658	328	10	well	well	RB
47658	328	11	as	as	IN
47658	328	12	that	that	DT
47658	328	13	of	of	IN
47658	328	14	movement	movement	NN
47658	328	15	.	.	.
47658	329	1	If	if	IN
47658	329	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	329	3	suppose	suppose	VBP
47658	329	4	a	a	DT
47658	329	5	space	space	NN
47658	329	6	to	to	TO
47658	329	7	be	be	VB
47658	329	8	fully	fully	RB
47658	329	9	occupied	occupy	VBN
47658	329	10	,	,	,
47658	329	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	329	12	shall	shall	MD
47658	329	13	agree	agree	VB
47658	329	14	that	that	IN
47658	329	15	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	329	16	within	within	IN
47658	329	17	that	that	DT
47658	329	18	space	space	NN
47658	329	19	can	can	MD
47658	329	20	move	move	VB
47658	329	21	without	without	IN
47658	329	22	thereby	thereby	RB
47658	329	23	displacing	displace	VBG
47658	329	24	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	329	25	occupies	occupy	VBZ
47658	329	26	the	the	DT
47658	329	27	position	position	NN
47658	329	28	into	into	IN
47658	329	29	which	which	WDT
47658	329	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	329	31	moves	move	VBZ
47658	329	32	.	.	.
47658	330	1	That	that	DT
47658	330	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	330	3	to	to	TO
47658	330	4	say	say	VB
47658	330	5	,	,	,
47658	330	6	the	the	DT
47658	330	7	movement	movement	NN
47658	330	8	of	of	IN
47658	330	9	any	any	DT
47658	330	10	occupant	occupant	NN
47658	330	11	of	of	IN
47658	330	12	one	one	CD
47658	330	13	position	position	NN
47658	330	14	must	must	MD
47658	330	15	cause	cause	VB
47658	330	16	the	the	DT
47658	330	17	displacement	displacement	NN
47658	330	18	of	of	IN
47658	330	19	the	the	DT
47658	330	20	occupant	occupant	NN
47658	330	21	of	of	IN
47658	330	22	the	the	DT
47658	330	23	new	new	JJ
47658	330	24	position	position	NN
47658	330	25	into	into	IN
47658	330	26	which	which	WDT
47658	330	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	330	28	moves	move	VBZ
47658	330	29	.	.	.
47658	331	1	But	but	CC
47658	331	2	on	on	IN
47658	331	3	the	the	DT
47658	331	4	other	other	JJ
47658	331	5	hand	hand	NN
47658	331	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	331	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	331	8	equally	equally	RB
47658	331	9	clear	clear	JJ
47658	331	10	that	that	IN
47658	331	11	the	the	DT
47658	331	12	displacement	displacement	NN
47658	331	13	of	of	IN
47658	331	14	the	the	DT
47658	331	15	occupant	occupant	NN
47658	331	16	of	of	IN
47658	331	17	the	the	DT
47658	331	18	new	new	JJ
47658	331	19	position	position	NN
47658	331	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	331	21	a	a	DT
47658	331	22	prior	prior	JJ
47658	331	23	condition	condition	NN
47658	331	24	of	of	IN
47658	331	25	the	the	DT
47658	331	26	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	331	27	of	of	IN
47658	331	28	the	the	DT
47658	331	29	movement	movement	NN
47658	331	30	of	of	IN
47658	331	31	{	{	-LRB-
47658	331	32	35	35	CD
47658	331	33	}	}	-RRB-
47658	331	34	the	the	DT
47658	331	35	mover	mover	NN
47658	331	36	,	,	,
47658	331	37	for	for	IN
47658	331	38	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	331	39	can	can	MD
47658	331	40	move	move	VB
47658	331	41	unless	unless	IN
47658	331	42	there	there	EX
47658	331	43	is	be	VBZ
47658	331	44	an	an	DT
47658	331	45	unoccupied	unoccupied	JJ
47658	331	46	place	place	NN
47658	331	47	for	for	IN
47658	331	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	331	49	to	to	TO
47658	331	50	move	move	VB
47658	331	51	into	into	IN
47658	331	52	,	,	,
47658	331	53	and	and	CC
47658	331	54	there	there	EX
47658	331	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	331	56	no	no	DT
47658	331	57	unoccupied	unoccupied	JJ
47658	331	58	place	place	NN
47658	331	59	unless	unless	IN
47658	331	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	331	61	has	have	VBZ
47658	331	62	been	be	VBN
47658	331	63	vacated	vacate	VBN
47658	331	64	by	by	IN
47658	331	65	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	331	66	occupant	occupant	NN
47658	331	67	before	before	IN
47658	331	68	the	the	DT
47658	331	69	movement	movement	NN
47658	331	70	begins	begin	VBZ
47658	331	71	.	.	.
47658	332	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	332	2	have	have	VBP
47658	332	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	332	4	the	the	DT
47658	332	5	clear	clear	JJ
47658	332	6	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	332	7	that	that	IN
47658	332	8	a	a	DT
47658	332	9	thing	thing	NN
47658	332	10	can	can	MD
47658	332	11	only	only	RB
47658	332	12	move	move	VB
47658	332	13	when	when	WRB
47658	332	14	something	something	NN
47658	332	15	else	else	RB
47658	332	16	which	which	WDT
47658	332	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	332	18	causes	cause	VBZ
47658	332	19	to	to	TO
47658	332	20	move	move	VB
47658	332	21	has	have	VBZ
47658	332	22	already	already	RB
47658	332	23	moved	move	VBN
47658	332	24	.	.	.
47658	333	1	Now	now	RB
47658	333	2	if	if	IN
47658	333	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	333	4	reflect	reflect	VBP
47658	333	5	on	on	IN
47658	333	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	333	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	333	8	shall	shall	MD
47658	333	9	see	see	VB
47658	333	10	that	that	IN
47658	333	11	this	this	DT
47658	333	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	333	13	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	333	14	the	the	DT
47658	333	15	position	position	NN
47658	333	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	333	17	occupy	occupy	VBP
47658	333	18	in	in	IN
47658	333	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	333	20	three	three	CD
47658	333	21	-	-	HYPH
47658	333	22	dimensional	dimensional	JJ
47658	333	23	space	space	NN
47658	333	24	.	.	.
47658	334	1	The	the	DT
47658	334	2	space	space	NN
47658	334	3	which	which	WDT
47658	334	4	surrounds	surround	VBZ
47658	334	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	334	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	334	7	occupied	occupy	VBN
47658	334	8	,	,	,
47658	334	9	and	and	CC
47658	334	10	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	334	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	334	12	can	can	MD
47658	334	13	not	not	RB
47658	334	14	move	move	VB
47658	334	15	until	until	IN
47658	334	16	a	a	DT
47658	334	17	way	way	NN
47658	334	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	334	19	made	make	VBN
47658	334	20	clear	clear	JJ
47658	334	21	for	for	IN
47658	334	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	334	23	,	,	,
47658	334	24	and	and	CC
47658	334	25	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	334	26	makes	make	VBZ
47658	334	27	way	way	NN
47658	334	28	for	for	IN
47658	334	29	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	334	30	unless	unless	IN
47658	334	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	334	32	move	move	VBP
47658	334	33	.	.	.
47658	335	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	335	2	can	can	MD
47658	335	3	not	not	RB
47658	335	4	move	move	VB
47658	335	5	through	through	IN
47658	335	6	stone	stone	NN
47658	335	7	walls	wall	NNS
47658	335	8	because	because	IN
47658	335	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	335	10	can	can	MD
47658	335	11	not	not	RB
47658	335	12	displace	displace	VB
47658	335	13	solid	solid	JJ
47658	335	14	matter	matter	NN
47658	335	15	,	,	,
47658	335	16	but	but	CC
47658	335	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	335	18	can	can	MD
47658	335	19	move	move	VB
47658	335	20	through	through	IN
47658	335	21	air	air	NN
47658	335	22	and	and	CC
47658	335	23	water	water	NN
47658	335	24	because	because	IN
47658	335	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	335	26	are	be	VBP
47658	335	27	able	able	JJ
47658	335	28	to	to	TO
47658	335	29	displace	displace	VB
47658	335	30	these	these	DT
47658	335	31	.	.	.
47658	336	1	The	the	DT
47658	336	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	336	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	336	4	the	the	DT
47658	336	5	same	same	JJ
47658	336	6	.	.	.
47658	337	1	My	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	337	2	movement	movement	NN
47658	337	3	displaces	displace	VBZ
47658	337	4	the	the	DT
47658	337	5	air	air	NN
47658	337	6	,	,	,
47658	337	7	but	but	CC
47658	337	8	there	there	EX
47658	337	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	337	10	no	no	DT
47658	337	11	movement	movement	NN
47658	337	12	until	until	IN
47658	337	13	the	the	DT
47658	337	14	air	air	NN
47658	337	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	337	16	displaced	displace	VBN
47658	337	17	.	.	.
47658	338	1	Can	Can	MD
47658	338	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	338	3	escape	escape	VB
47658	338	4	the	the	DT
47658	338	5	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	338	6	by	by	IN
47658	338	7	supposing	suppose	VBG
47658	338	8	the	the	DT
47658	338	9	displacement	displacement	NN
47658	338	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	338	11	the	the	DT
47658	338	12	cause	cause	NN
47658	338	13	and	and	CC
47658	338	14	the	the	DT
47658	338	15	movement	movement	NN
47658	338	16	the	the	DT
47658	338	17	effect	effect	NN
47658	338	18	.	.	.
47658	339	1	Are	be	VBP
47658	339	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	339	3	,	,	,
47658	339	4	like	like	IN
47658	339	5	people	people	NNS
47658	339	6	in	in	IN
47658	339	7	a	a	DT
47658	339	8	theatre	theatre	NN
47658	339	9	queue	queue	NN
47658	339	10	,	,	,
47658	339	11	only	only	RB
47658	339	12	able	able	JJ
47658	339	13	to	to	TO
47658	339	14	move	move	VB
47658	339	15	from	from	IN
47658	339	16	behind	behind	RB
47658	339	17	forward	forward	RB
47658	339	18	as	as	IN
47658	339	19	the	the	DT
47658	339	20	place	place	NN
47658	339	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	339	22	vacated	vacate	VBN
47658	339	23	for	for	IN
47658	339	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	339	25	in	in	IN
47658	339	26	front	front	NN
47658	339	27	?	?	.
47658	340	1	In	in	IN
47658	340	2	that	that	DT
47658	340	3	case	case	NN
47658	340	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	340	5	should	should	MD
47658	340	6	be	be	VB
47658	340	7	driven	drive	VBN
47658	340	8	to	to	IN
47658	340	9	the	the	DT
47658	340	10	incredible	incredible	JJ
47658	340	11	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	340	12	that	that	IN
47658	340	13	the	the	DT
47658	340	14	original	original	JJ
47658	340	15	cause	cause	NN
47658	340	16	or	or	CC
47658	340	17	condition	condition	NN
47658	340	18	of	of	IN
47658	340	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	340	20	movement	movement	NN
47658	340	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	340	22	the	the	DT
47658	340	23	previous	previous	JJ
47658	340	24	movement	movement	NN
47658	340	25	of	of	IN
47658	340	26	something	something	NN
47658	340	27	at	at	IN
47658	340	28	the	the	DT
47658	340	29	outskirts	outskirt	NNS
47658	340	30	of	of	IN
47658	340	31	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	340	32	occupied	occupy	VBN
47658	340	33	space	space	NN
47658	340	34	,	,	,
47658	340	35	that	that	IN
47658	340	36	this	this	DT
47658	340	37	somewhat	somewhat	RB
47658	340	38	moving	move	VBG
47658	340	39	into	into	IN
47658	340	40	the	the	DT
47658	340	41	void	void	NN
47658	340	42	made	make	VBN
47658	340	43	possible	possible	JJ
47658	340	44	the	the	DT
47658	340	45	movement	movement	NN
47658	340	46	of	of	IN
47658	340	47	the	the	DT
47658	340	48	occupant	occupant	NN
47658	340	49	of	of	IN
47658	340	50	the	the	DT
47658	340	51	space	space	NN
47658	340	52	next	next	IN
47658	340	53	adjoining	adjoin	VBG
47658	340	54	,	,	,
47658	340	55	and	and	CC
47658	340	56	so	so	RB
47658	340	57	on	on	RB
47658	340	58	until	until	IN
47658	340	59	after	after	IN
47658	340	60	a	a	DT
47658	340	61	lapse	lapse	NN
47658	340	62	of	of	IN
47658	340	63	time	time	NN
47658	340	64	which	which	WDT
47658	340	65	may	may	MD
47658	340	66	be	be	VB
47658	340	67	ages	age	NNS
47658	340	68	,	,	,
47658	340	69	which	which	WDT
47658	340	70	may	may	MD
47658	340	71	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	340	72	be	be	VB
47658	340	73	infinite	infinite	JJ
47658	340	74	,	,	,
47658	340	75	the	the	DT
47658	340	76	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	340	77	of	of	IN
47658	340	78	movement	movement	NN
47658	340	79	is	be	VBZ
47658	340	80	opened	open	VBN
47658	340	81	to	to	IN
47658	340	82	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	340	83	.	.	.
47658	341	1	In	in	IN
47658	341	2	fact	fact	NN
47658	341	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	341	4	must	must	MD
47658	341	5	believe	believe	VB
47658	341	6	that	that	IN
47658	341	7	the	the	DT
47658	341	8	effect	effect	NN
47658	341	9	of	of	IN
47658	341	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	341	11	movement	movement	NN
47658	341	12	--	--	:
47658	341	13	namely	namely	RB
47658	341	14	,	,	,
47658	341	15	the	the	DT
47658	341	16	displacement	displacement	NN
47658	341	17	of	of	IN
47658	341	18	the	the	DT
47658	341	19	previous	previous	JJ
47658	341	20	occupants	occupant	NNS
47658	341	21	from	from	IN
47658	341	22	the	the	DT
47658	341	23	positions	position	NNS
47658	341	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	341	25	occupy	occupy	VBP
47658	341	26	in	in	IN
47658	341	27	moving	move	VBG
47658	341	28	--	--	:
47658	341	29	happened	happen	VBN
47658	341	30	before	before	IN
47658	341	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	341	32	was	be	VBD
47658	341	33	caused	cause	VBN
47658	341	34	.	.	.
47658	342	1	Now	now	RB
47658	342	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	342	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	342	4	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	342	5	for	for	IN
47658	342	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	342	7	to	to	TO
47658	342	8	believe	believe	VB
47658	342	9	either	either	DT
47658	342	10	of	of	IN
47658	342	11	the	the	DT
47658	342	12	only	only	JJ
47658	342	13	two	two	CD
47658	342	14	alternatives	alternative	NNS
47658	342	15	--	--	:
47658	342	16	either	either	CC
47658	342	17	that	that	IN
47658	342	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	342	19	do	do	VBP
47658	342	20	not	not	RB
47658	342	21	really	really	RB
47658	342	22	move	move	VB
47658	342	23	but	but	CC
47658	342	24	only	only	RB
47658	342	25	{	{	-LRB-
47658	342	26	36	36	CD
47658	342	27	}	}	-RRB-
47658	342	28	appear	appear	VBP
47658	342	29	to	to	TO
47658	342	30	do	do	VB
47658	342	31	so	so	RB
47658	342	32	,	,	,
47658	342	33	or	or	CC
47658	342	34	that	that	IN
47658	342	35	the	the	DT
47658	342	36	displacement	displacement	NN
47658	342	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	342	38	movement	movement	NN
47658	342	39	causes	cause	VBZ
47658	342	40	really	really	RB
47658	342	41	precedes	precede	VBZ
47658	342	42	the	the	DT
47658	342	43	movement	movement	NN
47658	342	44	.	.	.
47658	343	1	When	when	WRB
47658	343	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	343	3	meet	meet	VBP
47658	343	4	with	with	IN
47658	343	5	a	a	DT
47658	343	6	direct	direct	JJ
47658	343	7	self	self	NN
47658	343	8	-	-	HYPH
47658	343	9	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	343	10	in	in	IN
47658	343	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	343	12	thoughts	thought	NNS
47658	343	13	about	about	IN
47658	343	14	anything	anything	NN
47658	343	15	,	,	,
47658	343	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	343	17	can	can	MD
47658	343	18	only	only	RB
47658	343	19	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	343	20	that	that	IN
47658	343	21	that	that	IN
47658	343	22	about	about	IN
47658	343	23	which	which	WDT
47658	343	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	343	25	are	be	VBP
47658	343	26	thinking	think	VBG
47658	343	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	343	28	in	in	IN
47658	343	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	343	30	nature	nature	NN
47658	343	31	nonsensical	nonsensical	JJ
47658	343	32	,	,	,
47658	343	33	or	or	CC
47658	343	34	else	else	RB
47658	343	35	that	that	WDT
47658	343	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	343	37	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	343	38	about	about	IN
47658	343	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	343	40	are	be	VBP
47658	343	41	wrong	wrong	JJ
47658	343	42	.	.	.
47658	344	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	344	2	may	may	MD
47658	344	3	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	344	4	be	be	VB
47658	344	5	thought	think	VBN
47658	344	6	that	that	IN
47658	344	7	the	the	DT
47658	344	8	whole	whole	JJ
47658	344	9	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	344	10	arises	arise	VBZ
47658	344	11	simply	simply	RB
47658	344	12	because	because	IN
47658	344	13	what	what	WP
47658	344	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	344	15	are	be	VBP
47658	344	16	trying	try	VBG
47658	344	17	to	to	TO
47658	344	18	think	think	VB
47658	344	19	consistently	consistently	RB
47658	344	20	about	about	IN
47658	344	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	344	22	a	a	DT
47658	344	23	reality	reality	NN
47658	344	24	that	that	WDT
47658	344	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	344	26	external	external	JJ
47658	344	27	to	to	IN
47658	344	28	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	344	29	.	.	.
47658	345	1	Space	space	NN
47658	345	2	and	and	CC
47658	345	3	time	time	NN
47658	345	4	,	,	,
47658	345	5	movement	movement	NN
47658	345	6	,	,	,
47658	345	7	cause	cause	NN
47658	345	8	and	and	CC
47658	345	9	effect	effect	NN
47658	345	10	are	be	VBP
47658	345	11	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	345	12	that	that	WDT
47658	345	13	apply	apply	VBP
47658	345	14	to	to	IN
47658	345	15	a	a	DT
47658	345	16	world	world	NN
47658	345	17	outside	outside	IN
47658	345	18	and	and	CC
47658	345	19	independent	independent	JJ
47658	345	20	of	of	IN
47658	345	21	the	the	DT
47658	345	22	mind	mind	NN
47658	345	23	that	that	WDT
47658	345	24	tries	try	VBZ
47658	345	25	to	to	TO
47658	345	26	think	think	VB
47658	345	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	345	28	.	.	.
47658	346	1	May	May	MD
47658	346	2	not	not	RB
47658	346	3	this	this	DT
47658	346	4	be	be	VB
47658	346	5	the	the	DT
47658	346	6	reason	reason	NN
47658	346	7	of	of	IN
47658	346	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	346	9	failure	failure	NN
47658	346	10	and	and	CC
47658	346	11	the	the	DT
47658	346	12	whole	whole	JJ
47658	346	13	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	346	14	of	of	IN
47658	346	15	the	the	DT
47658	346	16	seeming	seeming	JJ
47658	346	17	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	346	18	?	?	.
47658	347	1	If	if	IN
47658	347	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	347	3	turn	turn	VBP
47658	347	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	347	5	thoughts	thought	NNS
47658	347	6	inward	inward	RB
47658	347	7	upon	upon	IN
47658	347	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	347	9	own	own	JJ
47658	347	10	being	being	NN
47658	347	11	and	and	CC
47658	347	12	think	think	VB
47658	347	13	of	of	IN
47658	347	14	the	the	DT
47658	347	15	self	self	NN
47658	347	16	,	,	,
47658	347	17	the	the	DT
47658	347	18	I	I	NNP
47658	347	19	,	,	,
47658	347	20	the	the	DT
47658	347	21	real	real	JJ
47658	347	22	subject	subject	NN
47658	347	23	of	of	IN
47658	347	24	experience	experience	NN
47658	347	25	,	,	,
47658	347	26	then	then	RB
47658	347	27	surely	surely	RB
47658	347	28	where	where	WRB
47658	347	29	thought	thought	NN
47658	347	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	347	31	at	at	IN
47658	347	32	home	home	NN
47658	347	33	and	and	CC
47658	347	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	347	35	object	object	NN
47658	347	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	347	37	mental	mental	JJ
47658	347	38	not	not	RB
47658	347	39	physical	physical	JJ
47658	347	40	,	,	,
47658	347	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	347	42	shall	shall	MD
47658	347	43	know	know	VB
47658	347	44	reality	reality	NN
47658	347	45	.	.	.
47658	348	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	348	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	348	3	not	not	RB
47658	348	4	so	so	RB
47658	348	5	.	.	.
47658	349	1	The	the	DT
47658	349	2	same	same	JJ
47658	349	3	self	self	NN
47658	349	4	-	-	HYPH
47658	349	5	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	349	6	characterises	characterise	VBZ
47658	349	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	349	8	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	349	9	when	when	WRB
47658	349	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	349	11	try	try	VBP
47658	349	12	to	to	TO
47658	349	13	present	present	VB
47658	349	14	the	the	DT
47658	349	15	real	real	JJ
47658	349	16	object	object	NN
47658	349	17	of	of	IN
47658	349	18	inner	inner	JJ
47658	349	19	perception	perception	NN
47658	349	20	as	as	IN
47658	349	21	when	when	WRB
47658	349	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	349	23	try	try	VBP
47658	349	24	to	to	TO
47658	349	25	present	present	VB
47658	349	26	the	the	DT
47658	349	27	real	real	JJ
47658	349	28	object	object	NN
47658	349	29	of	of	IN
47658	349	30	external	external	JJ
47658	349	31	perception	perception	NN
47658	349	32	.	.	.
47658	350	1	Not	not	RB
47658	350	2	,	,	,
47658	350	3	of	of	IN
47658	350	4	course	course	NN
47658	350	5	,	,	,
47658	350	6	that	that	IN
47658	350	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	350	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	350	9	possible	possible	JJ
47658	350	10	to	to	TO
47658	350	11	doubt	doubt	VB
47658	350	12	the	the	DT
47658	350	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	350	14	of	of	IN
47658	350	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	350	16	own	own	JJ
47658	350	17	existence	existence	NN
47658	350	18	,	,	,
47658	350	19	but	but	CC
47658	350	20	that	that	IN
47658	350	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	350	22	fail	fail	VBP
47658	350	23	altogether	altogether	RB
47658	350	24	to	to	TO
47658	350	25	express	express	VB
47658	350	26	the	the	DT
47658	350	27	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	350	28	of	of	IN
47658	350	29	the	the	DT
47658	350	30	self	self	NN
47658	350	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	350	32	so	so	RB
47658	350	33	surely	surely	RB
47658	350	34	know	know	VBP
47658	350	35	to	to	TO
47658	350	36	exist	exist	VB
47658	350	37	in	in	IN
47658	350	38	any	any	DT
47658	350	39	idea	idea	NN
47658	350	40	which	which	WDT
47658	350	41	does	do	VBZ
47658	350	42	not	not	RB
47658	350	43	fall	fall	VB
47658	350	44	into	into	IN
47658	350	45	self	self	NN
47658	350	46	-	-	HYPH
47658	350	47	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	350	48	.	.	.
47658	351	1	As	as	IN
47658	351	2	in	in	IN
47658	351	3	the	the	DT
47658	351	4	case	case	NN
47658	351	5	of	of	IN
47658	351	6	the	the	DT
47658	351	7	thing	thing	NN
47658	351	8	and	and	CC
47658	351	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	351	10	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	351	11	,	,	,
47658	351	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	351	13	think	think	VBP
47658	351	14	that	that	IN
47658	351	15	there	there	EX
47658	351	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	351	17	something	something	NN
47658	351	18	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	351	19	from	from	IN
47658	351	20	the	the	DT
47658	351	21	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	351	22	in	in	IN
47658	351	23	which	which	WDT
47658	351	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	351	25	inhere	inhere	VBP
47658	351	26	and	and	CC
47658	351	27	yet	yet	RB
47658	351	28	find	find	VB
47658	351	29	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	351	30	unable	unable	JJ
47658	351	31	to	to	TO
47658	351	32	present	present	VB
47658	351	33	to	to	IN
47658	351	34	the	the	DT
47658	351	35	mind	mind	NN
47658	351	36	any	any	DT
47658	351	37	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	351	38	idea	idea	NN
47658	351	39	of	of	IN
47658	351	40	such	such	JJ
47658	351	41	thing	thing	NN
47658	351	42	,	,	,
47658	351	43	so	so	RB
47658	351	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	351	45	think	think	VBP
47658	351	46	that	that	IN
47658	351	47	there	there	EX
47658	351	48	must	must	MD
47658	351	49	be	be	VB
47658	351	50	some	some	DT
47658	351	51	substance	substance	NN
47658	351	52	or	or	CC
47658	351	53	basis	basis	NN
47658	351	54	of	of	IN
47658	351	55	personal	personal	JJ
47658	351	56	identity	identity	NN
47658	351	57	,	,	,
47658	351	58	some	some	DT
47658	351	59	real	real	JJ
47658	351	60	self	self	NN
47658	351	61	which	which	WDT
47658	351	62	_	_	NNP
47658	351	63	has	have	VBZ
47658	351	64	_	_	NNP
47658	351	65	the	the	DT
47658	351	66	successive	successive	JJ
47658	351	67	changing	change	VBG
47658	351	68	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	351	69	states	state	NNS
47658	351	70	,	,	,
47658	351	71	which	which	WDT
47658	351	72	has	have	VBZ
47658	351	73	the	the	DT
47658	351	74	character	character	NN
47658	351	75	which	which	WDT
47658	351	76	distinguishes	distinguish	VBZ
47658	351	77	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	351	78	actions	action	NNS
47658	351	79	as	as	IN
47658	351	80	personal	personal	JJ
47658	351	81	but	but	CC
47658	351	82	which	which	WDT
47658	351	83	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
47658	351	84	_	_	NNP
47658	351	85	is	be	VBZ
47658	351	86	_	_	NNP
47658	351	87	not	not	RB
47658	351	88	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	351	89	these	these	DT
47658	351	90	things	thing	NNS
47658	351	91	.	.	.
47658	352	1	The	the	DT
47658	352	2	self	self	NN
47658	352	3	-	-	HYPH
47658	352	4	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	352	5	{	{	-LRB-
47658	352	6	37	37	CD
47658	352	7	}	}	-RRB-
47658	352	8	in	in	IN
47658	352	9	the	the	DT
47658	352	10	idea	idea	NN
47658	352	11	of	of	IN
47658	352	12	self	self	NN
47658	352	13	,	,	,
47658	352	14	or	or	CC
47658	352	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	352	16	,	,	,
47658	352	17	or	or	CC
47658	352	18	subject	subject	JJ
47658	352	19	,	,	,
47658	352	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	352	21	that	that	IN
47658	352	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	352	23	both	both	DT
47658	352	24	can	can	MD
47658	352	25	not	not	RB
47658	352	26	change	change	VB
47658	352	27	and	and	CC
47658	352	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	352	29	always	always	RB
47658	352	30	changing	change	VBG
47658	352	31	.	.	.
47658	353	1	As	as	IN
47658	353	2	unchanging	unchanging	JJ
47658	353	3	,	,	,
47658	353	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	353	5	distinguish	distinguish	VBP
47658	353	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	353	7	from	from	IN
47658	353	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	353	9	body	body	NN
47658	353	10	,	,	,
47658	353	11	which	which	WDT
47658	353	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	353	13	an	an	DT
47658	353	14	external	external	JJ
47658	353	15	object	object	NN
47658	353	16	among	among	IN
47658	353	17	other	other	JJ
47658	353	18	objects	object	NNS
47658	353	19	and	and	CC
47658	353	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	353	21	different	different	JJ
47658	353	22	from	from	IN
47658	353	23	other	other	JJ
47658	353	24	objects	object	NNS
47658	353	25	only	only	RB
47658	353	26	in	in	IN
47658	353	27	the	the	DT
47658	353	28	more	more	RBR
47658	353	29	direct	direct	JJ
47658	353	30	and	and	CC
47658	353	31	intimate	intimate	JJ
47658	353	32	relation	relation	NN
47658	353	33	in	in	IN
47658	353	34	which	which	WDT
47658	353	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	353	36	stands	stand	VBZ
47658	353	37	to	to	IN
47658	353	38	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	353	39	.	.	.
47658	354	1	The	the	DT
47658	354	2	body	body	NN
47658	354	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	354	4	always	always	RB
47658	354	5	changing	change	VBG
47658	354	6	;	;	:
47658	354	7	never	never	RB
47658	354	8	for	for	IN
47658	354	9	two	two	CD
47658	354	10	successive	successive	JJ
47658	354	11	moments	moment	NNS
47658	354	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	354	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	354	14	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	354	15	the	the	DT
47658	354	16	same	same	JJ
47658	354	17	combination	combination	NN
47658	354	18	of	of	IN
47658	354	19	chemical	chemical	NN
47658	354	20	elements	element	NNS
47658	354	21	.	.	.
47658	355	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	355	2	distinguish	distinguish	VBP
47658	355	3	also	also	RB
47658	355	4	ourself	ourself	VBP
47658	355	5	from	from	IN
47658	355	6	that	that	DT
47658	355	7	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	355	8	which	which	WDT
47658	355	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	355	10	memory	memory	NN
47658	355	11	,	,	,
47658	355	12	the	the	DT
47658	355	13	awareness	awareness	NN
47658	355	14	of	of	IN
47658	355	15	past	past	JJ
47658	355	16	experience	experience	NN
47658	355	17	,	,	,
47658	355	18	from	from	IN
47658	355	19	present	present	JJ
47658	355	20	feelings	feeling	NNS
47658	355	21	,	,	,
47658	355	22	desires	desire	NNS
47658	355	23	,	,	,
47658	355	24	thoughts	thought	NNS
47658	355	25	,	,	,
47658	355	26	and	and	CC
47658	355	27	strivings	striving	NNS
47658	355	28	--	--	:
47658	355	29	these	these	DT
47658	355	30	,	,	,
47658	355	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	355	32	say	say	VBP
47658	355	33	,	,	,
47658	355	34	belong	belong	VBP
47658	355	35	to	to	IN
47658	355	36	the	the	DT
47658	355	37	self	self	NN
47658	355	38	but	but	CC
47658	355	39	are	be	VBP
47658	355	40	not	not	RB
47658	355	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	355	42	.	.	.
47658	356	1	The	the	DT
47658	356	2	self	self	NN
47658	356	3	must	must	MD
47658	356	4	have	have	VB
47658	356	5	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	356	6	and	and	CC
47658	356	7	dwell	dwell	VB
47658	356	8	in	in	IN
47658	356	9	the	the	DT
47658	356	10	body	body	NN
47658	356	11	,	,	,
47658	356	12	guiding	guide	VBG
47658	356	13	,	,	,
47658	356	14	directing	direct	VBG
47658	356	15	,	,	,
47658	356	16	and	and	CC
47658	356	17	controlling	control	VBG
47658	356	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	356	19	,	,	,
47658	356	20	yet	yet	RB
47658	356	21	this	this	DT
47658	356	22	self	self	NN
47658	356	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	356	24	never	never	RB
47658	356	25	perceive	perceive	VBP
47658	356	26	,	,	,
47658	356	27	nor	nor	CC
47658	356	28	can	can	MD
47658	356	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	356	30	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	356	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	356	32	,	,	,
47658	356	33	for	for	IN
47658	356	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	356	35	idea	idea	NN
47658	356	36	of	of	IN
47658	356	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	356	38	is	be	VBZ
47658	356	39	of	of	IN
47658	356	40	a	a	DT
47658	356	41	reality	reality	NN
47658	356	42	that	that	WDT
47658	356	43	changes	change	VBZ
47658	356	44	and	and	CC
47658	356	45	is	be	VBZ
47658	356	46	yet	yet	RB
47658	356	47	unchangeable	unchangeable	JJ
47658	356	48	.	.	.
47658	357	1	There	there	EX
47658	357	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	357	3	,	,	,
47658	357	4	however	however	RB
47658	357	5	,	,	,
47658	357	6	one	one	CD
47658	357	7	idea	idea	NN
47658	357	8	--	--	:
47658	357	9	an	an	DT
47658	357	10	idea	idea	NN
47658	357	11	to	to	TO
47658	357	12	which	which	WDT
47658	357	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	357	14	have	have	VBP
47658	357	15	already	already	RB
47658	357	16	alluded	allude	VBN
47658	357	17	--	--	:
47658	357	18	that	that	DT
47658	357	19	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	357	20	to	to	TO
47658	357	21	offer	offer	VB
47658	357	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	357	23	an	an	DT
47658	357	24	escape	escape	NN
47658	357	25	from	from	IN
47658	357	26	the	the	DT
47658	357	27	whole	whole	NN
47658	357	28	of	of	IN
47658	357	29	this	this	DT
47658	357	30	logical	logical	JJ
47658	357	31	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	357	32	,	,	,
47658	357	33	the	the	DT
47658	357	34	idea	idea	NN
47658	357	35	that	that	IN
47658	357	36	reality	reality	NN
47658	357	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	357	38	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	357	39	.	.	.
47658	358	1	May	May	MD
47658	358	2	not	not	RB
47658	358	3	the	the	DT
47658	358	4	contradictoriness	contradictoriness	NN
47658	358	5	of	of	IN
47658	358	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	358	7	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	358	8	be	be	VB
47658	358	9	due	due	JJ
47658	358	10	to	to	IN
47658	358	11	this	this	DT
47658	358	12	fact	fact	NN
47658	358	13	,	,	,
47658	358	14	that	that	IN
47658	358	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	358	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	358	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	358	18	entirely	entirely	RB
47658	358	19	of	of	IN
47658	358	20	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
47658	358	21	,	,	,
47658	358	22	of	of	IN
47658	358	23	appearances	appearance	NNS
47658	358	24	of	of	IN
47658	358	25	things	thing	NNS
47658	358	26	,	,	,
47658	358	27	and	and	CC
47658	358	28	not	not	RB
47658	358	29	of	of	IN
47658	358	30	things	thing	NNS
47658	358	31	as	as	IN
47658	358	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	358	33	are	be	VBP
47658	358	34	in	in	IN
47658	358	35	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	358	36	?	?	.
47658	359	1	By	by	IN
47658	359	2	a	a	DT
47658	359	3	thing	thing	NN
47658	359	4	-	-	HYPH
47658	359	5	in	in	IN
47658	359	6	-	-	HYPH
47658	359	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	359	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	359	9	do	do	VBP
47658	359	10	not	not	RB
47658	359	11	mean	mean	VB
47658	359	12	a	a	DT
47658	359	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	359	14	that	that	WDT
47658	359	15	dwells	dwell	VBZ
47658	359	16	apart	apart	RB
47658	359	17	in	in	IN
47658	359	18	a	a	DT
47658	359	19	universe	universe	NN
47658	359	20	of	of	IN
47658	359	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	359	22	own	own	JJ
47658	359	23	,	,	,
47658	359	24	out	out	IN
47658	359	25	of	of	IN
47658	359	26	any	any	DT
47658	359	27	relation	relation	NN
47658	359	28	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	359	29	to	to	IN
47658	359	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	359	31	universe	universe	NN
47658	359	32	.	.	.
47658	360	1	There	there	EX
47658	360	2	may	may	MD
47658	360	3	or	or	CC
47658	360	4	may	may	MD
47658	360	5	not	not	RB
47658	360	6	be	be	VB
47658	360	7	such	such	JJ
47658	360	8	realities	reality	NNS
47658	360	9	,	,	,
47658	360	10	and	and	CC
47658	360	11	whether	whether	IN
47658	360	12	there	there	EX
47658	360	13	are	be	VBP
47658	360	14	or	or	CC
47658	360	15	not	not	RB
47658	360	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	360	17	purely	purely	RB
47658	360	18	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	360	19	to	to	IN
47658	360	20	any	any	DT
47658	360	21	question	question	NN
47658	360	22	of	of	IN
47658	360	23	the	the	DT
47658	360	24	nature	nature	NN
47658	360	25	of	of	IN
47658	360	26	reality	reality	NN
47658	360	27	in	in	IN
47658	360	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	360	29	universe	universe	NN
47658	360	30	.	.	.
47658	361	1	The	the	DT
47658	361	2	thing	thing	NN
47658	361	3	-	-	HYPH
47658	361	4	in	in	IN
47658	361	5	-	-	HYPH
47658	361	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	361	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	361	8	the	the	DT
47658	361	9	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	361	10	reality	reality	NN
47658	361	11	of	of	IN
47658	361	12	the	the	DT
47658	361	13	thing	thing	NN
47658	361	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	361	15	know	know	VBP
47658	361	16	.	.	.
47658	362	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	362	2	conceive	conceive	VBP
47658	362	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	362	4	as	as	IN
47658	362	5	existing	exist	VBG
47658	362	6	in	in	IN
47658	362	7	complete	complete	JJ
47658	362	8	abstraction	abstraction	NN
47658	362	9	from	from	IN
47658	362	10	every	every	DT
47658	362	11	aspect	aspect	NN
47658	362	12	or	or	CC
47658	362	13	relation	relation	NN
47658	362	14	of	of	IN
47658	362	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	362	16	that	that	WDT
47658	362	17	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
47658	362	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	362	19	of	of	IN
47658	362	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	362	21	in	in	IN
47658	362	22	another	another	DT
47658	362	23	.	.	.
47658	363	1	The	the	DT
47658	363	2	self	self	NN
47658	363	3	-	-	HYPH
47658	363	4	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	363	5	of	of	IN
47658	363	6	such	such	PDT
47658	363	7	an	an	DT
47658	363	8	idea	idea	NN
47658	363	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	363	10	not	not	RB
47658	363	11	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	363	12	to	to	TO
47658	363	13	show	show	VB
47658	363	14	,	,	,
47658	363	15	quite	quite	RB
47658	363	16	apart	apart	RB
47658	363	17	from	from	IN
47658	363	18	any	any	DT
47658	363	19	consideration	consideration	NN
47658	363	20	of	of	IN
47658	363	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	363	22	utter	utter	JJ
47658	363	23	futility	futility	NN
47658	363	24	as	as	IN
47658	363	25	an	an	DT
47658	363	26	{	{	-LRB-
47658	363	27	38	38	CD
47658	363	28	}	}	-RRB-
47658	363	29	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	363	30	.	.	.
47658	364	1	The	the	DT
47658	364	2	thing	thing	NN
47658	364	3	-	-	HYPH
47658	364	4	in	in	IN
47658	364	5	-	-	HYPH
47658	364	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	364	7	either	either	CC
47658	364	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	364	9	or	or	CC
47658	364	10	else	else	RB
47658	364	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	364	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	364	13	not	not	RB
47658	364	14	the	the	DT
47658	364	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	364	16	of	of	IN
47658	364	17	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
47658	364	18	.	.	.
47658	365	1	If	if	IN
47658	365	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	365	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	365	4	,	,	,
47658	365	5	then	then	RB
47658	365	6	,	,	,
47658	365	7	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
47658	365	8	as	as	IN
47658	365	9	the	the	DT
47658	365	10	phenomena	phenomena	NN
47658	365	11	reveal	reveal	VBP
47658	365	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	365	13	,	,	,
47658	365	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	365	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	365	16	neither	neither	CC
47658	365	17	in	in	IN
47658	365	18	-	-	HYPH
47658	365	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	365	20	nor	nor	CC
47658	365	21	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	365	22	.	.	.
47658	366	1	If	if	IN
47658	366	2	,	,	,
47658	366	3	on	on	IN
47658	366	4	the	the	DT
47658	366	5	other	other	JJ
47658	366	6	hand	hand	NN
47658	366	7	,	,	,
47658	366	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	366	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	366	10	not	not	RB
47658	366	11	,	,	,
47658	366	12	if	if	IN
47658	366	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	366	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	366	15	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
47658	366	16	in	in	IN
47658	366	17	any	any	DT
47658	366	18	way	way	NN
47658	366	19	to	to	IN
47658	366	20	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
47658	366	21	,	,	,
47658	366	22	then	then	RB
47658	366	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	366	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	366	25	not	not	RB
47658	366	26	only	only	RB
47658	366	27	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
47658	366	28	--	--	:
47658	366	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	366	30	does	do	VBZ
47658	366	31	not	not	RB
47658	366	32	exist	exist	VB
47658	366	33	to	to	TO
47658	366	34	be	be	VB
47658	366	35	known	know	VBN
47658	366	36	.	.	.
47658	367	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	367	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	367	3	an	an	DT
47658	367	4	idea	idea	NN
47658	367	5	without	without	IN
47658	367	6	any	any	DT
47658	367	7	content	content	NN
47658	367	8	or	or	CC
47658	367	9	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	367	10	,	,	,
47658	367	11	and	and	CC
47658	367	12	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	367	13	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	JJ
47658	367	14	from	from	IN
47658	367	15	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	367	16	.	.	.
47658	368	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	368	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	368	3	simply	simply	RB
47658	368	4	saying	say	VBG
47658	368	5	of	of	IN
47658	368	6	one	one	CD
47658	368	7	and	and	CC
47658	368	8	the	the	DT
47658	368	9	same	same	JJ
47658	368	10	thing	thing	NN
47658	368	11	that	that	WDT
47658	368	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	368	13	must	must	MD
47658	368	14	be	be	VB
47658	368	15	and	and	CC
47658	368	16	that	that	IN
47658	368	17	there	there	EX
47658	368	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	368	19	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	368	20	that	that	IN
47658	368	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	368	22	can	can	MD
47658	368	23	be	be	VB
47658	368	24	.	.	.
47658	369	1	While	while	IN
47658	369	2	,	,	,
47658	369	3	then	then	RB
47658	369	4	,	,	,
47658	369	5	there	there	EX
47658	369	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	369	7	no	no	DT
47658	369	8	actual	actual	JJ
47658	369	9	thing	thing	NN
47658	369	10	that	that	WDT
47658	369	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	12	experience	experience	VBP
47658	369	13	,	,	,
47658	369	14	whether	whether	IN
47658	369	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	16	be	be	VB
47658	369	17	an	an	DT
47658	369	18	object	object	NN
47658	369	19	outside	outside	IN
47658	369	20	of	of	IN
47658	369	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	22	or	or	CC
47658	369	23	an	an	DT
47658	369	24	object	object	NN
47658	369	25	within	within	IN
47658	369	26	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	27	,	,	,
47658	369	28	of	of	IN
47658	369	29	which	which	WDT
47658	369	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	31	can	can	MD
47658	369	32	say	say	VB
47658	369	33	this	this	DT
47658	369	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	369	35	not	not	RB
47658	369	36	a	a	DT
47658	369	37	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
47658	369	38	or	or	CC
47658	369	39	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	369	40	of	of	IN
47658	369	41	reality	reality	NN
47658	369	42	but	but	CC
47658	369	43	the	the	DT
47658	369	44	actual	actual	JJ
47658	369	45	reality	reality	NN
47658	369	46	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	47	,	,	,
47658	369	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	49	can	can	MD
47658	369	50	not	not	RB
47658	369	51	also	also	RB
47658	369	52	say	say	VB
47658	369	53	that	that	IN
47658	369	54	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	55	do	do	VBP
47658	369	56	not	not	RB
47658	369	57	know	know	VB
47658	369	58	reality	reality	NN
47658	369	59	,	,	,
47658	369	60	because	because	IN
47658	369	61	if	if	IN
47658	369	62	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	63	had	have	VBD
47658	369	64	no	no	DT
47658	369	65	idea	idea	NN
47658	369	66	,	,	,
47658	369	67	no	no	DT
47658	369	68	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	369	69	,	,	,
47658	369	70	of	of	IN
47658	369	71	reality	reality	NN
47658	369	72	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	369	73	could	could	MD
47658	369	74	never	never	RB
47658	369	75	know	know	VB
47658	369	76	that	that	IN
47658	369	77	anything	anything	NN
47658	369	78	was	be	VBD
47658	369	79	only	only	RB
47658	369	80	an	an	DT
47658	369	81	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	369	82	.	.	.
47658	370	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	370	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	370	3	this	this	DT
47658	370	4	fact	fact	NN
47658	370	5	--	--	:
47658	370	6	the	the	DT
47658	370	7	fact	fact	NN
47658	370	8	that	that	IN
47658	370	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	370	10	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
47658	370	11	possess	possess	VBP
47658	370	12	,	,	,
47658	370	13	in	in	IN
47658	370	14	the	the	DT
47658	370	15	very	very	JJ
47658	370	16	process	process	NN
47658	370	17	of	of	IN
47658	370	18	thinking	think	VBG
47658	370	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	370	20	,	,	,
47658	370	21	a	a	DT
47658	370	22	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	370	23	of	of	IN
47658	370	24	reality	reality	NN
47658	370	25	--	--	:
47658	370	26	that	that	IN
47658	370	27	the	the	DT
47658	370	28	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	370	29	argument	argument	NN
47658	370	30	lays	lay	VBZ
47658	370	31	hold	hold	VBP
47658	370	32	of	of	IN
47658	370	33	as	as	IN
47658	370	34	the	the	DT
47658	370	35	basis	basis	NN
47658	370	36	of	of	IN
47658	370	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	370	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	370	39	.	.	.
47658	371	1	The	the	DT
47658	371	2	mere	mere	JJ
47658	371	3	fact	fact	NN
47658	371	4	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	371	5	,	,	,
47658	371	6	at	at	IN
47658	371	7	first	first	JJ
47658	371	8	sight	sight	NN
47658	371	9	,	,	,
47658	371	10	barren	barren	JJ
47658	371	11	and	and	CC
47658	371	12	unpromising	unpromise	VBG
47658	371	13	enough	enough	RB
47658	371	14	,	,	,
47658	371	15	but	but	CC
47658	371	16	the	the	DT
47658	371	17	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	371	18	does	do	VBZ
47658	371	19	not	not	RB
47658	371	20	find	find	VB
47658	371	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	371	22	so	so	RB
47658	371	23	.	.	.
47658	372	1	Possessed	possess	VBN
47658	372	2	of	of	IN
47658	372	3	this	this	DT
47658	372	4	principle	principle	NN
47658	372	5	,	,	,
47658	372	6	logic	logic	NN
47658	372	7	,	,	,
47658	372	8	which	which	WDT
47658	372	9	has	have	VBZ
47658	372	10	seemed	seem	VBN
47658	372	11	till	till	IN
47658	372	12	now	now	RB
47658	372	13	purely	purely	RB
47658	372	14	destructive	destructive	JJ
47658	372	15	,	,	,
47658	372	16	becomes	become	VBZ
47658	372	17	in	in	IN
47658	372	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	372	19	hands	hand	NNS
47658	372	20	creative	creative	JJ
47658	372	21	,	,	,
47658	372	22	and	and	CC
47658	372	23	gives	give	VBZ
47658	372	24	form	form	NN
47658	372	25	and	and	CC
47658	372	26	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	372	27	to	to	IN
47658	372	28	an	an	DT
47658	372	29	object	object	NN
47658	372	30	of	of	IN
47658	372	31	pure	pure	JJ
47658	372	32	reason	reason	NN
47658	372	33	.	.	.
47658	373	1	The	the	DT
47658	373	2	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	373	3	of	of	IN
47658	373	4	reality	reality	NN
47658	373	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	373	6	self	self	NN
47658	373	7	-	-	HYPH
47658	373	8	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	373	9	.	.	.
47658	374	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	374	2	can	can	MD
47658	374	3	not	not	RB
47658	374	4	think	think	VB
47658	374	5	that	that	IN
47658	374	6	anything	anything	NN
47658	374	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	374	8	ultimately	ultimately	RB
47658	374	9	real	real	JJ
47658	374	10	which	which	WDT
47658	374	11	has	have	VBZ
47658	374	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	374	13	ground	ground	NN
47658	374	14	of	of	IN
47658	374	15	existence	existence	NN
47658	374	16	in	in	IN
47658	374	17	something	something	NN
47658	374	18	else	else	RB
47658	374	19	.	.	.
47658	375	1	A	a	DT
47658	375	2	real	real	JJ
47658	375	3	thing	thing	NN
47658	375	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	375	5	that	that	DT
47658	375	6	which	which	WDT
47658	375	7	can	can	MD
47658	375	8	be	be	VB
47658	375	9	explained	explain	VBN
47658	375	10	without	without	IN
47658	375	11	reference	reference	NN
47658	375	12	to	to	IN
47658	375	13	some	some	DT
47658	375	14	other	other	JJ
47658	375	15	thing	thing	NN
47658	375	16	.	.	.
47658	376	1	Reality	reality	NN
47658	376	2	,	,	,
47658	376	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	376	4	,	,	,
47658	376	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	376	6	completely	completely	RB
47658	376	7	self	self	NN
47658	376	8	-	-	HYPH
47658	376	9	contained	contain	VBN
47658	376	10	existence	existence	NN
47658	376	11	,	,	,
47658	376	12	not	not	RB
47658	376	13	merely	merely	RB
47658	376	14	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	376	15	existence	existence	NN
47658	376	16	.	.	.
47658	377	1	Contradictions	contradiction	NNS
47658	377	2	can	can	MD
47658	377	3	not	not	RB
47658	377	4	be	be	VB
47658	377	5	true	true	JJ
47658	377	6	.	.	.
47658	378	1	If	if	IN
47658	378	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	378	3	have	have	VBP
47658	378	4	to	to	TO
47658	378	5	affirm	affirm	VB
47658	378	6	a	a	DT
47658	378	7	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	378	8	of	of	IN
47658	378	9	anything	anything	NN
47658	378	10	,	,	,
47658	378	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	378	12	must	must	MD
47658	378	13	be	be	VB
47658	378	14	due	due	IN
47658	378	15	to	to	IN
47658	378	16	an	an	DT
47658	378	17	{	{	-LRB-
47658	378	18	39	39	CD
47658	378	19	}	}	-RRB-
47658	378	20	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	378	21	,	,	,
47658	378	22	and	and	CC
47658	378	23	the	the	DT
47658	378	24	reality	reality	NN
47658	378	25	must	must	MD
47658	378	26	reconcile	reconcile	VB
47658	378	27	the	the	DT
47658	378	28	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	378	29	.	.	.
47658	379	1	The	the	DT
47658	379	2	idea	idea	NN
47658	379	3	of	of	IN
47658	379	4	reality	reality	NN
47658	379	5	,	,	,
47658	379	6	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	379	7	,	,	,
47658	379	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	379	9	the	the	DT
47658	379	10	idea	idea	NN
47658	379	11	of	of	IN
47658	379	12	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	379	13	harmony	harmony	NN
47658	379	14	.	.	.
47658	380	1	Knowing	Knowing	NNP
47658	380	2	,	,	,
47658	380	3	then	then	RB
47658	380	4	,	,	,
47658	380	5	what	what	WDT
47658	380	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	380	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	380	8	,	,	,
47658	380	9	can	can	MD
47658	380	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	380	11	say	say	VB
47658	380	12	that	that	IN
47658	380	13	there	there	EX
47658	380	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	380	15	any	any	DT
47658	380	16	actual	actual	JJ
47658	380	17	object	object	NN
47658	380	18	of	of	IN
47658	380	19	thought	thought	NN
47658	380	20	that	that	WDT
47658	380	21	conforms	conform	VBZ
47658	380	22	to	to	IN
47658	380	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	380	24	?	?	.
47658	381	1	And	and	CC
47658	381	2	have	have	VB
47658	381	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	381	4	in	in	IN
47658	381	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	381	6	limited	limited	JJ
47658	381	7	experience	experience	NN
47658	381	8	anything	anything	NN
47658	381	9	that	that	WDT
47658	381	10	will	will	MD
47658	381	11	guide	guide	VB
47658	381	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	381	13	to	to	IN
47658	381	14	the	the	DT
47658	381	15	attainment	attainment	NN
47658	381	16	of	of	IN
47658	381	17	this	this	DT
47658	381	18	object	object	NN
47658	381	19	?	?	.
47658	382	1	The	the	DT
47658	382	2	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	382	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	382	4	confident	confident	JJ
47658	382	5	that	that	IN
47658	382	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	382	7	have	have	VBP
47658	382	8	.	.	.
47658	383	1	Some	some	DT
47658	383	2	things	thing	NNS
47658	383	3	seem	seem	VBP
47658	383	4	to	to	IN
47658	383	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	383	6	to	to	TO
47658	383	7	possess	possess	VB
47658	383	8	a	a	DT
47658	383	9	far	far	RB
47658	383	10	higher	high	JJR
47658	383	11	degree	degree	NN
47658	383	12	of	of	IN
47658	383	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	383	14	than	than	IN
47658	383	15	others	other	NNS
47658	383	16	,	,	,
47658	383	17	just	just	RB
47658	383	18	because	because	IN
47658	383	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	383	20	conform	conform	VBP
47658	383	21	in	in	IN
47658	383	22	a	a	DT
47658	383	23	greater	great	JJR
47658	383	24	degree	degree	NN
47658	383	25	to	to	IN
47658	383	26	this	this	DT
47658	383	27	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	383	28	of	of	IN
47658	383	29	harmonious	harmonious	JJ
47658	383	30	existence	existence	NN
47658	383	31	.	.	.
47658	384	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	384	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	384	3	when	when	WRB
47658	384	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	384	5	compare	compare	VBP
47658	384	6	the	the	DT
47658	384	7	reality	reality	NN
47658	384	8	of	of	IN
47658	384	9	physical	physical	JJ
47658	384	10	things	thing	NNS
47658	384	11	with	with	IN
47658	384	12	the	the	DT
47658	384	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	384	14	of	of	IN
47658	384	15	mental	mental	JJ
47658	384	16	things	thing	NNS
47658	384	17	that	that	WDT
47658	384	18	the	the	DT
47658	384	19	contrast	contrast	NN
47658	384	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	384	21	most	most	RBS
47658	384	22	striking	striking	JJ
47658	384	23	,	,	,
47658	384	24	and	and	CC
47658	384	25	in	in	IN
47658	384	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	384	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	384	28	have	have	VBP
47658	384	29	the	the	DT
47658	384	30	clue	clue	NN
47658	384	31	to	to	IN
47658	384	32	the	the	DT
47658	384	33	nature	nature	NN
47658	384	34	of	of	IN
47658	384	35	the	the	DT
47658	384	36	higher	high	JJR
47658	384	37	reality	reality	NN
47658	384	38	.	.	.
47658	385	1	Physical	physical	JJ
47658	385	2	reality	reality	NN
47658	385	3	may	may	MD
47658	385	4	seem	seem	VB
47658	385	5	,	,	,
47658	385	6	and	and	CC
47658	385	7	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	385	8	in	in	IN
47658	385	9	a	a	DT
47658	385	10	certain	certain	JJ
47658	385	11	sense	sense	NN
47658	385	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	385	13	,	,	,
47658	385	14	the	the	DT
47658	385	15	basis	basis	NN
47658	385	16	of	of	IN
47658	385	17	existence	existence	NN
47658	385	18	,	,	,
47658	385	19	but	but	CC
47658	385	20	when	when	WRB
47658	385	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	385	22	try	try	VBP
47658	385	23	to	to	TO
47658	385	24	think	think	VB
47658	385	25	out	out	RP
47658	385	26	the	the	DT
47658	385	27	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	385	28	of	of	IN
47658	385	29	physical	physical	JJ
47658	385	30	reality	reality	NN
47658	385	31	,	,	,
47658	385	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	385	33	becomes	become	VBZ
47658	385	34	increasingly	increasingly	RB
47658	385	35	abstract	abstract	JJ
47658	385	36	,	,	,
47658	385	37	and	and	CC
47658	385	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	385	39	seem	seem	VBP
47658	385	40	unable	unable	JJ
47658	385	41	to	to	TO
47658	385	42	set	set	VB
47658	385	43	any	any	DT
47658	385	44	actual	actual	JJ
47658	385	45	limit	limit	NN
47658	385	46	to	to	TO
47658	385	47	prevent	prevent	VB
47658	385	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	385	49	dissipating	dissipate	VBG
47658	385	50	into	into	IN
47658	385	51	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	385	52	.	.	.
47658	386	1	In	in	IN
47658	386	2	physical	physical	JJ
47658	386	3	science	science	NN
47658	386	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	386	5	never	never	RB
47658	386	6	have	have	VBP
47658	386	7	before	before	IN
47658	386	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	386	9	an	an	DT
47658	386	10	actual	actual	JJ
47658	386	11	element	element	NN
47658	386	12	,	,	,
47658	386	13	either	either	CC
47658	386	14	matter	matter	NN
47658	386	15	or	or	CC
47658	386	16	energy	energy	NN
47658	386	17	,	,	,
47658	386	18	in	in	IN
47658	386	19	which	which	WDT
47658	386	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	386	21	can	can	MD
47658	386	22	recognise	recognise	VB
47658	386	23	,	,	,
47658	386	24	however	however	RB
47658	386	25	far	far	RB
47658	386	26	below	below	IN
47658	386	27	the	the	DT
47658	386	28	limit	limit	NN
47658	386	29	of	of	IN
47658	386	30	perceivability	perceivability	NN
47658	386	31	,	,	,
47658	386	32	the	the	DT
47658	386	33	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	386	34	stuff	stuff	NN
47658	386	35	of	of	IN
47658	386	36	which	which	WDT
47658	386	37	the	the	DT
47658	386	38	universe	universe	NN
47658	386	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	386	40	composed	compose	VBN
47658	386	41	.	.	.
47658	387	1	Science	science	NN
47658	387	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	387	3	simply	simply	RB
47658	387	4	to	to	TO
47658	387	5	arrest	arrest	VB
47658	387	6	the	the	DT
47658	387	7	dissipation	dissipation	NN
47658	387	8	by	by	IN
47658	387	9	boldly	boldly	RB
47658	387	10	assuming	assume	VBG
47658	387	11	a	a	DT
47658	387	12	matter	matter	NN
47658	387	13	that	that	WDT
47658	387	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	387	15	the	the	DT
47658	387	16	substance	substance	NN
47658	387	17	and	and	CC
47658	387	18	foundation	foundation	NN
47658	387	19	of	of	IN
47658	387	20	reality	reality	NN
47658	387	21	and	and	CC
47658	387	22	an	an	DT
47658	387	23	energy	energy	NN
47658	387	24	that	that	WDT
47658	387	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	387	26	the	the	DT
47658	387	27	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	387	28	cause	cause	NN
47658	387	29	of	of	IN
47658	387	30	the	the	DT
47658	387	31	evolution	evolution	NN
47658	387	32	of	of	IN
47658	387	33	the	the	DT
47658	387	34	universe	universe	NN
47658	387	35	.	.	.
47658	388	1	On	on	IN
47658	388	2	the	the	DT
47658	388	3	other	other	JJ
47658	388	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	388	5	,	,	,
47658	388	6	when	when	WRB
47658	388	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	388	8	consider	consider	VBP
47658	388	9	mental	mental	JJ
47658	388	10	existence	existence	NN
47658	388	11	,	,	,
47658	388	12	the	the	DT
47658	388	13	pursuit	pursuit	NN
47658	388	14	of	of	IN
47658	388	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	388	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	388	17	in	in	IN
47658	388	18	an	an	DT
47658	388	19	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	388	20	contrary	contrary	JJ
47658	388	21	direction	direction	NN
47658	388	22	.	.	.
47658	389	1	There	there	RB
47658	389	2	,	,	,
47658	389	3	the	the	DT
47658	389	4	more	more	RBR
47658	389	5	concrete	concrete	NN
47658	389	6	,	,	,
47658	389	7	the	the	DT
47658	389	8	more	more	RBR
47658	389	9	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
47658	389	10	,	,	,
47658	389	11	the	the	DT
47658	389	12	more	more	RBR
47658	389	13	individual	individual	JJ
47658	389	14	a	a	DT
47658	389	15	thing	thing	NN
47658	389	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	389	17	,	,	,
47658	389	18	the	the	DT
47658	389	19	greater	great	JJR
47658	389	20	degree	degree	NN
47658	389	21	of	of	IN
47658	389	22	reality	reality	NN
47658	389	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	389	24	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	389	25	to	to	TO
47658	389	26	have	have	VB
47658	389	27	.	.	.
47658	390	1	In	in	IN
47658	390	2	the	the	DT
47658	390	3	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
47658	390	4	realm	realm	NN
47658	390	5	,	,	,
47658	390	6	by	by	IN
47658	390	7	which	which	WDT
47658	390	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	390	9	mean	mean	VBP
47658	390	10	,	,	,
47658	390	11	not	not	RB
47658	390	12	some	some	DT
47658	390	13	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	390	14	supra	supra	NNP
47658	390	15	-	-	HYPH
47658	390	16	mundane	mundane	JJ
47658	390	17	sphere	sphere	NN
47658	390	18	,	,	,
47658	390	19	but	but	CC
47658	390	20	the	the	DT
47658	390	21	world	world	NN
47658	390	22	of	of	IN
47658	390	23	values	value	NNS
47658	390	24	,	,	,
47658	390	25	the	the	DT
47658	390	26	world	world	NN
47658	390	27	in	in	IN
47658	390	28	which	which	WDT
47658	390	29	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	390	30	have	have	VBP
47658	390	31	reality	reality	NN
47658	390	32	,	,	,
47658	390	33	in	in	IN
47658	390	34	which	which	WDT
47658	390	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	390	36	live	live	VBP
47658	390	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	390	38	rational	rational	JJ
47658	390	39	life	life	NN
47658	390	40	,	,	,
47658	390	41	reality	reality	NN
47658	390	42	is	be	VBZ
47658	390	43	always	always	RB
47658	390	44	sought	seek	VBN
47658	390	45	in	in	IN
47658	390	46	a	a	DT
47658	390	47	{	{	-LRB-
47658	390	48	40	40	CD
47658	390	49	}	}	-RRB-
47658	390	50	higher	high	JJR
47658	390	51	and	and	CC
47658	390	52	higher	high	JJR
47658	390	53	individuality	individuality	NN
47658	390	54	.	.	.
47658	391	1	The	the	DT
47658	391	2	principle	principle	NN
47658	391	3	of	of	IN
47658	391	4	individuality	individuality	NN
47658	391	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	391	6	that	that	IN
47658	391	7	the	the	DT
47658	391	8	whole	whole	NN
47658	391	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	391	10	more	more	RBR
47658	391	11	real	real	JJ
47658	391	12	than	than	IN
47658	391	13	the	the	DT
47658	391	14	parts	part	NNS
47658	391	15	.	.	.
47658	392	1	An	an	DT
47658	392	2	individual	individual	JJ
47658	392	3	human	human	JJ
47658	392	4	being	being	NN
47658	392	5	,	,	,
47658	392	6	for	for	IN
47658	392	7	example	example	NN
47658	392	8	,	,	,
47658	392	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	392	10	a	a	DT
47658	392	11	whole	whole	NN
47658	392	12	,	,	,
47658	392	13	an	an	DT
47658	392	14	indivisible	indivisible	JJ
47658	392	15	organic	organic	JJ
47658	392	16	unity	unity	NN
47658	392	17	,	,	,
47658	392	18	not	not	RB
47658	392	19	merely	merely	RB
47658	392	20	an	an	DT
47658	392	21	aggregation	aggregation	NN
47658	392	22	of	of	IN
47658	392	23	physiological	physiological	JJ
47658	392	24	organs	organ	NNS
47658	392	25	with	with	IN
47658	392	26	special	special	JJ
47658	392	27	functions	function	NNS
47658	392	28	,	,	,
47658	392	29	nor	nor	CC
47658	392	30	are	be	VBP
47658	392	31	these	these	DT
47658	392	32	a	a	DT
47658	392	33	mere	mere	JJ
47658	392	34	collection	collection	NN
47658	392	35	of	of	IN
47658	392	36	special	special	JJ
47658	392	37	cells	cell	NNS
47658	392	38	,	,	,
47658	392	39	nor	nor	CC
47658	392	40	these	these	DT
47658	392	41	a	a	DT
47658	392	42	mere	mere	JJ
47658	392	43	concourse	concourse	NN
47658	392	44	of	of	IN
47658	392	45	chemical	chemical	JJ
47658	392	46	elements	element	NNS
47658	392	47	.	.	.
47658	393	1	The	the	DT
47658	393	2	State	State	NNP
47658	393	3	as	as	IN
47658	393	4	a	a	DT
47658	393	5	community	community	NN
47658	393	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	393	7	an	an	DT
47658	393	8	individual	individual	JJ
47658	393	9	organic	organic	JJ
47658	393	10	unity	unity	NN
47658	393	11	with	with	IN
47658	393	12	a	a	DT
47658	393	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	393	14	that	that	WDT
47658	393	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	393	16	more	more	JJR
47658	393	17	than	than	IN
47658	393	18	the	the	DT
47658	393	19	mere	mere	JJ
47658	393	20	total	total	NN
47658	393	21	of	of	IN
47658	393	22	the	the	DT
47658	393	23	reality	reality	NN
47658	393	24	of	of	IN
47658	393	25	individual	individual	JJ
47658	393	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
47658	393	27	who	who	WP
47658	393	28	compose	compose	VBP
47658	393	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	393	30	.	.	.
47658	394	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	394	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	394	3	this	this	DT
47658	394	4	principle	principle	NN
47658	394	5	of	of	IN
47658	394	6	individuality	individuality	NN
47658	394	7	that	that	WDT
47658	394	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	394	9	the	the	DT
47658	394	10	true	true	JJ
47658	394	11	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	394	12	of	of	IN
47658	394	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	394	14	.	.	.
47658	395	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	395	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	395	3	this	this	DT
47658	395	4	principle	principle	NN
47658	395	5	that	that	IN
47658	395	6	,	,	,
47658	395	7	while	while	IN
47658	395	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	395	9	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	395	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	395	11	to	to	TO
47658	395	12	seek	seek	VB
47658	395	13	the	the	DT
47658	395	14	unity	unity	NN
47658	395	15	in	in	IN
47658	395	16	an	an	DT
47658	395	17	individuality	individuality	NN
47658	395	18	ever	ever	RB
47658	395	19	higher	higher	RBR
47658	395	20	and	and	CC
47658	395	21	more	more	RBR
47658	395	22	complete	complete	JJ
47658	395	23	than	than	IN
47658	395	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	395	25	have	have	VBP
47658	395	26	attained	attain	VBN
47658	395	27	,	,	,
47658	395	28	at	at	IN
47658	395	29	the	the	DT
47658	395	30	same	same	JJ
47658	395	31	time	time	NN
47658	395	32	explains	explain	VBZ
47658	395	33	the	the	DT
47658	395	34	discrepancy	discrepancy	NN
47658	395	35	of	of	IN
47658	395	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	395	37	partial	partial	JJ
47658	395	38	view	view	NN
47658	395	39	,	,	,
47658	395	40	explains	explain	VBZ
47658	395	41	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
47658	395	42	as	as	IN
47658	395	43	the	the	DT
47658	395	44	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	395	45	result	result	NN
47658	395	46	of	of	IN
47658	395	47	the	the	DT
47658	395	48	effort	effort	NN
47658	395	49	to	to	TO
47658	395	50	understand	understand	VB
47658	395	51	the	the	DT
47658	395	52	parts	part	NNS
47658	395	53	in	in	IN
47658	395	54	independence	independence	NN
47658	395	55	of	of	IN
47658	395	56	the	the	DT
47658	395	57	whole	whole	NN
47658	395	58	which	which	WDT
47658	395	59	gives	give	VBZ
47658	395	60	to	to	IN
47658	395	61	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	395	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	395	63	reality	reality	NN
47658	395	64	.	.	.
47658	396	1	Thus	thus	RB
47658	396	2	,	,	,
47658	396	3	while	while	IN
47658	396	4	on	on	IN
47658	396	5	the	the	DT
47658	396	6	one	one	CD
47658	396	7	hand	hand	NN
47658	396	8	the	the	DT
47658	396	9	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	396	10	search	search	NN
47658	396	11	for	for	IN
47658	396	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	396	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	396	14	ever	ever	RB
47658	396	15	towards	towards	IN
47658	396	16	greater	great	JJR
47658	396	17	simplicity	simplicity	NN
47658	396	18	and	and	CC
47658	396	19	abstractness	abstractness	NN
47658	396	20	,	,	,
47658	396	21	a	a	DT
47658	396	22	simplicity	simplicity	NN
47658	396	23	whose	whose	WP$
47658	396	24	ideal	ideal	JJ
47658	396	25	limit	limit	NN
47658	396	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	396	27	zero	zero	CD
47658	396	28	,	,	,
47658	396	29	the	the	DT
47658	396	30	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	396	31	search	search	NN
47658	396	32	for	for	IN
47658	396	33	reality	reality	NN
47658	396	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	396	35	ever	ever	RB
47658	396	36	towards	towards	IN
47658	396	37	greater	great	JJR
47658	396	38	concreteness	concreteness	NN
47658	396	39	,	,	,
47658	396	40	towards	towards	IN
47658	396	41	full	full	JJ
47658	396	42	comprehensiveness	comprehensiveness	NN
47658	396	43	,	,	,
47658	396	44	and	and	CC
47658	396	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	396	46	ideal	ideal	JJ
47658	396	47	limit	limit	NN
47658	396	48	is	be	VBZ
47658	396	49	the	the	DT
47658	396	50	whole	whole	JJ
47658	396	51	universe	universe	NN
47658	396	52	as	as	IN
47658	396	53	one	one	CD
47658	396	54	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	396	55	and	and	CC
47658	396	56	completely	completely	RB
47658	396	57	harmonious	harmonious	JJ
47658	396	58	individual	individual	NN
47658	396	59	.	.	.
47658	397	1	This	this	DT
47658	397	2	idea	idea	NN
47658	397	3	of	of	IN
47658	397	4	full	full	JJ
47658	397	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	397	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	397	7	the	the	DT
47658	397	8	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	397	9	.	.	.
47658	398	1	There	there	EX
47658	398	2	are	be	VBP
47658	398	3	not	not	RB
47658	398	4	two	two	CD
47658	398	5	realities	reality	NNS
47658	398	6	,	,	,
47658	398	7	one	one	CD
47658	398	8	material	material	NN
47658	398	9	and	and	CC
47658	398	10	the	the	DT
47658	398	11	other	other	JJ
47658	398	12	spiritual	spiritual	NN
47658	398	13	;	;	:
47658	398	14	the	the	DT
47658	398	15	material	material	NN
47658	398	16	and	and	CC
47658	398	17	the	the	DT
47658	398	18	spiritual	spiritual	NN
47658	398	19	are	be	VBP
47658	398	20	two	two	CD
47658	398	21	directions	direction	NNS
47658	398	22	in	in	IN
47658	398	23	which	which	WDT
47658	398	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	398	25	may	may	MD
47658	398	26	seek	seek	VB
47658	398	27	the	the	DT
47658	398	28	one	one	CD
47658	398	29	reality	reality	NN
47658	398	30	,	,	,
47658	398	31	but	but	CC
47658	398	32	there	there	EX
47658	398	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	398	34	only	only	RB
47658	398	35	one	one	CD
47658	398	36	pathway	pathway	NN
47658	398	37	by	by	IN
47658	398	38	which	which	WDT
47658	398	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	398	40	shall	shall	MD
47658	398	41	find	find	VB
47658	398	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	398	43	.	.	.
47658	399	1	The	the	DT
47658	399	2	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	399	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	399	4	the	the	DT
47658	399	5	whole	whole	JJ
47658	399	6	universe	universe	NN
47658	399	7	not	not	RB
47658	399	8	in	in	IN
47658	399	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	399	10	aspect	aspect	NN
47658	399	11	of	of	IN
47658	399	12	an	an	DT
47658	399	13	aggregate	aggregate	NN
47658	399	14	of	of	IN
47658	399	15	infinitely	infinitely	RB
47658	399	16	diverse	diverse	JJ
47658	399	17	separate	separate	JJ
47658	399	18	elements	element	NNS
47658	399	19	,	,	,
47658	399	20	whether	whether	IN
47658	399	21	these	these	DT
47658	399	22	are	be	VBP
47658	399	23	material	material	JJ
47658	399	24	or	or	CC
47658	399	25	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
47658	399	26	,	,	,
47658	399	27	but	but	CC
47658	399	28	in	in	IN
47658	399	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	399	30	aspect	aspect	NN
47658	399	31	of	of	IN
47658	399	32	an	an	DT
47658	399	33	individual	individual	JJ
47658	399	34	whole	whole	NN
47658	399	35	and	and	CC
47658	399	36	in	in	IN
47658	399	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	399	38	nature	nature	NN
47658	399	39	as	as	IN
47658	399	40	a	a	DT
47658	399	41	whole	whole	NN
47658	399	42	.	.	.
47658	400	1	This	this	DT
47658	400	2	nature	nature	NN
47658	400	3	of	of	IN
47658	400	4	the	the	DT
47658	400	5	whole	whole	NN
47658	400	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	400	7	to	to	TO
47658	400	8	be	be	VB
47658	400	9	individual	individual	JJ
47658	400	10	--	--	:
47658	400	11	only	only	RB
47658	400	12	in	in	IN
47658	400	13	{	{	-LRB-
47658	400	14	41	41	CD
47658	400	15	}	}	-RRB-
47658	400	16	the	the	DT
47658	400	17	individual	individual	NN
47658	400	18	are	be	VBP
47658	400	19	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
47658	400	20	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
47658	400	21	.	.	.
47658	401	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	401	2	the	the	DT
47658	401	3	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	401	4	more	more	JJR
47658	401	5	than	than	IN
47658	401	6	an	an	DT
47658	401	7	idea	idea	NN
47658	401	8	?	?	.
47658	402	1	Does	do	VBZ
47658	402	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	402	3	actually	actually	RB
47658	402	4	exist	exist	VB
47658	402	5	?	?	.
47658	403	1	Clearly	clearly	RB
47658	403	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	403	3	can	can	MD
47658	403	4	not	not	RB
47658	403	5	claim	claim	VB
47658	403	6	to	to	TO
47658	403	7	know	know	VB
47658	403	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	403	9	by	by	IN
47658	403	10	direct	direct	JJ
47658	403	11	experience	experience	NN
47658	403	12	,	,	,
47658	403	13	by	by	IN
47658	403	14	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	403	15	;	;	:
47658	403	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	403	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	403	18	not	not	RB
47658	403	19	a	a	DT
47658	403	20	_	_	NNP
47658	403	21	that	that	WDT
47658	403	22	_	_	NNP
47658	403	23	of	of	IN
47658	403	24	which	which	WDT
47658	403	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	403	26	can	can	MD
47658	403	27	ask	ask	VB
47658	403	28	_	_	NNP
47658	403	29	what	what	WP
47658	403	30	_	_	NNP
47658	403	31	?	?	.
47658	404	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	404	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	404	3	the	the	DT
47658	404	4	object	object	NN
47658	404	5	of	of	IN
47658	404	6	reason	reason	NN
47658	404	7	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	404	8	,	,	,
47658	404	9	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	404	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	404	11	know	know	VBP
47658	404	12	that	that	IN
47658	404	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	404	14	must	must	MD
47658	404	15	be	be	VB
47658	404	16	.	.	.
47658	405	1	Also	also	RB
47658	405	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	405	3	know	know	VBP
47658	405	4	that	that	IN
47658	405	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	405	6	can	can	MD
47658	405	7	be	be	VB
47658	405	8	;	;	:
47658	405	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	405	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	405	11	a	a	DT
47658	405	12	possible	possible	JJ
47658	405	13	object	object	NN
47658	405	14	in	in	IN
47658	405	15	the	the	DT
47658	405	16	logical	logical	JJ
47658	405	17	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	405	18	that	that	IN
47658	405	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	405	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	405	21	not	not	RB
47658	405	22	a	a	DT
47658	405	23	self	self	NN
47658	405	24	-	-	HYPH
47658	405	25	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	405	26	idea	idea	NN
47658	405	27	,	,	,
47658	405	28	like	like	IN
47658	405	29	every	every	DT
47658	405	30	other	other	JJ
47658	405	31	idea	idea	NN
47658	405	32	that	that	IN
47658	405	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	405	34	can	can	MD
47658	405	35	have	have	VB
47658	405	36	.	.	.
47658	406	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	406	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	406	3	not	not	RB
47658	406	4	self	self	NN
47658	406	5	-	-	HYPH
47658	406	6	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	406	7	,	,	,
47658	406	8	for	for	IN
47658	406	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	406	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	406	11	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	406	12	the	the	DT
47658	406	13	idea	idea	NN
47658	406	14	of	of	IN
47658	406	15	that	that	DT
47658	406	16	which	which	WDT
47658	406	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	406	18	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	406	19	.	.	.
47658	407	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
47658	407	2	,	,	,
47658	407	3	argues	argue	VBZ
47658	407	4	the	the	DT
47658	407	5	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	407	6	,	,	,
47658	407	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	407	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	407	9	,	,	,
47658	407	10	for	for	IN
47658	407	11	that	that	DT
47658	407	12	which	which	WDT
47658	407	13	must	must	MD
47658	407	14	be	be	VB
47658	407	15	,	,	,
47658	407	16	and	and	CC
47658	407	17	can	can	MD
47658	407	18	be	be	VB
47658	407	19	,	,	,
47658	407	20	surely	surely	RB
47658	407	21	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	407	22	.	.	.
47658	408	1	The	the	DT
47658	408	2	reader	reader	NN
47658	408	3	will	will	MD
47658	408	4	now	now	RB
47658	408	5	understand	understand	VB
47658	408	6	why	why	WRB
47658	408	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	408	8	introduced	introduce	VBD
47658	408	9	this	this	DT
47658	408	10	account	account	NN
47658	408	11	of	of	IN
47658	408	12	the	the	DT
47658	408	13	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	408	14	with	with	IN
47658	408	15	a	a	DT
47658	408	16	description	description	NN
47658	408	17	for	for	IN
47658	408	18	comparison	comparison	NN
47658	408	19	of	of	IN
47658	408	20	the	the	DT
47658	408	21	St.	St.	NNP
47658	408	22	Anselm	Anselm	NNP
47658	408	23	proof	proof	NN
47658	408	24	of	of	IN
47658	408	25	the	the	DT
47658	408	26	existence	existence	NN
47658	408	27	of	of	IN
47658	408	28	God	God	NNP
47658	408	29	.	.	.
47658	409	1	There	there	EX
47658	409	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	409	3	one	one	CD
47658	409	4	further	further	JJ
47658	409	5	question	question	NN
47658	409	6	.	.	.
47658	410	1	Whether	whether	IN
47658	410	2	the	the	DT
47658	410	3	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	410	4	does	do	VBZ
47658	410	5	or	or	CC
47658	410	6	does	do	VBZ
47658	410	7	not	not	RB
47658	410	8	exist	exist	VB
47658	410	9	,	,	,
47658	410	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	410	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	410	12	,	,	,
47658	410	13	either	either	CC
47658	410	14	in	in	IN
47658	410	15	idea	idea	NN
47658	410	16	or	or	CC
47658	410	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	410	18	,	,	,
47658	410	19	of	of	IN
47658	410	20	any	any	DT
47658	410	21	use	use	NN
47658	410	22	to	to	IN
47658	410	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	410	24	?	?	.
47658	411	1	The	the	DT
47658	411	2	reply	reply	NN
47658	411	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	411	4	that	that	IN
47658	411	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	411	6	value	value	NN
47658	411	7	lies	lie	VBZ
47658	411	8	in	in	IN
47658	411	9	this	this	DT
47658	411	10	,	,	,
47658	411	11	that	that	IN
47658	411	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	411	13	reveals	reveal	VBZ
47658	411	14	to	to	IN
47658	411	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	411	16	the	the	DT
47658	411	17	nature	nature	NN
47658	411	18	of	of	IN
47658	411	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	411	20	and	and	CC
47658	411	21	the	the	DT
47658	411	22	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	411	23	of	of	IN
47658	411	24	truth	truth	NN
47658	411	25	.	.	.
47658	412	1	Logic	logic	NN
47658	412	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	412	3	the	the	DT
47658	412	4	creative	creative	JJ
47658	412	5	power	power	NN
47658	412	6	of	of	IN
47658	412	7	thought	thought	NN
47658	412	8	which	which	WDT
47658	412	9	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	412	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	412	11	to	to	IN
47658	412	12	the	the	DT
47658	412	13	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	412	14	of	of	IN
47658	412	15	higher	high	JJR
47658	412	16	and	and	CC
47658	412	17	higher	high	JJR
47658	412	18	degrees	degree	NNS
47658	412	19	of	of	IN
47658	412	20	reality	reality	NN
47658	412	21	.	.	.
47658	413	1	The	the	DT
47658	413	2	Satyr	Satyr	NNP
47658	413	3	,	,	,
47658	413	4	in	in	IN
47658	413	5	the	the	DT
47658	413	6	fable	fable	NN
47658	413	7	,	,	,
47658	413	8	drove	drive	VBD
47658	413	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	413	10	guest	guest	NN
47658	413	11	from	from	IN
47658	413	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	413	13	shelter	shelter	NN
47658	413	14	because	because	IN
47658	413	15	the	the	DT
47658	413	16	man	man	NN
47658	413	17	blew	blow	VBD
47658	413	18	into	into	IN
47658	413	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	413	20	hands	hand	NNS
47658	413	21	to	to	TO
47658	413	22	warm	warm	VB
47658	413	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	413	24	,	,	,
47658	413	25	and	and	CC
47658	413	26	into	into	IN
47658	413	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	413	28	porridge	porridge	NN
47658	413	29	to	to	TO
47658	413	30	cool	cool	VB
47658	413	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	413	32	.	.	.
47658	414	1	The	the	DT
47658	414	2	Satyr	Satyr	NNP
47658	414	3	could	could	MD
47658	414	4	not	not	RB
47658	414	5	reconcile	reconcile	VB
47658	414	6	the	the	DT
47658	414	7	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	414	8	that	that	IN
47658	414	9	one	one	PRP
47658	414	10	could	could	MD
47658	414	11	with	with	IN
47658	414	12	the	the	DT
47658	414	13	same	same	JJ
47658	414	14	breath	breath	NN
47658	414	15	blow	blow	VB
47658	414	16	hot	hot	JJ
47658	414	17	and	and	CC
47658	414	18	cold	cold	JJ
47658	414	19	.	.	.
47658	415	1	Nor	nor	CC
47658	415	2	would	would	MD
47658	415	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	415	4	reconcile	reconcile	VB
47658	415	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	415	6	ever	ever	RB
47658	415	7	,	,	,
47658	415	8	so	so	RB
47658	415	9	long	long	RB
47658	415	10	as	as	IN
47658	415	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	415	12	sought	seek	VBD
47658	415	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	415	14	as	as	IN
47658	415	15	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	415	16	.	.	.
47658	416	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	416	2	would	would	MD
47658	416	3	have	have	VB
47658	416	4	shown	show	VBN
47658	416	5	the	the	DT
47658	416	6	facts	fact	NNS
47658	416	7	coherent	coherent	JJ
47658	416	8	by	by	IN
47658	416	9	reconciling	reconcile	VBG
47658	416	10	the	the	DT
47658	416	11	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	416	12	in	in	IN
47658	416	13	a	a	DT
47658	416	14	higher	high	JJR
47658	416	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	416	16	.	.	.
47658	417	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	417	2	42	42	CD
47658	417	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	417	4	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
47658	417	5	V	v	NN
47658	417	6	PRAGMATISM	pragmatism	NN
47658	417	7	The	the	DT
47658	417	8	theory	theory	NN
47658	417	9	of	of	IN
47658	417	10	the	the	DT
47658	417	11	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	417	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	417	13	only	only	RB
47658	417	14	one	one	CD
47658	417	15	form	form	NN
47658	417	16	of	of	IN
47658	417	17	Idealism	Idealism	NNP
47658	417	18	,	,	,
47658	417	19	but	but	CC
47658	417	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	417	21	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
47658	417	22	the	the	DT
47658	417	23	nature	nature	NN
47658	417	24	and	and	CC
47658	417	25	general	general	JJ
47658	417	26	direction	direction	NN
47658	417	27	of	of	IN
47658	417	28	the	the	DT
47658	417	29	development	development	NN
47658	417	30	of	of	IN
47658	417	31	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	417	32	along	along	IN
47658	417	33	the	the	DT
47658	417	34	line	line	NN
47658	417	35	of	of	IN
47658	417	36	speculation	speculation	NN
47658	417	37	that	that	WDT
47658	417	38	began	begin	VBD
47658	417	39	with	with	IN
47658	417	40	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	417	41	.	.	.
47658	418	1	There	there	EX
47658	418	2	have	have	VBP
47658	418	3	been	be	VBN
47658	418	4	,	,	,
47658	418	5	of	of	IN
47658	418	6	course	course	NN
47658	418	7	,	,	,
47658	418	8	other	other	JJ
47658	418	9	directions	direction	NNS
47658	418	10	.	.	.
47658	419	1	In	in	IN
47658	419	2	particular	particular	JJ
47658	419	3	many	many	JJ
47658	419	4	attempts	attempt	NNS
47658	419	5	have	have	VBP
47658	419	6	been	be	VBN
47658	419	7	made	make	VBN
47658	419	8	to	to	TO
47658	419	9	make	make	VB
47658	419	10	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	419	11	an	an	DT
47658	419	12	adjunct	adjunct	NN
47658	419	13	of	of	IN
47658	419	14	physical	physical	JJ
47658	419	15	science	science	NN
47658	419	16	,	,	,
47658	419	17	but	but	CC
47658	419	18	the	the	DT
47658	419	19	theory	theory	NN
47658	419	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	419	21	have	have	VBP
47658	419	22	sketched	sketch	VBN
47658	419	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	419	24	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
47658	419	25	of	of	IN
47658	419	26	the	the	DT
47658	419	27	prevailing	prevail	VBG
47658	419	28	movement	movement	NN
47658	419	29	in	in	IN
47658	419	30	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	419	31	during	during	IN
47658	419	32	the	the	DT
47658	419	33	last	last	JJ
47658	419	34	period	period	NN
47658	419	35	of	of	IN
47658	419	36	the	the	DT
47658	419	37	Nineteenth	Nineteenth	NNP
47658	419	38	Century	Century	NNP
47658	419	39	,	,	,
47658	419	40	and	and	CC
47658	419	41	until	until	IN
47658	419	42	the	the	DT
47658	419	43	movement	movement	NN
47658	419	44	known	know	VBN
47658	419	45	as	as	IN
47658	419	46	Pragmatism	Pragmatism	NNP
47658	419	47	directed	direct	VBD
47658	419	48	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	419	49	upon	upon	IN
47658	419	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	419	51	.	.	.
47658	420	1	The	the	DT
47658	420	2	form	form	NN
47658	420	3	the	the	DT
47658	420	4	pragmatical	pragmatical	JJ
47658	420	5	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	420	6	of	of	IN
47658	420	7	the	the	DT
47658	420	8	theory	theory	NN
47658	420	9	of	of	IN
47658	420	10	the	the	DT
47658	420	11	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	420	12	took	take	VBD
47658	420	13	was	be	VBD
47658	420	14	to	to	TO
47658	420	15	direct	direct	VB
47658	420	16	attention	attention	NN
47658	420	17	to	to	IN
47658	420	18	the	the	DT
47658	420	19	logical	logical	JJ
47658	420	20	or	or	CC
47658	420	21	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	420	22	principle	principle	NN
47658	420	23	on	on	IN
47658	420	24	which	which	WDT
47658	420	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	420	26	rests	rest	VBZ
47658	420	27	--	--	:
47658	420	28	in	in	IN
47658	420	29	fact	fact	NN
47658	420	30	to	to	TO
47658	420	31	raise	raise	VB
47658	420	32	the	the	DT
47658	420	33	problem	problem	NN
47658	420	34	of	of	IN
47658	420	35	the	the	DT
47658	420	36	nature	nature	NN
47658	420	37	of	of	IN
47658	420	38	truth	truth	NN
47658	420	39	.	.	.
47658	421	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	421	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	421	3	a	a	DT
47658	421	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	421	5	of	of	IN
47658	421	6	the	the	DT
47658	421	7	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	421	8	of	of	IN
47658	421	9	truth	truth	NN
47658	421	10	.	.	.
47658	422	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	422	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	422	3	the	the	DT
47658	422	4	denial	denial	NN
47658	422	5	of	of	IN
47658	422	6	a	a	DT
47658	422	7	purely	purely	RB
47658	422	8	logical	logical	JJ
47658	422	9	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	422	10	of	of	IN
47658	422	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	422	12	,	,	,
47658	422	13	and	and	CC
47658	422	14	the	the	DT
47658	422	15	insistence	insistence	NN
47658	422	16	that	that	IN
47658	422	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	422	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	422	19	always	always	RB
47658	422	20	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	422	21	on	on	IN
47658	422	22	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	422	23	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	422	24	.	.	.
47658	423	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	423	2	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	423	3	rejects	reject	VBZ
47658	423	4	both	both	CC
47658	423	5	the	the	DT
47658	423	6	views	view	NNS
47658	423	7	that	that	WDT
47658	423	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	423	9	have	have	VBP
47658	423	10	examined	examine	VBN
47658	423	11	--	--	:
47658	423	12	the	the	DT
47658	423	13	theory	theory	NN
47658	423	14	that	that	IN
47658	423	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	423	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	423	17	a	a	DT
47658	423	18	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	423	19	of	of	IN
47658	423	20	the	the	DT
47658	423	21	idea	idea	NN
47658	423	22	with	with	IN
47658	423	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	423	24	object	object	NN
47658	423	25	,	,	,
47658	423	26	and	and	CC
47658	423	27	the	the	DT
47658	423	28	theory	theory	NN
47658	423	29	that	that	IN
47658	423	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	423	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	423	32	the	the	DT
47658	423	33	logical	logical	JJ
47658	423	34	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	423	35	and	and	CC
47658	423	36	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	423	37	of	of	IN
47658	423	38	the	the	DT
47658	423	39	idea	idea	NN
47658	423	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	423	41	.	.	.
47658	424	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	424	2	proposes	propose	VBZ
47658	424	3	instead	instead	RB
47658	424	4	the	the	DT
47658	424	5	theory	theory	NN
47658	424	6	that	that	IN
47658	424	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	424	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	424	9	always	always	RB
47658	424	10	founded	found	VBN
47658	424	11	on	on	IN
47658	424	12	a	a	DT
47658	424	13	practical	practical	JJ
47658	424	14	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	424	15	,	,	,
47658	424	16	and	and	CC
47658	424	17	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	424	18	in	in	IN
47658	424	19	the	the	DT
47658	424	20	verification	verification	NN
47658	424	21	of	of	IN
47658	424	22	that	that	DT
47658	424	23	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	424	24	;	;	:
47658	424	25	the	the	DT
47658	424	26	verification	verification	NN
47658	424	27	not	not	RB
47658	424	28	being	be	VBG
47658	424	29	the	the	DT
47658	424	30	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	424	31	of	of	IN
47658	424	32	something	something	NN
47658	424	33	that	that	WDT
47658	424	34	was	be	VBD
47658	424	35	waiting	wait	VBG
47658	424	36	to	to	TO
47658	424	37	be	be	VB
47658	424	38	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	424	39	,	,	,
47658	424	40	but	but	CC
47658	424	41	the	the	DT
47658	424	42	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	424	43	that	that	WDT
47658	424	44	the	the	DT
47658	424	45	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	424	46	that	that	WDT
47658	424	47	claims	claim	VBZ
47658	424	48	to	to	TO
47658	424	49	be	be	VB
47658	424	50	true	true	JJ
47658	424	51	is	be	VBZ
47658	424	52	useful	useful	JJ
47658	424	53	,	,	,
47658	424	54	in	in	IN
47658	424	55	that	that	IN
47658	424	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	424	57	works	work	VBZ
47658	424	58	.	.	.
47658	425	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	425	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	425	3	what	what	WP
47658	425	4	works	work	VBZ
47658	425	5	.	.	.
47658	426	1	The	the	DT
47658	426	2	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	426	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	426	4	reality	reality	NN
47658	426	5	and	and	CC
47658	426	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	426	7	.	.	.
47658	427	1	The	the	DT
47658	427	2	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	427	3	argument	argument	NN
47658	427	4	which	which	WDT
47658	427	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	427	6	have	have	VBP
47658	427	7	followed	follow	VBN
47658	427	8	was	be	VBD
47658	427	9	an	an	DT
47658	427	10	attempt	attempt	NN
47658	427	11	to	to	IN
47658	427	12	{	{	-LRB-
47658	427	13	43	43	CD
47658	427	14	}	}	-RRB-
47658	427	15	determine	determine	VBP
47658	427	16	the	the	DT
47658	427	17	nature	nature	NN
47658	427	18	of	of	IN
47658	427	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	427	20	,	,	,
47658	427	21	and	and	CC
47658	427	22	not	not	RB
47658	427	23	an	an	DT
47658	427	24	attempt	attempt	NN
47658	427	25	to	to	TO
47658	427	26	explain	explain	VB
47658	427	27	what	what	WP
47658	427	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	427	29	mean	mean	VBP
47658	427	30	when	when	WRB
47658	427	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	427	32	say	say	VBP
47658	427	33	that	that	IN
47658	427	34	an	an	DT
47658	427	35	idea	idea	NN
47658	427	36	agrees	agree	VBZ
47658	427	37	with	with	IN
47658	427	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	427	39	object	object	NN
47658	427	40	.	.	.
47658	428	1	What	what	WP
47658	428	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	428	3	true	true	JJ
47658	428	4	about	about	IN
47658	428	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	428	6	?	?	.
47658	429	1	was	be	VBD
47658	429	2	the	the	DT
47658	429	3	starting	starting	NN
47658	429	4	point	point	NN
47658	429	5	,	,	,
47658	429	6	and	and	CC
47658	429	7	not	not	RB
47658	429	8	,	,	,
47658	429	9	What	what	WP
47658	429	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	429	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	429	12	?	?	.
47658	430	1	nor	nor	CC
47658	430	2	even	even	RB
47658	430	3	,	,	,
47658	430	4	What	what	WP
47658	430	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	430	6	true	true	JJ
47658	430	7	about	about	IN
47658	430	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	430	9	?	?	.
47658	431	1	The	the	DT
47658	431	2	search	search	NN
47658	431	3	for	for	IN
47658	431	4	reality	reality	NN
47658	431	5	failed	fail	VBD
47658	431	6	to	to	TO
47658	431	7	discover	discover	VB
47658	431	8	any	any	DT
47658	431	9	object	object	NN
47658	431	10	that	that	WDT
47658	431	11	agreed	agree	VBD
47658	431	12	with	with	IN
47658	431	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	431	14	idea	idea	NN
47658	431	15	,	,	,
47658	431	16	but	but	CC
47658	431	17	at	at	IN
47658	431	18	last	last	JJ
47658	431	19	there	there	EX
47658	431	20	was	be	VBD
47658	431	21	found	find	VBN
47658	431	22	an	an	DT
47658	431	23	idea	idea	NN
47658	431	24	that	that	WDT
47658	431	25	must	must	MD
47658	431	26	agree	agree	VB
47658	431	27	with	with	IN
47658	431	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	431	29	object	object	NN
47658	431	30	,	,	,
47658	431	31	an	an	DT
47658	431	32	idea	idea	NN
47658	431	33	whose	whose	WP$
47658	431	34	object	object	NN
47658	431	35	can	can	MD
47658	431	36	not	not	RB
47658	431	37	not	not	RB
47658	431	38	be	be	VB
47658	431	39	.	.	.
47658	432	1	This	this	DT
47658	432	2	idea	idea	NN
47658	432	3	,	,	,
47658	432	4	the	the	DT
47658	432	5	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	432	6	,	,	,
47658	432	7	reveals	reveal	VBZ
47658	432	8	the	the	DT
47658	432	9	nature	nature	NN
47658	432	10	of	of	IN
47658	432	11	reality	reality	NN
47658	432	12	.	.	.
47658	433	1	The	the	DT
47658	433	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	433	3	when	when	WRB
47658	433	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	433	5	asks	ask	VBZ
47658	433	6	,	,	,
47658	433	7	What	what	WP
47658	433	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	433	9	truth	truth	NN
47658	433	10	?	?	.
47658	434	1	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	434	2	to	to	TO
47658	434	3	dig	dig	VB
47658	434	4	beneath	beneath	IN
47658	434	5	the	the	DT
47658	434	6	argument	argument	NN
47658	434	7	,	,	,
47658	434	8	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	434	9	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	434	10	even	even	RB
47658	434	11	to	to	TO
47658	434	12	reach	reach	VB
47658	434	13	the	the	DT
47658	434	14	bedrock	bedrock	NN
47658	434	15	,	,	,
47658	434	16	but	but	CC
47658	434	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	434	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	434	19	only	only	RB
47658	434	20	in	in	IN
47658	434	21	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	434	22	that	that	IN
47658	434	23	this	this	DT
47658	434	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	434	25	so	so	RB
47658	434	26	.	.	.
47658	435	1	How	how	WRB
47658	435	2	,	,	,
47658	435	3	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	435	4	,	,	,
47658	435	5	could	could	MD
47658	435	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	435	7	hope	hope	VB
47658	435	8	to	to	TO
47658	435	9	be	be	VB
47658	435	10	able	able	JJ
47658	435	11	to	to	TO
47658	435	12	answer	answer	VB
47658	435	13	the	the	DT
47658	435	14	question	question	NN
47658	435	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	435	16	has	have	VBZ
47658	435	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	435	18	asked	ask	VBN
47658	435	19	,	,	,
47658	435	20	if	if	IN
47658	435	21	there	there	EX
47658	435	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	435	23	no	no	DT
47658	435	24	way	way	NN
47658	435	25	of	of	IN
47658	435	26	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
47658	435	27	the	the	DT
47658	435	28	true	true	JJ
47658	435	29	answer	answer	NN
47658	435	30	from	from	IN
47658	435	31	the	the	DT
47658	435	32	false	false	JJ
47658	435	33	?	?	.
47658	436	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	436	2	must	must	MD
47658	436	3	already	already	RB
47658	436	4	know	know	VB
47658	436	5	what	what	WP
47658	436	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	436	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	436	8	even	even	RB
47658	436	9	to	to	TO
47658	436	10	be	be	VB
47658	436	11	able	able	JJ
47658	436	12	to	to	TO
47658	436	13	ask	ask	VB
47658	436	14	what	what	WP
47658	436	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	436	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	436	17	--	--	:
47658	436	18	a	a	DT
47658	436	19	point	point	NN
47658	436	20	which	which	WDT
47658	436	21	many	many	JJ
47658	436	22	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	436	23	writers	writer	NNS
47658	436	24	appear	appear	VBP
47658	436	25	to	to	IN
47658	436	26	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	436	27	to	to	TO
47658	436	28	have	have	VB
47658	436	29	overlooked	overlook	VBN
47658	436	30	.	.	.
47658	437	1	In	in	IN
47658	437	2	challenging	challenge	VBG
47658	437	3	the	the	DT
47658	437	4	idea	idea	NN
47658	437	5	of	of	IN
47658	437	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	437	7	,	,	,
47658	437	8	the	the	DT
47658	437	9	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	437	10	raises	raise	VBZ
47658	437	11	the	the	DT
47658	437	12	no	no	RB
47658	437	13	less	less	RBR
47658	437	14	important	important	JJ
47658	437	15	question	question	NN
47658	437	16	of	of	IN
47658	437	17	the	the	DT
47658	437	18	nature	nature	NN
47658	437	19	of	of	IN
47658	437	20	error	error	NN
47658	437	21	.	.	.
47658	438	1	A	a	DT
47658	438	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	438	3	of	of	IN
47658	438	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	438	5	must	must	MD
47658	438	6	not	not	RB
47658	438	7	only	only	RB
47658	438	8	show	show	VB
47658	438	9	in	in	IN
47658	438	10	what	what	WDT
47658	438	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	438	12	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	438	13	,	,	,
47658	438	14	but	but	CC
47658	438	15	must	must	MD
47658	438	16	distinguish	distinguish	VB
47658	438	17	false	false	JJ
47658	438	18	from	from	IN
47658	438	19	true	true	JJ
47658	438	20	and	and	CC
47658	438	21	show	show	VBP
47658	438	22	the	the	DT
47658	438	23	nature	nature	NN
47658	438	24	of	of	IN
47658	438	25	error	error	NN
47658	438	26	.	.	.
47658	439	1	The	the	DT
47658	439	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	439	3	claims	claim	VBZ
47658	439	4	for	for	IN
47658	439	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	439	6	theory	theory	NN
47658	439	7	that	that	IN
47658	439	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	439	9	alone	alone	RB
47658	439	10	can	can	MD
47658	439	11	give	give	VB
47658	439	12	a	a	DT
47658	439	13	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	439	14	account	account	NN
47658	439	15	of	of	IN
47658	439	16	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	439	17	and	and	CC
47658	439	18	error	error	NN
47658	439	19	.	.	.
47658	440	1	Now	now	RB
47658	440	2	,	,	,
47658	440	3	as	as	IN
47658	440	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	440	5	saw	see	VBD
47658	440	6	in	in	IN
47658	440	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	440	8	account	account	NN
47658	440	9	of	of	IN
47658	440	10	the	the	DT
47658	440	11	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	440	12	argument	argument	NN
47658	440	13	,	,	,
47658	440	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	440	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	440	16	the	the	DT
47658	440	17	fact	fact	NN
47658	440	18	of	of	IN
47658	440	19	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	440	20	and	and	CC
47658	440	21	error	error	NN
47658	440	22	that	that	WDT
47658	440	23	compels	compel	VBZ
47658	440	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	440	25	to	to	TO
47658	440	26	seek	seek	VB
47658	440	27	reality	reality	NN
47658	440	28	behind	behind	IN
47658	440	29	the	the	DT
47658	440	30	appearances	appearance	NNS
47658	440	31	that	that	WDT
47658	440	32	are	be	VBP
47658	440	33	the	the	DT
47658	440	34	sense	sense	NN
47658	440	35	data	datum	NNS
47658	440	36	of	of	IN
47658	440	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	440	38	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	440	39	experience	experience	NN
47658	440	40	.	.	.
47658	441	1	The	the	DT
47658	441	2	whole	whole	JJ
47658	441	3	force	force	NN
47658	441	4	of	of	IN
47658	441	5	the	the	DT
47658	441	6	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	441	7	movement	movement	NN
47658	441	8	in	in	IN
47658	441	9	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	441	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	441	11	directed	direct	VBN
47658	441	12	to	to	IN
47658	441	13	proving	prove	VBG
47658	441	14	that	that	IN
47658	441	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	441	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	441	17	a	a	DT
47658	441	18	prior	prior	JJ
47658	441	19	consideration	consideration	NN
47658	441	20	to	to	IN
47658	441	21	reality	reality	NN
47658	441	22	.	.	.
47658	442	1	If	if	IN
47658	442	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	442	3	understand	understand	VBP
47658	442	4	the	the	DT
47658	442	5	nature	nature	NN
47658	442	6	of	of	IN
47658	442	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	442	8	,	,	,
47658	442	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	442	10	shall	shall	MD
47658	442	11	see	see	VB
47658	442	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	442	13	in	in	IN
47658	442	14	the	the	DT
47658	442	15	making	making	NN
47658	442	16	.	.	.
47658	443	1	Reality	reality	NN
47658	443	2	can	can	MD
47658	443	3	in	in	IN
47658	443	4	fact	fact	NN
47658	443	5	be	be	VB
47658	443	6	left	leave	VBN
47658	443	7	to	to	TO
47658	443	8	look	look	VB
47658	443	9	after	after	IN
47658	443	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	443	11	;	;	:
47658	443	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	443	13	business	business	NN
47658	443	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	443	15	with	with	IN
47658	443	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	443	17	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	443	18	alone	alone	RB
47658	443	19	,	,	,
47658	443	20	which	which	WDT
47658	443	21	are	be	VBP
47658	443	22	either	either	CC
47658	443	23	true	true	JJ
47658	443	24	or	or	CC
47658	443	25	false	false	JJ
47658	443	26	.	.	.
47658	444	1	The	the	DT
47658	444	2	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	444	3	of	of	IN
47658	444	4	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	444	5	and	and	CC
47658	444	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	444	7	does	do	VBZ
47658	444	8	{	{	-LRB-
47658	444	9	44	44	CD
47658	444	10	}	}	-RRB-
47658	444	11	not	not	RB
47658	444	12	explain	explain	VB
47658	444	13	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	444	14	and	and	CC
47658	444	15	error	error	NN
47658	444	16	because	because	IN
47658	444	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	444	18	does	do	VBZ
47658	444	19	not	not	RB
47658	444	20	distinguish	distinguish	VB
47658	444	21	between	between	IN
47658	444	22	true	true	JJ
47658	444	23	and	and	CC
47658	444	24	false	false	JJ
47658	444	25	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	444	26	.	.	.
47658	445	1	There	there	EX
47658	445	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	445	3	no	no	DT
47658	445	4	principle	principle	NN
47658	445	5	in	in	IN
47658	445	6	idealism	idealism	NN
47658	445	7	by	by	IN
47658	445	8	which	which	WDT
47658	445	9	the	the	DT
47658	445	10	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	445	11	rejects	reject	VBZ
47658	445	12	the	the	DT
47658	445	13	false	false	JJ
47658	445	14	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	445	15	and	and	CC
47658	445	16	reconciles	reconcile	NNS
47658	445	17	the	the	DT
47658	445	18	true	true	JJ
47658	445	19	.	.	.
47658	446	1	Before	before	IN
47658	446	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	446	3	examine	examine	VBP
47658	446	4	the	the	DT
47658	446	5	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	446	6	argument	argument	NN
47658	446	7	,	,	,
47658	446	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	446	9	ought	ought	MD
47658	446	10	first	first	RB
47658	446	11	to	to	TO
47658	446	12	explain	explain	VB
47658	446	13	the	the	DT
47658	446	14	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	446	15	and	and	CC
47658	446	16	origin	origin	NN
47658	446	17	of	of	IN
47658	446	18	the	the	DT
47658	446	19	word	word	NN
47658	446	20	.	.	.
47658	447	1	The	the	DT
47658	447	2	term	term	NN
47658	447	3	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	447	4	,	,	,
47658	447	5	that	that	WDT
47658	447	6	has	have	VBZ
47658	447	7	in	in	IN
47658	447	8	the	the	DT
47658	447	9	last	last	JJ
47658	447	10	few	few	JJ
47658	447	11	years	year	NNS
47658	447	12	entered	enter	VBN
47658	447	13	so	so	RB
47658	447	14	widely	widely	RB
47658	447	15	into	into	IN
47658	447	16	all	all	DT
47658	447	17	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	447	18	discussion	discussion	NN
47658	447	19	,	,	,
47658	447	20	was	be	VBD
47658	447	21	used	use	VBN
47658	447	22	first	first	RB
47658	447	23	by	by	IN
47658	447	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
47658	447	25	C.	C.	NNP
47658	447	26	S.	S.	NNP
47658	447	27	Peirce	Peirce	NNP
47658	447	28	,	,	,
47658	447	29	an	an	DT
47658	447	30	American	american	JJ
47658	447	31	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	447	32	,	,	,
47658	447	33	in	in	IN
47658	447	34	a	a	DT
47658	447	35	magazine	magazine	NN
47658	447	36	article	article	NN
47658	447	37	written	write	VBN
47658	447	38	as	as	RB
47658	447	39	long	long	RB
47658	447	40	ago	ago	RB
47658	447	41	as	as	IN
47658	447	42	1878	1878	CD
47658	447	43	,	,	,
47658	447	44	but	but	CC
47658	447	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	447	46	attracted	attract	VBD
47658	447	47	no	no	DT
47658	447	48	attention	attention	NN
47658	447	49	for	for	IN
47658	447	50	nearly	nearly	RB
47658	447	51	twenty	twenty	CD
47658	447	52	years	year	NNS
47658	447	53	,	,	,
47658	447	54	when	when	WRB
47658	447	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	447	56	was	be	VBD
47658	447	57	recalled	recall	VBN
47658	447	58	by	by	IN
47658	447	59	William	William	NNP
47658	447	60	James	James	NNP
47658	447	61	in	in	IN
47658	447	62	the	the	DT
47658	447	63	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	447	64	of	of	IN
47658	447	65	the	the	DT
47658	447	66	current	current	JJ
47658	447	67	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	447	68	in	in	IN
47658	447	69	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	447	70	_	_	NNP
47658	447	71	Will	Will	MD
47658	447	72	to	to	TO
47658	447	73	Believe	believe	VB
47658	447	74	_	_	NNP
47658	447	75	,	,	,
47658	447	76	a	a	DT
47658	447	77	book	book	NN
47658	447	78	which	which	WDT
47658	447	79	marks	mark	VBZ
47658	447	80	the	the	DT
47658	447	81	beginning	beginning	NN
47658	447	82	of	of	IN
47658	447	83	the	the	DT
47658	447	84	new	new	JJ
47658	447	85	movement	movement	NN
47658	447	86	.	.	.
47658	448	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	448	2	was	be	VBD
47658	448	3	first	first	RB
47658	448	4	put	put	VBN
47658	448	5	forward	forward	RB
47658	448	6	as	as	IN
47658	448	7	the	the	DT
47658	448	8	principle	principle	NN
47658	448	9	that	that	IN
47658	448	10	the	the	DT
47658	448	11	whole	whole	JJ
47658	448	12	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	448	13	of	of	IN
47658	448	14	any	any	DT
47658	448	15	conception	conception	NN
47658	448	16	expresses	express	VBZ
47658	448	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	448	18	in	in	IN
47658	448	19	practical	practical	JJ
47658	448	20	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	448	21	.	.	.
47658	449	1	The	the	DT
47658	449	2	conception	conception	NN
47658	449	3	of	of	IN
47658	449	4	the	the	DT
47658	449	5	practical	practical	JJ
47658	449	6	effects	effect	NNS
47658	449	7	of	of	IN
47658	449	8	a	a	DT
47658	449	9	conception	conception	NN
47658	449	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	449	11	the	the	DT
47658	449	12	whole	whole	JJ
47658	449	13	conception	conception	NN
47658	449	14	of	of	IN
47658	449	15	the	the	DT
47658	449	16	object	object	NN
47658	449	17	.	.	.
47658	450	1	The	the	DT
47658	450	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	450	3	maxim	maxim	NN
47658	450	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	450	5	--	--	:
47658	450	6	would	would	MD
47658	450	7	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	450	8	know	know	VB
47658	450	9	what	what	WP
47658	450	10	any	any	DT
47658	450	11	idea	idea	NN
47658	450	12	or	or	CC
47658	450	13	conception	conception	NN
47658	450	14	means	mean	NNS
47658	450	15	,	,	,
47658	450	16	then	then	RB
47658	450	17	consider	consider	VB
47658	450	18	what	what	WDT
47658	450	19	practical	practical	JJ
47658	450	20	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	450	21	are	be	VBP
47658	450	22	involved	involve	VBN
47658	450	23	by	by	IN
47658	450	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	450	25	acceptance	acceptance	NN
47658	450	26	or	or	CC
47658	450	27	rejection	rejection	NN
47658	450	28	.	.	.
47658	451	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	451	2	Schiller	Schiller	NNP
47658	451	3	,	,	,
47658	451	4	the	the	DT
47658	451	5	leading	lead	VBG
47658	451	6	exponent	exponent	NN
47658	451	7	of	of	IN
47658	451	8	the	the	DT
47658	451	9	principle	principle	NN
47658	451	10	in	in	IN
47658	451	11	England	England	NNP
47658	451	12	,	,	,
47658	451	13	prefers	prefer	VBZ
47658	451	14	to	to	TO
47658	451	15	call	call	VB
47658	451	16	the	the	DT
47658	451	17	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	451	18	"	"	``
47658	451	19	Humanism	humanism	NN
47658	451	20	"	"	''
47658	451	21	in	in	IN
47658	451	22	order	order	NN
47658	451	23	still	still	RB
47658	451	24	more	more	JJR
47658	451	25	to	to	TO
47658	451	26	emphasize	emphasize	VB
47658	451	27	the	the	DT
47658	451	28	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	451	29	and	and	CC
47658	451	30	personal	personal	JJ
47658	451	31	character	character	NN
47658	451	32	of	of	IN
47658	451	33	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	451	34	.	.	.
47658	452	1	The	the	DT
47658	452	2	name	name	NN
47658	452	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	452	4	suggested	suggest	VBN
47658	452	5	by	by	IN
47658	452	6	the	the	DT
47658	452	7	maxim	maxim	NN
47658	452	8	of	of	IN
47658	452	9	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	452	10	,	,	,
47658	452	11	"	"	``
47658	452	12	Man	man	NN
47658	452	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	452	14	the	the	DT
47658	452	15	measure	measure	NN
47658	452	16	of	of	IN
47658	452	17	all	all	DT
47658	452	18	things	thing	NNS
47658	452	19	.	.	.
47658	452	20	"	"	''
47658	453	1	The	the	DT
47658	453	2	term	term	NN
47658	453	3	Intellectualism	Intellectualism	NNP
47658	453	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	453	5	used	use	VBN
47658	453	6	by	by	IN
47658	453	7	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	453	8	writers	writer	NNS
47658	453	9	to	to	TO
47658	453	10	include	include	VB
47658	453	11	all	all	DT
47658	453	12	theories	theory	NNS
47658	453	13	of	of	IN
47658	453	14	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	453	15	that	that	WDT
47658	453	16	do	do	VBP
47658	453	17	not	not	RB
47658	453	18	agree	agree	VB
47658	453	19	with	with	IN
47658	453	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	453	21	own	own	JJ
47658	453	22	,	,	,
47658	453	23	very	very	RB
47658	453	24	much	much	RB
47658	453	25	as	as	IN
47658	453	26	the	the	DT
47658	453	27	Greeks	Greeks	NNPS
47658	453	28	called	call	VBD
47658	453	29	all	all	DT
47658	453	30	who	who	WP
47658	453	31	were	be	VBD
47658	453	32	not	not	RB
47658	453	33	Greeks	Greeks	NNPS
47658	453	34	,	,	,
47658	453	35	Barbarians	Barbarians	NNPS
47658	453	36	.	.	.
47658	454	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	454	2	must	must	MD
47658	454	3	not	not	RB
47658	454	4	be	be	VB
47658	454	5	taken	take	VBN
47658	454	6	to	to	TO
47658	454	7	mean	mean	VB
47658	454	8	,	,	,
47658	454	9	as	as	IN
47658	454	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	454	11	etymology	etymology	NN
47658	454	12	would	would	MD
47658	454	13	imply	imply	VB
47658	454	14	,	,	,
47658	454	15	a	a	DT
47658	454	16	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	454	17	like	like	IN
47658	454	18	that	that	DT
47658	454	19	of	of	IN
47658	454	20	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	454	21	,	,	,
47658	454	22	which	which	WDT
47658	454	23	held	hold	VBD
47658	454	24	that	that	IN
47658	454	25	only	only	JJ
47658	454	26	universals	universal	NNS
47658	454	27	,	,	,
47658	454	28	the	the	DT
47658	454	29	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	454	30	,	,	,
47658	454	31	are	be	VBP
47658	454	32	real	real	JJ
47658	454	33	,	,	,
47658	454	34	or	or	CC
47658	454	35	like	like	IN
47658	454	36	that	that	DT
47658	454	37	of	of	IN
47658	454	38	Hegel	Hegel	NNP
47658	454	39	,	,	,
47658	454	40	who	who	WP
47658	454	41	said	say	VBD
47658	454	42	that	that	IN
47658	454	43	"	"	``
47658	454	44	the	the	DT
47658	454	45	actual	actual	JJ
47658	454	46	is	be	VBZ
47658	454	47	the	the	DT
47658	454	48	rational	rational	JJ
47658	454	49	and	and	CC
47658	454	50	the	the	DT
47658	454	51	rational	rational	JJ
47658	454	52	is	be	VBZ
47658	454	53	the	the	DT
47658	454	54	actual	actual	JJ
47658	454	55	.	.	.
47658	454	56	"	"	''
47658	455	1	The	the	DT
47658	455	2	{	{	-LRB-
47658	455	3	45	45	CD
47658	455	4	}	}	-RRB-
47658	455	5	pragmatists	pragmatist	NNS
47658	455	6	apply	apply	VBP
47658	455	7	the	the	DT
47658	455	8	term	term	NN
47658	455	9	intellectualist	intellectualist	JJ
47658	455	10	to	to	IN
47658	455	11	all	all	DT
47658	455	12	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	455	13	who	who	WP
47658	455	14	recognise	recognise	VBP
47658	455	15	an	an	DT
47658	455	16	objective	objective	JJ
47658	455	17	character	character	NN
47658	455	18	in	in	IN
47658	455	19	the	the	DT
47658	455	20	logical	logical	JJ
47658	455	21	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	455	22	of	of	IN
47658	455	23	truth	truth	NN
47658	455	24	,	,	,
47658	455	25	whether	whether	IN
47658	455	26	or	or	CC
47658	455	27	not	not	RB
47658	455	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	455	29	also	also	RB
47658	455	30	recognise	recognise	VBP
47658	455	31	non	non	JJ
47658	455	32	-	-	JJ
47658	455	33	logical	logical	JJ
47658	455	34	elements	element	NNS
47658	455	35	in	in	IN
47658	455	36	reality	reality	NN
47658	455	37	,	,	,
47658	455	38	and	and	CC
47658	455	39	whether	whether	IN
47658	455	40	or	or	CC
47658	455	41	not	not	RB
47658	455	42	these	these	DT
47658	455	43	non	non	JJ
47658	455	44	-	-	JJ
47658	455	45	logical	logical	JJ
47658	455	46	elements	element	NNS
47658	455	47	are	be	VBP
47658	455	48	physical	physical	JJ
47658	455	49	,	,	,
47658	455	50	such	such	JJ
47658	455	51	as	as	IN
47658	455	52	matter	matter	NN
47658	455	53	and	and	CC
47658	455	54	energy	energy	NN
47658	455	55	,	,	,
47658	455	56	or	or	CC
47658	455	57	purely	purely	RB
47658	455	58	psychical	psychical	JJ
47658	455	59	,	,	,
47658	455	60	such	such	JJ
47658	455	61	as	as	IN
47658	455	62	will	will	NN
47658	455	63	,	,	,
47658	455	64	desire	desire	NN
47658	455	65	,	,	,
47658	455	66	emotion	emotion	NN
47658	455	67	,	,	,
47658	455	68	pleasure	pleasure	NN
47658	455	69	,	,	,
47658	455	70	and	and	CC
47658	455	71	pain	pain	NN
47658	455	72	.	.	.
47658	456	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	456	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	456	3	a	a	DT
47658	456	4	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	456	5	and	and	CC
47658	456	6	a	a	DT
47658	456	7	theory	theory	NN
47658	456	8	.	.	.
47658	457	1	If	if	IN
47658	457	2	reality	reality	NN
47658	457	3	in	in	IN
47658	457	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	457	5	full	full	JJ
47658	457	6	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	457	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	457	8	the	the	DT
47658	457	9	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	457	10	,	,	,
47658	457	11	and	and	CC
47658	457	12	if	if	IN
47658	457	13	all	all	DT
47658	457	14	seeming	seeming	JJ
47658	457	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	457	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	457	17	only	only	RB
47658	457	18	a	a	DT
47658	457	19	degree	degree	NN
47658	457	20	of	of	IN
47658	457	21	or	or	CC
47658	457	22	approximation	approximation	NN
47658	457	23	to	to	IN
47658	457	24	this	this	DT
47658	457	25	full	full	JJ
47658	457	26	reality	reality	NN
47658	457	27	,	,	,
47658	457	28	if	if	IN
47658	457	29	the	the	DT
47658	457	30	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	457	31	of	of	IN
47658	457	32	this	this	DT
47658	457	33	reality	reality	NN
47658	457	34	only	only	RB
47658	457	35	is	be	VBZ
47658	457	36	truth	truth	NN
47658	457	37	,	,	,
47658	457	38	must	must	MD
47658	457	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	457	40	not	not	RB
47658	457	41	seem	seem	VB
47658	457	42	to	to	IN
47658	457	43	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	457	44	that	that	DT
47658	457	45	truth	truth	NN
47658	457	46	is	be	VBZ
47658	457	47	useless	useless	JJ
47658	457	48	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	457	49	?	?	.
47658	458	1	Useless	useless	JJ
47658	458	2	,	,	,
47658	458	3	not	not	RB
47658	458	4	in	in	IN
47658	458	5	the	the	DT
47658	458	6	sense	sense	NN
47658	458	7	that	that	IN
47658	458	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	458	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	458	10	without	without	IN
47658	458	11	value	value	NN
47658	458	12	to	to	IN
47658	458	13	the	the	DT
47658	458	14	mind	mind	NN
47658	458	15	that	that	WDT
47658	458	16	cares	care	VBZ
47658	458	17	to	to	TO
47658	458	18	contemplate	contemplate	VB
47658	458	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	458	20	,	,	,
47658	458	21	but	but	CC
47658	458	22	useless	useless	JJ
47658	458	23	in	in	IN
47658	458	24	so	so	RB
47658	458	25	far	far	RB
47658	458	26	as	as	IN
47658	458	27	the	the	DT
47658	458	28	hard	hard	JJ
47658	458	29	everyday	everyday	JJ
47658	458	30	working	work	VBG
47658	458	31	world	world	NN
47658	458	32	in	in	IN
47658	458	33	which	which	WDT
47658	458	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	458	35	have	have	VBP
47658	458	36	to	to	TO
47658	458	37	spend	spend	VB
47658	458	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	458	39	lives	life	NNS
47658	458	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	458	41	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	458	42	.	.	.
47658	459	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	459	2	who	who	WP
47658	459	3	have	have	VBP
47658	459	4	to	to	TO
47658	459	5	win	win	VB
47658	459	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	459	7	existence	existence	NN
47658	459	8	in	in	IN
47658	459	9	the	the	DT
47658	459	10	struggle	struggle	NN
47658	459	11	of	of	IN
47658	459	12	life	life	NN
47658	459	13	,	,	,
47658	459	14	need	need	VBP
47658	459	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	459	16	.	.	.
47658	460	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	460	2	need	need	VBP
47658	460	3	truth	truth	NN
47658	460	4	in	in	IN
47658	460	5	order	order	NN
47658	460	6	to	to	TO
47658	460	7	act	act	VB
47658	460	8	.	.	.
47658	461	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	461	2	that	that	WDT
47658	461	3	transcends	transcend	VBZ
47658	461	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	461	5	temporal	temporal	JJ
47658	461	6	needs	need	NNS
47658	461	7	,	,	,
47658	461	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	461	9	that	that	WDT
47658	461	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	461	11	eternal	eternal	JJ
47658	461	12	,	,	,
47658	461	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	461	14	that	that	WDT
47658	461	15	reconciles	reconcile	VBZ
47658	461	16	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	461	17	and	and	CC
47658	461	18	error	error	NN
47658	461	19	,	,	,
47658	461	20	that	that	WDT
47658	461	21	accepts	accept	VBZ
47658	461	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	461	23	as	as	IN
47658	461	24	a	a	DT
47658	461	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	461	26	condition	condition	NN
47658	461	27	of	of	IN
47658	461	28	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	461	29	in	in	IN
47658	461	30	time	time	NN
47658	461	31	,	,	,
47658	461	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	461	33	useless	useless	JJ
47658	461	34	in	in	IN
47658	461	35	practice	practice	NN
47658	461	36	,	,	,
47658	461	37	however	however	RB
47658	461	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	461	39	may	may	MD
47658	461	40	inspire	inspire	VB
47658	461	41	the	the	DT
47658	461	42	poet	poet	NN
47658	461	43	and	and	CC
47658	461	44	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	461	45	.	.	.
47658	462	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	462	2	to	to	TO
47658	462	3	serve	serve	VB
47658	462	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	462	5	must	must	MD
47658	462	6	reject	reject	VB
47658	462	7	error	error	NN
47658	462	8	and	and	CC
47658	462	9	not	not	RB
47658	462	10	reconcile	reconcile	VB
47658	462	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	462	12	,	,	,
47658	462	13	must	must	MD
47658	462	14	be	be	VB
47658	462	15	a	a	DT
47658	462	16	working	work	VBG
47658	462	17	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	462	18	and	and	CC
47658	462	19	not	not	RB
47658	462	20	only	only	RB
47658	462	21	a	a	DT
47658	462	22	rational	rational	JJ
47658	462	23	one	one	NN
47658	462	24	.	.	.
47658	463	1	Whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	463	2	truth	truth	NN
47658	463	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	463	4	,	,	,
47658	463	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	463	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	463	7	not	not	RB
47658	463	8	useless	useless	JJ
47658	463	9	;	;	:
47658	463	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	463	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	463	12	a	a	DT
47658	463	13	necessity	necessity	NN
47658	463	14	of	of	IN
47658	463	15	life	life	NN
47658	463	16	,	,	,
47658	463	17	not	not	RB
47658	463	18	a	a	DT
47658	463	19	luxury	luxury	NN
47658	463	20	of	of	IN
47658	463	21	speculation	speculation	NN
47658	463	22	.	.	.
47658	464	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	464	2	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	464	3	rejects	reject	VBZ
47658	464	4	the	the	DT
47658	464	5	logical	logical	JJ
47658	464	6	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	464	7	of	of	IN
47658	464	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	464	9	because	because	IN
47658	464	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	464	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	464	12	purely	purely	RB
47658	464	13	formal	formal	JJ
47658	464	14	and	and	CC
47658	464	15	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	464	16	useless	useless	JJ
47658	464	17	.	.	.
47658	465	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	465	2	demands	demand	VBZ
47658	465	3	for	for	IN
47658	465	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	465	5	a	a	DT
47658	465	6	practical	practical	JJ
47658	465	7	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	465	8	,	,	,
47658	465	9	one	one	NN
47658	465	10	that	that	WDT
47658	465	11	will	will	MD
47658	465	12	serve	serve	VB
47658	465	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	465	14	continual	continual	JJ
47658	465	15	needs	need	NNS
47658	465	16	.	.	.
47658	466	1	Whether	whether	IN
47658	466	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	466	3	working	work	VBG
47658	466	4	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	466	5	--	--	:
47658	466	6	cause	cause	VB
47658	466	7	,	,	,
47658	466	8	time	time	NN
47658	466	9	,	,	,
47658	466	10	space	space	NN
47658	466	11	,	,	,
47658	466	12	movement	movement	NN
47658	466	13	,	,	,
47658	466	14	things	thing	NNS
47658	466	15	and	and	CC
47658	466	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	466	17	qualities	quality	NNS
47658	466	18	,	,	,
47658	466	19	terms	term	NNS
47658	466	20	and	and	CC
47658	466	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	466	22	relations	relation	NNS
47658	466	23	,	,	,
47658	466	24	and	and	CC
47658	466	25	the	the	DT
47658	466	26	like	like	JJ
47658	466	27	--	--	:
47658	466	28	are	be	VBP
47658	466	29	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	466	30	or	or	CC
47658	466	31	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
47658	466	32	in	in	IN
47658	466	33	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	34	,	,	,
47658	466	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	36	more	more	RBR
47658	466	37	or	or	CC
47658	466	38	less	less	JJR
47658	466	39	work	work	NN
47658	466	40	;	;	:
47658	466	41	and	and	CC
47658	466	42	in	in	IN
47658	466	43	so	so	RB
47658	466	44	far	far	RB
47658	466	45	as	as	IN
47658	466	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	47	work	work	VBP
47658	466	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	49	are	be	VBP
47658	466	50	useful	useful	JJ
47658	466	51	and	and	CC
47658	466	52	serve	serve	VB
47658	466	53	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	54	,	,	,
47658	466	55	and	and	CC
47658	466	56	because	because	IN
47658	466	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	58	work	work	VBP
47658	466	59	,	,	,
47658	466	60	and	and	CC
47658	466	61	just	just	RB
47658	466	62	in	in	RB
47658	466	63	so	so	RB
47658	466	64	far	far	RB
47658	466	65	as	as	IN
47658	466	66	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	67	work	work	VBP
47658	466	68	,	,	,
47658	466	69	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	466	70	are	be	VBP
47658	466	71	true	true	JJ
47658	466	72	.	.	.
47658	467	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	467	2	46	46	CD
47658	467	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	467	4	The	the	DT
47658	467	5	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	467	6	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	467	7	declares	declare	VBZ
47658	467	8	that	that	DT
47658	467	9	utility	utility	NN
47658	467	10	,	,	,
47658	467	11	not	not	RB
47658	467	12	logical	logical	JJ
47658	467	13	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	467	14	,	,	,
47658	467	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	467	16	the	the	DT
47658	467	17	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	467	18	of	of	IN
47658	467	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	467	20	.	.	.
47658	468	1	Ideas	idea	NNS
47658	468	2	are	be	VBP
47658	468	3	true	true	JJ
47658	468	4	in	in	IN
47658	468	5	so	so	RB
47658	468	6	far	far	RB
47658	468	7	as	as	IN
47658	468	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	468	9	work	work	VBP
47658	468	10	.	.	.
47658	469	1	The	the	DT
47658	469	2	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	469	3	that	that	WDT
47658	469	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	469	5	serve	serve	VBP
47658	469	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	469	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	469	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	469	9	verification	verification	NN
47658	469	10	.	.	.
47658	470	1	If	if	IN
47658	470	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	470	3	discover	discover	VBP
47658	470	4	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	470	5	that	that	WDT
47658	470	6	will	will	MD
47658	470	7	serve	serve	VB
47658	470	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	470	9	better	well	RBR
47658	470	10	,	,	,
47658	470	11	the	the	DT
47658	470	12	old	old	JJ
47658	470	13	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	470	14	that	that	WDT
47658	470	15	were	be	VBD
47658	470	16	true	true	JJ
47658	470	17	become	become	VBN
47658	470	18	untrue	untrue	JJ
47658	470	19	,	,	,
47658	470	20	and	and	CC
47658	470	21	the	the	DT
47658	470	22	new	new	JJ
47658	470	23	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	470	24	that	that	WDT
47658	470	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	470	26	adopt	adopt	VBP
47658	470	27	become	become	VBP
47658	470	28	true	true	JJ
47658	470	29	because	because	IN
47658	470	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	470	31	are	be	VBP
47658	470	32	found	find	VBN
47658	470	33	to	to	TO
47658	470	34	work	work	VB
47658	470	35	.	.	.
47658	471	1	This	this	DT
47658	471	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	471	3	of	of	IN
47658	471	4	the	the	DT
47658	471	5	verification	verification	NN
47658	471	6	or	or	CC
47658	471	7	making	make	VBG
47658	471	8	true	true	JJ
47658	471	9	of	of	IN
47658	471	10	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	471	11	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	471	12	to	to	IN
47658	471	13	a	a	DT
47658	471	14	theory	theory	NN
47658	471	15	of	of	IN
47658	471	16	the	the	DT
47658	471	17	origin	origin	NN
47658	471	18	of	of	IN
47658	471	19	the	the	DT
47658	471	20	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	471	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	471	22	.	.	.
47658	472	1	Each	each	DT
47658	472	2	idea	idea	NN
47658	472	3	has	have	VBZ
47658	472	4	arisen	arise	VBN
47658	472	5	or	or	CC
47658	472	6	been	be	VBN
47658	472	7	called	call	VBN
47658	472	8	forth	forth	RP
47658	472	9	by	by	IN
47658	472	10	a	a	DT
47658	472	11	human	human	JJ
47658	472	12	need	need	NN
47658	472	13	.	.	.
47658	473	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	473	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	473	3	been	be	VBN
47658	473	4	formed	form	VBN
47658	473	5	by	by	IN
47658	473	6	human	human	JJ
47658	473	7	nature	nature	NN
47658	473	8	to	to	TO
47658	473	9	meet	meet	VB
47658	473	10	a	a	DT
47658	473	11	need	need	NN
47658	473	12	of	of	IN
47658	473	13	human	human	JJ
47658	473	14	nature	nature	NN
47658	473	15	.	.	.
47658	474	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	474	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	474	3	a	a	DT
47658	474	4	practical	practical	JJ
47658	474	5	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	474	6	claiming	claim	VBG
47658	474	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	474	8	.	.	.
47658	475	1	Even	even	RB
47658	475	2	the	the	DT
47658	475	3	axioms	axiom	NNS
47658	475	4	that	that	WDT
47658	475	5	now	now	RB
47658	475	6	seem	seem	VBP
47658	475	7	to	to	IN
47658	475	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	475	9	self	self	NN
47658	475	10	-	-	HYPH
47658	475	11	evident	evident	JJ
47658	475	12	--	--	:
47658	475	13	such	such	JJ
47658	475	14	,	,	,
47658	475	15	for	for	IN
47658	475	16	example	example	NN
47658	475	17	,	,	,
47658	475	18	as	as	IN
47658	475	19	the	the	DT
47658	475	20	very	very	JJ
47658	475	21	law	law	NN
47658	475	22	of	of	IN
47658	475	23	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	475	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	475	25	,	,	,
47658	475	26	from	from	IN
47658	475	27	which	which	WDT
47658	475	28	,	,	,
47658	475	29	as	as	IN
47658	475	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	475	31	have	have	VBP
47658	475	32	seen	see	VBN
47658	475	33	,	,	,
47658	475	34	the	the	DT
47658	475	35	logical	logical	JJ
47658	475	36	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	475	37	of	of	IN
47658	475	38	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	475	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	475	40	deduced	deduce	VBN
47658	475	41	--	--	:
47658	475	42	were	be	VBD
47658	475	43	in	in	IN
47658	475	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	475	45	origin	origin	NN
47658	475	46	practical	practical	JJ
47658	475	47	postulates	postulate	NNS
47658	475	48	,	,	,
47658	475	49	called	call	VBN
47658	475	50	forth	forth	RB
47658	475	51	by	by	IN
47658	475	52	a	a	DT
47658	475	53	need	need	NN
47658	475	54	,	,	,
47658	475	55	and	and	CC
47658	475	56	,	,	,
47658	475	57	because	because	IN
47658	475	58	found	find	VBN
47658	475	59	to	to	TO
47658	475	60	work	work	VB
47658	475	61	,	,	,
47658	475	62	true	true	JJ
47658	475	63	.	.	.
47658	476	1	The	the	DT
47658	476	2	inconsistencies	inconsistency	NNS
47658	476	3	and	and	CC
47658	476	4	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
47658	476	5	in	in	IN
47658	476	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	476	7	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	476	8	do	do	VBP
47658	476	9	not	not	RB
47658	476	10	condemn	condemn	VB
47658	476	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	476	12	as	as	IN
47658	476	13	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	476	14	,	,	,
47658	476	15	and	and	CC
47658	476	16	compel	compel	VB
47658	476	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	476	18	to	to	TO
47658	476	19	construct	construct	VB
47658	476	20	a	a	DT
47658	476	21	reality	reality	NN
47658	476	22	in	in	IN
47658	476	23	which	which	WDT
47658	476	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	476	25	disappear	disappear	VBP
47658	476	26	or	or	CC
47658	476	27	are	be	VBP
47658	476	28	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
47658	476	29	,	,	,
47658	476	30	but	but	CC
47658	476	31	are	be	VBP
47658	476	32	evidence	evidence	NN
47658	476	33	of	of	IN
47658	476	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	476	35	origin	origin	NN
47658	476	36	in	in	IN
47658	476	37	practical	practical	JJ
47658	476	38	need	need	NN
47658	476	39	and	and	CC
47658	476	40	of	of	IN
47658	476	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	476	42	provisional	provisional	JJ
47658	476	43	character	character	NN
47658	476	44	.	.	.
47658	477	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	477	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	477	3	not	not	RB
47658	477	4	eternal	eternal	JJ
47658	477	5	,	,	,
47658	477	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	477	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	477	8	changing	change	VBG
47658	477	9	.	.	.
47658	478	1	New	new	JJ
47658	478	2	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	478	3	are	be	VBP
47658	478	4	ever	ever	RB
47658	478	5	calling	call	VBG
47658	478	6	forth	forth	RP
47658	478	7	new	new	JJ
47658	478	8	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	478	9	,	,	,
47658	478	10	and	and	CC
47658	478	11	truths	truth	NNS
47658	478	12	become	become	VBP
47658	478	13	untrue	untrue	JJ
47658	478	14	.	.	.
47658	479	1	Each	each	DT
47658	479	2	new	new	JJ
47658	479	3	idea	idea	NN
47658	479	4	comes	come	VBZ
47658	479	5	forward	forward	RB
47658	479	6	with	with	IN
47658	479	7	a	a	DT
47658	479	8	claim	claim	NN
47658	479	9	to	to	IN
47658	479	10	truth	truth	NN
47658	479	11	,	,	,
47658	479	12	and	and	CC
47658	479	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	479	14	claim	claim	NN
47658	479	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	479	16	tested	test	VBN
47658	479	17	by	by	IN
47658	479	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	479	19	practicability	practicability	NN
47658	479	20	.	.	.
47658	480	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	480	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	480	3	not	not	RB
47658	480	4	something	something	NN
47658	480	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	480	6	discover	discover	VBP
47658	480	7	,	,	,
47658	480	8	and	and	CC
47658	480	9	which	which	WDT
47658	480	10	was	be	VBD
47658	480	11	there	there	RB
47658	480	12	to	to	TO
47658	480	13	be	be	VB
47658	480	14	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	480	15	.	.	.
47658	481	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	481	2	verify	verify	VBP
47658	481	3	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	481	4	.	.	.
47658	482	1	To	to	TO
47658	482	2	verify	verify	VB
47658	482	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	482	4	not	not	RB
47658	482	5	to	to	TO
47658	482	6	find	find	VB
47658	482	7	true	true	JJ
47658	482	8	but	but	CC
47658	482	9	to	to	TO
47658	482	10	make	make	VB
47658	482	11	true	true	JJ
47658	482	12	.	.	.
47658	483	1	The	the	DT
47658	483	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	483	3	theory	theory	NN
47658	483	4	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	483	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	483	6	that	that	DT
47658	483	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	483	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	483	9	made	make	VBN
47658	483	10	.	.	.
47658	484	1	In	in	IN
47658	484	2	all	all	DT
47658	484	3	other	other	JJ
47658	484	4	theories	theory	NNS
47658	484	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	484	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	484	7	found	find	VBN
47658	484	8	.	.	.
47658	485	1	But	but	CC
47658	485	2	if	if	IN
47658	485	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	485	4	make	make	VBP
47658	485	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	485	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	485	7	must	must	MD
47658	485	8	make	make	VB
47658	485	9	reality	reality	NN
47658	485	10	,	,	,
47658	485	11	for	for	IN
47658	485	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	485	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	485	14	clear	clear	JJ
47658	485	15	that	that	IN
47658	485	16	if	if	IN
47658	485	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	485	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	485	19	there	there	RB
47658	485	20	already	already	RB
47658	485	21	,	,	,
47658	485	22	the	the	DT
47658	485	23	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	485	24	with	with	IN
47658	485	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	485	26	of	of	IN
47658	485	27	man	man	NN
47658	485	28	-	-	HYPH
47658	485	29	made	make	VBN
47658	485	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	485	31	would	would	MD
47658	485	32	be	be	VB
47658	485	33	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	485	34	short	short	JJ
47658	485	35	of	of	IN
47658	485	36	a	a	DT
47658	485	37	miracle	miracle	NN
47658	485	38	.	.	.
47658	486	1	The	the	DT
47658	486	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	486	3	,	,	,
47658	486	4	or	or	CC
47658	486	5	at	at	IN
47658	486	6	all	all	DT
47658	486	7	events	event	NNS
47658	486	8	the	the	DT
47658	486	9	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	486	10	who	who	WP
47658	486	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	486	12	also	also	RB
47658	486	13	a	a	DT
47658	486	14	{	{	-LRB-
47658	486	15	47	47	CD
47658	486	16	}	}	-RRB-
47658	486	17	humanist	humanist	NN
47658	486	18	,	,	,
47658	486	19	finds	find	VBZ
47658	486	20	no	no	DT
47658	486	21	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	486	22	in	in	IN
47658	486	23	accepting	accept	VBG
47658	486	24	this	this	DT
47658	486	25	consequence	consequence	NN
47658	486	26	of	of	IN
47658	486	27	the	the	DT
47658	486	28	theory	theory	NN
47658	486	29	,	,	,
47658	486	30	although	although	IN
47658	486	31	at	at	IN
47658	486	32	the	the	DT
47658	486	33	same	same	JJ
47658	486	34	time	time	NN
47658	486	35	insisting	insist	VBG
47658	486	36	that	that	IN
47658	486	37	the	the	DT
47658	486	38	whole	whole	JJ
47658	486	39	problem	problem	NN
47658	486	40	,	,	,
47658	486	41	of	of	IN
47658	486	42	being	be	VBG
47658	486	43	as	as	RB
47658	486	44	well	well	RB
47658	486	45	as	as	IN
47658	486	46	of	of	IN
47658	486	47	knowing	know	VBG
47658	486	48	is	be	VBZ
47658	486	49	concerned	concern	VBN
47658	486	50	with	with	IN
47658	486	51	truth	truth	NN
47658	486	52	.	.	.
47658	487	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	487	2	shall	shall	MD
47658	487	3	see	see	VB
47658	487	4	,	,	,
47658	487	5	however	however	RB
47658	487	6	,	,	,
47658	487	7	that	that	IN
47658	487	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	487	9	offers	offer	VBZ
47658	487	10	a	a	DT
47658	487	11	serious	serious	JJ
47658	487	12	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	487	13	to	to	IN
47658	487	14	the	the	DT
47658	487	15	acceptance	acceptance	NN
47658	487	16	of	of	IN
47658	487	17	the	the	DT
47658	487	18	theory	theory	NN
47658	487	19	--	--	:
47658	487	20	a	a	DT
47658	487	21	theory	theory	NN
47658	487	22	which	which	WDT
47658	487	23	in	in	IN
47658	487	24	very	very	RB
47658	487	25	many	many	JJ
47658	487	26	respects	respect	NNS
47658	487	27	agrees	agree	VBZ
47658	487	28	with	with	IN
47658	487	29	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	487	30	practice	practice	NN
47658	487	31	and	and	CC
47658	487	32	with	with	IN
47658	487	33	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	487	34	method	method	NN
47658	487	35	.	.	.
47658	488	1	Take	take	VB
47658	488	2	,	,	,
47658	488	3	for	for	IN
47658	488	4	example	example	NN
47658	488	5	,	,	,
47658	488	6	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	488	7	method	method	NN
47658	488	8	.	.	.
47658	489	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	489	2	not	not	RB
47658	489	3	all	all	DT
47658	489	4	progress	progress	NN
47658	489	5	in	in	IN
47658	489	6	science	science	NN
47658	489	7	made	make	VBN
47658	489	8	by	by	IN
47658	489	9	suggesting	suggest	VBG
47658	489	10	a	a	DT
47658	489	11	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	489	12	,	,	,
47658	489	13	and	and	CC
47658	489	14	testing	test	VBG
47658	489	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	489	16	by	by	IN
47658	489	17	experiment	experiment	NN
47658	489	18	to	to	TO
47658	489	19	see	see	VB
47658	489	20	if	if	IN
47658	489	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	489	22	works	work	VBZ
47658	489	23	?	?	.
47658	490	1	Do	do	VBP
47658	490	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	490	3	not	not	RB
47658	490	4	judge	judge	VB
47658	490	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	490	6	claim	claim	NN
47658	490	7	to	to	IN
47658	490	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	490	9	by	by	IN
47658	490	10	the	the	DT
47658	490	11	practical	practical	JJ
47658	490	12	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	490	13	involved	involve	VBN
47658	490	14	in	in	IN
47658	490	15	accepting	accept	VBG
47658	490	16	or	or	CC
47658	490	17	rejecting	reject	VBG
47658	490	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	490	19	?	?	.
47658	491	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	491	2	there	there	EX
47658	491	3	any	any	DT
47658	491	4	other	other	JJ
47658	491	5	verification	verification	NN
47658	491	6	?	?	.
47658	492	1	This	this	DT
47658	492	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	492	3	the	the	DT
47658	492	4	simple	simple	JJ
47658	492	5	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	492	6	test,--does	test,--doe	VBZ
47658	492	7	the	the	DT
47658	492	8	laboratory	laboratory	NN
47658	492	9	worker	worker	NN
47658	492	10	add	add	VB
47658	492	11	to	to	IN
47658	492	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	492	13	or	or	CC
47658	492	14	find	find	VB
47658	492	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	492	16	in	in	IN
47658	492	17	any	any	DT
47658	492	18	respect	respect	NN
47658	492	19	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
47658	492	20	?	?	.
47658	493	1	If	if	IN
47658	493	2	truth	truth	NN
47658	493	3	can	can	MD
47658	493	4	be	be	VB
47658	493	5	considered	consider	VBN
47658	493	6	alone	alone	JJ
47658	493	7	,	,	,
47658	493	8	then	then	RB
47658	493	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	493	10	must	must	MD
47658	493	11	admit	admit	VB
47658	493	12	that	that	IN
47658	493	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	493	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	493	15	the	the	DT
47658	493	16	attribute	attribute	NN
47658	493	17	of	of	IN
47658	493	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	493	19	which	which	WDT
47658	493	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	493	21	comprised	comprise	VBN
47658	493	22	under	under	IN
47658	493	23	the	the	DT
47658	493	24	term	term	NN
47658	493	25	useful	useful	JJ
47658	493	26	,	,	,
47658	493	27	the	the	DT
47658	493	28	term	term	NN
47658	493	29	being	be	VBG
47658	493	30	used	use	VBN
47658	493	31	in	in	IN
47658	493	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	493	33	most	most	RBS
47658	493	34	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
47658	493	35	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	493	36	to	to	TO
47658	493	37	include	include	VB
47658	493	38	every	every	DT
47658	493	39	kind	kind	NN
47658	493	40	of	of	IN
47658	493	41	practical	practical	JJ
47658	493	42	consequence	consequence	NN
47658	493	43	.	.	.
47658	494	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	494	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	494	3	the	the	DT
47658	494	4	question	question	NN
47658	494	5	of	of	IN
47658	494	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	494	7	that	that	WDT
47658	494	8	raises	raise	VBZ
47658	494	9	the	the	DT
47658	494	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	494	11	for	for	IN
47658	494	12	the	the	DT
47658	494	13	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	494	14	worker	worker	NN
47658	494	15	.	.	.
47658	495	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	495	2	can	can	MD
47658	495	3	not	not	RB
47658	495	4	believe	believe	VB
47658	495	5	,	,	,
47658	495	6	or	or	CC
47658	495	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	495	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	495	9	should	should	MD
47658	495	10	say	say	VB
47658	495	11	,	,	,
47658	495	12	the	the	DT
47658	495	13	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	495	14	man	man	NN
47658	495	15	and	and	CC
47658	495	16	the	the	DT
47658	495	17	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	495	18	man	man	NN
47658	495	19	would	would	MD
47658	495	20	find	find	VB
47658	495	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	495	22	very	very	RB
47658	495	23	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	495	24	to	to	TO
47658	495	25	believe	believe	VB
47658	495	26	,	,	,
47658	495	27	that	that	IN
47658	495	28	reality	reality	NN
47658	495	29	changes	change	VBZ
47658	495	30	correspondingly	correspondingly	RB
47658	495	31	with	with	IN
47658	495	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	495	33	success	success	NN
47658	495	34	or	or	CC
47658	495	35	failure	failure	NN
47658	495	36	in	in	IN
47658	495	37	the	the	DT
47658	495	38	verification	verification	NN
47658	495	39	of	of	IN
47658	495	40	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	495	41	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	495	42	.	.	.
47658	496	1	When	when	WRB
47658	496	2	the	the	DT
47658	496	3	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	496	4	worker	worker	NN
47658	496	5	verifies	verify	VBZ
47658	496	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	496	7	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	496	8	,	,	,
47658	496	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	496	10	feels	feel	VBZ
47658	496	11	not	not	RB
47658	496	12	that	that	IN
47658	496	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	496	14	has	have	VBZ
47658	496	15	made	make	VBN
47658	496	16	something	something	NN
47658	496	17	true	true	JJ
47658	496	18	which	which	WDT
47658	496	19	before	before	RB
47658	496	20	was	be	VBD
47658	496	21	not	not	RB
47658	496	22	true	true	JJ
47658	496	23	,	,	,
47658	496	24	but	but	CC
47658	496	25	that	that	IN
47658	496	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	496	27	has	have	VBZ
47658	496	28	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	496	29	what	what	WP
47658	496	30	always	always	RB
47658	496	31	was	be	VBD
47658	496	32	true	true	JJ
47658	496	33	,	,	,
47658	496	34	although	although	IN
47658	496	35	until	until	IN
47658	496	36	the	the	DT
47658	496	37	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	496	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	496	39	did	do	VBD
47658	496	40	not	not	RB
47658	496	41	know	know	VB
47658	496	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	496	43	.	.	.
47658	497	1	To	to	IN
47658	497	2	this	this	DT
47658	497	3	the	the	DT
47658	497	4	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	497	5	reply	reply	NN
47658	497	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	497	7	,	,	,
47658	497	8	that	that	IN
47658	497	9	this	this	DT
47658	497	10	very	very	JJ
47658	497	11	belief	belief	NN
47658	497	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	497	13	a	a	DT
47658	497	14	practical	practical	JJ
47658	497	15	consequence	consequence	NN
47658	497	16	involved	involve	VBN
47658	497	17	in	in	IN
47658	497	18	the	the	DT
47658	497	19	verification	verification	NN
47658	497	20	of	of	IN
47658	497	21	the	the	DT
47658	497	22	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	497	23	,	,	,
47658	497	24	involved	involve	VBN
47658	497	25	in	in	IN
47658	497	26	the	the	DT
47658	497	27	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	497	28	that	that	IN
47658	497	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	497	30	works	work	VBZ
47658	497	31	.	.	.
47658	498	1	What	what	WP
47658	498	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	498	3	denies	deny	VBZ
47658	498	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	498	5	that	that	IN
47658	498	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	498	7	reveals	reveal	NNS
47658	498	8	,	,	,
47658	498	9	or	or	CC
47658	498	10	ever	ever	RB
47658	498	11	can	can	MD
47658	498	12	reveal	reveal	VB
47658	498	13	,	,	,
47658	498	14	a	a	DT
47658	498	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	498	16	entirely	entirely	RB
47658	498	17	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	498	18	to	to	IN
47658	498	19	any	any	DT
47658	498	20	human	human	JJ
47658	498	21	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	498	22	.	.	.
47658	499	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	499	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	499	3	also	also	RB
47658	499	4	very	very	RB
47658	499	5	important	important	JJ
47658	499	6	to	to	TO
47658	499	7	add	add	VB
47658	499	8	that	that	IN
47658	499	9	in	in	IN
47658	499	10	declaring	declare	VBG
47658	499	11	that	that	DT
47658	499	12	truth	truth	NN
47658	499	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	499	14	verification	verification	NN
47658	499	15	,	,	,
47658	499	16	the	the	DT
47658	499	17	{	{	-LRB-
47658	499	18	48	48	CD
47658	499	19	}	}	-RRB-
47658	499	20	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	499	21	does	do	VBZ
47658	499	22	not	not	RB
47658	499	23	set	set	VB
47658	499	24	up	up	RP
47658	499	25	a	a	DT
47658	499	26	purely	purely	RB
47658	499	27	practical	practical	JJ
47658	499	28	or	or	CC
47658	499	29	utilitarian	utilitarian	JJ
47658	499	30	standard	standard	NN
47658	499	31	.	.	.
47658	500	1	The	the	DT
47658	500	2	"	"	``
47658	500	3	working	working	NN
47658	500	4	"	"	''
47658	500	5	of	of	IN
47658	500	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	500	7	means	mean	NNS
47658	500	8	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
47658	500	9	as	as	RB
47658	500	10	well	well	RB
47658	500	11	as	as	IN
47658	500	12	practical	practical	JJ
47658	500	13	working	working	NN
47658	500	14	.	.	.
47658	501	1	Much	much	JJ
47658	501	2	of	of	IN
47658	501	3	the	the	DT
47658	501	4	current	current	JJ
47658	501	5	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	501	6	of	of	IN
47658	501	7	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	501	8	has	have	VBZ
47658	501	9	failed	fail	VBN
47658	501	10	to	to	TO
47658	501	11	take	take	VB
47658	501	12	notice	notice	NN
47658	501	13	of	of	IN
47658	501	14	this	this	DT
47658	501	15	intention	intention	NN
47658	501	16	or	or	CC
47658	501	17	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	501	18	of	of	IN
47658	501	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	501	20	principle	principle	NN
47658	501	21	,	,	,
47658	501	22	and	and	CC
47658	501	23	hence	hence	RB
47658	501	24	the	the	DT
47658	501	25	common	common	JJ
47658	501	26	misapprehension	misapprehension	NN
47658	501	27	that	that	WDT
47658	501	28	the	the	DT
47658	501	29	maxim	maxim	NN
47658	501	30	"	"	``
47658	501	31	truth	truth	NN
47658	501	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	501	33	what	what	WP
47658	501	34	works	work	VBZ
47658	501	35	"	"	``
47658	501	36	must	must	MD
47658	501	37	mean	mean	VB
47658	501	38	that	that	IN
47658	501	39	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	501	40	a	a	DT
47658	501	41	man	man	NN
47658	501	42	believes	believe	VBZ
47658	501	43	is	be	VBZ
47658	501	44	for	for	IN
47658	501	45	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	501	46	truth	truth	NN
47658	501	47	.	.	.
47658	502	1	The	the	DT
47658	502	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	502	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	502	4	and	and	CC
47658	502	5	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	502	6	will	will	MD
47658	502	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	502	8	be	be	VB
47658	502	9	easier	easy	JJR
47658	502	10	to	to	TO
47658	502	11	understand	understand	VB
47658	502	12	if	if	IN
47658	502	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	502	14	take	take	VBP
47658	502	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	502	16	in	in	IN
47658	502	17	regard	regard	NN
47658	502	18	to	to	IN
47658	502	19	a	a	DT
47658	502	20	particular	particular	JJ
47658	502	21	instance	instance	NN
47658	502	22	of	of	IN
47658	502	23	truth	truth	NN
47658	502	24	and	and	CC
47658	502	25	error	error	NN
47658	502	26	in	in	IN
47658	502	27	regard	regard	NN
47658	502	28	to	to	IN
47658	502	29	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	502	30	notions	notion	NNS
47658	502	31	.	.	.
47658	503	1	In	in	IN
47658	503	2	the	the	DT
47658	503	3	last	last	JJ
47658	503	4	four	four	CD
47658	503	5	or	or	CC
47658	503	6	five	five	CD
47658	503	7	years	year	NNS
47658	503	8	a	a	DT
47658	503	9	new	new	JJ
47658	503	10	principle	principle	NN
47658	503	11	has	have	VBZ
47658	503	12	been	be	VBN
47658	503	13	formulated	formulate	VBN
47658	503	14	in	in	IN
47658	503	15	Physics	Physics	NNP
47658	503	16	,	,	,
47658	503	17	named	name	VBD
47658	503	18	the	the	DT
47658	503	19	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	503	20	of	of	IN
47658	503	21	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	503	22	.	.	.
47658	504	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	504	2	revolutionises	revolutionise	VBZ
47658	504	3	the	the	DT
47658	504	4	current	current	JJ
47658	504	5	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	504	6	of	of	IN
47658	504	7	space	space	NN
47658	504	8	and	and	CC
47658	504	9	time	time	NN
47658	504	10	.	.	.
47658	505	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	505	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	505	3	so	so	RB
47658	505	4	recent	recent	JJ
47658	505	5	that	that	IN
47658	505	6	probably	probably	RB
47658	505	7	some	some	DT
47658	505	8	of	of	IN
47658	505	9	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	505	10	readers	reader	NNS
47658	505	11	now	now	RB
47658	505	12	hear	hear	VBP
47658	505	13	of	of	IN
47658	505	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	505	15	for	for	IN
47658	505	16	the	the	DT
47658	505	17	first	first	JJ
47658	505	18	time	time	NN
47658	505	19	,	,	,
47658	505	20	and	and	CC
47658	505	21	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	505	22	before	before	IN
47658	505	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	505	24	refer	refer	VBP
47658	505	25	to	to	IN
47658	505	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	505	27	formulation	formulation	NN
47658	505	28	by	by	IN
47658	505	29	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
47658	505	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	505	31	will	will	MD
47658	505	32	give	give	VB
47658	505	33	a	a	DT
47658	505	34	simple	simple	JJ
47658	505	35	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	505	36	to	to	TO
47658	505	37	explain	explain	VB
47658	505	38	what	what	WP
47658	505	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	505	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	505	41	.	.	.
47658	506	1	Suppose	suppose	VB
47658	506	2	that	that	IN
47658	506	3	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	506	4	are	be	VBP
47658	506	5	walking	walk	VBG
47658	506	6	up	up	IN
47658	506	7	and	and	CC
47658	506	8	down	down	IN
47658	506	9	the	the	DT
47658	506	10	deck	deck	NN
47658	506	11	of	of	IN
47658	506	12	a	a	DT
47658	506	13	steamer	steamer	NN
47658	506	14	,	,	,
47658	506	15	and	and	CC
47658	506	16	let	let	VB
47658	506	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	506	18	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	506	19	that	that	IN
47658	506	20	the	the	DT
47658	506	21	steamer	steamer	NN
47658	506	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	506	23	proceeding	proceed	VBG
47658	506	24	at	at	IN
47658	506	25	the	the	DT
47658	506	26	speed	speed	NN
47658	506	27	of	of	IN
47658	506	28	four	four	CD
47658	506	29	miles	mile	NNS
47658	506	30	an	an	DT
47658	506	31	hour	hour	NN
47658	506	32	,	,	,
47658	506	33	the	the	DT
47658	506	34	space	space	NN
47658	506	35	that	that	WDT
47658	506	36	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	506	37	cover	cover	VBP
47658	506	38	and	and	CC
47658	506	39	the	the	DT
47658	506	40	interval	interval	NN
47658	506	41	of	of	IN
47658	506	42	time	time	NN
47658	506	43	that	that	WDT
47658	506	44	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	506	45	occupy	occupy	VBP
47658	506	46	are	be	VBP
47658	506	47	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	506	48	the	the	DT
47658	506	49	same	same	JJ
47658	506	50	for	for	IN
47658	506	51	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	506	52	whether	whether	IN
47658	506	53	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	506	54	are	be	VBP
47658	506	55	moving	move	VBG
47658	506	56	up	up	IN
47658	506	57	the	the	DT
47658	506	58	deck	deck	NN
47658	506	59	in	in	IN
47658	506	60	the	the	DT
47658	506	61	direction	direction	NN
47658	506	62	the	the	DT
47658	506	63	steamer	steamer	NN
47658	506	64	is	be	VBZ
47658	506	65	going	go	VBG
47658	506	66	or	or	CC
47658	506	67	down	down	IN
47658	506	68	the	the	DT
47658	506	69	deck	deck	NN
47658	506	70	in	in	IN
47658	506	71	the	the	DT
47658	506	72	direction	direction	NN
47658	506	73	which	which	WDT
47658	506	74	is	be	VBZ
47658	506	75	the	the	DT
47658	506	76	reverse	reverse	NN
47658	506	77	of	of	IN
47658	506	78	the	the	DT
47658	506	79	steamer	steamer	NN
47658	506	80	's	's	POS
47658	506	81	movement	movement	NN
47658	506	82	.	.	.
47658	507	1	But	but	CC
47658	507	2	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	507	3	some	some	DT
47658	507	4	one	one	NN
47658	507	5	on	on	IN
47658	507	6	the	the	DT
47658	507	7	shore	shore	NN
47658	507	8	could	could	MD
47658	507	9	observe	observe	VB
47658	507	10	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	507	11	moving	move	VBG
47658	507	12	while	while	IN
47658	507	13	the	the	DT
47658	507	14	ship	ship	NN
47658	507	15	was	be	VBD
47658	507	16	invisible	invisible	JJ
47658	507	17	to	to	IN
47658	507	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	507	19	,	,	,
47658	507	20	your	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	507	21	movement	movement	NN
47658	507	22	would	would	MD
47658	507	23	appear	appear	VB
47658	507	24	to	to	IN
47658	507	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	507	26	entirely	entirely	RB
47658	507	27	different	different	JJ
47658	507	28	to	to	IN
47658	507	29	what	what	WP
47658	507	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	507	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	507	32	to	to	IN
47658	507	33	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	507	34	.	.	.
47658	508	1	When	when	WRB
47658	508	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	508	3	were	be	VBD
47658	508	4	walking	walk	VBG
47658	508	5	up	up	IN
47658	508	6	the	the	DT
47658	508	7	deck	deck	NN
47658	508	8	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	508	9	would	would	MD
47658	508	10	seem	seem	VB
47658	508	11	to	to	TO
47658	508	12	be	be	VB
47658	508	13	going	go	VBG
47658	508	14	at	at	IN
47658	508	15	twice	twice	PDT
47658	508	16	the	the	DT
47658	508	17	speed	speed	NN
47658	508	18	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	508	19	would	would	MD
47658	508	20	be	be	VB
47658	508	21	going	go	VBG
47658	508	22	,	,	,
47658	508	23	and	and	CC
47658	508	24	when	when	WRB
47658	508	25	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	508	26	were	be	VBD
47658	508	27	going	go	VBG
47658	508	28	down	down	IN
47658	508	29	the	the	DT
47658	508	30	deck	deck	NN
47658	508	31	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	508	32	would	would	MD
47658	508	33	seem	seem	VB
47658	508	34	not	not	RB
47658	508	35	to	to	TO
47658	508	36	be	be	VB
47658	508	37	moving	move	VBG
47658	508	38	at	at	RB
47658	508	39	all	all	RB
47658	508	40	.	.	.
47658	509	1	The	the	DT
47658	509	2	time	time	NN
47658	509	3	measurement	measurement	NN
47658	509	4	would	would	MD
47658	509	5	also	also	RB
47658	509	6	seem	seem	VB
47658	509	7	different	different	JJ
47658	509	8	to	to	IN
47658	509	9	the	the	DT
47658	509	10	observer	observer	NN
47658	509	11	on	on	IN
47658	509	12	the	the	DT
47658	509	13	shore	shore	NN
47658	509	14	,	,	,
47658	509	15	for	for	IN
47658	509	16	while	while	IN
47658	509	17	to	to	IN
47658	509	18	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	509	19	each	each	DT
47658	509	20	moment	moment	NN
47658	509	21	would	would	MD
47658	509	22	be	be	VB
47658	509	23	measured	measure	VBN
47658	509	24	by	by	IN
47658	509	25	an	an	DT
47658	509	26	equal	equal	JJ
47658	509	27	{	{	-LRB-
47658	509	28	49	49	CD
47658	509	29	}	}	-RRB-
47658	509	30	space	space	NN
47658	509	31	covered	cover	VBN
47658	509	32	,	,	,
47658	509	33	to	to	IN
47658	509	34	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	509	35	one	one	CD
47658	509	36	moment	moment	NN
47658	509	37	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	509	38	would	would	MD
47658	509	39	be	be	VB
47658	509	40	moving	move	VBG
47658	509	41	rapidly	rapidly	RB
47658	509	42	,	,	,
47658	509	43	the	the	DT
47658	509	44	next	next	JJ
47658	509	45	at	at	IN
47658	509	46	rest	rest	NN
47658	509	47	.	.	.
47658	510	1	This	this	DT
47658	510	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	510	3	simple	simple	JJ
47658	510	4	and	and	CC
47658	510	5	easy	easy	JJ
47658	510	6	to	to	TO
47658	510	7	understand	understand	VB
47658	510	8	.	.	.
47658	511	1	Now	now	RB
47658	511	2	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	511	3	that	that	IN
47658	511	4	both	both	CC
47658	511	5	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	511	6	and	and	CC
47658	511	7	the	the	DT
47658	511	8	observer	observer	NN
47658	511	9	were	be	VBD
47658	511	10	each	each	DT
47658	511	11	observing	observe	VBG
47658	511	12	a	a	DT
47658	511	13	natural	natural	JJ
47658	511	14	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
47658	511	15	,	,	,
47658	511	16	say	say	VBP
47658	511	17	a	a	DT
47658	511	18	thunder	thunder	NN
47658	511	19	-	-	HYPH
47658	511	20	storm	storm	NN
47658	511	21	,	,	,
47658	511	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	511	23	would	would	MD
47658	511	24	seem	seem	VB
47658	511	25	that	that	IN
47658	511	26	each	each	DT
47658	511	27	of	of	IN
47658	511	28	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	511	29	ought	ought	MD
47658	511	30	to	to	TO
47658	511	31	observe	observe	VB
47658	511	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	511	33	with	with	IN
47658	511	34	a	a	DT
47658	511	35	difference	difference	NN
47658	511	36	--	--	:
47658	511	37	a	a	DT
47658	511	38	difference	difference	NN
47658	511	39	strictly	strictly	RB
47658	511	40	calculable	calculable	JJ
47658	511	41	from	from	IN
47658	511	42	the	the	DT
47658	511	43	system	system	NN
47658	511	44	of	of	IN
47658	511	45	movement	movement	NN
47658	511	46	,	,	,
47658	511	47	the	the	DT
47658	511	48	ship	ship	NN
47658	511	49	,	,	,
47658	511	50	in	in	IN
47658	511	51	which	which	WDT
47658	511	52	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	511	53	were	be	VBD
47658	511	54	placed	place	VBN
47658	511	55	in	in	IN
47658	511	56	relation	relation	NN
47658	511	57	to	to	IN
47658	511	58	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	511	59	.	.	.
47658	512	1	The	the	DT
47658	512	2	propagation	propagation	NN
47658	512	3	of	of	IN
47658	512	4	the	the	DT
47658	512	5	sound	sound	NN
47658	512	6	and	and	CC
47658	512	7	of	of	IN
47658	512	8	the	the	DT
47658	512	9	light	light	NN
47658	512	10	would	would	MD
47658	512	11	have	have	VB
47658	512	12	to	to	TO
47658	512	13	undergo	undergo	VB
47658	512	14	a	a	DT
47658	512	15	correction	correction	NN
47658	512	16	if	if	IN
47658	512	17	each	each	DT
47658	512	18	of	of	IN
47658	512	19	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	512	20	described	describe	VBD
47658	512	21	your	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	512	22	experience	experience	NN
47658	512	23	to	to	IN
47658	512	24	the	the	DT
47658	512	25	other	other	JJ
47658	512	26	.	.	.
47658	513	1	If	if	IN
47658	513	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	3	were	be	VBD
47658	513	4	moving	move	VBG
47658	513	5	in	in	IN
47658	513	6	the	the	DT
47658	513	7	direction	direction	NN
47658	513	8	of	of	IN
47658	513	9	the	the	DT
47658	513	10	light	light	JJ
47658	513	11	waves	wave	NNS
47658	513	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	13	would	would	MD
47658	513	14	be	be	VB
47658	513	15	slower	slow	JJR
47658	513	16	for	for	IN
47658	513	17	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	18	than	than	IN
47658	513	19	for	for	IN
47658	513	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	21	,	,	,
47658	513	22	and	and	CC
47658	513	23	if	if	IN
47658	513	24	against	against	IN
47658	513	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	513	26	direction	direction	NN
47658	513	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	28	would	would	MD
47658	513	29	be	be	VB
47658	513	30	faster	fast	JJR
47658	513	31	for	for	IN
47658	513	32	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	33	than	than	IN
47658	513	34	for	for	IN
47658	513	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	513	36	.	.	.
47658	514	1	Of	of	RB
47658	514	2	course	course	RB
47658	514	3	the	the	DT
47658	514	4	immense	immense	JJ
47658	514	5	velocity	velocity	NN
47658	514	6	of	of	IN
47658	514	7	the	the	DT
47658	514	8	light	light	JJ
47658	514	9	waves	wave	NNS
47658	514	10	,	,	,
47658	514	11	about	about	RB
47658	514	12	200,000	200,000	CD
47658	514	13	miles	mile	NNS
47658	514	14	a	a	DT
47658	514	15	second	second	NN
47658	514	16	,	,	,
47658	514	17	would	would	MD
47658	514	18	make	make	VB
47658	514	19	the	the	DT
47658	514	20	difference	difference	NN
47658	514	21	in	in	IN
47658	514	22	a	a	DT
47658	514	23	movement	movement	NN
47658	514	24	of	of	IN
47658	514	25	four	four	CD
47658	514	26	miles	mile	NNS
47658	514	27	an	an	DT
47658	514	28	hour	hour	NN
47658	514	29	so	so	RB
47658	514	30	infinitesimal	infinitesimal	JJ
47658	514	31	as	as	IN
47658	514	32	to	to	TO
47658	514	33	be	be	VB
47658	514	34	altogether	altogether	RB
47658	514	35	inappreciable	inappreciable	JJ
47658	514	36	,	,	,
47658	514	37	but	but	CC
47658	514	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	514	39	would	would	MD
47658	514	40	not	not	RB
47658	514	41	be	be	VB
47658	514	42	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	514	43	,	,	,
47658	514	44	and	and	CC
47658	514	45	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	514	46	would	would	MD
47658	514	47	feel	feel	VB
47658	514	48	quite	quite	RB
47658	514	49	confident	confident	JJ
47658	514	50	that	that	IN
47658	514	51	if	if	IN
47658	514	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	514	53	could	could	MD
47658	514	54	be	be	VB
47658	514	55	measured	measure	VBN
47658	514	56	the	the	DT
47658	514	57	infinitesimal	infinitesimal	JJ
47658	514	58	quantity	quantity	NN
47658	514	59	would	would	MD
47658	514	60	appear	appear	VB
47658	514	61	in	in	IN
47658	514	62	the	the	DT
47658	514	63	result	result	NN
47658	514	64	.	.	.
47658	515	1	Now	now	RB
47658	515	2	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	515	3	that	that	IN
47658	515	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	515	5	could	could	MD
47658	515	6	measure	measure	VB
47658	515	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	515	8	with	with	IN
47658	515	9	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	515	10	accuracy	accuracy	NN
47658	515	11	,	,	,
47658	515	12	and	and	CC
47658	515	13	that	that	IN
47658	515	14	the	the	DT
47658	515	15	result	result	NN
47658	515	16	was	be	VBD
47658	515	17	the	the	DT
47658	515	18	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	515	19	that	that	IN
47658	515	20	the	the	DT
47658	515	21	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	515	22	difference	difference	NN
47658	515	23	did	do	VBD
47658	515	24	not	not	RB
47658	515	25	exist	exist	VB
47658	515	26	at	at	RB
47658	515	27	all	all	RB
47658	515	28	--	--	:
47658	515	29	and	and	CC
47658	515	30	of	of	IN
47658	515	31	course	course	NN
47658	515	32	,	,	,
47658	515	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	515	34	suppose	suppose	VBP
47658	515	35	that	that	IN
47658	515	36	there	there	EX
47658	515	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	515	38	no	no	DT
47658	515	39	doubt	doubt	RB
47658	515	40	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	515	41	about	about	IN
47658	515	42	the	the	DT
47658	515	43	measurement	measurement	NN
47658	515	44	--	--	:
47658	515	45	what	what	WP
47658	515	46	,	,	,
47658	515	47	then	then	RB
47658	515	48	,	,	,
47658	515	49	should	should	MD
47658	515	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	515	51	be	be	VB
47658	515	52	obliged	oblige	VBN
47658	515	53	to	to	TO
47658	515	54	think	think	VB
47658	515	55	?	?	.
47658	516	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	516	2	should	should	MD
47658	516	3	be	be	VB
47658	516	4	forced	force	VBN
47658	516	5	to	to	TO
47658	516	6	believe	believe	VB
47658	516	7	that	that	IN
47658	516	8	as	as	IN
47658	516	9	the	the	DT
47658	516	10	velocity	velocity	NN
47658	516	11	of	of	IN
47658	516	12	light	light	NN
47658	516	13	was	be	VBD
47658	516	14	the	the	DT
47658	516	15	same	same	JJ
47658	516	16	for	for	IN
47658	516	17	the	the	DT
47658	516	18	two	two	CD
47658	516	19	observers	observer	NNS
47658	516	20	,	,	,
47658	516	21	one	one	CD
47658	516	22	moving	move	VBG
47658	516	23	,	,	,
47658	516	24	one	one	CD
47658	516	25	at	at	IN
47658	516	26	rest	rest	NN
47658	516	27	,	,	,
47658	516	28	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	516	29	the	the	DT
47658	516	30	space	space	NN
47658	516	31	and	and	CC
47658	516	32	the	the	DT
47658	516	33	time	time	NN
47658	516	34	must	must	MD
47658	516	35	be	be	VB
47658	516	36	different	different	JJ
47658	516	37	for	for	IN
47658	516	38	each	each	DT
47658	516	39	.	.	.
47658	517	1	Now	now	RB
47658	517	2	,	,	,
47658	517	3	however	however	RB
47658	517	4	strange	strange	JJ
47658	517	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	517	6	may	may	MD
47658	517	7	seem	seem	VB
47658	517	8	,	,	,
47658	517	9	such	such	PDT
47658	517	10	a	a	DT
47658	517	11	measurement	measurement	NN
47658	517	12	has	have	VBZ
47658	517	13	been	be	VBN
47658	517	14	made	make	VBN
47658	517	15	,	,	,
47658	517	16	and	and	CC
47658	517	17	with	with	IN
47658	517	18	this	this	DT
47658	517	19	surprising	surprising	JJ
47658	517	20	result	result	NN
47658	517	21	.	.	.
47658	518	1	In	in	IN
47658	518	2	consequence	consequence	NN
47658	518	3	there	there	EX
47658	518	4	has	have	VBZ
47658	518	5	been	be	VBN
47658	518	6	formulated	formulate	VBN
47658	518	7	a	a	DT
47658	518	8	new	new	JJ
47658	518	9	principle	principle	NN
47658	518	10	in	in	IN
47658	518	11	Physics	Physics	NNP
47658	518	12	named	name	VBD
47658	518	13	the	the	DT
47658	518	14	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	518	15	of	of	IN
47658	518	16	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	518	17	.	.	.
47658	519	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	519	2	take	take	VBP
47658	519	3	this	this	DT
47658	519	4	Principle	principle	NN
47658	519	5	of	of	IN
47658	519	6	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	519	7	for	for	IN
47658	519	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	519	9	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	519	10	because	because	IN
47658	519	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	519	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	519	13	based	base	VBN
47658	519	14	on	on	IN
47658	519	15	reasoning	reason	VBG
47658	519	16	that	that	IN
47658	519	17	practically	practically	RB
47658	519	18	admits	admit	NNS
47658	519	19	of	of	IN
47658	519	20	no	no	DT
47658	519	21	doubt	doubt	NN
47658	519	22	,	,	,
47658	519	23	and	and	CC
47658	519	24	because	because	IN
47658	519	25	{	{	-LRB-
47658	519	26	50	50	CD
47658	519	27	}	}	-RRB-
47658	519	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	519	29	requires	require	VBZ
47658	519	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	519	31	to	to	TO
47658	519	32	form	form	VB
47658	519	33	new	new	JJ
47658	519	34	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	519	35	of	of	IN
47658	519	36	space	space	NN
47658	519	37	and	and	CC
47658	519	38	time	time	NN
47658	519	39	which	which	WDT
47658	519	40	seem	seem	VBP
47658	519	41	to	to	TO
47658	519	42	alter	alter	VB
47658	519	43	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
47658	519	44	what	what	WP
47658	519	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	519	46	have	have	VBP
47658	519	47	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
47658	519	48	considered	consider	VBN
47658	519	49	as	as	IN
47658	519	50	the	the	DT
47658	519	51	evident	evident	JJ
47658	519	52	and	and	CC
47658	519	53	unmistakable	unmistakable	JJ
47658	519	54	nature	nature	NN
47658	519	55	of	of	IN
47658	519	56	those	those	DT
47658	519	57	realities	reality	NNS
47658	519	58	.	.	.
47658	520	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	520	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	520	3	always	always	RB
47658	520	4	seemed	seem	VBN
47658	520	5	that	that	IN
47658	520	6	the	the	DT
47658	520	7	distance	distance	NN
47658	520	8	separating	separate	VBG
47658	520	9	two	two	CD
47658	520	10	points	point	NNS
47658	520	11	,	,	,
47658	520	12	and	and	CC
47658	520	13	the	the	DT
47658	520	14	interval	interval	NN
47658	520	15	of	of	IN
47658	520	16	time	time	NN
47658	520	17	separating	separate	VBG
47658	520	18	two	two	CD
47658	520	19	events	event	NNS
47658	520	20	,	,	,
47658	520	21	were	be	VBD
47658	520	22	each	each	DT
47658	520	23	independent	independent	JJ
47658	520	24	of	of	IN
47658	520	25	the	the	DT
47658	520	26	other	other	JJ
47658	520	27	and	and	CC
47658	520	28	each	each	DT
47658	520	29	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	520	30	.	.	.
47658	521	1	However	however	WRB
47658	521	2	different	different	JJ
47658	521	3	the	the	DT
47658	521	4	distance	distance	NN
47658	521	5	and	and	CC
47658	521	6	the	the	DT
47658	521	7	interval	interval	NN
47658	521	8	may	may	MD
47658	521	9	appear	appear	VB
47658	521	10	to	to	IN
47658	521	11	observers	observer	NNS
47658	521	12	in	in	IN
47658	521	13	movement	movement	NN
47658	521	14	or	or	CC
47658	521	15	to	to	IN
47658	521	16	observers	observer	NNS
47658	521	17	in	in	IN
47658	521	18	different	different	JJ
47658	521	19	systems	system	NNS
47658	521	20	of	of	IN
47658	521	21	movement	movement	NN
47658	521	22	in	in	IN
47658	521	23	relation	relation	NN
47658	521	24	to	to	IN
47658	521	25	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	521	26	and	and	CC
47658	521	27	to	to	IN
47658	521	28	one	one	CD
47658	521	29	another	another	DT
47658	521	30	,	,	,
47658	521	31	in	in	IN
47658	521	32	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	521	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	521	34	are	be	VBP
47658	521	35	the	the	DT
47658	521	36	same	same	JJ
47658	521	37	distance	distance	NN
47658	521	38	and	and	CC
47658	521	39	the	the	DT
47658	521	40	same	same	JJ
47658	521	41	interval	interval	NN
47658	521	42	for	for	IN
47658	521	43	all	all	DT
47658	521	44	.	.	.
47658	522	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
47658	522	2	are	be	VBP
47658	522	3	the	the	DT
47658	522	4	same	same	JJ
47658	522	5	for	for	IN
47658	522	6	the	the	DT
47658	522	7	man	man	NN
47658	522	8	in	in	IN
47658	522	9	the	the	DT
47658	522	10	express	express	JJ
47658	522	11	train	train	NN
47658	522	12	as	as	IN
47658	522	13	for	for	IN
47658	522	14	the	the	DT
47658	522	15	man	man	NN
47658	522	16	standing	stand	VBG
47658	522	17	on	on	IN
47658	522	18	the	the	DT
47658	522	19	station	station	NN
47658	522	20	platform	platform	NN
47658	522	21	.	.	.
47658	523	1	The	the	DT
47658	523	2	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	523	3	of	of	IN
47658	523	4	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	523	5	requires	require	VBZ
47658	523	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	523	7	to	to	TO
47658	523	8	think	think	VB
47658	523	9	that	that	IN
47658	523	10	this	this	DT
47658	523	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	523	12	not	not	RB
47658	523	13	so	so	RB
47658	523	14	,	,	,
47658	523	15	but	but	CC
47658	523	16	that	that	IN
47658	523	17	,	,	,
47658	523	18	contrary	contrary	JJ
47658	523	19	to	to	IN
47658	523	20	all	all	DT
47658	523	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	523	22	settled	settled	JJ
47658	523	23	notions	notion	NNS
47658	523	24	,	,	,
47658	523	25	the	the	DT
47658	523	26	actual	actual	JJ
47658	523	27	space	space	NN
47658	523	28	and	and	CC
47658	523	29	time	time	NN
47658	523	30	vary	vary	VBP
47658	523	31	--	--	:
47658	523	32	really	really	RB
47658	523	33	undergo	undergo	VB
47658	523	34	an	an	DT
47658	523	35	alteration	alteration	NN
47658	523	36	,	,	,
47658	523	37	a	a	DT
47658	523	38	contraction	contraction	NN
47658	523	39	or	or	CC
47658	523	40	expansion	expansion	NN
47658	523	41	--	--	:
47658	523	42	with	with	IN
47658	523	43	each	each	DT
47658	523	44	different	different	JJ
47658	523	45	system	system	NN
47658	523	46	of	of	IN
47658	523	47	movement	movement	NN
47658	523	48	of	of	IN
47658	523	49	translation	translation	NN
47658	523	50	to	to	TO
47658	523	51	which	which	WDT
47658	523	52	the	the	DT
47658	523	53	observer	observer	NN
47658	523	54	is	be	VBZ
47658	523	55	bound	bind	VBN
47658	523	56	.	.	.
47658	524	1	Events	event	NNS
47658	524	2	that	that	WDT
47658	524	3	for	for	IN
47658	524	4	an	an	DT
47658	524	5	observer	observer	NN
47658	524	6	belonging	belong	VBG
47658	524	7	to	to	IN
47658	524	8	one	one	CD
47658	524	9	system	system	NN
47658	524	10	of	of	IN
47658	524	11	movement	movement	NN
47658	524	12	happen	happen	VB
47658	524	13	in	in	IN
47658	524	14	the	the	DT
47658	524	15	same	same	JJ
47658	524	16	place	place	NN
47658	524	17	,	,	,
47658	524	18	for	for	IN
47658	524	19	another	another	DT
47658	524	20	observer	observer	NN
47658	524	21	in	in	IN
47658	524	22	a	a	DT
47658	524	23	different	different	JJ
47658	524	24	system	system	NN
47658	524	25	of	of	IN
47658	524	26	movement	movement	NN
47658	524	27	happen	happen	VB
47658	524	28	in	in	IN
47658	524	29	different	different	JJ
47658	524	30	places	place	NNS
47658	524	31	.	.	.
47658	525	1	Events	event	NNS
47658	525	2	that	that	IN
47658	525	3	for	for	IN
47658	525	4	one	one	CD
47658	525	5	observer	observer	NN
47658	525	6	happen	happen	VB
47658	525	7	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
47658	525	8	,	,	,
47658	525	9	for	for	IN
47658	525	10	other	other	JJ
47658	525	11	observers	observer	NNS
47658	525	12	are	be	VBP
47658	525	13	separated	separate	VBN
47658	525	14	by	by	IN
47658	525	15	a	a	DT
47658	525	16	time	time	NN
47658	525	17	interval	interval	NN
47658	525	18	according	accord	VBG
47658	525	19	to	to	IN
47658	525	20	the	the	DT
47658	525	21	movement	movement	NN
47658	525	22	of	of	IN
47658	525	23	translation	translation	NN
47658	525	24	of	of	IN
47658	525	25	the	the	DT
47658	525	26	system	system	NN
47658	525	27	to	to	TO
47658	525	28	which	which	WDT
47658	525	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	525	30	belong	belong	VBP
47658	525	31	.	.	.
47658	526	1	So	so	RB
47658	526	2	that	that	DT
47658	526	3	space	space	NN
47658	526	4	,	,	,
47658	526	5	which	which	WDT
47658	526	6	Newton	Newton	NNP
47658	526	7	described	describe	VBD
47658	526	8	as	as	IN
47658	526	9	rigid	rigid	JJ
47658	526	10	,	,	,
47658	526	11	and	and	CC
47658	526	12	time	time	NN
47658	526	13	which	which	WDT
47658	526	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	526	15	described	describe	VBD
47658	526	16	as	as	IN
47658	526	17	flowing	flow	VBG
47658	526	18	at	at	IN
47658	526	19	a	a	DT
47658	526	20	constant	constant	JJ
47658	526	21	rate	rate	NN
47658	526	22	,	,	,
47658	526	23	and	and	CC
47658	526	24	which	which	WDT
47658	526	25	for	for	IN
47658	526	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	526	27	was	be	VBD
47658	526	28	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	526	29	,	,	,
47658	526	30	are	be	VBP
47658	526	31	for	for	IN
47658	526	32	the	the	DT
47658	526	33	new	new	JJ
47658	526	34	theory	theory	NN
47658	526	35	relative	relative	JJ
47658	526	36	,	,	,
47658	526	37	different	different	JJ
47658	526	38	for	for	IN
47658	526	39	an	an	DT
47658	526	40	observer	observer	NN
47658	526	41	in	in	IN
47658	526	42	every	every	DT
47658	526	43	different	different	JJ
47658	526	44	system	system	NN
47658	526	45	of	of	IN
47658	526	46	movement	movement	NN
47658	526	47	of	of	IN
47658	526	48	translation	translation	NN
47658	526	49	.	.	.
47658	527	1	Or	or	CC
47658	527	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	527	3	may	may	MD
47658	527	4	state	state	VB
47658	527	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	527	6	in	in	IN
47658	527	7	the	the	DT
47658	527	8	opposite	opposite	JJ
47658	527	9	way	way	NN
47658	527	10	,	,	,
47658	527	11	and	and	CC
47658	527	12	say	say	VB
47658	527	13	that	that	IN
47658	527	14	the	the	DT
47658	527	15	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	527	16	of	of	IN
47658	527	17	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	527	18	shows	show	VBZ
47658	527	19	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	527	20	that	that	IN
47658	527	21	the	the	DT
47658	527	22	reason	reason	NN
47658	527	23	why	why	WRB
47658	527	24	natural	natural	JJ
47658	527	25	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
47658	527	26	,	,	,
47658	527	27	such	such	JJ
47658	527	28	as	as	IN
47658	527	29	the	the	DT
47658	527	30	rate	rate	NN
47658	527	31	of	of	IN
47658	527	32	propagation	propagation	NN
47658	527	33	of	of	IN
47658	527	34	light	light	NN
47658	527	35	,	,	,
47658	527	36	undergo	undergo	VBP
47658	527	37	no	no	DT
47658	527	38	alteration	alteration	NN
47658	527	39	when	when	WRB
47658	527	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	527	41	pass	pass	VBP
47658	527	42	from	from	IN
47658	527	43	one	one	CD
47658	527	44	system	system	NN
47658	527	45	of	of	IN
47658	527	46	movement	movement	NN
47658	527	47	of	of	IN
47658	527	48	translation	translation	NN
47658	527	49	to	to	IN
47658	527	50	another	another	DT
47658	527	51	,	,	,
47658	527	52	as	as	IN
47658	527	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	527	54	{	{	-LRB-
47658	527	55	51	51	CD
47658	527	56	}	}	-RRB-
47658	527	57	are	be	VBP
47658	527	58	constantly	constantly	RB
47658	527	59	doing	do	VBG
47658	527	60	in	in	IN
47658	527	61	the	the	DT
47658	527	62	changing	change	VBG
47658	527	63	velocity	velocity	NN
47658	527	64	of	of	IN
47658	527	65	the	the	DT
47658	527	66	earth	earth	NN
47658	527	67	's	's	POS
47658	527	68	movement	movement	NN
47658	527	69	round	round	IN
47658	527	70	the	the	DT
47658	527	71	sun	sun	NN
47658	527	72	,	,	,
47658	527	73	is	be	VBZ
47658	527	74	that	that	DT
47658	527	75	space	space	NN
47658	527	76	and	and	CC
47658	527	77	time	time	NN
47658	527	78	alter	alter	NN
47658	527	79	with	with	IN
47658	527	80	the	the	DT
47658	527	81	velocity	velocity	NN
47658	527	82	.	.	.
47658	528	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	528	2	can	can	MD
47658	528	3	not	not	RB
47658	528	4	here	here	RB
47658	528	5	give	give	VB
47658	528	6	the	the	DT
47658	528	7	argument	argument	NN
47658	528	8	or	or	CC
47658	528	9	describe	describe	VB
47658	528	10	the	the	DT
47658	528	11	experiments	experiment	NNS
47658	528	12	which	which	WDT
47658	528	13	have	have	VBP
47658	528	14	given	give	VBN
47658	528	15	this	this	DT
47658	528	16	result	result	NN
47658	528	17	--	--	:
47658	528	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	528	19	am	be	VBP
47658	528	20	simply	simply	RB
47658	528	21	taking	take	VBG
47658	528	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	528	23	as	as	IN
47658	528	24	an	an	DT
47658	528	25	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	528	26	.	.	.
47658	529	1	[	[	-LRB-
47658	529	2	1	1	CD
47658	529	3	]	]	-RRB-
47658	529	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	529	5	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	529	6	to	to	IN
47658	529	7	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	529	8	admirably	admirably	RB
47658	529	9	suited	suited	JJ
47658	529	10	to	to	TO
47658	529	11	compare	compare	VB
47658	529	12	the	the	DT
47658	529	13	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	529	14	method	method	NN
47658	529	15	and	and	CC
47658	529	16	the	the	DT
47658	529	17	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	529	18	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	529	19	with	with	IN
47658	529	20	that	that	DT
47658	529	21	of	of	IN
47658	529	22	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	529	23	realism	realism	NN
47658	529	24	and	and	CC
47658	529	25	of	of	IN
47658	529	26	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	529	27	idealism	idealism	NN
47658	529	28	.	.	.
47658	530	1	[	[	-LRB-
47658	530	2	1	1	LS
47658	530	3	]	]	-RRB-
47658	530	4	The	the	DT
47658	530	5	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	530	6	of	of	IN
47658	530	7	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	530	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	530	9	mainly	mainly	RB
47658	530	10	the	the	DT
47658	530	11	result	result	NN
47658	530	12	of	of	IN
47658	530	13	the	the	DT
47658	530	14	recent	recent	JJ
47658	530	15	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
47658	530	16	work	work	NN
47658	530	17	of	of	IN
47658	530	18	H.	H.	NNP
47658	530	19	A.	A.	NNP
47658	530	20	Lorentz	Lorentz	NNP
47658	530	21	,	,	,
47658	530	22	Einstein	Einstein	NNP
47658	530	23	,	,	,
47658	530	24	and	and	CC
47658	530	25	the	the	DT
47658	530	26	late	late	JJ
47658	530	27	Professor	Professor	NNP
47658	530	28	Minkowski	Minkowski	NNP
47658	530	29	.	.	.
47658	531	1	A	a	DT
47658	531	2	very	very	RB
47658	531	3	interesting	interesting	JJ
47658	531	4	and	and	CC
47658	531	5	not	not	RB
47658	531	6	excessively	excessively	RB
47658	531	7	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	531	8	,	,	,
47658	531	9	account	account	NN
47658	531	10	of	of	IN
47658	531	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	531	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	531	13	contained	contain	VBN
47658	531	14	in	in	IN
47658	531	15	_	_	NNP
47658	531	16	Dernières	Dernières	NNPS
47658	531	17	Pensées	Pensées	NNP
47658	531	18	_	_	NNP
47658	531	19	,	,	,
47658	531	20	by	by	IN
47658	531	21	the	the	DT
47658	531	22	late	late	JJ
47658	531	23	Henri	Henri	NNP
47658	531	24	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
47658	531	25	;	;	:
47658	531	26	Paris	Paris	NNP
47658	531	27	,	,	,
47658	531	28	Alcan	Alcan	NNP
47658	531	29	.	.	.
47658	532	1	Here	here	RB
47658	532	2	,	,	,
47658	532	3	then	then	RB
47658	532	4	,	,	,
47658	532	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	532	6	a	a	DT
47658	532	7	question	question	NN
47658	532	8	in	in	IN
47658	532	9	which	which	WDT
47658	532	10	the	the	DT
47658	532	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	532	12	of	of	IN
47658	532	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	532	14	accepted	accepted	JJ
47658	532	15	notions	notion	NNS
47658	532	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	532	17	called	call	VBN
47658	532	18	in	in	IN
47658	532	19	question	question	NN
47658	532	20	,	,	,
47658	532	21	and	and	CC
47658	532	22	new	new	JJ
47658	532	23	notions	notion	NNS
47658	532	24	claim	claim	VBP
47658	532	25	to	to	TO
47658	532	26	be	be	VB
47658	532	27	true	true	JJ
47658	532	28	.	.	.
47658	533	1	The	the	DT
47658	533	2	sole	sole	JJ
47658	533	3	question	question	NN
47658	533	4	involved	involve	VBN
47658	533	5	,	,	,
47658	533	6	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	533	7	insists	insist	NNS
47658	533	8	,	,	,
47658	533	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	533	10	the	the	DT
47658	533	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	533	12	of	of	IN
47658	533	13	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	533	14	,	,	,
47658	533	15	not	not	RB
47658	533	16	the	the	DT
47658	533	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	533	18	of	of	IN
47658	533	19	things	thing	NNS
47658	533	20	,	,	,
47658	533	21	and	and	CC
47658	533	22	there	there	EX
47658	533	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	533	24	but	but	CC
47658	533	25	one	one	CD
47658	533	26	way	way	NN
47658	533	27	of	of	IN
47658	533	28	testing	test	VBG
47658	533	29	the	the	DT
47658	533	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	533	31	of	of	IN
47658	533	32	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	533	33	--	--	:
47658	533	34	and	and	CC
47658	533	35	that	that	DT
47658	533	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	533	37	by	by	IN
47658	533	38	comparing	compare	VBG
47658	533	39	the	the	DT
47658	533	40	rival	rival	JJ
47658	533	41	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	533	42	in	in	IN
47658	533	43	respect	respect	NN
47658	533	44	of	of	IN
47658	533	45	the	the	DT
47658	533	46	practical	practical	JJ
47658	533	47	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	533	48	that	that	WDT
47658	533	49	follow	follow	VBP
47658	533	50	from	from	IN
47658	533	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	533	52	and	and	CC
47658	533	53	adopting	adopt	VBG
47658	533	54	those	those	DT
47658	533	55	that	that	WDT
47658	533	56	will	will	MD
47658	533	57	work	work	VB
47658	533	58	.	.	.
47658	534	1	If	if	IN
47658	534	2	the	the	DT
47658	534	3	old	old	JJ
47658	534	4	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	534	5	of	of	IN
47658	534	6	space	space	NN
47658	534	7	and	and	CC
47658	534	8	time	time	NN
47658	534	9	fail	fail	VBP
47658	534	10	to	to	TO
47658	534	11	conform	conform	VB
47658	534	12	to	to	IN
47658	534	13	a	a	DT
47658	534	14	new	new	JJ
47658	534	15	need	need	NN
47658	534	16	,	,	,
47658	534	17	then	then	RB
47658	534	18	what	what	WP
47658	534	19	was	be	VBD
47658	534	20	true	true	JJ
47658	534	21	before	before	IN
47658	534	22	the	the	DT
47658	534	23	need	need	NN
47658	534	24	was	be	VBD
47658	534	25	revealed	reveal	VBN
47658	534	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	534	27	no	no	DT
47658	534	28	longer	long	RBR
47658	534	29	true	true	JJ
47658	534	30	,	,	,
47658	534	31	the	the	DT
47658	534	32	new	new	JJ
47658	534	33	conception	conception	NN
47658	534	34	has	have	VBZ
47658	534	35	become	become	VBN
47658	534	36	true	true	JJ
47658	534	37	.	.	.
47658	535	1	By	by	IN
47658	535	2	verifying	verify	VBG
47658	535	3	the	the	DT
47658	535	4	new	new	JJ
47658	535	5	conception	conception	NN
47658	535	6	,	,	,
47658	535	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	535	8	make	make	VBP
47658	535	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	535	10	true	true	JJ
47658	535	11	.	.	.
47658	536	1	But	but	CC
47658	536	2	,	,	,
47658	536	3	objects	object	VBZ
47658	536	4	the	the	DT
47658	536	5	realist	realist	NN
47658	536	6	,	,	,
47658	536	7	an	an	DT
47658	536	8	idea	idea	NN
47658	536	9	can	can	MD
47658	536	10	not	not	RB
47658	536	11	become	become	VB
47658	536	12	true	true	JJ
47658	536	13	;	;	:
47658	536	14	what	what	WP
47658	536	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	536	16	now	now	RB
47658	536	17	true	true	JJ
47658	536	18	always	always	RB
47658	536	19	was	be	VBD
47658	536	20	true	true	JJ
47658	536	21	,	,	,
47658	536	22	and	and	CC
47658	536	23	what	what	WP
47658	536	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	536	25	no	no	DT
47658	536	26	longer	long	RBR
47658	536	27	true	true	JJ
47658	536	28	never	never	RB
47658	536	29	was	be	VBD
47658	536	30	true	true	JJ
47658	536	31	,	,	,
47658	536	32	though	though	IN
47658	536	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	536	34	may	may	MD
47658	536	35	have	have	VB
47658	536	36	worked	work	VBN
47658	536	37	with	with	IN
47658	536	38	the	the	DT
47658	536	39	false	false	JJ
47658	536	40	notion	notion	NN
47658	536	41	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
47658	536	42	that	that	IN
47658	536	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	536	44	was	be	VBD
47658	536	45	false	false	JJ
47658	536	46	.	.	.
47658	537	1	Behind	behind	IN
47658	537	2	truth	truth	NN
47658	537	3	there	there	EX
47658	537	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	537	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	537	6	.	.	.
47658	538	1	The	the	DT
47658	538	2	earth	earth	NN
47658	538	3	was	be	VBD
47658	538	4	spherical	spherical	JJ
47658	538	5	even	even	RB
47658	538	6	when	when	WRB
47658	538	7	all	all	DT
47658	538	8	mankind	mankind	NN
47658	538	9	believed	believe	VBD
47658	538	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	538	11	flat	flat	JJ
47658	538	12	and	and	CC
47658	538	13	found	find	VBD
47658	538	14	the	the	DT
47658	538	15	belief	belief	NN
47658	538	16	work	work	NN
47658	538	17	.	.	.
47658	539	1	To	to	IN
47658	539	2	this	this	DT
47658	539	3	the	the	DT
47658	539	4	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	539	5	reply	reply	NN
47658	539	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	539	7	that	that	IN
47658	539	8	reality	reality	NN
47658	539	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	539	10	only	only	RB
47658	539	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	539	12	objectification	objectification	NN
47658	539	13	of	of	IN
47658	539	14	truth	truth	NN
47658	539	15	;	;	:
47658	539	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	539	17	possesses	possess	VBZ
47658	539	18	no	no	DT
47658	539	19	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	539	20	divorced	divorce	VBN
47658	539	21	from	from	IN
47658	539	22	human	human	JJ
47658	539	23	purposes	purpose	NNS
47658	539	24	.	.	.
47658	540	1	Had	have	VBD
47658	540	2	anyone	anyone	NN
47658	540	3	announced	announce	VBN
47658	540	4	that	that	IN
47658	540	5	the	the	DT
47658	540	6	earth	earth	NN
47658	540	7	was	be	VBD
47658	540	8	a	a	DT
47658	540	9	sphere	sphere	NN
47658	540	10	{	{	-LRB-
47658	540	11	52	52	CD
47658	540	12	}	}	-RRB-
47658	540	13	when	when	WRB
47658	540	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	540	15	was	be	VBD
47658	540	16	generally	generally	RB
47658	540	17	held	hold	VBN
47658	540	18	to	to	TO
47658	540	19	be	be	VB
47658	540	20	flat	flat	JJ
47658	540	21	,	,	,
47658	540	22	unless	unless	IN
47658	540	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	540	24	announcement	announcement	NN
47658	540	25	had	have	VBD
47658	540	26	some	some	DT
47658	540	27	relevance	relevance	NN
47658	540	28	to	to	IN
47658	540	29	a	a	DT
47658	540	30	defect	defect	NN
47658	540	31	in	in	IN
47658	540	32	the	the	DT
47658	540	33	flat	flat	JJ
47658	540	34	earth	earth	NN
47658	540	35	notion	notion	NN
47658	540	36	,	,	,
47658	540	37	or	or	CC
47658	540	38	a	a	DT
47658	540	39	claim	claim	NN
47658	540	40	to	to	TO
47658	540	41	revise	revise	VB
47658	540	42	that	that	DT
47658	540	43	notion	notion	NN
47658	540	44	,	,	,
47658	540	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	540	46	announcement	announcement	NN
47658	540	47	would	would	MD
47658	540	48	have	have	VB
47658	540	49	been	be	VBN
47658	540	50	neither	neither	CC
47658	540	51	a	a	DT
47658	540	52	truth	truth	NN
47658	540	53	nor	nor	CC
47658	540	54	a	a	DT
47658	540	55	falsehood	falsehood	NN
47658	540	56	in	in	IN
47658	540	57	any	any	DT
47658	540	58	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
47658	540	59	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	540	60	of	of	IN
47658	540	61	the	the	DT
47658	540	62	term	term	NN
47658	540	63	--	--	:
47658	540	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	540	65	would	would	MD
47658	540	66	have	have	VB
47658	540	67	been	be	VBN
47658	540	68	making	make	VBG
47658	540	69	an	an	DT
47658	540	70	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	540	71	remark	remark	NN
47658	540	72	.	.	.
47658	541	1	The	the	DT
47658	541	2	notions	notion	NNS
47658	541	3	of	of	IN
47658	541	4	space	space	NN
47658	541	5	and	and	CC
47658	541	6	time	time	NN
47658	541	7	that	that	WDT
47658	541	8	Newton	Newton	NNP
47658	541	9	held	hold	VBD
47658	541	10	worked	work	VBD
47658	541	11	,	,	,
47658	541	12	and	and	CC
47658	541	13	were	be	VBD
47658	541	14	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	541	15	true	true	JJ
47658	541	16	;	;	:
47658	541	17	if	if	IN
47658	541	18	a	a	DT
47658	541	19	new	new	JJ
47658	541	20	need	need	NN
47658	541	21	requires	require	VBZ
47658	541	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	541	23	to	to	TO
47658	541	24	replace	replace	VB
47658	541	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	541	26	with	with	IN
47658	541	27	other	other	JJ
47658	541	28	notions	notion	NNS
47658	541	29	,	,	,
47658	541	30	and	and	CC
47658	541	31	these	these	DT
47658	541	32	other	other	JJ
47658	541	33	notions	notion	NNS
47658	541	34	will	will	MD
47658	541	35	work	work	VB
47658	541	36	and	and	CC
47658	541	37	are	be	VBP
47658	541	38	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	541	39	true	true	JJ
47658	541	40	,	,	,
47658	541	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	541	42	have	have	VBP
47658	541	43	become	become	VBN
47658	541	44	true	true	JJ
47658	541	45	and	and	CC
47658	541	46	Newton	Newton	NNP
47658	541	47	's	's	POS
47658	541	48	notions	notion	NNS
47658	541	49	have	have	VBP
47658	541	50	become	become	VBN
47658	541	51	false	false	JJ
47658	541	52	.	.	.
47658	542	1	If	if	IN
47658	542	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	542	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	542	4	still	still	RB
47658	542	5	objected	object	VBN
47658	542	6	that	that	IN
47658	542	7	the	the	DT
47658	542	8	new	new	JJ
47658	542	9	notions	notion	NNS
47658	542	10	were	be	VBD
47658	542	11	also	also	RB
47658	542	12	true	true	JJ
47658	542	13	for	for	IN
47658	542	14	Newton	Newton	NNP
47658	542	15	,	,	,
47658	542	16	although	although	IN
47658	542	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	542	18	was	be	VBD
47658	542	19	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
47658	542	20	of	of	IN
47658	542	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	542	22	,	,	,
47658	542	23	the	the	DT
47658	542	24	need	need	NN
47658	542	25	for	for	IN
47658	542	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	542	27	not	not	RB
47658	542	28	having	have	VBG
47658	542	29	arisen	arise	VBN
47658	542	30	,	,	,
47658	542	31	the	the	DT
47658	542	32	only	only	JJ
47658	542	33	reply	reply	NN
47658	542	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	542	35	that	that	DT
47658	542	36	truth	truth	NN
47658	542	37	,	,	,
47658	542	38	or	or	CC
47658	542	39	reality	reality	NN
47658	542	40	,	,	,
47658	542	41	in	in	IN
47658	542	42	complete	complete	JJ
47658	542	43	detachment	detachment	NN
47658	542	44	from	from	IN
47658	542	45	human	human	JJ
47658	542	46	purposes	purpose	NNS
47658	542	47	,	,	,
47658	542	48	can	can	MD
47658	542	49	not	not	RB
47658	542	50	be	be	VB
47658	542	51	either	either	CC
47658	542	52	affirmed	affirm	VBN
47658	542	53	or	or	CC
47658	542	54	denied	deny	VBN
47658	542	55	.	.	.
47658	543	1	With	with	IN
47658	543	2	this	this	DT
47658	543	3	view	view	NN
47658	543	4	the	the	DT
47658	543	5	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	543	6	will	will	MD
47658	543	7	be	be	VB
47658	543	8	in	in	IN
47658	543	9	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	543	10	;	;	:
47658	543	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	543	12	objection	objection	NN
47658	543	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	543	14	of	of	IN
47658	543	15	a	a	DT
47658	543	16	different	different	JJ
47658	543	17	kind	kind	NN
47658	543	18	.	.	.
47658	544	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	544	2	rejects	reject	VBZ
47658	544	3	,	,	,
47658	544	4	as	as	IN
47658	544	5	the	the	DT
47658	544	6	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	544	7	does	do	VBZ
47658	544	8	,	,	,
47658	544	9	the	the	DT
47658	544	10	notion	notion	NN
47658	544	11	of	of	IN
47658	544	12	a	a	DT
47658	544	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	544	14	independent	independent	JJ
47658	544	15	of	of	IN
47658	544	16	human	human	JJ
47658	544	17	nature	nature	NN
47658	544	18	that	that	WDT
47658	544	19	forces	force	VBZ
47658	544	20	upon	upon	IN
47658	544	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	544	22	the	the	DT
47658	544	23	changes	change	NNS
47658	544	24	that	that	WDT
47658	544	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	544	26	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	544	27	undergo	undergo	VBP
47658	544	28	.	.	.
47658	545	1	These	these	DT
47658	545	2	changes	change	NNS
47658	545	3	,	,	,
47658	545	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	545	5	holds	hold	VBZ
47658	545	6	,	,	,
47658	545	7	are	be	VBP
47658	545	8	the	the	DT
47658	545	9	inner	inner	JJ
47658	545	10	working	working	NN
47658	545	11	of	of	IN
47658	545	12	the	the	DT
47658	545	13	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	545	14	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	545	15	,	,	,
47658	545	16	the	the	DT
47658	545	17	manifestation	manifestation	NN
47658	545	18	of	of	IN
47658	545	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	545	20	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	545	21	nature	nature	NN
47658	545	22	,	,	,
47658	545	23	ever	ever	RB
47658	545	24	striving	strive	VBG
47658	545	25	for	for	IN
47658	545	26	an	an	DT
47658	545	27	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	545	28	of	of	IN
47658	545	29	logical	logical	JJ
47658	545	30	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	545	31	.	.	.
47658	546	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	546	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	546	3	this	this	DT
47658	546	4	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	546	5	.	.	.
47658	547	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	547	2	do	do	VBP
47658	547	3	not	not	RB
47658	547	4	make	make	VB
47658	547	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	547	6	;	;	:
47658	547	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	547	8	move	move	VBP
47658	547	9	towards	towards	IN
47658	547	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	547	11	.	.	.
47658	548	1	If	if	IN
47658	548	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	548	3	compare	compare	VBP
47658	548	4	,	,	,
47658	548	5	then	then	RB
47658	548	6	,	,	,
47658	548	7	the	the	DT
47658	548	8	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	548	9	and	and	CC
47658	548	10	the	the	DT
47658	548	11	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	548	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	548	13	,	,	,
47658	548	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	548	15	will	will	MD
47658	548	16	seem	seem	VB
47658	548	17	that	that	IN
47658	548	18	,	,	,
47658	548	19	while	while	IN
47658	548	20	for	for	IN
47658	548	21	the	the	DT
47658	548	22	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	548	23	truth	truth	NN
47658	548	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	548	25	growing	grow	VBG
47658	548	26	with	with	IN
47658	548	27	advancing	advance	VBG
47658	548	28	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	548	29	into	into	IN
47658	548	30	an	an	DT
47658	548	31	ever	ever	RB
47658	548	32	larger	large	JJR
47658	548	33	because	because	IN
47658	548	34	more	more	RBR
47658	548	35	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
47658	548	36	system	system	NN
47658	548	37	of	of	IN
47658	548	38	reality	reality	NN
47658	548	39	,	,	,
47658	548	40	for	for	IN
47658	548	41	the	the	DT
47658	548	42	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	548	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	548	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	548	45	ever	ever	RB
47658	548	46	narrowing	narrow	VBG
47658	548	47	,	,	,
47658	548	48	discarding	discard	VBG
47658	548	49	failures	failure	NNS
47658	548	50	as	as	IN
47658	548	51	useless	useless	JJ
47658	548	52	and	and	CC
47658	548	53	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	548	54	to	to	TO
47658	548	55	present	present	VB
47658	548	56	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	548	57	.	.	.
47658	549	1	How	how	WRB
47658	549	2	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	549	3	,	,	,
47658	549	4	the	the	DT
47658	549	5	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	549	6	will	will	MD
47658	549	7	ask	ask	VB
47658	549	8	,	,	,
47658	549	9	if	if	IN
47658	549	10	practical	practical	JJ
47658	549	11	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	549	12	be	be	VBP
47658	549	13	the	the	DT
47658	549	14	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	549	15	of	of	IN
47658	549	16	truth	truth	NN
47658	549	17	,	,	,
47658	549	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	549	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	549	20	possible	possible	JJ
47658	549	21	to	to	TO
47658	549	22	understand	understand	VB
47658	549	23	that	that	IN
47658	549	24	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	549	25	has	have	VBZ
47658	549	26	advanced	advance	VBN
47658	549	27	or	or	CC
47658	549	28	can	can	MD
47658	549	29	advance	advance	VB
47658	549	30	?	?	.
47658	550	1	Does	do	VBZ
47658	550	2	not	not	RB
47658	550	3	the	the	DT
47658	550	4	history	history	NN
47658	550	5	of	of	IN
47658	550	6	science	science	NN
47658	550	7	prove	prove	VBP
47658	550	8	a	a	DT
47658	550	9	continual	continual	JJ
47658	550	10	expansion	expansion	NN
47658	550	11	,	,	,
47658	550	12	an	an	DT
47658	550	13	increasing	increase	VBG
47658	550	14	{	{	-LRB-
47658	550	15	53	53	CD
47658	550	16	}	}	-RRB-
47658	550	17	comprehension	comprehension	NN
47658	550	18	?	?	.
47658	551	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	551	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	551	3	within	within	IN
47658	551	4	the	the	DT
47658	551	5	conception	conception	NN
47658	551	6	that	that	WDT
47658	551	7	the	the	DT
47658	551	8	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
47658	551	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	551	10	revealed	reveal	VBN
47658	551	11	,	,	,
47658	551	12	not	not	RB
47658	551	13	in	in	IN
47658	551	14	any	any	DT
47658	551	15	mere	mere	JJ
47658	551	16	outward	outward	JJ
47658	551	17	use	use	NN
47658	551	18	of	of	IN
47658	551	19	the	the	DT
47658	551	20	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	551	21	,	,	,
47658	551	22	and	and	CC
47658	551	23	the	the	DT
47658	551	24	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	551	25	effort	effort	NN
47658	551	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	551	27	to	to	TO
47658	551	28	reconcile	reconcile	VB
47658	551	29	the	the	DT
47658	551	30	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	551	31	by	by	IN
47658	551	32	relating	relate	VBG
47658	551	33	the	the	DT
47658	551	34	conception	conception	NN
47658	551	35	to	to	IN
47658	551	36	a	a	DT
47658	551	37	more	more	RBR
47658	551	38	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
47658	551	39	whole	whole	NN
47658	551	40	.	.	.
47658	552	1	How	how	WRB
47658	552	2	,	,	,
47658	552	3	then	then	RB
47658	552	4	,	,	,
47658	552	5	does	do	VBZ
47658	552	6	the	the	DT
47658	552	7	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	552	8	meet	meet	VB
47658	552	9	this	this	DT
47658	552	10	case	case	NN
47658	552	11	which	which	WDT
47658	552	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	552	13	have	have	VBP
47658	552	14	specially	specially	RB
47658	552	15	instanced	instance	VBN
47658	552	16	,	,	,
47658	552	17	the	the	DT
47658	552	18	demand	demand	NN
47658	552	19	for	for	IN
47658	552	20	new	new	JJ
47658	552	21	notions	notion	NNS
47658	552	22	of	of	IN
47658	552	23	space	space	NN
47658	552	24	and	and	CC
47658	552	25	time	time	NN
47658	552	26	made	make	VBN
47658	552	27	by	by	IN
47658	552	28	the	the	DT
47658	552	29	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	552	30	of	of	IN
47658	552	31	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	552	32	?	?	.
47658	553	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	553	2	denies	deny	VBZ
47658	553	3	that	that	IN
47658	553	4	the	the	DT
47658	553	5	new	new	JJ
47658	553	6	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	553	7	are	be	VBP
47658	553	8	called	call	VBN
47658	553	9	forth	forth	RB
47658	553	10	by	by	IN
47658	553	11	human	human	JJ
47658	553	12	needs	need	NNS
47658	553	13	in	in	IN
47658	553	14	the	the	DT
47658	553	15	narrow	narrow	JJ
47658	553	16	sense	sense	NN
47658	553	17	--	--	:
47658	553	18	that	that	DT
47658	553	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	553	20	to	to	TO
47658	553	21	say	say	VB
47658	553	22	,	,	,
47658	553	23	in	in	IN
47658	553	24	the	the	DT
47658	553	25	sense	sense	NN
47658	553	26	that	that	IN
47658	553	27	working	work	VBG
47658	553	28	hypotheses	hypothesis	NNS
47658	553	29	or	or	CC
47658	553	30	practical	practical	JJ
47658	553	31	postulates	postulate	NNS
47658	553	32	are	be	VBP
47658	553	33	required	require	VBN
47658	553	34	.	.	.
47658	554	1	The	the	DT
47658	554	2	need	need	NN
47658	554	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	554	4	purely	purely	RB
47658	554	5	logical	logical	JJ
47658	554	6	.	.	.
47658	555	1	The	the	DT
47658	555	2	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
47658	555	3	revealed	reveal	VBD
47658	555	4	in	in	IN
47658	555	5	the	the	DT
47658	555	6	notions	notion	NNS
47658	555	7	that	that	WDT
47658	555	8	have	have	VBP
47658	555	9	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
47658	555	10	served	serve	VBN
47658	555	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	555	12	can	can	MD
47658	555	13	only	only	RB
47658	555	14	be	be	VB
47658	555	15	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
47658	555	16	by	by	IN
47658	555	17	apprehending	apprehend	VBG
47658	555	18	a	a	DT
47658	555	19	higher	high	JJR
47658	555	20	unity	unity	NN
47658	555	21	.	.	.
47658	556	1	If	if	IN
47658	556	2	the	the	DT
47658	556	3	older	old	JJR
47658	556	4	notions	notion	NNS
47658	556	5	of	of	IN
47658	556	6	space	space	NN
47658	556	7	and	and	CC
47658	556	8	time	time	NN
47658	556	9	are	be	VBP
47658	556	10	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
47658	556	11	to	to	IN
47658	556	12	the	the	DT
47658	556	13	more	more	RBR
47658	556	14	comprehensive	comprehensive	JJ
47658	556	15	view	view	NN
47658	556	16	of	of	IN
47658	556	17	the	the	DT
47658	556	18	universe	universe	NN
47658	556	19	as	as	IN
47658	556	20	a	a	DT
47658	556	21	co	co	NN
47658	556	22	-	-	NN
47658	556	23	ordination	ordination	NN
47658	556	24	of	of	IN
47658	556	25	systems	system	NNS
47658	556	26	of	of	IN
47658	556	27	movement	movement	NN
47658	556	28	,	,	,
47658	556	29	then	then	RB
47658	556	30	this	this	DT
47658	556	31	very	very	JJ
47658	556	32	negation	negation	NN
47658	556	33	of	of	IN
47658	556	34	the	the	DT
47658	556	35	older	old	JJR
47658	556	36	notions	notion	NNS
47658	556	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	556	38	the	the	DT
47658	556	39	affirmation	affirmation	NN
47658	556	40	of	of	IN
47658	556	41	the	the	DT
47658	556	42	new	new	JJ
47658	556	43	,	,	,
47658	556	44	and	and	CC
47658	556	45	from	from	IN
47658	556	46	the	the	DT
47658	556	47	negation	negation	NN
47658	556	48	by	by	IN
47658	556	49	pure	pure	JJ
47658	556	50	logic	logic	NN
47658	556	51	the	the	DT
47658	556	52	content	content	NN
47658	556	53	and	and	CC
47658	556	54	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	556	55	which	which	WDT
47658	556	56	are	be	VBP
47658	556	57	the	the	DT
47658	556	58	truth	truth	NN
47658	556	59	of	of	IN
47658	556	60	the	the	DT
47658	556	61	new	new	JJ
47658	556	62	notions	notion	NNS
47658	556	63	are	be	VBP
47658	556	64	derived	derive	VBN
47658	556	65	.	.	.
47658	557	1	To	to	IN
47658	557	2	this	this	DT
47658	557	3	objection	objection	NN
47658	557	4	the	the	DT
47658	557	5	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	557	6	reply	reply	NN
47658	557	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	557	8	that	that	IN
47658	557	9	if	if	IN
47658	557	10	this	this	DT
47658	557	11	be	be	VB
47658	557	12	the	the	DT
47658	557	13	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	557	14	of	of	IN
47658	557	15	the	the	DT
47658	557	16	truth	truth	NN
47658	557	17	there	there	EX
47658	557	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	557	19	no	no	DT
47658	557	20	way	way	NN
47658	557	21	shown	show	VBN
47658	557	22	by	by	IN
47658	557	23	which	which	WDT
47658	557	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	557	25	can	can	MD
47658	557	26	be	be	VB
47658	557	27	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
47658	557	28	from	from	IN
47658	557	29	error	error	NN
47658	557	30	.	.	.
47658	558	1	There	there	EX
47658	558	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	558	3	in	in	IN
47658	558	4	fact	fact	NN
47658	558	5	for	for	IN
47658	558	6	idealism	idealism	NN
47658	558	7	no	no	DT
47658	558	8	error	error	NN
47658	558	9	,	,	,
47658	558	10	no	no	DT
47658	558	11	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	558	12	,	,	,
47658	558	13	no	no	DT
47658	558	14	falsehood	falsehood	NN
47658	558	15	;	;	:
47658	558	16	as	as	IN
47658	558	17	real	real	JJ
47658	558	18	facts	fact	NNS
47658	558	19	,	,	,
47658	558	20	there	there	EX
47658	558	21	are	be	VBP
47658	558	22	only	only	RB
47658	558	23	degrees	degree	NNS
47658	558	24	of	of	IN
47658	558	25	truth	truth	NN
47658	558	26	.	.	.
47658	559	1	But	but	CC
47658	559	2	a	a	DT
47658	559	3	theory	theory	NN
47658	559	4	of	of	IN
47658	559	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	559	6	which	which	WDT
47658	559	7	ignores	ignore	VBZ
47658	559	8	such	such	JJ
47658	559	9	stubborn	stubborn	JJ
47658	559	10	realities	reality	NNS
47658	559	11	as	as	IN
47658	559	12	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	559	13	,	,	,
47658	559	14	falsehood	falsehood	NN
47658	559	15	,	,	,
47658	559	16	and	and	CC
47658	559	17	error	error	NN
47658	559	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	559	19	,	,	,
47658	559	20	from	from	IN
47658	559	21	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	559	22	standpoint	standpoint	NN
47658	559	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	559	24	view	view	VBP
47658	559	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	559	26	,	,	,
47658	559	27	useless	useless	JJ
47658	559	28	.	.	.
47658	560	1	On	on	IN
47658	560	2	the	the	DT
47658	560	3	other	other	JJ
47658	560	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	560	5	,	,	,
47658	560	6	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	560	7	offers	offer	VBZ
47658	560	8	a	a	DT
47658	560	9	test	test	NN
47658	560	10	by	by	IN
47658	560	11	which	which	WDT
47658	560	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	560	13	can	can	MD
47658	560	14	discriminate	discriminate	VB
47658	560	15	between	between	IN
47658	560	16	true	true	JJ
47658	560	17	and	and	CC
47658	560	18	false	false	JJ
47658	560	19	--	--	:
47658	560	20	namely	namely	RB
47658	560	21	,	,	,
47658	560	22	the	the	DT
47658	560	23	method	method	NN
47658	560	24	of	of	IN
47658	560	25	judging	judge	VBG
47658	560	26	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	560	27	by	by	IN
47658	560	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	560	29	practical	practical	JJ
47658	560	30	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	560	31	.	.	.
47658	561	1	Can	Can	MD
47658	561	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	561	3	or	or	CC
47658	561	4	can	can	MD
47658	561	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	561	6	not	not	RB
47658	561	7	make	make	VB
47658	561	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	561	9	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	561	10	work	work	VB
47658	561	11	?	?	.
47658	562	1	That	that	DT
47658	562	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	562	3	the	the	DT
47658	562	4	whole	whole	JJ
47658	562	5	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	562	6	of	of	IN
47658	562	7	asking	asking	NN
47658	562	8	,	,	,
47658	562	9	Are	be	VBP
47658	562	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	562	11	true	true	JJ
47658	562	12	or	or	CC
47658	562	13	false	false	JJ
47658	562	14	?	?	.
47658	563	1	And	and	CC
47658	563	2	now	now	RB
47658	563	3	,	,	,
47658	563	4	lest	lest	IN
47658	563	5	the	the	DT
47658	563	6	reader	reader	NN
47658	563	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	563	8	alarmed	alarm	VBN
47658	563	9	at	at	IN
47658	563	10	the	the	DT
47658	563	11	prospect	prospect	NN
47658	563	12	of	of	IN
47658	563	13	having	have	VBG
47658	563	14	to	to	TO
47658	563	15	revise	revise	VB
47658	563	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	563	17	working	work	VBG
47658	563	18	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	563	19	of	of	IN
47658	563	20	space	space	NN
47658	563	21	and	and	CC
47658	563	22	{	{	-LRB-
47658	563	23	54	54	CD
47658	563	24	}	}	-RRB-
47658	563	25	time	time	NN
47658	563	26	,	,	,
47658	563	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	563	28	will	will	MD
47658	563	29	,	,	,
47658	563	30	to	to	TO
47658	563	31	reassure	reassure	VB
47658	563	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	563	33	,	,	,
47658	563	34	quote	quote	VB
47658	563	35	the	the	DT
47658	563	36	words	word	NNS
47658	563	37	with	with	IN
47658	563	38	which	which	WDT
47658	563	39	Henri	Henri	NNP
47658	563	40	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
47658	563	41	concluded	conclude	VBD
47658	563	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	563	43	account	account	NN
47658	563	44	of	of	IN
47658	563	45	the	the	DT
47658	563	46	new	new	JJ
47658	563	47	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	563	48	,	,	,
47658	563	49	and	and	CC
47658	563	50	which	which	WDT
47658	563	51	admirably	admirably	RB
47658	563	52	express	express	VBP
47658	563	53	and	and	CC
47658	563	54	illustrate	illustrate	VB
47658	563	55	the	the	DT
47658	563	56	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	563	57	's	's	POS
47658	563	58	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	563	59	:	:	:
47658	563	60	"	"	``
47658	563	61	What	what	WP
47658	563	62	is	be	VBZ
47658	563	63	to	to	TO
47658	563	64	be	be	VB
47658	563	65	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	563	66	position	position	NN
47658	563	67	in	in	IN
47658	563	68	view	view	NN
47658	563	69	of	of	IN
47658	563	70	these	these	DT
47658	563	71	new	new	JJ
47658	563	72	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	563	73	?	?	.
47658	564	1	Are	be	VBP
47658	564	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	564	3	about	about	IN
47658	564	4	to	to	TO
47658	564	5	be	be	VB
47658	564	6	forced	force	VBN
47658	564	7	to	to	TO
47658	564	8	modify	modify	VB
47658	564	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	564	10	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
47658	564	11	?	?	.
47658	565	1	No	no	UH
47658	565	2	,	,	,
47658	565	3	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	565	4	:	:	:
47658	565	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	565	6	had	have	VBD
47658	565	7	adopted	adopt	VBN
47658	565	8	a	a	DT
47658	565	9	convention	convention	NN
47658	565	10	because	because	IN
47658	565	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	565	12	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	565	13	to	to	IN
47658	565	14	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	565	15	convenient	convenient	JJ
47658	565	16	,	,	,
47658	565	17	and	and	CC
47658	565	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	565	19	declared	declare	VBD
47658	565	20	that	that	IN
47658	565	21	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	565	22	could	could	MD
47658	565	23	compel	compel	VB
47658	565	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	565	25	to	to	TO
47658	565	26	abandon	abandon	VB
47658	565	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	565	28	.	.	.
47658	566	1	To	to	IN
47658	566	2	-	-	HYPH
47658	566	3	day	day	NN
47658	566	4	certain	certain	JJ
47658	566	5	physicists	physicist	NNS
47658	566	6	wish	wish	VBP
47658	566	7	to	to	TO
47658	566	8	adopt	adopt	VB
47658	566	9	a	a	DT
47658	566	10	new	new	JJ
47658	566	11	convention	convention	NN
47658	566	12	.	.	.
47658	567	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	567	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	567	3	not	not	RB
47658	567	4	because	because	IN
47658	567	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	567	6	are	be	VBP
47658	567	7	compelled	compel	VBN
47658	567	8	to	to	TO
47658	567	9	;	;	:
47658	567	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	567	11	judge	judge	VBP
47658	567	12	this	this	DT
47658	567	13	new	new	JJ
47658	567	14	convention	convention	NN
47658	567	15	to	to	TO
47658	567	16	be	be	VB
47658	567	17	more	more	RBR
47658	567	18	convenient	convenient	JJ
47658	567	19	--	--	:
47658	567	20	that	that	DT
47658	567	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	567	22	all	all	DT
47658	567	23	;	;	:
47658	567	24	and	and	CC
47658	567	25	those	those	DT
47658	567	26	who	who	WP
47658	567	27	are	be	VBP
47658	567	28	not	not	RB
47658	567	29	of	of	IN
47658	567	30	this	this	DT
47658	567	31	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	567	32	can	can	MD
47658	567	33	legitimately	legitimately	RB
47658	567	34	keep	keep	VB
47658	567	35	the	the	DT
47658	567	36	old	old	JJ
47658	567	37	and	and	CC
47658	567	38	so	so	RB
47658	567	39	leave	leave	VB
47658	567	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	567	41	old	old	JJ
47658	567	42	habits	habit	NNS
47658	567	43	undisturbed	undisturbed	JJ
47658	567	44	.	.	.
47658	568	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	568	2	think	think	VBP
47658	568	3	,	,	,
47658	568	4	between	between	IN
47658	568	5	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	568	6	,	,	,
47658	568	7	that	that	IN
47658	568	8	this	this	DT
47658	568	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	568	10	what	what	WP
47658	568	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	568	12	will	will	MD
47658	568	13	do	do	VB
47658	568	14	for	for	IN
47658	568	15	a	a	DT
47658	568	16	long	long	JJ
47658	568	17	time	time	NN
47658	568	18	to	to	TO
47658	568	19	come	come	VB
47658	568	20	.	.	.
47658	568	21	"	"	''
47658	569	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	569	2	have	have	VBP
47658	569	3	so	so	RB
47658	569	4	far	far	RB
47658	569	5	considered	consider	VBN
47658	569	6	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	569	7	rather	rather	RB
47658	569	8	as	as	IN
47658	569	9	a	a	DT
47658	569	10	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	569	11	than	than	IN
47658	569	12	as	as	IN
47658	569	13	a	a	DT
47658	569	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	569	15	.	.	.
47658	570	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	570	2	will	will	MD
47658	570	3	now	now	RB
47658	570	4	try	try	VB
47658	570	5	and	and	CC
47658	570	6	characterise	characterise	VB
47658	570	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	570	8	on	on	IN
47658	570	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	570	10	positive	positive	JJ
47658	570	11	side	side	NN
47658	570	12	.	.	.
47658	571	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	571	2	declares	declare	VBZ
47658	571	3	that	that	IN
47658	571	4	there	there	EX
47658	571	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	571	6	no	no	DT
47658	571	7	such	such	JJ
47658	571	8	thing	thing	NN
47658	571	9	as	as	IN
47658	571	10	pure	pure	JJ
47658	571	11	thought	thought	NN
47658	571	12	,	,	,
47658	571	13	but	but	CC
47658	571	14	that	that	IN
47658	571	15	all	all	DT
47658	571	16	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	571	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	571	18	personal	personal	JJ
47658	571	19	and	and	CC
47658	571	20	purposive	purposive	JJ
47658	571	21	;	;	:
47658	571	22	that	that	IN
47658	571	23	all	all	DT
47658	571	24	knowing	know	VBG
47658	571	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	571	26	directed	direct	VBN
47658	571	27	,	,	,
47658	571	28	controlled	control	VBN
47658	571	29	,	,	,
47658	571	30	and	and	CC
47658	571	31	qualified	qualify	VBN
47658	571	32	by	by	IN
47658	571	33	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	571	34	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	571	35	such	such	JJ
47658	571	36	as	as	IN
47658	571	37	interest	interest	NN
47658	571	38	,	,	,
47658	571	39	attention	attention	NN
47658	571	40	,	,	,
47658	571	41	desire	desire	NN
47658	571	42	,	,	,
47658	571	43	emotion	emotion	NN
47658	571	44	,	,	,
47658	571	45	and	and	CC
47658	571	46	the	the	DT
47658	571	47	like	like	JJ
47658	571	48	;	;	:
47658	571	49	and	and	CC
47658	571	50	that	that	IN
47658	571	51	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	571	52	can	can	MD
47658	571	53	not	not	RB
47658	571	54	,	,	,
47658	571	55	as	as	IN
47658	571	56	formal	formal	JJ
47658	571	57	logic	logic	NN
47658	571	58	does	do	VBZ
47658	571	59	,	,	,
47658	571	60	abstract	abstract	VB
47658	571	61	from	from	IN
47658	571	62	any	any	DT
47658	571	63	of	of	IN
47658	571	64	these	these	DT
47658	571	65	,	,	,
47658	571	66	for	for	IN
47658	571	67	logic	logic	NN
47658	571	68	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	571	69	is	be	VBZ
47658	571	70	part	part	NN
47658	571	71	of	of	IN
47658	571	72	a	a	DT
47658	571	73	psychical	psychical	JJ
47658	571	74	process	process	NN
47658	571	75	.	.	.
47658	572	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	572	2	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	572	3	depends	depend	VBZ
47658	572	4	upon	upon	IN
47658	572	5	belief	belief	NN
47658	572	6	;	;	:
47658	572	7	truths	truth	NNS
47658	572	8	are	be	VBP
47658	572	9	matters	matter	NNS
47658	572	10	of	of	IN
47658	572	11	belief	belief	NN
47658	572	12	,	,	,
47658	572	13	and	and	CC
47658	572	14	beliefs	belief	NNS
47658	572	15	are	be	VBP
47658	572	16	rules	rule	NNS
47658	572	17	of	of	IN
47658	572	18	action	action	NN
47658	572	19	.	.	.
47658	573	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	573	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	573	3	this	this	DT
47658	573	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	573	5	that	that	WDT
47658	573	6	gives	give	VBZ
47658	573	7	to	to	IN
47658	573	8	pragmatism	pragmatism	VB
47658	573	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	573	10	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
47658	573	11	,	,	,
47658	573	12	some	some	DT
47658	573	13	have	have	VBP
47658	573	14	even	even	RB
47658	573	15	said	say	VBN
47658	573	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	573	17	grotesque	grotesque	NN
47658	573	18	,	,	,
47658	573	19	character	character	NN
47658	573	20	.	.	.
47658	574	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	574	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	574	3	to	to	TO
47658	574	4	say	say	VB
47658	574	5	that	that	IN
47658	574	6	the	the	DT
47658	574	7	same	same	JJ
47658	574	8	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	574	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	574	10	both	both	CC
47658	574	11	true	true	JJ
47658	574	12	and	and	CC
47658	574	13	false	false	JJ
47658	574	14	--	--	:
47658	574	15	true	true	JJ
47658	574	16	for	for	IN
47658	574	17	the	the	DT
47658	574	18	man	man	NN
47658	574	19	who	who	WP
47658	574	20	believes	believe	VBZ
47658	574	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	574	22	,	,	,
47658	574	23	false	false	JJ
47658	574	24	for	for	IN
47658	574	25	the	the	DT
47658	574	26	man	man	NN
47658	574	27	who	who	WP
47658	574	28	can	can	MD
47658	574	29	not	not	RB
47658	574	30	.	.	.
47658	575	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	575	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	575	3	to	to	TO
47658	575	4	say	say	VB
47658	575	5	that	that	IN
47658	575	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	575	7	can	can	MD
47658	575	8	make	make	VB
47658	575	9	anything	anything	NN
47658	575	10	true	true	JJ
47658	575	11	by	by	IN
47658	575	12	believing	believe	VBG
47658	575	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	575	14	,	,	,
47658	575	15	and	and	CC
47658	575	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	575	17	can	can	MD
47658	575	18	believe	believe	VB
47658	575	19	anything	anything	NN
47658	575	20	so	so	RB
47658	575	21	long	long	RB
47658	575	22	as	as	IN
47658	575	23	the	the	DT
47658	575	24	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	575	25	of	of	IN
47658	575	26	acting	act	VBG
47658	575	27	on	on	IN
47658	575	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	575	29	are	be	VBP
47658	575	30	not	not	RB
47658	575	31	absolutely	absolutely	RB
47658	575	32	disastrous	disastrous	JJ
47658	575	33	.	.	.
47658	576	1	And	and	CC
47658	576	2	the	the	DT
47658	576	3	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	576	4	,	,	,
47658	576	5	All	all	DT
47658	576	6	truths	truth	NNS
47658	576	7	work	work	VBP
47658	576	8	,	,	,
47658	576	9	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	576	10	to	to	TO
47658	576	11	involve	involve	VB
47658	576	12	the	the	DT
47658	576	13	conclusion	conclusion	NN
47658	576	14	that	that	IN
47658	576	15	all	all	DT
47658	576	16	that	that	WDT
47658	576	17	works	work	VBZ
47658	576	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	576	19	true	true	JJ
47658	576	20	;	;	:
47658	576	21	and	and	CC
47658	576	22	the	the	DT
47658	576	23	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	576	24	,	,	,
47658	576	25	The	the	DT
47658	576	26	true	true	JJ
47658	576	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	576	28	the	the	DT
47658	576	29	useful	useful	JJ
47658	576	30	,	,	,
47658	576	31	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	576	32	to	to	TO
47658	576	33	imply	imply	VB
47658	576	34	that	that	IN
47658	576	35	{	{	-LRB-
47658	576	36	55	55	CD
47658	576	37	}	}	-RRB-
47658	576	38	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	576	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	576	40	useful	useful	JJ
47658	576	41	is	be	VBZ
47658	576	42	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	576	43	true	true	JJ
47658	576	44	.	.	.
47658	577	1	No	no	DT
47658	577	2	small	small	JJ
47658	577	3	part	part	NN
47658	577	4	of	of	IN
47658	577	5	the	the	DT
47658	577	6	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	577	7	controversy	controversy	NN
47658	577	8	has	have	VBZ
47658	577	9	been	be	VBN
47658	577	10	directed	direct	VBN
47658	577	11	to	to	IN
47658	577	12	the	the	DT
47658	577	13	attempt	attempt	NN
47658	577	14	to	to	TO
47658	577	15	show	show	VB
47658	577	16	that	that	IN
47658	577	17	all	all	DT
47658	577	18	and	and	CC
47658	577	19	each	each	DT
47658	577	20	of	of	IN
47658	577	21	these	these	DT
47658	577	22	corollaries	corollary	NNS
47658	577	23	are	be	VBP
47658	577	24	,	,	,
47658	577	25	or	or	CC
47658	577	26	arise	arise	VB
47658	577	27	from	from	IN
47658	577	28	,	,	,
47658	577	29	misconceptions	misconception	NNS
47658	577	30	of	of	IN
47658	577	31	the	the	DT
47658	577	32	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	577	33	.	.	.
47658	578	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	578	2	think	think	VBP
47658	578	3	,	,	,
47658	578	4	and	and	CC
47658	578	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	578	6	shall	shall	MD
47658	578	7	endeavour	endeavour	VB
47658	578	8	to	to	TO
47658	578	9	show	show	VB
47658	578	10	,	,	,
47658	578	11	that	that	IN
47658	578	12	there	there	EX
47658	578	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	578	14	a	a	DT
47658	578	15	serious	serious	JJ
47658	578	16	defect	defect	NN
47658	578	17	in	in	IN
47658	578	18	the	the	DT
47658	578	19	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	578	20	statement	statement	NN
47658	578	21	,	,	,
47658	578	22	and	and	CC
47658	578	23	that	that	IN
47658	578	24	these	these	DT
47658	578	25	misconceptions	misconception	NNS
47658	578	26	are	be	VBP
47658	578	27	in	in	IN
47658	578	28	a	a	DT
47658	578	29	great	great	JJ
47658	578	30	part	part	NN
47658	578	31	due	due	JJ
47658	578	32	to	to	IN
47658	578	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	578	34	.	.	.
47658	579	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
47658	579	2	,	,	,
47658	579	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	579	4	must	must	MD
47658	579	5	accept	accept	VB
47658	579	6	the	the	DT
47658	579	7	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	579	8	disavowal	disavowal	NN
47658	579	9	.	.	.
47658	580	1	And	and	CC
47658	580	2	there	there	EX
47658	580	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	580	4	no	no	DT
47658	580	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	580	6	in	in	IN
47658	580	7	doing	do	VBG
47658	580	8	so	so	RB
47658	580	9	,	,	,
47658	580	10	for	for	IN
47658	580	11	the	the	DT
47658	580	12	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	580	13	of	of	IN
47658	580	14	the	the	DT
47658	580	15	theory	theory	NN
47658	580	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	580	17	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
47658	580	18	clear	clear	JJ
47658	580	19	.	.	.
47658	581	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	581	2	,	,	,
47658	581	3	according	accord	VBG
47658	581	4	to	to	IN
47658	581	5	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	581	6	,	,	,
47658	581	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	581	8	a	a	DT
47658	581	9	value	value	NN
47658	581	10	and	and	CC
47658	581	11	not	not	RB
47658	581	12	a	a	DT
47658	581	13	fact	fact	NN
47658	581	14	.	.	.
47658	582	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	582	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	582	3	thus	thus	RB
47658	582	4	connected	connect	VBN
47658	582	5	with	with	IN
47658	582	6	the	the	DT
47658	582	7	conception	conception	NN
47658	582	8	of	of	IN
47658	582	9	"	"	``
47658	582	10	good	good	JJ
47658	582	11	.	.	.
47658	582	12	"	"	''
47658	583	1	In	in	IN
47658	583	2	saying	say	VBG
47658	583	3	that	that	IN
47658	583	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	583	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	583	6	useful	useful	JJ
47658	583	7	,	,	,
47658	583	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	583	9	say	say	VBP
47658	583	10	that	that	IN
47658	583	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	583	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	583	13	a	a	DT
47658	583	14	means	means	NN
47658	583	15	to	to	IN
47658	583	16	an	an	DT
47658	583	17	end	end	NN
47658	583	18	,	,	,
47658	583	19	a	a	DT
47658	583	20	good	good	NN
47658	583	21	.	.	.
47658	584	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	584	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	584	3	not	not	RB
47658	584	4	a	a	DT
47658	584	5	moral	moral	JJ
47658	584	6	end	end	NN
47658	584	7	,	,	,
47658	584	8	but	but	CC
47658	584	9	a	a	DT
47658	584	10	cognitive	cognitive	JJ
47658	584	11	end	end	NN
47658	584	12	,	,	,
47658	584	13	just	just	RB
47658	584	14	as	as	IN
47658	584	15	"	"	``
47658	584	16	beauty	beauty	NN
47658	584	17	"	"	''
47658	584	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	584	19	an	an	DT
47658	584	20	esthetic	esthetic	JJ
47658	584	21	end	end	NN
47658	584	22	.	.	.
47658	585	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	585	2	,	,	,
47658	585	3	beauty	beauty	NN
47658	585	4	,	,	,
47658	585	5	and	and	CC
47658	585	6	goodness	goodness	NN
47658	585	7	thus	thus	RB
47658	585	8	stand	stand	VBP
47658	585	9	together	together	RB
47658	585	10	as	as	IN
47658	585	11	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	585	12	of	of	IN
47658	585	13	value	value	NN
47658	585	14	or	or	CC
47658	585	15	worth	worth	NN
47658	585	16	.	.	.
47658	586	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	586	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	586	3	only	only	RB
47658	586	4	by	by	IN
47658	586	5	recognising	recognise	VBG
47658	586	6	that	that	DT
47658	586	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	586	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	586	9	a	a	DT
47658	586	10	value	value	NN
47658	586	11	that	that	WDT
47658	586	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	586	13	can	can	MD
47658	586	14	possess	possess	VB
47658	586	15	an	an	DT
47658	586	16	actual	actual	JJ
47658	586	17	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	586	18	to	to	TO
47658	586	19	distinguish	distinguish	VB
47658	586	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	586	21	from	from	IN
47658	586	22	error	error	NN
47658	586	23	,	,	,
47658	586	24	for	for	IN
47658	586	25	if	if	IN
47658	586	26	truth	truth	NN
47658	586	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	586	28	a	a	DT
47658	586	29	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	586	30	of	of	IN
47658	586	31	fact	fact	NN
47658	586	32	,	,	,
47658	586	33	if	if	IN
47658	586	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	586	35	asserts	assert	VBZ
47658	586	36	existence	existence	NN
47658	586	37	,	,	,
47658	586	38	so	so	RB
47658	586	39	also	also	RB
47658	586	40	does	do	VBZ
47658	586	41	error	error	NN
47658	586	42	.	.	.
47658	587	1	The	the	DT
47658	587	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	587	3	principle	principle	NN
47658	587	4	has	have	VBZ
47658	587	5	an	an	DT
47658	587	6	important	important	JJ
47658	587	7	bearing	bearing	NN
47658	587	8	on	on	IN
47658	587	9	religion	religion	NN
47658	587	10	.	.	.
47658	588	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	588	2	justifies	justify	VBZ
47658	588	3	the	the	DT
47658	588	4	Faith	Faith	NNP
47658	588	5	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	588	6	.	.	.
47658	589	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	589	2	shows	show	VBZ
47658	589	3	that	that	IN
47658	589	4	the	the	DT
47658	589	5	good	good	NN
47658	589	6	aimed	aim	VBN
47658	589	7	at	at	IN
47658	589	8	by	by	IN
47658	589	9	a	a	DT
47658	589	10	"	"	``
47658	589	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	589	12	claim	claim	NN
47658	589	13	"	"	''
47658	589	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	589	15	only	only	RB
47658	589	16	attainable	attainable	JJ
47658	589	17	by	by	IN
47658	589	18	the	the	DT
47658	589	19	exercise	exercise	NN
47658	589	20	of	of	IN
47658	589	21	the	the	DT
47658	589	22	will	will	NN
47658	589	23	to	to	TO
47658	589	24	believe	believe	VB
47658	589	25	.	.	.
47658	590	1	Thus	thus	RB
47658	590	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	590	3	replaces	replace	VBZ
47658	590	4	the	the	DT
47658	590	5	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	590	6	maxim	maxim	NN
47658	590	7	,	,	,
47658	590	8	Believe	believe	VB
47658	590	9	in	in	IN
47658	590	10	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	590	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	590	12	can	can	MD
47658	590	13	possibly	possibly	RB
47658	590	14	doubt	doubt	VB
47658	590	15	,	,	,
47658	590	16	with	with	IN
47658	590	17	the	the	DT
47658	590	18	practical	practical	JJ
47658	590	19	maxim	maxim	NN
47658	590	20	,	,	,
47658	590	21	Resolve	resolve	VB
47658	590	22	not	not	RB
47658	590	23	to	to	TO
47658	590	24	quench	quench	VB
47658	590	25	any	any	DT
47658	590	26	impulse	impulse	NN
47658	590	27	to	to	TO
47658	590	28	believe	believe	VB
47658	590	29	because	because	IN
47658	590	30	doubts	doubt	NNS
47658	590	31	of	of	IN
47658	590	32	the	the	DT
47658	590	33	truth	truth	NN
47658	590	34	are	be	VBP
47658	590	35	possible	possible	JJ
47658	590	36	.	.	.
47658	591	1	Belief	belief	NN
47658	591	2	may	may	MD
47658	591	3	even	even	RB
47658	591	4	be	be	VB
47658	591	5	a	a	DT
47658	591	6	condition	condition	NN
47658	591	7	of	of	IN
47658	591	8	the	the	DT
47658	591	9	success	success	NN
47658	591	10	of	of	IN
47658	591	11	the	the	DT
47658	591	12	truth	truth	NN
47658	591	13	claim	claim	NN
47658	591	14	.	.	.
47658	592	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
47658	592	2	VI	VI	NNP
47658	592	3	UTILITY	UTILITY	NNP
47658	592	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	592	5	have	have	VBP
47658	592	6	seen	see	VBN
47658	592	7	in	in	IN
47658	592	8	the	the	DT
47658	592	9	last	last	JJ
47658	592	10	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	592	11	that	that	DT
47658	592	12	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	592	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	592	14	both	both	CC
47658	592	15	a	a	DT
47658	592	16	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	592	17	and	and	CC
47658	592	18	a	a	DT
47658	592	19	theory	theory	NN
47658	592	20	.	.	.
47658	593	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	593	2	shows	show	VBZ
47658	593	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	593	4	that	that	IN
47658	593	5	the	the	DT
47658	593	6	{	{	-LRB-
47658	593	7	56	56	CD
47658	593	8	}	}	-RRB-
47658	593	9	notion	notion	NN
47658	593	10	that	that	IN
47658	593	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	593	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	593	13	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	593	14	involves	involve	VBZ
47658	593	15	the	the	DT
47658	593	16	conception	conception	NN
47658	593	17	of	of	IN
47658	593	18	an	an	DT
47658	593	19	"	"	``
47658	593	20	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	593	21	"	"	''
47658	593	22	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	593	23	,	,	,
47658	593	24	and	and	CC
47658	593	25	the	the	DT
47658	593	26	notion	notion	NN
47658	593	27	that	that	IN
47658	593	28	truth	truth	NN
47658	593	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	593	30	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	593	31	or	or	CC
47658	593	32	consistency	consistency	NN
47658	593	33	involves	involve	VBZ
47658	593	34	the	the	DT
47658	593	35	conception	conception	NN
47658	593	36	of	of	IN
47658	593	37	a	a	DT
47658	593	38	"	"	``
47658	593	39	useless	useless	JJ
47658	593	40	"	"	''
47658	593	41	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	593	42	.	.	.
47658	594	1	The	the	DT
47658	594	2	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	594	3	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	594	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	594	5	offers	offer	VBZ
47658	594	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	594	7	of	of	IN
47658	594	8	the	the	DT
47658	594	9	kind	kind	NN
47658	594	10	that	that	WDT
47658	594	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	594	12	called	call	VBN
47658	594	13	in	in	IN
47658	594	14	the	the	DT
47658	594	15	technical	technical	JJ
47658	594	16	language	language	NN
47658	594	17	of	of	IN
47658	594	18	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	594	19	teleological	teleological	NN
47658	594	20	.	.	.
47658	595	1	This	this	DT
47658	595	2	means	mean	VBZ
47658	595	3	that	that	IN
47658	595	4	to	to	TO
47658	595	5	explain	explain	VB
47658	595	6	or	or	CC
47658	595	7	to	to	TO
47658	595	8	give	give	VB
47658	595	9	a	a	DT
47658	595	10	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	595	11	to	to	TO
47658	595	12	truth	truth	NN
47658	595	13	all	all	DT
47658	595	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	595	15	can	can	MD
47658	595	16	do	do	VB
47658	595	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	595	18	to	to	TO
47658	595	19	point	point	VB
47658	595	20	out	out	RP
47658	595	21	the	the	DT
47658	595	22	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	595	23	on	on	IN
47658	595	24	account	account	NN
47658	595	25	of	of	IN
47658	595	26	which	which	WDT
47658	595	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	595	28	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	595	29	.	.	.
47658	596	1	This	this	DT
47658	596	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	596	3	not	not	RB
47658	596	4	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	596	5	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	596	6	.	.	.
47658	597	1	Physical	physical	JJ
47658	597	2	science	science	NN
47658	597	3	explains	explain	VBZ
47658	597	4	a	a	DT
47658	597	5	fact	fact	NN
47658	597	6	or	or	CC
47658	597	7	an	an	DT
47658	597	8	event	event	NN
47658	597	9	by	by	IN
47658	597	10	showing	show	VBG
47658	597	11	the	the	DT
47658	597	12	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	597	13	which	which	WDT
47658	597	14	give	give	VBP
47658	597	15	rise	rise	NN
47658	597	16	to	to	IN
47658	597	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	597	18	or	or	CC
47658	597	19	that	that	DT
47658	597	20	determine	determine	VBP
47658	597	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	597	22	character	character	NN
47658	597	23	.	.	.
47658	598	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	598	2	recognises	recognise	VBZ
47658	598	3	no	no	DT
47658	598	4	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	598	5	determining	determine	VBG
47658	598	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	598	7	such	such	JJ
47658	598	8	as	as	IN
47658	598	9	those	those	DT
47658	598	10	which	which	WDT
47658	598	11	science	science	NN
47658	598	12	embodies	embodie	NNS
47658	598	13	in	in	IN
47658	598	14	the	the	DT
47658	598	15	conception	conception	NN
47658	598	16	of	of	IN
47658	598	17	a	a	DT
47658	598	18	natural	natural	JJ
47658	598	19	law	law	NN
47658	598	20	--	--	:
47658	598	21	that	that	RB
47658	598	22	is	is	RB
47658	598	23	,	,	,
47658	598	24	the	the	DT
47658	598	25	idea	idea	NN
47658	598	26	of	of	IN
47658	598	27	a	a	DT
47658	598	28	connection	connection	NN
47658	598	29	of	of	IN
47658	598	30	natural	natural	JJ
47658	598	31	events	event	NNS
47658	598	32	with	with	IN
47658	598	33	one	one	CD
47658	598	34	another	another	DT
47658	598	35	which	which	WDT
47658	598	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	598	37	not	not	RB
47658	598	38	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	598	39	on	on	IN
47658	598	40	human	human	JJ
47658	598	41	thoughts	thought	NNS
47658	598	42	about	about	IN
47658	598	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	598	44	nor	nor	CC
47658	598	45	on	on	IN
47658	598	46	human	human	JJ
47658	598	47	purposes	purpose	NNS
47658	598	48	in	in	IN
47658	598	49	regard	regard	NN
47658	598	50	to	to	IN
47658	598	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	598	52	.	.	.
47658	599	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	599	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	599	3	in	in	IN
47658	599	4	intimate	intimate	JJ
47658	599	5	association	association	NN
47658	599	6	with	with	IN
47658	599	7	human	human	JJ
47658	599	8	practical	practical	JJ
47658	599	9	activity	activity	NN
47658	599	10	;	;	:
47658	599	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	599	12	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	599	13	lies	lie	VBZ
47658	599	14	wholly	wholly	RB
47658	599	15	in	in	IN
47658	599	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	599	17	utility	utility	NN
47658	599	18	.	.	.
47658	600	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	600	2	must	must	MD
47658	600	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	600	4	now	now	RB
47658	600	5	examine	examine	VB
47658	600	6	somewhat	somewhat	RB
47658	600	7	closely	closely	RB
47658	600	8	this	this	DT
47658	600	9	notion	notion	NN
47658	600	10	of	of	IN
47658	600	11	utility	utility	NN
47658	600	12	.	.	.
47658	601	1	There	there	EX
47658	601	2	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	601	3	to	to	IN
47658	601	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	601	5	to	to	TO
47658	601	6	be	be	VB
47658	601	7	a	a	DT
47658	601	8	serious	serious	JJ
47658	601	9	defect	defect	NN
47658	601	10	in	in	IN
47658	601	11	the	the	DT
47658	601	12	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	601	13	conception	conception	NN
47658	601	14	and	and	CC
47658	601	15	application	application	NN
47658	601	16	of	of	IN
47658	601	17	the	the	DT
47658	601	18	principle	principle	NN
47658	601	19	of	of	IN
47658	601	20	utility	utility	NN
47658	601	21	;	;	:
47658	601	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	601	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	601	24	based	base	VBN
47658	601	25	on	on	IN
47658	601	26	a	a	DT
47658	601	27	conception	conception	NN
47658	601	28	altogether	altogether	RB
47658	601	29	too	too	RB
47658	601	30	narrow	narrow	JJ
47658	601	31	.	.	.
47658	602	1	A	a	DT
47658	602	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	602	3	that	that	WDT
47658	602	4	condemns	condemn	VBZ
47658	602	5	any	any	DT
47658	602	6	purely	purely	RB
47658	602	7	logical	logical	JJ
47658	602	8	process	process	NN
47658	602	9	as	as	IN
47658	602	10	resulting	result	VBG
47658	602	11	in	in	IN
47658	602	12	"	"	``
47658	602	13	useless	useless	JJ
47658	602	14	"	"	''
47658	602	15	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	602	16	can	can	MD
47658	602	17	only	only	RB
47658	602	18	justify	justify	VB
47658	602	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	602	20	by	by	IN
47658	602	21	insisting	insist	VBG
47658	602	22	on	on	IN
47658	602	23	an	an	DT
47658	602	24	application	application	NN
47658	602	25	of	of	IN
47658	602	26	the	the	DT
47658	602	27	principle	principle	NN
47658	602	28	of	of	IN
47658	602	29	utility	utility	NN
47658	602	30	that	that	WDT
47658	602	31	will	will	MD
47658	602	32	be	be	VB
47658	602	33	found	find	VBN
47658	602	34	to	to	TO
47658	602	35	exclude	exclude	VB
47658	602	36	not	not	RB
47658	602	37	merely	merely	RB
47658	602	38	the	the	DT
47658	602	39	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	602	40	of	of	IN
47658	602	41	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	602	42	but	but	CC
47658	602	43	most	most	JJS
47658	602	44	if	if	IN
47658	602	45	not	not	RB
47658	602	46	all	all	DT
47658	602	47	of	of	IN
47658	602	48	the	the	DT
47658	602	49	results	result	NNS
47658	602	50	of	of	IN
47658	602	51	pure	pure	JJ
47658	602	52	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
47658	602	53	and	and	CC
47658	602	54	physics	physics	NN
47658	602	55	,	,	,
47658	602	56	for	for	IN
47658	602	57	these	these	DT
47658	602	58	sciences	science	NNS
47658	602	59	apply	apply	VBP
47658	602	60	a	a	DT
47658	602	61	method	method	NN
47658	602	62	of	of	IN
47658	602	63	pure	pure	JJ
47658	602	64	logical	logical	JJ
47658	602	65	deduction	deduction	NN
47658	602	66	and	and	CC
47658	602	67	induction	induction	NN
47658	602	68	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	JJ
47658	602	69	from	from	IN
47658	602	70	that	that	DT
47658	602	71	which	which	WDT
47658	602	72	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	602	73	condemns	condemn	NNS
47658	602	74	.	.	.
47658	603	1	The	the	DT
47658	603	2	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	603	3	nature	nature	NN
47658	603	4	of	of	IN
47658	603	5	man	man	NN
47658	603	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	603	7	an	an	DT
47658	603	8	endowment	endowment	NN
47658	603	9	which	which	WDT
47658	603	10	sharply	sharply	RB
47658	603	11	distinguishes	distinguish	VBZ
47658	603	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	603	13	from	from	IN
47658	603	14	other	other	JJ
47658	603	15	forms	form	NNS
47658	603	16	of	of	IN
47658	603	17	living	living	NN
47658	603	18	creatures	creature	NNS
47658	603	19	.	.	.
47658	604	1	So	so	RB
47658	604	2	supreme	supreme	NNP
47658	604	3	a	a	DT
47658	604	4	position	position	NN
47658	604	5	does	do	VBZ
47658	604	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	604	7	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	604	8	assign	assign	VB
47658	604	9	to	to	IN
47658	604	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	604	11	,	,	,
47658	604	12	so	so	RB
47658	604	13	wide	wide	JJ
47658	604	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	604	15	the	the	DT
47658	604	16	gap	gap	NN
47658	604	17	that	that	WDT
47658	604	18	separates	separate	VBZ
47658	604	19	{	{	-LRB-
47658	604	20	57	57	CD
47658	604	21	}	}	-RRB-
47658	604	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	604	23	from	from	IN
47658	604	24	other	other	JJ
47658	604	25	creatures	creature	NNS
47658	604	26	little	little	JJ
47658	604	27	different	different	JJ
47658	604	28	from	from	IN
47658	604	29	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	604	30	in	in	IN
47658	604	31	respect	respect	NN
47658	604	32	of	of	IN
47658	604	33	perfection	perfection	NN
47658	604	34	of	of	IN
47658	604	35	material	material	JJ
47658	604	36	organisation	organisation	NN
47658	604	37	and	and	CC
47658	604	38	adaptation	adaptation	NN
47658	604	39	to	to	IN
47658	604	40	environment	environment	NN
47658	604	41	,	,	,
47658	604	42	that	that	IN
47658	604	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	604	44	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	604	45	almost	almost	RB
47658	604	46	natural	natural	JJ
47658	604	47	to	to	TO
47658	604	48	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	604	49	that	that	IN
47658	604	50	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	604	51	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	604	52	is	be	VBZ
47658	604	53	that	that	IN
47658	604	54	for	for	IN
47658	604	55	which	which	WDT
47658	604	56	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	604	57	exist	exist	VBP
47658	604	58	,	,	,
47658	604	59	and	and	CC
47658	604	60	not	not	RB
47658	604	61	merely	merely	RB
47658	604	62	a	a	DT
47658	604	63	mode	mode	NN
47658	604	64	of	of	IN
47658	604	65	controlling	control	VBG
47658	604	66	,	,	,
47658	604	67	directing	direct	VBG
47658	604	68	,	,	,
47658	604	69	and	and	CC
47658	604	70	advancing	advance	VBG
47658	604	71	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	604	72	life	life	NN
47658	604	73	.	.	.
47658	605	1	Now	now	RB
47658	605	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	605	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	605	4	possible	possible	JJ
47658	605	5	to	to	TO
47658	605	6	hold	hold	VB
47658	605	7	--	--	:
47658	605	8	and	and	CC
47658	605	9	this	this	DT
47658	605	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	605	11	the	the	DT
47658	605	12	view	view	NN
47658	605	13	that	that	IN
47658	605	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	605	15	shall	shall	MD
47658	605	16	endeavour	endeavour	VB
47658	605	17	in	in	IN
47658	605	18	what	what	WP
47658	605	19	follows	follow	VBZ
47658	605	20	to	to	TO
47658	605	21	develop	develop	VB
47658	605	22	--	--	:
47658	605	23	that	that	IN
47658	605	24	the	the	DT
47658	605	25	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	605	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	605	27	subservient	subservient	JJ
47658	605	28	to	to	IN
47658	605	29	life	life	NN
47658	605	30	,	,	,
47658	605	31	and	and	CC
47658	605	32	that	that	IN
47658	605	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	605	34	can	can	MD
47658	605	35	show	show	VB
47658	605	36	the	the	DT
47658	605	37	manner	manner	NN
47658	605	38	and	and	CC
47658	605	39	method	method	NN
47658	605	40	of	of	IN
47658	605	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	605	42	working	working	NN
47658	605	43	and	and	CC
47658	605	44	the	the	DT
47658	605	45	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	605	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	605	47	serves	serve	VBZ
47658	605	48	.	.	.
47658	606	1	So	so	IN
47658	606	2	far	far	RB
47658	606	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	606	4	may	may	MD
47658	606	5	agree	agree	VB
47658	606	6	with	with	IN
47658	606	7	the	the	DT
47658	606	8	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	606	9	,	,	,
47658	606	10	but	but	CC
47658	606	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	606	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	606	13	not	not	RB
47658	606	14	the	the	DT
47658	606	15	same	same	JJ
47658	606	16	thing	thing	NN
47658	606	17	to	to	TO
47658	606	18	say	say	VB
47658	606	19	that	that	IN
47658	606	20	the	the	DT
47658	606	21	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	606	22	serves	serve	VBZ
47658	606	23	a	a	DT
47658	606	24	useful	useful	JJ
47658	606	25	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	606	26	and	and	CC
47658	606	27	to	to	TO
47658	606	28	say	say	VB
47658	606	29	that	that	DT
47658	606	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	606	31	,	,	,
47658	606	32	the	the	DT
47658	606	33	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	606	34	of	of	IN
47658	606	35	the	the	DT
47658	606	36	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	606	37	,	,	,
47658	606	38	the	the	DT
47658	606	39	end	end	NN
47658	606	40	which	which	WDT
47658	606	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	606	42	strives	strive	VBZ
47658	606	43	for	for	IN
47658	606	44	,	,	,
47658	606	45	is	be	VBZ
47658	606	46	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	606	47	only	only	RB
47658	606	48	a	a	DT
47658	606	49	utility	utility	NN
47658	606	50	.	.	.
47658	607	1	Were	be	VBD
47658	607	2	there	there	RB
47658	607	3	no	no	DT
47658	607	4	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	607	5	in	in	IN
47658	607	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	607	7	except	except	IN
47658	607	8	that	that	IN
47658	607	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	607	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	607	11	what	what	WP
47658	607	12	works	work	VBZ
47658	607	13	,	,	,
47658	607	14	were	be	VBD
47658	607	15	there	there	RB
47658	607	16	no	no	DT
47658	607	17	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	607	18	independent	independent	JJ
47658	607	19	of	of	IN
47658	607	20	and	and	CC
47658	607	21	altogether	altogether	RB
47658	607	22	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	607	23	from	from	IN
47658	607	24	the	the	DT
47658	607	25	practical	practical	JJ
47658	607	26	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	607	27	of	of	IN
47658	607	28	belief	belief	NN
47658	607	29	,	,	,
47658	607	30	of	of	IN
47658	607	31	what	what	WDT
47658	607	32	value	value	NN
47658	607	33	to	to	IN
47658	607	34	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	607	35	would	would	MD
47658	607	36	the	the	DT
47658	607	37	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	607	38	be	be	VB
47658	607	39	?	?	.
47658	608	1	If	if	IN
47658	608	2	the	the	DT
47658	608	3	meaning	mean	VBG
47658	608	4	the	the	DT
47658	608	5	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	608	6	assigns	assign	VBZ
47658	608	7	to	to	IN
47658	608	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	608	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	608	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	608	11	not	not	RB
47658	608	12	true	true	JJ
47658	608	13	,	,	,
47658	608	14	how	how	WRB
47658	608	15	can	can	MD
47658	608	16	the	the	DT
47658	608	17	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	608	18	serve	serve	VB
47658	608	19	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	608	20	?	?	.
47658	609	1	The	the	DT
47658	609	2	very	very	JJ
47658	609	3	essence	essence	NN
47658	609	4	of	of	IN
47658	609	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	609	6	service	service	NN
47658	609	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	609	8	reduced	reduce	VBN
47658	609	9	to	to	IN
47658	609	10	nought	nought	NN
47658	609	11	;	;	:
47658	609	12	for	for	IN
47658	609	13	what	what	WP
47658	609	14	else	else	RB
47658	609	15	but	but	CC
47658	609	16	the	the	DT
47658	609	17	conception	conception	NN
47658	609	18	of	of	IN
47658	609	19	an	an	DT
47658	609	20	objective	objective	JJ
47658	609	21	truth	truth	NN
47658	609	22	,	,	,
47658	609	23	a	a	DT
47658	609	24	logical	logical	JJ
47658	609	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	609	26	independent	independent	JJ
47658	609	27	of	of	IN
47658	609	28	any	any	DT
47658	609	29	and	and	CC
47658	609	30	every	every	DT
47658	609	31	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	609	32	condition	condition	NN
47658	609	33	,	,	,
47658	609	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	609	35	the	the	DT
47658	609	36	utility	utility	NN
47658	609	37	that	that	IN
47658	609	38	the	the	DT
47658	609	39	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	609	40	puts	put	VBZ
47658	609	41	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	609	42	in	in	IN
47658	609	43	possession	possession	NN
47658	609	44	of	of	IN
47658	609	45	?	?	.
47658	610	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	610	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	610	3	this	this	DT
47658	610	4	conception	conception	NN
47658	610	5	alone	alone	RB
47658	610	6	that	that	WDT
47658	610	7	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
47658	610	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	610	9	an	an	DT
47658	610	10	effective	effective	JJ
47658	610	11	mode	mode	NN
47658	610	12	of	of	IN
47658	610	13	activity	activity	NN
47658	610	14	.	.	.
47658	611	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
47658	611	2	,	,	,
47658	611	3	if	if	IN
47658	611	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	611	5	hold	hold	VBP
47658	611	6	with	with	IN
47658	611	7	the	the	DT
47658	611	8	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	611	9	that	that	IN
47658	611	10	the	the	DT
47658	611	11	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	611	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	611	13	subservient	subservient	JJ
47658	611	14	to	to	IN
47658	611	15	life	life	NN
47658	611	16	,	,	,
47658	611	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	611	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	611	19	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	611	20	a	a	DT
47658	611	21	utility	utility	NN
47658	611	22	,	,	,
47658	611	23	but	but	CC
47658	611	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	611	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	611	26	a	a	DT
47658	611	27	utility	utility	NN
47658	611	28	just	just	RB
47658	611	29	because	because	IN
47658	611	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	611	31	has	have	VBZ
47658	611	32	a	a	DT
47658	611	33	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	611	34	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	611	35	from	from	IN
47658	611	36	usefulness	usefulness	NN
47658	611	37	.	.	.
47658	612	1	On	on	IN
47658	612	2	the	the	DT
47658	612	3	other	other	JJ
47658	612	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	612	5	,	,	,
47658	612	6	to	to	TO
47658	612	7	condemn	condemn	VB
47658	612	8	any	any	DT
47658	612	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	612	10	as	as	IN
47658	612	11	"	"	``
47658	612	12	useless	useless	JJ
47658	612	13	"	"	''
47658	612	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	612	15	to	to	TO
47658	612	16	deny	deny	VB
47658	612	17	utility	utility	NN
47658	612	18	to	to	IN
47658	612	19	the	the	DT
47658	612	20	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	612	21	.	.	.
47658	613	1	Before	before	IN
47658	613	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	613	3	try	try	VBP
47658	613	4	to	to	TO
47658	613	5	show	show	VB
47658	613	6	that	that	IN
47658	613	7	the	the	DT
47658	613	8	logical	logical	JJ
47658	613	9	method	method	NN
47658	613	10	of	of	IN
47658	613	11	the	the	DT
47658	613	12	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	613	13	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	613	14	,	,	,
47658	613	15	which	which	WDT
47658	613	16	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	613	17	condemns	condemn	VBZ
47658	613	18	because	because	IN
47658	613	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	613	20	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	613	21	to	to	IN
47658	613	22	"	"	``
47658	613	23	useless	useless	JJ
47658	613	24	"	"	''
47658	613	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	613	26	,	,	,
47658	613	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	613	28	identical	identical	JJ
47658	613	29	in	in	IN
47658	613	30	every	every	DT
47658	613	31	respect	respect	NN
47658	613	32	with	with	IN
47658	613	33	the	the	DT
47658	613	34	method	method	NN
47658	613	35	employed	employ	VBN
47658	613	36	in	in	IN
47658	613	37	pure	pure	JJ
47658	613	38	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
47658	613	39	and	and	CC
47658	613	40	physics	physics	NN
47658	613	41	,	,	,
47658	613	42	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	613	43	will	will	MD
47658	613	44	give	give	VB
47658	613	45	for	for	IN
47658	613	46	comparison	comparison	NN
47658	613	47	two	two	CD
47658	613	48	illustrations	illustration	NNS
47658	613	49	{	{	-LRB-
47658	613	50	58	58	CD
47658	613	51	}	}	-RRB-
47658	613	52	that	that	WDT
47658	613	53	seem	seem	VBP
47658	613	54	to	to	IN
47658	613	55	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	613	56	instances	instance	NNS
47658	613	57	of	of	IN
47658	613	58	a	a	DT
47658	613	59	narrow	narrow	JJ
47658	613	60	and	and	CC
47658	613	61	of	of	IN
47658	613	62	a	a	DT
47658	613	63	wide	wide	JJ
47658	613	64	use	use	NN
47658	613	65	of	of	IN
47658	613	66	the	the	DT
47658	613	67	concept	concept	NN
47658	613	68	of	of	IN
47658	613	69	utility	utility	NN
47658	613	70	.	.	.
47658	614	1	A	a	DT
47658	614	2	short	short	JJ
47658	614	3	time	time	NN
47658	614	4	ago	ago	IN
47658	614	5	an	an	DT
47658	614	6	orang	orang	JJ
47658	614	7	-	-	HYPH
47658	614	8	utang	utang	NN
47658	614	9	escaped	escape	VBD
47658	614	10	from	from	IN
47658	614	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	614	12	cage	cage	NN
47658	614	13	in	in	IN
47658	614	14	the	the	DT
47658	614	15	Zoological	Zoological	NNP
47658	614	16	Gardens	Gardens	NNPS
47658	614	17	under	under	IN
47658	614	18	somewhat	somewhat	RB
47658	614	19	singular	singular	JJ
47658	614	20	and	and	CC
47658	614	21	very	very	RB
47658	614	22	interesting	interesting	JJ
47658	614	23	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
47658	614	24	.	.	.
47658	615	1	The	the	DT
47658	615	2	cage	cage	NN
47658	615	3	was	be	VBD
47658	615	4	secured	secure	VBN
47658	615	5	with	with	IN
47658	615	6	meshed	mesh	VBN
47658	615	7	wire	wire	NN
47658	615	8	of	of	IN
47658	615	9	great	great	JJ
47658	615	10	strength	strength	NN
47658	615	11	,	,	,
47658	615	12	judged	judge	VBN
47658	615	13	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
47658	615	14	to	to	TO
47658	615	15	resist	resist	VB
47658	615	16	the	the	DT
47658	615	17	direct	direct	JJ
47658	615	18	impact	impact	NN
47658	615	19	of	of	IN
47658	615	20	the	the	DT
47658	615	21	most	most	RBS
47658	615	22	powerful	powerful	JJ
47658	615	23	of	of	IN
47658	615	24	the	the	DT
47658	615	25	carnivora	carnivora	NN
47658	615	26	;	;	:
47658	615	27	but	but	CC
47658	615	28	the	the	DT
47658	615	29	ape	ape	NN
47658	615	30	,	,	,
47658	615	31	by	by	IN
47658	615	32	attention	attention	NN
47658	615	33	to	to	IN
47658	615	34	the	the	DT
47658	615	35	twisting	twisting	NN
47658	615	36	of	of	IN
47658	615	37	the	the	DT
47658	615	38	plied	ply	VBN
47658	615	39	wire	wire	NN
47658	615	40	,	,	,
47658	615	41	had	have	VBD
47658	615	42	by	by	IN
47658	615	43	constant	constant	JJ
47658	615	44	trying	trying	NN
47658	615	45	succeeded	succeed	VBN
47658	615	46	in	in	IN
47658	615	47	loosening	loosening	NN
47658	615	48	and	and	CC
47658	615	49	finally	finally	RB
47658	615	50	in	in	IN
47658	615	51	unwinding	unwind	VBG
47658	615	52	a	a	DT
47658	615	53	large	large	JJ
47658	615	54	section	section	NN
47658	615	55	.	.	.
47658	616	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	616	2	escaped	escape	VBD
47658	616	3	from	from	IN
47658	616	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	616	5	enclosure	enclosure	NN
47658	616	6	,	,	,
47658	616	7	and	and	CC
47658	616	8	after	after	IN
47658	616	9	doing	do	VBG
47658	616	10	considerable	considerable	JJ
47658	616	11	damage	damage	NN
47658	616	12	in	in	IN
47658	616	13	the	the	DT
47658	616	14	corridor	corridor	NN
47658	616	15	,	,	,
47658	616	16	including	include	VBG
47658	616	17	the	the	DT
47658	616	18	tearing	tearing	NN
47658	616	19	out	out	IN
47658	616	20	of	of	IN
47658	616	21	a	a	DT
47658	616	22	window	window	NN
47658	616	23	frame	frame	NN
47658	616	24	,	,	,
47658	616	25	made	make	VBD
47658	616	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	616	27	way	way	NN
47658	616	28	into	into	IN
47658	616	29	the	the	DT
47658	616	30	grounds	ground	NNS
47658	616	31	and	and	CC
47658	616	32	took	take	VBD
47658	616	33	refuge	refuge	NN
47658	616	34	in	in	IN
47658	616	35	a	a	DT
47658	616	36	tree	tree	NN
47658	616	37	,	,	,
47658	616	38	twisting	twist	VBG
47658	616	39	the	the	DT
47658	616	40	branches	branch	NNS
47658	616	41	into	into	IN
47658	616	42	a	a	DT
47658	616	43	platform	platform	NN
47658	616	44	said	say	VBN
47658	616	45	to	to	TO
47658	616	46	be	be	VB
47658	616	47	similar	similar	JJ
47658	616	48	to	to	IN
47658	616	49	the	the	DT
47658	616	50	constructions	construction	NNS
47658	616	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	616	52	makes	make	VBZ
47658	616	53	in	in	IN
47658	616	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	616	55	native	native	JJ
47658	616	56	forests	forest	NNS
47658	616	57	.	.	.
47658	617	1	In	in	IN
47658	617	2	taking	take	VBG
47658	617	3	this	this	DT
47658	617	4	action	action	NN
47658	617	5	as	as	IN
47658	617	6	an	an	DT
47658	617	7	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	617	8	,	,	,
47658	617	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	617	10	am	be	VBP
47658	617	11	not	not	RB
47658	617	12	concerned	concerned	JJ
47658	617	13	with	with	IN
47658	617	14	the	the	DT
47658	617	15	question	question	NN
47658	617	16	of	of	IN
47658	617	17	what	what	WP
47658	617	18	may	may	MD
47658	617	19	be	be	VB
47658	617	20	the	the	DT
47658	617	21	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	617	22	between	between	IN
47658	617	23	action	action	NN
47658	617	24	that	that	WDT
47658	617	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	617	26	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
47658	617	27	and	and	CC
47658	617	28	action	action	NN
47658	617	29	that	that	WDT
47658	617	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	617	31	instinctive	instinctive	JJ
47658	617	32	.	.	.
47658	618	1	If	if	IN
47658	618	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	618	3	take	take	VBP
47658	618	4	intelligence	intelligence	NN
47658	618	5	in	in	IN
47658	618	6	a	a	DT
47658	618	7	wide	wide	JJ
47658	618	8	and	and	CC
47658	618	9	general	general	JJ
47658	618	10	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	618	11	,	,	,
47658	618	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	618	13	may	may	MD
47658	618	14	compare	compare	VB
47658	618	15	the	the	DT
47658	618	16	intelligence	intelligence	NN
47658	618	17	shown	show	VBN
47658	618	18	by	by	IN
47658	618	19	this	this	DT
47658	618	20	ape	ape	NN
47658	618	21	with	with	IN
47658	618	22	the	the	DT
47658	618	23	intelligence	intelligence	NN
47658	618	24	shown	show	VBN
47658	618	25	by	by	IN
47658	618	26	man	man	NN
47658	618	27	in	in	IN
47658	618	28	the	the	DT
47658	618	29	highest	high	JJS
47658	618	30	processes	process	NNS
47658	618	31	of	of	IN
47658	618	32	the	the	DT
47658	618	33	mind	mind	NN
47658	618	34	.	.	.
47658	619	1	Psychologists	psychologist	NNS
47658	619	2	would	would	MD
47658	619	3	,	,	,
47658	619	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	619	5	think	think	VBP
47658	619	6	,	,	,
47658	619	7	be	be	VB
47658	619	8	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
47658	619	9	in	in	IN
47658	619	10	holding	hold	VBG
47658	619	11	that	that	IN
47658	619	12	in	in	IN
47658	619	13	the	the	DT
47658	619	14	mind	mind	NN
47658	619	15	of	of	IN
47658	619	16	the	the	DT
47658	619	17	ape	ape	NN
47658	619	18	there	there	EX
47658	619	19	was	be	VBD
47658	619	20	no	no	DT
47658	619	21	conception	conception	NN
47658	619	22	of	of	IN
47658	619	23	freedom	freedom	NN
47658	619	24	,	,	,
47658	619	25	no	no	DT
47658	619	26	kind	kind	NN
47658	619	27	of	of	IN
47658	619	28	mental	mental	JJ
47658	619	29	image	image	NN
47658	619	30	of	of	IN
47658	619	31	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
47658	619	32	life	life	NN
47658	619	33	and	and	CC
47658	619	34	of	of	IN
47658	619	35	a	a	DT
47658	619	36	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	619	37	means	mean	NNS
47658	619	38	of	of	IN
47658	619	39	attaining	attain	VBG
47658	619	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	619	41	,	,	,
47658	619	42	no	no	DT
47658	619	43	clearly	clearly	RB
47658	619	44	purposed	purpose	VBN
47658	619	45	end	end	NN
47658	619	46	,	,	,
47658	619	47	the	the	DT
47658	619	48	means	mean	NNS
47658	619	49	of	of	IN
47658	619	50	attaining	attaining	NN
47658	619	51	which	which	WDT
47658	619	52	was	be	VBD
47658	619	53	what	what	WP
47658	619	54	prompted	prompt	VBD
47658	619	55	the	the	DT
47658	619	56	undoing	undoing	NN
47658	619	57	of	of	IN
47658	619	58	the	the	DT
47658	619	59	wire	wire	NN
47658	619	60	,	,	,
47658	619	61	such	such	JJ
47658	619	62	as	as	IN
47658	619	63	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	619	64	should	should	MD
47658	619	65	certainly	certainly	RB
47658	619	66	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	619	67	in	in	IN
47658	619	68	the	the	DT
47658	619	69	case	case	NN
47658	619	70	of	of	IN
47658	619	71	a	a	DT
47658	619	72	man	man	NN
47658	619	73	in	in	IN
47658	619	74	a	a	DT
47658	619	75	similar	similar	JJ
47658	619	76	situation	situation	NN
47658	619	77	.	.	.
47658	620	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	620	2	was	be	VBD
47658	620	3	the	the	DT
47658	620	4	kind	kind	NN
47658	620	5	of	of	IN
47658	620	6	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
47658	620	7	action	action	NN
47658	620	8	that	that	WDT
47658	620	9	psychologists	psychologist	VBZ
47658	620	10	denote	denote	VB
47658	620	11	by	by	IN
47658	620	12	the	the	DT
47658	620	13	description	description	NN
47658	620	14	"	"	''
47658	620	15	trial	trial	NN
47658	620	16	and	and	CC
47658	620	17	error	error	NN
47658	620	18	.	.	.
47658	620	19	"	"	''
47658	621	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	621	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	621	3	to	to	IN
47658	621	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	621	5	,	,	,
47658	621	6	however	however	RB
47658	621	7	,	,	,
47658	621	8	that	that	IN
47658	621	9	this	this	DT
47658	621	10	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	621	11	fulfils	fulfil	VBZ
47658	621	12	the	the	DT
47658	621	13	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	621	14	that	that	WDT
47658	621	15	the	the	DT
47658	621	16	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	621	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	621	18	of	of	IN
47658	621	19	the	the	DT
47658	621	20	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	621	21	of	of	IN
47658	621	22	truth	truth	NN
47658	621	23	require	require	VBP
47658	621	24	.	.	.
47658	622	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	622	2	see	see	VBP
47658	622	3	the	the	DT
47658	622	4	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	622	5	of	of	IN
47658	622	6	the	the	DT
47658	622	7	ape	ape	NN
47658	622	8	making	make	VBG
47658	622	9	true	true	JJ
47658	622	10	by	by	IN
47658	622	11	finding	find	VBG
47658	622	12	out	out	RP
47658	622	13	what	what	WP
47658	622	14	works	work	VBZ
47658	622	15	.	.	.
47658	623	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	623	2	59	59	CD
47658	623	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	623	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	623	5	can	can	MD
47658	623	6	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	623	7	an	an	DT
47658	623	8	entire	entire	JJ
47658	623	9	absence	absence	NN
47658	623	10	of	of	IN
47658	623	11	the	the	DT
47658	623	12	idea	idea	NN
47658	623	13	of	of	IN
47658	623	14	objective	objective	JJ
47658	623	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	623	16	to	to	TO
47658	623	17	which	which	WDT
47658	623	18	reality	reality	NN
47658	623	19	must	must	MD
47658	623	20	conform	conform	VB
47658	623	21	,	,	,
47658	623	22	of	of	IN
47658	623	23	truth	truth	NN
47658	623	24	unaffected	unaffected	JJ
47658	623	25	by	by	IN
47658	623	26	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	623	27	.	.	.
47658	624	1	Here	here	RB
47658	624	2	,	,	,
47658	624	3	then	then	RB
47658	624	4	,	,	,
47658	624	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	624	6	seem	seem	VBP
47658	624	7	to	to	TO
47658	624	8	have	have	VB
47658	624	9	the	the	DT
47658	624	10	pure	pure	JJ
47658	624	11	type	type	NN
47658	624	12	of	of	IN
47658	624	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	624	14	in	in	IN
47658	624	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	624	16	simplest	simple	JJS
47658	624	17	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	624	18	,	,	,
47658	624	19	a	a	DT
47658	624	20	practical	practical	JJ
47658	624	21	activity	activity	NN
47658	624	22	using	use	VBG
47658	624	23	intelligence	intelligence	NN
47658	624	24	to	to	TO
47658	624	25	discover	discover	VB
47658	624	26	what	what	WP
47658	624	27	works	work	VBZ
47658	624	28	.	.	.
47658	625	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	625	2	the	the	DT
47658	625	3	difference	difference	NN
47658	625	4	between	between	IN
47658	625	5	this	this	DT
47658	625	6	practical	practical	JJ
47658	625	7	activity	activity	NN
47658	625	8	and	and	CC
47658	625	9	the	the	DT
47658	625	10	higher	high	JJR
47658	625	11	mental	mental	JJ
47658	625	12	activities	activity	NNS
47658	625	13	as	as	IN
47658	625	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	625	15	employ	employ	VBP
47658	625	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	625	17	in	in	IN
47658	625	18	the	the	DT
47658	625	19	abstract	abstract	JJ
47658	625	20	sciences	science	NNS
47658	625	21	one	one	CD
47658	625	22	of	of	IN
47658	625	23	degree	degree	NN
47658	625	24	of	of	IN
47658	625	25	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	625	26	only	only	RB
47658	625	27	,	,	,
47658	625	28	or	or	CC
47658	625	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	625	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	625	31	different	different	JJ
47658	625	32	in	in	IN
47658	625	33	kind	kind	NN
47658	625	34	?	?	.
47658	626	1	Let	let	VB
47658	626	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	626	3	consider	consider	VB
47658	626	4	now	now	RB
47658	626	5	,	,	,
47658	626	6	as	as	IN
47658	626	7	an	an	DT
47658	626	8	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	626	9	of	of	IN
47658	626	10	the	the	DT
47658	626	11	method	method	NN
47658	626	12	of	of	IN
47658	626	13	the	the	DT
47658	626	14	abstract	abstract	JJ
47658	626	15	sciences	science	NNS
47658	626	16	,	,	,
47658	626	17	the	the	DT
47658	626	18	well	well	RB
47658	626	19	-	-	HYPH
47658	626	20	known	know	VBN
47658	626	21	case	case	NN
47658	626	22	of	of	IN
47658	626	23	the	the	DT
47658	626	24	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	626	25	of	of	IN
47658	626	26	the	the	DT
47658	626	27	planet	planet	NN
47658	626	28	Neptune	Neptune	NNP
47658	626	29	.	.	.
47658	627	1	This	this	DT
47658	627	2	planet	planet	NN
47658	627	3	was	be	VBD
47658	627	4	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	627	5	by	by	IN
47658	627	6	calculation	calculation	NN
47658	627	7	and	and	CC
47658	627	8	deduction	deduction	NN
47658	627	9	,	,	,
47658	627	10	and	and	CC
47658	627	11	was	be	VBD
47658	627	12	only	only	RB
47658	627	13	seen	see	VBN
47658	627	14	when	when	WRB
47658	627	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	627	16	position	position	NN
47658	627	17	had	have	VBD
47658	627	18	been	be	VBN
47658	627	19	so	so	RB
47658	627	20	accurately	accurately	RB
47658	627	21	determined	determine	VBN
47658	627	22	that	that	IN
47658	627	23	the	the	DT
47658	627	24	astronomers	astronomer	NNS
47658	627	25	who	who	WP
47658	627	26	searched	search	VBD
47658	627	27	for	for	IN
47658	627	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	627	29	knew	know	VBD
47658	627	30	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	627	31	the	the	DT
47658	627	32	point	point	NN
47658	627	33	of	of	IN
47658	627	34	the	the	DT
47658	627	35	heavens	heaven	NNS
47658	627	36	to	to	TO
47658	627	37	which	which	WDT
47658	627	38	to	to	TO
47658	627	39	direct	direct	VB
47658	627	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	627	41	telescopes	telescope	NNS
47658	627	42	.	.	.
47658	628	1	The	the	DT
47658	628	2	calculation	calculation	NN
47658	628	3	was	be	VBD
47658	628	4	one	one	CD
47658	628	5	of	of	IN
47658	628	6	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
47658	628	7	intricacy	intricacy	NN
47658	628	8	,	,	,
47658	628	9	and	and	CC
47658	628	10	was	be	VBD
47658	628	11	made	make	VBN
47658	628	12	independently	independently	RB
47658	628	13	by	by	IN
47658	628	14	two	two	CD
47658	628	15	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
47658	628	16	,	,	,
47658	628	17	Adams	Adams	NNP
47658	628	18	of	of	IN
47658	628	19	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
47658	628	20	and	and	CC
47658	628	21	Leverrier	Leverrier	NNP
47658	628	22	of	of	IN
47658	628	23	Paris	Paris	NNP
47658	628	24	,	,	,
47658	628	25	between	between	IN
47658	628	26	the	the	DT
47658	628	27	years	year	NNS
47658	628	28	1843	1843	CD
47658	628	29	and	and	CC
47658	628	30	1846	1846	CD
47658	628	31	.	.	.
47658	629	1	Each	each	DT
47658	629	2	communicated	communicate	VBD
47658	629	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	629	4	result	result	NN
47658	629	5	independently	independently	RB
47658	629	6	--	--	:
47658	629	7	Adams	Adams	NNP
47658	629	8	to	to	IN
47658	629	9	the	the	DT
47658	629	10	astronomer	astronomer	NN
47658	629	11	Challis	Challis	NNP
47658	629	12	,	,	,
47658	629	13	the	the	DT
47658	629	14	Director	Director	NNP
47658	629	15	of	of	IN
47658	629	16	the	the	DT
47658	629	17	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
47658	629	18	Observatory	Observatory	NNP
47658	629	19	,	,	,
47658	629	20	and	and	CC
47658	629	21	Leverrier	Leverrier	NNP
47658	629	22	to	to	IN
47658	629	23	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	629	24	Galle	Galle	NNP
47658	629	25	of	of	IN
47658	629	26	the	the	DT
47658	629	27	Berlin	Berlin	NNP
47658	629	28	Observatory	Observatory	NNP
47658	629	29	.	.	.
47658	630	1	Within	within	IN
47658	630	2	six	six	CD
47658	630	3	weeks	week	NNS
47658	630	4	of	of	IN
47658	630	5	one	one	CD
47658	630	6	another	another	DT
47658	630	7	and	and	CC
47658	630	8	entirely	entirely	RB
47658	630	9	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	630	10	to	to	IN
47658	630	11	one	one	CD
47658	630	12	another	another	DT
47658	630	13	,	,	,
47658	630	14	in	in	IN
47658	630	15	August	August	NNP
47658	630	16	and	and	CC
47658	630	17	September	September	NNP
47658	630	18	1846	1846	CD
47658	630	19	,	,	,
47658	630	20	each	each	DT
47658	630	21	of	of	IN
47658	630	22	these	these	DT
47658	630	23	astronomers	astronomer	NNS
47658	630	24	observed	observe	VBD
47658	630	25	the	the	DT
47658	630	26	planet	planet	NN
47658	630	27	where	where	WRB
47658	630	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	630	29	had	have	VBD
47658	630	30	been	be	VBN
47658	630	31	told	tell	VBN
47658	630	32	to	to	TO
47658	630	33	look	look	VB
47658	630	34	for	for	IN
47658	630	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	630	36	.	.	.
47658	631	1	This	this	DT
47658	631	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	631	3	one	one	CD
47658	631	4	of	of	IN
47658	631	5	the	the	DT
47658	631	6	romances	romance	NNS
47658	631	7	of	of	IN
47658	631	8	modern	modern	JJ
47658	631	9	science	science	NN
47658	631	10	.	.	.
47658	632	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	632	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	632	3	not	not	RB
47658	632	4	the	the	DT
47658	632	5	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	632	6	but	but	CC
47658	632	7	the	the	DT
47658	632	8	method	method	NN
47658	632	9	that	that	WDT
47658	632	10	led	lead	VBD
47658	632	11	to	to	IN
47658	632	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	632	13	which	which	WDT
47658	632	14	may	may	MD
47658	632	15	throw	throw	VB
47658	632	16	light	light	NN
47658	632	17	on	on	IN
47658	632	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	632	19	problem	problem	NN
47658	632	20	of	of	IN
47658	632	21	the	the	DT
47658	632	22	nature	nature	NN
47658	632	23	of	of	IN
47658	632	24	truth	truth	NN
47658	632	25	.	.	.
47658	633	1	At	at	IN
47658	633	2	first	first	JJ
47658	633	3	sight	sight	NN
47658	633	4	this	this	DT
47658	633	5	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	633	6	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	633	7	to	to	TO
47658	633	8	accord	accord	VB
47658	633	9	with	with	IN
47658	633	10	and	and	CC
47658	633	11	even	even	RB
47658	633	12	to	to	TO
47658	633	13	illustrate	illustrate	VB
47658	633	14	the	the	DT
47658	633	15	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	633	16	theory	theory	NN
47658	633	17	,	,	,
47658	633	18	that	that	DT
47658	633	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	633	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	633	21	what	what	WP
47658	633	22	works	work	VBZ
47658	633	23	.	.	.
47658	634	1	The	the	DT
47658	634	2	investigation	investigation	NN
47658	634	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	634	4	prompted	prompt	VBN
47658	634	5	by	by	IN
47658	634	6	the	the	DT
47658	634	7	discrepancies	discrepancy	NNS
47658	634	8	between	between	IN
47658	634	9	the	the	DT
47658	634	10	actual	actual	JJ
47658	634	11	and	and	CC
47658	634	12	the	the	DT
47658	634	13	calculated	calculate	VBN
47658	634	14	positions	position	NNS
47658	634	15	of	of	IN
47658	634	16	Uranus	Uranus	NNP
47658	634	17	,	,	,
47658	634	18	the	the	DT
47658	634	19	outermost	outermost	JJ
47658	634	20	planet	planet	NN
47658	634	21	,	,	,
47658	634	22	as	as	IN
47658	634	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	634	24	was	be	VBD
47658	634	25	then	then	RB
47658	634	26	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	634	27	,	,	,
47658	634	28	of	of	IN
47658	634	29	the	the	DT
47658	634	30	system	system	NN
47658	634	31	.	.	.
47658	635	1	This	this	DT
47658	635	2	revealed	reveal	VBD
47658	635	3	a	a	DT
47658	635	4	need	need	NN
47658	635	5	,	,	,
47658	635	6	and	and	CC
47658	635	7	this	this	DT
47658	635	8	{	{	-LRB-
47658	635	9	60	60	CD
47658	635	10	}	}	-RRB-
47658	635	11	need	need	NN
47658	635	12	was	be	VBD
47658	635	13	met	meet	VBN
47658	635	14	by	by	IN
47658	635	15	the	the	DT
47658	635	16	practical	practical	JJ
47658	635	17	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	635	18	of	of	IN
47658	635	19	the	the	DT
47658	635	20	existence	existence	NN
47658	635	21	of	of	IN
47658	635	22	another	another	DT
47658	635	23	planet	planet	NN
47658	635	24	as	as	RB
47658	635	25	yet	yet	RB
47658	635	26	unseen	unseen	JJ
47658	635	27	.	.	.
47658	636	1	The	the	DT
47658	636	2	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	636	3	was	be	VBD
47658	636	4	found	find	VBN
47658	636	5	to	to	TO
47658	636	6	work	work	VB
47658	636	7	even	even	RB
47658	636	8	before	before	IN
47658	636	9	the	the	DT
47658	636	10	actual	actual	JJ
47658	636	11	observation	observation	NN
47658	636	12	put	put	VBD
47658	636	13	the	the	DT
47658	636	14	final	final	JJ
47658	636	15	seal	seal	NN
47658	636	16	of	of	IN
47658	636	17	actuality	actuality	NN
47658	636	18	on	on	IN
47658	636	19	the	the	DT
47658	636	20	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	636	21	.	.	.
47658	637	1	What	what	WP
47658	637	2	else	else	RB
47658	637	3	but	but	CC
47658	637	4	the	the	DT
47658	637	5	practical	practical	JJ
47658	637	6	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	637	7	of	of	IN
47658	637	8	the	the	DT
47658	637	9	truth	truth	NN
47658	637	10	claim	claim	NN
47658	637	11	in	in	IN
47658	637	12	the	the	DT
47658	637	13	form	form	NN
47658	637	14	of	of	IN
47658	637	15	the	the	DT
47658	637	16	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	637	17	of	of	IN
47658	637	18	an	an	DT
47658	637	19	undiscovered	undiscovered	JJ
47658	637	20	planet	planet	NN
47658	637	21	were	be	VBD
47658	637	22	ever	ever	RB
47658	637	23	in	in	IN
47658	637	24	question	question	NN
47658	637	25	?	?	.
47658	638	1	Yes	yes	UH
47658	638	2	,	,	,
47658	638	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	638	4	reply	reply	VBP
47658	638	5	,	,	,
47658	638	6	but	but	CC
47658	638	7	the	the	DT
47658	638	8	actual	actual	JJ
47658	638	9	method	method	NN
47658	638	10	adopted	adopt	VBN
47658	638	11	,	,	,
47658	638	12	and	and	CC
47658	638	13	the	the	DT
47658	638	14	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	638	15	sought	seek	VBN
47658	638	16	for	for	IN
47658	638	17	by	by	IN
47658	638	18	the	the	DT
47658	638	19	method	method	NN
47658	638	20	,	,	,
47658	638	21	are	be	VBP
47658	638	22	precisely	precisely	RB
47658	638	23	of	of	IN
47658	638	24	the	the	DT
47658	638	25	kind	kind	NN
47658	638	26	that	that	WDT
47658	638	27	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	638	28	rejects	reject	VBZ
47658	638	29	as	as	IN
47658	638	30	"	"	``
47658	638	31	useless	useless	JJ
47658	638	32	"	"	''
47658	638	33	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	638	34	.	.	.
47658	639	1	Why	why	WRB
47658	639	2	were	be	VBD
47658	639	3	not	not	RB
47658	639	4	the	the	DT
47658	639	5	observed	observed	JJ
47658	639	6	movements	movement	NNS
47658	639	7	of	of	IN
47658	639	8	Uranus	Uranus	NNP
47658	639	9	accepted	accept	VBD
47658	639	10	as	as	IN
47658	639	11	what	what	WP
47658	639	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	639	13	were	be	VBD
47658	639	14	?	?	.
47658	640	1	Why	why	WRB
47658	640	2	was	be	VBD
47658	640	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	640	4	felt	feel	VBN
47658	640	5	that	that	IN
47658	640	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	640	7	must	must	MD
47658	640	8	be	be	VB
47658	640	9	other	other	JJ
47658	640	10	than	than	IN
47658	640	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	640	12	were	be	VBD
47658	640	13	seen	see	VBN
47658	640	14	to	to	TO
47658	640	15	be	be	VB
47658	640	16	unless	unless	IN
47658	640	17	there	there	EX
47658	640	18	was	be	VBD
47658	640	19	another	another	DT
47658	640	20	planet	planet	NN
47658	640	21	?	?	.
47658	641	1	The	the	DT
47658	641	2	need	need	NN
47658	641	3	lay	lie	VBD
47658	641	4	in	in	IN
47658	641	5	the	the	DT
47658	641	6	idea	idea	NN
47658	641	7	of	of	IN
47658	641	8	system	system	NN
47658	641	9	.	.	.
47658	642	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	642	2	was	be	VBD
47658	642	3	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
47658	642	4	with	with	IN
47658	642	5	the	the	DT
47658	642	6	system	system	NN
47658	642	7	then	then	RB
47658	642	8	believed	believe	VBD
47658	642	9	complete	complete	JJ
47658	642	10	,	,	,
47658	642	11	and	and	CC
47658	642	12	the	the	DT
47658	642	13	need	need	NN
47658	642	14	was	be	VBD
47658	642	15	to	to	TO
47658	642	16	find	find	VB
47658	642	17	the	the	DT
47658	642	18	complete	complete	JJ
47658	642	19	system	system	NN
47658	642	20	in	in	IN
47658	642	21	which	which	WDT
47658	642	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	642	23	would	would	MD
47658	642	24	harmonise	harmonise	VB
47658	642	25	.	.	.
47658	643	1	The	the	DT
47658	643	2	truth	truth	NN
47658	643	3	that	that	WDT
47658	643	4	was	be	VBD
47658	643	5	sought	seek	VBN
47658	643	6	for	for	IN
47658	643	7	was	be	VBD
47658	643	8	a	a	DT
47658	643	9	harmonious	harmonious	JJ
47658	643	10	individual	individual	JJ
47658	643	11	whole	whole	NN
47658	643	12	,	,	,
47658	643	13	and	and	CC
47658	643	14	the	the	DT
47658	643	15	method	method	NN
47658	643	16	employed	employ	VBD
47658	643	17	precisely	precisely	RB
47658	643	18	that	that	IN
47658	643	19	which	which	WDT
47658	643	20	the	the	DT
47658	643	21	Absolutist	absolutist	JJ
47658	643	22	theory	theory	NN
47658	643	23	of	of	IN
47658	643	24	reality	reality	NN
47658	643	25	employs	employ	NNS
47658	643	26	.	.	.
47658	644	1	There	there	EX
47658	644	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	644	3	observed	observe	VBN
47658	644	4	a	a	DT
47658	644	5	discrepancy	discrepancy	NN
47658	644	6	,	,	,
47658	644	7	an	an	DT
47658	644	8	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
47658	644	9	,	,	,
47658	644	10	a	a	DT
47658	644	11	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	644	12	within	within	IN
47658	644	13	the	the	DT
47658	644	14	whole	whole	JJ
47658	644	15	conceived	conceive	VBD
47658	644	16	as	as	IN
47658	644	17	a	a	DT
47658	644	18	system	system	NN
47658	644	19	.	.	.
47658	645	1	This	this	DT
47658	645	2	negation	negation	NN
47658	645	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	645	4	treated	treat	VBN
47658	645	5	as	as	IN
47658	645	6	a	a	DT
47658	645	7	defect	defect	NN
47658	645	8	,	,	,
47658	645	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	645	10	calculated	calculate	VBN
47658	645	11	and	and	CC
47658	645	12	accurately	accurately	RB
47658	645	13	determined	determined	JJ
47658	645	14	,	,	,
47658	645	15	and	and	CC
47658	645	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	645	17	then	then	RB
47658	645	18	positively	positively	RB
47658	645	19	affirmed	affirm	VBN
47658	645	20	of	of	IN
47658	645	21	the	the	DT
47658	645	22	reality	reality	NN
47658	645	23	.	.	.
47658	646	1	Now	now	RB
47658	646	2	,	,	,
47658	646	3	what	what	WP
47658	646	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	646	5	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
47658	646	6	in	in	IN
47658	646	7	this	this	DT
47658	646	8	method	method	NN
47658	646	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	646	10	that	that	IN
47658	646	11	reality	reality	NN
47658	646	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	646	13	conceived	conceive	VBN
47658	646	14	as	as	IN
47658	646	15	a	a	DT
47658	646	16	complete	complete	JJ
47658	646	17	system	system	NN
47658	646	18	.	.	.
47658	647	1	If	if	IN
47658	647	2	the	the	DT
47658	647	3	felt	feel	VBN
47658	647	4	defect	defect	NN
47658	647	5	in	in	IN
47658	647	6	this	this	DT
47658	647	7	system	system	NN
47658	647	8	can	can	MD
47658	647	9	not	not	RB
47658	647	10	be	be	VB
47658	647	11	made	make	VBN
47658	647	12	good	good	JJ
47658	647	13	by	by	IN
47658	647	14	direct	direct	JJ
47658	647	15	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	647	16	,	,	,
47658	647	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	647	18	place	place	NN
47658	647	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	647	20	supplied	supply	VBN
47658	647	21	by	by	IN
47658	647	22	a	a	DT
47658	647	23	fiction	fiction	NN
47658	647	24	,	,	,
47658	647	25	using	use	VBG
47658	647	26	the	the	DT
47658	647	27	term	term	NN
47658	647	28	in	in	IN
47658	647	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	647	30	etymological	etymological	JJ
47658	647	31	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	647	32	to	to	TO
47658	647	33	express	express	VB
47658	647	34	something	something	NN
47658	647	35	made	make	VBN
47658	647	36	and	and	CC
47658	647	37	not	not	RB
47658	647	38	in	in	IN
47658	647	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	647	40	derived	derive	VBN
47658	647	41	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	647	42	to	to	TO
47658	647	43	express	express	VB
47658	647	44	something	something	NN
47658	647	45	found	find	VBD
47658	647	46	false	false	JJ
47658	647	47	.	.	.
47658	648	1	This	this	DT
47658	648	2	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	648	3	process	process	NN
47658	648	4	of	of	IN
47658	648	5	construction	construction	NN
47658	648	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	648	7	purely	purely	RB
47658	648	8	logical	logical	JJ
47658	648	9	;	;	:
47658	648	10	no	no	DT
47658	648	11	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	648	12	element	element	NN
47658	648	13	in	in	IN
47658	648	14	the	the	DT
47658	648	15	sense	sense	NN
47658	648	16	of	of	IN
47658	648	17	the	the	DT
47658	648	18	will	will	NN
47658	648	19	to	to	TO
47658	648	20	believe	believe	VB
47658	648	21	enters	enter	NNS
47658	648	22	into	into	IN
47658	648	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	648	24	or	or	CC
47658	648	25	colours	colour	VBZ
47658	648	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	648	27	in	in	IN
47658	648	28	any	any	DT
47658	648	29	way	way	NN
47658	648	30	.	.	.
47658	649	1	This	this	DT
47658	649	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	649	3	not	not	RB
47658	649	4	an	an	DT
47658	649	5	isolated	isolated	JJ
47658	649	6	instance	instance	NN
47658	649	7	,	,	,
47658	649	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	649	9	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
47658	649	10	the	the	DT
47658	649	11	method	method	NN
47658	649	12	of	of	IN
47658	649	13	science	science	NN
47658	649	14	in	in	IN
47658	649	15	all	all	DT
47658	649	16	theorising	theorising	NN
47658	649	17	.	.	.
47658	650	1	An	an	DT
47658	650	2	even	even	RB
47658	650	3	more	more	JJR
47658	650	4	{	{	-LRB-
47658	650	5	61	61	CD
47658	650	6	}	}	-RRB-
47658	650	7	striking	strike	VBG
47658	650	8	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	650	9	than	than	IN
47658	650	10	that	that	IN
47658	650	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	650	12	have	have	VBP
47658	650	13	just	just	RB
47658	650	14	given	give	VBN
47658	650	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	650	16	the	the	DT
47658	650	17	case	case	NN
47658	650	18	of	of	IN
47658	650	19	the	the	DT
47658	650	20	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	650	21	of	of	IN
47658	650	22	the	the	DT
47658	650	23	luminiferous	luminiferous	JJ
47658	650	24	æther	æther	NN
47658	650	25	--	--	:
47658	650	26	a	a	DT
47658	650	27	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	650	28	existence	existence	NN
47658	650	29	,	,	,
47658	650	30	a	a	DT
47658	650	31	fiction	fiction	NN
47658	650	32	,	,	,
47658	650	33	that	that	WDT
47658	650	34	has	have	VBZ
47658	650	35	served	serve	VBN
47658	650	36	a	a	DT
47658	650	37	useful	useful	JJ
47658	650	38	,	,	,
47658	650	39	even	even	RB
47658	650	40	an	an	DT
47658	650	41	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
47658	650	42	service	service	NN
47658	650	43	in	in	IN
47658	650	44	the	the	DT
47658	650	45	history	history	NN
47658	650	46	of	of	IN
47658	650	47	modern	modern	JJ
47658	650	48	physics	physics	NN
47658	650	49	.	.	.
47658	651	1	To	to	IN
47658	651	2	many	many	JJ
47658	651	3	physicists	physicist	NNS
47658	651	4	,	,	,
47658	651	5	even	even	RB
47658	651	6	to	to	IN
47658	651	7	Lord	Lord	NNP
47658	651	8	Kelvin	Kelvin	NNP
47658	651	9	,	,	,
47658	651	10	the	the	DT
47658	651	11	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	651	12	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	651	13	so	so	RB
47658	651	14	surely	surely	RB
47658	651	15	established	establish	VBN
47658	651	16	that	that	IN
47658	651	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	651	18	nonexistence	nonexistence	NN
47658	651	19	hardly	hardly	RB
47658	651	20	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	651	21	thinkable	thinkable	JJ
47658	651	22	,	,	,
47658	651	23	yet	yet	CC
47658	651	24	all	all	PDT
47658	651	25	the	the	DT
47658	651	26	experiments	experiment	NNS
47658	651	27	designed	design	VBN
47658	651	28	to	to	TO
47658	651	29	detect	detect	VB
47658	651	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	651	31	presence	presence	NN
47658	651	32	have	have	VBP
47658	651	33	been	be	VBN
47658	651	34	uniformly	uniformly	RB
47658	651	35	negative	negative	JJ
47658	651	36	in	in	IN
47658	651	37	result	result	NN
47658	651	38	,	,	,
47658	651	39	and	and	CC
47658	651	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	651	41	now	now	RB
47658	651	42	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	651	43	not	not	RB
47658	651	44	even	even	RB
47658	651	45	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	651	46	as	as	IN
47658	651	47	a	a	DT
47658	651	48	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	651	49	,	,	,
47658	651	50	and	and	CC
47658	651	51	likely	likely	JJ
47658	651	52	to	to	TO
47658	651	53	disappear	disappear	VB
47658	651	54	.	.	.
47658	652	1	The	the	DT
47658	652	2	æther	æther	NN
47658	652	3	was	be	VBD
47658	652	4	not	not	RB
47658	652	5	only	only	RB
47658	652	6	not	not	RB
47658	652	7	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	652	8	,	,	,
47658	652	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	652	10	was	be	VBD
47658	652	11	not	not	RB
47658	652	12	even	even	RB
47658	652	13	suspected	suspect	VBN
47658	652	14	to	to	TO
47658	652	15	exist	exist	VB
47658	652	16	,	,	,
47658	652	17	as	as	IN
47658	652	18	in	in	IN
47658	652	19	the	the	DT
47658	652	20	case	case	NN
47658	652	21	of	of	IN
47658	652	22	the	the	DT
47658	652	23	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	652	24	planet	planet	NN
47658	652	25	Neptune	Neptune	NNP
47658	652	26	--	--	:
47658	652	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	652	28	was	be	VBD
47658	652	29	logically	logically	RB
47658	652	30	constructed	construct	VBN
47658	652	31	.	.	.
47658	653	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	653	2	was	be	VBD
47658	653	3	required	require	VBN
47658	653	4	to	to	TO
47658	653	5	support	support	VB
47658	653	6	the	the	DT
47658	653	7	theory	theory	NN
47658	653	8	of	of	IN
47658	653	9	the	the	DT
47658	653	10	undulatory	undulatory	JJ
47658	653	11	nature	nature	NN
47658	653	12	of	of	IN
47658	653	13	light	light	NN
47658	653	14	and	and	CC
47658	653	15	to	to	TO
47658	653	16	fulfil	fulfil	VB
47658	653	17	the	the	DT
47658	653	18	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	653	19	of	of	IN
47658	653	20	light	light	JJ
47658	653	21	propagation	propagation	NN
47658	653	22	in	in	IN
47658	653	23	space	space	NN
47658	653	24	.	.	.
47658	654	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	654	2	was	be	VBD
47658	654	3	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	654	4	a	a	DT
47658	654	5	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	654	6	,	,	,
47658	654	7	called	call	VBN
47658	654	8	forth	forth	RB
47658	654	9	by	by	IN
47658	654	10	a	a	DT
47658	654	11	need	need	NN
47658	654	12	--	--	:
47658	654	13	so	so	RB
47658	654	14	far	far	RB
47658	654	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	654	16	may	may	MD
47658	654	17	adopt	adopt	VB
47658	654	18	the	the	DT
47658	654	19	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	654	20	account	account	NN
47658	654	21	.	.	.
47658	655	1	But	but	CC
47658	655	2	what	what	WP
47658	655	3	was	be	VBD
47658	655	4	the	the	DT
47658	655	5	nature	nature	NN
47658	655	6	of	of	IN
47658	655	7	the	the	DT
47658	655	8	need	need	NN
47658	655	9	,	,	,
47658	655	10	and	and	CC
47658	655	11	what	what	WP
47658	655	12	was	be	VBD
47658	655	13	the	the	DT
47658	655	14	method	method	NN
47658	655	15	by	by	IN
47658	655	16	which	which	WDT
47658	655	17	the	the	DT
47658	655	18	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	655	19	was	be	VBD
47658	655	20	called	call	VBN
47658	655	21	forth	forth	RB
47658	655	22	?	?	.
47658	656	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	656	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	656	3	in	in	IN
47658	656	4	answering	answer	VBG
47658	656	5	this	this	DT
47658	656	6	question	question	NN
47658	656	7	that	that	IN
47658	656	8	the	the	DT
47658	656	9	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	656	10	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	656	11	fails	fail	VBZ
47658	656	12	.	.	.
47658	657	1	The	the	DT
47658	657	2	need	need	NN
47658	657	3	was	be	VBD
47658	657	4	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	657	5	in	in	IN
47658	657	6	the	the	DT
47658	657	7	purely	purely	RB
47658	657	8	logical	logical	JJ
47658	657	9	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	657	10	of	of	IN
47658	657	11	the	the	DT
47658	657	12	term	term	NN
47658	657	13	,	,	,
47658	657	14	and	and	CC
47658	657	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	657	16	was	be	VBD
47658	657	17	met	meet	VBN
47658	657	18	by	by	IN
47658	657	19	a	a	DT
47658	657	20	purely	purely	RB
47658	657	21	logical	logical	JJ
47658	657	22	construction	construction	NN
47658	657	23	.	.	.
47658	658	1	The	the	DT
47658	658	2	need	need	NN
47658	658	3	was	be	VBD
47658	658	4	a	a	DT
47658	658	5	practical	practical	JJ
47658	658	6	human	human	JJ
47658	658	7	need	need	NN
47658	658	8	only	only	RB
47658	658	9	in	in	RB
47658	658	10	so	so	RB
47658	658	11	far	far	RB
47658	658	12	as	as	IN
47658	658	13	the	the	DT
47658	658	14	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	658	15	working	work	VBG
47658	658	16	by	by	IN
47658	658	17	logical	logical	JJ
47658	658	18	process	process	NN
47658	658	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	658	20	a	a	DT
47658	658	21	human	human	JJ
47658	658	22	endowment	endowment	NN
47658	658	23	but	but	CC
47658	658	24	not	not	RB
47658	658	25	in	in	IN
47658	658	26	any	any	DT
47658	658	27	personal	personal	JJ
47658	658	28	sense	sense	NN
47658	658	29	such	such	JJ
47658	658	30	as	as	IN
47658	658	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	658	32	conveyed	convey	VBN
47658	658	33	by	by	IN
47658	658	34	the	the	DT
47658	658	35	term	term	NN
47658	658	36	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	658	37	.	.	.
47658	659	1	Willingness	willingness	NN
47658	659	2	or	or	CC
47658	659	3	unwillingness	unwillingness	JJ
47658	659	4	to	to	TO
47658	659	5	believe	believe	VB
47658	659	6	,	,	,
47658	659	7	desire	desire	NN
47658	659	8	,	,	,
47658	659	9	aversion	aversion	NN
47658	659	10	,	,	,
47658	659	11	interest	interest	NN
47658	659	12	were	be	VBD
47658	659	13	all	all	RB
47658	659	14	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	659	15	.	.	.
47658	660	1	Given	give	VBN
47658	660	2	the	the	DT
47658	660	3	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	660	4	,	,	,
47658	660	5	the	the	DT
47658	660	6	logical	logical	JJ
47658	660	7	necessity	necessity	NN
47658	660	8	was	be	VBD
47658	660	9	the	the	DT
47658	660	10	only	only	JJ
47658	660	11	need	need	NN
47658	660	12	that	that	WDT
47658	660	13	called	call	VBN
47658	660	14	forth	forth	RP
47658	660	15	by	by	IN
47658	660	16	logical	logical	JJ
47658	660	17	process	process	NN
47658	660	18	the	the	DT
47658	660	19	"	"	``
47658	660	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	660	21	-	-	HYPH
47658	660	22	claiming	claim	VBG
47658	660	23	"	"	''
47658	660	24	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	660	25	of	of	IN
47658	660	26	the	the	DT
47658	660	27	æther	æther	NN
47658	660	28	.	.	.
47658	661	1	But	but	CC
47658	661	2	even	even	RB
47658	661	3	so	so	RB
47658	661	4	,	,	,
47658	661	5	the	the	DT
47658	661	6	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	661	7	will	will	MD
47658	661	8	urge	urge	VB
47658	661	9	,	,	,
47658	661	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	661	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	661	12	truth	truth	NN
47658	661	13	anything	anything	NN
47658	661	14	else	else	RB
47658	661	15	but	but	CC
47658	661	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	661	17	usefulness	usefulness	NN
47658	661	18	as	as	IN
47658	661	19	shown	show	VBN
47658	661	20	in	in	IN
47658	661	21	the	the	DT
47658	661	22	practical	practical	JJ
47658	661	23	consequences	consequence	NNS
47658	661	24	of	of	IN
47658	661	25	believing	believe	VBG
47658	661	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	661	27	?	?	.
47658	662	1	Was	be	VBD
47658	662	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	662	3	not	not	RB
47658	662	4	true	true	JJ
47658	662	5	while	while	IN
47658	662	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	662	7	was	be	VBD
47658	662	8	useful	useful	JJ
47658	662	9	,	,	,
47658	662	10	and	and	CC
47658	662	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	662	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	662	13	not	not	RB
47658	662	14	only	only	RB
47658	662	15	now	now	RB
47658	662	16	false	false	JJ
47658	662	17	,	,	,
47658	662	18	if	if	IN
47658	662	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	662	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	662	21	false	false	JJ
47658	662	22	,	,	,
47658	662	23	if	if	IN
47658	662	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	662	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	662	26	actually	actually	RB
47658	662	27	discovered	discover	VBN
47658	662	28	not	not	RB
47658	662	29	to	to	TO
47658	662	30	be	be	VB
47658	662	31	useful	useful	JJ
47658	662	32	?	?	.
47658	663	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	663	2	62	62	CD
47658	663	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	663	4	The	the	DT
47658	663	5	reply	reply	NN
47658	663	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	663	7	that	that	IN
47658	663	8	no	no	DT
47658	663	9	mathematician	mathematician	JJ
47658	663	10	or	or	CC
47658	663	11	physicist	physicist	JJ
47658	663	12	would	would	MD
47658	663	13	recognise	recognise	VB
47658	663	14	the	the	DT
47658	663	15	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	663	16	of	of	IN
47658	663	17	working	work	VBG
47658	663	18	with	with	IN
47658	663	19	a	a	DT
47658	663	20	conception	conception	NN
47658	663	21	of	of	IN
47658	663	22	truth	truth	NN
47658	663	23	that	that	WDT
47658	663	24	simply	simply	RB
47658	663	25	identified	identify	VBD
47658	663	26	truth	truth	NN
47658	663	27	with	with	IN
47658	663	28	utility	utility	NN
47658	663	29	,	,	,
47658	663	30	and	and	CC
47658	663	31	for	for	IN
47658	663	32	this	this	DT
47658	663	33	reason	reason	NN
47658	663	34	that	that	IN
47658	663	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	663	36	can	can	MD
47658	663	37	only	only	RB
47658	663	38	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	663	39	reality	reality	NN
47658	663	40	as	as	IN
47658	663	41	a	a	DT
47658	663	42	system	system	NN
47658	663	43	whose	whose	WP$
47658	663	44	truth	truth	NN
47658	663	45	is	be	VBZ
47658	663	46	symbolised	symbolise	VBN
47658	663	47	in	in	IN
47658	663	48	an	an	DT
47658	663	49	equation	equation	NN
47658	663	50	.	.	.
47658	664	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	664	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	664	3	the	the	DT
47658	664	4	system	system	NN
47658	664	5	that	that	WDT
47658	664	6	determines	determine	VBZ
47658	664	7	and	and	CC
47658	664	8	characterises	characterise	VBZ
47658	664	9	the	the	DT
47658	664	10	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	664	11	,	,	,
47658	664	12	and	and	CC
47658	664	13	not	not	RB
47658	664	14	the	the	DT
47658	664	15	postulate	postulate	NN
47658	664	16	advanced	advance	VBD
47658	664	17	at	at	IN
47658	664	18	a	a	DT
47658	664	19	venture	venture	NN
47658	664	20	,	,	,
47658	664	21	tried	try	VBN
47658	664	22	and	and	CC
47658	664	23	verified	verify	VBN
47658	664	24	,	,	,
47658	664	25	that	that	WDT
47658	664	26	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
47658	664	27	the	the	DT
47658	664	28	system	system	NN
47658	664	29	.	.	.
47658	665	1	The	the	DT
47658	665	2	mathematician	mathematician	NN
47658	665	3	begins	begin	VBZ
47658	665	4	by	by	IN
47658	665	5	placing	place	VBG
47658	665	6	symbols	symbol	NNS
47658	665	7	to	to	TO
47658	665	8	represent	represent	VB
47658	665	9	the	the	DT
47658	665	10	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	665	11	factors	factor	NNS
47658	665	12	in	in	IN
47658	665	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	665	14	equation	equation	NN
47658	665	15	,	,	,
47658	665	16	and	and	CC
47658	665	17	proceeds	proceed	NNS
47658	665	18	by	by	IN
47658	665	19	means	mean	NNS
47658	665	20	of	of	IN
47658	665	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	665	22	known	know	VBN
47658	665	23	factors	factor	NNS
47658	665	24	to	to	TO
47658	665	25	determine	determine	VB
47658	665	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	665	27	value	value	NN
47658	665	28	.	.	.
47658	666	1	The	the	DT
47658	666	2	æther	æther	NN
47658	666	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	666	4	at	at	IN
47658	666	5	first	first	RB
47658	666	6	a	a	DT
47658	666	7	pure	pure	JJ
47658	666	8	fiction	fiction	NN
47658	666	9	constructed	construct	VBN
47658	666	10	to	to	TO
47658	666	11	supply	supply	VB
47658	666	12	an	an	DT
47658	666	13	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	666	14	existence	existence	NN
47658	666	15	recognised	recognise	VBD
47658	666	16	as	as	IN
47658	666	17	a	a	DT
47658	666	18	defect	defect	NN
47658	666	19	.	.	.
47658	667	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	667	2	truth	truth	NN
47658	667	3	can	can	MD
47658	667	4	not	not	RB
47658	667	5	mean	mean	VB
47658	667	6	that	that	IN
47658	667	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	667	8	works	work	VBZ
47658	667	9	for	for	IN
47658	667	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	667	11	can	can	MD
47658	667	12	not	not	RB
47658	667	13	but	but	RB
47658	667	14	work	work	VB
47658	667	15	,	,	,
47658	667	16	having	have	VBG
47658	667	17	been	be	VBN
47658	667	18	constructed	construct	VBN
47658	667	19	purely	purely	RB
47658	667	20	for	for	IN
47658	667	21	that	that	DT
47658	667	22	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	667	23	.	.	.
47658	668	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	668	2	truth	truth	NN
47658	668	3	means	mean	VBZ
47658	668	4	that	that	IN
47658	668	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	668	6	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
47658	668	7	to	to	IN
47658	668	8	some	some	DT
47658	668	9	actual	actual	JJ
47658	668	10	existence	existence	NN
47658	668	11	at	at	IN
47658	668	12	present	present	JJ
47658	668	13	unknown	unknown	NN
47658	668	14	.	.	.
47658	669	1	To	to	TO
47658	669	2	prove	prove	VB
47658	669	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	669	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	669	5	the	the	DT
47658	669	6	physicist	physicist	NN
47658	669	7	does	do	VBZ
47658	669	8	not	not	RB
47658	669	9	appeal	appeal	VB
47658	669	10	to	to	IN
47658	669	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	669	12	value	value	NN
47658	669	13	as	as	IN
47658	669	14	a	a	DT
47658	669	15	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	669	16	,	,	,
47658	669	17	but	but	CC
47658	669	18	devises	devise	VBZ
47658	669	19	experiments	experiment	NNS
47658	669	20	by	by	IN
47658	669	21	which	which	WDT
47658	669	22	,	,	,
47658	669	23	if	if	IN
47658	669	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	669	25	does	do	VBZ
47658	669	26	exist	exist	VB
47658	669	27	,	,	,
47658	669	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	669	29	existence	existence	NN
47658	669	30	will	will	MD
47658	669	31	be	be	VB
47658	669	32	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
47658	669	33	.	.	.
47658	670	1	In	in	IN
47658	670	2	this	this	DT
47658	670	3	actual	actual	JJ
47658	670	4	case	case	NN
47658	670	5	the	the	DT
47658	670	6	experiments	experiment	NNS
47658	670	7	have	have	VBP
47658	670	8	had	have	VBN
47658	670	9	a	a	DT
47658	670	10	uniformly	uniformly	RB
47658	670	11	negative	negative	JJ
47658	670	12	result	result	NN
47658	670	13	,	,	,
47658	670	14	and	and	CC
47658	670	15	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	670	16	the	the	DT
47658	670	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	670	18	of	of	IN
47658	670	19	the	the	DT
47658	670	20	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	670	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	670	22	made	make	VBN
47658	670	23	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
47658	670	24	or	or	CC
47658	670	25	denied	deny	VBN
47658	670	26	.	.	.
47658	671	1	The	the	DT
47658	671	2	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	671	3	continues	continue	VBZ
47658	671	4	to	to	TO
47658	671	5	work	work	VB
47658	671	6	as	as	RB
47658	671	7	well	well	RB
47658	671	8	as	as	IN
47658	671	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	671	10	ever	ever	RB
47658	671	11	did	do	VBD
47658	671	12	,	,	,
47658	671	13	and	and	CC
47658	671	14	physicists	physicist	NNS
47658	671	15	will	will	MD
47658	671	16	probably	probably	RB
47658	671	17	long	long	RB
47658	671	18	continue	continue	VB
47658	671	19	to	to	TO
47658	671	20	use	use	VB
47658	671	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	671	22	,	,	,
47658	671	23	but	but	CC
47658	671	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	671	25	has	have	VBZ
47658	671	26	failed	fail	VBN
47658	671	27	to	to	TO
47658	671	28	establish	establish	VB
47658	671	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	671	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	671	31	claim	claim	NN
47658	671	32	.	.	.
47658	672	1	The	the	DT
47658	672	2	result	result	NN
47658	672	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	672	4	the	the	DT
47658	672	5	modern	modern	JJ
47658	672	6	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	672	7	of	of	IN
47658	672	8	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	672	9	,	,	,
47658	672	10	which	which	WDT
47658	672	11	,	,	,
47658	672	12	as	as	IN
47658	672	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	672	14	have	have	VBP
47658	672	15	already	already	RB
47658	672	16	said	say	VBN
47658	672	17	,	,	,
47658	672	18	has	have	VBZ
47658	672	19	produced	produce	VBN
47658	672	20	a	a	DT
47658	672	21	revolution	revolution	NN
47658	672	22	in	in	IN
47658	672	23	modern	modern	JJ
47658	672	24	physics	physics	NN
47658	672	25	.	.	.
47658	673	1	The	the	DT
47658	673	2	abolition	abolition	NN
47658	673	3	of	of	IN
47658	673	4	the	the	DT
47658	673	5	æther	æther	NN
47658	673	6	would	would	MD
47658	673	7	have	have	VB
47658	673	8	been	be	VBN
47658	673	9	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	673	10	if	if	IN
47658	673	11	the	the	DT
47658	673	12	physicist	physicist	NN
47658	673	13	had	have	VBD
47658	673	14	been	be	VBN
47658	673	15	content	content	JJ
47658	673	16	with	with	IN
47658	673	17	the	the	DT
47658	673	18	utility	utility	NN
47658	673	19	of	of	IN
47658	673	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	673	21	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
47658	673	22	and	and	CC
47658	673	23	had	have	VBD
47658	673	24	not	not	RB
47658	673	25	experimented	experiment	VBN
47658	673	26	to	to	TO
47658	673	27	prove	prove	VB
47658	673	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	673	29	truth	truth	NN
47658	673	30	.	.	.
47658	674	1	The	the	DT
47658	674	2	relation	relation	NN
47658	674	3	between	between	IN
47658	674	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	674	5	and	and	CC
47658	674	6	utility	utility	NN
47658	674	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	674	8	thus	thus	RB
47658	674	9	proved	prove	VBN
47658	674	10	to	to	TO
47658	674	11	be	be	VB
47658	674	12	that	that	IN
47658	674	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	674	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	674	15	useful	useful	JJ
47658	674	16	to	to	TO
47658	674	17	know	know	VB
47658	674	18	what	what	WP
47658	674	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	674	20	true	true	JJ
47658	674	21	.	.	.
47658	675	1	These	these	DT
47658	675	2	two	two	CD
47658	675	3	illustrations	illustration	NNS
47658	675	4	of	of	IN
47658	675	5	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	675	6	method	method	NN
47658	675	7	--	--	:
47658	675	8	namely	namely	RB
47658	675	9	,	,	,
47658	675	10	the	the	DT
47658	675	11	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	675	12	of	of	IN
47658	675	13	Neptune	Neptune	NNP
47658	675	14	and	and	CC
47658	675	15	the	the	DT
47658	675	16	negative	negative	JJ
47658	675	17	discovery	discovery	NN
47658	675	18	{	{	-LRB-
47658	675	19	63	63	CD
47658	675	20	}	}	-RRB-
47658	675	21	that	that	WDT
47658	675	22	the	the	DT
47658	675	23	æther	æther	NN
47658	675	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	675	25	non	non	JJ
47658	675	26	-	-	JJ
47658	675	27	existent	existent	JJ
47658	675	28	--	--	:
47658	675	29	make	make	VB
47658	675	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	675	31	evident	evident	JJ
47658	675	32	that	that	IN
47658	675	33	verification	verification	NN
47658	675	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	675	35	the	the	DT
47658	675	36	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	675	37	process	process	NN
47658	675	38	not	not	RB
47658	675	39	of	of	IN
47658	675	40	making	make	VBG
47658	675	41	true	true	JJ
47658	675	42	,	,	,
47658	675	43	but	but	CC
47658	675	44	of	of	IN
47658	675	45	finding	find	VBG
47658	675	46	true	true	JJ
47658	675	47	.	.	.
47658	676	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	676	2	can	can	MD
47658	676	3	,	,	,
47658	676	4	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	676	5	,	,	,
47658	676	6	distinguish	distinguish	VB
47658	676	7	quite	quite	RB
47658	676	8	clearly	clearly	RB
47658	676	9	the	the	DT
47658	676	10	two	two	CD
47658	676	11	processes	process	NNS
47658	676	12	.	.	.
47658	677	1	The	the	DT
47658	677	2	first	first	JJ
47658	677	3	process	process	NN
47658	677	4	,	,	,
47658	677	5	that	that	DT
47658	677	6	of	of	IN
47658	677	7	making	make	VBG
47658	677	8	true	true	JJ
47658	677	9	,	,	,
47658	677	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	677	11	the	the	DT
47658	677	12	constructing	constructing	NN
47658	677	13	of	of	IN
47658	677	14	the	the	DT
47658	677	15	fiction	fiction	NN
47658	677	16	by	by	IN
47658	677	17	which	which	WDT
47658	677	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	677	19	complete	complete	VBP
47658	677	20	an	an	DT
47658	677	21	incomplete	incomplete	JJ
47658	677	22	system	system	NN
47658	677	23	,	,	,
47658	677	24	and	and	CC
47658	677	25	the	the	DT
47658	677	26	second	second	JJ
47658	677	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	677	28	the	the	DT
47658	677	29	testing	testing	NN
47658	677	30	of	of	IN
47658	677	31	that	that	DT
47658	677	32	fiction	fiction	NN
47658	677	33	to	to	TO
47658	677	34	see	see	VB
47658	677	35	if	if	IN
47658	677	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	677	37	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
47658	677	38	to	to	IN
47658	677	39	anything	anything	NN
47658	677	40	actually	actually	RB
47658	677	41	existing	exist	VBG
47658	677	42	.	.	.
47658	678	1	No	no	DT
47658	678	2	kind	kind	NN
47658	678	3	of	of	IN
47658	678	4	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	678	5	activity	activity	NN
47658	678	6	will	will	MD
47658	678	7	make	make	VB
47658	678	8	an	an	DT
47658	678	9	idea	idea	NN
47658	678	10	true	true	JJ
47658	678	11	,	,	,
47658	678	12	and	and	CC
47658	678	13	conversely	conversely	RB
47658	678	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	678	15	may	may	MD
47658	678	16	say	say	VB
47658	678	17	that	that	DT
47658	678	18	were	be	VBD
47658	678	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	678	20	only	only	RB
47658	678	21	a	a	DT
47658	678	22	utility	utility	NN
47658	678	23	,	,	,
47658	678	24	then	then	RB
47658	678	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	678	26	instead	instead	RB
47658	678	27	of	of	IN
47658	678	28	being	be	VBG
47658	678	29	systematic	systematic	JJ
47658	678	30	would	would	MD
47658	678	31	be	be	VB
47658	678	32	chaotic	chaotic	JJ
47658	678	33	.	.	.
47658	679	1	Existence	Existence	NNP
47658	679	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	679	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	679	4	roots	root	NNS
47658	679	5	in	in	IN
47658	679	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	679	7	,	,	,
47658	679	8	not	not	RB
47658	679	9	in	in	IN
47658	679	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	679	11	.	.	.
47658	680	1	Reality	reality	NN
47658	680	2	does	do	VBZ
47658	680	3	not	not	RB
47658	680	4	depend	depend	VB
47658	680	5	on	on	IN
47658	680	6	truth	truth	NN
47658	680	7	.	.	.
47658	681	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	681	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	681	3	the	the	DT
47658	681	4	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	681	5	apprehension	apprehension	NN
47658	681	6	of	of	IN
47658	681	7	reality	reality	NN
47658	681	8	.	.	.
47658	682	1	If	if	IN
47658	682	2	the	the	DT
47658	682	3	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	682	4	objects	object	VBZ
47658	682	5	that	that	IN
47658	682	6	in	in	IN
47658	682	7	this	this	DT
47658	682	8	argument	argument	NN
47658	682	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	682	10	have	have	VBP
47658	682	11	throughout	throughout	RB
47658	682	12	supposed	suppose	VBN
47658	682	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	682	14	to	to	TO
47658	682	15	be	be	VB
47658	682	16	urging	urge	VBG
47658	682	17	the	the	DT
47658	682	18	narrow	narrow	JJ
47658	682	19	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	682	20	of	of	IN
47658	682	21	utility	utility	NN
47658	682	22	,	,	,
47658	682	23	namely	namely	RB
47658	682	24	,	,	,
47658	682	25	that	that	IN
47658	682	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	682	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	682	28	usefulness	usefulness	JJ
47658	682	29	in	in	IN
47658	682	30	the	the	DT
47658	682	31	strictly	strictly	RB
47658	682	32	practical	practical	JJ
47658	682	33	sense	sense	NN
47658	682	34	,	,	,
47658	682	35	whereas	whereas	IN
47658	682	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	682	37	intends	intend	VBZ
47658	682	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	682	39	in	in	IN
47658	682	40	the	the	DT
47658	682	41	widest	wide	JJS
47658	682	42	possible	possible	JJ
47658	682	43	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	682	44	--	--	:
47658	682	45	a	a	DT
47658	682	46	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	682	47	that	that	WDT
47658	682	48	includes	include	VBZ
47658	682	49	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
47658	682	50	usefulness	usefulness	NN
47658	682	51	--	--	:
47658	682	52	then	then	RB
47658	682	53	the	the	DT
47658	682	54	trouble	trouble	NN
47658	682	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	682	56	a	a	DT
47658	682	57	different	different	JJ
47658	682	58	one	one	NN
47658	682	59	;	;	:
47658	682	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	682	61	is	be	VBZ
47658	682	62	to	to	TO
47658	682	63	know	know	VB
47658	682	64	how	how	WRB
47658	682	65	and	and	CC
47658	682	66	where	where	WRB
47658	682	67	the	the	DT
47658	682	68	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
47658	682	69	stops	stop	VBZ
47658	682	70	short	short	RB
47658	682	71	of	of	IN
47658	682	72	the	the	DT
47658	682	73	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	682	74	theory	theory	NN
47658	682	75	of	of	IN
47658	682	76	truth	truth	NN
47658	682	77	,	,	,
47658	682	78	and	and	CC
47658	682	79	wherein	wherein	WRB
47658	682	80	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	682	81	method	method	NN
47658	682	82	differs	differ	VBZ
47658	682	83	from	from	IN
47658	682	84	that	that	DT
47658	682	85	of	of	IN
47658	682	86	the	the	DT
47658	682	87	idealist	idealist	NN
47658	682	88	.	.	.
47658	683	1	This	this	DT
47658	683	2	brings	bring	VBZ
47658	683	3	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	683	4	to	to	IN
47658	683	5	the	the	DT
47658	683	6	consideration	consideration	NN
47658	683	7	of	of	IN
47658	683	8	another	another	DT
47658	683	9	theory	theory	NN
47658	683	10	in	in	IN
47658	683	11	which	which	WDT
47658	683	12	the	the	DT
47658	683	13	concept	concept	NN
47658	683	14	of	of	IN
47658	683	15	utility	utility	NN
47658	683	16	plays	play	VBZ
47658	683	17	a	a	DT
47658	683	18	large	large	JJ
47658	683	19	,	,	,
47658	683	20	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	683	21	a	a	DT
47658	683	22	predominant	predominant	JJ
47658	683	23	part	part	NN
47658	683	24	.	.	.
47658	684	1	This	this	DT
47658	684	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	684	3	the	the	DT
47658	684	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	684	5	of	of	IN
47658	684	6	the	the	DT
47658	684	7	relation	relation	NN
47658	684	8	of	of	IN
47658	684	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	684	10	to	to	IN
47658	684	11	life	life	NN
47658	684	12	that	that	WDT
47658	684	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	684	14	given	give	VBN
47658	684	15	to	to	IN
47658	684	16	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	684	17	in	in	IN
47658	684	18	the	the	DT
47658	684	19	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	684	20	of	of	IN
47658	684	21	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	684	22	.	.	.
47658	685	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	685	2	have	have	VBP
47658	685	3	in	in	IN
47658	685	4	one	one	CD
47658	685	5	of	of	IN
47658	685	6	the	the	DT
47658	685	7	volumes	volume	NNS
47658	685	8	of	of	IN
47658	685	9	this	this	DT
47658	685	10	series	series	NN
47658	685	11	given	give	VBN
47658	685	12	an	an	DT
47658	685	13	account	account	NN
47658	685	14	of	of	IN
47658	685	15	this	this	DT
47658	685	16	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	685	17	;	;	:
47658	685	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	685	19	am	be	VBP
47658	685	20	here	here	RB
47658	685	21	only	only	RB
47658	685	22	dealing	deal	VBG
47658	685	23	with	with	IN
47658	685	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	685	25	relation	relation	NN
47658	685	26	to	to	IN
47658	685	27	this	this	DT
47658	685	28	special	special	JJ
47658	685	29	problem	problem	NN
47658	685	30	of	of	IN
47658	685	31	the	the	DT
47658	685	32	nature	nature	NN
47658	685	33	of	of	IN
47658	685	34	truth	truth	NN
47658	685	35	.	.	.
47658	686	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	686	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	686	3	been	be	VBN
47658	686	4	claimed	claim	VBN
47658	686	5	that	that	IN
47658	686	6	this	this	DT
47658	686	7	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	686	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	686	9	only	only	RB
47658	686	10	a	a	DT
47658	686	11	form	form	NN
47658	686	12	of	of	IN
47658	686	13	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	686	14	,	,	,
47658	686	15	but	but	CC
47658	686	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	686	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	686	18	not	not	RB
47658	686	19	a	a	DT
47658	686	20	theory	theory	NN
47658	686	21	of	of	IN
47658	686	22	truth	truth	NN
47658	686	23	,	,	,
47658	686	24	and	and	CC
47658	686	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	686	26	has	have	VBZ
47658	686	27	this	this	DT
47658	686	28	essential	essential	JJ
47658	686	29	difference	difference	NN
47658	686	30	from	from	IN
47658	686	31	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	686	32	that	that	IN
47658	686	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	686	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	686	35	the	the	DT
47658	686	36	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	686	37	and	and	CC
47658	686	38	not	not	RB
47658	686	39	truth	truth	NN
47658	686	40	that	that	DT
47658	686	41	is	be	VBZ
47658	686	42	a	a	DT
47658	686	43	utility	utility	NN
47658	686	44	.	.	.
47658	687	1	Before	before	IN
47658	687	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	687	3	consider	consider	VBP
47658	687	4	the	the	DT
47658	687	5	question	question	NN
47658	687	6	that	that	WDT
47658	687	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	687	8	gives	give	VBZ
47658	687	9	{	{	-LRB-
47658	687	10	64	64	CD
47658	687	11	}	}	-RRB-
47658	687	12	rise	rise	NN
47658	687	13	to	to	IN
47658	687	14	in	in	IN
47658	687	15	regard	regard	NN
47658	687	16	to	to	IN
47658	687	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	687	18	,	,	,
47658	687	19	let	let	VB
47658	687	20	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	687	21	first	first	RB
47658	687	22	examine	examine	VB
47658	687	23	the	the	DT
47658	687	24	theory	theory	NN
47658	687	25	of	of	IN
47658	687	26	the	the	DT
47658	687	27	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	687	28	,	,	,
47658	687	29	and	and	CC
47658	687	30	the	the	DT
47658	687	31	nature	nature	NN
47658	687	32	of	of	IN
47658	687	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	687	34	utility	utility	NN
47658	687	35	.	.	.
47658	688	1	The	the	DT
47658	688	2	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	688	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	688	4	a	a	DT
47658	688	5	mode	mode	NN
47658	688	6	of	of	IN
47658	688	7	activity	activity	NN
47658	688	8	,	,	,
47658	688	9	an	an	DT
47658	688	10	endowment	endowment	NN
47658	688	11	acquired	acquire	VBN
47658	688	12	in	in	IN
47658	688	13	the	the	DT
47658	688	14	course	course	NN
47658	688	15	of	of	IN
47658	688	16	evolution	evolution	NN
47658	688	17	,	,	,
47658	688	18	and	and	CC
47658	688	19	which	which	WDT
47658	688	20	has	have	VBZ
47658	688	21	been	be	VBN
47658	688	22	retained	retain	VBN
47658	688	23	and	and	CC
47658	688	24	perfected	perfect	VBN
47658	688	25	because	because	RB
47658	688	26	of	of	IN
47658	688	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	688	28	utility	utility	NN
47658	688	29	.	.	.
47658	689	1	This	this	DT
47658	689	2	does	do	VBZ
47658	689	3	not	not	RB
47658	689	4	mean	mean	VB
47658	689	5	that	that	IN
47658	689	6	the	the	DT
47658	689	7	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	689	8	directs	direct	VBZ
47658	689	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	689	10	to	to	IN
47658	689	11	what	what	WP
47658	689	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	689	13	useful	useful	JJ
47658	689	14	and	and	CC
47658	689	15	inhibits	inhibit	VBZ
47658	689	16	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	689	17	from	from	IN
47658	689	18	courses	course	NNS
47658	689	19	fatal	fatal	JJ
47658	689	20	to	to	IN
47658	689	21	life	life	NN
47658	689	22	,	,	,
47658	689	23	neither	neither	CC
47658	689	24	does	do	VBZ
47658	689	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	689	26	mean	mean	VB
47658	689	27	that	that	IN
47658	689	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	689	29	gives	give	VBZ
47658	689	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	689	31	any	any	DT
47658	689	32	power	power	NN
47658	689	33	to	to	TO
47658	689	34	make	make	VB
47658	689	35	true	true	JJ
47658	689	36	what	what	WP
47658	689	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	689	38	not	not	RB
47658	689	39	already	already	RB
47658	689	40	true	true	JJ
47658	689	41	,	,	,
47658	689	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	689	43	means	mean	VBZ
47658	689	44	that	that	IN
47658	689	45	the	the	DT
47658	689	46	power	power	NN
47658	689	47	to	to	TO
47658	689	48	acquire	acquire	VB
47658	689	49	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	689	50	is	be	VBZ
47658	689	51	useful	useful	JJ
47658	689	52	.	.	.
47658	690	1	There	there	EX
47658	690	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	690	3	a	a	DT
47658	690	4	contrast	contrast	NN
47658	690	5	in	in	IN
47658	690	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	690	7	own	own	JJ
47658	690	8	existence	existence	NN
47658	690	9	between	between	IN
47658	690	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	690	11	life	life	NN
47658	690	12	and	and	CC
47658	690	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	690	14	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	690	15	.	.	.
47658	691	1	To	to	TO
47658	691	2	understand	understand	VB
47658	691	3	the	the	DT
47658	691	4	way	way	NN
47658	691	5	in	in	IN
47658	691	6	which	which	WDT
47658	691	7	the	the	DT
47658	691	8	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	691	9	serves	serve	VBZ
47658	691	10	the	the	DT
47658	691	11	living	living	NN
47658	691	12	creature	creature	NN
47658	691	13	endowed	endow	VBN
47658	691	14	with	with	IN
47658	691	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	691	16	,	,	,
47658	691	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	691	18	need	need	VBP
47658	691	19	only	only	RB
47658	691	20	regard	regard	VB
47658	691	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	691	22	from	from	IN
47658	691	23	the	the	DT
47658	691	24	standpoint	standpoint	NN
47658	691	25	of	of	IN
47658	691	26	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	691	27	experience	experience	NN
47658	691	28	.	.	.
47658	692	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	692	2	know	know	VBP
47658	692	3	in	in	IN
47658	692	4	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	692	5	that	that	IN
47658	692	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	692	7	life	life	NN
47658	692	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	692	9	wider	wide	JJR
47658	692	10	than	than	IN
47658	692	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	692	12	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	692	13	,	,	,
47658	692	14	and	and	CC
47658	692	15	that	that	IN
47658	692	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	692	17	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	692	18	serves	serve	VBZ
47658	692	19	the	the	DT
47658	692	20	activity	activity	NN
47658	692	21	of	of	IN
47658	692	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	692	23	life	life	NN
47658	692	24	.	.	.
47658	693	1	The	the	DT
47658	693	2	common	common	JJ
47658	693	3	expressions	expression	NNS
47658	693	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	693	5	employ	employ	VBP
47658	693	6	,	,	,
47658	693	7	such	such	JJ
47658	693	8	as	as	IN
47658	693	9	using	use	VBG
47658	693	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	693	11	wits	wit	NNS
47658	693	12	,	,	,
47658	693	13	taking	take	VBG
47658	693	14	an	an	DT
47658	693	15	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
47658	693	16	interest	interest	NN
47658	693	17	,	,	,
47658	693	18	trying	try	VBG
47658	693	19	to	to	TO
47658	693	20	think	think	VB
47658	693	21	,	,	,
47658	693	22	all	all	DT
47658	693	23	imply	imply	VBP
47658	693	24	a	a	DT
47658	693	25	utility	utility	NN
47658	693	26	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	693	27	from	from	IN
47658	693	28	the	the	DT
47658	693	29	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	693	30	.	.	.
47658	694	1	So	so	RB
47658	694	2	viewed	view	VBN
47658	694	3	,	,	,
47658	694	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	694	5	life	life	NN
47658	694	6	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	694	7	as	as	IN
47658	694	8	an	an	DT
47658	694	9	active	active	JJ
47658	694	10	principle	principle	NN
47658	694	11	within	within	IN
47658	694	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	694	13	,	,	,
47658	694	14	maintaining	maintain	VBG
47658	694	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	694	16	organism	organism	NN
47658	694	17	in	in	IN
47658	694	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	694	19	relations	relation	NNS
47658	694	20	,	,	,
47658	694	21	active	active	JJ
47658	694	22	and	and	CC
47658	694	23	passive	passive	JJ
47658	694	24	,	,	,
47658	694	25	and	and	CC
47658	694	26	reactive	reactive	VB
47658	694	27	to	to	IN
47658	694	28	the	the	DT
47658	694	29	reality	reality	NN
47658	694	30	outside	outside	RB
47658	694	31	and	and	CC
47658	694	32	independent	independent	JJ
47658	694	33	of	of	IN
47658	694	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	694	35	.	.	.
47658	695	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	695	2	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	695	3	also	also	RB
47658	695	4	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	695	5	both	both	CC
47658	695	6	active	active	JJ
47658	695	7	and	and	CC
47658	695	8	passive	passive	JJ
47658	695	9	.	.	.
47658	696	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	696	2	receives	receive	VBZ
47658	696	3	the	the	DT
47658	696	4	influences	influence	NNS
47658	696	5	that	that	WDT
47658	696	6	stream	stream	VBP
47658	696	7	in	in	RP
47658	696	8	upon	upon	IN
47658	696	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	696	10	from	from	IN
47658	696	11	the	the	DT
47658	696	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	696	13	around	around	IN
47658	696	14	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	696	15	,	,	,
47658	696	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	696	17	apprehends	apprehend	VBZ
47658	696	18	and	and	CC
47658	696	19	interprets	interpret	VBZ
47658	696	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	696	21	,	,	,
47658	696	22	and	and	CC
47658	696	23	works	work	VBZ
47658	696	24	out	out	RP
47658	696	25	the	the	DT
47658	696	26	lines	line	NNS
47658	696	27	of	of	IN
47658	696	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	696	29	possible	possible	JJ
47658	696	30	action	action	NN
47658	696	31	in	in	IN
47658	696	32	regard	regard	NN
47658	696	33	to	to	IN
47658	696	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	696	35	.	.	.
47658	697	1	The	the	DT
47658	697	2	influences	influence	NNS
47658	697	3	that	that	WDT
47658	697	4	flow	flow	VBP
47658	697	5	in	in	RP
47658	697	6	upon	upon	IN
47658	697	7	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	697	8	from	from	IN
47658	697	9	the	the	DT
47658	697	10	outside	outside	JJ
47658	697	11	world	world	NN
47658	697	12	are	be	VBP
47658	697	13	already	already	RB
47658	697	14	selected	select	VBN
47658	697	15	before	before	IN
47658	697	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	697	17	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	697	18	apprehends	apprehend	VBZ
47658	697	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	697	20	,	,	,
47658	697	21	for	for	IN
47658	697	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	697	23	flow	flow	VBP
47658	697	24	in	in	RP
47658	697	25	by	by	IN
47658	697	26	the	the	DT
47658	697	27	avenues	avenue	NNS
47658	697	28	of	of	IN
47658	697	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	697	30	senses	sense	NNS
47658	697	31	,	,	,
47658	697	32	and	and	CC
47658	697	33	the	the	DT
47658	697	34	senses	sense	NNS
47658	697	35	are	be	VBP
47658	697	36	natural	natural	JJ
47658	697	37	instruments	instrument	NNS
47658	697	38	of	of	IN
47658	697	39	selection	selection	NN
47658	697	40	.	.	.
47658	698	1	If	if	IN
47658	698	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	698	3	picture	picture	VBP
47658	698	4	these	these	DT
47658	698	5	influences	influence	NNS
47658	698	6	as	as	IN
47658	698	7	vibrations	vibration	NNS
47658	698	8	,	,	,
47658	698	9	then	then	RB
47658	698	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	698	11	may	may	MD
47658	698	12	say	say	VB
47658	698	13	that	that	IN
47658	698	14	a	a	DT
47658	698	15	certain	certain	JJ
47658	698	16	group	group	NN
47658	698	17	of	of	IN
47658	698	18	vibrations	vibration	NNS
47658	698	19	of	of	IN
47658	698	20	a	a	DT
47658	698	21	very	very	RB
47658	698	22	rapid	rapid	JJ
47658	698	23	frequency	frequency	NN
47658	698	24	are	be	VBP
47658	698	25	selected	select	VBN
47658	698	26	by	by	IN
47658	698	27	the	the	DT
47658	698	28	eye	eye	NN
47658	698	29	and	and	CC
47658	698	30	give	give	VB
47658	698	31	rise	rise	NN
47658	698	32	to	to	IN
47658	698	33	vision	vision	NN
47658	698	34	,	,	,
47658	698	35	that	that	IN
47658	698	36	another	another	DT
47658	698	37	group	group	NN
47658	698	38	of	of	IN
47658	698	39	very	very	RB
47658	698	40	much	much	RB
47658	698	41	lower	low	JJR
47658	698	42	frequency	frequency	NN
47658	698	43	are	be	VBP
47658	698	44	selected	select	VBN
47658	698	45	by	by	IN
47658	698	46	the	the	DT
47658	698	47	ear	ear	NN
47658	698	48	and	and	CC
47658	698	49	{	{	-LRB-
47658	698	50	65	65	CD
47658	698	51	}	}	-RRB-
47658	698	52	give	give	VBP
47658	698	53	the	the	DT
47658	698	54	sensation	sensation	NN
47658	698	55	of	of	IN
47658	698	56	sound	sound	NN
47658	698	57	,	,	,
47658	698	58	and	and	CC
47658	698	59	other	other	JJ
47658	698	60	groups	group	NNS
47658	698	61	are	be	VBP
47658	698	62	selected	select	VBN
47658	698	63	by	by	IN
47658	698	64	taste	taste	NN
47658	698	65	,	,	,
47658	698	66	smell	smell	NN
47658	698	67	,	,	,
47658	698	68	and	and	CC
47658	698	69	touch	touch	NN
47658	698	70	.	.	.
47658	699	1	Many	many	JJ
47658	699	2	groups	group	NNS
47658	699	3	are	be	VBP
47658	699	4	known	know	VBN
47658	699	5	indirectly	indirectly	RB
47658	699	6	by	by	IN
47658	699	7	means	mean	NNS
47658	699	8	of	of	IN
47658	699	9	artificial	artificial	JJ
47658	699	10	instruments	instrument	NNS
47658	699	11	,	,	,
47658	699	12	and	and	CC
47658	699	13	all	all	PDT
47658	699	14	the	the	DT
47658	699	15	infinite	infinite	JJ
47658	699	16	series	series	NN
47658	699	17	that	that	WDT
47658	699	18	unite	unite	VBP
47658	699	19	these	these	DT
47658	699	20	groups	group	NNS
47658	699	21	of	of	IN
47658	699	22	the	the	DT
47658	699	23	actually	actually	RB
47658	699	24	experienced	experienced	JJ
47658	699	25	vibrations	vibration	NNS
47658	699	26	escape	escape	VBP
47658	699	27	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	699	28	apprehension	apprehension	NN
47658	699	29	altogether	altogether	RB
47658	699	30	--	--	:
47658	699	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	699	32	have	have	VBP
47658	699	33	no	no	DT
47658	699	34	means	means	NN
47658	699	35	of	of	IN
47658	699	36	selecting	select	VBG
47658	699	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	699	38	.	.	.
47658	700	1	But	but	CC
47658	700	2	all	all	PDT
47658	700	3	these	these	DT
47658	700	4	sense	sense	NN
47658	700	5	data	datum	NNS
47658	700	6	,	,	,
47658	700	7	as	as	IN
47658	700	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	9	may	may	MD
47658	700	10	call	call	VB
47658	700	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	12	,	,	,
47658	700	13	come	come	VB
47658	700	14	to	to	IN
47658	700	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	16	without	without	IN
47658	700	17	exertion	exertion	NN
47658	700	18	or	or	CC
47658	700	19	activity	activity	NN
47658	700	20	on	on	IN
47658	700	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	700	22	part	part	NN
47658	700	23	;	;	:
47658	700	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	700	26	the	the	DT
47658	700	27	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	700	28	which	which	WDT
47658	700	29	gives	give	VBZ
47658	700	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	31	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	700	32	,	,	,
47658	700	33	which	which	WDT
47658	700	34	interprets	interpret	VBZ
47658	700	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	36	,	,	,
47658	700	37	which	which	WDT
47658	700	38	makes	make	VBZ
47658	700	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	700	40	the	the	DT
47658	700	41	apprehension	apprehension	NN
47658	700	42	or	or	CC
47658	700	43	awareness	awareness	NN
47658	700	44	of	of	IN
47658	700	45	objects	object	NNS
47658	700	46	or	or	CC
47658	700	47	things	thing	NNS
47658	700	48	.	.	.
47658	701	1	And	and	CC
47658	701	2	the	the	DT
47658	701	3	active	active	JJ
47658	701	4	part	part	NN
47658	701	5	that	that	WDT
47658	701	6	the	the	DT
47658	701	7	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	701	8	plays	play	VBZ
47658	701	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	701	10	also	also	RB
47658	701	11	a	a	DT
47658	701	12	process	process	NN
47658	701	13	of	of	IN
47658	701	14	selection	selection	NN
47658	701	15	.	.	.
47658	702	1	This	this	DT
47658	702	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	702	3	evident	evident	JJ
47658	702	4	if	if	IN
47658	702	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	702	6	reflect	reflect	VBP
47658	702	7	upon	upon	IN
47658	702	8	the	the	DT
47658	702	9	universal	universal	JJ
47658	702	10	form	form	NN
47658	702	11	which	which	WDT
47658	702	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	702	13	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	702	14	activity	activity	NN
47658	702	15	takes	take	VBZ
47658	702	16	,	,	,
47658	702	17	namely	namely	RB
47658	702	18	,	,	,
47658	702	19	attention	attention	NN
47658	702	20	.	.	.
47658	703	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	703	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	703	3	in	in	IN
47658	703	4	the	the	DT
47658	703	5	act	act	NN
47658	703	6	of	of	IN
47658	703	7	attention	attention	NN
47658	703	8	that	that	WDT
47658	703	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	703	10	are	be	VBP
47658	703	11	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	703	12	of	of	IN
47658	703	13	mental	mental	JJ
47658	703	14	activity	activity	NN
47658	703	15	,	,	,
47658	703	16	and	and	CC
47658	703	17	attention	attention	NN
47658	703	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	703	19	essentially	essentially	RB
47658	703	20	selection	selection	NN
47658	703	21	--	--	:
47658	703	22	the	the	DT
47658	703	23	selection	selection	NN
47658	703	24	of	of	IN
47658	703	25	an	an	DT
47658	703	26	interest	interest	NN
47658	703	27	.	.	.
47658	704	1	Besides	besides	IN
47658	704	2	the	the	DT
47658	704	3	natural	natural	JJ
47658	704	4	selection	selection	NN
47658	704	5	that	that	WDT
47658	704	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	704	7	effected	effect	VBN
47658	704	8	by	by	IN
47658	704	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	704	10	senses	sense	NNS
47658	704	11	and	and	CC
47658	704	12	the	the	DT
47658	704	13	conscious	conscious	JJ
47658	704	14	selection	selection	NN
47658	704	15	that	that	WDT
47658	704	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	704	17	manifest	manif	JJS
47658	704	18	in	in	IN
47658	704	19	attention	attention	NN
47658	704	20	,	,	,
47658	704	21	there	there	EX
47658	704	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	704	23	also	also	RB
47658	704	24	a	a	DT
47658	704	25	more	more	RBR
47658	704	26	or	or	CC
47658	704	27	less	less	RBR
47658	704	28	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
47658	704	29	selection	selection	NN
47658	704	30	that	that	IN
47658	704	31	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	704	32	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	704	33	performs	perform	VBZ
47658	704	34	in	in	IN
47658	704	35	marking	mark	VBG
47658	704	36	out	out	RP
47658	704	37	the	the	DT
47658	704	38	lines	line	NNS
47658	704	39	of	of	IN
47658	704	40	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	704	41	practical	practical	JJ
47658	704	42	interest	interest	NN
47658	704	43	and	and	CC
47658	704	44	possible	possible	JJ
47658	704	45	action	action	NN
47658	704	46	.	.	.
47658	705	1	In	in	IN
47658	705	2	this	this	DT
47658	705	3	work	work	NN
47658	705	4	of	of	IN
47658	705	5	selection	selection	NN
47658	705	6	the	the	DT
47658	705	7	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	705	8	makes	make	VBZ
47658	705	9	the	the	DT
47658	705	10	world	world	NN
47658	705	11	conform	conform	VB
47658	705	12	to	to	IN
47658	705	13	the	the	DT
47658	705	14	necessities	necessity	NNS
47658	705	15	of	of	IN
47658	705	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	705	17	action	action	NN
47658	705	18	.	.	.
47658	706	1	So	so	RB
47658	706	2	far	far	RB
47658	706	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	706	4	have	have	VBP
47658	706	5	looked	look	VBN
47658	706	6	at	at	IN
47658	706	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	706	8	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	706	9	endowment	endowment	NN
47658	706	10	from	from	IN
47658	706	11	the	the	DT
47658	706	12	standpoint	standpoint	NN
47658	706	13	of	of	IN
47658	706	14	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	706	15	common	common	JJ
47658	706	16	-	-	HYPH
47658	706	17	sense	sense	NN
47658	706	18	experience	experience	NN
47658	706	19	.	.	.
47658	707	1	Let	let	VB
47658	707	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	707	3	now	now	RB
47658	707	4	consider	consider	VB
47658	707	5	the	the	DT
47658	707	6	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	707	7	theory	theory	NN
47658	707	8	based	base	VBN
47658	707	9	on	on	IN
47658	707	10	this	this	DT
47658	707	11	view	view	NN
47658	707	12	,	,	,
47658	707	13	which	which	WDT
47658	707	14	explains	explain	VBZ
47658	707	15	the	the	DT
47658	707	16	nature	nature	NN
47658	707	17	of	of	IN
47658	707	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	707	19	by	by	IN
47658	707	20	showing	show	VBG
47658	707	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	707	22	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	707	23	.	.	.
47658	708	1	The	the	DT
47658	708	2	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	708	3	not	not	RB
47658	708	4	only	only	RB
47658	708	5	selects	select	NNS
47658	708	6	,	,	,
47658	708	7	but	but	CC
47658	708	8	in	in	IN
47658	708	9	selecting	select	VBG
47658	708	10	transforms	transform	NNS
47658	708	11	the	the	DT
47658	708	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	708	13	.	.	.
47658	709	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	709	2	presents	present	VBZ
47658	709	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	709	4	with	with	IN
47658	709	5	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	709	6	that	that	WDT
47658	709	7	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	709	8	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
47658	709	9	with	with	IN
47658	709	10	reality	reality	NN
47658	709	11	,	,	,
47658	709	12	for	for	IN
47658	709	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	709	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	709	15	essentially	essentially	RB
47658	709	16	a	a	DT
47658	709	17	view	view	NN
47658	709	18	of	of	IN
47658	709	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	709	20	,	,	,
47658	709	21	but	but	CC
47658	709	22	also	also	RB
47658	709	23	in	in	IN
47658	709	24	selecting	select	VBG
47658	709	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	709	26	marks	mark	VBZ
47658	709	27	out	out	RP
47658	709	28	divisions	division	NNS
47658	709	29	,	,	,
47658	709	30	and	and	CC
47658	709	31	gives	give	VBZ
47658	709	32	to	to	IN
47658	709	33	reality	reality	NN
47658	709	34	a	a	DT
47658	709	35	form	form	NN
47658	709	36	that	that	WDT
47658	709	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	709	38	determined	determine	VBN
47658	709	39	by	by	IN
47658	709	40	practical	practical	JJ
47658	709	41	interest	interest	NN
47658	709	42	.	.	.
47658	710	1	The	the	DT
47658	710	2	same	same	JJ
47658	710	3	reality	reality	NN
47658	710	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	710	5	different	different	JJ
47658	710	6	to	to	IN
47658	710	7	different	different	JJ
47658	710	8	individuals	individual	NNS
47658	710	9	and	and	CC
47658	710	10	to	to	IN
47658	710	11	different	different	JJ
47658	710	12	species	specie	NNS
47658	710	13	according	accord	VBG
47658	710	14	to	to	IN
47658	710	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	710	16	practical	practical	JJ
47658	710	17	interests	interest	NNS
47658	710	18	.	.	.
47658	711	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	711	2	66	66	CD
47658	711	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	711	4	The	the	DT
47658	711	5	practical	practical	JJ
47658	711	6	end	end	NN
47658	711	7	which	which	WDT
47658	711	8	the	the	DT
47658	711	9	human	human	JJ
47658	711	10	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	711	11	serves	serve	VBZ
47658	711	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	711	13	to	to	TO
47658	711	14	present	present	VB
47658	711	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	711	16	with	with	IN
47658	711	17	a	a	DT
47658	711	18	field	field	NN
47658	711	19	for	for	IN
47658	711	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	711	21	life	life	NN
47658	711	22	activity	activity	NN
47658	711	23	.	.	.
47658	712	1	This	this	DT
47658	712	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	712	3	the	the	DT
47658	712	4	real	real	JJ
47658	712	5	world	world	NN
47658	712	6	for	for	IN
47658	712	7	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	712	8	,	,	,
47658	712	9	as	as	IN
47658	712	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	712	11	know	know	VBP
47658	712	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	712	13	,	,	,
47658	712	14	real	real	JJ
47658	712	15	objects	object	NNS
47658	712	16	in	in	IN
47658	712	17	a	a	DT
47658	712	18	real	real	JJ
47658	712	19	space	space	NN
47658	712	20	.	.	.
47658	713	1	Had	have	VBD
47658	713	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	713	3	no	no	DT
47658	713	4	other	other	JJ
47658	713	5	way	way	NN
47658	713	6	of	of	IN
47658	713	7	knowing	know	VBG
47658	713	8	but	but	CC
47658	713	9	that	that	DT
47658	713	10	of	of	IN
47658	713	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	713	12	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	713	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	713	14	should	should	MD
47658	713	15	not	not	RB
47658	713	16	know	know	VB
47658	713	17	the	the	DT
47658	713	18	life	life	NN
47658	713	19	which	which	WDT
47658	713	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	713	21	active	active	JJ
47658	713	22	within	within	IN
47658	713	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	713	24	as	as	IN
47658	713	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	713	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	713	27	really	really	RB
47658	713	28	lived	live	VBN
47658	713	29	,	,	,
47658	713	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	713	31	should	should	MD
47658	713	32	be	be	VB
47658	713	33	as	as	IN
47658	713	34	those	those	DT
47658	713	35	who	who	WP
47658	713	36	,	,	,
47658	713	37	standing	stand	VBG
47658	713	38	outside	outside	RB
47658	713	39	,	,	,
47658	713	40	watch	watch	VB
47658	713	41	a	a	DT
47658	713	42	movement	movement	NN
47658	713	43	,	,	,
47658	713	44	and	and	CC
47658	713	45	not	not	RB
47658	713	46	as	as	IN
47658	713	47	those	those	DT
47658	713	48	who	who	WP
47658	713	49	are	be	VBP
47658	713	50	carried	carry	VBN
47658	713	51	along	along	RB
47658	713	52	in	in	IN
47658	713	53	the	the	DT
47658	713	54	movement	movement	NN
47658	713	55	and	and	CC
47658	713	56	experience	experience	VB
47658	713	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	713	58	from	from	IN
47658	713	59	within	within	IN
47658	713	60	.	.	.
47658	714	1	In	in	IN
47658	714	2	life	life	NN
47658	714	3	and	and	CC
47658	714	4	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	714	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	714	6	have	have	VBP
47658	714	7	the	the	DT
47658	714	8	counterpart	counterpart	NN
47658	714	9	of	of	IN
47658	714	10	reality	reality	NN
47658	714	11	and	and	CC
47658	714	12	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	714	13	.	.	.
47658	715	1	Life	life	NN
47658	715	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	715	3	not	not	RB
47658	715	4	something	something	NN
47658	715	5	that	that	WDT
47658	715	6	changes	change	VBZ
47658	715	7	;	;	:
47658	715	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	715	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	715	10	the	the	DT
47658	715	11	change	change	NN
47658	715	12	of	of	IN
47658	715	13	which	which	WDT
47658	715	14	the	the	DT
47658	715	15	something	something	NN
47658	715	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	715	17	the	the	DT
47658	715	18	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	715	19	.	.	.
47658	716	1	Life	life	NN
47658	716	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	716	3	the	the	DT
47658	716	4	reality	reality	NN
47658	716	5	of	of	IN
47658	716	6	which	which	WDT
47658	716	7	all	all	DT
47658	716	8	things	thing	NNS
47658	716	9	,	,	,
47658	716	10	as	as	IN
47658	716	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	716	12	understand	understand	VBP
47658	716	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	716	14	,	,	,
47658	716	15	are	be	VBP
47658	716	16	the	the	DT
47658	716	17	appearances	appearance	NNS
47658	716	18	,	,	,
47658	716	19	and	and	CC
47658	716	20	on	on	IN
47658	716	21	account	account	NN
47658	716	22	of	of	IN
47658	716	23	which	which	WDT
47658	716	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	716	25	appear	appear	VBP
47658	716	26	.	.	.
47658	717	1	The	the	DT
47658	717	2	solid	solid	JJ
47658	717	3	things	thing	NNS
47658	717	4	in	in	IN
47658	717	5	space	space	NN
47658	717	6	and	and	CC
47658	717	7	time	time	NN
47658	717	8	are	be	VBP
47658	717	9	not	not	RB
47658	717	10	in	in	IN
47658	717	11	reality	reality	NN
47658	717	12	what	what	WP
47658	717	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	717	14	appear	appear	VBP
47658	717	15	;	;	:
47658	717	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	717	17	are	be	VBP
47658	717	18	views	view	NNS
47658	717	19	of	of	IN
47658	717	20	the	the	DT
47658	717	21	reality	reality	NN
47658	717	22	.	.	.
47658	718	1	The	the	DT
47658	718	2	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	718	3	guided	guide	VBN
47658	718	4	by	by	IN
47658	718	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	718	6	practical	practical	JJ
47658	718	7	interest	interest	NN
47658	718	8	presents	present	VBZ
47658	718	9	reality	reality	NN
47658	718	10	under	under	IN
47658	718	11	this	this	DT
47658	718	12	form	form	NN
47658	718	13	of	of	IN
47658	718	14	solid	solid	JJ
47658	718	15	spatial	spatial	JJ
47658	718	16	things	thing	NNS
47658	718	17	.	.	.
47658	719	1	Clearly	clearly	RB
47658	719	2	,	,	,
47658	719	3	then	then	RB
47658	719	4	,	,	,
47658	719	5	if	if	IN
47658	719	6	this	this	DT
47658	719	7	view	view	NN
47658	719	8	be	be	VB
47658	719	9	true	true	JJ
47658	719	10	,	,	,
47658	719	11	the	the	DT
47658	719	12	whole	whole	JJ
47658	719	13	world	world	NN
47658	719	14	,	,	,
47658	719	15	as	as	IN
47658	719	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	719	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	719	18	presented	present	VBN
47658	719	19	to	to	IN
47658	719	20	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	719	21	and	and	CC
47658	719	22	thought	think	VBD
47658	719	23	of	of	IN
47658	719	24	by	by	IN
47658	719	25	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	719	26	,	,	,
47658	719	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	719	28	an	an	DT
47658	719	29	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	719	30	.	.	.
47658	720	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	720	2	science	science	NN
47658	720	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	720	4	not	not	RB
47658	720	5	unreal	unreal	JJ
47658	720	6	,	,	,
47658	720	7	but	but	CC
47658	720	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	720	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	720	10	a	a	DT
47658	720	11	transformed	transform	VBN
47658	720	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	720	13	.	.	.
47658	721	1	The	the	DT
47658	721	2	illusions	illusion	NNS
47658	721	3	may	may	MD
47658	721	4	be	be	VB
47658	721	5	useful	useful	JJ
47658	721	6	,	,	,
47658	721	7	may	may	MD
47658	721	8	,	,	,
47658	721	9	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	721	10	,	,	,
47658	721	11	be	be	VB
47658	721	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
47658	721	13	and	and	CC
47658	721	14	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
47658	721	15	,	,	,
47658	721	16	but	but	CC
47658	721	17	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
47658	721	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	721	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	721	20	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	721	21	.	.	.
47658	722	1	But	but	CC
47658	722	2	here	here	RB
47658	722	3	there	there	EX
47658	722	4	arises	arise	VBZ
47658	722	5	a	a	DT
47658	722	6	new	new	JJ
47658	722	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	722	8	in	in	IN
47658	722	9	regard	regard	NN
47658	722	10	to	to	IN
47658	722	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	722	12	.	.	.
47658	723	1	If	if	IN
47658	723	2	the	the	DT
47658	723	3	usefulness	usefulness	NN
47658	723	4	of	of	IN
47658	723	5	the	the	DT
47658	723	6	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	723	7	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	723	8	in	in	IN
47658	723	9	the	the	DT
47658	723	10	active	active	JJ
47658	723	11	production	production	NN
47658	723	12	of	of	IN
47658	723	13	an	an	DT
47658	723	14	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	723	15	,	,	,
47658	723	16	can	can	MD
47658	723	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	723	18	say	say	VB
47658	723	19	that	that	IN
47658	723	20	the	the	DT
47658	723	21	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	723	22	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	723	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	723	24	to	to	IN
47658	723	25	truth	truth	NN
47658	723	26	?	?	.
47658	724	1	Is	be	VBZ
47658	724	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	724	3	not	not	RB
47658	724	4	only	only	RB
47658	724	5	if	if	IN
47658	724	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	724	7	can	can	MD
47658	724	8	turn	turn	VB
47658	724	9	away	away	RB
47658	724	10	from	from	IN
47658	724	11	the	the	DT
47658	724	12	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	724	13	and	and	CC
47658	724	14	obtain	obtain	VB
47658	724	15	a	a	DT
47658	724	16	non	non	JJ
47658	724	17	-	-	JJ
47658	724	18	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	724	19	intuition	intuition	NN
47658	724	20	that	that	WDT
47658	724	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	724	22	can	can	MD
47658	724	23	know	know	VB
47658	724	24	truth	truth	NN
47658	724	25	?	?	.
47658	725	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	725	2	67	67	CD
47658	725	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	725	4	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
47658	725	5	VII	VII	NNP
47658	725	6	ILLUSION	ILLUSION	NNP
47658	725	7	The	the	DT
47658	725	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	725	9	that	that	IN
47658	725	10	the	the	DT
47658	725	11	world	world	NN
47658	725	12	that	that	WDT
47658	725	13	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	725	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	725	15	essentially	essentially	RB
47658	725	16	unlike	unlike	IN
47658	725	17	the	the	DT
47658	725	18	world	world	NN
47658	725	19	that	that	WDT
47658	725	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	725	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	725	22	neither	neither	CC
47658	725	23	new	new	JJ
47658	725	24	nor	nor	CC
47658	725	25	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
47658	725	26	to	to	IN
47658	725	27	any	any	DT
47658	725	28	particular	particular	JJ
47658	725	29	theory	theory	NN
47658	725	30	of	of	IN
47658	725	31	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	725	32	.	.	.
47658	726	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	726	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	726	3	received	receive	VBN
47658	726	4	a	a	DT
47658	726	5	new	new	JJ
47658	726	6	interest	interest	NN
47658	726	7	and	and	CC
47658	726	8	a	a	DT
47658	726	9	new	new	JJ
47658	726	10	interpretation	interpretation	NN
47658	726	11	lately	lately	RB
47658	726	12	in	in	IN
47658	726	13	the	the	DT
47658	726	14	theory	theory	NN
47658	726	15	that	that	IN
47658	726	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	726	17	are	be	VBP
47658	726	18	now	now	RB
47658	726	19	considering	consider	VBG
47658	726	20	,	,	,
47658	726	21	that	that	IN
47658	726	22	the	the	DT
47658	726	23	clue	clue	NN
47658	726	24	to	to	IN
47658	726	25	the	the	DT
47658	726	26	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	726	27	of	of	IN
47658	726	28	the	the	DT
47658	726	29	world	world	NN
47658	726	30	to	to	IN
47658	726	31	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	726	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	726	33	to	to	TO
47658	726	34	be	be	VB
47658	726	35	found	find	VBN
47658	726	36	in	in	IN
47658	726	37	the	the	DT
47658	726	38	conception	conception	NN
47658	726	39	of	of	IN
47658	726	40	the	the	DT
47658	726	41	nature	nature	NN
47658	726	42	of	of	IN
47658	726	43	the	the	DT
47658	726	44	utility	utility	NN
47658	726	45	of	of	IN
47658	726	46	the	the	DT
47658	726	47	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	726	48	and	and	CC
47658	726	49	in	in	IN
47658	726	50	the	the	DT
47658	726	51	mode	mode	NN
47658	726	52	of	of	IN
47658	726	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	726	54	activity	activity	NN
47658	726	55	.	.	.
47658	727	1	The	the	DT
47658	727	2	idea	idea	NN
47658	727	3	that	that	IN
47658	727	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	727	5	are	be	VBP
47658	727	6	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	727	7	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
47658	727	8	by	by	IN
47658	727	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	727	10	very	very	JJ
47658	727	11	nature	nature	NN
47658	727	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	727	13	from	from	IN
47658	727	14	beholding	behold	VBG
47658	727	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	727	16	and	and	CC
47658	727	17	knowing	know	VBG
47658	727	18	truth	truth	NN
47658	727	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	727	20	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
47658	727	21	in	in	IN
47658	727	22	the	the	DT
47658	727	23	well	well	RB
47658	727	24	-	-	HYPH
47658	727	25	known	know	VBN
47658	727	26	allegory	allegory	NN
47658	727	27	in	in	IN
47658	727	28	the	the	DT
47658	727	29	_	_	NNP
47658	727	30	Republic	Republic	NNP
47658	727	31	_	_	NNP
47658	727	32	of	of	IN
47658	727	33	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	727	34	:	:	:
47658	727	35	"	"	``
47658	727	36	And	and	CC
47658	727	37	now	now	RB
47658	727	38	let	let	VB
47658	727	39	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	727	40	show	show	VB
47658	727	41	in	in	IN
47658	727	42	a	a	DT
47658	727	43	figure	figure	NN
47658	727	44	how	how	WRB
47658	727	45	far	far	RB
47658	727	46	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	727	47	nature	nature	NN
47658	727	48	is	be	VBZ
47658	727	49	enlightened	enlighten	VBN
47658	727	50	or	or	CC
47658	727	51	unenlightened	unenlightene	VBN
47658	727	52	.	.	.
47658	728	1	Behold	behold	VB
47658	728	2	!	!	.
47658	729	1	human	human	JJ
47658	729	2	beings	being	NNS
47658	729	3	living	live	VBG
47658	729	4	in	in	IN
47658	729	5	an	an	DT
47658	729	6	underground	underground	JJ
47658	729	7	den	den	NN
47658	729	8	,	,	,
47658	729	9	which	which	WDT
47658	729	10	has	have	VBZ
47658	729	11	a	a	DT
47658	729	12	mouth	mouth	NN
47658	729	13	open	open	JJ
47658	729	14	towards	towards	IN
47658	729	15	the	the	DT
47658	729	16	light	light	NN
47658	729	17	and	and	CC
47658	729	18	reaching	reach	VBG
47658	729	19	all	all	RB
47658	729	20	along	along	IN
47658	729	21	the	the	DT
47658	729	22	den	den	NN
47658	729	23	;	;	:
47658	729	24	here	here	RB
47658	729	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	729	26	have	have	VBP
47658	729	27	been	be	VBN
47658	729	28	from	from	IN
47658	729	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	729	30	childhood	childhood	NN
47658	729	31	,	,	,
47658	729	32	and	and	CC
47658	729	33	have	have	VBP
47658	729	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	729	35	legs	leg	NNS
47658	729	36	and	and	CC
47658	729	37	necks	neck	NNS
47658	729	38	chained	chain	VBN
47658	729	39	so	so	IN
47658	729	40	that	that	IN
47658	729	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	729	42	can	can	MD
47658	729	43	not	not	RB
47658	729	44	move	move	VB
47658	729	45	and	and	CC
47658	729	46	can	can	MD
47658	729	47	only	only	RB
47658	729	48	see	see	VB
47658	729	49	before	before	IN
47658	729	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	729	51	,	,	,
47658	729	52	being	be	VBG
47658	729	53	prevented	prevent	VBN
47658	729	54	by	by	IN
47658	729	55	the	the	DT
47658	729	56	chains	chain	NNS
47658	729	57	from	from	IN
47658	729	58	turning	turn	VBG
47658	729	59	round	round	RB
47658	729	60	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	729	61	heads	head	NNS
47658	729	62	.	.	.
47658	730	1	Above	above	IN
47658	730	2	and	and	CC
47658	730	3	behind	behind	IN
47658	730	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	730	5	a	a	DT
47658	730	6	fire	fire	NN
47658	730	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	730	8	blazing	blaze	VBG
47658	730	9	at	at	IN
47658	730	10	a	a	DT
47658	730	11	distance	distance	NN
47658	730	12	,	,	,
47658	730	13	and	and	CC
47658	730	14	between	between	IN
47658	730	15	the	the	DT
47658	730	16	fire	fire	NN
47658	730	17	and	and	CC
47658	730	18	the	the	DT
47658	730	19	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
47658	730	20	there	there	EX
47658	730	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	730	22	a	a	DT
47658	730	23	raised	raise	VBN
47658	730	24	way	way	NN
47658	730	25	;	;	:
47658	730	26	and	and	CC
47658	730	27	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	730	28	will	will	MD
47658	730	29	see	see	VB
47658	730	30	,	,	,
47658	730	31	if	if	IN
47658	730	32	you	-PRON-	PRP
47658	730	33	look	look	VBP
47658	730	34	,	,	,
47658	730	35	a	a	DT
47658	730	36	low	low	JJ
47658	730	37	wall	wall	NN
47658	730	38	built	build	VBN
47658	730	39	along	along	IN
47658	730	40	the	the	DT
47658	730	41	way	way	NN
47658	730	42	,	,	,
47658	730	43	like	like	IN
47658	730	44	the	the	DT
47658	730	45	screen	screen	NN
47658	730	46	which	which	WDT
47658	730	47	marionette	marionette	NNP
47658	730	48	players	player	NNS
47658	730	49	have	have	VBP
47658	730	50	in	in	IN
47658	730	51	front	front	NN
47658	730	52	of	of	IN
47658	730	53	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	730	54	,	,	,
47658	730	55	over	over	IN
47658	730	56	which	which	WDT
47658	730	57	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	730	58	show	show	VBP
47658	730	59	the	the	DT
47658	730	60	puppets	puppet	NNS
47658	730	61	.	.	.
47658	731	1	And	and	CC
47658	731	2	men	man	NNS
47658	731	3	are	be	VBP
47658	731	4	passing	pass	VBG
47658	731	5	along	along	IN
47658	731	6	the	the	DT
47658	731	7	wall	wall	NN
47658	731	8	carrying	carry	VBG
47658	731	9	all	all	DT
47658	731	10	sorts	sort	NNS
47658	731	11	of	of	IN
47658	731	12	vessels	vessel	NNS
47658	731	13	,	,	,
47658	731	14	and	and	CC
47658	731	15	statues	statue	NNS
47658	731	16	,	,	,
47658	731	17	and	and	CC
47658	731	18	figures	figure	NNS
47658	731	19	of	of	IN
47658	731	20	animals	animal	NNS
47658	731	21	made	make	VBN
47658	731	22	of	of	IN
47658	731	23	wood	wood	NN
47658	731	24	and	and	CC
47658	731	25	stone	stone	NN
47658	731	26	and	and	CC
47658	731	27	various	various	JJ
47658	731	28	materials	material	NNS
47658	731	29	,	,	,
47658	731	30	which	which	WDT
47658	731	31	appear	appear	VBP
47658	731	32	over	over	IN
47658	731	33	the	the	DT
47658	731	34	wall	wall	NN
47658	731	35	....	....	.
47658	731	36	"	"	``
47658	731	37	They	-PRON-	PRP
47658	731	38	are	be	VBP
47658	731	39	strange	strange	JJ
47658	731	40	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
47658	731	41	,	,	,
47658	731	42	like	like	IN
47658	731	43	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	731	44	,	,	,
47658	731	45	and	and	CC
47658	731	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	731	47	see	see	VBP
47658	731	48	only	only	RB
47658	731	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	731	50	own	own	JJ
47658	731	51	shadows	shadow	NNS
47658	731	52	or	or	CC
47658	731	53	the	the	DT
47658	731	54	shadows	shadow	NNS
47658	731	55	of	of	IN
47658	731	56	one	one	CD
47658	731	57	another	another	DT
47658	731	58	which	which	WDT
47658	731	59	the	the	DT
47658	731	60	fire	fire	NN
47658	731	61	throws	throw	VBZ
47658	731	62	on	on	IN
47658	731	63	the	the	DT
47658	731	64	opposite	opposite	JJ
47658	731	65	wall	wall	NN
47658	731	66	of	of	IN
47658	731	67	the	the	DT
47658	731	68	cave	cave	NN
47658	731	69	.	.	.
47658	732	1	And	and	CC
47658	732	2	so	so	RB
47658	732	3	also	also	RB
47658	732	4	of	of	IN
47658	732	5	the	the	DT
47658	732	6	objects	object	NNS
47658	732	7	carried	carry	VBN
47658	732	8	and	and	CC
47658	732	9	of	of	IN
47658	732	10	the	the	DT
47658	732	11	passers	passer	NNS
47658	732	12	-	-	HYPH
47658	732	13	by	by	RB
47658	732	14	;	;	:
47658	732	15	to	to	IN
47658	732	16	the	the	DT
47658	732	17	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
47658	732	18	the	the	DT
47658	732	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	732	20	would	would	MD
47658	732	21	be	be	VB
47658	732	22	literally	literally	RB
47658	732	23	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	732	24	but	but	IN
47658	732	25	the	the	DT
47658	732	26	shadows	shadow	NNS
47658	732	27	of	of	IN
47658	732	28	the	the	DT
47658	732	29	images	image	NNS
47658	732	30	.	.	.
47658	733	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	733	2	68	68	CD
47658	733	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	733	4	"	"	''
47658	733	5	And	and	CC
47658	733	6	now	now	RB
47658	733	7	look	look	VB
47658	733	8	again	again	RB
47658	733	9	,	,	,
47658	733	10	and	and	CC
47658	733	11	see	see	VB
47658	733	12	what	what	WP
47658	733	13	will	will	MD
47658	733	14	naturally	naturally	RB
47658	733	15	follow	follow	VB
47658	733	16	if	if	IN
47658	733	17	the	the	DT
47658	733	18	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
47658	733	19	are	be	VBP
47658	733	20	released	release	VBN
47658	733	21	and	and	CC
47658	733	22	disabused	disabuse	VBN
47658	733	23	of	of	IN
47658	733	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	733	25	error	error	NN
47658	733	26	.	.	.
47658	734	1	At	at	IN
47658	734	2	first	first	RB
47658	734	3	,	,	,
47658	734	4	when	when	WRB
47658	734	5	any	any	DT
47658	734	6	of	of	IN
47658	734	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	734	8	,	,	,
47658	734	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	734	10	liberated	liberate	VBN
47658	734	11	and	and	CC
47658	734	12	compelled	compel	VBN
47658	734	13	suddenly	suddenly	RB
47658	734	14	to	to	TO
47658	734	15	stand	stand	VB
47658	734	16	up	up	RP
47658	734	17	and	and	CC
47658	734	18	turn	turn	VB
47658	734	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	734	20	neck	neck	NN
47658	734	21	round	round	NN
47658	734	22	and	and	CC
47658	734	23	walk	walk	VB
47658	734	24	and	and	CC
47658	734	25	look	look	VB
47658	734	26	towards	towards	IN
47658	734	27	the	the	DT
47658	734	28	light	light	NN
47658	734	29	,	,	,
47658	734	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	734	31	will	will	MD
47658	734	32	suffer	suffer	VB
47658	734	33	sharp	sharp	JJ
47658	734	34	pains	pain	NNS
47658	734	35	;	;	:
47658	734	36	the	the	DT
47658	734	37	glare	glare	NN
47658	734	38	will	will	MD
47658	734	39	distress	distress	VB
47658	734	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	734	41	,	,	,
47658	734	42	and	and	CC
47658	734	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	734	44	will	will	MD
47658	734	45	be	be	VB
47658	734	46	unable	unable	JJ
47658	734	47	to	to	TO
47658	734	48	see	see	VB
47658	734	49	the	the	DT
47658	734	50	realities	reality	NNS
47658	734	51	of	of	IN
47658	734	52	which	which	WDT
47658	734	53	in	in	IN
47658	734	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	734	55	former	former	JJ
47658	734	56	state	state	NN
47658	734	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	734	58	had	have	VBD
47658	734	59	seen	see	VBN
47658	734	60	the	the	DT
47658	734	61	shadows	shadow	NNS
47658	734	62	.	.	.
47658	735	1	And	and	CC
47658	735	2	then	then	RB
47658	735	3	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	735	4	someone	someone	NN
47658	735	5	saying	say	VBG
47658	735	6	to	to	IN
47658	735	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	735	8	that	that	IN
47658	735	9	what	what	WP
47658	735	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	735	11	saw	see	VBD
47658	735	12	before	before	RB
47658	735	13	was	be	VBD
47658	735	14	an	an	DT
47658	735	15	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	735	16	,	,	,
47658	735	17	but	but	CC
47658	735	18	that	that	IN
47658	735	19	now	now	RB
47658	735	20	,	,	,
47658	735	21	when	when	WRB
47658	735	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	735	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	735	24	approaching	approach	VBG
47658	735	25	nearer	nearer	RB
47658	735	26	to	to	IN
47658	735	27	being	be	VBG
47658	735	28	,	,	,
47658	735	29	and	and	CC
47658	735	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	735	31	eye	eye	NN
47658	735	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	735	33	turned	turn	VBN
47658	735	34	towards	towards	IN
47658	735	35	more	more	JJR
47658	735	36	real	real	JJ
47658	735	37	existence	existence	NN
47658	735	38	,	,	,
47658	735	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	735	40	has	have	VBZ
47658	735	41	a	a	DT
47658	735	42	clearer	clear	JJR
47658	735	43	vision	vision	NN
47658	735	44	,	,	,
47658	735	45	and	and	CC
47658	735	46	what	what	WP
47658	735	47	will	will	MD
47658	735	48	be	be	VB
47658	735	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	735	50	reply	reply	NN
47658	735	51	?	?	.
47658	736	1	Will	Will	MD
47658	736	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	736	3	not	not	RB
47658	736	4	fancy	fancy	VB
47658	736	5	that	that	IN
47658	736	6	the	the	DT
47658	736	7	shadows	shadow	NNS
47658	736	8	which	which	WDT
47658	736	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	736	10	formerly	formerly	RB
47658	736	11	saw	see	VBD
47658	736	12	are	be	VBP
47658	736	13	truer	true	JJR
47658	736	14	than	than	IN
47658	736	15	the	the	DT
47658	736	16	objects	object	NNS
47658	736	17	which	which	WDT
47658	736	18	are	be	VBP
47658	736	19	now	now	RB
47658	736	20	shown	show	VBN
47658	736	21	to	to	IN
47658	736	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	736	23	?	?	.
47658	736	24	...	...	.
47658	737	1	"	"	``
47658	737	2	And	and	CC
47658	737	3	suppose	suppose	VB
47658	737	4	that	that	IN
47658	737	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	737	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	737	7	forced	force	VBN
47658	737	8	into	into	IN
47658	737	9	the	the	DT
47658	737	10	presence	presence	NN
47658	737	11	of	of	IN
47658	737	12	the	the	DT
47658	737	13	sun	sun	NN
47658	737	14	himself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	737	15	,	,	,
47658	737	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	737	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	737	18	not	not	RB
47658	737	19	likely	likely	JJ
47658	737	20	to	to	TO
47658	737	21	be	be	VB
47658	737	22	pained	pain	VBN
47658	737	23	and	and	CC
47658	737	24	irritated	irritated	JJ
47658	737	25	?	?	.
47658	738	1	When	when	WRB
47658	738	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	738	3	approaches	approach	VBZ
47658	738	4	the	the	DT
47658	738	5	light	light	JJ
47658	738	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	738	7	eyes	eye	NNS
47658	738	8	will	will	MD
47658	738	9	be	be	VB
47658	738	10	dazzled	dazzle	VBN
47658	738	11	,	,	,
47658	738	12	and	and	CC
47658	738	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	738	14	will	will	MD
47658	738	15	not	not	RB
47658	738	16	be	be	VB
47658	738	17	able	able	JJ
47658	738	18	to	to	TO
47658	738	19	see	see	VB
47658	738	20	anything	anything	NN
47658	738	21	at	at	RB
47658	738	22	all	all	DT
47658	738	23	of	of	IN
47658	738	24	what	what	WP
47658	738	25	are	be	VBP
47658	738	26	now	now	RB
47658	738	27	called	call	VBN
47658	738	28	realities	reality	NNS
47658	738	29	.	.	.
47658	738	30	"	"	''
47658	739	1	The	the	DT
47658	739	2	thought	thought	NN
47658	739	3	that	that	IN
47658	739	4	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	739	5	has	have	VBZ
47658	739	6	expressed	express	VBN
47658	739	7	in	in	IN
47658	739	8	this	this	DT
47658	739	9	wonderful	wonderful	JJ
47658	739	10	allegory	allegory	NN
47658	739	11	has	have	VBZ
47658	739	12	entered	enter	VBN
47658	739	13	deeply	deeply	RB
47658	739	14	into	into	IN
47658	739	15	all	all	DT
47658	739	16	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	739	17	.	.	.
47658	740	1	What	what	WP
47658	740	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	740	3	first	first	RB
47658	740	4	take	take	VBP
47658	740	5	for	for	IN
47658	740	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	740	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	740	8	merely	merely	RB
47658	740	9	a	a	DT
47658	740	10	shadow	shadow	NN
47658	740	11	world	world	NN
47658	740	12	.	.	.
47658	741	1	But	but	CC
47658	741	2	in	in	IN
47658	741	3	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	741	4	's	's	POS
47658	741	5	view	view	NN
47658	741	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	741	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	741	8	the	the	DT
47658	741	9	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	741	10	which	which	WDT
47658	741	11	gives	give	VBZ
47658	741	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	741	13	the	the	DT
47658	741	14	means	mean	NNS
47658	741	15	of	of	IN
47658	741	16	escape	escape	NN
47658	741	17	,	,	,
47658	741	18	the	the	DT
47658	741	19	power	power	NN
47658	741	20	to	to	TO
47658	741	21	turn	turn	VB
47658	741	22	from	from	IN
47658	741	23	the	the	DT
47658	741	24	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	741	25	to	to	TO
47658	741	26	behold	behold	VB
47658	741	27	the	the	DT
47658	741	28	reality	reality	NN
47658	741	29	.	.	.
47658	742	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	742	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	742	3	not	not	RB
47658	742	4	until	until	IN
47658	742	5	now	now	RB
47658	742	6	that	that	DT
47658	742	7	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	742	8	has	have	VBZ
47658	742	9	sought	seek	VBN
47658	742	10	the	the	DT
47658	742	11	clue	clue	NN
47658	742	12	to	to	IN
47658	742	13	the	the	DT
47658	742	14	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	742	15	in	in	IN
47658	742	16	the	the	DT
47658	742	17	nature	nature	NN
47658	742	18	of	of	IN
47658	742	19	the	the	DT
47658	742	20	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	742	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	742	22	.	.	.
47658	743	1	The	the	DT
47658	743	2	very	very	JJ
47658	743	3	instrument	instrument	NN
47658	743	4	of	of	IN
47658	743	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	743	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	743	7	unfitted	unfitted	JJ
47658	743	8	to	to	TO
47658	743	9	reveal	reveal	VB
47658	743	10	to	to	IN
47658	743	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	743	12	the	the	DT
47658	743	13	reality	reality	NN
47658	743	14	as	as	IN
47658	743	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	743	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	743	17	,	,	,
47658	743	18	because	because	IN
47658	743	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	743	20	nature	nature	NN
47658	743	21	and	and	CC
47658	743	22	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	743	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	743	24	to	to	TO
47658	743	25	transform	transform	VB
47658	743	26	reality	reality	NN
47658	743	27	,	,	,
47658	743	28	to	to	TO
47658	743	29	make	make	VB
47658	743	30	reality	reality	NN
47658	743	31	appear	appear	VB
47658	743	32	in	in	IN
47658	743	33	a	a	DT
47658	743	34	form	form	NN
47658	743	35	which	which	WDT
47658	743	36	,	,	,
47658	743	37	though	though	IN
47658	743	38	of	of	IN
47658	743	39	paramount	paramount	JJ
47658	743	40	importance	importance	NN
47658	743	41	to	to	IN
47658	743	42	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	743	43	as	as	IN
47658	743	44	active	active	JJ
47658	743	45	beings	being	NNS
47658	743	46	,	,	,
47658	743	47	is	be	VBZ
47658	743	48	essentially	essentially	RB
47658	743	49	an	an	DT
47658	743	50	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	743	51	.	.	.
47658	744	1	The	the	DT
47658	744	2	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	744	3	bent	bent	NN
47658	744	4	of	of	IN
47658	744	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	744	6	mind	mind	NN
47658	744	7	leads	lead	VBZ
47658	744	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	744	9	away	away	RB
47658	744	10	from	from	IN
47658	744	11	,	,	,
47658	744	12	and	and	CC
47658	744	13	not	not	RB
47658	744	14	towards	towards	IN
47658	744	15	a	a	DT
47658	744	16	vision	vision	NN
47658	744	17	of	of	IN
47658	744	18	reality	reality	NN
47658	744	19	in	in	IN
47658	744	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	744	21	purity	purity	NN
47658	744	22	.	.	.
47658	745	1	The	the	DT
47658	745	2	more	more	RBR
47658	745	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	745	4	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	745	5	progresses	progress	NNS
47658	745	6	,	,	,
47658	745	7	and	and	CC
47658	745	8	the	the	DT
47658	745	9	more	more	RBR
47658	745	10	and	and	CC
47658	745	11	more	more	RBR
47658	745	12	clearly	clearly	RB
47658	745	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	745	14	{	{	-LRB-
47658	745	15	69	69	CD
47658	745	16	}	}	-RRB-
47658	745	17	see	see	VBP
47658	745	18	into	into	IN
47658	745	19	a	a	DT
47658	745	20	greater	great	JJR
47658	745	21	and	and	CC
47658	745	22	ever	ever	RB
47658	745	23	greater	great	JJR
47658	745	24	number	number	NN
47658	745	25	of	of	IN
47658	745	26	things	thing	NNS
47658	745	27	,	,	,
47658	745	28	the	the	DT
47658	745	29	farther	farth	JJR
47658	745	30	are	be	VBP
47658	745	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	745	32	from	from	IN
47658	745	33	,	,	,
47658	745	34	and	and	CC
47658	745	35	not	not	RB
47658	745	36	the	the	DT
47658	745	37	nearer	nearer	NN
47658	745	38	to	to	IN
47658	745	39	a	a	DT
47658	745	40	grasp	grasp	NN
47658	745	41	of	of	IN
47658	745	42	reality	reality	NN
47658	745	43	as	as	IN
47658	745	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	745	45	is	be	VBZ
47658	745	46	.	.	.
47658	746	1	To	to	TO
47658	746	2	obtain	obtain	VB
47658	746	3	this	this	DT
47658	746	4	vision	vision	NN
47658	746	5	of	of	IN
47658	746	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	746	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	746	8	have	have	VBP
47658	746	9	to	to	TO
47658	746	10	turn	turn	VB
47658	746	11	away	away	RB
47658	746	12	from	from	IN
47658	746	13	the	the	DT
47658	746	14	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	746	15	and	and	CC
47658	746	16	find	find	VB
47658	746	17	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	746	18	again	again	RB
47658	746	19	in	in	IN
47658	746	20	that	that	DT
47658	746	21	wider	wide	JJR
47658	746	22	life	life	NN
47658	746	23	out	out	IN
47658	746	24	of	of	IN
47658	746	25	which	which	WDT
47658	746	26	the	the	DT
47658	746	27	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	746	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	746	29	formed	form	VBN
47658	746	30	.	.	.
47658	747	1	Life	life	NN
47658	747	2	,	,	,
47658	747	3	as	as	IN
47658	747	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	747	5	lives	live	VBZ
47658	747	6	,	,	,
47658	747	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	747	8	an	an	DT
47658	747	9	intuition	intuition	NN
47658	747	10	that	that	WDT
47658	747	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	747	12	nonintellectual	nonintellectual	JJ
47658	747	13	.	.	.
47658	748	1	"	"	``
47658	748	2	Human	human	JJ
47658	748	3	intelligence	intelligence	NN
47658	748	4	,	,	,
47658	748	5	"	"	''
47658	748	6	writes	write	VBZ
47658	748	7	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	748	8	,	,	,
47658	748	9	"	"	``
47658	748	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	748	11	not	not	RB
47658	748	12	at	at	RB
47658	748	13	all	all	RB
47658	748	14	what	what	WP
47658	748	15	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	748	16	taught	teach	VBD
47658	748	17	in	in	IN
47658	748	18	the	the	DT
47658	748	19	allegory	allegory	NN
47658	748	20	of	of	IN
47658	748	21	the	the	DT
47658	748	22	cave	cave	NN
47658	748	23	.	.	.
47658	749	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	749	2	function	function	NN
47658	749	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	749	4	not	not	RB
47658	749	5	to	to	TO
47658	749	6	look	look	VB
47658	749	7	at	at	IN
47658	749	8	passing	pass	VBG
47658	749	9	shadows	shadow	NNS
47658	749	10	,	,	,
47658	749	11	nor	nor	CC
47658	749	12	yet	yet	RB
47658	749	13	to	to	TO
47658	749	14	turn	turn	VB
47658	749	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	749	16	round	round	RB
47658	749	17	and	and	CC
47658	749	18	contemplate	contemplate	VB
47658	749	19	the	the	DT
47658	749	20	glaring	glare	VBG
47658	749	21	sun	sun	NN
47658	749	22	.	.	.
47658	750	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	750	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	750	3	something	something	NN
47658	750	4	else	else	RB
47658	750	5	to	to	TO
47658	750	6	do	do	VB
47658	750	7	.	.	.
47658	751	1	Harnessed	harness	VBN
47658	751	2	,	,	,
47658	751	3	like	like	IN
47658	751	4	yoked	yoke	VBN
47658	751	5	oxen	oxen	NNP
47658	751	6	,	,	,
47658	751	7	to	to	IN
47658	751	8	a	a	DT
47658	751	9	heavy	heavy	JJ
47658	751	10	task	task	NN
47658	751	11	,	,	,
47658	751	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	751	13	feel	feel	VBP
47658	751	14	the	the	DT
47658	751	15	play	play	NN
47658	751	16	of	of	IN
47658	751	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	751	18	muscles	muscle	NNS
47658	751	19	and	and	CC
47658	751	20	joints	joint	NNS
47658	751	21	,	,	,
47658	751	22	the	the	DT
47658	751	23	weight	weight	NN
47658	751	24	of	of	IN
47658	751	25	the	the	DT
47658	751	26	plough	plough	NN
47658	751	27	,	,	,
47658	751	28	and	and	CC
47658	751	29	the	the	DT
47658	751	30	resistance	resistance	NN
47658	751	31	of	of	IN
47658	751	32	the	the	DT
47658	751	33	soil	soil	NN
47658	751	34	.	.	.
47658	752	1	To	to	TO
47658	752	2	act	act	VB
47658	752	3	and	and	CC
47658	752	4	to	to	TO
47658	752	5	know	know	VB
47658	752	6	that	that	IN
47658	752	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	752	8	are	be	VBP
47658	752	9	acting	act	VBG
47658	752	10	,	,	,
47658	752	11	to	to	TO
47658	752	12	come	come	VB
47658	752	13	into	into	IN
47658	752	14	touch	touch	NN
47658	752	15	with	with	IN
47658	752	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	752	17	and	and	CC
47658	752	18	even	even	RB
47658	752	19	to	to	TO
47658	752	20	live	live	VB
47658	752	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	752	22	,	,	,
47658	752	23	but	but	CC
47658	752	24	only	only	RB
47658	752	25	in	in	IN
47658	752	26	the	the	DT
47658	752	27	measure	measure	NN
47658	752	28	in	in	IN
47658	752	29	which	which	WDT
47658	752	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	752	31	concerns	concern	VBZ
47658	752	32	the	the	DT
47658	752	33	work	work	NN
47658	752	34	that	that	WDT
47658	752	35	is	be	VBZ
47658	752	36	being	be	VBG
47658	752	37	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
47658	752	38	and	and	CC
47658	752	39	the	the	DT
47658	752	40	furrow	furrow	NN
47658	752	41	that	that	WDT
47658	752	42	is	be	VBZ
47658	752	43	being	be	VBG
47658	752	44	ploughed	plough	VBN
47658	752	45	,	,	,
47658	752	46	such	such	JJ
47658	752	47	is	be	VBZ
47658	752	48	the	the	DT
47658	752	49	function	function	NN
47658	752	50	of	of	IN
47658	752	51	human	human	JJ
47658	752	52	intelligence	intelligence	NN
47658	752	53	.	.	.
47658	752	54	"	"	''
47658	753	1	The	the	DT
47658	753	2	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	753	3	to	to	TO
47658	753	4	which	which	WDT
47658	753	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	753	6	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	753	7	nature	nature	NN
47658	753	8	subjects	subject	VBZ
47658	753	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	753	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	753	11	the	the	DT
47658	753	12	necessity	necessity	NN
47658	753	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	753	14	are	be	VBP
47658	753	15	under	under	JJ
47658	753	16	to	to	TO
47658	753	17	regard	regard	VB
47658	753	18	the	the	DT
47658	753	19	things	thing	NNS
47658	753	20	of	of	IN
47658	753	21	the	the	DT
47658	753	22	universe	universe	NN
47658	753	23	as	as	IN
47658	753	24	more	more	RBR
47658	753	25	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
47658	753	26	,	,	,
47658	753	27	as	as	IN
47658	753	28	more	more	RBR
47658	753	29	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	753	30	than	than	IN
47658	753	31	the	the	DT
47658	753	32	movement	movement	NN
47658	753	33	which	which	WDT
47658	753	34	actuates	actuate	VBZ
47658	753	35	the	the	DT
47658	753	36	universe	universe	NN
47658	753	37	.	.	.
47658	754	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	754	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	754	3	to	to	IN
47658	754	4	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	754	5	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	754	6	that	that	IN
47658	754	7	there	there	EX
47658	754	8	could	could	MD
47658	754	9	exist	exist	VB
47658	754	10	movement	movement	NN
47658	754	11	or	or	CC
47658	754	12	change	change	NN
47658	754	13	,	,	,
47658	754	14	unless	unless	IN
47658	754	15	there	there	EX
47658	754	16	already	already	RB
47658	754	17	existed	exist	VBD
47658	754	18	things	thing	NNS
47658	754	19	to	to	TO
47658	754	20	be	be	VB
47658	754	21	moved	move	VBN
47658	754	22	or	or	CC
47658	754	23	changed	change	VBN
47658	754	24	,	,	,
47658	754	25	things	thing	NNS
47658	754	26	whose	whose	WP$
47658	754	27	nature	nature	NN
47658	754	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	754	29	not	not	RB
47658	754	30	altered	alter	VBN
47658	754	31	,	,	,
47658	754	32	but	but	CC
47658	754	33	only	only	RB
47658	754	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	754	35	form	form	NN
47658	754	36	and	and	CC
47658	754	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	754	38	external	external	JJ
47658	754	39	relations	relation	NNS
47658	754	40	,	,	,
47658	754	41	when	when	WRB
47658	754	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	754	43	are	be	VBP
47658	754	44	moved	move	VBN
47658	754	45	or	or	CC
47658	754	46	changed	change	VBN
47658	754	47	.	.	.
47658	755	1	This	this	DT
47658	755	2	necessity	necessity	NN
47658	755	3	of	of	IN
47658	755	4	thought	thought	NN
47658	755	5	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	755	6	to	to	TO
47658	755	7	have	have	VB
47658	755	8	received	receive	VBN
47658	755	9	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
47658	755	10	recognition	recognition	NN
47658	755	11	in	in	IN
47658	755	12	all	all	DT
47658	755	13	attempts	attempt	NNS
47658	755	14	,	,	,
47658	755	15	religious	religious	JJ
47658	755	16	and	and	CC
47658	755	17	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	755	18	,	,	,
47658	755	19	to	to	TO
47658	755	20	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	755	21	origins	origin	NNS
47658	755	22	.	.	.
47658	756	1	Thus	thus	RB
47658	756	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	756	3	read	read	VBP
47658	756	4	in	in	IN
47658	756	5	the	the	DT
47658	756	6	Book	Book	NNP
47658	756	7	of	of	IN
47658	756	8	Genesis	Genesis	NNP
47658	756	9	:	:	:
47658	756	10	"	"	``
47658	756	11	In	in	IN
47658	756	12	the	the	DT
47658	756	13	beginning	begin	VBG
47658	756	14	God	God	NNP
47658	756	15	created	create	VBD
47658	756	16	the	the	DT
47658	756	17	heaven	heaven	NNP
47658	756	18	and	and	CC
47658	756	19	the	the	DT
47658	756	20	earth	earth	NN
47658	756	21	.	.	.
47658	757	1	And	and	CC
47658	757	2	the	the	DT
47658	757	3	earth	earth	NN
47658	757	4	was	be	VBD
47658	757	5	without	without	IN
47658	757	6	form	form	NN
47658	757	7	,	,	,
47658	757	8	and	and	CC
47658	757	9	void	void	JJ
47658	757	10	;	;	,
47658	757	11	and	and	CC
47658	757	12	darkness	darkness	NN
47658	757	13	was	be	VBD
47658	757	14	upon	upon	IN
47658	757	15	the	the	DT
47658	757	16	face	face	NN
47658	757	17	of	of	IN
47658	757	18	the	the	DT
47658	757	19	deep	deep	JJ
47658	757	20	.	.	.
47658	758	1	And	and	CC
47658	758	2	the	the	DT
47658	758	3	Spirit	Spirit	NNP
47658	758	4	of	of	IN
47658	758	5	God	God	NNP
47658	758	6	moved	move	VBD
47658	758	7	upon	upon	IN
47658	758	8	the	the	DT
47658	758	9	face	face	NN
47658	758	10	of	of	IN
47658	758	11	the	the	DT
47658	758	12	waters	water	NNS
47658	758	13	.	.	.
47658	758	14	"	"	''
47658	759	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	759	2	70	70	CD
47658	759	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	759	4	The	the	DT
47658	759	5	matter	matter	NN
47658	759	6	of	of	IN
47658	759	7	the	the	DT
47658	759	8	universe	universe	NN
47658	759	9	,	,	,
47658	759	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	759	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	759	12	felt	feel	VBN
47658	759	13	,	,	,
47658	759	14	must	must	MD
47658	759	15	be	be	VB
47658	759	16	in	in	IN
47658	759	17	existence	existence	NN
47658	759	18	before	before	IN
47658	759	19	the	the	DT
47658	759	20	movement	movement	NN
47658	759	21	which	which	WDT
47658	759	22	vivifies	vivify	VBZ
47658	759	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	759	24	.	.	.
47658	760	1	The	the	DT
47658	760	2	dead	dead	JJ
47658	760	3	inert	inert	JJ
47658	760	4	stuff	stuff	NN
47658	760	5	must	must	MD
47658	760	6	be	be	VB
47658	760	7	created	create	VBN
47658	760	8	before	before	IN
47658	760	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	760	10	can	can	MD
47658	760	11	receive	receive	VB
47658	760	12	the	the	DT
47658	760	13	breath	breath	NN
47658	760	14	of	of	IN
47658	760	15	life	life	NN
47658	760	16	.	.	.
47658	761	1	And	and	CC
47658	761	2	if	if	IN
47658	761	3	God	God	NNP
47658	761	4	the	the	DT
47658	761	5	creator	creator	NN
47658	761	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	761	7	conceived	conceive	VBN
47658	761	8	as	as	IN
47658	761	9	living	live	VBG
47658	761	10	before	before	IN
47658	761	11	the	the	DT
47658	761	12	matter	matter	NN
47658	761	13	which	which	WDT
47658	761	14	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	761	15	has	have	VBZ
47658	761	16	created	create	VBN
47658	761	17	,	,	,
47658	761	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	761	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	761	20	as	as	IN
47658	761	21	an	an	DT
47658	761	22	external	external	JJ
47658	761	23	principle	principle	NN
47658	761	24	,	,	,
47658	761	25	the	the	DT
47658	761	26	relation	relation	NN
47658	761	27	of	of	IN
47658	761	28	which	which	WDT
47658	761	29	to	to	IN
47658	761	30	the	the	DT
47658	761	31	creation	creation	NN
47658	761	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	761	33	by	by	IN
47658	761	34	most	most	RBS
47658	761	35	religious	religious	JJ
47658	761	36	minds	mind	NNS
47658	761	37	thought	think	VBD
47658	761	38	to	to	TO
47658	761	39	transcend	transcend	VB
47658	761	40	the	the	DT
47658	761	41	power	power	NN
47658	761	42	of	of	IN
47658	761	43	the	the	DT
47658	761	44	finite	finite	JJ
47658	761	45	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	761	46	to	to	TO
47658	761	47	conceive	conceive	VB
47658	761	48	.	.	.
47658	762	1	The	the	DT
47658	762	2	same	same	JJ
47658	762	3	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	762	4	conception	conception	NN
47658	762	5	of	of	IN
47658	762	6	the	the	DT
47658	762	7	primacy	primacy	NN
47658	762	8	of	of	IN
47658	762	9	matter	matter	NN
47658	762	10	over	over	IN
47658	762	11	movement	movement	NN
47658	762	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	762	13	evident	evident	JJ
47658	762	14	in	in	IN
47658	762	15	the	the	DT
47658	762	16	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	762	17	theories	theory	NNS
47658	762	18	of	of	IN
47658	762	19	the	the	DT
47658	762	20	nature	nature	NN
47658	762	21	and	and	CC
47658	762	22	origin	origin	NN
47658	762	23	of	of	IN
47658	762	24	life	life	NN
47658	762	25	.	.	.
47658	763	1	Life	life	NN
47658	763	2	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	763	3	to	to	TO
47658	763	4	science	science	VB
47658	763	5	as	as	IN
47658	763	6	a	a	DT
47658	763	7	form	form	NN
47658	763	8	of	of	IN
47658	763	9	energy	energy	NN
47658	763	10	that	that	WDT
47658	763	11	requires	require	VBZ
47658	763	12	things	thing	NNS
47658	763	13	,	,	,
47658	763	14	matter	matter	NN
47658	763	15	occupying	occupy	VBG
47658	763	16	space	space	NN
47658	763	17	,	,	,
47658	763	18	to	to	TO
47658	763	19	support	support	VB
47658	763	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	763	21	.	.	.
47658	764	1	According	accord	VBG
47658	764	2	to	to	IN
47658	764	3	one	one	CD
47658	764	4	view	view	NN
47658	764	5	,	,	,
47658	764	6	life	life	NN
47658	764	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	764	8	the	the	DT
47658	764	9	result	result	NN
47658	764	10	of	of	IN
47658	764	11	a	a	DT
47658	764	12	certain	certain	JJ
47658	764	13	combination	combination	NN
47658	764	14	or	or	CC
47658	764	15	synthesis	synthesis	NN
47658	764	16	of	of	IN
47658	764	17	chemical	chemical	NN
47658	764	18	or	or	CC
47658	764	19	physical	physical	JJ
47658	764	20	elements	element	NNS
47658	764	21	,	,	,
47658	764	22	previously	previously	RB
47658	764	23	existing	exist	VBG
47658	764	24	separately	separately	RB
47658	764	25	--	--	:
47658	764	26	a	a	DT
47658	764	27	combination	combination	NN
47658	764	28	of	of	IN
47658	764	29	very	very	RB
47658	764	30	great	great	JJ
47658	764	31	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	764	32	,	,	,
47658	764	33	and	and	CC
47658	764	34	one	one	NN
47658	764	35	that	that	WDT
47658	764	36	may	may	MD
47658	764	37	possibly	possibly	RB
47658	764	38	have	have	VB
47658	764	39	occurred	occur	VBN
47658	764	40	once	once	RB
47658	764	41	only	only	RB
47658	764	42	in	in	IN
47658	764	43	the	the	DT
47658	764	44	long	long	JJ
47658	764	45	process	process	NN
47658	764	46	of	of	IN
47658	764	47	nature	nature	NN
47658	764	48	,	,	,
47658	764	49	but	but	CC
47658	764	50	which	which	WDT
47658	764	51	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
47658	764	52	might	may	MD
47658	764	53	be	be	VB
47658	764	54	,	,	,
47658	764	55	and	and	CC
47658	764	56	some	some	DT
47658	764	57	think	think	VBP
47658	764	58	probably	probably	RB
47658	764	59	,	,	,
47658	764	60	or	or	CC
47658	764	61	even	even	RB
47658	764	62	certainly	certainly	RB
47658	764	63	,	,	,
47658	764	64	will	will	MD
47658	764	65	be	be	VB
47658	764	66	brought	bring	VBN
47658	764	67	about	about	RP
47658	764	68	by	by	IN
47658	764	69	a	a	DT
47658	764	70	chemist	chemist	NN
47658	764	71	working	work	VBG
47658	764	72	in	in	IN
47658	764	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	764	74	laboratory	laboratory	NN
47658	764	75	.	.	.
47658	765	1	This	this	DT
47658	765	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	765	3	the	the	DT
47658	765	4	mechanistic	mechanistic	JJ
47658	765	5	or	or	CC
47658	765	6	materialist	materialist	JJ
47658	765	7	view	view	NN
47658	765	8	.	.	.
47658	766	1	On	on	IN
47658	766	2	the	the	DT
47658	766	3	other	other	JJ
47658	766	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	766	5	,	,	,
47658	766	6	there	there	EX
47658	766	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	766	8	the	the	DT
47658	766	9	theory	theory	NN
47658	766	10	of	of	IN
47658	766	11	vitalism	vitalism	NN
47658	766	12	.	.	.
47658	767	1	Life	life	NN
47658	767	2	,	,	,
47658	767	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	767	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	767	5	contended	contend	VBN
47658	767	6	,	,	,
47658	767	7	can	can	MD
47658	767	8	not	not	RB
47658	767	9	be	be	VB
47658	767	10	due	due	JJ
47658	767	11	to	to	IN
47658	767	12	such	such	PDT
47658	767	13	a	a	DT
47658	767	14	synthesis	synthesis	NN
47658	767	15	of	of	IN
47658	767	16	material	material	JJ
47658	767	17	elements	element	NNS
47658	767	18	as	as	IN
47658	767	19	the	the	DT
47658	767	20	mechanistic	mechanistic	JJ
47658	767	21	view	view	NN
47658	767	22	supposes	suppose	VBZ
47658	767	23	,	,	,
47658	767	24	because	because	IN
47658	767	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	767	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	767	27	of	of	IN
47658	767	28	the	the	DT
47658	767	29	nature	nature	NN
47658	767	30	of	of	IN
47658	767	31	an	an	DT
47658	767	32	"	"	``
47658	767	33	entelechy"--that	entelechy"--that	NN
47658	767	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	767	35	,	,	,
47658	767	36	an	an	DT
47658	767	37	individual	individual	JJ
47658	767	38	existence	existence	NN
47658	767	39	which	which	WDT
47658	767	40	functions	function	NNS
47658	767	41	,	,	,
47658	767	42	as	as	IN
47658	767	43	a	a	DT
47658	767	44	whole	whole	NN
47658	767	45	,	,	,
47658	767	46	in	in	IN
47658	767	47	every	every	DT
47658	767	48	minutest	minute	JJS
47658	767	49	part	part	NN
47658	767	50	of	of	IN
47658	767	51	the	the	DT
47658	767	52	organism	organism	NN
47658	767	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	767	54	"	"	``
47658	767	55	vitalises	vitalise	NNS
47658	767	56	.	.	.
47658	767	57	"	"	''
47658	768	1	Life	life	NN
47658	768	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	768	3	supervened	supervene	VBN
47658	768	4	upon	upon	IN
47658	768	5	,	,	,
47658	768	6	and	and	CC
47658	768	7	not	not	RB
47658	768	8	arisen	arise	VBN
47658	768	9	out	out	IN
47658	768	10	of	of	IN
47658	768	11	the	the	DT
47658	768	12	material	material	JJ
47658	768	13	organism	organism	NN
47658	768	14	which	which	WDT
47658	768	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	768	16	guides	guide	VBZ
47658	768	17	and	and	CC
47658	768	18	controls	control	VBZ
47658	768	19	not	not	RB
47658	768	20	by	by	IN
47658	768	21	relating	relate	VBG
47658	768	22	independent	independent	JJ
47658	768	23	parts	part	NNS
47658	768	24	,	,	,
47658	768	25	but	but	CC
47658	768	26	by	by	IN
47658	768	27	making	make	VBG
47658	768	28	every	every	DT
47658	768	29	part	part	NN
47658	768	30	subserve	subserve	VB
47658	768	31	the	the	DT
47658	768	32	activity	activity	NN
47658	768	33	and	and	CC
47658	768	34	unity	unity	NN
47658	768	35	of	of	IN
47658	768	36	the	the	DT
47658	768	37	whole	whole	NN
47658	768	38	.	.	.
47658	769	1	But	but	CC
47658	769	2	the	the	DT
47658	769	3	vitalist	vitalist	NN
47658	769	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	769	5	,	,	,
47658	769	6	as	as	RB
47658	769	7	well	well	RB
47658	769	8	as	as	IN
47658	769	9	the	the	DT
47658	769	10	mechanistic	mechanistic	JJ
47658	769	11	theory	theory	NN
47658	769	12	,	,	,
47658	769	13	conceives	conceive	VBZ
47658	769	14	the	the	DT
47658	769	15	movement	movement	NN
47658	769	16	and	and	CC
47658	769	17	change	change	NN
47658	769	18	which	which	WDT
47658	769	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	769	20	life	life	NN
47658	769	21	as	as	RB
47658	769	22	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	769	23	on	on	IN
47658	769	24	the	the	DT
47658	769	25	previous	previous	JJ
47658	769	26	existence	existence	NN
47658	769	27	of	of	IN
47658	769	28	a	a	DT
47658	769	29	matter	matter	NN
47658	769	30	or	or	CC
47658	769	31	stuff	stuff	NN
47658	769	32	which	which	WDT
47658	769	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	769	34	moved	move	VBN
47658	769	35	or	or	CC
47658	769	36	changed	change	VBN
47658	769	37	.	.	.
47658	770	1	The	the	DT
47658	770	2	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	770	3	{	{	-LRB-
47658	770	4	71	71	CD
47658	770	5	}	}	-RRB-
47658	770	6	conception	conception	NN
47658	770	7	differs	differ	NNS
47658	770	8	,	,	,
47658	770	9	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	770	10	,	,	,
47658	770	11	from	from	IN
47658	770	12	both	both	PDT
47658	770	13	these	these	DT
47658	770	14	theories	theory	NNS
47658	770	15	.	.	.
47658	771	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	771	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	771	3	that	that	IN
47658	771	4	life	life	NN
47658	771	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	771	6	an	an	DT
47658	771	7	original	original	JJ
47658	771	8	movement	movement	NN
47658	771	9	,	,	,
47658	771	10	and	and	CC
47658	771	11	that	that	IN
47658	771	12	this	this	DT
47658	771	13	movement	movement	NN
47658	771	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	771	15	the	the	DT
47658	771	16	whole	whole	JJ
47658	771	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	771	18	of	of	IN
47658	771	19	which	which	WDT
47658	771	20	things	thing	NNS
47658	771	21	,	,	,
47658	771	22	inert	inert	JJ
47658	771	23	matter	matter	NN
47658	771	24	,	,	,
47658	771	25	even	even	RB
47658	771	26	spatial	spatial	JJ
47658	771	27	extension	extension	NN
47658	771	28	,	,	,
47658	771	29	are	be	VBP
47658	771	30	appearances	appearance	NNS
47658	771	31	.	.	.
47658	772	1	True	true	JJ
47658	772	2	duration	duration	NN
47658	772	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	772	4	change	change	NN
47658	772	5	,	,	,
47658	772	6	not	not	RB
47658	772	7	the	the	DT
47658	772	8	permanence	permanence	NN
47658	772	9	of	of	IN
47658	772	10	something	something	NN
47658	772	11	amidst	amidst	IN
47658	772	12	change	change	NN
47658	772	13	.	.	.
47658	773	1	There	there	EX
47658	773	2	are	be	VBP
47658	773	3	no	no	DT
47658	773	4	unchanging	unchanging	JJ
47658	773	5	things	thing	NNS
47658	773	6	.	.	.
47658	774	1	Everything	everything	NN
47658	774	2	changes	change	VBZ
47658	774	3	.	.	.
47658	775	1	Reality	reality	NN
47658	775	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	775	3	the	the	DT
47658	775	4	flux	flux	NN
47658	775	5	;	;	:
47658	775	6	things	thing	NNS
47658	775	7	are	be	VBP
47658	775	8	views	view	NNS
47658	775	9	of	of	IN
47658	775	10	the	the	DT
47658	775	11	flux	flux	NN
47658	775	12	,	,	,
47658	775	13	arrests	arrest	NNS
47658	775	14	or	or	CC
47658	775	15	contractions	contraction	NNS
47658	775	16	of	of	IN
47658	775	17	the	the	DT
47658	775	18	flowing	flow	VBG
47658	775	19	that	that	IN
47658	775	20	the	the	DT
47658	775	21	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	775	22	makes	make	VBZ
47658	775	23	.	.	.
47658	776	1	The	the	DT
47658	776	2	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	776	3	of	of	IN
47658	776	4	the	the	DT
47658	776	5	world	world	NN
47658	776	6	to	to	IN
47658	776	7	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	776	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	776	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	776	10	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	776	11	grasp	grasp	NN
47658	776	12	of	of	IN
47658	776	13	a	a	DT
47658	776	14	reality	reality	NN
47658	776	15	that	that	WDT
47658	776	16	flows	flow	VBZ
47658	776	17	.	.	.
47658	777	1	This	this	DT
47658	777	2	original	original	JJ
47658	777	3	movement	movement	NN
47658	777	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	777	5	the	the	DT
47658	777	6	life	life	NN
47658	777	7	of	of	IN
47658	777	8	the	the	DT
47658	777	9	universe	universe	NN
47658	777	10	.	.	.
47658	778	1	Briefly	briefly	RB
47658	778	2	stated	state	VBD
47658	778	3	,	,	,
47658	778	4	the	the	DT
47658	778	5	argument	argument	NN
47658	778	6	on	on	IN
47658	778	7	which	which	WDT
47658	778	8	the	the	DT
47658	778	9	theory	theory	NN
47658	778	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	778	11	based	base	VBN
47658	778	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	778	13	that	that	IN
47658	778	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	778	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	778	16	logically	logically	RB
47658	778	17	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	778	18	to	to	TO
47658	778	19	explain	explain	VB
47658	778	20	change	change	NN
47658	778	21	by	by	IN
47658	778	22	changelessness	changelessness	NN
47658	778	23	,	,	,
47658	778	24	movement	movement	NN
47658	778	25	by	by	IN
47658	778	26	immobility	immobility	NN
47658	778	27	.	.	.
47658	779	1	Real	real	JJ
47658	779	2	change	change	NN
47658	779	3	can	can	MD
47658	779	4	not	not	RB
47658	779	5	be	be	VB
47658	779	6	a	a	DT
47658	779	7	succession	succession	NN
47658	779	8	of	of	IN
47658	779	9	states	state	NNS
47658	779	10	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	779	11	fixed	fix	VBN
47658	779	12	and	and	CC
47658	779	13	changeless	changeless	NN
47658	779	14	;	;	:
47658	779	15	real	real	JJ
47658	779	16	movement	movement	NN
47658	779	17	can	can	MD
47658	779	18	not	not	RB
47658	779	19	be	be	VB
47658	779	20	the	the	DT
47658	779	21	immobile	immobile	JJ
47658	779	22	positions	position	NNS
47658	779	23	in	in	IN
47658	779	24	which	which	WDT
47658	779	25	some	some	DT
47658	779	26	thing	thing	NN
47658	779	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	779	28	successively	successively	RB
47658	779	29	at	at	IN
47658	779	30	rest	rest	NN
47658	779	31	.	.	.
47658	780	1	On	on	IN
47658	780	2	the	the	DT
47658	780	3	other	other	JJ
47658	780	4	hand	hand	NN
47658	780	5	,	,	,
47658	780	6	if	if	IN
47658	780	7	movement	movement	NN
47658	780	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	780	9	original	original	JJ
47658	780	10	,	,	,
47658	780	11	the	the	DT
47658	780	12	interruption	interruption	NN
47658	780	13	of	of	IN
47658	780	14	movement	movement	NN
47658	780	15	,	,	,
47658	780	16	in	in	IN
47658	780	17	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	780	18	way	way	NN
47658	780	19	effected	effect	VBN
47658	780	20	,	,	,
47658	780	21	will	will	MD
47658	780	22	appear	appear	VB
47658	780	23	as	as	IN
47658	780	24	things	thing	NNS
47658	780	25	.	.	.
47658	781	1	The	the	DT
47658	781	2	experience	experience	NN
47658	781	3	which	which	WDT
47658	781	4	confirms	confirm	VBZ
47658	781	5	this	this	DT
47658	781	6	argument	argument	NN
47658	781	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	781	8	the	the	DT
47658	781	9	insight	insight	NN
47658	781	10	that	that	IN
47658	781	11	everyone	everyone	NN
47658	781	12	may	may	MD
47658	781	13	obtain	obtain	VB
47658	781	14	of	of	IN
47658	781	15	the	the	DT
47658	781	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	781	17	of	of	IN
47658	781	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	781	19	own	own	JJ
47658	781	20	life	life	NN
47658	781	21	as	as	IN
47658	781	22	continuous	continuous	JJ
47658	781	23	movement	movement	NN
47658	781	24	,	,	,
47658	781	25	unceasing	unceasing	NN
47658	781	26	change	change	NN
47658	781	27	,	,	,
47658	781	28	wherein	wherein	WRB
47658	781	29	all	all	DT
47658	781	30	that	that	WDT
47658	781	31	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	781	32	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	781	33	together	together	RB
47658	781	34	in	in	IN
47658	781	35	a	a	DT
47658	781	36	present	present	JJ
47658	781	37	activity	activity	NN
47658	781	38	.	.	.
47658	782	1	To	to	TO
47658	782	2	develop	develop	VB
47658	782	3	this	this	DT
47658	782	4	argument	argument	NN
47658	782	5	would	would	MD
47658	782	6	exceed	exceed	VB
47658	782	7	the	the	DT
47658	782	8	limits	limit	NNS
47658	782	9	of	of	IN
47658	782	10	this	this	DT
47658	782	11	book	book	NN
47658	782	12	,	,	,
47658	782	13	and	and	CC
47658	782	14	would	would	MD
47658	782	15	be	be	VB
47658	782	16	outside	outside	IN
47658	782	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	782	18	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	782	19	.	.	.
47658	783	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	783	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	783	3	essential	essential	JJ
47658	783	4	,	,	,
47658	783	5	however	however	RB
47658	783	6	,	,	,
47658	783	7	that	that	IN
47658	783	8	such	such	PDT
47658	783	9	a	a	DT
47658	783	10	theory	theory	NN
47658	783	11	should	should	MD
47658	783	12	be	be	VB
47658	783	13	understood	understand	VBN
47658	783	14	,	,	,
47658	783	15	for	for	IN
47658	783	16	clearly	clearly	RB
47658	783	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	783	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	783	19	possible	possible	JJ
47658	783	20	to	to	TO
47658	783	21	hold	hold	VB
47658	783	22	not	not	RB
47658	783	23	only	only	RB
47658	783	24	that	that	IN
47658	783	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	783	26	are	be	VBP
47658	783	27	subject	subject	JJ
47658	783	28	to	to	IN
47658	783	29	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	783	30	,	,	,
47658	783	31	but	but	CC
47658	783	32	that	that	DT
47658	783	33	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	783	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	783	35	of	of	IN
47658	783	36	the	the	DT
47658	783	37	very	very	JJ
47658	783	38	nature	nature	NN
47658	783	39	of	of	IN
47658	783	40	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	783	41	apprehension	apprehension	NN
47658	783	42	.	.	.
47658	784	1	If	if	IN
47658	784	2	,	,	,
47658	784	3	then	then	RB
47658	784	4	,	,	,
47658	784	5	the	the	DT
47658	784	6	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	784	7	works	work	VBZ
47658	784	8	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	784	9	for	for	IN
47658	784	10	the	the	DT
47658	784	11	sake	sake	NN
47658	784	12	of	of	IN
47658	784	13	action	action	NN
47658	784	14	,	,	,
47658	784	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	784	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	784	17	thereby	thereby	RB
47658	784	18	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
47658	784	19	as	as	IN
47658	784	20	an	an	DT
47658	784	21	instrument	instrument	NN
47658	784	22	for	for	IN
47658	784	23	the	the	DT
47658	784	24	attainment	attainment	NN
47658	784	25	of	of	IN
47658	784	26	truth	truth	NN
47658	784	27	?	?	.
47658	785	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	785	2	are	be	VBP
47658	785	3	brought	bring	VBN
47658	785	4	,	,	,
47658	785	5	then	then	RB
47658	785	6	,	,	,
47658	785	7	to	to	IN
47658	785	8	the	the	DT
47658	785	9	critical	critical	JJ
47658	785	10	point	point	NN
47658	785	11	of	of	IN
47658	785	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	785	13	inquiry	inquiry	NN
47658	785	14	.	.	.
47658	786	1	If	if	IN
47658	786	2	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	786	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	786	4	the	the	DT
47658	786	5	essential	essential	JJ
47658	786	6	condition	condition	NN
47658	786	7	of	of	IN
47658	786	8	human	human	JJ
47658	786	9	activity	activity	NN
47658	786	10	,	,	,
47658	786	11	if	if	IN
47658	786	12	the	the	DT
47658	786	13	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	786	14	,	,	,
47658	786	15	the	the	DT
47658	786	16	very	very	JJ
47658	786	17	instrument	instrument	NN
47658	786	18	of	of	IN
47658	786	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	786	20	,	,	,
47658	786	21	{	{	-LRB-
47658	786	22	72	72	CD
47658	786	23	}	}	-RRB-
47658	786	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	786	25	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	786	26	affected	affect	VBN
47658	786	27	,	,	,
47658	786	28	what	what	WP
47658	786	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	786	30	to	to	TO
47658	786	31	save	save	VB
47658	786	32	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	786	33	from	from	IN
47658	786	34	universal	universal	JJ
47658	786	35	scepticism	scepticism	NN
47658	786	36	?	?	.
47658	787	1	If	if	IN
47658	787	2	the	the	DT
47658	787	3	salt	salt	NN
47658	787	4	have	have	VBP
47658	787	5	lost	lose	VBN
47658	787	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	787	7	savour	savour	NN
47658	787	8	,	,	,
47658	787	9	wherewith	wherewith	NN
47658	787	10	shall	shall	MD
47658	787	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	787	12	be	be	VB
47658	787	13	salted	salt	VBN
47658	787	14	?	?	.
47658	788	1	The	the	DT
47658	788	2	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	788	3	with	with	IN
47658	788	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	788	5	frames	frame	NNS
47658	788	6	and	and	CC
47658	788	7	moulds	mould	VBZ
47658	788	8	shapes	shape	NNS
47658	788	9	living	live	VBG
47658	788	10	change	change	NN
47658	788	11	and	and	CC
47658	788	12	movement	movement	NN
47658	788	13	into	into	IN
47658	788	14	fixed	fix	VBN
47658	788	15	immobile	immobile	JJ
47658	788	16	states	state	NNS
47658	788	17	;	;	:
47658	788	18	the	the	DT
47658	788	19	process	process	NN
47658	788	20	of	of	IN
47658	788	21	knowing	know	VBG
47658	788	22	alters	alter	NNS
47658	788	23	profoundly	profoundly	RB
47658	788	24	the	the	DT
47658	788	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	788	26	known	know	VBN
47658	788	27	.	.	.
47658	789	1	Must	Must	MD
47658	789	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	789	3	not	not	RB
47658	789	4	conclude	conclude	VB
47658	789	5	that	that	DT
47658	789	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	789	7	,	,	,
47658	789	8	however	however	RB
47658	789	9	useful	useful	JJ
47658	789	10	,	,	,
47658	789	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	789	12	not	not	RB
47658	789	13	true	true	JJ
47658	789	14	?	?	.
47658	790	1	And	and	CC
47658	790	2	to	to	IN
47658	790	3	what	what	WP
47658	790	4	shall	shall	MD
47658	790	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	790	6	turn	turn	VB
47658	790	7	for	for	IN
47658	790	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	790	9	?	?	.
47658	791	1	There	there	EX
47658	791	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	791	3	,	,	,
47658	791	4	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	791	5	,	,	,
47658	791	6	if	if	IN
47658	791	7	this	this	DT
47658	791	8	be	be	VB
47658	791	9	so	so	RB
47658	791	10	,	,	,
47658	791	11	a	a	DT
47658	791	12	deeper	deep	JJR
47658	791	13	irony	irony	NN
47658	791	14	in	in	IN
47658	791	15	the	the	DT
47658	791	16	question	question	NN
47658	791	17	,	,	,
47658	791	18	What	what	WP
47658	791	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	791	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	791	21	?	?	.
47658	792	1	than	than	IN
47658	792	2	even	even	RB
47658	792	3	Pilate	Pilate	NNP
47658	792	4	could	could	MD
47658	792	5	have	have	VB
47658	792	6	imagined	imagine	VBN
47658	792	7	.	.	.
47658	793	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	793	2	have	have	VBP
47658	793	3	absolutely	absolutely	RB
47658	793	4	no	no	DT
47658	793	5	practical	practical	JJ
47658	793	6	concern	concern	NN
47658	793	7	with	with	IN
47658	793	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	793	9	--	--	:
47658	793	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	793	11	must	must	MD
47658	793	12	leave	leave	VB
47658	793	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	793	14	to	to	IN
47658	793	15	the	the	DT
47658	793	16	mystic	mystic	NN
47658	793	17	,	,	,
47658	793	18	to	to	IN
47658	793	19	the	the	DT
47658	793	20	unpractical	unpractical	JJ
47658	793	21	,	,	,
47658	793	22	the	the	DT
47658	793	23	contemplative	contemplative	JJ
47658	793	24	man	man	NN
47658	793	25	who	who	WP
47658	793	26	has	have	VBZ
47658	793	27	turned	turn	VBN
47658	793	28	aside	aside	RB
47658	793	29	from	from	IN
47658	793	30	the	the	DT
47658	793	31	stern	stern	JJ
47658	793	32	task	task	NN
47658	793	33	of	of	IN
47658	793	34	busy	busy	JJ
47658	793	35	life	life	NN
47658	793	36	.	.	.
47658	794	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	794	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	794	3	not	not	RB
47658	794	4	so	so	RB
47658	794	5	.	.	.
47658	795	1	The	the	DT
47658	795	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	795	3	that	that	WDT
47658	795	4	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	795	5	so	so	RB
47658	795	6	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	795	7	admits	admit	NNS
47658	795	8	a	a	DT
47658	795	9	quite	quite	RB
47658	795	10	simple	simple	JJ
47658	795	11	solution	solution	NN
47658	795	12	.	.	.
47658	796	1	Illusion	illusion	NN
47658	796	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	796	3	not	not	RB
47658	796	4	error	error	NN
47658	796	5	,	,	,
47658	796	6	nor	nor	CC
47658	796	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	796	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	796	9	falsehood	falsehood	JJ
47658	796	10	;	;	:
47658	796	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	796	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	796	13	the	the	DT
47658	796	14	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	796	15	of	of	IN
47658	796	16	reality	reality	NN
47658	796	17	.	.	.
47658	797	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	797	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	797	3	the	the	DT
47658	797	4	reality	reality	NN
47658	797	5	that	that	WDT
47658	797	6	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	797	7	,	,	,
47658	797	8	and	and	CC
47658	797	9	when	when	WRB
47658	797	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	797	11	grasp	grasp	VBP
47658	797	12	the	the	DT
47658	797	13	principle	principle	NN
47658	797	14	of	of	IN
47658	797	15	utility	utility	NN
47658	797	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	797	17	understand	understand	VBP
47658	797	18	the	the	DT
47658	797	19	shape	shape	NN
47658	797	20	that	that	WDT
47658	797	21	the	the	DT
47658	797	22	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	797	23	must	must	MD
47658	797	24	assume	assume	VB
47658	797	25	.	.	.
47658	798	1	This	this	DT
47658	798	2	shape	shape	NN
47658	798	3	may	may	MD
47658	798	4	seem	seem	VB
47658	798	5	to	to	IN
47658	798	6	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	798	7	a	a	DT
47658	798	8	distortion	distortion	NN
47658	798	9	,	,	,
47658	798	10	but	but	CC
47658	798	11	in	in	IN
47658	798	12	recognising	recognise	VBG
47658	798	13	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	798	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	798	15	are	be	VBP
47658	798	16	in	in	IN
47658	798	17	touch	touch	NN
47658	798	18	with	with	IN
47658	798	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	798	20	,	,	,
47658	798	21	and	and	CC
47658	798	22	practical	practical	JJ
47658	798	23	interest	interest	NN
47658	798	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	798	25	the	the	DT
47658	798	26	key	key	NN
47658	798	27	that	that	WDT
47658	798	28	opens	open	VBZ
47658	798	29	to	to	IN
47658	798	30	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	798	31	the	the	DT
47658	798	32	interpretation	interpretation	NN
47658	798	33	of	of	IN
47658	798	34	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	798	35	experience	experience	NN
47658	798	36	.	.	.
47658	799	1	And	and	CC
47658	799	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	799	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	799	4	not	not	RB
47658	799	5	only	only	RB
47658	799	6	by	by	IN
47658	799	7	the	the	DT
47658	799	8	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	799	9	that	that	WDT
47658	799	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	799	11	interpret	interpret	VBP
47658	799	12	the	the	DT
47658	799	13	nature	nature	NN
47658	799	14	of	of	IN
47658	799	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	799	16	,	,	,
47658	799	17	for	for	IN
47658	799	18	besides	besides	IN
47658	799	19	logic	logic	NN
47658	799	20	there	there	EX
47658	799	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	799	22	life	life	NN
47658	799	23	,	,	,
47658	799	24	and	and	CC
47658	799	25	in	in	IN
47658	799	26	life	life	NN
47658	799	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	799	28	directly	directly	RB
47658	799	29	perceive	perceive	VBP
47658	799	30	the	the	DT
47658	799	31	reality	reality	NN
47658	799	32	that	that	IN
47658	799	33	in	in	IN
47658	799	34	logic	logic	NN
47658	799	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	799	36	think	think	VBP
47658	799	37	about	about	IN
47658	799	38	.	.	.
47658	800	1	The	the	DT
47658	800	2	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	800	3	,	,	,
47658	800	4	then	then	RB
47658	800	5	,	,	,
47658	800	6	does	do	VBZ
47658	800	7	not	not	RB
47658	800	8	make	make	VB
47658	800	9	truth	truth	NN
47658	800	10	,	,	,
47658	800	11	neither	neither	CC
47658	800	12	does	do	VBZ
47658	800	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	800	14	make	make	VB
47658	800	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	800	16	;	;	:
47658	800	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	800	18	makes	make	VBZ
47658	800	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	800	20	take	take	VB
47658	800	21	the	the	DT
47658	800	22	form	form	NN
47658	800	23	of	of	IN
47658	800	24	spatial	spatial	JJ
47658	800	25	things	thing	NNS
47658	800	26	,	,	,
47658	800	27	and	and	CC
47658	800	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	800	29	makes	make	VBZ
47658	800	30	things	thing	NNS
47658	800	31	seem	seem	VB
47658	800	32	to	to	TO
47658	800	33	be	be	VB
47658	800	34	the	the	DT
47658	800	35	ground	ground	NN
47658	800	36	of	of	IN
47658	800	37	reality	reality	NN
47658	800	38	.	.	.
47658	801	1	Were	be	VBD
47658	801	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	801	3	nature	nature	NN
47658	801	4	not	not	RB
47658	801	5	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	801	6	,	,	,
47658	801	7	if	if	IN
47658	801	8	all	all	DT
47658	801	9	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	801	10	was	be	VBD
47658	801	11	intuitive	intuitive	JJ
47658	801	12	,	,	,
47658	801	13	the	the	DT
47658	801	14	world	world	NN
47658	801	15	would	would	MD
47658	801	16	not	not	RB
47658	801	17	then	then	RB
47658	801	18	appear	appear	VB
47658	801	19	as	as	IN
47658	801	20	things	thing	NNS
47658	801	21	--	--	:
47658	801	22	there	there	EX
47658	801	23	would	would	MD
47658	801	24	be	be	VB
47658	801	25	no	no	DT
47658	801	26	things	thing	NNS
47658	801	27	.	.	.
47658	802	1	But	but	CC
47658	802	2	,	,	,
47658	802	3	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
47658	802	4	that	that	IN
47658	802	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	802	6	world	world	NN
47658	802	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	802	8	an	an	DT
47658	802	9	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	802	10	,	,	,
47658	802	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	802	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	802	13	not	not	RB
47658	802	14	the	the	DT
47658	802	15	less	less	JJR
47658	802	16	on	on	IN
47658	802	17	that	that	DT
47658	802	18	account	account	NN
47658	802	19	a	a	DT
47658	802	20	true	true	JJ
47658	802	21	world	world	NN
47658	802	22	,	,	,
47658	802	23	and	and	CC
47658	802	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	802	25	science	science	NN
47658	802	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	802	27	true	true	JJ
47658	802	28	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	802	29	,	,	,
47658	802	30	in	in	IN
47658	802	31	the	the	DT
47658	802	32	objective	objective	JJ
47658	802	33	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	802	34	of	of	IN
47658	802	35	truth	truth	NN
47658	802	36	,	,	,
47658	802	37	for	for	IN
47658	802	38	{	{	-LRB-
47658	802	39	73	73	CD
47658	802	40	}	}	-RRB-
47658	802	41	once	once	IN
47658	802	42	an	an	DT
47658	802	43	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	802	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	802	45	interpreted	interpret	VBN
47658	802	46	,	,	,
47658	802	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	802	48	becomes	become	VBZ
47658	802	49	an	an	DT
47658	802	50	integral	integral	JJ
47658	802	51	part	part	NN
47658	802	52	of	of	IN
47658	802	53	the	the	DT
47658	802	54	conception	conception	NN
47658	802	55	of	of	IN
47658	802	56	reality	reality	NN
47658	802	57	.	.	.
47658	803	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	803	2	would	would	MD
47658	803	3	be	be	VB
47658	803	4	easy	easy	JJ
47658	803	5	to	to	TO
47658	803	6	find	find	VB
47658	803	7	abundant	abundant	JJ
47658	803	8	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	803	9	of	of	IN
47658	803	10	this	this	DT
47658	803	11	fact	fact	NN
47658	803	12	within	within	IN
47658	803	13	science	science	NN
47658	803	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	803	15	.	.	.
47658	804	1	Thus	thus	RB
47658	804	2	in	in	IN
47658	804	3	the	the	DT
47658	804	4	familiar	familiar	JJ
47658	804	5	case	case	NN
47658	804	6	of	of	IN
47658	804	7	the	the	DT
47658	804	8	straight	straight	JJ
47658	804	9	stick	stick	NN
47658	804	10	which	which	WDT
47658	804	11	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	804	12	bent	bent	JJ
47658	804	13	when	when	WRB
47658	804	14	partly	partly	RB
47658	804	15	immersed	immerse	VBN
47658	804	16	in	in	IN
47658	804	17	water	water	NN
47658	804	18	,	,	,
47658	804	19	as	as	RB
47658	804	20	soon	soon	RB
47658	804	21	as	as	IN
47658	804	22	the	the	DT
47658	804	23	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	804	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	804	25	understood	understand	VBN
47658	804	26	as	as	IN
47658	804	27	due	due	IN
47658	804	28	to	to	IN
47658	804	29	the	the	DT
47658	804	30	different	different	JJ
47658	804	31	refraction	refraction	NN
47658	804	32	of	of	IN
47658	804	33	light	light	NN
47658	804	34	in	in	IN
47658	804	35	media	medium	NNS
47658	804	36	of	of	IN
47658	804	37	different	different	JJ
47658	804	38	density	density	NN
47658	804	39	,	,	,
47658	804	40	air	air	NN
47658	804	41	and	and	CC
47658	804	42	water	water	NN
47658	804	43	,	,	,
47658	804	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	804	45	ceases	cease	VBZ
47658	804	46	to	to	TO
47658	804	47	be	be	VB
47658	804	48	an	an	DT
47658	804	49	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	804	50	.	.	.
47658	805	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	805	2	then	then	RB
47658	805	3	recognise	recognise	VBP
47658	805	4	that	that	IN
47658	805	5	if	if	IN
47658	805	6	a	a	DT
47658	805	7	partly	partly	RB
47658	805	8	immersed	immerse	VBN
47658	805	9	stick	stick	NN
47658	805	10	did	do	VBD
47658	805	11	not	not	RB
47658	805	12	appear	appear	VB
47658	805	13	bent	bent	JJ
47658	805	14	,	,	,
47658	805	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	805	16	would	would	MD
47658	805	17	really	really	RB
47658	805	18	be	be	VB
47658	805	19	bent	bent	JJ
47658	805	20	.	.	.
47658	806	1	Again	again	RB
47658	806	2	,	,	,
47658	806	3	the	the	DT
47658	806	4	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	806	5	that	that	WDT
47658	806	6	clings	cling	VBZ
47658	806	7	to	to	IN
47658	806	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	806	9	most	most	RBS
47658	806	10	persistently	persistently	RB
47658	806	11	throughout	throughout	IN
47658	806	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	806	13	experience	experience	NN
47658	806	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	806	15	that	that	DT
47658	806	16	which	which	WDT
47658	806	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	806	18	connected	connect	VBN
47658	806	19	with	with	IN
47658	806	20	movement	movement	NN
47658	806	21	and	and	CC
47658	806	22	rest	rest	NN
47658	806	23	.	.	.
47658	807	1	The	the	DT
47658	807	2	system	system	NN
47658	807	3	of	of	IN
47658	807	4	movement	movement	NN
47658	807	5	in	in	IN
47658	807	6	which	which	WDT
47658	807	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	807	8	are	be	VBP
47658	807	9	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	807	10	carried	carry	VBN
47658	807	11	along	along	RB
47658	807	12	appears	appear	VBZ
47658	807	13	to	to	IN
47658	807	14	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	807	15	stationary	stationary	JJ
47658	807	16	,	,	,
47658	807	17	while	while	IN
47658	807	18	that	that	DT
47658	807	19	which	which	WDT
47658	807	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	807	21	outside	outside	IN
47658	807	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	807	23	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	807	24	alone	alone	JJ
47658	807	25	to	to	TO
47658	807	26	move	move	VB
47658	807	27	.	.	.
47658	808	1	In	in	IN
47658	808	2	very	very	RB
47658	808	3	simple	simple	JJ
47658	808	4	cases	case	NNS
47658	808	5	,	,	,
47658	808	6	such	such	JJ
47658	808	7	as	as	IN
47658	808	8	viewing	view	VBG
47658	808	9	the	the	DT
47658	808	10	landscape	landscape	NN
47658	808	11	from	from	IN
47658	808	12	a	a	DT
47658	808	13	railway	railway	NN
47658	808	14	-	-	HYPH
47658	808	15	carriage	carriage	NN
47658	808	16	window	window	NN
47658	808	17	,	,	,
47658	808	18	habit	habit	NN
47658	808	19	has	have	VBZ
47658	808	20	long	long	RB
47658	808	21	caused	cause	VBN
47658	808	22	the	the	DT
47658	808	23	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	808	24	to	to	TO
47658	808	25	cease	cease	VB
47658	808	26	,	,	,
47658	808	27	but	but	CC
47658	808	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	808	29	all	all	DT
47658	808	30	remember	remember	VBP
47658	808	31	the	the	DT
47658	808	32	child	child	NN
47658	808	33	's	's	POS
47658	808	34	feeling	feeling	NN
47658	808	35	that	that	IN
47658	808	36	the	the	DT
47658	808	37	trees	tree	NNS
47658	808	38	and	and	CC
47658	808	39	fields	field	NNS
47658	808	40	were	be	VBD
47658	808	41	flying	fly	VBG
47658	808	42	past	past	IN
47658	808	43	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	808	44	.	.	.
47658	809	1	The	the	DT
47658	809	2	earth	earth	NN
47658	809	3	's	's	POS
47658	809	4	motion	motion	NN
47658	809	5	never	never	RB
47658	809	6	becomes	become	VBZ
47658	809	7	to	to	IN
47658	809	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	809	9	a	a	DT
47658	809	10	real	real	JJ
47658	809	11	experience	experience	NN
47658	809	12	of	of	IN
47658	809	13	movement	movement	NN
47658	809	14	,	,	,
47658	809	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	809	16	accept	accept	VBP
47658	809	17	the	the	DT
47658	809	18	fact	fact	NN
47658	809	19	and	and	CC
47658	809	20	never	never	RB
47658	809	21	doubt	doubt	VB
47658	809	22	the	the	DT
47658	809	23	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	809	24	evidence	evidence	NN
47658	809	25	on	on	IN
47658	809	26	which	which	WDT
47658	809	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	809	28	rests	rest	VBZ
47658	809	29	,	,	,
47658	809	30	yet	yet	CC
47658	809	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	809	32	always	always	RB
47658	809	33	speak	speak	VBP
47658	809	34	and	and	CC
47658	809	35	think	think	VBP
47658	809	36	of	of	IN
47658	809	37	sunrise	sunrise	NN
47658	809	38	and	and	CC
47658	809	39	sunset	sunset	NN
47658	809	40	;	;	,
47658	809	41	and	and	CC
47658	809	42	this	this	DT
47658	809	43	is	be	VBZ
47658	809	44	not	not	RB
47658	809	45	merely	merely	RB
47658	809	46	due	due	JJ
47658	809	47	to	to	IN
47658	809	48	the	the	DT
47658	809	49	accident	accident	NN
47658	809	50	that	that	IN
47658	809	51	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	809	52	language	language	NN
47658	809	53	was	be	VBD
47658	809	54	fixed	fix	VBN
47658	809	55	before	before	IN
47658	809	56	the	the	DT
47658	809	57	nature	nature	NN
47658	809	58	of	of	IN
47658	809	59	the	the	DT
47658	809	60	celestial	celestial	JJ
47658	809	61	movement	movement	NN
47658	809	62	was	be	VBD
47658	809	63	known	know	VBN
47658	809	64	,	,	,
47658	809	65	but	but	CC
47658	809	66	to	to	IN
47658	809	67	a	a	DT
47658	809	68	natural	natural	JJ
47658	809	69	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	809	70	which	which	WDT
47658	809	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	809	72	is	be	VBZ
47658	809	73	far	far	RB
47658	809	74	more	more	RBR
47658	809	75	convenient	convenient	JJ
47658	809	76	to	to	TO
47658	809	77	retain	retain	VB
47658	809	78	than	than	IN
47658	809	79	to	to	TO
47658	809	80	abandon	abandon	VB
47658	809	81	.	.	.
47658	810	1	The	the	DT
47658	810	2	fact	fact	NN
47658	810	3	of	of	IN
47658	810	4	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	810	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	810	6	not	not	RB
47658	810	7	the	the	DT
47658	810	8	tenet	tenet	NN
47658	810	9	of	of	IN
47658	810	10	any	any	DT
47658	810	11	particular	particular	JJ
47658	810	12	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	810	13	,	,	,
47658	810	14	nor	nor	CC
47658	810	15	even	even	RB
47658	810	16	of	of	IN
47658	810	17	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	810	18	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	810	19	;	;	:
47658	810	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	810	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	810	22	a	a	DT
47658	810	23	recognised	recognise	VBN
47658	810	24	factor	factor	NN
47658	810	25	in	in	IN
47658	810	26	common	common	JJ
47658	810	27	life	life	NN
47658	810	28	and	and	CC
47658	810	29	in	in	IN
47658	810	30	physical	physical	JJ
47658	810	31	science	science	NN
47658	810	32	,	,	,
47658	810	33	but	but	CC
47658	810	34	in	in	IN
47658	810	35	instancing	instance	VBG
47658	810	36	the	the	DT
47658	810	37	theory	theory	NN
47658	810	38	of	of	IN
47658	810	39	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	810	40	's	's	POS
47658	810	41	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	810	42	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	810	43	am	be	VBP
47658	810	44	choosing	choose	VBG
47658	810	45	an	an	DT
47658	810	46	extreme	extreme	JJ
47658	810	47	case	case	NN
47658	810	48	.	.	.
47658	811	1	Berkeley	Berkeley	NNP
47658	811	2	held	hold	VBD
47658	811	3	that	that	DT
47658	811	4	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	811	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	811	6	practically	practically	RB
47658	811	7	universal	universal	JJ
47658	811	8	;	;	:
47658	811	9	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	811	10	taught	teach	VBD
47658	811	11	that	that	IN
47658	811	12	the	the	DT
47658	811	13	apparent	apparent	JJ
47658	811	14	objectivity	objectivity	NN
47658	811	15	of	of	IN
47658	811	16	phenomena	phenomenon	NNS
47658	811	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	811	18	the	the	DT
47658	811	19	form	form	NN
47658	811	20	that	that	WDT
47658	811	21	the	the	DT
47658	811	22	understanding	understanding	NN
47658	811	23	imposes	impose	VBZ
47658	811	24	on	on	IN
47658	811	25	things	thing	NNS
47658	811	26	;	;	:
47658	811	27	but	but	CC
47658	811	28	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	811	29	teaches	teach	VBZ
47658	811	30	{	{	-LRB-
47658	811	31	74	74	CD
47658	811	32	}	}	-RRB-
47658	811	33	not	not	RB
47658	811	34	only	only	RB
47658	811	35	that	that	IN
47658	811	36	all	all	DT
47658	811	37	material	material	JJ
47658	811	38	reality	reality	NN
47658	811	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	811	40	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	811	41	,	,	,
47658	811	42	but	but	CC
47658	811	43	also	also	RB
47658	811	44	that	that	IN
47658	811	45	this	this	DT
47658	811	46	very	very	JJ
47658	811	47	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	811	48	is	be	VBZ
47658	811	49	the	the	DT
47658	811	50	work	work	NN
47658	811	51	of	of	IN
47658	811	52	the	the	DT
47658	811	53	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	811	54	,	,	,
47658	811	55	that	that	IN
47658	811	56	the	the	DT
47658	811	57	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	811	58	is	be	VBZ
47658	811	59	formed	form	VBN
47658	811	60	for	for	IN
47658	811	61	this	this	DT
47658	811	62	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	811	63	,	,	,
47658	811	64	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	811	65	and	and	CC
47658	811	66	matter	matter	NN
47658	811	67	being	be	VBG
47658	811	68	correlative	correlative	JJ
47658	811	69	,	,	,
47658	811	70	evolving	evolve	VBG
47658	811	71	_	_	NNP
47658	811	72	pari	pari	JJ
47658	811	73	passu	passu	NN
47658	811	74	_	_	NNP
47658	811	75	.	.	.
47658	812	1	To	to	IN
47658	812	2	such	such	PDT
47658	812	3	a	a	DT
47658	812	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	812	5	there	there	EX
47658	812	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	812	7	of	of	IN
47658	812	8	necessity	necessity	NN
47658	812	9	a	a	DT
47658	812	10	positive	positive	JJ
47658	812	11	side	side	NN
47658	812	12	,	,	,
47658	812	13	for	for	IN
47658	812	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	812	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	812	16	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	812	17	that	that	IN
47658	812	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	812	19	can	can	MD
47658	812	20	rest	rest	VB
47658	812	21	on	on	IN
47658	812	22	universal	universal	JJ
47658	812	23	scepticism	scepticism	NN
47658	812	24	--	--	:
47658	812	25	scepticism	scepticism	NN
47658	812	26	both	both	DT
47658	812	27	of	of	IN
47658	812	28	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	812	29	and	and	CC
47658	812	30	of	of	IN
47658	812	31	the	the	DT
47658	812	32	instrument	instrument	NN
47658	812	33	of	of	IN
47658	812	34	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	812	35	.	.	.
47658	813	1	If	if	IN
47658	813	2	the	the	DT
47658	813	3	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
47658	813	4	view	view	NN
47658	813	5	of	of	IN
47658	813	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	813	7	as	as	IN
47658	813	8	solid	solid	JJ
47658	813	9	matter	matter	NN
47658	813	10	in	in	IN
47658	813	11	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	813	12	space	space	NN
47658	813	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	813	14	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	813	15	,	,	,
47658	813	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	813	17	must	must	MD
47658	813	18	be	be	VB
47658	813	19	possible	possible	JJ
47658	813	20	to	to	TO
47658	813	21	apprehend	apprehend	VB
47658	813	22	the	the	DT
47658	813	23	reality	reality	NN
47658	813	24	from	from	IN
47658	813	25	which	which	WDT
47658	813	26	the	the	DT
47658	813	27	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	813	28	that	that	IN
47658	813	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	813	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	813	31	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	813	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	813	33	derived	derive	VBN
47658	813	34	.	.	.
47658	814	1	If	if	IN
47658	814	2	the	the	DT
47658	814	3	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	814	4	distorts	distort	VBZ
47658	814	5	,	,	,
47658	814	6	there	there	EX
47658	814	7	must	must	MD
47658	814	8	be	be	VB
47658	814	9	an	an	DT
47658	814	10	intuition	intuition	NN
47658	814	11	which	which	WDT
47658	814	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	814	13	pure	pure	JJ
47658	814	14	,	,	,
47658	814	15	and	and	CC
47658	814	16	the	the	DT
47658	814	17	relation	relation	NN
47658	814	18	between	between	IN
47658	814	19	these	these	DT
47658	814	20	will	will	MD
47658	814	21	be	be	VB
47658	814	22	the	the	DT
47658	814	23	relation	relation	NN
47658	814	24	between	between	IN
47658	814	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	814	26	and	and	CC
47658	814	27	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	814	28	.	.	.
47658	815	1	Neither	neither	DT
47658	815	2	,	,	,
47658	815	3	then	then	RB
47658	815	4	,	,	,
47658	815	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	815	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	815	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	815	8	,	,	,
47658	815	9	nor	nor	CC
47658	815	10	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	815	11	error	error	NN
47658	815	12	.	.	.
47658	816	1	There	there	EX
47658	816	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	816	3	a	a	DT
47658	816	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	816	5	of	of	IN
47658	816	6	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	816	7	,	,	,
47658	816	8	a	a	DT
47658	816	9	truth	truth	NN
47658	816	10	that	that	WDT
47658	816	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	816	12	a	a	DT
47658	816	13	value	value	NN
47658	816	14	in	in	IN
47658	816	15	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	816	16	,	,	,
47658	816	17	a	a	DT
47658	816	18	truth	truth	NN
47658	816	19	that	that	WDT
47658	816	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	816	21	more	more	JJR
47658	816	22	than	than	IN
47658	816	23	the	the	DT
47658	816	24	mere	mere	JJ
47658	816	25	negation	negation	NN
47658	816	26	that	that	IN
47658	816	27	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	816	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	816	29	not	not	RB
47658	816	30	reality	reality	NN
47658	816	31	.	.	.
47658	817	1	The	the	DT
47658	817	2	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	817	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	817	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	817	5	hold	hold	NN
47658	817	6	upon	upon	IN
47658	817	7	the	the	DT
47658	817	8	reality	reality	NN
47658	817	9	,	,	,
47658	817	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	817	11	actual	actual	JJ
47658	817	12	contact	contact	NN
47658	817	13	with	with	IN
47658	817	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	817	15	,	,	,
47658	817	16	the	the	DT
47658	817	17	mode	mode	NN
47658	817	18	and	and	CC
47658	817	19	direction	direction	NN
47658	817	20	of	of	IN
47658	817	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	817	22	action	action	NN
47658	817	23	upon	upon	IN
47658	817	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	817	25	.	.	.
47658	818	1	What	what	WP
47658	818	2	,	,	,
47658	818	3	then	then	RB
47658	818	4	,	,	,
47658	818	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	818	6	error	error	NN
47658	818	7	?	?	.
47658	819	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	819	2	can	can	MD
47658	819	3	not	not	RB
47658	819	4	consist	consist	VB
47658	819	5	in	in	IN
47658	819	6	the	the	DT
47658	819	7	fact	fact	NN
47658	819	8	that	that	IN
47658	819	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	819	10	know	know	VBP
47658	819	11	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	819	12	only	only	RB
47658	819	13	,	,	,
47658	819	14	not	not	RB
47658	819	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	819	16	,	,	,
47658	819	17	for	for	IN
47658	819	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	819	19	can	can	MD
47658	819	20	only	only	RB
47658	819	21	know	know	VB
47658	819	22	reality	reality	NN
47658	819	23	by	by	IN
47658	819	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	819	25	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	819	26	.	.	.
47658	820	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	820	2	can	can	MD
47658	820	3	not	not	RB
47658	820	4	be	be	VB
47658	820	5	an	an	DT
47658	820	6	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	820	7	behind	behind	IN
47658	820	8	which	which	WDT
47658	820	9	there	there	EX
47658	820	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	820	11	no	no	DT
47658	820	12	reality	reality	NN
47658	820	13	,	,	,
47658	820	14	for	for	IN
47658	820	15	non	non	JJ
47658	820	16	-	-	NN
47658	820	17	being	being	JJ
47658	820	18	can	can	MD
47658	820	19	not	not	RB
47658	820	20	appear	appear	VB
47658	820	21	.	.	.
47658	821	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	821	2	can	can	MD
47658	821	3	not	not	RB
47658	821	4	be	be	VB
47658	821	5	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	821	6	at	at	RB
47658	821	7	all	all	RB
47658	821	8	or	or	CC
47658	821	9	pure	pure	JJ
47658	821	10	non	non	JJ
47658	821	11	-	-	JJ
47658	821	12	being	being	JJ
47658	821	13	,	,	,
47658	821	14	for	for	IN
47658	821	15	to	to	TO
47658	821	16	think	think	VB
47658	821	17	of	of	IN
47658	821	18	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	821	19	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	821	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	821	21	not	not	RB
47658	821	22	to	to	TO
47658	821	23	think	think	VB
47658	821	24	.	.	.
47658	822	1	In	in	IN
47658	822	2	error	error	NN
47658	822	3	there	there	EX
47658	822	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	822	5	some	some	DT
47658	822	6	object	object	NN
47658	822	7	of	of	IN
47658	822	8	thought	thought	NN
47658	822	9	which	which	WDT
47658	822	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	822	11	denied	deny	VBN
47658	822	12	real	real	JJ
47658	822	13	being	being	NN
47658	822	14	.	.	.
47658	823	1	What	what	WP
47658	823	2	this	this	DT
47658	823	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	823	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	823	5	the	the	DT
47658	823	6	problem	problem	NN
47658	823	7	of	of	IN
47658	823	8	error	error	NN
47658	823	9	.	.	.
47658	824	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
47658	824	2	VIII	viii	VBP
47658	824	3	THE	the	DT
47658	824	4	PROBLEM	problem	NN
47658	824	5	OF	of	IN
47658	824	6	ERROR	ERROR	NNP
47658	824	7	In	in	IN
47658	824	8	the	the	DT
47658	824	9	_	_	NNP
47658	824	10	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	824	11	_	_	NNP
47658	824	12	of	of	IN
47658	824	13	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	824	14	,	,	,
47658	824	15	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
47658	824	16	has	have	VBZ
47658	824	17	been	be	VBN
47658	824	18	discussing	discuss	VBG
47658	824	19	with	with	IN
47658	824	20	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	824	21	what	what	WDT
47658	824	22	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	824	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	824	24	,	,	,
47658	824	25	and	and	CC
47658	824	26	when	when	WRB
47658	824	27	at	at	IN
47658	824	28	last	last	JJ
47658	824	29	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	824	30	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	824	31	to	to	TO
47658	824	32	be	be	VB
47658	824	33	reached	reach	VBN
47658	824	34	in	in	IN
47658	824	35	the	the	DT
47658	824	36	definition	definition	NN
47658	824	37	that	that	IN
47658	824	38	{	{	-LRB-
47658	824	39	75	75	CD
47658	824	40	}	}	-RRB-
47658	824	41	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	824	42	is	be	VBZ
47658	824	43	true	true	JJ
47658	824	44	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	824	45	,	,	,
47658	824	46	a	a	DT
47658	824	47	new	new	JJ
47658	824	48	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	824	49	occurs	occur	VBZ
47658	824	50	to	to	IN
47658	824	51	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
47658	824	52	:	:	:
47658	824	53	"	"	``
47658	824	54	There	there	EX
47658	824	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	824	56	a	a	DT
47658	824	57	point	point	NN
47658	824	58	which	which	WDT
47658	824	59	often	often	RB
47658	824	60	troubles	trouble	VBZ
47658	824	61	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	824	62	and	and	CC
47658	824	63	is	be	VBZ
47658	824	64	a	a	DT
47658	824	65	great	great	JJ
47658	824	66	perplexity	perplexity	NN
47658	824	67	to	to	IN
47658	824	68	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	824	69	both	both	CC
47658	824	70	in	in	IN
47658	824	71	regard	regard	NN
47658	824	72	to	to	IN
47658	824	73	myself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	824	74	and	and	CC
47658	824	75	to	to	IN
47658	824	76	others	other	NNS
47658	824	77	.	.	.
47658	825	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	825	2	can	can	MD
47658	825	3	not	not	RB
47658	825	4	make	make	VB
47658	825	5	out	out	RP
47658	825	6	the	the	DT
47658	825	7	nature	nature	NN
47658	825	8	or	or	CC
47658	825	9	origin	origin	NN
47658	825	10	of	of	IN
47658	825	11	the	the	DT
47658	825	12	mental	mental	JJ
47658	825	13	experience	experience	NN
47658	825	14	to	to	TO
47658	825	15	which	which	WDT
47658	825	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	825	17	refer	refer	VBP
47658	825	18	.	.	.
47658	826	1	How	how	WRB
47658	826	2	there	there	EX
47658	826	3	can	can	MD
47658	826	4	be	be	VB
47658	826	5	false	false	JJ
47658	826	6	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	826	7	--	--	:
47658	826	8	that	that	WDT
47658	826	9	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	826	10	still	still	RB
47658	826	11	troubles	trouble	VBZ
47658	826	12	the	the	DT
47658	826	13	eye	eye	NN
47658	826	14	of	of	IN
47658	826	15	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	826	16	mind	mind	NN
47658	826	17	.	.	.
47658	827	1	Do	do	VBP
47658	827	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	827	3	not	not	RB
47658	827	4	speak	speak	VB
47658	827	5	of	of	IN
47658	827	6	false	false	JJ
47658	827	7	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	827	8	,	,	,
47658	827	9	and	and	CC
47658	827	10	say	say	VB
47658	827	11	that	that	IN
47658	827	12	one	one	CD
47658	827	13	man	man	NN
47658	827	14	holds	hold	VBZ
47658	827	15	a	a	DT
47658	827	16	false	false	JJ
47658	827	17	and	and	CC
47658	827	18	another	another	DT
47658	827	19	a	a	DT
47658	827	20	true	true	JJ
47658	827	21	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	827	22	,	,	,
47658	827	23	as	as	IN
47658	827	24	though	though	IN
47658	827	25	there	there	EX
47658	827	26	were	be	VBD
47658	827	27	some	some	DT
47658	827	28	natural	natural	JJ
47658	827	29	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	827	30	between	between	IN
47658	827	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	827	32	?	?	.
47658	828	1	All	all	DT
47658	828	2	things	thing	NNS
47658	828	3	and	and	CC
47658	828	4	everything	everything	NN
47658	828	5	are	be	VBP
47658	828	6	either	either	CC
47658	828	7	known	known	JJ
47658	828	8	or	or	CC
47658	828	9	not	not	RB
47658	828	10	known	know	VBN
47658	828	11	.	.	.
47658	829	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	829	2	who	who	WP
47658	829	3	knows	know	VBZ
47658	829	4	,	,	,
47658	829	5	can	can	MD
47658	829	6	not	not	RB
47658	829	7	but	but	CC
47658	829	8	know	know	VB
47658	829	9	;	;	:
47658	829	10	and	and	CC
47658	829	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	829	12	who	who	WP
47658	829	13	does	do	VBZ
47658	829	14	not	not	RB
47658	829	15	know	know	VB
47658	829	16	,	,	,
47658	829	17	can	can	MD
47658	829	18	not	not	RB
47658	829	19	know	know	VB
47658	829	20	....	....	.
47658	829	21	Where	where	WRB
47658	829	22	,	,	,
47658	829	23	then	then	RB
47658	829	24	,	,	,
47658	829	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	829	26	false	false	JJ
47658	829	27	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	829	28	?	?	.
47658	830	1	For	for	IN
47658	830	2	if	if	IN
47658	830	3	all	all	DT
47658	830	4	things	thing	NNS
47658	830	5	are	be	VBP
47658	830	6	either	either	CC
47658	830	7	known	known	JJ
47658	830	8	or	or	CC
47658	830	9	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	830	10	,	,	,
47658	830	11	there	there	EX
47658	830	12	can	can	MD
47658	830	13	be	be	VB
47658	830	14	no	no	DT
47658	830	15	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	830	16	which	which	WDT
47658	830	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	830	18	not	not	RB
47658	830	19	comprehended	comprehend	VBN
47658	830	20	under	under	IN
47658	830	21	this	this	DT
47658	830	22	alternative	alternative	NN
47658	830	23	,	,	,
47658	830	24	and	and	CC
47658	830	25	so	so	RB
47658	830	26	false	false	JJ
47658	830	27	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	830	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	830	29	excluded	exclude	VBN
47658	830	30	.	.	.
47658	830	31	"	"	''
47658	831	1	This	this	DT
47658	831	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	831	3	may	may	MD
47658	831	4	appear	appear	VB
47658	831	5	at	at	IN
47658	831	6	first	first	JJ
47658	831	7	sight	sight	NN
47658	831	8	purely	purely	RB
47658	831	9	verbal	verbal	JJ
47658	831	10	,	,	,
47658	831	11	and	and	CC
47658	831	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	831	13	shall	shall	MD
47658	831	14	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	831	15	be	be	VB
47658	831	16	inclined	incline	VBN
47658	831	17	to	to	TO
47658	831	18	see	see	VB
47658	831	19	the	the	DT
47658	831	20	answer	answer	NN
47658	831	21	to	to	IN
47658	831	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	831	23	in	in	IN
47658	831	24	the	the	DT
47658	831	25	double	double	JJ
47658	831	26	use	use	NN
47658	831	27	that	that	WDT
47658	831	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	831	29	make	make	VBP
47658	831	30	of	of	IN
47658	831	31	the	the	DT
47658	831	32	word	word	NN
47658	831	33	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	831	34	.	.	.
47658	832	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	832	2	use	use	VBP
47658	832	3	the	the	DT
47658	832	4	word	word	NN
47658	832	5	in	in	IN
47658	832	6	two	two	CD
47658	832	7	senses	sense	NNS
47658	832	8	,	,	,
47658	832	9	in	in	IN
47658	832	10	one	one	CD
47658	832	11	of	of	IN
47658	832	12	which	which	WDT
47658	832	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	832	14	includes	include	VBZ
47658	832	15	all	all	DT
47658	832	16	and	and	CC
47658	832	17	everything	everything	NN
47658	832	18	that	that	WDT
47658	832	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	832	20	or	or	CC
47658	832	21	can	can	MD
47658	832	22	be	be	VB
47658	832	23	present	present	JJ
47658	832	24	to	to	IN
47658	832	25	the	the	DT
47658	832	26	mind	mind	NN
47658	832	27	in	in	IN
47658	832	28	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	832	29	,	,	,
47658	832	30	and	and	CC
47658	832	31	in	in	IN
47658	832	32	another	another	DT
47658	832	33	and	and	CC
47658	832	34	narrower	narrow	JJR
47658	832	35	sense	sense	NN
47658	832	36	the	the	DT
47658	832	37	word	word	NN
47658	832	38	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	832	39	means	mean	VBZ
47658	832	40	truth	truth	NN
47658	832	41	.	.	.
47658	833	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	833	2	was	be	VBD
47658	833	3	in	in	IN
47658	833	4	the	the	DT
47658	833	5	narrow	narrow	JJ
47658	833	6	sense	sense	NN
47658	833	7	of	of	IN
47658	833	8	the	the	DT
47658	833	9	word	word	NN
47658	833	10	that	that	IN
47658	833	11	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	833	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	833	13	not	not	RB
47658	833	14	true	true	JJ
47658	833	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	833	16	not	not	RB
47658	833	17	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	833	18	that	that	IN
47658	833	19	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
47658	833	20	interpreted	interpret	VBD
47658	833	21	the	the	DT
47658	833	22	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	833	23	of	of	IN
47658	833	24	the	the	DT
47658	833	25	Delphic	delphic	JJ
47658	833	26	oracle	oracle	NN
47658	833	27	that	that	WDT
47658	833	28	had	have	VBD
47658	833	29	declared	declare	VBN
47658	833	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
47658	833	31	the	the	DT
47658	833	32	wisest	wise	JJS
47658	833	33	of	of	IN
47658	833	34	men	man	NNS
47658	833	35	.	.	.
47658	834	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	834	2	wisdom	wisdom	NN
47658	834	3	must	must	MD
47658	834	4	be	be	VB
47658	834	5	,	,	,
47658	834	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	834	7	said	say	VBD
47658	834	8	,	,	,
47658	834	9	that	that	IN
47658	834	10	whereas	whereas	IN
47658	834	11	other	other	JJ
47658	834	12	men	man	NNS
47658	834	13	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	834	14	to	to	TO
47658	834	15	be	be	VB
47658	834	16	wise	wise	JJ
47658	834	17	and	and	CC
47658	834	18	to	to	TO
47658	834	19	know	know	VB
47658	834	20	something	something	NN
47658	834	21	,	,	,
47658	834	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	834	23	knew	know	VBD
47658	834	24	that	that	IN
47658	834	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	834	26	knew	know	VBD
47658	834	27	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	834	28	.	.	.
47658	835	1	All	all	DT
47658	835	2	men	man	NNS
47658	835	3	have	have	VBP
47658	835	4	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	835	5	,	,	,
47658	835	6	but	but	CC
47658	835	7	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	835	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	835	9	not	not	RB
47658	835	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	835	11	,	,	,
47658	835	12	though	though	IN
47658	835	13	easily	easily	RB
47658	835	14	and	and	CC
47658	835	15	generally	generally	RB
47658	835	16	mistaken	mistaken	JJ
47658	835	17	for	for	IN
47658	835	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	835	19	.	.	.
47658	836	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	836	2	perplexity	perplexity	NN
47658	836	3	was	be	VBD
47658	836	4	to	to	TO
47658	836	5	understand	understand	VB
47658	836	6	what	what	WP
47658	836	7	actually	actually	RB
47658	836	8	this	this	DT
47658	836	9	false	false	JJ
47658	836	10	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	836	11	could	could	MD
47658	836	12	be	be	VB
47658	836	13	which	which	WDT
47658	836	14	passed	pass	VBN
47658	836	15	for	for	IN
47658	836	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	836	17	.	.	.
47658	837	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	837	2	could	could	MD
47658	837	3	not	not	RB
47658	837	4	be	be	VB
47658	837	5	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	837	6	at	at	RB
47658	837	7	all	all	RB
47658	837	8	,	,	,
47658	837	9	for	for	IN
47658	837	10	then	then	RB
47658	837	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	837	12	would	would	MD
47658	837	13	simply	simply	RB
47658	837	14	mean	mean	VB
47658	837	15	ignorance	ignorance	NN
47658	837	16	;	;	:
47658	837	17	but	but	CC
47658	837	18	in	in	IN
47658	837	19	false	false	JJ
47658	837	20	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	837	21	{	{	-LRB-
47658	837	22	76	76	CD
47658	837	23	}	}	-RRB-
47658	837	24	some	some	DT
47658	837	25	object	object	NN
47658	837	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	837	27	present	present	JJ
47658	837	28	to	to	IN
47658	837	29	the	the	DT
47658	837	30	mind	mind	NN
47658	837	31	.	.	.
47658	838	1	Everything	everything	NN
47658	838	2	that	that	WDT
47658	838	3	the	the	DT
47658	838	4	mind	mind	NN
47658	838	5	thinks	think	VBZ
47658	838	6	of	of	IN
47658	838	7	has	have	VBZ
47658	838	8	being	be	VBG
47658	838	9	.	.	.
47658	839	1	A	a	DT
47658	839	2	thing	thing	NN
47658	839	3	may	may	MD
47658	839	4	have	have	VB
47658	839	5	being	be	VBG
47658	839	6	that	that	WDT
47658	839	7	does	do	VBZ
47658	839	8	not	not	RB
47658	839	9	exist	exist	VB
47658	839	10	if	if	IN
47658	839	11	by	by	IN
47658	839	12	existence	existence	NN
47658	839	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	839	14	meant	mean	VBN
47658	839	15	the	the	DT
47658	839	16	particular	particular	JJ
47658	839	17	existence	existence	NN
47658	839	18	of	of	IN
47658	839	19	an	an	DT
47658	839	20	event	event	NN
47658	839	21	in	in	IN
47658	839	22	time	time	NN
47658	839	23	,	,	,
47658	839	24	for	for	IN
47658	839	25	most	most	JJS
47658	839	26	of	of	IN
47658	839	27	the	the	DT
47658	839	28	things	thing	NNS
47658	839	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	839	30	think	think	VBP
47658	839	31	about	about	IN
47658	839	32	are	be	VBP
47658	839	33	timeless	timeless	NN
47658	839	34	--	--	:
47658	839	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	839	36	are	be	VBP
47658	839	37	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	839	38	,	,	,
47658	839	39	such	such	JJ
47658	839	40	as	as	IN
47658	839	41	whiteness	whiteness	NN
47658	839	42	,	,	,
47658	839	43	goodness	goodness	NN
47658	839	44	,	,	,
47658	839	45	numbers	number	NNS
47658	839	46	and	and	CC
47658	839	47	the	the	DT
47658	839	48	properties	property	NNS
47658	839	49	of	of	IN
47658	839	50	numbers	number	NNS
47658	839	51	,	,	,
47658	839	52	faith	faith	NN
47658	839	53	,	,	,
47658	839	54	love	love	NN
47658	839	55	,	,	,
47658	839	56	and	and	CC
47658	839	57	such	such	JJ
47658	839	58	-	-	HYPH
47658	839	59	like	like	JJ
47658	839	60	.	.	.
47658	840	1	All	all	DT
47658	840	2	such	such	JJ
47658	840	3	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	840	4	are	be	VBP
47658	840	5	called	call	VBN
47658	840	6	universals	universal	NNS
47658	840	7	,	,	,
47658	840	8	because	because	IN
47658	840	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	840	10	reality	reality	NN
47658	840	11	does	do	VBZ
47658	840	12	not	not	RB
47658	840	13	mean	mean	VB
47658	840	14	that	that	IN
47658	840	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	840	16	exist	exist	VBP
47658	840	17	at	at	IN
47658	840	18	one	one	CD
47658	840	19	particular	particular	JJ
47658	840	20	moment	moment	NN
47658	840	21	and	and	CC
47658	840	22	no	no	DT
47658	840	23	other	other	JJ
47658	840	24	,	,	,
47658	840	25	but	but	CC
47658	840	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	840	27	are	be	VBP
47658	840	28	real	real	JJ
47658	840	29	,	,	,
47658	840	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	840	31	have	have	VBP
47658	840	32	being	be	VBG
47658	840	33	.	.	.
47658	841	1	How	how	WRB
47658	841	2	,	,	,
47658	841	3	then	then	RB
47658	841	4	,	,	,
47658	841	5	can	can	MD
47658	841	6	there	there	EX
47658	841	7	be	be	VB
47658	841	8	anything	anything	NN
47658	841	9	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
47658	841	10	between	between	IN
47658	841	11	being	be	VBG
47658	841	12	and	and	CC
47658	841	13	not	not	RB
47658	841	14	being	be	VBG
47658	841	15	,	,	,
47658	841	16	anything	anything	NN
47658	841	17	that	that	WDT
47658	841	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	841	19	and	and	CC
47658	841	20	also	also	RB
47658	841	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	841	22	not	not	RB
47658	841	23	,	,	,
47658	841	24	for	for	IN
47658	841	25	this	this	DT
47658	841	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	841	27	what	what	WP
47658	841	28	false	false	JJ
47658	841	29	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	841	30	or	or	CC
47658	841	31	error	error	NN
47658	841	32	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	841	33	to	to	TO
47658	841	34	be	be	VB
47658	841	35	?	?	.
47658	842	1	There	there	EX
47658	842	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	842	3	,	,	,
47658	842	4	then	then	RB
47658	842	5	,	,	,
47658	842	6	a	a	DT
47658	842	7	problem	problem	NN
47658	842	8	of	of	IN
47658	842	9	error	error	NN
47658	842	10	,	,	,
47658	842	11	and	and	CC
47658	842	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	842	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	842	14	quite	quite	RB
47658	842	15	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	842	16	from	from	IN
47658	842	17	the	the	DT
47658	842	18	problem	problem	NN
47658	842	19	of	of	IN
47658	842	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	842	21	.	.	.
47658	843	1	The	the	DT
47658	843	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	843	3	of	of	IN
47658	843	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	843	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	843	6	to	to	TO
47658	843	7	know	know	VB
47658	843	8	by	by	IN
47658	843	9	what	what	WDT
47658	843	10	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	843	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	843	12	can	can	MD
47658	843	13	test	test	VB
47658	843	14	the	the	DT
47658	843	15	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	843	16	of	of	IN
47658	843	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	843	18	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	843	19	with	with	IN
47658	843	20	reality	reality	NN
47658	843	21	;	;	:
47658	843	22	the	the	DT
47658	843	23	problem	problem	NN
47658	843	24	of	of	IN
47658	843	25	error	error	NN
47658	843	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	843	27	to	to	TO
47658	843	28	know	know	VB
47658	843	29	how	how	WRB
47658	843	30	there	there	EX
47658	843	31	can	can	MD
47658	843	32	be	be	VB
47658	843	33	false	false	JJ
47658	843	34	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	843	35	.	.	.
47658	844	1	There	there	EX
47658	844	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	844	3	false	false	JJ
47658	844	4	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	844	5	,	,	,
47658	844	6	of	of	IN
47658	844	7	this	this	DT
47658	844	8	no	no	DT
47658	844	9	one	one	NN
47658	844	10	needs	need	VBZ
47658	844	11	to	to	TO
47658	844	12	be	be	VB
47658	844	13	convinced	convince	VBN
47658	844	14	;	;	:
47658	844	15	but	but	CC
47658	844	16	where	where	WRB
47658	844	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	844	18	place	place	NN
47658	844	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	844	20	in	in	IN
47658	844	21	the	the	DT
47658	844	22	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	844	23	scheme	scheme	NN
47658	844	24	of	of	IN
47658	844	25	the	the	DT
47658	844	26	mental	mental	JJ
47658	844	27	process	process	NN
47658	844	28	,	,	,
47658	844	29	in	in	IN
47658	844	30	what	what	WP
47658	844	31	precisely	precisely	RB
47658	844	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	844	33	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	844	34	,	,	,
47658	844	35	whether	whether	IN
47658	844	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	844	37	is	be	VBZ
47658	844	38	purely	purely	RB
47658	844	39	a	a	DT
47658	844	40	negation	negation	NN
47658	844	41	or	or	CC
47658	844	42	whether	whether	IN
47658	844	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	844	44	has	have	VBZ
47658	844	45	a	a	DT
47658	844	46	positive	positive	JJ
47658	844	47	nature	nature	NN
47658	844	48	of	of	IN
47658	844	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	844	50	own	own	JJ
47658	844	51	,	,	,
47658	844	52	this	this	DT
47658	844	53	is	be	VBZ
47658	844	54	the	the	DT
47658	844	55	problem	problem	NN
47658	844	56	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	844	57	have	have	VBP
47658	844	58	now	now	RB
47658	844	59	to	to	TO
47658	844	60	consider	consider	VB
47658	844	61	.	.	.
47658	845	1	There	there	EX
47658	845	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	845	3	an	an	DT
47658	845	4	important	important	JJ
47658	845	5	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	845	6	in	in	IN
47658	845	7	logic	logic	NN
47658	845	8	between	between	IN
47658	845	9	what	what	WP
47658	845	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	845	11	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	845	12	and	and	CC
47658	845	13	what	what	WP
47658	845	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	845	15	contrary	contrary	JJ
47658	845	16	.	.	.
47658	846	1	Of	of	IN
47658	846	2	two	two	CD
47658	846	3	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	846	4	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	846	5	one	one	PRP
47658	846	6	must	must	MD
47658	846	7	be	be	VB
47658	846	8	true	true	JJ
47658	846	9	,	,	,
47658	846	10	the	the	DT
47658	846	11	other	other	JJ
47658	846	12	must	must	MD
47658	846	13	be	be	VB
47658	846	14	false	false	JJ
47658	846	15	;	;	:
47658	846	16	but	but	CC
47658	846	17	of	of	IN
47658	846	18	two	two	CD
47658	846	19	contrary	contrary	JJ
47658	846	20	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	846	21	one	one	PRP
47658	846	22	must	must	MD
47658	846	23	be	be	VB
47658	846	24	false	false	JJ
47658	846	25	,	,	,
47658	846	26	but	but	CC
47658	846	27	both	both	DT
47658	846	28	may	may	MD
47658	846	29	be	be	VB
47658	846	30	false	false	JJ
47658	846	31	.	.	.
47658	847	1	Of	of	IN
47658	847	2	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	847	3	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	847	4	one	one	CD
47658	847	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	847	6	always	always	RB
47658	847	7	a	a	DT
47658	847	8	pure	pure	JJ
47658	847	9	negation	negation	NN
47658	847	10	,	,	,
47658	847	11	one	one	NN
47658	847	12	declares	declare	VBZ
47658	847	13	the	the	DT
47658	847	14	non	non	NN
47658	847	15	-	-	NN
47658	847	16	existence	existence	NN
47658	847	17	of	of	IN
47658	847	18	what	what	WP
47658	847	19	the	the	DT
47658	847	20	other	other	JJ
47658	847	21	affirms	affirm	VBZ
47658	847	22	the	the	DT
47658	847	23	existence	existence	NN
47658	847	24	;	;	:
47658	847	25	but	but	CC
47658	847	26	of	of	IN
47658	847	27	contrary	contrary	JJ
47658	847	28	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	847	29	each	each	DT
47658	847	30	has	have	VBZ
47658	847	31	a	a	DT
47658	847	32	positive	positive	JJ
47658	847	33	content	content	NN
47658	847	34	,	,	,
47658	847	35	and	and	CC
47658	847	36	both	both	DT
47658	847	37	may	may	MD
47658	847	38	be	be	VB
47658	847	39	false	false	JJ
47658	847	40	.	.	.
47658	848	1	A	a	DT
47658	848	2	true	true	JJ
47658	848	3	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	848	4	may	may	MD
47658	848	5	be	be	VB
47658	848	6	based	base	VBN
47658	848	7	on	on	IN
47658	848	8	a	a	DT
47658	848	9	false	false	JJ
47658	848	10	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	848	11	,	,	,
47658	848	12	and	and	CC
47658	848	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	848	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	848	15	very	very	RB
47658	848	16	important	important	JJ
47658	848	17	to	to	TO
47658	848	18	have	have	VB
47658	848	19	a	a	DT
47658	848	20	clear	clear	JJ
47658	848	21	idea	idea	NN
47658	848	22	of	of	IN
47658	848	23	what	what	WP
47658	848	24	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	848	25	intend	intend	VBP
47658	848	26	by	by	IN
47658	848	27	false	false	JJ
47658	848	28	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	848	29	.	.	.
47658	849	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	849	2	do	do	VBP
47658	849	3	not	not	RB
47658	849	4	mean	mean	VB
47658	849	5	by	by	IN
47658	849	6	false	false	JJ
47658	849	7	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	849	8	such	such	JJ
47658	849	9	plainly	plainly	RB
47658	849	10	false	false	JJ
47658	849	11	{	{	-LRB-
47658	849	12	77	77	CD
47658	849	13	}	}	-RRB-
47658	849	14	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	849	15	as	as	IN
47658	849	16	that	that	DT
47658	849	17	two	two	CD
47658	849	18	and	and	CC
47658	849	19	two	two	CD
47658	849	20	are	be	VBP
47658	849	21	five	five	CD
47658	849	22	or	or	CC
47658	849	23	that	that	IN
47658	849	24	there	there	EX
47658	849	25	may	may	MD
47658	849	26	be	be	VB
47658	849	27	no	no	DT
47658	849	28	corners	corner	NNS
47658	849	29	in	in	IN
47658	849	30	a	a	DT
47658	849	31	square	square	JJ
47658	849	32	--	--	:
47658	849	33	such	such	JJ
47658	849	34	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	849	35	are	be	VBP
47658	849	36	false	false	JJ
47658	849	37	,	,	,
47658	849	38	because	because	IN
47658	849	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	849	40	contradict	contradict	VBP
47658	849	41	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	849	42	that	that	WDT
47658	849	43	are	be	VBP
47658	849	44	self	self	NN
47658	849	45	-	-	HYPH
47658	849	46	evident	evident	JJ
47658	849	47	.	.	.
47658	850	1	If	if	IN
47658	850	2	anyone	anyone	NN
47658	850	3	should	should	MD
47658	850	4	seriously	seriously	RB
47658	850	5	affirm	affirm	VB
47658	850	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	850	7	,	,	,
47658	850	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	850	9	should	should	MD
47658	850	10	not	not	RB
47658	850	11	,	,	,
47658	850	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	850	13	think	think	VBP
47658	850	14	,	,	,
47658	850	15	say	say	VBP
47658	850	16	that	that	IN
47658	850	17	such	such	PDT
47658	850	18	a	a	DT
47658	850	19	one	one	NN
47658	850	20	had	have	VBD
47658	850	21	a	a	DT
47658	850	22	false	false	JJ
47658	850	23	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	850	24	,	,	,
47658	850	25	but	but	CC
47658	850	26	that	that	IN
47658	850	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	850	28	failed	fail	VBD
47658	850	29	,	,	,
47658	850	30	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	850	31	through	through	IN
47658	850	32	some	some	DT
47658	850	33	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	850	34	,	,	,
47658	850	35	to	to	TO
47658	850	36	understand	understand	VB
47658	850	37	the	the	DT
47658	850	38	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	850	39	of	of	IN
47658	850	40	the	the	DT
47658	850	41	terms	term	NNS
47658	850	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	850	43	was	be	VBD
47658	850	44	using	use	VBG
47658	850	45	.	.	.
47658	851	1	An	an	DT
47658	851	2	example	example	NN
47658	851	3	of	of	IN
47658	851	4	what	what	WP
47658	851	5	would	would	MD
47658	851	6	now	now	RB
47658	851	7	,	,	,
47658	851	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	851	9	suppose	suppose	VBP
47658	851	10	,	,	,
47658	851	11	be	be	VB
47658	851	12	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
47658	851	13	regarded	regard	VBN
47658	851	14	by	by	IN
47658	851	15	everyone	everyone	NN
47658	851	16	as	as	IN
47658	851	17	error	error	NN
47658	851	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	851	19	that	that	DT
47658	851	20	whole	whole	JJ
47658	851	21	body	body	NN
47658	851	22	of	of	IN
47658	851	23	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	851	24	that	that	WDT
47658	851	25	found	find	VBD
47658	851	26	expression	expression	NN
47658	851	27	in	in	IN
47658	851	28	the	the	DT
47658	851	29	theory	theory	NN
47658	851	30	and	and	CC
47658	851	31	practice	practice	NN
47658	851	32	of	of	IN
47658	851	33	witchcraft	witchcraft	NN
47658	851	34	.	.	.
47658	852	1	This	this	DT
47658	852	2	was	be	VBD
47658	852	3	once	once	RB
47658	852	4	almost	almost	RB
47658	852	5	universally	universally	RB
47658	852	6	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	852	7	,	,	,
47658	852	8	and	and	CC
47658	852	9	though	though	IN
47658	852	10	probably	probably	RB
47658	852	11	at	at	IN
47658	852	12	no	no	DT
47658	852	13	period	period	NN
47658	852	14	nor	nor	CC
47658	852	15	in	in	IN
47658	852	16	any	any	DT
47658	852	17	country	country	NN
47658	852	18	was	be	VBD
47658	852	19	there	there	RB
47658	852	20	not	not	RB
47658	852	21	some	some	DT
47658	852	22	one	one	NN
47658	852	23	who	who	WP
47658	852	24	doubted	doubt	VBD
47658	852	25	or	or	CC
47658	852	26	disbelieved	disbelieve	VBN
47658	852	27	,	,	,
47658	852	28	still	still	RB
47658	852	29	the	the	DT
47658	852	30	reasons	reason	NNS
47658	852	31	of	of	IN
47658	852	32	such	such	JJ
47658	852	33	doubt	doubt	NN
47658	852	34	or	or	CC
47658	852	35	disbelief	disbelief	NN
47658	852	36	would	would	MD
47658	852	37	probably	probably	RB
47658	852	38	be	be	VB
47658	852	39	very	very	RB
47658	852	40	different	different	JJ
47658	852	41	from	from	IN
47658	852	42	those	those	DT
47658	852	43	reasons	reason	NNS
47658	852	44	which	which	WDT
47658	852	45	lead	lead	VBP
47658	852	46	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	852	47	to	to	TO
47658	852	48	reject	reject	VB
47658	852	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	852	50	to	to	IN
47658	852	51	-	-	HYPH
47658	852	52	day	day	NN
47658	852	53	.	.	.
47658	853	1	For	for	IN
47658	853	2	witchcraft	witchcraft	NN
47658	853	3	was	be	VBD
47658	853	4	grounded	ground	VBN
47658	853	5	on	on	IN
47658	853	6	a	a	DT
47658	853	7	general	general	JJ
47658	853	8	belief	belief	NN
47658	853	9	that	that	IN
47658	853	10	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
47658	853	11	agencies	agency	NNS
47658	853	12	,	,	,
47658	853	13	beneficent	beneficent	JJ
47658	853	14	and	and	CC
47658	853	15	malign	malign	NN
47658	853	16	,	,	,
47658	853	17	were	be	VBD
47658	853	18	the	the	DT
47658	853	19	cause	cause	NN
47658	853	20	of	of	IN
47658	853	21	material	material	NN
47658	853	22	well	well	NN
47658	853	23	-	-	HYPH
47658	853	24	being	being	NN
47658	853	25	or	or	CC
47658	853	26	evil	evil	NN
47658	853	27	.	.	.
47658	854	1	This	this	DT
47658	854	2	conception	conception	NN
47658	854	3	has	have	VBZ
47658	854	4	now	now	RB
47658	854	5	given	give	VBN
47658	854	6	place	place	NN
47658	854	7	to	to	IN
47658	854	8	the	the	DT
47658	854	9	mechanistic	mechanistic	JJ
47658	854	10	or	or	CC
47658	854	11	naturalistic	naturalistic	JJ
47658	854	12	theory	theory	NN
47658	854	13	on	on	IN
47658	854	14	which	which	WDT
47658	854	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	854	16	modern	modern	JJ
47658	854	17	physical	physical	JJ
47658	854	18	science	science	NN
47658	854	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	854	20	based	base	VBN
47658	854	21	.	.	.
47658	855	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	855	2	interpret	interpret	VBP
47658	855	3	all	all	DT
47658	855	4	physical	physical	JJ
47658	855	5	occurrences	occurrence	NNS
47658	855	6	as	as	IN
47658	855	7	caused	cause	VBN
47658	855	8	by	by	IN
47658	855	9	material	material	JJ
47658	855	10	agency	agency	NN
47658	855	11	.	.	.
47658	856	1	But	but	CC
47658	856	2	this	this	DT
47658	856	3	belief	belief	NN
47658	856	4	,	,	,
47658	856	5	quite	quite	RB
47658	856	6	as	as	RB
47658	856	7	much	much	RB
47658	856	8	as	as	IN
47658	856	9	the	the	DT
47658	856	10	belief	belief	NN
47658	856	11	in	in	IN
47658	856	12	spiritual	spiritual	JJ
47658	856	13	agencies	agency	NNS
47658	856	14	,	,	,
47658	856	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	856	16	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	856	17	,	,	,
47658	856	18	not	not	RB
47658	856	19	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	856	20	,	,	,
47658	856	21	and	and	CC
47658	856	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	856	23	may	may	MD
47658	856	24	be	be	VB
47658	856	25	false	false	JJ
47658	856	26	.	.	.
47658	857	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	857	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	857	3	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
47658	857	4	that	that	IN
47658	857	5	future	future	JJ
47658	857	6	generations	generation	NNS
47658	857	7	will	will	MD
47658	857	8	reject	reject	VB
47658	857	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	857	10	scientific	scientific	JJ
47658	857	11	notions	notion	NNS
47658	857	12	,	,	,
47658	857	13	self	self	NN
47658	857	14	-	-	HYPH
47658	857	15	evident	evident	JJ
47658	857	16	though	though	IN
47658	857	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	857	18	seem	seem	VBP
47658	857	19	to	to	IN
47658	857	20	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	857	21	,	,	,
47658	857	22	as	as	RB
47658	857	23	completely	completely	RB
47658	857	24	as	as	IN
47658	857	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	857	26	reject	reject	VBP
47658	857	27	the	the	DT
47658	857	28	notions	notion	NNS
47658	857	29	of	of	IN
47658	857	30	the	the	DT
47658	857	31	dark	dark	JJ
47658	857	32	ages	age	NNS
47658	857	33	.	.	.
47658	858	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	858	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	858	3	even	even	RB
47658	858	4	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
47658	858	5	that	that	IN
47658	858	6	the	the	DT
47658	858	7	whole	whole	NN
47658	858	8	of	of	IN
47658	858	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	858	10	modern	modern	JJ
47658	858	11	science	science	NN
47658	858	12	may	may	MD
47658	858	13	come	come	VB
47658	858	14	to	to	TO
47658	858	15	appear	appear	VB
47658	858	16	to	to	IN
47658	858	17	mankind	mankind	VB
47658	858	18	as	as	RB
47658	858	19	not	not	RB
47658	858	20	even	even	RB
47658	858	21	an	an	DT
47658	858	22	approximation	approximation	NN
47658	858	23	to	to	IN
47658	858	24	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	858	25	.	.	.
47658	859	1	Error	error	NN
47658	859	2	,	,	,
47658	859	3	like	like	IN
47658	859	4	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	859	5	,	,	,
47658	859	6	may	may	MD
47658	859	7	be	be	VB
47658	859	8	universal	universal	JJ
47658	859	9	.	.	.
47658	860	1	No	no	DT
47658	860	2	one	one	NN
47658	860	3	whose	whose	WP$
47658	860	4	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	860	5	counts	count	VBZ
47658	860	6	as	as	IN
47658	860	7	a	a	DT
47658	860	8	rational	rational	JJ
47658	860	9	belief	belief	NN
47658	860	10	now	now	RB
47658	860	11	holds	hold	VBZ
47658	860	12	that	that	IN
47658	860	13	sickness	sickness	NN
47658	860	14	may	may	MD
47658	860	15	be	be	VB
47658	860	16	caused	cause	VBN
47658	860	17	by	by	IN
47658	860	18	the	the	DT
47658	860	19	malign	malign	NN
47658	860	20	influence	influence	NN
47658	860	21	of	of	IN
47658	860	22	the	the	DT
47658	860	23	evil	evil	JJ
47658	860	24	eye	eye	NN
47658	860	25	,	,	,
47658	860	26	and	and	CC
47658	860	27	that	that	IN
47658	860	28	this	this	DT
47658	860	29	influence	influence	NN
47658	860	30	may	may	MD
47658	860	31	be	be	VB
47658	860	32	neutralised	neutralise	VBN
47658	860	33	by	by	IN
47658	860	34	making	make	VBG
47658	860	35	the	the	DT
47658	860	36	sign	sign	NN
47658	860	37	of	of	IN
47658	860	38	the	the	DT
47658	860	39	cross	cross	NN
47658	860	40	;	;	:
47658	860	41	some	some	DT
47658	860	42	,	,	,
47658	860	43	but	but	CC
47658	860	44	very	very	RB
47658	860	45	few	few	JJ
47658	860	46	,	,	,
47658	860	47	believe	believe	VBP
47658	860	48	that	that	IN
47658	860	49	a	a	DT
47658	860	50	{	{	-LRB-
47658	860	51	78	78	CD
47658	860	52	}	}	-RRB-
47658	860	53	sick	sick	JJ
47658	860	54	man	man	NN
47658	860	55	may	may	MD
47658	860	56	be	be	VB
47658	860	57	healed	heal	VBN
47658	860	58	by	by	IN
47658	860	59	the	the	DT
47658	860	60	prayers	prayer	NNS
47658	860	61	and	and	CC
47658	860	62	anointing	anointing	NN
47658	860	63	of	of	IN
47658	860	64	righteous	righteous	JJ
47658	860	65	men	man	NNS
47658	860	66	;	;	:
47658	860	67	many	many	JJ
47658	860	68	believe	believe	VBP
47658	860	69	that	that	IN
47658	860	70	material	material	NN
47658	860	71	disease	disease	NN
47658	860	72	,	,	,
47658	860	73	however	however	RB
47658	860	74	malignant	malignant	JJ
47658	860	75	,	,	,
47658	860	76	may	may	MD
47658	860	77	be	be	VB
47658	860	78	expelled	expel	VBN
47658	860	79	from	from	IN
47658	860	80	the	the	DT
47658	860	81	body	body	NN
47658	860	82	by	by	IN
47658	860	83	faith	faith	NN
47658	860	84	;	;	:
47658	860	85	while	while	IN
47658	860	86	the	the	DT
47658	860	87	majority	majority	NN
47658	860	88	of	of	IN
47658	860	89	rational	rational	JJ
47658	860	90	men	man	NNS
47658	860	91	,	,	,
47658	860	92	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	860	93	independent	independent	JJ
47658	860	94	religious	religious	JJ
47658	860	95	views	view	NNS
47658	860	96	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	860	97	hold	hold	VBP
47658	860	98	,	,	,
47658	860	99	regard	regard	VBP
47658	860	100	sickness	sickness	NN
47658	860	101	and	and	CC
47658	860	102	disease	disease	NN
47658	860	103	as	as	IN
47658	860	104	material	material	NN
47658	860	105	in	in	IN
47658	860	106	the	the	DT
47658	860	107	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	860	108	sense	sense	NN
47658	860	109	,	,	,
47658	860	110	and	and	CC
47658	860	111	expect	expect	VB
47658	860	112	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	860	113	to	to	TO
47658	860	114	yield	yield	VB
47658	860	115	to	to	IN
47658	860	116	drugs	drug	NNS
47658	860	117	and	and	CC
47658	860	118	treatment	treatment	NN
47658	860	119	.	.	.
47658	861	1	Now	now	RB
47658	861	2	,	,	,
47658	861	3	of	of	IN
47658	861	4	these	these	DT
47658	861	5	various	various	JJ
47658	861	6	opinions	opinion	NNS
47658	861	7	some	some	DT
47658	861	8	must	must	MD
47658	861	9	be	be	VB
47658	861	10	false	false	JJ
47658	861	11	,	,	,
47658	861	12	while	while	IN
47658	861	13	all	all	DT
47658	861	14	may	may	MD
47658	861	15	be	be	VB
47658	861	16	false	false	JJ
47658	861	17	.	.	.
47658	862	1	Let	let	VB
47658	862	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	862	3	add	add	VB
47658	862	4	some	some	DT
47658	862	5	illustrations	illustration	NNS
47658	862	6	from	from	IN
47658	862	7	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	862	8	.	.	.
47658	863	1	Some	some	DT
47658	863	2	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	863	3	hold	hold	VBP
47658	863	4	,	,	,
47658	863	5	in	in	IN
47658	863	6	common	common	JJ
47658	863	7	with	with	IN
47658	863	8	general	general	JJ
47658	863	9	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	863	10	,	,	,
47658	863	11	that	that	DT
47658	863	12	sense	sense	NN
47658	863	13	experience	experience	NN
47658	863	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	863	15	caused	cause	VBN
47658	863	16	by	by	IN
47658	863	17	physical	physical	JJ
47658	863	18	objects	object	NNS
47658	863	19	;	;	:
47658	863	20	others	other	NNS
47658	863	21	hold	hold	VBP
47658	863	22	that	that	IN
47658	863	23	there	there	EX
47658	863	24	are	be	VBP
47658	863	25	no	no	DT
47658	863	26	physical	physical	JJ
47658	863	27	objects	object	NNS
47658	863	28	,	,	,
47658	863	29	but	but	CC
47658	863	30	that	that	DT
47658	863	31	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	863	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	863	33	the	the	DT
47658	863	34	one	one	CD
47658	863	35	and	and	CC
47658	863	36	only	only	JJ
47658	863	37	reality	reality	NN
47658	863	38	;	;	:
47658	863	39	and	and	CC
47658	863	40	there	there	EX
47658	863	41	are	be	VBP
47658	863	42	others	other	NNS
47658	863	43	who	who	WP
47658	863	44	think	think	VBP
47658	863	45	that	that	IN
47658	863	46	the	the	DT
47658	863	47	reality	reality	NN
47658	863	48	that	that	WDT
47658	863	49	gives	give	VBZ
47658	863	50	rise	rise	NN
47658	863	51	to	to	IN
47658	863	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	863	53	sense	sense	NN
47658	863	54	experience	experience	NN
47658	863	55	is	be	VBZ
47658	863	56	neither	neither	CC
47658	863	57	physical	physical	JJ
47658	863	58	in	in	IN
47658	863	59	the	the	DT
47658	863	60	sense	sense	NN
47658	863	61	of	of	IN
47658	863	62	a	a	DT
47658	863	63	material	material	JJ
47658	863	64	thing	thing	NN
47658	863	65	,	,	,
47658	863	66	nor	nor	CC
47658	863	67	mental	mental	JJ
47658	863	68	in	in	IN
47658	863	69	the	the	DT
47658	863	70	sense	sense	NN
47658	863	71	of	of	IN
47658	863	72	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	863	73	or	or	CC
47658	863	74	thought	thought	NN
47658	863	75	,	,	,
47658	863	76	but	but	CC
47658	863	77	is	be	VBZ
47658	863	78	movement	movement	NN
47658	863	79	or	or	CC
47658	863	80	change	change	NN
47658	863	81	--	--	:
47658	863	82	change	change	NN
47658	863	83	that	that	WDT
47658	863	84	requires	require	VBZ
47658	863	85	no	no	DT
47658	863	86	support	support	NN
47658	863	87	and	and	CC
47658	863	88	is	be	VBZ
47658	863	89	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	863	90	.	.	.
47658	864	1	All	all	PDT
47658	864	2	these	these	DT
47658	864	3	are	be	VBP
47658	864	4	opinions	opinion	NNS
47658	864	5	,	,	,
47658	864	6	and	and	CC
47658	864	7	may	may	MD
47658	864	8	be	be	VB
47658	864	9	false	false	JJ
47658	864	10	,	,	,
47658	864	11	and	and	CC
47658	864	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	864	13	belief	belief	NN
47658	864	14	that	that	IN
47658	864	15	any	any	DT
47658	864	16	one	one	CD
47658	864	17	of	of	IN
47658	864	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	864	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	864	20	true	true	JJ
47658	864	21	does	do	VBZ
47658	864	22	not	not	RB
47658	864	23	depend	depend	VB
47658	864	24	on	on	IN
47658	864	25	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	864	26	experience	experience	NN
47658	864	27	,	,	,
47658	864	28	but	but	CC
47658	864	29	on	on	IN
47658	864	30	reasons	reason	NNS
47658	864	31	.	.	.
47658	865	1	The	the	DT
47658	865	2	best	good	JJS
47658	865	3	that	that	WDT
47658	865	4	can	can	MD
47658	865	5	be	be	VB
47658	865	6	said	say	VBN
47658	865	7	in	in	IN
47658	865	8	favour	favour	NN
47658	865	9	of	of	IN
47658	865	10	any	any	DT
47658	865	11	belief	belief	NN
47658	865	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	865	13	that	that	IN
47658	865	14	there	there	EX
47658	865	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	865	16	no	no	DT
47658	865	17	reason	reason	NN
47658	865	18	for	for	IN
47658	865	19	supposing	suppose	VBG
47658	865	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	865	21	false	false	JJ
47658	865	22	,	,	,
47658	865	23	and	and	CC
47658	865	24	the	the	DT
47658	865	25	worst	bad	JJS
47658	865	26	that	that	WDT
47658	865	27	can	can	MD
47658	865	28	be	be	VB
47658	865	29	said	say	VBN
47658	865	30	against	against	IN
47658	865	31	any	any	DT
47658	865	32	belief	belief	NN
47658	865	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	865	34	that	that	IN
47658	865	35	there	there	EX
47658	865	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	865	37	no	no	DT
47658	865	38	reason	reason	NN
47658	865	39	for	for	IN
47658	865	40	supposing	suppose	VBG
47658	865	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	865	42	true	true	JJ
47658	865	43	.	.	.
47658	866	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	866	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	866	3	,	,	,
47658	866	4	then	then	RB
47658	866	5	,	,	,
47658	866	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	866	7	to	to	TO
47658	866	8	know	know	VB
47658	866	9	what	what	WP
47658	866	10	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
47658	866	11	the	the	DT
47658	866	12	nature	nature	NN
47658	866	13	of	of	IN
47658	866	14	error	error	NN
47658	866	15	in	in	IN
47658	866	16	any	any	DT
47658	866	17	one	one	CD
47658	866	18	of	of	IN
47658	866	19	these	these	DT
47658	866	20	examples	example	NNS
47658	866	21	if	if	IN
47658	866	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	866	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	866	24	,	,	,
47658	866	25	as	as	IN
47658	866	26	each	each	DT
47658	866	27	one	one	NN
47658	866	28	may	may	MD
47658	866	29	be	be	VB
47658	866	30	,	,	,
47658	866	31	false	false	JJ
47658	866	32	?	?	.
47658	867	1	The	the	DT
47658	867	2	instances	instance	NNS
47658	867	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	867	4	have	have	VBP
47658	867	5	given	give	VBN
47658	867	6	are	be	VBP
47658	867	7	all	all	DT
47658	867	8	of	of	IN
47658	867	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	867	10	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	867	11	or	or	CC
47658	867	12	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	867	13	,	,	,
47658	867	14	or	or	CC
47658	867	15	else	else	RB
47658	867	16	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	867	17	formed	form	VBN
47658	867	18	out	out	IN
47658	867	19	of	of	IN
47658	867	20	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	867	21	or	or	CC
47658	867	22	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	867	23	,	,	,
47658	867	24	the	the	DT
47658	867	25	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	867	26	of	of	IN
47658	867	27	which	which	WDT
47658	867	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	867	29	to	to	TO
47658	867	30	interpret	interpret	VB
47658	867	31	experience	experience	NN
47658	867	32	.	.	.
47658	868	1	The	the	DT
47658	868	2	actual	actual	JJ
47658	868	3	experience	experience	NN
47658	868	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	868	5	,	,	,
47658	868	6	in	in	IN
47658	868	7	so	so	RB
47658	868	8	far	far	RB
47658	868	9	as	as	IN
47658	868	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	868	11	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	868	12	of	of	IN
47658	868	13	the	the	DT
47658	868	14	actual	actual	JJ
47658	868	15	presence	presence	NN
47658	868	16	of	of	IN
47658	868	17	the	the	DT
47658	868	18	object	object	NN
47658	868	19	to	to	IN
47658	868	20	the	the	DT
47658	868	21	mind	mind	NN
47658	868	22	aware	aware	JJ
47658	868	23	of	of	IN
47658	868	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	868	25	,	,	,
47658	868	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	868	27	,	,	,
47658	868	28	as	as	IN
47658	868	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	868	30	have	have	VBP
47658	868	31	seen	see	VBN
47658	868	32	,	,	,
47658	868	33	neither	neither	CC
47658	868	34	truth	truth	NN
47658	868	35	nor	nor	CC
47658	868	36	error	error	NN
47658	868	37	;	;	:
47658	868	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	868	39	simply	simply	RB
47658	868	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	868	41	what	what	WP
47658	868	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	868	43	is	be	VBZ
47658	868	44	.	.	.
47658	869	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	869	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	869	3	the	the	DT
47658	869	4	conceptions	conception	NNS
47658	869	5	by	by	IN
47658	869	6	which	which	WDT
47658	869	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	869	8	interpret	interpret	VBP
47658	869	9	this	this	DT
47658	869	10	experience	experience	NN
47658	869	11	that	that	WDT
47658	869	12	are	be	VBP
47658	869	13	{	{	-LRB-
47658	869	14	79	79	CD
47658	869	15	}	}	-RRB-
47658	869	16	true	true	JJ
47658	869	17	or	or	CC
47658	869	18	false	false	JJ
47658	869	19	.	.	.
47658	870	1	And	and	CC
47658	870	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	870	3	problem	problem	NN
47658	870	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	870	5	that	that	IN
47658	870	6	the	the	DT
47658	870	7	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	870	8	or	or	CC
47658	870	9	content	content	NN
47658	870	10	of	of	IN
47658	870	11	a	a	DT
47658	870	12	conception	conception	NN
47658	870	13	,	,	,
47658	870	14	that	that	IN
47658	870	15	which	which	WDT
47658	870	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	870	17	present	present	JJ
47658	870	18	to	to	IN
47658	870	19	the	the	DT
47658	870	20	mind	mind	NN
47658	870	21	when	when	WRB
47658	870	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	870	23	make	make	VBP
47658	870	24	a	a	DT
47658	870	25	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	870	26	,	,	,
47658	870	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	870	28	precisely	precisely	RB
47658	870	29	the	the	DT
47658	870	30	same	same	JJ
47658	870	31	whether	whether	IN
47658	870	32	the	the	DT
47658	870	33	conception	conception	NN
47658	870	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	870	35	true	true	JJ
47658	870	36	or	or	CC
47658	870	37	false	false	JJ
47658	870	38	,	,	,
47658	870	39	there	there	EX
47658	870	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	870	41	no	no	DT
47658	870	42	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
47658	870	43	mark	mark	NN
47658	870	44	or	or	CC
47658	870	45	feature	feature	NN
47658	870	46	by	by	IN
47658	870	47	which	which	WDT
47658	870	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	870	49	can	can	MD
47658	870	50	know	know	VB
47658	870	51	that	that	IN
47658	870	52	in	in	IN
47658	870	53	the	the	DT
47658	870	54	one	one	CD
47658	870	55	case	case	NN
47658	870	56	the	the	DT
47658	870	57	object	object	NN
47658	870	58	of	of	IN
47658	870	59	thought	thought	NN
47658	870	60	is	be	VBZ
47658	870	61	a	a	DT
47658	870	62	real	real	JJ
47658	870	63	or	or	CC
47658	870	64	actual	actual	JJ
47658	870	65	fact	fact	NN
47658	870	66	,	,	,
47658	870	67	in	in	IN
47658	870	68	the	the	DT
47658	870	69	other	other	JJ
47658	870	70	an	an	DT
47658	870	71	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	870	72	to	to	TO
47658	870	73	which	which	WDT
47658	870	74	no	no	DT
47658	870	75	reality	reality	NN
47658	870	76	corresponds	correspond	NNS
47658	870	77	.	.	.
47658	871	1	And	and	CC
47658	871	2	,	,	,
47658	871	3	further	further	RB
47658	871	4	,	,	,
47658	871	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	871	6	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	871	7	exceedingly	exceedingly	RB
47658	871	8	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	871	9	to	to	TO
47658	871	10	understand	understand	VB
47658	871	11	in	in	IN
47658	871	12	what	what	WDT
47658	871	13	way	way	NN
47658	871	14	a	a	DT
47658	871	15	non	non	JJ
47658	871	16	-	-	JJ
47658	871	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	871	18	can	can	MD
47658	871	19	be	be	VB
47658	871	20	present	present	JJ
47658	871	21	to	to	IN
47658	871	22	the	the	DT
47658	871	23	mind	mind	NN
47658	871	24	at	at	RB
47658	871	25	all	all	RB
47658	871	26	.	.	.
47658	872	1	Let	let	VB
47658	872	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	872	3	now	now	RB
47658	872	4	examine	examine	VB
47658	872	5	some	some	DT
47658	872	6	attempts	attempt	NNS
47658	872	7	to	to	TO
47658	872	8	solve	solve	VB
47658	872	9	this	this	DT
47658	872	10	problem	problem	NN
47658	872	11	,	,	,
47658	872	12	and	and	CC
47658	872	13	first	first	RB
47658	872	14	of	of	IN
47658	872	15	all	all	DT
47658	872	16	let	let	VB
47658	872	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	872	18	take	take	VB
47658	872	19	the	the	DT
47658	872	20	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	872	21	solution	solution	NN
47658	872	22	.	.	.
47658	873	1	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	873	2	claims	claim	VBZ
47658	873	3	that	that	IN
47658	873	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	873	5	has	have	VBZ
47658	873	6	no	no	DT
47658	873	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	873	8	in	in	IN
47658	873	9	explaining	explain	VBG
47658	873	10	error	error	NN
47658	873	11	,	,	,
47658	873	12	because	because	IN
47658	873	13	,	,	,
47658	873	14	as	as	IN
47658	873	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	873	16	have	have	VBP
47658	873	17	already	already	RB
47658	873	18	seen	see	VBN
47658	873	19	,	,	,
47658	873	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	873	21	acknowledges	acknowledge	VBZ
47658	873	22	no	no	DT
47658	873	23	other	other	JJ
47658	873	24	test	test	NN
47658	873	25	or	or	CC
47658	873	26	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	873	27	of	of	IN
47658	873	28	truth	truth	NN
47658	873	29	except	except	IN
47658	873	30	a	a	DT
47658	873	31	pragmatic	pragmatic	JJ
47658	873	32	one	one	NN
47658	873	33	.	.	.
47658	874	1	Every	every	DT
47658	874	2	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	874	3	or	or	CC
47658	874	4	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	874	5	that	that	WDT
47658	874	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	874	7	make	make	VBP
47658	874	8	must	must	MD
47658	874	9	,	,	,
47658	874	10	in	in	IN
47658	874	11	order	order	NN
47658	874	12	to	to	TO
47658	874	13	have	have	VB
47658	874	14	any	any	DT
47658	874	15	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	874	16	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	874	17	,	,	,
47658	874	18	be	be	VB
47658	874	19	relevant	relevant	JJ
47658	874	20	to	to	IN
47658	874	21	some	some	DT
47658	874	22	human	human	JJ
47658	874	23	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	874	24	;	;	:
47658	874	25	every	every	DT
47658	874	26	such	such	JJ
47658	874	27	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	874	28	is	be	VBZ
47658	874	29	a	a	DT
47658	874	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	874	31	-	-	HYPH
47658	874	32	claim	claim	NN
47658	874	33	;	;	:
47658	874	34	and	and	CC
47658	874	35	every	every	DT
47658	874	36	truth	truth	NN
47658	874	37	-	-	HYPH
47658	874	38	claim	claim	NN
47658	874	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	874	40	tested	test	VBN
47658	874	41	by	by	IN
47658	874	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	874	43	workability	workability	NN
47658	874	44	.	.	.
47658	875	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
47658	875	2	,	,	,
47658	875	3	error	error	NN
47658	875	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	875	5	simply	simply	RB
47658	875	6	the	the	DT
47658	875	7	failure	failure	NN
47658	875	8	of	of	IN
47658	875	9	a	a	DT
47658	875	10	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	875	11	to	to	TO
47658	875	12	establish	establish	VB
47658	875	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	875	14	claim	claim	NN
47658	875	15	by	by	IN
47658	875	16	the	the	DT
47658	875	17	practical	practical	JJ
47658	875	18	test	test	NN
47658	875	19	of	of	IN
47658	875	20	working	work	VBG
47658	875	21	.	.	.
47658	876	1	Propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	876	2	marked	mark	VBN
47658	876	3	by	by	IN
47658	876	4	such	such	JJ
47658	876	5	failure	failure	NN
47658	876	6	are	be	VBP
47658	876	7	errors	error	NNS
47658	876	8	.	.	.
47658	877	1	As	as	IN
47658	877	2	there	there	EX
47658	877	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	877	4	no	no	DT
47658	877	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	877	6	independent	independent	JJ
47658	877	7	of	of	IN
47658	877	8	time	time	NN
47658	877	9	,	,	,
47658	877	10	place	place	NN
47658	877	11	,	,	,
47658	877	12	and	and	CC
47658	877	13	circumstance	circumstance	NN
47658	877	14	,	,	,
47658	877	15	no	no	DT
47658	877	16	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
47658	877	17	truth	truth	NN
47658	877	18	,	,	,
47658	877	19	no	no	DT
47658	877	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	877	21	independent	independent	JJ
47658	877	22	of	of	IN
47658	877	23	the	the	DT
47658	877	24	conditions	condition	NNS
47658	877	25	under	under	IN
47658	877	26	which	which	WDT
47658	877	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	877	28	claim	claim	NN
47658	877	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	877	30	put	put	VBN
47658	877	31	forward	forward	RB
47658	877	32	,	,	,
47658	877	33	there	there	EX
47658	877	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	877	35	no	no	DT
47658	877	36	truth	truth	NN
47658	877	37	that	that	WDT
47658	877	38	may	may	MD
47658	877	39	not	not	RB
47658	877	40	become	become	VB
47658	877	41	error	error	NN
47658	877	42	.	.	.
47658	878	1	No	no	DT
47658	878	2	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	878	3	,	,	,
47658	878	4	according	accord	VBG
47658	878	5	to	to	IN
47658	878	6	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	878	7	,	,	,
47658	878	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	878	9	an	an	DT
47658	878	10	error	error	NN
47658	878	11	pure	pure	JJ
47658	878	12	and	and	CC
47658	878	13	simple	simple	JJ
47658	878	14	--	--	:
47658	878	15	that	that	DT
47658	878	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	878	17	to	to	TO
47658	878	18	say	say	VB
47658	878	19	,	,	,
47658	878	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	878	21	can	can	MD
47658	878	22	not	not	RB
47658	878	23	come	come	VB
47658	878	24	into	into	IN
47658	878	25	existence	existence	NN
47658	878	26	as	as	IN
47658	878	27	error	error	NN
47658	878	28	,	,	,
47658	878	29	for	for	IN
47658	878	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	878	31	comes	come	VBZ
47658	878	32	claiming	claim	VBG
47658	878	33	truth	truth	NN
47658	878	34	,	,	,
47658	878	35	and	and	CC
47658	878	36	maintaining	maintain	VBG
47658	878	37	that	that	DT
47658	878	38	claim	claim	NN
47658	878	39	until	until	IN
47658	878	40	challenged	challenge	VBN
47658	878	41	;	;	:
47658	878	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	878	43	becomes	become	VBZ
47658	878	44	an	an	DT
47658	878	45	error	error	NN
47658	878	46	in	in	IN
47658	878	47	retrospect	retrospect	NN
47658	878	48	only	only	RB
47658	878	49	,	,	,
47658	878	50	and	and	CC
47658	878	51	always	always	RB
47658	878	52	in	in	IN
47658	878	53	relation	relation	NN
47658	878	54	to	to	IN
47658	878	55	another	another	DT
47658	878	56	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	878	57	which	which	WDT
47658	878	58	corrects	correct	VBZ
47658	878	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	878	60	.	.	.
47658	879	1	Error	error	NN
47658	879	2	does	do	VBZ
47658	879	3	not	not	RB
47658	879	4	characterise	characterise	VB
47658	879	5	a	a	DT
47658	879	6	class	class	NN
47658	879	7	of	of	IN
47658	879	8	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	879	9	;	;	:
47658	879	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	879	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	879	12	something	something	NN
47658	879	13	that	that	WDT
47658	879	14	happens	happen	VBZ
47658	879	15	to	to	IN
47658	879	16	a	a	DT
47658	879	17	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	879	18	,	,	,
47658	879	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	879	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	879	21	a	a	DT
47658	879	22	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	879	23	whose	whose	WP$
47658	879	24	truth	truth	NN
47658	879	25	-	-	HYPH
47658	879	26	claim	claim	NN
47658	879	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	879	28	rejected	reject	VBN
47658	879	29	in	in	IN
47658	879	30	reference	reference	NN
47658	879	31	to	to	IN
47658	879	32	another	another	DT
47658	879	33	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	879	34	{	{	-LRB-
47658	879	35	80	80	CD
47658	879	36	}	}	-RRB-
47658	879	37	which	which	WDT
47658	879	38	succeeds	succeed	VBZ
47658	879	39	.	.	.
47658	880	1	The	the	DT
47658	880	2	essential	essential	JJ
47658	880	3	thing	thing	NN
47658	880	4	in	in	IN
47658	880	5	the	the	DT
47658	880	6	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	880	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	880	8	of	of	IN
47658	880	9	error	error	NN
47658	880	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	880	11	that	that	IN
47658	880	12	in	in	IN
47658	880	13	claiming	claim	VBG
47658	880	14	to	to	TO
47658	880	15	be	be	VB
47658	880	16	true	true	JJ
47658	880	17	a	a	DT
47658	880	18	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	880	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	880	20	not	not	RB
47658	880	21	challenging	challenge	VBG
47658	880	22	comparison	comparison	NN
47658	880	23	with	with	IN
47658	880	24	some	some	DT
47658	880	25	independent	independent	JJ
47658	880	26	reality	reality	NN
47658	880	27	,	,	,
47658	880	28	nor	nor	CC
47658	880	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	880	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	880	31	claiming	claim	VBG
47658	880	32	to	to	TO
47658	880	33	belong	belong	VB
47658	880	34	to	to	IN
47658	880	35	a	a	DT
47658	880	36	timeless	timeless	NN
47658	880	37	order	order	NN
47658	880	38	of	of	IN
47658	880	39	existence	existence	NN
47658	880	40	--	--	:
47658	880	41	to	to	TO
47658	880	42	be	be	VB
47658	880	43	eternal	eternal	JJ
47658	880	44	;	;	:
47658	880	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	880	46	is	be	VBZ
47658	880	47	claiming	claim	VBG
47658	880	48	to	to	TO
47658	880	49	fulfil	fulfil	VB
47658	880	50	the	the	DT
47658	880	51	particular	particular	JJ
47658	880	52	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	880	53	for	for	IN
47658	880	54	which	which	WDT
47658	880	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	880	56	has	have	VBZ
47658	880	57	been	be	VBN
47658	880	58	called	call	VBN
47658	880	59	forth	forth	RB
47658	880	60	,	,	,
47658	880	61	whether	whether	IN
47658	880	62	that	that	DT
47658	880	63	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	880	64	be	be	VB
47658	880	65	practical	practical	JJ
47658	880	66	or	or	CC
47658	880	67	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
47658	880	68	.	.	.
47658	881	1	Let	let	VB
47658	881	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	881	3	now	now	RB
47658	881	4	consider	consider	VB
47658	881	5	the	the	DT
47658	881	6	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	881	7	of	of	IN
47658	881	8	error	error	NN
47658	881	9	offered	offer	VBN
47658	881	10	by	by	IN
47658	881	11	the	the	DT
47658	881	12	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	881	13	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	881	14	.	.	.
47658	882	1	In	in	IN
47658	882	2	this	this	DT
47658	882	3	view	view	NN
47658	882	4	only	only	RB
47658	882	5	the	the	DT
47658	882	6	whole	whole	JJ
47658	882	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	882	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	882	9	wholly	wholly	RB
47658	882	10	true	true	JJ
47658	882	11	;	;	:
47658	882	12	the	the	DT
47658	882	13	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	882	14	,	,	,
47658	882	15	as	as	IN
47658	882	16	a	a	DT
47658	882	17	perfect	perfect	JJ
47658	882	18	,	,	,
47658	882	19	concrete	concrete	JJ
47658	882	20	,	,	,
47658	882	21	individual	individual	JJ
47658	882	22	system	system	NN
47658	882	23	,	,	,
47658	882	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	882	25	the	the	DT
47658	882	26	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	882	27	,	,	,
47658	882	28	and	and	CC
47658	882	29	all	all	DT
47658	882	30	that	that	WDT
47658	882	31	falls	fall	VBZ
47658	882	32	short	short	JJ
47658	882	33	of	of	IN
47658	882	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	882	35	can	can	MD
47658	882	36	only	only	RB
47658	882	37	possess	possess	VB
47658	882	38	a	a	DT
47658	882	39	degree	degree	NN
47658	882	40	of	of	IN
47658	882	41	truth	truth	NN
47658	882	42	--	--	:
47658	882	43	a	a	DT
47658	882	44	degree	degree	NN
47658	882	45	which	which	WDT
47658	882	46	is	be	VBZ
47658	882	47	greater	great	JJR
47658	882	48	or	or	CC
47658	882	49	less	less	RBR
47658	882	50	according	accord	VBG
47658	882	51	as	as	IN
47658	882	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	882	53	approximates	approximate	VBZ
47658	882	54	to	to	IN
47658	882	55	the	the	DT
47658	882	56	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	882	57	.	.	.
47658	883	1	The	the	DT
47658	883	2	degrees	degree	NNS
47658	883	3	of	of	IN
47658	883	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	883	5	are	be	VBP
47658	883	6	not	not	RB
47658	883	7	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
47658	883	8	,	,	,
47658	883	9	not	not	RB
47658	883	10	a	a	DT
47658	883	11	mixture	mixture	NN
47658	883	12	of	of	IN
47658	883	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	883	14	and	and	CC
47658	883	15	error	error	NN
47658	883	16	,	,	,
47658	883	17	but	but	CC
47658	883	18	a	a	DT
47658	883	19	nearer	near	JJR
47658	883	20	or	or	CC
47658	883	21	more	more	RBR
47658	883	22	distant	distant	JJ
47658	883	23	approach	approach	NN
47658	883	24	to	to	IN
47658	883	25	the	the	DT
47658	883	26	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	883	27	.	.	.
47658	884	1	There	there	EX
47658	884	2	can	can	MD
47658	884	3	be	be	VB
47658	884	4	no	no	DT
47658	884	5	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	884	6	error	error	NN
47658	884	7	,	,	,
47658	884	8	because	because	IN
47658	884	9	if	if	IN
47658	884	10	truth	truth	NN
47658	884	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	884	12	the	the	DT
47658	884	13	whole	whole	JJ
47658	884	14	,	,	,
47658	884	15	error	error	NN
47658	884	16	,	,	,
47658	884	17	if	if	IN
47658	884	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	884	19	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	884	20	at	at	RB
47658	884	21	all	all	RB
47658	884	22	,	,	,
47658	884	23	must	must	MD
47658	884	24	in	in	IN
47658	884	25	some	some	DT
47658	884	26	way	way	NN
47658	884	27	be	be	VB
47658	884	28	included	include	VBN
47658	884	29	in	in	IN
47658	884	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	884	31	.	.	.
47658	885	1	Clearly	clearly	RB
47658	885	2	error	error	NN
47658	885	3	can	can	MD
47658	885	4	not	not	RB
47658	885	5	as	as	RB
47658	885	6	such	such	JJ
47658	885	7	be	be	VB
47658	885	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	885	9	,	,	,
47658	885	10	and	and	CC
47658	885	11	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	885	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	885	13	must	must	MD
47658	885	14	follow	follow	VB
47658	885	15	that	that	IN
47658	885	16	,	,	,
47658	885	17	in	in	IN
47658	885	18	the	the	DT
47658	885	19	whole	whole	NN
47658	885	20	,	,	,
47658	885	21	error	error	NN
47658	885	22	loses	lose	VBZ
47658	885	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	885	24	character	character	NN
47658	885	25	of	of	IN
47658	885	26	error	error	NN
47658	885	27	,	,	,
47658	885	28	and	and	CC
47658	885	29	finds	find	VBZ
47658	885	30	reconciliation	reconciliation	NN
47658	885	31	of	of	IN
47658	885	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	885	33	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	885	34	to	to	IN
47658	885	35	truth	truth	NN
47658	885	36	.	.	.
47658	886	1	Error	error	NN
47658	886	2	,	,	,
47658	886	3	then	then	RB
47658	886	4	,	,	,
47658	886	5	if	if	IN
47658	886	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	886	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	886	8	something	something	NN
47658	886	9	,	,	,
47658	886	10	and	and	CC
47658	886	11	not	not	RB
47658	886	12	a	a	DT
47658	886	13	pure	pure	JJ
47658	886	14	negation	negation	NN
47658	886	15	,	,	,
47658	886	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	886	17	partial	partial	JJ
47658	886	18	or	or	CC
47658	886	19	incomplete	incomplete	JJ
47658	886	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	886	21	;	;	:
47658	886	22	the	the	DT
47658	886	23	perplexity	perplexity	NN
47658	886	24	and	and	CC
47658	886	25	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	886	26	that	that	WDT
47658	886	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	886	28	gives	give	VBZ
47658	886	29	rise	rise	NN
47658	886	30	to	to	TO
47658	886	31	are	be	VBP
47658	886	32	incidental	incidental	JJ
47658	886	33	to	to	IN
47658	886	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	886	35	partial	partial	JJ
47658	886	36	view	view	NN
47658	886	37	.	.	.
47658	887	1	Knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	887	2	,	,	,
47658	887	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	887	4	must	must	MD
47658	887	5	seem	seem	VB
47658	887	6	to	to	IN
47658	887	7	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	887	8	,	,	,
47658	887	9	can	can	MD
47658	887	10	exist	exist	VB
47658	887	11	only	only	RB
47658	887	12	for	for	IN
47658	887	13	omniscience	omniscience	NN
47658	887	14	.	.	.
47658	888	1	Unless	unless	IN
47658	888	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	888	3	know	know	VBP
47658	888	4	everything	everything	NN
47658	888	5	,	,	,
47658	888	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	888	7	know	know	VBP
47658	888	8	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	888	9	.	.	.
47658	889	1	These	these	DT
47658	889	2	two	two	CD
47658	889	3	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
47658	889	4	are	be	VBP
47658	889	5	in	in	IN
47658	889	6	a	a	DT
47658	889	7	sense	sense	NN
47658	889	8	the	the	DT
47658	889	9	exact	exact	JJ
47658	889	10	antithesis	antithesis	NN
47658	889	11	of	of	IN
47658	889	12	one	one	CD
47658	889	13	another	another	DT
47658	889	14	.	.	.
47658	890	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
47658	890	2	agree	agree	VBP
47658	890	3	together	together	RB
47658	890	4	in	in	IN
47658	890	5	this	this	DT
47658	890	6	,	,	,
47658	890	7	that	that	IN
47658	890	8	in	in	IN
47658	890	9	each	each	DT
47658	890	10	the	the	DT
47658	890	11	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	890	12	of	of	IN
47658	890	13	error	error	NN
47658	890	14	follows	follow	VBZ
47658	890	15	as	as	IN
47658	890	16	a	a	DT
47658	890	17	consequence	consequence	NN
47658	890	18	of	of	IN
47658	890	19	the	the	DT
47658	890	20	conception	conception	NN
47658	890	21	of	of	IN
47658	890	22	the	the	DT
47658	890	23	nature	nature	NN
47658	890	24	of	of	IN
47658	890	25	truth	truth	NN
47658	890	26	.	.	.
47658	891	1	The	the	DT
47658	891	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
47658	891	3	theory	theory	NN
47658	891	4	implies	imply	VBZ
47658	891	5	that	that	IN
47658	891	6	there	there	EX
47658	891	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	891	8	no	no	DT
47658	891	9	truth	truth	NN
47658	891	10	in	in	IN
47658	891	11	any	any	DT
47658	891	12	real	real	JJ
47658	891	13	sense	sense	NN
47658	891	14	,	,	,
47658	891	15	but	but	CC
47658	891	16	only	only	RB
47658	891	17	more	more	RBR
47658	891	18	or	or	CC
47658	891	19	less	less	RBR
47658	891	20	successful	successful	JJ
47658	891	21	error	error	NN
47658	891	22	.	.	.
47658	892	1	The	the	DT
47658	892	2	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	892	3	theory	theory	NN
47658	892	4	implies	imply	VBZ
47658	892	5	that	that	IN
47658	892	6	there	there	EX
47658	892	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	892	8	no	no	DT
47658	892	9	real	real	JJ
47658	892	10	error	error	NN
47658	892	11	,	,	,
47658	892	12	but	but	CC
47658	892	13	only	only	RB
47658	892	14	a	a	DT
47658	892	15	variety	variety	NN
47658	892	16	in	in	IN
47658	892	17	the	the	DT
47658	892	18	degree	degree	NN
47658	892	19	of	of	IN
47658	892	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	892	21	.	.	.
47658	893	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	893	2	81	81	CD
47658	893	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	893	4	Most	Most	JJS
47658	893	5	people	people	NNS
47658	893	6	,	,	,
47658	893	7	however	however	RB
47658	893	8	,	,	,
47658	893	9	are	be	VBP
47658	893	10	convinced	convince	VBN
47658	893	11	that	that	IN
47658	893	12	truth	truth	NN
47658	893	13	and	and	CC
47658	893	14	error	error	NN
47658	893	15	are	be	VBP
47658	893	16	not	not	RB
47658	893	17	related	relate	VBN
47658	893	18	to	to	IN
47658	893	19	one	one	CD
47658	893	20	another	another	DT
47658	893	21	,	,	,
47658	893	22	nor	nor	CC
47658	893	23	to	to	IN
47658	893	24	the	the	DT
47658	893	25	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
47658	893	26	that	that	WDT
47658	893	27	call	call	VBP
47658	893	28	forth	forth	RP
47658	893	29	belief	belief	NN
47658	893	30	or	or	CC
47658	893	31	disbelief	disbelief	NN
47658	893	32	.	.	.
47658	894	1	Let	let	VB
47658	894	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	894	3	now	now	RB
47658	894	4	examine	examine	VB
47658	894	5	a	a	DT
47658	894	6	theory	theory	NN
47658	894	7	that	that	WDT
47658	894	8	recognises	recognise	VBZ
47658	894	9	this	this	DT
47658	894	10	.	.	.
47658	895	1	There	there	EX
47658	895	2	are	be	VBP
47658	895	3	false	false	JJ
47658	895	4	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	895	5	,	,	,
47658	895	6	and	and	CC
47658	895	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	895	8	need	need	VBP
47658	895	9	explanation	explanation	NN
47658	895	10	;	;	:
47658	895	11	error	error	NN
47658	895	12	has	have	VBZ
47658	895	13	a	a	DT
47658	895	14	nature	nature	NN
47658	895	15	of	of	IN
47658	895	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	895	17	own	own	JJ
47658	895	18	.	.	.
47658	896	1	If	if	IN
47658	896	2	a	a	DT
47658	896	3	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	896	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	896	5	false	false	JJ
47658	896	6	,	,	,
47658	896	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	896	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	896	9	absolutely	absolutely	RB
47658	896	10	and	and	CC
47658	896	11	unalterably	unalterably	RB
47658	896	12	false	false	JJ
47658	896	13	;	;	:
47658	896	14	if	if	IN
47658	896	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	896	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	896	17	true	true	JJ
47658	896	18	,	,	,
47658	896	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	896	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	896	21	unconditionally	unconditionally	RB
47658	896	22	true	true	JJ
47658	896	23	and	and	CC
47658	896	24	with	with	IN
47658	896	25	no	no	DT
47658	896	26	reserve	reserve	NN
47658	896	27	.	.	.
47658	897	1	No	no	DT
47658	897	2	logical	logical	JJ
47658	897	3	process	process	NN
47658	897	4	,	,	,
47658	897	5	no	no	DT
47658	897	6	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	897	7	disposition	disposition	NN
47658	897	8	,	,	,
47658	897	9	can	can	MD
47658	897	10	make	make	VB
47658	897	11	what	what	WP
47658	897	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	897	13	false	false	JJ
47658	897	14	true	true	JJ
47658	897	15	.	.	.
47658	898	1	Error	error	NN
47658	898	2	must	must	MD
47658	898	3	lie	lie	VB
47658	898	4	in	in	IN
47658	898	5	the	the	DT
47658	898	6	nature	nature	NN
47658	898	7	of	of	IN
47658	898	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	898	9	,	,	,
47658	898	10	and	and	CC
47658	898	11	to	to	TO
47658	898	12	discover	discover	VB
47658	898	13	that	that	IN
47658	898	14	nature	nature	NN
47658	898	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	898	16	must	must	MD
47658	898	17	understand	understand	VB
47658	898	18	the	the	DT
47658	898	19	theory	theory	NN
47658	898	20	of	of	IN
47658	898	21	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	898	22	and	and	CC
47658	898	23	determine	determine	VB
47658	898	24	the	the	DT
47658	898	25	exact	exact	JJ
47658	898	26	nature	nature	NN
47658	898	27	of	of	IN
47658	898	28	the	the	DT
47658	898	29	mental	mental	JJ
47658	898	30	act	act	NN
47658	898	31	in	in	IN
47658	898	32	knowing	know	VBG
47658	898	33	.	.	.
47658	899	1	The	the	DT
47658	899	2	first	first	JJ
47658	899	3	essential	essential	NN
47658	899	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	899	5	to	to	TO
47658	899	6	distinguish	distinguish	VB
47658	899	7	the	the	DT
47658	899	8	kind	kind	NN
47658	899	9	of	of	IN
47658	899	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	899	11	to	to	TO
47658	899	12	which	which	WDT
47658	899	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	899	14	and	and	CC
47658	899	15	error	error	NN
47658	899	16	can	can	MD
47658	899	17	apply	apply	VB
47658	899	18	.	.	.
47658	900	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	900	2	pointed	point	VBD
47658	900	3	out	out	RP
47658	900	4	in	in	IN
47658	900	5	the	the	DT
47658	900	6	second	second	JJ
47658	900	7	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	900	8	that	that	IN
47658	900	9	all	all	DT
47658	900	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	900	11	rests	rest	NNS
47658	900	12	ultimately	ultimately	RB
47658	900	13	on	on	IN
47658	900	14	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	900	15	experience	experience	NN
47658	900	16	.	.	.
47658	901	1	In	in	IN
47658	901	2	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	901	3	experience	experience	NN
47658	901	4	the	the	DT
47658	901	5	relation	relation	NN
47658	901	6	between	between	IN
47658	901	7	the	the	DT
47658	901	8	mental	mental	JJ
47658	901	9	act	act	NN
47658	901	10	of	of	IN
47658	901	11	knowing	know	VBG
47658	901	12	and	and	CC
47658	901	13	the	the	DT
47658	901	14	object	object	NN
47658	901	15	that	that	WDT
47658	901	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	901	17	known	know	VBN
47658	901	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	901	19	so	so	RB
47658	901	20	simple	simple	JJ
47658	901	21	that	that	IN
47658	901	22	any	any	DT
47658	901	23	question	question	NN
47658	901	24	as	as	IN
47658	901	25	to	to	IN
47658	901	26	truth	truth	NN
47658	901	27	or	or	CC
47658	901	28	error	error	NN
47658	901	29	in	in	IN
47658	901	30	regard	regard	NN
47658	901	31	to	to	IN
47658	901	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	901	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	901	34	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
47658	901	35	.	.	.
47658	902	1	To	to	TO
47658	902	2	question	question	VB
47658	902	3	the	the	DT
47658	902	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	902	5	of	of	IN
47658	902	6	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	902	7	experience	experience	NN
47658	902	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	902	9	to	to	TO
47658	902	10	question	question	VB
47658	902	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	902	12	existence	existence	NN
47658	902	13	;	;	:
47658	902	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	902	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	902	16	to	to	TO
47658	902	17	ask	ask	VB
47658	902	18	if	if	IN
47658	902	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	902	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	902	21	what	what	WP
47658	902	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	902	23	is	be	VBZ
47658	902	24	,	,	,
47658	902	25	and	and	CC
47658	902	26	this	this	DT
47658	902	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	902	28	plainly	plainly	RB
47658	902	29	unmeaning	unmeaning	JJ
47658	902	30	.	.	.
47658	903	1	But	but	CC
47658	903	2	thinking	think	VBG
47658	903	3	,	,	,
47658	903	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	903	5	said	say	VBD
47658	903	6	,	,	,
47658	903	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	903	8	questioning	question	VBG
47658	903	9	experience	experience	NN
47658	903	10	in	in	IN
47658	903	11	order	order	NN
47658	903	12	to	to	TO
47658	903	13	know	know	VB
47658	903	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	903	15	content	content	NN
47658	903	16	or	or	CC
47658	903	17	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	903	18	,	,	,
47658	903	19	and	and	CC
47658	903	20	in	in	IN
47658	903	21	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	903	22	,	,	,
47658	903	23	the	the	DT
47658	903	24	simplicity	simplicity	NN
47658	903	25	of	of	IN
47658	903	26	the	the	DT
47658	903	27	relation	relation	NN
47658	903	28	which	which	WDT
47658	903	29	unites	unite	VBZ
47658	903	30	the	the	DT
47658	903	31	mind	mind	NN
47658	903	32	to	to	IN
47658	903	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	903	34	object	object	NN
47658	903	35	in	in	IN
47658	903	36	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	903	37	experience	experience	NN
47658	903	38	is	be	VBZ
47658	903	39	left	leave	VBN
47658	903	40	behind	behind	RB
47658	903	41	,	,	,
47658	903	42	and	and	CC
47658	903	43	a	a	DT
47658	903	44	logical	logical	JJ
47658	903	45	process	process	NN
47658	903	46	of	of	IN
47658	903	47	very	very	RB
47658	903	48	great	great	JJ
47658	903	49	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	903	50	takes	take	VBZ
47658	903	51	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	903	52	place	place	NN
47658	903	53	.	.	.
47658	904	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	904	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	904	3	in	in	IN
47658	904	4	this	this	DT
47658	904	5	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	904	6	that	that	IN
47658	904	7	the	the	DT
47658	904	8	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	904	9	of	of	IN
47658	904	10	error	error	NN
47658	904	11	lies	lie	NNS
47658	904	12	.	.	.
47658	905	1	Let	let	VB
47658	905	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	905	3	look	look	VB
47658	905	4	at	at	IN
47658	905	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	905	6	a	a	DT
47658	905	7	little	little	RB
47658	905	8	more	more	RBR
47658	905	9	closely	closely	RB
47658	905	10	.	.	.
47658	906	1	Knowing	Knowing	NNP
47658	906	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	906	3	a	a	DT
47658	906	4	relation	relation	NN
47658	906	5	which	which	WDT
47658	906	6	unites	unite	VBZ
47658	906	7	two	two	CD
47658	906	8	things	thing	NNS
47658	906	9	,	,	,
47658	906	10	one	one	CD
47658	906	11	the	the	DT
47658	906	12	mind	mind	NN
47658	906	13	that	that	WDT
47658	906	14	knows	know	VBZ
47658	906	15	,	,	,
47658	906	16	the	the	DT
47658	906	17	other	other	JJ
47658	906	18	the	the	DT
47658	906	19	thing	thing	NN
47658	906	20	known	know	VBN
47658	906	21	.	.	.
47658	907	1	In	in	IN
47658	907	2	every	every	DT
47658	907	3	act	act	NN
47658	907	4	of	of	IN
47658	907	5	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	907	6	,	,	,
47658	907	7	something	something	NN
47658	907	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	907	9	present	present	JJ
47658	907	10	to	to	IN
47658	907	11	the	the	DT
47658	907	12	mind	mind	NN
47658	907	13	;	;	:
47658	907	14	if	if	IN
47658	907	15	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	907	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	907	17	simply	simply	RB
47658	907	18	awareness	awareness	NN
47658	907	19	of	of	IN
47658	907	20	this	this	DT
47658	907	21	actually	actually	RB
47658	907	22	present	present	JJ
47658	907	23	something	something	NN
47658	907	24	,	,	,
47658	907	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	907	26	call	call	VBP
47658	907	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	907	28	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	907	29	experience	experience	NN
47658	907	30	,	,	,
47658	907	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	907	32	are	be	VBP
47658	907	33	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	907	34	with	with	IN
47658	907	35	the	the	DT
47658	907	36	object	object	NN
47658	907	37	.	.	.
47658	908	1	But	but	CC
47658	908	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	908	3	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	908	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	908	5	not	not	RB
47658	908	6	only	only	RB
47658	908	7	of	of	IN
47658	908	8	objects	object	NNS
47658	908	9	{	{	-LRB-
47658	908	10	82	82	CD
47658	908	11	}	}	-RRB-
47658	908	12	immediately	immediately	RB
47658	908	13	present	present	JJ
47658	908	14	to	to	IN
47658	908	15	the	the	DT
47658	908	16	mind	mind	NN
47658	908	17	and	and	CC
47658	908	18	with	with	IN
47658	908	19	which	which	WDT
47658	908	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	908	21	are	be	VBP
47658	908	22	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	908	23	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	908	24	.	.	.
47658	909	1	Knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	909	2	embraces	embrace	VBZ
47658	909	3	the	the	DT
47658	909	4	past	past	NN
47658	909	5	and	and	CC
47658	909	6	future	future	NN
47658	909	7	and	and	CC
47658	909	8	the	the	DT
47658	909	9	distant	distant	JJ
47658	909	10	realms	realm	NNS
47658	909	11	of	of	IN
47658	909	12	space	space	NN
47658	909	13	.	.	.
47658	910	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
47658	910	2	were	be	VBD
47658	910	3	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	910	4	only	only	RB
47658	910	5	of	of	IN
47658	910	6	what	what	WP
47658	910	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	910	8	actually	actually	RB
47658	910	9	present	present	JJ
47658	910	10	to	to	IN
47658	910	11	the	the	DT
47658	910	12	mind	mind	NN
47658	910	13	,	,	,
47658	910	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	910	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	910	16	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	910	17	to	to	TO
47658	910	18	imagine	imagine	VB
47658	910	19	that	that	IN
47658	910	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	910	21	could	could	MD
47658	910	22	,	,	,
47658	910	23	in	in	IN
47658	910	24	the	the	DT
47658	910	25	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	910	26	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	910	27	of	of	IN
47658	910	28	the	the	DT
47658	910	29	word	word	NN
47658	910	30	,	,	,
47658	910	31	know	know	VB
47658	910	32	anything	anything	NN
47658	910	33	at	at	RB
47658	910	34	all	all	RB
47658	910	35	.	.	.
47658	911	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	911	2	may	may	MD
47658	911	3	be	be	VB
47658	911	4	thinking	think	VBG
47658	911	5	,	,	,
47658	911	6	for	for	IN
47658	911	7	example	example	NN
47658	911	8	,	,	,
47658	911	9	of	of	IN
47658	911	10	an	an	DT
47658	911	11	absent	absent	JJ
47658	911	12	friend	friend	NN
47658	911	13	;	;	:
47658	911	14	all	all	DT
47658	911	15	that	that	WDT
47658	911	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	911	17	present	present	JJ
47658	911	18	to	to	IN
47658	911	19	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	911	20	mind	mind	NN
47658	911	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	911	22	,	,	,
47658	911	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	911	24	may	may	MD
47658	911	25	be	be	VB
47658	911	26	,	,	,
47658	911	27	a	a	DT
47658	911	28	memory	memory	NN
47658	911	29	image	image	NN
47658	911	30	,	,	,
47658	911	31	a	a	DT
47658	911	32	faint	faint	JJ
47658	911	33	recall	recall	NN
47658	911	34	of	of	IN
47658	911	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	911	36	appearance	appearance	NN
47658	911	37	on	on	IN
47658	911	38	some	some	DT
47658	911	39	one	one	CD
47658	911	40	occasion	occasion	NN
47658	911	41	,	,	,
47658	911	42	or	or	CC
47658	911	43	perhaps	perhaps	RB
47658	911	44	a	a	DT
47658	911	45	recollection	recollection	NN
47658	911	46	of	of	IN
47658	911	47	the	the	DT
47658	911	48	tone	tone	NN
47658	911	49	of	of	IN
47658	911	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	911	51	voice	voice	NN
47658	911	52	,	,	,
47658	911	53	or	or	CC
47658	911	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	911	55	may	may	MD
47658	911	56	be	be	VB
47658	911	57	the	the	DT
47658	911	58	black	black	JJ
47658	911	59	marks	mark	NNS
47658	911	60	on	on	IN
47658	911	61	white	white	JJ
47658	911	62	paper	paper	NN
47658	911	63	which	which	WDT
47658	911	64	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	911	65	recognise	recognise	VBP
47658	911	66	as	as	IN
47658	911	67	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	911	68	handwriting	handwriting	NN
47658	911	69	.	.	.
47658	912	1	This	this	DT
47658	912	2	image	image	NN
47658	912	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	912	4	present	present	JJ
47658	912	5	to	to	IN
47658	912	6	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	912	7	mind	mind	NN
47658	912	8	,	,	,
47658	912	9	but	but	CC
47658	912	10	the	the	DT
47658	912	11	image	image	NN
47658	912	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	912	13	not	not	RB
47658	912	14	the	the	DT
47658	912	15	object	object	NN
47658	912	16	,	,	,
47658	912	17	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	912	18	friend	friend	NN
47658	912	19	,	,	,
47658	912	20	about	about	IN
47658	912	21	whom	whom	WP
47658	912	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	912	23	think	think	VBP
47658	912	24	and	and	CC
47658	912	25	make	make	VBP
47658	912	26	endless	endless	JJ
47658	912	27	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	912	28	,	,	,
47658	912	29	true	true	JJ
47658	912	30	and	and	CC
47658	912	31	false	false	JJ
47658	912	32	.	.	.
47658	913	1	So	so	RB
47658	913	2	also	also	RB
47658	913	3	,	,	,
47658	913	4	if	if	IN
47658	913	5	what	what	WP
47658	913	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	913	7	present	present	JJ
47658	913	8	to	to	IN
47658	913	9	the	the	DT
47658	913	10	mind	mind	NN
47658	913	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	913	12	affecting	affect	VBG
47658	913	13	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	14	through	through	IN
47658	913	15	the	the	DT
47658	913	16	external	external	JJ
47658	913	17	senses	sense	NNS
47658	913	18	,	,	,
47658	913	19	if	if	IN
47658	913	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	913	22	a	a	DT
47658	913	23	sense	sense	NN
47658	913	24	impression	impression	NN
47658	913	25	,	,	,
47658	913	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	913	28	clear	clear	JJ
47658	913	29	that	that	IN
47658	913	30	what	what	WP
47658	913	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	913	32	actually	actually	RB
47658	913	33	present	present	JJ
47658	913	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	913	35	not	not	RB
47658	913	36	the	the	DT
47658	913	37	whole	whole	JJ
47658	913	38	object	object	NN
47658	913	39	of	of	IN
47658	913	40	which	which	WDT
47658	913	41	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	42	am	be	VBP
47658	913	43	aware	aware	JJ
47658	913	44	,	,	,
47658	913	45	but	but	CC
47658	913	46	only	only	RB
47658	913	47	a	a	DT
47658	913	48	very	very	RB
47658	913	49	small	small	JJ
47658	913	50	part	part	NN
47658	913	51	of	of	IN
47658	913	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	53	,	,	,
47658	913	54	or	or	CC
47658	913	55	,	,	,
47658	913	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	57	may	may	MD
47658	913	58	be	be	VB
47658	913	59	,	,	,
47658	913	60	no	no	DT
47658	913	61	part	part	NN
47658	913	62	of	of	IN
47658	913	63	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	64	at	at	RB
47658	913	65	all	all	RB
47658	913	66	,	,	,
47658	913	67	but	but	CC
47658	913	68	something	something	NN
47658	913	69	,	,	,
47658	913	70	a	a	DT
47658	913	71	sound	sound	NN
47658	913	72	,	,	,
47658	913	73	or	or	CC
47658	913	74	an	an	DT
47658	913	75	odour	odour	NN
47658	913	76	,	,	,
47658	913	77	that	that	DT
47658	913	78	represents	represent	VBZ
47658	913	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	913	80	.	.	.
47658	914	1	The	the	DT
47658	914	2	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	914	3	data	datum	NNS
47658	914	4	of	of	IN
47658	914	5	consciousness	consciousness	NN
47658	914	6	are	be	VBP
47658	914	7	named	name	VBN
47658	914	8	by	by	IN
47658	914	9	some	some	DT
47658	914	10	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	914	11	sense	sense	VBP
47658	914	12	data	datum	NNS
47658	914	13	,	,	,
47658	914	14	by	by	IN
47658	914	15	others	other	NNS
47658	914	16	,	,	,
47658	914	17	presentations	presentation	NNS
47658	914	18	,	,	,
47658	914	19	by	by	IN
47658	914	20	others	other	NNS
47658	914	21	images	image	NNS
47658	914	22	,	,	,
47658	914	23	and	and	CC
47658	914	24	there	there	EX
47658	914	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	914	26	much	much	JJ
47658	914	27	controversy	controversy	NN
47658	914	28	as	as	IN
47658	914	29	to	to	IN
47658	914	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	914	31	nature	nature	NN
47658	914	32	and	and	CC
47658	914	33	existence	existence	NN
47658	914	34	,	,	,
47658	914	35	but	but	CC
47658	914	36	with	with	IN
47658	914	37	this	this	DT
47658	914	38	controversy	controversy	NN
47658	914	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	914	40	are	be	VBP
47658	914	41	not	not	RB
47658	914	42	here	here	RB
47658	914	43	concerned	concerned	JJ
47658	914	44	--	--	:
47658	914	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	914	46	are	be	VBP
47658	914	47	seeking	seek	VBG
47658	914	48	to	to	TO
47658	914	49	make	make	VB
47658	914	50	clear	clear	JJ
47658	914	51	an	an	DT
47658	914	52	obvious	obvious	JJ
47658	914	53	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	914	54	,	,	,
47658	914	55	namely	namely	RB
47658	914	56	,	,	,
47658	914	57	the	the	DT
47658	914	58	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	914	59	between	between	IN
47658	914	60	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	914	61	by	by	IN
47658	914	62	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	914	63	and	and	CC
47658	914	64	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	914	65	by	by	IN
47658	914	66	description	description	NN
47658	914	67	.	.	.
47658	915	1	What	what	WDT
47658	915	2	kind	kind	NN
47658	915	3	of	of	IN
47658	915	4	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	915	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	915	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	915	7	that	that	WDT
47658	915	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	915	9	acquire	acquire	VBP
47658	915	10	by	by	IN
47658	915	11	description	description	NN
47658	915	12	?	?	.
47658	916	1	Knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	916	2	about	about	IN
47658	916	3	things	thing	NNS
47658	916	4	with	with	IN
47658	916	5	which	which	WDT
47658	916	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	916	7	are	be	VBP
47658	916	8	not	not	RB
47658	916	9	first	first	RB
47658	916	10	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	916	11	.	.	.
47658	917	1	The	the	DT
47658	917	2	most	most	RBS
47658	917	3	important	important	JJ
47658	917	4	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	917	5	that	that	WDT
47658	917	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	917	7	possess	possess	VBP
47658	917	8	or	or	CC
47658	917	9	acquire	acquire	VBP
47658	917	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	917	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	917	12	of	of	IN
47658	917	13	objects	object	NNS
47658	917	14	which	which	WDT
47658	917	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	917	16	know	know	VBP
47658	917	17	only	only	RB
47658	917	18	by	by	IN
47658	917	19	the	the	DT
47658	917	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	917	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	917	22	have	have	VBP
47658	917	23	about	about	IN
47658	917	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	917	25	--	--	:
47658	917	26	objects	object	NNS
47658	917	27	that	that	WDT
47658	917	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	917	29	know	know	VBP
47658	917	30	about	about	IN
47658	917	31	without	without	IN
47658	917	32	knowing	know	VBG
47658	917	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	917	34	.	.	.
47658	918	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
47658	918	2	are	be	VBP
47658	918	3	not	not	RB
47658	918	4	direct	direct	JJ
47658	918	5	impressions	impression	NNS
47658	918	6	on	on	IN
47658	918	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	918	8	senses	sense	NNS
47658	918	9	,	,	,
47658	918	10	{	{	-LRB-
47658	918	11	83	83	CD
47658	918	12	}	}	-RRB-
47658	918	13	nor	nor	CC
47658	918	14	are	be	VBP
47658	918	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	918	16	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	918	17	known	know	VBN
47658	918	18	in	in	IN
47658	918	19	actual	actual	JJ
47658	918	20	experience	experience	NN
47658	918	21	.	.	.
47658	919	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	919	2	make	make	VBP
47658	919	3	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	919	4	about	about	IN
47658	919	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	919	6	,	,	,
47658	919	7	and	and	CC
47658	919	8	the	the	DT
47658	919	9	subjects	subject	NNS
47658	919	10	about	about	IN
47658	919	11	which	which	WDT
47658	919	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	919	13	make	make	VBP
47658	919	14	these	these	DT
47658	919	15	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	919	16	are	be	VBP
47658	919	17	really	really	RB
47658	919	18	composed	compose	VBN
47658	919	19	of	of	IN
47658	919	20	these	these	DT
47658	919	21	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	919	22	that	that	WDT
47658	919	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	919	24	make	make	VBP
47658	919	25	about	about	IN
47658	919	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	919	27	.	.	.
47658	920	1	To	to	TO
47658	920	2	go	go	VB
47658	920	3	back	back	RB
47658	920	4	to	to	IN
47658	920	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	920	6	illustrations	illustration	NNS
47658	920	7	,	,	,
47658	920	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	920	9	may	may	MD
47658	920	10	know	know	VB
47658	920	11	a	a	DT
47658	920	12	great	great	JJ
47658	920	13	deal	deal	NN
47658	920	14	about	about	IN
47658	920	15	the	the	DT
47658	920	16	evil	evil	JJ
47658	920	17	eye	eye	NN
47658	920	18	,	,	,
47658	920	19	a	a	DT
47658	920	20	malignant	malignant	JJ
47658	920	21	influence	influence	NN
47658	920	22	,	,	,
47658	920	23	disease	disease	NN
47658	920	24	,	,	,
47658	920	25	faith	faith	NN
47658	920	26	,	,	,
47658	920	27	healing	healing	NN
47658	920	28	,	,	,
47658	920	29	causality	causality	NN
47658	920	30	,	,	,
47658	920	31	physical	physical	JJ
47658	920	32	objects	object	NNS
47658	920	33	,	,	,
47658	920	34	without	without	IN
47658	920	35	any	any	DT
47658	920	36	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	920	37	with	with	IN
47658	920	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	920	39	,	,	,
47658	920	40	without	without	IN
47658	920	41	even	even	RB
47658	920	42	knowing	know	VBG
47658	920	43	that	that	IN
47658	920	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	920	45	exist	exist	VBP
47658	920	46	.	.	.
47658	921	1	Such	such	JJ
47658	921	2	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	921	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	921	4	descriptive	descriptive	JJ
47658	921	5	,	,	,
47658	921	6	and	and	CC
47658	921	7	the	the	DT
47658	921	8	objects	object	NNS
47658	921	9	are	be	VBP
47658	921	10	descriptions	description	NNS
47658	921	11	.	.	.
47658	922	1	Knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	922	2	by	by	IN
47658	922	3	description	description	NN
47658	922	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	922	5	never	never	RB
47658	922	6	quite	quite	RB
47658	922	7	simple	simple	JJ
47658	922	8	,	,	,
47658	922	9	and	and	CC
47658	922	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	922	11	often	often	RB
47658	922	12	very	very	RB
47658	922	13	complex	complex	JJ
47658	922	14	,	,	,
47658	922	15	for	for	IN
47658	922	16	,	,	,
47658	922	17	besides	besides	IN
47658	922	18	the	the	DT
47658	922	19	relation	relation	NN
47658	922	20	of	of	IN
47658	922	21	the	the	DT
47658	922	22	mental	mental	JJ
47658	922	23	act	act	NN
47658	922	24	to	to	IN
47658	922	25	the	the	DT
47658	922	26	object	object	NN
47658	922	27	known	know	VBN
47658	922	28	,	,	,
47658	922	29	there	there	EX
47658	922	30	are	be	VBP
47658	922	31	the	the	DT
47658	922	32	terms	term	NNS
47658	922	33	and	and	CC
47658	922	34	relations	relation	NNS
47658	922	35	which	which	WDT
47658	922	36	are	be	VBP
47658	922	37	the	the	DT
47658	922	38	elements	element	NNS
47658	922	39	in	in	IN
47658	922	40	the	the	DT
47658	922	41	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	922	42	and	and	CC
47658	922	43	the	the	DT
47658	922	44	relations	relation	NNS
47658	922	45	of	of	IN
47658	922	46	the	the	DT
47658	922	47	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	922	48	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	922	49	.	.	.
47658	923	1	If	if	IN
47658	923	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	923	3	analyse	analyse	VBP
47658	923	4	a	a	DT
47658	923	5	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	923	6	,	,	,
47658	923	7	every	every	DT
47658	923	8	word	word	NN
47658	923	9	in	in	IN
47658	923	10	which	which	WDT
47658	923	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	923	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	923	13	expressed	express	VBN
47658	923	14	,	,	,
47658	923	15	whether	whether	IN
47658	923	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	923	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	923	18	a	a	DT
47658	923	19	noun	noun	NN
47658	923	20	or	or	CC
47658	923	21	a	a	DT
47658	923	22	verb	verb	NN
47658	923	23	or	or	CC
47658	923	24	a	a	DT
47658	923	25	preposition	preposition	NN
47658	923	26	or	or	CC
47658	923	27	a	a	DT
47658	923	28	conjunction	conjunction	NN
47658	923	29	,	,	,
47658	923	30	conveys	convey	VBZ
47658	923	31	a	a	DT
47658	923	32	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	923	33	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	923	34	,	,	,
47658	923	35	indicates	indicate	VBZ
47658	923	36	a	a	DT
47658	923	37	term	term	NN
47658	923	38	or	or	CC
47658	923	39	a	a	DT
47658	923	40	relation	relation	NN
47658	923	41	,	,	,
47658	923	42	each	each	DT
47658	923	43	of	of	IN
47658	923	44	which	which	WDT
47658	923	45	can	can	MD
47658	923	46	be	be	VB
47658	923	47	made	make	VBN
47658	923	48	a	a	DT
47658	923	49	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	923	50	object	object	NN
47658	923	51	to	to	IN
47658	923	52	the	the	DT
47658	923	53	mind	mind	NN
47658	923	54	,	,	,
47658	923	55	and	and	CC
47658	923	56	all	all	DT
47658	923	57	of	of	IN
47658	923	58	which	which	WDT
47658	923	59	are	be	VBP
47658	923	60	combined	combine	VBN
47658	923	61	in	in	IN
47658	923	62	the	the	DT
47658	923	63	single	single	JJ
47658	923	64	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	923	65	the	the	DT
47658	923	66	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	923	67	expresses	express	VBZ
47658	923	68	.	.	.
47658	924	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	924	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	924	3	in	in	IN
47658	924	4	this	this	DT
47658	924	5	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	924	6	that	that	IN
47658	924	7	the	the	DT
47658	924	8	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	924	9	of	of	IN
47658	924	10	error	error	NN
47658	924	11	lies	lie	NNS
47658	924	12	,	,	,
47658	924	13	and	and	CC
47658	924	14	the	the	DT
47658	924	15	possibility	possibility	NN
47658	924	16	increases	increase	VBZ
47658	924	17	as	as	IN
47658	924	18	the	the	DT
47658	924	19	complexity	complexity	NN
47658	924	20	increases	increase	VBZ
47658	924	21	.	.	.
47658	925	1	All	all	PDT
47658	925	2	the	the	DT
47658	925	3	terms	term	NNS
47658	925	4	and	and	CC
47658	925	5	the	the	DT
47658	925	6	relations	relation	NNS
47658	925	7	which	which	WDT
47658	925	8	a	a	DT
47658	925	9	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	925	10	contains	contain	VBZ
47658	925	11	depend	depend	VBP
47658	925	12	on	on	IN
47658	925	13	the	the	DT
47658	925	14	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	925	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	925	16	have	have	VBP
47658	925	17	by	by	IN
47658	925	18	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	925	19	--	--	:
47658	925	20	that	that	DT
47658	925	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	925	22	to	to	TO
47658	925	23	say	say	VB
47658	925	24	,	,	,
47658	925	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	925	26	are	be	VBP
47658	925	27	ultimately	ultimately	RB
47658	925	28	dependent	dependent	JJ
47658	925	29	on	on	IN
47658	925	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	925	31	actual	actual	JJ
47658	925	32	experience	experience	NN
47658	925	33	for	for	IN
47658	925	34	all	all	DT
47658	925	35	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	925	36	whatever	whatever	WDT
47658	925	37	,	,	,
47658	925	38	whether	whether	IN
47658	925	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	925	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	925	41	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	925	42	or	or	CC
47658	925	43	description	description	NN
47658	925	44	,	,	,
47658	925	45	for	for	IN
47658	925	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	925	47	can	can	MD
47658	925	48	only	only	RB
47658	925	49	describe	describe	VB
47658	925	50	in	in	IN
47658	925	51	terms	term	NNS
47658	925	52	with	with	IN
47658	925	53	which	which	WDT
47658	925	54	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	925	55	are	be	VBP
47658	925	56	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	925	57	;	;	:
47658	925	58	but	but	CC
47658	925	59	in	in	IN
47658	925	60	the	the	DT
47658	925	61	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	925	62	these	these	DT
47658	925	63	elements	element	NNS
47658	925	64	are	be	VBP
47658	925	65	combined	combine	VBN
47658	925	66	into	into	IN
47658	925	67	new	new	JJ
47658	925	68	objects	object	NNS
47658	925	69	,	,	,
47658	925	70	or	or	CC
47658	925	71	a	a	DT
47658	925	72	certain	certain	JJ
47658	925	73	relation	relation	NN
47658	925	74	is	be	VBZ
47658	925	75	declared	declare	VBN
47658	925	76	to	to	TO
47658	925	77	exist	exist	VB
47658	925	78	between	between	IN
47658	925	79	objects	object	NNS
47658	925	80	,	,	,
47658	925	81	and	and	CC
47658	925	82	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	925	83	is	be	VBZ
47658	925	84	this	this	DT
47658	925	85	combination	combination	NN
47658	925	86	of	of	IN
47658	925	87	the	the	DT
47658	925	88	elements	element	NNS
47658	925	89	of	of	IN
47658	925	90	the	the	DT
47658	925	91	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	925	92	that	that	WDT
47658	925	93	involves	involve	VBZ
47658	925	94	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	925	95	truth	truth	NN
47658	925	96	or	or	CC
47658	925	97	falsehood	falsehood	NN
47658	925	98	.	.	.
47658	926	1	If	if	IN
47658	926	2	this	this	DT
47658	926	3	view	view	NN
47658	926	4	of	of	IN
47658	926	5	the	the	DT
47658	926	6	nature	nature	NN
47658	926	7	of	of	IN
47658	926	8	the	the	DT
47658	926	9	mental	mental	JJ
47658	926	10	act	act	NN
47658	926	11	of	of	IN
47658	926	12	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	926	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	926	14	accepted	accept	VBN
47658	926	15	,	,	,
47658	926	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	926	17	are	be	VBP
47658	926	18	able	able	JJ
47658	926	19	to	to	TO
47658	926	20	understand	understand	VB
47658	926	21	how	how	WRB
47658	926	22	false	false	JJ
47658	926	23	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	926	24	{	{	-LRB-
47658	926	25	84	84	CD
47658	926	26	}	}	-RRB-
47658	926	27	is	be	VBZ
47658	926	28	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	926	29	with	with	IN
47658	926	30	the	the	DT
47658	926	31	fact	fact	NN
47658	926	32	that	that	IN
47658	926	33	all	all	DT
47658	926	34	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	926	35	is	be	VBZ
47658	926	36	truth	truth	NN
47658	926	37	.	.	.
47658	927	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	927	2	escape	escape	VBP
47658	927	3	both	both	CC
47658	927	4	the	the	DT
47658	927	5	alternatives	alternative	NNS
47658	927	6	that	that	WDT
47658	927	7	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	927	8	to	to	IN
47658	927	9	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
47658	927	10	the	the	DT
47658	927	11	only	only	JJ
47658	927	12	possible	possible	JJ
47658	927	13	ones	one	NNS
47658	927	14	.	.	.
47658	928	1	"	"	``
47658	928	2	When	when	WRB
47658	928	3	a	a	DT
47658	928	4	man	man	NN
47658	928	5	has	have	VBZ
47658	928	6	a	a	DT
47658	928	7	false	false	JJ
47658	928	8	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	928	9	,	,	,
47658	928	10	does	do	VBZ
47658	928	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	928	12	think	think	VB
47658	928	13	that	that	IN
47658	928	14	which	which	WDT
47658	928	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	928	16	knows	know	VBZ
47658	928	17	to	to	TO
47658	928	18	be	be	VB
47658	928	19	some	some	DT
47658	928	20	other	other	JJ
47658	928	21	thing	thing	NN
47658	928	22	which	which	WDT
47658	928	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	928	24	knows	know	VBZ
47658	928	25	,	,	,
47658	928	26	and	and	CC
47658	928	27	knowing	know	VBG
47658	928	28	both	both	DT
47658	928	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	928	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	928	31	at	at	IN
47658	928	32	the	the	DT
47658	928	33	same	same	JJ
47658	928	34	time	time	NN
47658	928	35	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
47658	928	36	of	of	IN
47658	928	37	both	both	DT
47658	928	38	?	?	.
47658	929	1	Or	or	CC
47658	929	2	does	do	VBZ
47658	929	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	929	4	think	think	VB
47658	929	5	of	of	IN
47658	929	6	something	something	NN
47658	929	7	which	which	WDT
47658	929	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	929	9	does	do	VBZ
47658	929	10	not	not	RB
47658	929	11	know	know	VB
47658	929	12	as	as	IN
47658	929	13	some	some	DT
47658	929	14	other	other	JJ
47658	929	15	thing	thing	NN
47658	929	16	which	which	WDT
47658	929	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	929	18	does	do	VBZ
47658	929	19	not	not	RB
47658	929	20	know	know	VB
47658	929	21	?	?	.
47658	929	22	"	"	''
47658	930	1	No	no	UH
47658	930	2	,	,	,
47658	930	3	neither	neither	CC
47658	930	4	;	;	:
47658	930	5	in	in	IN
47658	930	6	error	error	NN
47658	930	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	930	8	thinks	think	VBZ
47658	930	9	that	that	IN
47658	930	10	something	something	NN
47658	930	11	that	that	WDT
47658	930	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	930	13	knows	know	VBZ
47658	930	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	930	15	in	in	IN
47658	930	16	a	a	DT
47658	930	17	relation	relation	NN
47658	930	18	that	that	IN
47658	930	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	930	20	knows	know	VBZ
47658	930	21	to	to	IN
47658	930	22	some	some	DT
47658	930	23	other	other	JJ
47658	930	24	thing	thing	NN
47658	930	25	that	that	WDT
47658	930	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	930	27	knows	know	VBZ
47658	930	28	,	,	,
47658	930	29	when	when	WRB
47658	930	30	in	in	IN
47658	930	31	fact	fact	NN
47658	930	32	that	that	IN
47658	930	33	relation	relation	NN
47658	930	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	930	35	not	not	RB
47658	930	36	relating	relate	VBG
47658	930	37	the	the	DT
47658	930	38	two	two	CD
47658	930	39	things	thing	NNS
47658	930	40	.	.	.
47658	931	1	The	the	DT
47658	931	2	false	false	JJ
47658	931	3	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	931	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	931	5	not	not	RB
47658	931	6	one	one	CD
47658	931	7	in	in	IN
47658	931	8	which	which	WDT
47658	931	9	the	the	DT
47658	931	10	constituent	constituent	NN
47658	931	11	terms	term	NNS
47658	931	12	and	and	CC
47658	931	13	relations	relation	NNS
47658	931	14	are	be	VBP
47658	931	15	unknown	unknown	JJ
47658	931	16	or	or	CC
47658	931	17	non	non	JJ
47658	931	18	-	-	JJ
47658	931	19	existent	existent	JJ
47658	931	20	,	,	,
47658	931	21	but	but	CC
47658	931	22	one	one	CD
47658	931	23	in	in	IN
47658	931	24	which	which	WDT
47658	931	25	a	a	DT
47658	931	26	combination	combination	NN
47658	931	27	of	of	IN
47658	931	28	these	these	DT
47658	931	29	terms	term	NNS
47658	931	30	and	and	CC
47658	931	31	relations	relation	NNS
47658	931	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	931	33	thought	think	VBN
47658	931	34	to	to	TO
47658	931	35	exist	exist	VB
47658	931	36	when	when	WRB
47658	931	37	in	in	IN
47658	931	38	fact	fact	NN
47658	931	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	931	40	does	do	VBZ
47658	931	41	not	not	RB
47658	931	42	exist	exist	VB
47658	931	43	;	;	:
47658	931	44	and	and	CC
47658	931	45	the	the	DT
47658	931	46	true	true	JJ
47658	931	47	proposition	proposition	NN
47658	931	48	is	be	VBZ
47658	931	49	that	that	IN
47658	931	50	in	in	IN
47658	931	51	which	which	WDT
47658	931	52	the	the	DT
47658	931	53	combination	combination	NN
47658	931	54	thought	think	VBD
47658	931	55	to	to	TO
47658	931	56	exist	exist	VB
47658	931	57	does	do	VBZ
47658	931	58	exist	exist	VB
47658	931	59	.	.	.
47658	932	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	932	2	can	can	MD
47658	932	3	,	,	,
47658	932	4	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	932	5	,	,	,
47658	932	6	if	if	IN
47658	932	7	this	this	DT
47658	932	8	account	account	NN
47658	932	9	be	be	VB
47658	932	10	true	true	JJ
47658	932	11	,	,	,
47658	932	12	at	at	IN
47658	932	13	least	least	JJS
47658	932	14	know	know	VB
47658	932	15	what	what	WP
47658	932	16	false	false	JJ
47658	932	17	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	932	18	or	or	CC
47658	932	19	error	error	NN
47658	932	20	can	can	MD
47658	932	21	be	be	VB
47658	932	22	,	,	,
47658	932	23	whether	whether	IN
47658	932	24	or	or	CC
47658	932	25	not	not	RB
47658	932	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	932	27	have	have	VBP
47658	932	28	any	any	DT
47658	932	29	means	mean	NNS
47658	932	30	of	of	IN
47658	932	31	deciding	decide	VBG
47658	932	32	in	in	IN
47658	932	33	regard	regard	NN
47658	932	34	to	to	IN
47658	932	35	any	any	DT
47658	932	36	particular	particular	JJ
47658	932	37	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	932	38	that	that	IN
47658	932	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	932	40	is	be	VBZ
47658	932	41	false	false	JJ
47658	932	42	.	.	.
47658	933	1	There	there	EX
47658	933	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	933	3	one	one	CD
47658	933	4	other	other	JJ
47658	933	5	theory	theory	NN
47658	933	6	,	,	,
47658	933	7	the	the	DT
47658	933	8	last	last	JJ
47658	933	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	933	10	shall	shall	MD
47658	933	11	notice	notice	VB
47658	933	12	.	.	.
47658	934	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	934	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	934	3	in	in	IN
47658	934	4	one	one	CD
47658	934	5	respect	respect	NN
47658	934	6	the	the	DT
47658	934	7	most	most	RBS
47658	934	8	important	important	JJ
47658	934	9	of	of	IN
47658	934	10	all	all	DT
47658	934	11	,	,	,
47658	934	12	namely	namely	RB
47658	934	13	,	,	,
47658	934	14	that	that	IN
47658	934	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	934	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	934	17	the	the	DT
47658	934	18	most	most	RBS
47658	934	19	direct	direct	JJ
47658	934	20	attempt	attempt	NN
47658	934	21	to	to	TO
47658	934	22	grapple	grapple	VB
47658	934	23	with	with	IN
47658	934	24	the	the	DT
47658	934	25	problem	problem	NN
47658	934	26	of	of	IN
47658	934	27	error	error	NN
47658	934	28	.	.	.
47658	935	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	935	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	935	3	founded	found	VBN
47658	935	4	on	on	IN
47658	935	5	a	a	DT
47658	935	6	theory	theory	NN
47658	935	7	of	of	IN
47658	935	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	935	9	which	which	WDT
47658	935	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	935	11	owe	owe	VBP
47658	935	12	mainly	mainly	RB
47658	935	13	to	to	IN
47658	935	14	the	the	DT
47658	935	15	profound	profound	JJ
47658	935	16	and	and	CC
47658	935	17	acute	acute	JJ
47658	935	18	work	work	NN
47658	935	19	of	of	IN
47658	935	20	a	a	DT
47658	935	21	German	german	JJ
47658	935	22	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	935	23	(	(	-LRB-
47658	935	24	Meinong	Meinong	NNP
47658	935	25	)	)	-RRB-
47658	935	26	,	,	,
47658	935	27	and	and	CC
47658	935	28	which	which	WDT
47658	935	29	at	at	IN
47658	935	30	the	the	DT
47658	935	31	present	present	JJ
47658	935	32	time	time	NN
47658	935	33	is	be	VBZ
47658	935	34	being	be	VBG
47658	935	35	keenly	keenly	RB
47658	935	36	discussed	discuss	VBN
47658	935	37	.	.	.
47658	936	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	936	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	936	3	an	an	DT
47658	936	4	attempt	attempt	NN
47658	936	5	to	to	TO
47658	936	6	determine	determine	VB
47658	936	7	more	more	RBR
47658	936	8	exactly	exactly	RB
47658	936	9	than	than	IN
47658	936	10	has	have	VBZ
47658	936	11	yet	yet	RB
47658	936	12	been	be	VBN
47658	936	13	done	do	VBN
47658	936	14	the	the	DT
47658	936	15	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	936	16	scheme	scheme	NN
47658	936	17	of	of	IN
47658	936	18	the	the	DT
47658	936	19	mental	mental	JJ
47658	936	20	life	life	NN
47658	936	21	and	and	CC
47658	936	22	development	development	NN
47658	936	23	.	.	.
47658	937	1	The	the	DT
47658	937	2	brief	brief	JJ
47658	937	3	account	account	NN
47658	937	4	that	that	WDT
47658	937	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	937	6	am	be	VBP
47658	937	7	now	now	RB
47658	937	8	offering	offer	VBG
47658	937	9	,	,	,
47658	937	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	937	11	owe	owe	VBP
47658	937	12	to	to	IN
47658	937	13	a	a	DT
47658	937	14	paper	paper	NN
47658	937	15	by	by	IN
47658	937	16	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	937	17	G.	G.	NNP
47658	937	18	F.	F.	NNP
47658	937	19	Stout	Stout	NNP
47658	937	20	on	on	IN
47658	937	21	"	"	``
47658	937	22	Some	Some	NNP
47658	937	23	Fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	937	24	Points	Points	NNPS
47658	937	25	in	in	IN
47658	937	26	the	the	DT
47658	937	27	Theory	Theory	NNP
47658	937	28	of	of	IN
47658	937	29	Knowledge	Knowledge	NNP
47658	937	30	.	.	.
47658	937	31	"	"	''
47658	938	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	938	2	have	have	VBP
47658	938	3	seen	see	VBN
47658	938	4	that	that	IN
47658	938	5	the	the	DT
47658	938	6	problem	problem	NN
47658	938	7	of	of	IN
47658	938	8	error	error	NN
47658	938	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	938	10	the	the	DT
47658	938	11	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	938	12	there	there	EX
47658	938	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	938	14	in	in	IN
47658	938	15	conceiving	conceive	VBG
47658	938	16	how	how	WRB
47658	938	17	there	there	EX
47658	938	18	can	can	MD
47658	938	19	be	be	VB
47658	938	20	any	any	DT
47658	938	21	real	real	JJ
47658	938	22	thing	thing	NN
47658	938	23	,	,	,
47658	938	24	any	any	DT
47658	938	25	real	real	JJ
47658	938	26	{	{	-LRB-
47658	938	27	85	85	CD
47658	938	28	}	}	-RRB-
47658	938	29	object	object	NN
47658	938	30	of	of	IN
47658	938	31	thought	thought	NN
47658	938	32	,	,	,
47658	938	33	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
47658	938	34	between	between	IN
47658	938	35	being	be	VBG
47658	938	36	and	and	CC
47658	938	37	not	not	RB
47658	938	38	-	-	HYPH
47658	938	39	being	being	NN
47658	938	40	.	.	.
47658	939	1	Error	error	NN
47658	939	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	939	3	to	to	TO
47658	939	4	exist	exist	VB
47658	939	5	and	and	CC
47658	939	6	yet	yet	RB
47658	939	7	to	to	TO
47658	939	8	have	have	VB
47658	939	9	a	a	DT
47658	939	10	nature	nature	NN
47658	939	11	which	which	WDT
47658	939	12	is	be	VBZ
47658	939	13	a	a	DT
47658	939	14	negation	negation	NN
47658	939	15	of	of	IN
47658	939	16	existence	existence	NN
47658	939	17	,	,	,
47658	939	18	and	and	CC
47658	939	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	939	20	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	939	21	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	939	22	to	to	TO
47658	939	23	be	be	VB
47658	939	24	a	a	DT
47658	939	25	downright	downright	JJ
47658	939	26	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	939	27	when	when	WRB
47658	939	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	939	29	affirm	affirm	VBP
47658	939	30	that	that	DT
47658	939	31	error	error	NN
47658	939	32	or	or	CC
47658	939	33	false	false	JJ
47658	939	34	opinion	opinion	NN
47658	939	35	can	can	MD
47658	939	36	_	_	IN
47658	939	37	be_--that	be_--that	IN
47658	939	38	there	there	EX
47658	939	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	939	40	a	a	DT
47658	939	41	real	real	JJ
47658	939	42	object	object	NN
47658	939	43	of	of	IN
47658	939	44	thought	thought	NN
47658	939	45	when	when	WRB
47658	939	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	939	47	judge	judge	VBP
47658	939	48	falsely	falsely	RB
47658	939	49	.	.	.
47658	940	1	This	this	DT
47658	940	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	940	3	meets	meet	VBZ
47658	940	4	the	the	DT
47658	940	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	940	6	directly	directly	RB
47658	940	7	by	by	IN
47658	940	8	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
47658	940	9	in	in	IN
47658	940	10	the	the	DT
47658	940	11	mental	mental	JJ
47658	940	12	act	act	NN
47658	940	13	of	of	IN
47658	940	14	knowing	know	VBG
47658	940	15	a	a	DT
47658	940	16	process	process	NN
47658	940	17	that	that	WDT
47658	940	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	940	19	neither	neither	DT
47658	940	20	perceiving	perceiving	NN
47658	940	21	nor	nor	CC
47658	940	22	thinking	think	VBG
47658	940	23	of	of	IN
47658	940	24	things	thing	NNS
47658	940	25	,	,	,
47658	940	26	and	and	CC
47658	940	27	that	that	DT
47658	940	28	involves	involve	VBZ
47658	940	29	neither	neither	CC
47658	940	30	believing	believe	VBG
47658	940	31	nor	nor	CC
47658	940	32	disbelieving	disbelieve	VBG
47658	940	33	on	on	IN
47658	940	34	the	the	DT
47658	940	35	one	one	CD
47658	940	36	hand	hand	NN
47658	940	37	nor	nor	CC
47658	940	38	desiring	desiring	JJ
47658	940	39	or	or	CC
47658	940	40	willing	willing	JJ
47658	940	41	on	on	IN
47658	940	42	the	the	DT
47658	940	43	other	other	JJ
47658	940	44	:	:	:
47658	940	45	this	this	DT
47658	940	46	is	be	VBZ
47658	940	47	the	the	DT
47658	940	48	process	process	NN
47658	940	49	of	of	IN
47658	940	50	supposing	suppose	VBG
47658	940	51	.	.	.
47658	941	1	Corresponding	correspond	VBG
47658	941	2	to	to	IN
47658	941	3	this	this	DT
47658	941	4	mental	mental	JJ
47658	941	5	act	act	NN
47658	941	6	of	of	IN
47658	941	7	supposing	supposing	NN
47658	941	8	,	,	,
47658	941	9	there	there	EX
47658	941	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	941	11	a	a	DT
47658	941	12	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	941	13	kind	kind	NN
47658	941	14	of	of	IN
47658	941	15	object	object	NN
47658	941	16	intended	intend	VBN
47658	941	17	or	or	CC
47658	941	18	meant	mean	VBN
47658	941	19	by	by	IN
47658	941	20	the	the	DT
47658	941	21	mind	mind	NN
47658	941	22	--	--	:
47658	941	23	an	an	DT
47658	941	24	object	object	NN
47658	941	25	that	that	WDT
47658	941	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	941	27	neither	neither	CC
47658	941	28	a	a	DT
47658	941	29	sense	sense	NN
47658	941	30	datum	datum	NN
47658	941	31	nor	nor	CC
47658	941	32	an	an	DT
47658	941	33	idea	idea	NN
47658	941	34	,	,	,
47658	941	35	nor	nor	CC
47658	941	36	a	a	DT
47658	941	37	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	941	38	,	,	,
47658	941	39	but	but	CC
47658	941	40	a	a	DT
47658	941	41	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	941	42	.	.	.
47658	942	1	Also	also	RB
47658	942	2	and	and	CC
47658	942	3	again	again	RB
47658	942	4	corresponding	correspond	VBG
47658	942	5	to	to	IN
47658	942	6	this	this	DT
47658	942	7	mental	mental	JJ
47658	942	8	act	act	NN
47658	942	9	of	of	IN
47658	942	10	supposing	supposing	NN
47658	942	11	and	and	CC
47658	942	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	942	13	intended	intended	JJ
47658	942	14	object	object	NN
47658	942	15	the	the	DT
47658	942	16	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	942	17	,	,	,
47658	942	18	there	there	EX
47658	942	19	is	be	VBZ
47658	942	20	a	a	DT
47658	942	21	mode	mode	NN
47658	942	22	of	of	IN
47658	942	23	being	being	NN
47658	942	24	which	which	WDT
47658	942	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	942	26	neither	neither	CC
47658	942	27	existence	existence	NN
47658	942	28	nor	nor	CC
47658	942	29	non	non	NN
47658	942	30	-	-	JJ
47658	942	31	existence	existence	NN
47658	942	32	,	,	,
47658	942	33	but	but	CC
47658	942	34	is	be	VBZ
47658	942	35	named	name	VBN
47658	942	36	subsistence	subsistence	NN
47658	942	37	.	.	.
47658	943	1	A	a	DT
47658	943	2	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	943	3	,	,	,
47658	943	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	943	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	943	6	said	say	VBN
47658	943	7	,	,	,
47658	943	8	does	do	VBZ
47658	943	9	not	not	RB
47658	943	10	exist	exist	VB
47658	943	11	--	--	:
47658	943	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	943	13	subsists	subsist	VBZ
47658	943	14	.	.	.
47658	944	1	This	this	DT
47658	944	2	thesis	thesis	NN
47658	944	3	,	,	,
47658	944	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	944	5	will	will	MD
47658	944	6	easily	easily	RB
47658	944	7	be	be	VB
47658	944	8	understood	understand	VBN
47658	944	9	,	,	,
47658	944	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	944	11	based	base	VBN
47658	944	12	on	on	IN
47658	944	13	an	an	DT
47658	944	14	analysis	analysis	NN
47658	944	15	,	,	,
47658	944	16	and	and	CC
47658	944	17	deals	deal	NNS
47658	944	18	with	with	IN
47658	944	19	arguments	argument	NNS
47658	944	20	that	that	WDT
47658	944	21	touch	touch	VBP
47658	944	22	the	the	DT
47658	944	23	most	most	RBS
47658	944	24	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	944	25	problems	problem	NNS
47658	944	26	of	of	IN
47658	944	27	theory	theory	NN
47658	944	28	of	of	IN
47658	944	29	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	944	30	.	.	.
47658	945	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
47658	945	2	,	,	,
47658	945	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	945	4	presentment	presentment	NN
47658	945	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	945	6	excessively	excessively	RB
47658	945	7	technical	technical	JJ
47658	945	8	,	,	,
47658	945	9	and	and	CC
47658	945	10	only	only	RB
47658	945	11	those	those	DT
47658	945	12	highly	highly	RB
47658	945	13	trained	train	VBN
47658	945	14	in	in	IN
47658	945	15	the	the	DT
47658	945	16	habit	habit	NN
47658	945	17	of	of	IN
47658	945	18	psychological	psychological	JJ
47658	945	19	introspection	introspection	NN
47658	945	20	and	and	CC
47658	945	21	skilled	skilled	JJ
47658	945	22	in	in	IN
47658	945	23	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	945	24	analysis	analysis	NN
47658	945	25	are	be	VBP
47658	945	26	really	really	RB
47658	945	27	competent	competent	JJ
47658	945	28	to	to	TO
47658	945	29	discuss	discuss	VB
47658	945	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	945	31	.	.	.
47658	946	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	946	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	946	3	not	not	RB
47658	946	4	possible	possible	JJ
47658	946	5	to	to	TO
47658	946	6	offer	offer	VB
47658	946	7	here	here	RB
47658	946	8	anything	anything	NN
47658	946	9	but	but	IN
47658	946	10	a	a	DT
47658	946	11	simple	simple	JJ
47658	946	12	outline	outline	NN
47658	946	13	of	of	IN
47658	946	14	the	the	DT
47658	946	15	part	part	NN
47658	946	16	of	of	IN
47658	946	17	the	the	DT
47658	946	18	theory	theory	NN
47658	946	19	that	that	WDT
47658	946	20	concerns	concern	VBZ
47658	946	21	the	the	DT
47658	946	22	present	present	JJ
47658	946	23	problem	problem	NN
47658	946	24	.	.	.
47658	947	1	The	the	DT
47658	947	2	actual	actual	JJ
47658	947	3	experience	experience	NN
47658	947	4	of	of	IN
47658	947	5	knowing	know	VBG
47658	947	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	947	7	a	a	DT
47658	947	8	relation	relation	NN
47658	947	9	between	between	IN
47658	947	10	two	two	CD
47658	947	11	things	thing	NNS
47658	947	12	,	,	,
47658	947	13	one	one	CD
47658	947	14	of	of	IN
47658	947	15	which	which	WDT
47658	947	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	947	17	a	a	DT
47658	947	18	mental	mental	JJ
47658	947	19	_	_	NNP
47658	947	20	act	act	NN
47658	947	21	_	_	NNP
47658	947	22	,	,	,
47658	947	23	the	the	DT
47658	947	24	act	act	NN
47658	947	25	of	of	IN
47658	947	26	perceiving	perceive	VBG
47658	947	27	or	or	CC
47658	947	28	thinking	think	VBG
47658	947	29	or	or	CC
47658	947	30	having	have	VBG
47658	947	31	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	947	32	,	,	,
47658	947	33	and	and	CC
47658	947	34	the	the	DT
47658	947	35	other	other	JJ
47658	947	36	is	be	VBZ
47658	947	37	an	an	DT
47658	947	38	_	_	NNP
47658	947	39	object	object	NN
47658	947	40	_	_	NNP
47658	947	41	,	,	,
47658	947	42	that	that	DT
47658	947	43	which	which	WDT
47658	947	44	is	be	VBZ
47658	947	45	perceived	perceive	VBN
47658	947	46	or	or	CC
47658	947	47	thought	think	VBD
47658	947	48	of	of	IN
47658	947	49	.	.	.
47658	948	1	The	the	DT
47658	948	2	act	act	NN
47658	948	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	948	4	a	a	DT
47658	948	5	particular	particular	JJ
47658	948	6	mental	mental	JJ
47658	948	7	existence	existence	NN
47658	948	8	,	,	,
47658	948	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	948	10	is	be	VBZ
47658	948	11	the	the	DT
47658	948	12	act	act	NN
47658	948	13	of	of	IN
47658	948	14	a	a	DT
47658	948	15	psychical	psychical	JJ
47658	948	16	individual	individual	NN
47658	948	17	.	.	.
47658	949	1	The	the	DT
47658	949	2	object	object	NN
47658	949	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	949	4	not	not	RB
47658	949	5	included	include	VBN
47658	949	6	within	within	IN
47658	949	7	the	the	DT
47658	949	8	actual	actual	JJ
47658	949	9	experience	experience	NN
47658	949	10	which	which	WDT
47658	949	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	949	12	the	the	DT
47658	949	13	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	949	14	of	of	IN
47658	949	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	949	16	,	,	,
47658	949	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	949	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	949	19	{	{	-LRB-
47658	949	20	86	86	CD
47658	949	21	}	}	-RRB-
47658	949	22	that	that	WDT
47658	949	23	which	which	WDT
47658	949	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	949	25	meant	mean	VBN
47658	949	26	or	or	CC
47658	949	27	intended	intend	VBN
47658	949	28	by	by	IN
47658	949	29	the	the	DT
47658	949	30	experience	experience	NN
47658	949	31	.	.	.
47658	950	1	The	the	DT
47658	950	2	act	act	NN
47658	950	3	,	,	,
47658	950	4	then	then	RB
47658	950	5	,	,	,
47658	950	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	950	7	the	the	DT
47658	950	8	mental	mental	JJ
47658	950	9	process	process	NN
47658	950	10	of	of	IN
47658	950	11	meaning	mean	VBG
47658	950	12	or	or	CC
47658	950	13	intending	intend	VBG
47658	950	14	,	,	,
47658	950	15	the	the	DT
47658	950	16	object	object	NN
47658	950	17	the	the	DT
47658	950	18	thing	thing	NN
47658	950	19	meant	mean	VBN
47658	950	20	or	or	CC
47658	950	21	intended	intend	VBN
47658	950	22	.	.	.
47658	951	1	The	the	DT
47658	951	2	mental	mental	JJ
47658	951	3	act	act	NN
47658	951	4	differs	differ	NNS
47658	951	5	according	accord	VBG
47658	951	6	to	to	IN
47658	951	7	the	the	DT
47658	951	8	kind	kind	NN
47658	951	9	of	of	IN
47658	951	10	object	object	NN
47658	951	11	intended	intend	VBN
47658	951	12	.	.	.
47658	952	1	The	the	DT
47658	952	2	act	act	NN
47658	952	3	of	of	IN
47658	952	4	perceiving	perceiving	NN
47658	952	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	952	6	the	the	DT
47658	952	7	direction	direction	NN
47658	952	8	of	of	IN
47658	952	9	the	the	DT
47658	952	10	mind	mind	NN
47658	952	11	towards	towards	IN
47658	952	12	sense	sense	NN
47658	952	13	data	datum	NNS
47658	952	14	and	and	CC
47658	952	15	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	952	16	;	;	:
47658	952	17	the	the	DT
47658	952	18	act	act	NN
47658	952	19	of	of	IN
47658	952	20	judging	judging	NN
47658	952	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	952	22	the	the	DT
47658	952	23	direction	direction	NN
47658	952	24	of	of	IN
47658	952	25	the	the	DT
47658	952	26	mind	mind	NN
47658	952	27	towards	towards	IN
47658	952	28	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	952	29	or	or	CC
47658	952	30	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	952	31	about	about	IN
47658	952	32	things	thing	NNS
47658	952	33	,	,	,
47658	952	34	propositions	proposition	NNS
47658	952	35	that	that	WDT
47658	952	36	affirm	affirm	VBP
47658	952	37	or	or	CC
47658	952	38	deny	deny	VBP
47658	952	39	relations	relation	NNS
47658	952	40	between	between	IN
47658	952	41	things	thing	NNS
47658	952	42	;	;	:
47658	952	43	the	the	DT
47658	952	44	act	act	NN
47658	952	45	of	of	IN
47658	952	46	supposing	supposing	NN
47658	952	47	is	be	VBZ
47658	952	48	different	different	JJ
47658	952	49	from	from	IN
47658	952	50	both	both	CC
47658	952	51	these	these	DT
47658	952	52	--	--	:
47658	952	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	952	54	is	be	VBZ
47658	952	55	the	the	DT
47658	952	56	direction	direction	NN
47658	952	57	of	of	IN
47658	952	58	the	the	DT
47658	952	59	mind	mind	NN
47658	952	60	towards	towards	IN
47658	952	61	suppositions	supposition	NNS
47658	952	62	.	.	.
47658	953	1	Suppositions	supposition	NNS
47658	953	2	differ	differ	VBP
47658	953	3	from	from	IN
47658	953	4	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	953	5	in	in	IN
47658	953	6	this	this	DT
47658	953	7	,	,	,
47658	953	8	that	that	IN
47658	953	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	953	10	may	may	MD
47658	953	11	be	be	VB
47658	953	12	either	either	CC
47658	953	13	positive	positive	JJ
47658	953	14	or	or	CC
47658	953	15	negative	negative	JJ
47658	953	16	,	,	,
47658	953	17	whereas	whereas	IN
47658	953	18	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	953	19	are	be	VBP
47658	953	20	never	never	RB
47658	953	21	negative	negative	JJ
47658	953	22	.	.	.
47658	954	1	This	this	DT
47658	954	2	may	may	MD
47658	954	3	seem	seem	VB
47658	954	4	to	to	TO
47658	954	5	contradict	contradict	VB
47658	954	6	experience	experience	NN
47658	954	7	.	.	.
47658	955	1	Can	Can	MD
47658	955	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	955	3	not	not	RB
47658	955	4	,	,	,
47658	955	5	for	for	IN
47658	955	6	example	example	NN
47658	955	7	,	,	,
47658	955	8	have	have	VBP
47658	955	9	an	an	DT
47658	955	10	idea	idea	NN
47658	955	11	of	of	IN
47658	955	12	not	not	RB
47658	955	13	-	-	HYPH
47658	955	14	red	red	JJ
47658	955	15	just	just	RB
47658	955	16	as	as	RB
47658	955	17	well	well	RB
47658	955	18	as	as	IN
47658	955	19	an	an	DT
47658	955	20	idea	idea	NN
47658	955	21	of	of	IN
47658	955	22	red	red	NN
47658	955	23	?	?	.
47658	956	1	No	no	UH
47658	956	2	,	,	,
47658	956	3	the	the	DT
47658	956	4	two	two	CD
47658	956	5	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	956	6	can	can	MD
47658	956	7	easily	easily	RB
47658	956	8	be	be	VB
47658	956	9	seen	see	VBN
47658	956	10	to	to	TO
47658	956	11	be	be	VB
47658	956	12	one	one	CD
47658	956	13	and	and	CC
47658	956	14	the	the	DT
47658	956	15	same	same	JJ
47658	956	16	;	;	:
47658	956	17	in	in	IN
47658	956	18	each	each	DT
47658	956	19	case	case	NN
47658	956	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	956	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	956	22	red	red	JJ
47658	956	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	956	24	are	be	VBP
47658	956	25	actually	actually	RB
47658	956	26	acquainted	acquaint	VBN
47658	956	27	with	with	IN
47658	956	28	,	,	,
47658	956	29	and	and	CC
47658	956	30	the	the	DT
47658	956	31	difference	difference	NN
47658	956	32	is	be	VBZ
47658	956	33	in	in	IN
47658	956	34	affirming	affirm	VBG
47658	956	35	or	or	CC
47658	956	36	denying	deny	VBG
47658	956	37	existence	existence	NN
47658	956	38	to	to	IN
47658	956	39	the	the	DT
47658	956	40	one	one	CD
47658	956	41	idea	idea	NN
47658	956	42	.	.	.
47658	957	1	The	the	DT
47658	957	2	difference	difference	NN
47658	957	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	957	4	in	in	IN
47658	957	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	957	6	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	957	7	,	,	,
47658	957	8	which	which	WDT
47658	957	9	may	may	MD
47658	957	10	be	be	VB
47658	957	11	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
47658	957	12	or	or	CC
47658	957	13	negative	negative	JJ
47658	957	14	.	.	.
47658	958	1	A	a	DT
47658	958	2	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	958	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	958	4	like	like	IN
47658	958	5	a	a	DT
47658	958	6	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	958	7	in	in	IN
47658	958	8	this	this	DT
47658	958	9	respect	respect	NN
47658	958	10	;	;	:
47658	958	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	958	12	may	may	MD
47658	958	13	be	be	VB
47658	958	14	either	either	CC
47658	958	15	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
47658	958	16	or	or	CC
47658	958	17	negative	negative	JJ
47658	958	18	,	,	,
47658	958	19	but	but	CC
47658	958	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	958	21	differs	differ	VBZ
47658	958	22	from	from	IN
47658	958	23	a	a	DT
47658	958	24	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	958	25	in	in	IN
47658	958	26	another	another	DT
47658	958	27	respect	respect	NN
47658	958	28	,	,	,
47658	958	29	that	that	IN
47658	958	30	while	while	IN
47658	958	31	a	a	DT
47658	958	32	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	958	33	always	always	RB
47658	958	34	conveys	convey	VBZ
47658	958	35	a	a	DT
47658	958	36	conviction	conviction	NN
47658	958	37	,	,	,
47658	958	38	always	always	RB
47658	958	39	expresses	express	VBZ
47658	958	40	belief	belief	NN
47658	958	41	or	or	CC
47658	958	42	disbelief	disbelief	NN
47658	958	43	,	,	,
47658	958	44	a	a	DT
47658	958	45	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	958	46	does	do	VBZ
47658	958	47	not	not	RB
47658	958	48	--	--	:
47658	958	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	958	50	is	be	VBZ
47658	958	51	neither	neither	CC
47658	958	52	believed	believe	VBN
47658	958	53	nor	nor	CC
47658	958	54	disbelieved	disbelieve	VBN
47658	958	55	.	.	.
47658	959	1	Before	before	IN
47658	959	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	959	3	show	show	VBP
47658	959	4	the	the	DT
47658	959	5	application	application	NN
47658	959	6	of	of	IN
47658	959	7	this	this	DT
47658	959	8	analysis	analysis	NN
47658	959	9	of	of	IN
47658	959	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	959	11	to	to	IN
47658	959	12	the	the	DT
47658	959	13	problem	problem	NN
47658	959	14	of	of	IN
47658	959	15	error	error	NN
47658	959	16	,	,	,
47658	959	17	let	let	VB
47658	959	18	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	959	19	try	try	VB
47658	959	20	and	and	CC
47658	959	21	clear	clear	VB
47658	959	22	up	up	RP
47658	959	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	959	24	obscurity	obscurity	NN
47658	959	25	,	,	,
47658	959	26	for	for	IN
47658	959	27	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
47658	959	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	959	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	959	30	difficult	difficult	JJ
47658	959	31	to	to	TO
47658	959	32	comprehend	comprehend	VB
47658	959	33	.	.	.
47658	960	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	960	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	960	3	lies	lie	VBZ
47658	960	4	in	in	IN
47658	960	5	this	this	DT
47658	960	6	,	,	,
47658	960	7	that	that	IN
47658	960	8	though	though	IN
47658	960	9	all	all	PDT
47658	960	10	the	the	DT
47658	960	11	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	960	12	with	with	IN
47658	960	13	which	which	WDT
47658	960	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	960	15	deals	deal	VBZ
47658	960	16	are	be	VBP
47658	960	17	quite	quite	RB
47658	960	18	familiar	familiar	JJ
47658	960	19	--	--	:
47658	960	20	suppositions	supposition	NNS
47658	960	21	,	,	,
47658	960	22	real	real	JJ
47658	960	23	and	and	CC
47658	960	24	unreal	unreal	JJ
47658	960	25	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	960	26	,	,	,
47658	960	27	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
47658	960	28	and	and	CC
47658	960	29	non	non	JJ
47658	960	30	-	-	JJ
47658	960	31	fulfilled	fulfilled	JJ
47658	960	32	beliefs	belief	NNS
47658	960	33	--	--	:
47658	960	34	yet	yet	CC
47658	960	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	960	36	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	960	37	to	to	TO
47658	960	38	run	run	VB
47658	960	39	counter	counter	RB
47658	960	40	to	to	IN
47658	960	41	all	all	PDT
47658	960	42	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	960	43	notions	notion	NNS
47658	960	44	of	of	IN
47658	960	45	the	the	DT
47658	960	46	extreme	extreme	JJ
47658	960	47	simplicity	simplicity	NN
47658	960	48	of	of	IN
47658	960	49	the	the	DT
47658	960	50	appeal	appeal	NN
47658	960	51	to	to	IN
47658	960	52	reality	reality	NN
47658	960	53	.	.	.
47658	961	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	961	2	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	961	3	strange	strange	JJ
47658	961	4	and	and	CC
47658	961	5	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
47658	961	6	to	to	IN
47658	961	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	961	8	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
47658	961	9	habit	habit	NN
47658	961	10	{	{	-LRB-
47658	961	11	87	87	CD
47658	961	12	}	}	-RRB-
47658	961	13	of	of	IN
47658	961	14	thinking	think	VBG
47658	961	15	to	to	TO
47658	961	16	affirm	affirm	VB
47658	961	17	that	that	IN
47658	961	18	there	there	EX
47658	961	19	are	be	VBP
47658	961	20	real	real	JJ
47658	961	21	things	thing	NNS
47658	961	22	and	and	CC
47658	961	23	real	real	JJ
47658	961	24	relations	relation	NNS
47658	961	25	between	between	IN
47658	961	26	things	thing	NNS
47658	961	27	which	which	WDT
47658	961	28	though	though	IN
47658	961	29	real	real	JJ
47658	961	30	yet	yet	RB
47658	961	31	do	do	VBP
47658	961	32	not	not	RB
47658	961	33	exist	exist	VB
47658	961	34	,	,	,
47658	961	35	and	and	CC
47658	961	36	also	also	RB
47658	961	37	that	that	DT
47658	961	38	non	non	JJ
47658	961	39	-	-	JJ
47658	961	40	existent	existent	JJ
47658	961	41	realities	reality	NNS
47658	961	42	are	be	VBP
47658	961	43	not	not	RB
47658	961	44	things	thing	NNS
47658	961	45	that	that	WDT
47658	961	46	once	once	RB
47658	961	47	were	be	VBD
47658	961	48	real	real	JJ
47658	961	49	but	but	CC
47658	961	50	now	now	RB
47658	961	51	are	be	VBP
47658	961	52	nought	nought	JJ
47658	961	53	--	--	:
47658	961	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	961	55	are	be	VBP
47658	961	56	things	thing	NNS
47658	961	57	that	that	WDT
47658	961	58	subsist	subsist	NN
47658	961	59	.	.	.
47658	962	1	Yet	yet	CC
47658	962	2	this	this	DT
47658	962	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	962	4	no	no	DT
47658	962	5	new	new	JJ
47658	962	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	962	7	.	.	.
47658	963	1	The	the	DT
47658	963	2	most	most	RBS
47658	963	3	familiar	familiar	JJ
47658	963	4	case	case	NN
47658	963	5	of	of	IN
47658	963	6	such	such	JJ
47658	963	7	realities	reality	NNS
47658	963	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	963	9	that	that	DT
47658	963	10	of	of	IN
47658	963	11	numbers	number	NNS
47658	963	12	.	.	.
47658	964	1	The	the	DT
47658	964	2	Greeks	Greeks	NNPS
47658	964	3	discovered	discover	VBD
47658	964	4	that	that	IN
47658	964	5	numbers	number	NNS
47658	964	6	do	do	VBP
47658	964	7	not	not	RB
47658	964	8	exist	exist	VB
47658	964	9	--	--	:
47658	964	10	that	that	DT
47658	964	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	964	12	to	to	TO
47658	964	13	say	say	VB
47658	964	14	,	,	,
47658	964	15	that	that	IN
47658	964	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	964	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	964	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	964	19	of	of	IN
47658	964	20	another	another	DT
47658	964	21	kind	kind	NN
47658	964	22	to	to	IN
47658	964	23	that	that	DT
47658	964	24	which	which	WDT
47658	964	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	964	26	denote	denote	VBP
47658	964	27	by	by	IN
47658	964	28	existence	existence	NN
47658	964	29	.	.	.
47658	965	1	Numbers	number	NNS
47658	965	2	are	be	VBP
47658	965	3	realities	reality	NNS
47658	965	4	,	,	,
47658	965	5	otherwise	otherwise	RB
47658	965	6	there	there	EX
47658	965	7	would	would	MD
47658	965	8	be	be	VB
47658	965	9	no	no	DT
47658	965	10	science	science	NN
47658	965	11	of	of	IN
47658	965	12	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
47658	965	13	.	.	.
47658	966	1	Pythagoras	Pythagoras	NNP
47658	966	2	(	(	-LRB-
47658	966	3	about	about	RB
47658	966	4	540	540	CD
47658	966	5	-	-	SYM
47658	966	6	500	500	CD
47658	966	7	B.C.	B.C.	NNP
47658	966	8	)	)	-RRB-
47658	967	1	taught	teach	VBD
47658	967	2	that	that	IN
47658	967	3	numbers	number	NNS
47658	967	4	are	be	VBP
47658	967	5	the	the	DT
47658	967	6	reality	reality	NN
47658	967	7	from	from	IN
47658	967	8	which	which	WDT
47658	967	9	all	all	DT
47658	967	10	else	else	RB
47658	967	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	967	12	derived	derive	VBN
47658	967	13	.	.	.
47658	968	1	And	and	CC
47658	968	2	there	there	EX
47658	968	3	are	be	VBP
47658	968	4	many	many	JJ
47658	968	5	other	other	JJ
47658	968	6	things	thing	NNS
47658	968	7	of	of	IN
47658	968	8	the	the	DT
47658	968	9	mind	mind	NN
47658	968	10	that	that	WDT
47658	968	11	seem	seem	VBP
47658	968	12	indeed	indeed	RB
47658	968	13	to	to	TO
47658	968	14	be	be	VB
47658	968	15	more	more	RBR
47658	968	16	real	real	JJ
47658	968	17	than	than	IN
47658	968	18	the	the	DT
47658	968	19	things	thing	NNS
47658	968	20	of	of	IN
47658	968	21	sense	sense	NN
47658	968	22	.	.	.
47658	969	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	969	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	969	3	this	this	DT
47658	969	4	very	very	JJ
47658	969	5	problem	problem	NN
47658	969	6	of	of	IN
47658	969	7	error	error	NN
47658	969	8	that	that	WDT
47658	969	9	brings	bring	VBZ
47658	969	10	into	into	IN
47658	969	11	relief	relief	NN
47658	969	12	this	this	DT
47658	969	13	most	most	RBS
47658	969	14	important	important	JJ
47658	969	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	969	16	.	.	.
47658	970	1	Now	now	RB
47658	970	2	let	let	VB
47658	970	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	970	4	apply	apply	VB
47658	970	5	this	this	DT
47658	970	6	theory	theory	NN
47658	970	7	of	of	IN
47658	970	8	the	the	DT
47658	970	9	supposition	supposition	NN
47658	970	10	to	to	IN
47658	970	11	the	the	DT
47658	970	12	problem	problem	NN
47658	970	13	of	of	IN
47658	970	14	error	error	NN
47658	970	15	,	,	,
47658	970	16	and	and	CC
47658	970	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	970	18	shall	shall	MD
47658	970	19	then	then	RB
47658	970	20	see	see	VB
47658	970	21	how	how	WRB
47658	970	22	there	there	EX
47658	970	23	can	can	MD
47658	970	24	be	be	VB
47658	970	25	an	an	DT
47658	970	26	object	object	NN
47658	970	27	present	present	JJ
47658	970	28	to	to	IN
47658	970	29	the	the	DT
47658	970	30	mind	mind	NN
47658	970	31	when	when	WRB
47658	970	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	970	33	judge	judge	VBP
47658	970	34	falsely	falsely	RB
47658	970	35	,	,	,
47658	970	36	and	and	CC
47658	970	37	also	also	RB
47658	970	38	that	that	IN
47658	970	39	the	the	DT
47658	970	40	object	object	NN
47658	970	41	is	be	VBZ
47658	970	42	the	the	DT
47658	970	43	same	same	JJ
47658	970	44	whether	whether	IN
47658	970	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	970	46	judge	judge	VBP
47658	970	47	truly	truly	RB
47658	970	48	or	or	CC
47658	970	49	falsely	falsely	RB
47658	970	50	.	.	.
47658	971	1	Suppositions	supposition	NNS
47658	971	2	are	be	VBP
47658	971	3	real	real	JJ
47658	971	4	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	971	5	;	;	:
47658	971	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	971	7	are	be	VBP
47658	971	8	alternatives	alternative	NNS
47658	971	9	that	that	WDT
47658	971	10	may	may	MD
47658	971	11	be	be	VB
47658	971	12	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
47658	971	13	or	or	CC
47658	971	14	that	that	WDT
47658	971	15	may	may	MD
47658	971	16	never	never	RB
47658	971	17	be	be	VB
47658	971	18	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
47658	971	19	.	.	.
47658	972	1	These	these	DT
47658	972	2	real	real	JJ
47658	972	3	possibilities	possibility	NNS
47658	972	4	,	,	,
47658	972	5	or	or	CC
47658	972	6	these	these	DT
47658	972	7	possible	possible	JJ
47658	972	8	alternatives	alternative	NNS
47658	972	9	,	,	,
47658	972	10	are	be	VBP
47658	972	11	objects	object	NNS
47658	972	12	of	of	IN
47658	972	13	thought	thought	NN
47658	972	14	;	;	:
47658	972	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	972	16	do	do	VBP
47658	972	17	not	not	RB
47658	972	18	belong	belong	VB
47658	972	19	to	to	IN
47658	972	20	the	the	DT
47658	972	21	mental	mental	JJ
47658	972	22	act	act	NN
47658	972	23	of	of	IN
47658	972	24	thinking	thinking	NN
47658	972	25	;	;	:
47658	972	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	972	27	are	be	VBP
47658	972	28	not	not	RB
47658	972	29	in	in	IN
47658	972	30	the	the	DT
47658	972	31	mind	mind	NN
47658	972	32	,	,	,
47658	972	33	but	but	CC
47658	972	34	realities	reality	NNS
47658	972	35	present	present	JJ
47658	972	36	to	to	IN
47658	972	37	the	the	DT
47658	972	38	mind	mind	NN
47658	972	39	.	.	.
47658	973	1	In	in	IN
47658	973	2	mere	mere	JJ
47658	973	3	supposing	supposing	NN
47658	973	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	973	5	are	be	VBP
47658	973	6	present	present	JJ
47658	973	7	as	as	IN
47658	973	8	alternatives	alternative	NNS
47658	973	9	;	;	:
47658	973	10	in	in	IN
47658	973	11	judging	judging	NN
47658	973	12	,	,	,
47658	973	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	973	14	affirm	affirm	VBP
47658	973	15	of	of	IN
47658	973	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	973	17	or	or	CC
47658	973	18	deny	deny	NN
47658	973	19	of	of	IN
47658	973	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	973	21	the	the	DT
47658	973	22	relation	relation	NN
47658	973	23	to	to	IN
47658	973	24	general	general	JJ
47658	973	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	973	26	that	that	IN
47658	973	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	973	28	are	be	VBP
47658	973	29	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
47658	973	30	.	.	.
47658	974	1	Judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	974	2	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	974	3	are	be	VBP
47658	974	4	true	true	JJ
47658	974	5	or	or	CC
47658	974	6	false	false	JJ
47658	974	7	accordingly	accordingly	RB
47658	974	8	as	as	IN
47658	974	9	the	the	DT
47658	974	10	fulfilment	fulfilment	NN
47658	974	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	974	12	affirm	affirm	VBP
47658	974	13	does	do	VBZ
47658	974	14	or	or	CC
47658	974	15	does	do	VBZ
47658	974	16	not	not	RB
47658	974	17	agree	agree	VB
47658	974	18	with	with	IN
47658	974	19	reality	reality	NN
47658	974	20	.	.	.
47658	975	1	In	in	IN
47658	975	2	this	this	DT
47658	975	3	way	way	NN
47658	975	4	,	,	,
47658	975	5	then	then	RB
47658	975	6	,	,	,
47658	975	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	975	8	may	may	MD
47658	975	9	answer	answer	VB
47658	975	10	the	the	DT
47658	975	11	perplexing	perplexing	NN
47658	975	12	question	question	NN
47658	975	13	,	,	,
47658	975	14	How	how	WRB
47658	975	15	can	can	MD
47658	975	16	there	there	EX
47658	975	17	be	be	VB
47658	975	18	an	an	DT
47658	975	19	object	object	NN
47658	975	20	of	of	IN
47658	975	21	thought	thought	NN
47658	975	22	in	in	IN
47658	975	23	a	a	DT
47658	975	24	false	false	JJ
47658	975	25	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	975	26	?	?	.
47658	976	1	The	the	DT
47658	976	2	answer	answer	NN
47658	976	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	976	4	,	,	,
47658	976	5	that	that	IN
47658	976	6	the	the	DT
47658	976	7	objects	object	NNS
47658	976	8	of	of	IN
47658	976	9	thought	thought	NN
47658	976	10	about	about	IN
47658	976	11	which	which	WDT
47658	976	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	976	13	make	make	VBP
47658	976	14	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	976	15	are	be	VBP
47658	976	16	suppositions	supposition	NNS
47658	976	17	,	,	,
47658	976	18	and	and	CC
47658	976	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	976	20	judgments	judgment	NNS
47658	976	21	{	{	-LRB-
47658	976	22	88	88	CD
47658	976	23	}	}	-RRB-
47658	976	24	concern	concern	VB
47658	976	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	976	26	fulfilment	fulfilment	NN
47658	976	27	,	,	,
47658	976	28	and	and	CC
47658	976	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	976	30	fulfilment	fulfilment	NN
47658	976	31	is	be	VBZ
47658	976	32	a	a	DT
47658	976	33	relation	relation	NN
47658	976	34	external	external	JJ
47658	976	35	to	to	IN
47658	976	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
47658	976	37	--	--	:
47658	976	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	976	39	is	be	VBZ
47658	976	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	976	41	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	976	42	or	or	CC
47658	976	43	disagreement	disagreement	NN
47658	976	44	with	with	IN
47658	976	45	reality	reality	NN
47658	976	46	.	.	.
47658	977	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
47658	977	2	IX	IX	NNP
47658	977	3	CONCLUSION	CONCLUSION	NNP
47658	977	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	977	5	will	will	MD
47658	977	6	now	now	RB
47658	977	7	briefly	briefly	RB
47658	977	8	sum	sum	VB
47658	977	9	up	up	RP
47658	977	10	the	the	DT
47658	977	11	argument	argument	NN
47658	977	12	of	of	IN
47658	977	13	this	this	DT
47658	977	14	book	book	NN
47658	977	15	.	.	.
47658	978	1	The	the	DT
47658	978	2	problem	problem	NN
47658	978	3	of	of	IN
47658	978	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	978	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	978	6	to	to	TO
47658	978	7	discover	discover	VB
47658	978	8	the	the	DT
47658	978	9	nature	nature	NN
47658	978	10	of	of	IN
47658	978	11	the	the	DT
47658	978	12	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	978	13	between	between	IN
47658	978	14	the	the	DT
47658	978	15	things	thing	NNS
47658	978	16	of	of	IN
47658	978	17	the	the	DT
47658	978	18	mind	mind	NN
47658	978	19	,	,	,
47658	978	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	978	21	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	978	22	,	,	,
47658	978	23	and	and	CC
47658	978	24	the	the	DT
47658	978	25	reality	reality	NN
47658	978	26	of	of	IN
47658	978	27	which	which	WDT
47658	978	28	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	978	29	are	be	VBP
47658	978	30	the	the	DT
47658	978	31	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	978	32	.	.	.
47658	979	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	979	2	call	call	VBP
47658	979	3	the	the	DT
47658	979	4	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	979	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	979	6	.	.	.
47658	980	1	What	what	WP
47658	980	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	980	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	980	4	?	?	.
47658	981	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	981	2	have	have	VBP
47658	981	3	seen	see	VBN
47658	981	4	that	that	IN
47658	981	5	there	there	EX
47658	981	6	are	be	VBP
47658	981	7	three	three	CD
47658	981	8	different	different	JJ
47658	981	9	answers	answer	NNS
47658	981	10	,	,	,
47658	981	11	namely--(1	namely--(1	LS
47658	981	12	)	)	-RRB-
47658	981	13	That	that	IN
47658	981	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	981	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	981	16	a	a	DT
47658	981	17	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	981	18	between	between	IN
47658	981	19	the	the	DT
47658	981	20	idea	idea	NN
47658	981	21	and	and	CC
47658	981	22	the	the	DT
47658	981	23	reality	reality	NN
47658	981	24	;	;	,
47658	981	25	(	(	-LRB-
47658	981	26	2	2	LS
47658	981	27	)	)	-RRB-
47658	981	28	That	that	IN
47658	981	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	981	30	is	be	VBZ
47658	981	31	the	the	DT
47658	981	32	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	981	33	of	of	IN
47658	981	34	the	the	DT
47658	981	35	idea	idea	NN
47658	981	36	in	in	IN
47658	981	37	a	a	DT
47658	981	38	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	981	39	and	and	CC
47658	981	40	harmonious	harmonious	JJ
47658	981	41	whole	whole	NN
47658	981	42	;	;	:
47658	981	43	and	and	CC
47658	981	44	(	(	-LRB-
47658	981	45	3	3	LS
47658	981	46	)	)	-RRB-
47658	981	47	That	that	IN
47658	981	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	981	49	is	be	VBZ
47658	981	50	a	a	DT
47658	981	51	value	value	NN
47658	981	52	that	that	WDT
47658	981	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	981	54	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
47658	981	55	give	give	VBP
47658	981	56	to	to	IN
47658	981	57	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	981	58	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	981	59	.	.	.
47658	982	1	The	the	DT
47658	982	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	982	3	that	that	IN
47658	982	4	truth	truth	NN
47658	982	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	982	6	correspondence	correspondence	NN
47658	982	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	982	8	found	find	VBD
47658	982	9	to	to	TO
47658	982	10	offer	offer	VB
47658	982	11	this	this	DT
47658	982	12	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	982	13	.	.	.
47658	983	1	To	to	TO
47658	983	2	say	say	VB
47658	983	3	of	of	IN
47658	983	4	an	an	DT
47658	983	5	idea	idea	NN
47658	983	6	that	that	IN
47658	983	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	983	8	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
47658	983	9	with	with	IN
47658	983	10	reality	reality	NN
47658	983	11	supposes	suppose	VBZ
47658	983	12	a	a	DT
47658	983	13	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	983	14	of	of	IN
47658	983	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	983	16	in	in	IN
47658	983	17	addition	addition	NN
47658	983	18	to	to	IN
47658	983	19	and	and	CC
47658	983	20	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	983	21	from	from	IN
47658	983	22	the	the	DT
47658	983	23	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	983	24	that	that	WDT
47658	983	25	is	be	VBZ
47658	983	26	the	the	DT
47658	983	27	idea	idea	NN
47658	983	28	,	,	,
47658	983	29	and	and	CC
47658	983	30	yet	yet	RB
47658	983	31	the	the	DT
47658	983	32	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	983	33	of	of	IN
47658	983	34	reality	reality	NN
47658	983	35	is	be	VBZ
47658	983	36	the	the	DT
47658	983	37	idea	idea	NN
47658	983	38	of	of	IN
47658	983	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	983	40	.	.	.
47658	984	1	And	and	CC
47658	984	2	if	if	IN
47658	984	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	984	4	be	be	VB
47658	984	5	said	say	VBN
47658	984	6	that	that	IN
47658	984	7	not	not	RB
47658	984	8	the	the	DT
47658	984	9	idea	idea	NN
47658	984	10	but	but	CC
47658	984	11	the	the	DT
47658	984	12	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	984	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	984	14	what	what	WP
47658	984	15	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
47658	984	16	with	with	IN
47658	984	17	reality	reality	NN
47658	984	18	in	in	IN
47658	984	19	truth	truth	NN
47658	984	20	,	,	,
47658	984	21	this	this	DT
47658	984	22	equally	equally	RB
47658	984	23	supposes	suppose	VBZ
47658	984	24	a	a	DT
47658	984	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	984	26	of	of	IN
47658	984	27	reality	reality	NN
47658	984	28	that	that	WDT
47658	984	29	is	be	VBZ
47658	984	30	not	not	RB
47658	984	31	a	a	DT
47658	984	32	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	984	33	.	.	.
47658	985	1	If	if	IN
47658	985	2	,	,	,
47658	985	3	as	as	IN
47658	985	4	the	the	DT
47658	985	5	common	common	JJ
47658	985	6	sense	sense	NN
47658	985	7	of	of	IN
47658	985	8	mankind	mankind	NN
47658	985	9	requires	require	VBZ
47658	985	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	985	11	to	to	TO
47658	985	12	believe	believe	VB
47658	985	13	,	,	,
47658	985	14	the	the	DT
47658	985	15	reality	reality	NN
47658	985	16	that	that	WDT
47658	985	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	985	18	known	know	VBN
47658	985	19	by	by	IN
47658	985	20	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	985	21	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	985	22	in	in	IN
47658	985	23	entire	entire	JJ
47658	985	24	independence	independence	NN
47658	985	25	of	of	IN
47658	985	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	985	27	relation	relation	NN
47658	985	28	of	of	IN
47658	985	29	knowing	know	VBG
47658	985	30	to	to	IN
47658	985	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	985	32	,	,	,
47658	985	33	how	how	WRB
47658	985	34	can	can	MD
47658	985	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	985	36	state	state	VB
47658	985	37	this	this	DT
47658	985	38	fact	fact	NN
47658	985	39	without	without	IN
47658	985	40	falling	fall	VBG
47658	985	41	into	into	IN
47658	985	42	contradiction	contradiction	NN
47658	985	43	in	in	IN
47658	985	44	the	the	DT
47658	985	45	very	very	JJ
47658	985	46	statement	statement	NN
47658	985	47	of	of	IN
47658	985	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	985	49	?	?	.
47658	986	1	This	this	DT
47658	986	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	986	3	the	the	DT
47658	986	4	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	986	5	of	of	IN
47658	986	6	a	a	DT
47658	986	7	realist	realist	NN
47658	986	8	theory	theory	NN
47658	986	9	of	of	IN
47658	986	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	986	11	.	.	.
47658	987	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	987	2	next	next	RB
47658	987	3	examined	examine	VBD
47658	987	4	the	the	DT
47658	987	5	theory	theory	NN
47658	987	6	that	that	IN
47658	987	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	987	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	987	9	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	987	10	,	,	,
47658	987	11	and	and	CC
47658	987	12	this	this	DT
47658	987	13	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	987	14	to	to	TO
47658	987	15	present	present	VB
47658	987	16	to	to	IN
47658	987	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	987	18	an	an	DT
47658	987	19	unattainable	unattainable	JJ
47658	987	20	ideal	ideal	NN
47658	987	21	.	.	.
47658	988	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	988	2	89	89	CD
47658	988	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	988	4	Only	only	RB
47658	988	5	the	the	DT
47658	988	6	whole	whole	JJ
47658	988	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	988	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	988	9	wholly	wholly	RB
47658	988	10	true	true	JJ
47658	988	11	.	.	.
47658	989	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	989	2	followed	follow	VBD
47658	989	3	the	the	DT
47658	989	4	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	989	5	argument	argument	NN
47658	989	6	on	on	IN
47658	989	7	which	which	WDT
47658	989	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	989	9	is	be	VBZ
47658	989	10	based	base	VBN
47658	989	11	,	,	,
47658	989	12	and	and	CC
47658	989	13	this	this	DT
47658	989	14	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	989	15	to	to	TO
47658	989	16	lead	lead	VB
47658	989	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	989	18	inevitably	inevitably	RB
47658	989	19	,	,	,
47658	989	20	in	in	IN
47658	989	21	the	the	DT
47658	989	22	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	989	23	of	of	IN
47658	989	24	the	the	DT
47658	989	25	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	989	26	,	,	,
47658	989	27	to	to	IN
47658	989	28	the	the	DT
47658	989	29	paradox	paradox	NN
47658	989	30	that	that	IN
47658	989	31	unless	unless	IN
47658	989	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	989	33	know	know	VBP
47658	989	34	everything	everything	NN
47658	989	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	989	36	know	know	VBP
47658	989	37	nothing	nothing	NN
47658	989	38	.	.	.
47658	990	1	In	in	IN
47658	990	2	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	990	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	990	4	met	meet	VBD
47658	990	5	a	a	DT
47658	990	6	new	new	JJ
47658	990	7	principle	principle	NN
47658	990	8	,	,	,
47658	990	9	the	the	DT
47658	990	10	proposal	proposal	NN
47658	990	11	to	to	TO
47658	990	12	regard	regard	VB
47658	990	13	truth	truth	NN
47658	990	14	as	as	IN
47658	990	15	a	a	DT
47658	990	16	value	value	NN
47658	990	17	.	.	.
47658	991	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	991	2	,	,	,
47658	991	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	991	4	is	be	VBZ
47658	991	5	said	say	VBN
47658	991	6	,	,	,
47658	991	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	991	8	something	something	NN
47658	991	9	that	that	WDT
47658	991	10	happens	happen	VBZ
47658	991	11	to	to	IN
47658	991	12	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	991	13	;	;	:
47658	991	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	991	15	become	become	VBP
47658	991	16	true	true	JJ
47658	991	17	,	,	,
47658	991	18	or	or	CC
47658	991	19	are	be	VBP
47658	991	20	made	make	VBN
47658	991	21	true	true	JJ
47658	991	22	.	.	.
47658	992	1	There	there	EX
47658	992	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	992	3	no	no	DT
47658	992	4	criterion	criterion	NN
47658	992	5	,	,	,
47658	992	6	no	no	DT
47658	992	7	absolute	absolute	JJ
47658	992	8	standard	standard	NN
47658	992	9	,	,	,
47658	992	10	independent	independent	JJ
47658	992	11	of	of	IN
47658	992	12	ideas	idea	NNS
47658	992	13	to	to	TO
47658	992	14	which	which	WDT
47658	992	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	992	16	must	must	MD
47658	992	17	conform	conform	VB
47658	992	18	if	if	IN
47658	992	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	992	20	are	be	VBP
47658	992	21	judged	judge	VBN
47658	992	22	to	to	TO
47658	992	23	be	be	VB
47658	992	24	true	true	JJ
47658	992	25	.	.	.
47658	993	1	The	the	DT
47658	993	2	value	value	NN
47658	993	3	of	of	IN
47658	993	4	an	an	DT
47658	993	5	idea	idea	NN
47658	993	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	993	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	993	8	practical	practical	JJ
47658	993	9	usefulness	usefulness	NN
47658	993	10	as	as	IN
47658	993	11	tested	test	VBN
47658	993	12	by	by	IN
47658	993	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	993	14	workability	workability	NN
47658	993	15	.	.	.
47658	994	1	Truth	truth	NN
47658	994	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	994	3	what	what	WP
47658	994	4	works	work	VBZ
47658	994	5	.	.	.
47658	995	1	This	this	DT
47658	995	2	led	lead	VBD
47658	995	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	995	4	to	to	TO
47658	995	5	criticise	criticise	VB
47658	995	6	the	the	DT
47658	995	7	concept	concept	NN
47658	995	8	of	of	IN
47658	995	9	utility	utility	NN
47658	995	10	.	.	.
47658	996	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	996	2	found	find	VBD
47658	996	3	that	that	IN
47658	996	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	996	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	996	6	impossible	impossible	JJ
47658	996	7	to	to	TO
47658	996	8	identify	identify	VB
47658	996	9	utility	utility	NN
47658	996	10	with	with	IN
47658	996	11	truth	truth	NN
47658	996	12	even	even	RB
47658	996	13	if	if	IN
47658	996	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	996	15	include	include	VBP
47658	996	16	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
47658	996	17	utility	utility	NN
47658	996	18	in	in	IN
47658	996	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	996	20	widest	wide	JJS
47658	996	21	meaning	meaning	NN
47658	996	22	,	,	,
47658	996	23	because	because	IN
47658	996	24	over	over	RB
47658	996	25	and	and	CC
47658	996	26	above	above	IN
47658	996	27	the	the	DT
47658	996	28	usefulness	usefulness	NN
47658	996	29	and	and	CC
47658	996	30	workability	workability	NN
47658	996	31	of	of	IN
47658	996	32	an	an	DT
47658	996	33	idea	idea	NN
47658	996	34	there	there	RB
47658	996	35	always	always	RB
47658	996	36	remains	remain	VBZ
47658	996	37	the	the	DT
47658	996	38	question	question	NN
47658	996	39	of	of	IN
47658	996	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	996	41	relation	relation	NN
47658	996	42	to	to	IN
47658	996	43	reality	reality	NN
47658	996	44	.	.	.
47658	997	1	But	but	CC
47658	997	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	997	3	recognised	recognise	VBD
47658	997	4	in	in	IN
47658	997	5	the	the	DT
47658	997	6	principle	principle	NN
47658	997	7	of	of	IN
47658	997	8	truth	truth	NN
47658	997	9	-	-	HYPH
47658	997	10	value	value	NN
47658	997	11	an	an	DT
47658	997	12	important	important	JJ
47658	997	13	advance	advance	NN
47658	997	14	towards	towards	IN
47658	997	15	a	a	DT
47658	997	16	theory	theory	NN
47658	997	17	of	of	IN
47658	997	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	997	19	.	.	.
47658	998	1	The	the	DT
47658	998	2	solution	solution	NN
47658	998	3	of	of	IN
47658	998	4	the	the	DT
47658	998	5	problem	problem	NN
47658	998	6	of	of	IN
47658	998	7	truth	truth	NN
47658	998	8	,	,	,
47658	998	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	998	10	became	become	VBD
47658	998	11	clear	clear	JJ
47658	998	12	,	,	,
47658	998	13	must	must	MD
47658	998	14	be	be	VB
47658	998	15	sought	seek	VBN
47658	998	16	in	in	IN
47658	998	17	a	a	DT
47658	998	18	theory	theory	NN
47658	998	19	of	of	IN
47658	998	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	998	21	.	.	.
47658	999	1	Have	have	VBP
47658	999	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	999	3	,	,	,
47658	999	4	in	in	IN
47658	999	5	the	the	DT
47658	999	6	new	new	JJ
47658	999	7	theory	theory	NN
47658	999	8	of	of	IN
47658	999	9	life	life	NN
47658	999	10	and	and	CC
47658	999	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	999	12	of	of	IN
47658	999	13	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	999	14	's	's	POS
47658	999	15	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	999	16	,	,	,
47658	999	17	an	an	DT
47658	999	18	answer	answer	NN
47658	999	19	to	to	IN
47658	999	20	the	the	DT
47658	999	21	question	question	NN
47658	999	22	,	,	,
47658	999	23	What	what	WP
47658	999	24	is	be	VBZ
47658	999	25	truth	truth	NN
47658	999	26	?	?	.
47658	1000	1	Yes	yes	UH
47658	1000	2	,	,	,
47658	1000	3	but	but	CC
47658	1000	4	not	not	RB
47658	1000	5	in	in	IN
47658	1000	6	the	the	DT
47658	1000	7	form	form	NN
47658	1000	8	of	of	IN
47658	1000	9	a	a	DT
47658	1000	10	direct	direct	JJ
47658	1000	11	solution	solution	NN
47658	1000	12	of	of	IN
47658	1000	13	the	the	DT
47658	1000	14	dilemma	dilemma	NN
47658	1000	15	which	which	WDT
47658	1000	16	confronts	confront	VBZ
47658	1000	17	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1000	18	in	in	IN
47658	1000	19	every	every	DT
47658	1000	20	theory	theory	NN
47658	1000	21	that	that	WDT
47658	1000	22	accepts	accept	VBZ
47658	1000	23	the	the	DT
47658	1000	24	independence	independence	NN
47658	1000	25	of	of	IN
47658	1000	26	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	1000	27	and	and	CC
47658	1000	28	reality	reality	NN
47658	1000	29	--	--	:
47658	1000	30	rather	rather	RB
47658	1000	31	in	in	IN
47658	1000	32	a	a	DT
47658	1000	33	theory	theory	NN
47658	1000	34	of	of	IN
47658	1000	35	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	1000	36	in	in	IN
47658	1000	37	which	which	WDT
47658	1000	38	the	the	DT
47658	1000	39	dilemma	dilemma	NN
47658	1000	40	does	do	VBZ
47658	1000	41	not	not	RB
47658	1000	42	and	and	CC
47658	1000	43	can	can	MD
47658	1000	44	not	not	RB
47658	1000	45	arise	arise	VB
47658	1000	46	.	.	.
47658	1001	1	The	the	DT
47658	1001	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	1001	3	of	of	IN
47658	1001	4	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	1001	5	is	be	VBZ
47658	1001	6	that	that	IN
47658	1001	7	in	in	IN
47658	1001	8	the	the	DT
47658	1001	9	intuition	intuition	NN
47658	1001	10	of	of	IN
47658	1001	11	life	life	NN
47658	1001	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1001	13	know	know	VBP
47658	1001	14	reality	reality	NN
47658	1001	15	as	as	IN
47658	1001	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1001	17	is	be	VBZ
47658	1001	18	,	,	,
47658	1001	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1001	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	1001	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	1001	22	one	one	CD
47658	1001	23	with	with	IN
47658	1001	24	our	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1001	25	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	1001	26	;	;	:
47658	1001	27	and	and	CC
47658	1001	28	in	in	IN
47658	1001	29	the	the	DT
47658	1001	30	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	1001	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1001	32	possess	possess	VBP
47658	1001	33	a	a	DT
47658	1001	34	mode	mode	NN
47658	1001	35	of	of	IN
47658	1001	36	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	1001	37	which	which	WDT
47658	1001	38	is	be	VBZ
47658	1001	39	equally	equally	RB
47658	1001	40	immediate	immediate	JJ
47658	1001	41	but	but	CC
47658	1001	42	the	the	DT
47658	1001	43	essential	essential	JJ
47658	1001	44	quality	quality	NN
47658	1001	45	of	of	IN
47658	1001	46	which	which	WDT
47658	1001	47	is	be	VBZ
47658	1001	48	that	that	IN
47658	1001	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1001	50	externalises	externalise	VBZ
47658	1001	51	or	or	CC
47658	1001	52	spatialises	spatialise	VBZ
47658	1001	53	reality	reality	NN
47658	1001	54	.	.	.
47658	1002	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1002	2	understand	understand	VBP
47658	1002	3	this	this	DT
47658	1002	4	mode	mode	NN
47658	1002	5	of	of	IN
47658	1002	6	knowing	know	VBG
47658	1002	7	in	in	RP
47658	1002	8	{	{	-LRB-
47658	1002	9	90	90	CD
47658	1002	10	}	}	-RRB-
47658	1002	11	recognising	recognise	VBG
47658	1002	12	the	the	DT
47658	1002	13	purpose	purpose	NN
47658	1002	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1002	15	serves	serve	VBZ
47658	1002	16	,	,	,
47658	1002	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1002	18	practical	practical	JJ
47658	1002	19	advantage	advantage	NN
47658	1002	20	to	to	IN
47658	1002	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1002	22	.	.	.
47658	1003	1	The	the	DT
47658	1003	2	theory	theory	NN
47658	1003	3	,	,	,
47658	1003	4	therefore	therefore	RB
47658	1003	5	,	,	,
47658	1003	6	resembles	resemble	VBZ
47658	1003	7	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	1003	8	in	in	IN
47658	1003	9	bringing	bring	VBG
47658	1003	10	the	the	DT
47658	1003	11	concept	concept	NN
47658	1003	12	of	of	IN
47658	1003	13	utility	utility	NN
47658	1003	14	to	to	IN
47658	1003	15	the	the	DT
47658	1003	16	aid	aid	NN
47658	1003	17	of	of	IN
47658	1003	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1003	19	theory	theory	NN
47658	1003	20	of	of	IN
47658	1003	21	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	1003	22	.	.	.
47658	1004	1	But	but	CC
47658	1004	2	,	,	,
47658	1004	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1004	4	insisted	insist	VBD
47658	1004	5	,	,	,
47658	1004	6	the	the	DT
47658	1004	7	resemblance	resemblance	NN
47658	1004	8	is	be	VBZ
47658	1004	9	outward	outward	JJ
47658	1004	10	only	only	RB
47658	1004	11	,	,	,
47658	1004	12	for	for	IN
47658	1004	13	the	the	DT
47658	1004	14	essential	essential	JJ
47658	1004	15	tenet	tenet	NN
47658	1004	16	of	of	IN
47658	1004	17	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	1004	18	,	,	,
47658	1004	19	that	that	DT
47658	1004	20	truth	truth	NN
47658	1004	21	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1004	22	is	be	VBZ
47658	1004	23	a	a	DT
47658	1004	24	value	value	NN
47658	1004	25	,	,	,
47658	1004	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	1004	27	fatal	fatal	JJ
47658	1004	28	to	to	IN
47658	1004	29	the	the	DT
47658	1004	30	theory	theory	NN
47658	1004	31	.	.	.
47658	1005	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1005	2	would	would	MD
47658	1005	3	mean	mean	VB
47658	1005	4	,	,	,
47658	1005	5	in	in	IN
47658	1005	6	fact	fact	NN
47658	1005	7	,	,	,
47658	1005	8	that	that	IN
47658	1005	9	not	not	RB
47658	1005	10	the	the	DT
47658	1005	11	mode	mode	NN
47658	1005	12	of	of	IN
47658	1005	13	knowing	knowing	NN
47658	1005	14	,	,	,
47658	1005	15	that	that	DT
47658	1005	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	1005	17	the	the	DT
47658	1005	18	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	1005	19	,	,	,
47658	1005	20	but	but	CC
47658	1005	21	the	the	DT
47658	1005	22	actual	actual	JJ
47658	1005	23	knowledge	knowledge	NN
47658	1005	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1005	25	,	,	,
47658	1005	26	is	be	VBZ
47658	1005	27	a	a	DT
47658	1005	28	practical	practical	JJ
47658	1005	29	endowment	endowment	NN
47658	1005	30	.	.	.
47658	1006	1	But	but	CC
47658	1006	2	the	the	DT
47658	1006	3	problem	problem	NN
47658	1006	4	of	of	IN
47658	1006	5	truth	truth	NN
47658	1006	6	arises	arise	VBZ
47658	1006	7	in	in	IN
47658	1006	8	a	a	DT
47658	1006	9	new	new	JJ
47658	1006	10	form	form	NN
47658	1006	11	,	,	,
47658	1006	12	for	for	IN
47658	1006	13	the	the	DT
47658	1006	14	practical	practical	JJ
47658	1006	15	utility	utility	NN
47658	1006	16	of	of	IN
47658	1006	17	the	the	DT
47658	1006	18	intellect	intellect	NN
47658	1006	19	consists	consist	VBZ
47658	1006	20	in	in	IN
47658	1006	21	the	the	DT
47658	1006	22	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	1006	23	which	which	WDT
47658	1006	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1006	25	produces	produce	VBZ
47658	1006	26	in	in	IN
47658	1006	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1006	28	.	.	.
47658	1007	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1007	2	makes	make	VBZ
47658	1007	3	the	the	DT
47658	1007	4	flowing	flow	VBG
47658	1007	5	reality	reality	NN
47658	1007	6	appear	appear	VBP
47658	1007	7	as	as	IN
47658	1007	8	fixed	fix	VBN
47658	1007	9	states	state	NNS
47658	1007	10	.	.	.
47658	1008	1	How	how	WRB
47658	1008	2	,	,	,
47658	1008	3	then	then	RB
47658	1008	4	,	,	,
47658	1008	5	can	can	MD
47658	1008	6	universal	universal	JJ
47658	1008	7	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	1008	8	be	be	VB
47658	1008	9	consistent	consistent	JJ
47658	1008	10	with	with	IN
47658	1008	11	the	the	DT
47658	1008	12	possession	possession	NN
47658	1008	13	of	of	IN
47658	1008	14	truth	truth	NN
47658	1008	15	?	?	.
47658	1009	1	To	to	TO
47658	1009	2	answer	answer	VB
47658	1009	3	this	this	DT
47658	1009	4	question	question	NN
47658	1009	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1009	6	examined	examine	VBD
47658	1009	7	the	the	DT
47658	1009	8	nature	nature	NN
47658	1009	9	of	of	IN
47658	1009	10	illusion	illusion	NN
47658	1009	11	and	and	CC
47658	1009	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1009	13	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	1009	14	from	from	IN
47658	1009	15	error	error	NN
47658	1009	16	.	.	.
47658	1010	1	In	in	IN
47658	1010	2	the	the	DT
47658	1010	3	last	last	JJ
47658	1010	4	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	1010	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1010	6	have	have	VBP
47658	1010	7	dealt	deal	VBN
47658	1010	8	with	with	IN
47658	1010	9	the	the	DT
47658	1010	10	problem	problem	NN
47658	1010	11	of	of	IN
47658	1010	12	error	error	NN
47658	1010	13	.	.	.
47658	1011	1	The	the	DT
47658	1011	2	fact	fact	NN
47658	1011	3	of	of	IN
47658	1011	4	error	error	NN
47658	1011	5	presented	present	VBD
47658	1011	6	a	a	DT
47658	1011	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
47658	1011	8	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	1011	9	from	from	IN
47658	1011	10	the	the	DT
47658	1011	11	question	question	NN
47658	1011	12	,	,	,
47658	1011	13	What	what	WP
47658	1011	14	is	be	VBZ
47658	1011	15	truth	truth	NN
47658	1011	16	?	?	.
47658	1012	1	for	for	IN
47658	1012	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1012	3	implied	imply	VBD
47658	1012	4	a	a	DT
47658	1012	5	real	real	JJ
47658	1012	6	object	object	NN
47658	1012	7	of	of	IN
47658	1012	8	thought	thought	NN
47658	1012	9	,	,	,
47658	1012	10	of	of	IN
47658	1012	11	which	which	WDT
47658	1012	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1012	13	seemed	seem	VBD
47658	1012	14	equally	equally	RB
47658	1012	15	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
47658	1012	16	to	to	TO
47658	1012	17	say	say	VB
47658	1012	18	that	that	IN
47658	1012	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1012	20	exists	exist	VBZ
47658	1012	21	and	and	CC
47658	1012	22	that	that	IN
47658	1012	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1012	24	does	do	VBZ
47658	1012	25	not	not	RB
47658	1012	26	exist	exist	VB
47658	1012	27	.	.	.
47658	1013	1	In	in	IN
47658	1013	2	the	the	DT
47658	1013	3	solutions	solution	NNS
47658	1013	4	that	that	WDT
47658	1013	5	have	have	VBP
47658	1013	6	been	be	VBN
47658	1013	7	proposed	propose	VBN
47658	1013	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1013	9	saw	see	VBD
47658	1013	10	how	how	WRB
47658	1013	11	the	the	DT
47658	1013	12	problem	problem	NN
47658	1013	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	1013	14	forcing	force	VBG
47658	1013	15	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
47658	1013	16	to	to	TO
47658	1013	17	examine	examine	VB
47658	1013	18	again	again	RB
47658	1013	19	the	the	DT
47658	1013	20	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	1013	21	processes	process	NNS
47658	1013	22	of	of	IN
47658	1013	23	the	the	DT
47658	1013	24	mind	mind	NN
47658	1013	25	and	and	CC
47658	1013	26	the	the	DT
47658	1013	27	nature	nature	NN
47658	1013	28	of	of	IN
47658	1013	29	the	the	DT
47658	1013	30	universe	universe	NN
47658	1013	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1013	32	reveal	reveal	VBP
47658	1013	33	.	.	.
47658	1014	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	1014	2	91	91	CD
47658	1014	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	1014	4	BIBLIOGRAPHY	BIBLIOGRAPHY	NNP
47658	1014	5	The	the	DT
47658	1014	6	_	_	NNP
47658	1014	7	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	1014	8	_	_	NNP
47658	1014	9	of	of	IN
47658	1014	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1014	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	1014	12	an	an	DT
47658	1014	13	exposition	exposition	NN
47658	1014	14	of	of	IN
47658	1014	15	the	the	DT
47658	1014	16	problem	problem	NN
47658	1014	17	of	of	IN
47658	1014	18	truth	truth	NN
47658	1014	19	and	and	CC
47658	1014	20	error	error	NN
47658	1014	21	as	as	IN
47658	1014	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1014	23	presented	present	VBD
47658	1014	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1014	25	in	in	IN
47658	1014	26	ancient	ancient	JJ
47658	1014	27	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	1014	28	.	.	.
47658	1015	1	The	the	DT
47658	1015	2	quotation	quotation	NN
47658	1015	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1015	4	have	have	VBP
47658	1015	5	made	make	VBN
47658	1015	6	from	from	IN
47658	1015	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1015	8	,	,	,
47658	1015	9	and	and	CC
47658	1015	10	also	also	RB
47658	1015	11	the	the	DT
47658	1015	12	quotations	quotation	NNS
47658	1015	13	from	from	IN
47658	1015	14	the	the	DT
47658	1015	15	_	_	NNP
47658	1015	16	Republic	Republic	NNP
47658	1015	17	_	_	NNP
47658	1015	18	,	,	,
47658	1015	19	are	be	VBP
47658	1015	20	from	from	IN
47658	1015	21	Jowett	Jowett	NNP
47658	1015	22	's	's	POS
47658	1015	23	translation	translation	NN
47658	1015	24	.	.	.
47658	1016	1	The	the	DT
47658	1016	2	most	most	RBS
47658	1016	3	clear	clear	JJ
47658	1016	4	exposition	exposition	NN
47658	1016	5	of	of	IN
47658	1016	6	what	what	WP
47658	1016	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1016	8	have	have	VBP
47658	1016	9	called	call	VBN
47658	1016	10	the	the	DT
47658	1016	11	realistic	realistic	JJ
47658	1016	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1016	13	is	be	VBZ
47658	1016	14	_	_	NNP
47658	1016	15	The	the	DT
47658	1016	16	Problems	Problems	NNPS
47658	1016	17	of	of	IN
47658	1016	18	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
47658	1016	19	_	_	NNP
47658	1016	20	,	,	,
47658	1016	21	by	by	IN
47658	1016	22	the	the	DT
47658	1016	23	Hon	Hon	NNP
47658	1016	24	.	.	.
47658	1017	1	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
47658	1017	2	Russell	Russell	NNP
47658	1017	3	,	,	,
47658	1017	4	in	in	IN
47658	1017	5	the	the	DT
47658	1017	6	Home	Home	NNP
47658	1017	7	University	University	NNP
47658	1017	8	Library	Library	NNP
47658	1017	9	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1017	10	Williams	Williams	NNP
47658	1017	11	and	and	CC
47658	1017	12	Norgate	Norgate	NNP
47658	1017	13	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1017	14	.	.	.
47658	1018	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1018	2	have	have	VBP
47658	1018	3	adopted	adopt	VBN
47658	1018	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
47658	1018	5	Russell	Russell	NNP
47658	1018	6	's	's	POS
47658	1018	7	terms	term	NNS
47658	1018	8	,	,	,
47658	1018	9	"	"	``
47658	1018	10	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
47658	1018	11	"	"	''
47658	1018	12	and	and	CC
47658	1018	13	"	"	``
47658	1018	14	description	description	NN
47658	1018	15	"	"	''
47658	1018	16	;	;	:
47658	1018	17	the	the	DT
47658	1018	18	distinction	distinction	NN
47658	1018	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1018	20	denote	denote	VBP
47658	1018	21	seems	seem	VBZ
47658	1018	22	to	to	IN
47658	1018	23	me	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1018	24	of	of	IN
47658	1018	25	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	1018	26	importance	importance	NN
47658	1018	27	,	,	,
47658	1018	28	and	and	CC
47658	1018	29	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
47658	1018	30	Russell	Russell	NNP
47658	1018	31	's	's	POS
47658	1018	32	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1018	33	on	on	IN
47658	1018	34	this	this	DT
47658	1018	35	point	point	NN
47658	1018	36	a	a	DT
47658	1018	37	permanent	permanent	JJ
47658	1018	38	addition	addition	NN
47658	1018	39	to	to	IN
47658	1018	40	philosophy	philosophy	NN
47658	1018	41	.	.	.
47658	1019	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
47658	1019	2	Russell	Russell	NNP
47658	1019	3	's	's	POS
47658	1019	4	theory	theory	NN
47658	1019	5	,	,	,
47658	1019	6	that	that	IN
47658	1019	7	in	in	IN
47658	1019	8	the	the	DT
47658	1019	9	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	1019	10	what	what	WP
47658	1019	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	1019	12	present	present	JJ
47658	1019	13	to	to	IN
47658	1019	14	the	the	DT
47658	1019	15	mind	mind	NN
47658	1019	16	is	be	VBZ
47658	1019	17	a	a	DT
47658	1019	18	relation	relation	NN
47658	1019	19	which	which	WDT
47658	1019	20	is	be	VBZ
47658	1019	21	external	external	JJ
47658	1019	22	to	to	IN
47658	1019	23	the	the	DT
47658	1019	24	terms	term	NNS
47658	1019	25	of	of	IN
47658	1019	26	the	the	DT
47658	1019	27	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	1019	28	,	,	,
47658	1019	29	and	and	CC
47658	1019	30	that	that	DT
47658	1019	31	agreement	agreement	NN
47658	1019	32	or	or	CC
47658	1019	33	disagreement	disagreement	NN
47658	1019	34	between	between	IN
47658	1019	35	this	this	DT
47658	1019	36	relation	relation	NN
47658	1019	37	and	and	CC
47658	1019	38	reality	reality	NN
47658	1019	39	makes	make	VBZ
47658	1019	40	the	the	DT
47658	1019	41	truth	truth	NN
47658	1019	42	or	or	CC
47658	1019	43	falsehood	falsehood	NN
47658	1019	44	of	of	IN
47658	1019	45	the	the	DT
47658	1019	46	judgment	judgment	NN
47658	1019	47	,	,	,
47658	1019	48	can	can	MD
47658	1019	49	only	only	RB
47658	1019	50	be	be	VB
47658	1019	51	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
47658	1019	52	if	if	IN
47658	1019	53	studied	study	VBN
47658	1019	54	in	in	IN
47658	1019	55	connection	connection	NN
47658	1019	56	with	with	IN
47658	1019	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1019	58	general	general	JJ
47658	1019	59	scheme	scheme	NN
47658	1019	60	.	.	.
47658	1020	1	The	the	DT
47658	1020	2	classical	classical	JJ
47658	1020	3	work	work	NN
47658	1020	4	on	on	IN
47658	1020	5	what	what	WP
47658	1020	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1020	7	have	have	VBP
47658	1020	8	called	call	VBN
47658	1020	9	the	the	DT
47658	1020	10	modern	modern	JJ
47658	1020	11	idealist	idealist	JJ
47658	1020	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1020	13	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1020	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1020	15	have	have	VBP
47658	1020	16	avoided	avoid	VBN
47658	1020	17	the	the	DT
47658	1020	18	word	word	NN
47658	1020	19	intellectualist	intellectualist	NN
47658	1020	20	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1020	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	1020	22	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
47658	1020	23	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1020	24	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1020	25	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
47658	1020	26	's	's	POS
47658	1020	27	_	_	NNP
47658	1020	28	Appearance	Appearance	NNP
47658	1020	29	and	and	CC
47658	1020	30	Reality	Reality	NNP
47658	1020	31	_	_	NNP
47658	1020	32	.	.	.
47658	1021	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1021	2	have	have	VBP
47658	1021	3	attempted	attempt	VBN
47658	1021	4	to	to	TO
47658	1021	5	give	give	VB
47658	1021	6	the	the	DT
47658	1021	7	main	main	JJ
47658	1021	8	lines	line	NNS
47658	1021	9	of	of	IN
47658	1021	10	the	the	DT
47658	1021	11	theory	theory	NN
47658	1021	12	in	in	IN
47658	1021	13	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1021	14	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	1021	15	on	on	IN
47658	1021	16	"	"	``
47658	1021	17	The	The	NNP
47658	1021	18	Absolute	Absolute	NNP
47658	1021	19	.	.	.
47658	1021	20	"	"	''
47658	1022	1	Although	although	IN
47658	1022	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1022	3	is	be	VBZ
47658	1022	4	a	a	DT
47658	1022	5	book	book	NN
47658	1022	6	for	for	IN
47658	1022	7	advanced	advanced	JJ
47658	1022	8	students	student	NNS
47658	1022	9	,	,	,
47658	1022	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1022	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	1022	12	not	not	RB
47658	1022	13	a	a	DT
47658	1022	14	closed	closed	JJ
47658	1022	15	volume	volume	NN
47658	1022	16	even	even	RB
47658	1022	17	to	to	IN
47658	1022	18	the	the	DT
47658	1022	19	uninstructed	uninstructed	JJ
47658	1022	20	.	.	.
47658	1023	1	The	the	DT
47658	1023	2	brilliant	brilliant	JJ
47658	1023	3	dialectical	dialectical	JJ
47658	1023	4	skill	skill	NN
47658	1023	5	of	of	IN
47658	1023	6	the	the	DT
47658	1023	7	{	{	-LRB-
47658	1023	8	92	92	CD
47658	1023	9	}	}	-RRB-
47658	1023	10	author	author	NN
47658	1023	11	is	be	VBZ
47658	1023	12	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
47658	1023	13	and	and	CC
47658	1023	14	may	may	MD
47658	1023	15	be	be	VB
47658	1023	16	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
47658	1023	17	by	by	IN
47658	1023	18	those	those	DT
47658	1023	19	who	who	WP
47658	1023	20	reject	reject	VBP
47658	1023	21	or	or	CC
47658	1023	22	may	may	MD
47658	1023	23	fail	fail	VB
47658	1023	24	to	to	TO
47658	1023	25	understand	understand	VB
47658	1023	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1023	27	conclusion	conclusion	NN
47658	1023	28	.	.	.
47658	1024	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
47658	1024	2	Harold	Harold	NNP
47658	1024	3	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1024	4	Joachim	Joachim	NNP
47658	1024	5	's	's	POS
47658	1024	6	_	_	NNP
47658	1024	7	The	the	DT
47658	1024	8	Nature	Nature	NNP
47658	1024	9	of	of	IN
47658	1024	10	Truth	Truth	NNP
47658	1024	11	_	_	NNP
47658	1024	12	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1024	13	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
47658	1024	14	,	,	,
47658	1024	15	Clarendon	Clarendon	NNP
47658	1024	16	Press	Press	NNP
47658	1024	17	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1024	18	is	be	VBZ
47658	1024	19	a	a	DT
47658	1024	20	most	most	RBS
47658	1024	21	able	able	JJ
47658	1024	22	and	and	CC
47658	1024	23	scholarly	scholarly	JJ
47658	1024	24	argument	argument	NN
47658	1024	25	for	for	IN
47658	1024	26	the	the	DT
47658	1024	27	coherence	coherence	NN
47658	1024	28	theory	theory	NN
47658	1024	29	of	of	IN
47658	1024	30	truth	truth	NN
47658	1024	31	.	.	.
47658	1025	1	The	the	DT
47658	1025	2	principal	principal	JJ
47658	1025	3	expositions	exposition	NNS
47658	1025	4	of	of	IN
47658	1025	5	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	1025	6	are	be	VBP
47658	1025	7	the	the	DT
47658	1025	8	works	work	NNS
47658	1025	9	of	of	IN
47658	1025	10	William	William	NNP
47658	1025	11	James	James	NNP
47658	1025	12	and	and	CC
47658	1025	13	of	of	IN
47658	1025	14	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	1025	15	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1025	16	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1025	17	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1025	18	Schiller	Schiller	NNP
47658	1025	19	.	.	.
47658	1026	1	William	William	NNP
47658	1026	2	James	James	NNP
47658	1026	3	'	'	POS
47658	1026	4	_	_	NNP
47658	1026	5	The	the	DT
47658	1026	6	Will	Will	NNP
47658	1026	7	to	to	TO
47658	1026	8	Believe	believe	VB
47658	1026	9	_	_	NNP
47658	1026	10	was	be	VBD
47658	1026	11	the	the	DT
47658	1026	12	first	first	JJ
47658	1026	13	distinct	distinct	JJ
47658	1026	14	formulation	formulation	NN
47658	1026	15	of	of	IN
47658	1026	16	the	the	DT
47658	1026	17	principle	principle	NN
47658	1026	18	.	.	.
47658	1027	1	_	_	NNP
47658	1027	2	Pragmatism	Pragmatism	NNP
47658	1027	3	,	,	,
47658	1027	4	a	a	DT
47658	1027	5	New	New	NNP
47658	1027	6	Name	Name	NNP
47658	1027	7	for	for	IN
47658	1027	8	some	some	DT
47658	1027	9	Old	Old	NNP
47658	1027	10	Ways	Ways	NNPS
47658	1027	11	of	of	IN
47658	1027	12	Thinking	Thinking	NNP
47658	1027	13	_	_	NNP
47658	1027	14	,	,	,
47658	1027	15	is	be	VBZ
47658	1027	16	the	the	DT
47658	1027	17	fullest	full	JJS
47658	1027	18	and	and	CC
47658	1027	19	most	most	RBS
47658	1027	20	systematic	systematic	JJ
47658	1027	21	statement	statement	NN
47658	1027	22	of	of	IN
47658	1027	23	the	the	DT
47658	1027	24	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1027	25	.	.	.
47658	1028	1	_	_	NNP
47658	1028	2	The	the	DT
47658	1028	3	Meaning	Meaning	NNP
47658	1028	4	of	of	IN
47658	1028	5	Truth	Truth	NNP
47658	1028	6	_	_	NNP
47658	1028	7	is	be	VBZ
47658	1028	8	a	a	DT
47658	1028	9	defence	defence	NN
47658	1028	10	of	of	IN
47658	1028	11	the	the	DT
47658	1028	12	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1028	13	against	against	IN
47658	1028	14	the	the	DT
47658	1028	15	criticism	criticism	NN
47658	1028	16	that	that	WDT
47658	1028	17	had	have	VBD
47658	1028	18	been	be	VBN
47658	1028	19	meted	mete	VBN
47658	1028	20	out	out	RP
47658	1028	21	to	to	IN
47658	1028	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1028	23	unsparingly	unsparingly	RB
47658	1028	24	.	.	.
47658	1029	1	All	all	DT
47658	1029	2	three	three	CD
47658	1029	3	books	book	NNS
47658	1029	4	are	be	VBP
47658	1029	5	published	publish	VBN
47658	1029	6	by	by	IN
47658	1029	7	Longmans	Longmans	NNPS
47658	1029	8	.	.	.
47658	1030	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	1030	2	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1030	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1030	4	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1030	5	Schiller	Schiller	NNP
47658	1030	6	is	be	VBZ
47658	1030	7	uncompromising	uncompromise	VBG
47658	1030	8	in	in	IN
47658	1030	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1030	10	advocacy	advocacy	NN
47658	1030	11	of	of	IN
47658	1030	12	a	a	DT
47658	1030	13	complete	complete	JJ
47658	1030	14	return	return	NN
47658	1030	15	to	to	IN
47658	1030	16	the	the	DT
47658	1030	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1030	18	taught	teach	VBN
47658	1030	19	in	in	IN
47658	1030	20	the	the	DT
47658	1030	21	ancient	ancient	JJ
47658	1030	22	world	world	NN
47658	1030	23	by	by	IN
47658	1030	24	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	1030	25	.	.	.
47658	1031	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1031	2	has	have	VBZ
47658	1031	3	defended	defend	VBN
47658	1031	4	that	that	DT
47658	1031	5	philosopher	philosopher	NN
47658	1031	6	against	against	IN
47658	1031	7	the	the	DT
47658	1031	8	arguments	argument	NNS
47658	1031	9	of	of	IN
47658	1031	10	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1031	11	in	in	IN
47658	1031	12	a	a	DT
47658	1031	13	polemical	polemical	JJ
47658	1031	14	pamphlet	pamphlet	NN
47658	1031	15	entitled	entitle	VBN
47658	1031	16	_	_	NNP
47658	1031	17	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1031	18	or	or	CC
47658	1031	19	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	1031	20	?	?	.
47658	1031	21	_	_	NNP
47658	1031	22	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1031	23	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
47658	1031	24	,	,	,
47658	1031	25	Blackwell	Blackwell	NNP
47658	1031	26	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1031	27	.	.	.
47658	1032	1	An	an	DT
47658	1032	2	Essay	essay	NN
47658	1032	3	on	on	IN
47658	1032	4	"	"	``
47658	1032	5	Axioms	axiom	NNS
47658	1032	6	as	as	IN
47658	1032	7	Postulates	Postulates	NNP
47658	1032	8	"	"	''
47658	1032	9	in	in	IN
47658	1032	10	_	_	NNP
47658	1032	11	Personal	Personal	NNP
47658	1032	12	Idealism	Idealism	NNP
47658	1032	13	_	_	NNP
47658	1032	14	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1032	15	Macmillan	Macmillan	NNP
47658	1032	16	&	&	CC
47658	1032	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
47658	1032	18	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1032	19	,	,	,
47658	1032	20	and	and	CC
47658	1032	21	two	two	CD
47658	1032	22	volumes	volume	NNS
47658	1032	23	of	of	IN
47658	1032	24	collected	collect	VBN
47658	1032	25	essays	essay	NNS
47658	1032	26	on	on	IN
47658	1032	27	_	_	NNP
47658	1032	28	Humanism	Humanism	NNP
47658	1032	29	_	_	NNP
47658	1032	30	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1032	31	Macmillan	Macmillan	NNP
47658	1032	32	&	&	CC
47658	1032	33	Co.	Co.	NNP
47658	1032	34	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1032	35	,	,	,
47658	1032	36	set	set	VBN
47658	1032	37	forth	forth	RP
47658	1032	38	the	the	DT
47658	1032	39	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1032	40	,	,	,
47658	1032	41	which	which	WDT
47658	1032	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1032	43	prefers	prefer	VBZ
47658	1032	44	to	to	TO
47658	1032	45	call	call	VB
47658	1032	46	Humanism	Humanism	NNP
47658	1032	47	,	,	,
47658	1032	48	with	with	IN
47658	1032	49	great	great	JJ
47658	1032	50	force	force	NN
47658	1032	51	,	,	,
47658	1032	52	abundant	abundant	JJ
47658	1032	53	illustration	illustration	NN
47658	1032	54	,	,	,
47658	1032	55	and	and	CC
47658	1032	56	the	the	DT
47658	1032	57	relief	relief	NN
47658	1032	58	of	of	IN
47658	1032	59	no	no	DT
47658	1032	60	small	small	JJ
47658	1032	61	amount	amount	NN
47658	1032	62	of	of	IN
47658	1032	63	humour	humour	NN
47658	1032	64	.	.	.
47658	1033	1	For	for	IN
47658	1033	2	an	an	DT
47658	1033	3	account	account	NN
47658	1033	4	of	of	IN
47658	1033	5	the	the	DT
47658	1033	6	theories	theory	NNS
47658	1033	7	of	of	IN
47658	1033	8	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	1033	9	,	,	,
47658	1033	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1033	11	may	may	MD
47658	1033	12	mention	mention	VB
47658	1033	13	my	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1033	14	own	own	JJ
47658	1033	15	little	little	JJ
47658	1033	16	book	book	NN
47658	1033	17	in	in	IN
47658	1033	18	this	this	DT
47658	1033	19	series	series	NN
47658	1033	20	,	,	,
47658	1033	21	_	_	NNP
47658	1033	22	Henri	Henri	NNP
47658	1033	23	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	1033	24	:	:	:
47658	1033	25	The	the	DT
47658	1033	26	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
47658	1033	27	of	of	IN
47658	1033	28	Change	Change	NNP
47658	1033	29	_	_	NNP
47658	1033	30	.	.	.
47658	1034	1	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1034	2	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	1034	3	's	's	POS
47658	1034	4	books	book	NNS
47658	1034	5	are	be	VBP
47658	1034	6	_	_	NNP
47658	1034	7	Time	Time	NNP
47658	1034	8	and	and	CC
47658	1034	9	Freewill	Freewill	NNP
47658	1034	10	_	_	NNP
47658	1034	11	,	,	,
47658	1034	12	_	_	NNP
47658	1034	13	Matter	Matter	NNP
47658	1034	14	and	and	CC
47658	1034	15	Memory	Memory	NNP
47658	1034	16	_	_	NNP
47658	1034	17	,	,	,
47658	1034	18	and	and	CC
47658	1034	19	_	_	NNP
47658	1034	20	Creative	Creative	NNP
47658	1034	21	Evolution	Evolution	NNP
47658	1034	22	_	_	NNP
47658	1034	23	.	.	.
47658	1035	1	To	to	IN
47658	1035	2	these	these	DT
47658	1035	3	has	have	VBZ
47658	1035	4	been	be	VBN
47658	1035	5	recently	recently	RB
47658	1035	6	added	add	VBN
47658	1035	7	_	_	NNP
47658	1035	8	An	an	DT
47658	1035	9	Introduction	introduction	NN
47658	1035	10	to	to	IN
47658	1035	11	Metaphysics	Metaphysics	NNP
47658	1035	12	_	_	NNP
47658	1035	13	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1035	14	Macmillan	Macmillan	NNP
47658	1035	15	,	,	,
47658	1035	16	1912	1912	CD
47658	1035	17	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1035	18	.	.	.
47658	1036	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1036	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	1036	3	the	the	DT
47658	1036	4	republication	republication	NN
47658	1036	5	in	in	IN
47658	1036	6	English	English	NNP
47658	1036	7	of	of	IN
47658	1036	8	an	an	DT
47658	1036	9	article	article	NN
47658	1036	10	written	write	VBN
47658	1036	11	in	in	IN
47658	1036	12	1903	1903	CD
47658	1036	13	,	,	,
47658	1036	14	which	which	WDT
47658	1036	15	has	have	VBZ
47658	1036	16	been	be	VBN
47658	1036	17	for	for	IN
47658	1036	18	a	a	DT
47658	1036	19	long	long	JJ
47658	1036	20	time	time	NN
47658	1036	21	out	out	IN
47658	1036	22	of	of	IN
47658	1036	23	print	print	NN
47658	1036	24	.	.	.
47658	1037	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1037	2	is	be	VBZ
47658	1037	3	a	a	DT
47658	1037	4	short	short	JJ
47658	1037	5	and	and	CC
47658	1037	6	clear	clear	JJ
47658	1037	7	statement	statement	NN
47658	1037	8	of	of	IN
47658	1037	9	the	the	DT
47658	1037	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
47658	1037	11	of	of	IN
47658	1037	12	Intuition	Intuition	NNP
47658	1037	13	.	.	.
47658	1038	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	1038	2	93	93	CD
47658	1038	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	1038	4	The	the	DT
47658	1038	5	important	important	JJ
47658	1038	6	studies	study	NNS
47658	1038	7	of	of	IN
47658	1038	8	Professor	Professor	NNP
47658	1038	9	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1038	10	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1038	11	Stout	Stout	NNP
47658	1038	12	are	be	VBP
47658	1038	13	not	not	RB
47658	1038	14	easily	easily	RB
47658	1038	15	accessible	accessible	JJ
47658	1038	16	to	to	IN
47658	1038	17	the	the	DT
47658	1038	18	general	general	JJ
47658	1038	19	reader	reader	NN
47658	1038	20	,	,	,
47658	1038	21	as	as	IN
47658	1038	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1038	23	consist	consist	VBP
47658	1038	24	in	in	IN
47658	1038	25	contributions	contribution	NNS
47658	1038	26	to	to	IN
47658	1038	27	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
47658	1038	28	journals	journal	NNS
47658	1038	29	and	and	CC
47658	1038	30	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
47658	1038	31	of	of	IN
47658	1038	32	learned	learn	VBN
47658	1038	33	societies	society	NNS
47658	1038	34	.	.	.
47658	1039	1	The	the	DT
47658	1039	2	essay	essay	NN
47658	1039	3	referred	refer	VBD
47658	1039	4	to	to	IN
47658	1039	5	in	in	IN
47658	1039	6	the	the	DT
47658	1039	7	last	last	JJ
47658	1039	8	chapter	chapter	NN
47658	1039	9	,	,	,
47658	1039	10	"	"	``
47658	1039	11	Some	some	DT
47658	1039	12	Fundamental	fundamental	JJ
47658	1039	13	Points	Points	NNPS
47658	1039	14	in	in	IN
47658	1039	15	the	the	DT
47658	1039	16	Theory	Theory	NNP
47658	1039	17	of	of	IN
47658	1039	18	Knowledge	Knowledge	NNP
47658	1039	19	,	,	,
47658	1039	20	"	"	''
47658	1039	21	is	be	VBZ
47658	1039	22	in	in	IN
47658	1039	23	the	the	DT
47658	1039	24	_	_	NNP
47658	1039	25	St.	St.	NNP
47658	1040	1	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
47658	1040	2	Quincentenary	Quincentenary	NNP
47658	1040	3	Publications	Publications	NNPS
47658	1040	4	_	_	NNP
47658	1040	5	,	,	,
47658	1040	6	1911	1911	CD
47658	1040	7	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1040	8	Maclehose	Maclehose	NNP
47658	1040	9	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1040	10	.	.	.
47658	1041	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
47658	1041	2	may	may	MD
47658	1041	3	mention	mention	VB
47658	1041	4	also	also	RB
47658	1041	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1041	6	essay	essay	NN
47658	1041	7	on	on	IN
47658	1041	8	"	"	``
47658	1041	9	Error	Error	NNP
47658	1041	10	"	"	''
47658	1041	11	in	in	IN
47658	1041	12	_	_	NNP
47658	1041	13	Personal	Personal	NNP
47658	1041	14	Idealism	Idealism	NNP
47658	1041	15	_	_	NNP
47658	1041	16	,	,	,
47658	1041	17	noticed	notice	VBN
47658	1041	18	above	above	RB
47658	1041	19	,	,	,
47658	1041	20	and	and	CC
47658	1041	21	"	"	``
47658	1041	22	The	the	DT
47658	1041	23	Object	object	NN
47658	1041	24	of	of	IN
47658	1041	25	Thought	Thought	NNP
47658	1041	26	and	and	CC
47658	1041	27	Real	Real	NNP
47658	1041	28	Being	being	NN
47658	1041	29	,	,	,
47658	1041	30	"	"	''
47658	1041	31	in	in	IN
47658	1041	32	_	_	NNP
47658	1041	33	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
47658	1041	34	of	of	IN
47658	1041	35	the	the	DT
47658	1041	36	Aristotelian	Aristotelian	NNP
47658	1041	37	Society	Society	NNP
47658	1041	38	_	_	NNP
47658	1041	39	,	,	,
47658	1041	40	1911	1911	CD
47658	1041	41	.	.	.
47658	1042	1	{	{	-LRB-
47658	1042	2	94	94	CD
47658	1042	3	}	}	-RRB-
47658	1042	4	INDEX	INDEX	NNP
47658	1042	5	NDX	NDX	NNP
47658	1042	6	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	1042	7	,	,	,
47658	1042	8	Mons	Mons	NNP
47658	1042	9	.	.	.
47658	1043	1	Henri	Henri	NNP
47658	1043	2	,	,	,
47658	1043	3	63	63	CD
47658	1043	4	,	,	,
47658	1043	5	69	69	CD
47658	1043	6	,	,	,
47658	1043	7	73	73	CD
47658	1043	8	,	,	,
47658	1043	9	89	89	CD
47658	1043	10	Berkeley	Berkeley	NNP
47658	1043	11	,	,	,
47658	1043	12	20	20	CD
47658	1043	13	,	,	,
47658	1043	14	32	32	CD
47658	1043	15	,	,	,
47658	1043	16	73	73	CD
47658	1043	17	Coherence	Coherence	NNP
47658	1043	18	Theory	Theory	NNP
47658	1043	19	,	,	,
47658	1043	20	25	25	CD
47658	1043	21	,	,	,
47658	1043	22	27	27	CD
47658	1043	23	Correspondence	Correspondence	NNP
47658	1043	24	Theory	Theory	NNP
47658	1043	25	,	,	,
47658	1043	26	24	24	CD
47658	1043	27	,	,	,
47658	1043	28	27	27	CD
47658	1043	29	Discovery	Discovery	NNP
47658	1043	30	of	of	IN
47658	1043	31	Planet	Planet	NNP
47658	1043	32	Neptune	Neptune	NNP
47658	1043	33	,	,	,
47658	1043	34	59	59	CD
47658	1043	35	Faith	faith	NN
47658	1043	36	-	-	HYPH
47658	1043	37	attitude	attitude	NN
47658	1043	38	of	of	IN
47658	1043	39	Pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
47658	1043	40	,	,	,
47658	1043	41	55	55	CD
47658	1043	42	Formal	Formal	NNP
47658	1043	43	Logic	Logic	NNP
47658	1043	44	,	,	,
47658	1043	45	10	10	CD
47658	1043	46	Hegel	Hegel	NNP
47658	1043	47	,	,	,
47658	1043	48	44	44	CD
47658	1043	49	Hume	Hume	NNP
47658	1043	50	,	,	,
47658	1043	51	30	30	CD
47658	1043	52	Intellectualism	intellectualism	NN
47658	1043	53	,	,	,
47658	1043	54	44	44	CD
47658	1043	55	James	James	NNP
47658	1043	56	,	,	,
47658	1043	57	William	William	NNP
47658	1043	58	,	,	,
47658	1043	59	44	44	CD
47658	1043	60	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	1043	61	,	,	,
47658	1043	62	26	26	CD
47658	1043	63	,	,	,
47658	1043	64	27	27	CD
47658	1043	65	,	,	,
47658	1043	66	42	42	CD
47658	1043	67	,	,	,
47658	1043	68	73	73	CD
47658	1043	69	Meinong	Meinong	NNP
47658	1043	70	,	,	,
47658	1043	71	84	84	CD
47658	1043	72	Pierce	Pierce	NNP
47658	1043	73	,	,	,
47658	1043	74	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1043	75	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1043	76	,	,	,
47658	1043	77	44	44	CD
47658	1043	78	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1043	79	,	,	,
47658	1043	80	11	11	CD
47658	1043	81	,	,	,
47658	1043	82	44	44	CD
47658	1043	83	,	,	,
47658	1043	84	67	67	CD
47658	1043	85	,	,	,
47658	1043	86	68	68	CD
47658	1043	87	,	,	,
47658	1043	88	74	74	CD
47658	1043	89	Pluralistic	pluralistic	JJ
47658	1043	90	Realism	realism	NN
47658	1043	91	,	,	,
47658	1043	92	24	24	CD
47658	1043	93	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
47658	1043	94	,	,	,
47658	1043	95	Henri	Henri	NNP
47658	1043	96	,	,	,
47658	1043	97	54	54	CD
47658	1043	98	Pragmatist	Pragmatist	NNP
47658	1043	99	Theory	Theory	NNP
47658	1043	100	of	of	IN
47658	1043	101	Truth	Truth	NNP
47658	1043	102	,	,	,
47658	1043	103	55	55	CD
47658	1043	104	Primary	Primary	NNP
47658	1043	105	Qualities	Qualities	NNPS
47658	1043	106	,	,	,
47658	1043	107	32	32	CD
47658	1043	108	Protagoras	Protagoras	NNP
47658	1043	109	,	,	,
47658	1043	110	His	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1043	111	book	book	NN
47658	1043	112	_	_	NNP
47658	1043	113	The	the	DT
47658	1043	114	Truth	Truth	NNP
47658	1043	115	_	_	NNP
47658	1043	116	,	,	,
47658	1043	117	10	10	CD
47658	1043	118	,	,	,
47658	1043	119	11	11	CD
47658	1043	120	;	;	:
47658	1043	121	His	-PRON-	PRP$
47658	1043	122	maxim	maxim	NN
47658	1043	123	,	,	,
47658	1043	124	44	44	CD
47658	1043	125	Pythagoras	Pythagoras	NNPS
47658	1043	126	,	,	,
47658	1043	127	87	87	CD
47658	1043	128	Relativity	Relativity	NNP
47658	1043	129	,	,	,
47658	1043	130	Principle	Principle	NNP
47658	1043	131	of	of	IN
47658	1043	132	,	,	,
47658	1043	133	48	48	CD
47658	1043	134	,	,	,
47658	1043	135	53	53	CD
47658	1043	136	,	,	,
47658	1043	137	62	62	CD
47658	1043	138	_	_	NNP
47658	1043	139	Republic	Republic	NNP
47658	1043	140	_	_	NNP
47658	1043	141	of	of	IN
47658	1043	142	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1043	143	,	,	,
47658	1043	144	67	67	CD
47658	1043	145	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1043	146	Anselm	Anselm	NNP
47658	1043	147	's	's	POS
47658	1043	148	Argument	argument	NN
47658	1043	149	,	,	,
47658	1043	150	29	29	CD
47658	1043	151	,	,	,
47658	1043	152	31	31	CD
47658	1043	153	,	,	,
47658	1043	154	41	41	CD
47658	1043	155	Schiller	Schiller	NNP
47658	1043	156	,	,	,
47658	1043	157	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
47658	1043	158	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1043	159	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1043	160	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1043	161	,	,	,
47658	1043	162	44	44	CD
47658	1043	163	Self	self	NN
47658	1043	164	,	,	,
47658	1043	165	The	the	DT
47658	1043	166	Idea	Idea	NNP
47658	1043	167	of	of	IN
47658	1043	168	,	,	,
47658	1043	169	36	36	CD
47658	1043	170	Socrates	socrate	NNS
47658	1043	171	,	,	,
47658	1043	172	11	11	CD
47658	1043	173	,	,	,
47658	1043	174	74	74	CD
47658	1043	175	Space	Space	NNP
47658	1043	176	and	and	CC
47658	1043	177	Time	Time	NNP
47658	1043	178	,	,	,
47658	1043	179	33	33	CD
47658	1043	180	,	,	,
47658	1043	181	34	34	CD
47658	1043	182	,	,	,
47658	1043	183	36	36	CD
47658	1043	184	Stout	Stout	NNP
47658	1043	185	,	,	,
47658	1043	186	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1043	187	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1043	188	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1043	189	,	,	,
47658	1043	190	84	84	CD
47658	1043	191	Theætetus	Theætetus	NNP
47658	1043	192	of	of	IN
47658	1043	193	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1043	194	,	,	,
47658	1043	195	11	11	CD
47658	1043	196	,	,	,
47658	1043	197	74	74	CD
47658	1043	198	Unknowable	Unknowable	NNP
47658	1043	199	,	,	,
47658	1043	200	The	the	DT
47658	1043	201	,	,	,
47658	1043	202	29	29	CD
47658	1043	203	,	,	,
47658	1043	204	37	37	CD
47658	1043	205	Zeno	Zeno	NNP
47658	1043	206	,	,	,
47658	1043	207	34	34	CD
47658	1043	208	ENDX	endx	NN
47658	1043	209	Printed	print	VBN
47658	1043	210	by	by	IN
47658	1043	211	BALLANTYNE	BALLANTYNE	NNP
47658	1043	212	,	,	,
47658	1043	213	HANSON	HANSON	NNP
47658	1043	214	&	&	CC
47658	1043	215	Co.	Co.	NNP
47658	1043	216	Edinburgh	Edinburgh	NNP
47658	1043	217	&	&	CC
47658	1043	218	London	London	NNP
47658	1043	219	*	*	NFP
47658	1043	220	*	*	NFP
47658	1043	221	*	*	NFP
47658	1043	222	*	*	NFP
47658	1043	223	*	*	NFP
47658	1043	224	THE	the	DT
47658	1043	225	PEOPLE	PEOPLE	NNS
47658	1043	226	'S	be	VBZ
47658	1043	227	BOOKS	BOOKS	NNP
47658	1043	228	THE	the	DT
47658	1043	229	FIRST	first	JJ
47658	1043	230	HUNDRED	hundred	CD
47658	1043	231	VOLUMES	volume	NNS
47658	1043	232	(	(	-LRB-
47658	1043	233	Spring	spring	NN
47658	1043	234	1913	1913	CD
47658	1043	235	)	)	-RRB-
47658	1043	236	SCIENCE	science	NN
47658	1043	237	1	1	CD
47658	1043	238	.	.	.
47658	1044	1	The	the	DT
47658	1044	2	Foundations	Foundations	NNPS
47658	1044	3	of	of	IN
47658	1044	4	Science	Science	NNP
47658	1044	5	.	.	.
47658	1045	1	.	.	.
47658	1046	1	.	.	.
47658	1047	1	By	by	IN
47658	1047	2	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1047	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1047	4	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1047	5	Whetham	Whetham	NNP
47658	1047	6	,	,	,
47658	1047	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1047	8	,	,	,
47658	1047	9	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
47658	1048	1	2	2	LS
47658	1048	2	.	.	.
47658	1049	1	Embryology	embryology	NN
47658	1049	2	--	--	:
47658	1049	3	The	the	DT
47658	1049	4	Beginnings	Beginnings	NNPS
47658	1049	5	of	of	IN
47658	1049	6	Life	life	NN
47658	1049	7	.	.	.
47658	1050	1	.	.	.
47658	1051	1	.	.	.
47658	1052	1	By	by	IN
47658	1052	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1052	3	Gerald	Gerald	NNP
47658	1052	4	Leighton	Leighton	NNP
47658	1052	5	,	,	,
47658	1052	6	M.D.	M.D.	NNP
47658	1053	1	3	3	LS
47658	1053	2	.	.	.
47658	1054	1	Biology	biology	NN
47658	1054	2	.	.	.
47658	1055	1	.	.	.
47658	1056	1	.	.	.
47658	1057	1	By	by	IN
47658	1057	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1057	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1057	4	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1057	5	Henderson	Henderson	NNP
47658	1057	6	,	,	,
47658	1057	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1058	1	4	4	LS
47658	1058	2	.	.	.
47658	1059	1	Zoology	zoology	NN
47658	1059	2	:	:	:
47658	1059	3	The	the	DT
47658	1059	4	Study	Study	NNP
47658	1059	5	of	of	IN
47658	1059	6	Animal	Animal	NNP
47658	1059	7	Life	Life	NNP
47658	1059	8	.	.	.
47658	1060	1	.	.	.
47658	1061	1	.	.	.
47658	1062	1	By	by	IN
47658	1062	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1062	3	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1062	4	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1062	5	MacBride	MacBride	NNP
47658	1062	6	,	,	,
47658	1062	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1062	8	,	,	,
47658	1062	9	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
47658	1063	1	5	5	CD
47658	1063	2	.	.	.
47658	1064	1	Botany	botany	VB
47658	1064	2	;	;	:
47658	1064	3	The	the	DT
47658	1064	4	Modern	Modern	NNP
47658	1064	5	Study	Study	NNP
47658	1064	6	of	of	IN
47658	1064	7	Plants	Plants	NNPS
47658	1064	8	.	.	.
47658	1065	1	.	.	.
47658	1066	1	.	.	.
47658	1067	1	By	by	IN
47658	1067	2	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1067	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1067	4	Stopes	Stopes	NNP
47658	1067	5	,	,	,
47658	1067	6	D.Sc	D.Sc	NNP
47658	1067	7	.	.	NNP
47658	1067	8	,	,	,
47658	1067	9	Ph.D.	Ph.D.	NNP
47658	1067	10	,	,	,
47658	1067	11	F.L.S.	F.L.S.	NNP
47658	1068	1	7	7	LS
47658	1068	2	.	.	.
47658	1069	1	The	the	DT
47658	1069	2	Structure	structure	NN
47658	1069	3	of	of	IN
47658	1069	4	the	the	DT
47658	1069	5	Earth	Earth	NNP
47658	1069	6	.	.	.
47658	1070	1	.	.	.
47658	1071	1	.	.	.
47658	1072	1	By	by	IN
47658	1072	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1072	3	T.	T.	NNP
47658	1072	4	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1072	5	Bonney	Bonney	NNP
47658	1072	6	,	,	,
47658	1072	7	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
47658	1073	1	8	8	LS
47658	1073	2	.	.	.
47658	1074	1	Evolution	evolution	NN
47658	1074	2	.	.	.
47658	1075	1	.	.	.
47658	1076	1	.	.	.
47658	1077	1	By	by	IN
47658	1077	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1077	3	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1077	4	Goodrich	Goodrich	NNP
47658	1077	5	,	,	,
47658	1077	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1077	7	,	,	,
47658	1077	8	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
47658	1078	1	10	10	CD
47658	1078	2	.	.	.
47658	1079	1	Heredity	heredity	NN
47658	1079	2	.	.	.
47658	1080	1	.	.	.
47658	1081	1	.	.	.
47658	1082	1	By	by	IN
47658	1082	2	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1083	1	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1083	2	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1083	3	Watson	Watson	NNP
47658	1083	4	,	,	,
47658	1083	5	B.Sc	B.Sc	NNP
47658	1083	6	.	.	.
47658	1084	1	11	11	CD
47658	1084	2	.	.	.
47658	1085	1	Inorganic	Inorganic	NNP
47658	1085	2	Chemistry	Chemistry	NNP
47658	1085	3	.	.	.
47658	1086	1	.	.	.
47658	1087	1	.	.	.
47658	1088	1	By	by	IN
47658	1088	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1088	3	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1088	4	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1088	5	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1088	6	Baly	Baly	NNP
47658	1088	7	,	,	,
47658	1088	8	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
47658	1089	1	12	12	CD
47658	1089	2	.	.	.
47658	1090	1	Organic	organic	JJ
47658	1090	2	Chemistry	Chemistry	NNP
47658	1090	3	.	.	.
47658	1091	1	.	.	.
47658	1092	1	.	.	.
47658	1093	1	By	by	IN
47658	1093	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1093	3	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1094	1	B.	B.	NNP
47658	1094	2	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
47658	1094	3	,	,	,
47658	1094	4	B.Sc	B.Sc	NNP
47658	1094	5	.	.	NNP
47658	1094	6	,	,	,
47658	1094	7	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
47658	1095	1	13	13	CD
47658	1095	2	.	.	.
47658	1096	1	The	the	DT
47658	1096	2	Principles	principle	NNS
47658	1096	3	of	of	IN
47658	1096	4	Electricity	Electricity	NNP
47658	1096	5	.	.	.
47658	1097	1	.	.	.
47658	1098	1	.	.	.
47658	1099	1	By	by	IN
47658	1099	2	Norman	Norman	NNP
47658	1099	3	K.	K.	NNP
47658	1099	4	Campbell	Campbell	NNP
47658	1099	5	,	,	,
47658	1099	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1100	1	14	14	CD
47658	1100	2	.	.	.
47658	1101	1	Radiation	radiation	NN
47658	1101	2	.	.	.
47658	1102	1	.	.	.
47658	1103	1	.	.	.
47658	1104	1	By	by	IN
47658	1104	2	P.	P.	NNP
47658	1104	3	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
47658	1104	4	,	,	,
47658	1104	5	D.Sc	D.Sc	NNP
47658	1104	6	.	.	.
47658	1105	1	15	15	CD
47658	1105	2	.	.	.
47658	1106	1	The	the	DT
47658	1106	2	Science	Science	NNP
47658	1106	3	of	of	IN
47658	1106	4	the	the	DT
47658	1106	5	Stars	star	NNS
47658	1106	6	.	.	.
47658	1107	1	.	.	.
47658	1108	1	.	.	.
47658	1109	1	By	by	IN
47658	1109	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1109	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1109	4	Maunder	Maunder	NNP
47658	1109	5	,	,	,
47658	1109	6	F.R.A.S.	F.R.A.S.	NNP
47658	1110	1	16	16	CD
47658	1110	2	.	.	.
47658	1111	1	The	the	DT
47658	1111	2	Science	Science	NNP
47658	1111	3	of	of	IN
47658	1111	4	Light	Light	NNP
47658	1111	5	.	.	.
47658	1112	1	.	.	.
47658	1113	1	.	.	.
47658	1114	1	By	by	IN
47658	1114	2	P.	P.	NNP
47658	1114	3	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
47658	1114	4	,	,	,
47658	1114	5	D.Sc	D.Sc	NNP
47658	1114	6	.	.	.
47658	1115	1	17	17	CD
47658	1115	2	.	.	.
47658	1116	1	Weather	weather	NN
47658	1116	2	Science	Science	NNP
47658	1116	3	.	.	.
47658	1117	1	.	.	.
47658	1118	1	.	.	.
47658	1119	1	By	by	IN
47658	1119	2	R.	R.	NNP
47658	1119	3	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1119	4	K.	K.	NNP
47658	1119	5	Lempfert	Lempfert	NNP
47658	1119	6	,	,	,
47658	1119	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1120	1	18	18	CD
47658	1120	2	.	.	.
47658	1121	1	Hypnotism	Hypnotism	NNP
47658	1121	2	and	and	CC
47658	1121	3	Self	Self	NNP
47658	1121	4	-	-	HYPH
47658	1121	5	Education	Education	NNP
47658	1121	6	.	.	.
47658	1122	1	.	.	.
47658	1123	1	.	.	.
47658	1124	1	By	by	IN
47658	1124	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1124	3	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1124	4	Hutchison	Hutchison	NNP
47658	1124	5	,	,	,
47658	1124	6	M.D.	M.D.	NNP
47658	1125	1	19	19	CD
47658	1125	2	.	.	.
47658	1126	1	The	the	DT
47658	1126	2	Baby	baby	NN
47658	1126	3	:	:	:
47658	1126	4	A	A	NNP
47658	1126	5	Mother	Mother	NNP
47658	1126	6	's	's	POS
47658	1126	7	Book	Book	NNP
47658	1126	8	.	.	.
47658	1127	1	.	.	.
47658	1128	1	.	.	.
47658	1129	1	By	by	IN
47658	1129	2	a	a	DT
47658	1129	3	University	University	NNP
47658	1129	4	Woman	Woman	NNP
47658	1129	5	.	.	.
47658	1130	1	20	20	CD
47658	1130	2	.	.	.
47658	1131	1	Youth	youth	NN
47658	1131	2	and	and	CC
47658	1131	3	Sex	sex	NN
47658	1131	4	--	--	:
47658	1131	5	Dangers	danger	NNS
47658	1131	6	and	and	CC
47658	1131	7	Safeguards	Safeguards	NNPS
47658	1131	8	for	for	IN
47658	1131	9	Boys	Boys	NNPS
47658	1131	10	and	and	CC
47658	1131	11	Girls	Girls	NNPS
47658	1131	12	.	.	.
47658	1132	1	.	.	.
47658	1133	1	.	.	.
47658	1134	1	By	by	IN
47658	1134	2	Mary	Mary	NNP
47658	1134	3	Scharlieb	Scharlieb	NNP
47658	1134	4	,	,	,
47658	1134	5	M.D.	M.D.	NNP
47658	1134	6	,	,	,
47658	1134	7	M.S.	M.S.	NNP
47658	1134	8	,	,	,
47658	1134	9	and	and	CC
47658	1134	10	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1134	11	Arthur	Arthur	NNP
47658	1134	12	Sibly	Sibly	NNP
47658	1134	13	,	,	,
47658	1134	14	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1134	15	,	,	,
47658	1134	16	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
47658	1135	1	21	21	CD
47658	1135	2	.	.	.
47658	1136	1	Marriage	marriage	NN
47658	1136	2	and	and	CC
47658	1136	3	Motherhood	Motherhood	NNP
47658	1136	4	.	.	.
47658	1137	1	.	.	.
47658	1138	1	.	.	.
47658	1139	1	By	by	IN
47658	1139	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1139	3	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1139	4	Davidson	Davidson	NNP
47658	1139	5	,	,	,
47658	1139	6	M.B.	M.B.	NNP
47658	1139	7	,	,	,
47658	1139	8	F.R.C.S.E.	f.r.c.s.e.	ADD
47658	1140	1	22	22	CD
47658	1140	2	.	.	.
47658	1141	1	Lord	Lord	NNP
47658	1141	2	Kelvin	Kelvin	NNP
47658	1141	3	.	.	.
47658	1142	1	.	.	.
47658	1143	1	.	.	.
47658	1144	1	By	by	IN
47658	1144	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1144	3	Russell	Russell	NNP
47658	1144	4	,	,	,
47658	1144	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1144	6	,	,	,
47658	1144	7	D.Sc	D.Sc	NNP
47658	1144	8	.	.	NNP
47658	1144	9	,	,	,
47658	1144	10	M.I.E.E.	M.I.E.E.	NNP
47658	1145	1	23	23	CD
47658	1145	2	.	.	.
47658	1146	1	Huxley	Huxley	NNP
47658	1146	2	.	.	.
47658	1147	1	.	.	.
47658	1148	1	.	.	.
47658	1149	1	By	by	IN
47658	1149	2	Professor	Professor	NNP
47658	1149	3	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1149	4	Leighton	Leighton	NNP
47658	1149	5	,	,	,
47658	1149	6	M.D.	M.D.	NNP
47658	1150	1	24	24	CD
47658	1150	2	.	.	.
47658	1151	1	Sir	Sir	NNP
47658	1151	2	William	William	NNP
47658	1151	3	Huggins	Huggins	NNP
47658	1151	4	and	and	CC
47658	1151	5	Spectroscopic	Spectroscopic	NNP
47658	1151	6	Astronomy	Astronomy	NNP
47658	1151	7	.	.	.
47658	1152	1	.	.	.
47658	1153	1	.	.	.
47658	1154	1	By	by	IN
47658	1154	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1154	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1154	4	Maunder	Maunder	NNP
47658	1154	5	,	,	,
47658	1154	6	F.R.A.S.	F.R.A.S.	NNP
47658	1154	7	,	,	,
47658	1154	8	of	of	IN
47658	1154	9	the	the	DT
47658	1154	10	Royal	Royal	NNP
47658	1154	11	Observatory	Observatory	NNP
47658	1154	12	,	,	,
47658	1154	13	Greenwich	Greenwich	NNP
47658	1154	14	.	.	.
47658	1155	1	62	62	CD
47658	1155	2	.	.	.
47658	1156	1	Practical	Practical	NNP
47658	1156	2	Astronomy	Astronomy	NNP
47658	1156	3	.	.	.
47658	1157	1	.	.	.
47658	1158	1	.	.	.
47658	1159	1	By	by	IN
47658	1159	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1159	3	Macpherson	Macpherson	NNP
47658	1159	4	,	,	,
47658	1159	5	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
47658	1159	6	,	,	,
47658	1159	7	F.R.A.S.	F.R.A.S.	NNP
47658	1160	1	63	63	CD
47658	1160	2	.	.	.
47658	1161	1	Aviation	aviation	NN
47658	1161	2	.	.	.
47658	1162	1	.	.	.
47658	1163	1	.	.	.
47658	1164	1	By	by	IN
47658	1164	2	Sydney	Sydney	NNP
47658	1164	3	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1164	4	Walker	Walker	NNP
47658	1164	5	,	,	,
47658	1164	6	R.N.	R.N.	NNP
47658	1165	1	64	64	CD
47658	1165	2	.	.	.
47658	1166	1	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
47658	1166	2	.	.	.
47658	1167	1	.	.	.
47658	1168	1	.	.	.
47658	1169	1	By	by	IN
47658	1169	2	William	William	NNP
47658	1169	3	Hall	Hall	NNP
47658	1169	4	,	,	,
47658	1169	5	R.N.	R.N.	NNP
47658	1169	6	,	,	,
47658	1169	7	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1170	1	65	65	CD
47658	1170	2	.	.	.
47658	1171	1	Pond	Pond	NNP
47658	1171	2	Life	Life	NNP
47658	1171	3	.	.	.
47658	1172	1	.	.	.
47658	1173	1	.	.	.
47658	1174	1	By	by	IN
47658	1174	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1174	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1174	4	Ash	Ash	NNP
47658	1174	5	,	,	,
47658	1174	6	M.R.A.C.	M.R.A.C.	NNP
47658	1175	1	66	66	CD
47658	1175	2	.	.	.
47658	1176	1	Dietetics	dietetic	NNS
47658	1176	2	.	.	.
47658	1177	1	.	.	.
47658	1178	1	.	.	.
47658	1179	1	By	by	IN
47658	1179	2	Alex	Alex	NNP
47658	1179	3	.	.	.
47658	1180	1	Bryce	Bryce	NNP
47658	1180	2	,	,	,
47658	1180	3	M.D.	M.D.	NNP
47658	1180	4	,	,	,
47658	1180	5	D.P.H.	D.P.H.	NNP
47658	1181	1	94	94	CD
47658	1181	2	.	.	.
47658	1182	1	The	the	DT
47658	1182	2	Nature	Nature	NNP
47658	1182	3	of	of	IN
47658	1182	4	Mathematics	Mathematics	NNP
47658	1182	5	.	.	.
47658	1183	1	.	.	.
47658	1184	1	.	.	.
47658	1185	1	By	by	IN
47658	1185	2	P.	P.	NNP
47658	1185	3	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1185	4	B.	B.	NNP
47658	1185	5	Jourdain	Jourdain	NNP
47658	1185	6	,	,	,
47658	1185	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1186	1	95	95	CD
47658	1186	2	.	.	.
47658	1187	1	Applications	application	NNS
47658	1187	2	of	of	IN
47658	1187	3	Electricity	Electricity	NNP
47658	1187	4	.	.	.
47658	1188	1	.	.	.
47658	1189	1	.	.	.
47658	1190	1	By	by	IN
47658	1190	2	Alex	Alex	NNP
47658	1190	3	.	.	.
47658	1191	1	Ogilvie	Ogilvie	NNP
47658	1191	2	,	,	,
47658	1191	3	B.Sc	B.Sc	NNP
47658	1191	4	.	.	.
47658	1192	1	96	96	CD
47658	1192	2	.	.	.
47658	1193	1	Gardening	garden	VBG
47658	1193	2	.	.	.
47658	1194	1	.	.	.
47658	1195	1	.	.	.
47658	1196	1	By	by	IN
47658	1196	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1196	3	Cecil	Cecil	NNP
47658	1196	4	Bartlett	Bartlett	NNP
47658	1196	5	.	.	.
47658	1197	1	97	97	CD
47658	1197	2	.	.	.
47658	1198	1	The	the	DT
47658	1198	2	Care	care	NN
47658	1198	3	of	of	IN
47658	1198	4	the	the	DT
47658	1198	5	Teeth	Teeth	NNP
47658	1198	6	.	.	.
47658	1199	1	.	.	.
47658	1200	1	.	.	.
47658	1201	1	By	by	IN
47658	1201	2	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1202	1	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1203	1	Young	young	JJ
47658	1203	2	,	,	,
47658	1203	3	L.D.S.	L.D.S.	NNP
47658	1204	1	98	98	CD
47658	1204	2	.	.	.
47658	1205	1	Atlas	Atlas	NNP
47658	1205	2	of	of	IN
47658	1205	3	the	the	DT
47658	1205	4	World	World	NNP
47658	1205	5	.	.	.
47658	1206	1	.	.	.
47658	1207	1	.	.	.
47658	1208	1	By	by	IN
47658	1208	2	T.	T.	NNP
47658	1208	3	Bartholomew	Bartholomew	NNP
47658	1208	4	,	,	,
47658	1208	5	F.R.G.S.	F.R.G.S.	NNP
47658	1209	1	110	110	CD
47658	1209	2	.	.	.
47658	1210	1	British	british	JJ
47658	1210	2	Birds	Birds	NNPS
47658	1210	3	.	.	.
47658	1211	1	.	.	.
47658	1212	1	.	.	.
47658	1213	1	By	by	IN
47658	1213	2	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1213	3	B	B	NNP
47658	1213	4	Kirkman	Kirkman	NNP
47658	1213	5	,	,	,
47658	1213	6	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1214	1	PHILOSOPHY	PHILOSOPHY	NNS
47658	1214	2	AND	and	CC
47658	1214	3	RELIGION	religion	VB
47658	1214	4	25	25	CD
47658	1214	5	.	.	.
47658	1215	1	The	the	DT
47658	1215	2	Meaning	Meaning	NNP
47658	1215	3	of	of	IN
47658	1215	4	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
47658	1215	5	.	.	.
47658	1216	1	.	.	.
47658	1217	1	.	.	.
47658	1218	1	By	by	IN
47658	1218	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1218	3	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1218	4	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1218	5	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
47658	1218	6	,	,	,
47658	1218	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1218	8	,	,	,
47658	1218	9	F.B.A.	F.B.A.	NNP
47658	1219	1	26	26	CD
47658	1219	2	.	.	.
47658	1220	1	Henri	Henri	NNP
47658	1220	2	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
47658	1220	3	.	.	.
47658	1221	1	.	.	.
47658	1222	1	.	.	.
47658	1223	1	By	by	IN
47658	1223	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1223	3	Wildon	Wildon	NNP
47658	1223	4	Carr	Carr	NNP
47658	1223	5	,	,	,
47658	1223	6	Litt	Litt	NNP
47658	1223	7	.	.	.
47658	1223	8	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1224	1	27	27	CD
47658	1224	2	.	.	.
47658	1225	1	Psychology	psychology	NN
47658	1225	2	.	.	.
47658	1226	1	.	.	.
47658	1227	1	.	.	.
47658	1228	1	By	by	IN
47658	1228	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1228	3	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1228	4	Watt	Watt	NNP
47658	1228	5	,	,	,
47658	1228	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1228	7	,	,	,
47658	1228	8	Ph.D.	ph.d.	NN
47658	1228	9	,	,	,
47658	1228	10	D.Phil	D.Phil	NNP
47658	1228	11	.	.	.
47658	1229	1	28	28	CD
47658	1229	2	.	.	.
47658	1230	1	Ethics	ethic	NNS
47658	1230	2	.	.	.
47658	1231	1	.	.	.
47658	1232	1	.	.	.
47658	1233	1	By	by	IN
47658	1233	2	Canon	Canon	NNP
47658	1233	3	Rashdall	Rashdall	NNP
47658	1233	4	,	,	,
47658	1233	5	D.Litt	D.Litt	NNP
47658	1233	6	.	.	NNP
47658	1233	7	,	,	,
47658	1233	8	F.B.A.	F.B.A.	NNP
47658	1234	1	29	29	CD
47658	1234	2	.	.	.
47658	1235	1	Kant	Kant	NNP
47658	1235	2	's	's	POS
47658	1235	3	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
47658	1235	4	.	.	.
47658	1236	1	.	.	.
47658	1237	1	.	.	.
47658	1238	1	By	by	IN
47658	1238	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1238	3	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1238	4	Lindsay	Lindsay	NNP
47658	1238	5	,	,	,
47658	1238	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1238	7	,	,	,
47658	1238	8	of	of	IN
47658	1238	9	Balliol	Balliol	NNP
47658	1238	10	College	College	NNP
47658	1238	11	,	,	,
47658	1238	12	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
47658	1238	13	.	.	.
47658	1239	1	30	30	CD
47658	1239	2	.	.	.
47658	1240	1	The	the	DT
47658	1240	2	Teaching	Teaching	NNP
47658	1240	3	of	of	IN
47658	1240	4	Plato	Plato	NNP
47658	1240	5	.	.	.
47658	1241	1	.	.	.
47658	1242	1	.	.	.
47658	1243	1	By	by	IN
47658	1243	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1243	3	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1243	4	Lindsay	Lindsay	NNP
47658	1243	5	,	,	,
47658	1243	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1244	1	67	67	CD
47658	1244	2	.	.	.
47658	1245	1	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
47658	1245	2	.	.	.
47658	1246	1	.	.	.
47658	1247	1	.	.	.
47658	1248	1	By	by	IN
47658	1248	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1248	3	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1248	4	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1248	5	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
47658	1248	6	,	,	,
47658	1248	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1248	8	,	,	,
47658	1248	9	F.B.A.	F.B.A.	NNP
47658	1249	1	68	68	CD
47658	1249	2	.	.	.
47658	1250	1	Friedrich	Friedrich	NNP
47658	1250	2	Nietzsche	Nietzsche	NNP
47658	1250	3	.	.	.
47658	1251	1	.	.	.
47658	1252	1	.	.	.
47658	1253	1	By	by	IN
47658	1253	2	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1253	3	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1253	4	Mügge	Mügge	NNP
47658	1253	5	.	.	.
47658	1254	1	69	69	CD
47658	1254	2	.	.	.
47658	1255	1	Eucken	Eucken	VBN
47658	1255	2	:	:	:
47658	1255	3	A	a	DT
47658	1255	4	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
47658	1255	5	of	of	IN
47658	1255	6	Life	life	NN
47658	1255	7	.	.	.
47658	1256	1	.	.	.
47658	1257	1	.	.	.
47658	1258	1	By	by	IN
47658	1258	2	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1258	3	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1258	4	Jones	Jones	NNP
47658	1258	5	,	,	,
47658	1258	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1258	7	,	,	,
47658	1258	8	B.Sc	B.Sc	NNP
47658	1258	9	.	.	.
47658	1258	10	,	,	,
47658	1258	11	Ph.D.	Ph.D.	NNP
47658	1258	12	70	70	CD
47658	1258	13	.	.	.
47658	1259	1	The	the	DT
47658	1259	2	Experimental	Experimental	NNP
47658	1259	3	Psychology	Psychology	NNP
47658	1259	4	of	of	IN
47658	1259	5	Beauty	Beauty	NNP
47658	1259	6	.	.	.
47658	1260	1	.	.	.
47658	1261	1	.	.	.
47658	1262	1	By	by	IN
47658	1262	2	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1262	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1262	4	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
47658	1262	5	,	,	,
47658	1262	6	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1262	7	,	,	,
47658	1262	8	D.Phil	d.phil	RB
47658	1262	9	.	.	.
47658	1263	1	71	71	CD
47658	1263	2	.	.	.
47658	1264	1	The	the	DT
47658	1264	2	Problem	problem	NN
47658	1264	3	of	of	IN
47658	1264	4	Truth	truth	NN
47658	1264	5	.	.	.
47658	1265	1	.	.	.
47658	1266	1	.	.	.
47658	1267	1	By	by	IN
47658	1267	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1267	3	Wildon	Wildon	NNP
47658	1267	4	Carr	Carr	NNP
47658	1267	5	,	,	,
47658	1267	6	Litt	Litt	NNP
47658	1267	7	.	.	.
47658	1267	8	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1268	1	99	99	CD
47658	1268	2	.	.	.
47658	1269	1	George	George	NNP
47658	1269	2	Berkeley	Berkeley	NNP
47658	1269	3	:	:	:
47658	1269	4	The	the	DT
47658	1269	5	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
47658	1269	6	of	of	IN
47658	1269	7	Idealism	Idealism	NNP
47658	1269	8	.	.	.
47658	1270	1	.	.	.
47658	1271	1	.	.	.
47658	1272	1	By	by	IN
47658	1272	2	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1272	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1272	4	Valentine	Valentine	NNP
47658	1272	5	,	,	,
47658	1272	6	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1273	1	31	31	CD
47658	1273	2	.	.	.
47658	1274	1	Buddhism	Buddhism	NNP
47658	1274	2	.	.	.
47658	1275	1	.	.	.
47658	1276	1	.	.	.
47658	1277	1	By	by	IN
47658	1277	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1277	3	T.	T.	NNP
47658	1277	4	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1277	5	Rhys	Rhys	NNP
47658	1277	6	Davids	Davids	NNP
47658	1277	7	,	,	,
47658	1277	8	F.B.A.	F.B.A.	NNP
47658	1278	1	32	32	CD
47658	1278	2	.	.	.
47658	1279	1	Roman	Roman	NNP
47658	1279	2	Catholicism	Catholicism	NNP
47658	1279	3	.	.	.
47658	1280	1	.	.	.
47658	1281	1	.	.	.
47658	1282	1	By	by	IN
47658	1282	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1282	3	B.	B.	NNP
47658	1282	4	Coxon	Coxon	NNP
47658	1282	5	.	.	.
47658	1283	1	Preface	Preface	NNP
47658	1283	2	,	,	,
47658	1283	3	Mgr	Mgr	NNP
47658	1283	4	.	.	.
47658	1284	1	R.	R.	NNP
47658	1284	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1284	3	Benson	Benson	NNP
47658	1284	4	.	.	.
47658	1285	1	33	33	CD
47658	1285	2	.	.	.
47658	1286	1	The	the	DT
47658	1286	2	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
47658	1286	3	Movement	Movement	NNP
47658	1286	4	.	.	.
47658	1287	1	.	.	.
47658	1288	1	.	.	.
47658	1289	1	By	by	IN
47658	1289	2	Wilfrid	Wilfrid	NNP
47658	1289	3	Ward	Ward	NNP
47658	1289	4	.	.	.
47658	1290	1	34	34	CD
47658	1290	2	.	.	.
47658	1291	1	The	the	DT
47658	1291	2	Bible	Bible	NNP
47658	1291	3	and	and	CC
47658	1291	4	Criticism	Criticism	NNP
47658	1291	5	.	.	.
47658	1292	1	.	.	.
47658	1293	1	.	.	.
47658	1294	1	By	by	IN
47658	1294	2	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1294	3	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1294	4	Bennett	Bennett	NNP
47658	1294	5	,	,	,
47658	1294	6	D.D.	D.D.	NNP
47658	1294	7	,	,	,
47658	1294	8	Litt	Litt	NNP
47658	1294	9	.	.	.
47658	1294	10	P.	P.	NNP
47658	1294	11	,	,	,
47658	1294	12	and	and	CC
47658	1294	13	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1294	14	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1294	15	Adeney	Adeney	NNP
47658	1294	16	,	,	,
47658	1294	17	D.D.	D.D.	NNP
47658	1295	1	35	35	CD
47658	1295	2	.	.	.
47658	1296	1	Cardinal	Cardinal	NNP
47658	1296	2	Newman	Newman	NNP
47658	1296	3	.	.	.
47658	1297	1	.	.	.
47658	1298	1	.	.	.
47658	1299	1	By	by	IN
47658	1299	2	Wilfrid	Wilfrid	NNP
47658	1299	3	Meynell	Meynell	NNP
47658	1299	4	.	.	.
47658	1300	1	72	72	CD
47658	1300	2	.	.	.
47658	1301	1	The	the	DT
47658	1301	2	Church	Church	NNP
47658	1301	3	of	of	IN
47658	1301	4	England	England	NNP
47658	1301	5	.	.	.
47658	1302	1	.	.	.
47658	1303	1	.	.	.
47658	1304	1	By	by	IN
47658	1304	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
47658	1305	1	Canon	Canon	NNP
47658	1305	2	Masterman	Masterman	NNP
47658	1305	3	.	.	.
47658	1306	1	73	73	CD
47658	1306	2	.	.	.
47658	1307	1	Anglo	Anglo	NNP
47658	1307	2	-	-	HYPH
47658	1307	3	Catholicism	Catholicism	NNP
47658	1307	4	.	.	.
47658	1308	1	.	.	.
47658	1309	1	.	.	.
47658	1310	1	By	by	IN
47658	1310	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1310	3	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1310	4	Manning	Manning	NNP
47658	1310	5	Foster	Foster	NNP
47658	1310	6	.	.	.
47658	1311	1	74	74	CD
47658	1311	2	.	.	.
47658	1312	1	The	the	DT
47658	1312	2	Free	Free	NNP
47658	1312	3	Churches	Churches	NNPS
47658	1312	4	.	.	.
47658	1313	1	.	.	.
47658	1314	1	.	.	.
47658	1315	1	By	by	IN
47658	1315	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
47658	1316	1	Edward	Edward	NNP
47658	1316	2	Shillito	Shillito	NNP
47658	1316	3	,	,	,
47658	1316	4	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1317	1	75	75	CD
47658	1317	2	.	.	.
47658	1318	1	Judaism	Judaism	NNP
47658	1318	2	.	.	.
47658	1319	1	.	.	.
47658	1320	1	.	.	.
47658	1321	1	By	by	IN
47658	1321	2	Ephraim	Ephraim	NNP
47658	1321	3	Levine	Levine	NNP
47658	1321	4	,	,	,
47658	1321	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1322	1	76	76	CD
47658	1322	2	.	.	.
47658	1323	1	Theosophy	theosophy	NN
47658	1323	2	.	.	.
47658	1324	1	.	.	.
47658	1325	1	.	.	.
47658	1326	1	By	by	IN
47658	1326	2	Annie	Annie	NNP
47658	1326	3	Besant	Besant	NNP
47658	1326	4	.	.	.
47658	1327	1	HISTORY	HISTORY	NNP
47658	1327	2	36	36	CD
47658	1327	3	.	.	.
47658	1328	1	The	the	DT
47658	1328	2	Growth	Growth	NNP
47658	1328	3	of	of	IN
47658	1328	4	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
47658	1328	5	.	.	.
47658	1329	1	.	.	.
47658	1330	1	.	.	.
47658	1331	1	By	by	IN
47658	1331	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1331	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1331	4	Nevinson	Nevinson	NNP
47658	1331	5	.	.	.
47658	1332	1	37	37	CD
47658	1332	2	.	.	.
47658	1333	1	Bismarck	Bismarck	NNP
47658	1333	2	and	and	CC
47658	1333	3	the	the	DT
47658	1333	4	Origin	Origin	NNP
47658	1333	5	of	of	IN
47658	1333	6	the	the	DT
47658	1333	7	German	German	NNP
47658	1333	8	Empire	Empire	NNP
47658	1333	9	.	.	.
47658	1334	1	.	.	.
47658	1335	1	.	.	.
47658	1336	1	By	by	IN
47658	1336	2	Professor	Professor	NNP
47658	1336	3	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1336	4	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1336	5	Powicke	Powicke	NNP
47658	1336	6	.	.	.
47658	1337	1	38	38	CD
47658	1337	2	.	.	.
47658	1338	1	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
47658	1338	2	Cromwell	Cromwell	NNP
47658	1338	3	.	.	.
47658	1339	1	.	.	.
47658	1340	1	.	.	.
47658	1341	1	By	by	IN
47658	1341	2	Hilda	Hilda	NNP
47658	1341	3	Johnstone	Johnstone	NNP
47658	1341	4	,	,	,
47658	1341	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1342	1	39	39	CD
47658	1342	2	.	.	.
47658	1343	1	Mary	Mary	NNP
47658	1343	2	Queen	Queen	NNP
47658	1343	3	of	of	IN
47658	1343	4	Scots	Scots	NNPS
47658	1343	5	.	.	.
47658	1344	1	.	.	.
47658	1345	1	.	.	.
47658	1346	1	By	by	IN
47658	1346	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1346	3	O'Neill	O'Neill	NNP
47658	1346	4	,	,	,
47658	1346	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1347	1	40	40	CD
47658	1347	2	.	.	.
47658	1348	1	Cecil	Cecil	NNP
47658	1348	2	John	John	NNP
47658	1348	3	Rhodes	Rhodes	NNP
47658	1348	4	,	,	,
47658	1348	5	1853	1853	CD
47658	1348	6	-	-	SYM
47658	1348	7	1902	1902	CD
47658	1348	8	.	.	.
47658	1349	1	.	.	.
47658	1350	1	.	.	.
47658	1351	1	By	by	IN
47658	1351	2	Ian	Ian	NNP
47658	1351	3	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1351	4	Colvin	Colvin	NNP
47658	1351	5	.	.	.
47658	1352	1	41	41	CD
47658	1352	2	.	.	.
47658	1353	1	Julius	Julius	NNP
47658	1353	2	Cæsar	Cæsar	NNP
47658	1353	3	.	.	.
47658	1354	1	.	.	.
47658	1355	1	.	.	.
47658	1356	1	By	by	IN
47658	1356	2	Hilary	Hilary	NNP
47658	1356	3	Hardinge	Hardinge	NNP
47658	1356	4	.	.	.
47658	1357	1	42	42	CD
47658	1357	2	.	.	.
47658	1358	1	England	England	NNP
47658	1358	2	in	in	IN
47658	1358	3	the	the	DT
47658	1358	4	Making	making	NN
47658	1358	5	.	.	.
47658	1359	1	.	.	.
47658	1360	1	.	.	.
47658	1361	1	By	by	IN
47658	1361	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1361	3	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1361	4	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1361	5	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1361	6	Hearnshaw	Hearnshaw	NNP
47658	1361	7	,	,	,
47658	1361	8	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1361	9	,	,	,
47658	1361	10	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
47658	1362	1	43	43	CD
47658	1362	2	.	.	.
47658	1363	1	England	England	NNP
47658	1363	2	in	in	IN
47658	1363	3	the	the	DT
47658	1363	4	Middle	Middle	NNP
47658	1363	5	Ages	Ages	NNPS
47658	1363	6	.	.	.
47658	1364	1	.	.	.
47658	1365	1	.	.	.
47658	1366	1	By	by	IN
47658	1366	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1366	3	O'Neill	O'Neill	NNP
47658	1366	4	,	,	,
47658	1366	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1367	1	44	44	CD
47658	1367	2	.	.	.
47658	1368	1	The	the	DT
47658	1368	2	Monarchy	Monarchy	NNP
47658	1368	3	and	and	CC
47658	1368	4	the	the	DT
47658	1368	5	People	People	NNS
47658	1368	6	.	.	.
47658	1369	1	.	.	.
47658	1370	1	.	.	.
47658	1371	1	By	by	IN
47658	1371	2	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1371	3	T.	T.	NNP
47658	1371	4	Waugh	Waugh	NNP
47658	1371	5	,	,	,
47658	1371	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1372	1	45	45	CD
47658	1372	2	.	.	.
47658	1373	1	The	the	DT
47658	1373	2	Industrial	Industrial	NNP
47658	1373	3	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
47658	1373	4	.	.	.
47658	1374	1	.	.	.
47658	1375	1	.	.	.
47658	1376	1	By	by	IN
47658	1376	2	Arthur	Arthur	NNP
47658	1376	3	Jones	Jones	NNP
47658	1376	4	,	,	,
47658	1376	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1377	1	46	46	CD
47658	1377	2	.	.	.
47658	1378	1	Empire	empire	NN
47658	1378	2	and	and	CC
47658	1378	3	Democracy	Democracy	NNP
47658	1378	4	.	.	.
47658	1379	1	.	.	.
47658	1380	1	.	.	.
47658	1381	1	By	by	IN
47658	1381	2	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1381	3	S.	S.	NNP
47658	1381	4	Veitch	Veitch	NNP
47658	1381	5	,	,	,
47658	1381	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1381	7	,	,	,
47658	1381	8	Litt	Litt	NNP
47658	1381	9	.	.	.
47658	1381	10	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1382	1	61	61	CD
47658	1382	2	.	.	.
47658	1383	1	Home	Home	NNP
47658	1383	2	Rule	Rule	NNP
47658	1383	3	.	.	.
47658	1384	1	.	.	.
47658	1385	1	.	.	.
47658	1386	1	By	by	IN
47658	1386	2	L.	L.	NNP
47658	1386	3	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1386	4	Redmond	Redmond	NNP
47658	1386	5	Howard	Howard	NNP
47658	1386	6	.	.	.
47658	1387	1	Preface	preface	NN
47658	1387	2	by	by	IN
47658	1387	3	Robert	Robert	NNP
47658	1387	4	Harcourt	Harcourt	NNP
47658	1387	5	,	,	,
47658	1387	6	M.P.	M.P.	NNP
47658	1388	1	77	77	CD
47658	1388	2	.	.	.
47658	1389	1	Nelson	Nelson	NNP
47658	1389	2	.	.	.
47658	1390	1	.	.	.
47658	1391	1	.	.	.
47658	1392	1	By	by	IN
47658	1392	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1392	3	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1392	4	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
47658	1392	5	.	.	.
47658	1393	1	78	78	CD
47658	1393	2	.	.	.
47658	1394	1	Wellington	Wellington	NNP
47658	1394	2	and	and	CC
47658	1394	3	Waterloo	Waterloo	NNP
47658	1394	4	.	.	.
47658	1395	1	.	.	.
47658	1396	1	.	.	.
47658	1397	1	By	by	IN
47658	1397	2	Major	Major	NNP
47658	1397	3	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1397	4	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1397	5	Redway	Redway	NNP
47658	1397	6	.	.	.
47658	1398	1	100	100	CD
47658	1398	2	.	.	.
47658	1399	1	A	a	DT
47658	1399	2	History	history	NN
47658	1399	3	of	of	IN
47658	1399	4	Greece	Greece	NNP
47658	1399	5	.	.	.
47658	1400	1	.	.	.
47658	1401	1	.	.	.
47658	1402	1	By	by	IN
47658	1402	2	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1402	3	Fearenside	Fearenside	NNP
47658	1402	4	,	,	,
47658	1402	5	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1403	1	101	101	CD
47658	1403	2	.	.	.
47658	1404	1	Luther	Luther	NNP
47658	1404	2	and	and	CC
47658	1404	3	the	the	DT
47658	1404	4	Reformation	Reformation	NNP
47658	1404	5	.	.	.
47658	1405	1	.	.	.
47658	1406	1	.	.	.
47658	1407	1	By	by	IN
47658	1407	2	Leonard	Leonard	NNP
47658	1407	3	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1407	4	Agate	Agate	NNP
47658	1407	5	,	,	,
47658	1407	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1408	1	102	102	CD
47658	1408	2	.	.	.
47658	1409	1	The	the	DT
47658	1409	2	Discovery	Discovery	NNP
47658	1409	3	of	of	IN
47658	1409	4	the	the	DT
47658	1409	5	New	New	NNP
47658	1409	6	World	World	NNP
47658	1409	7	.	.	.
47658	1410	1	.	.	.
47658	1411	1	.	.	.
47658	1412	1	By	by	IN
47658	1412	2	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1412	3	B.	B.	NNP
47658	1412	4	Kirkman	Kirkman	NNP
47658	1412	5	,	,	,
47658	1412	6	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1413	1	103	103	CD
47658	1413	2	.	.	.
47658	1414	1	Turkey	Turkey	NNP
47658	1414	2	and	and	CC
47658	1414	3	the	the	DT
47658	1414	4	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
47658	1414	5	Question	Question	NNP
47658	1414	6	.	.	.
47658	1415	1	.	.	.
47658	1416	1	.	.	.
47658	1417	1	By	by	IN
47658	1417	2	John	John	NNP
47658	1417	3	Macdonald	Macdonald	NNP
47658	1417	4	,	,	,
47658	1417	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1418	1	104	104	CD
47658	1418	2	.	.	.
47658	1419	1	Architecture	architecture	NN
47658	1419	2	.	.	.
47658	1420	1	.	.	.
47658	1421	1	.	.	.
47658	1422	1	By	by	IN
47658	1422	2	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
47658	1422	3	Arthur	Arthur	NNP
47658	1422	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
47658	1422	5	.	.	.
47658	1423	1	SOCIAL	SOCIAL	NNP
47658	1423	2	AND	and	CC
47658	1423	3	ECONOMIC	ECONOMIC	NNP
47658	1423	4	47	47	CD
47658	1423	5	.	.	.
47658	1424	1	Women	woman	NNS
47658	1424	2	's	's	POS
47658	1424	3	Suffrage	suffrage	NN
47658	1424	4	.	.	.
47658	1425	1	.	.	.
47658	1426	1	.	.	.
47658	1427	1	By	by	IN
47658	1427	2	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1427	3	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1427	4	Fawcett	Fawcett	NNP
47658	1427	5	,	,	,
47658	1427	6	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
47658	1428	1	48	48	CD
47658	1428	2	.	.	.
47658	1429	1	The	the	DT
47658	1429	2	Working	Working	NNP
47658	1429	3	of	of	IN
47658	1429	4	the	the	DT
47658	1429	5	British	british	JJ
47658	1429	6	System	System	NNP
47658	1429	7	of	of	IN
47658	1429	8	Government	Government	NNP
47658	1429	9	to	to	IN
47658	1429	10	-	-	HYPH
47658	1429	11	day	day	NN
47658	1429	12	.	.	.
47658	1430	1	.	.	.
47658	1431	1	.	.	.
47658	1432	1	By	by	IN
47658	1432	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1432	3	Ramsay	Ramsay	NNP
47658	1432	4	Muir	Muir	NNP
47658	1432	5	,	,	,
47658	1432	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1433	1	49	49	CD
47658	1433	2	.	.	.
47658	1434	1	An	an	DT
47658	1434	2	Introduction	introduction	NN
47658	1434	3	to	to	IN
47658	1434	4	Economic	Economic	NNP
47658	1434	5	Science	Science	NNP
47658	1434	6	.	.	.
47658	1435	1	.	.	.
47658	1436	1	.	.	.
47658	1437	1	By	by	IN
47658	1437	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1437	3	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1437	4	O.	O.	NNP
47658	1437	5	Meredith	Meredith	NNP
47658	1437	6	,	,	,
47658	1437	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1438	1	50	50	CD
47658	1438	2	.	.	.
47658	1439	1	Socialism	socialism	NN
47658	1439	2	.	.	.
47658	1440	1	.	.	.
47658	1441	1	.	.	.
47658	1442	1	By	by	IN
47658	1442	2	F.	F.	NNP
47658	1442	3	B.	B.	NNP
47658	1442	4	Kirkman	Kirkman	NNP
47658	1442	5	,	,	,
47658	1442	6	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1443	1	79	79	CD
47658	1443	2	.	.	.
47658	1444	1	Mediæval	Mediæval	NNP
47658	1444	2	Socialism	Socialism	NNP
47658	1444	3	.	.	.
47658	1445	1	.	.	.
47658	1446	1	.	.	.
47658	1447	1	By	by	IN
47658	1447	2	Bede	Bede	NNP
47658	1447	3	Jarrett	Jarrett	NNP
47658	1447	4	,	,	,
47658	1447	5	O.P.	O.P.	NNP
47658	1447	6	,	,	,
47658	1447	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1448	1	80	80	CD
47658	1448	2	.	.	.
47658	1449	1	Syndicalism	syndicalism	NN
47658	1449	2	.	.	.
47658	1450	1	.	.	.
47658	1451	1	.	.	.
47658	1452	1	By	by	IN
47658	1452	2	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1452	3	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1452	4	Harley	Harley	NNP
47658	1452	5	,	,	,
47658	1452	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1453	1	81	81	CD
47658	1453	2	.	.	.
47658	1454	1	Labour	Labour	NNP
47658	1454	2	and	and	CC
47658	1454	3	Wages	wage	NNS
47658	1454	4	.	.	.
47658	1455	1	.	.	.
47658	1456	1	.	.	.
47658	1457	1	By	by	IN
47658	1457	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1457	3	M.	M.	NNP
47658	1457	4	Hallsworth	Hallsworth	NNP
47658	1457	5	,	,	,
47658	1457	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1457	7	,	,	,
47658	1457	8	B.Sc	B.Sc	NNP
47658	1457	9	.	.	.
47658	1458	1	82	82	CD
47658	1458	2	.	.	.
47658	1459	1	Co	co	NN
47658	1459	2	-	-	NN
47658	1459	3	operation	operation	NN
47658	1459	4	.	.	.
47658	1460	1	.	.	.
47658	1461	1	.	.	.
47658	1462	1	By	by	IN
47658	1462	2	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
47658	1462	3	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
47658	1462	4	.	.	.
47658	1463	1	83	83	CD
47658	1463	2	.	.	.
47658	1464	1	Insurance	insurance	NN
47658	1464	2	as	as	IN
47658	1464	3	a	a	DT
47658	1464	4	Means	Means	NNP
47658	1464	5	of	of	IN
47658	1464	6	Investment	investment	NN
47658	1464	7	.	.	.
47658	1465	1	.	.	.
47658	1466	1	.	.	.
47658	1467	1	By	by	IN
47658	1467	2	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1467	3	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1467	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
47658	1467	5	,	,	,
47658	1467	6	F.F.A.	F.F.A.	NNP
47658	1468	1	92	92	CD
47658	1468	2	.	.	.
47658	1469	1	The	the	DT
47658	1469	2	Training	training	NN
47658	1469	3	of	of	IN
47658	1469	4	the	the	DT
47658	1469	5	Child	child	NN
47658	1469	6	.	.	.
47658	1470	1	.	.	.
47658	1471	1	.	.	.
47658	1472	1	By	by	IN
47658	1472	2	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1472	3	Spiller	Spiller	NNP
47658	1472	4	.	.	.
47658	1473	1	105	105	CD
47658	1473	2	.	.	.
47658	1474	1	Trade	Trade	NNP
47658	1474	2	Unions	Unions	NNPS
47658	1474	3	.	.	.
47658	1475	1	.	.	.
47658	1476	1	.	.	.
47658	1477	1	By	by	IN
47658	1477	2	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
47658	1477	3	Clayton	Clayton	NNP
47658	1477	4	.	.	.
47658	1478	1	106	106	CD
47658	1478	2	.	.	.
47658	1479	1	Everyday	Everyday	NNP
47658	1479	2	Law	Law	NNP
47658	1479	3	.	.	.
47658	1480	1	.	.	.
47658	1481	1	.	.	.
47658	1482	1	By	by	IN
47658	1482	2	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1482	3	J.	J.	NNP
47658	1482	4	Adams	Adams	NNP
47658	1482	5	.	.	.
47658	1483	1	LETTERS	letter	NNS
47658	1483	2	51	51	CD
47658	1483	3	.	.	.
47658	1484	1	Shakespeare	Shakespeare	NNP
47658	1484	2	.	.	.
47658	1485	1	.	.	.
47658	1486	1	.	.	.
47658	1487	1	By	by	IN
47658	1487	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1487	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1487	4	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1487	5	Herford	Herford	NNP
47658	1487	6	,	,	,
47658	1487	7	Litt	Litt	NNP
47658	1487	8	.	.	.
47658	1487	9	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1488	1	52	52	CD
47658	1488	2	.	.	.
47658	1489	1	Wordsworth	wordsworth	RB
47658	1489	2	.	.	.
47658	1490	1	.	.	.
47658	1491	1	.	.	.
47658	1492	1	By	by	IN
47658	1492	2	Rosaline	Rosaline	NNP
47658	1492	3	Masson	Masson	NNP
47658	1492	4	.	.	.
47658	1493	1	53	53	CD
47658	1493	2	.	.	.
47658	1494	1	Pure	pure	JJ
47658	1494	2	Gold	gold	NN
47658	1494	3	--	--	:
47658	1494	4	A	a	DT
47658	1494	5	Choice	Choice	NNP
47658	1494	6	of	of	IN
47658	1494	7	Lyrics	Lyrics	NNPS
47658	1494	8	and	and	CC
47658	1494	9	Sonnets	Sonnets	NNPS
47658	1494	10	.	.	.
47658	1495	1	.	.	.
47658	1496	1	.	.	.
47658	1497	1	by	by	IN
47658	1497	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1497	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1497	4	O'Neill	O'Neill	NNP
47658	1497	5	54	54	CD
47658	1497	6	.	.	.
47658	1498	1	Francis	Francis	NNP
47658	1498	2	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
47658	1498	3	.	.	.
47658	1499	1	.	.	.
47658	1500	1	.	.	.
47658	1501	1	By	by	IN
47658	1501	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1501	3	A.	a.	NN
47658	1501	4	R.	R.	NNP
47658	1501	5	Skemp	Skemp	NNP
47658	1501	6	,	,	,
47658	1501	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1502	1	55	55	CD
47658	1502	2	.	.	.
47658	1503	1	The	the	DT
47658	1503	2	Brontës	Brontës	NNP
47658	1503	3	.	.	.
47658	1504	1	.	.	.
47658	1505	1	.	.	.
47658	1506	1	By	by	IN
47658	1506	2	Flora	Flora	NNP
47658	1506	3	Masson	Masson	NNP
47658	1506	4	.	.	.
47658	1507	1	56	56	CD
47658	1507	2	.	.	.
47658	1508	1	Carlyle	Carlyle	NNP
47658	1508	2	.	.	.
47658	1509	1	.	.	.
47658	1510	1	.	.	.
47658	1511	1	By	by	IN
47658	1511	2	L.	L.	NNP
47658	1511	3	MacLean	MacLean	NNP
47658	1511	4	Watt	Watt	NNP
47658	1511	5	.	.	.
47658	1512	1	57	57	CD
47658	1512	2	.	.	.
47658	1513	1	Dante	Dante	NNP
47658	1513	2	.	.	.
47658	1514	1	.	.	.
47658	1515	1	.	.	.
47658	1516	1	By	by	IN
47658	1516	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1516	3	G.	G.	NNP
47658	1516	4	Ferrers	Ferrers	NNP
47658	1516	5	Howell	Howell	NNP
47658	1516	6	.	.	.
47658	1517	1	60	60	CD
47658	1517	2	.	.	.
47658	1518	1	A	a	DT
47658	1518	2	Dictionary	Dictionary	NNP
47658	1518	3	of	of	IN
47658	1518	4	Synonyms	Synonyms	NNP
47658	1518	5	.	.	.
47658	1519	1	.	.	.
47658	1520	1	.	.	.
47658	1521	1	By	by	IN
47658	1521	2	Austin	Austin	NNP
47658	1521	3	K.	K.	NNP
47658	1521	4	Gray	Gray	NNP
47658	1521	5	,	,	,
47658	1521	6	B.A.	B.A.	NNP
47658	1522	1	83	83	CD
47658	1522	2	.	.	.
47658	1523	1	Insurance	insurance	NN
47658	1523	2	as	as	IN
47658	1523	3	a	a	DT
47658	1523	4	Means	Means	NNP
47658	1523	5	of	of	IN
47658	1523	6	Investment	investment	NN
47658	1523	7	.	.	.
47658	1524	1	.	.	.
47658	1525	1	.	.	.
47658	1526	1	By	by	IN
47658	1526	2	W.	W.	NNP
47658	1526	3	A.	A.	NNP
47658	1526	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
47658	1526	5	,	,	,
47658	1526	6	F.F.A.	F.F.A.	NNP
47658	1527	1	84	84	CD
47658	1527	2	.	.	.
47658	1528	1	Classical	Classical	NNP
47658	1528	2	Dictionary	Dictionary	NNP
47658	1528	3	.	.	.
47658	1529	1	.	.	.
47658	1530	1	.	.	.
47658	1531	1	By	by	IN
47658	1531	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1531	3	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1531	4	Stirling	Stirling	NNP
47658	1531	5	.	.	.
47658	1532	1	85	85	CD
47658	1532	2	.	.	.
47658	1533	1	A	a	DT
47658	1533	2	History	history	NN
47658	1533	3	of	of	IN
47658	1533	4	English	English	NNP
47658	1533	5	Literature	Literature	NNP
47658	1533	6	.	.	.
47658	1534	1	.	.	.
47658	1535	1	.	.	.
47658	1536	1	By	by	IN
47658	1536	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1536	3	Compton	Compton	NNP
47658	1536	4	-	-	HYPH
47658	1536	5	Rickett	Rickett	NNP
47658	1536	6	,	,	,
47658	1536	7	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
47658	1537	1	86	86	CD
47658	1537	2	.	.	.
47658	1538	1	Browning	brown	VBG
47658	1538	2	.	.	.
47658	1539	1	.	.	.
47658	1540	1	.	.	.
47658	1541	1	By	by	IN
47658	1541	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1541	3	A.	a.	NN
47658	1541	4	R.	R.	NNP
47658	1541	5	Skemp	Skemp	NNP
47658	1541	6	,	,	,
47658	1541	7	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1542	1	87	87	CD
47658	1542	2	.	.	.
47658	1543	1	Charles	Charles	NNP
47658	1543	2	Lamb	Lamb	NNP
47658	1543	3	.	.	.
47658	1544	1	.	.	.
47658	1545	1	.	.	.
47658	1546	1	By	by	IN
47658	1546	2	Flora	Flora	NNP
47658	1546	3	Masson	Masson	NNP
47658	1546	4	.	.	.
47658	1547	1	88	88	CD
47658	1547	2	.	.	.
47658	1548	1	Goethe	goethe	UH
47658	1548	2	.	.	.
47658	1549	1	.	.	.
47658	1550	1	.	.	.
47658	1551	1	By	by	IN
47658	1551	2	Prof.	Prof.	NNP
47658	1551	3	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1551	4	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1551	5	Herford	Herford	NNP
47658	1551	6	,	,	,
47658	1551	7	Litt	Litt	NNP
47658	1551	8	.	.	.
47658	1551	9	D.	D.	NNP
47658	1552	1	89	89	CD
47658	1552	2	.	.	.
47658	1553	1	Balzac	Balzac	NNP
47658	1553	2	.	.	.
47658	1554	1	.	.	.
47658	1555	1	.	.	.
47658	1556	1	By	by	IN
47658	1556	2	Frank	Frank	NNP
47658	1556	3	Harris	Harris	NNP
47658	1556	4	.	.	.
47658	1557	1	90	90	CD
47658	1557	2	.	.	.
47658	1558	1	Rousseau	rousseau	NN
47658	1558	2	.	.	.
47658	1559	1	.	.	.
47658	1560	1	.	.	.
47658	1561	1	By	by	IN
47658	1561	2	H.	H.	NNP
47658	1561	3	Sacher	Sacher	NNP
47658	1561	4	91	91	CD
47658	1561	5	.	.	.
47658	1562	1	Ibsen	Ibsen	NNP
47658	1562	2	.	.	.
47658	1563	1	.	.	.
47658	1564	1	.	.	.
47658	1565	1	By	by	IN
47658	1565	2	Hilary	Hilary	NNP
47658	1565	3	Hardinge	Hardinge	NNP
47658	1565	4	.	.	.
47658	1566	1	93	93	CD
47658	1566	2	.	.	.
47658	1567	1	Tennyson	Tennyson	NNP
47658	1567	2	.	.	.
47658	1568	1	.	.	.
47658	1569	1	.	.	.
47658	1570	1	By	by	IN
47658	1570	2	Aaron	Aaron	NNP
47658	1570	3	Watson	Watson	NNP
47658	1570	4	.	.	.
47658	1571	1	107	107	CD
47658	1571	2	.	.	.
47658	1572	1	R.	R.	NNP
47658	1572	2	L.	L.	NNP
47658	1572	3	Stevenson	Stevenson	NNP
47658	1572	4	.	.	.
47658	1573	1	.	.	.
47658	1574	1	.	.	.
47658	1575	1	By	by	IN
47658	1575	2	Rosaline	Rosaline	NNP
47658	1575	3	Masson	Masson	NNP
47658	1575	4	.	.	.
47658	1576	1	108	108	CD
47658	1576	2	.	.	.
47658	1577	1	Shelley	Shelley	NNP
47658	1577	2	.	.	.
47658	1578	1	.	.	.
47658	1579	1	.	.	.
47658	1580	1	By	by	IN
47658	1580	2	Sydney	Sydney	NNP
47658	1580	3	Waterlow	Waterlow	NNP
47658	1580	4	,	,	,
47658	1580	5	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1581	1	109	109	CD
47658	1581	2	.	.	.
47658	1582	1	William	William	NNP
47658	1582	2	Morris	Morris	NNP
47658	1582	3	.	.	.
47658	1583	1	.	.	.
47658	1584	1	.	.	.
47658	1585	1	By	by	IN
47658	1585	2	A.	a.	NN
47658	1585	3	Blyth	Blyth	NNP
47658	1585	4	Webster	Webster	NNP
47658	1585	5	,	,	,
47658	1585	6	M.A.	M.A.	NNP
47658	1586	1	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
47658	1586	2	AND	and	CC
47658	1586	3	EDINBURGH	EDINBURGH	NNP
47658	1586	4	:	:	:
47658	1586	5	T.	T.	NNP
47658	1586	6	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1586	7	&	&	CC
47658	1586	8	E.	E.	NNP
47658	1586	9	C.	C.	NNP
47658	1586	10	JACK	JACK	NNP
47658	1586	11	NEW	NEW	NNP
47658	1586	12	YORK	YORK	NNP
47658	1586	13	:	:	:
47658	1586	14	DODGE	DODGE	NNP
47658	1586	15	PUBLISHING	PUBLISHING	NNP
47658	1586	16	CO	CO	NNP
47658	1586	17	.	.	.