id sid tid token lemma pos 19613 1 1 HISTORY history NN 19613 1 2 OF of IN 19613 1 3 DOGMA DOGMA NNS 19613 1 4 BY by IN 19613 1 5 DR DR NNP 19613 1 6 . . . 19613 1 7 ADOLPH adolph NN 19613 1 8 HARNACK HARNACK NNP 19613 1 9 ORDINARY ORDINARY NNP 19613 1 10 PROF PROF NNP 19613 1 11 . . NNP 19613 1 12 OF of IN 19613 1 13 CHURCH church NN 19613 1 14 HISTORY HISTORY NNP 19613 1 15 IN in IN 19613 1 16 THE the DT 19613 1 17 UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY NNP 19613 1 18 , , , 19613 1 19 AND and CC 19613 1 20 FELLOW FELLOW NNP 19613 1 21 OF of IN 19613 1 22 THE the DT 19613 1 23 ROYAL ROYAL NNP 19613 1 24 ACADEMY ACADEMY NNP 19613 1 25 OF of IN 19613 1 26 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 19613 1 27 , , , 19613 1 28 BERLIN BERLIN NNP 19613 1 29 _ _ NNP 19613 1 30 TRANSLATED translate VBD 19613 1 31 FROM from IN 19613 1 32 THE the DT 19613 1 33 THIRD third JJ 19613 1 34 GERMAN GERMAN NNP 19613 1 35 EDITION EDITION VBN 19613 1 36 _ _ NNP 19613 1 37 BY by IN 19613 1 38 NEIL NEIL NNP 19613 1 39 BUCHANAN BUCHANAN NNP 19613 1 40 VOL VOL NNP 19613 1 41 . . . 19613 2 1 II ii CD 19613 2 2 . . . 19613 3 1 BOSTON BOSTON NNP 19613 3 2 LITTLE LITTLE NNP 19613 3 3 , , , 19613 3 4 BROWN BROWN NNP 19613 3 5 , , , 19613 3 6 AND and CC 19613 3 7 COMPANY company NN 19613 3 8 1901 1901 CD 19613 3 9 CONTENTS content NNS 19613 3 10 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 3 11 I.--Historical i.--historical JJ 19613 3 12 Survey survey NN 19613 3 13 The The NNP 19613 3 14 Old Old NNP 19613 3 15 and and CC 19613 3 16 New New NNP 19613 3 17 Elements Elements NNPS 19613 3 18 in in IN 19613 3 19 the the DT 19613 3 20 formation formation NN 19613 3 21 of of IN 19613 3 22 the the DT 19613 3 23 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3 24 Church Church NNP 19613 3 25 ; ; : 19613 3 26 The the DT 19613 3 27 fixing fixing NN 19613 3 28 of of IN 19613 3 29 that that DT 19613 3 30 which which WDT 19613 3 31 is be VBZ 19613 3 32 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 3 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3 34 Rule Rule NNP 19613 3 35 of of IN 19613 3 36 Faith Faith NNP 19613 3 37 , , , 19613 3 38 Collection Collection NNP 19613 3 39 of of IN 19613 3 40 Writings Writings NNP 19613 3 41 , , , 19613 3 42 Organization Organization NNP 19613 3 43 , , , 19613 3 44 Cultus Cultus NNP 19613 3 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3 46 ; ; : 19613 3 47 The the DT 19613 3 48 Stages stage NNS 19613 3 49 in in IN 19613 3 50 the the DT 19613 3 51 Genesis Genesis NNP 19613 3 52 of of IN 19613 3 53 the the DT 19613 3 54 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3 55 Rule Rule NNP 19613 3 56 of of IN 19613 3 57 Faith Faith NNP 19613 3 58 , , , 19613 3 59 the the DT 19613 3 60 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 3 61 ; ; : 19613 3 62 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3 63 , , , 19613 3 64 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3 65 , , , 19613 3 66 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3 67 ; ; : 19613 3 68 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3 69 and and CC 19613 3 70 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3 71 ; ; : 19613 3 72 Obscurities obscurity NNS 19613 3 73 in in IN 19613 3 74 reference reference NN 19613 3 75 to to IN 19613 3 76 the the DT 19613 3 77 origin origin NN 19613 3 78 of of IN 19613 3 79 the the DT 19613 3 80 most most RBS 19613 3 81 important important JJ 19613 3 82 Institutions institution NNS 19613 3 83 ; ; : 19613 3 84 Difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 3 85 in in IN 19613 3 86 determining determine VBG 19613 3 87 the the DT 19613 3 88 importance importance NN 19613 3 89 of of IN 19613 3 90 individual individual JJ 19613 3 91 Personalities Personalities NNPS 19613 3 92 ; ; : 19613 3 93 Differences difference NNS 19613 3 94 of of IN 19613 3 95 development development NN 19613 3 96 in in IN 19613 3 97 the the DT 19613 3 98 Churches church NNS 19613 3 99 of of IN 19613 3 100 different different JJ 19613 3 101 countries country NNS 19613 3 102 . . . 19613 4 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4 2 FIXING FIXING NNP 19613 4 3 AND and CC 19613 4 4 GRADUAL GRADUAL NNP 19613 4 5 SECULARISING SECULARISING NNP 19613 4 6 OF of IN 19613 4 7 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 4 8 AS as IN 19613 4 9 A a DT 19613 4 10 CHURCH CHURCH NNP 19613 4 11 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 4 12 II.--The II.--The NNP 19613 4 13 setting set VBG 19613 4 14 up up RP 19613 4 15 of of IN 19613 4 16 the the DT 19613 4 17 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 4 18 Standards Standards NNPS 19613 4 19 for for IN 19613 4 20 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 4 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4 22 . . . 19613 5 1 The the DT 19613 5 2 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 5 3 Church Church NNP 19613 5 4 A. a. NN 19613 6 1 The the DT 19613 6 2 transformation transformation NN 19613 6 3 of of IN 19613 6 4 the the DT 19613 6 5 Baptismal Baptismal NNP 19613 6 6 Confession Confession NNP 19613 6 7 into into IN 19613 6 8 the the DT 19613 6 9 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 6 10 Rule Rule NNP 19613 6 11 of of IN 19613 6 12 Faith Faith NNP 19613 6 13 Necessities Necessities NNP 19613 6 14 for for IN 19613 6 15 setting set VBG 19613 6 16 up up RP 19613 6 17 the the DT 19613 6 18 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 6 19 Rule Rule NNP 19613 6 20 of of IN 19613 6 21 Faith Faith NNP 19613 6 22 ; ; : 19613 6 23 The the DT 19613 6 24 Rule Rule NNP 19613 6 25 of of IN 19613 6 26 Faith Faith NNP 19613 6 27 is be VBZ 19613 6 28 the the DT 19613 6 29 Baptismal Baptismal NNP 19613 6 30 Confession Confession NNP 19613 6 31 definitely definitely RB 19613 6 32 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 6 33 ; ; : 19613 6 34 Estimate Estimate NNP 19613 6 35 of of IN 19613 6 36 this this DT 19613 6 37 transformation transformation NN 19613 6 38 ; ; : 19613 6 39 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6 40 ; ; : 19613 6 41 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6 42 ; ; : 19613 6 43 Results result NNS 19613 6 44 of of IN 19613 6 45 the the DT 19613 6 46 transformation transformation NN 19613 6 47 ; ; : 19613 6 48 Slower slow JJR 19613 6 49 development development NN 19613 6 50 in in IN 19613 6 51 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 6 52 : : : 19613 6 53 Clement Clement NNP 19613 6 54 and and CC 19613 6 55 Origen Origen NNP 19613 6 56 . . . 19613 7 1 B. B. NNP 19613 8 1 The the DT 19613 8 2 designation designation NN 19613 8 3 of of IN 19613 8 4 selected select VBN 19613 8 5 writings writing NNS 19613 8 6 read read VBN 19613 8 7 in in IN 19613 8 8 the the DT 19613 8 9 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 8 10 as as IN 19613 8 11 New New NNP 19613 8 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 13 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8 14 or or CC 19613 8 15 , , , 19613 8 16 in in IN 19613 8 17 other other JJ 19613 8 18 words word NNS 19613 8 19 , , , 19613 8 20 as as IN 19613 8 21 a a DT 19613 8 22 collection collection NN 19613 8 23 of of IN 19613 8 24 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 8 25 Writings Writings NNP 19613 8 26 Plausible Plausible NNP 19613 8 27 arguments argument NNS 19613 8 28 against against IN 19613 8 29 the the DT 19613 8 30 statement statement NN 19613 8 31 that that IN 19613 8 32 up up IN 19613 8 33 to to IN 19613 8 34 the the DT 19613 8 35 year year NN 19613 8 36 150 150 CD 19613 8 37 there there EX 19613 8 38 was be VBD 19613 8 39 no no DT 19613 8 40 New New NNP 19613 8 41 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 42 in in IN 19613 8 43 the the DT 19613 8 44 Church church NN 19613 8 45 ; ; : 19613 8 46 Sudden sudden JJ 19613 8 47 emergence emergence NN 19613 8 48 of of IN 19613 8 49 the the DT 19613 8 50 New New NNP 19613 8 51 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 52 in in IN 19613 8 53 the the DT 19613 8 54 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 8 55 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 8 56 , , , 19613 8 57 in in IN 19613 8 58 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8 59 Melito Melito NNP 19613 8 60 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8 61 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8 62 and and CC 19613 8 63 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8 64 ; ; : 19613 8 65 Conditions condition NNS 19613 8 66 under under IN 19613 8 67 which which WDT 19613 8 68 the the DT 19613 8 69 New New NNP 19613 8 70 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 71 originated originate VBD 19613 8 72 ; ; : 19613 8 73 Relation relation NN 19613 8 74 of of IN 19613 8 75 the the DT 19613 8 76 New New NNP 19613 8 77 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 78 to to IN 19613 8 79 the the DT 19613 8 80 earlier early JJR 19613 8 81 writings writing NNS 19613 8 82 that that WDT 19613 8 83 were be VBD 19613 8 84 read read VBN 19613 8 85 in in IN 19613 8 86 the the DT 19613 8 87 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 8 88 ; ; , 19613 8 89 Causes cause NNS 19613 8 90 and and CC 19613 8 91 motives motive NNS 19613 8 92 for for IN 19613 8 93 the the DT 19613 8 94 formation formation NN 19613 8 95 of of IN 19613 8 96 the the DT 19613 8 97 Canon Canon NNP 19613 8 98 , , , 19613 8 99 manner manner NN 19613 8 100 of of IN 19613 8 101 using use VBG 19613 8 102 and and CC 19613 8 103 results result NNS 19613 8 104 of of IN 19613 8 105 the the DT 19613 8 106 New New NNP 19613 8 107 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 108 ; ; : 19613 8 109 The the DT 19613 8 110 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 8 111 collection collection NN 19613 8 112 of of IN 19613 8 113 writings writing NNS 19613 8 114 can can MD 19613 8 115 be be VB 19613 8 116 proved prove VBN 19613 8 117 at at IN 19613 8 118 first first RB 19613 8 119 only only RB 19613 8 120 in in IN 19613 8 121 those those DT 19613 8 122 Churches church NNS 19613 8 123 in in IN 19613 8 124 which which WDT 19613 8 125 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8 126 find find VBP 19613 8 127 the the DT 19613 8 128 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 8 129 Rule Rule NNP 19613 8 130 of of IN 19613 8 131 Faith Faith NNP 19613 8 132 ; ; : 19613 8 133 probably probably RB 19613 8 134 there there EX 19613 8 135 was be VBD 19613 8 136 no no DT 19613 8 137 New New NNP 19613 8 138 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 139 in in IN 19613 8 140 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 8 141 about about IN 19613 8 142 the the DT 19613 8 143 year year NN 19613 8 144 200 200 CD 19613 8 145 , , , 19613 8 146 nor nor CC 19613 8 147 in in IN 19613 8 148 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8 149 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8 150 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8 151 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8 152 ; ; : 19613 8 153 Probable probable JJ 19613 8 154 history history NN 19613 8 155 of of IN 19613 8 156 the the DT 19613 8 157 genesis genesis NN 19613 8 158 of of IN 19613 8 159 the the DT 19613 8 160 New New NNP 19613 8 161 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8 162 in in IN 19613 8 163 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8 164 up up RP 19613 8 165 to to IN 19613 8 166 the the DT 19613 8 167 time time NN 19613 8 168 of of IN 19613 8 169 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8 170 ; ; : 19613 8 171 ADDENDUM ADDENDUM NNP 19613 8 172 . . . 19613 9 1 The the DT 19613 9 2 results result NNS 19613 9 3 which which WDT 19613 9 4 the the DT 19613 9 5 creation creation NN 19613 9 6 of of IN 19613 9 7 the the DT 19613 9 8 New New NNP 19613 9 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 9 10 produced produce VBD 19613 9 11 in in IN 19613 9 12 the the DT 19613 9 13 following following JJ 19613 9 14 period period NN 19613 9 15 . . . 19613 10 1 C. C. NNP 19613 10 2 The the DT 19613 10 3 transformation transformation NN 19613 10 4 of of IN 19613 10 5 the the DT 19613 10 6 Episcopal Episcopal NNP 19613 10 7 Office Office NNP 19613 10 8 in in IN 19613 10 9 the the DT 19613 10 10 Church Church NNP 19613 10 11 into into IN 19613 10 12 an an DT 19613 10 13 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 10 14 Office Office NNP 19613 10 15 . . . 19613 11 1 The the DT 19613 11 2 History history NN 19613 11 3 of of IN 19613 11 4 the the DT 19613 11 5 remodelling remodelling NN 19613 11 6 of of IN 19613 11 7 the the DT 19613 11 8 conception conception NN 19613 11 9 of of IN 19613 11 10 the the DT 19613 11 11 Church Church NNP 19613 11 12 The the DT 19613 11 13 legitimising legitimising NN 19613 11 14 of of IN 19613 11 15 the the DT 19613 11 16 Rule Rule NNP 19613 11 17 of of IN 19613 11 18 Faith Faith NNP 19613 11 19 by by IN 19613 11 20 the the DT 19613 11 21 Communities Communities NNPS 19613 11 22 which which WDT 19613 11 23 were be VBD 19613 11 24 founded found VBN 19613 11 25 by by IN 19613 11 26 the the DT 19613 11 27 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 11 28 ; ; : 19613 11 29 By by IN 19613 11 30 the the DT 19613 11 31 " " `` 19613 11 32 Elders Elders NNPS 19613 11 33 " " '' 19613 11 34 ; ; : 19613 11 35 By by IN 19613 11 36 the the DT 19613 11 37 Bishops Bishops NNPS 19613 11 38 of of IN 19613 11 39 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 11 40 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 11 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 11 42 disciples disciple NNS 19613 11 43 of of IN 19613 11 44 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 11 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 11 46 ; ; : 19613 11 47 By by IN 19613 11 48 the the DT 19613 11 49 Bishops Bishops NNPS 19613 11 50 as as IN 19613 11 51 such such JJ 19613 11 52 , , , 19613 11 53 who who WP 19613 11 54 have have VBP 19613 11 55 received receive VBN 19613 11 56 the the DT 19613 11 57 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 11 58 _ _ NNP 19613 11 59 Charisma Charisma NNP 19613 11 60 veritatis veritatis NN 19613 11 61 _ _ NNP 19613 11 62 ; ; : 19613 11 63 Excursus Excursus NNP 19613 11 64 on on IN 19613 11 65 the the DT 19613 11 66 conceptions conception NNS 19613 11 67 of of IN 19613 11 68 the the DT 19613 11 69 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 11 70 ; ; : 19613 11 71 The the DT 19613 11 72 Bishops Bishops NNPS 19613 11 73 as as IN 19613 11 74 successors successor NNS 19613 11 75 of of IN 19613 11 76 the the DT 19613 11 77 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 11 78 ; ; : 19613 11 79 Original original JJ 19613 11 80 idea idea NN 19613 11 81 of of IN 19613 11 82 the the DT 19613 11 83 Church Church NNP 19613 11 84 as as IN 19613 11 85 the the DT 19613 11 86 Holy Holy NNP 19613 11 87 Community Community NNP 19613 11 88 that that WDT 19613 11 89 comes come VBZ 19613 11 90 from from IN 19613 11 91 Heaven Heaven NNP 19613 11 92 and and CC 19613 11 93 is be VBZ 19613 11 94 destined destine VBN 19613 11 95 for for IN 19613 11 96 it -PRON- PRP 19613 11 97 ; ; : 19613 11 98 The the DT 19613 11 99 Church Church NNP 19613 11 100 as as IN 19613 11 101 the the DT 19613 11 102 empiric empiric NN 19613 11 103 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 11 104 Communion Communion NNP 19613 11 105 resting rest VBG 19613 11 106 on on IN 19613 11 107 the the DT 19613 11 108 Law Law NNP 19613 11 109 of of IN 19613 11 110 Faith Faith NNP 19613 11 111 ; ; : 19613 11 112 Obscurities obscurity NNS 19613 11 113 in in IN 19613 11 114 the the DT 19613 11 115 idea idea NN 19613 11 116 of of IN 19613 11 117 the the DT 19613 11 118 Church Church NNP 19613 11 119 as as IN 19613 11 120 held hold VBN 19613 11 121 by by IN 19613 11 122 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 11 123 and and CC 19613 11 124 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 11 125 ; ; : 19613 11 126 By by IN 19613 11 127 Clement Clement NNP 19613 11 128 and and CC 19613 11 129 Origen Origen NNP 19613 11 130 ; ; : 19613 11 131 Transition transition NN 19613 11 132 to to IN 19613 11 133 the the DT 19613 11 134 Hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 11 135 idea idea NN 19613 11 136 of of IN 19613 11 137 the the DT 19613 11 138 Church Church NNP 19613 11 139 ; ; : 19613 11 140 The the DT 19613 11 141 Hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 11 142 idea idea NN 19613 11 143 of of IN 19613 11 144 the the DT 19613 11 145 Church Church NNP 19613 11 146 : : : 19613 11 147 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 11 148 and and CC 19613 11 149 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 11 150 ; ; : 19613 11 151 Appendix Appendix NNP 19613 11 152 I. I. NNP 19613 11 153 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 11 154 's 's POS 19613 11 155 idea idea NN 19613 11 156 of of IN 19613 11 157 the the DT 19613 11 158 Church Church NNP 19613 11 159 and and CC 19613 11 160 the the DT 19613 11 161 actual actual JJ 19613 11 162 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 11 163 ; ; : 19613 11 164 Appendix Appendix NNP 19613 11 165 II II NNP 19613 11 166 . . . 19613 12 1 Church church NN 19613 12 2 and and CC 19613 12 3 Heresy Heresy NNP 19613 12 4 ; ; : 19613 12 5 Appendix Appendix NNP 19613 12 6 III III NNP 19613 12 7 . . . 19613 13 1 Uncertainties uncertainty NNS 19613 13 2 regarding regard VBG 19613 13 3 the the DT 19613 13 4 consequences consequence NNS 19613 13 5 of of IN 19613 13 6 the the DT 19613 13 7 new new JJ 19613 13 8 idea idea NN 19613 13 9 of of IN 19613 13 10 the the DT 19613 13 11 Church Church NNP 19613 13 12 . . . 19613 14 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 14 2 III.--Continuation.--The iii.--continuation.--the CD 19613 14 3 Old Old NNP 19613 14 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 14 5 and and CC 19613 14 6 the the DT 19613 14 7 New New NNP 19613 14 8 Church Church NNP 19613 14 9 Introduction introduction NN 19613 14 10 ; ; : 19613 14 11 The the DT 19613 14 12 Original Original NNP 19613 14 13 Montanism montanism NN 19613 14 14 ; ; : 19613 14 15 The the DT 19613 14 16 later later JJ 19613 14 17 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 14 18 as as IN 19613 14 19 the the DT 19613 14 20 dregs dreg NNS 19613 14 21 of of IN 19613 14 22 the the DT 19613 14 23 movement movement NN 19613 14 24 and and CC 19613 14 25 as as IN 19613 14 26 the the DT 19613 14 27 product product NN 19613 14 28 of of IN 19613 14 29 a a DT 19613 14 30 compromise compromise NN 19613 14 31 ; ; : 19613 14 32 The the DT 19613 14 33 opposition opposition NN 19613 14 34 to to IN 19613 14 35 the the DT 19613 14 36 demands demand NNS 19613 14 37 of of IN 19613 14 38 the the DT 19613 14 39 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 14 40 by by IN 19613 14 41 the the DT 19613 14 42 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 14 43 Bishops Bishops NNPS 19613 14 44 : : : 19613 14 45 importance importance NN 19613 14 46 of of IN 19613 14 47 the the DT 19613 14 48 victory victory NN 19613 14 49 for for IN 19613 14 50 the the DT 19613 14 51 Church Church NNP 19613 14 52 ; ; : 19613 14 53 History history NN 19613 14 54 of of IN 19613 14 55 penance penance NN 19613 14 56 : : : 19613 14 57 the the DT 19613 14 58 old old JJ 19613 14 59 practice practice NN 19613 14 60 ; ; : 19613 14 61 The the DT 19613 14 62 laxer laxer NN 19613 14 63 practice practice NN 19613 14 64 in in IN 19613 14 65 the the DT 19613 14 66 days day NNS 19613 14 67 of of IN 19613 14 68 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 14 69 and and CC 19613 14 70 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 14 71 ; ; : 19613 14 72 The the DT 19613 14 73 abolition abolition NN 19613 14 74 of of IN 19613 14 75 the the DT 19613 14 76 old old JJ 19613 14 77 practice practice NN 19613 14 78 in in IN 19613 14 79 the the DT 19613 14 80 days day NNS 19613 14 81 of of IN 19613 14 82 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 14 83 ; ; : 19613 14 84 Significance significance NN 19613 14 85 of of IN 19613 14 86 the the DT 19613 14 87 new new JJ 19613 14 88 kind kind NN 19613 14 89 of of IN 19613 14 90 penance penance NN 19613 14 91 for for IN 19613 14 92 the the DT 19613 14 93 idea idea NN 19613 14 94 of of IN 19613 14 95 the the DT 19613 14 96 Church Church NNP 19613 14 97 ; ; : 19613 14 98 the the DT 19613 14 99 Church church NN 19613 14 100 no no RB 19613 14 101 longer long RBR 19613 14 102 a a DT 19613 14 103 Communion Communion NNP 19613 14 104 of of IN 19613 14 105 Salvation Salvation NNP 19613 14 106 and and CC 19613 14 107 of of IN 19613 14 108 Saints saint NNS 19613 14 109 , , , 19613 14 110 but but CC 19613 14 111 a a DT 19613 14 112 condition condition NN 19613 14 113 of of IN 19613 14 114 Salvation Salvation NNP 19613 14 115 and and CC 19613 14 116 a a DT 19613 14 117 Holy Holy NNP 19613 14 118 Institution Institution NNP 19613 14 119 and and CC 19613 14 120 thereby thereby RB 19613 14 121 a a DT 19613 14 122 _ _ NNP 19613 14 123 corpus corpus NN 19613 14 124 permixtum permixtum NN 19613 14 125 _ _ NNP 19613 14 126 ; ; : 19613 14 127 After after IN 19613 14 128 effect effect NN 19613 14 129 of of IN 19613 14 130 the the DT 19613 14 131 old old JJ 19613 14 132 idea idea NN 19613 14 133 of of IN 19613 14 134 the the DT 19613 14 135 Church Church NNP 19613 14 136 in in IN 19613 14 137 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 14 138 ; ; : 19613 14 139 Origen Origen NNP 19613 14 140 's 's POS 19613 14 141 idea idea NN 19613 14 142 of of IN 19613 14 143 the the DT 19613 14 144 Church Church NNP 19613 14 145 ; ; : 19613 14 146 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 14 147 's 's POS 19613 14 148 idea idea NN 19613 14 149 of of IN 19613 14 150 the the DT 19613 14 151 Church Church NNP 19613 14 152 and and CC 19613 14 153 of of IN 19613 14 154 penance penance NN 19613 14 155 , , , 19613 14 156 the the DT 19613 14 157 Church Church NNP 19613 14 158 of of IN 19613 14 159 the the DT 19613 14 160 Catharists Catharists NNPS 19613 14 161 ; ; : 19613 14 162 Conclusion conclusion NN 19613 14 163 : : : 19613 14 164 the the DT 19613 14 165 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 14 166 Church Church NNP 19613 14 167 as as IN 19613 14 168 capable capable JJ 19613 14 169 of of IN 19613 14 170 being be VBG 19613 14 171 a a DT 19613 14 172 support support NN 19613 14 173 to to IN 19613 14 174 society society NN 19613 14 175 and and CC 19613 14 176 the the DT 19613 14 177 state state NN 19613 14 178 ; ; : 19613 14 179 Addenda Addenda NNP 19613 14 180 I. I. NNP 19613 15 1 The the DT 19613 15 2 Priesthood Priesthood NNP 19613 15 3 ; ; : 19613 15 4 Addenda Addenda NNP 19613 15 5 II II NNP 19613 15 6 . . . 19613 16 1 Sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 16 2 ; ; : 19613 16 3 Addenda Addenda NNP 19613 16 4 III III NNP 19613 16 5 . . . 19613 17 1 Means Means NNPS 19613 17 2 of of IN 19613 17 3 Grace Grace NNP 19613 17 4 . . . 19613 18 1 Baptism baptism NN 19613 18 2 and and CC 19613 18 3 the the DT 19613 18 4 Eucharist eucharist NN 19613 18 5 ; ; : 19613 18 6 Excursus Excursus NNP 19613 18 7 to to IN 19613 18 8 Chapters Chapters NNP 19613 18 9 II II NNP 19613 18 10 . . . 19613 19 1 and and CC 19613 19 2 III.--Catholic III.--Catholic NNP 19613 19 3 and and CC 19613 19 4 Roman Roman NNP 19613 19 5 . . . 19613 20 1 II ii CD 19613 20 2 . . . 19613 21 1 FIXING FIXING NNP 19613 21 2 AND and CC 19613 21 3 GRADUAL gradual NN 19613 21 4 HELLENISING HELLENISING NNP 19613 21 5 OF of IN 19613 21 6 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 21 7 AS as IN 19613 21 8 A a DT 19613 21 9 SYSTEM system NN 19613 21 10 OF of IN 19613 21 11 DOCTRINE DOCTRINE NNP 19613 21 12 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 21 13 IV.--Ecclesiastical IV.--Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 21 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 21 15 and and CC 19613 21 16 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 21 17 ; ; : 19613 21 18 The the DT 19613 21 19 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 21 20 1 1 CD 19613 21 21 . . . 19613 22 1 Introduction introduction NN 19613 22 2 The the DT 19613 22 3 historical historical JJ 19613 22 4 position position NN 19613 22 5 of of IN 19613 22 6 the the DT 19613 22 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 22 8 ; ; : 19613 22 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 22 10 and and CC 19613 22 11 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 22 12 ; ; : 19613 22 13 Nature nature NN 19613 22 14 and and CC 19613 22 15 importance importance NN 19613 22 16 of of IN 19613 22 17 the the DT 19613 22 18 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 22 19 ' ' POS 19613 22 20 theology theology NN 19613 22 21 . . . 19613 23 1 2 2 LS 19613 23 2 . . . 19613 24 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 24 2 as as IN 19613 24 3 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 24 4 and and CC 19613 24 5 as as IN 19613 24 6 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 24 7 Aristides Aristides NNPS 19613 24 8 ; ; : 19613 24 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 24 10 ; ; : 19613 24 11 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 24 12 ; ; : 19613 24 13 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 19613 24 14 , , , 19613 24 15 Melito Melito NNP 19613 24 16 ; ; : 19613 24 17 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 24 18 ; ; : 19613 24 19 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 24 20 - - HYPH 19613 24 21 Justin Justin NNP 19613 24 22 , , , 19613 24 23 Orat Orat NNP 19613 24 24 . . . 19613 25 1 ad ad NN 19613 25 2 Gr Gr NNP 19613 25 3 . . . 19613 26 1 ; ; : 19613 26 2 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 26 3 ; ; : 19613 26 4 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 26 5 - - HYPH 19613 26 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 26 7 , , , 19613 26 8 de de NNP 19613 26 9 Resurr Resurr NNP 19613 26 10 . . . 19613 27 1 ; ; : 19613 27 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 27 3 and and CC 19613 27 4 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 27 5 ; ; : 19613 27 6 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 27 7 - - HYPH 19613 27 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 27 9 , , , 19613 27 10 de de NNP 19613 27 11 Monarch Monarch NNP 19613 27 12 . . . 19613 28 1 ; ; : 19613 28 2 Results result NNS 19613 28 3 . . . 19613 29 1 3 3 LS 19613 29 2 . . . 19613 30 1 The the DT 19613 30 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 30 3 of of IN 19613 30 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 30 5 as as IN 19613 30 6 the the DT 19613 30 7 revealed revealed JJ 19613 30 8 and and CC 19613 30 9 rational rational JJ 19613 30 10 religion religion NN 19613 30 11 Arrangement arrangement NN 19613 30 12 ; ; : 19613 30 13 The the DT 19613 30 14 Monotheistic Monotheistic NNP 19613 30 15 Cosmology Cosmology NNP 19613 30 16 ; ; : 19613 30 17 Theology Theology NNP 19613 30 18 ; ; : 19613 30 19 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 30 20 of of IN 19613 30 21 the the DT 19613 30 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 30 23 ; ; : 19613 30 24 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 30 25 of of IN 19613 30 26 the the DT 19613 30 27 World World NNP 19613 30 28 and and CC 19613 30 29 of of IN 19613 30 30 Man Man NNP 19613 30 31 ; ; : 19613 30 32 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 30 33 of of IN 19613 30 34 Freedom Freedom NNP 19613 30 35 and and CC 19613 30 36 Morality Morality NNP 19613 30 37 ; ; : 19613 30 38 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 30 39 of of IN 19613 30 40 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 30 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 30 42 Proofs Proofs NNP 19613 30 43 from from IN 19613 30 44 Prophecy Prophecy NNP 19613 30 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 30 46 ; ; : 19613 30 47 Significance significance NN 19613 30 48 of of IN 19613 30 49 the the DT 19613 30 50 History history NN 19613 30 51 of of IN 19613 30 52 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 30 53 ; ; : 19613 30 54 Christology Christology NNP 19613 30 55 of of IN 19613 30 56 Justin Justin NNP 19613 30 57 ; ; : 19613 30 58 Interpretation Interpretation NNP 19613 30 59 and and CC 19613 30 60 Criticism Criticism NNP 19613 30 61 , , , 19613 30 62 especially especially RB 19613 30 63 of of IN 19613 30 64 Justin Justin NNP 19613 30 65 's 's POS 19613 30 66 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 30 67 . . . 19613 31 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 19613 31 2 V.--The V.--The NNS 19613 31 3 Beginnings beginning NNS 19613 31 4 of of IN 19613 31 5 an an DT 19613 31 6 Ecclesiastico Ecclesiastico NNP 19613 31 7 - - HYPH 19613 31 8 theological theological JJ 19613 31 9 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 31 10 and and CC 19613 31 11 revision revision NN 19613 31 12 of of IN 19613 31 13 the the DT 19613 31 14 Rule Rule NNP 19613 31 15 of of IN 19613 31 16 Faith Faith NNP 19613 31 17 in in IN 19613 31 18 opposition opposition NN 19613 31 19 to to IN 19613 31 20 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 31 21 , , , 19613 31 22 on on IN 19613 31 23 the the DT 19613 31 24 basis basis NN 19613 31 25 of of IN 19613 31 26 the the DT 19613 31 27 New New NNP 19613 31 28 Testament Testament NNP 19613 31 29 and and CC 19613 31 30 the the DT 19613 31 31 Christian Christian NNP 19613 31 32 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 31 33 of of IN 19613 31 34 the the DT 19613 31 35 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 31 36 , , , 19613 31 37 Melito Melito NNP 19613 31 38 , , , 19613 31 39 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 31 40 , , , 19613 31 41 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 31 42 , , , 19613 31 43 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 31 44 , , , 19613 31 45 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 31 46 1 1 CD 19613 31 47 . . . 19613 32 1 The the DT 19613 32 2 theological theological JJ 19613 32 3 position position NN 19613 32 4 of of IN 19613 32 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 32 6 and and CC 19613 32 7 of of IN 19613 32 8 the the DT 19613 32 9 later later JJ 19613 32 10 contemporary contemporary JJ 19613 32 11 Church Church NNP 19613 32 12 teachers teacher VBZ 19613 32 13 Characteristics Characteristics NNP 19613 32 14 of of IN 19613 32 15 the the DT 19613 32 16 theology theology NN 19613 32 17 of of IN 19613 32 18 the the DT 19613 32 19 Old Old NNP 19613 32 20 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 32 21 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 32 22 , , , 19613 32 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 32 24 wavering wavering NN 19613 32 25 between between IN 19613 32 26 Reason Reason NNP 19613 32 27 and and CC 19613 32 28 Tradition tradition NN 19613 32 29 ; ; , 19613 32 30 Loose loose JJ 19613 32 31 structure structure NN 19613 32 32 of of IN 19613 32 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 32 34 Dogmas Dogmas NNPS 19613 32 35 ; ; : 19613 32 36 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 32 37 ' ' POS 19613 32 38 attempt attempt NN 19613 32 39 to to TO 19613 32 40 construct construct VB 19613 32 41 a a DT 19613 32 42 systematic systematic JJ 19613 32 43 theology theology NN 19613 32 44 and and CC 19613 32 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 32 46 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 32 47 theological theological JJ 19613 32 48 convictions conviction NNS 19613 32 49 ; ; : 19613 32 50 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 32 51 and and CC 19613 32 52 anti anti JJ 19613 32 53 - - JJ 19613 32 54 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 32 55 features feature NNS 19613 32 56 of of IN 19613 32 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 32 58 theology theology NN 19613 32 59 ; ; : 19613 32 60 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 32 61 conceived conceive VBD 19613 32 62 as as IN 19613 32 63 a a DT 19613 32 64 real real JJ 19613 32 65 redemption redemption NN 19613 32 66 by by IN 19613 32 67 Christ Christ NNP 19613 32 68 ( ( -LRB- 19613 32 69 recapitulatio recapitulatio NN 19613 32 70 ) ) -RRB- 19613 32 71 ; ; : 19613 32 72 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 32 73 conception conception NN 19613 32 74 of of IN 19613 32 75 a a DT 19613 32 76 history history NN 19613 32 77 of of IN 19613 32 78 salvation salvation NN 19613 32 79 ; ; . 19613 32 80 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 32 81 historical historical JJ 19613 32 82 significance significance NN 19613 32 83 : : : 19613 32 84 conserving conserve VBG 19613 32 85 of of IN 19613 32 86 tradition tradition NN 19613 32 87 and and CC 19613 32 88 gradual gradual JJ 19613 32 89 hellenising hellenising NN 19613 32 90 of of IN 19613 32 91 the the DT 19613 32 92 Rule Rule NNP 19613 32 93 of of IN 19613 32 94 Faith Faith NNP 19613 32 95 . . . 19613 33 1 2 2 LS 19613 33 2 . . . 19613 34 1 The the DT 19613 34 2 Old Old NNP 19613 34 3 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 34 4 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 34 5 ' ' POS 19613 34 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 7 of of IN 19613 34 8 the the DT 19613 34 9 Church Church NNP 19613 34 10 The The NNP 19613 34 11 Antithesis Antithesis NNP 19613 34 12 to to IN 19613 34 13 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 34 14 ; ; : 19613 34 15 The the DT 19613 34 16 " " `` 19613 34 17 Scripture scripture NN 19613 34 18 theology theology NN 19613 34 19 " " '' 19613 34 20 as as IN 19613 34 21 a a DT 19613 34 22 sign sign NN 19613 34 23 of of IN 19613 34 24 the the DT 19613 34 25 dependence dependence NN 19613 34 26 on on IN 19613 34 27 " " `` 19613 34 28 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 34 29 " " '' 19613 34 30 and and CC 19613 34 31 as as IN 19613 34 32 a a DT 19613 34 33 means means NN 19613 34 34 of of IN 19613 34 35 conserving conserve VBG 19613 34 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 34 37 ; ; : 19613 34 38 The the DT 19613 34 39 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 34 40 of of IN 19613 34 41 God God NNP 19613 34 42 ; ; : 19613 34 43 The the DT 19613 34 44 Logos Logos NNP 19613 34 45 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 34 46 of of IN 19613 34 47 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 34 48 and and CC 19613 34 49 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 34 50 ; ; : 19613 34 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 34 52 Conceptions conception NNS 19613 34 53 regarding regard VBG 19613 34 54 the the DT 19613 34 55 Holy Holy NNP 19613 34 56 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 34 57 ) ) -RRB- 19613 34 58 ; ; : 19613 34 59 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 34 60 ' ' POS 19613 34 61 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 62 of of IN 19613 34 63 the the DT 19613 34 64 Logos Logos NNP 19613 34 65 ; ; : 19613 34 66 ( ( -LRB- 19613 34 67 Conceptions conception NNS 19613 34 68 regarding regard VBG 19613 34 69 the the DT 19613 34 70 Holy Holy NNP 19613 34 71 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 34 72 ) ) -RRB- 19613 34 73 ; ; : 19613 34 74 The the DT 19613 34 75 views view NNS 19613 34 76 of of IN 19613 34 77 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 34 78 regarding regard VBG 19613 34 79 the the DT 19613 34 80 destination destination NN 19613 34 81 of of IN 19613 34 82 man man NN 19613 34 83 , , , 19613 34 84 the the DT 19613 34 85 original original JJ 19613 34 86 state state NN 19613 34 87 , , , 19613 34 88 the the DT 19613 34 89 fall fall NN 19613 34 90 and and CC 19613 34 91 the the DT 19613 34 92 doom doom NN 19613 34 93 of of IN 19613 34 94 death death NN 19613 34 95 ( ( -LRB- 19613 34 96 the the DT 19613 34 97 disparate disparate JJ 19613 34 98 series series NN 19613 34 99 of of IN 19613 34 100 ideas idea NNS 19613 34 101 in in IN 19613 34 102 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 34 103 ; ; : 19613 34 104 rudiments rudiment NNS 19613 34 105 of of IN 19613 34 106 the the DT 19613 34 107 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 108 of of IN 19613 34 109 original original JJ 19613 34 110 sin sin NN 19613 34 111 in in IN 19613 34 112 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 34 113 ) ) -RRB- 19613 34 114 ; ; : 19613 34 115 The the DT 19613 34 116 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 117 of of IN 19613 34 118 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 34 119 Christ Christ NNP 19613 34 120 as as IN 19613 34 121 the the DT 19613 34 122 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 34 123 son son NN 19613 34 124 of of IN 19613 34 125 God God NNP 19613 34 126 ; ; : 19613 34 127 Assertion assertion NN 19613 34 128 of of IN 19613 34 129 the the DT 19613 34 130 complete complete JJ 19613 34 131 mixture mixture NN 19613 34 132 and and CC 19613 34 133 unity unity NN 19613 34 134 of of IN 19613 34 135 the the DT 19613 34 136 divine divine JJ 19613 34 137 and and CC 19613 34 138 human human JJ 19613 34 139 elements element NNS 19613 34 140 ; ; : 19613 34 141 Significance significance NN 19613 34 142 of of IN 19613 34 143 Mary Mary NNP 19613 34 144 ; ; : 19613 34 145 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 34 146 's 's POS 19613 34 147 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 148 of of IN 19613 34 149 the the DT 19613 34 150 two two CD 19613 34 151 natures nature NNS 19613 34 152 and and CC 19613 34 153 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 34 154 origin origin NN 19613 34 155 ; ; : 19613 34 156 Rudiments rudiment NNS 19613 34 157 of of IN 19613 34 158 this this DT 19613 34 159 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 160 in in IN 19613 34 161 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 34 162 ; ; : 19613 34 163 The the DT 19613 34 164 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 34 165 character character NN 19613 34 166 of of IN 19613 34 167 this this DT 19613 34 168 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 169 ; ; : 19613 34 170 Christology Christology NNP 19613 34 171 of of IN 19613 34 172 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 34 173 ; ; : 19613 34 174 Views view NNS 19613 34 175 as as IN 19613 34 176 to to IN 19613 34 177 Christ Christ NNP 19613 34 178 's 's POS 19613 34 179 work work NN 19613 34 180 ; ; : 19613 34 181 Redemption Redemption NNP 19613 34 182 , , , 19613 34 183 Perfection Perfection NNP 19613 34 184 ; ; : 19613 34 185 Reconciliation Reconciliation NNP 19613 34 186 ; ; : 19613 34 187 Categories category NNS 19613 34 188 for for IN 19613 34 189 the the DT 19613 34 190 fruit fruit NN 19613 34 191 of of IN 19613 34 192 Christ Christ NNP 19613 34 193 's 's POS 19613 34 194 work work NN 19613 34 195 ; ; : 19613 34 196 Things thing NNS 19613 34 197 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 34 198 to to IN 19613 34 199 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 34 200 ; ; : 19613 34 201 Satisfacere Satisfacere NNP 19613 34 202 Deo Deo NNP 19613 34 203 ; ; : 19613 34 204 The the DT 19613 34 205 Soul Soul NNP 19613 34 206 as as IN 19613 34 207 the the DT 19613 34 208 Bride Bride NNP 19613 34 209 of of IN 19613 34 210 Christ Christ NNP 19613 34 211 ; ; : 19613 34 212 The the DT 19613 34 213 Eschatology Eschatology NNP 19613 34 214 ; ; : 19613 34 215 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 34 216 archaic archaic JJ 19613 34 217 nature nature NN 19613 34 218 , , , 19613 34 219 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 34 220 incompatibility incompatibility NN 19613 34 221 with with IN 19613 34 222 speculation speculation NN 19613 34 223 and and CC 19613 34 224 the the DT 19613 34 225 advantage advantage NN 19613 34 226 of of IN 19613 34 227 connection connection NN 19613 34 228 with with IN 19613 34 229 that that DT 19613 34 230 ; ; : 19613 34 231 Conflict conflict NN 19613 34 232 with with IN 19613 34 233 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 34 234 in in IN 19613 34 235 the the DT 19613 34 236 East East NNP 19613 34 237 ; ; : 19613 34 238 The the DT 19613 34 239 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 34 240 of of IN 19613 34 241 the the DT 19613 34 242 two two CD 19613 34 243 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 34 244 ; ; : 19613 34 245 The the DT 19613 34 246 influence influence NN 19613 34 247 of of IN 19613 34 248 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 34 249 on on IN 19613 34 250 the the DT 19613 34 251 estimate estimate NN 19613 34 252 of of IN 19613 34 253 the the DT 19613 34 254 two two CD 19613 34 255 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 34 256 , , , 19613 34 257 the the DT 19613 34 258 _ _ NNP 19613 34 259 complexus complexus NN 19613 34 260 oppositorum oppositorum NNP 19613 34 261 _ _ NNP 19613 34 262 ; ; : 19613 34 263 the the DT 19613 34 264 Old Old NNP 19613 34 265 Testament Testament NNP 19613 34 266 a a DT 19613 34 267 uniform uniform JJ 19613 34 268 Christian Christian NNP 19613 34 269 Book Book NNP 19613 34 270 as as IN 19613 34 271 in in IN 19613 34 272 the the DT 19613 34 273 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 34 274 ; ; : 19613 34 275 The The NNP 19613 34 276 Old Old NNP 19613 34 277 Testament Testament NNP 19613 34 278 a a DT 19613 34 279 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 34 280 stage stage NN 19613 34 281 of of IN 19613 34 282 the the DT 19613 34 283 New New NNP 19613 34 284 Testament Testament NNP 19613 34 285 and and CC 19613 34 286 a a DT 19613 34 287 compound compound NN 19613 34 288 Book Book NNP 19613 34 289 ; ; : 19613 34 290 The the DT 19613 34 291 stages stage NNS 19613 34 292 in in IN 19613 34 293 the the DT 19613 34 294 history history NN 19613 34 295 of of IN 19613 34 296 salvation salvation NN 19613 34 297 ; ; : 19613 34 298 The the DT 19613 34 299 law law NN 19613 34 300 of of IN 19613 34 301 freedom freedom NN 19613 34 302 the the DT 19613 34 303 climax climax NN 19613 34 304 of of IN 19613 34 305 the the DT 19613 34 306 revelation revelation NN 19613 34 307 in in IN 19613 34 308 Christ Christ NNP 19613 34 309 . . . 19613 35 1 3 3 LS 19613 35 2 . . . 19613 36 1 Results result NNS 19613 36 2 to to IN 19613 36 3 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 36 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 36 5 , , , 19613 36 6 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 36 7 in in IN 19613 36 8 the the DT 19613 36 9 West West NNP 19613 36 10 , , , 19613 36 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 36 12 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 36 13 , , , 19613 36 14 Novation Novation NNP 19613 36 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 36 16 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 36 17 VI.--The VI.--The NNP 19613 36 18 Transformation Transformation NNP 19613 36 19 of of IN 19613 36 20 the the DT 19613 36 21 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 36 22 Tradition Tradition NNP 19613 36 23 into into IN 19613 36 24 a a DT 19613 36 25 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 36 26 of of IN 19613 36 27 Religion religion NN 19613 36 28 , , , 19613 36 29 or or CC 19613 36 30 the the DT 19613 36 31 Origin Origin NNP 19613 36 32 of of IN 19613 36 33 the the DT 19613 36 34 Scientific Scientific NNP 19613 36 35 Theology Theology NNP 19613 36 36 and and CC 19613 36 37 Dogmatic Dogmatic NNP 19613 36 38 of of IN 19613 36 39 the the DT 19613 36 40 Church Church NNP 19613 36 41 : : : 19613 36 42 Clement Clement NNP 19613 36 43 and and CC 19613 36 44 Origen Origen NNP 19613 36 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 36 46 1 1 LS 19613 36 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 36 48 The the DT 19613 36 49 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 36 50 Catechetical Catechetical NNP 19613 36 51 School School NNP 19613 36 52 and and CC 19613 36 53 Clement Clement NNP 19613 36 54 of of IN 19613 36 55 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 36 56 Schools Schools NNPS 19613 36 57 and and CC 19613 36 58 Teachers Teachers NNPS 19613 36 59 in in IN 19613 36 60 the the DT 19613 36 61 Church Church NNP 19613 36 62 at at IN 19613 36 63 the the DT 19613 36 64 end end NN 19613 36 65 of of IN 19613 36 66 the the DT 19613 36 67 second second JJ 19613 36 68 and and CC 19613 36 69 the the DT 19613 36 70 beginning beginning NN 19613 36 71 of of IN 19613 36 72 the the DT 19613 36 73 third third JJ 19613 36 74 century century NN 19613 36 75 ; ; : 19613 36 76 scientific scientific JJ 19613 36 77 efforts effort NNS 19613 36 78 ( ( -LRB- 19613 36 79 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 36 80 in in IN 19613 36 81 Asia Asia NNP 19613 36 82 Minor Minor NNP 19613 36 83 , , , 19613 36 84 Cappadocian Cappadocian NNP 19613 36 85 Scholars Scholars NNPS 19613 36 86 , , , 19613 36 87 Bardesanes Bardesanes NNPS 19613 36 88 of of IN 19613 36 89 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 36 90 , , , 19613 36 91 Julius Julius NNP 19613 36 92 Africanus Africanus NNP 19613 36 93 , , , 19613 36 94 Scholars Scholars NNPS 19613 36 95 in in IN 19613 36 96 Palestine Palestine NNP 19613 36 97 , , , 19613 36 98 Rome Rome NNP 19613 36 99 and and CC 19613 36 100 Carthage Carthage NNP 19613 36 101 ) ) -RRB- 19613 36 102 ; ; : 19613 36 103 The the DT 19613 36 104 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 36 105 Catechetical Catechetical NNP 19613 36 106 School School NNP 19613 36 107 . . . 19613 37 1 Clement clement NN 19613 37 2 ; ; : 19613 37 3 The the DT 19613 37 4 temper temper NN 19613 37 5 of of IN 19613 37 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 37 7 and and CC 19613 37 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 37 9 importance importance NN 19613 37 10 in in IN 19613 37 11 the the DT 19613 37 12 History History NNP 19613 37 13 of of IN 19613 37 14 Dogma Dogma NNP 19613 37 15 ; ; : 19613 37 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 37 17 relation relation NN 19613 37 18 to to IN 19613 37 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 37 20 , , , 19613 37 21 to to IN 19613 37 22 the the DT 19613 37 23 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 37 24 and and CC 19613 37 25 to to IN 19613 37 26 primitive primitive JJ 19613 37 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 37 28 ; ; : 19613 37 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 37 30 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 37 31 of of IN 19613 37 32 Religion religion NN 19613 37 33 ; ; : 19613 37 34 Clement Clement NNP 19613 37 35 and and CC 19613 37 36 Origen Origen NNP 19613 37 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 37 38 2 2 LS 19613 37 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 37 40 The the DT 19613 37 41 system system NN 19613 37 42 of of IN 19613 37 43 Origen Origen NNP 19613 37 44 Introductory Introductory NNP 19613 37 45 : : : 19613 37 46 The the DT 19613 37 47 personality personality NN 19613 37 48 and and CC 19613 37 49 importance importance NN 19613 37 50 of of IN 19613 37 51 Origen Origen NNP 19613 37 52 ; ; : 19613 37 53 The the DT 19613 37 54 Elements Elements NNPS 19613 37 55 of of IN 19613 37 56 Origen Origen NNP 19613 37 57 's 's POS 19613 37 58 theology theology NN 19613 37 59 ; ; : 19613 37 60 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 37 61 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 37 62 features feature NNS 19613 37 63 ; ; : 19613 37 64 The the DT 19613 37 65 relative relative JJ 19613 37 66 view view NN 19613 37 67 of of IN 19613 37 68 Origen Origen NNP 19613 37 69 ; ; : 19613 37 70 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 37 71 temper temper NN 19613 37 72 and and CC 19613 37 73 final final JJ 19613 37 74 aim aim NN 19613 37 75 : : : 19613 37 76 relation relation NN 19613 37 77 to to IN 19613 37 78 Greek Greek NNP 19613 37 79 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 37 80 ; ; : 19613 37 81 Theology Theology NNP 19613 37 82 as as IN 19613 37 83 a a DT 19613 37 84 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 37 85 of of IN 19613 37 86 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 37 87 , , , 19613 37 88 and and CC 19613 37 89 a a DT 19613 37 90 cosmological cosmological JJ 19613 37 91 speculation speculation NN 19613 37 92 ; ; : 19613 37 93 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 37 94 on on IN 19613 37 95 Origen Origen NNP 19613 37 96 ; ; : 19613 37 97 The the DT 19613 37 98 neutralising neutralising NN 19613 37 99 of of IN 19613 37 100 History history NN 19613 37 101 , , , 19613 37 102 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 37 103 and and CC 19613 37 104 exoteric exoteric JJ 19613 37 105 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 37 106 ; ; , 19613 37 107 Fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 37 108 ideas idea NNS 19613 37 109 and and CC 19613 37 110 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 37 111 of of IN 19613 37 112 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 37 113 system system NN 19613 37 114 ; ; : 19613 37 115 Sources source NNS 19613 37 116 of of IN 19613 37 117 truth truth NN 19613 37 118 , , , 19613 37 119 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 37 120 of of IN 19613 37 121 Scripture scripture NN 19613 37 122 . . . 19613 38 1 I. I. NNP 19613 39 1 The the DT 19613 39 2 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 39 3 of of IN 19613 39 4 God God NNP 19613 39 5 and and CC 19613 39 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 39 7 unfolding unfold VBG 19613 39 8 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 39 9 of of IN 19613 39 10 God God NNP 19613 39 11 ; ; : 19613 39 12 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 39 13 of of IN 19613 39 14 the the DT 19613 39 15 Logos Logos NNP 19613 39 16 ; ; : 19613 39 17 Clement Clement NNP 19613 39 18 's 's POS 19613 39 19 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 39 20 of of IN 19613 39 21 the the DT 19613 39 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 39 23 ; ; : 19613 39 24 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 39 25 of of IN 19613 39 26 the the DT 19613 39 27 Holy Holy NNP 19613 39 28 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 39 29 ; ; : 19613 39 30 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 39 31 of of IN 19613 39 32 Spirits Spirits NNPS 19613 39 33 . . . 19613 40 1 II ii CD 19613 40 2 . . . 19613 41 1 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 41 2 of of IN 19613 41 3 the the DT 19613 41 4 Fall Fall NNP 19613 41 5 and and CC 19613 41 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 41 7 consequences consequence NNS 19613 41 8 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 41 9 of of IN 19613 41 10 Man Man NNP 19613 41 11 III III NNP 19613 41 12 . . . 19613 42 1 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 42 2 of of IN 19613 42 3 Redemption Redemption NNP 19613 42 4 and and CC 19613 42 5 Restoration Restoration NNP 19613 42 6 The the DT 19613 42 7 notions notion NNS 19613 42 8 necessary necessary JJ 19613 42 9 to to IN 19613 42 10 the the DT 19613 42 11 Psychical Psychical NNP 19613 42 12 ; ; : 19613 42 13 The the DT 19613 42 14 Christology Christology NNP 19613 42 15 ; ; : 19613 42 16 The the DT 19613 42 17 Appropriation Appropriation NNP 19613 42 18 of of IN 19613 42 19 Salvation Salvation NNP 19613 42 20 ; ; : 19613 42 21 The the DT 19613 42 22 Eschatology Eschatology NNP 19613 42 23 ; ; : 19613 42 24 Concluding Concluding NNP 19613 42 25 Remarks Remarks NNPS 19613 42 26 : : : 19613 42 27 The the DT 19613 42 28 importance importance NN 19613 42 29 of of IN 19613 42 30 this this DT 19613 42 31 system system NN 19613 42 32 to to IN 19613 42 33 the the DT 19613 42 34 following follow VBG 19613 42 35 period period NN 19613 42 36 . . . 19613 43 1 DIVISION division NN 19613 43 2 I -PRON- PRP 19613 43 3 BOOK BOOK VBD 19613 43 4 II ii CD 19613 43 5 . . . 19613 44 1 THE the DT 19613 44 2 LAYING laying NN 19613 44 3 OF of IN 19613 44 4 THE the DT 19613 44 5 FOUNDATIONS foundation NNS 19613 44 6 . . . 19613 45 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 45 2 I. I. NNP 19613 46 1 HISTORICAL HISTORICAL NNP 19613 46 2 SURVEY SURVEY NNP 19613 46 3 . . . 19613 47 1 The the DT 19613 47 2 second second JJ 19613 47 3 century century NN 19613 47 4 of of IN 19613 47 5 the the DT 19613 47 6 existence existence NN 19613 47 7 of of IN 19613 47 8 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 47 9 - - HYPH 19613 47 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 47 11 communities community NNS 19613 47 12 was be VBD 19613 47 13 characterised characterise VBN 19613 47 14 by by IN 19613 47 15 the the DT 19613 47 16 victorious victorious JJ 19613 47 17 conflict conflict NN 19613 47 18 with with IN 19613 47 19 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 47 20 and and CC 19613 47 21 the the DT 19613 47 22 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 47 23 Church Church NNP 19613 47 24 , , , 19613 47 25 by by IN 19613 47 26 the the DT 19613 47 27 gradual gradual JJ 19613 47 28 development development NN 19613 47 29 of of IN 19613 47 30 an an DT 19613 47 31 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 47 32 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 47 33 , , , 19613 47 34 and and CC 19613 47 35 by by IN 19613 47 36 the the DT 19613 47 37 decay decay NN 19613 47 38 of of IN 19613 47 39 the the DT 19613 47 40 early early JJ 19613 47 41 Christian christian JJ 19613 47 42 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 47 43 . . . 19613 48 1 The the DT 19613 48 2 general general JJ 19613 48 3 result result NN 19613 48 4 was be VBD 19613 48 5 the the DT 19613 48 6 establishment establishment NN 19613 48 7 of of IN 19613 48 8 a a DT 19613 48 9 great great JJ 19613 48 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 48 11 association association NN 19613 48 12 , , , 19613 48 13 which which WDT 19613 48 14 , , , 19613 48 15 forming form VBG 19613 48 16 at at IN 19613 48 17 one one CD 19613 48 18 and and CC 19613 48 19 the the DT 19613 48 20 same same JJ 19613 48 21 time time NN 19613 48 22 a a DT 19613 48 23 political political JJ 19613 48 24 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 48 25 , , , 19613 48 26 school school NN 19613 48 27 and and CC 19613 48 28 union union NN 19613 48 29 for for IN 19613 48 30 worship worship NN 19613 48 31 , , , 19613 48 32 was be VBD 19613 48 33 based base VBN 19613 48 34 on on IN 19613 48 35 the the DT 19613 48 36 firm firm JJ 19613 48 37 foundation foundation NN 19613 48 38 of of IN 19613 48 39 an an DT 19613 48 40 " " `` 19613 48 41 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 48 42 " " '' 19613 48 43 law law NN 19613 48 44 of of IN 19613 48 45 faith faith NN 19613 48 46 , , , 19613 48 47 a a DT 19613 48 48 collection collection NN 19613 48 49 of of IN 19613 48 50 " " `` 19613 48 51 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 48 52 " " '' 19613 48 53 writings writing NNS 19613 48 54 , , , 19613 48 55 and and CC 19613 48 56 finally finally RB 19613 48 57 , , , 19613 48 58 an an DT 19613 48 59 " " `` 19613 48 60 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 48 61 " " '' 19613 48 62 organisation organisation NN 19613 48 63 . . . 19613 49 1 This this DT 19613 49 2 institution institution NN 19613 49 3 was be VBD 19613 49 4 _ _ NNP 19613 49 5 the the DT 19613 49 6 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 49 7 Church Church NNP 19613 49 8 _ _ NNP 19613 49 9 . . . 19613 50 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 50 2 1 1 LS 19613 50 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 50 4 In in IN 19613 50 5 opposition opposition NN 19613 50 6 to to IN 19613 50 7 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 50 8 and and CC 19613 50 9 Marcionitism Marcionitism NNP 19613 50 10 , , , 19613 50 11 the the DT 19613 50 12 main main JJ 19613 50 13 articles article NNS 19613 50 14 forming form VBG 19613 50 15 the the DT 19613 50 16 estate estate NN 19613 50 17 and and CC 19613 50 18 possession possession NN 19613 50 19 of of IN 19613 50 20 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 50 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 50 22 were be VBD 19613 50 23 raised raise VBN 19613 50 24 to to IN 19613 50 25 the the DT 19613 50 26 rank rank NN 19613 50 27 of of IN 19613 50 28 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 50 29 regulations regulation NNS 19613 50 30 and and CC 19613 50 31 laws law NNS 19613 50 32 , , , 19613 50 33 and and CC 19613 50 34 thereby thereby RB 19613 50 35 placed place VBN 19613 50 36 beyond beyond IN 19613 50 37 all all DT 19613 50 38 discussion discussion NN 19613 50 39 and and CC 19613 50 40 assault assault NN 19613 50 41 . . . 19613 51 1 At at IN 19613 51 2 first first RB 19613 51 3 the the DT 19613 51 4 innovations innovation NNS 19613 51 5 introduced introduce VBN 19613 51 6 by by IN 19613 51 7 this this DT 19613 51 8 were be VBD 19613 51 9 not not RB 19613 51 10 of of IN 19613 51 11 a a DT 19613 51 12 material material NN 19613 51 13 , , , 19613 51 14 but but CC 19613 51 15 of of IN 19613 51 16 a a DT 19613 51 17 formal formal JJ 19613 51 18 , , , 19613 51 19 character character NN 19613 51 20 . . . 19613 52 1 Hence hence RB 19613 52 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 52 3 were be VBD 19613 52 4 not not RB 19613 52 5 noticed notice VBN 19613 52 6 by by IN 19613 52 7 any any DT 19613 52 8 of of IN 19613 52 9 those those DT 19613 52 10 who who WP 19613 52 11 had have VBD 19613 52 12 never never RB 19613 52 13 , , , 19613 52 14 or or CC 19613 52 15 only only RB 19613 52 16 in in IN 19613 52 17 a a DT 19613 52 18 vague vague JJ 19613 52 19 fashion fashion NN 19613 52 20 , , , 19613 52 21 been be VBN 19613 52 22 elevated elevate VBN 19613 52 23 to to IN 19613 52 24 the the DT 19613 52 25 feeling feeling NN 19613 52 26 and and CC 19613 52 27 idea idea NN 19613 52 28 of of IN 19613 52 29 freedom freedom NN 19613 52 30 and and CC 19613 52 31 independence independence NN 19613 52 32 in in IN 19613 52 33 religion religion NN 19613 52 34 . . . 19613 53 1 How how WRB 19613 53 2 great great JJ 19613 53 3 the the DT 19613 53 4 innovations innovation NNS 19613 53 5 actually actually RB 19613 53 6 were be VBD 19613 53 7 , , , 19613 53 8 however however RB 19613 53 9 , , , 19613 53 10 may may MD 19613 53 11 be be VB 19613 53 12 measured measure VBN 19613 53 13 by by IN 19613 53 14 the the DT 19613 53 15 fact fact NN 19613 53 16 that that IN 19613 53 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 53 18 signified signify VBD 19613 53 19 a a DT 19613 53 20 scholastic scholastic JJ 19613 53 21 tutelage tutelage NN 19613 53 22 of of IN 19613 53 23 the the DT 19613 53 24 faith faith NN 19613 53 25 of of IN 19613 53 26 the the DT 19613 53 27 individual individual JJ 19613 53 28 Christian Christian NNP 19613 53 29 , , , 19613 53 30 and and CC 19613 53 31 restricted restrict VBD 19613 53 32 the the DT 19613 53 33 immediateness immediateness NN 19613 53 34 of of IN 19613 53 35 religious religious JJ 19613 53 36 feelings feeling NNS 19613 53 37 and and CC 19613 53 38 ideas idea NNS 19613 53 39 to to IN 19613 53 40 the the DT 19613 53 41 narrowest narrow JJS 19613 53 42 limits limit NNS 19613 53 43 . . . 19613 54 1 But but CC 19613 54 2 the the DT 19613 54 3 conflict conflict NN 19613 54 4 with with IN 19613 54 5 the the DT 19613 54 6 so so RB 19613 54 7 - - HYPH 19613 54 8 called call VBN 19613 54 9 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 54 10 showed show VBD 19613 54 11 that that IN 19613 54 12 there there EX 19613 54 13 were be VBD 19613 54 14 still still RB 19613 54 15 a a DT 19613 54 16 considerable considerable JJ 19613 54 17 number number NN 19613 54 18 of of IN 19613 54 19 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 54 20 who who WP 19613 54 21 valued value VBD 19613 54 22 that that IN 19613 54 23 immediateness immediateness NN 19613 54 24 and and CC 19613 54 25 freedom freedom NN 19613 54 26 ; ; , 19613 54 27 these these DT 19613 54 28 were be VBD 19613 54 29 , , , 19613 54 30 however however RB 19613 54 31 , , , 19613 54 32 defeated defeat VBD 19613 54 33 . . . 19613 55 1 The the DT 19613 55 2 fixing fixing NN 19613 55 3 of of IN 19613 55 4 the the DT 19613 55 5 tradition tradition NN 19613 55 6 under under IN 19613 55 7 the the DT 19613 55 8 title title NN 19613 55 9 of of IN 19613 55 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 55 11 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 55 12 led lead VBD 19613 55 13 to to IN 19613 55 14 the the DT 19613 55 15 assumption assumption NN 19613 55 16 that that IN 19613 55 17 whoever whoever WP 19613 55 18 held hold VBD 19613 55 19 the the DT 19613 55 20 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 55 21 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 55 22 was be VBD 19613 55 23 also also RB 19613 55 24 essentially essentially RB 19613 55 25 a a DT 19613 55 26 Christian Christian NNP 19613 55 27 in in IN 19613 55 28 the the DT 19613 55 29 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 55 30 sense sense NN 19613 55 31 . . . 19613 56 1 This this DT 19613 56 2 assumption assumption NN 19613 56 3 , , , 19613 56 4 quite quite RB 19613 56 5 apart apart RB 19613 56 6 from from IN 19613 56 7 the the DT 19613 56 8 innovations innovation NNS 19613 56 9 which which WDT 19613 56 10 were be VBD 19613 56 11 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 56 12 by by IN 19613 56 13 tracing trace VBG 19613 56 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 56 15 to to IN 19613 56 16 the the DT 19613 56 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 56 18 , , , 19613 56 19 meant mean VBD 19613 56 20 the the DT 19613 56 21 separation separation NN 19613 56 22 of of IN 19613 56 23 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 56 24 and and CC 19613 56 25 conduct conduct NN 19613 56 26 , , , 19613 56 27 the the DT 19613 56 28 preference preference NN 19613 56 29 of of IN 19613 56 30 the the DT 19613 56 31 former former JJ 19613 56 32 to to IN 19613 56 33 the the DT 19613 56 34 latter latter JJ 19613 56 35 , , , 19613 56 36 and and CC 19613 56 37 the the DT 19613 56 38 transformation transformation NN 19613 56 39 of of IN 19613 56 40 a a DT 19613 56 41 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 56 42 of of IN 19613 56 43 faith faith NN 19613 56 44 , , , 19613 56 45 hope hope NN 19613 56 46 , , , 19613 56 47 and and CC 19613 56 48 discipline discipline VB 19613 56 49 into into IN 19613 56 50 a a DT 19613 56 51 communion communion NN 19613 56 52 " " `` 19613 56 53 eiusdem eiusdem JJ 19613 56 54 sacramenti sacramenti NN 19613 56 55 , , , 19613 56 56 " " '' 19613 56 57 that that RB 19613 56 58 is is RB 19613 56 59 , , , 19613 56 60 into into IN 19613 56 61 a a DT 19613 56 62 union union NN 19613 56 63 which which WDT 19613 56 64 , , , 19613 56 65 like like IN 19613 56 66 the the DT 19613 56 67 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 56 68 schools school NNS 19613 56 69 , , , 19613 56 70 rested rest VBD 19613 56 71 on on IN 19613 56 72 a a DT 19613 56 73 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 56 74 law law NN 19613 56 75 , , , 19613 56 76 and and CC 19613 56 77 which which WDT 19613 56 78 was be VBD 19613 56 79 subject subject JJ 19613 56 80 to to IN 19613 56 81 a a DT 19613 56 82 legal legal JJ 19613 56 83 code code NN 19613 56 84 of of IN 19613 56 85 divine divine JJ 19613 56 86 institution institution NN 19613 56 87 . . . 19613 57 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 57 2 2 2 LS 19613 57 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 57 4 The the DT 19613 57 5 movement movement NN 19613 57 6 which which WDT 19613 57 7 resulted result VBD 19613 57 8 in in IN 19613 57 9 the the DT 19613 57 10 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 57 11 Church Church NNP 19613 57 12 owes owe VBZ 19613 57 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 57 14 right right NN 19613 57 15 to to IN 19613 57 16 a a DT 19613 57 17 place place NN 19613 57 18 in in IN 19613 57 19 the the DT 19613 57 20 history history NN 19613 57 21 of of IN 19613 57 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 57 23 to to IN 19613 57 24 the the DT 19613 57 25 victory victory NN 19613 57 26 over over IN 19613 57 27 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 57 28 and and CC 19613 57 29 to to IN 19613 57 30 the the DT 19613 57 31 preservation preservation NN 19613 57 32 of of IN 19613 57 33 an an DT 19613 57 34 important important JJ 19613 57 35 part part NN 19613 57 36 of of IN 19613 57 37 early early JJ 19613 57 38 Christian christian JJ 19613 57 39 tradition tradition NN 19613 57 40 . . . 19613 58 1 If if IN 19613 58 2 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 58 3 in in IN 19613 58 4 all all DT 19613 58 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 58 6 phases phase NNS 19613 58 7 was be VBD 19613 58 8 the the DT 19613 58 9 violent violent JJ 19613 58 10 attempt attempt NN 19613 58 11 to to TO 19613 58 12 drag drag VB 19613 58 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 58 14 down down RP 19613 58 15 to to IN 19613 58 16 the the DT 19613 58 17 level level NN 19613 58 18 of of IN 19613 58 19 the the DT 19613 58 20 Greek greek JJ 19613 58 21 world world NN 19613 58 22 , , , 19613 58 23 and and CC 19613 58 24 to to TO 19613 58 25 rob rob VB 19613 58 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 58 27 of of IN 19613 58 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 58 29 dearest dear JJS 19613 58 30 possession possession NN 19613 58 31 , , , 19613 58 32 belief belief NN 19613 58 33 in in IN 19613 58 34 the the DT 19613 58 35 Almighty Almighty NNP 19613 58 36 God God NNP 19613 58 37 of of IN 19613 58 38 creation creation NN 19613 58 39 and and CC 19613 58 40 redemption redemption NN 19613 58 41 , , , 19613 58 42 then then RB 19613 58 43 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 58 44 , , , 19613 58 45 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 58 46 as as IN 19613 58 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 58 48 secured secure VBD 19613 58 49 this this DT 19613 58 50 belief belief NN 19613 58 51 for for IN 19613 58 52 the the DT 19613 58 53 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 58 54 , , , 19613 58 55 preserved preserve VBD 19613 58 56 the the DT 19613 58 57 Old Old NNP 19613 58 58 Testament Testament NNP 19613 58 59 , , , 19613 58 60 and and CC 19613 58 61 supplemented supplement VBD 19613 58 62 it -PRON- PRP 19613 58 63 with with IN 19613 58 64 early early JJ 19613 58 65 Christian christian JJ 19613 58 66 writings writing NNS 19613 58 67 , , , 19613 58 68 thereby thereby RB 19613 58 69 saving save VBG 19613 58 70 -- -- : 19613 58 71 as as RB 19613 58 72 far far RB 19613 58 73 as as IN 19613 58 74 documents document NNS 19613 58 75 , , , 19613 58 76 at at IN 19613 58 77 least least JJS 19613 58 78 , , , 19613 58 79 were be VBD 19613 58 80 concerned concern VBN 19613 58 81 -- -- : 19613 58 82 and and CC 19613 58 83 proclaiming proclaim VBG 19613 58 84 the the DT 19613 58 85 authority authority NN 19613 58 86 of of IN 19613 58 87 an an DT 19613 58 88 important important JJ 19613 58 89 part part NN 19613 58 90 of of IN 19613 58 91 primitive primitive JJ 19613 58 92 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 58 93 , , , 19613 58 94 must must MD 19613 58 95 in in IN 19613 58 96 one one CD 19613 58 97 respect respect NN 19613 58 98 be be VB 19613 58 99 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 58 100 as as IN 19613 58 101 a a DT 19613 58 102 conservative conservative JJ 19613 58 103 force force NN 19613 58 104 born bear VBN 19613 58 105 from from IN 19613 58 106 the the DT 19613 58 107 vigour vigour NN 19613 58 108 of of IN 19613 58 109 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 58 110 . . . 19613 59 1 If if IN 19613 59 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 59 3 put put VBP 19613 59 4 aside aside RB 19613 59 5 abstract abstract JJ 19613 59 6 considerations consideration NNS 19613 59 7 and and CC 19613 59 8 merely merely RB 19613 59 9 look look VBP 19613 59 10 at at IN 19613 59 11 the the DT 19613 59 12 facts fact NNS 19613 59 13 of of IN 19613 59 14 the the DT 19613 59 15 given give VBN 19613 59 16 situation situation NN 19613 59 17 , , , 19613 59 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 59 19 can can MD 19613 59 20 not not RB 19613 59 21 but but RB 19613 59 22 admire admire VB 19613 59 23 a a DT 19613 59 24 creation creation NN 19613 59 25 which which WDT 19613 59 26 first first RB 19613 59 27 broke break VBD 19613 59 28 up up RP 19613 59 29 the the DT 19613 59 30 various various JJ 19613 59 31 outside outside JJ 19613 59 32 forces force NNS 19613 59 33 assailing assail VBG 19613 59 34 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 59 35 , , , 19613 59 36 and and CC 19613 59 37 in in IN 19613 59 38 which which WDT 19613 59 39 the the DT 19613 59 40 highest high JJS 19613 59 41 blessings blessing NNS 19613 59 42 of of IN 19613 59 43 this this DT 19613 59 44 faith faith NN 19613 59 45 have have VBP 19613 59 46 always always RB 19613 59 47 continued continue VBN 19613 59 48 to to TO 19613 59 49 be be VB 19613 59 50 accessible accessible JJ 19613 59 51 . . . 19613 60 1 If if IN 19613 60 2 the the DT 19613 60 3 founder founder NN 19613 60 4 of of IN 19613 60 5 the the DT 19613 60 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 60 7 religion religion NN 19613 60 8 had have VBD 19613 60 9 deemed deem VBN 19613 60 10 belief belief NN 19613 60 11 in in IN 19613 60 12 the the DT 19613 60 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 60 14 and and CC 19613 60 15 a a DT 19613 60 16 life life NN 19613 60 17 in in IN 19613 60 18 accordance accordance NN 19613 60 19 with with IN 19613 60 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 60 21 to to TO 19613 60 22 be be VB 19613 60 23 compatible compatible JJ 19613 60 24 with with IN 19613 60 25 membership membership NN 19613 60 26 of of IN 19613 60 27 the the DT 19613 60 28 Synagogue Synagogue NNP 19613 60 29 and and CC 19613 60 30 observance observance NN 19613 60 31 of of IN 19613 60 32 the the DT 19613 60 33 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 60 34 law law NN 19613 60 35 , , , 19613 60 36 there there EX 19613 60 37 could could MD 19613 60 38 at at IN 19613 60 39 least least JJS 19613 60 40 be be VB 19613 60 41 no no DT 19613 60 42 impossibility impossibility NN 19613 60 43 of of IN 19613 60 44 adhering adhere VBG 19613 60 45 to to IN 19613 60 46 the the DT 19613 60 47 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 60 48 within within IN 19613 60 49 the the DT 19613 60 50 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 60 51 Church Church NNP 19613 60 52 . . . 19613 61 1 Still still RB 19613 61 2 , , , 19613 61 3 that that DT 19613 61 4 is be VBZ 19613 61 5 only only RB 19613 61 6 one one CD 19613 61 7 side side NN 19613 61 8 of of IN 19613 61 9 the the DT 19613 61 10 case case NN 19613 61 11 . . . 19613 62 1 The the DT 19613 62 2 older old JJR 19613 62 3 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 62 4 never never RB 19613 62 5 clearly clearly RB 19613 62 6 put put VBD 19613 62 7 the the DT 19613 62 8 question question NN 19613 62 9 , , , 19613 62 10 " " `` 19613 62 11 What what WP 19613 62 12 is be VBZ 19613 62 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 62 14 ? ? . 19613 62 15 " " '' 19613 63 1 Instead instead RB 19613 63 2 of of IN 19613 63 3 answering answer VBG 19613 63 4 that that DT 19613 63 5 question question VBP 19613 63 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 63 7 rather rather RB 19613 63 8 laid lay VBD 19613 63 9 down down RP 19613 63 10 rules rule NNS 19613 63 11 , , , 19613 63 12 the the DT 19613 63 13 recognition recognition NN 19613 63 14 of of IN 19613 63 15 which which WDT 19613 63 16 was be VBD 19613 63 17 to to TO 19613 63 18 be be VB 19613 63 19 the the DT 19613 63 20 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 63 21 of of IN 19613 63 22 Christianism Christianism NNP 19613 63 23 . . . 19613 64 1 This this DT 19613 64 2 solution solution NN 19613 64 3 of of IN 19613 64 4 the the DT 19613 64 5 problem problem NN 19613 64 6 seems seem VBZ 19613 64 7 to to TO 19613 64 8 be be VB 19613 64 9 on on IN 19613 64 10 the the DT 19613 64 11 one one CD 19613 64 12 hand hand NN 19613 64 13 too too RB 19613 64 14 narrow narrow JJ 19613 64 15 and and CC 19613 64 16 on on IN 19613 64 17 the the DT 19613 64 18 other other JJ 19613 64 19 too too RB 19613 64 20 broad broad JJ 19613 64 21 . . . 19613 65 1 Too too RB 19613 65 2 narrow narrow JJ 19613 65 3 , , , 19613 65 4 because because IN 19613 65 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 65 6 bound bind VBD 19613 65 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 65 8 to to IN 19613 65 9 rules rule NNS 19613 65 10 under under IN 19613 65 11 which which WDT 19613 65 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 65 13 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 65 14 languished languish VBD 19613 65 15 ; ; : 19613 65 16 too too RB 19613 65 17 broad broad JJ 19613 65 18 , , , 19613 65 19 because because IN 19613 65 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 65 21 did do VBD 19613 65 22 not not RB 19613 65 23 in in IN 19613 65 24 any any DT 19613 65 25 way way NN 19613 65 26 exclude exclude VB 19613 65 27 the the DT 19613 65 28 introduction introduction NN 19613 65 29 of of IN 19613 65 30 new new JJ 19613 65 31 and and CC 19613 65 32 foreign foreign JJ 19613 65 33 conceptions conception NNS 19613 65 34 . . . 19613 66 1 In in IN 19613 66 2 throwing throw VBG 19613 66 3 a a DT 19613 66 4 protective protective JJ 19613 66 5 covering covering NN 19613 66 6 round round IN 19613 66 7 the the DT 19613 66 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 66 9 , , , 19613 66 10 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 66 11 also also RB 19613 66 12 obscured obscure VBD 19613 66 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 66 14 . . . 19613 67 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 67 2 preserved preserve VBD 19613 67 3 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 67 4 from from IN 19613 67 5 being be VBG 19613 67 6 hellenised hellenise VBN 19613 67 7 to to IN 19613 67 8 the the DT 19613 67 9 most most RBS 19613 67 10 extreme extreme JJ 19613 67 11 extent extent NN 19613 67 12 , , , 19613 67 13 but but CC 19613 67 14 , , , 19613 67 15 as as IN 19613 67 16 time time NN 19613 67 17 went go VBD 19613 67 18 on on RP 19613 67 19 , , , 19613 67 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 67 21 was be VBD 19613 67 22 forced force VBN 19613 67 23 to to TO 19613 67 24 admit admit VB 19613 67 25 into into IN 19613 67 26 this this DT 19613 67 27 religion religion NN 19613 67 28 an an DT 19613 67 29 ever ever RB 19613 67 30 greater great JJR 19613 67 31 measure measure NN 19613 67 32 of of IN 19613 67 33 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 67 34 . . . 19613 68 1 In in IN 19613 68 2 the the DT 19613 68 3 interests interest NNS 19613 68 4 of of IN 19613 68 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 68 6 world world NN 19613 68 7 - - HYPH 19613 68 8 wide wide JJ 19613 68 9 mission mission NN 19613 68 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 68 11 did do VBD 19613 68 12 not not RB 19613 68 13 indeed indeed RB 19613 68 14 directly directly RB 19613 68 15 disguise disguise VB 19613 68 16 the the DT 19613 68 17 terrible terrible JJ 19613 68 18 seriousness seriousness NN 19613 68 19 of of IN 19613 68 20 religion religion NN 19613 68 21 , , , 19613 68 22 but but CC 19613 68 23 , , , 19613 68 24 by by IN 19613 68 25 tolerating tolerate VBG 19613 68 26 a a DT 19613 68 27 less less RBR 19613 68 28 strict strict JJ 19613 68 29 ideal ideal NN 19613 68 30 of of IN 19613 68 31 life life NN 19613 68 32 , , , 19613 68 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 68 34 made make VBD 19613 68 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 68 36 possible possible JJ 19613 68 37 for for IN 19613 68 38 those those DT 19613 68 39 less less JJR 19613 68 40 in in IN 19613 68 41 earnest earnest NN 19613 68 42 to to TO 19613 68 43 be be VB 19613 68 44 considered consider VBN 19613 68 45 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 68 46 , , , 19613 68 47 and and CC 19613 68 48 to to TO 19613 68 49 regard regard VB 19613 68 50 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 68 51 as as IN 19613 68 52 such such JJ 19613 68 53 . . . 19613 69 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 69 2 permitted permit VBD 19613 69 3 the the DT 19613 69 4 genesis genesis NN 19613 69 5 of of IN 19613 69 6 a a DT 19613 69 7 Church Church NNP 19613 69 8 , , , 19613 69 9 which which WDT 19613 69 10 was be VBD 19613 69 11 no no RB 19613 69 12 longer long RBR 19613 69 13 a a DT 19613 69 14 communion communion NN 19613 69 15 of of IN 19613 69 16 faith faith NN 19613 69 17 , , , 19613 69 18 hope hope NN 19613 69 19 , , , 19613 69 20 and and CC 19613 69 21 discipline discipline NN 19613 69 22 , , , 19613 69 23 but but CC 19613 69 24 a a DT 19613 69 25 political political JJ 19613 69 26 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 69 27 in in IN 19613 69 28 which which WDT 19613 69 29 the the DT 19613 69 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 69 31 merely merely RB 19613 69 32 had have VBD 19613 69 33 a a DT 19613 69 34 place place NN 19613 69 35 beside beside IN 19613 69 36 other other JJ 19613 69 37 things thing NNS 19613 69 38 . . . 19613 70 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 70 2 3 3 LS 19613 70 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 70 4 In in IN 19613 70 5 ever ever RB 19613 70 6 increasing increase VBG 19613 70 7 measure measure NN 19613 70 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 70 9 invested invest VBD 19613 70 10 all all PDT 19613 70 11 the the DT 19613 70 12 forms form NNS 19613 70 13 which which WDT 19613 70 14 this this DT 19613 70 15 secular secular JJ 19613 70 16 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 70 17 required require VBN 19613 70 18 with with IN 19613 70 19 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 70 20 , , , 19613 70 21 that that RB 19613 70 22 is is RB 19613 70 23 , , , 19613 70 24 indirectly indirectly RB 19613 70 25 , , , 19613 70 26 with with IN 19613 70 27 divine divine JJ 19613 70 28 authority authority NN 19613 70 29 . . . 19613 71 1 This this DT 19613 71 2 course course NN 19613 71 3 disfigured disfigure VBD 19613 71 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 71 5 and and CC 19613 71 6 made make VBD 19613 71 7 a a DT 19613 71 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 71 9 of of IN 19613 71 10 what what WP 19613 71 11 is be VBZ 19613 71 12 Christian Christian NNP 19613 71 13 an an DT 19613 71 14 obscure obscure JJ 19613 71 15 and and CC 19613 71 16 difficult difficult JJ 19613 71 17 matter matter NN 19613 71 18 . . . 19613 72 1 But but CC 19613 72 2 , , , 19613 72 3 in in IN 19613 72 4 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 72 5 , , , 19613 72 6 religion religion NN 19613 72 7 for for IN 19613 72 8 the the DT 19613 72 9 first first JJ 19613 72 10 time time NN 19613 72 11 obtained obtain VBD 19613 72 12 a a DT 19613 72 13 formal formal JJ 19613 72 14 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 72 15 system system NN 19613 72 16 . . . 19613 73 1 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 73 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 73 3 discovered discover VBD 19613 73 4 the the DT 19613 73 5 formula formula NN 19613 73 6 which which WDT 19613 73 7 reconciled reconcile VBD 19613 73 8 faith faith NN 19613 73 9 and and CC 19613 73 10 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 73 11 . . . 19613 74 1 This this DT 19613 74 2 formula formula NN 19613 74 3 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 74 4 humanity humanity NN 19613 74 5 for for IN 19613 74 6 centuries century NNS 19613 74 7 , , , 19613 74 8 and and CC 19613 74 9 the the DT 19613 74 10 blessed bless VBN 19613 74 11 effects effect NNS 19613 74 12 which which WDT 19613 74 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 74 14 accomplished accomplish VBD 19613 74 15 continued continue VBD 19613 74 16 to to TO 19613 74 17 operate operate VB 19613 74 18 even even RB 19613 74 19 after after IN 19613 74 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 74 21 had have VBD 19613 74 22 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 74 23 already already RB 19613 74 24 become become VBN 19613 74 25 a a DT 19613 74 26 fetter fetter NN 19613 74 27 . . . 19613 75 1 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 75 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 75 3 grew grow VBD 19613 75 4 out out IN 19613 75 5 of of IN 19613 75 6 two two CD 19613 75 7 converging converge VBG 19613 75 8 series series NN 19613 75 9 of of IN 19613 75 10 developments development NNS 19613 75 11 . . . 19613 76 1 In in IN 19613 76 2 the the DT 19613 76 3 one one NN 19613 76 4 were be VBD 19613 76 5 set set VBN 19613 76 6 up up RP 19613 76 7 fixed fix VBN 19613 76 8 outer outer JJ 19613 76 9 standards standard NNS 19613 76 10 for for IN 19613 76 11 determining determine VBG 19613 76 12 what what WP 19613 76 13 is be VBZ 19613 76 14 Christian christian JJ 19613 76 15 , , , 19613 76 16 and and CC 19613 76 17 these these DT 19613 76 18 standards standard NNS 19613 76 19 were be VBD 19613 76 20 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 76 21 to to TO 19613 76 22 be be VB 19613 76 23 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 76 24 institutions institution NNS 19613 76 25 . . . 19613 77 1 The the DT 19613 77 2 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 77 3 confession confession NN 19613 77 4 was be VBD 19613 77 5 exalted exalted JJ 19613 77 6 to to IN 19613 77 7 an an DT 19613 77 8 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 77 9 rule rule NN 19613 77 10 of of IN 19613 77 11 faith faith NN 19613 77 12 , , , 19613 77 13 that that RB 19613 77 14 is is RB 19613 77 15 , , , 19613 77 16 to to IN 19613 77 17 an an DT 19613 77 18 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 77 19 law law NN 19613 77 20 of of IN 19613 77 21 faith faith NN 19613 77 22 . . . 19613 78 1 A a DT 19613 78 2 collection collection NN 19613 78 3 of of IN 19613 78 4 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 78 5 writings writing NNS 19613 78 6 was be VBD 19613 78 7 formed form VBN 19613 78 8 from from IN 19613 78 9 those those DT 19613 78 10 read read NN 19613 78 11 in in IN 19613 78 12 the the DT 19613 78 13 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 78 14 , , , 19613 78 15 and and CC 19613 78 16 this this DT 19613 78 17 compilation compilation NN 19613 78 18 was be VBD 19613 78 19 placed place VBN 19613 78 20 on on IN 19613 78 21 an an DT 19613 78 22 equal equal JJ 19613 78 23 footing footing NN 19613 78 24 with with IN 19613 78 25 the the DT 19613 78 26 Old Old NNP 19613 78 27 Testament Testament NNP 19613 78 28 . . . 19613 79 1 The the DT 19613 79 2 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 79 3 and and CC 19613 79 4 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 79 5 constitution constitution NN 19613 79 6 was be VBD 19613 79 7 declared declare VBN 19613 79 8 to to TO 19613 79 9 be be VB 19613 79 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 79 11 , , , 19613 79 12 and and CC 19613 79 13 the the DT 19613 79 14 attribute attribute NN 19613 79 15 of of IN 19613 79 16 successor successor NN 19613 79 17 of of IN 19613 79 18 the the DT 19613 79 19 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 79 20 was be VBD 19613 79 21 conferred confer VBN 19613 79 22 on on IN 19613 79 23 the the DT 19613 79 24 bishop bishop NN 19613 79 25 . . . 19613 80 1 Finally finally RB 19613 80 2 , , , 19613 80 3 the the DT 19613 80 4 religious religious JJ 19613 80 5 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 80 6 developed develop VBN 19613 80 7 into into IN 19613 80 8 a a DT 19613 80 9 celebration celebration NN 19613 80 10 of of IN 19613 80 11 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 80 12 , , , 19613 80 13 which which WDT 19613 80 14 was be VBD 19613 80 15 in in IN 19613 80 16 like like JJ 19613 80 17 manner manner NN 19613 80 18 traced trace VBN 19613 80 19 back back RB 19613 80 20 to to IN 19613 80 21 the the DT 19613 80 22 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 80 23 . . . 19613 81 1 The the DT 19613 81 2 result result NN 19613 81 3 of of IN 19613 81 4 these these DT 19613 81 5 institutions institution NNS 19613 81 6 was be VBD 19613 81 7 a a DT 19613 81 8 strictly strictly RB 19613 81 9 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 81 10 Church Church NNP 19613 81 11 in in IN 19613 81 12 the the DT 19613 81 13 form form NN 19613 81 14 of of IN 19613 81 15 a a DT 19613 81 16 communion communion NN 19613 81 17 of of IN 19613 81 18 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 81 19 , , , 19613 81 20 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 81 21 , , , 19613 81 22 and and CC 19613 81 23 law law NN 19613 81 24 , , , 19613 81 25 a a DT 19613 81 26 confederation confederation NN 19613 81 27 which which WDT 19613 81 28 more more RBR 19613 81 29 and and CC 19613 81 30 more more RBR 19613 81 31 gathered gather VBD 19613 81 32 the the DT 19613 81 33 various various JJ 19613 81 34 communities community NNS 19613 81 35 within within IN 19613 81 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 81 37 pale pale NN 19613 81 38 , , , 19613 81 39 and and CC 19613 81 40 brought bring VBD 19613 81 41 about about RP 19613 81 42 the the DT 19613 81 43 decline decline NN 19613 81 44 of of IN 19613 81 45 all all DT 19613 81 46 nonconforming nonconforme VBG 19613 81 47 sects sect NNS 19613 81 48 . . . 19613 82 1 The the DT 19613 82 2 confederation confederation NN 19613 82 3 was be VBD 19613 82 4 primarily primarily RB 19613 82 5 based base VBN 19613 82 6 on on IN 19613 82 7 a a DT 19613 82 8 common common JJ 19613 82 9 confession confession NN 19613 82 10 , , , 19613 82 11 which which WDT 19613 82 12 , , , 19613 82 13 however however RB 19613 82 14 , , , 19613 82 15 was be VBD 19613 82 16 not not RB 19613 82 17 only only RB 19613 82 18 conceived conceive VBN 19613 82 19 as as IN 19613 82 20 " " `` 19613 82 21 law law NN 19613 82 22 , , , 19613 82 23 " " '' 19613 82 24 but but CC 19613 82 25 was be VBD 19613 82 26 also also RB 19613 82 27 very very RB 19613 82 28 soon soon RB 19613 82 29 supplemented supplement VBN 19613 82 30 by by IN 19613 82 31 new new JJ 19613 82 32 standards standard NNS 19613 82 33 . . . 19613 83 1 One one CD 19613 83 2 of of IN 19613 83 3 the the DT 19613 83 4 most most RBS 19613 83 5 important important JJ 19613 83 6 problems problem NNS 19613 83 7 to to TO 19613 83 8 be be VB 19613 83 9 investigated investigate VBN 19613 83 10 in in IN 19613 83 11 the the DT 19613 83 12 history history NN 19613 83 13 of of IN 19613 83 14 dogma dogma NN 19613 83 15 , , , 19613 83 16 and and CC 19613 83 17 one one CD 19613 83 18 which which WDT 19613 83 19 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 83 20 can can MD 19613 83 21 not not RB 19613 83 22 be be VB 19613 83 23 completely completely RB 19613 83 24 solved solve VBN 19613 83 25 , , , 19613 83 26 is be VBZ 19613 83 27 to to TO 19613 83 28 show show VB 19613 83 29 what what WP 19613 83 30 necessities necessity NNS 19613 83 31 led lead VBD 19613 83 32 to to IN 19613 83 33 the the DT 19613 83 34 setting setting NN 19613 83 35 up up RP 19613 83 36 of of IN 19613 83 37 a a DT 19613 83 38 new new JJ 19613 83 39 canon canon NN 19613 83 40 of of IN 19613 83 41 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 83 42 , , , 19613 83 43 what what WP 19613 83 44 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 83 45 required require VBD 19613 83 46 the the DT 19613 83 47 appearance appearance NN 19613 83 48 of of IN 19613 83 49 living living NN 19613 83 50 authorities authority NNS 19613 83 51 in in IN 19613 83 52 the the DT 19613 83 53 communities community NNS 19613 83 54 , , , 19613 83 55 and and CC 19613 83 56 what what WDT 19613 83 57 relation relation NN 19613 83 58 was be VBD 19613 83 59 established establish VBN 19613 83 60 between between IN 19613 83 61 the the DT 19613 83 62 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 83 63 rule rule NN 19613 83 64 of of IN 19613 83 65 faith faith NN 19613 83 66 , , , 19613 83 67 the the DT 19613 83 68 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 83 69 canon canon NN 19613 83 70 of of IN 19613 83 71 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 83 72 , , , 19613 83 73 and and CC 19613 83 74 the the DT 19613 83 75 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 83 76 office office NN 19613 83 77 . . . 19613 84 1 The the DT 19613 84 2 development development NN 19613 84 3 ended end VBD 19613 84 4 with with IN 19613 84 5 the the DT 19613 84 6 formation formation NN 19613 84 7 of of IN 19613 84 8 a a DT 19613 84 9 clerical clerical JJ 19613 84 10 class class NN 19613 84 11 , , , 19613 84 12 at at IN 19613 84 13 whose whose WP$ 19613 84 14 head head NN 19613 84 15 stood stand VBD 19613 84 16 the the DT 19613 84 17 bishop bishop NN 19613 84 18 , , , 19613 84 19 who who WP 19613 84 20 united unite VBD 19613 84 21 in in IN 19613 84 22 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 84 23 all all DT 19613 84 24 conceivable conceivable JJ 19613 84 25 powers power NNS 19613 84 26 , , , 19613 84 27 as as IN 19613 84 28 teacher teacher NN 19613 84 29 , , , 19613 84 30 priest priest NN 19613 84 31 , , , 19613 84 32 and and CC 19613 84 33 judge judge NN 19613 84 34 . . . 19613 85 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 85 2 disposed dispose VBD 19613 85 3 of of IN 19613 85 4 the the DT 19613 85 5 powers power NNS 19613 85 6 of of IN 19613 85 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 85 8 , , , 19613 85 9 guaranteed guarantee VBD 19613 85 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 85 11 purity purity NN 19613 85 12 , , , 19613 85 13 and and CC 19613 85 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 85 15 in in IN 19613 85 16 every every DT 19613 85 17 respect respect NN 19613 85 18 held hold VBD 19613 85 19 the the DT 19613 85 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 85 21 laity laity NN 19613 85 22 in in IN 19613 85 23 tutelage tutelage NN 19613 85 24 . . . 19613 86 1 But but CC 19613 86 2 even even RB 19613 86 3 apart apart RB 19613 86 4 from from IN 19613 86 5 the the DT 19613 86 6 content content NN 19613 86 7 which which WDT 19613 86 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 86 9 here here RB 19613 86 10 received receive VBD 19613 86 11 , , , 19613 86 12 this this DT 19613 86 13 process process NN 19613 86 14 in in IN 19613 86 15 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 86 16 represents represent VBZ 19613 86 17 a a DT 19613 86 18 progressive progressive JJ 19613 86 19 secularising secularising NN 19613 86 20 of of IN 19613 86 21 the the DT 19613 86 22 Church Church NNP 19613 86 23 , , , 19613 86 24 This this DT 19613 86 25 would would MD 19613 86 26 be be VB 19613 86 27 self self NN 19613 86 28 - - HYPH 19613 86 29 evident evident JJ 19613 86 30 enough enough RB 19613 86 31 , , , 19613 86 32 even even RB 19613 86 33 if if IN 19613 86 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 86 35 were be VBD 19613 86 36 not not RB 19613 86 37 confirmed confirm VBN 19613 86 38 by by IN 19613 86 39 noting note VBG 19613 86 40 the the DT 19613 86 41 fact fact NN 19613 86 42 that that IN 19613 86 43 the the DT 19613 86 44 process process NN 19613 86 45 had have VBD 19613 86 46 already already RB 19613 86 47 been be VBN 19613 86 48 to to IN 19613 86 49 some some DT 19613 86 50 extent extent NN 19613 86 51 anticipated anticipate VBN 19613 86 52 in in IN 19613 86 53 the the DT 19613 86 54 so so RB 19613 86 55 - - HYPH 19613 86 56 called call VBN 19613 86 57 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 86 58 ( ( -LRB- 19613 86 59 See see VB 19613 86 60 vol vol NNP 19613 86 61 . . . 19613 87 1 I. I. NNP 19613 87 2 p. p. NN 19613 87 3 253 253 CD 19613 87 4 and and CC 19613 87 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 87 6 , , , 19613 87 7 de de NNP 19613 87 8 præscr præscr NNS 19613 87 9 . . . 19613 88 1 35 35 CD 19613 88 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 88 3 . . . 19613 89 1 But but CC 19613 89 2 the the DT 19613 89 3 element element NN 19613 89 4 which which WDT 19613 89 5 the the DT 19613 89 6 latter latter JJ 19613 89 7 lacked lack VBD 19613 89 8 , , , 19613 89 9 namely namely RB 19613 89 10 , , , 19613 89 11 a a DT 19613 89 12 firmly firmly RB 19613 89 13 welded weld VBN 19613 89 14 , , , 19613 89 15 suitably suitably RB 19613 89 16 regulated regulate VBN 19613 89 17 constitution constitution NN 19613 89 18 , , , 19613 89 19 must must MD 19613 89 20 by by IN 19613 89 21 no no DT 19613 89 22 means means NN 19613 89 23 be be VB 19613 89 24 regarded regard VBN 19613 89 25 as as IN 19613 89 26 one one CD 19613 89 27 originally originally RB 19613 89 28 belonging belong VBG 19613 89 29 and and CC 19613 89 30 essential essential JJ 19613 89 31 to to IN 19613 89 32 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 89 33 . . . 19613 90 1 The the DT 19613 90 2 depotentiation depotentiation NN 19613 90 3 to to TO 19613 90 4 which which WDT 19613 90 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 90 6 was be VBD 19613 90 7 here here RB 19613 90 8 subjected subject VBN 19613 90 9 appears appear VBZ 19613 90 10 still still RB 19613 90 11 more more RBR 19613 90 12 plainly plainly RB 19613 90 13 in in IN 19613 90 14 the the DT 19613 90 15 facts fact NNS 19613 90 16 , , , 19613 90 17 that that IN 19613 90 18 the the DT 19613 90 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 90 20 hopes hope NNS 19613 90 21 were be VBD 19613 90 22 deadened deaden VBN 19613 90 23 , , , 19613 90 24 that that IN 19613 90 25 the the DT 19613 90 26 secularising secularising NN 19613 90 27 of of IN 19613 90 28 the the DT 19613 90 29 Christian christian JJ 19613 90 30 life life NN 19613 90 31 was be VBD 19613 90 32 tolerated tolerate VBN 19613 90 33 and and CC 19613 90 34 even even RB 19613 90 35 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 90 36 , , , 19613 90 37 and and CC 19613 90 38 that that IN 19613 90 39 the the DT 19613 90 40 manifestations manifestation NNS 19613 90 41 of of IN 19613 90 42 an an DT 19613 90 43 unconditional unconditional JJ 19613 90 44 devotion devotion NN 19613 90 45 to to IN 19613 90 46 the the DT 19613 90 47 heavenly heavenly RB 19613 90 48 excited excite VBN 19613 90 49 suspicion suspicion NN 19613 90 50 or or CC 19613 90 51 were be VBD 19613 90 52 compelled compel VBN 19613 90 53 to to TO 19613 90 54 confine confine VB 19613 90 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 90 56 to to IN 19613 90 57 very very RB 19613 90 58 narrow narrow JJ 19613 90 59 limits limit NNS 19613 90 60 . . . 19613 91 1 But but CC 19613 91 2 these these DT 19613 91 3 considerations consideration NNS 19613 91 4 are be VBP 19613 91 5 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 91 6 needed need VBN 19613 91 7 as as RB 19613 91 8 soon soon RB 19613 91 9 as as IN 19613 91 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 91 11 turn turn VBP 19613 91 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 91 13 attention attention NN 19613 91 14 to to IN 19613 91 15 the the DT 19613 91 16 second second JJ 19613 91 17 series series NN 19613 91 18 of of IN 19613 91 19 developments development NNS 19613 91 20 that that WDT 19613 91 21 make make VBP 19613 91 22 up up RP 19613 91 23 the the DT 19613 91 24 history history NN 19613 91 25 of of IN 19613 91 26 this this DT 19613 91 27 period period NN 19613 91 28 . . . 19613 92 1 The the DT 19613 92 2 Church Church NNP 19613 92 3 did do VBD 19613 92 4 not not RB 19613 92 5 merely merely RB 19613 92 6 set set VBN 19613 92 7 up up RP 19613 92 8 dykes dyke NNS 19613 92 9 and and CC 19613 92 10 walls wall NNS 19613 92 11 against against IN 19613 92 12 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 92 13 in in IN 19613 92 14 order order NN 19613 92 15 to to TO 19613 92 16 ward ward VB 19613 92 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 92 18 off off RP 19613 92 19 externally externally RB 19613 92 20 , , , 19613 92 21 nor nor CC 19613 92 22 was be VBD 19613 92 23 she -PRON- PRP 19613 92 24 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 92 25 with with IN 19613 92 26 defending defend VBG 19613 92 27 against against IN 19613 92 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 92 29 the the DT 19613 92 30 facts fact NNS 19613 92 31 which which WDT 19613 92 32 were be VBD 19613 92 33 the the DT 19613 92 34 objects object NNS 19613 92 35 of of IN 19613 92 36 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 92 37 belief belief NN 19613 92 38 and and CC 19613 92 39 hope hope NN 19613 92 40 ; ; : 19613 92 41 but but CC 19613 92 42 , , , 19613 92 43 taking take VBG 19613 92 44 the the DT 19613 92 45 creed creed NN 19613 92 46 for for IN 19613 92 47 granted grant VBN 19613 92 48 , , , 19613 92 49 she -PRON- PRP 19613 92 50 began begin VBD 19613 92 51 to to TO 19613 92 52 follow follow VB 19613 92 53 this this DT 19613 92 54 heresy heresy NN 19613 92 55 into into IN 19613 92 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 92 57 own own JJ 19613 92 58 special special JJ 19613 92 59 territory territory NN 19613 92 60 and and CC 19613 92 61 to to TO 19613 92 62 combat combat VB 19613 92 63 it -PRON- PRP 19613 92 64 with with IN 19613 92 65 a a DT 19613 92 66 scientific scientific JJ 19613 92 67 theology theology NN 19613 92 68 . . . 19613 93 1 That that DT 19613 93 2 was be VBD 19613 93 3 a a DT 19613 93 4 necessity necessity NN 19613 93 5 which which WDT 19613 93 6 did do VBD 19613 93 7 not not RB 19613 93 8 first first JJ 19613 93 9 spring spring VB 19613 93 10 from from IN 19613 93 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 93 12 's 's POS 19613 93 13 own own JJ 19613 93 14 internal internal JJ 19613 93 15 struggles struggle NNS 19613 93 16 . . . 19613 94 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 94 2 was be VBD 19613 94 3 already already RB 19613 94 4 involved involve VBN 19613 94 5 in in IN 19613 94 6 the the DT 19613 94 7 fact fact NN 19613 94 8 that that IN 19613 94 9 the the DT 19613 94 10 Christian Christian NNP 19613 94 11 Church Church NNP 19613 94 12 had have VBD 19613 94 13 been be VBN 19613 94 14 joined join VBN 19613 94 15 by by IN 19613 94 16 cultured cultured JJ 19613 94 17 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 94 18 , , , 19613 94 19 who who WP 19613 94 20 felt feel VBD 19613 94 21 the the DT 19613 94 22 need need NN 19613 94 23 of of IN 19613 94 24 justifying justify VBG 19613 94 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 94 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 94 27 to to IN 19613 94 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 94 29 and and CC 19613 94 30 the the DT 19613 94 31 world world NN 19613 94 32 , , , 19613 94 33 and and CC 19613 94 34 of of IN 19613 94 35 presenting present VBG 19613 94 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 94 37 as as IN 19613 94 38 the the DT 19613 94 39 desired desire VBN 19613 94 40 and and CC 19613 94 41 certain certain JJ 19613 94 42 answer answer NN 19613 94 43 to to IN 19613 94 44 all all PDT 19613 94 45 the the DT 19613 94 46 pressing press VBG 19613 94 47 questions question NNS 19613 94 48 which which WDT 19613 94 49 then then RB 19613 94 50 occupied occupy VBD 19613 94 51 men man NNS 19613 94 52 's 's POS 19613 94 53 minds mind NNS 19613 94 54 . . . 19613 95 1 The the DT 19613 95 2 beginning beginning NN 19613 95 3 of of IN 19613 95 4 a a DT 19613 95 5 development development NN 19613 95 6 which which WDT 19613 95 7 a a DT 19613 95 8 century century NN 19613 95 9 later later RB 19613 95 10 reached reach VBD 19613 95 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 95 12 provisional provisional JJ 19613 95 13 completion completion NN 19613 95 14 in in IN 19613 95 15 the the DT 19613 95 16 theology theology NN 19613 95 17 of of IN 19613 95 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 95 19 , , , 19613 95 20 that that RB 19613 95 21 is is RB 19613 95 22 , , , 19613 95 23 in in IN 19613 95 24 the the DT 19613 95 25 transformation transformation NN 19613 95 26 of of IN 19613 95 27 the the DT 19613 95 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 95 29 into into IN 19613 95 30 a a DT 19613 95 31 scientific scientific JJ 19613 95 32 system system NN 19613 95 33 of of IN 19613 95 34 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 95 35 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 95 36 , , , 19613 95 37 appears appear VBZ 19613 95 38 in in IN 19613 95 39 the the DT 19613 95 40 Christian Christian NNP 19613 95 41 Apologetic Apologetic NNP 19613 95 42 , , , 19613 95 43 as as IN 19613 95 44 we -PRON- PRP 19613 95 45 already already RB 19613 95 46 find find VBP 19613 95 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 95 48 before before IN 19613 95 49 the the DT 19613 95 50 middle middle NN 19613 95 51 of of IN 19613 95 52 the the DT 19613 95 53 second second JJ 19613 95 54 century century NN 19613 95 55 . . . 19613 96 1 As as IN 19613 96 2 regards regard VBZ 19613 96 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 96 4 content content NN 19613 96 5 , , , 19613 96 6 this this DT 19613 96 7 system system NN 19613 96 8 of of IN 19613 96 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 96 10 meant mean VBD 19613 96 11 the the DT 19613 96 12 legitimising legitimising NN 19613 96 13 of of IN 19613 96 14 Greek greek JJ 19613 96 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 96 16 within within IN 19613 96 17 the the DT 19613 96 18 sphere sphere NN 19613 96 19 of of IN 19613 96 20 the the DT 19613 96 21 rule rule NN 19613 96 22 of of IN 19613 96 23 faith faith NN 19613 96 24 . . . 19613 97 1 The the DT 19613 97 2 theology theology NN 19613 97 3 of of IN 19613 97 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 97 5 bears bear VBZ 19613 97 6 the the DT 19613 97 7 same same JJ 19613 97 8 relation relation NN 19613 97 9 to to IN 19613 97 10 the the DT 19613 97 11 New New NNP 19613 97 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 97 13 as as IN 19613 97 14 that that DT 19613 97 15 of of IN 19613 97 16 Philo Philo NNP 19613 97 17 does do VBZ 19613 97 18 to to IN 19613 97 19 the the DT 19613 97 20 Old Old NNP 19613 97 21 . . . 19613 98 1 What what WP 19613 98 2 is be VBZ 19613 98 3 here here RB 19613 98 4 presented present VBN 19613 98 5 as as IN 19613 98 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 98 7 is be VBZ 19613 98 8 in in IN 19613 98 9 fact fact NN 19613 98 10 the the DT 19613 98 11 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 98 12 religious religious JJ 19613 98 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 98 14 of of IN 19613 98 15 the the DT 19613 98 16 age age NN 19613 98 17 , , , 19613 98 18 attested attest VBN 19613 98 19 by by IN 19613 98 20 divine divine JJ 19613 98 21 revelation revelation NN 19613 98 22 , , , 19613 98 23 made make VBN 19613 98 24 accessible accessible JJ 19613 98 25 to to IN 19613 98 26 all all DT 19613 98 27 by by IN 19613 98 28 the the DT 19613 98 29 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 98 30 of of IN 19613 98 31 the the DT 19613 98 32 Logos Logos NNP 19613 98 33 , , , 19613 98 34 and and CC 19613 98 35 purified purify VBD 19613 98 36 from from IN 19613 98 37 any any DT 19613 98 38 connection connection NN 19613 98 39 with with IN 19613 98 40 Greek greek JJ 19613 98 41 mythology mythology NN 19613 98 42 and and CC 19613 98 43 gross gross JJ 19613 98 44 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 98 45 . . . 19613 99 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 99 2 4 4 LS 19613 99 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 99 4 A a DT 19613 99 5 motley motley JJ 19613 99 6 multitude multitude NN 19613 99 7 of of IN 19613 99 8 primitive primitive JJ 19613 99 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 99 10 ideas idea NNS 19613 99 11 and and CC 19613 99 12 hopes hope NNS 19613 99 13 , , , 19613 99 14 derived derive VBN 19613 99 15 from from IN 19613 99 16 both both DT 19613 99 17 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 99 18 , , , 19613 99 19 and and CC 19613 99 20 too too RB 19613 99 21 brittle brittle JJ 19613 99 22 to to TO 19613 99 23 be be VB 19613 99 24 completely completely RB 19613 99 25 recast recast VBN 19613 99 26 , , , 19613 99 27 as as RB 19613 99 28 yet yet RB 19613 99 29 enclosed enclose VBN 19613 99 30 the the DT 19613 99 31 kernel kernel NN 19613 99 32 . . . 19613 100 1 But but CC 19613 100 2 the the DT 19613 100 3 majority majority NN 19613 100 4 of of IN 19613 100 5 these these DT 19613 100 6 were be VBD 19613 100 7 successfully successfully RB 19613 100 8 manipulated manipulate VBN 19613 100 9 by by IN 19613 100 10 theological theological JJ 19613 100 11 art art NN 19613 100 12 , , , 19613 100 13 and and CC 19613 100 14 the the DT 19613 100 15 traditional traditional JJ 19613 100 16 rule rule NN 19613 100 17 of of IN 19613 100 18 faith faith NN 19613 100 19 was be VBD 19613 100 20 transformed transform VBN 19613 100 21 into into IN 19613 100 22 a a DT 19613 100 23 system system NN 19613 100 24 of of IN 19613 100 25 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 100 26 , , , 19613 100 27 in in IN 19613 100 28 which which WDT 19613 100 29 , , , 19613 100 30 to to IN 19613 100 31 some some DT 19613 100 32 extent extent NN 19613 100 33 , , , 19613 100 34 the the DT 19613 100 35 old old JJ 19613 100 36 articles article NNS 19613 100 37 found find VBD 19613 100 38 only only RB 19613 100 39 a a DT 19613 100 40 nominal nominal JJ 19613 100 41 place place NN 19613 100 42 . . . 19613 101 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 101 2 5 5 LS 19613 101 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 101 4 This this DT 19613 101 5 hellenising hellenising NN 19613 101 6 of of IN 19613 101 7 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 101 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 101 9 , , , 19613 101 10 by by IN 19613 101 11 which which WDT 19613 101 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 101 13 do do VBP 19613 101 14 not not RB 19613 101 15 mean mean VB 19613 101 16 the the DT 19613 101 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 101 18 , , , 19613 101 19 was be VBD 19613 101 20 not not RB 19613 101 21 a a DT 19613 101 22 gradual gradual JJ 19613 101 23 process process NN 19613 101 24 ; ; : 19613 101 25 for for IN 19613 101 26 the the DT 19613 101 27 truth truth NN 19613 101 28 rather rather RB 19613 101 29 is be VBZ 19613 101 30 that that IN 19613 101 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 101 32 was be VBD 19613 101 33 already already RB 19613 101 34 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 101 35 the the DT 19613 101 36 moment moment NN 19613 101 37 that that IN 19613 101 38 the the DT 19613 101 39 reflective reflective JJ 19613 101 40 Greek Greek NNP 19613 101 41 confronted confront VBD 19613 101 42 the the DT 19613 101 43 new new JJ 19613 101 44 religion religion NN 19613 101 45 which which WDT 19613 101 46 he -PRON- PRP 19613 101 47 had have VBD 19613 101 48 accepted accept VBN 19613 101 49 . . . 19613 102 1 The the DT 19613 102 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 102 3 of of IN 19613 102 4 men man NNS 19613 102 5 like like IN 19613 102 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 102 7 , , , 19613 102 8 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 102 9 , , , 19613 102 10 and and CC 19613 102 11 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 102 12 is be VBZ 19613 102 13 not not RB 19613 102 14 a a DT 19613 102 15 whit whit NN 19613 102 16 less less RBR 19613 102 17 Hellenistic hellenistic JJ 19613 102 18 than than IN 19613 102 19 that that DT 19613 102 20 of of IN 19613 102 21 Origen Origen NNP 19613 102 22 . . . 19613 103 1 But but CC 19613 103 2 yet yet RB 19613 103 3 an an DT 19613 103 4 important important JJ 19613 103 5 distinction distinction NN 19613 103 6 obtains obtain NNS 19613 103 7 here here RB 19613 103 8 . . . 19613 104 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 104 2 is be VBZ 19613 104 3 twofold twofold JJ 19613 104 4 . . . 19613 105 1 In in IN 19613 105 2 the the DT 19613 105 3 first first JJ 19613 105 4 place place NN 19613 105 5 , , , 19613 105 6 those those DT 19613 105 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 105 8 did do VBD 19613 105 9 not not RB 19613 105 10 yet yet RB 19613 105 11 find find VB 19613 105 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 105 13 face face NN 19613 105 14 to to IN 19613 105 15 face face NN 19613 105 16 with with IN 19613 105 17 a a DT 19613 105 18 fixed fix VBN 19613 105 19 collection collection NN 19613 105 20 of of IN 19613 105 21 writings writing NNS 19613 105 22 having have VBG 19613 105 23 a a DT 19613 105 24 title title NN 19613 105 25 to to TO 19613 105 26 be be VB 19613 105 27 reverenced reverence VBN 19613 105 28 as as IN 19613 105 29 Christian Christian NNP 19613 105 30 ; ; : 19613 105 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 105 32 have have VBP 19613 105 33 to to TO 19613 105 34 do do VB 19613 105 35 with with IN 19613 105 36 the the DT 19613 105 37 Old Old NNP 19613 105 38 Testament Testament NNP 19613 105 39 and and CC 19613 105 40 the the DT 19613 105 41 " " `` 19613 105 42 Teachings teaching NNS 19613 105 43 of of IN 19613 105 44 Christ Christ NNP 19613 105 45 " " '' 19613 105 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 105 47 [ [ -LRB- 19613 105 48 Greek Greek NNP 19613 105 49 : : : 19613 105 50 didagmata didagmata NNP 19613 105 51 Christou Christou NNP 19613 105 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 105 53 ) ) -RRB- 19613 105 54 . . . 19613 106 1 In in IN 19613 106 2 the the DT 19613 106 3 second second JJ 19613 106 4 place place NN 19613 106 5 , , , 19613 106 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 106 7 do do VBP 19613 106 8 not not RB 19613 106 9 yet yet RB 19613 106 10 regard regard VB 19613 106 11 the the DT 19613 106 12 scientific scientific JJ 19613 106 13 presentation presentation NN 19613 106 14 of of IN 19613 106 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 106 16 as as IN 19613 106 17 the the DT 19613 106 18 main main JJ 19613 106 19 task task NN 19613 106 20 and and CC 19613 106 21 as as IN 19613 106 22 one one CD 19613 106 23 which which WDT 19613 106 24 this this DT 19613 106 25 religion religion NN 19613 106 26 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 106 27 demands demand VBZ 19613 106 28 . . . 19613 107 1 As as IN 19613 107 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 107 3 really really RB 19613 107 4 never never RB 19613 107 5 enquired enquire VBD 19613 107 6 what what WP 19613 107 7 was be VBD 19613 107 8 meant mean VBN 19613 107 9 by by IN 19613 107 10 " " `` 19613 107 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 107 12 , , , 19613 107 13 " " '' 19613 107 14 or or CC 19613 107 15 at at IN 19613 107 16 least least JJS 19613 107 17 never never RB 19613 107 18 put put VBN 19613 107 19 the the DT 19613 107 20 question question NN 19613 107 21 clearly clearly RB 19613 107 22 to to IN 19613 107 23 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 107 24 , , , 19613 107 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 107 26 never never RB 19613 107 27 claimed claim VBD 19613 107 28 that that IN 19613 107 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 107 30 scientific scientific JJ 19613 107 31 presentation presentation NN 19613 107 32 of of IN 19613 107 33 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 107 34 was be VBD 19613 107 35 the the DT 19613 107 36 first first JJ 19613 107 37 proper proper JJ 19613 107 38 expression expression NN 19613 107 39 of of IN 19613 107 40 it -PRON- PRP 19613 107 41 that that WDT 19613 107 42 had have VBD 19613 107 43 been be VBN 19613 107 44 given give VBN 19613 107 45 . . . 19613 108 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 108 2 and and CC 19613 108 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 108 4 contemporaries contemporary NNS 19613 108 5 make make VBP 19613 108 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 108 7 perfectly perfectly RB 19613 108 8 clear clear JJ 19613 108 9 that that IN 19613 108 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 108 11 consider consider VBP 19613 108 12 the the DT 19613 108 13 traditional traditional JJ 19613 108 14 faith faith NN 19613 108 15 existing exist VBG 19613 108 16 in in IN 19613 108 17 the the DT 19613 108 18 churches church NNS 19613 108 19 to to TO 19613 108 20 be be VB 19613 108 21 complete complete JJ 19613 108 22 and and CC 19613 108 23 pure pure JJ 19613 108 24 and and CC 19613 108 25 in in IN 19613 108 26 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 108 27 requiring require VBG 19613 108 28 no no DT 19613 108 29 scientific scientific JJ 19613 108 30 revision revision NN 19613 108 31 . . . 19613 109 1 In in IN 19613 109 2 a a DT 19613 109 3 word word NN 19613 109 4 , , , 19613 109 5 the the DT 19613 109 6 gulf gulf NNP 19613 109 7 which which WDT 19613 109 8 existed exist VBD 19613 109 9 between between IN 19613 109 10 the the DT 19613 109 11 religious religious JJ 19613 109 12 thought thought NN 19613 109 13 of of IN 19613 109 14 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 109 15 and and CC 19613 109 16 the the DT 19613 109 17 sum sum NN 19613 109 18 of of IN 19613 109 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 109 20 tradition tradition NN 19613 109 21 is be VBZ 19613 109 22 still still RB 19613 109 23 altogether altogether RB 19613 109 24 unperceived unperceive VBN 19613 109 25 , , , 19613 109 26 because because IN 19613 109 27 that that DT 19613 109 28 tradition tradition NN 19613 109 29 was be VBD 19613 109 30 not not RB 19613 109 31 yet yet RB 19613 109 32 fixed fix VBN 19613 109 33 in in IN 19613 109 34 rigid rigid JJ 19613 109 35 forms form NNS 19613 109 36 , , , 19613 109 37 because because IN 19613 109 38 no no DT 19613 109 39 religious religious JJ 19613 109 40 utterance utterance NN 19613 109 41 testifying testify VBG 19613 109 42 to to IN 19613 109 43 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 109 44 , , , 19613 109 45 virtue virtue NN 19613 109 46 , , , 19613 109 47 and and CC 19613 109 48 reward reward NN 19613 109 49 was be VBD 19613 109 50 as as RB 19613 109 51 yet yet RB 19613 109 52 threatened threaten VBN 19613 109 53 by by IN 19613 109 54 any any DT 19613 109 55 control control NN 19613 109 56 , , , 19613 109 57 and and CC 19613 109 58 finally finally RB 19613 109 59 , , , 19613 109 60 because because IN 19613 109 61 the the DT 19613 109 62 speech speech NN 19613 109 63 of of IN 19613 109 64 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 109 65 was be VBD 19613 109 66 only only RB 19613 109 67 understood understand VBN 19613 109 68 by by IN 19613 109 69 a a DT 19613 109 70 small small JJ 19613 109 71 minority minority NN 19613 109 72 in in IN 19613 109 73 the the DT 19613 109 74 Church Church NNP 19613 109 75 , , , 19613 109 76 though though IN 19613 109 77 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 109 78 interests interest NNS 19613 109 79 and and CC 19613 109 80 aims aim NNS 19613 109 81 were be VBD 19613 109 82 not not RB 19613 109 83 unknown unknown JJ 19613 109 84 to to IN 19613 109 85 most most JJS 19613 109 86 . . . 19613 110 1 Christian christian JJ 19613 110 2 thinkers thinker NNS 19613 110 3 were be VBD 19613 110 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 110 5 still still RB 19613 110 6 free free JJ 19613 110 7 to to IN 19613 110 8 divest divest NN 19613 110 9 of of IN 19613 110 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 110 11 direct direct JJ 19613 110 12 religious religious JJ 19613 110 13 value value NN 19613 110 14 all all DT 19613 110 15 realistic realistic JJ 19613 110 16 and and CC 19613 110 17 historical historical JJ 19613 110 18 elements element NNS 19613 110 19 of of IN 19613 110 20 the the DT 19613 110 21 tradition tradition NN 19613 110 22 , , , 19613 110 23 while while IN 19613 110 24 still still RB 19613 110 25 retaining retain VBG 19613 110 26 them -PRON- PRP 19613 110 27 as as IN 19613 110 28 parts part NNS 19613 110 29 of of IN 19613 110 30 a a DT 19613 110 31 huge huge JJ 19613 110 32 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 110 33 of of IN 19613 110 34 proof proof NN 19613 110 35 , , , 19613 110 36 which which WDT 19613 110 37 accomplished accomplish VBD 19613 110 38 what what WP 19613 110 39 was be VBD 19613 110 40 really really RB 19613 110 41 the the DT 19613 110 42 only only JJ 19613 110 43 thing thing NN 19613 110 44 that that WDT 19613 110 45 many many JJ 19613 110 46 sought seek VBD 19613 110 47 in in IN 19613 110 48 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 110 49 , , , 19613 110 50 viz viz NNP 19613 110 51 . . NNP 19613 110 52 , , , 19613 110 53 the the DT 19613 110 54 assurance assurance NN 19613 110 55 that that IN 19613 110 56 the the DT 19613 110 57 theory theory NN 19613 110 58 of of IN 19613 110 59 the the DT 19613 110 60 world world NN 19613 110 61 obtained obtain VBN 19613 110 62 from from IN 19613 110 63 other other JJ 19613 110 64 sources source NNS 19613 110 65 was be VBD 19613 110 66 the the DT 19613 110 67 truth truth NN 19613 110 68 . . . 19613 111 1 The the DT 19613 111 2 danger danger NN 19613 111 3 which which WDT 19613 111 4 here here RB 19613 111 5 threatened threaten VBD 19613 111 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 111 7 as as IN 19613 111 8 a a DT 19613 111 9 religion religion NN 19613 111 10 was be VBD 19613 111 11 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 111 12 less less RBR 19613 111 13 serious serious JJ 19613 111 14 than than IN 19613 111 15 that that DT 19613 111 16 which which WDT 19613 111 17 had have VBD 19613 111 18 been be VBN 19613 111 19 caused cause VBN 19613 111 20 to to IN 19613 111 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 111 22 by by IN 19613 111 23 the the DT 19613 111 24 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 111 25 . . . 19613 112 1 These these DT 19613 112 2 remodelled remodelle VBN 19613 112 3 tradition tradition NN 19613 112 4 , , , 19613 112 5 the the DT 19613 112 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 112 7 made make VBD 19613 112 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 112 9 to to IN 19613 112 10 some some DT 19613 112 11 extent extent NN 19613 112 12 inoperative inoperative JJ 19613 112 13 without without IN 19613 112 14 attacking attack VBG 19613 112 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 112 16 . . . 19613 113 1 The the DT 19613 113 2 latter latter JJ 19613 113 3 were be VBD 19613 113 4 not not RB 19613 113 5 disowned disown VBN 19613 113 6 , , , 19613 113 7 but but CC 19613 113 8 rather rather RB 19613 113 9 laid lay VBD 19613 113 10 the the DT 19613 113 11 foundation foundation NN 19613 113 12 of of IN 19613 113 13 Church Church NNP 19613 113 14 theology theology NN 19613 113 15 , , , 19613 113 16 and and CC 19613 113 17 determined determine VBD 19613 113 18 the the DT 19613 113 19 circle circle NN 19613 113 20 of of IN 19613 113 21 interests interest NNS 19613 113 22 within within IN 19613 113 23 which which WDT 19613 113 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 113 25 was be VBD 19613 113 26 to to TO 19613 113 27 move move VB 19613 113 28 in in IN 19613 113 29 the the DT 19613 113 30 future future NN 19613 113 31 . . . 19613 114 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 114 2 6 6 CD 19613 114 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 114 4 But but CC 19613 114 5 the the DT 19613 114 6 problem problem NN 19613 114 7 which which WDT 19613 114 8 the the DT 19613 114 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 114 10 solved solve VBD 19613 114 11 almost almost RB 19613 114 12 offhand offhand JJ 19613 114 13 , , , 19613 114 14 namely namely RB 19613 114 15 , , , 19613 114 16 the the DT 19613 114 17 task task NN 19613 114 18 of of IN 19613 114 19 showing show VBG 19613 114 20 that that IN 19613 114 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 114 22 was be VBD 19613 114 23 the the DT 19613 114 24 perfect perfect JJ 19613 114 25 and and CC 19613 114 26 certain certain JJ 19613 114 27 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 114 28 , , , 19613 114 29 because because IN 19613 114 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 114 31 rested rest VBD 19613 114 32 on on IN 19613 114 33 revelation revelation NN 19613 114 34 , , , 19613 114 35 and and CC 19613 114 36 that that IN 19613 114 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 114 38 was be VBD 19613 114 39 the the DT 19613 114 40 highest high JJS 19613 114 41 scientific scientific JJ 19613 114 42 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 114 43 of of IN 19613 114 44 God God NNP 19613 114 45 and and CC 19613 114 46 the the DT 19613 114 47 world world NN 19613 114 48 , , , 19613 114 49 was be VBD 19613 114 50 to to TO 19613 114 51 be be VB 19613 114 52 rendered render VBN 19613 114 53 more more RBR 19613 114 54 difficult difficult JJ 19613 114 55 . . . 19613 115 1 To to IN 19613 115 2 these these DT 19613 115 3 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 115 4 all all PDT 19613 115 5 that that WDT 19613 115 6 primitive primitive JJ 19613 115 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 115 8 has have VBZ 19613 115 9 up up IN 19613 115 10 to to IN 19613 115 11 the the DT 19613 115 12 present present NN 19613 115 13 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 115 14 to to IN 19613 115 15 the the DT 19613 115 16 Church Church NNP 19613 115 17 of of IN 19613 115 18 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 115 19 times time NNS 19613 115 20 contributes contribute VBZ 19613 115 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 115 22 share share NN 19613 115 23 . . . 19613 116 1 The the DT 19613 116 2 conflict conflict NN 19613 116 3 with with IN 19613 116 4 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 116 5 made make VBD 19613 116 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 116 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 116 8 to to TO 19613 116 9 find find VB 19613 116 10 some some DT 19613 116 11 sort sort NN 19613 116 12 of of IN 19613 116 13 solution solution NN 19613 116 14 to to IN 19613 116 15 the the DT 19613 116 16 question question NN 19613 116 17 , , , 19613 116 18 " " `` 19613 116 19 What what WP 19613 116 20 is be VBZ 19613 116 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 116 22 ? ? . 19613 116 23 " " '' 19613 117 1 and and CC 19613 117 2 to to TO 19613 117 3 fix fix VB 19613 117 4 this this DT 19613 117 5 answer answer NN 19613 117 6 . . . 19613 118 1 But but CC 19613 118 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 118 3 the the DT 19613 118 4 Fathers father NNS 19613 118 5 were be VBD 19613 118 6 not not RB 19613 118 7 able able JJ 19613 118 8 to to TO 19613 118 9 answer answer VB 19613 118 10 the the DT 19613 118 11 question question NN 19613 118 12 confidently confidently RB 19613 118 13 and and CC 19613 118 14 definitely definitely RB 19613 118 15 . . . 19613 119 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 119 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 119 3 made make VBD 19613 119 4 a a DT 19613 119 5 selection selection NN 19613 119 6 from from IN 19613 119 7 tradition tradition NN 19613 119 8 and and CC 19613 119 9 contented content VBD 19613 119 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 119 11 with with IN 19613 119 12 making make VBG 19613 119 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 119 14 binding bind VBG 19613 119 15 on on IN 19613 119 16 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 119 17 . . . 19613 120 1 Whatever whatever WDT 19613 120 2 was be VBD 19613 120 3 to to TO 19613 120 4 lay lay VB 19613 120 5 claim claim NN 19613 120 6 to to IN 19613 120 7 authority authority NN 19613 120 8 in in IN 19613 120 9 the the DT 19613 120 10 Church Church NNP 19613 120 11 had have VBD 19613 120 12 henceforth henceforth RB 19613 120 13 to to TO 19613 120 14 be be VB 19613 120 15 in in IN 19613 120 16 harmony harmony NN 19613 120 17 with with IN 19613 120 18 the the DT 19613 120 19 rule rule NN 19613 120 20 of of IN 19613 120 21 faith faith NN 19613 120 22 and and CC 19613 120 23 the the DT 19613 120 24 canon canon NN 19613 120 25 of of IN 19613 120 26 New New NNP 19613 120 27 Testament Testament NNP 19613 120 28 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 120 29 . . . 19613 121 1 That that DT 19613 121 2 created create VBD 19613 121 3 an an DT 19613 121 4 entirely entirely RB 19613 121 5 new new JJ 19613 121 6 situation situation NN 19613 121 7 for for IN 19613 121 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 121 9 thinkers thinker NNS 19613 121 10 , , , 19613 121 11 that that RB 19613 121 12 is is RB 19613 121 13 , , , 19613 121 14 for for IN 19613 121 15 those those DT 19613 121 16 trying try VBG 19613 121 17 to to TO 19613 121 18 solve solve VB 19613 121 19 the the DT 19613 121 20 problem problem NN 19613 121 21 of of IN 19613 121 22 subordinating subordinate VBG 19613 121 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 121 24 to to IN 19613 121 25 the the DT 19613 121 26 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 19613 121 27 spirit spirit NN 19613 121 28 . . . 19613 122 1 That that DT 19613 122 2 spirit spirit NN 19613 122 3 never never RB 19613 122 4 became become VBD 19613 122 5 quite quite RB 19613 122 6 master master NN 19613 122 7 of of IN 19613 122 8 the the DT 19613 122 9 situation situation NN 19613 122 10 ; ; : 19613 122 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 122 12 was be VBD 19613 122 13 obliged oblige VBN 19613 122 14 to to TO 19613 122 15 accommodate accommodate VB 19613 122 16 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 122 17 to to IN 19613 122 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 122 19 . . . 19613 123 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 123 2 7 7 LS 19613 123 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 123 4 The the DT 19613 123 5 work work NN 19613 123 6 first first RB 19613 123 7 began begin VBD 19613 123 8 with with IN 19613 123 9 the the DT 19613 123 10 scientific scientific JJ 19613 123 11 treatment treatment NN 19613 123 12 of of IN 19613 123 13 individual individual JJ 19613 123 14 articles article NNS 19613 123 15 contained contain VBN 19613 123 16 in in IN 19613 123 17 the the DT 19613 123 18 rule rule NN 19613 123 19 of of IN 19613 123 20 faith faith NN 19613 123 21 , , , 19613 123 22 partly partly RB 19613 123 23 with with IN 19613 123 24 the the DT 19613 123 25 view view NN 19613 123 26 of of IN 19613 123 27 disproving disproving JJ 19613 123 28 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 123 29 conceptions conception NNS 19613 123 30 , , , 19613 123 31 partly partly RB 19613 123 32 for for IN 19613 123 33 the the DT 19613 123 34 purpose purpose NN 19613 123 35 of of IN 19613 123 36 satisfying satisfy VBG 19613 123 37 the the DT 19613 123 38 Church Church NNP 19613 123 39 's 's POS 19613 123 40 own own JJ 19613 123 41 needs need NNS 19613 123 42 . . . 19613 124 1 The the DT 19613 124 2 framework framework NN 19613 124 3 in in IN 19613 124 4 which which WDT 19613 124 5 these these DT 19613 124 6 articles article NNS 19613 124 7 were be VBD 19613 124 8 placed place VBN 19613 124 9 virtually virtually RB 19613 124 10 continued continue VBN 19613 124 11 to to TO 19613 124 12 be be VB 19613 124 13 the the DT 19613 124 14 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 124 15 theology theology NN 19613 124 16 , , , 19613 124 17 for for IN 19613 124 18 this this DT 19613 124 19 maintained maintain VBD 19613 124 20 a a DT 19613 124 21 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 124 22 of of IN 19613 124 23 God God NNP 19613 124 24 and and CC 19613 124 25 the the DT 19613 124 26 world world NN 19613 124 27 , , , 19613 124 28 which which WDT 19613 124 29 seemed seem VBD 19613 124 30 to to TO 19613 124 31 correspond correspond VB 19613 124 32 to to IN 19613 124 33 the the DT 19613 124 34 earliest early JJS 19613 124 35 tradition tradition NN 19613 124 36 as as RB 19613 124 37 much much RB 19613 124 38 as as IN 19613 124 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 124 40 ran run VBD 19613 124 41 counter counter RB 19613 124 42 to to IN 19613 124 43 the the DT 19613 124 44 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 124 45 these these DT 19613 124 46 s s NNS 19613 124 47 . . . 19613 125 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 125 2 Melito Melito NNP 19613 125 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 125 4 , , , 19613 125 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 125 6 , , , 19613 125 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 125 8 and and CC 19613 125 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 125 10 , , , 19613 125 11 aided aid VBD 19613 125 12 more more RBR 19613 125 13 or or CC 19613 125 14 less less RBR 19613 125 15 by by IN 19613 125 16 tradition tradition NN 19613 125 17 on on IN 19613 125 18 the the DT 19613 125 19 one one CD 19613 125 20 hand hand NN 19613 125 21 and and CC 19613 125 22 by by IN 19613 125 23 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 125 24 on on IN 19613 125 25 the the DT 19613 125 26 other other JJ 19613 125 27 , , , 19613 125 28 opposed opposed JJ 19613 125 29 to to IN 19613 125 30 the the DT 19613 125 31 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 125 32 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 125 33 about about IN 19613 125 34 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 125 35 the the DT 19613 125 36 articles article NNS 19613 125 37 of of IN 19613 125 38 the the DT 19613 125 39 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 125 40 confession confession NN 19613 125 41 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 125 42 as as IN 19613 125 43 a a DT 19613 125 44 rule rule NN 19613 125 45 of of IN 19613 125 46 faith faith NN 19613 125 47 , , , 19613 125 48 these these DT 19613 125 49 articles article NNS 19613 125 50 being be VBG 19613 125 51 developed develop VBN 19613 125 52 into into IN 19613 125 53 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 125 54 . . . 19613 126 1 Here here RB 19613 126 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 126 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 126 4 learned learn VBD 19613 126 5 very very RB 19613 126 6 much much RB 19613 126 7 from from IN 19613 126 8 the the DT 19613 126 9 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 126 10 and and CC 19613 126 11 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 126 12 . . . 19613 127 1 If if IN 19613 127 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 127 3 define define VBP 19613 127 4 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 127 5 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 127 6 as as IN 19613 127 7 propositions proposition NNS 19613 127 8 handed hand VBD 19613 127 9 down down RP 19613 127 10 in in IN 19613 127 11 the the DT 19613 127 12 creed creed NN 19613 127 13 of of IN 19613 127 14 the the DT 19613 127 15 Church Church NNP 19613 127 16 , , , 19613 127 17 shown show VBN 19613 127 18 to to TO 19613 127 19 exist exist VB 19613 127 20 in in IN 19613 127 21 the the DT 19613 127 22 Holy Holy NNP 19613 127 23 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 127 24 of of IN 19613 127 25 both both DT 19613 127 26 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 127 27 , , , 19613 127 28 and and CC 19613 127 29 rationally rationally RB 19613 127 30 reproduced reproduce VBN 19613 127 31 and and CC 19613 127 32 formulated formulate VBD 19613 127 33 , , , 19613 127 34 then then RB 19613 127 35 the the DT 19613 127 36 men man NNS 19613 127 37 we -PRON- PRP 19613 127 38 have have VBP 19613 127 39 just just RB 19613 127 40 mentioned mention VBN 19613 127 41 were be VBD 19613 127 42 the the DT 19613 127 43 first first JJ 19613 127 44 to to TO 19613 127 45 set set VB 19613 127 46 up up RP 19613 127 47 dogmas[8]--dogmas dogmas[8]--dogma NNS 19613 127 48 but but CC 19613 127 49 no no DT 19613 127 50 system system NN 19613 127 51 of of IN 19613 127 52 dogmatics dogmatic NNS 19613 127 53 . . . 19613 128 1 As as IN 19613 128 2 yet yet RB 19613 128 3 the the DT 19613 128 4 difficulty difficulty NN 19613 128 5 of of IN 19613 128 6 the the DT 19613 128 7 problem problem NN 19613 128 8 was be VBD 19613 128 9 by by IN 19613 128 10 no no DT 19613 128 11 means means NN 19613 128 12 perceived perceive VBN 19613 128 13 by by IN 19613 128 14 these these DT 19613 128 15 men man NNS 19613 128 16 either either RB 19613 128 17 . . . 19613 129 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 129 2 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 129 3 capacity capacity NN 19613 129 4 for for IN 19613 129 5 sympathising sympathise VBG 19613 129 6 with with IN 19613 129 7 and and CC 19613 129 8 understanding understand VBG 19613 129 9 the the DT 19613 129 10 traditional traditional JJ 19613 129 11 and and CC 19613 129 12 the the DT 19613 129 13 old old JJ 19613 129 14 still still RB 19613 129 15 left leave VBD 19613 129 16 them -PRON- PRP 19613 129 17 in in IN 19613 129 18 a a DT 19613 129 19 happy happy JJ 19613 129 20 blindness blindness NN 19613 129 21 . . . 19613 130 1 So so RB 19613 130 2 far far RB 19613 130 3 as as IN 19613 130 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 130 5 had have VBD 19613 130 6 a a DT 19613 130 7 theology theology NN 19613 130 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 130 9 supposed suppose VBD 19613 130 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 130 11 to to TO 19613 130 12 be be VB 19613 130 13 nothing nothing NN 19613 130 14 more more JJR 19613 130 15 than than IN 19613 130 16 the the DT 19613 130 17 explanation explanation NN 19613 130 18 of of IN 19613 130 19 the the DT 19613 130 20 faith faith NN 19613 130 21 of of IN 19613 130 22 the the DT 19613 130 23 Christian christian JJ 19613 130 24 multitude multitude NN 19613 130 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 130 26 yet yet CC 19613 130 27 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 130 28 already already RB 19613 130 29 noted note VBD 19613 130 30 the the DT 19613 130 31 difference difference NN 19613 130 32 in in IN 19613 130 33 one one CD 19613 130 34 point point NN 19613 130 35 , , , 19613 130 36 certainly certainly RB 19613 130 37 a a DT 19613 130 38 very very RB 19613 130 39 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 130 40 one one CD 19613 130 41 , , , 19613 130 42 viz viz NNP 19613 130 43 . . NNP 19613 130 44 , , , 19613 130 45 the the DT 19613 130 46 Logos Logos NNP 19613 130 47 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 130 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 130 49 . . . 19613 131 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 131 2 still still RB 19613 131 3 lived live VBD 19613 131 4 in in IN 19613 131 5 the the DT 19613 131 6 belief belief NN 19613 131 7 that that IN 19613 131 8 the the DT 19613 131 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 131 10 which which WDT 19613 131 11 filled fill VBD 19613 131 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 131 13 minds mind NNS 19613 131 14 required require VBD 19613 131 15 no no DT 19613 131 16 scientific scientific JJ 19613 131 17 remodelling remodelling NN 19613 131 18 in in IN 19613 131 19 order order NN 19613 131 20 to to TO 19613 131 21 be be VB 19613 131 22 an an DT 19613 131 23 expression expression NN 19613 131 24 of of IN 19613 131 25 the the DT 19613 131 26 highest high JJS 19613 131 27 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 131 28 , , , 19613 131 29 and and CC 19613 131 30 that that IN 19613 131 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 131 32 was be VBD 19613 131 33 in in IN 19613 131 34 all all DT 19613 131 35 respects respect NNS 19613 131 36 identical identical JJ 19613 131 37 with with IN 19613 131 38 the the DT 19613 131 39 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 131 40 which which WDT 19613 131 41 even even RB 19613 131 42 the the DT 19613 131 43 most most RBS 19613 131 44 uncultivated uncultivated JJ 19613 131 45 could could MD 19613 131 46 grasp grasp VB 19613 131 47 . . . 19613 132 1 That that IN 19613 132 2 this this DT 19613 132 3 was be VBD 19613 132 4 an an DT 19613 132 5 illusion illusion NN 19613 132 6 is be VBZ 19613 132 7 proved prove VBN 19613 132 8 by by IN 19613 132 9 many many JJ 19613 132 10 considerations consideration NNS 19613 132 11 , , , 19613 132 12 but but CC 19613 132 13 most most RBS 19613 132 14 convincingly convincingly RB 19613 132 15 by by IN 19613 132 16 the the DT 19613 132 17 fact fact NN 19613 132 18 that that IN 19613 132 19 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 132 20 and and CC 19613 132 21 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 132 22 had have VBD 19613 132 23 the the DT 19613 132 24 main main JJ 19613 132 25 share share NN 19613 132 26 in in IN 19613 132 27 introducing introduce VBG 19613 132 28 into into IN 19613 132 29 the the DT 19613 132 30 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 132 31 of of IN 19613 132 32 faith faith NN 19613 132 33 a a DT 19613 132 34 philosophically philosophically RB 19613 132 35 formulated formulate VBN 19613 132 36 dogma dogma NN 19613 132 37 , , , 19613 132 38 viz viz NNP 19613 132 39 . . NNP 19613 132 40 , , , 19613 132 41 that that IN 19613 132 42 the the DT 19613 132 43 Son Son NNP 19613 132 44 of of IN 19613 132 45 God God NNP 19613 132 46 is be VBZ 19613 132 47 the the DT 19613 132 48 Logos Logos NNP 19613 132 49 , , , 19613 132 50 and and CC 19613 132 51 in in IN 19613 132 52 having have VBG 19613 132 53 it -PRON- PRP 19613 132 54 made make VBD 19613 132 55 the the DT 19613 132 56 _ _ NNP 19613 132 57 articulus articulus JJ 19613 132 58 constitutivus constitutivu VBN 19613 132 59 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 132 60 _ _ NNP 19613 132 61 . . . 19613 133 1 The the DT 19613 133 2 effects effect NNS 19613 133 3 of of IN 19613 133 4 this this DT 19613 133 5 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 133 6 can can MD 19613 133 7 never never RB 19613 133 8 be be VB 19613 133 9 too too RB 19613 133 10 highly highly RB 19613 133 11 estimated estimate VBN 19613 133 12 , , , 19613 133 13 for for IN 19613 133 14 the the DT 19613 133 15 Logos Logos NNP 19613 133 16 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 133 17 is be VBZ 19613 133 18 Greek greek JJ 19613 133 19 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 133 20 _ _ NNP 19613 133 21 in in IN 19613 133 22 nuce nuce NN 19613 133 23 _ _ NNP 19613 133 24 , , , 19613 133 25 though though IN 19613 133 26 primitive primitive JJ 19613 133 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 133 28 views view NNS 19613 133 29 may may MD 19613 133 30 have have VB 19613 133 31 been be VBN 19613 133 32 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 133 33 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 133 34 with with IN 19613 133 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 133 36 . . . 19613 134 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 134 2 introduction introduction NN 19613 134 3 into into IN 19613 134 4 the the DT 19613 134 5 creed creed NN 19613 134 6 of of IN 19613 134 7 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 134 8 , , , 19613 134 9 which which WDT 19613 134 10 was be VBD 19613 134 11 , , , 19613 134 12 strictly strictly RB 19613 134 13 speaking speak VBG 19613 134 14 , , , 19613 134 15 the the DT 19613 134 16 setting setting NN 19613 134 17 up up RP 19613 134 18 _ _ NNP 19613 134 19 of of IN 19613 134 20 the the DT 19613 134 21 first first JJ 19613 134 22 dogma dogma NN 19613 134 23 in in IN 19613 134 24 the the DT 19613 134 25 Church Church NNP 19613 134 26 _ _ NNP 19613 134 27 , , , 19613 134 28 meant mean VBD 19613 134 29 the the DT 19613 134 30 future future JJ 19613 134 31 conversion conversion NN 19613 134 32 of of IN 19613 134 33 the the DT 19613 134 34 rule rule NN 19613 134 35 of of IN 19613 134 36 faith faith NN 19613 134 37 into into IN 19613 134 38 a a DT 19613 134 39 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 134 40 system system NN 19613 134 41 . . . 19613 135 1 But but CC 19613 135 2 in in IN 19613 135 3 yet yet RB 19613 135 4 another another DT 19613 135 5 respect respect NN 19613 135 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 135 7 and and CC 19613 135 8 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 135 9 denote denote VB 19613 135 10 an an DT 19613 135 11 immense immense JJ 19613 135 12 advance advance NN 19613 135 13 beyond beyond IN 19613 135 14 the the DT 19613 135 15 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 135 16 , , , 19613 135 17 which which WDT 19613 135 18 , , , 19613 135 19 paradoxically paradoxically RB 19613 135 20 enough enough RB 19613 135 21 , , , 19613 135 22 results result VBZ 19613 135 23 both both DT 19613 135 24 from from IN 19613 135 25 the the DT 19613 135 26 progress progress NN 19613 135 27 of of IN 19613 135 28 Christian Christian NNP 19613 135 29 Hellenism Hellenism NNP 19613 135 30 and and CC 19613 135 31 from from IN 19613 135 32 a a DT 19613 135 33 deeper deep JJR 19613 135 34 study study NN 19613 135 35 of of IN 19613 135 36 the the DT 19613 135 37 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 135 38 theology theology NN 19613 135 39 , , , 19613 135 40 that that RB 19613 135 41 is is RB 19613 135 42 , , , 19613 135 43 emanates emanate NNS 19613 135 44 from from IN 19613 135 45 the the DT 19613 135 46 controversy controversy NN 19613 135 47 with with IN 19613 135 48 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 135 49 . . . 19613 136 1 In in IN 19613 136 2 them -PRON- PRP 19613 136 3 a a DT 19613 136 4 religious religious JJ 19613 136 5 and and CC 19613 136 6 realistic realistic JJ 19613 136 7 idea idea NN 19613 136 8 takes take VBZ 19613 136 9 the the DT 19613 136 10 place place NN 19613 136 11 of of IN 19613 136 12 the the DT 19613 136 13 moralism moralism NN 19613 136 14 of of IN 19613 136 15 the the DT 19613 136 16 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 136 17 , , , 19613 136 18 namely namely RB 19613 136 19 , , , 19613 136 20 the the DT 19613 136 21 deifying deifying NN 19613 136 22 of of IN 19613 136 23 the the DT 19613 136 24 human human JJ 19613 136 25 race race NN 19613 136 26 through through IN 19613 136 27 the the DT 19613 136 28 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 136 29 of of IN 19613 136 30 the the DT 19613 136 31 Son Son NNP 19613 136 32 of of IN 19613 136 33 God God NNP 19613 136 34 . . . 19613 137 1 The the DT 19613 137 2 apotheosis apotheosis NN 19613 137 3 of of IN 19613 137 4 mortal mortal JJ 19613 137 5 man man NN 19613 137 6 through through IN 19613 137 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 137 8 acquisition acquisition NN 19613 137 9 of of IN 19613 137 10 immortality immortality NN 19613 137 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 137 12 divine divine JJ 19613 137 13 life life NN 19613 137 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 137 15 is be VBZ 19613 137 16 the the DT 19613 137 17 idea idea NN 19613 137 18 of of IN 19613 137 19 salvation salvation NN 19613 137 20 which which WDT 19613 137 21 was be VBD 19613 137 22 taught teach VBN 19613 137 23 in in IN 19613 137 24 the the DT 19613 137 25 ancient ancient JJ 19613 137 26 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 137 27 . . . 19613 138 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 138 2 is be VBZ 19613 138 3 here here RB 19613 138 4 adopted adopt VBN 19613 138 5 as as IN 19613 138 6 a a DT 19613 138 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 138 8 one one NN 19613 138 9 , , , 19613 138 10 supported support VBN 19613 138 11 by by IN 19613 138 12 the the DT 19613 138 13 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 138 14 theology theology NN 19613 138 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 138 16 especially especially RB 19613 138 17 as as IN 19613 138 18 contained contain VBN 19613 138 19 in in IN 19613 138 20 the the DT 19613 138 21 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 138 22 to to IN 19613 138 23 the the DT 19613 138 24 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 19613 138 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 138 26 , , , 19613 138 27 and and CC 19613 138 28 brought bring VBD 19613 138 29 into into IN 19613 138 30 the the DT 19613 138 31 closest close JJS 19613 138 32 connection connection NN 19613 138 33 with with IN 19613 138 34 the the DT 19613 138 35 historical historical JJ 19613 138 36 Christ Christ NNP 19613 138 37 , , , 19613 138 38 the the DT 19613 138 39 Son Son NNP 19613 138 40 of of IN 19613 138 41 God God NNP 19613 138 42 and and CC 19613 138 43 Son Son NNP 19613 138 44 of of IN 19613 138 45 man man NNP 19613 138 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 138 47 filius filius NNP 19613 138 48 dei dei NNP 19613 138 49 et et NNP 19613 138 50 filius filius NNP 19613 138 51 hominis hominis NNP 19613 138 52 ) ) -RRB- 19613 138 53 . . . 19613 139 1 What what WP 19613 139 2 the the DT 19613 139 3 heathen heathen NN 19613 139 4 faintly faintly RB 19613 139 5 hoped hope VBD 19613 139 6 for for IN 19613 139 7 as as IN 19613 139 8 a a DT 19613 139 9 possibility possibility NN 19613 139 10 was be VBD 19613 139 11 here here RB 19613 139 12 announced announce VBN 19613 139 13 as as IN 19613 139 14 certain certain JJ 19613 139 15 , , , 19613 139 16 and and CC 19613 139 17 indeed indeed RB 19613 139 18 as as IN 19613 139 19 having have VBG 19613 139 20 already already RB 19613 139 21 taken take VBN 19613 139 22 place place NN 19613 139 23 . . . 19613 140 1 What what WDT 19613 140 2 a a DT 19613 140 3 message message NN 19613 140 4 ! ! . 19613 141 1 This this DT 19613 141 2 conception conception NN 19613 141 3 was be VBD 19613 141 4 to to TO 19613 141 5 become become VB 19613 141 6 the the DT 19613 141 7 central central JJ 19613 141 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 141 9 idea idea NN 19613 141 10 of of IN 19613 141 11 the the DT 19613 141 12 future future NN 19613 141 13 . . . 19613 142 1 A a DT 19613 142 2 long long JJ 19613 142 3 time time NN 19613 142 4 , , , 19613 142 5 however however RB 19613 142 6 , , , 19613 142 7 elapsed elapse VBD 19613 142 8 before before IN 19613 142 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 142 10 made make VBD 19613 142 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 142 12 way way NN 19613 142 13 into into IN 19613 142 14 the the DT 19613 142 15 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 142 16 system system NN 19613 142 17 of of IN 19613 142 18 the the DT 19613 142 19 Church Church NNP 19613 142 20 . . . 19613 143 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 143 2 9 9 CD 19613 143 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 143 4 But but CC 19613 143 5 meanwhile meanwhile RB 19613 143 6 the the DT 19613 143 7 huge huge JJ 19613 143 8 gulf gulf NN 19613 143 9 which which WDT 19613 143 10 existed exist VBD 19613 143 11 between between IN 19613 143 12 both both DT 19613 143 13 Testaments testament NNS 19613 143 14 and and CC 19613 143 15 the the DT 19613 143 16 rule rule NN 19613 143 17 of of IN 19613 143 18 faith faith NN 19613 143 19 on on IN 19613 143 20 the the DT 19613 143 21 one one CD 19613 143 22 hand hand NN 19613 143 23 , , , 19613 143 24 and and CC 19613 143 25 the the DT 19613 143 26 current current JJ 19613 143 27 ideas idea NNS 19613 143 28 of of IN 19613 143 29 the the DT 19613 143 30 time time NN 19613 143 31 on on IN 19613 143 32 the the DT 19613 143 33 other other JJ 19613 143 34 , , , 19613 143 35 had have VBD 19613 143 36 been be VBN 19613 143 37 recognized recognize VBN 19613 143 38 in in IN 19613 143 39 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 143 40 . . . 19613 144 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 144 2 was be VBD 19613 144 3 not not RB 19613 144 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 144 5 felt feel VBN 19613 144 6 as as IN 19613 144 7 a a DT 19613 144 8 gulf gulf NN 19613 144 9 , , , 19613 144 10 for for IN 19613 144 11 then then RB 19613 144 12 either either CC 19613 144 13 the the DT 19613 144 14 one one CD 19613 144 15 or or CC 19613 144 16 the the DT 19613 144 17 other other JJ 19613 144 18 would would MD 19613 144 19 have have VB 19613 144 20 had have VBN 19613 144 21 to to TO 19613 144 22 be be VB 19613 144 23 given give VBN 19613 144 24 up up RP 19613 144 25 , , , 19613 144 26 but but CC 19613 144 27 as as IN 19613 144 28 a a DT 19613 144 29 _ _ NNP 19613 144 30 problem problem NN 19613 144 31 _ _ NNP 19613 144 32 . . . 19613 145 1 If if IN 19613 145 2 the the DT 19613 145 3 Church Church NNP 19613 145 4 tradition tradition NN 19613 145 5 contained contain VBD 19613 145 6 the the DT 19613 145 7 assurance assurance NN 19613 145 8 , , , 19613 145 9 not not RB 19613 145 10 to to TO 19613 145 11 be be VB 19613 145 12 obtained obtain VBN 19613 145 13 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 145 14 , , , 19613 145 15 of of IN 19613 145 16 all all DT 19613 145 17 that that DT 19613 145 18 Greek greek JJ 19613 145 19 culture culture NN 19613 145 20 knew know VBD 19613 145 21 , , , 19613 145 22 hoped hope VBD 19613 145 23 for for IN 19613 145 24 , , , 19613 145 25 and and CC 19613 145 26 prized prize VBN 19613 145 27 , , , 19613 145 28 and and CC 19613 145 29 if if IN 19613 145 30 for for IN 19613 145 31 that that DT 19613 145 32 very very JJ 19613 145 33 reason reason NN 19613 145 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 145 35 was be VBD 19613 145 36 regarded regard VBN 19613 145 37 as as IN 19613 145 38 in in IN 19613 145 39 every every DT 19613 145 40 respect respect NN 19613 145 41 inviolable inviolable JJ 19613 145 42 , , , 19613 145 43 then then RB 19613 145 44 the the DT 19613 145 45 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 145 46 indissoluble indissoluble JJ 19613 145 47 union union NN 19613 145 48 of of IN 19613 145 49 Christian christian JJ 19613 145 50 tradition tradition NN 19613 145 51 with with IN 19613 145 52 the the DT 19613 145 53 Greek greek JJ 19613 145 54 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 145 55 of of IN 19613 145 56 religion religion NN 19613 145 57 was be VBD 19613 145 58 placed place VBN 19613 145 59 beyond beyond IN 19613 145 60 all all DT 19613 145 61 doubt doubt NN 19613 145 62 . . . 19613 146 1 But but CC 19613 146 2 an an DT 19613 146 3 immense immense JJ 19613 146 4 number number NN 19613 146 5 of of IN 19613 146 6 problems problem NNS 19613 146 7 were be VBD 19613 146 8 at at IN 19613 146 9 the the DT 19613 146 10 same same JJ 19613 146 11 time time NN 19613 146 12 raised raise VBN 19613 146 13 , , , 19613 146 14 especially especially RB 19613 146 15 when when WRB 19613 146 16 , , , 19613 146 17 as as IN 19613 146 18 in in IN 19613 146 19 the the DT 19613 146 20 case case NN 19613 146 21 of of IN 19613 146 22 the the DT 19613 146 23 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 146 24 , , , 19613 146 25 heathen heathen NNP 19613 146 26 syncretism syncretism NN 19613 146 27 in in IN 19613 146 28 the the DT 19613 146 29 entire entire JJ 19613 146 30 breadth breadth NN 19613 146 31 of of IN 19613 146 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 146 33 development development NN 19613 146 34 was be VBD 19613 146 35 united unite VBN 19613 146 36 with with IN 19613 146 37 the the DT 19613 146 38 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 146 39 of of IN 19613 146 40 the the DT 19613 146 41 Church Church NNP 19613 146 42 . . . 19613 147 1 The the DT 19613 147 2 task task NN 19613 147 3 , , , 19613 147 4 which which WDT 19613 147 5 had have VBD 19613 147 6 been be VBN 19613 147 7 begun begin VBN 19613 147 8 by by IN 19613 147 9 Philo Philo NNP 19613 147 10 and and CC 19613 147 11 carried carry VBN 19613 147 12 on on RP 19613 147 13 by by IN 19613 147 14 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 147 15 and and CC 19613 147 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 147 17 school school NN 19613 147 18 , , , 19613 147 19 was be VBD 19613 147 20 now now RB 19613 147 21 undertaken undertake VBN 19613 147 22 in in IN 19613 147 23 the the DT 19613 147 24 Church Church NNP 19613 147 25 . . . 19613 148 1 Clement clement NN 19613 148 2 led lead VBD 19613 148 3 the the DT 19613 148 4 way way NN 19613 148 5 in in IN 19613 148 6 attempting attempt VBG 19613 148 7 a a DT 19613 148 8 solution solution NN 19613 148 9 of of IN 19613 148 10 the the DT 19613 148 11 problem problem NN 19613 148 12 , , , 19613 148 13 but but CC 19613 148 14 the the DT 19613 148 15 huge huge JJ 19613 148 16 task task NN 19613 148 17 proved prove VBD 19613 148 18 too too RB 19613 148 19 much much JJ 19613 148 20 for for IN 19613 148 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 148 22 . . . 19613 149 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 149 2 took take VBD 19613 149 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 149 4 up up RP 19613 149 5 under under IN 19613 149 6 more more RBR 19613 149 7 difficult difficult JJ 19613 149 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 149 9 , , , 19613 149 10 and and CC 19613 149 11 in in IN 19613 149 12 a a DT 19613 149 13 certain certain JJ 19613 149 14 fashion fashion NN 19613 149 15 brought bring VBD 19613 149 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 149 17 to to IN 19613 149 18 a a DT 19613 149 19 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 149 20 . . . 19613 150 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 150 2 , , , 19613 150 3 the the DT 19613 150 4 rival rival NN 19613 150 5 of of IN 19613 150 6 the the DT 19613 150 7 Neoplatonic neoplatonic JJ 19613 150 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 150 9 , , , 19613 150 10 the the DT 19613 150 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 150 12 Philo Philo NNP 19613 150 13 , , , 19613 150 14 wrote write VBD 19613 150 15 the the DT 19613 150 16 first first JJ 19613 150 17 Christian christian JJ 19613 150 18 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 150 19 , , , 19613 150 20 which which WDT 19613 150 21 competed compete VBD 19613 150 22 with with IN 19613 150 23 the the DT 19613 150 24 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 150 25 systems system NNS 19613 150 26 of of IN 19613 150 27 the the DT 19613 150 28 time time NN 19613 150 29 , , , 19613 150 30 and and CC 19613 150 31 which which WDT 19613 150 32 , , , 19613 150 33 founded found VBD 19613 150 34 on on IN 19613 150 35 the the DT 19613 150 36 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 150 37 of of IN 19613 150 38 both both DT 19613 150 39 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 150 40 , , , 19613 150 41 presents present VBZ 19613 150 42 a a DT 19613 150 43 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 150 44 union union NN 19613 150 45 of of IN 19613 150 46 the the DT 19613 150 47 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 150 48 theology theology NN 19613 150 49 of of IN 19613 150 50 a a DT 19613 150 51 Justin Justin NNP 19613 150 52 and and CC 19613 150 53 the the DT 19613 150 54 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 150 55 theology theology NN 19613 150 56 of of IN 19613 150 57 a a DT 19613 150 58 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 150 59 , , , 19613 150 60 while while IN 19613 150 61 keeping keep VBG 19613 150 62 steadily steadily RB 19613 150 63 in in IN 19613 150 64 view view NN 19613 150 65 a a DT 19613 150 66 simple simple JJ 19613 150 67 and and CC 19613 150 68 highly highly RB 19613 150 69 practical practical JJ 19613 150 70 aim aim NN 19613 150 71 . . . 19613 151 1 In in IN 19613 151 2 this this DT 19613 151 3 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 151 4 the the DT 19613 151 5 rule rule NN 19613 151 6 of of IN 19613 151 7 faith faith NN 19613 151 8 is be VBZ 19613 151 9 recast recast VBN 19613 151 10 and and CC 19613 151 11 that that IN 19613 151 12 quite quite RB 19613 151 13 consciously consciously RB 19613 151 14 . . . 19613 152 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 152 2 did do VBD 19613 152 3 not not RB 19613 152 4 conceal conceal VB 19613 152 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 152 6 conviction conviction NN 19613 152 7 that that IN 19613 152 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 152 9 finds find VBZ 19613 152 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 152 11 correct correct JJ 19613 152 12 expression expression NN 19613 152 13 only only RB 19613 152 14 in in IN 19613 152 15 scientific scientific JJ 19613 152 16 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 152 17 , , , 19613 152 18 and and CC 19613 152 19 that that IN 19613 152 20 every every DT 19613 152 21 form form NN 19613 152 22 of of IN 19613 152 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 152 24 that that WDT 19613 152 25 lacks lack VBZ 19613 152 26 theology theology NN 19613 152 27 is be VBZ 19613 152 28 but but CC 19613 152 29 a a DT 19613 152 30 meagre meagre JJ 19613 152 31 kind kind NN 19613 152 32 with with IN 19613 152 33 no no DT 19613 152 34 clear clear JJ 19613 152 35 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 152 36 of of IN 19613 152 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 152 38 own own JJ 19613 152 39 content content NN 19613 152 40 . . . 19613 153 1 This this DT 19613 153 2 conviction conviction NN 19613 153 3 plainly plainly RB 19613 153 4 shows show VBZ 19613 153 5 that that IN 19613 153 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 153 7 was be VBD 19613 153 8 dealing deal VBG 19613 153 9 with with IN 19613 153 10 a a DT 19613 153 11 different different JJ 19613 153 12 kind kind NN 19613 153 13 of of IN 19613 153 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 153 15 , , , 19613 153 16 though though IN 19613 153 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 153 18 view view NN 19613 153 19 that that IN 19613 153 20 a a DT 19613 153 21 mere mere JJ 19613 153 22 relative relative JJ 19613 153 23 distinction distinction NN 19613 153 24 existed exist VBD 19613 153 25 here here RB 19613 153 26 may may MD 19613 153 27 have have VB 19613 153 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 153 29 justification justification NN 19613 153 30 in in IN 19613 153 31 the the DT 19613 153 32 fact fact NN 19613 153 33 , , , 19613 153 34 that that IN 19613 153 35 the the DT 19613 153 36 untheological untheological JJ 19613 153 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 153 38 of of IN 19613 153 39 the the DT 19613 153 40 age age NN 19613 153 41 with with IN 19613 153 42 which which WDT 19613 153 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 153 44 compared compare VBD 19613 153 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 153 46 own own JJ 19613 153 47 was be VBD 19613 153 48 already already RB 19613 153 49 permeated permeate VBN 19613 153 50 by by IN 19613 153 51 Hellenic hellenic JJ 19613 153 52 elements element NNS 19613 153 53 and and CC 19613 153 54 in in IN 19613 153 55 a a DT 19613 153 56 very very RB 19613 153 57 great great JJ 19613 153 58 measure measure NN 19613 153 59 secularised secularise VBD 19613 153 60 . . . 19613 154 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 154 2 10 10 CD 19613 154 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 154 4 But but CC 19613 154 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 154 6 , , , 19613 154 7 as as RB 19613 154 8 well well RB 19613 154 9 as as IN 19613 154 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 154 11 before before IN 19613 154 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 154 13 , , , 19613 154 14 had have VBD 19613 154 15 really really RB 19613 154 16 a a DT 19613 154 17 right right NN 19613 154 18 to to IN 19613 154 19 the the DT 19613 154 20 conviction conviction NN 19613 154 21 that that IN 19613 154 22 the the DT 19613 154 23 true true JJ 19613 154 24 essence essence NN 19613 154 25 of of IN 19613 154 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 154 27 , , , 19613 154 28 or or CC 19613 154 29 , , , 19613 154 30 in in IN 19613 154 31 other other JJ 19613 154 32 words word NNS 19613 154 33 , , , 19613 154 34 the the DT 19613 154 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 154 36 , , , 19613 154 37 is be VBZ 19613 154 38 only only RB 19613 154 39 arrived arrive VBN 19613 154 40 at at IN 19613 154 41 by by IN 19613 154 42 the the DT 19613 154 43 aid aid NN 19613 154 44 of of IN 19613 154 45 critical critical JJ 19613 154 46 speculation speculation NN 19613 154 47 ; ; , 19613 154 48 for for IN 19613 154 49 was be VBD 19613 154 50 not not RB 19613 154 51 the the DT 19613 154 52 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 154 53 veiled veil VBD 19613 154 54 and and CC 19613 154 55 hidden hide VBN 19613 154 56 in in IN 19613 154 57 the the DT 19613 154 58 canon canon NN 19613 154 59 of of IN 19613 154 60 both both DT 19613 154 61 Testaments Testaments NNP 19613 154 62 , , , 19613 154 63 was be VBD 19613 154 64 it -PRON- PRP 19613 154 65 not not RB 19613 154 66 displaced displace VBN 19613 154 67 by by IN 19613 154 68 the the DT 19613 154 69 rule rule NN 19613 154 70 of of IN 19613 154 71 faith faith NN 19613 154 72 , , , 19613 154 73 was be VBD 19613 154 74 it -PRON- PRP 19613 154 75 not not RB 19613 154 76 crushed crush VBN 19613 154 77 down down RP 19613 154 78 , , , 19613 154 79 depotentiated depotentiate VBN 19613 154 80 , , , 19613 154 81 and and CC 19613 154 82 disfigured disfigure VBD 19613 154 83 in in IN 19613 154 84 the the DT 19613 154 85 Church Church NNP 19613 154 86 which which WDT 19613 154 87 identified identify VBD 19613 154 88 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 154 89 with with IN 19613 154 90 the the DT 19613 154 91 people people NNS 19613 154 92 of of IN 19613 154 93 Christ Christ NNP 19613 154 94 ? ? . 19613 155 1 Clement Clement NNP 19613 155 2 and and CC 19613 155 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 155 4 found find VBD 19613 155 5 freedom freedom NN 19613 155 6 and and CC 19613 155 7 independence independence NN 19613 155 8 in in IN 19613 155 9 what what WP 19613 155 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 155 11 recognized recognize VBD 19613 155 12 to to TO 19613 155 13 be be VB 19613 155 14 the the DT 19613 155 15 essence essence NN 19613 155 16 of of IN 19613 155 17 the the DT 19613 155 18 matter matter NN 19613 155 19 and and CC 19613 155 20 what what WP 19613 155 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 155 22 contrived contrive VBD 19613 155 23 with with IN 19613 155 24 masterly masterly JJ 19613 155 25 skill skill NN 19613 155 26 to to TO 19613 155 27 determine determine VB 19613 155 28 as as IN 19613 155 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 155 30 proper proper JJ 19613 155 31 aim aim NN 19613 155 32 , , , 19613 155 33 after after IN 19613 155 34 an an DT 19613 155 35 examination examination NN 19613 155 36 of of IN 19613 155 37 the the DT 19613 155 38 huge huge JJ 19613 155 39 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 155 40 of of IN 19613 155 41 tradition tradition NN 19613 155 42 . . . 19613 156 1 But but CC 19613 156 2 was be VBD 19613 156 3 not not RB 19613 156 4 that that IN 19613 156 5 the the DT 19613 156 6 ideal ideal NN 19613 156 7 of of IN 19613 156 8 Greek greek JJ 19613 156 9 sages sage NNS 19613 156 10 and and CC 19613 156 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 156 12 ? ? . 19613 157 1 This this DT 19613 157 2 question question NN 19613 157 3 can can MD 19613 157 4 by by IN 19613 157 5 no no DT 19613 157 6 means means NN 19613 157 7 be be VB 19613 157 8 flatly flatly RB 19613 157 9 answered answer VBN 19613 157 10 in in IN 19613 157 11 the the DT 19613 157 12 negative negative JJ 19613 157 13 , , , 19613 157 14 and and CC 19613 157 15 still still RB 19613 157 16 less less RBR 19613 157 17 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 157 18 in in IN 19613 157 19 the the DT 19613 157 20 affirmative affirmative JJ 19613 157 21 , , , 19613 157 22 for for IN 19613 157 23 a a DT 19613 157 24 new new JJ 19613 157 25 significance significance NN 19613 157 26 was be VBD 19613 157 27 here here RB 19613 157 28 given give VBN 19613 157 29 to to IN 19613 157 30 the the DT 19613 157 31 ideal ideal NN 19613 157 32 by by IN 19613 157 33 representing represent VBG 19613 157 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 157 35 _ _ NNP 19613 157 36 as as RB 19613 157 37 assured assure VBN 19613 157 38 beyond beyond IN 19613 157 39 all all RB 19613 157 40 doubt doubt NN 19613 157 41 , , , 19613 157 42 already already RB 19613 157 43 realised realise VBN 19613 157 44 _ _ NNP 19613 157 45 in in IN 19613 157 46 the the DT 19613 157 47 person person NN 19613 157 48 of of IN 19613 157 49 Christ Christ NNP 19613 157 50 and and CC 19613 157 51 incompatible incompatible JJ 19613 157 52 with with IN 19613 157 53 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 157 54 . . . 19613 158 1 If if IN 19613 158 2 , , , 19613 158 3 as as IN 19613 158 4 is be VBZ 19613 158 5 manifestly manifestly RB 19613 158 6 the the DT 19613 158 7 case case NN 19613 158 8 , , , 19613 158 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 158 10 found find VBD 19613 158 11 joy joy NN 19613 158 12 and and CC 19613 158 13 peace peace NN 19613 158 14 in in IN 19613 158 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 158 16 faith faith NN 19613 158 17 and and CC 19613 158 18 in in IN 19613 158 19 the the DT 19613 158 20 theory theory NN 19613 158 21 of of IN 19613 158 22 the the DT 19613 158 23 universe universe NN 19613 158 24 connected connect VBN 19613 158 25 with with IN 19613 158 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 158 27 , , , 19613 158 28 if if IN 19613 158 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 158 30 prepared prepare VBD 19613 158 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 158 32 for for IN 19613 158 33 an an DT 19613 158 34 eternal eternal JJ 19613 158 35 life life NN 19613 158 36 and and CC 19613 158 37 expected expect VBD 19613 158 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 158 39 with with IN 19613 158 40 certainty certainty NN 19613 158 41 , , , 19613 158 42 if if IN 19613 158 43 they -PRON- PRP 19613 158 44 felt feel VBD 19613 158 45 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 158 46 to to TO 19613 158 47 be be VB 19613 158 48 perfect perfect JJ 19613 158 49 only only RB 19613 158 50 through through IN 19613 158 51 dependence dependence NN 19613 158 52 on on IN 19613 158 53 God God NNP 19613 158 54 , , , 19613 158 55 then then RB 19613 158 56 , , , 19613 158 57 in in IN 19613 158 58 spite spite NN 19613 158 59 of of IN 19613 158 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 158 61 Hellenism Hellenism NNP 19613 158 62 , , , 19613 158 63 they -PRON- PRP 19613 158 64 unquestionably unquestionably RB 19613 158 65 came come VBD 19613 158 66 nearer nearer RB 19613 158 67 to to IN 19613 158 68 the the DT 19613 158 69 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 158 70 than than IN 19613 158 71 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 158 72 with with IN 19613 158 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 158 74 slavish slavish JJ 19613 158 75 dependence dependence NN 19613 158 76 on on IN 19613 158 77 authority authority NN 19613 158 78 . . . 19613 159 1 The the DT 19613 159 2 setting setting NN 19613 159 3 up up RP 19613 159 4 of of IN 19613 159 5 a a DT 19613 159 6 scientific scientific JJ 19613 159 7 system system NN 19613 159 8 of of IN 19613 159 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 159 10 dogmatics dogmatic NNS 19613 159 11 , , , 19613 159 12 which which WDT 19613 159 13 was be VBD 19613 159 14 still still RB 19613 159 15 something something NN 19613 159 16 different different JJ 19613 159 17 from from IN 19613 159 18 the the DT 19613 159 19 rule rule NN 19613 159 20 of of IN 19613 159 21 faith faith NN 19613 159 22 , , , 19613 159 23 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 159 24 in in IN 19613 159 25 an an DT 19613 159 26 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 159 27 sense sense NN 19613 159 28 , , , 19613 159 29 philosophically philosophically RB 19613 159 30 wrought work VBD 19613 159 31 out out RP 19613 159 32 , , , 19613 159 33 and and CC 19613 159 34 in in IN 19613 159 35 some some DT 19613 159 36 parts part NNS 19613 159 37 proved prove VBN 19613 159 38 from from IN 19613 159 39 the the DT 19613 159 40 Bible Bible NNP 19613 159 41 , , , 19613 159 42 was be VBD 19613 159 43 a a DT 19613 159 44 private private JJ 19613 159 45 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 159 46 of of IN 19613 159 47 Origen Origen NNP 19613 159 48 , , , 19613 159 49 and and CC 19613 159 50 at at IN 19613 159 51 first first JJ 19613 159 52 only only RB 19613 159 53 approved approve VBN 19613 159 54 in in IN 19613 159 55 limited limited JJ 19613 159 56 circles circle NNS 19613 159 57 . . . 19613 160 1 As as IN 19613 160 2 yet yet RB 19613 160 3 , , , 19613 160 4 not not RB 19613 160 5 only only RB 19613 160 6 were be VBD 19613 160 7 certain certain JJ 19613 160 8 bold bold JJ 19613 160 9 changes change NNS 19613 160 10 of of IN 19613 160 11 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 160 12 disputed dispute VBN 19613 160 13 in in IN 19613 160 14 the the DT 19613 160 15 Church Church NNP 19613 160 16 , , , 19613 160 17 but but CC 19613 160 18 the the DT 19613 160 19 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 160 20 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 160 21 , , , 19613 160 22 as as IN 19613 160 23 a a DT 19613 160 24 whole whole NN 19613 160 25 , , , 19613 160 26 was be VBD 19613 160 27 disapproved disapprove VBN 19613 160 28 . . . 19613 161 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 161 2 11 11 CD 19613 161 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 161 4 The the DT 19613 161 5 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 161 6 of of IN 19613 161 7 the the DT 19613 161 8 several several JJ 19613 161 9 provincial provincial JJ 19613 161 10 churches church NNS 19613 161 11 in in IN 19613 161 12 the the DT 19613 161 13 first first JJ 19613 161 14 half half NN 19613 161 15 of of IN 19613 161 16 the the DT 19613 161 17 third third JJ 19613 161 18 century century NN 19613 161 19 were be VBD 19613 161 20 still still RB 19613 161 21 very very RB 19613 161 22 diverse diverse JJ 19613 161 23 . . . 19613 162 1 Many many JJ 19613 162 2 communities community NNS 19613 162 3 had have VBD 19613 162 4 yet yet RB 19613 162 5 to to TO 19613 162 6 adopt adopt VB 19613 162 7 the the DT 19613 162 8 basis basis NN 19613 162 9 that that WDT 19613 162 10 made make VBD 19613 162 11 them -PRON- PRP 19613 162 12 into into IN 19613 162 13 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 162 14 ones one NNS 19613 162 15 ; ; : 19613 162 16 and and CC 19613 162 17 in in IN 19613 162 18 most most RBS 19613 162 19 , , , 19613 162 20 if if IN 19613 162 21 not not RB 19613 162 22 in in IN 19613 162 23 all all DT 19613 162 24 , , , 19613 162 25 the the DT 19613 162 26 education education NN 19613 162 27 of of IN 19613 162 28 the the DT 19613 162 29 clergy clergy NN 19613 162 30 -- -- : 19613 162 31 not not RB 19613 162 32 to to TO 19613 162 33 speak speak VB 19613 162 34 of of IN 19613 162 35 the the DT 19613 162 36 laity laity NN 19613 162 37 -- -- : 19613 162 38 was be VBD 19613 162 39 not not RB 19613 162 40 high high JJ 19613 162 41 enough enough RB 19613 162 42 to to TO 19613 162 43 enable enable VB 19613 162 44 them -PRON- PRP 19613 162 45 to to TO 19613 162 46 appreciate appreciate VB 19613 162 47 systematic systematic JJ 19613 162 48 theology theology NN 19613 162 49 . . . 19613 163 1 But but CC 19613 163 2 the the DT 19613 163 3 schools school NNS 19613 163 4 in in IN 19613 163 5 which which WDT 19613 163 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 163 7 taught teach VBD 19613 163 8 carried carry VBN 19613 163 9 on on IN 19613 163 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 163 11 work work NN 19613 163 12 , , , 19613 163 13 similar similar JJ 19613 163 14 ones one NNS 19613 163 15 were be VBD 19613 163 16 established establish VBN 19613 163 17 , , , 19613 163 18 and and CC 19613 163 19 these these DT 19613 163 20 produced produce VBD 19613 163 21 a a DT 19613 163 22 number number NN 19613 163 23 of of IN 19613 163 24 the the DT 19613 163 25 bishops bishop NNS 19613 163 26 and and CC 19613 163 27 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 163 28 of of IN 19613 163 29 the the DT 19613 163 30 East East NNP 19613 163 31 in in IN 19613 163 32 the the DT 19613 163 33 last last JJ 19613 163 34 half half NN 19613 163 35 of of IN 19613 163 36 the the DT 19613 163 37 third third JJ 19613 163 38 century century NN 19613 163 39 . . . 19613 164 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 164 2 had have VBD 19613 164 3 in in IN 19613 164 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 164 5 hands hand NNS 19613 164 6 the the DT 19613 164 7 means mean NNS 19613 164 8 of of IN 19613 164 9 culture culture NN 19613 164 10 afforded afford VBN 19613 164 11 by by IN 19613 164 12 the the DT 19613 164 13 age age NN 19613 164 14 , , , 19613 164 15 and and CC 19613 164 16 this this DT 19613 164 17 was be VBD 19613 164 18 all all PDT 19613 164 19 the the DT 19613 164 20 more more RBR 19613 164 21 a a DT 19613 164 22 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 164 23 of of IN 19613 164 24 victory victory NN 19613 164 25 because because IN 19613 164 26 the the DT 19613 164 27 laity laity NN 19613 164 28 no no RB 19613 164 29 longer longer RB 19613 164 30 took take VBD 19613 164 31 any any DT 19613 164 32 part part NN 19613 164 33 in in IN 19613 164 34 deciding decide VBG 19613 164 35 the the DT 19613 164 36 form form NN 19613 164 37 of of IN 19613 164 38 religion religion NN 19613 164 39 . . . 19613 165 1 Wherever wherever WRB 19613 165 2 the the DT 19613 165 3 Logos Logos NNP 19613 165 4 Christology Christology NNP 19613 165 5 had have VBD 19613 165 6 been be VBN 19613 165 7 adopted adopt VBN 19613 165 8 the the DT 19613 165 9 future future NN 19613 165 10 of of IN 19613 165 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 165 12 Hellenism Hellenism NNP 19613 165 13 was be VBD 19613 165 14 certain certain JJ 19613 165 15 . . . 19613 166 1 At at IN 19613 166 2 the the DT 19613 166 3 beginning beginning NN 19613 166 4 of of IN 19613 166 5 the the DT 19613 166 6 fourth fourth JJ 19613 166 7 century century NN 19613 166 8 there there EX 19613 166 9 was be VBD 19613 166 10 no no DT 19613 166 11 community community NN 19613 166 12 in in IN 19613 166 13 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 166 14 which which WDT 19613 166 15 , , , 19613 166 16 apart apart RB 19613 166 17 from from IN 19613 166 18 the the DT 19613 166 19 Logos Logos NNP 19613 166 20 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 166 21 , , , 19613 166 22 possessed possess VBD 19613 166 23 a a DT 19613 166 24 purely purely RB 19613 166 25 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 166 26 theory theory NN 19613 166 27 that that WDT 19613 166 28 was be VBD 19613 166 29 regarded regard VBN 19613 166 30 as as IN 19613 166 31 an an DT 19613 166 32 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 166 33 dogma dogma NN 19613 166 34 , , , 19613 166 35 to to TO 19613 166 36 say say VB 19613 166 37 nothing nothing NN 19613 166 38 of of IN 19613 166 39 an an DT 19613 166 40 official official JJ 19613 166 41 scientific scientific JJ 19613 166 42 theology theology NN 19613 166 43 . . . 19613 167 1 But but CC 19613 167 2 the the DT 19613 167 3 system system NN 19613 167 4 of of IN 19613 167 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 167 6 was be VBD 19613 167 7 a a DT 19613 167 8 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 167 9 of of IN 19613 167 10 the the DT 19613 167 11 future future NN 19613 167 12 . . . 19613 168 1 The the DT 19613 168 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 168 3 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 168 4 started start VBD 19613 168 5 the the DT 19613 168 6 crystallising crystallising JJ 19613 168 7 process process NN 19613 168 8 which which WDT 19613 168 9 resulted result VBD 19613 168 10 in in IN 19613 168 11 further further JJ 19613 168 12 deposits deposit NNS 19613 168 13 . . . 19613 169 1 Symbols symbol NNS 19613 169 2 of of IN 19613 169 3 faith faith NN 19613 169 4 were be VBD 19613 169 5 already already RB 19613 169 6 drawn draw VBN 19613 169 7 up up RP 19613 169 8 which which WDT 19613 169 9 contained contain VBD 19613 169 10 a a DT 19613 169 11 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 169 12 mixture mixture NN 19613 169 13 of of IN 19613 169 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 169 15 's 's POS 19613 169 16 theology theology NN 19613 169 17 with with IN 19613 169 18 the the DT 19613 169 19 inflexible inflexible JJ 19613 169 20 Antignostic Antignostic NNP 19613 169 21 _ _ NNP 19613 169 22 regula regula NN 19613 169 23 fidei fidei NNP 19613 169 24 _ _ NNP 19613 169 25 . . . 19613 170 1 One one CD 19613 170 2 celebrated celebrate VBN 19613 170 3 theologian theologian NN 19613 170 4 , , , 19613 170 5 Methodius Methodius NNP 19613 170 6 , , , 19613 170 7 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 170 8 to to TO 19613 170 9 unite unite VB 19613 170 10 the the DT 19613 170 11 theology theology NN 19613 170 12 of of IN 19613 170 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 170 14 and and CC 19613 170 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 170 16 , , , 19613 170 17 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 170 18 realism realism NN 19613 170 19 and and CC 19613 170 20 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 170 21 spiritualism spiritualism NN 19613 170 22 , , , 19613 170 23 under under IN 19613 170 24 the the DT 19613 170 25 badge badge NN 19613 170 26 of of IN 19613 170 27 monastic monastic JJ 19613 170 28 mysticism mysticism NN 19613 170 29 . . . 19613 171 1 The the DT 19613 171 2 developments development NNS 19613 171 3 of of IN 19613 171 4 the the DT 19613 171 5 following follow VBG 19613 171 6 period period NN 19613 171 7 therefore therefore RB 19613 171 8 no no RB 19613 171 9 longer longer RB 19613 171 10 appear appear VBP 19613 171 11 surprising surprising JJ 19613 171 12 in in IN 19613 171 13 any any DT 19613 171 14 respect respect NN 19613 171 15 . . . 19613 172 1 As as IN 19613 172 2 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 172 3 , , , 19613 172 4 from from IN 19613 172 5 every every DT 19613 172 6 point point NN 19613 172 7 of of IN 19613 172 8 view view NN 19613 172 9 , , , 19613 172 10 is be VBZ 19613 172 11 the the DT 19613 172 12 result result NN 19613 172 13 of of IN 19613 172 14 the the DT 19613 172 15 blending blending NN 19613 172 16 of of IN 19613 172 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 172 18 with with IN 19613 172 19 the the DT 19613 172 20 ideas idea NNS 19613 172 21 of of IN 19613 172 22 antiquity,[12 antiquity,[12 CD 19613 172 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 172 24 so so CC 19613 172 25 the the DT 19613 172 26 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 172 27 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 172 28 , , , 19613 172 29 as as IN 19613 172 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 172 31 was be VBD 19613 172 32 developed develop VBN 19613 172 33 after after IN 19613 172 34 the the DT 19613 172 35 second second JJ 19613 172 36 or or CC 19613 172 37 third third JJ 19613 172 38 century century NN 19613 172 39 on on IN 19613 172 40 the the DT 19613 172 41 basis basis NN 19613 172 42 of of IN 19613 172 43 the the DT 19613 172 44 Logos Logos NNP 19613 172 45 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 172 46 , , , 19613 172 47 is be VBZ 19613 172 48 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 172 49 conceived conceive VBD 19613 172 50 and and CC 19613 172 51 formulated formulate VBN 19613 172 52 from from IN 19613 172 53 the the DT 19613 172 54 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 172 55 of of IN 19613 172 56 the the DT 19613 172 57 Greek greek JJ 19613 172 58 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 172 59 of of IN 19613 172 60 religion religion NN 19613 172 61 . . . 19613 173 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 173 2 13 13 CD 19613 173 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 173 4 This this DT 19613 173 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 173 6 conquered conquer VBD 19613 173 7 the the DT 19613 173 8 old old JJ 19613 173 9 world world NN 19613 173 10 , , , 19613 173 11 and and CC 19613 173 12 became become VBD 19613 173 13 the the DT 19613 173 14 foundation foundation NN 19613 173 15 of of IN 19613 173 16 a a DT 19613 173 17 new new JJ 19613 173 18 phase phase NN 19613 173 19 of of IN 19613 173 20 history history NN 19613 173 21 in in IN 19613 173 22 the the DT 19613 173 23 Middle Middle NNP 19613 173 24 Ages Ages NNPS 19613 173 25 . . . 19613 174 1 The the DT 19613 174 2 union union NN 19613 174 3 of of IN 19613 174 4 the the DT 19613 174 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 174 6 religion religion NN 19613 174 7 with with IN 19613 174 8 a a DT 19613 174 9 definite definite JJ 19613 174 10 historical historical JJ 19613 174 11 phase phase NN 19613 174 12 of of IN 19613 174 13 human human JJ 19613 174 14 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 174 15 and and CC 19613 174 16 culture culture NN 19613 174 17 may may MD 19613 174 18 be be VB 19613 174 19 lamented lament VBN 19613 174 20 in in IN 19613 174 21 the the DT 19613 174 22 interest interest NN 19613 174 23 of of IN 19613 174 24 the the DT 19613 174 25 Christian christian JJ 19613 174 26 religion religion NN 19613 174 27 , , , 19613 174 28 which which WDT 19613 174 29 was be VBD 19613 174 30 thereby thereby RB 19613 174 31 secularised secularise VBN 19613 174 32 , , , 19613 174 33 and and CC 19613 174 34 in in IN 19613 174 35 the the DT 19613 174 36 interest interest NN 19613 174 37 of of IN 19613 174 38 the the DT 19613 174 39 development development NN 19613 174 40 of of IN 19613 174 41 culture culture NN 19613 174 42 which which WDT 19613 174 43 was be VBD 19613 174 44 thereby thereby RB 19613 174 45 retarded retarded JJ 19613 174 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 174 47 ? ? . 19613 174 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 174 49 . . . 19613 175 1 But but CC 19613 175 2 lamentations lamentation NNS 19613 175 3 become become VBP 19613 175 4 here here RB 19613 175 5 ill ill RB 19613 175 6 - - HYPH 19613 175 7 founded found VBN 19613 175 8 assumptions assumption NNS 19613 175 9 , , , 19613 175 10 as as IN 19613 175 11 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 175 12 everything everything NN 19613 175 13 that that WDT 19613 175 14 we -PRON- PRP 19613 175 15 have have VBP 19613 175 16 and and CC 19613 175 17 value value NN 19613 175 18 is be VBZ 19613 175 19 due due JJ 19613 175 20 to to IN 19613 175 21 the the DT 19613 175 22 alliance alliance NN 19613 175 23 that that IN 19613 175 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 175 25 and and CC 19613 175 26 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 175 27 concluded conclude VBD 19613 175 28 in in IN 19613 175 29 such such PDT 19613 175 30 a a DT 19613 175 31 way way NN 19613 175 32 that that WDT 19613 175 33 neither neither DT 19613 175 34 was be VBD 19613 175 35 able able JJ 19613 175 36 to to TO 19613 175 37 prevail prevail VB 19613 175 38 over over IN 19613 175 39 the the DT 19613 175 40 other other JJ 19613 175 41 . . . 19613 176 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 176 2 inward inward JJ 19613 176 3 and and CC 19613 176 4 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 176 5 life life NN 19613 176 6 , , , 19613 176 7 which which WDT 19613 176 8 owes owe VBZ 19613 176 9 the the DT 19613 176 10 least least JJS 19613 176 11 part part NN 19613 176 12 of of IN 19613 176 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 176 14 content content NN 19613 176 15 to to IN 19613 176 16 the the DT 19613 176 17 empiric empiric JJ 19613 176 18 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 176 19 which which WDT 19613 176 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 176 21 have have VBP 19613 176 22 acquired acquire VBN 19613 176 23 , , , 19613 176 24 is be VBZ 19613 176 25 based base VBN 19613 176 26 up up RP 19613 176 27 to to IN 19613 176 28 the the DT 19613 176 29 present present JJ 19613 176 30 moment moment NN 19613 176 31 on on IN 19613 176 32 the the DT 19613 176 33 discords discord NNS 19613 176 34 resulting result VBG 19613 176 35 from from IN 19613 176 36 that that DT 19613 176 37 union union NN 19613 176 38 . . . 19613 177 1 These these DT 19613 177 2 hints hint NNS 19613 177 3 are be VBP 19613 177 4 meant mean VBN 19613 177 5 among among IN 19613 177 6 other other JJ 19613 177 7 things thing NNS 19613 177 8 to to TO 19613 177 9 explain explain VB 19613 177 10 and and CC 19613 177 11 justify[14 justify[14 NNP 19613 177 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 177 13 the the DT 19613 177 14 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 177 15 chosen choose VBN 19613 177 16 for for IN 19613 177 17 the the DT 19613 177 18 following follow VBG 19613 177 19 presentation presentation NN 19613 177 20 , , , 19613 177 21 which which WDT 19613 177 22 embraces embrace VBZ 19613 177 23 the the DT 19613 177 24 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 177 25 section section NN 19613 177 26 of of IN 19613 177 27 the the DT 19613 177 28 history history NN 19613 177 29 of of IN 19613 177 30 Christian christian JJ 19613 177 31 dogma dogma NN 19613 177 32 . . . 19613 178 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 178 2 15 15 CD 19613 178 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 178 4 A a DT 19613 178 5 few few JJ 19613 178 6 more more JJR 19613 178 7 remarks remark NNS 19613 178 8 are be VBP 19613 178 9 , , , 19613 178 10 however however RB 19613 178 11 , , , 19613 178 12 necessary necessary JJ 19613 178 13 . . . 19613 179 1 1 1 LS 19613 179 2 . . . 19613 180 1 One one CD 19613 180 2 special special JJ 19613 180 3 difficulty difficulty NN 19613 180 4 in in IN 19613 180 5 ascertaining ascertain VBG 19613 180 6 the the DT 19613 180 7 genesis genesis NN 19613 180 8 of of IN 19613 180 9 the the DT 19613 180 10 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 180 11 rules rule NNS 19613 180 12 is be VBZ 19613 180 13 that that IN 19613 180 14 the the DT 19613 180 15 churches church NNS 19613 180 16 , , , 19613 180 17 though though RB 19613 180 18 on on IN 19613 180 19 terms term NNS 19613 180 20 of of IN 19613 180 21 close close JJ 19613 180 22 connection connection NN 19613 180 23 and and CC 19613 180 24 mutual mutual JJ 19613 180 25 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 180 26 , , , 19613 180 27 had have VBD 19613 180 28 no no DT 19613 180 29 real real JJ 19613 180 30 _ _ NNP 19613 180 31 forum forum NN 19613 180 32 publicum publicum NN 19613 180 33 _ _ NNP 19613 180 34 , , , 19613 180 35 though though IN 19613 180 36 indeed indeed RB 19613 180 37 , , , 19613 180 38 in in IN 19613 180 39 a a DT 19613 180 40 certain certain JJ 19613 180 41 sense sense NN 19613 180 42 , , , 19613 180 43 each each DT 19613 180 44 bishop bishop NN 19613 180 45 was be VBD 19613 180 46 _ _ NNP 19613 180 47 in in IN 19613 180 48 foro foro NNP 19613 180 49 publico publico NNS 19613 180 50 _ _ NNP 19613 180 51 . . . 19613 181 1 As as IN 19613 181 2 a a DT 19613 181 3 rule rule NN 19613 181 4 , , , 19613 181 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 181 6 , , , 19613 181 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 181 8 can can MD 19613 181 9 only only RB 19613 181 10 see see VB 19613 181 11 the the DT 19613 181 12 advance advance NN 19613 181 13 in in IN 19613 181 14 the the DT 19613 181 15 establishment establishment NN 19613 181 16 of of IN 19613 181 17 fixed fix VBN 19613 181 18 forms form NNS 19613 181 19 in in IN 19613 181 20 the the DT 19613 181 21 shape shape NN 19613 181 22 of of IN 19613 181 23 results result NNS 19613 181 24 , , , 19613 181 25 without without IN 19613 181 26 being be VBG 19613 181 27 able able JJ 19613 181 28 to to TO 19613 181 29 state state VB 19613 181 30 precisely precisely RB 19613 181 31 the the DT 19613 181 32 ways way NNS 19613 181 33 and and CC 19613 181 34 means mean NNS 19613 181 35 which which WDT 19613 181 36 led lead VBD 19613 181 37 to to IN 19613 181 38 them -PRON- PRP 19613 181 39 . . . 19613 182 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 182 2 do do VBP 19613 182 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 182 4 know know VB 19613 182 5 the the DT 19613 182 6 factors factor NNS 19613 182 7 , , , 19613 182 8 and and CC 19613 182 9 can can MD 19613 182 10 therefore therefore RB 19613 182 11 theoretically theoretically RB 19613 182 12 construct construct VB 19613 182 13 the the DT 19613 182 14 development development NN 19613 182 15 ; ; : 19613 182 16 but but CC 19613 182 17 the the DT 19613 182 18 real real JJ 19613 182 19 course course NN 19613 182 20 of of IN 19613 182 21 things thing NNS 19613 182 22 is be VBZ 19613 182 23 frequently frequently RB 19613 182 24 hidden hide VBN 19613 182 25 from from IN 19613 182 26 us -PRON- PRP 19613 182 27 . . . 19613 183 1 The the DT 19613 183 2 genesis genesis NN 19613 183 3 of of IN 19613 183 4 a a DT 19613 183 5 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 183 6 Church Church NNP 19613 183 7 , , , 19613 183 8 firmly firmly RB 19613 183 9 welded weld VBD 19613 183 10 together together RB 19613 183 11 in in IN 19613 183 12 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 183 13 and and CC 19613 183 14 constitution constitution NN 19613 183 15 , , , 19613 183 16 can can MD 19613 183 17 no no RB 19613 183 18 more more RBR 19613 183 19 have have VB 19613 183 20 been be VBN 19613 183 21 the the DT 19613 183 22 natural natural JJ 19613 183 23 unpremeditated unpremeditated JJ 19613 183 24 product product NN 19613 183 25 of of IN 19613 183 26 the the DT 19613 183 27 conditions condition NNS 19613 183 28 of of IN 19613 183 29 the the DT 19613 183 30 time time NN 19613 183 31 than than IN 19613 183 32 were be VBD 19613 183 33 the the DT 19613 183 34 genesis genesis NN 19613 183 35 and and CC 19613 183 36 adoption adoption NN 19613 183 37 of of IN 19613 183 38 the the DT 19613 183 39 New New NNP 19613 183 40 Testament Testament NNP 19613 183 41 canon canon NN 19613 183 42 of of IN 19613 183 43 Scripture scripture NN 19613 183 44 . . . 19613 184 1 But but CC 19613 184 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 184 3 have have VBP 19613 184 4 no no DT 19613 184 5 direct direct JJ 19613 184 6 evidence evidence NN 19613 184 7 as as IN 19613 184 8 to to IN 19613 184 9 what what WP 19613 184 10 communities community NNS 19613 184 11 had have VBD 19613 184 12 a a DT 19613 184 13 special special JJ 19613 184 14 share share NN 19613 184 15 in in IN 19613 184 16 the the DT 19613 184 17 development development NN 19613 184 18 , , , 19613 184 19 although although IN 19613 184 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 184 21 know know VBP 19613 184 22 that that IN 19613 184 23 the the DT 19613 184 24 Roman Roman NNP 19613 184 25 Church Church NNP 19613 184 26 played play VBD 19613 184 27 a a DT 19613 184 28 leading leading JJ 19613 184 29 part part NN 19613 184 30 . . . 19613 185 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 185 2 , , , 19613 185 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 185 4 can can MD 19613 185 5 only only RB 19613 185 6 conjecture conjecture VB 19613 185 7 that that WDT 19613 185 8 conferences conference VBZ 19613 185 9 , , , 19613 185 10 common common JJ 19613 185 11 measures measure NNS 19613 185 12 , , , 19613 185 13 and and CC 19613 185 14 synodical synodical JJ 19613 185 15 decisions decision NNS 19613 185 16 were be VBD 19613 185 17 not not RB 19613 185 18 wanting want VBG 19613 185 19 . . . 19613 186 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 186 2 is be VBZ 19613 186 3 certain certain JJ 19613 186 4 that that IN 19613 186 5 , , , 19613 186 6 beginning begin VBG 19613 186 7 with with IN 19613 186 8 the the DT 19613 186 9 last last JJ 19613 186 10 quarter quarter NN 19613 186 11 of of IN 19613 186 12 the the DT 19613 186 13 second second JJ 19613 186 14 century century NN 19613 186 15 , , , 19613 186 16 there there EX 19613 186 17 were be VBD 19613 186 18 held hold VBN 19613 186 19 in in IN 19613 186 20 the the DT 19613 186 21 different different JJ 19613 186 22 provinces province NNS 19613 186 23 , , , 19613 186 24 mostly mostly RB 19613 186 25 in in IN 19613 186 26 the the DT 19613 186 27 East East NNP 19613 186 28 , , , 19613 186 29 but but CC 19613 186 30 later later RB 19613 186 31 also also RB 19613 186 32 in in IN 19613 186 33 the the DT 19613 186 34 West West NNP 19613 186 35 , , , 19613 186 36 Synods Synods NNPS 19613 186 37 in in IN 19613 186 38 which which WDT 19613 186 39 an an DT 19613 186 40 understanding understanding NN 19613 186 41 was be VBD 19613 186 42 arrived arrive VBN 19613 186 43 at at IN 19613 186 44 on on IN 19613 186 45 all all DT 19613 186 46 questions question NNS 19613 186 47 of of IN 19613 186 48 importance importance NN 19613 186 49 to to IN 19613 186 50 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 186 51 , , , 19613 186 52 including include VBG 19613 186 53 , , , 19613 186 54 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 186 55 , , , 19613 186 56 the the DT 19613 186 57 extent extent NN 19613 186 58 of of IN 19613 186 59 the the DT 19613 186 60 canon canon NN 19613 186 61 . . . 19613 187 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 187 2 16 16 CD 19613 187 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 187 4 2 2 CD 19613 187 5 . . . 19613 188 1 The the DT 19613 188 2 degree degree NN 19613 188 3 of of IN 19613 188 4 influence influence NN 19613 188 5 exercised exercise VBN 19613 188 6 by by IN 19613 188 7 particular particular JJ 19613 188 8 ecclesiastics ecclesiastic NNS 19613 188 9 on on IN 19613 188 10 the the DT 19613 188 11 development development NN 19613 188 12 of of IN 19613 188 13 the the DT 19613 188 14 Church Church NNP 19613 188 15 and and CC 19613 188 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 188 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 188 18 is be VBZ 19613 188 19 also also RB 19613 188 20 obscure obscure JJ 19613 188 21 and and CC 19613 188 22 difficult difficult JJ 19613 188 23 to to TO 19613 188 24 determine determine VB 19613 188 25 . . . 19613 189 1 As as IN 19613 189 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 189 3 were be VBD 19613 189 4 compelled compel VBN 19613 189 5 to to TO 19613 189 6 claim claim VB 19613 189 7 the the DT 19613 189 8 sanction sanction NN 19613 189 9 of of IN 19613 189 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 189 11 for for IN 19613 189 12 every every DT 19613 189 13 innovation innovation NN 19613 189 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 189 15 introduced introduce VBD 19613 189 16 , , , 19613 189 17 and and CC 19613 189 18 did do VBD 19613 189 19 in in IN 19613 189 20 fact fact NN 19613 189 21 do do VB 19613 189 22 so so RB 19613 189 23 , , , 19613 189 24 and and CC 19613 189 25 as as IN 19613 189 26 every every DT 19613 189 27 fresh fresh JJ 19613 189 28 step step NN 19613 189 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 189 30 took take VBD 19613 189 31 appeared appear VBN 19613 189 32 to to IN 19613 189 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 189 34 necessary necessary JJ 19613 189 35 only only RB 19613 189 36 as as IN 19613 189 37 an an DT 19613 189 38 explanation explanation NN 19613 189 39 , , , 19613 189 40 it -PRON- PRP 19613 189 41 is be VBZ 19613 189 42 in in IN 19613 189 43 many many JJ 19613 189 44 cases case NNS 19613 189 45 quite quite RB 19613 189 46 impossible impossible JJ 19613 189 47 to to TO 19613 189 48 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 189 49 between between IN 19613 189 50 what what WP 19613 189 51 they -PRON- PRP 19613 189 52 received receive VBD 19613 189 53 from from IN 19613 189 54 tradition tradition NN 19613 189 55 and and CC 19613 189 56 what what WP 19613 189 57 they -PRON- PRP 19613 189 58 added add VBD 19613 189 59 to to IN 19613 189 60 it -PRON- PRP 19613 189 61 of of IN 19613 189 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 189 63 own own JJ 19613 189 64 . . . 19613 190 1 Yet yet RB 19613 190 2 an an DT 19613 190 3 investigation investigation NN 19613 190 4 from from IN 19613 190 5 the the DT 19613 190 6 point point NN 19613 190 7 of of IN 19613 190 8 view view NN 19613 190 9 of of IN 19613 190 10 the the DT 19613 190 11 historian historian NN 19613 190 12 of of IN 19613 190 13 literature literature NN 19613 190 14 shows show VBZ 19613 190 15 that that IN 19613 190 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 190 17 and and CC 19613 190 18 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 190 19 were be VBD 19613 190 20 to to IN 19613 190 21 a a DT 19613 190 22 great great JJ 19613 190 23 extent extent NN 19613 190 24 dependent dependent JJ 19613 190 25 on on IN 19613 190 26 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 190 27 . . . 19613 191 1 What what WDT 19613 191 2 amount amount NN 19613 191 3 of of IN 19613 191 4 innovation innovation NN 19613 191 5 these these DT 19613 191 6 men man NNS 19613 191 7 independently independently RB 19613 191 8 contributed contribute VBD 19613 191 9 can can MD 19613 191 10 therefore therefore RB 19613 191 11 still still RB 19613 191 12 be be VB 19613 191 13 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 191 14 . . . 19613 192 1 Both both DT 19613 192 2 are be VBP 19613 192 3 men man NNS 19613 192 4 of of IN 19613 192 5 the the DT 19613 192 6 second second JJ 19613 192 7 generation generation NN 19613 192 8 . . . 19613 193 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 193 2 is be VBZ 19613 193 3 related relate VBN 19613 193 4 to to IN 19613 193 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 193 6 pretty pretty RB 19613 193 7 much much RB 19613 193 8 as as IN 19613 193 9 Calvin Calvin NNP 19613 193 10 to to IN 19613 193 11 Luther Luther NNP 19613 193 12 . . . 19613 194 1 This this DT 19613 194 2 parallel parallel NN 19613 194 3 holds hold VBZ 19613 194 4 good good JJ 19613 194 5 in in IN 19613 194 6 more more JJR 19613 194 7 than than IN 19613 194 8 one one CD 19613 194 9 respect respect NN 19613 194 10 . . . 19613 195 1 First first RB 19613 195 2 , , , 19613 195 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 195 4 drew draw VBD 19613 195 5 up up RP 19613 195 6 a a DT 19613 195 7 series series NN 19613 195 8 of of IN 19613 195 9 plain plain JJ 19613 195 10 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 195 11 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 195 12 which which WDT 19613 195 13 are be VBP 19613 195 14 not not RB 19613 195 15 found find VBN 19613 195 16 in in IN 19613 195 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 195 18 and and CC 19613 195 19 which which WDT 19613 195 20 proved prove VBD 19613 195 21 of of IN 19613 195 22 the the DT 19613 195 23 greatest great JJS 19613 195 24 importance importance NN 19613 195 25 in in IN 19613 195 26 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 195 27 times time NNS 19613 195 28 . . . 19613 196 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 196 2 , , , 19613 196 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 196 4 did do VBD 19613 196 5 not not RB 19613 196 6 attain attain VB 19613 196 7 the the DT 19613 196 8 power power NN 19613 196 9 , , , 19613 196 10 vividness vividness NN 19613 196 11 , , , 19613 196 12 and and CC 19613 196 13 unity unity NN 19613 196 14 of of IN 19613 196 15 religious religious JJ 19613 196 16 intuition intuition NN 19613 196 17 which which WDT 19613 196 18 distinguish distinguish VBP 19613 196 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 196 20 . . . 19613 197 1 The the DT 19613 197 2 truth truth NN 19613 197 3 rather rather RB 19613 197 4 is be VBZ 19613 197 5 that that DT 19613 197 6 , , , 19613 197 7 just just RB 19613 197 8 because because IN 19613 197 9 of of IN 19613 197 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 197 11 forms form NNS 19613 197 12 , , , 19613 197 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 197 14 partly partly RB 19613 197 15 destroyed destroy VBD 19613 197 16 the the DT 19613 197 17 unity unity NN 19613 197 18 of of IN 19613 197 19 the the DT 19613 197 20 matter matter NN 19613 197 21 and and CC 19613 197 22 partly partly RB 19613 197 23 led lead VBD 19613 197 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 197 25 into into IN 19613 197 26 a a DT 19613 197 27 false false JJ 19613 197 28 path path NN 19613 197 29 of of IN 19613 197 30 development development NN 19613 197 31 . . . 19613 198 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 198 2 , , , 19613 198 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 198 4 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 198 5 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 198 6 to to TO 19613 198 7 give give VB 19613 198 8 a a DT 19613 198 9 conception conception NN 19613 198 10 of of IN 19613 198 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 198 12 which which WDT 19613 198 13 represented represent VBD 19613 198 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 198 15 as as IN 19613 198 16 the the DT 19613 198 17 divine divine JJ 19613 198 18 law law NN 19613 198 19 , , , 19613 198 20 whereas whereas IN 19613 198 21 in in IN 19613 198 22 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 198 23 this this DT 19613 198 24 idea idea NN 19613 198 25 is be VBZ 19613 198 26 overshadowed overshadow VBN 19613 198 27 by by IN 19613 198 28 the the DT 19613 198 29 conception conception NN 19613 198 30 of of IN 19613 198 31 the the DT 19613 198 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 198 33 as as IN 19613 198 34 real real JJ 19613 198 35 redemption redemption NN 19613 198 36 . . . 19613 199 1 The the DT 19613 199 2 main main JJ 19613 199 3 problem problem NN 19613 199 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 199 5 resolves resolve VBZ 19613 199 6 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 199 7 into into IN 19613 199 8 the the DT 19613 199 9 question question NN 19613 199 10 as as IN 19613 199 11 to to IN 19613 199 12 the the DT 19613 199 13 position position NN 19613 199 14 of of IN 19613 199 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 199 16 in in IN 19613 199 17 the the DT 19613 199 18 history history NN 19613 199 19 of of IN 19613 199 20 the the DT 19613 199 21 Church Church NNP 19613 199 22 . . . 19613 200 1 To to IN 19613 200 2 what what WDT 19613 200 3 extent extent NN 19613 200 4 were be VBD 19613 200 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 200 6 expositions exposition NNS 19613 200 7 new new JJ 19613 200 8 , , , 19613 200 9 to to IN 19613 200 10 what what WDT 19613 200 11 extent extent NN 19613 200 12 were be VBD 19613 200 13 the the DT 19613 200 14 standards standard NNS 19613 200 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 200 16 formulated formulate VBD 19613 200 17 already already RB 19613 200 18 employed employ VBN 19613 200 19 in in IN 19613 200 20 the the DT 19613 200 21 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 200 22 , , , 19613 200 23 and and CC 19613 200 24 in in IN 19613 200 25 which which WDT 19613 200 26 of of IN 19613 200 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 200 28 ? ? . 19613 201 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 201 2 can can MD 19613 201 3 not not RB 19613 201 4 form form VB 19613 201 5 to to IN 19613 201 6 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 201 7 a a DT 19613 201 8 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 201 9 vivid vivid JJ 19613 201 10 picture picture NN 19613 201 11 of of IN 19613 201 12 the the DT 19613 201 13 interchange interchange NN 19613 201 14 of of IN 19613 201 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 201 16 writings writing NNS 19613 201 17 in in IN 19613 201 18 the the DT 19613 201 19 Church Church NNP 19613 201 20 after after IN 19613 201 21 the the DT 19613 201 22 last last JJ 19613 201 23 quarter quarter NN 19613 201 24 of of IN 19613 201 25 the the DT 19613 201 26 second second JJ 19613 201 27 century century NN 19613 201 28 . . . 19613 202 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 202 2 17 17 CD 19613 202 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 202 4 Every every DT 19613 202 5 important important JJ 19613 202 6 work work NN 19613 202 7 speedily speedily RB 19613 202 8 found find VBD 19613 202 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 202 10 way way NN 19613 202 11 into into IN 19613 202 12 the the DT 19613 202 13 churches church NNS 19613 202 14 of of IN 19613 202 15 the the DT 19613 202 16 chief chief JJ 19613 202 17 cities city NNS 19613 202 18 in in IN 19613 202 19 the the DT 19613 202 20 Empire Empire NNP 19613 202 21 . . . 19613 203 1 The the DT 19613 203 2 diffusion diffusion NN 19613 203 3 was be VBD 19613 203 4 not not RB 19613 203 5 merely merely RB 19613 203 6 from from IN 19613 203 7 East East NNP 19613 203 8 to to IN 19613 203 9 West West NNP 19613 203 10 , , , 19613 203 11 though though IN 19613 203 12 this this DT 19613 203 13 was be VBD 19613 203 14 the the DT 19613 203 15 general general JJ 19613 203 16 rule rule NN 19613 203 17 . . . 19613 204 1 At at IN 19613 204 2 the the DT 19613 204 3 beginning beginning NN 19613 204 4 of of IN 19613 204 5 the the DT 19613 204 6 fourth fourth JJ 19613 204 7 century century NN 19613 204 8 there there EX 19613 204 9 was be VBD 19613 204 10 in in IN 19613 204 11 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 19613 204 12 a a DT 19613 204 13 Greek greek JJ 19613 204 14 translation translation NN 19613 204 15 of of IN 19613 204 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 204 17 's 's POS 19613 204 18 Apology Apology NNP 19613 204 19 and and CC 19613 204 20 a a DT 19613 204 21 collection collection NN 19613 204 22 of of IN 19613 204 23 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 204 24 's 's POS 19613 204 25 epistles epistle NNS 19613 204 26 . . . 19613 205 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 205 2 18 18 CD 19613 205 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 205 4 The the DT 19613 205 5 influence influence NN 19613 205 6 of of IN 19613 205 7 the the DT 19613 205 8 Roman Roman NNP 19613 205 9 Church Church NNP 19613 205 10 extended extend VBD 19613 205 11 over over IN 19613 205 12 the the DT 19613 205 13 greater great JJR 19613 205 14 part part NN 19613 205 15 of of IN 19613 205 16 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 205 17 . . . 19613 206 1 Up up IN 19613 206 2 till till IN 19613 206 3 about about IN 19613 206 4 the the DT 19613 206 5 year year NN 19613 206 6 260 260 CD 19613 206 7 the the DT 19613 206 8 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 206 9 in in IN 19613 206 10 East East NNP 19613 206 11 and and CC 19613 206 12 West West NNP 19613 206 13 had have VBD 19613 206 14 still still RB 19613 206 15 in in IN 19613 206 16 some some DT 19613 206 17 degree degree NN 19613 206 18 a a DT 19613 206 19 common common JJ 19613 206 20 history history NN 19613 206 21 . . . 19613 207 1 3 3 LS 19613 207 2 . . . 19613 208 1 The the DT 19613 208 2 developments development NNS 19613 208 3 in in IN 19613 208 4 the the DT 19613 208 5 history history NN 19613 208 6 of of IN 19613 208 7 dogma dogma NN 19613 208 8 within within IN 19613 208 9 the the DT 19613 208 10 period period NN 19613 208 11 extending extend VBG 19613 208 12 from from IN 19613 208 13 about about RB 19613 208 14 150 150 CD 19613 208 15 to to TO 19613 208 16 about about IN 19613 208 17 300 300 CD 19613 208 18 were be VBD 19613 208 19 by by IN 19613 208 20 no no DT 19613 208 21 means means NN 19613 208 22 brought bring VBN 19613 208 23 about about RP 19613 208 24 in in IN 19613 208 25 the the DT 19613 208 26 different different JJ 19613 208 27 communities community NNS 19613 208 28 at at IN 19613 208 29 the the DT 19613 208 30 same same JJ 19613 208 31 time time NN 19613 208 32 and and CC 19613 208 33 in in IN 19613 208 34 a a DT 19613 208 35 completely completely RB 19613 208 36 analogous analogous JJ 19613 208 37 fashion fashion NN 19613 208 38 . . . 19613 209 1 This this DT 19613 209 2 fact fact NN 19613 209 3 is be VBZ 19613 209 4 in in IN 19613 209 5 great great JJ 19613 209 6 measure measure NN 19613 209 7 concealed conceal VBD 19613 209 8 from from IN 19613 209 9 us -PRON- PRP 19613 209 10 , , , 19613 209 11 because because IN 19613 209 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 209 13 authorities authority NNS 19613 209 14 are be VBP 19613 209 15 almost almost RB 19613 209 16 completely completely RB 19613 209 17 derived derive VBN 19613 209 18 from from IN 19613 209 19 those those DT 19613 209 20 leading lead VBG 19613 209 21 Churches church NNS 19613 209 22 that that WDT 19613 209 23 were be VBD 19613 209 24 connected connect VBN 19613 209 25 with with IN 19613 209 26 each each DT 19613 209 27 other other JJ 19613 209 28 by by IN 19613 209 29 constant constant JJ 19613 209 30 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 209 31 . . . 19613 210 1 Yet yet RB 19613 210 2 the the DT 19613 210 3 difference difference NN 19613 210 4 can can MD 19613 210 5 still still RB 19613 210 6 be be VB 19613 210 7 clearly clearly RB 19613 210 8 proved prove VBN 19613 210 9 by by IN 19613 210 10 the the DT 19613 210 11 ratio ratio NN 19613 210 12 of of IN 19613 210 13 development development NN 19613 210 14 in in IN 19613 210 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 210 16 , , , 19613 210 17 Lyons Lyons NNP 19613 210 18 , , , 19613 210 19 and and CC 19613 210 20 Carthage carthage NN 19613 210 21 on on IN 19613 210 22 the the DT 19613 210 23 one one CD 19613 210 24 hand hand NN 19613 210 25 , , , 19613 210 26 and and CC 19613 210 27 in in IN 19613 210 28 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 210 29 on on IN 19613 210 30 the the DT 19613 210 31 other other JJ 19613 210 32 . . . 19613 211 1 Besides besides RB 19613 211 2 , , , 19613 211 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 211 4 have have VBP 19613 211 5 several several JJ 19613 211 6 valuable valuable JJ 19613 211 7 accounts account NNS 19613 211 8 showing show VBG 19613 211 9 that that IN 19613 211 10 in in IN 19613 211 11 more more JJR 19613 211 12 remote remote JJ 19613 211 13 provinces province NNS 19613 211 14 and and CC 19613 211 15 communities community NNS 19613 211 16 the the DT 19613 211 17 development development NN 19613 211 18 was be VBD 19613 211 19 slower slow JJR 19613 211 20 , , , 19613 211 21 and and CC 19613 211 22 a a DT 19613 211 23 primitive primitive JJ 19613 211 24 and and CC 19613 211 25 freer free JJR 19613 211 26 condition condition NN 19613 211 27 of of IN 19613 211 28 things thing NNS 19613 211 29 much much RB 19613 211 30 longer long RBR 19613 211 31 preserved preserve VBN 19613 211 32 . . . 19613 212 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 212 2 19 19 CD 19613 212 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 212 4 4 4 CD 19613 212 5 . . . 19613 213 1 From from IN 19613 213 2 the the DT 19613 213 3 time time NN 19613 213 4 that that WDT 19613 213 5 the the DT 19613 213 6 clergy clergy NNP 19613 213 7 acquired acquire VBD 19613 213 8 complete complete JJ 19613 213 9 sway sway NN 19613 213 10 over over IN 19613 213 11 the the DT 19613 213 12 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 213 13 , , , 19613 213 14 that that RB 19613 213 15 is is RB 19613 213 16 , , , 19613 213 17 from from IN 19613 213 18 the the DT 19613 213 19 beginning beginning NN 19613 213 20 of of IN 19613 213 21 the the DT 19613 213 22 second second JJ 19613 213 23 third third NN 19613 213 24 of of IN 19613 213 25 the the DT 19613 213 26 third third JJ 19613 213 27 century century NN 19613 213 28 , , , 19613 213 29 the the DT 19613 213 30 development development NN 19613 213 31 of of IN 19613 213 32 the the DT 19613 213 33 history history NN 19613 213 34 of of IN 19613 213 35 dogma dogma NN 19613 213 36 practically practically RB 19613 213 37 took take VBD 19613 213 38 place place NN 19613 213 39 within within IN 19613 213 40 the the DT 19613 213 41 ranks rank NNS 19613 213 42 of of IN 19613 213 43 that that DT 19613 213 44 class class NN 19613 213 45 , , , 19613 213 46 and and CC 19613 213 47 was be VBD 19613 213 48 carried carry VBN 19613 213 49 on on RP 19613 213 50 by by IN 19613 213 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 213 52 learned learn VBN 19613 213 53 men man NNS 19613 213 54 . . . 19613 214 1 Every every DT 19613 214 2 mystery mystery NN 19613 214 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 214 4 set set VBD 19613 214 5 up up RP 19613 214 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 214 7 became become VBD 19613 214 8 doubly doubly RB 19613 214 9 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 214 10 to to IN 19613 214 11 the the DT 19613 214 12 laity laity NN 19613 214 13 , , , 19613 214 14 for for IN 19613 214 15 these these DT 19613 214 16 did do VBD 19613 214 17 not not RB 19613 214 18 even even RB 19613 214 19 understand understand VB 19613 214 20 the the DT 19613 214 21 terms term NNS 19613 214 22 , , , 19613 214 23 and and CC 19613 214 24 hence hence RB 19613 214 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 214 26 formed form VBD 19613 214 27 another another DT 19613 214 28 new new JJ 19613 214 29 fetter fetter NN 19613 214 30 . . . 19613 215 1 Footnotes footnote NNS 19613 215 2 : : : 19613 215 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 215 4 Footnote footnote NN 19613 215 5 1 1 CD 19613 215 6 : : : 19613 215 7 Aubé aubé NN 19613 215 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 215 9 Histoire Histoire NNP 19613 215 10 des des FW 19613 215 11 Persécutions Persécutions NNP 19613 215 12 de de IN 19613 215 13 l'Eglise l'Eglise NNP 19613 215 14 , , , 19613 215 15 Vol Vol NNP 19613 215 16 . . . 19613 216 1 II ii CD 19613 216 2 . . . 19613 217 1 1878 1878 CD 19613 217 2 , , , 19613 217 3 pp pp NNP 19613 217 4 . . . 19613 218 1 1 1 CD 19613 218 2 - - SYM 19613 218 3 68 68 CD 19613 218 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 218 5 has have VBZ 19613 218 6 given give VBN 19613 218 7 a a DT 19613 218 8 survey survey NN 19613 218 9 of of IN 19613 218 10 the the DT 19613 218 11 genesis genesis NN 19613 218 12 of of IN 19613 218 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 218 14 dogma dogma NN 19613 218 15 . . . 19613 219 1 The the DT 19613 219 2 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 219 3 of of IN 19613 219 4 Renan Renan NNP 19613 219 5 in in IN 19613 219 6 the the DT 19613 219 7 last last JJ 19613 219 8 volumes volume NNS 19613 219 9 of of IN 19613 219 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 219 11 great great JJ 19613 219 12 historical historical JJ 19613 219 13 work work NN 19613 219 14 are be VBP 19613 219 15 excellent excellent JJ 19613 219 16 , , , 19613 219 17 though though IN 19613 219 18 not not RB 19613 219 19 seldom seldom RB 19613 219 20 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 19613 219 21 in in IN 19613 219 22 particular particular JJ 19613 219 23 points point NNS 19613 219 24 . . . 19613 220 1 See see VB 19613 220 2 especially especially RB 19613 220 3 the the DT 19613 220 4 concluding conclude VBG 19613 220 5 observations observation NNS 19613 220 6 in in IN 19613 220 7 Vol Vol NNP 19613 220 8 . . . 19613 221 1 VII VII NNP 19613 221 2 . . . 19613 222 1 cc cc NNP 19613 222 2 . . . 19613 223 1 28 28 CD 19613 223 2 - - SYM 19613 223 3 34 34 CD 19613 223 4 . . . 19613 224 1 Since since IN 19613 224 2 the the DT 19613 224 3 appearance appearance NN 19613 224 4 of of IN 19613 224 5 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 224 6 's 's POS 19613 224 7 monograph monograph NN 19613 224 8 on on IN 19613 224 9 the the DT 19613 224 10 genesis genesis NN 19613 224 11 of of IN 19613 224 12 the the DT 19613 224 13 old old JJ 19613 224 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 224 15 Church Church NNP 19613 224 16 , , , 19613 224 17 a a DT 19613 224 18 treatise treatise NN 19613 224 19 which which WDT 19613 224 20 , , , 19613 224 21 however however RB 19613 224 22 , , , 19613 224 23 forms form NNS 19613 224 24 too too RB 19613 224 25 narrow narrow JJ 19613 224 26 a a DT 19613 224 27 conception conception NN 19613 224 28 of of IN 19613 224 29 the the DT 19613 224 30 problem problem NN 19613 224 31 , , , 19613 224 32 German german JJ 19613 224 33 science science NN 19613 224 34 can can MD 19613 224 35 point point VB 19613 224 36 to to IN 19613 224 37 no no DT 19613 224 38 work work NN 19613 224 39 of of IN 19613 224 40 equal equal JJ 19613 224 41 rank rank NN 19613 224 42 with with IN 19613 224 43 the the DT 19613 224 44 French French NNP 19613 224 45 . . . 19613 225 1 Cf cf NN 19613 225 2 . . . 19613 226 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 226 2 's 's POS 19613 226 3 Kirchenrecht Kirchenrecht NNP 19613 226 4 , , , 19613 226 5 Vol Vol NNP 19613 226 6 . . . 19613 227 1 I. I. NNP 19613 227 2 which which WDT 19613 227 3 , , , 19613 227 4 however however RB 19613 227 5 , , , 19613 227 6 in in IN 19613 227 7 a a DT 19613 227 8 very very RB 19613 227 9 one one CD 19613 227 10 - - HYPH 19613 227 11 sided sided JJ 19613 227 12 manner manner NN 19613 227 13 , , , 19613 227 14 makes make VBZ 19613 227 15 the the DT 19613 227 16 adoption adoption NN 19613 227 17 of of IN 19613 227 18 the the DT 19613 227 19 legal legal JJ 19613 227 20 and and CC 19613 227 21 constitutional constitutional JJ 19613 227 22 arrangements arrangement NNS 19613 227 23 responsible responsible JJ 19613 227 24 for for IN 19613 227 25 all all PDT 19613 227 26 the the DT 19613 227 27 evil evil NN 19613 227 28 in in IN 19613 227 29 the the DT 19613 227 30 Church Church NNP 19613 227 31 . . . 19613 227 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 228 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 228 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 228 3 2 2 CD 19613 228 4 : : : 19613 228 5 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 228 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 228 7 p. p. NN 19613 228 8 160 160 CD 19613 228 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 228 10 declares declare VBZ 19613 228 11 : : : 19613 228 12 " " `` 19613 228 13 The the DT 19613 228 14 foundation foundation NN 19613 228 15 of of IN 19613 228 16 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 228 17 is be VBZ 19613 228 18 the the DT 19613 228 19 divine divine JJ 19613 228 20 Church Church NNP 19613 228 21 law law NN 19613 228 22 to to IN 19613 228 23 which which WDT 19613 228 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 228 25 lays lay VBZ 19613 228 26 claim claim NN 19613 228 27 . . . 19613 228 28 " " '' 19613 229 1 In in IN 19613 229 2 many many JJ 19613 229 3 other other JJ 19613 229 4 passages passage NNS 19613 229 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 229 6 even even RB 19613 229 7 seems seem VBZ 19613 229 8 to to TO 19613 229 9 express express VB 19613 229 10 the the DT 19613 229 11 opinion opinion NN 19613 229 12 that that IN 19613 229 13 the the DT 19613 229 14 Church Church NNP 19613 229 15 law law NN 19613 229 16 of of IN 19613 229 17 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 229 18 , , , 19613 229 19 even even RB 19613 229 20 when when WRB 19613 229 21 not not RB 19613 229 22 represented represent VBN 19613 229 23 as as IN 19613 229 24 divine divine JJ 19613 229 25 , , , 19613 229 26 is be VBZ 19613 229 27 the the DT 19613 229 28 hereditary hereditary JJ 19613 229 29 enemy enemy NN 19613 229 30 of of IN 19613 229 31 the the DT 19613 229 32 true true JJ 19613 229 33 Church Church NNP 19613 229 34 and and CC 19613 229 35 at at IN 19613 229 36 the the DT 19613 229 37 same same JJ 19613 229 38 time time NN 19613 229 39 denotes denote VBZ 19613 229 40 the the DT 19613 229 41 essence essence NN 19613 229 42 of of IN 19613 229 43 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 229 44 . . . 19613 230 1 See see VB 19613 230 2 , , , 19613 230 3 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 230 4 , , , 19613 230 5 p. p. NN 19613 230 6 2 2 CD 19613 230 7 : : : 19613 230 8 " " `` 19613 230 9 The the DT 19613 230 10 whole whole JJ 19613 230 11 essence essence NN 19613 230 12 of of IN 19613 230 13 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 230 14 consists consist VBZ 19613 230 15 in in IN 19613 230 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 230 17 declaring declare VBG 19613 230 18 legal legal JJ 19613 230 19 institutions institution NNS 19613 230 20 to to TO 19613 230 21 be be VB 19613 230 22 necessary necessary JJ 19613 230 23 to to IN 19613 230 24 the the DT 19613 230 25 Church Church NNP 19613 230 26 . . . 19613 230 27 " " '' 19613 231 1 Page page NN 19613 231 2 700 700 CD 19613 231 3 : : : 19613 231 4 " " `` 19613 231 5 The the DT 19613 231 6 essence essence NN 19613 231 7 of of IN 19613 231 8 Church Church NNP 19613 231 9 law law NN 19613 231 10 is be VBZ 19613 231 11 incompatible incompatible JJ 19613 231 12 with with IN 19613 231 13 the the DT 19613 231 14 essence essence NN 19613 231 15 of of IN 19613 231 16 the the DT 19613 231 17 Church Church NNP 19613 231 18 . . . 19613 231 19 " " '' 19613 232 1 This this DT 19613 232 2 thesis thesis NN 19613 232 3 really really RB 19613 232 4 characterises characterise VBZ 19613 232 5 Catholicism catholicism NN 19613 232 6 well well RB 19613 232 7 and and CC 19613 232 8 contains contain VBZ 19613 232 9 a a DT 19613 232 10 great great JJ 19613 232 11 truth truth NN 19613 232 12 , , , 19613 232 13 if if IN 19613 232 14 expressed express VBN 19613 232 15 in in IN 19613 232 16 more more RBR 19613 232 17 careful careful JJ 19613 232 18 terms term NNS 19613 232 19 , , , 19613 232 20 somewhat somewhat RB 19613 232 21 as as IN 19613 232 22 follows follow VBZ 19613 232 23 : : : 19613 232 24 " " `` 19613 232 25 The the DT 19613 232 26 assertion assertion NN 19613 232 27 that that IN 19613 232 28 there there EX 19613 232 29 is be VBZ 19613 232 30 a a DT 19613 232 31 divine divine JJ 19613 232 32 Church Church NNP 19613 232 33 law law NN 19613 232 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 232 35 emanating emanate VBG 19613 232 36 from from IN 19613 232 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 232 38 , , , 19613 232 39 or or CC 19613 232 40 , , , 19613 232 41 in in IN 19613 232 42 other other JJ 19613 232 43 words word NNS 19613 232 44 , , , 19613 232 45 from from IN 19613 232 46 the the DT 19613 232 47 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 232 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 232 49 , , , 19613 232 50 which which WDT 19613 232 51 is be VBZ 19613 232 52 necessary necessary JJ 19613 232 53 to to IN 19613 232 54 the the DT 19613 232 55 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 232 56 character character NN 19613 232 57 of of IN 19613 232 58 the the DT 19613 232 59 Church Church NNP 19613 232 60 and and CC 19613 232 61 which which WDT 19613 232 62 in in IN 19613 232 63 fact fact NN 19613 232 64 is be VBZ 19613 232 65 a a DT 19613 232 66 token token NN 19613 232 67 of of IN 19613 232 68 this this DT 19613 232 69 very very JJ 19613 232 70 attribute attribute NN 19613 232 71 , , , 19613 232 72 is be VBZ 19613 232 73 incompatible incompatible JJ 19613 232 74 with with IN 19613 232 75 the the DT 19613 232 76 essence essence NN 19613 232 77 of of IN 19613 232 78 the the DT 19613 232 79 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 232 80 and and CC 19613 232 81 is be VBZ 19613 232 82 the the DT 19613 232 83 mark mark NN 19613 232 84 of of IN 19613 232 85 a a DT 19613 232 86 pseudo pseudo NN 19613 232 87 - - NNP 19613 232 88 Catholicism catholicism NN 19613 232 89 . . . 19613 232 90 " " '' 19613 233 1 But but CC 19613 233 2 the the DT 19613 233 3 thesis thesis NN 19613 233 4 contains contain VBZ 19613 233 5 too too RB 19613 233 6 narrow narrow JJ 19613 233 7 a a DT 19613 233 8 view view NN 19613 233 9 of of IN 19613 233 10 the the DT 19613 233 11 case case NN 19613 233 12 . . . 19613 234 1 For for IN 19613 234 2 the the DT 19613 234 3 divine divine JJ 19613 234 4 Church Church NNP 19613 234 5 law law NN 19613 234 6 is be VBZ 19613 234 7 only only RB 19613 234 8 one one CD 19613 234 9 feature feature NN 19613 234 10 of of IN 19613 234 11 the the DT 19613 234 12 essence essence NN 19613 234 13 of of IN 19613 234 14 the the DT 19613 234 15 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 234 16 Church Church NNP 19613 234 17 , , , 19613 234 18 though though IN 19613 234 19 a a DT 19613 234 20 very very RB 19613 234 21 important important JJ 19613 234 22 element element NN 19613 234 23 , , , 19613 234 24 which which WDT 19613 234 25 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 234 26 , , , 19613 234 27 as as IN 19613 234 28 a a DT 19613 234 29 jurist jurist NN 19613 234 30 , , , 19613 234 31 was be VBD 19613 234 32 peculiarly peculiarly RB 19613 234 33 capable capable JJ 19613 234 34 of of IN 19613 234 35 recognising recognise VBG 19613 234 36 . . . 19613 235 1 The the DT 19613 235 2 whole whole JJ 19613 235 3 essence essence NN 19613 235 4 of of IN 19613 235 5 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 235 6 , , , 19613 235 7 however however RB 19613 235 8 , , , 19613 235 9 consists consist VBZ 19613 235 10 in in IN 19613 235 11 the the DT 19613 235 12 deification deification NN 19613 235 13 of of IN 19613 235 14 tradition tradition NN 19613 235 15 generally generally RB 19613 235 16 . . . 19613 236 1 The the DT 19613 236 2 declaration declaration NN 19613 236 3 that that IN 19613 236 4 the the DT 19613 236 5 empirical empirical JJ 19613 236 6 institutions institution NNS 19613 236 7 of of IN 19613 236 8 the the DT 19613 236 9 Church Church NNP 19613 236 10 , , , 19613 236 11 created create VBN 19613 236 12 for for IN 19613 236 13 and and CC 19613 236 14 necessary necessary JJ 19613 236 15 to to IN 19613 236 16 this this DT 19613 236 17 purpose purpose NN 19613 236 18 , , , 19613 236 19 are be VBP 19613 236 20 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 236 21 , , , 19613 236 22 a a DT 19613 236 23 declaration declaration NN 19613 236 24 which which WDT 19613 236 25 amalgamates amalgamate VBZ 19613 236 26 them -PRON- PRP 19613 236 27 with with IN 19613 236 28 the the DT 19613 236 29 essence essence NN 19613 236 30 and and CC 19613 236 31 content content NN 19613 236 32 of of IN 19613 236 33 the the DT 19613 236 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 236 35 and and CC 19613 236 36 places place VBZ 19613 236 37 them -PRON- PRP 19613 236 38 beyond beyond IN 19613 236 39 all all DT 19613 236 40 criticism criticism NN 19613 236 41 , , , 19613 236 42 is be VBZ 19613 236 43 the the DT 19613 236 44 peculiarly peculiarly JJ 19613 236 45 " " `` 19613 236 46 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 236 47 " " '' 19613 236 48 feature feature NN 19613 236 49 . . . 19613 237 1 Now now RB 19613 237 2 , , , 19613 237 3 as as IN 19613 237 4 a a DT 19613 237 5 great great JJ 19613 237 6 part part NN 19613 237 7 of of IN 19613 237 8 these these DT 19613 237 9 institutions institution NNS 19613 237 10 can can MD 19613 237 11 not not RB 19613 237 12 be be VB 19613 237 13 inwardly inwardly RB 19613 237 14 appropriated appropriate VBN 19613 237 15 and and CC 19613 237 16 can can MD 19613 237 17 not not RB 19613 237 18 really really RB 19613 237 19 amalgamate amalgamate VB 19613 237 20 with with IN 19613 237 21 faith faith NN 19613 237 22 and and CC 19613 237 23 piety piety NN 19613 237 24 , , , 19613 237 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 237 26 is be VBZ 19613 237 27 self self NN 19613 237 28 - - HYPH 19613 237 29 evident evident JJ 19613 237 30 that that IN 19613 237 31 such such JJ 19613 237 32 portions portion NNS 19613 237 33 become become VBP 19613 237 34 continued continued JJ 19613 237 35 : : : 19613 237 36 legal legal JJ 19613 237 37 ordinances ordinance NNS 19613 237 38 , , , 19613 237 39 to to TO 19613 237 40 which which WDT 19613 237 41 obedience obedience NN 19613 237 42 must must MD 19613 237 43 be be VB 19613 237 44 rendered render VBN 19613 237 45 . . . 19613 238 1 For for IN 19613 238 2 no no DT 19613 238 3 other other JJ 19613 238 4 relation relation NN 19613 238 5 to to IN 19613 238 6 these these DT 19613 238 7 ordinances ordinance NNS 19613 238 8 can can MD 19613 238 9 be be VB 19613 238 10 conceived conceive VBN 19613 238 11 . . . 19613 239 1 Hence hence RB 19613 239 2 the the DT 19613 239 3 legal legal JJ 19613 239 4 regulations regulation NNS 19613 239 5 and and CC 19613 239 6 the the DT 19613 239 7 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 239 8 slavish slavish JJ 19613 239 9 devotion devotion NN 19613 239 10 come come VBP 19613 239 11 to to TO 19613 239 12 have have VB 19613 239 13 such such JJ 19613 239 14 immense immense JJ 19613 239 15 scope scope NN 19613 239 16 in in IN 19613 239 17 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 239 18 , , , 19613 239 19 and and CC 19613 239 20 well well RB 19613 239 21 - - HYPH 19613 239 22 nigh nigh NN 19613 239 23 express express VB 19613 239 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 239 25 essence essence NN 19613 239 26 . . . 19613 240 1 But but CC 19613 240 2 behind behind IN 19613 240 3 this this DT 19613 240 4 is be VBZ 19613 240 5 found find VBN 19613 240 6 the the DT 19613 240 7 more more RBR 19613 240 8 general general JJ 19613 240 9 conviction conviction NN 19613 240 10 that that IN 19613 240 11 the the DT 19613 240 12 empirical empirical JJ 19613 240 13 Church Church NNP 19613 240 14 , , , 19613 240 15 as as IN 19613 240 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 240 17 actually actually RB 19613 240 18 exists exist VBZ 19613 240 19 , , , 19613 240 20 is be VBZ 19613 240 21 the the DT 19613 240 22 authentic authentic JJ 19613 240 23 , , , 19613 240 24 pure pure JJ 19613 240 25 , , , 19613 240 26 and and CC 19613 240 27 infallible infallible JJ 19613 240 28 creation creation NN 19613 240 29 : : : 19613 240 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 240 31 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 240 32 , , , 19613 240 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 240 34 regulations regulation NNS 19613 240 35 , , , 19613 240 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 240 37 religious religious JJ 19613 240 38 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 240 39 are be VBP 19613 240 40 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 240 41 . . . 19613 241 1 Whoever whoever WP 19613 241 2 doubts doubt VBZ 19613 241 3 that that IN 19613 241 4 renounces renounce VBZ 19613 241 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 241 6 . . . 19613 242 1 Now now RB 19613 242 2 , , , 19613 242 3 if if IN 19613 242 4 , , , 19613 242 5 as as IN 19613 242 6 in in IN 19613 242 7 the the DT 19613 242 8 case case NN 19613 242 9 of of IN 19613 242 10 the the DT 19613 242 11 Reformers Reformers NNPS 19613 242 12 , , , 19613 242 13 this this DT 19613 242 14 conception conception NN 19613 242 15 be be VB 19613 242 16 recognised recognise VBN 19613 242 17 as as IN 19613 242 18 erroneous erroneous JJ 19613 242 19 and and CC 19613 242 20 unevangelical unevangelical JJ 19613 242 21 , , , 19613 242 22 the the DT 19613 242 23 result result NN 19613 242 24 must must MD 19613 242 25 certainly certainly RB 19613 242 26 be be VB 19613 242 27 a a DT 19613 242 28 strong strong JJ 19613 242 29 detestation detestation NN 19613 242 30 of of IN 19613 242 31 " " `` 19613 242 32 the the DT 19613 242 33 divine divine JJ 19613 242 34 Church Church NNP 19613 242 35 law law NN 19613 242 36 . . . 19613 242 37 " " '' 19613 243 1 Indeed indeed RB 19613 243 2 , , , 19613 243 3 the the DT 19613 243 4 inclination inclination NN 19613 243 5 to to TO 19613 243 6 sweep sweep VB 19613 243 7 away away RP 19613 243 8 all all DT 19613 243 9 Church Church NNP 19613 243 10 law law NN 19613 243 11 is be VBZ 19613 243 12 quite quite RB 19613 243 13 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 243 14 , , , 19613 243 15 for for IN 19613 243 16 when when WRB 19613 243 17 you -PRON- PRP 19613 243 18 give give VBP 19613 243 19 the the DT 19613 243 20 devil devil NN 19613 243 21 your -PRON- PRP$ 19613 243 22 little little JJ 19613 243 23 finger finger NN 19613 243 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 243 25 takes take VBZ 19613 243 26 the the DT 19613 243 27 whole whole JJ 19613 243 28 hand hand NN 19613 243 29 . . . 19613 244 1 But but CC 19613 244 2 , , , 19613 244 3 on on IN 19613 244 4 the the DT 19613 244 5 other other JJ 19613 244 6 hand hand NN 19613 244 7 , , , 19613 244 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 244 9 can can MD 19613 244 10 not not RB 19613 244 11 be be VB 19613 244 12 imagined imagine VBN 19613 244 13 how how WRB 19613 244 14 communities community NNS 19613 244 15 are be VBP 19613 244 16 to to TO 19613 244 17 exist exist VB 19613 244 18 on on IN 19613 244 19 earth earth NN 19613 244 20 , , , 19613 244 21 propagate propagate VB 19613 244 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 244 23 , , , 19613 244 24 and and CC 19613 244 25 train train NN 19613 244 26 men man NNS 19613 244 27 without without IN 19613 244 28 regulations regulation NNS 19613 244 29 ; ; : 19613 244 30 and and CC 19613 244 31 how how WRB 19613 244 32 regulations regulation NNS 19613 244 33 are be VBP 19613 244 34 to to TO 19613 244 35 exist exist VB 19613 244 36 without without IN 19613 244 37 resulting result VBG 19613 244 38 in in IN 19613 244 39 the the DT 19613 244 40 formation formation NN 19613 244 41 of of IN 19613 244 42 a a DT 19613 244 43 code code NN 19613 244 44 of of IN 19613 244 45 laws law NNS 19613 244 46 . . . 19613 245 1 In in IN 19613 245 2 truth truth NN 19613 245 3 , , , 19613 245 4 such such JJ 19613 245 5 regulations regulation NNS 19613 245 6 have have VBP 19613 245 7 at at IN 19613 245 8 no no DT 19613 245 9 time time NN 19613 245 10 been be VBN 19613 245 11 wanting want VBG 19613 245 12 in in IN 19613 245 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 245 14 communities community NNS 19613 245 15 , , , 19613 245 16 and and CC 19613 245 17 have have VBP 19613 245 18 always always RB 19613 245 19 possessed possess VBN 19613 245 20 the the DT 19613 245 21 character character NN 19613 245 22 of of IN 19613 245 23 a a DT 19613 245 24 legal legal JJ 19613 245 25 code code NN 19613 245 26 . . . 19613 246 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 246 2 's 's POS 19613 246 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 246 4 , , , 19613 246 5 that that IN 19613 246 6 in in IN 19613 246 7 the the DT 19613 246 8 oldest old JJS 19613 246 9 period period NN 19613 246 10 there there EX 19613 246 11 was be VBD 19613 246 12 no no DT 19613 246 13 " " `` 19613 246 14 law law NN 19613 246 15 , , , 19613 246 16 " " '' 19613 246 17 but but CC 19613 246 18 only only RB 19613 246 19 a a DT 19613 246 20 " " `` 19613 246 21 regulation regulation NN 19613 246 22 , , , 19613 246 23 " " '' 19613 246 24 is be VBZ 19613 246 25 artificial artificial JJ 19613 246 26 , , , 19613 246 27 though though IN 19613 246 28 possessed possess VBN 19613 246 29 of of IN 19613 246 30 a a DT 19613 246 31 certain certain JJ 19613 246 32 degree degree NN 19613 246 33 of of IN 19613 246 34 truth truth NN 19613 246 35 ; ; : 19613 246 36 for for IN 19613 246 37 the the DT 19613 246 38 regulation regulation NN 19613 246 39 has have VBZ 19613 246 40 one one CD 19613 246 41 aspect aspect NN 19613 246 42 in in IN 19613 246 43 a a DT 19613 246 44 circle circle NN 19613 246 45 of of IN 19613 246 46 like like JJ 19613 246 47 - - HYPH 19613 246 48 minded minded JJ 19613 246 49 enthusiasts enthusiast NNS 19613 246 50 , , , 19613 246 51 and and CC 19613 246 52 a a DT 19613 246 53 different different JJ 19613 246 54 one one CD 19613 246 55 in in IN 19613 246 56 a a DT 19613 246 57 community community NN 19613 246 58 where where WRB 19613 246 59 all all DT 19613 246 60 stages stage NNS 19613 246 61 of of IN 19613 246 62 moral moral JJ 19613 246 63 and and CC 19613 246 64 religious religious JJ 19613 246 65 culture culture NN 19613 246 66 are be VBP 19613 246 67 represented represent VBN 19613 246 68 , , , 19613 246 69 and and CC 19613 246 70 which which WDT 19613 246 71 has have VBZ 19613 246 72 therefore therefore RB 19613 246 73 to to TO 19613 246 74 train train VB 19613 246 75 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 246 76 members member NNS 19613 246 77 . . . 19613 247 1 Or or CC 19613 247 2 should should MD 19613 247 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 247 4 not not RB 19613 247 5 do do VB 19613 247 6 so so RB 19613 247 7 ? ? . 19613 248 1 And and CC 19613 248 2 , , , 19613 248 3 on on IN 19613 248 4 the the DT 19613 248 5 other other JJ 19613 248 6 hand hand NN 19613 248 7 , , , 19613 248 8 had have VBD 19613 248 9 the the DT 19613 248 10 oldest old JJS 19613 248 11 Churches church NNS 19613 248 12 not not RB 19613 248 13 the the DT 19613 248 14 Old Old NNP 19613 248 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 248 16 and and CC 19613 248 17 the the DT 19613 248 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 248 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 248 20 : : : 19613 248 21 diataxeis diataxeis NNP 19613 248 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 248 23 of of IN 19613 248 24 the the DT 19613 248 25 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 248 26 ? ? . 19613 249 1 Were be VBD 19613 249 2 these these DT 19613 249 3 no no DT 19613 249 4 code code NN 19613 249 5 of of IN 19613 249 6 laws law NNS 19613 249 7 ? ? . 19613 250 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 250 2 's 's POS 19613 250 3 proposition proposition NN 19613 250 4 : : : 19613 250 5 " " `` 19613 250 6 The the DT 19613 250 7 essence essence NN 19613 250 8 of of IN 19613 250 9 Church Church NNP 19613 250 10 law law NN 19613 250 11 is be VBZ 19613 250 12 incompatible incompatible JJ 19613 250 13 with with IN 19613 250 14 the the DT 19613 250 15 essence essence NN 19613 250 16 of of IN 19613 250 17 the the DT 19613 250 18 Church Church NNP 19613 250 19 , , , 19613 250 20 " " '' 19613 250 21 does do VBZ 19613 250 22 not not RB 19613 250 23 rise rise VB 19613 250 24 to to IN 19613 250 25 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 250 26 clearness clearness NN 19613 250 27 and and CC 19613 250 28 freedom freedom NN 19613 250 29 , , , 19613 250 30 but but CC 19613 250 31 has have VBZ 19613 250 32 been be VBN 19613 250 33 formed form VBN 19613 250 34 under under IN 19613 250 35 the the DT 19613 250 36 shadow shadow NN 19613 250 37 and and CC 19613 250 38 ban ban NN 19613 250 39 of of IN 19613 250 40 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 250 41 . . . 19613 251 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 251 2 am be VBP 19613 251 3 inclined inclined JJ 19613 251 4 to to TO 19613 251 5 call call VB 19613 251 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 251 7 an an DT 19613 251 8 Anabaptist anabaptist JJ 19613 251 9 thesis thesis NN 19613 251 10 . . . 19613 252 1 The the DT 19613 252 2 Anabaptists Anabaptists NNPS 19613 252 3 were be VBD 19613 252 4 also also RB 19613 252 5 in in IN 19613 252 6 the the DT 19613 252 7 shadow shadow NN 19613 252 8 and and CC 19613 252 9 ban ban NN 19613 252 10 of of IN 19613 252 11 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 252 12 ; ; : 19613 252 13 hence hence RB 19613 252 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 252 15 only only JJ 19613 252 16 course course NN 19613 252 17 was be VBD 19613 252 18 either either CC 19613 252 19 the the DT 19613 252 20 attempt attempt NN 19613 252 21 to to TO 19613 252 22 wreck wreck VB 19613 252 23 the the DT 19613 252 24 Church Church NNP 19613 252 25 and and CC 19613 252 26 Church Church NNP 19613 252 27 history history NN 19613 252 28 and and CC 19613 252 29 found find VBD 19613 252 30 a a DT 19613 252 31 new new JJ 19613 252 32 empire empire NN 19613 252 33 , , , 19613 252 34 or or CC 19613 252 35 a a DT 19613 252 36 return return NN 19613 252 37 to to IN 19613 252 38 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 252 39 . . . 19613 253 1 Hermann Hermann NNP 19613 253 2 Bockelson Bockelson NNP 19613 253 3 or or CC 19613 253 4 the the DT 19613 253 5 Pope Pope NNP 19613 253 6 ! ! . 19613 254 1 But but CC 19613 254 2 the the DT 19613 254 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 254 4 is be VBZ 19613 254 5 above above IN 19613 254 6 the the DT 19613 254 7 question question NN 19613 254 8 of of IN 19613 254 9 Jew Jew NNP 19613 254 10 or or CC 19613 254 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 254 12 , , , 19613 254 13 and and CC 19613 254 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 254 15 also also RB 19613 254 16 above above IN 19613 254 17 the the DT 19613 254 18 question question NN 19613 254 19 of of IN 19613 254 20 a a DT 19613 254 21 legal legal JJ 19613 254 22 code code NN 19613 254 23 . . . 19613 255 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 255 2 is be VBZ 19613 255 3 reconcilable reconcilable JJ 19613 255 4 with with IN 19613 255 5 everything everything NN 19613 255 6 that that WDT 19613 255 7 is be VBZ 19613 255 8 not not RB 19613 255 9 sin sin NN 19613 255 10 , , , 19613 255 11 even even RB 19613 255 12 with with IN 19613 255 13 the the DT 19613 255 14 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 255 15 of of IN 19613 255 16 the the DT 19613 255 17 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 255 18 . . . 19613 256 1 Why why WRB 19613 256 2 should should MD 19613 256 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 256 4 not not RB 19613 256 5 be be VB 19613 256 6 also also RB 19613 256 7 compatible compatible JJ 19613 256 8 with with IN 19613 256 9 the the DT 19613 256 10 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 256 11 bishop bishop NN 19613 256 12 , , , 19613 256 13 with with IN 19613 256 14 the the DT 19613 256 15 legal legal JJ 19613 256 16 code code NN 19613 256 17 of of IN 19613 256 18 the the DT 19613 256 19 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 256 20 , , , 19613 256 21 and and CC 19613 256 22 even even RB 19613 256 23 with with IN 19613 256 24 the the DT 19613 256 25 Pope Pope NNP 19613 256 26 , , , 19613 256 27 provided provide VBN 19613 256 28 these these DT 19613 256 29 are be VBP 19613 256 30 not not RB 19613 256 31 made make VBN 19613 256 32 part part NN 19613 256 33 of of IN 19613 256 34 the the DT 19613 256 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 256 36 . . . 19613 256 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 257 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 257 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 257 3 3 3 CD 19613 257 4 : : : 19613 257 5 In in IN 19613 257 6 the the DT 19613 257 7 formation formation NN 19613 257 8 of of IN 19613 257 9 the the DT 19613 257 10 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 257 11 Church Church NNP 19613 257 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 257 13 have have VBP 19613 257 14 , , , 19613 257 15 on on IN 19613 257 16 the the DT 19613 257 17 other other JJ 19613 257 18 hand hand NN 19613 257 19 , , , 19613 257 20 the the DT 19613 257 21 attempt attempt NN 19613 257 22 to to TO 19613 257 23 create create VB 19613 257 24 a a DT 19613 257 25 rigid rigid JJ 19613 257 26 oecumenical oecumenical JJ 19613 257 27 community community NN 19613 257 28 , , , 19613 257 29 held hold VBN 19613 257 30 together together RB 19613 257 31 solely solely RB 19613 257 32 by by IN 19613 257 33 religion religion NN 19613 257 34 . . . 19613 258 1 The the DT 19613 258 2 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 258 3 Church Church NNP 19613 258 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 258 5 had have VBD 19613 258 6 a a DT 19613 258 7 founder founder NN 19613 258 8 , , , 19613 258 9 the the DT 19613 258 10 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 258 11 has have VBZ 19613 258 12 none none NN 19613 258 13 . . . 19613 258 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 259 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 259 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 259 3 4 4 CD 19613 259 4 : : : 19613 259 5 The the DT 19613 259 6 historian historian NN 19613 259 7 who who WP 19613 259 8 wishes wish VBZ 19613 259 9 to to TO 19613 259 10 determine determine VB 19613 259 11 the the DT 19613 259 12 advance advance NN 19613 259 13 made make VBN 19613 259 14 by by IN 19613 259 15 Græco Græco NNP 19613 259 16 - - HYPH 19613 259 17 Roman roman JJ 19613 259 18 humanity humanity NN 19613 259 19 in in IN 19613 259 20 the the DT 19613 259 21 third third JJ 19613 259 22 and and CC 19613 259 23 fourth fourth JJ 19613 259 24 centuries century NNS 19613 259 25 , , , 19613 259 26 under under IN 19613 259 27 the the DT 19613 259 28 influence influence NN 19613 259 29 of of IN 19613 259 30 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 259 31 and and CC 19613 259 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 259 33 theology theology NN 19613 259 34 , , , 19613 259 35 must must MD 19613 259 36 above above RB 19613 259 37 all all DT 19613 259 38 keep keep VB 19613 259 39 in in IN 19613 259 40 view view NN 19613 259 41 the the DT 19613 259 42 fact fact NN 19613 259 43 that that IN 19613 259 44 gross gross JJ 19613 259 45 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 259 46 and and CC 19613 259 47 immoral immoral JJ 19613 259 48 mythology mythology NN 19613 259 49 were be VBD 19613 259 50 swept sweep VBN 19613 259 51 away away RB 19613 259 52 , , , 19613 259 53 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 259 54 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 259 55 brought bring VBN 19613 259 56 near near RB 19613 259 57 to to IN 19613 259 58 all all DT 19613 259 59 , , , 19613 259 60 and and CC 19613 259 61 the the DT 19613 259 62 ideal ideal NN 19613 259 63 of of IN 19613 259 64 a a DT 19613 259 65 divine divine JJ 19613 259 66 life life NN 19613 259 67 and and CC 19613 259 68 the the DT 19613 259 69 hope hope NN 19613 259 70 of of IN 19613 259 71 an an DT 19613 259 72 eternal eternal JJ 19613 259 73 one one CD 19613 259 74 made make VBD 19613 259 75 certain certain JJ 19613 259 76 . . . 19613 260 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 19613 260 2 also also RB 19613 260 3 aimed aim VBD 19613 260 4 at at IN 19613 260 5 that that DT 19613 260 6 , , , 19613 260 7 but but CC 19613 260 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 260 9 was be VBD 19613 260 10 not not RB 19613 260 11 able able JJ 19613 260 12 to to TO 19613 260 13 establish establish VB 19613 260 14 a a DT 19613 260 15 community community NN 19613 260 16 of of IN 19613 260 17 men man NNS 19613 260 18 on on IN 19613 260 19 these these DT 19613 260 20 foundations foundation NNS 19613 260 21 . . . 19613 260 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 261 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 261 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 261 3 5 5 CD 19613 261 4 : : : 19613 261 5 Luther Luther NNP 19613 261 6 , , , 19613 261 7 as as IN 19613 261 8 is be VBZ 19613 261 9 well well RB 19613 261 10 known know VBN 19613 261 11 , , , 19613 261 12 had have VBD 19613 261 13 a a DT 19613 261 14 very very RB 19613 261 15 profound profound JJ 19613 261 16 impression impression NN 19613 261 17 of of IN 19613 261 18 the the DT 19613 261 19 distinction distinction NN 19613 261 20 between between IN 19613 261 21 Biblical Biblical NNP 19613 261 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 261 23 and and CC 19613 261 24 the the DT 19613 261 25 theology theology NN 19613 261 26 of of IN 19613 261 27 the the DT 19613 261 28 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 261 29 , , , 19613 261 30 who who WP 19613 261 31 followed follow VBD 19613 261 32 the the DT 19613 261 33 theories theory NNS 19613 261 34 of of IN 19613 261 35 Origen Origen NNP 19613 261 36 . . . 19613 262 1 See see VB 19613 262 2 , , , 19613 262 3 for for IN 19613 262 4 example example NN 19613 262 5 , , , 19613 262 6 Werke Werke NNP 19613 262 7 , , , 19613 262 8 Vol Vol NNP 19613 262 9 . . . 19613 263 1 LXII lxii RB 19613 263 2 . . . 19613 264 1 p. p. NN 19613 264 2 49 49 CD 19613 264 3 , , , 19613 264 4 quoting quote VBG 19613 264 5 Proles Proles NNP 19613 264 6 : : : 19613 264 7 " " `` 19613 264 8 When when WRB 19613 264 9 the the DT 19613 264 10 word word NN 19613 264 11 of of IN 19613 264 12 God God NNP 19613 264 13 comes come VBZ 19613 264 14 to to IN 19613 264 15 the the DT 19613 264 16 Fathers father NNS 19613 264 17 , , , 19613 264 18 me -PRON- PRP 19613 264 19 thinks think VBZ 19613 264 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 264 21 is be VBZ 19613 264 22 as as IN 19613 264 23 if if IN 19613 264 24 milk milk NN 19613 264 25 were be VBD 19613 264 26 filtered filter VBN 19613 264 27 through through IN 19613 264 28 a a DT 19613 264 29 coal coal NN 19613 264 30 sack sack NN 19613 264 31 , , , 19613 264 32 where where WRB 19613 264 33 the the DT 19613 264 34 milk milk NN 19613 264 35 must must MD 19613 264 36 become become VB 19613 264 37 black black JJ 19613 264 38 and and CC 19613 264 39 spoiled spoiled JJ 19613 264 40 . . . 19613 264 41 " " '' 19613 264 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 265 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 265 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 265 3 6 6 CD 19613 265 4 : : : 19613 265 5 They -PRON- PRP 19613 265 6 were be VBD 19613 265 7 not not RB 19613 265 8 the the DT 19613 265 9 first first JJ 19613 265 10 to to TO 19613 265 11 determine determine VB 19613 265 12 this this DT 19613 265 13 circle circle NN 19613 265 14 of of IN 19613 265 15 interests interest NNS 19613 265 16 . . . 19613 266 1 So so RB 19613 266 2 far far RB 19613 266 3 as as IN 19613 266 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 266 5 can can MD 19613 266 6 demonstrate demonstrate VB 19613 266 7 traces trace NNS 19613 266 8 of of IN 19613 266 9 independent independent JJ 19613 266 10 religious religious JJ 19613 266 11 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 266 12 among among IN 19613 266 13 the the DT 19613 266 14 so so RB 19613 266 15 - - HYPH 19613 266 16 called call VBN 19613 266 17 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 266 18 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 266 19 of of IN 19613 266 20 the the DT 19613 266 21 post post JJ 19613 266 22 - - JJ 19613 266 23 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 266 24 age age NN 19613 266 25 , , , 19613 266 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 266 27 are be VBP 19613 266 28 in in IN 19613 266 29 thorough thorough JJ 19613 266 30 harmony harmony NN 19613 266 31 with with IN 19613 266 32 the the DT 19613 266 33 theories theory NNS 19613 266 34 of of IN 19613 266 35 the the DT 19613 266 36 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 266 37 , , , 19613 266 38 which which WDT 19613 266 39 are be VBP 19613 266 40 merely merely RB 19613 266 41 expressed express VBN 19613 266 42 with with IN 19613 266 43 precision precision NN 19613 266 44 and and CC 19613 266 45 divested divested JJ 19613 266 46 of of IN 19613 266 47 Old Old NNP 19613 266 48 Testament Testament NNP 19613 266 49 language language NN 19613 266 50 . . . 19613 266 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 267 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 267 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 267 3 7 7 CD 19613 267 4 : : : 19613 267 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 267 6 was be VBD 19613 267 7 only only RB 19613 267 8 after after IN 19613 267 9 the the DT 19613 267 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 267 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 267 12 , , , 19613 267 13 fixed fix VBN 19613 267 14 in in IN 19613 267 15 the the DT 19613 267 16 form form NN 19613 267 17 of of IN 19613 267 18 a a DT 19613 267 19 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 267 20 collection collection NN 19613 267 21 , , , 19613 267 22 seemed seem VBD 19613 267 23 to to TO 19613 267 24 guarantee guarantee VB 19613 267 25 the the DT 19613 267 26 admissibility admissibility NN 19613 267 27 of of IN 19613 267 28 every every DT 19613 267 29 form form NN 19613 267 30 of of IN 19613 267 31 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 267 32 that that WDT 19613 267 33 reverenced reverence VBD 19613 267 34 that that DT 19613 267 35 collection collection NN 19613 267 36 , , , 19613 267 37 that that IN 19613 267 38 the the DT 19613 267 39 hellenising hellenising NN 19613 267 40 of of IN 19613 267 41 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 267 42 within within IN 19613 267 43 the the DT 19613 267 44 Church Church NNP 19613 267 45 began begin VBD 19613 267 46 in in IN 19613 267 47 serious serious JJ 19613 267 48 fashion fashion NN 19613 267 49 . . . 19613 268 1 The the DT 19613 268 2 fixing fixing NN 19613 268 3 of of IN 19613 268 4 tradition tradition NN 19613 268 5 had have VBD 19613 268 6 had have VBN 19613 268 7 a a DT 19613 268 8 twofold twofold JJ 19613 268 9 result result NN 19613 268 10 . . . 19613 269 1 On on IN 19613 269 2 the the DT 19613 269 3 one one CD 19613 269 4 hand hand NN 19613 269 5 , , , 19613 269 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 269 7 opened open VBD 19613 269 8 the the DT 19613 269 9 way way NN 19613 269 10 more more RBR 19613 269 11 than than IN 19613 269 12 ever ever RB 19613 269 13 before before RB 19613 269 14 for for IN 19613 269 15 a a DT 19613 269 16 free free JJ 19613 269 17 and and CC 19613 269 18 unhesitating unhesitating JJ 19613 269 19 introduction introduction NN 19613 269 20 of of IN 19613 269 21 foreign foreign JJ 19613 269 22 ideas idea NNS 19613 269 23 into into IN 19613 269 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 269 25 , , , 19613 269 26 and and CC 19613 269 27 , , , 19613 269 28 on on IN 19613 269 29 the the DT 19613 269 30 other other JJ 19613 269 31 hand hand NN 19613 269 32 , , , 19613 269 33 so so RB 19613 269 34 far far RB 19613 269 35 as as IN 19613 269 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 269 37 really really RB 19613 269 38 also also RB 19613 269 39 included include VBD 19613 269 40 the the DT 19613 269 41 documents document NNS 19613 269 42 and and CC 19613 269 43 convictions conviction NNS 19613 269 44 of of IN 19613 269 45 primitive primitive JJ 19613 269 46 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 269 47 , , , 19613 269 48 it -PRON- PRP 19613 269 49 preserved preserve VBD 19613 269 50 this this DT 19613 269 51 religion religion NN 19613 269 52 to to IN 19613 269 53 the the DT 19613 269 54 future future NN 19613 269 55 and and CC 19613 269 56 led lead VBD 19613 269 57 to to IN 19613 269 58 a a DT 19613 269 59 return return NN 19613 269 60 to to IN 19613 269 61 it -PRON- PRP 19613 269 62 , , , 19613 269 63 either either CC 19613 269 64 from from IN 19613 269 65 scientific scientific JJ 19613 269 66 or or CC 19613 269 67 religious religious JJ 19613 269 68 considerations consideration NNS 19613 269 69 . . . 19613 270 1 That that IN 19613 270 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 270 3 know know VBP 19613 270 4 anything anything NN 19613 270 5 at at RB 19613 270 6 all all DT 19613 270 7 of of IN 19613 270 8 original original JJ 19613 270 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 270 10 is be VBZ 19613 270 11 entirely entirely RB 19613 270 12 due due IN 19613 270 13 to to IN 19613 270 14 the the DT 19613 270 15 fixing fixing NN 19613 270 16 of of IN 19613 270 17 the the DT 19613 270 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 270 19 , , , 19613 270 20 as as IN 19613 270 21 found find VBN 19613 270 22 at at IN 19613 270 23 the the DT 19613 270 24 basis basis NN 19613 270 25 of of IN 19613 270 26 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 270 27 . . . 19613 271 1 On on IN 19613 271 2 the the DT 19613 271 3 supposition supposition NN 19613 271 4 -- -- : 19613 271 5 which which WDT 19613 271 6 is be VBZ 19613 271 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 271 8 an an DT 19613 271 9 academic academic JJ 19613 271 10 consideration consideration NN 19613 271 11 -- -- : 19613 271 12 that that IN 19613 271 13 this this DT 19613 271 14 fixing fixing NN 19613 271 15 had have VBD 19613 271 16 not not RB 19613 271 17 taken take VBN 19613 271 18 place place NN 19613 271 19 because because IN 19613 271 20 of of IN 19613 271 21 the the DT 19613 271 22 non non JJ 19613 271 23 - - JJ 19613 271 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 271 25 of of IN 19613 271 26 the the DT 19613 271 27 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 271 28 which which WDT 19613 271 29 occasioned occasion VBD 19613 271 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 271 31 , , , 19613 271 32 and and CC 19613 271 33 on on IN 19613 271 34 the the DT 19613 271 35 further further JJ 19613 271 36 supposition supposition NN 19613 271 37 that that IN 19613 271 38 the the DT 19613 271 39 original original JJ 19613 271 40 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 271 41 had have VBD 19613 271 42 continued continue VBN 19613 271 43 , , , 19613 271 44 we -PRON- PRP 19613 271 45 would would MD 19613 271 46 in in IN 19613 271 47 all all DT 19613 271 48 probability probability NN 19613 271 49 know know VBP 19613 271 50 next next RB 19613 271 51 to to IN 19613 271 52 nothing nothing NN 19613 271 53 of of IN 19613 271 54 original original JJ 19613 271 55 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 271 56 today today NN 19613 271 57 . . . 19613 272 1 How how WRB 19613 272 2 much much JJ 19613 272 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 272 4 would would MD 19613 272 5 have have VB 19613 272 6 known know VBN 19613 272 7 may may MD 19613 272 8 be be VB 19613 272 9 seen see VBN 19613 272 10 from from IN 19613 272 11 the the DT 19613 272 12 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 272 13 of of IN 19613 272 14 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 272 15 . . . 19613 272 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 273 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 273 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 273 3 8 8 CD 19613 273 4 : : : 19613 273 5 So so RB 19613 273 6 far far RB 19613 273 7 as as IN 19613 273 8 the the DT 19613 273 9 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 273 10 Church Church NNP 19613 273 11 is be VBZ 19613 273 12 concerned concern VBN 19613 273 13 , , , 19613 273 14 the the DT 19613 273 15 idea idea NN 19613 273 16 of of IN 19613 273 17 dogmas dogmas NNP 19613 273 18 , , , 19613 273 19 as as IN 19613 273 20 individual individual JJ 19613 273 21 theorems theorem NNS 19613 273 22 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 273 23 of of IN 19613 273 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 273 25 , , , 19613 273 26 and and CC 19613 273 27 capable capable JJ 19613 273 28 of of IN 19613 273 29 being be VBG 19613 273 30 scholastically scholastically RB 19613 273 31 proved prove VBN 19613 273 32 , , , 19613 273 33 originated originate VBN 19613 273 34 with with IN 19613 273 35 the the DT 19613 273 36 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 273 37 . . . 19613 274 1 Even even RB 19613 274 2 as as RB 19613 274 3 early early RB 19613 274 4 as as IN 19613 274 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 274 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 274 7 find find VBP 19613 274 8 tendencies tendency NNS 19613 274 9 to to TO 19613 274 10 amalgamate amalgamate VB 19613 274 11 historical historical JJ 19613 274 12 material material NN 19613 274 13 and and CC 19613 274 14 natural natural JJ 19613 274 15 theology theology NN 19613 274 16 . . . 19613 274 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 275 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 275 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 275 3 9 9 CD 19613 275 4 : : : 19613 275 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 275 6 is be VBZ 19613 275 7 almost almost RB 19613 275 8 completely completely RB 19613 275 9 wanting want VBG 19613 275 10 in in IN 19613 275 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 275 12 . . . 19613 276 1 That that DT 19613 276 2 is be VBZ 19613 276 3 explained explain VBN 19613 276 4 by by IN 19613 276 5 the the DT 19613 276 6 fact fact NN 19613 276 7 that that IN 19613 276 8 this this DT 19613 276 9 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 276 10 man man NN 19613 276 11 was be VBD 19613 276 12 in in IN 19613 276 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 276 14 inmost inmost JJ 19613 276 15 soul soul NN 19613 276 16 an an DT 19613 276 17 old old JJ 19613 276 18 - - HYPH 19613 276 19 fashioned fashioned JJ 19613 276 20 Christian Christian NNP 19613 276 21 , , , 19613 276 22 to to TO 19613 276 23 whom whom WP 19613 276 24 the the DT 19613 276 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 276 26 was be VBD 19613 276 27 _ _ NNP 19613 276 28 conscientia conscientia NN 19613 276 29 religionis religionis NNP 19613 276 30 , , , 19613 276 31 disciplina disciplina NNP 19613 276 32 vitæ vitæ NNP 19613 276 33 _ _ NNP 19613 276 34 and and CC 19613 276 35 _ _ NNP 19613 276 36 spes spe NNS 19613 276 37 fidei fidei NNP 19613 276 38 _ _ NNP 19613 276 39 , , , 19613 276 40 and and CC 19613 276 41 who who WP 19613 276 42 found find VBD 19613 276 43 no no DT 19613 276 44 sort sort NN 19613 276 45 of of IN 19613 276 46 edification edification NN 19613 276 47 in in IN 19613 276 48 Neoplatonic Neoplatonic NNP 19613 276 49 notions notion NNS 19613 276 50 , , , 19613 276 51 but but CC 19613 276 52 rather rather RB 19613 276 53 dwelt dwelt VB 19613 276 54 on on IN 19613 276 55 the the DT 19613 276 56 ideas idea NNS 19613 276 57 " " `` 19613 276 58 command command NN 19613 276 59 , , , 19613 276 60 " " '' 19613 276 61 " " `` 19613 276 62 performance performance NN 19613 276 63 , , , 19613 276 64 " " '' 19613 276 65 " " `` 19613 276 66 error error NN 19613 276 67 , , , 19613 276 68 " " '' 19613 276 69 " " `` 19613 276 70 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 276 71 . . . 19613 276 72 " " '' 19613 277 1 In in IN 19613 277 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 277 3 also also RB 19613 277 4 , , , 19613 277 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 277 6 , , , 19613 277 7 the the DT 19613 277 8 ancient ancient JJ 19613 277 9 idea idea NN 19613 277 10 of of IN 19613 277 11 salvation salvation NN 19613 277 12 , , , 19613 277 13 supplemented supplement VBN 19613 277 14 by by IN 19613 277 15 elements element NNS 19613 277 16 derived derive VBN 19613 277 17 from from IN 19613 277 18 the the DT 19613 277 19 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 277 20 theology theology NN 19613 277 21 , , , 19613 277 22 is be VBZ 19613 277 23 united united JJ 19613 277 24 with with IN 19613 277 25 the the DT 19613 277 26 primitive primitive JJ 19613 277 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 277 28 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 277 29 . . . 19613 277 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 278 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 278 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 278 3 10 10 CD 19613 278 4 : : : 19613 278 5 On on IN 19613 278 6 the the DT 19613 278 7 significance significance NN 19613 278 8 of of IN 19613 278 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 278 10 and and CC 19613 278 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 278 12 see see VB 19613 278 13 Overbeck overbeck NN 19613 278 14 , , , 19613 278 15 " " '' 19613 278 16 Über Über NNP 19613 278 17 die die VBP 19613 278 18 Anfänge Anfänge NNP 19613 278 19 der der NN 19613 278 20 patristischen patristischen NNP 19613 278 21 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 278 22 " " '' 19613 278 23 in in IN 19613 278 24 d. d. NNP 19613 278 25 Hist Hist NNP 19613 278 26 . . . 19613 279 1 Ztschr Ztschr NNP 19613 279 2 , , , 19613 279 3 N. N. NNP 19613 279 4 F. F. NNP 19613 279 5 , , , 19613 279 6 Vol Vol NNP 19613 279 7 , , , 19613 279 8 XII XII NNP 19613 279 9 . . . 19613 280 1 p. p. NN 19613 280 2 417 417 CD 19613 280 3 ff ff NNS 19613 280 4 . . . 19613 280 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 281 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 281 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 281 3 11 11 CD 19613 281 4 : : : 19613 281 5 Information information NN 19613 281 6 on on IN 19613 281 7 this this DT 19613 281 8 point point NN 19613 281 9 may may MD 19613 281 10 be be VB 19613 281 11 got get VBN 19613 281 12 not not RB 19613 281 13 only only RB 19613 281 14 from from IN 19613 281 15 the the DT 19613 281 16 writings writing NNS 19613 281 17 of of IN 19613 281 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 281 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 281 20 see see VB 19613 281 21 especially especially RB 19613 281 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 281 23 work work NN 19613 281 24 against against IN 19613 281 25 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 281 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 281 27 , , , 19613 281 28 but but CC 19613 281 29 also also RB 19613 281 30 and and CC 19613 281 31 above above IN 19613 281 32 all all DT 19613 281 33 from from IN 19613 281 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 281 35 history history NN 19613 281 36 . . . 19613 282 1 The the DT 19613 282 2 controversy controversy NN 19613 282 3 between between IN 19613 282 4 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 282 5 of of IN 19613 282 6 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 282 7 and and CC 19613 282 8 the the DT 19613 282 9 Chiliasts Chiliasts NNPS 19613 282 10 is be VBZ 19613 282 11 also also RB 19613 282 12 instructive instructive JJ 19613 282 13 on on IN 19613 282 14 the the DT 19613 282 15 matter matter NN 19613 282 16 . . . 19613 282 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 283 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 283 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 283 3 12 12 CD 19613 283 4 : : : 19613 283 5 The the DT 19613 283 6 three three CD 19613 283 7 or or CC 19613 283 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 283 9 reckoning reckon VBG 19613 283 10 Methodius Methodius NNP 19613 283 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 283 12 four four CD 19613 283 13 steps step NNS 19613 283 14 of of IN 19613 283 15 the the DT 19613 283 16 development development NN 19613 283 17 of of IN 19613 283 18 church church NN 19613 283 19 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 283 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 283 21 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 283 22 , , , 19613 283 23 Old Old NNP 19613 283 24 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 283 25 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 283 26 , , , 19613 283 27 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 283 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 283 29 correspond correspond VBP 19613 283 30 to to IN 19613 283 31 the the DT 19613 283 32 progressive progressive JJ 19613 283 33 religious religious JJ 19613 283 34 and and CC 19613 283 35 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 283 36 development development NN 19613 283 37 of of IN 19613 283 38 heathendom heathendom NN 19613 283 39 at at IN 19613 283 40 that that DT 19613 283 41 period period NN 19613 283 42 : : : 19613 283 43 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 283 44 moralism moralism NN 19613 283 45 , , , 19613 283 46 ideas idea NNS 19613 283 47 of of IN 19613 283 48 salvation salvation NN 19613 283 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 283 50 theology theology NN 19613 283 51 and and CC 19613 283 52 practice practice NN 19613 283 53 of of IN 19613 283 54 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 283 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 283 56 , , , 19613 283 57 Neoplatonic neoplatonic JJ 19613 283 58 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 283 59 , , , 19613 283 60 and and CC 19613 283 61 complete complete JJ 19613 283 62 syncretism syncretism NN 19613 283 63 . . . 19613 283 64 ] ] -RRB- 19613 284 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 284 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 284 3 13 13 CD 19613 284 4 : : : 19613 284 5 " " `` 19613 284 6 Virtus Virtus NNP 19613 284 7 omnis omnis NNP 19613 284 8 ex ex VBP 19613 284 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 284 10 causam causam NNP 19613 284 11 accipit accipit NNP 19613 284 12 , , , 19613 284 13 a a DT 19613 284 14 quibus quibus NNP 19613 284 15 provocatur provocatur NNP 19613 284 16 " " '' 19613 284 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 284 18 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 284 19 . . NNP 19613 284 20 , , , 19613 284 21 de de NNP 19613 284 22 bapt bapt NNP 19613 284 23 . . . 19613 285 1 2 2 LS 19613 285 2 . . . 19613 285 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 285 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 286 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 286 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 286 3 14 14 CD 19613 286 4 : : : 19613 286 5 The the DT 19613 286 6 plan plan NN 19613 286 7 of of IN 19613 286 8 placing place VBG 19613 286 9 the the DT 19613 286 10 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 286 11 theology theology NN 19613 286 12 before before IN 19613 286 13 everything everything NN 19613 286 14 else else RB 19613 286 15 would would MD 19613 286 16 have have VB 19613 286 17 much much JJ 19613 286 18 to to TO 19613 286 19 recommend recommend VB 19613 286 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 286 21 , , , 19613 286 22 but but CC 19613 286 23 I -PRON- PRP 19613 286 24 adhere adhere VBP 19613 286 25 to to IN 19613 286 26 the the DT 19613 286 27 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 286 28 here here RB 19613 286 29 chosen choose VBN 19613 286 30 , , , 19613 286 31 because because IN 19613 286 32 the the DT 19613 286 33 advantage advantage NN 19613 286 34 of of IN 19613 286 35 being be VBG 19613 286 36 able able JJ 19613 286 37 to to TO 19613 286 38 represent represent VB 19613 286 39 and and CC 19613 286 40 survey survey VB 19613 286 41 the the DT 19613 286 42 outer outer JJ 19613 286 43 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 286 44 development development NN 19613 286 45 and and CC 19613 286 46 the the DT 19613 286 47 inner inner JJ 19613 286 48 theological theological JJ 19613 286 49 one one CD 19613 286 50 , , , 19613 286 51 each each DT 19613 286 52 being be VBG 19613 286 53 viewed view VBN 19613 286 54 as as IN 19613 286 55 a a DT 19613 286 56 unity unity NN 19613 286 57 , , , 19613 286 58 seems seem VBZ 19613 286 59 to to IN 19613 286 60 me -PRON- PRP 19613 286 61 to to TO 19613 286 62 be be VB 19613 286 63 very very RB 19613 286 64 great great JJ 19613 286 65 . . . 19613 287 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 287 2 must must MD 19613 287 3 then then RB 19613 287 4 of of RB 19613 287 5 course course NN 19613 287 6 understand understand VB 19613 287 7 the the DT 19613 287 8 two two CD 19613 287 9 developments development NNS 19613 287 10 as as IN 19613 287 11 proceeding proceed VBG 19613 287 12 on on IN 19613 287 13 parallel parallel JJ 19613 287 14 lines line NNS 19613 287 15 . . . 19613 288 1 But but CC 19613 288 2 the the DT 19613 288 3 placing placing NN 19613 288 4 of of IN 19613 288 5 the the DT 19613 288 6 former former JJ 19613 288 7 parallel parallel NN 19613 288 8 before before IN 19613 288 9 the the DT 19613 288 10 latter latter JJ 19613 288 11 in in IN 19613 288 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 288 13 presentation presentation NN 19613 288 14 is be VBZ 19613 288 15 justified justify VBN 19613 288 16 by by IN 19613 288 17 the the DT 19613 288 18 fact fact NN 19613 288 19 that that IN 19613 288 20 what what WP 19613 288 21 was be VBD 19613 288 22 gained gain VBN 19613 288 23 in in IN 19613 288 24 the the DT 19613 288 25 former former JJ 19613 288 26 passed pass VBN 19613 288 27 over over RP 19613 288 28 much much RB 19613 288 29 more more RBR 19613 288 30 directly directly RB 19613 288 31 and and CC 19613 288 32 swiftly swiftly RB 19613 288 33 into into IN 19613 288 34 the the DT 19613 288 35 general general JJ 19613 288 36 life life NN 19613 288 37 of of IN 19613 288 38 the the DT 19613 288 39 Church Church NNP 19613 288 40 , , , 19613 288 41 than than IN 19613 288 42 what what WP 19613 288 43 was be VBD 19613 288 44 reached reach VBN 19613 288 45 in in IN 19613 288 46 the the DT 19613 288 47 latter latter NN 19613 288 48 . . . 19613 289 1 Decades decade NNS 19613 289 2 elapsed elapse VBD 19613 289 3 , , , 19613 289 4 for for IN 19613 289 5 instance instance NN 19613 289 6 , , , 19613 289 7 before before IN 19613 289 8 the the DT 19613 289 9 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 289 10 theology theology NN 19613 289 11 came come VBD 19613 289 12 to to TO 19613 289 13 be be VB 19613 289 14 generally generally RB 19613 289 15 known know VBN 19613 289 16 and and CC 19613 289 17 accepted accept VBN 19613 289 18 in in IN 19613 289 19 the the DT 19613 289 20 Church Church NNP 19613 289 21 , , , 19613 289 22 as as IN 19613 289 23 is be VBZ 19613 289 24 shown show VBN 19613 289 25 by by IN 19613 289 26 the the DT 19613 289 27 long long JJ 19613 289 28 continued continue VBN 19613 289 29 conflict conflict NN 19613 289 30 against against IN 19613 289 31 Monarchianism Monarchianism NNP 19613 289 32 . . . 19613 289 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 290 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 290 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 290 3 15 15 CD 19613 290 4 : : : 19613 290 5 The the DT 19613 290 6 origin origin NN 19613 290 7 of of IN 19613 290 8 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 290 9 can can MD 19613 290 10 only only RB 19613 290 11 be be VB 19613 290 12 very very RB 19613 290 13 imperfectly imperfectly RB 19613 290 14 described describe VBN 19613 290 15 within within IN 19613 290 16 the the DT 19613 290 17 framework framework NN 19613 290 18 of of IN 19613 290 19 the the DT 19613 290 20 history history NN 19613 290 21 of of IN 19613 290 22 dogma dogma NN 19613 290 23 , , , 19613 290 24 for for IN 19613 290 25 the the DT 19613 290 26 political political JJ 19613 290 27 situation situation NN 19613 290 28 of of IN 19613 290 29 the the DT 19613 290 30 Christian christian JJ 19613 290 31 communities community NNS 19613 290 32 in in IN 19613 290 33 the the DT 19613 290 34 Roman Roman NNP 19613 290 35 Empire Empire NNP 19613 290 36 had have VBD 19613 290 37 quite quite RB 19613 290 38 as as RB 19613 290 39 important important JJ 19613 290 40 an an DT 19613 290 41 influence influence NN 19613 290 42 on on IN 19613 290 43 the the DT 19613 290 44 development development NN 19613 290 45 of of IN 19613 290 46 the the DT 19613 290 47 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 290 48 Church Church NNP 19613 290 49 as as IN 19613 290 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 290 51 internal internal JJ 19613 290 52 conflicts conflict NNS 19613 290 53 . . . 19613 291 1 But but CC 19613 291 2 inasmuch inasmuch VB 19613 291 3 as as IN 19613 291 4 that that DT 19613 291 5 situation situation NN 19613 291 6 and and CC 19613 291 7 these these DT 19613 291 8 struggles struggle NNS 19613 291 9 are be VBP 19613 291 10 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 291 11 connected connect VBN 19613 291 12 in in IN 19613 291 13 the the DT 19613 291 14 closest close JJS 19613 291 15 way way NN 19613 291 16 , , , 19613 291 17 the the DT 19613 291 18 history history NN 19613 291 19 of of IN 19613 291 20 dogma dogma NN 19613 291 21 can can MD 19613 291 22 not not RB 19613 291 23 even even RB 19613 291 24 furnish furnish VB 19613 291 25 a a DT 19613 291 26 complete complete JJ 19613 291 27 picture picture NN 19613 291 28 of of IN 19613 291 29 this this DT 19613 291 30 development development NN 19613 291 31 within within IN 19613 291 32 definite definite JJ 19613 291 33 limits limit NNS 19613 291 34 . . . 19613 291 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 292 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 292 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 292 3 16 16 CD 19613 292 4 : : : 19613 292 5 See see VB 19613 292 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 292 7 , , , 19613 292 8 de de FW 19613 292 9 pudic pudic JJ 19613 292 10 . . . 19613 293 1 10 10 CD 19613 293 2 : : : 19613 293 3 " " `` 19613 293 4 Sed Sed NNP 19613 293 5 cederem cederem JJ 19613 293 6 tibi tibi NN 19613 293 7 , , , 19613 293 8 si si NNP 19613 293 9 scriptura scriptura NNP 19613 293 10 Pastoris Pastoris NNP 19613 293 11 , , , 19613 293 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 293 13 sola sola NNP 19613 293 14 moechos moechos NNP 19613 293 15 amat amat NNP 19613 293 16 , , , 19613 293 17 divino divino NNP 19613 293 18 instrumento instrumento NNP 19613 293 19 meruisset meruisset NN 19613 293 20 incidi incidi NN 19613 293 21 , , , 19613 293 22 si si NNP 19613 293 23 non non NNP 19613 293 24 ab ab NNP 19613 293 25 omni omni NNP 19613 293 26 concilio concilio NNP 19613 293 27 ecclesiarum ecclesiarum NNP 19613 293 28 etiam etiam NNP 19613 293 29 vestrarum vestrarum NNP 19613 293 30 inter inter NNP 19613 293 31 aprocrypha aprocrypha NNP 19613 293 32 et et FW 19613 293 33 falsa falsa NNP 19613 293 34 iudicaretur iudicaretur NNP 19613 293 35 ; ; : 19613 293 36 " " `` 19613 293 37 de de FW 19613 293 38 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 293 39 . . . 19613 294 1 13 13 CD 19613 294 2 : : : 19613 294 3 " " `` 19613 294 4 Aguntur Aguntur NNP 19613 294 5 præsterea præsterea NN 19613 294 6 per per IN 19613 294 7 Græcias Græcias NNP 19613 294 8 illa illa RB 19613 294 9 certis certis NN 19613 294 10 in in IN 19613 294 11 locis locis NNP 19613 294 12 concilia concilia NNP 19613 294 13 ex ex NNP 19613 294 14 universis universis NNP 19613 294 15 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 294 16 , , , 19613 294 17 per per IN 19613 294 18 quæ quæ NNP 19613 294 19 et et NNP 19613 294 20 altiora altiora NNP 19613 294 21 quæque quæque NNP 19613 294 22 in in IN 19613 294 23 commune commune NNP 19613 294 24 tractantur tractantur NNP 19613 294 25 , , , 19613 294 26 et et NNP 19613 294 27 ipsa ipsa FW 19613 294 28 repræsentatio repræsentatio NNP 19613 294 29 totius totius NNP 19613 294 30 nominis nominis NNP 19613 294 31 Christiani Christiani NNP 19613 294 32 magna magna NNS 19613 294 33 veneratione veneratione IN 19613 294 34 celebratur celebratur NN 19613 294 35 . . . 19613 294 36 " " '' 19613 295 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 295 2 must must MD 19613 295 3 also also RB 19613 295 4 take take VB 19613 295 5 into into IN 19613 295 6 account account NN 19613 295 7 here here RB 19613 295 8 the the DT 19613 295 9 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 295 10 by by IN 19613 295 11 letter letter NN 19613 295 12 , , , 19613 295 13 in in IN 19613 295 14 which which WDT 19613 295 15 connection connection NN 19613 295 16 I -PRON- PRP 19613 295 17 may may MD 19613 295 18 specially specially RB 19613 295 19 remind remind VB 19613 295 20 the the DT 19613 295 21 reader reader NN 19613 295 22 of of IN 19613 295 23 the the DT 19613 295 24 correspondence correspondence NN 19613 295 25 between between IN 19613 295 26 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 295 27 , , , 19613 295 28 Bishop Bishop NNP 19613 295 29 of of IN 19613 295 30 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 295 31 , , , 19613 295 32 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 295 33 . . NNP 19613 295 34 , , , 19613 295 35 H. H. NNP 19613 295 36 E. E. NNP 19613 295 37 IV IV NNP 19613 295 38 . . . 19613 296 1 23 23 CD 19613 296 2 , , , 19613 296 3 and and CC 19613 296 4 journeys journey NNS 19613 296 5 such such JJ 19613 296 6 as as IN 19613 296 7 those those DT 19613 296 8 of of IN 19613 296 9 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 296 10 and and CC 19613 296 11 Abercius Abercius NNP 19613 296 12 to to IN 19613 296 13 Rome Rome NNP 19613 296 14 . . . 19613 297 1 Cf cf NN 19613 297 2 . . . 19613 298 1 generally generally RB 19613 298 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 298 3 , , , 19613 298 4 Weltverkehr Weltverkehr NNP 19613 298 5 und und JJ 19613 298 6 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 298 7 währeud währeud NNP 19613 298 8 der der NN 19613 298 9 drei drei NN 19613 298 10 ersten ersten VBD 19613 298 11 Jahrhunderte Jahrhunderte NNP 19613 298 12 , , , 19613 298 13 1877 1877 CD 19613 298 14 . . . 19613 298 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 299 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 299 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 299 3 17 17 CD 19613 299 4 : : : 19613 299 5 See see VB 19613 299 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 299 7 studies study NNS 19613 299 8 respecting respect VBG 19613 299 9 the the DT 19613 299 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 299 11 of of IN 19613 299 12 the the DT 19613 299 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 299 14 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 299 15 of of IN 19613 299 16 the the DT 19613 299 17 second second JJ 19613 299 18 century century NN 19613 299 19 in in IN 19613 299 20 the the DT 19613 299 21 early early JJ 19613 299 22 Church Church NNP 19613 299 23 in in IN 19613 299 24 the the DT 19613 299 25 Texte Texte NNP 19613 299 26 und und NN 19613 299 27 Unters Unters NNP 19613 299 28 . . . 19613 300 1 z. z. NNP 19613 300 2 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 300 3 . . . 19613 301 1 der der NNP 19613 301 2 alt alt NNP 19613 301 3 christl christl NNP 19613 301 4 . . . 19613 302 1 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 302 2 , , , 19613 302 3 Vol Vol NNP 19613 302 4 . . . 19613 303 1 I. I. NNP 19613 304 1 Part part NN 19613 304 2 I. I. NNP 19613 305 1 2 2 LS 19613 305 2 . . . 19613 305 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 306 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 306 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 306 3 18 18 CD 19613 306 4 : : : 19613 306 5 See see VB 19613 306 6 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 306 7 . . NNP 19613 306 8 , , , 19613 306 9 H. H. NNP 19613 306 10 E. E. NNP 19613 306 11 II II NNP 19613 306 12 . . . 19613 307 1 2 2 LS 19613 307 2 ; ; : 19613 307 3 VI VI NNP 19613 307 4 . . . 19613 308 1 43 43 CD 19613 308 2 . . . 19613 308 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 309 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 309 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 309 3 19 19 CD 19613 309 4 : : : 19613 309 5 See see VB 19613 309 6 the the DT 19613 309 7 accounts account NNS 19613 309 8 of of IN 19613 309 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 309 10 in in IN 19613 309 11 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 309 12 and and CC 19613 309 13 the the DT 19613 309 14 far far NNP 19613 309 15 East East NNP 19613 309 16 generally generally RB 19613 309 17 . . . 19613 310 1 The the DT 19613 310 2 Acta Acta NNP 19613 310 3 Archelai Archelai NNP 19613 310 4 and and CC 19613 310 5 the the DT 19613 310 6 Homilies Homilies NNPS 19613 310 7 of of IN 19613 310 8 Aphraates Aphraates NNPS 19613 310 9 should should MD 19613 310 10 also also RB 19613 310 11 be be VB 19613 310 12 specially specially RB 19613 310 13 examined examine VBN 19613 310 14 . . . 19613 311 1 Cf cf NN 19613 311 2 . . . 19613 312 1 further further JJ 19613 312 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 312 3 . . NNP 19613 312 4 , , , 19613 312 5 H. H. NNP 19613 312 6 E. E. NNP 19613 312 7 VI VI NNP 19613 312 8 . . . 19613 313 1 12 12 CD 19613 313 2 , , , 19613 313 3 and and CC 19613 313 4 finally finally RB 19613 313 5 the the DT 19613 313 6 remains remain NNS 19613 313 7 of of IN 19613 313 8 the the DT 19613 313 9 Latin latin JJ 19613 313 10 - - HYPH 19613 313 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 313 12 literature literature NN 19613 313 13 of of IN 19613 313 14 the the DT 19613 313 15 third third JJ 19613 313 16 century century NN 19613 313 17 -- -- : 19613 313 18 apart apart RB 19613 313 19 from from IN 19613 313 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 313 21 , , , 19613 313 22 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 313 23 and and CC 19613 313 24 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 313 25 -- -- : 19613 313 26 as as IN 19613 313 27 found find VBN 19613 313 28 partly partly RB 19613 313 29 under under IN 19613 313 30 the the DT 19613 313 31 name name NN 19613 313 32 of of IN 19613 313 33 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 313 34 , , , 19613 313 35 partly partly RB 19613 313 36 under under IN 19613 313 37 other other JJ 19613 313 38 titles title NNS 19613 313 39 . . . 19613 314 1 Commodian Commodian NNP 19613 314 2 , , , 19613 314 3 Arnobius Arnobius NNP 19613 314 4 , , , 19613 314 5 and and CC 19613 314 6 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 19613 314 7 are be VBP 19613 314 8 also also RB 19613 314 9 instructive instructive JJ 19613 314 10 here here RB 19613 314 11 . . . 19613 315 1 This this DT 19613 315 2 literature literature NN 19613 315 3 has have VBZ 19613 315 4 been be VBN 19613 315 5 but but CC 19613 315 6 little little JJ 19613 315 7 utilised utilise VBN 19613 315 8 with with IN 19613 315 9 respect respect NN 19613 315 10 to to IN 19613 315 11 the the DT 19613 315 12 history history NN 19613 315 13 of of IN 19613 315 14 dogma dogma NN 19613 315 15 and and CC 19613 315 16 of of IN 19613 315 17 the the DT 19613 315 18 Church Church NNP 19613 315 19 . . . 19613 315 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 316 1 I. I. NNP 19613 316 2 FIXING FIXING NNP 19613 316 3 AND and CC 19613 316 4 GRADUAL GRADUAL NNP 19613 316 5 SECULARISING SECULARISING NNP 19613 316 6 OF of IN 19613 316 7 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 316 8 AS as IN 19613 316 9 A a DT 19613 316 10 CHURCH CHURCH NNP 19613 316 11 CHAPTER chapter NN 19613 316 12 II II NNP 19613 316 13 THE the DT 19613 316 14 SETTING setting NN 19613 316 15 UP up RP 19613 316 16 OF of IN 19613 316 17 THE the DT 19613 316 18 APOSTOLIC APOSTOLIC NNP 19613 316 19 STANDARDS standard NNS 19613 316 20 FOR for IN 19613 316 21 ECCLESIASTICAL ecclesiastical NN 19613 316 22 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 316 23 . . . 19613 317 1 THE the DT 19613 317 2 CATHOLIC CATHOLIC NNP 19613 317 3 CHURCH CHURCH NNS 19613 317 4 . . . 19613 318 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 318 2 20 20 CD 19613 318 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 318 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 318 5 may may MD 19613 318 6 take take VB 19613 318 7 as as IN 19613 318 8 preface preface NN 19613 318 9 to to IN 19613 318 10 this this DT 19613 318 11 chapter chapter NN 19613 318 12 three three CD 19613 318 13 celebrated celebrated JJ 19613 318 14 passages passage NNS 19613 318 15 from from IN 19613 318 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 318 17 's 's POS 19613 318 18 " " `` 19613 318 19 de de NNP 19613 318 20 præscriptione præscriptione NNP 19613 318 21 hæreticorum hæreticorum NNP 19613 318 22 . . . 19613 318 23 " " '' 19613 319 1 In in IN 19613 319 2 chap chap NN 19613 319 3 . . . 19613 320 1 21 21 CD 19613 320 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 320 3 find find VBP 19613 320 4 : : : 19613 320 5 " " `` 19613 320 6 It -PRON- PRP 19613 320 7 is be VBZ 19613 320 8 plain plain JJ 19613 320 9 that that IN 19613 320 10 all all DT 19613 320 11 teaching teaching NN 19613 320 12 that that WDT 19613 320 13 agrees agree VBZ 19613 320 14 with with IN 19613 320 15 those those DT 19613 320 16 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 320 17 Churches church NNS 19613 320 18 which which WDT 19613 320 19 are be VBP 19613 320 20 the the DT 19613 320 21 wombs womb NNS 19613 320 22 and and CC 19613 320 23 origins origin NNS 19613 320 24 of of IN 19613 320 25 the the DT 19613 320 26 faith faith NN 19613 320 27 must must MD 19613 320 28 be be VB 19613 320 29 set set VBN 19613 320 30 down down RP 19613 320 31 as as IN 19613 320 32 truth truth NN 19613 320 33 , , , 19613 320 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 320 35 being be VBG 19613 320 36 certain certain JJ 19613 320 37 that that IN 19613 320 38 such such JJ 19613 320 39 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 320 40 contains contain VBZ 19613 320 41 that that IN 19613 320 42 which which WDT 19613 320 43 the the DT 19613 320 44 Church Church NNP 19613 320 45 received receive VBD 19613 320 46 from from IN 19613 320 47 the the DT 19613 320 48 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 320 49 , , , 19613 320 50 the the DT 19613 320 51 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 320 52 from from IN 19613 320 53 Christ Christ NNP 19613 320 54 , , , 19613 320 55 and and CC 19613 320 56 Christ Christ NNP 19613 320 57 from from IN 19613 320 58 God God NNP 19613 320 59 . . . 19613 320 60 " " '' 19613 321 1 In in IN 19613 321 2 chap chap NN 19613 321 3 . . . 19613 322 1 36 36 CD 19613 322 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 322 3 read read VBP 19613 322 4 : : : 19613 322 5 " " `` 19613 322 6 Let let VB 19613 322 7 us -PRON- PRP 19613 322 8 see see VB 19613 322 9 what what WP 19613 322 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 322 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 322 12 the the DT 19613 322 13 Roman Roman NNP 19613 322 14 Church Church NNP 19613 322 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 322 16 has have VBZ 19613 322 17 learned learn VBN 19613 322 18 , , , 19613 322 19 what what WP 19613 322 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 322 21 has have VBZ 19613 322 22 taught teach VBN 19613 322 23 , , , 19613 322 24 and and CC 19613 322 25 what what WDT 19613 322 26 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 322 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 322 28 has have VBZ 19613 322 29 likewise likewise RB 19613 322 30 had have VBN 19613 322 31 with with IN 19613 322 32 the the DT 19613 322 33 African african JJ 19613 322 34 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 322 35 . . . 19613 323 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 323 2 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 19613 323 3 one one CD 19613 323 4 God God NNP 19613 323 5 the the DT 19613 323 6 Lord Lord NNP 19613 323 7 , , , 19613 323 8 the the DT 19613 323 9 creator creator NN 19613 323 10 of of IN 19613 323 11 the the DT 19613 323 12 universe universe NN 19613 323 13 , , , 19613 323 14 and and CC 19613 323 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 323 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 323 17 , , , 19613 323 18 the the DT 19613 323 19 Son Son NNP 19613 323 20 of of IN 19613 323 21 God God NNP 19613 323 22 the the DT 19613 323 23 creator creator NN 19613 323 24 , , , 19613 323 25 born bear VBN 19613 323 26 of of IN 19613 323 27 the the DT 19613 323 28 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 323 29 Mary Mary NNP 19613 323 30 , , , 19613 323 31 as as RB 19613 323 32 well well RB 19613 323 33 as as IN 19613 323 34 the the DT 19613 323 35 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 323 36 of of IN 19613 323 37 the the DT 19613 323 38 flesh flesh NN 19613 323 39 . . . 19613 324 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 324 2 unites unite VBZ 19613 324 3 the the DT 19613 324 4 Law Law NNP 19613 324 5 and and CC 19613 324 6 the the DT 19613 324 7 Prophets prophet NNS 19613 324 8 with with IN 19613 324 9 the the DT 19613 324 10 writings writing NNS 19613 324 11 of of IN 19613 324 12 the the DT 19613 324 13 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 19613 324 14 and and CC 19613 324 15 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 324 16 . . . 19613 325 1 From from IN 19613 325 2 these these DT 19613 325 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 325 4 draws draw VBZ 19613 325 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 325 6 faith faith NN 19613 325 7 , , , 19613 325 8 and and CC 19613 325 9 by by IN 19613 325 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 325 11 authority authority NN 19613 325 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 325 13 seals seal VBZ 19613 325 14 this this DT 19613 325 15 faith faith NN 19613 325 16 with with IN 19613 325 17 water water NN 19613 325 18 , , , 19613 325 19 clothes clothe VBZ 19613 325 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 325 21 with with IN 19613 325 22 the the DT 19613 325 23 Holy Holy NNP 19613 325 24 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 325 25 , , , 19613 325 26 feeds feed VBZ 19613 325 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 325 28 with with IN 19613 325 29 the the DT 19613 325 30 eucharist eucharist NN 19613 325 31 , , , 19613 325 32 and and CC 19613 325 33 encourages encourage VBZ 19613 325 34 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 325 35 . . . 19613 326 1 Hence hence RB 19613 326 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 326 3 receives receive VBZ 19613 326 4 no no DT 19613 326 5 one one NN 19613 326 6 who who WP 19613 326 7 rejects reject VBZ 19613 326 8 this this DT 19613 326 9 institution institution NN 19613 326 10 . . . 19613 326 11 " " '' 19613 327 1 In in IN 19613 327 2 chap chap NN 19613 327 3 . . . 19613 328 1 32 32 CD 19613 328 2 the the DT 19613 328 3 following follow VBG 19613 328 4 challenge challenge NN 19613 328 5 is be VBZ 19613 328 6 addressed address VBN 19613 328 7 to to IN 19613 328 8 the the DT 19613 328 9 heretics heretic NNS 19613 328 10 : : : 19613 328 11 " " `` 19613 328 12 Let let VB 19613 328 13 them -PRON- PRP 19613 328 14 unfold unfold VB 19613 328 15 a a DT 19613 328 16 series series NN 19613 328 17 of of IN 19613 328 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 328 19 bishops bishop NNS 19613 328 20 proceeding proceed VBG 19613 328 21 by by IN 19613 328 22 succession succession NN 19613 328 23 from from IN 19613 328 24 the the DT 19613 328 25 beginning beginning NN 19613 328 26 in in IN 19613 328 27 such such PDT 19613 328 28 a a DT 19613 328 29 way way NN 19613 328 30 that that IN 19613 328 31 this this DT 19613 328 32 first first JJ 19613 328 33 bishop bishop NN 19613 328 34 of of IN 19613 328 35 theirs -PRON- PRP 19613 328 36 had have VBD 19613 328 37 as as IN 19613 328 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 328 39 authority authority NN 19613 328 40 and and CC 19613 328 41 predecessor predecessor VB 19613 328 42 some some DT 19613 328 43 one one CD 19613 328 44 of of IN 19613 328 45 the the DT 19613 328 46 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 328 47 or or CC 19613 328 48 one one CD 19613 328 49 of of IN 19613 328 50 the the DT 19613 328 51 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 328 52 men man NNS 19613 328 53 , , , 19613 328 54 who who WP 19613 328 55 , , , 19613 328 56 however however RB 19613 328 57 , , , 19613 328 58 associated associate VBN 19613 328 59 with with IN 19613 328 60 the the DT 19613 328 61 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 328 62 . . . 19613 329 1 " " `` 19613 329 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 329 3 21 21 CD 19613 329 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 329 5 From from IN 19613 329 6 the the DT 19613 329 7 consideration consideration NN 19613 329 8 of of IN 19613 329 9 these these DT 19613 329 10 three three CD 19613 329 11 passages passage NNS 19613 329 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 329 13 directly directly RB 19613 329 14 follows follow VBZ 19613 329 15 that that IN 19613 329 16 three three CD 19613 329 17 standards standard NNS 19613 329 18 are be VBP 19613 329 19 to to TO 19613 329 20 be be VB 19613 329 21 kept keep VBN 19613 329 22 in in IN 19613 329 23 view view NN 19613 329 24 , , , 19613 329 25 viz viz NNP 19613 329 26 . . NNP 19613 329 27 , , , 19613 329 28 the the DT 19613 329 29 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 329 30 doctrine doctrine NNP 19613 329 31 , , , 19613 329 32 the the DT 19613 329 33 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 329 34 canon canon NN 19613 329 35 of of IN 19613 329 36 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 329 37 , , , 19613 329 38 and and CC 19613 329 39 the the DT 19613 329 40 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 329 41 of of IN 19613 329 42 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 329 43 authority authority NNP 19613 329 44 , , , 19613 329 45 afforded afford VBN 19613 329 46 by by IN 19613 329 47 the the DT 19613 329 48 organisation organisation NN 19613 329 49 of of IN 19613 329 50 the the DT 19613 329 51 Church Church NNP 19613 329 52 , , , 19613 329 53 that that RB 19613 329 54 is is RB 19613 329 55 , , , 19613 329 56 by by IN 19613 329 57 the the DT 19613 329 58 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 329 59 , , , 19613 329 60 and and CC 19613 329 61 traced trace VBD 19613 329 62 back back RB 19613 329 63 to to IN 19613 329 64 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 329 65 institution institution NN 19613 329 66 . . . 19613 330 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 330 2 will will MD 19613 330 3 be be VB 19613 330 4 seen see VBN 19613 330 5 that that IN 19613 330 6 the the DT 19613 330 7 Church Church NNP 19613 330 8 always always RB 19613 330 9 adopted adopt VBD 19613 330 10 these these DT 19613 330 11 three three CD 19613 330 12 standards standard NNS 19613 330 13 together together RB 19613 330 14 , , , 19613 330 15 that that DT 19613 330 16 is be VBZ 19613 330 17 simultaneously simultaneously RB 19613 330 18 . . . 19613 331 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 331 2 22 22 CD 19613 331 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 331 4 As as IN 19613 331 5 a a DT 19613 331 6 matter matter NN 19613 331 7 of of IN 19613 331 8 fact fact NN 19613 331 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 331 10 originated originate VBD 19613 331 11 in in IN 19613 331 12 Rome Rome NNP 19613 331 13 and and CC 19613 331 14 gradually gradually RB 19613 331 15 made make VBD 19613 331 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 331 17 way way NN 19613 331 18 in in IN 19613 331 19 the the DT 19613 331 20 other other JJ 19613 331 21 Churches church NNS 19613 331 22 . . . 19613 332 1 That that IN 19613 332 2 Asia Asia NNP 19613 332 3 Minor Minor NNP 19613 332 4 had have VBD 19613 332 5 a a DT 19613 332 6 share share NN 19613 332 7 in in IN 19613 332 8 this this DT 19613 332 9 is be VBZ 19613 332 10 probable probable JJ 19613 332 11 , , , 19613 332 12 though though IN 19613 332 13 the the DT 19613 332 14 question question NN 19613 332 15 is be VBZ 19613 332 16 involved involve VBN 19613 332 17 in in IN 19613 332 18 obscurity obscurity NN 19613 332 19 . . . 19613 333 1 The the DT 19613 333 2 three three CD 19613 333 3 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 333 4 standards standard NNS 19613 333 5 had have VBD 19613 333 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 333 7 preparatory preparatory JJ 19613 333 8 stages stage NNS 19613 333 9 , , , 19613 333 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 333 11 1 1 LS 19613 333 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 333 13 in in IN 19613 333 14 short short JJ 19613 333 15 kerygmatic kerygmatic JJ 19613 333 16 creeds creed NNS 19613 333 17 ; ; : 19613 333 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 333 19 2 2 LS 19613 333 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 333 21 in in IN 19613 333 22 the the DT 19613 333 23 authority authority NN 19613 333 24 of of IN 19613 333 25 the the DT 19613 333 26 Lord Lord NNP 19613 333 27 and and CC 19613 333 28 the the DT 19613 333 29 formless formless NN 19613 333 30 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 333 31 tradition tradition NN 19613 333 32 as as RB 19613 333 33 well well RB 19613 333 34 as as IN 19613 333 35 in in IN 19613 333 36 the the DT 19613 333 37 writings writing NNS 19613 333 38 read read VBN 19613 333 39 in in IN 19613 333 40 the the DT 19613 333 41 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 333 42 ; ; : 19613 333 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 333 44 3 3 LS 19613 333 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 333 46 in in IN 19613 333 47 the the DT 19613 333 48 veneration veneration NN 19613 333 49 paid pay VBN 19613 333 50 to to IN 19613 333 51 apostles apostle NNS 19613 333 52 , , , 19613 333 53 prophets prophet NNS 19613 333 54 , , , 19613 333 55 and and CC 19613 333 56 teachers teacher NNS 19613 333 57 , , , 19613 333 58 or or CC 19613 333 59 the the DT 19613 333 60 " " `` 19613 333 61 elders elder NNS 19613 333 62 " " '' 19613 333 63 and and CC 19613 333 64 leaders leader NNS 19613 333 65 of of IN 19613 333 66 the the DT 19613 333 67 individual individual JJ 19613 333 68 communities community NNS 19613 333 69 . . . 19613 334 1 A. A. NNP 19613 335 1 _ _ NNP 19613 335 2 The the DT 19613 335 3 Transformation Transformation NNP 19613 335 4 of of IN 19613 335 5 the the DT 19613 335 6 Baptismal Baptismal NNP 19613 335 7 Confession Confession NNP 19613 335 8 into into IN 19613 335 9 the the DT 19613 335 10 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 335 11 Rule Rule NNP 19613 335 12 of of IN 19613 335 13 Faith Faith NNP 19613 335 14 . . . 19613 335 15 _ _ NNP 19613 335 16 It -PRON- PRP 19613 335 17 has have VBZ 19613 335 18 been be VBN 19613 335 19 explained explain VBN 19613 335 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 335 21 vol vol NNP 19613 335 22 . . . 19613 336 1 I. I. NNP 19613 336 2 p. p. NNP 19613 336 3 157 157 CD 19613 336 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 336 5 that that IN 19613 336 6 the the DT 19613 336 7 idea idea NN 19613 336 8 of of IN 19613 336 9 the the DT 19613 336 10 complete complete JJ 19613 336 11 identity identity NN 19613 336 12 of of IN 19613 336 13 what what WP 19613 336 14 the the DT 19613 336 15 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 336 16 possessed possess VBD 19613 336 17 as as IN 19613 336 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 336 19 communities community NNS 19613 336 20 with with IN 19613 336 21 the the DT 19613 336 22 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 336 23 or or CC 19613 336 24 regulations regulation NNS 19613 336 25 of of IN 19613 336 26 the the DT 19613 336 27 twelve twelve CD 19613 336 28 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 336 29 can can MD 19613 336 30 already already RB 19613 336 31 be be VB 19613 336 32 shown show VBN 19613 336 33 in in IN 19613 336 34 the the DT 19613 336 35 earliest early JJS 19613 336 36 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 336 37 - - HYPH 19613 336 38 Christian christian JJ 19613 336 39 literature literature NN 19613 336 40 . . . 19613 337 1 In in IN 19613 337 2 the the DT 19613 337 3 widest wide JJS 19613 337 4 sense sense NN 19613 337 5 the the DT 19613 337 6 expression expression NN 19613 337 7 , , , 19613 337 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 337 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 337 10 : : : 19613 337 11 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 337 12 tês tês NNP 19613 337 13 paradoseôs paradoseôs NNP 19613 337 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 337 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 337 16 canon canon NNP 19613 337 17 of of IN 19613 337 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 337 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 337 20 , , , 19613 337 21 originally originally RB 19613 337 22 included include VBD 19613 337 23 all all DT 19613 337 24 that that WDT 19613 337 25 was be VBD 19613 337 26 traced trace VBN 19613 337 27 back back RB 19613 337 28 to to IN 19613 337 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 337 30 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 337 31 through through IN 19613 337 32 the the DT 19613 337 33 medium medium NN 19613 337 34 of of IN 19613 337 35 the the DT 19613 337 36 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 337 37 and and CC 19613 337 38 was be VBD 19613 337 39 of of IN 19613 337 40 value value NN 19613 337 41 for for IN 19613 337 42 the the DT 19613 337 43 faith faith NN 19613 337 44 and and CC 19613 337 45 life life NN 19613 337 46 of of IN 19613 337 47 the the DT 19613 337 48 Church Church NNP 19613 337 49 , , , 19613 337 50 together together RB 19613 337 51 with with IN 19613 337 52 everything everything NN 19613 337 53 that that WDT 19613 337 54 was be VBD 19613 337 55 or or CC 19613 337 56 seemed seem VBD 19613 337 57 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 337 58 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 337 59 possession possession NN 19613 337 60 , , , 19613 337 61 as as IN 19613 337 62 , , , 19613 337 63 for for IN 19613 337 64 instance instance NN 19613 337 65 , , , 19613 337 66 the the DT 19613 337 67 Christian christian JJ 19613 337 68 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 337 69 of of IN 19613 337 70 the the DT 19613 337 71 Old Old NNP 19613 337 72 Testament Testament NNP 19613 337 73 . . . 19613 338 1 In in IN 19613 338 2 the the DT 19613 338 3 narrower narrow JJR 19613 338 4 sense sense NN 19613 338 5 that that IN 19613 338 6 canon canon NNP 19613 338 7 consisted consist VBD 19613 338 8 of of IN 19613 338 9 the the DT 19613 338 10 history history NN 19613 338 11 and and CC 19613 338 12 words word NNS 19613 338 13 of of IN 19613 338 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 338 15 . . . 19613 339 1 In in IN 19613 339 2 so so RB 19613 339 3 far far RB 19613 339 4 as as IN 19613 339 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 339 6 formed form VBD 19613 339 7 the the DT 19613 339 8 content content NN 19613 339 9 of of IN 19613 339 10 faith faith NN 19613 339 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 339 12 were be VBD 19613 339 13 the the DT 19613 339 14 faith faith NN 19613 339 15 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 339 16 , , , 19613 339 17 that that RB 19613 339 18 is is RB 19613 339 19 , , , 19613 339 20 the the DT 19613 339 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 339 22 truth truth NN 19613 339 23 ; ; : 19613 339 24 in in IN 19613 339 25 so so RB 19613 339 26 far far RB 19613 339 27 as as IN 19613 339 28 this this DT 19613 339 29 faith faith NN 19613 339 30 was be VBD 19613 339 31 to to TO 19613 339 32 determine determine VB 19613 339 33 the the DT 19613 339 34 essence essence NN 19613 339 35 of of IN 19613 339 36 everything everything NN 19613 339 37 Christian Christian NNP 19613 339 38 , , , 19613 339 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 339 40 might may MD 19613 339 41 be be VB 19613 339 42 termed term VBN 19613 339 43 [ [ -LRB- 19613 339 44 Greek Greek NNP 19613 339 45 : : : 19613 339 46 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 339 47 tês tês NNP 19613 339 48 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 339 49 , , , 19613 339 50 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 339 51 tês tês NNP 19613 339 52 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 339 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 339 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 339 55 canon canon NNP 19613 339 56 of of IN 19613 339 57 the the DT 19613 339 58 faith faith NN 19613 339 59 , , , 19613 339 60 canon canon NN 19613 339 61 of of IN 19613 339 62 the the DT 19613 339 63 truth truth NN 19613 339 64 ) ) -RRB- 19613 339 65 . . . 19613 340 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 340 2 23 23 CD 19613 340 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 340 4 But but CC 19613 340 5 the the DT 19613 340 6 very very JJ 19613 340 7 fact fact NN 19613 340 8 that that IN 19613 340 9 the the DT 19613 340 10 extent extent NN 19613 340 11 of of IN 19613 340 12 what what WP 19613 340 13 was be VBD 19613 340 14 regarded regard VBN 19613 340 15 as as IN 19613 340 16 tradition tradition NN 19613 340 17 of of IN 19613 340 18 the the DT 19613 340 19 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 340 20 was be VBD 19613 340 21 quite quite RB 19613 340 22 undetermined undetermined JJ 19613 340 23 ensured ensure VBD 19613 340 24 the the DT 19613 340 25 possibility possibility NN 19613 340 26 of of IN 19613 340 27 the the DT 19613 340 28 highest high JJS 19613 340 29 degree degree NN 19613 340 30 of of IN 19613 340 31 freedom freedom NN 19613 340 32 ; ; : 19613 340 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 340 34 was be VBD 19613 340 35 also also RB 19613 340 36 still still RB 19613 340 37 allowable allowable JJ 19613 340 38 to to TO 19613 340 39 give give VB 19613 340 40 expression expression NN 19613 340 41 to to IN 19613 340 42 Christian christian JJ 19613 340 43 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 340 44 and and CC 19613 340 45 to to IN 19613 340 46 the the DT 19613 340 47 intuition intuition NN 19613 340 48 of of IN 19613 340 49 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 340 50 without without IN 19613 340 51 any any DT 19613 340 52 regard regard NN 19613 340 53 to to IN 19613 340 54 tradition tradition NN 19613 340 55 . . . 19613 341 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 341 2 now now RB 19613 341 3 know know VBP 19613 341 4 that that IN 19613 341 5 before before IN 19613 341 6 the the DT 19613 341 7 violent violent JJ 19613 341 8 conflict conflict NN 19613 341 9 with with IN 19613 341 10 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 341 11 short short JJ 19613 341 12 formulated formulate VBN 19613 341 13 summaries summary NNS 19613 341 14 of of IN 19613 341 15 the the DT 19613 341 16 faith faith NN 19613 341 17 had have VBD 19613 341 18 already already RB 19613 341 19 grown grow VBN 19613 341 20 out out IN 19613 341 21 of of IN 19613 341 22 the the DT 19613 341 23 missionary missionary JJ 19613 341 24 practice practice NN 19613 341 25 of of IN 19613 341 26 the the DT 19613 341 27 Church Church NNP 19613 341 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 341 29 catechising catechising NN 19613 341 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 341 31 . . . 19613 342 1 The the DT 19613 342 2 shortest short JJS 19613 342 3 formula formula NN 19613 342 4 was be VBD 19613 342 5 that that IN 19613 342 6 which which WDT 19613 342 7 defined define VBD 19613 342 8 the the DT 19613 342 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 342 10 faith faith NN 19613 342 11 as as IN 19613 342 12 belief belief NN 19613 342 13 in in IN 19613 342 14 the the DT 19613 342 15 Father Father NNP 19613 342 16 , , , 19613 342 17 Son Son NNP 19613 342 18 , , , 19613 342 19 and and CC 19613 342 20 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 342 21 . . . 19613 343 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 343 2 24 24 CD 19613 343 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 343 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 343 5 appears appear VBZ 19613 343 6 to to TO 19613 343 7 have have VB 19613 343 8 been be VBN 19613 343 9 universally universally RB 19613 343 10 current current JJ 19613 343 11 in in IN 19613 343 12 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 343 13 about about IN 19613 343 14 the the DT 19613 343 15 year year NN 19613 343 16 150 150 CD 19613 343 17 . . . 19613 344 1 In in IN 19613 344 2 the the DT 19613 344 3 solemn solemn JJ 19613 344 4 transactions transaction NNS 19613 344 5 of of IN 19613 344 6 the the DT 19613 344 7 Church Church NNP 19613 344 8 , , , 19613 344 9 therefore therefore RB 19613 344 10 especially especially RB 19613 344 11 in in IN 19613 344 12 baptism baptism NN 19613 344 13 , , , 19613 344 14 in in IN 19613 344 15 the the DT 19613 344 16 great great JJ 19613 344 17 prayer prayer NN 19613 344 18 of of IN 19613 344 19 the the DT 19613 344 20 Lord Lord NNP 19613 344 21 's 's POS 19613 344 22 Supper Supper NNP 19613 344 23 , , , 19613 344 24 as as RB 19613 344 25 well well RB 19613 344 26 as as IN 19613 344 27 in in IN 19613 344 28 the the DT 19613 344 29 exorcism exorcism NN 19613 344 30 of of IN 19613 344 31 demons,[25 demons,[25 NNP 19613 344 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 344 33 fixed fix VBN 19613 344 34 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 344 35 were be VBD 19613 344 36 used use VBN 19613 344 37 . . . 19613 345 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 345 2 embraced embrace VBD 19613 345 3 also also RB 19613 345 4 such such JJ 19613 345 5 articles article NNS 19613 345 6 as as IN 19613 345 7 contained contain VBD 19613 345 8 the the DT 19613 345 9 most most RBS 19613 345 10 important important JJ 19613 345 11 facts fact NNS 19613 345 12 in in IN 19613 345 13 the the DT 19613 345 14 history history NN 19613 345 15 of of IN 19613 345 16 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 345 17 . . . 19613 346 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 346 2 26 26 CD 19613 346 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 346 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 346 5 know know VBP 19613 346 6 definitely definitely RB 19613 346 7 that that IN 19613 346 8 not not RB 19613 346 9 later later RB 19613 346 10 than than IN 19613 346 11 about about IN 19613 346 12 the the DT 19613 346 13 middle middle NN 19613 346 14 of of IN 19613 346 15 the the DT 19613 346 16 second second JJ 19613 346 17 century century NN 19613 346 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 346 19 about about RB 19613 346 20 140 140 CD 19613 346 21 A.D. A.D. NNP 19613 346 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 346 23 the the DT 19613 346 24 Roman Roman NNP 19613 346 25 Church Church NNP 19613 346 26 possessed possess VBD 19613 346 27 a a DT 19613 346 28 fixed fix VBN 19613 346 29 creed creed NN 19613 346 30 , , , 19613 346 31 which which WDT 19613 346 32 every every DT 19613 346 33 candidate candidate NN 19613 346 34 for for IN 19613 346 35 baptism baptism NN 19613 346 36 had have VBD 19613 346 37 to to IN 19613 346 38 profess;[27 profess;[27 NNP 19613 346 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 346 40 and and CC 19613 346 41 something something NN 19613 346 42 similar similar JJ 19613 346 43 must must MD 19613 346 44 also also RB 19613 346 45 have have VB 19613 346 46 existed exist VBN 19613 346 47 in in IN 19613 346 48 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 19613 346 49 and and CC 19613 346 50 other other JJ 19613 346 51 Churches church NNS 19613 346 52 of of IN 19613 346 53 Asia Asia NNP 19613 346 54 Minor Minor NNP 19613 346 55 about about IN 19613 346 56 the the DT 19613 346 57 year year NN 19613 346 58 150 150 CD 19613 346 59 , , , 19613 346 60 in in IN 19613 346 61 some some DT 19613 346 62 cases case NNS 19613 346 63 , , , 19613 346 64 even even RB 19613 346 65 rather rather RB 19613 346 66 earlier early RBR 19613 346 67 . . . 19613 347 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 347 2 may may MD 19613 347 3 suppose suppose VB 19613 347 4 that that DT 19613 347 5 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 347 6 of of IN 19613 347 7 similar similar JJ 19613 347 8 plan plan NN 19613 347 9 and and CC 19613 347 10 extent extent NN 19613 347 11 were be VBD 19613 347 12 also also RB 19613 347 13 found find VBN 19613 347 14 in in IN 19613 347 15 other other JJ 19613 347 16 provincial provincial JJ 19613 347 17 Churches church NNS 19613 347 18 about about IN 19613 347 19 this this DT 19613 347 20 time time NN 19613 347 21 . . . 19613 348 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 348 2 28 28 CD 19613 348 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 348 4 Still still RB 19613 348 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 348 6 is be VBZ 19613 348 7 neither neither RB 19613 348 8 probable probable JJ 19613 348 9 that that IN 19613 348 10 all all PDT 19613 348 11 the the DT 19613 348 12 then then RB 19613 348 13 existing exist VBG 19613 348 14 communities community NNS 19613 348 15 possessed possess VBD 19613 348 16 such such JJ 19613 348 17 creeds creed NNS 19613 348 18 , , , 19613 348 19 nor nor CC 19613 348 20 that that IN 19613 348 21 those those DT 19613 348 22 who who WP 19613 348 23 used use VBD 19613 348 24 them -PRON- PRP 19613 348 25 had have VBD 19613 348 26 formulated formulate VBN 19613 348 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 348 28 in in IN 19613 348 29 such such PDT 19613 348 30 a a DT 19613 348 31 rigid rigid JJ 19613 348 32 way way NN 19613 348 33 as as IN 19613 348 34 the the DT 19613 348 35 Roman Roman NNP 19613 348 36 Church Church NNP 19613 348 37 had have VBD 19613 348 38 done do VBN 19613 348 39 . . . 19613 349 1 The the DT 19613 349 2 proclamation proclamation NN 19613 349 3 of of IN 19613 349 4 the the DT 19613 349 5 history history NN 19613 349 6 of of IN 19613 349 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 349 8 predicted predict VBD 19613 349 9 in in IN 19613 349 10 the the DT 19613 349 11 Old Old NNP 19613 349 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 349 13 , , , 19613 349 14 the the DT 19613 349 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 349 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 349 17 : : : 19613 349 18 kerygma kerygma NNP 19613 349 19 tês tês NNP 19613 349 20 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 349 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 349 22 , , , 19613 349 23 also also RB 19613 349 24 accompanied accompany VBD 19613 349 25 the the DT 19613 349 26 short short JJ 19613 349 27 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 349 28 formula formula NN 19613 349 29 without without IN 19613 349 30 being be VBG 19613 349 31 expressed express VBN 19613 349 32 in in IN 19613 349 33 set set VBN 19613 349 34 terms term NNS 19613 349 35 . . . 19613 350 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 350 2 29 29 CD 19613 350 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 350 4 Words word NNS 19613 350 5 of of IN 19613 350 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 350 7 and and CC 19613 350 8 , , , 19613 350 9 in in IN 19613 350 10 general general JJ 19613 350 11 , , , 19613 350 12 directions direction NNS 19613 350 13 for for IN 19613 350 14 the the DT 19613 350 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 350 16 life life NN 19613 350 17 were be VBD 19613 350 18 not not RB 19613 350 19 , , , 19613 350 20 as as IN 19613 350 21 a a DT 19613 350 22 rule rule NN 19613 350 23 , , , 19613 350 24 admitted admit VBD 19613 350 25 into into IN 19613 350 26 the the DT 19613 350 27 short short JJ 19613 350 28 formulated formulate VBN 19613 350 29 creed creed NN 19613 350 30 . . . 19613 351 1 In in IN 19613 351 2 the the DT 19613 351 3 recently recently RB 19613 351 4 discovered discover VBN 19613 351 5 " " `` 19613 351 6 Teaching teaching NN 19613 351 7 of of IN 19613 351 8 the the DT 19613 351 9 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 351 10 " " '' 19613 351 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 351 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 351 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 351 14 : : : 19613 351 15 Didachê didachê NN 19613 351 16 tôn tôn NNP 19613 351 17 apostolôn apostolôn NN 19613 351 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 351 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 351 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 351 21 have have VBP 19613 351 22 no no RB 19613 351 23 doubt doubt RB 19613 351 24 a a DT 19613 351 25 notable notable JJ 19613 351 26 attempt attempt NN 19613 351 27 to to TO 19613 351 28 fix fix VB 19613 351 29 the the DT 19613 351 30 rules rule NNS 19613 351 31 of of IN 19613 351 32 Christian christian JJ 19613 351 33 life life NN 19613 351 34 as as IN 19613 351 35 traced trace VBN 19613 351 36 back back RB 19613 351 37 to to IN 19613 351 38 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 351 39 through through IN 19613 351 40 the the DT 19613 351 41 medium medium NN 19613 351 42 of of IN 19613 351 43 the the DT 19613 351 44 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 351 45 , , , 19613 351 46 and and CC 19613 351 47 to to TO 19613 351 48 elevate elevate VB 19613 351 49 them -PRON- PRP 19613 351 50 into into IN 19613 351 51 the the DT 19613 351 52 foundation foundation NN 19613 351 53 of of IN 19613 351 54 the the DT 19613 351 55 confederation confederation NN 19613 351 56 of of IN 19613 351 57 Christian Christian NNP 19613 351 58 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 351 59 ; ; : 19613 351 60 but but CC 19613 351 61 this this DT 19613 351 62 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 351 63 , , , 19613 351 64 which which WDT 19613 351 65 could could MD 19613 351 66 not not RB 19613 351 67 but but CC 19613 351 68 have have VBP 19613 351 69 led lead VBN 19613 351 70 the the DT 19613 351 71 development development NN 19613 351 72 of of IN 19613 351 73 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 351 74 into into IN 19613 351 75 other other JJ 19613 351 76 paths path NNS 19613 351 77 , , , 19613 351 78 did do VBD 19613 351 79 not not RB 19613 351 80 succeed succeed VB 19613 351 81 . . . 19613 352 1 That that IN 19613 352 2 the the DT 19613 352 3 formulated formulate VBN 19613 352 4 creeds creed NNS 19613 352 5 did do VBD 19613 352 6 not not RB 19613 352 7 express express VB 19613 352 8 the the DT 19613 352 9 principles principle NNS 19613 352 10 of of IN 19613 352 11 conduct conduct NN 19613 352 12 , , , 19613 352 13 but but CC 19613 352 14 the the DT 19613 352 15 facts fact NNS 19613 352 16 on on IN 19613 352 17 which which WDT 19613 352 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 352 19 based base VBD 19613 352 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 352 21 faith faith NN 19613 352 22 , , , 19613 352 23 was be VBD 19613 352 24 an an DT 19613 352 25 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 352 26 necessity necessity NN 19613 352 27 . . . 19613 353 1 Besides besides RB 19613 353 2 , , , 19613 353 3 the the DT 19613 353 4 universal universal JJ 19613 353 5 agreement agreement NN 19613 353 6 of of IN 19613 353 7 all all DT 19613 353 8 earnest earnest JJ 19613 353 9 and and CC 19613 353 10 thoughtful thoughtful JJ 19613 353 11 minds mind NNS 19613 353 12 on on IN 19613 353 13 the the DT 19613 353 14 question question NN 19613 353 15 of of IN 19613 353 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 353 17 morals moral NNS 19613 353 18 was be VBD 19613 353 19 practically practically RB 19613 353 20 assured assure VBN 19613 353 21 . . . 19613 354 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 354 2 30 30 CD 19613 354 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 354 4 Objection objection NN 19613 354 5 was be VBD 19613 354 6 not not RB 19613 354 7 taken take VBN 19613 354 8 to to IN 19613 354 9 the the DT 19613 354 10 principles principle NNS 19613 354 11 of of IN 19613 354 12 morality morality NN 19613 354 13 -- -- : 19613 354 14 at at IN 19613 354 15 least least JJS 19613 354 16 this this DT 19613 354 17 was be VBD 19613 354 18 not not RB 19613 354 19 a a DT 19613 354 20 primary primary JJ 19613 354 21 consideration consideration NN 19613 354 22 -- -- : 19613 354 23 for for IN 19613 354 24 there there EX 19613 354 25 were be VBD 19613 354 26 many many JJ 19613 354 27 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 354 28 to to TO 19613 354 29 whom whom WP 19613 354 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 354 31 did do VBD 19613 354 32 not not RB 19613 354 33 seem seem VB 19613 354 34 foolishness foolishness NN 19613 354 35 , , , 19613 354 36 but but CC 19613 354 37 to to IN 19613 354 38 the the DT 19613 354 39 adoration adoration NN 19613 354 40 of of IN 19613 354 41 Christ Christ NNP 19613 354 42 as as IN 19613 354 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 354 44 was be VBD 19613 354 45 represented represent VBN 19613 354 46 in in IN 19613 354 47 tradition tradition NN 19613 354 48 and and CC 19613 354 49 to to IN 19613 354 50 the the DT 19613 354 51 Church Church NNP 19613 354 52 's 's POS 19613 354 53 worship worship NN 19613 354 54 of of IN 19613 354 55 a a DT 19613 354 56 God God NNP 19613 354 57 , , , 19613 354 58 who who WP 19613 354 59 , , , 19613 354 60 as as IN 19613 354 61 creator creator NN 19613 354 62 of of IN 19613 354 63 the the DT 19613 354 64 world world NN 19613 354 65 and and CC 19613 354 66 as as IN 19613 354 67 a a DT 19613 354 68 speaking speaking NN 19613 354 69 and and CC 19613 354 70 visible visible JJ 19613 354 71 being being NN 19613 354 72 , , , 19613 354 73 appeared appear VBD 19613 354 74 to to IN 19613 354 75 the the DT 19613 354 76 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 354 77 , , , 19613 354 78 with with IN 19613 354 79 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 354 80 ideas idea NNS 19613 354 81 of of IN 19613 354 82 a a DT 19613 354 83 purely purely RB 19613 354 84 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 354 85 deity deity NN 19613 354 86 , , , 19613 354 87 to to TO 19613 354 88 be be VB 19613 354 89 interwoven interwoven JJ 19613 354 90 with with IN 19613 354 91 the the DT 19613 354 92 world world NN 19613 354 93 , , , 19613 354 94 and and CC 19613 354 95 who who WP 19613 354 96 , , , 19613 354 97 as as IN 19613 354 98 the the DT 19613 354 99 God God NNP 19613 354 100 worshipped worship VBD 19613 354 101 by by IN 19613 354 102 the the DT 19613 354 103 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 354 104 also also RB 19613 354 105 , , , 19613 354 106 seemed seem VBD 19613 354 107 clearly clearly RB 19613 354 108 distinct distinct JJ 19613 354 109 from from IN 19613 354 110 the the DT 19613 354 111 Supreme Supreme NNP 19613 354 112 Being Being NNP 19613 354 113 . . . 19613 355 1 This this DT 19613 355 2 gave give VBD 19613 355 3 rise rise NN 19613 355 4 to to IN 19613 355 5 the the DT 19613 355 6 mockery mockery NN 19613 355 7 of of IN 19613 355 8 the the DT 19613 355 9 heathen heathen NNP 19613 355 10 , , , 19613 355 11 the the DT 19613 355 12 theological theological JJ 19613 355 13 art art NN 19613 355 14 of of IN 19613 355 15 the the DT 19613 355 16 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 355 17 , , , 19613 355 18 and and CC 19613 355 19 the the DT 19613 355 20 radical radical JJ 19613 355 21 reconstruction reconstruction NN 19613 355 22 of of IN 19613 355 23 tradition tradition NN 19613 355 24 as as IN 19613 355 25 attempted attempt VBN 19613 355 26 by by IN 19613 355 27 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 355 28 . . . 19613 356 1 With with IN 19613 356 2 the the DT 19613 356 3 freedom freedom NN 19613 356 4 that that WDT 19613 356 5 still still RB 19613 356 6 prevailed prevail VBD 19613 356 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 356 8 was be VBD 19613 356 9 in in IN 19613 356 10 danger danger NN 19613 356 11 of of IN 19613 356 12 being be VBG 19613 356 13 resolved resolve VBN 19613 356 14 into into IN 19613 356 15 a a DT 19613 356 16 motley motley JJ 19613 356 17 mass mass NN 19613 356 18 of of IN 19613 356 19 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 356 20 speculations speculation NNS 19613 356 21 or or CC 19613 356 22 of of IN 19613 356 23 being be VBG 19613 356 24 completely completely RB 19613 356 25 detached detach VBN 19613 356 26 from from IN 19613 356 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 356 28 original original JJ 19613 356 29 conditions condition NNS 19613 356 30 . . . 19613 357 1 " " `` 19613 357 2 It -PRON- PRP 19613 357 3 was be VBD 19613 357 4 admitted admit VBN 19613 357 5 on on IN 19613 357 6 all all DT 19613 357 7 sides side NNS 19613 357 8 that that IN 19613 357 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 357 10 had have VBD 19613 357 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 357 12 starting starting NN 19613 357 13 - - HYPH 19613 357 14 point point NN 19613 357 15 in in IN 19613 357 16 certain certain JJ 19613 357 17 facts fact NNS 19613 357 18 and and CC 19613 357 19 sayings saying NNS 19613 357 20 ; ; : 19613 357 21 but but CC 19613 357 22 if if IN 19613 357 23 any any DT 19613 357 24 and and CC 19613 357 25 every every DT 19613 357 26 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 357 27 of of IN 19613 357 28 those those DT 19613 357 29 facts fact NNS 19613 357 30 and and CC 19613 357 31 sayings saying NNS 19613 357 32 was be VBD 19613 357 33 possible possible JJ 19613 357 34 , , , 19613 357 35 if if IN 19613 357 36 any any DT 19613 357 37 system system NN 19613 357 38 of of IN 19613 357 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 357 40 might may MD 19613 357 41 be be VB 19613 357 42 taught teach VBN 19613 357 43 into into IN 19613 357 44 which which WDT 19613 357 45 the the DT 19613 357 46 words word NNS 19613 357 47 that that WDT 19613 357 48 expressed express VBD 19613 357 49 them -PRON- PRP 19613 357 50 might may MD 19613 357 51 be be VB 19613 357 52 woven weave VBN 19613 357 53 , , , 19613 357 54 it -PRON- PRP 19613 357 55 is be VBZ 19613 357 56 clear clear JJ 19613 357 57 that that IN 19613 357 58 there there EX 19613 357 59 could could MD 19613 357 60 be be VB 19613 357 61 but but CC 19613 357 62 little little JJ 19613 357 63 cohesion cohesion NN 19613 357 64 between between IN 19613 357 65 the the DT 19613 357 66 members member NNS 19613 357 67 of of IN 19613 357 68 the the DT 19613 357 69 Christian christian JJ 19613 357 70 communities community NNS 19613 357 71 . . . 19613 358 1 The the DT 19613 358 2 problem problem NN 19613 358 3 arose arise VBD 19613 358 4 and and CC 19613 358 5 pressed press VBD 19613 358 6 for for IN 19613 358 7 an an DT 19613 358 8 answer answer NN 19613 358 9 : : : 19613 358 10 What what WP 19613 358 11 should should MD 19613 358 12 be be VB 19613 358 13 the the DT 19613 358 14 basis basis NN 19613 358 15 of of IN 19613 358 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 358 17 union union NN 19613 358 18 ? ? . 19613 359 1 But but CC 19613 359 2 the the DT 19613 359 3 problem problem NN 19613 359 4 was be VBD 19613 359 5 for for IN 19613 359 6 a a DT 19613 359 7 time time NN 19613 359 8 insoluble insoluble JJ 19613 359 9 . . . 19613 360 1 For for IN 19613 360 2 there there EX 19613 360 3 was be VBD 19613 360 4 no no DT 19613 360 5 standard standard NN 19613 360 6 and and CC 19613 360 7 no no DT 19613 360 8 court court NN 19613 360 9 of of IN 19613 360 10 appeal appeal NN 19613 360 11 . . . 19613 360 12 " " '' 19613 361 1 From from IN 19613 361 2 the the DT 19613 361 3 very very JJ 19613 361 4 beginning beginning NN 19613 361 5 , , , 19613 361 6 when when WRB 19613 361 7 the the DT 19613 361 8 differences difference NNS 19613 361 9 in in IN 19613 361 10 the the DT 19613 361 11 various various JJ 19613 361 12 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 361 13 began begin VBD 19613 361 14 to to TO 19613 361 15 threaten threaten VB 19613 361 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 361 17 unity unity NN 19613 361 18 , , , 19613 361 19 appeal appeal NN 19613 361 20 was be VBD 19613 361 21 probably probably RB 19613 361 22 made make VBN 19613 361 23 to to IN 19613 361 24 the the DT 19613 361 25 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 361 26 ' ' POS 19613 361 27 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 361 28 , , , 19613 361 29 the the DT 19613 361 30 words word NNS 19613 361 31 of of IN 19613 361 32 the the DT 19613 361 33 Lord Lord NNP 19613 361 34 , , , 19613 361 35 tradition tradition NN 19613 361 36 , , , 19613 361 37 " " `` 19613 361 38 sound sound JJ 19613 361 39 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 361 40 " " '' 19613 361 41 , , , 19613 361 42 definite definite JJ 19613 361 43 facts fact NNS 19613 361 44 , , , 19613 361 45 such such JJ 19613 361 46 as as IN 19613 361 47 the the DT 19613 361 48 reality reality NN 19613 361 49 of of IN 19613 361 50 the the DT 19613 361 51 human human JJ 19613 361 52 nature nature NN 19613 361 53 ( ( -LRB- 19613 361 54 flesh flesh NN 19613 361 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 361 56 of of IN 19613 361 57 Christ Christ NNP 19613 361 58 , , , 19613 361 59 and and CC 19613 361 60 the the DT 19613 361 61 reality reality NN 19613 361 62 of of IN 19613 361 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 361 64 death death NN 19613 361 65 and and CC 19613 361 66 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 361 67 . . . 19613 362 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 362 2 31 31 CD 19613 362 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 362 4 In in IN 19613 362 5 instruction instruction NN 19613 362 6 , , , 19613 362 7 in in IN 19613 362 8 exhortations exhortation NNS 19613 362 9 , , , 19613 362 10 and and CC 19613 362 11 above above IN 19613 362 12 all all DT 19613 362 13 in in IN 19613 362 14 opposing oppose VBG 19613 362 15 erroneous erroneous JJ 19613 362 16 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 362 17 and and CC 19613 362 18 moral moral JJ 19613 362 19 aberrations aberration NNS 19613 362 20 , , , 19613 362 21 this this DT 19613 362 22 precept precept NN 19613 362 23 was be VBD 19613 362 24 inculcated inculcate VBN 19613 362 25 from from IN 19613 362 26 the the DT 19613 362 27 beginning beginning NN 19613 362 28 : : : 19613 362 29 [ [ -LRB- 19613 362 30 Greek Greek NNP 19613 362 31 : : : 19613 362 32 apolipômen apolipômen NNP 19613 362 33 tas tas NNP 19613 362 34 kenas kenas NNP 19613 362 35 kai kai NNP 19613 362 36 mataias mataias NNP 19613 362 37 phrontidas phrontidas NNP 19613 362 38 , , , 19613 362 39 kai kai NNP 19613 362 40 elthômen elthômen NNP 19613 362 41 epi epi NNP 19613 362 42 ton ton NNP 19613 362 43 eukleê eukleê NNP 19613 362 44 kai kai NNP 19613 362 45 semnon semnon NNP 19613 362 46 tês tês NNP 19613 362 47 paradoseôs paradoseôs NNP 19613 362 48 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 362 49 kanona kanona NNP 19613 362 50 ] ] -RRB- 19613 362 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 362 52 " " `` 19613 362 53 Let let VB 19613 362 54 us -PRON- PRP 19613 362 55 leave leave VB 19613 362 56 off off RP 19613 362 57 vain vain JJ 19613 362 58 and and CC 19613 362 59 foolish foolish JJ 19613 362 60 thoughts thought NNS 19613 362 61 and and CC 19613 362 62 betake betake VB 19613 362 63 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 362 64 to to IN 19613 362 65 the the DT 19613 362 66 glorious glorious JJ 19613 362 67 and and CC 19613 362 68 august august NNP 19613 362 69 canon canon NN 19613 362 70 of of IN 19613 362 71 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 362 72 tradition tradition NN 19613 362 73 " " '' 19613 362 74 ) ) -RRB- 19613 362 75 . . . 19613 363 1 But but CC 19613 363 2 the the DT 19613 363 3 very very JJ 19613 363 4 question question NN 19613 363 5 was be VBD 19613 363 6 : : : 19613 363 7 What what WP 19613 363 8 is be VBZ 19613 363 9 sound sound JJ 19613 363 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 363 11 ? ? . 19613 364 1 What what WP 19613 364 2 is be VBZ 19613 364 3 the the DT 19613 364 4 content content NN 19613 364 5 of of IN 19613 364 6 tradition tradition NN 19613 364 7 ? ? . 19613 365 1 Was be VBD 19613 365 2 the the DT 19613 365 3 flesh flesh NN 19613 365 4 of of IN 19613 365 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 365 6 a a DT 19613 365 7 reality reality NN 19613 365 8 ? ? . 19613 366 1 etc etc FW 19613 366 2 . . . 19613 367 1 There there EX 19613 367 2 is be VBZ 19613 367 3 no no DT 19613 367 4 doubt doubt NN 19613 367 5 that that IN 19613 367 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 367 7 , , , 19613 367 8 in in IN 19613 367 9 opposition opposition NN 19613 367 10 to to IN 19613 367 11 those those DT 19613 367 12 whom whom WP 19613 367 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 367 14 viewed view VBD 19613 367 15 as as IN 19613 367 16 pseudo pseudo NN 19613 367 17 - - HYPH 19613 367 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 367 19 , , , 19613 367 20 insisted insist VBD 19613 367 21 on on IN 19613 367 22 the the DT 19613 367 23 absolute absolute JJ 19613 367 24 necessity necessity NN 19613 367 25 of of IN 19613 367 26 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 19613 367 27 certain certain JJ 19613 367 28 definite definite JJ 19613 367 29 traditional traditional JJ 19613 367 30 facts fact NNS 19613 367 31 and and CC 19613 367 32 made make VBD 19613 367 33 this this DT 19613 367 34 recognition recognition NN 19613 367 35 the the DT 19613 367 36 standard standard NN 19613 367 37 of of IN 19613 367 38 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 367 39 . . . 19613 368 1 To to IN 19613 368 2 all all DT 19613 368 3 appearance appearance NN 19613 368 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 368 5 was be VBD 19613 368 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 368 7 who who WP 19613 368 8 began begin VBD 19613 368 9 the the DT 19613 368 10 great great JJ 19613 368 11 literary literary JJ 19613 368 12 struggle struggle NN 19613 368 13 for for IN 19613 368 14 the the DT 19613 368 15 expulsion expulsion NN 19613 368 16 of of IN 19613 368 17 heterodoxy heterodoxy NN 19613 368 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 368 19 see see VB 19613 368 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 368 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 368 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 368 23 : : : 19613 368 24 syntagma syntagma NNP 19613 368 25 kata kata NNP 19613 368 26 pasôn pasôn NNP 19613 368 27 tôn tôn NNP 19613 368 28 gegenêmenôn gegenêmenôn NNP 19613 368 29 haireseôn haireseôn NNP 19613 368 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 368 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 368 32 ; ; : 19613 368 33 but but CC 19613 368 34 , , , 19613 368 35 judging judge VBG 19613 368 36 from from IN 19613 368 37 those those DT 19613 368 38 writings writing NNS 19613 368 39 of of IN 19613 368 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 368 41 that that WDT 19613 368 42 have have VBP 19613 368 43 been be VBN 19613 368 44 preserved preserve VBN 19613 368 45 to to IN 19613 368 46 us -PRON- PRP 19613 368 47 , , , 19613 368 48 it -PRON- PRP 19613 368 49 seems seem VBZ 19613 368 50 very very RB 19613 368 51 unlikely unlikely JJ 19613 368 52 that that IN 19613 368 53 he -PRON- PRP 19613 368 54 was be VBD 19613 368 55 already already RB 19613 368 56 successful successful JJ 19613 368 57 in in IN 19613 368 58 finding find VBG 19613 368 59 a a DT 19613 368 60 fixed fix VBN 19613 368 61 standard standard NN 19613 368 62 for for IN 19613 368 63 determining determine VBG 19613 368 64 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 368 65 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 368 66 . . . 19613 369 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 369 2 32 32 CD 19613 369 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 369 4 The the DT 19613 369 5 permanence permanence NN 19613 369 6 of of IN 19613 369 7 the the DT 19613 369 8 communities community NNS 19613 369 9 , , , 19613 369 10 however however RB 19613 369 11 , , , 19613 369 12 depended depend VBD 19613 369 13 on on IN 19613 369 14 the the DT 19613 369 15 discovery discovery NN 19613 369 16 of of IN 19613 369 17 such such PDT 19613 369 18 a a DT 19613 369 19 standard standard NN 19613 369 20 . . . 19613 370 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 370 2 were be VBD 19613 370 3 no no RB 19613 370 4 longer long RBR 19613 370 5 held hold VBN 19613 370 6 together together RB 19613 370 7 by by IN 19613 370 8 the the DT 19613 370 9 _ _ NNP 19613 370 10 conscientia conscientia NN 19613 370 11 religionis religionis NNP 19613 370 12 _ _ NNP 19613 370 13 , , , 19613 370 14 the the DT 19613 370 15 _ _ NNP 19613 370 16 unitas unitas NNP 19613 370 17 disciplinæ disciplinæ NNS 19613 370 18 _ _ NNP 19613 370 19 , , , 19613 370 20 and and CC 19613 370 21 the the DT 19613 370 22 _ _ NNP 19613 370 23 foedus foedus NN 19613 370 24 spei spei FW 19613 370 25 _ _ NNP 19613 370 26 . . . 19613 371 1 The the DT 19613 371 2 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 371 3 were be VBD 19613 371 4 not not RB 19613 371 5 solely solely RB 19613 371 6 to to TO 19613 371 7 blame blame VB 19613 371 8 for for IN 19613 371 9 that that DT 19613 371 10 . . . 19613 372 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 372 2 rather rather RB 19613 372 3 show show VBP 19613 372 4 us -PRON- PRP 19613 372 5 merely merely RB 19613 372 6 the the DT 19613 372 7 excess excess NN 19613 372 8 of of IN 19613 372 9 a a DT 19613 372 10 continuous continuous JJ 19613 372 11 transformation transformation NN 19613 372 12 which which WDT 19613 372 13 no no DT 19613 372 14 community community NN 19613 372 15 could could MD 19613 372 16 escape escape VB 19613 372 17 . . . 19613 373 1 The the DT 19613 373 2 gnosis gnosis NN 19613 373 3 which which WDT 19613 373 4 subjected subject VBD 19613 373 5 religion religion NN 19613 373 6 to to IN 19613 373 7 a a DT 19613 373 8 critical critical JJ 19613 373 9 examination examination NN 19613 373 10 awoke awake VBD 19613 373 11 in in IN 19613 373 12 proportion proportion NN 19613 373 13 as as IN 19613 373 14 religious religious JJ 19613 373 15 life life NN 19613 373 16 from from IN 19613 373 17 generation generation NN 19613 373 18 to to IN 19613 373 19 generation generation NN 19613 373 20 lost lose VBD 19613 373 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 373 22 warmth warmth NN 19613 373 23 and and CC 19613 373 24 spontaneity spontaneity NN 19613 373 25 . . . 19613 374 1 There there EX 19613 374 2 was be VBD 19613 374 3 a a DT 19613 374 4 time time NN 19613 374 5 when when WRB 19613 374 6 the the DT 19613 374 7 majority majority NN 19613 374 8 of of IN 19613 374 9 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 374 10 knew know VBD 19613 374 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 374 12 to to TO 19613 374 13 be be VB 19613 374 14 such such JJ 19613 374 15 , , , 19613 374 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 374 17 1 1 LS 19613 374 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 374 19 because because IN 19613 374 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 374 21 had have VBD 19613 374 22 the the DT 19613 374 23 " " `` 19613 374 24 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 374 25 " " '' 19613 374 26 and and CC 19613 374 27 found find VBD 19613 374 28 in in IN 19613 374 29 that that IN 19613 374 30 an an DT 19613 374 31 indestructible indestructible JJ 19613 374 32 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 374 33 of of IN 19613 374 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 374 35 Christian christian JJ 19613 374 36 position position NN 19613 374 37 , , , 19613 374 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 374 39 2 2 LS 19613 374 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 374 41 because because IN 19613 374 42 they -PRON- PRP 19613 374 43 observed observe VBD 19613 374 44 all all PDT 19613 374 45 the the DT 19613 374 46 commandments commandment NNS 19613 374 47 of of IN 19613 374 48 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 374 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 374 50 [ [ -LRB- 19613 374 51 Greek Greek NNP 19613 374 52 : : : 19613 374 53 entolai entolai NNP 19613 374 54 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 374 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 374 56 ) ) -RRB- 19613 374 57 . . . 19613 375 1 But but CC 19613 375 2 when when WRB 19613 375 3 these these DT 19613 375 4 guarantees guarantee NNS 19613 375 5 died die VBD 19613 375 6 away away RB 19613 375 7 , , , 19613 375 8 and and CC 19613 375 9 when when WRB 19613 375 10 at at IN 19613 375 11 the the DT 19613 375 12 same same JJ 19613 375 13 time time NN 19613 375 14 the the DT 19613 375 15 most most RBS 19613 375 16 diverse diverse JJ 19613 375 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 375 18 that that WDT 19613 375 19 were be VBD 19613 375 20 threatening threaten VBG 19613 375 21 to to TO 19613 375 22 break break VB 19613 375 23 up up RP 19613 375 24 the the DT 19613 375 25 Church Church NNP 19613 375 26 were be VBD 19613 375 27 preached preach VBN 19613 375 28 in in IN 19613 375 29 the the DT 19613 375 30 name name NN 19613 375 31 of of IN 19613 375 32 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 375 33 , , , 19613 375 34 the the DT 19613 375 35 fixing fixing NN 19613 375 36 of of IN 19613 375 37 tradition tradition NN 19613 375 38 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 375 39 became become VBD 19613 375 40 the the DT 19613 375 41 supreme supreme NNP 19613 375 42 task task NNP 19613 375 43 . . . 19613 376 1 Here here RB 19613 376 2 , , , 19613 376 3 as as IN 19613 376 4 in in IN 19613 376 5 every every DT 19613 376 6 other other JJ 19613 376 7 case case NN 19613 376 8 , , , 19613 376 9 the the DT 19613 376 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 376 11 was be VBD 19613 376 12 not not RB 19613 376 13 fixed fix VBN 19613 376 14 till till IN 19613 376 15 after after IN 19613 376 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 376 17 had have VBD 19613 376 18 been be VBN 19613 376 19 to to IN 19613 376 20 some some DT 19613 376 21 extent extent NN 19613 376 22 departed depart VBN 19613 376 23 from from IN 19613 376 24 . . . 19613 377 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 377 2 was be VBD 19613 377 3 just just RB 19613 377 4 the the DT 19613 377 5 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 377 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 377 7 who who WP 19613 377 8 took take VBD 19613 377 9 the the DT 19613 377 10 lead lead NN 19613 377 11 in in IN 19613 377 12 a a DT 19613 377 13 fixing fixing NN 19613 377 14 process process NN 19613 377 15 , , , 19613 377 16 a a DT 19613 377 17 plain plain JJ 19613 377 18 proof proof NN 19613 377 19 that that IN 19613 377 20 the the DT 19613 377 21 setting setting NN 19613 377 22 up up RP 19613 377 23 of of IN 19613 377 24 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 377 25 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 377 26 has have VBZ 19613 377 27 always always RB 19613 377 28 been be VBN 19613 377 29 the the DT 19613 377 30 support support NN 19613 377 31 of of IN 19613 377 32 new new JJ 19613 377 33 formations formation NNS 19613 377 34 . . . 19613 378 1 But but CC 19613 378 2 the the DT 19613 378 3 example example NN 19613 378 4 set set VBN 19613 378 5 by by IN 19613 378 6 the the DT 19613 378 7 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 378 8 was be VBD 19613 378 9 the the DT 19613 378 10 very very JJ 19613 378 11 thing thing NN 19613 378 12 that that WDT 19613 378 13 rendered render VBD 19613 378 14 the the DT 19613 378 15 problem problem NN 19613 378 16 difficult difficult JJ 19613 378 17 . . . 19613 379 1 Where where WRB 19613 379 2 was be VBD 19613 379 3 a a DT 19613 379 4 beginning beginning NN 19613 379 5 to to TO 19613 379 6 be be VB 19613 379 7 made make VBN 19613 379 8 ? ? . 19613 380 1 " " `` 19613 380 2 There there EX 19613 380 3 is be VBZ 19613 380 4 a a DT 19613 380 5 kind kind NN 19613 380 6 of of IN 19613 380 7 unconscious unconscious JJ 19613 380 8 logic logic NN 19613 380 9 in in IN 19613 380 10 the the DT 19613 380 11 minds mind NNS 19613 380 12 of of IN 19613 380 13 masses masse NNS 19613 380 14 of of IN 19613 380 15 men man NNS 19613 380 16 when when WRB 19613 380 17 great great JJ 19613 380 18 questions question NNS 19613 380 19 are be VBP 19613 380 20 abroad abroad RB 19613 380 21 , , , 19613 380 22 which which WDT 19613 380 23 some some DT 19613 380 24 one one CD 19613 380 25 thinker thinker NN 19613 380 26 throws throw VBZ 19613 380 27 into into IN 19613 380 28 suitable suitable JJ 19613 380 29 form form NN 19613 380 30 . . . 19613 381 1 " " `` 19613 381 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 381 3 33 33 CD 19613 381 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 381 5 There there EX 19613 381 6 could could MD 19613 381 7 be be VB 19613 381 8 no no DT 19613 381 9 doubt doubt NN 19613 381 10 that that IN 19613 381 11 the the DT 19613 381 12 needful needful JJ 19613 381 13 thing thing NN 19613 381 14 was be VBD 19613 381 15 to to TO 19613 381 16 fix fix VB 19613 381 17 what what WP 19613 381 18 was be VBD 19613 381 19 " " `` 19613 381 20 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 381 21 , , , 19613 381 22 " " '' 19613 381 23 for for IN 19613 381 24 the the DT 19613 381 25 one one CD 19613 381 26 certain certain JJ 19613 381 27 thing thing NN 19613 381 28 was be VBD 19613 381 29 that that IN 19613 381 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 381 31 was be VBD 19613 381 32 based base VBN 19613 381 33 on on IN 19613 381 34 a a DT 19613 381 35 divine divine JJ 19613 381 36 revelation revelation NN 19613 381 37 which which WDT 19613 381 38 had have VBD 19613 381 39 been be VBN 19613 381 40 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 381 41 through through IN 19613 381 42 the the DT 19613 381 43 medium medium NN 19613 381 44 of of IN 19613 381 45 the the DT 19613 381 46 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 381 47 to to IN 19613 381 48 the the DT 19613 381 49 Churches church NNS 19613 381 50 of of IN 19613 381 51 the the DT 19613 381 52 whole whole JJ 19613 381 53 earth earth NN 19613 381 54 . . . 19613 382 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 382 2 certainly certainly RB 19613 382 3 was be VBD 19613 382 4 not not RB 19613 382 5 a a DT 19613 382 6 single single JJ 19613 382 7 individual individual NN 19613 382 8 who who WP 19613 382 9 hit hit VBD 19613 382 10 on on IN 19613 382 11 the the DT 19613 382 12 expedient expedient NN 19613 382 13 of of IN 19613 382 14 affirming affirm VBG 19613 382 15 the the DT 19613 382 16 fixed fix VBN 19613 382 17 forms form NNS 19613 382 18 employed employ VBN 19613 382 19 by by IN 19613 382 20 the the DT 19613 382 21 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 382 22 in in IN 19613 382 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 382 24 solemn solemn JJ 19613 382 25 transactions transaction NNS 19613 382 26 to to TO 19613 382 27 be be VB 19613 382 28 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 382 29 in in IN 19613 382 30 the the DT 19613 382 31 strict strict JJ 19613 382 32 sense sense NN 19613 382 33 . . . 19613 383 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 383 2 must must MD 19613 383 3 have have VB 19613 383 4 come come VBN 19613 383 5 about about RP 19613 383 6 by by IN 19613 383 7 a a DT 19613 383 8 natural natural JJ 19613 383 9 process process NN 19613 383 10 . . . 19613 384 1 But but CC 19613 384 2 the the DT 19613 384 3 confession confession NN 19613 384 4 of of IN 19613 384 5 the the DT 19613 384 6 Father Father NNP 19613 384 7 , , , 19613 384 8 Son Son NNP 19613 384 9 , , , 19613 384 10 and and CC 19613 384 11 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 384 12 and and CC 19613 384 13 the the DT 19613 384 14 _ _ NNP 19613 384 15 kerygma kerygma NNP 19613 384 16 _ _ NNP 19613 384 17 of of IN 19613 384 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 384 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 384 20 had have VBD 19613 384 21 the the DT 19613 384 22 most most RBS 19613 384 23 prominent prominent JJ 19613 384 24 place place NN 19613 384 25 among among IN 19613 384 26 these these DT 19613 384 27 forms form NNS 19613 384 28 . . . 19613 385 1 The the DT 19613 385 2 special special JJ 19613 385 3 emphasising emphasising NN 19613 385 4 of of IN 19613 385 5 these these DT 19613 385 6 articles article NNS 19613 385 7 , , , 19613 385 8 in in IN 19613 385 9 opposition opposition NN 19613 385 10 to to IN 19613 385 11 the the DT 19613 385 12 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 385 13 and and CC 19613 385 14 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 385 15 undertakings undertaking NNS 19613 385 16 , , , 19613 385 17 may may MD 19613 385 18 also also RB 19613 385 19 be be VB 19613 385 20 viewed view VBN 19613 385 21 as as IN 19613 385 22 the the DT 19613 385 23 result result NN 19613 385 24 of of IN 19613 385 25 the the DT 19613 385 26 " " `` 19613 385 27 common common JJ 19613 385 28 sense sense NN 19613 385 29 " " '' 19613 385 30 of of IN 19613 385 31 all all PDT 19613 385 32 those those DT 19613 385 33 who who WP 19613 385 34 clung clung VBP 19613 385 35 to to IN 19613 385 36 the the DT 19613 385 37 belief belief NN 19613 385 38 that that IN 19613 385 39 the the DT 19613 385 40 Father Father NNP 19613 385 41 of of IN 19613 385 42 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 385 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 385 44 was be VBD 19613 385 45 the the DT 19613 385 46 creator creator NN 19613 385 47 of of IN 19613 385 48 the the DT 19613 385 49 world world NN 19613 385 50 , , , 19613 385 51 and and CC 19613 385 52 that that IN 19613 385 53 the the DT 19613 385 54 Son Son NNP 19613 385 55 of of IN 19613 385 56 God God NNP 19613 385 57 really really RB 19613 385 58 appeared appear VBD 19613 385 59 in in IN 19613 385 60 the the DT 19613 385 61 flesh flesh NN 19613 385 62 . . . 19613 386 1 But but CC 19613 386 2 that that DT 19613 386 3 was be VBD 19613 386 4 not not RB 19613 386 5 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 386 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 386 7 , , , 19613 386 8 for for IN 19613 386 9 , , , 19613 386 10 even even RB 19613 386 11 admitting admit VBG 19613 386 12 that that IN 19613 386 13 about about IN 19613 386 14 the the DT 19613 386 15 period period NN 19613 386 16 between between IN 19613 386 17 150 150 CD 19613 386 18 and and CC 19613 386 19 180 180 CD 19613 386 20 A.D. A.D. NNP 19613 386 21 all all PDT 19613 386 22 the the DT 19613 386 23 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 386 24 had have VBD 19613 386 25 a a DT 19613 386 26 fixed fix VBN 19613 386 27 creed creed NN 19613 386 28 which which WDT 19613 386 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 386 30 regarded regard VBD 19613 386 31 as as IN 19613 386 32 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 386 33 in in IN 19613 386 34 the the DT 19613 386 35 strict strict JJ 19613 386 36 sense sense NN 19613 386 37 -- -- : 19613 386 38 and and CC 19613 386 39 this this DT 19613 386 40 can can MD 19613 386 41 not not RB 19613 386 42 be be VB 19613 386 43 proved,--the proved,--the RB 19613 386 44 most most RBS 19613 386 45 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 386 46 of of IN 19613 386 47 all all DT 19613 386 48 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 386 49 schools school NNS 19613 386 50 , , , 19613 386 51 viz viz NNP 19613 386 52 . . NNP 19613 386 53 , , , 19613 386 54 those those DT 19613 386 55 of of IN 19613 386 56 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 386 57 , , , 19613 386 58 could could MD 19613 386 59 recognise recognise VB 19613 386 60 this this DT 19613 386 61 creed creed NN 19613 386 62 , , , 19613 386 63 since since IN 19613 386 64 they -PRON- PRP 19613 386 65 already already RB 19613 386 66 possessed possess VBD 19613 386 67 the the DT 19613 386 68 art art NN 19613 386 69 of of IN 19613 386 70 explaining explain VBG 19613 386 71 a a DT 19613 386 72 given give VBN 19613 386 73 text text NN 19613 386 74 in in IN 19613 386 75 whatever whatever WDT 19613 386 76 way way NN 19613 386 77 they -PRON- PRP 19613 386 78 chose choose VBD 19613 386 79 . . . 19613 387 1 What what WP 19613 387 2 was be VBD 19613 387 3 needed need VBN 19613 387 4 was be VBD 19613 387 5 an an DT 19613 387 6 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 387 7 creed creed NN 19613 387 8 _ _ NNP 19613 387 9 definitely definitely RB 19613 387 10 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 387 11 _ _ NNP 19613 387 12 ; ; : 19613 387 13 for for IN 19613 387 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 387 15 was be VBD 19613 387 16 only only RB 19613 387 17 by by IN 19613 387 18 the the DT 19613 387 19 aid aid NN 19613 387 20 of of IN 19613 387 21 a a DT 19613 387 22 definite definite JJ 19613 387 23 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 387 24 that that IN 19613 387 25 the the DT 19613 387 26 creed creed NN 19613 387 27 could could MD 19613 387 28 be be VB 19613 387 29 used use VBN 19613 387 30 to to TO 19613 387 31 repel repel VB 19613 387 32 the the DT 19613 387 33 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 387 34 speculations speculation NNS 19613 387 35 and and CC 19613 387 36 the the DT 19613 387 37 Marcionite marcionite JJ 19613 387 38 conception conception NN 19613 387 39 of of IN 19613 387 40 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 387 41 . . . 19613 388 1 In in IN 19613 388 2 this this DT 19613 388 3 state state NN 19613 388 4 of of IN 19613 388 5 matters matter NNS 19613 388 6 the the DT 19613 388 7 Church Church NNP 19613 388 8 of of IN 19613 388 9 Rome Rome NNP 19613 388 10 , , , 19613 388 11 the the DT 19613 388 12 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 388 13 of of IN 19613 388 14 which which WDT 19613 388 15 are be VBP 19613 388 16 known know VBN 19613 388 17 to to IN 19613 388 18 us -PRON- PRP 19613 388 19 through through IN 19613 388 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 388 21 and and CC 19613 388 22 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 388 23 , , , 19613 388 24 took take VBD 19613 388 25 , , , 19613 388 26 with with IN 19613 388 27 regard regard NN 19613 388 28 to to IN 19613 388 29 the the DT 19613 388 30 fixed fix VBN 19613 388 31 Roman roman JJ 19613 388 32 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 388 33 confession confession NN 19613 388 34 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 388 35 to to IN 19613 388 36 the the DT 19613 388 37 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 388 38 , , , 19613 388 39 the the DT 19613 388 40 following follow VBG 19613 388 41 step step NN 19613 388 42 : : : 19613 388 43 The the DT 19613 388 44 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 388 45 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 388 46 required require VBN 19613 388 47 by by IN 19613 388 48 the the DT 19613 388 49 necessities necessity NNS 19613 388 50 of of IN 19613 388 51 the the DT 19613 388 52 times time NNS 19613 388 53 was be VBD 19613 388 54 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 388 55 as as IN 19613 388 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 388 57 self self NN 19613 388 58 - - HYPH 19613 388 59 evident evident JJ 19613 388 60 content content NN 19613 388 61 ; ; : 19613 388 62 the the DT 19613 388 63 confession confession NN 19613 388 64 , , , 19613 388 65 thus thus RB 19613 388 66 explained explain VBD 19613 388 67 , , , 19613 388 68 was be VBD 19613 388 69 designated designate VBN 19613 388 70 as as IN 19613 388 71 the the DT 19613 388 72 " " `` 19613 388 73 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 388 74 faith faith NN 19613 388 75 " " '' 19613 388 76 ( ( -LRB- 19613 388 77 " " `` 19613 388 78 fides fide NNS 19613 388 79 catholica catholica NNP 19613 388 80 " " '' 19613 388 81 ) ) -RRB- 19613 388 82 , , , 19613 388 83 that that DT 19613 388 84 is be VBZ 19613 388 85 the the DT 19613 388 86 rule rule NN 19613 388 87 of of IN 19613 388 88 truth truth NN 19613 388 89 for for IN 19613 388 90 the the DT 19613 388 91 faith faith NN 19613 388 92 ; ; : 19613 388 93 and and CC 19613 388 94 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 388 95 acceptance acceptance NN 19613 388 96 was be VBD 19613 388 97 made make VBN 19613 388 98 the the DT 19613 388 99 test test NN 19613 388 100 of of IN 19613 388 101 adherence adherence NN 19613 388 102 to to IN 19613 388 103 the the DT 19613 388 104 Roman Roman NNP 19613 388 105 Church Church NNP 19613 388 106 as as RB 19613 388 107 well well RB 19613 388 108 as as IN 19613 388 109 to to IN 19613 388 110 the the DT 19613 388 111 general general JJ 19613 388 112 confederation confederation NN 19613 388 113 of of IN 19613 388 114 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 388 115 . . . 19613 389 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 389 2 was be VBD 19613 389 3 not not RB 19613 389 4 the the DT 19613 389 5 author author NN 19613 389 6 of of IN 19613 389 7 this this DT 19613 389 8 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 389 9 . . . 19613 390 1 How how WRB 19613 390 2 far far RB 19613 390 3 Rome Rome NNP 19613 390 4 acted act VBD 19613 390 5 with with IN 19613 390 6 the the DT 19613 390 7 coöperation coöperation NN 19613 390 8 or or CC 19613 390 9 under under IN 19613 390 10 the the DT 19613 390 11 influence influence NN 19613 390 12 of of IN 19613 390 13 the the DT 19613 390 14 Church Church NNP 19613 390 15 of of IN 19613 390 16 Asia Asia NNP 19613 390 17 Minor Minor NNP 19613 390 18 is be VBZ 19613 390 19 a a DT 19613 390 20 matter matter NN 19613 390 21 that that WDT 19613 390 22 is be VBZ 19613 390 23 still still RB 19613 390 24 obscure,[34 obscure,[34 ADD 19613 390 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 390 26 and and CC 19613 390 27 will will MD 19613 390 28 probably probably RB 19613 390 29 never never RB 19613 390 30 be be VB 19613 390 31 determined determine VBN 19613 390 32 with with IN 19613 390 33 certainty certainty NN 19613 390 34 . . . 19613 391 1 What what WP 19613 391 2 the the DT 19613 391 3 Roman roman JJ 19613 391 4 community community NN 19613 391 5 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 391 6 practically practically RB 19613 391 7 was be VBD 19613 391 8 theoretically theoretically RB 19613 391 9 established establish VBN 19613 391 10 by by IN 19613 391 11 Irenæus[35 irenæus[35 ADD 19613 391 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 391 13 and and CC 19613 391 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 391 15 . . . 19613 392 1 The the DT 19613 392 2 former former JJ 19613 392 3 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 392 4 the the DT 19613 392 5 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 392 6 confession confession NN 19613 392 7 , , , 19613 392 8 definitely definitely RB 19613 392 9 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 392 10 and and CC 19613 392 11 expressed express VBD 19613 392 12 in in IN 19613 392 13 an an DT 19613 392 14 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 392 15 form form NN 19613 392 16 , , , 19613 392 17 to to TO 19613 392 18 be be VB 19613 392 19 the the DT 19613 392 20 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 392 21 rule rule NN 19613 392 22 of of IN 19613 392 23 truth truth NN 19613 392 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 392 25 regula regula NNP 19613 392 26 veritatis veritatis NN 19613 392 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 392 28 , , , 19613 392 29 and and CC 19613 392 30 tried try VBD 19613 392 31 to to TO 19613 392 32 prove prove VB 19613 392 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 392 34 so so RB 19613 392 35 . . . 19613 393 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 393 2 based base VBD 19613 393 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 393 4 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 393 5 on on IN 19613 393 6 the the DT 19613 393 7 theory theory NN 19613 393 8 that that IN 19613 393 9 this this DT 19613 393 10 series series NN 19613 393 11 of of IN 19613 393 12 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 393 13 embodied embody VBD 19613 393 14 the the DT 19613 393 15 faith faith NN 19613 393 16 of of IN 19613 393 17 the the DT 19613 393 18 churches church NNS 19613 393 19 founded found VBN 19613 393 20 by by IN 19613 393 21 the the DT 19613 393 22 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 393 23 , , , 19613 393 24 and and CC 19613 393 25 that that IN 19613 393 26 these these DT 19613 393 27 communities community NNS 19613 393 28 had have VBD 19613 393 29 always always RB 19613 393 30 preserved preserve VBN 19613 393 31 the the DT 19613 393 32 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 393 33 teaching teaching NN 19613 393 34 unchanged unchanged JJ 19613 393 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 393 36 see see VB 19613 393 37 under under IN 19613 393 38 C c NN 19613 393 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 393 40 . . . 19613 394 1 Viewed view VBN 19613 394 2 historically historically RB 19613 394 3 , , , 19613 394 4 this this DT 19613 394 5 thesis thesis NN 19613 394 6 , , , 19613 394 7 which which WDT 19613 394 8 preserved preserve VBD 19613 394 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 394 10 from from IN 19613 394 11 complete complete JJ 19613 394 12 dissolution dissolution NN 19613 394 13 , , , 19613 394 14 is be VBZ 19613 394 15 based base VBN 19613 394 16 on on IN 19613 394 17 two two CD 19613 394 18 unproved unproved JJ 19613 394 19 assumptions assumption NNS 19613 394 20 and and CC 19613 394 21 on on IN 19613 394 22 a a DT 19613 394 23 confusion confusion NN 19613 394 24 of of IN 19613 394 25 ideas idea NNS 19613 394 26 . . . 19613 395 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 395 2 is be VBZ 19613 395 3 not not RB 19613 395 4 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 19613 395 5 that that IN 19613 395 6 any any DT 19613 395 7 creed creed NN 19613 395 8 emanated emanate VBD 19613 395 9 from from IN 19613 395 10 the the DT 19613 395 11 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 395 12 , , , 19613 395 13 nor nor CC 19613 395 14 that that IN 19613 395 15 the the DT 19613 395 16 Churches church NNS 19613 395 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 395 18 founded found VBD 19613 395 19 always always RB 19613 395 20 preserved preserve VBN 19613 395 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 395 22 teaching teaching NN 19613 395 23 in in IN 19613 395 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 395 25 original original JJ 19613 395 26 form form NN 19613 395 27 ; ; : 19613 395 28 the the DT 19613 395 29 creed creed NN 19613 395 30 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 395 31 , , , 19613 395 32 moreover moreover RB 19613 395 33 , , , 19613 395 34 is be VBZ 19613 395 35 confused confused JJ 19613 395 36 with with IN 19613 395 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 395 38 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 395 39 . . . 19613 396 1 Finally finally RB 19613 396 2 , , , 19613 396 3 the the DT 19613 396 4 existence existence NN 19613 396 5 of of IN 19613 396 6 a a DT 19613 396 7 _ _ NNP 19613 396 8 fides fide NNS 19613 396 9 catholica catholica NNP 19613 396 10 _ _ NNP 19613 396 11 , , , 19613 396 12 in in IN 19613 396 13 the the DT 19613 396 14 strict strict JJ 19613 396 15 sense sense NN 19613 396 16 of of IN 19613 396 17 the the DT 19613 396 18 word word NN 19613 396 19 , , , 19613 396 20 can can MD 19613 396 21 not not RB 19613 396 22 be be VB 19613 396 23 justly justly RB 19613 396 24 inferred infer VBN 19613 396 25 from from IN 19613 396 26 the the DT 19613 396 27 essential essential JJ 19613 396 28 agreement agreement NN 19613 396 29 found find VBN 19613 396 30 in in IN 19613 396 31 the the DT 19613 396 32 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 396 33 of of IN 19613 396 34 a a DT 19613 396 35 series series NN 19613 396 36 of of IN 19613 396 37 communities community NNS 19613 396 38 . . . 19613 397 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 397 2 36 36 CD 19613 397 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 397 4 But but CC 19613 397 5 , , , 19613 397 6 on on IN 19613 397 7 the the DT 19613 397 8 other other JJ 19613 397 9 hand hand NN 19613 397 10 , , , 19613 397 11 the the DT 19613 397 12 course course NN 19613 397 13 taken take VBN 19613 397 14 by by IN 19613 397 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 397 16 was be VBD 19613 397 17 the the DT 19613 397 18 only only JJ 19613 397 19 one one CD 19613 397 20 capable capable JJ 19613 397 21 of of IN 19613 397 22 saving save VBG 19613 397 23 what what WP 19613 397 24 yet yet RB 19613 397 25 remained remain VBD 19613 397 26 of of IN 19613 397 27 primitive primitive JJ 19613 397 28 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 397 29 , , , 19613 397 30 and and CC 19613 397 31 that that DT 19613 397 32 is be VBZ 19613 397 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 397 34 historical historical JJ 19613 397 35 justification justification NN 19613 397 36 . . . 19613 398 1 A a DT 19613 398 2 _ _ NNP 19613 398 3 fides fide NNS 19613 398 4 apostolica apostolica NNP 19613 398 5 _ _ NNP 19613 398 6 had have VBD 19613 398 7 to to TO 19613 398 8 be be VB 19613 398 9 set set VBN 19613 398 10 up up RP 19613 398 11 and and CC 19613 398 12 declared declare VBD 19613 398 13 identical identical JJ 19613 398 14 with with IN 19613 398 15 the the DT 19613 398 16 already already RB 19613 398 17 existing exist VBG 19613 398 18 _ _ NNP 19613 398 19 fides fide NNS 19613 398 20 catholica catholica NNP 19613 398 21 _ _ NNP 19613 398 22 . . . 19613 399 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 399 2 had have VBD 19613 399 3 to to TO 19613 399 4 be be VB 19613 399 5 made make VBN 19613 399 6 the the DT 19613 399 7 standard standard NN 19613 399 8 for for IN 19613 399 9 judging judge VBG 19613 399 10 all all DT 19613 399 11 particular particular JJ 19613 399 12 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 399 13 opinions opinion NNS 19613 399 14 , , , 19613 399 15 that that IN 19613 399 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 399 17 might may MD 19613 399 18 be be VB 19613 399 19 determined determine VBN 19613 399 20 whether whether IN 19613 399 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 399 22 were be VBD 19613 399 23 admissible admissible JJ 19613 399 24 or or CC 19613 399 25 not not RB 19613 399 26 . . . 19613 400 1 The the DT 19613 400 2 persuasive persuasive JJ 19613 400 3 power power NN 19613 400 4 with with IN 19613 400 5 which which WDT 19613 400 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 400 7 set set VBD 19613 400 8 up up RP 19613 400 9 the the DT 19613 400 10 principle principle NN 19613 400 11 of of IN 19613 400 12 the the DT 19613 400 13 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 400 14 " " '' 19613 400 15 rule rule NN 19613 400 16 of of IN 19613 400 17 truth truth NN 19613 400 18 , , , 19613 400 19 " " '' 19613 400 20 or or CC 19613 400 21 of of IN 19613 400 22 " " `` 19613 400 23 tradition tradition NN 19613 400 24 " " '' 19613 400 25 or or CC 19613 400 26 simply simply RB 19613 400 27 of of IN 19613 400 28 " " `` 19613 400 29 faith faith NN 19613 400 30 , , , 19613 400 31 " " '' 19613 400 32 was be VBD 19613 400 33 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 400 34 , , , 19613 400 35 as as RB 19613 400 36 far far RB 19613 400 37 as as IN 19613 400 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 400 39 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 400 40 was be VBD 19613 400 41 concerned concern VBN 19613 400 42 , , , 19613 400 43 based base VBN 19613 400 44 on on IN 19613 400 45 the the DT 19613 400 46 facts fact NNS 19613 400 47 that that WDT 19613 400 48 he -PRON- PRP 19613 400 49 had have VBD 19613 400 50 already already RB 19613 400 51 a a DT 19613 400 52 rigidly rigidly RB 19613 400 53 formulated formulate VBN 19613 400 54 creed creed NN 19613 400 55 before before IN 19613 400 56 him -PRON- PRP 19613 400 57 and and CC 19613 400 58 that that IN 19613 400 59 he -PRON- PRP 19613 400 60 had have VBD 19613 400 61 no no DT 19613 400 62 doubt doubt NN 19613 400 63 as as IN 19613 400 64 to to IN 19613 400 65 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 400 66 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 400 67 . . . 19613 401 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 401 2 37 37 CD 19613 401 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 401 4 The the DT 19613 401 5 rule rule NN 19613 401 6 of of IN 19613 401 7 truth truth NN 19613 401 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 401 9 also also RB 19613 401 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 401 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 401 12 : : : 19613 401 13 hê hê VB 19613 401 14 hypo hypo NNP 19613 401 15 tês tês NNP 19613 401 16 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 401 17 kêryssomenê kêryssomenê NNP 19613 401 18 alêtheia alêtheia NNP 19613 401 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 401 20 " " `` 19613 401 21 the the DT 19613 401 22 truth truth NN 19613 401 23 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 401 24 by by IN 19613 401 25 the the DT 19613 401 26 Church Church NNP 19613 401 27 ; ; : 19613 401 28 " " '' 19613 401 29 and and CC 19613 401 30 [ [ -LRB- 19613 401 31 Greek Greek NNP 19613 401 32 : : : 19613 401 33 to to TO 19613 401 34 tês tês VB 19613 401 35 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 401 36 sômation sômation NN 19613 401 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 401 38 , , , 19613 401 39 " " `` 19613 401 40 the the DT 19613 401 41 body body NN 19613 401 42 of of IN 19613 401 43 the the DT 19613 401 44 truth truth NN 19613 401 45 " " '' 19613 401 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 401 47 is be VBZ 19613 401 48 the the DT 19613 401 49 old old JJ 19613 401 50 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 401 51 confession confession NN 19613 401 52 well well RB 19613 401 53 known know VBN 19613 401 54 to to IN 19613 401 55 the the DT 19613 401 56 communities community NNS 19613 401 57 for for IN 19613 401 58 which which WDT 19613 401 59 he -PRON- PRP 19613 401 60 immediately immediately RB 19613 401 61 writes write VBZ 19613 401 62 . . . 19613 402 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 402 2 See see VB 19613 402 3 I. i. NN 19613 403 1 9 9 CD 19613 403 2 . . . 19613 404 1 4 4 LS 19613 404 2 ; ; : 19613 404 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 404 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 404 5 : : : 19613 404 6 houtô houtô NNP 19613 404 7 de de NNP 19613 404 8 kai kai NNP 19613 404 9 ho ho NNP 19613 404 10 ton ton NNP 19613 404 11 kanona kanona NNP 19613 404 12 tês tês NNP 19613 404 13 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 404 14 aklinê aklinê VBP 19613 404 15 en en NNP 19613 404 16 heautô heautô NNP 19613 404 17 katechôn katechôn NNP 19613 404 18 hon hon NNP 19613 404 19 dia dia NNP 19613 404 20 tou tou NNP 19613 404 21 baptismatos baptismatos NNP 19613 404 22 eilêphe eilêphe NNP 19613 404 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 404 24 , , , 19613 404 25 " " `` 19613 404 26 in in IN 19613 404 27 like like JJ 19613 404 28 manner manner NN 19613 404 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 404 30 also also RB 19613 404 31 who who WP 19613 404 32 retains retain VBZ 19613 404 33 immovably immovably RB 19613 404 34 in in IN 19613 404 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 404 36 heart heart NN 19613 404 37 the the DT 19613 404 38 rule rule NN 19613 404 39 of of IN 19613 404 40 truth truth NN 19613 404 41 which which WDT 19613 404 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 404 43 received receive VBD 19613 404 44 through through IN 19613 404 45 baptism baptism NN 19613 404 46 " " '' 19613 404 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 404 48 ; ; : 19613 404 49 because because IN 19613 404 50 it -PRON- PRP 19613 404 51 is be VBZ 19613 404 52 this this DT 19613 404 53 , , , 19613 404 54 it -PRON- PRP 19613 404 55 is be VBZ 19613 404 56 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 404 57 , , , 19613 404 58 firm firm JJ 19613 404 59 and and CC 19613 404 60 immovable immovable JJ 19613 404 61 . . . 19613 405 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 405 2 38 38 CD 19613 405 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 405 4 By by IN 19613 405 5 the the DT 19613 405 6 fixing fixing NN 19613 405 7 of of IN 19613 405 8 the the DT 19613 405 9 rule rule NN 19613 405 10 of of IN 19613 405 11 truth truth NN 19613 405 12 , , , 19613 405 13 the the DT 19613 405 14 formulation formulation NN 19613 405 15 of of IN 19613 405 16 which which WDT 19613 405 17 in in IN 19613 405 18 the the DT 19613 405 19 case case NN 19613 405 20 of of IN 19613 405 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 405 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 405 23 I. I. NNP 19613 406 1 10 10 CD 19613 406 2 . . . 19613 407 1 1 1 CD 19613 407 2 , , , 19613 407 3 2 2 CD 19613 407 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 407 5 naturally naturally RB 19613 407 6 follows follow VBZ 19613 407 7 the the DT 19613 407 8 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 407 9 of of IN 19613 407 10 the the DT 19613 407 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 407 12 Roman roman JJ 19613 407 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 407 14 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 407 15 confession confession NN 19613 407 16 , , , 19613 407 17 the the DT 19613 407 18 most most RBS 19613 407 19 important important JJ 19613 407 20 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 407 21 these these DT 19613 407 22 s s NNPS 19613 407 23 were be VBD 19613 407 24 at at RB 19613 407 25 once once RB 19613 407 26 set set VBN 19613 407 27 aside aside RB 19613 407 28 and and CC 19613 407 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 407 30 antitheses antithesis NNS 19613 407 31 established establish VBN 19613 407 32 as as IN 19613 407 33 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 407 34 . . . 19613 408 1 In in IN 19613 408 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 408 3 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 408 4 rule rule NN 19613 408 5 of of IN 19613 408 6 truth truth NN 19613 408 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 408 8 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 408 9 already already RB 19613 408 10 gave give VBD 19613 408 11 prominence prominence NN 19613 408 12 to to IN 19613 408 13 the the DT 19613 408 14 following follow VBG 19613 408 15 doctrines:[39 doctrines:[39 FW 19613 408 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 408 17 the the DT 19613 408 18 unity unity NN 19613 408 19 of of IN 19613 408 20 God God NNP 19613 408 21 , , , 19613 408 22 the the DT 19613 408 23 identity identity NN 19613 408 24 of of IN 19613 408 25 the the DT 19613 408 26 supreme supreme JJ 19613 408 27 God God NNP 19613 408 28 with with IN 19613 408 29 the the DT 19613 408 30 Creator Creator NNP 19613 408 31 ; ; : 19613 408 32 the the DT 19613 408 33 identity identity NN 19613 408 34 of of IN 19613 408 35 the the DT 19613 408 36 supreme supreme JJ 19613 408 37 God God NNP 19613 408 38 with with IN 19613 408 39 the the DT 19613 408 40 God God NNP 19613 408 41 of of IN 19613 408 42 the the DT 19613 408 43 Old Old NNP 19613 408 44 Testament Testament NNP 19613 408 45 ; ; : 19613 408 46 the the DT 19613 408 47 unity unity NN 19613 408 48 of of IN 19613 408 49 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 408 50 Christ Christ NNP 19613 408 51 as as IN 19613 408 52 the the DT 19613 408 53 Son Son NNP 19613 408 54 of of IN 19613 408 55 the the DT 19613 408 56 God God NNP 19613 408 57 who who WP 19613 408 58 created create VBD 19613 408 59 the the DT 19613 408 60 world world NN 19613 408 61 ; ; , 19613 408 62 the the DT 19613 408 63 essential essential JJ 19613 408 64 divinity divinity NN 19613 408 65 of of IN 19613 408 66 Christ Christ NNP 19613 408 67 ; ; : 19613 408 68 the the DT 19613 408 69 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 408 70 of of IN 19613 408 71 the the DT 19613 408 72 Son Son NNP 19613 408 73 of of IN 19613 408 74 God God NNP 19613 408 75 ; ; : 19613 408 76 the the DT 19613 408 77 prediction prediction NN 19613 408 78 of of IN 19613 408 79 the the DT 19613 408 80 entire entire JJ 19613 408 81 history history NN 19613 408 82 of of IN 19613 408 83 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 408 84 through through IN 19613 408 85 the the DT 19613 408 86 Holy Holy NNP 19613 408 87 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 408 88 in in IN 19613 408 89 the the DT 19613 408 90 Old Old NNP 19613 408 91 Testament Testament NNP 19613 408 92 ; ; : 19613 408 93 the the DT 19613 408 94 reality reality NN 19613 408 95 of of IN 19613 408 96 that that DT 19613 408 97 history history NN 19613 408 98 ; ; : 19613 408 99 the the DT 19613 408 100 bodily bodily JJ 19613 408 101 reception reception NN 19613 408 102 ( ( -LRB- 19613 408 103 [ [ -LRB- 19613 408 104 Greek Greek NNP 19613 408 105 : : : 19613 408 106 ensarkos ensarkos NNP 19613 408 107 analêpsis analêpsis NN 19613 408 108 ] ] -RRB- 19613 408 109 ) ) -RRB- 19613 408 110 of of IN 19613 408 111 Christ Christ NNP 19613 408 112 into into IN 19613 408 113 heaven heaven NNP 19613 408 114 ; ; : 19613 408 115 the the DT 19613 408 116 visible visible JJ 19613 408 117 return return NN 19613 408 118 of of IN 19613 408 119 Christ Christ NNP 19613 408 120 ; ; : 19613 408 121 the the DT 19613 408 122 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 408 123 of of IN 19613 408 124 all all DT 19613 408 125 flesh flesh NN 19613 408 126 ( ( -LRB- 19613 408 127 [ [ -LRB- 19613 408 128 Greek Greek NNP 19613 408 129 : : : 19613 408 130 anastasis anastasis NNP 19613 408 131 pasês pasês NNP 19613 408 132 sarkos sarkos NNP 19613 408 133 , , , 19613 408 134 pasês pasês NNP 19613 408 135 anthropôtêtos anthropôtêtos NNP 19613 408 136 ] ] -RRB- 19613 408 137 ) ) -RRB- 19613 408 138 , , , 19613 408 139 the the DT 19613 408 140 universal universal JJ 19613 408 141 judgment judgment NN 19613 408 142 . . . 19613 409 1 These these DT 19613 409 2 dogmas dogmas NNP 19613 409 3 , , , 19613 409 4 the the DT 19613 409 5 antitheses antithesis NNS 19613 409 6 of of IN 19613 409 7 the the DT 19613 409 8 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 409 9 regulæ,[40 regulæ,[40 NNP 19613 409 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 409 11 were be VBD 19613 409 12 consequently consequently RB 19613 409 13 , , , 19613 409 14 as as IN 19613 409 15 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 409 16 and and CC 19613 409 17 therefore therefore RB 19613 409 18 also also RB 19613 409 19 as as IN 19613 409 20 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 409 21 , , , 19613 409 22 removed remove VBN 19613 409 23 beyond beyond IN 19613 409 24 all all DT 19613 409 25 discussion discussion NN 19613 409 26 . . . 19613 410 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 410 2 followed follow VBD 19613 410 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 410 4 in in IN 19613 410 5 every every DT 19613 410 6 particular particular NN 19613 410 7 . . . 19613 411 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 411 2 also also RB 19613 411 3 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 411 4 the the DT 19613 411 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 411 6 Romish romish JJ 19613 411 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 411 8 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 411 9 confession confession NN 19613 411 10 , , , 19613 411 11 represented represent VBD 19613 411 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 411 13 , , , 19613 411 14 thus thus RB 19613 411 15 explained explain VBD 19613 411 16 , , , 19613 411 17 as as IN 19613 411 18 the the DT 19613 411 19 _ _ NNP 19613 411 20 regula regula NN 19613 411 21 fidei_,[41 fidei_,[41 NFP 19613 411 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 411 23 and and CC 19613 411 24 transferred transfer VBN 19613 411 25 to to IN 19613 411 26 the the DT 19613 411 27 latter latter JJ 19613 411 28 the the DT 19613 411 29 attributes attribute NNS 19613 411 30 of of IN 19613 411 31 the the DT 19613 411 32 confession confession NN 19613 411 33 , , , 19613 411 34 viz viz NNP 19613 411 35 . . NNP 19613 411 36 , , , 19613 411 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 411 38 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 411 39 origin origin NN 19613 411 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 411 41 or or CC 19613 411 42 origin origin NN 19613 411 43 from from IN 19613 411 44 Christ Christ NNP 19613 411 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 411 46 , , , 19613 411 47 as as RB 19613 411 48 well well RB 19613 411 49 as as IN 19613 411 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 411 51 fixedness fixedness NN 19613 411 52 and and CC 19613 411 53 completeness completeness JJ 19613 411 54 . . . 19613 412 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 412 2 42 42 CD 19613 412 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 412 4 Like like IN 19613 412 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 412 6 , , , 19613 412 7 though though IN 19613 412 8 still still RB 19613 412 9 more more RBR 19613 412 10 stringently stringently RB 19613 412 11 , , , 19613 412 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 412 13 also also RB 19613 412 14 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 412 15 to to TO 19613 412 16 prove prove VB 19613 412 17 that that IN 19613 412 18 the the DT 19613 412 19 formula formula NN 19613 412 20 had have VBD 19613 412 21 descended descend VBN 19613 412 22 from from IN 19613 412 23 Christ Christ NNP 19613 412 24 , , , 19613 412 25 that that RB 19613 412 26 is is RB 19613 412 27 , , , 19613 412 28 from from IN 19613 412 29 the the DT 19613 412 30 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 412 31 , , , 19613 412 32 and and CC 19613 412 33 was be VBD 19613 412 34 incorrupt incorrupt JJ 19613 412 35 . . . 19613 413 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 413 2 based base VBD 19613 413 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 413 4 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 413 5 on on IN 19613 413 6 the the DT 19613 413 7 alleged allege VBN 19613 413 8 incontestable incontestable JJ 19613 413 9 facts fact NNS 19613 413 10 that that WDT 19613 413 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 413 12 contained contain VBD 19613 413 13 the the DT 19613 413 14 faith faith NN 19613 413 15 of of IN 19613 413 16 those those DT 19613 413 17 Churches church NNS 19613 413 18 founded found VBN 19613 413 19 by by IN 19613 413 20 the the DT 19613 413 21 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 413 22 , , , 19613 413 23 that that IN 19613 413 24 in in IN 19613 413 25 these these DT 19613 413 26 communities community NNS 19613 413 27 a a DT 19613 413 28 corruption corruption NN 19613 413 29 of of IN 19613 413 30 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 413 31 was be VBD 19613 413 32 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 19613 413 33 , , , 19613 413 34 because because IN 19613 413 35 in in IN 19613 413 36 them -PRON- PRP 19613 413 37 , , , 19613 413 38 as as IN 19613 413 39 could could MD 19613 413 40 be be VB 19613 413 41 proved prove VBN 19613 413 42 , , , 19613 413 43 the the DT 19613 413 44 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 413 45 had have VBD 19613 413 46 always always RB 19613 413 47 had have VBN 19613 413 48 successors successor NNS 19613 413 49 , , , 19613 413 50 and and CC 19613 413 51 that that IN 19613 413 52 the the DT 19613 413 53 other other JJ 19613 413 54 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 413 55 were be VBD 19613 413 56 in in IN 19613 413 57 communion communion NN 19613 413 58 with with IN 19613 413 59 them -PRON- PRP 19613 413 60 ( ( -LRB- 19613 413 61 see see VB 19613 413 62 under under IN 19613 413 63 C c NN 19613 413 64 ) ) -RRB- 19613 413 65 . . . 19613 414 1 In in IN 19613 414 2 a a DT 19613 414 3 more more RBR 19613 414 4 definite definite JJ 19613 414 5 way way NN 19613 414 6 than than IN 19613 414 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 414 8 , , , 19613 414 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 414 10 conceives conceive VBZ 19613 414 11 the the DT 19613 414 12 rule rule NN 19613 414 13 of of IN 19613 414 14 faith faith NN 19613 414 15 as as IN 19613 414 16 a a DT 19613 414 17 rule rule NN 19613 414 18 for for IN 19613 414 19 the the DT 19613 414 20 faith,[43 faith,[43 CD 19613 414 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 414 22 as as IN 19613 414 23 the the DT 19613 414 24 law law NN 19613 414 25 given give VBN 19613 414 26 to to IN 19613 414 27 faith,[44 faith,[44 CD 19613 414 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 414 29 also also RB 19613 414 30 as as IN 19613 414 31 a a DT 19613 414 32 " " `` 19613 414 33 regula regula JJ 19613 414 34 doctrinæ doctrinæ NN 19613 414 35 " " '' 19613 414 36 or or CC 19613 414 37 " " `` 19613 414 38 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 414 39 regulæ regulæ NN 19613 414 40 " " '' 19613 414 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 414 42 here here RB 19613 414 43 the the DT 19613 414 44 creed creed NN 19613 414 45 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 414 46 is be VBZ 19613 414 47 quite quite RB 19613 414 48 plainly plainly RB 19613 414 49 the the DT 19613 414 50 regula regula NN 19613 414 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 414 52 , , , 19613 414 53 and and CC 19613 414 54 even even RB 19613 414 55 simply simply RB 19613 414 56 as as IN 19613 414 57 " " `` 19613 414 58 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 414 59 " " '' 19613 414 60 or or CC 19613 414 61 " " `` 19613 414 62 institutio institutio NNP 19613 414 63 . . . 19613 415 1 " " `` 19613 415 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 415 3 45 45 CD 19613 415 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 415 5 As as IN 19613 415 6 to to IN 19613 415 7 the the DT 19613 415 8 content content NN 19613 415 9 of of IN 19613 415 10 the the DT 19613 415 11 _ _ NNP 19613 415 12 regula regula NN 19613 415 13 _ _ NNP 19613 415 14 , , , 19613 415 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 415 16 was be VBD 19613 415 17 set set VBN 19613 415 18 forth forth RP 19613 415 19 by by IN 19613 415 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 415 21 in in IN 19613 415 22 three three CD 19613 415 23 passages passage NNS 19613 415 24 . . . 19613 416 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 416 2 46 46 CD 19613 416 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 416 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 416 5 is be VBZ 19613 416 6 essentially essentially RB 19613 416 7 the the DT 19613 416 8 same same JJ 19613 416 9 as as IN 19613 416 10 in in IN 19613 416 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 416 12 . . . 19613 417 1 But but CC 19613 417 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 417 3 already already RB 19613 417 4 gives give VBZ 19613 417 5 prominence prominence NN 19613 417 6 within within IN 19613 417 7 the the DT 19613 417 8 _ _ NNP 19613 417 9 regula regula NN 19613 417 10 _ _ NNP 19613 417 11 to to IN 19613 417 12 the the DT 19613 417 13 creation creation NN 19613 417 14 of of IN 19613 417 15 the the DT 19613 417 16 universe universe NN 19613 417 17 out out IN 19613 417 18 of of IN 19613 417 19 nothing,[47 nothing,[47 RB 19613 417 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 417 21 the the DT 19613 417 22 creative creative JJ 19613 417 23 instrumentality instrumentality NN 19613 417 24 of of IN 19613 417 25 the the DT 19613 417 26 Logos,[48 Logos,[48 NNP 19613 417 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 417 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 417 29 origin origin NN 19613 417 30 before before IN 19613 417 31 all all DT 19613 417 32 creatures,[49 creatures,[49 CD 19613 417 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 417 34 a a DT 19613 417 35 definite definite JJ 19613 417 36 theory theory NN 19613 417 37 of of IN 19613 417 38 the the DT 19613 417 39 Incarnation,[50 incarnation,[50 XX 19613 417 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 417 41 the the DT 19613 417 42 preaching preaching NN 19613 417 43 by by IN 19613 417 44 Christ Christ NNP 19613 417 45 of of IN 19613 417 46 a a DT 19613 417 47 _ _ NNP 19613 417 48 nova nova NNP 19613 417 49 lex lex NNP 19613 417 50 _ _ NNP 19613 417 51 and and CC 19613 417 52 a a DT 19613 417 53 _ _ NNP 19613 417 54 nova nova NNP 19613 417 55 promissio promissio NNP 19613 417 56 regni regni NNP 19613 417 57 coelorum_,[51 coelorum_,[51 NNP 19613 417 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 417 59 and and CC 19613 417 60 finally finally RB 19613 417 61 also also RB 19613 417 62 the the DT 19613 417 63 Trinitarian trinitarian JJ 19613 417 64 economy economy NN 19613 417 65 of of IN 19613 417 66 God God NNP 19613 417 67 . . . 19613 418 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 418 2 52 52 CD 19613 418 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 418 4 Materially materially RB 19613 418 5 , , , 19613 418 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 418 7 , , , 19613 418 8 the the DT 19613 418 9 advance advance NN 19613 418 10 beyond beyond IN 19613 418 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 418 12 is be VBZ 19613 418 13 already already RB 19613 418 14 very very RB 19613 418 15 significant significant JJ 19613 418 16 . . . 19613 419 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 419 2 's 's POS 19613 419 3 _ _ NNP 19613 419 4 regula regula NN 19613 419 5 _ _ NNP 19613 419 6 is be VBZ 19613 419 7 in in IN 19613 419 8 point point NN 19613 419 9 of of IN 19613 419 10 fact fact NN 19613 419 11 a a DT 19613 419 12 _ _ NNP 19613 419 13 doctrina doctrina NN 19613 419 14 _ _ NNP 19613 419 15 . . . 19613 420 1 In in IN 19613 420 2 attempting attempt VBG 19613 420 3 to to TO 19613 420 4 bind bind VB 19613 420 5 the the DT 19613 420 6 communities community NNS 19613 420 7 to to IN 19613 420 8 this this DT 19613 420 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 420 10 represents represent VBZ 19613 420 11 them -PRON- PRP 19613 420 12 as as IN 19613 420 13 schools school NNS 19613 420 14 . . . 19613 421 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 421 2 53 53 CD 19613 421 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 421 4 The the DT 19613 421 5 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 421 6 " " `` 19613 421 7 lex lex NNP 19613 421 8 et et NNP 19613 421 9 doctrina doctrina NN 19613 421 10 " " '' 19613 421 11 is be VBZ 19613 421 12 to to TO 19613 421 13 be be VB 19613 421 14 regarded regard VBN 19613 421 15 as as IN 19613 421 16 inviolable inviolable JJ 19613 421 17 by by IN 19613 421 18 every every DT 19613 421 19 Christian Christian NNP 19613 421 20 . . . 19613 422 1 Assent assent NN 19613 422 2 to to IN 19613 422 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 422 4 decides decide VBZ 19613 422 5 the the DT 19613 422 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 422 7 character character NN 19613 422 8 of of IN 19613 422 9 the the DT 19613 422 10 individual individual NN 19613 422 11 . . . 19613 423 1 Thus thus RB 19613 423 2 the the DT 19613 423 3 Christian Christian NNP 19613 423 4 _ _ NNP 19613 423 5 disposition disposition NN 19613 423 6 and and CC 19613 423 7 life life NN 19613 423 8 _ _ NNP 19613 423 9 come come VB 19613 423 10 to to TO 19613 423 11 be be VB 19613 423 12 a a DT 19613 423 13 matter matter NN 19613 423 14 which which WDT 19613 423 15 is be VBZ 19613 423 16 separate separate JJ 19613 423 17 from from IN 19613 423 18 this this DT 19613 423 19 and and CC 19613 423 20 subject subject JJ 19613 423 21 to to IN 19613 423 22 particular particular JJ 19613 423 23 conditions condition NNS 19613 423 24 . . . 19613 424 1 In in IN 19613 424 2 this this DT 19613 424 3 way way NN 19613 424 4 the the DT 19613 424 5 essence essence NN 19613 424 6 of of IN 19613 424 7 religion religion NN 19613 424 8 was be VBD 19613 424 9 split split VBN 19613 424 10 up up RP 19613 424 11 -- -- : 19613 424 12 the the DT 19613 424 13 most most RBS 19613 424 14 fatal fatal JJ 19613 424 15 turning turning NN 19613 424 16 - - HYPH 19613 424 17 point point NN 19613 424 18 in in IN 19613 424 19 the the DT 19613 424 20 history history NN 19613 424 21 of of IN 19613 424 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 424 23 . . . 19613 425 1 But but CC 19613 425 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 425 3 are be VBP 19613 425 4 not not RB 19613 425 5 of of RB 19613 425 6 course course NN 19613 425 7 to to TO 19613 425 8 suppose suppose VB 19613 425 9 that that IN 19613 425 10 at at IN 19613 425 11 the the DT 19613 425 12 beginning beginning NN 19613 425 13 of of IN 19613 425 14 the the DT 19613 425 15 third third JJ 19613 425 16 century century NN 19613 425 17 the the DT 19613 425 18 actual actual JJ 19613 425 19 bond bond NN 19613 425 20 of of IN 19613 425 21 union union NN 19613 425 22 between between IN 19613 425 23 all all PDT 19613 425 24 the the DT 19613 425 25 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 425 26 was be VBD 19613 425 27 a a DT 19613 425 28 fixed fix VBN 19613 425 29 confession confession NN 19613 425 30 developed develop VBD 19613 425 31 into into IN 19613 425 32 a a DT 19613 425 33 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 425 34 , , , 19613 425 35 that that RB 19613 425 36 is is RB 19613 425 37 , , , 19613 425 38 definitely definitely RB 19613 425 39 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 425 40 . . . 19613 426 1 This this DT 19613 426 2 much much JJ 19613 426 3 was be VBD 19613 426 4 gained gain VBN 19613 426 5 , , , 19613 426 6 as as IN 19613 426 7 is be VBZ 19613 426 8 clear clear JJ 19613 426 9 from from IN 19613 426 10 the the DT 19613 426 11 treatise treatise NN 19613 426 12 _ _ NNP 19613 426 13 de de IN 19613 426 14 præscriptione præscriptione NNP 19613 426 15 _ _ NNP 19613 426 16 and and CC 19613 426 17 from from IN 19613 426 18 other other JJ 19613 426 19 evidence evidence NN 19613 426 20 , , , 19613 426 21 that that IN 19613 426 22 in in IN 19613 426 23 the the DT 19613 426 24 communities community NNS 19613 426 25 with with IN 19613 426 26 which which WDT 19613 426 27 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 426 28 was be VBD 19613 426 29 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 426 30 , , , 19613 426 31 mutual mutual JJ 19613 426 32 recognition recognition NN 19613 426 33 and and CC 19613 426 34 brotherly brotherly JJ 19613 426 35 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 426 36 were be VBD 19613 426 37 made make VBN 19613 426 38 to to TO 19613 426 39 depend depend VB 19613 426 40 on on IN 19613 426 41 assent assent NN 19613 426 42 to to TO 19613 426 43 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 426 44 which which WDT 19613 426 45 virtually virtually RB 19613 426 46 coincided coincide VBD 19613 426 47 with with IN 19613 426 48 the the DT 19613 426 49 Roman roman JJ 19613 426 50 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 426 51 confession confession NN 19613 426 52 . . . 19613 427 1 Whoever whoever WP 19613 427 2 assented assent VBD 19613 427 3 to to IN 19613 427 4 such such PDT 19613 427 5 a a DT 19613 427 6 formula formula NN 19613 427 7 was be VBD 19613 427 8 regarded regard VBN 19613 427 9 as as IN 19613 427 10 a a DT 19613 427 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 427 12 brother brother NN 19613 427 13 , , , 19613 427 14 and and CC 19613 427 15 was be VBD 19613 427 16 entitled entitle VBN 19613 427 17 to to IN 19613 427 18 the the DT 19613 427 19 salutation salutation NN 19613 427 20 of of IN 19613 427 21 peace peace NN 19613 427 22 , , , 19613 427 23 the the DT 19613 427 24 name name NN 19613 427 25 of of IN 19613 427 26 brother brother NN 19613 427 27 , , , 19613 427 28 and and CC 19613 427 29 hospitality hospitality NN 19613 427 30 . . . 19613 428 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 428 2 54 54 CD 19613 428 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 428 4 In in IN 19613 428 5 so so RB 19613 428 6 far far RB 19613 428 7 as as IN 19613 428 8 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 428 9 confined confine VBD 19613 428 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 428 11 to to IN 19613 428 12 a a DT 19613 428 13 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 428 14 formula formula NN 19613 428 15 which which WDT 19613 428 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 428 17 , , , 19613 428 18 however however RB 19613 428 19 , , , 19613 428 20 strictly strictly RB 19613 428 21 applied apply VBN 19613 428 22 , , , 19613 428 23 the the DT 19613 428 24 adoption adoption NN 19613 428 25 of of IN 19613 428 26 this this DT 19613 428 27 practice practice NN 19613 428 28 betokened betoken VBD 19613 428 29 an an DT 19613 428 30 advance advance NN 19613 428 31 . . . 19613 429 1 The the DT 19613 429 2 scattered scatter VBN 19613 429 3 communities community NNS 19613 429 4 now now RB 19613 429 5 possessed possess VBD 19613 429 6 a a DT 19613 429 7 " " `` 19613 429 8 lex lex NN 19613 429 9 " " '' 19613 429 10 to to TO 19613 429 11 bind bind VB 19613 429 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 429 13 together together RB 19613 429 14 , , , 19613 429 15 quite quite RB 19613 429 16 as as RB 19613 429 17 certainly certainly RB 19613 429 18 as as IN 19613 429 19 the the DT 19613 429 20 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 429 21 schools school NNS 19613 429 22 possessed possess VBD 19613 429 23 a a DT 19613 429 24 bond bond NN 19613 429 25 of of IN 19613 429 26 union union NN 19613 429 27 of of IN 19613 429 28 a a DT 19613 429 29 real real JJ 19613 429 30 and and CC 19613 429 31 practical practical JJ 19613 429 32 character[55 character[55 NN 19613 429 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 429 34 in in IN 19613 429 35 the the DT 19613 429 36 shape shape NN 19613 429 37 of of IN 19613 429 38 certain certain JJ 19613 429 39 briefly briefly NN 19613 429 40 formulated formulate VBN 19613 429 41 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 429 42 . . . 19613 430 1 In in IN 19613 430 2 virtue virtue NN 19613 430 3 of of IN 19613 430 4 the the DT 19613 430 5 common common JJ 19613 430 6 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 430 7 _ _ NNP 19613 430 8 lex lex NN 19613 430 9 _ _ NNP 19613 430 10 of of IN 19613 430 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 430 12 the the DT 19613 430 13 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 430 14 Church Church NNP 19613 430 15 became become VBD 19613 430 16 a a DT 19613 430 17 reality reality NN 19613 430 18 , , , 19613 430 19 and and CC 19613 430 20 was be VBD 19613 430 21 at at IN 19613 430 22 the the DT 19613 430 23 same same JJ 19613 430 24 time time NN 19613 430 25 clearly clearly RB 19613 430 26 marked mark VBN 19613 430 27 off off RP 19613 430 28 from from IN 19613 430 29 the the DT 19613 430 30 heretic heretic JJ 19613 430 31 sects sect NNS 19613 430 32 . . . 19613 431 1 But but CC 19613 431 2 more more JJR 19613 431 3 than than IN 19613 431 4 this this DT 19613 431 5 was be VBD 19613 431 6 gained gain VBN 19613 431 7 , , , 19613 431 8 in in RB 19613 431 9 so so RB 19613 431 10 far far RB 19613 431 11 as as IN 19613 431 12 the the DT 19613 431 13 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 431 14 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 431 15 of of IN 19613 431 16 the the DT 19613 431 17 formula formula NN 19613 431 18 , , , 19613 431 19 and and CC 19613 431 20 consequently consequently RB 19613 431 21 a a DT 19613 431 22 " " `` 19613 431 23 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 431 24 , , , 19613 431 25 " " '' 19613 431 26 was be VBD 19613 431 27 indeed indeed RB 19613 431 28 in in IN 19613 431 29 some some DT 19613 431 30 measure measure NN 19613 431 31 involved involve VBN 19613 431 32 in in IN 19613 431 33 the the DT 19613 431 34 _ _ NNP 19613 431 35 lex lex NN 19613 431 36 _ _ NNP 19613 431 37 . . . 19613 432 1 The the DT 19613 432 2 extent extent NN 19613 432 3 to to TO 19613 432 4 which which WDT 19613 432 5 this this DT 19613 432 6 was be VBD 19613 432 7 the the DT 19613 432 8 case case NN 19613 432 9 depended depend VBD 19613 432 10 , , , 19613 432 11 of of IN 19613 432 12 course course NN 19613 432 13 , , , 19613 432 14 on on IN 19613 432 15 the the DT 19613 432 16 individual individual JJ 19613 432 17 community community NN 19613 432 18 or or CC 19613 432 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 432 20 leaders leader NNS 19613 432 21 . . . 19613 433 1 All all DT 19613 433 2 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 433 3 could could MD 19613 433 4 not not RB 19613 433 5 be be VB 19613 433 6 excluded exclude VBN 19613 433 7 by by IN 19613 433 8 the the DT 19613 433 9 wording wording NN 19613 433 10 of of IN 19613 433 11 the the DT 19613 433 12 confession confession NN 19613 433 13 ; ; : 19613 433 14 and and CC 19613 433 15 , , , 19613 433 16 on on IN 19613 433 17 the the DT 19613 433 18 other other JJ 19613 433 19 hand hand NN 19613 433 20 , , , 19613 433 21 every every DT 19613 433 22 formulated formulate VBN 19613 433 23 faith faith NN 19613 433 24 leads lead VBZ 19613 433 25 to to IN 19613 433 26 a a DT 19613 433 27 formulated formulate VBN 19613 433 28 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 433 29 , , , 19613 433 30 as as RB 19613 433 31 soon soon RB 19613 433 32 as as IN 19613 433 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 433 34 is be VBZ 19613 433 35 set set VBN 19613 433 36 up up RP 19613 433 37 as as IN 19613 433 38 a a DT 19613 433 39 critical critical JJ 19613 433 40 canon canon NN 19613 433 41 . . . 19613 434 1 What what WP 19613 434 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 434 3 observe observe VBP 19613 434 4 in in IN 19613 434 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 434 6 and and CC 19613 434 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 434 8 must must MD 19613 434 9 have have VB 19613 434 10 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 434 11 taken take VBN 19613 434 12 place place NN 19613 434 13 in in IN 19613 434 14 a a DT 19613 434 15 greater great JJR 19613 434 16 or or CC 19613 434 17 less less JJR 19613 434 18 degree degree NN 19613 434 19 ; ; : 19613 434 20 that that DT 19613 434 21 is be VBZ 19613 434 22 to to TO 19613 434 23 say say VB 19613 434 24 , , , 19613 434 25 the the DT 19613 434 26 authority authority NN 19613 434 27 of of IN 19613 434 28 the the DT 19613 434 29 confessional confessional JJ 19613 434 30 formula formula NN 19613 434 31 must must MD 19613 434 32 have have VB 19613 434 33 been be VBN 19613 434 34 extended extend VBN 19613 434 35 to to IN 19613 434 36 statements statement NNS 19613 434 37 not not RB 19613 434 38 found find VBN 19613 434 39 in in IN 19613 434 40 the the DT 19613 434 41 formula formula NN 19613 434 42 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 434 43 . . . 19613 435 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 435 2 can can MD 19613 435 3 still still RB 19613 435 4 prove prove VB 19613 435 5 from from IN 19613 435 6 the the DT 19613 435 7 works work NNS 19613 435 8 of of IN 19613 435 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 435 10 of of IN 19613 435 11 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 435 12 that that IN 19613 435 13 a a DT 19613 435 14 confession confession NN 19613 435 15 claiming claim VBG 19613 435 16 to to TO 19613 435 17 be be VB 19613 435 18 an an DT 19613 435 19 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 435 20 law law NN 19613 435 21 of of IN 19613 435 22 faith,[56 faith,[56 NNP 19613 435 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 435 24 ostensibly ostensibly RB 19613 435 25 comprehending comprehend VBG 19613 435 26 the the DT 19613 435 27 whole whole JJ 19613 435 28 essence essence NN 19613 435 29 of of IN 19613 435 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 435 31 , , , 19613 435 32 was be VBD 19613 435 33 not not RB 19613 435 34 set set VBN 19613 435 35 up up RP 19613 435 36 in in IN 19613 435 37 the the DT 19613 435 38 different different JJ 19613 435 39 provincial provincial JJ 19613 435 40 Churches church NNS 19613 435 41 at at IN 19613 435 42 one one CD 19613 435 43 and and CC 19613 435 44 the the DT 19613 435 45 same same JJ 19613 435 46 time time NN 19613 435 47 . . . 19613 436 1 From from IN 19613 436 2 this this DT 19613 436 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 436 4 is be VBZ 19613 436 5 clearly clearly RB 19613 436 6 manifest manifest JJ 19613 436 7 that that IN 19613 436 8 at at IN 19613 436 9 this this DT 19613 436 10 period period NN 19613 436 11 the the DT 19613 436 12 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 436 13 Church Church NNP 19613 436 14 neither neither CC 19613 436 15 possessed possess VBD 19613 436 16 a a DT 19613 436 17 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 436 18 confession confession NN 19613 436 19 similar similar JJ 19613 436 20 to to IN 19613 436 21 that that DT 19613 436 22 of of IN 19613 436 23 Rome,[57 Rome,[57 NNP 19613 436 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 436 25 nor nor CC 19613 436 26 understood understand VBN 19613 436 27 by by IN 19613 436 28 " " `` 19613 436 29 regula regula NNP 19613 436 30 fidei fidei NN 19613 436 31 " " '' 19613 436 32 and and CC 19613 436 33 synonymous synonymous JJ 19613 436 34 expressions expression NNS 19613 436 35 a a DT 19613 436 36 collection collection NN 19613 436 37 of of IN 19613 436 38 beliefs belief NNS 19613 436 39 fixed fix VBN 19613 436 40 in in IN 19613 436 41 some some DT 19613 436 42 fashion fashion NN 19613 436 43 and and CC 19613 436 44 derived derive VBN 19613 436 45 from from IN 19613 436 46 the the DT 19613 436 47 apostles apostle NNS 19613 436 48 . . . 19613 437 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 437 2 58 58 CD 19613 437 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 437 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 437 5 of of IN 19613 437 6 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 437 7 in in IN 19613 437 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 437 9 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 437 10 appeals appeal NNS 19613 437 11 to to IN 19613 437 12 the the DT 19613 437 13 holy holy JJ 19613 437 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 437 15 divine divine JJ 19613 437 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 437 17 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 437 18 , , , 19613 437 19 to to IN 19613 437 20 the the DT 19613 437 21 teaching teaching NN 19613 437 22 of of IN 19613 437 23 the the DT 19613 437 24 Lord,[59 Lord,[59 NNP 19613 437 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 437 26 and and CC 19613 437 27 to to IN 19613 437 28 the the DT 19613 437 29 standard standard JJ 19613 437 30 tradition tradition NN 19613 437 31 which which WDT 19613 437 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 437 33 designates designate VBZ 19613 437 34 by by IN 19613 437 35 a a DT 19613 437 36 great great JJ 19613 437 37 variety variety NN 19613 437 38 of of IN 19613 437 39 names name NNS 19613 437 40 , , , 19613 437 41 though though IN 19613 437 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 437 43 never never RB 19613 437 44 gives give VBZ 19613 437 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 437 46 content content NN 19613 437 47 , , , 19613 437 48 because because IN 19613 437 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 437 50 regards regard VBZ 19613 437 51 the the DT 19613 437 52 whole whole NN 19613 437 53 of of IN 19613 437 54 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 437 55 in in IN 19613 437 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 437 57 present present JJ 19613 437 58 condition condition NN 19613 437 59 as as IN 19613 437 60 needing need VBG 19613 437 61 to to TO 19613 437 62 be be VB 19613 437 63 reconstructed reconstruct VBN 19613 437 64 by by IN 19613 437 65 gnosis gnosis NN 19613 437 66 , , , 19613 437 67 and and CC 19613 437 68 therefore therefore RB 19613 437 69 as as IN 19613 437 70 coming come VBG 19613 437 71 under under IN 19613 437 72 the the DT 19613 437 73 head head NN 19613 437 74 of of IN 19613 437 75 tradition tradition NN 19613 437 76 . . . 19613 438 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 438 2 60 60 CD 19613 438 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 438 4 In in IN 19613 438 5 one one CD 19613 438 6 respect respect NN 19613 438 7 therefore therefore RB 19613 438 8 , , , 19613 438 9 as as IN 19613 438 10 compared compare VBN 19613 438 11 with with IN 19613 438 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 438 13 and and CC 19613 438 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 438 15 , , , 19613 438 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 438 17 to to IN 19613 438 18 some some DT 19613 438 19 extent extent NN 19613 438 20 represents represent VBZ 19613 438 21 an an DT 19613 438 22 earlier early JJR 19613 438 23 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 438 24 ; ; : 19613 438 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 438 26 stands stand VBZ 19613 438 27 midway midway RB 19613 438 28 between between IN 19613 438 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 438 30 and and CC 19613 438 31 Justin Justin NNP 19613 438 32 . . . 19613 439 1 From from IN 19613 439 2 this this DT 19613 439 3 author author NN 19613 439 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 439 5 is be VBZ 19613 439 6 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 439 7 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 439 8 by by IN 19613 439 9 the the DT 19613 439 10 fact fact NN 19613 439 11 that that IN 19613 439 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 439 13 employs employ VBZ 19613 439 14 sacred sacred JJ 19613 439 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 439 16 writings writing NNS 19613 439 17 as as RB 19613 439 18 well well RB 19613 439 19 as as IN 19613 439 20 the the DT 19613 439 21 Old Old NNP 19613 439 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 439 23 , , , 19613 439 24 makes make VBZ 19613 439 25 the the DT 19613 439 26 true true JJ 19613 439 27 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 439 28 quite quite RB 19613 439 29 as as IN 19613 439 30 dependent dependent JJ 19613 439 31 on on IN 19613 439 32 the the DT 19613 439 33 former former JJ 19613 439 34 as as IN 19613 439 35 on on IN 19613 439 36 the the DT 19613 439 37 latter latter JJ 19613 439 38 and and CC 19613 439 39 has have VBZ 19613 439 40 lost lose VBN 19613 439 41 that that DT 19613 439 42 naive naive JJ 19613 439 43 view view NN 19613 439 44 of of IN 19613 439 45 tradition tradition NN 19613 439 46 , , , 19613 439 47 that that RB 19613 439 48 is is RB 19613 439 49 , , , 19613 439 50 the the DT 19613 439 51 complete complete JJ 19613 439 52 content content NN 19613 439 53 of of IN 19613 439 54 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 439 55 , , , 19613 439 56 which which WDT 19613 439 57 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 439 58 and and CC 19613 439 59 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 439 60 still still RB 19613 439 61 had have VBD 19613 439 62 . . . 19613 440 1 As as IN 19613 440 2 is be VBZ 19613 440 3 to to TO 19613 440 4 be be VB 19613 440 5 expected expect VBN 19613 440 6 , , , 19613 440 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 440 8 too too RB 19613 440 9 assigns assign VBZ 19613 440 10 the the DT 19613 440 11 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 440 12 authorship authorship NN 19613 440 13 of of IN 19613 440 14 the the DT 19613 440 15 tradition tradition NN 19613 440 16 to to IN 19613 440 17 the the DT 19613 440 18 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 440 19 ; ; : 19613 440 20 but but CC 19613 440 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 440 22 is be VBZ 19613 440 23 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 440 24 that that IN 19613 440 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 440 26 neither neither CC 19613 440 27 does do VBZ 19613 440 28 this this DT 19613 440 29 of of IN 19613 440 30 such such JJ 19613 440 31 set set JJ 19613 440 32 purpose purpose NN 19613 440 33 as as IN 19613 440 34 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 440 35 and and CC 19613 440 36 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 440 37 , , , 19613 440 38 nor nor CC 19613 440 39 thinks think VBZ 19613 440 40 it -PRON- PRP 19613 440 41 necessary necessary JJ 19613 440 42 to to TO 19613 440 43 prove prove VB 19613 440 44 that that IN 19613 440 45 the the DT 19613 440 46 Church Church NNP 19613 440 47 had have VBD 19613 440 48 presented present VBN 19613 440 49 the the DT 19613 440 50 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 440 51 tradition tradition NN 19613 440 52 intact intact JJ 19613 440 53 . . . 19613 441 1 But but CC 19613 441 2 as as IN 19613 441 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 441 4 did do VBD 19613 441 5 not not RB 19613 441 6 extract extract VB 19613 441 7 from from IN 19613 441 8 the the DT 19613 441 9 tradition tradition NN 19613 441 10 a a DT 19613 441 11 fixed fix VBN 19613 441 12 complex complex NN 19613 441 13 of of IN 19613 441 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 441 15 propositions proposition NNS 19613 441 16 , , , 19613 441 17 so so RB 19613 441 18 also also RB 19613 441 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 441 20 failed fail VBD 19613 441 21 to to TO 19613 441 22 recognise recognise VB 19613 441 23 the the DT 19613 441 24 importance importance NN 19613 441 25 of of IN 19613 441 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 441 27 publicity publicity NN 19613 441 28 and and CC 19613 441 29 catholicity catholicity NN 19613 441 30 , , , 19613 441 31 and and CC 19613 441 32 rather rather RB 19613 441 33 placed place VBD 19613 441 34 an an DT 19613 441 35 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 441 36 alongside alongside IN 19613 441 37 of of IN 19613 441 38 an an DT 19613 441 39 exoteric exoteric JJ 19613 441 40 tradition tradition NN 19613 441 41 . . . 19613 442 1 Although although IN 19613 442 2 , , , 19613 442 3 like like IN 19613 442 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 442 5 and and CC 19613 442 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 442 7 , , , 19613 442 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 442 9 attitude attitude NN 19613 442 10 is be VBZ 19613 442 11 throughout throughout RB 19613 442 12 determined determine VBN 19613 442 13 by by IN 19613 442 14 opposition opposition NN 19613 442 15 to to IN 19613 442 16 the the DT 19613 442 17 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 442 18 and and CC 19613 442 19 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 442 20 , , , 19613 442 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 442 22 supposes suppose VBZ 19613 442 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 442 24 possible possible JJ 19613 442 25 to to TO 19613 442 26 refute refute VB 19613 442 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 442 28 by by IN 19613 442 29 giving give VBG 19613 442 30 to to IN 19613 442 31 the the DT 19613 442 32 Holy Holy NNP 19613 442 33 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 442 34 a a DT 19613 442 35 scientific scientific JJ 19613 442 36 exposition exposition NN 19613 442 37 which which WDT 19613 442 38 must must MD 19613 442 39 not not RB 19613 442 40 oppose oppose VB 19613 442 41 the the DT 19613 442 42 [ [ -LRB- 19613 442 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 442 44 : : : 19613 442 45 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 442 46 tês tês NNP 19613 442 47 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 442 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 442 49 , , , 19613 442 50 that that RB 19613 442 51 is is RB 19613 442 52 , , , 19613 442 53 the the DT 19613 442 54 Christian christian JJ 19613 442 55 common common JJ 19613 442 56 sense sense NN 19613 442 57 , , , 19613 442 58 but but CC 19613 442 59 receives receive VBZ 19613 442 60 from from IN 19613 442 61 it -PRON- PRP 19613 442 62 only only RB 19613 442 63 certain certain JJ 19613 442 64 guiding guide VBG 19613 442 65 rules rule NNS 19613 442 66 . . . 19613 443 1 But but CC 19613 443 2 this this DT 19613 443 3 attitude attitude NN 19613 443 4 of of IN 19613 443 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 443 6 would would MD 19613 443 7 be be VB 19613 443 8 simply simply RB 19613 443 9 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 19613 443 10 if if IN 19613 443 11 the the DT 19613 443 12 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 443 13 Church Church NNP 19613 443 14 of of IN 19613 443 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 443 16 time time NN 19613 443 17 had have VBD 19613 443 18 already already RB 19613 443 19 employed employ VBN 19613 443 20 the the DT 19613 443 21 fixed fix VBN 19613 443 22 standard standard NN 19613 443 23 applied apply VBN 19613 443 24 in in IN 19613 443 25 those those DT 19613 443 26 of of IN 19613 443 27 Rome Rome NNP 19613 443 28 , , , 19613 443 29 Carthage Carthage NNP 19613 443 30 and and CC 19613 443 31 Lyons Lyons NNP 19613 443 32 . . . 19613 444 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 444 2 61 61 CD 19613 444 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 444 4 Such such PDT 19613 444 5 a a DT 19613 444 6 standard standard NN 19613 444 7 did do VBD 19613 444 8 not not RB 19613 444 9 exist exist VB 19613 444 10 ; ; : 19613 444 11 but but CC 19613 444 12 Clement Clement NNP 19613 444 13 made make VBD 19613 444 14 no no DT 19613 444 15 distinction distinction NN 19613 444 16 in in IN 19613 444 17 the the DT 19613 444 18 yet yet RB 19613 444 19 unsystematised unsystematised JJ 19613 444 20 tradition tradition NN 19613 444 21 , , , 19613 444 22 even even RB 19613 444 23 between between IN 19613 444 24 faith faith NN 19613 444 25 and and CC 19613 444 26 discipline discipline NN 19613 444 27 , , , 19613 444 28 because because IN 19613 444 29 as as IN 19613 444 30 a a DT 19613 444 31 theologian theologian NN 19613 444 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 444 33 was be VBD 19613 444 34 not not RB 19613 444 35 able able JJ 19613 444 36 to to TO 19613 444 37 identify identify VB 19613 444 38 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 444 39 with with IN 19613 444 40 any any DT 19613 444 41 single single JJ 19613 444 42 article article NN 19613 444 43 of of IN 19613 444 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 444 45 without without IN 19613 444 46 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 444 47 , , , 19613 444 48 and and CC 19613 444 49 because because IN 19613 444 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 444 51 ascribed ascribe VBD 19613 444 52 to to IN 19613 444 53 the the DT 19613 444 54 true true JJ 19613 444 55 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 444 56 the the DT 19613 444 57 ability ability NN 19613 444 58 to to TO 19613 444 59 fix fix VB 19613 444 60 and and CC 19613 444 61 guarantee guarantee VB 19613 444 62 the the DT 19613 444 63 truth truth NN 19613 444 64 of of IN 19613 444 65 Christian christian JJ 19613 444 66 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 444 67 . . . 19613 445 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 445 2 , , , 19613 445 3 although although IN 19613 445 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 445 5 also also RB 19613 445 6 attempted attempt VBD 19613 445 7 to to TO 19613 445 8 refute refute VB 19613 445 9 the the DT 19613 445 10 heretics heretic NNS 19613 445 11 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 445 12 by by IN 19613 445 13 a a DT 19613 445 14 scientific scientific JJ 19613 445 15 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 445 16 of of IN 19613 445 17 the the DT 19613 445 18 Holy Holy NNP 19613 445 19 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 445 20 , , , 19613 445 21 exhibits exhibit VBZ 19613 445 22 an an DT 19613 445 23 attitude attitude NN 19613 445 24 which which WDT 19613 445 25 is be VBZ 19613 445 26 already already RB 19613 445 27 more more RBR 19613 445 28 akin akin JJ 19613 445 29 to to IN 19613 445 30 that that DT 19613 445 31 of of IN 19613 445 32 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 445 33 and and CC 19613 445 34 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 445 35 than than IN 19613 445 36 to to IN 19613 445 37 that that DT 19613 445 38 of of IN 19613 445 39 Clement Clement NNP 19613 445 40 . . . 19613 446 1 In in IN 19613 446 2 the the DT 19613 446 3 preface preface NN 19613 446 4 to to IN 19613 446 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 446 6 great great JJ 19613 446 7 work work NN 19613 446 8 , , , 19613 446 9 " " '' 19613 446 10 De De NNP 19613 446 11 principiis principiis VB 19613 446 12 , , , 19613 446 13 " " '' 19613 446 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 446 15 prefixed prefix VBD 19613 446 16 the the DT 19613 446 17 Church Church NNP 19613 446 18 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 446 19 as as IN 19613 446 20 a a DT 19613 446 21 detailed detailed JJ 19613 446 22 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 446 23 rule rule NN 19613 446 24 of of IN 19613 446 25 faith faith NN 19613 446 26 , , , 19613 446 27 and and CC 19613 446 28 in in IN 19613 446 29 other other JJ 19613 446 30 instances instance NNS 19613 446 31 also also RB 19613 446 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 446 33 appealed appeal VBD 19613 446 34 to to IN 19613 446 35 the the DT 19613 446 36 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 446 37 teaching teaching NN 19613 446 38 . . . 19613 447 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 447 2 62 62 CD 19613 447 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 447 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 447 5 may may MD 19613 447 6 be be VB 19613 447 7 assumed assume VBN 19613 447 8 that that IN 19613 447 9 in in IN 19613 447 10 the the DT 19613 447 11 time time NN 19613 447 12 of of IN 19613 447 13 Caracalla Caracalla NNP 19613 447 14 and and CC 19613 447 15 Heliogabalus Heliogabalus NNP 19613 447 16 the the DT 19613 447 17 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 447 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 447 19 had have VBD 19613 447 20 also also RB 19613 447 21 begun begin VBN 19613 447 22 to to TO 19613 447 23 adopt adopt VB 19613 447 24 the the DT 19613 447 25 principles principle NNS 19613 447 26 acted act VBN 19613 447 27 upon upon IN 19613 447 28 in in IN 19613 447 29 Rome Rome NNP 19613 447 30 and and CC 19613 447 31 other other JJ 19613 447 32 communities community NNS 19613 447 33 . . . 19613 448 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 448 2 63 63 CD 19613 448 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 448 4 The the DT 19613 448 5 Syrian syrian JJ 19613 448 6 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 448 7 , , , 19613 448 8 or or CC 19613 448 9 at at IN 19613 448 10 least least JJS 19613 448 11 a a DT 19613 448 12 part part NN 19613 448 13 of of IN 19613 448 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 448 15 , , , 19613 448 16 followed follow VBD 19613 448 17 still still RB 19613 448 18 later later RB 19613 448 19 . . . 19613 449 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 449 2 64 64 CD 19613 449 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 449 4 There there EX 19613 449 5 can can MD 19613 449 6 be be VB 19613 449 7 no no DT 19613 449 8 doubt doubt NN 19613 449 9 that that IN 19613 449 10 , , , 19613 449 11 from from IN 19613 449 12 the the DT 19613 449 13 last last JJ 19613 449 14 decades decade NNS 19613 449 15 of of IN 19613 449 16 the the DT 19613 449 17 third third JJ 19613 449 18 century century NN 19613 449 19 onward onward RB 19613 449 20 , , , 19613 449 21 one one CD 19613 449 22 and and CC 19613 449 23 the the DT 19613 449 24 same same JJ 19613 449 25 confession confession NN 19613 449 26 , , , 19613 449 27 identical identical JJ 19613 449 28 not not RB 19613 449 29 in in IN 19613 449 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 449 31 wording wording NN 19613 449 32 , , , 19613 449 33 but but CC 19613 449 34 in in IN 19613 449 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 449 36 main main JJ 19613 449 37 features feature NNS 19613 449 38 , , , 19613 449 39 prevailed prevail VBD 19613 449 40 in in IN 19613 449 41 the the DT 19613 449 42 great great JJ 19613 449 43 confederation confederation NN 19613 449 44 of of IN 19613 449 45 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 449 46 extending extend VBG 19613 449 47 from from IN 19613 449 48 Spain Spain NNP 19613 449 49 to to IN 19613 449 50 the the DT 19613 449 51 Euphrates Euphrates NNP 19613 449 52 and and CC 19613 449 53 from from IN 19613 449 54 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 449 55 to to IN 19613 449 56 beyond beyond IN 19613 449 57 the the DT 19613 449 58 Alps Alps NNPS 19613 449 59 . . . 19613 450 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 450 2 65 65 CD 19613 450 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 450 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 450 5 was be VBD 19613 450 6 the the DT 19613 450 7 basis basis NN 19613 450 8 of of IN 19613 450 9 the the DT 19613 450 10 confederation confederation NN 19613 450 11 , , , 19613 450 12 and and CC 19613 450 13 therefore therefore RB 19613 450 14 also also RB 19613 450 15 a a DT 19613 450 16 passport passport NN 19613 450 17 , , , 19613 450 18 mark mark NN 19613 450 19 of of IN 19613 450 20 recognition recognition NNP 19613 450 21 , , , 19613 450 22 etc etc FW 19613 450 23 . . FW 19613 450 24 , , , 19613 450 25 for for IN 19613 450 26 the the DT 19613 450 27 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 450 28 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 450 29 . . . 19613 451 1 The the DT 19613 451 2 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 451 3 of of IN 19613 451 4 this this DT 19613 451 5 confession confession NN 19613 451 6 was be VBD 19613 451 7 fixed fix VBN 19613 451 8 in in IN 19613 451 9 certain certain JJ 19613 451 10 ground ground NN 19613 451 11 features feature NNS 19613 451 12 , , , 19613 451 13 that that RB 19613 451 14 is is RB 19613 451 15 , , , 19613 451 16 in in IN 19613 451 17 an an DT 19613 451 18 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 451 19 sense sense NN 19613 451 20 . . . 19613 452 1 But but CC 19613 452 2 a a DT 19613 452 3 definite definite JJ 19613 452 4 theological theological JJ 19613 452 5 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 452 6 was be VBD 19613 452 7 also also RB 19613 452 8 more more RBR 19613 452 9 and and CC 19613 452 10 more more RBR 19613 452 11 enforced enforced JJ 19613 452 12 . . . 19613 453 1 By by IN 19613 453 2 the the DT 19613 453 3 end end NN 19613 453 4 of of IN 19613 453 5 the the DT 19613 453 6 third third JJ 19613 453 7 century century NN 19613 453 8 there there EX 19613 453 9 can can MD 19613 453 10 no no RB 19613 453 11 longer longer RB 19613 453 12 have have VB 19613 453 13 been be VBN 19613 453 14 any any DT 19613 453 15 considerable considerable JJ 19613 453 16 number number NN 19613 453 17 of of IN 19613 453 18 outlying outlying JJ 19613 453 19 communities community NNS 19613 453 20 where where WRB 19613 453 21 the the DT 19613 453 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 453 23 of of IN 19613 453 24 the the DT 19613 453 25 pre pre NN 19613 453 26 - - NN 19613 453 27 existence existence NN 19613 453 28 of of IN 19613 453 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 453 30 and and CC 19613 453 31 the the DT 19613 453 32 identity identity NN 19613 453 33 of of IN 19613 453 34 this this DT 19613 453 35 pre pre JJ 19613 453 36 - - JJ 19613 453 37 existent existent NN 19613 453 38 One one CD 19613 453 39 with with IN 19613 453 40 the the DT 19613 453 41 divine divine JJ 19613 453 42 Logos Logos NNP 19613 453 43 were be VBD 19613 453 44 not not RB 19613 453 45 recognised recognise VBN 19613 453 46 as as IN 19613 453 47 the the DT 19613 453 48 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 453 49 belief belief NN 19613 453 50 . . . 19613 454 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 454 2 66 66 CD 19613 454 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 454 4 They -PRON- PRP 19613 454 5 may may MD 19613 454 6 have have VB 19613 454 7 first first RB 19613 454 8 become become VBN 19613 454 9 an an DT 19613 454 10 " " `` 19613 454 11 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 454 12 confession confession NN 19613 454 13 of of IN 19613 454 14 faith faith NN 19613 454 15 " " '' 19613 454 16 through through IN 19613 454 17 the the DT 19613 454 18 Nicene Nicene NNP 19613 454 19 Creed Creed NNP 19613 454 20 . . . 19613 455 1 But but CC 19613 455 2 even even RB 19613 455 3 this this DT 19613 455 4 creed creed NN 19613 455 5 was be VBD 19613 455 6 not not RB 19613 455 7 adopted adopt VBN 19613 455 8 all all RB 19613 455 9 at at IN 19613 455 10 once once RB 19613 455 11 . . . 19613 456 1 B. B. NNP 19613 457 1 _ _ NNP 19613 457 2 The the DT 19613 457 3 designation designation NN 19613 457 4 of of IN 19613 457 5 selected select VBN 19613 457 6 writings writing NNS 19613 457 7 read read VBN 19613 457 8 in in IN 19613 457 9 the the DT 19613 457 10 churches church NNS 19613 457 11 as as IN 19613 457 12 New New NNP 19613 457 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 457 14 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 457 15 or or CC 19613 457 16 , , , 19613 457 17 in in IN 19613 457 18 other other JJ 19613 457 19 words word NNS 19613 457 20 , , , 19613 457 21 as as IN 19613 457 22 a a DT 19613 457 23 collection collection NN 19613 457 24 of of IN 19613 457 25 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 457 26 writings writing NNS 19613 457 27 _ _ NNP 19613 457 28 . . . 19613 458 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 458 2 67 67 CD 19613 458 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 458 4 Every every DT 19613 458 5 word word NN 19613 458 6 and and CC 19613 458 7 every every DT 19613 458 8 writing writing NN 19613 458 9 which which WDT 19613 458 10 testified testify VBD 19613 458 11 of of IN 19613 458 12 the the DT 19613 458 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 458 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 458 15 : : : 19613 458 16 kurios kurio NNS 19613 458 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 458 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 458 19 Lord Lord NNP 19613 458 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 458 21 was be VBD 19613 458 22 originally originally RB 19613 458 23 regarded regard VBN 19613 458 24 as as IN 19613 458 25 emanating emanate VBG 19613 458 26 from from IN 19613 458 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 458 28 , , , 19613 458 29 that that RB 19613 458 30 is is RB 19613 458 31 , , , 19613 458 32 from from IN 19613 458 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 458 34 spirit spirit NN 19613 458 35 : : : 19613 458 36 [ [ -LRB- 19613 458 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 458 38 : : : 19613 458 39 Hothen Hothen NNP 19613 458 40 hê hê NNP 19613 458 41 kuriotês kuriotês NNP 19613 458 42 laleitai laleitai NNP 19613 458 43 ekei ekei NNP 19613 458 44 Kurios Kurios NNP 19613 458 45 estin estin NNP 19613 458 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 458 47 . . . 19613 459 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 459 2 Didache Didache NNP 19613 459 3 IV IV NNP 19613 459 4 . . . 19613 460 1 1 1 LS 19613 460 2 ; ; : 19613 460 3 see see VB 19613 460 4 also also RB 19613 460 5 1 1 CD 19613 460 6 Cor Cor NNP 19613 460 7 . . . 19613 461 1 XII XII NNP 19613 461 2 . . . 19613 462 1 3 3 LS 19613 462 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 462 3 . . . 19613 463 1 Hence hence RB 19613 463 2 the the DT 19613 463 3 contents content NNS 19613 463 4 were be VBD 19613 463 5 holy holy JJ 19613 463 6 . . . 19613 464 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 464 2 68 68 CD 19613 464 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 464 4 In in IN 19613 464 5 this this DT 19613 464 6 sense sense NN 19613 464 7 the the DT 19613 464 8 New New NNP 19613 464 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 464 10 is be VBZ 19613 464 11 a a DT 19613 464 12 " " `` 19613 464 13 residuary residuary JJ 19613 464 14 product product NN 19613 464 15 , , , 19613 464 16 " " '' 19613 464 17 just just RB 19613 464 18 as as IN 19613 464 19 the the DT 19613 464 20 idea idea NN 19613 464 21 of of IN 19613 464 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 464 23 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 464 24 is be VBZ 19613 464 25 a a DT 19613 464 26 remnant remnant NN 19613 464 27 of of IN 19613 464 28 a a DT 19613 464 29 much much RB 19613 464 30 broader broad JJR 19613 464 31 view view NN 19613 464 32 . . . 19613 465 1 But but CC 19613 465 2 on on IN 19613 465 3 the the DT 19613 465 4 other other JJ 19613 465 5 hand hand NN 19613 465 6 , , , 19613 465 7 the the DT 19613 465 8 New New NNP 19613 465 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 465 10 is be VBZ 19613 465 11 a a DT 19613 465 12 new new JJ 19613 465 13 creation creation NN 19613 465 14 of of IN 19613 465 15 the the DT 19613 465 16 Church,[69 Church,[69 NNP 19613 465 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 465 18 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 465 19 as as IN 19613 465 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 465 21 takes take VBZ 19613 465 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 465 23 place place NN 19613 465 24 alongside alongside IN 19613 465 25 of of IN 19613 465 26 the the DT 19613 465 27 Old old JJ 19613 465 28 -- -- : 19613 465 29 which which WDT 19613 465 30 through through IN 19613 465 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 465 32 has have VBZ 19613 465 33 become become VBN 19613 465 34 a a DT 19613 465 35 complicated complicated JJ 19613 465 36 book book NN 19613 465 37 for for IN 19613 465 38 Christendom,--as christendom,--as NN 19613 465 39 a a DT 19613 465 40 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 465 41 and and CC 19613 465 42 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 465 43 collection collection NN 19613 465 44 of of IN 19613 465 45 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 465 46 containing contain VBG 19613 465 47 and and CC 19613 465 48 attesting attest VBG 19613 465 49 the the DT 19613 465 50 truth truth NN 19613 465 51 . . . 19613 466 1 Marcion marcion NN 19613 466 2 had have VBD 19613 466 3 founded found VBN 19613 466 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 466 5 conception conception NN 19613 466 6 of of IN 19613 466 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 466 8 on on IN 19613 466 9 a a DT 19613 466 10 new new JJ 19613 466 11 canon canon NN 19613 466 12 of of IN 19613 466 13 Scripture,[70 Scripture,[70 NNP 19613 466 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 466 15 which which WDT 19613 466 16 seems seem VBZ 19613 466 17 to to TO 19613 466 18 have have VB 19613 466 19 enjoyed enjoy VBN 19613 466 20 the the DT 19613 466 21 same same JJ 19613 466 22 authority authority NN 19613 466 23 among among IN 19613 466 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 466 25 followers follower NNS 19613 466 26 as as IN 19613 466 27 was be VBD 19613 466 28 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 466 29 to to IN 19613 466 30 the the DT 19613 466 31 Old Old NNP 19613 466 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 466 33 in in IN 19613 466 34 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 466 35 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 466 36 . . . 19613 467 1 In in IN 19613 467 2 the the DT 19613 467 3 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 467 4 schools school NNS 19613 467 5 , , , 19613 467 6 which which WDT 19613 467 7 likewise likewise RB 19613 467 8 rejected reject VBD 19613 467 9 the the DT 19613 467 10 Old Old NNP 19613 467 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 467 12 altogether altogether RB 19613 467 13 or or CC 19613 467 14 in in IN 19613 467 15 part part NN 19613 467 16 , , , 19613 467 17 Evangelic Evangelic NNP 19613 467 18 and and CC 19613 467 19 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 467 20 writings writing NNS 19613 467 21 were be VBD 19613 467 22 , , , 19613 467 23 by by IN 19613 467 24 the the DT 19613 467 25 middle middle NN 19613 467 26 of of IN 19613 467 27 the the DT 19613 467 28 second second JJ 19613 467 29 century century NN 19613 467 30 , , , 19613 467 31 treated treat VBN 19613 467 32 as as IN 19613 467 33 sacred sacred JJ 19613 467 34 texts text NNS 19613 467 35 and and CC 19613 467 36 made make VBD 19613 467 37 use use NN 19613 467 38 of of IN 19613 467 39 to to TO 19613 467 40 confirm confirm VB 19613 467 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 467 42 theological theological JJ 19613 467 43 speculations speculation NNS 19613 467 44 . . . 19613 468 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 468 2 71 71 CD 19613 468 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 468 4 On on IN 19613 468 5 the the DT 19613 468 6 other other JJ 19613 468 7 hand hand NN 19613 468 8 , , , 19613 468 9 about about IN 19613 468 10 the the DT 19613 468 11 year year NN 19613 468 12 150 150 CD 19613 468 13 the the DT 19613 468 14 main main JJ 19613 468 15 body body NN 19613 468 16 of of IN 19613 468 17 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 468 18 had have VBD 19613 468 19 still still RB 19613 468 20 no no DT 19613 468 21 collection collection NN 19613 468 22 of of IN 19613 468 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 468 24 and and CC 19613 468 25 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 468 26 possessing possess VBG 19613 468 27 equal equal JJ 19613 468 28 authority authority NN 19613 468 29 with with IN 19613 468 30 the the DT 19613 468 31 Old Old NNP 19613 468 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 468 33 , , , 19613 468 34 and and CC 19613 468 35 , , , 19613 468 36 apart apart RB 19613 468 37 from from IN 19613 468 38 Apocalypses Apocalypses NNP 19613 468 39 , , , 19613 468 40 no no DT 19613 468 41 new new JJ 19613 468 42 writings writing NNS 19613 468 43 at at RB 19613 468 44 all all RB 19613 468 45 , , , 19613 468 46 which which WDT 19613 468 47 as as IN 19613 468 48 such such JJ 19613 468 49 , , , 19613 468 50 that that RB 19613 468 51 is is RB 19613 468 52 , , , 19613 468 53 as as IN 19613 468 54 sacred sacred JJ 19613 468 55 texts text NNS 19613 468 56 , , , 19613 468 57 were be VBD 19613 468 58 regarded regard VBN 19613 468 59 as as IN 19613 468 60 inspired inspired JJ 19613 468 61 and and CC 19613 468 62 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 468 63 . . . 19613 469 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 469 2 72 72 CD 19613 469 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 469 4 Here here RB 19613 469 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 469 6 leave leave VBP 19613 469 7 out out IN 19613 469 8 of of IN 19613 469 9 consideration consideration NN 19613 469 10 that that IN 19613 469 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 469 12 content content NN 19613 469 13 is be VBZ 19613 469 14 a a DT 19613 469 15 testimony testimony NN 19613 469 16 of of IN 19613 469 17 the the DT 19613 469 18 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 469 19 . . . 19613 470 1 From from IN 19613 470 2 the the DT 19613 470 3 works work NNS 19613 470 4 of of IN 19613 470 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 470 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 470 7 is be VBZ 19613 470 8 to to TO 19613 470 9 be be VB 19613 470 10 inferred infer VBN 19613 470 11 that that IN 19613 470 12 the the DT 19613 470 13 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 470 14 authorities authority NNS 19613 470 15 were be VBD 19613 470 16 the the DT 19613 470 17 Old Old NNP 19613 470 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 470 19 , , , 19613 470 20 the the DT 19613 470 21 words word NNS 19613 470 22 of of IN 19613 470 23 the the DT 19613 470 24 Lord Lord NNP 19613 470 25 , , , 19613 470 26 and and CC 19613 470 27 the the DT 19613 470 28 communications communication NNS 19613 470 29 of of IN 19613 470 30 Christian christian JJ 19613 470 31 prophets prophet NNS 19613 470 32 . . . 19613 471 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 471 2 73 73 CD 19613 471 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 471 4 The the DT 19613 471 5 memoirs memoir NNS 19613 471 6 of of IN 19613 471 7 the the DT 19613 471 8 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 471 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 471 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 471 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 471 12 : : : 19613 471 13 apomnêmoneumata apomnêmoneumata NN 19613 471 14 ton ton NN 19613 471 15 apostolôn apostolôn NN 19613 471 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 471 17 = = NFP 19613 471 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 471 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 471 20 : : : 19613 471 21 ta ta NNP 19613 471 22 euangelia euangelia NNP 19613 471 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 471 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 471 25 owed owe VBD 19613 471 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 471 27 significance significance NN 19613 471 28 solely solely RB 19613 471 29 to to IN 19613 471 30 the the DT 19613 471 31 fact fact NN 19613 471 32 that that IN 19613 471 33 they -PRON- PRP 19613 471 34 recorded record VBD 19613 471 35 the the DT 19613 471 36 words word NNS 19613 471 37 and and CC 19613 471 38 history history NN 19613 471 39 of of IN 19613 471 40 the the DT 19613 471 41 Lord Lord NNP 19613 471 42 and and CC 19613 471 43 bore bear VBD 19613 471 44 witness witness NN 19613 471 45 to to IN 19613 471 46 the the DT 19613 471 47 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 471 48 of of IN 19613 471 49 Old Old NNP 19613 471 50 Testament Testament NNP 19613 471 51 predictions prediction NNS 19613 471 52 . . . 19613 472 1 There there EX 19613 472 2 is be VBZ 19613 472 3 no no DT 19613 472 4 mention mention NN 19613 472 5 whatever whatever WDT 19613 472 6 of of IN 19613 472 7 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 472 8 epistles epistle NNS 19613 472 9 as as IN 19613 472 10 holy holy JJ 19613 472 11 writings writing NNS 19613 472 12 of of IN 19613 472 13 standard standard JJ 19613 472 14 authority authority NN 19613 472 15 . . . 19613 473 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 473 2 74 74 CD 19613 473 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 473 4 But but CC 19613 473 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 473 6 learn learn VBP 19613 473 7 further further RB 19613 473 8 from from IN 19613 473 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 473 10 that that IN 19613 473 11 the the DT 19613 473 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 473 13 as as RB 19613 473 14 well well RB 19613 473 15 as as IN 19613 473 16 the the DT 19613 473 17 Old Old NNP 19613 473 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 473 19 were be VBD 19613 473 20 read read VBN 19613 473 21 in in IN 19613 473 22 public public JJ 19613 473 23 worship worship NN 19613 473 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 473 25 Apol Apol NNP 19613 473 26 . . . 19613 474 1 I. I. NNP 19613 475 1 67 67 CD 19613 475 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 475 3 and and CC 19613 475 4 that that IN 19613 475 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 475 6 first first JJ 19613 475 7 three three CD 19613 475 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 475 9 were be VBD 19613 475 10 already already RB 19613 475 11 in in IN 19613 475 12 use use NN 19613 475 13 . . . 19613 476 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 476 2 can can MD 19613 476 3 , , , 19613 476 4 moreover moreover RB 19613 476 5 , , , 19613 476 6 gather gather VB 19613 476 7 from from IN 19613 476 8 other other JJ 19613 476 9 sources source NNS 19613 476 10 that that WDT 19613 476 11 other other JJ 19613 476 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 476 13 writings writing NNS 19613 476 14 , , , 19613 476 15 early early RB 19613 476 16 and and CC 19613 476 17 late late JJ 19613 476 18 , , , 19613 476 19 were be VBD 19613 476 20 more more RBR 19613 476 21 or or CC 19613 476 22 less less RBR 19613 476 23 regularly regularly RB 19613 476 24 read read VBN 19613 476 25 in in IN 19613 476 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 476 27 meetings meeting NNS 19613 476 28 . . . 19613 477 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 477 2 75 75 CD 19613 477 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 477 4 Such such JJ 19613 477 5 writings writing NNS 19613 477 6 naturally naturally RB 19613 477 7 possessed possess VBD 19613 477 8 a a DT 19613 477 9 high high JJ 19613 477 10 degree degree NN 19613 477 11 of of IN 19613 477 12 authority authority NN 19613 477 13 . . . 19613 478 1 As as IN 19613 478 2 the the DT 19613 478 3 Holy Holy NNP 19613 478 4 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 478 5 and and CC 19613 478 6 the the DT 19613 478 7 Church Church NNP 19613 478 8 are be VBP 19613 478 9 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 478 10 , , , 19613 478 11 everything everything NN 19613 478 12 that that WDT 19613 478 13 edifies edify VBZ 19613 478 14 the the DT 19613 478 15 Church church NN 19613 478 16 originates originate VBZ 19613 478 17 with with IN 19613 478 18 the the DT 19613 478 19 Holy Holy NNP 19613 478 20 Spirit,[76 Spirit,[76 NNP 19613 478 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 478 22 which which WDT 19613 478 23 in in IN 19613 478 24 this this DT 19613 478 25 , , , 19613 478 26 as as RB 19613 478 27 well well RB 19613 478 28 as as IN 19613 478 29 every every DT 19613 478 30 other other JJ 19613 478 31 respect respect NN 19613 478 32 , , , 19613 478 33 is be VBZ 19613 478 34 inexhaustibly inexhaustibly RB 19613 478 35 rich rich JJ 19613 478 36 . . . 19613 479 1 Here here RB 19613 479 2 , , , 19613 479 3 however however RB 19613 479 4 , , , 19613 479 5 two two CD 19613 479 6 interests interest NNS 19613 479 7 were be VBD 19613 479 8 predominant predominant JJ 19613 479 9 from from IN 19613 479 10 the the DT 19613 479 11 beginning beginning NN 19613 479 12 , , , 19613 479 13 that that DT 19613 479 14 of of IN 19613 479 15 immediate immediate JJ 19613 479 16 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 479 17 edification edification NN 19613 479 18 and and CC 19613 479 19 that that DT 19613 479 20 of of IN 19613 479 21 attesting attest VBG 19613 479 22 and and CC 19613 479 23 certifying certify VBG 19613 479 24 the the DT 19613 479 25 Christian Christian NNP 19613 479 26 _ _ NNP 19613 479 27 Kerygma Kerygma NNP 19613 479 28 _ _ NNP 19613 479 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 479 30 [ [ -LRB- 19613 479 31 Greek Greek NNP 19613 479 32 : : : 19613 479 33 hê hê NNP 19613 479 34 asphaleia asphaleia NNP 19613 479 35 tôn tôn NNP 19613 479 36 logôn logôn NNP 19613 479 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 479 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 479 39 . . . 19613 480 1 _ _ NNP 19613 480 2 The the DT 19613 480 3 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 480 4 canon canon NN 19613 480 5 was be VBD 19613 480 6 the the DT 19613 480 7 result result NN 19613 480 8 of of IN 19613 480 9 the the DT 19613 480 10 latter latter JJ 19613 480 11 interest interest NN 19613 480 12 _ _ NNP 19613 480 13 , , , 19613 480 14 not not RB 19613 480 15 indeed indeed RB 19613 480 16 in in IN 19613 480 17 consequence consequence NN 19613 480 18 of of IN 19613 480 19 a a DT 19613 480 20 process process NN 19613 480 21 of of IN 19613 480 22 collection collection NN 19613 480 23 , , , 19613 480 24 for for IN 19613 480 25 individual individual JJ 19613 480 26 communities community NNS 19613 480 27 had have VBD 19613 480 28 already already RB 19613 480 29 made make VBN 19613 480 30 a a DT 19613 480 31 far far RB 19613 480 32 larger large JJR 19613 480 33 compilation,[77 compilation,[77 CD 19613 480 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 480 35 but but CC 19613 480 36 , , , 19613 480 37 in in IN 19613 480 38 the the DT 19613 480 39 first first JJ 19613 480 40 instance instance NN 19613 480 41 , , , 19613 480 42 through through IN 19613 480 43 selection selection NN 19613 480 44 , , , 19613 480 45 and and CC 19613 480 46 afterwards afterwards RB 19613 480 47 , , , 19613 480 48 but but CC 19613 480 49 not not RB 19613 480 50 till till IN 19613 480 51 then then RB 19613 480 52 , , , 19613 480 53 through through IN 19613 480 54 addition addition NN 19613 480 55 . . . 19613 481 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 481 2 must must MD 19613 481 3 not not RB 19613 481 4 think think VB 19613 481 5 that that IN 19613 481 6 the the DT 19613 481 7 four four CD 19613 481 8 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 481 9 now now RB 19613 481 10 found find VBN 19613 481 11 in in IN 19613 481 12 the the DT 19613 481 13 canon canon NN 19613 481 14 had have VBD 19613 481 15 attained attain VBN 19613 481 16 full full JJ 19613 481 17 canonical canonical JJ 19613 481 18 authority authority NN 19613 481 19 by by IN 19613 481 20 the the DT 19613 481 21 middle middle NN 19613 481 22 of of IN 19613 481 23 the the DT 19613 481 24 second second JJ 19613 481 25 century century NN 19613 481 26 , , , 19613 481 27 for for IN 19613 481 28 the the DT 19613 481 29 fact fact NN 19613 481 30 -- -- : 19613 481 31 easily easily RB 19613 481 32 demonstrable demonstrable JJ 19613 481 33 -- -- : 19613 481 34 that that IN 19613 481 35 the the DT 19613 481 36 texts text NNS 19613 481 37 were be VBD 19613 481 38 still still RB 19613 481 39 very very RB 19613 481 40 freely freely RB 19613 481 41 dealt deal VBN 19613 481 42 with with IN 19613 481 43 about about IN 19613 481 44 this this DT 19613 481 45 period period NN 19613 481 46 is be VBZ 19613 481 47 in in IN 19613 481 48 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 481 49 a a DT 19613 481 50 proof proof NN 19613 481 51 of of IN 19613 481 52 this this DT 19613 481 53 . . . 19613 482 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 482 2 78 78 CD 19613 482 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 482 4 Our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 482 5 first first JJ 19613 482 6 three three CD 19613 482 7 Gospels gospel NNS 19613 482 8 contain contain VBP 19613 482 9 passages passage NNS 19613 482 10 and and CC 19613 482 11 corrections correction NNS 19613 482 12 that that WDT 19613 482 13 could could MD 19613 482 14 hardly hardly RB 19613 482 15 have have VB 19613 482 16 been be VBN 19613 482 17 fixed fix VBN 19613 482 18 before before IN 19613 482 19 about about IN 19613 482 20 the the DT 19613 482 21 year year NN 19613 482 22 150 150 CD 19613 482 23 . . . 19613 483 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 483 2 , , , 19613 483 3 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 483 4 's 's POS 19613 483 5 attempt attempt NN 19613 483 6 to to TO 19613 483 7 create create VB 19613 483 8 a a DT 19613 483 9 new new JJ 19613 483 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 483 11 from from IN 19613 483 12 the the DT 19613 483 13 four four CD 19613 483 14 shews shew NNS 19613 483 15 that that IN 19613 483 16 the the DT 19613 483 17 text text NN 19613 483 18 of of IN 19613 483 19 these these DT 19613 483 20 was be VBD 19613 483 21 not not RB 19613 483 22 yet yet RB 19613 483 23 fixed fix VBN 19613 483 24 . . . 19613 484 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 484 2 79 79 CD 19613 484 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 484 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 484 5 may may MD 19613 484 6 remark remark VB 19613 484 7 that that IN 19613 484 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 484 9 was be VBD 19613 484 10 the the DT 19613 484 11 first first JJ 19613 484 12 in in IN 19613 484 13 whom whom WP 19613 484 14 we -PRON- PRP 19613 484 15 find find VBP 19613 484 16 the the DT 19613 484 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 484 18 of of IN 19613 484 19 John[80 john[80 NN 19613 484 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 484 21 alongside alongside IN 19613 484 22 of of IN 19613 484 23 the the DT 19613 484 24 Synoptists Synoptists NNPS 19613 484 25 , , , 19613 484 26 and and CC 19613 484 27 these these DT 19613 484 28 four four CD 19613 484 29 the the DT 19613 484 30 only only JJ 19613 484 31 ones one NNS 19613 484 32 recognised recognise VBN 19613 484 33 . . . 19613 485 1 From from IN 19613 485 2 the the DT 19613 485 3 assault assault NN 19613 485 4 of of IN 19613 485 5 the the DT 19613 485 6 " " `` 19613 485 7 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 485 8 " " '' 19613 485 9 on on IN 19613 485 10 the the DT 19613 485 11 Johannine Johannine NNP 19613 485 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 485 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 485 14 learn learn VBP 19613 485 15 that that IN 19613 485 16 about about RB 19613 485 17 160 160 CD 19613 485 18 the the DT 19613 485 19 whole whole NN 19613 485 20 of of IN 19613 485 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 485 22 four four CD 19613 485 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 485 24 had have VBD 19613 485 25 not not RB 19613 485 26 been be VBN 19613 485 27 definitely definitely RB 19613 485 28 recognised recognise VBN 19613 485 29 even even RB 19613 485 30 in in IN 19613 485 31 Asia Asia NNP 19613 485 32 Minor Minor NNP 19613 485 33 . . . 19613 486 1 Finally finally RB 19613 486 2 , , , 19613 486 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 486 4 must must MD 19613 486 5 refer refer VB 19613 486 6 to to IN 19613 486 7 the the DT 19613 486 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 486 9 of of IN 19613 486 10 the the DT 19613 486 11 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 19613 486 12 , , , 19613 486 13 the the DT 19613 486 14 use use NN 19613 486 15 of of IN 19613 486 16 which which WDT 19613 486 17 was be VBD 19613 486 18 not not RB 19613 486 19 confined confine VBN 19613 486 20 to to IN 19613 486 21 circles circle NNS 19613 486 22 outside outside IN 19613 486 23 the the DT 19613 486 24 Church Church NNP 19613 486 25 . . . 19613 487 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 487 2 81 81 CD 19613 487 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 487 4 From from IN 19613 487 5 the the DT 19613 487 6 middle middle NN 19613 487 7 of of IN 19613 487 8 the the DT 19613 487 9 second second JJ 19613 487 10 century century NN 19613 487 11 the the DT 19613 487 12 Encratites Encratites NNPS 19613 487 13 stood stand VBD 19613 487 14 midway midway RB 19613 487 15 between between IN 19613 487 16 the the DT 19613 487 17 larger large JJR 19613 487 18 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 487 19 and and CC 19613 487 20 the the DT 19613 487 21 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 487 22 Church Church NNP 19613 487 23 as as RB 19613 487 24 well well RB 19613 487 25 as as IN 19613 487 26 the the DT 19613 487 27 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 487 28 schools school NNS 19613 487 29 . . . 19613 488 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 488 2 hear hear VBP 19613 488 3 of of IN 19613 488 4 some some DT 19613 488 5 of of IN 19613 488 6 these these DT 19613 488 7 using use VBG 19613 488 8 the the DT 19613 488 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 488 10 as as IN 19613 488 11 canonical canonical JJ 19613 488 12 writings writing NNS 19613 488 13 side side VBP 19613 488 14 by by IN 19613 488 15 side side NN 19613 488 16 with with IN 19613 488 17 the the DT 19613 488 18 Old Old NNP 19613 488 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 488 20 , , , 19613 488 21 though though IN 19613 488 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 488 23 would would MD 19613 488 24 have have VB 19613 488 25 nothing nothing NN 19613 488 26 to to TO 19613 488 27 do do VB 19613 488 28 with with IN 19613 488 29 the the DT 19613 488 30 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 488 31 of of IN 19613 488 32 Paul Paul NNP 19613 488 33 and and CC 19613 488 34 the the DT 19613 488 35 Acts act NNS 19613 488 36 of of IN 19613 488 37 the the DT 19613 488 38 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 488 39 . . . 19613 489 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 489 2 82 82 CD 19613 489 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 489 4 But but CC 19613 489 5 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 489 6 , , , 19613 489 7 the the DT 19613 489 8 prominent prominent JJ 19613 489 9 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 489 10 , , , 19613 489 11 who who WP 19613 489 12 joined join VBD 19613 489 13 them -PRON- PRP 19613 489 14 , , , 19613 489 15 gave give VBD 19613 489 16 this this DT 19613 489 17 sect sect NN 19613 489 18 a a DT 19613 489 19 more more RBR 19613 489 20 complete complete JJ 19613 489 21 canon canon NN 19613 489 22 , , , 19613 489 23 an an DT 19613 489 24 important important JJ 19613 489 25 fact fact NN 19613 489 26 about about IN 19613 489 27 which which WDT 19613 489 28 was be VBD 19613 489 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 489 30 inclusion inclusion NN 19613 489 31 of of IN 19613 489 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 489 33 of of IN 19613 489 34 Paul Paul NNP 19613 489 35 . . . 19613 490 1 Even even RB 19613 490 2 this this DT 19613 490 3 period period NN 19613 490 4 , , , 19613 490 5 however however RB 19613 490 6 , , , 19613 490 7 still still RB 19613 490 8 supplies supply VBZ 19613 490 9 us -PRON- PRP 19613 490 10 with with IN 19613 490 11 no no DT 19613 490 12 testimony testimony NN 19613 490 13 as as IN 19613 490 14 to to IN 19613 490 15 the the DT 19613 490 16 existence existence NN 19613 490 17 of of IN 19613 490 18 a a DT 19613 490 19 New New NNP 19613 490 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 490 21 canon canon NN 19613 490 22 in in IN 19613 490 23 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 490 24 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 490 25 , , , 19613 490 26 in in IN 19613 490 27 fact fact NN 19613 490 28 the the DT 19613 490 29 rise rise NN 19613 490 30 of of IN 19613 490 31 the the DT 19613 490 32 so so RB 19613 490 33 - - HYPH 19613 490 34 called call VBN 19613 490 35 " " `` 19613 490 36 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 490 37 " " '' 19613 490 38 and and CC 19613 490 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 490 40 extreme extreme JJ 19613 490 41 antithesis antithesis NN 19613 490 42 , , , 19613 490 43 the the DT 19613 490 44 " " `` 19613 490 45 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 490 46 , , , 19613 490 47 " " '' 19613 490 48 in in IN 19613 490 49 Asia Asia NNP 19613 490 50 Minor Minor NNP 19613 490 51 soon soon RB 19613 490 52 after after IN 19613 490 53 the the DT 19613 490 54 middle middle NN 19613 490 55 of of IN 19613 490 56 the the DT 19613 490 57 second second JJ 19613 490 58 century century NN 19613 490 59 proves prove VBZ 19613 490 60 that that IN 19613 490 61 there there EX 19613 490 62 was be VBD 19613 490 63 still still RB 19613 490 64 no no DT 19613 490 65 New New NNP 19613 490 66 Testament Testament NNP 19613 490 67 canon canon NN 19613 490 68 there there RB 19613 490 69 ; ; : 19613 490 70 for for IN 19613 490 71 , , , 19613 490 72 if if IN 19613 490 73 such such PDT 19613 490 74 an an DT 19613 490 75 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 490 76 compilation compilation NN 19613 490 77 had have VBD 19613 490 78 existed exist VBN 19613 490 79 , , , 19613 490 80 these these DT 19613 490 81 movements movement NNS 19613 490 82 could could MD 19613 490 83 not not RB 19613 490 84 have have VB 19613 490 85 arisen arise VBN 19613 490 86 . . . 19613 491 1 If if IN 19613 491 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 491 3 gather gather VBP 19613 491 4 together together RB 19613 491 5 all all PDT 19613 491 6 the the DT 19613 491 7 indications indication NNS 19613 491 8 and and CC 19613 491 9 evidence evidence NN 19613 491 10 bearing bear VBG 19613 491 11 on on IN 19613 491 12 the the DT 19613 491 13 subject subject NN 19613 491 14 , , , 19613 491 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 491 16 shall shall MD 19613 491 17 indeed indeed RB 19613 491 18 be be VB 19613 491 19 ready ready JJ 19613 491 20 to to TO 19613 491 21 expect expect VB 19613 491 22 the the DT 19613 491 23 speedy speedy JJ 19613 491 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 491 25 in in IN 19613 491 26 the the DT 19613 491 27 Church Church NNP 19613 491 28 of of IN 19613 491 29 a a DT 19613 491 30 kind kind NN 19613 491 31 of of IN 19613 491 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 491 33 canon canon NN 19613 491 34 comprising comprise VBG 19613 491 35 the the DT 19613 491 36 four four CD 19613 491 37 Gospels;[83 Gospels;[83 NNP 19613 491 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 491 39 but but CC 19613 491 40 we -PRON- PRP 19613 491 41 are be VBP 19613 491 42 prepared prepared JJ 19613 491 43 neither neither CC 19613 491 44 for for IN 19613 491 45 this this DT 19613 491 46 being be VBG 19613 491 47 formally formally RB 19613 491 48 placed place VBN 19613 491 49 on on IN 19613 491 50 an an DT 19613 491 51 equality equality NN 19613 491 52 with with IN 19613 491 53 the the DT 19613 491 54 Old Old NNP 19613 491 55 Testament Testament NNP 19613 491 56 , , , 19613 491 57 nor nor CC 19613 491 58 for for IN 19613 491 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 491 60 containing contain VBG 19613 491 61 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 491 62 writings writing NNS 19613 491 63 , , , 19613 491 64 which which WDT 19613 491 65 as as IN 19613 491 66 yet yet RB 19613 491 67 are be VBP 19613 491 68 only only RB 19613 491 69 found find VBN 19613 491 70 in in IN 19613 491 71 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 491 72 and and CC 19613 491 73 the the DT 19613 491 74 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 491 75 . . . 19613 492 1 The the DT 19613 492 2 canon canon NN 19613 492 3 emerges emerge VBZ 19613 492 4 quite quite RB 19613 492 5 suddenly suddenly RB 19613 492 6 in in IN 19613 492 7 an an DT 19613 492 8 allusion allusion NN 19613 492 9 of of IN 19613 492 10 Melito Melito NNP 19613 492 11 of of IN 19613 492 12 Sardis Sardis NNP 19613 492 13 preserved preserve VBN 19613 492 14 by by IN 19613 492 15 Eusebius,[84 Eusebius,[84 NNP 19613 492 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 492 17 the the DT 19613 492 18 meaning meaning NN 19613 492 19 of of IN 19613 492 20 which which WDT 19613 492 21 is be VBZ 19613 492 22 , , , 19613 492 23 however however RB 19613 492 24 , , , 19613 492 25 still still RB 19613 492 26 dubious dubious JJ 19613 492 27 ; ; : 19613 492 28 in in IN 19613 492 29 the the DT 19613 492 30 works work NNS 19613 492 31 of of IN 19613 492 32 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 492 33 and and CC 19613 492 34 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 492 35 ; ; : 19613 492 36 and and CC 19613 492 37 in in IN 19613 492 38 the the DT 19613 492 39 so so RB 19613 492 40 - - HYPH 19613 492 41 called call VBN 19613 492 42 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 492 43 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 492 44 . . . 19613 493 1 There there EX 19613 493 2 is be VBZ 19613 493 3 no no DT 19613 493 4 direct direct JJ 19613 493 5 account account NN 19613 493 6 of of IN 19613 493 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 493 8 origin origin NN 19613 493 9 and and CC 19613 493 10 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 493 11 any any DT 19613 493 12 indirect indirect NN 19613 493 13 ; ; : 19613 493 14 yet yet CC 19613 493 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 493 16 already already RB 19613 493 17 appears appear VBZ 19613 493 18 as as IN 19613 493 19 something something NN 19613 493 20 to to IN 19613 493 21 all all DT 19613 493 22 intents intent NNS 19613 493 23 and and CC 19613 493 24 purposes purpose NNS 19613 493 25 finished finish VBD 19613 493 26 and and CC 19613 493 27 complete complete JJ 19613 493 28 . . . 19613 494 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 494 2 85 85 CD 19613 494 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 494 4 Moreover moreover RB 19613 494 5 , , , 19613 494 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 494 7 emerges emerge VBZ 19613 494 8 in in IN 19613 494 9 the the DT 19613 494 10 same same JJ 19613 494 11 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 494 12 district district NN 19613 494 13 where where WRB 19613 494 14 we -PRON- PRP 19613 494 15 were be VBD 19613 494 16 first first RB 19613 494 17 able able JJ 19613 494 18 to to TO 19613 494 19 show show VB 19613 494 20 the the DT 19613 494 21 existence existence NN 19613 494 22 of of IN 19613 494 23 the the DT 19613 494 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 494 25 _ _ NNP 19613 494 26 regula regula NN 19613 494 27 fidei fidei NNP 19613 494 28 _ _ NNP 19613 494 29 . . . 19613 495 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 495 2 hear hear VBP 19613 495 3 nothing nothing NN 19613 495 4 of of IN 19613 495 5 any any DT 19613 495 6 authority authority NN 19613 495 7 belonging belong VBG 19613 495 8 to to IN 19613 495 9 the the DT 19613 495 10 compilers compiler NNS 19613 495 11 , , , 19613 495 12 because because IN 19613 495 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 495 14 learn learn VBP 19613 495 15 nothing nothing NN 19613 495 16 at at RB 19613 495 17 all all RB 19613 495 18 of of IN 19613 495 19 such such JJ 19613 495 20 persons person NNS 19613 495 21 . . . 19613 496 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 496 2 86 86 CD 19613 496 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 496 4 And and CC 19613 496 5 yet yet RB 19613 496 6 the the DT 19613 496 7 collection collection NN 19613 496 8 is be VBZ 19613 496 9 regarded regard VBN 19613 496 10 by by IN 19613 496 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 496 12 and and CC 19613 496 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 496 14 as as IN 19613 496 15 completed complete VBN 19613 496 16 . . . 19613 497 1 A a DT 19613 497 2 refusal refusal NN 19613 497 3 on on IN 19613 497 4 the the DT 19613 497 5 part part NN 19613 497 6 of of IN 19613 497 7 the the DT 19613 497 8 heretics heretic NNS 19613 497 9 to to TO 19613 497 10 recognise recognise VB 19613 497 11 this this DT 19613 497 12 or or CC 19613 497 13 that that DT 19613 497 14 book book NN 19613 497 15 is be VBZ 19613 497 16 already already RB 19613 497 17 made make VBN 19613 497 18 a a DT 19613 497 19 severe severe JJ 19613 497 20 reproach reproach NN 19613 497 21 against against IN 19613 497 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 497 23 . . . 19613 498 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 498 2 Bibles bible NNS 19613 498 3 are be VBP 19613 498 4 tested test VBN 19613 498 5 by by IN 19613 498 6 the the DT 19613 498 7 Church Church NNP 19613 498 8 compilation compilation NN 19613 498 9 as as IN 19613 498 10 the the DT 19613 498 11 older old JJR 19613 498 12 one one CD 19613 498 13 , , , 19613 498 14 and and CC 19613 498 15 the the DT 19613 498 16 latter latter JJ 19613 498 17 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 498 18 is be VBZ 19613 498 19 already already RB 19613 498 20 used use VBN 19613 498 21 exactly exactly RB 19613 498 22 like like IN 19613 498 23 the the DT 19613 498 24 Old Old NNP 19613 498 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 498 26 . . . 19613 499 1 The the DT 19613 499 2 assumption assumption NN 19613 499 3 of of IN 19613 499 4 the the DT 19613 499 5 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 499 6 of of IN 19613 499 7 the the DT 19613 499 8 books book NNS 19613 499 9 ; ; : 19613 499 10 the the DT 19613 499 11 harmonistic harmonistic JJ 19613 499 12 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 499 13 of of IN 19613 499 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 499 15 ; ; : 19613 499 16 the the DT 19613 499 17 idea idea NN 19613 499 18 of of IN 19613 499 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 499 20 absolute absolute JJ 19613 499 21 sufficiency sufficiency NN 19613 499 22 with with IN 19613 499 23 regard regard NN 19613 499 24 to to IN 19613 499 25 every every DT 19613 499 26 question question NN 19613 499 27 which which WDT 19613 499 28 can can MD 19613 499 29 arise arise VB 19613 499 30 and and CC 19613 499 31 every every DT 19613 499 32 event event NN 19613 499 33 which which WDT 19613 499 34 they -PRON- PRP 19613 499 35 record record VBP 19613 499 36 ; ; : 19613 499 37 the the DT 19613 499 38 right right NN 19613 499 39 of of IN 19613 499 40 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 499 41 combination combination NN 19613 499 42 of of IN 19613 499 43 passages passage NNS 19613 499 44 ; ; : 19613 499 45 the the DT 19613 499 46 assumption assumption NN 19613 499 47 that that IN 19613 499 48 nothing nothing NN 19613 499 49 in in IN 19613 499 50 the the DT 19613 499 51 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 499 52 is be VBZ 19613 499 53 without without IN 19613 499 54 importance importance NN 19613 499 55 ; ; : 19613 499 56 and and CC 19613 499 57 , , , 19613 499 58 finally finally RB 19613 499 59 , , , 19613 499 60 the the DT 19613 499 61 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 499 62 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 499 63 : : : 19613 499 64 are be VBP 19613 499 65 the the DT 19613 499 66 immediately immediately RB 19613 499 67 observable observable JJ 19613 499 68 result result NN 19613 499 69 of of IN 19613 499 70 the the DT 19613 499 71 creation creation NN 19613 499 72 of of IN 19613 499 73 the the DT 19613 499 74 canon canon NN 19613 499 75 . . . 19613 500 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 500 2 87 87 CD 19613 500 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 500 4 The the DT 19613 500 5 probable probable JJ 19613 500 6 conditions condition NNS 19613 500 7 which which WDT 19613 500 8 brought bring VBD 19613 500 9 about about RP 19613 500 10 the the DT 19613 500 11 formation formation NN 19613 500 12 of of IN 19613 500 13 the the DT 19613 500 14 New New NNP 19613 500 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 500 16 canon canon NN 19613 500 17 in in IN 19613 500 18 the the DT 19613 500 19 Church Church NNP 19613 500 20 , , , 19613 500 21 for for IN 19613 500 22 in in IN 19613 500 23 this this DT 19613 500 24 case case NN 19613 500 25 we -PRON- PRP 19613 500 26 are be VBP 19613 500 27 only only RB 19613 500 28 dealing deal VBG 19613 500 29 with with IN 19613 500 30 probabilities probability NNS 19613 500 31 , , , 19613 500 32 and and CC 19613 500 33 the the DT 19613 500 34 interests interest NNS 19613 500 35 which which WDT 19613 500 36 led lead VBD 19613 500 37 to to IN 19613 500 38 and and CC 19613 500 39 remained remain VBD 19613 500 40 associated associate VBN 19613 500 41 with with IN 19613 500 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 500 43 can can MD 19613 500 44 only only RB 19613 500 45 be be VB 19613 500 46 briefly briefly NN 19613 500 47 indicated indicate VBN 19613 500 48 here here RB 19613 500 49 . . . 19613 501 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 501 2 88 88 CD 19613 501 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 501 4 The the DT 19613 501 5 compilation compilation NN 19613 501 6 and and CC 19613 501 7 formation formation NN 19613 501 8 of of IN 19613 501 9 a a DT 19613 501 10 canon canon NN 19613 501 11 of of IN 19613 501 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 501 13 writings writing NNS 19613 501 14 by by IN 19613 501 15 a a DT 19613 501 16 process process NN 19613 501 17 of of IN 19613 501 18 selection[89 selection[89 NNP 19613 501 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 501 20 was be VBD 19613 501 21 , , , 19613 501 22 so so RB 19613 501 23 to to TO 19613 501 24 speak speak VB 19613 501 25 , , , 19613 501 26 a a DT 19613 501 27 kind kind NN 19613 501 28 of of IN 19613 501 29 involuntary involuntary JJ 19613 501 30 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 501 31 of of IN 19613 501 32 the the DT 19613 501 33 Church Church NNP 19613 501 34 in in IN 19613 501 35 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 501 36 conflict conflict NN 19613 501 37 with with IN 19613 501 38 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 501 39 and and CC 19613 501 40 the the DT 19613 501 41 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 501 42 , , , 19613 501 43 as as IN 19613 501 44 is be VBZ 19613 501 45 most most RBS 19613 501 46 plainly plainly RB 19613 501 47 proved prove VBN 19613 501 48 by by IN 19613 501 49 the the DT 19613 501 50 warnings warning NNS 19613 501 51 of of IN 19613 501 52 the the DT 19613 501 53 Fathers father NNS 19613 501 54 not not RB 19613 501 55 to to TO 19613 501 56 dispute dispute VB 19613 501 57 with with IN 19613 501 58 the the DT 19613 501 59 heretics heretic NNS 19613 501 60 about about IN 19613 501 61 the the DT 19613 501 62 Holy Holy NNP 19613 501 63 Scriptures,[90 Scriptures,[90 NNP 19613 501 64 ] ] -RRB- 19613 501 65 although although IN 19613 501 66 the the DT 19613 501 67 New New NNP 19613 501 68 Testament Testament NNP 19613 501 69 was be VBD 19613 501 70 already already RB 19613 501 71 in in IN 19613 501 72 existence existence NN 19613 501 73 . . . 19613 502 1 That that DT 19613 502 2 conflict conflict NN 19613 502 3 necessitated necessitate VBD 19613 502 4 the the DT 19613 502 5 formation formation NN 19613 502 6 of of IN 19613 502 7 a a DT 19613 502 8 new new JJ 19613 502 9 Bible Bible NNP 19613 502 10 . . . 19613 503 1 The the DT 19613 503 2 exclusion exclusion NN 19613 503 3 of of IN 19613 503 4 particular particular JJ 19613 503 5 persons person NNS 19613 503 6 on on IN 19613 503 7 the the DT 19613 503 8 strength strength NN 19613 503 9 of of IN 19613 503 10 some some DT 19613 503 11 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 503 12 standards standard NNS 19613 503 13 , , , 19613 503 14 and and CC 19613 503 15 by by IN 19613 503 16 reference reference NN 19613 503 17 to to IN 19613 503 18 the the DT 19613 503 19 Old Old NNP 19613 503 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 503 21 , , , 19613 503 22 could could MD 19613 503 23 not not RB 19613 503 24 be be VB 19613 503 25 justified justify VBN 19613 503 26 by by IN 19613 503 27 the the DT 19613 503 28 Church Church NNP 19613 503 29 in in IN 19613 503 30 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 503 31 own own JJ 19613 503 32 eyes eye NNS 19613 503 33 and and CC 19613 503 34 those those DT 19613 503 35 of of IN 19613 503 36 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 503 37 opponents opponent NNS 19613 503 38 , , , 19613 503 39 so so RB 19613 503 40 long long RB 19613 503 41 as as IN 19613 503 42 she -PRON- PRP 19613 503 43 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 503 44 recognised recognise VBD 19613 503 45 that that IN 19613 503 46 there there EX 19613 503 47 were be VBD 19613 503 48 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 503 49 writings writing NNS 19613 503 50 , , , 19613 503 51 and and CC 19613 503 52 so so RB 19613 503 53 long long RB 19613 503 54 as as IN 19613 503 55 these these DT 19613 503 56 heretics heretic NNS 19613 503 57 appealed appeal VBD 19613 503 58 to to IN 19613 503 59 such such JJ 19613 503 60 . . . 19613 504 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 504 2 was be VBD 19613 504 3 compelled compel VBN 19613 504 4 to to TO 19613 504 5 claim claim VB 19613 504 6 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 504 7 possession possession NN 19613 504 8 of of IN 19613 504 9 _ _ NNP 19613 504 10 everything everything NN 19613 504 11 _ _ NNP 19613 504 12 that that WDT 19613 504 13 had have VBD 19613 504 14 a a DT 19613 504 15 right right NN 19613 504 16 to to IN 19613 504 17 the the DT 19613 504 18 name name NN 19613 504 19 " " `` 19613 504 20 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 504 21 , , , 19613 504 22 " " '' 19613 504 23 to to TO 19613 504 24 deny deny VB 19613 504 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 504 26 to to IN 19613 504 27 the the DT 19613 504 28 heretics heretic NNS 19613 504 29 , , , 19613 504 30 and and CC 19613 504 31 to to TO 19613 504 32 shew shew VB 19613 504 33 that that IN 19613 504 34 she -PRON- PRP 19613 504 35 held hold VBD 19613 504 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 504 37 in in IN 19613 504 38 the the DT 19613 504 39 highest high JJS 19613 504 40 honour honour NN 19613 504 41 . . . 19613 505 1 Hitherto Hitherto NNP 19613 505 2 she -PRON- PRP 19613 505 3 had have VBD 19613 505 4 " " `` 19613 505 5 contented content VBN 19613 505 6 " " '' 19613 505 7 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 505 8 with with IN 19613 505 9 proving prove VBG 19613 505 10 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 505 11 legal legal JJ 19613 505 12 title title NN 19613 505 13 from from IN 19613 505 14 the the DT 19613 505 15 Old Old NNP 19613 505 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 505 17 , , , 19613 505 18 and and CC 19613 505 19 , , , 19613 505 20 passing pass VBG 19613 505 21 over over IN 19613 505 22 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 505 23 actual actual JJ 19613 505 24 origin origin NN 19613 505 25 , , , 19613 505 26 had have VBD 19613 505 27 dated date VBN 19613 505 28 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 505 29 back back RB 19613 505 30 to to IN 19613 505 31 the the DT 19613 505 32 beginning beginning NN 19613 505 33 of of IN 19613 505 34 all all DT 19613 505 35 things thing NNS 19613 505 36 . . . 19613 506 1 Marcion marcion NN 19613 506 2 and and CC 19613 506 3 the the DT 19613 506 4 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 506 5 were be VBD 19613 506 6 the the DT 19613 506 7 first first JJ 19613 506 8 who who WP 19613 506 9 energetically energetically RB 19613 506 10 pointed point VBD 19613 506 11 out out RP 19613 506 12 that that IN 19613 506 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 506 14 began begin VBD 19613 506 15 with with IN 19613 506 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 506 17 , , , 19613 506 18 and and CC 19613 506 19 that that IN 19613 506 20 all all DT 19613 506 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 506 22 was be VBD 19613 506 23 really really RB 19613 506 24 to to TO 19613 506 25 be be VB 19613 506 26 _ _ NNP 19613 506 27 tested test VBN 19613 506 28 _ _ NNP 19613 506 29 by by IN 19613 506 30 the the DT 19613 506 31 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 506 32 preaching preaching NNP 19613 506 33 , , , 19613 506 34 that that IN 19613 506 35 the the DT 19613 506 36 assumed assumed JJ 19613 506 37 identity identity NN 19613 506 38 of of IN 19613 506 39 Christian christian JJ 19613 506 40 common common JJ 19613 506 41 sense sense NN 19613 506 42 with with IN 19613 506 43 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 506 44 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 506 45 did do VBD 19613 506 46 not not RB 19613 506 47 exist exist VB 19613 506 48 , , , 19613 506 49 and and CC 19613 506 50 ( ( -LRB- 19613 506 51 so so RB 19613 506 52 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 506 53 said say VBD 19613 506 54 ) ) -RRB- 19613 506 55 that that IN 19613 506 56 the the DT 19613 506 57 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 506 58 contradicted contradict VBD 19613 506 59 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 506 60 . . . 19613 507 1 This this DT 19613 507 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 507 3 made make VBD 19613 507 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 507 5 necessary necessary JJ 19613 507 6 to to TO 19613 507 7 enter enter VB 19613 507 8 into into IN 19613 507 9 the the DT 19613 507 10 questions question NNS 19613 507 11 raised raise VBN 19613 507 12 by by IN 19613 507 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 507 14 opponents opponent NNS 19613 507 15 . . . 19613 508 1 But but CC 19613 508 2 , , , 19613 508 3 in in IN 19613 508 4 point point NN 19613 508 5 of of IN 19613 508 6 content content NN 19613 508 7 , , , 19613 508 8 the the DT 19613 508 9 problem problem NN 19613 508 10 of of IN 19613 508 11 proving prove VBG 19613 508 12 the the DT 19613 508 13 contested contest VBN 19613 508 14 identity identity NN 19613 508 15 was be VBD 19613 508 16 simply simply RB 19613 508 17 insoluble insoluble JJ 19613 508 18 , , , 19613 508 19 because because IN 19613 508 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 508 21 was be VBD 19613 508 22 endless endless JJ 19613 508 23 and and CC 19613 508 24 subject subject JJ 19613 508 25 to to IN 19613 508 26 question question NN 19613 508 27 on on IN 19613 508 28 every every DT 19613 508 29 particular particular JJ 19613 508 30 point point NN 19613 508 31 . . . 19613 509 1 The the DT 19613 509 2 " " `` 19613 509 3 unconscious unconscious JJ 19613 509 4 logic logic NN 19613 509 5 , , , 19613 509 6 " " '' 19613 509 7 that that DT 19613 509 8 is be VBZ 19613 509 9 the the DT 19613 509 10 logic logic NN 19613 509 11 of of IN 19613 509 12 self self NN 19613 509 13 - - HYPH 19613 509 14 preservation preservation NN 19613 509 15 , , , 19613 509 16 could could MD 19613 509 17 only only RB 19613 509 18 prescribe prescribe VB 19613 509 19 an an DT 19613 509 20 expedient expedient NN 19613 509 21 . . . 19613 510 1 The the DT 19613 510 2 Church Church NNP 19613 510 3 had have VBD 19613 510 4 to to TO 19613 510 5 collect collect VB 19613 510 6 everything everything NN 19613 510 7 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 510 8 and and CC 19613 510 9 declare declare VB 19613 510 10 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 510 11 to to TO 19613 510 12 be be VB 19613 510 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 510 14 only only JJ 19613 510 15 legal legal JJ 19613 510 16 possessor possessor NN 19613 510 17 . . . 19613 511 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 511 2 was be VBD 19613 511 3 obliged oblige VBN 19613 511 4 , , , 19613 511 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 511 6 , , , 19613 511 7 to to TO 19613 511 8 amalgamate amalgamate VB 19613 511 9 the the DT 19613 511 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 511 11 with with IN 19613 511 12 the the DT 19613 511 13 canon canon NN 19613 511 14 of of IN 19613 511 15 the the DT 19613 511 16 Old Old NNP 19613 511 17 Testament Testament NNP 19613 511 18 in in IN 19613 511 19 such such PDT 19613 511 20 a a DT 19613 511 21 way way NN 19613 511 22 as as IN 19613 511 23 to to TO 19613 511 24 fix fix VB 19613 511 25 the the DT 19613 511 26 exposition exposition NN 19613 511 27 from from IN 19613 511 28 the the DT 19613 511 29 very very RB 19613 511 30 first first JJ 19613 511 31 . . . 19613 512 1 But but CC 19613 512 2 what what WP 19613 512 3 writings writing NNS 19613 512 4 were be VBD 19613 512 5 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 512 6 ? ? . 19613 513 1 From from IN 19613 513 2 the the DT 19613 513 3 middle middle NN 19613 513 4 of of IN 19613 513 5 the the DT 19613 513 6 second second JJ 19613 513 7 century century NN 19613 513 8 great great JJ 19613 513 9 numbers number NNS 19613 513 10 of of IN 19613 513 11 writings writing NNS 19613 513 12 named name VBN 19613 513 13 after after IN 19613 513 14 the the DT 19613 513 15 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 513 16 had have VBD 19613 513 17 already already RB 19613 513 18 been be VBN 19613 513 19 in in IN 19613 513 20 circulation circulation NN 19613 513 21 , , , 19613 513 22 and and CC 19613 513 23 there there EX 19613 513 24 were be VBD 19613 513 25 often often RB 19613 513 26 different different JJ 19613 513 27 recensions recension NNS 19613 513 28 of of IN 19613 513 29 one one CD 19613 513 30 and and CC 19613 513 31 the the DT 19613 513 32 same same JJ 19613 513 33 writing writing NN 19613 513 34 . . . 19613 514 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 514 2 91 91 CD 19613 514 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 514 4 Versions version NNS 19613 514 5 which which WDT 19613 514 6 contained contain VBD 19613 514 7 docetic docetic JJ 19613 514 8 elements element NNS 19613 514 9 and and CC 19613 514 10 exhortations exhortation NNS 19613 514 11 to to IN 19613 514 12 the the DT 19613 514 13 most most RBS 19613 514 14 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 514 15 asceticism asceticism NN 19613 514 16 had have VBD 19613 514 17 even even RB 19613 514 18 made make VBN 19613 514 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 514 20 way way NN 19613 514 21 into into IN 19613 514 22 the the DT 19613 514 23 public public JJ 19613 514 24 worship worship NN 19613 514 25 of of IN 19613 514 26 the the DT 19613 514 27 Church Church NNP 19613 514 28 . . . 19613 515 1 Above above IN 19613 515 2 all all DT 19613 515 3 , , , 19613 515 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 515 5 , , , 19613 515 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 515 7 was be VBD 19613 515 8 necessary necessary JJ 19613 515 9 to to TO 19613 515 10 determine determine VB 19613 515 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 515 12 1 1 CD 19613 515 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 515 14 what what WP 19613 515 15 writings writing NNS 19613 515 16 were be VBD 19613 515 17 really really RB 19613 515 18 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 515 19 , , , 19613 515 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 515 21 2 2 LS 19613 515 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 515 23 what what WDT 19613 515 24 form form NN 19613 515 25 or or CC 19613 515 26 recension recension NN 19613 515 27 should should MD 19613 515 28 be be VB 19613 515 29 regarded regard VBN 19613 515 30 as as IN 19613 515 31 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 515 32 . . . 19613 516 1 The the DT 19613 516 2 selection selection NN 19613 516 3 was be VBD 19613 516 4 made make VBN 19613 516 5 by by IN 19613 516 6 the the DT 19613 516 7 Church Church NNP 19613 516 8 , , , 19613 516 9 that that RB 19613 516 10 is is RB 19613 516 11 , , , 19613 516 12 primarily primarily RB 19613 516 13 , , , 19613 516 14 by by IN 19613 516 15 the the DT 19613 516 16 churches church NNS 19613 516 17 of of IN 19613 516 18 Rome Rome NNP 19613 516 19 and and CC 19613 516 20 Asia Asia NNP 19613 516 21 Minor Minor NNP 19613 516 22 , , , 19613 516 23 which which WDT 19613 516 24 had have VBD 19613 516 25 still still RB 19613 516 26 an an DT 19613 516 27 unbroken unbroken JJ 19613 516 28 history history NN 19613 516 29 up up IN 19613 516 30 to to IN 19613 516 31 the the DT 19613 516 32 days day NNS 19613 516 33 of of IN 19613 516 34 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 516 35 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 19613 516 36 and and CC 19613 516 37 Commodus Commodus NNP 19613 516 38 . . . 19613 517 1 In in IN 19613 517 2 making make VBG 19613 517 3 this this DT 19613 517 4 choice choice NN 19613 517 5 , , , 19613 517 6 the the DT 19613 517 7 Church Church NNP 19613 517 8 limited limit VBD 19613 517 9 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 517 10 to to IN 19613 517 11 the the DT 19613 517 12 writings writing NNS 19613 517 13 that that WDT 19613 517 14 were be VBD 19613 517 15 used use VBN 19613 517 16 in in IN 19613 517 17 public public JJ 19613 517 18 worship worship NN 19613 517 19 , , , 19613 517 20 and and CC 19613 517 21 only only RB 19613 517 22 admitted admit VBD 19613 517 23 what what WP 19613 517 24 the the DT 19613 517 25 tradition tradition NN 19613 517 26 of of IN 19613 517 27 the the DT 19613 517 28 elders elder NNS 19613 517 29 justified justify VBD 19613 517 30 her -PRON- PRP 19613 517 31 in in IN 19613 517 32 regarding regard VBG 19613 517 33 as as IN 19613 517 34 genuinely genuinely RB 19613 517 35 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 517 36 . . . 19613 518 1 The the DT 19613 518 2 principle principle NN 19613 518 3 on on IN 19613 518 4 which which WDT 19613 518 5 she -PRON- PRP 19613 518 6 proceeded proceed VBD 19613 518 7 was be VBD 19613 518 8 to to TO 19613 518 9 reject reject VB 19613 518 10 as as IN 19613 518 11 spurious spurious JJ 19613 518 12 all all DT 19613 518 13 writings writing NNS 19613 518 14 , , , 19613 518 15 bearing bear VBG 19613 518 16 the the DT 19613 518 17 names name NNS 19613 518 18 of of IN 19613 518 19 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 518 20 , , , 19613 518 21 that that WDT 19613 518 22 contained contain VBD 19613 518 23 anything anything NN 19613 518 24 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 518 25 to to IN 19613 518 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 518 27 common common JJ 19613 518 28 sense sense NN 19613 518 29 , , , 19613 518 30 that that RB 19613 518 31 is is RB 19613 518 32 , , , 19613 518 33 to to IN 19613 518 34 the the DT 19613 518 35 rule rule NN 19613 518 36 of of IN 19613 518 37 faith faith NN 19613 518 38 -- -- : 19613 518 39 hence hence RB 19613 518 40 admission admission NN 19613 518 41 was be VBD 19613 518 42 refused refuse VBN 19613 518 43 to to IN 19613 518 44 all all DT 19613 518 45 books book NNS 19613 518 46 in in IN 19613 518 47 which which WDT 19613 518 48 the the DT 19613 518 49 God God NNP 19613 518 50 of of IN 19613 518 51 the the DT 19613 518 52 Old Old NNP 19613 518 53 Testament Testament NNP 19613 518 54 , , , 19613 518 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 518 56 creation creation NN 19613 518 57 , , , 19613 518 58 etc etc FW 19613 518 59 . . . 19613 518 60 , , , 19613 518 61 appeared appear VBD 19613 518 62 to to TO 19613 518 63 be be VB 19613 518 64 depreciated,--and depreciated,--and NNP 19613 518 65 to to TO 19613 518 66 exclude exclude VB 19613 518 67 all all DT 19613 518 68 recensions recension NNS 19613 518 69 of of IN 19613 518 70 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 518 71 writings writing NNS 19613 518 72 that that WDT 19613 518 73 seemed seem VBD 19613 518 74 to to TO 19613 518 75 endanger endanger VB 19613 518 76 the the DT 19613 518 77 Old Old NNP 19613 518 78 Testament Testament NNP 19613 518 79 and and CC 19613 518 80 the the DT 19613 518 81 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 518 82 of of IN 19613 518 83 God God NNP 19613 518 84 . . . 19613 519 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 519 2 retained retain VBD 19613 519 3 , , , 19613 519 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 519 5 , , , 19613 519 6 only only RB 19613 519 7 those those DT 19613 519 8 writings writing NNS 19613 519 9 which which WDT 19613 519 10 bore bear VBD 19613 519 11 the the DT 19613 519 12 names name NNS 19613 519 13 of of IN 19613 519 14 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 519 15 , , , 19613 519 16 or or CC 19613 519 17 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 519 18 writings writing NNS 19613 519 19 to to TO 19613 519 20 which which WDT 19613 519 21 she -PRON- PRP 19613 519 22 considered consider VBD 19613 519 23 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 519 24 justified justified JJ 19613 519 25 in in IN 19613 519 26 attaching attach VBG 19613 519 27 such such JJ 19613 519 28 names,[92 names,[92 CD 19613 519 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 519 30 and and CC 19613 519 31 whose whose WP$ 19613 519 32 contents content NNS 19613 519 33 were be VBD 19613 519 34 not not RB 19613 519 35 at at IN 19613 519 36 variance variance NN 19613 519 37 with with IN 19613 519 38 the the DT 19613 519 39 orthodox orthodox NNP 19613 519 40 creed creed NN 19613 519 41 or or CC 19613 519 42 attested attest VBD 19613 519 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 519 44 . . . 19613 520 1 This this DT 19613 520 2 selection selection NN 19613 520 3 resulted result VBD 19613 520 4 in in IN 19613 520 5 the the DT 19613 520 6 awkward awkward JJ 19613 520 7 fact fact NN 19613 520 8 that that IN 19613 520 9 besides besides IN 19613 520 10 the the DT 19613 520 11 four four CD 19613 520 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 520 13 there there EX 19613 520 14 was be VBD 19613 520 15 almost almost RB 19613 520 16 nothing nothing NN 19613 520 17 but but IN 19613 520 18 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 520 19 epistles epistle NNS 19613 520 20 to to TO 19613 520 21 dispose dispose VB 19613 520 22 of of IN 19613 520 23 , , , 19613 520 24 and and CC 19613 520 25 therefore therefore RB 19613 520 26 no no DT 19613 520 27 writings writing NNS 19613 520 28 or or CC 19613 520 29 almost almost RB 19613 520 30 none none NN 19613 520 31 which which WDT 19613 520 32 , , , 19613 520 33 as as IN 19613 520 34 emanating emanate VBG 19613 520 35 from from IN 19613 520 36 the the DT 19613 520 37 twelve twelve CD 19613 520 38 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 520 39 , , , 19613 520 40 could could MD 19613 520 41 immediately immediately RB 19613 520 42 confirm confirm VB 19613 520 43 the the DT 19613 520 44 truth truth NN 19613 520 45 of of IN 19613 520 46 the the DT 19613 520 47 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 520 48 _ _ NNP 19613 520 49 Kerygma Kerygma NNP 19613 520 50 _ _ NNP 19613 520 51 . . . 19613 521 1 _ _ NNP 19613 521 2 This this DT 19613 521 3 perplexity perplexity NN 19613 521 4 was be VBD 19613 521 5 removed remove VBN 19613 521 6 by by IN 19613 521 7 the the DT 19613 521 8 introduction introduction NN 19613 521 9 of of IN 19613 521 10 the the DT 19613 521 11 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 521 12 of of IN 19613 521 13 the the DT 19613 521 14 Apostles_[93 Apostles_[93 NNPS 19613 521 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 521 16 _ _ NNP 19613 521 17 and and CC 19613 521 18 in in IN 19613 521 19 some some DT 19613 521 20 cases case NNS 19613 521 21 also also RB 19613 521 22 the the DT 19613 521 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 521 24 of of IN 19613 521 25 Peter Peter NNP 19613 521 26 and and CC 19613 521 27 John John NNP 19613 521 28 _ _ NNP 19613 521 29 , , , 19613 521 30 though though IN 19613 521 31 that that DT 19613 521 32 of of IN 19613 521 33 Peter Peter NNP 19613 521 34 was be VBD 19613 521 35 not not RB 19613 521 36 recognised recognise VBN 19613 521 37 at at IN 19613 521 38 Rome Rome NNP 19613 521 39 at at IN 19613 521 40 first first RB 19613 521 41 . . . 19613 522 1 As as IN 19613 522 2 a a DT 19613 522 3 collection collection NN 19613 522 4 this this DT 19613 522 5 group group NN 19613 522 6 is be VBZ 19613 522 7 the the DT 19613 522 8 most most RBS 19613 522 9 interesting interesting JJ 19613 522 10 in in IN 19613 522 11 the the DT 19613 522 12 new new JJ 19613 522 13 compilation compilation NN 19613 522 14 . . . 19613 523 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 523 2 gives give VBZ 19613 523 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 523 4 the the DT 19613 523 5 stamp stamp NN 19613 523 6 of of IN 19613 523 7 Catholicity Catholicity NNP 19613 523 8 , , , 19613 523 9 unites unite VBZ 19613 523 10 the the DT 19613 523 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 523 12 with with IN 19613 523 13 the the DT 19613 523 14 Apostle apostle JJ 19613 523 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 523 16 Paul Paul NNP 19613 523 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 523 18 , , , 19613 523 19 and and CC 19613 523 20 , , , 19613 523 21 by by IN 19613 523 22 subordinating subordinate VBG 19613 523 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 523 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 523 25 to to IN 19613 523 26 the the DT 19613 523 27 " " `` 19613 523 28 Acta Acta NNP 19613 523 29 omnium omnium NN 19613 523 30 apostolorum apostolorum NN 19613 523 31 , , , 19613 523 32 " " `` 19613 523 33 makes make VBZ 19613 523 34 them -PRON- PRP 19613 523 35 witnesses witness NNS 19613 523 36 to to IN 19613 523 37 the the DT 19613 523 38 particular particular JJ 19613 523 39 tradition tradition NN 19613 523 40 that that WDT 19613 523 41 was be VBD 19613 523 42 required require VBN 19613 523 43 and and CC 19613 523 44 divests divest VBZ 19613 523 45 them -PRON- PRP 19613 523 46 of of IN 19613 523 47 every every DT 19613 523 48 thing thing NN 19613 523 49 suspicious suspicious JJ 19613 523 50 and and CC 19613 523 51 insufficient insufficient JJ 19613 523 52 . . . 19613 524 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 524 2 94 94 CD 19613 524 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 524 4 The the DT 19613 524 5 Church Church NNP 19613 524 6 , , , 19613 524 7 however however RB 19613 524 8 , , , 19613 524 9 found find VBD 19613 524 10 the the DT 19613 524 11 selection selection NN 19613 524 12 facilitated facilitate VBN 19613 524 13 by by IN 19613 524 14 the the DT 19613 524 15 fact fact NN 19613 524 16 that that IN 19613 524 17 the the DT 19613 524 18 content content NN 19613 524 19 of of IN 19613 524 20 the the DT 19613 524 21 early early JJ 19613 524 22 Christian christian JJ 19613 524 23 writings writing NNS 19613 524 24 was be VBD 19613 524 25 for for IN 19613 524 26 the the DT 19613 524 27 most most JJS 19613 524 28 part part NN 19613 524 29 unintelligible unintelligible JJ 19613 524 30 to to IN 19613 524 31 the the DT 19613 524 32 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 524 33 of of IN 19613 524 34 the the DT 19613 524 35 time time NN 19613 524 36 , , , 19613 524 37 whereas whereas IN 19613 524 38 the the DT 19613 524 39 late late JJ 19613 524 40 and and CC 19613 524 41 spurious spurious JJ 19613 524 42 additions addition NNS 19613 524 43 were be VBD 19613 524 44 betrayed betray VBN 19613 524 45 not not RB 19613 524 46 only only RB 19613 524 47 by by IN 19613 524 48 heretical heretical JJ 19613 524 49 theologoumena theologoumena NNP 19613 524 50 , , , 19613 524 51 but but CC 19613 524 52 also also RB 19613 524 53 and and CC 19613 524 54 above above IN 19613 524 55 all all DT 19613 524 56 by by IN 19613 524 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 524 58 profane profane NN 19613 524 59 lucidity lucidity NN 19613 524 60 . . . 19613 525 1 Thus thus RB 19613 525 2 arose arise VBD 19613 525 3 a a DT 19613 525 4 collection collection NN 19613 525 5 of of IN 19613 525 6 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 525 7 writings writing NNS 19613 525 8 , , , 19613 525 9 which which WDT 19613 525 10 in in IN 19613 525 11 extent extent NN 19613 525 12 may may MD 19613 525 13 not not RB 19613 525 14 have have VB 19613 525 15 been be VBN 19613 525 16 strikingly strikingly RB 19613 525 17 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 525 18 from from IN 19613 525 19 the the DT 19613 525 20 list list NN 19613 525 21 of of IN 19613 525 22 writings writing NNS 19613 525 23 that that IN 19613 525 24 for for IN 19613 525 25 more more JJR 19613 525 26 than than IN 19613 525 27 a a DT 19613 525 28 generation generation NN 19613 525 29 had have VBD 19613 525 30 formed form VBN 19613 525 31 the the DT 19613 525 32 chief chief JJ 19613 525 33 and and CC 19613 525 34 favourite favourite JJ 19613 525 35 reading reading NN 19613 525 36 in in IN 19613 525 37 the the DT 19613 525 38 communities community NNS 19613 525 39 . . . 19613 526 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 526 2 95 95 CD 19613 526 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 526 4 The the DT 19613 526 5 new new JJ 19613 526 6 collection collection NN 19613 526 7 was be VBD 19613 526 8 already already RB 19613 526 9 exalted exalted JJ 19613 526 10 to to IN 19613 526 11 a a DT 19613 526 12 high high JJ 19613 526 13 place place NN 19613 526 14 by by IN 19613 526 15 the the DT 19613 526 16 use use NN 19613 526 17 of of IN 19613 526 18 other other JJ 19613 526 19 writings writing NNS 19613 526 20 being be VBG 19613 526 21 prohibited prohibit VBN 19613 526 22 either either CC 19613 526 23 for for IN 19613 526 24 purposes purpose NNS 19613 526 25 of of IN 19613 526 26 general general JJ 19613 526 27 edification edification NN 19613 526 28 or or CC 19613 526 29 for for IN 19613 526 30 theological theological JJ 19613 526 31 ends end NNS 19613 526 32 . . . 19613 527 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 527 2 96 96 CD 19613 527 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 527 4 But but CC 19613 527 5 the the DT 19613 527 6 causes cause NNS 19613 527 7 and and CC 19613 527 8 motives motive NNS 19613 527 9 which which WDT 19613 527 10 led lead VBD 19613 527 11 to to IN 19613 527 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 527 13 being be VBG 19613 527 14 formed form VBN 19613 527 15 into into IN 19613 527 16 a a DT 19613 527 17 canon canon NN 19613 527 18 , , , 19613 527 19 that that RB 19613 527 20 is is RB 19613 527 21 , , , 19613 527 22 being be VBG 19613 527 23 placed place VBN 19613 527 24 on on IN 19613 527 25 a a DT 19613 527 26 footing footing NN 19613 527 27 of of IN 19613 527 28 complete complete JJ 19613 527 29 equality equality NN 19613 527 30 with with IN 19613 527 31 the the DT 19613 527 32 Old Old NNP 19613 527 33 Testament Testament NNP 19613 527 34 , , , 19613 527 35 may may MD 19613 527 36 be be VB 19613 527 37 gathered gather VBN 19613 527 38 partly partly RB 19613 527 39 from from IN 19613 527 40 the the DT 19613 527 41 earlier early JJR 19613 527 42 history history NN 19613 527 43 , , , 19613 527 44 partly partly RB 19613 527 45 from from IN 19613 527 46 the the DT 19613 527 47 mode mode NN 19613 527 48 of of IN 19613 527 49 using use VBG 19613 527 50 the the DT 19613 527 51 new new JJ 19613 527 52 Bible Bible NNP 19613 527 53 and and CC 19613 527 54 partly partly RB 19613 527 55 from from IN 19613 527 56 the the DT 19613 527 57 results result NNS 19613 527 58 attending attend VBG 19613 527 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 527 60 compilation compilation NN 19613 527 61 . . . 19613 528 1 First first RB 19613 528 2 , , , 19613 528 3 Words word NNS 19613 528 4 of of IN 19613 528 5 the the DT 19613 528 6 Lord Lord NNP 19613 528 7 and and CC 19613 528 8 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 528 9 utterances utterance NNS 19613 528 10 , , , 19613 528 11 including include VBG 19613 528 12 the the DT 19613 528 13 written write VBN 19613 528 14 records record NNS 19613 528 15 of of IN 19613 528 16 these these DT 19613 528 17 , , , 19613 528 18 had have VBD 19613 528 19 always always RB 19613 528 20 possessed possess VBN 19613 528 21 standard standard JJ 19613 528 22 authority authority NN 19613 528 23 in in IN 19613 528 24 the the DT 19613 528 25 Church Church NNP 19613 528 26 ; ; : 19613 528 27 there there EX 19613 528 28 were be VBD 19613 528 29 therefore therefore RB 19613 528 30 parts part NNS 19613 528 31 of of IN 19613 528 32 the the DT 19613 528 33 collection collection NN 19613 528 34 the the DT 19613 528 35 absolute absolute NNP 19613 528 36 authority authority NNP 19613 528 37 of of IN 19613 528 38 which which WDT 19613 528 39 was be VBD 19613 528 40 undoubted undoubted JJ 19613 528 41 from from IN 19613 528 42 the the DT 19613 528 43 first first JJ 19613 528 44 . . . 19613 529 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 529 2 97 97 CD 19613 529 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 529 4 Secondly secondly RB 19613 529 5 , , , 19613 529 6 what what WP 19613 529 7 was be VBD 19613 529 8 called call VBN 19613 529 9 " " `` 19613 529 10 Preaching Preaching NNP 19613 529 11 of of IN 19613 529 12 the the DT 19613 529 13 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 529 14 , , , 19613 529 15 " " '' 19613 529 16 " " `` 19613 529 17 Teaching teaching NN 19613 529 18 of of IN 19613 529 19 the the DT 19613 529 20 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 529 21 , , , 19613 529 22 " " '' 19613 529 23 etc etc FW 19613 529 24 . . . 19613 529 25 , , , 19613 529 26 was be VBD 19613 529 27 likewise likewise RB 19613 529 28 regarded regard VBN 19613 529 29 from from IN 19613 529 30 the the DT 19613 529 31 earliest early JJS 19613 529 32 times time NNS 19613 529 33 as as RB 19613 529 34 completely completely RB 19613 529 35 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 529 36 as as RB 19613 529 37 well well RB 19613 529 38 as as IN 19613 529 39 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 529 40 . . . 19613 530 1 There there EX 19613 530 2 had have VBD 19613 530 3 , , , 19613 530 4 however however RB 19613 530 5 , , , 19613 530 6 been be VBN 19613 530 7 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 530 8 no no DT 19613 530 9 motive motive NN 19613 530 10 for for IN 19613 530 11 fixing fix VBG 19613 530 12 this this DT 19613 530 13 in in IN 19613 530 14 documents document NNS 19613 530 15 , , , 19613 530 16 because because IN 19613 530 17 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 530 18 supposed suppose VBD 19613 530 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 530 20 possessed possess VBD 19613 530 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 530 22 in in IN 19613 530 23 a a DT 19613 530 24 state state NN 19613 530 25 of of IN 19613 530 26 purity purity NN 19613 530 27 and and CC 19613 530 28 reproduced reproduce VBD 19613 530 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 530 30 freely freely RB 19613 530 31 . . . 19613 531 1 The the DT 19613 531 2 moment moment NN 19613 531 3 the the DT 19613 531 4 Church church NN 19613 531 5 was be VBD 19613 531 6 called call VBN 19613 531 7 upon upon IN 19613 531 8 to to TO 19613 531 9 fix fix VB 19613 531 10 this this DT 19613 531 11 teaching teaching NN 19613 531 12 authentically authentically RB 19613 531 13 , , , 19613 531 14 and and CC 19613 531 15 this this DT 19613 531 16 denotes denote VBZ 19613 531 17 a a DT 19613 531 18 decisive decisive JJ 19613 531 19 revolution revolution NN 19613 531 20 , , , 19613 531 21 she -PRON- PRP 19613 531 22 was be VBD 19613 531 23 forced force VBN 19613 531 24 to to TO 19613 531 25 have have VB 19613 531 26 recourse recourse VBN 19613 531 27 to to IN 19613 531 28 _ _ NNP 19613 531 29 writings writing NNS 19613 531 30 _ _ NNP 19613 531 31 , , , 19613 531 32 whether whether IN 19613 531 33 she -PRON- PRP 19613 531 34 would would MD 19613 531 35 or or CC 19613 531 36 not not RB 19613 531 37 . . . 19613 532 1 The the DT 19613 532 2 attributes attribute NNS 19613 532 3 formerly formerly RB 19613 532 4 applied apply VBD 19613 532 5 to to IN 19613 532 6 the the DT 19613 532 7 testimony testimony NN 19613 532 8 of of IN 19613 532 9 the the DT 19613 532 10 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 532 11 , , , 19613 532 12 so so RB 19613 532 13 long long RB 19613 532 14 as as IN 19613 532 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 532 16 was be VBD 19613 532 17 not not RB 19613 532 18 collected collect VBN 19613 532 19 and and CC 19613 532 20 committed commit VBN 19613 532 21 to to IN 19613 532 22 writing writing NN 19613 532 23 , , , 19613 532 24 had have VBD 19613 532 25 now now RB 19613 532 26 to to TO 19613 532 27 be be VB 19613 532 28 transferred transfer VBN 19613 532 29 to to IN 19613 532 30 the the DT 19613 532 31 written write VBN 19613 532 32 records record NNS 19613 532 33 they -PRON- PRP 19613 532 34 had have VBD 19613 532 35 left leave VBN 19613 532 36 . . . 19613 533 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 533 2 , , , 19613 533 3 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 533 4 had have VBD 19613 533 5 already already RB 19613 533 6 taken take VBN 19613 533 7 the the DT 19613 533 8 lead lead NN 19613 533 9 in in IN 19613 533 10 forming form VBG 19613 533 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 533 12 writings writing NNS 19613 533 13 into into IN 19613 533 14 a a DT 19613 533 15 canon canon NN 19613 533 16 in in IN 19613 533 17 the the DT 19613 533 18 strict strict JJ 19613 533 19 sense sense NN 19613 533 20 of of IN 19613 533 21 the the DT 19613 533 22 word word NN 19613 533 23 . . . 19613 534 1 Fourthly fourthly RB 19613 534 2 , , , 19613 534 3 the the DT 19613 534 4 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 534 5 was be VBD 19613 534 6 at at IN 19613 534 7 once once RB 19613 534 8 fixed fix VBN 19613 534 9 by by IN 19613 534 10 forming form VBG 19613 534 11 the the DT 19613 534 12 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 534 13 writings writing NNS 19613 534 14 into into IN 19613 534 15 a a DT 19613 534 16 canon canon NN 19613 534 17 , , , 19613 534 18 and and CC 19613 534 19 placing place VBG 19613 534 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 534 21 on on IN 19613 534 22 an an DT 19613 534 23 equality equality NN 19613 534 24 with with IN 19613 534 25 the the DT 19613 534 26 Old Old NNP 19613 534 27 Testament Testament NNP 19613 534 28 , , , 19613 534 29 as as RB 19613 534 30 well well RB 19613 534 31 as as IN 19613 534 32 by by IN 19613 534 33 subordinating subordinate VBG 19613 534 34 troublesome troublesome JJ 19613 534 35 writings writing NNS 19613 534 36 to to IN 19613 534 37 the the DT 19613 534 38 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 534 39 of of IN 19613 534 40 the the DT 19613 534 41 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 534 42 . . . 19613 535 1 Considered consider VBN 19613 535 2 by by IN 19613 535 3 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 535 4 these these DT 19613 535 5 writings writing NNS 19613 535 6 , , , 19613 535 7 especially especially RB 19613 535 8 the the DT 19613 535 9 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 535 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 535 11 , , , 19613 535 12 presented present VBD 19613 535 13 the the DT 19613 535 14 greatest great JJS 19613 535 15 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 535 16 . . . 19613 536 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 536 2 can can MD 19613 536 3 see see VB 19613 536 4 even even RB 19613 536 5 yet yet RB 19613 536 6 from from IN 19613 536 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 536 8 and and CC 19613 536 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 536 10 that that IN 19613 536 11 the the DT 19613 536 12 duty duty NN 19613 536 13 of of IN 19613 536 14 accommodating accommodate VBG 19613 536 15 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 536 16 to to IN 19613 536 17 these these DT 19613 536 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 536 19 was be VBD 19613 536 20 _ _ NNP 19613 536 21 forced force VBN 19613 536 22 _ _ NNP 19613 536 23 upon upon IN 19613 536 24 the the DT 19613 536 25 Church Church NNP 19613 536 26 by by IN 19613 536 27 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 536 28 and and CC 19613 536 29 the the DT 19613 536 30 heretics heretic NNS 19613 536 31 , , , 19613 536 32 and and CC 19613 536 33 that that IN 19613 536 34 , , , 19613 536 35 but but CC 19613 536 36 for for IN 19613 536 37 this this DT 19613 536 38 constraint constraint NN 19613 536 39 , , , 19613 536 40 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 536 41 method method NN 19613 536 42 of of IN 19613 536 43 satisfying satisfy VBG 19613 536 44 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 536 45 as as IN 19613 536 46 to to IN 19613 536 47 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 536 48 relationship relationship NN 19613 536 49 to to IN 19613 536 50 them -PRON- PRP 19613 536 51 would would MD 19613 536 52 hardly hardly RB 19613 536 53 have have VB 19613 536 54 taken take VBN 19613 536 55 the the DT 19613 536 56 shape shape NN 19613 536 57 of of IN 19613 536 58 incorporating incorporate VBG 19613 536 59 them -PRON- PRP 19613 536 60 with with IN 19613 536 61 the the DT 19613 536 62 canon canon NN 19613 536 63 . . . 19613 537 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 537 2 98 98 CD 19613 537 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 537 4 This this DT 19613 537 5 shows show VBZ 19613 537 6 most most RBS 19613 537 7 clearly clearly RB 19613 537 8 that that IN 19613 537 9 the the DT 19613 537 10 collection collection NN 19613 537 11 of of IN 19613 537 12 writings writing NNS 19613 537 13 must must MD 19613 537 14 not not RB 19613 537 15 be be VB 19613 537 16 traced trace VBN 19613 537 17 to to IN 19613 537 18 the the DT 19613 537 19 Church Church NNP 19613 537 20 's 's POS 19613 537 21 effort effort NN 19613 537 22 to to TO 19613 537 23 create create VB 19613 537 24 for for IN 19613 537 25 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 537 26 a a DT 19613 537 27 powerful powerful JJ 19613 537 28 controversial controversial JJ 19613 537 29 weapon weapon NN 19613 537 30 . . . 19613 538 1 But but CC 19613 538 2 the the DT 19613 538 3 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 538 4 which which WDT 19613 538 5 the the DT 19613 538 6 compilation compilation NN 19613 538 7 presented present VBD 19613 538 8 so so RB 19613 538 9 long long RB 19613 538 10 as as IN 19613 538 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 538 12 was be VBD 19613 538 13 a a DT 19613 538 14 mere mere JJ 19613 538 15 collection collection NN 19613 538 16 vanished vanish VBD 19613 538 17 as as RB 19613 538 18 soon soon RB 19613 538 19 as as IN 19613 538 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 538 21 was be VBD 19613 538 22 viewed view VBN 19613 538 23 as as IN 19613 538 24 a a DT 19613 538 25 _ _ NNP 19613 538 26 sacred sacred JJ 19613 538 27 _ _ NNP 19613 538 28 collection collection NN 19613 538 29 . . . 19613 539 1 For for IN 19613 539 2 now now RB 19613 539 3 the the DT 19613 539 4 principle principle NN 19613 539 5 : : : 19613 539 6 " " `` 19613 539 7 as as IN 19613 539 8 the the DT 19613 539 9 teaching teaching NN 19613 539 10 of of IN 19613 539 11 the the DT 19613 539 12 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 539 13 was be VBD 19613 539 14 one one CD 19613 539 15 , , , 19613 539 16 so so RB 19613 539 17 also also RB 19613 539 18 is be VBZ 19613 539 19 the the DT 19613 539 20 tradition tradition NN 19613 539 21 " " '' 19613 539 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 539 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 539 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 539 25 : : : 19613 539 26 mia mia NNP 19613 539 27 hê hê NNP 19613 539 28 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 539 29 gegone gegone NNP 19613 539 30 tôn tôn NNP 19613 539 31 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 539 32 hôsper hôsper NNP 19613 539 33 didaskalia didaskalia NNP 19613 539 34 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 539 35 de de NNP 19613 539 36 kai kai NNP 19613 539 37 hê hê NNP 19613 539 38 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 539 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 539 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 539 41 was be VBD 19613 539 42 to to TO 19613 539 43 be be VB 19613 539 44 applied apply VBN 19613 539 45 to to IN 19613 539 46 all all DT 19613 539 47 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 539 48 and and CC 19613 539 49 objectionable objectionable JJ 19613 539 50 details detail NNS 19613 539 51 . . . 19613 540 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 540 2 99 99 CD 19613 540 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 540 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 540 5 was be VBD 19613 540 6 now now RB 19613 540 7 imperative imperative JJ 19613 540 8 to to TO 19613 540 9 explain explain VB 19613 540 10 one one CD 19613 540 11 writing writing NN 19613 540 12 by by IN 19613 540 13 another another DT 19613 540 14 ; ; : 19613 540 15 the the DT 19613 540 16 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 540 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 540 18 , , , 19613 540 19 for for IN 19613 540 20 example example NN 19613 540 21 , , , 19613 540 22 were be VBD 19613 540 23 to to TO 19613 540 24 be be VB 19613 540 25 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 540 26 by by IN 19613 540 27 the the DT 19613 540 28 Pastoral Pastoral NNP 19613 540 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 540 30 and and CC 19613 540 31 the the DT 19613 540 32 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 540 33 of of IN 19613 540 34 the the DT 19613 540 35 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 540 36 . . . 19613 541 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 541 2 100 100 CD 19613 541 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 541 4 Now now RB 19613 541 5 was be VBD 19613 541 6 required require VBN 19613 541 7 what what WP 19613 541 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 541 9 calls call VBZ 19613 541 10 the the DT 19613 541 11 " " `` 19613 541 12 mixture mixture NN 19613 541 13 " " '' 19613 541 14 of of IN 19613 541 15 the the DT 19613 541 16 Old Old NNP 19613 541 17 and and CC 19613 541 18 New New NNP 19613 541 19 Testaments,[101 Testaments,[101 NNP 19613 541 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 541 21 in in IN 19613 541 22 consequence consequence NN 19613 541 23 of of IN 19613 541 24 which which WDT 19613 541 25 the the DT 19613 541 26 full full JJ 19613 541 27 recognition recognition NN 19613 541 28 of of IN 19613 541 29 the the DT 19613 541 30 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 541 31 got get VBD 19613 541 32 from from IN 19613 541 33 the the DT 19613 541 34 old old JJ 19613 541 35 Bible Bible NNP 19613 541 36 was be VBD 19613 541 37 regarded regard VBN 19613 541 38 as as IN 19613 541 39 the the DT 19613 541 40 first first JJ 19613 541 41 law law NN 19613 541 42 for for IN 19613 541 43 the the DT 19613 541 44 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 541 45 of of IN 19613 541 46 the the DT 19613 541 47 new new JJ 19613 541 48 . . . 19613 542 1 The the DT 19613 542 2 formation formation NN 19613 542 3 of of IN 19613 542 4 the the DT 19613 542 5 new new JJ 19613 542 6 collection collection NN 19613 542 7 into into IN 19613 542 8 a a DT 19613 542 9 canon canon NN 19613 542 10 was be VBD 19613 542 11 therefore therefore RB 19613 542 12 an an DT 19613 542 13 immediate immediate JJ 19613 542 14 and and CC 19613 542 15 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 542 16 necessity necessity NN 19613 542 17 if if IN 19613 542 18 doubts doubt NNS 19613 542 19 of of IN 19613 542 20 all all DT 19613 542 21 kinds kind NNS 19613 542 22 were be VBD 19613 542 23 to to TO 19613 542 24 be be VB 19613 542 25 averted avert VBN 19613 542 26 . . . 19613 543 1 These these DT 19613 543 2 were be VBD 19613 543 3 abundantly abundantly RB 19613 543 4 excited excite VBN 19613 543 5 by by IN 19613 543 6 the the DT 19613 543 7 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 543 8 of of IN 19613 543 9 the the DT 19613 543 10 heretics heretic NNS 19613 543 11 ; ; : 19613 543 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 543 13 were be VBD 19613 543 14 got get VBN 19613 543 15 rid rid VBN 19613 543 16 of of IN 19613 543 17 by by IN 19613 543 18 making make VBG 19613 543 19 the the DT 19613 543 20 writings writing NNS 19613 543 21 into into IN 19613 543 22 a a DT 19613 543 23 canon canon NN 19613 543 24 . . . 19613 544 1 Fifthly fifthly RB 19613 544 2 , , , 19613 544 3 the the DT 19613 544 4 early early JJ 19613 544 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 544 6 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 544 7 more more RBR 19613 544 8 and and CC 19613 544 9 more more RBR 19613 544 10 decreased decrease VBD 19613 544 11 in in IN 19613 544 12 the the DT 19613 544 13 course course NN 19613 544 14 of of IN 19613 544 15 the the DT 19613 544 16 second second JJ 19613 544 17 century century NN 19613 544 18 ; ; : 19613 544 19 not not RB 19613 544 20 only only RB 19613 544 21 did do VBD 19613 544 22 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 544 23 , , , 19613 544 24 prophets prophet NNS 19613 544 25 , , , 19613 544 26 and and CC 19613 544 27 teachers teacher NNS 19613 544 28 die die VBP 19613 544 29 out out RP 19613 544 30 , , , 19613 544 31 but but CC 19613 544 32 the the DT 19613 544 33 religious religious JJ 19613 544 34 mood mood NN 19613 544 35 of of IN 19613 544 36 the the DT 19613 544 37 majority majority NN 19613 544 38 of of IN 19613 544 39 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 544 40 was be VBD 19613 544 41 changed change VBN 19613 544 42 . . . 19613 545 1 A a DT 19613 545 2 reflective reflective JJ 19613 545 3 piety piety NN 19613 545 4 took take VBD 19613 545 5 the the DT 19613 545 6 place place NN 19613 545 7 of of IN 19613 545 8 the the DT 19613 545 9 instinctive instinctive JJ 19613 545 10 religious religious JJ 19613 545 11 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 545 12 which which WDT 19613 545 13 made make VBD 19613 545 14 those those DT 19613 545 15 who who WP 19613 545 16 felt feel VBD 19613 545 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 545 18 believe believe VBP 19613 545 19 that that IN 19613 545 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 545 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 545 22 possessed possess VBD 19613 545 23 the the DT 19613 545 24 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 545 25 . . . 19613 546 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 546 2 102 102 CD 19613 546 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 546 4 Such such PDT 19613 546 5 a a DT 19613 546 6 piety piety NN 19613 546 7 requires require VBZ 19613 546 8 rules rule NNS 19613 546 9 ; ; , 19613 546 10 at at IN 19613 546 11 the the DT 19613 546 12 same same JJ 19613 546 13 time time NN 19613 546 14 , , , 19613 546 15 however however RB 19613 546 16 , , , 19613 546 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 546 18 is be VBZ 19613 546 19 characterised characterise VBN 19613 546 20 by by IN 19613 546 21 the the DT 19613 546 22 perception perception NN 19613 546 23 that that IN 19613 546 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 546 25 has have VBZ 19613 546 26 not not RB 19613 546 27 the the DT 19613 546 28 active active JJ 19613 546 29 and and CC 19613 546 30 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 19613 546 31 character character NN 19613 546 32 which which WDT 19613 546 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 546 34 ought ought MD 19613 546 35 to to TO 19613 546 36 have have VB 19613 546 37 , , , 19613 546 38 but but CC 19613 546 39 has have VBZ 19613 546 40 to to TO 19613 546 41 prove prove VB 19613 546 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 546 43 legitimacy legitimacy NN 19613 546 44 in in IN 19613 546 45 an an DT 19613 546 46 indirect indirect NN 19613 546 47 and and CC 19613 546 48 " " `` 19613 546 49 objective objective JJ 19613 546 50 " " '' 19613 546 51 way way NN 19613 546 52 . . . 19613 547 1 The the DT 19613 547 2 breach breach NN 19613 547 3 with with IN 19613 547 4 tradition tradition NN 19613 547 5 , , , 19613 547 6 the the DT 19613 547 7 deviation deviation NN 19613 547 8 from from IN 19613 547 9 the the DT 19613 547 10 original original JJ 19613 547 11 state state NN 19613 547 12 of of IN 19613 547 13 things thing NNS 19613 547 14 is be VBZ 19613 547 15 felt feel VBN 19613 547 16 and and CC 19613 547 17 recognised recognise VBN 19613 547 18 . . . 19613 548 1 Men man NNS 19613 548 2 , , , 19613 548 3 however however RB 19613 548 4 , , , 19613 548 5 conceal conceal NN 19613 548 6 from from IN 19613 548 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 548 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 548 9 own own JJ 19613 548 10 defects defect NNS 19613 548 11 , , , 19613 548 12 by by IN 19613 548 13 placing place VBG 19613 548 14 the the DT 19613 548 15 representatives representative NNS 19613 548 16 of of IN 19613 548 17 the the DT 19613 548 18 past past NN 19613 548 19 on on IN 19613 548 20 an an DT 19613 548 21 unattainable unattainable JJ 19613 548 22 height height NN 19613 548 23 , , , 19613 548 24 and and CC 19613 548 25 forming form VBG 19613 548 26 such such PDT 19613 548 27 an an DT 19613 548 28 estimate estimate NN 19613 548 29 of of IN 19613 548 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 548 31 qualities quality NNS 19613 548 32 as as IN 19613 548 33 makes make VBZ 19613 548 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 548 35 unlawful unlawful JJ 19613 548 36 and and CC 19613 548 37 impossible impossible JJ 19613 548 38 for for IN 19613 548 39 those those DT 19613 548 40 of of IN 19613 548 41 the the DT 19613 548 42 present present JJ 19613 548 43 generation generation NN 19613 548 44 , , , 19613 548 45 in in IN 19613 548 46 the the DT 19613 548 47 interests interest NNS 19613 548 48 of of IN 19613 548 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 548 50 own own JJ 19613 548 51 comfort comfort NN 19613 548 52 , , , 19613 548 53 to to TO 19613 548 54 compare compare VB 19613 548 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 548 56 with with IN 19613 548 57 them -PRON- PRP 19613 548 58 . . . 19613 549 1 When when WRB 19613 549 2 matters matter NNS 19613 549 3 reach reach VBP 19613 549 4 this this DT 19613 549 5 point point NN 19613 549 6 , , , 19613 549 7 great great JJ 19613 549 8 suspicion suspicion NN 19613 549 9 attaches attach VBZ 19613 549 10 to to IN 19613 549 11 those those DT 19613 549 12 who who WP 19613 549 13 hold hold VBP 19613 549 14 fast fast RB 19613 549 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 549 16 religious religious JJ 19613 549 17 independence independence NN 19613 549 18 and and CC 19613 549 19 wish wish VBP 19613 549 20 to to TO 19613 549 21 apply apply VB 19613 549 22 the the DT 19613 549 23 old old JJ 19613 549 24 standards standard NNS 19613 549 25 . . . 19613 550 1 Not not RB 19613 550 2 only only RB 19613 550 3 do do VBP 19613 550 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 550 5 seem seem VB 19613 550 6 arrogant arrogant JJ 19613 550 7 and and CC 19613 550 8 proud proud JJ 19613 550 9 , , , 19613 550 10 but but CC 19613 550 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 550 12 also also RB 19613 550 13 appear appear VBP 19613 550 14 disturbers disturber NNS 19613 550 15 of of IN 19613 550 16 the the DT 19613 550 17 necessary necessary JJ 19613 550 18 new new JJ 19613 550 19 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 550 20 which which WDT 19613 550 21 has have VBZ 19613 550 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 550 23 justification justification NN 19613 550 24 in in IN 19613 550 25 the the DT 19613 550 26 fact fact NN 19613 550 27 of of IN 19613 550 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 550 29 being be VBG 19613 550 30 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 550 31 . . . 19613 551 1 This this DT 19613 551 2 development development NN 19613 551 3 of of IN 19613 551 4 the the DT 19613 551 5 matter matter NN 19613 551 6 was be VBD 19613 551 7 , , , 19613 551 8 moreover moreover RB 19613 551 9 , , , 19613 551 10 of of IN 19613 551 11 the the DT 19613 551 12 greatest great JJS 19613 551 13 significance significance NN 19613 551 14 for for IN 19613 551 15 the the DT 19613 551 16 history history NN 19613 551 17 of of IN 19613 551 18 the the DT 19613 551 19 canon canon NN 19613 551 20 . . . 19613 552 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 552 2 creation creation NN 19613 552 3 very very RB 19613 552 4 speedily speedily RB 19613 552 5 resulted result VBD 19613 552 6 in in IN 19613 552 7 the the DT 19613 552 8 opinion opinion NN 19613 552 9 that that IN 19613 552 10 the the DT 19613 552 11 time time NN 19613 552 12 of of IN 19613 552 13 divine divine JJ 19613 552 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 552 15 had have VBD 19613 552 16 gone go VBN 19613 552 17 past past RB 19613 552 18 and and CC 19613 552 19 was be VBD 19613 552 20 exhausted exhaust VBN 19613 552 21 in in IN 19613 552 22 the the DT 19613 552 23 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 552 24 , , , 19613 552 25 that that RB 19613 552 26 is is RB 19613 552 27 , , , 19613 552 28 in in IN 19613 552 29 the the DT 19613 552 30 records record NNS 19613 552 31 left leave VBN 19613 552 32 by by IN 19613 552 33 them -PRON- PRP 19613 552 34 . . . 19613 553 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 553 2 can can MD 19613 553 3 not not RB 19613 553 4 prove prove VB 19613 553 5 with with IN 19613 553 6 certainty certainty NN 19613 553 7 that that IN 19613 553 8 the the DT 19613 553 9 canon canon NN 19613 553 10 was be VBD 19613 553 11 formed form VBN 19613 553 12 to to TO 19613 553 13 confirm confirm VB 19613 553 14 this this DT 19613 553 15 opinion opinion NN 19613 553 16 , , , 19613 553 17 but but CC 19613 553 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 553 19 can can MD 19613 553 20 show show VB 19613 553 21 that that IN 19613 553 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 553 23 was be VBD 19613 553 24 very very RB 19613 553 25 soon soon RB 19613 553 26 used use VBN 19613 553 27 to to TO 19613 553 28 oppose oppose VB 19613 553 29 those those DT 19613 553 30 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 553 31 who who WP 19613 553 32 professed profess VBD 19613 553 33 to to TO 19613 553 34 be be VB 19613 553 35 prophets prophet NNS 19613 553 36 or or CC 19613 553 37 appealed appeal VBD 19613 553 38 to to IN 19613 553 39 the the DT 19613 553 40 continuance continuance NN 19613 553 41 of of IN 19613 553 42 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 553 43 . . . 19613 554 1 The the DT 19613 554 2 influence influence NN 19613 554 3 which which WDT 19613 554 4 the the DT 19613 554 5 canon canon NN 19613 554 6 exercised exercise VBD 19613 554 7 in in IN 19613 554 8 this this DT 19613 554 9 respect respect NN 19613 554 10 is be VBZ 19613 554 11 the the DT 19613 554 12 most most RBS 19613 554 13 decisive decisive JJ 19613 554 14 and and CC 19613 554 15 important important JJ 19613 554 16 . . . 19613 555 1 That that DT 19613 555 2 which which WDT 19613 555 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 555 4 , , , 19613 555 5 as as IN 19613 555 6 a a DT 19613 555 7 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 555 8 , , , 19613 555 9 asserts assert VBZ 19613 555 10 of of IN 19613 555 11 one one CD 19613 555 12 of of IN 19613 555 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 555 14 opponents opponent NNS 19613 555 15 : : : 19613 555 16 " " `` 19613 555 17 Prophetiam prophetiam RB 19613 555 18 expulit expulit VBD 19613 555 19 , , , 19613 555 20 paracletum paracletum JJ 19613 555 21 fugavit fugavit NN 19613 555 22 " " '' 19613 555 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 555 24 " " '' 19613 555 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 555 26 expelled expel VBD 19613 555 27 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 555 28 , , , 19613 555 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 555 30 drove drive VBD 19613 555 31 away away RB 19613 555 32 the the DT 19613 555 33 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 555 34 " " '' 19613 555 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 555 36 , , , 19613 555 37 can can MD 19613 555 38 be be VB 19613 555 39 far far RB 19613 555 40 more more RBR 19613 555 41 truly truly RB 19613 555 42 said say VBD 19613 555 43 of of IN 19613 555 44 the the DT 19613 555 45 New New NNP 19613 555 46 Testament Testament NNP 19613 555 47 which which WDT 19613 555 48 the the DT 19613 555 49 same same JJ 19613 555 50 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 555 51 as as IN 19613 555 52 a a DT 19613 555 53 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 555 54 recognised recognise VBD 19613 555 55 . . . 19613 556 1 The the DT 19613 556 2 New New NNP 19613 556 3 Testament Testament NNP 19613 556 4 , , , 19613 556 5 though though IN 19613 556 6 not not RB 19613 556 7 all all DT 19613 556 8 at at IN 19613 556 9 once once RB 19613 556 10 , , , 19613 556 11 put put VB 19613 556 12 an an DT 19613 556 13 end end NN 19613 556 14 to to IN 19613 556 15 a a DT 19613 556 16 situation situation NN 19613 556 17 where where WRB 19613 556 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 556 19 was be VBD 19613 556 20 possible possible JJ 19613 556 21 for for IN 19613 556 22 any any DT 19613 556 23 Christian Christian NNP 19613 556 24 under under IN 19613 556 25 the the DT 19613 556 26 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 556 27 of of IN 19613 556 28 the the DT 19613 556 29 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 556 30 to to TO 19613 556 31 give give VB 19613 556 32 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 556 33 disclosures disclosure NNS 19613 556 34 and and CC 19613 556 35 instructions instruction NNS 19613 556 36 . . . 19613 557 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 557 2 likewise likewise RB 19613 557 3 prevented prevent VBD 19613 557 4 belief belief NN 19613 557 5 in in IN 19613 557 6 the the DT 19613 557 7 fanciful fanciful JJ 19613 557 8 creations creation NNS 19613 557 9 with with IN 19613 557 10 which which WDT 19613 557 11 such such JJ 19613 557 12 men man NNS 19613 557 13 enriched enrich VBD 19613 557 14 the the DT 19613 557 15 history history NN 19613 557 16 of of IN 19613 557 17 the the DT 19613 557 18 past past NN 19613 557 19 , , , 19613 557 20 and and CC 19613 557 21 destroyed destroy VBD 19613 557 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 557 23 pretensions pretension NNS 19613 557 24 to to TO 19613 557 25 read read VB 19613 557 26 the the DT 19613 557 27 future future NN 19613 557 28 . . . 19613 558 1 As as IN 19613 558 2 the the DT 19613 558 3 creation creation NN 19613 558 4 of of IN 19613 558 5 the the DT 19613 558 6 canon canon NN 19613 558 7 , , , 19613 558 8 though though IN 19613 558 9 not not RB 19613 558 10 in in IN 19613 558 11 a a DT 19613 558 12 hard hard JJ 19613 558 13 and and CC 19613 558 14 fast fast JJ 19613 558 15 way way NN 19613 558 16 , , , 19613 558 17 fixed fix VBD 19613 558 18 the the DT 19613 558 19 period period NN 19613 558 20 of of IN 19613 558 21 the the DT 19613 558 22 production production NN 19613 558 23 of of IN 19613 558 24 sacred sacred JJ 19613 558 25 facts fact NNS 19613 558 26 , , , 19613 558 27 so so CC 19613 558 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 558 29 put put VBD 19613 558 30 down down RP 19613 558 31 all all DT 19613 558 32 claims claim NNS 19613 558 33 of of IN 19613 558 34 Christian christian JJ 19613 558 35 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 558 36 to to IN 19613 558 37 public public JJ 19613 558 38 credence credence NN 19613 558 39 . . . 19613 559 1 Through through IN 19613 559 2 the the DT 19613 559 3 canon canon NN 19613 559 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 559 5 came come VBD 19613 559 6 to to TO 19613 559 7 be be VB 19613 559 8 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 559 9 that that IN 19613 559 10 all all DT 19613 559 11 post post JJ 19613 559 12 - - JJ 19613 559 13 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 559 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 559 15 is be VBZ 19613 559 16 only only RB 19613 559 17 of of IN 19613 559 18 a a DT 19613 559 19 mediate mediate JJ 19613 559 20 and and CC 19613 559 21 particular particular JJ 19613 559 22 kind kind NN 19613 559 23 , , , 19613 559 24 and and CC 19613 559 25 can can MD 19613 559 26 therefore therefore RB 19613 559 27 never never RB 19613 559 28 be be VB 19613 559 29 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 559 30 a a DT 19613 559 31 standard standard NN 19613 559 32 . . . 19613 560 1 The the DT 19613 560 2 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 560 3 alone alone RB 19613 560 4 possessed possess VBD 19613 560 5 the the DT 19613 560 6 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 560 7 of of IN 19613 560 8 God God NNP 19613 560 9 completely completely RB 19613 560 10 and and CC 19613 560 11 without without IN 19613 560 12 measure measure NN 19613 560 13 . . . 19613 561 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 561 2 only only RB 19613 561 3 , , , 19613 561 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 561 5 , , , 19613 561 6 are be VBP 19613 561 7 the the DT 19613 561 8 media medium NNS 19613 561 9 of of IN 19613 561 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 561 11 , , , 19613 561 12 and and CC 19613 561 13 by by IN 19613 561 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 561 15 word word NN 19613 561 16 alone alone RB 19613 561 17 , , , 19613 561 18 which which WDT 19613 561 19 , , , 19613 561 20 as as IN 19613 561 21 emanating emanate VBG 19613 561 22 from from IN 19613 561 23 the the DT 19613 561 24 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 561 25 , , , 19613 561 26 is be VBZ 19613 561 27 of of IN 19613 561 28 equal equal JJ 19613 561 29 authority authority NN 19613 561 30 with with IN 19613 561 31 the the DT 19613 561 32 word word NN 19613 561 33 of of IN 19613 561 34 Christ Christ NNP 19613 561 35 , , , 19613 561 36 all all DT 19613 561 37 that that WDT 19613 561 38 is be VBZ 19613 561 39 Christian Christian NNP 19613 561 40 must must MD 19613 561 41 be be VB 19613 561 42 tested test VBN 19613 561 43 . . . 19613 562 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 562 2 103 103 CD 19613 562 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 562 4 The the DT 19613 562 5 Holy Holy NNP 19613 562 6 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 562 7 and and CC 19613 562 8 the the DT 19613 562 9 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 562 10 became become VBD 19613 562 11 correlative correlative JJ 19613 562 12 conceptions conception NNS 19613 562 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 562 14 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 562 15 . . NNP 19613 562 16 , , , 19613 562 17 de de NNP 19613 562 18 pudic pudic NNP 19613 562 19 . . . 19613 563 1 21 21 CD 19613 563 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 563 3 . . . 19613 564 1 The the DT 19613 564 2 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 564 3 , , , 19613 564 4 however however RB 19613 564 5 , , , 19613 564 6 were be VBD 19613 564 7 more more JJR 19613 564 8 and and CC 19613 564 9 more more RBR 19613 564 10 overshadowed overshadow VBN 19613 564 11 by by IN 19613 564 12 the the DT 19613 564 13 New New NNP 19613 564 14 Testament Testament NNP 19613 564 15 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 564 16 ; ; : 19613 564 17 and and CC 19613 564 18 this this DT 19613 564 19 was be VBD 19613 564 20 in in IN 19613 564 21 fact fact NN 19613 564 22 an an DT 19613 564 23 advance advance NN 19613 564 24 beyond beyond IN 19613 564 25 the the DT 19613 564 26 earlier early JJR 19613 564 27 state state NN 19613 564 28 of of IN 19613 564 29 things thing NNS 19613 564 30 , , , 19613 564 31 for for IN 19613 564 32 what what WP 19613 564 33 was be VBD 19613 564 34 known know VBN 19613 564 35 of of IN 19613 564 36 the the DT 19613 564 37 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 564 38 ? ? . 19613 565 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 565 2 , , , 19613 565 3 _ _ NNP 19613 565 4 as as IN 19613 565 5 authors author NNS 19613 565 6 of of IN 19613 565 7 these these DT 19613 565 8 writings writing NNS 19613 565 9 _ _ NNP 19613 565 10 , , , 19613 565 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 565 12 and and CC 19613 565 13 the the DT 19613 565 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 565 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 565 16 became become VBD 19613 565 17 correlative correlative JJ 19613 565 18 conceptions conception NNS 19613 565 19 . . . 19613 566 1 This this DT 19613 566 2 led lead VBD 19613 566 3 to to IN 19613 566 4 the the DT 19613 566 5 assumption assumption NN 19613 566 6 that that IN 19613 566 7 the the DT 19613 566 8 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 566 9 writings writing NNS 19613 566 10 were be VBD 19613 566 11 inspired inspire VBN 19613 566 12 , , , 19613 566 13 that that RB 19613 566 14 is is RB 19613 566 15 , , , 19613 566 16 in in IN 19613 566 17 the the DT 19613 566 18 full full JJ 19613 566 19 and and CC 19613 566 20 only only JJ 19613 566 21 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 566 22 sense sense NN 19613 566 23 attached attach VBN 19613 566 24 to to IN 19613 566 25 the the DT 19613 566 26 word word NN 19613 566 27 by by IN 19613 566 28 the the DT 19613 566 29 ancients ancient NNS 19613 566 30 . . . 19613 567 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 567 2 104 104 CD 19613 567 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 567 4 By by IN 19613 567 5 this this DT 19613 567 6 assumption assumption NN 19613 567 7 the the DT 19613 567 8 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 567 9 , , , 19613 567 10 viewed view VBD 19613 567 11 as as IN 19613 567 12 _ _ NNP 19613 567 13 prophets prophet NNS 19613 567 14 _ _ NNP 19613 567 15 , , , 19613 567 16 received receive VBD 19613 567 17 a a DT 19613 567 18 significance significance NN 19613 567 19 quite quite RB 19613 567 20 equal equal JJ 19613 567 21 to to IN 19613 567 22 that that DT 19613 567 23 of of IN 19613 567 24 Old Old NNP 19613 567 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 567 26 writers writer NNS 19613 567 27 . . . 19613 568 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 568 2 105 105 CD 19613 568 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 568 4 But but CC 19613 568 5 , , , 19613 568 6 though though IN 19613 568 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 568 8 and and CC 19613 568 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 568 10 placed place VBD 19613 568 11 both both DT 19613 568 12 parties party NNS 19613 568 13 on on IN 19613 568 14 a a DT 19613 568 15 level level NN 19613 568 16 , , , 19613 568 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 568 18 preserved preserve VBD 19613 568 19 a a DT 19613 568 20 distinction distinction NN 19613 568 21 between between IN 19613 568 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 568 23 by by IN 19613 568 24 basing base VBG 19613 568 25 the the DT 19613 568 26 whole whole JJ 19613 568 27 authority authority NN 19613 568 28 of of IN 19613 568 29 the the DT 19613 568 30 New New NNP 19613 568 31 Testament Testament NNP 19613 568 32 on on IN 19613 568 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 568 34 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 568 35 origin origin NN 19613 568 36 , , , 19613 568 37 the the DT 19613 568 38 concept concept NN 19613 568 39 " " `` 19613 568 40 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 568 41 " " '' 19613 568 42 being be VBG 19613 568 43 much much RB 19613 568 44 more more RBR 19613 568 45 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 568 46 than than IN 19613 568 47 that that DT 19613 568 48 of of IN 19613 568 49 " " `` 19613 568 50 prophet prophet NN 19613 568 51 . . . 19613 568 52 " " '' 19613 569 1 These these DT 19613 569 2 men man NNS 19613 569 3 , , , 19613 569 4 being be VBG 19613 569 5 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 569 6 , , , 19613 569 7 that that RB 19613 569 8 is be VBZ 19613 569 9 men man NNS 19613 569 10 chosen choose VBN 19613 569 11 by by IN 19613 569 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 569 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 569 14 and and CC 19613 569 15 entrusted entrust VBD 19613 569 16 with with IN 19613 569 17 the the DT 19613 569 18 proclamation proclamation NN 19613 569 19 of of IN 19613 569 20 the the DT 19613 569 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 569 22 , , , 19613 569 23 have have VBP 19613 569 24 for for IN 19613 569 25 that that DT 19613 569 26 reason reason NN 19613 569 27 received receive VBD 19613 569 28 the the DT 19613 569 29 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 569 30 , , , 19613 569 31 and and CC 19613 569 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 569 33 writings writing NNS 19613 569 34 are be VBP 19613 569 35 filled fill VBN 19613 569 36 with with IN 19613 569 37 the the DT 19613 569 38 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 569 39 . . . 19613 570 1 To to IN 19613 570 2 the the DT 19613 570 3 minds mind NNS 19613 570 4 of of IN 19613 570 5 Western Western NNP 19613 570 6 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 570 7 the the DT 19613 570 8 primary primary JJ 19613 570 9 feature feature NN 19613 570 10 in in IN 19613 570 11 the the DT 19613 570 12 collection collection NN 19613 570 13 is be VBZ 19613 570 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 570 15 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 570 16 authorship authorship NN 19613 570 17 . . . 19613 571 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 571 2 106 106 CD 19613 571 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 571 4 This this DT 19613 571 5 implies imply VBZ 19613 571 6 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 571 7 also also RB 19613 571 8 , , , 19613 571 9 because because IN 19613 571 10 the the DT 19613 571 11 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 571 12 can can MD 19613 571 13 not not RB 19613 571 14 be be VB 19613 571 15 inferior inferior JJ 19613 571 16 to to IN 19613 571 17 the the DT 19613 571 18 writers writer NNS 19613 571 19 of of IN 19613 571 20 the the DT 19613 571 21 Old Old NNP 19613 571 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 571 23 . . . 19613 572 1 For for IN 19613 572 2 that that DT 19613 572 3 very very JJ 19613 572 4 reason reason NN 19613 572 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 572 6 could could MD 19613 572 7 , , , 19613 572 8 in in IN 19613 572 9 a a DT 19613 572 10 much much RB 19613 572 11 more more RBR 19613 572 12 radical radical JJ 19613 572 13 way way NN 19613 572 14 , , , 19613 572 15 rid rid VBD 19613 572 16 the the DT 19613 572 17 new new JJ 19613 572 18 collection collection NN 19613 572 19 of of IN 19613 572 20 everything everything NN 19613 572 21 that that WDT 19613 572 22 was be VBD 19613 572 23 not not RB 19613 572 24 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 572 25 . . . 19613 573 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 573 2 even even RB 19613 573 3 rejected reject VBD 19613 573 4 writings writing NNS 19613 573 5 which which WDT 19613 573 6 , , , 19613 573 7 in in IN 19613 573 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 573 9 form form NN 19613 573 10 , , , 19613 573 11 plainly plainly RB 19613 573 12 claimed claim VBD 19613 573 13 the the DT 19613 573 14 character character NN 19613 573 15 of of IN 19613 573 16 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 573 17 ; ; , 19613 573 18 and and CC 19613 573 19 this this DT 19613 573 20 was be VBD 19613 573 21 evidently evidently RB 19613 573 22 done do VBN 19613 573 23 because because IN 19613 573 24 they -PRON- PRP 19613 573 25 did do VBD 19613 573 26 not not RB 19613 573 27 attribute attribute VB 19613 573 28 to to IN 19613 573 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 573 30 the the DT 19613 573 31 degree degree NN 19613 573 32 of of IN 19613 573 33 authority authority NN 19613 573 34 which which WDT 19613 573 35 , , , 19613 573 36 in in IN 19613 573 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 573 38 view view NN 19613 573 39 , , , 19613 573 40 only only RB 19613 573 41 belonged belong VBD 19613 573 42 to to IN 19613 573 43 that that DT 19613 573 44 which which WDT 19613 573 45 was be VBD 19613 573 46 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 573 47 . . . 19613 574 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 574 2 107 107 CD 19613 574 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 574 4 The the DT 19613 574 5 new new JJ 19613 574 6 canon canon NN 19613 574 7 of of IN 19613 574 8 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 574 9 set set VBN 19613 574 10 up up RP 19613 574 11 by by IN 19613 574 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 574 13 and and CC 19613 574 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 574 15 primarily primarily RB 19613 574 16 professes profess VBZ 19613 574 17 to to TO 19613 574 18 be be VB 19613 574 19 nothing nothing NN 19613 574 20 else else RB 19613 574 21 than than IN 19613 574 22 a a DT 19613 574 23 collection collection NN 19613 574 24 of of IN 19613 574 25 _ _ NNP 19613 574 26 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 574 27 _ _ NNP 19613 574 28 writings writing NNS 19613 574 29 , , , 19613 574 30 which which WDT 19613 574 31 , , , 19613 574 32 as as IN 19613 574 33 such such JJ 19613 574 34 , , , 19613 574 35 claim claim VB 19613 574 36 absolute absolute JJ 19613 574 37 authority authority NNP 19613 574 38 . . . 19613 575 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 575 2 108 108 CD 19613 575 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 575 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 575 5 takes take VBZ 19613 575 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 575 7 place place NN 19613 575 8 beside beside IN 19613 575 9 the the DT 19613 575 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 575 11 rule rule NN 19613 575 12 of of IN 19613 575 13 faith faith NN 19613 575 14 ; ; : 19613 575 15 and and CC 19613 575 16 by by IN 19613 575 17 this this DT 19613 575 18 faithfully faithfully RB 19613 575 19 preserved preserve VBN 19613 575 20 possession possession NN 19613 575 21 , , , 19613 575 22 the the DT 19613 575 23 Church Church NNP 19613 575 24 scattered scatter VBD 19613 575 25 over over IN 19613 575 26 the the DT 19613 575 27 world world NN 19613 575 28 proves prove VBZ 19613 575 29 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 575 30 to to TO 19613 575 31 be be VB 19613 575 32 that that DT 19613 575 33 of of IN 19613 575 34 the the DT 19613 575 35 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 575 36 . . . 19613 576 1 But but CC 19613 576 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 576 3 are be VBP 19613 576 4 very very RB 19613 576 5 far far RB 19613 576 6 from from IN 19613 576 7 being be VBG 19613 576 8 able able JJ 19613 576 9 to to TO 19613 576 10 show show VB 19613 576 11 that that IN 19613 576 12 such such PDT 19613 576 13 a a DT 19613 576 14 rigidly rigidly RB 19613 576 15 fixed fix VBN 19613 576 16 collection collection NN 19613 576 17 of of IN 19613 576 18 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 576 19 writings writing NNS 19613 576 20 existed exist VBD 19613 576 21 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 576 22 in in IN 19613 576 23 the the DT 19613 576 24 Church Church NNP 19613 576 25 about about IN 19613 576 26 the the DT 19613 576 27 year year NN 19613 576 28 200 200 CD 19613 576 29 . . . 19613 577 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 577 2 is be VBZ 19613 577 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 577 4 continually continually RB 19613 577 5 asserted assert VBN 19613 577 6 that that IN 19613 577 7 the the DT 19613 577 8 Antiochian Antiochian NNP 19613 577 9 and and CC 19613 577 10 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 577 11 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 577 12 had have VBD 19613 577 13 at at IN 19613 577 14 that that DT 19613 577 15 date date NN 19613 577 16 a a DT 19613 577 17 New New NNP 19613 577 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 577 19 which which WDT 19613 577 20 , , , 19613 577 21 in in IN 19613 577 22 extent extent NN 19613 577 23 and and CC 19613 577 24 authority authority NN 19613 577 25 , , , 19613 577 26 essentially essentially RB 19613 577 27 coincided coincide VBD 19613 577 28 with with IN 19613 577 29 that that DT 19613 577 30 of of IN 19613 577 31 the the DT 19613 577 32 Roman Roman NNP 19613 577 33 Church Church NNP 19613 577 34 ; ; : 19613 577 35 but but CC 19613 577 36 this this DT 19613 577 37 opinion opinion NN 19613 577 38 is be VBZ 19613 577 39 not not RB 19613 577 40 well well RB 19613 577 41 founded found VBN 19613 577 42 . . . 19613 578 1 As as RB 19613 578 2 far far RB 19613 578 3 as as IN 19613 578 4 the the DT 19613 578 5 Church Church NNP 19613 578 6 of of IN 19613 578 7 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 578 8 is be VBZ 19613 578 9 immediately immediately RB 19613 578 10 concerned concern VBN 19613 578 11 , , , 19613 578 12 the the DT 19613 578 13 letter letter NN 19613 578 14 of of IN 19613 578 15 Bishop Bishop NNP 19613 578 16 Serapion Serapion NNP 19613 578 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 578 18 whose whose WP$ 19613 578 19 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 578 20 lasted last VBD 19613 578 21 from from IN 19613 578 22 about about IN 19613 578 23 190 190 CD 19613 578 24 to to TO 19613 578 25 about about IN 19613 578 26 209 209 CD 19613 578 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 578 28 , , , 19613 578 29 given give VBN 19613 578 30 in in IN 19613 578 31 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 578 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 578 33 VI VI NNP 19613 578 34 . . . 19613 579 1 12 12 CD 19613 579 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 579 3 , , , 19613 579 4 clearly clearly RB 19613 579 5 shows show VBZ 19613 579 6 that that IN 19613 579 7 Cilicia Cilicia NNP 19613 579 8 and and CC 19613 579 9 probably probably RB 19613 579 10 also also RB 19613 579 11 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 579 12 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 579 13 as as RB 19613 579 14 yet yet RB 19613 579 15 possessed possess VBN 19613 579 16 no no DT 19613 579 17 such such JJ 19613 579 18 thing thing NN 19613 579 19 as as IN 19613 579 20 a a DT 19613 579 21 completed complete VBN 19613 579 22 New New NNP 19613 579 23 Testament Testament NNP 19613 579 24 . . . 19613 580 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 580 2 is be VBZ 19613 580 3 evident evident JJ 19613 580 4 that that IN 19613 580 5 Serapion Serapion NNP 19613 580 6 already already RB 19613 580 7 holds hold VBZ 19613 580 8 the the DT 19613 580 9 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 580 10 principle principle NN 19613 580 11 that that IN 19613 580 12 all all DT 19613 580 13 words word NNS 19613 580 14 of of IN 19613 580 15 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 580 16 possess possess VBP 19613 580 17 the the DT 19613 580 18 same same JJ 19613 580 19 value value NN 19613 580 20 to to IN 19613 580 21 the the DT 19613 580 22 Church Church NNP 19613 580 23 as as IN 19613 580 24 words word NNS 19613 580 25 of of IN 19613 580 26 the the DT 19613 580 27 Lord Lord NNP 19613 580 28 ; ; : 19613 580 29 but but CC 19613 580 30 a a DT 19613 580 31 completed complete VBN 19613 580 32 collection collection NN 19613 580 33 of of IN 19613 580 34 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 580 35 writings writing NNS 19613 580 36 was be VBD 19613 580 37 not not RB 19613 580 38 yet yet RB 19613 580 39 at at IN 19613 580 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 580 41 disposal disposal NN 19613 580 42 . . . 19613 581 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 581 2 109 109 CD 19613 581 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 581 4 Hence hence RB 19613 581 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 581 6 is be VBZ 19613 581 7 very very RB 19613 581 8 improbable improbable JJ 19613 581 9 that that IN 19613 581 10 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 581 11 , , , 19613 581 12 bishop bishop NN 19613 581 13 of of IN 19613 581 14 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 581 15 , , , 19613 581 16 who who WP 19613 581 17 died die VBD 19613 581 18 as as RB 19613 581 19 early early RB 19613 581 20 as as IN 19613 581 21 the the DT 19613 581 22 reign reign NN 19613 581 23 of of IN 19613 581 24 Commodus Commodus NNP 19613 581 25 , , , 19613 581 26 presupposed presuppose VBD 19613 581 27 such such PDT 19613 581 28 a a DT 19613 581 29 collection collection NN 19613 581 30 . . . 19613 582 1 Nor nor CC 19613 582 2 , , , 19613 582 3 in in IN 19613 582 4 point point NN 19613 582 5 of of IN 19613 582 6 fact fact NN 19613 582 7 , , , 19613 582 8 do do VBP 19613 582 9 the the DT 19613 582 10 statements statement NNS 19613 582 11 in in IN 19613 582 12 the the DT 19613 582 13 treatise treatise NN 19613 582 14 " " '' 19613 582 15 ad ad NN 19613 582 16 Autolycum Autolycum NNP 19613 582 17 " " '' 19613 582 18 point point NN 19613 582 19 to to IN 19613 582 20 a a DT 19613 582 21 completed complete VBN 19613 582 22 New New NNP 19613 582 23 Testament Testament NNP 19613 582 24 . . . 19613 583 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 583 2 110 110 CD 19613 583 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 583 4 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 583 5 makes make VBZ 19613 583 6 diligent diligent JJ 19613 583 7 use use NN 19613 583 8 of of IN 19613 583 9 the the DT 19613 583 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 583 11 of of IN 19613 583 12 Paul Paul NNP 19613 583 13 and and CC 19613 583 14 mentions mention VBZ 19613 583 15 the the DT 19613 583 16 evangelist evangelist NN 19613 583 17 John John NNP 19613 583 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 583 19 C. C. NNP 19613 583 20 I. I. NNP 19613 584 1 1 1 LS 19613 584 2 . . . 19613 584 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 585 1 as as IN 19613 585 2 one one CD 19613 585 3 of of IN 19613 585 4 the the DT 19613 585 5 bearers bearer NNS 19613 585 6 of of IN 19613 585 7 the the DT 19613 585 8 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 585 9 . . . 19613 586 1 But but CC 19613 586 2 with with IN 19613 586 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 586 4 the the DT 19613 586 5 one one CD 19613 586 6 canonical canonical JJ 19613 586 7 court court NN 19613 586 8 of of IN 19613 586 9 appeal appeal NN 19613 586 10 is be VBZ 19613 586 11 the the DT 19613 586 12 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 586 13 of of IN 19613 586 14 the the DT 19613 586 15 Old Old NNP 19613 586 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 586 17 , , , 19613 586 18 that that RB 19613 586 19 is is RB 19613 586 20 , , , 19613 586 21 the the DT 19613 586 22 writings writing NNS 19613 586 23 of of IN 19613 586 24 the the DT 19613 586 25 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 586 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 586 27 bearers bearer NNS 19613 586 28 of of IN 19613 586 29 the the DT 19613 586 30 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 586 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 586 32 . . . 19613 587 1 These these DT 19613 587 2 Old Old NNP 19613 587 3 Testament Testament NNP 19613 587 4 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 587 5 , , , 19613 587 6 however however RB 19613 587 7 , , , 19613 587 8 are be VBP 19613 587 9 continued continue VBN 19613 587 10 in in IN 19613 587 11 a a DT 19613 587 12 further further JJ 19613 587 13 group group NN 19613 587 14 of of IN 19613 587 15 " " `` 19613 587 16 bearers bearer NNS 19613 587 17 of of IN 19613 587 18 the the DT 19613 587 19 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 587 20 , , , 19613 587 21 " " '' 19613 587 22 which which WDT 19613 587 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 587 24 can can MD 19613 587 25 not not RB 19613 587 26 definitely definitely RB 19613 587 27 determine determine VB 19613 587 28 , , , 19613 587 29 but but CC 19613 587 30 which which WDT 19613 587 31 at at IN 19613 587 32 any any DT 19613 587 33 rate rate NN 19613 587 34 included include VBD 19613 587 35 the the DT 19613 587 36 authors author NNS 19613 587 37 of of IN 19613 587 38 the the DT 19613 587 39 four four CD 19613 587 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 587 41 and and CC 19613 587 42 the the DT 19613 587 43 writer writer NN 19613 587 44 of of IN 19613 587 45 the the DT 19613 587 46 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 587 47 . . . 19613 588 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 588 2 is be VBZ 19613 588 3 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 588 4 that that IN 19613 588 5 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 588 6 has have VBZ 19613 588 7 never never RB 19613 588 8 mentioned mention VBN 19613 588 9 the the DT 19613 588 10 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 588 11 . . . 19613 589 1 Though though IN 19613 589 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 589 3 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 589 4 regards regard VBZ 19613 589 5 them -PRON- PRP 19613 589 6 all all DT 19613 589 7 , , , 19613 589 8 including include VBG 19613 589 9 Paul Paul NNP 19613 589 10 , , , 19613 589 11 as as IN 19613 589 12 " " `` 19613 589 13 bearers bearer NNS 19613 589 14 of of IN 19613 589 15 the the DT 19613 589 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 589 17 , , , 19613 589 18 " " `` 19613 589 19 yet yet CC 19613 589 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 589 21 have have VBP 19613 589 22 no no DT 19613 589 23 indication indication NN 19613 589 24 that that IN 19613 589 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 589 26 looked look VBD 19613 589 27 on on IN 19613 589 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 589 29 _ _ NNP 19613 589 30 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 589 31 _ _ NNP 19613 589 32 as as RB 19613 589 33 canonical canonical JJ 19613 589 34 . . . 19613 590 1 The the DT 19613 590 2 different different JJ 19613 590 3 way way NN 19613 590 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 590 5 uses use VBZ 19613 590 6 the the DT 19613 590 7 Old Old NNP 19613 590 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 590 9 and and CC 19613 590 10 the the DT 19613 590 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 590 12 on on IN 19613 590 13 the the DT 19613 590 14 one one CD 19613 590 15 hand hand NN 19613 590 16 and and CC 19613 590 17 the the DT 19613 590 18 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 590 19 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 590 20 on on IN 19613 590 21 the the DT 19613 590 22 other other JJ 19613 590 23 is be VBZ 19613 590 24 rather rather RB 19613 590 25 evidence evidence NN 19613 590 26 of of IN 19613 590 27 the the DT 19613 590 28 contrary contrary NN 19613 590 29 . . . 19613 591 1 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 591 2 was be VBD 19613 591 3 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 591 4 with with IN 19613 591 5 the the DT 19613 591 6 four four CD 19613 591 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 591 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 591 9 but but CC 19613 591 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 591 11 have have VBP 19613 591 12 no no DT 19613 591 13 reference reference NN 19613 591 14 to to IN 19613 591 15 Mark Mark NNP 19613 591 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 591 17 , , , 19613 591 18 the the DT 19613 591 19 thirteen thirteen CD 19613 591 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 591 21 of of IN 19613 591 22 Paul Paul NNP 19613 591 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 591 24 though though IN 19613 591 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 591 26 does do VBZ 19613 591 27 not not RB 19613 591 28 mention mention VB 19613 591 29 Thessalonians Thessalonians NNPS 19613 591 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 591 31 , , , 19613 591 32 most most RBS 19613 591 33 probably probably RB 19613 591 34 also also RB 19613 591 35 with with IN 19613 591 36 the the DT 19613 591 37 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 591 38 to to IN 19613 591 39 the the DT 19613 591 40 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 19613 591 41 , , , 19613 591 42 as as RB 19613 591 43 well well RB 19613 591 44 as as IN 19613 591 45 1st 1st NNP 19613 591 46 Peter Peter NNP 19613 591 47 and and CC 19613 591 48 the the DT 19613 591 49 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 591 50 of of IN 19613 591 51 John John NNP 19613 591 52 . . . 19613 592 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 592 2 is be VBZ 19613 592 3 significant significant JJ 19613 592 4 that that IN 19613 592 5 no no DT 19613 592 6 single single JJ 19613 592 7 passage passage NN 19613 592 8 of of IN 19613 592 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 592 10 betrays betray NNS 19613 592 11 an an DT 19613 592 12 acquaintance acquaintance NN 19613 592 13 with with IN 19613 592 14 the the DT 19613 592 15 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 592 16 of of IN 19613 592 17 the the DT 19613 592 18 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 592 19 . . . 19613 593 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 593 2 111 111 CD 19613 593 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 593 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 593 5 might may MD 19613 593 6 certainly certainly RB 19613 593 7 seem seem VB 19613 593 8 venturesome venturesome JJ 19613 593 9 , , , 19613 593 10 on on IN 19613 593 11 the the DT 19613 593 12 basis basis NN 19613 593 13 of of IN 19613 593 14 the the DT 19613 593 15 material material NN 19613 593 16 found find VBN 19613 593 17 in in IN 19613 593 18 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 593 19 and and CC 19613 593 20 the the DT 19613 593 21 original original JJ 19613 593 22 document document NN 19613 593 23 of of IN 19613 593 24 the the DT 19613 593 25 first first JJ 19613 593 26 six six CD 19613 593 27 books book NNS 19613 593 28 of of IN 19613 593 29 the the DT 19613 593 30 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 593 31 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 593 32 , , , 19613 593 33 to to TO 19613 593 34 conclude conclude VB 19613 593 35 that that IN 19613 593 36 the the DT 19613 593 37 formation formation NN 19613 593 38 of of IN 19613 593 39 a a DT 19613 593 40 New New NNP 19613 593 41 Testament Testament NNP 19613 593 42 canon canon NN 19613 593 43 was be VBD 19613 593 44 not not RB 19613 593 45 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 593 46 determined determine VBN 19613 593 47 by by IN 19613 593 48 the the DT 19613 593 49 same same JJ 19613 593 50 interest interest NN 19613 593 51 and and CC 19613 593 52 therefore therefore RB 19613 593 53 did do VBD 19613 593 54 not not RB 19613 593 55 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 593 56 take take VB 19613 593 57 a a DT 19613 593 58 similar similar JJ 19613 593 59 course course NN 19613 593 60 . . . 19613 594 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 594 2 might may MD 19613 594 3 seem seem VB 19613 594 4 hazardous hazardous JJ 19613 594 5 to to TO 19613 594 6 assume assume VB 19613 594 7 that that IN 19613 594 8 the the DT 19613 594 9 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 594 10 of of IN 19613 594 11 Asia Asia NNP 19613 594 12 Minor Minor NNP 19613 594 13 and and CC 19613 594 14 Rome Rome NNP 19613 594 15 began begin VBD 19613 594 16 by by IN 19613 594 17 creating create VBG 19613 594 18 a a DT 19613 594 19 fixed fix VBN 19613 594 20 canon canon NN 19613 594 21 of of IN 19613 594 22 _ _ NNP 19613 594 23 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 594 24 _ _ NNP 19613 594 25 writings writing NNS 19613 594 26 , , , 19613 594 27 which which WDT 19613 594 28 was be VBD 19613 594 29 thus thus RB 19613 594 30 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 594 31 declared declare VBN 19613 594 32 to to TO 19613 594 33 be be VB 19613 594 34 inspired inspire VBN 19613 594 35 , , , 19613 594 36 whereas whereas IN 19613 594 37 other other JJ 19613 594 38 communities community NNS 19613 594 39 applied apply VBD 19613 594 40 or or CC 19613 594 41 did do VBD 19613 594 42 not not RB 19613 594 43 deny deny VB 19613 594 44 the the DT 19613 594 45 notion notion NN 19613 594 46 of of IN 19613 594 47 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 594 48 to to IN 19613 594 49 a a DT 19613 594 50 great great JJ 19613 594 51 number number NN 19613 594 52 of of IN 19613 594 53 venerable venerable JJ 19613 594 54 and and CC 19613 594 55 ancient ancient JJ 19613 594 56 writings writing NNS 19613 594 57 not not RB 19613 594 58 rigidly rigidly RB 19613 594 59 defined define VBN 19613 594 60 , , , 19613 594 61 and and CC 19613 594 62 did do VBD 19613 594 63 not not RB 19613 594 64 make make VB 19613 594 65 a a DT 19613 594 66 selection selection NN 19613 594 67 from from IN 19613 594 68 a a DT 19613 594 69 stricter strict JJR 19613 594 70 historical historical JJ 19613 594 71 point point NN 19613 594 72 of of IN 19613 594 73 view view NN 19613 594 74 , , , 19613 594 75 till till IN 19613 594 76 a a DT 19613 594 77 later later JJ 19613 594 78 date date NN 19613 594 79 . . . 19613 595 1 But but CC 19613 595 2 the the DT 19613 595 3 latter latter JJ 19613 595 4 development development NN 19613 595 5 not not RB 19613 595 6 only only RB 19613 595 7 corresponds correspond VBZ 19613 595 8 to to IN 19613 595 9 the the DT 19613 595 10 indication indication NN 19613 595 11 found find VBN 19613 595 12 in in IN 19613 595 13 Justin Justin NNP 19613 595 14 , , , 19613 595 15 but but CC 19613 595 16 in in IN 19613 595 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 595 18 opinion opinion NN 19613 595 19 may may MD 19613 595 20 be be VB 19613 595 21 verified verify VBN 19613 595 22 from from IN 19613 595 23 the the DT 19613 595 24 copious copious JJ 19613 595 25 accounts account NNS 19613 595 26 of of IN 19613 595 27 Clement Clement NNP 19613 595 28 of of IN 19613 595 29 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 595 30 . . . 19613 596 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 596 2 112 112 CD 19613 596 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 596 4 In in IN 19613 596 5 the the DT 19613 596 6 entire entire JJ 19613 596 7 literature literature NN 19613 596 8 of of IN 19613 596 9 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 596 10 and and CC 19613 596 11 barbarians barbarian VBZ 19613 596 12 Clement Clement NNP 19613 596 13 distinguishes distinguishe NNS 19613 596 14 between between IN 19613 596 15 profane profane NN 19613 596 16 and and CC 19613 596 17 sacred sacred NN 19613 596 18 , , , 19613 596 19 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 596 20 , , , 19613 596 21 inspired inspire VBN 19613 596 22 writings writing NNS 19613 596 23 . . . 19613 597 1 As as IN 19613 597 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 597 3 is be VBZ 19613 597 4 conscious conscious JJ 19613 597 5 that that IN 19613 597 6 all all DT 19613 597 7 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 597 8 of of IN 19613 597 9 truth truth NN 19613 597 10 is be VBZ 19613 597 11 based base VBN 19613 597 12 on on IN 19613 597 13 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 597 14 , , , 19613 597 15 so so IN 19613 597 16 all all DT 19613 597 17 writings writing NNS 19613 597 18 , , , 19613 597 19 that that WDT 19613 597 20 is be VBZ 19613 597 21 all all DT 19613 597 22 parts part NNS 19613 597 23 , , , 19613 597 24 paragraphs paragraph NNS 19613 597 25 , , , 19613 597 26 or or CC 19613 597 27 sentences sentence NNS 19613 597 28 of of IN 19613 597 29 writings writing NNS 19613 597 30 which which WDT 19613 597 31 contain contain VBP 19613 597 32 moral moral JJ 19613 597 33 and and CC 19613 597 34 religious religious JJ 19613 597 35 truth truth NN 19613 597 36 are be VBP 19613 597 37 in in IN 19613 597 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 597 39 view view NN 19613 597 40 inspired inspire VBN 19613 597 41 . . . 19613 598 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 598 2 113 113 CD 19613 598 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 598 4 This this DT 19613 598 5 opinion opinion NN 19613 598 6 , , , 19613 598 7 however however RB 19613 598 8 , , , 19613 598 9 does do VBZ 19613 598 10 not not RB 19613 598 11 exclude exclude VB 19613 598 12 a a DT 19613 598 13 distinction distinction NN 19613 598 14 between between IN 19613 598 15 these these DT 19613 598 16 writings writing NNS 19613 598 17 , , , 19613 598 18 but but CC 19613 598 19 rather rather RB 19613 598 20 requires require VBZ 19613 598 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 598 22 . . . 19613 599 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 599 2 2 2 LS 19613 599 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 599 4 The The NNP 19613 599 5 Old Old NNP 19613 599 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 599 7 , , , 19613 599 8 a a DT 19613 599 9 fixed fix VBN 19613 599 10 collection collection NN 19613 599 11 of of IN 19613 599 12 books book NNS 19613 599 13 , , , 19613 599 14 is be VBZ 19613 599 15 regarded regard VBN 19613 599 16 by by IN 19613 599 17 Clement Clement NNP 19613 599 18 , , , 19613 599 19 as as IN 19613 599 20 a a DT 19613 599 21 whole whole NN 19613 599 22 and and CC 19613 599 23 in in IN 19613 599 24 all all DT 19613 599 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 599 26 parts part NNS 19613 599 27 , , , 19613 599 28 as as IN 19613 599 29 the the DT 19613 599 30 divine divine JJ 19613 599 31 , , , 19613 599 32 that that RB 19613 599 33 is is RB 19613 599 34 , , , 19613 599 35 inspired inspire VBN 19613 599 36 book book NN 19613 599 37 _ _ NNP 19613 599 38 par par NN 19613 599 39 excellence excellence NN 19613 599 40 _ _ NNP 19613 599 41 . . . 19613 600 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 600 2 3 3 LS 19613 600 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 600 4 As as IN 19613 600 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 600 6 in in IN 19613 600 7 theory theory NN 19613 600 8 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 600 9 a a DT 19613 600 10 new new JJ 19613 600 11 covenant covenant NN 19613 600 12 from from IN 19613 600 13 the the DT 19613 600 14 old old JJ 19613 600 15 , , , 19613 600 16 so so RB 19613 600 17 also also RB 19613 600 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 600 19 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 600 20 the the DT 19613 600 21 books book NNS 19613 600 22 of of IN 19613 600 23 the the DT 19613 600 24 new new JJ 19613 600 25 covenant covenant NN 19613 600 26 from from IN 19613 600 27 those those DT 19613 600 28 of of IN 19613 600 29 the the DT 19613 600 30 old old JJ 19613 600 31 . . . 19613 601 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 601 2 4 4 LS 19613 601 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 601 4 These these DT 19613 601 5 books book NNS 19613 601 6 to to TO 19613 601 7 which which WDT 19613 601 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 601 9 applies apply VBZ 19613 601 10 the the DT 19613 601 11 formula formula NN 19613 601 12 " " `` 19613 601 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 601 14 " " '' 19613 601 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 601 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 601 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 601 18 : : : 19613 601 19 to to IN 19613 601 20 euangelion euangelion NN 19613 601 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 601 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 601 23 and and CC 19613 601 24 " " `` 19613 601 25 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 601 26 " " '' 19613 601 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 601 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 601 29 Greek Greek NNP 19613 601 30 : : : 19613 601 31 hoi hoi NNP 19613 601 32 apostoloi apostoloi NNP 19613 601 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 601 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 601 35 are be VBP 19613 601 36 likewise likewise RB 19613 601 37 viewed view VBN 19613 601 38 by by IN 19613 601 39 him -PRON- PRP 19613 601 40 as as IN 19613 601 41 inspired inspire VBN 19613 601 42 , , , 19613 601 43 but but CC 19613 601 44 he -PRON- PRP 19613 601 45 does do VBZ 19613 601 46 not not RB 19613 601 47 consider consider VB 19613 601 48 them -PRON- PRP 19613 601 49 as as IN 19613 601 50 forming form VBG 19613 601 51 a a DT 19613 601 52 fixed fix VBN 19613 601 53 collection collection NN 19613 601 54 . . . 19613 602 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 602 2 5 5 LS 19613 602 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 602 4 Unless unless IN 19613 602 5 all all DT 19613 602 6 appearances appearance NNS 19613 602 7 are be VBP 19613 602 8 deceptive deceptive JJ 19613 602 9 , , , 19613 602 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 602 11 was be VBD 19613 602 12 , , , 19613 602 13 strictly strictly RB 19613 602 14 speaking speak VBG 19613 602 15 , , , 19613 602 16 only only RB 19613 602 17 the the DT 19613 602 18 four four CD 19613 602 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 602 20 that that WDT 19613 602 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 602 22 considered consider VBD 19613 602 23 and and CC 19613 602 24 treated treat VBD 19613 602 25 as as RB 19613 602 26 completely completely RB 19613 602 27 on on IN 19613 602 28 a a DT 19613 602 29 level level NN 19613 602 30 with with IN 19613 602 31 the the DT 19613 602 32 Old Old NNP 19613 602 33 Testament Testament NNP 19613 602 34 . . . 19613 603 1 The the DT 19613 603 2 formula formula NN 19613 603 3 : : : 19613 603 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 603 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 603 6 : : : 19613 603 7 ho ho NNP 19613 603 8 nomos nomos NNP 19613 603 9 kai kai NNP 19613 603 10 hoi hoi NNP 19613 603 11 prophêtai prophêtai NNP 19613 603 12 kai kai NNP 19613 603 13 to to IN 19613 603 14 euangelion euangelion NN 19613 603 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 603 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 603 17 " " `` 19613 603 18 the the DT 19613 603 19 Law Law NNP 19613 603 20 and and CC 19613 603 21 the the DT 19613 603 22 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 603 23 and and CC 19613 603 24 the the DT 19613 603 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 603 26 " " '' 19613 603 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 603 28 is be VBZ 19613 603 29 frequently frequently RB 19613 603 30 found find VBN 19613 603 31 , , , 19613 603 32 and and CC 19613 603 33 everything everything NN 19613 603 34 else else RB 19613 603 35 , , , 19613 603 36 even even RB 19613 603 37 the the DT 19613 603 38 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 603 39 writings writing NNS 19613 603 40 , , , 19613 603 41 is be VBZ 19613 603 42 judged judge VBN 19613 603 43 by by IN 19613 603 44 this this DT 19613 603 45 group group NN 19613 603 46 . . . 19613 604 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 604 2 114 114 CD 19613 604 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 604 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 604 5 does do VBZ 19613 604 6 not not RB 19613 604 7 consider consider VB 19613 604 8 even even RB 19613 604 9 the the DT 19613 604 10 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 604 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 604 12 to to TO 19613 604 13 be be VB 19613 604 14 a a DT 19613 604 15 court court NN 19613 604 16 of of IN 19613 604 17 appeal appeal NN 19613 604 18 of of IN 19613 604 19 equal equal JJ 19613 604 20 value value NN 19613 604 21 with with IN 19613 604 22 the the DT 19613 604 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 604 24 , , , 19613 604 25 though though IN 19613 604 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 604 27 occasionally occasionally RB 19613 604 28 describes describe VBZ 19613 604 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 604 30 as as IN 19613 604 31 [ [ -LRB- 19613 604 32 Greek Greek NNP 19613 604 33 : : : 19613 604 34 graphai graphai NNP 19613 604 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 604 36 . . . 19613 605 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 605 2 115 115 CD 19613 605 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 605 4 A a DT 19613 605 5 further further JJ 19613 605 6 class class NN 19613 605 7 of of IN 19613 605 8 writings writing NNS 19613 605 9 stands stand VBZ 19613 605 10 a a DT 19613 605 11 stage stage NN 19613 605 12 lower low JJR 19613 605 13 than than IN 19613 605 14 the the DT 19613 605 15 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 605 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 605 17 , , , 19613 605 18 viz viz NNP 19613 605 19 . . NNP 19613 605 20 , , , 19613 605 21 the the DT 19613 605 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 605 23 of of IN 19613 605 24 Clement Clement NNP 19613 605 25 and and CC 19613 605 26 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 605 27 , , , 19613 605 28 the the DT 19613 605 29 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 605 30 of of IN 19613 605 31 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 605 32 , , , 19613 605 33 etc etc FW 19613 605 34 . . . 19613 606 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 606 2 would would MD 19613 606 3 be be VB 19613 606 4 wrong wrong JJ 19613 606 5 to to TO 19613 606 6 say say VB 19613 606 7 that that IN 19613 606 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 606 9 views view VBZ 19613 606 10 this this DT 19613 606 11 group group NN 19613 606 12 as as IN 19613 606 13 an an DT 19613 606 14 appendix appendix NNP 19613 606 15 to to IN 19613 606 16 the the DT 19613 606 17 New New NNP 19613 606 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 606 19 , , , 19613 606 20 or or CC 19613 606 21 as as IN 19613 606 22 in in IN 19613 606 23 any any DT 19613 606 24 sense sense NN 19613 606 25 Antilegomena Antilegomena NNP 19613 606 26 . . . 19613 607 1 This this DT 19613 607 2 would would MD 19613 607 3 imply imply VB 19613 607 4 that that IN 19613 607 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 607 6 assumed assume VBD 19613 607 7 the the DT 19613 607 8 existence existence NN 19613 607 9 of of IN 19613 607 10 a a DT 19613 607 11 fixed fix VBN 19613 607 12 collection collection NN 19613 607 13 whose whose WP$ 19613 607 14 parts part NNS 19613 607 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 607 16 considered consider VBD 19613 607 17 of of IN 19613 607 18 equal equal JJ 19613 607 19 value value NN 19613 607 20 , , , 19613 607 21 an an DT 19613 607 22 assumption assumption NN 19613 607 23 which which WDT 19613 607 24 can can MD 19613 607 25 not not RB 19613 607 26 be be VB 19613 607 27 proved prove VBN 19613 607 28 . . . 19613 608 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 608 2 116 116 CD 19613 608 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 608 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 608 5 6 6 CD 19613 608 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 608 7 As as IN 19613 608 8 to to IN 19613 608 9 certain certain JJ 19613 608 10 books book NNS 19613 608 11 , , , 19613 608 12 such such JJ 19613 608 13 as as IN 19613 608 14 the the DT 19613 608 15 " " `` 19613 608 16 Teaching teaching NN 19613 608 17 of of IN 19613 608 18 the the DT 19613 608 19 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 608 20 , , , 19613 608 21 " " '' 19613 608 22 the the DT 19613 608 23 " " `` 19613 608 24 Kerygma Kerygma NNP 19613 608 25 of of IN 19613 608 26 Peter Peter NNP 19613 608 27 , , , 19613 608 28 " " `` 19613 608 29 etc etc FW 19613 608 30 . . . 19613 608 31 , , , 19613 608 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 608 33 remains remain VBZ 19613 608 34 quite quite RB 19613 608 35 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 608 36 what what WP 19613 608 37 authority authority NN 19613 608 38 Clement Clement NNP 19613 608 39 attributed attribute VBD 19613 608 40 to to IN 19613 608 41 them -PRON- PRP 19613 608 42 . . . 19613 609 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 609 2 117 117 CD 19613 609 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 609 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 609 5 quotes quote VBZ 19613 609 6 the the DT 19613 609 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 609 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 609 9 : : : 19613 609 10 Didachê didachê NN 19613 609 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 609 12 as as IN 19613 609 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 609 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 609 15 : : : 19613 609 16 graphê graphê NN 19613 609 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 609 18 . . . 19613 610 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 610 2 7 7 LS 19613 610 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 610 4 In in IN 19613 610 5 determining determine VBG 19613 610 6 and and CC 19613 610 7 estimating estimate VBG 19613 610 8 the the DT 19613 610 9 sacred sacred JJ 19613 610 10 books book NNS 19613 610 11 of of IN 19613 610 12 the the DT 19613 610 13 New New NNP 19613 610 14 Testament Testament NNP 19613 610 15 Clement Clement NNP 19613 610 16 is be VBZ 19613 610 17 manifestly manifestly RB 19613 610 18 influenced influence VBN 19613 610 19 by by IN 19613 610 20 an an DT 19613 610 21 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 610 22 tradition tradition NN 19613 610 23 , , , 19613 610 24 for for IN 19613 610 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 610 26 recognises recognise VBZ 19613 610 27 four four CD 19613 610 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 610 29 and and CC 19613 610 30 no no DT 19613 610 31 more more JJR 19613 610 32 because because IN 19613 610 33 that that DT 19613 610 34 was be VBD 19613 610 35 the the DT 19613 610 36 exact exact JJ 19613 610 37 number number NN 19613 610 38 handed hand VBD 19613 610 39 down down RP 19613 610 40 . . . 19613 611 1 This this DT 19613 611 2 tradition tradition NN 19613 611 3 had have VBD 19613 611 4 already already RB 19613 611 5 applied apply VBN 19613 611 6 the the DT 19613 611 7 name name NN 19613 611 8 " " `` 19613 611 9 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 611 10 " " '' 19613 611 11 to to IN 19613 611 12 most most JJS 19613 611 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 611 14 writings writing NNS 19613 611 15 which which WDT 19613 611 16 were be VBD 19613 611 17 to to TO 19613 611 18 be be VB 19613 611 19 considered consider VBN 19613 611 20 as as IN 19613 611 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 611 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 611 23 : : : 19613 611 24 graphai graphai NNP 19613 611 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 611 26 , , , 19613 611 27 but but CC 19613 611 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 611 29 had have VBD 19613 611 30 given give VBN 19613 611 31 the the DT 19613 611 32 concept concept NN 19613 611 33 " " `` 19613 611 34 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 611 35 " " '' 19613 611 36 a a DT 19613 611 37 far far RB 19613 611 38 wider wide JJR 19613 611 39 content content NN 19613 611 40 than than IN 19613 611 41 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 611 42 and and CC 19613 611 43 Tertullian,[118 tertullian,[118 CD 19613 611 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 611 45 although although IN 19613 611 46 it -PRON- PRP 19613 611 47 had have VBD 19613 611 48 not not RB 19613 611 49 been be VBN 19613 611 50 able able JJ 19613 611 51 to to TO 19613 611 52 include include VB 19613 611 53 all all PDT 19613 611 54 the the DT 19613 611 55 new new JJ 19613 611 56 writings writing NNS 19613 611 57 which which WDT 19613 611 58 were be VBD 19613 611 59 regarded regard VBN 19613 611 60 as as IN 19613 611 61 sacred sacred JJ 19613 611 62 under under IN 19613 611 63 this this DT 19613 611 64 idea idea NN 19613 611 65 . . . 19613 612 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 612 2 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 612 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 612 4 . . . 19613 613 1 At at IN 19613 613 2 the the DT 19613 613 3 time time NN 19613 613 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 613 5 wrote write VBD 19613 613 6 , , , 19613 613 7 the the DT 19613 613 8 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 613 9 _ _ NNP 19613 613 10 Church Church NNP 19613 613 11 _ _ NNP 19613 613 12 can can MD 19613 613 13 neither neither CC 19613 613 14 have have VB 19613 613 15 held hold VBN 19613 613 16 the the DT 19613 613 17 principle principle NN 19613 613 18 that that IN 19613 613 19 all all DT 19613 613 20 writings writing NNS 19613 613 21 of of IN 19613 613 22 the the DT 19613 613 23 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 613 24 must must MD 19613 613 25 be be VB 19613 613 26 read read VBN 19613 613 27 in in IN 19613 613 28 the the DT 19613 613 29 Church Church NNP 19613 613 30 and and CC 19613 613 31 form form VB 19613 613 32 a a DT 19613 613 33 decisive decisive JJ 19613 613 34 court court NN 19613 613 35 of of IN 19613 613 36 appeal appeal NN 19613 613 37 like like IN 19613 613 38 the the DT 19613 613 39 Old Old NNP 19613 613 40 Testament Testament NNP 19613 613 41 , , , 19613 613 42 nor nor CC 19613 613 43 have have VBP 19613 613 44 believed believe VBN 19613 613 45 that that IN 19613 613 46 nothing nothing NN 19613 613 47 but but IN 19613 613 48 the the DT 19613 613 49 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 613 50 -- -- : 19613 613 51 using use VBG 19613 613 52 this this DT 19613 613 53 word word NN 19613 613 54 also also RB 19613 613 55 in in IN 19613 613 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 613 57 wider wide JJR 19613 613 58 sense sense NN 19613 613 59 -- -- : 19613 613 60 has have VBZ 19613 613 61 any any DT 19613 613 62 claim claim NN 19613 613 63 to to IN 19613 613 64 authority authority NN 19613 613 65 among among IN 19613 613 66 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 613 67 . . . 19613 614 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 614 2 willingly willingly RB 19613 614 3 admit admit VBP 19613 614 4 the the DT 19613 614 5 great great JJ 19613 614 6 degree degree NN 19613 614 7 of of IN 19613 614 8 freedom freedom NN 19613 614 9 and and CC 19613 614 10 peculiarity peculiarity NN 19613 614 11 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 614 12 of of IN 19613 614 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 614 14 , , , 19613 614 15 and and CC 19613 614 16 freely freely RB 19613 614 17 acknowledge acknowledge VB 19613 614 18 the the DT 19613 614 19 serious serious JJ 19613 614 20 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 614 21 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 614 22 from from IN 19613 614 23 the the DT 19613 614 24 attempt attempt NN 19613 614 25 to to TO 19613 614 26 ascertain ascertain VB 19613 614 27 from from IN 19613 614 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 614 29 writings writing NNS 19613 614 30 what what WP 19613 614 31 was be VBD 19613 614 32 regarded regard VBN 19613 614 33 as as IN 19613 614 34 possessing possess VBG 19613 614 35 standard standard JJ 19613 614 36 authority authority NN 19613 614 37 in in IN 19613 614 38 the the DT 19613 614 39 _ _ NNP 19613 614 40 Church Church NNP 19613 614 41 _ _ NNP 19613 614 42 . . . 19613 615 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 615 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 615 3 may may MD 19613 615 4 be be VB 19613 615 5 assumed assume VBN 19613 615 6 with with IN 19613 615 7 certainty certainty NN 19613 615 8 that that IN 19613 615 9 , , , 19613 615 10 at at IN 19613 615 11 the the DT 19613 615 12 time time NN 19613 615 13 this this DT 19613 615 14 author author NN 19613 615 15 wrote write VBD 19613 615 16 , , , 19613 615 17 the the DT 19613 615 18 content content NN 19613 615 19 of of IN 19613 615 20 the the DT 19613 615 21 New New NNP 19613 615 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 615 23 canon canon NN 19613 615 24 , , , 19613 615 25 or or CC 19613 615 26 , , , 19613 615 27 to to TO 19613 615 28 speak speak VB 19613 615 29 more more RBR 19613 615 30 correctly correctly RB 19613 615 31 , , , 19613 615 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 615 33 reception reception NN 19613 615 34 in in IN 19613 615 35 the the DT 19613 615 36 Church Church NNP 19613 615 37 and and CC 19613 615 38 exact exact JJ 19613 615 39 attributes attribute NNS 19613 615 40 had have VBD 19613 615 41 not not RB 19613 615 42 yet yet RB 19613 615 43 been be VBN 19613 615 44 finally finally RB 19613 615 45 settled settle VBN 19613 615 46 in in IN 19613 615 47 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 615 48 . . . 19613 616 1 The the DT 19613 616 2 condition condition NN 19613 616 3 of of IN 19613 616 4 the the DT 19613 616 5 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 616 6 Church Church NNP 19613 616 7 of of IN 19613 616 8 the the DT 19613 616 9 time time NN 19613 616 10 may may MD 19613 616 11 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 616 12 be be VB 19613 616 13 described describe VBN 19613 616 14 as as IN 19613 616 15 follows follow VBZ 19613 616 16 : : : 19613 616 17 Ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 616 18 custom custom NN 19613 616 19 had have VBD 19613 616 20 attributed attribute VBN 19613 616 21 an an DT 19613 616 22 authority authority NN 19613 616 23 to to IN 19613 616 24 a a DT 19613 616 25 great great JJ 19613 616 26 number number NN 19613 616 27 of of IN 19613 616 28 early early JJ 19613 616 29 Christian christian JJ 19613 616 30 writings writing NNS 19613 616 31 without without IN 19613 616 32 strictly strictly RB 19613 616 33 defining define VBG 19613 616 34 the the DT 19613 616 35 nature nature NN 19613 616 36 of of IN 19613 616 37 this this DT 19613 616 38 authority authority NN 19613 616 39 or or CC 19613 616 40 making make VBG 19613 616 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 616 42 equal equal JJ 19613 616 43 to to IN 19613 616 44 that that DT 19613 616 45 of of IN 19613 616 46 the the DT 19613 616 47 Old Old NNP 19613 616 48 Testament Testament NNP 19613 616 49 . . . 19613 617 1 Whatever whatever WDT 19613 617 2 professed profess VBD 19613 617 3 to to TO 19613 617 4 be be VB 19613 617 5 inspired inspire VBN 19613 617 6 , , , 19613 617 7 or or CC 19613 617 8 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 617 9 , , , 19613 617 10 or or CC 19613 617 11 ancient ancient JJ 19613 617 12 , , , 19613 617 13 or or CC 19613 617 14 edifying edifying NN 19613 617 15 was be VBD 19613 617 16 regarded regard VBN 19613 617 17 as as IN 19613 617 18 the the DT 19613 617 19 work work NN 19613 617 20 of of IN 19613 617 21 the the DT 19613 617 22 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 617 23 and and CC 19613 617 24 therefore therefore RB 19613 617 25 as as IN 19613 617 26 the the DT 19613 617 27 Word Word NNP 19613 617 28 of of IN 19613 617 29 God God NNP 19613 617 30 . . . 19613 618 1 The the DT 19613 618 2 prestige prestige NN 19613 618 3 of of IN 19613 618 4 these these DT 19613 618 5 writings writing NNS 19613 618 6 increased increase VBD 19613 618 7 in in IN 19613 618 8 proportion proportion NN 19613 618 9 as as IN 19613 618 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 618 11 became become VBD 19613 618 12 more more RBR 19613 618 13 incapable incapable JJ 19613 618 14 of of IN 19613 618 15 producing produce VBG 19613 618 16 the the DT 19613 618 17 like like IN 19613 618 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 618 19 . . . 19613 619 1 Not not RB 19613 619 2 long long RB 19613 619 3 before before IN 19613 619 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 619 5 wrote write VBD 19613 619 6 , , , 19613 619 7 however however RB 19613 619 8 , , , 19613 619 9 a a DT 19613 619 10 systematic systematic JJ 19613 619 11 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 619 12 of of IN 19613 619 13 writings writing NNS 19613 619 14 embodying embody VBG 19613 619 15 the the DT 19613 619 16 early early JJ 19613 619 17 Christian christian JJ 19613 619 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 619 19 had have VBD 19613 619 20 been be VBN 19613 619 21 made make VBN 19613 619 22 in in IN 19613 619 23 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 619 24 also also RB 19613 619 25 . . . 19613 620 1 But but CC 19613 620 2 , , , 19613 620 3 while while IN 19613 620 4 in in IN 19613 620 5 the the DT 19613 620 6 regions region NNS 19613 620 7 represented represent VBN 19613 620 8 by by IN 19613 620 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 620 10 and and CC 19613 620 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 620 12 the the DT 19613 620 13 canon canon NN 19613 620 14 must must MD 19613 620 15 have have VB 19613 620 16 arisen arise VBN 19613 620 17 and and CC 19613 620 18 been be VBN 19613 620 19 adopted adopt VBN 19613 620 20 all all RB 19613 620 21 at at IN 19613 620 22 once once RB 19613 620 23 , , , 19613 620 24 so so RB 19613 620 25 to to TO 19613 620 26 speak speak VB 19613 620 27 , , , 19613 620 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 620 29 was be VBD 19613 620 30 a a DT 19613 620 31 slow slow JJ 19613 620 32 process process NN 19613 620 33 that that WDT 19613 620 34 led lead VBD 19613 620 35 to to IN 19613 620 36 this this DT 19613 620 37 result result NN 19613 620 38 in in IN 19613 620 39 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 620 40 . . . 19613 621 1 Here here RB 19613 621 2 also also RB 19613 621 3 the the DT 19613 621 4 principle principle NN 19613 621 5 of of IN 19613 621 6 apostolicity apostolicity NN 19613 621 7 seems seem VBZ 19613 621 8 to to TO 19613 621 9 have have VB 19613 621 10 been be VBN 19613 621 11 of of IN 19613 621 12 great great JJ 19613 621 13 importance importance NN 19613 621 14 for for IN 19613 621 15 the the DT 19613 621 16 collectors collector NNS 19613 621 17 and and CC 19613 621 18 editors editor NNS 19613 621 19 , , , 19613 621 20 but but CC 19613 621 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 621 22 was be VBD 19613 621 23 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 621 24 applied apply VBN 19613 621 25 than than IN 19613 621 26 at at IN 19613 621 27 Rome Rome NNP 19613 621 28 . . . 19613 622 1 A a DT 19613 622 2 conservative conservative JJ 19613 622 3 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 622 4 was be VBD 19613 622 5 adopted adopt VBN 19613 622 6 , , , 19613 622 7 as as IN 19613 622 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 622 9 wished wish VBD 19613 622 10 to to TO 19613 622 11 insure insure VB 19613 622 12 as as RB 19613 622 13 far far RB 19613 622 14 as as IN 19613 622 15 possible possible JJ 19613 622 16 the the DT 19613 622 17 permanence permanence NN 19613 622 18 of of IN 19613 622 19 ancient ancient JJ 19613 622 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 622 21 writings writing NNS 19613 622 22 regarded regard VBN 19613 622 23 as as IN 19613 622 24 inspired inspire VBN 19613 622 25 . . . 19613 623 1 In in IN 19613 623 2 other other JJ 19613 623 3 words word NNS 19613 623 4 , , , 19613 623 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 623 6 sought seek VBD 19613 623 7 , , , 19613 623 8 wherever wherever WRB 19613 623 9 practicable practicable JJ 19613 623 10 , , , 19613 623 11 to to TO 19613 623 12 proclaim proclaim VB 19613 623 13 all all PDT 19613 623 14 these these DT 19613 623 15 writings writing NNS 19613 623 16 to to TO 19613 623 17 be be VB 19613 623 18 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 623 19 by by IN 19613 623 20 giving give VBG 19613 623 21 a a DT 19613 623 22 wider wide JJR 19613 623 23 meaning meaning NN 19613 623 24 to to IN 19613 623 25 the the DT 19613 623 26 designation designation NN 19613 623 27 and and CC 19613 623 28 ascribing ascribe VBG 19613 623 29 an an DT 19613 623 30 imaginary imaginary JJ 19613 623 31 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 623 32 origin origin NN 19613 623 33 to to IN 19613 623 34 many many JJ 19613 623 35 of of IN 19613 623 36 them -PRON- PRP 19613 623 37 . . . 19613 624 1 This this DT 19613 624 2 explains explain VBZ 19613 624 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 624 4 judgment judgment NN 19613 624 5 as as IN 19613 624 6 to to IN 19613 624 7 the the DT 19613 624 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 624 9 to to IN 19613 624 10 the the DT 19613 624 11 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 19613 624 12 , , , 19613 624 13 and and CC 19613 624 14 how how WRB 19613 624 15 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 624 16 and and CC 19613 624 17 Clement Clement NNP 19613 624 18 were be VBD 19613 624 19 described describe VBN 19613 624 20 by by IN 19613 624 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 624 22 as as IN 19613 624 23 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 624 24 . . . 19613 625 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 625 2 119 119 CD 19613 625 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 625 4 Had have VBD 19613 625 5 this this DT 19613 625 6 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 625 7 succeeded succeed VBN 19613 625 8 in in IN 19613 625 9 the the DT 19613 625 10 Church Church NNP 19613 625 11 , , , 19613 625 12 a a DT 19613 625 13 much much RB 19613 625 14 more more RBR 19613 625 15 extensive extensive JJ 19613 625 16 canon canon NN 19613 625 17 would would MD 19613 625 18 have have VB 19613 625 19 resulted result VBN 19613 625 20 than than IN 19613 625 21 in in IN 19613 625 22 the the DT 19613 625 23 West West NNP 19613 625 24 . . . 19613 626 1 But but CC 19613 626 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 626 3 is be VBZ 19613 626 4 more more RBR 19613 626 5 than than IN 19613 626 6 questionable questionable JJ 19613 626 7 whether whether IN 19613 626 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 626 9 was be VBD 19613 626 10 really really RB 19613 626 11 the the DT 19613 626 12 intention intention NN 19613 626 13 of of IN 19613 626 14 those those DT 19613 626 15 first first JJ 19613 626 16 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 626 17 collectors collector NNS 19613 626 18 to to TO 19613 626 19 place place VB 19613 626 20 the the DT 19613 626 21 great great JJ 19613 626 22 compilation compilation NN 19613 626 23 thus thus RB 19613 626 24 produced produce VBN 19613 626 25 , , , 19613 626 26 as as IN 19613 626 27 a a DT 19613 626 28 New New NNP 19613 626 29 Testament Testament NNP 19613 626 30 , , , 19613 626 31 side side NN 19613 626 32 by by IN 19613 626 33 side side NN 19613 626 34 with with IN 19613 626 35 the the DT 19613 626 36 Old Old NNP 19613 626 37 , , , 19613 626 38 or or CC 19613 626 39 , , , 19613 626 40 whether whether IN 19613 626 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 626 42 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 626 43 was be VBD 19613 626 44 immediately immediately RB 19613 626 45 approved approve VBN 19613 626 46 in in IN 19613 626 47 this this DT 19613 626 48 sense sense NN 19613 626 49 by by IN 19613 626 50 the the DT 19613 626 51 Church Church NNP 19613 626 52 . . . 19613 627 1 In in IN 19613 627 2 view view NN 19613 627 3 of of IN 19613 627 4 the the DT 19613 627 5 difference difference NN 19613 627 6 of of IN 19613 627 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 627 8 's 's POS 19613 627 9 attitude attitude NN 19613 627 10 to to IN 19613 627 11 the the DT 19613 627 12 various various JJ 19613 627 13 groups group NNS 19613 627 14 within within IN 19613 627 15 this this DT 19613 627 16 collection collection NN 19613 627 17 of of IN 19613 627 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 627 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 627 20 : : : 19613 627 21 graphai graphai NNP 19613 627 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 627 23 , , , 19613 627 24 we -PRON- PRP 19613 627 25 may may MD 19613 627 26 assert assert VB 19613 627 27 that that IN 19613 627 28 in in IN 19613 627 29 the the DT 19613 627 30 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 627 31 _ _ NNP 19613 627 32 Church Church NNP 19613 627 33 _ _ NNP 19613 627 34 of of IN 19613 627 35 that that DT 19613 627 36 time time NN 19613 627 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 627 38 and and CC 19613 627 39 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 627 40 were be VBD 19613 627 41 indeed indeed RB 19613 627 42 ranked rank VBN 19613 627 43 with with IN 19613 627 44 the the DT 19613 627 45 Law Law NNP 19613 627 46 and and CC 19613 627 47 the the DT 19613 627 48 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 627 49 , , , 19613 627 50 but but CC 19613 627 51 that that IN 19613 627 52 this this DT 19613 627 53 position position NN 19613 627 54 of of IN 19613 627 55 equality equality NN 19613 627 56 with with IN 19613 627 57 the the DT 19613 627 58 Old Old NNP 19613 627 59 Testament Testament NNP 19613 627 60 was be VBD 19613 627 61 not not RB 19613 627 62 assigned assign VBN 19613 627 63 to to IN 19613 627 64 all all PDT 19613 627 65 the the DT 19613 627 66 writings writing NNS 19613 627 67 that that WDT 19613 627 68 were be VBD 19613 627 69 prized prize VBN 19613 627 70 either either CC 19613 627 71 on on IN 19613 627 72 the the DT 19613 627 73 score score NN 19613 627 74 of of IN 19613 627 75 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 627 76 or or CC 19613 627 77 of of IN 19613 627 78 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 627 79 authority authority NNP 19613 627 80 . . . 19613 628 1 The the DT 19613 628 2 reason reason NN 19613 628 3 of of IN 19613 628 4 this this DT 19613 628 5 was be VBD 19613 628 6 that that IN 19613 628 7 the the DT 19613 628 8 great great JJ 19613 628 9 collection collection NN 19613 628 10 of of IN 19613 628 11 early early JJ 19613 628 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 628 13 literature literature NN 19613 628 14 that that WDT 19613 628 15 was be VBD 19613 628 16 inspired inspire VBN 19613 628 17 and and CC 19613 628 18 declared declare VBN 19613 628 19 to to TO 19613 628 20 be be VB 19613 628 21 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 628 22 could could MD 19613 628 23 hardly hardly RB 19613 628 24 have have VB 19613 628 25 been be VBN 19613 628 26 used use VBN 19613 628 27 so so RB 19613 628 28 much much JJ 19613 628 29 in in IN 19613 628 30 public public JJ 19613 628 31 worship worship NN 19613 628 32 as as IN 19613 628 33 the the DT 19613 628 34 Old Old NNP 19613 628 35 Testament Testament NNP 19613 628 36 and and CC 19613 628 37 the the DT 19613 628 38 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 628 39 . . . 19613 629 1 Be be VB 19613 629 2 this this DT 19613 629 3 as as IN 19613 629 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 629 5 may may MD 19613 629 6 , , , 19613 629 7 if if IN 19613 629 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 629 9 understand understand VBP 19613 629 10 by by IN 19613 629 11 the the DT 19613 629 12 New New NNP 19613 629 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 629 14 a a DT 19613 629 15 fixed fix VBN 19613 629 16 collection collection NN 19613 629 17 , , , 19613 629 18 equally equally RB 19613 629 19 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 629 20 throughout throughout IN 19613 629 21 , , , 19613 629 22 of of IN 19613 629 23 all all PDT 19613 629 24 the the DT 19613 629 25 writings writing NNS 19613 629 26 that that WDT 19613 629 27 were be VBD 19613 629 28 regarded regard VBN 19613 629 29 as as IN 19613 629 30 genuinely genuinely RB 19613 629 31 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 629 32 , , , 19613 629 33 that that RB 19613 629 34 is is RB 19613 629 35 , , , 19613 629 36 those those DT 19613 629 37 of of IN 19613 629 38 the the DT 19613 629 39 original original JJ 19613 629 40 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 629 41 and and CC 19613 629 42 Paul Paul NNP 19613 629 43 , , , 19613 629 44 then then RB 19613 629 45 the the DT 19613 629 46 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 629 47 Church Church NNP 19613 629 48 at at IN 19613 629 49 the the DT 19613 629 50 time time NN 19613 629 51 of of IN 19613 629 52 Clement Clement NNP 19613 629 53 did do VBD 19613 629 54 not not RB 19613 629 55 yet yet RB 19613 629 56 possess possess VB 19613 629 57 such such PDT 19613 629 58 a a DT 19613 629 59 book book NN 19613 629 60 ; ; : 19613 629 61 but but CC 19613 629 62 the the DT 19613 629 63 process process NN 19613 629 64 which which WDT 19613 629 65 led lead VBD 19613 629 66 to to IN 19613 629 67 it -PRON- PRP 19613 629 68 had have VBD 19613 629 69 begun begin VBN 19613 629 70 . . . 19613 630 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 630 2 had have VBD 19613 630 3 come come VBN 19613 630 4 much much JJ 19613 630 5 nearer nearer NN 19613 630 6 this this DT 19613 630 7 goal goal NN 19613 630 8 by by IN 19613 630 9 the the DT 19613 630 10 time time NN 19613 630 11 of of IN 19613 630 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 630 13 . . . 19613 631 1 At at IN 19613 631 2 that that DT 19613 631 3 period period NN 19613 631 4 the the DT 19613 631 5 writings writing NNS 19613 631 6 included include VBN 19613 631 7 in in IN 19613 631 8 the the DT 19613 631 9 New New NNP 19613 631 10 Testament Testament NNP 19613 631 11 of of IN 19613 631 12 the the DT 19613 631 13 West West NNP 19613 631 14 were be VBD 19613 631 15 all all DT 19613 631 16 regarded regard VBN 19613 631 17 in in IN 19613 631 18 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 631 19 as as IN 19613 631 20 equally equally RB 19613 631 21 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 631 22 , , , 19613 631 23 and and CC 19613 631 24 also also RB 19613 631 25 stood stand VBD 19613 631 26 in in IN 19613 631 27 every every DT 19613 631 28 respect respect NN 19613 631 29 on on IN 19613 631 30 a a DT 19613 631 31 level level NN 19613 631 32 with with IN 19613 631 33 the the DT 19613 631 34 Old Old NNP 19613 631 35 Testament Testament NNP 19613 631 36 . . . 19613 632 1 The the DT 19613 632 2 principle principle NN 19613 632 3 of of IN 19613 632 4 apostolicity apostolicity NN 19613 632 5 was be VBD 19613 632 6 more more RBR 19613 632 7 strictly strictly RB 19613 632 8 conceived conceive VBN 19613 632 9 and and CC 19613 632 10 more more RBR 19613 632 11 surely surely RB 19613 632 12 applied apply VBN 19613 632 13 . . . 19613 633 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 633 2 the the DT 19613 633 3 extent extent NN 19613 633 4 of of IN 19613 633 5 " " `` 19613 633 6 Holy Holy NNP 19613 633 7 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 633 8 " " '' 19613 633 9 was be VBD 19613 633 10 already already RB 19613 633 11 limited limit VBN 19613 633 12 in in IN 19613 633 13 the the DT 19613 633 14 days day NNS 19613 633 15 of of IN 19613 633 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 633 17 . . . 19613 634 1 Yet yet CC 19613 634 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 634 3 have have VBP 19613 634 4 to to TO 19613 634 5 thank thank VB 19613 634 6 the the DT 19613 634 7 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 634 8 Church Church NNP 19613 634 9 for for IN 19613 634 10 giving give VBG 19613 634 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 634 12 the the DT 19613 634 13 seven seven CD 19613 634 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 634 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 634 16 . . . 19613 635 1 But but CC 19613 635 2 , , , 19613 635 3 measured measure VBN 19613 635 4 by by IN 19613 635 5 the the DT 19613 635 6 canon canon NN 19613 635 7 of of IN 19613 635 8 the the DT 19613 635 9 Western Western NNP 19613 635 10 Church Church NNP 19613 635 11 , , , 19613 635 12 which which WDT 19613 635 13 must must MD 19613 635 14 have have VB 19613 635 15 had have VBN 19613 635 16 a a DT 19613 635 17 share share NN 19613 635 18 in in IN 19613 635 19 the the DT 19613 635 20 matter matter NN 19613 635 21 , , , 19613 635 22 this this DT 19613 635 23 sifting sift VBG 19613 635 24 process process NN 19613 635 25 was be VBD 19613 635 26 by by IN 19613 635 27 no no DT 19613 635 28 means means NN 19613 635 29 complete complete JJ 19613 635 30 . . . 19613 636 1 The the DT 19613 636 2 inventive inventive JJ 19613 636 3 minds mind NNS 19613 636 4 of of IN 19613 636 5 scholars scholar NNS 19613 636 6 designated designate VBD 19613 636 7 a a DT 19613 636 8 group group NN 19613 636 9 of of IN 19613 636 10 writings writing NNS 19613 636 11 in in IN 19613 636 12 the the DT 19613 636 13 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 636 14 canon canon NN 19613 636 15 as as IN 19613 636 16 " " `` 19613 636 17 Antilegomena Antilegomena NNP 19613 636 18 . . . 19613 636 19 " " '' 19613 637 1 The the DT 19613 637 2 historian historian NN 19613 637 3 of of IN 19613 637 4 dogma dogma NNP 19613 637 5 can can MD 19613 637 6 take take VB 19613 637 7 no no DT 19613 637 8 great great JJ 19613 637 9 interest interest NN 19613 637 10 in in IN 19613 637 11 the the DT 19613 637 12 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 637 13 development development NN 19613 637 14 , , , 19613 637 15 which which WDT 19613 637 16 first first RB 19613 637 17 led lead VBD 19613 637 18 to to IN 19613 637 19 the the DT 19613 637 20 canon canon NNP 19613 637 21 being be VBG 19613 637 22 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 637 23 finally finally RB 19613 637 24 fixed fix VBN 19613 637 25 , , , 19613 637 26 so so RB 19613 637 27 far far RB 19613 637 28 as as IN 19613 637 29 we -PRON- PRP 19613 637 30 can can MD 19613 637 31 say say VB 19613 637 32 that that IN 19613 637 33 this this DT 19613 637 34 was be VBD 19613 637 35 ever ever RB 19613 637 36 the the DT 19613 637 37 case case NN 19613 637 38 . . . 19613 638 1 For for IN 19613 638 2 the the DT 19613 638 3 still still RB 19613 638 4 unsettled unsettled JJ 19613 638 5 dispute dispute NN 19613 638 6 as as IN 19613 638 7 to to IN 19613 638 8 the the DT 19613 638 9 extent extent NN 19613 638 10 of of IN 19613 638 11 the the DT 19613 638 12 canon canon NN 19613 638 13 did do VBD 19613 638 14 not not RB 19613 638 15 essentially essentially RB 19613 638 16 affect affect VB 19613 638 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 638 18 use use NN 19613 638 19 and and CC 19613 638 20 authority authority NN 19613 638 21 , , , 19613 638 22 and and CC 19613 638 23 in in IN 19613 638 24 the the DT 19613 638 25 following following JJ 19613 638 26 period period NN 19613 638 27 the the DT 19613 638 28 continuous continuous JJ 19613 638 29 efforts effort NNS 19613 638 30 to to TO 19613 638 31 establish establish VB 19613 638 32 a a DT 19613 638 33 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 638 34 and and CC 19613 638 35 strictly strictly RB 19613 638 36 fixed fix VBN 19613 638 37 canon canon NN 19613 638 38 were be VBD 19613 638 39 solely solely RB 19613 638 40 determined determine VBN 19613 638 41 by by IN 19613 638 42 a a DT 19613 638 43 regard regard NN 19613 638 44 to to IN 19613 638 45 tradition tradition NN 19613 638 46 . . . 19613 639 1 The the DT 19613 639 2 results result NNS 19613 639 3 are be VBP 19613 639 4 no no RB 19613 639 5 doubt doubt NN 19613 639 6 of of IN 19613 639 7 great great JJ 19613 639 8 importance importance NN 19613 639 9 to to IN 19613 639 10 Church church NN 19613 639 11 history history NN 19613 639 12 , , , 19613 639 13 because because IN 19613 639 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 639 15 show show VBP 19613 639 16 us -PRON- PRP 19613 639 17 the the DT 19613 639 18 varying varying NN 19613 639 19 influence influence NN 19613 639 20 exerted exert VBD 19613 639 21 on on IN 19613 639 22 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 639 23 at at IN 19613 639 24 different different JJ 19613 639 25 periods period NNS 19613 639 26 by by IN 19613 639 27 the the DT 19613 639 28 great great JJ 19613 639 29 Churches church NNS 19613 639 30 of of IN 19613 639 31 the the DT 19613 639 32 East East NNP 19613 639 33 and and CC 19613 639 34 West West NNP 19613 639 35 and and CC 19613 639 36 by by IN 19613 639 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 639 38 learned learn VBN 19613 639 39 men man NNS 19613 639 40 . . . 19613 640 1 _ _ NNP 19613 640 2 Addendum._--The Addendum._--The NNP 19613 640 3 results result NNS 19613 640 4 arising arise VBG 19613 640 5 from from IN 19613 640 6 the the DT 19613 640 7 formation formation NN 19613 640 8 of of IN 19613 640 9 a a DT 19613 640 10 part part NN 19613 640 11 of of IN 19613 640 12 early early JJ 19613 640 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 640 14 writings writing NNS 19613 640 15 into into IN 19613 640 16 a a DT 19613 640 17 canon canon NN 19613 640 18 , , , 19613 640 19 which which WDT 19613 640 20 was be VBD 19613 640 21 a a DT 19613 640 22 great great JJ 19613 640 23 and and CC 19613 640 24 meritorious meritorious JJ 19613 640 25 act act NN 19613 640 26 of of IN 19613 640 27 the the DT 19613 640 28 Church[120 Church[120 NNP 19613 640 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 640 30 , , , 19613 640 31 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 19613 640 32 the the DT 19613 640 33 fact fact NN 19613 640 34 that that IN 19613 640 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 640 36 was be VBD 19613 640 37 forced force VBN 19613 640 38 on on IN 19613 640 39 her -PRON- PRP 19613 640 40 by by IN 19613 640 41 a a DT 19613 640 42 combination combination NN 19613 640 43 of of IN 19613 640 44 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 640 45 , , , 19613 640 46 may may MD 19613 640 47 be be VB 19613 640 48 summed sum VBN 19613 640 49 up up RP 19613 640 50 in in IN 19613 640 51 a a DT 19613 640 52 series series NN 19613 640 53 of of IN 19613 640 54 antitheses antithesis NNS 19613 640 55 . . . 19613 641 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 641 2 1 1 LS 19613 641 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 641 4 The the DT 19613 641 5 New New NNP 19613 641 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 641 7 , , , 19613 641 8 or or CC 19613 641 9 group group NN 19613 641 10 of of IN 19613 641 11 " " `` 19613 641 12 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 641 13 " " '' 19613 641 14 writings writing NNS 19613 641 15 formed form VBN 19613 641 16 by by IN 19613 641 17 selection selection NN 19613 641 18 , , , 19613 641 19 preserved preserve VBN 19613 641 20 from from IN 19613 641 21 destruction destruction NN 19613 641 22 one one CD 19613 641 23 part part NN 19613 641 24 , , , 19613 641 25 and and CC 19613 641 26 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 641 27 the the DT 19613 641 28 most most RBS 19613 641 29 valuable valuable JJ 19613 641 30 one one NN 19613 641 31 , , , 19613 641 32 of of IN 19613 641 33 primitive primitive JJ 19613 641 34 Church Church NNP 19613 641 35 literature literature NN 19613 641 36 ; ; : 19613 641 37 but but CC 19613 641 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 641 39 caused cause VBD 19613 641 40 all all PDT 19613 641 41 the the DT 19613 641 42 rest rest NN 19613 641 43 of of IN 19613 641 44 these these DT 19613 641 45 writings writing NNS 19613 641 46 , , , 19613 641 47 as as IN 19613 641 48 being be VBG 19613 641 49 intrusive intrusive JJ 19613 641 50 , , , 19613 641 51 or or CC 19613 641 52 spurious spurious JJ 19613 641 53 , , , 19613 641 54 or or CC 19613 641 55 superfluous superfluous JJ 19613 641 56 , , , 19613 641 57 to to TO 19613 641 58 be be VB 19613 641 59 more more RBR 19613 641 60 and and CC 19613 641 61 more more RBR 19613 641 62 neglected neglected JJ 19613 641 63 , , , 19613 641 64 so so IN 19613 641 65 that that IN 19613 641 66 they -PRON- PRP 19613 641 67 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 641 68 perished perish VBD 19613 641 69 . . . 19613 642 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 642 2 121 121 CD 19613 642 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 642 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 642 5 2 2 LS 19613 642 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 642 7 The the DT 19613 642 8 New New NNP 19613 642 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 642 10 , , , 19613 642 11 though though IN 19613 642 12 not not RB 19613 642 13 all all DT 19613 642 14 at at IN 19613 642 15 once once RB 19613 642 16 , , , 19613 642 17 put put VB 19613 642 18 an an DT 19613 642 19 end end NN 19613 642 20 to to IN 19613 642 21 the the DT 19613 642 22 composition composition NN 19613 642 23 of of IN 19613 642 24 works work NNS 19613 642 25 which which WDT 19613 642 26 claimed claim VBD 19613 642 27 an an DT 19613 642 28 authority authority NN 19613 642 29 binding bind VBG 19613 642 30 on on IN 19613 642 31 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 642 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 642 33 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 642 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 642 35 ; ; : 19613 642 36 but but CC 19613 642 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 642 38 first first RB 19613 642 39 made make VBD 19613 642 40 possible possible JJ 19613 642 41 the the DT 19613 642 42 production production NN 19613 642 43 of of IN 19613 642 44 secular secular JJ 19613 642 45 Church Church NNP 19613 642 46 literature literature NN 19613 642 47 and and CC 19613 642 48 neutralised neutralise VBD 19613 642 49 the the DT 19613 642 50 extreme extreme JJ 19613 642 51 dangers danger NNS 19613 642 52 attendant attendant JJ 19613 642 53 on on IN 19613 642 54 writings writing NNS 19613 642 55 of of IN 19613 642 56 this this DT 19613 642 57 kind kind NN 19613 642 58 . . . 19613 643 1 By by IN 19613 643 2 making make VBG 19613 643 3 room room NN 19613 643 4 for for IN 19613 643 5 all all DT 19613 643 6 kinds kind NNS 19613 643 7 of of IN 19613 643 8 writings writing NNS 19613 643 9 that that WDT 19613 643 10 did do VBD 19613 643 11 not not RB 19613 643 12 oppose oppose VB 19613 643 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 643 14 , , , 19613 643 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 643 16 enabled enable VBD 19613 643 17 the the DT 19613 643 18 Church Church NNP 19613 643 19 to to TO 19613 643 20 utilise utilise VB 19613 643 21 all all PDT 19613 643 22 the the DT 19613 643 23 elements element NNS 19613 643 24 of of IN 19613 643 25 Greek greek JJ 19613 643 26 culture culture NN 19613 643 27 . . . 19613 644 1 At at IN 19613 644 2 the the DT 19613 644 3 same same JJ 19613 644 4 time time NN 19613 644 5 , , , 19613 644 6 however however RB 19613 644 7 , , , 19613 644 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 644 9 required require VBD 19613 644 10 an an DT 19613 644 11 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 644 12 stamp stamp NN 19613 644 13 to to TO 19613 644 14 be be VB 19613 644 15 placed place VBN 19613 644 16 on on IN 19613 644 17 all all PDT 19613 644 18 the the DT 19613 644 19 new new JJ 19613 644 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 644 21 productions production NNS 19613 644 22 due due JJ 19613 644 23 to to IN 19613 644 24 this this DT 19613 644 25 cause cause NN 19613 644 26 . . . 19613 645 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 645 2 122 122 CD 19613 645 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 645 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 645 5 3 3 LS 19613 645 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 645 7 The the DT 19613 645 8 New New NNP 19613 645 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 645 10 obscured obscure VBD 19613 645 11 the the DT 19613 645 12 historical historical JJ 19613 645 13 meaning meaning NN 19613 645 14 and and CC 19613 645 15 the the DT 19613 645 16 historical historical JJ 19613 645 17 origin origin NN 19613 645 18 of of IN 19613 645 19 the the DT 19613 645 20 writing writing NN 19613 645 21 contained contain VBN 19613 645 22 in in IN 19613 645 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 645 24 , , , 19613 645 25 especially especially RB 19613 645 26 the the DT 19613 645 27 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 645 28 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 645 29 , , , 19613 645 30 though though IN 19613 645 31 at at IN 19613 645 32 the the DT 19613 645 33 same same JJ 19613 645 34 time time NN 19613 645 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 645 36 created create VBD 19613 645 37 the the DT 19613 645 38 conditions condition NNS 19613 645 39 for for IN 19613 645 40 a a DT 19613 645 41 thorough thorough JJ 19613 645 42 study study NN 19613 645 43 of of IN 19613 645 44 all all PDT 19613 645 45 those those DT 19613 645 46 documents document NNS 19613 645 47 . . . 19613 646 1 Although although IN 19613 646 2 primarily primarily RB 19613 646 3 the the DT 19613 646 4 new new JJ 19613 646 5 science science NN 19613 646 6 of of IN 19613 646 7 theological theological JJ 19613 646 8 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 646 9 in in IN 19613 646 10 the the DT 19613 646 11 Church Church NNP 19613 646 12 did do VBD 19613 646 13 more more JJR 19613 646 14 than than IN 19613 646 15 anything anything NN 19613 646 16 else else RB 19613 646 17 to to TO 19613 646 18 neutralise neutralise VB 19613 646 19 the the DT 19613 646 20 historical historical JJ 19613 646 21 value value NN 19613 646 22 of of IN 19613 646 23 the the DT 19613 646 24 New New NNP 19613 646 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 646 26 writings writing NNS 19613 646 27 , , , 19613 646 28 yet yet RB 19613 646 29 , , , 19613 646 30 on on IN 19613 646 31 the the DT 19613 646 32 other other JJ 19613 646 33 hand hand NN 19613 646 34 , , , 19613 646 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 646 36 immediately immediately RB 19613 646 37 commenced commence VBD 19613 646 38 a a DT 19613 646 39 critical critical JJ 19613 646 40 restoration restoration NN 19613 646 41 of of IN 19613 646 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 646 43 original original JJ 19613 646 44 sense sense NN 19613 646 45 . . . 19613 647 1 But but CC 19613 647 2 , , , 19613 647 3 even even RB 19613 647 4 apart apart RB 19613 647 5 from from IN 19613 647 6 theological theological JJ 19613 647 7 science science NN 19613 647 8 , , , 19613 647 9 the the DT 19613 647 10 New New NNP 19613 647 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 647 12 enabled enable VBD 19613 647 13 original original JJ 19613 647 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 647 15 to to TO 19613 647 16 exercise exercise VB 19613 647 17 here here RB 19613 647 18 and and CC 19613 647 19 there there RB 19613 647 20 a a DT 19613 647 21 quiet quiet JJ 19613 647 22 and and CC 19613 647 23 gradual gradual JJ 19613 647 24 effect effect NN 19613 647 25 on on IN 19613 647 26 the the DT 19613 647 27 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 647 28 development development NN 19613 647 29 of of IN 19613 647 30 the the DT 19613 647 31 Church Church NNP 19613 647 32 , , , 19613 647 33 without without IN 19613 647 34 indeed indeed RB 19613 647 35 being be VBG 19613 647 36 able able JJ 19613 647 37 to to TO 19613 647 38 exert exert VB 19613 647 39 a a DT 19613 647 40 dominant dominant JJ 19613 647 41 influence influence NN 19613 647 42 on on IN 19613 647 43 the the DT 19613 647 44 natural natural JJ 19613 647 45 development development NN 19613 647 46 of of IN 19613 647 47 the the DT 19613 647 48 traditional traditional JJ 19613 647 49 system system NN 19613 647 50 . . . 19613 648 1 As as IN 19613 648 2 the the DT 19613 648 3 standard standard NN 19613 648 4 of of IN 19613 648 5 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 648 6 for for IN 19613 648 7 the the DT 19613 648 8 Holy Holy NNP 19613 648 9 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 648 10 was be VBD 19613 648 11 the the DT 19613 648 12 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 648 13 _ _ NNP 19613 648 14 regula regula NN 19613 648 15 fidei fidei NNP 19613 648 16 _ _ NNP 19613 648 17 , , , 19613 648 18 always always RB 19613 648 19 more more RBR 19613 648 20 and and CC 19613 648 21 more more RBR 19613 648 22 precisely precisely RB 19613 648 23 explained explain VBN 19613 648 24 , , , 19613 648 25 and and CC 19613 648 26 as as IN 19613 648 27 that that DT 19613 648 28 _ _ NNP 19613 648 29 regula regula NN 19613 648 30 _ _ NNP 19613 648 31 , , , 19613 648 32 in in IN 19613 648 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 648 34 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 648 35 and and CC 19613 648 36 philosophico philosophico NN 19613 648 37 - - HYPH 19613 648 38 theological theological JJ 19613 648 39 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 648 40 , , , 19613 648 41 was be VBD 19613 648 42 regarded regard VBN 19613 648 43 as as IN 19613 648 44 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 648 45 , , , 19613 648 46 the the DT 19613 648 47 New New NNP 19613 648 48 Testament Testament NNP 19613 648 49 was be VBD 19613 648 50 explained explain VBN 19613 648 51 in in IN 19613 648 52 accordance accordance NN 19613 648 53 with with IN 19613 648 54 the the DT 19613 648 55 conception conception NN 19613 648 56 of of IN 19613 648 57 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 648 58 that that WDT 19613 648 59 had have VBD 19613 648 60 become become VBN 19613 648 61 prevalent prevalent JJ 19613 648 62 in in IN 19613 648 63 the the DT 19613 648 64 Church Church NNP 19613 648 65 . . . 19613 649 1 At at IN 19613 649 2 first first RB 19613 649 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 649 4 the the DT 19613 649 5 spirit spirit NN 19613 649 6 of of IN 19613 649 7 the the DT 19613 649 8 New New NNP 19613 649 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 649 10 could could MD 19613 649 11 only only RB 19613 649 12 assert assert VB 19613 649 13 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 649 14 in in IN 19613 649 15 certain certain JJ 19613 649 16 undercurrents undercurrent NNS 19613 649 17 and and CC 19613 649 18 in in IN 19613 649 19 the the DT 19613 649 20 recognition recognition NN 19613 649 21 of of IN 19613 649 22 particular particular JJ 19613 649 23 truths truth NNS 19613 649 24 . . . 19613 650 1 But but CC 19613 650 2 the the DT 19613 650 3 book book NN 19613 650 4 did do VBD 19613 650 5 not not RB 19613 650 6 in in IN 19613 650 7 the the DT 19613 650 8 least least JJS 19613 650 9 ward ward NN 19613 650 10 off off IN 19613 650 11 the the DT 19613 650 12 danger danger NN 19613 650 13 of of IN 19613 650 14 a a DT 19613 650 15 total total JJ 19613 650 16 secularising secularising NN 19613 650 17 of of IN 19613 650 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 650 19 . . . 19613 651 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 651 2 4 4 LS 19613 651 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 651 4 The the DT 19613 651 5 New New NNP 19613 651 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 651 7 opposed oppose VBD 19613 651 8 a a DT 19613 651 9 barrier barrier NN 19613 651 10 to to IN 19613 651 11 the the DT 19613 651 12 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 651 13 manufacture manufacture NN 19613 651 14 of of IN 19613 651 15 " " `` 19613 651 16 facts fact NNS 19613 651 17 . . . 19613 651 18 " " '' 19613 652 1 But but CC 19613 652 2 at at IN 19613 652 3 the the DT 19613 652 4 same same JJ 19613 652 5 time time NN 19613 652 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 652 7 claim claim NN 19613 652 8 to to TO 19613 652 9 be be VB 19613 652 10 a a DT 19613 652 11 collection collection NN 19613 652 12 of of IN 19613 652 13 _ _ NNP 19613 652 14 inspired inspire VBN 19613 652 15 _ _ NNP 19613 652 16 writings[123 writings[123 NN 19613 652 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 652 18 naturally naturally RB 19613 652 19 resulted result VBD 19613 652 20 in in IN 19613 652 21 principles principle NNS 19613 652 22 of of IN 19613 652 23 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 652 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 652 25 such such JJ 19613 652 26 as as IN 19613 652 27 the the DT 19613 652 28 principle principle NN 19613 652 29 of of IN 19613 652 30 unanimity unanimity NN 19613 652 31 , , , 19613 652 32 of of IN 19613 652 33 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 652 34 combination combination NN 19613 652 35 , , , 19613 652 36 of of IN 19613 652 37 absolute absolute JJ 19613 652 38 clearness clearness NN 19613 652 39 and and CC 19613 652 40 sufficiency sufficiency NN 19613 652 41 , , , 19613 652 42 and and CC 19613 652 43 of of IN 19613 652 44 allegorism allegorism NN 19613 652 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 652 46 which which WDT 19613 652 47 were be VBD 19613 652 48 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 652 49 followed follow VBN 19613 652 50 by by IN 19613 652 51 the the DT 19613 652 52 manufacture manufacture NN 19613 652 53 of of IN 19613 652 54 new new JJ 19613 652 55 facts fact NNS 19613 652 56 on on IN 19613 652 57 the the DT 19613 652 58 part part NN 19613 652 59 of of IN 19613 652 60 theological theological JJ 19613 652 61 experts expert NNS 19613 652 62 . . . 19613 653 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 653 2 5 5 LS 19613 653 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 653 4 The the DT 19613 653 5 New New NNP 19613 653 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 653 7 fixed fix VBD 19613 653 8 a a DT 19613 653 9 time time NN 19613 653 10 within within IN 19613 653 11 which which WDT 19613 653 12 divine divine JJ 19613 653 13 revelation revelation NN 19613 653 14 ceased cease VBD 19613 653 15 , , , 19613 653 16 and and CC 19613 653 17 prevented prevent VBD 19613 653 18 any any DT 19613 653 19 Christian Christian NNP 19613 653 20 from from IN 19613 653 21 putting put VBG 19613 653 22 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 653 23 into into IN 19613 653 24 comparison comparison NN 19613 653 25 with with IN 19613 653 26 the the DT 19613 653 27 disciples disciple NNS 19613 653 28 of of IN 19613 653 29 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 653 30 . . . 19613 654 1 By by IN 19613 654 2 doing do VBG 19613 654 3 so so RB 19613 654 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 654 5 directly directly RB 19613 654 6 promoted promote VBD 19613 654 7 the the DT 19613 654 8 lowering lowering NN 19613 654 9 of of IN 19613 654 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 654 11 ideals ideal NNS 19613 654 12 and and CC 19613 654 13 requirements requirement NNS 19613 654 14 , , , 19613 654 15 and and CC 19613 654 16 in in IN 19613 654 17 a a DT 19613 654 18 certain certain JJ 19613 654 19 fashion fashion NN 19613 654 20 legitimised legitimise VBD 19613 654 21 this this DT 19613 654 22 weakening weakening NN 19613 654 23 of of IN 19613 654 24 religious religious JJ 19613 654 25 power power NN 19613 654 26 . . . 19613 655 1 At at IN 19613 655 2 the the DT 19613 655 3 same same JJ 19613 655 4 time time NN 19613 655 5 , , , 19613 655 6 however however RB 19613 655 7 , , , 19613 655 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 655 9 maintained maintain VBD 19613 655 10 the the DT 19613 655 11 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 655 12 of of IN 19613 655 13 these these DT 19613 655 14 ideals ideal NNS 19613 655 15 and and CC 19613 655 16 requirements requirement NNS 19613 655 17 , , , 19613 655 18 became become VBD 19613 655 19 a a DT 19613 655 20 spur spur NN 19613 655 21 to to IN 19613 655 22 the the DT 19613 655 23 conscience conscience NN 19613 655 24 of of IN 19613 655 25 believers believer NNS 19613 655 26 , , , 19613 655 27 and and CC 19613 655 28 averted avert VBD 19613 655 29 the the DT 19613 655 30 danger danger NN 19613 655 31 of of IN 19613 655 32 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 655 33 being be VBG 19613 655 34 corrupted corrupt VBN 19613 655 35 by by IN 19613 655 36 the the DT 19613 655 37 excesses excess NNS 19613 655 38 of of IN 19613 655 39 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 655 40 . . . 19613 656 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 656 2 6 6 LS 19613 656 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 656 4 The the DT 19613 656 5 fact fact NN 19613 656 6 of of IN 19613 656 7 the the DT 19613 656 8 New New NNP 19613 656 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 656 10 being be VBG 19613 656 11 placed place VBN 19613 656 12 on on IN 19613 656 13 a a DT 19613 656 14 level level NN 19613 656 15 with with IN 19613 656 16 the the DT 19613 656 17 Old Old NNP 19613 656 18 proved prove VBD 19613 656 19 the the DT 19613 656 20 most most RBS 19613 656 21 effective effective JJ 19613 656 22 means mean NNS 19613 656 23 of of IN 19613 656 24 preserving preserve VBG 19613 656 25 to to IN 19613 656 26 the the DT 19613 656 27 latter latter JJ 19613 656 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 656 29 canonical canonical JJ 19613 656 30 authority authority NN 19613 656 31 , , , 19613 656 32 which which WDT 19613 656 33 had have VBD 19613 656 34 been be VBN 19613 656 35 so so RB 19613 656 36 often often RB 19613 656 37 assailed assail VBN 19613 656 38 in in IN 19613 656 39 the the DT 19613 656 40 second second JJ 19613 656 41 century century NN 19613 656 42 . . . 19613 657 1 But but CC 19613 657 2 at at IN 19613 657 3 the the DT 19613 657 4 same same JJ 19613 657 5 time time NN 19613 657 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 657 7 brought bring VBD 19613 657 8 about about RP 19613 657 9 an an DT 19613 657 10 examination examination NN 19613 657 11 of of IN 19613 657 12 the the DT 19613 657 13 relation relation NN 19613 657 14 between between IN 19613 657 15 the the DT 19613 657 16 Old Old NNP 19613 657 17 and and CC 19613 657 18 New New NNP 19613 657 19 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 657 20 , , , 19613 657 21 which which WDT 19613 657 22 , , , 19613 657 23 however however RB 19613 657 24 , , , 19613 657 25 also also RB 19613 657 26 involved involve VBD 19613 657 27 an an DT 19613 657 28 enquiry enquiry NN 19613 657 29 into into IN 19613 657 30 the the DT 19613 657 31 connection connection NN 19613 657 32 between between IN 19613 657 33 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 657 34 and and CC 19613 657 35 pre pre JJ 19613 657 36 - - JJ 19613 657 37 christian christian JJ 19613 657 38 revelation revelation NN 19613 657 39 . . . 19613 658 1 The the DT 19613 658 2 immediate immediate JJ 19613 658 3 result result NN 19613 658 4 of of IN 19613 658 5 this this DT 19613 658 6 investigation investigation NN 19613 658 7 was be VBD 19613 658 8 not not RB 19613 658 9 only only RB 19613 658 10 a a DT 19613 658 11 theological theological JJ 19613 658 12 exposition exposition NN 19613 658 13 of of IN 19613 658 14 the the DT 19613 658 15 Old Old NNP 19613 658 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 658 17 , , , 19613 658 18 but but CC 19613 658 19 also also RB 19613 658 20 a a DT 19613 658 21 theory theory NN 19613 658 22 which which WDT 19613 658 23 ceased cease VBD 19613 658 24 to to TO 19613 658 25 view view VB 19613 658 26 the the DT 19613 658 27 two two CD 19613 658 28 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 658 29 as as IN 19613 658 30 of of IN 19613 658 31 equal equal JJ 19613 658 32 authority authority NN 19613 658 33 and and CC 19613 658 34 _ _ NNP 19613 658 35 subordinated subordinate VBN 19613 658 36 _ _ NNP 19613 658 37 the the DT 19613 658 38 Old Old NNP 19613 658 39 to to IN 19613 658 40 the the DT 19613 658 41 New New NNP 19613 658 42 . . . 19613 659 1 This this DT 19613 659 2 result result NN 19613 659 3 , , , 19613 659 4 which which WDT 19613 659 5 can can MD 19613 659 6 be be VB 19613 659 7 plainly plainly RB 19613 659 8 seen see VBN 19613 659 9 in in IN 19613 659 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 659 11 , , , 19613 659 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 659 13 , , , 19613 659 14 and and CC 19613 659 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 659 16 , , , 19613 659 17 led lead VBD 19613 659 18 to to IN 19613 659 19 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 659 20 important important JJ 19613 659 21 consequences consequence NNS 19613 659 22 . . . 19613 660 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 660 2 124 124 CD 19613 660 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 660 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 660 5 gave give VBD 19613 660 6 some some DT 19613 660 7 degree degree NN 19613 660 8 of of IN 19613 660 9 insight insight NN 19613 660 10 into into IN 19613 660 11 statements statement NNS 19613 660 12 , , , 19613 660 13 hitherto hitherto NNP 19613 660 14 completely completely RB 19613 660 15 unintelligible unintelligible JJ 19613 660 16 , , , 19613 660 17 in in IN 19613 660 18 certain certain JJ 19613 660 19 New New NNP 19613 660 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 660 21 writings writing NNS 19613 660 22 , , , 19613 660 23 and and CC 19613 660 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 660 25 caused cause VBD 19613 660 26 the the DT 19613 660 27 Church Church NNP 19613 660 28 to to TO 19613 660 29 reflect reflect VB 19613 660 30 upon upon IN 19613 660 31 a a DT 19613 660 32 question question NN 19613 660 33 that that WDT 19613 660 34 had have VBD 19613 660 35 as as RB 19613 660 36 yet yet RB 19613 660 37 been be VBN 19613 660 38 raised raise VBN 19613 660 39 only only RB 19613 660 40 by by IN 19613 660 41 heretics heretic NNS 19613 660 42 , , , 19613 660 43 viz viz NNP 19613 660 44 . . NNP 19613 660 45 , , , 19613 660 46 what what WP 19613 660 47 are be VBP 19613 660 48 the the DT 19613 660 49 marks mark NNS 19613 660 50 which which WDT 19613 660 51 distinguish distinguish VBP 19613 660 52 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 660 53 from from IN 19613 660 54 the the DT 19613 660 55 Old Old NNP 19613 660 56 Testament Testament NNP 19613 660 57 religion religion NN 19613 660 58 ? ? . 19613 661 1 An an DT 19613 661 2 historical historical JJ 19613 661 3 examination examination NN 19613 661 4 imperceptibly imperceptibly RB 19613 661 5 arose arise VBD 19613 661 6 ; ; : 19613 661 7 but but CC 19613 661 8 the the DT 19613 661 9 old old JJ 19613 661 10 notion notion NN 19613 661 11 of of IN 19613 661 12 the the DT 19613 661 13 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 661 14 of of IN 19613 661 15 the the DT 19613 661 16 Old Old NNP 19613 661 17 Testament Testament NNP 19613 661 18 confined confine VBD 19613 661 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 661 20 to to IN 19613 661 21 the the DT 19613 661 22 narrowest narrow JJS 19613 661 23 limits limit NNS 19613 661 24 , , , 19613 661 25 and and CC 19613 661 26 in in IN 19613 661 27 fact fact NN 19613 661 28 always always RB 19613 661 29 continued continue VBD 19613 661 30 to to TO 19613 661 31 forbid forbid VB 19613 661 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 661 33 ; ; : 19613 661 34 for for IN 19613 661 35 , , , 19613 661 36 as as IN 19613 661 37 before before RB 19613 661 38 , , , 19613 661 39 appeal appeal NN 19613 661 40 was be VBD 19613 661 41 constantly constantly RB 19613 661 42 made make VBN 19613 661 43 to to IN 19613 661 44 the the DT 19613 661 45 Old Old NNP 19613 661 46 Testament Testament NNP 19613 661 47 as as IN 19613 661 48 a a DT 19613 661 49 Christian christian JJ 19613 661 50 book book NN 19613 661 51 which which WDT 19613 661 52 contained contain VBD 19613 661 53 all all PDT 19613 661 54 the the DT 19613 661 55 truths truth NNS 19613 661 56 of of IN 19613 661 57 religion religion NN 19613 661 58 in in IN 19613 661 59 a a DT 19613 661 60 perfect perfect JJ 19613 661 61 form form NN 19613 661 62 . . . 19613 662 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 662 2 the the DT 19613 662 3 conception conception NN 19613 662 4 of of IN 19613 662 5 the the DT 19613 662 6 Old Old NNP 19613 662 7 Testament Testament NNP 19613 662 8 was be VBD 19613 662 9 here here RB 19613 662 10 and and CC 19613 662 11 there there EX 19613 662 12 full full JJ 19613 662 13 of of IN 19613 662 14 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 662 15 . . . 19613 663 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 663 2 125 125 CD 19613 663 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 663 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 663 5 7 7 LS 19613 663 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 663 7 The the DT 19613 663 8 fatal fatal JJ 19613 663 9 identification identification NN 19613 663 10 of of IN 19613 663 11 words word NNS 19613 663 12 of of IN 19613 663 13 the the DT 19613 663 14 Lord Lord NNP 19613 663 15 and and CC 19613 663 16 words word NNS 19613 663 17 of of IN 19613 663 18 the the DT 19613 663 19 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 663 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 663 21 apostolical apostolical JJ 19613 663 22 tradition tradition NN 19613 663 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 663 24 had have VBD 19613 663 25 existed exist VBN 19613 663 26 before before IN 19613 663 27 the the DT 19613 663 28 creation creation NN 19613 663 29 of of IN 19613 663 30 the the DT 19613 663 31 New New NNP 19613 663 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 663 33 , , , 19613 663 34 though though IN 19613 663 35 this this DT 19613 663 36 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 663 37 gave give VBD 19613 663 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 663 39 a a DT 19613 663 40 new new JJ 19613 663 41 range range NN 19613 663 42 and and CC 19613 663 43 content content NN 19613 663 44 and and CC 19613 663 45 a a DT 19613 663 46 new new JJ 19613 663 47 significance significance NN 19613 663 48 . . . 19613 664 1 But but CC 19613 664 2 , , , 19613 664 3 with with IN 19613 664 4 the the DT 19613 664 5 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 664 6 of of IN 19613 664 7 Paul Paul NNP 19613 664 8 included include VBD 19613 664 9 , , , 19613 664 10 the the DT 19613 664 11 New New NNP 19613 664 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 664 13 elevated elevate VBD 19613 664 14 the the DT 19613 664 15 highest high JJS 19613 664 16 expression expression NN 19613 664 17 of of IN 19613 664 18 the the DT 19613 664 19 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 664 20 of of IN 19613 664 21 redemption redemption NN 19613 664 22 into into IN 19613 664 23 a a DT 19613 664 24 guiding guide VBG 19613 664 25 principle principle NN 19613 664 26 , , , 19613 664 27 and and CC 19613 664 28 by by IN 19613 664 29 admitting admit VBG 19613 664 30 Paulinism Paulinism NNP 19613 664 31 into into IN 19613 664 32 the the DT 19613 664 33 canon canon NN 19613 664 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 664 35 introduced introduce VBD 19613 664 36 a a DT 19613 664 37 wholesome wholesome JJ 19613 664 38 ferment ferment NN 19613 664 39 into into IN 19613 664 40 the the DT 19613 664 41 history history NN 19613 664 42 of of IN 19613 664 43 the the DT 19613 664 44 Church Church NNP 19613 664 45 . . . 19613 665 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 665 2 8) 8) CD 19613 665 3 By by IN 19613 665 4 creating create VBG 19613 665 5 the the DT 19613 665 6 New New NNP 19613 665 7 Testament Testament NNP 19613 665 8 and and CC 19613 665 9 claiming claim VBG 19613 665 10 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 665 11 possession possession NN 19613 665 12 of of IN 19613 665 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 665 14 the the DT 19613 665 15 Church Church NNP 19613 665 16 deprived deprive VBD 19613 665 17 the the DT 19613 665 18 non non JJ 19613 665 19 - - JJ 19613 665 20 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 665 21 communions communion NNS 19613 665 22 of of IN 19613 665 23 every every DT 19613 665 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 665 25 foundation foundation NN 19613 665 26 , , , 19613 665 27 just just RB 19613 665 28 as as IN 19613 665 29 she -PRON- PRP 19613 665 30 had have VBD 19613 665 31 divested divest VBN 19613 665 32 Judaism Judaism NNP 19613 665 33 of of IN 19613 665 34 every every DT 19613 665 35 legal legal JJ 19613 665 36 title title NN 19613 665 37 by by IN 19613 665 38 taking take VBG 19613 665 39 possession possession NN 19613 665 40 of of IN 19613 665 41 the the DT 19613 665 42 Old Old NNP 19613 665 43 Testament Testament NNP 19613 665 44 ; ; : 19613 665 45 but but CC 19613 665 46 , , , 19613 665 47 by by IN 19613 665 48 raising raise VBG 19613 665 49 the the DT 19613 665 50 New New NNP 19613 665 51 Testament Testament NNP 19613 665 52 to to IN 19613 665 53 standard standard JJ 19613 665 54 authority authority NN 19613 665 55 , , , 19613 665 56 she -PRON- PRP 19613 665 57 created create VBD 19613 665 58 the the DT 19613 665 59 armoury armoury NN 19613 665 60 which which WDT 19613 665 61 supplied supply VBD 19613 665 62 the the DT 19613 665 63 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 665 64 period period NN 19613 665 65 with with IN 19613 665 66 the the DT 19613 665 67 keenest keen JJS 19613 665 68 weapons weapon NNS 19613 665 69 against against IN 19613 665 70 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 665 71 . . . 19613 666 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 666 2 126 126 CD 19613 666 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 666 4 The the DT 19613 666 5 place place NN 19613 666 6 of of IN 19613 666 7 the the DT 19613 666 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 666 9 was be VBD 19613 666 10 taken take VBN 19613 666 11 by by IN 19613 666 12 a a DT 19613 666 13 book book NN 19613 666 14 with with IN 19613 666 15 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 666 16 varied varied JJ 19613 666 17 contents content NNS 19613 666 18 , , , 19613 666 19 which which WDT 19613 666 20 theoretically theoretically RB 19613 666 21 acquired acquire VBD 19613 666 22 the the DT 19613 666 23 same same JJ 19613 666 24 authority authority NN 19613 666 25 as as IN 19613 666 26 the the DT 19613 666 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 666 28 . . . 19613 667 1 Still still RB 19613 667 2 , , , 19613 667 3 the the DT 19613 667 4 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 667 5 Church Church NNP 19613 667 6 never never RB 19613 667 7 became become VBD 19613 667 8 a a DT 19613 667 9 religion religion NN 19613 667 10 " " '' 19613 667 11 of of IN 19613 667 12 the the DT 19613 667 13 book book NN 19613 667 14 , , , 19613 667 15 " " '' 19613 667 16 because because IN 19613 667 17 every every DT 19613 667 18 inconvenient inconvenient JJ 19613 667 19 text text NN 19613 667 20 could could MD 19613 667 21 be be VB 19613 667 22 explained explain VBN 19613 667 23 away away RP 19613 667 24 by by IN 19613 667 25 the the DT 19613 667 26 allegoric allegoric NN 19613 667 27 method method NN 19613 667 28 , , , 19613 667 29 and and CC 19613 667 30 because because IN 19613 667 31 the the DT 19613 667 32 book book NN 19613 667 33 was be VBD 19613 667 34 not not RB 19613 667 35 made make VBN 19613 667 36 use use NN 19613 667 37 of of IN 19613 667 38 as as IN 19613 667 39 the the DT 19613 667 40 immediate immediate JJ 19613 667 41 authority authority NN 19613 667 42 for for IN 19613 667 43 the the DT 19613 667 44 guidance guidance NN 19613 667 45 of of IN 19613 667 46 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 667 47 , , , 19613 667 48 this this DT 19613 667 49 latter latter JJ 19613 667 50 function function NN 19613 667 51 being be VBG 19613 667 52 directly directly RB 19613 667 53 discharged discharge VBN 19613 667 54 by by IN 19613 667 55 the the DT 19613 667 56 rule rule NN 19613 667 57 of of IN 19613 667 58 faith faith NN 19613 667 59 . . . 19613 668 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 668 2 127 127 CD 19613 668 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 668 4 In in IN 19613 668 5 practice practice NN 19613 668 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 668 7 continued continue VBD 19613 668 8 to to TO 19613 668 9 be be VB 19613 668 10 the the DT 19613 668 11 rule rule NN 19613 668 12 for for IN 19613 668 13 the the DT 19613 668 14 New New NNP 19613 668 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 668 16 to to TO 19613 668 17 take take VB 19613 668 18 a a DT 19613 668 19 secondary secondary JJ 19613 668 20 place place NN 19613 668 21 in in IN 19613 668 22 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 668 23 writings writing NNS 19613 668 24 and and CC 19613 668 25 disputes dispute NNS 19613 668 26 with with IN 19613 668 27 heretics heretic NNS 19613 668 28 . . . 19613 669 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 669 2 128 128 CD 19613 669 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 669 4 On on IN 19613 669 5 the the DT 19613 669 6 other other JJ 19613 669 7 hand hand NN 19613 669 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 669 9 was be VBD 19613 669 10 regarded regard VBN 19613 669 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 669 12 1 1 CD 19613 669 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 669 14 as as IN 19613 669 15 the the DT 19613 669 16 directly directly RB 19613 669 17 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 669 18 document document NN 19613 669 19 for for IN 19613 669 20 the the DT 19613 669 21 direction direction NN 19613 669 22 of of IN 19613 669 23 the the DT 19613 669 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 669 25 life,[129 life,[129 NN 19613 669 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 669 27 and and CC 19613 669 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 669 29 2 2 LS 19613 669 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 669 31 as as IN 19613 669 32 the the DT 19613 669 33 final final JJ 19613 669 34 court court NN 19613 669 35 of of IN 19613 669 36 appeal appeal NN 19613 669 37 in in IN 19613 669 38 all all PDT 19613 669 39 the the DT 19613 669 40 conflicts conflict NNS 19613 669 41 that that WDT 19613 669 42 arose arise VBD 19613 669 43 within within IN 19613 669 44 the the DT 19613 669 45 sphere sphere NN 19613 669 46 of of IN 19613 669 47 the the DT 19613 669 48 rule rule NN 19613 669 49 of of IN 19613 669 50 faith faith NN 19613 669 51 . . . 19613 670 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 670 2 was be VBD 19613 670 3 freely freely RB 19613 670 4 applied apply VBN 19613 670 5 in in IN 19613 670 6 the the DT 19613 670 7 second second JJ 19613 670 8 stage stage NN 19613 670 9 of of IN 19613 670 10 the the DT 19613 670 11 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 670 12 struggle struggle NN 19613 670 13 , , , 19613 670 14 but but CC 19613 670 15 still still RB 19613 670 16 more more JJR 19613 670 17 in in IN 19613 670 18 the the DT 19613 670 19 controversies controversy NNS 19613 670 20 about about IN 19613 670 21 Christology Christology NNP 19613 670 22 , , , 19613 670 23 that that RB 19613 670 24 is is RB 19613 670 25 , , , 19613 670 26 in in IN 19613 670 27 the the DT 19613 670 28 conflict conflict NN 19613 670 29 with with IN 19613 670 30 the the DT 19613 670 31 Monarchians Monarchians NNPS 19613 670 32 . . . 19613 671 1 The the DT 19613 671 2 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 671 3 writings writing NNS 19613 671 4 belong belong VBP 19613 671 5 solely solely RB 19613 671 6 to to IN 19613 671 7 the the DT 19613 671 8 Church Church NNP 19613 671 9 , , , 19613 671 10 because because IN 19613 671 11 she -PRON- PRP 19613 671 12 alone alone RB 19613 671 13 has have VBZ 19613 671 14 preserved preserve VBN 19613 671 15 the the DT 19613 671 16 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 671 17 doctrine doctrine NNP 19613 671 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 671 19 regula regula NNP 19613 671 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 671 21 . . . 19613 672 1 This this DT 19613 672 2 was be VBD 19613 672 3 declared declare VBN 19613 672 4 to to IN 19613 672 5 the the DT 19613 672 6 heretics heretic NNS 19613 672 7 and and CC 19613 672 8 therewith therewith NNP 19613 672 9 all all DT 19613 672 10 controversy controversy NN 19613 672 11 about about IN 19613 672 12 Scripture scripture NN 19613 672 13 , , , 19613 672 14 or or CC 19613 672 15 the the DT 19613 672 16 sense sense NN 19613 672 17 of of IN 19613 672 18 Scripture scripture NN 19613 672 19 passages passage NNS 19613 672 20 , , , 19613 672 21 was be VBD 19613 672 22 in in IN 19613 672 23 principle principle NN 19613 672 24 declined decline VBD 19613 672 25 . . . 19613 673 1 But but CC 19613 673 2 within within IN 19613 673 3 the the DT 19613 673 4 Church Church NNP 19613 673 5 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 673 6 the the DT 19613 673 7 Holy Holy NNP 19613 673 8 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 673 9 was be VBD 19613 673 10 regarded regard VBN 19613 673 11 as as IN 19613 673 12 the the DT 19613 673 13 supreme supreme NNP 19613 673 14 and and CC 19613 673 15 completely completely RB 19613 673 16 independent independent JJ 19613 673 17 tribunal tribunal NN 19613 673 18 against against IN 19613 673 19 which which WDT 19613 673 20 not not RB 19613 673 21 even even RB 19613 673 22 an an DT 19613 673 23 old old JJ 19613 673 24 tradition tradition NN 19613 673 25 could could MD 19613 673 26 be be VB 19613 673 27 appealed appeal VBN 19613 673 28 to to IN 19613 673 29 ; ; : 19613 673 30 and and CC 19613 673 31 the the DT 19613 673 32 rule rule NN 19613 673 33 [ [ -LRB- 19613 673 34 Greek Greek NNP 19613 673 35 : : : 19613 673 36 politeuesthai politeuesthai NNP 19613 673 37 kata kata NNP 19613 673 38 to to IN 19613 673 39 euangelion euangelion NN 19613 673 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 673 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 673 42 " " `` 19613 673 43 live live RB 19613 673 44 according accord VBG 19613 673 45 to to IN 19613 673 46 the the DT 19613 673 47 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 673 48 " " '' 19613 673 49 ) ) -RRB- 19613 673 50 held hold VBD 19613 673 51 good good JJ 19613 673 52 in in IN 19613 673 53 every every DT 19613 673 54 respect respect NN 19613 673 55 . . . 19613 674 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 674 2 , , , 19613 674 3 this this DT 19613 674 4 formula formula NN 19613 674 5 , , , 19613 674 6 which which WDT 19613 674 7 is be VBZ 19613 674 8 rarely rarely RB 19613 674 9 replaced replace VBN 19613 674 10 by by IN 19613 674 11 the the DT 19613 674 12 other other JJ 19613 674 13 one one CD 19613 674 14 , , , 19613 674 15 viz viz NN 19613 674 16 . . . 19613 674 17 , , , 19613 674 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 674 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 674 20 : : : 19613 674 21 kata kata NNP 19613 674 22 tên tên NNP 19613 674 23 kainên kainên NNP 19613 674 24 diathêkên diathêkên NNP 19613 674 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 674 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 674 27 " " `` 19613 674 28 according accord VBG 19613 674 29 to to IN 19613 674 30 the the DT 19613 674 31 New New NNP 19613 674 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 674 33 " " '' 19613 674 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 674 35 , , , 19613 674 36 shows show VBZ 19613 674 37 that that IN 19613 674 38 the the DT 19613 674 39 words word NNS 19613 674 40 of of IN 19613 674 41 the the DT 19613 674 42 Lord Lord NNP 19613 674 43 , , , 19613 674 44 as as IN 19613 674 45 in in IN 19613 674 46 the the DT 19613 674 47 earlier early JJR 19613 674 48 period period NN 19613 674 49 , , , 19613 674 50 continued continue VBD 19613 674 51 to to TO 19613 674 52 be be VB 19613 674 53 the the DT 19613 674 54 chief chief JJ 19613 674 55 standard standard NN 19613 674 56 of of IN 19613 674 57 _ _ NNP 19613 674 58 life life NN 19613 674 59 and and CC 19613 674 60 conduct conduct VB 19613 674 61 _ _ NNP 19613 674 62 . . . 19613 675 1 C. C. NNP 19613 675 2 _ _ NNP 19613 675 3 The the DT 19613 675 4 transformation transformation NN 19613 675 5 of of IN 19613 675 6 the the DT 19613 675 7 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 675 8 office office NN 19613 675 9 in in IN 19613 675 10 the the DT 19613 675 11 Church Church NNP 19613 675 12 into into IN 19613 675 13 an an DT 19613 675 14 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 675 15 office office NN 19613 675 16 . . . 19613 676 1 The the DT 19613 676 2 history history NN 19613 676 3 of of IN 19613 676 4 the the DT 19613 676 5 remodelling remodelling NN 19613 676 6 of of IN 19613 676 7 the the DT 19613 676 8 conception conception NN 19613 676 9 of of IN 19613 676 10 the the DT 19613 676 11 Church._[130 Church._[130 NNP 19613 676 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 676 13 1 1 CD 19613 676 14 . . . 19613 677 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 677 2 was be VBD 19613 677 3 not not RB 19613 677 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 677 5 to to TO 19613 677 6 prove prove VB 19613 677 7 that that IN 19613 677 8 the the DT 19613 677 9 rule rule NN 19613 677 10 of of IN 19613 677 11 faith faith NN 19613 677 12 was be VBD 19613 677 13 of of IN 19613 677 14 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 677 15 origin origin NN 19613 677 16 , , , 19613 677 17 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 677 18 , , , 19613 677 19 that that IN 19613 677 20 the the DT 19613 677 21 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 677 22 had have VBD 19613 677 23 set set VBN 19613 677 24 up up RP 19613 677 25 a a DT 19613 677 26 rule rule NN 19613 677 27 of of IN 19613 677 28 faith faith NN 19613 677 29 . . . 19613 678 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 678 2 had have VBD 19613 678 3 further far RBR 19613 678 4 to to TO 19613 678 5 be be VB 19613 678 6 shown show VBN 19613 678 7 that that IN 19613 678 8 , , , 19613 678 9 up up RB 19613 678 10 to to IN 19613 678 11 the the DT 19613 678 12 present present NN 19613 678 13 , , , 19613 678 14 the the DT 19613 678 15 Church Church NNP 19613 678 16 had have VBD 19613 678 17 always always RB 19613 678 18 maintained maintain VBN 19613 678 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 678 20 unchanged unchanged JJ 19613 678 21 . . . 19613 679 1 This this DT 19613 679 2 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 679 3 was be VBD 19613 679 4 all all PDT 19613 679 5 the the DT 19613 679 6 more more RBR 19613 679 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 679 8 because because IN 19613 679 9 the the DT 19613 679 10 heretics heretic NNS 19613 679 11 also also RB 19613 679 12 claimed claim VBD 19613 679 13 an an DT 19613 679 14 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 679 15 origin origin NN 19613 679 16 for for IN 19613 679 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 679 18 _ _ NNP 19613 679 19 regulæ regulæ NN 19613 679 20 _ _ NNP 19613 679 21 , , , 19613 679 22 and and CC 19613 679 23 in in IN 19613 679 24 different different JJ 19613 679 25 ways way NNS 19613 679 26 tried try VBD 19613 679 27 to to TO 19613 679 28 adduce adduce VB 19613 679 29 proof proof NN 19613 679 30 that that IN 19613 679 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 679 32 alone alone RB 19613 679 33 possessed possess VBD 19613 679 34 a a DT 19613 679 35 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 679 36 of of IN 19613 679 37 inheriting inherit VBG 19613 679 38 the the DT 19613 679 39 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 679 40 ' ' POS 19613 679 41 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 679 42 in in IN 19613 679 43 all all DT 19613 679 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 679 45 purity purity NN 19613 679 46 . . . 19613 680 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 680 2 131 131 CD 19613 680 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 680 4 An an DT 19613 680 5 historical historical JJ 19613 680 6 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 680 7 was be VBD 19613 680 8 first first RB 19613 680 9 attempted attempt VBN 19613 680 10 by by IN 19613 680 11 the the DT 19613 680 12 earliest early JJS 19613 680 13 of of IN 19613 680 14 the the DT 19613 680 15 old old JJ 19613 680 16 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 680 17 Fathers father NNS 19613 680 18 . . . 19613 681 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 681 2 pointed point VBD 19613 681 3 to to IN 19613 681 4 communities community NNS 19613 681 5 of of IN 19613 681 6 whose whose WP$ 19613 681 7 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 681 8 origin origin NN 19613 681 9 there there EX 19613 681 10 could could MD 19613 681 11 be be VB 19613 681 12 no no RB 19613 681 13 doubt doubt RB 19613 681 14 , , , 19613 681 15 and and CC 19613 681 16 thought think VBD 19613 681 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 681 18 could could MD 19613 681 19 not not RB 19613 681 20 reasonably reasonably RB 19613 681 21 be be VB 19613 681 22 denied deny VBN 19613 681 23 that that IN 19613 681 24 those those DT 19613 681 25 Churches church NNS 19613 681 26 must must MD 19613 681 27 have have VB 19613 681 28 preserved preserve VBN 19613 681 29 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 681 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 681 31 in in IN 19613 681 32 a a DT 19613 681 33 pure pure JJ 19613 681 34 and and CC 19613 681 35 incorrupt incorrupt JJ 19613 681 36 form form NN 19613 681 37 . . . 19613 682 1 The the DT 19613 682 2 proof proof NN 19613 682 3 that that IN 19613 682 4 the the DT 19613 682 5 Church Church NNP 19613 682 6 had have VBD 19613 682 7 always always RB 19613 682 8 held hold VBN 19613 682 9 fast fast RB 19613 682 10 by by IN 19613 682 11 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 682 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 682 13 depended depend VBD 19613 682 14 on on IN 19613 682 15 the the DT 19613 682 16 agreement agreement NN 19613 682 17 in in IN 19613 682 18 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 682 19 between between IN 19613 682 20 the the DT 19613 682 21 other other JJ 19613 682 22 communities community NNS 19613 682 23 and and CC 19613 682 24 these these DT 19613 682 25 . . . 19613 683 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 683 2 132 132 CD 19613 683 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 683 4 But but CC 19613 683 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 683 6 as as RB 19613 683 7 well well RB 19613 683 8 as as IN 19613 683 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 683 10 felt feel VBD 19613 683 11 that that IN 19613 683 12 a a DT 19613 683 13 special special JJ 19613 683 14 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 683 15 was be VBD 19613 683 16 needed need VBN 19613 683 17 to to TO 19613 683 18 show show VB 19613 683 19 that that IN 19613 683 20 the the DT 19613 683 21 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 683 22 founded found VBN 19613 683 23 by by IN 19613 683 24 the the DT 19613 683 25 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 683 26 had have VBD 19613 683 27 really really RB 19613 683 28 at at RB 19613 683 29 all all DT 19613 683 30 times time NNS 19613 683 31 faithfully faithfully RB 19613 683 32 preserved preserve VBD 19613 683 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 683 34 genuine genuine JJ 19613 683 35 teaching teaching NN 19613 683 36 . . . 19613 684 1 General general JJ 19613 684 2 considerations consideration NNS 19613 684 3 , , , 19613 684 4 as as IN 19613 684 5 , , , 19613 684 6 for for IN 19613 684 7 instance instance NN 19613 684 8 , , , 19613 684 9 the the DT 19613 684 10 notion notion NN 19613 684 11 that that IN 19613 684 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 684 13 would would MD 19613 684 14 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 684 15 have have VB 19613 684 16 temporarily temporarily RB 19613 684 17 perished perish VBN 19613 684 18 , , , 19613 684 19 or or CC 19613 684 20 " " `` 19613 684 21 that that DT 19613 684 22 one one CD 19613 684 23 event event NN 19613 684 24 among among IN 19613 684 25 many many JJ 19613 684 26 is be VBZ 19613 684 27 as as RB 19613 684 28 good good JJ 19613 684 29 as as IN 19613 684 30 none none NN 19613 684 31 ; ; : 19613 684 32 but but CC 19613 684 33 when when WRB 19613 684 34 one one CD 19613 684 35 and and CC 19613 684 36 the the DT 19613 684 37 same same JJ 19613 684 38 feature feature NN 19613 684 39 is be VBZ 19613 684 40 found find VBN 19613 684 41 among among IN 19613 684 42 many many JJ 19613 684 43 , , , 19613 684 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 684 45 is be VBZ 19613 684 46 not not RB 19613 684 47 an an DT 19613 684 48 aberration aberration NN 19613 684 49 but but CC 19613 684 50 a a DT 19613 684 51 tradition tradition NN 19613 684 52 " " '' 19613 684 53 ( ( -LRB- 19613 684 54 " " `` 19613 684 55 Nullus nullus JJ 19613 684 56 inter inter JJ 19613 684 57 multos multos NN 19613 684 58 eventus eventus NN 19613 684 59 unus unus JJ 19613 684 60 est est NNP 19613 684 61 ... ... : 19613 684 62 quod quod NN 19613 684 63 apud apud NNP 19613 684 64 multos multos NNP 19613 684 65 unum unum NNP 19613 684 66 invenitur invenitur NNP 19613 684 67 , , , 19613 684 68 non non NNP 19613 684 69 est est NNP 19613 684 70 erratum erratum NNP 19613 684 71 sed se VBD 19613 684 72 traditum traditum NNP 19613 684 73 " " '' 19613 684 74 ) ) -RRB- 19613 684 75 and and CC 19613 684 76 similar similar JJ 19613 684 77 ones one NNS 19613 684 78 which which WDT 19613 684 79 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 684 80 does do VBZ 19613 684 81 not not RB 19613 684 82 fail fail VB 19613 684 83 to to TO 19613 684 84 mention mention VB 19613 684 85 , , , 19613 684 86 were be VBD 19613 684 87 not not RB 19613 684 88 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 684 89 . . . 19613 685 1 But but CC 19613 685 2 the the DT 19613 685 3 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 685 4 conception conception NN 19613 685 5 that that WDT 19613 685 6 the the DT 19613 685 7 _ _ NNP 19613 685 8 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 685 9 _ _ NNP 19613 685 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 685 11 or or CC 19613 685 12 _ _ NNP 19613 685 13 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 685 14 _ _ NNP 19613 685 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 685 16 are be VBP 19613 685 17 the the DT 19613 685 18 abode abode NN 19613 685 19 of of IN 19613 685 20 the the DT 19613 685 21 Holy Holy NNP 19613 685 22 Spirit,[133 Spirit,[133 NNP 19613 685 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 685 24 was be VBD 19613 685 25 incapable incapable JJ 19613 685 26 of of IN 19613 685 27 making make VBG 19613 685 28 any any DT 19613 685 29 impression impression NN 19613 685 30 on on IN 19613 685 31 the the DT 19613 685 32 heretics heretic NNS 19613 685 33 , , , 19613 685 34 as as IN 19613 685 35 the the DT 19613 685 36 correct correct JJ 19613 685 37 application application NN 19613 685 38 of of IN 19613 685 39 this this DT 19613 685 40 theory theory NN 19613 685 41 was be VBD 19613 685 42 the the DT 19613 685 43 very very JJ 19613 685 44 point point NN 19613 685 45 in in IN 19613 685 46 question question NN 19613 685 47 . . . 19613 686 1 To to TO 19613 686 2 make make VB 19613 686 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 686 4 proof proof NN 19613 686 5 more more RBR 19613 686 6 precise precise JJ 19613 686 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 686 8 and and CC 19613 686 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 686 10 therefore therefore RB 19613 686 11 asserted assert VBD 19613 686 12 that that IN 19613 686 13 the the DT 19613 686 14 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 686 15 guaranteed guarantee VBD 19613 686 16 the the DT 19613 686 17 incorruptness incorruptness NN 19613 686 18 of of IN 19613 686 19 the the DT 19613 686 20 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 686 21 inheritance inheritance NN 19613 686 22 , , , 19613 686 23 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 686 24 as as IN 19613 686 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 686 26 could could MD 19613 686 27 point point VB 19613 686 28 to to IN 19613 686 29 a a DT 19613 686 30 chain chain NN 19613 686 31 of of IN 19613 686 32 " " `` 19613 686 33 elders elder NNS 19613 686 34 , , , 19613 686 35 " " '' 19613 686 36 or or CC 19613 686 37 , , , 19613 686 38 in in IN 19613 686 39 other other JJ 19613 686 40 words word NNS 19613 686 41 , , , 19613 686 42 an an DT 19613 686 43 " " `` 19613 686 44 ordo ordo NN 19613 686 45 episcoporum episcoporum NN 19613 686 46 per per IN 19613 686 47 successionem successionem NNP 19613 686 48 ab ab NNP 19613 686 49 initio initio NN 19613 686 50 decurrens decurrens NNP 19613 686 51 , , , 19613 686 52 " " '' 19613 686 53 which which WDT 19613 686 54 was be VBD 19613 686 55 a a DT 19613 686 56 pledge pledge NN 19613 686 57 that that IN 19613 686 58 nothing nothing NN 19613 686 59 false false JJ 19613 686 60 had have VBD 19613 686 61 been be VBN 19613 686 62 mixed mix VBN 19613 686 63 up up RP 19613 686 64 with with IN 19613 686 65 it -PRON- PRP 19613 686 66 . . . 19613 687 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 687 2 134 134 CD 19613 687 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 687 4 This this DT 19613 687 5 thesis thesis NN 19613 687 6 has have VBZ 19613 687 7 quite quite RB 19613 687 8 as as RB 19613 687 9 many many JJ 19613 687 10 aspects aspect NNS 19613 687 11 as as IN 19613 687 12 the the DT 19613 687 13 conception conception NN 19613 687 14 of of IN 19613 687 15 the the DT 19613 687 16 " " `` 19613 687 17 Elders elder NNS 19613 687 18 , , , 19613 687 19 " " '' 19613 687 20 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 687 21 , , , 19613 687 22 disciples disciple NNS 19613 687 23 of of IN 19613 687 24 the the DT 19613 687 25 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 687 26 , , , 19613 687 27 disciples disciple NNS 19613 687 28 of of IN 19613 687 29 the the DT 19613 687 30 disciples disciple NNS 19613 687 31 of of IN 19613 687 32 the the DT 19613 687 33 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 687 34 , , , 19613 687 35 bishops bishop NNS 19613 687 36 . . . 19613 688 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 688 2 partly partly RB 19613 688 3 preserves preserve VBZ 19613 688 4 a a DT 19613 688 5 historic historic JJ 19613 688 6 and and CC 19613 688 7 partly partly RB 19613 688 8 assumes assume VBZ 19613 688 9 a a DT 19613 688 10 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 688 11 character character NN 19613 688 12 . . . 19613 689 1 The the DT 19613 689 2 former former JJ 19613 689 3 aspect aspect NN 19613 689 4 appears appear VBZ 19613 689 5 in in IN 19613 689 6 the the DT 19613 689 7 appeal appeal NN 19613 689 8 made make VBN 19613 689 9 to to IN 19613 689 10 the the DT 19613 689 11 foundation foundation NN 19613 689 12 of of IN 19613 689 13 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 689 14 by by IN 19613 689 15 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 689 16 , , , 19613 689 17 and and CC 19613 689 18 in in IN 19613 689 19 the the DT 19613 689 20 argument argument NN 19613 689 21 that that IN 19613 689 22 each each DT 19613 689 23 series series NN 19613 689 24 of of IN 19613 689 25 successors successor NNS 19613 689 26 were be VBD 19613 689 27 faithful faithful JJ 19613 689 28 disciples disciple NNS 19613 689 29 of of IN 19613 689 30 those those DT 19613 689 31 before before IN 19613 689 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 689 33 and and CC 19613 689 34 therefore therefore RB 19613 689 35 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 689 36 of of IN 19613 689 37 the the DT 19613 689 38 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 689 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 689 40 . . . 19613 690 1 But but CC 19613 690 2 no no DT 19613 690 3 historical historical JJ 19613 690 4 consideration consideration NN 19613 690 5 , , , 19613 690 6 no no DT 19613 690 7 appeal appeal NN 19613 690 8 to to IN 19613 690 9 the the DT 19613 690 10 " " `` 19613 690 11 Elders Elders NNPS 19613 690 12 " " '' 19613 690 13 was be VBD 19613 690 14 capable capable JJ 19613 690 15 of of IN 19613 690 16 affording afford VBG 19613 690 17 the the DT 19613 690 18 assurance assurance NN 19613 690 19 sought seek VBN 19613 690 20 for for IN 19613 690 21 . . . 19613 691 1 Hence hence RB 19613 691 2 even even RB 19613 691 3 in in IN 19613 691 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 691 5 the the DT 19613 691 6 historical historical JJ 19613 691 7 view view NN 19613 691 8 of of IN 19613 691 9 the the DT 19613 691 10 case case NN 19613 691 11 had have VBD 19613 691 12 clearly clearly RB 19613 691 13 changed change VBN 19613 691 14 into into IN 19613 691 15 a a DT 19613 691 16 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 691 17 one one NN 19613 691 18 . . . 19613 692 1 This this DT 19613 692 2 , , , 19613 692 3 however however RB 19613 692 4 , , , 19613 692 5 by by IN 19613 692 6 no no DT 19613 692 7 means means NN 19613 692 8 resulted result VBD 19613 692 9 merely merely RB 19613 692 10 from from IN 19613 692 11 the the DT 19613 692 12 controversy controversy NN 19613 692 13 with with IN 19613 692 14 the the DT 19613 692 15 heretics heretic NNS 19613 692 16 , , , 19613 692 17 but but CC 19613 692 18 was be VBD 19613 692 19 quite quite RB 19613 692 20 as as RB 19613 692 21 much much RB 19613 692 22 produced produce VBN 19613 692 23 by by IN 19613 692 24 the the DT 19613 692 25 altered altered JJ 19613 692 26 constitution constitution NN 19613 692 27 of of IN 19613 692 28 the the DT 19613 692 29 Church Church NNP 19613 692 30 and and CC 19613 692 31 the the DT 19613 692 32 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 692 33 position position NN 19613 692 34 that that IN 19613 692 35 the the DT 19613 692 36 bishops bishop NNS 19613 692 37 had have VBD 19613 692 38 actually actually RB 19613 692 39 attained attain VBN 19613 692 40 . . . 19613 693 1 The the DT 19613 693 2 idea idea NN 19613 693 3 was be VBD 19613 693 4 that that IN 19613 693 5 the the DT 19613 693 6 Elders Elders NNPS 19613 693 7 , , , 19613 693 8 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 693 9 , , , 19613 693 10 the the DT 19613 693 11 bishops bishop NNS 19613 693 12 , , , 19613 693 13 had have VBD 19613 693 14 received receive VBN 19613 693 15 " " `` 19613 693 16 cum cum NNP 19613 693 17 episcopatus episcopatus NNP 19613 693 18 successione successione VBD 19613 693 19 certum certum NNP 19613 693 20 veritatis veritatis NNP 19613 693 21 charisma charisma NNP 19613 693 22 , , , 19613 693 23 " " '' 19613 693 24 that that RB 19613 693 25 is is RB 19613 693 26 , , , 19613 693 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 693 28 office office NN 19613 693 29 conferred confer VBD 19613 693 30 on on IN 19613 693 31 them -PRON- PRP 19613 693 32 the the DT 19613 693 33 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 693 34 heritage heritage NN 19613 693 35 of of IN 19613 693 36 truth truth NN 19613 693 37 , , , 19613 693 38 which which WDT 19613 693 39 was be VBD 19613 693 40 therefore therefore RB 19613 693 41 objectively objectively RB 19613 693 42 attached attach VBN 19613 693 43 to to IN 19613 693 44 this this DT 19613 693 45 dignity dignity NN 19613 693 46 as as IN 19613 693 47 a a DT 19613 693 48 _ _ NNP 19613 693 49 charism charism NN 19613 693 50 _ _ NNP 19613 693 51 . . . 19613 694 1 This this DT 19613 694 2 notion notion NN 19613 694 3 of of IN 19613 694 4 the the DT 19613 694 5 transmissibility transmissibility NN 19613 694 6 of of IN 19613 694 7 the the DT 19613 694 8 charism charism NN 19613 694 9 of of IN 19613 694 10 truth truth NN 19613 694 11 became become VBD 19613 694 12 associated associate VBN 19613 694 13 with with IN 19613 694 14 the the DT 19613 694 15 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 694 16 office office NN 19613 694 17 after after IN 19613 694 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 694 19 had have VBD 19613 694 20 become become VBN 19613 694 21 a a DT 19613 694 22 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 694 23 one one NN 19613 694 24 , , , 19613 694 25 exercising exercise VBG 19613 694 26 authority authority NN 19613 694 27 over over IN 19613 694 28 the the DT 19613 694 29 Church Church NNP 19613 694 30 in in IN 19613 694 31 all all DT 19613 694 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 694 33 relations;[135 relations;[135 NNS 19613 694 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 694 35 and and CC 19613 694 36 after after IN 19613 694 37 the the DT 19613 694 38 bishops bishop NNS 19613 694 39 had have VBD 19613 694 40 proved prove VBN 19613 694 41 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 694 42 the the DT 19613 694 43 strongest strong JJS 19613 694 44 supports support NNS 19613 694 45 of of IN 19613 694 46 the the DT 19613 694 47 communities community NNS 19613 694 48 against against IN 19613 694 49 the the DT 19613 694 50 attacks attack NNS 19613 694 51 of of IN 19613 694 52 the the DT 19613 694 53 secular secular JJ 19613 694 54 power power NN 19613 694 55 and and CC 19613 694 56 of of IN 19613 694 57 heresy heresy NN 19613 694 58 . . . 19613 695 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 695 2 136 136 CD 19613 695 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 695 4 In in IN 19613 695 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 695 6 and and CC 19613 695 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 695 8 , , , 19613 695 9 however however RB 19613 695 10 , , , 19613 695 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 695 12 only only RB 19613 695 13 find find VBP 19613 695 14 the the DT 19613 695 15 first first JJ 19613 695 16 traces trace NNS 19613 695 17 of of IN 19613 695 18 this this DT 19613 695 19 new new JJ 19613 695 20 theory theory NN 19613 695 21 . . . 19613 696 1 The the DT 19613 696 2 old old JJ 19613 696 3 notion notion NN 19613 696 4 , , , 19613 696 5 which which WDT 19613 696 6 regarded regard VBD 19613 696 7 the the DT 19613 696 8 _ _ NNP 19613 696 9 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 696 10 _ _ NNP 19613 696 11 as as IN 19613 696 12 possessing possess VBG 19613 696 13 the the DT 19613 696 14 heritage heritage NN 19613 696 15 of of IN 19613 696 16 the the DT 19613 696 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 696 18 in in RB 19613 696 19 so so RB 19613 696 20 far far RB 19613 696 21 as as IN 19613 696 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 696 23 possess possess VBP 19613 696 24 the the DT 19613 696 25 Holy Holy NNP 19613 696 26 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 696 27 , , , 19613 696 28 continued continue VBD 19613 696 29 to to TO 19613 696 30 exercise exercise VB 19613 696 31 a a DT 19613 696 32 powerful powerful JJ 19613 696 33 influence influence NN 19613 696 34 on on IN 19613 696 35 these these DT 19613 696 36 writers writer NNS 19613 696 37 , , , 19613 696 38 who who WP 19613 696 39 still still RB 19613 696 40 united unite VBD 19613 696 41 the the DT 19613 696 42 new new JJ 19613 696 43 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 696 44 view view NN 19613 696 45 with with IN 19613 696 46 a a DT 19613 696 47 historical historical JJ 19613 696 48 one one NN 19613 696 49 , , , 19613 696 50 at at IN 19613 696 51 least least JJS 19613 696 52 in in IN 19613 696 53 controversies controversy NNS 19613 696 54 with with IN 19613 696 55 the the DT 19613 696 56 heretics heretic NNS 19613 696 57 . . . 19613 697 1 Neither neither CC 19613 697 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 697 3 , , , 19613 697 4 nor nor CC 19613 697 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 697 6 in in IN 19613 697 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 697 8 earlier early JJR 19613 697 9 writings,[137 writings,[137 NNP 19613 697 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 697 11 asserted assert VBD 19613 697 12 that that IN 19613 697 13 the the DT 19613 697 14 transmission transmission NN 19613 697 15 of of IN 19613 697 16 the the DT 19613 697 17 _ _ NNP 19613 697 18 charisma charisma NN 19613 697 19 veritatis veritatis NN 19613 697 20 _ _ NNP 19613 697 21 to to IN 19613 697 22 the the DT 19613 697 23 bishops bishop NNS 19613 697 24 had have VBD 19613 697 25 really really RB 19613 697 26 invested invest VBN 19613 697 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 697 28 with with IN 19613 697 29 the the DT 19613 697 30 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 697 31 office office NN 19613 697 32 in in IN 19613 697 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 697 34 full full JJ 19613 697 35 sense sense NN 19613 697 36 . . . 19613 698 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 698 2 had have VBD 19613 698 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 698 4 , , , 19613 698 5 according accord VBG 19613 698 6 to to IN 19613 698 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 698 8 , , , 19613 698 9 received receive VBD 19613 698 10 the the DT 19613 698 11 " " `` 19613 698 12 locum locum JJ 19613 698 13 magisterii magisterii NNP 19613 698 14 apostolorum apostolorum NN 19613 698 15 " " '' 19613 698 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 698 17 " " `` 19613 698 18 place place NN 19613 698 19 of of IN 19613 698 20 government government NN 19613 698 21 of of IN 19613 698 22 the the DT 19613 698 23 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 698 24 " " '' 19613 698 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 698 26 , , , 19613 698 27 but but CC 19613 698 28 nothing nothing NN 19613 698 29 more more JJR 19613 698 30 . . . 19613 699 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 699 2 is be VBZ 19613 699 3 only only RB 19613 699 4 the the DT 19613 699 5 later later JJ 19613 699 6 writings writing NNS 19613 699 7 of of IN 19613 699 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 699 9 , , , 19613 699 10 dating date VBG 19613 699 11 from from IN 19613 699 12 the the DT 19613 699 13 reigns reign NNS 19613 699 14 of of IN 19613 699 15 Caracalla Caracalla NNP 19613 699 16 and and CC 19613 699 17 Heliogabalus Heliogabalus NNP 19613 699 18 , , , 19613 699 19 which which WDT 19613 699 20 show show VBP 19613 699 21 that that IN 19613 699 22 the the DT 19613 699 23 bishop bishop NN 19613 699 24 of of IN 19613 699 25 Rome Rome NNP 19613 699 26 , , , 19613 699 27 who who WP 19613 699 28 must must MD 19613 699 29 have have VB 19613 699 30 had have VBN 19613 699 31 imitators imitator NNS 19613 699 32 in in IN 19613 699 33 this this DT 19613 699 34 respect respect NN 19613 699 35 , , , 19613 699 36 claimed claim VBD 19613 699 37 for for IN 19613 699 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 699 39 office office NN 19613 699 40 the the DT 19613 699 41 full full JJ 19613 699 42 authority authority NN 19613 699 43 of of IN 19613 699 44 the the DT 19613 699 45 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 699 46 office office NN 19613 699 47 . . . 19613 700 1 Both both DT 19613 700 2 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 700 3 and and CC 19613 700 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 700 5 rival rival JJ 19613 700 6 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 700 7 described describe VBD 19613 700 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 700 9 as as IN 19613 700 10 successors successor NNS 19613 700 11 of of IN 19613 700 12 the the DT 19613 700 13 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 700 14 in in IN 19613 700 15 the the DT 19613 700 16 full full JJ 19613 700 17 sense sense NN 19613 700 18 of of IN 19613 700 19 the the DT 19613 700 20 word word NN 19613 700 21 , , , 19613 700 22 and and CC 19613 700 23 claimed claim VBD 19613 700 24 for for IN 19613 700 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 700 26 in in IN 19613 700 27 that that DT 19613 700 28 capacity capacity NN 19613 700 29 much much RB 19613 700 30 more more JJR 19613 700 31 than than IN 19613 700 32 a a DT 19613 700 33 mere mere JJ 19613 700 34 guaranteeing guaranteeing NN 19613 700 35 of of IN 19613 700 36 the the DT 19613 700 37 purity purity NN 19613 700 38 of of IN 19613 700 39 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 700 40 . . . 19613 701 1 Even even RB 19613 701 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 701 3 did do VBD 19613 701 4 not not RB 19613 701 5 question question VB 19613 701 6 this this DT 19613 701 7 last last JJ 19613 701 8 mentioned mention VBN 19613 701 9 attribute attribute NN 19613 701 10 of of IN 19613 701 11 the the DT 19613 701 12 bishops bishop NNS 19613 701 13 . . . 19613 702 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 702 2 138 138 CD 19613 702 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 702 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 702 5 found find VBD 19613 702 6 the the DT 19613 702 7 theory theory NN 19613 702 8 already already RB 19613 702 9 in in IN 19613 702 10 existence existence NN 19613 702 11 , , , 19613 702 12 but but CC 19613 702 13 was be VBD 19613 702 14 the the DT 19613 702 15 first first JJ 19613 702 16 to to TO 19613 702 17 develop develop VB 19613 702 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 702 19 definitely definitely RB 19613 702 20 and and CC 19613 702 21 to to TO 19613 702 22 eradicate eradicate VB 19613 702 23 every every DT 19613 702 24 remnant remnant NN 19613 702 25 of of IN 19613 702 26 the the DT 19613 702 27 historical historical JJ 19613 702 28 argument argument NN 19613 702 29 in in IN 19613 702 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 702 31 favour favour NN 19613 702 32 . . . 19613 703 1 The the DT 19613 703 2 conception conception NN 19613 703 3 of of IN 19613 703 4 the the DT 19613 703 5 Church Church NNP 19613 703 6 was be VBD 19613 703 7 thereby thereby RB 19613 703 8 subjected subject VBN 19613 703 9 to to IN 19613 703 10 a a DT 19613 703 11 further further JJ 19613 703 12 transformation transformation NN 19613 703 13 . . . 19613 704 1 2 2 LS 19613 704 2 . . . 19613 705 1 The the DT 19613 705 2 transformation transformation NN 19613 705 3 of of IN 19613 705 4 the the DT 19613 705 5 idea idea NN 19613 705 6 of of IN 19613 705 7 the the DT 19613 705 8 Church Church NNP 19613 705 9 by by IN 19613 705 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 705 11 completed complete VBD 19613 705 12 the the DT 19613 705 13 radical radical JJ 19613 705 14 changes change NNS 19613 705 15 that that WDT 19613 705 16 had have VBD 19613 705 17 been be VBN 19613 705 18 gradually gradually RB 19613 705 19 taking take VBG 19613 705 20 place place NN 19613 705 21 from from IN 19613 705 22 the the DT 19613 705 23 last last JJ 19613 705 24 half half NN 19613 705 25 of of IN 19613 705 26 the the DT 19613 705 27 second second JJ 19613 705 28 century century NN 19613 705 29 . . . 19613 706 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 706 2 139 139 CD 19613 706 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 706 4 In in IN 19613 706 5 order order NN 19613 706 6 to to TO 19613 706 7 understand understand VB 19613 706 8 them -PRON- PRP 19613 706 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 706 10 is be VBZ 19613 706 11 necessary necessary JJ 19613 706 12 to to TO 19613 706 13 go go VB 19613 706 14 back back RB 19613 706 15 . . . 19613 707 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 707 2 was be VBD 19613 707 3 only only RB 19613 707 4 with with IN 19613 707 5 slowness slowness NN 19613 707 6 and and CC 19613 707 7 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 707 8 that that WDT 19613 707 9 the the DT 19613 707 10 theories theory NNS 19613 707 11 of of IN 19613 707 12 the the DT 19613 707 13 Church Church NNP 19613 707 14 followed follow VBD 19613 707 15 the the DT 19613 707 16 actual actual JJ 19613 707 17 changes change NNS 19613 707 18 in in IN 19613 707 19 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 707 20 history history NN 19613 707 21 . . . 19613 708 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 708 2 may may MD 19613 708 3 be be VB 19613 708 4 said say VBN 19613 708 5 that that IN 19613 708 6 the the DT 19613 708 7 idea idea NN 19613 708 8 of of IN 19613 708 9 the the DT 19613 708 10 Church Church NNP 19613 708 11 always always RB 19613 708 12 remained remain VBD 19613 708 13 a a DT 19613 708 14 stage stage NN 19613 708 15 behind behind IN 19613 708 16 the the DT 19613 708 17 condition condition NN 19613 708 18 reached reach VBN 19613 708 19 in in IN 19613 708 20 practice practice NN 19613 708 21 . . . 19613 709 1 That that DT 19613 709 2 may may MD 19613 709 3 be be VB 19613 709 4 seen see VBN 19613 709 5 in in IN 19613 709 6 the the DT 19613 709 7 whole whole JJ 19613 709 8 course course NN 19613 709 9 of of IN 19613 709 10 the the DT 19613 709 11 history history NN 19613 709 12 of of IN 19613 709 13 dogma dogma NN 19613 709 14 up up IN 19613 709 15 to to IN 19613 709 16 the the DT 19613 709 17 present present JJ 19613 709 18 day day NN 19613 709 19 . . . 19613 710 1 The the DT 19613 710 2 essential essential JJ 19613 710 3 character character NN 19613 710 4 of of IN 19613 710 5 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 710 6 in in IN 19613 710 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 710 8 first first JJ 19613 710 9 period period NN 19613 710 10 was be VBD 19613 710 11 a a DT 19613 710 12 new new JJ 19613 710 13 holy holy JJ 19613 710 14 life life NN 19613 710 15 and and CC 19613 710 16 a a DT 19613 710 17 sure sure JJ 19613 710 18 hope hope NN 19613 710 19 , , , 19613 710 20 both both DT 19613 710 21 based base VBN 19613 710 22 on on IN 19613 710 23 repentance repentance NN 19613 710 24 towards towards IN 19613 710 25 God God NNP 19613 710 26 and and CC 19613 710 27 faith faith NN 19613 710 28 in in IN 19613 710 29 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 710 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 710 31 and and CC 19613 710 32 brought bring VBD 19613 710 33 about about RP 19613 710 34 by by IN 19613 710 35 the the DT 19613 710 36 Holy Holy NNP 19613 710 37 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 710 38 . . . 19613 711 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 711 2 and and CC 19613 711 3 the the DT 19613 711 4 Church Church NNP 19613 711 5 , , , 19613 711 6 that that RB 19613 711 7 is is RB 19613 711 8 , , , 19613 711 9 the the DT 19613 711 10 Holy Holy NNP 19613 711 11 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 711 12 and and CC 19613 711 13 the the DT 19613 711 14 holy holy NNP 19613 711 15 Church Church NNP 19613 711 16 , , , 19613 711 17 were be VBD 19613 711 18 inseparably inseparably RB 19613 711 19 connected connect VBN 19613 711 20 . . . 19613 712 1 The the DT 19613 712 2 Church Church NNP 19613 712 3 , , , 19613 712 4 or or CC 19613 712 5 , , , 19613 712 6 in in IN 19613 712 7 other other JJ 19613 712 8 words word NNS 19613 712 9 , , , 19613 712 10 the the DT 19613 712 11 community community NN 19613 712 12 of of IN 19613 712 13 all all DT 19613 712 14 believers believer NNS 19613 712 15 , , , 19613 712 16 attains attain VBZ 19613 712 17 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 712 18 unity unity NN 19613 712 19 through through IN 19613 712 20 the the DT 19613 712 21 Holy Holy NNP 19613 712 22 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 712 23 . . . 19613 713 1 This this DT 19613 713 2 unity unity NN 19613 713 3 manifested manifest VBD 19613 713 4 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 713 5 in in IN 19613 713 6 brotherly brotherly JJ 19613 713 7 love love NN 19613 713 8 and and CC 19613 713 9 in in IN 19613 713 10 the the DT 19613 713 11 common common JJ 19613 713 12 relation relation NN 19613 713 13 to to IN 19613 713 14 a a DT 19613 713 15 common common JJ 19613 713 16 ideal ideal NN 19613 713 17 and and CC 19613 713 18 a a DT 19613 713 19 common common JJ 19613 713 20 hope hope NN 19613 713 21 . . . 19613 714 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 714 2 140 140 CD 19613 714 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 714 4 The the DT 19613 714 5 assembly assembly NN 19613 714 6 of of IN 19613 714 7 all all DT 19613 714 8 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 714 9 is be VBZ 19613 714 10 realised realise VBN 19613 714 11 in in IN 19613 714 12 the the DT 19613 714 13 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 714 14 of of IN 19613 714 15 God God NNP 19613 714 16 , , , 19613 714 17 viz viz NNP 19613 714 18 . . NNP 19613 714 19 , , , 19613 714 20 in in IN 19613 714 21 heaven heaven NNP 19613 714 22 ; ; : 19613 714 23 on on IN 19613 714 24 earth earth NN 19613 714 25 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 714 26 and and CC 19613 714 27 the the DT 19613 714 28 Church Church NNP 19613 714 29 are be VBP 19613 714 30 dispersed disperse VBN 19613 714 31 and and CC 19613 714 32 in in IN 19613 714 33 a a DT 19613 714 34 foreign foreign JJ 19613 714 35 land land NN 19613 714 36 . . . 19613 715 1 Hence hence RB 19613 715 2 , , , 19613 715 3 properly properly RB 19613 715 4 speaking speak VBG 19613 715 5 , , , 19613 715 6 the the DT 19613 715 7 Church Church NNP 19613 715 8 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 715 9 is be VBZ 19613 715 10 a a DT 19613 715 11 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 715 12 community community NN 19613 715 13 inseparable inseparable NN 19613 715 14 from from IN 19613 715 15 the the DT 19613 715 16 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 715 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 715 18 . . . 19613 716 1 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 716 2 believe believe VBP 19613 716 3 that that IN 19613 716 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 716 5 belong belong VBP 19613 716 6 to to IN 19613 716 7 a a DT 19613 716 8 real real RB 19613 716 9 super super RB 19613 716 10 - - JJ 19613 716 11 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 19613 716 12 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 716 13 , , , 19613 716 14 which which WDT 19613 716 15 , , , 19613 716 16 from from IN 19613 716 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 716 18 very very JJ 19613 716 19 nature nature NN 19613 716 20 , , , 19613 716 21 can can MD 19613 716 22 not not RB 19613 716 23 be be VB 19613 716 24 realised realise VBN 19613 716 25 on on IN 19613 716 26 earth earth NN 19613 716 27 . . . 19613 717 1 The the DT 19613 717 2 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 717 3 goal goal NN 19613 717 4 is be VBZ 19613 717 5 not not RB 19613 717 6 yet yet RB 19613 717 7 separated separate VBN 19613 717 8 from from IN 19613 717 9 the the DT 19613 717 10 idea idea NN 19613 717 11 of of IN 19613 717 12 the the DT 19613 717 13 Church Church NNP 19613 717 14 ; ; : 19613 717 15 there there EX 19613 717 16 is be VBZ 19613 717 17 a a DT 19613 717 18 holy holy JJ 19613 717 19 Church Church NNP 19613 717 20 on on IN 19613 717 21 earth earth NN 19613 717 22 in in IN 19613 717 23 so so RB 19613 717 24 far far RB 19613 717 25 as as IN 19613 717 26 heaven heaven NNP 19613 717 27 is be VBZ 19613 717 28 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 717 29 destination destination NN 19613 717 30 . . . 19613 718 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 718 2 141 141 CD 19613 718 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 718 4 Every every DT 19613 718 5 individual individual JJ 19613 718 6 congregation congregation NN 19613 718 7 is be VBZ 19613 718 8 to to TO 19613 718 9 be be VB 19613 718 10 an an DT 19613 718 11 image image NN 19613 718 12 of of IN 19613 718 13 the the DT 19613 718 14 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 718 15 Church Church NNP 19613 718 16 . . . 19613 719 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 719 2 142 142 CD 19613 719 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 719 4 Reflections reflection NNS 19613 719 5 were be VBD 19613 719 6 no no DT 19613 719 7 doubt doubt RB 19613 719 8 made make VBN 19613 719 9 on on IN 19613 719 10 the the DT 19613 719 11 contrast contrast NN 19613 719 12 between between IN 19613 719 13 the the DT 19613 719 14 empirical empirical JJ 19613 719 15 community community NN 19613 719 16 and and CC 19613 719 17 the the DT 19613 719 18 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 719 19 Church Church NNP 19613 719 20 whose whose WP$ 19613 719 21 earthly earthly JJ 19613 719 22 likeness likeness NN 19613 719 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 719 24 was be VBD 19613 719 25 to to TO 19613 719 26 be be VB 19613 719 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 719 28 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 719 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 719 30 ; ; : 19613 719 31 but but CC 19613 719 32 these these DT 19613 719 33 did do VBD 19613 719 34 not not RB 19613 719 35 affect affect VB 19613 719 36 the the DT 19613 719 37 theory theory NN 19613 719 38 of of IN 19613 719 39 the the DT 19613 719 40 subject subject NN 19613 719 41 . . . 19613 720 1 Only only RB 19613 720 2 the the DT 19613 720 3 saints saint NNS 19613 720 4 of of IN 19613 720 5 God God NNP 19613 720 6 , , , 19613 720 7 whose whose WP$ 19613 720 8 salvation salvation NN 19613 720 9 is be VBZ 19613 720 10 certain certain JJ 19613 720 11 , , , 19613 720 12 belong belong VB 19613 720 13 to to IN 19613 720 14 her -PRON- PRP 19613 720 15 , , , 19613 720 16 for for IN 19613 720 17 the the DT 19613 720 18 essential essential JJ 19613 720 19 thing thing NN 19613 720 20 is be VBZ 19613 720 21 not not RB 19613 720 22 to to TO 19613 720 23 be be VB 19613 720 24 called call VBN 19613 720 25 , , , 19613 720 26 but but CC 19613 720 27 to to TO 19613 720 28 be be VB 19613 720 29 , , , 19613 720 30 a a DT 19613 720 31 Christian Christian NNP 19613 720 32 . . . 19613 721 1 There there EX 19613 721 2 was be VBD 19613 721 3 as as RB 19613 721 4 yet yet RB 19613 721 5 no no DT 19613 721 6 empirical empirical JJ 19613 721 7 universal universal JJ 19613 721 8 Church Church NNP 19613 721 9 possessing possess VBG 19613 721 10 an an DT 19613 721 11 outward outward JJ 19613 721 12 legal legal JJ 19613 721 13 title title NN 19613 721 14 that that WDT 19613 721 15 could could MD 19613 721 16 , , , 19613 721 17 so so RB 19613 721 18 to to TO 19613 721 19 speak speak VB 19613 721 20 , , , 19613 721 21 be be VB 19613 721 22 detached detach VBN 19613 721 23 from from IN 19613 721 24 the the DT 19613 721 25 personal personal JJ 19613 721 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 721 27 of of IN 19613 721 28 the the DT 19613 721 29 individual individual JJ 19613 721 30 Christian Christian NNP 19613 721 31 . . . 19613 722 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 722 2 143 143 CD 19613 722 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 722 4 All all PDT 19613 722 5 the the DT 19613 722 6 lofty lofty JJ 19613 722 7 designations designation NNS 19613 722 8 which which WDT 19613 722 9 Paul Paul NNP 19613 722 10 , , , 19613 722 11 the the DT 19613 722 12 so so RB 19613 722 13 - - HYPH 19613 722 14 called call VBN 19613 722 15 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 722 16 Fathers Fathers NNP 19613 722 17 , , , 19613 722 18 and and CC 19613 722 19 Justin Justin NNP 19613 722 20 gathered gather VBD 19613 722 21 from from IN 19613 722 22 the the DT 19613 722 23 Old Old NNP 19613 722 24 Testament Testament NNP 19613 722 25 and and CC 19613 722 26 applied apply VBD 19613 722 27 to to IN 19613 722 28 the the DT 19613 722 29 Church Church NNP 19613 722 30 , , , 19613 722 31 relate relate VB 19613 722 32 to to IN 19613 722 33 the the DT 19613 722 34 holy holy JJ 19613 722 35 community community NN 19613 722 36 which which WDT 19613 722 37 originates originate VBZ 19613 722 38 in in IN 19613 722 39 heaven heaven NN 19613 722 40 and and CC 19613 722 41 returns return VBZ 19613 722 42 thither thither RB 19613 722 43 . . . 19613 723 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 723 2 144 144 CD 19613 723 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 723 4 But but CC 19613 723 5 , , , 19613 723 6 in in IN 19613 723 7 consequence consequence NN 19613 723 8 of of IN 19613 723 9 the the DT 19613 723 10 naturalising naturalising NN 19613 723 11 of of IN 19613 723 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 723 13 in in IN 19613 723 14 the the DT 19613 723 15 world world NN 19613 723 16 and and CC 19613 723 17 the the DT 19613 723 18 repelling repelling NN 19613 723 19 of of IN 19613 723 20 heresy heresy NN 19613 723 21 , , , 19613 723 22 a a DT 19613 723 23 formulated formulate VBN 19613 723 24 creed creed NN 19613 723 25 was be VBD 19613 723 26 made make VBN 19613 723 27 the the DT 19613 723 28 basis basis NN 19613 723 29 of of IN 19613 723 30 the the DT 19613 723 31 Church Church NNP 19613 723 32 . . . 19613 724 1 This this DT 19613 724 2 confession confession NN 19613 724 3 was be VBD 19613 724 4 also also RB 19613 724 5 recognised recognise VBN 19613 724 6 as as IN 19613 724 7 a a DT 19613 724 8 foundation foundation NN 19613 724 9 of of IN 19613 724 10 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 724 11 unity unity NN 19613 724 12 and and CC 19613 724 13 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 724 14 of of IN 19613 724 15 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 724 16 truth truth NN 19613 724 17 , , , 19613 724 18 and and CC 19613 724 19 in in IN 19613 724 20 certain certain JJ 19613 724 21 respects respect NNS 19613 724 22 as as IN 19613 724 23 the the DT 19613 724 24 main main JJ 19613 724 25 one one NN 19613 724 26 . . . 19613 725 1 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 725 2 protected protect VBD 19613 725 3 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 725 4 by by IN 19613 725 5 this this DT 19613 725 6 conception conception NN 19613 725 7 , , , 19613 725 8 though though IN 19613 725 9 no no DT 19613 725 10 doubt doubt NN 19613 725 11 at at IN 19613 725 12 a a DT 19613 725 13 heavy heavy JJ 19613 725 14 price price NN 19613 725 15 . . . 19613 726 1 To to IN 19613 726 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 726 3 and and CC 19613 726 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 726 5 the the DT 19613 726 6 Church Church NNP 19613 726 7 rests rest NNS 19613 726 8 entirely entirely RB 19613 726 9 on on IN 19613 726 10 the the DT 19613 726 11 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 726 12 , , , 19613 726 13 traditional traditional JJ 19613 726 14 faith faith NN 19613 726 15 which which WDT 19613 726 16 legitimises legitimise VBZ 19613 726 17 her -PRON- PRP 19613 726 18 . . . 19613 727 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 727 2 145 145 CD 19613 727 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 727 4 But but CC 19613 727 5 this this DT 19613 727 6 faith faith NN 19613 727 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 727 8 appeared appear VBD 19613 727 9 as as IN 19613 727 10 a a DT 19613 727 11 _ _ NNP 19613 727 12 law law NN 19613 727 13 _ _ NNP 19613 727 14 and and CC 19613 727 15 aggregate aggregate NN 19613 727 16 of of IN 19613 727 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 727 18 , , , 19613 727 19 all all DT 19613 727 20 of of IN 19613 727 21 which which WDT 19613 727 22 are be VBP 19613 727 23 of of IN 19613 727 24 equally equally RB 19613 727 25 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 727 26 importance importance NN 19613 727 27 , , , 19613 727 28 so so IN 19613 727 29 that that IN 19613 727 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 727 31 practical practical JJ 19613 727 32 aim aim NN 19613 727 33 became become VBD 19613 727 34 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 727 35 and and CC 19613 727 36 threatened threaten VBD 19613 727 37 to to TO 19613 727 38 vanish vanish VB 19613 727 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 727 40 " " `` 19613 727 41 fides fide NNS 19613 727 42 in in IN 19613 727 43 regula regula NNP 19613 727 44 posita posita NNP 19613 727 45 est est NNP 19613 727 46 , , , 19613 727 47 habet habet NNP 19613 727 48 legem legem NNP 19613 727 49 et et NNP 19613 727 50 salutem salutem NNP 19613 727 51 de de NNP 19613 727 52 observatione observatione NNP 19613 727 53 legis legis NNP 19613 727 54 " " '' 19613 727 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 727 56 . . . 19613 728 1 The the DT 19613 728 2 Church Church NNP 19613 728 3 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 728 4 , , , 19613 728 5 however however RB 19613 728 6 , , , 19613 728 7 became become VBD 19613 728 8 a a DT 19613 728 9 union union NN 19613 728 10 based base VBN 19613 728 11 on on IN 19613 728 12 the the DT 19613 728 13 true true JJ 19613 728 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 728 15 and and CC 19613 728 16 visible visible JJ 19613 728 17 in in IN 19613 728 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 728 19 ; ; : 19613 728 20 and and CC 19613 728 21 this this DT 19613 728 22 confederation confederation NN 19613 728 23 was be VBD 19613 728 24 at at IN 19613 728 25 the the DT 19613 728 26 same same JJ 19613 728 27 time time NN 19613 728 28 enabled enable VBD 19613 728 29 to to TO 19613 728 30 realise realise VB 19613 728 31 an an DT 19613 728 32 actual actual JJ 19613 728 33 outward outward JJ 19613 728 34 unity unity NN 19613 728 35 by by IN 19613 728 36 means mean NNS 19613 728 37 of of IN 19613 728 38 the the DT 19613 728 39 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 728 40 inheritance inheritance NN 19613 728 41 , , , 19613 728 42 the the DT 19613 728 43 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 728 44 confession confession NN 19613 728 45 , , , 19613 728 46 and and CC 19613 728 47 the the DT 19613 728 48 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 728 49 writings writing NNS 19613 728 50 . . . 19613 729 1 The the DT 19613 729 2 narrower narrow JJR 19613 729 3 and and CC 19613 729 4 more more RBR 19613 729 5 external external JJ 19613 729 6 character character NN 19613 729 7 assumed assume VBN 19613 729 8 by by IN 19613 729 9 the the DT 19613 729 10 idea idea NN 19613 729 11 of of IN 19613 729 12 the the DT 19613 729 13 Church Church NNP 19613 729 14 was be VBD 19613 729 15 concealed conceal VBN 19613 729 16 by by IN 19613 729 17 the the DT 19613 729 18 fact fact NN 19613 729 19 that that IN 19613 729 20 , , , 19613 729 21 since since IN 19613 729 22 the the DT 19613 729 23 latter latter JJ 19613 729 24 half half NN 19613 729 25 of of IN 19613 729 26 the the DT 19613 729 27 second second JJ 19613 729 28 century century NN 19613 729 29 , , , 19613 729 30 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 729 31 in in IN 19613 729 32 all all DT 19613 729 33 parts part NNS 19613 729 34 of of IN 19613 729 35 the the DT 19613 729 36 world world NN 19613 729 37 had have VBD 19613 729 38 really really RB 19613 729 39 united unite VBN 19613 729 40 in in IN 19613 729 41 opposition opposition NN 19613 729 42 to to IN 19613 729 43 the the DT 19613 729 44 state state NN 19613 729 45 and and CC 19613 729 46 " " `` 19613 729 47 heresy heresy VB 19613 729 48 , , , 19613 729 49 " " '' 19613 729 50 and and CC 19613 729 51 had have VBD 19613 729 52 found find VBN 19613 729 53 compensation compensation NN 19613 729 54 for for IN 19613 729 55 the the DT 19613 729 56 incipient incipient JJ 19613 729 57 decline decline NN 19613 729 58 of of IN 19613 729 59 the the DT 19613 729 60 original original JJ 19613 729 61 lofty lofty JJ 19613 729 62 thoughts thought NNS 19613 729 63 and and CC 19613 729 64 practical practical JJ 19613 729 65 obligations obligation NNS 19613 729 66 in in IN 19613 729 67 the the DT 19613 729 68 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 729 69 of of IN 19613 729 70 forming form VBG 19613 729 71 an an DT 19613 729 72 ecumenical ecumenical JJ 19613 729 73 and and CC 19613 729 74 international international JJ 19613 729 75 alliance alliance NN 19613 729 76 . . . 19613 730 1 The the DT 19613 730 2 designation designation NN 19613 730 3 " " `` 19613 730 4 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 730 5 Church Church NNP 19613 730 6 " " '' 19613 730 7 gave give VBD 19613 730 8 expression expression NN 19613 730 9 to to IN 19613 730 10 the the DT 19613 730 11 claim claim NN 19613 730 12 of of IN 19613 730 13 this this DT 19613 730 14 world world NN 19613 730 15 - - HYPH 19613 730 16 wide wide JJ 19613 730 17 union union NN 19613 730 18 of of IN 19613 730 19 the the DT 19613 730 20 same same JJ 19613 730 21 faith faith NN 19613 730 22 to to TO 19613 730 23 represent represent VB 19613 730 24 the the DT 19613 730 25 true true JJ 19613 730 26 Church Church NNP 19613 730 27 . . . 19613 731 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 731 2 146 146 CD 19613 731 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 731 4 This this DT 19613 731 5 expression expression NN 19613 731 6 corresponds correspond VBZ 19613 731 7 to to IN 19613 731 8 the the DT 19613 731 9 powerful powerful JJ 19613 731 10 position position NN 19613 731 11 which which WDT 19613 731 12 the the DT 19613 731 13 " " `` 19613 731 14 great great JJ 19613 731 15 Church Church NNP 19613 731 16 " " '' 19613 731 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 731 18 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 731 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 731 20 , , , 19613 731 21 or or CC 19613 731 22 the the DT 19613 731 23 " " `` 19613 731 24 old old JJ 19613 731 25 " " '' 19613 731 26 Church Church NNP 19613 731 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 731 28 Clemens Clemens NNP 19613 731 29 Alex Alex NNP 19613 731 30 . . . 19613 731 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 732 1 had have VBD 19613 732 2 attained attain VBN 19613 732 3 by by IN 19613 732 4 the the DT 19613 732 5 end end NN 19613 732 6 of of IN 19613 732 7 the the DT 19613 732 8 second second JJ 19613 732 9 century century NN 19613 732 10 , , , 19613 732 11 as as IN 19613 732 12 compared compare VBN 19613 732 13 with with IN 19613 732 14 the the DT 19613 732 15 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 732 16 Church Church NNP 19613 732 17 , , , 19613 732 18 the the DT 19613 732 19 school school NN 19613 732 20 sects sect VBZ 19613 732 21 , , , 19613 732 22 the the DT 19613 732 23 Christian christian JJ 19613 732 24 associations association NNS 19613 732 25 of of IN 19613 732 26 all all DT 19613 732 27 kinds kind NNS 19613 732 28 , , , 19613 732 29 and and CC 19613 732 30 the the DT 19613 732 31 independent independent JJ 19613 732 32 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 732 33 . . . 19613 733 1 This this DT 19613 733 2 Church Church NNP 19613 733 3 , , , 19613 733 4 however however RB 19613 733 5 , , , 19613 733 6 was be VBD 19613 733 7 declared declare VBN 19613 733 8 to to TO 19613 733 9 be be VB 19613 733 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 733 11 , , , 19613 733 12 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 733 13 , , , 19613 733 14 founded found VBN 19613 733 15 in in IN 19613 733 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 733 17 present present JJ 19613 733 18 form form NN 19613 733 19 by by IN 19613 733 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 733 21 through through IN 19613 733 22 the the DT 19613 733 23 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 733 24 . . . 19613 734 1 Through through IN 19613 734 2 this this DT 19613 734 3 idea idea NN 19613 734 4 , , , 19613 734 5 which which WDT 19613 734 6 was be VBD 19613 734 7 supported support VBN 19613 734 8 by by IN 19613 734 9 the the DT 19613 734 10 old old JJ 19613 734 11 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 734 12 notion notion NN 19613 734 13 that that IN 19613 734 14 the the DT 19613 734 15 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 734 16 had have VBD 19613 734 17 already already RB 19613 734 18 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 734 19 the the DT 19613 734 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 734 21 to to IN 19613 734 22 all all PDT 19613 734 23 the the DT 19613 734 24 world world NN 19613 734 25 , , , 19613 734 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 734 27 came come VBD 19613 734 28 to to TO 19613 734 29 be be VB 19613 734 30 completely completely RB 19613 734 31 forgotten forget VBN 19613 734 32 how how WRB 19613 734 33 Christ Christ NNP 19613 734 34 and and CC 19613 734 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 734 36 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 734 37 had have VBD 19613 734 38 exercised exercise VBN 19613 734 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 734 40 ministry ministry NN 19613 734 41 , , , 19613 734 42 and and CC 19613 734 43 an an DT 19613 734 44 empirical empirical JJ 19613 734 45 conception conception NN 19613 734 46 of of IN 19613 734 47 the the DT 19613 734 48 Church Church NNP 19613 734 49 was be VBD 19613 734 50 created create VBN 19613 734 51 in in IN 19613 734 52 which which WDT 19613 734 53 the the DT 19613 734 54 idea idea NN 19613 734 55 of of IN 19613 734 56 a a DT 19613 734 57 holy holy JJ 19613 734 58 life life NN 19613 734 59 in in IN 19613 734 60 the the DT 19613 734 61 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 734 62 could could MD 19613 734 63 no no RB 19613 734 64 longer longer RB 19613 734 65 be be VB 19613 734 66 the the DT 19613 734 67 ruling rule VBG 19613 734 68 one one CD 19613 734 69 . . . 19613 735 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 735 2 was be VBD 19613 735 3 taught teach VBN 19613 735 4 that that IN 19613 735 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 735 6 received receive VBD 19613 735 7 from from IN 19613 735 8 God God NNP 19613 735 9 a a DT 19613 735 10 law law NN 19613 735 11 of of IN 19613 735 12 faith faith NN 19613 735 13 , , , 19613 735 14 which which WDT 19613 735 15 , , , 19613 735 16 as as IN 19613 735 17 a a DT 19613 735 18 new new JJ 19613 735 19 lawgiver lawgiver NN 19613 735 20 , , , 19613 735 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 735 22 imparted impart VBD 19613 735 23 to to IN 19613 735 24 the the DT 19613 735 25 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 735 26 , , , 19613 735 27 and and CC 19613 735 28 that that IN 19613 735 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 735 30 , , , 19613 735 31 by by IN 19613 735 32 transmitting transmit VBG 19613 735 33 the the DT 19613 735 34 truth truth NN 19613 735 35 of of IN 19613 735 36 which which WDT 19613 735 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 735 38 were be VBD 19613 735 39 the the DT 19613 735 40 depositaries depositary NNS 19613 735 41 , , , 19613 735 42 founded found VBD 19613 735 43 the the DT 19613 735 44 one one CD 19613 735 45 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 735 46 Church Church NNP 19613 735 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 735 48 Iren Iren NNP 19613 735 49 . . . 19613 736 1 III iii CD 19613 736 2 . . . 19613 737 1 4 4 LS 19613 737 2 . . . 19613 738 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 738 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 738 3 . . . 19613 739 1 The the DT 19613 739 2 latter latter JJ 19613 739 3 , , , 19613 739 4 being be VBG 19613 739 5 guardian guardian NN 19613 739 6 of of IN 19613 739 7 the the DT 19613 739 8 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 739 9 heritage heritage NN 19613 739 10 , , , 19613 739 11 has have VBZ 19613 739 12 the the DT 19613 739 13 assurance assurance NN 19613 739 14 of of IN 19613 739 15 possessing possess VBG 19613 739 16 the the DT 19613 739 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 739 18 ; ; : 19613 739 19 whereas whereas IN 19613 739 20 all all DT 19613 739 21 communities community NNS 19613 739 22 other other JJ 19613 739 23 than than IN 19613 739 24 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 739 25 , , , 19613 739 26 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 739 27 as as IN 19613 739 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 739 29 have have VBP 19613 739 30 not not RB 19613 739 31 received receive VBN 19613 739 32 that that DT 19613 739 33 deposit deposit NN 19613 739 34 , , , 19613 739 35 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 739 36 lack lack VBP 19613 739 37 the the DT 19613 739 38 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 739 39 and and CC 19613 739 40 are be VBP 19613 739 41 therefore therefore RB 19613 739 42 separated separate VBN 19613 739 43 from from IN 19613 739 44 Christ Christ NNP 19613 739 45 and and CC 19613 739 46 salvation salvation NN 19613 739 47 . . . 19613 740 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 740 2 147 147 CD 19613 740 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 740 4 Hence hence RB 19613 740 5 one one PRP 19613 740 6 must must MD 19613 740 7 be be VB 19613 740 8 a a DT 19613 740 9 member member NN 19613 740 10 of of IN 19613 740 11 this this DT 19613 740 12 Church Church NNP 19613 740 13 in in IN 19613 740 14 order order NN 19613 740 15 to to TO 19613 740 16 be be VB 19613 740 17 a a DT 19613 740 18 partaker partaker NN 19613 740 19 of of IN 19613 740 20 salvation salvation NN 19613 740 21 , , , 19613 740 22 because because IN 19613 740 23 in in IN 19613 740 24 her -PRON- PRP 19613 740 25 alone alone JJ 19613 740 26 one one NN 19613 740 27 can can MD 19613 740 28 find find VB 19613 740 29 the the DT 19613 740 30 creed creed NN 19613 740 31 which which WDT 19613 740 32 must must MD 19613 740 33 be be VB 19613 740 34 recognised recognise VBN 19613 740 35 as as IN 19613 740 36 the the DT 19613 740 37 condition condition NN 19613 740 38 of of IN 19613 740 39 redemption redemption NN 19613 740 40 . . . 19613 741 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 741 2 148 148 CD 19613 741 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 741 4 Consequently consequently RB 19613 741 5 , , , 19613 741 6 in in IN 19613 741 7 proportion proportion NN 19613 741 8 as as IN 19613 741 9 the the DT 19613 741 10 faith faith NN 19613 741 11 became become VBD 19613 741 12 a a DT 19613 741 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 741 14 of of IN 19613 741 15 faith faith NN 19613 741 16 , , , 19613 741 17 the the DT 19613 741 18 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 741 19 Church Church NNP 19613 741 20 interposed interpose VBD 19613 741 21 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 741 22 as as IN 19613 741 23 an an DT 19613 741 24 empiric empiric NN 19613 741 25 power power NN 19613 741 26 between between IN 19613 741 27 the the DT 19613 741 28 individual individual NN 19613 741 29 and and CC 19613 741 30 salvation salvation NN 19613 741 31 . . . 19613 742 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 742 2 became become VBD 19613 742 3 a a DT 19613 742 4 condition condition NN 19613 742 5 of of IN 19613 742 6 salvation salvation NN 19613 742 7 ; ; : 19613 742 8 but but CC 19613 742 9 the the DT 19613 742 10 result result NN 19613 742 11 was be VBD 19613 742 12 that that IN 19613 742 13 she -PRON- PRP 19613 742 14 ceased cease VBD 19613 742 15 to to TO 19613 742 16 be be VB 19613 742 17 a a DT 19613 742 18 sure sure JJ 19613 742 19 communion communion NN 19613 742 20 of of IN 19613 742 21 the the DT 19613 742 22 saved save VBN 19613 742 23 and and CC 19613 742 24 of of IN 19613 742 25 saints saint NNS 19613 742 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 742 27 see see VB 19613 742 28 on on IN 19613 742 29 this this DT 19613 742 30 point point NN 19613 742 31 the the DT 19613 742 32 following follow VBG 19613 742 33 chapter chapter NN 19613 742 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 742 35 . . . 19613 743 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 743 2 was be VBD 19613 743 3 quite quite PDT 19613 743 4 a a DT 19613 743 5 logical logical JJ 19613 743 6 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 743 7 when when WRB 19613 743 8 about about IN 19613 743 9 the the DT 19613 743 10 year year NN 19613 743 11 220 220 CD 19613 743 12 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 743 13 , , , 19613 743 14 a a DT 19613 743 15 Roman roman JJ 19613 743 16 bishop bishop NN 19613 743 17 , , , 19613 743 18 started start VBD 19613 743 19 the the DT 19613 743 20 theory theory NN 19613 743 21 that that IN 19613 743 22 there there EX 19613 743 23 _ _ NNP 19613 743 24 must must MD 19613 743 25 _ _ NNP 19613 743 26 be be VB 19613 743 27 wheat wheat NN 19613 743 28 and and CC 19613 743 29 tares tare NNS 19613 743 30 in in IN 19613 743 31 the the DT 19613 743 32 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 743 33 Church Church NNP 19613 743 34 and and CC 19613 743 35 that that IN 19613 743 36 the the DT 19613 743 37 Ark Ark NNP 19613 743 38 of of IN 19613 743 39 Noah Noah NNP 19613 743 40 with with IN 19613 743 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 743 42 clean clean JJ 19613 743 43 and and CC 19613 743 44 unclean unclean JJ 19613 743 45 beasts beast NNS 19613 743 46 was be VBD 19613 743 47 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 743 48 type type NN 19613 743 49 . . . 19613 744 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 744 2 149 149 CD 19613 744 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 744 4 The the DT 19613 744 5 departure departure NN 19613 744 6 from from IN 19613 744 7 the the DT 19613 744 8 old old JJ 19613 744 9 idea idea NN 19613 744 10 of of IN 19613 744 11 the the DT 19613 744 12 Church Church NNP 19613 744 13 appears appear VBZ 19613 744 14 completed complete VBN 19613 744 15 in in IN 19613 744 16 this this DT 19613 744 17 statement statement NN 19613 744 18 . . . 19613 745 1 But but CC 19613 745 2 the the DT 19613 745 3 following follow VBG 19613 745 4 facts fact NNS 19613 745 5 must must MD 19613 745 6 not not RB 19613 745 7 be be VB 19613 745 8 overlooked:--First overlooked:--first JJ 19613 745 9 , , , 19613 745 10 the the DT 19613 745 11 new new JJ 19613 745 12 conception conception NN 19613 745 13 of of IN 19613 745 14 the the DT 19613 745 15 Church Church NNP 19613 745 16 was be VBD 19613 745 17 not not RB 19613 745 18 yet yet RB 19613 745 19 a a DT 19613 745 20 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 745 21 one one NN 19613 745 22 . . . 19613 746 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 746 2 , , , 19613 746 3 the the DT 19613 746 4 idea idea NN 19613 746 5 of of IN 19613 746 6 the the DT 19613 746 7 union union NN 19613 746 8 and and CC 19613 746 9 unity unity NN 19613 746 10 of of IN 19613 746 11 all all DT 19613 746 12 believers believer NNS 19613 746 13 found find VBN 19613 746 14 here here RB 19613 746 15 magnificent magnificent JJ 19613 746 16 expression expression NN 19613 746 17 . . . 19613 747 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 747 2 , , , 19613 747 3 the the DT 19613 747 4 development development NN 19613 747 5 of of IN 19613 747 6 the the DT 19613 747 7 communities community NNS 19613 747 8 into into IN 19613 747 9 one one CD 19613 747 10 solid solid JJ 19613 747 11 Church Church NNP 19613 747 12 also also RB 19613 747 13 represents represent VBZ 19613 747 14 the the DT 19613 747 15 creative creative JJ 19613 747 16 power power NN 19613 747 17 of of IN 19613 747 18 the the DT 19613 747 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 747 20 spirit spirit NN 19613 747 21 . . . 19613 748 1 Fourthly fourthly RB 19613 748 2 , , , 19613 748 3 through through IN 19613 748 4 the the DT 19613 748 5 consolidation consolidation NN 19613 748 6 effected effect VBN 19613 748 7 in in IN 19613 748 8 the the DT 19613 748 9 Church Church NNP 19613 748 10 by by IN 19613 748 11 the the DT 19613 748 12 rule rule NN 19613 748 13 of of IN 19613 748 14 faith faith NN 19613 748 15 the the DT 19613 748 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 748 17 religion religion NN 19613 748 18 was be VBD 19613 748 19 in in IN 19613 748 20 some some DT 19613 748 21 measure measure NN 19613 748 22 preserved preserve VBN 19613 748 23 from from IN 19613 748 24 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 748 25 extravagancies extravagancy NNS 19613 748 26 and and CC 19613 748 27 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 19613 748 28 misinterpretation misinterpretation NN 19613 748 29 . . . 19613 749 1 Fifthly fifthly RB 19613 749 2 , , , 19613 749 3 in in IN 19613 749 4 consequence consequence NN 19613 749 5 of of IN 19613 749 6 the the DT 19613 749 7 regard regard NN 19613 749 8 for for IN 19613 749 9 a a DT 19613 749 10 Church Church NNP 19613 749 11 founded found VBN 19613 749 12 on on IN 19613 749 13 the the DT 19613 749 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 749 15 of of IN 19613 749 16 faith faith NN 19613 749 17 the the DT 19613 749 18 specific specific JJ 19613 749 19 significance significance NN 19613 749 20 of of IN 19613 749 21 redemption redemption NN 19613 749 22 by by IN 19613 749 23 Christ Christ NNP 19613 749 24 , , , 19613 749 25 as as IN 19613 749 26 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 749 27 from from IN 19613 749 28 natural natural JJ 19613 749 29 religion religion NN 19613 749 30 and and CC 19613 749 31 that that DT 19613 749 32 of of IN 19613 749 33 the the DT 19613 749 34 Old Old NNP 19613 749 35 Testament Testament NNP 19613 749 36 , , , 19613 749 37 could could MD 19613 749 38 no no RB 19613 749 39 longer longer RB 19613 749 40 be be VB 19613 749 41 lost lose VBN 19613 749 42 to to IN 19613 749 43 believers believer NNS 19613 749 44 . . . 19613 750 1 Sixthly sixthly RB 19613 750 2 , , , 19613 750 3 the the DT 19613 750 4 independence independence NN 19613 750 5 of of IN 19613 750 6 each each DT 19613 750 7 individual individual JJ 19613 750 8 community community NN 19613 750 9 had have VBD 19613 750 10 a a DT 19613 750 11 wide wide JJ 19613 750 12 scope scope NN 19613 750 13 not not RB 19613 750 14 only only RB 19613 750 15 at at IN 19613 750 16 the the DT 19613 750 17 end end NN 19613 750 18 of of IN 19613 750 19 the the DT 19613 750 20 second second JJ 19613 750 21 but but CC 19613 750 22 also also RB 19613 750 23 in in IN 19613 750 24 the the DT 19613 750 25 third third JJ 19613 750 26 century century NN 19613 750 27 . . . 19613 751 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 751 2 150 150 CD 19613 751 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 751 4 Consequently consequently RB 19613 751 5 , , , 19613 751 6 though though IN 19613 751 7 the the DT 19613 751 8 revolution revolution NN 19613 751 9 which which WDT 19613 751 10 led lead VBD 19613 751 11 to to IN 19613 751 12 the the DT 19613 751 13 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 751 14 Church Church NNP 19613 751 15 was be VBD 19613 751 16 a a DT 19613 751 17 result result NN 19613 751 18 of of IN 19613 751 19 the the DT 19613 751 20 situation situation NN 19613 751 21 of of IN 19613 751 22 the the DT 19613 751 23 communities community NNS 19613 751 24 in in IN 19613 751 25 the the DT 19613 751 26 world world NN 19613 751 27 in in IN 19613 751 28 general general JJ 19613 751 29 and and CC 19613 751 30 of of IN 19613 751 31 the the DT 19613 751 32 struggle struggle NN 19613 751 33 with with IN 19613 751 34 the the DT 19613 751 35 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 751 36 and and CC 19613 751 37 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 751 38 in in IN 19613 751 39 particular particular JJ 19613 751 40 , , , 19613 751 41 and and CC 19613 751 42 though though IN 19613 751 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 751 44 was be VBD 19613 751 45 a a DT 19613 751 46 fatal fatal JJ 19613 751 47 error error NN 19613 751 48 to to TO 19613 751 49 identify identify VB 19613 751 50 the the DT 19613 751 51 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 751 52 and and CC 19613 751 53 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 751 54 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 751 55 , , , 19613 751 56 this this DT 19613 751 57 change change NN 19613 751 58 did do VBD 19613 751 59 not not RB 19613 751 60 take take VB 19613 751 61 place place NN 19613 751 62 without without IN 19613 751 63 an an DT 19613 751 64 exalting exalting NN 19613 751 65 of of IN 19613 751 66 the the DT 19613 751 67 Christian christian JJ 19613 751 68 spirit spirit NN 19613 751 69 and and CC 19613 751 70 an an DT 19613 751 71 awakening awakening NN 19613 751 72 of of IN 19613 751 73 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 751 74 self self NN 19613 751 75 - - HYPH 19613 751 76 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 751 77 . . . 19613 752 1 But but CC 19613 752 2 there there EX 19613 752 3 was be VBD 19613 752 4 never never RB 19613 752 5 a a DT 19613 752 6 time time NN 19613 752 7 in in IN 19613 752 8 history history NN 19613 752 9 when when WRB 19613 752 10 the the DT 19613 752 11 conception conception NN 19613 752 12 of of IN 19613 752 13 the the DT 19613 752 14 Church Church NNP 19613 752 15 , , , 19613 752 16 as as IN 19613 752 17 nothing nothing NN 19613 752 18 else else RB 19613 752 19 than than IN 19613 752 20 the the DT 19613 752 21 visible visible JJ 19613 752 22 communion communion NN 19613 752 23 of of IN 19613 752 24 those those DT 19613 752 25 holding hold VBG 19613 752 26 the the DT 19613 752 27 correct correct JJ 19613 752 28 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 752 29 doctrine doctrine NNP 19613 752 30 , , , 19613 752 31 was be VBD 19613 752 32 clearly clearly RB 19613 752 33 grasped grasped JJ 19613 752 34 or or CC 19613 752 35 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 752 36 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 752 37 . . . 19613 753 1 In in IN 19613 753 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 753 3 and and CC 19613 753 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 753 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 753 6 rather rather RB 19613 753 7 find find VBP 19613 753 8 , , , 19613 753 9 on on IN 19613 753 10 the the DT 19613 753 11 one one CD 19613 753 12 hand hand NN 19613 753 13 , , , 19613 753 14 that that IN 19613 753 15 the the DT 19613 753 16 old old JJ 19613 753 17 theory theory NN 19613 753 18 of of IN 19613 753 19 the the DT 19613 753 20 Church Church NNP 19613 753 21 was be VBD 19613 753 22 still still RB 19613 753 23 to to IN 19613 753 24 a a DT 19613 753 25 great great JJ 19613 753 26 extent extent NN 19613 753 27 preserved preserve VBN 19613 753 28 and and CC 19613 753 29 , , , 19613 753 30 on on IN 19613 753 31 the the DT 19613 753 32 other other JJ 19613 753 33 , , , 19613 753 34 that that IN 19613 753 35 the the DT 19613 753 36 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 753 37 notion notion NN 19613 753 38 was be VBD 19613 753 39 already already RB 19613 753 40 making make VBG 19613 753 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 753 42 appearance appearance NN 19613 753 43 . . . 19613 754 1 As as IN 19613 754 2 to to IN 19613 754 3 the the DT 19613 754 4 first first JJ 19613 754 5 point point NN 19613 754 6 , , , 19613 754 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 754 8 frequently frequently RB 19613 754 9 asserts assert VBZ 19613 754 10 that that IN 19613 754 11 the the DT 19613 754 12 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 754 13 and and CC 19613 754 14 the the DT 19613 754 15 Church Church NNP 19613 754 16 , , , 19613 754 17 that that RB 19613 754 18 is is RB 19613 754 19 , , , 19613 754 20 the the DT 19613 754 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 754 22 people people NNS 19613 754 23 , , , 19613 754 24 are be VBP 19613 754 25 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 754 26 ; ; : 19613 754 27 that that IN 19613 754 28 the the DT 19613 754 29 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 754 30 in in IN 19613 754 31 divers diver NNS 19613 754 32 ways way NNS 19613 754 33 continually continually RB 19613 754 34 effects effect VBZ 19613 754 35 whatever whatever WDT 19613 754 36 she -PRON- PRP 19613 754 37 needs need VBZ 19613 754 38 ; ; : 19613 754 39 that that IN 19613 754 40 she -PRON- PRP 19613 754 41 is be VBZ 19613 754 42 the the DT 19613 754 43 totality totality NN 19613 754 44 of of IN 19613 754 45 all all DT 19613 754 46 true true JJ 19613 754 47 believers believer NNS 19613 754 48 , , , 19613 754 49 that that IN 19613 754 50 all all PDT 19613 754 51 the the DT 19613 754 52 faithful faithful JJ 19613 754 53 have have VBP 19613 754 54 the the DT 19613 754 55 rank rank NN 19613 754 56 of of IN 19613 754 57 priests priest NNS 19613 754 58 ; ; : 19613 754 59 that that IN 19613 754 60 outside outside IN 19613 754 61 the the DT 19613 754 62 holy holy NNP 19613 754 63 Church Church NNP 19613 754 64 there there EX 19613 754 65 is be VBZ 19613 754 66 no no DT 19613 754 67 salvation salvation NN 19613 754 68 , , , 19613 754 69 etc etc FW 19613 754 70 . . . 19613 755 1 ; ; : 19613 755 2 in in IN 19613 755 3 fact fact NN 19613 755 4 these these DT 19613 755 5 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 755 6 form form VBP 19613 755 7 the the DT 19613 755 8 very very JJ 19613 755 9 essence essence NN 19613 755 10 of of IN 19613 755 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 755 12 teaching teaching NN 19613 755 13 . . . 19613 756 1 But but CC 19613 756 2 , , , 19613 756 3 since since IN 19613 756 4 she -PRON- PRP 19613 756 5 was be VBD 19613 756 6 also also RB 19613 756 7 regarded regard VBN 19613 756 8 as as IN 19613 756 9 the the DT 19613 756 10 visible visible JJ 19613 756 11 institution institution NN 19613 756 12 for for IN 19613 756 13 objectively objectively RB 19613 756 14 preserving preserve VBG 19613 756 15 and and CC 19613 756 16 communicating communicate VBG 19613 756 17 the the DT 19613 756 18 truth truth NN 19613 756 19 , , , 19613 756 20 and and CC 19613 756 21 since since IN 19613 756 22 the the DT 19613 756 23 idea idea NN 19613 756 24 of of IN 19613 756 25 the the DT 19613 756 26 Church Church NNP 19613 756 27 in in IN 19613 756 28 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 756 29 to to TO 19613 756 30 heresy heresy VB 19613 756 31 was be VBD 19613 756 32 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 756 33 exhausted exhaust VBN 19613 756 34 in in IN 19613 756 35 this this DT 19613 756 36 as as RB 19613 756 37 far far RB 19613 756 38 as as IN 19613 756 39 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 756 40 was be VBD 19613 756 41 concerned concern VBN 19613 756 42 , , , 19613 756 43 the the DT 19613 756 44 old old JJ 19613 756 45 theories theory NNS 19613 756 46 of of IN 19613 756 47 the the DT 19613 756 48 matter matter NN 19613 756 49 could could MD 19613 756 50 not not RB 19613 756 51 operate operate VB 19613 756 52 correctively correctively RB 19613 756 53 , , , 19613 756 54 but but CC 19613 756 55 in in IN 19613 756 56 the the DT 19613 756 57 end end NN 19613 756 58 only only RB 19613 756 59 served serve VBD 19613 756 60 to to TO 19613 756 61 glorify glorify VB 19613 756 62 the the DT 19613 756 63 earthly earthly JJ 19613 756 64 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 756 65 Church Church NNP 19613 756 66 . . . 19613 757 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 757 2 151 151 CD 19613 757 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 757 4 The the DT 19613 757 5 proposition proposition NN 19613 757 6 that that IN 19613 757 7 truth truth NN 19613 757 8 is be VBZ 19613 757 9 only only RB 19613 757 10 to to TO 19613 757 11 be be VB 19613 757 12 found find VBN 19613 757 13 in in IN 19613 757 14 the the DT 19613 757 15 Church Church NNP 19613 757 16 and and CC 19613 757 17 that that IN 19613 757 18 she -PRON- PRP 19613 757 19 and and CC 19613 757 20 the the DT 19613 757 21 Holy Holy NNP 19613 757 22 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 757 23 are be VBP 19613 757 24 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 757 25 must must MD 19613 757 26 be be VB 19613 757 27 understood understand VBN 19613 757 28 in in IN 19613 757 29 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 757 30 as as IN 19613 757 31 already already RB 19613 757 32 referring refer VBG 19613 757 33 to to IN 19613 757 34 the the DT 19613 757 35 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 757 36 Church Church NNP 19613 757 37 in in IN 19613 757 38 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 757 39 to to IN 19613 757 40 every every DT 19613 757 41 other other JJ 19613 757 42 calling call VBG 19613 757 43 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 757 44 Christian Christian NNP 19613 757 45 . . . 19613 758 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 758 2 152 152 CD 19613 758 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 758 4 As as IN 19613 758 5 to to IN 19613 758 6 the the DT 19613 758 7 second second JJ 19613 758 8 point point NN 19613 758 9 , , , 19613 758 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 758 11 can can MD 19613 758 12 not not RB 19613 758 13 be be VB 19613 758 14 denied deny VBN 19613 758 15 that that IN 19613 758 16 , , , 19613 758 17 though though IN 19613 758 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 758 19 desires desire NNS 19613 758 20 to to TO 19613 758 21 maintain maintain VB 19613 758 22 that that IN 19613 758 23 the the DT 19613 758 24 only only JJ 19613 758 25 essential essential JJ 19613 758 26 part part NN 19613 758 27 of of IN 19613 758 28 the the DT 19613 758 29 idea idea NN 19613 758 30 of of IN 19613 758 31 the the DT 19613 758 32 Church Church NNP 19613 758 33 is be VBZ 19613 758 34 the the DT 19613 758 35 fact fact NN 19613 758 36 of of IN 19613 758 37 her -PRON- PRP 19613 758 38 being be VBG 19613 758 39 the the DT 19613 758 40 depository depository NN 19613 758 41 of of IN 19613 758 42 the the DT 19613 758 43 truth truth NN 19613 758 44 , , , 19613 758 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 758 46 was be VBD 19613 758 47 no no RB 19613 758 48 longer long RBR 19613 758 49 able able JJ 19613 758 50 to to TO 19613 758 51 confine confine VB 19613 758 52 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 758 53 to to IN 19613 758 54 this this DT 19613 758 55 ( ( -LRB- 19613 758 56 see see VB 19613 758 57 above above RB 19613 758 58 ) ) -RRB- 19613 758 59 . . . 19613 759 1 The the DT 19613 759 2 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 759 3 succession succession NN 19613 759 4 and and CC 19613 759 5 the the DT 19613 759 6 transmission transmission NN 19613 759 7 to to IN 19613 759 8 the the DT 19613 759 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 759 10 of of IN 19613 759 11 the the DT 19613 759 12 _ _ NNP 19613 759 13 magisterium magisterium NN 19613 759 14 _ _ NNP 19613 759 15 of of IN 19613 759 16 the the DT 19613 759 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 759 18 were be VBD 19613 759 19 not not RB 19613 759 20 indeed indeed RB 19613 759 21 of of IN 19613 759 22 any any DT 19613 759 23 direct direct JJ 19613 759 24 importance importance NN 19613 759 25 to to IN 19613 759 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 759 27 idea idea NN 19613 759 28 of of IN 19613 759 29 the the DT 19613 759 30 Church Church NNP 19613 759 31 , , , 19613 759 32 but but CC 19613 759 33 they -PRON- PRP 19613 759 34 were be VBD 19613 759 35 of of IN 19613 759 36 consequence consequence NN 19613 759 37 for for IN 19613 759 38 the the DT 19613 759 39 preservation preservation NN 19613 759 40 of of IN 19613 759 41 truth truth NN 19613 759 42 and and CC 19613 759 43 therefore therefore RB 19613 759 44 indirectly indirectly RB 19613 759 45 for for IN 19613 759 46 the the DT 19613 759 47 idea idea NN 19613 759 48 of of IN 19613 759 49 the the DT 19613 759 50 Church Church NNP 19613 759 51 also also RB 19613 759 52 . . . 19613 760 1 To to IN 19613 760 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 760 3 , , , 19613 760 4 however however RB 19613 760 5 , , , 19613 760 6 that that IN 19613 760 7 theory theory NN 19613 760 8 was be VBD 19613 760 9 still still RB 19613 760 10 nothing nothing NN 19613 760 11 more more JJR 19613 760 12 than than IN 19613 760 13 an an DT 19613 760 14 artificial artificial JJ 19613 760 15 line line NN 19613 760 16 ; ; , 19613 760 17 but but CC 19613 760 18 artificial artificial JJ 19613 760 19 lines line NNS 19613 760 20 are be VBP 19613 760 21 really really RB 19613 760 22 supports support NNS 19613 760 23 and and CC 19613 760 24 must must MD 19613 760 25 therefore therefore RB 19613 760 26 soon soon RB 19613 760 27 attain attain VB 19613 760 28 the the DT 19613 760 29 value value NN 19613 760 30 of of IN 19613 760 31 foundations foundation NNS 19613 760 32 . . . 19613 761 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 761 2 153 153 CD 19613 761 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 761 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 761 5 's 's POS 19613 761 6 conception conception NN 19613 761 7 of of IN 19613 761 8 the the DT 19613 761 9 Church Church NNP 19613 761 10 was be VBD 19613 761 11 essentially essentially RB 19613 761 12 the the DT 19613 761 13 same same JJ 19613 761 14 as as IN 19613 761 15 that that DT 19613 761 16 of of IN 19613 761 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 761 18 ; ; : 19613 761 19 but but CC 19613 761 20 with with IN 19613 761 21 the the DT 19613 761 22 former former JJ 19613 761 23 the the DT 19613 761 24 idea idea NN 19613 761 25 that that IN 19613 761 26 she -PRON- PRP 19613 761 27 is be VBZ 19613 761 28 the the DT 19613 761 29 outward outward JJ 19613 761 30 manifestation manifestation NN 19613 761 31 of of IN 19613 761 32 the the DT 19613 761 33 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 761 34 , , , 19613 761 35 and and CC 19613 761 36 therefore therefore RB 19613 761 37 a a DT 19613 761 38 communion communion NN 19613 761 39 of of IN 19613 761 40 those those DT 19613 761 41 who who WP 19613 761 42 are be VBP 19613 761 43 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 761 44 , , , 19613 761 45 at at IN 19613 761 46 all all DT 19613 761 47 times time NNS 19613 761 48 continued continue VBD 19613 761 49 to to TO 19613 761 50 operate operate VB 19613 761 51 more more RBR 19613 761 52 powerfully powerfully RB 19613 761 53 than than IN 19613 761 54 with with IN 19613 761 55 the the DT 19613 761 56 latter latter JJ 19613 761 57 . . . 19613 762 1 In in IN 19613 762 2 the the DT 19613 762 3 last last JJ 19613 762 4 period period NN 19613 762 5 of of IN 19613 762 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 762 7 life life NN 19613 762 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 762 9 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 762 10 this this DT 19613 762 11 theory theory NN 19613 762 12 so so RB 19613 762 13 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 762 14 that that IN 19613 762 15 the the DT 19613 762 16 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 762 17 idea idea NN 19613 762 18 of of IN 19613 762 19 the the DT 19613 762 20 Church Church NNP 19613 762 21 being be VBG 19613 762 22 based base VBN 19613 762 23 on on IN 19613 762 24 the the DT 19613 762 25 " " `` 19613 762 26 traditio traditio NNP 19613 762 27 unius unius NNP 19613 762 28 sacramenti sacramenti NNP 19613 762 29 " " `` 19613 762 30 fell fall VBD 19613 762 31 into into IN 19613 762 32 the the DT 19613 762 33 background background NN 19613 762 34 . . . 19613 763 1 Consequently consequently RB 19613 763 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 763 3 find find VBP 19613 763 4 nothing nothing NN 19613 763 5 more more JJR 19613 763 6 than than IN 19613 763 7 traces trace NNS 19613 763 8 of of IN 19613 763 9 the the DT 19613 763 10 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 763 11 conception conception NN 19613 763 12 of of IN 19613 763 13 the the DT 19613 763 14 Church Church NNP 19613 763 15 in in IN 19613 763 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 763 17 . . . 19613 764 1 But but CC 19613 764 2 towards towards IN 19613 764 3 the the DT 19613 764 4 end end NN 19613 764 5 of of IN 19613 764 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 764 7 life life NN 19613 764 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 764 9 found find VBD 19613 764 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 764 11 face face NN 19613 764 12 to to IN 19613 764 13 face face NN 19613 764 14 with with IN 19613 764 15 a a DT 19613 764 16 _ _ NNP 19613 764 17 fully fully RB 19613 764 18 developed develop VBN 19613 764 19 _ _ NNP 19613 764 20 theory theory NN 19613 764 21 of of IN 19613 764 22 this this DT 19613 764 23 kind kind NN 19613 764 24 . . . 19613 765 1 This this DT 19613 765 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 765 3 most most RBS 19613 765 4 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 765 5 rejected reject VBN 19613 765 6 , , , 19613 765 7 and and CC 19613 765 8 , , , 19613 765 9 in in IN 19613 765 10 doing do VBG 19613 765 11 so so RB 19613 765 12 , , , 19613 765 13 advanced advanced JJ 19613 765 14 to to IN 19613 765 15 such such PDT 19613 765 16 a a DT 19613 765 17 conception conception NN 19613 765 18 of of IN 19613 765 19 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 765 20 orders order NNS 19613 765 21 , , , 19613 765 22 and and CC 19613 765 23 therefore therefore RB 19613 765 24 also also RB 19613 765 25 of of IN 19613 765 26 the the DT 19613 765 27 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 765 28 , , , 19613 765 29 as as RB 19613 765 30 clearly clearly RB 19613 765 31 involved involve VBD 19613 765 32 him -PRON- PRP 19613 765 33 in in IN 19613 765 34 a a DT 19613 765 35 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 765 36 of of IN 19613 765 37 the the DT 19613 765 38 other other JJ 19613 765 39 theory theory NN 19613 765 40 -- -- : 19613 765 41 which which WDT 19613 765 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 765 43 also also RB 19613 765 44 never never RB 19613 765 45 gave give VBD 19613 765 46 up up RP 19613 765 47 -- -- : 19613 765 48 viz viz NN 19613 765 49 . . . 19613 765 50 , , , 19613 765 51 that that IN 19613 765 52 the the DT 19613 765 53 bishops bishop NNS 19613 765 54 , , , 19613 765 55 as as IN 19613 765 56 the the DT 19613 765 57 class class NN 19613 765 58 which which WDT 19613 765 59 transmits transmit VBZ 19613 765 60 the the DT 19613 765 61 rule rule NN 19613 765 62 of of IN 19613 765 63 faith faith NN 19613 765 64 , , , 19613 765 65 are be VBP 19613 765 66 an an DT 19613 765 67 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 765 68 institution institution NN 19613 765 69 and and CC 19613 765 70 therefore therefore RB 19613 765 71 necessary necessary JJ 19613 765 72 to to IN 19613 765 73 the the DT 19613 765 74 Church[154 church[154 CD 19613 765 75 ] ] -RRB- 19613 765 76 . . . 19613 766 1 From from IN 19613 766 2 the the DT 19613 766 3 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 766 4 of of IN 19613 766 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 766 6 of of IN 19613 766 7 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 766 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 766 9 see see VBP 19613 766 10 how how WRB 19613 766 11 vigorous vigorous JJ 19613 766 12 the the DT 19613 766 13 old old JJ 19613 766 14 conception conception NN 19613 766 15 of of IN 19613 766 16 the the DT 19613 766 17 Church Church NNP 19613 766 18 , , , 19613 766 19 as as IN 19613 766 20 the the DT 19613 766 21 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 766 22 communion communion NN 19613 766 23 of of IN 19613 766 24 the the DT 19613 766 25 elect elect NN 19613 766 26 and and CC 19613 766 27 believing believe VBG 19613 766 28 , , , 19613 766 29 still still RB 19613 766 30 continued continue VBD 19613 766 31 to to TO 19613 766 32 be be VB 19613 766 33 about about IN 19613 766 34 the the DT 19613 766 35 year year NN 19613 766 36 200 200 CD 19613 766 37 . . . 19613 767 1 This this DT 19613 767 2 will will MD 19613 767 3 not not RB 19613 767 4 appear appear VB 19613 767 5 strange strange JJ 19613 767 6 after after IN 19613 767 7 what what WP 19613 767 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 767 9 have have VBP 19613 767 10 already already RB 19613 767 11 said say VBN 19613 767 12 as as IN 19613 767 13 to to IN 19613 767 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 767 15 's 's POS 19613 767 16 views view NNS 19613 767 17 about about IN 19613 767 18 the the DT 19613 767 19 rule rule NN 19613 767 20 of of IN 19613 767 21 faith faith NN 19613 767 22 , , , 19613 767 23 the the DT 19613 767 24 New New NNP 19613 767 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 767 26 , , , 19613 767 27 and and CC 19613 767 28 the the DT 19613 767 29 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 767 30 . . . 19613 768 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 768 2 is be VBZ 19613 768 3 evident evident JJ 19613 768 4 that that IN 19613 768 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 768 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 768 7 of of IN 19613 768 8 religion religion NN 19613 768 9 led lead VBD 19613 768 10 him -PRON- PRP 19613 768 11 to to TO 19613 768 12 give give VB 19613 768 13 a a DT 19613 768 14 new new JJ 19613 768 15 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 768 16 to to IN 19613 768 17 the the DT 19613 768 18 original original JJ 19613 768 19 ideas idea NNS 19613 768 20 . . . 19613 769 1 Yet yet CC 19613 769 2 the the DT 19613 769 3 old old JJ 19613 769 4 form form NN 19613 769 5 of of IN 19613 769 6 these these DT 19613 769 7 notions notion NNS 19613 769 8 can can MD 19613 769 9 be be VB 19613 769 10 more more RBR 19613 769 11 easily easily RB 19613 769 12 made make VBN 19613 769 13 out out RP 19613 769 14 from from IN 19613 769 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 769 16 works work NNS 19613 769 17 than than IN 19613 769 18 from from IN 19613 769 19 those those DT 19613 769 20 of of IN 19613 769 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 769 22 . . . 19613 770 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 770 2 155 155 CD 19613 770 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 770 4 Up up IN 19613 770 5 to to IN 19613 770 6 the the DT 19613 770 7 15th 15th JJ 19613 770 8 Chapter chapter NN 19613 770 9 of of IN 19613 770 10 the the DT 19613 770 11 7th 7th JJ 19613 770 12 Book Book NNP 19613 770 13 of of IN 19613 770 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 770 15 great great JJ 19613 770 16 work work NN 19613 770 17 , , , 19613 770 18 the the DT 19613 770 19 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 770 20 , , , 19613 770 21 and and CC 19613 770 22 in in IN 19613 770 23 the the DT 19613 770 24 Pædagogus Pædagogus NNP 19613 770 25 , , , 19613 770 26 Clement Clement NNP 19613 770 27 simply simply RB 19613 770 28 speaks speak VBZ 19613 770 29 of of IN 19613 770 30 the the DT 19613 770 31 Church Church NNP 19613 770 32 in in IN 19613 770 33 the the DT 19613 770 34 sense sense NN 19613 770 35 of of IN 19613 770 36 the the DT 19613 770 37 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 770 38 to to IN 19613 770 39 the the DT 19613 770 40 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 19613 770 41 and and CC 19613 770 42 the the DT 19613 770 43 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 770 44 of of IN 19613 770 45 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 770 46 . . . 19613 771 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 771 2 is be VBZ 19613 771 3 a a DT 19613 771 4 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 771 5 formation formation NN 19613 771 6 , , , 19613 771 7 continued continue VBN 19613 771 8 in in IN 19613 771 9 that that DT 19613 771 10 which which WDT 19613 771 11 appears appear VBZ 19613 771 12 on on IN 19613 771 13 earth earth NN 19613 771 14 as as IN 19613 771 15 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 771 16 image image NN 19613 771 17 . . . 19613 772 1 Instead instead RB 19613 772 2 of of IN 19613 772 3 distinguishing distinguish VBG 19613 772 4 two two CD 19613 772 5 Churches Churches NNP 19613 772 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 772 7 sees see VBZ 19613 772 8 one one CD 19613 772 9 , , , 19613 772 10 the the DT 19613 772 11 product product NN 19613 772 12 of of IN 19613 772 13 God God NNP 19613 772 14 's 's POS 19613 772 15 will will MD 19613 772 16 aiming aim VBG 19613 772 17 at at IN 19613 772 18 the the DT 19613 772 19 salvation salvation NN 19613 772 20 of of IN 19613 772 21 man man NN 19613 772 22 -- -- : 19613 772 23 a a DT 19613 772 24 Church church NN 19613 772 25 which which WDT 19613 772 26 is be VBZ 19613 772 27 to to TO 19613 772 28 be be VB 19613 772 29 on on IN 19613 772 30 earth earth NN 19613 772 31 as as IN 19613 772 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 772 33 is be VBZ 19613 772 34 in in IN 19613 772 35 heaven heaven NNP 19613 772 36 , , , 19613 772 37 and and CC 19613 772 38 of of IN 19613 772 39 which which WDT 19613 772 40 faith faith NN 19613 772 41 forms form VBZ 19613 772 42 the the DT 19613 772 43 subjective subjective JJ 19613 772 44 and and CC 19613 772 45 the the DT 19613 772 46 Logos Logos NNP 19613 772 47 the the DT 19613 772 48 objective objective JJ 19613 772 49 bond bond NN 19613 772 50 of of IN 19613 772 51 union union NN 19613 772 52 . . . 19613 773 1 But but CC 19613 773 2 , , , 19613 773 3 beginning begin VBG 19613 773 4 with with IN 19613 773 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 773 6 . . . 19613 774 1 VII VII NNP 19613 774 2 . . . 19613 775 1 15 15 CD 19613 775 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 775 3 see see VB 19613 775 4 especially especially RB 19613 775 5 17 17 CD 19613 775 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 775 7 , , , 19613 775 8 where where WRB 19613 775 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 775 10 is be VBZ 19613 775 11 influenced influence VBN 19613 775 12 by by IN 19613 775 13 opposition opposition NN 19613 775 14 to to IN 19613 775 15 the the DT 19613 775 16 heretics heretic NNS 19613 775 17 , , , 19613 775 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 775 19 suddenly suddenly RB 19613 775 20 identifies identify VBZ 19613 775 21 this this DT 19613 775 22 Church Church NNP 19613 775 23 with with IN 19613 775 24 the the DT 19613 775 25 single single JJ 19613 775 26 old old JJ 19613 775 27 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 775 28 one one NN 19613 775 29 , , , 19613 775 30 that that RB 19613 775 31 is is RB 19613 775 32 , , , 19613 775 33 with with IN 19613 775 34 the the DT 19613 775 35 visible visible JJ 19613 775 36 " " `` 19613 775 37 Church Church NNP 19613 775 38 " " '' 19613 775 39 in in IN 19613 775 40 opposition opposition NN 19613 775 41 to to IN 19613 775 42 the the DT 19613 775 43 heretic heretic JJ 19613 775 44 sects sect NNS 19613 775 45 . . . 19613 776 1 Thus thus RB 19613 776 2 the the DT 19613 776 3 empirical empirical JJ 19613 776 4 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 776 5 of of IN 19613 776 6 the the DT 19613 776 7 Church Church NNP 19613 776 8 , , , 19613 776 9 which which WDT 19613 776 10 makes make VBZ 19613 776 11 her -PRON- PRP 19613 776 12 the the DT 19613 776 13 institution institution NN 19613 776 14 in in IN 19613 776 15 possession possession NN 19613 776 16 of of IN 19613 776 17 the the DT 19613 776 18 true true JJ 19613 776 19 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 776 20 , , , 19613 776 21 was be VBD 19613 776 22 also also RB 19613 776 23 completely completely RB 19613 776 24 adopted adopt VBN 19613 776 25 by by IN 19613 776 26 Clement Clement NNP 19613 776 27 ; ; : 19613 776 28 but but CC 19613 776 29 as as RB 19613 776 30 yet yet RB 19613 776 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 776 32 employed employ VBD 19613 776 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 776 34 simply simply RB 19613 776 35 in in IN 19613 776 36 polemics polemic NNS 19613 776 37 and and CC 19613 776 38 not not RB 19613 776 39 in in IN 19613 776 40 positive positive JJ 19613 776 41 teachings teaching NNS 19613 776 42 . . . 19613 777 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 777 2 neither neither CC 19613 777 3 reconciled reconcile VBD 19613 777 4 nor nor CC 19613 777 5 seemingly seemingly RB 19613 777 6 felt feel VBD 19613 777 7 the the DT 19613 777 8 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 777 9 in in IN 19613 777 10 the the DT 19613 777 11 statement statement NN 19613 777 12 that that IN 19613 777 13 the the DT 19613 777 14 Church Church NNP 19613 777 15 is be VBZ 19613 777 16 to to TO 19613 777 17 be be VB 19613 777 18 at at IN 19613 777 19 one one CD 19613 777 20 and and CC 19613 777 21 the the DT 19613 777 22 same same JJ 19613 777 23 time time NN 19613 777 24 the the DT 19613 777 25 assembly assembly NN 19613 777 26 of of IN 19613 777 27 the the DT 19613 777 28 elect elect NN 19613 777 29 and and CC 19613 777 30 the the DT 19613 777 31 empiric empiric NN 19613 777 32 universal universal NNP 19613 777 33 Church Church NNP 19613 777 34 . . . 19613 778 1 At at IN 19613 778 2 any any DT 19613 778 3 rate rate NN 19613 778 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 778 5 made make VBD 19613 778 6 as as IN 19613 778 7 yet yet RB 19613 778 8 no no DT 19613 778 9 unconditional unconditional JJ 19613 778 10 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 778 11 of of IN 19613 778 12 the the DT 19613 778 13 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 778 14 Church Church NNP 19613 778 15 , , , 19613 778 16 because because IN 19613 778 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 778 18 was be VBD 19613 778 19 still still RB 19613 778 20 able able JJ 19613 778 21 to to TO 19613 778 22 attribute attribute VB 19613 778 23 independent independent JJ 19613 778 24 value value NN 19613 778 25 to to IN 19613 778 26 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 778 27 , , , 19613 778 28 that that RB 19613 778 29 is is RB 19613 778 30 , , , 19613 778 31 to to IN 19613 778 32 independent independent JJ 19613 778 33 piety piety NN 19613 778 34 as as IN 19613 778 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 778 36 understood understand VBD 19613 778 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 778 38 . . . 19613 779 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 779 2 156 156 CD 19613 779 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 779 4 Consequently consequently RB 19613 779 5 , , , 19613 779 6 as as IN 19613 779 7 regards regard VBZ 19613 779 8 the the DT 19613 779 9 conception conception NN 19613 779 10 of of IN 19613 779 11 the the DT 19613 779 12 Church Church NNP 19613 779 13 , , , 19613 779 14 the the DT 19613 779 15 mystic mystic JJ 19613 779 16 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 779 17 exercised exercise VBD 19613 779 18 the the DT 19613 779 19 same same JJ 19613 779 20 effect effect NN 19613 779 21 as as IN 19613 779 22 the the DT 19613 779 23 old old JJ 19613 779 24 religious religious JJ 19613 779 25 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 779 26 from from IN 19613 779 27 which which WDT 19613 779 28 in in IN 19613 779 29 other other JJ 19613 779 30 respects respect NNS 19613 779 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 779 32 differs differ VBZ 19613 779 33 so so RB 19613 779 34 much much RB 19613 779 35 . . . 19613 780 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 780 2 157 157 CD 19613 780 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 780 4 The the DT 19613 780 5 hierarchy hierarchy NN 19613 780 6 has have VBZ 19613 780 7 still still RB 19613 780 8 no no DT 19613 780 9 significance significance NN 19613 780 10 as as RB 19613 780 11 far far RB 19613 780 12 as as IN 19613 780 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 780 14 's 's POS 19613 780 15 idea idea NN 19613 780 16 of of IN 19613 780 17 the the DT 19613 780 18 Church Church NNP 19613 780 19 is be VBZ 19613 780 20 concerned concern VBN 19613 780 21 . . . 19613 781 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 781 2 158 158 CD 19613 781 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 781 4 At at IN 19613 781 5 first first RB 19613 781 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 781 7 entirely entirely RB 19613 781 8 agrees agree VBZ 19613 781 9 with with IN 19613 781 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 781 11 in in IN 19613 781 12 regard regard NN 19613 781 13 to to IN 19613 781 14 this this DT 19613 781 15 conception conception NN 19613 781 16 . . . 19613 782 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 782 2 also also RB 19613 782 3 starts start VBZ 19613 782 4 with with IN 19613 782 5 the the DT 19613 782 6 theory theory NN 19613 782 7 that that IN 19613 782 8 the the DT 19613 782 9 Church Church NNP 19613 782 10 is be VBZ 19613 782 11 essentially essentially RB 19613 782 12 a a DT 19613 782 13 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 782 14 communion communion NN 19613 782 15 and and CC 19613 782 16 a a DT 19613 782 17 holy holy JJ 19613 782 18 communion communion NN 19613 782 19 of of IN 19613 782 20 believers believer NNS 19613 782 21 , , , 19613 782 22 and and CC 19613 782 23 keeps keep VBZ 19613 782 24 this this DT 19613 782 25 idea idea NN 19613 782 26 constantly constantly RB 19613 782 27 before before IN 19613 782 28 him -PRON- PRP 19613 782 29 . . . 19613 783 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 783 2 159 159 CD 19613 783 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 783 4 When when WRB 19613 783 5 opposing oppose VBG 19613 783 6 heretics heretic NNS 19613 783 7 , , , 19613 783 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 783 9 also also RB 19613 783 10 , , , 19613 783 11 like like IN 19613 783 12 Clement Clement NNP 19613 783 13 , , , 19613 783 14 can can MD 19613 783 15 not not RB 19613 783 16 help help VB 19613 783 17 identifying identify VBG 19613 783 18 her -PRON- PRP 19613 783 19 with with IN 19613 783 20 the the DT 19613 783 21 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 783 22 Church Church NNP 19613 783 23 , , , 19613 783 24 because because IN 19613 783 25 the the DT 19613 783 26 latter latter NN 19613 783 27 contains contain VBZ 19613 783 28 the the DT 19613 783 29 true true JJ 19613 783 30 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 783 31 , , , 19613 783 32 though though IN 19613 783 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 783 34 likewise likewise RB 19613 783 35 refrains refrain VBZ 19613 783 36 from from IN 19613 783 37 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 19613 783 38 any any DT 19613 783 39 hierarchy hierarchy NN 19613 783 40 . . . 19613 784 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 784 2 160 160 CD 19613 784 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 784 4 But but CC 19613 784 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 784 6 is be VBZ 19613 784 7 influenced influence VBN 19613 784 8 by by IN 19613 784 9 two two CD 19613 784 10 further further JJ 19613 784 11 considerations consideration NNS 19613 784 12 , , , 19613 784 13 which which WDT 19613 784 14 are be VBP 19613 784 15 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 784 16 hinted hint VBN 19613 784 17 at at IN 19613 784 18 in in IN 19613 784 19 Clement Clement NNP 19613 784 20 , , , 19613 784 21 but but CC 19613 784 22 which which WDT 19613 784 23 were be VBD 19613 784 24 called call VBN 19613 784 25 forth forth RP 19613 784 26 by by IN 19613 784 27 the the DT 19613 784 28 actual actual JJ 19613 784 29 course course NN 19613 784 30 of of IN 19613 784 31 events event NNS 19613 784 32 and and CC 19613 784 33 signified signify VBD 19613 784 34 a a DT 19613 784 35 further further JJ 19613 784 36 development development NN 19613 784 37 in in IN 19613 784 38 the the DT 19613 784 39 idea idea NN 19613 784 40 of of IN 19613 784 41 the the DT 19613 784 42 Church Church NNP 19613 784 43 . . . 19613 785 1 For for IN 19613 785 2 , , , 19613 785 3 in in IN 19613 785 4 the the DT 19613 785 5 first first JJ 19613 785 6 place place NN 19613 785 7 , , , 19613 785 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 785 9 saw see VBD 19613 785 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 785 11 already already RB 19613 785 12 compelled compel VBN 19613 785 13 to to TO 19613 785 14 examine examine VB 19613 785 15 closely closely RB 19613 785 16 the the DT 19613 785 17 distinction distinction NN 19613 785 18 between between IN 19613 785 19 the the DT 19613 785 20 essence essence NN 19613 785 21 and and CC 19613 785 22 the the DT 19613 785 23 outward outward JJ 19613 785 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 785 25 of of IN 19613 785 26 the the DT 19613 785 27 Church Church NNP 19613 785 28 , , , 19613 785 29 and and CC 19613 785 30 , , , 19613 785 31 in in IN 19613 785 32 this this DT 19613 785 33 process process NN 19613 785 34 , , , 19613 785 35 reached reach VBD 19613 785 36 results result NNS 19613 785 37 which which WDT 19613 785 38 again again RB 19613 785 39 called call VBD 19613 785 40 in in IN 19613 785 41 question question NN 19613 785 42 the the DT 19613 785 43 identification identification NN 19613 785 44 of of IN 19613 785 45 the the DT 19613 785 46 Holy Holy NNP 19613 785 47 Church Church NNP 19613 785 48 with with IN 19613 785 49 the the DT 19613 785 50 empiric empiric NN 19613 785 51 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 785 52 one one CD 19613 785 53 ( ( -LRB- 19613 785 54 see see VB 19613 785 55 on on IN 19613 785 56 this this DT 19613 785 57 point point NN 19613 785 58 the the DT 19613 785 59 following follow VBG 19613 785 60 chapter chapter NN 19613 785 61 ) ) -RRB- 19613 785 62 . . . 19613 786 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 786 2 , , , 19613 786 3 in in IN 19613 786 4 consequence consequence NN 19613 786 5 of of IN 19613 786 6 the the DT 19613 786 7 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 786 8 extension extension NN 19613 786 9 and and CC 19613 786 10 powerful powerful JJ 19613 786 11 position position NN 19613 786 12 attained attain VBN 19613 786 13 by by IN 19613 786 14 the the DT 19613 786 15 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 786 16 Church Church NNP 19613 786 17 by by IN 19613 786 18 the the DT 19613 786 19 time time NN 19613 786 20 of of IN 19613 786 21 Philip Philip NNP 19613 786 22 the the DT 19613 786 23 Arabian arabian JJ 19613 786 24 , , , 19613 786 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 786 26 , , , 19613 786 27 giving give VBG 19613 786 28 a a DT 19613 786 29 new new JJ 19613 786 30 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 786 31 to to IN 19613 786 32 a a DT 19613 786 33 very very RB 19613 786 34 old old JJ 19613 786 35 Christian christian JJ 19613 786 36 notion notion NN 19613 786 37 and and CC 19613 786 38 making make VBG 19613 786 39 use use NN 19613 786 40 of of IN 19613 786 41 a a DT 19613 786 42 Platonic platonic JJ 19613 786 43 conception,[161 conception,[161 NN 19613 786 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 786 45 arrived arrive VBD 19613 786 46 at at IN 19613 786 47 the the DT 19613 786 48 idea idea NN 19613 786 49 that that IN 19613 786 50 she -PRON- PRP 19613 786 51 was be VBD 19613 786 52 the the DT 19613 786 53 earthly earthly JJ 19613 786 54 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 786 55 of of IN 19613 786 56 God God NNP 19613 786 57 , , , 19613 786 58 destined destine VBN 19613 786 59 to to TO 19613 786 60 enter enter VB 19613 786 61 the the DT 19613 786 62 world world NN 19613 786 63 , , , 19613 786 64 to to TO 19613 786 65 absorb absorb VB 19613 786 66 the the DT 19613 786 67 Roman Roman NNP 19613 786 68 Empire Empire NNP 19613 786 69 and and CC 19613 786 70 indeed indeed RB 19613 786 71 all all DT 19613 786 72 mankind mankind NN 19613 786 73 , , , 19613 786 74 and and CC 19613 786 75 to to TO 19613 786 76 unite unite VB 19613 786 77 and and CC 19613 786 78 take take VB 19613 786 79 the the DT 19613 786 80 place place NN 19613 786 81 of of IN 19613 786 82 the the DT 19613 786 83 various various JJ 19613 786 84 secular secular JJ 19613 786 85 states state NNS 19613 786 86 . . . 19613 787 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 787 2 162 162 CD 19613 787 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 787 4 This this DT 19613 787 5 magnificent magnificent JJ 19613 787 6 idea idea NN 19613 787 7 , , , 19613 787 8 which which WDT 19613 787 9 regards regard VBZ 19613 787 10 the the DT 19613 787 11 Church Church NNP 19613 787 12 as as IN 19613 787 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 787 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 787 15 : : : 19613 787 16 kosmos kosmos NNP 19613 787 17 tou tou NNP 19613 787 18 kosmou][163 kosmou][163 NNP 19613 787 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 787 20 , , , 19613 787 21 denoted denote VBD 19613 787 22 indeed indeed RB 19613 787 23 a a DT 19613 787 24 complete complete JJ 19613 787 25 departure departure NN 19613 787 26 from from IN 19613 787 27 the the DT 19613 787 28 original original JJ 19613 787 29 theory theory NN 19613 787 30 of of IN 19613 787 31 the the DT 19613 787 32 subject subject NN 19613 787 33 , , , 19613 787 34 determined determine VBN 19613 787 35 by by IN 19613 787 36 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 787 37 considerations consideration NNS 19613 787 38 ; ; : 19613 787 39 though though IN 19613 787 40 we -PRON- PRP 19613 787 41 must must MD 19613 787 42 not not RB 19613 787 43 forget forget VB 19613 787 44 that that IN 19613 787 45 Origen Origen NNP 19613 787 46 still still RB 19613 787 47 demanded demand VBD 19613 787 48 a a DT 19613 787 49 really really RB 19613 787 50 holy holy JJ 19613 787 51 Church Church NNP 19613 787 52 and and CC 19613 787 53 a a DT 19613 787 54 new new JJ 19613 787 55 polity polity NN 19613 787 56 . . . 19613 788 1 Hence hence RB 19613 788 2 , , , 19613 788 3 as as IN 19613 788 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 788 5 also also RB 19613 788 6 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 788 7 the the DT 19613 788 8 various various JJ 19613 788 9 degrees degree NNS 19613 788 10 of of IN 19613 788 11 connection connection NN 19613 788 12 with with IN 19613 788 13 the the DT 19613 788 14 Church,[164 Church,[164 NNP 19613 788 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 788 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 788 17 already already RB 19613 788 18 find find VBP 19613 788 19 in in IN 19613 788 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 788 21 theory theory NN 19613 788 22 a a DT 19613 788 23 combination combination NN 19613 788 24 of of IN 19613 788 25 all all PDT 19613 788 26 the the DT 19613 788 27 features feature NNS 19613 788 28 that that WDT 19613 788 29 became become VBD 19613 788 30 essential essential JJ 19613 788 31 parts part NNS 19613 788 32 of of IN 19613 788 33 the the DT 19613 788 34 conception conception NN 19613 788 35 of of IN 19613 788 36 the the DT 19613 788 37 Church Church NNP 19613 788 38 in in IN 19613 788 39 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 788 40 times time NNS 19613 788 41 , , , 19613 788 42 with with IN 19613 788 43 the the DT 19613 788 44 exception exception NN 19613 788 45 of of IN 19613 788 46 the the DT 19613 788 47 clerical clerical JJ 19613 788 48 element element NN 19613 788 49 . . . 19613 789 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 789 2 165 165 CD 19613 789 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 789 4 3 3 CD 19613 789 5 . . . 19613 790 1 The the DT 19613 790 2 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 790 3 notions notion NNS 19613 790 4 of of IN 19613 790 5 the the DT 19613 790 6 Church Church NNP 19613 790 7 , , , 19613 790 8 for for IN 19613 790 9 so so RB 19613 790 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 790 11 appear appear VBP 19613 790 12 to to IN 19613 790 13 us -PRON- PRP 19613 790 14 , , , 19613 790 15 in in IN 19613 790 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 790 17 and and CC 19613 790 18 Clement Clement NNP 19613 790 19 and and CC 19613 790 20 still still RB 19613 790 21 more more JJR 19613 790 22 in in IN 19613 790 23 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 790 24 and and CC 19613 790 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 790 26 , , , 19613 790 27 need nee MD 19613 790 28 not not RB 19613 790 29 astonish astonish VB 19613 790 30 any any DT 19613 790 31 one one NN 19613 790 32 who who WP 19613 790 33 bears bear VBZ 19613 790 34 in in IN 19613 790 35 mind mind NN 19613 790 36 that that IN 19613 790 37 none none NN 19613 790 38 of of IN 19613 790 39 these these DT 19613 790 40 Fathers father NNS 19613 790 41 made make VBD 19613 790 42 the the DT 19613 790 43 Church Church NNP 19613 790 44 the the DT 19613 790 45 subject subject NN 19613 790 46 of of IN 19613 790 47 a a DT 19613 790 48 theological theological JJ 19613 790 49 theory theory NN 19613 790 50 . . . 19613 791 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 791 2 166 166 CD 19613 791 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 791 4 Hence hence RB 19613 791 5 no no DT 19613 791 6 one one NN 19613 791 7 as as RB 19613 791 8 yet yet RB 19613 791 9 thought think VBN 19613 791 10 of of IN 19613 791 11 questioning question VBG 19613 791 12 the the DT 19613 791 13 old old JJ 19613 791 14 article article NN 19613 791 15 : : : 19613 791 16 " " `` 19613 791 17 I -PRON- PRP 19613 791 18 believe believe VBP 19613 791 19 in in IN 19613 791 20 a a DT 19613 791 21 holy holy NNP 19613 791 22 Church Church NNP 19613 791 23 . . . 19613 791 24 " " '' 19613 792 1 But but CC 19613 792 2 , , , 19613 792 3 at at IN 19613 792 4 the the DT 19613 792 5 same same JJ 19613 792 6 time time NN 19613 792 7 , , , 19613 792 8 actual actual JJ 19613 792 9 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 792 10 , , , 19613 792 11 though though IN 19613 792 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 792 13 did do VBD 19613 792 14 not not RB 19613 792 15 at at IN 19613 792 16 first first RB 19613 792 17 succeed succeed VB 19613 792 18 in in IN 19613 792 19 altering alter VBG 19613 792 20 the the DT 19613 792 21 Church Church NNP 19613 792 22 's 's POS 19613 792 23 belief belief NN 19613 792 24 , , , 19613 792 25 forced force VBD 19613 792 26 her -PRON- PRP 19613 792 27 to to IN 19613 792 28 _ _ NNP 19613 792 29 realise realise NN 19613 792 30 _ _ NNP 19613 792 31 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 792 32 changed changed JJ 19613 792 33 position position NN 19613 792 34 , , , 19613 792 35 for for IN 19613 792 36 she -PRON- PRP 19613 792 37 had have VBD 19613 792 38 in in IN 19613 792 39 point point NN 19613 792 40 of of IN 19613 792 41 fact fact NN 19613 792 42 become become VBP 19613 792 43 an an DT 19613 792 44 association association NN 19613 792 45 which which WDT 19613 792 46 was be VBD 19613 792 47 founded found VBN 19613 792 48 on on IN 19613 792 49 a a DT 19613 792 50 definite definite JJ 19613 792 51 law law NN 19613 792 52 of of IN 19613 792 53 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 792 54 and and CC 19613 792 55 rejected reject VBD 19613 792 56 everything everything NN 19613 792 57 that that WDT 19613 792 58 did do VBD 19613 792 59 not not RB 19613 792 60 conform conform VB 19613 792 61 to to IN 19613 792 62 it -PRON- PRP 19613 792 63 . . . 19613 793 1 The the DT 19613 793 2 identifying identifying NN 19613 793 3 of of IN 19613 793 4 this this DT 19613 793 5 association association NN 19613 793 6 with with IN 19613 793 7 the the DT 19613 793 8 ideal ideal JJ 19613 793 9 Church Church NNP 19613 793 10 was be VBD 19613 793 11 a a DT 19613 793 12 matter matter NN 19613 793 13 of of IN 19613 793 14 course,[167 course,[167 NNP 19613 793 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 793 16 but but CC 19613 793 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 793 18 was be VBD 19613 793 19 quite quite RB 19613 793 20 as as RB 19613 793 21 natural natural JJ 19613 793 22 to to TO 19613 793 23 take take VB 19613 793 24 no no DT 19613 793 25 immediate immediate JJ 19613 793 26 _ _ NNP 19613 793 27 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 793 28 _ _ NNP 19613 793 29 notice notice NN 19613 793 30 of of IN 19613 793 31 the the DT 19613 793 32 identification identification NN 19613 793 33 except except IN 19613 793 34 in in IN 19613 793 35 cases case NNS 19613 793 36 where where WRB 19613 793 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 793 38 was be VBD 19613 793 39 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 793 40 necessary necessary JJ 19613 793 41 , , , 19613 793 42 that that RB 19613 793 43 is is RB 19613 793 44 , , , 19613 793 45 in in IN 19613 793 46 polemics polemic NNS 19613 793 47 . . . 19613 794 1 In in IN 19613 794 2 the the DT 19613 794 3 latter latter JJ 19613 794 4 case case NN 19613 794 5 the the DT 19613 794 6 unity unity NN 19613 794 7 of of IN 19613 794 8 faith faith NN 19613 794 9 and and CC 19613 794 10 hope hope NN 19613 794 11 became become VBD 19613 794 12 the the DT 19613 794 13 unity unity NN 19613 794 14 of of IN 19613 794 15 the the DT 19613 794 16 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 794 17 of of IN 19613 794 18 faith faith NN 19613 794 19 , , , 19613 794 20 and and CC 19613 794 21 the the DT 19613 794 22 Church Church NNP 19613 794 23 was be VBD 19613 794 24 , , , 19613 794 25 in in IN 19613 794 26 this this DT 19613 794 27 instance instance NN 19613 794 28 , , , 19613 794 29 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 794 30 by by IN 19613 794 31 the the DT 19613 794 32 possession possession NN 19613 794 33 of of IN 19613 794 34 the the DT 19613 794 35 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 794 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 794 37 instead instead RB 19613 794 38 of of IN 19613 794 39 by by IN 19613 794 40 the the DT 19613 794 41 realising realising NN 19613 794 42 of of IN 19613 794 43 that that DT 19613 794 44 tradition tradition NN 19613 794 45 in in IN 19613 794 46 heart heart NN 19613 794 47 and and CC 19613 794 48 life life NN 19613 794 49 . . . 19613 795 1 From from IN 19613 795 2 the the DT 19613 795 3 principle principle NN 19613 795 4 that that WDT 19613 795 5 had have VBD 19613 795 6 been be VBN 19613 795 7 set set VBN 19613 795 8 up up RP 19613 795 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 795 10 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 795 11 followed follow VBD 19613 795 12 that that IN 19613 795 13 the the DT 19613 795 14 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 795 15 inheritance inheritance NN 19613 795 16 on on IN 19613 795 17 which which WDT 19613 795 18 the the DT 19613 795 19 truth truth NN 19613 795 20 and and CC 19613 795 21 legitimacy legitimacy NN 19613 795 22 of of IN 19613 795 23 the the DT 19613 795 24 Church Church NNP 19613 795 25 was be VBD 19613 795 26 based base VBN 19613 795 27 , , , 19613 795 28 could could MD 19613 795 29 not not RB 19613 795 30 but but RB 19613 795 31 remain remain VB 19613 795 32 an an DT 19613 795 33 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 795 34 court court NN 19613 795 35 of of IN 19613 795 36 appeal appeal NN 19613 795 37 until until IN 19613 795 38 _ _ NNP 19613 795 39 living live VBG 19613 795 40 _ _ NNP 19613 795 41 authorities authority NNS 19613 795 42 could could MD 19613 795 43 be be VB 19613 795 44 pointed point VBN 19613 795 45 to to IN 19613 795 46 in in IN 19613 795 47 this this DT 19613 795 48 court court NN 19613 795 49 , , , 19613 795 50 and and CC 19613 795 51 until until IN 19613 795 52 _ _ NNP 19613 795 53 every every DT 19613 795 54 _ _ NNP 19613 795 55 possible possible JJ 19613 795 56 cause cause NN 19613 795 57 of of IN 19613 795 58 strife strife NN 19613 795 59 and and CC 19613 795 60 separation separation NN 19613 795 61 was be VBD 19613 795 62 settled settle VBN 19613 795 63 by by IN 19613 795 64 reference reference NN 19613 795 65 to to IN 19613 795 66 it -PRON- PRP 19613 795 67 . . . 19613 796 1 An an DT 19613 796 2 empirical empirical JJ 19613 796 3 community community NN 19613 796 4 can can MD 19613 796 5 not not RB 19613 796 6 be be VB 19613 796 7 ruled rule VBN 19613 796 8 by by IN 19613 796 9 a a DT 19613 796 10 traditional traditional JJ 19613 796 11 written write VBN 19613 796 12 word word NN 19613 796 13 , , , 19613 796 14 but but CC 19613 796 15 only only RB 19613 796 16 by by IN 19613 796 17 persons person NNS 19613 796 18 ; ; : 19613 796 19 for for IN 19613 796 20 the the DT 19613 796 21 written written JJ 19613 796 22 law law NN 19613 796 23 will will MD 19613 796 24 always always RB 19613 796 25 separate separate VB 19613 796 26 and and CC 19613 796 27 split split VB 19613 796 28 . . . 19613 797 1 If if IN 19613 797 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 797 3 has have VBZ 19613 797 4 such such JJ 19613 797 5 persons person NNS 19613 797 6 , , , 19613 797 7 however however RB 19613 797 8 , , , 19613 797 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 797 10 can can MD 19613 797 11 tolerate tolerate VB 19613 797 12 within within IN 19613 797 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 797 14 a a DT 19613 797 15 great great JJ 19613 797 16 amount amount NN 19613 797 17 of of IN 19613 797 18 individual individual JJ 19613 797 19 differences difference NNS 19613 797 20 , , , 19613 797 21 provided provide VBD 19613 797 22 that that IN 19613 797 23 the the DT 19613 797 24 leaders leader NNS 19613 797 25 subordinate subordinate VBP 19613 797 26 the the DT 19613 797 27 interests interest NNS 19613 797 28 of of IN 19613 797 29 the the DT 19613 797 30 whole whole NN 19613 797 31 to to IN 19613 797 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 797 33 own own JJ 19613 797 34 ambition ambition NN 19613 797 35 . . . 19613 798 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 798 2 have have VBP 19613 798 3 seen see VBN 19613 798 4 how how WRB 19613 798 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 798 6 and and CC 19613 798 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 798 8 , , , 19613 798 9 though though IN 19613 798 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 798 11 in in IN 19613 798 12 all all DT 19613 798 13 earnestness earnestness NN 19613 798 14 represented represent VBD 19613 798 15 the the DT 19613 798 16 _ _ NNP 19613 798 17 fides fide NNS 19613 798 18 catholica catholica NNP 19613 798 19 _ _ NNP 19613 798 20 and and CC 19613 798 21 _ _ NNP 19613 798 22 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 798 23 catholica catholica NNP 19613 798 24 _ _ NNP 19613 798 25 as as IN 19613 798 26 inseparably inseparably RB 19613 798 27 connected,[168 connected,[168 NN 19613 798 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 798 29 were be VBD 19613 798 30 already already RB 19613 798 31 compelled compel VBN 19613 798 32 to to TO 19613 798 33 have have VB 19613 798 34 recourse recourse VBN 19613 798 35 to to IN 19613 798 36 bishops bishop NNS 19613 798 37 in in IN 19613 798 38 order order NN 19613 798 39 to to TO 19613 798 40 ensure ensure VB 19613 798 41 the the DT 19613 798 42 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 798 43 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 798 44 . . . 19613 799 1 The the DT 19613 799 2 conflicts conflict NNS 19613 799 3 within within IN 19613 799 4 the the DT 19613 799 5 sphere sphere NN 19613 799 6 of of IN 19613 799 7 the the DT 19613 799 8 rule rule NN 19613 799 9 of of IN 19613 799 10 faith faith NN 19613 799 11 , , , 19613 799 12 the the DT 19613 799 13 struggles struggle NNS 19613 799 14 with with IN 19613 799 15 the the DT 19613 799 16 so so RB 19613 799 17 - - HYPH 19613 799 18 called call VBN 19613 799 19 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 799 20 , , , 19613 799 21 but but CC 19613 799 22 finally finally RB 19613 799 23 and and CC 19613 799 24 above above IN 19613 799 25 all all DT 19613 799 26 , , , 19613 799 27 the the DT 19613 799 28 existing exist VBG 19613 799 29 situation situation NN 19613 799 30 of of IN 19613 799 31 the the DT 19613 799 32 Church Church NNP 19613 799 33 in in IN 19613 799 34 the the DT 19613 799 35 third third JJ 19613 799 36 century century NN 19613 799 37 with with IN 19613 799 38 regard regard NN 19613 799 39 to to IN 19613 799 40 the the DT 19613 799 41 world world NN 19613 799 42 within within IN 19613 799 43 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 799 44 pale pale NN 19613 799 45 , , , 19613 799 46 made make VBD 19613 799 47 the the DT 19613 799 48 question question NN 19613 799 49 of of IN 19613 799 50 organisation organisation NN 19613 799 51 the the DT 19613 799 52 vital vital JJ 19613 799 53 one one CD 19613 799 54 for for IN 19613 799 55 her -PRON- PRP 19613 799 56 . . . 19613 800 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 800 2 and and CC 19613 800 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 800 4 already already RB 19613 800 5 found find VBD 19613 800 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 800 7 face face NN 19613 800 8 to to IN 19613 800 9 face face NN 19613 800 10 with with IN 19613 800 11 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 800 12 claims claim NNS 19613 800 13 of of IN 19613 800 14 which which WDT 19613 800 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 800 16 highly highly RB 19613 800 17 disapproved disapprove VBD 19613 800 18 and and CC 19613 800 19 which which WDT 19613 800 20 , , , 19613 800 21 in in IN 19613 800 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 800 23 own own JJ 19613 800 24 way way NN 19613 800 25 , , , 19613 800 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 800 27 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 800 28 to to TO 19613 800 29 oppose oppose VB 19613 800 30 . . . 19613 801 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 801 2 was be VBD 19613 801 3 again again RB 19613 801 4 the the DT 19613 801 5 Roman roman JJ 19613 801 6 bishop[169 bishop[169 NN 19613 801 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 801 8 who who WP 19613 801 9 first first RB 19613 801 10 converted convert VBD 19613 801 11 the the DT 19613 801 12 proposition proposition NN 19613 801 13 that that IN 19613 801 14 the the DT 19613 801 15 bishops bishop NNS 19613 801 16 are be VBP 19613 801 17 direct direct JJ 19613 801 18 successors successor NNS 19613 801 19 of of IN 19613 801 20 the the DT 19613 801 21 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 801 22 and and CC 19613 801 23 have have VB 19613 801 24 the the DT 19613 801 25 same same JJ 19613 801 26 " " `` 19613 801 27 locus locus NN 19613 801 28 magisterii magisterii NN 19613 801 29 " " '' 19613 801 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 801 31 " " `` 19613 801 32 place place NN 19613 801 33 of of IN 19613 801 34 government government NN 19613 801 35 " " '' 19613 801 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 801 37 into into IN 19613 801 38 a a DT 19613 801 39 theory theory NN 19613 801 40 which which WDT 19613 801 41 declares declare VBZ 19613 801 42 that that IN 19613 801 43 _ _ NNP 19613 801 44 all all DT 19613 801 45 _ _ NNP 19613 801 46 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 801 47 powers power NNS 19613 801 48 have have VBP 19613 801 49 devolved devolve VBN 19613 801 50 on on IN 19613 801 51 the the DT 19613 801 52 bishops bishop NNS 19613 801 53 and and CC 19613 801 54 that that IN 19613 801 55 these these DT 19613 801 56 have have VBP 19613 801 57 therefore therefore RB 19613 801 58 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 801 59 rights right NNS 19613 801 60 and and CC 19613 801 61 duties duty NNS 19613 801 62 in in IN 19613 801 63 virtue virtue NN 19613 801 64 of of IN 19613 801 65 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 801 66 office office NN 19613 801 67 . . . 19613 802 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 802 2 170 170 CD 19613 802 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 802 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 802 5 added add VBD 19613 802 6 to to IN 19613 802 7 this this DT 19613 802 8 the the DT 19613 802 9 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 802 10 theory theory NN 19613 802 11 of of IN 19613 802 12 the the DT 19613 802 13 Church Church NNP 19613 802 14 . . . 19613 803 1 In in IN 19613 803 2 one one CD 19613 803 3 decisive decisive JJ 19613 803 4 point point NN 19613 803 5 , , , 19613 803 6 however however RB 19613 803 7 , , , 19613 803 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 803 9 did do VBD 19613 803 10 not not RB 19613 803 11 assist assist VB 19613 803 12 the the DT 19613 803 13 secularising secularising NN 19613 803 14 process process NN 19613 803 15 which which WDT 19613 803 16 had have VBD 19613 803 17 been be VBN 19613 803 18 completed complete VBN 19613 803 19 by by IN 19613 803 20 the the DT 19613 803 21 Roman roman JJ 19613 803 22 bishop bishop NN 19613 803 23 , , , 19613 803 24 in in IN 19613 803 25 the the DT 19613 803 26 interest interest NN 19613 803 27 of of IN 19613 803 28 Catholicity Catholicity NNP 19613 803 29 as as RB 19613 803 30 well well RB 19613 803 31 as as IN 19613 803 32 in in IN 19613 803 33 that that DT 19613 803 34 of of IN 19613 803 35 the the DT 19613 803 36 Church Church NNP 19613 803 37 's 's POS 19613 803 38 existence existence NN 19613 803 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 803 40 see see VB 19613 803 41 the the DT 19613 803 42 following follow VBG 19613 803 43 chapter chapter NN 19613 803 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 803 45 . . . 19613 804 1 In in IN 19613 804 2 the the DT 19613 804 3 second second JJ 19613 804 4 half half NN 19613 804 5 of of IN 19613 804 6 the the DT 19613 804 7 third third JJ 19613 804 8 century century NN 19613 804 9 there there EX 19613 804 10 were be VBD 19613 804 11 no no RB 19613 804 12 longer long RBR 19613 804 13 any any DT 19613 804 14 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 804 15 , , , 19613 804 16 except except IN 19613 804 17 remote remote JJ 19613 804 18 communities community NNS 19613 804 19 , , , 19613 804 20 where where WRB 19613 804 21 the the DT 19613 804 22 only only JJ 19613 804 23 requirement requirement NN 19613 804 24 was be VBD 19613 804 25 to to TO 19613 804 26 preserve preserve VB 19613 804 27 the the DT 19613 804 28 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 804 29 faith faith NN 19613 804 30 ; ; : 19613 804 31 the the DT 19613 804 32 bishops bishop NNS 19613 804 33 had have VBD 19613 804 34 to to TO 19613 804 35 be be VB 19613 804 36 obeyed obey VBN 19613 804 37 . . . 19613 805 1 The the DT 19613 805 2 idea idea NN 19613 805 3 of of IN 19613 805 4 the the DT 19613 805 5 one one NN 19613 805 6 episcopally episcopally RB 19613 805 7 organised organise VBN 19613 805 8 Church church NN 19613 805 9 became become VBD 19613 805 10 the the DT 19613 805 11 main main JJ 19613 805 12 one one NN 19613 805 13 and and CC 19613 805 14 overshadowed overshadow VBD 19613 805 15 the the DT 19613 805 16 significance significance NN 19613 805 17 of of IN 19613 805 18 the the DT 19613 805 19 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 805 20 of of IN 19613 805 21 faith faith NN 19613 805 22 as as IN 19613 805 23 a a DT 19613 805 24 bond bond NN 19613 805 25 of of IN 19613 805 26 unity unity NN 19613 805 27 . . . 19613 806 1 _ _ NNP 19613 806 2 The the DT 19613 806 3 Church Church NNP 19613 806 4 based base VBN 19613 806 5 on on IN 19613 806 6 the the DT 19613 806 7 bishops bishop NNS 19613 806 8 , , , 19613 806 9 the the DT 19613 806 10 successors successor NNS 19613 806 11 of of IN 19613 806 12 the the DT 19613 806 13 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 806 14 , , , 19613 806 15 the the DT 19613 806 16 vicegerents vicegerent NNS 19613 806 17 of of IN 19613 806 18 God God NNP 19613 806 19 , , , 19613 806 20 is be VBZ 19613 806 21 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 806 22 the the DT 19613 806 23 legacy legacy NN 19613 806 24 of of IN 19613 806 25 the the DT 19613 806 26 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 806 27 in in IN 19613 806 28 virtue virtue NN 19613 806 29 of of IN 19613 806 30 this this DT 19613 806 31 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 806 32 foundation foundation NN 19613 806 33 . . . 19613 806 34 _ _ NNP 19613 806 35 This this DT 19613 806 36 idea idea NN 19613 806 37 was be VBD 19613 806 38 never never RB 19613 806 39 converted convert VBN 19613 806 40 into into IN 19613 806 41 a a DT 19613 806 42 rigid rigid JJ 19613 806 43 theory theory NN 19613 806 44 in in IN 19613 806 45 the the DT 19613 806 46 East East NNP 19613 806 47 , , , 19613 806 48 though though IN 19613 806 49 the the DT 19613 806 50 reality reality NN 19613 806 51 to to TO 19613 806 52 which which WDT 19613 806 53 it -PRON- PRP 19613 806 54 corresponded correspond VBD 19613 806 55 was be VBD 19613 806 56 not not RB 19613 806 57 the the DT 19613 806 58 less less RBR 19613 806 59 certain certain JJ 19613 806 60 on on IN 19613 806 61 that that DT 19613 806 62 account account NN 19613 806 63 . . . 19613 807 1 The the DT 19613 807 2 fancy fancy JJ 19613 807 3 that that IN 19613 807 4 the the DT 19613 807 5 earthly earthly JJ 19613 807 6 hierarchy hierarchy NN 19613 807 7 was be VBD 19613 807 8 the the DT 19613 807 9 image image NN 19613 807 10 of of IN 19613 807 11 the the DT 19613 807 12 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 807 13 was be VBD 19613 807 14 the the DT 19613 807 15 only only JJ 19613 807 16 part part NN 19613 807 17 that that WDT 19613 807 18 began begin VBD 19613 807 19 to to TO 19613 807 20 be be VB 19613 807 21 taken take VBN 19613 807 22 in in IN 19613 807 23 real real RB 19613 807 24 earnest earnest NN 19613 807 25 . . . 19613 808 1 In in IN 19613 808 2 the the DT 19613 808 3 West West NNP 19613 808 4 , , , 19613 808 5 on on IN 19613 808 6 the the DT 19613 808 7 other other JJ 19613 808 8 hand hand NN 19613 808 9 , , , 19613 808 10 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 808 11 compelled compel VBD 19613 808 12 the the DT 19613 808 13 Carthaginian carthaginian JJ 19613 808 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 808 15 to to TO 19613 808 16 set set VB 19613 808 17 up up RP 19613 808 18 a a DT 19613 808 19 finished finished JJ 19613 808 20 theory theory NN 19613 808 21 . . . 19613 809 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 809 2 171 171 CD 19613 809 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 809 4 According accord VBG 19613 809 5 to to IN 19613 809 6 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 809 7 , , , 19613 809 8 the the DT 19613 809 9 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 809 10 Church Church NNP 19613 809 11 , , , 19613 809 12 to to TO 19613 809 13 which which WDT 19613 809 14 all all PDT 19613 809 15 the the DT 19613 809 16 lofty lofty JJ 19613 809 17 predictions prediction NNS 19613 809 18 and and CC 19613 809 19 predicates predicate NNS 19613 809 20 in in IN 19613 809 21 the the DT 19613 809 22 Bible Bible NNP 19613 809 23 apply apply VB 19613 809 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 809 25 see see VB 19613 809 26 Hartel Hartel NNP 19613 809 27 's 's POS 19613 809 28 index index NN 19613 809 29 under under IN 19613 809 30 " " `` 19613 809 31 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 809 32 " " '' 19613 809 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 809 34 , , , 19613 809 35 is be VBZ 19613 809 36 the the DT 19613 809 37 one one CD 19613 809 38 institution institution NN 19613 809 39 of of IN 19613 809 40 salvation salvation NN 19613 809 41 outside outside IN 19613 809 42 of of IN 19613 809 43 which which WDT 19613 809 44 there there EX 19613 809 45 is be VBZ 19613 809 46 no no DT 19613 809 47 redemption redemption NN 19613 809 48 ( ( -LRB- 19613 809 49 ep ep NNP 19613 809 50 . . . 19613 810 1 73 73 CD 19613 810 2 . . . 19613 811 1 21 21 CD 19613 811 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 811 3 . . . 19613 812 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 812 2 is be VBZ 19613 812 3 this this DT 19613 812 4 , , , 19613 812 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 812 6 , , , 19613 812 7 not not RB 19613 812 8 only only RB 19613 812 9 as as IN 19613 812 10 the the DT 19613 812 11 community community NN 19613 812 12 possessing possess VBG 19613 812 13 the the DT 19613 812 14 true true JJ 19613 812 15 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 812 16 faith faith NN 19613 812 17 , , , 19613 812 18 for for IN 19613 812 19 this this DT 19613 812 20 definition definition NN 19613 812 21 does do VBZ 19613 812 22 not not RB 19613 812 23 exhaust exhaust VB 19613 812 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 812 25 conception conception NN 19613 812 26 , , , 19613 812 27 but but CC 19613 812 28 as as IN 19613 812 29 a a DT 19613 812 30 harmoniously harmoniously RB 19613 812 31 organised organise VBN 19613 812 32 federation federation NN 19613 812 33 . . . 19613 813 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 813 2 172 172 CD 19613 813 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 813 4 This this DT 19613 813 5 Church Church NNP 19613 813 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 813 7 rests rest VBZ 19613 813 8 entirely entirely RB 19613 813 9 on on IN 19613 813 10 the the DT 19613 813 11 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 813 12 , , , 19613 813 13 which which WDT 19613 813 14 sustains sustain VBZ 19613 813 15 her,[173 her,[173 NNP 19613 813 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 813 17 because because IN 19613 813 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 813 19 is be VBZ 19613 813 20 the the DT 19613 813 21 continuance continuance NN 19613 813 22 of of IN 19613 813 23 the the DT 19613 813 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 813 25 office office NNP 19613 813 26 and and CC 19613 813 27 is be VBZ 19613 813 28 equipped equip VBN 19613 813 29 with with IN 19613 813 30 all all PDT 19613 813 31 the the DT 19613 813 32 power power NN 19613 813 33 of of IN 19613 813 34 the the DT 19613 813 35 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 813 36 . . . 19613 814 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 814 2 174 174 CD 19613 814 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 814 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 814 5 , , , 19613 814 6 the the DT 19613 814 7 union union NN 19613 814 8 of of IN 19613 814 9 individuals individual NNS 19613 814 10 with with IN 19613 814 11 the the DT 19613 814 12 Church Church NNP 19613 814 13 , , , 19613 814 14 and and CC 19613 814 15 therefore therefore RB 19613 814 16 with with IN 19613 814 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 814 18 , , , 19613 814 19 is be VBZ 19613 814 20 effected effect VBN 19613 814 21 only only RB 19613 814 22 by by IN 19613 814 23 obedient obedient JJ 19613 814 24 dependence dependence NN 19613 814 25 on on IN 19613 814 26 the the DT 19613 814 27 bishop bishop NN 19613 814 28 , , , 19613 814 29 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 814 30 , , , 19613 814 31 such such PDT 19613 814 32 a a DT 19613 814 33 connection connection NN 19613 814 34 alone alone RB 19613 814 35 makes make VBZ 19613 814 36 one one PRP 19613 814 37 a a DT 19613 814 38 member member NN 19613 814 39 of of IN 19613 814 40 the the DT 19613 814 41 Church Church NNP 19613 814 42 . . . 19613 815 1 But but CC 19613 815 2 the the DT 19613 815 3 unity unity NN 19613 815 4 of of IN 19613 815 5 the the DT 19613 815 6 Church Church NNP 19613 815 7 , , , 19613 815 8 which which WDT 19613 815 9 is be VBZ 19613 815 10 an an DT 19613 815 11 attribute attribute NN 19613 815 12 of of IN 19613 815 13 equal equal JJ 19613 815 14 importance importance NN 19613 815 15 with with IN 19613 815 16 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 815 17 truth truth NN 19613 815 18 , , , 19613 815 19 because because IN 19613 815 20 this this DT 19613 815 21 union union NN 19613 815 22 is be VBZ 19613 815 23 only only RB 19613 815 24 brought bring VBN 19613 815 25 about about RP 19613 815 26 by by IN 19613 815 27 love,[175 love,[175 NNP 19613 815 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 815 29 primarily primarily RB 19613 815 30 appears appear VBZ 19613 815 31 in in IN 19613 815 32 the the DT 19613 815 33 unity unity NN 19613 815 34 of of IN 19613 815 35 the the DT 19613 815 36 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 815 37 . . . 19613 816 1 For for IN 19613 816 2 , , , 19613 816 3 according accord VBG 19613 816 4 to to IN 19613 816 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 816 6 , , , 19613 816 7 the the DT 19613 816 8 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 816 9 has have VBZ 19613 816 10 been be VBN 19613 816 11 from from IN 19613 816 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 816 13 beginning begin VBG 19613 816 14 undivided undivided JJ 19613 816 15 and and CC 19613 816 16 has have VBZ 19613 816 17 continued continue VBN 19613 816 18 to to TO 19613 816 19 be be VB 19613 816 20 so so RB 19613 816 21 in in IN 19613 816 22 the the DT 19613 816 23 Church Church NNP 19613 816 24 , , , 19613 816 25 in in IN 19613 816 26 so so RB 19613 816 27 far far RB 19613 816 28 as as IN 19613 816 29 the the DT 19613 816 30 bishops bishop NNS 19613 816 31 are be VBP 19613 816 32 appointed appoint VBN 19613 816 33 and and CC 19613 816 34 guided guide VBN 19613 816 35 by by IN 19613 816 36 God God NNP 19613 816 37 , , , 19613 816 38 are be VBP 19613 816 39 on on IN 19613 816 40 terms term NNS 19613 816 41 of of IN 19613 816 42 brotherly brotherly JJ 19613 816 43 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 816 44 and and CC 19613 816 45 exchange exchange NN 19613 816 46 , , , 19613 816 47 and and CC 19613 816 48 each each DT 19613 816 49 bishop bishop NN 19613 816 50 represents represent VBZ 19613 816 51 the the DT 19613 816 52 whole whole JJ 19613 816 53 significance significance NN 19613 816 54 of of IN 19613 816 55 the the DT 19613 816 56 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 816 57 . . . 19613 817 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 817 2 176 176 CD 19613 817 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 817 4 Hence hence RB 19613 817 5 the the DT 19613 817 6 individual individual JJ 19613 817 7 bishops bishop NNS 19613 817 8 are be VBP 19613 817 9 no no RB 19613 817 10 longer long JJR 19613 817 11 to to TO 19613 817 12 be be VB 19613 817 13 considered consider VBN 19613 817 14 primarily primarily RB 19613 817 15 as as IN 19613 817 16 leaders leader NNS 19613 817 17 of of IN 19613 817 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 817 19 special special JJ 19613 817 20 communities community NNS 19613 817 21 , , , 19613 817 22 but but CC 19613 817 23 as as IN 19613 817 24 the the DT 19613 817 25 foundation foundation NN 19613 817 26 of of IN 19613 817 27 the the DT 19613 817 28 one one CD 19613 817 29 Church Church NNP 19613 817 30 . . . 19613 818 1 Each each DT 19613 818 2 of of IN 19613 818 3 these these DT 19613 818 4 prelates prelate NNS 19613 818 5 , , , 19613 818 6 however however RB 19613 818 7 , , , 19613 818 8 provided provide VBD 19613 818 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 818 10 keeps keep VBZ 19613 818 11 within within IN 19613 818 12 the the DT 19613 818 13 association association NN 19613 818 14 of of IN 19613 818 15 the the DT 19613 818 16 bishops bishop NNS 19613 818 17 , , , 19613 818 18 preserves preserve VBZ 19613 818 19 the the DT 19613 818 20 independent independent JJ 19613 818 21 right right NN 19613 818 22 of of IN 19613 818 23 regulating regulate VBG 19613 818 24 the the DT 19613 818 25 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 818 26 of of IN 19613 818 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 818 28 own own JJ 19613 818 29 diocese diocese NN 19613 818 30 . . . 19613 819 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 819 2 177 177 CD 19613 819 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 819 4 But but CC 19613 819 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 819 6 also also RB 19613 819 7 follows follow VBZ 19613 819 8 that that IN 19613 819 9 the the DT 19613 819 10 bishops bishop NNS 19613 819 11 of of IN 19613 819 12 those those DT 19613 819 13 communities community NNS 19613 819 14 founded found VBN 19613 819 15 by by IN 19613 819 16 the the DT 19613 819 17 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 819 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 819 19 can can MD 19613 819 20 raise raise VB 19613 819 21 no no DT 19613 819 22 claim claim NN 19613 819 23 to to IN 19613 819 24 any any DT 19613 819 25 special special JJ 19613 819 26 dignity dignity NN 19613 819 27 , , , 19613 819 28 since since IN 19613 819 29 the the DT 19613 819 30 unity unity NN 19613 819 31 of of IN 19613 819 32 the the DT 19613 819 33 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 819 34 as as IN 19613 819 35 a a DT 19613 819 36 continuation continuation NN 19613 819 37 of of IN 19613 819 38 the the DT 19613 819 39 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 819 40 office office NNP 19613 819 41 involves involve VBZ 19613 819 42 the the DT 19613 819 43 equality equality NN 19613 819 44 of of IN 19613 819 45 all all DT 19613 819 46 bishops bishop NNS 19613 819 47 . . . 19613 820 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 820 2 178 178 CD 19613 820 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 820 4 However however RB 19613 820 5 , , , 19613 820 6 a a DT 19613 820 7 special special JJ 19613 820 8 importance importance NN 19613 820 9 attaches attach VBZ 19613 820 10 to to IN 19613 820 11 the the DT 19613 820 12 Roman Roman NNP 19613 820 13 see see VB 19613 820 14 , , , 19613 820 15 because because IN 19613 820 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 820 17 is be VBZ 19613 820 18 the the DT 19613 820 19 seat seat NN 19613 820 20 of of IN 19613 820 21 the the DT 19613 820 22 Apostle apostle NN 19613 820 23 to to TO 19613 820 24 whom whom WP 19613 820 25 Christ Christ NNP 19613 820 26 first first RB 19613 820 27 granted grant VBD 19613 820 28 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 820 29 authority authority NN 19613 820 30 in in IN 19613 820 31 order order NN 19613 820 32 to to TO 19613 820 33 show show VB 19613 820 34 with with IN 19613 820 35 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 19613 820 36 plainness plainness NN 19613 820 37 the the DT 19613 820 38 unity unity NN 19613 820 39 of of IN 19613 820 40 these these DT 19613 820 41 powers power NNS 19613 820 42 and and CC 19613 820 43 the the DT 19613 820 44 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 820 45 unity unity NN 19613 820 46 of of IN 19613 820 47 the the DT 19613 820 48 Church Church NNP 19613 820 49 that that WDT 19613 820 50 rests rest VBZ 19613 820 51 on on IN 19613 820 52 them -PRON- PRP 19613 820 53 ; ; : 19613 820 54 and and CC 19613 820 55 further far RBR 19613 820 56 because because IN 19613 820 57 , , , 19613 820 58 from from IN 19613 820 59 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 820 60 historical historical JJ 19613 820 61 origin origin NN 19613 820 62 , , , 19613 820 63 the the DT 19613 820 64 Church Church NNP 19613 820 65 of of IN 19613 820 66 this this DT 19613 820 67 see see NN 19613 820 68 had have VBD 19613 820 69 become become VBN 19613 820 70 the the DT 19613 820 71 mother mother NN 19613 820 72 and and CC 19613 820 73 root root NN 19613 820 74 of of IN 19613 820 75 the the DT 19613 820 76 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 820 77 Church Church NNP 19613 820 78 spread spread VBD 19613 820 79 over over IN 19613 820 80 the the DT 19613 820 81 earth earth NN 19613 820 82 . . . 19613 821 1 In in IN 19613 821 2 a a DT 19613 821 3 severe severe JJ 19613 821 4 crisis crisis NN 19613 821 5 which which WDT 19613 821 6 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 821 7 had have VBD 19613 821 8 to to TO 19613 821 9 pass pass VB 19613 821 10 through through RP 19613 821 11 in in IN 19613 821 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 821 13 own own JJ 19613 821 14 diocese diocese NN 19613 821 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 821 16 appealed appeal VBD 19613 821 17 to to IN 19613 821 18 the the DT 19613 821 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 821 20 Church Church NNP 19613 821 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 821 22 the the DT 19613 821 23 Roman roman JJ 19613 821 24 bishop bishop NN 19613 821 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 821 26 in in IN 19613 821 27 a a DT 19613 821 28 manner manner NN 19613 821 29 which which WDT 19613 821 30 made make VBD 19613 821 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 821 32 appear appear VB 19613 821 33 as as IN 19613 821 34 if if IN 19613 821 35 communion communion NN 19613 821 36 with with IN 19613 821 37 that that DT 19613 821 38 Church Church NNP 19613 821 39 was be VBD 19613 821 40 in in IN 19613 821 41 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 821 42 the the DT 19613 821 43 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 821 44 of of IN 19613 821 45 truth truth NN 19613 821 46 . . . 19613 822 1 But but CC 19613 822 2 in in IN 19613 822 3 the the DT 19613 822 4 controversy controversy NN 19613 822 5 about about IN 19613 822 6 heretical heretical JJ 19613 822 7 baptism baptism NN 19613 822 8 with with IN 19613 822 9 the the DT 19613 822 10 Roman roman JJ 19613 822 11 bishop bishop NN 19613 822 12 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 822 13 , , , 19613 822 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 822 15 emphatically emphatically RB 19613 822 16 denied deny VBD 19613 822 17 the the DT 19613 822 18 latter latter NN 19613 822 19 's 's POS 19613 822 20 pretensions pretension NNS 19613 822 21 to to TO 19613 822 22 exercise exercise VB 19613 822 23 special special JJ 19613 822 24 rights right NNS 19613 822 25 over over IN 19613 822 26 the the DT 19613 822 27 Church Church NNP 19613 822 28 in in IN 19613 822 29 consequence consequence NN 19613 822 30 of of IN 19613 822 31 the the DT 19613 822 32 Petrine Petrine NNP 19613 822 33 succession succession NN 19613 822 34 . . . 19613 823 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 823 2 179 179 CD 19613 823 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 823 4 Finally finally RB 19613 823 5 , , , 19613 823 6 although although IN 19613 823 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 823 8 exalted exalt VBD 19613 823 9 the the DT 19613 823 10 unity unity NN 19613 823 11 of of IN 19613 823 12 the the DT 19613 823 13 organisation organisation NN 19613 823 14 of of IN 19613 823 15 the the DT 19613 823 16 Church Church NNP 19613 823 17 above above IN 19613 823 18 the the DT 19613 823 19 unity unity NN 19613 823 20 of of IN 19613 823 21 the the DT 19613 823 22 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 823 23 of of IN 19613 823 24 faith faith NN 19613 823 25 , , , 19613 823 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 823 27 preserved preserve VBD 19613 823 28 the the DT 19613 823 29 Christian christian JJ 19613 823 30 element element NN 19613 823 31 so so RB 19613 823 32 far far RB 19613 823 33 as as IN 19613 823 34 to to TO 19613 823 35 assume assume VB 19613 823 36 in in IN 19613 823 37 all all PDT 19613 823 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 823 39 statements statement NNS 19613 823 40 that that IN 19613 823 41 the the DT 19613 823 42 bishops bishop NNS 19613 823 43 display display VBP 19613 823 44 a a DT 19613 823 45 moral moral JJ 19613 823 46 and and CC 19613 823 47 Christian christian JJ 19613 823 48 conduct conduct NN 19613 823 49 in in IN 19613 823 50 keeping keep VBG 19613 823 51 with with IN 19613 823 52 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 823 53 office office NN 19613 823 54 , , , 19613 823 55 and and CC 19613 823 56 that that IN 19613 823 57 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 823 58 they -PRON- PRP 19613 823 59 have have VBP 19613 823 60 _ _ NNP 19613 823 61 ipso ipso FW 19613 823 62 facto facto FW 19613 823 63 _ _ NNP 19613 823 64 forfeited forfeit VBD 19613 823 65 it -PRON- PRP 19613 823 66 . . . 19613 824 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 824 2 180 180 CD 19613 824 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 824 4 Thus thus RB 19613 824 5 , , , 19613 824 6 according accord VBG 19613 824 7 to to IN 19613 824 8 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 824 9 , , , 19613 824 10 the the DT 19613 824 11 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 824 12 office office NN 19613 824 13 does do VBZ 19613 824 14 not not RB 19613 824 15 confer confer VB 19613 824 16 any any DT 19613 824 17 indelible indelible JJ 19613 824 18 character character NN 19613 824 19 , , , 19613 824 20 though though IN 19613 824 21 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 824 22 and and CC 19613 824 23 other other JJ 19613 824 24 bishops bishop NNS 19613 824 25 of of IN 19613 824 26 Rome Rome NNP 19613 824 27 after after IN 19613 824 28 him -PRON- PRP 19613 824 29 presupposed presuppose VBD 19613 824 30 this this DT 19613 824 31 attribute attribute NN 19613 824 32 . . . 19613 825 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 825 2 For for IN 19613 825 3 more more JJR 19613 825 4 details detail NNS 19613 825 5 on on IN 19613 825 6 this this DT 19613 825 7 point point NN 19613 825 8 , , , 19613 825 9 as as RB 19613 825 10 well well RB 19613 825 11 as as IN 19613 825 12 with with IN 19613 825 13 regard regard NN 19613 825 14 to to IN 19613 825 15 the the DT 19613 825 16 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 825 17 that that WDT 19613 825 18 remain remain VBP 19613 825 19 unreconciled unreconciled JJ 19613 825 20 in in IN 19613 825 21 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 825 22 's 's POS 19613 825 23 conception conception NN 19613 825 24 of of IN 19613 825 25 the the DT 19613 825 26 Church Church NNP 19613 825 27 , , , 19613 825 28 see see VB 19613 825 29 the the DT 19613 825 30 following follow VBG 19613 825 31 chapter chapter NN 19613 825 32 , , , 19613 825 33 in in IN 19613 825 34 which which WDT 19613 825 35 will will MD 19613 825 36 be be VB 19613 825 37 shown show VBN 19613 825 38 the the DT 19613 825 39 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 825 40 interests interest NNS 19613 825 41 that that WDT 19613 825 42 lie lie VBP 19613 825 43 at at IN 19613 825 44 the the DT 19613 825 45 basis basis NN 19613 825 46 of of IN 19613 825 47 the the DT 19613 825 48 new new JJ 19613 825 49 idea idea NN 19613 825 50 of of IN 19613 825 51 the the DT 19613 825 52 Church Church NNP 19613 825 53 ) ) -RRB- 19613 825 54 . . . 19613 826 1 _ _ NNP 19613 826 2 Addendum Addendum NNP 19613 826 3 I._--The I._--The NNP 19613 826 4 great great JJ 19613 826 5 confederation confederation NN 19613 826 6 of of IN 19613 826 7 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 826 8 which which WDT 19613 826 9 Cyprian cyprian JJ 19613 826 10 presupposes presuppose NNS 19613 826 11 and and CC 19613 826 12 which which WDT 19613 826 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 826 14 terms term VBZ 19613 826 15 _ _ NNP 19613 826 16 the the DT 19613 826 17 _ _ NNP 19613 826 18 Church Church NNP 19613 826 19 was be VBD 19613 826 20 in in IN 19613 826 21 truth truth NN 19613 826 22 not not RB 19613 826 23 complete complete JJ 19613 826 24 , , , 19613 826 25 for for IN 19613 826 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 826 27 can can MD 19613 826 28 not not RB 19613 826 29 be be VB 19613 826 30 proved prove VBN 19613 826 31 that that IN 19613 826 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 826 33 extended extend VBD 19613 826 34 to to IN 19613 826 35 any any DT 19613 826 36 regions region NNS 19613 826 37 beyond beyond IN 19613 826 38 the the DT 19613 826 39 confines confine NNS 19613 826 40 of of IN 19613 826 41 the the DT 19613 826 42 Roman Roman NNP 19613 826 43 Empire Empire NNP 19613 826 44 or or CC 19613 826 45 that that IN 19613 826 46 it -PRON- PRP 19613 826 47 even even RB 19613 826 48 embraced embrace VBD 19613 826 49 all all DT 19613 826 50 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 826 51 and and CC 19613 826 52 episcopally episcopally RB 19613 826 53 organised organise VBN 19613 826 54 communities community NNS 19613 826 55 within within IN 19613 826 56 those those DT 19613 826 57 bounds bound NNS 19613 826 58 . . . 19613 827 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 827 2 181 181 CD 19613 827 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 827 4 But but CC 19613 827 5 , , , 19613 827 6 further further RB 19613 827 7 , , , 19613 827 8 the the DT 19613 827 9 conditions condition NNS 19613 827 10 of of IN 19613 827 11 the the DT 19613 827 12 confederation confederation NN 19613 827 13 , , , 19613 827 14 which which WDT 19613 827 15 only only RB 19613 827 16 began begin VBD 19613 827 17 to to TO 19613 827 18 be be VB 19613 827 19 realised realise VBN 19613 827 20 in in IN 19613 827 21 the the DT 19613 827 22 full full JJ 19613 827 23 sense sense NN 19613 827 24 in in IN 19613 827 25 the the DT 19613 827 26 days day NNS 19613 827 27 of of IN 19613 827 28 Constantine Constantine NNP 19613 827 29 , , , 19613 827 30 were be VBD 19613 827 31 never never RB 19613 827 32 definitely definitely RB 19613 827 33 formulated formulate VBN 19613 827 34 -- -- : 19613 827 35 before before IN 19613 827 36 the the DT 19613 827 37 fourth fourth JJ 19613 827 38 century century NN 19613 827 39 at at IN 19613 827 40 least least JJS 19613 827 41 . . . 19613 828 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 828 2 182 182 CD 19613 828 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 828 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 828 5 , , , 19613 828 6 the the DT 19613 828 7 idea idea NN 19613 828 8 of of IN 19613 828 9 the the DT 19613 828 10 one one CD 19613 828 11 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 828 12 Church Church NNP 19613 828 13 , , , 19613 828 14 embracing embrace VBG 19613 828 15 all all DT 19613 828 16 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 828 17 and and CC 19613 828 18 founded found VBN 19613 828 19 on on IN 19613 828 20 the the DT 19613 828 21 bishops bishop NNS 19613 828 22 , , , 19613 828 23 was be VBD 19613 828 24 always always RB 19613 828 25 a a DT 19613 828 26 mere mere JJ 19613 828 27 theory theory NN 19613 828 28 . . . 19613 829 1 But but CC 19613 829 2 , , , 19613 829 3 in in IN 19613 829 4 so so RB 19613 829 5 far far RB 19613 829 6 as as IN 19613 829 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 829 8 is be VBZ 19613 829 9 not not RB 19613 829 10 the the DT 19613 829 11 idea idea NN 19613 829 12 , , , 19613 829 13 but but CC 19613 829 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 829 15 realisation realisation NN 19613 829 16 to to IN 19613 829 17 which which WDT 19613 829 18 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 829 19 here here RB 19613 829 20 attaches attach VBZ 19613 829 21 sole sole JJ 19613 829 22 importance importance NN 19613 829 23 , , , 19613 829 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 829 25 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 829 26 conception conception NN 19613 829 27 appears appear VBZ 19613 829 28 to to TO 19613 829 29 be be VB 19613 829 30 refuted refute VBN 19613 829 31 by by IN 19613 829 32 actual actual JJ 19613 829 33 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 829 34 . . . 19613 830 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 830 2 183 183 CD 19613 830 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 830 4 _ _ NNP 19613 830 5 Addendum Addendum NNP 19613 830 6 II._--The II._--The NNP 19613 830 7 idea idea NN 19613 830 8 of of IN 19613 830 9 heresy heresy NN 19613 830 10 is be VBZ 19613 830 11 always always RB 19613 830 12 decided decide VBN 19613 830 13 by by IN 19613 830 14 the the DT 19613 830 15 idea idea NN 19613 830 16 of of IN 19613 830 17 the the DT 19613 830 18 Church Church NNP 19613 830 19 . . . 19613 831 1 The the DT 19613 831 2 designation designation NN 19613 831 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 831 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 831 5 : : : 19613 831 6 hairesis hairesis NN 19613 831 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 831 8 implies imply VBZ 19613 831 9 an an DT 19613 831 10 adherence adherence NN 19613 831 11 to to IN 19613 831 12 something something NN 19613 831 13 self self NN 19613 831 14 - - HYPH 19613 831 15 chosen choose VBN 19613 831 16 in in IN 19613 831 17 opposition opposition NN 19613 831 18 to to IN 19613 831 19 the the DT 19613 831 20 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 831 21 of of IN 19613 831 22 something something NN 19613 831 23 objectively objectively RB 19613 831 24 handed hand VBD 19613 831 25 down down RP 19613 831 26 , , , 19613 831 27 and and CC 19613 831 28 assumes assume VBZ 19613 831 29 that that IN 19613 831 30 this this DT 19613 831 31 is be VBZ 19613 831 32 the the DT 19613 831 33 particular particular JJ 19613 831 34 thing thing NN 19613 831 35 in in IN 19613 831 36 which which WDT 19613 831 37 the the DT 19613 831 38 apostasy apostasy NNP 19613 831 39 consists consist VBZ 19613 831 40 . . . 19613 832 1 Hence hence RB 19613 832 2 all all PDT 19613 832 3 those those DT 19613 832 4 who who WP 19613 832 5 call call VBP 19613 832 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 832 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 832 8 and and CC 19613 832 9 yet yet RB 19613 832 10 do do VBP 19613 832 11 not not RB 19613 832 12 adhere adhere VB 19613 832 13 to to IN 19613 832 14 the the DT 19613 832 15 traditional traditional NNP 19613 832 16 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 832 17 creed creed NNP 19613 832 18 , , , 19613 832 19 but but CC 19613 832 20 give give VB 19613 832 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 832 22 up up RP 19613 832 23 to to IN 19613 832 24 vain vain JJ 19613 832 25 and and CC 19613 832 26 empty empty JJ 19613 832 27 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 832 28 , , , 19613 832 29 are be VBP 19613 832 30 regarded regard VBN 19613 832 31 as as IN 19613 832 32 heretics heretic NNS 19613 832 33 by by IN 19613 832 34 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 832 35 , , , 19613 832 36 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 832 37 , , , 19613 832 38 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 832 39 , , , 19613 832 40 Clement Clement NNP 19613 832 41 , , , 19613 832 42 and and CC 19613 832 43 Origen Origen NNP 19613 832 44 . . . 19613 833 1 These these DT 19613 833 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 833 3 are be VBP 19613 833 4 as as IN 19613 833 5 a a DT 19613 833 6 rule rule NN 19613 833 7 traced trace VBN 19613 833 8 to to IN 19613 833 9 the the DT 19613 833 10 devil devil NN 19613 833 11 , , , 19613 833 12 that that RB 19613 833 13 is is RB 19613 833 14 , , , 19613 833 15 to to IN 19613 833 16 the the DT 19613 833 17 non non JJ 19613 833 18 - - JJ 19613 833 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 833 20 religions religion NNS 19613 833 21 and and CC 19613 833 22 speculations speculation NNS 19613 833 23 , , , 19613 833 24 or or CC 19613 833 25 to to IN 19613 833 26 wilful wilful JJ 19613 833 27 wickedness wickedness NN 19613 833 28 . . . 19613 834 1 Any any DT 19613 834 2 other other JJ 19613 834 3 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 834 4 of of IN 19613 834 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 834 6 origin origin NN 19613 834 7 would would MD 19613 834 8 at at IN 19613 834 9 once once RB 19613 834 10 have have VBP 19613 834 11 been be VBN 19613 834 12 an an DT 19613 834 13 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 834 14 that that IN 19613 834 15 the the DT 19613 834 16 opponents opponent NNS 19613 834 17 of of IN 19613 834 18 the the DT 19613 834 19 Church Church NNP 19613 834 20 had have VBD 19613 834 21 a a DT 19613 834 22 right right NN 19613 834 23 to to IN 19613 834 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 834 25 opinions,[184 opinions,[184 NN 19613 834 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 834 27 and and CC 19613 834 28 such such PDT 19613 834 29 an an DT 19613 834 30 explanation explanation NN 19613 834 31 is be VBZ 19613 834 32 not not RB 19613 834 33 quite quite RB 19613 834 34 foreign foreign JJ 19613 834 35 to to IN 19613 834 36 Origen Origen NNP 19613 834 37 in in IN 19613 834 38 one one CD 19613 834 39 of of IN 19613 834 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 834 41 lines line NNS 19613 834 42 of of IN 19613 834 43 argument argument NN 19613 834 44 . . . 19613 835 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 835 2 185 185 CD 19613 835 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 835 4 Hence hence RB 19613 835 5 the the DT 19613 835 6 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 835 7 party party NN 19613 835 8 were be VBD 19613 835 9 perfectly perfectly RB 19613 835 10 consistent consistent JJ 19613 835 11 in in IN 19613 835 12 attaching attach VBG 19613 835 13 no no DT 19613 835 14 value value NN 19613 835 15 to to IN 19613 835 16 any any DT 19613 835 17 sacrament[186 sacrament[186 NN 19613 835 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 835 19 or or CC 19613 835 20 acts act VBZ 19613 835 21 esteemed esteem VBN 19613 835 22 in in IN 19613 835 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 835 24 own own JJ 19613 835 25 communion communion NN 19613 835 26 , , , 19613 835 27 when when WRB 19613 835 28 these these DT 19613 835 29 were be VBD 19613 835 30 performed perform VBN 19613 835 31 by by IN 19613 835 32 heretics;[187 heretics;[187 NNS 19613 835 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 835 34 and and CC 19613 835 35 this this DT 19613 835 36 was be VBD 19613 835 37 a a DT 19613 835 38 practical practical JJ 19613 835 39 application application NN 19613 835 40 of of IN 19613 835 41 the the DT 19613 835 42 saying saying NN 19613 835 43 that that IN 19613 835 44 the the DT 19613 835 45 devil devil NN 19613 835 46 could could MD 19613 835 47 transform transform VB 19613 835 48 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 835 49 into into IN 19613 835 50 an an DT 19613 835 51 angel angel NN 19613 835 52 of of IN 19613 835 53 light light NN 19613 835 54 . . . 19613 836 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 836 2 188 188 CD 19613 836 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 836 4 But but CC 19613 836 5 the the DT 19613 836 6 Fathers father NNS 19613 836 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 836 8 have have VBP 19613 836 9 named name VBN 19613 836 10 did do VBD 19613 836 11 not not RB 19613 836 12 yet yet RB 19613 836 13 completely completely RB 19613 836 14 identify identify VB 19613 836 15 the the DT 19613 836 16 Church Church NNP 19613 836 17 with with IN 19613 836 18 a a DT 19613 836 19 harmoniously harmoniously RB 19613 836 20 organised organise VBN 19613 836 21 institution institution NN 19613 836 22 . . . 19613 837 1 For for IN 19613 837 2 that that DT 19613 837 3 very very JJ 19613 837 4 reason reason NN 19613 837 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 837 6 do do VBP 19613 837 7 not not RB 19613 837 8 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 837 9 deny deny VB 19613 837 10 the the DT 19613 837 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 837 12 of of IN 19613 837 13 such such JJ 19613 837 14 as as IN 19613 837 15 take take VB 19613 837 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 837 17 stand stand NN 19613 837 18 on on IN 19613 837 19 the the DT 19613 837 20 rule rule NN 19613 837 21 of of IN 19613 837 22 faith faith NN 19613 837 23 , , , 19613 837 24 even even RB 19613 837 25 when when WRB 19613 837 26 these these DT 19613 837 27 for for IN 19613 837 28 various various JJ 19613 837 29 reasons reason NNS 19613 837 30 occupy occupy VBP 19613 837 31 a a DT 19613 837 32 position position NN 19613 837 33 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 837 34 to to IN 19613 837 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 837 36 . . . 19613 838 1 Though though IN 19613 838 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 838 3 are be VBP 19613 838 4 by by IN 19613 838 5 no no DT 19613 838 6 means means NN 19613 838 7 entitled entitle VBN 19613 838 8 to to TO 19613 838 9 say say VB 19613 838 10 that that IN 19613 838 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 838 12 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 838 13 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 838 14 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 838 15 , , , 19613 838 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 838 17 did do VBD 19613 838 18 not not RB 19613 838 19 yet yet RB 19613 838 20 venture venture VB 19613 838 21 to to TO 19613 838 22 reckon reckon VB 19613 838 23 them -PRON- PRP 19613 838 24 simply simply RB 19613 838 25 as as IN 19613 838 26 heretics heretic NNS 19613 838 27 . . . 19613 839 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 839 2 189 189 CD 19613 839 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 839 4 If if IN 19613 839 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 839 6 was be VBD 19613 839 7 desired desire VBN 19613 839 8 to to TO 19613 839 9 get get VB 19613 839 10 rid rid VBN 19613 839 11 of of IN 19613 839 12 these these DT 19613 839 13 , , , 19613 839 14 an an DT 19613 839 15 effort effort NN 19613 839 16 was be VBD 19613 839 17 made make VBN 19613 839 18 to to TO 19613 839 19 impute impute VB 19613 839 20 to to IN 19613 839 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 839 22 some some DT 19613 839 23 deviation deviation NN 19613 839 24 from from IN 19613 839 25 the the DT 19613 839 26 rule rule NN 19613 839 27 of of IN 19613 839 28 faith faith NN 19613 839 29 ; ; : 19613 839 30 and and CC 19613 839 31 under under IN 19613 839 32 this this DT 19613 839 33 pretext pretext NN 19613 839 34 the the DT 19613 839 35 Church Church NNP 19613 839 36 freed free VBD 19613 839 37 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 839 38 from from IN 19613 839 39 the the DT 19613 839 40 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 839 41 and and CC 19613 839 42 the the DT 19613 839 43 Monarchians Monarchians NNPS 19613 839 44 . . . 19613 840 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 840 2 190 190 CD 19613 840 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 840 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 840 5 was be VBD 19613 840 6 the the DT 19613 840 7 first first JJ 19613 840 8 to to TO 19613 840 9 proclaim proclaim VB 19613 840 10 the the DT 19613 840 11 identity identity NN 19613 840 12 of of IN 19613 840 13 heretics heretic NNS 19613 840 14 and and CC 19613 840 15 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 840 16 , , , 19613 840 17 by by IN 19613 840 18 making make VBG 19613 840 19 a a DT 19613 840 20 man man NN 19613 840 21 's 's POS 19613 840 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 840 23 depend depend VB 19613 840 24 on on IN 19613 840 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 840 26 belonging belong VBG 19613 840 27 to to IN 19613 840 28 the the DT 19613 840 29 great great JJ 19613 840 30 episcopal episcopal NNP 19613 840 31 Church Church NNP 19613 840 32 confederation confederation NN 19613 840 33 . . . 19613 841 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 841 2 191 191 CD 19613 841 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 841 4 But but CC 19613 841 5 , , , 19613 841 6 both both DT 19613 841 7 in in IN 19613 841 8 East East NNP 19613 841 9 and and CC 19613 841 10 West West NNP 19613 841 11 , , , 19613 841 12 this this DT 19613 841 13 theory theory NN 19613 841 14 of of IN 19613 841 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 841 16 became become VBD 19613 841 17 established establish VBN 19613 841 18 only only RB 19613 841 19 by by IN 19613 841 20 very very RB 19613 841 21 imperceptible imperceptible JJ 19613 841 22 degrees degree NNS 19613 841 23 , , , 19613 841 24 and and CC 19613 841 25 indeed indeed RB 19613 841 26 , , , 19613 841 27 strictly strictly RB 19613 841 28 speaking speak VBG 19613 841 29 , , , 19613 841 30 the the DT 19613 841 31 process process NN 19613 841 32 was be VBD 19613 841 33 never never RB 19613 841 34 completed complete VBN 19613 841 35 at at RB 19613 841 36 all all RB 19613 841 37 . . . 19613 842 1 The the DT 19613 842 2 distinction distinction NN 19613 842 3 between between IN 19613 842 4 heretics heretic NNS 19613 842 5 and and CC 19613 842 6 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 842 7 was be VBD 19613 842 8 preserved preserve VBN 19613 842 9 , , , 19613 842 10 because because IN 19613 842 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 842 12 prevented prevent VBD 19613 842 13 a a DT 19613 842 14 public public JJ 19613 842 15 denial denial NN 19613 842 16 of of IN 19613 842 17 the the DT 19613 842 18 old old JJ 19613 842 19 principles principle NNS 19613 842 20 , , , 19613 842 21 because because IN 19613 842 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 842 23 was be VBD 19613 842 24 advisable advisable JJ 19613 842 25 on on IN 19613 842 26 political political JJ 19613 842 27 grounds ground NNS 19613 842 28 to to TO 19613 842 29 treat treat VB 19613 842 30 certain certain JJ 19613 842 31 schismatic schismatic JJ 19613 842 32 communities community NNS 19613 842 33 with with IN 19613 842 34 indulgence indulgence NN 19613 842 35 , , , 19613 842 36 and and CC 19613 842 37 because because IN 19613 842 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 842 39 was be VBD 19613 842 40 always always RB 19613 842 41 possible possible JJ 19613 842 42 in in IN 19613 842 43 case case NN 19613 842 44 of of IN 19613 842 45 need need NN 19613 842 46 to to TO 19613 842 47 prove prove VB 19613 842 48 heresy heresy NN 19613 842 49 against against IN 19613 842 50 the the DT 19613 842 51 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 842 52 . . . 19613 843 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 843 2 192 192 CD 19613 843 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 843 4 _ _ NNP 19613 843 5 Addendum Addendum NNP 19613 843 6 III._--As III._--As . 19613 843 7 soon soon RB 19613 843 8 as as IN 19613 843 9 the the DT 19613 843 10 empiric empiric NN 19613 843 11 Church Church NNP 19613 843 12 ruled rule VBD 19613 843 13 by by IN 19613 843 14 the the DT 19613 843 15 bishops bishop NNS 19613 843 16 was be VBD 19613 843 17 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 843 18 to to TO 19613 843 19 be be VB 19613 843 20 the the DT 19613 843 21 foundation foundation NN 19613 843 22 of of IN 19613 843 23 the the DT 19613 843 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 843 25 religion religion NN 19613 843 26 , , , 19613 843 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 843 28 have have VBP 19613 843 29 the the DT 19613 843 30 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 843 31 premises premise NNS 19613 843 32 for for IN 19613 843 33 the the DT 19613 843 34 conception conception NN 19613 843 35 that that IN 19613 843 36 everything everything NN 19613 843 37 progressively progressively RB 19613 843 38 adopted adopt VBN 19613 843 39 by by IN 19613 843 40 the the DT 19613 843 41 Church Church NNP 19613 843 42 , , , 19613 843 43 all all DT 19613 843 44 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 843 45 functions function NNS 19613 843 46 , , , 19613 843 47 institutions institution NNS 19613 843 48 , , , 19613 843 49 and and CC 19613 843 50 liturgy liturgy NN 19613 843 51 , , , 19613 843 52 in in IN 19613 843 53 short short JJ 19613 843 54 , , , 19613 843 55 all all DT 19613 843 56 her -PRON- PRP 19613 843 57 continuously continuously RB 19613 843 58 changing change VBG 19613 843 59 arrangements arrangement NNS 19613 843 60 were be VBD 19613 843 61 holy holy JJ 19613 843 62 and and CC 19613 843 63 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 843 64 . . . 19613 844 1 But but CC 19613 844 2 the the DT 19613 844 3 courage courage NN 19613 844 4 to to TO 19613 844 5 draw draw VB 19613 844 6 all all PDT 19613 844 7 the the DT 19613 844 8 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 844 9 here here RB 19613 844 10 was be VBD 19613 844 11 restrained restrain VBN 19613 844 12 by by IN 19613 844 13 the the DT 19613 844 14 fact fact NN 19613 844 15 that that IN 19613 844 16 certain certain JJ 19613 844 17 portions portion NNS 19613 844 18 of of IN 19613 844 19 tradition tradition NN 19613 844 20 , , , 19613 844 21 such such JJ 19613 844 22 as as IN 19613 844 23 the the DT 19613 844 24 New New NNP 19613 844 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 844 26 canon canon NN 19613 844 27 of of IN 19613 844 28 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 844 29 and and CC 19613 844 30 the the DT 19613 844 31 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 844 32 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 844 33 , , , 19613 844 34 had have VBD 19613 844 35 been be VBN 19613 844 36 once once RB 19613 844 37 for for IN 19613 844 38 all all RB 19613 844 39 exalted exalted JJ 19613 844 40 to to IN 19613 844 41 an an DT 19613 844 42 unapproachable unapproachable JJ 19613 844 43 height height NN 19613 844 44 . . . 19613 845 1 Hence hence RB 19613 845 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 845 3 was be VBD 19613 845 4 only only RB 19613 845 5 with with IN 19613 845 6 slowness slowness NN 19613 845 7 and and CC 19613 845 8 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 845 9 that that WDT 19613 845 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 845 11 accepted accept VBD 19613 845 12 the the DT 19613 845 13 inferences inference NNS 19613 845 14 from from IN 19613 845 15 the the DT 19613 845 16 idea idea NN 19613 845 17 of of IN 19613 845 18 the the DT 19613 845 19 Church Church NNP 19613 845 20 in in IN 19613 845 21 the the DT 19613 845 22 remaining remain VBG 19613 845 23 directions direction NNS 19613 845 24 , , , 19613 845 25 and and CC 19613 845 26 these these DT 19613 845 27 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 845 28 always always RB 19613 845 29 continued continue VBD 19613 845 30 to to TO 19613 845 31 be be VB 19613 845 32 hampered hamper VBN 19613 845 33 with with IN 19613 845 34 some some DT 19613 845 35 degree degree NN 19613 845 36 of of IN 19613 845 37 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 845 38 . . . 19613 846 1 The the DT 19613 846 2 idea idea NN 19613 846 3 of of IN 19613 846 4 the the DT 19613 846 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 846 6 Greek greek JJ 19613 846 7 : : : 19613 846 8 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 846 9 agraphos agraphos NNP 19613 846 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 846 11 ; ; , 19613 846 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 846 13 unwritten unwritten VB 19613 846 14 tradition tradition NN 19613 846 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 846 16 ; ; : 19613 846 17 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 846 18 , , , 19613 846 19 that that IN 19613 846 20 every every DT 19613 846 21 custom custom NN 19613 846 22 , , , 19613 846 23 however however RB 19613 846 24 recent recent JJ 19613 846 25 , , , 19613 846 26 within within IN 19613 846 27 the the DT 19613 846 28 sphere sphere NN 19613 846 29 of of IN 19613 846 30 outward outward JJ 19613 846 31 regulations regulation NNS 19613 846 32 , , , 19613 846 33 of of IN 19613 846 34 public public JJ 19613 846 35 worship worship NN 19613 846 36 , , , 19613 846 37 discipline discipline NN 19613 846 38 , , , 19613 846 39 etc etc FW 19613 846 40 . . . 19613 846 41 , , , 19613 846 42 is be VBZ 19613 846 43 as as RB 19613 846 44 holy holy JJ 19613 846 45 and and CC 19613 846 46 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 846 47 as as IN 19613 846 48 the the DT 19613 846 49 Bible Bible NNP 19613 846 50 and and CC 19613 846 51 the the DT 19613 846 52 " " `` 19613 846 53 faith faith NN 19613 846 54 " " '' 19613 846 55 , , , 19613 846 56 never never RB 19613 846 57 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 846 58 in in IN 19613 846 59 gaining gain VBG 19613 846 60 complete complete JJ 19613 846 61 acceptance acceptance NN 19613 846 62 . . . 19613 847 1 In in IN 19613 847 2 this this DT 19613 847 3 case case NN 19613 847 4 , , , 19613 847 5 complicated complicated JJ 19613 847 6 , , , 19613 847 7 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 847 8 , , , 19613 847 9 and and CC 19613 847 10 indistinct indistinct JJ 19613 847 11 assumptions assumption NNS 19613 847 12 were be VBD 19613 847 13 the the DT 19613 847 14 result result NN 19613 847 15 . . . 19613 848 1 Footnotes footnote NNS 19613 848 2 : : : 19613 848 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 848 4 Footnote footnote NN 19613 848 5 20 20 CD 19613 848 6 : : : 19613 848 7 In in IN 19613 848 8 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 848 9 the the DT 19613 848 10 predicate predicate NN 19613 848 11 " " `` 19613 848 12 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 848 13 " " '' 19613 848 14 contains contain VBZ 19613 848 15 no no DT 19613 848 16 element element NN 19613 848 17 that that WDT 19613 848 18 signifies signify VBZ 19613 848 19 a a DT 19613 848 20 secularising secularising NN 19613 848 21 of of IN 19613 848 22 the the DT 19613 848 23 Church Church NNP 19613 848 24 . . . 19613 849 1 " " `` 19613 849 2 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 849 3 " " '' 19613 849 4 originally originally RB 19613 849 5 means mean VBZ 19613 849 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 849 7 in in IN 19613 849 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 849 9 totality totality NN 19613 849 10 as as IN 19613 849 11 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 849 12 with with IN 19613 849 13 single single JJ 19613 849 14 congregations congregation NNS 19613 849 15 . . . 19613 850 1 Hence hence RB 19613 850 2 the the DT 19613 850 3 concepts concept NNS 19613 850 4 " " `` 19613 850 5 all all DT 19613 850 6 communities community NNS 19613 850 7 " " '' 19613 850 8 and and CC 19613 850 9 the the DT 19613 850 10 " " `` 19613 850 11 universal universal JJ 19613 850 12 Church Church NNP 19613 850 13 " " '' 19613 850 14 are be VBP 19613 850 15 identical identical JJ 19613 850 16 . . . 19613 851 1 But but CC 19613 851 2 from from IN 19613 851 3 the the DT 19613 851 4 beginning beginning NN 19613 851 5 there there EX 19613 851 6 was be VBD 19613 851 7 a a DT 19613 851 8 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 851 9 element element NN 19613 851 10 in in IN 19613 851 11 the the DT 19613 851 12 concept concept NN 19613 851 13 of of IN 19613 851 14 the the DT 19613 851 15 universal universal JJ 19613 851 16 Church Church NNP 19613 851 17 , , , 19613 851 18 in in IN 19613 851 19 so so RB 19613 851 20 far far RB 19613 851 21 as as IN 19613 851 22 the the DT 19613 851 23 latter latter NN 19613 851 24 was be VBD 19613 851 25 conceived conceive VBN 19613 851 26 to to TO 19613 851 27 have have VB 19613 851 28 been be VBN 19613 851 29 spread spread VBN 19613 851 30 over over IN 19613 851 31 the the DT 19613 851 32 whole whole JJ 19613 851 33 earth earth NN 19613 851 34 by by IN 19613 851 35 the the DT 19613 851 36 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 851 37 ; ; : 19613 851 38 an an DT 19613 851 39 idea idea NN 19613 851 40 which which WDT 19613 851 41 involved involve VBD 19613 851 42 the the DT 19613 851 43 conviction conviction NN 19613 851 44 that that IN 19613 851 45 only only RB 19613 851 46 that that DT 19613 851 47 could could MD 19613 851 48 be be VB 19613 851 49 true true JJ 19613 851 50 which which WDT 19613 851 51 was be VBD 19613 851 52 found find VBN 19613 851 53 _ _ NNP 19613 851 54 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 851 55 _ _ NNP 19613 851 56 in in IN 19613 851 57 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 851 58 . . . 19613 852 1 Consequently consequently RB 19613 852 2 , , , 19613 852 3 " " `` 19613 852 4 entire entire JJ 19613 852 5 or or CC 19613 852 6 universal universal JJ 19613 852 7 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 852 8 , , , 19613 852 9 " " '' 19613 852 10 " " `` 19613 852 11 the the DT 19613 852 12 Church Church NNP 19613 852 13 spread spread VBD 19613 852 14 over over IN 19613 852 15 the the DT 19613 852 16 whole whole JJ 19613 852 17 earth earth NN 19613 852 18 , , , 19613 852 19 " " '' 19613 852 20 and and CC 19613 852 21 " " `` 19613 852 22 the the DT 19613 852 23 true true JJ 19613 852 24 Church Church NNP 19613 852 25 " " '' 19613 852 26 were be VBD 19613 852 27 regarded regard VBN 19613 852 28 as as IN 19613 852 29 identical identical JJ 19613 852 30 conceptions conception NNS 19613 852 31 . . . 19613 853 1 In in IN 19613 853 2 this this DT 19613 853 3 way way NN 19613 853 4 the the DT 19613 853 5 concept concept NN 19613 853 6 " " `` 19613 853 7 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 853 8 " " '' 19613 853 9 became become VBD 19613 853 10 a a DT 19613 853 11 pregnant pregnant JJ 19613 853 12 one one NN 19613 853 13 , , , 19613 853 14 and and CC 19613 853 15 finally finally RB 19613 853 16 received receive VBD 19613 853 17 a a DT 19613 853 18 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 853 19 and and CC 19613 853 20 political political JJ 19613 853 21 content content NN 19613 853 22 . . . 19613 854 1 As as IN 19613 854 2 this this DT 19613 854 3 result result NN 19613 854 4 actually actually RB 19613 854 5 took take VBD 19613 854 6 place place NN 19613 854 7 , , , 19613 854 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 854 9 is be VBZ 19613 854 10 not not RB 19613 854 11 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 19613 854 12 to to TO 19613 854 13 speak speak VB 19613 854 14 of of IN 19613 854 15 pre pre JJ 19613 854 16 - - JJ 19613 854 17 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 854 18 and and CC 19613 854 19 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 854 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 854 21 . . . 19613 854 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 855 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 855 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 855 3 21 21 CD 19613 855 4 : : : 19613 855 5 _ _ NNP 19613 855 6 Translator Translator NNP 19613 855 7 's 's POS 19613 855 8 note note NN 19613 855 9 . . . 19613 855 10 _ _ NNP 19613 855 11 The the DT 19613 855 12 following follow VBG 19613 855 13 is be VBZ 19613 855 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 855 15 's 's POS 19613 855 16 Latin Latin NNP 19613 855 17 as as IN 19613 855 18 given give VBN 19613 855 19 by by IN 19613 855 20 Professor Professor NNP 19613 855 21 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 855 22 : : : 19613 855 23 Cap Cap NNP 19613 855 24 . . . 19613 856 1 21 21 CD 19613 856 2 : : : 19613 856 3 " " `` 19613 856 4 Constat constat JJ 19613 856 5 omnem omnem NN 19613 856 6 doctrinam doctrinam NN 19613 856 7 quæ quæ NNP 19613 856 8 cum cum NNP 19613 856 9 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 856 10 apostolicis apostolicis NNP 19613 856 11 matricibus matricibus NNP 19613 856 12 et et NNP 19613 856 13 originalibus originalibus NNP 19613 856 14 fidei fidei NNP 19613 856 15 conspiret conspiret NNP 19613 856 16 veritati veritati NNP 19613 856 17 deputandam deputandam NNP 19613 856 18 , , , 19613 856 19 i -PRON- PRP 19613 856 20 d d VBD 19613 856 21 sine sine VB 19613 856 22 dubio dubio NNP 19613 856 23 tenentem tenentem NNP 19613 856 24 quod quod NNP 19613 856 25 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 856 26 ab ab NNP 19613 856 27 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 856 28 , , , 19613 856 29 apostoli apostoli VBZ 19613 856 30 a a DT 19613 856 31 Christo Christo NNP 19613 856 32 , , , 19613 856 33 Christus Christus NNP 19613 856 34 a a DT 19613 856 35 deo deo NNP 19613 856 36 accepit accepit NN 19613 856 37 . . . 19613 856 38 " " '' 19613 857 1 Cap Cap NNP 19613 857 2 . . . 19613 858 1 36 36 CD 19613 858 2 : : : 19613 858 3 " " `` 19613 858 4 Videamus Videamus NNP 19613 858 5 quid quid NNP 19613 858 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 858 7 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 858 8 Romanensis Romanensis NNP 19613 858 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 858 10 didicerit didicerit NN 19613 858 11 , , , 19613 858 12 quid quid NNP 19613 858 13 docuerit docuerit NNP 19613 858 14 , , , 19613 858 15 cum cum NNP 19613 858 16 Africanis Africanis NNP 19613 858 17 quoque quoque NNP 19613 858 18 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 858 19 contesserarit contesserarit NNP 19613 858 20 . . . 19613 859 1 Unum Unum NNP 19613 859 2 deum deum NNP 19613 859 3 dominum dominum NN 19613 859 4 novit novit NN 19613 859 5 , , , 19613 859 6 creatorem creatorem VB 19613 859 7 universitatis universitatis NN 19613 859 8 , , , 19613 859 9 et et NNP 19613 859 10 Christum Christum NNP 19613 859 11 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 859 12 ex ex NNP 19613 859 13 virgine virgine JJ 19613 859 14 Maria Maria NNP 19613 859 15 filium filium NN 19613 859 16 dei dei NNP 19613 859 17 creatoris creatoris NNP 19613 859 18 , , , 19613 859 19 et et NNP 19613 859 20 carnis carnis NNP 19613 859 21 resurrectionem resurrectionem NNP 19613 859 22 ; ; : 19613 859 23 legem legem NNP 19613 859 24 et et NNP 19613 859 25 prophetas prophetas NNP 19613 859 26 cum cum NNP 19613 859 27 evangelicis evangelicis NNP 19613 859 28 et et NNP 19613 859 29 apostolicis apostolicis NNP 19613 859 30 litteris litteris NNP 19613 859 31 miscet miscet NNP 19613 859 32 ; ; , 19613 859 33 inde inde NNP 19613 859 34 potat potat NNP 19613 859 35 fidem fidem NNP 19613 859 36 , , , 19613 859 37 eam eam NNP 19613 859 38 aqua aqua NNP 19613 859 39 signat signat NNP 19613 859 40 , , , 19613 859 41 sancto sancto NNP 19613 859 42 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 859 43 vestit vestit NNP 19613 859 44 , , , 19613 859 45 eucharistia eucharistia NNP 19613 859 46 pascit pascit NNP 19613 859 47 , , , 19613 859 48 martyrium martyrium NN 19613 859 49 exhortatur exhortatur NN 19613 859 50 , , , 19613 859 51 et et NNP 19613 859 52 ita ita NNP 19613 859 53 adversus adversus NNP 19613 859 54 hanc hanc NNP 19613 859 55 institutionem institutionem NNP 19613 859 56 neminem neminem NNP 19613 859 57 recipit recipit NNP 19613 859 58 . . . 19613 859 59 " " '' 19613 860 1 Chap Chap NNP 19613 860 2 . . . 19613 861 1 32 32 CD 19613 861 2 : : : 19613 861 3 " " `` 19613 861 4 Evolvant evolvant JJ 19613 861 5 ordinem ordinem NN 19613 861 6 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 861 7 suorum suorum NNP 19613 861 8 , , , 19613 861 9 ita ita NNP 19613 861 10 per per IN 19613 861 11 successionem successionem NNP 19613 861 12 ab ab NNP 19613 861 13 initio initio NNP 19613 861 14 decurrentem decurrentem NNP 19613 861 15 , , , 19613 861 16 ut ut NNP 19613 861 17 primus primus NNP 19613 861 18 ille ille NNP 19613 861 19 episcopus episcopus NNP 19613 861 20 aliquem aliquem NNP 19613 861 21 ex ex NNP 19613 861 22 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 861 23 vel vel NNP 19613 861 24 apostolicis apostolicis NNP 19613 861 25 viris viris NNP 19613 861 26 , , , 19613 861 27 qui qui NNP 19613 861 28 tamen tamen NNPS 19613 861 29 cum cum NNP 19613 861 30 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 861 31 perseveravit perseveravit NNP 19613 861 32 , , , 19613 861 33 habuerit habuerit NNP 19613 861 34 auctorem auctorem NNP 19613 861 35 et et NNP 19613 861 36 antecessorem antecessorem NN 19613 861 37 . . . 19613 861 38 " " '' 19613 861 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 862 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 862 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 862 3 22 22 CD 19613 862 4 : : : 19613 862 5 None none NN 19613 862 6 of of IN 19613 862 7 the the DT 19613 862 8 three three CD 19613 862 9 standards standard NNS 19613 862 10 , , , 19613 862 11 for for IN 19613 862 12 instance instance NN 19613 862 13 , , , 19613 862 14 were be VBD 19613 862 15 in in IN 19613 862 16 the the DT 19613 862 17 original original NN 19613 862 18 of of IN 19613 862 19 the the DT 19613 862 20 first first JJ 19613 862 21 six six CD 19613 862 22 books book NNS 19613 862 23 of of IN 19613 862 24 the the DT 19613 862 25 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 862 26 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 862 27 , , , 19613 862 28 which which WDT 19613 862 29 belong belong VBP 19613 862 30 to to IN 19613 862 31 the the DT 19613 862 32 third third JJ 19613 862 33 century century NN 19613 862 34 and and CC 19613 862 35 are be VBP 19613 862 36 of of IN 19613 862 37 Syrian syrian JJ 19613 862 38 origin origin NN 19613 862 39 ; ; : 19613 862 40 but but CC 19613 862 41 instead instead RB 19613 862 42 of of IN 19613 862 43 them -PRON- PRP 19613 862 44 the the DT 19613 862 45 Old Old NNP 19613 862 46 Testament Testament NNP 19613 862 47 and and CC 19613 862 48 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 862 49 on on IN 19613 862 50 the the DT 19613 862 51 one one CD 19613 862 52 hand hand NN 19613 862 53 , , , 19613 862 54 and and CC 19613 862 55 the the DT 19613 862 56 bishop bishop NN 19613 862 57 , , , 19613 862 58 as as IN 19613 862 59 the the DT 19613 862 60 God God NNP 19613 862 61 of of IN 19613 862 62 the the DT 19613 862 63 community community NN 19613 862 64 , , , 19613 862 65 on on IN 19613 862 66 the the DT 19613 862 67 other other JJ 19613 862 68 , , , 19613 862 69 are be VBP 19613 862 70 taken take VBN 19613 862 71 as as IN 19613 862 72 authorities authority NNS 19613 862 73 . . . 19613 862 74 ] ] -RRB- 19613 863 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 863 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 863 3 23 23 CD 19613 863 4 : : : 19613 863 5 See see VB 19613 863 6 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 863 7 , , , 19613 863 8 Glaubensregel Glaubensregel NNP 19613 863 9 und und VBD 19613 863 10 Taufbekenntniss Taufbekenntniss NNP 19613 863 11 in in IN 19613 863 12 der der NN 19613 863 13 alten alten NNP 19613 863 14 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 863 15 in in IN 19613 863 16 the the DT 19613 863 17 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 863 18 f. f. NN 19613 863 19 Kirchl Kirchl NNP 19613 863 20 . . . 19613 864 1 Wissensch Wissensch NNP 19613 864 2 . . . 19613 865 1 u. u. NNP 19613 865 2 Kirchl Kirchl NNP 19613 865 3 . . . 19613 866 1 Leben Leben NNP 19613 866 2 , , , 19613 866 3 1881 1881 CD 19613 866 4 , , , 19613 866 5 Part Part NNP 19613 866 6 6 6 CD 19613 866 7 , , , 19613 866 8 p. p. NN 19613 866 9 302 302 CD 19613 866 10 ff ff NNP 19613 866 11 . . NNP 19613 866 12 , , , 19613 866 13 especially especially RB 19613 866 14 p. p. NN 19613 866 15 314 314 CD 19613 866 16 ff ff NN 19613 866 17 . . . 19613 867 1 In in IN 19613 867 2 the the DT 19613 867 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 867 4 of of IN 19613 867 5 Jude Jude NNP 19613 867 6 , , , 19613 867 7 v. v. CC 19613 867 8 3 3 CD 19613 867 9 , , , 19613 867 10 mention mention NN 19613 867 11 is be VBZ 19613 867 12 made make VBN 19613 867 13 of of IN 19613 867 14 the the DT 19613 867 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 867 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 867 17 : : : 19613 867 18 hapax hapax NNP 19613 867 19 paradotheisa paradotheisa NNP 19613 867 20 tois tois NNP 19613 867 21 hagiois hagiois NNP 19613 867 22 pistis pistis NNP 19613 867 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 867 24 , , , 19613 867 25 and and CC 19613 867 26 in in IN 19613 867 27 v. v. IN 19613 867 28 20 20 CD 19613 867 29 of of IN 19613 867 30 " " `` 19613 867 31 building build VBG 19613 867 32 yourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 867 33 up up RP 19613 867 34 in in IN 19613 867 35 your -PRON- PRP$ 19613 867 36 most most RBS 19613 867 37 holy holy JJ 19613 867 38 faith faith NN 19613 867 39 . . . 19613 867 40 " " '' 19613 868 1 See see VB 19613 868 2 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 868 3 , , , 19613 868 4 ep ep NNP 19613 868 5 . . . 19613 869 1 III iii CD 19613 869 2 . . . 19613 870 1 2 2 LS 19613 870 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 870 3 also also RB 19613 870 4 VII VII NNP 19613 870 5 . . . 19613 871 1 2 2 LS 19613 871 2 ; ; : 19613 871 3 II II NNP 19613 871 4 . . . 19613 872 1 1 1 LS 19613 872 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 872 3 . . . 19613 873 1 In in IN 19613 873 2 either either DT 19613 873 3 case case NN 19613 873 4 the the DT 19613 873 5 expressions expression NNS 19613 873 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 873 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 873 8 : : : 19613 873 9 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 873 10 tês tês NNP 19613 873 11 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 873 12 , , , 19613 873 13 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 873 14 tês tês NNP 19613 873 15 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 873 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 873 17 , , , 19613 873 18 or or CC 19613 873 19 the the DT 19613 873 20 like like JJ 19613 873 21 , , , 19613 873 22 might may MD 19613 873 23 stand stand VB 19613 873 24 for for IN 19613 873 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 873 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 873 27 : : : 19613 873 28 pistis pistis NN 19613 873 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 873 30 , , , 19613 873 31 for for IN 19613 873 32 the the DT 19613 873 33 faith faith NN 19613 873 34 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 873 35 is be VBZ 19613 873 36 primarily primarily RB 19613 873 37 the the DT 19613 873 38 canon canon NN 19613 873 39 ; ; : 19613 873 40 but but CC 19613 873 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 873 42 is be VBZ 19613 873 43 the the DT 19613 873 44 canon canon NN 19613 873 45 only only RB 19613 873 46 in in RB 19613 873 47 so so RB 19613 873 48 far far RB 19613 873 49 as as IN 19613 873 50 it -PRON- PRP 19613 873 51 is be VBZ 19613 873 52 comprehensible comprehensible JJ 19613 873 53 and and CC 19613 873 54 plainly plainly RB 19613 873 55 defined define VBN 19613 873 56 . . . 19613 874 1 Here here RB 19613 874 2 lies lie VBZ 19613 874 3 the the DT 19613 874 4 transition transition NN 19613 874 5 to to IN 19613 874 6 a a DT 19613 874 7 new new JJ 19613 874 8 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 874 9 of of IN 19613 874 10 the the DT 19613 874 11 conception conception NN 19613 874 12 of of IN 19613 874 13 a a DT 19613 874 14 standard standard NN 19613 874 15 in in IN 19613 874 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 874 17 relation relation NN 19613 874 18 to to IN 19613 874 19 the the DT 19613 874 20 faith faith NN 19613 874 21 . . . 19613 875 1 Voigt Voigt NNP 19613 875 2 has have VBZ 19613 875 3 published publish VBN 19613 875 4 an an DT 19613 875 5 excellent excellent JJ 19613 875 6 investigation investigation NN 19613 875 7 of of IN 19613 875 8 the the DT 19613 875 9 concept concept NN 19613 875 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 875 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 875 12 : : : 19613 875 13 ho ho NNP 19613 875 14 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 875 15 tês tês NNP 19613 875 16 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 875 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 875 18 cum cum NNP 19613 875 19 synonymis synonymis NN 19613 875 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 875 21 Eine Eine NNP 19613 875 22 verschollene verschollene NN 19613 875 23 Urkunde Urkunde NNP 19613 875 24 des des NNP 19613 875 25 antimont antimont NN 19613 875 26 . . . 19613 876 1 Kampfes Kampfes NNP 19613 876 2 , , , 19613 876 3 1891 1891 CD 19613 876 4 , , , 19613 876 5 pp pp NNP 19613 876 6 . . . 19613 877 1 184 184 CD 19613 877 2 - - SYM 19613 877 3 205 205 CD 19613 877 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 877 5 . . . 19613 877 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 878 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 878 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 878 3 24 24 CD 19613 878 4 : : : 19613 878 5 In in IN 19613 878 6 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 878 7 , , , 19613 878 8 Mand Mand NNP 19613 878 9 . . . 19613 879 1 I. I. NNP 19613 879 2 , , , 19613 879 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 879 4 find find VBP 19613 879 5 a a DT 19613 879 6 still still RB 19613 879 7 shorter short JJR 19613 879 8 formula formula NN 19613 879 9 which which WDT 19613 879 10 only only RB 19613 879 11 contains contain VBZ 19613 879 12 the the DT 19613 879 13 Confession Confession NNP 19613 879 14 of of IN 19613 879 15 the the DT 19613 879 16 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 879 17 of of IN 19613 879 18 God God NNP 19613 879 19 , , , 19613 879 20 who who WP 19613 879 21 created create VBD 19613 879 22 the the DT 19613 879 23 world world NN 19613 879 24 , , , 19613 879 25 that that WDT 19613 879 26 is be VBZ 19613 879 27 the the DT 19613 879 28 formula formula NN 19613 879 29 [ [ -LRB- 19613 879 30 Greek Greek NNP 19613 879 31 : : : 19613 879 32 pisteôu pisteôu NNP 19613 879 33 eis eis NNP 19613 879 34 hena hena NNP 19613 879 35 theon theon NNP 19613 879 36 pantakratora pantakratora NNP 19613 879 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 879 38 , , , 19613 879 39 which which WDT 19613 879 40 did do VBD 19613 879 41 not not RB 19613 879 42 originate originate VB 19613 879 43 with with IN 19613 879 44 the the DT 19613 879 45 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 879 46 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 879 47 . . . 19613 880 1 But but CC 19613 880 2 though though IN 19613 880 3 at at IN 19613 880 4 first first RB 19613 880 5 the the DT 19613 880 6 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 880 7 may may MD 19613 880 8 have have VB 19613 880 9 been be VBN 19613 880 10 the the DT 19613 880 11 only only JJ 19613 880 12 dogma dogma NN 19613 880 13 in in IN 19613 880 14 the the DT 19613 880 15 strict strict JJ 19613 880 16 sense sense NN 19613 880 17 , , , 19613 880 18 the the DT 19613 880 19 mission mission NN 19613 880 20 of of IN 19613 880 21 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 880 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 880 23 beyond beyond IN 19613 880 24 doubt doubt NN 19613 880 25 occupied occupy VBD 19613 880 26 a a DT 19613 880 27 place place NN 19613 880 28 alongside alongside IN 19613 880 29 of of IN 19613 880 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 880 31 from from IN 19613 880 32 the the DT 19613 880 33 beginning beginning NN 19613 880 34 ; ; : 19613 880 35 and and CC 19613 880 36 the the DT 19613 880 37 new new JJ 19613 880 38 religion religion NN 19613 880 39 was be VBD 19613 880 40 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 19613 880 41 without without IN 19613 880 42 this this DT 19613 880 43 . . . 19613 880 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 881 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 881 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 881 3 25 25 CD 19613 881 4 : : : 19613 881 5 See see VB 19613 881 6 on on IN 19613 881 7 this this DT 19613 881 8 point point NN 19613 881 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 881 10 , , , 19613 881 11 index index NN 19613 881 12 to to IN 19613 881 13 Otto Otto NNP 19613 881 14 's 's POS 19613 881 15 edition edition NN 19613 881 16 . . . 19613 882 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 882 2 is be VBZ 19613 882 3 not not RB 19613 882 4 surprising surprising JJ 19613 882 5 that that IN 19613 882 6 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 882 7 similar similar JJ 19613 882 8 to to IN 19613 882 9 those those DT 19613 882 10 used use VBN 19613 882 11 at at IN 19613 882 12 baptism baptism NN 19613 882 13 were be VBD 19613 882 14 employed employ VBN 19613 882 15 in in IN 19613 882 16 the the DT 19613 882 17 exorcism exorcism NN 19613 882 18 of of IN 19613 882 19 demons demon NNS 19613 882 20 . . . 19613 883 1 However however RB 19613 883 2 , , , 19613 883 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 883 4 can can MD 19613 883 5 not not RB 19613 883 6 immediately immediately RB 19613 883 7 infer infer VB 19613 883 8 from from IN 19613 883 9 the the DT 19613 883 10 latter latter JJ 19613 883 11 what what WP 19613 883 12 was be VBD 19613 883 13 the the DT 19613 883 14 wording wording NN 19613 883 15 of of IN 19613 883 16 the the DT 19613 883 17 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 883 18 confession confession NN 19613 883 19 . . . 19613 884 1 Though though IN 19613 884 2 , , , 19613 884 3 for for IN 19613 884 4 example example NN 19613 884 5 , , , 19613 884 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 884 7 is be VBZ 19613 884 8 an an DT 19613 884 9 established establish VBN 19613 884 10 fact fact NN 19613 884 11 that that IN 19613 884 12 in in IN 19613 884 13 Justin Justin NNP 19613 884 14 's 's POS 19613 884 15 time time NN 19613 884 16 demons demon NNS 19613 884 17 were be VBD 19613 884 18 exorcised exorcise VBN 19613 884 19 with with IN 19613 884 20 the the DT 19613 884 21 words word NNS 19613 884 22 : : : 19613 884 23 " " `` 19613 884 24 In in IN 19613 884 25 the the DT 19613 884 26 name name NN 19613 884 27 of of IN 19613 884 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 884 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 884 30 who who WP 19613 884 31 was be VBD 19613 884 32 crucified crucify VBN 19613 884 33 under under IN 19613 884 34 Pontius Pontius NNP 19613 884 35 Pilate Pilate NNP 19613 884 36 , , , 19613 884 37 " " `` 19613 884 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 884 39 does do VBZ 19613 884 40 not not RB 19613 884 41 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 884 42 follow follow VB 19613 884 43 from from IN 19613 884 44 this this DT 19613 884 45 that that IN 19613 884 46 these these DT 19613 884 47 words word NNS 19613 884 48 were be VBD 19613 884 49 also also RB 19613 884 50 found find VBN 19613 884 51 in in IN 19613 884 52 the the DT 19613 884 53 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 884 54 confession confession NN 19613 884 55 . . . 19613 885 1 The the DT 19613 885 2 sign sign NN 19613 885 3 of of IN 19613 885 4 the the DT 19613 885 5 cross cross NN 19613 885 6 was be VBD 19613 885 7 made make VBN 19613 885 8 over over IN 19613 885 9 those those DT 19613 885 10 possessed possess VBN 19613 885 11 by by IN 19613 885 12 demons demon NNS 19613 885 13 ; ; : 19613 885 14 hence hence RB 19613 885 15 nothing nothing NN 19613 885 16 was be VBD 19613 885 17 more more RBR 19613 885 18 natural natural JJ 19613 885 19 than than IN 19613 885 20 that that IN 19613 885 21 these these DT 19613 885 22 words word NNS 19613 885 23 should should MD 19613 885 24 be be VB 19613 885 25 spoken speak VBN 19613 885 26 . . . 19613 886 1 Hence hence RB 19613 886 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 886 3 are be VBP 19613 886 4 not not RB 19613 886 5 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 886 6 borrowed borrow VBN 19613 886 7 from from IN 19613 886 8 a a DT 19613 886 9 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 886 10 confession confession NN 19613 886 11 . . . 19613 886 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 887 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 887 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 887 3 26 26 CD 19613 887 4 : : : 19613 887 5 These these DT 19613 887 6 facts fact NNS 19613 887 7 were be VBD 19613 887 8 known know VBN 19613 887 9 to to IN 19613 887 10 every every DT 19613 887 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 887 12 . . . 19613 888 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 888 2 are be VBP 19613 888 3 probably probably RB 19613 888 4 also also RB 19613 888 5 alluded allude VBN 19613 888 6 to to IN 19613 888 7 in in IN 19613 888 8 Luke Luke NNP 19613 888 9 I. I. NNP 19613 889 1 4 4 LS 19613 889 2 . . . 19613 889 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 890 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 890 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 890 3 27 27 CD 19613 890 4 : : : 19613 890 5 The the DT 19613 890 6 most most RBS 19613 890 7 important important JJ 19613 890 8 result result NN 19613 890 9 of of IN 19613 890 10 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 890 11 's 's POS 19613 890 12 extensive extensive JJ 19613 890 13 and and CC 19613 890 14 exact exact JJ 19613 890 15 studies study NNS 19613 890 16 is be VBZ 19613 890 17 the the DT 19613 890 18 establishment establishment NN 19613 890 19 of of IN 19613 890 20 this this DT 19613 890 21 fact fact NN 19613 890 22 and and CC 19613 890 23 the the DT 19613 890 24 fixing fixing NN 19613 890 25 of of IN 19613 890 26 the the DT 19613 890 27 wording wording NN 19613 890 28 of of IN 19613 890 29 the the DT 19613 890 30 Romish Romish NNP 19613 890 31 Confession Confession NNP 19613 890 32 . . . 19613 891 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 891 2 Ungedruckte Ungedruckte NNP 19613 891 3 , , , 19613 891 4 unbeachtete unbeachtete JJ 19613 891 5 und und NN 19613 891 6 wenig wenig NNP 19613 891 7 beachtete beachtete NNP 19613 891 8 Quellen Quellen NNP 19613 891 9 z. z. NNP 19613 891 10 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 891 11 . . . 19613 892 1 des des NNP 19613 892 2 Taufsymbols Taufsymbols NNP 19613 892 3 u u NNP 19613 892 4 d. d. NNP 19613 892 5 Glaubensregels Glaubensregels NNP 19613 892 6 . . . 19613 893 1 3 3 CD 19613 893 2 Vols Vols NNP 19613 893 3 . . . 19613 894 1 1866 1866 CD 19613 894 2 - - SYM 19613 894 3 1875 1875 CD 19613 894 4 . . . 19613 895 1 Alte Alte NNP 19613 895 2 u. u. CC 19613 895 3 neue neue NN 19613 895 4 Quellen Quellen NNP 19613 895 5 zur zur NNP 19613 895 6 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 895 7 . . . 19613 896 1 des des NNP 19613 896 2 Taufsymbols Taufsymbols NNP 19613 896 3 u. u. CC 19613 896 4 d. d. NNP 19613 896 5 Glaubensregel Glaubensregel NNP 19613 896 6 , , , 19613 896 7 1879 1879 CD 19613 896 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 896 9 . . . 19613 897 1 After after IN 19613 897 2 this this DT 19613 897 3 Hahn Hahn NNP 19613 897 4 , , , 19613 897 5 Bibliothek Bibliothek NNP 19613 897 6 d. d. NNP 19613 897 7 Symbole Symbole NNP 19613 897 8 u. u. CC 19613 897 9 Glaubensregeln Glaubensregeln NNP 19613 897 10 der der RB 19613 897 11 alten alten VB 19613 897 12 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 897 13 . . . 19613 898 1 2 2 CD 19613 898 2 Aufl Aufl NNP 19613 898 3 . . . 19613 899 1 1877 1877 CD 19613 899 2 ; ; : 19613 899 3 see see VB 19613 899 4 also also RB 19613 899 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 899 6 article article NN 19613 899 7 " " `` 19613 899 8 Apostol Apostol NNP 19613 899 9 . . . 19613 900 1 Symbol symbol NN 19613 900 2 " " `` 19613 900 3 in in IN 19613 900 4 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 900 5 's 's POS 19613 900 6 R.E R.E NNP 19613 900 7 .. .. . 19613 900 8 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 900 9 . . . 19613 901 1 ed ed NNP 19613 901 2 . . NNP 19613 901 3 , , , 19613 901 4 as as RB 19613 901 5 well well RB 19613 901 6 as as IN 19613 901 7 Book Book NNP 19613 901 8 I. I. NNP 19613 901 9 of of IN 19613 901 10 the the DT 19613 901 11 present present JJ 19613 901 12 work work NN 19613 901 13 , , , 19613 901 14 Chap Chap NNP 19613 901 15 . . . 19613 902 1 III iii CD 19613 902 2 . . . 19613 903 1 § § ADD 19613 903 2 2 2 CD 19613 903 3 . . . 19613 903 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 904 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 904 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 904 3 28 28 CD 19613 904 4 : : : 19613 904 5 This this DT 19613 904 6 supposition supposition NN 19613 904 7 is be VBZ 19613 904 8 based base VBN 19613 904 9 on on IN 19613 904 10 observation observation NN 19613 904 11 of of IN 19613 904 12 the the DT 19613 904 13 fact fact NN 19613 904 14 that that IN 19613 904 15 particular particular JJ 19613 904 16 statements statement NNS 19613 904 17 of of IN 19613 904 18 the the DT 19613 904 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 904 20 Symbol Symbol NNP 19613 904 21 , , , 19613 904 22 in in IN 19613 904 23 exactly exactly RB 19613 904 24 the the DT 19613 904 25 same same JJ 19613 904 26 form form NN 19613 904 27 or or CC 19613 904 28 nearly nearly RB 19613 904 29 so so RB 19613 904 30 , , , 19613 904 31 are be VBP 19613 904 32 found find VBN 19613 904 33 in in IN 19613 904 34 many many JJ 19613 904 35 early early JJ 19613 904 36 Christian christian JJ 19613 904 37 writings writing NNS 19613 904 38 . . . 19613 905 1 See see VB 19613 905 2 Patr Patr NNP 19613 905 3 . . . 19613 906 1 App App NNP 19613 906 2 . . . 19613 907 1 Opp Opp NNP 19613 907 2 . . . 19613 908 1 I. I. NNP 19613 909 1 2 2 LS 19613 909 2 , , , 19613 909 3 ed ed NN 19613 909 4 . . . 19613 910 1 2 2 CD 19613 910 2 , , , 19613 910 3 pp pp NNP 19613 910 4 . . . 19613 911 1 115 115 CD 19613 911 2 - - SYM 19613 911 3 42 42 CD 19613 911 4 . . . 19613 911 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 912 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 912 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 912 3 29 29 CD 19613 912 4 : : : 19613 912 5 The the DT 19613 912 6 investigations investigation NNS 19613 912 7 which which WDT 19613 912 8 lead lead VBP 19613 912 9 to to IN 19613 912 10 this this DT 19613 912 11 result result NN 19613 912 12 are be VBP 19613 912 13 of of IN 19613 912 14 a a DT 19613 912 15 very very RB 19613 912 16 complicated complicated JJ 19613 912 17 nature nature NN 19613 912 18 and and CC 19613 912 19 can can MD 19613 912 20 not not RB 19613 912 21 therefore therefore RB 19613 912 22 be be VB 19613 912 23 given give VBN 19613 912 24 here here RB 19613 912 25 . . . 19613 913 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 913 2 must must MD 19613 913 3 content content VB 19613 913 4 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 913 5 with with IN 19613 913 6 remarking remark VBG 19613 913 7 that that IN 19613 913 8 all all DT 19613 913 9 Western western JJ 19613 913 10 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 913 11 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 913 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 913 13 creeds creed NNS 19613 913 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 913 15 may may MD 19613 913 16 be be VB 19613 913 17 traced trace VBN 19613 913 18 back back RB 19613 913 19 to to IN 19613 913 20 the the DT 19613 913 21 Roman Roman NNP 19613 913 22 , , , 19613 913 23 and and CC 19613 913 24 that that IN 19613 913 25 there there EX 19613 913 26 was be VBD 19613 913 27 no no DT 19613 913 28 universal universal JJ 19613 913 29 Eastern eastern JJ 19613 913 30 creed creed NN 19613 913 31 on on IN 19613 913 32 parallel parallel JJ 19613 913 33 lines line NNS 19613 913 34 with with IN 19613 913 35 the the DT 19613 913 36 latter latter JJ 19613 913 37 . . . 19613 914 1 There there EX 19613 914 2 is be VBZ 19613 914 3 no no DT 19613 914 4 mistaking mistake VBG 19613 914 5 the the DT 19613 914 6 importance importance NN 19613 914 7 which which WDT 19613 914 8 , , , 19613 914 9 in in IN 19613 914 10 these these DT 19613 914 11 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 914 12 , , , 19613 914 13 is be VBZ 19613 914 14 to to TO 19613 914 15 be be VB 19613 914 16 attributed attribute VBN 19613 914 17 to to IN 19613 914 18 the the DT 19613 914 19 Roman roman JJ 19613 914 20 symbol symbol NN 19613 914 21 and and CC 19613 914 22 Church Church NNP 19613 914 23 as as IN 19613 914 24 regards regard VBZ 19613 914 25 the the DT 19613 914 26 development development NN 19613 914 27 of of IN 19613 914 28 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 914 29 . . . 19613 914 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 915 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 915 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 915 3 30 30 CD 19613 915 4 : : : 19613 915 5 This this DT 19613 915 6 caused cause VBD 19613 915 7 the the DT 19613 915 8 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 915 9 tendency tendency NN 19613 915 10 of of IN 19613 915 11 the the DT 19613 915 12 Church Church NNP 19613 915 13 to to IN 19613 915 14 the the DT 19613 915 15 formation formation NN 19613 915 16 of of IN 19613 915 17 dogma dogma NN 19613 915 18 , , , 19613 915 19 a a DT 19613 915 20 movement movement NN 19613 915 21 for for IN 19613 915 22 which which WDT 19613 915 23 Paul Paul NNP 19613 915 24 had have VBD 19613 915 25 already already RB 19613 915 26 paved pave VBN 19613 915 27 the the DT 19613 915 28 way way NN 19613 915 29 . . . 19613 916 1 The the DT 19613 916 2 development development NN 19613 916 3 of of IN 19613 916 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 916 5 , , , 19613 916 6 as as IN 19613 916 7 attested attest VBN 19613 916 8 , , , 19613 916 9 for for IN 19613 916 10 example example NN 19613 916 11 , , , 19613 916 12 by by IN 19613 916 13 the the DT 19613 916 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 916 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 916 16 : : : 19613 916 17 Didachê didachê NN 19613 916 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 916 19 , , , 19613 916 20 received receive VBD 19613 916 21 an an DT 19613 916 22 additional additional JJ 19613 916 23 factor factor NN 19613 916 24 in in IN 19613 916 25 the the DT 19613 916 26 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 916 27 tradition tradition NN 19613 916 28 , , , 19613 916 29 which which WDT 19613 916 30 soon soon RB 19613 916 31 gained gain VBD 19613 916 32 the the DT 19613 916 33 upper upper JJ 19613 916 34 hand hand NN 19613 916 35 . . . 19613 917 1 The the DT 19613 917 2 great great JJ 19613 917 3 reaction reaction NN 19613 917 4 is be VBZ 19613 917 5 then then RB 19613 917 6 found find VBN 19613 917 7 in in IN 19613 917 8 monasticism monasticism NN 19613 917 9 . . . 19613 918 1 Here here RB 19613 918 2 again again RB 19613 918 3 the the DT 19613 918 4 rules rule NNS 19613 918 5 of of IN 19613 918 6 morality morality NN 19613 918 7 become become VBP 19613 918 8 the the DT 19613 918 9 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 918 10 feature feature NN 19613 918 11 , , , 19613 918 12 and and CC 19613 918 13 therefore therefore RB 19613 918 14 the the DT 19613 918 15 old old JJ 19613 918 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 918 17 gnomic gnomic JJ 19613 918 18 literature literature NN 19613 918 19 attains attain VBZ 19613 918 20 in in IN 19613 918 21 this this DT 19613 918 22 movement movement NN 19613 918 23 a a DT 19613 918 24 second second JJ 19613 918 25 period period NN 19613 918 26 of of IN 19613 918 27 vigour vigour NN 19613 918 28 . . . 19613 919 1 In in IN 19613 919 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 919 3 again again RB 19613 919 4 dogmatics dogmatic VBZ 19613 919 5 only only RB 19613 919 6 form form VBP 19613 919 7 the the DT 19613 919 8 background background NN 19613 919 9 for for IN 19613 919 10 the the DT 19613 919 11 strict strict JJ 19613 919 12 regulation regulation NN 19613 919 13 of of IN 19613 919 14 life life NN 19613 919 15 . . . 19613 920 1 In in IN 19613 920 2 the the DT 19613 920 3 instruction instruction NN 19613 920 4 given give VBN 19613 920 5 as as IN 19613 920 6 a a DT 19613 920 7 preparation preparation NN 19613 920 8 for for IN 19613 920 9 baptism baptism NN 19613 920 10 the the DT 19613 920 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 920 12 moral moral JJ 19613 920 13 commandments commandment NNS 19613 920 14 were be VBD 19613 920 15 of of IN 19613 920 16 course course NN 19613 920 17 always always RB 19613 920 18 inculcated inculcate VBN 19613 920 19 , , , 19613 920 20 and and CC 19613 920 21 the the DT 19613 920 22 obligation obligation NN 19613 920 23 to to TO 19613 920 24 observe observe VB 19613 920 25 these these DT 19613 920 26 was be VBD 19613 920 27 expressed express VBN 19613 920 28 in in IN 19613 920 29 the the DT 19613 920 30 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 920 31 of of IN 19613 920 32 Satan Satan NNP 19613 920 33 and and CC 19613 920 34 all all PDT 19613 920 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 920 36 works work NNS 19613 920 37 . . . 19613 921 1 In in IN 19613 921 2 consequence consequence NN 19613 921 3 of of IN 19613 921 4 this this DT 19613 921 5 , , , 19613 921 6 there there EX 19613 921 7 were be VBD 19613 921 8 also also RB 19613 921 9 fixed fix VBN 19613 921 10 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 921 11 in in IN 19613 921 12 these these DT 19613 921 13 cases case NNS 19613 921 14 . . . 19613 921 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 922 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 922 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 922 3 31 31 CD 19613 922 4 : : : 19613 922 5 See see VB 19613 922 6 the the DT 19613 922 7 Pastoral Pastoral NNP 19613 922 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 922 9 , , , 19613 922 10 those those DT 19613 922 11 of of IN 19613 922 12 John John NNP 19613 922 13 and and CC 19613 922 14 of of IN 19613 922 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 922 16 ; ; : 19613 922 17 also also RB 19613 922 18 the the DT 19613 922 19 epistle epistle NN 19613 922 20 of of IN 19613 922 21 Jude Jude NNP 19613 922 22 , , , 19613 922 23 1 1 CD 19613 922 24 Clem Clem NNP 19613 922 25 . . . 19613 923 1 VII VII NNP 19613 923 2 . . NNP 19613 923 3 , , , 19613 923 4 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 923 5 , , , 19613 923 6 ad ad NN 19613 923 7 Philipp Philipp NNP 19613 923 8 . . . 19613 924 1 VII VII NNP 19613 924 2 . . NNP 19613 924 3 , , , 19613 924 4 II II NNP 19613 924 5 . . . 19613 925 1 1 1 CD 19613 925 2 , , , 19613 925 3 VI VI NNP 19613 925 4 . . . 19613 926 1 3 3 LS 19613 926 2 , , , 19613 926 3 Justin Justin NNP 19613 926 4 . . . 19613 926 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 927 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 927 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 927 3 32 32 CD 19613 927 4 : : : 19613 927 5 In in IN 19613 927 6 the the DT 19613 927 7 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 927 8 writings writing NNS 19613 927 9 of of IN 19613 927 10 Justin Justin NNP 19613 927 11 the the DT 19613 927 12 courts court NNS 19613 927 13 of of IN 19613 927 14 appeal appeal NN 19613 927 15 invariably invariably RB 19613 927 16 continue continue VBP 19613 927 17 to to TO 19613 927 18 be be VB 19613 927 19 the the DT 19613 927 20 Old Old NNP 19613 927 21 Testament Testament NNP 19613 927 22 , , , 19613 927 23 the the DT 19613 927 24 words word NNS 19613 927 25 of of IN 19613 927 26 the the DT 19613 927 27 Lord Lord NNP 19613 927 28 , , , 19613 927 29 and and CC 19613 927 30 the the DT 19613 927 31 communications communication NNS 19613 927 32 of of IN 19613 927 33 prophets prophet NNS 19613 927 34 ; ; : 19613 927 35 hence hence RB 19613 927 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 927 37 has have VBZ 19613 927 38 hardly hardly RB 19613 927 39 insisted insist VBN 19613 927 40 on on IN 19613 927 41 any any DT 19613 927 42 other other JJ 19613 927 43 in in IN 19613 927 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 927 45 anti anti JJ 19613 927 46 - - JJ 19613 927 47 heretical heretical JJ 19613 927 48 work work NN 19613 927 49 . . . 19613 928 1 On on IN 19613 928 2 the the DT 19613 928 3 other other JJ 19613 928 4 hand hand NN 19613 928 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 928 6 can can MD 19613 928 7 not not RB 19613 928 8 appeal appeal VB 19613 928 9 to to IN 19613 928 10 the the DT 19613 928 11 observed observed JJ 19613 928 12 fact fact NN 19613 928 13 that that IN 19613 928 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 928 15 also also RB 19613 928 16 , , , 19613 928 17 in in IN 19613 928 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 928 19 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 928 20 writings writing NNS 19613 928 21 , , , 19613 928 22 did do VBD 19613 928 23 not not RB 19613 928 24 reveal reveal VB 19613 928 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 928 26 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 928 27 as as IN 19613 928 28 a a DT 19613 928 29 churchman churchman NN 19613 928 30 and and CC 19613 928 31 opponent opponent NN 19613 928 32 of of IN 19613 928 33 heresy heresy NN 19613 928 34 ; ; : 19613 928 35 for for IN 19613 928 36 , , , 19613 928 37 with with IN 19613 928 38 one one CD 19613 928 39 exception exception NN 19613 928 40 , , , 19613 928 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 928 42 did do VBD 19613 928 43 not not RB 19613 928 44 discuss discuss VB 19613 928 45 heretics heretic NNS 19613 928 46 in in IN 19613 928 47 these these DT 19613 928 48 tractates tractate NNS 19613 928 49 at at RB 19613 928 50 all all RB 19613 928 51 . . . 19613 929 1 On on IN 19613 929 2 the the DT 19613 929 3 contrary contrary JJ 19613 929 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 929 5 discussed discuss VBD 19613 929 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 929 7 position position NN 19613 929 8 even even RB 19613 929 9 in in IN 19613 929 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 929 11 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 929 12 writings writing NNS 19613 929 13 ; ; : 19613 929 14 but but CC 19613 929 15 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 929 16 , , , 19613 929 17 for for IN 19613 929 18 instance instance NN 19613 929 19 , , , 19613 929 20 wrote write VBD 19613 929 21 anything anything NN 19613 929 22 similar similar JJ 19613 929 23 to to IN 19613 929 24 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 929 25 ' ' POS 19613 929 26 remarks remark NNS 19613 929 27 in in IN 19613 929 28 " " `` 19613 929 29 ad ad NN 19613 929 30 Autol Autol NNP 19613 929 31 . . . 19613 929 32 , , , 19613 929 33 " " `` 19613 929 34 II ii CD 19613 929 35 . . . 19613 930 1 14 14 CD 19613 930 2 . . . 19613 931 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 931 2 was be VBD 19613 931 3 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 931 4 with with IN 19613 931 5 and and CC 19613 931 6 frequently frequently RB 19613 931 7 alluded allude VBN 19613 931 8 to to IN 19613 931 9 fixed fix VBN 19613 931 10 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 931 11 and and CC 19613 931 12 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 931 13 a a DT 19613 931 14 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 931 15 symbol symbol NN 19613 931 16 related relate VBN 19613 931 17 to to IN 19613 931 18 the the DT 19613 931 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 931 20 , , , 19613 931 21 if if IN 19613 931 22 not not RB 19613 931 23 essentially essentially RB 19613 931 24 identical identical JJ 19613 931 25 with with IN 19613 931 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 931 27 . . . 19613 932 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 932 2 See see VB 19613 932 3 Bornemann Bornemann NNP 19613 932 4 . . . 19613 933 1 Das Das NNP 19613 933 2 Taufsymbol Taufsymbol NNP 19613 933 3 Justins Justins NNP 19613 933 4 in in IN 19613 933 5 the the DT 19613 933 6 Ztschr Ztschr NNP 19613 933 7 . . . 19613 934 1 f. f. NNP 19613 934 2 K. K. NNP 19613 934 3 G. G. NNP 19613 934 4 Vol Vol NNP 19613 934 5 . . . 19613 935 1 III iii CD 19613 935 2 . . . 19613 936 1 p. p. NN 19613 936 2 1 1 CD 19613 936 3 ff ff NN 19613 936 4 . . . 19613 937 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 937 2 , , , 19613 937 3 but but CC 19613 937 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 937 5 can can MD 19613 937 6 not not RB 19613 937 7 prove prove VB 19613 937 8 that that IN 19613 937 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 937 10 utilised utilise VBD 19613 937 11 these these DT 19613 937 12 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 937 13 in in IN 19613 937 14 the the DT 19613 937 15 sense sense NN 19613 937 16 of of IN 19613 937 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 937 18 and and CC 19613 937 19 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 937 20 . . . 19613 938 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 938 2 find find VBP 19613 938 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 938 4 using use VBG 19613 938 5 the the DT 19613 938 6 expression expression NN 19613 938 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 938 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 938 9 : : : 19613 938 10 orthognômones orthognômone NNS 19613 938 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 938 12 in in IN 19613 938 13 Dial Dial NNP 19613 938 14 . . . 19613 939 1 80 80 CD 19613 939 2 . . . 19613 940 1 The the DT 19613 940 2 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 940 3 of of IN 19613 940 4 the the DT 19613 940 5 flesh flesh NN 19613 940 6 and and CC 19613 940 7 the the DT 19613 940 8 thousand thousand CD 19613 940 9 years year NNS 19613 940 10 ' ' POS 19613 940 11 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 940 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 940 13 at at IN 19613 940 14 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 940 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 940 16 are be VBP 19613 940 17 there there EX 19613 940 18 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 940 19 among among IN 19613 940 20 the the DT 19613 940 21 beliefs belief NNS 19613 940 22 held hold VBN 19613 940 23 by by IN 19613 940 24 the the DT 19613 940 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 940 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 940 27 : : : 19613 940 28 orthognômones orthognômone NNS 19613 940 29 kata kata VBP 19613 940 30 panta panta NNP 19613 940 31 Christianoi Christianoi NNP 19613 940 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 940 33 . . . 19613 941 1 But but CC 19613 941 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 941 3 is be VBZ 19613 941 4 very very RB 19613 941 5 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 941 6 of of IN 19613 941 7 the the DT 19613 941 8 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 941 9 taken take VBN 19613 941 10 up up RP 19613 941 11 by by IN 19613 941 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 941 13 that that IN 19613 941 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 941 15 places place VBZ 19613 941 16 between between IN 19613 941 17 the the DT 19613 941 18 heretics heretic NNS 19613 941 19 inspired inspire VBN 19613 941 20 by by IN 19613 941 21 demons demon NNS 19613 941 22 and and CC 19613 941 23 the the DT 19613 941 24 orthodox orthodox NN 19613 941 25 a a DT 19613 941 26 class class NN 19613 941 27 of of IN 19613 941 28 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 941 29 to to TO 19613 941 30 whom whom WP 19613 941 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 941 32 gives give VBZ 19613 941 33 the the DT 19613 941 34 general general JJ 19613 941 35 testimony testimony NN 19613 941 36 that that WDT 19613 941 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 941 38 are be VBP 19613 941 39 [ [ -LRB- 19613 941 40 Greek Greek NNP 19613 941 41 : : : 19613 941 42 tês tês NNP 19613 941 43 katharas katharas NNP 19613 941 44 kai kai NNP 19613 941 45 eusebous eusebous JJ 19613 941 46 gnômês gnômês NNP 19613 941 47 ] ] -RRB- 19613 941 48 , , , 19613 941 49 though though IN 19613 941 50 they -PRON- PRP 19613 941 51 are be VBP 19613 941 52 not not RB 19613 941 53 fully fully RB 19613 941 54 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 941 55 in in IN 19613 941 56 so so RB 19613 941 57 far far RB 19613 941 58 as as IN 19613 941 59 they -PRON- PRP 19613 941 60 reject reject VBP 19613 941 61 one one CD 19613 941 62 important important JJ 19613 941 63 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 941 64 . . . 19613 942 1 Such such PDT 19613 942 2 an an DT 19613 942 3 estimate estimate NN 19613 942 4 would would MD 19613 942 5 have have VB 19613 942 6 been be VBN 19613 942 7 impossible impossible JJ 19613 942 8 to to IN 19613 942 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 942 10 and and CC 19613 942 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 942 12 . . . 19613 943 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 943 2 have have VBP 19613 943 3 advanced advance VBN 19613 943 4 to to IN 19613 943 5 the the DT 19613 943 6 principle principle NN 19613 943 7 that that IN 19613 943 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 943 9 who who WP 19613 943 10 violates violate VBZ 19613 943 11 the the DT 19613 943 12 law law NN 19613 943 13 of of IN 19613 943 14 faith faith NN 19613 943 15 in in IN 19613 943 16 one one CD 19613 943 17 point point NN 19613 943 18 is be VBZ 19613 943 19 guilty guilty JJ 19613 943 20 of of IN 19613 943 21 breaking break VBG 19613 943 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 943 23 all all DT 19613 943 24 . . . 19613 943 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 944 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 944 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 944 3 33 33 CD 19613 944 4 : : : 19613 944 5 Hatch Hatch NNP 19613 944 6 , , , 19613 944 7 " " '' 19613 944 8 Organisation organisation NN 19613 944 9 of of IN 19613 944 10 the the DT 19613 944 11 Church Church NNP 19613 944 12 , , , 19613 944 13 " " '' 19613 944 14 p. p. NN 19613 945 1 96 96 CD 19613 945 2 . . . 19613 945 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 946 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 946 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 946 3 34 34 CD 19613 946 4 : : : 19613 946 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 946 6 can can MD 19613 946 7 only only RB 19613 946 8 conjecture conjecture VB 19613 946 9 that that WDT 19613 946 10 some some DT 19613 946 11 teachers teacher NNS 19613 946 12 in in IN 19613 946 13 Asia Asia NNP 19613 946 14 Minor Minor NNP 19613 946 15 contemporary contemporary NN 19613 946 16 with with IN 19613 946 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 946 18 , , , 19613 946 19 or or CC 19613 946 20 even even RB 19613 946 21 of of IN 19613 946 22 older old JJR 19613 946 23 date date NN 19613 946 24 , , , 19613 946 25 and and CC 19613 946 26 especially especially RB 19613 946 27 Melito Melito NNP 19613 946 28 , , , 19613 946 29 proceeded proceed VBD 19613 946 30 in in IN 19613 946 31 like like JJ 19613 946 32 manner manner NN 19613 946 33 , , , 19613 946 34 adhering adhere VBG 19613 946 35 to to IN 19613 946 36 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 946 37 's 's POS 19613 946 38 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 946 39 attitude attitude NN 19613 946 40 . . . 19613 947 1 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 947 2 of of IN 19613 947 3 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 947 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 947 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 947 6 , , , 19613 947 7 H. H. NNP 19613 947 8 E. E. NNP 19613 947 9 IV IV NNP 19613 947 10 . . . 19613 948 1 23 23 CD 19613 948 2 . . . 19613 949 1 2 2 CD 19613 949 2 , , , 19613 949 3 4 4 CD 19613 949 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 949 5 may may MD 19613 949 6 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 949 7 be be VB 19613 949 8 also also RB 19613 949 9 mentioned mention VBN 19613 949 10 . . . 19613 949 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 950 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 950 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 950 3 35 35 CD 19613 950 4 : : : 19613 950 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 950 6 set set VBD 19613 950 7 forth forth RP 19613 950 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 950 9 theory theory NN 19613 950 10 in in IN 19613 950 11 a a DT 19613 950 12 great great JJ 19613 950 13 work work NN 19613 950 14 , , , 19613 950 15 adv adv NN 19613 950 16 . . . 19613 951 1 hæres hæres NNP 19613 951 2 . . . 19613 951 3 , , , 19613 951 4 especially especially RB 19613 951 5 in in IN 19613 951 6 the the DT 19613 951 7 third third JJ 19613 951 8 book book NN 19613 951 9 . . . 19613 952 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 952 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 952 3 treatise treatise NN 19613 952 4 , , , 19613 952 5 " " '' 19613 952 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 952 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 952 8 : : : 19613 952 9 logos logos NNP 19613 952 10 eis eis NNP 19613 952 11 epideixin epideixin NNP 19613 952 12 tou tou NNP 19613 952 13 apostolikou apostolikou NNP 19613 952 14 kêrygmatos kêrygmatos NNP 19613 952 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 952 16 " " `` 19613 952 17 , , , 19613 952 18 probably probably RB 19613 952 19 the the DT 19613 952 20 oldest old JJS 19613 952 21 treatise treatise NN 19613 952 22 on on IN 19613 952 23 the the DT 19613 952 24 rule rule NN 19613 952 25 of of IN 19613 952 26 faith faith NN 19613 952 27 , , , 19613 952 28 has have VBZ 19613 952 29 not not RB 19613 952 30 been be VBN 19613 952 31 preserved preserve VBN 19613 952 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 952 33 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 952 34 . . NNP 19613 952 35 , , , 19613 952 36 H. H. NNP 19613 952 37 E. E. NNP 19613 952 38 V. V. NNP 19613 953 1 26 26 CD 19613 953 2 . . . 19613 953 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 953 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 954 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 954 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 954 3 36 36 CD 19613 954 4 : : : 19613 954 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 954 6 indeed indeed RB 19613 954 7 asserts assert VBZ 19613 954 8 in in IN 19613 954 9 several several JJ 19613 954 10 passages passage NNS 19613 954 11 that that WDT 19613 954 12 all all DT 19613 954 13 Churches church NNS 19613 954 14 -- -- : 19613 954 15 those those DT 19613 954 16 in in IN 19613 954 17 Germany Germany NNP 19613 954 18 , , , 19613 954 19 Iberia Iberia NNP 19613 954 20 , , , 19613 954 21 among among IN 19613 954 22 the the DT 19613 954 23 Celts Celts NNPS 19613 954 24 , , , 19613 954 25 in in IN 19613 954 26 the the DT 19613 954 27 East East NNP 19613 954 28 , , , 19613 954 29 in in IN 19613 954 30 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 954 31 , , , 19613 954 32 in in IN 19613 954 33 Lybia Lybia NNP 19613 954 34 and and CC 19613 954 35 Italy Italy NNP 19613 954 36 ; ; : 19613 954 37 see see VB 19613 954 38 I. I. NNP 19613 955 1 10 10 CD 19613 955 2 . . . 19613 956 1 2 2 LS 19613 956 2 ; ; : 19613 956 3 III iii CD 19613 956 4 . . . 19613 957 1 3 3 LS 19613 957 2 . . . 19613 958 1 1 1 LS 19613 958 2 ; ; : 19613 958 3 III iii CD 19613 958 4 . . . 19613 959 1 4 4 LS 19613 959 2 . . . 19613 960 1 1 1 LS 19613 960 2 sq.--possess sq.--possess NN 19613 960 3 the the DT 19613 960 4 same same JJ 19613 960 5 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 960 6 _ _ NNP 19613 960 7 kerygma kerygma NNP 19613 960 8 _ _ NNP 19613 960 9 ; ; : 19613 960 10 but but CC 19613 960 11 " " `` 19613 960 12 qui qui NNP 19613 960 13 nimis nimis NNP 19613 960 14 probat probat NNP 19613 960 15 nihil nihil NNP 19613 960 16 probat probat NN 19613 960 17 . . . 19613 960 18 " " '' 19613 961 1 The the DT 19613 961 2 extravagance extravagance NN 19613 961 3 of of IN 19613 961 4 the the DT 19613 961 5 expressions expression NNS 19613 961 6 shows show VBZ 19613 961 7 that that IN 19613 961 8 a a DT 19613 961 9 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 961 10 theory theory NN 19613 961 11 is be VBZ 19613 961 12 here here RB 19613 961 13 at at IN 19613 961 14 work work NN 19613 961 15 . . . 19613 962 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 962 2 this this DT 19613 962 3 is be VBZ 19613 962 4 based base VBN 19613 962 5 on on IN 19613 962 6 the the DT 19613 962 7 correct correct JJ 19613 962 8 view view NN 19613 962 9 that that IN 19613 962 10 the the DT 19613 962 11 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 962 12 speculations speculation NNS 19613 962 13 are be VBP 19613 962 14 foreign foreign JJ 19613 962 15 to to IN 19613 962 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 962 17 and and CC 19613 962 18 of of IN 19613 962 19 later later JJ 19613 962 20 date date NN 19613 962 21 . . . 19613 962 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 963 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 963 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 963 3 37 37 CD 19613 963 4 : : : 19613 963 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 963 6 must must MD 19613 963 7 further further RB 19613 963 8 point point VB 19613 963 9 out out RP 19613 963 10 here here RB 19613 963 11 that that IN 19613 963 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 963 13 not not RB 19613 963 14 only only RB 19613 963 15 knew know VBD 19613 963 16 the the DT 19613 963 17 tradition tradition NN 19613 963 18 of of IN 19613 963 19 the the DT 19613 963 20 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 963 21 of of IN 19613 963 22 Asia Asia NNP 19613 963 23 Minor Minor NNP 19613 963 24 and and CC 19613 963 25 Rome Rome NNP 19613 963 26 , , , 19613 963 27 but but CC 19613 963 28 that that IN 19613 963 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 963 30 had have VBD 19613 963 31 sat sit VBN 19613 963 32 at at IN 19613 963 33 the the DT 19613 963 34 feet foot NNS 19613 963 35 of of IN 19613 963 36 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 963 37 and and CC 19613 963 38 associated associate VBN 19613 963 39 in in IN 19613 963 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 963 41 youth youth NN 19613 963 42 with with IN 19613 963 43 many many JJ 19613 963 44 of of IN 19613 963 45 the the DT 19613 963 46 " " `` 19613 963 47 elders elder NNS 19613 963 48 " " '' 19613 963 49 in in IN 19613 963 50 Asia Asia NNP 19613 963 51 . . . 19613 964 1 Of of IN 19613 964 2 these these DT 19613 964 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 964 4 knew know VBD 19613 964 5 for for IN 19613 964 6 certain certain JJ 19613 964 7 that that IN 19613 964 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 964 9 in in IN 19613 964 10 part part NN 19613 964 11 did do VBD 19613 964 12 not not RB 19613 964 13 approve approve VB 19613 964 14 of of IN 19613 964 15 the the DT 19613 964 16 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 964 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 964 18 and and CC 19613 964 19 in in IN 19613 964 20 part part NN 19613 964 21 would would MD 19613 964 22 not not RB 19613 964 23 have have VB 19613 964 24 done do VBN 19613 964 25 so so RB 19613 964 26 . . . 19613 965 1 The the DT 19613 965 2 confidence confidence NN 19613 965 3 with with IN 19613 965 4 which which WDT 19613 965 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 965 6 represented represent VBD 19613 965 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 965 8 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 965 9 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 965 10 of of IN 19613 965 11 the the DT 19613 965 12 creed creed NN 19613 965 13 as as IN 19613 965 14 that that DT 19613 965 15 of of IN 19613 965 16 the the DT 19613 965 17 Church Church NNP 19613 965 18 of of IN 19613 965 19 the the DT 19613 965 20 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 965 21 was be VBD 19613 965 22 no no RB 19613 965 23 doubt doubt RB 19613 965 24 owing owing JJ 19613 965 25 to to IN 19613 965 26 this this DT 19613 965 27 sure sure JJ 19613 965 28 historical historical JJ 19613 965 29 recollection recollection NN 19613 965 30 . . . 19613 966 1 See see VB 19613 966 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 966 3 epistle epistle NN 19613 966 4 to to IN 19613 966 5 Florinus Florinus NNP 19613 966 6 in in IN 19613 966 7 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 966 8 . . NNP 19613 966 9 , , , 19613 966 10 H. H. NNP 19613 966 11 E. E. NNP 19613 966 12 V. V. NNP 19613 966 13 20 20 CD 19613 966 14 and and CC 19613 966 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 966 16 numerous numerous JJ 19613 966 17 references reference NNS 19613 966 18 to to IN 19613 966 19 the the DT 19613 966 20 " " `` 19613 966 21 elders elder NNS 19613 966 22 " " '' 19613 966 23 in in IN 19613 966 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 966 25 great great JJ 19613 966 26 work work NN 19613 966 27 . . . 19613 967 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 967 2 A a DT 19613 967 3 collection collection NN 19613 967 4 of of IN 19613 967 5 these these DT 19613 967 6 may may MD 19613 967 7 be be VB 19613 967 8 found find VBN 19613 967 9 in in IN 19613 967 10 Patr Patr NNP 19613 967 11 . . . 19613 968 1 App App NNP 19613 968 2 . . . 19613 969 1 Opp Opp NNP 19613 969 2 . . . 19613 970 1 I. I. NNP 19613 971 1 3 3 CD 19613 971 2 , , , 19613 971 3 p. p. NN 19613 971 4 105 105 CD 19613 971 5 sq sq NNP 19613 971 6 . . NNP 19613 971 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 971 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 972 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 972 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 972 3 38 38 CD 19613 972 4 : : : 19613 972 5 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 972 6 's 's POS 19613 972 7 investigations investigation NNS 19613 972 8 leave leave VBP 19613 972 9 no no DT 19613 972 10 room room NN 19613 972 11 for for IN 19613 972 12 doubt doubt NN 19613 972 13 as as IN 19613 972 14 to to IN 19613 972 15 the the DT 19613 972 16 relation relation NN 19613 972 17 of of IN 19613 972 18 the the DT 19613 972 19 rule rule NN 19613 972 20 of of IN 19613 972 21 faith faith NN 19613 972 22 to to IN 19613 972 23 the the DT 19613 972 24 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 972 25 confession confession NN 19613 972 26 . . . 19613 973 1 The the DT 19613 973 2 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 973 3 confession confession NN 19613 973 4 was be VBD 19613 973 5 not not RB 19613 973 6 a a DT 19613 973 7 deposit deposit NN 19613 973 8 resulting result VBG 19613 973 9 from from IN 19613 973 10 fluctuating fluctuate VBG 19613 973 11 anti anti JJ 19613 973 12 - - JJ 19613 973 13 heretical heretical JJ 19613 973 14 rules rule NNS 19613 973 15 of of IN 19613 973 16 faith faith NN 19613 973 17 ; ; : 19613 973 18 but but CC 19613 973 19 the the DT 19613 973 20 latter latter JJ 19613 973 21 were be VBD 19613 973 22 the the DT 19613 973 23 explanations explanation NNS 19613 973 24 of of IN 19613 973 25 the the DT 19613 973 26 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 973 27 confession confession NN 19613 973 28 . . . 19613 974 1 The the DT 19613 974 2 full full JJ 19613 974 3 authority authority NN 19613 974 4 of of IN 19613 974 5 the the DT 19613 974 6 confession confession NN 19613 974 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 974 8 was be VBD 19613 974 9 transferred transfer VBN 19613 974 10 to to IN 19613 974 11 every every DT 19613 974 12 elucidation elucidation NN 19613 974 13 that that WDT 19613 974 14 appeared appear VBD 19613 974 15 necessary necessary JJ 19613 974 16 , , , 19613 974 17 in in IN 19613 974 18 so so RB 19613 974 19 far far RB 19613 974 20 as as IN 19613 974 21 the the DT 19613 974 22 needful needful JJ 19613 974 23 explanation explanation NN 19613 974 24 was be VBD 19613 974 25 regarded regard VBN 19613 974 26 as as IN 19613 974 27 given give VBN 19613 974 28 with with IN 19613 974 29 authority authority NN 19613 974 30 . . . 19613 975 1 Each each DT 19613 975 2 momentary momentary JJ 19613 975 3 formula formula NN 19613 975 4 employed employ VBN 19613 975 5 to to TO 19613 975 6 defend defend VB 19613 975 7 the the DT 19613 975 8 Church Church NNP 19613 975 9 against against IN 19613 975 10 heresy heresy NN 19613 975 11 has have VBZ 19613 975 12 therefore therefore RB 19613 975 13 the the DT 19613 975 14 full full JJ 19613 975 15 value value NN 19613 975 16 of of IN 19613 975 17 the the DT 19613 975 18 creed creed NN 19613 975 19 . . . 19613 976 1 This this DT 19613 976 2 explains explain VBZ 19613 976 3 the the DT 19613 976 4 fact fact NN 19613 976 5 that that IN 19613 976 6 , , , 19613 976 7 beginning begin VBG 19613 976 8 with with IN 19613 976 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 976 10 ' ' POS 19613 976 11 time time NN 19613 976 12 , , , 19613 976 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 976 14 meet meet VBP 19613 976 15 with with IN 19613 976 16 differently differently RB 19613 976 17 formulated formulate VBN 19613 976 18 rules rule NNS 19613 976 19 of of IN 19613 976 20 faith faith NN 19613 976 21 , , , 19613 976 22 partly partly RB 19613 976 23 in in IN 19613 976 24 the the DT 19613 976 25 same same JJ 19613 976 26 writer writer NN 19613 976 27 , , , 19613 976 28 and and CC 19613 976 29 yet yet RB 19613 976 30 each each DT 19613 976 31 is be VBZ 19613 976 32 declared declare VBN 19613 976 33 to to TO 19613 976 34 be be VB 19613 976 35 _ _ NNP 19613 976 36 the the DT 19613 976 37 _ _ NNP 19613 976 38 rule rule NN 19613 976 39 of of IN 19613 976 40 faith faith NN 19613 976 41 . . . 19613 977 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 977 2 is be VBZ 19613 977 3 virtually virtually RB 19613 977 4 right right JJ 19613 977 5 when when WRB 19613 977 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 977 7 says say VBZ 19613 977 8 , , , 19613 977 9 in in IN 19613 977 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 977 11 essay essay NN 19613 977 12 quoted quote VBN 19613 977 13 above above RB 19613 977 14 , , , 19613 977 15 that that IN 19613 977 16 the the DT 19613 977 17 rule rule NN 19613 977 18 of of IN 19613 977 19 faith faith NN 19613 977 20 is be VBZ 19613 977 21 the the DT 19613 977 22 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 977 23 confession confession NN 19613 977 24 . . . 19613 978 1 But but CC 19613 978 2 , , , 19613 978 3 so so RB 19613 978 4 far far RB 19613 978 5 as as IN 19613 978 6 I -PRON- PRP 19613 978 7 can can MD 19613 978 8 judge judge VB 19613 978 9 , , , 19613 978 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 978 11 has have VBZ 19613 978 12 not not RB 19613 978 13 discerned discern VBN 19613 978 14 the the DT 19613 978 15 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 978 16 in in IN 19613 978 17 which which WDT 19613 978 18 the the DT 19613 978 19 Old Old NNP 19613 978 20 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 978 21 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 978 22 were be VBD 19613 978 23 placed place VBN 19613 978 24 , , , 19613 978 25 and and CC 19613 978 26 which which WDT 19613 978 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 978 28 were be VBD 19613 978 29 not not RB 19613 978 30 able able JJ 19613 978 31 to to TO 19613 978 32 conceal conceal VB 19613 978 33 . . . 19613 979 1 This this DT 19613 979 2 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 979 3 arose arise VBD 19613 979 4 from from IN 19613 979 5 the the DT 19613 979 6 fact fact NN 19613 979 7 that that IN 19613 979 8 the the DT 19613 979 9 Church Church NNP 19613 979 10 needed need VBD 19613 979 11 an an DT 19613 979 12 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 979 13 creed creed NN 19613 979 14 , , , 19613 979 15 expressed express VBN 19613 979 16 in in IN 19613 979 17 fixed fix VBN 19613 979 18 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 979 19 and and CC 19613 979 20 at at IN 19613 979 21 the the DT 19613 979 22 same same JJ 19613 979 23 time time NN 19613 979 24 definitely definitely RB 19613 979 25 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 979 26 in in IN 19613 979 27 an an DT 19613 979 28 anti anti JJ 19613 979 29 - - JJ 19613 979 30 heretical heretical JJ 19613 979 31 sense sense NN 19613 979 32 ; ; : 19613 979 33 whereas whereas IN 19613 979 34 she -PRON- PRP 19613 979 35 only only RB 19613 979 36 possessed possess VBD 19613 979 37 , , , 19613 979 38 and and CC 19613 979 39 this this DT 19613 979 40 not not RB 19613 979 41 in in IN 19613 979 42 all all DT 19613 979 43 churches church NNS 19613 979 44 , , , 19613 979 45 a a DT 19613 979 46 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 979 47 confession confession NN 19613 979 48 , , , 19613 979 49 contained contain VBN 19613 979 50 in in IN 19613 979 51 fixed fix VBN 19613 979 52 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 979 53 but but CC 19613 979 54 not not RB 19613 979 55 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 979 56 , , , 19613 979 57 along along IN 19613 979 58 with with IN 19613 979 59 an an DT 19613 979 60 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 979 61 tradition tradition NN 19613 979 62 which which WDT 19613 979 63 was be VBD 19613 979 64 not not RB 19613 979 65 formulated formulate VBN 19613 979 66 , , , 19613 979 67 although although IN 19613 979 68 it -PRON- PRP 19613 979 69 no no RB 19613 979 70 doubt doubt RB 19613 979 71 excluded exclude VBD 19613 979 72 the the DT 19613 979 73 most most RBS 19613 979 74 offensive offensive JJ 19613 979 75 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 979 76 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 979 77 . . . 19613 980 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 980 2 was be VBD 19613 980 3 not not RB 19613 980 4 yet yet RB 19613 980 5 possible possible JJ 19613 980 6 for for IN 19613 980 7 the the DT 19613 980 8 Old Old NNP 19613 980 9 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 980 10 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 980 11 to to TO 19613 980 12 frame frame VB 19613 980 13 and and CC 19613 980 14 formulate formulate VB 19613 980 15 that that DT 19613 980 16 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 980 17 confession confession NN 19613 980 18 , , , 19613 980 19 and and CC 19613 980 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 980 21 did do VBD 19613 980 22 not not RB 19613 980 23 attempt attempt VB 19613 980 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 980 25 . . . 19613 981 1 The the DT 19613 981 2 only only JJ 19613 981 3 course course NN 19613 981 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 981 5 was be VBD 19613 981 6 to to TO 19613 981 7 assert assert VB 19613 981 8 that that IN 19613 981 9 an an DT 19613 981 10 elastic elastic JJ 19613 981 11 collection collection NN 19613 981 12 of of IN 19613 981 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 981 14 which which WDT 19613 981 15 were be VBD 19613 981 16 ever ever RB 19613 981 17 being be VBG 19613 981 18 formulated formulate VBN 19613 981 19 anew anew RB 19613 981 20 , , , 19613 981 21 was be VBD 19613 981 22 a a DT 19613 981 23 fixed fix VBN 19613 981 24 standard standard NN 19613 981 25 in in IN 19613 981 26 so so RB 19613 981 27 far far RB 19613 981 28 as as IN 19613 981 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 981 30 was be VBD 19613 981 31 based base VBN 19613 981 32 on on IN 19613 981 33 a a DT 19613 981 34 fixed fix VBN 19613 981 35 creed creed NN 19613 981 36 . . . 19613 982 1 But but CC 19613 982 2 this this DT 19613 982 3 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 982 4 -- -- : 19613 982 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 982 6 do do VBP 19613 982 7 not not RB 19613 982 8 know know VB 19613 982 9 how how WRB 19613 982 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 982 11 was be VBD 19613 982 12 viewed view VBN 19613 982 13 by by IN 19613 982 14 opponents opponent NNS 19613 982 15 -- -- : 19613 982 16 proved prove VBD 19613 982 17 an an DT 19613 982 18 advantage advantage NN 19613 982 19 in in IN 19613 982 20 the the DT 19613 982 21 end end NN 19613 982 22 , , , 19613 982 23 for for IN 19613 982 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 982 25 enabled enable VBD 19613 982 26 churchmen churchman NNS 19613 982 27 to to TO 19613 982 28 make make VB 19613 982 29 continual continual JJ 19613 982 30 additions addition NNS 19613 982 31 to to IN 19613 982 32 the the DT 19613 982 33 rule rule NN 19613 982 34 of of IN 19613 982 35 faith faith NN 19613 982 36 , , , 19613 982 37 whilst whilst IN 19613 982 38 at at IN 19613 982 39 the the DT 19613 982 40 same same JJ 19613 982 41 time time NN 19613 982 42 continuing continue VBG 19613 982 43 to to TO 19613 982 44 assert assert VB 19613 982 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 982 46 identity identity NN 19613 982 47 with with IN 19613 982 48 the the DT 19613 982 49 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 982 50 confession confession NN 19613 982 51 . . . 19613 983 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 983 2 must must MD 19613 983 3 make make VB 19613 983 4 the the DT 19613 983 5 reservation reservation NN 19613 983 6 , , , 19613 983 7 however however RB 19613 983 8 , , , 19613 983 9 that that IN 19613 983 10 not not RB 19613 983 11 only only RB 19613 983 12 the the DT 19613 983 13 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 983 14 confession confession NN 19613 983 15 , , , 19613 983 16 but but CC 19613 983 17 other other JJ 19613 983 18 fixed fix VBN 19613 983 19 propositions proposition NNS 19613 983 20 as as RB 19613 983 21 well well RB 19613 983 22 , , , 19613 983 23 formed form VBD 19613 983 24 the the DT 19613 983 25 basis basis NN 19613 983 26 on on IN 19613 983 27 which which WDT 19613 983 28 particular particular JJ 19613 983 29 rules rule NNS 19613 983 30 of of IN 19613 983 31 faith faith NN 19613 983 32 were be VBD 19613 983 33 formulated formulate VBN 19613 983 34 . . . 19613 983 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 984 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 984 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 984 3 39 39 CD 19613 984 4 : : : 19613 984 5 Besides besides IN 19613 984 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 984 7 I. I. NNP 19613 985 1 10 10 CD 19613 985 2 . . . 19613 986 1 1 1 CD 19613 986 2 , , , 19613 986 3 2 2 CD 19613 986 4 , , , 19613 986 5 cf cf NN 19613 986 6 . . . 19613 987 1 9 9 CD 19613 987 2 . . . 19613 988 1 1 1 CD 19613 988 2 - - SYM 19613 988 3 5 5 CD 19613 988 4 ; ; SYM 19613 988 5 22 22 CD 19613 988 6 . . . 19613 989 1 1 1 LS 19613 989 2 ; ; : 19613 989 3 II II NNP 19613 989 4 . . . 19613 990 1 1 1 LS 19613 990 2 . . . 19613 991 1 1 1 CD 19613 991 2 ; ; SYM 19613 991 3 9 9 CD 19613 991 4 . . . 19613 992 1 1 1 CD 19613 992 2 ; ; : 19613 992 3 28 28 CD 19613 992 4 . . . 19613 993 1 1 1 CD 19613 993 2 ; ; : 19613 993 3 32 32 CD 19613 993 4 . . . 19613 994 1 3 3 CD 19613 994 2 , , , 19613 994 3 4 4 CD 19613 994 4 ; ; : 19613 994 5 III iii CD 19613 994 6 . . . 19613 995 1 1 1 CD 19613 995 2 - - SYM 19613 995 3 4 4 CD 19613 995 4 ; ; SYM 19613 995 5 11 11 CD 19613 995 6 . . . 19613 996 1 1 1 CD 19613 996 2 ; ; SYM 19613 996 3 12 12 CD 19613 996 4 . . . 19613 997 1 9 9 CD 19613 997 2 ; ; : 19613 997 3 15 15 CD 19613 997 4 . . . 19613 998 1 1 1 CD 19613 998 2 ; ; : 19613 998 3 16 16 CD 19613 998 4 . . . 19613 999 1 5 5 CD 19613 999 2 sq sq NN 19613 999 3 . . . 19613 1000 1 ; ; : 19613 1000 2 18 18 CD 19613 1000 3 . . . 19613 1001 1 3 3 CD 19613 1001 2 ; ; : 19613 1001 3 24 24 CD 19613 1001 4 . . . 19613 1002 1 1 1 LS 19613 1002 2 ; ; : 19613 1002 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1002 4 . . . 19613 1003 1 1 1 LS 19613 1003 2 . . . 19613 1004 1 2 2 CD 19613 1004 2 ; ; SYM 19613 1004 3 9 9 CD 19613 1004 4 . . . 19613 1005 1 2 2 CD 19613 1005 2 ; ; : 19613 1005 3 20 20 CD 19613 1005 4 . . . 19613 1006 1 6 6 CD 19613 1006 2 ; ; SYM 19613 1006 3 33 33 CD 19613 1006 4 . . . 19613 1007 1 7 7 CD 19613 1007 2 sq sq NNP 19613 1007 3 . . . 19613 1008 1 ; ; : 19613 1008 2 V. V. NNP 19613 1008 3 Præf Præf NNP 19613 1008 4 . . . 19613 1009 1 12 12 CD 19613 1009 2 . . . 19613 1010 1 5 5 CD 19613 1010 2 ; ; : 19613 1010 3 20 20 CD 19613 1010 4 . . . 19613 1011 1 1 1 LS 19613 1011 2 . . . 19613 1011 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1012 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1012 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1012 3 40 40 CD 19613 1012 4 : : : 19613 1012 5 See see VB 19613 1012 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 1012 7 . . . 19613 1013 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1014 1 31 31 CD 19613 1014 2 . . . 19613 1015 1 3 3 LS 19613 1015 2 ; ; : 19613 1015 3 II II NNP 19613 1015 4 . . . 19613 1016 1 Præf Præf NNP 19613 1016 2 . . . 19613 1017 1 19 19 CD 19613 1017 2 . . . 19613 1018 1 8 8 LS 19613 1018 2 . . . 19613 1018 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1019 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1019 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1019 3 41 41 CD 19613 1019 4 : : : 19613 1019 5 This this DT 19613 1019 6 expression expression NN 19613 1019 7 is be VBZ 19613 1019 8 not not RB 19613 1019 9 found find VBN 19613 1019 10 in in IN 19613 1019 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1019 12 , , , 19613 1019 13 but but CC 19613 1019 14 is be VBZ 19613 1019 15 very very RB 19613 1019 16 common common JJ 19613 1019 17 in in IN 19613 1019 18 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1019 19 . . . 19613 1019 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1020 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1020 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1020 3 42 42 CD 19613 1020 4 : : : 19613 1020 5 See see VB 19613 1020 6 de de NNP 19613 1020 7 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1020 8 . . . 19613 1021 1 13 13 CD 19613 1021 2 : : : 19613 1021 3 " " `` 19613 1021 4 Hæc Hæc NNP 19613 1021 5 regula regula NN 19613 1021 6 a a DT 19613 1021 7 Christo Christo NNP 19613 1021 8 instituta instituta NN 19613 1021 9 nullas nullas NNP 19613 1021 10 habet habet NNP 19613 1021 11 apud apud NNP 19613 1021 12 nos nos NNP 19613 1021 13 quæstiones quæstiones NNP 19613 1021 14 . . . 19613 1021 15 " " '' 19613 1021 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1022 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1022 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1022 3 43 43 CD 19613 1022 4 : : : 19613 1022 5 See see VB 19613 1022 6 I. I. NNP 19613 1022 7 c. c. NN 19613 1022 8 14 14 CD 19613 1022 9 : : : 19613 1022 10 " " `` 19613 1022 11 Ceterum Ceterum NNP 19613 1022 12 manente manente NN 19613 1022 13 forma forma NN 19613 1022 14 regulæ regulæ NN 19613 1022 15 in in IN 19613 1022 16 suo suo NNP 19613 1022 17 ordine ordine NNP 19613 1022 18 quantumlibet quantumlibet NNP 19613 1022 19 quæras quæras NNP 19613 1022 20 et et NN 19613 1022 21 tractes tracte NNS 19613 1022 22 . . . 19613 1022 23 " " '' 19613 1023 1 See see VB 19613 1023 2 de de NNP 19613 1023 3 virg virg NNS 19613 1023 4 . . . 19613 1024 1 vol vol NNP 19613 1024 2 . . . 19613 1025 1 1 1 LS 19613 1025 2 . . . 19613 1025 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1026 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1026 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1026 3 44 44 CD 19613 1026 4 : : : 19613 1026 5 See see VB 19613 1026 6 1 1 CD 19613 1026 7 . . . 19613 1026 8 c. c. NNP 19613 1026 9 14 14 CD 19613 1026 10 : : : 19613 1026 11 " " `` 19613 1026 12 Fides Fides NNPS 19613 1026 13 in in IN 19613 1026 14 regula regula NNP 19613 1026 15 posita posita NNP 19613 1026 16 est est NNP 19613 1026 17 , , , 19613 1026 18 habet habet NNP 19613 1026 19 legem legem NNP 19613 1026 20 et et NNP 19613 1026 21 salutem salutem NNP 19613 1026 22 de de NNP 19613 1026 23 observatione observatione NNP 19613 1026 24 legis legis NNP 19613 1026 25 , , , 19613 1026 26 " " '' 19613 1026 27 and and CC 19613 1026 28 de de NNP 19613 1026 29 vir vir NNP 19613 1026 30 . . . 19613 1027 1 vol vol NNP 19613 1027 2 . . . 19613 1028 1 1 1 LS 19613 1028 2 . . . 19613 1028 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1029 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1029 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1029 3 45 45 CD 19613 1029 4 : : : 19613 1029 5 See see VB 19613 1029 6 de de NNP 19613 1029 7 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1029 8 . . . 19613 1030 1 21 21 CD 19613 1030 2 : : : 19613 1030 3 " " `` 19613 1030 4 Si Si NNP 19613 1030 5 hæc hæc NNP 19613 1030 6 ita ita NNP 19613 1030 7 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1030 8 , , , 19613 1030 9 constat constat NNP 19613 1030 10 perinde perinde NNP 19613 1030 11 omnem omnem NNP 19613 1030 12 doctrinam doctrinam NNP 19613 1030 13 , , , 19613 1030 14 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1030 15 cum cum NNP 19613 1030 16 illis illis NNP 19613 1030 17 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 1030 18 apostolicis apostolicis NNP 19613 1030 19 matricibus matricibus NNP 19613 1030 20 et et NNP 19613 1030 21 originalibus originalibus NNP 19613 1030 22 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1030 23 conspiret conspiret NNP 19613 1030 24 , , , 19613 1030 25 veritati veritati NNP 19613 1030 26 deputandum deputandum NN 19613 1030 27 ... ... . 19613 1030 28 Superest superest IN 19613 1030 29 ergo ergo NN 19613 1030 30 ut ut UH 19613 1030 31 demonstremus demonstremus NN 19613 1030 32 an an DT 19613 1030 33 hæc hæc NNP 19613 1030 34 nostra nostra NNP 19613 1030 35 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 1030 36 , , , 19613 1030 37 cujus cujus NNP 19613 1030 38 regulam regulam NNP 19613 1030 39 supra supra NNP 19613 1030 40 edidimus edidimus NNP 19613 1030 41 , , , 19613 1030 42 de de NNP 19613 1030 43 apostolorum apostolorum NNP 19613 1030 44 traditione traditione NNP 19613 1030 45 censeatur censeatur NNP 19613 1030 46 ... ... : 19613 1030 47 Communicamus Communicamus NNP 19613 1030 48 cum cum NNP 19613 1030 49 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 1030 50 catholicis catholicis NNP 19613 1030 51 , , , 19613 1030 52 quod quod NN 19613 1030 53 nulla nulla NNP 19613 1030 54 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 1030 55 diversa diversa VBN 19613 1030 56 . . . 19613 1030 57 " " '' 19613 1031 1 De De NNP 19613 1031 2 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1031 3 . . . 19613 1032 1 32 32 CD 19613 1032 2 : : : 19613 1032 3 " " `` 19613 1032 4 Ecclesiæ Ecclesiæ NNP 19613 1032 5 , , , 19613 1032 6 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1032 7 licet licet NN 19613 1032 8 nullum nullum NNP 19613 1032 9 ex ex NNP 19613 1032 10 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1032 11 auctorem auctorem NNP 19613 1032 12 suum suum NNP 19613 1032 13 proferant proferant NNP 19613 1032 14 , , , 19613 1032 15 ut ut NNP 19613 1032 16 multo multo NNP 19613 1032 17 posteriores posteriores NNP 19613 1032 18 , , , 19613 1032 19 tamen taman NNS 19613 1032 20 in in IN 19613 1032 21 eadem eadem NN 19613 1032 22 fide fide NN 19613 1032 23 conspirantes conspirante VBZ 19613 1032 24 non non AFX 19613 1032 25 minus minus NNP 19613 1032 26 apostolicæ apostolicæ NNP 19613 1032 27 deputantur deputantur NNP 19613 1032 28 pro pro JJ 19613 1032 29 consanguinitate consanguinitate JJ 19613 1032 30 doctrinæ doctrinæ NNS 19613 1032 31 . . . 19613 1032 32 " " '' 19613 1033 1 That that IN 19613 1033 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1033 3 regards regard VBZ 19613 1033 4 the the DT 19613 1033 5 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1033 6 confession confession NN 19613 1033 7 as as IN 19613 1033 8 identical identical JJ 19613 1033 9 with with IN 19613 1033 10 the the DT 19613 1033 11 _ _ NNP 19613 1033 12 regula regula NN 19613 1033 13 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1033 14 _ _ NNP 19613 1033 15 , , , 19613 1033 16 just just RB 19613 1033 17 as as IN 19613 1033 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1033 19 does do VBZ 19613 1033 20 , , , 19613 1033 21 is be VBZ 19613 1033 22 shown show VBN 19613 1033 23 by by IN 19613 1033 24 the the DT 19613 1033 25 fact fact NN 19613 1033 26 that that IN 19613 1033 27 in in IN 19613 1033 28 de de FW 19613 1033 29 spectac spectac NNP 19613 1033 30 . . . 19613 1034 1 4 4 LS 19613 1034 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1034 3 " " `` 19613 1034 4 Cum Cum NNP 19613 1034 5 aquam aquam NNP 19613 1034 6 ingressi ingressi NNP 19613 1034 7 Christianam Christianam NNP 19613 1034 8 fidem fidem NN 19613 1034 9 in in IN 19613 1034 10 legis legis NNP 19613 1034 11 suæ suæ NNP 19613 1034 12 verba verba NNP 19613 1034 13 profitemur profitemur NNP 19613 1034 14 , , , 19613 1034 15 renuntiasse renuntiasse NNP 19613 1034 16 nos nos NNP 19613 1034 17 diabolo diabolo NNP 19613 1034 18 et et NNP 19613 1034 19 pompæ pompæ NNP 19613 1034 20 et et NNP 19613 1034 21 angelis angelis NNP 19613 1034 22 eius eius NNP 19613 1034 23 ore ore NNP 19613 1034 24 nostro nostro NNP 19613 1034 25 contestamur contestamur NNP 19613 1034 26 . . . 19613 1034 27 " " '' 19613 1034 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1035 1 the the DT 19613 1035 2 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 1035 3 confession confession NN 19613 1035 4 is be VBZ 19613 1035 5 the the DT 19613 1035 6 _ _ NNP 19613 1035 7 lex lex NN 19613 1035 8 _ _ NNP 19613 1035 9 . . . 19613 1036 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1036 2 also also RB 19613 1036 3 calls call VBZ 19613 1036 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1036 5 " " `` 19613 1036 6 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 1036 7 " " '' 19613 1036 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1036 9 military military JJ 19613 1036 10 oath oath NN 19613 1036 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1036 12 in in IN 19613 1036 13 ad ad NN 19613 1036 14 mart mart NNP 19613 1036 15 . . . 19613 1037 1 3 3 LS 19613 1037 2 ; ; : 19613 1037 3 de de NNP 19613 1037 4 idolol idolol NNP 19613 1037 5 . . . 19613 1038 1 6 6 CD 19613 1038 2 ; ; : 19613 1038 3 de de NNP 19613 1038 4 corona corona NNP 19613 1038 5 11 11 CD 19613 1038 6 ; ; : 19613 1038 7 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 1038 8 . . . 19613 1039 1 4 4 LS 19613 1039 2 . . . 19613 1040 1 But but CC 19613 1040 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1040 3 likewise likewise RB 19613 1040 4 gives give VBZ 19613 1040 5 the the DT 19613 1040 6 same same JJ 19613 1040 7 designation designation NN 19613 1040 8 to to IN 19613 1040 9 the the DT 19613 1040 10 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 1040 11 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 1040 12 confession confession NN 19613 1040 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1040 14 de de NNP 19613 1040 15 præscr præscr NNP 19613 1040 16 . . . 19613 1041 1 20 20 CD 19613 1041 2 , , , 19613 1041 3 32 32 CD 19613 1041 4 ; ; : 19613 1041 5 adv adv NN 19613 1041 6 . . . 19613 1042 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 1042 2 . . . 19613 1043 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1043 2 . . . 19613 1044 1 5 5 LS 19613 1044 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1044 3 ; ; : 19613 1044 4 for for IN 19613 1044 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1044 6 must must MD 19613 1044 7 regard regard VB 19613 1044 8 the the DT 19613 1044 9 passages passage NNS 19613 1044 10 cited cite VBN 19613 1044 11 as as IN 19613 1044 12 referring refer VBG 19613 1044 13 to to IN 19613 1044 14 this this DT 19613 1044 15 . . . 19613 1045 1 Adv Adv NNP 19613 1045 2 . . . 19613 1046 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 1046 2 . . . 19613 1047 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1048 1 21 21 CD 19613 1048 2 : : : 19613 1048 3 " " `` 19613 1048 4 regula regula NNP 19613 1048 5 sacramenti sacramenti NNP 19613 1048 6 ; ; : 19613 1048 7 " " `` 19613 1048 8 likewise likewise RB 19613 1048 9 V. V. NNP 19613 1048 10 20 20 CD 19613 1048 11 , , , 19613 1048 12 a a DT 19613 1048 13 passage passage NN 19613 1048 14 specially specially RB 19613 1048 15 instructive instructive JJ 19613 1048 16 as as IN 19613 1048 17 to to IN 19613 1048 18 the the DT 19613 1048 19 fact fact NN 19613 1048 20 that that IN 19613 1048 21 there there EX 19613 1048 22 can can MD 19613 1048 23 be be VB 19613 1048 24 only only RB 19613 1048 25 one one CD 19613 1048 26 regula regula NN 19613 1048 27 . . . 19613 1049 1 The the DT 19613 1049 2 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1049 3 confession confession NN 19613 1049 4 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1049 5 had have VBD 19613 1049 6 a a DT 19613 1049 7 fixed fixed JJ 19613 1049 8 and and CC 19613 1049 9 short short JJ 19613 1049 10 form form NN 19613 1049 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1049 12 see see VB 19613 1049 13 de de FW 19613 1049 14 spectac spectac NNP 19613 1049 15 . . . 19613 1050 1 4 4 LS 19613 1050 2 ; ; : 19613 1050 3 de de NNP 19613 1050 4 corona corona NNP 19613 1050 5 , , , 19613 1050 6 3 3 CD 19613 1050 7 : : : 19613 1050 8 " " `` 19613 1050 9 amplius amplius NNP 19613 1050 10 aliquid aliquid NNP 19613 1050 11 respondentes respondente NNS 19613 1050 12 quam quam NNP 19613 1050 13 dominus dominus NNP 19613 1050 14 in in IN 19613 1050 15 evangelio evangelio NNP 19613 1050 16 determinavit determinavit NNP 19613 1050 17 ; ; : 19613 1050 18 " " `` 19613 1050 19 de de FW 19613 1050 20 bapt bapt NNP 19613 1050 21 . . . 19613 1051 1 2 2 LS 19613 1051 2 : : : 19613 1051 3 " " `` 19613 1051 4 homo homo NNP 19613 1051 5 in in IN 19613 1051 6 aqua aqua NNP 19613 1051 7 demissus demissus NNP 19613 1051 8 et et NNP 19613 1051 9 inter inter NNP 19613 1051 10 pauca pauca NNP 19613 1051 11 verba verba NNP 19613 1051 12 tinctus tinctus NNP 19613 1051 13 ; ; : 19613 1051 14 " " '' 19613 1051 15 de de FW 19613 1051 16 bapt bapt NNP 19613 1051 17 . . . 19613 1052 1 6 6 CD 19613 1052 2 , , , 19613 1052 3 11 11 CD 19613 1052 4 ; ; : 19613 1052 5 de de FW 19613 1052 6 orat orat NNP 19613 1052 7 . . . 19613 1053 1 2 2 CD 19613 1053 2 etc etc FW 19613 1053 3 . . . 19613 1053 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1053 5 . . . 19613 1054 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1054 2 can can MD 19613 1054 3 still still RB 19613 1054 4 prove prove VB 19613 1054 5 that that IN 19613 1054 6 , , , 19613 1054 7 apart apart RB 19613 1054 8 from from IN 19613 1054 9 a a DT 19613 1054 10 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 1054 11 alteration alteration NN 19613 1054 12 , , , 19613 1054 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1054 14 was be VBD 19613 1054 15 the the DT 19613 1054 16 Roman roman JJ 19613 1054 17 confession confession NN 19613 1054 18 that that WDT 19613 1054 19 was be VBD 19613 1054 20 used use VBN 19613 1054 21 in in IN 19613 1054 22 Carthage carthage NN 19613 1054 23 in in IN 19613 1054 24 the the DT 19613 1054 25 days day NNS 19613 1054 26 of of IN 19613 1054 27 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1054 28 . . . 19613 1055 1 In in IN 19613 1055 2 de de NNP 19613 1055 3 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1055 4 . . . 19613 1056 1 26 26 CD 19613 1056 2 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 1056 3 admits admit VBZ 19613 1056 4 that that IN 19613 1056 5 the the DT 19613 1056 6 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1056 7 may may MD 19613 1056 8 have have VB 19613 1056 9 spoken speak VBN 19613 1056 10 some some DT 19613 1056 11 things thing NNS 19613 1056 12 " " `` 19613 1056 13 inter inter JJ 19613 1056 14 domesticos domesticos NNP 19613 1056 15 , , , 19613 1056 16 " " '' 19613 1056 17 but but CC 19613 1056 18 declares declare VBZ 19613 1056 19 that that IN 19613 1056 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1056 21 could could MD 19613 1056 22 not not RB 19613 1056 23 be be VB 19613 1056 24 communications communication NNS 19613 1056 25 " " `` 19613 1056 26 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1056 27 aliam aliam NNP 19613 1056 28 regulam regulam NNP 19613 1056 29 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1056 30 superducerent superducerent NN 19613 1056 31 . . . 19613 1056 32 " " '' 19613 1056 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1057 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1057 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1057 3 46 46 CD 19613 1057 4 : : : 19613 1057 5 De De NNP 19613 1057 6 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1057 7 . . . 19613 1058 1 13 13 CD 19613 1058 2 ; ; : 19613 1058 3 de de NNP 19613 1058 4 virg virg NNS 19613 1058 5 . . . 19613 1059 1 vol vol NNP 19613 1059 2 . . . 19613 1060 1 1 1 LS 19613 1060 2 ; ; : 19613 1060 3 adv adv NN 19613 1060 4 . . . 19613 1061 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 1061 2 . . . 19613 1062 1 2 2 LS 19613 1062 2 . . . 19613 1063 1 The the DT 19613 1063 2 latter latter JJ 19613 1063 3 passage passage NN 19613 1063 4 is be VBZ 19613 1063 5 thus thus RB 19613 1063 6 worded word VBN 19613 1063 7 : : : 19613 1063 8 " " `` 19613 1063 9 Unicum Unicum NNP 19613 1063 10 quidem quidem NN 19613 1063 11 deum deum NN 19613 1063 12 credimus credimus NNP 19613 1063 13 , , , 19613 1063 14 sub sub NNP 19613 1063 15 hac hac NNP 19613 1063 16 tamen tamen VBZ 19613 1063 17 dispensatione dispensatione NNP 19613 1063 18 quam quam NNP 19613 1063 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1063 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1063 21 : : : 19613 1063 22 oikonomian oikonomian NNP 19613 1063 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1063 24 dicimus dicimus NNP 19613 1063 25 , , , 19613 1063 26 ut ut UH 19613 1063 27 unici unici NNP 19613 1063 28 del del NNP 19613 1063 29 sit sit NNP 19613 1063 30 et et NNP 19613 1063 31 filius filius NNP 19613 1063 32 sermo sermo NNP 19613 1063 33 ipsius ipsius NNP 19613 1063 34 , , , 19613 1063 35 qui qui VBD 19613 1063 36 ex ex FW 19613 1063 37 ipso ipso FW 19613 1063 38 processerit processerit NN 19613 1063 39 , , , 19613 1063 40 per per IN 19613 1063 41 quern quern NNP 19613 1063 42 omnia omnia NNP 19613 1063 43 facta facta NNP 19613 1063 44 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1063 45 et et NNP 19613 1063 46 sine sine NNP 19613 1063 47 quo quo NNP 19613 1063 48 factum factum NNP 19613 1063 49 est est NNP 19613 1063 50 nihil nihil NNP 19613 1063 51 , , , 19613 1063 52 hunc hunc NNP 19613 1063 53 missum missum VBD 19613 1063 54 a a DT 19613 1063 55 patre patre NN 19613 1063 56 in in IN 19613 1063 57 virginem virginem NNP 19613 1063 58 et et FW 19613 1063 59 ex ex NNP 19613 1063 60 ea ea NNP 19613 1063 61 natum natum NNP 19613 1063 62 , , , 19613 1063 63 hominem hominem NNP 19613 1063 64 et et NNP 19613 1063 65 deum deum NNP 19613 1063 66 , , , 19613 1063 67 filium filium NN 19613 1063 68 hominis hominis NNP 19613 1063 69 et et NNP 19613 1063 70 filium filium NN 19613 1063 71 dei dei NNP 19613 1063 72 et et NNP 19613 1063 73 cognominatum cognominatum NN 19613 1063 74 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 1063 75 Christum Christum NNP 19613 1063 76 , , , 19613 1063 77 hunc hunc JJ 19613 1063 78 passum passum NN 19613 1063 79 , , , 19613 1063 80 hunc hunc NNP 19613 1063 81 mortuum mortuum NNP 19613 1063 82 et et NNP 19613 1063 83 sepultum sepultum NNP 19613 1063 84 secundum secundum NNP 19613 1063 85 scripturas scripturas NNP 19613 1063 86 et et NNP 19613 1063 87 resuscitatum resuscitatum NNP 19613 1063 88 a a DT 19613 1063 89 patre patre NN 19613 1063 90 et et NNP 19613 1063 91 in in IN 19613 1063 92 coelo coelo NNP 19613 1063 93 resumptum resumptum NNP 19613 1063 94 sedere sedere NNP 19613 1063 95 ad ad NN 19613 1063 96 dextram dextram NNP 19613 1063 97 patris patris NNP 19613 1063 98 , , , 19613 1063 99 venturum venturum NNP 19613 1063 100 judicare judicare NNP 19613 1063 101 vivos vivos NNP 19613 1063 102 et et NNP 19613 1063 103 mortuos mortuos NN 19613 1063 104 ; ; : 19613 1063 105 qui qui NNP 19613 1063 106 exinde exinde NNP 19613 1063 107 miserit miserit NNP 19613 1063 108 secundum secundum NNP 19613 1063 109 promissionem promissionem NNP 19613 1063 110 suam suam NNP 19613 1063 111 a a DT 19613 1063 112 patre patre NN 19613 1063 113 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 1063 114 s. s. NNP 19613 1063 115 paracletum paracletum NNP 19613 1063 116 sanctificatorem sanctificatorem VB 19613 1063 117 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1063 118 eorum eorum NNP 19613 1063 119 qui qui NNP 19613 1063 120 credunt credunt VB 19613 1063 121 in in IN 19613 1063 122 patrem patrem NN 19613 1063 123 et et NNP 19613 1063 124 filium filium NN 19613 1063 125 et et NNP 19613 1063 126 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 1063 127 s. s. NNP 19613 1063 128 Hanc Hanc NNP 19613 1063 129 regulam regulam JJ 19613 1063 130 ab ab NNP 19613 1063 131 initio initio NNP 19613 1063 132 evangelii evangelii NNP 19613 1063 133 decucurrisse decucurrisse NNP 19613 1063 134 . . . 19613 1063 135 " " '' 19613 1063 136 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1064 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1064 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1064 3 47 47 CD 19613 1064 4 : : : 19613 1064 5 De De NNP 19613 1064 6 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1064 7 . . . 19613 1065 1 13 13 CD 19613 1065 2 . . . 19613 1065 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1066 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1066 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1066 3 48 48 CD 19613 1066 4 : : : 19613 1066 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 1066 6 . . . 19613 1066 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1067 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1067 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1067 3 49 49 CD 19613 1067 4 : : : 19613 1067 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 1067 6 . . . 19613 1067 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1068 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1068 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1068 3 50 50 CD 19613 1068 4 : : : 19613 1068 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 1068 6 . . . 19613 1069 1 : : : 19613 1069 2 " " `` 19613 1069 3 i -PRON- PRP 19613 1069 4 d d NNP 19613 1069 5 verbum verbum NNP 19613 1069 6 filium filium NNP 19613 1069 7 eius eius NNP 19613 1069 8 appellatum appellatum NNP 19613 1069 9 , , , 19613 1069 10 in in IN 19613 1069 11 nomine nomine NNP 19613 1069 12 dei dei NNP 19613 1069 13 varie varie NNP 19613 1069 14 visum visum NNP 19613 1069 15 a a DT 19613 1069 16 patriarchis patriarchis NN 19613 1069 17 , , , 19613 1069 18 in in IN 19613 1069 19 prophetis prophetis NN 19613 1069 20 semper semper NNP 19613 1069 21 auditum auditum NNP 19613 1069 22 , , , 19613 1069 23 postremo postremo NNP 19613 1069 24 delatum delatum NNP 19613 1069 25 ex ex NNP 19613 1069 26 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 1069 27 patris patris NNP 19613 1069 28 dei dei NNP 19613 1069 29 et et NNP 19613 1069 30 virtute virtute NNP 19613 1069 31 in in IN 19613 1069 32 virginem virginem NNP 19613 1069 33 Mariam Mariam NNP 19613 1069 34 , , , 19613 1069 35 carnem carnem VBP 19613 1069 36 factum factum NN 19613 1069 37 , , , 19613 1069 38 " " `` 19613 1069 39 etc etc FW 19613 1069 40 . . . 19613 1069 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1070 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1070 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1070 3 51 51 CD 19613 1070 4 : : : 19613 1070 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 1070 6 . . . 19613 1070 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1071 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1071 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1071 3 52 52 CD 19613 1071 4 : : : 19613 1071 5 Adv Adv NNP 19613 1071 6 . . . 19613 1072 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 1072 2 . . . 19613 1073 1 2 2 LS 19613 1073 2 : : : 19613 1073 3 " " `` 19613 1073 4 Unicum Unicum NNP 19613 1073 5 quidem quidem NN 19613 1073 6 deum deum NN 19613 1073 7 credimus credimus NNP 19613 1073 8 , , , 19613 1073 9 sub sub NNP 19613 1073 10 hac hac NNP 19613 1073 11 tamen tamen VBZ 19613 1073 12 dispensatione dispensatione NNP 19613 1073 13 quam quam NNP 19613 1073 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1073 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1073 16 : : : 19613 1073 17 oikonomian oikonomian NNP 19613 1073 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1073 19 dicimus dicimus NNP 19613 1073 20 , , , 19613 1073 21 ut ut UH 19613 1073 22 unici unici NNP 19613 1073 23 dei dei NNP 19613 1073 24 sit sit NNP 19613 1073 25 et et NNP 19613 1073 26 filius filius NNP 19613 1073 27 sermo sermo NNP 19613 1073 28 ipsius ipsius NNP 19613 1073 29 , , , 19613 1073 30 " " '' 19613 1073 31 etc etc FW 19613 1073 32 . . . 19613 1073 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1074 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1074 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1074 3 53 53 CD 19613 1074 4 : : : 19613 1074 5 But but CC 19613 1074 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1074 7 also also RB 19613 1074 8 knows know VBZ 19613 1074 9 of of IN 19613 1074 10 a a DT 19613 1074 11 " " `` 19613 1074 12 regula regula JJ 19613 1074 13 disciplinæ disciplinæ NN 19613 1074 14 " " '' 19613 1074 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1074 16 according accord VBG 19613 1074 17 to to IN 19613 1074 18 the the DT 19613 1074 19 New New NNP 19613 1074 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1074 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1074 22 on on IN 19613 1074 23 which which WDT 19613 1074 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1074 25 puts put VBZ 19613 1074 26 great great JJ 19613 1074 27 value value NN 19613 1074 28 , , , 19613 1074 29 and and CC 19613 1074 30 thereby thereby RB 19613 1074 31 shows show VBZ 19613 1074 32 that that IN 19613 1074 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1074 34 has have VBZ 19613 1074 35 by by IN 19613 1074 36 no no DT 19613 1074 37 means means NN 19613 1074 38 forgotten forget VBN 19613 1074 39 that that IN 19613 1074 40 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1074 41 is be VBZ 19613 1074 42 a a DT 19613 1074 43 matter matter NN 19613 1074 44 of of IN 19613 1074 45 conduct conduct NN 19613 1074 46 . . . 19613 1075 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1075 2 can can MD 19613 1075 3 not not RB 19613 1075 4 enter enter VB 19613 1075 5 more more RBR 19613 1075 6 particularly particularly RB 19613 1075 7 into into IN 19613 1075 8 this this DT 19613 1075 9 rule rule NN 19613 1075 10 here here RB 19613 1075 11 . . . 19613 1075 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1076 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1076 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1076 3 54 54 CD 19613 1076 4 : : : 19613 1076 5 Note note VB 19613 1076 6 here here RB 19613 1076 7 the the DT 19613 1076 8 use use NN 19613 1076 9 of of IN 19613 1076 10 " " `` 19613 1076 11 contesserare contesserare NN 19613 1076 12 " " '' 19613 1076 13 in in IN 19613 1076 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1076 15 . . . 19613 1077 1 See see VB 19613 1077 2 de de NNP 19613 1077 3 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1077 4 . . . 19613 1078 1 20 20 CD 19613 1078 2 : : : 19613 1078 3 " " `` 19613 1078 4 Itaque itaque JJ 19613 1078 5 tot tot NN 19613 1078 6 ac ac NNP 19613 1078 7 tantæ tantæ NNP 19613 1078 8 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 1078 9 una una NNP 19613 1078 10 est est VBD 19613 1078 11 illa illa RB 19613 1078 12 ab ab NNP 19613 1078 13 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1078 14 prima prima NNP 19613 1078 15 , , , 19613 1078 16 ex ex FW 19613 1078 17 qua qua NNP 19613 1078 18 omnes omne NNS 19613 1078 19 . . . 19613 1079 1 Sic Sic NNP 19613 1079 2 omnes omne NNS 19613 1079 3 prima prima VBP 19613 1079 4 et et NNP 19613 1079 5 omnes omnes NNP 19613 1079 6 apostolicæ apostolicæ NNP 19613 1079 7 , , , 19613 1079 8 dum dum NNP 19613 1079 9 una una NNP 19613 1079 10 omnes omne NNS 19613 1079 11 . . . 19613 1080 1 Probant probant JJ 19613 1080 2 unitatem unitatem NN 19613 1080 3 communicatio communicatio NN 19613 1080 4 pacis pacis NNP 19613 1080 5 et et NNP 19613 1080 6 appellatio appellatio NNP 19613 1080 7 fraternitatis fraternitatis NNP 19613 1080 8 et et NNP 19613 1080 9 _ _ NNP 19613 1080 10 contesseratio contesseratio NN 19613 1080 11 _ _ NNP 19613 1080 12 hospitalitatis hospitalitatis NN 19613 1080 13 , , , 19613 1080 14 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1080 15 iura iura NNP 19613 1080 16 non non PRP$ 19613 1080 17 alia alia NNP 19613 1080 18 ratio ratio NNP 19613 1080 19 regit regit NNP 19613 1080 20 quam quam NNP 19613 1080 21 eiusdem eiusdem NNP 19613 1080 22 sacramenti sacramenti NNP 19613 1080 23 una una NNP 19613 1080 24 traditio traditio NN 19613 1080 25 . . . 19613 1080 26 " " '' 19613 1081 1 De De NNP 19613 1081 2 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1081 3 . . . 19613 1082 1 36 36 CD 19613 1082 2 : : : 19613 1082 3 " " `` 19613 1082 4 Videamus Videamus NNP 19613 1082 5 , , , 19613 1082 6 quid quid NNP 19613 1082 7 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 1082 8 Romanensis Romanensis NNP 19613 1082 9 cum cum NNP 19613 1082 10 Africanis Africanis NNP 19613 1082 11 ecclesiis ecclesiis NN 19613 1082 12 contesserarit contesserarit NN 19613 1082 13 . . . 19613 1082 14 " " '' 19613 1082 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1083 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1083 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1083 3 55 55 CD 19613 1083 4 : : : 19613 1083 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1083 6 need need VBP 19613 1083 7 not not RB 19613 1083 8 here here RB 19613 1083 9 discuss discuss VB 19613 1083 10 whether whether IN 19613 1083 11 and and CC 19613 1083 12 in in IN 19613 1083 13 what what WDT 19613 1083 14 way way NN 19613 1083 15 the the DT 19613 1083 16 model model NN 19613 1083 17 of of IN 19613 1083 18 the the DT 19613 1083 19 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 1083 20 schools school NNS 19613 1083 21 was be VBD 19613 1083 22 taken take VBN 19613 1083 23 as as IN 19613 1083 24 a a DT 19613 1083 25 standard standard NN 19613 1083 26 . . . 19613 1084 1 But but CC 19613 1084 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1084 3 may may MD 19613 1084 4 refer refer VB 19613 1084 5 to to IN 19613 1084 6 the the DT 19613 1084 7 fact fact NN 19613 1084 8 that that IN 19613 1084 9 from from IN 19613 1084 10 the the DT 19613 1084 11 middle middle NN 19613 1084 12 of of IN 19613 1084 13 the the DT 19613 1084 14 second second JJ 19613 1084 15 century century NN 19613 1084 16 the the DT 19613 1084 17 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 1084 18 , , , 19613 1084 19 that that DT 19613 1084 20 is be VBZ 19613 1084 21 the the DT 19613 1084 22 Christian christian JJ 19613 1084 23 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 1084 24 , , , 19613 1084 25 had have VBD 19613 1084 26 exercised exercise VBN 19613 1084 27 a a DT 19613 1084 28 very very RB 19613 1084 29 great great JJ 19613 1084 30 influence influence NN 19613 1084 31 on on IN 19613 1084 32 the the DT 19613 1084 33 Old Old NNP 19613 1084 34 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1084 35 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 1084 36 . . . 19613 1085 1 But but CC 19613 1085 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1085 3 can can MD 19613 1085 4 not not RB 19613 1085 5 say say VB 19613 1085 6 that that IN 19613 1085 7 2 2 CD 19613 1085 8 . . . 19613 1086 1 John John NNP 19613 1086 2 7 7 CD 19613 1086 3 - - SYM 19613 1086 4 11 11 CD 19613 1086 5 and and CC 19613 1086 6 Didache Didache NNP 19613 1086 7 XI XI NNP 19613 1086 8 . . . 19613 1087 1 1 1 CD 19613 1087 2 f. f. NNP 19613 1087 3 attest attest VBP 19613 1087 4 the the DT 19613 1087 5 practice practice NN 19613 1087 6 to to TO 19613 1087 7 be be VB 19613 1087 8 a a DT 19613 1087 9 very very RB 19613 1087 10 old old JJ 19613 1087 11 one one CD 19613 1087 12 . . . 19613 1088 1 These these DT 19613 1088 2 passages passage NNS 19613 1088 3 only only RB 19613 1088 4 show show VBP 19613 1088 5 that that IN 19613 1088 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1088 7 had have VBD 19613 1088 8 preparatory preparatory JJ 19613 1088 9 stages stage NNS 19613 1088 10 ; ; : 19613 1088 11 the the DT 19613 1088 12 main main JJ 19613 1088 13 element element NN 19613 1088 14 , , , 19613 1088 15 namely namely RB 19613 1088 16 , , , 19613 1088 17 the the DT 19613 1088 18 formulated formulated JJ 19613 1088 19 summary summary NN 19613 1088 20 of of IN 19613 1088 21 the the DT 19613 1088 22 faith faith NN 19613 1088 23 , , , 19613 1088 24 is be VBZ 19613 1088 25 there there EX 19613 1088 26 sought seek VBN 19613 1088 27 for for IN 19613 1088 28 in in IN 19613 1088 29 vain vain JJ 19613 1088 30 . . . 19613 1088 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1089 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1089 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1089 3 56 56 CD 19613 1089 4 : : : 19613 1089 5 Herein Herein NNP 19613 1089 6 lay lie VBD 19613 1089 7 the the DT 19613 1089 8 defect defect NN 19613 1089 9 , , , 19613 1089 10 even even RB 19613 1089 11 if if IN 19613 1089 12 the the DT 19613 1089 13 content content NN 19613 1089 14 of of IN 19613 1089 15 the the DT 19613 1089 16 law law NN 19613 1089 17 of of IN 19613 1089 18 faith faith NN 19613 1089 19 had have VBD 19613 1089 20 coincided coincide VBN 19613 1089 21 completely completely RB 19613 1089 22 with with IN 19613 1089 23 the the DT 19613 1089 24 earliest early JJS 19613 1089 25 tradition tradition NN 19613 1089 26 . . . 19613 1090 1 A a DT 19613 1090 2 man man NN 19613 1090 3 like like IN 19613 1090 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1090 5 knew know VBD 19613 1090 6 how how WRB 19613 1090 7 to to TO 19613 1090 8 protect protect VB 19613 1090 9 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1090 10 in in IN 19613 1090 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1090 12 own own JJ 19613 1090 13 way way NN 19613 1090 14 from from IN 19613 1090 15 this this DT 19613 1090 16 defect defect NN 19613 1090 17 , , , 19613 1090 18 but but CC 19613 1090 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1090 20 attitude attitude NN 19613 1090 21 is be VBZ 19613 1090 22 not not RB 19613 1090 23 typical typical JJ 19613 1090 24 . . . 19613 1090 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1091 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1091 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1091 3 57 57 CD 19613 1091 4 : : : 19613 1091 5 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 1091 6 , , , 19613 1091 7 who who WP 19613 1091 8 wrote write VBD 19613 1091 9 about about IN 19613 1091 10 the the DT 19613 1091 11 time time NN 19613 1091 12 of of IN 19613 1091 13 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 19613 1091 14 , , , 19613 1091 15 and and CC 19613 1091 16 was be VBD 19613 1091 17 in in IN 19613 1091 18 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1091 19 about about IN 19613 1091 20 the the DT 19613 1091 21 middle middle NN 19613 1091 22 of of IN 19613 1091 23 the the DT 19613 1091 24 second second JJ 19613 1091 25 century century NN 19613 1091 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1091 27 probably probably RB 19613 1091 28 somewhat somewhat RB 19613 1091 29 earlier early RBR 19613 1091 30 than than IN 19613 1091 31 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1091 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1091 33 , , , 19613 1091 34 already already RB 19613 1091 35 set set VBD 19613 1091 36 up up RP 19613 1091 37 the the DT 19613 1091 38 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1091 39 rule rule NN 19613 1091 40 of of IN 19613 1091 41 faith faith NN 19613 1091 42 as as IN 19613 1091 43 a a DT 19613 1091 44 standard standard NN 19613 1091 45 . . . 19613 1092 1 This this DT 19613 1092 2 is be VBZ 19613 1092 3 clear clear JJ 19613 1092 4 from from IN 19613 1092 5 the the DT 19613 1092 6 description description NN 19613 1092 7 of of IN 19613 1092 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1092 9 work work NN 19613 1092 10 in in IN 19613 1092 11 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1092 12 . . NNP 19613 1092 13 , , , 19613 1092 14 H. H. NNP 19613 1092 15 E. E. NNP 19613 1092 16 IV IV NNP 19613 1092 17 . . . 19613 1093 1 8 8 LS 19613 1093 2 . . . 19613 1094 1 2 2 LS 19613 1094 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1094 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1094 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1094 5 : : : 19613 1094 6 en en IN 19613 1094 7 pente pente NNP 19613 1094 8 sungrammasin sungrammasin NN 19613 1094 9 tên tên NNP 19613 1094 10 aplanê aplanê NNP 19613 1094 11 paradosin paradosin NNP 19613 1094 12 tou tou NNP 19613 1094 13 apostolikou apostolikou NNP 19613 1094 14 kêrygmatos kêrygmatos NNP 19613 1094 15 hypomnêmatisamenos hypomnêmatisamenos NNP 19613 1094 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1094 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1094 18 as as RB 19613 1094 19 well well RB 19613 1094 20 as as IN 19613 1094 21 from from IN 19613 1094 22 the the DT 19613 1094 23 fragments fragment NNS 19613 1094 24 of of IN 19613 1094 25 this this DT 19613 1094 26 work work NN 19613 1094 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1094 28 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1094 29 . . . 19613 1095 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1095 2 . . . 19613 1096 1 22 22 CD 19613 1096 2 . . . 19613 1097 1 2 2 CD 19613 1097 2 , , , 19613 1097 3 3 3 CD 19613 1097 4 : : : 19613 1097 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1097 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1097 7 : : : 19613 1097 8 ho ho NNP 19613 1097 9 orthos orthos NNP 19613 1097 10 logos logos NNP 19613 1097 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1097 12 and and CC 19613 1097 13 § § -LRB- 19613 1097 14 5 5 CD 19613 1097 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1097 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1097 17 : : : 19613 1097 18 emerisan emerisan NNP 19613 1097 19 tên tên NNP 19613 1097 20 henôsin henôsin NNP 19613 1097 21 tês tês NNP 19613 1097 22 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1097 23 phthorimaiois phthorimaiois NNP 19613 1097 24 logois logois NNP 19613 1097 25 kata kata NNP 19613 1097 26 tou tou NNP 19613 1097 27 theou theou NNP 19613 1097 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1097 29 ; ; : 19613 1097 30 see see VB 19613 1097 31 also also RB 19613 1097 32 § § CD 19613 1097 33 4 4 CD 19613 1097 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1097 35 . . . 19613 1098 1 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 1098 2 already already RB 19613 1098 3 regarded regard VBD 19613 1098 4 the the DT 19613 1098 5 unity unity NN 19613 1098 6 of of IN 19613 1098 7 the the DT 19613 1098 8 Church Church NNP 19613 1098 9 as as RB 19613 1098 10 dependent dependent JJ 19613 1098 11 on on IN 19613 1098 12 the the DT 19613 1098 13 correct correct JJ 19613 1098 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 1098 15 . . . 19613 1099 1 Polycrates Polycrates NNP 19613 1099 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1099 3 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1099 4 . . NNP 19613 1099 5 , , , 19613 1099 6 H. H. NNP 19613 1099 7 E. E. NNP 19613 1099 8 V. V. NNP 19613 1099 9 24 24 CD 19613 1099 10 . . . 19613 1100 1 6 6 LS 19613 1100 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1100 3 used use VBD 19613 1100 4 the the DT 19613 1100 5 expression expression NN 19613 1100 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1100 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1100 8 : : : 19613 1100 9 ho ho NNP 19613 1100 10 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 1100 11 tês tês NNP 19613 1100 12 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 1100 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1100 14 in in IN 19613 1100 15 a a DT 19613 1100 16 very very RB 19613 1100 17 wide wide JJ 19613 1100 18 sense sense NN 19613 1100 19 . . . 19613 1101 1 But but CC 19613 1101 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1101 3 may may MD 19613 1101 4 beyond beyond IN 19613 1101 5 doubt doubt NN 19613 1101 6 attribute attribute VB 19613 1101 7 to to IN 19613 1101 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1101 9 the the DT 19613 1101 10 same same JJ 19613 1101 11 conception conception NN 19613 1101 12 with with IN 19613 1101 13 regard regard NN 19613 1101 14 to to IN 19613 1101 15 the the DT 19613 1101 16 significance significance NN 19613 1101 17 of of IN 19613 1101 18 the the DT 19613 1101 19 rule rule NN 19613 1101 20 of of IN 19613 1101 21 faith faith NN 19613 1101 22 as as IN 19613 1101 23 was be VBD 19613 1101 24 held hold VBN 19613 1101 25 by by IN 19613 1101 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1101 27 opponent opponent NN 19613 1101 28 Victor Victor NNP 19613 1101 29 . . . 19613 1102 1 The the DT 19613 1102 2 Antimontanist Antimontanist NNP 19613 1102 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1102 4 in in IN 19613 1102 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1102 6 . . . 19613 1103 1 H. H. NNP 19613 1103 2 E. E. NNP 19613 1103 3 V. V. NNP 19613 1103 4 16 16 CD 19613 1103 5 . . . 19613 1104 1 22 22 CD 19613 1104 2 . . . 19613 1104 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1105 1 will will MD 19613 1105 2 only only RB 19613 1105 3 allow allow VB 19613 1105 4 that that IN 19613 1105 5 the the DT 19613 1105 6 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 1105 7 who who WP 19613 1105 8 went go VBD 19613 1105 9 to to IN 19613 1105 10 death death NN 19613 1105 11 for for IN 19613 1105 12 the the DT 19613 1105 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1105 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1105 15 : : : 19613 1105 16 kata kata NNP 19613 1105 17 alêtheian alêtheian JJ 19613 1105 18 pistis pistis NN 19613 1105 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1105 20 were be VBD 19613 1105 21 those those DT 19613 1105 22 belonging belong VBG 19613 1105 23 to to IN 19613 1105 24 the the DT 19613 1105 25 Church Church NNP 19613 1105 26 . . . 19613 1106 1 The the DT 19613 1106 2 _ _ NNP 19613 1106 3 regula regula NN 19613 1106 4 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1106 5 _ _ NNP 19613 1106 6 is be VBZ 19613 1106 7 not not RB 19613 1106 8 here here RB 19613 1106 9 meant mean VBN 19613 1106 10 , , , 19613 1106 11 as as IN 19613 1106 12 in in IN 19613 1106 13 this this DT 19613 1106 14 case case NN 19613 1106 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1106 16 was be VBD 19613 1106 17 not not RB 19613 1106 18 a a DT 19613 1106 19 subject subject NN 19613 1106 20 of of IN 19613 1106 21 dispute dispute NN 19613 1106 22 . . . 19613 1107 1 On on IN 19613 1107 2 the the DT 19613 1107 3 other other JJ 19613 1107 4 hand hand NN 19613 1107 5 , , , 19613 1107 6 the the DT 19613 1107 7 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 1107 8 writer writer NN 19613 1107 9 in in IN 19613 1107 10 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 1107 11 , , , 19613 1107 12 H. H. NNP 19613 1107 13 E. E. NNP 19613 1107 14 V. V. NNP 19613 1107 15 28 28 CD 19613 1107 16 . . . 19613 1108 1 6 6 CD 19613 1108 2 , , , 19613 1108 3 13 13 CD 19613 1108 4 understood understand VBN 19613 1108 5 by by IN 19613 1108 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1108 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1108 8 : : : 19613 1108 9 to to TO 19613 1108 10 ekklêsiastikon ekklêsiastikon VB 19613 1108 11 phronêma phronêma NN 19613 1108 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1108 13 or or CC 19613 1108 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1108 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1108 16 : : : 19613 1108 17 ho ho NNP 19613 1108 18 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 1108 19 tês tês NNP 19613 1108 20 archaias archaias NNP 19613 1108 21 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 1108 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1108 23 the the DT 19613 1108 24 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 1108 25 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 1108 26 confession confession NN 19613 1108 27 , , , 19613 1108 28 just just RB 19613 1108 29 as as IN 19613 1108 30 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1108 31 and and CC 19613 1108 32 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1108 33 did do VBD 19613 1108 34 . . . 19613 1109 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 1109 2 entirely entirely RB 19613 1109 3 agrees agree VBZ 19613 1109 4 with with IN 19613 1109 5 these these DT 19613 1109 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1109 7 see see VB 19613 1109 8 Philosoph Philosoph NNP 19613 1109 9 . . . 19613 1110 1 Præf Præf NNP 19613 1110 2 . . NNP 19613 1110 3 , , , 19613 1110 4 p. p. NN 19613 1110 5 4 4 CD 19613 1110 6 . . . 19613 1110 7 v. v. CC 19613 1110 8 50 50 CD 19613 1110 9 sq sq NN 19613 1110 10 . . . 19613 1111 1 and and CC 19613 1111 2 X. X. NNP 19613 1112 1 32 32 CD 19613 1112 2 - - SYM 19613 1112 3 34 34 CD 19613 1112 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1112 5 . . . 19613 1113 1 Whether whether IN 19613 1113 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1113 3 are be VBP 19613 1113 4 to to TO 19613 1113 5 ascribe ascribe VB 19613 1113 6 the the DT 19613 1113 7 theory theory NN 19613 1113 8 of of IN 19613 1113 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1113 10 to to IN 19613 1113 11 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 1113 12 is be VBZ 19613 1113 13 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 1113 14 . . . 19613 1114 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1114 2 idea idea NN 19613 1114 3 of of IN 19613 1114 4 the the DT 19613 1114 5 Church Church NNP 19613 1114 6 is be VBZ 19613 1114 7 that that DT 19613 1114 8 of of IN 19613 1114 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1114 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1114 11 ad ad NN 19613 1114 12 Autol Autol NNP 19613 1114 13 . . . 19613 1115 1 II ii CD 19613 1115 2 . . . 19613 1116 1 14 14 CD 19613 1116 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1116 3 : : : 19613 1116 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1116 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1116 6 : : : 19613 1116 7 dedôken dedôken JJ 19613 1116 8 ho ho NNP 19613 1116 9 Theos Theos NNP 19613 1116 10 tô tô CC 19613 1116 11 kosmô kosmô NNP 19613 1116 12 kumainomenô kumainomenô NNP 19613 1116 13 kai kai NNP 19613 1116 14 cheimazomenô cheimazomenô NNP 19613 1116 15 hypo hypo NNP 19613 1116 16 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1116 17 hamartêmatôn hamartêmatôn NNP 19613 1116 18 tas tas NNP 19613 1116 19 synagôgas synagôgas NNP 19613 1116 20 , , , 19613 1116 21 legomenas legomenas NNP 19613 1116 22 de de NNP 19613 1116 23 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1116 24 hagias hagias NNP 19613 1116 25 , , , 19613 1116 26 en en IN 19613 1116 27 ais ais NNP 19613 1116 28 kathaper kathaper NNP 19613 1116 29 limesin limesin NNP 19613 1116 30 euormois euormois NNP 19613 1116 31 en en IN 19613 1116 32 nêsois nêsois NNP 19613 1116 33 hai hai NNP 19613 1116 34 didaskaliai didaskaliai NNP 19613 1116 35 tês tês NNP 19613 1116 36 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 1116 37 eisin eisin NNP 19613 1116 38 ... ... : 19613 1116 39 Kai Kai NNP 19613 1116 40 hôsper hôsper NN 19613 1116 41 au au NNP 19613 1116 42 nêsoi nêsoi NNP 19613 1116 43 eisin eisin NNP 19613 1116 44 heterai heterai NNP 19613 1116 45 petrôdeis petrôdeis NNP 19613 1116 46 kai kai NNP 19613 1116 47 anudroi anudroi NNP 19613 1116 48 kai kai NNP 19613 1116 49 akarpoi akarpoi NNP 19613 1116 50 kai kai NNP 19613 1116 51 thêriôdeis thêriôdeis NNP 19613 1116 52 kai kai NNP 19613 1116 53 aoikêtoi aoikêtoi NNP 19613 1116 54 epi epi NNP 19613 1116 55 blabê blabê NNP 19613 1116 56 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1116 57 pleontôn pleontôn NNP 19613 1116 58 ... ... NFP 19613 1116 59 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 1116 60 eisin eisin NNP 19613 1116 61 hai hai NNP 19613 1116 62 didaskaliai didaskaliai NNP 19613 1116 63 tês tês NNP 19613 1116 64 planês planês NNP 19613 1116 65 , , , 19613 1116 66 legô legô NNP 19613 1116 67 de de NNP 19613 1116 68 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1116 69 haireseôn haireseôn NNP 19613 1116 70 , , , 19613 1116 71 hai hai NNP 19613 1116 72 exapolluousin exapolluousin NNP 19613 1116 73 tous tous JJ 19613 1116 74 prosiontas prosionta NNS 19613 1116 75 autais autais RB 19613 1116 76 . . . 19613 1116 77 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1116 78 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1117 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1117 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1117 3 58 58 CD 19613 1117 4 : : : 19613 1117 5 This this DT 19613 1117 6 has have VBZ 19613 1117 7 been be VBN 19613 1117 8 contested contest VBN 19613 1117 9 by by IN 19613 1117 10 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 1117 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1117 12 Ztschr Ztschr NNP 19613 1117 13 . . . 19613 1118 1 f. f. NNP 19613 1118 2 Kirchl Kirchl NNP 19613 1118 3 . . . 19613 1119 1 Wissensch Wissensch NNP 19613 1119 2 . . . 19613 1120 1 1886 1886 CD 19613 1120 2 , , , 19613 1120 3 Part part NN 19613 1120 4 . . . 19613 1121 1 7 7 CD 19613 1121 2 , , , 19613 1121 3 p. p. NN 19613 1121 4 352 352 CD 19613 1121 5 ff ff NN 19613 1121 6 . . . 19613 1122 1 : : : 19613 1122 2 " " `` 19613 1122 3 Did do VBD 19613 1122 4 the the DT 19613 1122 5 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 1122 6 Church Church NNP 19613 1122 7 in in IN 19613 1122 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1122 9 's 's POS 19613 1122 10 time time NN 19613 1122 11 possess possess VBP 19613 1122 12 a a DT 19613 1122 13 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1122 14 confession confession NN 19613 1122 15 or or CC 19613 1122 16 not not RB 19613 1122 17 ? ? . 19613 1123 1 ") ") `` 19613 1123 2 ; ; : 19613 1123 3 but but CC 19613 1123 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1123 5 arguments argument NNS 19613 1123 6 have have VBP 19613 1123 7 not not RB 19613 1123 8 convinced convince VBN 19613 1123 9 me -PRON- PRP 19613 1123 10 . . . 19613 1124 1 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 1124 2 correctly correctly RB 19613 1124 3 shows show VBZ 19613 1124 4 that that IN 19613 1124 5 in in IN 19613 1124 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1124 7 the the DT 19613 1124 8 expression expression NN 19613 1124 9 " " `` 19613 1124 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1124 11 canon canon NN 19613 1124 12 " " '' 19613 1124 13 denotes denote VBZ 19613 1124 14 the the DT 19613 1124 15 summary summary NN 19613 1124 16 of of IN 19613 1124 17 the the DT 19613 1124 18 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1124 19 faith faith NN 19613 1124 20 and and CC 19613 1124 21 of of IN 19613 1124 22 the the DT 19613 1124 23 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1124 24 rule rule NN 19613 1124 25 of of IN 19613 1124 26 conduct conduct NN 19613 1124 27 ; ; : 19613 1124 28 but but CC 19613 1124 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1124 30 goes go VBZ 19613 1124 31 on on RP 19613 1124 32 to to TO 19613 1124 33 trace trace VB 19613 1124 34 the the DT 19613 1124 35 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 1124 36 confession confession NN 19613 1124 37 , , , 19613 1124 38 and and CC 19613 1124 39 that that IN 19613 1124 40 in in IN 19613 1124 41 a a DT 19613 1124 42 fixed fix VBN 19613 1124 43 form form NN 19613 1124 44 , , , 19613 1124 45 in in IN 19613 1124 46 the the DT 19613 1124 47 expression expression NN 19613 1124 48 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1124 49 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1124 50 : : : 19613 1124 51 hê hê VB 19613 1124 52 peri peri NNP 19613 1124 53 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1124 54 megistôn megistôn NNP 19613 1124 55 homologia homologia NNP 19613 1124 56 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1124 57 , , , 19613 1124 58 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1124 59 . . . 19613 1125 1 VII VII NNP 19613 1125 2 . . . 19613 1126 1 15 15 CD 19613 1126 2 . . . 19613 1127 1 90 90 CD 19613 1127 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1127 3 see see VB 19613 1127 4 remarks remark NNS 19613 1127 5 on on IN 19613 1127 6 this this DT 19613 1127 7 passage passage NN 19613 1127 8 below below RB 19613 1127 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1127 10 , , , 19613 1127 11 and and CC 19613 1127 12 is be VBZ 19613 1127 13 supported support VBN 19613 1127 14 in in IN 19613 1127 15 this this DT 19613 1127 16 view view NN 19613 1127 17 by by IN 19613 1127 18 Voigt Voigt NNP 19613 1127 19 , , , 19613 1127 20 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1127 21 . . . 19613 1128 1 p. p. NN 19613 1128 2 196 196 CD 19613 1128 3 ff ff NN 19613 1128 4 . . . 19613 1129 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1129 2 also also RB 19613 1129 3 regard regard VBP 19613 1129 4 this this DT 19613 1129 5 as as IN 19613 1129 6 a a DT 19613 1129 7 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1129 8 confession confession NN 19613 1129 9 ; ; : 19613 1129 10 but but CC 19613 1129 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1129 12 is be VBZ 19613 1129 13 questionable questionable JJ 19613 1129 14 if if IN 19613 1129 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1129 16 was be VBD 19613 1129 17 definitely definitely RB 19613 1129 18 formulated formulate VBN 19613 1129 19 , , , 19613 1129 20 and and CC 19613 1129 21 the the DT 19613 1129 22 passage passage NN 19613 1129 23 is be VBZ 19613 1129 24 not not RB 19613 1129 25 conclusive conclusive JJ 19613 1129 26 on on IN 19613 1129 27 the the DT 19613 1129 28 point point NN 19613 1129 29 . . . 19613 1130 1 But but CC 19613 1130 2 , , , 19613 1130 3 supposing suppose VBG 19613 1130 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1130 5 to to TO 19613 1130 6 be be VB 19613 1130 7 definitely definitely RB 19613 1130 8 formulated formulate VBN 19613 1130 9 , , , 19613 1130 10 who who WP 19613 1130 11 can can MD 19613 1130 12 prove prove VB 19613 1130 13 that that IN 19613 1130 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1130 15 went go VBD 19613 1130 16 further far RBR 19613 1130 17 than than IN 19613 1130 18 the the DT 19613 1130 19 formula formula NN 19613 1130 20 in in IN 19613 1130 21 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1130 22 , , , 19613 1130 23 Mand Mand NNP 19613 1130 24 . . . 19613 1131 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1131 2 with with IN 19613 1131 3 the the DT 19613 1131 4 addition addition NN 19613 1131 5 of of IN 19613 1131 6 a a DT 19613 1131 7 mere mere JJ 19613 1131 8 mention mention NN 19613 1131 9 of of IN 19613 1131 10 the the DT 19613 1131 11 Son Son NNP 19613 1131 12 and and CC 19613 1131 13 Holy Holy NNP 19613 1131 14 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 1131 15 . . . 19613 1132 1 That that IN 19613 1132 2 a a DT 19613 1132 3 free free JJ 19613 1132 4 _ _ NNP 19613 1132 5 kerygma kerygma NNP 19613 1132 6 _ _ NNP 19613 1132 7 of of IN 19613 1132 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 1132 9 and and CC 19613 1132 10 some some DT 19613 1132 11 other other JJ 19613 1132 12 matter matter NN 19613 1132 13 were be VBD 19613 1132 14 added add VBN 19613 1132 15 to to IN 19613 1132 16 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1132 17 , , , 19613 1132 18 Mand Mand NNP 19613 1132 19 . . . 19613 1133 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1133 2 may may MD 19613 1133 3 still still RB 19613 1133 4 be be VB 19613 1133 5 proved prove VBN 19613 1133 6 by by IN 19613 1133 7 a a DT 19613 1133 8 reference reference NN 19613 1133 9 to to IN 19613 1133 10 Orig Orig NNP 19613 1133 11 . . . 19613 1134 1 Comm Comm NNP 19613 1134 2 . . . 19613 1135 1 in in IN 19613 1135 2 Joh Joh NNP 19613 1135 3 . . . 19613 1136 1 XXXII XXXII NNP 19613 1136 2 . . . 19613 1137 1 9 9 CD 19613 1137 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1137 3 see see VB 19613 1137 4 the the DT 19613 1137 5 passage passage NN 19613 1137 6 in in IN 19613 1137 7 vol vol NNP 19613 1137 8 . . . 19613 1138 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1138 2 p. p. NN 19613 1139 1 155 155 CD 19613 1139 2 . . . 19613 1139 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1139 4 . . . 19613 1139 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1140 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1140 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1140 3 59 59 CD 19613 1140 4 : : : 19613 1140 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1140 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1140 7 : : : 19613 1140 8 Hê Hê NNP 19613 1140 9 kyriakê kyriakê JJ 19613 1140 10 didaskalia didaskalia NN 19613 1140 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1140 12 , , , 19613 1140 13 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 1140 14 , , , 19613 1140 15 VI VI NNP 19613 1140 16 . . . 19613 1141 1 15 15 CD 19613 1141 2 . . . 19613 1142 1 124 124 CD 19613 1142 2 ; ; : 19613 1142 3 VI VI NNP 19613 1142 4 . . . 19613 1143 1 18 18 CD 19613 1143 2 . . . 19613 1144 1 165 165 CD 19613 1144 2 ; ; : 19613 1144 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1144 4 . . . 19613 1145 1 10 10 CD 19613 1145 2 . . . 19613 1146 1 57 57 CD 19613 1146 2 ; ; : 19613 1146 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1146 4 . . . 19613 1147 1 15 15 CD 19613 1147 2 . . . 19613 1148 1 90 90 CD 19613 1148 2 ; ; : 19613 1148 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1148 4 . . . 19613 1149 1 18 18 CD 19613 1149 2 . . . 19613 1150 1 165 165 CD 19613 1150 2 , , , 19613 1150 3 etc etc FW 19613 1150 4 . . . 19613 1150 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1151 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1151 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1151 3 60 60 CD 19613 1151 4 : : : 19613 1151 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1151 6 do do VBP 19613 1151 7 not not RB 19613 1151 8 find find VB 19613 1151 9 in in IN 19613 1151 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1151 11 the the DT 19613 1151 12 slightest slight JJS 19613 1151 13 traces trace NNS 19613 1151 14 of of IN 19613 1151 15 a a DT 19613 1151 16 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1151 17 confession confession NN 19613 1151 18 related relate VBN 19613 1151 19 to to IN 19613 1151 20 the the DT 19613 1151 21 Roman Roman NNP 19613 1151 22 , , , 19613 1151 23 unless unless IN 19613 1151 24 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1151 25 reckon reckon VBP 19613 1151 26 the the DT 19613 1151 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1151 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1151 29 : : : 19613 1151 30 Theos theos JJ 19613 1151 31 pantokratôr pantokratôr JJ 19613 1151 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1151 33 or or CC 19613 1151 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1151 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1151 36 : : : 19613 1151 37 eis eis NNP 19613 1151 38 Th th XX 19613 1151 39 . . . 19613 1152 1 p. p. NN 19613 1152 2 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1152 3 as as IN 19613 1152 4 such such JJ 19613 1152 5 . . . 19613 1153 1 But but CC 19613 1153 2 this this DT 19613 1153 3 designation designation NN 19613 1153 4 of of IN 19613 1153 5 God God NNP 19613 1153 6 is be VBZ 19613 1153 7 found find VBN 19613 1153 8 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 1153 9 and and CC 19613 1153 10 is be VBZ 19613 1153 11 not not RB 19613 1153 12 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 1153 13 of of IN 19613 1153 14 the the DT 19613 1153 15 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1153 16 confession confession NN 19613 1153 17 . . . 19613 1154 1 In in IN 19613 1154 2 the the DT 19613 1154 3 lost lost JJ 19613 1154 4 treatise treatise NN 19613 1154 5 on on IN 19613 1154 6 the the DT 19613 1154 7 Passover Passover NNP 19613 1154 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1154 9 expounded expound VBD 19613 1154 10 the the DT 19613 1154 11 " " `` 19613 1154 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1154 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1154 14 : : : 19613 1154 15 paradoseis paradoseis NNP 19613 1154 16 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1154 17 archaiôn archaiôn NNP 19613 1154 18 presbyterôn presbyterôn NNP 19613 1154 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1154 20 " " '' 19613 1154 21 which which WDT 19613 1154 22 had have VBD 19613 1154 23 been be VBN 19613 1154 24 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 1154 25 to to IN 19613 1154 26 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1154 27 . . . 19613 1154 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1155 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1155 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1155 3 61 61 CD 19613 1155 4 : : : 19613 1155 5 Considering consider VBG 19613 1155 6 the the DT 19613 1155 7 importance importance NN 19613 1155 8 of of IN 19613 1155 9 the the DT 19613 1155 10 matter matter NN 19613 1155 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1155 12 is be VBZ 19613 1155 13 necessary necessary JJ 19613 1155 14 to to TO 19613 1155 15 quote quote VB 19613 1155 16 as as RB 19613 1155 17 copiously copiously RB 19613 1155 18 as as IN 19613 1155 19 possible possible JJ 19613 1155 20 from from IN 19613 1155 21 original original JJ 19613 1155 22 sources source NNS 19613 1155 23 . . . 19613 1156 1 In in IN 19613 1156 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1156 3 . . . 19613 1157 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1157 2 . . . 19613 1158 1 15 15 CD 19613 1158 2 . . . 19613 1159 1 98 98 CD 19613 1159 2 , , , 19613 1159 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1159 4 find find VBP 19613 1159 5 the the DT 19613 1159 6 expression expression NN 19613 1159 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1159 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1159 9 : : : 19613 1159 10 ho ho NNP 19613 1159 11 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 1159 12 teê teê NNP 19613 1159 13 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 1159 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1159 15 ; ; : 19613 1159 16 but but CC 19613 1159 17 the the DT 19613 1159 18 context context NN 19613 1159 19 shows show VBZ 19613 1159 20 that that IN 19613 1159 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1159 22 is be VBZ 19613 1159 23 used use VBN 19613 1159 24 here here RB 19613 1159 25 in in IN 19613 1159 26 a a DT 19613 1159 27 quite quite RB 19613 1159 28 general general JJ 19613 1159 29 sense sense NN 19613 1159 30 . . . 19613 1160 1 With with IN 19613 1160 2 regard regard NN 19613 1160 3 to to IN 19613 1160 4 the the DT 19613 1160 5 statement statement NN 19613 1160 6 of of IN 19613 1160 7 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1160 8 : : : 19613 1160 9 " " `` 19613 1160 10 whatever whatever WDT 19613 1160 11 you -PRON- PRP 19613 1160 12 do do VBP 19613 1160 13 , , , 19613 1160 14 do do VB 19613 1160 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1160 16 to to IN 19613 1160 17 the the DT 19613 1160 18 glory glory NN 19613 1160 19 of of IN 19613 1160 20 God God NNP 19613 1160 21 , , , 19613 1160 22 " " `` 19613 1160 23 Clement clement NN 19613 1160 24 remarks remark NNS 19613 1160 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1160 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1160 27 : : : 19613 1160 28 hosa hosa NNP 19613 1160 29 hypo hypo NNP 19613 1160 30 ton ton NNP 19613 1160 31 kanona kanona NNP 19613 1160 32 tês tês NNP 19613 1160 33 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 1160 34 poiein poiein NNP 19613 1160 35 epitetraptai epitetraptai NNP 19613 1160 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1160 37 . . . 19613 1161 1 In in IN 19613 1161 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1161 3 . . . 19613 1162 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1163 1 19 19 CD 19613 1163 2 . . . 19613 1164 1 96 96 CD 19613 1164 2 ; ; : 19613 1164 3 VI VI NNP 19613 1164 4 . . . 19613 1165 1 15 15 CD 19613 1165 2 . . . 19613 1166 1 125 125 CD 19613 1166 2 ; ; : 19613 1166 3 VI VI NNP 19613 1166 4 . . . 19613 1167 1 18 18 CD 19613 1167 2 . . . 19613 1168 1 165 165 CD 19613 1168 2 ; ; : 19613 1168 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1168 4 . . . 19613 1169 1 7 7 LS 19613 1169 2 . . . 19613 1170 1 41 41 CD 19613 1170 2 ; ; : 19613 1170 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1170 4 . . . 19613 1171 1 15 15 CD 19613 1171 2 . . . 19613 1172 1 90 90 CD 19613 1172 2 ; ; : 19613 1172 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1172 4 . . . 19613 1173 1 16 16 CD 19613 1173 2 . . . 19613 1174 1 105 105 CD 19613 1174 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1174 3 find find VBP 19613 1174 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1174 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1174 6 : : : 19613 1174 7 ho ho NNP 19613 1174 8 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 1174 9 tês tês NNP 19613 1174 10 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1174 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1174 12 ekklêsiastikos ekklêsiastikos NNP 19613 1174 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1174 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1174 15 . . . 19613 1175 1 In in IN 19613 1175 2 the the DT 19613 1175 3 first first JJ 19613 1175 4 passage passage NN 19613 1175 5 that that IN 19613 1175 6 canon canon NNP 19613 1175 7 is be VBZ 19613 1175 8 the the DT 19613 1175 9 rule rule NN 19613 1175 10 for for IN 19613 1175 11 the the DT 19613 1175 12 right right JJ 19613 1175 13 observance observance NN 19613 1175 14 of of IN 19613 1175 15 the the DT 19613 1175 16 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1175 17 's 's POS 19613 1175 18 Supper Supper NNP 19613 1175 19 . . . 19613 1176 1 In in IN 19613 1176 2 the the DT 19613 1176 3 other other JJ 19613 1176 4 passages passage NNS 19613 1176 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1176 6 describes describe VBZ 19613 1176 7 no no RB 19613 1176 8 doubt doubt RB 19613 1176 9 the the DT 19613 1176 10 correct correct JJ 19613 1176 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 1176 12 , , , 19613 1176 13 that that RB 19613 1176 14 is is RB 19613 1176 15 , , , 19613 1176 16 the the DT 19613 1176 17 rule rule NN 19613 1176 18 by by IN 19613 1176 19 which which WDT 19613 1176 20 the the DT 19613 1176 21 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 1176 22 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 1176 23 has have VBZ 19613 1176 24 to to TO 19613 1176 25 be be VB 19613 1176 26 guided guide VBN 19613 1176 27 in in IN 19613 1176 28 contrast contrast NN 19613 1176 29 with with IN 19613 1176 30 the the DT 19613 1176 31 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1176 32 who who WP 19613 1176 33 are be VBP 19613 1176 34 guided guide VBN 19613 1176 35 by by IN 19613 1176 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1176 37 own own JJ 19613 1176 38 desires desire NNS 19613 1176 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1176 40 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1176 41 is be VBZ 19613 1176 42 therefore therefore RB 19613 1176 43 parallel parallel JJ 19613 1176 44 to to IN 19613 1176 45 the the DT 19613 1176 46 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1176 47 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1176 48 : : : 19613 1176 49 didaskalia didaskalia NNP 19613 1176 50 tou tou NNP 19613 1176 51 kyriou kyriou NNP 19613 1176 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1176 53 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1176 54 ; ; : 19613 1176 55 but but CC 19613 1176 56 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1176 57 feels feel VBZ 19613 1176 58 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 1176 59 no no DT 19613 1176 60 need need NN 19613 1176 61 to to TO 19613 1176 62 mention mention VB 19613 1176 63 wherein wherein WRB 19613 1176 64 this this DT 19613 1176 65 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1176 66 canon canon NN 19613 1176 67 consists consist VBZ 19613 1176 68 . . . 19613 1177 1 In in IN 19613 1177 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1177 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1177 4 . . . 19613 1178 1 1 1 LS 19613 1178 2 . . . 19613 1179 1 3 3 LS 19613 1179 2 ; ; : 19613 1179 3 VI VI NNP 19613 1179 4 . . . 19613 1180 1 15 15 CD 19613 1180 2 . . . 19613 1181 1 124 124 CD 19613 1181 2 ; ; : 19613 1181 3 VI VI NNP 19613 1181 4 15 15 CD 19613 1181 5 . . . 19613 1182 1 131 131 CD 19613 1182 2 ; ; : 19613 1182 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1182 4 . . . 19613 1183 1 16 16 CD 19613 1183 2 . . . 19613 1184 1 94 94 CD 19613 1184 2 , , , 19613 1184 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1184 4 find find VBP 19613 1184 5 the the DT 19613 1184 6 expression expression NN 19613 1184 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1184 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1184 9 : : : 19613 1184 10 ho ho NNP 19613 1184 11 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 1184 12 tês tês NNP 19613 1184 13 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 1184 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1184 15 . . . 19613 1185 1 In in IN 19613 1185 2 the the DT 19613 1185 3 first first JJ 19613 1185 4 passage passage NN 19613 1185 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1185 6 is be VBZ 19613 1185 7 said say VBN 19613 1185 8 : : : 19613 1185 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1185 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1185 11 : : : 19613 1185 12 hê hê NNP 19613 1185 13 goun goun NNP 19613 1185 14 kata kata NNP 19613 1185 15 ton ton NNP 19613 1185 16 tês tês NNP 19613 1185 17 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 1185 18 kanona kanona NNP 19613 1185 19 gnôstikês gnôstikês NNP 19613 1185 20 paradoseôs paradoseôs NNP 19613 1185 21 physiologia physiologia NNP 19613 1185 22 , , , 19613 1185 23 mallon mallon NNP 19613 1185 24 de de NNP 19613 1185 25 epopteia epopteia NNP 19613 1185 26 , , , 19613 1185 27 ek ek NNP 19613 1185 28 tou tou NNP 19613 1185 29 peri peri NNP 19613 1185 30 kosmogonias kosmogonias NNP 19613 1185 31 êrtêtai êrtêtai NNP 19613 1185 32 logou logou NNP 19613 1185 33 , , , 19613 1185 34 enthende enthende NNP 19613 1185 35 anabainousa anabainousa VBD 19613 1185 36 epi epi NNP 19613 1185 37 to to IN 19613 1185 38 theologikon theologikon NNP 19613 1185 39 eidos eidos NNP 19613 1185 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1185 41 . . . 19613 1186 1 Here here RB 19613 1186 2 no no DT 19613 1186 3 one one NN 19613 1186 4 can can MD 19613 1186 5 understand understand VB 19613 1186 6 by by IN 19613 1186 7 the the DT 19613 1186 8 rule rule NN 19613 1186 9 of of IN 19613 1186 10 truth truth NN 19613 1186 11 what what WP 19613 1186 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1186 13 understood understand VBD 19613 1186 14 by by IN 19613 1186 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1186 16 . . . 19613 1187 1 Very very RB 19613 1187 2 instructive instructive JJ 19613 1187 3 is be VBZ 19613 1187 4 the the DT 19613 1187 5 second second JJ 19613 1187 6 passage passage NN 19613 1187 7 in in IN 19613 1187 8 which which WDT 19613 1187 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1187 10 is be VBZ 19613 1187 11 dealing deal VBG 19613 1187 12 with with IN 19613 1187 13 the the DT 19613 1187 14 right right JJ 19613 1187 15 and and CC 19613 1187 16 wrong wrong JJ 19613 1187 17 exposition exposition NN 19613 1187 18 of of IN 19613 1187 19 Scripture scripture NN 19613 1187 20 . . . 19613 1188 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1188 2 says say VBZ 19613 1188 3 first first RB 19613 1188 4 : : : 19613 1188 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1188 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1188 7 : : : 19613 1188 8 parakatathêke parakatathêke NNP 19613 1188 9 apodidomenê apodidomenê NNP 19613 1188 10 Theô Theô NNP 19613 1188 11 hê hê NNP 19613 1188 12 kata kata NNP 19613 1188 13 tên tên NNP 19613 1188 14 tou tou NNP 19613 1188 15 kyriou kyriou NNP 19613 1188 16 didaskalian didaskalian NNP 19613 1188 17 dia dia NNP 19613 1188 18 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1188 19 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1188 20 autou autou NNP 19613 1188 21 tês tês NNP 19613 1188 22 theosebous theosebous NNP 19613 1188 23 paradoseôs paradoseôs NNP 19613 1188 24 synesis synesis NNP 19613 1188 25 te te NNP 19613 1188 26 kai kai NNP 19613 1188 27 synaskêsis synaskêsis NNP 19613 1188 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1188 29 ; ; : 19613 1188 30 then then RB 19613 1188 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1188 32 demands demand VBZ 19613 1188 33 that that IN 19613 1188 34 the the DT 19613 1188 35 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 1188 36 be be VB 19613 1188 37 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 1188 38 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1188 39 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1188 40 : : : 19613 1188 41 kata kata NNP 19613 1188 42 ton ton NNP 19613 1188 43 tês tês NNP 19613 1188 44 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 1188 45 kanona kanona NNP 19613 1188 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1188 47 , , , 19613 1188 48 or or CC 19613 1188 49 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1188 50 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1188 51 : : : 19613 1188 52 t. t. NNP 19613 1188 53 ekklês ekklê NNS 19613 1188 54 . . . 19613 1189 1 kan kan NNP 19613 1189 2 . . . 19613 1189 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1189 4 ; ; : 19613 1189 5 and and CC 19613 1189 6 continues continue VBZ 19613 1189 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1189 8 125 125 CD 19613 1189 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1189 10 : : : 19613 1189 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1189 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1189 13 : : : 19613 1189 14 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 1189 15 de de FW 19613 1189 16 ekklêsiastikos ekklêsiastikos NNP 19613 1189 17 hê hê NNP 19613 1189 18 synôdia synôdia NNP 19613 1189 19 kai kai NNP 19613 1189 20 hê hê NNP 19613 1189 21 symphônia symphônia NNP 19613 1189 22 nomou nomou NNP 19613 1189 23 te te NNP 19613 1189 24 kai kai NNP 19613 1189 25 prophêtôn prophêtôn NNP 19613 1189 26 tê tê DT 19613 1189 27 kata kata NNP 19613 1189 28 tên tên NNP 19613 1189 29 tou tou NNP 19613 1189 30 kyriou kyriou NNP 19613 1189 31 parousian parousian NNP 19613 1189 32 paradidomenê paradidomenê NNP 19613 1189 33 diathêkê diathêkê NNP 19613 1189 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1189 35 . . . 19613 1190 1 Here here RB 19613 1190 2 then then RB 19613 1190 3 the the DT 19613 1190 4 agreement agreement NN 19613 1190 5 of of IN 19613 1190 6 the the DT 19613 1190 7 Old Old NNP 19613 1190 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1190 9 with with IN 19613 1190 10 the the DT 19613 1190 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1190 12 of of IN 19613 1190 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 1190 14 is be VBZ 19613 1190 15 described describe VBN 19613 1190 16 as as IN 19613 1190 17 the the DT 19613 1190 18 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1190 19 canon canon NN 19613 1190 20 . . . 19613 1191 1 Apart apart RB 19613 1191 2 from from IN 19613 1191 3 the the DT 19613 1191 4 question question NN 19613 1191 5 as as IN 19613 1191 6 to to IN 19613 1191 7 whether whether IN 19613 1191 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1191 9 is be VBZ 19613 1191 10 here here RB 19613 1191 11 already already RB 19613 1191 12 referring refer VBG 19613 1191 13 to to IN 19613 1191 14 a a DT 19613 1191 15 New New NNP 19613 1191 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1191 17 canon canon NN 19613 1191 18 of of IN 19613 1191 19 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 1191 20 , , , 19613 1191 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1191 22 rule rule NN 19613 1191 23 agrees agree VBZ 19613 1191 24 with with IN 19613 1191 25 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1191 26 's 's POS 19613 1191 27 testimony testimony NN 19613 1191 28 about about IN 19613 1191 29 the the DT 19613 1191 30 Roman Roman NNP 19613 1191 31 Church Church NNP 19613 1191 32 : : : 19613 1191 33 " " `` 19613 1191 34 legem legem NNP 19613 1191 35 et et NNP 19613 1191 36 prophetas prophetas NNP 19613 1191 37 cum cum NNP 19613 1191 38 evangelicis evangelicis NNP 19613 1191 39 et et NNP 19613 1191 40 apostolicis apostolicis NNP 19613 1191 41 litteris litteris NNP 19613 1191 42 miscet miscet NNP 19613 1191 43 . . . 19613 1191 44 " " '' 19613 1192 1 But but CC 19613 1192 2 at at IN 19613 1192 3 any any DT 19613 1192 4 rate rate NN 19613 1192 5 the the DT 19613 1192 6 passage passage NN 19613 1192 7 shows show VBZ 19613 1192 8 the the DT 19613 1192 9 broad broad JJ 19613 1192 10 sense sense NN 19613 1192 11 in in IN 19613 1192 12 which which WDT 19613 1192 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1192 14 used use VBD 19613 1192 15 the the DT 19613 1192 16 term term NN 19613 1192 17 " " `` 19613 1192 18 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1192 19 canon canon NN 19613 1192 20 . . . 19613 1192 21 " " '' 19613 1193 1 The the DT 19613 1193 2 following follow VBG 19613 1193 3 expressions expression NNS 19613 1193 4 are be VBP 19613 1193 5 also also RB 19613 1193 6 found find VBN 19613 1193 7 in in IN 19613 1193 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1193 9 : : : 19613 1193 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1193 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1193 12 : : : 19613 1193 13 hê hê NN 19613 1193 14 alêthes alêthes NNP 19613 1193 15 tês tês NNP 19613 1193 16 makarias makarias NNP 19613 1193 17 didaskalias didaskalias NNP 19613 1193 18 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 1193 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1193 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1193 21 I. i. NN 19613 1194 1 1 1 LS 19613 1194 2 . . . 19613 1195 1 11 11 CD 19613 1195 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1195 3 , , , 19613 1195 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1195 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1195 6 : : : 19613 1195 7 hai hai NNP 19613 1195 8 hagiai hagiai NNP 19613 1195 9 paradoseis paradoseis NNP 19613 1195 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1195 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1195 12 VII VII NNP 19613 1195 13 . . . 19613 1196 1 18 18 CD 19613 1196 2 . . . 19613 1197 1 110 110 CD 19613 1197 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1197 3 , , , 19613 1197 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1197 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1197 6 : : : 19613 1197 7 hê hê NN 19613 1197 8 eukleês eukleês NNP 19613 1197 9 kai kai NNP 19613 1197 10 semnos semnos NNP 19613 1197 11 tês tês NNP 19613 1197 12 paradoseôs paradoseôs NNP 19613 1197 13 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 1197 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1197 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1197 16 all all DT 19613 1197 17 gnosis gnosis NN 19613 1197 18 is be VBZ 19613 1197 19 to to TO 19613 1197 20 be be VB 19613 1197 21 guided guide VBN 19613 1197 22 by by IN 19613 1197 23 this this DT 19613 1197 24 , , , 19613 1197 25 see see VB 19613 1197 26 also also RB 19613 1197 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1197 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1197 29 : : : 19613 1197 30 hê hê NNP 19613 1197 31 kata kata NNP 19613 1197 32 tên tên NNP 19613 1197 33 theian theian NNP 19613 1197 34 paradosin paradosin NNP 19613 1197 35 philosophia philosophia NNP 19613 1197 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1197 37 , , , 19613 1197 38 I I NNP 19613 1197 39 , , , 19613 1197 40 1 1 CD 19613 1197 41 . . . 19613 1198 1 15 15 CD 19613 1198 2 . . . 19613 1199 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1199 2 : : : 19613 1199 3 11 11 CD 19613 1199 4 . . . 19613 1200 1 52 52 CD 19613 1200 2 . . . 19613 1200 3 , , , 19613 1200 4 also also RB 19613 1200 5 the the DT 19613 1200 6 expression expression NN 19613 1200 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1200 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1200 9 : : : 19613 1200 10 hê hê VB 19613 1200 11 theia theia NN 19613 1200 12 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 1200 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1200 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1200 15 VII VII NNP 19613 1200 16 . . . 19613 1201 1 16 16 CD 19613 1201 2 . . . 19613 1202 1 103 103 CD 19613 1202 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1202 3 , , , 19613 1202 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1202 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1202 6 : : : 19613 1202 7 hê hê VB 19613 1202 8 ekklêsiastike ekklêsiastike NNP 19613 1202 9 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 1202 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1202 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1202 12 VII VII NNP 19613 1202 13 . . . 19613 1203 1 16 16 CD 19613 1203 2 . . . 19613 1204 1 95 95 CD 19613 1204 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1204 3 , , , 19613 1204 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1204 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1204 6 : : : 19613 1204 7 hai hai NNP 19613 1204 8 tou tou NNP 19613 1204 9 Christou Christou NNP 19613 1204 10 paradoseis paradoseis NNP 19613 1204 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1204 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1204 13 VII VII NNP 19613 1204 14 . . . 19613 1205 1 16 16 CD 19613 1205 2 . . . 19613 1206 1 99 99 CD 19613 1206 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1206 3 , , , 19613 1206 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1206 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1206 6 : : : 19613 1206 7 hê hê NNP 19613 1206 8 tou tou NNP 19613 1206 9 kyriou kyriou NNP 19613 1206 10 paradosis paradosis NNP 19613 1206 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1206 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1206 13 VII VII NNP 19613 1206 14 . . . 19613 1207 1 17 17 CD 19613 1207 2 . . . 19613 1208 1 106 106 CD 19613 1208 2 : : : 19613 1208 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1208 4 . . . 19613 1209 1 16 16 CD 19613 1209 2 . . . 19613 1210 1 104 104 CD 19613 1210 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1210 3 , , , 19613 1210 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1210 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1210 6 : : : 19613 1210 7 hê hê VB 19613 1210 8 theosebês theosebês NN 19613 1210 9 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 1210 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1210 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1210 12 VI VI NNP 19613 1210 13 . . . 19613 1211 1 15 15 CD 19613 1211 2 . . . 19613 1212 1 124 124 LS 19613 1212 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1212 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1212 4 . . . 19613 1213 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1213 2 content content NN 19613 1213 3 is be VBZ 19613 1213 4 not not RB 19613 1213 5 more more RBR 19613 1213 6 precisely precisely RB 19613 1213 7 defined define VBN 19613 1213 8 , , , 19613 1213 9 and and CC 19613 1213 10 , , , 19613 1213 11 as as IN 19613 1213 12 a a DT 19613 1213 13 rule rule NN 19613 1213 14 , , , 19613 1213 15 nothing nothing NN 19613 1213 16 more more JJR 19613 1213 17 can can MD 19613 1213 18 be be VB 19613 1213 19 gathered gather VBN 19613 1213 20 from from IN 19613 1213 21 the the DT 19613 1213 22 context context NN 19613 1213 23 than than IN 19613 1213 24 what what WP 19613 1213 25 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1213 26 once once RB 19613 1213 27 calls call VBZ 19613 1213 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1213 29 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1213 30 : : : 19613 1213 31 to to TO 19613 1213 32 koinon koinon VB 19613 1213 33 tês tês NNP 19613 1213 34 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 1213 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1213 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1213 37 VII VII NNP 19613 1213 38 . . . 19613 1214 1 16 16 CD 19613 1214 2 . . . 19613 1215 1 97 97 CD 19613 1215 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1215 3 . . . 19613 1216 1 Where where WRB 19613 1216 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1216 3 wishes wish VBZ 19613 1216 4 to to TO 19613 1216 5 determine determine VB 19613 1216 6 the the DT 19613 1216 7 content content NN 19613 1216 8 more more RBR 19613 1216 9 accurately accurately RB 19613 1216 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1216 11 makes make VBZ 19613 1216 12 use use NN 19613 1216 13 of of IN 19613 1216 14 supplementary supplementary JJ 19613 1216 15 terms term NNS 19613 1216 16 . . . 19613 1217 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1217 2 speaks speak VBZ 19613 1217 3 , , , 19613 1217 4 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 1217 5 , , , 19613 1217 6 in in IN 19613 1217 7 III III NNP 19613 1217 8 . . . 19613 1218 1 10 10 CD 19613 1218 2 . . . 19613 1219 1 66 66 CD 19613 1219 2 of of IN 19613 1219 3 the the DT 19613 1219 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1219 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1219 6 : : : 19613 1219 7 kata kata NNP 19613 1219 8 alêtheian alêtheian NNP 19613 1219 9 euangelikos euangelikos NNP 19613 1219 10 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 1219 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1219 12 , , , 19613 1219 13 and and CC 19613 1219 14 means mean VBZ 19613 1219 15 by by IN 19613 1219 16 that that DT 19613 1219 17 the the DT 19613 1219 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 1219 19 contained contain VBN 19613 1219 20 in in IN 19613 1219 21 the the DT 19613 1219 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1219 23 recognised recognise VBN 19613 1219 24 by by IN 19613 1219 25 the the DT 19613 1219 26 Church Church NNP 19613 1219 27 in in IN 19613 1219 28 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 1219 29 to to IN 19613 1219 30 that that DT 19613 1219 31 found find VBN 19613 1219 32 in in IN 19613 1219 33 other other JJ 19613 1219 34 gospels gospel NNS 19613 1219 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1219 36 IV IV NNP 19613 1219 37 . . . 19613 1220 1 4 4 LS 19613 1220 2 . . . 19613 1221 1 15 15 CD 19613 1221 2 : : : 19613 1221 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1221 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1221 5 : : : 19613 1221 6 kata kata NNP 19613 1221 7 ton ton NNP 19613 1221 8 kanona kanona NNP 19613 1221 9 tou tou NNP 19613 1221 10 euangeliou euangeliou NNP 19613 1221 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1221 12 = = NFP 19613 1221 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1221 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1221 15 : : : 19613 1221 16 kata kata NNP 19613 1221 17 t. t. . 19613 1222 1 euang euang NNP 19613 1222 2 . . . 19613 1222 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1222 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1222 5 . . . 19613 1223 1 In in IN 19613 1223 2 none none NN 19613 1223 3 of of IN 19613 1223 4 these these DT 19613 1223 5 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 1223 6 is be VBZ 19613 1223 7 any any DT 19613 1223 8 notice notice NN 19613 1223 9 taken take VBN 19613 1223 10 of of IN 19613 1223 11 the the DT 19613 1223 12 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1223 13 . . . 19613 1224 1 That that DT 19613 1224 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1224 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1224 4 like like IN 19613 1224 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 1224 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1224 7 traced trace VBD 19613 1224 8 back back RP 19613 1224 9 the the DT 19613 1224 10 public public JJ 19613 1224 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 1224 12 to to IN 19613 1224 13 the the DT 19613 1224 14 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1224 15 is be VBZ 19613 1224 16 a a DT 19613 1224 17 matter matter NN 19613 1224 18 of of IN 19613 1224 19 course course NN 19613 1224 20 and and CC 19613 1224 21 manifest manif JJS 19613 1224 22 from from IN 19613 1224 23 I. i. NN 19613 1225 1 1 1 LS 19613 1225 2 . . . 19613 1226 1 11 11 CD 19613 1226 2 , , , 19613 1226 3 where where WRB 19613 1226 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1226 5 gives give VBZ 19613 1226 6 an an DT 19613 1226 7 account account NN 19613 1226 8 of of IN 19613 1226 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1226 10 early early JJ 19613 1226 11 teachers teacher NNS 19613 1226 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1226 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1226 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1226 15 : : : 19613 1226 16 hoi hoi NNP 19613 1226 17 men man NNS 19613 1226 18 tên tên VBP 19613 1226 19 alêthê alêthê VB 19613 1226 20 tês tês NNP 19613 1226 21 makarias makarias NNP 19613 1226 22 sôzontes sôzonte VBZ 19613 1226 23 didaskalias didaskalias NNP 19613 1226 24 paradosin paradosin NNP 19613 1226 25 euthus euthus NNP 19613 1226 26 apo apo NNP 19613 1226 27 Petrou Petrou NNP 19613 1226 28 te te NNP 19613 1226 29 kai kai NNP 19613 1226 30 Iakôbou Iakôbou NNP 19613 1226 31 , , , 19613 1226 32 Iôannou Iôannou NNP 19613 1226 33 te te NNP 19613 1226 34 kai kai NNP 19613 1226 35 Paulou Paulou NNP 19613 1226 36 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1226 37 hagiôn hagiôn NNP 19613 1226 38 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1226 39 , , , 19613 1226 40 tais tais NNP 19613 1226 41 para para NNP 19613 1226 42 patros patros NNP 19613 1226 43 ekdechomenos ekdechomenos NNPS 19613 1226 44 hêkon hêkon NNP 19613 1226 45 dê dê NNP 19613 1226 46 syn syn NNP 19613 1226 47 theô theô NNP 19613 1226 48 kai kai NNP 19613 1226 49 eis eis NNP 19613 1226 50 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 1226 51 ta ta NNP 19613 1226 52 progonika progonika NNP 19613 1226 53 ekeina ekeina NNP 19613 1226 54 kai kai NNP 19613 1226 55 apostolika apostolika NNP 19613 1226 56 katathêsomenoi katathêsomenoi NNP 19613 1226 57 spermata spermata NNP 19613 1226 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1226 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1226 60 . . . 19613 1227 1 Clement clement NN 19613 1227 2 does do VBZ 19613 1227 3 not not RB 19613 1227 4 yet yet RB 19613 1227 5 appeal appeal VB 19613 1227 6 to to IN 19613 1227 7 a a DT 19613 1227 8 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 1227 9 tradition tradition NN 19613 1227 10 through through IN 19613 1227 11 the the DT 19613 1227 12 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1227 13 , , , 19613 1227 14 but but CC 19613 1227 15 adheres adhere VBZ 19613 1227 16 to to IN 19613 1227 17 the the DT 19613 1227 18 natural natural JJ 19613 1227 19 one one CD 19613 1227 20 through through IN 19613 1227 21 the the DT 19613 1227 22 teachers teacher NNS 19613 1227 23 , , , 19613 1227 24 though though IN 19613 1227 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1227 26 indeed indeed RB 19613 1227 27 admits admit VBZ 19613 1227 28 an an DT 19613 1227 29 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 1227 30 tradition tradition NN 19613 1227 31 alongside alongside IN 19613 1227 32 of of IN 19613 1227 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1227 34 . . . 19613 1228 1 On on IN 19613 1228 2 one one CD 19613 1228 3 occasion occasion NN 19613 1228 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1228 5 also also RB 19613 1228 6 says say VBZ 19613 1228 7 that that IN 19613 1228 8 the the DT 19613 1228 9 true true JJ 19613 1228 10 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 1228 11 keeps keep VBZ 19613 1228 12 the the DT 19613 1228 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1228 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1228 15 : : : 19613 1228 16 apostolikê apostolikê NNP 19613 1228 17 kai kai NNP 19613 1228 18 ekklêsiastikê ekklêsiastikê NNP 19613 1228 19 orthotomia orthotomia NNP 19613 1228 20 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1228 21 dogmatôn dogmatôn NNP 19613 1228 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1228 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1228 24 VII VII NNP 19613 1228 25 . . . 19613 1229 1 16 16 CD 19613 1229 2 . . . 19613 1230 1 104 104 CD 19613 1230 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1230 3 . . . 19613 1231 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1231 2 has have VBZ 19613 1231 3 no no DT 19613 1231 4 doubt doubt NN 19613 1231 5 that that DT 19613 1231 6 : : : 19613 1231 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1231 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1231 9 : : : 19613 1231 10 mia mia NNP 19613 1231 11 hê hê NNP 19613 1231 12 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 1231 13 gegone gegone NNP 19613 1231 14 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1231 15 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1231 16 hôsper hôsper NNP 19613 1231 17 didaskalia didaskalia NNP 19613 1231 18 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 1231 19 de de NNP 19613 1231 20 kai kai NNP 19613 1231 21 hê hê NNP 19613 1231 22 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 1231 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1231 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1231 25 VII VII NNP 19613 1231 26 . . . 19613 1232 1 17 17 CD 19613 1232 2 . . . 19613 1233 1 108 108 CD 19613 1233 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1233 3 . . . 19613 1234 1 But but CC 19613 1234 2 all all DT 19613 1234 3 that that WDT 19613 1234 4 might may MD 19613 1234 5 just just RB 19613 1234 6 as as RB 19613 1234 7 well well RB 19613 1234 8 have have VBP 19613 1234 9 been be VBN 19613 1234 10 written write VBN 19613 1234 11 in in IN 19613 1234 12 the the DT 19613 1234 13 first first JJ 19613 1234 14 half half NN 19613 1234 15 of of IN 19613 1234 16 the the DT 19613 1234 17 second second JJ 19613 1234 18 century century NN 19613 1234 19 . . . 19613 1235 1 On on IN 19613 1235 2 the the DT 19613 1235 3 tracing tracing NN 19613 1235 4 back back RB 19613 1235 5 of of IN 19613 1235 6 the the DT 19613 1235 7 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 1235 8 , , , 19613 1235 9 the the DT 19613 1235 10 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 1235 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 1235 12 , , , 19613 1235 13 to to IN 19613 1235 14 the the DT 19613 1235 15 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1235 16 see see VB 19613 1235 17 Hypotyp Hypotyp NNP 19613 1235 18 . . . 19613 1236 1 in in IN 19613 1236 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1236 3 . . NNP 19613 1236 4 , , , 19613 1236 5 H. H. NNP 19613 1236 6 E. E. NNP 19613 1236 7 II II NNP 19613 1236 8 . . . 19613 1237 1 1 1 LS 19613 1237 2 . . . 19613 1238 1 4 4 LS 19613 1238 2 , , , 19613 1238 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1238 4 . . . 19613 1239 1 VI VI NNP 19613 1239 2 . . . 19613 1240 1 15 15 CD 19613 1240 2 . . . 19613 1241 1 131 131 CD 19613 1241 2 : : : 19613 1241 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1241 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1241 5 : : : 19613 1241 6 autika autika NNP 19613 1241 7 didaxantos didaxantos NNP 19613 1241 8 tou tou NNP 19613 1241 9 sôtêros sôtêros NNP 19613 1241 10 tous tous NNP 19613 1241 11 apostolous apostolous JJ 19613 1241 12 hê hê NNP 19613 1241 13 tês tês NNP 19613 1241 14 engraphou engraphou NNP 19613 1241 15 agraphos agraphos NNP 19613 1241 16 êdê êdê NNP 19613 1241 17 kai kai NNP 19613 1241 18 eis eis NNP 19613 1241 19 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 1241 20 diadidotai diadidotai NNP 19613 1241 21 paradosis paradosis NNP 19613 1241 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1241 23 . . . 19613 1242 1 VI VI NNP 19613 1242 2 . . . 19613 1243 1 7 7 LS 19613 1243 2 . . . 19613 1244 1 61 61 CD 19613 1244 2 : : : 19613 1244 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1244 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1244 5 : : : 19613 1244 6 hê hê VB 19613 1244 7 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 1244 8 de de FW 19613 1244 9 autê autê NNP 19613 1244 10 hê hê NNP 19613 1244 11 kata kata NNP 19613 1244 12 diadochas diadochas NNP 19613 1244 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1244 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1244 15 this this DT 19613 1244 16 is be VBZ 19613 1244 17 the the DT 19613 1244 18 only only JJ 19613 1244 19 place place NN 19613 1244 20 where where WRB 19613 1244 21 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1244 22 find find VBP 19613 1244 23 this this DT 19613 1244 24 expression expression NN 19613 1244 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1244 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1244 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1244 28 : : : 19613 1244 29 eis eis NNP 19613 1244 30 oligous oligous NNP 19613 1244 31 ek ek NNP 19613 1244 32 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1244 33 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1244 34 agraphôs agraphôs NNP 19613 1244 35 paradotheisa paradotheisa NNP 19613 1244 36 katelêluthen katelêluthen NNP 19613 1244 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1244 38 , , , 19613 1244 39 ibid ibid RB 19613 1244 40 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1244 41 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1244 42 : : : 19613 1244 43 hê hê NNP 19613 1244 44 gnôstikê gnôstikê NNP 19613 1244 45 paradosis paradosis NNP 19613 1244 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1244 47 ; ; : 19613 1244 48 VII VII NNP 19613 1244 49 . . . 19613 1245 1 10 10 CD 19613 1245 2 . . . 19613 1246 1 55 55 CD 19613 1246 2 : : : 19613 1246 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1246 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1246 5 : : : 19613 1246 6 hê hê VB 19613 1246 7 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 1246 8 ek ek NNP 19613 1246 9 paradoseôs paradoseôs NN 19613 1246 10 diadidomenê diadidomenê NN 19613 1246 11 tois tois NNP 19613 1246 12 axious axious JJ 19613 1246 13 sphas sphas NNP 19613 1246 14 autous autous JJ 19613 1246 15 tês tês NNP 19613 1246 16 didaskalias didaskalias NNP 19613 1246 17 parechomenois parechomenois NNP 19613 1246 18 oion oion NN 19613 1246 19 parakatathêkê parakatathêkê NNP 19613 1246 20 egcheirizetai egcheirizetai NNP 19613 1246 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1246 22 . . . 19613 1247 1 In in IN 19613 1247 2 VII VII NNP 19613 1247 3 . . . 19613 1248 1 17 17 CD 19613 1248 2 . . . 19613 1249 1 106 106 CD 19613 1249 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1249 3 has have VBZ 19613 1249 4 briefly briefly RB 19613 1249 5 recorded record VBN 19613 1249 6 the the DT 19613 1249 7 theories theory NNS 19613 1249 8 of of IN 19613 1249 9 the the DT 19613 1249 10 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 1249 11 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1249 12 with with IN 19613 1249 13 regard regard NN 19613 1249 14 to to IN 19613 1249 15 the the DT 19613 1249 16 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1249 17 origin origin NN 19613 1249 18 of of IN 19613 1249 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1249 20 teaching teaching NN 19613 1249 21 , , , 19613 1249 22 and and CC 19613 1249 23 expressed express VBD 19613 1249 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1249 25 doubts doubt NNS 19613 1249 26 . . . 19613 1250 1 That that IN 19613 1250 2 the the DT 19613 1250 3 tradition tradition NN 19613 1250 4 of of IN 19613 1250 5 the the DT 19613 1250 6 " " `` 19613 1250 7 Old Old NNP 19613 1250 8 Church Church NNP 19613 1250 9 , , , 19613 1250 10 " " '' 19613 1250 11 for for IN 19613 1250 12 so so RB 19613 1250 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1250 14 designates designate VBZ 19613 1250 15 the the DT 19613 1250 16 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 1250 17 Church Church NNP 19613 1250 18 as as IN 19613 1250 19 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 1250 20 from from IN 19613 1250 21 the the DT 19613 1250 22 " " `` 19613 1250 23 human human JJ 19613 1250 24 congregation congregation NN 19613 1250 25 " " '' 19613 1250 26 of of IN 19613 1250 27 the the DT 19613 1250 28 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1250 29 of of IN 19613 1250 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1250 31 day day NN 19613 1250 32 , , , 19613 1250 33 is be VBZ 19613 1250 34 throughout throughout IN 19613 1250 35 derived derive VBN 19613 1250 36 from from IN 19613 1250 37 the the DT 19613 1250 38 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1250 39 , , , 19613 1250 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1250 41 regards regard VBZ 19613 1250 42 as as IN 19613 1250 43 so so RB 19613 1250 44 certain certain JJ 19613 1250 45 and and CC 19613 1250 46 self self NN 19613 1250 47 - - HYPH 19613 1250 48 evident evident JJ 19613 1250 49 that that IN 19613 1250 50 , , , 19613 1250 51 as as IN 19613 1250 52 a a DT 19613 1250 53 rule rule NN 19613 1250 54 , , , 19613 1250 55 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1250 56 never never RB 19613 1250 57 specially specially RB 19613 1250 58 mentions mention VBZ 19613 1250 59 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1250 60 , , , 19613 1250 61 or or CC 19613 1250 62 gives give VBZ 19613 1250 63 prominence prominence NN 19613 1250 64 to to IN 19613 1250 65 any any DT 19613 1250 66 particular particular JJ 19613 1250 67 article article NN 19613 1250 68 as as IN 19613 1250 69 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1250 70 . . . 19613 1251 1 But but CC 19613 1251 2 the the DT 19613 1251 3 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 1251 4 that that IN 19613 1251 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1251 6 had have VBD 19613 1251 7 no no DT 19613 1251 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 1251 9 of of IN 19613 1251 10 any any DT 19613 1251 11 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 1251 12 or or CC 19613 1251 13 fixed fix VBN 19613 1251 14 confession confession NN 19613 1251 15 might may MD 19613 1251 16 seem seem VB 19613 1251 17 to to TO 19613 1251 18 be be VB 19613 1251 19 disproved disprove VBN 19613 1251 20 by by IN 19613 1251 21 one one CD 19613 1251 22 passage passage NN 19613 1251 23 . . . 19613 1252 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1252 2 is be VBZ 19613 1252 3 said say VBN 19613 1252 4 in in IN 19613 1252 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1252 6 . . . 19613 1253 1 VII VII NNP 19613 1253 2 . . . 19613 1254 1 15 15 CD 19613 1254 2 . . . 19613 1255 1 90 90 CD 19613 1255 2 : : : 19613 1255 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1255 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1255 5 : : : 19613 1255 6 Mê Mê NNP 19613 1255 7 ti ti IN 19613 1255 8 oun oun NNP 19613 1255 9 , , , 19613 1255 10 ei ei NNP 19613 1255 11 kai kai NNP 19613 1255 12 parabaiê parabaiê NNP 19613 1255 13 tis tis NNP 19613 1255 14 synthêkas synthêkas VBP 19613 1255 15 kai kai NNP 19613 1255 16 tên tên NNP 19613 1255 17 homologian homologian NNP 19613 1255 18 parelthoi parelthoi NNP 19613 1255 19 tên tên NNP 19613 1255 20 pros pros NNP 19613 1255 21 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 1255 22 , , , 19613 1255 23 dia dia NNP 19613 1255 24 ton ton NN 19613 1255 25 pseusamenon pseusamenon NNP 19613 1255 26 tên tên NNP 19613 1255 27 homologian homologian NNP 19613 1255 28 aphexometha aphexometha NNP 19613 1255 29 tês tês NNP 19613 1255 30 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 1255 31 kai kai NNP 19613 1255 32 hêmeis hêmeis NNP 19613 1255 33 , , , 19613 1255 34 all all DT 19613 1255 35 ' ' '' 19613 1255 36 hôs hôs NNP 19613 1255 37 apseudein apseudein NNP 19613 1255 38 chrê chrê NNP 19613 1255 39 ton ton NN 19613 1255 40 epieikê epieikê NNP 19613 1255 41 kai kai NNP 19613 1255 42 mêden mêden NNP 19613 1255 43 hôn hôn NNP 19613 1255 44 hupeschêtai hupeschêtai NNP 19613 1255 45 akuroun akuroun NNP 19613 1255 46 kan kan NNP 19613 1255 47 alloi alloi NNP 19613 1255 48 tines tines NNPS 19613 1255 49 parabainôsi parabainôsi NNP 19613 1255 50 synthêkas synthêkas NN 19613 1255 51 , , , 19613 1255 52 outôs outôs NNP 19613 1255 53 kai kai NNP 19613 1255 54 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 1255 55 kata kata NNP 19613 1255 56 mêdena mêdena NNP 19613 1255 57 tropon tropon NNP 19613 1255 58 ton ton NNP 19613 1255 59 ekklêsiastikon ekklêsiastikon NNP 19613 1255 60 parabainein parabainein NNP 19613 1255 61 prosekei prosekei NNP 19613 1255 62 kanona kanona NNP 19613 1255 63 kai kai NNP 19613 1255 64 malista malista NNP 19613 1255 65 tên tên NNP 19613 1255 66 peri peri NNP 19613 1255 67 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1255 68 megistôn megistôn NNP 19613 1255 69 homologian homologian JJ 19613 1255 70 hêmeis hêmeis NNP 19613 1255 71 men man NNS 19613 1255 72 phylattomen phylattoman NNS 19613 1255 73 , , , 19613 1255 74 oi oi NNP 19613 1255 75 de de NNP 19613 1255 76 parabainousi parabainousi NNP 19613 1255 77 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1255 78 . . . 19613 1256 1 But but CC 19613 1256 2 in in IN 19613 1256 3 the the DT 19613 1256 4 other other JJ 19613 1256 5 passages passage NNS 19613 1256 6 in in IN 19613 1256 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1256 8 where where WRB 19613 1256 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1256 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1256 11 : : : 19613 1256 12 homologia homologia NNP 19613 1256 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1256 14 appears appear VBZ 19613 1256 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1256 16 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 1256 17 signifies signify VBZ 19613 1256 18 a a DT 19613 1256 19 fixed fix VBN 19613 1256 20 formula formula NN 19613 1256 21 of of IN 19613 1256 22 confession confession NN 19613 1256 23 , , , 19613 1256 24 but but CC 19613 1256 25 always always RB 19613 1256 26 the the DT 19613 1256 27 confession confession NN 19613 1256 28 in in IN 19613 1256 29 general general JJ 19613 1256 30 which which WDT 19613 1256 31 receives receive VBZ 19613 1256 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1256 33 content content NN 19613 1256 34 according accord VBG 19613 1256 35 to to IN 19613 1256 36 the the DT 19613 1256 37 situation situation NN 19613 1256 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1256 39 see see VB 19613 1256 40 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1256 41 . . . 19613 1257 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1257 2 . . . 19613 1258 1 4 4 LS 19613 1258 2 . . . 19613 1259 1 15 15 CD 19613 1259 2 ; ; : 19613 1259 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1259 4 . . . 19613 1260 1 9 9 CD 19613 1260 2 . . . 19613 1261 1 71 71 CD 19613 1261 2 ; ; : 19613 1261 3 III iii CD 19613 1261 4 . . . 19613 1262 1 1 1 LS 19613 1262 2 . . . 19613 1263 1 4 4 LS 19613 1263 2 : : : 19613 1263 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1263 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1263 5 : : : 19613 1263 6 egkrateia egkrateia VB 19613 1263 7 sômatos sômatos NNP 19613 1263 8 hyperopsia hyperopsia NNP 19613 1263 9 kata kata NNP 19613 1263 10 tên tên NNP 19613 1263 11 pros pro NNS 19613 1263 12 theon theon NNP 19613 1263 13 homologian homologian NNP 19613 1263 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1263 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1263 16 . . . 19613 1264 1 In in IN 19613 1264 2 the the DT 19613 1264 3 passage passage NN 19613 1264 4 quoted quote VBD 19613 1264 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1264 6 means mean VBZ 19613 1264 7 the the DT 19613 1264 8 confession confession NN 19613 1264 9 of of IN 19613 1264 10 the the DT 19613 1264 11 main main JJ 19613 1264 12 points point NNS 19613 1264 13 of of IN 19613 1264 14 the the DT 19613 1264 15 true true JJ 19613 1264 16 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 1264 17 . . . 19613 1265 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1265 2 is be VBZ 19613 1265 3 possible possible JJ 19613 1265 4 or or CC 19613 1265 5 probable probable JJ 19613 1265 6 that that IN 19613 1265 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1265 8 was be VBD 19613 1265 9 here here RB 19613 1265 10 alluding allude VBG 19613 1265 11 to to IN 19613 1265 12 a a DT 19613 1265 13 confession confession NN 19613 1265 14 at at IN 19613 1265 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 1265 16 , , , 19613 1265 17 but but CC 19613 1265 18 that that DT 19613 1265 19 is be VBZ 19613 1265 20 also also RB 19613 1265 21 not not RB 19613 1265 22 quite quite RB 19613 1265 23 certain certain JJ 19613 1265 24 . . . 19613 1266 1 At at IN 19613 1266 2 any any DT 19613 1266 3 rate rate NN 19613 1266 4 this this DT 19613 1266 5 one one CD 19613 1266 6 passage passage NN 19613 1266 7 can can MD 19613 1266 8 not not RB 19613 1266 9 prove prove VB 19613 1266 10 that that IN 19613 1266 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1266 12 identified identify VBD 19613 1266 13 the the DT 19613 1266 14 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1266 15 canon canon NN 19613 1266 16 with with IN 19613 1266 17 a a DT 19613 1266 18 formulated formulate VBN 19613 1266 19 confession confession NN 19613 1266 20 similar similar JJ 19613 1266 21 to to IN 19613 1266 22 or or CC 19613 1266 23 identical identical JJ 19613 1266 24 with with IN 19613 1266 25 the the DT 19613 1266 26 Roman Roman NNP 19613 1266 27 , , , 19613 1266 28 or or CC 19613 1266 29 else else RB 19613 1266 30 such such JJ 19613 1266 31 identification identification NN 19613 1266 32 must must MD 19613 1266 33 have have VB 19613 1266 34 appeared appear VBN 19613 1266 35 more more RBR 19613 1266 36 frequently frequently RB 19613 1266 37 in in IN 19613 1266 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1266 39 works work NNS 19613 1266 40 . . . 19613 1266 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1267 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1267 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1267 3 62 62 CD 19613 1267 4 : : : 19613 1267 5 De De NNP 19613 1267 6 princip princip NN 19613 1267 7 . . . 19613 1268 1 l. l. NNP 19613 1268 2 I. I. NNP 19613 1268 3 præf præf NNP 19613 1268 4 . . . 19613 1269 1 § § ADD 19613 1269 2 4 4 CD 19613 1269 3 - - SYM 19613 1269 4 10 10 CD 19613 1269 5 . . . 19613 1269 6 , , , 19613 1269 7 IV IV NNP 19613 1269 8 . . . 19613 1270 1 2 2 LS 19613 1270 2 . . . 19613 1271 1 2 2 LS 19613 1271 2 . . . 19613 1272 1 Yet yet CC 19613 1272 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1272 3 must must MD 19613 1272 4 consider consider VB 19613 1272 5 the the DT 19613 1272 6 passage passage NN 19613 1272 7 already already RB 19613 1272 8 twice twice RB 19613 1272 9 quoted quote VBN 19613 1272 10 , , , 19613 1272 11 namely namely RB 19613 1272 12 , , , 19613 1272 13 Com Com NNP 19613 1272 14 . . . 19613 1273 1 in in IN 19613 1273 2 John John NNP 19613 1273 3 . . . 19613 1274 1 XXXII XXXII NNP 19613 1274 2 . . . 19613 1275 1 9 9 LS 19613 1275 2 , , , 19613 1275 3 in in IN 19613 1275 4 order order NN 19613 1275 5 to to TO 19613 1275 6 determine determine VB 19613 1275 7 the the DT 19613 1275 8 practice practice NN 19613 1275 9 of of IN 19613 1275 10 the the DT 19613 1275 11 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 1275 12 Church Church NNP 19613 1275 13 at at IN 19613 1275 14 that that DT 19613 1275 15 time time NN 19613 1275 16 . . . 19613 1276 1 Was be VBD 19613 1276 2 this this DT 19613 1276 3 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1276 4 confession confession NN 19613 1276 5 not not RB 19613 1276 6 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1276 7 compiled compile VBN 19613 1276 8 from from IN 19613 1276 9 Herm Herm NNP 19613 1276 10 . . . 19613 1276 11 , , , 19613 1276 12 Mand Mand NNP 19613 1276 13 . . . 19613 1277 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1277 2 , , , 19613 1277 3 and and CC 19613 1277 4 Christological christological JJ 19613 1277 5 and and CC 19613 1277 6 theological theological JJ 19613 1277 7 teachings teaching NNS 19613 1277 8 , , , 19613 1277 9 so so IN 19613 1277 10 that that IN 19613 1277 11 the the DT 19613 1277 12 later later JJ 19613 1277 13 confessions confession NNS 19613 1277 14 of of IN 19613 1277 15 the the DT 19613 1277 16 East East NNP 19613 1277 17 with with IN 19613 1277 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1277 19 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 1277 20 details detail NNS 19613 1277 21 are be VBP 19613 1277 22 already already RB 19613 1277 23 to to TO 19613 1277 24 be be VB 19613 1277 25 found find VBN 19613 1277 26 here here RB 19613 1277 27 ? ? . 19613 1277 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1278 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1278 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1278 3 63 63 CD 19613 1278 4 : : : 19613 1278 5 That that DT 19613 1278 6 may may MD 19613 1278 7 be be VB 19613 1278 8 also also RB 19613 1278 9 shown show VBN 19613 1278 10 with with IN 19613 1278 11 regard regard NN 19613 1278 12 to to IN 19613 1278 13 the the DT 19613 1278 14 New New NNP 19613 1278 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1278 16 canon canon NN 19613 1278 17 . . . 19613 1279 1 Very very RB 19613 1279 2 important important JJ 19613 1279 3 is be VBZ 19613 1279 4 the the DT 19613 1279 5 declaration declaration NN 19613 1279 6 of of IN 19613 1279 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 1279 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1279 9 H. H. NNP 19613 1279 10 E. E. NNP 19613 1279 11 VI VI NNP 19613 1279 12 . . . 19613 1280 1 14 14 CD 19613 1280 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1280 3 that that IN 19613 1280 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1280 5 , , , 19613 1280 6 on on IN 19613 1280 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1280 8 own own JJ 19613 1280 9 testimony testimony NN 19613 1280 10 , , , 19613 1280 11 paid pay VBD 19613 1280 12 a a DT 19613 1280 13 brief brief JJ 19613 1280 14 visit visit NN 19613 1280 15 to to IN 19613 1280 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1280 17 in in IN 19613 1280 18 the the DT 19613 1280 19 time time NN 19613 1280 20 of of IN 19613 1280 21 Zephyrinus Zephyrinus NNP 19613 1280 22 , , , 19613 1280 23 " " `` 19613 1280 24 because because IN 19613 1280 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1280 26 wished wish VBD 19613 1280 27 to to TO 19613 1280 28 become become VB 19613 1280 29 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 1280 30 with with IN 19613 1280 31 the the DT 19613 1280 32 ancient ancient JJ 19613 1280 33 Church Church NNP 19613 1280 34 of of IN 19613 1280 35 the the DT 19613 1280 36 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 1280 37 . . . 19613 1280 38 " " '' 19613 1281 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1281 2 learn learn VBP 19613 1281 3 from from IN 19613 1281 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 1281 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1281 6 de de NNP 19613 1281 7 vir vir NNP 19613 1281 8 . . . 19613 1282 1 inl inl UH 19613 1282 2 . . . 19613 1283 1 61 61 CD 19613 1283 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1283 3 that that WDT 19613 1283 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1283 5 there there EX 19613 1283 6 became become VBD 19613 1283 7 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 1283 8 with with IN 19613 1283 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 1283 10 , , , 19613 1283 11 who who WP 19613 1283 12 even even RB 19613 1283 13 called call VBD 19613 1283 14 attention attention NN 19613 1283 15 to to IN 19613 1283 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1283 17 presence presence NN 19613 1283 18 in in IN 19613 1283 19 the the DT 19613 1283 20 church church NN 19613 1283 21 in in IN 19613 1283 22 a a DT 19613 1283 23 sermon sermon NN 19613 1283 24 . . . 19613 1284 1 That that IN 19613 1284 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1284 3 kept keep VBD 19613 1284 4 up up RP 19613 1284 5 a a DT 19613 1284 6 connection connection NN 19613 1284 7 with with IN 19613 1284 8 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1284 9 still still RB 19613 1284 10 later later RB 19613 1284 11 and and CC 19613 1284 12 followed follow VBD 19613 1284 13 the the DT 19613 1284 14 conflicts conflict NNS 19613 1284 15 there there RB 19613 1284 16 with with IN 19613 1284 17 keen keen JJ 19613 1284 18 interest interest NN 19613 1284 19 may may MD 19613 1284 20 be be VB 19613 1284 21 gathered gather VBN 19613 1284 22 from from IN 19613 1284 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1284 24 works work NNS 19613 1284 25 . . . 19613 1285 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1285 2 See see VB 19613 1285 3 Döllinger döllinger NN 19613 1285 4 , , , 19613 1285 5 " " '' 19613 1285 6 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 1285 7 und und JJ 19613 1285 8 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 1285 9 " " '' 19613 1285 10 p. p. NN 19613 1285 11 254 254 CD 19613 1285 12 ff ff NN 19613 1285 13 . . . 19613 1285 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1286 1 On on IN 19613 1286 2 the the DT 19613 1286 3 other other JJ 19613 1286 4 hand hand NN 19613 1286 5 , , , 19613 1286 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1286 7 was be VBD 19613 1286 8 quite quite RB 19613 1286 9 unacquainted unacquainted JJ 19613 1286 10 with with IN 19613 1286 11 that that DT 19613 1286 12 city city NN 19613 1286 13 . . . 19613 1287 1 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 1287 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 1287 3 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1287 4 . . . 19613 1288 1 rightly rightly RB 19613 1288 2 remarks remark VBZ 19613 1288 3 : : : 19613 1288 4 " " `` 19613 1288 5 The the DT 19613 1288 6 West West NNP 19613 1288 7 is be VBZ 19613 1288 8 as as RB 19613 1288 9 unknown unknown JJ 19613 1288 10 to to IN 19613 1288 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1288 12 as as IN 19613 1288 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1288 14 was be VBD 19613 1288 15 to to IN 19613 1288 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1288 17 favourite favourite JJ 19613 1288 18 Homer Homer NNP 19613 1288 19 . . . 19613 1288 20 " " '' 19613 1289 1 That that IN 19613 1289 2 there there EX 19613 1289 3 was be VBD 19613 1289 4 a a DT 19613 1289 5 formulated formulated JJ 19613 1289 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1289 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1289 8 : : : 19613 1289 9 pistis pistis NN 19613 1289 10 kai kai NNP 19613 1289 11 homologia homologia NNP 19613 1289 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1289 13 in in IN 19613 1289 14 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1289 15 about about IN 19613 1289 16 250 250 CD 19613 1289 17 A.D. A.D. NNP 19613 1289 18 is be VBZ 19613 1289 19 shown show VBN 19613 1289 20 by by IN 19613 1289 21 the the DT 19613 1289 22 epistle epistle NN 19613 1289 23 of of IN 19613 1289 24 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 1289 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1289 26 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1289 27 . . NNP 19613 1289 28 , , , 19613 1289 29 H. H. NNP 19613 1289 30 E. E. NNP 19613 1289 31 VII VII NNP 19613 1289 32 . . . 19613 1290 1 8) 8) CD 19613 1290 2 . . . 19613 1291 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1291 2 says say VBZ 19613 1291 3 of of IN 19613 1291 4 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 1291 5 , , , 19613 1291 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1291 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1291 8 : : : 19613 1291 9 anatrepei anatrepei NNP 19613 1291 10 tên tên FW 19613 1291 11 pro pro FW 19613 1291 12 loutrou loutrou NNP 19613 1291 13 pistin pistin NNP 19613 1291 14 kai kai NNP 19613 1291 15 homologian homologian NNP 19613 1291 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1291 17 . . . 19613 1292 1 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 1292 2 would would MD 19613 1292 3 hardly hardly RB 19613 1292 4 have have VB 19613 1292 5 reproduced reproduce VBN 19613 1292 6 this this DT 19613 1292 7 Roman roman JJ 19613 1292 8 reproach reproach NN 19613 1292 9 in in IN 19613 1292 10 that that DT 19613 1292 11 way way NN 19613 1292 12 , , , 19613 1292 13 if if IN 19613 1292 14 the the DT 19613 1292 15 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 1292 16 Church Church NNP 19613 1292 17 had have VBD 19613 1292 18 not not RB 19613 1292 19 possessed possess VBN 19613 1292 20 a a DT 19613 1292 21 similar similar JJ 19613 1292 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1292 23 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1292 24 : : : 19613 1292 25 pistis pistis NN 19613 1292 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1292 27 . . . 19613 1292 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1293 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1293 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1293 3 64 64 CD 19613 1293 4 : : : 19613 1293 5 The the DT 19613 1293 6 original original NN 19613 1293 7 of of IN 19613 1293 8 the the DT 19613 1293 9 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 1293 10 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 1293 11 has have VBZ 19613 1293 12 as as RB 19613 1293 13 yet yet RB 19613 1293 14 no no DT 19613 1293 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 1293 16 of of IN 19613 1293 17 the the DT 19613 1293 18 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 1293 19 rule rule NN 19613 1293 20 of of IN 19613 1293 21 faith faith NN 19613 1293 22 in in IN 19613 1293 23 the the DT 19613 1293 24 Western western JJ 19613 1293 25 sense sense NN 19613 1293 26 . . . 19613 1293 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1294 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1294 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1294 3 65 65 CD 19613 1294 4 : : : 19613 1294 5 The the DT 19613 1294 6 close close NN 19613 1294 7 of of IN 19613 1294 8 the the DT 19613 1294 9 first first JJ 19613 1294 10 homily homily RB 19613 1294 11 of of IN 19613 1294 12 Aphraates Aphraates NNP 19613 1294 13 shows show VBZ 19613 1294 14 how how WRB 19613 1294 15 simple simple JJ 19613 1294 16 , , , 19613 1294 17 antique antique JJ 19613 1294 18 , , , 19613 1294 19 and and CC 19613 1294 20 original original JJ 19613 1294 21 this this DT 19613 1294 22 confession confession NN 19613 1294 23 still still RB 19613 1294 24 was be VBD 19613 1294 25 in in IN 19613 1294 26 outlying outlying JJ 19613 1294 27 districts district NNS 19613 1294 28 at at IN 19613 1294 29 the the DT 19613 1294 30 beginning beginning NN 19613 1294 31 of of IN 19613 1294 32 the the DT 19613 1294 33 fourth fourth JJ 19613 1294 34 century century NN 19613 1294 35 . . . 19613 1295 1 On on IN 19613 1295 2 the the DT 19613 1295 3 other other JJ 19613 1295 4 hand hand NN 19613 1295 5 , , , 19613 1295 6 there there EX 19613 1295 7 were be VBD 19613 1295 8 oriental oriental JJ 19613 1295 9 communities community NNS 19613 1295 10 where where WRB 19613 1295 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1295 12 was be VBD 19613 1295 13 already already RB 19613 1295 14 heavily heavily RB 19613 1295 15 weighted weight VBN 19613 1295 16 with with IN 19613 1295 17 theology theology NN 19613 1295 18 . . . 19613 1295 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1296 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1296 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1296 3 66 66 CD 19613 1296 4 : : : 19613 1296 5 Cf cf NN 19613 1296 6 . . . 19613 1297 1 the the DT 19613 1297 2 epistles epistle NNS 19613 1297 3 of of IN 19613 1297 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1297 5 , , , 19613 1297 6 especially especially RB 19613 1297 7 ep ep VB 19613 1297 8 . . . 19613 1298 1 69 69 CD 19613 1298 2 . . . 19613 1299 1 70 70 CD 19613 1299 2 . . . 19613 1300 1 When when WRB 19613 1300 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1300 3 speaks speak VBZ 19613 1300 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1300 5 69 69 CD 19613 1300 6 . . . 19613 1301 1 7 7 LS 19613 1301 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1301 3 of of IN 19613 1301 4 one one CD 19613 1301 5 and and CC 19613 1301 6 the the DT 19613 1301 7 same same JJ 19613 1301 8 law law NN 19613 1301 9 which which WDT 19613 1301 10 is be VBZ 19613 1301 11 held hold VBN 19613 1301 12 by by IN 19613 1301 13 the the DT 19613 1301 14 whole whole JJ 19613 1301 15 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1301 16 Church Church NNP 19613 1301 17 , , , 19613 1301 18 and and CC 19613 1301 19 of of IN 19613 1301 20 one one CD 19613 1301 21 _ _ NNP 19613 1301 22 symbol symbol NN 19613 1301 23 _ _ NNP 19613 1301 24 with with IN 19613 1301 25 which which WDT 19613 1301 26 she -PRON- PRP 19613 1301 27 administers administer VBZ 19613 1301 28 baptism baptism NN 19613 1301 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1301 30 this this DT 19613 1301 31 is be VBZ 19613 1301 32 the the DT 19613 1301 33 first first JJ 19613 1301 34 time time NN 19613 1301 35 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1301 36 meet meet VBP 19613 1301 37 with with IN 19613 1301 38 this this DT 19613 1301 39 expression expression NN 19613 1301 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1301 41 , , , 19613 1301 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1301 43 words word NNS 19613 1301 44 mean mean VBP 19613 1301 45 far far RB 19613 1301 46 more more JJR 19613 1301 47 than than IN 19613 1301 48 the the DT 19613 1301 49 assertion assertion NN 19613 1301 50 of of IN 19613 1301 51 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1301 52 that that IN 19613 1301 53 the the DT 19613 1301 54 confession confession NN 19613 1301 55 expounded expound VBN 19613 1301 56 by by IN 19613 1301 57 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1301 58 is be VBZ 19613 1301 59 the the DT 19613 1301 60 guiding guide VBG 19613 1301 61 rule rule NN 19613 1301 62 in in IN 19613 1301 63 all all DT 19613 1301 64 Churches church NNS 19613 1301 65 ; ; : 19613 1301 66 for for IN 19613 1301 67 in in IN 19613 1301 68 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1301 69 's 's POS 19613 1301 70 time time NN 19613 1301 71 the the DT 19613 1301 72 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 1301 73 of of IN 19613 1301 74 most most JJS 19613 1301 75 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1301 76 communities community NNS 19613 1301 77 with with IN 19613 1301 78 each each DT 19613 1301 79 other other JJ 19613 1301 80 was be VBD 19613 1301 81 so so RB 19613 1301 82 regulated regulate VBN 19613 1301 83 that that IN 19613 1301 84 the the DT 19613 1301 85 state state NN 19613 1301 86 of of IN 19613 1301 87 things thing NNS 19613 1301 88 in in IN 19613 1301 89 each each DT 19613 1301 90 was be VBD 19613 1301 91 to to IN 19613 1301 92 some some DT 19613 1301 93 extent extent NN 19613 1301 94 really really RB 19613 1301 95 known know VBN 19613 1301 96 . . . 19613 1302 1 Cf cf NN 19613 1302 2 . . . 19613 1303 1 also also RB 19613 1303 2 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 1303 3 , , , 19613 1303 4 " " '' 19613 1303 5 de de FW 19613 1303 6 trinitate trinitate NNP 19613 1303 7 seu seu NNP 19613 1303 8 de de IN 19613 1303 9 regula regula NNP 19613 1303 10 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1303 11 , , , 19613 1303 12 " " '' 19613 1303 13 as as RB 19613 1303 14 well well RB 19613 1303 15 as as IN 19613 1303 16 the the DT 19613 1303 17 circular circular JJ 19613 1303 18 letter letter NN 19613 1303 19 of of IN 19613 1303 20 the the DT 19613 1303 21 Synod Synod NNP 19613 1303 22 of of IN 19613 1303 23 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 1303 24 referring refer VBG 19613 1303 25 to to IN 19613 1303 26 the the DT 19613 1303 27 Metropolitan Metropolitan NNP 19613 1303 28 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1303 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1303 30 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1303 31 . . NNP 19613 1303 32 , , , 19613 1303 33 H. H. NNP 19613 1303 34 E. E. NNP 19613 1303 35 VII VII NNP 19613 1303 36 . . . 19613 1304 1 30 30 CD 19613 1304 2 . . . 19613 1305 1 6 6 LS 19613 1305 2 ... ... NFP 19613 1305 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1305 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1305 5 : : : 19613 1305 6 apostas apostas NNP 19613 1305 7 tou tou NNP 19613 1305 8 kanonos kanonos NNP 19613 1305 9 epi epi NNP 19613 1305 10 kibdêla kibdêla NNP 19613 1305 11 kai kai NNP 19613 1305 12 notha notha NNP 19613 1305 13 didagmata didagmata NNP 19613 1305 14 metelêluthen metelêluthen NNP 19613 1305 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1305 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1305 17 , , , 19613 1305 18 and and CC 19613 1305 19 the the DT 19613 1305 20 homilies homily NNS 19613 1305 21 of of IN 19613 1305 22 Aphraates Aphraates NNPS 19613 1305 23 . . . 19613 1306 1 The the DT 19613 1306 2 closer close JJR 19613 1306 3 examination examination NN 19613 1306 4 of of IN 19613 1306 5 the the DT 19613 1306 6 last last JJ 19613 1306 7 phase phase NN 19613 1306 8 in in IN 19613 1306 9 the the DT 19613 1306 10 development development NN 19613 1306 11 of of IN 19613 1306 12 the the DT 19613 1306 13 confession confession NN 19613 1306 14 of of IN 19613 1306 15 faith faith NN 19613 1306 16 during during IN 19613 1306 17 this this DT 19613 1306 18 epoch epoch NN 19613 1306 19 , , , 19613 1306 20 when when WRB 19613 1306 21 the the DT 19613 1306 22 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1306 23 confessions confession NNS 19613 1306 24 received receive VBD 19613 1306 25 an an DT 19613 1306 26 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 1306 27 in in IN 19613 1306 28 accordance accordance NN 19613 1306 29 with with IN 19613 1306 30 the the DT 19613 1306 31 theology theology NN 19613 1306 32 of of IN 19613 1306 33 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1306 34 , , , 19613 1306 35 will will MD 19613 1306 36 be be VB 19613 1306 37 more more RBR 19613 1306 38 conveniently conveniently RB 19613 1306 39 left leave VBN 19613 1306 40 over over RP 19613 1306 41 till till IN 19613 1306 42 the the DT 19613 1306 43 close close NN 19613 1306 44 of of IN 19613 1306 45 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1306 46 description description NN 19613 1306 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1306 48 see see VB 19613 1306 49 chap chap NNP 19613 1306 50 . . . 19613 1307 1 7 7 CD 19613 1307 2 fin fin NNP 19613 1307 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1307 4 . . . 19613 1307 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1308 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1308 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1308 3 67 67 CD 19613 1308 4 : : : 19613 1308 5 See see VB 19613 1308 6 the the DT 19613 1308 7 histories history NNS 19613 1308 8 of of IN 19613 1308 9 the the DT 19613 1308 10 canon canon NN 19613 1308 11 by by IN 19613 1308 12 Credner Credner NNP 19613 1308 13 , , , 19613 1308 14 Reuss Reuss NNP 19613 1308 15 , , , 19613 1308 16 Westcott Westcott NNP 19613 1308 17 , , , 19613 1308 18 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 19613 1308 19 , , , 19613 1308 20 Schmiedel Schmiedel NNP 19613 1308 21 , , , 19613 1308 22 Holtzmann Holtzmann NNP 19613 1308 23 , , , 19613 1308 24 and and CC 19613 1308 25 Weiss Weiss NNP 19613 1308 26 ; ; : 19613 1308 27 the the DT 19613 1308 28 latter latter JJ 19613 1308 29 two two CD 19613 1308 30 , , , 19613 1308 31 which which WDT 19613 1308 32 to to IN 19613 1308 33 some some DT 19613 1308 34 extent extent NN 19613 1308 35 supplement supplement VB 19613 1308 36 each each DT 19613 1308 37 other other JJ 19613 1308 38 , , , 19613 1308 39 are be VBP 19613 1308 40 specially specially RB 19613 1308 41 instructive instructive JJ 19613 1308 42 . . . 19613 1309 1 To to IN 19613 1309 2 Weiss Weiss NNP 19613 1309 3 belongs belong VBZ 19613 1309 4 the the DT 19613 1309 5 merit merit NN 19613 1309 6 of of IN 19613 1309 7 having have VBG 19613 1309 8 kept keep VBN 19613 1309 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1309 10 and and CC 19613 1309 11 Apostles apostle VBZ 19613 1309 12 clearly clearly RB 19613 1309 13 apart apart RB 19613 1309 14 in in IN 19613 1309 15 the the DT 19613 1309 16 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 1309 17 history history NN 19613 1309 18 of of IN 19613 1309 19 the the DT 19613 1309 20 canon canon NN 19613 1309 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1309 22 see see VB 19613 1309 23 Th Th NNP 19613 1309 24 . . . 19613 1310 1 L. L. NNP 19613 1310 2 Z. Z. NNP 19613 1311 1 1886 1886 CD 19613 1311 2 . . . 19613 1312 1 Nr Nr NNP 19613 1312 2 . . . 19613 1313 1 24 24 CD 19613 1313 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1313 3 ; ; : 19613 1313 4 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 1313 5 , , , 19613 1313 6 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1313 7 . . . 19613 1314 1 des des NNP 19613 1314 2 N. N. NNP 19613 1314 3 Tlichen Tlichen NNP 19613 1314 4 Kanons Kanons NNP 19613 1314 5 , , , 19613 1314 6 2 2 CD 19613 1314 7 vols vol NNS 19613 1314 8 , , , 19613 1314 9 1888 1888 CD 19613 1314 10 ff ff NNP 19613 1314 11 . . . 19613 1315 1 ; ; : 19613 1315 2 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 1315 3 , , , 19613 1315 4 Das Das NNP 19613 1315 5 Neue Neue NNP 19613 1315 6 Test Test NNP 19613 1315 7 . . . 19613 1316 1 um um UH 19613 1316 2 d. d. NNP 19613 1316 3 J. J. NNP 19613 1317 1 200 200 CD 19613 1317 2 , , , 19613 1317 3 1889 1889 CD 19613 1317 4 ; ; : 19613 1317 5 Voigt Voigt NNP 19613 1317 6 , , , 19613 1317 7 Eine Eine NNP 19613 1317 8 verschollene verschollene NN 19613 1317 9 Urkunde Urkunde NNP 19613 1317 10 des des NNP 19613 1317 11 antimontan antimontan NNP 19613 1317 12 . . . 19613 1318 1 Kampfes Kampfes NNP 19613 1318 2 , , , 19613 1318 3 1891 1891 CD 19613 1318 4 , , , 19613 1318 5 p. p. NN 19613 1318 6 236 236 CD 19613 1318 7 ff ff NN 19613 1318 8 . . . 19613 1319 1 ; ; : 19613 1319 2 Weizsäcker Weizsäcker NNP 19613 1319 3 , , , 19613 1319 4 Rede Rede NNP 19613 1319 5 bei bei NNP 19613 1319 6 der der VBP 19613 1319 7 akad akad NNP 19613 1319 8 . . . 19613 1320 1 Preisvertheilung Preisvertheilung NNP 19613 1320 2 , , , 19613 1320 3 1892 1892 CD 19613 1320 4 . . . 19613 1321 1 Nov. November NNP 19613 1321 2 ; ; : 19613 1321 3 Köppel Köppel NNP 19613 1321 4 , , , 19613 1321 5 Stud Stud NNP 19613 1321 6 . . . 19613 1322 1 u. u. NNP 19613 1322 2 Krit Krit NNP 19613 1322 3 . . . 19613 1323 1 1891 1891 CD 19613 1323 2 , , , 19613 1323 3 p. p. NN 19613 1323 4 102 102 CD 19613 1323 5 ff ff NN 19613 1323 6 ; ; : 19613 1323 7 Barth Barth NNP 19613 1323 8 , , , 19613 1323 9 Neue Neue NNP 19613 1323 10 Jahrbb Jahrbb NNP 19613 1323 11 . . . 19613 1324 1 f. f. NNP 19613 1324 2 deutsche deutsche NNP 19613 1324 3 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 1324 4 , , , 19613 1324 5 1893 1893 CD 19613 1324 6 , , , 19613 1324 7 p. p. NN 19613 1324 8 56 56 CD 19613 1324 9 ff ff NN 19613 1324 10 . . . 19613 1325 1 The the DT 19613 1325 2 following follow VBG 19613 1325 3 account account NN 19613 1325 4 gives give VBZ 19613 1325 5 only only RB 19613 1325 6 a a DT 19613 1325 7 few few JJ 19613 1325 8 aspects aspect NNS 19613 1325 9 of of IN 19613 1325 10 the the DT 19613 1325 11 case case NN 19613 1325 12 , , , 19613 1325 13 not not RB 19613 1325 14 a a DT 19613 1325 15 history history NN 19613 1325 16 of of IN 19613 1325 17 the the DT 19613 1325 18 genesis genesis NN 19613 1325 19 of of IN 19613 1325 20 the the DT 19613 1325 21 canon canon NN 19613 1325 22 . . . 19613 1325 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1326 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1326 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1326 3 68 68 CD 19613 1326 4 : : : 19613 1326 5 " " `` 19613 1326 6 Holy Holy NNP 19613 1326 7 " " '' 19613 1326 8 is be VBZ 19613 1326 9 not not RB 19613 1326 10 always always RB 19613 1326 11 equivalent equivalent JJ 19613 1326 12 to to IN 19613 1326 13 " " `` 19613 1326 14 possessing possess VBG 19613 1326 15 absolute absolute JJ 19613 1326 16 authority authority NN 19613 1326 17 . . . 19613 1326 18 " " '' 19613 1327 1 There there EX 19613 1327 2 are be VBP 19613 1327 3 also also RB 19613 1327 4 various various JJ 19613 1327 5 stages stage NNS 19613 1327 6 and and CC 19613 1327 7 degrees degree NNS 19613 1327 8 of of IN 19613 1327 9 " " `` 19613 1327 10 holy holy JJ 19613 1327 11 . . . 19613 1327 12 " " '' 19613 1327 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1328 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1328 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1328 3 69 69 CD 19613 1328 4 : : : 19613 1328 5 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1328 6 beg beg VBP 19613 1328 7 here here RB 19613 1328 8 to to TO 19613 1328 9 lay lay VB 19613 1328 10 down down RP 19613 1328 11 the the DT 19613 1328 12 following follow VBG 19613 1328 13 principles principle NNS 19613 1328 14 as as IN 19613 1328 15 to to IN 19613 1328 16 criticism criticism NN 19613 1328 17 of of IN 19613 1328 18 the the DT 19613 1328 19 New New NNP 19613 1328 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1328 21 . . . 19613 1329 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1329 2 1 1 LS 19613 1329 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1329 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1329 5 is be VBZ 19613 1329 6 not not RB 19613 1329 7 individual individual JJ 19613 1329 8 writings writing NNS 19613 1329 9 , , , 19613 1329 10 but but CC 19613 1329 11 the the DT 19613 1329 12 whole whole JJ 19613 1329 13 book book NN 19613 1329 14 that that WDT 19613 1329 15 has have VBZ 19613 1329 16 been be VBN 19613 1329 17 immediately immediately RB 19613 1329 18 handed hand VBN 19613 1329 19 down down RP 19613 1329 20 to to IN 19613 1329 21 us -PRON- PRP 19613 1329 22 . . . 19613 1330 1 Hence hence RB 19613 1330 2 , , , 19613 1330 3 in in IN 19613 1330 4 the the DT 19613 1330 5 case case NN 19613 1330 6 of of IN 19613 1330 7 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 1330 8 arising arise VBG 19613 1330 9 , , , 19613 1330 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1330 11 must must MD 19613 1330 12 first first RB 19613 1330 13 of of IN 19613 1330 14 all all DT 19613 1330 15 enquire enquire NN 19613 1330 16 , , , 19613 1330 17 not not RB 19613 1330 18 whether whether IN 19613 1330 19 the the DT 19613 1330 20 title title NN 19613 1330 21 and and CC 19613 1330 22 historical historical JJ 19613 1330 23 setting setting NN 19613 1330 24 of of IN 19613 1330 25 a a DT 19613 1330 26 book book NN 19613 1330 27 are be VBP 19613 1330 28 genuine genuine JJ 19613 1330 29 or or CC 19613 1330 30 not not RB 19613 1330 31 , , , 19613 1330 32 but but CC 19613 1330 33 if if IN 19613 1330 34 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1330 35 are be VBP 19613 1330 36 original original JJ 19613 1330 37 , , , 19613 1330 38 or or CC 19613 1330 39 were be VBD 19613 1330 40 only only RB 19613 1330 41 given give VBN 19613 1330 42 to to IN 19613 1330 43 the the DT 19613 1330 44 work work NN 19613 1330 45 when when WRB 19613 1330 46 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1330 47 became become VBD 19613 1330 48 a a DT 19613 1330 49 component component JJ 19613 1330 50 part part NN 19613 1330 51 of of IN 19613 1330 52 the the DT 19613 1330 53 collection collection NN 19613 1330 54 . . . 19613 1331 1 This this DT 19613 1331 2 also also RB 19613 1331 3 gives give VBZ 19613 1331 4 us -PRON- PRP 19613 1331 5 the the DT 19613 1331 6 right right NN 19613 1331 7 to to TO 19613 1331 8 assume assume VB 19613 1331 9 interpolations interpolation NNS 19613 1331 10 in in IN 19613 1331 11 the the DT 19613 1331 12 text text NN 19613 1331 13 belonging belong VBG 19613 1331 14 to to IN 19613 1331 15 the the DT 19613 1331 16 time time NN 19613 1331 17 when when WRB 19613 1331 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1331 19 was be VBD 19613 1331 20 included include VBN 19613 1331 21 in in IN 19613 1331 22 the the DT 19613 1331 23 canon canon NN 19613 1331 24 , , , 19613 1331 25 though though IN 19613 1331 26 this this DT 19613 1331 27 right right NN 19613 1331 28 must must MD 19613 1331 29 be be VB 19613 1331 30 used use VBN 19613 1331 31 with with IN 19613 1331 32 caution caution NN 19613 1331 33 . . . 19613 1332 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1332 2 2 2 LS 19613 1332 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1332 4 Baur Baur NNP 19613 1332 5 's 's POS 19613 1332 6 " " `` 19613 1332 7 tendency tendency NN 19613 1332 8 - - HYPH 19613 1332 9 criticism criticism NN 19613 1332 10 " " '' 19613 1332 11 has have VBZ 19613 1332 12 fallen fall VBN 19613 1332 13 into into IN 19613 1332 14 disrepute disrepute JJ 19613 1332 15 ; ; : 19613 1332 16 hence hence RB 19613 1332 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1332 18 must must MD 19613 1332 19 also also RB 19613 1332 20 free free VB 19613 1332 21 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 1332 22 from from IN 19613 1332 23 the the DT 19613 1332 24 pedantry pedantry NN 19613 1332 25 and and CC 19613 1332 26 hair hair NN 19613 1332 27 - - HYPH 19613 1332 28 splitting splitting NN 19613 1332 29 which which WDT 19613 1332 30 were be VBD 19613 1332 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1332 32 after after IN 19613 1332 33 effects effect NNS 19613 1332 34 . . . 19613 1333 1 In in IN 19613 1333 2 consequence consequence NN 19613 1333 3 of of IN 19613 1333 4 the the DT 19613 1333 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1333 6 erroneous erroneous JJ 19613 1333 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1333 8 assumptions assumption NNS 19613 1333 9 of of IN 19613 1333 10 the the DT 19613 1333 11 Tübingen Tübingen NNP 19613 1333 12 school school NN 19613 1333 13 of of IN 19613 1333 14 critics critic NNS 19613 1333 15 a a DT 19613 1333 16 suspicious suspicious JJ 19613 1333 17 examination examination NN 19613 1333 18 of of IN 19613 1333 19 the the DT 19613 1333 20 texts text NNS 19613 1333 21 was be VBD 19613 1333 22 justifiable justifiable JJ 19613 1333 23 and and CC 19613 1333 24 obligatory obligatory JJ 19613 1333 25 on on IN 19613 1333 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1333 27 part part NN 19613 1333 28 . . . 19613 1334 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1334 2 3 3 LS 19613 1334 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1334 4 Individual individual JJ 19613 1334 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 1334 6 about about IN 19613 1334 7 the the DT 19613 1334 8 date date NN 19613 1334 9 of of IN 19613 1334 10 a a DT 19613 1334 11 document document NN 19613 1334 12 ought ought MD 19613 1334 13 not not RB 19613 1334 14 to to TO 19613 1334 15 have have VB 19613 1334 16 the the DT 19613 1334 17 result result NN 19613 1334 18 of of IN 19613 1334 19 casting cast VBG 19613 1334 20 suspicion suspicion NN 19613 1334 21 on on IN 19613 1334 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1334 23 , , , 19613 1334 24 when when WRB 19613 1334 25 other other JJ 19613 1334 26 good good JJ 19613 1334 27 grounds ground NNS 19613 1334 28 speak speak VBP 19613 1334 29 in in IN 19613 1334 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1334 31 favour favour NN 19613 1334 32 ; ; , 19613 1334 33 for for IN 19613 1334 34 , , , 19613 1334 35 in in IN 19613 1334 36 dealing deal VBG 19613 1334 37 with with IN 19613 1334 38 writings writing NNS 19613 1334 39 which which WDT 19613 1334 40 have have VBP 19613 1334 41 no no UH 19613 1334 42 , , , 19613 1334 43 or or CC 19613 1334 44 almost almost RB 19613 1334 45 no no DT 19613 1334 46 accompanying accompany VBG 19613 1334 47 literature literature NN 19613 1334 48 , , , 19613 1334 49 such such JJ 19613 1334 50 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 1334 51 can can MD 19613 1334 52 not not RB 19613 1334 53 fail fail VB 19613 1334 54 to to TO 19613 1334 55 arise arise VB 19613 1334 56 . . . 19613 1335 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1335 2 4 4 LS 19613 1335 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1335 4 The the DT 19613 1335 5 condition condition NN 19613 1335 6 of of IN 19613 1335 7 the the DT 19613 1335 8 oldest old JJS 19613 1335 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1335 10 up up RP 19613 1335 11 to to IN 19613 1335 12 the the DT 19613 1335 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 1335 14 of of IN 19613 1335 15 the the DT 19613 1335 16 second second JJ 19613 1335 17 century century NN 19613 1335 18 did do VBD 19613 1335 19 not not RB 19613 1335 20 favour favour VB 19613 1335 21 literary literary JJ 19613 1335 22 forgeries forgery NNS 19613 1335 23 or or CC 19613 1335 24 interpolations interpolation NNS 19613 1335 25 in in IN 19613 1335 26 support support NN 19613 1335 27 of of IN 19613 1335 28 a a DT 19613 1335 29 definite definite JJ 19613 1335 30 tendency tendency NN 19613 1335 31 . . . 19613 1336 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1336 2 5 5 LS 19613 1336 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1336 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1336 5 must must MD 19613 1336 6 remember remember VB 19613 1336 7 that that IN 19613 1336 8 , , , 19613 1336 9 from from IN 19613 1336 10 the the DT 19613 1336 11 death death NN 19613 1336 12 of of IN 19613 1336 13 Nero Nero NNP 19613 1336 14 till till IN 19613 1336 15 the the DT 19613 1336 16 time time NN 19613 1336 17 of of IN 19613 1336 18 Trajan Trajan NNP 19613 1336 19 , , , 19613 1336 20 very very RB 19613 1336 21 little little JJ 19613 1336 22 is be VBZ 19613 1336 23 known know VBN 19613 1336 24 of of IN 19613 1336 25 the the DT 19613 1336 26 history history NN 19613 1336 27 of of IN 19613 1336 28 the the DT 19613 1336 29 Church Church NNP 19613 1336 30 except except IN 19613 1336 31 the the DT 19613 1336 32 fact fact NN 19613 1336 33 that that IN 19613 1336 34 , , , 19613 1336 35 by by IN 19613 1336 36 the the DT 19613 1336 37 end end NN 19613 1336 38 of of IN 19613 1336 39 this this DT 19613 1336 40 time time NN 19613 1336 41 , , , 19613 1336 42 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1336 43 had have VBD 19613 1336 44 not not RB 19613 1336 45 only only RB 19613 1336 46 spread spread VBN 19613 1336 47 to to IN 19613 1336 48 an an DT 19613 1336 49 astonishing astonishing JJ 19613 1336 50 extent extent NN 19613 1336 51 , , , 19613 1336 52 but but CC 19613 1336 53 also also RB 19613 1336 54 had have VBD 19613 1336 55 become become VBN 19613 1336 56 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 1336 57 consolidated consolidate VBN 19613 1336 58 . . . 19613 1336 59 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1337 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1337 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1337 3 70 70 CD 19613 1337 4 : : : 19613 1337 5 The the DT 19613 1337 6 novelty novelty NN 19613 1337 7 lies lie VBZ 19613 1337 8 first first RB 19613 1337 9 in in IN 19613 1337 10 the the DT 19613 1337 11 idea idea NN 19613 1337 12 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1337 13 , , , 19613 1337 14 secondly secondly RB 19613 1337 15 in in IN 19613 1337 16 the the DT 19613 1337 17 form form NN 19613 1337 18 in in IN 19613 1337 19 which which WDT 19613 1337 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1337 21 was be VBD 19613 1337 22 worked work VBN 19613 1337 23 out out RP 19613 1337 24 , , , 19613 1337 25 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 1337 26 as as IN 19613 1337 27 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 1337 28 would would MD 19613 1337 29 only only RB 19613 1337 30 admit admit VB 19613 1337 31 the the DT 19613 1337 32 authority authority NN 19613 1337 33 of of IN 19613 1337 34 one one CD 19613 1337 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1337 36 to to IN 19613 1337 37 the the DT 19613 1337 38 exclusion exclusion NN 19613 1337 39 of of IN 19613 1337 40 all all PDT 19613 1337 41 the the DT 19613 1337 42 rest rest NN 19613 1337 43 , , , 19613 1337 44 and and CC 19613 1337 45 added add VBD 19613 1337 46 the the DT 19613 1337 47 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1337 48 epistles epistle NNS 19613 1337 49 which which WDT 19613 1337 50 had have VBD 19613 1337 51 originally originally RB 19613 1337 52 little little JJ 19613 1337 53 to to TO 19613 1337 54 do do VB 19613 1337 55 with with IN 19613 1337 56 the the DT 19613 1337 57 conception conception NN 19613 1337 58 of of IN 19613 1337 59 the the DT 19613 1337 60 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1337 61 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 1337 62 tradition tradition NN 19613 1337 63 of of IN 19613 1337 64 the the DT 19613 1337 65 Church Church NNP 19613 1337 66 . . . 19613 1337 67 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1338 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1338 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1338 3 71 71 CD 19613 1338 4 : : : 19613 1338 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1338 6 is be VBZ 19613 1338 7 easy easy JJ 19613 1338 8 to to TO 19613 1338 9 understand understand VB 19613 1338 10 that that IN 19613 1338 11 , , , 19613 1338 12 wherever wherever WRB 19613 1338 13 there there EX 19613 1338 14 was be VBD 19613 1338 15 criticism criticism NN 19613 1338 16 of of IN 19613 1338 17 the the DT 19613 1338 18 Old Old NNP 19613 1338 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1338 20 , , , 19613 1338 21 the the DT 19613 1338 22 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1338 23 epistles epistle NNS 19613 1338 24 circulating circulate VBG 19613 1338 25 in in IN 19613 1338 26 the the DT 19613 1338 27 Church Church NNP 19613 1338 28 would would MD 19613 1338 29 be be VB 19613 1338 30 thrust thrust VBN 19613 1338 31 into into IN 19613 1338 32 the the DT 19613 1338 33 foreground foreground NN 19613 1338 34 . . . 19613 1339 1 The the DT 19613 1339 2 same same JJ 19613 1339 3 thing thing NN 19613 1339 4 was be VBD 19613 1339 5 done do VBN 19613 1339 6 by by IN 19613 1339 7 the the DT 19613 1339 8 Manichæans Manichæans NNPS 19613 1339 9 in in IN 19613 1339 10 the the DT 19613 1339 11 Byzantine byzantine JJ 19613 1339 12 age age NN 19613 1339 13 . . . 19613 1339 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1340 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1340 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1340 3 72 72 CD 19613 1340 4 : : : 19613 1340 5 Four four CD 19613 1340 6 passages passage NNS 19613 1340 7 may may MD 19613 1340 8 be be VB 19613 1340 9 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 1340 10 appealed appeal VBN 19613 1340 11 to to IN 19613 1340 12 in in IN 19613 1340 13 support support NN 19613 1340 14 of of IN 19613 1340 15 the the DT 19613 1340 16 opposite opposite JJ 19613 1340 17 view view NN 19613 1340 18 , , , 19613 1340 19 viz viz NNP 19613 1340 20 . . NNP 19613 1340 21 , , , 19613 1340 22 2 2 CD 19613 1340 23 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1340 24 III III NNP 19613 1340 25 . . . 19613 1341 1 16 16 CD 19613 1341 2 ; ; : 19613 1341 3 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 1341 4 ep ep VB 19613 1341 5 . . . 19613 1342 1 12 12 CD 19613 1342 2 . . . 19613 1343 1 1 1 LS 19613 1343 2 ; ; : 19613 1343 3 Barn Barn NNP 19613 1343 4 . . . 19613 1344 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1344 2 . . . 19613 1345 1 14 14 CD 19613 1345 2 ; ; : 19613 1345 3 2 2 CD 19613 1345 4 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1345 5 . . . 19613 1346 1 II ii CD 19613 1346 2 . . . 19613 1347 1 4 4 LS 19613 1347 2 . . . 19613 1348 1 But but CC 19613 1348 2 the the DT 19613 1348 3 first first JJ 19613 1348 4 is be VBZ 19613 1348 5 put put VBN 19613 1348 6 out out IN 19613 1348 7 of of IN 19613 1348 8 court court NN 19613 1348 9 , , , 19613 1348 10 as as IN 19613 1348 11 the the DT 19613 1348 12 second second JJ 19613 1348 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1348 14 of of IN 19613 1348 15 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1348 16 is be VBZ 19613 1348 17 quite quite PDT 19613 1348 18 a a DT 19613 1348 19 late late JJ 19613 1348 20 writing writing NN 19613 1348 21 . . . 19613 1349 1 The the DT 19613 1349 2 second second JJ 19613 1349 3 is be VBZ 19613 1349 4 only only RB 19613 1349 5 known know VBN 19613 1349 6 from from IN 19613 1349 7 an an DT 19613 1349 8 unreliable unreliable JJ 19613 1349 9 Latin latin JJ 19613 1349 10 translation translation NN 19613 1349 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1349 12 see see VB 19613 1349 13 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 1349 14 on on IN 19613 1349 15 the the DT 19613 1349 16 passage passage NN 19613 1349 17 : : : 19613 1349 18 " " `` 19613 1349 19 verba verba NNP 19613 1349 20 ' ' '' 19613 1349 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1349 22 scripturis scripturis NN 19613 1349 23 ' ' POS 19613 1349 24 suspecta suspecta NNP 19613 1349 25 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1349 26 , , , 19613 1349 27 cum cum NNP 19613 1349 28 interpres interpre NNS 19613 1349 29 in in IN 19613 1349 30 c. c. NNP 19613 1349 31 II II NNP 19613 1349 32 . . . 19613 1350 1 3 3 LS 19613 1350 2 ex ex NNP 19613 1350 3 suis suis NNP 19613 1350 4 inseruerit inseruerit NNP 19613 1350 5 quod quod NN 19613 1350 6 dictum dictum JJ 19613 1350 7 est est IN 19613 1350 8 " " '' 19613 1350 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1350 10 , , , 19613 1350 11 and and CC 19613 1350 12 even even RB 19613 1350 13 if if IN 19613 1350 14 the the DT 19613 1350 15 latter latter JJ 19613 1350 16 were be VBD 19613 1350 17 faithful faithful JJ 19613 1350 18 here here RB 19613 1350 19 , , , 19613 1350 20 the the DT 19613 1350 21 quotation quotation NN 19613 1350 22 from from IN 19613 1350 23 the the DT 19613 1350 24 Psalms Psalms NNPS 19613 1350 25 prefixed prefix VBN 19613 1350 26 to to IN 19613 1350 27 the the DT 19613 1350 28 quotation quotation NN 19613 1350 29 from from IN 19613 1350 30 the the DT 19613 1350 31 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1350 32 to to IN 19613 1350 33 the the DT 19613 1350 34 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 19613 1350 35 prevents prevent VBZ 19613 1350 36 us -PRON- PRP 19613 1350 37 from from IN 19613 1350 38 treating treat VBG 19613 1350 39 the the DT 19613 1350 40 passage passage NN 19613 1350 41 as as IN 19613 1350 42 certain certain JJ 19613 1350 43 evidence evidence NN 19613 1350 44 . . . 19613 1351 1 As as IN 19613 1351 2 to to IN 19613 1351 3 the the DT 19613 1351 4 third third JJ 19613 1351 5 passage passage NN 19613 1351 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1351 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1351 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1351 9 : : : 19613 1351 10 mêpote mêpote NN 19613 1351 11 , , , 19613 1351 12 hôs hôs NNP 19613 1351 13 gegraptai gegraptai NNP 19613 1351 14 , , , 19613 1351 15 polloi polloi NNP 19613 1351 16 klêtoi klêtoi NNP 19613 1351 17 , , , 19613 1351 18 oligoi oligoi NNP 19613 1351 19 de de IN 19613 1351 20 eklektoi eklektoi NNP 19613 1351 21 heurethômen heurethômen NNP 19613 1351 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1351 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1351 24 , , , 19613 1351 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1351 26 should should MD 19613 1351 27 be be VB 19613 1351 28 noted note VBN 19613 1351 29 that that IN 19613 1351 30 the the DT 19613 1351 31 author author NN 19613 1351 32 of of IN 19613 1351 33 the the DT 19613 1351 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1351 35 of of IN 19613 1351 36 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1351 37 , , , 19613 1351 38 although although IN 19613 1351 39 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1351 40 makes make VBZ 19613 1351 41 abundant abundant JJ 19613 1351 42 use use NN 19613 1351 43 of of IN 19613 1351 44 the the DT 19613 1351 45 evangelic evangelic JJ 19613 1351 46 tradition tradition NN 19613 1351 47 , , , 19613 1351 48 has have VBZ 19613 1351 49 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 1351 50 else else RB 19613 1351 51 described describe VBN 19613 1351 52 evangelic evangelic JJ 19613 1351 53 writings writing NNS 19613 1351 54 as as IN 19613 1351 55 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1351 56 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1351 57 : : : 19613 1351 58 graphê graphê NN 19613 1351 59 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1351 60 , , , 19613 1351 61 and and CC 19613 1351 62 must must MD 19613 1351 63 have have VB 19613 1351 64 drawn draw VBN 19613 1351 65 from from IN 19613 1351 66 more more JJR 19613 1351 67 sources source NNS 19613 1351 68 than than IN 19613 1351 69 the the DT 19613 1351 70 canonic canonic JJ 19613 1351 71 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1351 72 . . . 19613 1352 1 Here here RB 19613 1352 2 , , , 19613 1352 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 1352 4 , , , 19613 1352 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1352 6 have have VBP 19613 1352 7 an an DT 19613 1352 8 enigma enigma NN 19613 1352 9 which which WDT 19613 1352 10 may may MD 19613 1352 11 be be VB 19613 1352 12 solved solve VBN 19613 1352 13 in in IN 19613 1352 14 a a DT 19613 1352 15 variety variety NN 19613 1352 16 of of IN 19613 1352 17 ways way NNS 19613 1352 18 . . . 19613 1353 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1353 2 seems seem VBZ 19613 1353 3 worth worth JJ 19613 1353 4 noting note VBG 19613 1353 5 that that IN 19613 1353 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1353 7 is be VBZ 19613 1353 8 a a DT 19613 1353 9 saying saying NN 19613 1353 10 of of IN 19613 1353 11 the the DT 19613 1353 12 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1353 13 which which WDT 19613 1353 14 is be VBZ 19613 1353 15 here here RB 19613 1353 16 in in IN 19613 1353 17 question question NN 19613 1353 18 . . . 19613 1354 1 But but CC 19613 1354 2 from from IN 19613 1354 3 the the DT 19613 1354 4 very very RB 19613 1354 5 beginning beginning NN 19613 1354 6 words word NNS 19613 1354 7 of of IN 19613 1354 8 the the DT 19613 1354 9 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1354 10 were be VBD 19613 1354 11 equally equally RB 19613 1354 12 reverenced reverence VBN 19613 1354 13 with with IN 19613 1354 14 the the DT 19613 1354 15 Old Old NNP 19613 1354 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1354 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1354 18 see see VB 19613 1354 19 the the DT 19613 1354 20 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1354 21 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1354 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1354 23 . . . 19613 1355 1 This this DT 19613 1355 2 may may MD 19613 1355 3 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1355 4 explain explain VB 19613 1355 5 how how WRB 19613 1355 6 the the DT 19613 1355 7 author author NN 19613 1355 8 -- -- : 19613 1355 9 like like IN 19613 1355 10 2 2 CD 19613 1355 11 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1355 12 . . . 19613 1356 1 II ii CD 19613 1356 2 . . . 19613 1357 1 4 4 LS 19613 1357 2 : : : 19613 1357 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1357 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1357 5 : : : 19613 1357 6 hetera hetera NNP 19613 1357 7 de de NNP 19613 1357 8 graphê graphê NNP 19613 1357 9 legei legei NNP 19613 1357 10 hoti hoti NNP 19613 1357 11 ouk ouk NNP 19613 1357 12 êlthon êlthon NNP 19613 1357 13 kalesai kalesai NNP 19613 1357 14 dikaious dikaious NNP 19613 1357 15 alla alla NNP 19613 1357 16 hamartôlous]--has hamartôlous]--has NNP 19613 1357 17 introduced introduce VBD 19613 1357 18 a a DT 19613 1357 19 saying saying NN 19613 1357 20 of of IN 19613 1357 21 this this DT 19613 1357 22 kind kind NN 19613 1357 23 with with IN 19613 1357 24 the the DT 19613 1357 25 same same JJ 19613 1357 26 formula formula NN 19613 1357 27 as as IN 19613 1357 28 was be VBD 19613 1357 29 used use VBN 19613 1357 30 in in IN 19613 1357 31 introducing introduce VBG 19613 1357 32 Old Old NNP 19613 1357 33 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1357 34 quotations quotation NNS 19613 1357 35 . . . 19613 1358 1 Passages passage NNS 19613 1358 2 , , , 19613 1358 3 such such JJ 19613 1358 4 as as IN 19613 1358 5 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1358 6 . . . 19613 1359 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 1359 2 . . . 19613 1360 1 4 4 LS 19613 1360 2 : : : 19613 1360 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1360 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1360 5 : : : 19613 1360 6 legei legei NNP 19613 1360 7 ho ho NNP 19613 1360 8 theos theos NNP 19613 1360 9 : : : 19613 1360 10 ou ou NNP 19613 1360 11 charis charis NNP 19613 1360 12 humin humin NNP 19613 1360 13 ei ei NNP 19613 1360 14 agapate agapate NNP 19613 1360 15 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 1360 16 . . . 19613 1360 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1361 1 would would MD 19613 1361 2 mark mark VB 19613 1361 3 the the DT 19613 1361 4 transition transition NN 19613 1361 5 to to IN 19613 1361 6 this this DT 19613 1361 7 mode mode NN 19613 1361 8 of of IN 19613 1361 9 expression expression NN 19613 1361 10 . . . 19613 1362 1 The the DT 19613 1362 2 correctness correctness NN 19613 1362 3 of of IN 19613 1362 4 this this DT 19613 1362 5 explanation explanation NN 19613 1362 6 is be VBZ 19613 1362 7 confirmed confirm VBN 19613 1362 8 by by IN 19613 1362 9 observation observation NN 19613 1362 10 of of IN 19613 1362 11 the the DT 19613 1362 12 fact fact NN 19613 1362 13 that that IN 19613 1362 14 the the DT 19613 1362 15 same same JJ 19613 1362 16 formula formula NN 19613 1362 17 as as IN 19613 1362 18 was be VBD 19613 1362 19 employed employ VBN 19613 1362 20 in in IN 19613 1362 21 the the DT 19613 1362 22 case case NN 19613 1362 23 of of IN 19613 1362 24 the the DT 19613 1362 25 Old Old NNP 19613 1362 26 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1362 27 was be VBD 19613 1362 28 used use VBN 19613 1362 29 in in IN 19613 1362 30 making make VBG 19613 1362 31 quotations quotation NNS 19613 1362 32 from from IN 19613 1362 33 early early JJ 19613 1362 34 Christian christian JJ 19613 1362 35 apocalypses apocalypse NNS 19613 1362 36 , , , 19613 1362 37 or or CC 19613 1362 38 utterances utterance NNS 19613 1362 39 of of IN 19613 1362 40 early early JJ 19613 1362 41 Christian christian JJ 19613 1362 42 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1362 43 in in IN 19613 1362 44 the the DT 19613 1362 45 earliest early JJS 19613 1362 46 period period NN 19613 1362 47 . . . 19613 1363 1 Thus thus RB 19613 1363 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1363 3 already already RB 19613 1363 4 read read VBD 19613 1363 5 in in IN 19613 1363 6 Ephesians Ephesians NNP 19613 1363 7 V. V. NNP 19613 1363 8 14 14 CD 19613 1363 9 : : : 19613 1363 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1363 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1363 12 : : : 19613 1363 13 dio dio NNP 19613 1363 14 legei legei NNP 19613 1363 15 : : : 19613 1363 16 egeire egeire VB 19613 1363 17 ho ho NNP 19613 1363 18 katheudôn katheudôn NNP 19613 1363 19 kai kai NNP 19613 1363 20 anasta anasta NNP 19613 1363 21 ek ek NNP 19613 1363 22 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1363 23 nekrôn nekrôn NNP 19613 1363 24 kai kai NNP 19613 1363 25 epiphausei epiphausei NNP 19613 1363 26 soi soi NNP 19613 1363 27 ho ho NNP 19613 1363 28 Christos Christos NNP 19613 1363 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1363 30 . . . 19613 1364 1 That that IN 19613 1364 2 , , , 19613 1364 3 certainly certainly RB 19613 1364 4 , , , 19613 1364 5 is be VBZ 19613 1364 6 a a DT 19613 1364 7 saying saying NN 19613 1364 8 of of IN 19613 1364 9 a a DT 19613 1364 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 1364 11 prophet prophet NN 19613 1364 12 , , , 19613 1364 13 and and CC 19613 1364 14 yet yet RB 19613 1364 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1364 16 is be VBZ 19613 1364 17 introduced introduce VBN 19613 1364 18 with with IN 19613 1364 19 the the DT 19613 1364 20 usual usual JJ 19613 1364 21 " " '' 19613 1364 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1364 23 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1364 24 : : : 19613 1364 25 legei legei LS 19613 1364 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1364 27 " " '' 19613 1364 28 . . . 19613 1365 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1365 2 also also RB 19613 1365 3 find find VBP 19613 1365 4 a a DT 19613 1365 5 saying saying NN 19613 1365 6 of of IN 19613 1365 7 a a DT 19613 1365 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 1365 9 prophet prophet NN 19613 1365 10 in in IN 19613 1365 11 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1365 12 . . . 19613 1366 1 XXIII XXIII NNP 19613 1366 2 . . . 19613 1367 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1367 2 the the DT 19613 1367 3 saying saying NN 19613 1367 4 is be VBZ 19613 1367 5 more more RBR 19613 1367 6 complete complete JJ 19613 1367 7 in in IN 19613 1367 8 2 2 CD 19613 1367 9 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1367 10 . . . 19613 1368 1 XI XI NNP 19613 1368 2 . . . 19613 1368 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1369 1 introduced introduce VBN 19613 1369 2 with with IN 19613 1369 3 the the DT 19613 1369 4 words word NNS 19613 1369 5 : : : 19613 1369 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1369 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1369 8 : : : 19613 1369 9 hê hê VB 19613 1369 10 graphê graphê NNP 19613 1369 11 hautê hautê NN 19613 1369 12 , , , 19613 1369 13 hopou hopou NNP 19613 1369 14 legei legei NNP 19613 1369 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1369 16 . . . 19613 1370 1 These these DT 19613 1370 2 examples example NNS 19613 1370 3 may may MD 19613 1370 4 be be VB 19613 1370 5 multiplied multiply VBN 19613 1370 6 still still RB 19613 1370 7 further further RB 19613 1370 8 . . . 19613 1371 1 From from IN 19613 1371 2 all all PDT 19613 1371 3 this this DT 19613 1371 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1371 5 may may MD 19613 1371 6 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1371 7 assume assume VB 19613 1371 8 that that IN 19613 1371 9 the the DT 19613 1371 10 trite trite NNP 19613 1371 11 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 1371 12 of of IN 19613 1371 13 quotation quotation NN 19613 1371 14 " " '' 19613 1371 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1371 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1371 17 : : : 19613 1371 18 graphê graphê NN 19613 1371 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1371 20 , , , 19613 1371 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1371 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1371 23 : : : 19613 1371 24 gegraptai gegraptai NN 19613 1371 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1371 26 , , , 19613 1371 27 " " '' 19613 1371 28 etc etc FW 19613 1371 29 . . . 19613 1371 30 , , , 19613 1371 31 were be VBD 19613 1371 32 applied apply VBN 19613 1371 33 wherever wherever WRB 19613 1371 34 reference reference NN 19613 1371 35 was be VBD 19613 1371 36 made make VBN 19613 1371 37 to to IN 19613 1371 38 sayings saying NNS 19613 1371 39 of of IN 19613 1371 40 the the DT 19613 1371 41 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1371 42 and and CC 19613 1371 43 of of IN 19613 1371 44 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1371 45 that that WDT 19613 1371 46 were be VBD 19613 1371 47 fixed fix VBN 19613 1371 48 in in IN 19613 1371 49 writings writing NNS 19613 1371 50 , , , 19613 1371 51 even even RB 19613 1371 52 when when WRB 19613 1371 53 the the DT 19613 1371 54 documents document NNS 19613 1371 55 in in IN 19613 1371 56 question question NN 19613 1371 57 had have VBD 19613 1371 58 not not RB 19613 1371 59 yet yet RB 19613 1371 60 as as IN 19613 1371 61 a a DT 19613 1371 62 whole whole NN 19613 1371 63 obtained obtain VBN 19613 1371 64 canonical canonical JJ 19613 1371 65 authority authority NN 19613 1371 66 . . . 19613 1372 1 Finally finally RB 19613 1372 2 , , , 19613 1372 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1372 4 must must MD 19613 1372 5 also also RB 19613 1372 6 draw draw VB 19613 1372 7 attention attention NN 19613 1372 8 to to IN 19613 1372 9 the the DT 19613 1372 10 following:--The following:--the NN 19613 1372 11 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1372 12 of of IN 19613 1372 13 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1372 14 belongs belong VBZ 19613 1372 15 to to IN 19613 1372 16 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 1372 17 ; ; : 19613 1372 18 and and CC 19613 1372 19 there there EX 19613 1372 20 probably probably RB 19613 1372 21 , , , 19613 1372 22 contrary contrary JJ 19613 1372 23 to to IN 19613 1372 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1372 25 former former JJ 19613 1372 26 opinion opinion NN 19613 1372 27 , , , 19613 1372 28 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1372 29 must must MD 19613 1372 30 also also RB 19613 1372 31 look look VB 19613 1372 32 for for IN 19613 1372 33 the the DT 19613 1372 34 author author NN 19613 1372 35 of of IN 19613 1372 36 the the DT 19613 1372 37 second second JJ 19613 1372 38 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1372 39 of of IN 19613 1372 40 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1372 41 . . . 19613 1373 1 There there EX 19613 1373 2 is be VBZ 19613 1373 3 much much JJ 19613 1373 4 to to TO 19613 1373 5 favour favour VB 19613 1373 6 the the DT 19613 1373 7 view view NN 19613 1373 8 that that IN 19613 1373 9 in in IN 19613 1373 10 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 1373 11 _ _ NNP 19613 1373 12 Christian Christian NNP 19613 1373 13 _ _ NNP 19613 1373 14 writings writing NNS 19613 1373 15 were be VBD 19613 1373 16 treated treat VBN 19613 1373 17 as as IN 19613 1373 18 sacred sacred JJ 19613 1373 19 texts text NNS 19613 1373 20 , , , 19613 1373 21 without without IN 19613 1373 22 being be VBG 19613 1373 23 united unite VBN 19613 1373 24 into into IN 19613 1373 25 a a DT 19613 1373 26 collection collection NN 19613 1373 27 of of IN 19613 1373 28 equal equal JJ 19613 1373 29 rank rank NN 19613 1373 30 with with IN 19613 1373 31 the the DT 19613 1373 32 Old Old NNP 19613 1373 33 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1373 34 . . . 19613 1374 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1374 2 See see VB 19613 1374 3 below below RB 19613 1374 4 on on IN 19613 1374 5 this this DT 19613 1374 6 point point NN 19613 1374 7 . . . 19613 1374 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1374 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1375 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1375 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1375 3 73 73 CD 19613 1375 4 : : : 19613 1375 5 See see VB 19613 1375 6 on on IN 19613 1375 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 1375 8 Bousset Bousset NNP 19613 1375 9 . . . 19613 1376 1 Die die VB 19613 1376 2 Evv.-Citate Evv.-Citate NNP 19613 1376 3 Justins Justins NNPS 19613 1376 4 . . . 19613 1377 1 Gott Gott NNP 19613 1377 2 . . NNP 19613 1377 3 , , , 19613 1377 4 1891 1891 CD 19613 1377 5 . . . 19613 1378 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1378 2 may may MD 19613 1378 3 also also RB 19613 1378 4 infer infer VB 19613 1378 5 from from IN 19613 1378 6 the the DT 19613 1378 7 expression expression NN 19613 1378 8 of of IN 19613 1378 9 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 1378 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1378 11 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1378 12 . . NNP 19613 1378 13 , , , 19613 1378 14 H. H. NNP 19613 1378 15 E. E. NNP 19613 1378 16 IV IV NNP 19613 1378 17 . . . 19613 1379 1 22 22 CD 19613 1379 2 . . . 19613 1380 1 3 3 LS 19613 1380 2 ; ; : 19613 1380 3 Stephanus Stephanus NNP 19613 1380 4 Gobarus Gobarus NNP 19613 1380 5 in in IN 19613 1380 6 Photius Photius NNP 19613 1380 7 , , , 19613 1380 8 Bibl Bibl NNP 19613 1380 9 . . . 19613 1381 1 232 232 CD 19613 1381 2 . . . 19613 1381 3 p. p. NN 19613 1381 4 288 288 CD 19613 1381 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1381 6 that that IN 19613 1381 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1381 8 was be VBD 19613 1381 9 not not RB 19613 1381 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 1381 11 writings writing NNS 19613 1381 12 , , , 19613 1381 13 but but CC 19613 1381 14 the the DT 19613 1381 15 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1381 16 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1381 17 , , , 19613 1381 18 who who WP 19613 1381 19 was be VBD 19613 1381 20 placed place VBN 19613 1381 21 on on IN 19613 1381 22 an an DT 19613 1381 23 equality equality NN 19613 1381 24 with with IN 19613 1381 25 Law Law NNP 19613 1381 26 and and CC 19613 1381 27 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 1381 28 . . . 19613 1382 1 Very very RB 19613 1382 2 instructive instructive JJ 19613 1382 3 is be VBZ 19613 1382 4 the the DT 19613 1382 5 formula formula NN 19613 1382 6 : : : 19613 1382 7 " " `` 19613 1382 8 Libri Libri NNPS 19613 1382 9 et et NNP 19613 1382 10 epistolæ epistolæ JJ 19613 1382 11 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1382 12 viri viri NN 19613 1382 13 iusti iusti NN 19613 1382 14 " " '' 19613 1382 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1382 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1382 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1382 18 : : : 19613 1382 19 hai hai NNP 19613 1382 20 kath kath NNP 19613 1382 21 ' ' POS 19613 1382 22 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 1382 23 bibloi bibloi NNP 19613 1382 24 kai kai NNP 19613 1382 25 hai hai NNP 19613 1382 26 prosepitoutois prosepitoutois NNP 19613 1382 27 epistolai epistolai NNP 19613 1382 28 Paulou Paulou NNP 19613 1382 29 tou tou NNP 19613 1382 30 hosiou hosiou NNP 19613 1382 31 andros andros NNP 19613 1382 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1382 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1382 34 , , , 19613 1382 35 which which WDT 19613 1382 36 is be VBZ 19613 1382 37 found find VBN 19613 1382 38 in in IN 19613 1382 39 the the DT 19613 1382 40 Acta Acta NNP 19613 1382 41 Mart Mart NNP 19613 1382 42 . . . 19613 1383 1 Scillit Scillit VBN 19613 1383 2 . . . 19613 1384 1 anno anno NNP 19613 1384 2 180 180 CD 19613 1384 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1384 4 ed ed NN 19613 1384 5 . . . 19613 1385 1 Robinson Robinson NNP 19613 1385 2 , , , 19613 1385 3 Texts Texts NNP 19613 1385 4 and and CC 19613 1385 5 Studies Studies NNPS 19613 1385 6 , , , 19613 1385 7 1891 1891 CD 19613 1385 8 , , , 19613 1385 9 I. i. NN 19613 1386 1 2 2 CD 19613 1386 2 , , , 19613 1386 3 p. p. NN 19613 1386 4 114 114 CD 19613 1386 5 f. f. NNP 19613 1386 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1386 7 , , , 19613 1386 8 and and CC 19613 1386 9 tempts tempt VBZ 19613 1386 10 us -PRON- PRP 19613 1386 11 to to TO 19613 1386 12 make make VB 19613 1386 13 certain certain JJ 19613 1386 14 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 1386 15 . . . 19613 1387 1 In in IN 19613 1387 2 the the DT 19613 1387 3 later later JJ 19613 1387 4 recensions recension NNS 19613 1387 5 of of IN 19613 1387 6 the the DT 19613 1387 7 Acta Acta NNP 19613 1387 8 the the DT 19613 1387 9 passage passage NN 19613 1387 10 , , , 19613 1387 11 characteristically characteristically RB 19613 1387 12 enough enough RB 19613 1387 13 , , , 19613 1387 14 is be VBZ 19613 1387 15 worded word VBN 19613 1387 16 : : : 19613 1387 17 " " `` 19613 1387 18 Libri Libri NNPS 19613 1387 19 evangeliorum evangeliorum NNP 19613 1387 20 et et NN 19613 1387 21 epistolæ epistolæ NNP 19613 1387 22 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1387 23 viri viri NNP 19613 1387 24 sanctissimi sanctissimi NNP 19613 1387 25 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1387 26 " " '' 19613 1387 27 or or CC 19613 1387 28 " " `` 19613 1387 29 Quattuor Quattuor NNP 19613 1387 30 evv evv RB 19613 1387 31 . . . 19613 1388 1 dom dom NNP 19613 1388 2 . . . 19613 1389 1 nostri nostri NNP 19613 1389 2 J. J. NNP 19613 1389 3 Chr Chr NNP 19613 1389 4 . . . 19613 1390 1 et et FW 19613 1390 2 epp epp NNP 19613 1390 3 . . . 19613 1391 1 S. S. NNP 19613 1391 2 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1391 3 ap ap NNP 19613 1391 4 . . . 19613 1392 1 et et FW 19613 1392 2 omnis omnis NNP 19613 1392 3 divinitus divinitus NNP 19613 1392 4 inspirata inspirata NNP 19613 1392 5 scriptura scriptura NNP 19613 1392 6 . . . 19613 1392 7 " " '' 19613 1392 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1393 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1393 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1393 3 74 74 CD 19613 1393 4 : : : 19613 1393 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1393 6 is be VBZ 19613 1393 7 worthy worthy JJ 19613 1393 8 of of IN 19613 1393 9 note note NN 19613 1393 10 that that IN 19613 1393 11 the the DT 19613 1393 12 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 1393 13 also also RB 19613 1393 14 , , , 19613 1393 15 though though IN 19613 1393 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1393 17 quote quote VBP 19613 1393 18 the the DT 19613 1393 19 words word NNS 19613 1393 20 of of IN 19613 1393 21 the the DT 19613 1393 22 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 1393 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1393 24 John John NNP 19613 1393 25 and and CC 19613 1393 26 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1393 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1393 28 as as IN 19613 1393 29 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 1393 30 , , , 19613 1393 31 place place VB 19613 1393 32 the the DT 19613 1393 33 utterances utterance NNS 19613 1393 34 of of IN 19613 1393 35 the the DT 19613 1393 36 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1393 37 on on IN 19613 1393 38 an an DT 19613 1393 39 unattainable unattainable JJ 19613 1393 40 height height NN 19613 1393 41 . . . 19613 1394 1 See see VB 19613 1394 2 in in IN 19613 1394 3 support support NN 19613 1394 4 of of IN 19613 1394 5 this this DT 19613 1394 6 the the DT 19613 1394 7 epistle epistle NN 19613 1394 8 of of IN 19613 1394 9 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 19613 1394 10 to to IN 19613 1394 11 Flora Flora NNP 19613 1394 12 . . . 19613 1394 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1395 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1395 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1395 3 75 75 CD 19613 1395 4 : : : 19613 1395 5 Rev. Rev. NNP 19613 1396 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1397 1 3 3 LS 19613 1397 2 ; ; : 19613 1397 3 Herm Herm NNP 19613 1397 4 . . . 19613 1398 1 Vis Vis NNP 19613 1398 2 . . . 19613 1399 1 II ii CD 19613 1399 2 . . . 19613 1400 1 4 4 LS 19613 1400 2 ; ; : 19613 1400 3 Dionys dionys NN 19613 1400 4 . . . 19613 1401 1 Cor Cor NNP 19613 1401 2 . . . 19613 1402 1 in in IN 19613 1402 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1402 3 . . NNP 19613 1402 4 , , , 19613 1402 5 IV IV NNP 19613 1402 6 . . . 19613 1403 1 23 23 CD 19613 1403 2 . . . 19613 1404 1 11 11 CD 19613 1404 2 . . . 19613 1404 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1405 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1405 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1405 3 76 76 CD 19613 1405 4 : : : 19613 1405 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1405 6 , , , 19613 1405 7 this this DT 19613 1405 8 Christian Christian NNP 19613 1405 9 of of IN 19613 1405 10 the the DT 19613 1405 11 primitive primitive JJ 19613 1405 12 type type NN 19613 1405 13 , , , 19613 1405 14 still still RB 19613 1405 15 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 1405 16 the the DT 19613 1405 17 old old JJ 19613 1405 18 conception conception NN 19613 1405 19 of of IN 19613 1405 20 things thing NNS 19613 1405 21 in in IN 19613 1405 22 one one CD 19613 1405 23 passage passage NN 19613 1405 24 where where WRB 19613 1405 25 , , , 19613 1405 26 reversing reverse VBG 19613 1405 27 2 2 CD 19613 1405 28 Tim Tim NNP 19613 1405 29 . . . 19613 1406 1 III iii CD 19613 1406 2 . . . 19613 1407 1 16 16 CD 19613 1407 2 , , , 19613 1407 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1407 4 says say VBZ 19613 1407 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1407 6 de de FW 19613 1407 7 cultu cultu NNP 19613 1407 8 fem fem NNP 19613 1407 9 . . . 19613 1408 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1409 1 3 3 LS 19613 1409 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1409 3 " " `` 19613 1409 4 Legimus Legimus NNP 19613 1409 5 omnem omnem NN 19613 1409 6 scripturam scripturam NN 19613 1409 7 ædificationi ædificationi NNP 19613 1409 8 habilem habilem NNP 19613 1409 9 divinitus divinitus NNP 19613 1409 10 inspirari inspirari NNP 19613 1409 11 . . . 19613 1409 12 " " '' 19613 1409 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1410 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1410 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1410 3 77 77 CD 19613 1410 4 : : : 19613 1410 5 The the DT 19613 1410 6 history history NN 19613 1410 7 of of IN 19613 1410 8 the the DT 19613 1410 9 collection collection NN 19613 1410 10 of of IN 19613 1410 11 the the DT 19613 1410 12 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1410 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1410 14 may may MD 19613 1410 15 be be VB 19613 1410 16 traced trace VBN 19613 1410 17 back back RB 19613 1410 18 to to IN 19613 1410 19 the the DT 19613 1410 20 first first JJ 19613 1410 21 century century NN 19613 1410 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1410 23 1 1 CD 19613 1410 24 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1410 25 . . . 19613 1411 1 XLVII XLVII NNP 19613 1411 2 . . . 19613 1412 1 and and CC 19613 1412 2 like like IN 19613 1412 3 passages passage NNS 19613 1412 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1412 5 . . . 19613 1413 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1413 2 follows follow VBZ 19613 1413 3 from from IN 19613 1413 4 the the DT 19613 1413 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1413 6 of of IN 19613 1413 7 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 1413 8 that that IN 19613 1413 9 this this DT 19613 1413 10 native native NN 19613 1413 11 of of IN 19613 1413 12 Asia Asia NNP 19613 1413 13 Minor Minor NNP 19613 1413 14 had have VBD 19613 1413 15 in in IN 19613 1413 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1413 17 hands hand NNS 19613 1413 18 all all PDT 19613 1413 19 the the DT 19613 1413 20 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1413 21 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1413 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1413 23 quotations quotation NNS 19613 1413 24 are be VBP 19613 1413 25 made make VBN 19613 1413 26 from from IN 19613 1413 27 nine nine CD 19613 1413 28 of of IN 19613 1413 29 the the DT 19613 1413 30 latter latter JJ 19613 1413 31 ; ; : 19613 1413 32 these these DT 19613 1413 33 nine nine CD 19613 1413 34 imply imply VBP 19613 1413 35 the the DT 19613 1413 36 four four CD 19613 1413 37 that that WDT 19613 1413 38 are be VBP 19613 1413 39 wanting want VBG 19613 1413 40 , , , 19613 1413 41 yet yet CC 19613 1413 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1413 43 must must MD 19613 1413 44 remain remain VB 19613 1413 45 an an DT 19613 1413 46 open open JJ 19613 1413 47 question question NN 19613 1413 48 whether whether IN 19613 1413 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1413 50 did do VBD 19613 1413 51 not not RB 19613 1413 52 yet yet RB 19613 1413 53 possess possess VB 19613 1413 54 the the DT 19613 1413 55 Pastoral Pastoral NNP 19613 1413 56 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1413 57 in in IN 19613 1413 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1413 59 present present JJ 19613 1413 60 form form NN 19613 1413 61 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1413 62 , , , 19613 1413 63 also also RB 19613 1413 64 1 1 CD 19613 1413 65 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1413 66 , , , 19613 1413 67 1 1 CD 19613 1413 68 John John NNP 19613 1413 69 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1413 70 though though IN 19613 1413 71 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1413 72 has have VBZ 19613 1413 73 not not RB 19613 1413 74 named name VBN 19613 1413 75 the the DT 19613 1413 76 authors author NNS 19613 1413 77 of of IN 19613 1413 78 these these DT 19613 1413 79 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1413 80 , , , 19613 1413 81 the the DT 19613 1413 82 first first JJ 19613 1413 83 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1413 84 of of IN 19613 1413 85 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1413 86 and and CC 19613 1413 87 the the DT 19613 1413 88 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1413 89 . . . 19613 1414 1 The the DT 19613 1414 2 extent extent NN 19613 1414 3 of of IN 19613 1414 4 the the DT 19613 1414 5 writings writing NNS 19613 1414 6 read read VBN 19613 1414 7 in in IN 19613 1414 8 churches church NNS 19613 1414 9 which which WDT 19613 1414 10 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 1414 11 is be VBZ 19613 1414 12 thus thus RB 19613 1414 13 seen see VBN 19613 1414 14 to to TO 19613 1414 15 have have VB 19613 1414 16 had have VBN 19613 1414 17 approaches approach NNS 19613 1414 18 pretty pretty RB 19613 1414 19 nearly nearly RB 19613 1414 20 that that DT 19613 1414 21 of of IN 19613 1414 22 the the DT 19613 1414 23 later later RB 19613 1414 24 recognised recognise VBN 19613 1414 25 canon canon NNP 19613 1414 26 . . . 19613 1415 1 Compare compare VB 19613 1415 2 , , , 19613 1415 3 however however RB 19613 1415 4 , , , 19613 1415 5 the the DT 19613 1415 6 way way NN 19613 1415 7 in in IN 19613 1415 8 which which WDT 19613 1415 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1415 10 assumes assume VBZ 19613 1415 11 sayings saying NNS 19613 1415 12 from from IN 19613 1415 13 those those DT 19613 1415 14 writings writing NNS 19613 1415 15 to to TO 19613 1415 16 be be VB 19613 1415 17 well well RB 19613 1415 18 known know VBN 19613 1415 19 by by IN 19613 1415 20 introducing introduce VBG 19613 1415 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 1415 22 with with IN 19613 1415 23 " " `` 19613 1415 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1415 25 Greek greek JJ 19613 1415 26 : : : 19613 1415 27 eidotes eidote NNS 19613 1415 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1415 29 " " `` 19613 1415 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1415 31 I. i. NN 19613 1416 1 3 3 LS 19613 1416 2 ; ; : 19613 1416 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1416 4 . . . 19613 1417 1 1 1 LS 19613 1417 2 ; ; : 19613 1417 3 V. V. NNP 19613 1417 4 1 1 CD 19613 1417 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1417 6 . . . 19613 1418 1 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 1418 2 likewise likewise RB 19613 1418 3 shows show VBZ 19613 1418 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1418 5 to to TO 19613 1418 6 be be VB 19613 1418 7 familiar familiar JJ 19613 1418 8 with with IN 19613 1418 9 the the DT 19613 1418 10 writings writing NNS 19613 1418 11 which which WDT 19613 1418 12 were be VBD 19613 1418 13 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 1418 14 united united JJ 19613 1418 15 to to TO 19613 1418 16 form form VB 19613 1418 17 the the DT 19613 1418 18 New New NNP 19613 1418 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1418 20 . . . 19613 1419 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1419 2 see see VBP 19613 1419 3 from from IN 19613 1419 4 the the DT 19613 1419 5 works work NNS 19613 1419 6 of of IN 19613 1419 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1419 8 , , , 19613 1419 9 that that IN 19613 1419 10 , , , 19613 1419 11 at at IN 19613 1419 12 the the DT 19613 1419 13 end end NN 19613 1419 14 of of IN 19613 1419 15 the the DT 19613 1419 16 second second JJ 19613 1419 17 century century NN 19613 1419 18 , , , 19613 1419 19 a a DT 19613 1419 20 great great JJ 19613 1419 21 mass mass NN 19613 1419 22 of of IN 19613 1419 23 Christian christian JJ 19613 1419 24 writings writing NNS 19613 1419 25 were be VBD 19613 1419 26 collected collect VBN 19613 1419 27 in in IN 19613 1419 28 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1419 29 and and CC 19613 1419 30 were be VBD 19613 1419 31 used use VBN 19613 1419 32 and and CC 19613 1419 33 honoured honour VBN 19613 1419 34 . . . 19613 1419 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1420 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1420 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1420 3 78 78 CD 19613 1420 4 : : : 19613 1420 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1420 6 should should MD 19613 1420 7 also also RB 19613 1420 8 be be VB 19613 1420 9 pointed point VBN 19613 1420 10 out out RP 19613 1420 11 that that IN 19613 1420 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 1420 13 most most RBS 19613 1420 14 probably probably RB 19613 1420 15 used use VBD 19613 1420 16 the the DT 19613 1420 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1420 18 of of IN 19613 1420 19 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1420 20 among among IN 19613 1420 21 the the DT 19613 1420 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1420 23 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1420 24 : : : 19613 1420 25 apomnêmoneumata apomnêmoneumata NN 19613 1420 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1420 27 ; ; : 19613 1420 28 see see VB 19613 1420 29 Texte Texte NNP 19613 1420 30 u. u. NNP 19613 1420 31 Unters Unters NNP 19613 1420 32 . . . 19613 1421 1 IX ix NN 19613 1421 2 . . . 19613 1422 1 2 2 LS 19613 1422 2 . . . 19613 1422 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1423 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1423 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1423 3 79 79 CD 19613 1423 4 : : : 19613 1423 5 See see VB 19613 1423 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1423 7 article article NN 19613 1423 8 in in IN 19613 1423 9 the the DT 19613 1423 10 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 19613 1423 11 . . . 19613 1424 1 f. f. NNP 19613 1424 2 K. K. NNP 19613 1424 3 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1424 4 . . . 19613 1425 1 Vol Vol NNP 19613 1425 2 . . . 19613 1426 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1426 2 . . . 19613 1427 1 p. p. NN 19613 1427 2 471 471 CD 19613 1427 3 ff ff NNP 19613 1427 4 . . . 19613 1428 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 1428 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1428 3 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 1428 4 's 's POS 19613 1428 5 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 19613 1428 6 , , , 19613 1428 7 1881 1881 CD 19613 1428 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1428 9 takes take VBZ 19613 1428 10 a a DT 19613 1428 11 different different JJ 19613 1428 12 view view NN 19613 1428 13 . . . 19613 1428 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1429 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1429 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1429 3 80 80 CD 19613 1429 4 : : : 19613 1429 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 1429 6 also also RB 19613 1429 7 used use VBD 19613 1429 8 the the DT 19613 1429 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1429 10 of of IN 19613 1429 11 John John NNP 19613 1429 12 , , , 19613 1429 13 but but CC 19613 1429 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1429 15 is be VBZ 19613 1429 16 a a DT 19613 1429 17 disputed disputed JJ 19613 1429 18 matter matter NN 19613 1429 19 whether whether IN 19613 1429 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1429 21 regarded regard VBD 19613 1429 22 and and CC 19613 1429 23 used use VBD 19613 1429 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1429 25 like like IN 19613 1429 26 the the DT 19613 1429 27 other other JJ 19613 1429 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1429 29 . . . 19613 1429 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1430 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1430 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1430 3 81 81 CD 19613 1430 4 : : : 19613 1430 5 The the DT 19613 1430 6 Sabellians Sabellians NNPS 19613 1430 7 still still RB 19613 1430 8 used use VBD 19613 1430 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1430 10 in in IN 19613 1430 11 the the DT 19613 1430 12 third third JJ 19613 1430 13 century century NN 19613 1430 14 , , , 19613 1430 15 which which WDT 19613 1430 16 is be VBZ 19613 1430 17 a a DT 19613 1430 18 proof proof NN 19613 1430 19 of of IN 19613 1430 20 the the DT 19613 1430 21 great great JJ 19613 1430 22 authority authority NNP 19613 1430 23 possessed possess VBN 19613 1430 24 by by IN 19613 1430 25 this this DT 19613 1430 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1430 27 in in IN 19613 1430 28 Christian christian JJ 19613 1430 29 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 1430 30 . . . 19613 1431 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1431 2 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 1431 3 . . NNP 19613 1431 4 , , , 19613 1431 5 H. H. NNP 19613 1431 6 62 62 CD 19613 1431 7 . . . 19613 1432 1 2 2 LS 19613 1432 2 . . . 19613 1432 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1432 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1433 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1433 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1433 3 82 82 CD 19613 1433 4 : : : 19613 1433 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1433 6 . . . 19613 1434 1 H. H. NNP 19613 1434 2 E. E. NNP 19613 1434 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1434 4 . . . 19613 1435 1 29 29 CD 19613 1435 2 . . . 19613 1436 1 5 5 CD 19613 1436 2 . . . 19613 1436 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1437 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1437 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1437 3 83 83 CD 19613 1437 4 : : : 19613 1437 5 In in IN 19613 1437 6 many many JJ 19613 1437 7 regions region NNS 19613 1437 8 the the DT 19613 1437 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1437 10 canon canon NN 19613 1437 11 alone alone RB 19613 1437 12 appeared appear VBD 19613 1437 13 at at IN 19613 1437 14 first first RB 19613 1437 15 , , , 19613 1437 16 and and CC 19613 1437 17 in in IN 19613 1437 18 very very RB 19613 1437 19 many many JJ 19613 1437 20 others other NNS 19613 1437 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1437 22 long long RB 19613 1437 23 occupied occupy VBD 19613 1437 24 a a DT 19613 1437 25 more more RBR 19613 1437 26 prominent prominent JJ 19613 1437 27 place place NN 19613 1437 28 than than IN 19613 1437 29 the the DT 19613 1437 30 other other JJ 19613 1437 31 canonical canonical JJ 19613 1437 32 writings writing NNS 19613 1437 33 . . . 19613 1438 1 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 1438 2 of of IN 19613 1438 3 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1438 4 , , , 19613 1438 5 for for IN 19613 1438 6 instance instance NN 19613 1438 7 , , , 19613 1438 8 still still RB 19613 1438 9 calls call VBZ 19613 1438 10 God God NNP 19613 1438 11 the the DT 19613 1438 12 giver giver NN 19613 1438 13 of of IN 19613 1438 14 the the DT 19613 1438 15 Law Law NNP 19613 1438 16 , , , 19613 1438 17 the the DT 19613 1438 18 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 1438 19 , , , 19613 1438 20 and and CC 19613 1438 21 the the DT 19613 1438 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1438 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1438 24 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 19613 1438 25 , , , 19613 1438 26 I. i. NN 19613 1439 1 4 4 LS 19613 1439 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1439 3 . . . 19613 1439 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1440 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1440 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1440 3 84 84 CD 19613 1440 4 : : : 19613 1440 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1440 6 . . NNP 19613 1440 7 , , , 19613 1440 8 H. H. NNP 19613 1440 9 E. E. NNP 19613 1440 10 II II NNP 19613 1440 11 . . . 19613 1441 1 26 26 CD 19613 1441 2 . . . 19613 1442 1 13 13 CD 19613 1442 2 . . . 19613 1443 1 As as IN 19613 1443 2 Melito Melito NNP 19613 1443 3 speaks speak VBZ 19613 1443 4 here here RB 19613 1443 5 of of IN 19613 1443 6 the the DT 19613 1443 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1443 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1443 9 : : : 19613 1443 10 akribeia akribeia NNP 19613 1443 11 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1443 12 palaiôn palaiôn NNP 19613 1443 13 bibliôn bibliôn NNP 19613 1443 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1443 15 , , , 19613 1443 16 and and CC 19613 1443 17 of of IN 19613 1443 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1443 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1443 20 : : : 19613 1443 21 ta ta NNP 19613 1443 22 biblia biblia NNP 19613 1443 23 tês tês NNP 19613 1443 24 palaias palaias RB 19613 1443 25 diathêkês diathêkês NNP 19613 1443 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1443 27 , , , 19613 1443 28 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1443 29 may may MD 19613 1443 30 assume assume VB 19613 1443 31 that that IN 19613 1443 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1443 33 knows know VBZ 19613 1443 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1443 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1443 36 : : : 19613 1443 37 ta ta NNP 19613 1443 38 biblia biblia NNP 19613 1443 39 tês tês NNP 19613 1443 40 kainês kainês NNP 19613 1443 41 diathêkês diathêkês NNP 19613 1443 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1443 43 . . . 19613 1443 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1444 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1444 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1444 3 85 85 CD 19613 1444 4 : : : 19613 1444 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1444 6 may may MD 19613 1444 7 here here RB 19613 1444 8 leave leave VB 19613 1444 9 undiscussed undiscusse VBN 19613 1444 10 the the DT 19613 1444 11 hesitancy hesitancy NN 19613 1444 12 with with IN 19613 1444 13 regard regard NN 19613 1444 14 to to IN 19613 1444 15 the the DT 19613 1444 16 admissibility admissibility NN 19613 1444 17 of of IN 19613 1444 18 particular particular JJ 19613 1444 19 books book NNS 19613 1444 20 . . . 19613 1445 1 That that IN 19613 1445 2 the the DT 19613 1445 3 Pastoral Pastoral NNP 19613 1445 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1445 5 had have VBD 19613 1445 6 a a DT 19613 1445 7 fixed fix VBN 19613 1445 8 place place NN 19613 1445 9 in in IN 19613 1445 10 the the DT 19613 1445 11 canon canon NN 19613 1445 12 almost almost RB 19613 1445 13 from from IN 19613 1445 14 the the DT 19613 1445 15 very very RB 19613 1445 16 first first JJ 19613 1445 17 is be VBZ 19613 1445 18 of of IN 19613 1445 19 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1445 20 a a DT 19613 1445 21 proof proof NN 19613 1445 22 that that IN 19613 1445 23 the the DT 19613 1445 24 date date NN 19613 1445 25 of of IN 19613 1445 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1445 27 origin origin NN 19613 1445 28 can can MD 19613 1445 29 not not RB 19613 1445 30 be be VB 19613 1445 31 long long JJ 19613 1445 32 before before IN 19613 1445 33 180 180 CD 19613 1445 34 . . . 19613 1446 1 In in IN 19613 1446 2 connection connection NN 19613 1446 3 with with IN 19613 1446 4 this this DT 19613 1446 5 , , , 19613 1446 6 however however RB 19613 1446 7 , , , 19613 1446 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1446 9 is be VBZ 19613 1446 10 an an DT 19613 1446 11 important important JJ 19613 1446 12 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 1446 13 that that WDT 19613 1446 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1446 15 makes make VBZ 19613 1446 16 the the DT 19613 1446 17 general general JJ 19613 1446 18 statement statement NN 19613 1446 19 that that IN 19613 1446 20 the the DT 19613 1446 21 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1446 22 reject reject VBP 19613 1446 23 the the DT 19613 1446 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1446 25 to to IN 19613 1446 26 Timothy Timothy NNP 19613 1446 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1446 28 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1446 29 . . . 19613 1447 1 II ii CD 19613 1447 2 . . . 19613 1448 1 12 12 CD 19613 1448 2 . . . 19613 1449 1 52 52 CD 19613 1449 2 : : : 19613 1449 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1449 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1449 5 : : : 19613 1449 6 hoi hoi NNP 19613 1449 7 apo apo NNP 19613 1449 8 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1449 9 haireseôn haireseôn NNP 19613 1449 10 tas tas NNP 19613 1449 11 pros pro NNS 19613 1449 12 Timotheon Timotheon NNP 19613 1449 13 athetousin athetousin NNP 19613 1449 14 epistolas epistola NNS 19613 1449 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1449 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1449 17 . . . 19613 1450 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 1450 2 did do VBD 19613 1450 3 not not RB 19613 1450 4 happen happen VB 19613 1450 5 to to TO 19613 1450 6 be be VB 19613 1450 7 at at IN 19613 1450 8 the the DT 19613 1450 9 disposal disposal NN 19613 1450 10 of of IN 19613 1450 11 the the DT 19613 1450 12 Church Church NNP 19613 1450 13 at at RB 19613 1450 14 all all RB 19613 1450 15 till till IN 19613 1450 16 the the DT 19613 1450 17 middle middle NN 19613 1450 18 of of IN 19613 1450 19 the the DT 19613 1450 20 second second JJ 19613 1450 21 century century NN 19613 1450 22 . . . 19613 1450 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1451 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1451 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1451 3 86 86 CD 19613 1451 4 : : : 19613 1451 5 Yet yet CC 19613 1451 6 see see VB 19613 1451 7 the the DT 19613 1451 8 passage passage NN 19613 1451 9 from from IN 19613 1451 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1451 11 quoted quote VBD 19613 1451 12 , , , 19613 1451 13 p. p. NN 19613 1451 14 15 15 CD 19613 1451 15 , , , 19613 1451 16 note note VB 19613 1451 17 1 1 CD 19613 1451 18 ; ; : 19613 1451 19 see see VB 19613 1451 20 also also RB 19613 1451 21 the the DT 19613 1451 22 " " `` 19613 1451 23 receptior receptior JJ 19613 1451 24 , , , 19613 1451 25 " " '' 19613 1451 26 de de FW 19613 1451 27 pudic pudic JJ 19613 1451 28 . . . 19613 1452 1 20 20 CD 19613 1452 2 , , , 19613 1452 3 the the DT 19613 1452 4 cause cause NN 19613 1452 5 of of IN 19613 1452 6 the the DT 19613 1452 7 rejection rejection NN 19613 1452 8 of of IN 19613 1452 9 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1452 10 in in IN 19613 1452 11 the the DT 19613 1452 12 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1452 13 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1452 14 and and CC 19613 1452 15 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1452 16 . . . 19613 1453 1 de de NNP 19613 1453 2 bapt bapt NNP 19613 1453 3 . . . 19613 1454 1 17 17 CD 19613 1454 2 : : : 19613 1454 3 " " `` 19613 1454 4 Quodsi Quodsi NNP 19613 1454 5 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1454 6 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1454 7 perperam perperam NNP 19613 1454 8 scripta scripta NNP 19613 1454 9 sunt sunt NN 19613 1454 10 exemplum exemplum NNP 19613 1454 11 Theclæ Theclæ NNP 19613 1454 12 ad ad NN 19613 1454 13 licentiam licentiam NNP 19613 1454 14 mulierum mulierum NNP 19613 1454 15 docendi docendi NNP 19613 1454 16 tinguendique tinguendique NNP 19613 1454 17 defendunt defendunt NNP 19613 1454 18 , , , 19613 1454 19 sciant sciant NN 19613 1454 20 in in IN 19613 1454 21 Asia Asia NNP 19613 1454 22 presbyterum presbyterum NN 19613 1454 23 , , , 19613 1454 24 qui qui NNP 19613 1454 25 eam eam NNP 19613 1454 26 scripturam scripturam NNP 19613 1454 27 construxit construxit NNP 19613 1454 28 , , , 19613 1454 29 quasi quasi NNP 19613 1454 30 titulo titulo NNP 19613 1454 31 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1454 32 de de NNP 19613 1454 33 suo suo NNP 19613 1454 34 cumulans cumulans NNPS 19613 1454 35 , , , 19613 1454 36 convictum convictum NN 19613 1454 37 atque atque NNP 19613 1454 38 confessum confessum NNP 19613 1454 39 i -PRON- PRP 19613 1454 40 d d NNP 19613 1454 41 se se FW 19613 1454 42 amore amore FW 19613 1454 43 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1454 44 fecisse fecisse NNP 19613 1454 45 , , , 19613 1454 46 loco loco NNP 19613 1454 47 decessisse decessisse NNP 19613 1454 48 . . . 19613 1454 49 " " '' 19613 1455 1 The the DT 19613 1455 2 hypothesis hypothesis NN 19613 1455 3 that that WDT 19613 1455 4 the the DT 19613 1455 5 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1455 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 1455 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1455 8 or or CC 19613 1455 9 the the DT 19613 1455 10 apostle apostle NN 19613 1455 11 John John NNP 19613 1455 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1455 13 compiled compile VBD 19613 1455 14 the the DT 19613 1455 15 New New NNP 19613 1455 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1455 17 was be VBD 19613 1455 18 definitely definitely RB 19613 1455 19 set set VBN 19613 1455 20 up up RP 19613 1455 21 by by IN 19613 1455 22 no no DT 19613 1455 23 one one NN 19613 1455 24 in in IN 19613 1455 25 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 1455 26 and and CC 19613 1455 27 therefore therefore RB 19613 1455 28 need nee MD 19613 1455 29 not not RB 19613 1455 30 be be VB 19613 1455 31 discussed discuss VBN 19613 1455 32 . . . 19613 1456 1 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 1456 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1456 3 c. c. NN 19613 1456 4 Faustum Faustum NNP 19613 1456 5 XXII XXII NNP 19613 1456 6 . . . 19613 1457 1 79 79 LS 19613 1457 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1457 3 speaks speak VBZ 19613 1457 4 frankly frankly RB 19613 1457 5 of of IN 19613 1457 6 " " `` 19613 1457 7 sancti sancti NNP 19613 1457 8 et et NNP 19613 1457 9 docti docti NN 19613 1457 10 homines homine VBZ 19613 1457 11 " " '' 19613 1457 12 who who WP 19613 1457 13 produced produce VBD 19613 1457 14 the the DT 19613 1457 15 New New NNP 19613 1457 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1457 17 . . . 19613 1458 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1458 2 can can MD 19613 1458 3 prove prove VB 19613 1458 4 by by IN 19613 1458 5 a a DT 19613 1458 6 series series NN 19613 1458 7 of of IN 19613 1458 8 testimonies testimony NNS 19613 1458 9 that that WDT 19613 1458 10 the the DT 19613 1458 11 idea idea NN 19613 1458 12 of of IN 19613 1458 13 the the DT 19613 1458 14 Church Church NNP 19613 1458 15 having have VBG 19613 1458 16 compiled compile VBN 19613 1458 17 the the DT 19613 1458 18 New New NNP 19613 1458 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1458 20 writings writing NNS 19613 1458 21 was be VBD 19613 1458 22 in in IN 19613 1458 23 no no DT 19613 1458 24 way way NN 19613 1458 25 offensive offensive JJ 19613 1458 26 to to IN 19613 1458 27 the the DT 19613 1458 28 Old Old NNP 19613 1458 29 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1458 30 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 1458 31 . . . 19613 1459 1 As as IN 19613 1459 2 a a DT 19613 1459 3 rule rule NN 19613 1459 4 , , , 19613 1459 5 indeed indeed RB 19613 1459 6 , , , 19613 1459 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1459 8 are be VBP 19613 1459 9 silent silent JJ 19613 1459 10 on on IN 19613 1459 11 the the DT 19613 1459 12 matter matter NN 19613 1459 13 . . . 19613 1460 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1460 2 and and CC 19613 1460 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1460 4 already already RB 19613 1460 5 treat treat VBP 19613 1460 6 the the DT 19613 1460 7 collection collection NN 19613 1460 8 as as RB 19613 1460 9 simply simply RB 19613 1460 10 existent existent NN 19613 1460 11 . . . 19613 1460 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1461 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1461 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1461 3 87 87 CD 19613 1461 4 : : : 19613 1461 5 Numerous numerous JJ 19613 1461 6 examples example NNS 19613 1461 7 may may MD 19613 1461 8 be be VB 19613 1461 9 found find VBN 19613 1461 10 in in IN 19613 1461 11 proof proof NN 19613 1461 12 of of IN 19613 1461 13 all all PDT 19613 1461 14 these these DT 19613 1461 15 points point NNS 19613 1461 16 , , , 19613 1461 17 especially especially RB 19613 1461 18 in in IN 19613 1461 19 the the DT 19613 1461 20 writings writing NNS 19613 1461 21 of of IN 19613 1461 22 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1461 23 , , , 19613 1461 24 though though IN 19613 1461 25 such such JJ 19613 1461 26 are be VBP 19613 1461 27 already already RB 19613 1461 28 to to TO 19613 1461 29 be be VB 19613 1461 30 met meet VBN 19613 1461 31 with with IN 19613 1461 32 in in IN 19613 1461 33 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1461 34 also also RB 19613 1461 35 . . . 19613 1462 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1462 2 is be VBZ 19613 1462 3 not not RB 19613 1462 4 yet yet RB 19613 1462 5 so so RB 19613 1462 6 bold bold JJ 19613 1462 7 in in IN 19613 1462 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1462 9 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 1462 10 exposition exposition NN 19613 1462 11 of of IN 19613 1462 12 the the DT 19613 1462 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1462 14 as as IN 19613 1462 15 Ptolemæus Ptolemæus NNP 19613 1462 16 whom whom WP 19613 1462 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1462 18 finds find VBZ 19613 1462 19 fault fault NN 19613 1462 20 with with IN 19613 1462 21 in in IN 19613 1462 22 this this DT 19613 1462 23 respect respect NN 19613 1462 24 ; ; : 19613 1462 25 but but CC 19613 1462 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1462 27 already already RB 19613 1462 28 gives give VBZ 19613 1462 29 an an DT 19613 1462 30 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 1462 31 of of IN 19613 1462 32 the the DT 19613 1462 33 books book NNS 19613 1462 34 of of IN 19613 1462 35 the the DT 19613 1462 36 New New NNP 19613 1462 37 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1462 38 not not RB 19613 1462 39 essentially essentially RB 19613 1462 40 different different JJ 19613 1462 41 from from IN 19613 1462 42 that that DT 19613 1462 43 of of IN 19613 1462 44 the the DT 19613 1462 45 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 1462 46 . . . 19613 1463 1 One one CD 19613 1463 2 should should MD 19613 1463 3 above above RB 19613 1463 4 all all DT 19613 1463 5 read read VB 19613 1463 6 the the DT 19613 1463 7 treatise treatise NN 19613 1463 8 of of IN 19613 1463 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1463 10 " " '' 19613 1463 11 de de FW 19613 1463 12 idololatria idololatria NNP 19613 1463 13 " " '' 19613 1463 14 to to TO 19613 1463 15 perceive perceive VB 19613 1463 16 how how WRB 19613 1463 17 the the DT 19613 1463 18 authority authority NN 19613 1463 19 of of IN 19613 1463 20 the the DT 19613 1463 21 New New NNP 19613 1463 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1463 23 was be VBD 19613 1463 24 even even RB 19613 1463 25 by by IN 19613 1463 26 that that DT 19613 1463 27 time time NN 19613 1463 28 used use VBN 19613 1463 29 for for IN 19613 1463 30 solving solve VBG 19613 1463 31 all all DT 19613 1463 32 questions question NNS 19613 1463 33 . . . 19613 1463 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1464 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1464 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1464 3 88 88 CD 19613 1464 4 : : : 19613 1464 5 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1464 6 can can MD 19613 1464 7 not not RB 19613 1464 8 here here RB 19613 1464 9 enter enter VB 19613 1464 10 into into IN 19613 1464 11 the the DT 19613 1464 12 disputed dispute VBN 19613 1464 13 question question NN 19613 1464 14 as as IN 19613 1464 15 to to IN 19613 1464 16 the the DT 19613 1464 17 position position NN 19613 1464 18 that that WDT 19613 1464 19 should should MD 19613 1464 20 be be VB 19613 1464 21 assigned assign VBN 19613 1464 22 to to IN 19613 1464 23 the the DT 19613 1464 24 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1464 25 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1464 26 in in IN 19613 1464 27 the the DT 19613 1464 28 history history NN 19613 1464 29 of of IN 19613 1464 30 the the DT 19613 1464 31 formation formation NN 19613 1464 32 of of IN 19613 1464 33 the the DT 19613 1464 34 canon canon NN 19613 1464 35 , , , 19613 1464 36 nor nor CC 19613 1464 37 into into IN 19613 1464 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1464 39 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 1464 40 , , , 19613 1464 41 etc etc FW 19613 1464 42 . . . 19613 1465 1 See see VB 19613 1465 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1465 3 article article NN 19613 1465 4 " " `` 19613 1465 5 Das Das NNP 19613 1465 6 Muratorische Muratorische NNP 19613 1465 7 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1465 8 und und NN 19613 1465 9 die die NN 19613 1465 10 Entstehung Entstehung NNP 19613 1465 11 einer einer NN 19613 1465 12 Sammlung Sammlung NNP 19613 1465 13 apostolisch apostolisch NN 19613 1465 14 - - HYPH 19613 1465 15 katholischer katholischer NNP 19613 1465 16 Schriften Schriften NNP 19613 1465 17 " " '' 19613 1465 18 in in IN 19613 1465 19 the the DT 19613 1465 20 Ztschr Ztschr NNP 19613 1465 21 . . . 19613 1466 1 f. f. NNP 19613 1466 2 K. K. NNP 19613 1466 3 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1466 4 . . . 19613 1467 1 III iii CD 19613 1467 2 . . . 19613 1468 1 p. p. NN 19613 1468 2 358 358 CD 19613 1468 3 ff ff NN 19613 1468 4 . . . 19613 1469 1 See see VB 19613 1469 2 also also RB 19613 1469 3 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 1469 4 , , , 19613 1469 5 Zur Zur NNP 19613 1469 6 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 1469 7 des des NNP 19613 1469 8 Kanons Kanons NNP 19613 1469 9 , , , 19613 1469 10 1880 1880 CD 19613 1469 11 ; ; : 19613 1469 12 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 19613 1469 13 , , , 19613 1469 14 in in IN 19613 1469 15 the the DT 19613 1469 16 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 1469 17 f. f. NNP 19613 1469 18 Wissensch Wissensch NNP 19613 1469 19 . . . 19613 1470 1 Theol Theol NNP 19613 1470 2 . . . 19613 1471 1 1881 1881 CD 19613 1471 2 , , , 19613 1471 3 part part NN 19613 1471 4 2 2 CD 19613 1471 5 ; ; : 19613 1471 6 Schmiedel Schmiedel NNP 19613 1471 7 , , , 19613 1471 8 Art art NN 19613 1471 9 . . . 19613 1472 1 " " `` 19613 1472 2 Kanon Kanon NNP 19613 1472 3 " " '' 19613 1472 4 in in IN 19613 1472 5 Ersch Ersch NNP 19613 1472 6 . . . 19613 1473 1 u. u. NNP 19613 1473 2 Gruber Gruber NNP 19613 1473 3 's 's POS 19613 1473 4 Encykl Encykl NNP 19613 1473 5 . . . 19613 1473 6 , , , 19613 1473 7 2 2 CD 19613 1473 8 Section Section NNP 19613 1473 9 , , , 19613 1473 10 Vol Vol NNP 19613 1473 11 . . . 19613 1474 1 XXXII XXXII NNP 19613 1474 2 . . . 19613 1475 1 p. p. NN 19613 1475 2 309 309 CD 19613 1475 3 ff ff NN 19613 1475 4 . . . 19613 1476 1 ; ; : 19613 1476 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 1476 3 , , , 19613 1476 4 Kanongeschichte Kanongeschichte NNP 19613 1476 5 , , , 19613 1476 6 Vol Vol NNP 19613 1476 7 . . . 19613 1477 1 II ii CD 19613 1477 2 . . . 19613 1478 1 p. p. NN 19613 1478 2 1 1 CD 19613 1478 3 ff ff NN 19613 1478 4 . . . 19613 1479 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1479 2 leave leave VBP 19613 1479 3 the the DT 19613 1479 4 fragment fragment NN 19613 1479 5 and and CC 19613 1479 6 the the DT 19613 1479 7 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 1479 8 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1479 9 have have VBP 19613 1479 10 drawn draw VBN 19613 1479 11 from from IN 19613 1479 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1479 13 almost almost RB 19613 1479 14 entirely entirely RB 19613 1479 15 out out IN 19613 1479 16 of of IN 19613 1479 17 account account NN 19613 1479 18 here here RB 19613 1479 19 . . . 19613 1480 1 The the DT 19613 1480 2 following follow VBG 19613 1480 3 sketch sketch NN 19613 1480 4 will will MD 19613 1480 5 show show VB 19613 1480 6 that that IN 19613 1480 7 the the DT 19613 1480 8 objections objection NNS 19613 1480 9 of of IN 19613 1480 10 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 1480 11 have have VBP 19613 1480 12 not not RB 19613 1480 13 been be VBN 19613 1480 14 without without IN 19613 1480 15 influence influence NN 19613 1480 16 on on IN 19613 1480 17 me -PRON- PRP 19613 1480 18 . . . 19613 1480 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1481 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1481 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1481 3 89 89 CD 19613 1481 4 : : : 19613 1481 5 The the DT 19613 1481 6 use use NN 19613 1481 7 of of IN 19613 1481 8 the the DT 19613 1481 9 word word NN 19613 1481 10 " " `` 19613 1481 11 canon canon NN 19613 1481 12 " " '' 19613 1481 13 as as IN 19613 1481 14 a a DT 19613 1481 15 designation designation NN 19613 1481 16 of of IN 19613 1481 17 the the DT 19613 1481 18 collection collection NN 19613 1481 19 is be VBZ 19613 1481 20 first first RB 19613 1481 21 plainly plainly RB 19613 1481 22 demonstrable demonstrable JJ 19613 1481 23 in in IN 19613 1481 24 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 19613 1481 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1481 26 ep ep NNP 19613 1481 27 . . . 19613 1482 1 fest f JJS 19613 1482 2 . . . 19613 1483 1 of of IN 19613 1483 2 the the DT 19613 1483 3 year year NN 19613 1483 4 365 365 CD 19613 1483 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1483 6 and and CC 19613 1483 7 in in IN 19613 1483 8 the the DT 19613 1483 9 59th 59th JJ 19613 1483 10 canon canon NN 19613 1483 11 of of IN 19613 1483 12 the the DT 19613 1483 13 synod synod NN 19613 1483 14 of of IN 19613 1483 15 Laodicea Laodicea NNP 19613 1483 16 . . . 19613 1484 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1484 2 is be VBZ 19613 1484 3 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 1484 4 whether whether IN 19613 1484 5 the the DT 19613 1484 6 term term NN 19613 1484 7 was be VBD 19613 1484 8 already already RB 19613 1484 9 used use VBN 19613 1484 10 by by IN 19613 1484 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1484 12 . . . 19613 1485 1 Besides besides RB 19613 1485 2 , , , 19613 1485 3 the the DT 19613 1485 4 word word NN 19613 1485 5 " " `` 19613 1485 6 canon canon NN 19613 1485 7 " " '' 19613 1485 8 was be VBD 19613 1485 9 not not RB 19613 1485 10 applied apply VBN 19613 1485 11 even even RB 19613 1485 12 to to IN 19613 1485 13 the the DT 19613 1485 14 Old Old NNP 19613 1485 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1485 16 before before IN 19613 1485 17 the the DT 19613 1485 18 fourth fourth JJ 19613 1485 19 century century NN 19613 1485 20 . . . 19613 1486 1 The the DT 19613 1486 2 name name NN 19613 1486 3 " " `` 19613 1486 4 New New NNP 19613 1486 5 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1486 6 " " '' 19613 1486 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1486 8 books book NNS 19613 1486 9 of of IN 19613 1486 10 the the DT 19613 1486 11 New New NNP 19613 1486 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1486 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1486 14 is be VBZ 19613 1486 15 first first RB 19613 1486 16 found find VBN 19613 1486 17 in in IN 19613 1486 18 Melito Melito NNP 19613 1486 19 and and CC 19613 1486 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1486 21 . . . 19613 1487 1 For for IN 19613 1487 2 other other JJ 19613 1487 3 designations designation NNS 19613 1487 4 of of IN 19613 1487 5 the the DT 19613 1487 6 latter latter JJ 19613 1487 7 see see VB 19613 1487 8 Ronsch Ronsch NNP 19613 1487 9 , , , 19613 1487 10 Das Das NNP 19613 1487 11 N. N. NNP 19613 1487 12 T. T. NNP 19613 1487 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1487 14 's 's POS 19613 1487 15 p. p. NN 19613 1487 16 47 47 CD 19613 1487 17 f. f. NNS 19613 1487 18 The the DT 19613 1487 19 most most RBS 19613 1487 20 common common JJ 19613 1487 21 name name NN 19613 1487 22 is be VBZ 19613 1487 23 " " `` 19613 1487 24 Holy Holy NNP 19613 1487 25 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 1487 26 . . . 19613 1487 27 " " '' 19613 1488 1 In in IN 19613 1488 2 accordance accordance NN 19613 1488 3 with with IN 19613 1488 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1488 5 main main JJ 19613 1488 6 components component NNS 19613 1488 7 the the DT 19613 1488 8 collection collection NN 19613 1488 9 is be VBZ 19613 1488 10 designated designate VBN 19613 1488 11 as as IN 19613 1488 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1488 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1488 14 : : : 19613 1488 15 to to TO 19613 1488 16 euangelion euangelion VB 19613 1488 17 kai kai NNP 19613 1488 18 ho ho NNP 19613 1488 19 apostolos apostolos NNP 19613 1488 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1488 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1488 22 evangelicæ evangelicæ NNP 19613 1488 23 et et NNP 19613 1488 24 apostolicæ apostolicæ NNP 19613 1488 25 litteræ litteræ NNP 19613 1488 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1488 27 ; ; : 19613 1488 28 see see VB 19613 1488 29 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1488 30 , , , 19613 1488 31 de de FW 19613 1488 32 bapt bapt NNP 19613 1488 33 . . . 19613 1489 1 15 15 CD 19613 1489 2 : : : 19613 1489 3 " " `` 19613 1489 4 tam tam NNP 19613 1489 5 ex ex NNP 19613 1489 6 domini domini NNP 19613 1489 7 evangelio evangelio NNP 19613 1489 8 quam quam NNP 19613 1489 9 ex ex FW 19613 1489 10 apostoli apostoli JJ 19613 1489 11 litteris litteris NN 19613 1489 12 . . . 19613 1489 13 " " '' 19613 1490 1 The the DT 19613 1490 2 name name NN 19613 1490 3 " " `` 19613 1490 4 writings writing NNS 19613 1490 5 of of IN 19613 1490 6 the the DT 19613 1490 7 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1490 8 " " '' 19613 1490 9 is be VBZ 19613 1490 10 also also RB 19613 1490 11 found find VBN 19613 1490 12 very very RB 19613 1490 13 early early RB 19613 1490 14 . . . 19613 1491 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1491 2 was be VBD 19613 1491 3 already already RB 19613 1491 4 used use VBN 19613 1491 5 for for IN 19613 1491 6 the the DT 19613 1491 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1491 8 at at IN 19613 1491 9 a a DT 19613 1491 10 time time NN 19613 1491 11 when when WRB 19613 1491 12 there there EX 19613 1491 13 was be VBD 19613 1491 14 no no DT 19613 1491 15 such such JJ 19613 1491 16 thing thing NN 19613 1491 17 as as IN 19613 1491 18 a a DT 19613 1491 19 canon canon NN 19613 1491 20 . . . 19613 1492 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1492 2 was be VBD 19613 1492 3 then then RB 19613 1492 4 occasionally occasionally RB 19613 1492 5 transferred transfer VBN 19613 1492 6 to to IN 19613 1492 7 all all DT 19613 1492 8 writings writing NNS 19613 1492 9 of of IN 19613 1492 10 the the DT 19613 1492 11 collection collection NN 19613 1492 12 . . . 19613 1493 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 1493 2 , , , 19613 1493 3 the the DT 19613 1493 4 entire entire JJ 19613 1493 5 collection collection NN 19613 1493 6 was be VBD 19613 1493 7 named name VBN 19613 1493 8 , , , 19613 1493 9 after after IN 19613 1493 10 the the DT 19613 1493 11 authors author NNS 19613 1493 12 , , , 19613 1493 13 a a DT 19613 1493 14 collection collection NN 19613 1493 15 of of IN 19613 1493 16 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1493 17 writings writing NNS 19613 1493 18 , , , 19613 1493 19 just just RB 19613 1493 20 as as IN 19613 1493 21 the the DT 19613 1493 22 Old Old NNP 19613 1493 23 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1493 24 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 1493 25 were be VBD 19613 1493 26 collectively collectively RB 19613 1493 27 called call VBN 19613 1493 28 the the DT 19613 1493 29 writings writing NNS 19613 1493 30 of of IN 19613 1493 31 the the DT 19613 1493 32 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1493 33 . . . 19613 1494 1 Prophets prophet NNS 19613 1494 2 and and CC 19613 1494 3 Apostles apostle VBZ 19613 1494 4 (= (= NNP 19613 1494 5 Old Old NNP 19613 1494 6 and and CC 19613 1494 7 New New NNP 19613 1494 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1494 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1494 10 were be VBD 19613 1494 11 now now RB 19613 1494 12 conceived conceive VBN 19613 1494 13 as as IN 19613 1494 14 the the DT 19613 1494 15 media medium NNS 19613 1494 16 of of IN 19613 1494 17 God God NNP 19613 1494 18 's 's POS 19613 1494 19 revelation revelation NN 19613 1494 20 fixed fix VBN 19613 1494 21 in in IN 19613 1494 22 writing writing NN 19613 1494 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1494 24 see see VB 19613 1494 25 the the DT 19613 1494 26 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1494 27 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1494 28 in in IN 19613 1494 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1494 30 account account NN 19613 1494 31 of of IN 19613 1494 32 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1494 33 , , , 19613 1494 34 and and CC 19613 1494 35 the the DT 19613 1494 36 designation designation NN 19613 1494 37 of of IN 19613 1494 38 the the DT 19613 1494 39 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1494 40 as as IN 19613 1494 41 " " `` 19613 1494 42 Apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 1494 43 memoirs memoir NNS 19613 1494 44 " " '' 19613 1494 45 already already RB 19613 1494 46 found find VBN 19613 1494 47 in in IN 19613 1494 48 Justin Justin NNP 19613 1494 49 . . . 19613 1494 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1495 1 This this DT 19613 1495 2 grouping grouping NN 19613 1495 3 became become VBD 19613 1495 4 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 1495 5 important important JJ 19613 1495 6 . . . 19613 1496 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1496 2 occasioned occasion VBD 19613 1496 3 new new JJ 19613 1496 4 speculations speculation NNS 19613 1496 5 about about IN 19613 1496 6 the the DT 19613 1496 7 unique unique JJ 19613 1496 8 dignity dignity NN 19613 1496 9 of of IN 19613 1496 10 the the DT 19613 1496 11 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1496 12 and and CC 19613 1496 13 did do VBD 19613 1496 14 away away RB 19613 1496 15 with with IN 19613 1496 16 the the DT 19613 1496 17 old old JJ 19613 1496 18 collocation collocation NN 19613 1496 19 of of IN 19613 1496 20 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1496 21 and and CC 19613 1496 22 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 1496 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1496 24 that that DT 19613 1496 25 is be VBZ 19613 1496 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 1496 27 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1496 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1496 29 . . . 19613 1497 1 By by IN 19613 1497 2 this this DT 19613 1497 3 alteration alteration NN 19613 1497 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1497 5 may may MD 19613 1497 6 measure measure VB 19613 1497 7 the the DT 19613 1497 8 revolution revolution NN 19613 1497 9 of of IN 19613 1497 10 the the DT 19613 1497 11 times time NNS 19613 1497 12 . . . 19613 1498 1 Finally finally RB 19613 1498 2 , , , 19613 1498 3 the the DT 19613 1498 4 new new JJ 19613 1498 5 collection collection NN 19613 1498 6 was be VBD 19613 1498 7 also also RB 19613 1498 8 called call VBN 19613 1498 9 " " `` 19613 1498 10 the the DT 19613 1498 11 writings writing NNS 19613 1498 12 of of IN 19613 1498 13 the the DT 19613 1498 14 Church Church NNP 19613 1498 15 " " '' 19613 1498 16 as as IN 19613 1498 17 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 1498 18 from from IN 19613 1498 19 the the DT 19613 1498 20 Old Old NNP 19613 1498 21 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1498 22 and and CC 19613 1498 23 the the DT 19613 1498 24 writings writing NNS 19613 1498 25 of of IN 19613 1498 26 the the DT 19613 1498 27 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1498 28 . . . 19613 1499 1 This this DT 19613 1499 2 expression expression NN 19613 1499 3 and and CC 19613 1499 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1499 5 amplifications amplification NNS 19613 1499 6 shew shew NN 19613 1499 7 that that IN 19613 1499 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1499 9 was be VBD 19613 1499 10 the the DT 19613 1499 11 Church Church NNP 19613 1499 12 which which WDT 19613 1499 13 selected select VBD 19613 1499 14 these these DT 19613 1499 15 writings writing NNS 19613 1499 16 . . . 19613 1499 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1500 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1500 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1500 3 90 90 CD 19613 1500 4 : : : 19613 1500 5 Here here RB 19613 1500 6 there there EX 19613 1500 7 is be VBZ 19613 1500 8 a a DT 19613 1500 9 distinction distinction NN 19613 1500 10 between between IN 19613 1500 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1500 12 and and CC 19613 1500 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1500 14 . . . 19613 1501 1 The the DT 19613 1501 2 former former JJ 19613 1501 3 disputed dispute VBN 19613 1501 4 with with IN 19613 1501 5 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1501 6 about about IN 19613 1501 7 the the DT 19613 1501 8 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 1501 9 of of IN 19613 1501 10 the the DT 19613 1501 11 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 1501 12 , , , 19613 1501 13 the the DT 19613 1501 14 latter latter JJ 19613 1501 15 , , , 19613 1501 16 although although IN 19613 1501 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1501 18 has have VBZ 19613 1501 19 read read VBN 19613 1501 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1501 21 , , , 19613 1501 22 forbids forbid NNS 19613 1501 23 such such JJ 19613 1501 24 dispute dispute NN 19613 1501 25 . . . 19613 1502 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1502 2 can can MD 19613 1502 3 not not RB 19613 1502 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 1502 5 have have VB 19613 1502 6 considered consider VBN 19613 1502 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1502 8 ' ' POS 19613 1502 9 efforts effort NNS 19613 1502 10 as as IN 19613 1502 11 successful successful JJ 19613 1502 12 . . . 19613 1502 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1503 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1503 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1503 3 91 91 CD 19613 1503 4 : : : 19613 1503 5 The the DT 19613 1503 6 reader reader NN 19613 1503 7 should should MD 19613 1503 8 remember remember VB 19613 1503 9 the the DT 19613 1503 10 different different JJ 19613 1503 11 recensions recension NNS 19613 1503 12 of of IN 19613 1503 13 the the DT 19613 1503 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1503 15 and and CC 19613 1503 16 the the DT 19613 1503 17 complaints complaint NNS 19613 1503 18 made make VBN 19613 1503 19 by by IN 19613 1503 20 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 1503 21 of of IN 19613 1503 22 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 1503 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1503 24 in in IN 19613 1503 25 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1503 26 . . NNP 19613 1503 27 , , , 19613 1503 28 H. H. NNP 19613 1503 29 E. E. NNP 19613 1503 30 IV IV NNP 19613 1503 31 . . . 19613 1504 1 23 23 CD 19613 1504 2 . . . 19613 1505 1 12 12 CD 19613 1505 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1505 3 . . . 19613 1505 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1506 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1506 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1506 3 92 92 CD 19613 1506 4 : : : 19613 1506 5 That that IN 19613 1506 6 the the DT 19613 1506 7 text text NN 19613 1506 8 of of IN 19613 1506 9 these these DT 19613 1506 10 writings writing NNS 19613 1506 11 was be VBD 19613 1506 12 at at IN 19613 1506 13 the the DT 19613 1506 14 same same JJ 19613 1506 15 time time NN 19613 1506 16 revised revise VBN 19613 1506 17 is be VBZ 19613 1506 18 more more JJR 19613 1506 19 than than IN 19613 1506 20 probable probable JJ 19613 1506 21 , , , 19613 1506 22 especially especially RB 19613 1506 23 in in IN 19613 1506 24 view view NN 19613 1506 25 of of IN 19613 1506 26 the the DT 19613 1506 27 beginnings beginning NNS 19613 1506 28 and and CC 19613 1506 29 endings ending NNS 19613 1506 30 of of IN 19613 1506 31 many many JJ 19613 1506 32 New New NNP 19613 1506 33 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1506 34 writings writing NNS 19613 1506 35 , , , 19613 1506 36 as as RB 19613 1506 37 well well RB 19613 1506 38 as as IN 19613 1506 39 , , , 19613 1506 40 in in IN 19613 1506 41 the the DT 19613 1506 42 case case NN 19613 1506 43 of of IN 19613 1506 44 the the DT 19613 1506 45 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1506 46 , , , 19613 1506 47 from from IN 19613 1506 48 a a DT 19613 1506 49 comparison comparison NN 19613 1506 50 of of IN 19613 1506 51 the the DT 19613 1506 52 canon canon NNP 19613 1506 53 text text NN 19613 1506 54 with with IN 19613 1506 55 the the DT 19613 1506 56 quotations quotation NNS 19613 1506 57 dating date VBG 19613 1506 58 from from IN 19613 1506 59 the the DT 19613 1506 60 time time NN 19613 1506 61 when when WRB 19613 1506 62 there there EX 19613 1506 63 was be VBD 19613 1506 64 no no DT 19613 1506 65 canon canon NN 19613 1506 66 . . . 19613 1507 1 But but CC 19613 1507 2 much much RB 19613 1507 3 more more RBR 19613 1507 4 important important JJ 19613 1507 5 still still RB 19613 1507 6 is be VBZ 19613 1507 7 the the DT 19613 1507 8 perception perception NN 19613 1507 9 of of IN 19613 1507 10 the the DT 19613 1507 11 fact fact NN 19613 1507 12 that that IN 19613 1507 13 , , , 19613 1507 14 in in IN 19613 1507 15 the the DT 19613 1507 16 course course NN 19613 1507 17 of of IN 19613 1507 18 the the DT 19613 1507 19 second second JJ 19613 1507 20 century century NN 19613 1507 21 , , , 19613 1507 22 a a DT 19613 1507 23 series series NN 19613 1507 24 of of IN 19613 1507 25 writings writing NNS 19613 1507 26 which which WDT 19613 1507 27 had have VBD 19613 1507 28 originally originally RB 19613 1507 29 been be VBN 19613 1507 30 circulated circulate VBN 19613 1507 31 anonymously anonymously RB 19613 1507 32 or or CC 19613 1507 33 under under IN 19613 1507 34 the the DT 19613 1507 35 name name NN 19613 1507 36 of of IN 19613 1507 37 an an DT 19613 1507 38 unknown unknown JJ 19613 1507 39 author author NN 19613 1507 40 were be VBD 19613 1507 41 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 1507 42 to to IN 19613 1507 43 an an DT 19613 1507 44 Apostle apostle NN 19613 1507 45 and and CC 19613 1507 46 were be VBD 19613 1507 47 also also RB 19613 1507 48 slightly slightly RB 19613 1507 49 altered alter VBN 19613 1507 50 in in IN 19613 1507 51 accordance accordance NN 19613 1507 52 with with IN 19613 1507 53 this this DT 19613 1507 54 . . . 19613 1508 1 In in IN 19613 1508 2 what what WDT 19613 1508 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 1508 4 or or CC 19613 1508 5 at at IN 19613 1508 6 what what WDT 19613 1508 7 time time NN 19613 1508 8 this this DT 19613 1508 9 happened happen VBD 19613 1508 10 , , , 19613 1508 11 whether whether IN 19613 1508 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1508 13 took take VBD 19613 1508 14 place place NN 19613 1508 15 as as RB 19613 1508 16 early early RB 19613 1508 17 as as IN 19613 1508 18 the the DT 19613 1508 19 beginning beginning NN 19613 1508 20 of of IN 19613 1508 21 the the DT 19613 1508 22 second second JJ 19613 1508 23 century century NN 19613 1508 24 or or CC 19613 1508 25 only only RB 19613 1508 26 immediately immediately RB 19613 1508 27 before before IN 19613 1508 28 the the DT 19613 1508 29 formation formation NN 19613 1508 30 of of IN 19613 1508 31 the the DT 19613 1508 32 canon canon NN 19613 1508 33 , , , 19613 1508 34 is be VBZ 19613 1508 35 in in IN 19613 1508 36 almost almost RB 19613 1508 37 every every DT 19613 1508 38 individual individual JJ 19613 1508 39 case case NN 19613 1508 40 involved involve VBN 19613 1508 41 in in IN 19613 1508 42 obscurity obscurity NN 19613 1508 43 , , , 19613 1508 44 but but CC 19613 1508 45 the the DT 19613 1508 46 fact fact NN 19613 1508 47 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1508 48 , , , 19613 1508 49 of of IN 19613 1508 50 which which WDT 19613 1508 51 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 1508 52 the the DT 19613 1508 53 Introductions Introductions NNPS 19613 1508 54 to to IN 19613 1508 55 the the DT 19613 1508 56 New New NNP 19613 1508 57 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1508 58 still still RB 19613 1508 59 know know VBP 19613 1508 60 so so RB 19613 1508 61 little little JJ 19613 1508 62 , , , 19613 1508 63 is be VBZ 19613 1508 64 , , , 19613 1508 65 in in IN 19613 1508 66 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1508 67 opinion opinion NN 19613 1508 68 , , , 19613 1508 69 incontestable incontestable JJ 19613 1508 70 . . . 19613 1509 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1509 2 refer refer VBP 19613 1509 3 the the DT 19613 1509 4 reader reader NN 19613 1509 5 to to IN 19613 1509 6 the the DT 19613 1509 7 following follow VBG 19613 1509 8 examples example NNS 19613 1509 9 , , , 19613 1509 10 without without IN 19613 1509 11 indeed indeed RB 19613 1509 12 being be VBG 19613 1509 13 able able JJ 19613 1509 14 to to TO 19613 1509 15 enter enter VB 19613 1509 16 on on IN 19613 1509 17 the the DT 19613 1509 18 proof proof NN 19613 1509 19 here here RB 19613 1509 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1509 21 see see VB 19613 1509 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1509 23 edition edition NN 19613 1509 24 of of IN 19613 1509 25 the the DT 19613 1509 26 " " `` 19613 1509 27 Teaching Teaching NNP 19613 1509 28 of of IN 19613 1509 29 the the DT 19613 1509 30 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1509 31 " " '' 19613 1509 32 p. p. NN 19613 1509 33 106 106 CD 19613 1509 34 ff ff NN 19613 1509 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1509 36 . . . 19613 1510 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1510 2 1 1 LS 19613 1510 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1510 4 The the DT 19613 1510 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1510 6 of of IN 19613 1510 7 Luke Luke NNP 19613 1510 8 seems seem VBZ 19613 1510 9 not not RB 19613 1510 10 to to TO 19613 1510 11 have have VB 19613 1510 12 been be VBN 19613 1510 13 known know VBN 19613 1510 14 to to IN 19613 1510 15 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 1510 16 under under IN 19613 1510 17 this this DT 19613 1510 18 name name NN 19613 1510 19 , , , 19613 1510 20 and and CC 19613 1510 21 to to TO 19613 1510 22 have have VB 19613 1510 23 been be VBN 19613 1510 24 called call VBN 19613 1510 25 so so RB 19613 1510 26 only only RB 19613 1510 27 at at IN 19613 1510 28 a a DT 19613 1510 29 later later JJ 19613 1510 30 date date NN 19613 1510 31 . . . 19613 1511 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1511 2 2 2 LS 19613 1511 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1511 4 The the DT 19613 1511 5 canonical canonical JJ 19613 1511 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1511 7 of of IN 19613 1511 8 Matthew Matthew NNP 19613 1511 9 and and CC 19613 1511 10 Mark Mark NNP 19613 1511 11 do do VBP 19613 1511 12 not not RB 19613 1511 13 claim claim VB 19613 1511 14 , , , 19613 1511 15 through through IN 19613 1511 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1511 17 content content NN 19613 1511 18 , , , 19613 1511 19 to to TO 19613 1511 20 originate originate VB 19613 1511 21 with with IN 19613 1511 22 these these DT 19613 1511 23 men man NNS 19613 1511 24 ; ; : 19613 1511 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1511 26 were be VBD 19613 1511 27 regarded regard VBN 19613 1511 28 as as IN 19613 1511 29 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1511 30 at at IN 19613 1511 31 a a DT 19613 1511 32 later later JJ 19613 1511 33 period period NN 19613 1511 34 . . . 19613 1512 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1512 2 3 3 LS 19613 1512 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1512 4 The the DT 19613 1512 5 so so RB 19613 1512 6 - - HYPH 19613 1512 7 called call VBN 19613 1512 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1512 9 of of IN 19613 1512 10 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1512 11 was be VBD 19613 1512 12 first first RB 19613 1512 13 attributed attribute VBN 19613 1512 14 to to IN 19613 1512 15 the the DT 19613 1512 16 Apostle Apostle NNP 19613 1512 17 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1512 18 by by IN 19613 1512 19 tradition tradition NN 19613 1512 20 . . . 19613 1513 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1513 2 4 4 LS 19613 1513 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1513 4 The the DT 19613 1513 5 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 1513 6 of of IN 19613 1513 7 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1513 8 was be VBD 19613 1513 9 first first RB 19613 1513 10 connected connect VBN 19613 1513 11 with with IN 19613 1513 12 an an DT 19613 1513 13 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 1513 14 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1513 15 by by IN 19613 1513 16 tradition tradition NN 19613 1513 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1513 18 Rom Rom NNP 19613 1513 19 . . . 19613 1514 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 1514 2 . . . 19613 1515 1 14 14 CD 19613 1515 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1515 3 . . . 19613 1516 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1516 2 5 5 LS 19613 1516 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1516 4 The the DT 19613 1516 5 same same JJ 19613 1516 6 thing thing NN 19613 1516 7 took take VBD 19613 1516 8 place place NN 19613 1516 9 with with IN 19613 1516 10 regard regard NN 19613 1516 11 to to IN 19613 1516 12 the the DT 19613 1516 13 first first JJ 19613 1516 14 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1516 15 of of IN 19613 1516 16 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1516 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1516 18 Philipp Philipp NNP 19613 1516 19 , , , 19613 1516 20 IV IV NNP 19613 1516 21 . . . 19613 1517 1 3 3 LS 19613 1517 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1517 3 . . . 19613 1518 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1518 2 6 6 LS 19613 1518 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1518 4 The the DT 19613 1518 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1518 6 to to IN 19613 1518 7 the the DT 19613 1518 8 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 19613 1518 9 , , , 19613 1518 10 originally originally RB 19613 1518 11 the the DT 19613 1518 12 writing writing NN 19613 1518 13 of of IN 19613 1518 14 an an DT 19613 1518 15 unknown unknown JJ 19613 1518 16 author author NN 19613 1518 17 or or CC 19613 1518 18 of of IN 19613 1518 19 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1518 20 , , , 19613 1518 21 was be VBD 19613 1518 22 transformed transform VBN 19613 1518 23 into into IN 19613 1518 24 a a DT 19613 1518 25 writing writing NN 19613 1518 26 of of IN 19613 1518 27 the the DT 19613 1518 28 Apostle Apostle NNP 19613 1518 29 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1518 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1518 31 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 1518 32 zur zur NNP 19613 1518 33 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1518 34 . . . 19613 1519 1 des des NNP 19613 1519 2 Kanons Kanons NNP 19613 1519 3 , , , 19613 1519 4 1880 1880 CD 19613 1519 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1519 6 , , , 19613 1519 7 or or CC 19613 1519 8 given give VBN 19613 1519 9 out out RP 19613 1519 10 to to TO 19613 1519 11 be be VB 19613 1519 12 such such JJ 19613 1519 13 . . . 19613 1520 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1520 2 7 7 LS 19613 1520 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1520 4 The the DT 19613 1520 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1520 6 of of IN 19613 1520 7 James James NNP 19613 1520 8 , , , 19613 1520 9 originally originally RB 19613 1520 10 the the DT 19613 1520 11 communication communication NN 19613 1520 12 of of IN 19613 1520 13 an an DT 19613 1520 14 early early JJ 19613 1520 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 1520 16 prophet prophet NN 19613 1520 17 , , , 19613 1520 18 or or CC 19613 1520 19 a a DT 19613 1520 20 collection collection NN 19613 1520 21 of of IN 19613 1520 22 ancient ancient JJ 19613 1520 23 holy holy JJ 19613 1520 24 addresses address NNS 19613 1520 25 , , , 19613 1520 26 first first RB 19613 1520 27 seems seem VBZ 19613 1520 28 to to TO 19613 1520 29 have have VB 19613 1520 30 received receive VBN 19613 1520 31 the the DT 19613 1520 32 name name NN 19613 1520 33 of of IN 19613 1520 34 James James NNP 19613 1520 35 in in IN 19613 1520 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 1520 37 . . . 19613 1521 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1521 2 8) 8) CD 19613 1521 3 The the DT 19613 1521 4 first first JJ 19613 1521 5 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1521 6 of of IN 19613 1521 7 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1521 8 , , , 19613 1521 9 which which WDT 19613 1521 10 originally originally RB 19613 1521 11 appears appear VBZ 19613 1521 12 to to TO 19613 1521 13 have have VB 19613 1521 14 been be VBN 19613 1521 15 written write VBN 19613 1521 16 by by IN 19613 1521 17 an an DT 19613 1521 18 unknown unknown JJ 19613 1521 19 follower follower NN 19613 1521 20 of of IN 19613 1521 21 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1521 22 , , , 19613 1521 23 first first RB 19613 1521 24 received receive VBD 19613 1521 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1521 26 present present JJ 19613 1521 27 name name NN 19613 1521 28 from from IN 19613 1521 29 tradition tradition NN 19613 1521 30 . . . 19613 1522 1 The the DT 19613 1522 2 same same JJ 19613 1522 3 thing thing NN 19613 1522 4 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1522 5 holds hold VBZ 19613 1522 6 good good JJ 19613 1522 7 of of IN 19613 1522 8 the the DT 19613 1522 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1522 10 of of IN 19613 1522 11 Jude Jude NNP 19613 1522 12 . . . 19613 1523 1 Tradition tradition NN 19613 1523 2 was be VBD 19613 1523 3 similarly similarly RB 19613 1523 4 at at IN 19613 1523 5 work work NN 19613 1523 6 , , , 19613 1523 7 even even RB 19613 1523 8 at at IN 19613 1523 9 a a DT 19613 1523 10 later later JJ 19613 1523 11 period period NN 19613 1523 12 , , , 19613 1523 13 as as IN 19613 1523 14 may may MD 19613 1523 15 for for IN 19613 1523 16 example example NN 19613 1523 17 be be VB 19613 1523 18 recognised recognise VBN 19613 1523 19 by by IN 19613 1523 20 the the DT 19613 1523 21 transformation transformation NN 19613 1523 22 of of IN 19613 1523 23 the the DT 19613 1523 24 epistle epistle NN 19613 1523 25 " " `` 19613 1523 26 de de FW 19613 1523 27 virginitate virginitate NNP 19613 1523 28 " " '' 19613 1523 29 into into IN 19613 1523 30 two two CD 19613 1523 31 writings writing NNS 19613 1523 32 by by IN 19613 1523 33 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1523 34 . . . 19613 1524 1 The the DT 19613 1524 2 critics critic NNS 19613 1524 3 of of IN 19613 1524 4 early early JJ 19613 1524 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 1524 6 literature literature NN 19613 1524 7 have have VBP 19613 1524 8 created create VBN 19613 1524 9 for for IN 19613 1524 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 1524 11 insoluble insoluble JJ 19613 1524 12 problems problem NNS 19613 1524 13 by by IN 19613 1524 14 misunderstanding misunderstand VBG 19613 1524 15 the the DT 19613 1524 16 work work NN 19613 1524 17 of of IN 19613 1524 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 1524 19 . . . 19613 1525 1 Instead instead RB 19613 1525 2 of of IN 19613 1525 3 asking ask VBG 19613 1525 4 whether whether IN 19613 1525 5 the the DT 19613 1525 6 tradition tradition NN 19613 1525 7 is be VBZ 19613 1525 8 reliable reliable JJ 19613 1525 9 , , , 19613 1525 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1525 11 always always RB 19613 1525 12 wrestle wrestle VBP 19613 1525 13 with with IN 19613 1525 14 the the DT 19613 1525 15 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 1525 16 " " `` 19613 1525 17 genuine genuine JJ 19613 1525 18 or or CC 19613 1525 19 spurious spurious JJ 19613 1525 20 " " '' 19613 1525 21 , , , 19613 1525 22 and and CC 19613 1525 23 can can MD 19613 1525 24 prove prove VB 19613 1525 25 neither neither DT 19613 1525 26 . . . 19613 1525 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1526 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1526 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1526 3 93 93 CD 19613 1526 4 : : : 19613 1526 5 As as IN 19613 1526 6 regards regard VBZ 19613 1526 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1526 8 aim aim NN 19613 1526 9 and and CC 19613 1526 10 contents content NNS 19613 1526 11 , , , 19613 1526 12 this this DT 19613 1526 13 book book NN 19613 1526 14 is be VBZ 19613 1526 15 furthest furthest RB 19613 1526 16 removed remove VBN 19613 1526 17 from from IN 19613 1526 18 the the DT 19613 1526 19 claim claim NN 19613 1526 20 to to TO 19613 1526 21 be be VB 19613 1526 22 a a DT 19613 1526 23 portion portion NN 19613 1526 24 of of IN 19613 1526 25 a a DT 19613 1526 26 collection collection NN 19613 1526 27 of of IN 19613 1526 28 Holy Holy NNP 19613 1526 29 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 1526 30 . . . 19613 1527 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 1527 2 , , , 19613 1527 3 so so RB 19613 1527 4 far far RB 19613 1527 5 as as IN 19613 1527 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1527 7 know know VBP 19613 1527 8 , , , 19613 1527 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1527 10 reception reception NN 19613 1527 11 into into IN 19613 1527 12 the the DT 19613 1527 13 canon canon NN 19613 1527 14 has have VBZ 19613 1527 15 no no DT 19613 1527 16 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 1527 17 history history NN 19613 1527 18 . . . 19613 1527 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1528 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1528 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1528 3 94 94 CD 19613 1528 4 : : : 19613 1528 5 People People NNS 19613 1528 6 were be VBD 19613 1528 7 compelled compel VBN 19613 1528 8 by by IN 19613 1528 9 internal internal JJ 19613 1528 10 and and CC 19613 1528 11 external external JJ 19613 1528 12 evidence evidence NN 19613 1528 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1528 14 recognition recognition NN 19613 1528 15 of of IN 19613 1528 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1528 17 apostolicity apostolicity NN 19613 1528 18 ; ; : 19613 1528 19 example example NN 19613 1528 20 of of IN 19613 1528 21 the the DT 19613 1528 22 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 1528 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1528 24 to to TO 19613 1528 25 accept accept VB 19613 1528 26 the the DT 19613 1528 27 epistles epistle NNS 19613 1528 28 of of IN 19613 1528 29 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1528 30 . . . 19613 1529 1 But but CC 19613 1529 2 , , , 19613 1529 3 from from IN 19613 1529 4 the the DT 19613 1529 5 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1529 6 point point NN 19613 1529 7 of of IN 19613 1529 8 view view NN 19613 1529 9 , , , 19613 1529 10 a a DT 19613 1529 11 canon canon NN 19613 1529 12 which which WDT 19613 1529 13 comprised comprise VBD 19613 1529 14 only only RB 19613 1529 15 the the DT 19613 1529 16 four four CD 19613 1529 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1529 18 and and CC 19613 1529 19 the the DT 19613 1529 20 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1529 21 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1529 22 , , , 19613 1529 23 would would MD 19613 1529 24 have have VB 19613 1529 25 been be VBN 19613 1529 26 at at IN 19613 1529 27 best good JJS 19613 1529 28 an an DT 19613 1529 29 edifice edifice NN 19613 1529 30 of of IN 19613 1529 31 two two CD 19613 1529 32 wings wing NNS 19613 1529 33 without without IN 19613 1529 34 the the DT 19613 1529 35 central central JJ 19613 1529 36 structure structure NN 19613 1529 37 , , , 19613 1529 38 and and CC 19613 1529 39 therefore therefore RB 19613 1529 40 incomplete incomplete JJ 19613 1529 41 and and CC 19613 1529 42 uninhabitable uninhabitable JJ 19613 1529 43 . . . 19613 1530 1 The the DT 19613 1530 2 actual actual JJ 19613 1530 3 novelty novelty NN 19613 1530 4 was be VBD 19613 1530 5 the the DT 19613 1530 6 bold bold JJ 19613 1530 7 insertion insertion NN 19613 1530 8 into into IN 19613 1530 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1530 10 midst midst NN 19613 1530 11 of of IN 19613 1530 12 a a DT 19613 1530 13 book book NN 19613 1530 14 , , , 19613 1530 15 which which WDT 19613 1530 16 , , , 19613 1530 17 if if IN 19613 1530 18 everything everything NN 19613 1530 19 is be VBZ 19613 1530 20 not not RB 19613 1530 21 deceptive deceptive JJ 19613 1530 22 , , , 19613 1530 23 had have VBD 19613 1530 24 formerly formerly RB 19613 1530 25 been be VBN 19613 1530 26 only only RB 19613 1530 27 in in IN 19613 1530 28 private private JJ 19613 1530 29 use use NN 19613 1530 30 , , , 19613 1530 31 namely namely RB 19613 1530 32 , , , 19613 1530 33 the the DT 19613 1530 34 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1530 35 of of IN 19613 1530 36 the the DT 19613 1530 37 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1530 38 , , , 19613 1530 39 which which WDT 19613 1530 40 some some DT 19613 1530 41 associated associate VBD 19613 1530 42 with with IN 19613 1530 43 an an DT 19613 1530 44 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1530 45 of of IN 19613 1530 46 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1530 47 and and CC 19613 1530 48 an an DT 19613 1530 49 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1530 50 of of IN 19613 1530 51 John John NNP 19613 1530 52 , , , 19613 1530 53 others other NNS 19613 1530 54 with with IN 19613 1530 55 an an DT 19613 1530 56 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1530 57 of of IN 19613 1530 58 Jude Jude NNP 19613 1530 59 , , , 19613 1530 60 two two CD 19613 1530 61 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1530 62 of of IN 19613 1530 63 John John NNP 19613 1530 64 , , , 19613 1530 65 and and CC 19613 1530 66 the the DT 19613 1530 67 like like JJ 19613 1530 68 . . . 19613 1531 1 There there EX 19613 1531 2 were be VBD 19613 1531 3 now now RB 19613 1531 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1531 5 1 1 LS 19613 1531 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1531 7 writings writing NNS 19613 1531 8 of of IN 19613 1531 9 the the DT 19613 1531 10 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1531 11 which which WDT 19613 1531 12 were be VBD 19613 1531 13 at at IN 19613 1531 14 the the DT 19613 1531 15 same same JJ 19613 1531 16 time time NN 19613 1531 17 regarded regard VBD 19613 1531 18 as as IN 19613 1531 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1531 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1531 21 : : : 19613 1531 22 apomnêmoneumata apomnêmoneumata NN 19613 1531 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1531 24 of of IN 19613 1531 25 definite definite JJ 19613 1531 26 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1531 27 ; ; : 19613 1531 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1531 29 2 2 LS 19613 1531 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1531 31 a a DT 19613 1531 32 book book NN 19613 1531 33 which which WDT 19613 1531 34 contained contain VBD 19613 1531 35 the the DT 19613 1531 36 acts act NNS 19613 1531 37 and and CC 19613 1531 38 preaching preaching NN 19613 1531 39 of of IN 19613 1531 40 all all PDT 19613 1531 41 the the DT 19613 1531 42 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1531 43 , , , 19613 1531 44 which which WDT 19613 1531 45 historically historically RB 19613 1531 46 legitimised legitimise VBD 19613 1531 47 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1531 48 , , , 19613 1531 49 and and CC 19613 1531 50 at at IN 19613 1531 51 the the DT 19613 1531 52 same same JJ 19613 1531 53 time time NN 19613 1531 54 gave give VBD 19613 1531 55 hints hint NNS 19613 1531 56 for for IN 19613 1531 57 the the DT 19613 1531 58 explanation explanation NN 19613 1531 59 of of IN 19613 1531 60 " " `` 19613 1531 61 difficult difficult JJ 19613 1531 62 " " '' 19613 1531 63 passages passage NNS 19613 1531 64 in in IN 19613 1531 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1531 66 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1531 67 ; ; : 19613 1531 68 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1531 69 3 3 LS 19613 1531 70 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1531 71 the the DT 19613 1531 72 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1531 73 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1531 74 increased increase VBD 19613 1531 75 by by IN 19613 1531 76 the the DT 19613 1531 77 compilation compilation NN 19613 1531 78 of of IN 19613 1531 79 the the DT 19613 1531 80 Pastoral pastoral JJ 19613 1531 81 ones one NNS 19613 1531 82 , , , 19613 1531 83 documents document NNS 19613 1531 84 which which WDT 19613 1531 85 " " `` 19613 1531 86 in in IN 19613 1531 87 ordinatione ordinatione NNP 19613 1531 88 ecclesiasticæ ecclesiasticæ NNP 19613 1531 89 disciplinæ disciplinæ NNP 19613 1531 90 sanctificatæ sanctificatæ NNP 19613 1531 91 erant erant NNP 19613 1531 92 . . . 19613 1531 93 " " '' 19613 1532 1 The the DT 19613 1532 2 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1532 3 of of IN 19613 1532 4 the the DT 19613 1532 5 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1532 6 is be VBZ 19613 1532 7 thus thus RB 19613 1532 8 the the DT 19613 1532 9 key key NN 19613 1532 10 to to IN 19613 1532 11 the the DT 19613 1532 12 understanding understanding NN 19613 1532 13 of of IN 19613 1532 14 the the DT 19613 1532 15 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1532 16 canon canon NN 19613 1532 17 and and CC 19613 1532 18 at at IN 19613 1532 19 the the DT 19613 1532 20 same same JJ 19613 1532 21 time time NN 19613 1532 22 shows show VBZ 19613 1532 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1532 24 novelty novelty NN 19613 1532 25 . . . 19613 1533 1 In in IN 19613 1533 2 this this DT 19613 1533 3 book book NN 19613 1533 4 the the DT 19613 1533 5 new new JJ 19613 1533 6 collection collection NN 19613 1533 7 had have VBD 19613 1533 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1533 9 bond bond NN 19613 1533 10 of of IN 19613 1533 11 cohesion cohesion NN 19613 1533 12 , , , 19613 1533 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1533 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1533 15 element element NN 19613 1533 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1533 17 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1533 18 tradition tradition NNP 19613 1533 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1533 20 , , , 19613 1533 21 and and CC 19613 1533 22 the the DT 19613 1533 23 guide guide NN 19613 1533 24 for for IN 19613 1533 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1533 26 exposition exposition NN 19613 1533 27 . . . 19613 1534 1 That that IN 19613 1534 2 the the DT 19613 1534 3 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1534 4 of of IN 19613 1534 5 the the DT 19613 1534 6 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1534 7 found find VBD 19613 1534 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1534 9 place place NN 19613 1534 10 in in IN 19613 1534 11 the the DT 19613 1534 12 canon canon NNP 19613 1534 13 _ _ NNP 19613 1534 14 faute faute NN 19613 1534 15 de de FW 19613 1534 16 mieux mieux NNP 19613 1534 17 _ _ NNP 19613 1534 18 is be VBZ 19613 1534 19 clear clear JJ 19613 1534 20 from from IN 19613 1534 21 the the DT 19613 1534 22 extravagant extravagant JJ 19613 1534 23 terms term NNS 19613 1534 24 , , , 19613 1534 25 not not RB 19613 1534 26 at at RB 19613 1534 27 all all RB 19613 1534 28 suited suited JJ 19613 1534 29 to to IN 19613 1534 30 the the DT 19613 1534 31 book book NN 19613 1534 32 , , , 19613 1534 33 in in IN 19613 1534 34 which which WDT 19613 1534 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1534 36 appearance appearance NN 19613 1534 37 there there EX 19613 1534 38 is be VBZ 19613 1534 39 immediately immediately RB 19613 1534 40 hailed hail VBN 19613 1534 41 . . . 19613 1535 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1535 2 is be VBZ 19613 1535 3 inserted insert VBN 19613 1535 4 in in IN 19613 1535 5 place place NN 19613 1535 6 of of IN 19613 1535 7 a a DT 19613 1535 8 book book NN 19613 1535 9 which which WDT 19613 1535 10 should should MD 19613 1535 11 have have VB 19613 1535 12 contained contain VBN 19613 1535 13 the the DT 19613 1535 14 teaching teaching NN 19613 1535 15 and and CC 19613 1535 16 missionary missionary JJ 19613 1535 17 acts act NNS 19613 1535 18 of of IN 19613 1535 19 all all PDT 19613 1535 20 the the DT 19613 1535 21 12 12 CD 19613 1535 22 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1535 23 ; ; : 19613 1535 24 but but CC 19613 1535 25 , , , 19613 1535 26 as as IN 19613 1535 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1535 28 happened happen VBD 19613 1535 29 , , , 19613 1535 30 such such PDT 19613 1535 31 a a DT 19613 1535 32 record record NN 19613 1535 33 was be VBD 19613 1535 34 not not RB 19613 1535 35 in in IN 19613 1535 36 existence existence NN 19613 1535 37 . . . 19613 1536 1 The the DT 19613 1536 2 first first JJ 19613 1536 3 evidence evidence NN 19613 1536 4 regarding regard VBG 19613 1536 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1536 6 is be VBZ 19613 1536 7 found find VBN 19613 1536 8 in in IN 19613 1536 9 the the DT 19613 1536 10 Muratorian muratorian JJ 19613 1536 11 fragment fragment NN 19613 1536 12 and and CC 19613 1536 13 in in IN 19613 1536 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1536 15 and and CC 19613 1536 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1536 17 . . . 19613 1537 1 There there RB 19613 1537 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1537 3 is be VBZ 19613 1537 4 called call VBN 19613 1537 5 " " `` 19613 1537 6 acta acta NNP 19613 1537 7 omnium omnium NNP 19613 1537 8 apostolorum apostolorum NNP 19613 1537 9 sub sub NNP 19613 1537 10 uno uno NNP 19613 1537 11 libro libro NNP 19613 1537 12 scripta scripta NNP 19613 1537 13 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1537 14 , , , 19613 1537 15 etc etc FW 19613 1537 16 . . . 19613 1537 17 " " '' 19613 1538 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1538 2 says say VBZ 19613 1538 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1538 4 III iii CD 19613 1538 5 . . . 19613 1539 1 14 14 CD 19613 1539 2 . . . 19613 1540 1 1 1 LS 19613 1540 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1540 3 : : : 19613 1540 4 " " `` 19613 1540 5 Lucas Lucas NNP 19613 1540 6 non non NNP 19613 1540 7 solum solum NNP 19613 1540 8 prosecutor prosecutor NN 19613 1540 9 sed se VBD 19613 1540 10 et et NNP 19613 1540 11 cooperarius cooperarius NNP 19613 1540 12 fuit fuit NN 19613 1540 13 _ _ NNP 19613 1540 14 Apostolorum Apostolorum NNP 19613 1540 15 _ _ NNP 19613 1540 16 , , , 19613 1540 17 maxime maxime JJ 19613 1540 18 autem autem NN 19613 1540 19 Pauli Pauli NNP 19613 1540 20 , , , 19613 1540 21 " " '' 19613 1540 22 and and CC 19613 1540 23 makes make VBZ 19613 1540 24 use use NN 19613 1540 25 of of IN 19613 1540 26 the the DT 19613 1540 27 book book NN 19613 1540 28 to to TO 19613 1540 29 prove prove VB 19613 1540 30 the the DT 19613 1540 31 subordination subordination NN 19613 1540 32 of of IN 19613 1540 33 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1540 34 to to IN 19613 1540 35 the the DT 19613 1540 36 twelve twelve CD 19613 1540 37 . . . 19613 1541 1 In in IN 19613 1541 2 the the DT 19613 1541 3 celebrated celebrated JJ 19613 1541 4 passages passage NNS 19613 1541 5 , , , 19613 1541 6 de de NNP 19613 1541 7 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1541 8 . . . 19613 1542 1 22 22 CD 19613 1542 2 , , , 19613 1542 3 23 23 CD 19613 1542 4 : : : 19613 1542 5 adv adv NN 19613 1542 6 . . . 19613 1543 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 1543 2 . . . 19613 1544 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1545 1 20 20 CD 19613 1545 2 ; ; : 19613 1545 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1545 4 . . . 19613 1546 1 2 2 CD 19613 1546 2 - - SYM 19613 1546 3 5 5 CD 19613 1546 4 ; ; : 19613 1546 5 V. V. NNP 19613 1546 6 1 1 CD 19613 1546 7 - - SYM 19613 1546 8 3 3 CD 19613 1546 9 , , , 19613 1546 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1546 11 made make VBD 19613 1546 12 a a DT 19613 1546 13 still still RB 19613 1546 14 more more RBR 19613 1546 15 extensive extensive JJ 19613 1546 16 use use NN 19613 1546 17 of of IN 19613 1546 18 the the DT 19613 1546 19 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1546 20 of of IN 19613 1546 21 the the DT 19613 1546 22 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1546 23 , , , 19613 1546 24 as as IN 19613 1546 25 the the DT 19613 1546 26 Antimarcionite Antimarcionite NNP 19613 1546 27 book book NN 19613 1546 28 in in IN 19613 1546 29 the the DT 19613 1546 30 canon canon NN 19613 1546 31 . . . 19613 1547 1 One one PRP 19613 1547 2 can can MD 19613 1547 3 see see VB 19613 1547 4 here here RB 19613 1547 5 why why WRB 19613 1547 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1547 7 was be VBD 19613 1547 8 admitted admit VBN 19613 1547 9 into into IN 19613 1547 10 that that DT 19613 1547 11 collection collection NN 19613 1547 12 and and CC 19613 1547 13 used use VBN 19613 1547 14 against against IN 19613 1547 15 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1547 16 as as IN 19613 1547 17 the the DT 19613 1547 18 Apostle apostle NN 19613 1547 19 of of IN 19613 1547 20 the the DT 19613 1547 21 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1547 22 . . . 19613 1548 1 The the DT 19613 1548 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 1548 3 thought thought NN 19613 1548 4 of of IN 19613 1548 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1548 6 is be VBZ 19613 1548 7 that that IN 19613 1548 8 no no DT 19613 1548 9 one one NN 19613 1548 10 who who WP 19613 1548 11 fails fail VBZ 19613 1548 12 to to TO 19613 1548 13 recognise recognise VB 19613 1548 14 the the DT 19613 1548 15 Acts act NNS 19613 1548 16 of of IN 19613 1548 17 the the DT 19613 1548 18 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1548 19 has have VBZ 19613 1548 20 any any DT 19613 1548 21 right right NN 19613 1548 22 to to TO 19613 1548 23 recognise recognise VB 19613 1548 24 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1548 25 , , , 19613 1548 26 and and CC 19613 1548 27 that that IN 19613 1548 28 to to TO 19613 1548 29 elevate elevate VB 19613 1548 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1548 31 by by IN 19613 1548 32 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1548 33 into into IN 19613 1548 34 a a DT 19613 1548 35 position position NN 19613 1548 36 of of IN 19613 1548 37 authority authority NN 19613 1548 38 is be VBZ 19613 1548 39 unhistorical unhistorical JJ 19613 1548 40 and and CC 19613 1548 41 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 1548 42 unfounded unfounded JJ 19613 1548 43 fanaticism fanaticism NN 19613 1548 44 . . . 19613 1549 1 If if IN 19613 1549 2 the the DT 19613 1549 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1549 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1549 5 : : : 19613 1549 6 didachê didachê NNP 19613 1549 7 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1549 8 dôdeka dôdeka NNP 19613 1549 9 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1549 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1549 11 was be VBD 19613 1549 12 needed need VBN 19613 1549 13 as as IN 19613 1549 14 an an DT 19613 1549 15 authority authority NN 19613 1549 16 in in IN 19613 1549 17 the the DT 19613 1549 18 earlier early JJR 19613 1549 19 time time NN 19613 1549 20 , , , 19613 1549 21 a a DT 19613 1549 22 _ _ NNP 19613 1549 23 book book NN 19613 1549 24 _ _ NNP 19613 1549 25 which which WDT 19613 1549 26 contained contain VBD 19613 1549 27 that that IN 19613 1549 28 authority authority NN 19613 1549 29 was be VBD 19613 1549 30 required require VBN 19613 1549 31 in in IN 19613 1549 32 the the DT 19613 1549 33 later later JJ 19613 1549 34 period period NN 19613 1549 35 ; ; : 19613 1549 36 and and CC 19613 1549 37 nothing nothing NN 19613 1549 38 else else RB 19613 1549 39 could could MD 19613 1549 40 be be VB 19613 1549 41 found find VBN 19613 1549 42 than than IN 19613 1549 43 the the DT 19613 1549 44 work work NN 19613 1549 45 of of IN 19613 1549 46 the the DT 19613 1549 47 so so RB 19613 1549 48 - - HYPH 19613 1549 49 called call VBN 19613 1549 50 Luke Luke NNP 19613 1549 51 . . . 19613 1550 1 " " `` 19613 1550 2 Qui Qui NNP 19613 1550 3 Acta Acta NNP 19613 1550 4 Apostolorum Apostolorum NNP 19613 1550 5 non non JJ 19613 1550 6 recipiunt recipiunt NNP 19613 1550 7 , , , 19613 1550 8 nec nec NNP 19613 1550 9 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 1550 10 sancti sancti NNP 19613 1550 11 esse esse NNP 19613 1550 12 possunt possunt NNP 19613 1550 13 , , , 19613 1550 14 qui qui NNP 19613 1550 15 necdum necdum NNP 19613 1550 16 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 1550 17 sanctum sanctum NNP 19613 1550 18 possunt possunt NNP 19613 1550 19 agnoscere agnoscere NNP 19613 1550 20 discentibus discentibus NNP 19613 1550 21 missum missum NNP 19613 1550 22 , , , 19613 1550 23 sed sed NNP 19613 1550 24 nec nec NNP 19613 1550 25 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 1550 26 se se FW 19613 1550 27 dicant dicant JJ 19613 1550 28 defendere defendere NNP 19613 1550 29 qui qui NNP 19613 1550 30 quando quando NNP 19613 1550 31 et et NNP 19613 1550 32 quibus quibus NNP 19613 1550 33 incunabulis incunabulis NNP 19613 1550 34 institutum institutum NNP 19613 1550 35 est est NNP 19613 1550 36 hoc hoc FW 19613 1550 37 corpus corpus NNP 19613 1550 38 probare probare NNP 19613 1550 39 non non AFX 19613 1550 40 habent habent NNP 19613 1550 41 . . . 19613 1550 42 " " '' 19613 1551 1 But but CC 19613 1551 2 the the DT 19613 1551 3 greater great JJR 19613 1551 4 part part NN 19613 1551 5 of of IN 19613 1551 6 the the DT 19613 1551 7 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1551 8 remained remain VBD 19613 1551 9 obstinate obstinate NN 19613 1551 10 . . . 19613 1552 1 Neither neither DT 19613 1552 2 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 1552 3 , , , 19613 1552 4 Severians Severians NNPS 19613 1552 5 , , , 19613 1552 6 nor nor CC 19613 1552 7 the the DT 19613 1552 8 later later JJ 19613 1552 9 Manicheans Manicheans NNPS 19613 1552 10 recognised recognise VBD 19613 1552 11 the the DT 19613 1552 12 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1552 13 of of IN 19613 1552 14 the the DT 19613 1552 15 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1552 16 . . . 19613 1553 1 To to IN 19613 1553 2 some some DT 19613 1553 3 extent extent NN 19613 1553 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1553 5 replied reply VBD 19613 1553 6 by by IN 19613 1553 7 setting set VBG 19613 1553 8 up up RP 19613 1553 9 other other JJ 19613 1553 10 histories history NNS 19613 1553 11 of of IN 19613 1553 12 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1553 13 in in IN 19613 1553 14 opposition opposition NN 19613 1553 15 to to IN 19613 1553 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1553 17 , , , 19613 1553 18 as as IN 19613 1553 19 was be VBD 19613 1553 20 done do VBN 19613 1553 21 later later RB 19613 1553 22 by by IN 19613 1553 23 a a DT 19613 1553 24 fraction fraction NN 19613 1553 25 of of IN 19613 1553 26 the the DT 19613 1553 27 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 19613 1553 28 and and CC 19613 1553 29 even even RB 19613 1553 30 by by IN 19613 1553 31 the the DT 19613 1553 32 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 1553 33 . . . 19613 1554 1 But but CC 19613 1554 2 the the DT 19613 1554 3 Church Church NNP 19613 1554 4 also also RB 19613 1554 5 was be VBD 19613 1554 6 firm firm JJ 19613 1554 7 . . . 19613 1555 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1555 2 is be VBZ 19613 1555 3 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1555 4 the the DT 19613 1555 5 most most RBS 19613 1555 6 striking striking JJ 19613 1555 7 phenomenon phenomenon NN 19613 1555 8 in in IN 19613 1555 9 the the DT 19613 1555 10 history history NN 19613 1555 11 of of IN 19613 1555 12 the the DT 19613 1555 13 formation formation NN 19613 1555 14 of of IN 19613 1555 15 the the DT 19613 1555 16 canon canon NN 19613 1555 17 that that IN 19613 1555 18 this this DT 19613 1555 19 late late JJ 19613 1555 20 book book NN 19613 1555 21 , , , 19613 1555 22 from from IN 19613 1555 23 the the DT 19613 1555 24 very very JJ 19613 1555 25 moment moment NN 19613 1555 26 of of IN 19613 1555 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1555 28 appearance appearance NN 19613 1555 29 , , , 19613 1555 30 asserts assert VBZ 19613 1555 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1555 32 right right NN 19613 1555 33 to to IN 19613 1555 34 a a DT 19613 1555 35 place place NN 19613 1555 36 in in IN 19613 1555 37 the the DT 19613 1555 38 collection collection NN 19613 1555 39 , , , 19613 1555 40 just just RB 19613 1555 41 as as RB 19613 1555 42 certainly certainly RB 19613 1555 43 as as IN 19613 1555 44 the the DT 19613 1555 45 four four CD 19613 1555 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1555 47 , , , 19613 1555 48 though though IN 19613 1555 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1555 50 position position NN 19613 1555 51 varied vary VBD 19613 1555 52 . . . 19613 1556 1 In in IN 19613 1556 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1556 3 of of IN 19613 1556 4 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1556 5 indeed indeed RB 19613 1556 6 the the DT 19613 1556 7 book book NN 19613 1556 8 is be VBZ 19613 1556 9 still still RB 19613 1556 10 pretty pretty RB 19613 1556 11 much much RB 19613 1556 12 in in IN 19613 1556 13 the the DT 19613 1556 14 background background NN 19613 1556 15 , , , 19613 1556 16 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1556 17 on on IN 19613 1556 18 a a DT 19613 1556 19 level level NN 19613 1556 20 with with IN 19613 1556 21 the the DT 19613 1556 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1556 23 Greek greek JJ 19613 1556 24 : : : 19613 1556 25 kêrugma kêrugma NNP 19613 1556 26 Petrou Petrou NNP 19613 1556 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1556 28 , , , 19613 1556 29 but but CC 19613 1556 30 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1556 31 has have VBZ 19613 1556 32 no no DT 19613 1556 33 New New NNP 19613 1556 34 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1556 35 at at RB 19613 1556 36 all all RB 19613 1556 37 in in IN 19613 1556 38 the the DT 19613 1556 39 strict strict JJ 19613 1556 40 sense sense NN 19613 1556 41 of of IN 19613 1556 42 the the DT 19613 1556 43 word word NN 19613 1556 44 ; ; : 19613 1556 45 see see VB 19613 1556 46 below below RB 19613 1556 47 . . . 19613 1557 1 But but CC 19613 1557 2 at at IN 19613 1557 3 the the DT 19613 1557 4 very very RB 19613 1557 5 beginning begin VBG 19613 1557 6 the the DT 19613 1557 7 book book NN 19613 1557 8 stood stand VBD 19613 1557 9 where where WRB 19613 1557 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1557 11 is be VBZ 19613 1557 12 to to IN 19613 1557 13 - - HYPH 19613 1557 14 day day NN 19613 1557 15 , , , 19613 1557 16 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 1557 17 , , , 19613 1557 18 immediately immediately RB 19613 1557 19 after after IN 19613 1557 20 the the DT 19613 1557 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1557 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1557 23 see see VB 19613 1557 24 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1557 25 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1557 26 , , , 19613 1557 27 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1557 28 , , , 19613 1557 29 etc etc FW 19613 1557 30 . . . 19613 1557 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1557 32 . . . 19613 1558 1 The the DT 19613 1558 2 parallel parallel JJ 19613 1558 3 creation creation NN 19613 1558 4 , , , 19613 1558 5 the the DT 19613 1558 6 group group NN 19613 1558 7 of of IN 19613 1558 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1558 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1558 10 , , , 19613 1558 11 acquired acquire VBD 19613 1558 12 a a DT 19613 1558 13 much much RB 19613 1558 14 more more RBR 19613 1558 15 dubious dubious JJ 19613 1558 16 position position NN 19613 1558 17 than than IN 19613 1558 18 the the DT 19613 1558 19 Acts act NNS 19613 1558 20 of of IN 19613 1558 21 the the DT 19613 1558 22 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1558 23 , , , 19613 1558 24 and and CC 19613 1558 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1558 26 place place NN 19613 1558 27 was be VBD 19613 1558 28 never never RB 19613 1558 29 really really RB 19613 1558 30 settled settle VBN 19613 1558 31 . . . 19613 1559 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1559 2 germ germ NN 19613 1559 3 is be VBZ 19613 1559 4 probably probably RB 19613 1559 5 to to TO 19613 1559 6 be be VB 19613 1559 7 found find VBN 19613 1559 8 in in IN 19613 1559 9 two two CD 19613 1559 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1559 11 of of IN 19613 1559 12 John John NNP 19613 1559 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1559 14 viz viz NNP 19613 1559 15 . . NNP 19613 1559 16 , , , 19613 1559 17 1st 1st NNP 19613 1559 18 and and CC 19613 1559 19 3rd 3rd NNP 19613 1559 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1559 21 which which WDT 19613 1559 22 acquired acquire VBD 19613 1559 23 dignity dignity NN 19613 1559 24 along along IN 19613 1559 25 with with IN 19613 1559 26 the the DT 19613 1559 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1559 28 , , , 19613 1559 29 as as RB 19613 1559 30 well well RB 19613 1559 31 as as IN 19613 1559 32 in in IN 19613 1559 33 the the DT 19613 1559 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1559 35 of of IN 19613 1559 36 Jude Jude NNP 19613 1559 37 . . . 19613 1560 1 These these DT 19613 1560 2 may may MD 19613 1560 3 have have VB 19613 1560 4 given give VBN 19613 1560 5 the the DT 19613 1560 6 impulse impulse NN 19613 1560 7 to to TO 19613 1560 8 create create VB 19613 1560 9 a a DT 19613 1560 10 group group NN 19613 1560 11 of of IN 19613 1560 12 narratives narrative NNS 19613 1560 13 about about IN 19613 1560 14 the the DT 19613 1560 15 twelve twelve CD 19613 1560 16 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1560 17 from from IN 19613 1560 18 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 1560 19 writings writing NNS 19613 1560 20 of of IN 19613 1560 21 old old JJ 19613 1560 22 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1560 23 , , , 19613 1560 24 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1560 25 , , , 19613 1560 26 and and CC 19613 1560 27 teachers teacher NNS 19613 1560 28 . . . 19613 1561 1 But but CC 19613 1561 2 the the DT 19613 1561 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1561 4 of of IN 19613 1561 5 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1561 6 is be VBZ 19613 1561 7 still still RB 19613 1561 8 wanting want VBG 19613 1561 9 in in IN 19613 1561 10 the the DT 19613 1561 11 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1561 12 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1561 13 , , , 19613 1561 14 nor nor CC 19613 1561 15 do do VBP 19613 1561 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1561 17 yet yet RB 19613 1561 18 find find VB 19613 1561 19 the the DT 19613 1561 20 group group NN 19613 1561 21 there there RB 19613 1561 22 associated associate VBN 19613 1561 23 with with IN 19613 1561 24 the the DT 19613 1561 25 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1561 26 of of IN 19613 1561 27 the the DT 19613 1561 28 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1561 29 . . . 19613 1562 1 The the DT 19613 1562 2 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1562 3 of of IN 19613 1562 4 Jude Jude NNP 19613 1562 5 , , , 19613 1562 6 two two CD 19613 1562 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1562 8 of of IN 19613 1562 9 John John NNP 19613 1562 10 , , , 19613 1562 11 the the DT 19613 1562 12 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 19613 1562 13 of of IN 19613 1562 14 Solomon Solomon NNP 19613 1562 15 , , , 19613 1562 16 the the DT 19613 1562 17 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 1562 18 of of IN 19613 1562 19 John John NNP 19613 1562 20 and and CC 19613 1562 21 that that DT 19613 1562 22 of of IN 19613 1562 23 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1562 24 form form VB 19613 1562 25 the the DT 19613 1562 26 unsymmetrical unsymmetrical JJ 19613 1562 27 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 1562 28 of of IN 19613 1562 29 this this DT 19613 1562 30 oldest old JJS 19613 1562 31 catalogue catalogue NN 19613 1562 32 of of IN 19613 1562 33 the the DT 19613 1562 34 canon canon NN 19613 1562 35 . . . 19613 1563 1 But but CC 19613 1563 2 , , , 19613 1563 3 all all PDT 19613 1563 4 the the DT 19613 1563 5 same same JJ 19613 1563 6 writings writing NNS 19613 1563 7 , , , 19613 1563 8 by by IN 19613 1563 9 Jude Jude NNP 19613 1563 10 , , , 19613 1563 11 John John NNP 19613 1563 12 , , , 19613 1563 13 and and CC 19613 1563 14 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1563 15 are be VBP 19613 1563 16 here here RB 19613 1563 17 found find VBN 19613 1563 18 side side NN 19613 1563 19 by by IN 19613 1563 20 side side NN 19613 1563 21 ; ; : 19613 1563 22 thus thus RB 19613 1563 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1563 24 have have VBP 19613 1563 25 a a DT 19613 1563 26 preparation preparation NN 19613 1563 27 for for IN 19613 1563 28 the the DT 19613 1563 29 future future JJ 19613 1563 30 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 1563 31 made make VBN 19613 1563 32 in in IN 19613 1563 33 different different JJ 19613 1563 34 though though IN 19613 1563 35 similar similar JJ 19613 1563 36 fashion fashion NN 19613 1563 37 by by IN 19613 1563 38 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1563 39 and and CC 19613 1563 40 again again RB 19613 1563 41 altered alter VBN 19613 1563 42 by by IN 19613 1563 43 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1563 44 . . . 19613 1564 1 The the DT 19613 1564 2 genuine genuine JJ 19613 1564 3 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1564 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1564 5 appear appear VBP 19613 1564 6 enclosed enclose VBN 19613 1564 7 on on IN 19613 1564 8 the the DT 19613 1564 9 one one CD 19613 1564 10 hand hand NN 19613 1564 11 by by IN 19613 1564 12 the the DT 19613 1564 13 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1564 14 of of IN 19613 1564 15 the the DT 19613 1564 16 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1564 17 and and CC 19613 1564 18 the the DT 19613 1564 19 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1564 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1564 21 , , , 19613 1564 22 and and CC 19613 1564 23 on on IN 19613 1564 24 the the DT 19613 1564 25 other other JJ 19613 1564 26 by by IN 19613 1564 27 the the DT 19613 1564 28 Pastoral pastoral JJ 19613 1564 29 ones one NNS 19613 1564 30 , , , 19613 1564 31 which which WDT 19613 1564 32 in in IN 19613 1564 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1564 34 way way NN 19613 1564 35 are be VBP 19613 1564 36 also also RB 19613 1564 37 " " `` 19613 1564 38 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1564 39 . . . 19613 1564 40 " " '' 19613 1565 1 That that DT 19613 1565 2 is be VBZ 19613 1565 3 the the DT 19613 1565 4 character character NN 19613 1565 5 of of IN 19613 1565 6 the the DT 19613 1565 7 " " `` 19613 1565 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1565 9 " " '' 19613 1565 10 New New NNP 19613 1565 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1565 12 which which WDT 19613 1565 13 is be VBZ 19613 1565 14 confirmed confirm VBN 19613 1565 15 by by IN 19613 1565 16 the the DT 19613 1565 17 earliest early JJS 19613 1565 18 use use NN 19613 1565 19 of of IN 19613 1565 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1565 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1565 22 in in IN 19613 1565 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1565 24 and and CC 19613 1565 25 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1565 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1565 27 . . . 19613 1566 1 In in IN 19613 1566 2 speaking speak VBG 19613 1566 3 above above RB 19613 1566 4 of of IN 19613 1566 5 the the DT 19613 1566 6 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1566 7 of of IN 19613 1566 8 the the DT 19613 1566 9 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1566 10 as as IN 19613 1566 11 a a DT 19613 1566 12 late late JJ 19613 1566 13 book book NN 19613 1566 14 , , , 19613 1566 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1566 16 meant mean VBD 19613 1566 17 that that IN 19613 1566 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1566 19 was be VBD 19613 1566 20 so so RB 19613 1566 21 relatively relatively RB 19613 1566 22 to to IN 19613 1566 23 the the DT 19613 1566 24 canon canon NN 19613 1566 25 . . . 19613 1567 1 In in IN 19613 1567 2 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1567 3 the the DT 19613 1567 4 book book NN 19613 1567 5 is be VBZ 19613 1567 6 old old JJ 19613 1567 7 and and CC 19613 1567 8 for for IN 19613 1567 9 the the DT 19613 1567 10 most most JJS 19613 1567 11 part part NN 19613 1567 12 reliable reliable JJ 19613 1567 13 . . . 19613 1567 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1568 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1568 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1568 3 95 95 CD 19613 1568 4 : : : 19613 1568 5 There there EX 19613 1568 6 is be VBZ 19613 1568 7 no no DT 19613 1568 8 doubt doubt NN 19613 1568 9 that that IN 19613 1568 10 this this DT 19613 1568 11 was be VBD 19613 1568 12 the the DT 19613 1568 13 reason reason NN 19613 1568 14 why why WRB 19613 1568 15 to to IN 19613 1568 16 all all DT 19613 1568 17 appearance appearance VB 19613 1568 18 the the DT 19613 1568 19 innovation innovation NN 19613 1568 20 was be VBD 19613 1568 21 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 1568 22 felt feel VBN 19613 1568 23 . . . 19613 1569 1 Similar similar JJ 19613 1569 2 causes cause NNS 19613 1569 3 were be VBD 19613 1569 4 at at IN 19613 1569 5 work work NN 19613 1569 6 here here RB 19613 1569 7 as as IN 19613 1569 8 in in IN 19613 1569 9 the the DT 19613 1569 10 case case NN 19613 1569 11 of of IN 19613 1569 12 the the DT 19613 1569 13 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1569 14 rule rule NN 19613 1569 15 of of IN 19613 1569 16 faith faith NN 19613 1569 17 . . . 19613 1570 1 In in IN 19613 1570 2 the the DT 19613 1570 3 one one CD 19613 1570 4 case case NN 19613 1570 5 the the DT 19613 1570 6 writings writing NNS 19613 1570 7 that that WDT 19613 1570 8 had have VBD 19613 1570 9 long long RB 19613 1570 10 been be VBN 19613 1570 11 read read VBN 19613 1570 12 in in IN 19613 1570 13 the the DT 19613 1570 14 Church Church NNP 19613 1570 15 formed form VBD 19613 1570 16 the the DT 19613 1570 17 basis basis NN 19613 1570 18 , , , 19613 1570 19 in in IN 19613 1570 20 the the DT 19613 1570 21 other other JJ 19613 1570 22 the the DT 19613 1570 23 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1570 24 confession confession NN 19613 1570 25 . . . 19613 1571 1 But but CC 19613 1571 2 a a DT 19613 1571 3 great great JJ 19613 1571 4 distinction distinction NN 19613 1571 5 is be VBZ 19613 1571 6 found find VBN 19613 1571 7 in in IN 19613 1571 8 the the DT 19613 1571 9 fact fact NN 19613 1571 10 that that IN 19613 1571 11 the the DT 19613 1571 12 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1571 13 confession confession NN 19613 1571 14 , , , 19613 1571 15 as as IN 19613 1571 16 already already RB 19613 1571 17 settled settle VBN 19613 1571 18 , , , 19613 1571 19 afforded afford VBD 19613 1571 20 an an DT 19613 1571 21 elastic elastic JJ 19613 1571 22 standard standard NN 19613 1571 23 which which WDT 19613 1571 24 was be VBD 19613 1571 25 treated treat VBN 19613 1571 26 as as IN 19613 1571 27 a a DT 19613 1571 28 fixed fix VBN 19613 1571 29 one one NN 19613 1571 30 and and CC 19613 1571 31 was be VBD 19613 1571 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 1571 33 extremely extremely RB 19613 1571 34 practical practical JJ 19613 1571 35 ; ; : 19613 1571 36 whilst whilst RB 19613 1571 37 , , , 19613 1571 38 conversely conversely RB 19613 1571 39 , , , 19613 1571 40 the the DT 19613 1571 41 undefined undefined JJ 19613 1571 42 group group NN 19613 1571 43 of of IN 19613 1571 44 writings writing NNS 19613 1571 45 hitherto hitherto NNP 19613 1571 46 read read VBD 19613 1571 47 in in IN 19613 1571 48 the the DT 19613 1571 49 Church Church NNP 19613 1571 50 was be VBD 19613 1571 51 reduced reduce VBN 19613 1571 52 to to IN 19613 1571 53 a a DT 19613 1571 54 collection collection NN 19613 1571 55 which which WDT 19613 1571 56 could could MD 19613 1571 57 neither neither CC 19613 1571 58 be be VB 19613 1571 59 increased increase VBN 19613 1571 60 nor nor CC 19613 1571 61 diminished diminish VBN 19613 1571 62 . . . 19613 1571 63 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1572 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1572 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1572 3 96 96 CD 19613 1572 4 : : : 19613 1572 5 At at IN 19613 1572 6 the the DT 19613 1572 7 beginning beginning NN 19613 1572 8 , , , 19613 1572 9 that that DT 19613 1572 10 is be VBZ 19613 1572 11 about about RB 19613 1572 12 180 180 CD 19613 1572 13 , , , 19613 1572 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1572 15 was be VBD 19613 1572 16 only only RB 19613 1572 17 in in IN 19613 1572 18 practice practice NN 19613 1572 19 , , , 19613 1572 20 and and CC 19613 1572 21 not not RB 19613 1572 22 in in IN 19613 1572 23 theory theory NN 19613 1572 24 , , , 19613 1572 25 that that IN 19613 1572 26 the the DT 19613 1572 27 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1572 28 and and CC 19613 1572 29 the the DT 19613 1572 30 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1572 31 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1572 32 possessed possess VBD 19613 1572 33 equal equal JJ 19613 1572 34 authority authority NN 19613 1572 35 . . . 19613 1573 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 1573 2 , , , 19613 1573 3 the the DT 19613 1573 4 name name NN 19613 1573 5 New New NNP 19613 1573 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1573 7 is be VBZ 19613 1573 8 not not RB 19613 1573 9 yet yet RB 19613 1573 10 found find VBN 19613 1573 11 in in IN 19613 1573 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1573 13 , , , 19613 1573 14 nor nor CC 19613 1573 15 do do VBP 19613 1573 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1573 17 yet yet RB 19613 1573 18 find find VB 19613 1573 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1573 20 giving give VBG 19613 1573 21 an an DT 19613 1573 22 exact exact JJ 19613 1573 23 idea idea NN 19613 1573 24 of of IN 19613 1573 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1573 26 content content NN 19613 1573 27 . . . 19613 1574 1 See see VB 19613 1574 2 Werner Werner NNP 19613 1574 3 in in IN 19613 1574 4 the the DT 19613 1574 5 Text Text NNP 19613 1574 6 . . . 19613 1575 1 u. u. NNP 19613 1575 2 Unters Unters NNP 19613 1575 3 . . . 19613 1576 1 z. z. NNP 19613 1576 2 altchristl altchristl NNP 19613 1576 3 . . . 19613 1577 1 Lit Lit NNP 19613 1577 2 . . . 19613 1578 1 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1578 2 . . . 19613 1579 1 Bd Bd NNP 19613 1579 2 . . . 19613 1580 1 VI VI NNP 19613 1580 2 . . . 19613 1581 1 2 2 LS 19613 1581 2 . . . 19613 1581 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1582 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1582 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1582 3 97 97 CD 19613 1582 4 : : : 19613 1582 5 See see VB 19613 1582 6 above above RB 19613 1582 7 , , , 19613 1582 8 p. p. NN 19613 1582 9 40 40 CD 19613 1582 10 , , , 19613 1582 11 note note VBP 19613 1582 12 2 2 CD 19613 1582 13 . . . 19613 1582 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1583 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1583 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1583 3 98 98 CD 19613 1583 4 : : : 19613 1583 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1583 6 have have VBP 19613 1583 7 ample ample JJ 19613 1583 8 evidence evidence NN 19613 1583 9 in in IN 19613 1583 10 the the DT 19613 1583 11 great great JJ 19613 1583 12 work work NN 19613 1583 13 of of IN 19613 1583 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1583 15 as as IN 19613 1583 16 to to IN 19613 1583 17 the the DT 19613 1583 18 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 1583 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1583 20 found find VBD 19613 1583 21 in in IN 19613 1583 22 many many JJ 19613 1583 23 passages passage NNS 19613 1583 24 of of IN 19613 1583 25 the the DT 19613 1583 26 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1583 27 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1583 28 , , , 19613 1583 29 which which WDT 19613 1583 30 as as IN 19613 1583 31 yet yet RB 19613 1583 32 were be VBD 19613 1583 33 almost almost RB 19613 1583 34 solely solely RB 19613 1583 35 utilised utilise VBN 19613 1583 36 as as IN 19613 1583 37 sources source NNS 19613 1583 38 of of IN 19613 1583 39 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 1583 40 by by IN 19613 1583 41 such such JJ 19613 1583 42 men man NNS 19613 1583 43 as as IN 19613 1583 44 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 1583 45 , , , 19613 1583 46 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 1583 47 , , , 19613 1583 48 and and CC 19613 1583 49 theologians theologian NNS 19613 1583 50 of of IN 19613 1583 51 the the DT 19613 1583 52 school school NN 19613 1583 53 of of IN 19613 1583 54 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 1583 55 . . . 19613 1584 1 The the DT 19613 1584 2 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 1584 3 of of IN 19613 1584 4 course course NN 19613 1584 5 still still RB 19613 1584 6 continued continue VBD 19613 1584 7 to to TO 19613 1584 8 be be VB 19613 1584 9 felt feel VBN 19613 1584 10 in in IN 19613 1584 11 the the DT 19613 1584 12 period period NN 19613 1584 13 which which WDT 19613 1584 14 followed follow VBD 19613 1584 15 . . . 19613 1585 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1585 2 See see VB 19613 1585 3 , , , 19613 1585 4 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 1585 5 , , , 19613 1585 6 Method Method NNP 19613 1585 7 , , , 19613 1585 8 Conviv Conviv NNP 19613 1585 9 . . . 19613 1586 1 Orat Orat NNP 19613 1586 2 . . . 19613 1587 1 III iii CD 19613 1587 2 . . . 19613 1588 1 1 1 CD 19613 1588 2 , , , 19613 1588 3 2 2 CD 19613 1588 4 . . . 19613 1588 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1588 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1589 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1589 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1589 3 99 99 CD 19613 1589 4 : : : 19613 1589 5 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 19613 1589 6 of of IN 19613 1589 7 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 19613 1589 8 already already RB 19613 1589 9 regards regard VBZ 19613 1589 10 any any DT 19613 1589 11 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 1589 12 between between IN 19613 1589 13 the the DT 19613 1589 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1589 15 4 4 CD 19613 1589 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1589 17 Gospels gospel NNS 19613 1589 18 as as IN 19613 1589 19 impossible impossible JJ 19613 1589 20 . . . 19613 1590 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1590 2 See see VB 19613 1590 3 Routh Routh NNP 19613 1590 4 , , , 19613 1590 5 Reliq Reliq NNP 19613 1590 6 . . . 19613 1591 1 Sacr Sacr NNP 19613 1591 2 . . . 19613 1592 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1592 2 p. p. NN 19613 1593 1 150 150 CD 19613 1593 2 . . . 19613 1593 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1593 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1594 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1594 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1594 3 100 100 CD 19613 1594 4 : : : 19613 1594 5 See see VB 19613 1594 6 Overbeck overbeck NN 19613 1594 7 , , , 19613 1594 8 " " '' 19613 1594 9 Ueber Ueber NNP 19613 1594 10 die die NN 19613 1594 11 Auffassung Auffassung NNP 19613 1594 12 des des FW 19613 1594 13 Streites Streites NNP 19613 1594 14 des des NNP 19613 1594 15 Paulus Paulus NNP 19613 1594 16 mit mit VB 19613 1594 17 Petrus Petrus NNP 19613 1594 18 in in IN 19613 1594 19 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 19613 1594 20 bei bei NNP 19613 1594 21 den den NN 19613 1594 22 Kirchenvätern Kirchenvätern NNP 19613 1594 23 , , , 19613 1594 24 " " '' 19613 1594 25 1877 1877 CD 19613 1594 26 , , , 19613 1594 27 p. p. NN 19613 1595 1 8 8 LS 19613 1595 2 . . . 19613 1595 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1596 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1596 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1596 3 101 101 CD 19613 1596 4 : : : 19613 1596 5 See see VB 19613 1596 6 also also RB 19613 1596 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1596 8 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1596 9 . . . 19613 1597 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1597 2 . . . 19613 1598 1 21 21 CD 19613 1598 2 . . . 19613 1599 1 124 124 CD 19613 1599 2 ; ; : 19613 1599 3 VI VI NNP 19613 1599 4 . . . 19613 1600 1 15 15 CD 19613 1600 2 . . . 19613 1601 1 125 125 CD 19613 1601 2 . . . 19613 1602 1 The the DT 19613 1602 2 expression expression NN 19613 1602 3 is be VBZ 19613 1602 4 also also RB 19613 1602 5 frequent frequent JJ 19613 1602 6 in in IN 19613 1602 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1602 8 , , , 19613 1602 9 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 1602 10 , , , 19613 1602 11 de de FW 19613 1602 12 princip princip RB 19613 1602 13 . . . 19613 1603 1 præf præf NNP 19613 1603 2 . . . 19613 1604 1 4 4 LS 19613 1604 2 . . . 19613 1604 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1605 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1605 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1605 3 102 102 CD 19613 1605 4 : : : 19613 1605 5 The the DT 19613 1605 6 Roman Roman NNP 19613 1605 7 Church Church NNP 19613 1605 8 in in IN 19613 1605 9 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1605 10 letter letter NN 19613 1605 11 to to IN 19613 1605 12 that that DT 19613 1605 13 of of IN 19613 1605 14 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 1605 15 designates designate VBZ 19613 1605 16 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1605 17 own own JJ 19613 1605 18 words word NNS 19613 1605 19 as as IN 19613 1605 20 the the DT 19613 1605 21 words word NNS 19613 1605 22 of of IN 19613 1605 23 God God NNP 19613 1605 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1605 25 1 1 CD 19613 1605 26 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1605 27 . . . 19613 1606 1 LIX lix UH 19613 1606 2 . . . 19613 1607 1 1 1 LS 19613 1607 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1607 3 and and CC 19613 1607 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 1607 5 requires require VBZ 19613 1607 6 obedience obedience NN 19613 1607 7 " " '' 19613 1607 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1607 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1607 10 : : : 19613 1607 11 tois tois NNP 19613 1607 12 huph huph NNP 19613 1607 13 ' ' '' 19613 1607 14 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 1607 15 gegrammenois gegrammenois NNP 19613 1607 16 dia dia NNP 19613 1607 17 tou tou NNP 19613 1607 18 hagiou hagiou NNP 19613 1607 19 pneumatos pneumatos NNP 19613 1607 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1607 21 " " '' 19613 1607 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1607 23 LXIII LXIII NNP 19613 1607 24 . . . 19613 1608 1 2 2 LS 19613 1608 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1608 3 . . . 19613 1608 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1609 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1609 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1609 3 103 103 CD 19613 1609 4 : : : 19613 1609 5 Tertull tertull JJ 19613 1609 6 . . . 19613 1610 1 de de FW 19613 1610 2 exhort exhort NNP 19613 1610 3 . . . 19613 1611 1 4 4 LS 19613 1611 2 : : : 19613 1611 3 " " `` 19613 1611 4 Spiritum Spiritum NNP 19613 1611 5 quidem quidem NN 19613 1611 6 dei dei NNP 19613 1611 7 etiam etiam NNP 19613 1611 8 fideles fideles NNPS 19613 1611 9 habent habent NNP 19613 1611 10 , , , 19613 1611 11 sed se VBD 19613 1611 12 non non NNP 19613 1611 13 omnes omne NNS 19613 1611 14 fideles fidele NNS 19613 1611 15 apostoli apostoli JJ 19613 1611 16 ... ... : 19613 1611 17 Proprie Proprie NNP 19613 1611 18 enim enim NNP 19613 1611 19 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1611 20 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 1611 21 sanctum sanctum NNP 19613 1611 22 habent habent NNP 19613 1611 23 , , , 19613 1611 24 qui qui NNP 19613 1611 25 plene plene JJ 19613 1611 26 habent habent NN 19613 1611 27 in in IN 19613 1611 28 operibus operibus NNP 19613 1611 29 prophetiæ prophetiæ NNP 19613 1611 30 et et NNP 19613 1611 31 efficacia efficacia NNP 19613 1611 32 virtutum virtutum NNP 19613 1611 33 documentisque documentisque NNP 19613 1611 34 linguarum linguarum NNP 19613 1611 35 , , , 19613 1611 36 non non AFX 19613 1611 37 ex ex NNP 19613 1611 38 parte parte NNP 19613 1611 39 , , , 19613 1611 40 quod quod NNP 19613 1611 41 ceteri ceteri NNP 19613 1611 42 . . . 19613 1611 43 " " '' 19613 1612 1 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1612 2 . . . 19613 1613 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 1613 2 . . . 19613 1614 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1614 2 . . . 19613 1615 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1615 2 . . . 19613 1616 1 21 21 CD 19613 1616 2 . . . 19613 1617 1 135 135 CD 19613 1617 2 : : : 19613 1617 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1617 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1617 5 : : : 19613 1617 6 Hekastos Hekastos NNP 19613 1617 7 idion idion NN 19613 1617 8 echei echei NNP 19613 1617 9 charisma charisma NNP 19613 1617 10 apo apo NNP 19613 1617 11 theou theou NNP 19613 1617 12 , , , 19613 1617 13 ho ho NNP 19613 1617 14 men man NNS 19613 1617 15 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 1617 16 , , , 19613 1617 17 ho ho NNP 19613 1617 18 de de NNP 19613 1617 19 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 1617 20 , , , 19613 1617 21 hoi hoi NNP 19613 1617 22 apostoloi apostoloi JJ 19613 1617 23 de de FW 19613 1617 24 en en FW 19613 1617 25 pasi pasi NN 19613 1617 26 peplêromenoi peplêromenoi NNS 19613 1617 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1617 28 ; ; : 19613 1617 29 Serapion Serapion NNP 19613 1617 30 in in IN 19613 1617 31 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1617 32 . . NNP 19613 1617 33 , , , 19613 1617 34 H. H. NNP 19613 1617 35 E. E. NNP 19613 1617 36 VI VI NNP 19613 1617 37 . . . 19613 1618 1 12 12 CD 19613 1618 2 . . . 19613 1619 1 3 3 LS 19613 1619 2 : : : 19613 1619 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1619 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1619 5 : : : 19613 1619 6 hêmeis hêmeis NNP 19613 1619 7 kai kai NNP 19613 1619 8 ton ton NN 19613 1619 9 Petron Petron NNP 19613 1619 10 kai kai NNP 19613 1619 11 tous tous JJ 19613 1619 12 allous allous JJ 19613 1619 13 apostolous apostolous JJ 19613 1619 14 apodechometha apodechometha NN 19613 1619 15 hôs hôs NNP 19613 1619 16 Christon Christon NNP 19613 1619 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1619 18 . . . 19613 1620 1 The the DT 19613 1620 2 success success NN 19613 1620 3 of of IN 19613 1620 4 the the DT 19613 1620 5 canon canon NN 19613 1620 6 here here RB 19613 1620 7 referred refer VBD 19613 1620 8 to to IN 19613 1620 9 was be VBD 19613 1620 10 an an DT 19613 1620 11 undoubted undoubted JJ 19613 1620 12 blessing blessing NN 19613 1620 13 , , , 19613 1620 14 for for IN 19613 1620 15 , , , 19613 1620 16 as as IN 19613 1620 17 the the DT 19613 1620 18 result result NN 19613 1620 19 of of IN 19613 1620 20 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 1620 21 , , , 19613 1620 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1620 23 was be VBD 19613 1620 24 menaced menace VBN 19613 1620 25 with with IN 19613 1620 26 complete complete JJ 19613 1620 27 corruption corruption NN 19613 1620 28 , , , 19613 1620 29 and and CC 19613 1620 30 things thing NNS 19613 1620 31 and and CC 19613 1620 32 ideas idea NNS 19613 1620 33 , , , 19613 1620 34 no no RB 19613 1620 35 matter matter RB 19613 1620 36 how how WRB 19613 1620 37 alien alien JJ 19613 1620 38 to to IN 19613 1620 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1620 40 spirit spirit NN 19613 1620 41 , , , 19613 1620 42 were be VBD 19613 1620 43 able able JJ 19613 1620 44 to to TO 19613 1620 45 obtain obtain VB 19613 1620 46 a a DT 19613 1620 47 lodgment lodgment NN 19613 1620 48 under under IN 19613 1620 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1620 50 protection protection NN 19613 1620 51 . . . 19613 1621 1 The the DT 19613 1621 2 removal removal NN 19613 1621 3 of of IN 19613 1621 4 this this DT 19613 1621 5 danger danger NN 19613 1621 6 , , , 19613 1621 7 which which WDT 19613 1621 8 was be VBD 19613 1621 9 in in IN 19613 1621 10 some some DT 19613 1621 11 measure measure NN 19613 1621 12 averted avert VBN 19613 1621 13 by by IN 19613 1621 14 the the DT 19613 1621 15 canon canon NNP 19613 1621 16 , , , 19613 1621 17 was be VBD 19613 1621 18 indeed indeed RB 19613 1621 19 coupled couple VBN 19613 1621 20 with with IN 19613 1621 21 great great JJ 19613 1621 22 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 19613 1621 23 , , , 19613 1621 24 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 1621 25 as as IN 19613 1621 26 believers believer NNS 19613 1621 27 were be VBD 19613 1621 28 referred refer VBN 19613 1621 29 in in IN 19613 1621 30 legal legal JJ 19613 1621 31 fashion fashion NN 19613 1621 32 to to IN 19613 1621 33 a a DT 19613 1621 34 new new JJ 19613 1621 35 book book NN 19613 1621 36 , , , 19613 1621 37 and and CC 19613 1621 38 the the DT 19613 1621 39 writings writing NNS 19613 1621 40 contained contain VBN 19613 1621 41 in in IN 19613 1621 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1621 43 were be VBD 19613 1621 44 at at IN 19613 1621 45 first first RB 19613 1621 46 completely completely RB 19613 1621 47 obscured obscure VBN 19613 1621 48 by by IN 19613 1621 49 the the DT 19613 1621 50 assumption assumption NN 19613 1621 51 that that IN 19613 1621 52 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1621 53 were be VBD 19613 1621 54 inspired inspire VBN 19613 1621 55 and and CC 19613 1621 56 by by IN 19613 1621 57 the the DT 19613 1621 58 requirement requirement NN 19613 1621 59 of of IN 19613 1621 60 an an DT 19613 1621 61 " " `` 19613 1621 62 expositio expositio NN 19613 1621 63 legitima legitima NN 19613 1621 64 . . . 19613 1621 65 " " '' 19613 1621 66 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1622 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1622 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1622 3 104 104 CD 19613 1622 4 : : : 19613 1622 5 See see VB 19613 1622 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1622 7 . . NNP 19613 1622 8 , , , 19613 1622 9 de de NNP 19613 1622 10 virg virg NNP 19613 1622 11 . . . 19613 1623 1 vol vol NNP 19613 1623 2 . . . 19613 1624 1 4 4 LS 19613 1624 2 , , , 19613 1624 3 de de NNP 19613 1624 4 resurr resurr NNP 19613 1624 5 . . . 19613 1625 1 24 24 CD 19613 1625 2 , , , 19613 1625 3 de de NNP 19613 1625 4 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 1625 5 . . . 19613 1626 1 15 15 CD 19613 1626 2 , , , 19613 1626 3 de de FW 19613 1626 4 pudic pudic JJ 19613 1626 5 . . . 19613 1627 1 12 12 CD 19613 1627 2 . . . 19613 1628 1 Sufficiency sufficiency NN 19613 1628 2 is be VBZ 19613 1628 3 above above IN 19613 1628 4 all all DT 19613 1628 5 included include VBN 19613 1628 6 in in IN 19613 1628 7 the the DT 19613 1628 8 concept concept NN 19613 1628 9 " " `` 19613 1628 10 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 1628 11 " " '' 19613 1628 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1628 13 see see VB 19613 1628 14 for for IN 19613 1628 15 ex ex NNP 19613 1628 16 . . . 19613 1629 1 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1629 2 . . NNP 19613 1629 3 , , , 19613 1629 4 de de NNP 19613 1629 5 monog monog NNP 19613 1629 6 . . . 19613 1630 1 4 4 LS 19613 1630 2 : : : 19613 1630 3 " " `` 19613 1630 4 Negat Negat NNP 19613 1630 5 scriptura scriptura NNP 19613 1630 6 quod quod NN 19613 1630 7 non non AFX 19613 1630 8 notat notat NNP 19613 1630 9 " " '' 19613 1630 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1630 11 , , , 19613 1630 12 and and CC 19613 1630 13 the the DT 19613 1630 14 same same JJ 19613 1630 15 measure measure NN 19613 1630 16 of of IN 19613 1630 17 authority authority NN 19613 1630 18 belongs belong VBZ 19613 1630 19 to to IN 19613 1630 20 all all DT 19613 1630 21 parts part NNS 19613 1630 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1630 23 see see VB 19613 1630 24 Iren Iren NNP 19613 1630 25 . . . 19613 1630 26 , , , 19613 1630 27 IV IV NNP 19613 1630 28 . . . 19613 1631 1 28 28 CD 19613 1631 2 . . . 19613 1632 1 3 3 LS 19613 1632 2 . . . 19613 1633 1 " " `` 19613 1633 2 Nihil nihil JJ 19613 1633 3 vacuum vacuum NN 19613 1633 4 neque neque NN 19613 1633 5 sine sine NNP 19613 1633 6 signo signo NNP 19613 1633 7 apud apud NNP 19613 1633 8 deum deum NNP 19613 1633 9 " " '' 19613 1633 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1633 11 . . . 19613 1633 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1634 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1634 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1634 3 105 105 CD 19613 1634 4 : : : 19613 1634 5 The the DT 19613 1634 6 direct direct JJ 19613 1634 7 designation designation NN 19613 1634 8 " " `` 19613 1634 9 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1634 10 " " '' 19613 1634 11 was be VBD 19613 1634 12 , , , 19613 1634 13 however however RB 19613 1634 14 , , , 19613 1634 15 as as IN 19613 1634 16 a a DT 19613 1634 17 rule rule NN 19613 1634 18 , , , 19613 1634 19 avoided avoid VBD 19613 1634 20 . . . 19613 1635 1 The the DT 19613 1635 2 conflict conflict NN 19613 1635 3 with with IN 19613 1635 4 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 1635 5 made make VBD 19613 1635 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1635 7 expedient expedient JJ 19613 1635 8 to to TO 19613 1635 9 refrain refrain VB 19613 1635 10 from from IN 19613 1635 11 this this DT 19613 1635 12 name name NN 19613 1635 13 ; ; : 19613 1635 14 but but CC 19613 1635 15 see see VB 19613 1635 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1635 17 , , , 19613 1635 18 adv adv NN 19613 1635 19 . . . 19613 1636 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 1636 2 . . . 19613 1637 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1637 2 . . . 19613 1638 1 24 24 CD 19613 1638 2 : : : 19613 1638 3 " " `` 19613 1638 4 Tam Tam NNP 19613 1638 5 apostolus apostolus NN 19613 1638 6 Moyses Moyses NNP 19613 1638 7 , , , 19613 1638 8 quam quam NNP 19613 1638 9 et et FW 19613 1638 10 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1638 11 prophetæ prophetæ NNS 19613 1638 12 . . . 19613 1638 13 " " '' 19613 1638 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1639 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1639 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1639 3 106 106 CD 19613 1639 4 : : : 19613 1639 5 Compare compare VB 19613 1639 6 also also RB 19613 1639 7 what what WP 19613 1639 8 the the DT 19613 1639 9 author author NN 19613 1639 10 of of IN 19613 1639 11 the the DT 19613 1639 12 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1639 13 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1639 14 says say VBZ 19613 1639 15 in in IN 19613 1639 16 the the DT 19613 1639 17 passage passage NN 19613 1639 18 about about IN 19613 1639 19 the the DT 19613 1639 20 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 1639 21 of of IN 19613 1639 22 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1639 23 . . . 19613 1639 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1640 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1640 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1640 3 107 107 CD 19613 1640 4 : : : 19613 1640 5 This this DT 19613 1640 6 caused cause VBD 19613 1640 7 the the DT 19613 1640 8 most most RBS 19613 1640 9 decisive decisive JJ 19613 1640 10 breach breach NN 19613 1640 11 with with IN 19613 1640 12 tradition tradition NN 19613 1640 13 , , , 19613 1640 14 and and CC 19613 1640 15 the the DT 19613 1640 16 estimate estimate NN 19613 1640 17 to to TO 19613 1640 18 be be VB 19613 1640 19 formed form VBN 19613 1640 20 of of IN 19613 1640 21 the the DT 19613 1640 22 Apocalypses Apocalypses NNPS 19613 1640 23 must must MD 19613 1640 24 at at IN 19613 1640 25 first first RB 19613 1640 26 have have VBP 19613 1640 27 remained remain VBN 19613 1640 28 an an DT 19613 1640 29 open open JJ 19613 1640 30 question question NN 19613 1640 31 . . . 19613 1641 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1641 2 fate fate NN 19613 1641 3 was be VBD 19613 1641 4 long long RB 19613 1641 5 undecided undecided JJ 19613 1641 6 in in IN 19613 1641 7 the the DT 19613 1641 8 West West NNP 19613 1641 9 ; ; : 19613 1641 10 but but CC 19613 1641 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1641 12 was be VBD 19613 1641 13 very very RB 19613 1641 14 soon soon RB 19613 1641 15 settled settle VBN 19613 1641 16 that that IN 19613 1641 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1641 18 could could MD 19613 1641 19 have have VB 19613 1641 20 no no DT 19613 1641 21 claim claim NN 19613 1641 22 to to IN 19613 1641 23 public public JJ 19613 1641 24 recognition recognition NN 19613 1641 25 in in IN 19613 1641 26 the the DT 19613 1641 27 Church Church NNP 19613 1641 28 , , , 19613 1641 29 because because IN 19613 1641 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1641 31 authors author NNS 19613 1641 32 had have VBD 19613 1641 33 not not RB 19613 1641 34 that that DT 19613 1641 35 fulness fulness NN 19613 1641 36 of of IN 19613 1641 37 the the DT 19613 1641 38 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 1641 39 which which WDT 19613 1641 40 belongs belong VBZ 19613 1641 41 to to IN 19613 1641 42 the the DT 19613 1641 43 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1641 44 alone alone JJ 19613 1641 45 . . . 19613 1641 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1642 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1642 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1642 3 108 108 CD 19613 1642 4 : : : 19613 1642 5 The the DT 19613 1642 6 disputed disputed JJ 19613 1642 7 question question NN 19613 1642 8 as as IN 19613 1642 9 to to IN 19613 1642 10 whether whether IN 19613 1642 11 all all PDT 19613 1642 12 the the DT 19613 1642 13 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 1642 14 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1642 15 writings writing NNS 19613 1642 16 were be VBD 19613 1642 17 regarded regard VBN 19613 1642 18 as as IN 19613 1642 19 canonical canonical JJ 19613 1642 20 must must MD 19613 1642 21 be be VB 19613 1642 22 answered answer VBN 19613 1642 23 in in IN 19613 1642 24 the the DT 19613 1642 25 affirmative affirmative NN 19613 1642 26 in in IN 19613 1642 27 reference reference NN 19613 1642 28 to to IN 19613 1642 29 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1642 30 and and CC 19613 1642 31 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1642 32 , , , 19613 1642 33 who who WP 19613 1642 34 conversely conversely RB 19613 1642 35 regarded regard VBD 19613 1642 36 no no DT 19613 1642 37 book book NN 19613 1642 38 as as RB 19613 1642 39 canonical canonical JJ 19613 1642 40 unless unless IN 19613 1642 41 written write VBN 19613 1642 42 by by IN 19613 1642 43 the the DT 19613 1642 44 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1642 45 . . . 19613 1643 1 On on IN 19613 1643 2 the the DT 19613 1643 3 other other JJ 19613 1643 4 hand hand NN 19613 1643 5 , , , 19613 1643 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1643 7 appears appear VBZ 19613 1643 8 to to IN 19613 1643 9 me -PRON- PRP 19613 1643 10 that that IN 19613 1643 11 no no DT 19613 1643 12 certain certain JJ 19613 1643 13 opinion opinion NN 19613 1643 14 on on IN 19613 1643 15 this this DT 19613 1643 16 point point NN 19613 1643 17 can can MD 19613 1643 18 be be VB 19613 1643 19 got get VBN 19613 1643 20 from from IN 19613 1643 21 the the DT 19613 1643 22 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1643 23 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1643 24 . . . 19613 1644 1 In in IN 19613 1644 2 the the DT 19613 1644 3 end end NN 19613 1644 4 the the DT 19613 1644 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1644 6 , , , 19613 1644 7 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1644 8 , , , 19613 1644 9 Kerygma Kerygma NNP 19613 1644 10 , , , 19613 1644 11 and and CC 19613 1644 12 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 1644 13 of of IN 19613 1644 14 Peter Peter NNP 19613 1644 15 as as RB 19613 1644 16 well well RB 19613 1644 17 as as IN 19613 1644 18 the the DT 19613 1644 19 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1644 20 of of IN 19613 1644 21 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1644 22 were be VBD 19613 1644 23 rejected reject VBN 19613 1644 24 , , , 19613 1644 25 a a DT 19613 1644 26 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 1644 27 which which WDT 19613 1644 28 was be VBD 19613 1644 29 at at IN 19613 1644 30 the the DT 19613 1644 31 same same JJ 19613 1644 32 time time NN 19613 1644 33 a a DT 19613 1644 34 declaration declaration NN 19613 1644 35 that that IN 19613 1644 36 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1644 37 were be VBD 19613 1644 38 spurious spurious JJ 19613 1644 39 . . . 19613 1645 1 But but CC 19613 1645 2 these these DT 19613 1645 3 three three CD 19613 1645 4 witnesses witness NNS 19613 1645 5 agree agree VBP 19613 1645 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1645 7 see see VB 19613 1645 8 also also RB 19613 1645 9 App App NNP 19613 1645 10 . . . 19613 1646 1 Constit Constit NNP 19613 1646 2 . . . 19613 1647 1 VI VI NNP 19613 1647 2 . . . 19613 1648 1 16 16 LS 19613 1648 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1648 3 that that IN 19613 1648 4 the the DT 19613 1648 5 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1648 6 _ _ NNP 19613 1648 7 regula regula NN 19613 1648 8 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1648 9 _ _ NNP 19613 1648 10 is be VBZ 19613 1648 11 practically practically RB 19613 1648 12 the the DT 19613 1648 13 final final JJ 19613 1648 14 court court NN 19613 1648 15 of of IN 19613 1648 16 appeal appeal NN 19613 1648 17 , , , 19613 1648 18 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 1648 19 as as IN 19613 1648 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1648 21 decides decide VBZ 19613 1648 22 whether whether IN 19613 1648 23 a a DT 19613 1648 24 writing writing NN 19613 1648 25 is be VBZ 19613 1648 26 really really RB 19613 1648 27 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 1648 28 or or CC 19613 1648 29 not not RB 19613 1648 30 , , , 19613 1648 31 and and CC 19613 1648 32 inasmuch inasmuch VB 19613 1648 33 as as IN 19613 1648 34 , , , 19613 1648 35 according accord VBG 19613 1648 36 to to IN 19613 1648 37 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1648 38 , , , 19613 1648 39 the the DT 19613 1648 40 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1648 41 writings writing NNS 19613 1648 42 belong belong VBP 19613 1648 43 to to IN 19613 1648 44 the the DT 19613 1648 45 Church Church NNP 19613 1648 46 alone alone RB 19613 1648 47 , , , 19613 1648 48 because because IN 19613 1648 49 she -PRON- PRP 19613 1648 50 alone alone RB 19613 1648 51 possesses possess VBZ 19613 1648 52 the the DT 19613 1648 53 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1648 54 _ _ NNP 19613 1648 55 regula regula NN 19613 1648 56 _ _ NNP 19613 1648 57 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1648 58 de de NNP 19613 1648 59 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1648 60 . . . 19613 1649 1 37 37 CD 19613 1649 2 ff ff NNP 19613 1649 3 . . NNP 19613 1649 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1649 5 . . . 19613 1650 1 The the DT 19613 1650 2 _ _ NNP 19613 1650 3 regula regula NN 19613 1650 4 _ _ NNP 19613 1650 5 of of IN 19613 1650 6 course course NN 19613 1650 7 does do VBZ 19613 1650 8 not not RB 19613 1650 9 legitimise legitimise VB 19613 1650 10 those those DT 19613 1650 11 writings writing NNS 19613 1650 12 , , , 19613 1650 13 but but CC 19613 1650 14 only only RB 19613 1650 15 proves prove VBZ 19613 1650 16 that that IN 19613 1650 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1650 18 are be VBP 19613 1650 19 authentic authentic JJ 19613 1650 20 and and CC 19613 1650 21 do do VBP 19613 1650 22 not not RB 19613 1650 23 belong belong VB 19613 1650 24 to to IN 19613 1650 25 the the DT 19613 1650 26 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1650 27 . . . 19613 1651 1 These these DT 19613 1651 2 witnesses witness NNS 19613 1651 3 also also RB 19613 1651 4 agree agree VBP 19613 1651 5 that that IN 19613 1651 6 a a DT 19613 1651 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 1651 8 writing writing NN 19613 1651 9 has have VBZ 19613 1651 10 no no DT 19613 1651 11 claim claim NN 19613 1651 12 to to TO 19613 1651 13 be be VB 19613 1651 14 received receive VBN 19613 1651 15 into into IN 19613 1651 16 the the DT 19613 1651 17 canon canon NN 19613 1651 18 merely merely RB 19613 1651 19 on on IN 19613 1651 20 account account NN 19613 1651 21 of of IN 19613 1651 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1651 23 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 1651 24 form form NN 19613 1651 25 . . . 19613 1652 1 On on IN 19613 1652 2 looking look VBG 19613 1652 3 at at IN 19613 1652 4 the the DT 19613 1652 5 matter matter NN 19613 1652 6 more more RBR 19613 1652 7 closely closely RB 19613 1652 8 , , , 19613 1652 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1652 10 see see VBP 19613 1652 11 that that IN 19613 1652 12 the the DT 19613 1652 13 view view NN 19613 1652 14 of of IN 19613 1652 15 the the DT 19613 1652 16 early early JJ 19613 1652 17 Church Church NNP 19613 1652 18 , , , 19613 1652 19 as as IN 19613 1652 20 opposed oppose VBN 19613 1652 21 to to IN 19613 1652 22 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 1652 23 , , , 19613 1652 24 led lead VBD 19613 1652 25 to to IN 19613 1652 26 the the DT 19613 1652 27 paradox paradox NN 19613 1652 28 that that IN 19613 1652 29 the the DT 19613 1652 30 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1652 31 were be VBD 19613 1652 32 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1652 33 in in IN 19613 1652 34 the the DT 19613 1652 35 sense sense NN 19613 1652 36 of of IN 19613 1652 37 being be VBG 19613 1652 38 inspired inspire VBN 19613 1652 39 by by IN 19613 1652 40 the the DT 19613 1652 41 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 1652 42 , , , 19613 1652 43 but but CC 19613 1652 44 that that IN 19613 1652 45 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1652 46 were be VBD 19613 1652 47 not not RB 19613 1652 48 so so RB 19613 1652 49 in in IN 19613 1652 50 the the DT 19613 1652 51 strict strict JJ 19613 1652 52 sense sense NN 19613 1652 53 of of IN 19613 1652 54 the the DT 19613 1652 55 word word NN 19613 1652 56 . . . 19613 1652 57 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1653 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1653 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1653 3 109 109 CD 19613 1653 4 : : : 19613 1653 5 The the DT 19613 1653 6 fragment fragment NN 19613 1653 7 of of IN 19613 1653 8 Serapion serapion NN 19613 1653 9 's 's POS 19613 1653 10 letter letter NN 19613 1653 11 given give VBN 19613 1653 12 in in IN 19613 1653 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 1653 14 owes owe VBZ 19613 1653 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1653 16 interest interest NN 19613 1653 17 to to IN 19613 1653 18 the the DT 19613 1653 19 fact fact NN 19613 1653 20 that that IN 19613 1653 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1653 22 not not RB 19613 1653 23 only only RB 19613 1653 24 shows show VBZ 19613 1653 25 the the DT 19613 1653 26 progress progress NN 19613 1653 27 made make VBN 19613 1653 28 at at IN 19613 1653 29 this this DT 19613 1653 30 time time NN 19613 1653 31 with with IN 19613 1653 32 the the DT 19613 1653 33 formation formation NN 19613 1653 34 of of IN 19613 1653 35 the the DT 19613 1653 36 canon canon NN 19613 1653 37 at at IN 19613 1653 38 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 1653 39 , , , 19613 1653 40 but but CC 19613 1653 41 also also RB 19613 1653 42 what what WP 19613 1653 43 still still RB 19613 1653 44 remained remain VBD 19613 1653 45 to to TO 19613 1653 46 be be VB 19613 1653 47 done do VBN 19613 1653 48 . . . 19613 1653 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1654 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1654 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1654 3 110 110 CD 19613 1654 4 : : : 19613 1654 5 See see VB 19613 1654 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1654 7 essay essay NN 19613 1654 8 " " '' 19613 1654 9 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 1654 10 v. v. IN 19613 1654 11 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 19613 1654 12 und und JJ 19613 1654 13 das das NNP 19613 1654 14 N. n. NN 19613 1654 15 T. t. NN 19613 1654 16 " " '' 19613 1654 17 in in IN 19613 1654 18 the the DT 19613 1654 19 Ztschr Ztschr NNP 19613 1654 20 . . . 19613 1655 1 f. f. NNP 19613 1655 2 K. K. NNP 19613 1655 3 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1655 4 . . . 19613 1656 1 XI XI NNP 19613 1656 2 . . . 19613 1657 1 p. p. NN 19613 1657 2 1 1 CD 19613 1657 3 ff ff NNP 19613 1657 4 . . . 19613 1657 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1658 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1658 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1658 3 111 111 CD 19613 1658 4 : : : 19613 1658 5 The the DT 19613 1658 6 most most RBS 19613 1658 7 important important JJ 19613 1658 8 passages passage NNS 19613 1658 9 are be VBP 19613 1658 10 Autol Autol NNP 19613 1658 11 . . . 19613 1659 1 II ii CD 19613 1659 2 . . . 19613 1660 1 9 9 CD 19613 1660 2 . . . 19613 1661 1 22 22 CD 19613 1661 2 : : : 19613 1661 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1661 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1661 5 : : : 19613 1661 6 hothen hothen NNP 19613 1661 7 didaskousin didaskousin NNP 19613 1661 8 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 1661 9 hai hai NNP 19613 1661 10 hagiai hagiai NNP 19613 1661 11 graphai graphai NNP 19613 1661 12 kai kai NNP 19613 1661 13 pantes pant VBZ 19613 1661 14 hoi hoi NNP 19613 1661 15 pneumatophoroi pneumatophoroi NNP 19613 1661 16 , , , 19613 1661 17 ex ex NNP 19613 1661 18 hôn hôn NNP 19613 1661 19 Iôannaes Iôannaes NNP 19613 1661 20 legei legei NNP 19613 1661 21 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 1661 22 . . . 19613 1661 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1662 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1662 2 follows follow VBZ 19613 1662 3 John John NNP 19613 1662 4 I. I. NNP 19613 1663 1 1 1 LS 19613 1663 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1663 3 III iii CD 19613 1663 4 . . . 19613 1664 1 12 12 CD 19613 1664 2 : : : 19613 1664 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1664 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1664 5 : : : 19613 1664 6 kai kai NNP 19613 1664 7 peri peri NNP 19613 1664 8 dikaiosunês dikaiosunês NNP 19613 1664 9 , , , 19613 1664 10 hês hês NNP 19613 1664 11 ho ho NNP 19613 1664 12 nomos nomos NNP 19613 1664 13 eirêken eirêken NNP 19613 1664 14 , , , 19613 1664 15 akoloutha akoloutha NNP 19613 1664 16 heurisketai heurisketai NNP 19613 1664 17 kai kai NNP 19613 1664 18 ta ta NNP 19613 1664 19 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1664 20 prophêtôn prophêtôn NNP 19613 1664 21 kai kai NNP 19613 1664 22 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1664 23 euangeliôn euangeliôn NNP 19613 1664 24 echein echein NNP 19613 1664 25 , , , 19613 1664 26 dia dia NNP 19613 1664 27 to to IN 19613 1664 28 tous tous JJ 19613 1664 29 pantas pantas JJ 19613 1664 30 pneumatophorous pneumatophorous JJ 19613 1664 31 heni heni NN 19613 1664 32 pneumati pneumati RB 19613 1664 33 theou theou IN 19613 1664 34 lelalêkenai lelalêkenai NNP 19613 1664 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1664 36 ; ; : 19613 1664 37 III iii CD 19613 1664 38 . . . 19613 1665 1 13 13 CD 19613 1665 2 : : : 19613 1665 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1665 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1665 5 : : : 19613 1665 6 ho ho NNP 19613 1665 7 hagios hagio NNS 19613 1665 8 logos logos NNP 19613 1665 9 -- -- : 19613 1665 10 hê hê VB 19613 1665 11 euangelios euangelios NNP 19613 1665 12 phônê phônê NNP 19613 1665 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1665 14 . . . 19613 1666 1 ; ; : 19613 1666 2 III iii CD 19613 1666 3 . . . 19613 1667 1 14 14 CD 19613 1667 2 : : : 19613 1667 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1667 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1667 5 : : : 19613 1667 6 Êsaias Êsaias NNP 19613 1667 7 -- -- : 19613 1667 8 to to IN 19613 1667 9 de de NNP 19613 1667 10 euangelion euangelion NNP 19613 1667 11 -- -- : 19613 1667 12 ho ho NNP 19613 1667 13 theios theios NNP 19613 1667 14 logos logos NNP 19613 1667 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1667 16 . . . 19613 1668 1 The the DT 19613 1668 2 latter latter JJ 19613 1668 3 formula formula NN 19613 1668 4 is be VBZ 19613 1668 5 not not RB 19613 1668 6 a a DT 19613 1668 7 quotation quotation NN 19613 1668 8 of of IN 19613 1668 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1668 10 of of IN 19613 1668 11 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1668 12 viewed view VBD 19613 1668 13 as as IN 19613 1668 14 canonical canonical JJ 19613 1668 15 , , , 19613 1668 16 but but CC 19613 1668 17 of of IN 19613 1668 18 a a DT 19613 1668 19 divine divine JJ 19613 1668 20 command command NN 19613 1668 21 found find VBN 19613 1668 22 in in IN 19613 1668 23 the the DT 19613 1668 24 Old Old NNP 19613 1668 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1668 26 and and CC 19613 1668 27 given give VBN 19613 1668 28 in in IN 19613 1668 29 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1668 30 form form NN 19613 1668 31 . . . 19613 1669 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1669 2 is be VBZ 19613 1669 3 specially specially RB 19613 1669 4 worthy worthy JJ 19613 1669 5 of of IN 19613 1669 6 note note NN 19613 1669 7 that that IN 19613 1669 8 the the DT 19613 1669 9 original original NN 19613 1669 10 of of IN 19613 1669 11 the the DT 19613 1669 12 six six CD 19613 1669 13 books book NNS 19613 1669 14 of of IN 19613 1669 15 the the DT 19613 1669 16 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 1669 17 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 1669 18 , , , 19613 1669 19 written write VBN 19613 1669 20 in in IN 19613 1669 21 Syria Syria NNP 19613 1669 22 and and CC 19613 1669 23 belonging belong VBG 19613 1669 24 to to IN 19613 1669 25 the the DT 19613 1669 26 second second JJ 19613 1669 27 half half NN 19613 1669 28 of of IN 19613 1669 29 the the DT 19613 1669 30 third third JJ 19613 1669 31 century century NN 19613 1669 32 , , , 19613 1669 33 knows know VBZ 19613 1669 34 yet yet RB 19613 1669 35 of of IN 19613 1669 36 no no DT 19613 1669 37 New New NNP 19613 1669 38 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1669 39 . . . 19613 1670 1 In in IN 19613 1670 2 addition addition NN 19613 1670 3 to to IN 19613 1670 4 the the DT 19613 1670 5 Old Old NNP 19613 1670 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1670 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1670 8 has have VBZ 19613 1670 9 no no DT 19613 1670 10 authority authority NN 19613 1670 11 but but CC 19613 1670 12 the the DT 19613 1670 13 " " `` 19613 1670 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 1670 15 . . . 19613 1670 16 " " '' 19613 1670 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1671 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1671 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1671 3 112 112 CD 19613 1671 4 : : : 19613 1671 5 There there EX 19613 1671 6 has have VBZ 19613 1671 7 as as RB 19613 1671 8 yet yet RB 19613 1671 9 been be VBN 19613 1671 10 no no DT 19613 1671 11 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 1671 12 investigation investigation NN 19613 1671 13 of of IN 19613 1671 14 the the DT 19613 1671 15 New New NNP 19613 1671 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1671 17 of of IN 19613 1671 18 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1671 19 . . . 19613 1672 1 The the DT 19613 1672 2 information information NN 19613 1672 3 given give VBN 19613 1672 4 by by IN 19613 1672 5 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 19613 1672 6 in in IN 19613 1672 7 Credner Credner NNP 19613 1672 8 's 's POS 19613 1672 9 Gesch Gesch NNP 19613 1672 10 . . . 19613 1673 1 d. d. NNP 19613 1673 2 N. N. NNP 19613 1673 3 Tlichen Tlichen NNP 19613 1673 4 Kanon Kanon NNP 19613 1673 5 , , , 19613 1673 6 p. p. NN 19613 1673 7 382 382 CD 19613 1673 8 ff ff NNP 19613 1673 9 . . NNP 19613 1673 10 , , , 19613 1673 11 is be VBZ 19613 1673 12 not not RB 19613 1673 13 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 1673 14 . . . 19613 1674 1 The the DT 19613 1674 2 space space NN 19613 1674 3 at at IN 19613 1674 4 the the DT 19613 1674 5 disposal disposal NN 19613 1674 6 of of IN 19613 1674 7 this this DT 19613 1674 8 manual manual JJ 19613 1674 9 prevents prevent VBZ 19613 1674 10 me -PRON- PRP 19613 1674 11 from from IN 19613 1674 12 establishing establish VBG 19613 1674 13 the the DT 19613 1674 14 results result NNS 19613 1674 15 of of IN 19613 1674 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1674 17 studies study NNS 19613 1674 18 on on IN 19613 1674 19 this this DT 19613 1674 20 point point NN 19613 1674 21 . . . 19613 1675 1 Let let VB 19613 1675 2 me -PRON- PRP 19613 1675 3 at at IN 19613 1675 4 least least JJS 19613 1675 5 refer refer VB 19613 1675 6 to to IN 19613 1675 7 some some DT 19613 1675 8 important important JJ 19613 1675 9 passages passage NNS 19613 1675 10 which which WDT 19613 1675 11 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1675 12 have have VBP 19613 1675 13 collected collect VBN 19613 1675 14 . . . 19613 1676 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1676 2 . . . 19613 1677 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1678 1 § § ADD 19613 1678 2 § § CD 19613 1678 3 28 28 CD 19613 1678 4 , , , 19613 1678 5 100 100 CD 19613 1678 6 ; ; : 19613 1678 7 II II NNP 19613 1678 8 . . . 19613 1679 1 § § ADD 19613 1679 2 § § CD 19613 1679 3 22 22 CD 19613 1679 4 , , , 19613 1679 5 28 28 CD 19613 1679 6 , , , 19613 1679 7 29 29 CD 19613 1679 8 ; ; : 19613 1679 9 III.,§§ III.,§§ NNP 19613 1679 10 11 11 CD 19613 1679 11 , , , 19613 1679 12 66 66 CD 19613 1679 13 , , , 19613 1679 14 70 70 CD 19613 1679 15 , , , 19613 1679 16 71 71 CD 19613 1679 17 , , , 19613 1679 18 76 76 CD 19613 1679 19 , , , 19613 1679 20 93 93 CD 19613 1679 21 , , , 19613 1679 22 108 108 CD 19613 1679 23 ; ; : 19613 1679 24 IV IV NNP 19613 1679 25 . . . 19613 1680 1 § § ADD 19613 1680 2 § § CD 19613 1680 3 2 2 CD 19613 1680 4 , , , 19613 1680 5 91 91 CD 19613 1680 6 , , , 19613 1680 7 97 97 CD 19613 1680 8 , , , 19613 1680 9 105 105 CD 19613 1680 10 , , , 19613 1680 11 130 130 CD 19613 1680 12 , , , 19613 1680 13 133 133 CD 19613 1680 14 , , , 19613 1680 15 134 134 CD 19613 1680 16 , , , 19613 1680 17 138 138 CD 19613 1680 18 , , , 19613 1680 19 159 159 CD 19613 1680 20 ; ; : 19613 1680 21 V. v. NN 19613 1680 22 § § NNS 19613 1680 23 § § CD 19613 1680 24 3 3 CD 19613 1680 25 , , , 19613 1680 26 17 17 CD 19613 1680 27 , , , 19613 1680 28 27 27 CD 19613 1680 29 , , , 19613 1680 30 28 28 CD 19613 1680 31 , , , 19613 1680 32 30 30 CD 19613 1680 33 , , , 19613 1680 34 31 31 CD 19613 1680 35 , , , 19613 1680 36 38 38 CD 19613 1680 37 , , , 19613 1680 38 80 80 CD 19613 1680 39 , , , 19613 1680 40 85 85 CD 19613 1680 41 , , , 19613 1680 42 86 86 CD 19613 1680 43 ; ; : 19613 1680 44 VI VI NNP 19613 1680 45 . . . 19613 1681 1 § § ADD 19613 1681 2 § § CD 19613 1681 3 42,44 42,44 CD 19613 1681 4 , , , 19613 1681 5 54 54 CD 19613 1681 6 , , , 19613 1681 7 59 59 CD 19613 1681 8 , , , 19613 1681 9 61 61 CD 19613 1681 10 , , , 19613 1681 11 66 66 CD 19613 1681 12 - - HYPH 19613 1681 13 -68 -68 NN 19613 1681 14 , , , 19613 1681 15 88 88 CD 19613 1681 16 , , , 19613 1681 17 91 91 CD 19613 1681 18 , , , 19613 1681 19 106 106 CD 19613 1681 20 , , , 19613 1681 21 107 107 CD 19613 1681 22 , , , 19613 1681 23 119 119 CD 19613 1681 24 , , , 19613 1681 25 124 124 CD 19613 1681 26 , , , 19613 1681 27 125 125 CD 19613 1681 28 , , , 19613 1681 29 127 127 CD 19613 1681 30 , , , 19613 1681 31 128 128 CD 19613 1681 32 , , , 19613 1681 33 133 133 CD 19613 1681 34 , , , 19613 1681 35 161 161 CD 19613 1681 36 , , , 19613 1681 37 164 164 CD 19613 1681 38 ; ; : 19613 1681 39 VII VII NNP 19613 1681 40 . . . 19613 1682 1 § § ADD 19613 1682 2 § § CD 19613 1682 3 1 1 CD 19613 1682 4 , , , 19613 1682 5 14 14 CD 19613 1682 6 , , , 19613 1682 7 34 34 CD 19613 1682 8 , , , 19613 1682 9 76 76 CD 19613 1682 10 , , , 19613 1682 11 82 82 CD 19613 1682 12 , , , 19613 1682 13 84 84 CD 19613 1682 14 , , , 19613 1682 15 88 88 CD 19613 1682 16 , , , 19613 1682 17 94 94 CD 19613 1682 18 , , , 19613 1682 19 95 95 CD 19613 1682 20 , , , 19613 1682 21 97 97 CD 19613 1682 22 , , , 19613 1682 23 100 100 CD 19613 1682 24 , , , 19613 1682 25 101 101 CD 19613 1682 26 , , , 19613 1682 27 103 103 CD 19613 1682 28 , , , 19613 1682 29 104 104 CD 19613 1682 30 , , , 19613 1682 31 106 106 CD 19613 1682 32 , , , 19613 1682 33 107 107 CD 19613 1682 34 . . . 19613 1683 1 As as IN 19613 1683 2 to to IN 19613 1683 3 the the DT 19613 1683 4 estimate estimate NN 19613 1683 5 of of IN 19613 1683 6 the the DT 19613 1683 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1683 8 of of IN 19613 1683 9 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1683 10 and and CC 19613 1683 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1683 12 of of IN 19613 1683 13 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1683 14 as as RB 19613 1683 15 well well RB 19613 1683 16 as as IN 19613 1683 17 of of IN 19613 1683 18 the the DT 19613 1683 19 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 1683 20 , , , 19613 1683 21 in in IN 19613 1683 22 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1683 23 , , , 19613 1683 24 see see VB 19613 1683 25 the the DT 19613 1683 26 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 19613 1683 27 . . . 19613 1684 1 to to IN 19613 1684 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1684 3 edition edition NN 19613 1684 4 of of IN 19613 1684 5 the the DT 19613 1684 6 Opp Opp NNP 19613 1684 7 . . . 19613 1685 1 Patr Patr NNP 19613 1685 2 . . . 19613 1686 1 Apost Apost NNP 19613 1686 2 . . . 19613 1686 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1687 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1687 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1687 3 113 113 CD 19613 1687 4 : : : 19613 1687 5 According accord VBG 19613 1687 6 to to IN 19613 1687 7 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1687 8 . . . 19613 1688 1 V. V. NNP 19613 1688 2 14 14 CD 19613 1688 3 . . . 19613 1689 1 138 138 CD 19613 1689 2 even even RB 19613 1689 3 the the DT 19613 1689 4 Epicurean Epicurean NNP 19613 1689 5 Metrodorus Metrodorus NNP 19613 1689 6 uttered utter VBD 19613 1689 7 certain certain JJ 19613 1689 8 words word NNS 19613 1689 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1689 10 Greek greek JJ 19613 1689 11 : : : 19613 1689 12 entheôs entheôs NN 19613 1689 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1689 14 ; ; : 19613 1689 15 but but CC 19613 1689 16 on on IN 19613 1689 17 the the DT 19613 1689 18 other other JJ 19613 1689 19 hand hand NN 19613 1689 20 Homer Homer NNP 19613 1689 21 was be VBD 19613 1689 22 a a DT 19613 1689 23 prophet prophet NN 19613 1689 24 against against IN 19613 1689 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1689 26 will will NN 19613 1689 27 . . . 19613 1690 1 See see VB 19613 1690 2 Pæd Pæd NNP 19613 1690 3 . . . 19613 1691 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1692 1 6 6 CD 19613 1692 2 . . . 19613 1693 1 36 36 CD 19613 1693 2 , , , 19613 1693 3 also also RB 19613 1693 4 § § CD 19613 1693 5 51 51 CD 19613 1693 6 . . . 19613 1693 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1694 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1694 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1694 3 114 114 CD 19613 1694 4 : : : 19613 1694 5 In in IN 19613 1694 6 the the DT 19613 1694 7 Pæd pæd NN 19613 1694 8 . . . 19613 1695 1 the the DT 19613 1695 2 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1695 3 are be VBP 19613 1695 4 regularly regularly RB 19613 1695 5 called call VBN 19613 1695 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1695 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1695 8 : : : 19613 1695 9 hê hê VB 19613 1695 10 graphê graphê NNS 19613 1695 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1695 12 but but CC 19613 1695 13 this this DT 19613 1695 14 is be VBZ 19613 1695 15 seldom seldom RB 19613 1695 16 the the DT 19613 1695 17 case case NN 19613 1695 18 with with IN 19613 1695 19 the the DT 19613 1695 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1695 21 . . . 19613 1696 1 The the DT 19613 1696 2 word word NN 19613 1696 3 " " `` 19613 1696 4 Apostle apostle NN 19613 1696 5 " " '' 19613 1696 6 is be VBZ 19613 1696 7 used use VBN 19613 1696 8 in in IN 19613 1696 9 quoting quote VBG 19613 1696 10 these these DT 19613 1696 11 . . . 19613 1696 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1697 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1697 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1697 3 115 115 CD 19613 1697 4 : : : 19613 1697 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1697 6 is be VBZ 19613 1697 7 also also RB 19613 1697 8 very very RB 19613 1697 9 interesting interesting JJ 19613 1697 10 to to TO 19613 1697 11 note note VB 19613 1697 12 that that IN 19613 1697 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1697 14 almost almost RB 19613 1697 15 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 1697 16 illustrates illustrate VBZ 19613 1697 17 the the DT 19613 1697 18 parabolic parabolic JJ 19613 1697 19 character character NN 19613 1697 20 of of IN 19613 1697 21 the the DT 19613 1697 22 Holy Holy NNP 19613 1697 23 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 1697 24 by by IN 19613 1697 25 quoting quote VBG 19613 1697 26 the the DT 19613 1697 27 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1697 28 , , , 19613 1697 29 but but CC 19613 1697 30 in in IN 19613 1697 31 this this DT 19613 1697 32 connection connection NN 19613 1697 33 employs employ VBZ 19613 1697 34 the the DT 19613 1697 35 Old Old NNP 19613 1697 36 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1697 37 and and CC 19613 1697 38 the the DT 19613 1697 39 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1697 40 , , , 19613 1697 41 just just RB 19613 1697 42 as as IN 19613 1697 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1697 44 almost almost RB 19613 1697 45 never never RB 19613 1697 46 allegorises allegorise VBZ 19613 1697 47 passages passage NNS 19613 1697 48 from from IN 19613 1697 49 other other JJ 19613 1697 50 writings writing NNS 19613 1697 51 . . . 19613 1698 1 1 1 CD 19613 1698 2 Cor Cor NNP 19613 1698 3 . . . 19613 1699 1 III iii CD 19613 1699 2 . . . 19613 1700 1 2 2 CD 19613 1700 2 is be VBZ 19613 1700 3 once once RB 19613 1700 4 quoted quote VBN 19613 1700 5 thus thus RB 19613 1700 6 in in IN 19613 1700 7 Pæd pæd NN 19613 1700 8 . . . 19613 1701 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1702 1 6 6 CD 19613 1702 2 . . . 19613 1703 1 49 49 CD 19613 1703 2 : : : 19613 1703 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1703 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1703 5 : : : 19613 1703 6 to to TO 19613 1703 7 en en VB 19613 1703 8 tô tô NNP 19613 1703 9 apostolô apostolô NNP 19613 1703 10 hagion hagion NNP 19613 1703 11 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 1703 12 tê tê NNP 19613 1703 13 tou tou NNP 19613 1703 14 kuriou kuriou NNP 19613 1703 15 apochrômenon apochrômenon NNP 19613 1703 16 phônê phônê NNP 19613 1703 17 legei legei NNP 19613 1703 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1703 19 . . . 19613 1704 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1704 2 can can MD 19613 1704 3 hardly hardly RB 19613 1704 4 conclude conclude VB 19613 1704 5 from from IN 19613 1704 6 Pæd Pæd NNP 19613 1704 7 . . . 19613 1705 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1706 1 7 7 LS 19613 1706 2 . . . 19613 1707 1 61 61 CD 19613 1707 2 that that IN 19613 1707 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1707 4 called call VBD 19613 1707 5 Paul Paul NNP 19613 1707 6 a a DT 19613 1707 7 " " `` 19613 1707 8 prophet prophet NN 19613 1707 9 . . . 19613 1707 10 " " '' 19613 1707 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1708 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1708 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1708 3 116 116 CD 19613 1708 4 : : : 19613 1708 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1708 6 is be VBZ 19613 1708 7 worthy worthy JJ 19613 1708 8 of of IN 19613 1708 9 special special JJ 19613 1708 10 note note NN 19613 1708 11 that that IN 19613 1708 12 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1708 13 . . . 19613 1708 14 , , , 19613 1708 15 Pæd pæd NN 19613 1708 16 . . . 19613 1709 1 II ii CD 19613 1709 2 . . . 19613 1710 1 10.3 10.3 CD 19613 1710 2 ; ; : 19613 1710 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1710 4 . . . 19613 1711 1 II ii CD 19613 1711 2 . . . 19613 1712 1 15 15 CD 19613 1712 2 . . . 19613 1713 1 67 67 CD 19613 1713 2 has have VBZ 19613 1713 3 criticised criticise VBN 19613 1713 4 an an DT 19613 1713 5 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 1713 6 given give VBN 19613 1713 7 by by IN 19613 1713 8 the the DT 19613 1713 9 author author NN 19613 1713 10 of of IN 19613 1713 11 the the DT 19613 1713 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1713 13 of of IN 19613 1713 14 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1713 15 , , , 19613 1713 16 although although IN 19613 1713 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1713 18 calls call VBZ 19613 1713 19 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 1713 20 an an DT 19613 1713 21 Apostle Apostle NNP 19613 1713 22 . . . 19613 1713 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1714 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1714 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1714 3 117 117 CD 19613 1714 4 : : : 19613 1714 5 In in IN 19613 1714 6 this this DT 19613 1714 7 category category NN 19613 1714 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1714 9 may may MD 19613 1714 10 also also RB 19613 1714 11 include include VB 19613 1714 12 the the DT 19613 1714 13 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 1714 14 of of IN 19613 1714 15 the the DT 19613 1714 16 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1714 17 , , , 19613 1714 18 which which WDT 19613 1714 19 is be VBZ 19613 1714 20 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1714 21 used use VBN 19613 1714 22 like like IN 19613 1714 23 the the DT 19613 1714 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1714 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1714 26 : : : 19613 1714 27 kêrugma kêrugma NNP 19613 1714 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1714 29 . . . 19613 1715 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1715 2 is be VBZ 19613 1715 3 quoted quote VBN 19613 1715 4 in in IN 19613 1715 5 Pæd Pæd NNP 19613 1715 6 . . . 19613 1716 1 II ii CD 19613 1716 2 . . . 19613 1717 1 16 16 CD 19613 1717 2 . . . 19613 1718 1 56 56 LS 19613 1718 2 ; ; : 19613 1718 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1718 4 . . . 19613 1719 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1720 1 50 50 CD 19613 1720 2 , , , 19613 1720 3 89 89 CD 19613 1720 4 , , , 19613 1720 5 91 91 CD 19613 1720 6 , , , 19613 1720 7 92 92 CD 19613 1720 8 , , , 19613 1720 9 153 153 CD 19613 1720 10 , , , 19613 1720 11 154 154 CD 19613 1720 12 ; ; : 19613 1720 13 III iii CD 19613 1720 14 . . . 19613 1721 1 49 49 CD 19613 1721 2 ; ; : 19613 1721 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1721 4 . . . 19613 1722 1 97 97 CD 19613 1722 2 ; ; : 19613 1722 3 V. V. NNP 19613 1722 4 75 75 CD 19613 1722 5 , , , 19613 1722 6 82 82 CD 19613 1722 7 ; ; : 19613 1722 8 VI VI NNP 19613 1722 9 . . . 19613 1723 1 63 63 CD 19613 1723 2 , , , 19613 1723 3 101 101 CD 19613 1723 4 , , , 19613 1723 5 124 124 CD 19613 1723 6 , , , 19613 1723 7 165 165 CD 19613 1723 8 . . . 19613 1723 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1724 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1724 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1724 3 118 118 CD 19613 1724 4 : : : 19613 1724 5 The the DT 19613 1724 6 " " `` 19613 1724 7 seventy seventy CD 19613 1724 8 disciples disciple NNS 19613 1724 9 " " '' 19613 1724 10 were be VBD 19613 1724 11 also also RB 19613 1724 12 regarded regard VBN 19613 1724 13 as as IN 19613 1724 14 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 1724 15 , , , 19613 1724 16 and and CC 19613 1724 17 the the DT 19613 1724 18 authors author NNS 19613 1724 19 of of IN 19613 1724 20 writings writing NNS 19613 1724 21 the the DT 19613 1724 22 names name NNS 19613 1724 23 of of IN 19613 1724 24 which which WDT 19613 1724 25 did do VBD 19613 1724 26 not not RB 19613 1724 27 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 1724 28 offer offer VB 19613 1724 29 a a DT 19613 1724 30 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 1724 31 of of IN 19613 1724 32 authority authority NN 19613 1724 33 were be VBD 19613 1724 34 likewise likewise RB 19613 1724 35 included include VBN 19613 1724 36 in in IN 19613 1724 37 this this DT 19613 1724 38 category category NN 19613 1724 39 . . . 19613 1725 1 That that DT 19613 1725 2 is be VBZ 19613 1725 3 to to TO 19613 1725 4 say say VB 19613 1725 5 , , , 19613 1725 6 writings writing NNS 19613 1725 7 which which WDT 19613 1725 8 were be VBD 19613 1725 9 regarded regard VBN 19613 1725 10 as as IN 19613 1725 11 valuable valuable JJ 19613 1725 12 and and CC 19613 1725 13 which which WDT 19613 1725 14 for for IN 19613 1725 15 some some DT 19613 1725 16 reason reason NN 19613 1725 17 or or CC 19613 1725 18 other other JJ 19613 1725 19 could could MD 19613 1725 20 not not RB 19613 1725 21 be be VB 19613 1725 22 characterised characterise VBN 19613 1725 23 as as IN 19613 1725 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1725 25 in in IN 19613 1725 26 the the DT 19613 1725 27 narrower narrow JJR 19613 1725 28 sense sense NN 19613 1725 29 were be VBD 19613 1725 30 attributed attribute VBN 19613 1725 31 to to IN 19613 1725 32 authors author NNS 19613 1725 33 whom whom WP 19613 1725 34 there there EX 19613 1725 35 was be VBD 19613 1725 36 no no DT 19613 1725 37 reason reason NN 19613 1725 38 for for IN 19613 1725 39 denying deny VBG 19613 1725 40 to to TO 19613 1725 41 be be VB 19613 1725 42 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1725 43 in in IN 19613 1725 44 the the DT 19613 1725 45 wider wide JJR 19613 1725 46 sense sense NN 19613 1725 47 . . . 19613 1726 1 This this DT 19613 1726 2 wider wide JJR 19613 1726 3 use use NN 19613 1726 4 of of IN 19613 1726 5 the the DT 19613 1726 6 concept concept NN 19613 1726 7 " " `` 19613 1726 8 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1726 9 " " '' 19613 1726 10 is be VBZ 19613 1726 11 moreover moreover RB 19613 1726 12 no no DT 19613 1726 13 innovation innovation NN 19613 1726 14 . . . 19613 1727 1 See see VB 19613 1727 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1727 3 edition edition NN 19613 1727 4 of of IN 19613 1727 5 the the DT 19613 1727 6 Didache Didache NNP 19613 1727 7 , , , 19613 1727 8 pp pp NNP 19613 1727 9 . . . 19613 1728 1 111 111 CD 19613 1728 2 - - SYM 19613 1728 3 118 118 CD 19613 1728 4 . . . 19613 1728 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1729 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1729 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1729 3 119 119 CD 19613 1729 4 : : : 19613 1729 5 The the DT 19613 1729 6 formation formation NN 19613 1729 7 of of IN 19613 1729 8 the the DT 19613 1729 9 canon canon NN 19613 1729 10 in in IN 19613 1729 11 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1729 12 must must MD 19613 1729 13 have have VB 19613 1729 14 had have VBN 19613 1729 15 some some DT 19613 1729 16 connection connection NN 19613 1729 17 with with IN 19613 1729 18 the the DT 19613 1729 19 same same JJ 19613 1729 20 process process NN 19613 1729 21 in in IN 19613 1729 22 Asia Asia NNP 19613 1729 23 Minor Minor NNP 19613 1729 24 and and CC 19613 1729 25 in in IN 19613 1729 26 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1729 27 . . . 19613 1730 1 This this DT 19613 1730 2 is be VBZ 19613 1730 3 shown show VBN 19613 1730 4 not not RB 19613 1730 5 only only RB 19613 1730 6 by by IN 19613 1730 7 each each DT 19613 1730 8 Church church NN 19613 1730 9 recognising recognise VBG 19613 1730 10 four four CD 19613 1730 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 1730 12 , , , 19613 1730 13 but but CC 19613 1730 14 still still RB 19613 1730 15 more more JJR 19613 1730 16 by by IN 19613 1730 17 the the DT 19613 1730 18 admission admission NN 19613 1730 19 of of IN 19613 1730 20 thirteen thirteen CD 19613 1730 21 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1730 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1730 23 . . . 19613 1731 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1731 2 would would MD 19613 1731 3 see see VB 19613 1731 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1731 5 way way NN 19613 1731 6 more more RBR 19613 1731 7 clearly clearly RB 19613 1731 8 here here RB 19613 1731 9 , , , 19613 1731 10 if if IN 19613 1731 11 anything anything NN 19613 1731 12 certain certain JJ 19613 1731 13 could could MD 19613 1731 14 be be VB 19613 1731 15 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 1731 16 from from IN 19613 1731 17 the the DT 19613 1731 18 works work NNS 19613 1731 19 of of IN 19613 1731 20 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1731 21 , , , 19613 1731 22 including include VBG 19613 1731 23 the the DT 19613 1731 24 Hypotyposes Hypotyposes NNPS 19613 1731 25 , , , 19613 1731 26 as as IN 19613 1731 27 to to IN 19613 1731 28 the the DT 19613 1731 29 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 1731 30 of of IN 19613 1731 31 the the DT 19613 1731 32 Holy Holy NNP 19613 1731 33 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 1731 34 ; ; : 19613 1731 35 but but CC 19613 1731 36 the the DT 19613 1731 37 attempt attempt NN 19613 1731 38 to to TO 19613 1731 39 fix fix VB 19613 1731 40 this this DT 19613 1731 41 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 1731 42 is be VBZ 19613 1731 43 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 1731 44 a a DT 19613 1731 45 dubious dubious JJ 19613 1731 46 one one NN 19613 1731 47 , , , 19613 1731 48 because because IN 19613 1731 49 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1731 50 's 's POS 19613 1731 51 " " `` 19613 1731 52 canon canon NN 19613 1731 53 of of IN 19613 1731 54 the the DT 19613 1731 55 New New NNP 19613 1731 56 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1731 57 " " '' 19613 1731 58 was be VBD 19613 1731 59 not not RB 19613 1731 60 yet yet RB 19613 1731 61 finally finally RB 19613 1731 62 fixed fix VBN 19613 1731 63 . . . 19613 1732 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1732 2 may may MD 19613 1732 3 be be VB 19613 1732 4 compared compare VBN 19613 1732 5 to to IN 19613 1732 6 a a DT 19613 1732 7 half half RB 19613 1732 8 - - HYPH 19613 1732 9 finished finished JJ 19613 1732 10 statue statue NN 19613 1732 11 whose whose WP$ 19613 1732 12 bust bust NN 19613 1732 13 is be VBZ 19613 1732 14 already already RB 19613 1732 15 completely completely RB 19613 1732 16 chiselled chisel VBN 19613 1732 17 , , , 19613 1732 18 while while IN 19613 1732 19 the the DT 19613 1732 20 under under JJ 19613 1732 21 parts part NNS 19613 1732 22 are be VBP 19613 1732 23 still still RB 19613 1732 24 embedded embed VBN 19613 1732 25 in in IN 19613 1732 26 the the DT 19613 1732 27 stone stone NN 19613 1732 28 . . . 19613 1732 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1733 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1733 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1733 3 120 120 CD 19613 1733 4 : : : 19613 1733 5 No no RB 19613 1733 6 greater great JJR 19613 1733 7 creative creative JJ 19613 1733 8 act act NN 19613 1733 9 can can MD 19613 1733 10 be be VB 19613 1733 11 mentioned mention VBN 19613 1733 12 in in IN 19613 1733 13 the the DT 19613 1733 14 whole whole JJ 19613 1733 15 history history NN 19613 1733 16 of of IN 19613 1733 17 the the DT 19613 1733 18 Church Church NNP 19613 1733 19 than than IN 19613 1733 20 the the DT 19613 1733 21 formation formation NN 19613 1733 22 of of IN 19613 1733 23 the the DT 19613 1733 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1733 25 collection collection NN 19613 1733 26 and and CC 19613 1733 27 the the DT 19613 1733 28 assigning assigning NN 19613 1733 29 to to IN 19613 1733 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1733 31 of of IN 19613 1733 32 a a DT 19613 1733 33 position position NN 19613 1733 34 of of IN 19613 1733 35 equal equal JJ 19613 1733 36 rank rank NN 19613 1733 37 with with IN 19613 1733 38 the the DT 19613 1733 39 Old Old NNP 19613 1733 40 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1733 41 . . . 19613 1733 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1734 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1734 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1734 3 121 121 CD 19613 1734 4 : : : 19613 1734 5 The the DT 19613 1734 6 history history NN 19613 1734 7 of of IN 19613 1734 8 early early JJ 19613 1734 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 1734 10 writings writing NNS 19613 1734 11 in in IN 19613 1734 12 the the DT 19613 1734 13 Church Church NNP 19613 1734 14 which which WDT 19613 1734 15 were be VBD 19613 1734 16 not not RB 19613 1734 17 definitely definitely RB 19613 1734 18 admitted admit VBN 19613 1734 19 into into IN 19613 1734 20 the the DT 19613 1734 21 New New NNP 19613 1734 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1734 23 is be VBZ 19613 1734 24 instructive instructive JJ 19613 1734 25 on on IN 19613 1734 26 this this DT 19613 1734 27 point point NN 19613 1734 28 . . . 19613 1735 1 The the DT 19613 1735 2 fate fate NN 19613 1735 3 of of IN 19613 1735 4 some some DT 19613 1735 5 of of IN 19613 1735 6 these these DT 19613 1735 7 may may MD 19613 1735 8 be be VB 19613 1735 9 described describe VBN 19613 1735 10 as as IN 19613 1735 11 tragical tragical JJ 19613 1735 12 . . . 19613 1736 1 Even even RB 19613 1736 2 when when WRB 19613 1736 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1736 4 were be VBD 19613 1736 5 not not RB 19613 1736 6 branded brand VBN 19613 1736 7 as as IN 19613 1736 8 downright downright JJ 19613 1736 9 forgeries forgery NNS 19613 1736 10 , , , 19613 1736 11 the the DT 19613 1736 12 writings writing NNS 19613 1736 13 of of IN 19613 1736 14 the the DT 19613 1736 15 Fathers father NNS 19613 1736 16 from from IN 19613 1736 17 the the DT 19613 1736 18 fourth fourth JJ 19613 1736 19 century century NN 19613 1736 20 downwards downward NNS 19613 1736 21 were be VBD 19613 1736 22 far far RB 19613 1736 23 preferred prefer VBN 19613 1736 24 to to IN 19613 1736 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 1736 26 . . . 19613 1736 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1737 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1737 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1737 3 122 122 CD 19613 1737 4 : : : 19613 1737 5 See see VB 19613 1737 6 on on IN 19613 1737 7 this this DT 19613 1737 8 point point NN 19613 1737 9 Overbeck overbeck NN 19613 1737 10 " " `` 19613 1737 11 Abhandlung Abhandlung NNP 19613 1737 12 über über NN 19613 1737 13 die die VBP 19613 1737 14 Anfange Anfange NNP 19613 1737 15 der der VBD 19613 1737 16 patristischen patristischen NNP 19613 1737 17 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 1737 18 , , , 19613 1737 19 " " '' 19613 1737 20 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1737 21 . . NNP 19613 1737 22 , , , 19613 1737 23 p. p. NN 19613 1737 24 469 469 CD 19613 1737 25 . . . 19613 1738 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 1738 2 , , , 19613 1738 3 even even RB 19613 1738 4 after after IN 19613 1738 5 the the DT 19613 1738 6 creation creation NN 19613 1738 7 of of IN 19613 1738 8 the the DT 19613 1738 9 New New NNP 19613 1738 10 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1738 11 canon canon NN 19613 1738 12 , , , 19613 1738 13 theological theological JJ 19613 1738 14 authorship authorship NN 19613 1738 15 was be VBD 19613 1738 16 an an DT 19613 1738 17 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 1738 18 which which WDT 19613 1738 19 was be VBD 19613 1738 20 at at IN 19613 1738 21 first first RB 19613 1738 22 regarded regard VBN 19613 1738 23 as as RB 19613 1738 24 highly highly RB 19613 1738 25 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 1738 26 . . . 19613 1739 1 See see VB 19613 1739 2 the the DT 19613 1739 3 Antimontanist Antimontanist NNP 19613 1739 4 in in IN 19613 1739 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1739 6 . . NNP 19613 1739 7 , , , 19613 1739 8 H. H. NNP 19613 1739 9 E. E. NNP 19613 1739 10 V. V. NNP 19613 1739 11 16 16 CD 19613 1739 12 . . . 19613 1740 1 3 3 LS 19613 1740 2 : : : 19613 1740 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1740 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1740 5 : : : 19613 1740 6 dediôs dediôs NNP 19613 1740 7 kai kai NNP 19613 1740 8 exeulaboumenos exeulaboumenos NNP 19613 1740 9 , , , 19613 1740 10 mê mê NNP 19613 1740 11 pê pê NNP 19613 1740 12 doxô doxô NNP 19613 1740 13 prin prin NNP 19613 1740 14 episungraphein episungraphein NNP 19613 1740 15 ê ê NNP 19613 1740 16 epidiatassesthai epidiatassesthai NNP 19613 1740 17 tô tô NNP 19613 1740 18 tês tês NNP 19613 1740 19 tou tou NNP 19613 1740 20 euangeliou euangeliou NNP 19613 1740 21 kainês kainês NNP 19613 1740 22 diathêkês diathêkês NNP 19613 1740 23 logô logô NNP 19613 1740 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1740 25 . . . 19613 1741 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1741 2 find find VBP 19613 1741 3 similar similar JJ 19613 1741 4 remarks remark NNS 19613 1741 5 in in IN 19613 1741 6 other other JJ 19613 1741 7 old old JJ 19613 1741 8 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1741 9 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 1741 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1741 11 see see VB 19613 1741 12 Clemen Clemen NNP 19613 1741 13 . . . 19613 1742 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 1742 2 . . . 19613 1742 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1742 4 . . . 19613 1742 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1743 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1743 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1743 3 123 123 CD 19613 1743 4 : : : 19613 1743 5 But but CC 19613 1743 6 how how WRB 19613 1743 7 diverse diverse JJ 19613 1743 8 were be VBD 19613 1743 9 the the DT 19613 1743 10 expositions exposition NNS 19613 1743 11 ; ; : 19613 1743 12 compare compare VB 19613 1743 13 the the DT 19613 1743 14 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 1743 15 of of IN 19613 1743 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1743 17 and and CC 19613 1743 18 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1743 19 , , , 19613 1743 20 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 1743 21 . . . 19613 1744 1 II II NNP 19613 1744 2 . . . 19613 1744 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1745 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1745 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1745 3 124 124 CD 19613 1745 4 : : : 19613 1745 5 On on IN 19613 1745 6 the the DT 19613 1745 7 extent extent NN 19613 1745 8 to to TO 19613 1745 9 which which WDT 19613 1745 10 the the DT 19613 1745 11 Old Old NNP 19613 1745 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1745 13 had have VBD 19613 1745 14 become become VBN 19613 1745 15 subordinated subordinated JJ 19613 1745 16 to to IN 19613 1745 17 the the DT 19613 1745 18 New New NNP 19613 1745 19 and and CC 19613 1745 20 the the DT 19613 1745 21 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 1745 22 to to IN 19613 1745 23 the the DT 19613 1745 24 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1745 25 , , , 19613 1745 26 since since IN 19613 1745 27 the the DT 19613 1745 28 end end NN 19613 1745 29 of of IN 19613 1745 30 the the DT 19613 1745 31 second second JJ 19613 1745 32 century century NN 19613 1745 33 , , , 19613 1745 34 see see VB 19613 1745 35 the the DT 19613 1745 36 following follow VBG 19613 1745 37 passage passage NN 19613 1745 38 from from IN 19613 1745 39 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 1745 40 , , , 19613 1745 41 de de FW 19613 1745 42 trinit trinit NN 19613 1745 43 . . . 19613 1746 1 29 29 CD 19613 1746 2 : : : 19613 1746 3 " " `` 19613 1746 4 Unus Unus NNP 19613 1746 5 ergo ergo FW 19613 1746 6 et et FW 19613 1746 7 idem idem NN 19613 1746 8 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 1746 9 qui qui NN 19613 1746 10 in in IN 19613 1746 11 prophetis prophetis NN 19613 1746 12 et et FW 19613 1746 13 apostolis apostolis NNPS 19613 1746 14 , , , 19613 1746 15 nisi nisi NNP 19613 1746 16 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 1746 17 ibi ibi NNP 19613 1746 18 ad ad NN 19613 1746 19 momentum momentum NN 19613 1746 20 , , , 19613 1746 21 hic hic JJ 19613 1746 22 semper semper NN 19613 1746 23 . . . 19613 1747 1 Ceterum Ceterum NNP 19613 1747 2 ibi ibi FW 19613 1747 3 non non AFX 19613 1747 4 ut ut NNP 19613 1747 5 semper semper NN 19613 1747 6 in in IN 19613 1747 7 illis illis NNP 19613 1747 8 inesset inesset NNP 19613 1747 9 , , , 19613 1747 10 hic hic JJ 19613 1747 11 ut ut UH 19613 1747 12 in in IN 19613 1747 13 illis illis NNP 19613 1747 14 semper semper NNP 19613 1747 15 maneret maneret NNP 19613 1747 16 , , , 19613 1747 17 et et NNP 19613 1747 18 ibi ibi NNP 19613 1747 19 mediocriter mediocriter NNP 19613 1747 20 distributus distributus NNP 19613 1747 21 , , , 19613 1747 22 hic hic JJ 19613 1747 23 totus totus NN 19613 1747 24 effusus effusus NNP 19613 1747 25 , , , 19613 1747 26 ibi ibi NNP 19613 1747 27 parce parce NN 19613 1747 28 datus datus NN 19613 1747 29 , , , 19613 1747 30 hic hic JJ 19613 1747 31 large large JJ 19613 1747 32 commodatus commodatus NN 19613 1747 33 . . . 19613 1747 34 " " '' 19613 1747 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1748 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1748 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1748 3 125 125 CD 19613 1748 4 : : : 19613 1748 5 That that DT 19613 1748 6 may may MD 19613 1748 7 be be VB 19613 1748 8 shown show VBN 19613 1748 9 in in IN 19613 1748 10 all all PDT 19613 1748 11 the the DT 19613 1748 12 old old JJ 19613 1748 13 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1748 14 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 1748 15 , , , 19613 1748 16 but but CC 19613 1748 17 most most RBS 19613 1748 18 plainly plainly RB 19613 1748 19 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1748 20 in in IN 19613 1748 21 the the DT 19613 1748 22 theology theology NN 19613 1748 23 of of IN 19613 1748 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1748 25 . . . 19613 1749 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 1749 2 , , , 19613 1749 3 the the DT 19613 1749 4 subordination subordination NN 19613 1749 5 of of IN 19613 1749 6 the the DT 19613 1749 7 Old Old NNP 19613 1749 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1749 9 revelation revelation NN 19613 1749 10 to to IN 19613 1749 11 the the DT 19613 1749 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 1749 13 one one NN 19613 1749 14 is be VBZ 19613 1749 15 not not RB 19613 1749 16 simply simply RB 19613 1749 17 a a DT 19613 1749 18 result result NN 19613 1749 19 of of IN 19613 1749 20 the the DT 19613 1749 21 creation creation NN 19613 1749 22 of of IN 19613 1749 23 the the DT 19613 1749 24 New New NNP 19613 1749 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1749 26 , , , 19613 1749 27 but but CC 19613 1749 28 may may MD 19613 1749 29 be be VB 19613 1749 30 explained explain VBN 19613 1749 31 by by IN 19613 1749 32 other other JJ 19613 1749 33 causes cause NNS 19613 1749 34 ; ; : 19613 1749 35 see see VB 19613 1749 36 chap chap NNP 19613 1749 37 . . . 19613 1750 1 5 5 CD 19613 1750 2 . . . 19613 1751 1 If if IN 19613 1751 2 the the DT 19613 1751 3 New New NNP 19613 1751 4 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1751 5 had have VBD 19613 1751 6 not not RB 19613 1751 7 been be VBN 19613 1751 8 formed form VBN 19613 1751 9 , , , 19613 1751 10 the the DT 19613 1751 11 Church Church NNP 19613 1751 12 would would MD 19613 1751 13 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 1751 14 have have VB 19613 1751 15 obtained obtain VBN 19613 1751 16 a a DT 19613 1751 17 Christian Christian NNP 19613 1751 18 Old Old NNP 19613 1751 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1751 20 with with IN 19613 1751 21 numerous numerous JJ 19613 1751 22 interpolations interpolation NNS 19613 1751 23 -- -- : 19613 1751 24 tendencies tendency NNS 19613 1751 25 in in IN 19613 1751 26 this this DT 19613 1751 27 direction direction NN 19613 1751 28 were be VBD 19613 1751 29 not not RB 19613 1751 30 wanting want VBG 19613 1751 31 : : : 19613 1751 32 see see VB 19613 1751 33 vol vol NNP 19613 1751 34 . . . 19613 1752 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1752 2 , , , 19613 1752 3 p. p. NN 19613 1752 4 114 114 CD 19613 1752 5 f.--and f.--and CC 19613 1752 6 increased increase VBD 19613 1752 7 in in IN 19613 1752 8 extent extent NN 19613 1752 9 by by IN 19613 1752 10 the the DT 19613 1752 11 admission admission NN 19613 1752 12 of of IN 19613 1752 13 apocalypses apocalypse NNS 19613 1752 14 . . . 19613 1753 1 The the DT 19613 1753 2 creation creation NN 19613 1753 3 of of IN 19613 1753 4 the the DT 19613 1753 5 New New NNP 19613 1753 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1753 7 preserved preserve VBD 19613 1753 8 the the DT 19613 1753 9 purity purity NN 19613 1753 10 of of IN 19613 1753 11 the the DT 19613 1753 12 Old Old NNP 19613 1753 13 , , , 19613 1753 14 for for IN 19613 1753 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1753 16 removed remove VBD 19613 1753 17 the the DT 19613 1753 18 need need NN 19613 1753 19 of of IN 19613 1753 20 doing do VBG 19613 1753 21 violence violence NN 19613 1753 22 to to IN 19613 1753 23 the the DT 19613 1753 24 latter latter JJ 19613 1753 25 in in IN 19613 1753 26 the the DT 19613 1753 27 interests interest NNS 19613 1753 28 of of IN 19613 1753 29 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1753 30 . . . 19613 1753 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1754 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1754 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1754 3 126 126 CD 19613 1754 4 : : : 19613 1754 5 The the DT 19613 1754 6 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1754 7 Church Church NNP 19613 1754 8 had have VBD 19613 1754 9 from from IN 19613 1754 10 the the DT 19613 1754 11 beginning beginning NN 19613 1754 12 a a DT 19613 1754 13 very very RB 19613 1754 14 clear clear JJ 19613 1754 15 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 1754 16 of of IN 19613 1754 17 the the DT 19613 1754 18 dangerousness dangerousness NN 19613 1754 19 of of IN 19613 1754 20 many many JJ 19613 1754 21 New New NNP 19613 1754 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1754 23 writings writing NNS 19613 1754 24 , , , 19613 1754 25 in in IN 19613 1754 26 fact fact NN 19613 1754 27 she -PRON- PRP 19613 1754 28 made make VBD 19613 1754 29 a a DT 19613 1754 30 virtue virtue NN 19613 1754 31 of of IN 19613 1754 32 necessity necessity NN 19613 1754 33 in in IN 19613 1754 34 so so RB 19613 1754 35 far far RB 19613 1754 36 as as IN 19613 1754 37 she -PRON- PRP 19613 1754 38 set set VBD 19613 1754 39 up up RP 19613 1754 40 a a DT 19613 1754 41 theory theory NN 19613 1754 42 to to TO 19613 1754 43 prove prove VB 19613 1754 44 the the DT 19613 1754 45 unavoidableness unavoidableness NN 19613 1754 46 of of IN 19613 1754 47 this this DT 19613 1754 48 danger danger NN 19613 1754 49 . . . 19613 1755 1 See see VB 19613 1755 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1755 3 , , , 19613 1755 4 de de NNP 19613 1755 5 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1755 6 . . . 19613 1756 1 passim passim NNP 19613 1756 2 , , , 19613 1756 3 and and CC 19613 1756 4 de de NNP 19613 1756 5 resurr resurr NNP 19613 1756 6 . . . 19613 1757 1 63 63 CD 19613 1757 2 . . . 19613 1757 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1758 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1758 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1758 3 127 127 CD 19613 1758 4 : : : 19613 1758 5 To to IN 19613 1758 6 a a DT 19613 1758 7 certain certain JJ 19613 1758 8 extent extent NN 19613 1758 9 the the DT 19613 1758 10 New New NNP 19613 1758 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1758 12 disturbs disturb NNS 19613 1758 13 and and CC 19613 1758 14 prevents prevent VBZ 19613 1758 15 the the DT 19613 1758 16 tendency tendency NN 19613 1758 17 to to TO 19613 1758 18 summarise summarise VB 19613 1758 19 the the DT 19613 1758 20 faith faith NN 19613 1758 21 and and CC 19613 1758 22 reduce reduce VB 19613 1758 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1758 24 to to IN 19613 1758 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1758 26 most most RBS 19613 1758 27 essential essential JJ 19613 1758 28 content content NN 19613 1758 29 . . . 19613 1759 1 For for IN 19613 1759 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1759 3 not not RB 19613 1759 4 only only RB 19613 1759 5 puts put VBZ 19613 1759 6 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1759 7 in in IN 19613 1759 8 the the DT 19613 1759 9 place place NN 19613 1759 10 of of IN 19613 1759 11 the the DT 19613 1759 12 unity unity NN 19613 1759 13 of of IN 19613 1759 14 a a DT 19613 1759 15 system system NN 19613 1759 16 , , , 19613 1759 17 but but CC 19613 1759 18 frequently frequently RB 19613 1759 19 also also RB 19613 1759 20 in in IN 19613 1759 21 the the DT 19613 1759 22 place place NN 19613 1759 23 of of IN 19613 1759 24 a a DT 19613 1759 25 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 1759 26 and and CC 19613 1759 27 complete complete JJ 19613 1759 28 creed creed NN 19613 1759 29 . . . 19613 1760 1 Hence hence RB 19613 1760 2 the the DT 19613 1760 3 rule rule NN 19613 1760 4 of of IN 19613 1760 5 faith faith NN 19613 1760 6 is be VBZ 19613 1760 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 1760 8 as as IN 19613 1760 9 a a DT 19613 1760 10 guiding guide VBG 19613 1760 11 principle principle NN 19613 1760 12 , , , 19613 1760 13 and and CC 19613 1760 14 even even RB 19613 1760 15 an an DT 19613 1760 16 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 1760 17 one one NN 19613 1760 18 is be VBZ 19613 1760 19 better well JJR 19613 1760 20 than than IN 19613 1760 21 a a DT 19613 1760 22 mere mere JJ 19613 1760 23 haphazard haphazard NN 19613 1760 24 reliance reliance NN 19613 1760 25 upon upon IN 19613 1760 26 the the DT 19613 1760 27 Bible Bible NNP 19613 1760 28 . . . 19613 1760 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1761 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1761 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1761 3 128 128 CD 19613 1761 4 : : : 19613 1761 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1761 6 must must MD 19613 1761 7 not not RB 19613 1761 8 , , , 19613 1761 9 however however RB 19613 1761 10 , , , 19613 1761 11 ascribe ascribe VBP 19613 1761 12 that that DT 19613 1761 13 to to IN 19613 1761 14 conscious conscious JJ 19613 1761 15 mistrust mistrust NN 19613 1761 16 , , , 19613 1761 17 for for IN 19613 1761 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1761 19 and and CC 19613 1761 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1761 21 bear bear NN 19613 1761 22 very very RB 19613 1761 23 decided decide VBD 19613 1761 24 testimony testimony NN 19613 1761 25 against against IN 19613 1761 26 such such PDT 19613 1761 27 an an DT 19613 1761 28 idea idea NN 19613 1761 29 , , , 19613 1761 30 but but CC 19613 1761 31 to to IN 19613 1761 32 the the DT 19613 1761 33 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 1761 34 that that IN 19613 1761 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1761 36 was be VBD 19613 1761 37 impossible impossible JJ 19613 1761 38 to to TO 19613 1761 39 make make VB 19613 1761 40 any any DT 19613 1761 41 effective effective JJ 19613 1761 42 use use NN 19613 1761 43 of of IN 19613 1761 44 the the DT 19613 1761 45 New New NNP 19613 1761 46 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1761 47 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 1761 48 in in IN 19613 1761 49 arguments argument NNS 19613 1761 50 with with IN 19613 1761 51 educated educate VBN 19613 1761 52 non non NNS 19613 1761 53 - - NNS 19613 1761 54 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 1761 55 and and CC 19613 1761 56 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1761 57 . . . 19613 1762 1 For for IN 19613 1762 2 these these DT 19613 1762 3 writings writing NNS 19613 1762 4 could could MD 19613 1762 5 carry carry VB 19613 1762 6 no no DT 19613 1762 7 weight weight NN 19613 1762 8 with with IN 19613 1762 9 the the DT 19613 1762 10 former former JJ 19613 1762 11 , , , 19613 1762 12 and and CC 19613 1762 13 the the DT 19613 1762 14 latter latter JJ 19613 1762 15 either either CC 19613 1762 16 did do VBD 19613 1762 17 not not RB 19613 1762 18 recognise recognise VB 19613 1762 19 them -PRON- PRP 19613 1762 20 or or CC 19613 1762 21 else else RB 19613 1762 22 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 1762 23 them -PRON- PRP 19613 1762 24 by by IN 19613 1762 25 different different JJ 19613 1762 26 rules rule NNS 19613 1762 27 . . . 19613 1763 1 Even even RB 19613 1763 2 the the DT 19613 1763 3 offer offer NN 19613 1763 4 of of IN 19613 1763 5 several several JJ 19613 1763 6 of of IN 19613 1763 7 the the DT 19613 1763 8 Fathers father NNS 19613 1763 9 to to TO 19613 1763 10 refute refute VB 19613 1763 11 the the DT 19613 1763 12 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 1763 13 from from IN 19613 1763 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1763 15 own own JJ 19613 1763 16 canon canon NN 19613 1763 17 must must MD 19613 1763 18 by by IN 19613 1763 19 no no DT 19613 1763 20 means means NN 19613 1763 21 be be VB 19613 1763 22 attributed attribute VBN 19613 1763 23 to to IN 19613 1763 24 an an DT 19613 1763 25 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 1763 26 on on IN 19613 1763 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1763 28 part part NN 19613 1763 29 with with IN 19613 1763 30 regard regard NN 19613 1763 31 to to IN 19613 1763 32 the the DT 19613 1763 33 authority authority NN 19613 1763 34 of of IN 19613 1763 35 the the DT 19613 1763 36 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1763 37 canon canon NN 19613 1763 38 of of IN 19613 1763 39 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 1763 40 . . . 19613 1764 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1764 2 need need VBP 19613 1764 3 merely merely RB 19613 1764 4 add add VB 19613 1764 5 that that IN 19613 1764 6 the the DT 19613 1764 7 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 1764 8 difficulty difficulty NN 19613 1764 9 originally originally RB 19613 1764 10 felt feel VBN 19613 1764 11 by by IN 19613 1764 12 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 1764 13 in in IN 19613 1764 14 conceiving conceive VBG 19613 1764 15 the the DT 19613 1764 16 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 1764 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 1764 18 , , , 19613 1764 19 for for IN 19613 1764 20 instance instance NN 19613 1764 21 , , , 19613 1764 22 to to TO 19613 1764 23 be be VB 19613 1764 24 analogous analogous JJ 19613 1764 25 and and CC 19613 1764 26 equal equal JJ 19613 1764 27 in in IN 19613 1764 28 value value NN 19613 1764 29 to to IN 19613 1764 30 Genesis Genesis NNP 19613 1764 31 or or CC 19613 1764 32 the the DT 19613 1764 33 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1764 34 occasionally occasionally RB 19613 1764 35 appears appear VBZ 19613 1764 36 in in IN 19613 1764 37 the the DT 19613 1764 38 terminology terminology NN 19613 1764 39 even even RB 19613 1764 40 in in IN 19613 1764 41 the the DT 19613 1764 42 third third JJ 19613 1764 43 century century NN 19613 1764 44 , , , 19613 1764 45 in in IN 19613 1764 46 so so RB 19613 1764 47 far far RB 19613 1764 48 as as IN 19613 1764 49 the the DT 19613 1764 50 term term NN 19613 1764 51 " " `` 19613 1764 52 divine divine JJ 19613 1764 53 writings writing NNS 19613 1764 54 " " '' 19613 1764 55 continues continue VBZ 19613 1764 56 to to TO 19613 1764 57 be be VB 19613 1764 58 more more RBR 19613 1764 59 frequently frequently RB 19613 1764 60 applied apply VBN 19613 1764 61 to to IN 19613 1764 62 the the DT 19613 1764 63 Old Old NNP 19613 1764 64 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1764 65 than than IN 19613 1764 66 to to IN 19613 1764 67 certain certain JJ 19613 1764 68 parts part NNS 19613 1764 69 of of IN 19613 1764 70 the the DT 19613 1764 71 New New NNP 19613 1764 72 . . . 19613 1764 73 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1765 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1765 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1765 3 129 129 CD 19613 1765 4 : : : 19613 1765 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1765 6 , , , 19613 1765 7 in in IN 19613 1765 8 de de NNP 19613 1765 9 corona corona NNP 19613 1765 10 3 3 CD 19613 1765 11 , , , 19613 1765 12 makes make VBZ 19613 1765 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1765 14 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 1765 15 opponent opponent NN 19613 1765 16 say say VB 19613 1765 17 : : : 19613 1765 18 " " `` 19613 1765 19 Etiam Etiam NNP 19613 1765 20 in in IN 19613 1765 21 traditionis traditionis NNP 19613 1765 22 obtentu obtentu NNP 19613 1765 23 exigenda exigenda NNP 19613 1765 24 est est NNP 19613 1765 25 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 19613 1765 26 scripta scripta NNP 19613 1765 27 . . . 19613 1765 28 " " '' 19613 1765 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1766 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1766 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1766 3 130 130 CD 19613 1766 4 : : : 19613 1766 5 Hatch Hatch NNP 19613 1766 6 , , , 19613 1766 7 Organisation Organisation NNP 19613 1766 8 of of IN 19613 1766 9 the the DT 19613 1766 10 early early JJ 19613 1766 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 1766 12 Church Church NNP 19613 1766 13 , , , 19613 1766 14 1883 1883 CD 19613 1766 15 . . . 19613 1767 1 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 1767 2 , , , 19613 1767 3 Die Die NNP 19613 1767 4 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 1767 5 der der NN 19613 1767 6 zwölf zwölf NNP 19613 1767 7 Apostel Apostel NNP 19613 1767 8 , , , 19613 1767 9 1884 1884 CD 19613 1767 10 . . . 19613 1768 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 1768 2 , , , 19613 1768 3 Kirchenrecht Kirchenrecht NNP 19613 1768 4 , , , 19613 1768 5 Vol Vol NNP 19613 1768 6 . . . 19613 1769 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1770 1 1892 1892 CD 19613 1770 2 . . . 19613 1770 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1771 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1771 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1771 3 131 131 CD 19613 1771 4 : : : 19613 1771 5 Marcion marcion NN 19613 1771 6 was be VBD 19613 1771 7 the the DT 19613 1771 8 only only JJ 19613 1771 9 one one CD 19613 1771 10 who who WP 19613 1771 11 did do VBD 19613 1771 12 not not RB 19613 1771 13 claim claim VB 19613 1771 14 to to TO 19613 1771 15 prove prove VB 19613 1771 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1771 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1771 18 from from IN 19613 1771 19 traditions tradition NNS 19613 1771 20 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 1771 21 as as IN 19613 1771 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1771 23 rather rather RB 19613 1771 24 put put VBD 19613 1771 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1771 26 in in IN 19613 1771 27 opposition opposition NN 19613 1771 28 to to IN 19613 1771 29 tradition tradition NN 19613 1771 30 . . . 19613 1772 1 This this DT 19613 1772 2 disclaimer disclaimer NN 19613 1772 3 of of IN 19613 1772 4 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 1772 5 is be VBZ 19613 1772 6 in in IN 19613 1772 7 keeping keep VBG 19613 1772 8 with with IN 19613 1772 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1772 10 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 1772 11 of of IN 19613 1772 12 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 1772 13 proof proof NN 19613 1772 14 , , , 19613 1772 15 whilst whilst RB 19613 1772 16 , , , 19613 1772 17 conversely conversely RB 19613 1772 18 , , , 19613 1772 19 in in IN 19613 1772 20 the the DT 19613 1772 21 Church Church NNP 19613 1772 22 the the DT 19613 1772 23 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 1772 24 proof proof NN 19613 1772 25 , , , 19613 1772 26 and and CC 19613 1772 27 the the DT 19613 1772 28 proof proof NN 19613 1772 29 from from IN 19613 1772 30 tradition tradition NN 19613 1772 31 adduced adduce VBN 19613 1772 32 against against IN 19613 1772 33 the the DT 19613 1772 34 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1772 35 , , , 19613 1772 36 were be VBD 19613 1772 37 closely closely RB 19613 1772 38 related related JJ 19613 1772 39 . . . 19613 1773 1 In in IN 19613 1773 2 the the DT 19613 1773 3 one one CD 19613 1773 4 case case NN 19613 1773 5 the the DT 19613 1773 6 truth truth NN 19613 1773 7 of of IN 19613 1773 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1773 9 was be VBD 19613 1773 10 proved prove VBN 19613 1773 11 by by IN 19613 1773 12 showing show VBG 19613 1773 13 that that IN 19613 1773 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1773 15 is be VBZ 19613 1773 16 the the DT 19613 1773 17 oldest old JJS 19613 1773 18 religion religion NN 19613 1773 19 , , , 19613 1773 20 and and CC 19613 1773 21 in in IN 19613 1773 22 the the DT 19613 1773 23 other other JJ 19613 1773 24 the the DT 19613 1773 25 truth truth NN 19613 1773 26 of of IN 19613 1773 27 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1773 28 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1773 29 was be VBD 19613 1773 30 established establish VBN 19613 1773 31 from from IN 19613 1773 32 the the DT 19613 1773 33 thesis thesis NN 19613 1773 34 that that IN 19613 1773 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1773 36 is be VBZ 19613 1773 37 the the DT 19613 1773 38 oldest old JJS 19613 1773 39 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1773 40 , , , 19613 1773 41 viz viz NN 19613 1773 42 . . NNP 19613 1773 43 , , , 19613 1773 44 that that DT 19613 1773 45 of of IN 19613 1773 46 the the DT 19613 1773 47 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1773 48 . . . 19613 1773 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1774 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1774 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1774 3 132 132 CD 19613 1774 4 : : : 19613 1774 5 See see VB 19613 1774 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1774 7 , , , 19613 1774 8 de de NNP 19613 1774 9 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1774 10 . . . 19613 1775 1 20 20 CD 19613 1775 2 , , , 19613 1775 3 21 21 CD 19613 1775 4 , , , 19613 1775 5 32 32 CD 19613 1775 6 . . . 19613 1775 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1776 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1776 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1776 3 133 133 CD 19613 1776 4 : : : 19613 1776 5 This this DT 19613 1776 6 theory theory NN 19613 1776 7 is be VBZ 19613 1776 8 maintained maintain VBN 19613 1776 9 by by IN 19613 1776 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1776 11 and and CC 19613 1776 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1776 13 , , , 19613 1776 14 and and CC 19613 1776 15 is be VBZ 19613 1776 16 as as RB 19613 1776 17 old old JJ 19613 1776 18 as as IN 19613 1776 19 the the DT 19613 1776 20 association association NN 19613 1776 21 of of IN 19613 1776 22 the the DT 19613 1776 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1776 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1776 25 : : : 19613 1776 26 hagia hagia NNP 19613 1776 27 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 1776 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1776 29 and and CC 19613 1776 30 the the DT 19613 1776 31 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1776 32 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1776 33 : : : 19613 1776 34 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 1776 35 hagion hagion NNP 19613 1776 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1776 37 . . . 19613 1777 1 Just just RB 19613 1777 2 for for IN 19613 1777 3 that that DT 19613 1777 4 reason reason NN 19613 1777 5 the the DT 19613 1777 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 1777 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1777 8 make make VBP 19613 1777 9 between between IN 19613 1777 10 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 1777 11 founded found VBN 19613 1777 12 by by IN 19613 1777 13 the the DT 19613 1777 14 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1777 15 and and CC 19613 1777 16 those those DT 19613 1777 17 of of IN 19613 1777 18 later later JJ 19613 1777 19 origin origin NN 19613 1777 20 is be VBZ 19613 1777 21 of of IN 19613 1777 22 chief chief JJ 19613 1777 23 value value NN 19613 1777 24 to to IN 19613 1777 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 1777 26 in in IN 19613 1777 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1777 28 arguments argument NNS 19613 1777 29 against against IN 19613 1777 30 heretics heretic NNS 19613 1777 31 . . . 19613 1778 1 This this DT 19613 1778 2 distinction distinction NN 19613 1778 3 , , , 19613 1778 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1778 5 may may MD 19613 1778 6 be be VB 19613 1778 7 remarked remark VBN 19613 1778 8 , , , 19613 1778 9 is be VBZ 19613 1778 10 clearly clearly RB 19613 1778 11 expressed express VBN 19613 1778 12 in in IN 19613 1778 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1778 14 alone alone RB 19613 1778 15 . . . 19613 1779 1 Here here RB 19613 1779 2 , , , 19613 1779 3 for for IN 19613 1779 4 example example NN 19613 1779 5 , , , 19613 1779 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1779 7 is be VBZ 19613 1779 8 of of IN 19613 1779 9 importance importance NN 19613 1779 10 that that IN 19613 1779 11 the the DT 19613 1779 12 Church Church NNP 19613 1779 13 of of IN 19613 1779 14 Carthage Carthage NNP 19613 1779 15 derives derive VBZ 19613 1779 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1779 17 " " `` 19613 1779 18 authority authority NN 19613 1779 19 " " '' 19613 1779 20 from from IN 19613 1779 21 that that DT 19613 1779 22 of of IN 19613 1779 23 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1779 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1779 25 de de NNP 19613 1779 26 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1779 27 . . . 19613 1780 1 36 36 CD 19613 1780 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1780 3 . . . 19613 1780 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1781 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1781 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1781 3 134 134 CD 19613 1781 4 : : : 19613 1781 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1781 6 . . NNP 19613 1781 7 , , , 19613 1781 8 de de NNP 19613 1781 9 præscr præscr NNP 19613 1781 10 . . . 19613 1782 1 32 32 CD 19613 1782 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1782 3 see see VB 19613 1782 4 p. p. NN 19613 1782 5 19 19 CD 19613 1782 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1782 7 . . . 19613 1783 1 Iren Iren NNP 19613 1783 2 . . . 19613 1783 3 , , , 19613 1783 4 III iii CD 19613 1783 5 . . . 19613 1784 1 2 2 LS 19613 1784 2 . . . 19613 1785 1 2 2 LS 19613 1785 2 : : : 19613 1785 3 " " `` 19613 1785 4 Cum Cum NNP 19613 1785 5 autem autem NN 19613 1785 6 ad ad NN 19613 1785 7 eam eam NNP 19613 1785 8 iterum iterum NNP 19613 1785 9 traditionem traditionem NNP 19613 1785 10 , , , 19613 1785 11 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1785 12 est est NNP 19613 1785 13 ab ab NNP 19613 1785 14 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1785 15 , , , 19613 1785 16 quæ quæ NN 19613 1785 17 per per IN 19613 1785 18 successiones successione NNS 19613 1785 19 presbyterorum presbyterorum NNP 19613 1785 20 in in IN 19613 1785 21 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 1785 22 custoditur custoditur NNP 19613 1785 23 , , , 19613 1785 24 provocamus provocamus NNP 19613 1785 25 eos eos NNP 19613 1785 26 , , , 19613 1785 27 etc etc FW 19613 1785 28 . . . 19613 1785 29 " " '' 19613 1786 1 III iii CD 19613 1786 2 . . . 19613 1787 1 3 3 LS 19613 1787 2 . . . 19613 1788 1 1 1 LS 19613 1788 2 : : : 19613 1788 3 " " `` 19613 1788 4 Traditionem Traditionem NNP 19613 1788 5 itaque itaque NN 19613 1788 6 apostolorum apostolorum NN 19613 1788 7 in in IN 19613 1788 8 toto toto NNP 19613 1788 9 mundo mundo NNP 19613 1788 10 manifestatam manifestatam NNP 19613 1788 11 in in IN 19613 1788 12 omni omni NNP 19613 1788 13 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 1788 14 adest adest NNP 19613 1788 15 perspicere perspicere RB 19613 1788 16 omnibus omnibus JJ 19613 1788 17 qui qui NNP 19613 1788 18 vera vera NNP 19613 1788 19 velint velint NNP 19613 1788 20 videre videre NNP 19613 1788 21 , , , 19613 1788 22 et et NNP 19613 1788 23 habemus habemus NNP 19613 1788 24 annumerare annumerare NNP 19613 1788 25 eos eos NNP 19613 1788 26 , , , 19613 1788 27 qui qui NNP 19613 1788 28 ab ab NNP 19613 1788 29 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1788 30 instituti instituti NNP 19613 1788 31 sunt sunt FW 19613 1788 32 episcopi episcopi NNP 19613 1788 33 in in IN 19613 1788 34 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 1788 35 et et NNP 19613 1788 36 successiones successione VBZ 19613 1788 37 eorum eorum NNP 19613 1788 38 usque usque NNP 19613 1788 39 ad ad NN 19613 1788 40 nos nos NNP 19613 1788 41 ... ... NFP 19613 1788 42 valde valde NNP 19613 1788 43 enim enim NNP 19613 1788 44 perfectos perfectos NNP 19613 1788 45 in in IN 19613 1788 46 omnibus omnibus JJ 19613 1788 47 eos eos NNP 19613 1788 48 volebant volebant NNP 19613 1788 49 esse esse NNP 19613 1788 50 , , , 19613 1788 51 quos quos NNP 19613 1788 52 et et NNP 19613 1788 53 successores successore NNS 19613 1788 54 relinquebant relinquebant NNP 19613 1788 55 , , , 19613 1788 56 suum suum NNP 19613 1788 57 ipsorum ipsorum NNP 19613 1788 58 locum locum NNP 19613 1788 59 magisterii magisterii NNP 19613 1788 60 tradentes tradente NNS 19613 1788 61 ... ... : 19613 1788 62 traditio traditio NNP 19613 1788 63 Romanæ Romanæ NNP 19613 1788 64 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ JJ 19613 1788 65 , , , 19613 1788 66 quam quam NNP 19613 1788 67 habet habet NNP 19613 1788 68 ab ab NNP 19613 1788 69 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1788 70 , , , 19613 1788 71 et et NNP 19613 1788 72 annuntiata annuntiata NNP 19613 1788 73 hominibus hominibus NNP 19613 1788 74 fides fide NNS 19613 1788 75 per per IN 19613 1788 76 successiones successione NNS 19613 1788 77 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 1788 78 perveniens perveniens NNPS 19613 1788 79 usque usque NNP 19613 1788 80 ad ad NN 19613 1788 81 nos nos NN 19613 1788 82 . . . 19613 1788 83 " " '' 19613 1789 1 III iii CD 19613 1789 2 . . . 19613 1790 1 3 3 LS 19613 1790 2 . . . 19613 1791 1 4 4 CD 19613 1791 2 , , , 19613 1791 3 4 4 CD 19613 1791 4 . . . 19613 1792 1 1 1 LS 19613 1792 2 : : : 19613 1792 3 " " `` 19613 1792 4 Si Si NNP 19613 1792 5 de de NNP 19613 1792 6 aliqua aliqua NNP 19613 1792 7 modica modica NNP 19613 1792 8 qusestione qusestione NNP 19613 1792 9 disceptatio disceptatio NNP 19613 1792 10 esset esset NN 19613 1792 11 , , , 19613 1792 12 nonne nonne NNP 19613 1792 13 oporteret oporteret NN 19613 1792 14 in in IN 19613 1792 15 antiquissimas antiquissimas NNP 19613 1792 16 recurrere recurrere NNP 19613 1792 17 ecclesias ecclesias NNP 19613 1792 18 , , , 19613 1792 19 in in IN 19613 1792 20 quibus quibus NNP 19613 1792 21 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1792 22 conversati conversati NNP 19613 1792 23 sunt sunt JJR 19613 1792 24 ... ... NFP 19613 1792 25 quid quid NNP 19613 1792 26 autem autem NNP 19613 1792 27 si si NNP 19613 1792 28 neque neque FW 19613 1792 29 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1792 30 quidem quidem NNP 19613 1792 31 scripturas scripturas NNPS 19613 1792 32 reliquissent reliquissent NNP 19613 1792 33 nobis nobis NNP 19613 1792 34 , , , 19613 1792 35 nonne nonne NNP 19613 1792 36 oportebat oportebat NNP 19613 1792 37 ordinem ordinem NNP 19613 1792 38 sequi sequi NNP 19613 1792 39 traditionis traditionis NNP 19613 1792 40 , , , 19613 1792 41 quam quam NNP 19613 1792 42 tradiderunt tradiderunt NNP 19613 1792 43 iis iis NNP 19613 1792 44 , , , 19613 1792 45 quibus quibus NNP 19613 1792 46 committebant committebant NNP 19613 1792 47 ecclesias ecclesia NNS 19613 1792 48 ? ? . 19613 1792 49 " " '' 19613 1793 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1793 2 . . . 19613 1794 1 33 33 CD 19613 1794 2 . . . 19613 1795 1 8 8 LS 19613 1795 2 : : : 19613 1795 3 " " `` 19613 1795 4 Character Character NNP 19613 1795 5 corporis corporis NNP 19613 1795 6 Christi Christi NNP 19613 1795 7 secundum secundum NN 19613 1795 8 successiones successione VBZ 19613 1795 9 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 1795 10 , , , 19613 1795 11 quibus quibus NNP 19613 1795 12 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1795 13 eam eam NNP 19613 1795 14 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1795 15 in in IN 19613 1795 16 unoquoque unoquoque NNP 19613 1795 17 loco loco NNP 19613 1795 18 est est NNP 19613 1795 19 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 1795 20 tradiderunt tradiderunt NN 19613 1795 21 , , , 19613 1795 22 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1795 23 pervenit pervenit NNP 19613 1795 24 usque usque NNP 19613 1795 25 ad ad NN 19613 1795 26 nos nos NNP 19613 1795 27 , , , 19613 1795 28 etc etc FW 19613 1795 29 . . . 19613 1795 30 " " '' 19613 1796 1 V. V. NNP 19613 1796 2 20.1 20.1 CD 19613 1796 3 : : : 19613 1796 4 " " `` 19613 1796 5 Omnes omne NNS 19613 1796 6 enim enim NNP 19613 1796 7 ii ii NNP 19613 1796 8 valde valde NNP 19613 1796 9 posteriores posteriore NNS 19613 1796 10 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1796 11 quam quam NNP 19613 1796 12 episcopi episcopi NNP 19613 1796 13 , , , 19613 1796 14 quibus quibus NNP 19613 1796 15 apostoli apostoli NNP 19613 1796 16 tradiderunt tradiderunt NN 19613 1796 17 ecclesias ecclesia NNS 19613 1796 18 . . . 19613 1796 19 " " '' 19613 1797 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1797 2 . . . 19613 1798 1 26 26 CD 19613 1798 2 . . . 19613 1799 1 2 2 LS 19613 1799 2 : : : 19613 1799 3 " " `` 19613 1799 4 Quapropter quapropter JJ 19613 1799 5 eis eis NNP 19613 1799 6 , , , 19613 1799 7 qui qui NNP 19613 1799 8 in in IN 19613 1799 9 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 1799 10 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1799 11 , , , 19613 1799 12 presbyteris presbyteris NNP 19613 1799 13 obaudire obaudire NNP 19613 1799 14 oportet oportet NNP 19613 1799 15 , , , 19613 1799 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1799 17 qui qui NNP 19613 1799 18 successionem successionem NNP 19613 1799 19 habent habent NNP 19613 1799 20 ab ab NNP 19613 1799 21 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1799 22 ; ; , 19613 1799 23 qui qui NNP 19613 1799 24 cum cum NNP 19613 1799 25 episcopatus episcopatus NNP 19613 1799 26 successione successione NNP 19613 1799 27 charisma charisma NNP 19613 1799 28 veritatis veritatis NNP 19613 1799 29 certum certum NNP 19613 1799 30 secundum secundum NNP 19613 1799 31 placitum placitum NNP 19613 1799 32 patris patris NNP 19613 1799 33 acceperunt acceperunt NN 19613 1799 34 . . . 19613 1799 35 " " '' 19613 1800 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1800 2 . . . 19613 1801 1 26 26 CD 19613 1801 2 . . . 19613 1802 1 5 5 CD 19613 1802 2 : : : 19613 1802 3 " " `` 19613 1802 4 Ubi ubi VB 19613 1802 5 igitur igitur NN 19613 1802 6 charismata charismata NNP 19613 1802 7 domini domini NNP 19613 1802 8 posita posita NNP 19613 1802 9 sunt sunt NNP 19613 1802 10 , , , 19613 1802 11 ibi ibi NNP 19613 1802 12 discere discere NNP 19613 1802 13 oportet oportet NNP 19613 1802 14 veritatem veritatem NNP 19613 1802 15 , , , 19613 1802 16 apud apud NNP 19613 1802 17 quos quos NNP 19613 1802 18 est est NNP 19613 1802 19 ea ea NNP 19613 1802 20 quæ quæ NNP 19613 1802 21 est est NNP 19613 1802 22 ab ab NNP 19613 1802 23 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1802 24 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 1802 25 successio successio NN 19613 1802 26 . . . 19613 1802 27 " " '' 19613 1803 1 The the DT 19613 1803 2 declaration declaration NN 19613 1803 3 in in IN 19613 1803 4 Luke Luke NNP 19613 1803 5 X. X. NNP 19613 1804 1 16 16 CD 19613 1804 2 was be VBD 19613 1804 3 already already RB 19613 1804 4 applied apply VBN 19613 1804 5 by by IN 19613 1804 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1804 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1804 8 III iii CD 19613 1804 9 . . . 19613 1805 1 præf præf NNP 19613 1805 2 . . . 19613 1805 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1806 1 to to IN 19613 1806 2 the the DT 19613 1806 3 successors successor NNS 19613 1806 4 of of IN 19613 1806 5 the the DT 19613 1806 6 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1806 7 . . . 19613 1806 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1807 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1807 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1807 3 135 135 CD 19613 1807 4 : : : 19613 1807 5 For for IN 19613 1807 6 details detail NNS 19613 1807 7 on on IN 19613 1807 8 this this DT 19613 1807 9 point point NN 19613 1807 10 see see VB 19613 1807 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1807 12 edition edition NN 19613 1807 13 of of IN 19613 1807 14 the the DT 19613 1807 15 Didache Didache NNP 19613 1807 16 , , , 19613 1807 17 Proleg Proleg NNP 19613 1807 18 . . . 19613 1807 19 , , , 19613 1807 20 p. p. NN 19613 1807 21 140 140 CD 19613 1807 22 . . . 19613 1808 1 As as IN 19613 1808 2 the the DT 19613 1808 3 _ _ NNP 19613 1808 4 regula regula NN 19613 1808 5 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1808 6 _ _ NNP 19613 1808 7 has have VBZ 19613 1808 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1808 9 preparatory preparatory JJ 19613 1808 10 stages stage NNS 19613 1808 11 in in IN 19613 1808 12 the the DT 19613 1808 13 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 1808 14 confession confession NN 19613 1808 15 , , , 19613 1808 16 and and CC 19613 1808 17 the the DT 19613 1808 18 New New NNP 19613 1808 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1808 20 in in IN 19613 1808 21 the the DT 19613 1808 22 collection collection NN 19613 1808 23 of of IN 19613 1808 24 writings writing NNS 19613 1808 25 read read VBN 19613 1808 26 in in IN 19613 1808 27 the the DT 19613 1808 28 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 1808 29 , , , 19613 1808 30 so so CC 19613 1808 31 the the DT 19613 1808 32 theory theory NN 19613 1808 33 that that IN 19613 1808 34 the the DT 19613 1808 35 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1808 36 receive receive VBP 19613 1808 37 and and CC 19613 1808 38 guarantee guarantee VB 19613 1808 39 the the DT 19613 1808 40 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1808 41 heritage heritage NN 19613 1808 42 of of IN 19613 1808 43 truth truth NN 19613 1808 44 has have VBZ 19613 1808 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1808 46 preparatory preparatory JJ 19613 1808 47 stage stage NN 19613 1808 48 in in IN 19613 1808 49 the the DT 19613 1808 50 old old JJ 19613 1808 51 idea idea NN 19613 1808 52 that that IN 19613 1808 53 God God NNP 19613 1808 54 has have VBZ 19613 1808 55 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 1808 56 on on IN 19613 1808 57 the the DT 19613 1808 58 Church Church NNP 19613 1808 59 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1808 60 , , , 19613 1808 61 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1808 62 , , , 19613 1808 63 and and CC 19613 1808 64 teachers teacher NNS 19613 1808 65 , , , 19613 1808 66 who who WP 19613 1808 67 always always RB 19613 1808 68 communicate communicate VBP 19613 1808 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1808 70 word word NN 19613 1808 71 in in IN 19613 1808 72 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1808 73 full full JJ 19613 1808 74 purity purity NN 19613 1808 75 . . . 19613 1809 1 The the DT 19613 1809 2 functions function NNS 19613 1809 3 of of IN 19613 1809 4 these these DT 19613 1809 5 persons person NNS 19613 1809 6 devolved devolve VBN 19613 1809 7 by by IN 19613 1809 8 historical historical JJ 19613 1809 9 development development NN 19613 1809 10 upon upon IN 19613 1809 11 the the DT 19613 1809 12 bishop bishop NN 19613 1809 13 ; ; : 19613 1809 14 but but CC 19613 1809 15 at at IN 19613 1809 16 the the DT 19613 1809 17 same same JJ 19613 1809 18 time time NN 19613 1809 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1809 20 became become VBD 19613 1809 21 more more RBR 19613 1809 22 and and CC 19613 1809 23 more more RBR 19613 1809 24 a a DT 19613 1809 25 settled settled JJ 19613 1809 26 conviction conviction NN 19613 1809 27 that that IN 19613 1809 28 no no DT 19613 1809 29 one one NN 19613 1809 30 in in IN 19613 1809 31 this this DT 19613 1809 32 latter latter JJ 19613 1809 33 period period NN 19613 1809 34 could could MD 19613 1809 35 be be VB 19613 1809 36 compared compare VBN 19613 1809 37 with with IN 19613 1809 38 the the DT 19613 1809 39 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1809 40 . . . 19613 1810 1 The the DT 19613 1810 2 only only JJ 19613 1810 3 true true JJ 19613 1810 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1810 5 , , , 19613 1810 6 however however RB 19613 1810 7 , , , 19613 1810 8 was be VBD 19613 1810 9 that that DT 19613 1810 10 which which WDT 19613 1810 11 was be VBD 19613 1810 12 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1810 13 and and CC 19613 1810 14 which which WDT 19613 1810 15 could could MD 19613 1810 16 prove prove VB 19613 1810 17 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1810 18 to to TO 19613 1810 19 be be VB 19613 1810 20 so so RB 19613 1810 21 . . . 19613 1811 1 The the DT 19613 1811 2 natural natural JJ 19613 1811 3 result result NN 19613 1811 4 of of IN 19613 1811 5 the the DT 19613 1811 6 problem problem NN 19613 1811 7 which which WDT 19613 1811 8 thus thus RB 19613 1811 9 arose arise VBD 19613 1811 10 was be VBD 19613 1811 11 the the DT 19613 1811 12 theory theory NN 19613 1811 13 of of IN 19613 1811 14 an an DT 19613 1811 15 objective objective JJ 19613 1811 16 transference transference NN 19613 1811 17 of of IN 19613 1811 18 the the DT 19613 1811 19 _ _ NNP 19613 1811 20 charisma charisma NN 19613 1811 21 veritatis veritatis NN 19613 1811 22 _ _ NNP 19613 1811 23 from from IN 19613 1811 24 the the DT 19613 1811 25 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1811 26 to to IN 19613 1811 27 the the DT 19613 1811 28 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1811 29 . . . 19613 1812 1 This this DT 19613 1812 2 notion notion NN 19613 1812 3 preserved preserve VBD 19613 1812 4 the the DT 19613 1812 5 unique unique JJ 19613 1812 6 personal personal JJ 19613 1812 7 importance importance NN 19613 1812 8 of of IN 19613 1812 9 the the DT 19613 1812 10 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1812 11 , , , 19613 1812 12 guaranteed guarantee VBD 19613 1812 13 the the DT 19613 1812 14 apostolicity apostolicity NN 19613 1812 15 , , , 19613 1812 16 that that RB 19613 1812 17 is is RB 19613 1812 18 , , , 19613 1812 19 the the DT 19613 1812 20 truth truth NN 19613 1812 21 of of IN 19613 1812 22 the the DT 19613 1812 23 Church Church NNP 19613 1812 24 's 's POS 19613 1812 25 faith faith NN 19613 1812 26 , , , 19613 1812 27 and and CC 19613 1812 28 formed form VBD 19613 1812 29 a a DT 19613 1812 30 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 1812 31 justification justification NN 19613 1812 32 for for IN 19613 1812 33 the the DT 19613 1812 34 authority authority NN 19613 1812 35 already already RB 19613 1812 36 attained attain VBN 19613 1812 37 by by IN 19613 1812 38 the the DT 19613 1812 39 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1812 40 . . . 19613 1813 1 The the DT 19613 1813 2 old old JJ 19613 1813 3 idea idea NN 19613 1813 4 that that WDT 19613 1813 5 God God NNP 19613 1813 6 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 1813 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1813 8 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 1813 9 on on IN 19613 1813 10 the the DT 19613 1813 11 Church Church NNP 19613 1813 12 , , , 19613 1813 13 which which WDT 19613 1813 14 is be VBZ 19613 1813 15 therefore therefore RB 19613 1813 16 the the DT 19613 1813 17 holy holy NNP 19613 1813 18 Church Church NNP 19613 1813 19 , , , 19613 1813 20 was be VBD 19613 1813 21 ever ever RB 19613 1813 22 more more RBR 19613 1813 23 and and CC 19613 1813 24 more more RBR 19613 1813 25 transformed transform VBN 19613 1813 26 into into IN 19613 1813 27 the the DT 19613 1813 28 new new JJ 19613 1813 29 notion notion NN 19613 1813 30 that that IN 19613 1813 31 the the DT 19613 1813 32 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1813 33 receive receive VBP 19613 1813 34 this this DT 19613 1813 35 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 1813 36 , , , 19613 1813 37 and and CC 19613 1813 38 that that IN 19613 1813 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1813 40 appears appear VBZ 19613 1813 41 in in IN 19613 1813 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1813 43 official official JJ 19613 1813 44 authority authority NN 19613 1813 45 . . . 19613 1814 1 The the DT 19613 1814 2 theory theory NN 19613 1814 3 of of IN 19613 1814 4 a a DT 19613 1814 5 succession succession NN 19613 1814 6 of of IN 19613 1814 7 prophets prophet NNS 19613 1814 8 , , , 19613 1814 9 which which WDT 19613 1814 10 can can MD 19613 1814 11 be be VB 19613 1814 12 proved prove VBN 19613 1814 13 to to TO 19613 1814 14 have have VB 19613 1814 15 existed exist VBN 19613 1814 16 in in IN 19613 1814 17 Asia Asia NNP 19613 1814 18 Minor Minor NNP 19613 1814 19 , , , 19613 1814 20 never never RB 19613 1814 21 got get VBD 19613 1814 22 beyond beyond IN 19613 1814 23 a a DT 19613 1814 24 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 1814 25 form form NN 19613 1814 26 and and CC 19613 1814 27 speedily speedily RB 19613 1814 28 disappeared disappear VBD 19613 1814 29 . . . 19613 1814 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1815 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1815 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1815 3 136 136 CD 19613 1815 4 : : : 19613 1815 5 This this DT 19613 1815 6 theory theory NN 19613 1815 7 must must MD 19613 1815 8 have have VB 19613 1815 9 been be VBN 19613 1815 10 current current JJ 19613 1815 11 in in IN 19613 1815 12 the the DT 19613 1815 13 Roman Roman NNP 19613 1815 14 Church Church NNP 19613 1815 15 before before IN 19613 1815 16 the the DT 19613 1815 17 time time NN 19613 1815 18 when when WRB 19613 1815 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1815 20 wrote write VBD 19613 1815 21 ; ; : 19613 1815 22 for for IN 19613 1815 23 the the DT 19613 1815 24 list list NN 19613 1815 25 of of IN 19613 1815 26 Roman roman JJ 19613 1815 27 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1815 28 , , , 19613 1815 29 which which WDT 19613 1815 30 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1815 31 find find VBP 19613 1815 32 in in IN 19613 1815 33 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1815 34 and and CC 19613 1815 35 which which WDT 19613 1815 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1815 37 obtained obtain VBD 19613 1815 38 from from IN 19613 1815 39 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1815 40 , , , 19613 1815 41 must must MD 19613 1815 42 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1815 43 be be VB 19613 1815 44 considered consider VBN 19613 1815 45 as as IN 19613 1815 46 a a DT 19613 1815 47 result result NN 19613 1815 48 of of IN 19613 1815 49 that that DT 19613 1815 50 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 1815 51 theory theory NN 19613 1815 52 . . . 19613 1816 1 The the DT 19613 1816 2 first first JJ 19613 1816 3 half half NN 19613 1816 4 of of IN 19613 1816 5 the the DT 19613 1816 6 list list NN 19613 1816 7 must must MD 19613 1816 8 have have VB 19613 1816 9 been be VBN 19613 1816 10 concocted concoct VBN 19613 1816 11 , , , 19613 1816 12 as as IN 19613 1816 13 there there EX 19613 1816 14 were be VBD 19613 1816 15 no no DT 19613 1816 16 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 1816 17 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1816 18 in in IN 19613 1816 19 the the DT 19613 1816 20 strict strict JJ 19613 1816 21 sense sense NN 19613 1816 22 in in IN 19613 1816 23 the the DT 19613 1816 24 first first JJ 19613 1816 25 century century NN 19613 1816 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1816 27 see see VB 19613 1816 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1816 29 treatise treatise NN 19613 1816 30 : : : 19613 1816 31 " " `` 19613 1816 32 Die die VB 19613 1816 33 ältesten ältesten JJ 19613 1816 34 christlichen christlichen NNP 19613 1816 35 Datirungen Datirungen NNP 19613 1816 36 und und NN 19613 1816 37 die die VBP 19613 1816 38 Anfänge anfänge NN 19613 1816 39 einer einer NN 19613 1816 40 bischoflichen bischoflichen NNP 19613 1816 41 Chronographie Chronographie NNP 19613 1816 42 in in IN 19613 1816 43 Rom Rom NNP 19613 1816 44 . . . 19613 1816 45 " " '' 19613 1817 1 in in IN 19613 1817 2 the the DT 19613 1817 3 report report NN 19613 1817 4 of of IN 19613 1817 5 the the DT 19613 1817 6 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 1817 7 of of IN 19613 1817 8 the the DT 19613 1817 9 Royal Royal NNP 19613 1817 10 Prussian Prussian NNP 19613 1817 11 Academy Academy NNP 19613 1817 12 of of IN 19613 1817 13 Science Science NNP 19613 1817 14 , , , 19613 1817 15 1892 1892 CD 19613 1817 16 , , , 19613 1817 17 p. p. NN 19613 1817 18 617 617 CD 19613 1817 19 ff ff NN 19613 1817 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1817 21 . . . 19613 1818 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1818 2 do do VBP 19613 1818 3 not not RB 19613 1818 4 know know VB 19613 1818 5 whether whether IN 19613 1818 6 such such JJ 19613 1818 7 lists list NNS 19613 1818 8 were be VBD 19613 1818 9 drawn draw VBN 19613 1818 10 up up RP 19613 1818 11 so so RB 19613 1818 12 early early RB 19613 1818 13 in in IN 19613 1818 14 the the DT 19613 1818 15 other other JJ 19613 1818 16 churches church NNS 19613 1818 17 of of IN 19613 1818 18 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1818 19 origin origin NN 19613 1818 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1818 21 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 1818 22 ? ? . 19613 1818 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1818 24 . . . 19613 1819 1 Not not RB 19613 1819 2 till till IN 19613 1819 3 the the DT 19613 1819 4 beginning beginning NN 19613 1819 5 of of IN 19613 1819 6 the the DT 19613 1819 7 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 1819 8 century century NN 19613 1819 9 have have VBP 19613 1819 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1819 11 proofs proofs JJ 19613 1819 12 of of IN 19613 1819 13 that that DT 19613 1819 14 being be VBG 19613 1819 15 done do VBN 19613 1819 16 , , , 19613 1819 17 whereas whereas IN 19613 1819 18 the the DT 19613 1819 19 Roman roman JJ 19613 1819 20 community community NN 19613 1819 21 , , , 19613 1819 22 as as RB 19613 1819 23 early early RB 19613 1819 24 as as IN 19613 1819 25 Soter Soter NNP 19613 1819 26 's 's POS 19613 1819 27 time time NN 19613 1819 28 , , , 19613 1819 29 had have VBD 19613 1819 30 a a DT 19613 1819 31 list list NN 19613 1819 32 of of IN 19613 1819 33 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1819 34 giving give VBG 19613 1819 35 the the DT 19613 1819 36 duration duration NN 19613 1819 37 of of IN 19613 1819 38 each each DT 19613 1819 39 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 1819 40 . . . 19613 1820 1 Nor nor CC 19613 1820 2 is be VBZ 19613 1820 3 there there EX 19613 1820 4 any any DT 19613 1820 5 evidence evidence NN 19613 1820 6 before before IN 19613 1820 7 the the DT 19613 1820 8 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 1820 9 century century NN 19613 1820 10 of of IN 19613 1820 11 an an DT 19613 1820 12 attempt attempt NN 19613 1820 13 to to TO 19613 1820 14 invent invent VB 19613 1820 15 such such PDT 19613 1820 16 a a DT 19613 1820 17 list list NN 19613 1820 18 for for IN 19613 1820 19 Churches church NNS 19613 1820 20 possessing possess VBG 19613 1820 21 no no DT 19613 1820 22 claim claim NN 19613 1820 23 to to TO 19613 1820 24 have have VB 19613 1820 25 been be VBN 19613 1820 26 founded found VBN 19613 1820 27 by by IN 19613 1820 28 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 1820 29 . . . 19613 1820 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1821 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1821 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1821 3 137 137 CD 19613 1821 4 : : : 19613 1821 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 1821 6 do do VBP 19613 1821 7 not not RB 19613 1821 8 yet yet RB 19613 1821 9 find find VB 19613 1821 10 this this DT 19613 1821 11 assertion assertion NN 19613 1821 12 in in IN 19613 1821 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1821 14 's 's POS 19613 1821 15 treatise treatise NN 19613 1821 16 " " '' 19613 1821 17 de de NNP 19613 1821 18 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1821 19 . . . 19613 1821 20 " " '' 19613 1821 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1822 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1822 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1822 3 138 138 CD 19613 1822 4 : : : 19613 1822 5 Special special JJ 19613 1822 6 importance importance NN 19613 1822 7 attaches attache NNS 19613 1822 8 to to IN 19613 1822 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1822 10 's 's POS 19613 1822 11 treatise treatise NN 19613 1822 12 " " `` 19613 1822 13 de de FW 19613 1822 14 pudicitia pudicitia NNP 19613 1822 15 , , , 19613 1822 16 " " '' 19613 1822 17 which which WDT 19613 1822 18 has have VBZ 19613 1822 19 not not RB 19613 1822 20 been be VBN 19613 1822 21 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 1822 22 utilised utilise VBN 19613 1822 23 to to TO 19613 1822 24 explain explain VB 19613 1822 25 the the DT 19613 1822 26 development development NN 19613 1822 27 of of IN 19613 1822 28 the the DT 19613 1822 29 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 1822 30 and and CC 19613 1822 31 the the DT 19613 1822 32 pretensions pretension NNS 19613 1822 33 at at IN 19613 1822 34 that that DT 19613 1822 35 time time NN 19613 1822 36 set set VBN 19613 1822 37 up up RP 19613 1822 38 by by IN 19613 1822 39 the the DT 19613 1822 40 Roman roman JJ 19613 1822 41 bishop bishop NN 19613 1822 42 . . . 19613 1823 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1823 2 shows show VBZ 19613 1823 3 clearly clearly RB 19613 1823 4 that that IN 19613 1823 5 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 1823 6 claimed claim VBD 19613 1823 7 for for IN 19613 1823 8 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1823 9 as as IN 19613 1823 10 bishop bishop NN 19613 1823 11 the the DT 19613 1823 12 powers power NNS 19613 1823 13 and and CC 19613 1823 14 rights right NNS 19613 1823 15 of of IN 19613 1823 16 the the DT 19613 1823 17 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1823 18 in in IN 19613 1823 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1823 20 full full JJ 19613 1823 21 extent extent NN 19613 1823 22 , , , 19613 1823 23 and and CC 19613 1823 24 that that IN 19613 1823 25 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1823 26 did do VBD 19613 1823 27 not not RB 19613 1823 28 deny deny VB 19613 1823 29 that that IN 19613 1823 30 the the DT 19613 1823 31 " " `` 19613 1823 32 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 1823 33 apostolorum apostolorum NN 19613 1823 34 " " '' 19613 1823 35 was be VBD 19613 1823 36 inherent inherent JJ 19613 1823 37 in in IN 19613 1823 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1823 39 office office NN 19613 1823 40 , , , 19613 1823 41 but but CC 19613 1823 42 merely merely RB 19613 1823 43 questioned question VBD 19613 1823 44 the the DT 19613 1823 45 " " `` 19613 1823 46 potestas potestas NNP 19613 1823 47 apostolorum apostolorum NN 19613 1823 48 . . . 19613 1823 49 " " '' 19613 1824 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1824 2 is be VBZ 19613 1824 3 very very RB 19613 1824 4 significant significant JJ 19613 1824 5 that that IN 19613 1824 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1824 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1824 8 c. c. NNP 19613 1824 9 21 21 CD 19613 1824 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1824 11 sneeringly sneeringly RB 19613 1824 12 addressed address VBD 19613 1824 13 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1824 14 as as IN 19613 1824 15 " " `` 19613 1824 16 apostolice apostolice JJ 19613 1824 17 " " '' 19613 1824 18 and and CC 19613 1824 19 reminded remind VBD 19613 1824 20 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1824 21 that that IN 19613 1824 22 " " `` 19613 1824 23 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 1824 24 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 1824 25 , , , 19613 1824 26 non non NNP 19613 1824 27 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 1824 28 numerus numerus NNP 19613 1824 29 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 1824 30 . . . 19613 1824 31 " " '' 19613 1825 1 What what WDT 19613 1825 2 rights right NNS 19613 1825 3 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 1825 4 had have VBD 19613 1825 5 already already RB 19613 1825 6 claimed claim VBN 19613 1825 7 as as IN 19613 1825 8 belonging belong VBG 19613 1825 9 to to IN 19613 1825 10 the the DT 19613 1825 11 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1825 12 office office NN 19613 1825 13 may may MD 19613 1825 14 be be VB 19613 1825 15 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 1825 16 from from IN 19613 1825 17 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 1825 18 . . . 19613 1826 1 Philos Philos NNP 19613 1826 2 . . . 19613 1827 1 IX ix NN 19613 1827 2 . . . 19613 1828 1 11 11 CD 19613 1828 2 . . . 19613 1829 1 12 12 CD 19613 1829 2 . . . 19613 1830 1 But but CC 19613 1830 2 the the DT 19613 1830 3 introduction introduction NN 19613 1830 4 to to IN 19613 1830 5 the the DT 19613 1830 6 Philosophoumena Philosophoumena NNP 19613 1830 7 proves prove VBZ 19613 1830 8 that that IN 19613 1830 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 1830 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1830 11 was be VBD 19613 1830 12 at at IN 19613 1830 13 one one CD 19613 1830 14 with with IN 19613 1830 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1830 16 opponent opponent NN 19613 1830 17 in in IN 19613 1830 18 supposing suppose VBG 19613 1830 19 that that IN 19613 1830 20 the the DT 19613 1830 21 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1830 22 , , , 19613 1830 23 as as IN 19613 1830 24 successors successor NNS 19613 1830 25 of of IN 19613 1830 26 the the DT 19613 1830 27 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1830 28 , , , 19613 1830 29 had have VBD 19613 1830 30 received receive VBN 19613 1830 31 the the DT 19613 1830 32 attributes attribute NNS 19613 1830 33 of of IN 19613 1830 34 the the DT 19613 1830 35 latter latter JJ 19613 1830 36 : : : 19613 1830 37 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1830 38 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1830 39 : : : 19613 1830 40 Tas Tas NNP 19613 1830 41 haireseis haireseis NNP 19613 1830 42 heteros heteros NNP 19613 1830 43 ouk ouk NNP 19613 1830 44 elegxei elegxei NNP 19613 1830 45 , , , 19613 1830 46 ê ê NNP 19613 1830 47 to to TO 19613 1830 48 en en NNP 19613 1830 49 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 1830 50 paradothen paradothen NNP 19613 1830 51 hagion hagion NNP 19613 1830 52 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 1830 53 , , , 19613 1830 54 ou ou NNP 19613 1830 55 tuchontes tuchonte NNS 19613 1830 56 proteroi proteroi VBP 19613 1830 57 hoi hoi NNP 19613 1830 58 apostoloi apostoloi NNP 19613 1830 59 metedosan metedosan NNP 19613 1830 60 tois tois NNP 19613 1830 61 orthôs orthôs NNP 19613 1830 62 pepisteukosin pepisteukosin NNP 19613 1830 63 hôn hôn NNP 19613 1830 64 hêmeis hêmeis NNP 19613 1830 65 diadochoi diadochoi NNP 19613 1830 66 tugchanontes tugchanonte VBZ 19613 1830 67 tês tês NNP 19613 1830 68 te te NNP 19613 1830 69 autês autês NNP 19613 1830 70 charitos charitos NNP 19613 1830 71 metechontes metechontes NNPS 19613 1830 72 archierateias archierateias NNP 19613 1830 73 te te NNP 19613 1830 74 kai kai NNP 19613 1830 75 didaskalias didaskalias NNP 19613 1830 76 kai kai NNP 19613 1830 77 phrouroi phrouroi NNP 19613 1830 78 tês tês NNP 19613 1830 79 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1830 80 lelogismenoi lelogismenoi NNP 19613 1830 81 ouk ouk NNP 19613 1830 82 ophthalmô ophthalmô NNP 19613 1830 83 nustazomen nustazomen NNP 19613 1830 84 , , , 19613 1830 85 oude oude NNP 19613 1830 86 logon logon NNP 19613 1830 87 orthon orthon NNP 19613 1830 88 siôpômen siôpômen NNP 19613 1830 89 , , , 19613 1830 90 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 1830 91 . . . 19613 1830 92 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1831 1 In in IN 19613 1831 2 these these DT 19613 1831 3 words word NNS 19613 1831 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1831 5 have have VBP 19613 1831 6 an an DT 19613 1831 7 immense immense JJ 19613 1831 8 advance advance NN 19613 1831 9 beyond beyond IN 19613 1831 10 the the DT 19613 1831 11 conception conception NN 19613 1831 12 of of IN 19613 1831 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1831 14 . . . 19613 1832 1 This this DT 19613 1832 2 advance advance NN 19613 1832 3 , , , 19613 1832 4 of of IN 19613 1832 5 course course NN 19613 1832 6 , , , 19613 1832 7 was be VBD 19613 1832 8 first first RB 19613 1832 9 made make VBN 19613 1832 10 in in IN 19613 1832 11 practice practice NN 19613 1832 12 , , , 19613 1832 13 and and CC 19613 1832 14 the the DT 19613 1832 15 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 1832 16 theory theory NN 19613 1832 17 followed follow VBD 19613 1832 18 . . . 19613 1833 1 How how WRB 19613 1833 2 greatly greatly RB 19613 1833 3 the the DT 19613 1833 4 prestige prestige NN 19613 1833 5 and and CC 19613 1833 6 power power NN 19613 1833 7 of of IN 19613 1833 8 the the DT 19613 1833 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1833 10 had have VBD 19613 1833 11 increased increase VBN 19613 1833 12 in in IN 19613 1833 13 the the DT 19613 1833 14 first first JJ 19613 1833 15 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 1833 16 part part NN 19613 1833 17 of of IN 19613 1833 18 the the DT 19613 1833 19 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 1833 20 century century NN 19613 1833 21 may may MD 19613 1833 22 be be VB 19613 1833 23 seen see VBN 19613 1833 24 by by IN 19613 1833 25 comparing compare VBG 19613 1833 26 the the DT 19613 1833 27 edict edict NN 19613 1833 28 of of IN 19613 1833 29 Maximinus Maximinus NNP 19613 1833 30 Thrax Thrax NNP 19613 1833 31 with with IN 19613 1833 32 the the DT 19613 1833 33 earlier early JJR 19613 1833 34 ones one NNS 19613 1833 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1833 36 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1833 37 . . NNP 19613 1833 38 , , , 19613 1833 39 H. H. NNP 19613 1833 40 E. E. NNP 19613 1833 41 VI VI NNP 19613 1833 42 . . . 19613 1834 1 28 28 CD 19613 1834 2 ; ; : 19613 1834 3 see see VB 19613 1834 4 also also RB 19613 1834 5 the the DT 19613 1834 6 genuine genuine JJ 19613 1834 7 Martyr Martyr NNP 19613 1834 8 . . . 19613 1835 1 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 19613 1835 2 , , , 19613 1835 3 Mariani Mariani NNP 19613 1835 4 , , , 19613 1835 5 etc etc FW 19613 1835 6 . . FW 19613 1835 7 , , , 19613 1835 8 in in IN 19613 1835 9 Numidia Numidia NNP 19613 1835 10 c. c. CC 19613 1835 11 10 10 CD 19613 1835 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1835 13 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 19613 1835 14 , , , 19613 1835 15 Acta Acta NNP 19613 1835 16 mart mart NNP 19613 1835 17 . . . 19613 1836 1 p. p. NN 19613 1836 2 272 272 CD 19613 1836 3 edit edit NN 19613 1836 4 . . . 19613 1837 1 Ratisb Ratisb NNP 19613 1837 2 . . . 19613 1838 1 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1838 2 ): ): NN 19613 1838 3 " " `` 19613 1838 4 Nam Nam NNP 19613 1838 5 ita ita NNP 19613 1838 6 inter inter NNP 19613 1838 7 se se FW 19613 1838 8 nostræ nostræ NNP 19613 1838 9 religionis religionis NNP 19613 1838 10 gradus gradus NNP 19613 1838 11 artifex artifex NNP 19613 1838 12 sævitia sævitia NNP 19613 1838 13 diviserat diviserat NNP 19613 1838 14 , , , 19613 1838 15 ut ut NNP 19613 1838 16 laicos laicos NNP 19613 1838 17 clericis clericis NNP 19613 1838 18 separatos separatos NNP 19613 1838 19 tentationibus tentationibus NNP 19613 1838 20 sæculi sæculi NNP 19613 1838 21 et et NNP 19613 1838 22 terroribus terroribus NNP 19613 1838 23 suis suis NNP 19613 1838 24 putaret putaret NNP 19613 1838 25 esse esse NNP 19613 1838 26 cessuros cessuros NNP 19613 1838 27 " " '' 19613 1838 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1838 29 that that RB 19613 1838 30 is is RB 19613 1838 31 , , , 19613 1838 32 the the DT 19613 1838 33 heathen heathen NNP 19613 1838 34 authorities authority NNS 19613 1838 35 also also RB 19613 1838 36 knew know VBD 19613 1838 37 that that IN 19613 1838 38 the the DT 19613 1838 39 clergy clergy NNS 19613 1838 40 formed form VBD 19613 1838 41 the the DT 19613 1838 42 bond bond NN 19613 1838 43 of of IN 19613 1838 44 union union NN 19613 1838 45 in in IN 19613 1838 46 the the DT 19613 1838 47 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 1838 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1838 49 . . . 19613 1839 1 But but CC 19613 1839 2 the the DT 19613 1839 3 theory theory NN 19613 1839 4 that that IN 19613 1839 5 the the DT 19613 1839 6 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1839 7 were be VBD 19613 1839 8 successors successor NNS 19613 1839 9 of of IN 19613 1839 10 the the DT 19613 1839 11 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 1839 12 , , , 19613 1839 13 that that RB 19613 1839 14 is is RB 19613 1839 15 , , , 19613 1839 16 possessed possess VBD 19613 1839 17 the the DT 19613 1839 18 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1839 19 office office NN 19613 1839 20 , , , 19613 1839 21 must must MD 19613 1839 22 be be VB 19613 1839 23 considered consider VBN 19613 1839 24 a a DT 19613 1839 25 Western western JJ 19613 1839 26 one one NN 19613 1839 27 which which WDT 19613 1839 28 was be VBD 19613 1839 29 very very RB 19613 1839 30 slowly slowly RB 19613 1839 31 and and CC 19613 1839 32 gradually gradually RB 19613 1839 33 adopted adopt VBN 19613 1839 34 in in IN 19613 1839 35 the the DT 19613 1839 36 East East NNP 19613 1839 37 . . . 19613 1840 1 Even even RB 19613 1840 2 in in IN 19613 1840 3 the the DT 19613 1840 4 original original NN 19613 1840 5 of of IN 19613 1840 6 the the DT 19613 1840 7 first first JJ 19613 1840 8 six six CD 19613 1840 9 books book NNS 19613 1840 10 of of IN 19613 1840 11 the the DT 19613 1840 12 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 1840 13 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 1840 14 , , , 19613 1840 15 composed compose VBN 19613 1840 16 about about IN 19613 1840 17 the the DT 19613 1840 18 end end NN 19613 1840 19 of of IN 19613 1840 20 the the DT 19613 1840 21 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 1840 22 century century NN 19613 1840 23 , , , 19613 1840 24 which which WDT 19613 1840 25 represents represent VBZ 19613 1840 26 the the DT 19613 1840 27 bishop bishop NN 19613 1840 28 as as IN 19613 1840 29 mediator mediator NN 19613 1840 30 , , , 19613 1840 31 king king NN 19613 1840 32 , , , 19613 1840 33 and and CC 19613 1840 34 teacher teacher NN 19613 1840 35 of of IN 19613 1840 36 the the DT 19613 1840 37 community community NN 19613 1840 38 , , , 19613 1840 39 the the DT 19613 1840 40 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 1840 41 office office NN 19613 1840 42 is be VBZ 19613 1840 43 not not RB 19613 1840 44 yet yet RB 19613 1840 45 regarded regard VBN 19613 1840 46 as as IN 19613 1840 47 the the DT 19613 1840 48 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1840 49 one one NN 19613 1840 50 . . . 19613 1841 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1841 2 is be VBZ 19613 1841 3 rather rather RB 19613 1841 4 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 1841 5 , , , 19613 1841 6 as as IN 19613 1841 7 in in IN 19613 1841 8 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 1841 9 , , , 19613 1841 10 who who WP 19613 1841 11 are be VBP 19613 1841 12 classed class VBN 19613 1841 13 with with IN 19613 1841 14 the the DT 19613 1841 15 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1841 16 . . . 19613 1842 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1842 2 is be VBZ 19613 1842 3 very very RB 19613 1842 4 important important JJ 19613 1842 5 to to TO 19613 1842 6 note note VB 19613 1842 7 that that IN 19613 1842 8 the the DT 19613 1842 9 whole whole JJ 19613 1842 10 theory theory NN 19613 1842 11 of of IN 19613 1842 12 the the DT 19613 1842 13 significance significance NN 19613 1842 14 of of IN 19613 1842 15 the the DT 19613 1842 16 bishop bishop NN 19613 1842 17 in in IN 19613 1842 18 determining determine VBG 19613 1842 19 the the DT 19613 1842 20 truth truth NN 19613 1842 21 of of IN 19613 1842 22 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1842 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 1842 24 is be VBZ 19613 1842 25 completely completely RB 19613 1842 26 unknown unknown JJ 19613 1842 27 to to IN 19613 1842 28 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1842 29 of of IN 19613 1842 30 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1842 31 . . . 19613 1843 1 As as IN 19613 1843 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1843 3 have have VBP 19613 1843 4 not not RB 19613 1843 5 the the DT 19613 1843 6 slightest slight JJS 19613 1843 7 evidence evidence NN 19613 1843 8 that that IN 19613 1843 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1843 10 conception conception NN 19613 1843 11 of of IN 19613 1843 12 the the DT 19613 1843 13 Church Church NNP 19613 1843 14 was be VBD 19613 1843 15 of of IN 19613 1843 16 a a DT 19613 1843 17 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 1843 18 and and CC 19613 1843 19 anti anti JJ 19613 1843 20 - - JJ 19613 1843 21 heretical heretical JJ 19613 1843 22 type type NN 19613 1843 23 , , , 19613 1843 24 so so RB 19613 1843 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1843 26 very very RB 19613 1843 27 rarely rarely RB 19613 1843 28 mentions mention VBZ 19613 1843 29 the the DT 19613 1843 30 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1843 31 officials official NNS 19613 1843 32 in in IN 19613 1843 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1843 34 works work NNS 19613 1843 35 and and CC 19613 1843 36 rarest rare JJS 19613 1843 37 of of IN 19613 1843 38 all all PDT 19613 1843 39 the the DT 19613 1843 40 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1843 41 . . . 19613 1844 1 These these DT 19613 1844 2 do do VBP 19613 1844 3 not not RB 19613 1844 4 at at RB 19613 1844 5 all all RB 19613 1844 6 belong belong VB 19613 1844 7 to to IN 19613 1844 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1844 9 conception conception NN 19613 1844 10 of of IN 19613 1844 11 the the DT 19613 1844 12 Church Church NNP 19613 1844 13 , , , 19613 1844 14 or or CC 19613 1844 15 at at IN 19613 1844 16 least least JJS 19613 1844 17 only only RB 19613 1844 18 in in IN 19613 1844 19 so so RB 19613 1844 20 far far RB 19613 1844 21 as as IN 19613 1844 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 1844 23 resemble resemble VBP 19613 1844 24 the the DT 19613 1844 25 English english JJ 19613 1844 26 orders order NNS 19613 1844 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1844 28 cf cf NN 19613 1844 29 . . . 19613 1845 1 Pæd pæd NN 19613 1845 2 . . . 19613 1846 1 III iii CD 19613 1846 2 . . . 19613 1847 1 12 12 CD 19613 1847 2 . . . 19613 1848 1 97 97 CD 19613 1848 2 , , , 19613 1848 3 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 1848 4 , , , 19613 1848 5 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1848 6 , , , 19613 1848 7 deacons deacon NNS 19613 1848 8 , , , 19613 1848 9 widows widow NNS 19613 1848 10 ; ; : 19613 1848 11 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1848 12 . . . 19613 1849 1 VII VII NNP 19613 1849 2 . . . 19613 1850 1 1 1 LS 19613 1850 2 . . . 19613 1851 1 3 3 LS 19613 1851 2 ; ; : 19613 1851 3 III iii CD 19613 1851 4 . . . 19613 1852 1 12 12 CD 19613 1852 2 . . . 19613 1853 1 90 90 CD 19613 1853 2 , , , 19613 1853 3 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 1853 4 , , , 19613 1853 5 deacons deacon NNS 19613 1853 6 , , , 19613 1853 7 laity laity NN 19613 1853 8 ; ; : 19613 1853 9 VI VI NNP 19613 1853 10 . . . 19613 1854 1 13 13 CD 19613 1854 2 . . . 19613 1855 1 106 106 CD 19613 1855 2 , , , 19613 1855 3 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 1855 4 , , , 19613 1855 5 deacons deacon NNS 19613 1855 6 : : : 19613 1855 7 VI VI NNP 19613 1855 8 . . . 19613 1856 1 13 13 CD 19613 1856 2 . . . 19613 1857 1 107 107 CD 19613 1857 2 , , , 19613 1857 3 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1857 4 , , , 19613 1857 5 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 1857 6 , , , 19613 1857 7 deacons deacon NNS 19613 1857 8 : : : 19613 1857 9 Quis Quis NNP 19613 1857 10 dives dive VBZ 19613 1857 11 42 42 CD 19613 1857 12 , , , 19613 1857 13 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1857 14 and and CC 19613 1857 15 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 1857 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1857 17 . . . 19613 1858 1 On on IN 19613 1858 2 the the DT 19613 1858 3 other other JJ 19613 1858 4 hand hand NN 19613 1858 5 , , , 19613 1858 6 according accord VBG 19613 1858 7 to to IN 19613 1858 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1858 9 , , , 19613 1858 10 the the DT 19613 1858 11 true true JJ 19613 1858 12 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 1858 13 has have VBZ 19613 1858 14 an an DT 19613 1858 15 office office NN 19613 1858 16 like like IN 19613 1858 17 that that DT 19613 1858 18 of of IN 19613 1858 19 the the DT 19613 1858 20 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1858 21 . . . 19613 1859 1 See see VB 19613 1859 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1859 3 . . . 19613 1860 1 VI VI NNP 19613 1860 2 . . . 19613 1861 1 13 13 CD 19613 1861 2 . . . 19613 1862 1 106 106 CD 19613 1862 2 , , , 19613 1862 3 107 107 CD 19613 1862 4 : : : 19613 1862 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1862 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1862 7 : : : 19613 1862 8 exestin exestin NNP 19613 1862 9 oun oun NNP 19613 1862 10 kai kai NNP 19613 1862 11 nun nun NNP 19613 1862 12 tais tais NNP 19613 1862 13 kyriakais kyriakais NNP 19613 1862 14 enaskêsantas enaskêsantas NNP 19613 1862 15 entolais entolais NNP 19613 1862 16 kata kata NNP 19613 1862 17 to to IN 19613 1862 18 euangelion euangelion NN 19613 1862 19 teleiôs teleiôs NNP 19613 1862 20 biôsantas biôsantas NNP 19613 1862 21 kai kai NNP 19613 1862 22 gnôstikôs gnôstikôs NNP 19613 1862 23 eis eis NNP 19613 1862 24 tên tên NNP 19613 1862 25 eklogên eklogên NNP 19613 1862 26 tôn tôn NNP 19613 1862 27 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1862 28 engraphênai engraphênai NNP 19613 1862 29 houtos houtos NNP 19613 1862 30 presbuteros presbuteros NNP 19613 1862 31 esti esti NNP 19613 1862 32 tô tô NNP 19613 1862 33 onti onti NNP 19613 1862 34 tês tês NNP 19613 1862 35 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1862 36 kai kai NNP 19613 1862 37 diakonos diakonos NNP 19613 1862 38 alêthês alêthês NNP 19613 1862 39 tês tês NNP 19613 1862 40 tou tou NNP 19613 1862 41 theou theou NNP 19613 1862 42 boulêseôs boulêseôs NNP 19613 1862 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1862 44 . . . 19613 1863 1 Here here RB 19613 1863 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1863 3 see see VBP 19613 1863 4 plainly plainly RB 19613 1863 5 that that IN 19613 1863 6 the the DT 19613 1863 7 servants servant NNS 19613 1863 8 of of IN 19613 1863 9 the the DT 19613 1863 10 earthly earthly JJ 19613 1863 11 Church Church NNP 19613 1863 12 , , , 19613 1863 13 as as IN 19613 1863 14 such such JJ 19613 1863 15 , , , 19613 1863 16 have have VBP 19613 1863 17 nothing nothing NN 19613 1863 18 to to TO 19613 1863 19 do do VB 19613 1863 20 with with IN 19613 1863 21 the the DT 19613 1863 22 true true JJ 19613 1863 23 Church Church NNP 19613 1863 24 and and CC 19613 1863 25 the the DT 19613 1863 26 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 1863 27 hierarchy hierarchy NN 19613 1863 28 . . . 19613 1864 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1864 2 VII VII NNP 19613 1864 3 . . . 19613 1865 1 9 9 CD 19613 1865 2 , , , 19613 1865 3 52 52 CD 19613 1865 4 says say VBZ 19613 1865 5 : : : 19613 1865 6 the the DT 19613 1865 7 true true JJ 19613 1865 8 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 1865 9 is be VBZ 19613 1865 10 the the DT 19613 1865 11 mediator mediator NN 19613 1865 12 with with IN 19613 1865 13 God God NNP 19613 1865 14 . . . 19613 1866 1 In in IN 19613 1866 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1866 3 . . . 19613 1867 1 VI VI NNP 19613 1867 2 . . . 19613 1868 1 14 14 CD 19613 1868 2 . . . 19613 1869 1 108 108 CD 19613 1869 2 ; ; : 19613 1869 3 VII VII NNP 19613 1869 4 . . . 19613 1870 1 12 12 CD 19613 1870 2 . . . 19613 1871 1 77 77 CD 19613 1871 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1871 3 find find VBP 19613 1871 4 the the DT 19613 1871 5 words word NNS 19613 1871 6 : : : 19613 1871 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1871 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1871 9 : : : 19613 1871 10 ho ho NNP 19613 1871 11 gnôstikos gnôstikos NNP 19613 1871 12 houtos houtos NNP 19613 1871 13 sunelonti sunelonti NNP 19613 1871 14 eipein eipein NNP 19613 1871 15 tên tên NNP 19613 1871 16 apostolikên apostolikên NNP 19613 1871 17 apousian apousian NNP 19613 1871 18 antanaplêroi antanaplêroi NNP 19613 1871 19 , , , 19613 1871 20 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 1871 21 . . . 19613 1871 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1872 1 Clement clement NN 19613 1872 2 could could MD 19613 1872 3 not not RB 19613 1872 4 have have VB 19613 1872 5 expressed express VBN 19613 1872 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1872 7 in in IN 19613 1872 8 this this DT 19613 1872 9 way way NN 19613 1872 10 if if IN 19613 1872 11 the the DT 19613 1872 12 office office NNP 19613 1872 13 of of IN 19613 1872 14 bishop bishop NNP 19613 1872 15 had have VBD 19613 1872 16 at at IN 19613 1872 17 that that DT 19613 1872 18 time time NN 19613 1872 19 been be VBN 19613 1872 20 as as RB 19613 1872 21 much much RB 19613 1872 22 esteemed esteem VBN 19613 1872 23 in in IN 19613 1872 24 the the DT 19613 1872 25 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 1872 26 Church Church NNP 19613 1872 27 , , , 19613 1872 28 of of IN 19613 1872 29 which which WDT 19613 1872 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 1872 31 was be VBD 19613 1872 32 a a DT 19613 1872 33 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 1872 34 , , , 19613 1872 35 as as IN 19613 1872 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1872 37 was be VBD 19613 1872 38 at at IN 19613 1872 39 Rome Rome NNP 19613 1872 40 and and CC 19613 1872 41 in in IN 19613 1872 42 other other JJ 19613 1872 43 Churches church NNS 19613 1872 44 of of IN 19613 1872 45 the the DT 19613 1872 46 West West NNP 19613 1872 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1872 48 see see VB 19613 1872 49 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 1872 50 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1872 51 . . . 19613 1873 1 101 101 CD 19613 1873 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1873 3 . . . 19613 1874 1 According accord VBG 19613 1874 2 to to IN 19613 1874 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1874 4 the the DT 19613 1874 5 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 1874 6 as as IN 19613 1874 7 a a DT 19613 1874 8 teacher teacher NN 19613 1874 9 has have VBZ 19613 1874 10 the the DT 19613 1874 11 same same JJ 19613 1874 12 significance significance NN 19613 1874 13 as as IN 19613 1874 14 is be VBZ 19613 1874 15 possessed possess VBN 19613 1874 16 by by IN 19613 1874 17 the the DT 19613 1874 18 bishop bishop NN 19613 1874 19 in in IN 19613 1874 20 the the DT 19613 1874 21 West West NNP 19613 1874 22 ; ; : 19613 1874 23 and and CC 19613 1874 24 according accord VBG 19613 1874 25 to to IN 19613 1874 26 him -PRON- PRP 19613 1874 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1874 28 may may MD 19613 1874 29 speak speak VB 19613 1874 30 of of IN 19613 1874 31 a a DT 19613 1874 32 natural natural JJ 19613 1874 33 succession succession NN 19613 1874 34 of of IN 19613 1874 35 teachers teacher NNS 19613 1874 36 . . . 19613 1875 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1875 2 in in IN 19613 1875 3 the the DT 19613 1875 4 main main JJ 19613 1875 5 still still RB 19613 1875 6 held hold VBD 19613 1875 7 the the DT 19613 1875 8 same same JJ 19613 1875 9 view view NN 19613 1875 10 as as IN 19613 1875 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1875 12 predecessor predecessor NN 19613 1875 13 . . . 19613 1876 1 But but CC 19613 1876 2 numerous numerous JJ 19613 1876 3 passages passage NNS 19613 1876 4 in in IN 19613 1876 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1876 6 works work NNS 19613 1876 7 and and CC 19613 1876 8 above above IN 19613 1876 9 all all DT 19613 1876 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1876 11 own own JJ 19613 1876 12 history history NN 19613 1876 13 shew shew NN 19613 1876 14 that that IN 19613 1876 15 in in IN 19613 1876 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1876 17 day day NN 19613 1876 18 the the DT 19613 1876 19 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 1876 20 had have VBD 19613 1876 21 become become VBN 19613 1876 22 stronger strong JJR 19613 1876 23 in in IN 19613 1876 24 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 1876 25 also also RB 19613 1876 26 , , , 19613 1876 27 and and CC 19613 1876 28 had have VBD 19613 1876 29 begun begin VBN 19613 1876 30 to to TO 19613 1876 31 claim claim VB 19613 1876 32 the the DT 19613 1876 33 same same JJ 19613 1876 34 attributes attribute NNS 19613 1876 35 and and CC 19613 1876 36 rights right NNS 19613 1876 37 as as IN 19613 1876 38 in in IN 19613 1876 39 the the DT 19613 1876 40 West West NNP 19613 1876 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1876 42 see see VB 19613 1876 43 besides besides IN 19613 1876 44 de de NNP 19613 1876 45 princip princip NN 19613 1876 46 . . . 19613 1877 1 præf præf NNP 19613 1877 2 . . . 19613 1878 1 2 2 LS 19613 1878 2 : : : 19613 1878 3 " " `` 19613 1878 4 servetur servetur NNP 19613 1878 5 ecclesiastica ecclesiastica NNP 19613 1878 6 prædicatio prædicatio NNP 19613 1878 7 per per IN 19613 1878 8 successionis successionis NNP 19613 1878 9 ordinem ordinem NNP 19613 1878 10 ab ab NNP 19613 1878 11 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 1878 12 tradita tradita NNP 19613 1878 13 et et NNP 19613 1878 14 usque usque NNP 19613 1878 15 ad ad NNP 19613 1878 16 præsens præsen VBZ 19613 1878 17 in in IN 19613 1878 18 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 1878 19 permanens permanen NNS 19613 1878 20 : : : 19613 1878 21 illa illa NNP 19613 1878 22 sola sola NNP 19613 1878 23 credenda credenda NNP 19613 1878 24 est est NNP 19613 1878 25 veritas veritas NNP 19613 1878 26 , , , 19613 1878 27 quæ quæ NN 19613 1878 28 in in IN 19613 1878 29 nullo nullo NNP 19613 1878 30 ab ab NNP 19613 1878 31 ecclesiastica ecclesiastica NNP 19613 1878 32 et et NNP 19613 1878 33 apostolica apostolica NNP 19613 1878 34 discordat discordat NN 19613 1878 35 traditione"--so traditione"--so NNP 19613 1878 36 in in IN 19613 1878 37 Rufinus Rufinus NNP 19613 1878 38 , , , 19613 1878 39 and and CC 19613 1878 40 in in IN 19613 1878 41 IV IV NNP 19613 1878 42 . . . 19613 1879 1 2 2 LS 19613 1879 2 . . . 19613 1880 1 2 2 LS 19613 1880 2 : : : 19613 1880 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1880 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1880 5 : : : 19613 1880 6 tou tou NNP 19613 1880 7 kanonos kanonos NNP 19613 1880 8 tês tês NNP 19613 1880 9 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 1880 10 Christou Christou NNP 19613 1880 11 kata kata NN 19613 1880 12 diadochên diadochên NN 19613 1880 13 t. t. NNP 19613 1880 14 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 1880 15 ouraniou ouraniou IN 19613 1880 16 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1880 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1880 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1880 19 . . . 19613 1881 1 The the DT 19613 1881 2 state state NN 19613 1881 3 of of IN 19613 1881 4 things thing NNS 19613 1881 5 here here RB 19613 1881 6 is be VBZ 19613 1881 7 therefore therefore RB 19613 1881 8 exactly exactly RB 19613 1881 9 the the DT 19613 1881 10 same same JJ 19613 1881 11 as as IN 19613 1881 12 in in IN 19613 1881 13 the the DT 19613 1881 14 case case NN 19613 1881 15 of of IN 19613 1881 16 the the DT 19613 1881 17 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1881 18 _ _ NNP 19613 1881 19 regula regula NN 19613 1881 20 fidei fidei NNP 19613 1881 21 _ _ NNP 19613 1881 22 and and CC 19613 1881 23 the the DT 19613 1881 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1881 25 canon canon NNP 19613 1881 26 of of IN 19613 1881 27 scripture scripture NN 19613 1881 28 . . . 19613 1882 1 Clement clement NN 19613 1882 2 still still RB 19613 1882 3 represents represent VBZ 19613 1882 4 an an DT 19613 1882 5 earlier early JJR 19613 1882 6 stage stage NN 19613 1882 7 , , , 19613 1882 8 whereas whereas IN 19613 1882 9 by by IN 19613 1882 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 1882 11 's 's POS 19613 1882 12 time time NN 19613 1882 13 the the DT 19613 1882 14 revolution revolution NN 19613 1882 15 has have VBZ 19613 1882 16 been be VBN 19613 1882 17 completed complete VBN 19613 1882 18 . . . 19613 1883 1 Wherever wherever WRB 19613 1883 2 this this DT 19613 1883 3 was be VBD 19613 1883 4 so so RB 19613 1883 5 , , , 19613 1883 6 the the DT 19613 1883 7 theory theory NN 19613 1883 8 that that IN 19613 1883 9 the the DT 19613 1883 10 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 1883 11 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 1883 12 was be VBD 19613 1883 13 based base VBN 19613 1883 14 on on IN 19613 1883 15 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1883 16 institution institution NN 19613 1883 17 was be VBD 19613 1883 18 the the DT 19613 1883 19 natural natural JJ 19613 1883 20 result result NN 19613 1883 21 . . . 19613 1884 1 This this DT 19613 1884 2 idea idea NN 19613 1884 3 led lead VBD 19613 1884 4 to to IN 19613 1884 5 the the DT 19613 1884 6 assumption assumption NN 19613 1884 7 -- -- : 19613 1884 8 which which WDT 19613 1884 9 , , , 19613 1884 10 however however RB 19613 1884 11 , , , 19613 1884 12 was be VBD 19613 1884 13 not not RB 19613 1884 14 an an DT 19613 1884 15 immediate immediate JJ 19613 1884 16 consequence consequence NN 19613 1884 17 in in IN 19613 1884 18 all all DT 19613 1884 19 cases case NNS 19613 1884 20 -- -- : 19613 1884 21 that that IN 19613 1884 22 the the DT 19613 1884 23 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 1884 24 office office NN 19613 1884 25 , , , 19613 1884 26 and and CC 19613 1884 27 therefore therefore RB 19613 1884 28 the the DT 19613 1884 29 authority authority NN 19613 1884 30 of of IN 19613 1884 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 1884 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 1884 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 1884 34 , , , 19613 1884 35 was be VBD 19613 1884 36 continued continue VBN 19613 1884 37 in in IN 19613 1884 38 the the DT 19613 1884 39 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 1884 40 : : : 19613 1884 41 " " `` 19613 1884 42 Manifesta Manifesta NNS 19613 1884 43 est e JJS 19613 1884 44 sententia sententia NNP 19613 1884 45 Iesu Iesu NNP 19613 1884 46 Christi Christi NNP 19613 1884 47 apostolos apostolo NNS 19613 1884 48 suos suos NNP 19613 1884 49 mittentis mittentis NNP 19613 1884 50 et et NNP 19613 1884 51 ipsis ipsis NNP 19613 1884 52 solis solis NNP 19613 1884 53 potestatem potestatem NNP 19613 1884 54 a a DT 19613 1884 55 patre patre NNP 19613 1884 56 sibi sibi NNP 19613 1884 57 datam datam NNP 19613 1884 58 permittentis permittentis NNP 19613 1884 59 , , , 19613 1884 60 quibus quibus NNP 19613 1884 61 nos nos NNP 19613 1884 62 successimus successimus NNP 19613 1884 63 eadem eadem NNP 19613 1884 64 potestatex potestatex NNP 19613 1884 65 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 1884 66 domini domini NNP 19613 1884 67 gubernantes gubernantes NNPS 19613 1884 68 et et NNP 19613 1884 69 credentium credentium NN 19613 1884 70 fidem fidem NN 19613 1884 71 baptizantes baptizante NNS 19613 1884 72 " " '' 19613 1884 73 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1884 74 Hartel Hartel NNP 19613 1884 75 , , , 19613 1884 76 Opp Opp NNP 19613 1884 77 . . . 19613 1885 1 Cypr Cypr NNS 19613 1885 2 . . . 19613 1886 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1887 1 459 459 CD 19613 1887 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1887 3 . . . 19613 1887 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1888 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1888 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1888 3 139 139 CD 19613 1888 4 : : : 19613 1888 5 See see VB 19613 1888 6 Rothe rothe DT 19613 1888 7 , , , 19613 1888 8 Die die VB 19613 1888 9 Anfänge anfänge NN 19613 1888 10 der der NN 19613 1888 11 christlichen christlichen NNP 19613 1888 12 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1888 13 und und JJ 19613 1888 14 ihrer ihrer NN 19613 1888 15 Verfassung Verfassung NNP 19613 1888 16 , , , 19613 1888 17 1837 1837 CD 19613 1888 18 . . . 19613 1889 1 Köstlin Köstlin NNP 19613 1889 2 , , , 19613 1889 3 Die Die NNP 19613 1889 4 Katholische Katholische NNP 19613 1889 5 Auffassung Auffassung NNP 19613 1889 6 von von NNP 19613 1889 7 der der VBP 19613 1889 8 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1889 9 in in IN 19613 1889 10 ihrer ihrer NN 19613 1889 11 ersten ersten VBD 19613 1889 12 Ausbildung Ausbildung NNP 19613 1889 13 in in IN 19613 1889 14 the the DT 19613 1889 15 Deutsche Deutsche NNP 19613 1889 16 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 1889 17 für für NN 19613 1889 18 christliche christliche NN 19613 1889 19 Wissenschaft Wissenschaft NNP 19613 1889 20 und und NN 19613 1889 21 christliches christliche VBZ 19613 1889 22 Leben Leben NNP 19613 1889 23 , , , 19613 1889 24 1855 1855 CD 19613 1889 25 . . . 19613 1890 1 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 1890 2 , , , 19613 1890 3 Entstehung Entstehung NNP 19613 1890 4 der der NN 19613 1890 5 altkatholischen altkatholischen NNP 19613 1890 6 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1890 7 , , , 19613 1890 8 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 1890 9 ed ed NNP 19613 1890 10 . . NNP 19613 1890 11 , , , 19613 1890 12 1857 1857 CD 19613 1890 13 . . . 19613 1891 1 Ziegler Ziegler NNP 19613 1891 2 , , , 19613 1891 3 Des Des NNP 19613 1891 4 Irenäus Irenäus NNP 19613 1891 5 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 1891 6 von von NNP 19613 1891 7 der der IN 19613 1891 8 Autorität Autorität NNP 19613 1891 9 der der VBP 19613 1891 10 Schrift Schrift NNP 19613 1891 11 , , , 19613 1891 12 der der VBP 19613 1891 13 Tradition tradition NN 19613 1891 14 und und RB 19613 1891 15 der der NN 19613 1891 16 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1891 17 , , , 19613 1891 18 1868 1868 CD 19613 1891 19 . . . 19613 1892 1 Hackenschmidt hackenschmidt RB 19613 1892 2 , , , 19613 1892 3 Die die VB 19613 1892 4 Anfänge anfänge NN 19613 1892 5 des des FW 19613 1892 6 katholischen katholischen NNP 19613 1892 7 Kirchenbegriffs Kirchenbegriffs NNP 19613 1892 8 , , , 19613 1892 9 1874 1874 CD 19613 1892 10 . . . 19613 1893 1 Hatch Hatch NNP 19613 1893 2 - - HYPH 19613 1893 3 Harnack harnack NN 19613 1893 4 , , , 19613 1893 5 Die Die NNP 19613 1893 6 Gesellschaftsverfassung Gesellschaftsverfassung NNP 19613 1893 7 der der NN 19613 1893 8 christlichen christlichen NNP 19613 1893 9 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1893 10 i -PRON- PRP 19613 1893 11 m be VBP 19613 1893 12 Alterthum Alterthum NNP 19613 1893 13 , , , 19613 1893 14 1883 1883 CD 19613 1893 15 . . . 19613 1894 1 Seeberg Seeberg NNP 19613 1894 2 , , , 19613 1894 3 Zur Zur NNP 19613 1894 4 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 1894 5 des des FW 19613 1894 6 Begriffs Begriffs NNP 19613 1894 7 der der VBP 19613 1894 8 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1894 9 , , , 19613 1894 10 Dorpat Dorpat NNP 19613 1894 11 , , , 19613 1894 12 1884 1884 CD 19613 1894 13 . . . 19613 1895 1 Söder söder NN 19613 1895 2 , , , 19613 1895 3 Der Der NNP 19613 1895 4 Begriff Begriff NNP 19613 1895 5 der der VBD 19613 1895 6 Katholicität Katholicität NNP 19613 1895 7 der der IN 19613 1895 8 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1895 9 und und NN 19613 1895 10 des des FW 19613 1895 11 Glaubens Glaubens NNP 19613 1895 12 , , , 19613 1895 13 1881 1881 CD 19613 1895 14 . . . 19613 1896 1 O. O. NNP 19613 1896 2 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 1896 3 , , , 19613 1896 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1896 5 von von NNP 19613 1896 6 Karthago Karthago NNP 19613 1896 7 und und RB 19613 1896 8 die die VBP 19613 1896 9 Verfassung Verfassung NNP 19613 1896 10 der der NN 19613 1896 11 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 1896 12 , , , 19613 1896 13 1885 1885 CD 19613 1896 14 . . . 19613 1897 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1897 2 This this DT 19613 1897 3 contains contain VBZ 19613 1897 4 the the DT 19613 1897 5 special special JJ 19613 1897 6 literature literature NN 19613 1897 7 treating treating NN 19613 1897 8 of of IN 19613 1897 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1897 10 's 's POS 19613 1897 11 conception conception NN 19613 1897 12 of of IN 19613 1897 13 the the DT 19613 1897 14 Church Church NNP 19613 1897 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1897 16 . . . 19613 1898 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 1898 2 , , , 19613 1898 3 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1898 4 . . NNP 19613 1898 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1899 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1899 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1899 3 140 140 CD 19613 1899 4 : : : 19613 1899 5 See see VB 19613 1899 6 Hatch Hatch NNP 19613 1899 7 , , , 19613 1899 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 1899 9 . . . 19613 1900 1 pp pp NNP 19613 1900 2 . . . 19613 1901 1 191 191 CD 19613 1901 2 , , , 19613 1901 3 253 253 CD 19613 1901 4 . . . 19613 1901 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1902 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1902 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1902 3 141 141 CD 19613 1902 4 : : : 19613 1902 5 See see VB 19613 1902 6 vol vol NNP 19613 1902 7 . . . 19613 1903 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1903 2 p. p. NN 19613 1903 3 150 150 CD 19613 1903 4 f. f. NN 19613 1903 5 Special special JJ 19613 1903 6 note note NN 19613 1903 7 should should MD 19613 1903 8 be be VB 19613 1903 9 given give VBN 19613 1903 10 to to IN 19613 1903 11 the the DT 19613 1903 12 teachings teaching NNS 19613 1903 13 in in IN 19613 1903 14 the the DT 19613 1903 15 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 1903 16 , , , 19613 1903 17 in in IN 19613 1903 18 the the DT 19613 1903 19 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 1903 20 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 1903 21 of of IN 19613 1903 22 Clement Clement NNP 19613 1903 23 and and CC 19613 1903 24 in in IN 19613 1903 25 the the DT 19613 1903 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1903 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1903 28 : : : 19613 1903 29 Didachê didachê NN 19613 1903 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1903 31 . . . 19613 1903 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1904 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1904 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1904 3 142 142 CD 19613 1904 4 : : : 19613 1904 5 This this DT 19613 1904 6 notion notion NN 19613 1904 7 lies lie VBZ 19613 1904 8 at at IN 19613 1904 9 the the DT 19613 1904 10 basis basis NN 19613 1904 11 of of IN 19613 1904 12 the the DT 19613 1904 13 exhortations exhortation NNS 19613 1904 14 of of IN 19613 1904 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 1904 16 . . . 19613 1905 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 1905 2 knows know VBZ 19613 1905 3 nothing nothing NN 19613 1905 4 of of IN 19613 1905 5 an an DT 19613 1905 6 empirical empirical JJ 19613 1905 7 union union NN 19613 1905 8 of of IN 19613 1905 9 the the DT 19613 1905 10 different different JJ 19613 1905 11 communities community NNS 19613 1905 12 into into IN 19613 1905 13 one one CD 19613 1905 14 Church Church NNP 19613 1905 15 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 1905 16 by by IN 19613 1905 17 any any DT 19613 1905 18 law law NN 19613 1905 19 or or CC 19613 1905 20 office office NN 19613 1905 21 . . . 19613 1906 1 The the DT 19613 1906 2 bishop bishop NN 19613 1906 3 is be VBZ 19613 1906 4 of of IN 19613 1906 5 importance importance NN 19613 1906 6 only only RB 19613 1906 7 for for IN 19613 1906 8 the the DT 19613 1906 9 individual individual JJ 19613 1906 10 community community NN 19613 1906 11 , , , 19613 1906 12 and and CC 19613 1906 13 has have VBZ 19613 1906 14 nothing nothing NN 19613 1906 15 to to TO 19613 1906 16 do do VB 19613 1906 17 with with IN 19613 1906 18 the the DT 19613 1906 19 essence essence NN 19613 1906 20 of of IN 19613 1906 21 the the DT 19613 1906 22 Church Church NNP 19613 1906 23 ; ; : 19613 1906 24 nor nor CC 19613 1906 25 does do VBZ 19613 1906 26 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 1906 27 view view VB 19613 1906 28 the the DT 19613 1906 29 separate separate JJ 19613 1906 30 communities community NNS 19613 1906 31 as as IN 19613 1906 32 united united JJ 19613 1906 33 in in IN 19613 1906 34 any any DT 19613 1906 35 other other JJ 19613 1906 36 way way NN 19613 1906 37 than than IN 19613 1906 38 by by IN 19613 1906 39 faith faith NN 19613 1906 40 , , , 19613 1906 41 charity charity NN 19613 1906 42 , , , 19613 1906 43 and and CC 19613 1906 44 hope hope NN 19613 1906 45 . . . 19613 1907 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 1907 2 , , , 19613 1907 3 the the DT 19613 1907 4 invisible invisible JJ 19613 1907 5 Bishop Bishop NNP 19613 1907 6 , , , 19613 1907 7 and and CC 19613 1907 8 the the DT 19613 1907 9 Church Church NNP 19613 1907 10 are be VBP 19613 1907 11 inseparably inseparably RB 19613 1907 12 connected connect VBN 19613 1907 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1907 14 ad ad NN 19613 1907 15 Ephes ephe NNS 19613 1907 16 . . . 19613 1908 1 V. V. NNP 19613 1908 2 1 1 CD 19613 1908 3 ; ; : 19613 1908 4 as as RB 19613 1908 5 well well RB 19613 1908 6 as as IN 19613 1908 7 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 1908 8 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1908 9 . . . 19613 1909 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 1909 2 . . . 19613 1910 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1910 2 , , , 19613 1910 3 and and CC 19613 1910 4 that that DT 19613 1910 5 is be VBZ 19613 1910 6 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 1910 7 the the DT 19613 1910 8 same same JJ 19613 1910 9 idea idea NN 19613 1910 10 , , , 19613 1910 11 as as IN 19613 1910 12 is be VBZ 19613 1910 13 expressed express VBN 19613 1910 14 in in IN 19613 1910 15 the the DT 19613 1910 16 associating associating NN 19613 1910 17 of of IN 19613 1910 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1910 19 Greek greek JJ 19613 1910 20 : : : 19613 1910 21 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 1910 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1910 23 and and CC 19613 1910 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1910 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1910 26 : : : 19613 1910 27 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 1910 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1910 29 . . . 19613 1911 1 But but CC 19613 1911 2 every every DT 19613 1911 3 individual individual JJ 19613 1911 4 community community NN 19613 1911 5 is be VBZ 19613 1911 6 an an DT 19613 1911 7 image image NN 19613 1911 8 of of IN 19613 1911 9 the the DT 19613 1911 10 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 1911 11 Church Church NNP 19613 1911 12 , , , 19613 1911 13 or or CC 19613 1911 14 at at IN 19613 1911 15 least least JJS 19613 1911 16 ought ought MD 19613 1911 17 to to TO 19613 1911 18 be be VB 19613 1911 19 . . . 19613 1911 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1912 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1912 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 1912 3 143 143 CD 19613 1912 4 : : : 19613 1912 5 The the DT 19613 1912 6 expression expression NN 19613 1912 7 " " `` 19613 1912 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 1912 9 Church Church NNP 19613 1912 10 " " '' 19613 1912 11 appears appear VBZ 19613 1912 12 first first RB 19613 1912 13 in in IN 19613 1912 14 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 1912 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1912 16 ad ad FW 19613 1912 17 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 19613 1912 18 . . . 19613 1913 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 1913 2 . . . 19613 1914 1 2 2 LS 19613 1914 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1914 3 : : : 19613 1914 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1914 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1914 6 : : : 19613 1914 7 hopou hopou IN 19613 1914 8 an an DT 19613 1914 9 phanêi phanêi NN 19613 1914 10 ho ho NNP 19613 1914 11 episkopos episkopos NNP 19613 1914 12 , , , 19613 1914 13 ekei ekei NNP 19613 1914 14 to to IN 19613 1914 15 plêthos plêthos NNP 19613 1914 16 esto esto NNP 19613 1914 17 ; ; : 19613 1914 18 hôsper hôsper NNP 19613 1914 19 hopou hopou IN 19613 1914 20 an an DT 19613 1914 21 ê ê NN 19613 1914 22 Christos Christos NNP 19613 1914 23 Iêsous Iêsous NNP 19613 1914 24 , , , 19613 1914 25 ekei ekei RB 19613 1914 26 hê hê NNP 19613 1914 27 katholikê katholikê NNP 19613 1914 28 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 1914 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1914 30 . . . 19613 1915 1 But but CC 19613 1915 2 in in IN 19613 1915 3 this this DT 19613 1915 4 passage passage NN 19613 1915 5 these these DT 19613 1915 6 words word NNS 19613 1915 7 do do VBP 19613 1915 8 not not RB 19613 1915 9 yet yet RB 19613 1915 10 express express VB 19613 1915 11 a a DT 19613 1915 12 new new JJ 19613 1915 13 conception conception NN 19613 1915 14 of of IN 19613 1915 15 the the DT 19613 1915 16 Church Church NNP 19613 1915 17 , , , 19613 1915 18 which which WDT 19613 1915 19 represents represent VBZ 19613 1915 20 her -PRON- PRP 19613 1915 21 as as IN 19613 1915 22 an an DT 19613 1915 23 empirical empirical JJ 19613 1915 24 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 1915 25 . . . 19613 1916 1 Only only RB 19613 1916 2 the the DT 19613 1916 3 individual individual JJ 19613 1916 4 earthly earthly JJ 19613 1916 5 communities community NNS 19613 1916 6 exist exist VBP 19613 1916 7 empirically empirically RB 19613 1916 8 , , , 19613 1916 9 and and CC 19613 1916 10 the the DT 19613 1916 11 universal universal JJ 19613 1916 12 , , , 19613 1916 13 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 1916 14 , , , 19613 1916 15 the the DT 19613 1916 16 whole whole JJ 19613 1916 17 Church Church NNP 19613 1916 18 , , , 19613 1916 19 occupies occupy VBZ 19613 1916 20 the the DT 19613 1916 21 same same JJ 19613 1916 22 position position NN 19613 1916 23 towards towards IN 19613 1916 24 these these DT 19613 1916 25 as as IN 19613 1916 26 the the DT 19613 1916 27 bishops bishop NNS 19613 1916 28 of of IN 19613 1916 29 the the DT 19613 1916 30 individual individual JJ 19613 1916 31 communities community NNS 19613 1916 32 do do VBP 19613 1916 33 towards towards IN 19613 1916 34 the the DT 19613 1916 35 Lord Lord NNP 19613 1916 36 . . . 19613 1917 1 The the DT 19613 1917 2 epithet epithet NN 19613 1917 3 " " `` 19613 1917 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1917 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1917 6 : : : 19613 1917 7 katholikos katholikos NNP 19613 1917 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1917 9 " " `` 19613 1917 10 does do VBZ 19613 1917 11 not not RB 19613 1917 12 of of IN 19613 1917 13 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1917 14 imply imply VB 19613 1917 15 any any DT 19613 1917 16 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 1917 17 of of IN 19613 1917 18 the the DT 19613 1917 19 idea idea NN 19613 1917 20 of of IN 19613 1917 21 the the DT 19613 1917 22 Church Church NNP 19613 1917 23 . . . 19613 1917 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1918 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1918 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1918 3 144 144 CD 19613 1918 4 : : : 19613 1918 5 The the DT 19613 1918 6 expression expression NN 19613 1918 7 " " `` 19613 1918 8 invisible invisible JJ 19613 1918 9 Church Church NNP 19613 1918 10 " " '' 19613 1918 11 is be VBZ 19613 1918 12 liable liable JJ 19613 1918 13 to to TO 19613 1918 14 be be VB 19613 1918 15 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 19613 1918 16 here here RB 19613 1918 17 , , , 19613 1918 18 because because IN 19613 1918 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1918 20 is be VBZ 19613 1918 21 apt apt JJ 19613 1918 22 to to TO 19613 1918 23 impress impress VB 19613 1918 24 us -PRON- PRP 19613 1918 25 as as IN 19613 1918 26 a a DT 19613 1918 27 mere mere JJ 19613 1918 28 idea idea NN 19613 1918 29 , , , 19613 1918 30 which which WDT 19613 1918 31 is be VBZ 19613 1918 32 certainly certainly RB 19613 1918 33 not not RB 19613 1918 34 the the DT 19613 1918 35 meaning meaning NN 19613 1918 36 attached attach VBN 19613 1918 37 to to IN 19613 1918 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1918 39 in in IN 19613 1918 40 the the DT 19613 1918 41 earliest early JJS 19613 1918 42 period period NN 19613 1918 43 . . . 19613 1918 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1919 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1919 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1919 3 145 145 CD 19613 1919 4 : : : 19613 1919 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 1919 6 was be VBD 19613 1919 7 thus thus RB 19613 1919 8 regarded regard VBN 19613 1919 9 by by IN 19613 1919 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 1919 11 in in IN 19613 1919 12 whom whom WP 19613 1919 13 the the DT 19613 1919 14 expression expression NN 19613 1919 15 " " `` 19613 1919 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1919 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1919 18 : : : 19613 1919 19 hê hê VB 19613 1919 20 henôsis henôsis NNP 19613 1919 21 tês tês NNP 19613 1919 22 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1919 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1919 24 " " `` 19613 1919 25 is be VBZ 19613 1919 26 first first RB 19613 1919 27 found find VBN 19613 1919 28 . . . 19613 1920 1 In in IN 19613 1920 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1920 3 view view NN 19613 1920 4 the the DT 19613 1920 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1920 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1920 7 : : : 19613 1920 8 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 1920 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1920 10 is be VBZ 19613 1920 11 founded found VBN 19613 1920 12 on on IN 19613 1920 13 the the DT 19613 1920 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1920 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1920 16 : : : 19613 1920 17 orthos ortho NNS 19613 1920 18 logos logo NNS 19613 1920 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1920 20 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 1920 21 by by IN 19613 1920 22 the the DT 19613 1920 23 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 1920 24 . . . 19613 1921 1 The the DT 19613 1921 2 innovation innovation NN 19613 1921 3 does do VBZ 19613 1921 4 not not RB 19613 1921 5 consist consist VB 19613 1921 6 in in IN 19613 1921 7 the the DT 19613 1921 8 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 1921 9 laid lay VBN 19613 1921 10 upon upon IN 19613 1921 11 faith faith NN 19613 1921 12 , , , 19613 1921 13 for for IN 19613 1921 14 the the DT 19613 1921 15 unity unity NN 19613 1921 16 of of IN 19613 1921 17 faith faith NN 19613 1921 18 was be VBD 19613 1921 19 always always RB 19613 1921 20 supposed suppose VBN 19613 1921 21 to to TO 19613 1921 22 be be VB 19613 1921 23 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 1921 24 by by IN 19613 1921 25 the the DT 19613 1921 26 possession possession NN 19613 1921 27 of of IN 19613 1921 28 the the DT 19613 1921 29 one one CD 19613 1921 30 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 1921 31 and and CC 19613 1921 32 the the DT 19613 1921 33 same same JJ 19613 1921 34 hope hope NN 19613 1921 35 , , , 19613 1921 36 but but CC 19613 1921 37 in in IN 19613 1921 38 the the DT 19613 1921 39 setting setting NN 19613 1921 40 up up RP 19613 1921 41 of of IN 19613 1921 42 a a DT 19613 1921 43 formulated formulate VBN 19613 1921 44 creed creed NN 19613 1921 45 , , , 19613 1921 46 which which WDT 19613 1921 47 resulted result VBD 19613 1921 48 in in IN 19613 1921 49 a a DT 19613 1921 50 loosening loosening NN 19613 1921 51 of of IN 19613 1921 52 the the DT 19613 1921 53 connection connection NN 19613 1921 54 between between IN 19613 1921 55 faith faith NN 19613 1921 56 and and CC 19613 1921 57 conduct conduct NN 19613 1921 58 . . . 19613 1922 1 The the DT 19613 1922 2 transition transition NN 19613 1922 3 to to IN 19613 1922 4 the the DT 19613 1922 5 new new JJ 19613 1922 6 conception conception NN 19613 1922 7 of of IN 19613 1922 8 the the DT 19613 1922 9 Church Church NNP 19613 1922 10 was be VBD 19613 1922 11 therefore therefore RB 19613 1922 12 a a DT 19613 1922 13 gradual gradual JJ 19613 1922 14 one one NN 19613 1922 15 . . . 19613 1923 1 The the DT 19613 1923 2 way way NN 19613 1923 3 is be VBZ 19613 1923 4 very very RB 19613 1923 5 plainly plainly RB 19613 1923 6 prepared prepared JJ 19613 1923 7 for for IN 19613 1923 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1923 9 in in IN 19613 1923 10 1 1 CD 19613 1923 11 Tim Tim NNP 19613 1923 12 . . . 19613 1924 1 III iii CD 19613 1924 2 . . . 19613 1925 1 15 15 CD 19613 1925 2 : : : 19613 1925 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1925 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1925 5 : : : 19613 1925 6 oikos oikos NNP 19613 1925 7 theou theou NNP 19613 1925 8 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 1925 9 , , , 19613 1925 10 stulos stulos NNP 19613 1925 11 kai kai NNP 19613 1925 12 hedraiôma hedraiôma NNP 19613 1925 13 tês tês NNP 19613 1925 14 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 1925 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1925 16 . . . 19613 1925 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1926 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1926 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 1926 3 146 146 CD 19613 1926 4 : : : 19613 1926 5 The the DT 19613 1926 6 oldest old JJS 19613 1926 7 predicate predicate NN 19613 1926 8 which which WDT 19613 1926 9 was be VBD 19613 1926 10 given give VBN 19613 1926 11 to to IN 19613 1926 12 the the DT 19613 1926 13 Church Church NNP 19613 1926 14 and and CC 19613 1926 15 which which WDT 19613 1926 16 was be VBD 19613 1926 17 always always RB 19613 1926 18 associated associate VBN 19613 1926 19 with with IN 19613 1926 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1926 21 , , , 19613 1926 22 was be VBD 19613 1926 23 that that DT 19613 1926 24 of of IN 19613 1926 25 _ _ NNP 19613 1926 26 holiness holiness NN 19613 1926 27 _ _ NNP 19613 1926 28 . . . 19613 1927 1 See see VB 19613 1927 2 the the DT 19613 1927 3 New New NNP 19613 1927 4 Testament Testament NNP 19613 1927 5 ; ; : 19613 1927 6 Barn Barn NNP 19613 1927 7 . . . 19613 1928 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 1928 2 . . . 19613 1929 1 6 6 LS 19613 1929 2 ; ; : 19613 1929 3 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1929 4 , , , 19613 1929 5 Vis Vis NNP 19613 1929 6 . . . 19613 1930 1 I. I. NNP 19613 1931 1 3 3 CD 19613 1931 2 , , , 19613 1931 3 4 4 CD 19613 1931 4 ; ; : 19613 1931 5 I. I. NNP 19613 1932 1 6 6 CD 19613 1932 2 ; ; : 19613 1932 3 the the DT 19613 1932 4 Roman roman JJ 19613 1932 5 symbol symbol NN 19613 1932 6 ; ; : 19613 1932 7 Dial dial NN 19613 1932 8 . . . 19613 1933 1 119 119 CD 19613 1933 2 ; ; : 19613 1933 3 Ignat ignat JJ 19613 1933 4 . . . 19613 1934 1 ad ad NNP 19613 1934 2 Trail Trail NNP 19613 1934 3 , , , 19613 1934 4 inscr inscr NNS 19613 1934 5 . . . 19613 1935 1 ; ; : 19613 1935 2 Theophil Theophil NNP 19613 1935 3 . . . 19613 1936 1 ad ad FW 19613 1936 2 Autol Autol NNP 19613 1936 3 . . . 19613 1936 4 , , , 19613 1936 5 II II NNP 19613 1936 6 . . . 19613 1937 1 14 14 CD 19613 1937 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1937 3 here here RB 19613 1937 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1937 5 have have VBP 19613 1937 6 even even RB 19613 1937 7 the the DT 19613 1937 8 plural plural NN 19613 1937 9 , , , 19613 1937 10 " " `` 19613 1937 11 holy holy JJ 19613 1937 12 churches church NNS 19613 1937 13 " " '' 19613 1937 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1937 15 ; ; : 19613 1937 16 Apollon Apollon NNP 19613 1937 17 . . . 19613 1938 1 in in IN 19613 1938 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1938 3 , , , 19613 1938 4 H. H. NNP 19613 1938 5 E. E. NNP 19613 1938 6 V. V. NNP 19613 1938 7 18 18 CD 19613 1938 8 . . . 19613 1939 1 5 5 LS 19613 1939 2 ; ; : 19613 1939 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1939 4 . . NNP 19613 1939 5 , , , 19613 1939 6 adv adv NNP 19613 1939 7 . . . 19613 1940 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 1940 2 . . . 19613 1941 1 IV IV NNP 19613 1941 2 . . . 19613 1942 1 13 13 CD 19613 1942 2 ; ; : 19613 1942 3 V. V. NNP 19613 1942 4 4 4 CD 19613 1942 5 ; ; : 19613 1942 6 de de NNP 19613 1942 7 pudicit pudicit NNP 19613 1942 8 . . . 19613 1943 1 1 1 LS 19613 1943 2 ; ; : 19613 1943 3 Mart Mart NNP 19613 1943 4 . . . 19613 1944 1 Polyc polyc NN 19613 1944 2 inscr inscr NNS 19613 1944 3 . . . 19613 1945 1 ; ; : 19613 1945 2 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 1945 3 Hieros Hieros NNP 19613 1945 4 . . . 19613 1946 1 in in IN 19613 1946 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1946 3 . . NNP 19613 1946 4 , , , 19613 1946 5 H. H. NNP 19613 1946 6 E. E. NNP 19613 1946 7 VI VI NNP 19613 1946 8 . . . 19613 1947 1 11 11 CD 19613 1947 2 . . . 19613 1948 1 5 5 LS 19613 1948 2 ; ; : 19613 1948 3 Clemens Clemens NNP 19613 1948 4 Alex Alex NNP 19613 1948 5 . . . 19613 1949 1 ; ; : 19613 1949 2 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 1949 3 in in IN 19613 1949 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1949 5 . . NNP 19613 1949 6 , , , 19613 1949 7 VI VI NNP 19613 1949 8 . . . 19613 1950 1 43 43 CD 19613 1950 2 . . . 19613 1951 1 6 6 LS 19613 1951 2 ; ; : 19613 1951 3 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1951 4 . . . 19613 1952 1 But but CC 19613 1952 2 the the DT 19613 1952 3 holiness holiness NN 19613 1952 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1952 5 purity purity NN 19613 1952 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1952 7 of of IN 19613 1952 8 the the DT 19613 1952 9 Church Church NNP 19613 1952 10 was be VBD 19613 1952 11 already already RB 19613 1952 12 referred refer VBN 19613 1952 13 by by IN 19613 1952 14 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 1952 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1952 16 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1952 17 . . NNP 19613 1952 18 , , , 19613 1952 19 H. H. NNP 19613 1952 20 E. E. NNP 19613 1952 21 IV IV NNP 19613 1952 22 . . . 19613 1953 1 22 22 CD 19613 1953 2 . . . 19613 1954 1 4 4 LS 19613 1954 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1954 3 to to IN 19613 1954 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1954 5 pure pure JJ 19613 1954 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 1954 7 : : : 19613 1954 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1954 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1954 10 : : : 19613 1954 11 ekaloun ekaloun NNP 19613 1954 12 tên tên NNP 19613 1954 13 ekklêsian ekklêsian NNP 19613 1954 14 parthenon parthenon NNP 19613 1954 15 ; ; : 19613 1954 16 oupô oupô NNP 19613 1954 17 gar gar NNP 19613 1954 18 ephtharto ephtharto NNP 19613 1954 19 akoais akoais NNP 19613 1954 20 mataiais mataiais NNP 19613 1954 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1954 22 . . . 19613 1955 1 The the DT 19613 1955 2 unity unity NN 19613 1955 3 of of IN 19613 1955 4 the the DT 19613 1955 5 Church Church NNP 19613 1955 6 according accord VBG 19613 1955 7 to to IN 19613 1955 8 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 1955 9 is be VBZ 19613 1955 10 specially specially RB 19613 1955 11 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 1955 12 in in IN 19613 1955 13 the the DT 19613 1955 14 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1955 15 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1955 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1955 17 line line NN 19613 1955 18 55 55 CD 19613 1955 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1955 20 : : : 19613 1955 21 see see VB 19613 1955 22 also also RB 19613 1955 23 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 1955 24 ; ; : 19613 1955 25 Justin Justin NNP 19613 1955 26 ; ; : 19613 1955 27 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1955 28 ; ; : 19613 1955 29 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1955 30 , , , 19613 1955 31 de de NNP 19613 1955 32 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1955 33 . . . 19613 1956 1 20 20 CD 19613 1956 2 ; ; : 19613 1956 3 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1956 4 . . . 19613 1957 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 1957 2 . . . 19613 1957 3 , , , 19613 1957 4 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1957 5 . . . 19613 1958 1 VII VII NNP 19613 1958 2 . . . 19613 1959 1 17 17 CD 19613 1959 2 . . . 19613 1960 1 107 107 CD 19613 1960 2 . . . 19613 1961 1 Even even RB 19613 1961 2 before before IN 19613 1961 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1961 4 and and CC 19613 1961 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 1961 6 the the DT 19613 1961 7 _ _ NNP 19613 1961 8 universality universality NN 19613 1961 9 _ _ NNP 19613 1961 10 of of IN 19613 1961 11 the the DT 19613 1961 12 Church Church NNP 19613 1961 13 was be VBD 19613 1961 14 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 1961 15 for for IN 19613 1961 16 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 1961 17 purposes purpose NNS 19613 1961 18 . . . 19613 1962 1 In in IN 19613 1962 2 so so RB 19613 1962 3 far far RB 19613 1962 4 as as IN 19613 1962 5 universality universality NN 19613 1962 6 is be VBZ 19613 1962 7 a a DT 19613 1962 8 proof proof NN 19613 1962 9 of of IN 19613 1962 10 truth truth NN 19613 1962 11 , , , 19613 1962 12 " " '' 19613 1962 13 universal universal JJ 19613 1962 14 " " '' 19613 1962 15 is be VBZ 19613 1962 16 equivalent equivalent JJ 19613 1962 17 to to IN 19613 1962 18 " " `` 19613 1962 19 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 1962 20 . . . 19613 1962 21 " " '' 19613 1963 1 This this DT 19613 1963 2 signification signification NN 19613 1963 3 is be VBZ 19613 1963 4 specially specially RB 19613 1963 5 clear clear JJ 19613 1963 6 in in IN 19613 1963 7 expressions expression NNS 19613 1963 8 like like IN 19613 1963 9 : : : 19613 1963 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1963 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1963 12 : : : 19613 1963 13 hê hê VB 19613 1963 14 en en NNP 19613 1963 15 Smurnê Smurnê NNP 19613 1963 16 katholikê katholikê NNP 19613 1963 17 ekklêsia ekklêsia NN 19613 1963 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1963 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1963 20 Mart Mart NNP 19613 1963 21 . . . 19613 1964 1 Polyc polyc NN 19613 1964 2 . . . 19613 1965 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 1965 2 . . . 19613 1966 1 2 2 LS 19613 1966 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1966 3 . . . 19613 1967 1 From from IN 19613 1967 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1967 3 , , , 19613 1967 4 III III NNP 19613 1967 5 . . . 19613 1968 1 15 15 CD 19613 1968 2 , , , 19613 1968 3 2 2 CD 19613 1968 4 , , , 19613 1968 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 1968 6 must must MD 19613 1968 7 conclude conclude VB 19613 1968 8 that that IN 19613 1968 9 the the DT 19613 1968 10 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 1968 11 called call VBD 19613 1968 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 1968 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 1968 14 opponents opponent NNS 19613 1968 15 " " '' 19613 1968 16 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 1968 17 . . . 19613 1968 18 " " '' 19613 1969 1 The the DT 19613 1969 2 word word NN 19613 1969 3 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 1969 4 is be VBZ 19613 1969 5 not not RB 19613 1969 6 yet yet RB 19613 1969 7 found find VBN 19613 1969 8 in in IN 19613 1969 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 1969 10 , , , 19613 1969 11 but but CC 19613 1969 12 the the DT 19613 1969 13 idea idea NN 19613 1969 14 is be VBZ 19613 1969 15 there there RB 19613 1969 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1969 17 see see UH 19613 1969 18 I. I. NNP 19613 1970 1 10 10 CD 19613 1970 2 . . . 19613 1971 1 2 2 LS 19613 1971 2 ; ; : 19613 1971 3 II II NNP 19613 1971 4 . . . 19613 1972 1 9 9 CD 19613 1972 2 . . . 19613 1973 1 1 1 CD 19613 1973 2 , , , 19613 1973 3 etc etc FW 19613 1973 4 . . FW 19613 1973 5 , , , 19613 1973 6 Serapion Serapion NNP 19613 1973 7 in in IN 19613 1973 8 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1973 9 . . NNP 19613 1973 10 , , , 19613 1973 11 H.E. H.E. NNP 19613 1974 1 V. V. NNP 19613 1974 2 19 19 CD 19613 1974 3 : : : 19613 1974 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1974 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1974 6 : : : 19613 1974 7 pasa pasa NNP 19613 1974 8 hê hê NNP 19613 1974 9 en en FW 19613 1974 10 kosmô kosmô NNP 19613 1974 11 adelphotês adelphotês NN 19613 1974 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1974 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1974 14 . . . 19613 1975 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1975 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1975 3 : : : 19613 1975 4 Katholikos Katholikos NNP 19613 1975 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1975 6 is be VBZ 19613 1975 7 found find VBN 19613 1975 8 as as IN 19613 1975 9 a a DT 19613 1975 10 designation designation NN 19613 1975 11 of of IN 19613 1975 12 the the DT 19613 1975 13 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 1975 14 , , , 19613 1975 15 visible visible JJ 19613 1975 16 Church Church NNP 19613 1975 17 in in IN 19613 1975 18 Mart Mart NNP 19613 1975 19 . . . 19613 1976 1 Polyc polyc NN 19613 1976 2 . . . 19613 1977 1 inscr inscr NNP 19613 1977 2 . . . 19613 1978 1 : : : 19613 1978 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 1978 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 1978 4 : : : 19613 1978 5 hai hai NNP 19613 1978 6 kata kata NNP 19613 1978 7 panta panta NNP 19613 1978 8 topon topon NNP 19613 1978 9 tês tês NNP 19613 1978 10 hagias hagias NNP 19613 1978 11 katholikês katholikês NNP 19613 1978 12 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 1978 13 paroikiai paroikiai NNP 19613 1978 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 1978 15 ; ; : 19613 1978 16 19 19 CD 19613 1978 17 . . . 19613 1979 1 2 2 CD 19613 1979 2 ; ; : 19613 1979 3 16 16 CD 19613 1979 4 . . . 19613 1980 1 2 2 LS 19613 1980 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 1980 3 in in IN 19613 1980 4 all all PDT 19613 1980 5 these these DT 19613 1980 6 passages passage NNS 19613 1980 7 , , , 19613 1980 8 however however RB 19613 1980 9 , , , 19613 1980 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 1980 11 is be VBZ 19613 1980 12 probably probably RB 19613 1980 13 an an DT 19613 1980 14 interpolation interpolation NN 19613 1980 15 , , , 19613 1980 16 as as IN 19613 1980 17 I -PRON- PRP 19613 1980 18 have have VBP 19613 1980 19 shown show VBN 19613 1980 20 in in IN 19613 1980 21 the the DT 19613 1980 22 " " `` 19613 1980 23 Expositor Expositor NNP 19613 1980 24 " " '' 19613 1980 25 for for IN 19613 1980 26 Dec. December NNP 19613 1980 27 1885 1885 CD 19613 1980 28 , , , 19613 1980 29 p. p. NN 19613 1980 30 410 410 CD 19613 1980 31 f f NNP 19613 1980 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 1980 33 ; ; : 19613 1980 34 in in IN 19613 1980 35 the the DT 19613 1980 36 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 1980 37 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 1980 38 61 61 CD 19613 1980 39 , , , 19613 1980 40 66 66 CD 19613 1980 41 , , , 19613 1980 42 69 69 CD 19613 1980 43 ; ; : 19613 1980 44 in in IN 19613 1980 45 the the DT 19613 1980 46 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 1980 47 writer writer NN 19613 1980 48 in in IN 19613 1980 49 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 1980 50 . . NNP 19613 1980 51 , , , 19613 1980 52 H. H. NNP 19613 1980 53 E. E. NNP 19613 1980 54 V. V. NNP 19613 1980 55 16 16 CD 19613 1980 56 . . . 19613 1981 1 9 9 CD 19613 1981 2 . . . 19613 1981 3 in in IN 19613 1981 4 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1981 5 . . . 19613 1982 1 frequently frequently RB 19613 1982 2 , , , 19613 1982 3 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 1982 4 , , , 19613 1982 5 de de NNP 19613 1982 6 præscr præscr NNS 19613 1982 7 . . . 19613 1983 1 26 26 CD 19613 1983 2 , , , 19613 1983 3 30 30 CD 19613 1983 4 ; ; : 19613 1983 5 adv adv NN 19613 1983 6 . . . 19613 1984 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 1984 2 . . . 19613 1985 1 III iii CD 19613 1985 2 . . . 19613 1986 1 22 22 CD 19613 1986 2 : : : 19613 1986 3 IV IV NNP 19613 1986 4 . . . 19613 1987 1 4 4 LS 19613 1987 2 ; ; : 19613 1987 3 in in IN 19613 1987 4 Clem Clem NNP 19613 1987 5 . . . 19613 1988 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 1988 2 . . . 19613 1988 3 , , , 19613 1988 4 Strom Strom NNP 19613 1988 5 . . . 19613 1989 1 VII VII NNP 19613 1989 2 . . . 19613 1990 1 17 17 CD 19613 1990 2 . . . 19613 1991 1 106 106 CD 19613 1991 2 , , , 19613 1991 3 107 107 CD 19613 1991 4 ; ; : 19613 1991 5 in in IN 19613 1991 6 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 1991 7 . . . 19613 1992 1 Philos Philos NNP 19613 1992 2 . . . 19613 1993 1 IX ix NN 19613 1993 2 . . . 19613 1994 1 12 12 CD 19613 1994 2 ; ; : 19613 1994 3 in in IN 19613 1994 4 Mart Mart NNP 19613 1994 5 . . . 19613 1995 1 Pionii Pionii NNP 19613 1995 2 2 2 CD 19613 1995 3 , , , 19613 1995 4 9 9 CD 19613 1995 5 , , , 19613 1995 6 13 13 CD 19613 1995 7 , , , 19613 1995 8 19 19 CD 19613 1995 9 ; ; : 19613 1995 10 in in IN 19613 1995 11 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 1995 12 in in IN 19613 1995 13 Cypr Cypr NNP 19613 1995 14 . . . 19613 1995 15 , , , 19613 1995 16 epp epp NNP 19613 1995 17 . . . 19613 1996 1 49 49 CD 19613 1996 2 . . . 19613 1997 1 2 2 LS 19613 1997 2 ; ; : 19613 1997 3 and and CC 19613 1997 4 in in IN 19613 1997 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1997 6 . . . 19613 1998 1 The the DT 19613 1998 2 expression expression NN 19613 1998 3 " " `` 19613 1998 4 catholica catholica NNP 19613 1998 5 traditio traditio NNP 19613 1998 6 " " '' 19613 1998 7 occurs occur VBZ 19613 1998 8 in in IN 19613 1998 9 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 1998 10 . . NNP 19613 1998 11 , , , 19613 1998 12 de de NNP 19613 1998 13 monog monog NNP 19613 1998 14 . . . 19613 1999 1 2 2 LS 19613 1999 2 , , , 19613 1999 3 " " `` 19613 1999 4 fides fide VBZ 19613 1999 5 catholica catholica NNP 19613 1999 6 " " '' 19613 1999 7 in in IN 19613 1999 8 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 1999 9 ep ep NNP 19613 1999 10 . . . 19613 2000 1 25 25 CD 19613 2000 2 , , , 19613 2000 3 " " '' 19613 2000 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2000 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2000 6 : : : 19613 2000 7 kanôn kanôn NNP 19613 2000 8 katholikos katholikos NNP 19613 2000 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2000 10 " " `` 19613 2000 11 in in IN 19613 2000 12 the the DT 19613 2000 13 Mart Mart NNP 19613 2000 14 . . . 19613 2001 1 Polyc polyc NN 19613 2001 2 . . . 19613 2002 1 rec rec NNP 19613 2002 2 . . . 19613 2003 1 Mosq Mosq NNP 19613 2003 2 . . . 19613 2004 1 fin fin NNP 19613 2004 2 . . . 19613 2005 1 and and CC 19613 2005 2 Cypr Cypr NNS 19613 2005 3 . . . 19613 2006 1 ep ep NNP 19613 2006 2 . . . 19613 2007 1 70 70 CD 19613 2007 2 . . . 19613 2008 1 1 1 LS 19613 2008 2 , , , 19613 2008 3 " " `` 19613 2008 4 catholica catholica NNP 19613 2008 5 fides fides NNPS 19613 2008 6 et et NNP 19613 2008 7 religio religio VBN 19613 2008 8 " " '' 19613 2008 9 in in IN 19613 2008 10 the the DT 19613 2008 11 Mart Mart NNP 19613 2008 12 . . . 19613 2009 1 Pionii Pionii NNP 19613 2009 2 18 18 CD 19613 2009 3 . . . 19613 2010 1 In in IN 19613 2010 2 the the DT 19613 2010 3 earlier early JJR 19613 2010 4 Christian christian JJ 19613 2010 5 literature literature NN 19613 2010 6 the the DT 19613 2010 7 word word NN 19613 2010 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2010 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2010 10 : : : 19613 2010 11 katholikos katholikos NNP 19613 2010 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2010 13 occurs occur VBZ 19613 2010 14 in in IN 19613 2010 15 various various JJ 19613 2010 16 connections connection NNS 19613 2010 17 in in IN 19613 2010 18 the the DT 19613 2010 19 following follow VBG 19613 2010 20 passages passage NNS 19613 2010 21 : : : 19613 2010 22 in in IN 19613 2010 23 fragments fragment NNS 19613 2010 24 of of IN 19613 2010 25 the the DT 19613 2010 26 Peratae Peratae NNP 19613 2010 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2010 28 Philos Philos NNP 19613 2010 29 . . . 19613 2011 1 V. V. NNP 19613 2011 2 16 16 CD 19613 2011 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2011 4 , , , 19613 2011 5 and and CC 19613 2011 6 in in IN 19613 2011 7 Herakleon Herakleon NNP 19613 2011 8 , , , 19613 2011 9 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 2012 1 in in IN 19613 2012 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2012 3 , , , 19613 2012 4 Strom Strom NNP 19613 2012 5 . . . 19613 2013 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2013 2 . . . 19613 2014 1 9 9 CD 19613 2014 2 . . . 19613 2015 1 71 71 CD 19613 2015 2 ; ; : 19613 2015 3 in in IN 19613 2015 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 2015 5 , , , 19613 2015 6 Dial Dial NNP 19613 2015 7 . . NNP 19613 2015 8 , , , 19613 2015 9 81 81 CD 19613 2015 10 , , , 19613 2015 11 102 102 CD 19613 2015 12 ; ; : 19613 2015 13 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 2015 14 . . NNP 19613 2015 15 , , , 19613 2015 16 27 27 CD 19613 2015 17 ; ; : 19613 2015 18 Theophil Theophil NNP 19613 2015 19 . . . 19613 2016 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2017 1 13 13 CD 19613 2017 2 ; ; : 19613 2017 3 Pseudojustin Pseudojustin NNP 19613 2017 4 , , , 19613 2017 5 de de FW 19613 2017 6 monarch monarch NNP 19613 2017 7 . . . 19613 2018 1 1 1 CD 19613 2018 2 , , , 19613 2018 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2018 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2018 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2018 6 : : : 19613 2018 7 kathol kathol NNP 19613 2018 8 . . . 19613 2019 1 doxa doxa NNP 19613 2019 2 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2019 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2019 4 ; ; : 19613 2019 5 Iren Iren NNP 19613 2019 6 . . . 19613 2019 7 , , , 19613 2019 8 III iii CD 19613 2019 9 . . . 19613 2020 1 11 11 CD 19613 2020 2 , , , 19613 2020 3 8 8 CD 19613 2020 4 ; ; : 19613 2020 5 Apollon Apollon NNP 19613 2020 6 . . . 19613 2021 1 in in IN 19613 2021 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2021 3 . . NNP 19613 2021 4 , , , 19613 2021 5 H. H. NNP 19613 2021 6 E. E. NNP 19613 2021 7 IV IV NNP 19613 2021 8 . . . 19613 2022 1 18 18 CD 19613 2022 2 5 5 CD 19613 2022 3 , , , 19613 2022 4 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2022 5 . . NNP 19613 2022 6 , , , 19613 2022 7 de de FW 19613 2022 8 fuga fuga NNP 19613 2022 9 3 3 CD 19613 2022 10 ; ; : 19613 2022 11 adv adv NN 19613 2022 12 . . . 19613 2023 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 2023 2 . . . 19613 2024 1 II ii CD 19613 2024 2 . . . 19613 2025 1 17 17 CD 19613 2025 2 ; ; : 19613 2025 3 IV IV NNP 19613 2025 4 . . . 19613 2026 1 9 9 LS 19613 2026 2 ; ; : 19613 2026 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2026 4 , , , 19613 2026 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 2026 6 , , , 19613 2026 7 IV IV NNP 19613 2026 8 . . . 19613 2027 1 15 15 CD 19613 2027 2 . . . 19613 2028 1 97 97 CD 19613 2028 2 ; ; : 19613 2028 3 VI VI NNP 19613 2028 4 . . . 19613 2029 1 6 6 CD 19613 2029 2 . . . 19613 2030 1 47 47 CD 19613 2030 2 ; ; SYM 19613 2030 3 7 7 CD 19613 2030 4 . . . 19613 2031 1 57 57 CD 19613 2031 2 ; ; SYM 19613 2031 3 8 8 CD 19613 2031 4 . . . 19613 2032 1 67 67 CD 19613 2032 2 . . . 19613 2033 1 The the DT 19613 2033 2 addition addition NN 19613 2033 3 " " `` 19613 2033 4 catholicam catholicam NN 19613 2033 5 " " '' 19613 2033 6 found find VBD 19613 2033 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2033 8 way way NN 19613 2033 9 into into IN 19613 2033 10 the the DT 19613 2033 11 symbols symbol NNS 19613 2033 12 of of IN 19613 2033 13 the the DT 19613 2033 14 West West NNP 19613 2033 15 only only RB 19613 2033 16 at at IN 19613 2033 17 a a DT 19613 2033 18 comparatively comparatively RB 19613 2033 19 late late JJ 19613 2033 20 period period NN 19613 2033 21 . . . 19613 2034 1 The the DT 19613 2034 2 earlier early JJR 19613 2034 3 expressions expression NNS 19613 2034 4 for for IN 19613 2034 5 the the DT 19613 2034 6 whole whole NN 19613 2034 7 of of IN 19613 2034 8 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2034 9 are be VBP 19613 2034 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2034 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2034 12 : : : 19613 2034 13 pasai pasai NNP 19613 2034 14 hai hai NNP 19613 2034 15 ekklêsiai ekklêsiai NNP 19613 2034 16 , , , 19613 2034 17 ekklêsiai ekklêsiai NNP 19613 2034 18 kata kata NNP 19613 2034 19 pasan pasan NNP 19613 2034 20 polin polin NNP 19613 2034 21 , , , 19613 2034 22 ekklêsiai ekklêsiai NNP 19613 2034 23 en en IN 19613 2034 24 kosmô kosmô NNP 19613 2034 25 , , , 19613 2034 26 hai hai VB 19613 2034 27 huph huph NNP 19613 2034 28 ' ' POS 19613 2034 29 ouranou ouranou NN 19613 2034 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2034 31 , , , 19613 2034 32 etc etc FW 19613 2034 33 . . . 19613 2034 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2035 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2035 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2035 3 147 147 CD 19613 2035 4 : : : 19613 2035 5 Very very RB 19613 2035 6 significant significant JJ 19613 2035 7 is be VBZ 19613 2035 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2035 9 's 's POS 19613 2035 10 expression expression NN 19613 2035 11 in in IN 19613 2035 12 adv adv NN 19613 2035 13 . . . 19613 2036 1 Val Val NNP 19613 2036 2 . . . 19613 2037 1 4 4 LS 19613 2037 2 : : : 19613 2037 3 " " `` 19613 2037 4 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 2037 5 de de NNP 19613 2037 6 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2037 7 authenticæ authenticæ NNP 19613 2037 8 regulæ regulæ NNP 19613 2037 9 abrupit abrupit NNP 19613 2037 10 , , , 19613 2037 11 " " '' 19613 2037 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2037 13 but but CC 19613 2037 14 probably probably RB 19613 2037 15 this this DT 19613 2037 16 still still RB 19613 2037 17 refers refer VBZ 19613 2037 18 specially specially RB 19613 2037 19 to to IN 19613 2037 20 the the DT 19613 2037 21 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2037 22 Church Church NNP 19613 2037 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2037 24 . . . 19613 2037 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2038 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2038 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2038 3 148 148 CD 19613 2038 4 : : : 19613 2038 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2038 6 called call VBD 19613 2038 7 the the DT 19613 2038 8 Church Church NNP 19613 2038 9 _ _ NNP 19613 2038 10 mother mother NN 19613 2038 11 _ _ NNP 19613 2038 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2038 13 in in IN 19613 2038 14 Gal Gal NNP 19613 2038 15 . . . 19613 2039 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2039 2 . . . 19613 2040 1 26 26 CD 19613 2040 2 the the DT 19613 2040 3 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 2040 4 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 2040 5 is be VBZ 19613 2040 6 called call VBN 19613 2040 7 " " `` 19613 2040 8 mother mother NN 19613 2040 9 " " '' 19613 2040 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2040 11 ; ; : 19613 2040 12 see see VB 19613 2040 13 de de NNP 19613 2040 14 oral oral NNP 19613 2040 15 . . . 19613 2041 1 2 2 LS 19613 2041 2 : : : 19613 2041 3 " " `` 19613 2041 4 ne ne NNP 19613 2041 5 mater mater NNP 19613 2041 6 quidem quidem NNP 19613 2041 7 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2041 8 pixeterhur pixeterhur NNP 19613 2041 9 , , , 19613 2041 10 " " '' 19613 2041 11 de de FW 19613 2041 12 monog monog NNP 19613 2041 13 . . . 19613 2042 1 7 7 LS 19613 2042 2 ; ; : 19613 2042 3 adv adv NN 19613 2042 4 . . . 19613 2043 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 2043 2 . . . 19613 2044 1 V. V. NNP 19613 2044 2 4 4 CD 19613 2044 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2044 4 the the DT 19613 2044 5 author author NN 19613 2044 6 of of IN 19613 2044 7 the the DT 19613 2044 8 letter letter NN 19613 2044 9 in in IN 19613 2044 10 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2044 11 . . NNP 19613 2044 12 , , , 19613 2044 13 H. H. NNP 19613 2044 14 E. E. NNP 19613 2044 15 V. V. NNP 19613 2044 16 2 2 CD 19613 2044 17 . . . 19613 2045 1 7 7 CD 19613 2045 2 , , , 19613 2045 3 1 1 CD 19613 2045 4 . . . 19613 2046 1 45 45 CD 19613 2046 2 , , , 19613 2046 3 had have VBD 19613 2046 4 already already RB 19613 2046 5 done do VBN 19613 2046 6 this this DT 19613 2046 7 before before IN 19613 2046 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2046 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2046 10 . . . 19613 2047 1 In in IN 19613 2047 2 the the DT 19613 2047 3 African African NNP 19613 2047 4 Church Church NNP 19613 2047 5 the the DT 19613 2047 6 symbol symbol NN 19613 2047 7 was be VBD 19613 2047 8 thus thus RB 19613 2047 9 worded word VBN 19613 2047 10 soon soon RB 19613 2047 11 after after IN 19613 2047 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2047 13 's 's POS 19613 2047 14 time time NN 19613 2047 15 : : : 19613 2047 16 " " `` 19613 2047 17 credis credis NNP 19613 2047 18 in in IN 19613 2047 19 remissionem remissionem NNP 19613 2047 20 peccatorum peccatorum NNP 19613 2047 21 et et NNP 19613 2047 22 vitam vitam NNP 19613 2047 23 æsternam æsternam NNP 19613 2047 24 per per IN 19613 2047 25 sanctam sanctam NNP 19613 2047 26 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 2047 27 " " '' 19613 2047 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2047 29 see see VB 19613 2047 30 Hahn Hahn NNP 19613 2047 31 , , , 19613 2047 32 Bibliothek Bibliothek NNP 19613 2047 33 der der IN 19613 2047 34 Symbole Symbole NNP 19613 2047 35 , , , 19613 2047 36 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 2047 37 ed ed NN 19613 2047 38 . . . 19613 2048 1 p. p. NN 19613 2048 2 29 29 CD 19613 2048 3 ff ff NNP 19613 2048 4 . . . 19613 2048 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2049 1 On on IN 19613 2049 2 the the DT 19613 2049 3 other other JJ 19613 2049 4 hand hand NN 19613 2049 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2049 6 of of IN 19613 2049 7 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2049 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2049 9 Strom Strom NNP 19613 2049 10 . . . 19613 2050 1 VI VI NNP 19613 2050 2 . . . 19613 2051 1 16 16 CD 19613 2051 2 . . . 19613 2052 1 146 146 LS 19613 2052 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2052 3 rejected reject VBD 19613 2052 4 the the DT 19613 2052 5 designation designation NN 19613 2052 6 of of IN 19613 2052 7 the the DT 19613 2052 8 Church Church NNP 19613 2052 9 , , , 19613 2052 10 as as IN 19613 2052 11 " " `` 19613 2052 12 mother mother NN 19613 2052 13 " " '' 19613 2052 14 : : : 19613 2052 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2052 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2052 17 : : : 19613 2052 18 mêtêr mêtêr NNP 19613 2052 19 de de NNP 19613 2052 20 ouch ouch NNP 19613 2052 21 , , , 19613 2052 22 hôs hôs NNP 19613 2052 23 tines tin VBZ 19613 2052 24 ekdedôkasin ekdedôkasin NNP 19613 2052 25 , , , 19613 2052 26 hê hê NNP 19613 2052 27 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2052 28 , , , 19613 2052 29 all all DT 19613 2052 30 ' ' `` 19613 2052 31 hê hê VB 19613 2052 32 theia theia NN 19613 2052 33 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 2052 34 kai kai NNP 19613 2052 35 hê hê NNP 19613 2052 36 sophia sophia NNP 19613 2052 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2052 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2052 39 there there EX 19613 2052 40 is be VBZ 19613 2052 41 a a DT 19613 2052 42 different different JJ 19613 2052 43 idea idea NN 19613 2052 44 in in IN 19613 2052 45 Pæd pæd NN 19613 2052 46 . . . 19613 2053 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2054 1 5 5 CD 19613 2054 2 . . . 19613 2055 1 21 21 CD 19613 2055 2 . . . 19613 2055 3 and and CC 19613 2055 4 6 6 CD 19613 2055 5 . . . 19613 2056 1 42 42 CD 19613 2056 2 : : : 19613 2056 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2056 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2056 5 : : : 19613 2056 6 mêtêr mêtêr NNP 19613 2056 7 parthenos parthenos NNP 19613 2056 8 ; ; : 19613 2056 9 ekklêsian ekklêsian NNP 19613 2056 10 emoi emoi NNP 19613 2056 11 philon philon NNP 19613 2056 12 autên autên NNP 19613 2056 13 kalein kalein NNP 19613 2056 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2056 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2056 16 . . . 19613 2057 1 In in IN 19613 2057 2 the the DT 19613 2057 3 Acta Acta NNP 19613 2057 4 Justini Justini NNP 19613 2057 5 c. c. NN 19613 2057 6 4 4 CD 19613 2057 7 the the DT 19613 2057 8 faith faith NN 19613 2057 9 is be VBZ 19613 2057 10 named name VBN 19613 2057 11 " " `` 19613 2057 12 mother mother NN 19613 2057 13 . . . 19613 2057 14 " " '' 19613 2057 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2058 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2058 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2058 3 149 149 CD 19613 2058 4 : : : 19613 2058 5 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 2058 6 . . . 19613 2059 1 Philos Philos NNP 19613 2059 2 . . . 19613 2060 1 IX ix NN 19613 2060 2 . . . 19613 2061 1 12 12 CD 19613 2061 2 p. p. NN 19613 2062 1 460 460 CD 19613 2062 2 . . . 19613 2062 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2063 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2063 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2063 3 150 150 CD 19613 2063 4 : : : 19613 2063 5 The the DT 19613 2063 6 phraseology phraseology NN 19613 2063 7 of of IN 19613 2063 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2063 9 is be VBZ 19613 2063 10 very very RB 19613 2063 11 instructive instructive JJ 19613 2063 12 here here RB 19613 2063 13 . . . 19613 2064 1 As as IN 19613 2064 2 a a DT 19613 2064 3 rule rule NN 19613 2064 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2064 5 still still RB 19613 2064 6 speaks speak VBZ 19613 2064 7 of of IN 19613 2064 8 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2064 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2064 10 in in IN 19613 2064 11 the the DT 19613 2064 12 plural plural NN 19613 2064 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2064 14 when when WRB 19613 2064 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2064 16 means mean VBZ 19613 2064 17 the the DT 19613 2064 18 empirical empirical JJ 19613 2064 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2064 20 . . . 19613 2065 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2065 2 is be VBZ 19613 2065 3 already already RB 19613 2065 4 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 2065 5 with with IN 19613 2065 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2065 7 , , , 19613 2065 8 though though IN 19613 2065 9 even even RB 19613 2065 10 with with IN 19613 2065 11 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2065 12 the the DT 19613 2065 13 old old JJ 19613 2065 14 custom custom NN 19613 2065 15 still still RB 19613 2065 16 lingers linger VBZ 19613 2065 17 . . . 19613 2065 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2066 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2066 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2066 3 151 151 CD 19613 2066 4 : : : 19613 2066 5 The the DT 19613 2066 6 most most RBS 19613 2066 7 important important JJ 19613 2066 8 passages passage NNS 19613 2066 9 bearing bear VBG 19613 2066 10 on on IN 19613 2066 11 this this DT 19613 2066 12 are be VBP 19613 2066 13 II ii CD 19613 2066 14 . . . 19613 2067 1 31 31 CD 19613 2067 2 . . . 19613 2068 1 3 3 LS 19613 2068 2 : : : 19613 2068 3 III iii CD 19613 2068 4 . . . 19613 2069 1 24 24 CD 19613 2069 2 . . . 19613 2070 1 1 1 LS 19613 2070 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2070 3 see see VB 19613 2070 4 the the DT 19613 2070 5 whole whole JJ 19613 2070 6 section section NN 19613 2070 7 , , , 19613 2070 8 but but CC 19613 2070 9 especially especially RB 19613 2070 10 : : : 19613 2070 11 " " `` 19613 2070 12 in in IN 19613 2070 13 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2070 14 posuit posuit NNP 19613 2070 15 deus deus NNP 19613 2070 16 universam universam NNP 19613 2070 17 operationem operationem NNP 19613 2070 18 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2070 19 ; ; : 19613 2070 20 cuius cuius NN 19613 2070 21 non non AFX 19613 2070 22 sunt sunt NN 19613 2070 23 participes participe NNS 19613 2070 24 omnes omne NNS 19613 2070 25 qui qui VBP 19613 2070 26 non non AFX 19613 2070 27 concurrunt concurrunt NN 19613 2070 28 ad ad NN 19613 2070 29 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 2070 30 ... ... NFP 19613 2070 31 ubi ubi VB 19613 2070 32 enim enim NNP 19613 2070 33 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2070 34 , , , 19613 2070 35 ibi ibi NNP 19613 2070 36 et et NNP 19613 2070 37 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2070 38 dei dei NNP 19613 2070 39 , , , 19613 2070 40 et et NNP 19613 2070 41 ubi ubi NNP 19613 2070 42 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2070 43 dei dei NNP 19613 2070 44 , , , 19613 2070 45 illic illic NNP 19613 2070 46 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2070 47 et et NNP 19613 2070 48 omnis omnis NNP 19613 2070 49 gratia gratia NNP 19613 2070 50 " " '' 19613 2070 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2070 52 ; ; : 19613 2070 53 III.11 III.11 NNP 19613 2070 54 . . . 19613 2071 1 8 8 CD 19613 2071 2 : : : 19613 2071 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2071 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2071 5 : : : 19613 2071 6 stulos stulos NNP 19613 2071 7 kai kai NNP 19613 2071 8 stêrigma stêrigma NNP 19613 2071 9 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 2071 10 to to IN 19613 2071 11 euangelion euangelion NNP 19613 2071 12 kai kai NNP 19613 2071 13 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 2071 14 zôês zôês NNP 19613 2071 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2071 16 : : : 19613 2071 17 IV IV NNP 19613 2071 18 . . . 19613 2072 1 8 8 LS 19613 2072 2 . . . 19613 2073 1 1 1 LS 19613 2073 2 : : : 19613 2073 3 " " `` 19613 2073 4 semen semen NNP 19613 2073 5 Abrahæ Abrahæ NNP 19613 2073 6 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2073 7 " " '' 19613 2073 8 , , , 19613 2073 9 IV IV NNP 19613 2073 10 . . . 19613 2074 1 8 8 LS 19613 2074 2 . . . 19613 2075 1 3 3 LS 19613 2075 2 : : : 19613 2075 3 " " `` 19613 2075 4 omnes omne NNS 19613 2075 5 iusti iusti VBP 19613 2075 6 sacerdotalem sacerdotalem NNP 19613 2075 7 habent habent NNP 19613 2075 8 ordinem ordinem NNP 19613 2075 9 ; ; : 19613 2075 10 " " `` 19613 2075 11 IV IV NNP 19613 2075 12 . . . 19613 2076 1 36 36 CD 19613 2076 2 . . . 19613 2077 1 2 2 LS 19613 2077 2 : : : 19613 2077 3 " " `` 19613 2077 4 ubique ubique NNP 19613 2077 5 præclara præclara NNP 19613 2077 6 est est NNP 19613 2077 7 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2077 8 ; ; : 19613 2077 9 ubique ubique NNP 19613 2077 10 enim enim NNP 19613 2077 11 sunt sunt NNP 19613 2077 12 qui qui NNP 19613 2077 13 suscipiunt suscipiunt NNP 19613 2077 14 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 2077 15 ; ; : 19613 2077 16 " " `` 19613 2077 17 IV IV NNP 19613 2077 18 . . . 19613 2078 1 33 33 CD 19613 2078 2 . . . 19613 2079 1 7 7 LS 19613 2079 2 : : : 19613 2079 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2079 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2079 5 : : : 19613 2079 6 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2079 7 mega mega NNP 19613 2079 8 kai kai NNP 19613 2079 9 endoxon endoxon NNP 19613 2079 10 sôma sôma NN 19613 2079 11 tou tou NNP 19613 2079 12 Christou Christou NNP 19613 2079 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2079 14 ; ; : 19613 2079 15 IV IV NNP 19613 2079 16 . . . 19613 2080 1 26 26 CD 19613 2080 2 . . . 19613 2081 1 1 1 CD 19613 2081 2 sq sq NNP 19613 2081 3 . . . 19613 2082 1 : : : 19613 2082 2 V. V. NNP 19613 2082 3 20 20 CD 19613 2082 4 . . . 19613 2083 1 1 1 LS 19613 2083 2 . . . 19613 2083 3 : : : 19613 2083 4 V. V. NNP 19613 2083 5 32 32 CD 19613 2083 6 . . . 19613 2083 7 : : : 19613 2083 8 V. V. NNP 19613 2083 9 34 34 CD 19613 2083 10 . . . 19613 2084 1 3 3 LS 19613 2084 2 . . . 19613 2084 3 , , , 19613 2084 4 " " `` 19613 2084 5 Levitae Levitae NNP 19613 2084 6 et et NNP 19613 2084 7 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 2084 8 sunt sunt NN 19613 2084 9 discipuli discipuli NNP 19613 2084 10 omnes omnes NNP 19613 2084 11 domini domini NNP 19613 2084 12 . . . 19613 2084 13 " " '' 19613 2084 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2085 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2085 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2085 3 152 152 CD 19613 2085 4 : : : 19613 2085 5 Hence hence RB 19613 2085 6 the the DT 19613 2085 7 repudiation repudiation NN 19613 2085 8 of of IN 19613 2085 9 all all PDT 19613 2085 10 those those DT 19613 2085 11 who who WP 19613 2085 12 separate separate VBP 19613 2085 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2085 14 from from IN 19613 2085 15 the the DT 19613 2085 16 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2085 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2085 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2085 19 III III NNP 19613 2085 20 . . . 19613 2086 1 11 11 CD 19613 2086 2 . . . 19613 2087 1 9 9 CD 19613 2087 2 ; ; : 19613 2087 3 24 24 CD 19613 2087 4 . . . 19613 2088 1 1 1 LS 19613 2088 2 : : : 19613 2088 3 IV IV NNP 19613 2088 4 . . . 19613 2089 1 26 26 CD 19613 2089 2 . . . 19613 2090 1 2 2 CD 19613 2090 2 ; ; : 19613 2090 3 33 33 CD 19613 2090 4 . . . 19613 2091 1 7 7 LS 19613 2091 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2091 3 . . . 19613 2091 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2092 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2092 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2092 3 153 153 CD 19613 2092 4 : : : 19613 2092 5 On on IN 19613 2092 6 IV IV NNP 19613 2092 7 . . . 19613 2093 1 33 33 CD 19613 2093 2 . . . 19613 2094 1 7 7 CD 19613 2094 2 see see VB 19613 2094 3 Seeberg Seeberg NNP 19613 2094 4 , , , 19613 2094 5 l.c l.c NNP 19613 2094 6 . . NNP 19613 2094 7 , , , 19613 2094 8 p. p. NN 19613 2094 9 20 20 CD 19613 2094 10 , , , 19613 2094 11 who who WP 19613 2094 12 has have VBZ 19613 2094 13 correctly correctly RB 19613 2094 14 punctuated punctuate VBN 19613 2094 15 the the DT 19613 2094 16 passage passage NN 19613 2094 17 , , , 19613 2094 18 but but CC 19613 2094 19 has have VBZ 19613 2094 20 weakened weaken VBN 19613 2094 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2094 22 force force NN 19613 2094 23 . . . 19613 2095 1 The the DT 19613 2095 2 fact fact NN 19613 2095 3 that that IN 19613 2095 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2095 5 was be VBD 19613 2095 6 here here RB 19613 2095 7 able able JJ 19613 2095 8 to to TO 19613 2095 9 cite cite VB 19613 2095 10 the the DT 19613 2095 11 " " `` 19613 2095 12 antiquus antiquus IN 19613 2095 13 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ JJ 19613 2095 14 status status NN 19613 2095 15 in in IN 19613 2095 16 universo universo NNP 19613 2095 17 mundo mundo NNP 19613 2095 18 et et FW 19613 2095 19 character character NN 19613 2095 20 corporis corporis NNP 19613 2095 21 Christi Christi NNP 19613 2095 22 secundum secundum NN 19613 2095 23 successiones successione VBZ 19613 2095 24 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 2095 25 , , , 19613 2095 26 " " '' 19613 2095 27 etc etc FW 19613 2095 28 . . . 19613 2095 29 , , , 19613 2095 30 as as IN 19613 2095 31 a a DT 19613 2095 32 second second JJ 19613 2095 33 and and CC 19613 2095 34 independent independent JJ 19613 2095 35 item item NN 19613 2095 36 alongside alongside RB 19613 2095 37 of of IN 19613 2095 38 the the DT 19613 2095 39 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2095 40 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2095 41 is be VBZ 19613 2095 42 , , , 19613 2095 43 however however RB 19613 2095 44 , , , 19613 2095 45 a a DT 19613 2095 46 proof proof NN 19613 2095 47 that that IN 19613 2095 48 the the DT 19613 2095 49 transition transition NN 19613 2095 50 from from IN 19613 2095 51 the the DT 19613 2095 52 idea idea NN 19613 2095 53 of of IN 19613 2095 54 the the DT 19613 2095 55 Church Church NNP 19613 2095 56 , , , 19613 2095 57 as as IN 19613 2095 58 a a DT 19613 2095 59 community community NN 19613 2095 60 united unite VBN 19613 2095 61 by by IN 19613 2095 62 a a DT 19613 2095 63 common common JJ 19613 2095 64 faith faith NN 19613 2095 65 , , , 19613 2095 66 to to IN 19613 2095 67 that that DT 19613 2095 68 of of IN 19613 2095 69 a a DT 19613 2095 70 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 2095 71 institution institution NN 19613 2095 72 was be VBD 19613 2095 73 already already RB 19613 2095 74 revealing reveal VBG 19613 2095 75 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2095 76 in in IN 19613 2095 77 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2095 78 writings writing NNS 19613 2095 79 . . . 19613 2095 80 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2096 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2096 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2096 3 154 154 CD 19613 2096 4 : : : 19613 2096 5 The the DT 19613 2096 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2096 7 as as IN 19613 2096 8 a a DT 19613 2096 9 communion communion NN 19613 2096 10 of of IN 19613 2096 11 the the DT 19613 2096 12 same same JJ 19613 2096 13 faith faith NN 19613 2096 14 , , , 19613 2096 15 that that WDT 19613 2096 16 is be VBZ 19613 2096 17 of of IN 19613 2096 18 the the DT 19613 2096 19 same same JJ 19613 2096 20 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2096 21 , , , 19613 2096 22 is be VBZ 19613 2096 23 spoken speak VBN 19613 2096 24 of of IN 19613 2096 25 in in IN 19613 2096 26 de de NNP 19613 2096 27 præscr præscr NNS 19613 2096 28 . . . 19613 2097 1 20 20 CD 19613 2097 2 ; ; : 19613 2097 3 de de NNP 19613 2097 4 virg virg NNS 19613 2097 5 . . . 19613 2098 1 vol vol NNP 19613 2098 2 . . . 19613 2099 1 2 2 LS 19613 2099 2 . . . 19613 2100 1 On on IN 19613 2100 2 the the DT 19613 2100 3 other other JJ 19613 2100 4 hand hand NN 19613 2100 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2100 6 find find VBP 19613 2100 7 the the DT 19613 2100 8 ideal ideal JJ 19613 2100 9 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2100 10 conception conception NN 19613 2100 11 in in IN 19613 2100 12 de de NNP 19613 2100 13 bapt bapt NNP 19613 2100 14 . . . 19613 2101 1 6 6 CD 19613 2101 2 : : : 19613 2101 3 " " `` 19613 2101 4 ubi ubi NN 19613 2101 5 tres tre NNS 19613 2101 6 , , , 19613 2101 7 i -PRON- PRP 19613 2101 8 d d VBD 19613 2101 9 est est NNP 19613 2101 10 pater pater NNP 19613 2101 11 et et NNP 19613 2101 12 filius filius NNP 19613 2101 13 et et NNP 19613 2101 14 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2101 15 sanctus sanctus NN 19613 2101 16 , , , 19613 2101 17 ibi ibi NNP 19613 2101 18 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2101 19 , , , 19613 2101 20 quæ quæ NNP 19613 2101 21 trium trium NNP 19613 2101 22 corpus corpus NNP 19613 2101 23 est est NNP 19613 2101 24 ; ; : 19613 2101 25 " " `` 19613 2101 26 8 8 CD 19613 2101 27 : : : 19613 2101 28 " " '' 19613 2101 29 columba columba NNP 19613 2101 30 s. s. NNP 19613 2101 31 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2101 32 advolat advolat NNP 19613 2101 33 , , , 19613 2101 34 pacem pacem NNP 19613 2101 35 dei dei NNP 19613 2101 36 adferens adferen VBZ 19613 2101 37 , , , 19613 2101 38 emissa emissa NNP 19613 2101 39 de de NNP 19613 2101 40 coelis coelis NNP 19613 2101 41 , , , 19613 2101 42 ubi ubi NNP 19613 2101 43 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2101 44 est est NNP 19613 2101 45 arca arca NNP 19613 2101 46 figurata figurata NNP 19613 2101 47 ; ; : 19613 2101 48 " " `` 19613 2101 49 15 15 CD 19613 2101 50 : : : 19613 2101 51 " " `` 19613 2101 52 unus unus NNP 19613 2101 53 deus deus NNP 19613 2101 54 et et NNP 19613 2101 55 unum unum NNP 19613 2101 56 baptismum baptismum NNP 19613 2101 57 et et NNP 19613 2101 58 una una NNP 19613 2101 59 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2101 60 in in IN 19613 2101 61 coelis coelis NNP 19613 2101 62 ; ; : 19613 2101 63 " " `` 19613 2101 64 de de IN 19613 2101 65 pænit pænit NNP 19613 2101 66 . . . 19613 2102 1 10 10 CD 19613 2102 2 : : : 19613 2102 3 " " `` 19613 2102 4 in in IN 19613 2102 5 uno uno NNP 19613 2102 6 et et NNP 19613 2102 7 altero altero NNP 19613 2102 8 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2102 9 est est NNP 19613 2102 10 , , , 19613 2102 11 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2102 12 vero vero NNP 19613 2102 13 Christus Christus NNP 19613 2102 14 ; ; : 19613 2102 15 " " `` 19613 2102 16 de de FW 19613 2102 17 orat orat NNP 19613 2102 18 . . . 19613 2103 1 28 28 CD 19613 2103 2 : : : 19613 2103 3 " " `` 19613 2103 4 nos nos NNP 19613 2103 5 sumus sumus NNP 19613 2103 6 veri veri NNP 19613 2103 7 adoratores adoratore VBZ 19613 2103 8 et et NNP 19613 2103 9 veri veri NN 19613 2103 10 sacerdotes sacerdote NNS 19613 2103 11 , , , 19613 2103 12 qui qui NNP 19613 2103 13 spiritu spiritu NN 19613 2103 14 orantes orantes CD 19613 2103 15 spiritu spiritu JJ 19613 2103 16 sacrificamus sacrificamus NN 19613 2103 17 ; ; : 19613 2103 18 " " `` 19613 2103 19 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 2103 20 . . . 19613 2104 1 39 39 CD 19613 2104 2 ; ; : 19613 2104 3 de de NNP 19613 2104 4 exhort exhort NN 19613 2104 5 . . . 19613 2105 1 7 7 LS 19613 2105 2 : : : 19613 2105 3 " " `` 19613 2105 4 differentiam differentiam NNP 19613 2105 5 inter inter NNP 19613 2105 6 ordinem ordinem NNP 19613 2105 7 et et NNP 19613 2105 8 plebem plebem NNP 19613 2105 9 constituit constituit NNP 19613 2105 10 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2105 11 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 19613 2105 12 et et NN 19613 2105 13 honor honor NN 19613 2105 14 per per IN 19613 2105 15 ordinis ordinis FW 19613 2105 16 consessum consessum NN 19613 2105 17 sanctificatus sanctificatus NNP 19613 2105 18 . . . 19613 2106 1 Adeo Adeo NNP 19613 2106 2 ubi ubi NN 19613 2106 3 ecclesiastici ecclesiastici NNP 19613 2106 4 ordinis ordinis NNP 19613 2106 5 non non NNP 19613 2106 6 est est NNP 19613 2106 7 consessus consessus NNP 19613 2106 8 , , , 19613 2106 9 et et NNP 19613 2106 10 offers offer VBZ 19613 2106 11 et et NNP 19613 2106 12 tinguis tinguis NNP 19613 2106 13 et et NNP 19613 2106 14 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 2106 15 es es NNP 19613 2106 16 tibi tibi NNP 19613 2106 17 solus solus NNP 19613 2106 18 . . . 19613 2107 1 Sed Sed NNP 19613 2107 2 ubi ubi NNP 19613 2107 3 tres tre NNS 19613 2107 4 , , , 19613 2107 5 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2107 6 est est NNP 19613 2107 7 , , , 19613 2107 8 licet licet NN 19613 2107 9 laici laici NNS 19613 2107 10 " " '' 19613 2107 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2107 12 the the DT 19613 2107 13 same same JJ 19613 2107 14 idea idea NN 19613 2107 15 , , , 19613 2107 16 only only RB 19613 2107 17 not not RB 19613 2107 18 so so RB 19613 2107 19 definitely definitely RB 19613 2107 20 expressed express VBN 19613 2107 21 , , , 19613 2107 22 is be VBZ 19613 2107 23 already already RB 19613 2107 24 found find VBN 19613 2107 25 in in IN 19613 2107 26 de de NNP 19613 2107 27 bapt bapt NNP 19613 2107 28 . . . 19613 2108 1 17 17 CD 19613 2108 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2108 3 ; ; : 19613 2108 4 de de NNP 19613 2108 5 monog monog NNP 19613 2108 6 . . . 19613 2109 1 7 7 LS 19613 2109 2 : : : 19613 2109 3 " " `` 19613 2109 4 nos nos NNP 19613 2109 5 autem autem NNP 19613 2109 6 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 2109 7 summus summus NNP 19613 2109 8 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 2109 9 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 2109 10 deo deo NNP 19613 2109 11 patri patri NNP 19613 2109 12 suo suo NNP 19613 2109 13 fecit fecit NNP 19613 2109 14 ... ... : 19613 2109 15 vivit vivit NNP 19613 2109 16 unicus unicus NNP 19613 2109 17 pater pater NNP 19613 2109 18 noster noster NNP 19613 2109 19 deus deus NNP 19613 2109 20 et et NNP 19613 2109 21 mater mater NNP 19613 2109 22 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2109 23 , , , 19613 2109 24 ... ... : 19613 2109 25 certe certe NNP 19613 2109 26 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 2109 27 sumus sumus NNP 19613 2109 28 a a DT 19613 2109 29 Christo Christo NNP 19613 2109 30 vocati vocati VBZ 19613 2109 31 ; ; : 19613 2109 32 " " `` 19613 2109 33 12 12 CD 19613 2109 34 ; ; : 19613 2109 35 de de NNP 19613 2109 36 pudic pudic JJ 19613 2109 37 . . . 19613 2110 1 21 21 CD 19613 2110 2 : : : 19613 2110 3 " " `` 19613 2110 4 nam nam NNP 19613 2110 5 et et NNP 19613 2110 6 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 2110 7 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2110 8 proprie proprie NNP 19613 2110 9 et et NNP 19613 2110 10 principaliter principaliter NN 19613 2110 11 ipse ipse NNP 19613 2110 12 est est NNP 19613 2110 13 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2110 14 , , , 19613 2110 15 in in IN 19613 2110 16 quo quo NNP 19613 2110 17 est est NNP 19613 2110 18 trinitas trinitas NNP 19613 2110 19 unius unius NNP 19613 2110 20 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 2110 21 , , , 19613 2110 22 pater pater NNP 19613 2110 23 et et NNP 19613 2110 24 filius filius NNP 19613 2110 25 et et NNP 19613 2110 26 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 2110 27 sanctus sanctus NN 19613 2110 28 . . . 19613 2111 1 Illam illam JJ 19613 2111 2 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 2111 3 congregat congregat VBZ 19613 2111 4 quam quam NNP 19613 2111 5 dominus dominus NNP 19613 2111 6 in in IN 19613 2111 7 tribus tribus NNP 19613 2111 8 posuit posuit NNP 19613 2111 9 . . . 19613 2112 1 Atque Atque NNP 19613 2112 2 ita ita NNP 19613 2112 3 exinde exinde NNP 19613 2112 4 etiam etiam NNP 19613 2112 5 numerus numerus NNP 19613 2112 6 omnis omnis NNP 19613 2112 7 qui qui NNP 19613 2112 8 in in IN 19613 2112 9 hanc hanc NNP 19613 2112 10 fidem fidem NNP 19613 2112 11 conspiraverint conspiraverint NNP 19613 2112 12 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2112 13 ab ab NNP 19613 2112 14 auctore auctore NNP 19613 2112 15 et et NNP 19613 2112 16 consecratore consecratore NNP 19613 2112 17 censetur censetur NNP 19613 2112 18 . . . 19613 2113 1 Et et NN 19613 2113 2 ideo ideo NN 19613 2113 3 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2113 4 quidem quidem NNP 19613 2113 5 delicta delicta NNP 19613 2113 6 donabit donabit NNP 19613 2113 7 , , , 19613 2113 8 sed sed NNP 19613 2113 9 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2113 10 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 2113 11 per per IN 19613 2113 12 spiritalem spiritalem NNP 19613 2113 13 hominem hominem NNP 19613 2113 14 , , , 19613 2113 15 non non NNP 19613 2113 16 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2113 17 numerus numerus NNP 19613 2113 18 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 2113 19 ; ; : 19613 2113 20 " " `` 19613 2113 21 de de FW 19613 2113 22 anima anima NNP 19613 2113 23 11 11 CD 19613 2113 24 , , , 19613 2113 25 21 21 CD 19613 2113 26 . . . 19613 2114 1 Contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 2114 2 in in IN 19613 2114 3 detail detail NN 19613 2114 4 need nee MD 19613 2114 5 not not RB 19613 2114 6 surprise surprise VB 19613 2114 7 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2114 8 in in IN 19613 2114 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2114 10 , , , 19613 2114 11 since since IN 19613 2114 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2114 13 whole whole JJ 19613 2114 14 position position NN 19613 2114 15 as as IN 19613 2114 16 a a DT 19613 2114 17 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2114 18 and and CC 19613 2114 19 as as IN 19613 2114 20 a a DT 19613 2114 21 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2114 22 is be VBZ 19613 2114 23 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 2114 24 . . . 19613 2114 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2115 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2115 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2115 3 155 155 CD 19613 2115 4 : : : 19613 2115 5 The the DT 19613 2115 6 notion notion NN 19613 2115 7 that that IN 19613 2115 8 the the DT 19613 2115 9 true true JJ 19613 2115 10 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 2115 11 can can MD 19613 2115 12 attain attain VB 19613 2115 13 the the DT 19613 2115 14 same same JJ 19613 2115 15 position position NN 19613 2115 16 as as IN 19613 2115 17 the the DT 19613 2115 18 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2115 19 also also RB 19613 2115 20 preserved preserve VBD 19613 2115 21 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2115 22 from from IN 19613 2115 23 thrusting thrust VBG 19613 2115 24 the the DT 19613 2115 25 ideal ideal JJ 19613 2115 26 conception conception NN 19613 2115 27 of of IN 19613 2115 28 the the DT 19613 2115 29 Church Church NNP 19613 2115 30 into into IN 19613 2115 31 the the DT 19613 2115 32 background background NN 19613 2115 33 . . . 19613 2115 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2116 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2116 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2116 3 156 156 CD 19613 2116 4 : : : 19613 2116 5 Some some DT 19613 2116 6 very very RB 19613 2116 7 significant significant JJ 19613 2116 8 remarks remark NNS 19613 2116 9 are be VBP 19613 2116 10 found find VBN 19613 2116 11 in in IN 19613 2116 12 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2116 13 about about IN 19613 2116 14 the the DT 19613 2116 15 Church church NN 19613 2116 16 which which WDT 19613 2116 17 is be VBZ 19613 2116 18 the the DT 19613 2116 19 object object NN 19613 2116 20 of of IN 19613 2116 21 faith faith NN 19613 2116 22 . . . 19613 2117 1 See see VB 19613 2117 2 Pæd Pæd NNP 19613 2117 3 . . . 19613 2118 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2119 1 5 5 CD 19613 2119 2 . . . 19613 2120 1 18 18 CD 19613 2120 2 , , , 19613 2120 3 21 21 CD 19613 2120 4 ; ; SYM 19613 2120 5 6 6 CD 19613 2120 6 . . . 19613 2121 1 27 27 CD 19613 2121 2 : : : 19613 2121 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2121 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2121 5 : : : 19613 2121 6 hôs hôs NNP 19613 2121 7 gar gar NNP 19613 2121 8 thelêma thelêma NNP 19613 2121 9 tou tou NNP 19613 2121 10 Theou Theou NNP 19613 2121 11 ergon ergon NNP 19613 2121 12 esti esti NNP 19613 2121 13 kai kai NNP 19613 2121 14 touto touto NNP 19613 2121 15 kosmos kosmos NNP 19613 2121 16 onomazetai onomazetai NNP 19613 2121 17 , , , 19613 2121 18 houtô houtô NNP 19613 2121 19 kai kai NNP 19613 2121 20 to to IN 19613 2121 21 boulêma boulêma NNP 19613 2121 22 autou autou NNP 19613 2121 23 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 2121 24 esti esti NNP 19613 2121 25 sôtêria sôtêria NNP 19613 2121 26 , , , 19613 2121 27 kai kai NNP 19613 2121 28 touto touto NNP 19613 2121 29 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2121 30 keklêtai]--here keklêtai]--here NNP 19613 2121 31 an an DT 19613 2121 32 idea idea NN 19613 2121 33 which which WDT 19613 2121 34 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 2121 35 had have VBD 19613 2121 36 in in IN 19613 2121 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2121 38 mind mind NN 19613 2121 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2121 40 see see VB 19613 2121 41 Vol Vol NNP 19613 2121 42 . . . 19613 2122 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2122 2 , , , 19613 2122 3 p. p. NN 19613 2122 4 180 180 CD 19613 2122 5 . . . 19613 2122 6 note note VB 19613 2122 7 4 4 CD 19613 2122 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2122 9 is be VBZ 19613 2122 10 pregnantly pregnantly RB 19613 2122 11 and and CC 19613 2122 12 excellently excellently RB 19613 2122 13 expressed express VBN 19613 2122 14 . . . 19613 2123 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 2123 2 . . . 19613 2124 1 II ii CD 19613 2124 2 . . . 19613 2125 1 12 12 CD 19613 2125 2 . . . 19613 2126 1 55 55 CD 19613 2126 2 ; ; : 19613 2126 3 IV IV NNP 19613 2126 4 . . . 19613 2127 1 8 8 LS 19613 2127 2 . . . 19613 2128 1 66 66 CD 19613 2128 2 : : : 19613 2128 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2128 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2128 5 : : : 19613 2128 6 eikôn eikôn NNP 19613 2128 7 tês tês NNP 19613 2128 8 ouraniou ouraniou JJ 19613 2128 9 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 2128 10 hê hê NNP 19613 2128 11 epigeios epigeio NNS 19613 2128 12 , , , 19613 2128 13 dioper dioper RB 19613 2128 14 euchometha euchometha NNP 19613 2128 15 kai kai NNP 19613 2128 16 epi epi NNP 19613 2128 17 gês gês NNP 19613 2128 18 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 2128 19 to to TO 19613 2128 20 thelêma thelêma VB 19613 2128 21 tou tou NNP 19613 2128 22 Theou Theou NNP 19613 2128 23 hôs hôs NNP 19613 2128 24 en en IN 19613 2128 25 ouranô ouranô NN 19613 2128 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2128 27 ; ; : 19613 2128 28 IV IV NNP 19613 2128 29 . . . 19613 2129 1 26 26 CD 19613 2129 2 . . . 19613 2130 1 172 172 CD 19613 2130 2 : : : 19613 2130 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2130 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2130 5 : : : 19613 2130 6 hê hê NNP 19613 2130 7 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2130 8 hupo hupo NNP 19613 2130 9 logou logou NNP 19613 2130 10 apoliorkêtos apoliorkêtos NNP 19613 2130 11 aturannêtos aturannêtos NNP 19613 2130 12 polis polis NNP 19613 2130 13 epi epi NNP 19613 2130 14 gês gês NNP 19613 2130 15 , , , 19613 2130 16 thelêma thelêma NNP 19613 2130 17 theion theion NN 19613 2130 18 epi epi NNP 19613 2130 19 gês gês NNP 19613 2130 20 , , , 19613 2130 21 hôs hôs NNP 19613 2130 22 en en NNP 19613 2130 23 ouranô ouranô NNP 19613 2130 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2130 25 ; ; : 19613 2130 26 VI VI NNP 19613 2130 27 . . . 19613 2131 1 13 13 CD 19613 2131 2 . . . 19613 2132 1 106 106 CD 19613 2132 2 , , , 19613 2132 3 107 107 CD 19613 2132 4 ; ; : 19613 2132 5 VI VI NNP 19613 2132 6 . . . 19613 2133 1 14 14 CD 19613 2133 2 . . . 19613 2134 1 108 108 CD 19613 2134 2 : : : 19613 2134 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2134 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2134 5 : : : 19613 2134 6 hê hê VB 19613 2134 7 anôtatô anôtatô NNP 19613 2134 8 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2134 9 , , , 19613 2134 10 kath kath NNP 19613 2134 11 ' ' '' 19613 2134 12 hên hên NNP 19613 2134 13 hoi hoi NNP 19613 2134 14 philosophoi philosophoi JJ 19613 2134 15 sunagontai sunagontai NN 19613 2134 16 tou tou NNP 19613 2134 17 Theou Theou NNP 19613 2134 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2134 19 ; ; : 19613 2134 20 VII VII NNP 19613 2134 21 . . . 19613 2135 1 5 5 CD 19613 2135 2 . . . 19613 2136 1 29 29 CD 19613 2136 2 : : : 19613 2136 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2136 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2136 5 : : : 19613 2136 6 pôs pôs NNP 19613 2136 7 ou ou NNP 19613 2136 8 kurios kurios NNP 19613 2136 9 tên tên NNP 19613 2136 10 eis eis NNP 19613 2136 11 timên timên NNP 19613 2136 12 tou tou NNP 19613 2136 13 Theou Theou NNP 19613 2136 14 kat kat NNP 19613 2136 15 ' ' POS 19613 2136 16 epignôsin epignôsin NNP 19613 2136 17 hagian hagian NNP 19613 2136 18 genomenên genomenên NNP 19613 2136 19 ekklêsian ekklêsian NNP 19613 2136 20 hieron hieron VBD 19613 2136 21 an an DT 19613 2136 22 eipoimen eipoimen NN 19613 2136 23 Theou Theou NNP 19613 2136 24 to to TO 19613 2136 25 pollou pollou VB 19613 2136 26 axion axion NN 19613 2136 27 ... ... : 19613 2136 28 ou ou NNP 19613 2136 29 gar gar NNP 19613 2136 30 nun nun NNP 19613 2136 31 ton ton NNP 19613 2136 32 topon topon RB 19613 2136 33 , , , 19613 2136 34 alla alla NN 19613 2136 35 to to IN 19613 2136 36 athroisma athroisma NNP 19613 2136 37 tôn tôn NNP 19613 2136 38 eklektôn eklektôn NNP 19613 2136 39 ekklêsian ekklêsian NNP 19613 2136 40 kalô kalô NNP 19613 2136 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2136 42 ; ; : 19613 2136 43 VII VII NNP 19613 2136 44 . . . 19613 2137 1 6 6 CD 19613 2137 2 . . . 19613 2138 1 32 32 CD 19613 2138 2 ; ; : 19613 2138 3 VII VII NNP 19613 2138 4 . . . 19613 2139 1 11 11 CD 19613 2139 2 . . . 19613 2140 1 68 68 CD 19613 2140 2 : : : 19613 2140 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2140 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2140 5 : : : 19613 2140 6 hê hê NNP 19613 2140 7 pneumatikê pneumatikê NNP 19613 2140 8 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2140 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2140 10 . . . 19613 2141 1 The the DT 19613 2141 2 empirical empirical JJ 19613 2141 3 conception conception NN 19613 2141 4 of of IN 19613 2141 5 the the DT 19613 2141 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2141 7 is be VBZ 19613 2141 8 most most RBS 19613 2141 9 clearly clearly RB 19613 2141 10 formulated formulate VBN 19613 2141 11 in in IN 19613 2141 12 VII VII NNP 19613 2141 13 . . . 19613 2142 1 17 17 CD 19613 2142 2 . . . 19613 2143 1 107 107 LS 19613 2143 2 ; ; : 19613 2143 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2143 4 may may MD 19613 2143 5 draw draw VB 19613 2143 6 special special JJ 19613 2143 7 attention attention NN 19613 2143 8 to to IN 19613 2143 9 the the DT 19613 2143 10 following following JJ 19613 2143 11 sentences sentence NNS 19613 2143 12 : : : 19613 2143 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2143 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2143 15 : : : 19613 2143 16 phaneron phaneron NNP 19613 2143 17 oimai oimai NNP 19613 2143 18 gegenêsthai gegenêsthai NNP 19613 2143 19 mian mian NNP 19613 2143 20 einai einai NNP 19613 2143 21 tên tên NNP 19613 2143 22 alêthê alêthê NNP 19613 2143 23 ekklêsian ekklêsian NNP 19613 2143 24 tên tên NNP 19613 2143 25 tôi tôi NNP 19613 2143 26 onti onti NNP 19613 2143 27 archaian archaian NNP 19613 2143 28 , , , 19613 2143 29 eis eis NNP 19613 2143 30 hên hên NNP 19613 2143 31 hoi hoi NNP 19613 2143 32 kata kata NNP 19613 2143 33 prothesin prothesin NNP 19613 2143 34 dikaioi dikaioi NNP 19613 2143 35 egkatalegontai egkatalegontai NNP 19613 2143 36 , , , 19613 2143 37 henos henos NNP 19613 2143 38 gar gar NNP 19613 2143 39 ontos ontos NNP 19613 2143 40 tou tou NNP 19613 2143 41 Theou Theou NNP 19613 2143 42 kai kai NNP 19613 2143 43 henos henos NNP 19613 2143 44 tou tou NNP 19613 2143 45 kuriou kuriou NNP 19613 2143 46 ... ... : 19613 2143 47 tê tê NNP 19613 2143 48 goun goun NNP 19613 2143 49 tou tou NNP 19613 2143 50 henos henos NNP 19613 2143 51 phusei phusei NNP 19613 2143 52 sunklêrountai sunklêrountai NNP 19613 2143 53 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2143 54 hê hê NNP 19613 2143 55 mia mia NNP 19613 2143 56 , , , 19613 2143 57 hên hên NNP 19613 2143 58 eis eis NNP 19613 2143 59 pollas pollas NNP 19613 2143 60 katatemnein katatemnein NNP 19613 2143 61 biazontai biazontai NNP 19613 2143 62 haireseis haireseis NNP 19613 2143 63 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2143 64 . . . 19613 2143 65 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2144 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2144 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2144 3 157 157 CD 19613 2144 4 : : : 19613 2144 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2144 6 may may MD 19613 2144 7 , , , 19613 2144 8 however however RB 19613 2144 9 , , , 19613 2144 10 be be VB 19613 2144 11 noted note VBN 19613 2144 12 that that IN 19613 2144 13 the the DT 19613 2144 14 old old JJ 19613 2144 15 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 2144 16 aim aim NN 19613 2144 17 has have VBZ 19613 2144 18 fallen fall VBN 19613 2144 19 into into IN 19613 2144 20 the the DT 19613 2144 21 background background NN 19613 2144 22 in in IN 19613 2144 23 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2144 24 's 's POS 19613 2144 25 conception conception NN 19613 2144 26 of of IN 19613 2144 27 the the DT 19613 2144 28 Church Church NNP 19613 2144 29 . . . 19613 2144 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2145 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2145 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2145 3 158 158 CD 19613 2145 4 : : : 19613 2145 5 A a DT 19613 2145 6 significance significance NN 19613 2145 7 of of IN 19613 2145 8 this this DT 19613 2145 9 kind kind NN 19613 2145 10 is be VBZ 19613 2145 11 suggested suggest VBN 19613 2145 12 by by IN 19613 2145 13 the the DT 19613 2145 14 notion notion NN 19613 2145 15 that that IN 19613 2145 16 the the DT 19613 2145 17 orders order NNS 19613 2145 18 in in IN 19613 2145 19 the the DT 19613 2145 20 earthly earthly JJ 19613 2145 21 Church Church NNP 19613 2145 22 correspond correspond NN 19613 2145 23 to to IN 19613 2145 24 those those DT 19613 2145 25 in in IN 19613 2145 26 the the DT 19613 2145 27 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 2145 28 one one CD 19613 2145 29 ; ; : 19613 2145 30 but but CC 19613 2145 31 this this DT 19613 2145 32 idea idea NN 19613 2145 33 , , , 19613 2145 34 which which WDT 19613 2145 35 afterwards afterwards RB 19613 2145 36 became become VBD 19613 2145 37 so so RB 19613 2145 38 important important JJ 19613 2145 39 in in IN 19613 2145 40 the the DT 19613 2145 41 East East NNP 19613 2145 42 , , , 19613 2145 43 was be VBD 19613 2145 44 turned turn VBN 19613 2145 45 to to IN 19613 2145 46 no no DT 19613 2145 47 further further JJ 19613 2145 48 account account NN 19613 2145 49 by by IN 19613 2145 50 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2145 51 . . . 19613 2146 1 In in IN 19613 2146 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2146 3 view view NN 19613 2146 4 the the DT 19613 2146 5 " " `` 19613 2146 6 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 2146 7 " " '' 19613 2146 8 are be VBP 19613 2146 9 the the DT 19613 2146 10 highest high JJS 19613 2146 11 stage stage NN 19613 2146 12 in in IN 19613 2146 13 the the DT 19613 2146 14 Church Church NNP 19613 2146 15 . . . 19613 2147 1 See See NNP 19613 2147 2 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 2147 3 , , , 19613 2147 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 2147 5 . . NNP 19613 2147 6 , , , 19613 2147 7 p. p. NN 19613 2148 1 100 100 CD 19613 2148 2 . . . 19613 2148 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2149 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2149 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2149 3 159 159 CD 19613 2149 4 : : : 19613 2149 5 De De NNP 19613 2149 6 princip princip NN 19613 2149 7 . . . 19613 2150 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2150 2 . . . 19613 2151 1 2 2 CD 19613 2151 2 , , , 19613 2151 3 2 2 CD 19613 2151 4 : : : 19613 2151 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2151 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2151 7 : : : 19613 2151 8 hê hê VB 19613 2151 9 ouranios ouranios NNP 19613 2151 10 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 2151 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2151 12 ; ; : 19613 2151 13 Hom Hom NNP 19613 2151 14 . . . 19613 2152 1 IX ix NN 19613 2152 2 . . . 19613 2153 1 in in IN 19613 2153 2 Exod Exod NNP 19613 2153 3 . . . 19613 2154 1 c. c. NNP 19613 2154 2 3 3 CD 19613 2154 3 : : : 19613 2154 4 " " `` 19613 2154 5 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2154 6 credentium credentium NN 19613 2154 7 plebs plebs NN 19613 2154 8 ; ; : 19613 2154 9 " " `` 19613 2154 10 Hom hom NN 19613 2154 11 . . . 19613 2155 1 XI XI NNP 19613 2155 2 . . . 19613 2156 1 in in IN 19613 2156 2 Lev Lev NNP 19613 2156 3 . . . 19613 2157 1 c. c. NNP 19613 2157 2 5 5 CD 19613 2157 3 ; ; : 19613 2157 4 Hom Hom NNP 19613 2157 5 . . . 19613 2158 1 VI VI NNP 19613 2158 2 . . . 19613 2159 1 in in IN 19613 2159 2 Lev Lev NNP 19613 2159 3 . . . 19613 2160 1 c. c. NNP 19613 2160 2 5 5 CD 19613 2160 3 ; ; : 19613 2160 4 ibid ibid NNP 19613 2160 5 . . . 19613 2161 1 Hom hom UH 19613 2161 2 . . . 19613 2162 1 IX ix NN 19613 2162 2 . . . 19613 2163 1 : : : 19613 2163 2 " " `` 19613 2163 3 omni omni NNP 19613 2163 4 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2163 5 dei dei NNP 19613 2163 6 et et NNP 19613 2163 7 credentium credentium NN 19613 2163 8 populo populo NNP 19613 2163 9 sacerdotium sacerdotium NN 19613 2163 10 datum datum NN 19613 2163 11 . . . 19613 2164 1 " " `` 19613 2164 2 : : : 19613 2164 3 T. T. NNP 19613 2164 4 XIV XIV NNP 19613 2164 5 . . . 19613 2165 1 in in IN 19613 2165 2 Mt. Mount NNP 19613 2166 1 c. c. NNP 19613 2166 2 17 17 CD 19613 2166 3 : : : 19613 2166 4 c. c. NNP 19613 2166 5 Cels Cels NNP 19613 2166 6 . . . 19613 2167 1 VI VI NNP 19613 2167 2 . . . 19613 2168 1 48 48 CD 19613 2168 2 : : : 19613 2168 3 VI VI NNP 19613 2168 4 . . . 19613 2169 1 79 79 LS 19613 2169 2 ; ; : 19613 2169 3 Hom Hom NNP 19613 2169 4 . . . 19613 2170 1 VII VII NNP 19613 2170 2 . . . 19613 2171 1 in in IN 19613 2171 2 Lk Lk NNP 19613 2171 3 . . . 19613 2172 1 ; ; : 19613 2172 2 and and CC 19613 2172 3 de de NNP 19613 2172 4 orat orat NNP 19613 2172 5 . . . 19613 2173 1 31 31 CD 19613 2173 2 a a DT 19613 2173 3 twofold twofold JJ 19613 2173 4 Church Church NNP 19613 2173 5 is be VBZ 19613 2173 6 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 2173 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2173 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2173 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2173 10 : : : 19613 2173 11 hôste hôste VB 19613 2173 12 einai einai NNP 19613 2173 13 epi epi NNP 19613 2173 14 tôn tôn NNP 19613 2173 15 hagiôn hagiôn NNP 19613 2173 16 sunathroizomenôn sunathroizomenôn NNP 19613 2173 17 diplên diplên NNP 19613 2173 18 ekklêsian ekklêsian NNP 19613 2173 19 tên tên NNP 19613 2173 20 men man NNS 19613 2173 21 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 2173 22 , , , 19613 2173 23 tên tên NNP 19613 2173 24 de de NNP 19613 2173 25 angelôn angelôn NNP 19613 2173 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2173 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2173 28 . . . 19613 2174 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2174 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2174 3 does do VBZ 19613 2174 4 not not RB 19613 2174 5 assume assume VB 19613 2174 6 two two CD 19613 2174 7 Churches church NNS 19613 2174 8 , , , 19613 2174 9 but but CC 19613 2174 10 , , , 19613 2174 11 like like IN 19613 2174 12 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2174 13 , , , 19613 2174 14 holds hold VBZ 19613 2174 15 that that IN 19613 2174 16 there there EX 19613 2174 17 is be VBZ 19613 2174 18 only only RB 19613 2174 19 one one CD 19613 2174 20 , , , 19613 2174 21 part part NN 19613 2174 22 of of IN 19613 2174 23 which which WDT 19613 2174 24 is be VBZ 19613 2174 25 already already RB 19613 2174 26 in in IN 19613 2174 27 a a DT 19613 2174 28 state state NN 19613 2174 29 of of IN 19613 2174 30 perfection perfection NN 19613 2174 31 and and CC 19613 2174 32 part part NN 19613 2174 33 still still RB 19613 2174 34 on on IN 19613 2174 35 earth earth NN 19613 2174 36 . . . 19613 2175 1 But but CC 19613 2175 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2175 3 is be VBZ 19613 2175 4 worthy worthy JJ 19613 2175 5 of of IN 19613 2175 6 note note NN 19613 2175 7 that that IN 19613 2175 8 the the DT 19613 2175 9 ideas idea NNS 19613 2175 10 of of IN 19613 2175 11 the the DT 19613 2175 12 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 2175 13 hierarchy hierarchy NN 19613 2175 14 are be VBP 19613 2175 15 already already RB 19613 2175 16 more more RBR 19613 2175 17 developed developed JJ 19613 2175 18 in in IN 19613 2175 19 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2175 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2175 21 de de FW 19613 2175 22 princip princip NN 19613 2175 23 . . . 19613 2176 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2177 1 7 7 LS 19613 2177 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2177 3 . . . 19613 2178 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2178 2 adopted adopt VBD 19613 2178 3 the the DT 19613 2178 4 old old JJ 19613 2178 5 speculation speculation NN 19613 2178 6 about about IN 19613 2178 7 the the DT 19613 2178 8 origin origin NN 19613 2178 9 of of IN 19613 2178 10 the the DT 19613 2178 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2178 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2178 13 see see VB 19613 2178 14 Papias Papias NNP 19613 2178 15 , , , 19613 2178 16 fragm fragm NN 19613 2178 17 . . . 19613 2179 1 6 6 CD 19613 2179 2 ; ; SYM 19613 2179 3 2 2 CD 19613 2179 4 Clem Clem NNP 19613 2179 5 . . . 19613 2180 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 2180 2 . . . 19613 2180 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2180 4 . . . 19613 2181 1 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 2181 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2181 3 H. H. NNP 19613 2181 4 E. E. NNP 19613 2181 5 III III NNP 19613 2181 6 . . . 19613 2182 1 7 7 LS 19613 2182 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2182 3 reports report VBZ 19613 2182 4 that that IN 19613 2182 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2182 6 , , , 19613 2182 7 in in IN 19613 2182 8 the the DT 19613 2182 9 9th 9th NNP 19613 2182 10 vol vol NNP 19613 2182 11 . . . 19613 2183 1 of of IN 19613 2183 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2183 3 commentary commentary NN 19613 2183 4 on on IN 19613 2183 5 Genesis Genesis NNP 19613 2183 6 , , , 19613 2183 7 compared compare VBN 19613 2183 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2183 9 with with IN 19613 2183 10 Adam Adam NNP 19613 2183 11 and and CC 19613 2183 12 Eve Eve NNP 19613 2183 13 with with IN 19613 2183 14 the the DT 19613 2183 15 Church Church NNP 19613 2183 16 , , , 19613 2183 17 and and CC 19613 2183 18 remarks remark VBZ 19613 2183 19 that that IN 19613 2183 20 Pamphilus Pamphilus NNP 19613 2183 21 ' ' POS 19613 2183 22 apology apology NN 19613 2183 23 for for IN 19613 2183 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2183 25 stated state VBD 19613 2183 26 that that IN 19613 2183 27 this this DT 19613 2183 28 allegory allegory NN 19613 2183 29 was be VBD 19613 2183 30 not not RB 19613 2183 31 new new JJ 19613 2183 32 : : : 19613 2183 33 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2183 34 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2183 35 : : : 19613 2183 36 ou ou NNP 19613 2183 37 prôton prôton JJ 19613 2183 38 Ôrigenên Ôrigenên NNP 19613 2183 39 epi epi NNP 19613 2183 40 tautên tautên NN 19613 2183 41 tên tên NNP 19613 2183 42 pragmateian pragmateian NNP 19613 2183 43 elthein elthein NNP 19613 2183 44 phasin phasin NN 19613 2183 45 , , , 19613 2183 46 alla alla NN 19613 2183 47 tên tên NNP 19613 2183 48 tês tês NNP 19613 2183 49 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 2183 50 mustikên mustikên NNP 19613 2183 51 hermêneusai hermêneusai NNP 19613 2183 52 paradosin paradosin NNP 19613 2183 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2183 54 . . . 19613 2184 1 A a DT 19613 2184 2 great great JJ 19613 2184 3 many many JJ 19613 2184 4 more more JJR 19613 2184 5 of of IN 19613 2184 6 these these DT 19613 2184 7 speculations speculation NNS 19613 2184 8 are be VBP 19613 2184 9 to to TO 19613 2184 10 be be VB 19613 2184 11 found find VBN 19613 2184 12 in in IN 19613 2184 13 the the DT 19613 2184 14 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 2184 15 century century NN 19613 2184 16 . . . 19613 2185 1 See see VB 19613 2185 2 , , , 19613 2185 3 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 2185 4 , , , 19613 2185 5 _ _ NNP 19613 2185 6 the the DT 19613 2185 7 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 2185 8 of of IN 19613 2185 9 Peter Peter NNP 19613 2185 10 and and CC 19613 2185 11 Paul Paul NNP 19613 2185 12 _ _ NNP 19613 2185 13 29 29 CD 19613 2185 14 . . . 19613 2185 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2186 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2186 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2186 3 160 160 CD 19613 2186 4 : : : 19613 2186 5 De De NNP 19613 2186 6 princip princip NN 19613 2186 7 . . . 19613 2187 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2187 2 . . . 19613 2188 1 2 2 LS 19613 2188 2 . . . 19613 2189 1 2 2 LS 19613 2189 2 ; ; : 19613 2189 3 Hom Hom NNP 19613 2189 4 . . . 19613 2190 1 III iii CD 19613 2190 2 . . . 19613 2191 1 in in IN 19613 2191 2 Jesu Jesu NNP 19613 2191 3 N. N. NNP 19613 2191 4 5 5 CD 19613 2191 5 : : : 19613 2191 6 " " `` 19613 2191 7 nemo nemo NNP 19613 2191 8 tibi tibi NNP 19613 2191 9 persuadeat persuadeat NNP 19613 2191 10 , , , 19613 2191 11 nemo nemo NNP 19613 2191 12 semetipsum semetipsum NNP 19613 2191 13 decipiat decipiat NNP 19613 2191 14 : : : 19613 2191 15 extra extra JJ 19613 2191 16 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 2191 17 nemo nemo NNP 19613 2191 18 salvatur salvatur NNP 19613 2191 19 . . . 19613 2191 20 " " '' 19613 2192 1 The the DT 19613 2192 2 reference reference NN 19613 2192 3 is be VBZ 19613 2192 4 to to IN 19613 2192 5 the the DT 19613 2192 6 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2192 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2192 8 which which WDT 19613 2192 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2192 10 also also RB 19613 2192 11 calls call VBZ 19613 2192 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2192 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2192 14 : : : 19613 2192 15 to to IN 19613 2192 16 holon holon NNP 19613 2192 17 sôma sôma NNP 19613 2192 18 tôn tôn NNP 19613 2192 19 sunagôgôn sunagôgôn VBZ 19613 2192 20 tês tês NNP 19613 2192 21 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 2192 22 . . . 19613 2192 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2192 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2193 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2193 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2193 3 161 161 CD 19613 2193 4 : : : 19613 2193 5 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 2193 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2193 7 Sim Sim NNP 19613 2193 8 . . . 19613 2194 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2194 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2195 1 has have VBZ 19613 2195 2 spoken speak VBN 19613 2195 3 of of IN 19613 2195 4 the the DT 19613 2195 5 " " `` 19613 2195 6 city city NN 19613 2195 7 of of IN 19613 2195 8 God God NNP 19613 2195 9 " " '' 19613 2195 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2195 11 see see VB 19613 2195 12 also also RB 19613 2195 13 pseudo pseudo NN 19613 2195 14 - - : 19613 2195 15 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2195 16 's 's POS 19613 2195 17 tractate tractate NN 19613 2195 18 " " `` 19613 2195 19 de de FW 19613 2195 20 pascha pascha NNP 19613 2195 21 computus computus NNP 19613 2195 22 " " '' 19613 2195 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2195 24 ; ; : 19613 2195 25 but but CC 19613 2195 26 for for IN 19613 2195 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2195 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2195 29 lies lie VBZ 19613 2195 30 in in IN 19613 2195 31 Heaven Heaven NNP 19613 2195 32 and and CC 19613 2195 33 is be VBZ 19613 2195 34 the the DT 19613 2195 35 complete complete JJ 19613 2195 36 contrast contrast NN 19613 2195 37 of of IN 19613 2195 38 the the DT 19613 2195 39 world world NN 19613 2195 40 . . . 19613 2196 1 The the DT 19613 2196 2 idea idea NN 19613 2196 3 of of IN 19613 2196 4 Plato Plato NNP 19613 2196 5 here here RB 19613 2196 6 referred refer VBD 19613 2196 7 to to IN 19613 2196 8 is be VBZ 19613 2196 9 to to TO 19613 2196 10 be be VB 19613 2196 11 found find VBN 19613 2196 12 in in IN 19613 2196 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2196 14 _ _ NNP 19613 2196 15 Republic Republic NNP 19613 2196 16 _ _ NNP 19613 2196 17 . . . 19613 2196 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2197 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2197 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2197 3 162 162 CD 19613 2197 4 : : : 19613 2197 5 See see VB 19613 2197 6 c. c. NN 19613 2197 7 Cels Cels NNP 19613 2197 8 . . . 19613 2198 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 2198 2 . . . 19613 2199 1 68 68 CD 19613 2199 2 - - SYM 19613 2199 3 75 75 CD 19613 2199 4 . . . 19613 2199 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2200 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2200 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2200 3 163 163 CD 19613 2200 4 : : : 19613 2200 5 Comment comment NN 19613 2200 6 . . . 19613 2201 1 in in IN 19613 2201 2 Joh Joh NNP 19613 2201 3 . . . 19613 2202 1 VI VI NNP 19613 2202 2 . . . 19613 2203 1 38 38 CD 19613 2203 2 . . . 19613 2203 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2204 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2204 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2204 3 164 164 CD 19613 2204 4 : : : 19613 2204 5 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 2204 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2204 7 often often RB 19613 2204 8 speaks speak VBZ 19613 2204 9 in in IN 19613 2204 10 a a DT 19613 2204 11 depreciatory depreciatory JJ 19613 2204 12 way way NN 19613 2204 13 of of IN 19613 2204 14 the the DT 19613 2204 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2204 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2204 17 : : : 19613 2204 18 ochlos ochlos NNP 19613 2204 19 tês tês NNP 19613 2204 20 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 2204 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2204 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2204 23 the the DT 19613 2204 24 ignorant ignorant JJ 19613 2204 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2204 26 without without IN 19613 2204 27 accusing accuse VBG 19613 2204 28 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2204 29 of of IN 19613 2204 30 being be VBG 19613 2204 31 unchristian unchristian JJ 19613 2204 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2204 33 this this DT 19613 2204 34 is be VBZ 19613 2204 35 very very RB 19613 2204 36 frequent frequent JJ 19613 2204 37 in in IN 19613 2204 38 the the DT 19613 2204 39 books book NNS 19613 2204 40 c. c. NN 19613 2205 1 Cels Cels NNP 19613 2205 2 . . . 19613 2205 3 , , , 19613 2205 4 but but CC 19613 2205 5 is be VBZ 19613 2205 6 also also RB 19613 2205 7 found find VBN 19613 2205 8 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 2205 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2205 10 . . . 19613 2205 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2206 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2206 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2206 3 165 165 CD 19613 2206 4 : : : 19613 2206 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2206 6 , , , 19613 2206 7 who who WP 19613 2206 8 is be VBZ 19613 2206 9 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 2206 10 's 's POS 19613 2206 11 equal equal JJ 19613 2206 12 in in IN 19613 2206 13 other other JJ 19613 2206 14 respects respect NNS 19613 2206 15 also also RB 19613 2206 16 , , , 19613 2206 17 and and CC 19613 2206 18 who who WP 19613 2206 19 anticipated anticipate VBD 19613 2206 20 many many JJ 19613 2206 21 of of IN 19613 2206 22 the the DT 19613 2206 23 problems problem NNS 19613 2206 24 considered consider VBN 19613 2206 25 by by IN 19613 2206 26 the the DT 19613 2206 27 latter latter JJ 19613 2206 28 , , , 19613 2206 29 anticipated anticipate VBN 19613 2206 30 prophetically prophetically RB 19613 2206 31 this this DT 19613 2206 32 Father Father NNP 19613 2206 33 's 's POS 19613 2206 34 view view NN 19613 2206 35 of of IN 19613 2206 36 the the DT 19613 2206 37 City City NNP 19613 2206 38 of of IN 19613 2206 39 God God NNP 19613 2206 40 -- -- : 19613 2206 41 of of RB 19613 2206 42 course course NN 19613 2206 43 as as IN 19613 2206 44 a a DT 19613 2206 45 hope hope NN 19613 2206 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2206 47 c. c. NNP 19613 2206 48 Cels Cels NNP 19613 2206 49 . . . 19613 2207 1 viii viii RB 19613 2207 2 . . . 19613 2208 1 68 68 CD 19613 2208 2 f f CD 19613 2208 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2208 4 . . . 19613 2209 1 The the DT 19613 2209 2 Church Church NNP 19613 2209 3 is be VBZ 19613 2209 4 also also RB 19613 2209 5 viewed view VBN 19613 2209 6 as as IN 19613 2209 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2209 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2209 9 : : : 19613 2209 10 to to TO 19613 2209 11 kata kata VB 19613 2209 12 Theon Theon NNP 19613 2209 13 politeuma politeuma NNS 19613 2209 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2209 15 in in IN 19613 2209 16 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2209 17 . . NNP 19613 2209 18 , , , 19613 2209 19 H. H. NNP 19613 2209 20 E. E. NNP 19613 2209 21 V. V. NNP 19613 2209 22 Præf Præf NNP 19613 2209 23 . . . 19613 2210 1 § § ADD 19613 2210 2 4 4 CD 19613 2210 3 , , , 19613 2210 4 and and CC 19613 2210 5 at at IN 19613 2210 6 an an DT 19613 2210 7 earlier early JJR 19613 2210 8 period period NN 19613 2210 9 in in IN 19613 2210 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2210 11 . . . 19613 2210 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2211 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2211 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2211 3 166 166 CD 19613 2211 4 : : : 19613 2211 5 This this DT 19613 2211 6 was be VBD 19613 2211 7 not not RB 19613 2211 8 done do VBN 19613 2211 9 even even RB 19613 2211 10 by by IN 19613 2211 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2211 12 , , , 19613 2211 13 for for IN 19613 2211 14 in in IN 19613 2211 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2211 16 great great JJ 19613 2211 17 work work NN 19613 2211 18 " " '' 19613 2211 19 de de FW 19613 2211 20 principiis principiis NNP 19613 2211 21 " " `` 19613 2211 22 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2211 23 find find VBP 19613 2211 24 no no DT 19613 2211 25 section section NN 19613 2211 26 devoted devote VBN 19613 2211 27 to to IN 19613 2211 28 the the DT 19613 2211 29 Church Church NNP 19613 2211 30 . . . 19613 2211 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2212 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2212 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2212 3 167 167 CD 19613 2212 4 : : : 19613 2212 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2212 6 is be VBZ 19613 2212 7 frequently frequently RB 19613 2212 8 represented represent VBN 19613 2212 9 in in IN 19613 2212 10 Protestant Protestant NNP 19613 2212 11 writers writer NNS 19613 2212 12 that that IN 19613 2212 13 the the DT 19613 2212 14 mistake mistake NN 19613 2212 15 consisted consist VBD 19613 2212 16 in in IN 19613 2212 17 this this DT 19613 2212 18 identification identification NN 19613 2212 19 , , , 19613 2212 20 whereas whereas IN 19613 2212 21 , , , 19613 2212 22 if if IN 19613 2212 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2212 24 once once RB 19613 2212 25 admit admit VBP 19613 2212 26 this this DT 19613 2212 27 criticism criticism NN 19613 2212 28 , , , 19613 2212 29 the the DT 19613 2212 30 defect defect NN 19613 2212 31 is be VBZ 19613 2212 32 rather rather RB 19613 2212 33 to to TO 19613 2212 34 be be VB 19613 2212 35 found find VBN 19613 2212 36 in in IN 19613 2212 37 the the DT 19613 2212 38 development development NN 19613 2212 39 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2212 40 which which WDT 19613 2212 41 took take VBD 19613 2212 42 place place NN 19613 2212 43 in in IN 19613 2212 44 the the DT 19613 2212 45 Church Church NNP 19613 2212 46 , , , 19613 2212 47 that that RB 19613 2212 48 is is RB 19613 2212 49 , , , 19613 2212 50 in in IN 19613 2212 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2212 52 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 2212 53 . . . 19613 2213 1 No no DT 19613 2213 2 one one CD 19613 2213 3 thought thought NN 19613 2213 4 of of IN 19613 2213 5 the the DT 19613 2213 6 desperate desperate JJ 19613 2213 7 idea idea NN 19613 2213 8 of of IN 19613 2213 9 an an DT 19613 2213 10 invisible invisible JJ 19613 2213 11 Church church NN 19613 2213 12 ; ; : 19613 2213 13 this this DT 19613 2213 14 notion notion NN 19613 2213 15 would would MD 19613 2213 16 probably probably RB 19613 2213 17 have have VB 19613 2213 18 brought bring VBN 19613 2213 19 about about RP 19613 2213 20 a a DT 19613 2213 21 lapse lapse NN 19613 2213 22 from from IN 19613 2213 23 pure pure JJ 19613 2213 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2213 25 far far RB 19613 2213 26 more more RBR 19613 2213 27 rapidly rapidly RB 19613 2213 28 than than IN 19613 2213 29 the the DT 19613 2213 30 idea idea NN 19613 2213 31 of of IN 19613 2213 32 the the DT 19613 2213 33 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2213 34 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2213 35 Church Church NNP 19613 2213 36 . . . 19613 2213 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2214 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2214 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2214 3 168 168 CD 19613 2214 4 : : : 19613 2214 5 Both both DT 19613 2214 6 repeatedly repeatedly RB 19613 2214 7 and and CC 19613 2214 8 very very RB 19613 2214 9 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 2214 10 declared declare VBD 19613 2214 11 that that IN 19613 2214 12 the the DT 19613 2214 13 unity unity NN 19613 2214 14 of of IN 19613 2214 15 faith faith NN 19613 2214 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2214 17 the the DT 19613 2214 18 rule rule NN 19613 2214 19 of of IN 19613 2214 20 faith faith NN 19613 2214 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2214 22 is be VBZ 19613 2214 23 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 2214 24 for for IN 19613 2214 25 the the DT 19613 2214 26 unity unity NN 19613 2214 27 of of IN 19613 2214 28 the the DT 19613 2214 29 Church Church NNP 19613 2214 30 , , , 19613 2214 31 and and CC 19613 2214 32 that that IN 19613 2214 33 in in IN 19613 2214 34 other other JJ 19613 2214 35 things thing NNS 19613 2214 36 there there EX 19613 2214 37 must must MD 19613 2214 38 be be VB 19613 2214 39 freedom freedom NN 19613 2214 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2214 41 see see VB 19613 2214 42 above above IN 19613 2214 43 all all DT 19613 2214 44 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2214 45 . . . 19613 2214 46 , , , 19613 2214 47 de de NNP 19613 2214 48 orat orat NNP 19613 2214 49 . . NNP 19613 2214 50 , , , 19613 2214 51 de de NNP 19613 2214 52 bapt bapt NNP 19613 2214 53 . . . 19613 2214 54 , , , 19613 2214 55 and and CC 19613 2214 56 the the DT 19613 2214 57 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 2214 58 writings writing NNS 19613 2214 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2214 60 . . . 19613 2215 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2215 2 is be VBZ 19613 2215 3 all all PDT 19613 2215 4 the the DT 19613 2215 5 more more RBR 19613 2215 6 worthy worthy JJ 19613 2215 7 of of IN 19613 2215 8 note note NN 19613 2215 9 that that IN 19613 2215 10 , , , 19613 2215 11 in in IN 19613 2215 12 the the DT 19613 2215 13 case case NN 19613 2215 14 of of IN 19613 2215 15 a a DT 19613 2215 16 question question NN 19613 2215 17 in in IN 19613 2215 18 which which WDT 19613 2215 19 indeed indeed RB 19613 2215 20 the the DT 19613 2215 21 customs custom NNS 19613 2215 22 of of IN 19613 2215 23 the the DT 19613 2215 24 different different JJ 19613 2215 25 countries country NNS 19613 2215 26 were be VBD 19613 2215 27 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 2215 28 productive productive JJ 19613 2215 29 of of IN 19613 2215 30 confusion confusion NN 19613 2215 31 , , , 19613 2215 32 but but CC 19613 2215 33 which which WDT 19613 2215 34 was be VBD 19613 2215 35 certainly certainly RB 19613 2215 36 not not RB 19613 2215 37 a a DT 19613 2215 38 matter matter NN 19613 2215 39 of of IN 19613 2215 40 faith faith NN 19613 2215 41 , , , 19613 2215 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2215 43 was be VBD 19613 2215 44 again again RB 19613 2215 45 a a DT 19613 2215 46 bishop bishop NN 19613 2215 47 of of IN 19613 2215 48 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2215 49 , , , 19613 2215 50 and and CC 19613 2215 51 that that IN 19613 2215 52 as as RB 19613 2215 53 far far RB 19613 2215 54 back back RB 19613 2215 55 as as IN 19613 2215 56 the the DT 19613 2215 57 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 2215 58 century century NN 19613 2215 59 , , , 19613 2215 60 who who WP 19613 2215 61 first first RB 19613 2215 62 made make VBD 19613 2215 63 the the DT 19613 2215 64 observance observance NN 19613 2215 65 of of IN 19613 2215 66 the the DT 19613 2215 67 Roman roman JJ 19613 2215 68 practice practice NN 19613 2215 69 a a DT 19613 2215 70 condition condition NN 19613 2215 71 of of IN 19613 2215 72 the the DT 19613 2215 73 unity unity NN 19613 2215 74 of of IN 19613 2215 75 the the DT 19613 2215 76 Church Church NNP 19613 2215 77 and and CC 19613 2215 78 treated treat VBN 19613 2215 79 nonconformists nonconformist NNS 19613 2215 80 as as IN 19613 2215 81 heterodox heterodox NNP 19613 2215 82 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2215 83 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2215 84 ; ; : 19613 2215 85 see see VB 19613 2215 86 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2215 87 . . NNP 19613 2215 88 , , , 19613 2215 89 H. H. NNP 19613 2215 90 E. E. NNP 19613 2215 91 V. V. NNP 19613 2215 92 24 24 CD 19613 2215 93 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2215 94 . . . 19613 2216 1 On on IN 19613 2216 2 the the DT 19613 2216 3 other other JJ 19613 2216 4 hand hand NN 19613 2216 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2216 6 says say VBZ 19613 2216 7 : : : 19613 2216 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2216 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2216 10 : : : 19613 2216 11 hê hê VB 19613 2216 12 diaphônia diaphônia NNP 19613 2216 13 tês tês NNP 19613 2216 14 nêsteias nêsteias NNP 19613 2216 15 tên tên NNP 19613 2216 16 homonoian homonoian NNP 19613 2216 17 tês tês NNP 19613 2216 18 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 2216 19 sunistêsi sunistêsi NNP 19613 2216 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2216 21 . . . 19613 2216 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2217 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2217 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2217 3 169 169 CD 19613 2217 4 : : : 19613 2217 5 On on IN 19613 2217 6 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2217 7 see see VB 19613 2217 8 Hippolyt Hippolyt NNP 19613 2217 9 . . . 19613 2217 10 , , , 19613 2217 11 Philos Philos NNP 19613 2217 12 . . . 19613 2218 1 IX ix NN 19613 2218 2 . . . 19613 2219 1 I2 I2 NNP 19613 2219 2 ; ; : 19613 2219 3 and and CC 19613 2219 4 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2219 5 . . NNP 19613 2219 6 , , , 19613 2219 7 de de NNP 19613 2219 8 pudic pudic NNP 19613 2219 9 . . . 19613 2219 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2220 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2220 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2220 3 170 170 CD 19613 2220 4 : : : 19613 2220 5 See see VB 19613 2220 6 on on IN 19613 2220 7 the the DT 19613 2220 8 other other JJ 19613 2220 9 hand hand NN 19613 2220 10 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2220 11 . . NNP 19613 2220 12 , , , 19613 2220 13 de de NNP 19613 2220 14 monog monog NNP 19613 2220 15 . . . 19613 2220 16 , , , 19613 2220 17 but but CC 19613 2220 18 also also RB 19613 2220 19 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 2220 20 . . . 19613 2220 21 , , , 19613 2220 22 l.c l.c NNP 19613 2220 23 . . NNP 19613 2220 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2221 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2221 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2221 3 171 171 CD 19613 2221 4 : : : 19613 2221 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2221 6 's 's POS 19613 2221 7 idea idea NN 19613 2221 8 of of IN 19613 2221 9 the the DT 19613 2221 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2221 11 , , , 19613 2221 12 an an DT 19613 2221 13 imitation imitation NN 19613 2221 14 of of IN 19613 2221 15 the the DT 19613 2221 16 conception conception NN 19613 2221 17 of of IN 19613 2221 18 a a DT 19613 2221 19 political political JJ 19613 2221 20 empire empire NN 19613 2221 21 , , , 19613 2221 22 viz viz NNP 19613 2221 23 . . NNP 19613 2221 24 , , , 19613 2221 25 one one CD 19613 2221 26 great great JJ 19613 2221 27 aristocratically aristocratically RB 19613 2221 28 governed govern VBN 19613 2221 29 state state NN 19613 2221 30 with with IN 19613 2221 31 an an DT 19613 2221 32 ideal ideal JJ 19613 2221 33 head head NN 19613 2221 34 , , , 19613 2221 35 is be VBZ 19613 2221 36 the the DT 19613 2221 37 result result NN 19613 2221 38 of of IN 19613 2221 39 the the DT 19613 2221 40 conflicts conflict NNS 19613 2221 41 through through IN 19613 2221 42 which which WDT 19613 2221 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2221 44 passed pass VBD 19613 2221 45 . . . 19613 2222 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2222 2 is be VBZ 19613 2222 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 2222 4 first first RB 19613 2222 5 found find VBN 19613 2222 6 in in IN 19613 2222 7 a a DT 19613 2222 8 complete complete JJ 19613 2222 9 form form NN 19613 2222 10 in in IN 19613 2222 11 the the DT 19613 2222 12 treatise treatise NN 19613 2222 13 " " '' 19613 2222 14 de de FW 19613 2222 15 unitate unitate JJ 19613 2222 16 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ JJ 19613 2222 17 " " '' 19613 2222 18 and and CC 19613 2222 19 , , , 19613 2222 20 above above IN 19613 2222 21 all all DT 19613 2222 22 , , , 19613 2222 23 in in IN 19613 2222 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2222 25 later later JJ 19613 2222 26 epistles epistle NNS 19613 2222 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2222 28 Epp Epp NNP 19613 2222 29 . . . 19613 2223 1 43 43 CD 19613 2223 2 sq sq NN 19613 2223 3 . . . 19613 2224 1 ed ed NNP 19613 2224 2 . . . 19613 2225 1 Hartel Hartel NNP 19613 2225 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2225 3 . . . 19613 2226 1 The the DT 19613 2226 2 passages passage NNS 19613 2226 3 in in IN 19613 2226 4 which which WDT 19613 2226 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2226 6 defines define VBZ 19613 2226 7 the the DT 19613 2226 8 Church Church NNP 19613 2226 9 as as IN 19613 2226 10 " " `` 19613 2226 11 constituta constituta NN 19613 2226 12 in in IN 19613 2226 13 episcopo episcopo NNP 19613 2226 14 et et NNP 19613 2226 15 in in IN 19613 2226 16 clero clero NNP 19613 2226 17 et et NNP 19613 2226 18 in in IN 19613 2226 19 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 2226 20 credentibus credentibus NNP 19613 2226 21 " " '' 19613 2226 22 date date NN 19613 2226 23 from from IN 19613 2226 24 an an DT 19613 2226 25 earlier early JJR 19613 2226 26 period period NN 19613 2226 27 , , , 19613 2226 28 when when WRB 19613 2226 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2226 30 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2226 31 essentially essentially RB 19613 2226 32 retained retain VBD 19613 2226 33 the the DT 19613 2226 34 old old JJ 19613 2226 35 idea idea NN 19613 2226 36 of of IN 19613 2226 37 the the DT 19613 2226 38 subject subject NN 19613 2226 39 . . . 19613 2227 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2227 2 , , , 19613 2227 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2227 4 never never RB 19613 2227 5 regarded regard VBD 19613 2227 6 those those DT 19613 2227 7 elements element NNS 19613 2227 8 as as IN 19613 2227 9 similar similar JJ 19613 2227 10 and and CC 19613 2227 11 of of IN 19613 2227 12 equal equal JJ 19613 2227 13 value value NN 19613 2227 14 . . . 19613 2228 1 The the DT 19613 2228 2 limitation limitation NN 19613 2228 3 of of IN 19613 2228 4 the the DT 19613 2228 5 Church Church NNP 19613 2228 6 to to IN 19613 2228 7 the the DT 19613 2228 8 community community NN 19613 2228 9 ruled rule VBN 19613 2228 10 by by IN 19613 2228 11 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2228 12 was be VBD 19613 2228 13 the the DT 19613 2228 14 result result NN 19613 2228 15 of of IN 19613 2228 16 the the DT 19613 2228 17 Novatian novatian JJ 19613 2228 18 crisis crisis NN 19613 2228 19 . . . 19613 2229 1 The the DT 19613 2229 2 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 2229 3 necessity necessity NN 19613 2229 4 of of IN 19613 2229 5 excluding exclude VBG 19613 2229 6 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 2229 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2229 8 from from IN 19613 2229 9 the the DT 19613 2229 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2229 11 communion communion NN 19613 2229 12 , , , 19613 2229 13 or or CC 19613 2229 14 , , , 19613 2229 15 in in IN 19613 2229 16 other other JJ 19613 2229 17 words word NNS 19613 2229 18 , , , 19613 2229 19 the the DT 19613 2229 20 fact fact NN 19613 2229 21 that that IN 19613 2229 22 such such JJ 19613 2229 23 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 2229 24 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2229 25 had have VBD 19613 2229 26 separated separate VBN 19613 2229 27 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2229 28 from from IN 19613 2229 29 the the DT 19613 2229 30 majority majority NN 19613 2229 31 guided guide VBN 19613 2229 32 by by IN 19613 2229 33 the the DT 19613 2229 34 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2229 35 , , , 19613 2229 36 led lead VBD 19613 2229 37 to to IN 19613 2229 38 the the DT 19613 2229 39 setting setting NN 19613 2229 40 up up RP 19613 2229 41 of of IN 19613 2229 42 a a DT 19613 2229 43 new new JJ 19613 2229 44 theory theory NN 19613 2229 45 of of IN 19613 2229 46 the the DT 19613 2229 47 Church Church NNP 19613 2229 48 , , , 19613 2229 49 which which WDT 19613 2229 50 therefore therefore RB 19613 2229 51 resulted result VBD 19613 2229 52 from from IN 19613 2229 53 stress stress NN 19613 2229 54 of of IN 19613 2229 55 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2229 56 just just RB 19613 2229 57 as as RB 19613 2229 58 much much RB 19613 2229 59 as as IN 19613 2229 60 the the DT 19613 2229 61 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 2229 62 conception conception NN 19613 2229 63 of of IN 19613 2229 64 the the DT 19613 2229 65 matter matter NN 19613 2229 66 held hold VBN 19613 2229 67 by by IN 19613 2229 68 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2229 69 . . . 19613 2230 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2230 2 's 's POS 19613 2230 3 notion notion NN 19613 2230 4 of of IN 19613 2230 5 the the DT 19613 2230 6 relation relation NN 19613 2230 7 between between IN 19613 2230 8 the the DT 19613 2230 9 whole whole JJ 19613 2230 10 body body NN 19613 2230 11 of of IN 19613 2230 12 the the DT 19613 2230 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2230 14 and and CC 19613 2230 15 the the DT 19613 2230 16 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 2230 17 may may MD 19613 2230 18 , , , 19613 2230 19 however however RB 19613 2230 20 , , , 19613 2230 21 be be VB 19613 2230 22 also also RB 19613 2230 23 understood understand VBN 19613 2230 24 as as IN 19613 2230 25 a a DT 19613 2230 26 generalisation generalisation NN 19613 2230 27 of of IN 19613 2230 28 the the DT 19613 2230 29 old old JJ 19613 2230 30 theory theory NN 19613 2230 31 about about IN 19613 2230 32 the the DT 19613 2230 33 connection connection NN 19613 2230 34 between between IN 19613 2230 35 the the DT 19613 2230 36 individual individual JJ 19613 2230 37 community community NN 19613 2230 38 and and CC 19613 2230 39 the the DT 19613 2230 40 bishop bishop NN 19613 2230 41 . . . 19613 2231 1 This this DT 19613 2231 2 already already RB 19613 2231 3 contained contain VBD 19613 2231 4 an an DT 19613 2231 5 oecumenical oecumenical JJ 19613 2231 6 element element NN 19613 2231 7 , , , 19613 2231 8 for for IN 19613 2231 9 , , , 19613 2231 10 in in IN 19613 2231 11 fact fact NN 19613 2231 12 , , , 19613 2231 13 every every DT 19613 2231 14 separate separate JJ 19613 2231 15 community community NN 19613 2231 16 was be VBD 19613 2231 17 regarded regard VBN 19613 2231 18 as as IN 19613 2231 19 a a DT 19613 2231 20 copy copy NN 19613 2231 21 of of IN 19613 2231 22 the the DT 19613 2231 23 one one CD 19613 2231 24 Church Church NNP 19613 2231 25 , , , 19613 2231 26 and and CC 19613 2231 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2231 28 bishop bishop NN 19613 2231 29 therefore therefore RB 19613 2231 30 as as IN 19613 2231 31 the the DT 19613 2231 32 representative representative NN 19613 2231 33 of of IN 19613 2231 34 God God NNP 19613 2231 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2231 36 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2231 37 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2231 38 . . . 19613 2231 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2232 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2232 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2232 3 172 172 CD 19613 2232 4 : : : 19613 2232 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2232 6 need need VBP 19613 2232 7 only only RB 19613 2232 8 quote quote UH 19613 2232 9 one one CD 19613 2232 10 passage passage NN 19613 2232 11 here here RB 19613 2232 12 -- -- : 19613 2232 13 but but CC 19613 2232 14 see see VB 19613 2232 15 also also RB 19613 2232 16 epp epp NNP 19613 2232 17 . . . 19613 2233 1 69 69 CD 19613 2233 2 . . . 19613 2234 1 3 3 CD 19613 2234 2 , , , 19613 2234 3 7 7 CD 19613 2234 4 sq sq NN 19613 2234 5 . . . 19613 2235 1 : : : 19613 2235 2 70 70 CD 19613 2235 3 . . . 19613 2236 1 2 2 LS 19613 2236 2 : : SYM 19613 2236 3 73 73 CD 19613 2236 4 . . . 19613 2237 1 8 8 CD 19613 2237 2 - - HYPH 19613 2237 3 -ep -ep NN 19613 2237 4 . . . 19613 2238 1 55 55 CD 19613 2238 2 . . . 19613 2239 1 24 24 CD 19613 2239 2 : : : 19613 2239 3 " " `` 19613 2239 4 Quod quod JJ 19613 2239 5 vero vero NN 19613 2239 6 ad ad NN 19613 2239 7 Novatiani Novatiani NNP 19613 2239 8 personam personam NN 19613 2239 9 pertinet pertinet NNP 19613 2239 10 , , , 19613 2239 11 scias scias NNP 19613 2239 12 nos nos NNP 19613 2239 13 primo primo NNP 19613 2239 14 in in IN 19613 2239 15 loco loco NNP 19613 2239 16 nec nec NNP 19613 2239 17 curiosos curiosos NNP 19613 2239 18 esse esse NNP 19613 2239 19 debere debere NNP 19613 2239 20 quid quid NNP 19613 2239 21 ille ille NNP 19613 2239 22 doceat doceat NNP 19613 2239 23 , , , 19613 2239 24 cum cum NNP 19613 2239 25 foris foris NNP 19613 2239 26 doceat doceat NNP 19613 2239 27 ; ; : 19613 2239 28 quisquis quisquis NNP 19613 2239 29 ille ille NNP 19613 2239 30 est est NNP 19613 2239 31 et et NNP 19613 2239 32 qualiscunque qualiscunque NNP 19613 2239 33 est est NNP 19613 2239 34 , , , 19613 2239 35 christianus christianus NN 19613 2239 36 non non AFX 19613 2239 37 est est NNP 19613 2239 38 , , , 19613 2239 39 qui qui VBN 19613 2239 40 in in IN 19613 2239 41 Christi Christi NNP 19613 2239 42 ecclesia ecclesia NN 19613 2239 43 non non AFX 19613 2239 44 est est NNP 19613 2239 45 . . . 19613 2239 46 " " '' 19613 2240 1 In in IN 19613 2240 2 the the DT 19613 2240 3 famous famous JJ 19613 2240 4 sentence sentence NN 19613 2240 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2240 6 ep ep NNP 19613 2240 7 . . . 19613 2241 1 74 74 CD 19613 2241 2 . . . 19613 2242 1 7 7 LS 19613 2242 2 ; ; : 19613 2242 3 de de NNP 19613 2242 4 unit unit NN 19613 2242 5 . . . 19613 2243 1 6 6 LS 19613 2243 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2243 3 : : : 19613 2243 4 " " `` 19613 2243 5 habere habere RB 19613 2243 6 non non AFX 19613 2243 7 potest potest NNP 19613 2243 8 deum deum JJ 19613 2243 9 patrem patrem NN 19613 2243 10 qui qui NN 19613 2243 11 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 2243 12 non non AFX 19613 2243 13 habet habet NN 19613 2243 14 matrem matrem NN 19613 2243 15 , , , 19613 2243 16 " " `` 19613 2243 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2243 18 must must MD 19613 2243 19 understand understand VB 19613 2243 20 the the DT 19613 2243 21 Church Church NNP 19613 2243 22 held hold VBN 19613 2243 23 together together RB 19613 2243 24 by by IN 19613 2243 25 the the DT 19613 2243 26 _ _ NNP 19613 2243 27 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 2243 28 unitatis unitatis NNP 19613 2243 29 _ _ NNP 19613 2243 30 , , , 19613 2243 31 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2243 32 , , , 19613 2243 33 by by IN 19613 2243 34 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2243 35 constitution constitution NN 19613 2243 36 . . . 19613 2244 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2244 2 is be VBZ 19613 2244 3 fond fond JJ 19613 2244 4 of of IN 19613 2244 5 referring refer VBG 19613 2244 6 to to IN 19613 2244 7 Korah Korah NNP 19613 2244 8 's 's POS 19613 2244 9 faction faction NN 19613 2244 10 , , , 19613 2244 11 who who WP 19613 2244 12 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2244 13 held hold VBD 19613 2244 14 the the DT 19613 2244 15 same same JJ 19613 2244 16 faith faith NN 19613 2244 17 as as IN 19613 2244 18 Moses Moses NNP 19613 2244 19 . . . 19613 2244 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2245 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2245 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2245 3 173 173 CD 19613 2245 4 : : : 19613 2245 5 Epp Epp NNP 19613 2245 6 . . . 19613 2246 1 4 4 LS 19613 2246 2 . . . 19613 2247 1 4 4 CD 19613 2247 2 : : SYM 19613 2247 3 33 33 CD 19613 2247 4 . . . 19613 2248 1 1 1 LS 19613 2248 2 : : : 19613 2248 3 " " `` 19613 2248 4 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2248 5 super super NNP 19613 2248 6 episcopos episcopos NN 19613 2248 7 constituta constituta NN 19613 2248 8 ; ; : 19613 2248 9 " " '' 19613 2248 10 43 43 CD 19613 2248 11 . . . 19613 2249 1 5 5 CD 19613 2249 2 : : SYM 19613 2249 3 45 45 CD 19613 2249 4 . . . 19613 2250 1 3 3 LS 19613 2250 2 : : : 19613 2250 3 " " `` 19613 2250 4 unitatem unitatem VB 19613 2250 5 a a DT 19613 2250 6 domino domino NN 19613 2250 7 et et NN 19613 2250 8 per per IN 19613 2250 9 apostolos apostolo NNS 19613 2250 10 nobis nobi MD 19613 2250 11 successoribus successoribus NNP 19613 2250 12 traditam traditam NNP 19613 2250 13 ; ; : 19613 2250 14 " " `` 19613 2250 15 46 46 CD 19613 2250 16 . . . 19613 2251 1 1 1 CD 19613 2251 2 : : SYM 19613 2251 3 66 66 CD 19613 2251 4 . . . 19613 2252 1 8 8 LS 19613 2252 2 : : : 19613 2252 3 " " `` 19613 2252 4 scire scire NN 19613 2252 5 debes debe NNS 19613 2252 6 episcopum episcopum VBP 19613 2252 7 in in IN 19613 2252 8 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2252 9 esse esse NNP 19613 2252 10 et et FW 19613 2252 11 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 2252 12 in in IN 19613 2252 13 episcopo episcopo NNP 19613 2252 14 et et FW 19613 2252 15 si si FW 19613 2252 16 qui qui NNP 19613 2252 17 cum cum NNP 19613 2252 18 episcopo episcopo VBP 19613 2252 19 non non AFX 19613 2252 20 sit sit VB 19613 2252 21 in in IN 19613 2252 22 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2252 23 non non AFX 19613 2252 24 esse esse NNP 19613 2252 25 ; ; : 19613 2252 26 " " '' 19613 2252 27 de de VBD 19613 2252 28 unit unit NN 19613 2252 29 . . . 19613 2253 1 4 4 LS 19613 2253 2 . . . 19613 2253 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2254 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2254 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2254 3 174 174 CD 19613 2254 4 : : : 19613 2254 5 According accord VBG 19613 2254 6 to to IN 19613 2254 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2254 8 the the DT 19613 2254 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2254 10 are be VBP 19613 2254 11 the the DT 19613 2254 12 _ _ NNP 19613 2254 13 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 2254 14 _ _ NNP 19613 2254 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2254 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2254 17 : : : 19613 2254 18 kat kat NNP 19613 2254 19 ' ' POS 19613 2254 20 eksochên eksochên NN 19613 2254 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2254 22 and and CC 19613 2254 23 the the DT 19613 2254 24 _ _ NNP 19613 2254 25 iudices iudice VBZ 19613 2254 26 vice vice NN 19613 2254 27 Christi Christi NNP 19613 2254 28 _ _ NNP 19613 2254 29 . . . 19613 2255 1 See see VB 19613 2255 2 epp epp NN 19613 2255 3 . . . 19613 2256 1 59 59 CD 19613 2256 2 . . . 19613 2257 1 5 5 CD 19613 2257 2 : : SYM 19613 2257 3 66 66 CD 19613 2257 4 . . . 19613 2258 1 3 3 LS 19613 2258 2 as as RB 19613 2258 3 well well RB 19613 2258 4 as as IN 19613 2258 5 c. c. NN 19613 2258 6 4 4 CD 19613 2258 7 : : : 19613 2258 8 " " `` 19613 2258 9 Christus Christus NNP 19613 2258 10 dicit dicit NN 19613 2258 11 ad ad NN 19613 2258 12 apostolos apostolo NNS 19613 2258 13 ac ac RB 19613 2258 14 per per IN 19613 2258 15 hoc hoc FW 19613 2258 16 ad ad NN 19613 2258 17 omnes omne NNS 19613 2258 18 præpositos præpositos NNP 19613 2258 19 , , , 19613 2258 20 qui qui NNP 19613 2258 21 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 2258 22 vicaria vicaria NNP 19613 2258 23 ordinatione ordinatione NNP 19613 2258 24 succedunt succedunt NNP 19613 2258 25 : : : 19613 2258 26 qui qui NNP 19613 2258 27 audit audit NN 19613 2258 28 vos vos NNP 19613 2258 29 me -PRON- PRP 19613 2258 30 audit audit NN 19613 2258 31 . . . 19613 2258 32 " " '' 19613 2259 1 Ep Ep NNP 19613 2259 2 . . . 19613 2260 1 3 3 LS 19613 2260 2 . . . 19613 2261 1 3 3 LS 19613 2261 2 : : : 19613 2261 3 " " `` 19613 2261 4 dominus dominus NNP 19613 2261 5 apostolos apostolo NNS 19613 2261 6 , , , 19613 2261 7 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2261 8 , , , 19613 2261 9 episcopos episcopos NNP 19613 2261 10 elegit elegit NNP 19613 2261 11 " " '' 19613 2261 12 ; ; : 19613 2261 13 ep ep NNP 19613 2261 14 . . . 19613 2262 1 75 75 CD 19613 2262 2 . . . 19613 2263 1 16 16 CD 19613 2263 2 . . . 19613 2263 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2264 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2264 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2264 3 175 175 CD 19613 2264 4 : : : 19613 2264 5 That that DT 19613 2264 6 is be VBZ 19613 2264 7 a a DT 19613 2264 8 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 2264 9 idea idea NN 19613 2264 10 and and CC 19613 2264 11 in in IN 19613 2264 12 fact fact NN 19613 2264 13 the the DT 19613 2264 14 outstanding outstanding JJ 19613 2264 15 feature feature NN 19613 2264 16 of of IN 19613 2264 17 the the DT 19613 2264 18 treatise treatise NN 19613 2264 19 " " '' 19613 2264 20 de de FW 19613 2264 21 unitate unitate JJ 19613 2264 22 . . . 19613 2264 23 " " '' 19613 2265 1 The the DT 19613 2265 2 heretics heretic NNS 19613 2265 3 and and CC 19613 2265 4 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 2265 5 lack lack NN 19613 2265 6 love love NN 19613 2265 7 , , , 19613 2265 8 whereas whereas IN 19613 2265 9 the the DT 19613 2265 10 unity unity NN 19613 2265 11 of of IN 19613 2265 12 the the DT 19613 2265 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2265 14 is be VBZ 19613 2265 15 the the DT 19613 2265 16 product product NN 19613 2265 17 of of IN 19613 2265 18 love love NN 19613 2265 19 , , , 19613 2265 20 this this DT 19613 2265 21 being be VBG 19613 2265 22 the the DT 19613 2265 23 main main JJ 19613 2265 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 2265 25 virtue virtue NN 19613 2265 26 . . . 19613 2266 1 That that DT 19613 2266 2 is be VBZ 19613 2266 3 the the DT 19613 2266 4 _ _ NNP 19613 2266 5 ideal ideal NN 19613 2266 6 _ _ NNP 19613 2266 7 thought think VBD 19613 2266 8 on on IN 19613 2266 9 which which WDT 19613 2266 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2266 11 builds build VBZ 19613 2266 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2266 13 theory theory NN 19613 2266 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2266 15 see see VB 19613 2266 16 also also RB 19613 2266 17 epp epp NNP 19613 2266 18 . . . 19613 2267 1 45 45 CD 19613 2267 2 . . . 19613 2268 1 1 1 CD 19613 2268 2 : : SYM 19613 2268 3 55 55 CD 19613 2268 4 . . . 19613 2269 1 24 24 CD 19613 2269 2 : : SYM 19613 2269 3 69 69 CD 19613 2269 4 . . . 19613 2270 1 1 1 CD 19613 2270 2 and and CC 19613 2270 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 2270 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2270 5 , , , 19613 2270 6 and and CC 19613 2270 7 not not RB 19613 2270 8 quite quite RB 19613 2270 9 wrongly wrongly RB 19613 2270 10 , , , 19613 2270 11 in in IN 19613 2270 12 so so RB 19613 2270 13 far far RB 19613 2270 14 as as IN 19613 2270 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2270 16 purpose purpose NN 19613 2270 17 was be VBD 19613 2270 18 to to TO 19613 2270 19 gather gather VB 19613 2270 20 and and CC 19613 2270 21 preserve preserve VB 19613 2270 22 , , , 19613 2270 23 and and CC 19613 2270 24 not not RB 19613 2270 25 scatter scatter VB 19613 2270 26 . . . 19613 2271 1 The the DT 19613 2271 2 reader reader NN 19613 2271 3 may may MD 19613 2271 4 also also RB 19613 2271 5 recall recall VB 19613 2271 6 the the DT 19613 2271 7 early early JJ 19613 2271 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 2271 9 notion notion NN 19613 2271 10 that that IN 19613 2271 11 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2271 12 should should MD 19613 2271 13 be be VB 19613 2271 14 a a DT 19613 2271 15 band band NN 19613 2271 16 of of IN 19613 2271 17 brethren brother NNS 19613 2271 18 ruled rule VBN 19613 2271 19 by by IN 19613 2271 20 love love NN 19613 2271 21 . . . 19613 2272 1 But but CC 19613 2272 2 this this DT 19613 2272 3 love love NN 19613 2272 4 ceases cease VBZ 19613 2272 5 to to TO 19613 2272 6 have have VB 19613 2272 7 any any DT 19613 2272 8 application application NN 19613 2272 9 to to IN 19613 2272 10 the the DT 19613 2272 11 case case NN 19613 2272 12 of of IN 19613 2272 13 those those DT 19613 2272 14 who who WP 19613 2272 15 are be VBP 19613 2272 16 disobedient disobedient JJ 19613 2272 17 to to IN 19613 2272 18 the the DT 19613 2272 19 authority authority NN 19613 2272 20 of of IN 19613 2272 21 the the DT 19613 2272 22 bishop bishop NN 19613 2272 23 and and CC 19613 2272 24 to to IN 19613 2272 25 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2272 26 of of IN 19613 2272 27 the the DT 19613 2272 28 sterner sterner NN 19613 2272 29 sort sort NN 19613 2272 30 . . . 19613 2273 1 The the DT 19613 2273 2 appeal appeal NN 19613 2273 3 which which WDT 19613 2273 4 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2273 5 makes make VBZ 19613 2273 6 to to TO 19613 2273 7 love love VB 19613 2273 8 , , , 19613 2273 9 even even RB 19613 2273 10 at at IN 19613 2273 11 the the DT 19613 2273 12 present present JJ 19613 2273 13 day day NN 19613 2273 14 , , , 19613 2273 15 in in IN 19613 2273 16 order order NN 19613 2273 17 to to TO 19613 2273 18 justify justify VB 19613 2273 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2273 20 secularised secularised JJ 19613 2273 21 and and CC 19613 2273 22 tyrannical tyrannical JJ 19613 2273 23 Church Church NNP 19613 2273 24 , , , 19613 2273 25 turns turn VBZ 19613 2273 26 in in IN 19613 2273 27 the the DT 19613 2273 28 mouth mouth NN 19613 2273 29 of of IN 19613 2273 30 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 19613 2273 31 politicians politician NNS 19613 2273 32 into into IN 19613 2273 33 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 19613 2273 34 , , , 19613 2273 35 of of IN 19613 2273 36 which which WDT 19613 2273 37 one one PRP 19613 2273 38 would would MD 19613 2273 39 like like VB 19613 2273 40 to to TO 19613 2273 41 acquit acquit VB 19613 2273 42 a a DT 19613 2273 43 man man NN 19613 2273 44 of of IN 19613 2273 45 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2273 46 's 's POS 19613 2273 47 stamp stamp NN 19613 2273 48 . . . 19613 2273 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2274 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2274 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2274 3 176 176 CD 19613 2274 4 : : : 19613 2274 5 Ep ep IN 19613 2274 6 . . . 19613 2275 1 43 43 CD 19613 2275 2 . . . 19613 2276 1 5 5 CD 19613 2276 2 : : SYM 19613 2276 3 55 55 CD 19613 2276 4 . . . 19613 2277 1 24 24 CD 19613 2277 2 : : : 19613 2277 3 " " `` 19613 2277 4 episcopatus episcopatus NNP 19613 2277 5 unus unus NNP 19613 2277 6 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 2277 7 multorum multorum NNP 19613 2277 8 concordi concordi NNP 19613 2277 9 numerositate numerositate NNP 19613 2277 10 diffusus diffusus NNP 19613 2277 11 ; ; : 19613 2277 12 " " `` 19613 2277 13 de de VBD 19613 2277 14 unit unit NN 19613 2277 15 . . . 19613 2278 1 5 5 CD 19613 2278 2 : : : 19613 2278 3 " " `` 19613 2278 4 episcopatus episcopatus NNP 19613 2278 5 unus unus NNP 19613 2278 6 est est NNP 19613 2278 7 , , , 19613 2278 8 cuius cuius NNP 19613 2278 9 a a DT 19613 2278 10 singulis singulis NNP 19613 2278 11 in in IN 19613 2278 12 solidum solidum NNP 19613 2278 13 pars pars NNPS 19613 2278 14 tenetur tenetur NNP 19613 2278 15 . . . 19613 2278 16 " " '' 19613 2279 1 Strictly strictly RB 19613 2279 2 speaking speak VBG 19613 2279 3 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2279 4 did do VBD 19613 2279 5 not not RB 19613 2279 6 set set VB 19613 2279 7 up up RP 19613 2279 8 a a DT 19613 2279 9 theory theory NN 19613 2279 10 that that IN 19613 2279 11 the the DT 19613 2279 12 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2279 13 were be VBD 19613 2279 14 directed direct VBN 19613 2279 15 by by IN 19613 2279 16 the the DT 19613 2279 17 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2279 18 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2279 19 , , , 19613 2279 20 but but CC 19613 2279 21 in in IN 19613 2279 22 identifying identify VBG 19613 2279 23 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2279 24 and and CC 19613 2279 25 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2279 26 and and CC 19613 2279 27 asserting assert VBG 19613 2279 28 the the DT 19613 2279 29 divine divine JJ 19613 2279 30 appointment appointment NN 19613 2279 31 of of IN 19613 2279 32 the the DT 19613 2279 33 latter latter NN 19613 2279 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2279 35 took take VBD 19613 2279 36 for for IN 19613 2279 37 granted grant VBN 19613 2279 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2279 39 special special JJ 19613 2279 40 endowment endowment NN 19613 2279 41 with with IN 19613 2279 42 the the DT 19613 2279 43 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2279 44 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2279 45 . . . 19613 2280 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2280 2 , , , 19613 2280 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2280 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2280 5 frequently frequently RB 19613 2280 6 appealed appeal VBD 19613 2280 7 to to IN 19613 2280 8 special special JJ 19613 2280 9 communications communication NNS 19613 2280 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2280 11 had have VBD 19613 2280 12 received receive VBN 19613 2280 13 from from IN 19613 2280 14 the the DT 19613 2280 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2280 16 as as IN 19613 2280 17 aids aids NNP 19613 2280 18 in in IN 19613 2280 19 discharging discharge VBG 19613 2280 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2280 21 official official JJ 19613 2280 22 duties duty NNS 19613 2280 23 . . . 19613 2280 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2281 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2281 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2281 3 177 177 CD 19613 2281 4 : : : 19613 2281 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2281 6 did do VBD 19613 2281 7 not not RB 19613 2281 8 yet yet RB 19613 2281 9 regard regard VB 19613 2281 10 uniformity uniformity NN 19613 2281 11 of of IN 19613 2281 12 Church Church NNP 19613 2281 13 practice practice NN 19613 2281 14 as as IN 19613 2281 15 a a DT 19613 2281 16 matter matter NN 19613 2281 17 of of IN 19613 2281 18 moment moment NN 19613 2281 19 -- -- : 19613 2281 20 or or CC 19613 2281 21 rather rather RB 19613 2281 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2281 23 knew know VBD 19613 2281 24 that that IN 19613 2281 25 diversities diversity NNS 19613 2281 26 must must MD 19613 2281 27 be be VB 19613 2281 28 tolerated tolerate VBN 19613 2281 29 . . . 19613 2282 1 In in IN 19613 2282 2 so so RB 19613 2282 3 far far RB 19613 2282 4 as as IN 19613 2282 5 the the DT 19613 2282 6 _ _ NNP 19613 2282 7 concordia concordia NNP 19613 2282 8 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 2282 9 _ _ NNP 19613 2282 10 was be VBD 19613 2282 11 consistent consistent JJ 19613 2282 12 with with IN 19613 2282 13 this this DT 19613 2282 14 diversity diversity NN 19613 2282 15 , , , 19613 2282 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2282 17 did do VBD 19613 2282 18 not not RB 19613 2282 19 interfere interfere VB 19613 2282 20 with with IN 19613 2282 21 the the DT 19613 2282 22 differences difference NNS 19613 2282 23 , , , 19613 2282 24 provided provide VBD 19613 2282 25 the the DT 19613 2282 26 _ _ NNP 19613 2282 27 regula regula NN 19613 2282 28 fidei fidei NNP 19613 2282 29 _ _ NNP 19613 2282 30 was be VBD 19613 2282 31 adhered adhere VBN 19613 2282 32 to to IN 19613 2282 33 . . . 19613 2283 1 Every every DT 19613 2283 2 bishop bishop NN 19613 2283 3 who who WP 19613 2283 4 adheres adhere VBZ 19613 2283 5 to to IN 19613 2283 6 the the DT 19613 2283 7 confederation confederation NN 19613 2283 8 has have VBZ 19613 2283 9 the the DT 19613 2283 10 greatest great JJS 19613 2283 11 freedom freedom NN 19613 2283 12 even even RB 19613 2283 13 in in IN 19613 2283 14 questions question NNS 19613 2283 15 of of IN 19613 2283 16 Church church NN 19613 2283 17 discipline discipline NN 19613 2283 18 and and CC 19613 2283 19 practice practice NN 19613 2283 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2283 21 as as IN 19613 2283 22 for for IN 19613 2283 23 instance instance NN 19613 2283 24 in in IN 19613 2283 25 the the DT 19613 2283 26 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 2283 27 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 2283 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2283 29 ; ; : 19613 2283 30 see see VB 19613 2283 31 ep ep NNP 19613 2283 32 . . . 19613 2284 1 59 59 CD 19613 2284 2 . . . 19613 2285 1 14 14 CD 19613 2285 2 : : : 19613 2285 3 " " `` 19613 2285 4 Singulis Singulis NNP 19613 2285 5 pastoribus pastoribus NNP 19613 2285 6 portio portio NN 19613 2285 7 gregis gregi VBZ 19613 2285 8 est est NNP 19613 2285 9 adscripta adscripta NNP 19613 2285 10 , , , 19613 2285 11 quam quam NNP 19613 2285 12 regit regit NNP 19613 2285 13 unusquisque unusquisque NNP 19613 2285 14 et et NNP 19613 2285 15 gubernat gubernat NNP 19613 2285 16 rationem rationem NNP 19613 2285 17 sui sui NNP 19613 2285 18 actus actus NNP 19613 2285 19 domino domino NNP 19613 2285 20 redditurus redditurus NNP 19613 2285 21 ; ; : 19613 2285 22 " " `` 19613 2285 23 55 55 CD 19613 2285 24 . . . 19613 2286 1 21 21 CD 19613 2286 2 : : : 19613 2286 3 " " `` 19613 2286 4 Et Et NNP 19613 2286 5 quidem quidem NN 19613 2286 6 apud apud NNP 19613 2286 7 antecessores antecessores NNPS 19613 2286 8 nostros nostros NNP 19613 2286 9 quidam quidam NNP 19613 2286 10 de de NNP 19613 2286 11 episcopis episcopi VBD 19613 2286 12 istic istic JJ 19613 2286 13 in in IN 19613 2286 14 provincia provincia NNP 19613 2286 15 nostra nostra NNP 19613 2286 16 dandam dandam NNP 19613 2286 17 pacis pacis NNP 19613 2286 18 moechis moechis NNP 19613 2286 19 non non NNP 19613 2286 20 putaverunt putaverunt NN 19613 2286 21 et et NNP 19613 2286 22 in in IN 19613 2286 23 totum totum NNP 19613 2286 24 pænitentiæ pænitentiæ NNP 19613 2286 25 locum locum NNP 19613 2286 26 contra contra NNP 19613 2286 27 adulteria adulteria NNP 19613 2286 28 cluserunt cluserunt NNP 19613 2286 29 , , , 19613 2286 30 non non NNP 19613 2286 31 tamen tamen NNP 19613 2286 32 a a DT 19613 2286 33 co co NN 19613 2286 34 - - NN 19613 2286 35 episcoporum episcoporum JJ 19613 2286 36 suorum suorum NNP 19613 2286 37 collegio collegio NNP 19613 2286 38 recesserunt recesserunt NNP 19613 2286 39 aut aut NNP 19613 2286 40 catholicæ catholicæ NNP 19613 2286 41 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2286 42 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 2286 43 ruperunt ruperunt NN 19613 2286 44 , , , 19613 2286 45 ut ut UH 19613 2286 46 quia quia NNP 19613 2286 47 apud apud NNP 19613 2286 48 alios alios NNPS 19613 2286 49 adulteris adulteris NNP 19613 2286 50 pax pax NNP 19613 2286 51 dabatur dabatur NNP 19613 2286 52 , , , 19613 2286 53 qui qui VBD 19613 2286 54 non non AFX 19613 2286 55 dabat dabat NNP 19613 2286 56 de de NNP 19613 2286 57 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2286 58 separaretur separaretur NNP 19613 2286 59 . . . 19613 2286 60 " " '' 19613 2287 1 According accord VBG 19613 2287 2 to to IN 19613 2287 3 ep ep NNP 19613 2287 4 . . . 19613 2288 1 57 57 CD 19613 2288 2 . . . 19613 2289 1 5 5 CD 19613 2289 2 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2289 3 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2289 4 , , , 19613 2289 5 who who WP 19613 2289 6 insist insist VBP 19613 2289 7 on on IN 19613 2289 8 the the DT 19613 2289 9 strict strict JJ 19613 2289 10 practice practice NN 19613 2289 11 of of IN 19613 2289 12 penance penance NN 19613 2289 13 , , , 19613 2289 14 but but CC 19613 2289 15 do do VBP 19613 2289 16 not not RB 19613 2289 17 separate separate VB 19613 2289 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2289 19 from from IN 19613 2289 20 the the DT 19613 2289 21 unity unity NN 19613 2289 22 of of IN 19613 2289 23 the the DT 19613 2289 24 Church Church NNP 19613 2289 25 , , , 19613 2289 26 are be VBP 19613 2289 27 left leave VBN 19613 2289 28 to to IN 19613 2289 29 the the DT 19613 2289 30 judgment judgment NN 19613 2289 31 of of IN 19613 2289 32 God God NNP 19613 2289 33 . . . 19613 2290 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2290 2 is be VBZ 19613 2290 3 different different JJ 19613 2290 4 in in IN 19613 2290 5 the the DT 19613 2290 6 case case NN 19613 2290 7 referred refer VBD 19613 2290 8 to to IN 19613 2290 9 in in IN 19613 2290 10 ep ep NNP 19613 2290 11 . . . 19613 2291 1 68 68 CD 19613 2291 2 , , , 19613 2291 3 for for IN 19613 2291 4 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 2291 5 had have VBD 19613 2291 6 formally formally RB 19613 2291 7 joined join VBN 19613 2291 8 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2291 9 . . . 19613 2292 1 Even even RB 19613 2292 2 in in IN 19613 2292 3 the the DT 19613 2292 4 disputed dispute VBN 19613 2292 5 question question NN 19613 2292 6 of of IN 19613 2292 7 heretical heretical JJ 19613 2292 8 baptism baptism NN 19613 2292 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2292 10 ep ep NNP 19613 2292 11 . . . 19613 2293 1 72 72 CD 19613 2293 2 . . . 19613 2294 1 3 3 LS 19613 2294 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2294 3 Cyprian cyprian NN 19613 2294 4 declares declare VBZ 19613 2294 5 to to IN 19613 2294 6 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2294 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2294 8 See See NNP 19613 2294 9 69 69 CD 19613 2294 10 . . . 19613 2295 1 17 17 CD 19613 2295 2 : : SYM 19613 2295 3 73 73 CD 19613 2295 4 . . . 19613 2296 1 26 26 CD 19613 2296 2 ; ; : 19613 2296 3 _ _ NNP 19613 2296 4 Sententiæ Sententiæ NNP 19613 2296 5 episc episc NN 19613 2296 6 . . . 19613 2296 7 _ _ NNP 19613 2296 8 , , , 19613 2296 9 præfat præfat NN 19613 2296 10 . . . 19613 2297 1 ): ): LS 19613 2297 2 " " `` 19613 2297 3 qua qua NNP 19613 2297 4 in in IN 19613 2297 5 re re IN 19613 2297 6 nec nec NNP 19613 2297 7 nos nos NNP 19613 2297 8 vim vim NNP 19613 2297 9 cuiquam cuiquam NNP 19613 2297 10 facimus facimus NNP 19613 2297 11 aut aut NNP 19613 2297 12 legem legem NNP 19613 2297 13 damus damus NNP 19613 2297 14 , , , 19613 2297 15 quando quando NNP 19613 2297 16 habeat habeat NNP 19613 2297 17 in in IN 19613 2297 18 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2297 19 administratione administratione NN 19613 2297 20 voluntatis voluntatis NN 19613 2297 21 suæ suæ NNP 19613 2297 22 arbitrium arbitrium NN 19613 2297 23 liberum liberum NNP 19613 2297 24 unusquisque unusquisque NNP 19613 2297 25 præpositus præpositus NNP 19613 2297 26 , , , 19613 2297 27 rationem rationem NNP 19613 2297 28 actus actus NNP 19613 2297 29 sui sui NNP 19613 2297 30 domino domino NNP 19613 2297 31 redditurus redditurus NNP 19613 2297 32 . . . 19613 2297 33 " " '' 19613 2298 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2298 2 is be VBZ 19613 2298 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 2298 4 plain plain JJ 19613 2298 5 wherein wherein WRB 19613 2298 6 the the DT 19613 2298 7 unity unity NN 19613 2298 8 of of IN 19613 2298 9 the the DT 19613 2298 10 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 2298 11 and and CC 19613 2298 12 the the DT 19613 2298 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2298 14 actually actually RB 19613 2298 15 consists consist VBZ 19613 2298 16 ; ; : 19613 2298 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2298 18 may may MD 19613 2298 19 say say VB 19613 2298 20 that that IN 19613 2298 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2298 22 is be VBZ 19613 2298 23 found find VBN 19613 2298 24 in in IN 19613 2298 25 the the DT 19613 2298 26 _ _ NNP 19613 2298 27 regula regula NN 19613 2298 28 _ _ NNP 19613 2298 29 , , , 19613 2298 30 in in IN 19613 2298 31 the the DT 19613 2298 32 fixed fix VBN 19613 2298 33 purpose purpose NN 19613 2298 34 not not RB 19613 2298 35 to to TO 19613 2298 36 give give VB 19613 2298 37 up up RP 19613 2298 38 the the DT 19613 2298 39 unity unity NN 19613 2298 40 in in IN 19613 2298 41 spite spite NN 19613 2298 42 of of IN 19613 2298 43 all all DT 19613 2298 44 differences difference NNS 19613 2298 45 , , , 19613 2298 46 and and CC 19613 2298 47 in in IN 19613 2298 48 the the DT 19613 2298 49 principle principle NN 19613 2298 50 of of IN 19613 2298 51 regulating regulate VBG 19613 2298 52 all all PDT 19613 2298 53 the the DT 19613 2298 54 affairs affair NNS 19613 2298 55 of of IN 19613 2298 56 the the DT 19613 2298 57 Church Church NNP 19613 2298 58 " " '' 19613 2298 59 ad ad NN 19613 2298 60 originem originem NNP 19613 2298 61 dominicam dominicam NNP 19613 2298 62 et et NNP 19613 2298 63 ad ad NN 19613 2298 64 evangelicam evangelicam NNP 19613 2298 65 adque adque NNP 19613 2298 66 apostolicam apostolicam NNP 19613 2298 67 traditionem traditionem NNP 19613 2298 68 " " '' 19613 2298 69 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2298 70 ep ep NNP 19613 2298 71 . . . 19613 2299 1 74 74 CD 19613 2299 2 . . . 19613 2300 1 10 10 LS 19613 2300 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2300 3 . . . 19613 2301 1 This this DT 19613 2301 2 refers refer VBZ 19613 2301 3 to to IN 19613 2301 4 the the DT 19613 2301 5 New New NNP 19613 2301 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2301 7 , , , 19613 2301 8 which which WDT 19613 2301 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2301 10 emphatically emphatically RB 19613 2301 11 insisted insist VBD 19613 2301 12 on on IN 19613 2301 13 making make VBG 19613 2301 14 the the DT 19613 2301 15 standard standard NN 19613 2301 16 for for IN 19613 2301 17 the the DT 19613 2301 18 Church Church NNP 19613 2301 19 . . . 19613 2302 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2302 2 must must MD 19613 2302 3 be be VB 19613 2302 4 taken take VBN 19613 2302 5 as as IN 19613 2302 6 the the DT 19613 2302 7 guide guide NN 19613 2302 8 , , , 19613 2302 9 " " '' 19613 2302 10 si si NNP 19613 2302 11 in in IN 19613 2302 12 aliquo aliquo NNP 19613 2302 13 in in IN 19613 2302 14 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2302 15 nutaverit nutaverit NNP 19613 2302 16 et et FW 19613 2302 17 vacillaverit vacillaverit FW 19613 2302 18 veritas veritas FW 19613 2302 19 ; ; : 19613 2302 20 " " `` 19613 2302 21 by by IN 19613 2302 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2302 23 , , , 19613 2302 24 moreover moreover RB 19613 2302 25 , , , 19613 2302 26 all all DT 19613 2302 27 false false JJ 19613 2302 28 customs custom NNS 19613 2302 29 are be VBP 19613 2302 30 to to TO 19613 2302 31 be be VB 19613 2302 32 corrected correct VBN 19613 2302 33 . . . 19613 2303 1 In in IN 19613 2303 2 the the DT 19613 2303 3 controversy controversy NN 19613 2303 4 about about IN 19613 2303 5 heretical heretical JJ 19613 2303 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 2303 7 , , , 19613 2303 8 the the DT 19613 2303 9 alteration alteration NN 19613 2303 10 of of IN 19613 2303 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2303 12 practice practice NN 19613 2303 13 in in IN 19613 2303 14 Carthage Carthage NNP 19613 2303 15 and and CC 19613 2303 16 Africa Africa NNP 19613 2303 17 , , , 19613 2303 18 which which WDT 19613 2303 19 was be VBD 19613 2303 20 the the DT 19613 2303 21 point point NN 19613 2303 22 in in IN 19613 2303 23 question question NN 19613 2303 24 -- -- : 19613 2303 25 for for IN 19613 2303 26 whilst whilst NN 19613 2303 27 in in IN 19613 2303 28 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2303 29 heretical heretical JJ 19613 2303 30 baptism baptism NN 19613 2303 31 had have VBD 19613 2303 32 for for IN 19613 2303 33 a a DT 19613 2303 34 very very RB 19613 2303 35 long long JJ 19613 2303 36 time time NN 19613 2303 37 been be VBN 19613 2303 38 declared declare VBN 19613 2303 39 invalid invalid JJ 19613 2303 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2303 41 see see VB 19613 2303 42 ep ep NNP 19613 2303 43 . . . 19613 2304 1 75 75 CD 19613 2304 2 . . . 19613 2305 1 19 19 LS 19613 2305 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2305 3 this this DT 19613 2305 4 had have VBD 19613 2305 5 only only RB 19613 2305 6 been be VBN 19613 2305 7 the the DT 19613 2305 8 case case NN 19613 2305 9 in in IN 19613 2305 10 Carthage carthage NN 19613 2305 11 for for IN 19613 2305 12 a a DT 19613 2305 13 few few JJ 19613 2305 14 years year NNS 19613 2305 15 -- -- : 19613 2305 16 was be VBD 19613 2305 17 justified justify VBN 19613 2305 18 by by IN 19613 2305 19 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2305 20 through through IN 19613 2305 21 an an DT 19613 2305 22 appeal appeal NN 19613 2305 23 to to IN 19613 2305 24 _ _ NNP 19613 2305 25 veritas veritas NNP 19613 2305 26 _ _ NNP 19613 2305 27 in in IN 19613 2305 28 contrast contrast NN 19613 2305 29 to to IN 19613 2305 30 _ _ NNP 19613 2305 31 consuetudo consuetudo NN 19613 2305 32 sine sine NNP 19613 2305 33 veritate veritate NNP 19613 2305 34 _ _ NNP 19613 2305 35 . . . 19613 2306 1 See see VB 19613 2306 2 epp epp NN 19613 2306 3 . . . 19613 2307 1 71 71 CD 19613 2307 2 . . . 19613 2308 1 2 2 CD 19613 2308 2 , , , 19613 2308 3 3 3 CD 19613 2308 4 : : SYM 19613 2308 5 73 73 CD 19613 2308 6 . . . 19613 2309 1 13 13 CD 19613 2309 2 , , , 19613 2309 3 23 23 CD 19613 2309 4 : : SYM 19613 2309 5 74 74 CD 19613 2309 6 . . . 19613 2310 1 2 2 CD 19613 2310 2 sq sq NNP 19613 2310 3 . . . 19613 2311 1 : : : 19613 2311 2 9 9 CD 19613 2311 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2311 4 the the DT 19613 2311 5 formula formula NN 19613 2311 6 originates originate VBZ 19613 2311 7 with with IN 19613 2311 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2311 9 ; ; : 19613 2311 10 see see VB 19613 2311 11 de de NNP 19613 2311 12 virg virg NNS 19613 2311 13 . . . 19613 2312 1 vel vel NNP 19613 2312 2 . . . 19613 2313 1 1 1 CD 19613 2313 2 - - SYM 19613 2313 3 3 3 CD 19613 2313 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2313 5 . . . 19613 2314 1 The the DT 19613 2314 2 _ _ NNP 19613 2314 3 veritas verita VBD 19613 2314 4 _ _ NNP 19613 2314 5 , , , 19613 2314 6 however however RB 19613 2314 7 , , , 19613 2314 8 is be VBZ 19613 2314 9 to to TO 19613 2314 10 be be VB 19613 2314 11 learned learn VBN 19613 2314 12 from from IN 19613 2314 13 the the DT 19613 2314 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2314 15 and and CC 19613 2314 16 words word NNS 19613 2314 17 of of IN 19613 2314 18 the the DT 19613 2314 19 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2314 20 : : : 19613 2314 21 " " `` 19613 2314 22 Lex lex NN 19613 2314 23 evangelii evangelii NN 19613 2314 24 , , , 19613 2314 25 " " '' 19613 2314 26 " " `` 19613 2314 27 præcepta præcepta NNP 19613 2314 28 dominica dominica NNP 19613 2314 29 , , , 19613 2314 30 " " '' 19613 2314 31 and and CC 19613 2314 32 synonymous synonymous JJ 19613 2314 33 expressions expression NNS 19613 2314 34 are be VBP 19613 2314 35 very very RB 19613 2314 36 frequent frequent JJ 19613 2314 37 in in IN 19613 2314 38 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2314 39 , , , 19613 2314 40 more more RBR 19613 2314 41 frequent frequent JJ 19613 2314 42 than than IN 19613 2314 43 reference reference NN 19613 2314 44 to to IN 19613 2314 45 the the DT 19613 2314 46 _ _ NNP 19613 2314 47 regula regula NN 19613 2314 48 _ _ NNP 19613 2314 49 or or CC 19613 2314 50 to to IN 19613 2314 51 the the DT 19613 2314 52 symbol symbol NN 19613 2314 53 . . . 19613 2315 1 In in IN 19613 2315 2 fact fact NN 19613 2315 3 there there EX 19613 2315 4 was be VBD 19613 2315 5 still still RB 19613 2315 6 no no DT 19613 2315 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2315 8 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 2315 9 , , , 19613 2315 10 there there EX 19613 2315 11 being be VBG 19613 2315 12 only only JJ 19613 2315 13 principles principle NNS 19613 2315 14 of of IN 19613 2315 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 2315 16 faith faith NN 19613 2315 17 and and CC 19613 2315 18 life life NN 19613 2315 19 , , , 19613 2315 20 which which WDT 19613 2315 21 , , , 19613 2315 22 however however RB 19613 2315 23 , , , 19613 2315 24 were be VBD 19613 2315 25 taken take VBN 19613 2315 26 from from IN 19613 2315 27 the the DT 19613 2315 28 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2315 29 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 2315 30 and and CC 19613 2315 31 the the DT 19613 2315 32 _ _ NNP 19613 2315 33 regula regula NN 19613 2315 34 _ _ NNP 19613 2315 35 . . . 19613 2315 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2316 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2316 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2316 3 178 178 CD 19613 2316 4 : : : 19613 2316 5 Cyprian cyprian NN 19613 2316 6 no no RB 19613 2316 7 longer long RBR 19613 2316 8 makes make VBZ 19613 2316 9 any any DT 19613 2316 10 distinction distinction NN 19613 2316 11 between between IN 19613 2316 12 Churches church NNS 19613 2316 13 founded found VBN 19613 2316 14 by by IN 19613 2316 15 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2316 16 , , , 19613 2316 17 and and CC 19613 2316 18 those those DT 19613 2316 19 which which WDT 19613 2316 20 arose arise VBD 19613 2316 21 later later RB 19613 2316 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2316 23 that that RB 19613 2316 24 is is RB 19613 2316 25 , , , 19613 2316 26 between between IN 19613 2316 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2316 28 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2316 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2316 30 . . . 19613 2316 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2317 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2317 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2317 3 179 179 CD 19613 2317 4 : : : 19613 2317 5 The the DT 19613 2317 6 statement statement NN 19613 2317 7 that that IN 19613 2317 8 the the DT 19613 2317 9 Church Church NNP 19613 2317 10 is be VBZ 19613 2317 11 " " `` 19613 2317 12 super super JJ 19613 2317 13 Petrum Petrum NNP 19613 2317 14 fundata fundata NN 19613 2317 15 " " '' 19613 2317 16 is be VBZ 19613 2317 17 very very RB 19613 2317 18 frequently frequently RB 19613 2317 19 made make VBN 19613 2317 20 by by IN 19613 2317 21 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2317 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2317 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2317 24 find find VBP 19613 2317 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2317 26 already already RB 19613 2317 27 in in IN 19613 2317 28 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2317 29 , , , 19613 2317 30 de de FW 19613 2317 31 monog monog NNP 19613 2317 32 . . . 19613 2318 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2318 2 ; ; : 19613 2318 3 see see VB 19613 2318 4 de de NNP 19613 2318 5 habitu habitu NNP 19613 2318 6 virg virg NNS 19613 2318 7 . . . 19613 2319 1 10 10 LS 19613 2319 2 ; ; : 19613 2319 3 Epp Epp NNP 19613 2319 4 . . . 19613 2320 1 59 59 CD 19613 2320 2 . . . 19613 2321 1 7 7 LS 19613 2321 2 : : SYM 19613 2321 3 66 66 CD 19613 2321 4 . . . 19613 2322 1 8 8 CD 19613 2322 2 : : SYM 19613 2322 3 71 71 CD 19613 2322 4 . . . 19613 2323 1 3 3 CD 19613 2323 2 : : SYM 19613 2323 3 74 74 CD 19613 2323 4 . . . 19613 2324 1 11 11 CD 19613 2324 2 : : SYM 19613 2324 3 73 73 CD 19613 2324 4 . . . 19613 2325 1 7 7 LS 19613 2325 2 . . . 19613 2326 1 But but CC 19613 2326 2 on on IN 19613 2326 3 the the DT 19613 2326 4 strength strength NN 19613 2326 5 of of IN 19613 2326 6 Matth Matth NNP 19613 2326 7 . . . 19613 2327 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 2327 2 . . . 19613 2328 1 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2328 2 went go VBD 19613 2328 3 still still RB 19613 2328 4 farther farther RB 19613 2328 5 ; ; : 19613 2328 6 see see VB 19613 2328 7 ep ep NNP 19613 2328 8 . . . 19613 2329 1 43 43 CD 19613 2329 2 . . . 19613 2330 1 5 5 CD 19613 2330 2 : : : 19613 2330 3 " " `` 19613 2330 4 deus deu VBZ 19613 2330 5 unus unus JJ 19613 2330 6 est est FW 19613 2330 7 et et NNP 19613 2330 8 Christus Christus NNP 19613 2330 9 unus unus JJ 19613 2330 10 et et FW 19613 2330 11 una una NNP 19613 2330 12 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2330 13 et et NNP 19613 2330 14 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 2330 15 una una VBD 19613 2330 16 super super JJ 19613 2330 17 Petrum Petrum NNP 19613 2330 18 domini domini NN 19613 2330 19 voce voce NNP 19613 2330 20 fundata fundata NN 19613 2330 21 ; ; : 19613 2330 22 " " '' 19613 2330 23 ep ep NNP 19613 2330 24 . . . 19613 2331 1 48 48 CD 19613 2331 2 . . . 19613 2332 1 3 3 LS 19613 2332 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2332 3 ad ad NN 19613 2332 4 Cornel Cornel NNP 19613 2332 5 . . . 19613 2333 1 ): ): LS 19613 2333 2 " " `` 19613 2333 3 communicatio communicatio NNP 19613 2333 4 tua tua NNP 19613 2333 5 , , , 19613 2333 6 i -PRON- PRP 19613 2333 7 d d VBN 19613 2333 8 est est NNP 19613 2333 9 catholicæ catholicæ NNP 19613 2333 10 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2333 11 unitas unitas NNP 19613 2333 12 pariter pariter NNP 19613 2333 13 et et NNP 19613 2333 14 caritas caritas NN 19613 2333 15 ; ; : 19613 2333 16 " " `` 19613 2333 17 de de IN 19613 2333 18 unit unit NN 19613 2333 19 . . . 19613 2334 1 4 4 LS 19613 2334 2 : : : 19613 2334 3 " " `` 19613 2334 4 superunum superunum NNP 19613 2334 5 ædificat ædificat NN 19613 2334 6 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 2334 7 , , , 19613 2334 8 et et FW 19613 2334 9 quamvis quamvis NNP 19613 2334 10 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 2334 11 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 2334 12 post post NNP 19613 2334 13 resurrectionem resurrectionem NNP 19613 2334 14 suam suam NNP 19613 2334 15 parem parem NNP 19613 2334 16 potestatem potestatem NNP 19613 2334 17 tribuat tribuat NNP 19613 2334 18 , , , 19613 2334 19 tamen tamen NNP 19613 2334 20 ut ut NNP 19613 2334 21 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 2334 22 manifestaret manifestaret NNP 19613 2334 23 , , , 19613 2334 24 unitatis unitatis NNP 19613 2334 25 eiusdem eiusdem NNP 19613 2334 26 originem originem NNP 19613 2334 27 ab ab NNP 19613 2334 28 uno uno NNP 19613 2334 29 incipientem incipientem NNP 19613 2334 30 sua sua NNP 19613 2334 31 auctoritate auctoritate NNP 19613 2334 32 disposuit disposuit NNP 19613 2334 33 ; ; : 19613 2334 34 " " '' 19613 2334 35 ep ep NNP 19613 2334 36 . . . 19613 2335 1 70 70 CD 19613 2335 2 . . . 19613 2336 1 3 3 LS 19613 2336 2 : : : 19613 2336 3 " " `` 19613 2336 4 una una NNP 19613 2336 5 ecclesia ecclesia VBZ 19613 2336 6 a a DT 19613 2336 7 Christo Christo NNP 19613 2336 8 domino domino NN 19613 2336 9 nostro nostro NN 19613 2336 10 super super NNP 19613 2336 11 Petrum Petrum NNP 19613 2336 12 origine origine NN 19613 2336 13 unitatis unitatis NN 19613 2336 14 et et FW 19613 2336 15 ratione ratione JJ 19613 2336 16 fundata fundata NN 19613 2336 17 " " '' 19613 2336 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2336 19 " " '' 19613 2336 20 with with IN 19613 2336 21 regard regard NN 19613 2336 22 to to IN 19613 2336 23 the the DT 19613 2336 24 origin origin NN 19613 2336 25 and and CC 19613 2336 26 constitution constitution NN 19613 2336 27 of of IN 19613 2336 28 the the DT 19613 2336 29 unity unity NN 19613 2336 30 " " '' 19613 2336 31 is be VBZ 19613 2336 32 the the DT 19613 2336 33 translation translation NN 19613 2336 34 of of IN 19613 2336 35 this this DT 19613 2336 36 last last JJ 19613 2336 37 passage passage NN 19613 2336 38 in in IN 19613 2336 39 the the DT 19613 2336 40 " " `` 19613 2336 41 Stimmen Stimmen NNP 19613 2336 42 aus au VBD 19613 2336 43 Maria Maria NNP 19613 2336 44 Laach Laach NNP 19613 2336 45 , , , 19613 2336 46 " " '' 19613 2336 47 1877 1877 CD 19613 2336 48 , , , 19613 2336 49 part part NN 19613 2336 50 8 8 CD 19613 2336 51 , , , 19613 2336 52 p. p. NN 19613 2336 53 355 355 CD 19613 2336 54 ; ; : 19613 2336 55 but but CC 19613 2336 56 " " `` 19613 2336 57 ratio ratio NN 19613 2336 58 " " '' 19613 2336 59 can can MD 19613 2336 60 not not RB 19613 2336 61 mean mean VB 19613 2336 62 that that DT 19613 2336 63 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2336 64 ; ; : 19613 2336 65 ep ep ADD 19613 2336 66 . . . 19613 2337 1 73 73 CD 19613 2337 2 . . . 19613 2338 1 7 7 LS 19613 2338 2 ; ; : 19613 2338 3 " " `` 19613 2338 4 Petro petro JJ 19613 2338 5 primum primum JJ 19613 2338 6 dominus dominus NN 19613 2338 7 , , , 19613 2338 8 super super JJ 19613 2338 9 quem quem NNP 19613 2338 10 ædificavit ædificavit NNP 19613 2338 11 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 2338 12 et et NNP 19613 2338 13 unde unde NNP 19613 2338 14 unitatis unitatis NNP 19613 2338 15 originem originem NNP 19613 2338 16 instituit instituit NNP 19613 2338 17 et et NNP 19613 2338 18 ostendit ostendit NNP 19613 2338 19 , , , 19613 2338 20 potestatem potestatem NNP 19613 2338 21 istam istam NNP 19613 2338 22 dedit dedit NNP 19613 2338 23 . . . 19613 2338 24 " " '' 19613 2339 1 The the DT 19613 2339 2 most most RBS 19613 2339 3 emphatic emphatic JJ 19613 2339 4 passages passage NNS 19613 2339 5 are be VBP 19613 2339 6 ep ep NNP 19613 2339 7 . . . 19613 2340 1 48 48 CD 19613 2340 2 . . . 19613 2341 1 3 3 LS 19613 2341 2 , , , 19613 2341 3 where where WRB 19613 2341 4 the the DT 19613 2341 5 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2341 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2341 7 is be VBZ 19613 2341 8 called call VBN 19613 2341 9 " " `` 19613 2341 10 matrix matrix NNP 19613 2341 11 et et NNP 19613 2341 12 radix radix NNP 19613 2341 13 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2341 14 catholicæ catholicæ NNP 19613 2341 15 " " '' 19613 2341 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2341 17 the the DT 19613 2341 18 expression expression NN 19613 2341 19 " " `` 19613 2341 20 radix radix NNP 19613 2341 21 et et NNP 19613 2341 22 mater mater NN 19613 2341 23 " " '' 19613 2341 24 in in IN 19613 2341 25 ep ep NNP 19613 2341 26 . . . 19613 2342 1 45 45 CD 19613 2342 2 . . . 19613 2343 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 2343 2 no no RB 19613 2343 3 doubt doubt RB 19613 2343 4 also also RB 19613 2343 5 refers refer VBZ 19613 2343 6 to to IN 19613 2343 7 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2343 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2343 9 , , , 19613 2343 10 and and CC 19613 2343 11 ep ep NNP 19613 2343 12 . . . 19613 2344 1 59 59 CD 19613 2344 2 . . . 19613 2345 1 14 14 CD 19613 2345 2 : : : 19613 2345 3 " " `` 19613 2345 4 navigare navigare NNP 19613 2345 5 audent audent NNP 19613 2345 6 et et FW 19613 2345 7 ad ad NN 19613 2345 8 Petri Petri NNP 19613 2345 9 cathedram cathedram NN 19613 2345 10 atque atque NN 19613 2345 11 ad ad NN 19613 2345 12 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 2345 13 principalem principalem NNP 19613 2345 14 , , , 19613 2345 15 unde unde NNP 19613 2345 16 unitas unitas NNP 19613 2345 17 sacerdotalis sacerdotalis NNP 19613 2345 18 exorta exorta NNP 19613 2345 19 est est NNP 19613 2345 20 , , , 19613 2345 21 ab ab NNP 19613 2345 22 schismaticis schismaticis NNP 19613 2345 23 et et NNP 19613 2345 24 profanis profanis NNP 19613 2345 25 litteras litteras NNP 19613 2345 26 ferre ferre NNP 19613 2345 27 nec nec NNP 19613 2345 28 cogitare cogitare NNP 19613 2345 29 eos eos NNP 19613 2345 30 esse esse NNP 19613 2345 31 Romanes Romanes NNP 19613 2345 32 , , , 19613 2345 33 quorum quorum NN 19613 2345 34 fides fide VBZ 19613 2345 35 apostolo apostolo JJ 19613 2345 36 prædicante prædicante JJ 19613 2345 37 laudata laudata NNS 19613 2345 38 est est NNP 19613 2345 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2345 40 see see VB 19613 2345 41 epp epp NNP 19613 2345 42 . . . 19613 2346 1 30 30 CD 19613 2346 2 . . . 19613 2347 1 2 2 CD 19613 2347 2 , , , 19613 2347 3 3 3 CD 19613 2347 4 : : SYM 19613 2347 5 60 60 CD 19613 2347 6 . . . 19613 2348 1 2 2 LS 19613 2348 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2348 3 , , , 19613 2348 4 ad ad NN 19613 2348 5 quos quos NN 19613 2348 6 perfidia perfidia NN 19613 2348 7 habere habere NNP 19613 2348 8 non non AFX 19613 2348 9 possit possit NNP 19613 2348 10 accessum accessum NN 19613 2348 11 . . . 19613 2348 12 " " '' 19613 2349 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2349 2 can can MD 19613 2349 3 see see VB 19613 2349 4 most most RBS 19613 2349 5 clearly clearly RB 19613 2349 6 from from IN 19613 2349 7 epp epp NNP 19613 2349 8 . . . 19613 2350 1 67 67 CD 19613 2350 2 . . . 19613 2351 1 5 5 CD 19613 2351 2 and and CC 19613 2351 3 68 68 CD 19613 2351 4 what what WP 19613 2351 5 rights right NNS 19613 2351 6 were be VBD 19613 2351 7 in in IN 19613 2351 8 point point NN 19613 2351 9 of of IN 19613 2351 10 fact fact NN 19613 2351 11 exercised exercise VBN 19613 2351 12 by by IN 19613 2351 13 the the DT 19613 2351 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 2351 15 of of IN 19613 2351 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2351 17 . . . 19613 2352 1 But but CC 19613 2352 2 the the DT 19613 2352 3 same same JJ 19613 2352 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2352 5 says say VBZ 19613 2352 6 quite quite RB 19613 2352 7 naively naively RB 19613 2352 8 , , , 19613 2352 9 even even RB 19613 2352 10 at at IN 19613 2352 11 the the DT 19613 2352 12 time time NN 19613 2352 13 when when WRB 19613 2352 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2352 15 exalted exalt VBD 19613 2352 16 the the DT 19613 2352 17 Roman roman JJ 19613 2352 18 cathedra cathedra NNS 19613 2352 19 so so RB 19613 2352 20 highly highly RB 19613 2352 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2352 22 ep ep NNP 19613 2352 23 . . . 19613 2353 1 52 52 CD 19613 2353 2 . . . 19613 2354 1 2 2 LS 19613 2354 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2354 3 , , , 19613 2354 4 " " '' 19613 2354 5 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 2354 6 _ _ NNP 19613 2354 7 pro pro FW 19613 2354 8 magnitudine magnitudine NN 19613 2354 9 sua sua NNP 19613 2354 10 _ _ NNP 19613 2354 11 debeat debeat NN 19613 2354 12 Carthaginem Carthaginem NNP 19613 2354 13 Roma Roma NNP 19613 2354 14 præcedere præcedere NN 19613 2354 15 . . . 19613 2354 16 " " '' 19613 2355 1 In in IN 19613 2355 2 the the DT 19613 2355 3 controversy controversy NN 19613 2355 4 about about IN 19613 2355 5 heretical heretical JJ 19613 2355 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 2355 7 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2355 8 like like IN 19613 2355 9 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2355 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2355 11 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2355 12 . . NNP 19613 2355 13 , , , 19613 2355 14 de de NNP 19613 2355 15 pudic pudic NNP 19613 2355 16 . . . 19613 2356 1 1 1 LS 19613 2356 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2356 3 designated designate VBD 19613 2356 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2356 5 , , , 19613 2356 6 on on IN 19613 2356 7 the the DT 19613 2356 8 ground ground NN 19613 2356 9 of of IN 19613 2356 10 the the DT 19613 2356 11 _ _ NNP 19613 2356 12 successio successio NN 19613 2356 13 Petri Petri NNP 19613 2356 14 _ _ NNP 19613 2356 15 and and CC 19613 2356 16 by by IN 19613 2356 17 reference reference NN 19613 2356 18 to to IN 19613 2356 19 Matth Matth NNP 19613 2356 20 . . . 19613 2357 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 2357 2 . . NNP 19613 2357 3 , , , 19613 2357 4 in in IN 19613 2357 5 such such PDT 19613 2357 6 a a DT 19613 2357 7 way way NN 19613 2357 8 that that WDT 19613 2357 9 one one PRP 19613 2357 10 might may MD 19613 2357 11 suppose suppose VB 19613 2357 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2357 13 wished wish VBD 19613 2357 14 to to TO 19613 2357 15 be be VB 19613 2357 16 regarded regard VBN 19613 2357 17 as as IN 19613 2357 18 " " `` 19613 2357 19 episcopus episcopus NN 19613 2357 20 episcoporum episcoporum NN 19613 2357 21 " " '' 19613 2357 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2357 23 Sentent sentent NN 19613 2357 24 . . . 19613 2358 1 episc episc NNP 19613 2358 2 . . . 19613 2359 1 in in IN 19613 2359 2 Hartel Hartel NNP 19613 2359 3 I. I. NNP 19613 2359 4 , , , 19613 2359 5 p. p. NN 19613 2359 6 436 436 CD 19613 2359 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2359 8 . . . 19613 2360 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2360 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 2360 3 claimed claim VBD 19613 2360 4 a a DT 19613 2360 5 primacy primacy NN 19613 2360 6 and and CC 19613 2360 7 demanded demand VBD 19613 2360 8 obedience obedience NN 19613 2360 9 from from IN 19613 2360 10 the the DT 19613 2360 11 " " `` 19613 2360 12 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2360 13 novellæ novellæ NNP 19613 2360 14 et et NNP 19613 2360 15 posteræ posteræ NNP 19613 2360 16 " " '' 19613 2360 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2360 18 ep ep NNP 19613 2360 19 . . . 19613 2361 1 71 71 CD 19613 2361 2 . . . 19613 2362 1 3 3 LS 19613 2362 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2362 3 . . . 19613 2363 1 Like like IN 19613 2363 2 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2363 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2363 4 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 2363 5 to to TO 19613 2363 6 enforce enforce VB 19613 2363 7 the the DT 19613 2363 8 Roman roman JJ 19613 2363 9 practice practice NN 19613 2363 10 " " `` 19613 2363 11 tyrannico tyrannico NN 19613 2363 12 terrore terrore NN 19613 2363 13 " " '' 19613 2363 14 and and CC 19613 2363 15 insisted insist VBD 19613 2363 16 that that IN 19613 2363 17 the the DT 19613 2363 18 _ _ NNP 19613 2363 19 unitas unita VBZ 19613 2363 20 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2363 21 _ _ NNP 19613 2363 22 required require VBD 19613 2363 23 the the DT 19613 2363 24 observance observance NN 19613 2363 25 of of IN 19613 2363 26 this this DT 19613 2363 27 Church Church NNP 19613 2363 28 's 's POS 19613 2363 29 practice practice NN 19613 2363 30 in in IN 19613 2363 31 all all DT 19613 2363 32 communities community NNS 19613 2363 33 . . . 19613 2364 1 But but CC 19613 2364 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2364 3 opposed oppose VBD 19613 2364 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2364 5 in in IN 19613 2364 6 the the DT 19613 2364 7 most most RBS 19613 2364 8 decided decide VBN 19613 2364 9 fashion fashion NN 19613 2364 10 , , , 19613 2364 11 and and CC 19613 2364 12 maintained maintain VBD 19613 2364 13 the the DT 19613 2364 14 principle principle NN 19613 2364 15 that that IN 19613 2364 16 every every DT 19613 2364 17 bishop bishop NN 19613 2364 18 , , , 19613 2364 19 as as IN 19613 2364 20 a a DT 19613 2364 21 member member NN 19613 2364 22 of of IN 19613 2364 23 the the DT 19613 2364 24 episcopal episcopal NNP 19613 2364 25 confederation confederation NNP 19613 2364 26 based base VBN 19613 2364 27 on on IN 19613 2364 28 the the DT 19613 2364 29 _ _ NNP 19613 2364 30 regula regula NN 19613 2364 31 _ _ NNP 19613 2364 32 and and CC 19613 2364 33 the the DT 19613 2364 34 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2364 35 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 2364 36 , , , 19613 2364 37 is be VBZ 19613 2364 38 responsible responsible JJ 19613 2364 39 for for IN 19613 2364 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2364 41 practice practice NN 19613 2364 42 to to IN 19613 2364 43 God God NNP 19613 2364 44 alone alone JJ 19613 2364 45 . . . 19613 2365 1 This this DT 19613 2365 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2365 3 did do VBD 19613 2365 4 in in IN 19613 2365 5 a a DT 19613 2365 6 way way NN 19613 2365 7 which which WDT 19613 2365 8 left leave VBD 19613 2365 9 no no DT 19613 2365 10 room room NN 19613 2365 11 for for IN 19613 2365 12 any any DT 19613 2365 13 special special JJ 19613 2365 14 and and CC 19613 2365 15 actual actual JJ 19613 2365 16 authority authority NN 19613 2365 17 of of IN 19613 2365 18 the the DT 19613 2365 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2365 20 see see VBP 19613 2365 21 alongside alongside RB 19613 2365 22 of of IN 19613 2365 23 the the DT 19613 2365 24 others other NNS 19613 2365 25 . . . 19613 2366 1 Besides besides RB 19613 2366 2 , , , 19613 2366 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2366 4 expressly expressly RB 19613 2366 5 rejected reject VBD 19613 2366 6 the the DT 19613 2366 7 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 2366 8 drawn draw VBN 19613 2366 9 by by IN 19613 2366 10 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2366 11 from from IN 19613 2366 12 the the DT 19613 2366 13 admittedly admittedly RB 19613 2366 14 historical historical JJ 19613 2366 15 position position NN 19613 2366 16 of of IN 19613 2366 17 the the DT 19613 2366 18 Roman Roman NNPS 19613 2366 19 see see NN 19613 2366 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2366 21 ep ep NNP 19613 2366 22 . . . 19613 2367 1 71 71 CD 19613 2367 2 . . . 19613 2368 1 3 3 LS 19613 2368 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2368 3 : : : 19613 2368 4 " " `` 19613 2368 5 Petrus petrus VB 19613 2368 6 non non JJ 19613 2368 7 sibi sibi JJ 19613 2368 8 vindicavit vindicavit NN 19613 2368 9 aliquid aliquid NNP 19613 2368 10 insolenter insolenter NNP 19613 2368 11 aut aut NNP 19613 2368 12 adroganter adroganter NNP 19613 2368 13 adsumpsit adsumpsit NNP 19613 2368 14 , , , 19613 2368 15 ut ut UH 19613 2368 16 diceret diceret NNP 19613 2368 17 se se NNP 19613 2368 18 principatum principatum NNP 19613 2368 19 tenere tenere NNP 19613 2368 20 et et NNP 19613 2368 21 obtemperari obtemperari NNP 19613 2368 22 a a DT 19613 2368 23 novellis novellis NNP 19613 2368 24 et et NNP 19613 2368 25 posteris posteris NNP 19613 2368 26 sibi sibi NNP 19613 2368 27 potius potius NNP 19613 2368 28 oportere oportere NNP 19613 2368 29 . . . 19613 2368 30 " " '' 19613 2369 1 Firmilian Firmilian NNP 19613 2369 2 , , , 19613 2369 3 ep ep NNP 19613 2369 4 . . . 19613 2370 1 75 75 CD 19613 2370 2 , , , 19613 2370 3 went go VBD 19613 2370 4 much much RB 19613 2370 5 farther farther RB 19613 2370 6 still still RB 19613 2370 7 , , , 19613 2370 8 for for IN 19613 2370 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2370 10 indirectly indirectly RB 19613 2370 11 declares declare VBZ 19613 2370 12 the the DT 19613 2370 13 _ _ NNP 19613 2370 14 successio successio NN 19613 2370 15 Petri Petri NNP 19613 2370 16 _ _ NNP 19613 2370 17 claimed claim VBD 19613 2370 18 by by IN 19613 2370 19 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2370 20 to to TO 19613 2370 21 be be VB 19613 2370 22 of of IN 19613 2370 23 no no DT 19613 2370 24 importance importance NN 19613 2370 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2370 26 c. c. NNP 19613 2370 27 17 17 CD 19613 2370 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2370 29 , , , 19613 2370 30 and and CC 19613 2370 31 flatly flatly RB 19613 2370 32 denies deny VBZ 19613 2370 33 that that IN 19613 2370 34 the the DT 19613 2370 35 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2370 36 Church Church NNP 19613 2370 37 has have VBZ 19613 2370 38 preserved preserve VBN 19613 2370 39 the the DT 19613 2370 40 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2370 41 tradition tradition NN 19613 2370 42 in in IN 19613 2370 43 a a DT 19613 2370 44 specially specially RB 19613 2370 45 faithful faithful JJ 19613 2370 46 way way NN 19613 2370 47 . . . 19613 2371 1 See see VB 19613 2371 2 Otto Otto NNP 19613 2371 3 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 2371 4 , , , 19613 2371 5 l.c l.c NNP 19613 2371 6 . . NNP 19613 2371 7 , , , 19613 2371 8 pp pp NNP 19613 2371 9 . . . 19613 2372 1 92 92 CD 19613 2372 2 ff ff NN 19613 2372 3 . . NNP 19613 2372 4 , , , 19613 2372 5 110 110 CD 19613 2372 6 - - SYM 19613 2372 7 141 141 CD 19613 2372 8 . . . 19613 2373 1 In in IN 19613 2373 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2373 3 conflict conflict NN 19613 2373 4 with with IN 19613 2373 5 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2373 6 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2373 7 unmistakably unmistakably RB 19613 2373 8 took take VBD 19613 2373 9 up up RP 19613 2373 10 a a DT 19613 2373 11 position position NN 19613 2373 12 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 19613 2373 13 with with IN 19613 2373 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2373 15 former former JJ 19613 2373 16 views view NNS 19613 2373 17 as as IN 19613 2373 18 to to IN 19613 2373 19 the the DT 19613 2373 20 significance significance NN 19613 2373 21 of of IN 19613 2373 22 the the DT 19613 2373 23 Roman Roman NNPS 19613 2373 24 see see NN 19613 2373 25 for for IN 19613 2373 26 the the DT 19613 2373 27 Church Church NNP 19613 2373 28 , , , 19613 2373 29 though though IN 19613 2373 30 no no RB 19613 2373 31 doubt doubt RB 19613 2373 32 these these DT 19613 2373 33 were be VBD 19613 2373 34 ideas idea NNS 19613 2373 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2373 36 had have VBD 19613 2373 37 expressed express VBN 19613 2373 38 at at IN 19613 2373 39 a a DT 19613 2373 40 critical critical JJ 19613 2373 41 time time NN 19613 2373 42 when when WRB 19613 2373 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2373 44 stood stand VBD 19613 2373 45 shoulder shoulder NN 19613 2373 46 to to IN 19613 2373 47 shoulder shoulder VB 19613 2373 48 with with IN 19613 2373 49 the the DT 19613 2373 50 Roman roman JJ 19613 2373 51 bishop bishop NN 19613 2373 52 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 2373 53 . . . 19613 2373 54 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2374 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2374 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2374 3 180 180 CD 19613 2374 4 : : : 19613 2374 5 See see VB 19613 2374 6 specially specially RB 19613 2374 7 epp epp VB 19613 2374 8 . . . 19613 2375 1 65 65 CD 19613 2375 2 , , , 19613 2375 3 67 67 CD 19613 2375 4 , , , 19613 2375 5 68 68 CD 19613 2375 6 . . . 19613 2375 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2376 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2376 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2376 3 181 181 CD 19613 2376 4 : : : 19613 2376 5 Hatch Hatch NNP 19613 2376 6 l.c l.c NNP 19613 2376 7 . . NNP 19613 2376 8 , , , 19613 2376 9 p. p. NN 19613 2376 10 189 189 CD 19613 2376 11 f. f. NN 19613 2376 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2376 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2376 14 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2376 15 182 182 CD 19613 2376 16 : : : 19613 2376 17 The the DT 19613 2376 18 gradual gradual JJ 19613 2376 19 union union NN 19613 2376 20 of of IN 19613 2376 21 the the DT 19613 2376 22 provincial provincial JJ 19613 2376 23 communities community NNS 19613 2376 24 into into IN 19613 2376 25 one one CD 19613 2376 26 Church Church NNP 19613 2376 27 may may MD 19613 2376 28 be be VB 19613 2376 29 studied study VBN 19613 2376 30 in in IN 19613 2376 31 a a DT 19613 2376 32 very very RB 19613 2376 33 interesting interesting JJ 19613 2376 34 way way NN 19613 2376 35 in in IN 19613 2376 36 the the DT 19613 2376 37 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2376 38 Fasti Fasti NNP 19613 2376 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2376 40 records record NNS 19613 2376 41 , , , 19613 2376 42 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 19613 2376 43 , , , 19613 2376 44 calendars calendar NNS 19613 2376 45 , , , 19613 2376 46 etc etc FW 19613 2376 47 . . . 19613 2377 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2377 2 , , , 19613 2377 3 though though IN 19613 2377 4 these these DT 19613 2377 5 studies study NNS 19613 2377 6 are be VBP 19613 2377 7 as as RB 19613 2377 8 yet yet RB 19613 2377 9 only only RB 19613 2377 10 in in IN 19613 2377 11 an an DT 19613 2377 12 incipient incipient JJ 19613 2377 13 stage stage NN 19613 2377 14 . . . 19613 2378 1 See See NNP 19613 2378 2 De De NNP 19613 2378 3 Rossi Rossi NNP 19613 2378 4 , , , 19613 2378 5 Roma Roma NNP 19613 2378 6 Sotter Sotter NNP 19613 2378 7 , , , 19613 2378 8 the the DT 19613 2378 9 Bollandists Bollandists NNPS 19613 2378 10 in in IN 19613 2378 11 the the DT 19613 2378 12 12th 12th JJ 19613 2378 13 vol vol NN 19613 2378 14 . . . 19613 2379 1 for for IN 19613 2379 2 October October NNP 19613 2379 3 ; ; : 19613 2379 4 Stevenson Stevenson NNP 19613 2379 5 , , , 19613 2379 6 Studi Studi NNP 19613 2379 7 in in IN 19613 2379 8 Italia Italia NNP 19613 2379 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2379 10 1879 1879 CD 19613 2379 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2379 12 , , , 19613 2379 13 pp pp NNP 19613 2379 14 . . . 19613 2380 1 439 439 CD 19613 2380 2 , , , 19613 2380 3 458 458 CD 19613 2380 4 ; ; : 19613 2380 5 the the DT 19613 2380 6 works work NNS 19613 2380 7 of of IN 19613 2380 8 Nilles Nilles NNPS 19613 2380 9 ; ; : 19613 2380 10 Egli Egli NNP 19613 2380 11 , , , 19613 2380 12 Altchristl Altchristl NNP 19613 2380 13 . . . 19613 2381 1 Studien Studien NNP 19613 2381 2 1887 1887 CD 19613 2381 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2381 4 Theol Theol NNP 19613 2381 5 . . . 19613 2382 1 Lit Lit NNP 19613 2382 2 . . . 19613 2383 1 Ztg Ztg NNP 19613 2383 2 . . . 19613 2384 1 1887 1887 CD 19613 2384 2 , , , 19613 2384 3 no no UH 19613 2384 4 . . . 19613 2385 1 13 13 CD 19613 2385 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2385 3 : : : 19613 2385 4 Duchesne duchesne VB 19613 2385 5 , , , 19613 2385 6 Les Les NNP 19613 2385 7 sources source NNS 19613 2385 8 du du NNP 19613 2385 9 Martyrol Martyrol NNP 19613 2385 10 . . . 19613 2386 1 Hieron Hieron NNP 19613 2386 2 . . . 19613 2387 1 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2387 2 1885 1885 CD 19613 2387 3 , , , 19613 2387 4 but but CC 19613 2387 5 above above IN 19613 2387 6 all all PDT 19613 2387 7 the the DT 19613 2387 8 latter latter NN 19613 2387 9 's 's POS 19613 2387 10 study study NN 19613 2387 11 : : : 19613 2387 12 Mémoire mémoire VB 19613 2387 13 sur sur FW 19613 2387 14 l'origine l'origine FW 19613 2387 15 des des FW 19613 2387 16 diocèses diocèse VBZ 19613 2387 17 épiscopaux épiscopaux NNP 19613 2387 18 dans dan NNS 19613 2387 19 l'ancienne l'ancienne NNP 19613 2387 20 Gaule Gaule NNP 19613 2387 21 , , , 19613 2387 22 1890 1890 CD 19613 2387 23 . . . 19613 2388 1 The the DT 19613 2388 2 history history NN 19613 2388 3 of of IN 19613 2388 4 the the DT 19613 2388 5 unification unification NN 19613 2388 6 of of IN 19613 2388 7 liturgies liturgy NNS 19613 2388 8 from from IN 19613 2388 9 the the DT 19613 2388 10 4th 4th JJ 19613 2388 11 century century NN 19613 2388 12 should should MD 19613 2388 13 also also RB 19613 2388 14 be be VB 19613 2388 15 studied study VBN 19613 2388 16 . . . 19613 2388 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2389 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2389 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2389 3 183 183 CD 19613 2389 4 : : : 19613 2389 5 There there EX 19613 2389 6 were be VBD 19613 2389 7 communities community NNS 19613 2389 8 in in IN 19613 2389 9 the the DT 19613 2389 10 latter latter JJ 19613 2389 11 half half NN 19613 2389 12 of of IN 19613 2389 13 the the DT 19613 2389 14 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 2389 15 century century NN 19613 2389 16 , , , 19613 2389 17 which which WDT 19613 2389 18 can can MD 19613 2389 19 be be VB 19613 2389 20 proved prove VBN 19613 2389 21 to to TO 19613 2389 22 have have VB 19613 2389 23 been be VBN 19613 2389 24 outside outside IN 19613 2389 25 the the DT 19613 2389 26 confederation confederation NN 19613 2389 27 , , , 19613 2389 28 although although IN 19613 2389 29 in in IN 19613 2389 30 perfect perfect JJ 19613 2389 31 harmony harmony NN 19613 2389 32 with with IN 19613 2389 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2389 34 in in IN 19613 2389 35 point point NN 19613 2389 36 of of IN 19613 2389 37 belief belief NN 19613 2389 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2389 39 see see VB 19613 2389 40 the the DT 19613 2389 41 interesting interesting JJ 19613 2389 42 case case NN 19613 2389 43 in in IN 19613 2389 44 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2389 45 . . NNP 19613 2389 46 , , , 19613 2389 47 H. H. NNP 19613 2389 48 E. E. NNP 19613 2389 49 VII VII NNP 19613 2389 50 . . . 19613 2390 1 24 24 CD 19613 2390 2 . . . 19613 2391 1 6 6 LS 19613 2391 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2391 3 . . . 19613 2392 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 2392 2 , , , 19613 2392 3 there there EX 19613 2392 4 were be VBD 19613 2392 5 Churches church NNS 19613 2392 6 in in IN 19613 2392 7 the the DT 19613 2392 8 confederation confederation NN 19613 2392 9 whose whose WP$ 19613 2392 10 faith faith NN 19613 2392 11 did do VBD 19613 2392 12 not not RB 19613 2392 13 in in IN 19613 2392 14 all all DT 19613 2392 15 respects respect NNS 19613 2392 16 correspond correspond VB 19613 2392 17 with with IN 19613 2392 18 the the DT 19613 2392 19 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2392 20 _ _ NNP 19613 2392 21 regula regula NN 19613 2392 22 _ _ NNP 19613 2392 23 as as RB 19613 2392 24 already already RB 19613 2392 25 expounded expound VBN 19613 2392 26 . . . 19613 2393 1 But but CC 19613 2393 2 the the DT 19613 2393 3 fact fact NN 19613 2393 4 that that IN 19613 2393 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2393 6 was be VBD 19613 2393 7 not not RB 19613 2393 8 the the DT 19613 2393 9 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 2393 10 system system NN 19613 2393 11 , , , 19613 2393 12 but but CC 19613 2393 13 the the DT 19613 2393 14 practical practical JJ 19613 2393 15 constitution constitution NN 19613 2393 16 and and CC 19613 2393 17 principles principle NNS 19613 2393 18 of of IN 19613 2393 19 the the DT 19613 2393 20 Church Church NNP 19613 2393 21 , , , 19613 2393 22 as as IN 19613 2393 23 based base VBN 19613 2393 24 on on IN 19613 2393 25 a a DT 19613 2393 26 still still RB 19613 2393 27 elastic elastic JJ 19613 2393 28 creed creed NN 19613 2393 29 , , , 19613 2393 30 which which WDT 19613 2393 31 formed form VBD 19613 2393 32 the the DT 19613 2393 33 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 2393 34 determining determine VBG 19613 2393 35 factor factor NN 19613 2393 36 , , , 19613 2393 37 was be VBD 19613 2393 38 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 2393 39 a a DT 19613 2393 40 great great JJ 19613 2393 41 gain gain NN 19613 2393 42 ; ; : 19613 2393 43 for for IN 19613 2393 44 a a DT 19613 2393 45 system system NN 19613 2393 46 of of IN 19613 2393 47 dogmatics dogmatic NNS 19613 2393 48 developed develop VBD 19613 2393 49 beyond beyond IN 19613 2393 50 the the DT 19613 2393 51 limits limit NNS 19613 2393 52 of of IN 19613 2393 53 the the DT 19613 2393 54 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2393 55 _ _ NNP 19613 2393 56 kerygma kerygma NNP 19613 2393 57 _ _ NNP 19613 2393 58 can can MD 19613 2393 59 only only RB 19613 2393 60 separate separate VB 19613 2393 61 . . . 19613 2394 1 Here here RB 19613 2394 2 , , , 19613 2394 3 however however RB 19613 2394 4 , , , 19613 2394 5 all all DT 19613 2394 6 differences difference NNS 19613 2394 7 of of IN 19613 2394 8 faith faith NN 19613 2394 9 had have VBD 19613 2394 10 of of IN 19613 2394 11 couise couise NN 19613 2394 12 to to TO 19613 2394 13 be be VB 19613 2394 14 glossed gloss VBN 19613 2394 15 over over RP 19613 2394 16 , , , 19613 2394 17 for for IN 19613 2394 18 the the DT 19613 2394 19 demand demand NN 19613 2394 20 of of IN 19613 2394 21 Apelles apelle NNS 19613 2394 22 : : : 19613 2394 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2394 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2394 25 : : : 19613 2394 26 mê mê NNP 19613 2394 27 dein dein NNP 19613 2394 28 holôs holôs NNP 19613 2394 29 exetazein exetazein NNP 19613 2394 30 ton ton NNP 19613 2394 31 logon logon NNP 19613 2394 32 , , , 19613 2394 33 all all DT 19613 2394 34 ' ' '' 19613 2394 35 ekaston ekaston NNP 19613 2394 36 . . . 19613 2395 1 hôs hôs NNP 19613 2395 2 pepisteuke pepisteuke NNP 19613 2395 3 , , , 19613 2395 4 diamenein diamenein NNP 19613 2395 5 sôthêsesthai sôthêsesthai NNP 19613 2395 6 gar gar NNP 19613 2395 7 tous tous NNP 19613 2395 8 epi epi NNP 19613 2395 9 ton ton NNP 19613 2395 10 hestaurômenon hestaurômenon NNP 19613 2395 11 êlpikotas êlpikotas NNP 19613 2395 12 , , , 19613 2395 13 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 2395 14 . . . 19613 2396 1 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2396 2 , , , 19613 2396 3 was be VBD 19613 2396 4 naturally naturally RB 19613 2396 5 regarded regard VBN 19613 2396 6 as as IN 19613 2396 7 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 19613 2396 8 . . . 19613 2396 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2397 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2397 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2397 3 184 184 CD 19613 2397 4 : : : 19613 2397 5 Hence hence RB 19613 2397 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2397 7 need need VBP 19613 2397 8 not not RB 19613 2397 9 be be VB 19613 2397 10 surprised surprised JJ 19613 2397 11 to to TO 19613 2397 12 find find VB 19613 2397 13 that that IN 19613 2397 14 the the DT 19613 2397 15 notion notion NN 19613 2397 16 of of IN 19613 2397 17 heresy heresy NN 19613 2397 18 which which WDT 19613 2397 19 arose arise VBD 19613 2397 20 in in IN 19613 2397 21 the the DT 19613 2397 22 Church Church NNP 19613 2397 23 was be VBD 19613 2397 24 immediately immediately RB 19613 2397 25 coupled couple VBN 19613 2397 26 with with IN 19613 2397 27 an an DT 19613 2397 28 estimate estimate NN 19613 2397 29 of of IN 19613 2397 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2397 31 , , , 19613 2397 32 which which WDT 19613 2397 33 for for IN 19613 2397 34 injustice injustice NN 19613 2397 35 and and CC 19613 2397 36 harshness harshness NN 19613 2397 37 could could MD 19613 2397 38 not not RB 19613 2397 39 possibly possibly RB 19613 2397 40 be be VB 19613 2397 41 surpassed surpass VBN 19613 2397 42 in in IN 19613 2397 43 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 2397 44 times time NNS 19613 2397 45 . . . 19613 2398 1 The the DT 19613 2398 2 best good JJS 19613 2398 3 definition definition NN 19613 2398 4 is be VBZ 19613 2398 5 in in IN 19613 2398 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2398 7 . . NNP 19613 2398 8 , , , 19613 2398 9 de de NNP 19613 2398 10 præscr præscr NNP 19613 2398 11 . . . 19613 2399 1 6 6 CD 19613 2399 2 : : : 19613 2399 3 " " `` 19613 2399 4 Nobis Nobis NNP 19613 2399 5 nihil nihil NNP 19613 2399 6 ex ex NNP 19613 2399 7 nostro nostro NNP 19613 2399 8 arbitrio arbitrio NNP 19613 2399 9 indulgere indulgere NNP 19613 2399 10 licet licet NNP 19613 2399 11 , , , 19613 2399 12 sed se VBD 19613 2399 13 nec nec NNP 19613 2399 14 eligere eligere NNP 19613 2399 15 quod quod NNP 19613 2399 16 aliquis aliquis NNP 19613 2399 17 de de NNP 19613 2399 18 arbitrio arbitrio NNP 19613 2399 19 suo suo NNP 19613 2399 20 induxerit induxerit NNP 19613 2399 21 . . . 19613 2400 1 Apostolos apostolo NNS 19613 2400 2 domini domini IN 19613 2400 3 habemus habemus NN 19613 2400 4 auctores auctore NNS 19613 2400 5 , , , 19613 2400 6 qui qui NNP 19613 2400 7 nec nec NNP 19613 2400 8 ipsi ipsi NNP 19613 2400 9 quicquam quicquam NNP 19613 2400 10 ex ex NNP 19613 2400 11 suo suo NNP 19613 2400 12 arbitrio arbitrio NNP 19613 2400 13 quod quod NNP 19613 2400 14 inducerent inducerent NNP 19613 2400 15 elegerunt elegerunt NNP 19613 2400 16 , , , 19613 2400 17 sed sed NNP 19613 2400 18 acceptam acceptam NNP 19613 2400 19 a a DT 19613 2400 20 Christo Christo NNP 19613 2400 21 disciplinam disciplinam NN 19613 2400 22 fideliter fideliter NN 19613 2400 23 nationibus nationibus NNP 19613 2400 24 assignaverunt assignaverunt NNP 19613 2400 25 . . . 19613 2400 26 " " '' 19613 2400 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2401 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2401 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2401 3 185 185 CD 19613 2401 4 : : : 19613 2401 5 See see VB 19613 2401 6 Vol Vol NNP 19613 2401 7 . . . 19613 2402 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2402 2 , , , 19613 2402 3 p. p. NN 19613 2402 4 224 224 CD 19613 2402 5 , , , 19613 2402 6 note note VB 19613 2402 7 1 1 CD 19613 2402 8 . . . 19613 2402 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2403 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2403 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 2403 3 186 186 CD 19613 2403 4 : : : 19613 2403 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2403 6 already already RB 19613 2403 7 find find VBP 19613 2403 8 this this DT 19613 2403 9 idea idea NN 19613 2403 10 in in IN 19613 2403 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2403 12 ; ; : 19613 2403 13 see see VB 19613 2403 14 de de FW 19613 2403 15 bapt bapt NNP 19613 2403 16 . . . 19613 2404 1 15 15 CD 19613 2404 2 : : : 19613 2404 3 " " `` 19613 2404 4 Hæretici Hæretici NNP 19613 2404 5 nullum nullum NN 19613 2404 6 habent habent NNP 19613 2404 7 consortium consortium NNP 19613 2404 8 nostra nostra NNP 19613 2404 9 discipline discipline NN 19613 2404 10 , , , 19613 2404 11 quos quos NNP 19613 2404 12 extraneos extraneos NNP 19613 2404 13 utique utique NNP 19613 2404 14 testatur testatur NNP 19613 2404 15 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 2404 16 ademptio ademptio NNP 19613 2404 17 communicationis communicationis NNP 19613 2404 18 . . . 19613 2405 1 Non non JJ 19613 2405 2 debeo debeo NN 19613 2405 3 in in IN 19613 2405 4 illis illis NNP 19613 2405 5 cognoscere cognoscere NNP 19613 2405 6 , , , 19613 2405 7 quod quod NNP 19613 2405 8 mihi mihi NN 19613 2405 9 est est NNP 19613 2405 10 præceptum præceptum NN 19613 2405 11 , , , 19613 2405 12 quia quia NNP 19613 2405 13 non non AFX 19613 2405 14 idem idem NN 19613 2405 15 deus deus NNP 19613 2405 16 est est NNP 19613 2405 17 nobis nobis NNP 19613 2405 18 et et NNP 19613 2405 19 illis illis NNP 19613 2405 20 , , , 19613 2405 21 nec nec NNP 19613 2405 22 unus unus JJ 19613 2405 23 Christus Christus NNP 19613 2405 24 , , , 19613 2405 25 i -PRON- PRP 19613 2405 26 d d VBD 19613 2405 27 est est NNP 19613 2405 28 idem idem NNP 19613 2405 29 , , , 19613 2405 30 ideoque ideoque NNP 19613 2405 31 nec nec NNP 19613 2405 32 baptismus baptismus NNP 19613 2405 33 unus unus NNP 19613 2405 34 , , , 19613 2405 35 quia quia NNP 19613 2405 36 non non AFX 19613 2405 37 idem idem NN 19613 2405 38 ; ; : 19613 2405 39 quem quem NNP 19613 2405 40 cum cum NNP 19613 2405 41 rite rite NNP 19613 2405 42 non non AFX 19613 2405 43 habeant habeant JJ 19613 2405 44 , , , 19613 2405 45 sine sine VB 19613 2405 46 dubio dubio NNP 19613 2405 47 non non AFX 19613 2405 48 habent habent NNP 19613 2405 49 , , , 19613 2405 50 nec nec NNP 19613 2405 51 capit capit NNP 19613 2405 52 numerari numerari NNP 19613 2405 53 , , , 19613 2405 54 quod quod NN 19613 2405 55 non non AFX 19613 2405 56 habetur habetur NNP 19613 2405 57 ; ; : 19613 2405 58 ita ita NNP 19613 2405 59 nec nec NNP 19613 2405 60 possunt possunt NNP 19613 2405 61 accipere accipere NNP 19613 2405 62 quia quia NNP 19613 2405 63 non non AFX 19613 2405 64 habent habent NNP 19613 2405 65 . . . 19613 2405 66 " " '' 19613 2406 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2406 2 passed pass VBD 19613 2406 3 the the DT 19613 2406 4 same same JJ 19613 2406 5 judgment judgment NN 19613 2406 6 on on IN 19613 2406 7 all all DT 19613 2406 8 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 2406 9 , , , 19613 2406 10 even even RB 19613 2406 11 on on IN 19613 2406 12 the the DT 19613 2406 13 Novatians Novatians NNPS 19613 2406 14 , , , 19613 2406 15 and and CC 19613 2406 16 like like IN 19613 2406 17 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2406 18 maintained maintain VBD 19613 2406 19 the the DT 19613 2406 20 invalidity invalidity NN 19613 2406 21 of of IN 19613 2406 22 heretical heretical JJ 19613 2406 23 baptism baptism NN 19613 2406 24 . . . 19613 2407 1 This this DT 19613 2407 2 question question NN 19613 2407 3 agitated agitate VBD 19613 2407 4 the the DT 19613 2407 5 Church Church NNP 19613 2407 6 as as RB 19613 2407 7 early early RB 19613 2407 8 as as IN 19613 2407 9 the the DT 19613 2407 10 end end NN 19613 2407 11 of of IN 19613 2407 12 the the DT 19613 2407 13 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 2407 14 century century NN 19613 2407 15 , , , 19613 2407 16 when when WRB 19613 2407 17 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2407 18 already already RB 19613 2407 19 wrote write VBD 19613 2407 20 against against IN 19613 2407 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2407 22 in in IN 19613 2407 23 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2407 24 . . . 19613 2407 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2408 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2408 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2408 3 187 187 CD 19613 2408 4 : : : 19613 2408 5 As as RB 19613 2408 6 far far RB 19613 2408 7 as as IN 19613 2408 8 possible possible JJ 19613 2408 9 the the DT 19613 2408 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 2408 11 virtues virtue NNS 19613 2408 12 of of IN 19613 2408 13 the the DT 19613 2408 14 heretics heretic NNS 19613 2408 15 were be VBD 19613 2408 16 described describe VBN 19613 2408 17 as as IN 19613 2408 18 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 19613 2408 19 and and CC 19613 2408 20 love love NN 19613 2408 21 of of IN 19613 2408 22 ostentation ostentation NN 19613 2408 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2408 24 see see VB 19613 2408 25 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 2408 26 , , , 19613 2408 27 Rhodon Rhodon NNP 19613 2408 28 in in IN 19613 2408 29 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2408 30 . . NNP 19613 2408 31 , , , 19613 2408 32 H. H. NNP 19613 2408 33 E. E. NNP 19613 2408 34 V. V. NNP 19613 2408 35 13 13 CD 19613 2408 36 . . . 19613 2409 1 2 2 CD 19613 2409 2 and and CC 19613 2409 3 others other NNS 19613 2409 4 in in IN 19613 2409 5 the the DT 19613 2409 6 second second JJ 19613 2409 7 century century NN 19613 2409 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2409 9 . . . 19613 2410 1 If if IN 19613 2410 2 this this DT 19613 2410 3 view view NN 19613 2410 4 was be VBD 19613 2410 5 untenable untenable JJ 19613 2410 6 , , , 19613 2410 7 then then RB 19613 2410 8 all all DT 19613 2410 9 morality morality NN 19613 2410 10 and and CC 19613 2410 11 heroism heroism NN 19613 2410 12 among among IN 19613 2410 13 heretics heretic NNS 19613 2410 14 were be VBD 19613 2410 15 simply simply RB 19613 2410 16 declared declare VBN 19613 2410 17 to to TO 19613 2410 18 be be VB 19613 2410 19 of of IN 19613 2410 20 no no DT 19613 2410 21 value value NN 19613 2410 22 . . . 19613 2411 1 See see VB 19613 2411 2 the the DT 19613 2411 3 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 2411 4 writer writer NN 19613 2411 5 in in IN 19613 2411 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 2411 7 , , , 19613 2411 8 H. H. NNP 19613 2411 9 E. E. NNP 19613 2411 10 V. V. NNP 19613 2411 11 16 16 CD 19613 2411 12 . . . 19613 2412 1 21 21 CD 19613 2412 2 , , , 19613 2412 3 22 22 CD 19613 2412 4 ; ; : 19613 2412 5 Clem Clem NNP 19613 2412 6 , , , 19613 2412 7 Strom Strom NNP 19613 2412 8 . . . 19613 2413 1 VII VII NNP 19613 2413 2 . . . 19613 2414 1 16 16 CD 19613 2414 2 . . . 19613 2415 1 95 95 CD 19613 2415 2 ; ; : 19613 2415 3 Orig Orig NNP 19613 2415 4 . . . 19613 2415 5 , , , 19613 2415 6 Comm Comm NNP 19613 2415 7 . . . 19613 2416 1 ad ad NN 19613 2416 2 Rom rom NN 19613 2416 3 . . . 19613 2417 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2417 2 X. X. NNP 19613 2417 3 , , , 19613 2417 4 c. c. NNP 19613 2417 5 5 5 CD 19613 2417 6 ; ; : 19613 2417 7 Cypr Cypr NNP 19613 2417 8 . . . 19613 2417 9 , , , 19613 2417 10 de de NNP 19613 2417 11 unit unit NN 19613 2417 12 . . . 19613 2418 1 14 14 CD 19613 2418 2 , , , 19613 2418 3 15 15 CD 19613 2418 4 ; ; : 19613 2418 5 cp cp NNP 19613 2418 6 . . . 19613 2419 1 73 73 CD 19613 2419 2 . . . 19613 2420 1 21 21 CD 19613 2420 2 etc etc FW 19613 2420 3 . . . 19613 2420 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2421 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2421 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2421 3 188 188 CD 19613 2421 4 : : : 19613 2421 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2421 6 . . NNP 19613 2421 7 , , , 19613 2421 8 de de NNP 19613 2421 9 præscr præscr NNP 19613 2421 10 . . . 19613 2422 1 3 3 CD 19613 2422 2 - - SYM 19613 2422 3 6 6 CD 19613 2422 4 . . . 19613 2422 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2423 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2423 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2423 3 189 189 CD 19613 2423 4 : : : 19613 2423 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2423 6 definitely definitely RB 19613 2423 7 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 2423 8 between between IN 19613 2423 9 heretics heretic NNS 19613 2423 10 and and CC 19613 2423 11 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 2423 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2423 13 III iii CD 19613 2423 14 . . . 19613 2424 1 11 11 CD 19613 2424 2 . . . 19613 2425 1 9 9 LS 19613 2425 2 : : : 19613 2425 3 IV IV NNP 19613 2425 4 . . . 19613 2426 1 26 26 CD 19613 2426 2 . . . 19613 2427 1 2 2 CD 19613 2427 2 ; ; : 19613 2427 3 33 33 CD 19613 2427 4 . . . 19613 2428 1 7 7 LS 19613 2428 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2428 3 , , , 19613 2428 4 but but CC 19613 2428 5 also also RB 19613 2428 6 blames blame VBZ 19613 2428 7 the the DT 19613 2428 8 latter latter JJ 19613 2428 9 very very RB 19613 2428 10 severely severely RB 19613 2428 11 , , , 19613 2428 12 " " '' 19613 2428 13 qui qui VBD 19613 2428 14 gloriosum gloriosum NNP 19613 2428 15 corpus corpus NN 19613 2428 16 Christi Christi NNP 19613 2428 17 , , , 19613 2428 18 quantum quantum NN 19613 2428 19 in in IN 19613 2428 20 ipsis ipsis NN 19613 2428 21 est est NNP 19613 2428 22 , , , 19613 2428 23 interficiunt interficiunt VB 19613 2428 24 , , , 19613 2428 25 non non NNP 19613 2428 26 habentes habente NNS 19613 2428 27 dei dei NNP 19613 2428 28 dilectionem dilectionem NNP 19613 2428 29 suamque suamque NNP 19613 2428 30 utilitatem utilitatem NNP 19613 2428 31 potius potius NNP 19613 2428 32 considerantes considerante VBZ 19613 2428 33 quam quam NNP 19613 2428 34 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 2428 35 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2428 36 . . . 19613 2428 37 " " '' 19613 2429 1 Note note VB 19613 2429 2 the the DT 19613 2429 3 parallel parallel NN 19613 2429 4 with with IN 19613 2429 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2429 6 . . . 19613 2430 1 Yet yet CC 19613 2430 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2430 3 does do VBZ 19613 2430 4 not not RB 19613 2430 5 class class VB 19613 2430 6 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2430 7 with with IN 19613 2430 8 those those DT 19613 2430 9 " " `` 19613 2430 10 qui qui NN 19613 2430 11 sunt sunt NN 19613 2430 12 extra extra JJ 19613 2430 13 veritatem veritatem NN 19613 2430 14 , , , 19613 2430 15 " " '' 19613 2430 16 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2430 17 , , , 19613 2430 18 " " `` 19613 2430 19 extra extra JJ 19613 2430 20 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 2430 21 , , , 19613 2430 22 " " '' 19613 2430 23 although although IN 19613 2430 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2430 25 declares declare VBZ 19613 2430 26 the the DT 19613 2430 27 severest severe JJS 19613 2430 28 penalties penalty NNS 19613 2430 29 await await VBP 19613 2430 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2430 31 . . . 19613 2431 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2431 2 was be VBD 19613 2431 3 completely completely RB 19613 2431 4 preserved preserve VBN 19613 2431 5 by by IN 19613 2431 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2431 7 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 2431 8 from from IN 19613 2431 9 identifying identify VBG 19613 2431 10 heretics heretic NNS 19613 2431 11 and and CC 19613 2431 12 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 2431 13 , , , 19613 2431 14 though though IN 19613 2431 15 in in IN 19613 2431 16 the the DT 19613 2431 17 last last JJ 19613 2431 18 years year NNS 19613 2431 19 of of IN 19613 2431 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2431 21 life life NN 19613 2431 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2431 23 also also RB 19613 2431 24 appears appear VBZ 19613 2431 25 to to TO 19613 2431 26 have have VB 19613 2431 27 denied deny VBN 19613 2431 28 the the DT 19613 2431 29 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2431 30 of of IN 19613 2431 31 the the DT 19613 2431 32 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 2431 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2431 34 ? ? . 19613 2431 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2431 36 . . . 19613 2431 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2432 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2432 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2432 3 190 190 CD 19613 2432 4 : : : 19613 2432 5 Read read VB 19613 2432 6 , , , 19613 2432 7 on on IN 19613 2432 8 the the DT 19613 2432 9 one one CD 19613 2432 10 hand hand NN 19613 2432 11 , , , 19613 2432 12 the the DT 19613 2432 13 Antimontanists Antimontanists NNPS 19613 2432 14 in in IN 19613 2432 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 2432 16 and and CC 19613 2432 17 the the DT 19613 2432 18 later later JJ 19613 2432 19 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2432 20 of of IN 19613 2432 21 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 2432 22 ; ; : 19613 2432 23 and and CC 19613 2432 24 on on IN 19613 2432 25 the the DT 19613 2432 26 other other JJ 19613 2432 27 , , , 19613 2432 28 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2432 29 . . NNP 19613 2432 30 , , , 19613 2432 31 adv adv NNP 19613 2432 32 . . . 19613 2433 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 2433 2 . . . 19613 2434 1 ; ; : 19613 2434 2 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 2434 3 . . . 19613 2434 4 , , , 19613 2434 5 c. c. NN 19613 2434 6 Noët Noët NNP 19613 2434 7 ; ; : 19613 2434 8 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2434 9 , , , 19613 2434 10 de de FW 19613 2434 11 trinitate trinitate NNP 19613 2434 12 . . . 19613 2435 1 Even even RB 19613 2435 2 in in IN 19613 2435 3 the the DT 19613 2435 4 case case NN 19613 2435 5 of of IN 19613 2435 6 the the DT 19613 2435 7 Novatians Novatians NNP 19613 2435 8 heresies heresy NNS 19613 2435 9 were be VBD 19613 2435 10 sought seek VBN 19613 2435 11 and and CC 19613 2435 12 found find VBN 19613 2435 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2435 14 see see VB 19613 2435 15 Dionys dionys NN 19613 2435 16 . . . 19613 2436 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 2436 2 . . . 19613 2436 3 , , , 19613 2436 4 in in IN 19613 2436 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2436 6 . . NNP 19613 2436 7 , , , 19613 2436 8 H. H. NNP 19613 2436 9 E. E. NNP 19613 2436 10 VII VII NNP 19613 2436 11 . . . 19613 2437 1 8 8 LS 19613 2437 2 , , , 19613 2437 3 where where WRB 19613 2437 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2437 5 find find VBP 19613 2437 6 distortions distortion NNS 19613 2437 7 and and CC 19613 2437 8 wicked wicked JJ 19613 2437 9 misinterpretations misinterpretation NNS 19613 2437 10 of of IN 19613 2437 11 Novatian novatian JJ 19613 2437 12 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 2437 13 , , , 19613 2437 14 and and CC 19613 2437 15 many many JJ 19613 2437 16 later later JJ 19613 2437 17 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2437 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2437 19 . . . 19613 2438 1 Nay nay UH 19613 2438 2 , , , 19613 2438 3 even even RB 19613 2438 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2438 5 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2438 6 did do VBD 19613 2438 7 not not RB 19613 2438 8 disdain disdain VB 19613 2438 9 to to TO 19613 2438 10 join join VB 19613 2438 11 in in IN 19613 2438 12 this this DT 19613 2438 13 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 2438 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2438 15 see see VB 19613 2438 16 epp epp NNP 19613 2438 17 . . . 19613 2439 1 69 69 CD 19613 2439 2 . . . 19613 2440 1 7 7 CD 19613 2440 2 : : SYM 19613 2440 3 70 70 CD 19613 2440 4 . . . 19613 2441 1 2 2 LS 19613 2441 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2441 3 . . . 19613 2442 1 The the DT 19613 2442 2 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2442 3 at at IN 19613 2442 4 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2442 5 were be VBD 19613 2442 6 placed place VBN 19613 2442 7 by by IN 19613 2442 8 Hippolylus Hippolylus NNP 19613 2442 9 in in IN 19613 2442 10 the the DT 19613 2442 11 catalogue catalogue NN 19613 2442 12 of of IN 19613 2442 13 heretics heretics NNP 19613 2442 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2442 15 see see VB 19613 2442 16 the the DT 19613 2442 17 Syntagma Syntagma NNP 19613 2442 18 and and CC 19613 2442 19 Philosoph Philosoph NNP 19613 2442 20 . . . 19613 2442 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2442 22 . . . 19613 2443 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2443 2 was be VBD 19613 2443 3 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 2443 4 whether whether IN 19613 2443 5 to to TO 19613 2443 6 reckon reckon VB 19613 2443 7 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2443 8 among among IN 19613 2443 9 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 2443 10 or or CC 19613 2443 11 heretics heretic NNS 19613 2443 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2443 13 see see VB 19613 2443 14 in in IN 19613 2443 15 Tit Tit NNP 19613 2443 16 . . . 19613 2444 1 Opp Opp NNP 19613 2444 2 . . . 19613 2445 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2445 2 . . NNP 19613 2445 3 , , , 19613 2445 4 p. p. NN 19613 2446 1 696 696 CD 19613 2446 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2446 3 . . . 19613 2446 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2447 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2447 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2447 3 191 191 CD 19613 2447 4 : : : 19613 2447 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2447 6 plainly plainly RB 19613 2447 7 asserts assert VBZ 19613 2447 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2447 9 ep ep NNP 19613 2447 10 . . . 19613 2448 1 3 3 LS 19613 2448 2 . . . 19613 2449 1 3 3 LS 19613 2449 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2449 3 : : : 19613 2449 4 " " `` 19613 2449 5 hæc hæc NNP 19613 2449 6 sunt sunt NNP 19613 2449 7 initia initia NNP 19613 2449 8 hæreticorum hæreticorum NNP 19613 2449 9 et et NNP 19613 2449 10 ortus ortus NNP 19613 2449 11 adque adque NNP 19613 2449 12 conatus conatus NNP 19613 2449 13 schismaticorum schismaticorum NNP 19613 2449 14 , , , 19613 2449 15 ut ut NNP 19613 2449 16 præpositum præpositum NNP 19613 2449 17 superbo superbo JJ 19613 2449 18 tumore tumore NN 19613 2449 19 contemnant contemnant NN 19613 2449 20 " " '' 19613 2449 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2449 22 as as IN 19613 2449 23 to to IN 19613 2449 24 the the DT 19613 2449 25 early early JJ 19613 2449 26 history history NN 19613 2449 27 of of IN 19613 2449 28 this this DT 19613 2449 29 conception conception NN 19613 2449 30 , , , 19613 2449 31 which which WDT 19613 2449 32 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 2449 33 has have VBZ 19613 2449 34 a a DT 19613 2449 35 basis basis NN 19613 2449 36 of of IN 19613 2449 37 truth truth NN 19613 2449 38 , , , 19613 2449 39 see see VB 19613 2449 40 Clem Clem NNP 19613 2449 41 . . . 19613 2449 42 , , , 19613 2449 43 ep ep NNP 19613 2449 44 . . . 19613 2450 1 ad ad NN 19613 2450 2 Cor Cor NNP 19613 2450 3 . . . 19613 2451 1 1 1 LS 19613 2451 2 . . . 19613 2452 1 44 44 CD 19613 2452 2 ; ; : 19613 2452 3 Ignat ignat JJ 19613 2452 4 . . . 19613 2453 1 ; ; : 19613 2453 2 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 2453 3 in in IN 19613 2453 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2453 5 . . NNP 19613 2453 6 , , , 19613 2453 7 H. H. NNP 19613 2453 8 E. E. NNP 19613 2453 9 IV IV NNP 19613 2453 10 . . . 19613 2454 1 22 22 CD 19613 2454 2 . . . 19613 2455 1 5 5 LS 19613 2455 2 ; ; : 19613 2455 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2455 4 . . NNP 19613 2455 5 , , , 19613 2455 6 adv adv NNP 19613 2455 7 . . . 19613 2456 1 Valent Valent NNP 19613 2456 2 . . . 19613 2457 1 4 4 LS 19613 2457 2 ; ; : 19613 2457 3 de de NNP 19613 2457 4 bapt bapt NNP 19613 2457 5 . . . 19613 2458 1 17 17 LS 19613 2458 2 ; ; : 19613 2458 3 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 19613 2458 4 in in IN 19613 2458 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2458 6 ; ; : 19613 2458 7 H. H. NNP 19613 2458 8 E. E. NNP 19613 2458 9 V. V. NNP 19613 2458 10 16 16 CD 19613 2458 11 . . . 19613 2459 1 7 7 LS 19613 2459 2 ; ; : 19613 2459 3 Hippolyt Hippolyt NNP 19613 2459 4 . . . 19613 2460 1 ad ad NN 19613 2460 2 . . . 19613 2461 1 Epiphan Epiphan NNP 19613 2461 2 . . . 19613 2462 1 H. H. NNP 19613 2462 2 42 42 CD 19613 2462 3 . . . 19613 2463 1 1 1 LS 19613 2463 2 ; ; : 19613 2463 3 Anonymus Anonymus NNP 19613 2463 4 in in IN 19613 2463 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 2463 6 , , , 19613 2463 7 H. H. NNP 19613 2463 8 E. E. NNP 19613 2463 9 V. V. NNP 19613 2463 10 28 28 CD 19613 2463 11 . . . 19613 2464 1 12 12 CD 19613 2464 2 ; ; : 19613 2464 3 according accord VBG 19613 2464 4 to to IN 19613 2464 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2464 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2464 7 is be VBZ 19613 2464 8 quite quite PDT 19613 2464 9 the the DT 19613 2464 10 common common JJ 19613 2464 11 one one NN 19613 2464 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2464 13 ; ; : 19613 2464 14 see see VB 19613 2464 15 further further RB 19613 2464 16 ep ep NNP 19613 2464 17 . . . 19613 2465 1 59 59 CD 19613 2465 2 . . . 19613 2466 1 3 3 LS 19613 2466 2 : : : 19613 2466 3 " " `` 19613 2466 4 neque neque NNP 19613 2466 5 enim enim NNP 19613 2466 6 aliunde aliunde NNP 19613 2466 7 hæreses hæreses NNP 19613 2466 8 obortæ obortæ NNP 19613 2466 9 sunt sunt NNP 19613 2466 10 aut aut NNP 19613 2466 11 nata nata NNP 19613 2466 12 sunt sunt NNP 19613 2466 13 schismata schismata NNP 19613 2466 14 , , , 19613 2466 15 quam quam NNP 19613 2466 16 quando quando NNP 19613 2466 17 sacerdoti sacerdoti NNP 19613 2466 18 dei dei NNP 19613 2466 19 non non AFX 19613 2466 20 obtemperatur obtemperatur NNP 19613 2466 21 ; ; : 19613 2466 22 " " `` 19613 2466 23 epp epp NNP 19613 2466 24 . . . 19613 2467 1 66 66 CD 19613 2467 2 . . . 19613 2468 1 5 5 CD 19613 2468 2 : : SYM 19613 2468 3 69 69 CD 19613 2468 4 . . . 19613 2469 1 1 1 LS 19613 2469 2 : : : 19613 2469 3 " " `` 19613 2469 4 item item NNP 19613 2469 5 b. b. NNP 19613 2469 6 apostolus apostolus NNP 19613 2469 7 Johannes Johannes NNP 19613 2469 8 nec nec NNP 19613 2469 9 ipse ipse NNP 19613 2469 10 ullam ullam NNP 19613 2469 11 hæresin hæresin NNP 19613 2469 12 aut aut NNP 19613 2469 13 schisma schisma NNP 19613 2469 14 discrevit discrevit NNP 19613 2469 15 aut aut NNP 19613 2469 16 aliquos aliquos NN 19613 2469 17 speciatim speciatim NN 19613 2469 18 separes separe VBZ 19613 2469 19 posuit posuit NN 19613 2469 20 " " '' 19613 2469 21 ; ; : 19613 2469 22 52 52 CD 19613 2469 23 . . . 19613 2470 1 1 1 CD 19613 2470 2 : : SYM 19613 2470 3 73 73 CD 19613 2470 4 . . . 19613 2471 1 2 2 CD 19613 2471 2 : : SYM 19613 2471 3 74 74 CD 19613 2471 4 . . . 19613 2472 1 11 11 CD 19613 2472 2 . . . 19613 2473 1 Schism schism NN 19613 2473 2 and and CC 19613 2473 3 heresy heresy NN 19613 2473 4 are be VBP 19613 2473 5 always always RB 19613 2473 6 identical identical JJ 19613 2473 7 . . . 19613 2473 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2474 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2474 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 2474 3 192 192 CD 19613 2474 4 : : : 19613 2474 5 Neither neither CC 19613 2474 6 Optatus Optatus NNP 19613 2474 7 nor nor CC 19613 2474 8 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 2474 9 take take VB 19613 2474 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2474 11 's 's POS 19613 2474 12 theory theory NN 19613 2474 13 as as IN 19613 2474 14 the the DT 19613 2474 15 starting starting NN 19613 2474 16 - - HYPH 19613 2474 17 point point NN 19613 2474 18 of of IN 19613 2474 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2474 20 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 2474 21 , , , 19613 2474 22 but but CC 19613 2474 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2474 24 adhere adhere VBP 19613 2474 25 in in IN 19613 2474 26 principle principle NN 19613 2474 27 to to IN 19613 2474 28 the the DT 19613 2474 29 distinction distinction NN 19613 2474 30 between between IN 19613 2474 31 heretic heretic JJ 19613 2474 32 and and CC 19613 2474 33 schismatic schismatic JJ 19613 2474 34 . . . 19613 2475 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2475 2 was be VBD 19613 2475 3 compelled compel VBN 19613 2475 4 by by IN 19613 2475 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2475 6 special special JJ 19613 2475 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2475 8 to to TO 19613 2475 9 identify identify VB 19613 2475 10 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2475 11 , , , 19613 2475 12 but but CC 19613 2475 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2475 14 united unite VBD 19613 2475 15 this this DT 19613 2475 16 identification identification NN 19613 2475 17 with with IN 19613 2475 18 the the DT 19613 2475 19 greatest great JJS 19613 2475 20 liberality liberality NN 19613 2475 21 of of IN 19613 2475 22 view view NN 19613 2475 23 as as IN 19613 2475 24 to to IN 19613 2475 25 the the DT 19613 2475 26 conditions condition NNS 19613 2475 27 of of IN 19613 2475 28 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2475 29 unity unity NN 19613 2475 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2475 31 as as IN 19613 2475 32 regards regard VBZ 19613 2475 33 individual individual JJ 19613 2475 34 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2475 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2475 36 . . . 19613 2476 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2476 2 did do VBD 19613 2476 3 not not RB 19613 2476 4 make make VB 19613 2476 5 a a DT 19613 2476 6 single single JJ 19613 2476 7 new new JJ 19613 2476 8 article article NN 19613 2476 9 an an DT 19613 2476 10 " " `` 19613 2476 11 articulus articulus JJ 19613 2476 12 stantis stantis NN 19613 2476 13 et et NN 19613 2476 14 cadentis cadentis NN 19613 2476 15 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 2476 16 . . . 19613 2476 17 " " '' 19613 2477 1 In in IN 19613 2477 2 fact fact NN 19613 2477 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2477 4 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 2477 5 declared declare VBD 19613 2477 6 -- -- : 19613 2477 7 and and CC 19613 2477 8 this this DT 19613 2477 9 may may MD 19613 2477 10 have have VB 19613 2477 11 cost cost VBN 19613 2477 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2477 13 struggle struggle NN 19613 2477 14 enough enough RB 19613 2477 15 -- -- : 19613 2477 16 that that IN 19613 2477 17 even even RB 19613 2477 18 the the DT 19613 2477 19 question question NN 19613 2477 20 of of IN 19613 2477 21 the the DT 19613 2477 22 validity validity NN 19613 2477 23 of of IN 19613 2477 24 heretical heretical JJ 19613 2477 25 baptism baptism NN 19613 2477 26 was be VBD 19613 2477 27 not not RB 19613 2477 28 a a DT 19613 2477 29 question question NN 19613 2477 30 of of IN 19613 2477 31 faith faith NN 19613 2477 32 . . . 19613 2477 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2478 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 2478 2 III III NNP 19613 2478 3 . . . 19613 2479 1 CONTINUATION continuation NN 19613 2479 2 . . . 19613 2480 1 THE the DT 19613 2480 2 OLD old JJ 19613 2480 3 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 2480 4 AND and CC 19613 2480 5 THE the DT 19613 2480 6 NEW new JJ 19613 2480 7 CHURCH CHURCH NNS 19613 2480 8 . . . 19613 2481 1 1 1 LS 19613 2481 2 . . . 19613 2482 1 The the DT 19613 2482 2 legal legal JJ 19613 2482 3 and and CC 19613 2482 4 political political JJ 19613 2482 5 forms form NNS 19613 2482 6 by by IN 19613 2482 7 which which WDT 19613 2482 8 the the DT 19613 2482 9 Church Church NNP 19613 2482 10 secured secure VBD 19613 2482 11 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 2482 12 against against IN 19613 2482 13 the the DT 19613 2482 14 secular secular JJ 19613 2482 15 power power NN 19613 2482 16 and and CC 19613 2482 17 heresy heresy NN 19613 2482 18 , , , 19613 2482 19 and and CC 19613 2482 20 still still RB 19613 2482 21 more more RBR 19613 2482 22 the the DT 19613 2482 23 lower low JJR 19613 2482 24 moral moral JJ 19613 2482 25 standard standard NN 19613 2482 26 exacted exact VBN 19613 2482 27 from from IN 19613 2482 28 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2482 29 members member NNS 19613 2482 30 in in IN 19613 2482 31 consequence consequence NN 19613 2482 32 of of IN 19613 2482 33 the the DT 19613 2482 34 naturalisation naturalisation NN 19613 2482 35 of of IN 19613 2482 36 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2482 37 in in IN 19613 2482 38 the the DT 19613 2482 39 world world NN 19613 2482 40 , , , 19613 2482 41 called call VBD 19613 2482 42 forth forth RB 19613 2482 43 a a DT 19613 2482 44 reaction reaction NN 19613 2482 45 soon soon RB 19613 2482 46 after after IN 19613 2482 47 the the DT 19613 2482 48 middle middle NN 19613 2482 49 of of IN 19613 2482 50 the the DT 19613 2482 51 second second JJ 19613 2482 52 century century NN 19613 2482 53 . . . 19613 2483 1 This this DT 19613 2483 2 movement movement NN 19613 2483 3 , , , 19613 2483 4 which which WDT 19613 2483 5 first first RB 19613 2483 6 began begin VBD 19613 2483 7 in in IN 19613 2483 8 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2483 9 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2483 10 and and CC 19613 2483 11 then then RB 19613 2483 12 spread spread VBD 19613 2483 13 into into IN 19613 2483 14 other other JJ 19613 2483 15 regions region NNS 19613 2483 16 of of IN 19613 2483 17 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2483 18 , , , 19613 2483 19 aimed aim VBN 19613 2483 20 at at IN 19613 2483 21 preserving preserve VBG 19613 2483 22 or or CC 19613 2483 23 restoring restore VBG 19613 2483 24 the the DT 19613 2483 25 old old JJ 19613 2483 26 feelings feeling NNS 19613 2483 27 and and CC 19613 2483 28 conditions condition NNS 19613 2483 29 , , , 19613 2483 30 and and CC 19613 2483 31 preventing prevent VBG 19613 2483 32 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2483 33 from from IN 19613 2483 34 being be VBG 19613 2483 35 secularised secularise VBN 19613 2483 36 . . . 19613 2484 1 This this DT 19613 2484 2 crisis crisis NN 19613 2484 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2484 4 the the DT 19613 2484 5 so so RB 19613 2484 6 called call VBN 19613 2484 7 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2484 8 struggle struggle NN 19613 2484 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2484 10 and and CC 19613 2484 11 the the DT 19613 2484 12 kindred kindred JJ 19613 2484 13 one one CD 19613 2484 14 which which WDT 19613 2484 15 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 2484 16 produced produce VBD 19613 2484 17 the the DT 19613 2484 18 following following JJ 19613 2484 19 results result NNS 19613 2484 20 : : : 19613 2484 21 The the DT 19613 2484 22 Church Church NNP 19613 2484 23 merely merely RB 19613 2484 24 regarded regard VBD 19613 2484 25 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 2484 26 all all PDT 19613 2484 27 the the DT 19613 2484 28 more more RBR 19613 2484 29 strictly strictly RB 19613 2484 30 as as IN 19613 2484 31 a a DT 19613 2484 32 legal legal JJ 19613 2484 33 community community NN 19613 2484 34 basing base VBG 19613 2484 35 the the DT 19613 2484 36 truth truth NN 19613 2484 37 of of IN 19613 2484 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2484 39 title title NN 19613 2484 40 on on IN 19613 2484 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2484 42 historic historic JJ 19613 2484 43 and and CC 19613 2484 44 objective objective JJ 19613 2484 45 foundations foundation NNS 19613 2484 46 , , , 19613 2484 47 and and CC 19613 2484 48 gave give VBD 19613 2484 49 a a DT 19613 2484 50 correspondingly correspondingly RB 19613 2484 51 new new JJ 19613 2484 52 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 2484 53 to to IN 19613 2484 54 the the DT 19613 2484 55 attribute attribute NN 19613 2484 56 of of IN 19613 2484 57 holiness holiness NN 19613 2484 58 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2484 59 claimed claim VBD 19613 2484 60 . . . 19613 2485 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 2485 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 2485 3 recognised recognise VBD 19613 2485 4 two two CD 19613 2485 5 distinct distinct JJ 19613 2485 6 classes class NNS 19613 2485 7 in in IN 19613 2485 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2485 9 midst midst NN 19613 2485 10 , , , 19613 2485 11 a a DT 19613 2485 12 spiritual spiritual NN 19613 2485 13 and and CC 19613 2485 14 a a DT 19613 2485 15 secular secular JJ 19613 2485 16 , , , 19613 2485 17 as as RB 19613 2485 18 well well RB 19613 2485 19 as as IN 19613 2485 20 a a DT 19613 2485 21 double double JJ 19613 2485 22 standard standard NN 19613 2485 23 of of IN 19613 2485 24 morality morality NN 19613 2485 25 . . . 19613 2486 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2486 2 , , , 19613 2486 3 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2486 4 renounced renounce VBD 19613 2486 5 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2486 6 character character NN 19613 2486 7 as as IN 19613 2486 8 the the DT 19613 2486 9 communion communion NN 19613 2486 10 of of IN 19613 2486 11 those those DT 19613 2486 12 who who WP 19613 2486 13 were be VBD 19613 2486 14 sure sure JJ 19613 2486 15 of of IN 19613 2486 16 salvation salvation NN 19613 2486 17 , , , 19613 2486 18 and and CC 19613 2486 19 substituted substitute VBD 19613 2486 20 the the DT 19613 2486 21 claim claim NN 19613 2486 22 to to TO 19613 2486 23 be be VB 19613 2486 24 an an DT 19613 2486 25 educational educational JJ 19613 2486 26 institution institution NN 19613 2486 27 and and CC 19613 2486 28 a a DT 19613 2486 29 necessary necessary JJ 19613 2486 30 condition condition NN 19613 2486 31 of of IN 19613 2486 32 redemption redemption NN 19613 2486 33 . . . 19613 2487 1 After after IN 19613 2487 2 a a DT 19613 2487 3 keen keen JJ 19613 2487 4 struggle struggle NN 19613 2487 5 , , , 19613 2487 6 in in IN 19613 2487 7 which which WDT 19613 2487 8 the the DT 19613 2487 9 New New NNP 19613 2487 10 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2487 11 did do VBD 19613 2487 12 excellent excellent JJ 19613 2487 13 service service NN 19613 2487 14 to to IN 19613 2487 15 the the DT 19613 2487 16 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2487 17 , , , 19613 2487 18 the the DT 19613 2487 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2487 20 expelled expel VBD 19613 2487 21 the the DT 19613 2487 22 Cataphrygian cataphrygian JJ 19613 2487 23 fanatics fanatic NNS 19613 2487 24 and and CC 19613 2487 25 the the DT 19613 2487 26 adherents adherent NNS 19613 2487 27 of of IN 19613 2487 28 the the DT 19613 2487 29 new new JJ 19613 2487 30 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2487 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2487 32 between between IN 19613 2487 33 180 180 CD 19613 2487 34 and and CC 19613 2487 35 220 220 CD 19613 2487 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2487 37 ; ; : 19613 2487 38 and and CC 19613 2487 39 in in IN 19613 2487 40 the the DT 19613 2487 41 same same JJ 19613 2487 42 way way NN 19613 2487 43 , , , 19613 2487 44 during during IN 19613 2487 45 the the DT 19613 2487 46 course course NN 19613 2487 47 of of IN 19613 2487 48 the the DT 19613 2487 49 third third JJ 19613 2487 50 century century NN 19613 2487 51 , , , 19613 2487 52 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2487 53 caused cause VBD 19613 2487 54 the the DT 19613 2487 55 secession secession NN 19613 2487 56 of of IN 19613 2487 57 all all PDT 19613 2487 58 those those DT 19613 2487 59 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2487 60 who who WP 19613 2487 61 made make VBD 19613 2487 62 the the DT 19613 2487 63 truth truth NN 19613 2487 64 of of IN 19613 2487 65 the the DT 19613 2487 66 Church Church NNP 19613 2487 67 depend depend VBP 19613 2487 68 on on IN 19613 2487 69 a a DT 19613 2487 70 stricter strict JJR 19613 2487 71 administration administration NN 19613 2487 72 of of IN 19613 2487 73 moral moral JJ 19613 2487 74 discipline discipline NN 19613 2487 75 . . . 19613 2488 1 Hence hence RB 19613 2488 2 , , , 19613 2488 3 apart apart RB 19613 2488 4 from from IN 19613 2488 5 the the DT 19613 2488 6 heretic heretic JJ 19613 2488 7 and and CC 19613 2488 8 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2488 9 sects sect NNS 19613 2488 10 , , , 19613 2488 11 there there EX 19613 2488 12 existed exist VBD 19613 2488 13 in in IN 19613 2488 14 the the DT 19613 2488 15 Empire empire NN 19613 2488 16 , , , 19613 2488 17 after after IN 19613 2488 18 the the DT 19613 2488 19 middle middle NN 19613 2488 20 of of IN 19613 2488 21 the the DT 19613 2488 22 second second JJ 19613 2488 23 century century NN 19613 2488 24 , , , 19613 2488 25 two two CD 19613 2488 26 great great JJ 19613 2488 27 but but CC 19613 2488 28 numerically numerically RB 19613 2488 29 unequal unequal JJ 19613 2488 30 Church Church NNP 19613 2488 31 confederations confederation NNS 19613 2488 32 , , , 19613 2488 33 both both DT 19613 2488 34 based base VBN 19613 2488 35 on on IN 19613 2488 36 the the DT 19613 2488 37 same same JJ 19613 2488 38 rule rule NN 19613 2488 39 of of IN 19613 2488 40 faith faith NN 19613 2488 41 and and CC 19613 2488 42 claiming claim VBG 19613 2488 43 the the DT 19613 2488 44 title title NN 19613 2488 45 " " `` 19613 2488 46 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2488 47 catholica catholica NNP 19613 2488 48 , , , 19613 2488 49 " " '' 19613 2488 50 viz viz NNP 19613 2488 51 . . NNP 19613 2488 52 , , , 19613 2488 53 the the DT 19613 2488 54 confederation confederation NN 19613 2488 55 which which WDT 19613 2488 56 Constantine Constantine NNP 19613 2488 57 afterwards afterwards RB 19613 2488 58 chose choose VBD 19613 2488 59 for for IN 19613 2488 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2488 61 support support NN 19613 2488 62 , , , 19613 2488 63 and and CC 19613 2488 64 the the DT 19613 2488 65 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2488 66 Catharist Catharist NNP 19613 2488 67 one one CD 19613 2488 68 . . . 19613 2489 1 In in IN 19613 2489 2 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2489 3 , , , 19613 2489 4 however however RB 19613 2489 5 , , , 19613 2489 6 the the DT 19613 2489 7 beginning beginning NN 19613 2489 8 of of IN 19613 2489 9 the the DT 19613 2489 10 great great JJ 19613 2489 11 disruption disruption NN 19613 2489 12 goes go VBZ 19613 2489 13 back back RB 19613 2489 14 to to IN 19613 2489 15 the the DT 19613 2489 16 time time NN 19613 2489 17 of of IN 19613 2489 18 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2489 19 and and CC 19613 2489 20 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2489 21 ; ; : 19613 2489 22 yet yet CC 19613 2489 23 the the DT 19613 2489 24 schism schism NN 19613 2489 25 of of IN 19613 2489 26 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2489 27 must must MD 19613 2489 28 not not RB 19613 2489 29 be be VB 19613 2489 30 considered consider VBN 19613 2489 31 as as IN 19613 2489 32 an an DT 19613 2489 33 immediate immediate JJ 19613 2489 34 continuation continuation NN 19613 2489 35 of of IN 19613 2489 36 that that DT 19613 2489 37 of of IN 19613 2489 38 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2489 39 . . . 19613 2490 1 2 2 LS 19613 2490 2 . . . 19613 2491 1 The the DT 19613 2491 2 so so RB 19613 2491 3 - - HYPH 19613 2491 4 called call VBN 19613 2491 5 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2491 6 reaction[193 reaction[193 NN 19613 2491 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2491 8 was be VBD 19613 2491 9 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2491 10 subjected subject VBN 19613 2491 11 to to IN 19613 2491 12 a a DT 19613 2491 13 similar similar JJ 19613 2491 14 change change NN 19613 2491 15 , , , 19613 2491 16 in in IN 19613 2491 17 accordance accordance NN 19613 2491 18 with with IN 19613 2491 19 the the DT 19613 2491 20 advancing advance VBG 19613 2491 21 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2491 22 development development NN 19613 2491 23 of of IN 19613 2491 24 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2491 25 . . . 19613 2492 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2492 2 was be VBD 19613 2492 3 originally originally RB 19613 2492 4 the the DT 19613 2492 5 violent violent JJ 19613 2492 6 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 2492 7 of of IN 19613 2492 8 a a DT 19613 2492 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 2492 10 prophet prophet NN 19613 2492 11 , , , 19613 2492 12 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 2492 13 , , , 19613 2492 14 who who WP 19613 2492 15 , , , 19613 2492 16 supported support VBN 19613 2492 17 by by IN 19613 2492 18 prophetesses prophetess NNS 19613 2492 19 , , , 19613 2492 20 felt feel VBD 19613 2492 21 called call VBN 19613 2492 22 upon upon IN 19613 2492 23 to to TO 19613 2492 24 realise realise VB 19613 2492 25 the the DT 19613 2492 26 promises promise NNS 19613 2492 27 held hold VBN 19613 2492 28 forth forth RB 19613 2492 29 in in IN 19613 2492 30 the the DT 19613 2492 31 Fourth Fourth NNP 19613 2492 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2492 33 . . . 19613 2493 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2493 2 explained explain VBD 19613 2493 3 these these DT 19613 2493 4 by by IN 19613 2493 5 the the DT 19613 2493 6 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 2493 7 , , , 19613 2493 8 and and CC 19613 2493 9 declared declare VBD 19613 2493 10 that that IN 19613 2493 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2493 12 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2493 13 was be VBD 19613 2493 14 the the DT 19613 2493 15 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2493 16 whom whom WP 19613 2493 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2493 18 had have VBD 19613 2493 19 promised promise VBN 19613 2493 20 -- -- : 19613 2493 21 that that IN 19613 2493 22 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2493 23 in in IN 19613 2493 24 whom whom WP 19613 2493 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 2493 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2493 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2493 28 , , , 19613 2493 29 nay nay NN 19613 2493 30 , , , 19613 2493 31 even even RB 19613 2493 32 God God NNP 19613 2493 33 the the DT 19613 2493 34 Father Father NNP 19613 2493 35 Almighty Almighty NNP 19613 2493 36 , , , 19613 2493 37 comes come VBZ 19613 2493 38 to to IN 19613 2493 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2493 40 own own JJ 19613 2493 41 to to TO 19613 2493 42 guide guide VB 19613 2493 43 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2493 44 to to IN 19613 2493 45 all all DT 19613 2493 46 truth truth NN 19613 2493 47 , , , 19613 2493 48 to to TO 19613 2493 49 gather gather VB 19613 2493 50 those those DT 19613 2493 51 that that WDT 19613 2493 52 are be VBP 19613 2493 53 dispersed disperse VBN 19613 2493 54 , , , 19613 2493 55 and and CC 19613 2493 56 to to TO 19613 2493 57 bring bring VB 19613 2493 58 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2493 59 into into IN 19613 2493 60 one one CD 19613 2493 61 flock flock NN 19613 2493 62 . . . 19613 2494 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2494 2 main main JJ 19613 2494 3 effort effort NN 19613 2494 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 2494 5 was be VBD 19613 2494 6 to to TO 19613 2494 7 make make VB 19613 2494 8 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2494 9 give give VB 19613 2494 10 up up RP 19613 2494 11 the the DT 19613 2494 12 local local JJ 19613 2494 13 and and CC 19613 2494 14 civil civil JJ 19613 2494 15 relations relation NNS 19613 2494 16 in in IN 19613 2494 17 which which WDT 19613 2494 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2494 19 lived live VBD 19613 2494 20 , , , 19613 2494 21 to to TO 19613 2494 22 collect collect VB 19613 2494 23 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2494 24 , , , 19613 2494 25 and and CC 19613 2494 26 create create VB 19613 2494 27 a a DT 19613 2494 28 new new JJ 19613 2494 29 undivided undivided JJ 19613 2494 30 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2494 31 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 2494 32 , , , 19613 2494 33 which which WDT 19613 2494 34 , , , 19613 2494 35 separated separate VBD 19613 2494 36 from from IN 19613 2494 37 the the DT 19613 2494 38 world world NN 19613 2494 39 , , , 19613 2494 40 should should MD 19613 2494 41 prepare prepare VB 19613 2494 42 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2494 43 for for IN 19613 2494 44 the the DT 19613 2494 45 descent descent NN 19613 2494 46 of of IN 19613 2494 47 the the DT 19613 2494 48 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 2494 49 from from IN 19613 2494 50 above above RB 19613 2494 51 . . . 19613 2495 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2495 2 194 194 CD 19613 2495 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2495 4 The the DT 19613 2495 5 natural natural JJ 19613 2495 6 resistance resistance NN 19613 2495 7 offered offer VBD 19613 2495 8 to to IN 19613 2495 9 the the DT 19613 2495 10 new new JJ 19613 2495 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2495 12 with with IN 19613 2495 13 this this DT 19613 2495 14 extravagant extravagant JJ 19613 2495 15 message message NN 19613 2495 16 -- -- : 19613 2495 17 especially especially RB 19613 2495 18 by by IN 19613 2495 19 the the DT 19613 2495 20 leaders leader NNS 19613 2495 21 of of IN 19613 2495 22 communities community NNS 19613 2495 23 , , , 19613 2495 24 and and CC 19613 2495 25 the the DT 19613 2495 26 persecutions persecution NNS 19613 2495 27 to to TO 19613 2495 28 which which WDT 19613 2495 29 the the DT 19613 2495 30 Church Church NNP 19613 2495 31 was be VBD 19613 2495 32 soon soon RB 19613 2495 33 after after IN 19613 2495 34 subjected subject VBN 19613 2495 35 under under IN 19613 2495 36 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 2495 37 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 19613 2495 38 , , , 19613 2495 39 led lead VBD 19613 2495 40 to to IN 19613 2495 41 an an DT 19613 2495 42 intensifying intensifying NN 19613 2495 43 of of IN 19613 2495 44 the the DT 19613 2495 45 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 2495 46 expectations expectation NNS 19613 2495 47 that that IN 19613 2495 48 beyond beyond IN 19613 2495 49 doubt doubt NN 19613 2495 50 had have VBD 19613 2495 51 been be VBN 19613 2495 52 specially specially RB 19613 2495 53 keen keen JJ 19613 2495 54 in in IN 19613 2495 55 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 2495 56 circles circle NNS 19613 2495 57 from from IN 19613 2495 58 the the DT 19613 2495 59 beginning beginning NN 19613 2495 60 . . . 19613 2496 1 For for IN 19613 2496 2 the the DT 19613 2496 3 New New NNP 19613 2496 4 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 2496 5 was be VBD 19613 2496 6 soon soon RB 19613 2496 7 to to TO 19613 2496 8 come come VB 19613 2496 9 down down RP 19613 2496 10 from from IN 19613 2496 11 heaven heaven NNP 19613 2496 12 in in IN 19613 2496 13 visible visible JJ 19613 2496 14 form form NN 19613 2496 15 , , , 19613 2496 16 and and CC 19613 2496 17 establish establish VB 19613 2496 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2496 19 in in IN 19613 2496 20 the the DT 19613 2496 21 spot spot NN 19613 2496 22 which which WDT 19613 2496 23 , , , 19613 2496 24 by by IN 19613 2496 25 direction direction NN 19613 2496 26 of of IN 19613 2496 27 the the DT 19613 2496 28 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2496 29 , , , 19613 2496 30 had have VBD 19613 2496 31 been be VBN 19613 2496 32 chosen choose VBN 19613 2496 33 for for IN 19613 2496 34 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2496 35 in in IN 19613 2496 36 Phrygia Phrygia NNP 19613 2496 37 . . . 19613 2497 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2497 2 195 195 CD 19613 2497 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2497 4 Whatever whatever WDT 19613 2497 5 amount amount NN 19613 2497 6 of of IN 19613 2497 7 peculiarity peculiarity NN 19613 2497 8 the the DT 19613 2497 9 movement movement NN 19613 2497 10 lost lose VBD 19613 2497 11 , , , 19613 2497 12 in in RB 19613 2497 13 so so RB 19613 2497 14 far far RB 19613 2497 15 as as IN 19613 2497 16 the the DT 19613 2497 17 ideal ideal NN 19613 2497 18 of of IN 19613 2497 19 an an DT 19613 2497 20 assembly assembly NN 19613 2497 21 of of IN 19613 2497 22 all all DT 19613 2497 23 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2497 24 proved prove VBD 19613 2497 25 incapable incapable JJ 19613 2497 26 of of IN 19613 2497 27 being be VBG 19613 2497 28 realised realise VBN 19613 2497 29 or or CC 19613 2497 30 at at IN 19613 2497 31 least least JJS 19613 2497 32 only only RB 19613 2497 33 possible possible JJ 19613 2497 34 within within IN 19613 2497 35 narrow narrow JJ 19613 2497 36 limits limit NNS 19613 2497 37 , , , 19613 2497 38 was be VBD 19613 2497 39 abundantly abundantly RB 19613 2497 40 restored restore VBN 19613 2497 41 in in IN 19613 2497 42 the the DT 19613 2497 43 last last JJ 19613 2497 44 decades decade NNS 19613 2497 45 of of IN 19613 2497 46 the the DT 19613 2497 47 second second JJ 19613 2497 48 century century NN 19613 2497 49 by by IN 19613 2497 50 the the DT 19613 2497 51 strength strength NN 19613 2497 52 and and CC 19613 2497 53 courage courage NN 19613 2497 54 that that IN 19613 2497 55 the the DT 19613 2497 56 news news NN 19613 2497 57 of of IN 19613 2497 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2497 59 spread spread NN 19613 2497 60 in in IN 19613 2497 61 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2497 62 gave give VBD 19613 2497 63 to to IN 19613 2497 64 the the DT 19613 2497 65 earnest earnest JJ 19613 2497 66 minded minded JJ 19613 2497 67 to to TO 19613 2497 68 unite unite VB 19613 2497 69 and and CC 19613 2497 70 offer offer VB 19613 2497 71 resistance resistance NN 19613 2497 72 to to IN 19613 2497 73 the the DT 19613 2497 74 ever ever RB 19613 2497 75 increasing increase VBG 19613 2497 76 tendency tendency NN 19613 2497 77 of of IN 19613 2497 78 the the DT 19613 2497 79 Church Church NNP 19613 2497 80 to to TO 19613 2497 81 assume assume VB 19613 2497 82 a a DT 19613 2497 83 secular secular JJ 19613 2497 84 and and CC 19613 2497 85 political political JJ 19613 2497 86 character character NN 19613 2497 87 . . . 19613 2498 1 Many many JJ 19613 2498 2 entire entire JJ 19613 2498 3 communities community NNS 19613 2498 4 in in IN 19613 2498 5 Phrygia Phrygia NNP 19613 2498 6 and and CC 19613 2498 7 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2498 8 recognised recognise VBD 19613 2498 9 the the DT 19613 2498 10 divine divine JJ 19613 2498 11 mission mission NN 19613 2498 12 of of IN 19613 2498 13 the the DT 19613 2498 14 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2498 15 . . . 19613 2499 1 In in IN 19613 2499 2 the the DT 19613 2499 3 Churches church NNS 19613 2499 4 of of IN 19613 2499 5 other other JJ 19613 2499 6 provinces province NNS 19613 2499 7 religious religious JJ 19613 2499 8 societies society NNS 19613 2499 9 were be VBD 19613 2499 10 formed form VBN 19613 2499 11 in in IN 19613 2499 12 which which WDT 19613 2499 13 the the DT 19613 2499 14 predictions prediction NNS 19613 2499 15 of of IN 19613 2499 16 these these DT 19613 2499 17 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2499 18 were be VBD 19613 2499 19 circulated circulate VBN 19613 2499 20 and and CC 19613 2499 21 viewed view VBD 19613 2499 22 as as IN 19613 2499 23 a a DT 19613 2499 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2499 25 , , , 19613 2499 26 though though IN 19613 2499 27 at at IN 19613 2499 28 the the DT 19613 2499 29 same same JJ 19613 2499 30 time time NN 19613 2499 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2499 32 lost lose VBD 19613 2499 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2499 34 effect effect NN 19613 2499 35 by by IN 19613 2499 36 being be VBG 19613 2499 37 so so RB 19613 2499 38 treated treat VBN 19613 2499 39 . . . 19613 2500 1 The the DT 19613 2500 2 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2500 3 at at IN 19613 2500 4 Lyons Lyons NNP 19613 2500 5 openly openly RB 19613 2500 6 expressed express VBD 19613 2500 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2500 8 full full JJ 19613 2500 9 sympathy sympathy NN 19613 2500 10 with with IN 19613 2500 11 the the DT 19613 2500 12 movement movement NN 19613 2500 13 in in IN 19613 2500 14 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2500 15 . . . 19613 2501 1 The the DT 19613 2501 2 bishop bishop NN 19613 2501 3 of of IN 19613 2501 4 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2501 5 was be VBD 19613 2501 6 on on IN 19613 2501 7 the the DT 19613 2501 8 verge verge NN 19613 2501 9 of of IN 19613 2501 10 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 19613 2501 11 the the DT 19613 2501 12 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2501 13 to to TO 19613 2501 14 be be VB 19613 2501 15 in in IN 19613 2501 16 full full JJ 19613 2501 17 communion communion NN 19613 2501 18 with with IN 19613 2501 19 the the DT 19613 2501 20 Church Church NNP 19613 2501 21 . . . 19613 2502 1 But but CC 19613 2502 2 among among IN 19613 2502 3 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2502 4 there there EX 19613 2502 5 was be VBD 19613 2502 6 no no RB 19613 2502 7 longer long RBR 19613 2502 8 , , , 19613 2502 9 as as IN 19613 2502 10 at at IN 19613 2502 11 the the DT 19613 2502 12 beginning beginning NN 19613 2502 13 , , , 19613 2502 14 any any DT 19613 2502 15 question question NN 19613 2502 16 of of IN 19613 2502 17 a a DT 19613 2502 18 new new JJ 19613 2502 19 organisation organisation NN 19613 2502 20 in in IN 19613 2502 21 the the DT 19613 2502 22 strict strict JJ 19613 2502 23 sense sense NN 19613 2502 24 of of IN 19613 2502 25 the the DT 19613 2502 26 word word NN 19613 2502 27 , , , 19613 2502 28 and and CC 19613 2502 29 of of IN 19613 2502 30 a a DT 19613 2502 31 radical radical JJ 19613 2502 32 remodelling remodelling NN 19613 2502 33 of of IN 19613 2502 34 Christian christian JJ 19613 2502 35 society society NN 19613 2502 36 . . . 19613 2503 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2503 2 196 196 CD 19613 2503 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2503 4 Whenever Whenever NNP 19613 2503 5 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 2503 6 comes come VBZ 19613 2503 7 before before IN 19613 2503 8 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2503 9 in in IN 19613 2503 10 the the DT 19613 2503 11 clear clear JJ 19613 2503 12 light light NN 19613 2503 13 of of IN 19613 2503 14 history history NN 19613 2503 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2503 16 rather rather RB 19613 2503 17 appears appear VBZ 19613 2503 18 as as IN 19613 2503 19 a a DT 19613 2503 20 religious religious JJ 19613 2503 21 movement movement NN 19613 2503 22 already already RB 19613 2503 23 deadened deaden VBN 19613 2503 24 , , , 19613 2503 25 though though IN 19613 2503 26 still still RB 19613 2503 27 very very RB 19613 2503 28 powerful powerful JJ 19613 2503 29 . . . 19613 2504 1 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 2504 2 and and CC 19613 2504 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2504 4 prophetesses prophetess NNS 19613 2504 5 had have VBD 19613 2504 6 set set VBN 19613 2504 7 no no DT 19613 2504 8 limits limit NNS 19613 2504 9 to to IN 19613 2504 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2504 11 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 2504 12 ; ; : 19613 2504 13 nor nor CC 19613 2504 14 were be VBD 19613 2504 15 there there RB 19613 2504 16 as as IN 19613 2504 17 yet yet RB 19613 2504 18 any any DT 19613 2504 19 fixed fix VBN 19613 2504 20 barriers barrier NNS 19613 2504 21 in in IN 19613 2504 22 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2504 23 that that WDT 19613 2504 24 could could MD 19613 2504 25 have have VB 19613 2504 26 restrained restrain VBN 19613 2504 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2504 28 . . . 19613 2505 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2505 2 197 197 CD 19613 2505 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2505 4 The the DT 19613 2505 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2505 6 , , , 19613 2505 7 the the DT 19613 2505 8 Son Son NNP 19613 2505 9 , , , 19613 2505 10 nay nay NNP 19613 2505 11 , , , 19613 2505 12 the the DT 19613 2505 13 Father Father NNP 19613 2505 14 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2505 15 had have VBD 19613 2505 16 appeared appear VBN 19613 2505 17 in in IN 19613 2505 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2505 19 and and CC 19613 2505 20 spoke speak VBD 19613 2505 21 through through IN 19613 2505 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2505 23 . . . 19613 2506 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2506 2 198 198 CD 19613 2506 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2506 4 Imagination Imagination NNP 19613 2506 5 pictured picture VBD 19613 2506 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2506 7 bodily bodily RB 19613 2506 8 in in IN 19613 2506 9 female female JJ 19613 2506 10 form form NN 19613 2506 11 to to IN 19613 2506 12 the the DT 19613 2506 13 eyes eye NNS 19613 2506 14 of of IN 19613 2506 15 Prisca Prisca NNP 19613 2506 16 . . . 19613 2507 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2507 2 199 199 CD 19613 2507 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2507 4 The the DT 19613 2507 5 most most RBS 19613 2507 6 extravagant extravagant JJ 19613 2507 7 promises promise NNS 19613 2507 8 were be VBD 19613 2507 9 given give VBN 19613 2507 10 . . . 19613 2508 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2508 2 200 200 CD 19613 2508 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2508 4 These these DT 19613 2508 5 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2508 6 spoke speak VBD 19613 2508 7 in in IN 19613 2508 8 a a DT 19613 2508 9 loftier lofty JJR 19613 2508 10 tone tone NN 19613 2508 11 than than IN 19613 2508 12 any any DT 19613 2508 13 Apostle Apostle NNP 19613 2508 14 ever ever RB 19613 2508 15 did do VBD 19613 2508 16 , , , 19613 2508 17 and and CC 19613 2508 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2508 19 were be VBD 19613 2508 20 even even RB 19613 2508 21 bold bold JJ 19613 2508 22 enough enough RB 19613 2508 23 to to TO 19613 2508 24 overturn overturn VB 19613 2508 25 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2508 26 regulations regulation NNS 19613 2508 27 . . . 19613 2509 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2509 2 201 201 CD 19613 2509 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2509 4 They -PRON- PRP 19613 2509 5 set set VBP 19613 2509 6 up up RP 19613 2509 7 new new JJ 19613 2509 8 commandments commandment NNS 19613 2509 9 for for IN 19613 2509 10 the the DT 19613 2509 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 2509 12 life life NN 19613 2509 13 , , , 19613 2509 14 regardless regardless RB 19613 2509 15 of of IN 19613 2509 16 any any DT 19613 2509 17 tradition,[202 tradition,[202 NNP 19613 2509 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2509 19 and and CC 19613 2509 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2509 21 inveighed inveigh VBD 19613 2509 22 against against IN 19613 2509 23 the the DT 19613 2509 24 main main JJ 19613 2509 25 body body NN 19613 2509 26 of of IN 19613 2509 27 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2509 28 . . . 19613 2510 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2510 2 203 203 CD 19613 2510 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2510 4 They -PRON- PRP 19613 2510 5 not not RB 19613 2510 6 only only RB 19613 2510 7 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 2510 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2510 9 as as IN 19613 2510 10 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2510 11 , , , 19613 2510 12 but but CC 19613 2510 13 as as IN 19613 2510 14 the the DT 19613 2510 15 last last JJ 19613 2510 16 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2510 17 , , , 19613 2510 18 as as IN 19613 2510 19 notable notable JJ 19613 2510 20 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2510 21 in in IN 19613 2510 22 whom whom WP 19613 2510 23 was be VBD 19613 2510 24 first first RB 19613 2510 25 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 2510 26 the the DT 19613 2510 27 promise promise NN 19613 2510 28 of of IN 19613 2510 29 the the DT 19613 2510 30 sending sending NN 19613 2510 31 of of IN 19613 2510 32 the the DT 19613 2510 33 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2510 34 . . . 19613 2511 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2511 2 204 204 CD 19613 2511 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2511 4 These these DT 19613 2511 5 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2511 6 as as IN 19613 2511 7 yet yet RB 19613 2511 8 knew know VBD 19613 2511 9 nothing nothing NN 19613 2511 10 of of IN 19613 2511 11 the the DT 19613 2511 12 " " `` 19613 2511 13 absoluteness absoluteness NN 19613 2511 14 of of IN 19613 2511 15 a a DT 19613 2511 16 historically historically RB 19613 2511 17 complete complete JJ 19613 2511 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 2511 19 of of IN 19613 2511 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2511 21 as as IN 19613 2511 22 the the DT 19613 2511 23 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 2511 24 condition condition NN 19613 2511 25 of of IN 19613 2511 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 2511 27 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 2511 28 ; ; : 19613 2511 29 " " `` 19613 2511 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2511 31 only only RB 19613 2511 32 felt feel VBD 19613 2511 33 a a DT 19613 2511 34 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2511 35 to to TO 19613 2511 36 which which WDT 19613 2511 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2511 38 yielded yield VBD 19613 2511 39 unconditionally unconditionally RB 19613 2511 40 and and CC 19613 2511 41 without without IN 19613 2511 42 reserve reserve NN 19613 2511 43 . . . 19613 2512 1 But but CC 19613 2512 2 , , , 19613 2512 3 after after IN 19613 2512 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2512 5 had have VBD 19613 2512 6 quitted quit VBN 19613 2512 7 the the DT 19613 2512 8 scene scene NN 19613 2512 9 , , , 19613 2512 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2512 11 followers follower NNS 19613 2512 12 sought seek VBD 19613 2512 13 and and CC 19613 2512 14 found find VBD 19613 2512 15 a a DT 19613 2512 16 kind kind NN 19613 2512 17 of of IN 19613 2512 18 compromise compromise NN 19613 2512 19 . . . 19613 2513 1 The the DT 19613 2513 2 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2513 3 congregations congregation NNS 19613 2513 4 that that WDT 19613 2513 5 sought seek VBD 19613 2513 6 for for IN 19613 2513 7 recognition recognition NN 19613 2513 8 in in IN 19613 2513 9 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2513 10 , , , 19613 2513 11 whose whose WP$ 19613 2513 12 part part NN 19613 2513 13 was be VBD 19613 2513 14 taken take VBN 19613 2513 15 by by IN 19613 2513 16 the the DT 19613 2513 17 Gallic Gallic NNP 19613 2513 18 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2513 19 , , , 19613 2513 20 and and CC 19613 2513 21 whose whose WP$ 19613 2513 22 principles principle NNS 19613 2513 23 gained gain VBD 19613 2513 24 a a DT 19613 2513 25 footing footing NN 19613 2513 26 in in IN 19613 2513 27 North North NNP 19613 2513 28 Africa Africa NNP 19613 2513 29 , , , 19613 2513 30 may may MD 19613 2513 31 have have VB 19613 2513 32 stood stand VBN 19613 2513 33 in in IN 19613 2513 34 the the DT 19613 2513 35 same same JJ 19613 2513 36 relation relation NN 19613 2513 37 to to IN 19613 2513 38 the the DT 19613 2513 39 original original JJ 19613 2513 40 adherents adherent NNS 19613 2513 41 of of IN 19613 2513 42 the the DT 19613 2513 43 new new JJ 19613 2513 44 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2513 45 and and CC 19613 2513 46 to to IN 19613 2513 47 these these DT 19613 2513 48 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2513 49 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2513 50 , , , 19613 2513 51 as as IN 19613 2513 52 the the DT 19613 2513 53 Mennonite Mennonite NNP 19613 2513 54 communities community NNS 19613 2513 55 did do VBD 19613 2513 56 to to IN 19613 2513 57 the the DT 19613 2513 58 primitive primitive JJ 19613 2513 59 Anabaptists Anabaptists NNPS 19613 2513 60 and and CC 19613 2513 61 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2513 62 empire empire NN 19613 2513 63 in in IN 19613 2513 64 Münster Münster NNP 19613 2513 65 . . . 19613 2514 1 The the DT 19613 2514 2 " " `` 19613 2514 3 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2514 4 " " '' 19613 2514 5 outside outside IN 19613 2514 6 of of IN 19613 2514 7 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2514 8 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2514 9 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 2514 10 to to IN 19613 2514 11 the the DT 19613 2514 12 fullest full JJS 19613 2514 13 extent extent NN 19613 2514 14 the the DT 19613 2514 15 legal legal JJ 19613 2514 16 position position NN 19613 2514 17 of of IN 19613 2514 18 the the DT 19613 2514 19 great great JJ 19613 2514 20 Church Church NNP 19613 2514 21 . . . 19613 2515 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 2515 2 declared declare VBD 19613 2515 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2515 4 adherence adherence NN 19613 2515 5 to to IN 19613 2515 6 the the DT 19613 2515 7 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2515 8 " " `` 19613 2515 9 regula regula NN 19613 2515 10 " " '' 19613 2515 11 and and CC 19613 2515 12 the the DT 19613 2515 13 New New NNP 19613 2515 14 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2515 15 canon canon NN 19613 2515 16 . . . 19613 2516 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2516 2 205 205 CD 19613 2516 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2516 4 The the DT 19613 2516 5 organisation organisation NN 19613 2516 6 of of IN 19613 2516 7 the the DT 19613 2516 8 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2516 9 , , , 19613 2516 10 and and CC 19613 2516 11 , , , 19613 2516 12 above above IN 19613 2516 13 all all DT 19613 2516 14 , , , 19613 2516 15 the the DT 19613 2516 16 position position NN 19613 2516 17 of of IN 19613 2516 18 the the DT 19613 2516 19 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2516 20 as as IN 19613 2516 21 successors successor NNS 19613 2516 22 of of IN 19613 2516 23 the the DT 19613 2516 24 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2516 25 and and CC 19613 2516 26 guardians guardian NNS 19613 2516 27 of of IN 19613 2516 28 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2516 29 were be VBD 19613 2516 30 no no RB 19613 2516 31 longer long RBR 19613 2516 32 disputed dispute VBN 19613 2516 33 . . . 19613 2517 1 The the DT 19613 2517 2 distinction distinction NN 19613 2517 3 between between IN 19613 2517 4 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2517 5 and and CC 19613 2517 6 the the DT 19613 2517 7 main main JJ 19613 2517 8 body body NN 19613 2517 9 of of IN 19613 2517 10 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2517 11 , , , 19613 2517 12 from from IN 19613 2517 13 which which WDT 19613 2517 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2517 15 were be VBD 19613 2517 16 unwilling unwilling JJ 19613 2517 17 to to TO 19613 2517 18 secede secede VB 19613 2517 19 , , , 19613 2517 20 was be VBD 19613 2517 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2517 22 belief belief NN 19613 2517 23 in in IN 19613 2517 24 the the DT 19613 2517 25 new new JJ 19613 2517 26 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2517 27 of of IN 19613 2517 28 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 2517 29 , , , 19613 2517 30 Prisca Prisca NNP 19613 2517 31 , , , 19613 2517 32 and and CC 19613 2517 33 Maximilla Maximilla NNP 19613 2517 34 , , , 19613 2517 35 which which WDT 19613 2517 36 was be VBD 19613 2517 37 contained contain VBN 19613 2517 38 , , , 19613 2517 39 in in IN 19613 2517 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2517 41 final final JJ 19613 2517 42 form form NN 19613 2517 43 , , , 19613 2517 44 in in IN 19613 2517 45 written write VBN 19613 2517 46 records record NNS 19613 2517 47 and and CC 19613 2517 48 in in IN 19613 2517 49 this this DT 19613 2517 50 shape shape NN 19613 2517 51 may may MD 19613 2517 52 have have VB 19613 2517 53 produced produce VBN 19613 2517 54 the the DT 19613 2517 55 same same JJ 19613 2517 56 impression impression NN 19613 2517 57 as as IN 19613 2517 58 is be VBZ 19613 2517 59 excited excite VBN 19613 2517 60 by by IN 19613 2517 61 the the DT 19613 2517 62 fragments fragment NNS 19613 2517 63 of of IN 19613 2517 64 an an DT 19613 2517 65 exploded explode VBN 19613 2517 66 bomb bomb NN 19613 2517 67 . . . 19613 2518 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2518 2 206 206 CD 19613 2518 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2518 4 In in IN 19613 2518 5 this this DT 19613 2518 6 new new JJ 19613 2518 7 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2518 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2518 9 recognised recognise VBD 19613 2518 10 a a DT 19613 2518 11 _ _ NNP 19613 2518 12 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 2518 13 revelation revelation NN 19613 2518 14 _ _ NNP 19613 2518 15 of of IN 19613 2518 16 God God NNP 19613 2518 17 , , , 19613 2518 18 which which WDT 19613 2518 19 for for IN 19613 2518 20 that that DT 19613 2518 21 very very JJ 19613 2518 22 reason reason NN 19613 2518 23 assumed assume VBD 19613 2518 24 the the DT 19613 2518 25 existence existence NN 19613 2518 26 of of IN 19613 2518 27 a a DT 19613 2518 28 previous previous JJ 19613 2518 29 one one CD 19613 2518 30 . . . 19613 2519 1 This this DT 19613 2519 2 after after IN 19613 2519 3 - - HYPH 19613 2519 4 revelation revelation NN 19613 2519 5 professed profess VBD 19613 2519 6 to to TO 19613 2519 7 decide decide VB 19613 2519 8 the the DT 19613 2519 9 practical practical JJ 19613 2519 10 questions question NNS 19613 2519 11 which which WDT 19613 2519 12 , , , 19613 2519 13 at at IN 19613 2519 14 the the DT 19613 2519 15 end end NN 19613 2519 16 of of IN 19613 2519 17 the the DT 19613 2519 18 second second JJ 19613 2519 19 century century NN 19613 2519 20 , , , 19613 2519 21 were be VBD 19613 2519 22 burning burn VBG 19613 2519 23 topics topic NNS 19613 2519 24 throughout throughout IN 19613 2519 25 all all DT 19613 2519 26 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2519 27 , , , 19613 2519 28 and and CC 19613 2519 29 for for IN 19613 2519 30 which which WDT 19613 2519 31 no no DT 19613 2519 32 direct direct JJ 19613 2519 33 divine divine JJ 19613 2519 34 law law NN 19613 2519 35 could could MD 19613 2519 36 hitherto hitherto RB 19613 2519 37 be be VB 19613 2519 38 adduced adduce VBN 19613 2519 39 , , , 19613 2519 40 in in IN 19613 2519 41 the the DT 19613 2519 42 form form NN 19613 2519 43 of of IN 19613 2519 44 a a DT 19613 2519 45 strict strict JJ 19613 2519 46 injunction injunction NN 19613 2519 47 . . . 19613 2520 1 Herein Herein NNP 19613 2520 2 lay lie VBD 19613 2520 3 the the DT 19613 2520 4 importance importance NN 19613 2520 5 of of IN 19613 2520 6 the the DT 19613 2520 7 new new JJ 19613 2520 8 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2520 9 for for IN 19613 2520 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2520 11 adherents adherent NNS 19613 2520 12 in in IN 19613 2520 13 the the DT 19613 2520 14 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2520 15 , , , 19613 2520 16 and and CC 19613 2520 17 for for IN 19613 2520 18 this this DT 19613 2520 19 reason reason NN 19613 2520 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2520 21 believed believe VBD 19613 2520 22 in in IN 19613 2520 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2520 24 . . . 19613 2521 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2521 2 207 207 CD 19613 2521 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2521 4 The the DT 19613 2521 5 belief belief NN 19613 2521 6 in in IN 19613 2521 7 the the DT 19613 2521 8 efficacy efficacy NN 19613 2521 9 of of IN 19613 2521 10 the the DT 19613 2521 11 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2521 12 , , , 19613 2521 13 who who WP 19613 2521 14 , , , 19613 2521 15 in in IN 19613 2521 16 order order NN 19613 2521 17 to to TO 19613 2521 18 establish establish VB 19613 2521 19 a a DT 19613 2521 20 relatively relatively RB 19613 2521 21 stricter strict JJR 19613 2521 22 standard standard NN 19613 2521 23 of of IN 19613 2521 24 conduct conduct NN 19613 2521 25 in in IN 19613 2521 26 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2521 27 during during IN 19613 2521 28 the the DT 19613 2521 29 latter latter JJ 19613 2521 30 days day NNS 19613 2521 31 , , , 19613 2521 32 had have VBD 19613 2521 33 , , , 19613 2521 34 a a DT 19613 2521 35 few few JJ 19613 2521 36 decades decade NNS 19613 2521 37 before before RB 19613 2521 38 , , , 19613 2521 39 for for IN 19613 2521 40 several several JJ 19613 2521 41 years year NNS 19613 2521 42 given give VBN 19613 2521 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2521 44 revelations revelation NNS 19613 2521 45 in in IN 19613 2521 46 a a DT 19613 2521 47 remote remote JJ 19613 2521 48 corner corner NN 19613 2521 49 of of IN 19613 2521 50 the the DT 19613 2521 51 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2521 52 , , , 19613 2521 53 was be VBD 19613 2521 54 the the DT 19613 2521 55 dregs dreg NNS 19613 2521 56 of of IN 19613 2521 57 the the DT 19613 2521 58 original original JJ 19613 2521 59 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 2521 60 , , , 19613 2521 61 the the DT 19613 2521 62 real real JJ 19613 2521 63 aspect aspect NN 19613 2521 64 of of IN 19613 2521 65 which which WDT 19613 2521 66 had have VBD 19613 2521 67 been be VBN 19613 2521 68 known know VBN 19613 2521 69 only only RB 19613 2521 70 to to IN 19613 2521 71 the the DT 19613 2521 72 fewest few JJS 19613 2521 73 . . . 19613 2522 1 But but CC 19613 2522 2 the the DT 19613 2522 3 diluted diluted JJ 19613 2522 4 form form NN 19613 2522 5 in in IN 19613 2522 6 which which WDT 19613 2522 7 this this DT 19613 2522 8 force force NN 19613 2522 9 remained remain VBD 19613 2522 10 was be VBD 19613 2522 11 still still RB 19613 2522 12 a a DT 19613 2522 13 mighty mighty JJ 19613 2522 14 power power NN 19613 2522 15 , , , 19613 2522 16 because because IN 19613 2522 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2522 18 was be VBD 19613 2522 19 just just RB 19613 2522 20 in in IN 19613 2522 21 the the DT 19613 2522 22 generation generation NN 19613 2522 23 between between IN 19613 2522 24 190 190 CD 19613 2522 25 and and CC 19613 2522 26 220 220 CD 19613 2522 27 that that IN 19613 2522 28 the the DT 19613 2522 29 secularising secularising NN 19613 2522 30 of of IN 19613 2522 31 the the DT 19613 2522 32 Church Church NNP 19613 2522 33 had have VBD 19613 2522 34 made make VBN 19613 2522 35 the the DT 19613 2522 36 greatest great JJS 19613 2522 37 strides stride NNS 19613 2522 38 . . . 19613 2523 1 Though though IN 19613 2523 2 the the DT 19613 2523 3 followers follower NNS 19613 2523 4 of of IN 19613 2523 5 the the DT 19613 2523 6 new new JJ 19613 2523 7 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2523 8 merely merely RB 19613 2523 9 insisted insist VBD 19613 2523 10 on on IN 19613 2523 11 abstinence abstinence NN 19613 2523 12 from from IN 19613 2523 13 second second JJ 19613 2523 14 marriage marriage NN 19613 2523 15 , , , 19613 2523 16 on on IN 19613 2523 17 stricter strict JJR 19613 2523 18 regulations regulation NNS 19613 2523 19 with with IN 19613 2523 20 regard regard NN 19613 2523 21 to to IN 19613 2523 22 fasts fast NNS 19613 2523 23 , , , 19613 2523 24 on on IN 19613 2523 25 a a DT 19613 2523 26 stronger strong JJR 19613 2523 27 manifestation manifestation NN 19613 2523 28 of of IN 19613 2523 29 the the DT 19613 2523 30 Christian christian JJ 19613 2523 31 spirit spirit NN 19613 2523 32 in in IN 19613 2523 33 daily daily JJ 19613 2523 34 life life NN 19613 2523 35 , , , 19613 2523 36 in in IN 19613 2523 37 morals moral NNS 19613 2523 38 and and CC 19613 2523 39 customs custom NNS 19613 2523 40 , , , 19613 2523 41 and and CC 19613 2523 42 finally finally RB 19613 2523 43 on on IN 19613 2523 44 the the DT 19613 2523 45 full full JJ 19613 2523 46 resolve resolve NN 19613 2523 47 not not RB 19613 2523 48 to to TO 19613 2523 49 avoid avoid VB 19613 2523 50 suffering suffering NN 19613 2523 51 and and CC 19613 2523 52 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 2523 53 for for IN 19613 2523 54 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2523 55 's 's POS 19613 2523 56 name name NN 19613 2523 57 's 's POS 19613 2523 58 sake sake NN 19613 2523 59 , , , 19613 2523 60 but but CC 19613 2523 61 to to TO 19613 2523 62 bear bear VB 19613 2523 63 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2523 64 willingly willingly RB 19613 2523 65 and and CC 19613 2523 66 joyfully,[208 joyfully,[208 NNP 19613 2523 67 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2523 68 yet yet RB 19613 2523 69 , , , 19613 2523 70 under under IN 19613 2523 71 the the DT 19613 2523 72 given give VBN 19613 2523 73 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2523 74 , , , 19613 2523 75 these these DT 19613 2523 76 requirements requirement NNS 19613 2523 77 , , , 19613 2523 78 in in IN 19613 2523 79 spite spite NN 19613 2523 80 of of IN 19613 2523 81 the the DT 19613 2523 82 express express JJ 19613 2523 83 repudiation repudiation NN 19613 2523 84 of of IN 19613 2523 85 everything everything NN 19613 2523 86 " " '' 19613 2523 87 Encratite,"[209 encratite,"[209 NN 19613 2523 88 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2523 89 implied imply VBD 19613 2523 90 a a DT 19613 2523 91 demand demand NN 19613 2523 92 that that WDT 19613 2523 93 directly directly RB 19613 2523 94 endangered endanger VBD 19613 2523 95 the the DT 19613 2523 96 conquests conquest NNS 19613 2523 97 already already RB 19613 2523 98 made make VBN 19613 2523 99 by by IN 19613 2523 100 the the DT 19613 2523 101 Church Church NNP 19613 2523 102 and and CC 19613 2523 103 impeded impede VBD 19613 2523 104 the the DT 19613 2523 105 progress progress NN 19613 2523 106 of of IN 19613 2523 107 the the DT 19613 2523 108 new new JJ 19613 2523 109 propaganda propaganda NN 19613 2523 110 . . . 19613 2524 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2524 2 210 210 CD 19613 2524 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2524 4 The the DT 19613 2524 5 people people NNS 19613 2524 6 who who WP 19613 2524 7 put put VBD 19613 2524 8 forth forth RP 19613 2524 9 these these DT 19613 2524 10 demands demand NNS 19613 2524 11 , , , 19613 2524 12 expressly expressly RB 19613 2524 13 based base VBD 19613 2524 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2524 15 on on IN 19613 2524 16 the the DT 19613 2524 17 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 2524 18 of of IN 19613 2524 19 the the DT 19613 2524 20 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2524 21 , , , 19613 2524 22 and and CC 19613 2524 23 really really RB 19613 2524 24 lived live VBD 19613 2524 25 in in IN 19613 2524 26 accordance accordance NN 19613 2524 27 with with IN 19613 2524 28 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2524 29 , , , 19613 2524 30 were be VBD 19613 2524 31 not not RB 19613 2524 32 permanently permanently RB 19613 2524 33 capable capable JJ 19613 2524 34 of of IN 19613 2524 35 maintaining maintain VBG 19613 2524 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2524 37 position position NN 19613 2524 38 in in IN 19613 2524 39 the the DT 19613 2524 40 Church Church NNP 19613 2524 41 . . . 19613 2525 1 In in IN 19613 2525 2 fact fact NN 19613 2525 3 , , , 19613 2525 4 the the DT 19613 2525 5 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 2525 6 to to TO 19613 2525 7 found find VBD 19613 2525 8 these these DT 19613 2525 9 demands demand NNS 19613 2525 10 on on IN 19613 2525 11 the the DT 19613 2525 12 legislation legislation NN 19613 2525 13 of of IN 19613 2525 14 the the DT 19613 2525 15 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2525 16 was be VBD 19613 2525 17 an an DT 19613 2525 18 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 2525 19 quite quite RB 19613 2525 20 as as IN 19613 2525 21 strange strange JJ 19613 2525 22 , , , 19613 2525 23 in in IN 19613 2525 24 form form NN 19613 2525 25 and and CC 19613 2525 26 content content NN 19613 2525 27 , , , 19613 2525 28 as as IN 19613 2525 29 the the DT 19613 2525 30 possible possible JJ 19613 2525 31 attempt attempt NN 19613 2525 32 to to TO 19613 2525 33 represent represent VB 19613 2525 34 the the DT 19613 2525 35 wild wild JJ 19613 2525 36 utterances utterance NNS 19613 2525 37 of of IN 19613 2525 38 determined determined JJ 19613 2525 39 anarchists anarchist NNS 19613 2525 40 as as IN 19613 2525 41 the the DT 19613 2525 42 programme programme NN 19613 2525 43 of of IN 19613 2525 44 a a DT 19613 2525 45 constitutional constitutional JJ 19613 2525 46 government government NN 19613 2525 47 . . . 19613 2526 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 2 was be VBD 19613 2526 3 of of IN 19613 2526 4 no no DT 19613 2526 5 avail avail NN 19613 2526 6 that that IN 19613 2526 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 8 appealed appeal VBD 19613 2526 9 to to IN 19613 2526 10 the the DT 19613 2526 11 confirmation confirmation NN 19613 2526 12 of of IN 19613 2526 13 the the DT 19613 2526 14 rule rule NN 19613 2526 15 of of IN 19613 2526 16 faith faith NN 19613 2526 17 by by IN 19613 2526 18 the the DT 19613 2526 19 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2526 20 ; ; : 19613 2526 21 that that IN 19613 2526 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 23 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 19613 2526 24 the the DT 19613 2526 25 harmlessness harmlessness NN 19613 2526 26 of of IN 19613 2526 27 the the DT 19613 2526 28 new new JJ 19613 2526 29 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2526 30 , , , 19613 2526 31 thereby thereby RB 19613 2526 32 involving involve VBG 19613 2526 33 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 34 in in IN 19613 2526 35 contradictions;[211 contradictions;[211 NNP 19613 2526 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2526 37 that that IN 19613 2526 38 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 39 showed show VBD 19613 2526 40 all all DT 19613 2526 41 honour honour NN 19613 2526 42 to to IN 19613 2526 43 the the DT 19613 2526 44 New New NNP 19613 2526 45 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2526 46 ; ; : 19613 2526 47 and and CC 19613 2526 48 that that IN 19613 2526 49 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 50 did do VBD 19613 2526 51 not not RB 19613 2526 52 insist insist VB 19613 2526 53 on on IN 19613 2526 54 the the DT 19613 2526 55 oracles oracle NNS 19613 2526 56 of of IN 19613 2526 57 the the DT 19613 2526 58 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2526 59 being be VBG 19613 2526 60 inserted insert VBN 19613 2526 61 in in IN 19613 2526 62 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2526 63 . . . 19613 2527 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2527 2 212 212 CD 19613 2527 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2527 4 As as RB 19613 2527 5 soon soon RB 19613 2527 6 as as IN 19613 2527 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2527 8 proved prove VBD 19613 2527 9 the the DT 19613 2527 10 earnestness earnestness NN 19613 2527 11 of of IN 19613 2527 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2527 13 temperate temperate NN 19613 2527 14 but but CC 19613 2527 15 far far RB 19613 2527 16 - - HYPH 19613 2527 17 reaching reach VBG 19613 2527 18 demands demand NNS 19613 2527 19 , , , 19613 2527 20 a a DT 19613 2527 21 deep deep JJ 19613 2527 22 gulf gulf NN 19613 2527 23 that that IN 19613 2527 24 neither neither DT 19613 2527 25 side side NN 19613 2527 26 could could MD 19613 2527 27 ignore ignore VB 19613 2527 28 opened open VBN 19613 2527 29 up up RP 19613 2527 30 between between IN 19613 2527 31 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2527 32 and and CC 19613 2527 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2527 34 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2527 35 . . . 19613 2528 1 Though though IN 19613 2528 2 here here RB 19613 2528 3 and and CC 19613 2528 4 there there RB 19613 2528 5 an an DT 19613 2528 6 earnest earnest JJ 19613 2528 7 effort effort NN 19613 2528 8 was be VBD 19613 2528 9 made make VBN 19613 2528 10 to to TO 19613 2528 11 avoid avoid VB 19613 2528 12 a a DT 19613 2528 13 schism schism NN 19613 2528 14 , , , 19613 2528 15 yet yet CC 19613 2528 16 in in IN 19613 2528 17 a a DT 19613 2528 18 short short JJ 19613 2528 19 time time NN 19613 2528 20 this this DT 19613 2528 21 became become VBD 19613 2528 22 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 2528 23 ; ; : 19613 2528 24 for for IN 19613 2528 25 variations variation NNS 19613 2528 26 in in IN 19613 2528 27 rules rule NNS 19613 2528 28 of of IN 19613 2528 29 conduct conduct NN 19613 2528 30 make make VBP 19613 2528 31 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2528 32 impossible impossible JJ 19613 2528 33 . . . 19613 2529 1 The the DT 19613 2529 2 lax lax NN 19613 2529 3 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2529 4 , , , 19613 2529 5 who who WP 19613 2529 6 , , , 19613 2529 7 on on IN 19613 2529 8 the the DT 19613 2529 9 strength strength NN 19613 2529 10 of of IN 19613 2529 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2529 12 objective objective JJ 19613 2529 13 possession possession NN 19613 2529 14 , , , 19613 2529 15 viz viz NNP 19613 2529 16 . . NNP 19613 2529 17 , , , 19613 2529 18 the the DT 19613 2529 19 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2529 20 doctrine doctrine NNP 19613 2529 21 and and CC 19613 2529 22 writings writing NNS 19613 2529 23 , , , 19613 2529 24 sought seek VBD 19613 2529 25 to to TO 19613 2529 26 live live VB 19613 2529 27 comfortably comfortably RB 19613 2529 28 by by IN 19613 2529 29 conforming conform VBG 19613 2529 30 to to IN 19613 2529 31 the the DT 19613 2529 32 ways way NNS 19613 2529 33 of of IN 19613 2529 34 the the DT 19613 2529 35 world world NN 19613 2529 36 , , , 19613 2529 37 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 2529 38 sought seek VBN 19613 2529 39 to to TO 19613 2529 40 rid rid VB 19613 2529 41 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2529 42 of of IN 19613 2529 43 inconvenient inconvenient JJ 19613 2529 44 societies society NNS 19613 2529 45 and and CC 19613 2529 46 inconvenient inconvenient NN 19613 2529 47 monitors;[213 monitors;[213 CD 19613 2529 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2529 49 and and CC 19613 2529 50 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2529 51 could could MD 19613 2529 52 only only RB 19613 2529 53 do do VB 19613 2529 54 so so RB 19613 2529 55 by by IN 19613 2529 56 reproaching reproach VBG 19613 2529 57 the the DT 19613 2529 58 latter latter JJ 19613 2529 59 with with IN 19613 2529 60 heresy heresy NN 19613 2529 61 and and CC 19613 2529 62 unchristian unchristian JJ 19613 2529 63 assumptions assumption NNS 19613 2529 64 . . . 19613 2530 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2530 2 , , , 19613 2530 3 the the DT 19613 2530 4 followers follower NNS 19613 2530 5 of of IN 19613 2530 6 the the DT 19613 2530 7 new new JJ 19613 2530 8 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2530 9 could could MD 19613 2530 10 not not RB 19613 2530 11 permanently permanently RB 19613 2530 12 recognise recognise VB 19613 2530 13 the the DT 19613 2530 14 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2530 15 of of IN 19613 2530 16 the the DT 19613 2530 17 " " `` 19613 2530 18 Psychical,"[214 psychical,"[214 NN 19613 2530 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2530 20 which which WDT 19613 2530 21 rejected reject VBD 19613 2530 22 the the DT 19613 2530 23 " " `` 19613 2530 24 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2530 25 " " '' 19613 2530 26 and and CC 19613 2530 27 extended extend VBD 19613 2530 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2530 29 toleration toleration NN 19613 2530 30 so so RB 19613 2530 31 far far RB 19613 2530 32 as as IN 19613 2530 33 to to TO 19613 2530 34 retain retain VB 19613 2530 35 even even RB 19613 2530 36 whoremongers whoremonger NNS 19613 2530 37 and and CC 19613 2530 38 adulterers adulterer NNS 19613 2530 39 within within IN 19613 2530 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2530 41 pale pale NN 19613 2530 42 . . . 19613 2531 1 In in IN 19613 2531 2 the the DT 19613 2531 3 East East NNP 19613 2531 4 , , , 19613 2531 5 that that RB 19613 2531 6 is is RB 19613 2531 7 , , , 19613 2531 8 in in IN 19613 2531 9 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2531 10 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2531 11 , , , 19613 2531 12 the the DT 19613 2531 13 breach breach NN 19613 2531 14 between between IN 19613 2531 15 the the DT 19613 2531 16 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2531 17 and and CC 19613 2531 18 the the DT 19613 2531 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2531 20 had have VBD 19613 2531 21 in in IN 19613 2531 22 all all DT 19613 2531 23 probability probability NN 19613 2531 24 broken break VBN 19613 2531 25 out out RP 19613 2531 26 before before IN 19613 2531 27 the the DT 19613 2531 28 question question NN 19613 2531 29 of of IN 19613 2531 30 Church Church NNP 19613 2531 31 discipline discipline NN 19613 2531 32 and and CC 19613 2531 33 the the DT 19613 2531 34 right right NN 19613 2531 35 of of IN 19613 2531 36 the the DT 19613 2531 37 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2531 38 had have VBD 19613 2531 39 yet yet RB 19613 2531 40 been be VBN 19613 2531 41 clearly clearly RB 19613 2531 42 raised raise VBN 19613 2531 43 . . . 19613 2532 1 In in IN 19613 2532 2 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2532 3 and and CC 19613 2532 4 Carthage carthage VB 19613 2532 5 this this DT 19613 2532 6 question question NN 19613 2532 7 completed complete VBD 19613 2532 8 the the DT 19613 2532 9 rupture rupture NN 19613 2532 10 that that WDT 19613 2532 11 had have VBD 19613 2532 12 already already RB 19613 2532 13 taken take VBN 19613 2532 14 place place NN 19613 2532 15 between between IN 19613 2532 16 the the DT 19613 2532 17 conventicles conventicle NNS 19613 2532 18 and and CC 19613 2532 19 the the DT 19613 2532 20 Church Church NNP 19613 2532 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2532 22 de de FW 19613 2532 23 pudic pudic JJ 19613 2532 24 . . . 19613 2533 1 1 1 LS 19613 2533 2 . . . 19613 2534 1 21 21 CD 19613 2534 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2534 3 . . . 19613 2535 1 Here here RB 19613 2535 2 , , , 19613 2535 3 by by IN 19613 2535 4 a a DT 19613 2535 5 peremptory peremptory JJ 19613 2535 6 edict edict NN 19613 2535 7 , , , 19613 2535 8 the the DT 19613 2535 9 bishop bishop NN 19613 2535 10 of of IN 19613 2535 11 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2535 12 claimed claim VBD 19613 2535 13 the the DT 19613 2535 14 right right NN 19613 2535 15 of of IN 19613 2535 16 forgiving forgiving JJ 19613 2535 17 sins sin NNS 19613 2535 18 as as IN 19613 2535 19 successor successor NN 19613 2535 20 of of IN 19613 2535 21 the the DT 19613 2535 22 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2535 23 ; ; : 19613 2535 24 and and CC 19613 2535 25 declared declare VBD 19613 2535 26 that that IN 19613 2535 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2535 28 would would MD 19613 2535 29 henceforth henceforth RB 19613 2535 30 exercise exercise VB 19613 2535 31 this this DT 19613 2535 32 right right NN 19613 2535 33 in in IN 19613 2535 34 favour favour NN 19613 2535 35 of of IN 19613 2535 36 repentant repentant JJ 19613 2535 37 adulterers adulterer NNS 19613 2535 38 . . . 19613 2536 1 Among among IN 19613 2536 2 the the DT 19613 2536 3 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2536 4 this this DT 19613 2536 5 claim claim NN 19613 2536 6 was be VBD 19613 2536 7 violently violently RB 19613 2536 8 contested contest VBN 19613 2536 9 both both CC 19613 2536 10 in in IN 19613 2536 11 an an DT 19613 2536 12 abstract abstract JJ 19613 2536 13 sense sense NN 19613 2536 14 and and CC 19613 2536 15 in in IN 19613 2536 16 this this DT 19613 2536 17 application application NN 19613 2536 18 of of IN 19613 2536 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2536 20 . . . 19613 2537 1 The the DT 19613 2537 2 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2537 3 the the DT 19613 2537 4 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2537 5 had have VBD 19613 2537 6 received receive VBN 19613 2537 7 , , , 19613 2537 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2537 9 said say VBD 19613 2537 10 , , , 19613 2537 11 could could MD 19613 2537 12 not not RB 19613 2537 13 be be VB 19613 2537 14 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 2537 15 ; ; : 19613 2537 16 the the DT 19613 2537 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2537 18 is be VBZ 19613 2537 19 given give VBN 19613 2537 20 to to IN 19613 2537 21 the the DT 19613 2537 22 Church church NN 19613 2537 23 ; ; : 19613 2537 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2537 25 works work VBZ 19613 2537 26 in in IN 19613 2537 27 the the DT 19613 2537 28 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2537 29 , , , 19613 2537 30 but but CC 19613 2537 31 lastly lastly RB 19613 2537 32 and and CC 19613 2537 33 in in IN 19613 2537 34 the the DT 19613 2537 35 highest high JJS 19613 2537 36 measure measure NN 19613 2537 37 in in IN 19613 2537 38 the the DT 19613 2537 39 new new JJ 19613 2537 40 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2537 41 . . . 19613 2538 1 The the DT 19613 2538 2 latter latter JJ 19613 2538 3 , , , 19613 2538 4 however however RB 19613 2538 5 , , , 19613 2538 6 expressly expressly RB 19613 2538 7 refused refuse VBD 19613 2538 8 to to TO 19613 2538 9 readmit readmit VB 19613 2538 10 gross gross JJ 19613 2538 11 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2538 12 , , , 19613 2538 13 though though IN 19613 2538 14 recommending recommend VBG 19613 2538 15 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2538 16 to to IN 19613 2538 17 the the DT 19613 2538 18 grace grace NN 19613 2538 19 of of IN 19613 2538 20 God God NNP 19613 2538 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2538 22 see see VB 19613 2538 23 the the DT 19613 2538 24 saying saying NN 19613 2538 25 of of IN 19613 2538 26 the the DT 19613 2538 27 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 2538 28 , , , 19613 2538 29 de de FW 19613 2538 30 pud pud NNP 19613 2538 31 . . . 19613 2539 1 21 21 CD 19613 2539 2 ; ; : 19613 2539 3 " " `` 19613 2539 4 potest potest NNP 19613 2539 5 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2539 6 donare donare NNP 19613 2539 7 delictum delictum NNP 19613 2539 8 , , , 19613 2539 9 sed se VBD 19613 2539 10 non non AFX 19613 2539 11 faciam faciam NNP 19613 2539 12 " " '' 19613 2539 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2539 14 . . . 19613 2540 1 Thus thus RB 19613 2540 2 agreement agreement NN 19613 2540 3 was be VBD 19613 2540 4 no no RB 19613 2540 5 longer long RBR 19613 2540 6 possible possible JJ 19613 2540 7 . . . 19613 2541 1 The the DT 19613 2541 2 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2541 3 were be VBD 19613 2541 4 determined determined JJ 19613 2541 5 to to TO 19613 2541 6 assert assert VB 19613 2541 7 the the DT 19613 2541 8 existing exist VBG 19613 2541 9 claims claim NNS 19613 2541 10 of of IN 19613 2541 11 the the DT 19613 2541 12 Church Church NNP 19613 2541 13 , , , 19613 2541 14 even even RB 19613 2541 15 at at IN 19613 2541 16 the the DT 19613 2541 17 cost cost NN 19613 2541 18 of of IN 19613 2541 19 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2541 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 2541 21 character character NN 19613 2541 22 , , , 19613 2541 23 or or CC 19613 2541 24 to to TO 19613 2541 25 represent represent VB 19613 2541 26 the the DT 19613 2541 27 constitution constitution NN 19613 2541 28 of of IN 19613 2541 29 the the DT 19613 2541 30 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2541 31 Church Church NNP 19613 2541 32 as as IN 19613 2541 33 the the DT 19613 2541 34 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 2541 35 of of IN 19613 2541 36 that that DT 19613 2541 37 character character NN 19613 2541 38 . . . 19613 2542 1 At at IN 19613 2542 2 the the DT 19613 2542 3 risk risk NN 19613 2542 4 of of IN 19613 2542 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2542 6 own own JJ 19613 2542 7 claim claim NN 19613 2542 8 to to TO 19613 2542 9 be be VB 19613 2542 10 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2542 11 , , , 19613 2542 12 the the DT 19613 2542 13 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2542 14 sects sect NNS 19613 2542 15 resisted resist VBN 19613 2542 16 in in IN 19613 2542 17 order order NN 19613 2542 18 to to TO 19613 2542 19 preserve preserve VB 19613 2542 20 the the DT 19613 2542 21 minimum minimum JJ 19613 2542 22 legal legal JJ 19613 2542 23 requirements requirement NNS 19613 2542 24 for for IN 19613 2542 25 a a DT 19613 2542 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 2542 27 life life NN 19613 2542 28 . . . 19613 2543 1 Thus thus RB 19613 2543 2 the the DT 19613 2543 3 opposition opposition NN 19613 2543 4 culminated culminate VBD 19613 2543 5 in in IN 19613 2543 6 an an DT 19613 2543 7 attack attack NN 19613 2543 8 on on IN 19613 2543 9 the the DT 19613 2543 10 new new JJ 19613 2543 11 powers power NNS 19613 2543 12 claimed claim VBN 19613 2543 13 by by IN 19613 2543 14 the the DT 19613 2543 15 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2543 16 , , , 19613 2543 17 and and CC 19613 2543 18 in in IN 19613 2543 19 consequence consequence NNP 19613 2543 20 awakened awaken VBD 19613 2543 21 old old JJ 19613 2543 22 memories memory NNS 19613 2543 23 as as IN 19613 2543 24 to to IN 19613 2543 25 the the DT 19613 2543 26 original original JJ 19613 2543 27 state state NN 19613 2543 28 of of IN 19613 2543 29 things thing NNS 19613 2543 30 , , , 19613 2543 31 when when WRB 19613 2543 32 the the DT 19613 2543 33 clergy clergy NN 19613 2543 34 had have VBD 19613 2543 35 possessed possess VBN 19613 2543 36 no no DT 19613 2543 37 importance importance NN 19613 2543 38 . . . 19613 2544 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2544 2 215 215 CD 19613 2544 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2544 4 But but CC 19613 2544 5 the the DT 19613 2544 6 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 2544 7 motive motive NN 19613 2544 8 was be VBD 19613 2544 9 the the DT 19613 2544 10 effort effort NN 19613 2544 11 to to TO 19613 2544 12 stop stop VB 19613 2544 13 the the DT 19613 2544 14 continuous continuous JJ 19613 2544 15 secularising secularising NN 19613 2544 16 of of IN 19613 2544 17 the the DT 19613 2544 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 2544 19 life life NN 19613 2544 20 and and CC 19613 2544 21 to to TO 19613 2544 22 preserve preserve VB 19613 2544 23 the the DT 19613 2544 24 virginity virginity NN 19613 2544 25 of of IN 19613 2544 26 the the DT 19613 2544 27 Church Church NNP 19613 2544 28 as as IN 19613 2544 29 a a DT 19613 2544 30 holy holy JJ 19613 2544 31 community community NN 19613 2544 32 . . . 19613 2545 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2545 2 216 216 CD 19613 2545 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2545 4 In in IN 19613 2545 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2545 6 latest late JJS 19613 2545 7 writings writing NNS 19613 2545 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2545 9 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 2545 10 defended defend VBD 19613 2545 11 a a DT 19613 2545 12 position position NN 19613 2545 13 already already RB 19613 2545 14 lost lose VBN 19613 2545 15 , , , 19613 2545 16 and and CC 19613 2545 17 carried carry VBN 19613 2545 18 with with IN 19613 2545 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2545 20 to to IN 19613 2545 21 the the DT 19613 2545 22 grave grave NN 19613 2545 23 the the DT 19613 2545 24 old old JJ 19613 2545 25 strictness strictness NN 19613 2545 26 of of IN 19613 2545 27 conduct conduct NN 19613 2545 28 insisted insist VBN 19613 2545 29 on on IN 19613 2545 30 by by IN 19613 2545 31 the the DT 19613 2545 32 Church Church NNP 19613 2545 33 . . . 19613 2546 1 Had have VBD 19613 2546 2 victory victory NN 19613 2546 3 remained remain VBD 19613 2546 4 with with IN 19613 2546 5 the the DT 19613 2546 6 stricter strict JJR 19613 2546 7 party party NN 19613 2546 8 , , , 19613 2546 9 which which WDT 19613 2546 10 , , , 19613 2546 11 though though IN 19613 2546 12 not not RB 19613 2546 13 invariably invariably RB 19613 2546 14 , , , 19613 2546 15 appealed appeal VBD 19613 2546 16 to to IN 19613 2546 17 the the DT 19613 2546 18 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 2546 19 of of IN 19613 2546 20 the the DT 19613 2546 21 Paraclete,[217 paraclete,[217 JJ 19613 2546 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2546 23 the the DT 19613 2546 24 Church Church NNP 19613 2546 25 would would MD 19613 2546 26 have have VB 19613 2546 27 been be VBN 19613 2546 28 rent rent NN 19613 2546 29 asunder asunder RB 19613 2546 30 and and CC 19613 2546 31 decimated decimate VBN 19613 2546 32 . . . 19613 2547 1 The the DT 19613 2547 2 great great JJ 19613 2547 3 opportunist opportunist JJ 19613 2547 4 party party NN 19613 2547 5 , , , 19613 2547 6 however however RB 19613 2547 7 , , , 19613 2547 8 was be VBD 19613 2547 9 in in IN 19613 2547 10 a a DT 19613 2547 11 very very RB 19613 2547 12 difficult difficult JJ 19613 2547 13 position position NN 19613 2547 14 , , , 19613 2547 15 since since IN 19613 2547 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2547 17 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2547 18 merely merely RB 19613 2547 19 seemed seem VBD 19613 2547 20 to to TO 19613 2547 21 be be VB 19613 2547 22 acting act VBG 19613 2547 23 up up IN 19613 2547 24 to to IN 19613 2547 25 a a DT 19613 2547 26 conception conception NN 19613 2547 27 that that IN 19613 2547 28 , , , 19613 2547 29 in in IN 19613 2547 30 many many JJ 19613 2547 31 respects respect NNS 19613 2547 32 , , , 19613 2547 33 could could MD 19613 2547 34 not not RB 19613 2547 35 be be VB 19613 2547 36 theoretically theoretically RB 19613 2547 37 disputed dispute VBN 19613 2547 38 . . . 19613 2548 1 The the DT 19613 2548 2 problem problem NN 19613 2548 3 was be VBD 19613 2548 4 how how WRB 19613 2548 5 to to TO 19613 2548 6 carry carry VB 19613 2548 7 on on RP 19613 2548 8 with with IN 19613 2548 9 caution caution NN 19613 2548 10 the the DT 19613 2548 11 work work NN 19613 2548 12 of of IN 19613 2548 13 naturalising naturalise VBG 19613 2548 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2548 15 in in IN 19613 2548 16 the the DT 19613 2548 17 world world NN 19613 2548 18 , , , 19613 2548 19 and and CC 19613 2548 20 at at IN 19613 2548 21 the the DT 19613 2548 22 same same JJ 19613 2548 23 time time NN 19613 2548 24 avoid avoid VB 19613 2548 25 all all DT 19613 2548 26 appearance appearance NN 19613 2548 27 of of IN 19613 2548 28 innovation innovation NN 19613 2548 29 which which WDT 19613 2548 30 , , , 19613 2548 31 as as IN 19613 2548 32 such such JJ 19613 2548 33 , , , 19613 2548 34 was be VBD 19613 2548 35 opposed opposed JJ 19613 2548 36 to to IN 19613 2548 37 the the DT 19613 2548 38 principle principle NN 19613 2548 39 of of IN 19613 2548 40 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2548 41 . . . 19613 2549 1 The the DT 19613 2549 2 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2549 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 2549 4 assailed assail VBD 19613 2549 5 the the DT 19613 2549 6 form form NN 19613 2549 7 of of IN 19613 2549 8 the the DT 19613 2549 9 new new JJ 19613 2549 10 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2549 11 on on IN 19613 2549 12 the the DT 19613 2549 13 ground ground NN 19613 2549 14 of of IN 19613 2549 15 innovation;[218 innovation;[218 NNP 19613 2549 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2549 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2549 18 sought seek VBD 19613 2549 19 to to TO 19613 2549 20 throw throw VB 19613 2549 21 suspicion suspicion NN 19613 2549 22 on on IN 19613 2549 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2549 24 content content NN 19613 2549 25 ; ; : 19613 2549 26 in in IN 19613 2549 27 some some DT 19613 2549 28 cases case NNS 19613 2549 29 even even RB 19613 2549 30 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 2549 31 , , , 19613 2549 32 as as IN 19613 2549 33 represented represent VBN 19613 2549 34 by by IN 19613 2549 35 the the DT 19613 2549 36 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2549 37 , , , 19613 2549 38 was be VBD 19613 2549 39 declared declare VBN 19613 2549 40 to to TO 19613 2549 41 have have VB 19613 2549 42 a a DT 19613 2549 43 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 2549 44 and and CC 19613 2549 45 fleshly fleshly JJ 19613 2549 46 character character NN 19613 2549 47 . . . 19613 2550 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2550 2 219 219 CD 19613 2550 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2550 4 They -PRON- PRP 19613 2550 5 tried try VBD 19613 2550 6 to to TO 19613 2550 7 show show VB 19613 2550 8 that that IN 19613 2550 9 the the DT 19613 2550 10 moral moral JJ 19613 2550 11 demands demand NNS 19613 2550 12 of of IN 19613 2550 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2550 14 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2550 15 were be VBD 19613 2550 16 extravagant extravagant JJ 19613 2550 17 , , , 19613 2550 18 that that IN 19613 2550 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2550 20 savoured savour VBD 19613 2550 21 of of IN 19613 2550 22 the the DT 19613 2550 23 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 2550 24 law law NN 19613 2550 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2550 26 of of IN 19613 2550 27 the the DT 19613 2550 28 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 2550 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2550 30 , , , 19613 2550 31 were be VBD 19613 2550 32 opposed opposed JJ 19613 2550 33 to to IN 19613 2550 34 Scripture scripture NN 19613 2550 35 , , , 19613 2550 36 and and CC 19613 2550 37 were be VBD 19613 2550 38 derived derive VBN 19613 2550 39 from from IN 19613 2550 40 the the DT 19613 2550 41 worship worship NN 19613 2550 42 of of IN 19613 2550 43 Apis Apis NNP 19613 2550 44 , , , 19613 2550 45 Isis Isis NNP 19613 2550 46 , , , 19613 2550 47 and and CC 19613 2550 48 the the DT 19613 2550 49 mother mother NN 19613 2550 50 of of IN 19613 2550 51 the the DT 19613 2550 52 Gods Gods NNPS 19613 2550 53 . . . 19613 2551 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2551 2 220 220 CD 19613 2551 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2551 4 To to IN 19613 2551 5 the the DT 19613 2551 6 claim claim NN 19613 2551 7 of of IN 19613 2551 8 furnishing furnish VBG 19613 2551 9 the the DT 19613 2551 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2551 11 with with IN 19613 2551 12 authentic authentic JJ 19613 2551 13 oracles oracle NNS 19613 2551 14 of of IN 19613 2551 15 God God NNP 19613 2551 16 , , , 19613 2551 17 set set VBN 19613 2551 18 up up RP 19613 2551 19 by by IN 19613 2551 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2551 21 antagonists antagonist NNS 19613 2551 22 , , , 19613 2551 23 the the DT 19613 2551 24 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2551 25 opposed oppose VBD 19613 2551 26 the the DT 19613 2551 27 newly newly RB 19613 2551 28 formed form VBN 19613 2551 29 canon canon NNP 19613 2551 30 ; ; : 19613 2551 31 and and CC 19613 2551 32 declared declare VBD 19613 2551 33 that that IN 19613 2551 34 everything everything NN 19613 2551 35 binding bind VBG 19613 2551 36 on on IN 19613 2551 37 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2551 38 was be VBD 19613 2551 39 contained contain VBN 19613 2551 40 in in IN 19613 2551 41 the the DT 19613 2551 42 utterances utterance NNS 19613 2551 43 of of IN 19613 2551 44 the the DT 19613 2551 45 Old Old NNP 19613 2551 46 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2551 47 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2551 48 and and CC 19613 2551 49 the the DT 19613 2551 50 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2551 51 . . . 19613 2552 1 Finally finally RB 19613 2552 2 , , , 19613 2552 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2552 4 began begin VBD 19613 2552 5 to to TO 19613 2552 6 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 2552 7 between between IN 19613 2552 8 the the DT 19613 2552 9 standard standard NN 19613 2552 10 of of IN 19613 2552 11 morality morality NN 19613 2552 12 incumbent incumbent NN 19613 2552 13 on on IN 19613 2552 14 the the DT 19613 2552 15 clergy clergy NN 19613 2552 16 and and CC 19613 2552 17 a a DT 19613 2552 18 different different JJ 19613 2552 19 one one NN 19613 2552 20 applying apply VBG 19613 2552 21 to to IN 19613 2552 22 the the DT 19613 2552 23 laity,[221 laity,[221 NN 19613 2552 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2552 25 as as IN 19613 2552 26 , , , 19613 2552 27 for for IN 19613 2552 28 instance instance NN 19613 2552 29 , , , 19613 2552 30 in in IN 19613 2552 31 the the DT 19613 2552 32 question question NN 19613 2552 33 of of IN 19613 2552 34 a a DT 19613 2552 35 single single JJ 19613 2552 36 marriage marriage NN 19613 2552 37 ; ; : 19613 2552 38 and and CC 19613 2552 39 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2552 40 dwelt dwelt VBP 19613 2552 41 with with IN 19613 2552 42 increased increase VBN 19613 2552 43 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 2552 44 on on IN 19613 2552 45 the the DT 19613 2552 46 glory glory NN 19613 2552 47 of of IN 19613 2552 48 the the DT 19613 2552 49 heroic heroic JJ 19613 2552 50 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2552 51 , , , 19613 2552 52 _ _ NNP 19613 2552 53 belonging belong VBG 19613 2552 54 to to IN 19613 2552 55 the the DT 19613 2552 56 great great JJ 19613 2552 57 Church Church NNP 19613 2552 58 _ _ NNP 19613 2552 59 , , , 19613 2552 60 who who WP 19613 2552 61 had have VBD 19613 2552 62 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 2552 63 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2552 64 by by IN 19613 2552 65 asceticism asceticism NN 19613 2552 66 and and CC 19613 2552 67 joyful joyful JJ 19613 2552 68 submission submission NN 19613 2552 69 to to IN 19613 2552 70 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 2552 71 . . . 19613 2553 1 By by IN 19613 2553 2 these these DT 19613 2553 3 methods method NNS 19613 2553 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2553 5 brought bring VBD 19613 2553 6 into into IN 19613 2553 7 disrepute disrepute NN 19613 2553 8 that that WDT 19613 2553 9 which which WDT 19613 2553 10 had have VBD 19613 2553 11 once once RB 19613 2553 12 been be VBN 19613 2553 13 dear dear JJ 19613 2553 14 to to IN 19613 2553 15 the the DT 19613 2553 16 whole whole JJ 19613 2553 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2553 18 , , , 19613 2553 19 but but CC 19613 2553 20 was be VBD 19613 2553 21 now now RB 19613 2553 22 of of IN 19613 2553 23 no no DT 19613 2553 24 further further JJ 19613 2553 25 service service NN 19613 2553 26 . . . 19613 2554 1 In in IN 19613 2554 2 repudiating repudiate VBG 19613 2554 3 supposed suppose VBN 19613 2554 4 abuses abuse NNS 19613 2554 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2554 6 more more RBR 19613 2554 7 and and CC 19613 2554 8 more more RBR 19613 2554 9 weakened weaken VBD 19613 2554 10 the the DT 19613 2554 11 regard regard NN 19613 2554 12 felt feel VBD 19613 2554 13 for for IN 19613 2554 14 the the DT 19613 2554 15 thing thing NN 19613 2554 16 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2554 17 , , , 19613 2554 18 as as IN 19613 2554 19 , , , 19613 2554 20 for for IN 19613 2554 21 example example NN 19613 2554 22 , , , 19613 2554 23 in in IN 19613 2554 24 the the DT 19613 2554 25 case case NN 19613 2554 26 of of IN 19613 2554 27 the the DT 19613 2554 28 so so RB 19613 2554 29 - - HYPH 19613 2554 30 called call VBN 19613 2554 31 Chiliasm,[222 Chiliasm,[222 NNP 19613 2554 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2554 33 congregational congregational JJ 19613 2554 34 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2554 35 and and CC 19613 2554 36 the the DT 19613 2554 37 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2554 38 independence independence NN 19613 2554 39 of of IN 19613 2554 40 the the DT 19613 2554 41 laity laity NN 19613 2554 42 . . . 19613 2555 1 But but CC 19613 2555 2 none none NN 19613 2555 3 of of IN 19613 2555 4 these these DT 19613 2555 5 things thing NNS 19613 2555 6 could could MD 19613 2555 7 be be VB 19613 2555 8 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 2555 9 rejected reject VBN 19613 2555 10 ; ; : 19613 2555 11 hence hence RB 19613 2555 12 , , , 19613 2555 13 for for IN 19613 2555 14 example example NN 19613 2555 15 , , , 19613 2555 16 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 2555 17 remained remain VBD 19613 2555 18 virtually virtually RB 19613 2555 19 unweakened unweakened JJ 19613 2555 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2555 21 though though IN 19613 2555 22 subject subject JJ 19613 2555 23 to to IN 19613 2555 24 limitations[223 limitations[223 NN 19613 2555 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2555 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2555 27 in in IN 19613 2555 28 the the DT 19613 2555 29 West west JJ 19613 2555 30 and and CC 19613 2555 31 certain certain JJ 19613 2555 32 districts district NNS 19613 2555 33 of of IN 19613 2555 34 the the DT 19613 2555 35 East East NNP 19613 2555 36 ; ; : 19613 2555 37 whereas whereas IN 19613 2555 38 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2555 39 lost lose VBD 19613 2555 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2555 41 force force NN 19613 2555 42 so so RB 19613 2555 43 much much RB 19613 2555 44 that that IN 19613 2555 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2555 46 appeared appear VBD 19613 2555 47 harmless harmless JJ 19613 2555 48 and and CC 19613 2555 49 therefore therefore RB 19613 2555 50 died die VBD 19613 2555 51 away away RB 19613 2555 52 . . . 19613 2556 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2556 2 224 224 CD 19613 2556 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2556 4 However however RB 19613 2556 5 , , , 19613 2556 6 the the DT 19613 2556 7 most most RBS 19613 2556 8 effective effective JJ 19613 2556 9 means mean NNS 19613 2556 10 of of IN 19613 2556 11 legitimising legitimise VBG 19613 2556 12 the the DT 19613 2556 13 present present JJ 19613 2556 14 state state NN 19613 2556 15 of of IN 19613 2556 16 things thing NNS 19613 2556 17 in in IN 19613 2556 18 the the DT 19613 2556 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2556 20 was be VBD 19613 2556 21 a a DT 19613 2556 22 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 2556 23 closely closely RB 19613 2556 24 connected connect VBN 19613 2556 25 with with IN 19613 2556 26 the the DT 19613 2556 27 formation formation NN 19613 2556 28 of of IN 19613 2556 29 a a DT 19613 2556 30 canon canon NN 19613 2556 31 of of IN 19613 2556 32 early early JJ 19613 2556 33 Christian christian JJ 19613 2556 34 writings writing NNS 19613 2556 35 , , , 19613 2556 36 viz viz NNP 19613 2556 37 . . NNP 19613 2556 38 , , , 19613 2556 39 the the DT 19613 2556 40 distinction distinction NN 19613 2556 41 of of IN 19613 2556 42 an an DT 19613 2556 43 _ _ NNP 19613 2556 44 epoch epoch NN 19613 2556 45 of of IN 19613 2556 46 revelation revelation NN 19613 2556 47 _ _ NNP 19613 2556 48 , , , 19613 2556 49 along along IN 19613 2556 50 with with IN 19613 2556 51 a a DT 19613 2556 52 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 2556 53 classical classical JJ 19613 2556 54 period period NN 19613 2556 55 of of IN 19613 2556 56 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2556 57 unattainable unattainable JJ 19613 2556 58 by by IN 19613 2556 59 later later JJ 19613 2556 60 generations generation NNS 19613 2556 61 . . . 19613 2557 1 This this DT 19613 2557 2 period period NN 19613 2557 3 was be VBD 19613 2557 4 connected connect VBN 19613 2557 5 with with IN 19613 2557 6 the the DT 19613 2557 7 present present NN 19613 2557 8 by by IN 19613 2557 9 means mean NNS 19613 2557 10 of of IN 19613 2557 11 the the DT 19613 2557 12 New New NNP 19613 2557 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2557 14 and and CC 19613 2557 15 the the DT 19613 2557 16 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2557 17 office office NNP 19613 2557 18 of of IN 19613 2557 19 the the DT 19613 2557 20 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2557 21 . . . 19613 2558 1 This this DT 19613 2558 2 later later JJ 19613 2558 3 time time NN 19613 2558 4 was be VBD 19613 2558 5 to to TO 19613 2558 6 regard regard VB 19613 2558 7 the the DT 19613 2558 8 older old JJR 19613 2558 9 period period NN 19613 2558 10 as as IN 19613 2558 11 an an DT 19613 2558 12 ideal ideal NN 19613 2558 13 , , , 19613 2558 14 but but CC 19613 2558 15 might may MD 19613 2558 16 not not RB 19613 2558 17 dream dream VB 19613 2558 18 of of IN 19613 2558 19 really really RB 19613 2558 20 attaining attain VBG 19613 2558 21 the the DT 19613 2558 22 same same JJ 19613 2558 23 perfection perfection NN 19613 2558 24 , , , 19613 2558 25 except except IN 19613 2558 26 at at IN 19613 2558 27 least least JJS 19613 2558 28 through through IN 19613 2558 29 the the DT 19613 2558 30 medium medium NN 19613 2558 31 of of IN 19613 2558 32 the the DT 19613 2558 33 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2558 34 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 2558 35 and and CC 19613 2558 36 the the DT 19613 2558 37 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2558 38 office office NN 19613 2558 39 , , , 19613 2558 40 that that RB 19613 2558 41 is is RB 19613 2558 42 , , , 19613 2558 43 the the DT 19613 2558 44 Church Church NNP 19613 2558 45 . . . 19613 2559 1 The the DT 19613 2559 2 place place NN 19613 2559 3 of of IN 19613 2559 4 the the DT 19613 2559 5 holy holy NNP 19613 2559 6 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2559 7 that that WDT 19613 2559 8 had have VBD 19613 2559 9 the the DT 19613 2559 10 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2559 11 in in IN 19613 2559 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2559 13 midst midst NN 19613 2559 14 was be VBD 19613 2559 15 taken take VBN 19613 2559 16 by by IN 19613 2559 17 the the DT 19613 2559 18 ecclesiastic ecclesiastic JJ 19613 2559 19 institution institution NN 19613 2559 20 possessing possess VBG 19613 2559 21 the the DT 19613 2559 22 " " `` 19613 2559 23 instrument instrument NN 19613 2559 24 of of IN 19613 2559 25 divine divine JJ 19613 2559 26 literature literature NN 19613 2559 27 " " '' 19613 2559 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2559 29 " " `` 19613 2559 30 instrumentum instrumentum JJ 19613 2559 31 divinæ divinæ NN 19613 2559 32 litteraturæ litteraturæ NNP 19613 2559 33 " " '' 19613 2559 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2559 35 and and CC 19613 2559 36 the the DT 19613 2559 37 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2559 38 office office NN 19613 2559 39 . . . 19613 2560 1 Finally finally RB 19613 2560 2 , , , 19613 2560 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2560 4 must must MD 19613 2560 5 mention mention VB 19613 2560 6 another another DT 19613 2560 7 factor factor NN 19613 2560 8 that that WDT 19613 2560 9 hastened hasten VBD 19613 2560 10 the the DT 19613 2560 11 various various JJ 19613 2560 12 changes change NNS 19613 2560 13 ; ; : 19613 2560 14 this this DT 19613 2560 15 was be VBD 19613 2560 16 the the DT 19613 2560 17 theology theology NN 19613 2560 18 of of IN 19613 2560 19 the the DT 19613 2560 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 2560 21 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 2560 22 , , , 19613 2560 23 which which WDT 19613 2560 24 attained attain VBD 19613 2560 25 importance importance NN 19613 2560 26 in in IN 19613 2560 27 the the DT 19613 2560 28 Church Church NNP 19613 2560 29 as as RB 19613 2560 30 soon soon RB 19613 2560 31 as as IN 19613 2560 32 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2560 33 based base VBD 19613 2560 34 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2560 35 claim claim NN 19613 2560 36 on on IN 19613 2560 37 and and CC 19613 2560 38 satisfied satisfy VBD 19613 2560 39 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2560 40 conscience conscience NN 19613 2560 41 with with IN 19613 2560 42 an an DT 19613 2560 43 objective objective JJ 19613 2560 44 possession possession NN 19613 2560 45 . . . 19613 2561 1 3 3 LS 19613 2561 2 . . . 19613 2562 1 But but CC 19613 2562 2 there there EX 19613 2562 3 was be VBD 19613 2562 4 one one CD 19613 2562 5 rule rule NN 19613 2562 6 which which WDT 19613 2562 7 specially specially RB 19613 2562 8 impeded impede VBD 19613 2562 9 the the DT 19613 2562 10 naturalisation naturalisation NN 19613 2562 11 of of IN 19613 2562 12 the the DT 19613 2562 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2562 14 in in IN 19613 2562 15 the the DT 19613 2562 16 world world NN 19613 2562 17 and and CC 19613 2562 18 the the DT 19613 2562 19 transformation transformation NN 19613 2562 20 of of IN 19613 2562 21 a a DT 19613 2562 22 communion communion NN 19613 2562 23 of of IN 19613 2562 24 the the DT 19613 2562 25 saved save VBN 19613 2562 26 into into IN 19613 2562 27 an an DT 19613 2562 28 institution institution NN 19613 2562 29 for for IN 19613 2562 30 obtaining obtain VBG 19613 2562 31 salvation salvation NN 19613 2562 32 , , , 19613 2562 33 viz viz NNP 19613 2562 34 . . NNP 19613 2562 35 , , , 19613 2562 36 the the DT 19613 2562 37 regulation regulation NN 19613 2562 38 that that WDT 19613 2562 39 excluded exclude VBD 19613 2562 40 gross gross JJ 19613 2562 41 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2562 42 from from IN 19613 2562 43 Christian christian JJ 19613 2562 44 membership membership NN 19613 2562 45 . . . 19613 2563 1 Down down IN 19613 2563 2 to to IN 19613 2563 3 the the DT 19613 2563 4 beginning beginning NN 19613 2563 5 of of IN 19613 2563 6 the the DT 19613 2563 7 third third JJ 19613 2563 8 century century NN 19613 2563 9 , , , 19613 2563 10 in in IN 19613 2563 11 so so RB 19613 2563 12 far far RB 19613 2563 13 as as IN 19613 2563 14 the the DT 19613 2563 15 backslider backslider NN 19613 2563 16 did do VBD 19613 2563 17 not not RB 19613 2563 18 atone atone VB 19613 2563 19 for for IN 19613 2563 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2563 21 guilt[225 guilt[225 NN 19613 2563 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2563 23 by by IN 19613 2563 24 public public JJ 19613 2563 25 confession confession NN 19613 2563 26 before before IN 19613 2563 27 the the DT 19613 2563 28 authorities authority NNS 19613 2563 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2563 30 see see VB 19613 2563 31 Ep Ep NNP 19613 2563 32 . . . 19613 2564 1 Lugd lugd VB 19613 2564 2 . . . 19613 2565 1 in in IN 19613 2565 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2565 3 . . NNP 19613 2565 4 , , , 19613 2565 5 H. H. NNP 19613 2565 6 E. E. NNP 19613 2565 7 V. V. NNP 19613 2565 8 1 1 CD 19613 2565 9 ff ff NNP 19613 2565 10 . . . 19613 2566 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2566 2 , , , 19613 2566 3 final final JJ 19613 2566 4 exclusion exclusion NN 19613 2566 5 from from IN 19613 2566 6 the the DT 19613 2566 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2566 8 was be VBD 19613 2566 9 still still RB 19613 2566 10 the the DT 19613 2566 11 penalty penalty NN 19613 2566 12 of of IN 19613 2566 13 relapse relapse NN 19613 2566 14 into into IN 19613 2566 15 idolatry idolatry NN 19613 2566 16 , , , 19613 2566 17 adultery adultery NN 19613 2566 18 , , , 19613 2566 19 whoredom whoredom NN 19613 2566 20 , , , 19613 2566 21 and and CC 19613 2566 22 murder murder NN 19613 2566 23 ; ; , 19613 2566 24 though though IN 19613 2566 25 at at IN 19613 2566 26 the the DT 19613 2566 27 same same JJ 19613 2566 28 time time NN 19613 2566 29 the the DT 19613 2566 30 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2566 31 of of IN 19613 2566 32 God God NNP 19613 2566 33 in in IN 19613 2566 34 the the DT 19613 2566 35 next next JJ 19613 2566 36 world world NN 19613 2566 37 was be VBD 19613 2566 38 reserved reserve VBN 19613 2566 39 for for IN 19613 2566 40 the the DT 19613 2566 41 fallen fall VBN 19613 2566 42 provided provide VBN 19613 2566 43 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2566 44 remained remain VBD 19613 2566 45 penitent penitent NN 19613 2566 46 to to IN 19613 2566 47 the the DT 19613 2566 48 end end NN 19613 2566 49 . . . 19613 2567 1 In in IN 19613 2567 2 _ _ NNP 19613 2567 3 theory theory NN 19613 2567 4 _ _ IN 19613 2567 5 indeed indeed RB 19613 2567 6 this this DT 19613 2567 7 rule rule NN 19613 2567 8 was be VBD 19613 2567 9 not not RB 19613 2567 10 very very RB 19613 2567 11 old old JJ 19613 2567 12 . . . 19613 2568 1 For for IN 19613 2568 2 the the DT 19613 2568 3 oldest old JJS 19613 2568 4 period period NN 19613 2568 5 possessed possess VBD 19613 2568 6 no no DT 19613 2568 7 theories theory NNS 19613 2568 8 ; ; : 19613 2568 9 and and CC 19613 2568 10 in in IN 19613 2568 11 those those DT 19613 2568 12 days day NNS 19613 2568 13 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2568 14 frequently frequently RB 19613 2568 15 broke break VBD 19613 2568 16 through through IN 19613 2568 17 what what WP 19613 2568 18 might may MD 19613 2568 19 have have VB 19613 2568 20 been be VBN 19613 2568 21 counted count VBN 19613 2568 22 as as IN 19613 2568 23 one one CD 19613 2568 24 by by IN 19613 2568 25 appealing appeal VBG 19613 2568 26 to to IN 19613 2568 27 the the DT 19613 2568 28 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2568 29 , , , 19613 2568 30 who who WP 19613 2568 31 , , , 19613 2568 32 by by IN 19613 2568 33 special special JJ 19613 2568 34 announcements announcement NNS 19613 2568 35 -- -- : 19613 2568 36 particularly particularly RB 19613 2568 37 by by IN 19613 2568 38 the the DT 19613 2568 39 mouth mouth NN 19613 2568 40 of of IN 19613 2568 41 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 2568 42 and and CC 19613 2568 43 prophets prophet NNS 19613 2568 44 -- -- : 19613 2568 45 commanded command VBD 19613 2568 46 or or CC 19613 2568 47 sanctioned sanction VBN 19613 2568 48 the the DT 19613 2568 49 readmission readmission NN 19613 2568 50 of of IN 19613 2568 51 lapsed lapse VBN 19613 2568 52 members member NNS 19613 2568 53 of of IN 19613 2568 54 the the DT 19613 2568 55 community community NN 19613 2568 56 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2568 57 see see VB 19613 2568 58 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 2568 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2568 60 . . . 19613 2569 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2569 2 226 226 CD 19613 2569 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2569 4 Still still RB 19613 2569 5 , , , 19613 2569 6 the the DT 19613 2569 7 rule rule NN 19613 2569 8 corresponded correspond VBD 19613 2569 9 to to IN 19613 2569 10 the the DT 19613 2569 11 ancient ancient JJ 19613 2569 12 notions notion NNS 19613 2569 13 that that IN 19613 2569 14 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2569 15 is be VBZ 19613 2569 16 a a DT 19613 2569 17 communion communion NN 19613 2569 18 of of IN 19613 2569 19 saints saint NNS 19613 2569 20 , , , 19613 2569 21 that that IN 19613 2569 22 there there EX 19613 2569 23 is be VBZ 19613 2569 24 no no DT 19613 2569 25 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 2569 26 _ _ NNP 19613 2569 27 invariably invariably RB 19613 2569 28 _ _ NNP 19613 2569 29 capable capable JJ 19613 2569 30 of of IN 19613 2569 31 replacing replace VBG 19613 2569 32 baptism baptism NN 19613 2569 33 , , , 19613 2569 34 that that RB 19613 2569 35 is is RB 19613 2569 36 , , , 19613 2569 37 possessing possess VBG 19613 2569 38 the the DT 19613 2569 39 same same JJ 19613 2569 40 value value NN 19613 2569 41 , , , 19613 2569 42 and and CC 19613 2569 43 that that IN 19613 2569 44 God God NNP 19613 2569 45 alone alone RB 19613 2569 46 can can MD 19613 2569 47 forgive forgive VB 19613 2569 48 sins sin NNS 19613 2569 49 . . . 19613 2570 1 The the DT 19613 2570 2 practice practice NN 19613 2570 3 must must MD 19613 2570 4 on on IN 19613 2570 5 the the DT 19613 2570 6 whole whole JJ 19613 2570 7 have have VBP 19613 2570 8 agreed agree VBN 19613 2570 9 with with IN 19613 2570 10 this this DT 19613 2570 11 rule rule NN 19613 2570 12 ; ; : 19613 2570 13 but but CC 19613 2570 14 in in IN 19613 2570 15 the the DT 19613 2570 16 course course NN 19613 2570 17 of of IN 19613 2570 18 the the DT 19613 2570 19 latter latter JJ 19613 2570 20 half half NN 19613 2570 21 of of IN 19613 2570 22 the the DT 19613 2570 23 second second JJ 19613 2570 24 century century NN 19613 2570 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2570 26 became become VBD 19613 2570 27 an an DT 19613 2570 28 established establish VBN 19613 2570 29 custom custom NN 19613 2570 30 , , , 19613 2570 31 in in IN 19613 2570 32 the the DT 19613 2570 33 case case NN 19613 2570 34 of of IN 19613 2570 35 a a DT 19613 2570 36 first first JJ 19613 2570 37 relapse relapse NN 19613 2570 38 , , , 19613 2570 39 to to TO 19613 2570 40 allow allow VB 19613 2570 41 atonement atonement NN 19613 2570 42 to to TO 19613 2570 43 be be VB 19613 2570 44 made make VBN 19613 2570 45 once once RB 19613 2570 46 for for IN 19613 2570 47 most most JJS 19613 2570 48 sins sin NNS 19613 2570 49 and and CC 19613 2570 50 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 2570 51 indeed indeed RB 19613 2570 52 for for IN 19613 2570 53 all all DT 19613 2570 54 , , , 19613 2570 55 on on IN 19613 2570 56 condition condition NN 19613 2570 57 of of IN 19613 2570 58 public public JJ 19613 2570 59 confession confession NN 19613 2570 60 . . . 19613 2571 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2571 2 227 227 CD 19613 2571 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2571 4 For for IN 19613 2571 5 this this DT 19613 2571 6 , , , 19613 2571 7 appeal appeal NN 19613 2571 8 was be VBD 19613 2571 9 probably probably RB 19613 2571 10 made make VBN 19613 2571 11 to to IN 19613 2571 12 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 2571 13 , , , 19613 2571 14 who who WP 19613 2571 15 very very RB 19613 2571 16 likely likely RB 19613 2571 17 owed owe VBD 19613 2571 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2571 19 prestige prestige NN 19613 2571 20 to to IN 19613 2571 21 the the DT 19613 2571 22 service service NN 19613 2571 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2571 24 here here RB 19613 2571 25 unwittingly unwittingly RB 19613 2571 26 rendered render VBN 19613 2571 27 . . . 19613 2572 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2572 2 say say VBP 19613 2572 3 " " `` 19613 2572 4 unwittingly unwittingly RB 19613 2572 5 , , , 19613 2572 6 " " '' 19613 2572 7 for for IN 19613 2572 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2572 9 could could MD 19613 2572 10 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 2572 11 have have VB 19613 2572 12 intended intend VBN 19613 2572 13 such such PDT 19613 2572 14 an an DT 19613 2572 15 application application NN 19613 2572 16 of of IN 19613 2572 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2572 18 precepts precept NNS 19613 2572 19 , , , 19613 2572 20 though though IN 19613 2572 21 at at IN 19613 2572 22 bottom bottom NN 19613 2572 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2572 24 was be VBD 19613 2572 25 not not RB 19613 2572 26 directly directly RB 19613 2572 27 opposed opposed JJ 19613 2572 28 to to IN 19613 2572 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2572 30 attitude attitude NN 19613 2572 31 . . . 19613 2573 1 In in IN 19613 2573 2 point point NN 19613 2573 3 of of IN 19613 2573 4 fact fact NN 19613 2573 5 , , , 19613 2573 6 however however RB 19613 2573 7 , , , 19613 2573 8 this this DT 19613 2573 9 practice practice NN 19613 2573 10 introduced introduce VBD 19613 2573 11 something something NN 19613 2573 12 closely closely RB 19613 2573 13 approximating approximate VBG 19613 2573 14 to to IN 19613 2573 15 a a DT 19613 2573 16 second second JJ 19613 2573 17 baptism baptism NN 19613 2573 18 . . . 19613 2574 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2574 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 2574 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2574 4 de de FW 19613 2574 5 pænit pænit NNP 19613 2574 6 . . . 19613 2575 1 12 12 LS 19613 2575 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2575 3 speaks speak VBZ 19613 2575 4 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 19613 2575 5 of of IN 19613 2575 6 _ _ NNP 19613 2575 7 two two CD 19613 2575 8 _ _ NNP 19613 2575 9 planks plank NNS 19613 2575 10 of of IN 19613 2575 11 salvation salvation NN 19613 2575 12 . . . 19613 2576 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2576 2 228 228 CD 19613 2576 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2576 4 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2576 5 , , , 19613 2576 6 if if IN 19613 2576 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2576 8 consider consider VBP 19613 2576 9 that that IN 19613 2576 10 in in IN 19613 2576 11 any any DT 19613 2576 12 particular particular JJ 19613 2576 13 case case NN 19613 2576 14 the the DT 19613 2576 15 decision decision NN 19613 2576 16 as as IN 19613 2576 17 to to IN 19613 2576 18 the the DT 19613 2576 19 deadly deadly JJ 19613 2576 20 nature nature NN 19613 2576 21 of of IN 19613 2576 22 the the DT 19613 2576 23 sin sin NN 19613 2576 24 in in IN 19613 2576 25 question question NN 19613 2576 26 was be VBD 19613 2576 27 frequently frequently RB 19613 2576 28 attended attend VBN 19613 2576 29 with with IN 19613 2576 30 great great JJ 19613 2576 31 difficulty difficulty NN 19613 2576 32 , , , 19613 2576 33 and and CC 19613 2576 34 certainly certainly RB 19613 2576 35 , , , 19613 2576 36 as as IN 19613 2576 37 a a DT 19613 2576 38 rule rule NN 19613 2576 39 , , , 19613 2576 40 was be VBD 19613 2576 41 not not RB 19613 2576 42 arrived arrive VBN 19613 2576 43 at at IN 19613 2576 44 with with IN 19613 2576 45 rigorous rigorous JJ 19613 2576 46 exactness exactness NN 19613 2576 47 , , , 19613 2576 48 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2576 49 can can MD 19613 2576 50 not not RB 19613 2576 51 fail fail VB 19613 2576 52 to to TO 19613 2576 53 see see VB 19613 2576 54 that that DT 19613 2576 55 , , , 19613 2576 56 in in IN 19613 2576 57 conceding concede VBG 19613 2576 58 a a DT 19613 2576 59 second second JJ 19613 2576 60 expiation expiation NN 19613 2576 61 , , , 19613 2576 62 the the DT 19613 2576 63 Church Church NNP 19613 2576 64 was be VBD 19613 2576 65 beginning begin VBG 19613 2576 66 to to TO 19613 2576 67 abandon abandon VB 19613 2576 68 the the DT 19613 2576 69 old old JJ 19613 2576 70 idea idea NN 19613 2576 71 that that IN 19613 2576 72 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2576 73 was be VBD 19613 2576 74 a a DT 19613 2576 75 community community NN 19613 2576 76 of of IN 19613 2576 77 saints saint NNS 19613 2576 78 . . . 19613 2577 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2577 2 the the DT 19613 2577 3 fixed fix VBN 19613 2577 4 practice practice NN 19613 2577 5 of of IN 19613 2577 6 refusing refuse VBG 19613 2577 7 whoremongers whoremonger NNS 19613 2577 8 , , , 19613 2577 9 adulterers adulterer NNS 19613 2577 10 , , , 19613 2577 11 murderers murderer NNS 19613 2577 12 , , , 19613 2577 13 and and CC 19613 2577 14 idolaters idolater NNS 19613 2577 15 readmission readmission NN 19613 2577 16 to to IN 19613 2577 17 the the DT 19613 2577 18 Church Church NNP 19613 2577 19 , , , 19613 2577 20 in in IN 19613 2577 21 ordinary ordinary JJ 19613 2577 22 cases case NNS 19613 2577 23 , , , 19613 2577 24 prevented prevent VBN 19613 2577 25 men man NNS 19613 2577 26 from from IN 19613 2577 27 forgetting forget VBG 19613 2577 28 that that IN 19613 2577 29 there there EX 19613 2577 30 was be VBD 19613 2577 31 a a DT 19613 2577 32 boundary boundary JJ 19613 2577 33 line line NN 19613 2577 34 dividing divide VBG 19613 2577 35 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2577 36 from from IN 19613 2577 37 the the DT 19613 2577 38 world world NN 19613 2577 39 . . . 19613 2578 1 This this DT 19613 2578 2 state state NN 19613 2578 3 of of IN 19613 2578 4 matters matter NNS 19613 2578 5 continued continue VBD 19613 2578 6 till till IN 19613 2578 7 about about IN 19613 2578 8 220 220 CD 19613 2578 9 . . . 19613 2579 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2579 2 229 229 CD 19613 2579 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2579 4 In in IN 19613 2579 5 reality reality NN 19613 2579 6 the the DT 19613 2579 7 rule rule NN 19613 2579 8 was be VBD 19613 2579 9 first first RB 19613 2579 10 infringed infringe VBN 19613 2579 11 by by IN 19613 2579 12 the the DT 19613 2579 13 peremptory peremptory JJ 19613 2579 14 edict edict NN 19613 2579 15 of of IN 19613 2579 16 bishop bishop NNP 19613 2579 17 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2579 18 , , , 19613 2579 19 who who WP 19613 2579 20 , , , 19613 2579 21 in in IN 19613 2579 22 order order NN 19613 2579 23 to to TO 19613 2579 24 avoid avoid VB 19613 2579 25 breaking break VBG 19613 2579 26 up up RP 19613 2579 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2579 28 community community NN 19613 2579 29 , , , 19613 2579 30 granted grant VBN 19613 2579 31 readmission readmission NN 19613 2579 32 to to IN 19613 2579 33 those those DT 19613 2579 34 who who WP 19613 2579 35 had have VBD 19613 2579 36 fallen fall VBN 19613 2579 37 into into IN 19613 2579 38 sins sin NNS 19613 2579 39 of of IN 19613 2579 40 the the DT 19613 2579 41 flesh flesh NN 19613 2579 42 . . . 19613 2580 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2580 2 , , , 19613 2580 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2580 4 claimed claim VBD 19613 2580 5 this this DT 19613 2580 6 power power NN 19613 2580 7 of of IN 19613 2580 8 readmission readmission NN 19613 2580 9 as as IN 19613 2580 10 a a DT 19613 2580 11 right right NN 19613 2580 12 appertaining appertain VBG 19613 2580 13 to to IN 19613 2580 14 the the DT 19613 2580 15 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2580 16 as as IN 19613 2580 17 successors successor NNS 19613 2580 18 of of IN 19613 2580 19 the the DT 19613 2580 20 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2580 21 , , , 19613 2580 22 that that RB 19613 2580 23 is is RB 19613 2580 24 , , , 19613 2580 25 as as IN 19613 2580 26 possessors possessor NNS 19613 2580 27 of of IN 19613 2580 28 the the DT 19613 2580 29 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2580 30 and and CC 19613 2580 31 the the DT 19613 2580 32 power power NN 19613 2580 33 of of IN 19613 2580 34 the the DT 19613 2580 35 keys key NNS 19613 2580 36 . . . 19613 2581 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2581 2 230 230 CD 19613 2581 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2581 4 At at IN 19613 2581 5 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2581 6 this this DT 19613 2581 7 rescript rescript NN 19613 2581 8 led lead VBD 19613 2581 9 to to IN 19613 2581 10 the the DT 19613 2581 11 secession secession NN 19613 2581 12 headed head VBN 19613 2581 13 by by IN 19613 2581 14 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2581 15 . . . 19613 2582 1 But but CC 19613 2582 2 , , , 19613 2582 3 between between IN 19613 2582 4 220 220 CD 19613 2582 5 and and CC 19613 2582 6 250 250 CD 19613 2582 7 , , , 19613 2582 8 the the DT 19613 2582 9 milder milder NN 19613 2582 10 practice practice NN 19613 2582 11 with with IN 19613 2582 12 regard regard NN 19613 2582 13 to to IN 19613 2582 14 the the DT 19613 2582 15 sins sin NNS 19613 2582 16 of of IN 19613 2582 17 the the DT 19613 2582 18 flesh flesh NN 19613 2582 19 became become VBD 19613 2582 20 prevalent prevalent JJ 19613 2582 21 , , , 19613 2582 22 though though IN 19613 2582 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2582 24 was be VBD 19613 2582 25 not not RB 19613 2582 26 yet yet RB 19613 2582 27 universally universally RB 19613 2582 28 accepted accept VBN 19613 2582 29 . . . 19613 2583 1 This this DT 19613 2583 2 , , , 19613 2583 3 however however RB 19613 2583 4 , , , 19613 2583 5 resulted result VBD 19613 2583 6 in in IN 19613 2583 7 no no DT 19613 2583 8 further further JJ 19613 2583 9 schism schism NN 19613 2583 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2583 11 Cyp Cyp NNP 19613 2583 12 . . NNP 19613 2583 13 , , , 19613 2583 14 ep ep NNP 19613 2583 15 . . . 19613 2584 1 55 55 CD 19613 2584 2 . . . 19613 2585 1 21 21 CD 19613 2585 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2585 3 . . . 19613 2586 1 But but CC 19613 2586 2 up up IN 19613 2586 3 to to IN 19613 2586 4 the the DT 19613 2586 5 year year NN 19613 2586 6 250 250 CD 19613 2586 7 no no DT 19613 2586 8 concessions concession NNS 19613 2586 9 were be VBD 19613 2586 10 allowed allow VBN 19613 2586 11 in in IN 19613 2586 12 the the DT 19613 2586 13 case case NN 19613 2586 14 of of IN 19613 2586 15 relapse relapse NN 19613 2586 16 into into IN 19613 2586 17 idolatry idolatry NN 19613 2586 18 . . . 19613 2587 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2587 2 231 231 CD 19613 2587 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2587 4 These these DT 19613 2587 5 were be VBD 19613 2587 6 first first RB 19613 2587 7 occasioned occasion VBN 19613 2587 8 by by IN 19613 2587 9 the the DT 19613 2587 10 Decian decian JJ 19613 2587 11 persecution persecution NN 19613 2587 12 , , , 19613 2587 13 since since IN 19613 2587 14 in in IN 19613 2587 15 many many JJ 19613 2587 16 towns town NNS 19613 2587 17 those those DT 19613 2587 18 who who WP 19613 2587 19 had have VBD 19613 2587 20 abjured abjure VBN 19613 2587 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2587 22 were be VBD 19613 2587 23 more more RBR 19613 2587 24 numerous numerous JJ 19613 2587 25 than than IN 19613 2587 26 those those DT 19613 2587 27 who who WP 19613 2587 28 adhered adhere VBD 19613 2587 29 to to IN 19613 2587 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2587 31 . . . 19613 2588 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2588 2 232 232 CD 19613 2588 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2588 4 The the DT 19613 2588 5 majority majority NN 19613 2588 6 of of IN 19613 2588 7 the the DT 19613 2588 8 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2588 9 , , , 19613 2588 10 part part NN 19613 2588 11 of of IN 19613 2588 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2588 13 with with IN 19613 2588 14 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 2588 15 , , , 19613 2588 16 agreed agree VBN 19613 2588 17 on on IN 19613 2588 18 new new JJ 19613 2588 19 principles principle NNS 19613 2588 20 . . . 19613 2589 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2589 2 233 233 CD 19613 2589 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2589 4 To to TO 19613 2589 5 begin begin VB 19613 2589 6 with with IN 19613 2589 7 , , , 19613 2589 8 permission permission NN 19613 2589 9 was be VBD 19613 2589 10 given give VBN 19613 2589 11 to to TO 19613 2589 12 absolve absolve VB 19613 2589 13 repentant repentant JJ 19613 2589 14 apostates apostate NNS 19613 2589 15 on on IN 19613 2589 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2589 17 deathbed deathbed NN 19613 2589 18 . . . 19613 2590 1 Next next RB 19613 2590 2 , , , 19613 2590 3 a a DT 19613 2590 4 distinction distinction NN 19613 2590 5 was be VBD 19613 2590 6 made make VBN 19613 2590 7 between between IN 19613 2590 8 _ _ NNP 19613 2590 9 sacrificati sacrificati NNPS 19613 2590 10 _ _ NNP 19613 2590 11 and and CC 19613 2590 12 _ _ NNP 19613 2590 13 libellatici libellatici VBD 19613 2590 14 _ _ NNP 19613 2590 15 , , , 19613 2590 16 the the DT 19613 2590 17 latter latter JJ 19613 2590 18 being be VBG 19613 2590 19 more more RBR 19613 2590 20 mildly mildly RB 19613 2590 21 treated treat VBN 19613 2590 22 . . . 19613 2591 1 Finally finally RB 19613 2591 2 , , , 19613 2591 3 the the DT 19613 2591 4 possibility possibility NN 19613 2591 5 of of IN 19613 2591 6 readmission readmission NN 19613 2591 7 was be VBD 19613 2591 8 conceded concede VBN 19613 2591 9 under under IN 19613 2591 10 certain certain JJ 19613 2591 11 severe severe JJ 19613 2591 12 conditions condition NNS 19613 2591 13 to to IN 19613 2591 14 all all PDT 19613 2591 15 the the DT 19613 2591 16 lapsed lapsed JJ 19613 2591 17 , , , 19613 2591 18 a a DT 19613 2591 19 casuistic casuistic JJ 19613 2591 20 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 2591 21 was be VBD 19613 2591 22 adopted adopt VBN 19613 2591 23 in in IN 19613 2591 24 regard regard NN 19613 2591 25 to to IN 19613 2591 26 the the DT 19613 2591 27 laity laity NN 19613 2591 28 , , , 19613 2591 29 and and CC 19613 2591 30 strict strict JJ 19613 2591 31 measures measure NNS 19613 2591 32 -- -- : 19613 2591 33 though though IN 19613 2591 34 this this DT 19613 2591 35 was be VBD 19613 2591 36 not not RB 19613 2591 37 the the DT 19613 2591 38 universal universal JJ 19613 2591 39 rule rule NN 19613 2591 40 -- -- : 19613 2591 41 were be VBD 19613 2591 42 only only RB 19613 2591 43 adopted adopt VBN 19613 2591 44 towards towards IN 19613 2591 45 the the DT 19613 2591 46 clergy clergy NNS 19613 2591 47 . . . 19613 2592 1 In in IN 19613 2592 2 consequence consequence NN 19613 2592 3 of of IN 19613 2592 4 this this DT 19613 2592 5 innovation innovation NN 19613 2592 6 , , , 19613 2592 7 which which WDT 19613 2592 8 logically logically RB 19613 2592 9 resulted result VBD 19613 2592 10 in in IN 19613 2592 11 the the DT 19613 2592 12 gradual gradual JJ 19613 2592 13 cessation cessation NN 19613 2592 14 of of IN 19613 2592 15 the the DT 19613 2592 16 belief belief NN 19613 2592 17 that that IN 19613 2592 18 there there EX 19613 2592 19 can can MD 19613 2592 20 be be VB 19613 2592 21 only only RB 19613 2592 22 one one CD 19613 2592 23 repentance repentance NN 19613 2592 24 after after IN 19613 2592 25 baptism baptism NN 19613 2592 26 -- -- : 19613 2592 27 an an DT 19613 2592 28 assumption assumption NN 19613 2592 29 that that WDT 19613 2592 30 was be VBD 19613 2592 31 untenable untenable JJ 19613 2592 32 in in IN 19613 2592 33 principle principle NN 19613 2592 34 -- -- : 19613 2592 35 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2592 36 's 's POS 19613 2592 37 schism schism NN 19613 2592 38 took take VBD 19613 2592 39 place place NN 19613 2592 40 and and CC 19613 2592 41 speedily speedily RB 19613 2592 42 rent rent VB 19613 2592 43 the the DT 19613 2592 44 Church Church NNP 19613 2592 45 in in IN 19613 2592 46 twain twain NN 19613 2592 47 . . . 19613 2593 1 But but CC 19613 2593 2 , , , 19613 2593 3 even even RB 19613 2593 4 in in IN 19613 2593 5 cases case NNS 19613 2593 6 where where WRB 19613 2593 7 unity unity NN 19613 2593 8 was be VBD 19613 2593 9 maintained maintain VBN 19613 2593 10 , , , 19613 2593 11 many many JJ 19613 2593 12 communities community NNS 19613 2593 13 observed observe VBD 19613 2593 14 the the DT 19613 2593 15 stricter strict JJR 19613 2593 16 practice practice NN 19613 2593 17 down down IN 19613 2593 18 to to IN 19613 2593 19 the the DT 19613 2593 20 fifth fifth JJ 19613 2593 21 century century NN 19613 2593 22 . . . 19613 2594 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2594 2 234 234 CD 19613 2594 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2594 4 What what WP 19613 2594 5 made make VBD 19613 2594 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2594 7 difficult difficult JJ 19613 2594 8 to to TO 19613 2594 9 introduce introduce VB 19613 2594 10 this this DT 19613 2594 11 change change NN 19613 2594 12 by by IN 19613 2594 13 regular regular JJ 19613 2594 14 legislation legislation NN 19613 2594 15 was be VBD 19613 2594 16 the the DT 19613 2594 17 authority authority NN 19613 2594 18 to to TO 19613 2594 19 forgive forgive VB 19613 2594 20 sins sin NNS 19613 2594 21 in in IN 19613 2594 22 God God NNP 19613 2594 23 's 's POS 19613 2594 24 stead stead NN 19613 2594 25 , , , 19613 2594 26 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 2594 27 in in IN 19613 2594 28 primitive primitive JJ 19613 2594 29 times time NNS 19613 2594 30 to to IN 19613 2594 31 the the DT 19613 2594 32 inspired inspire VBN 19613 2594 33 , , , 19613 2594 34 and and CC 19613 2594 35 at at IN 19613 2594 36 a a DT 19613 2594 37 later later JJ 19613 2594 38 period period NN 19613 2594 39 to to IN 19613 2594 40 the the DT 19613 2594 41 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2594 42 in in IN 19613 2594 43 virtue virtue NN 19613 2594 44 of of IN 19613 2594 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2594 46 special special JJ 19613 2594 47 relation relation NN 19613 2594 48 to to IN 19613 2594 49 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2594 50 or or CC 19613 2594 51 the the DT 19613 2594 52 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2594 53 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2594 54 see see VB 19613 2594 55 Ep Ep NNP 19613 2594 56 . . . 19613 2595 1 Lugd lugd VB 19613 2595 2 . . . 19613 2596 1 in in IN 19613 2596 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2596 3 . . NNP 19613 2596 4 , , , 19613 2596 5 H. H. NNP 19613 2596 6 E. E. NNP 19613 2596 7 V. V. NNP 19613 2596 8 1 1 CD 19613 2596 9 ff ff NNP 19613 2596 10 . . . 19613 2597 1 ; ; : 19613 2597 2 Cypr Cypr NNS 19613 2597 3 . . . 19613 2598 1 epp epp NNP 19613 2598 2 . . . 19613 2599 1 ; ; : 19613 2599 2 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 2599 3 . . . 19613 2600 1 de de NNP 19613 2600 2 pudic pudic JJ 19613 2600 3 . . . 19613 2601 1 22 22 CD 19613 2601 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2601 3 . . . 19613 2602 1 The the DT 19613 2602 2 confusion confusion NN 19613 2602 3 occasioned occasion VBN 19613 2602 4 by by IN 19613 2602 5 the the DT 19613 2602 6 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2602 7 after after IN 19613 2602 8 the the DT 19613 2602 9 Decian decian JJ 19613 2602 10 persecution persecution NN 19613 2602 11 led lead VBD 19613 2602 12 to to IN 19613 2602 13 the the DT 19613 2602 14 non non JJ 19613 2602 15 - - NN 19613 2602 16 recognition recognition NN 19613 2602 17 of of IN 19613 2602 18 any any DT 19613 2602 19 rights right NNS 19613 2602 20 of of IN 19613 2602 21 " " `` 19613 2602 22 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2602 23 " " '' 19613 2602 24 persons person NNS 19613 2602 25 other other JJ 19613 2602 26 than than IN 19613 2602 27 the the DT 19613 2602 28 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2602 29 . . . 19613 2603 1 These these DT 19613 2603 2 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2603 3 had have VBD 19613 2603 4 frequently frequently RB 19613 2603 5 abetted abet VBN 19613 2603 6 laxity laxity NN 19613 2603 7 of of IN 19613 2603 8 conduct conduct NN 19613 2603 9 , , , 19613 2603 10 whereas whereas IN 19613 2603 11 , , , 19613 2603 12 if if IN 19613 2603 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2603 14 consider consider VBP 19613 2603 15 the the DT 19613 2603 16 measure measure NN 19613 2603 17 of of IN 19613 2603 18 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 2603 19 found find VBN 19613 2603 20 among among IN 19613 2603 21 the the DT 19613 2603 22 great great JJ 19613 2603 23 mass mass NN 19613 2603 24 of of IN 19613 2603 25 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2603 26 , , , 19613 2603 27 the the DT 19613 2603 28 penitential penitential JJ 19613 2603 29 discipline discipline NN 19613 2603 30 insisted insist VBD 19613 2603 31 on on IN 19613 2603 32 by by IN 19613 2603 33 the the DT 19613 2603 34 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2603 35 is be VBZ 19613 2603 36 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 2603 37 for for IN 19613 2603 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2603 39 comparative comparative JJ 19613 2603 40 severity severity NN 19613 2603 41 . . . 19613 2604 1 The the DT 19613 2604 2 complete complete JJ 19613 2604 3 adoption adoption NN 19613 2604 4 of of IN 19613 2604 5 the the DT 19613 2604 6 episcopal episcopal NNP 19613 2604 7 constitution constitution NNP 19613 2604 8 coincided coincide VBD 19613 2604 9 with with IN 19613 2604 10 the the DT 19613 2604 11 introduction introduction NN 19613 2604 12 of of IN 19613 2604 13 the the DT 19613 2604 14 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 2604 15 right right NN 19613 2604 16 to to TO 19613 2604 17 forgive forgive VB 19613 2604 18 sins sin NNS 19613 2604 19 . . . 19613 2605 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2605 2 235 235 CD 19613 2605 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2605 4 4 4 CD 19613 2605 5 . . . 19613 2606 1 The the DT 19613 2606 2 original original JJ 19613 2606 3 conception conception NN 19613 2606 4 of of IN 19613 2606 5 the the DT 19613 2606 6 relation relation NN 19613 2606 7 of of IN 19613 2606 8 the the DT 19613 2606 9 Church Church NNP 19613 2606 10 to to IN 19613 2606 11 salvation salvation NN 19613 2606 12 or or CC 19613 2606 13 eternal eternal JJ 19613 2606 14 bliss bliss NN 19613 2606 15 was be VBD 19613 2606 16 altered alter VBN 19613 2606 17 by by IN 19613 2606 18 this this DT 19613 2606 19 development development NN 19613 2606 20 . . . 19613 2607 1 According accord VBG 19613 2607 2 to to IN 19613 2607 3 the the DT 19613 2607 4 older old JJR 19613 2607 5 notion notion NN 19613 2607 6 the the DT 19613 2607 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2607 8 was be VBD 19613 2607 9 the the DT 19613 2607 10 sure sure JJ 19613 2607 11 communion communion NN 19613 2607 12 of of IN 19613 2607 13 salvation salvation NN 19613 2607 14 and and CC 19613 2607 15 of of IN 19613 2607 16 saints saint NNS 19613 2607 17 , , , 19613 2607 18 which which WDT 19613 2607 19 rested rest VBD 19613 2607 20 on on IN 19613 2607 21 the the DT 19613 2607 22 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2607 23 of of IN 19613 2607 24 sins sin NNS 19613 2607 25 mediated mediate VBN 19613 2607 26 by by IN 19613 2607 27 baptism baptism NN 19613 2607 28 , , , 19613 2607 29 and and CC 19613 2607 30 excluded exclude VBD 19613 2607 31 everything everything NN 19613 2607 32 unholy unholy JJ 19613 2607 33 . . . 19613 2608 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2608 2 is be VBZ 19613 2608 3 not not RB 19613 2608 4 the the DT 19613 2608 5 Church Church NNP 19613 2608 6 , , , 19613 2608 7 but but CC 19613 2608 8 God God NNP 19613 2608 9 alone alone RB 19613 2608 10 , , , 19613 2608 11 that that IN 19613 2608 12 forgives forgive VBZ 19613 2608 13 sins sin NNS 19613 2608 14 , , , 19613 2608 15 and and CC 19613 2608 16 , , , 19613 2608 17 as as IN 19613 2608 18 a a DT 19613 2608 19 rule rule NN 19613 2608 20 , , , 19613 2608 21 indeed indeed RB 19613 2608 22 , , , 19613 2608 23 this this DT 19613 2608 24 is be VBZ 19613 2608 25 only only RB 19613 2608 26 done do VBN 19613 2608 27 through through IN 19613 2608 28 baptism baptism NN 19613 2608 29 , , , 19613 2608 30 though though RB 19613 2608 31 , , , 19613 2608 32 in in IN 19613 2608 33 virtue virtue NN 19613 2608 34 of of IN 19613 2608 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2608 36 unfathomable unfathomable JJ 19613 2608 37 grace grace NN 19613 2608 38 , , , 19613 2608 39 also also RB 19613 2608 40 now now RB 19613 2608 41 and and CC 19613 2608 42 then then RB 19613 2608 43 by by IN 19613 2608 44 special special JJ 19613 2608 45 proclamations proclamation NNS 19613 2608 46 , , , 19613 2608 47 the the DT 19613 2608 48 pardon pardon NN 19613 2608 49 coming come VBG 19613 2608 50 into into IN 19613 2608 51 effect effect NN 19613 2608 52 for for IN 19613 2608 53 repentant repentant JJ 19613 2608 54 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2608 55 , , , 19613 2608 56 after after IN 19613 2608 57 death death NN 19613 2608 58 , , , 19613 2608 59 in in IN 19613 2608 60 heaven heaven NNP 19613 2608 61 . . . 19613 2609 1 If if IN 19613 2609 2 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2609 3 readmitted readmitte VBD 19613 2609 4 gross gross JJ 19613 2609 5 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2609 6 , , , 19613 2609 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2609 8 would would MD 19613 2609 9 anticipate anticipate VB 19613 2609 10 the the DT 19613 2609 11 judgment judgment NN 19613 2609 12 of of IN 19613 2609 13 God God NNP 19613 2609 14 , , , 19613 2609 15 as as IN 19613 2609 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2609 17 would would MD 19613 2609 18 thereby thereby RB 19613 2609 19 assure assure VB 19613 2609 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2609 21 of of IN 19613 2609 22 salvation salvation NN 19613 2609 23 . . . 19613 2610 1 Hence hence RB 19613 2610 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2610 3 can can MD 19613 2610 4 only only RB 19613 2610 5 take take VB 19613 2610 6 back back RB 19613 2610 7 those those DT 19613 2610 8 who who WP 19613 2610 9 have have VBP 19613 2610 10 been be VBN 19613 2610 11 excluded exclude VBN 19613 2610 12 in in IN 19613 2610 13 cases case NNS 19613 2610 14 where where WRB 19613 2610 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2610 16 offences offence NNS 19613 2610 17 have have VBP 19613 2610 18 not not RB 19613 2610 19 been be VBN 19613 2610 20 committed commit VBN 19613 2610 21 against against IN 19613 2610 22 God God NNP 19613 2610 23 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2610 24 , , , 19613 2610 25 but but CC 19613 2610 26 have have VBP 19613 2610 27 consisted consist VBN 19613 2610 28 in in IN 19613 2610 29 transgressing transgress VBG 19613 2610 30 the the DT 19613 2610 31 commandments commandment NNS 19613 2610 32 of of IN 19613 2610 33 the the DT 19613 2610 34 Church Church NNP 19613 2610 35 , , , 19613 2610 36 that that RB 19613 2610 37 is is RB 19613 2610 38 , , , 19613 2610 39 in in IN 19613 2610 40 venial venial JJ 19613 2610 41 sins sin NNS 19613 2610 42 . . . 19613 2611 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2611 2 236 236 CD 19613 2611 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2611 4 But but CC 19613 2611 5 in in IN 19613 2611 6 course course NN 19613 2611 7 of of IN 19613 2611 8 time time NN 19613 2611 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2611 10 was be VBD 19613 2611 11 just just RB 19613 2611 12 in in IN 19613 2611 13 lay lay JJ 19613 2611 14 circles circle NNS 19613 2611 15 that that IN 19613 2611 16 faith faith NN 19613 2611 17 in in IN 19613 2611 18 God God NNP 19613 2611 19 's 's POS 19613 2611 20 grace grace NN 19613 2611 21 became become VBD 19613 2611 22 weaker weak JJR 19613 2611 23 and and CC 19613 2611 24 trust trust NN 19613 2611 25 in in IN 19613 2611 26 the the DT 19613 2611 27 Church Church NNP 19613 2611 28 stronger stronger RBR 19613 2611 29 . . . 19613 2612 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2612 2 whom whom WP 19613 2612 3 the the DT 19613 2612 4 Church Church NNP 19613 2612 5 abandoned abandon VBD 19613 2612 6 was be VBD 19613 2612 7 lost lose VBN 19613 2612 8 to to IN 19613 2612 9 the the DT 19613 2612 10 world world NN 19613 2612 11 ; ; : 19613 2612 12 therefore therefore RB 19613 2612 13 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2612 14 must must MD 19613 2612 15 not not RB 19613 2612 16 abandon abandon VB 19613 2612 17 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2612 18 . . . 19613 2613 1 This this DT 19613 2613 2 state state NN 19613 2613 3 of of IN 19613 2613 4 things thing NNS 19613 2613 5 was be VBD 19613 2613 6 expressed express VBN 19613 2613 7 in in IN 19613 2613 8 the the DT 19613 2613 9 new new JJ 19613 2613 10 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 2613 11 of of IN 19613 2613 12 the the DT 19613 2613 13 proposition proposition NN 19613 2613 14 , , , 19613 2613 15 " " '' 19613 2613 16 no no DT 19613 2613 17 salvation salvation NN 19613 2613 18 outside outside IN 19613 2613 19 the the DT 19613 2613 20 Church Church NNP 19613 2613 21 " " '' 19613 2613 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2613 23 " " `` 19613 2613 24 extra extra JJ 19613 2613 25 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 2613 26 nulla nulla NN 19613 2613 27 salus salus NNP 19613 2613 28 " " '' 19613 2613 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2613 30 , , , 19613 2613 31 viz viz NNP 19613 2613 32 . . NNP 19613 2613 33 , , , 19613 2613 34 _ _ NNP 19613 2613 35 the the DT 19613 2613 36 Church Church NNP 19613 2613 37 alone alone RB 19613 2613 38 saves save VBZ 19613 2613 39 from from IN 19613 2613 40 damnation damnation NN 19613 2613 41 which which WDT 19613 2613 42 is be VBZ 19613 2613 43 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 2613 44 certain certain JJ 19613 2613 45 _ _ NNP 19613 2613 46 . . . 19613 2614 1 In in IN 19613 2614 2 this this DT 19613 2614 3 conception conception NN 19613 2614 4 the the DT 19613 2614 5 nature nature NN 19613 2614 6 of of IN 19613 2614 7 the the DT 19613 2614 8 Church Church NNP 19613 2614 9 is be VBZ 19613 2614 10 depotentiated depotentiate VBN 19613 2614 11 , , , 19613 2614 12 but but CC 19613 2614 13 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2614 14 powers power NNS 19613 2614 15 are be VBP 19613 2614 16 extended extend VBN 19613 2614 17 . . . 19613 2615 1 If if IN 19613 2615 2 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2615 3 is be VBZ 19613 2615 4 the the DT 19613 2615 5 institution institution NN 19613 2615 6 which which WDT 19613 2615 7 , , , 19613 2615 8 according accord VBG 19613 2615 9 to to IN 19613 2615 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2615 11 , , , 19613 2615 12 is be VBZ 19613 2615 13 the the DT 19613 2615 14 indispensable indispensable JJ 19613 2615 15 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 2615 16 condition condition NN 19613 2615 17 of of IN 19613 2615 18 salvation salvation NN 19613 2615 19 , , , 19613 2615 20 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2615 21 can can MD 19613 2615 22 no no RB 19613 2615 23 longer longer RB 19613 2615 24 be be VB 19613 2615 25 a a DT 19613 2615 26 sure sure JJ 19613 2615 27 communion communion NN 19613 2615 28 of of IN 19613 2615 29 the the DT 19613 2615 30 saved save VBN 19613 2615 31 ; ; : 19613 2615 32 in in IN 19613 2615 33 other other JJ 19613 2615 34 words word NNS 19613 2615 35 , , , 19613 2615 36 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2615 37 becomes become VBZ 19613 2615 38 an an DT 19613 2615 39 institution institution NN 19613 2615 40 from from IN 19613 2615 41 which which WDT 19613 2615 42 proceeds proceed VBZ 19613 2615 43 the the DT 19613 2615 44 communion communion NN 19613 2615 45 of of IN 19613 2615 46 saints saint NNS 19613 2615 47 ; ; : 19613 2615 48 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2615 49 includes include VBZ 19613 2615 50 both both DT 19613 2615 51 saved save VBD 19613 2615 52 and and CC 19613 2615 53 unsaved unsaved JJ 19613 2615 54 . . . 19613 2616 1 Thus thus RB 19613 2616 2 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2616 3 religious religious JJ 19613 2616 4 character character NN 19613 2616 5 consists consist VBZ 19613 2616 6 in in IN 19613 2616 7 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2616 8 being be VBG 19613 2616 9 the the DT 19613 2616 10 indispensable indispensable JJ 19613 2616 11 medium medium NN 19613 2616 12 , , , 19613 2616 13 in in IN 19613 2616 14 so so RB 19613 2616 15 far far RB 19613 2616 16 as as IN 19613 2616 17 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2616 18 alone alone RB 19613 2616 19 guarantees guarantee VBZ 19613 2616 20 to to IN 19613 2616 21 the the DT 19613 2616 22 individual individual NN 19613 2616 23 the the DT 19613 2616 24 _ _ NNP 19613 2616 25 possibility possibility NN 19613 2616 26 _ _ NNP 19613 2616 27 of of IN 19613 2616 28 redemption redemption NN 19613 2616 29 . . . 19613 2617 1 From from IN 19613 2617 2 this this DT 19613 2617 3 , , , 19613 2617 4 however however RB 19613 2617 5 , , , 19613 2617 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2617 7 immediately immediately RB 19613 2617 8 follows follow VBZ 19613 2617 9 that that IN 19613 2617 10 the the DT 19613 2617 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2617 12 would would MD 19613 2617 13 anticipate anticipate VB 19613 2617 14 the the DT 19613 2617 15 judgment judgment NN 19613 2617 16 of of IN 19613 2617 17 God God NNP 19613 2617 18 if if IN 19613 2617 19 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2617 20 finally finally RB 19613 2617 21 excluded exclude VBD 19613 2617 22 anyone anyone NN 19613 2617 23 from from IN 19613 2617 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2617 25 membership membership NN 19613 2617 26 who who WP 19613 2617 27 did do VBD 19613 2617 28 not not RB 19613 2617 29 give give VB 19613 2617 30 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2617 31 up up IN 19613 2617 32 of of IN 19613 2617 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2617 34 own own JJ 19613 2617 35 accord accord NN 19613 2617 36 ; ; : 19613 2617 37 whereas whereas IN 19613 2617 38 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2617 39 could could MD 19613 2617 40 never never RB 19613 2617 41 prejudge prejudge VB 19613 2617 42 the the DT 19613 2617 43 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 2617 44 destiny destiny NN 19613 2617 45 of of IN 19613 2617 46 a a DT 19613 2617 47 man man NN 19613 2617 48 by by IN 19613 2617 49 readmission readmission NN 19613 2617 50 . . . 19613 2618 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2618 2 237 237 CD 19613 2618 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2618 4 But but CC 19613 2618 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2618 6 also also RB 19613 2618 7 follows follow VBZ 19613 2618 8 that that IN 19613 2618 9 the the DT 19613 2618 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2618 11 must must MD 19613 2618 12 possess possess VB 19613 2618 13 a a DT 19613 2618 14 means means NN 19613 2618 15 of of IN 19613 2618 16 repairing repair VBG 19613 2618 17 any any DT 19613 2618 18 injury injury NN 19613 2618 19 upon upon IN 19613 2618 20 earth earth NN 19613 2618 21 , , , 19613 2618 22 a a DT 19613 2618 23 means means NN 19613 2618 24 of of IN 19613 2618 25 equal equal JJ 19613 2618 26 value value NN 19613 2618 27 with with IN 19613 2618 28 baptism baptism NN 19613 2618 29 , , , 19613 2618 30 namely namely RB 19613 2618 31 , , , 19613 2618 32 a a DT 19613 2618 33 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 2618 34 of of IN 19613 2618 35 the the DT 19613 2618 36 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2618 37 of of IN 19613 2618 38 sins sin NNS 19613 2618 39 . . . 19613 2619 1 With with IN 19613 2619 2 this this DT 19613 2619 3 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2619 4 acts act VBZ 19613 2619 5 in in IN 19613 2619 6 God God NNP 19613 2619 7 's 's POS 19613 2619 8 name name NN 19613 2619 9 and and CC 19613 2619 10 stead stead NN 19613 2619 11 , , , 19613 2619 12 but but CC 19613 2619 13 -- -- : 19613 2619 14 and and CC 19613 2619 15 herein herein NNP 19613 2619 16 lies lie VBZ 19613 2619 17 the the DT 19613 2619 18 inconsistency inconsistency NN 19613 2619 19 -- -- : 19613 2619 20 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2619 21 can can MD 19613 2619 22 not not RB 19613 2619 23 by by IN 19613 2619 24 this this DT 19613 2619 25 means mean NNS 19613 2619 26 establish establish VB 19613 2619 27 any any DT 19613 2619 28 final final JJ 19613 2619 29 condition condition NN 19613 2619 30 of of IN 19613 2619 31 salvation salvation NN 19613 2619 32 . . . 19613 2620 1 In in IN 19613 2620 2 bestowing bestow VBG 19613 2620 3 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2620 4 on on IN 19613 2620 5 the the DT 19613 2620 6 sinner sinner NN 19613 2620 7 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2620 8 in in IN 19613 2620 9 reality reality NN 19613 2620 10 only only RB 19613 2620 11 reconciles reconcile VBZ 19613 2620 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2620 13 with with IN 19613 2620 14 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 2620 15 , , , 19613 2620 16 and and CC 19613 2620 17 thereby thereby RB 19613 2620 18 , , , 19613 2620 19 in in IN 19613 2620 20 fact fact NN 19613 2620 21 , , , 19613 2620 22 merely merely RB 19613 2620 23 removes remove VBZ 19613 2620 24 the the DT 19613 2620 25 certainty certainty NN 19613 2620 26 of of IN 19613 2620 27 damnation damnation NN 19613 2620 28 . . . 19613 2621 1 In in IN 19613 2621 2 accordance accordance NN 19613 2621 3 with with IN 19613 2621 4 this this DT 19613 2621 5 theory theory NN 19613 2621 6 the the DT 19613 2621 7 holiness holiness NN 19613 2621 8 of of IN 19613 2621 9 the the DT 19613 2621 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2621 11 can can MD 19613 2621 12 merely merely RB 19613 2621 13 consist consist VB 19613 2621 14 in in IN 19613 2621 15 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2621 16 possession possession NN 19613 2621 17 of of IN 19613 2621 18 the the DT 19613 2621 19 means mean NNS 19613 2621 20 of of IN 19613 2621 21 salvation salvation NN 19613 2621 22 : : : 19613 2621 23 _ _ NNP 19613 2621 24 the the DT 19613 2621 25 Church Church NNP 19613 2621 26 is be VBZ 19613 2621 27 a a DT 19613 2621 28 holy holy JJ 19613 2621 29 institution institution NN 19613 2621 30 in in IN 19613 2621 31 virtue virtue NN 19613 2621 32 of of IN 19613 2621 33 the the DT 19613 2621 34 gifts gift NNS 19613 2621 35 with with IN 19613 2621 36 which which WDT 19613 2621 37 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2621 38 is be VBZ 19613 2621 39 endowed endow VBN 19613 2621 40 _ _ NNP 19613 2621 41 . . . 19613 2622 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 2622 2 is be VBZ 19613 2622 3 the the DT 19613 2622 4 moral moral JJ 19613 2622 5 seminary seminary NN 19613 2622 6 that that WDT 19613 2622 7 trains train VBZ 19613 2622 8 for for IN 19613 2622 9 salvation salvation NN 19613 2622 10 and and CC 19613 2622 11 the the DT 19613 2622 12 institution institution NN 19613 2622 13 that that WDT 19613 2622 14 exercises exercise VBZ 19613 2622 15 divine divine JJ 19613 2622 16 powers power NNS 19613 2622 17 in in IN 19613 2622 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2622 19 's 's POS 19613 2622 20 room room NN 19613 2622 21 . . . 19613 2623 1 Both both DT 19613 2623 2 of of IN 19613 2623 3 these these DT 19613 2623 4 conceptions conception NNS 19613 2623 5 presuppose presuppose VBP 19613 2623 6 political political JJ 19613 2623 7 forms form NNS 19613 2623 8 ; ; : 19613 2623 9 both both DT 19613 2623 10 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 2623 11 require require VBP 19613 2623 12 priests priest NNS 19613 2623 13 and and CC 19613 2623 14 more more RBR 19613 2623 15 especially especially RB 19613 2623 16 an an DT 19613 2623 17 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 2623 18 . . . 19613 2624 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2624 2 In in IN 19613 2624 3 de de FW 19613 2624 4 pudic pudic JJ 19613 2624 5 . . . 19613 2625 1 21 21 CD 19613 2625 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2625 3 already already RB 19613 2625 4 defines define VBZ 19613 2625 5 the the DT 19613 2625 6 position position NN 19613 2625 7 of of IN 19613 2625 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2625 9 adversary adversary NN 19613 2625 10 by by IN 19613 2625 11 the the DT 19613 2625 12 saying saying NN 19613 2625 13 , , , 19613 2625 14 " " '' 19613 2625 15 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 2625 16 est est NNP 19613 2625 17 numerus numerus NNP 19613 2625 18 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 2625 19 . . . 19613 2625 20 " " '' 19613 2625 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2626 1 This this DT 19613 2626 2 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 2626 3 by by IN 19613 2626 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2626 5 unity unity NN 19613 2626 6 guarantees guarantee VBZ 19613 2626 7 the the DT 19613 2626 8 unity unity NN 19613 2626 9 of of IN 19613 2626 10 the the DT 19613 2626 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2626 12 and and CC 19613 2626 13 has have VBZ 19613 2626 14 received receive VBN 19613 2626 15 the the DT 19613 2626 16 power power NN 19613 2626 17 to to TO 19613 2626 18 forgive forgive VB 19613 2626 19 sins sin NNS 19613 2626 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2626 21 Cyp Cyp NNP 19613 2626 22 . . NNP 19613 2626 23 , , , 19613 2626 24 ep ep NNP 19613 2626 25 . . . 19613 2627 1 69 69 CD 19613 2627 2 . . . 19613 2628 1 11 11 CD 19613 2628 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2628 3 . . . 19613 2629 1 The the DT 19613 2629 2 new new JJ 19613 2629 3 conception conception NN 19613 2629 4 of of IN 19613 2629 5 the the DT 19613 2629 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2629 7 , , , 19613 2629 8 which which WDT 19613 2629 9 was be VBD 19613 2629 10 a a DT 19613 2629 11 necessary necessary JJ 19613 2629 12 outcome outcome NN 19613 2629 13 of of IN 19613 2629 14 existing exist VBG 19613 2629 15 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2629 16 and and CC 19613 2629 17 which which WDT 19613 2629 18 , , , 19613 2629 19 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2629 20 may may MD 19613 2629 21 remark remark VB 19613 2629 22 , , , 19613 2629 23 was be VBD 19613 2629 24 not not RB 19613 2629 25 formulated formulate VBN 19613 2629 26 in in IN 19613 2629 27 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 2629 28 terms term NNS 19613 2629 29 by by IN 19613 2629 30 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2629 31 , , , 19613 2629 32 but but CC 19613 2629 33 by by IN 19613 2629 34 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2629 35 bishops,[238 bishops,[238 NNP 19613 2629 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2629 37 was be VBD 19613 2629 38 the the DT 19613 2629 39 first first JJ 19613 2629 40 thing thing NN 19613 2629 41 that that WDT 19613 2629 42 gave give VBD 19613 2629 43 a a DT 19613 2629 44 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 2629 45 _ _ NNP 19613 2629 46 religious religious JJ 19613 2629 47 _ _ NNP 19613 2629 48 significance significance NN 19613 2629 49 to to IN 19613 2629 50 the the DT 19613 2629 51 separation separation NN 19613 2629 52 of of IN 19613 2629 53 clergy clergy NN 19613 2629 54 and and CC 19613 2629 55 laity laity NN 19613 2629 56 . . . 19613 2630 1 The the DT 19613 2630 2 powers power NNS 19613 2630 3 exercised exercise VBN 19613 2630 4 by by IN 19613 2630 5 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2630 6 and and CC 19613 2630 7 priests priest NNS 19613 2630 8 were be VBD 19613 2630 9 thereby thereby RB 19613 2630 10 fixed fix VBN 19613 2630 11 and and CC 19613 2630 12 hallowed hallowed JJ 19613 2630 13 . . . 19613 2631 1 No no RB 19613 2631 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 2631 3 the the DT 19613 2631 4 old old JJ 19613 2631 5 order order NN 19613 2631 6 of of IN 19613 2631 7 things thing NNS 19613 2631 8 , , , 19613 2631 9 which which WDT 19613 2631 10 gave give VBD 19613 2631 11 laymen laymen NNP 19613 2631 12 a a DT 19613 2631 13 share share NN 19613 2631 14 in in IN 19613 2631 15 the the DT 19613 2631 16 administration administration NN 19613 2631 17 of of IN 19613 2631 18 moral moral JJ 19613 2631 19 discipline discipline NN 19613 2631 20 , , , 19613 2631 21 still still RB 19613 2631 22 continued continue VBD 19613 2631 23 in in IN 19613 2631 24 the the DT 19613 2631 25 third third JJ 19613 2631 26 century century NN 19613 2631 27 , , , 19613 2631 28 but but CC 19613 2631 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2631 30 became become VBD 19613 2631 31 more more RBR 19613 2631 32 and and CC 19613 2631 33 more more RBR 19613 2631 34 a a DT 19613 2631 35 mere mere JJ 19613 2631 36 form form NN 19613 2631 37 . . . 19613 2632 1 The the DT 19613 2632 2 bishop bishop NN 19613 2632 3 became become VBD 19613 2632 4 the the DT 19613 2632 5 practical practical JJ 19613 2632 6 vicegerent vicegerent NN 19613 2632 7 of of IN 19613 2632 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2632 9 ; ; : 19613 2632 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2632 11 disposed dispose VBD 19613 2632 12 of of IN 19613 2632 13 the the DT 19613 2632 14 power power NN 19613 2632 15 to to TO 19613 2632 16 bind bind VB 19613 2632 17 and and CC 19613 2632 18 to to TO 19613 2632 19 loose loose VB 19613 2632 20 . . . 19613 2633 1 But but CC 19613 2633 2 the the DT 19613 2633 3 recollection recollection NN 19613 2633 4 of of IN 19613 2633 5 the the DT 19613 2633 6 older old JJR 19613 2633 7 form form NN 19613 2633 8 of of IN 19613 2633 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2633 10 continued continue VBD 19613 2633 11 to to TO 19613 2633 12 exert exert VB 19613 2633 13 an an DT 19613 2633 14 influence influence NN 19613 2633 15 on on IN 19613 2633 16 the the DT 19613 2633 17 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2633 18 Church Church NNP 19613 2633 19 of of IN 19613 2633 20 the the DT 19613 2633 21 third third JJ 19613 2633 22 century century NN 19613 2633 23 . . . 19613 2634 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2634 2 is be VBZ 19613 2634 3 true true JJ 19613 2634 4 that that IN 19613 2634 5 , , , 19613 2634 6 if if IN 19613 2634 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2634 8 can can MD 19613 2634 9 trust trust VB 19613 2634 10 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2634 11 ' ' POS 19613 2634 12 account account NN 19613 2634 13 , , , 19613 2634 14 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2634 15 had have VBD 19613 2634 16 by by IN 19613 2634 17 this this DT 19613 2634 18 time time NN 19613 2634 19 firmly firmly RB 19613 2634 20 set set VBD 19613 2634 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2634 22 face face NN 19613 2634 23 against against IN 19613 2634 24 the the DT 19613 2634 25 older old JJR 19613 2634 26 idea idea NN 19613 2634 27 , , , 19613 2634 28 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 2634 29 as as IN 19613 2634 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2634 31 not not RB 19613 2634 32 only only RB 19613 2634 33 defined define VBD 19613 2634 34 the the DT 19613 2634 35 Church Church NNP 19613 2634 36 as as IN 19613 2634 37 _ _ NNP 19613 2634 38 essentially essentially RB 19613 2634 39 a a DT 19613 2634 40 mixed mixed JJ 19613 2634 41 body body NN 19613 2634 42 _ _ NNP 19613 2634 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2634 44 _ _ NNP 19613 2634 45 corpus corpus NNP 19613 2634 46 permixtum permixtum NN 19613 2634 47 _ _ NNP 19613 2634 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2634 49 , , , 19613 2634 50 but but CC 19613 2634 51 also also RB 19613 2634 52 asserted assert VBD 19613 2634 53 the the DT 19613 2634 54 unlawfulness unlawfulness NN 19613 2634 55 of of IN 19613 2634 56 deposing depose VBG 19613 2634 57 the the DT 19613 2634 58 bishop bishop NN 19613 2634 59 even even RB 19613 2634 60 in in IN 19613 2634 61 case case NN 19613 2634 62 of of IN 19613 2634 63 mortal mortal JJ 19613 2634 64 sin sin NN 19613 2634 65 . . . 19613 2635 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2635 2 239 239 CD 19613 2635 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2635 4 But but CC 19613 2635 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2635 6 do do VBP 19613 2635 7 not not RB 19613 2635 8 find find VB 19613 2635 9 that that DT 19613 2635 10 definition definition NN 19613 2635 11 in in IN 19613 2635 12 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2635 13 , , , 19613 2635 14 and and CC 19613 2635 15 , , , 19613 2635 16 what what WP 19613 2635 17 is be VBZ 19613 2635 18 of of IN 19613 2635 19 more more JJR 19613 2635 20 importance importance NN 19613 2635 21 , , , 19613 2635 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2635 23 still still RB 19613 2635 24 required require VBD 19613 2635 25 a a DT 19613 2635 26 definite definite JJ 19613 2635 27 degree degree NN 19613 2635 28 of of IN 19613 2635 29 active active JJ 19613 2635 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2635 31 as as IN 19613 2635 32 a a DT 19613 2635 33 _ _ NNP 19613 2635 34 sine sine NN 19613 2635 35 quâ quâ NNP 19613 2635 36 non non AFX 19613 2635 37 _ _ NNP 19613 2635 38 in in IN 19613 2635 39 the the DT 19613 2635 40 case case NN 19613 2635 41 of of IN 19613 2635 42 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2635 43 ; ; : 19613 2635 44 and and CC 19613 2635 45 assumed assume VBD 19613 2635 46 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2635 47 as as IN 19613 2635 48 a a DT 19613 2635 49 self self NN 19613 2635 50 - - HYPH 19613 2635 51 evident evident JJ 19613 2635 52 necessity necessity NN 19613 2635 53 . . . 19613 2636 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2636 2 who who WP 19613 2636 3 does do VBZ 19613 2636 4 not not RB 19613 2636 5 give give VB 19613 2636 6 evidence evidence NN 19613 2636 7 of of IN 19613 2636 8 this this DT 19613 2636 9 forfeits forfeit VBZ 19613 2636 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2636 11 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 2636 12 office office NN 19613 2636 13 _ _ NNP 19613 2636 14 ipso ipso NN 19613 2636 15 facto facto FW 19613 2636 16 _ _ NNP 19613 2636 17 . . . 19613 2637 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2637 2 240 240 CD 19613 2637 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2637 4 Now now UH 19613 2637 5 if if IN 19613 2637 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2637 7 consider consider VBP 19613 2637 8 that that IN 19613 2637 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2637 10 makes make VBZ 19613 2637 11 the the DT 19613 2637 12 Church Church NNP 19613 2637 13 , , , 19613 2637 14 as as IN 19613 2637 15 the the DT 19613 2637 16 body body NN 19613 2637 17 of of IN 19613 2637 18 believers believer NNS 19613 2637 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2637 20 _ _ NNP 19613 2637 21 plebs plebs NN 19613 2637 22 credentium credentium NN 19613 2637 23 _ _ NNP 19613 2637 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2637 25 , , , 19613 2637 26 so so RB 19613 2637 27 dependent dependent JJ 19613 2637 28 on on IN 19613 2637 29 the the DT 19613 2637 30 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2637 31 , , , 19613 2637 32 that that IN 19613 2637 33 the the DT 19613 2637 34 latter latter JJ 19613 2637 35 are be VBP 19613 2637 36 the the DT 19613 2637 37 only only JJ 19613 2637 38 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2637 39 not not RB 19613 2637 40 under under IN 19613 2637 41 tutelage tutelage NN 19613 2637 42 , , , 19613 2637 43 the the DT 19613 2637 44 demand demand NN 19613 2637 45 in in IN 19613 2637 46 question question NN 19613 2637 47 denotes denote VBZ 19613 2637 48 a a DT 19613 2637 49 great great JJ 19613 2637 50 deal deal NN 19613 2637 51 . . . 19613 2638 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2638 2 carries carry VBZ 19613 2638 3 out out RP 19613 2638 4 the the DT 19613 2638 5 old old JJ 19613 2638 6 idea idea NN 19613 2638 7 of of IN 19613 2638 8 the the DT 19613 2638 9 Church Church NNP 19613 2638 10 in in IN 19613 2638 11 a a DT 19613 2638 12 certain certain JJ 19613 2638 13 fashion fashion NN 19613 2638 14 , , , 19613 2638 15 as as RB 19613 2638 16 far far RB 19613 2638 17 as as IN 19613 2638 18 the the DT 19613 2638 19 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2638 20 are be VBP 19613 2638 21 concerned concern VBN 19613 2638 22 . . . 19613 2639 1 But but CC 19613 2639 2 for for IN 19613 2639 3 this this DT 19613 2639 4 very very JJ 19613 2639 5 reason reason NN 19613 2639 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2639 7 endangers endanger VBZ 19613 2639 8 the the DT 19613 2639 9 new new JJ 19613 2639 10 conception conception NN 19613 2639 11 in in IN 19613 2639 12 a a DT 19613 2639 13 point point NN 19613 2639 14 of of IN 19613 2639 15 capital capital NN 19613 2639 16 importance importance NN 19613 2639 17 ; ; : 19613 2639 18 for for IN 19613 2639 19 the the DT 19613 2639 20 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2639 21 acts act NNS 19613 2639 22 of of IN 19613 2639 23 a a DT 19613 2639 24 sinful sinful JJ 19613 2639 25 bishop bishop NN 19613 2639 26 are be VBP 19613 2639 27 invalid;[241 invalid;[241 ADD 19613 2639 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2639 29 and and CC 19613 2639 30 if if IN 19613 2639 31 the the DT 19613 2639 32 latter latter JJ 19613 2639 33 , , , 19613 2639 34 as as IN 19613 2639 35 a a DT 19613 2639 36 notorious notorious JJ 19613 2639 37 sinner sinner NN 19613 2639 38 , , , 19613 2639 39 is be VBZ 19613 2639 40 no no DT 19613 2639 41 longer long RBR 19613 2639 42 bishop bishop NN 19613 2639 43 , , , 19613 2639 44 the the DT 19613 2639 45 whole whole JJ 19613 2639 46 certainty certainty NN 19613 2639 47 of of IN 19613 2639 48 the the DT 19613 2639 49 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2639 50 system system NN 19613 2639 51 ceases cease VBZ 19613 2639 52 . . . 19613 2640 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2640 2 , , , 19613 2640 3 an an DT 19613 2640 4 appeal appeal NN 19613 2640 5 to to IN 19613 2640 6 the the DT 19613 2640 7 certainty certainty NN 19613 2640 8 of of IN 19613 2640 9 God God NNP 19613 2640 10 's 's POS 19613 2640 11 installing instal VBG 19613 2640 12 the the DT 19613 2640 13 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2640 14 and and CC 19613 2640 15 always always RB 19613 2640 16 appointing appoint VBG 19613 2640 17 the the DT 19613 2640 18 right right NN 19613 2640 19 ones[242 ones[242 NN 19613 2640 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2640 21 is be VBZ 19613 2640 22 of of IN 19613 2640 23 no no DT 19613 2640 24 avail avail NN 19613 2640 25 , , , 19613 2640 26 if if IN 19613 2640 27 false false JJ 19613 2640 28 ones one NNS 19613 2640 29 manifestly manifestly RB 19613 2640 30 find find VBP 19613 2640 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2640 32 way way NN 19613 2640 33 in in IN 19613 2640 34 . . . 19613 2641 1 Hence hence RB 19613 2641 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2641 3 's 's POS 19613 2641 4 idea idea NN 19613 2641 5 of of IN 19613 2641 6 the the DT 19613 2641 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2641 8 -- -- : 19613 2641 9 and and CC 19613 2641 10 this this DT 19613 2641 11 is be VBZ 19613 2641 12 no no DT 19613 2641 13 dishonour dishonour NN 19613 2641 14 to to IN 19613 2641 15 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2641 16 -- -- : 19613 2641 17 still still RB 19613 2641 18 involved involve VBD 19613 2641 19 an an DT 19613 2641 20 inconsistency inconsistency NN 19613 2641 21 which which WDT 19613 2641 22 , , , 19613 2641 23 in in IN 19613 2641 24 the the DT 19613 2641 25 fourth fourth JJ 19613 2641 26 century century NN 19613 2641 27 , , , 19613 2641 28 was be VBD 19613 2641 29 destined destine VBN 19613 2641 30 to to TO 19613 2641 31 produce produce VB 19613 2641 32 a a DT 19613 2641 33 very very RB 19613 2641 34 serious serious JJ 19613 2641 35 crisis crisis NN 19613 2641 36 in in IN 19613 2641 37 the the DT 19613 2641 38 Donatist Donatist NNP 19613 2641 39 struggle struggle NN 19613 2641 40 . . . 19613 2642 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2642 2 243 243 CD 19613 2642 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2642 4 The the DT 19613 2642 5 view view NN 19613 2642 6 , , , 19613 2642 7 however however RB 19613 2642 8 -- -- : 19613 2642 9 which which WDT 19613 2642 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2642 11 never never RB 19613 2642 12 openly openly RB 19613 2642 13 expressed express VBD 19613 2642 14 , , , 19613 2642 15 and and CC 19613 2642 16 which which WDT 19613 2642 17 was be VBD 19613 2642 18 merely merely RB 19613 2642 19 the the DT 19613 2642 20 natural natural JJ 19613 2642 21 inference inference NN 19613 2642 22 from from IN 19613 2642 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2642 24 theory theory NN 19613 2642 25 -- -- : 19613 2642 26 that that IN 19613 2642 27 the the DT 19613 2642 28 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2642 29 Church Church NNP 19613 2642 30 , , , 19613 2642 31 though though IN 19613 2642 32 the the DT 19613 2642 33 " " `` 19613 2642 34 one one CD 19613 2642 35 dove dove NN 19613 2642 36 " " '' 19613 2642 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2642 38 " " `` 19613 2642 39 una una NNP 19613 2642 40 columba columba NNP 19613 2642 41 " " '' 19613 2642 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2642 43 , , , 19613 2642 44 is be VBZ 19613 2642 45 in in IN 19613 2642 46 truth truth NN 19613 2642 47 not not RB 19613 2642 48 coincident coincident NN 19613 2642 49 with with IN 19613 2642 50 the the DT 19613 2642 51 number number NN 19613 2642 52 of of IN 19613 2642 53 the the DT 19613 2642 54 elect elect NN 19613 2642 55 , , , 19613 2642 56 was be VBD 19613 2642 57 clearly clearly RB 19613 2642 58 recognised recognise VBN 19613 2642 59 and and CC 19613 2642 60 frankly frankly RB 19613 2642 61 expressed express VBN 19613 2642 62 by by IN 19613 2642 63 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2642 64 before before IN 19613 2642 65 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2642 66 . . . 19613 2643 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2643 2 plainly plainly RB 19613 2643 3 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 2643 4 between between IN 19613 2643 5 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2643 6 and and CC 19613 2643 7 fleshly fleshly JJ 19613 2643 8 members member NNS 19613 2643 9 of of IN 19613 2643 10 the the DT 19613 2643 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2643 12 ; ; : 19613 2643 13 and and CC 19613 2643 14 spoke speak VBD 19613 2643 15 of of IN 19613 2643 16 such such JJ 19613 2643 17 as as IN 19613 2643 18 only only RB 19613 2643 19 belong belong VB 19613 2643 20 to to IN 19613 2643 21 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2643 22 outwardly outwardly RB 19613 2643 23 , , , 19613 2643 24 but but CC 19613 2643 25 are be VBP 19613 2643 26 not not RB 19613 2643 27 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2643 28 . . . 19613 2644 1 As as IN 19613 2644 2 these these DT 19613 2644 3 are be VBP 19613 2644 4 finally finally RB 19613 2644 5 overpowered overpower VBN 19613 2644 6 by by IN 19613 2644 7 the the DT 19613 2644 8 gates gate NNS 19613 2644 9 of of IN 19613 2644 10 hell hell NN 19613 2644 11 , , , 19613 2644 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2644 13 does do VBZ 19613 2644 14 not not RB 19613 2644 15 hesitate hesitate VB 19613 2644 16 to to TO 19613 2644 17 class class VB 19613 2644 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2644 19 as as IN 19613 2644 20 merely merely RB 19613 2644 21 seeming seeming JJ 19613 2644 22 members member NNS 19613 2644 23 of of IN 19613 2644 24 the the DT 19613 2644 25 Church Church NNP 19613 2644 26 . . . 19613 2645 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 2645 2 , , , 19613 2645 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2645 4 contemplates contemplate VBZ 19613 2645 5 the the DT 19613 2645 6 possibility possibility NN 19613 2645 7 of of IN 19613 2645 8 a a DT 19613 2645 9 person person NN 19613 2645 10 being be VBG 19613 2645 11 expelled expel VBN 19613 2645 12 from from IN 19613 2645 13 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2645 14 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2645 15 and and CC 19613 2645 16 yet yet RB 19613 2645 17 remaining remain VBG 19613 2645 18 a a DT 19613 2645 19 member member NN 19613 2645 20 in in IN 19613 2645 21 the the DT 19613 2645 22 eyes eye NNS 19613 2645 23 of of IN 19613 2645 24 God God NNP 19613 2645 25 . . . 19613 2646 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2646 2 244 244 CD 19613 2646 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2646 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2646 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2646 6 by by IN 19613 2646 7 no no DT 19613 2646 8 means means NN 19613 2646 9 attained attain VBN 19613 2646 10 to to IN 19613 2646 11 clearness clearness VB 19613 2646 12 on on IN 19613 2646 13 the the DT 19613 2646 14 point point NN 19613 2646 15 , , , 19613 2646 16 in in IN 19613 2646 17 which which WDT 19613 2646 18 case case NN 19613 2646 19 , , , 19613 2646 20 moreover moreover RB 19613 2646 21 , , , 19613 2646 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2646 23 would would MD 19613 2646 24 have have VB 19613 2646 25 been be VBN 19613 2646 26 the the DT 19613 2646 27 first first JJ 19613 2646 28 to to TO 19613 2646 29 do do VB 19613 2646 30 so so RB 19613 2646 31 ; ; : 19613 2646 32 nor nor CC 19613 2646 33 did do VBD 19613 2646 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2646 35 give give VB 19613 2646 36 an an DT 19613 2646 37 impulse impulse NN 19613 2646 38 to to IN 19613 2646 39 further further JJ 19613 2646 40 reflection reflection NN 19613 2646 41 on on IN 19613 2646 42 the the DT 19613 2646 43 problem problem NN 19613 2646 44 . . . 19613 2647 1 Besides besides IN 19613 2647 2 , , , 19613 2647 3 speculations speculation NNS 19613 2647 4 were be VBD 19613 2647 5 of of IN 19613 2647 6 no no DT 19613 2647 7 use use NN 19613 2647 8 here here RB 19613 2647 9 . . . 19613 2648 1 The the DT 19613 2648 2 Church Church NNP 19613 2648 3 with with IN 19613 2648 4 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2648 5 priests priest NNS 19613 2648 6 , , , 19613 2648 7 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2648 8 holy holy JJ 19613 2648 9 books book NNS 19613 2648 10 , , , 19613 2648 11 and and CC 19613 2648 12 gifts gift NNS 19613 2648 13 of of IN 19613 2648 14 grace grace NN 19613 2648 15 , , , 19613 2648 16 that that RB 19613 2648 17 is is RB 19613 2648 18 , , , 19613 2648 19 the the DT 19613 2648 20 moderate moderate JJ 19613 2648 21 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 2648 22 of of IN 19613 2648 23 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2648 24 corrected correct VBN 19613 2648 25 by by IN 19613 2648 26 the the DT 19613 2648 27 means mean NNS 19613 2648 28 of of IN 19613 2648 29 grace grace NN 19613 2648 30 , , , 19613 2648 31 was be VBD 19613 2648 32 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 2648 33 needed need VBN 19613 2648 34 in in IN 19613 2648 35 order order NN 19613 2648 36 to to TO 19613 2648 37 prevent prevent VB 19613 2648 38 a a DT 19613 2648 39 complete complete JJ 19613 2648 40 lapse lapse NN 19613 2648 41 into into IN 19613 2648 42 immorality immorality NN 19613 2648 43 . . . 19613 2649 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2649 2 245 245 CD 19613 2649 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2649 4 But but CC 19613 2649 5 a a DT 19613 2649 6 minority minority NN 19613 2649 7 struggled struggle VBN 19613 2649 8 against against IN 19613 2649 9 this this DT 19613 2649 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2649 11 , , , 19613 2649 12 not not RB 19613 2649 13 with with IN 19613 2649 14 speculations speculation NNS 19613 2649 15 , , , 19613 2649 16 but but CC 19613 2649 17 by by IN 19613 2649 18 demanding demand VBG 19613 2649 19 adherence adherence NN 19613 2649 20 to to IN 19613 2649 21 the the DT 19613 2649 22 old old JJ 19613 2649 23 practice practice NN 19613 2649 24 with with IN 19613 2649 25 regard regard NN 19613 2649 26 to to IN 19613 2649 27 lapsed lapsed JJ 19613 2649 28 members member NNS 19613 2649 29 . . . 19613 2650 1 Under under IN 19613 2650 2 the the DT 19613 2650 3 leadership leadership NN 19613 2650 4 of of IN 19613 2650 5 the the DT 19613 2650 6 Roman roman JJ 19613 2650 7 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 2650 8 , , , 19613 2650 9 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2650 10 , , , 19613 2650 11 this this DT 19613 2650 12 section section NN 19613 2650 13 formed form VBD 19613 2650 14 a a DT 19613 2650 15 coalition coalition NN 19613 2650 16 in in IN 19613 2650 17 the the DT 19613 2650 18 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2650 19 that that WDT 19613 2650 20 opposed oppose VBD 19613 2650 21 the the DT 19613 2650 22 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2650 23 confederation confederation NN 19613 2650 24 . . . 19613 2651 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2651 2 246 246 CD 19613 2651 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2651 4 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2651 5 adherence adherence NN 19613 2651 6 to to IN 19613 2651 7 the the DT 19613 2651 8 old old JJ 19613 2651 9 system system NN 19613 2651 10 of of IN 19613 2651 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2651 12 discipline discipline NN 19613 2651 13 involved involve VBD 19613 2651 14 a a DT 19613 2651 15 reaction reaction NN 19613 2651 16 against against IN 19613 2651 17 the the DT 19613 2651 18 secularising secularising NN 19613 2651 19 process process NN 19613 2651 20 , , , 19613 2651 21 which which WDT 19613 2651 22 did do VBD 19613 2651 23 not not RB 19613 2651 24 seem seem VB 19613 2651 25 to to TO 19613 2651 26 be be VB 19613 2651 27 tempered temper VBN 19613 2651 28 by by IN 19613 2651 29 the the DT 19613 2651 30 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2651 31 powers power NNS 19613 2651 32 of of IN 19613 2651 33 the the DT 19613 2651 34 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2651 35 . . . 19613 2652 1 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2652 2 's 's POS 19613 2652 3 conception conception NN 19613 2652 4 of of IN 19613 2652 5 the the DT 19613 2652 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2652 7 , , , 19613 2652 8 of of IN 19613 2652 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2652 10 absolution absolution NN 19613 2652 11 and and CC 19613 2652 12 the the DT 19613 2652 13 rights right NNS 19613 2652 14 of of IN 19613 2652 15 the the DT 19613 2652 16 priests priest NNS 19613 2652 17 , , , 19613 2652 18 and and CC 19613 2652 19 in in IN 19613 2652 20 short short JJ 19613 2652 21 , , , 19613 2652 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2652 23 notion notion NN 19613 2652 24 of of IN 19613 2652 25 the the DT 19613 2652 26 power power NN 19613 2652 27 of of IN 19613 2652 28 the the DT 19613 2652 29 keys key NNS 19613 2652 30 is be VBZ 19613 2652 31 different different JJ 19613 2652 32 from from IN 19613 2652 33 that that DT 19613 2652 34 of of IN 19613 2652 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2652 36 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2652 37 . . . 19613 2653 1 This this DT 19613 2653 2 is be VBZ 19613 2653 3 clear clear JJ 19613 2653 4 from from IN 19613 2653 5 a a DT 19613 2653 6 variety variety NN 19613 2653 7 of of IN 19613 2653 8 considerations consideration NNS 19613 2653 9 . . . 19613 2654 1 For for IN 19613 2654 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2654 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2654 4 with with IN 19613 2654 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2654 6 followers follower NNS 19613 2654 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2654 8 assigned assign VBN 19613 2654 9 to to IN 19613 2654 10 the the DT 19613 2654 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2654 12 the the DT 19613 2654 13 right right NN 19613 2654 14 and and CC 19613 2654 15 duty duty NN 19613 2654 16 of of IN 19613 2654 17 expelling expel VBG 19613 2654 18 gross gross JJ 19613 2654 19 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2654 20 once once RB 19613 2654 21 for for IN 19613 2654 22 all;[247 all;[247 NNP 19613 2654 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2654 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2654 25 denied deny VBD 19613 2654 26 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2654 27 the the DT 19613 2654 28 authority authority NN 19613 2654 29 to to TO 19613 2654 30 absolve absolve VB 19613 2654 31 idolaters idolater NNS 19613 2654 32 , , , 19613 2654 33 but but CC 19613 2654 34 left leave VBD 19613 2654 35 these these DT 19613 2654 36 to to IN 19613 2654 37 the the DT 19613 2654 38 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2654 39 of of IN 19613 2654 40 God God NNP 19613 2654 41 who who WP 19613 2654 42 alone alone RB 19613 2654 43 has have VBZ 19613 2654 44 the the DT 19613 2654 45 power power NN 19613 2654 46 of of IN 19613 2654 47 pardoning pardon VBG 19613 2654 48 sins sin NNS 19613 2654 49 committed commit VBD 19613 2654 50 against against IN 19613 2654 51 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2654 52 ; ; : 19613 2654 53 and and CC 19613 2654 54 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2654 55 asserted assert VBD 19613 2654 56 : : : 19613 2654 57 " " `` 19613 2654 58 non non AFX 19613 2654 59 est est NNP 19613 2654 60 pax pax NNP 19613 2654 61 illi illi NNP 19613 2654 62 ab ab NNP 19613 2654 63 episcopo episcopo NNP 19613 2654 64 necessaria necessaria NNP 19613 2654 65 habituro habituro NNP 19613 2654 66 gloriæ gloriæ NNP 19613 2654 67 suæ suæ NNP 19613 2654 68 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2654 69 scil scil NN 19613 2654 70 . . . 19613 2655 1 martyrii martyrii NNP 19613 2655 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2655 3 pacem pacem NNP 19613 2655 4 et et NNP 19613 2655 5 accepturo accepturo NNP 19613 2655 6 maiorem maiorem NNP 19613 2655 7 de de NNP 19613 2655 8 domini domini NNP 19613 2655 9 dignatione dignatione NN 19613 2655 10 mercedem,"--"the mercedem,"--"the DT 19613 2655 11 absolution absolution NN 19613 2655 12 of of IN 19613 2655 13 the the DT 19613 2655 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 2655 15 is be VBZ 19613 2655 16 not not RB 19613 2655 17 needed need VBN 19613 2655 18 by by IN 19613 2655 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2655 20 who who WP 19613 2655 21 will will MD 19613 2655 22 receive receive VB 19613 2655 23 the the DT 19613 2655 24 peace peace NN 19613 2655 25 of of IN 19613 2655 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2655 27 glory glory NN 19613 2655 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2655 29 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2655 30 , , , 19613 2655 31 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 2655 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2655 33 and and CC 19613 2655 34 will will MD 19613 2655 35 obtain obtain VB 19613 2655 36 a a DT 19613 2655 37 greater great JJR 19613 2655 38 reward reward NN 19613 2655 39 from from IN 19613 2655 40 the the DT 19613 2655 41 approbation approbation NN 19613 2655 42 of of IN 19613 2655 43 the the DT 19613 2655 44 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2655 45 " " '' 19613 2655 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2655 47 Cypr Cypr NNS 19613 2655 48 . . . 19613 2656 1 ep ep NNP 19613 2656 2 . . . 19613 2657 1 57 57 CD 19613 2657 2 . . . 19613 2658 1 4 4 LS 19613 2658 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2658 3 , , , 19613 2658 4 and and CC 19613 2658 5 on on IN 19613 2658 6 the the DT 19613 2658 7 other other JJ 19613 2658 8 hand hand NN 19613 2658 9 taught teach VBD 19613 2658 10 : : : 19613 2658 11 " " `` 19613 2658 12 peccato peccato NNP 19613 2658 13 alterius alterius NNP 19613 2658 14 inquinari inquinari NNP 19613 2658 15 alterum alterum NNP 19613 2658 16 et et NNP 19613 2658 17 idololatriam idololatriam NNP 19613 2658 18 delinquentis delinquentis NNP 19613 2658 19 ad ad NNP 19613 2658 20 non non AFX 19613 2658 21 delinquentem delinquentem NNP 19613 2658 22 transire,"--"the transire,"--"the DT 19613 2658 23 one one NN 19613 2658 24 is be VBZ 19613 2658 25 defiled defile VBN 19613 2658 26 by by IN 19613 2658 27 the the DT 19613 2658 28 sin sin NN 19613 2658 29 of of IN 19613 2658 30 the the DT 19613 2658 31 other other JJ 19613 2658 32 and and CC 19613 2658 33 the the DT 19613 2658 34 idolatry idolatry NN 19613 2658 35 of of IN 19613 2658 36 the the DT 19613 2658 37 transgressor transgressor NNP 19613 2658 38 passes pass VBZ 19613 2658 39 over over RP 19613 2658 40 to to IN 19613 2658 41 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2658 42 who who WP 19613 2658 43 does do VBZ 19613 2658 44 not not RB 19613 2658 45 transgress transgress VB 19613 2658 46 . . . 19613 2658 47 " " '' 19613 2659 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2659 2 proposition proposition NN 19613 2659 3 that that IN 19613 2659 4 none none NN 19613 2659 5 but but IN 19613 2659 6 God God NNP 19613 2659 7 can can MD 19613 2659 8 forgive forgive VB 19613 2659 9 sins sin NNS 19613 2659 10 does do VBZ 19613 2659 11 not not RB 19613 2659 12 depotentiate depotentiate VB 19613 2659 13 the the DT 19613 2659 14 idea idea NN 19613 2659 15 of of IN 19613 2659 16 the the DT 19613 2659 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2659 18 ; ; : 19613 2659 19 but but CC 19613 2659 20 secures secure VBZ 19613 2659 21 both both CC 19613 2659 22 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2659 23 proper proper JJ 19613 2659 24 religious religious JJ 19613 2659 25 significance significance NN 19613 2659 26 and and CC 19613 2659 27 the the DT 19613 2659 28 full full JJ 19613 2659 29 sense sense NN 19613 2659 30 of of IN 19613 2659 31 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2659 32 dispensations dispensation NNS 19613 2659 33 of of IN 19613 2659 34 grace grace NN 19613 2659 35 : : : 19613 2659 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2659 37 limits limit VBZ 19613 2659 38 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2659 39 powers power NNS 19613 2659 40 and and CC 19613 2659 41 _ _ NNP 19613 2659 42 extent extent NN 19613 2659 43 _ _ NNP 19613 2659 44 in in IN 19613 2659 45 favour favour NN 19613 2659 46 of of IN 19613 2659 47 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2659 48 _ _ NNP 19613 2659 49 content content NN 19613 2659 50 _ _ NNP 19613 2659 51 . . . 19613 2660 1 Refusal refusal NN 19613 2660 2 of of IN 19613 2660 3 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2660 4 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2660 5 under under IN 19613 2660 6 certain certain JJ 19613 2660 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2660 8 -- -- : 19613 2660 9 though though IN 19613 2660 10 this this DT 19613 2660 11 does do VBZ 19613 2660 12 not not RB 19613 2660 13 exclude exclude VB 19613 2660 14 the the DT 19613 2660 15 confident confident JJ 19613 2660 16 hope hope NN 19613 2660 17 of of IN 19613 2660 18 God God NNP 19613 2660 19 's 's POS 19613 2660 20 mercy mercy NN 19613 2660 21 -- -- : 19613 2660 22 can can MD 19613 2660 23 only only RB 19613 2660 24 mean mean VB 19613 2660 25 that that IN 19613 2660 26 in in IN 19613 2660 27 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2660 28 's 's POS 19613 2660 29 view view NN 19613 2660 30 this this DT 19613 2660 31 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2660 32 is be VBZ 19613 2660 33 the the DT 19613 2660 34 foundation foundation NN 19613 2660 35 of of IN 19613 2660 36 salvation salvation NN 19613 2660 37 and and CC 19613 2660 38 does do VBZ 19613 2660 39 not not RB 19613 2660 40 merely merely RB 19613 2660 41 avert avert VB 19613 2660 42 the the DT 19613 2660 43 certainty certainty NN 19613 2660 44 of of IN 19613 2660 45 perdition perdition NN 19613 2660 46 . . . 19613 2661 1 To to IN 19613 2661 2 the the DT 19613 2661 3 Novatians Novatians NNPS 19613 2661 4 , , , 19613 2661 5 then then RB 19613 2661 6 , , , 19613 2661 7 membership membership NN 19613 2661 8 of of IN 19613 2661 9 the the DT 19613 2661 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2661 11 is be VBZ 19613 2661 12 not not RB 19613 2661 13 the the DT 19613 2661 14 _ _ NNP 19613 2661 15 sine sine NN 19613 2661 16 quâ quâ NNP 19613 2661 17 non non AFX 19613 2661 18 _ _ NNP 19613 2661 19 of of IN 19613 2661 20 salvation salvation NN 19613 2661 21 , , , 19613 2661 22 but but CC 19613 2661 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2661 24 really really RB 19613 2661 25 secures secure VBZ 19613 2661 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2661 27 in in IN 19613 2661 28 some some DT 19613 2661 29 measure measure NN 19613 2661 30 . . . 19613 2662 1 In in IN 19613 2662 2 certain certain JJ 19613 2662 3 cases case NNS 19613 2662 4 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2662 5 the the DT 19613 2662 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2662 7 may may MD 19613 2662 8 not not RB 19613 2662 9 anticipate anticipate VB 19613 2662 10 the the DT 19613 2662 11 judgment judgment NN 19613 2662 12 of of IN 19613 2662 13 God God NNP 19613 2662 14 . . . 19613 2663 1 Now now RB 19613 2663 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2663 3 is be VBZ 19613 2663 4 never never RB 19613 2663 5 by by IN 19613 2663 6 exclusion exclusion NN 19613 2663 7 , , , 19613 2663 8 but but CC 19613 2663 9 by by IN 19613 2663 10 readmission readmission NN 19613 2663 11 , , , 19613 2663 12 that that IN 19613 2663 13 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2663 14 does do VBZ 19613 2663 15 so so RB 19613 2663 16 . . . 19613 2664 1 As as IN 19613 2664 2 the the DT 19613 2664 3 assembly assembly NN 19613 2664 4 of of IN 19613 2664 5 the the DT 19613 2664 6 baptised baptise VBN 19613 2664 7 , , , 19613 2664 8 who who WP 19613 2664 9 have have VBP 19613 2664 10 received receive VBN 19613 2664 11 God God NNP 19613 2664 12 's 's POS 19613 2664 13 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2664 14 , , , 19613 2664 15 the the DT 19613 2664 16 Church Church NNP 19613 2664 17 must must MD 19613 2664 18 be be VB 19613 2664 19 a a DT 19613 2664 20 real real JJ 19613 2664 21 communion communion NN 19613 2664 22 of of IN 19613 2664 23 salvation salvation NN 19613 2664 24 and and CC 19613 2664 25 of of IN 19613 2664 26 saints saint NNS 19613 2664 27 ; ; : 19613 2664 28 hence hence RB 19613 2664 29 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2664 30 can can MD 19613 2664 31 not not RB 19613 2664 32 endure endure VB 19613 2664 33 unholy unholy JJ 19613 2664 34 persons person NNS 19613 2664 35 in in IN 19613 2664 36 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2664 37 midst midst NN 19613 2664 38 without without IN 19613 2664 39 losing lose VBG 19613 2664 40 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2664 41 essence essence NN 19613 2664 42 . . . 19613 2665 1 Each each DT 19613 2665 2 gross gross JJ 19613 2665 3 sinner sinner NN 19613 2665 4 that that WDT 19613 2665 5 is be VBZ 19613 2665 6 tolerated tolerate VBN 19613 2665 7 within within IN 19613 2665 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2665 9 calls call VBZ 19613 2665 10 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2665 11 legitimacy legitimacy NN 19613 2665 12 in in IN 19613 2665 13 question question NN 19613 2665 14 . . . 19613 2666 1 But but CC 19613 2666 2 , , , 19613 2666 3 from from IN 19613 2666 4 this this DT 19613 2666 5 point point NN 19613 2666 6 of of IN 19613 2666 7 view view NN 19613 2666 8 , , , 19613 2666 9 the the DT 19613 2666 10 constitution constitution NN 19613 2666 11 of of IN 19613 2666 12 the the DT 19613 2666 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2666 14 , , , 19613 2666 15 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2666 16 , , , 19613 2666 17 the the DT 19613 2666 18 distinction distinction NN 19613 2666 19 of of IN 19613 2666 20 lay lay NN 19613 2666 21 and and CC 19613 2666 22 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2666 23 and and CC 19613 2666 24 the the DT 19613 2666 25 authority authority NN 19613 2666 26 of of IN 19613 2666 27 the the DT 19613 2666 28 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2666 29 , , , 19613 2666 30 likewise likewise RB 19613 2666 31 retained retain VBD 19613 2666 32 nothing nothing NN 19613 2666 33 but but IN 19613 2666 34 the the DT 19613 2666 35 secondary secondary JJ 19613 2666 36 importance importance NN 19613 2666 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2666 38 had have VBD 19613 2666 39 in in IN 19613 2666 40 earlier early JJR 19613 2666 41 times time NNS 19613 2666 42 . . . 19613 2667 1 For for IN 19613 2667 2 , , , 19613 2667 3 according accord VBG 19613 2667 4 to to IN 19613 2667 5 those those DT 19613 2667 6 principles principle NNS 19613 2667 7 , , , 19613 2667 8 the the DT 19613 2667 9 primary primary JJ 19613 2667 10 question question NN 19613 2667 11 as as IN 19613 2667 12 regards regard VBZ 19613 2667 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2667 14 membership membership NN 19613 2667 15 is be VBZ 19613 2667 16 not not RB 19613 2667 17 connection connection NN 19613 2667 18 with with IN 19613 2667 19 the the DT 19613 2667 20 clergy clergy NN 19613 2667 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2667 22 the the DT 19613 2667 23 bishop bishop NN 19613 2667 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2667 25 . . . 19613 2668 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2668 2 is be VBZ 19613 2668 3 rather rather RB 19613 2668 4 connection connection NN 19613 2668 5 with with IN 19613 2668 6 the the DT 19613 2668 7 community community NN 19613 2668 8 , , , 19613 2668 9 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2668 10 with with IN 19613 2668 11 which which WDT 19613 2668 12 secures secure VBZ 19613 2668 13 the the DT 19613 2668 14 salvation salvation NN 19613 2668 15 that that WDT 19613 2668 16 may may MD 19613 2668 17 indeed indeed RB 19613 2668 18 be be VB 19613 2668 19 found find VBN 19613 2668 20 outside outside IN 19613 2668 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2668 22 pale pale NN 19613 2668 23 , , , 19613 2668 24 but but CC 19613 2668 25 not not RB 19613 2668 26 with with IN 19613 2668 27 certainty certainty NN 19613 2668 28 . . . 19613 2669 1 But but CC 19613 2669 2 other other JJ 19613 2669 3 causes cause NNS 19613 2669 4 contributed contribute VBD 19613 2669 5 to to TO 19613 2669 6 lessen lessen VB 19613 2669 7 the the DT 19613 2669 8 importance importance NN 19613 2669 9 of of IN 19613 2669 10 the the DT 19613 2669 11 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2669 12 : : : 19613 2669 13 the the DT 19613 2669 14 art art NN 19613 2669 15 of of IN 19613 2669 16 casuistry casuistry NN 19613 2669 17 , , , 19613 2669 18 so so RB 19613 2669 19 far far RB 19613 2669 20 - - HYPH 19613 2669 21 reaching reach VBG 19613 2669 22 in in IN 19613 2669 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2669 24 results result NNS 19613 2669 25 , , , 19613 2669 26 was be VBD 19613 2669 27 unable unable JJ 19613 2669 28 to to TO 19613 2669 29 find find VB 19613 2669 30 a a DT 19613 2669 31 fruitful fruitful JJ 19613 2669 32 soil soil NN 19613 2669 33 here here RB 19613 2669 34 , , , 19613 2669 35 and and CC 19613 2669 36 the the DT 19613 2669 37 laity laity NN 19613 2669 38 were be VBD 19613 2669 39 treated treat VBN 19613 2669 40 in in IN 19613 2669 41 exactly exactly RB 19613 2669 42 the the DT 19613 2669 43 same same JJ 19613 2669 44 way way NN 19613 2669 45 as as IN 19613 2669 46 the the DT 19613 2669 47 clergy clergy NN 19613 2669 48 . . . 19613 2670 1 The the DT 19613 2670 2 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 2670 3 difference difference NN 19613 2670 4 between between IN 19613 2670 5 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2670 6 and and CC 19613 2670 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2670 8 as as IN 19613 2670 9 to to IN 19613 2670 10 the the DT 19613 2670 11 idea idea NN 19613 2670 12 of of IN 19613 2670 13 the the DT 19613 2670 14 Church Church NNP 19613 2670 15 and and CC 19613 2670 16 the the DT 19613 2670 17 power power NN 19613 2670 18 to to TO 19613 2670 19 bind bind VB 19613 2670 20 and and CC 19613 2670 21 loose loose JJ 19613 2670 22 did do VBD 19613 2670 23 not not RB 19613 2670 24 become become VB 19613 2670 25 clear clear JJ 19613 2670 26 to to IN 19613 2670 27 the the DT 19613 2670 28 latter latter JJ 19613 2670 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2670 30 . . . 19613 2671 1 This this DT 19613 2671 2 was be VBD 19613 2671 3 because because IN 19613 2671 4 , , , 19613 2671 5 in in IN 19613 2671 6 regard regard NN 19613 2671 7 to to IN 19613 2671 8 the the DT 19613 2671 9 idea idea NN 19613 2671 10 of of IN 19613 2671 11 the the DT 19613 2671 12 Church Church NNP 19613 2671 13 , , , 19613 2671 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2671 15 partly partly RB 19613 2671 16 overlooked overlook VBD 19613 2671 17 the the DT 19613 2671 18 inferences inference NNS 19613 2671 19 from from IN 19613 2671 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2671 21 own own JJ 19613 2671 22 view view NN 19613 2671 23 and and CC 19613 2671 24 to to IN 19613 2671 25 some some DT 19613 2671 26 extent extent NN 19613 2671 27 even even RB 19613 2671 28 directly directly RB 19613 2671 29 repudiated repudiate VBD 19613 2671 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2671 31 . . . 19613 2672 1 An an DT 19613 2672 2 attempt attempt NN 19613 2672 3 to to TO 19613 2672 4 lay lay VB 19613 2672 5 down down RP 19613 2672 6 a a DT 19613 2672 7 principle principle NN 19613 2672 8 for for IN 19613 2672 9 judging judge VBG 19613 2672 10 the the DT 19613 2672 11 case case NN 19613 2672 12 is be VBZ 19613 2672 13 found find VBN 19613 2672 14 in in IN 19613 2672 15 ep ep NNP 19613 2672 16 . . . 19613 2673 1 69 69 CD 19613 2673 2 . . . 19613 2674 1 7 7 LS 19613 2674 2 : : : 19613 2674 3 " " `` 19613 2674 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2674 5 and and CC 19613 2674 6 the the DT 19613 2674 7 schismatics schismatic NNS 19613 2674 8 have have VBP 19613 2674 9 neither neither CC 19613 2674 10 the the DT 19613 2674 11 same same JJ 19613 2674 12 law law NN 19613 2674 13 of of IN 19613 2674 14 the the DT 19613 2674 15 creed creed NN 19613 2674 16 nor nor CC 19613 2674 17 the the DT 19613 2674 18 same same JJ 19613 2674 19 interrogation interrogation NN 19613 2674 20 , , , 19613 2674 21 for for IN 19613 2674 22 when when WRB 19613 2674 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2674 24 say say VBP 19613 2674 25 : : : 19613 2674 26 ' ' '' 19613 2674 27 you -PRON- PRP 19613 2674 28 believe believe VBP 19613 2674 29 in in IN 19613 2674 30 the the DT 19613 2674 31 remission remission NN 19613 2674 32 of of IN 19613 2674 33 sins sin NNS 19613 2674 34 and and CC 19613 2674 35 eternal eternal JJ 19613 2674 36 life life NN 19613 2674 37 through through IN 19613 2674 38 the the DT 19613 2674 39 holy holy NNP 19613 2674 40 Church Church NNP 19613 2674 41 , , , 19613 2674 42 ' ' '' 19613 2674 43 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2674 44 speak speak VBP 19613 2674 45 falsely falsely RB 19613 2674 46 " " '' 19613 2674 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2674 48 " " `` 19613 2674 49 non non AFX 19613 2674 50 est est NNP 19613 2674 51 una una NNP 19613 2674 52 nobis nobi NNS 19613 2674 53 et et NNP 19613 2674 54 schismaticis schismaticis NNP 19613 2674 55 symboli symboli NNP 19613 2674 56 lex lex NNP 19613 2674 57 neque neque NNP 19613 2674 58 eadem eadem NNP 19613 2674 59 interrogatio interrogatio NNP 19613 2674 60 ; ; : 19613 2674 61 nam nam NNP 19613 2674 62 cum cum NNP 19613 2674 63 dicunt dicunt NNP 19613 2674 64 , , , 19613 2674 65 credis credis NNP 19613 2674 66 in in IN 19613 2674 67 remissionem remissionem NNP 19613 2674 68 peccatorum peccatorum NNP 19613 2674 69 et et NNP 19613 2674 70 vitam vitam NNP 19613 2674 71 æternam æternam NNP 19613 2674 72 per per IN 19613 2674 73 sanctam sanctam NNP 19613 2674 74 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 2674 75 , , , 19613 2674 76 mentiuntur mentiuntur NN 19613 2674 77 " " '' 19613 2674 78 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2674 79 . . . 19613 2675 1 Nor nor CC 19613 2675 2 did do VBD 19613 2675 3 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 2675 4 of of IN 19613 2675 5 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2675 6 , , , 19613 2675 7 who who WP 19613 2675 8 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 2675 9 to to TO 19613 2675 10 accumulate accumulate VB 19613 2675 11 reproaches reproach NNS 19613 2675 12 against against IN 19613 2675 13 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2675 14 , , , 19613 2675 15 succeed succeed VB 19613 2675 16 in in IN 19613 2675 17 forming form VBG 19613 2675 18 any any DT 19613 2675 19 effective effective JJ 19613 2675 20 accusation accusation NN 19613 2675 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2675 22 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2675 23 . . NNP 19613 2675 24 , , , 19613 2675 25 H. H. NNP 19613 2675 26 E. E. NNP 19613 2675 27 VII VII NNP 19613 2675 28 . . . 19613 2676 1 8) 8) CD 19613 2676 2 . . . 19613 2677 1 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 2677 2 - - HYPH 19613 2677 3 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2677 4 had have VBD 19613 2677 5 just just RB 19613 2677 6 as as RB 19613 2677 7 little little JJ 19613 2677 8 success success NN 19613 2677 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2677 10 ad ad NN 19613 2677 11 Novatianum Novatianum NNP 19613 2677 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2677 13 . . . 19613 2678 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2678 2 was be VBD 19613 2678 3 not not RB 19613 2678 4 till till IN 19613 2678 5 the the DT 19613 2678 6 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 2678 7 period period NN 19613 2678 8 , , , 19613 2678 9 when when WRB 19613 2678 10 the the DT 19613 2678 11 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2678 12 Church Church NNP 19613 2678 13 had have VBD 19613 2678 14 resolutely resolutely RB 19613 2678 15 pursued pursue VBN 19613 2678 16 the the DT 19613 2678 17 path path NN 19613 2678 18 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2678 19 had have VBD 19613 2678 20 entered enter VBN 19613 2678 21 , , , 19613 2678 22 that that IN 19613 2678 23 the the DT 19613 2678 24 difference difference NN 19613 2678 25 in in IN 19613 2678 26 principle principle NN 19613 2678 27 manifested manifest VBD 19613 2678 28 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2678 29 with with IN 19613 2678 30 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 19613 2678 31 plainness plainness NN 19613 2678 32 . . . 19613 2679 1 The the DT 19613 2679 2 historical historical JJ 19613 2679 3 estimate estimate NN 19613 2679 4 of of IN 19613 2679 5 the the DT 19613 2679 6 contrast contrast NN 19613 2679 7 must must MD 19613 2679 8 vary vary VB 19613 2679 9 in in IN 19613 2679 10 proportion proportion NN 19613 2679 11 as as IN 19613 2679 12 one one CD 19613 2679 13 contemplates contemplate VBZ 19613 2679 14 the the DT 19613 2679 15 demands demand NNS 19613 2679 16 of of IN 19613 2679 17 primitive primitive JJ 19613 2679 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2679 19 or or CC 19613 2679 20 the the DT 19613 2679 21 requirements requirement NNS 19613 2679 22 of of IN 19613 2679 23 the the DT 19613 2679 24 time time NN 19613 2679 25 . . . 19613 2680 1 The the DT 19613 2680 2 Novatian novatian JJ 19613 2680 3 confederation confederation NN 19613 2680 4 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 2680 5 preserved preserve VBD 19613 2680 6 a a DT 19613 2680 7 valuable valuable JJ 19613 2680 8 remnant remnant NN 19613 2680 9 of of IN 19613 2680 10 the the DT 19613 2680 11 old old JJ 19613 2680 12 tradition tradition NN 19613 2680 13 . . . 19613 2681 1 The the DT 19613 2681 2 idea idea NN 19613 2681 3 that that IN 19613 2681 4 the the DT 19613 2681 5 Church Church NNP 19613 2681 6 , , , 19613 2681 7 as as IN 19613 2681 8 a a DT 19613 2681 9 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2681 10 of of IN 19613 2681 11 salvation salvation NN 19613 2681 12 , , , 19613 2681 13 must must MD 19613 2681 14 also also RB 19613 2681 15 be be VB 19613 2681 16 the the DT 19613 2681 17 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2681 18 of of IN 19613 2681 19 saints saint NNS 19613 2681 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2681 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2681 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2681 23 : : : 19613 2681 24 Katharoi Katharoi NNP 19613 2681 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2681 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2681 27 corresponds correspond VBZ 19613 2681 28 to to IN 19613 2681 29 the the DT 19613 2681 30 ideas idea NNS 19613 2681 31 of of IN 19613 2681 32 the the DT 19613 2681 33 earliest early JJS 19613 2681 34 period period NN 19613 2681 35 . . . 19613 2682 1 The the DT 19613 2682 2 followers follower NNS 19613 2682 3 of of IN 19613 2682 4 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2682 5 did do VBD 19613 2682 6 not not RB 19613 2682 7 entirely entirely RB 19613 2682 8 identify identify VB 19613 2682 9 the the DT 19613 2682 10 political political JJ 19613 2682 11 and and CC 19613 2682 12 religious religious JJ 19613 2682 13 attributes attribute NNS 19613 2682 14 of of IN 19613 2682 15 the the DT 19613 2682 16 Church Church NNP 19613 2682 17 ; ; : 19613 2682 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2682 19 neither neither CC 19613 2682 20 transformed transform VBD 19613 2682 21 the the DT 19613 2682 22 gifts gift NNS 19613 2682 23 of of IN 19613 2682 24 salvation salvation NN 19613 2682 25 into into IN 19613 2682 26 means mean NNS 19613 2682 27 of of IN 19613 2682 28 education education NN 19613 2682 29 , , , 19613 2682 30 nor nor CC 19613 2682 31 confused confuse VBD 19613 2682 32 the the DT 19613 2682 33 reality reality NN 19613 2682 34 with with IN 19613 2682 35 the the DT 19613 2682 36 possibility possibility NN 19613 2682 37 of of IN 19613 2682 38 redemption redemption NN 19613 2682 39 ; ; : 19613 2682 40 and and CC 19613 2682 41 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2682 42 did do VBD 19613 2682 43 not not RB 19613 2682 44 completely completely RB 19613 2682 45 lower lower VB 19613 2682 46 the the DT 19613 2682 47 requirements requirement NNS 19613 2682 48 for for IN 19613 2682 49 a a DT 19613 2682 50 holy holy JJ 19613 2682 51 life life NN 19613 2682 52 . . . 19613 2683 1 But but CC 19613 2683 2 on on IN 19613 2683 3 the the DT 19613 2683 4 other other JJ 19613 2683 5 hand hand NN 19613 2683 6 , , , 19613 2683 7 in in IN 19613 2683 8 view view NN 19613 2683 9 of of IN 19613 2683 10 the the DT 19613 2683 11 minimum minimum NN 19613 2683 12 insisted insist VBN 19613 2683 13 upon upon IN 19613 2683 14 , , , 19613 2683 15 the the DT 19613 2683 16 claim claim NN 19613 2683 17 _ _ NNP 19613 2683 18 that that IN 19613 2683 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2683 20 were be VBD 19613 2683 21 the the DT 19613 2683 22 really really RB 19613 2683 23 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 2683 24 party party NN 19613 2683 25 and and CC 19613 2683 26 that that IN 19613 2683 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2683 28 fulfilled fulfil VBD 19613 2683 29 the the DT 19613 2683 30 law law NN 19613 2683 31 of of IN 19613 2683 32 Christ_[248 Christ_[248 NNP 19613 2683 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2683 34 was be VBD 19613 2683 35 a a DT 19613 2683 36 presumption presumption NN 19613 2683 37 . . . 19613 2684 1 The the DT 19613 2684 2 one one CD 19613 2684 3 step step NN 19613 2684 4 taken take VBN 19613 2684 5 to to TO 19613 2684 6 avert avert VB 19613 2684 7 the the DT 19613 2684 8 secularising secularising NN 19613 2684 9 of of IN 19613 2684 10 the the DT 19613 2684 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2684 12 , , , 19613 2684 13 exclusion exclusion NN 19613 2684 14 of of IN 19613 2684 15 the the DT 19613 2684 16 lapsed lapse VBN 19613 2684 17 , , , 19613 2684 18 was be VBD 19613 2684 19 certainly certainly RB 19613 2684 20 , , , 19613 2684 21 considering consider VBG 19613 2684 22 the the DT 19613 2684 23 actual actual JJ 19613 2684 24 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2684 25 immediately immediately RB 19613 2684 26 following follow VBG 19613 2684 27 a a DT 19613 2684 28 great great JJ 19613 2684 29 apostasy apostasy NN 19613 2684 30 , , , 19613 2684 31 a a DT 19613 2684 32 measure measure NN 19613 2684 33 of of IN 19613 2684 34 radical radical JJ 19613 2684 35 importance importance NN 19613 2684 36 ; ; : 19613 2684 37 but but CC 19613 2684 38 , , , 19613 2684 39 estimated estimate VBN 19613 2684 40 by by IN 19613 2684 41 the the DT 19613 2684 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2684 43 and and CC 19613 2684 44 in in IN 19613 2684 45 fact fact NN 19613 2684 46 simply simply RB 19613 2684 47 by by IN 19613 2684 48 the the DT 19613 2684 49 demands demand NNS 19613 2684 50 of of IN 19613 2684 51 the the DT 19613 2684 52 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2684 53 fifty fifty CD 19613 2684 54 years year NNS 19613 2684 55 before before RB 19613 2684 56 , , , 19613 2684 57 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2684 58 was be VBD 19613 2684 59 remarkably remarkably RB 19613 2684 60 insignificant insignificant JJ 19613 2684 61 . . . 19613 2685 1 These these DT 19613 2685 2 Catharists Catharists NNPS 19613 2685 3 did do VBD 19613 2685 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 2685 5 go go VB 19613 2685 6 the the DT 19613 2685 7 length length NN 19613 2685 8 of of IN 19613 2685 9 expelling expel VBG 19613 2685 10 _ _ NNP 19613 2685 11 all all DT 19613 2685 12 _ _ NNP 19613 2685 13 so so RB 19613 2685 14 - - HYPH 19613 2685 15 called call VBN 19613 2685 16 mortal mortal JJ 19613 2685 17 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2685 18 , , , 19613 2685 19 because because IN 19613 2685 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2685 21 was be VBD 19613 2685 22 too too RB 19613 2685 23 crying cry VBG 19613 2685 24 an an DT 19613 2685 25 injustice injustice NN 19613 2685 26 to to TO 19613 2685 27 treat treat VB 19613 2685 28 _ _ NNP 19613 2685 29 libellatici libellatici JJ 19613 2685 30 _ _ NNP 19613 2685 31 more more RBR 19613 2685 32 severely severely RB 19613 2685 33 than than IN 19613 2685 34 unabashed unabashed JJ 19613 2685 35 transgressors;[249 transgressors;[249 CD 19613 2685 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2685 37 but but CC 19613 2685 38 , , , 19613 2685 39 even even RB 19613 2685 40 then then RB 19613 2685 41 , , , 19613 2685 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2685 43 was be VBD 19613 2685 44 still still RB 19613 2685 45 a a DT 19613 2685 46 gross gross JJ 19613 2685 47 self self NN 19613 2685 48 - - HYPH 19613 2685 49 deception deception NN 19613 2685 50 to to TO 19613 2685 51 style style VB 19613 2685 52 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2685 53 the the DT 19613 2685 54 " " `` 19613 2685 55 pure pure JJ 19613 2685 56 ones one NNS 19613 2685 57 , , , 19613 2685 58 " " '' 19613 2685 59 since since IN 19613 2685 60 the the DT 19613 2685 61 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2685 62 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2685 63 speedily speedily RB 19613 2685 64 ceased cease VBD 19613 2685 65 to to TO 19613 2685 66 be be VB 19613 2685 67 any any DT 19613 2685 68 stricter strict JJR 19613 2685 69 than than IN 19613 2685 70 the the DT 19613 2685 71 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2685 72 in in IN 19613 2685 73 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2685 74 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 2685 75 of of IN 19613 2685 76 the the DT 19613 2685 77 world world NN 19613 2685 78 . . . 19613 2686 1 At at IN 19613 2686 2 least least JJS 19613 2686 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2686 4 do do VBP 19613 2686 5 not not RB 19613 2686 6 hear hear VB 19613 2686 7 that that DT 19613 2686 8 asceticism asceticism NN 19613 2686 9 and and CC 19613 2686 10 devotion devotion NN 19613 2686 11 to to IN 19613 2686 12 religious religious JJ 19613 2686 13 faith faith NN 19613 2686 14 were be VBD 19613 2686 15 very very RB 19613 2686 16 much much RB 19613 2686 17 more more RBR 19613 2686 18 prominent prominent JJ 19613 2686 19 in in IN 19613 2686 20 the the DT 19613 2686 21 Catharist Catharist NNP 19613 2686 22 Church Church NNP 19613 2686 23 than than IN 19613 2686 24 in in IN 19613 2686 25 the the DT 19613 2686 26 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2686 27 . . . 19613 2687 1 On on IN 19613 2687 2 the the DT 19613 2687 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 2687 4 , , , 19613 2687 5 judging judge VBG 19613 2687 6 from from IN 19613 2687 7 the the DT 19613 2687 8 sources source NNS 19613 2687 9 that that WDT 19613 2687 10 have have VBP 19613 2687 11 come come VBN 19613 2687 12 down down RP 19613 2687 13 to to IN 19613 2687 14 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2687 15 , , , 19613 2687 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2687 17 may may MD 19613 2687 18 confidently confidently RB 19613 2687 19 say say VB 19613 2687 20 that that IN 19613 2687 21 the the DT 19613 2687 22 picture picture NN 19613 2687 23 presented present VBN 19613 2687 24 by by IN 19613 2687 25 the the DT 19613 2687 26 two two CD 19613 2687 27 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2687 28 in in IN 19613 2687 29 the the DT 19613 2687 30 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 2687 31 period period NN 19613 2687 32 was be VBD 19613 2687 33 practically practically RB 19613 2687 34 identical identical JJ 19613 2687 35 . . . 19613 2688 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2688 2 250 250 CD 19613 2688 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2688 4 As as IN 19613 2688 5 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 2688 6 's 's POS 19613 2688 7 adherents adherent NNS 19613 2688 8 did do VBD 19613 2688 9 not not RB 19613 2688 10 differ differ VB 19613 2688 11 from from IN 19613 2688 12 the the DT 19613 2688 13 opposite opposite JJ 19613 2688 14 party party NN 19613 2688 15 in in IN 19613 2688 16 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2688 17 and and CC 19613 2688 18 constitution constitution NN 19613 2688 19 , , , 19613 2688 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2688 21 discipline discipline NN 19613 2688 22 of of IN 19613 2688 23 penance penance NN 19613 2688 24 appears appear VBZ 19613 2688 25 an an DT 19613 2688 26 archaic archaic JJ 19613 2688 27 fragment fragment NN 19613 2688 28 which which WDT 19613 2688 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2688 30 was be VBD 19613 2688 31 a a DT 19613 2688 32 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 2688 33 advantage advantage NN 19613 2688 34 to to TO 19613 2688 35 preserve preserve VB 19613 2688 36 ; ; : 19613 2688 37 and and CC 19613 2688 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2688 39 rejection rejection NN 19613 2688 40 of of IN 19613 2688 41 the the DT 19613 2688 42 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2688 43 dispensations dispensation NNS 19613 2688 44 of of IN 19613 2688 45 grace grace NN 19613 2688 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2688 47 practice practice NN 19613 2688 48 of of IN 19613 2688 49 rebaptism rebaptism NN 19613 2688 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2688 51 a a DT 19613 2688 52 revolutionary revolutionary JJ 19613 2688 53 measure measure NN 19613 2688 54 , , , 19613 2688 55 because because IN 19613 2688 56 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2688 57 had have VBD 19613 2688 58 insufficient insufficient JJ 19613 2688 59 justification justification NN 19613 2688 60 . . . 19613 2689 1 But but CC 19613 2689 2 the the DT 19613 2689 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 2689 4 between between IN 19613 2689 5 venial venial NN 19613 2689 6 and and CC 19613 2689 7 mortal mortal JJ 19613 2689 8 sins sin NNS 19613 2689 9 , , , 19613 2689 10 a a DT 19613 2689 11 theory theory NN 19613 2689 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2689 13 held hold VBD 19613 2689 14 in in IN 19613 2689 15 common common NN 19613 2689 16 with with IN 19613 2689 17 the the DT 19613 2689 18 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2689 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2689 20 , , , 19613 2689 21 could could MD 19613 2689 22 not not RB 19613 2689 23 but but RB 19613 2689 24 prove prove VB 19613 2689 25 especially especially RB 19613 2689 26 fatal fatal JJ 19613 2689 27 to to IN 19613 2689 28 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2689 29 ; ; : 19613 2689 30 whereas whereas IN 19613 2689 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2689 32 opponents opponent NNS 19613 2689 33 , , , 19613 2689 34 through through IN 19613 2689 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2689 36 new new JJ 19613 2689 37 regulations regulation NNS 19613 2689 38 as as IN 19613 2689 39 to to IN 19613 2689 40 penance penance NN 19613 2689 41 , , , 19613 2689 42 softened soften VBD 19613 2689 43 this this DT 19613 2689 44 distinction distinction NN 19613 2689 45 , , , 19613 2689 46 and and CC 19613 2689 47 that that IN 19613 2689 48 not not RB 19613 2689 49 to to IN 19613 2689 50 the the DT 19613 2689 51 detriment detriment NN 19613 2689 52 of of IN 19613 2689 53 morality morality NN 19613 2689 54 . . . 19613 2690 1 For for IN 19613 2690 2 an an DT 19613 2690 3 entirely entirely RB 19613 2690 4 different different JJ 19613 2690 5 treatment treatment NN 19613 2690 6 of of IN 19613 2690 7 so so RB 19613 2690 8 - - HYPH 19613 2690 9 called call VBN 19613 2690 10 gross gross JJ 19613 2690 11 and and CC 19613 2690 12 venial venial JJ 19613 2690 13 transgressions transgression NNS 19613 2690 14 must must MD 19613 2690 15 in in IN 19613 2690 16 every every DT 19613 2690 17 case case NN 19613 2690 18 deaden deaden VB 19613 2690 19 the the DT 19613 2690 20 conscience conscience NN 19613 2690 21 towards towards IN 19613 2690 22 the the DT 19613 2690 23 latter latter JJ 19613 2690 24 . . . 19613 2691 1 5 5 CD 19613 2691 2 . . . 19613 2692 1 If if IN 19613 2692 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2692 3 glance glance VBP 19613 2692 4 at at IN 19613 2692 5 the the DT 19613 2692 6 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2692 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2692 8 and and CC 19613 2692 9 leave leave VB 19613 2692 10 the the DT 19613 2692 11 melancholy melancholy JJ 19613 2692 12 recriminations recrimination NNS 19613 2692 13 out out IN 19613 2692 14 of of IN 19613 2692 15 account account NN 19613 2692 16 , , , 19613 2692 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2692 18 can can MD 19613 2692 19 not not RB 19613 2692 20 fail fail VB 19613 2692 21 to to TO 19613 2692 22 see see VB 19613 2692 23 the the DT 19613 2692 24 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 2692 25 , , , 19613 2692 26 foresight foresight NN 19613 2692 27 , , , 19613 2692 28 and and CC 19613 2692 29 comparative comparative JJ 19613 2692 30 strictness[251 strictness[251 NN 19613 2692 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2692 32 with with IN 19613 2692 33 which which WDT 19613 2692 34 the the DT 19613 2692 35 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2692 36 carried carry VBD 19613 2692 37 out out RP 19613 2692 38 the the DT 19613 2692 39 great great JJ 19613 2692 40 revolution revolution NN 19613 2692 41 that that WDT 19613 2692 42 so so RB 19613 2692 43 depotentiated depotentiate VBD 19613 2692 44 the the DT 19613 2692 45 Church Church NNP 19613 2692 46 as as IN 19613 2692 47 to to TO 19613 2692 48 make make VB 19613 2692 49 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2692 50 capable capable JJ 19613 2692 51 of of IN 19613 2692 52 becoming become VBG 19613 2692 53 a a DT 19613 2692 54 prop prop NN 19613 2692 55 of of IN 19613 2692 56 civic civic JJ 19613 2692 57 society society NN 19613 2692 58 and and CC 19613 2692 59 of of IN 19613 2692 60 the the DT 19613 2692 61 state state NN 19613 2692 62 , , , 19613 2692 63 without without IN 19613 2692 64 forcing force VBG 19613 2692 65 any any DT 19613 2692 66 great great JJ 19613 2692 67 changes change NNS 19613 2692 68 upon upon IN 19613 2692 69 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2692 70 . . . 19613 2693 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2693 2 252 252 CD 19613 2693 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2693 4 In in IN 19613 2693 5 learning learn VBG 19613 2693 6 to to TO 19613 2693 7 look look VB 19613 2693 8 upon upon IN 19613 2693 9 the the DT 19613 2693 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2693 11 as as IN 19613 2693 12 a a DT 19613 2693 13 training training NN 19613 2693 14 school school NN 19613 2693 15 for for IN 19613 2693 16 salvation salvation NN 19613 2693 17 , , , 19613 2693 18 provided provide VBN 19613 2693 19 with with IN 19613 2693 20 penalties penalty NNS 19613 2693 21 and and CC 19613 2693 22 gifts gift NNS 19613 2693 23 of of IN 19613 2693 24 grace grace NN 19613 2693 25 , , , 19613 2693 26 and and CC 19613 2693 27 in in IN 19613 2693 28 giving give VBG 19613 2693 29 up up RP 19613 2693 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2693 31 religious religious JJ 19613 2693 32 independence independence NN 19613 2693 33 in in IN 19613 2693 34 deference deference NN 19613 2693 35 to to IN 19613 2693 36 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2693 37 authority authority NN 19613 2693 38 , , , 19613 2693 39 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2693 40 as as IN 19613 2693 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2693 42 existed exist VBD 19613 2693 43 in in IN 19613 2693 44 the the DT 19613 2693 45 latter latter JJ 19613 2693 46 half half NN 19613 2693 47 of of IN 19613 2693 48 the the DT 19613 2693 49 third third JJ 19613 2693 50 century,[253 century,[253 NN 19613 2693 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2693 52 submitted submit VBN 19613 2693 53 to to IN 19613 2693 54 an an DT 19613 2693 55 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 2693 56 that that WDT 19613 2693 57 was be VBD 19613 2693 58 really really RB 19613 2693 59 best well RBS 19613 2693 60 adapted adapt VBN 19613 2693 61 to to IN 19613 2693 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2693 63 own own JJ 19613 2693 64 interests interest NNS 19613 2693 65 . . . 19613 2694 1 In in IN 19613 2694 2 the the DT 19613 2694 3 great great JJ 19613 2694 4 Church church NN 19613 2694 5 every every DT 19613 2694 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 2694 7 between between IN 19613 2694 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2694 9 political political JJ 19613 2694 10 and and CC 19613 2694 11 religious religious JJ 19613 2694 12 conditions condition NNS 19613 2694 13 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 2694 14 led lead VBN 19613 2694 15 to to IN 19613 2694 16 fatal fatal JJ 19613 2694 17 disintegrations disintegration NNS 19613 2694 18 , , , 19613 2694 19 to to IN 19613 2694 20 laxities laxity NNS 19613 2694 21 , , , 19613 2694 22 such such JJ 19613 2694 23 as as IN 19613 2694 24 arose arise VBD 19613 2694 25 in in IN 19613 2694 26 Carthage carthage NN 19613 2694 27 owing owing NN 19613 2694 28 to to IN 19613 2694 29 the the DT 19613 2694 30 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 2694 31 behaviour behaviour NN 19613 2694 32 of of IN 19613 2694 33 the the DT 19613 2694 34 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2694 35 ; ; : 19613 2694 36 or or CC 19613 2694 37 to to IN 19613 2694 38 the the DT 19613 2694 39 breaking breaking NN 19613 2694 40 up up RP 19613 2694 41 of of IN 19613 2694 42 communities community NNS 19613 2694 43 . . . 19613 2695 1 The the DT 19613 2695 2 last last JJ 19613 2695 3 was be VBD 19613 2695 4 a a DT 19613 2695 5 danger danger NN 19613 2695 6 incurred incur VBN 19613 2695 7 in in IN 19613 2695 8 all all DT 19613 2695 9 cases case NNS 19613 2695 10 where where WRB 19613 2695 11 the the DT 19613 2695 12 attempt attempt NN 19613 2695 13 was be VBD 19613 2695 14 made make VBN 19613 2695 15 to to TO 19613 2695 16 exercise exercise VB 19613 2695 17 unsparing unsparing JJ 19613 2695 18 severity severity NN 19613 2695 19 . . . 19613 2696 1 A a DT 19613 2696 2 casuistic casuistic JJ 19613 2696 3 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 2696 4 was be VBD 19613 2696 5 necessary necessary JJ 19613 2696 6 as as RB 19613 2696 7 well well RB 19613 2696 8 as as IN 19613 2696 9 a a DT 19613 2696 10 firm firm JJ 19613 2696 11 union union NN 19613 2696 12 of of IN 19613 2696 13 the the DT 19613 2696 14 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2696 15 as as IN 19613 2696 16 pillars pillar NNS 19613 2696 17 of of IN 19613 2696 18 the the DT 19613 2696 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2696 20 . . . 19613 2697 1 Not not RB 19613 2697 2 the the DT 19613 2697 3 least least RBS 19613 2697 4 important important JJ 19613 2697 5 result result NN 19613 2697 6 of of IN 19613 2697 7 the the DT 19613 2697 8 crises crisis NNS 19613 2697 9 produced produce VBN 19613 2697 10 by by IN 19613 2697 11 the the DT 19613 2697 12 great great JJ 19613 2697 13 persecutions persecution NNS 19613 2697 14 was be VBD 19613 2697 15 the the DT 19613 2697 16 fact fact NN 19613 2697 17 that that IN 19613 2697 18 the the DT 19613 2697 19 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2697 20 in in IN 19613 2697 21 West West NNP 19613 2697 22 and and CC 19613 2697 23 East East NNP 19613 2697 24 were be VBD 19613 2697 25 thereby thereby RB 19613 2697 26 forced force VBN 19613 2697 27 into into IN 19613 2697 28 closer close JJR 19613 2697 29 connection connection NN 19613 2697 30 and and CC 19613 2697 31 at at IN 19613 2697 32 the the DT 19613 2697 33 same same JJ 19613 2697 34 time time NN 19613 2697 35 acquired acquire VBD 19613 2697 36 full full JJ 19613 2697 37 jurisdiction jurisdiction NN 19613 2697 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2697 39 " " `` 19613 2697 40 per per IN 19613 2697 41 episcopos episcopos NNP 19613 2697 42 solos solos NNP 19613 2697 43 peccata peccata NNP 19613 2697 44 posse posse NNP 19613 2697 45 dimitti dimitti NNP 19613 2697 46 " " '' 19613 2697 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2697 48 . . . 19613 2698 1 If if IN 19613 2698 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2698 3 consider consider VBP 19613 2698 4 that that IN 19613 2698 5 the the DT 19613 2698 6 archiepiscopal archiepiscopal NNP 19613 2698 7 constitution constitution NNP 19613 2698 8 had have VBD 19613 2698 9 not not RB 19613 2698 10 only only RB 19613 2698 11 been be VBN 19613 2698 12 simultaneously simultaneously RB 19613 2698 13 adopted adopt VBN 19613 2698 14 , , , 19613 2698 15 but but CC 19613 2698 16 had have VBD 19613 2698 17 also also RB 19613 2698 18 attained attain VBN 19613 2698 19 the the DT 19613 2698 20 chief chief JJ 19613 2698 21 significance significance NN 19613 2698 22 in in IN 19613 2698 23 the the DT 19613 2698 24 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2698 25 organisation,[254 organisation,[254 NNP 19613 2698 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2698 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2698 28 may may MD 19613 2698 29 say say VB 19613 2698 30 that that IN 19613 2698 31 the the DT 19613 2698 32 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2698 33 Church Church NNP 19613 2698 34 was be VBD 19613 2698 35 completed complete VBN 19613 2698 36 the the DT 19613 2698 37 moment moment NN 19613 2698 38 that that WDT 19613 2698 39 Diocletian Diocletian NNP 19613 2698 40 undertook undertake VBD 19613 2698 41 the the DT 19613 2698 42 great great JJ 19613 2698 43 reorganisation reorganisation NN 19613 2698 44 of of IN 19613 2698 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2698 46 dominions dominion NNS 19613 2698 47 . . . 19613 2699 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2699 2 255 255 CD 19613 2699 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2699 4 No no RB 19613 2699 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 2699 6 the the DT 19613 2699 7 old old JJ 19613 2699 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2699 9 had have VBD 19613 2699 10 found find VBN 19613 2699 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2699 12 place place NN 19613 2699 13 in in IN 19613 2699 14 the the DT 19613 2699 15 new new JJ 19613 2699 16 Church Church NNP 19613 2699 17 , , , 19613 2699 18 but but CC 19613 2699 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2699 20 was be VBD 19613 2699 21 covered cover VBN 19613 2699 22 over over RB 19613 2699 23 and and CC 19613 2699 24 concealed conceal VBD 19613 2699 25 . . . 19613 2700 1 In in IN 19613 2700 2 spite spite NN 19613 2700 3 of of IN 19613 2700 4 all all PDT 19613 2700 5 that that DT 19613 2700 6 , , , 19613 2700 7 little little JJ 19613 2700 8 alteration alteration NN 19613 2700 9 had have VBD 19613 2700 10 been be VBN 19613 2700 11 made make VBN 19613 2700 12 in in IN 19613 2700 13 the the DT 19613 2700 14 expression expression NN 19613 2700 15 of of IN 19613 2700 16 faith faith NN 19613 2700 17 , , , 19613 2700 18 in in IN 19613 2700 19 religious religious JJ 19613 2700 20 language language NN 19613 2700 21 ; ; : 19613 2700 22 people people NNS 19613 2700 23 spoke speak VBD 19613 2700 24 of of IN 19613 2700 25 the the DT 19613 2700 26 universal universal JJ 19613 2700 27 holy holy NNP 19613 2700 28 Church Church NNP 19613 2700 29 , , , 19613 2700 30 just just RB 19613 2700 31 as as IN 19613 2700 32 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2700 33 did do VBD 19613 2700 34 a a DT 19613 2700 35 hundred hundred CD 19613 2700 36 years year NNS 19613 2700 37 before before RB 19613 2700 38 . . . 19613 2701 1 Here here RB 19613 2701 2 the the DT 19613 2701 3 development development NN 19613 2701 4 in in IN 19613 2701 5 the the DT 19613 2701 6 history history NN 19613 2701 7 of of IN 19613 2701 8 dogma dogma NN 19613 2701 9 was be VBD 19613 2701 10 in in IN 19613 2701 11 a a DT 19613 2701 12 very very RB 19613 2701 13 special special JJ 19613 2701 14 sense sense NN 19613 2701 15 a a DT 19613 2701 16 development development NN 19613 2701 17 in in IN 19613 2701 18 the the DT 19613 2701 19 history history NN 19613 2701 20 of of IN 19613 2701 21 the the DT 19613 2701 22 Church Church NNP 19613 2701 23 . . . 19613 2702 1 Catholicism catholicism NN 19613 2702 2 was be VBD 19613 2702 3 now now RB 19613 2702 4 complete complete JJ 19613 2702 5 ; ; : 19613 2702 6 the the DT 19613 2702 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2702 8 had have VBD 19613 2702 9 suppressed suppress VBN 19613 2702 10 all all DT 19613 2702 11 utterances utterance NNS 19613 2702 12 of of IN 19613 2702 13 individual individual JJ 19613 2702 14 piety piety NN 19613 2702 15 , , , 19613 2702 16 in in IN 19613 2702 17 the the DT 19613 2702 18 sense sense NN 19613 2702 19 of of IN 19613 2702 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2702 21 being be VBG 19613 2702 22 binding bind VBG 19613 2702 23 on on IN 19613 2702 24 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2702 25 , , , 19613 2702 26 and and CC 19613 2702 27 freed free VBD 19613 2702 28 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 2702 29 from from IN 19613 2702 30 every every DT 19613 2702 31 feature feature NN 19613 2702 32 of of IN 19613 2702 33 exclusiveness exclusiveness NN 19613 2702 34 . . . 19613 2703 1 In in IN 19613 2703 2 order order NN 19613 2703 3 to to TO 19613 2703 4 be be VB 19613 2703 5 a a DT 19613 2703 6 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2703 7 a a DT 19613 2703 8 man man NN 19613 2703 9 no no RB 19613 2703 10 longer long RBR 19613 2703 11 required require VBN 19613 2703 12 in in IN 19613 2703 13 any any DT 19613 2703 14 sense sense NN 19613 2703 15 to to TO 19613 2703 16 be be VB 19613 2703 17 a a DT 19613 2703 18 saint saint NN 19613 2703 19 . . . 19613 2704 1 " " `` 19613 2704 2 What what WP 19613 2704 3 made make VBD 19613 2704 4 the the DT 19613 2704 5 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2704 6 a a DT 19613 2704 7 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2704 8 was be VBD 19613 2704 9 no no RB 19613 2704 10 longer long RBR 19613 2704 11 the the DT 19613 2704 12 possession possession NN 19613 2704 13 of of IN 19613 2704 14 charisms charism NNS 19613 2704 15 , , , 19613 2704 16 but but CC 19613 2704 17 obedience obedience NN 19613 2704 18 to to IN 19613 2704 19 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2704 20 authority authority NN 19613 2704 21 , , , 19613 2704 22 " " `` 19613 2704 23 share share VB 19613 2704 24 in in IN 19613 2704 25 the the DT 19613 2704 26 gifts gift NNS 19613 2704 27 of of IN 19613 2704 28 the the DT 19613 2704 29 Church Church NNP 19613 2704 30 , , , 19613 2704 31 and and CC 19613 2704 32 the the DT 19613 2704 33 performance performance NN 19613 2704 34 of of IN 19613 2704 35 penance penance NN 19613 2704 36 and and CC 19613 2704 37 good good JJ 19613 2704 38 works work NNS 19613 2704 39 . . . 19613 2705 1 The the DT 19613 2705 2 Church Church NNP 19613 2705 3 by by IN 19613 2705 4 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2705 5 edicts edict NNS 19613 2705 6 legitimised legitimise VBD 19613 2705 7 average average JJ 19613 2705 8 morality morality NN 19613 2705 9 , , , 19613 2705 10 after after IN 19613 2705 11 average average JJ 19613 2705 12 morality morality NN 19613 2705 13 had have VBD 19613 2705 14 created create VBN 19613 2705 15 the the DT 19613 2705 16 authority authority NN 19613 2705 17 of of IN 19613 2705 18 the the DT 19613 2705 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2705 20 . . . 19613 2706 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2706 2 " " `` 19613 2706 3 La La NNP 19613 2706 4 médiocrité médiocrité NNP 19613 2706 5 fonda fonda NNP 19613 2706 6 l'autorité l'autorité NNP 19613 2706 7 " " '' 19613 2706 8 . . . 19613 2706 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2707 1 The the DT 19613 2707 2 dispensations dispensation NNS 19613 2707 3 of of IN 19613 2707 4 grace grace NN 19613 2707 5 , , , 19613 2707 6 that that RB 19613 2707 7 is is RB 19613 2707 8 , , , 19613 2707 9 absolution absolution NN 19613 2707 10 and and CC 19613 2707 11 the the DT 19613 2707 12 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2707 13 's 's POS 19613 2707 14 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2707 15 , , , 19613 2707 16 abolished abolish VBD 19613 2707 17 the the DT 19613 2707 18 charismatic charismatic JJ 19613 2707 19 gifts gift NNS 19613 2707 20 . . . 19613 2708 1 The the DT 19613 2708 2 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2708 3 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 2708 4 , , , 19613 2708 5 the the DT 19613 2708 6 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2708 7 episcopate episcopate NNP 19613 2708 8 , , , 19613 2708 9 the the DT 19613 2708 10 priests priest NNS 19613 2708 11 , , , 19613 2708 12 the the DT 19613 2708 13 sacraments sacrament NNS 19613 2708 14 , , , 19613 2708 15 average average JJ 19613 2708 16 morality morality NN 19613 2708 17 in in IN 19613 2708 18 accordance accordance NN 19613 2708 19 with with IN 19613 2708 20 which which WDT 19613 2708 21 the the DT 19613 2708 22 whole whole JJ 19613 2708 23 world world NN 19613 2708 24 could could MD 19613 2708 25 live live VB 19613 2708 26 , , , 19613 2708 27 were be VBD 19613 2708 28 mutually mutually RB 19613 2708 29 conditioned condition VBN 19613 2708 30 . . . 19613 2709 1 The the DT 19613 2709 2 consoling consoling JJ 19613 2709 3 words word NNS 19613 2709 4 : : : 19613 2709 5 " " `` 19613 2709 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 2709 7 receives receive VBZ 19613 2709 8 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2709 9 , , , 19613 2709 10 " " `` 19613 2709 11 were be VBD 19613 2709 12 subjected subject VBN 19613 2709 13 to to IN 19613 2709 14 an an DT 19613 2709 15 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 2709 16 that that WDT 19613 2709 17 threatened threaten VBD 19613 2709 18 to to TO 19613 2709 19 make make VB 19613 2709 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2709 21 detrimental detrimental JJ 19613 2709 22 to to IN 19613 2709 23 morality morality NN 19613 2709 24 . . . 19613 2710 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2710 2 256 256 CD 19613 2710 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2710 4 And and CC 19613 2710 5 with with IN 19613 2710 6 all all DT 19613 2710 7 that that WDT 19613 2710 8 the the DT 19613 2710 9 self self NN 19613 2710 10 - - HYPH 19613 2710 11 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 2710 12 of of IN 19613 2710 13 proud proud JJ 19613 2710 14 ascetics ascetic NNS 19613 2710 15 was be VBD 19613 2710 16 not not RB 19613 2710 17 excluded exclude VBN 19613 2710 18 -- -- : 19613 2710 19 quite quite PDT 19613 2710 20 the the DT 19613 2710 21 contrary contrary NN 19613 2710 22 . . . 19613 2711 1 Alongside alongside IN 19613 2711 2 of of IN 19613 2711 3 a a DT 19613 2711 4 code code NN 19613 2711 5 of of IN 19613 2711 6 morals moral NNS 19613 2711 7 , , , 19613 2711 8 to to TO 19613 2711 9 which which WDT 19613 2711 10 any any DT 19613 2711 11 one one CD 19613 2711 12 in in IN 19613 2711 13 case case NN 19613 2711 14 of of IN 19613 2711 15 need need NN 19613 2711 16 could could MD 19613 2711 17 adapt adapt VB 19613 2711 18 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2711 19 , , , 19613 2711 20 the the DT 19613 2711 21 Church Church NNP 19613 2711 22 began begin VBD 19613 2711 23 to to TO 19613 2711 24 legitimise legitimise VB 19613 2711 25 a a DT 19613 2711 26 morality morality NN 19613 2711 27 of of IN 19613 2711 28 self self NN 19613 2711 29 - - HYPH 19613 2711 30 chosen choose VBN 19613 2711 31 , , , 19613 2711 32 refined refined JJ 19613 2711 33 sanctity sanctity NN 19613 2711 34 , , , 19613 2711 35 which which WDT 19613 2711 36 really really RB 19613 2711 37 required require VBD 19613 2711 38 no no DT 19613 2711 39 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 2711 40 . . . 19613 2712 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2712 2 was be VBD 19613 2712 3 as as IN 19613 2712 4 in in IN 19613 2712 5 possession possession NN 19613 2712 6 of of IN 19613 2712 7 this this DT 19613 2712 8 constitution constitution NN 19613 2712 9 that that IN 19613 2712 10 the the DT 19613 2712 11 great great JJ 19613 2712 12 statesman statesman NN 19613 2712 13 found find VBD 19613 2712 14 and and CC 19613 2712 15 admired admire VBD 19613 2712 16 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2712 17 , , , 19613 2712 18 and and CC 19613 2712 19 recognised recognise VBD 19613 2712 20 in in IN 19613 2712 21 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2712 22 the the DT 19613 2712 23 strongest strong JJS 19613 2712 24 support support NN 19613 2712 25 of of IN 19613 2712 26 the the DT 19613 2712 27 Empire empire NN 19613 2712 28 . . . 19613 2713 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2713 2 257 257 CD 19613 2713 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2713 4 A a DT 19613 2713 5 comparison comparison NN 19613 2713 6 of of IN 19613 2713 7 the the DT 19613 2713 8 aims aim NNS 19613 2713 9 of of IN 19613 2713 10 primitive primitive JJ 19613 2713 11 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2713 12 with with IN 19613 2713 13 those those DT 19613 2713 14 of of IN 19613 2713 15 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2713 16 society society NN 19613 2713 17 at at IN 19613 2713 18 the the DT 19613 2713 19 end end NN 19613 2713 20 of of IN 19613 2713 21 the the DT 19613 2713 22 third third JJ 19613 2713 23 century century NN 19613 2713 24 -- -- : 19613 2713 25 a a DT 19613 2713 26 comparison comparison NN 19613 2713 27 of of IN 19613 2713 28 the the DT 19613 2713 29 actual actual JJ 19613 2713 30 state state NN 19613 2713 31 of of IN 19613 2713 32 things thing NNS 19613 2713 33 at at IN 19613 2713 34 the the DT 19613 2713 35 different different JJ 19613 2713 36 periods period NNS 19613 2713 37 is be VBZ 19613 2713 38 hardly hardly RB 19613 2713 39 possible possible JJ 19613 2713 40 -- -- : 19613 2713 41 will will MD 19613 2713 42 always always RB 19613 2713 43 lead lead VB 19613 2713 44 to to IN 19613 2713 45 a a DT 19613 2713 46 disheartening disheartening JJ 19613 2713 47 result result NN 19613 2713 48 ; ; : 19613 2713 49 but but CC 19613 2713 50 the the DT 19613 2713 51 parallel parallel NN 19613 2713 52 is be VBZ 19613 2713 53 in in IN 19613 2713 54 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2713 55 unjust unjust JJ 19613 2713 56 . . . 19613 2714 1 The the DT 19613 2714 2 truth truth NN 19613 2714 3 rather rather RB 19613 2714 4 is be VBZ 19613 2714 5 that that IN 19613 2714 6 the the DT 19613 2714 7 correct correct JJ 19613 2714 8 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 2714 9 from from IN 19613 2714 10 which which WDT 19613 2714 11 to to TO 19613 2714 12 judge judge VB 19613 2714 13 the the DT 19613 2714 14 matter matter NN 19613 2714 15 was be VBD 19613 2714 16 already already RB 19613 2714 17 indicated indicate VBN 19613 2714 18 by by IN 19613 2714 19 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2714 20 in in IN 19613 2714 21 the the DT 19613 2714 22 comparison comparison NN 19613 2714 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2714 24 drew draw VBD 19613 2714 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2714 26 c. c. NNP 19613 2714 27 Cels Cels NNP 19613 2714 28 . . . 19613 2715 1 III iii CD 19613 2715 2 . . . 19613 2716 1 29 29 CD 19613 2716 2 . . . 19613 2717 1 30 30 CD 19613 2717 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2717 3 between between IN 19613 2717 4 the the DT 19613 2717 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 2717 6 society society NN 19613 2717 7 of of IN 19613 2717 8 the the DT 19613 2717 9 third third JJ 19613 2717 10 century century NN 19613 2717 11 and and CC 19613 2717 12 the the DT 19613 2717 13 non non JJ 19613 2717 14 - - JJ 19613 2717 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 2717 16 , , , 19613 2717 17 between between IN 19613 2717 18 the the DT 19613 2717 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2717 20 and and CC 19613 2717 21 the the DT 19613 2717 22 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2717 23 , , , 19613 2717 24 the the DT 19613 2717 25 clergy clergy NNS 19613 2717 26 and and CC 19613 2717 27 the the DT 19613 2717 28 magistrates magistrate NNS 19613 2717 29 . . . 19613 2718 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2718 2 258 258 CD 19613 2718 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2718 4 Amidst amidst IN 19613 2718 5 the the DT 19613 2718 6 general general JJ 19613 2718 7 disorganisation disorganisation NN 19613 2718 8 of of IN 19613 2718 9 all all DT 19613 2718 10 relationships relationship NNS 19613 2718 11 , , , 19613 2718 12 and and CC 19613 2718 13 from from IN 19613 2718 14 amongst amongst IN 19613 2718 15 the the DT 19613 2718 16 ruins ruin NNS 19613 2718 17 of of IN 19613 2718 18 a a DT 19613 2718 19 shattered shattered JJ 19613 2718 20 fabric fabric NN 19613 2718 21 , , , 19613 2718 22 a a DT 19613 2718 23 new new JJ 19613 2718 24 structure structure NN 19613 2718 25 , , , 19613 2718 26 founded found VBN 19613 2718 27 on on IN 19613 2718 28 the the DT 19613 2718 29 belief belief NN 19613 2718 30 in in IN 19613 2718 31 one one CD 19613 2718 32 God God NNP 19613 2718 33 , , , 19613 2718 34 in in IN 19613 2718 35 a a DT 19613 2718 36 sure sure JJ 19613 2718 37 revelation revelation NN 19613 2718 38 , , , 19613 2718 39 and and CC 19613 2718 40 in in IN 19613 2718 41 eternal eternal JJ 19613 2718 42 life life NN 19613 2718 43 , , , 19613 2718 44 was be VBD 19613 2718 45 being be VBG 19613 2718 46 laboriously laboriously RB 19613 2718 47 raised raise VBN 19613 2718 48 . . . 19613 2719 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2719 2 gathered gather VBD 19613 2719 3 within within IN 19613 2719 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2719 5 more more RBR 19613 2719 6 and and CC 19613 2719 7 more more RBR 19613 2719 8 all all PDT 19613 2719 9 the the DT 19613 2719 10 elements element NNS 19613 2719 11 still still RB 19613 2719 12 capable capable JJ 19613 2719 13 of of IN 19613 2719 14 continued continued JJ 19613 2719 15 existence existence NN 19613 2719 16 ; ; : 19613 2719 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2719 18 readmitted readmitte VBD 19613 2719 19 the the DT 19613 2719 20 old old JJ 19613 2719 21 world world NN 19613 2719 22 , , , 19613 2719 23 cleansed cleanse VBN 19613 2719 24 of of IN 19613 2719 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2719 26 grossest gross JJS 19613 2719 27 impurities impurity NNS 19613 2719 28 , , , 19613 2719 29 and and CC 19613 2719 30 raised raise VBD 19613 2719 31 holy holy JJ 19613 2719 32 barriers barrier NNS 19613 2719 33 to to TO 19613 2719 34 secure secure VB 19613 2719 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2719 36 conquests conquest NNS 19613 2719 37 against against IN 19613 2719 38 all all DT 19613 2719 39 attacks attack NNS 19613 2719 40 . . . 19613 2720 1 Within within IN 19613 2720 2 this this DT 19613 2720 3 edifice edifice JJ 19613 2720 4 justice justice NN 19613 2720 5 and and CC 19613 2720 6 civic civic JJ 19613 2720 7 virtue virtue NN 19613 2720 8 shone shine VBD 19613 2720 9 with with IN 19613 2720 10 no no DT 19613 2720 11 greater great JJR 19613 2720 12 brightness brightness NN 19613 2720 13 than than IN 19613 2720 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2720 15 did do VBD 19613 2720 16 upon upon IN 19613 2720 17 the the DT 19613 2720 18 earth earth NN 19613 2720 19 generally generally RB 19613 2720 20 , , , 19613 2720 21 but but CC 19613 2720 22 within within IN 19613 2720 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2720 24 burned burn VBD 19613 2720 25 two two CD 19613 2720 26 mighty mighty JJ 19613 2720 27 flames flame NNS 19613 2720 28 -- -- : 19613 2720 29 the the DT 19613 2720 30 assurance assurance NN 19613 2720 31 of of IN 19613 2720 32 eternal eternal JJ 19613 2720 33 life life NN 19613 2720 34 , , , 19613 2720 35 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 2720 36 by by IN 19613 2720 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2720 38 , , , 19613 2720 39 and and CC 19613 2720 40 the the DT 19613 2720 41 practice practice NN 19613 2720 42 of of IN 19613 2720 43 mercy mercy NN 19613 2720 44 . . . 19613 2721 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2721 2 who who WP 19613 2721 3 knows know VBZ 19613 2721 4 history history NN 19613 2721 5 is be VBZ 19613 2721 6 aware aware JJ 19613 2721 7 that that IN 19613 2721 8 the the DT 19613 2721 9 influence influence NN 19613 2721 10 of of IN 19613 2721 11 epoch epoch NN 19613 2721 12 - - HYPH 19613 2721 13 making make VBG 19613 2721 14 personages personage NNS 19613 2721 15 is be VBZ 19613 2721 16 not not RB 19613 2721 17 to to TO 19613 2721 18 be be VB 19613 2721 19 sought seek VBN 19613 2721 20 in in IN 19613 2721 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2721 22 direct direct JJ 19613 2721 23 consequences consequence NNS 19613 2721 24 alone alone RB 19613 2721 25 , , , 19613 2721 26 as as IN 19613 2721 27 these these DT 19613 2721 28 speedily speedily RB 19613 2721 29 disappear disappear VBP 19613 2721 30 : : : 19613 2721 31 that that IN 19613 2721 32 structure structure NN 19613 2721 33 which which WDT 19613 2721 34 prolonged prolong VBD 19613 2721 35 the the DT 19613 2721 36 life life NN 19613 2721 37 of of IN 19613 2721 38 a a DT 19613 2721 39 dying die VBG 19613 2721 40 world world NN 19613 2721 41 , , , 19613 2721 42 and and CC 19613 2721 43 brought bring VBD 19613 2721 44 strength strength NN 19613 2721 45 from from IN 19613 2721 46 the the DT 19613 2721 47 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2721 48 One One NNP 19613 2721 49 to to IN 19613 2721 50 another another DT 19613 2721 51 struggling struggle VBG 19613 2721 52 into into IN 19613 2721 53 existence existence NN 19613 2721 54 , , , 19613 2721 55 was be VBD 19613 2721 56 also also RB 19613 2721 57 partly partly RB 19613 2721 58 founded found VBN 19613 2721 59 on on IN 19613 2721 60 the the DT 19613 2721 61 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2721 62 , , , 19613 2721 63 and and CC 19613 2721 64 but but CC 19613 2721 65 for for IN 19613 2721 66 this this DT 19613 2721 67 would would MD 19613 2721 68 neither neither CC 19613 2721 69 have have VB 19613 2721 70 arisen arise VBN 19613 2721 71 nor nor CC 19613 2721 72 attained attain VBN 19613 2721 73 solidity solidity NN 19613 2721 74 . . . 19613 2722 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2722 2 , , , 19613 2722 3 a a DT 19613 2722 4 Church Church NNP 19613 2722 5 had have VBD 19613 2722 6 been be VBN 19613 2722 7 created create VBN 19613 2722 8 within within IN 19613 2722 9 which which WDT 19613 2722 10 the the DT 19613 2722 11 pious pious JJ 19613 2722 12 layman layman NN 19613 2722 13 could could MD 19613 2722 14 find find VB 19613 2722 15 a a DT 19613 2722 16 holy holy JJ 19613 2722 17 place place NN 19613 2722 18 of of IN 19613 2722 19 peace peace NN 19613 2722 20 and and CC 19613 2722 21 edification edification NN 19613 2722 22 . . . 19613 2723 1 With with IN 19613 2723 2 priestly priestly JJ 19613 2723 3 strife strife NN 19613 2723 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2723 5 had have VBD 19613 2723 6 nothing nothing NN 19613 2723 7 to to TO 19613 2723 8 do do VB 19613 2723 9 , , , 19613 2723 10 nor nor CC 19613 2723 11 had have VBD 19613 2723 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2723 13 any any DT 19613 2723 14 concern concern NN 19613 2723 15 in in IN 19613 2723 16 the the DT 19613 2723 17 profound profound JJ 19613 2723 18 and and CC 19613 2723 19 subtle subtle JJ 19613 2723 20 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 2723 21 system system NN 19613 2723 22 whose whose WP$ 19613 2723 23 foundation foundation NN 19613 2723 24 was be VBD 19613 2723 25 now now RB 19613 2723 26 being be VBG 19613 2723 27 laid lay VBN 19613 2723 28 . . . 19613 2724 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2724 2 may may MD 19613 2724 3 say say VB 19613 2724 4 that that IN 19613 2724 5 the the DT 19613 2724 6 religion religion NN 19613 2724 7 of of IN 19613 2724 8 the the DT 19613 2724 9 laity laity NN 19613 2724 10 attained attain VBD 19613 2724 11 freedom freedom NN 19613 2724 12 in in IN 19613 2724 13 proportion proportion NN 19613 2724 14 as as IN 19613 2724 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2724 16 became become VBD 19613 2724 17 impossible impossible JJ 19613 2724 18 for for IN 19613 2724 19 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2724 20 to to TO 19613 2724 21 take take VB 19613 2724 22 part part NN 19613 2724 23 in in IN 19613 2724 24 the the DT 19613 2724 25 establishment establishment NN 19613 2724 26 and and CC 19613 2724 27 guardianship guardianship NN 19613 2724 28 of of IN 19613 2724 29 the the DT 19613 2724 30 official official JJ 19613 2724 31 Church Church NNP 19613 2724 32 system system NN 19613 2724 33 . . . 19613 2725 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2725 2 is be VBZ 19613 2725 3 the the DT 19613 2725 4 professional professional JJ 19613 2725 5 guardians guardian NNS 19613 2725 6 of of IN 19613 2725 7 this this DT 19613 2725 8 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2725 9 edifice edifice NN 19613 2725 10 who who WP 19613 2725 11 are be VBP 19613 2725 12 the the DT 19613 2725 13 real real JJ 19613 2725 14 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 2725 15 of of IN 19613 2725 16 religion religion NN 19613 2725 17 , , , 19613 2725 18 and and CC 19613 2725 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2725 20 is be VBZ 19613 2725 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2725 22 who who WP 19613 2725 23 have have VBP 19613 2725 24 to to TO 19613 2725 25 bear bear VB 19613 2725 26 the the DT 19613 2725 27 consequences consequence NNS 19613 2725 28 of of IN 19613 2725 29 the the DT 19613 2725 30 worldliness worldliness NN 19613 2725 31 and and CC 19613 2725 32 lack lack NN 19613 2725 33 of of IN 19613 2725 34 genuineness genuineness NN 19613 2725 35 pertaining pertain VBG 19613 2725 36 to to IN 19613 2725 37 the the DT 19613 2725 38 system system NN 19613 2725 39 . . . 19613 2726 1 But but CC 19613 2726 2 to to IN 19613 2726 3 the the DT 19613 2726 4 layman layman NN 19613 2726 5 who who WP 19613 2726 6 seeks seek VBZ 19613 2726 7 from from IN 19613 2726 8 the the DT 19613 2726 9 Church Church NNP 19613 2726 10 nothing nothing NN 19613 2726 11 more more JJR 19613 2726 12 than than IN 19613 2726 13 aid aid NN 19613 2726 14 in in IN 19613 2726 15 raising raise VBG 19613 2726 16 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2726 17 to to IN 19613 2726 18 God God NNP 19613 2726 19 , , , 19613 2726 20 this this DT 19613 2726 21 worldliness worldliness NN 19613 2726 22 and and CC 19613 2726 23 unveracity unveracity NN 19613 2726 24 do do VBP 19613 2726 25 not not RB 19613 2726 26 exist exist VB 19613 2726 27 . . . 19613 2727 1 During during IN 19613 2727 2 the the DT 19613 2727 3 Greek greek JJ 19613 2727 4 period period NN 19613 2727 5 , , , 19613 2727 6 however however RB 19613 2727 7 , , , 19613 2727 8 laymen laymen NNP 19613 2727 9 were be VBD 19613 2727 10 only only RB 19613 2727 11 able able JJ 19613 2727 12 to to TO 19613 2727 13 recognise recognise VB 19613 2727 14 this this DT 19613 2727 15 advantage advantage NN 19613 2727 16 to to IN 19613 2727 17 a a DT 19613 2727 18 limited limited JJ 19613 2727 19 extent extent NN 19613 2727 20 . . . 19613 2728 1 The the DT 19613 2728 2 Church Church NNP 19613 2728 3 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 2728 4 and and CC 19613 2728 5 the the DT 19613 2728 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2728 7 system system NN 19613 2728 8 were be VBD 19613 2728 9 still still RB 19613 2728 10 too too RB 19613 2728 11 closely closely RB 19613 2728 12 connected connected JJ 19613 2728 13 with with IN 19613 2728 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2728 15 own own JJ 19613 2728 16 interests interest NNS 19613 2728 17 . . . 19613 2729 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2729 2 was be VBD 19613 2729 3 in in IN 19613 2729 4 the the DT 19613 2729 5 Middle Middle NNP 19613 2729 6 Ages Ages NNPS 19613 2729 7 , , , 19613 2729 8 that that IN 19613 2729 9 the the DT 19613 2729 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2729 11 first first RB 19613 2729 12 became become VBD 19613 2729 13 a a DT 19613 2729 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2729 15 Mother Mother NNP 19613 2729 16 and and CC 19613 2729 17 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2729 18 house house NN 19613 2729 19 a a DT 19613 2729 20 house house NN 19613 2729 21 of of IN 19613 2729 22 prayer prayer NN 19613 2729 23 -- -- : 19613 2729 24 for for IN 19613 2729 25 the the DT 19613 2729 26 Germanic germanic JJ 19613 2729 27 peoples people NNS 19613 2729 28 ; ; : 19613 2729 29 for for IN 19613 2729 30 these these DT 19613 2729 31 races race NNS 19613 2729 32 were be VBD 19613 2729 33 really really RB 19613 2729 34 the the DT 19613 2729 35 children child NNS 19613 2729 36 of of IN 19613 2729 37 the the DT 19613 2729 38 Church Church NNP 19613 2729 39 , , , 19613 2729 40 and and CC 19613 2729 41 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2729 42 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2729 43 had have VBD 19613 2729 44 not not RB 19613 2729 45 helped help VBN 19613 2729 46 to to TO 19613 2729 47 rear rear VB 19613 2729 48 the the DT 19613 2729 49 house house NN 19613 2729 50 in in IN 19613 2729 51 which which WDT 19613 2729 52 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2729 53 worshipped worship VBD 19613 2729 54 . . . 19613 2730 1 ADDENDA ADDENDA NNP 19613 2730 2 . . . 19613 2731 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2732 1 THE the DT 19613 2732 2 PRIESTHOOD PRIESTHOOD NNP 19613 2732 3 . . . 19613 2733 1 The the DT 19613 2733 2 completion completion NN 19613 2733 3 of of IN 19613 2733 4 the the DT 19613 2733 5 old old JJ 19613 2733 6 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2733 7 conception conception NN 19613 2733 8 of of IN 19613 2733 9 the the DT 19613 2733 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2733 11 , , , 19613 2733 12 as as IN 19613 2733 13 this this DT 19613 2733 14 idea idea NN 19613 2733 15 was be VBD 19613 2733 16 developed develop VBN 19613 2733 17 in in IN 19613 2733 18 the the DT 19613 2733 19 latter latter JJ 19613 2733 20 half half NN 19613 2733 21 of of IN 19613 2733 22 the the DT 19613 2733 23 third third JJ 19613 2733 24 century century NN 19613 2733 25 , , , 19613 2733 26 is be VBZ 19613 2733 27 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 2733 28 most most RBS 19613 2733 29 clearly clearly RB 19613 2733 30 shown show VBN 19613 2733 31 in in IN 19613 2733 32 the the DT 19613 2733 33 attribute attribute NN 19613 2733 34 of of IN 19613 2733 35 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 2733 36 , , , 19613 2733 37 with with IN 19613 2733 38 which which WDT 19613 2733 39 the the DT 19613 2733 40 clergy clergy NNS 19613 2733 41 were be VBD 19613 2733 42 invested invest VBN 19613 2733 43 and and CC 19613 2733 44 which which WDT 19613 2733 45 conferred confer VBD 19613 2733 46 on on IN 19613 2733 47 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2733 48 the the DT 19613 2733 49 greatest great JJS 19613 2733 50 importance importance NN 19613 2733 51 . . . 19613 2734 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2734 2 259 259 CD 19613 2734 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2734 4 The the DT 19613 2734 5 development development NN 19613 2734 6 of of IN 19613 2734 7 this this DT 19613 2734 8 conception conception NN 19613 2734 9 , , , 19613 2734 10 whose whose WP$ 19613 2734 11 adoption adoption NN 19613 2734 12 is be VBZ 19613 2734 13 a a DT 19613 2734 14 proof proof NN 19613 2734 15 that that IN 19613 2734 16 the the DT 19613 2734 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2734 18 had have VBD 19613 2734 19 assumed assume VBN 19613 2734 20 a a DT 19613 2734 21 heathen heathen NNP 19613 2734 22 complexion complexion NN 19613 2734 23 , , , 19613 2734 24 can can MD 19613 2734 25 not not RB 19613 2734 26 be be VB 19613 2734 27 more more RBR 19613 2734 28 particularly particularly RB 19613 2734 29 treated treat VBN 19613 2734 30 of of IN 19613 2734 31 here here RB 19613 2734 32 . . . 19613 2735 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2735 2 260 260 CD 19613 2735 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2735 4 What what WP 19613 2735 5 meaning meaning NN 19613 2735 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2735 7 has have VBZ 19613 2735 8 is be VBZ 19613 2735 9 shown show VBN 19613 2735 10 by by IN 19613 2735 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2735 12 application application NN 19613 2735 13 in in IN 19613 2735 14 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2735 15 and and CC 19613 2735 16 the the DT 19613 2735 17 original original NN 19613 2735 18 of of IN 19613 2735 19 the the DT 19613 2735 20 first first JJ 19613 2735 21 six six CD 19613 2735 22 books book NNS 19613 2735 23 of of IN 19613 2735 24 the the DT 19613 2735 25 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 2735 26 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 2735 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2735 28 see see VB 19613 2735 29 Book Book NNP 19613 2735 30 II II NNP 19613 2735 31 . . . 19613 2735 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2735 33 . . . 19613 2736 1 The the DT 19613 2736 2 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2736 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2736 4 and and CC 19613 2736 5 also also RB 19613 2736 6 the the DT 19613 2736 7 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 2736 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2736 9 are be VBP 19613 2736 10 priests priest NNS 19613 2736 11 , , , 19613 2736 12 in in IN 19613 2736 13 so so RB 19613 2736 14 far far RB 19613 2736 15 as as IN 19613 2736 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2736 17 alone alone RB 19613 2736 18 are be VBP 19613 2736 19 empowered empower VBN 19613 2736 20 to to TO 19613 2736 21 present present VB 19613 2736 22 the the DT 19613 2736 23 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2736 24 as as IN 19613 2736 25 representatives representative NNS 19613 2736 26 of of IN 19613 2736 27 the the DT 19613 2736 28 congregation congregation NN 19613 2736 29 before before IN 19613 2736 30 God[261 God[261 NNS 19613 2736 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2736 32 and and CC 19613 2736 33 in in IN 19613 2736 34 so so RB 19613 2736 35 far far RB 19613 2736 36 as as IN 19613 2736 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2736 38 dispense dispense VBP 19613 2736 39 or or CC 19613 2736 40 refuse refuse VBP 19613 2736 41 the the DT 19613 2736 42 divine divine JJ 19613 2736 43 grace grace NN 19613 2736 44 as as IN 19613 2736 45 representatives representative NNS 19613 2736 46 of of IN 19613 2736 47 God God NNP 19613 2736 48 in in IN 19613 2736 49 relation relation NN 19613 2736 50 to to IN 19613 2736 51 the the DT 19613 2736 52 congregation congregation NN 19613 2736 53 . . . 19613 2737 1 In in IN 19613 2737 2 this this DT 19613 2737 3 sense sense NN 19613 2737 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2737 5 are be VBP 19613 2737 6 also also RB 19613 2737 7 judges judge NNS 19613 2737 8 in in IN 19613 2737 9 God God NNP 19613 2737 10 's 's POS 19613 2737 11 stead stead NN 19613 2737 12 . . . 19613 2738 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2738 2 262 262 CD 19613 2738 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2738 4 The the DT 19613 2738 5 position position NN 19613 2738 6 here here RB 19613 2738 7 conceded concede VBD 19613 2738 8 to to IN 19613 2738 9 the the DT 19613 2738 10 higher high JJR 19613 2738 11 clergy clergy NN 19613 2738 12 corresponds correspond VBZ 19613 2738 13 to to IN 19613 2738 14 that that DT 19613 2738 15 of of IN 19613 2738 16 the the DT 19613 2738 17 mystagogue mystagogue NNP 19613 2738 18 in in IN 19613 2738 19 heathen heathen NNP 19613 2738 20 religions religion NNS 19613 2738 21 , , , 19613 2738 22 and and CC 19613 2738 23 is be VBZ 19613 2738 24 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 2738 25 to to TO 19613 2738 26 be be VB 19613 2738 27 borrowed borrow VBN 19613 2738 28 from from IN 19613 2738 29 the the DT 19613 2738 30 latter latter JJ 19613 2738 31 . . . 19613 2739 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2739 2 263 263 CD 19613 2739 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2739 4 Divine divine JJ 19613 2739 5 grace grace NN 19613 2739 6 already already RB 19613 2739 7 appears appear VBZ 19613 2739 8 as as IN 19613 2739 9 a a DT 19613 2739 10 sacramental sacramental JJ 19613 2739 11 consecration consecration NN 19613 2739 12 of of IN 19613 2739 13 an an DT 19613 2739 14 objective objective JJ 19613 2739 15 nature nature NN 19613 2739 16 , , , 19613 2739 17 the the DT 19613 2739 18 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 2739 19 of of IN 19613 2739 20 which which WDT 19613 2739 21 is be VBZ 19613 2739 22 confined confine VBN 19613 2739 23 to to IN 19613 2739 24 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2739 25 personages personage NNS 19613 2739 26 chosen choose VBN 19613 2739 27 by by IN 19613 2739 28 God God NNP 19613 2739 29 . . . 19613 2740 1 This this DT 19613 2740 2 fact fact NN 19613 2740 3 is be VBZ 19613 2740 4 no no DT 19613 2740 5 way way NN 19613 2740 6 affected affect VBN 19613 2740 7 by by IN 19613 2740 8 the the DT 19613 2740 9 perception perception NN 19613 2740 10 that that IN 19613 2740 11 an an DT 19613 2740 12 ever ever RB 19613 2740 13 increasing increase VBG 19613 2740 14 reference reference NN 19613 2740 15 is be VBZ 19613 2740 16 made make VBN 19613 2740 17 to to IN 19613 2740 18 the the DT 19613 2740 19 Old Old NNP 19613 2740 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2740 21 priests priest NNS 19613 2740 22 as as RB 19613 2740 23 well well RB 19613 2740 24 as as IN 19613 2740 25 to to IN 19613 2740 26 the the DT 19613 2740 27 whole whole JJ 19613 2740 28 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 2740 29 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 2740 30 and and CC 19613 2740 31 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2740 32 regulations regulation NNS 19613 2740 33 . . . 19613 2741 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2741 2 264 264 CD 19613 2741 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2741 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2741 5 is be VBZ 19613 2741 6 true true JJ 19613 2741 7 that that IN 19613 2741 8 there there EX 19613 2741 9 is be VBZ 19613 2741 10 no no DT 19613 2741 11 other other JJ 19613 2741 12 respect respect NN 19613 2741 13 in in IN 19613 2741 14 which which WDT 19613 2741 15 Old Old NNP 19613 2741 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2741 17 commandments commandment NNS 19613 2741 18 were be VBD 19613 2741 19 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 2741 20 with with IN 19613 2741 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2741 22 to to IN 19613 2741 23 such such PDT 19613 2741 24 an an DT 19613 2741 25 extent extent NN 19613 2741 26 as as IN 19613 2741 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2741 28 were be VBD 19613 2741 29 in in IN 19613 2741 30 this this DT 19613 2741 31 . . . 19613 2742 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2742 2 265 265 CD 19613 2742 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2742 4 But but CC 19613 2742 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2742 6 can can MD 19613 2742 7 be be VB 19613 2742 8 proved prove VBN 19613 2742 9 that that IN 19613 2742 10 this this DT 19613 2742 11 formal formal JJ 19613 2742 12 adoption adoption NN 19613 2742 13 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 2742 14 took take VBD 19613 2742 15 place place NN 19613 2742 16 at at IN 19613 2742 17 a a DT 19613 2742 18 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 2742 19 date date NN 19613 2742 20 , , , 19613 2742 21 that that RB 19613 2742 22 is is RB 19613 2742 23 , , , 19613 2742 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2742 25 had have VBD 19613 2742 26 practically practically RB 19613 2742 27 no no DT 19613 2742 28 influence influence NN 19613 2742 29 on on IN 19613 2742 30 the the DT 19613 2742 31 development development NN 19613 2742 32 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2742 33 , , , 19613 2742 34 which which WDT 19613 2742 35 was be VBD 19613 2742 36 not not RB 19613 2742 37 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 2742 38 by by IN 19613 2742 39 the the DT 19613 2742 40 commandments commandment NNS 19613 2742 41 till till IN 19613 2742 42 a a DT 19613 2742 43 later later JJ 19613 2742 44 period period NN 19613 2742 45 , , , 19613 2742 46 and and CC 19613 2742 47 that that IN 19613 2742 48 often often RB 19613 2742 49 in in IN 19613 2742 50 a a DT 19613 2742 51 somewhat somewhat RB 19613 2742 52 lame lame JJ 19613 2742 53 fashion fashion NN 19613 2742 54 . . . 19613 2743 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2743 2 may may MD 19613 2743 3 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 2743 4 say say VB 19613 2743 5 that that IN 19613 2743 6 the the DT 19613 2743 7 development development NN 19613 2743 8 which which WDT 19613 2743 9 made make VBD 19613 2743 10 the the DT 19613 2743 11 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2743 12 and and CC 19613 2743 13 elders elder NNS 19613 2743 14 priests priest NNS 19613 2743 15 altered alter VBD 19613 2743 16 the the DT 19613 2743 17 inward inward JJ 19613 2743 18 form form NN 19613 2743 19 of of IN 19613 2743 20 the the DT 19613 2743 21 Church Church NNP 19613 2743 22 in in IN 19613 2743 23 a a DT 19613 2743 24 more more RBR 19613 2743 25 radical radical JJ 19613 2743 26 fashion fashion NN 19613 2743 27 than than IN 19613 2743 28 any any DT 19613 2743 29 other other JJ 19613 2743 30 . . . 19613 2744 1 " " `` 19613 2744 2 Gnosticism gnosticism NN 19613 2744 3 , , , 19613 2744 4 " " '' 19613 2744 5 which which WDT 19613 2744 6 the the DT 19613 2744 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2744 8 had have VBD 19613 2744 9 repudiated repudiate VBN 19613 2744 10 in in IN 19613 2744 11 the the DT 19613 2744 12 second second JJ 19613 2744 13 century century NN 19613 2744 14 , , , 19613 2744 15 became become VBD 19613 2744 16 part part NN 19613 2744 17 of of IN 19613 2744 18 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2744 19 own own JJ 19613 2744 20 system system NN 19613 2744 21 in in IN 19613 2744 22 the the DT 19613 2744 23 third third NN 19613 2744 24 . . . 19613 2745 1 As as IN 19613 2745 2 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2745 3 integrity integrity NN 19613 2745 4 had have VBD 19613 2745 5 been be VBN 19613 2745 6 made make VBN 19613 2745 7 dependent dependent JJ 19613 2745 8 on on IN 19613 2745 9 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 2745 10 objective objective JJ 19613 2745 11 standards standard NNS 19613 2745 12 , , , 19613 2745 13 the the DT 19613 2745 14 adoption adoption NN 19613 2745 15 even even RB 19613 2745 16 of of IN 19613 2745 17 this this DT 19613 2745 18 greatest great JJS 19613 2745 19 innovation innovation NN 19613 2745 20 , , , 19613 2745 21 which which WDT 19613 2745 22 indeed indeed RB 19613 2745 23 was be VBD 19613 2745 24 in in IN 19613 2745 25 complete complete JJ 19613 2745 26 harmony harmony NN 19613 2745 27 with with IN 19613 2745 28 the the DT 19613 2745 29 secular secular JJ 19613 2745 30 element element NN 19613 2745 31 within within IN 19613 2745 32 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2745 33 , , , 19613 2745 34 was be VBD 19613 2745 35 an an DT 19613 2745 36 elementary elementary JJ 19613 2745 37 necessity necessity NN 19613 2745 38 . . . 19613 2746 1 In in IN 19613 2746 2 regard regard NN 19613 2746 3 to to IN 19613 2746 4 every every DT 19613 2746 5 sphere sphere NN 19613 2746 6 of of IN 19613 2746 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2746 8 life life NN 19613 2746 9 , , , 19613 2746 10 and and CC 19613 2746 11 hence hence RB 19613 2746 12 also also RB 19613 2746 13 in in IN 19613 2746 14 respect respect NN 19613 2746 15 to to IN 19613 2746 16 the the DT 19613 2746 17 development development NN 19613 2746 18 of of IN 19613 2746 19 dogma[266 dogma[266 NNP 19613 2746 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2746 21 and and CC 19613 2746 22 the the DT 19613 2746 23 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 2746 24 of of IN 19613 2746 25 the the DT 19613 2746 26 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2746 27 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 2746 28 , , , 19613 2746 29 the the DT 19613 2746 30 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 2746 31 proved prove VBD 19613 2746 32 of of IN 19613 2746 33 the the DT 19613 2746 34 highest high JJS 19613 2746 35 significance significance NN 19613 2746 36 . . . 19613 2747 1 The the DT 19613 2747 2 clerical clerical JJ 19613 2747 3 exposition exposition NN 19613 2747 4 of of IN 19613 2747 5 the the DT 19613 2747 6 sacred sacred JJ 19613 2747 7 books book NNS 19613 2747 8 , , , 19613 2747 9 with with IN 19613 2747 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2747 11 frightful frightful JJ 19613 2747 12 ideas idea NNS 19613 2747 13 , , , 19613 2747 14 found find VBD 19613 2747 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2747 16 earliest early JJS 19613 2747 17 advocate advocate NN 19613 2747 18 in in IN 19613 2747 19 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2747 20 and and CC 19613 2747 21 had have VBD 19613 2747 22 thus thus RB 19613 2747 23 a a DT 19613 2747 24 most most RBS 19613 2747 25 skilful skilful JJ 19613 2747 26 champion champion NN 19613 2747 27 at at IN 19613 2747 28 the the DT 19613 2747 29 very very RB 19613 2747 30 first first JJ 19613 2747 31 . . . 19613 2748 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2748 2 267 267 CD 19613 2748 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2748 4 II ii CD 19613 2748 5 . . . 19613 2749 1 SACRIFICE SACRIFICE NNP 19613 2749 2 . . . 19613 2750 1 In in IN 19613 2750 2 Book Book NNP 19613 2750 3 I. I. NNP 19613 2750 4 , , , 19613 2750 5 chap chap NNP 19613 2750 6 . . . 19613 2751 1 III III NNP 19613 2751 2 . . . 19613 2751 3 , , , 19613 2751 4 § § ADD 19613 2751 5 7 7 CD 19613 2751 6 , , , 19613 2751 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2751 8 have have VBP 19613 2751 9 already already RB 19613 2751 10 shown show VBN 19613 2751 11 what what WP 19613 2751 12 a a DT 19613 2751 13 wide wide JJ 19613 2751 14 field field NN 19613 2751 15 the the DT 19613 2751 16 idea idea NN 19613 2751 17 of of IN 19613 2751 18 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2751 19 occupied occupy VBN 19613 2751 20 in in IN 19613 2751 21 primitive primitive JJ 19613 2751 22 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2751 23 , , , 19613 2751 24 and and CC 19613 2751 25 how how WRB 19613 2751 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2751 27 was be VBD 19613 2751 28 specially specially RB 19613 2751 29 connected connect VBN 19613 2751 30 with with IN 19613 2751 31 the the DT 19613 2751 32 celebration celebration NN 19613 2751 33 of of IN 19613 2751 34 the the DT 19613 2751 35 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2751 36 's 's POS 19613 2751 37 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2751 38 . . . 19613 2752 1 The the DT 19613 2752 2 latter latter JJ 19613 2752 3 was be VBD 19613 2752 4 regarded regard VBN 19613 2752 5 as as IN 19613 2752 6 the the DT 19613 2752 7 pure pure JJ 19613 2752 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2752 9 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2752 10 , , , 19613 2752 11 to to TO 19613 2752 12 be be VB 19613 2752 13 presented present VBN 19613 2752 14 with with IN 19613 2752 15 a a DT 19613 2752 16 pure pure JJ 19613 2752 17 heart heart NN 19613 2752 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2752 19 , , , 19613 2752 20 bloodless bloodless NN 19613 2752 21 thank thank VBP 19613 2752 22 offering offering NN 19613 2752 23 of of IN 19613 2752 24 which which WDT 19613 2752 25 Malachi Malachi NNP 19613 2752 26 had have VBD 19613 2752 27 prophesied prophesy VBN 19613 2752 28 in in IN 19613 2752 29 I. I. NNP 19613 2753 1 11 11 CD 19613 2753 2 . . . 19613 2754 1 Priesthood priesthood NN 19613 2754 2 and and CC 19613 2754 3 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2754 4 , , , 19613 2754 5 however however RB 19613 2754 6 , , , 19613 2754 7 are be VBP 19613 2754 8 mutually mutually RB 19613 2754 9 conditioned condition VBN 19613 2754 10 . . . 19613 2755 1 The the DT 19613 2755 2 alteration alteration NN 19613 2755 3 of of IN 19613 2755 4 the the DT 19613 2755 5 concept concept NN 19613 2755 6 " " `` 19613 2755 7 priest priest NN 19613 2755 8 " " '' 19613 2755 9 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 2755 10 led lead VBD 19613 2755 11 to to IN 19613 2755 12 a a DT 19613 2755 13 simultaneous simultaneous JJ 19613 2755 14 and and CC 19613 2755 15 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 2755 16 change change NN 19613 2755 17 in in IN 19613 2755 18 the the DT 19613 2755 19 idea idea NN 19613 2755 20 of of IN 19613 2755 21 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2755 22 , , , 19613 2755 23 just just RB 19613 2755 24 as as IN 19613 2755 25 , , , 19613 2755 26 conversely conversely RB 19613 2755 27 , , , 19613 2755 28 the the DT 19613 2755 29 latter latter JJ 19613 2755 30 reacted react VBD 19613 2755 31 on on IN 19613 2755 32 the the DT 19613 2755 33 former former JJ 19613 2755 34 . . . 19613 2756 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2756 2 268 268 CD 19613 2756 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2756 4 In in IN 19613 2756 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2756 6 and and CC 19613 2756 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2756 8 the the DT 19613 2756 9 old old JJ 19613 2756 10 conception conception NN 19613 2756 11 of of IN 19613 2756 12 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2756 13 , , , 19613 2756 14 viz viz NNP 19613 2756 15 . . NNP 19613 2756 16 , , , 19613 2756 17 that that IN 19613 2756 18 prayers prayer NNS 19613 2756 19 are be VBP 19613 2756 20 the the DT 19613 2756 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 2756 22 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2756 23 and and CC 19613 2756 24 that that IN 19613 2756 25 the the DT 19613 2756 26 disposition disposition NN 19613 2756 27 of of IN 19613 2756 28 the the DT 19613 2756 29 believer believer NN 19613 2756 30 hallows hallow VBZ 19613 2756 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2756 32 whole whole JJ 19613 2756 33 life life NN 19613 2756 34 even even RB 19613 2756 35 as as IN 19613 2756 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2756 37 does do VBZ 19613 2756 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2756 39 offering offering NN 19613 2756 40 , , , 19613 2756 41 and and CC 19613 2756 42 forms form VBZ 19613 2756 43 a a DT 19613 2756 44 well well RB 19613 2756 45 - - HYPH 19613 2756 46 pleasing please VBG 19613 2756 47 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2756 48 to to IN 19613 2756 49 God God NNP 19613 2756 50 , , , 19613 2756 51 remains remain VBZ 19613 2756 52 essentially essentially RB 19613 2756 53 unchanged unchanged JJ 19613 2756 54 . . . 19613 2757 1 In in IN 19613 2757 2 particular particular JJ 19613 2757 3 , , , 19613 2757 4 there there EX 19613 2757 5 is be VBZ 19613 2757 6 no no DT 19613 2757 7 evidence evidence NN 19613 2757 8 of of IN 19613 2757 9 any any DT 19613 2757 10 alteration alteration NN 19613 2757 11 in in IN 19613 2757 12 the the DT 19613 2757 13 notion notion NN 19613 2757 14 of of IN 19613 2757 15 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2757 16 connected connect VBN 19613 2757 17 with with IN 19613 2757 18 the the DT 19613 2757 19 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2757 20 's 's POS 19613 2757 21 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2757 22 . . . 19613 2758 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2758 2 269 269 CD 19613 2758 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2758 4 But but CC 19613 2758 5 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2758 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2758 7 can can MD 19613 2758 8 already already RB 19613 2758 9 trace trace VB 19613 2758 10 a a DT 19613 2758 11 certain certain JJ 19613 2758 12 degree degree NN 19613 2758 13 of of IN 19613 2758 14 modification modification NN 19613 2758 15 in in IN 19613 2758 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2758 17 . . . 19613 2759 1 Not not RB 19613 2759 2 only only RB 19613 2759 3 does do VBZ 19613 2759 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2759 5 give give VB 19613 2759 6 fasting fast VBG 19613 2759 7 , , , 19613 2759 8 voluntary voluntary JJ 19613 2759 9 celibacy celibacy NN 19613 2759 10 , , , 19613 2759 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 2759 12 , , , 19613 2759 13 etc etc FW 19613 2759 14 . . FW 19613 2759 15 , , , 19613 2759 16 special special JJ 19613 2759 17 prominence prominence NN 19613 2759 18 among among IN 19613 2759 19 the the DT 19613 2759 20 sacrificial sacrificial JJ 19613 2759 21 acts act NNS 19613 2759 22 of of IN 19613 2759 23 a a DT 19613 2759 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 2759 25 life life NN 19613 2759 26 , , , 19613 2759 27 and and CC 19613 2759 28 extol extol VB 19613 2759 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2759 30 religious religious JJ 19613 2759 31 value value NN 19613 2759 32 -- -- : 19613 2759 33 as as IN 19613 2759 34 had have VBD 19613 2759 35 already already RB 19613 2759 36 been be VBN 19613 2759 37 done do VBN 19613 2759 38 before before RB 19613 2759 39 ; ; : 19613 2759 40 but but CC 19613 2759 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2759 42 also also RB 19613 2759 43 attributes attribute VBZ 19613 2759 44 a a DT 19613 2759 45 God God NNP 19613 2759 46 - - HYPH 19613 2759 47 propitiating propitiate VBG 19613 2759 48 significance significance NN 19613 2759 49 to to IN 19613 2759 50 these these DT 19613 2759 51 performances performance NNS 19613 2759 52 , , , 19613 2759 53 and and CC 19613 2759 54 plainly plainly RB 19613 2759 55 designates designate VBZ 19613 2759 56 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2759 57 as as IN 19613 2759 58 " " `` 19613 2759 59 merita merita FW 19613 2759 60 " " '' 19613 2759 61 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2759 62 " " `` 19613 2759 63 promereri promereri NNP 19613 2759 64 deum deum NNP 19613 2759 65 " " '' 19613 2759 66 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2759 67 . . . 19613 2760 1 To to IN 19613 2760 2 the the DT 19613 2760 3 best good JJS 19613 2760 4 of of IN 19613 2760 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2760 6 belief belief NN 19613 2760 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2760 8 was be VBD 19613 2760 9 the the DT 19613 2760 10 first first JJ 19613 2760 11 who who WP 19613 2760 12 definitely definitely RB 19613 2760 13 regarded regard VBD 19613 2760 14 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 2760 15 performances performance NNS 19613 2760 16 as as IN 19613 2760 17 propitiatory propitiatory JJ 19613 2760 18 offerings offering NNS 19613 2760 19 and and CC 19613 2760 20 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 2760 21 to to IN 19613 2760 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2760 23 the the DT 19613 2760 24 " " `` 19613 2760 25 potestas potestas NNP 19613 2760 26 reconciliandi reconciliandi NNP 19613 2760 27 iratum iratum NNP 19613 2760 28 deum deum NNP 19613 2760 29 . . . 19613 2761 1 " " `` 19613 2761 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2761 3 270 270 CD 19613 2761 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2761 5 But but CC 19613 2761 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2761 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2761 8 was be VBD 19613 2761 9 far far RB 19613 2761 10 from from IN 19613 2761 11 using use VBG 19613 2761 12 this this DT 19613 2761 13 fatal fatal JJ 19613 2761 14 theory theory NN 19613 2761 15 , , , 19613 2761 16 so so RB 19613 2761 17 often often RB 19613 2761 18 found find VBD 19613 2761 19 in in IN 19613 2761 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2761 21 works work NNS 19613 2761 22 , , , 19613 2761 23 to to TO 19613 2761 24 support support VB 19613 2761 25 a a DT 19613 2761 26 lax lax JJ 19613 2761 27 Church church NN 19613 2761 28 practice practice NN 19613 2761 29 that that WDT 19613 2761 30 made make VBD 19613 2761 31 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2761 32 consist consist VB 19613 2761 33 in in IN 19613 2761 34 outward outward JJ 19613 2761 35 forms form NNS 19613 2761 36 . . . 19613 2762 1 This this DT 19613 2762 2 result result NN 19613 2762 3 did do VBD 19613 2762 4 not not RB 19613 2762 5 come come VB 19613 2762 6 about about IN 19613 2762 7 till till IN 19613 2762 8 the the DT 19613 2762 9 eventful eventful JJ 19613 2762 10 decades decade NNS 19613 2762 11 , , , 19613 2762 12 prolific prolific JJ 19613 2762 13 in in IN 19613 2762 14 new new JJ 19613 2762 15 developments development NNS 19613 2762 16 , , , 19613 2762 17 that that WDT 19613 2762 18 elapsed elapse VBD 19613 2762 19 between between IN 19613 2762 20 the the DT 19613 2762 21 persecutions persecution NNS 19613 2762 22 of of IN 19613 2762 23 Septimius Septimius NNP 19613 2762 24 and and CC 19613 2762 25 Decius Decius NNP 19613 2762 26 ; ; : 19613 2762 27 and and CC 19613 2762 28 in in IN 19613 2762 29 the the DT 19613 2762 30 West West NNP 19613 2762 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2762 32 is be VBZ 19613 2762 33 again again RB 19613 2762 34 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2762 35 who who WP 19613 2762 36 is be VBZ 19613 2762 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2762 38 earliest early JJS 19613 2762 39 witness witness NN 19613 2762 40 as as IN 19613 2762 41 to to IN 19613 2762 42 the the DT 19613 2762 43 new new JJ 19613 2762 44 view view NN 19613 2762 45 and and CC 19613 2762 46 practice practice NN 19613 2762 47 . . . 19613 2763 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2763 2 271 271 CD 19613 2763 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2763 4 In in IN 19613 2763 5 the the DT 19613 2763 6 first first JJ 19613 2763 7 place place NN 19613 2763 8 , , , 19613 2763 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2763 10 was be VBD 19613 2763 11 quite quite RB 19613 2763 12 familiar familiar JJ 19613 2763 13 with with IN 19613 2763 14 the the DT 19613 2763 15 idea idea NN 19613 2763 16 of of IN 19613 2763 17 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 2763 18 propitiations propitiation NNS 19613 2763 19 and and CC 19613 2763 20 utilised utilise VBD 19613 2763 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2763 22 in in IN 19613 2763 23 the the DT 19613 2763 24 interest interest NN 19613 2763 25 of of IN 19613 2763 26 the the DT 19613 2763 27 Catholicity Catholicity NNP 19613 2763 28 of of IN 19613 2763 29 the the DT 19613 2763 30 Church Church NNP 19613 2763 31 ; ; : 19613 2763 32 secondly secondly RB 19613 2763 33 , , , 19613 2763 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2763 35 propounded propound VBD 19613 2763 36 a a DT 19613 2763 37 new new JJ 19613 2763 38 theory theory NN 19613 2763 39 of of IN 19613 2763 40 the the DT 19613 2763 41 offering offering NN 19613 2763 42 in in IN 19613 2763 43 the the DT 19613 2763 44 cultus cultus NN 19613 2763 45 . . . 19613 2764 1 As as RB 19613 2764 2 far far RB 19613 2764 3 as as IN 19613 2764 4 the the DT 19613 2764 5 first first JJ 19613 2764 6 point point NN 19613 2764 7 is be VBZ 19613 2764 8 concerned concern VBN 19613 2764 9 , , , 19613 2764 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2764 11 's 's POS 19613 2764 12 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 2764 13 with with IN 19613 2764 14 regard regard NN 19613 2764 15 to to IN 19613 2764 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2764 17 are be VBP 19613 2764 18 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 2764 19 based base VBN 19613 2764 20 on on IN 19613 2764 21 the the DT 19613 2764 22 understanding understanding NN 19613 2764 23 that that IN 19613 2764 24 even even RB 19613 2764 25 after after IN 19613 2764 26 baptism baptism NN 19613 2764 27 no no DT 19613 2764 28 one one NN 19613 2764 29 can can MD 19613 2764 30 be be VB 19613 2764 31 without without IN 19613 2764 32 sin sin NN 19613 2764 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2764 34 de de FW 19613 2764 35 op op NN 19613 2764 36 . . . 19613 2765 1 et et NN 19613 2765 2 cleemos cleemos NNP 19613 2765 3 . . . 19613 2766 1 3 3 LS 19613 2766 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2766 3 ; ; : 19613 2766 4 and and CC 19613 2766 5 also also RB 19613 2766 6 on on IN 19613 2766 7 the the DT 19613 2766 8 firm firm JJ 19613 2766 9 conviction conviction NN 19613 2766 10 that that IN 19613 2766 11 this this DT 19613 2766 12 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 2766 13 can can MD 19613 2766 14 only only RB 19613 2766 15 have have VB 19613 2766 16 a a DT 19613 2766 17 retrospective retrospective JJ 19613 2766 18 virtue virtue NN 19613 2766 19 . . . 19613 2767 1 Hence hence RB 19613 2767 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2767 3 concludes conclude VBZ 19613 2767 4 that that IN 19613 2767 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2767 6 must must MD 19613 2767 7 appease appease VB 19613 2767 8 God God NNP 19613 2767 9 , , , 19613 2767 10 whose whose WP$ 19613 2767 11 wrath wrath NN 19613 2767 12 has have VBZ 19613 2767 13 been be VBN 19613 2767 14 aroused arouse VBN 19613 2767 15 by by IN 19613 2767 16 sin sin NN 19613 2767 17 , , , 19613 2767 18 through through IN 19613 2767 19 performances performance NNS 19613 2767 20 of of IN 19613 2767 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2767 22 own own JJ 19613 2767 23 , , , 19613 2767 24 that that RB 19613 2767 25 is is RB 19613 2767 26 , , , 19613 2767 27 through through IN 19613 2767 28 offerings offering NNS 19613 2767 29 that that WDT 19613 2767 30 bear bear VBP 19613 2767 31 the the DT 19613 2767 32 character character NN 19613 2767 33 of of IN 19613 2767 34 " " `` 19613 2767 35 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 19613 2767 36 . . . 19613 2767 37 " " '' 19613 2768 1 In in IN 19613 2768 2 other other JJ 19613 2768 3 words word NNS 19613 2768 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2768 5 must must MD 19613 2768 6 blot blot VB 19613 2768 7 out out RP 19613 2768 8 transgressions transgression NNS 19613 2768 9 by by IN 19613 2768 10 specially specially RB 19613 2768 11 meritorious meritorious JJ 19613 2768 12 deeds deed NNS 19613 2768 13 in in IN 19613 2768 14 order order NN 19613 2768 15 thus thus RB 19613 2768 16 to to TO 19613 2768 17 escape escape VB 19613 2768 18 eternal eternal JJ 19613 2768 19 punishment punishment NN 19613 2768 20 . . . 19613 2769 1 These these DT 19613 2769 2 deeds deed NNS 19613 2769 3 Cyprian cyprian JJ 19613 2769 4 terms term NNS 19613 2769 5 " " `` 19613 2769 6 merita merita FW 19613 2769 7 , , , 19613 2769 8 " " '' 19613 2769 9 which which WDT 19613 2769 10 either either CC 19613 2769 11 possess possess VBP 19613 2769 12 the the DT 19613 2769 13 character character NN 19613 2769 14 of of IN 19613 2769 15 atonements atonement NNS 19613 2769 16 , , , 19613 2769 17 or or CC 19613 2769 18 , , , 19613 2769 19 in in IN 19613 2769 20 case case NN 19613 2769 21 there there EX 19613 2769 22 are be VBP 19613 2769 23 no no DT 19613 2769 24 sins sin NNS 19613 2769 25 to to TO 19613 2769 26 be be VB 19613 2769 27 expiated expiate VBN 19613 2769 28 , , , 19613 2769 29 entitle entitle VB 19613 2769 30 the the DT 19613 2769 31 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2769 32 to to IN 19613 2769 33 a a DT 19613 2769 34 special special JJ 19613 2769 35 reward reward NN 19613 2769 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2769 37 merces merce NNS 19613 2769 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2769 39 . . . 19613 2770 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2770 2 272 272 CD 19613 2770 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2770 4 But but CC 19613 2770 5 , , , 19613 2770 6 along along IN 19613 2770 7 with with IN 19613 2770 8 _ _ NNP 19613 2770 9 lamentationes lamentationes NNP 19613 2770 10 _ _ NNP 19613 2770 11 and and CC 19613 2770 12 acts act NNS 19613 2770 13 of of IN 19613 2770 14 penance penance NN 19613 2770 15 , , , 19613 2770 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2770 17 is be VBZ 19613 2770 18 principally principally RB 19613 2770 19 alms alms RB 19613 2770 20 - - , 19613 2770 21 giving give VBG 19613 2770 22 that that WDT 19613 2770 23 forms form NNS 19613 2770 24 such such JJ 19613 2770 25 means mean NNS 19613 2770 26 of of IN 19613 2770 27 atonement atonement NN 19613 2770 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2770 29 see see VB 19613 2770 30 de de FW 19613 2770 31 lapsis lapsis NNP 19613 2770 32 , , , 19613 2770 33 35 35 CD 19613 2770 34 , , , 19613 2770 35 36 36 CD 19613 2770 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2770 37 . . . 19613 2771 1 In in IN 19613 2771 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2771 3 's 's POS 19613 2771 4 eyes eye NNS 19613 2771 5 this this DT 19613 2771 6 is be VBZ 19613 2771 7 already already RB 19613 2771 8 the the DT 19613 2771 9 proper proper JJ 19613 2771 10 satisfaction satisfaction NN 19613 2771 11 ; ; , 19613 2771 12 mere mere JJ 19613 2771 13 prayer prayer NN 19613 2771 14 , , , 19613 2771 15 that that RB 19613 2771 16 is is RB 19613 2771 17 , , , 19613 2771 18 devotional devotional NN 19613 2771 19 exercises exercise NNS 19613 2771 20 unaccompanied unaccompanie VBN 19613 2771 21 by by IN 19613 2771 22 fasting fast VBG 19613 2771 23 and and CC 19613 2771 24 alms alm NNS 19613 2771 25 , , , 19613 2771 26 being be VBG 19613 2771 27 regarded regard VBN 19613 2771 28 as as IN 19613 2771 29 " " `` 19613 2771 30 bare bare JJ 19613 2771 31 and and CC 19613 2771 32 unfruitful unfruitful JJ 19613 2771 33 . . . 19613 2771 34 " " '' 19613 2772 1 In in IN 19613 2772 2 the the DT 19613 2772 3 work work NN 19613 2772 4 " " '' 19613 2772 5 de de FW 19613 2772 6 opere opere NNP 19613 2772 7 et et NNP 19613 2772 8 eleemosynis eleemosynis NNP 19613 2772 9 " " '' 19613 2772 10 which which WDT 19613 2772 11 , , , 19613 2772 12 after after IN 19613 2772 13 a a DT 19613 2772 14 fashion fashion NN 19613 2772 15 highly highly RB 19613 2772 16 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 2772 17 of of IN 19613 2772 18 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2772 19 , , , 19613 2772 20 is be VBZ 19613 2772 21 made make VBN 19613 2772 22 dependent dependent JJ 19613 2772 23 on on IN 19613 2772 24 Sirach Sirach NNP 19613 2772 25 and and CC 19613 2772 26 Tobias Tobias NNP 19613 2772 27 , , , 19613 2772 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2772 29 has have VBZ 19613 2772 30 set set VBN 19613 2772 31 forth forth RP 19613 2772 32 a a DT 19613 2772 33 detailed detailed JJ 19613 2772 34 theory theory NN 19613 2772 35 of of IN 19613 2772 36 what what WP 19613 2772 37 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2772 38 may may MD 19613 2772 39 call call VB 19613 2772 40 alms alm NNS 19613 2772 41 - - , 19613 2772 42 giving give VBG 19613 2772 43 as as IN 19613 2772 44 a a DT 19613 2772 45 _ _ NNP 19613 2772 46 means mean VBZ 19613 2772 47 of of IN 19613 2772 48 grace grace NN 19613 2772 49 _ _ NNP 19613 2772 50 in in IN 19613 2772 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2772 52 relation relation NN 19613 2772 53 to to IN 19613 2772 54 baptism baptism NN 19613 2772 55 and and CC 19613 2772 56 salvation salvation NN 19613 2772 57 . . . 19613 2773 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2773 2 273 273 CD 19613 2773 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2773 4 However however RB 19613 2773 5 , , , 19613 2773 6 this this DT 19613 2773 7 practice practice NN 19613 2773 8 can can MD 19613 2773 9 only only RB 19613 2773 10 be be VB 19613 2773 11 viewed view VBN 19613 2773 12 as as IN 19613 2773 13 a a DT 19613 2773 14 means means NN 19613 2773 15 of of IN 19613 2773 16 grace grace NN 19613 2773 17 in in IN 19613 2773 18 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2773 19 's 's POS 19613 2773 20 sense sense NN 19613 2773 21 in in RP 19613 2773 22 so so RB 19613 2773 23 far far RB 19613 2773 24 as as IN 19613 2773 25 God God NNP 19613 2773 26 has have VBZ 19613 2773 27 accepted accept VBN 19613 2773 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2773 29 , , , 19613 2773 30 that that RB 19613 2773 31 is is RB 19613 2773 32 , , , 19613 2773 33 pointed point VBD 19613 2773 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2773 35 out out RP 19613 2773 36 . . . 19613 2774 1 In in IN 19613 2774 2 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2774 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2774 4 is be VBZ 19613 2774 5 a a DT 19613 2774 6 free free JJ 19613 2774 7 human human JJ 19613 2774 8 act act NN 19613 2774 9 . . . 19613 2775 1 After after IN 19613 2775 2 the the DT 19613 2775 3 Decian decian JJ 19613 2775 4 persecution persecution NN 19613 2775 5 and and CC 19613 2775 6 the the DT 19613 2775 7 rearrangement rearrangement NN 19613 2775 8 of of IN 19613 2775 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2775 10 affairs affair NNS 19613 2775 11 necessitated necessitate VBN 19613 2775 12 by by IN 19613 2775 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2775 14 , , , 19613 2775 15 works work VBZ 19613 2775 16 and and CC 19613 2775 17 alms alm NNS 19613 2775 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2775 19 opera opera NNP 19613 2775 20 et et NNP 19613 2775 21 eleemosynæ eleemosynæ NNP 19613 2775 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2775 23 made make VBD 19613 2775 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2775 25 way way NN 19613 2775 26 into into IN 19613 2775 27 the the DT 19613 2775 28 absolution absolution NN 19613 2775 29 system system NN 19613 2775 30 of of IN 19613 2775 31 the the DT 19613 2775 32 Church Church NNP 19613 2775 33 , , , 19613 2775 34 and and CC 19613 2775 35 were be VBD 19613 2775 36 assigned assign VBN 19613 2775 37 a a DT 19613 2775 38 permanent permanent JJ 19613 2775 39 place place NN 19613 2775 40 in in IN 19613 2775 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2775 42 . . . 19613 2776 1 Even even RB 19613 2776 2 the the DT 19613 2776 3 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2776 4 who who WP 19613 2776 5 has have VBZ 19613 2776 6 forfeited forfeit VBN 19613 2776 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2776 8 Church Church NNP 19613 2776 9 membership membership NN 19613 2776 10 by by IN 19613 2776 11 abjuration abjuration NN 19613 2776 12 may may MD 19613 2776 13 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 2776 14 recover recover VB 19613 2776 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2776 16 by by IN 19613 2776 17 deeds deed NNS 19613 2776 18 of of IN 19613 2776 19 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2776 20 , , , 19613 2776 21 of of IN 19613 2776 22 course course NN 19613 2776 23 under under IN 19613 2776 24 the the DT 19613 2776 25 guidance guidance NN 19613 2776 26 and and CC 19613 2776 27 intercessory intercessory JJ 19613 2776 28 coöperation coöperation NN 19613 2776 29 of of IN 19613 2776 30 the the DT 19613 2776 31 Church Church NNP 19613 2776 32 . . . 19613 2777 1 The the DT 19613 2777 2 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 2777 3 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 2777 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2777 5 find find VBP 19613 2777 6 here here RB 19613 2777 7 can can MD 19613 2777 8 not not RB 19613 2777 9 be be VB 19613 2777 10 more more RBR 19613 2777 11 clearly clearly RB 19613 2777 12 characterised characterise VBN 19613 2777 13 than than IN 19613 2777 14 by by IN 19613 2777 15 simply simply RB 19613 2777 16 placing place VBG 19613 2777 17 the the DT 19613 2777 18 two two CD 19613 2777 19 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 2777 20 professed profess VBN 19613 2777 21 by by IN 19613 2777 22 Cyprian cyprian JJ 19613 2777 23 side side NN 19613 2777 24 by by IN 19613 2777 25 side side NN 19613 2777 26 . . . 19613 2778 1 These these DT 19613 2778 2 are:--(1 are:--(1 NN 19613 2778 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2778 4 that that IN 19613 2778 5 the the DT 19613 2778 6 sinfulness sinfulness NN 19613 2778 7 common common JJ 19613 2778 8 to to IN 19613 2778 9 each each DT 19613 2778 10 individual individual NN 19613 2778 11 can can MD 19613 2778 12 only only RB 19613 2778 13 be be VB 19613 2778 14 once once RB 19613 2778 15 extirpated extirpate VBN 19613 2778 16 by by IN 19613 2778 17 the the DT 19613 2778 18 power power NN 19613 2778 19 of of IN 19613 2778 20 baptism baptism NN 19613 2778 21 derived derive VBN 19613 2778 22 from from IN 19613 2778 23 the the DT 19613 2778 24 work work NN 19613 2778 25 of of IN 19613 2778 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2778 27 , , , 19613 2778 28 and and CC 19613 2778 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2778 30 2 2 LS 19613 2778 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2778 32 that that WDT 19613 2778 33 transgressions transgression NNS 19613 2778 34 committed commit VBD 19613 2778 35 after after IN 19613 2778 36 baptism baptism NN 19613 2778 37 , , , 19613 2778 38 inclusive inclusive JJ 19613 2778 39 of of IN 19613 2778 40 mortal mortal JJ 19613 2778 41 sins sin NNS 19613 2778 42 , , , 19613 2778 43 can can MD 19613 2778 44 and and CC 19613 2778 45 must must MD 19613 2778 46 be be VB 19613 2778 47 expiated expiate VBN 19613 2778 48 solely solely RB 19613 2778 49 by by IN 19613 2778 50 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 19613 2778 51 acts act NNS 19613 2778 52 of of IN 19613 2778 53 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2778 54 under under IN 19613 2778 55 the the DT 19613 2778 56 guidance guidance NN 19613 2778 57 of of IN 19613 2778 58 kind kind NN 19613 2778 59 mother mother NN 19613 2778 60 Church Church NNP 19613 2778 61 . . . 19613 2779 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2779 2 274 274 CD 19613 2779 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2779 4 A a DT 19613 2779 5 Church Church NNP 19613 2779 6 capable capable JJ 19613 2779 7 of of IN 19613 2779 8 being be VBG 19613 2779 9 permanently permanently RB 19613 2779 10 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 2779 11 with with IN 19613 2779 12 such such JJ 19613 2779 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 2779 14 would would MD 19613 2779 15 very very RB 19613 2779 16 soon soon RB 19613 2779 17 have have VB 19613 2779 18 lost lose VBN 19613 2779 19 the the DT 19613 2779 20 last last JJ 19613 2779 21 remains remain NNS 19613 2779 22 of of IN 19613 2779 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2779 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 2779 25 character character NN 19613 2779 26 . . . 19613 2780 1 What what WP 19613 2780 2 was be VBD 19613 2780 3 wanted want VBN 19613 2780 4 was be VBD 19613 2780 5 a a DT 19613 2780 6 means means NN 19613 2780 7 of of IN 19613 2780 8 grace grace NN 19613 2780 9 , , , 19613 2780 10 similar similar JJ 19613 2780 11 to to IN 19613 2780 12 baptism baptism NN 19613 2780 13 and and CC 19613 2780 14 granted grant VBN 19613 2780 15 by by IN 19613 2780 16 God God NNP 19613 2780 17 through through IN 19613 2780 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2780 19 , , , 19613 2780 20 to to TO 19613 2780 21 which which WDT 19613 2780 22 the the DT 19613 2780 23 _ _ NNP 19613 2780 24 opera opera NNP 19613 2780 25 et et NNP 19613 2780 26 eleemosynæ eleemosynæ NNP 19613 2780 27 _ _ NNP 19613 2780 28 are be VBP 19613 2780 29 merely merely RB 19613 2780 30 to to TO 19613 2780 31 bear bear VB 19613 2780 32 the the DT 19613 2780 33 relation relation NN 19613 2780 34 of of IN 19613 2780 35 _ _ NNP 19613 2780 36 accompanying accompany VBG 19613 2780 37 _ _ NNP 19613 2780 38 acts act VBZ 19613 2780 39 . . . 19613 2781 1 But but CC 19613 2781 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2781 3 was be VBD 19613 2781 4 no no DT 19613 2781 5 dogmatist dogmatist NN 19613 2781 6 and and CC 19613 2781 7 was be VBD 19613 2781 8 not not RB 19613 2781 9 able able JJ 19613 2781 10 to to TO 19613 2781 11 form form VB 19613 2781 12 a a DT 19613 2781 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2781 14 of of IN 19613 2781 15 the the DT 19613 2781 16 means mean NNS 19613 2781 17 of of IN 19613 2781 18 grace grace NN 19613 2781 19 . . . 19613 2782 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2782 2 never never RB 19613 2782 3 got get VBD 19613 2782 4 beyond beyond IN 19613 2782 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2782 6 " " `` 19613 2782 7 propitiate propitiate NN 19613 2782 8 God God NNP 19613 2782 9 the the DT 19613 2782 10 judge judge NN 19613 2782 11 by by IN 19613 2782 12 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 19613 2782 13 after after IN 19613 2782 14 baptism baptism NN 19613 2782 15 " " '' 19613 2782 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2782 17 " " `` 19613 2782 18 promereri promereri NNP 19613 2782 19 deum deum NNP 19613 2782 20 judicem judicem NNP 19613 2782 21 post post NNP 19613 2782 22 baptismum baptismum NNP 19613 2782 23 sacrificiis sacrificiis NNP 19613 2782 24 " " '' 19613 2782 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2782 26 , , , 19613 2782 27 and and CC 19613 2782 28 merely merely RB 19613 2782 29 hinted hint VBN 19613 2782 30 , , , 19613 2782 31 in in IN 19613 2782 32 an an DT 19613 2782 33 obscure obscure JJ 19613 2782 34 way way NN 19613 2782 35 , , , 19613 2782 36 that that IN 19613 2782 37 the the DT 19613 2782 38 absolution absolution NN 19613 2782 39 of of IN 19613 2782 40 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2782 41 who who WP 19613 2782 42 has have VBZ 19613 2782 43 committed commit VBN 19613 2782 44 a a DT 19613 2782 45 deadly deadly JJ 19613 2782 46 sin sin NN 19613 2782 47 after after IN 19613 2782 48 baptism baptism NN 19613 2782 49 emanates emanate NNS 19613 2782 50 from from IN 19613 2782 51 the the DT 19613 2782 52 same same JJ 19613 2782 53 readiness readiness NN 19613 2782 54 of of IN 19613 2782 55 God God NNP 19613 2782 56 to to TO 19613 2782 57 forgive forgive VB 19613 2782 58 as as IN 19613 2782 59 is be VBZ 19613 2782 60 expressed express VBN 19613 2782 61 in in IN 19613 2782 62 that that DT 19613 2782 63 rite rite NN 19613 2782 64 , , , 19613 2782 65 and and CC 19613 2782 66 that that IN 19613 2782 67 membership membership NN 19613 2782 68 in in IN 19613 2782 69 the the DT 19613 2782 70 Church Church NNP 19613 2782 71 is be VBZ 19613 2782 72 a a DT 19613 2782 73 condition condition NN 19613 2782 74 of of IN 19613 2782 75 absolution absolution NN 19613 2782 76 . . . 19613 2783 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2783 2 whole whole JJ 19613 2783 3 theory theory NN 19613 2783 4 as as IN 19613 2783 5 to to IN 19613 2783 6 the the DT 19613 2783 7 legal legal JJ 19613 2783 8 nature nature NN 19613 2783 9 of of IN 19613 2783 10 man man NN 19613 2783 11 's 's POS 19613 2783 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2783 13 the the DT 19613 2783 14 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2783 15 's 's POS 19613 2783 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2783 17 relationship relationship NN 19613 2783 18 to to IN 19613 2783 19 God God NNP 19613 2783 20 , , , 19613 2783 21 and and CC 19613 2783 22 the the DT 19613 2783 23 practice practice NN 19613 2783 24 , , , 19613 2783 25 inaugurated inaugurate VBN 19613 2783 26 by by IN 19613 2783 27 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2783 28 , , , 19613 2783 29 of of IN 19613 2783 30 designating designate VBG 19613 2783 31 this this DT 19613 2783 32 connection connection NN 19613 2783 33 by by IN 19613 2783 34 terms term NNS 19613 2783 35 derived derive VBN 19613 2783 36 from from IN 19613 2783 37 Roman roman JJ 19613 2783 38 law law NN 19613 2783 39 continued continue VBD 19613 2783 40 to to TO 19613 2783 41 prevail prevail VB 19613 2783 42 in in IN 19613 2783 43 the the DT 19613 2783 44 West West NNP 19613 2783 45 down down RP 19613 2783 46 to to IN 19613 2783 47 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 2783 48 's 's POS 19613 2783 49 time time NN 19613 2783 50 . . . 19613 2784 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2784 2 275 275 CD 19613 2784 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2784 4 But but CC 19613 2784 5 , , , 19613 2784 6 during during IN 19613 2784 7 this this DT 19613 2784 8 whole whole JJ 19613 2784 9 interval interval NN 19613 2784 10 , , , 19613 2784 11 no no DT 19613 2784 12 book book NN 19613 2784 13 was be VBD 19613 2784 14 written write VBN 19613 2784 15 by by IN 19613 2784 16 a a DT 19613 2784 17 Western Western NNP 19613 2784 18 Churchman Churchman NNP 19613 2784 19 which which WDT 19613 2784 20 made make VBD 19613 2784 21 the the DT 19613 2784 22 salvation salvation NN 19613 2784 23 of of IN 19613 2784 24 the the DT 19613 2784 25 sinful sinful JJ 19613 2784 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 2784 27 dependent dependent JJ 19613 2784 28 on on IN 19613 2784 29 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 2784 30 offerings offering NNS 19613 2784 31 of of IN 19613 2784 32 atonement atonement NN 19613 2784 33 , , , 19613 2784 34 with with IN 19613 2784 35 so so RB 19613 2784 36 little little JJ 19613 2784 37 regard regard NN 19613 2784 38 to to IN 19613 2784 39 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2784 40 's 's POS 19613 2784 41 grace grace NN 19613 2784 42 and and CC 19613 2784 43 the the DT 19613 2784 44 divine divine JJ 19613 2784 45 factor factor NN 19613 2784 46 in in IN 19613 2784 47 the the DT 19613 2784 48 case case NN 19613 2784 49 , , , 19613 2784 50 as as IN 19613 2784 51 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2784 52 's 's POS 19613 2784 53 work work NN 19613 2784 54 _ _ NNP 19613 2784 55 de de FW 19613 2784 56 opere opere NNP 19613 2784 57 et et NNP 19613 2784 58 eleemosynis eleemosynis NNP 19613 2784 59 _ _ NNP 19613 2784 60 . . . 19613 2785 1 No no DT 19613 2785 2 less less RBR 19613 2785 3 significant significant JJ 19613 2785 4 is be VBZ 19613 2785 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2785 6 's 's POS 19613 2785 7 advance advance NN 19613 2785 8 as as IN 19613 2785 9 regards regard VBZ 19613 2785 10 the the DT 19613 2785 11 idea idea NN 19613 2785 12 of of IN 19613 2785 13 the the DT 19613 2785 14 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2785 15 in in IN 19613 2785 16 public public JJ 19613 2785 17 worship worship NN 19613 2785 18 , , , 19613 2785 19 and and CC 19613 2785 20 that that IN 19613 2785 21 in in IN 19613 2785 22 three three CD 19613 2785 23 respects respect NNS 19613 2785 24 . . . 19613 2786 1 To to TO 19613 2786 2 begin begin VB 19613 2786 3 with with IN 19613 2786 4 , , , 19613 2786 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2786 6 was be VBD 19613 2786 7 the the DT 19613 2786 8 first first JJ 19613 2786 9 to to TO 19613 2786 10 associate associate VB 19613 2786 11 the the DT 19613 2786 12 specific specific JJ 19613 2786 13 offering offering NN 19613 2786 14 , , , 19613 2786 15 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 2786 16 , , , 19613 2786 17 the the DT 19613 2786 18 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2786 19 's 's POS 19613 2786 20 Supper[276 supper[276 CD 19613 2786 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2786 22 with with IN 19613 2786 23 the the DT 19613 2786 24 specific specific JJ 19613 2786 25 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 2786 26 . . . 19613 2787 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 2787 2 , , , 19613 2787 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2787 4 was be VBD 19613 2787 5 the the DT 19613 2787 6 first first JJ 19613 2787 7 to to TO 19613 2787 8 designate designate VB 19613 2787 9 the the DT 19613 2787 10 _ _ NNP 19613 2787 11 passio passio NNP 19613 2787 12 dominis dominis NNP 19613 2787 13 _ _ NNP 19613 2787 14 , , , 19613 2787 15 nay nay NNP 19613 2787 16 , , , 19613 2787 17 the the DT 19613 2787 18 _ _ NNP 19613 2787 19 sanguis sanguis NN 19613 2787 20 Christi Christi NNP 19613 2787 21 _ _ NNP 19613 2787 22 and and CC 19613 2787 23 the the DT 19613 2787 24 _ _ NNP 19613 2787 25 dominica dominica NNP 19613 2787 26 hostia hostia NN 19613 2787 27 _ _ NNP 19613 2787 28 as as IN 19613 2787 29 the the DT 19613 2787 30 object object NN 19613 2787 31 of of IN 19613 2787 32 the the DT 19613 2787 33 eucharistic eucharistic JJ 19613 2787 34 offering offering NN 19613 2787 35 . . . 19613 2788 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2788 2 277 277 CD 19613 2788 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2788 4 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 2788 5 , , , 19613 2788 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2788 7 expressly expressly RB 19613 2788 8 represented represent VBD 19613 2788 9 the the DT 19613 2788 10 celebration celebration NN 19613 2788 11 of of IN 19613 2788 12 the the DT 19613 2788 13 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2788 14 's 's POS 19613 2788 15 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2788 16 as as IN 19613 2788 17 an an DT 19613 2788 18 incorporation incorporation NN 19613 2788 19 of of IN 19613 2788 20 the the DT 19613 2788 21 congregation congregation NN 19613 2788 22 and and CC 19613 2788 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2788 24 individual individual JJ 19613 2788 25 members member NNS 19613 2788 26 with with IN 19613 2788 27 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2788 28 , , , 19613 2788 29 and and CC 19613 2788 30 was be VBD 19613 2788 31 the the DT 19613 2788 32 first first JJ 19613 2788 33 to to TO 19613 2788 34 bear bear VB 19613 2788 35 clear clear JJ 19613 2788 36 testimony testimony NN 19613 2788 37 as as IN 19613 2788 38 to to IN 19613 2788 39 the the DT 19613 2788 40 special special JJ 19613 2788 41 importance importance NN 19613 2788 42 attributed attribute VBN 19613 2788 43 to to IN 19613 2788 44 commemoration commemoration NN 19613 2788 45 of of IN 19613 2788 46 the the DT 19613 2788 47 celebrators celebrator NNS 19613 2788 48 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2788 49 " " `` 19613 2788 50 vivi vivi NNP 19613 2788 51 et et NNP 19613 2788 52 defuncti defuncti NN 19613 2788 53 " " '' 19613 2788 54 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2788 55 , , , 19613 2788 56 though though IN 19613 2788 57 no no DT 19613 2788 58 other other JJ 19613 2788 59 can can MD 19613 2788 60 be be VB 19613 2788 61 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 2788 62 than than IN 19613 2788 63 a a DT 19613 2788 64 specially specially RB 19613 2788 65 strong strong JJ 19613 2788 66 intercession intercession NN 19613 2788 67 . . . 19613 2789 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2789 2 278 278 CD 19613 2789 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2789 4 But but CC 19613 2789 5 this this DT 19613 2789 6 is be VBZ 19613 2789 7 really really RB 19613 2789 8 the the DT 19613 2789 9 essential essential JJ 19613 2789 10 effect effect NN 19613 2789 11 of of IN 19613 2789 12 the the DT 19613 2789 13 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2789 14 of of IN 19613 2789 15 the the DT 19613 2789 16 supper supper NN 19613 2789 17 as as IN 19613 2789 18 regards regard VBZ 19613 2789 19 the the DT 19613 2789 20 celebrators celebrator NNS 19613 2789 21 ; ; : 19613 2789 22 for for IN 19613 2789 23 however however RB 19613 2789 24 much much JJ 19613 2789 25 the the DT 19613 2789 26 conceptions conception NNS 19613 2789 27 about about IN 19613 2789 28 this this DT 19613 2789 29 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 2789 30 might may MD 19613 2789 31 be be VB 19613 2789 32 heightened heighten VBN 19613 2789 33 , , , 19613 2789 34 and and CC 19613 2789 35 whatever whatever WDT 19613 2789 36 additions addition NNS 19613 2789 37 might may MD 19613 2789 38 be be VB 19613 2789 39 made make VBN 19613 2789 40 to to IN 19613 2789 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2789 42 ritual ritual NN 19613 2789 43 , , , 19613 2789 44 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2789 45 of of IN 19613 2789 46 sins sin NNS 19613 2789 47 in in IN 19613 2789 48 the the DT 19613 2789 49 strict strict JJ 19613 2789 50 sense sense NN 19613 2789 51 could could MD 19613 2789 52 not not RB 19613 2789 53 be be VB 19613 2789 54 associated associate VBN 19613 2789 55 with with IN 19613 2789 56 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2789 57 . . . 19613 2790 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2790 2 's 's POS 19613 2790 3 statement statement NN 19613 2790 4 that that IN 19613 2790 5 every every DT 19613 2790 6 celebration celebration NN 19613 2790 7 of of IN 19613 2790 8 the the DT 19613 2790 9 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2790 10 's 's POS 19613 2790 11 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2790 12 is be VBZ 19613 2790 13 a a DT 19613 2790 14 repetition repetition NN 19613 2790 15 or or CC 19613 2790 16 imitation imitation NN 19613 2790 17 of of IN 19613 2790 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2790 19 's 's POS 19613 2790 20 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2790 21 of of IN 19613 2790 22 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2790 23 , , , 19613 2790 24 and and CC 19613 2790 25 that that IN 19613 2790 26 the the DT 19613 2790 27 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 2790 28 has have VBZ 19613 2790 29 therefore therefore RB 19613 2790 30 an an DT 19613 2790 31 expiatory expiatory NN 19613 2790 32 value value NN 19613 2790 33 remains remain VBZ 19613 2790 34 a a DT 19613 2790 35 mere mere JJ 19613 2790 36 assertion assertion NN 19613 2790 37 , , , 19613 2790 38 though though IN 19613 2790 39 the the DT 19613 2790 40 Romish Romish NNP 19613 2790 41 Church Church NNP 19613 2790 42 still still RB 19613 2790 43 continues continue VBZ 19613 2790 44 to to TO 19613 2790 45 repeat repeat VB 19613 2790 46 this this DT 19613 2790 47 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2790 48 to to IN 19613 2790 49 the the DT 19613 2790 50 present present JJ 19613 2790 51 day day NN 19613 2790 52 . . . 19613 2791 1 For for IN 19613 2791 2 the the DT 19613 2791 3 idea idea NN 19613 2791 4 that that IN 19613 2791 5 partaking partaking NN 19613 2791 6 of of IN 19613 2791 7 the the DT 19613 2791 8 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2791 9 's 's POS 19613 2791 10 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2791 11 cleansed cleanse VBD 19613 2791 12 from from IN 19613 2791 13 sin sin NN 19613 2791 14 like like IN 19613 2791 15 the the DT 19613 2791 16 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 2791 17 of of IN 19613 2791 18 the the DT 19613 2791 19 Great Great NNP 19613 2791 20 Mother Mother NNP 19613 2791 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2791 22 magna magna NNS 19613 2791 23 mater mater VBP 19613 2791 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2791 25 and and CC 19613 2791 26 Mithras Mithras NNP 19613 2791 27 , , , 19613 2791 28 though though IN 19613 2791 29 naturally naturally RB 19613 2791 30 suggested suggest VBN 19613 2791 31 by by IN 19613 2791 32 the the DT 19613 2791 33 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 2791 34 practice practice NN 19613 2791 35 , , , 19613 2791 36 was be VBD 19613 2791 37 counteracted counteract VBN 19613 2791 38 by by IN 19613 2791 39 the the DT 19613 2791 40 Church Church NNP 19613 2791 41 principles principle NNS 19613 2791 42 of of IN 19613 2791 43 penance penance NN 19613 2791 44 and and CC 19613 2791 45 by by IN 19613 2791 46 the the DT 19613 2791 47 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2791 48 of of IN 19613 2791 49 baptism baptism NN 19613 2791 50 . . . 19613 2792 1 As as IN 19613 2792 2 a a DT 19613 2792 3 sacrificial sacrificial JJ 19613 2792 4 rite rite NN 19613 2792 5 the the DT 19613 2792 6 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2792 7 never never RB 19613 2792 8 became become VBD 19613 2792 9 a a DT 19613 2792 10 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 2792 11 equivalent equivalent JJ 19613 2792 12 in in IN 19613 2792 13 effect effect NN 19613 2792 14 to to IN 19613 2792 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 2792 16 . . . 19613 2793 1 But but CC 19613 2793 2 no no RB 19613 2793 3 doubt doubt RB 19613 2793 4 , , , 19613 2793 5 as as RB 19613 2793 6 far far RB 19613 2793 7 as as IN 19613 2793 8 the the DT 19613 2793 9 popular popular JJ 19613 2793 10 conception conception NN 19613 2793 11 was be VBD 19613 2793 12 concerned concern VBN 19613 2793 13 , , , 19613 2793 14 the the DT 19613 2793 15 solemn solemn JJ 19613 2793 16 ritual ritual NN 19613 2793 17 copied copy VBN 19613 2793 18 from from IN 19613 2793 19 the the DT 19613 2793 20 ancient ancient JJ 19613 2793 21 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 2793 22 could could MD 19613 2793 23 not not RB 19613 2793 24 but but CC 19613 2793 25 attain attain VB 19613 2793 26 an an DT 19613 2793 27 indescribably indescribably RB 19613 2793 28 important important JJ 19613 2793 29 significance significance NN 19613 2793 30 . . . 19613 2794 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2794 2 is be VBZ 19613 2794 3 not not RB 19613 2794 4 possible possible JJ 19613 2794 5 , , , 19613 2794 6 within within IN 19613 2794 7 the the DT 19613 2794 8 framework framework NN 19613 2794 9 of of IN 19613 2794 10 the the DT 19613 2794 11 history history NN 19613 2794 12 of of IN 19613 2794 13 dogma dogma NN 19613 2794 14 , , , 19613 2794 15 to to TO 19613 2794 16 describe describe VB 19613 2794 17 the the DT 19613 2794 18 development development NN 19613 2794 19 of of IN 19613 2794 20 religious religious JJ 19613 2794 21 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 2794 22 in in IN 19613 2794 23 the the DT 19613 2794 24 third third JJ 19613 2794 25 century century NN 19613 2794 26 , , , 19613 2794 27 and and CC 19613 2794 28 to to TO 19613 2794 29 show show VB 19613 2794 30 what what WP 19613 2794 31 a a DT 19613 2794 32 radical radical JJ 19613 2794 33 alteration alteration NN 19613 2794 34 took take VBD 19613 2794 35 place place NN 19613 2794 36 in in IN 19613 2794 37 men man NNS 19613 2794 38 's 's POS 19613 2794 39 conceptions conception NNS 19613 2794 40 with with IN 19613 2794 41 regard regard NN 19613 2794 42 to to IN 19613 2794 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2794 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2794 45 cf cf UH 19613 2794 46 . . . 19613 2795 1 for for IN 19613 2795 2 example example NN 19613 2795 3 , , , 19613 2795 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 2795 5 with with IN 19613 2795 6 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2795 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2795 8 . . . 19613 2796 1 But but CC 19613 2796 2 , , , 19613 2796 3 in in IN 19613 2796 4 dealing deal VBG 19613 2796 5 with with IN 19613 2796 6 the the DT 19613 2796 7 history history NN 19613 2796 8 of of IN 19613 2796 9 dogma dogma NN 19613 2796 10 within within IN 19613 2796 11 this this DT 19613 2796 12 period period NN 19613 2796 13 , , , 19613 2796 14 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2796 15 must must MD 19613 2796 16 clearly clearly RB 19613 2796 17 keep keep VB 19613 2796 18 in in IN 19613 2796 19 view view NN 19613 2796 20 the the DT 19613 2796 21 development development NN 19613 2796 22 of of IN 19613 2796 23 the the DT 19613 2796 24 cultus cultus NN 19613 2796 25 , , , 19613 2796 26 the the DT 19613 2796 27 new new JJ 19613 2796 28 conceptions conception NNS 19613 2796 29 of of IN 19613 2796 30 the the DT 19613 2796 31 value value NN 19613 2796 32 of of IN 19613 2796 33 ritual ritual NN 19613 2796 34 , , , 19613 2796 35 and and CC 19613 2796 36 the the DT 19613 2796 37 reference reference NN 19613 2796 38 of of IN 19613 2796 39 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 2796 40 usages usage NNS 19613 2796 41 to to IN 19613 2796 42 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2796 43 tradition tradition NN 19613 2796 44 ; ; , 19613 2796 45 for for CC 19613 2796 46 there there EX 19613 2796 47 was be VBD 19613 2796 48 plainly plainly RB 19613 2796 49 a a DT 19613 2796 50 remodelling remodelling NN 19613 2796 51 of of IN 19613 2796 52 the the DT 19613 2796 53 ritual ritual NN 19613 2796 54 in in IN 19613 2796 55 imitation imitation NN 19613 2796 56 of of IN 19613 2796 57 the the DT 19613 2796 58 ancient ancient JJ 19613 2796 59 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 2796 60 and and CC 19613 2796 61 of of IN 19613 2796 62 the the DT 19613 2796 63 heathen heathen NNP 19613 2796 64 sacrificial sacrificial NNP 19613 2796 65 system system NN 19613 2796 66 , , , 19613 2796 67 and and CC 19613 2796 68 this this DT 19613 2796 69 fact fact NN 19613 2796 70 is be VBZ 19613 2796 71 admitted admit VBN 19613 2796 72 by by IN 19613 2796 73 Protestant protestant JJ 19613 2796 74 scholars scholar NNS 19613 2796 75 of of IN 19613 2796 76 all all DT 19613 2796 77 parties party NNS 19613 2796 78 . . . 19613 2797 1 Ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 2797 2 and and CC 19613 2797 3 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2797 4 may may MD 19613 2797 5 indeed indeed RB 19613 2797 6 be be VB 19613 2797 7 at at IN 19613 2797 8 variance variance NN 19613 2797 9 , , , 19613 2797 10 for for IN 19613 2797 11 the the DT 19613 2797 12 latter latter JJ 19613 2797 13 may may MD 19613 2797 14 lag lag VB 19613 2797 15 behind behind IN 19613 2797 16 the the DT 19613 2797 17 former former JJ 19613 2797 18 and and CC 19613 2797 19 vice vice NN 19613 2797 20 versa versa RB 19613 2797 21 , , , 19613 2797 22 but but CC 19613 2797 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2797 24 are be VBP 19613 2797 25 never never RB 19613 2797 26 subject subject JJ 19613 2797 27 to to IN 19613 2797 28 entirely entirely RB 19613 2797 29 different different JJ 19613 2797 30 conditions condition NNS 19613 2797 31 . . . 19613 2798 1 III iii CD 19613 2798 2 . . . 19613 2799 1 MEANS mean NNS 19613 2799 2 OF of IN 19613 2799 3 GRACE GRACE NNP 19613 2799 4 , , , 19613 2799 5 BAPTISM BAPTISM NNP 19613 2799 6 , , , 19613 2799 7 and and CC 19613 2799 8 EUCHARIST EUCHARIST NNP 19613 2799 9 . . . 19613 2800 1 That that DT 19613 2800 2 which which WDT 19613 2800 3 the the DT 19613 2800 4 Western Western NNP 19613 2800 5 Church Church NNP 19613 2800 6 of of IN 19613 2800 7 post post JJ 19613 2800 8 - - JJ 19613 2800 9 Augustinian augustinian JJ 19613 2800 10 times time NNS 19613 2800 11 calls call VBZ 19613 2800 12 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 2800 13 in in IN 19613 2800 14 the the DT 19613 2800 15 specific specific JJ 19613 2800 16 sense sense NN 19613 2800 17 of of IN 19613 2800 18 the the DT 19613 2800 19 word word NN 19613 2800 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2800 21 means mean NNS 19613 2800 22 of of IN 19613 2800 23 grace grace NN 19613 2800 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2800 25 was be VBD 19613 2800 26 only only RB 19613 2800 27 possessed possess VBN 19613 2800 28 by by IN 19613 2800 29 the the DT 19613 2800 30 Church Church NNP 19613 2800 31 of of IN 19613 2800 32 the the DT 19613 2800 33 third third JJ 19613 2800 34 century century NN 19613 2800 35 in in IN 19613 2800 36 the the DT 19613 2800 37 form form NN 19613 2800 38 of of IN 19613 2800 39 baptism baptism NN 19613 2800 40 . . . 19613 2801 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2801 2 279 279 CD 19613 2801 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2801 4 In in IN 19613 2801 5 strict strict JJ 19613 2801 6 theory theory NN 19613 2801 7 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2801 8 still still RB 19613 2801 9 held hold VBD 19613 2801 10 that that IN 19613 2801 11 the the DT 19613 2801 12 grace grace NN 19613 2801 13 once once RB 19613 2801 14 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 2801 15 in in IN 19613 2801 16 this this DT 19613 2801 17 rite rite NN 19613 2801 18 could could MD 19613 2801 19 be be VB 19613 2801 20 conferred confer VBN 19613 2801 21 by by IN 19613 2801 22 no no DT 19613 2801 23 holy holy JJ 19613 2801 24 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 2801 25 of of IN 19613 2801 26 equal equal JJ 19613 2801 27 virtue virtue NN 19613 2801 28 , , , 19613 2801 29 that that RB 19613 2801 30 is is RB 19613 2801 31 , , , 19613 2801 32 by by IN 19613 2801 33 no no DT 19613 2801 34 fresh fresh JJ 19613 2801 35 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 2801 36 . . . 19613 2802 1 The the DT 19613 2802 2 baptised baptise VBN 19613 2802 3 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2802 4 has have VBZ 19613 2802 5 no no DT 19613 2802 6 means means NN 19613 2802 7 of of IN 19613 2802 8 grace grace NN 19613 2802 9 , , , 19613 2802 10 conferred confer VBN 19613 2802 11 by by IN 19613 2802 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2802 13 , , , 19613 2802 14 at at IN 19613 2802 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2802 16 disposal disposal NN 19613 2802 17 , , , 19613 2802 18 but but CC 19613 2802 19 has have VBZ 19613 2802 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2802 21 law law NN 19613 2802 22 to to TO 19613 2802 23 fulfil fulfil VB 19613 2802 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2802 25 see see VB 19613 2802 26 , , , 19613 2802 27 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 2802 28 , , , 19613 2802 29 Iren Iren NNP 19613 2802 30 . . . 19613 2803 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2803 2 . . . 19613 2804 1 27 27 CD 19613 2804 2 . . . 19613 2805 1 2 2 LS 19613 2805 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2805 3 . . . 19613 2806 1 But but CC 19613 2806 2 , , , 19613 2806 3 as as RB 19613 2806 4 soon soon RB 19613 2806 5 as as IN 19613 2806 6 the the DT 19613 2806 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2806 8 began begin VBD 19613 2806 9 to to TO 19613 2806 10 absolve absolve VB 19613 2806 11 mortal mortal JJ 19613 2806 12 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2806 13 , , , 19613 2806 14 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2806 15 practically practically RB 19613 2806 16 possessed possess VBD 19613 2806 17 in in IN 19613 2806 18 absolution absolution NN 19613 2806 19 a a DT 19613 2806 20 real real JJ 19613 2806 21 means mean NNS 19613 2806 22 of of IN 19613 2806 23 grace grace NN 19613 2806 24 that that WDT 19613 2806 25 was be VBD 19613 2806 26 equally equally RB 19613 2806 27 effective effective JJ 19613 2806 28 with with IN 19613 2806 29 baptism baptism NN 19613 2806 30 from from IN 19613 2806 31 the the DT 19613 2806 32 moment moment NN 19613 2806 33 that that IN 19613 2806 34 this this DT 19613 2806 35 remission remission NN 19613 2806 36 became become VBD 19613 2806 37 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 2806 38 in in IN 19613 2806 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2806 40 application application NN 19613 2806 41 . . . 19613 2807 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2807 2 280 280 CD 19613 2807 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2807 4 The the DT 19613 2807 5 notions notion NNS 19613 2807 6 as as IN 19613 2807 7 to to IN 19613 2807 8 this this DT 19613 2807 9 means means NN 19613 2807 10 of of IN 19613 2807 11 grace grace NN 19613 2807 12 , , , 19613 2807 13 however however RB 19613 2807 14 , , , 19613 2807 15 continued continue VBD 19613 2807 16 quite quite RB 19613 2807 17 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 2807 18 in in IN 19613 2807 19 so so RB 19613 2807 20 far far RB 19613 2807 21 as as IN 19613 2807 22 the the DT 19613 2807 23 thought thought NN 19613 2807 24 of of IN 19613 2807 25 God God NNP 19613 2807 26 's 's POS 19613 2807 27 absolving absolve VBG 19613 2807 28 the the DT 19613 2807 29 sinner sinner NN 19613 2807 30 through through IN 19613 2807 31 the the DT 19613 2807 32 priest priest NN 19613 2807 33 was be VBD 19613 2807 34 qualified qualify VBN 19613 2807 35 by by IN 19613 2807 36 the the DT 19613 2807 37 other other JJ 19613 2807 38 theory theory NN 19613 2807 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2807 40 see see VB 19613 2807 41 above above RB 19613 2807 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2807 43 which which WDT 19613 2807 44 asserted assert VBD 19613 2807 45 that that DT 19613 2807 46 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2807 47 was be VBD 19613 2807 48 obtained obtain VBN 19613 2807 49 through through IN 19613 2807 50 the the DT 19613 2807 51 penitential penitential JJ 19613 2807 52 acts act NNS 19613 2807 53 of of IN 19613 2807 54 transgressors transgressor NNS 19613 2807 55 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2807 56 especially especially RB 19613 2807 57 baptism baptism NN 19613 2807 58 with with IN 19613 2807 59 blood blood NN 19613 2807 60 , , , 19613 2807 61 and and CC 19613 2807 62 next next RB 19613 2807 63 in in IN 19613 2807 64 importance importance NN 19613 2807 65 _ _ NNP 19613 2807 66 lamentationes lamentationes NNP 19613 2807 67 , , , 19613 2807 68 ieiunia ieiunia NNP 19613 2807 69 , , , 19613 2807 70 eleemosynæ eleemosynæ NNP 19613 2807 71 _ _ NNP 19613 2807 72 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2807 73 . . . 19613 2808 1 In in IN 19613 2808 2 the the DT 19613 2808 3 third third JJ 19613 2808 4 century century NN 19613 2808 5 there there EX 19613 2808 6 were be VBD 19613 2808 7 manifold manifold JJ 19613 2808 8 holy holy JJ 19613 2808 9 dispensations dispensation NNS 19613 2808 10 of of IN 19613 2808 11 grace grace NN 19613 2808 12 by by IN 19613 2808 13 the the DT 19613 2808 14 hands hand NNS 19613 2808 15 of of IN 19613 2808 16 priests priest NNS 19613 2808 17 ; ; : 19613 2808 18 but but CC 19613 2808 19 there there EX 19613 2808 20 was be VBD 19613 2808 21 still still RB 19613 2808 22 no no DT 19613 2808 23 theory theory NN 19613 2808 24 which which WDT 19613 2808 25 traced trace VBD 19613 2808 26 the the DT 19613 2808 27 means mean NNS 19613 2808 28 of of IN 19613 2808 29 grace grace NN 19613 2808 30 to to IN 19613 2808 31 the the DT 19613 2808 32 historical historical JJ 19613 2808 33 work work NN 19613 2808 34 of of IN 19613 2808 35 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2808 36 in in IN 19613 2808 37 the the DT 19613 2808 38 same same JJ 19613 2808 39 way way NN 19613 2808 40 that that WDT 19613 2808 41 the the DT 19613 2808 42 grace grace NN 19613 2808 43 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 2808 44 in in IN 19613 2808 45 baptism baptism NN 19613 2808 46 was be VBD 19613 2808 47 derived derive VBN 19613 2808 48 from from IN 19613 2808 49 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2808 50 . . . 19613 2809 1 From from IN 19613 2809 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2809 3 's 's POS 19613 2809 4 epistles epistle NNS 19613 2809 5 and and CC 19613 2809 6 the the DT 19613 2809 7 anti anti JJ 19613 2809 8 - - JJ 19613 2809 9 Novatian novatian JJ 19613 2809 10 sections section NNS 19613 2809 11 in in IN 19613 2809 12 the the DT 19613 2809 13 first first JJ 19613 2809 14 six six CD 19613 2809 15 books book NNS 19613 2809 16 of of IN 19613 2809 17 the the DT 19613 2809 18 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 2809 19 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 2809 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2809 21 indeed indeed RB 19613 2809 22 see see VBP 19613 2809 23 that that DT 19613 2809 24 appeal appeal NN 19613 2809 25 was be VBD 19613 2809 26 not not RB 19613 2809 27 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 2809 28 made make VBN 19613 2809 29 to to IN 19613 2809 30 the the DT 19613 2809 31 power power NN 19613 2809 32 of of IN 19613 2809 33 forgiving forgive VBG 19613 2809 34 sins sin NNS 19613 2809 35 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 2809 36 on on IN 19613 2809 37 the the DT 19613 2809 38 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2809 39 and and CC 19613 2809 40 to to IN 19613 2809 41 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2809 42 's 's POS 19613 2809 43 declaration declaration NN 19613 2809 44 that that IN 19613 2809 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2809 46 received receive VBD 19613 2809 47 sinners sinner NNS 19613 2809 48 ; ; : 19613 2809 49 but but CC 19613 2809 50 , , , 19613 2809 51 as as IN 19613 2809 52 the the DT 19613 2809 53 Church Church NNP 19613 2809 54 had have VBD 19613 2809 55 not not RB 19613 2809 56 made make VBN 19613 2809 57 up up RP 19613 2809 58 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2809 59 mind mind NN 19613 2809 60 to to TO 19613 2809 61 repeat repeat VB 19613 2809 62 baptism baptism NN 19613 2809 63 , , , 19613 2809 64 so so RB 19613 2809 65 also also RB 19613 2809 66 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2809 67 had have VBD 19613 2809 68 yet yet RB 19613 2809 69 no no DT 19613 2809 70 theory theory NN 19613 2809 71 that that IN 19613 2809 72 expressly expressly RB 19613 2809 73 and and CC 19613 2809 74 clearly clearly RB 19613 2809 75 supplemented supplement VBD 19613 2809 76 this this DT 19613 2809 77 rite rite NN 19613 2809 78 by by IN 19613 2809 79 a a DT 19613 2809 80 _ _ NNP 19613 2809 81 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 2809 82 absolutionis absolutionis NNP 19613 2809 83 _ _ NNP 19613 2809 84 . . . 19613 2810 1 In in IN 19613 2810 2 this this DT 19613 2810 3 respect respect NN 19613 2810 4 , , , 19613 2810 5 as as RB 19613 2810 6 well well RB 19613 2810 7 as as IN 19613 2810 8 in in IN 19613 2810 9 regard regard NN 19613 2810 10 to to IN 19613 2810 11 the the DT 19613 2810 12 _ _ NNP 19613 2810 13 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 2810 14 ordinis ordinis NNP 19613 2810 15 _ _ NNP 19613 2810 16 , , , 19613 2810 17 first first RB 19613 2810 18 instituted institute VBN 19613 2810 19 by by IN 19613 2810 20 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 2810 21 , , , 19613 2810 22 theory theory NN 19613 2810 23 remained remain VBD 19613 2810 24 far far RB 19613 2810 25 behind behind IN 19613 2810 26 practice practice NN 19613 2810 27 . . . 19613 2811 1 This this DT 19613 2811 2 was be VBD 19613 2811 3 by by IN 19613 2811 4 no no DT 19613 2811 5 means means NN 19613 2811 6 an an DT 19613 2811 7 advantage advantage NN 19613 2811 8 , , , 19613 2811 9 for for IN 19613 2811 10 , , , 19613 2811 11 as as IN 19613 2811 12 a a DT 19613 2811 13 matter matter NN 19613 2811 14 of of IN 19613 2811 15 fact fact NN 19613 2811 16 , , , 19613 2811 17 the the DT 19613 2811 18 whole whole JJ 19613 2811 19 religious religious JJ 19613 2811 20 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 2811 21 was be VBD 19613 2811 22 already already RB 19613 2811 23 regarded regard VBN 19613 2811 24 as as IN 19613 2811 25 a a DT 19613 2811 26 system system NN 19613 2811 27 of of IN 19613 2811 28 means mean NNS 19613 2811 29 of of IN 19613 2811 30 grace grace NN 19613 2811 31 . . . 19613 2812 1 The the DT 19613 2812 2 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 2812 3 of of IN 19613 2812 4 a a DT 19613 2812 5 personal personal JJ 19613 2812 6 , , , 19613 2812 7 living live VBG 19613 2812 8 connection connection NN 19613 2812 9 of of IN 19613 2812 10 the the DT 19613 2812 11 individual individual NN 19613 2812 12 with with IN 19613 2812 13 God God NNP 19613 2812 14 through through IN 19613 2812 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2812 16 had have VBD 19613 2812 17 already already RB 19613 2812 18 disappeared disappear VBN 19613 2812 19 , , , 19613 2812 20 and and CC 19613 2812 21 the the DT 19613 2812 22 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 2812 23 in in IN 19613 2812 24 setting set VBG 19613 2812 25 up up RP 19613 2812 26 new new JJ 19613 2812 27 means mean NNS 19613 2812 28 of of IN 19613 2812 29 grace grace NN 19613 2812 30 had have VBD 19613 2812 31 only only RB 19613 2812 32 the the DT 19613 2812 33 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 2812 34 result result NN 19613 2812 35 of of IN 19613 2812 36 increasing increase VBG 19613 2812 37 the the DT 19613 2812 38 significance significance NN 19613 2812 39 of of IN 19613 2812 40 human human JJ 19613 2812 41 acts act NNS 19613 2812 42 , , , 19613 2812 43 such such JJ 19613 2812 44 as as IN 19613 2812 45 offerings offering NNS 19613 2812 46 and and CC 19613 2812 47 satisfactions satisfaction NNS 19613 2812 48 , , , 19613 2812 49 to to IN 19613 2812 50 a a DT 19613 2812 51 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 2812 52 extent extent NN 19613 2812 53 . . . 19613 2813 1 Since since IN 19613 2813 2 the the DT 19613 2813 3 middle middle NN 19613 2813 4 of of IN 19613 2813 5 the the DT 19613 2813 6 second second JJ 19613 2813 7 century century NN 19613 2813 8 the the DT 19613 2813 9 notions notion NNS 19613 2813 10 of of IN 19613 2813 11 baptism[281 baptism[281 NNP 19613 2813 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2813 13 in in IN 19613 2813 14 the the DT 19613 2813 15 Church Church NNP 19613 2813 16 have have VBP 19613 2813 17 not not RB 19613 2813 18 essentially essentially RB 19613 2813 19 altered alter VBN 19613 2813 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2813 21 see see VB 19613 2813 22 Vol Vol NNP 19613 2813 23 . . . 19613 2814 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2814 2 p. p. NN 19613 2814 3 206 206 CD 19613 2814 4 ff ff NN 19613 2814 5 . . . 19613 2814 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2814 7 . . . 19613 2815 1 The the DT 19613 2815 2 result result NN 19613 2815 3 of of IN 19613 2815 4 baptism baptism NN 19613 2815 5 was be VBD 19613 2815 6 universally universally RB 19613 2815 7 considered consider VBN 19613 2815 8 to to TO 19613 2815 9 be be VB 19613 2815 10 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2815 11 of of IN 19613 2815 12 sins sin NNS 19613 2815 13 , , , 19613 2815 14 and and CC 19613 2815 15 this this DT 19613 2815 16 pardon pardon NN 19613 2815 17 was be VBD 19613 2815 18 supposed suppose VBN 19613 2815 19 to to TO 19613 2815 20 effect effect VB 19613 2815 21 an an DT 19613 2815 22 actual actual JJ 19613 2815 23 sinlessness sinlessness NN 19613 2815 24 which which WDT 19613 2815 25 now now RB 19613 2815 26 required require VBD 19613 2815 27 to to TO 19613 2815 28 be be VB 19613 2815 29 maintained maintain VBN 19613 2815 30 . . . 19613 2816 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2816 2 282 282 CD 19613 2816 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2816 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2816 5 frequently frequently RB 19613 2816 6 find find VBP 19613 2816 7 " " `` 19613 2816 8 deliverance deliverance NN 19613 2816 9 from from IN 19613 2816 10 death death NN 19613 2816 11 , , , 19613 2816 12 " " '' 19613 2816 13 " " `` 19613 2816 14 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 2816 15 of of IN 19613 2816 16 man man NN 19613 2816 17 , , , 19613 2816 18 " " '' 19613 2816 19 " " `` 19613 2816 20 restoration restoration NN 19613 2816 21 to to IN 19613 2816 22 the the DT 19613 2816 23 image image NN 19613 2816 24 of of IN 19613 2816 25 God God NNP 19613 2816 26 , , , 19613 2816 27 " " '' 19613 2816 28 and and CC 19613 2816 29 " " `` 19613 2816 30 obtaining obtain VBG 19613 2816 31 of of IN 19613 2816 32 the the DT 19613 2816 33 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2816 34 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2816 35 . . . 19613 2816 36 " " '' 19613 2817 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2817 2 " " `` 19613 2817 3 Absolutio absolutio NN 19613 2817 4 mortes morte NNS 19613 2817 5 , , , 19613 2817 6 " " '' 19613 2817 7 " " `` 19613 2817 8 regeneratio regeneratio NNP 19613 2817 9 hominis hominis NNP 19613 2817 10 , , , 19613 2817 11 " " '' 19613 2817 12 " " `` 19613 2817 13 restitutio restitutio VBZ 19613 2817 14 ad ad NN 19613 2817 15 similitudinem similitudinem NNP 19613 2817 16 dei dei NNP 19613 2817 17 " " '' 19613 2817 18 and and CC 19613 2817 19 " " `` 19613 2817 20 consecutio consecutio NNP 19613 2817 21 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 2817 22 sancti sancti NN 19613 2817 23 " " '' 19613 2817 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2817 25 named name VBN 19613 2817 26 along along IN 19613 2817 27 with with IN 19613 2817 28 the the DT 19613 2817 29 " " `` 19613 2817 30 remission remission NN 19613 2817 31 of of IN 19613 2817 32 sins sin NNS 19613 2817 33 " " '' 19613 2817 34 and and CC 19613 2817 35 " " `` 19613 2817 36 obtaining obtain VBG 19613 2817 37 of of IN 19613 2817 38 eternal eternal JJ 19613 2817 39 life life NN 19613 2817 40 " " '' 19613 2817 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2817 42 " " `` 19613 2817 43 remissio remissio NNP 19613 2817 44 delictorum delictorum NN 19613 2817 45 " " '' 19613 2817 46 and and CC 19613 2817 47 " " `` 19613 2817 48 consecutio consecutio VB 19613 2817 49 æternitatis æternitatis NN 19613 2817 50 " " '' 19613 2817 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2817 52 . . . 19613 2818 1 Examples example NNS 19613 2818 2 are be VBP 19613 2818 3 to to TO 19613 2818 4 be be VB 19613 2818 5 found find VBN 19613 2818 6 in in IN 19613 2818 7 Tertullian[283 tertullian[283 CD 19613 2818 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2818 9 adv adv NN 19613 2818 10 . . . 19613 2819 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 2819 2 . . . 19613 2820 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2821 1 28 28 CD 19613 2821 2 and and CC 19613 2821 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 2821 4 ; ; : 19613 2821 5 and and CC 19613 2821 6 Cyprian cyprian JJ 19613 2821 7 speaks speak VBZ 19613 2821 8 of of IN 19613 2821 9 the the DT 19613 2821 10 " " `` 19613 2821 11 bath bath NN 19613 2821 12 of of IN 19613 2821 13 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 2821 14 and and CC 19613 2821 15 sanctification sanctification NN 19613 2821 16 " " '' 19613 2821 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2821 18 " " '' 19613 2821 19 lavacrum lavacrum NNP 19613 2821 20 regenerationis regenerationis NNP 19613 2821 21 et et NNP 19613 2821 22 sanctificationis sanctificationis NNP 19613 2821 23 " " '' 19613 2821 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2821 25 . . . 19613 2822 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2822 2 , , , 19613 2822 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2822 4 pretty pretty RB 19613 2822 5 frequently frequently RB 19613 2822 6 find find VBP 19613 2822 7 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 19613 2822 8 passages passage NNS 19613 2822 9 where where WRB 19613 2822 10 , , , 19613 2822 11 on on IN 19613 2822 12 the the DT 19613 2822 13 strength strength NN 19613 2822 14 of of IN 19613 2822 15 New New NNP 19613 2822 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2822 17 texts text NNS 19613 2822 18 , , , 19613 2822 19 all all DT 19613 2822 20 possible possible JJ 19613 2822 21 blessings blessing NNS 19613 2822 22 are be VBP 19613 2822 23 associated associate VBN 19613 2822 24 with with IN 19613 2822 25 baptism baptism NN 19613 2822 26 . . . 19613 2823 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2823 2 284 284 CD 19613 2823 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2823 4 The the DT 19613 2823 5 constant constant JJ 19613 2823 6 additions addition NNS 19613 2823 7 to to IN 19613 2823 8 the the DT 19613 2823 9 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 2823 10 ritual ritual NN 19613 2823 11 , , , 19613 2823 12 a a DT 19613 2823 13 process process NN 19613 2823 14 which which WDT 19613 2823 15 had have VBD 19613 2823 16 begun begin VBN 19613 2823 17 at at IN 19613 2823 18 a a DT 19613 2823 19 very very RB 19613 2823 20 early early JJ 19613 2823 21 period period NN 19613 2823 22 , , , 19613 2823 23 are be VBP 19613 2823 24 partly partly RB 19613 2823 25 due due JJ 19613 2823 26 to to IN 19613 2823 27 the the DT 19613 2823 28 intention intention NN 19613 2823 29 of of IN 19613 2823 30 symbolising symbolise VBG 19613 2823 31 these these DT 19613 2823 32 supposedly supposedly RB 19613 2823 33 manifold manifold JJ 19613 2823 34 virtues virtue NNS 19613 2823 35 of of IN 19613 2823 36 baptism,[285 baptism,[285 NNP 19613 2823 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2823 38 and and CC 19613 2823 39 partly partly RB 19613 2823 40 owe owe VBP 19613 2823 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2823 42 origin origin NN 19613 2823 43 to to IN 19613 2823 44 the the DT 19613 2823 45 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 2823 46 to to TO 19613 2823 47 provide provide VB 19613 2823 48 the the DT 19613 2823 49 great great JJ 19613 2823 50 mystery mystery NN 19613 2823 51 with with IN 19613 2823 52 fit fit JJ 19613 2823 53 accompaniments accompaniment NNS 19613 2823 54 . . . 19613 2824 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2824 2 286 286 CD 19613 2824 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2824 4 As as IN 19613 2824 5 yet yet RB 19613 2824 6 the the DT 19613 2824 7 separate separate JJ 19613 2824 8 acts act NNS 19613 2824 9 can can MD 19613 2824 10 hardly hardly RB 19613 2824 11 be be VB 19613 2824 12 proved prove VBN 19613 2824 13 to to TO 19613 2824 14 have have VB 19613 2824 15 an an DT 19613 2824 16 independent independent JJ 19613 2824 17 signification signification NN 19613 2824 18 . . . 19613 2825 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2825 2 287 287 CD 19613 2825 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2825 4 The the DT 19613 2825 5 water water NN 19613 2825 6 was be VBD 19613 2825 7 regarded regard VBN 19613 2825 8 both both DT 19613 2825 9 as as IN 19613 2825 10 the the DT 19613 2825 11 symbol symbol NN 19613 2825 12 of of IN 19613 2825 13 the the DT 19613 2825 14 purification purification NN 19613 2825 15 of of IN 19613 2825 16 the the DT 19613 2825 17 soul soul NN 19613 2825 18 and and CC 19613 2825 19 as as IN 19613 2825 20 an an DT 19613 2825 21 efficacious efficacious JJ 19613 2825 22 , , , 19613 2825 23 holy holy JJ 19613 2825 24 medium medium NN 19613 2825 25 of of IN 19613 2825 26 the the DT 19613 2825 27 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2825 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2825 29 in in IN 19613 2825 30 accordance accordance NN 19613 2825 31 with with IN 19613 2825 32 Gen. Gen. NNP 19613 2826 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2827 1 2 2 LS 19613 2827 2 ; ; : 19613 2827 3 water water NN 19613 2827 4 and and CC 19613 2827 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2827 6 are be VBP 19613 2827 7 associated associate VBN 19613 2827 8 with with IN 19613 2827 9 each each DT 19613 2827 10 other other JJ 19613 2827 11 , , , 19613 2827 12 especially especially RB 19613 2827 13 in in IN 19613 2827 14 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2827 15 's 's POS 19613 2827 16 epistles epistle NNS 19613 2827 17 on on IN 19613 2827 18 baptism baptism NN 19613 2827 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2827 20 . . . 19613 2828 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2828 2 who who WP 19613 2828 3 asserted assert VBD 19613 2828 4 the the DT 19613 2828 5 latter latter JJ 19613 2828 6 did do VBD 19613 2828 7 not not RB 19613 2828 8 thereby thereby RB 19613 2828 9 repudiate repudiate VB 19613 2828 10 the the DT 19613 2828 11 former former JJ 19613 2828 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2828 13 see see VB 19613 2828 14 Orig Orig NNP 19613 2828 15 . . . 19613 2829 1 in in IN 19613 2829 2 Joann Joann NNP 19613 2829 3 . . . 19613 2830 1 Tom Tom NNP 19613 2830 2 . . . 19613 2831 1 VI VI NNP 19613 2831 2 . . . 19613 2832 1 17 17 CD 19613 2832 2 , , , 19613 2832 3 Opp Opp NNP 19613 2832 4 . . . 19613 2833 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2833 2 . . . 19613 2834 1 p. p. NN 19613 2835 1 133 133 LS 19613 2835 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2835 3 . . . 19613 2836 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2836 2 288 288 CD 19613 2836 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2836 4 Complete complete JJ 19613 2836 5 obscurity obscurity NN 19613 2836 6 prevails prevail VBZ 19613 2836 7 as as IN 19613 2836 8 to to IN 19613 2836 9 the the DT 19613 2836 10 Church Church NNP 19613 2836 11 's 's POS 19613 2836 12 adoption adoption NN 19613 2836 13 of of IN 19613 2836 14 the the DT 19613 2836 15 practice practice NN 19613 2836 16 of of IN 19613 2836 17 child child NN 19613 2836 18 baptism baptism NN 19613 2836 19 , , , 19613 2836 20 which which WDT 19613 2836 21 , , , 19613 2836 22 though though IN 19613 2836 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2836 24 owes owe VBZ 19613 2836 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2836 26 origin origin NN 19613 2836 27 to to IN 19613 2836 28 the the DT 19613 2836 29 idea idea NN 19613 2836 30 of of IN 19613 2836 31 this this DT 19613 2836 32 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 2836 33 being be VBG 19613 2836 34 indispensable indispensable JJ 19613 2836 35 to to IN 19613 2836 36 salvation salvation NN 19613 2836 37 , , , 19613 2836 38 is be VBZ 19613 2836 39 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 2836 40 a a DT 19613 2836 41 proof proof NN 19613 2836 42 that that IN 19613 2836 43 the the DT 19613 2836 44 superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 2836 45 view view NN 19613 2836 46 of of IN 19613 2836 47 baptism baptism NN 19613 2836 48 had have VBD 19613 2836 49 increased increase VBN 19613 2836 50 . . . 19613 2837 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2837 2 289 289 CD 19613 2837 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2837 4 In in IN 19613 2837 5 the the DT 19613 2837 6 time time NN 19613 2837 7 of of IN 19613 2837 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2837 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2837 10 II II NNP 19613 2837 11 . . . 19613 2838 1 22 22 CD 19613 2838 2 . . . 19613 2839 1 4 4 LS 19613 2839 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2839 3 and and CC 19613 2839 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2839 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2839 6 de de FW 19613 2839 7 bapt bapt NNP 19613 2839 8 . . . 19613 2840 1 18 18 LS 19613 2840 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2840 3 child child NN 19613 2840 4 baptism baptism NN 19613 2840 5 had have VBD 19613 2840 6 already already RB 19613 2840 7 become become VBN 19613 2840 8 very very RB 19613 2840 9 general general JJ 19613 2840 10 and and CC 19613 2840 11 was be VBD 19613 2840 12 founded found VBN 19613 2840 13 on on IN 19613 2840 14 Matt Matt NNP 19613 2840 15 . . . 19613 2841 1 XIX XIX NNP 19613 2841 2 . . . 19613 2842 1 14 14 CD 19613 2842 2 . . . 19613 2843 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2843 2 have have VBP 19613 2843 3 no no DT 19613 2843 4 testimony testimony NN 19613 2843 5 regarding regard VBG 19613 2843 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2843 7 from from IN 19613 2843 8 earlier early JJR 19613 2843 9 times time NNS 19613 2843 10 ; ; : 19613 2843 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2843 12 of of IN 19613 2843 13 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2843 14 does do VBZ 19613 2843 15 not not RB 19613 2843 16 yet yet RB 19613 2843 17 assume assume VB 19613 2843 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2843 19 . . . 19613 2844 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2844 2 argued argue VBD 19613 2844 3 against against IN 19613 2844 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2844 5 not not RB 19613 2844 6 only only RB 19613 2844 7 because because IN 19613 2844 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2844 9 regarded regard VBD 19613 2844 10 conscious conscious JJ 19613 2844 11 faith faith NN 19613 2844 12 as as IN 19613 2844 13 a a DT 19613 2844 14 needful needful JJ 19613 2844 15 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 2844 16 condition condition NN 19613 2844 17 , , , 19613 2844 18 but but CC 19613 2844 19 also also RB 19613 2844 20 because because IN 19613 2844 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2844 22 thought think VBD 19613 2844 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2844 24 advisable advisable JJ 19613 2844 25 to to TO 19613 2844 26 delay delay VB 19613 2844 27 baptism baptism NN 19613 2844 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2844 29 cunctatio cunctatio NNP 19613 2844 30 baptismi baptismi NNP 19613 2844 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2844 32 on on IN 19613 2844 33 account account NN 19613 2844 34 of of IN 19613 2844 35 the the DT 19613 2844 36 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 2844 37 involved involve VBN 19613 2844 38 in in IN 19613 2844 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2844 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2844 41 pondus pondus NNP 19613 2844 42 baptismi baptismi NNP 19613 2844 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2844 44 . . . 19613 2845 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2845 2 says say VBZ 19613 2845 3 : : : 19613 2845 4 " " `` 19613 2845 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2845 6 is be VBZ 19613 2845 7 more more RBR 19613 2845 8 advantageous advantageous JJ 19613 2845 9 to to TO 19613 2845 10 delay delay VB 19613 2845 11 baptism baptism NN 19613 2845 12 , , , 19613 2845 13 especially especially RB 19613 2845 14 in in IN 19613 2845 15 the the DT 19613 2845 16 case case NN 19613 2845 17 of of IN 19613 2845 18 little little JJ 19613 2845 19 children child NNS 19613 2845 20 . . . 19613 2846 1 For for IN 19613 2846 2 why why WRB 19613 2846 3 is be VBZ 19613 2846 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2846 5 necessary necessary JJ 19613 2846 6 for for IN 19613 2846 7 the the DT 19613 2846 8 sponsors sponsor NNS 19613 2846 9 " " '' 19613 2846 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2846 11 this this DT 19613 2846 12 is be VBZ 19613 2846 13 the the DT 19613 2846 14 first first JJ 19613 2846 15 mention mention NN 19613 2846 16 of of IN 19613 2846 17 " " `` 19613 2846 18 godparents godparent NNS 19613 2846 19 " " '' 19613 2846 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2846 21 " " '' 19613 2846 22 also also RB 19613 2846 23 to to TO 19613 2846 24 be be VB 19613 2846 25 thrust thrust VBN 19613 2846 26 into into IN 19613 2846 27 danger danger NN 19613 2846 28 ? ? . 19613 2846 29 ... ... . 19613 2847 1 let let VB 19613 2847 2 the the DT 19613 2847 3 little little JJ 19613 2847 4 ones one NNS 19613 2847 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 2847 6 come come VBP 19613 2847 7 when when WRB 19613 2847 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 9 are be VBP 19613 2847 10 growing grow VBG 19613 2847 11 up up RP 19613 2847 12 ; ; , 19613 2847 13 let let VB 19613 2847 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 15 come come VB 19613 2847 16 when when WRB 19613 2847 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 18 are be VBP 19613 2847 19 learning learn VBG 19613 2847 20 , , , 19613 2847 21 when when WRB 19613 2847 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 23 are be VBP 19613 2847 24 taught teach VBN 19613 2847 25 where where WRB 19613 2847 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 27 are be VBP 19613 2847 28 coming come VBG 19613 2847 29 to to TO 19613 2847 30 ; ; : 19613 2847 31 let let VB 19613 2847 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 33 become become VB 19613 2847 34 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2847 35 when when WRB 19613 2847 36 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2847 37 are be VBP 19613 2847 38 able able JJ 19613 2847 39 to to TO 19613 2847 40 know know VB 19613 2847 41 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2847 42 . . . 19613 2848 1 Why why WRB 19613 2848 2 does do VBZ 19613 2848 3 an an DT 19613 2848 4 age age NN 19613 2848 5 of of IN 19613 2848 6 innocence innocence NN 19613 2848 7 hasten hasten VBN 19613 2848 8 to to IN 19613 2848 9 the the DT 19613 2848 10 remission remission NN 19613 2848 11 of of IN 19613 2848 12 sins sin NNS 19613 2848 13 ? ? . 19613 2849 1 People People NNS 19613 2849 2 will will MD 19613 2849 3 act act VB 19613 2849 4 more more RBR 19613 2849 5 cautiously cautiously RB 19613 2849 6 in in IN 19613 2849 7 worldly worldly JJ 19613 2849 8 affairs affair NNS 19613 2849 9 , , , 19613 2849 10 so so IN 19613 2849 11 that that IN 19613 2849 12 one one NN 19613 2849 13 who who WP 19613 2849 14 is be VBZ 19613 2849 15 not not RB 19613 2849 16 trusted trust VBN 19613 2849 17 with with IN 19613 2849 18 earthly earthly JJ 19613 2849 19 things thing NNS 19613 2849 20 is be VBZ 19613 2849 21 trusted trust VBN 19613 2849 22 with with IN 19613 2849 23 divine divine JJ 19613 2849 24 . . . 19613 2850 1 Whoever whoever WP 19613 2850 2 understands understand VBZ 19613 2850 3 the the DT 19613 2850 4 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 2850 5 of of IN 19613 2850 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 2850 7 will will MD 19613 2850 8 fear fear VB 19613 2850 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2850 10 attainment attainment JJ 19613 2850 11 more more JJR 19613 2850 12 than than IN 19613 2850 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2850 14 delay delay NN 19613 2850 15 . . . 19613 2851 1 " " `` 19613 2851 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2851 3 290 290 CD 19613 2851 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2851 5 To to IN 19613 2851 6 all all DT 19613 2851 7 appearance appearance VB 19613 2851 8 the the DT 19613 2851 9 practice practice NN 19613 2851 10 of of IN 19613 2851 11 immediately immediately RB 19613 2851 12 baptising baptise VBG 19613 2851 13 the the DT 19613 2851 14 children child NNS 19613 2851 15 of of IN 19613 2851 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 2851 17 families family NNS 19613 2851 18 was be VBD 19613 2851 19 universally universally RB 19613 2851 20 adopted adopt VBN 19613 2851 21 in in IN 19613 2851 22 the the DT 19613 2851 23 Church Church NNP 19613 2851 24 in in IN 19613 2851 25 the the DT 19613 2851 26 course course NN 19613 2851 27 of of IN 19613 2851 28 the the DT 19613 2851 29 third third JJ 19613 2851 30 century century NN 19613 2851 31 . . . 19613 2852 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2852 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2852 3 , , , 19613 2852 4 Comment Comment NNP 19613 2852 5 , , , 19613 2852 6 in in IN 19613 2852 7 ep ep NNP 19613 2852 8 . . . 19613 2853 1 ad ad NN 19613 2853 2 Rom rom NN 19613 2853 3 . . . 19613 2854 1 V. V. NNP 19613 2854 2 9 9 CD 19613 2854 3 , , , 19613 2854 4 Opp Opp NNP 19613 2854 5 . . . 19613 2855 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2855 2 . . . 19613 2856 1 p. p. NN 19613 2856 2 565 565 CD 19613 2856 3 , , , 19613 2856 4 declared declare VBN 19613 2856 5 child child NN 19613 2856 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 2856 7 to to TO 19613 2856 8 be be VB 19613 2856 9 a a DT 19613 2856 10 custom custom NN 19613 2856 11 handed hand VBN 19613 2856 12 down down RP 19613 2856 13 by by IN 19613 2856 14 the the DT 19613 2856 15 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2856 16 . . . 19613 2856 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2857 1 Grown grow VBN 19613 2857 2 up up RP 19613 2857 3 people people NNS 19613 2857 4 , , , 19613 2857 5 on on IN 19613 2857 6 the the DT 19613 2857 7 other other JJ 19613 2857 8 hand hand NN 19613 2857 9 , , , 19613 2857 10 frequently frequently RB 19613 2857 11 postponed postpone VBD 19613 2857 12 baptism baptism NN 19613 2857 13 , , , 19613 2857 14 but but CC 19613 2857 15 this this DT 19613 2857 16 habit habit NN 19613 2857 17 was be VBD 19613 2857 18 disapproved disapprove VBN 19613 2857 19 . . . 19613 2858 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2858 2 291 291 CD 19613 2858 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2858 4 The the DT 19613 2858 5 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2858 6 's 's POS 19613 2858 7 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2858 8 was be VBD 19613 2858 9 not not RB 19613 2858 10 only only RB 19613 2858 11 regarded regard VBN 19613 2858 12 as as IN 19613 2858 13 a a DT 19613 2858 14 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2858 15 , , , 19613 2858 16 but but CC 19613 2858 17 also also RB 19613 2858 18 as as IN 19613 2858 19 a a DT 19613 2858 20 divine divine JJ 19613 2858 21 gift gift NN 19613 2858 22 . . . 19613 2859 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2859 2 292 292 CD 19613 2859 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2859 4 The the DT 19613 2859 5 effects effect NNS 19613 2859 6 of of IN 19613 2859 7 this this DT 19613 2859 8 gift gift NN 19613 2859 9 were be VBD 19613 2859 10 not not RB 19613 2859 11 theoretically theoretically RB 19613 2859 12 fixed fix VBN 19613 2859 13 , , , 19613 2859 14 because because IN 19613 2859 15 these these DT 19613 2859 16 were be VBD 19613 2859 17 excluded exclude VBN 19613 2859 18 by by IN 19613 2859 19 the the DT 19613 2859 20 strict strict JJ 19613 2859 21 scheme[293 scheme[293 NN 19613 2859 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2859 23 of of IN 19613 2859 24 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 2859 25 grace grace NN 19613 2859 26 and and CC 19613 2859 27 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 2859 28 obligation obligation NN 19613 2859 29 . . . 19613 2860 1 But but CC 19613 2860 2 in in IN 19613 2860 3 practice practice NN 19613 2860 4 Christians christian NNS 19613 2860 5 more more RBR 19613 2860 6 and and CC 19613 2860 7 more more RBR 19613 2860 8 assumed assume VBD 19613 2860 9 a a DT 19613 2860 10 real real JJ 19613 2860 11 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 2860 12 of of IN 19613 2860 13 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 2860 14 gifts gift NNS 19613 2860 15 in in IN 19613 2860 16 the the DT 19613 2860 17 holy holy JJ 19613 2860 18 food food NN 19613 2860 19 , , , 19613 2860 20 and and CC 19613 2860 21 gave give VBD 19613 2860 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2860 23 over over RP 19613 2860 24 to to IN 19613 2860 25 superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 2860 26 theories theory NNS 19613 2860 27 . . . 19613 2861 1 This this DT 19613 2861 2 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 2861 3 was be VBD 19613 2861 4 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 2861 5 regarded regard VBN 19613 2861 6 as as IN 19613 2861 7 a a DT 19613 2861 8 spiritual spiritual NN 19613 2861 9 and and CC 19613 2861 10 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 2861 11 as as IN 19613 2861 12 a a DT 19613 2861 13 bodily bodily RB 19613 2861 14 self self NN 19613 2861 15 - - HYPH 19613 2861 16 communication communication NN 19613 2861 17 of of IN 19613 2861 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2861 19 , , , 19613 2861 20 that that RB 19613 2861 21 is is RB 19613 2861 22 , , , 19613 2861 23 as as IN 19613 2861 24 a a DT 19613 2861 25 miraculous miraculous JJ 19613 2861 26 implanting implanting NN 19613 2861 27 of of IN 19613 2861 28 divine divine JJ 19613 2861 29 life life NN 19613 2861 30 . . . 19613 2862 1 Here here RB 19613 2862 2 ethical ethical JJ 19613 2862 3 and and CC 19613 2862 4 physical physical JJ 19613 2862 5 , , , 19613 2862 6 and and CC 19613 2862 7 again again RB 19613 2862 8 ethical ethical JJ 19613 2862 9 and and CC 19613 2862 10 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 2862 11 features feature NNS 19613 2862 12 were be VBD 19613 2862 13 intermixed intermix VBN 19613 2862 14 with with IN 19613 2862 15 each each DT 19613 2862 16 other other JJ 19613 2862 17 . . . 19613 2863 1 The the DT 19613 2863 2 utterances utterance NNS 19613 2863 3 of of IN 19613 2863 4 the the DT 19613 2863 5 Fathers father NNS 19613 2863 6 to to TO 19613 2863 7 which which WDT 19613 2863 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2863 9 have have VBP 19613 2863 10 access access NN 19613 2863 11 do do VBP 19613 2863 12 not not RB 19613 2863 13 allow allow VB 19613 2863 14 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2863 15 to to TO 19613 2863 16 classify classify VB 19613 2863 17 these these DT 19613 2863 18 elements element NNS 19613 2863 19 here here RB 19613 2863 20 ; ; : 19613 2863 21 for for IN 19613 2863 22 to to IN 19613 2863 23 all all DT 19613 2863 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 2863 25 not not RB 19613 2863 26 a a DT 19613 2863 27 single single JJ 19613 2863 28 one one NN 19613 2863 29 clearly clearly RB 19613 2863 30 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 2863 31 between between IN 19613 2863 32 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2863 33 and and CC 19613 2863 34 bodily bodily JJ 19613 2863 35 , , , 19613 2863 36 or or CC 19613 2863 37 ethical ethical JJ 19613 2863 38 and and CC 19613 2863 39 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 2863 40 effects effect NNS 19613 2863 41 unless unless IN 19613 2863 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2863 43 was be VBD 19613 2863 44 in in IN 19613 2863 45 principle principle NN 19613 2863 46 a a DT 19613 2863 47 spiritualist spiritualist NN 19613 2863 48 . . . 19613 2864 1 But but CC 19613 2864 2 even even RB 19613 2864 3 a a DT 19613 2864 4 writer writer NN 19613 2864 5 of of IN 19613 2864 6 this this DT 19613 2864 7 kind kind NN 19613 2864 8 had have VBD 19613 2864 9 quite quite RB 19613 2864 10 as as RB 19613 2864 11 superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 2864 12 an an DT 19613 2864 13 idea idea NN 19613 2864 14 of of IN 19613 2864 15 the the DT 19613 2864 16 holy holy JJ 19613 2864 17 elements element NNS 19613 2864 18 as as IN 19613 2864 19 the the DT 19613 2864 20 rest rest NN 19613 2864 21 . . . 19613 2865 1 Thus thus RB 19613 2865 2 the the DT 19613 2865 3 holy holy NNP 19613 2865 4 meal meal NN 19613 2865 5 was be VBD 19613 2865 6 extolled extoll VBN 19613 2865 7 as as IN 19613 2865 8 the the DT 19613 2865 9 communication communication NN 19613 2865 10 of of IN 19613 2865 11 incorruption incorruption NN 19613 2865 12 , , , 19613 2865 13 as as IN 19613 2865 14 a a DT 19613 2865 15 pledge pledge NN 19613 2865 16 of of IN 19613 2865 17 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 2865 18 , , , 19613 2865 19 as as IN 19613 2865 20 a a DT 19613 2865 21 medium medium NN 19613 2865 22 of of IN 19613 2865 23 the the DT 19613 2865 24 union union NN 19613 2865 25 of of IN 19613 2865 26 the the DT 19613 2865 27 flesh flesh NN 19613 2865 28 with with IN 19613 2865 29 the the DT 19613 2865 30 Holy Holy NNP 19613 2865 31 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2865 32 ; ; : 19613 2865 33 and and CC 19613 2865 34 again again RB 19613 2865 35 as as IN 19613 2865 36 food food NN 19613 2865 37 of of IN 19613 2865 38 the the DT 19613 2865 39 soul soul NN 19613 2865 40 , , , 19613 2865 41 as as IN 19613 2865 42 the the DT 19613 2865 43 bearer bearer NN 19613 2865 44 of of IN 19613 2865 45 the the DT 19613 2865 46 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 2865 47 of of IN 19613 2865 48 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2865 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2865 50 the the DT 19613 2865 51 Logos Logos NNP 19613 2865 52 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2865 53 , , , 19613 2865 54 as as IN 19613 2865 55 the the DT 19613 2865 56 means mean NNS 19613 2865 57 of of IN 19613 2865 58 strengthening strengthen VBG 19613 2865 59 faith faith NN 19613 2865 60 and and CC 19613 2865 61 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 2865 62 , , , 19613 2865 63 as as IN 19613 2865 64 a a DT 19613 2865 65 sanctifying sanctifying NN 19613 2865 66 of of IN 19613 2865 67 the the DT 19613 2865 68 whole whole JJ 19613 2865 69 personality personality NN 19613 2865 70 . . . 19613 2866 1 The the DT 19613 2866 2 thought thought NN 19613 2866 3 of of IN 19613 2866 4 the the DT 19613 2866 5 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 2866 6 of of IN 19613 2866 7 sins sin NNS 19613 2866 8 fell fall VBD 19613 2866 9 quite quite RB 19613 2866 10 into into IN 19613 2866 11 the the DT 19613 2866 12 background background NN 19613 2866 13 . . . 19613 2867 1 This this DT 19613 2867 2 ever ever RB 19613 2867 3 changing change VBG 19613 2867 4 conception conception NN 19613 2867 5 , , , 19613 2867 6 as as IN 19613 2867 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2867 8 seems seem VBZ 19613 2867 9 to to IN 19613 2867 10 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2867 11 , , , 19613 2867 12 of of IN 19613 2867 13 the the DT 19613 2867 14 effects effect NNS 19613 2867 15 of of IN 19613 2867 16 partaking partaking NN 19613 2867 17 of of IN 19613 2867 18 the the DT 19613 2867 19 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2867 20 's 's POS 19613 2867 21 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2867 22 had have VBD 19613 2867 23 also also RB 19613 2867 24 a a DT 19613 2867 25 parallel parallel NN 19613 2867 26 in in IN 19613 2867 27 the the DT 19613 2867 28 notions notion NNS 19613 2867 29 as as IN 19613 2867 30 to to IN 19613 2867 31 the the DT 19613 2867 32 relation relation NN 19613 2867 33 between between IN 19613 2867 34 the the DT 19613 2867 35 visible visible JJ 19613 2867 36 elements element NNS 19613 2867 37 and and CC 19613 2867 38 the the DT 19613 2867 39 body body NN 19613 2867 40 of of IN 19613 2867 41 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2867 42 . . . 19613 2868 1 So so RB 19613 2868 2 far far RB 19613 2868 3 as as IN 19613 2868 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2868 5 are be VBP 19613 2868 6 able able JJ 19613 2868 7 to to TO 19613 2868 8 judge judge VB 19613 2868 9 no no DT 19613 2868 10 one one NN 19613 2868 11 felt feel VBD 19613 2868 12 that that IN 19613 2868 13 there there EX 19613 2868 14 was be VBD 19613 2868 15 a a DT 19613 2868 16 _ _ NNP 19613 2868 17 problem problem NN 19613 2868 18 _ _ NNP 19613 2868 19 here here RB 19613 2868 20 , , , 19613 2868 21 no no DT 19613 2868 22 one one NN 19613 2868 23 enquired enquire VBD 19613 2868 24 whether whether IN 19613 2868 25 this this DT 19613 2868 26 relation relation NN 19613 2868 27 was be VBD 19613 2868 28 realistic realistic JJ 19613 2868 29 or or CC 19613 2868 30 symbolical symbolical JJ 19613 2868 31 . . . 19613 2869 1 The the DT 19613 2869 2 symbol symbol NN 19613 2869 3 is be VBZ 19613 2869 4 the the DT 19613 2869 5 mystery mystery NN 19613 2869 6 and and CC 19613 2869 7 the the DT 19613 2869 8 mystery mystery NN 19613 2869 9 was be VBD 19613 2869 10 not not RB 19613 2869 11 conceivable conceivable JJ 19613 2869 12 without without IN 19613 2869 13 a a DT 19613 2869 14 symbol symbol NN 19613 2869 15 . . . 19613 2870 1 What what WP 19613 2870 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2870 3 now now RB 19613 2870 4 - - : 19613 2870 5 a a DT 19613 2870 6 - - HYPH 19613 2870 7 days day NNS 19613 2870 8 understand understand VB 19613 2870 9 by by IN 19613 2870 10 " " `` 19613 2870 11 symbol symbol NN 19613 2870 12 " " '' 19613 2870 13 is be VBZ 19613 2870 14 a a DT 19613 2870 15 thing thing NN 19613 2870 16 which which WDT 19613 2870 17 is be VBZ 19613 2870 18 not not RB 19613 2870 19 that that IN 19613 2870 20 which which WDT 19613 2870 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2870 22 represents represent VBZ 19613 2870 23 ; ; : 19613 2870 24 at at IN 19613 2870 25 that that DT 19613 2870 26 time time NN 19613 2870 27 " " `` 19613 2870 28 symbol symbol NN 19613 2870 29 " " '' 19613 2870 30 denoted denote VBD 19613 2870 31 a a DT 19613 2870 32 thing thing NN 19613 2870 33 which which WDT 19613 2870 34 , , , 19613 2870 35 in in IN 19613 2870 36 some some DT 19613 2870 37 kind kind NN 19613 2870 38 of of IN 19613 2870 39 way way NN 19613 2870 40 , , , 19613 2870 41 really really RB 19613 2870 42 is be VBZ 19613 2870 43 what what WP 19613 2870 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2870 45 signifies signify VBZ 19613 2870 46 ; ; : 19613 2870 47 but but CC 19613 2870 48 , , , 19613 2870 49 on on IN 19613 2870 50 the the DT 19613 2870 51 other other JJ 19613 2870 52 hand hand NN 19613 2870 53 , , , 19613 2870 54 according accord VBG 19613 2870 55 to to IN 19613 2870 56 the the DT 19613 2870 57 ideas idea NNS 19613 2870 58 of of IN 19613 2870 59 that that DT 19613 2870 60 period period NN 19613 2870 61 , , , 19613 2870 62 the the DT 19613 2870 63 really really RB 19613 2870 64 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 2870 65 element element NN 19613 2870 66 lay lie VBD 19613 2870 67 either either CC 19613 2870 68 in in IN 19613 2870 69 or or CC 19613 2870 70 behind behind IN 19613 2870 71 the the DT 19613 2870 72 visible visible JJ 19613 2870 73 form form NN 19613 2870 74 without without IN 19613 2870 75 being be VBG 19613 2870 76 identical identical JJ 19613 2870 77 with with IN 19613 2870 78 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2870 79 . . . 19613 2871 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 2871 2 the the DT 19613 2871 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 2871 4 of of IN 19613 2871 5 a a DT 19613 2871 6 symbolic symbolic JJ 19613 2871 7 and and CC 19613 2871 8 realistic realistic JJ 19613 2871 9 conception conception NN 19613 2871 10 of of IN 19613 2871 11 the the DT 19613 2871 12 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2871 13 is be VBZ 19613 2871 14 altogether altogether RB 19613 2871 15 to to TO 19613 2871 16 be be VB 19613 2871 17 rejected reject VBN 19613 2871 18 ; ; : 19613 2871 19 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2871 20 could could MD 19613 2871 21 more more RBR 19613 2871 22 rightly rightly RB 19613 2871 23 distinguish distinguish JJ 19613 2871 24 between between IN 19613 2871 25 materialistic materialistic JJ 19613 2871 26 , , , 19613 2871 27 dyophysite dyophysite JJ 19613 2871 28 , , , 19613 2871 29 and and CC 19613 2871 30 docetic docetic JJ 19613 2871 31 conceptions conception NNS 19613 2871 32 which which WDT 19613 2871 33 , , , 19613 2871 34 however however RB 19613 2871 35 , , , 19613 2871 36 are be VBP 19613 2871 37 not not RB 19613 2871 38 to to TO 19613 2871 39 be be VB 19613 2871 40 regarded regard VBN 19613 2871 41 as as IN 19613 2871 42 severally severally RB 19613 2871 43 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 2871 44 in in IN 19613 2871 45 the the DT 19613 2871 46 strict strict JJ 19613 2871 47 sense sense NN 19613 2871 48 . . . 19613 2872 1 In in IN 19613 2872 2 the the DT 19613 2872 3 popular popular JJ 19613 2872 4 idea idea NN 19613 2872 5 the the DT 19613 2872 6 consecrated consecrate VBN 19613 2872 7 elements element NNS 19613 2872 8 were be VBD 19613 2872 9 heavenly heavenly RB 19613 2872 10 fragments fragment NNS 19613 2872 11 of of IN 19613 2872 12 magical magical JJ 19613 2872 13 virtue virtue NN 19613 2872 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2872 15 see see VB 19613 2872 16 Cypr Cypr NNP 19613 2872 17 . . . 19613 2872 18 , , , 19613 2872 19 de de NNP 19613 2872 20 laps laps NNP 19613 2872 21 . . . 19613 2873 1 25 25 CD 19613 2873 2 ; ; : 19613 2873 3 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 2873 4 . . NNP 19613 2873 5 , , , 19613 2873 6 H. H. NNP 19613 2873 7 E. E. NNP 19613 2873 8 VI VI NNP 19613 2873 9 . . . 19613 2874 1 44 44 CD 19613 2874 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2874 3 . . . 19613 2875 1 With with IN 19613 2875 2 these these DT 19613 2875 3 the the DT 19613 2875 4 rank rank NN 19613 2875 5 and and CC 19613 2875 6 file file NN 19613 2875 7 of of IN 19613 2875 8 third third JJ 19613 2875 9 - - HYPH 19613 2875 10 century century NN 19613 2875 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2875 12 already already RB 19613 2875 13 connected connect VBD 19613 2875 14 many many JJ 19613 2875 15 superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 2875 16 notions notion NNS 19613 2875 17 which which WDT 19613 2875 18 the the DT 19613 2875 19 priests priest NNS 19613 2875 20 tolerated tolerate VBD 19613 2875 21 or or CC 19613 2875 22 shared share VBN 19613 2875 23 . . . 19613 2876 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2876 2 294 294 CD 19613 2876 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2876 4 The the DT 19613 2876 5 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 2876 6 Fathers father NNS 19613 2876 7 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 2876 8 that that IN 19613 2876 9 the the DT 19613 2876 10 consecrated consecrate VBN 19613 2876 11 food food NN 19613 2876 12 consisted consist VBD 19613 2876 13 of of IN 19613 2876 14 two two CD 19613 2876 15 things thing NNS 19613 2876 16 , , , 19613 2876 17 an an DT 19613 2876 18 earthly earthly JJ 19613 2876 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2876 20 the the DT 19613 2876 21 elements element NNS 19613 2876 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2876 23 and and CC 19613 2876 24 a a DT 19613 2876 25 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 2876 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2876 27 the the DT 19613 2876 28 real real JJ 19613 2876 29 body body NN 19613 2876 30 of of IN 19613 2876 31 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2876 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2876 33 . . . 19613 2877 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 2877 2 thus thus RB 19613 2877 3 saw see VBD 19613 2877 4 in in IN 19613 2877 5 the the DT 19613 2877 6 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 2877 7 a a DT 19613 2877 8 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 2877 9 of of IN 19613 2877 10 the the DT 19613 2877 11 union union NN 19613 2877 12 between between IN 19613 2877 13 spirit spirit NN 19613 2877 14 and and CC 19613 2877 15 flesh flesh NN 19613 2877 16 , , , 19613 2877 17 which which WDT 19613 2877 18 the the DT 19613 2877 19 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 2877 20 denied deny VBD 19613 2877 21 ; ; : 19613 2877 22 and and CC 19613 2877 23 a a DT 19613 2877 24 pledge pledge NN 19613 2877 25 of of IN 19613 2877 26 the the DT 19613 2877 27 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 2877 28 of of IN 19613 2877 29 the the DT 19613 2877 30 flesh flesh NN 19613 2877 31 nourished nourish VBN 19613 2877 32 by by IN 19613 2877 33 the the DT 19613 2877 34 blood blood NN 19613 2877 35 of of IN 19613 2877 36 the the DT 19613 2877 37 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2877 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2877 39 Justin Justin NNP 19613 2877 40 ; ; : 19613 2877 41 Iren Iren NNP 19613 2877 42 . . . 19613 2878 1 IV IV NNP 19613 2878 2 . . . 19613 2879 1 18 18 CD 19613 2879 2 . . . 19613 2880 1 4 4 CD 19613 2880 2 , , , 19613 2880 3 5 5 CD 19613 2880 4 ; ; : 19613 2880 5 V. V. NNP 19613 2880 6 2 2 CD 19613 2880 7 . . . 19613 2881 1 2 2 CD 19613 2881 2 , , , 19613 2881 3 3 3 CD 19613 2881 4 ; ; : 19613 2881 5 likewise likewise RB 19613 2881 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2881 7 who who WP 19613 2881 8 is be VBZ 19613 2881 9 erroneously erroneously RB 19613 2881 10 credited credit VBN 19613 2881 11 with with IN 19613 2881 12 a a DT 19613 2881 13 " " `` 19613 2881 14 symbolical symbolical JJ 19613 2881 15 " " '' 19613 2881 16 doctrine[295 doctrine[295 NN 19613 2881 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2881 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2881 19 . . . 19613 2882 1 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2882 2 and and CC 19613 2882 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2882 4 " " '' 19613 2882 5 spiritualise spiritualise NN 19613 2882 6 , , , 19613 2882 7 " " '' 19613 2882 8 because because IN 19613 2882 9 , , , 19613 2882 10 like like IN 19613 2882 11 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 2882 12 , , , 19613 2882 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2882 14 assign assign VBP 19613 2882 15 a a DT 19613 2882 16 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2882 17 significance significance NN 19613 2882 18 to to IN 19613 2882 19 the the DT 19613 2882 20 flesh flesh NN 19613 2882 21 and and CC 19613 2882 22 blood blood NN 19613 2882 23 of of IN 19613 2882 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2882 25 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2882 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2882 27 summary summary NN 19613 2882 28 of of IN 19613 2882 29 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 2882 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2882 31 . . . 19613 2883 1 To to TO 19613 2883 2 judge judge VB 19613 2883 3 from from IN 19613 2883 4 the the DT 19613 2883 5 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 2883 6 confused confuse VBN 19613 2883 7 passage passage NN 19613 2883 8 in in IN 19613 2883 9 Pæd pæd NN 19613 2883 10 . . . 19613 2884 1 II ii CD 19613 2884 2 . . . 19613 2885 1 2 2 LS 19613 2885 2 , , , 19613 2885 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2885 4 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 2885 5 a a DT 19613 2885 6 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2885 7 and and CC 19613 2885 8 a a DT 19613 2885 9 material material JJ 19613 2885 10 blood blood NN 19613 2885 11 of of IN 19613 2885 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2885 13 . . . 19613 2886 1 Finally finally RB 19613 2886 2 , , , 19613 2886 3 however however RB 19613 2886 4 , , , 19613 2886 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2886 6 sees see VBZ 19613 2886 7 in in IN 19613 2886 8 the the DT 19613 2886 9 Eucharist Eucharist NNP 19613 2886 10 the the DT 19613 2886 11 union union NN 19613 2886 12 of of IN 19613 2886 13 the the DT 19613 2886 14 divine divine JJ 19613 2886 15 Logos Logos NNP 19613 2886 16 with with IN 19613 2886 17 the the DT 19613 2886 18 human human JJ 19613 2886 19 spirit spirit NN 19613 2886 20 , , , 19613 2886 21 recognises recognise NNS 19613 2886 22 , , , 19613 2886 23 like like IN 19613 2886 24 Cyprian cyprian NN 19613 2886 25 at at IN 19613 2886 26 a a DT 19613 2886 27 later later JJ 19613 2886 28 period period NN 19613 2886 29 , , , 19613 2886 30 that that IN 19613 2886 31 the the DT 19613 2886 32 mixture mixture NN 19613 2886 33 of of IN 19613 2886 34 wine wine NN 19613 2886 35 with with IN 19613 2886 36 water water NN 19613 2886 37 in in IN 19613 2886 38 the the DT 19613 2886 39 symbol symbol NN 19613 2886 40 represents represent VBZ 19613 2886 41 the the DT 19613 2886 42 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2886 43 process process NN 19613 2886 44 , , , 19613 2886 45 and and CC 19613 2886 46 lastly lastly RB 19613 2886 47 does do VBZ 19613 2886 48 not not RB 19613 2886 49 fail fail VB 19613 2886 50 to to TO 19613 2886 51 attribute attribute VB 19613 2886 52 to to IN 19613 2886 53 the the DT 19613 2886 54 holy holy NNP 19613 2886 55 food food NNP 19613 2886 56 a a DT 19613 2886 57 relationship relationship NN 19613 2886 58 to to IN 19613 2886 59 the the DT 19613 2886 60 body body NN 19613 2886 61 . . . 19613 2887 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2887 2 296 296 CD 19613 2887 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2887 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2887 5 is be VBZ 19613 2887 6 true true JJ 19613 2887 7 that that IN 19613 2887 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2887 9 , , , 19613 2887 10 the the DT 19613 2887 11 great great JJ 19613 2887 12 mysteriosophist mysteriosophist NN 19613 2887 13 and and CC 19613 2887 14 theologian theologian NN 19613 2887 15 of of IN 19613 2887 16 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 2887 17 , , , 19613 2887 18 expressed express VBD 19613 2887 19 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2887 20 in in RP 19613 2887 21 plainly plainly RB 19613 2887 22 " " `` 19613 2887 23 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 19613 2887 24 " " '' 19613 2887 25 fashion fashion NN 19613 2887 26 ; ; : 19613 2887 27 but but CC 19613 2887 28 in in IN 19613 2887 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2887 30 eyes eye NNS 19613 2887 31 religious religious JJ 19613 2887 32 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 2887 33 and and CC 19613 2887 34 the the DT 19613 2887 35 whole whole JJ 19613 2887 36 person person NN 19613 2887 37 of of IN 19613 2887 38 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2887 39 lay lie VBD 19613 2887 40 in in IN 19613 2887 41 the the DT 19613 2887 42 province province NN 19613 2887 43 of of IN 19613 2887 44 the the DT 19613 2887 45 spirit spirit NNP 19613 2887 46 , , , 19613 2887 47 and and CC 19613 2887 48 therefore therefore RB 19613 2887 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2887 50 theory theory NN 19613 2887 51 of of IN 19613 2887 52 the the DT 19613 2887 53 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2887 54 is be VBZ 19613 2887 55 not not RB 19613 2887 56 " " `` 19613 2887 57 symbolical symbolical JJ 19613 2887 58 , , , 19613 2887 59 " " '' 19613 2887 60 but but CC 19613 2887 61 conformable conformable JJ 19613 2887 62 to to IN 19613 2887 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2887 64 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2887 65 of of IN 19613 2887 66 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2887 67 . . . 19613 2888 1 Besides besides RB 19613 2888 2 , , , 19613 2888 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2888 4 was be VBD 19613 2888 5 only only RB 19613 2888 6 able able JJ 19613 2888 7 to to TO 19613 2888 8 recognise recognise VB 19613 2888 9 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2888 10 aids aid NNS 19613 2888 11 in in IN 19613 2888 12 the the DT 19613 2888 13 sphere sphere NN 19613 2888 14 of of IN 19613 2888 15 the the DT 19613 2888 16 intellect intellect NN 19613 2888 17 and and CC 19613 2888 18 the the DT 19613 2888 19 disposition disposition NN 19613 2888 20 , , , 19613 2888 21 and and CC 19613 2888 22 in in IN 19613 2888 23 the the DT 19613 2888 24 assistance assistance NN 19613 2888 25 given give VBN 19613 2888 26 to to IN 19613 2888 27 these these DT 19613 2888 28 by by IN 19613 2888 29 man man NN 19613 2888 30 's 's POS 19613 2888 31 own own JJ 19613 2888 32 free free JJ 19613 2888 33 and and CC 19613 2888 34 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 19613 2888 35 efforts effort NNS 19613 2888 36 . . . 19613 2889 1 Eating eating NN 19613 2889 2 and and CC 19613 2889 3 drinking drink VBG 19613 2889 4 and and CC 19613 2889 5 , , , 19613 2889 6 in in IN 19613 2889 7 general general JJ 19613 2889 8 , , , 19613 2889 9 participation participation NN 19613 2889 10 in in IN 19613 2889 11 a a DT 19613 2889 12 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 2889 13 are be VBP 19613 2889 14 from from IN 19613 2889 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2889 16 's 's POS 19613 2889 17 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 2889 18 completely completely RB 19613 2889 19 indifferent indifferent JJ 19613 2889 20 matters matter NNS 19613 2889 21 . . . 19613 2890 1 The the DT 19613 2890 2 intelligent intelligent JJ 19613 2890 3 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2890 4 feeds feed VBZ 19613 2890 5 at at IN 19613 2890 6 all all DT 19613 2890 7 times time NNS 19613 2890 8 on on IN 19613 2890 9 the the DT 19613 2890 10 body body NN 19613 2890 11 of of IN 19613 2890 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 2890 13 , , , 19613 2890 14 that that RB 19613 2890 15 is is RB 19613 2890 16 , , , 19613 2890 17 on on IN 19613 2890 18 the the DT 19613 2890 19 Word Word NNP 19613 2890 20 of of IN 19613 2890 21 God God NNP 19613 2890 22 , , , 19613 2890 23 and and CC 19613 2890 24 thus thus RB 19613 2890 25 celebrates celebrate VBZ 19613 2890 26 a a DT 19613 2890 27 never never RB 19613 2890 28 ending end VBG 19613 2890 29 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2890 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2890 31 c. c. NN 19613 2890 32 Cels Cels NNP 19613 2890 33 . . . 19613 2891 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 2891 2 . . . 19613 2892 1 22 22 CD 19613 2892 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2892 3 . . . 19613 2893 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2893 2 , , , 19613 2893 3 however however RB 19613 2893 4 , , , 19613 2893 5 was be VBD 19613 2893 6 not not RB 19613 2893 7 blind blind JJ 19613 2893 8 to to IN 19613 2893 9 the the DT 19613 2893 10 fact fact NN 19613 2893 11 that that IN 19613 2893 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2893 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 2893 14 of of IN 19613 2893 15 the the DT 19613 2893 16 Lord Lord NNP 19613 2893 17 's 's POS 19613 2893 18 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2893 19 was be VBD 19613 2893 20 just just RB 19613 2893 21 as as RB 19613 2893 22 far far RB 19613 2893 23 removed remove VBN 19613 2893 24 from from IN 19613 2893 25 the the DT 19613 2893 26 faith faith NN 19613 2893 27 of of IN 19613 2893 28 the the DT 19613 2893 29 simple simple JJ 19613 2893 30 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2893 31 as as IN 19613 2893 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2893 33 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 2893 34 system system NN 19613 2893 35 generally generally RB 19613 2893 36 . . . 19613 2894 1 Here here RB 19613 2894 2 also also RB 19613 2894 3 , , , 19613 2894 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 2894 5 , , , 19613 2894 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2894 7 accommodated accommodate VBD 19613 2894 8 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2894 9 to to IN 19613 2894 10 that that DT 19613 2894 11 faith faith NN 19613 2894 12 in in IN 19613 2894 13 points point NNS 19613 2894 14 where where WRB 19613 2894 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2894 16 seemed seem VBD 19613 2894 17 necessary necessary JJ 19613 2894 18 . . . 19613 2895 1 This this DT 19613 2895 2 , , , 19613 2895 3 however however RB 19613 2895 4 , , , 19613 2895 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2895 6 did do VBD 19613 2895 7 not not RB 19613 2895 8 find find VB 19613 2895 9 difficult difficult JJ 19613 2895 10 ; ; : 19613 2895 11 for for IN 19613 2895 12 , , , 19613 2895 13 though though RB 19613 2895 14 with with IN 19613 2895 15 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2895 16 everything everything NN 19613 2895 17 is be VBZ 19613 2895 18 at at IN 19613 2895 19 bottom bottom NN 19613 2895 20 " " `` 19613 2895 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 2895 22 , , , 19613 2895 23 " " '' 19613 2895 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2895 25 was be VBD 19613 2895 26 unwilling unwilling JJ 19613 2895 27 to to TO 19613 2895 28 dispense dispense VB 19613 2895 29 with with IN 19613 2895 30 symbols symbol NNS 19613 2895 31 and and CC 19613 2895 32 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 2895 33 , , , 19613 2895 34 because because IN 19613 2895 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2895 36 knew know VBD 19613 2895 37 that that IN 19613 2895 38 one one PRP 19613 2895 39 must must MD 19613 2895 40 be be VB 19613 2895 41 _ _ NNP 19613 2895 42 initiated initiate VBN 19613 2895 43 _ _ NNP 19613 2895 44 into into IN 19613 2895 45 the the DT 19613 2895 46 spiritual spiritual NN 19613 2895 47 , , , 19613 2895 48 since since IN 19613 2895 49 one one PRP 19613 2895 50 can can MD 19613 2895 51 not not RB 19613 2895 52 learn learn VB 19613 2895 53 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2895 54 as as IN 19613 2895 55 one one PRP 19613 2895 56 learns learn VBZ 19613 2895 57 the the DT 19613 2895 58 lower low JJR 19613 2895 59 sciences science NNS 19613 2895 60 . . . 19613 2896 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2896 2 297 297 CD 19613 2896 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2896 4 But but CC 19613 2896 5 , , , 19613 2896 6 whether whether IN 19613 2896 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2896 8 consider consider VBP 19613 2896 9 simple simple JJ 19613 2896 10 believers believer NNS 19613 2896 11 , , , 19613 2896 12 the the DT 19613 2896 13 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 2896 14 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 2896 15 or or CC 19613 2896 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2896 17 , , , 19613 2896 18 and and CC 19613 2896 19 , , , 19613 2896 20 moreover moreover RB 19613 2896 21 , , , 19613 2896 22 whether whether IN 19613 2896 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2896 24 view view VBP 19613 2896 25 the the DT 19613 2896 26 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2896 27 as as IN 19613 2896 28 offering offering NN 19613 2896 29 or or CC 19613 2896 30 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 2896 31 , , , 19613 2896 32 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2896 33 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 2896 34 observe observe VBP 19613 2896 35 that that IN 19613 2896 36 the the DT 19613 2896 37 holy holy JJ 19613 2896 38 ordinance ordinance NN 19613 2896 39 had have VBD 19613 2896 40 been be VBN 19613 2896 41 entirely entirely RB 19613 2896 42 diverted divert VBN 19613 2896 43 from from IN 19613 2896 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2896 45 original original JJ 19613 2896 46 purpose purpose NN 19613 2896 47 and and CC 19613 2896 48 pressed press VBD 19613 2896 49 into into IN 19613 2896 50 the the DT 19613 2896 51 service service NN 19613 2896 52 of of IN 19613 2896 53 the the DT 19613 2896 54 spirit spirit NN 19613 2896 55 of of IN 19613 2896 56 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 2896 57 . . . 19613 2897 1 In in IN 19613 2897 2 no no DT 19613 2897 3 other other JJ 19613 2897 4 point point NN 19613 2897 5 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 2897 6 is be VBZ 19613 2897 7 the the DT 19613 2897 8 hellenisation hellenisation NN 19613 2897 9 of of IN 19613 2897 10 the the DT 19613 2897 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2897 12 so so RB 19613 2897 13 evident evident JJ 19613 2897 14 as as IN 19613 2897 15 in in IN 19613 2897 16 this this DT 19613 2897 17 . . . 19613 2898 1 To to TO 19613 2898 2 mention mention VB 19613 2898 3 only only RB 19613 2898 4 one one CD 19613 2898 5 other other JJ 19613 2898 6 example example NN 19613 2898 7 , , , 19613 2898 8 this this DT 19613 2898 9 is be VBZ 19613 2898 10 also also RB 19613 2898 11 shown show VBN 19613 2898 12 in in IN 19613 2898 13 the the DT 19613 2898 14 practice practice NN 19613 2898 15 of of IN 19613 2898 16 child child NN 19613 2898 17 communion communion NN 19613 2898 18 , , , 19613 2898 19 which which WDT 19613 2898 20 , , , 19613 2898 21 though though IN 19613 2898 22 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2898 23 first first RB 19613 2898 24 hear hear VBP 19613 2898 25 of of IN 19613 2898 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2898 27 in in IN 19613 2898 28 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2898 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2898 30 Testim Testim NNP 19613 2898 31 . . . 19613 2899 1 III iii CD 19613 2899 2 . . . 19613 2900 1 25 25 CD 19613 2900 2 ; ; : 19613 2900 3 de de NNP 19613 2900 4 laps laps NNP 19613 2900 5 . . . 19613 2901 1 25 25 CD 19613 2901 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2901 3 , , , 19613 2901 4 can can MD 19613 2901 5 hardly hardly RB 19613 2901 6 be be VB 19613 2901 7 of of IN 19613 2901 8 later later JJ 19613 2901 9 origin origin NN 19613 2901 10 than than IN 19613 2901 11 child child NN 19613 2901 12 baptism baptism NN 19613 2901 13 . . . 19613 2902 1 Partaking partaking NN 19613 2902 2 of of IN 19613 2902 3 the the DT 19613 2902 4 Supper Supper NNP 19613 2902 5 seemed seem VBD 19613 2902 6 quite quite RB 19613 2902 7 as as RB 19613 2902 8 indispensable indispensable JJ 19613 2902 9 as as IN 19613 2902 10 baptism baptism NN 19613 2902 11 , , , 19613 2902 12 and and CC 19613 2902 13 the the DT 19613 2902 14 child child NN 19613 2902 15 had have VBD 19613 2902 16 no no RB 19613 2902 17 less less JJR 19613 2902 18 claim claim NN 19613 2902 19 than than IN 19613 2902 20 the the DT 19613 2902 21 adult adult NN 19613 2902 22 to to IN 19613 2902 23 a a DT 19613 2902 24 magical magical JJ 19613 2902 25 food food NN 19613 2902 26 from from IN 19613 2902 27 heaven heaven NNP 19613 2902 28 . . . 19613 2903 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2903 2 298 298 CD 19613 2903 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2903 4 * * NFP 19613 2903 5 * * NFP 19613 2903 6 * * NFP 19613 2903 7 * * NFP 19613 2903 8 * * NFP 19613 2903 9 In in IN 19613 2903 10 the the DT 19613 2903 11 course course NN 19613 2903 12 of of IN 19613 2903 13 the the DT 19613 2903 14 third third JJ 19613 2903 15 century century NN 19613 2903 16 a a DT 19613 2903 17 crass crass JJ 19613 2903 18 superstition superstition NN 19613 2903 19 became become VBD 19613 2903 20 developed developed JJ 19613 2903 21 in in IN 19613 2903 22 respect respect NN 19613 2903 23 to to IN 19613 2903 24 the the DT 19613 2903 25 conceptions conception NNS 19613 2903 26 of of IN 19613 2903 27 the the DT 19613 2903 28 Church Church NNP 19613 2903 29 and and CC 19613 2903 30 the the DT 19613 2903 31 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 2903 32 connected connect VBN 19613 2903 33 with with IN 19613 2903 34 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2903 35 . . . 19613 2904 1 According accord VBG 19613 2904 2 to to IN 19613 2904 3 this this DT 19613 2904 4 notion notion NN 19613 2904 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2904 6 must must MD 19613 2904 7 subject subject VB 19613 2904 8 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2904 9 to to IN 19613 2904 10 the the DT 19613 2904 11 Church Church NNP 19613 2904 12 and and CC 19613 2904 13 must must MD 19613 2904 14 have have VB 19613 2904 15 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 2904 16 filled fill VBN 19613 2904 17 with with IN 19613 2904 18 holy holy JJ 19613 2904 19 consecrations consecration NNS 19613 2904 20 as as IN 19613 2904 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2904 22 are be VBP 19613 2904 23 filled fill VBN 19613 2904 24 with with IN 19613 2904 25 food food NN 19613 2904 26 . . . 19613 2905 1 But but CC 19613 2905 2 the the DT 19613 2905 3 following follow VBG 19613 2905 4 chapters chapter NNS 19613 2905 5 will will MD 19613 2905 6 show show VB 19613 2905 7 that that IN 19613 2905 8 this this DT 19613 2905 9 superstition superstition NN 19613 2905 10 and and CC 19613 2905 11 mystery mystery NN 19613 2905 12 magic magic NNP 19613 2905 13 were be VBD 19613 2905 14 counterbalanced counterbalance VBN 19613 2905 15 by by IN 19613 2905 16 a a DT 19613 2905 17 most most RBS 19613 2905 18 lively lively JJ 19613 2905 19 conception conception NN 19613 2905 20 of of IN 19613 2905 21 the the DT 19613 2905 22 freedom freedom NN 19613 2905 23 and and CC 19613 2905 24 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 2905 25 of of IN 19613 2905 26 the the DT 19613 2905 27 individual individual NN 19613 2905 28 . . . 19613 2906 1 Fettered fetter VBN 19613 2906 2 by by IN 19613 2906 3 the the DT 19613 2906 4 bonds bond NNS 19613 2906 5 of of IN 19613 2906 6 authority authority NN 19613 2906 7 and and CC 19613 2906 8 superstition superstition NN 19613 2906 9 in in IN 19613 2906 10 the the DT 19613 2906 11 sphere sphere NN 19613 2906 12 of of IN 19613 2906 13 religion religion NN 19613 2906 14 , , , 19613 2906 15 free free JJ 19613 2906 16 and and CC 19613 2906 17 self self NN 19613 2906 18 - - HYPH 19613 2906 19 dependent dependent JJ 19613 2906 20 in in IN 19613 2906 21 the the DT 19613 2906 22 province province NN 19613 2906 23 of of IN 19613 2906 24 morality morality NN 19613 2906 25 , , , 19613 2906 26 this this DT 19613 2906 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2906 28 is be VBZ 19613 2906 29 characterised characterise VBN 19613 2906 30 by by IN 19613 2906 31 passive passive JJ 19613 2906 32 submission submission NN 19613 2906 33 in in IN 19613 2906 34 the the DT 19613 2906 35 first first JJ 19613 2906 36 respect respect NN 19613 2906 37 and and CC 19613 2906 38 by by IN 19613 2906 39 complete complete JJ 19613 2906 40 activity activity NN 19613 2906 41 in in IN 19613 2906 42 the the DT 19613 2906 43 second second NN 19613 2906 44 . . . 19613 2907 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2907 2 may may MD 19613 2907 3 be be VB 19613 2907 4 that that IN 19613 2907 5 exegetical exegetical JJ 19613 2907 6 theology theology NN 19613 2907 7 can can MD 19613 2907 8 never never RB 19613 2907 9 advance advance VB 19613 2907 10 beyond beyond IN 19613 2907 11 an an DT 19613 2907 12 alternation alternation NN 19613 2907 13 between between IN 19613 2907 14 these these DT 19613 2907 15 two two CD 19613 2907 16 aspects aspect NNS 19613 2907 17 of of IN 19613 2907 18 the the DT 19613 2907 19 case case NN 19613 2907 20 , , , 19613 2907 21 and and CC 19613 2907 22 a a DT 19613 2907 23 recognition recognition NN 19613 2907 24 of of IN 19613 2907 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2907 26 equal equal JJ 19613 2907 27 claim claim NN 19613 2907 28 to to IN 19613 2907 29 consideration consideration NN 19613 2907 30 ; ; : 19613 2907 31 for for IN 19613 2907 32 the the DT 19613 2907 33 religious religious JJ 19613 2907 34 phenomenon phenomenon NN 19613 2907 35 in in IN 19613 2907 36 which which WDT 19613 2907 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2907 38 are be VBP 19613 2907 39 combined combine VBN 19613 2907 40 defies defie NNS 19613 2907 41 any any DT 19613 2907 42 explanation explanation NN 19613 2907 43 . . . 19613 2908 1 But but CC 19613 2908 2 religion religion NN 19613 2908 3 is be VBZ 19613 2908 4 in in IN 19613 2908 5 danger danger NN 19613 2908 6 of of IN 19613 2908 7 being be VBG 19613 2908 8 destroyed destroy VBN 19613 2908 9 when when WRB 19613 2908 10 the the DT 19613 2908 11 insufficiency insufficiency NN 19613 2908 12 of of IN 19613 2908 13 the the DT 19613 2908 14 understanding understanding NN 19613 2908 15 is be VBZ 19613 2908 16 elevated elevate VBN 19613 2908 17 into into IN 19613 2908 18 a a DT 19613 2908 19 convenient convenient JJ 19613 2908 20 principle principle NN 19613 2908 21 of of IN 19613 2908 22 theory theory NN 19613 2908 23 and and CC 19613 2908 24 life life NN 19613 2908 25 , , , 19613 2908 26 and and CC 19613 2908 27 when when WRB 19613 2908 28 the the DT 19613 2908 29 real real JJ 19613 2908 30 mystery mystery NN 19613 2908 31 of of IN 19613 2908 32 the the DT 19613 2908 33 faith faith NN 19613 2908 34 , , , 19613 2908 35 viz viz NNP 19613 2908 36 . . NNP 19613 2908 37 , , , 19613 2908 38 how how WRB 19613 2908 39 one one PRP 19613 2908 40 becomes become VBZ 19613 2908 41 a a DT 19613 2908 42 new new JJ 19613 2908 43 man man NN 19613 2908 44 , , , 19613 2908 45 must must MD 19613 2908 46 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 2908 47 give give VB 19613 2908 48 place place NN 19613 2908 49 to to IN 19613 2908 50 the the DT 19613 2908 51 injunction injunction NN 19613 2908 52 that that IN 19613 2908 53 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2908 54 must must MD 19613 2908 55 obediently obediently RB 19613 2908 56 accept accept VB 19613 2908 57 the the DT 19613 2908 58 religious religious JJ 19613 2908 59 as as IN 19613 2908 60 a a DT 19613 2908 61 consecration consecration NN 19613 2908 62 , , , 19613 2908 63 and and CC 19613 2908 64 add add VB 19613 2908 65 to to IN 19613 2908 66 this this DT 19613 2908 67 the the DT 19613 2908 68 zealous zealous JJ 19613 2908 69 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 2908 70 after after IN 19613 2908 71 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 2908 72 virtue virtue NN 19613 2908 73 . . . 19613 2909 1 Such such JJ 19613 2909 2 , , , 19613 2909 3 however however RB 19613 2909 4 , , , 19613 2909 5 has have VBZ 19613 2909 6 been be VBN 19613 2909 7 the the DT 19613 2909 8 character character NN 19613 2909 9 of of IN 19613 2909 10 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2909 11 since since IN 19613 2909 12 the the DT 19613 2909 13 third third JJ 19613 2909 14 century century NN 19613 2909 15 , , , 19613 2909 16 and and CC 19613 2909 17 even even RB 19613 2909 18 after after IN 19613 2909 19 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 2909 20 's 's POS 19613 2909 21 time time NN 19613 2909 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2909 23 has have VBZ 19613 2909 24 still still RB 19613 2909 25 remained remain VBN 19613 2909 26 the the DT 19613 2909 27 same same JJ 19613 2909 28 in in IN 19613 2909 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2909 30 practice practice NN 19613 2909 31 . . . 19613 2910 1 _ _ NNP 19613 2910 2 EXCURSUS excursu NNS 19613 2910 3 TO to IN 19613 2910 4 CHAPTERS CHAPTERS NNP 19613 2910 5 II II NNP 19613 2910 6 . . . 19613 2911 1 AND and CC 19613 2911 2 III III NNP 19613 2911 3 . . . 19613 2911 4 _ _ NNP 19613 2911 5 CATHOLIC CATHOLIC NNP 19613 2911 6 AND and CC 19613 2911 7 ROMAN ROMAN NNP 19613 2911 8 . . . 19613 2912 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2912 2 299 299 CD 19613 2912 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2912 4 In in IN 19613 2912 5 investigating investigate VBG 19613 2912 6 the the DT 19613 2912 7 development development NN 19613 2912 8 of of IN 19613 2912 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2912 10 up up RP 19613 2912 11 till till IN 19613 2912 12 about about IN 19613 2912 13 the the DT 19613 2912 14 year year NN 19613 2912 15 270 270 CD 19613 2912 16 the the DT 19613 2912 17 following follow VBG 19613 2912 18 facts fact NNS 19613 2912 19 must must MD 19613 2912 20 be be VB 19613 2912 21 specially specially RB 19613 2912 22 kept keep VBN 19613 2912 23 in in IN 19613 2912 24 mind mind NN 19613 2912 25 : : : 19613 2912 26 In in IN 19613 2912 27 the the DT 19613 2912 28 regions region NNS 19613 2912 29 subject subject JJ 19613 2912 30 to to IN 19613 2912 31 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2912 32 , , , 19613 2912 33 apart apart RB 19613 2912 34 from from IN 19613 2912 35 the the DT 19613 2912 36 Judæo judæo JJ 19613 2912 37 - - HYPH 19613 2912 38 Christian christian JJ 19613 2912 39 districts district NNS 19613 2912 40 and and CC 19613 2912 41 passing pass VBG 19613 2912 42 disturbances disturbance NNS 19613 2912 43 , , , 19613 2912 44 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2912 45 had have VBD 19613 2912 46 yet yet RB 19613 2912 47 an an DT 19613 2912 48 undivided undivided JJ 19613 2912 49 history history NN 19613 2912 50 in in IN 19613 2912 51 vital vital JJ 19613 2912 52 questions;[300 questions;[300 CD 19613 2912 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2912 54 the the DT 19613 2912 55 independence independence NN 19613 2912 56 of of IN 19613 2912 57 individual individual JJ 19613 2912 58 congregations congregation NNS 19613 2912 59 and and CC 19613 2912 60 of of IN 19613 2912 61 the the DT 19613 2912 62 provincial provincial JJ 19613 2912 63 groups group NNS 19613 2912 64 of of IN 19613 2912 65 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2912 66 was be VBD 19613 2912 67 very very RB 19613 2912 68 great great JJ 19613 2912 69 ; ; : 19613 2912 70 and and CC 19613 2912 71 every every DT 19613 2912 72 advance advance NN 19613 2912 73 in in IN 19613 2912 74 the the DT 19613 2912 75 development development NN 19613 2912 76 of of IN 19613 2912 77 the the DT 19613 2912 78 communities community NNS 19613 2912 79 at at IN 19613 2912 80 the the DT 19613 2912 81 same same JJ 19613 2912 82 time time NN 19613 2912 83 denoted denote VBD 19613 2912 84 a a DT 19613 2912 85 forward forward JJ 19613 2912 86 step step NN 19613 2912 87 in in IN 19613 2912 88 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2912 89 adaptation adaptation NN 19613 2912 90 to to IN 19613 2912 91 the the DT 19613 2912 92 existing exist VBG 19613 2912 93 conditions condition NNS 19613 2912 94 of of IN 19613 2912 95 the the DT 19613 2912 96 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2912 97 . . . 19613 2913 1 The the DT 19613 2913 2 first first JJ 19613 2913 3 two two CD 19613 2913 4 facts fact NNS 19613 2913 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2913 6 have have VBP 19613 2913 7 mentioned mention VBN 19613 2913 8 have have VBP 19613 2913 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2913 10 limitations limitation NNS 19613 2913 11 . . . 19613 2914 1 The the DT 19613 2914 2 further far RBR 19613 2914 3 apart apart RB 19613 2914 4 the the DT 19613 2914 5 different different JJ 19613 2914 6 Churches church NNS 19613 2914 7 lay lie VBD 19613 2914 8 , , , 19613 2914 9 the the DT 19613 2914 10 more more RBR 19613 2914 11 various various JJ 19613 2914 12 were be VBD 19613 2914 13 the the DT 19613 2914 14 conditions condition NNS 19613 2914 15 under under IN 19613 2914 16 which which WDT 19613 2914 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2914 18 arose arise VBD 19613 2914 19 and and CC 19613 2914 20 flourished flourish VBD 19613 2914 21 ; ; : 19613 2914 22 the the DT 19613 2914 23 looser loose JJR 19613 2914 24 the the DT 19613 2914 25 relations relation NNS 19613 2914 26 between between IN 19613 2914 27 the the DT 19613 2914 28 towns town NNS 19613 2914 29 in in IN 19613 2914 30 which which WDT 19613 2914 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2914 32 had have VBD 19613 2914 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2914 34 home home NN 19613 2914 35 the the DT 19613 2914 36 looser loose JJR 19613 2914 37 also also RB 19613 2914 38 was be VBD 19613 2914 39 the the DT 19613 2914 40 connection connection NN 19613 2914 41 between between IN 19613 2914 42 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2914 43 . . . 19613 2915 1 Still still RB 19613 2915 2 , , , 19613 2915 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2915 4 is be VBZ 19613 2915 5 evident evident JJ 19613 2915 6 that that IN 19613 2915 7 towards towards IN 19613 2915 8 the the DT 19613 2915 9 end end NN 19613 2915 10 of of IN 19613 2915 11 the the DT 19613 2915 12 third third JJ 19613 2915 13 century century NN 19613 2915 14 the the DT 19613 2915 15 development development NN 19613 2915 16 in in IN 19613 2915 17 the the DT 19613 2915 18 Church Church NNP 19613 2915 19 had have VBD 19613 2915 20 well well NN 19613 2915 21 - - HYPH 19613 2915 22 nigh nigh NN 19613 2915 23 attained attain VBD 19613 2915 24 the the DT 19613 2915 25 same same JJ 19613 2915 26 point point NN 19613 2915 27 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 2915 28 -- -- : 19613 2915 29 except except IN 19613 2915 30 in in IN 19613 2915 31 outlying outlying JJ 19613 2915 32 communities community NNS 19613 2915 33 . . . 19613 2916 1 Catholicism catholicism NN 19613 2916 2 , , , 19613 2916 3 essentially essentially RB 19613 2916 4 as as IN 19613 2916 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2916 6 conceive conceive VBP 19613 2916 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2916 8 now now RB 19613 2916 9 , , , 19613 2916 10 was be VBD 19613 2916 11 what what WP 19613 2916 12 most most JJS 19613 2916 13 of of IN 19613 2916 14 the the DT 19613 2916 15 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2916 16 had have VBD 19613 2916 17 arrived arrive VBN 19613 2916 18 at at IN 19613 2916 19 . . . 19613 2917 1 Now now RB 19613 2917 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2917 3 is be VBZ 19613 2917 4 an an DT 19613 2917 5 _ _ NNP 19613 2917 6 a a DT 19613 2917 7 priori priori FW 19613 2917 8 _ _ NNP 19613 2917 9 probability probability NN 19613 2917 10 that that IN 19613 2917 11 this this DT 19613 2917 12 transformation transformation NN 19613 2917 13 of of IN 19613 2917 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2917 15 , , , 19613 2917 16 which which WDT 19613 2917 17 was be VBD 19613 2917 18 simply simply RB 19613 2917 19 the the DT 19613 2917 20 adaptation adaptation NN 19613 2917 21 of of IN 19613 2917 22 the the DT 19613 2917 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2917 24 to to IN 19613 2917 25 the the DT 19613 2917 26 then then RB 19613 2917 27 existing exist VBG 19613 2917 28 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2917 29 , , , 19613 2917 30 came come VBD 19613 2917 31 about about IN 19613 2917 32 under under IN 19613 2917 33 the the DT 19613 2917 34 guidance guidance NN 19613 2917 35 of of IN 19613 2917 36 the the DT 19613 2917 37 metropolitan metropolitan JJ 19613 2917 38 Church,[301 church,[301 NN 19613 2917 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2917 40 the the DT 19613 2917 41 Church Church NNP 19613 2917 42 of of IN 19613 2917 43 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2917 44 ; ; : 19613 2917 45 and and CC 19613 2917 46 that that IN 19613 2917 47 " " `` 19613 2917 48 Roman roman JJ 19613 2917 49 " " '' 19613 2917 50 and and CC 19613 2917 51 " " `` 19613 2917 52 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 2917 53 " " '' 19613 2917 54 had have VBD 19613 2917 55 therefore therefore RB 19613 2917 56 a a DT 19613 2917 57 special special JJ 19613 2917 58 relation relation NN 19613 2917 59 from from IN 19613 2917 60 the the DT 19613 2917 61 beginning beginning NN 19613 2917 62 . . . 19613 2918 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2918 2 might may MD 19613 2918 3 _ _ VB 19613 2918 4 a a DT 19613 2918 5 limine limine NN 19613 2918 6 _ _ NNP 19613 2918 7 be be VB 19613 2918 8 objected object VBN 19613 2918 9 to to IN 19613 2918 10 this this DT 19613 2918 11 proposition proposition NN 19613 2918 12 that that IN 19613 2918 13 there there EX 19613 2918 14 is be VBZ 19613 2918 15 no no DT 19613 2918 16 direct direct JJ 19613 2918 17 testimony testimony NN 19613 2918 18 in in IN 19613 2918 19 support support NN 19613 2918 20 of of IN 19613 2918 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2918 22 , , , 19613 2918 23 and and CC 19613 2918 24 that that IN 19613 2918 25 , , , 19613 2918 26 apart apart RB 19613 2918 27 from from IN 19613 2918 28 this this DT 19613 2918 29 consideration consideration NN 19613 2918 30 , , , 19613 2918 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2918 32 is be VBZ 19613 2918 33 also also RB 19613 2918 34 improbable improbable JJ 19613 2918 35 , , , 19613 2918 36 in in IN 19613 2918 37 so so RB 19613 2918 38 far far RB 19613 2918 39 as as IN 19613 2918 40 , , , 19613 2918 41 in in IN 19613 2918 42 view view NN 19613 2918 43 of of IN 19613 2918 44 the the DT 19613 2918 45 then then RB 19613 2918 46 existing exist VBG 19613 2918 47 condition condition NN 19613 2918 48 of of IN 19613 2918 49 society society NN 19613 2918 50 , , , 19613 2918 51 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2918 52 appears appear VBZ 19613 2918 53 as as IN 19613 2918 54 the the DT 19613 2918 55 _ _ NNP 19613 2918 56 natural natural JJ 19613 2918 57 and and CC 19613 2918 58 only only JJ 19613 2918 59 possible possible JJ 19613 2918 60 _ _ NNP 19613 2918 61 form form NN 19613 2918 62 in in IN 19613 2918 63 which which WDT 19613 2918 64 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2918 65 could could MD 19613 2918 66 be be VB 19613 2918 67 adapted adapt VBN 19613 2918 68 to to IN 19613 2918 69 the the DT 19613 2918 70 world world NN 19613 2918 71 . . . 19613 2919 1 But but CC 19613 2919 2 this this DT 19613 2919 3 is be VBZ 19613 2919 4 not not RB 19613 2919 5 the the DT 19613 2919 6 case case NN 19613 2919 7 ; ; : 19613 2919 8 for for IN 19613 2919 9 in in IN 19613 2919 10 the the DT 19613 2919 11 first first JJ 19613 2919 12 place place NN 19613 2919 13 very very RB 19613 2919 14 strong strong JJ 19613 2919 15 proofs proof NNS 19613 2919 16 can can MD 19613 2919 17 be be VB 19613 2919 18 adduced adduce VBN 19613 2919 19 , , , 19613 2919 20 and and CC 19613 2919 21 besides besides RB 19613 2919 22 , , , 19613 2919 23 as as IN 19613 2919 24 is be VBZ 19613 2919 25 shown show VBN 19613 2919 26 by by IN 19613 2919 27 the the DT 19613 2919 28 development development NN 19613 2919 29 in in IN 19613 2919 30 the the DT 19613 2919 31 second second JJ 19613 2919 32 century century NN 19613 2919 33 , , , 19613 2919 34 very very RB 19613 2919 35 different different JJ 19613 2919 36 kinds kind NNS 19613 2919 37 of of IN 19613 2919 38 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 2919 39 were be VBD 19613 2919 40 possible possible JJ 19613 2919 41 . . . 19613 2920 1 In in IN 19613 2920 2 fact fact NN 19613 2920 3 , , , 19613 2920 4 if if IN 19613 2920 5 all all DT 19613 2920 6 appearances appearance NNS 19613 2920 7 are be VBP 19613 2920 8 not not RB 19613 2920 9 deceptive deceptive JJ 19613 2920 10 , , , 19613 2920 11 the the DT 19613 2920 12 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 2920 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2920 14 , , , 19613 2920 15 for for IN 19613 2920 16 example example NN 19613 2920 17 , , , 19613 2920 18 was be VBD 19613 2920 19 up up IN 19613 2920 20 to to IN 19613 2920 21 the the DT 19613 2920 22 time time NN 19613 2920 23 of of IN 19613 2920 24 Septimius Septimius NNP 19613 2920 25 Severus Severus NNP 19613 2920 26 pursuing pursue VBG 19613 2920 27 a a DT 19613 2920 28 path path NN 19613 2920 29 of of IN 19613 2920 30 development development NN 19613 2920 31 which which WDT 19613 2920 32 , , , 19613 2920 33 left leave VBD 19613 2920 34 to to IN 19613 2920 35 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 2920 36 , , , 19613 2920 37 would would MD 19613 2920 38 _ _ NNP 19613 2920 39 not not RB 19613 2920 40 _ _ NNP 19613 2920 41 have have VBP 19613 2920 42 led lead VBN 19613 2920 43 to to IN 19613 2920 44 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2920 45 , , , 19613 2920 46 but but CC 19613 2920 47 , , , 19613 2920 48 in in IN 19613 2920 49 the the DT 19613 2920 50 most most RBS 19613 2920 51 favourable favourable JJ 19613 2920 52 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2920 53 , , , 19613 2920 54 to to IN 19613 2920 55 a a DT 19613 2920 56 parallel parallel JJ 19613 2920 57 form form NN 19613 2920 58 . . . 19613 2921 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2921 2 302 302 CD 19613 2921 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2921 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2921 5 can can MD 19613 2921 6 , , , 19613 2921 7 however however RB 19613 2921 8 , , , 19613 2921 9 be be VB 19613 2921 10 proved prove VBN 19613 2921 11 that that IN 19613 2921 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2921 13 was be VBD 19613 2921 14 in in IN 19613 2921 15 the the DT 19613 2921 16 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2921 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2921 18 , , , 19613 2921 19 which which WDT 19613 2921 20 up up RB 19613 2921 21 to to IN 19613 2921 22 about about IN 19613 2921 23 the the DT 19613 2921 24 year year NN 19613 2921 25 190 190 CD 19613 2921 26 was be VBD 19613 2921 27 closely closely RB 19613 2921 28 connected connect VBN 19613 2921 29 with with IN 19613 2921 30 that that DT 19613 2921 31 of of IN 19613 2921 32 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2921 33 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2921 34 , , , 19613 2921 35 that that IN 19613 2921 36 all all PDT 19613 2921 37 the the DT 19613 2921 38 elements element NNS 19613 2921 39 on on IN 19613 2921 40 which which WDT 19613 2921 41 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2921 42 is be VBZ 19613 2921 43 based base VBN 19613 2921 44 first first RB 19613 2921 45 assumed assume VBD 19613 2921 46 a a DT 19613 2921 47 definite definite JJ 19613 2921 48 form form NN 19613 2921 49 . . . 19613 2922 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2922 2 303 303 CD 19613 2922 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2922 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2922 5 1 1 LS 19613 2922 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2922 7 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2922 8 know know VBP 19613 2922 9 that that IN 19613 2922 10 the the DT 19613 2922 11 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2922 12 Church Church NNP 19613 2922 13 possessed possess VBD 19613 2922 14 a a DT 19613 2922 15 precisely precisely RB 19613 2922 16 formulated formulate VBN 19613 2922 17 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 2922 18 confession confession NN 19613 2922 19 , , , 19613 2922 20 and and CC 19613 2922 21 that that IN 19613 2922 22 as as RB 19613 2922 23 early early RB 19613 2922 24 as as IN 19613 2922 25 the the DT 19613 2922 26 year year NN 19613 2922 27 180 180 CD 19613 2922 28 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2922 29 declared declare VBD 19613 2922 30 this this DT 19613 2922 31 to to TO 19613 2922 32 be be VB 19613 2922 33 the the DT 19613 2922 34 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2922 35 rule rule NN 19613 2922 36 by by IN 19613 2922 37 which which WDT 19613 2922 38 everything everything NN 19613 2922 39 is be VBZ 19613 2922 40 to to TO 19613 2922 41 be be VB 19613 2922 42 measured measure VBN 19613 2922 43 . . . 19613 2923 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2923 2 is be VBZ 19613 2923 3 only only RB 19613 2923 4 in in IN 19613 2923 5 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2923 6 case case NN 19613 2923 7 that that IN 19613 2923 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2923 9 are be VBP 19613 2923 10 really really RB 19613 2923 11 certain certain JJ 19613 2923 12 of of IN 19613 2923 13 this this DT 19613 2923 14 , , , 19613 2923 15 for for IN 19613 2923 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2923 17 can can MD 19613 2923 18 merely merely RB 19613 2923 19 guess guess VB 19613 2923 20 at at IN 19613 2923 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2923 22 as as IN 19613 2923 23 regards regard VBZ 19613 2923 24 the the DT 19613 2923 25 Church Church NNP 19613 2923 26 of of IN 19613 2923 27 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 19613 2923 28 , , , 19613 2923 29 that that RB 19613 2923 30 is is RB 19613 2923 31 , , , 19613 2923 32 of of IN 19613 2923 33 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2923 34 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2923 35 . . . 19613 2924 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2924 2 was be VBD 19613 2924 3 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 2924 4 admitted admit VBN 19613 2924 5 that that IN 19613 2924 6 the the DT 19613 2924 7 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2924 8 Church Church NNP 19613 2924 9 was be VBD 19613 2924 10 able able JJ 19613 2924 11 to to TO 19613 2924 12 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 2924 13 true true JJ 19613 2924 14 from from IN 19613 2924 15 false false JJ 19613 2924 16 with with IN 19613 2924 17 special special JJ 19613 2924 18 exactness;[304 exactness;[304 NNS 19613 2924 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2924 20 and and CC 19613 2924 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2924 22 and and CC 19613 2924 23 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2924 24 appealed appeal VBD 19613 2924 25 to to IN 19613 2924 26 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2924 27 to to TO 19613 2924 28 decide decide VB 19613 2924 29 the the DT 19613 2924 30 practice practice NN 19613 2924 31 in in IN 19613 2924 32 Gaul Gaul NNP 19613 2924 33 and and CC 19613 2924 34 Africa Africa NNP 19613 2924 35 . . . 19613 2925 1 This this DT 19613 2925 2 practice practice NN 19613 2925 3 , , , 19613 2925 4 in in IN 19613 2925 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2925 6 precisely precisely RB 19613 2925 7 developed develop VBN 19613 2925 8 form form NN 19613 2925 9 , , , 19613 2925 10 can can MD 19613 2925 11 not not RB 19613 2925 12 be be VB 19613 2925 13 shown show VBN 19613 2925 14 to to TO 19613 2925 15 have have VB 19613 2925 16 existed exist VBN 19613 2925 17 in in IN 19613 2925 18 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2925 19 till till IN 19613 2925 20 a a DT 19613 2925 21 later later JJ 19613 2925 22 period period NN 19613 2925 23 ; ; : 19613 2925 24 but but CC 19613 2925 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2925 26 , , , 19613 2925 27 who who WP 19613 2925 28 testifies testify VBZ 19613 2925 29 to to IN 19613 2925 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2925 31 , , , 19613 2925 32 also also RB 19613 2925 33 bears bear VBZ 19613 2925 34 witness witness NN 19613 2925 35 to to IN 19613 2925 36 the the DT 19613 2925 37 special special JJ 19613 2925 38 reverence reverence NN 19613 2925 39 for for IN 19613 2925 40 and and CC 19613 2925 41 connection connection NN 19613 2925 42 with with IN 19613 2925 43 the the DT 19613 2925 44 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2925 45 Church Church NNP 19613 2925 46 . . . 19613 2926 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2926 2 2 2 LS 19613 2926 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2926 4 The the DT 19613 2926 5 New New NNP 19613 2926 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2926 7 canon canon NN 19613 2926 8 , , , 19613 2926 9 with with IN 19613 2926 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2926 11 claim claim NN 19613 2926 12 to to TO 19613 2926 13 be be VB 19613 2926 14 accounted account VBN 19613 2926 15 catholic catholic NNP 19613 2926 16 and and CC 19613 2926 17 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2926 18 and and CC 19613 2926 19 to to TO 19613 2926 20 possess possess VB 19613 2926 21 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 2926 22 authority authority NN 19613 2926 23 is be VBZ 19613 2926 24 first first RB 19613 2926 25 traceable traceable JJ 19613 2926 26 in in IN 19613 2926 27 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2926 28 ; ; : 19613 2926 29 in in IN 19613 2926 30 the the DT 19613 2926 31 other other JJ 19613 2926 32 communities community NNS 19613 2926 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2926 34 can can MD 19613 2926 35 only only RB 19613 2926 36 be be VB 19613 2926 37 proved prove VBN 19613 2926 38 to to TO 19613 2926 39 exist exist VB 19613 2926 40 at at IN 19613 2926 41 a a DT 19613 2926 42 later later JJ 19613 2926 43 period period NN 19613 2926 44 . . . 19613 2927 1 In in IN 19613 2927 2 the the DT 19613 2927 3 great great JJ 19613 2927 4 Antiochian antiochian JJ 19613 2927 5 diocese diocese NN 19613 2927 6 there there EX 19613 2927 7 was be VBD 19613 2927 8 , , , 19613 2927 9 for for IN 19613 2927 10 instance instance NN 19613 2927 11 , , , 19613 2927 12 a a DT 19613 2927 13 Church church NN 19613 2927 14 some some DT 19613 2927 15 of of IN 19613 2927 16 whose whose WP$ 19613 2927 17 members member NNS 19613 2927 18 wished wish VBD 19613 2927 19 the the DT 19613 2927 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2927 21 of of IN 19613 2927 22 Peter Peter NNP 19613 2927 23 read read VBD 19613 2927 24 ; ; : 19613 2927 25 in in IN 19613 2927 26 the the DT 19613 2927 27 Pentapolis Pentapolis NNP 19613 2927 28 group group NN 19613 2927 29 of of IN 19613 2927 30 congregations congregation NNS 19613 2927 31 the the DT 19613 2927 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 2927 33 of of IN 19613 2927 34 the the DT 19613 2927 35 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 19613 2927 36 was be VBD 19613 2927 37 still still RB 19613 2927 38 used use VBN 19613 2927 39 in in IN 19613 2927 40 the the DT 19613 2927 41 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 2927 42 century century NN 19613 2927 43 ; ; : 19613 2927 44 Syrian syrian JJ 19613 2927 45 Churches church NNS 19613 2927 46 of of IN 19613 2927 47 the the DT 19613 2927 48 same same JJ 19613 2927 49 epoch epoch NN 19613 2927 50 used use VBD 19613 2927 51 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 2927 52 's 's POS 19613 2927 53 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 19613 2927 54 ; ; : 19613 2927 55 and and CC 19613 2927 56 the the DT 19613 2927 57 original original NN 19613 2927 58 of of IN 19613 2927 59 the the DT 19613 2927 60 first first JJ 19613 2927 61 six six CD 19613 2927 62 books book NNS 19613 2927 63 of of IN 19613 2927 64 the the DT 19613 2927 65 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 2927 66 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 2927 67 still still RB 19613 2927 68 makes make VBZ 19613 2927 69 no no DT 19613 2927 70 mention mention NN 19613 2927 71 of of IN 19613 2927 72 a a DT 19613 2927 73 New New NNP 19613 2927 74 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2927 75 canon canon NN 19613 2927 76 . . . 19613 2928 1 Though though IN 19613 2928 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2928 3 of of IN 19613 2928 4 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2928 5 no no RB 19613 2928 6 doubt doubt RB 19613 2928 7 testifies testify VBZ 19613 2928 8 that that IN 19613 2928 9 , , , 19613 2928 10 in in IN 19613 2928 11 consequence consequence NN 19613 2928 12 of of IN 19613 2928 13 the the DT 19613 2928 14 common common JJ 19613 2928 15 history history NN 19613 2928 16 of of IN 19613 2928 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2928 18 , , , 19613 2928 19 the the DT 19613 2928 20 group group NN 19613 2928 21 of of IN 19613 2928 22 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 2928 23 read read VBD 19613 2928 24 in in IN 19613 2928 25 the the DT 19613 2928 26 Roman roman JJ 19613 2928 27 congregations congregation NNS 19613 2928 28 was be VBD 19613 2928 29 also also RB 19613 2928 30 the the DT 19613 2928 31 same same JJ 19613 2928 32 as as IN 19613 2928 33 that that DT 19613 2928 34 employed employ VBN 19613 2928 35 in in IN 19613 2928 36 public public JJ 19613 2928 37 worship worship NN 19613 2928 38 at at IN 19613 2928 39 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2928 40 , , , 19613 2928 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2928 42 had have VBD 19613 2928 43 as as RB 19613 2928 44 yet yet RB 19613 2928 45 no no DT 19613 2928 46 New New NNP 19613 2928 47 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2928 48 canon canon NN 19613 2928 49 before before IN 19613 2928 50 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2928 51 in in IN 19613 2928 52 the the DT 19613 2928 53 sense sense NN 19613 2928 54 of of IN 19613 2928 55 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2928 56 and and CC 19613 2928 57 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2928 58 . . . 19613 2929 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2929 2 was be VBD 19613 2929 3 not not RB 19613 2929 4 till till IN 19613 2929 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2929 6 's 's POS 19613 2929 7 time time NN 19613 2929 8 that that WDT 19613 2929 9 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 2929 10 reached reach VBD 19613 2929 11 the the DT 19613 2929 12 stage stage NN 19613 2929 13 already already RB 19613 2929 14 attained attain VBN 19613 2929 15 in in IN 19613 2929 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2929 17 about about RB 19613 2929 18 forty forty CD 19613 2929 19 years year NNS 19613 2929 20 earlier early RBR 19613 2929 21 . . . 19613 2930 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2930 2 must must MD 19613 2930 3 , , , 19613 2930 4 however however RB 19613 2930 5 , , , 19613 2930 6 be be VB 19613 2930 7 pointed point VBN 19613 2930 8 out out RP 19613 2930 9 that that IN 19613 2930 10 a a DT 19613 2930 11 series series NN 19613 2930 12 of of IN 19613 2930 13 New New NNP 19613 2930 14 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2930 15 books book NNS 19613 2930 16 , , , 19613 2930 17 in in IN 19613 2930 18 the the DT 19613 2930 19 form form NN 19613 2930 20 now now RB 19613 2930 21 found find VBN 19613 2930 22 in in IN 19613 2930 23 the the DT 19613 2930 24 canon canon NN 19613 2930 25 and and CC 19613 2930 26 universally universally RB 19613 2930 27 recognised recognise VBN 19613 2930 28 , , , 19613 2930 29 show show VB 19613 2930 30 marks mark NNS 19613 2930 31 of of IN 19613 2930 32 revision revision NN 19613 2930 33 that that WDT 19613 2930 34 can can MD 19613 2930 35 be be VB 19613 2930 36 traced trace VBN 19613 2930 37 back back RB 19613 2930 38 to to IN 19613 2930 39 the the DT 19613 2930 40 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2930 41 Church Church NNP 19613 2930 42 . . . 19613 2931 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2931 2 305 305 CD 19613 2931 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2931 4 Finally finally RB 19613 2931 5 , , , 19613 2931 6 the the DT 19613 2931 7 later later JJ 19613 2931 8 investigations investigation NNS 19613 2931 9 , , , 19613 2931 10 which which WDT 19613 2931 11 show show VBP 19613 2931 12 that that IN 19613 2931 13 after after IN 19613 2931 14 the the DT 19613 2931 15 third third JJ 19613 2931 16 century century NN 19613 2931 17 the the DT 19613 2931 18 Western western JJ 19613 2931 19 readings reading NNS 19613 2931 20 , , , 19613 2931 21 that that RB 19613 2931 22 is is RB 19613 2931 23 , , , 19613 2931 24 the the DT 19613 2931 25 Roman roman JJ 19613 2931 26 text text NN 19613 2931 27 , , , 19613 2931 28 of of IN 19613 2931 29 the the DT 19613 2931 30 New New NNP 19613 2931 31 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2931 32 were be VBD 19613 2931 33 adopted adopt VBN 19613 2931 34 in in IN 19613 2931 35 the the DT 19613 2931 36 Oriental Oriental NNP 19613 2931 37 MSS MSS NNP 19613 2931 38 . . . 19613 2932 1 of of IN 19613 2932 2 the the DT 19613 2932 3 Bible,[306 Bible,[306 NNP 19613 2932 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2932 5 are be VBP 19613 2932 6 of of IN 19613 2932 7 the the DT 19613 2932 8 utmost utmost JJ 19613 2932 9 value value NN 19613 2932 10 here here RB 19613 2932 11 ; ; : 19613 2932 12 for for IN 19613 2932 13 the the DT 19613 2932 14 most most RBS 19613 2932 15 natural natural JJ 19613 2932 16 explanation explanation NN 19613 2932 17 of of IN 19613 2932 18 these these DT 19613 2932 19 facts fact NNS 19613 2932 20 is be VBZ 19613 2932 21 that that IN 19613 2932 22 the the DT 19613 2932 23 Eastern Eastern NNP 19613 2932 24 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2932 25 then then RB 19613 2932 26 received receive VBD 19613 2932 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2932 28 New New NNP 19613 2932 29 Testament Testament NNP 19613 2932 30 from from IN 19613 2932 31 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2932 32 and and CC 19613 2932 33 used use VBD 19613 2932 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2932 35 to to TO 19613 2932 36 correct correct VB 19613 2932 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2932 38 copies copy NNS 19613 2932 39 of of IN 19613 2932 40 books book NNS 19613 2932 41 read read VBP 19613 2932 42 in in IN 19613 2932 43 public public JJ 19613 2932 44 worship worship NN 19613 2932 45 . . . 19613 2933 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2933 2 307 307 CD 19613 2933 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2933 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2933 5 3 3 LS 19613 2933 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2933 7 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2933 8 is be VBZ 19613 2933 9 the the DT 19613 2933 10 first first JJ 19613 2933 11 place place NN 19613 2933 12 which which WDT 19613 2933 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2933 14 can can MD 19613 2933 15 prove prove VB 19613 2933 16 to to TO 19613 2933 17 have have VB 19613 2933 18 constructed construct VBN 19613 2933 19 a a DT 19613 2933 20 list list NN 19613 2933 21 of of IN 19613 2933 22 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2933 23 reaching reach VBG 19613 2933 24 back back RB 19613 2933 25 to to IN 19613 2933 26 the the DT 19613 2933 27 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2933 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2933 29 see see VB 19613 2933 30 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2933 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2933 32 . . . 19613 2934 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2934 2 308 308 CD 19613 2934 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2934 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2934 5 know know VBP 19613 2934 6 that that IN 19613 2934 7 in in IN 19613 2934 8 the the DT 19613 2934 9 time time NN 19613 2934 10 of of IN 19613 2934 11 Heliogabalus Heliogabalus NNP 19613 2934 12 such such JJ 19613 2934 13 lists list NNS 19613 2934 14 also also RB 19613 2934 15 existed exist VBD 19613 2934 16 in in IN 19613 2934 17 other other JJ 19613 2934 18 communities community NNS 19613 2934 19 ; ; : 19613 2934 20 but but CC 19613 2934 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2934 22 can can MD 19613 2934 23 not not RB 19613 2934 24 be be VB 19613 2934 25 proved prove VBN 19613 2934 26 that that IN 19613 2934 27 these these DT 19613 2934 28 had have VBD 19613 2934 29 already already RB 19613 2934 30 been be VBN 19613 2934 31 drawn draw VBN 19613 2934 32 up up RP 19613 2934 33 by by IN 19613 2934 34 the the DT 19613 2934 35 time time NN 19613 2934 36 of of IN 19613 2934 37 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 2934 38 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 19613 2934 39 or or CC 19613 2934 40 Commodus Commodus NNP 19613 2934 41 , , , 19613 2934 42 as as IN 19613 2934 43 was be VBD 19613 2934 44 certainly certainly RB 19613 2934 45 the the DT 19613 2934 46 case case NN 19613 2934 47 at at IN 19613 2934 48 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2934 49 . . . 19613 2935 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2935 2 4 4 LS 19613 2935 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2935 4 The the DT 19613 2935 5 notion notion NN 19613 2935 6 of of IN 19613 2935 7 the the DT 19613 2935 8 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2935 9 succession succession NN 19613 2935 10 of of IN 19613 2935 11 the the DT 19613 2935 12 episcopate[309 episcopate[309 NN 19613 2935 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2935 14 was be VBD 19613 2935 15 first first RB 19613 2935 16 turned turn VBN 19613 2935 17 to to IN 19613 2935 18 account account NN 19613 2935 19 by by IN 19613 2935 20 the the DT 19613 2935 21 Roman roman JJ 19613 2935 22 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2935 23 , , , 19613 2935 24 and and CC 19613 2935 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2935 26 were be VBD 19613 2935 27 the the DT 19613 2935 28 first first JJ 19613 2935 29 who who WP 19613 2935 30 definitely definitely RB 19613 2935 31 formulated formulate VBD 19613 2935 32 the the DT 19613 2935 33 political political JJ 19613 2935 34 idea idea NN 19613 2935 35 of of IN 19613 2935 36 the the DT 19613 2935 37 Church Church NNP 19613 2935 38 in in IN 19613 2935 39 connection connection NN 19613 2935 40 with with IN 19613 2935 41 this this DT 19613 2935 42 . . . 19613 2936 1 The the DT 19613 2936 2 utterances utterance NNS 19613 2936 3 and and CC 19613 2936 4 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 2936 5 practical practical JJ 19613 2936 6 measures measure NNS 19613 2936 7 of of IN 19613 2936 8 Victor,[310 Victor,[310 NNP 19613 2936 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2936 10 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2936 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2936 12 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2936 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2936 14 , , , 19613 2936 15 and and CC 19613 2936 16 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2936 17 are be VBP 19613 2936 18 the the DT 19613 2936 19 earliest early JJS 19613 2936 20 of of IN 19613 2936 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2936 22 kind kind NN 19613 2936 23 ; ; : 19613 2936 24 whilst whilst IN 19613 2936 25 the the DT 19613 2936 26 precision precision NN 19613 2936 27 and and CC 19613 2936 28 assurance assurance NN 19613 2936 29 with with IN 19613 2936 30 which which WDT 19613 2936 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2936 32 substituted substitute VBD 19613 2936 33 the the DT 19613 2936 34 political political JJ 19613 2936 35 and and CC 19613 2936 36 clerical clerical JJ 19613 2936 37 for for IN 19613 2936 38 the the DT 19613 2936 39 ideal ideal JJ 19613 2936 40 conception conception NN 19613 2936 41 of of IN 19613 2936 42 the the DT 19613 2936 43 Church Church NNP 19613 2936 44 , , , 19613 2936 45 or or CC 19613 2936 46 amalgamated amalgamate VBD 19613 2936 47 the the DT 19613 2936 48 two two CD 19613 2936 49 notions notion NNS 19613 2936 50 , , , 19613 2936 51 as as RB 19613 2936 52 well well RB 19613 2936 53 as as IN 19613 2936 54 the the DT 19613 2936 55 decided decide VBN 19613 2936 56 way way NN 19613 2936 57 in in IN 19613 2936 58 which which WDT 19613 2936 59 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2936 60 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 2936 61 the the DT 19613 2936 62 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 2936 63 of of IN 19613 2936 64 the the DT 19613 2936 65 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2936 66 , , , 19613 2936 67 were be VBD 19613 2936 68 not not RB 19613 2936 69 surpassed surpass VBN 19613 2936 70 in in IN 19613 2936 71 the the DT 19613 2936 72 third third JJ 19613 2936 73 century century NN 19613 2936 74 by by IN 19613 2936 75 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2936 76 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2936 77 . . . 19613 2937 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2937 2 5 5 LS 19613 2937 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2937 4 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2937 5 was be VBD 19613 2937 6 the the DT 19613 2937 7 first first JJ 19613 2937 8 place place NN 19613 2937 9 , , , 19613 2937 10 and and CC 19613 2937 11 that that IN 19613 2937 12 at at IN 19613 2937 13 a a DT 19613 2937 14 very very RB 19613 2937 15 early early JJ 19613 2937 16 period period NN 19613 2937 17 , , , 19613 2937 18 to to IN 19613 2937 19 date date NN 19613 2937 20 occurrences occurrence NNS 19613 2937 21 according accord VBG 19613 2937 22 to to IN 19613 2937 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2937 24 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2937 25 ; ; : 19613 2937 26 and and CC 19613 2937 27 , , , 19613 2937 28 even even RB 19613 2937 29 outside outside IN 19613 2937 30 that that DT 19613 2937 31 city city NN 19613 2937 32 , , , 19613 2937 33 churches church NNS 19613 2937 34 reckoned reckon VBD 19613 2937 35 , , , 19613 2937 36 not not RB 19613 2937 37 according accord VBG 19613 2937 38 to to IN 19613 2937 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2937 40 own own JJ 19613 2937 41 , , , 19613 2937 42 but but CC 19613 2937 43 according accord VBG 19613 2937 44 to to IN 19613 2937 45 the the DT 19613 2937 46 Roman roman JJ 19613 2937 47 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 2937 48 . . . 19613 2938 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2938 2 311 311 CD 19613 2938 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2938 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2938 5 6 6 LS 19613 2938 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2938 7 The the DT 19613 2938 8 Oriental oriental JJ 19613 2938 9 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2938 10 say say VBP 19613 2938 11 that that IN 19613 2938 12 two two CD 19613 2938 13 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2938 14 of of IN 19613 2938 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2938 16 compiled compile VBD 19613 2938 17 the the DT 19613 2938 18 chief chief JJ 19613 2938 19 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 2938 20 regulations regulation NNS 19613 2938 21 for for IN 19613 2938 22 the the DT 19613 2938 23 organisation organisation NN 19613 2938 24 of of IN 19613 2938 25 the the DT 19613 2938 26 Church Church NNP 19613 2938 27 ; ; : 19613 2938 28 and and CC 19613 2938 29 this this DT 19613 2938 30 is be VBZ 19613 2938 31 only only RB 19613 2938 32 partially partially RB 19613 2938 33 wrong wrong JJ 19613 2938 34 . . . 19613 2939 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2939 2 312 312 CD 19613 2939 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2939 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2939 5 7 7 LS 19613 2939 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2939 7 The the DT 19613 2939 8 three three CD 19613 2939 9 great great JJ 19613 2939 10 theologians theologian NNS 19613 2939 11 of of IN 19613 2939 12 the the DT 19613 2939 13 age age NN 19613 2939 14 , , , 19613 2939 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2939 16 , , , 19613 2939 17 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2939 18 , , , 19613 2939 19 and and CC 19613 2939 20 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2939 21 , , , 19613 2939 22 opposed oppose VBD 19613 2939 23 the the DT 19613 2939 24 pretensions pretension NNS 19613 2939 25 of of IN 19613 2939 26 the the DT 19613 2939 27 Roman roman JJ 19613 2939 28 bishop bishop NN 19613 2939 29 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2939 30 ; ; : 19613 2939 31 and and CC 19613 2939 32 this this DT 19613 2939 33 very very JJ 19613 2939 34 attitude attitude NN 19613 2939 35 of of IN 19613 2939 36 theirs -PRON- PRP 19613 2939 37 testified testify VBD 19613 2939 38 that that IN 19613 2939 39 the the DT 19613 2939 40 advance advance NN 19613 2939 41 in in IN 19613 2939 42 the the DT 19613 2939 43 political political JJ 19613 2939 44 organisation organisation NN 19613 2939 45 of of IN 19613 2939 46 the the DT 19613 2939 47 Church Church NNP 19613 2939 48 , , , 19613 2939 49 denoted denote VBN 19613 2939 50 by by IN 19613 2939 51 the the DT 19613 2939 52 measures measure NNS 19613 2939 53 of of IN 19613 2939 54 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2939 55 , , , 19613 2939 56 was be VBD 19613 2939 57 still still RB 19613 2939 58 an an DT 19613 2939 59 unheard unheard JJ 19613 2939 60 - - HYPH 19613 2939 61 of of IN 19613 2939 62 novelty novelty NN 19613 2939 63 , , , 19613 2939 64 but but CC 19613 2939 65 immediately immediately RB 19613 2939 66 exercised exercise VBD 19613 2939 67 a a DT 19613 2939 68 very very RB 19613 2939 69 important important JJ 19613 2939 70 influence influence NN 19613 2939 71 on on IN 19613 2939 72 the the DT 19613 2939 73 attitude attitude NN 19613 2939 74 of of IN 19613 2939 75 other other JJ 19613 2939 76 Churches church NNS 19613 2939 77 . . . 19613 2940 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2940 2 know know VBP 19613 2940 3 that that IN 19613 2940 4 the the DT 19613 2940 5 other other JJ 19613 2940 6 communities community NNS 19613 2940 7 imitated imitate VBD 19613 2940 8 this this DT 19613 2940 9 advance advance NN 19613 2940 10 in in IN 19613 2940 11 the the DT 19613 2940 12 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 2940 13 decades decade NNS 19613 2940 14 . . . 19613 2941 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2941 2 8) 8) CD 19613 2941 3 The the DT 19613 2941 4 institution institution NN 19613 2941 5 of of IN 19613 2941 6 lower low JJR 19613 2941 7 orders order NNS 19613 2941 8 of of IN 19613 2941 9 clergy clergy NNS 19613 2941 10 with with IN 19613 2941 11 the the DT 19613 2941 12 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 2941 13 distinction distinction NN 19613 2941 14 of of IN 19613 2941 15 _ _ NNP 19613 2941 16 clerici clerici NNP 19613 2941 17 maiores maiore VBZ 19613 2941 18 _ _ NNP 19613 2941 19 and and CC 19613 2941 20 _ _ NNP 19613 2941 21 minores minores NNP 19613 2941 22 _ _ NNP 19613 2941 23 first first RB 19613 2941 24 took take VBD 19613 2941 25 place place NN 19613 2941 26 in in IN 19613 2941 27 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2941 28 ; ; : 19613 2941 29 but but CC 19613 2941 30 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2941 31 know know VBP 19613 2941 32 that that IN 19613 2941 33 this this DT 19613 2941 34 momentous momentous JJ 19613 2941 35 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 2941 36 gradually gradually RB 19613 2941 37 spread spread VBD 19613 2941 38 from from IN 19613 2941 39 that that DT 19613 2941 40 city city NN 19613 2941 41 to to IN 19613 2941 42 the the DT 19613 2941 43 rest rest NN 19613 2941 44 of of IN 19613 2941 45 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2941 46 . . . 19613 2942 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2942 2 313 313 CD 19613 2942 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2942 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2942 5 9 9 LS 19613 2942 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2942 7 The the DT 19613 2942 8 different different JJ 19613 2942 9 Churches church NNS 19613 2942 10 communicated communicate VBN 19613 2942 11 with with IN 19613 2942 12 one one CD 19613 2942 13 another another DT 19613 2942 14 through through IN 19613 2942 15 the the DT 19613 2942 16 medium medium NN 19613 2942 17 of of IN 19613 2942 18 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2942 19 . . . 19613 2943 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2943 2 314 314 CD 19613 2943 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2943 4 From from IN 19613 2943 5 these these DT 19613 2943 6 considerations consideration NNS 19613 2943 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2943 8 can can MD 19613 2943 9 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 2943 10 doubt doubt VB 19613 2943 11 that that IN 19613 2943 12 the the DT 19613 2943 13 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 2943 14 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2943 15 institutions institution NNS 19613 2943 16 and and CC 19613 2943 17 laws law NNS 19613 2943 18 of of IN 19613 2943 19 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 2943 20 were be VBD 19613 2943 21 framed frame VBN 19613 2943 22 in in IN 19613 2943 23 the the DT 19613 2943 24 same same JJ 19613 2943 25 city city NN 19613 2943 26 that that WDT 19613 2943 27 in in IN 19613 2943 28 other other JJ 19613 2943 29 respects respect NNS 19613 2943 30 imposed impose VBD 19613 2943 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2943 32 authority authority NN 19613 2943 33 on on IN 19613 2943 34 the the DT 19613 2943 35 whole whole JJ 19613 2943 36 earth earth NN 19613 2943 37 ; ; : 19613 2943 38 and and CC 19613 2943 39 that that IN 19613 2943 40 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2943 41 was be VBD 19613 2943 42 the the DT 19613 2943 43 centre centre NN 19613 2943 44 from from IN 19613 2943 45 which which WDT 19613 2943 46 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2943 47 spread spread VBP 19613 2943 48 , , , 19613 2943 49 because because IN 19613 2943 50 the the DT 19613 2943 51 world world NN 19613 2943 52 had have VBD 19613 2943 53 become become VBN 19613 2943 54 accustomed accustomed JJ 19613 2943 55 to to TO 19613 2943 56 receive receive VB 19613 2943 57 law law NN 19613 2943 58 and and CC 19613 2943 59 justice justice NN 19613 2943 60 from from IN 19613 2943 61 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2943 62 . . . 19613 2944 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2944 2 315 315 CD 19613 2944 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2944 4 But but CC 19613 2944 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2944 6 may may MD 19613 2944 7 be be VB 19613 2944 8 objected object VBN 19613 2944 9 that that IN 19613 2944 10 the the DT 19613 2944 11 parallel parallel JJ 19613 2944 12 development development NN 19613 2944 13 in in IN 19613 2944 14 other other JJ 19613 2944 15 provinces province NNS 19613 2944 16 and and CC 19613 2944 17 towns town NNS 19613 2944 18 was be VBD 19613 2944 19 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 19613 2944 20 , , , 19613 2944 21 though though IN 19613 2944 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2944 23 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 2944 24 came come VBD 19613 2944 25 about about RP 19613 2944 26 at at IN 19613 2944 27 a a DT 19613 2944 28 somewhat somewhat RB 19613 2944 29 later later JJ 19613 2944 30 date date NN 19613 2944 31 . . . 19613 2945 1 Nor nor CC 19613 2945 2 do do VBP 19613 2945 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2945 4 intend intend VB 19613 2945 5 to to TO 19613 2945 6 contest contest VB 19613 2945 7 the the DT 19613 2945 8 assumption assumption NN 19613 2945 9 in in IN 19613 2945 10 this this DT 19613 2945 11 general general JJ 19613 2945 12 sense sense NN 19613 2945 13 ; ; : 19613 2945 14 but but CC 19613 2945 15 , , , 19613 2945 16 as as IN 19613 2945 17 I -PRON- PRP 19613 2945 18 think think VBP 19613 2945 19 , , , 19613 2945 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2945 21 can can MD 19613 2945 22 be be VB 19613 2945 23 proved prove VBN 19613 2945 24 that that IN 19613 2945 25 the the DT 19613 2945 26 Roman roman JJ 19613 2945 27 community community NN 19613 2945 28 had have VBD 19613 2945 29 a a DT 19613 2945 30 direct direct JJ 19613 2945 31 and and CC 19613 2945 32 important important JJ 19613 2945 33 share share NN 19613 2945 34 in in IN 19613 2945 35 the the DT 19613 2945 36 process process NN 19613 2945 37 and and CC 19613 2945 38 that that IN 19613 2945 39 , , , 19613 2945 40 even even RB 19613 2945 41 in in IN 19613 2945 42 the the DT 19613 2945 43 second second JJ 19613 2945 44 century century NN 19613 2945 45 , , , 19613 2945 46 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2945 47 was be VBD 19613 2945 48 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 2945 49 the the DT 19613 2945 50 first first JJ 19613 2945 51 and and CC 19613 2945 52 most most RBS 19613 2945 53 influential influential JJ 19613 2945 54 Church church NN 19613 2945 55 . . . 19613 2946 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2946 2 316 316 CD 19613 2946 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2946 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2946 5 shall shall MD 19613 2946 6 give give VB 19613 2946 7 a a DT 19613 2946 8 bird's bird's NN 19613 2946 9 - - HYPH 19613 2946 10 eye eye NN 19613 2946 11 view view NN 19613 2946 12 of of IN 19613 2946 13 the the DT 19613 2946 14 most most RBS 19613 2946 15 important important JJ 19613 2946 16 facts fact NNS 19613 2946 17 bearing bear VBG 19613 2946 18 on on IN 19613 2946 19 the the DT 19613 2946 20 question question NN 19613 2946 21 , , , 19613 2946 22 in in IN 19613 2946 23 order order NN 19613 2946 24 to to TO 19613 2946 25 prove prove VB 19613 2946 26 this this DT 19613 2946 27 . . . 19613 2947 1 No no DT 19613 2947 2 other other JJ 19613 2947 3 community community NN 19613 2947 4 made make VBD 19613 2947 5 a a DT 19613 2947 6 more more RBR 19613 2947 7 brilliant brilliant JJ 19613 2947 8 entrance entrance NN 19613 2947 9 into into IN 19613 2947 10 Church church NN 19613 2947 11 history history NN 19613 2947 12 than than IN 19613 2947 13 did do VBD 19613 2947 14 that that DT 19613 2947 15 of of IN 19613 2947 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2947 17 by by IN 19613 2947 18 the the DT 19613 2947 19 so so RB 19613 2947 20 called call VBN 19613 2947 21 First First NNP 19613 2947 22 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 2947 23 of of IN 19613 2947 24 Clement Clement NNP 19613 2947 25 -- -- : 19613 2947 26 Paul Paul NNP 19613 2947 27 having have VBG 19613 2947 28 already already RB 19613 2947 29 testified testify VBN 19613 2947 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2947 31 Rom rom NN 19613 2947 32 . . . 19613 2948 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2949 1 8) 8) CD 19613 2949 2 that that IN 19613 2949 3 the the DT 19613 2949 4 faith faith NN 19613 2949 5 of of IN 19613 2949 6 this this DT 19613 2949 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2949 8 was be VBD 19613 2949 9 spoken speak VBN 19613 2949 10 of of IN 19613 2949 11 throughout throughout IN 19613 2949 12 the the DT 19613 2949 13 whole whole JJ 19613 2949 14 world world NN 19613 2949 15 . . . 19613 2950 1 That that DT 19613 2950 2 letter letter NN 19613 2950 3 to to IN 19613 2950 4 the the DT 19613 2950 5 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 19613 2950 6 proves prove VBZ 19613 2950 7 that that IN 19613 2950 8 , , , 19613 2950 9 by by IN 19613 2950 10 the the DT 19613 2950 11 end end NN 19613 2950 12 of of IN 19613 2950 13 the the DT 19613 2950 14 first first JJ 19613 2950 15 century century NN 19613 2950 16 , , , 19613 2950 17 the the DT 19613 2950 18 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2950 19 Church Church NNP 19613 2950 20 had have VBD 19613 2950 21 already already RB 19613 2950 22 drawn draw VBN 19613 2950 23 up up RP 19613 2950 24 fixed fix VBN 19613 2950 25 rules rule NNS 19613 2950 26 for for IN 19613 2950 27 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2950 28 own own JJ 19613 2950 29 guidance guidance NN 19613 2950 30 , , , 19613 2950 31 that that IN 19613 2950 32 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2950 33 watched watch VBD 19613 2950 34 with with IN 19613 2950 35 motherly motherly JJ 19613 2950 36 care care NN 19613 2950 37 over over IN 19613 2950 38 outlying outlying JJ 19613 2950 39 communities community NNS 19613 2950 40 , , , 19613 2950 41 and and CC 19613 2950 42 that that IN 19613 2950 43 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2950 44 then then RB 19613 2950 45 knew know VBD 19613 2950 46 how how WRB 19613 2950 47 to to TO 19613 2950 48 use use VB 19613 2950 49 language language NN 19613 2950 50 that that WDT 19613 2950 51 was be VBD 19613 2950 52 at at IN 19613 2950 53 once once RB 19613 2950 54 an an DT 19613 2950 55 expression expression NN 19613 2950 56 of of IN 19613 2950 57 duty duty NN 19613 2950 58 , , , 19613 2950 59 love love NN 19613 2950 60 , , , 19613 2950 61 and and CC 19613 2950 62 authority authority NN 19613 2950 63 . . . 19613 2951 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2951 2 317 317 CD 19613 2951 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2951 4 As as IN 19613 2951 5 yet yet RB 19613 2951 6 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2951 7 pretends pretend VBZ 19613 2951 8 to to IN 19613 2951 9 no no DT 19613 2951 10 legal legal JJ 19613 2951 11 title title NN 19613 2951 12 of of IN 19613 2951 13 any any DT 19613 2951 14 kind kind NN 19613 2951 15 , , , 19613 2951 16 but but CC 19613 2951 17 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2951 18 knows know VBZ 19613 2951 19 the the DT 19613 2951 20 " " `` 19613 2951 21 commandments commandment NNS 19613 2951 22 and and CC 19613 2951 23 ordinances ordinance NNS 19613 2951 24 " " '' 19613 2951 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2951 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2951 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2951 28 : : : 19613 2951 29 prostagmata prostagmata NN 19613 2951 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2951 31 and and CC 19613 2951 32 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2951 33 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2951 34 : : : 19613 2951 35 dokaiômata dokaiômata NN 19613 2951 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2951 37 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2951 38 of of IN 19613 2951 39 God God NNP 19613 2951 40 , , , 19613 2951 41 whereas whereas IN 19613 2951 42 the the DT 19613 2951 43 conduct conduct NN 19613 2951 44 of of IN 19613 2951 45 the the DT 19613 2951 46 sister sister NN 19613 2951 47 Church Church NNP 19613 2951 48 evinces evince VBZ 19613 2951 49 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2951 50 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 2951 51 on on IN 19613 2951 52 the the DT 19613 2951 53 matter matter NN 19613 2951 54 ; ; : 19613 2951 55 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2951 56 is be VBZ 19613 2951 57 in in IN 19613 2951 58 an an DT 19613 2951 59 orderly orderly JJ 19613 2951 60 condition condition NN 19613 2951 61 , , , 19613 2951 62 whereas whereas IN 19613 2951 63 the the DT 19613 2951 64 sister sister NN 19613 2951 65 community community NN 19613 2951 66 is be VBZ 19613 2951 67 threatened threaten VBN 19613 2951 68 with with IN 19613 2951 69 dissolution dissolution NN 19613 2951 70 ; ; : 19613 2951 71 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2951 72 adheres adhere VBZ 19613 2951 73 to to IN 19613 2951 74 the the DT 19613 2951 75 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2951 76 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2951 77 : : : 19613 2951 78 kanôn kanôn VB 19613 2951 79 tês tês NNP 19613 2951 80 paradoseôs paradoseôs NNP 19613 2951 81 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2951 82 , , , 19613 2951 83 whilst whilst IN 19613 2951 84 the the DT 19613 2951 85 other other JJ 19613 2951 86 body body NN 19613 2951 87 stands stand VBZ 19613 2951 88 in in IN 19613 2951 89 need need NN 19613 2951 90 of of IN 19613 2951 91 exhortation;[318 exhortation;[318 NNS 19613 2951 92 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2951 93 and and CC 19613 2951 94 in in IN 19613 2951 95 these these DT 19613 2951 96 facts fact NNS 19613 2951 97 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2951 98 claim claim NN 19613 2951 99 to to IN 19613 2951 100 authority authority NN 19613 2951 101 consists consist VBZ 19613 2951 102 . . . 19613 2952 1 The the DT 19613 2952 2 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 2952 3 of of IN 19613 2952 4 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 2952 5 also also RB 19613 2952 6 proves prove VBZ 19613 2952 7 that that IN 19613 2952 8 even even RB 19613 2952 9 in in IN 19613 2952 10 the the DT 19613 2952 11 circles circle NNS 19613 2952 12 of of IN 19613 2952 13 the the DT 19613 2952 14 laity laity NN 19613 2952 15 the the DT 19613 2952 16 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2952 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2952 18 is be VBZ 19613 2952 19 impressed impressed JJ 19613 2952 20 with with IN 19613 2952 21 the the DT 19613 2952 22 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 2952 23 that that IN 19613 2952 24 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2952 25 must must MD 19613 2952 26 care care VB 19613 2952 27 for for IN 19613 2952 28 the the DT 19613 2952 29 whole whole NN 19613 2952 30 of of IN 19613 2952 31 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2952 32 . . . 19613 2953 1 The the DT 19613 2953 2 first first JJ 19613 2953 3 testimony testimony NN 19613 2953 4 of of IN 19613 2953 5 an an DT 19613 2953 6 outsider outsider NN 19613 2953 7 as as IN 19613 2953 8 to to IN 19613 2953 9 this this DT 19613 2953 10 community community NN 19613 2953 11 is be VBZ 19613 2953 12 afforded afford VBN 19613 2953 13 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2953 14 by by IN 19613 2953 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 2953 16 . . . 19613 2954 1 Soften Soften NNP 19613 2954 2 as as IN 19613 2954 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2954 4 may may MD 19613 2954 5 all all PDT 19613 2954 6 the the DT 19613 2954 7 extravagant extravagant JJ 19613 2954 8 expressions expression NNS 19613 2954 9 in in IN 19613 2954 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2954 11 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 2954 12 to to IN 19613 2954 13 the the DT 19613 2954 14 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 2954 15 , , , 19613 2954 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2954 17 is be VBZ 19613 2954 18 at at IN 19613 2954 19 least least JJS 19613 2954 20 clear clear JJ 19613 2954 21 that that IN 19613 2954 22 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 2954 23 conceded concede VBD 19613 2954 24 to to IN 19613 2954 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2954 26 a a DT 19613 2954 27 precedence precedence NN 19613 2954 28 in in IN 19613 2954 29 the the DT 19613 2954 30 circle circle NN 19613 2954 31 of of IN 19613 2954 32 sister sister NN 19613 2954 33 Churches church NNS 19613 2954 34 ; ; : 19613 2954 35 and and CC 19613 2954 36 that that IN 19613 2954 37 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2954 38 was be VBD 19613 2954 39 well well RB 19613 2954 40 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 2954 41 with with IN 19613 2954 42 the the DT 19613 2954 43 energy energy NN 19613 2954 44 and and CC 19613 2954 45 activity activity NN 19613 2954 46 displayed display VBN 19613 2954 47 by by IN 19613 2954 48 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2954 49 in in IN 19613 2954 50 aiding aid VBG 19613 2954 51 and and CC 19613 2954 52 instructing instruct VBG 19613 2954 53 other other JJ 19613 2954 54 communities community NNS 19613 2954 55 . . . 19613 2955 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2955 2 319 319 CD 19613 2955 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2955 4 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 2955 5 of of IN 19613 2955 6 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 2955 7 , , , 19613 2955 8 in in IN 19613 2955 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2955 10 letter letter NN 19613 2955 11 to to IN 19613 2955 12 bishop bishop NNP 19613 2955 13 Soter Soter NNP 19613 2955 14 , , , 19613 2955 15 affords afford VBZ 19613 2955 16 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2955 17 a a DT 19613 2955 18 glimpse glimpse NN 19613 2955 19 of of IN 19613 2955 20 the the DT 19613 2955 21 vast vast JJ 19613 2955 22 activity activity NN 19613 2955 23 manifested manifest VBN 19613 2955 24 by by IN 19613 2955 25 the the DT 19613 2955 26 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2955 27 Church Church NNP 19613 2955 28 of of IN 19613 2955 29 the the DT 19613 2955 30 world world NN 19613 2955 31 's 's POS 19613 2955 32 metropolis metropolis NN 19613 2955 33 on on IN 19613 2955 34 behalf behalf NN 19613 2955 35 of of IN 19613 2955 36 all all DT 19613 2955 37 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2955 38 and and CC 19613 2955 39 of of IN 19613 2955 40 all all DT 19613 2955 41 brethren brother NNS 19613 2955 42 far far RB 19613 2955 43 and and CC 19613 2955 44 near near RB 19613 2955 45 ; ; : 19613 2955 46 and and CC 19613 2955 47 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 2955 48 to to IN 19613 2955 49 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2955 50 the the DT 19613 2955 51 feelings feeling NNS 19613 2955 52 of of IN 19613 2955 53 filial filial JJ 19613 2955 54 affection affection NN 19613 2955 55 and and CC 19613 2955 56 veneration veneration NN 19613 2955 57 with with IN 19613 2955 58 which which WDT 19613 2955 59 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2955 60 was be VBD 19613 2955 61 regarded regard VBN 19613 2955 62 in in IN 19613 2955 63 all all DT 19613 2955 64 Greece Greece NNP 19613 2955 65 as as RB 19613 2955 66 well well RB 19613 2955 67 as as IN 19613 2955 68 in in IN 19613 2955 69 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 2955 70 . . . 19613 2956 1 This this DT 19613 2956 2 author author NN 19613 2956 3 has have VBZ 19613 2956 4 specially specially RB 19613 2956 5 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 2956 6 the the DT 19613 2956 7 fact fact NN 19613 2956 8 that that IN 19613 2956 9 the the DT 19613 2956 10 Roman roman JJ 19613 2956 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 2956 12 are be VBP 19613 2956 13 _ _ NNP 19613 2956 14 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 2956 15 _ _ NNP 19613 2956 16 , , , 19613 2956 17 that that RB 19613 2956 18 is is RB 19613 2956 19 , , , 19613 2956 20 are be VBP 19613 2956 21 conscious conscious JJ 19613 2956 22 of of IN 19613 2956 23 the the DT 19613 2956 24 particular particular JJ 19613 2956 25 duties duty NNS 19613 2956 26 incumbent incumbent JJ 19613 2956 27 on on IN 19613 2956 28 them -PRON- PRP 19613 2956 29 as as IN 19613 2956 30 members member NNS 19613 2956 31 of of IN 19613 2956 32 the the DT 19613 2956 33 metropolitan metropolitan JJ 19613 2956 34 Church Church NNP 19613 2956 35 . . . 19613 2957 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2957 2 320 320 CD 19613 2957 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2957 4 After after IN 19613 2957 5 this this DT 19613 2957 6 evidence evidence NN 19613 2957 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2957 8 can can MD 19613 2957 9 not not RB 19613 2957 10 wonder wonder VB 19613 2957 11 that that IN 19613 2957 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2957 13 expressly expressly RB 19613 2957 14 assigned assign VBN 19613 2957 15 to to IN 19613 2957 16 the the DT 19613 2957 17 Church Church NNP 19613 2957 18 of of IN 19613 2957 19 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2957 20 the the DT 19613 2957 21 highest high JJS 19613 2957 22 rank rank NN 19613 2957 23 among among IN 19613 2957 24 those those DT 19613 2957 25 founded found VBN 19613 2957 26 by by IN 19613 2957 27 the the DT 19613 2957 28 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 2957 29 . . . 19613 2958 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2958 2 321 321 CD 19613 2958 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2958 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2958 5 famous famous JJ 19613 2958 6 testimony testimony NN 19613 2958 7 has have VBZ 19613 2958 8 been be VBN 19613 2958 9 quite quite RB 19613 2958 10 as as RB 19613 2958 11 often often RB 19613 2958 12 under under IN 19613 2958 13 as as IN 19613 2958 14 over over RB 19613 2958 15 - - HYPH 19613 2958 16 estimated estimate VBN 19613 2958 17 . . . 19613 2959 1 Doubtless doubtless VB 19613 2959 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2959 3 reference reference NN 19613 2959 4 to to IN 19613 2959 5 the the DT 19613 2959 6 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2959 7 Church Church NNP 19613 2959 8 is be VBZ 19613 2959 9 introduced introduce VBN 19613 2959 10 in in IN 19613 2959 11 such such PDT 19613 2959 12 a a DT 19613 2959 13 way way NN 19613 2959 14 that that WRB 19613 2959 15 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2959 16 is be VBZ 19613 2959 17 merely merely RB 19613 2959 18 mentioned mention VBN 19613 2959 19 by by IN 19613 2959 20 way way NN 19613 2959 21 of of IN 19613 2959 22 example example NN 19613 2959 23 , , , 19613 2959 24 just just RB 19613 2959 25 as as IN 19613 2959 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2959 27 also also RB 19613 2959 28 adds add VBZ 19613 2959 29 the the DT 19613 2959 30 allusion allusion NN 19613 2959 31 to to IN 19613 2959 32 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 19613 2959 33 and and CC 19613 2959 34 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 19613 2959 35 ; ; : 19613 2959 36 but but CC 19613 2959 37 there there EX 19613 2959 38 is be VBZ 19613 2959 39 quite quite RB 19613 2959 40 as as RB 19613 2959 41 little little JJ 19613 2959 42 doubt doubt NN 19613 2959 43 that that IN 19613 2959 44 this this DT 19613 2959 45 example example NN 19613 2959 46 was be VBD 19613 2959 47 no no DT 19613 2959 48 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 19613 2959 49 selection selection NN 19613 2959 50 . . . 19613 2960 1 The the DT 19613 2960 2 truth truth NN 19613 2960 3 rather rather RB 19613 2960 4 is be VBZ 19613 2960 5 that that IN 19613 2960 6 the the DT 19613 2960 7 Roman roman JJ 19613 2960 8 community community NN 19613 2960 9 _ _ NNP 19613 2960 10 must must MD 19613 2960 11 _ _ NNP 19613 2960 12 have have VBP 19613 2960 13 been be VBN 19613 2960 14 named name VBN 19613 2960 15 , , , 19613 2960 16 because because IN 19613 2960 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2960 18 decision decision NN 19613 2960 19 was be VBD 19613 2960 20 already already RB 19613 2960 21 the the DT 19613 2960 22 most most RBS 19613 2960 23 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 2960 24 and and CC 19613 2960 25 impressive impressive JJ 19613 2960 26 in in IN 19613 2960 27 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2960 28 . . . 19613 2961 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2961 2 322 322 CD 19613 2961 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2961 4 Whilst whilst IN 19613 2961 5 giving give VBG 19613 2961 6 a a DT 19613 2961 7 formal formal JJ 19613 2961 8 scheme scheme NN 19613 2961 9 of of IN 19613 2961 10 proof proof NN 19613 2961 11 that that WDT 19613 2961 12 assigned assign VBD 19613 2961 13 the the DT 19613 2961 14 same same JJ 19613 2961 15 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 2961 16 value value NN 19613 2961 17 to to IN 19613 2961 18 each each DT 19613 2961 19 Church church NN 19613 2961 20 founded found VBN 19613 2961 21 by by IN 19613 2961 22 the the DT 19613 2961 23 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2961 24 , , , 19613 2961 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2961 26 added add VBD 19613 2961 27 a a DT 19613 2961 28 reference reference NN 19613 2961 29 to to IN 19613 2961 30 particular particular JJ 19613 2961 31 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 2961 32 , , , 19613 2961 33 viz viz NNP 19613 2961 34 . . NNP 19613 2961 35 , , , 19613 2961 36 that that IN 19613 2961 37 in in IN 19613 2961 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2961 39 time time NN 19613 2961 40 many many JJ 19613 2961 41 communities community NNS 19613 2961 42 turned turn VBD 19613 2961 43 to to IN 19613 2961 44 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2961 45 in in IN 19613 2961 46 order order NN 19613 2961 47 to to TO 19613 2961 48 testify testify VB 19613 2961 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2961 50 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 2961 51 . . . 19613 2962 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2962 2 323 323 CD 19613 2962 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2962 4 As as RB 19613 2962 5 soon soon RB 19613 2962 6 as as IN 19613 2962 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2962 8 cease cease VBP 19613 2962 9 to to TO 19613 2962 10 obscure obscure VB 19613 2962 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2962 12 vision vision NN 19613 2962 13 with with IN 19613 2962 14 theories theory NNS 19613 2962 15 and and CC 19613 2962 16 keep keep VB 19613 2962 17 in in IN 19613 2962 18 view view NN 19613 2962 19 the the DT 19613 2962 20 actual actual JJ 19613 2962 21 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2962 22 , , , 19613 2962 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2962 24 have have VBP 19613 2962 25 no no DT 19613 2962 26 cause cause NN 19613 2962 27 for for IN 19613 2962 28 astonishment astonishment NN 19613 2962 29 . . . 19613 2963 1 Considering consider VBG 19613 2963 2 the the DT 19613 2963 3 active active JJ 19613 2963 4 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 2963 5 between between IN 19613 2963 6 the the DT 19613 2963 7 various various JJ 19613 2963 8 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2963 9 and and CC 19613 2963 10 the the DT 19613 2963 11 metropolis metropolis NN 19613 2963 12 , , , 19613 2963 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2963 14 was be VBD 19613 2963 15 of of IN 19613 2963 16 the the DT 19613 2963 17 utmost utmost JJ 19613 2963 18 importance importance NN 19613 2963 19 to to IN 19613 2963 20 all all DT 19613 2963 21 , , , 19613 2963 22 especially especially RB 19613 2963 23 so so RB 19613 2963 24 long long RB 19613 2963 25 as as IN 19613 2963 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 2963 27 required require VBD 19613 2963 28 financial financial JJ 19613 2963 29 aid aid NN 19613 2963 30 , , , 19613 2963 31 to to TO 19613 2963 32 be be VB 19613 2963 33 in in IN 19613 2963 34 connection connection NN 19613 2963 35 with with IN 19613 2963 36 that that DT 19613 2963 37 of of IN 19613 2963 38 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2963 39 , , , 19613 2963 40 to to TO 19613 2963 41 receive receive VB 19613 2963 42 support support NN 19613 2963 43 from from IN 19613 2963 44 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2963 45 , , , 19613 2963 46 to to TO 19613 2963 47 know know VB 19613 2963 48 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2963 49 would would MD 19613 2963 50 entertain entertain VB 19613 2963 51 travelling travel VBG 19613 2963 52 brethren brother NNS 19613 2963 53 , , , 19613 2963 54 and and CC 19613 2963 55 to to TO 19613 2963 56 have have VB 19613 2963 57 the the DT 19613 2963 58 power power NN 19613 2963 59 of of IN 19613 2963 60 recommending recommend VBG 19613 2963 61 prisoners prisoner NNS 19613 2963 62 and and CC 19613 2963 63 those those DT 19613 2963 64 pining pining NN 19613 2963 65 in in IN 19613 2963 66 the the DT 19613 2963 67 mines mine NNS 19613 2963 68 to to IN 19613 2963 69 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2963 70 influential influential JJ 19613 2963 71 intervention intervention NN 19613 2963 72 . . . 19613 2964 1 The the DT 19613 2964 2 evidence evidence NN 19613 2964 3 of of IN 19613 2964 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 2964 5 and and CC 19613 2964 6 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 2964 7 as as RB 19613 2964 8 well well RB 19613 2964 9 as as IN 19613 2964 10 the the DT 19613 2964 11 Marcia Marcia NNP 19613 2964 12 - - HYPH 19613 2964 13 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2964 14 episode episode NN 19613 2964 15 place place NN 19613 2964 16 this this DT 19613 2964 17 beyond beyond IN 19613 2964 18 doubt doubt NN 19613 2964 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2964 20 see see VB 19613 2964 21 above above RB 19613 2964 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2964 23 . . . 19613 2965 1 The the DT 19613 2965 2 efforts effort NNS 19613 2965 3 of of IN 19613 2965 4 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 2965 5 and and CC 19613 2965 6 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 2965 7 in in IN 19613 2965 8 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2965 9 have have VBP 19613 2965 10 also also RB 19613 2965 11 a a DT 19613 2965 12 bearing bearing NN 19613 2965 13 on on IN 19613 2965 14 this this DT 19613 2965 15 question question NN 19613 2965 16 , , , 19613 2965 17 and and CC 19613 2965 18 the the DT 19613 2965 19 venerable venerable JJ 19613 2965 20 bishop bishop NN 19613 2965 21 , , , 19613 2965 22 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 2965 23 , , , 19613 2965 24 did do VBD 19613 2965 25 not not RB 19613 2965 26 shrink shrink VB 19613 2965 27 from from IN 19613 2965 28 the the DT 19613 2965 29 toil toil NN 19613 2965 30 of of IN 19613 2965 31 a a DT 19613 2965 32 long long JJ 19613 2965 33 journey journey NN 19613 2965 34 to to TO 19613 2965 35 secure secure VB 19613 2965 36 the the DT 19613 2965 37 valuable valuable JJ 19613 2965 38 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2965 39 of of IN 19613 2965 40 the the DT 19613 2965 41 Roman roman JJ 19613 2965 42 Church;[324 church;[324 NN 19613 2965 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2965 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2965 45 was be VBD 19613 2965 46 not not RB 19613 2965 47 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 19613 2965 48 who who WP 19613 2965 49 came come VBD 19613 2965 50 to to IN 19613 2965 51 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 2965 52 , , , 19613 2965 53 but but CC 19613 2965 54 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 2965 55 to to IN 19613 2965 56 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 19613 2965 57 . . . 19613 2966 1 At at IN 19613 2966 2 the the DT 19613 2966 3 time time NN 19613 2966 4 when when WRB 19613 2966 5 the the DT 19613 2966 6 controversy controversy NN 19613 2966 7 with with IN 19613 2966 8 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 2966 9 ensued ensue VBN 19613 2966 10 , , , 19613 2966 11 the the DT 19613 2966 12 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2966 13 Church Church NNP 19613 2966 14 showed show VBD 19613 2966 15 all all PDT 19613 2966 16 the the DT 19613 2966 17 rest rest NN 19613 2966 18 an an DT 19613 2966 19 example example NN 19613 2966 20 of of IN 19613 2966 21 resolution resolution NN 19613 2966 22 ; ; : 19613 2966 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2966 24 was be VBD 19613 2966 25 naturally naturally RB 19613 2966 26 to to TO 19613 2966 27 be be VB 19613 2966 28 expected expect VBN 19613 2966 29 that that IN 19613 2966 30 , , , 19613 2966 31 as as IN 19613 2966 32 a a DT 19613 2966 33 necessary necessary JJ 19613 2966 34 condition condition NN 19613 2966 35 of of IN 19613 2966 36 mutual mutual JJ 19613 2966 37 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2966 38 , , , 19613 2966 39 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2966 40 should should MD 19613 2966 41 require require VB 19613 2966 42 other other JJ 19613 2966 43 communities community NNS 19613 2966 44 to to TO 19613 2966 45 recognise recognise VB 19613 2966 46 the the DT 19613 2966 47 law law NN 19613 2966 48 by by IN 19613 2966 49 which which WDT 19613 2966 50 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2966 51 had have VBD 19613 2966 52 regulated regulate VBN 19613 2966 53 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2966 54 own own JJ 19613 2966 55 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 2966 56 . . . 19613 2967 1 No no DT 19613 2967 2 community community NN 19613 2967 3 in in IN 19613 2967 4 the the DT 19613 2967 5 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2967 6 could could MD 19613 2967 7 regard regard VB 19613 2967 8 with with IN 19613 2967 9 indifference indifference NN 19613 2967 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2967 11 relationship relationship NN 19613 2967 12 to to IN 19613 2967 13 the the DT 19613 2967 14 great great JJ 19613 2967 15 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2967 16 Church Church NNP 19613 2967 17 ; ; : 19613 2967 18 almost almost RB 19613 2967 19 everyone everyone NN 19613 2967 20 had have VBD 19613 2967 21 connections connection NNS 19613 2967 22 with with IN 19613 2967 23 her -PRON- PRP 19613 2967 24 ; ; : 19613 2967 25 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2967 26 contained contain VBD 19613 2967 27 believers believer NNS 19613 2967 28 from from IN 19613 2967 29 all all PDT 19613 2967 30 the the DT 19613 2967 31 rest rest NN 19613 2967 32 . . . 19613 2968 1 As as RB 19613 2968 2 early early RB 19613 2968 3 as as IN 19613 2968 4 180 180 CD 19613 2968 5 this this DT 19613 2968 6 Church Church NNP 19613 2968 7 could could MD 19613 2968 8 point point VB 19613 2968 9 to to IN 19613 2968 10 a a DT 19613 2968 11 series series NN 19613 2968 12 of of IN 19613 2968 13 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2968 14 reaching reach VBG 19613 2968 15 in in IN 19613 2968 16 uninterrupted uninterrupted JJ 19613 2968 17 succession succession NN 19613 2968 18 from from IN 19613 2968 19 the the DT 19613 2968 20 glorious glorious JJ 19613 2968 21 apostles apostle NNS 19613 2968 22 Paul Paul NNP 19613 2968 23 and and CC 19613 2968 24 Peter[325 Peter[325 NNS 19613 2968 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2968 26 down down IN 19613 2968 27 to to IN 19613 2968 28 the the DT 19613 2968 29 present present JJ 19613 2968 30 time time NN 19613 2968 31 ; ; : 19613 2968 32 and and CC 19613 2968 33 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2968 34 alone alone RB 19613 2968 35 maintained maintain VBD 19613 2968 36 a a DT 19613 2968 37 brief brief NN 19613 2968 38 but but CC 19613 2968 39 definitely definitely RB 19613 2968 40 formulated formulate VBN 19613 2968 41 _ _ NNP 19613 2968 42 lex lex NN 19613 2968 43 _ _ NNP 19613 2968 44 , , , 19613 2968 45 which which WDT 19613 2968 46 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2968 47 entitled entitle VBD 19613 2968 48 the the DT 19613 2968 49 summary summary NNP 19613 2968 50 of of IN 19613 2968 51 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 2968 52 tradition tradition NN 19613 2968 53 , , , 19613 2968 54 and and CC 19613 2968 55 by by IN 19613 2968 56 reference reference NN 19613 2968 57 to to TO 19613 2968 58 which which WDT 19613 2968 59 she -PRON- PRP 19613 2968 60 decided decide VBD 19613 2968 61 all all DT 19613 2968 62 questions question NNS 19613 2968 63 of of IN 19613 2968 64 faith faith NN 19613 2968 65 with with IN 19613 2968 66 admirable admirable JJ 19613 2968 67 certainty certainty NN 19613 2968 68 . . . 19613 2969 1 Theories theory NNS 19613 2969 2 were be VBD 19613 2969 3 incapable incapable JJ 19613 2969 4 of of IN 19613 2969 5 overcoming overcome VBG 19613 2969 6 the the DT 19613 2969 7 elementary elementary JJ 19613 2969 8 differences difference NNS 19613 2969 9 that that WDT 19613 2969 10 could could MD 19613 2969 11 not not RB 19613 2969 12 but but RB 19613 2969 13 appear appear VB 19613 2969 14 as as RB 19613 2969 15 soon soon RB 19613 2969 16 as as IN 19613 2969 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 2969 18 became become VBD 19613 2969 19 naturalised naturalised JJ 19613 2969 20 in in IN 19613 2969 21 the the DT 19613 2969 22 various various JJ 19613 2969 23 provinces province NNS 19613 2969 24 and and CC 19613 2969 25 towns town NNS 19613 2969 26 of of IN 19613 2969 27 the the DT 19613 2969 28 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2969 29 . . . 19613 2970 1 Nor nor CC 19613 2970 2 was be VBD 19613 2970 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2970 4 theories theory NNS 19613 2970 5 that that WDT 19613 2970 6 created create VBD 19613 2970 7 the the DT 19613 2970 8 empiric empiric JJ 19613 2970 9 unity unity NN 19613 2970 10 of of IN 19613 2970 11 the the DT 19613 2970 12 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2970 13 , , , 19613 2970 14 but but CC 19613 2970 15 the the DT 19613 2970 16 unity unity NN 19613 2970 17 which which WDT 19613 2970 18 the the DT 19613 2970 19 Empire Empire NNP 19613 2970 20 possessed possess VBD 19613 2970 21 in in IN 19613 2970 22 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2970 23 ; ; : 19613 2970 24 the the DT 19613 2970 25 extent extent NN 19613 2970 26 and and CC 19613 2970 27 composition composition NN 19613 2970 28 of of IN 19613 2970 29 the the DT 19613 2970 30 Græco Græco NNP 19613 2970 31 - - HYPH 19613 2970 32 Latin Latin NNP 19613 2970 33 community community NN 19613 2970 34 there there RB 19613 2970 35 ; ; : 19613 2970 36 the the DT 19613 2970 37 security security NN 19613 2970 38 -- -- : 19613 2970 39 and and CC 19613 2970 40 this this DT 19613 2970 41 was be VBD 19613 2970 42 not not RB 19613 2970 43 the the DT 19613 2970 44 least least JJS 19613 2970 45 powerful powerful JJ 19613 2970 46 element element NN 19613 2970 47 -- -- : 19613 2970 48 that that WDT 19613 2970 49 accompanied accompany VBD 19613 2970 50 the the DT 19613 2970 51 development development NN 19613 2970 52 of of IN 19613 2970 53 this this DT 19613 2970 54 great great JJ 19613 2970 55 society society NN 19613 2970 56 , , , 19613 2970 57 well well RB 19613 2970 58 provided provide VBN 19613 2970 59 as as IN 19613 2970 60 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2970 61 was be VBD 19613 2970 62 with with IN 19613 2970 63 wealth wealth NN 19613 2970 64 and and CC 19613 2970 65 possessed possess VBD 19613 2970 66 of of IN 19613 2970 67 an an DT 19613 2970 68 influence influence NN 19613 2970 69 in in IN 19613 2970 70 high high JJ 19613 2970 71 quarters quarter NNS 19613 2970 72 already already RB 19613 2970 73 dating date VBG 19613 2970 74 from from IN 19613 2970 75 the the DT 19613 2970 76 first first JJ 19613 2970 77 century;[326 century;[326 NNPS 19613 2970 78 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2970 79 as as RB 19613 2970 80 well well RB 19613 2970 81 as as IN 19613 2970 82 the the DT 19613 2970 83 care care NN 19613 2970 84 which which WDT 19613 2970 85 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2970 86 displayed display VBD 19613 2970 87 on on IN 19613 2970 88 behalf behalf NN 19613 2970 89 of of IN 19613 2970 90 all all DT 19613 2970 91 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2970 92 . . . 19613 2971 1 _ _ NNP 19613 2971 2 All all PDT 19613 2971 3 these these DT 19613 2971 4 causes cause NNS 19613 2971 5 combined combine VBN 19613 2971 6 to to TO 19613 2971 7 convert convert VB 19613 2971 8 the the DT 19613 2971 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 2971 10 communities community NNS 19613 2971 11 into into IN 19613 2971 12 a a DT 19613 2971 13 real real JJ 19613 2971 14 confederation confederation NN 19613 2971 15 under under IN 19613 2971 16 the the DT 19613 2971 17 primacy primacy NN 19613 2971 18 of of IN 19613 2971 19 the the DT 19613 2971 20 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2971 21 Church Church NNP 19613 2971 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2971 23 and and CC 19613 2971 24 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 2971 25 under under IN 19613 2971 26 the the DT 19613 2971 27 leadership leadership NN 19613 2971 28 of of IN 19613 2971 29 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2971 30 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2971 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2971 32 . . . 19613 2971 33 _ _ NNP 19613 2971 34 This this DT 19613 2971 35 primacy primacy NN 19613 2971 36 can can MD 19613 2971 37 not not RB 19613 2971 38 of of RB 19613 2971 39 course course NN 19613 2971 40 be be VB 19613 2971 41 further far RBR 19613 2971 42 defined define VBN 19613 2971 43 , , , 19613 2971 44 for for IN 19613 2971 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2971 46 was be VBD 19613 2971 47 merely merely RB 19613 2971 48 a a DT 19613 2971 49 _ _ NNP 19613 2971 50 de de FW 19613 2971 51 facto facto FW 19613 2971 52 _ _ NNP 19613 2971 53 one one CD 19613 2971 54 . . . 19613 2972 1 But but CC 19613 2972 2 , , , 19613 2972 3 from from IN 19613 2972 4 the the DT 19613 2972 5 nature nature NN 19613 2972 6 of of IN 19613 2972 7 the the DT 19613 2972 8 case case NN 19613 2972 9 , , , 19613 2972 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2972 11 was be VBD 19613 2972 12 immediately immediately RB 19613 2972 13 shaken shake VBN 19613 2972 14 , , , 19613 2972 15 when when WRB 19613 2972 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2972 17 was be VBD 19613 2972 18 claimed claim VBN 19613 2972 19 as as IN 19613 2972 20 a a DT 19613 2972 21 _ _ NNP 19613 2972 22 legal legal JJ 19613 2972 23 _ _ NNP 19613 2972 24 right right RB 19613 2972 25 associated associate VBN 19613 2972 26 with with IN 19613 2972 27 the the DT 19613 2972 28 person person NN 19613 2972 29 of of IN 19613 2972 30 the the DT 19613 2972 31 Roman roman JJ 19613 2972 32 bishop bishop NN 19613 2972 33 . . . 19613 2973 1 That that IN 19613 2973 2 this this DT 19613 2973 3 theory theory NN 19613 2973 4 is be VBZ 19613 2973 5 more more JJR 19613 2973 6 than than IN 19613 2973 7 a a DT 19613 2973 8 hypothesis hypothesis NN 19613 2973 9 is be VBZ 19613 2973 10 shown show VBN 19613 2973 11 by by IN 19613 2973 12 several several JJ 19613 2973 13 facts fact NNS 19613 2973 14 which which WDT 19613 2973 15 prove prove VBP 19613 2973 16 the the DT 19613 2973 17 unique unique JJ 19613 2973 18 authority authority NN 19613 2973 19 as as RB 19613 2973 20 well well RB 19613 2973 21 as as IN 19613 2973 22 the the DT 19613 2973 23 interference interference NN 19613 2973 24 of of IN 19613 2973 25 the the DT 19613 2973 26 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2973 27 Church Church NNP 19613 2973 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2973 29 that that RB 19613 2973 30 is is RB 19613 2973 31 , , , 19613 2973 32 of of IN 19613 2973 33 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2973 34 bishop bishop NN 19613 2973 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2973 36 . . . 19613 2974 1 First first RB 19613 2974 2 , , , 19613 2974 3 in in IN 19613 2974 4 the the DT 19613 2974 5 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 2974 6 controversy controversy NN 19613 2974 7 -- -- : 19613 2974 8 and and CC 19613 2974 9 that that IN 19613 2974 10 too too RB 19613 2974 11 at at IN 19613 2974 12 the the DT 19613 2974 13 stage stage NN 19613 2974 14 when when WRB 19613 2974 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2974 16 was be VBD 19613 2974 17 still still RB 19613 2974 18 almost almost RB 19613 2974 19 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 2974 20 confined confine VBN 19613 2974 21 to to IN 19613 2974 22 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2974 23 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2974 24 -- -- : 19613 2974 25 the the DT 19613 2974 26 already already RB 19613 2974 27 sobered sober VBN 19613 2974 28 adherents adherent NNS 19613 2974 29 of of IN 19613 2974 30 the the DT 19613 2974 31 new new JJ 19613 2974 32 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 2974 33 petitioned petition VBD 19613 2974 34 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2974 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2974 36 bishop bishop NNP 19613 2974 37 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 19613 2974 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2974 39 to to TO 19613 2974 40 recognise recognise VB 19613 2974 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2974 42 Church Church NNP 19613 2974 43 , , , 19613 2974 44 and and CC 19613 2974 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2974 46 was be VBD 19613 2974 47 at at IN 19613 2974 48 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2974 49 that that IN 19613 2974 50 the the DT 19613 2974 51 Gallic gallic JJ 19613 2974 52 confessors confessor NNS 19613 2974 53 cautiously cautiously RB 19613 2974 54 interfered interfere VBD 19613 2974 55 in in IN 19613 2974 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2974 57 behalf behalf NN 19613 2974 58 ; ; : 19613 2974 59 after after IN 19613 2974 60 which which WDT 19613 2974 61 a a DT 19613 2974 62 native native NN 19613 2974 63 of of IN 19613 2974 64 Asia Asia NNP 19613 2974 65 Minor Minor NNP 19613 2974 66 induced induce VBD 19613 2974 67 the the DT 19613 2974 68 Roman roman JJ 19613 2974 69 bishop bishop NN 19613 2974 70 to to TO 19613 2974 71 withdraw withdraw VB 19613 2974 72 the the DT 19613 2974 73 letters letter NNS 19613 2974 74 of of IN 19613 2974 75 toleration toleration NN 19613 2974 76 already already RB 19613 2974 77 issued issue VBN 19613 2974 78 . . . 19613 2975 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2975 2 327 327 CD 19613 2975 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2975 4 In in IN 19613 2975 5 view view NN 19613 2975 6 of of IN 19613 2975 7 the the DT 19613 2975 8 facts fact NNS 19613 2975 9 that that IN 19613 2975 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2975 11 was be VBD 19613 2975 12 not not RB 19613 2975 13 Roman roman JJ 19613 2975 14 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 2975 15 who who WP 19613 2975 16 were be VBD 19613 2975 17 concerned concern VBN 19613 2975 18 , , , 19613 2975 19 that that IN 19613 2975 20 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2975 21 was be VBD 19613 2975 22 the the DT 19613 2975 23 place place NN 19613 2975 24 where where WRB 19613 2975 25 the the DT 19613 2975 26 Asiatic asiatic JJ 19613 2975 27 members member NNS 19613 2975 28 of of IN 19613 2975 29 this this DT 19613 2975 30 sect sect NN 19613 2975 31 sought seek VBD 19613 2975 32 for for IN 19613 2975 33 recognition recognition NN 19613 2975 34 , , , 19613 2975 35 and and CC 19613 2975 36 that that IN 19613 2975 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2975 38 was be VBD 19613 2975 39 in in IN 19613 2975 40 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2975 41 that that IN 19613 2975 42 the the DT 19613 2975 43 Gauls Gauls NNPS 19613 2975 44 interfered interfere VBD 19613 2975 45 in in IN 19613 2975 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2975 47 behalf behalf NN 19613 2975 48 , , , 19613 2975 49 the the DT 19613 2975 50 significance significance NN 19613 2975 51 of of IN 19613 2975 52 this this DT 19613 2975 53 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 2975 54 can can MD 19613 2975 55 not not RB 19613 2975 56 be be VB 19613 2975 57 readily readily RB 19613 2975 58 minimised minimise VBN 19613 2975 59 . . . 19613 2976 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 2976 2 can can MD 19613 2976 3 not not RB 19613 2976 4 of of RB 19613 2976 5 course course NN 19613 2976 6 dogmatise dogmatise NN 19613 2976 7 on on IN 19613 2976 8 the the DT 19613 2976 9 matter matter NN 19613 2976 10 ; ; : 19613 2976 11 but but CC 19613 2976 12 the the DT 19613 2976 13 fact fact NN 19613 2976 14 can can MD 19613 2976 15 be be VB 19613 2976 16 proved prove VBN 19613 2976 17 that that IN 19613 2976 18 the the DT 19613 2976 19 decision decision NN 19613 2976 20 of of IN 19613 2976 21 the the DT 19613 2976 22 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2976 23 Church Church NNP 19613 2976 24 must must MD 19613 2976 25 have have VB 19613 2976 26 settled settle VBN 19613 2976 27 the the DT 19613 2976 28 position position NN 19613 2976 29 of of IN 19613 2976 30 that that DT 19613 2976 31 sect sect NN 19613 2976 32 of of IN 19613 2976 33 enthusiasts enthusiast NNS 19613 2976 34 in in IN 19613 2976 35 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2976 36 . . . 19613 2977 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 2977 2 , , , 19613 2977 3 what what WP 19613 2977 4 is be VBZ 19613 2977 5 reported report VBN 19613 2977 6 to to IN 19613 2977 7 us -PRON- PRP 19613 2977 8 of of IN 19613 2977 9 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2977 10 , , , 19613 2977 11 the the DT 19613 2977 12 successor successor NN 19613 2977 13 of of IN 19613 2977 14 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 19613 2977 15 , , , 19613 2977 16 is be VBZ 19613 2977 17 still still RB 19613 2977 18 plainer plainer NN 19613 2977 19 testimony testimony NN 19613 2977 20 . . . 19613 2978 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 2978 2 ventured venture VBD 19613 2978 3 to to TO 19613 2978 4 issue issue VB 19613 2978 5 an an DT 19613 2978 6 edict edict NN 19613 2978 7 , , , 19613 2978 8 which which WDT 19613 2978 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 2978 10 may may MD 19613 2978 11 already already RB 19613 2978 12 style style VB 19613 2978 13 a a DT 19613 2978 14 peremptory peremptory JJ 19613 2978 15 one one CD 19613 2978 16 , , , 19613 2978 17 proclaiming proclaim VBG 19613 2978 18 the the DT 19613 2978 19 Roman roman JJ 19613 2978 20 practice practice NN 19613 2978 21 with with IN 19613 2978 22 regard regard NN 19613 2978 23 to to IN 19613 2978 24 the the DT 19613 2978 25 regulation regulation NN 19613 2978 26 of of IN 19613 2978 27 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 2978 28 festivals festival NNS 19613 2978 29 to to TO 19613 2978 30 be be VB 19613 2978 31 the the DT 19613 2978 32 universal universal JJ 19613 2978 33 rule rule NN 19613 2978 34 in in IN 19613 2978 35 the the DT 19613 2978 36 Church Church NNP 19613 2978 37 , , , 19613 2978 38 and and CC 19613 2978 39 declaring declare VBG 19613 2978 40 that that IN 19613 2978 41 every every DT 19613 2978 42 congregation congregation NN 19613 2978 43 , , , 19613 2978 44 that that WDT 19613 2978 45 failed fail VBD 19613 2978 46 to to TO 19613 2978 47 adopt adopt VB 19613 2978 48 the the DT 19613 2978 49 Roman roman JJ 19613 2978 50 arrangement,[328 arrangement,[328 NN 19613 2978 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2978 52 was be VBD 19613 2978 53 excluded exclude VBN 19613 2978 54 from from IN 19613 2978 55 the the DT 19613 2978 56 union union NN 19613 2978 57 of of IN 19613 2978 58 the the DT 19613 2978 59 one one CD 19613 2978 60 Church Church NNP 19613 2978 61 on on IN 19613 2978 62 the the DT 19613 2978 63 ground ground NN 19613 2978 64 of of IN 19613 2978 65 heresy heresy NN 19613 2978 66 . . . 19613 2979 1 How how WRB 19613 2979 2 would would MD 19613 2979 3 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2979 4 have have VB 19613 2979 5 ventured venture VBN 19613 2979 6 on on IN 19613 2979 7 such such PDT 19613 2979 8 an an DT 19613 2979 9 edict edict NN 19613 2979 10 -- -- : 19613 2979 11 though though IN 19613 2979 12 indeed indeed RB 19613 2979 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2979 14 had have VBD 19613 2979 15 not not RB 19613 2979 16 the the DT 19613 2979 17 power power NN 19613 2979 18 of of IN 19613 2979 19 enforcing enforce VBG 19613 2979 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2979 21 in in IN 19613 2979 22 every every DT 19613 2979 23 case case NN 19613 2979 24 -- -- : 19613 2979 25 unless unless IN 19613 2979 26 the the DT 19613 2979 27 special special JJ 19613 2979 28 prerogative prerogative NN 19613 2979 29 of of IN 19613 2979 30 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2979 31 to to TO 19613 2979 32 determine determine VB 19613 2979 33 the the DT 19613 2979 34 conditions condition NNS 19613 2979 35 of of IN 19613 2979 36 the the DT 19613 2979 37 " " `` 19613 2979 38 common common JJ 19613 2979 39 unity unity NN 19613 2979 40 " " '' 19613 2979 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2979 42 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2979 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2979 44 : : : 19613 2979 45 koinê koinê NNP 19613 2979 46 henôsis henôsis NNP 19613 2979 47 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2979 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2979 49 in in IN 19613 2979 50 the the DT 19613 2979 51 vital vital JJ 19613 2979 52 questions question NNS 19613 2979 53 of of IN 19613 2979 54 the the DT 19613 2979 55 faith faith NN 19613 2979 56 had have VBD 19613 2979 57 been be VBN 19613 2979 58 an an DT 19613 2979 59 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 2979 60 and and CC 19613 2979 61 well well RB 19613 2979 62 - - HYPH 19613 2979 63 established establish VBN 19613 2979 64 fact fact NN 19613 2979 65 ? ? . 19613 2980 1 How how WRB 19613 2980 2 could could MD 19613 2980 3 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2980 4 have have VB 19613 2980 5 addressed address VBN 19613 2980 6 such such PDT 19613 2980 7 a a DT 19613 2980 8 demand demand NN 19613 2980 9 to to IN 19613 2980 10 the the DT 19613 2980 11 independent independent JJ 19613 2980 12 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 2980 13 , , , 19613 2980 14 if if IN 19613 2980 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2980 16 had have VBD 19613 2980 17 not not RB 19613 2980 18 been be VBN 19613 2980 19 recognised recognise VBN 19613 2980 20 , , , 19613 2980 21 in in IN 19613 2980 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2980 23 capacity capacity NN 19613 2980 24 of of IN 19613 2980 25 bishop bishop NN 19613 2980 26 of of IN 19613 2980 27 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2980 28 , , , 19613 2980 29 as as IN 19613 2980 30 the the DT 19613 2980 31 special special JJ 19613 2980 32 guardian guardian NN 19613 2980 33 of of IN 19613 2980 34 the the DT 19613 2980 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2980 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2980 37 : : : 19613 2980 38 koinê koinê NNP 19613 2980 39 henôsis henôsis NNP 19613 2980 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2980 41 ? ? . 19613 2981 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2981 2 329 329 CD 19613 2981 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2981 4 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 2981 5 , , , 19613 2981 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2981 7 was be VBD 19613 2981 8 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2981 9 who who WP 19613 2981 10 formally formally RB 19613 2981 11 excluded exclude VBD 19613 2981 12 Theodotus Theodotus NNP 19613 2981 13 from from IN 19613 2981 14 Church church NN 19613 2981 15 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 2981 16 . . . 19613 2982 1 This this DT 19613 2982 2 is be VBZ 19613 2982 3 the the DT 19613 2982 4 first first JJ 19613 2982 5 really really RB 19613 2982 6 well well RB 19613 2982 7 - - HYPH 19613 2982 8 attested attest VBN 19613 2982 9 case case NN 19613 2982 10 of of IN 19613 2982 11 a a DT 19613 2982 12 Christian Christian NNP 19613 2982 13 _ _ NNP 19613 2982 14 taking take VBG 19613 2982 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2982 16 stand stand NN 19613 2982 17 on on IN 19613 2982 18 the the DT 19613 2982 19 rule rule NN 19613 2982 20 of of IN 19613 2982 21 faith faith NN 19613 2982 22 _ _ NNP 19613 2982 23 being be VBG 19613 2982 24 excommunicated excommunicate VBN 19613 2982 25 because because IN 19613 2982 26 a a DT 19613 2982 27 definite definite JJ 19613 2982 28 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 2982 29 of of IN 19613 2982 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2982 31 was be VBD 19613 2982 32 already already RB 19613 2982 33 insisted insist VBN 19613 2982 34 on on IN 19613 2982 35 . . . 19613 2983 1 In in IN 19613 2983 2 this this DT 19613 2983 3 instance instance NN 19613 2983 4 the the DT 19613 2983 5 expression expression NN 19613 2983 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2983 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2983 8 : : : 19613 2983 9 huios huios NNP 19613 2983 10 monogenês monogenês NNP 19613 2983 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2983 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2983 13 only only RB 19613 2983 14 begotten begotten VB 19613 2983 15 Son Son NNP 19613 2983 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2983 17 was be VBD 19613 2983 18 required require VBN 19613 2983 19 to to TO 19613 2983 20 be be VB 19613 2983 21 understood understand VBN 19613 2983 22 in in IN 19613 2983 23 the the DT 19613 2983 24 sense sense NN 19613 2983 25 of of IN 19613 2983 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2983 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 2983 28 : : : 19613 2983 29 Phusei Phusei NNP 19613 2983 30 Theos Theos NNPS 19613 2983 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2983 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2983 33 God God NNP 19613 2983 34 by by IN 19613 2983 35 nature nature NN 19613 2983 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2983 37 . . . 19613 2984 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2984 2 was be VBD 19613 2984 3 in in IN 19613 2984 4 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2984 5 that that IN 19613 2984 6 this this DT 19613 2984 7 first first JJ 19613 2984 8 took take VBD 19613 2984 9 place place NN 19613 2984 10 . . . 19613 2985 1 Fourthly fourthly RB 19613 2985 2 , , , 19613 2985 3 under under IN 19613 2985 4 Zephyrinus Zephyrinus NNP 19613 2985 5 , , , 19613 2985 6 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2985 7 's 's POS 19613 2985 8 successor successor NN 19613 2985 9 , , , 19613 2985 10 the the DT 19613 2985 11 Roman roman JJ 19613 2985 12 ecclesiastics ecclesiastic NNS 19613 2985 13 interfered interfere VBN 19613 2985 14 in in IN 19613 2985 15 the the DT 19613 2985 16 Carthaginian carthaginian JJ 19613 2985 17 veil veil NN 19613 2985 18 dispute dispute NN 19613 2985 19 , , , 19613 2985 20 making make VBG 19613 2985 21 common common JJ 19613 2985 22 cause cause NN 19613 2985 23 with with IN 19613 2985 24 the the DT 19613 2985 25 local local JJ 19613 2985 26 clergy clergy NN 19613 2985 27 against against IN 19613 2985 28 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2985 29 ; ; : 19613 2985 30 and and CC 19613 2985 31 both both DT 19613 2985 32 appealed appeal VBD 19613 2985 33 to to IN 19613 2985 34 the the DT 19613 2985 35 authority authority NN 19613 2985 36 of of IN 19613 2985 37 predecessors predecessor NNS 19613 2985 38 , , , 19613 2985 39 that that RB 19613 2985 40 is is RB 19613 2985 41 , , , 19613 2985 42 above above IN 19613 2985 43 all all DT 19613 2985 44 , , , 19613 2985 45 of of IN 19613 2985 46 the the DT 19613 2985 47 Roman roman JJ 19613 2985 48 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2985 49 . . . 19613 2986 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2986 2 330 330 CD 19613 2986 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2986 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2986 5 , , , 19613 2986 6 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 2986 7 , , , 19613 2986 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 2986 9 , , , 19613 2986 10 and and CC 19613 2986 11 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 2986 12 were be VBD 19613 2986 13 obliged oblige VBN 19613 2986 14 to to TO 19613 2986 15 resist resist VB 19613 2986 16 the the DT 19613 2986 17 pretensions pretension NNS 19613 2986 18 of of IN 19613 2986 19 these these DT 19613 2986 20 ecclesiastics ecclesiastic NNS 19613 2986 21 to to IN 19613 2986 22 authority authority NN 19613 2986 23 outside outside IN 19613 2986 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2986 25 own own JJ 19613 2986 26 Church church NN 19613 2986 27 , , , 19613 2986 28 the the DT 19613 2986 29 first first JJ 19613 2986 30 having have VBG 19613 2986 31 to to TO 19613 2986 32 contend contend VB 19613 2986 33 with with IN 19613 2986 34 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2986 35 , , , 19613 2986 36 and and CC 19613 2986 37 the the DT 19613 2986 38 three three CD 19613 2986 39 others other NNS 19613 2986 40 with with IN 19613 2986 41 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 2986 42 . . . 19613 2987 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2987 2 331 331 CD 19613 2987 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2987 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 2987 5 was be VBD 19613 2987 6 the the DT 19613 2987 7 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2987 8 _ _ NNP 19613 2987 9 Church Church NNP 19613 2987 10 _ _ NNP 19613 2987 11 that that IN 19613 2987 12 first first RB 19613 2987 13 displayed display VBD 19613 2987 14 this this DT 19613 2987 15 activity activity NN 19613 2987 16 and and CC 19613 2987 17 care care NN 19613 2987 18 ; ; : 19613 2987 19 the the DT 19613 2987 20 Roman roman JJ 19613 2987 21 bishop bishop NN 19613 2987 22 sprang spring VBD 19613 2987 23 from from IN 19613 2987 24 the the DT 19613 2987 25 community community NN 19613 2987 26 in in IN 19613 2987 27 exactly exactly RB 19613 2987 28 the the DT 19613 2987 29 same same JJ 19613 2987 30 way way NN 19613 2987 31 as as IN 19613 2987 32 the the DT 19613 2987 33 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 2987 34 official official NN 19613 2987 35 did do VBD 19613 2987 36 in in IN 19613 2987 37 other other JJ 19613 2987 38 places place NNS 19613 2987 39 . . . 19613 2988 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2988 2 332 332 CD 19613 2988 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2988 4 In in IN 19613 2988 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2988 6 ' ' POS 19613 2988 7 proof proof NN 19613 2988 8 from from IN 19613 2988 9 prescription prescription NN 19613 2988 10 , , , 19613 2988 11 however however RB 19613 2988 12 , , , 19613 2988 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2988 14 is be VBZ 19613 2988 15 already already RB 19613 2988 16 the the DT 19613 2988 17 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2988 18 _ _ NNP 19613 2988 19 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2988 20 _ _ NNP 19613 2988 21 that that WDT 19613 2988 22 are be VBP 19613 2988 23 specially specially RB 19613 2988 24 mentioned mention VBN 19613 2988 25 . . . 19613 2989 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2989 2 333 333 CD 19613 2989 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 2989 4 Praxeas Praxeas NNP 19613 2989 5 reminded remind VBD 19613 2989 6 the the DT 19613 2989 7 bishop bishop NN 19613 2989 8 of of IN 19613 2989 9 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2989 10 of of IN 19613 2989 11 the the DT 19613 2989 12 authority authority NN 19613 2989 13 of of IN 19613 2989 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2989 15 predecessors predecessor NNS 19613 2989 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2989 17 " " `` 19613 2989 18 auctoritates auctoritate VBZ 19613 2989 19 præcessorum præcessorum NNP 19613 2989 20 eius eius NNP 19613 2989 21 " " '' 19613 2989 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2989 23 and and CC 19613 2989 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2989 25 was be VBD 19613 2989 26 in in IN 19613 2989 27 the the DT 19613 2989 28 character character NN 19613 2989 29 of of IN 19613 2989 30 _ _ NNP 19613 2989 31 bishop bishop NNP 19613 2989 32 _ _ NNP 19613 2989 33 that that IN 19613 2989 34 Victor Victor NNP 19613 2989 35 acted act VBD 19613 2989 36 . . . 19613 2990 1 The the DT 19613 2990 2 assumption assumption NN 19613 2990 3 that that IN 19613 2990 4 Paul Paul NNP 19613 2990 5 and and CC 19613 2990 6 Peter Peter NNP 19613 2990 7 laboured labour VBD 19613 2990 8 in in IN 19613 2990 9 Rome Rome NNP 19613 2990 10 , , , 19613 2990 11 that that RB 19613 2990 12 is is RB 19613 2990 13 , , , 19613 2990 14 founded found VBD 19613 2990 15 the the DT 19613 2990 16 Church Church NNP 19613 2990 17 of of IN 19613 2990 18 that that DT 19613 2990 19 city city NN 19613 2990 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2990 21 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 2990 22 , , , 19613 2990 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 2990 24 , , , 19613 2990 25 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2990 26 , , , 19613 2990 27 Caius Caius NNP 19613 2990 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2990 29 , , , 19613 2990 30 must must MD 19613 2990 31 have have VB 19613 2990 32 conferred confer VBN 19613 2990 33 a a DT 19613 2990 34 high high JJ 19613 2990 35 degree degree NN 19613 2990 36 of of IN 19613 2990 37 prestige prestige NN 19613 2990 38 on on IN 19613 2990 39 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2990 40 bishops bishop NNS 19613 2990 41 , , , 19613 2990 42 as as RB 19613 2990 43 soon soon RB 19613 2990 44 as as IN 19613 2990 45 the the DT 19613 2990 46 latter latter JJ 19613 2990 47 officials official NNS 19613 2990 48 were be VBD 19613 2990 49 elevated elevate VBN 19613 2990 50 to to IN 19613 2990 51 the the DT 19613 2990 52 position position NN 19613 2990 53 of of IN 19613 2990 54 more more JJR 19613 2990 55 or or CC 19613 2990 56 less less JJR 19613 2990 57 sovereign sovereign JJ 19613 2990 58 lords lord NNS 19613 2990 59 of of IN 19613 2990 60 the the DT 19613 2990 61 communities community NNS 19613 2990 62 and and CC 19613 2990 63 were be VBD 19613 2990 64 regarded regard VBN 19613 2990 65 as as IN 19613 2990 66 successors successor NNS 19613 2990 67 of of IN 19613 2990 68 the the DT 19613 2990 69 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 2990 70 . . . 19613 2991 1 The the DT 19613 2991 2 first first JJ 19613 2991 3 who who WP 19613 2991 4 acted act VBD 19613 2991 5 up up RP 19613 2991 6 to to IN 19613 2991 7 this this DT 19613 2991 8 idea idea NN 19613 2991 9 was be VBD 19613 2991 10 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2991 11 . . . 19613 2992 1 The the DT 19613 2992 2 sarcastic sarcastic JJ 19613 2992 3 titles title NNS 19613 2992 4 of of IN 19613 2992 5 " " `` 19613 2992 6 pontifex pontifex NNP 19613 2992 7 maximus maximus NNP 19613 2992 8 , , , 19613 2992 9 " " '' 19613 2992 10 " " `` 19613 2992 11 episcopus episcopus NN 19613 2992 12 episcoporum episcoporum NN 19613 2992 13 , , , 19613 2992 14 " " '' 19613 2992 15 " " `` 19613 2992 16 benedictus benedictus NN 19613 2992 17 papa papa NN 19613 2992 18 " " '' 19613 2992 19 and and CC 19613 2992 20 " " `` 19613 2992 21 apostolicus apostolicus NNP 19613 2992 22 , , , 19613 2992 23 " " '' 19613 2992 24 applied apply VBD 19613 2992 25 to to IN 19613 2992 26 him -PRON- PRP 19613 2992 27 by by IN 19613 2992 28 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2992 29 in in IN 19613 2992 30 " " `` 19613 2992 31 de de FW 19613 2992 32 pudicitia pudicitia FW 19613 2992 33 " " '' 19613 2992 34 I. I. NNP 19613 2993 1 13 13 CD 19613 2993 2 , , , 19613 2993 3 are be VBP 19613 2993 4 so so RB 19613 2993 5 many many JJ 19613 2993 6 references reference NNS 19613 2993 7 to to IN 19613 2993 8 the the DT 19613 2993 9 fact fact NN 19613 2993 10 that that IN 19613 2993 11 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2993 12 already already RB 19613 2993 13 claimed claim VBD 19613 2993 14 for for IN 19613 2993 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 2993 16 a a DT 19613 2993 17 position position NN 19613 2993 18 of of IN 19613 2993 19 primacy primacy NN 19613 2993 20 , , , 19613 2993 21 in in IN 19613 2993 22 other other JJ 19613 2993 23 words word NNS 19613 2993 24 , , , 19613 2993 25 that that IN 19613 2993 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2993 27 associated associate VBD 19613 2993 28 with with IN 19613 2993 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2993 30 own own JJ 19613 2993 31 personal personal JJ 19613 2993 32 position position NN 19613 2993 33 as as IN 19613 2993 34 bishop bishop NNP 19613 2993 35 the the DT 19613 2993 36 primacy primacy NN 19613 2993 37 possessed possess VBN 19613 2993 38 by by IN 19613 2993 39 the the DT 19613 2993 40 Roman Roman NNP 19613 2993 41 Church Church NNP 19613 2993 42 , , , 19613 2993 43 which which WDT 19613 2993 44 pre pre NN 19613 2993 45 - - NN 19613 2993 46 eminence eminence VBP 19613 2993 47 , , , 19613 2993 48 however however RB 19613 2993 49 , , , 19613 2993 50 must must MD 19613 2993 51 have have VB 19613 2993 52 been be VBN 19613 2993 53 gradually gradually RB 19613 2993 54 vanishing vanish VBG 19613 2993 55 in in IN 19613 2993 56 proportion proportion NN 19613 2993 57 to to IN 19613 2993 58 the the DT 19613 2993 59 progress progress NN 19613 2993 60 of of IN 19613 2993 61 the the DT 19613 2993 62 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 2993 63 form form NN 19613 2993 64 of of IN 19613 2993 65 organisation organisation NN 19613 2993 66 among among IN 19613 2993 67 the the DT 19613 2993 68 other other JJ 19613 2993 69 communities community NNS 19613 2993 70 . . . 19613 2994 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 2994 2 , , , 19613 2994 3 that that DT 19613 2994 4 is be VBZ 19613 2994 5 evident evident JJ 19613 2994 6 from from IN 19613 2994 7 the the DT 19613 2994 8 form form NN 19613 2994 9 of of IN 19613 2994 10 the the DT 19613 2994 11 edict edict NN 19613 2994 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2994 13 issued issue VBD 19613 2994 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 2994 15 Tert Tert NNP 19613 2994 16 . . . 19613 2995 1 I. I. NNP 19613 2995 2 c. c. NNP 19613 2995 3 , , , 19613 2995 4 I -PRON- PRP 19613 2995 5 : : : 19613 2995 6 " " `` 19613 2995 7 I -PRON- PRP 19613 2995 8 hear hear VBP 19613 2995 9 that that IN 19613 2995 10 an an DT 19613 2995 11 edict edict NN 19613 2995 12 has have VBZ 19613 2995 13 been be VBN 19613 2995 14 issued issue VBN 19613 2995 15 and and CC 19613 2995 16 that that IN 19613 2995 17 a a DT 19613 2995 18 decisive decisive JJ 19613 2995 19 one one NN 19613 2995 20 , , , 19613 2995 21 " " '' 19613 2995 22 " " `` 19613 2995 23 audio audio NN 19613 2995 24 edictum edictum NNP 19613 2995 25 esse esse NNP 19613 2995 26 præpositum præpositum NNP 19613 2995 27 et et NNP 19613 2995 28 quidem quidem NNP 19613 2995 29 peremptorium peremptorium NNP 19613 2995 30 " " '' 19613 2995 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 2995 32 , , , 19613 2995 33 from from IN 19613 2995 34 the the DT 19613 2995 35 grounds ground NNS 19613 2995 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2995 37 assigned assign VBD 19613 2995 38 and and CC 19613 2995 39 from from IN 19613 2995 40 the the DT 19613 2995 41 opposition opposition NN 19613 2995 42 to to IN 19613 2995 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2995 44 on on IN 19613 2995 45 the the DT 19613 2995 46 part part NN 19613 2995 47 of of IN 19613 2995 48 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2995 49 . . . 19613 2996 1 From from IN 19613 2996 2 the the DT 19613 2996 3 form form NN 19613 2996 4 , , , 19613 2996 5 in in IN 19613 2996 6 so so RB 19613 2996 7 far far RB 19613 2996 8 as as IN 19613 2996 9 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 2996 10 acted act VBD 19613 2996 11 here here RB 19613 2996 12 quite quite RB 19613 2996 13 independently independently RB 19613 2996 14 and and CC 19613 2996 15 , , , 19613 2996 16 without without IN 19613 2996 17 previous previous JJ 19613 2996 18 consultation consultation NN 19613 2996 19 , , , 19613 2996 20 issued issue VBD 19613 2996 21 a a DT 19613 2996 22 _ _ NNP 19613 2996 23 peremptory peremptory NN 19613 2996 24 _ _ NNP 19613 2996 25 edict edict NNP 19613 2996 26 , , , 19613 2996 27 that that RB 19613 2996 28 is is RB 19613 2996 29 , , , 19613 2996 30 one one CD 19613 2996 31 settling settle VBG 19613 2996 32 the the DT 19613 2996 33 matter matter NN 19613 2996 34 and and CC 19613 2996 35 immediately immediately RB 19613 2996 36 taking take VBG 19613 2996 37 effect effect NN 19613 2996 38 ; ; : 19613 2996 39 from from IN 19613 2996 40 the the DT 19613 2996 41 grounds ground NNS 19613 2996 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2996 43 assigned assign VBD 19613 2996 44 , , , 19613 2996 45 in in IN 19613 2996 46 so so RB 19613 2996 47 far far RB 19613 2996 48 as as IN 19613 2996 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 2996 50 appealed appeal VBD 19613 2996 51 in in IN 19613 2996 52 justification justification NN 19613 2996 53 of of IN 19613 2996 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 2996 55 action action NN 19613 2996 56 to to IN 19613 2996 57 Matt Matt NNP 19613 2996 58 . . . 19613 2997 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 2997 2 . . . 19613 2998 1 18 18 CD 19613 2998 2 ff ff NN 19613 2998 3 . . . 19613 2999 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 2999 2 334]--the 334]--the DT 19613 2999 3 first first JJ 19613 2999 4 instance instance NN 19613 2999 5 of of IN 19613 2999 6 the the DT 19613 2999 7 kind kind NN 19613 2999 8 recorded record VBN 19613 2999 9 in in IN 19613 2999 10 history history NN 19613 2999 11 ; ; : 19613 2999 12 from from IN 19613 2999 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 2999 14 's 's POS 19613 2999 15 opposition opposition NN 19613 2999 16 to to IN 19613 2999 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2999 18 , , , 19613 2999 19 because because IN 19613 2999 20 the the DT 19613 2999 21 latter latter JJ 19613 2999 22 treats treat VBZ 19613 2999 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 2999 24 not not RB 19613 2999 25 as as IN 19613 2999 26 local local JJ 19613 2999 27 , , , 19613 2999 28 Roman roman JJ 19613 2999 29 , , , 19613 2999 30 but but CC 19613 2999 31 as as IN 19613 2999 32 pregnant pregnant JJ 19613 2999 33 in in IN 19613 2999 34 consequences consequence NNS 19613 2999 35 for for IN 19613 2999 36 all all DT 19613 2999 37 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 2999 38 . . . 19613 3000 1 But but CC 19613 3000 2 , , , 19613 3000 3 as as RB 19613 3000 4 soon soon RB 19613 3000 5 as as IN 19613 3000 6 the the DT 19613 3000 7 question question NN 19613 3000 8 took take VBD 19613 3000 9 the the DT 19613 3000 10 form form NN 19613 3000 11 of of IN 19613 3000 12 enquiring enquire VBG 19613 3000 13 whether whether IN 19613 3000 14 the the DT 19613 3000 15 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3000 16 _ _ NNP 19613 3000 17 bishop bishop NN 19613 3000 18 _ _ NNP 19613 3000 19 was be VBD 19613 3000 20 elevated elevate VBN 19613 3000 21 above above IN 19613 3000 22 the the DT 19613 3000 23 rest rest NN 19613 3000 24 , , , 19613 3000 25 a a DT 19613 3000 26 totally totally RB 19613 3000 27 new new JJ 19613 3000 28 situation situation NN 19613 3000 29 arose arise VBD 19613 3000 30 . . . 19613 3001 1 Even even RB 19613 3001 2 in in IN 19613 3001 3 the the DT 19613 3001 4 third third JJ 19613 3001 5 century century NN 19613 3001 6 , , , 19613 3001 7 as as IN 19613 3001 8 already already RB 19613 3001 9 shown show VBN 19613 3001 10 , , , 19613 3001 11 the the DT 19613 3001 12 Roman roman JJ 19613 3001 13 community community NN 19613 3001 14 , , , 19613 3001 15 led lead VBN 19613 3001 16 by by IN 19613 3001 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3001 18 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3001 19 , , , 19613 3001 20 still still RB 19613 3001 21 showed show VBD 19613 3001 22 the the DT 19613 3001 23 rest rest NN 19613 3001 24 an an DT 19613 3001 25 example example NN 19613 3001 26 in in IN 19613 3001 27 the the DT 19613 3001 28 process process NN 19613 3001 29 of of IN 19613 3001 30 giving give VBG 19613 3001 31 a a DT 19613 3001 32 political political JJ 19613 3001 33 constitution constitution NN 19613 3001 34 to to IN 19613 3001 35 the the DT 19613 3001 36 Church Church NNP 19613 3001 37 . . . 19613 3002 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3002 2 can can MD 19613 3002 3 also also RB 19613 3002 4 be be VB 19613 3002 5 proved prove VBN 19613 3002 6 that that IN 19613 3002 7 even even RB 19613 3002 8 far far RB 19613 3002 9 distant distant JJ 19613 3002 10 congregations congregation NNS 19613 3002 11 were be VBD 19613 3002 12 still still RB 19613 3002 13 being be VBG 19613 3002 14 bound bind VBN 19613 3002 15 to to IN 19613 3002 16 the the DT 19613 3002 17 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3002 18 Church Church NNP 19613 3002 19 through through IN 19613 3002 20 financial financial JJ 19613 3002 21 support,[335 support,[335 NNP 19613 3002 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3002 23 and and CC 19613 3002 24 that that IN 19613 3002 25 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3002 26 was be VBD 19613 3002 27 appealed appeal VBN 19613 3002 28 to to IN 19613 3002 29 in in IN 19613 3002 30 questions question NNS 19613 3002 31 of of IN 19613 3002 32 faith faith NN 19613 3002 33 , , , 19613 3002 34 just just RB 19613 3002 35 as as IN 19613 3002 36 the the DT 19613 3002 37 law law NN 19613 3002 38 of of IN 19613 3002 39 the the DT 19613 3002 40 city city NN 19613 3002 41 of of IN 19613 3002 42 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3002 43 was be VBD 19613 3002 44 invoked invoke VBN 19613 3002 45 as as IN 19613 3002 46 the the DT 19613 3002 47 standard standard NN 19613 3002 48 in in IN 19613 3002 49 civil civil JJ 19613 3002 50 questions question NNS 19613 3002 51 . . . 19613 3003 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3003 2 336 336 CD 19613 3003 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3003 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3003 5 is be VBZ 19613 3003 6 further further RB 19613 3003 7 manifest manif JJS 19613 3003 8 from from IN 19613 3003 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3003 10 's 's POS 19613 3003 11 epistles epistle NNS 19613 3003 12 that that IN 19613 3003 13 the the DT 19613 3003 14 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3003 15 Church Church NNP 19613 3003 16 was be VBD 19613 3003 17 regarded regard VBN 19613 3003 18 as as IN 19613 3003 19 the the DT 19613 3003 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3003 21 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3003 22 principalis principalis NNP 19613 3003 23 _ _ NNP 19613 3003 24 , , , 19613 3003 25 as as IN 19613 3003 26 the the DT 19613 3003 27 guardian guardian NN 19613 3003 28 _ _ NNP 19613 3003 29 par par NNP 19613 3003 30 excellence excellence NN 19613 3003 31 _ _ NNP 19613 3003 32 of of IN 19613 3003 33 the the DT 19613 3003 34 _ _ NNP 19613 3003 35 unity unity NN 19613 3003 36 _ _ NNP 19613 3003 37 of of IN 19613 3003 38 the the DT 19613 3003 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3003 40 . . . 19613 3004 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3004 2 may may MD 19613 3004 3 explain explain VB 19613 3004 4 from from IN 19613 3004 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3004 6 's 's POS 19613 3004 7 own own JJ 19613 3004 8 particular particular JJ 19613 3004 9 situation situation NN 19613 3004 10 all all DT 19613 3004 11 else else RB 19613 3004 12 that that WDT 19613 3004 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3004 14 said say VBD 19613 3004 15 in in IN 19613 3004 16 praise praise NN 19613 3004 17 of of IN 19613 3004 18 the the DT 19613 3004 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3004 20 Church Church NNP 19613 3004 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3004 22 see see VB 19613 3004 23 above above IN 19613 3004 24 p. p. NN 19613 3004 25 88 88 CD 19613 3004 26 , , , 19613 3004 27 note note VBP 19613 3004 28 2 2 CD 19613 3004 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3004 30 and and CC 19613 3004 31 specially specially RB 19613 3004 32 of of IN 19613 3004 33 the the DT 19613 3004 34 _ _ NNP 19613 3004 35 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3004 36 Petri Petri NNP 19613 3004 37 _ _ NNP 19613 3004 38 ; ; : 19613 3004 39 but but CC 19613 3004 40 the the DT 19613 3004 41 general general JJ 19613 3004 42 view view NN 19613 3004 43 that that IN 19613 3004 44 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3004 45 is be VBZ 19613 3004 46 the the DT 19613 3004 47 " " `` 19613 3004 48 matrix matrix NNP 19613 3004 49 et et NNP 19613 3004 50 radix radix NNP 19613 3004 51 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 3004 52 catholicæ catholicæ NNP 19613 3004 53 " " '' 19613 3004 54 is be VBZ 19613 3004 55 not not RB 19613 3004 56 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3004 57 to to IN 19613 3004 58 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3004 59 , , , 19613 3004 60 and and CC 19613 3004 61 the the DT 19613 3004 62 statement statement NN 19613 3004 63 that that IN 19613 3004 64 the the DT 19613 3004 65 " " `` 19613 3004 66 unitas unitas NNP 19613 3004 67 sacerdotalis sacerdotalis NNP 19613 3004 68 " " '' 19613 3004 69 originated originate VBD 19613 3004 70 in in IN 19613 3004 71 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3004 72 is be VBZ 19613 3004 73 merely merely RB 19613 3004 74 the the DT 19613 3004 75 modified modify VBN 19613 3004 76 expression expression NN 19613 3004 77 , , , 19613 3004 78 necessitated necessitate VBN 19613 3004 79 by by IN 19613 3004 80 the the DT 19613 3004 81 altered altered JJ 19613 3004 82 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 3004 83 of of IN 19613 3004 84 the the DT 19613 3004 85 Church Church NNP 19613 3004 86 , , , 19613 3004 87 for for IN 19613 3004 88 the the DT 19613 3004 89 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 3004 90 fact fact NN 19613 3004 91 that that IN 19613 3004 92 the the DT 19613 3004 93 Roman roman JJ 19613 3004 94 community community NN 19613 3004 95 was be VBD 19613 3004 96 the the DT 19613 3004 97 most most RBS 19613 3004 98 distinguished distinguished JJ 19613 3004 99 among among IN 19613 3004 100 the the DT 19613 3004 101 sister sister NN 19613 3004 102 groups group NNS 19613 3004 103 , , , 19613 3004 104 and and CC 19613 3004 105 as as IN 19613 3004 106 such such JJ 19613 3004 107 had have VBD 19613 3004 108 had have VBN 19613 3004 109 and and CC 19613 3004 110 still still RB 19613 3004 111 possessed possess VBD 19613 3004 112 the the DT 19613 3004 113 right right NN 19613 3004 114 and and CC 19613 3004 115 duty duty NN 19613 3004 116 of of IN 19613 3004 117 watching watch VBG 19613 3004 118 over over IN 19613 3004 119 the the DT 19613 3004 120 unity unity NN 19613 3004 121 of of IN 19613 3004 122 the the DT 19613 3004 123 whole whole NN 19613 3004 124 . . . 19613 3005 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3005 2 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3005 3 no no RB 19613 3005 4 doubt doubt RB 19613 3005 5 took take VBD 19613 3005 6 a a DT 19613 3005 7 further further JJ 19613 3005 8 step step NN 19613 3005 9 at at IN 19613 3005 10 the the DT 19613 3005 11 time time NN 19613 3005 12 of of IN 19613 3005 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3005 14 correspondence correspondence NN 19613 3005 15 with with IN 19613 3005 16 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 3005 17 , , , 19613 3005 18 and and CC 19613 3005 19 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 3005 20 the the DT 19613 3005 21 special special JJ 19613 3005 22 reference reference NN 19613 3005 23 of of IN 19613 3005 24 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3005 25 . . . 19613 3006 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 3006 2 . . . 19613 3007 1 to to IN 19613 3007 2 the the DT 19613 3007 3 _ _ NNP 19613 3007 4 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3007 5 Petri Petri NNP 19613 3007 6 _ _ NNP 19613 3007 7 ; ; : 19613 3007 8 but but CC 19613 3007 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3007 10 confined confine VBD 19613 3007 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3007 12 theory theory NN 19613 3007 13 to to IN 19613 3007 14 the the DT 19613 3007 15 abstractions abstraction NNS 19613 3007 16 " " `` 19613 3007 17 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3007 18 , , , 19613 3007 19 " " '' 19613 3007 20 " " `` 19613 3007 21 cathedra cathedra NNS 19613 3007 22 . . . 19613 3007 23 " " '' 19613 3008 1 In in IN 19613 3008 2 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3008 3 the the DT 19613 3008 4 importance importance NN 19613 3008 5 of of IN 19613 3008 6 this this DT 19613 3008 7 _ _ NNP 19613 3008 8 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3008 9 _ _ NNP 19613 3008 10 oscillates oscillate VBZ 19613 3008 11 between between IN 19613 3008 12 the the DT 19613 3008 13 significance significance NN 19613 3008 14 of of IN 19613 3008 15 a a DT 19613 3008 16 once once RB 19613 3008 17 existent existent NN 19613 3008 18 fact fact NN 19613 3008 19 that that WDT 19613 3008 20 continues continue VBZ 19613 3008 21 to to TO 19613 3008 22 live live VB 19613 3008 23 on on IN 19613 3008 24 as as IN 19613 3008 25 a a DT 19613 3008 26 symbol symbol NN 19613 3008 27 , , , 19613 3008 28 and and CC 19613 3008 29 that that DT 19613 3008 30 of of IN 19613 3008 31 a a DT 19613 3008 32 real real JJ 19613 3008 33 and and CC 19613 3008 34 permanent permanent JJ 19613 3008 35 court court NN 19613 3008 36 of of IN 19613 3008 37 appeal appeal NN 19613 3008 38 . . . 19613 3009 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 3009 2 , , , 19613 3009 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3009 4 did do VBD 19613 3009 5 not not RB 19613 3009 6 go go VB 19613 3009 7 the the DT 19613 3009 8 length length NN 19613 3009 9 of of IN 19613 3009 10 declaring declare VBG 19613 3009 11 that that IN 19613 3009 12 any any DT 19613 3009 13 special special JJ 19613 3009 14 authority authority NN 19613 3009 15 within within IN 19613 3009 16 the the DT 19613 3009 17 collective collective JJ 19613 3009 18 Church Church NNP 19613 3009 19 attached attach VBN 19613 3009 20 to to IN 19613 3009 21 the the DT 19613 3009 22 temporary temporary JJ 19613 3009 23 occupant occupant NN 19613 3009 24 of of IN 19613 3009 25 the the DT 19613 3009 26 _ _ NNP 19613 3009 27 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3009 28 Petri Petri NNP 19613 3009 29 _ _ NNP 19613 3009 30 . . . 19613 3010 1 If if IN 19613 3010 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3010 3 remove remove VBP 19613 3010 4 from from IN 19613 3010 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3010 6 's 's POS 19613 3010 7 abstractions abstraction NNS 19613 3010 8 everything everything NN 19613 3010 9 to to TO 19613 3010 10 which which WDT 19613 3010 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3010 12 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3010 13 thinks think VBZ 19613 3010 14 there there EX 19613 3010 15 is be VBZ 19613 3010 16 nothing nothing NN 19613 3010 17 concrete concrete JJ 19613 3010 18 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 3010 19 , , , 19613 3010 20 then then RB 19613 3010 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3010 22 must must MD 19613 3010 23 above above RB 19613 3010 24 all all DT 19613 3010 25 eliminate eliminate VB 19613 3010 26 every every DT 19613 3010 27 prerogative prerogative NN 19613 3010 28 of of IN 19613 3010 29 the the DT 19613 3010 30 Roman roman JJ 19613 3010 31 bishop bishop NN 19613 3010 32 for for IN 19613 3010 33 the the DT 19613 3010 34 time time NN 19613 3010 35 being be VBG 19613 3010 36 . . . 19613 3011 1 What what WP 19613 3011 2 remains remain VBZ 19613 3011 3 behind behind RB 19613 3011 4 is be VBZ 19613 3011 5 the the DT 19613 3011 6 special special JJ 19613 3011 7 position position NN 19613 3011 8 of of IN 19613 3011 9 the the DT 19613 3011 10 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3011 11 Church Church NNP 19613 3011 12 , , , 19613 3011 13 which which WDT 19613 3011 14 indeed indeed RB 19613 3011 15 is be VBZ 19613 3011 16 represented represent VBN 19613 3011 17 by by IN 19613 3011 18 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3011 19 bishop bishop NN 19613 3011 20 . . . 19613 3012 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3012 2 can can MD 19613 3012 3 say say VB 19613 3012 4 quite quite RB 19613 3012 5 frankly frankly RB 19613 3012 6 : : : 19613 3012 7 " " `` 19613 3012 8 owing owe VBG 19613 3012 9 to to IN 19613 3012 10 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3012 11 magnitude magnitude NN 19613 3012 12 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3012 13 ought ought MD 19613 3012 14 to to TO 19613 3012 15 have have VB 19613 3012 16 precedence precedence NN 19613 3012 17 over over IN 19613 3012 18 Carthage carthage NN 19613 3012 19 " " '' 19613 3012 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3012 21 " " `` 19613 3012 22 pro pro NNP 19613 3012 23 magnitudine magnitudine NN 19613 3012 24 sua sua NN 19613 3012 25 debet debet NN 19613 3012 26 Carthaginem Carthaginem NNP 19613 3012 27 Roma Roma NNP 19613 3012 28 præcedere præcedere NN 19613 3012 29 " " '' 19613 3012 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3012 31 and and CC 19613 3012 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3012 33 theory theory NN 19613 3012 34 : : : 19613 3012 35 " " `` 19613 3012 36 the the DT 19613 3012 37 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 3012 38 is be VBZ 19613 3012 39 one one CD 19613 3012 40 , , , 19613 3012 41 and and CC 19613 3012 42 a a DT 19613 3012 43 part part NN 19613 3012 44 of of IN 19613 3012 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3012 46 is be VBZ 19613 3012 47 held hold VBN 19613 3012 48 by by IN 19613 3012 49 each each DT 19613 3012 50 bishop bishop NN 19613 3012 51 for for IN 19613 3012 52 the the DT 19613 3012 53 whole whole NN 19613 3012 54 " " '' 19613 3012 55 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3012 56 " " `` 19613 3012 57 episcopatus episcopatus NNP 19613 3012 58 unus unus NNP 19613 3012 59 est est NNP 19613 3012 60 , , , 19613 3012 61 cuius cuius NNP 19613 3012 62 a a DT 19613 3012 63 singulis singulis NNP 19613 3012 64 in in IN 19613 3012 65 solidum solidum NNP 19613 3012 66 pars pars NNPS 19613 3012 67 tenetur tenetur NNP 19613 3012 68 " " '' 19613 3012 69 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3012 70 , , , 19613 3012 71 virtually virtually RB 19613 3012 72 excludes exclude VBZ 19613 3012 73 any any DT 19613 3012 74 special special JJ 19613 3012 75 prerogative prerogative NN 19613 3012 76 belonging belong VBG 19613 3012 77 to to IN 19613 3012 78 a a DT 19613 3012 79 particular particular JJ 19613 3012 80 bishop bishop NN 19613 3012 81 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3012 82 see see VB 19613 3012 83 also also RB 19613 3012 84 " " '' 19613 3012 85 de de IN 19613 3012 86 unit unit NN 19613 3012 87 . . . 19613 3012 88 " " '' 19613 3013 1 4 4 LS 19613 3013 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3013 3 . . . 19613 3014 1 Here here RB 19613 3014 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3014 3 have have VBP 19613 3014 4 reached reach VBN 19613 3014 5 the the DT 19613 3014 6 point point NN 19613 3014 7 that that WDT 19613 3014 8 has have VBZ 19613 3014 9 already already RB 19613 3014 10 been be VBN 19613 3014 11 briefly briefly RB 19613 3014 12 referred refer VBN 19613 3014 13 to to IN 19613 3014 14 above above RB 19613 3014 15 , , , 19613 3014 16 viz viz NNP 19613 3014 17 . . NNP 19613 3014 18 , , , 19613 3014 19 that that IN 19613 3014 20 the the DT 19613 3014 21 consolidation consolidation NN 19613 3014 22 of of IN 19613 3014 23 the the DT 19613 3014 24 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3014 25 in in IN 19613 3014 26 the the DT 19613 3014 27 Empire empire NN 19613 3014 28 after after IN 19613 3014 29 the the DT 19613 3014 30 Roman roman JJ 19613 3014 31 pattern pattern NN 19613 3014 32 could could MD 19613 3014 33 not not RB 19613 3014 34 but but RB 19613 3014 35 endanger endanger VB 19613 3014 36 the the DT 19613 3014 37 prestige prestige NN 19613 3014 38 and and CC 19613 3014 39 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3014 40 position position NN 19613 3014 41 of of IN 19613 3014 42 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3014 43 , , , 19613 3014 44 and and CC 19613 3014 45 did do VBD 19613 3014 46 in in IN 19613 3014 47 fact fact NN 19613 3014 48 do do VB 19613 3014 49 so so RB 19613 3014 50 . . . 19613 3015 1 If if IN 19613 3015 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3015 3 consider consider VBP 19613 3015 4 that that IN 19613 3015 5 each each DT 19613 3015 6 bishop bishop NN 19613 3015 7 was be VBD 19613 3015 8 the the DT 19613 3015 9 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 3015 10 sovereign sovereign NN 19613 3015 11 of of IN 19613 3015 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3015 13 own own JJ 19613 3015 14 diocese diocese NN 19613 3015 15 -- -- : 19613 3015 16 now now RB 19613 3015 17 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 3015 18 , , , 19613 3015 19 that that IN 19613 3015 20 all all DT 19613 3015 21 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3015 22 , , , 19613 3015 23 as as IN 19613 3015 24 such such JJ 19613 3015 25 , , , 19613 3015 26 were be VBD 19613 3015 27 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3015 28 to to TO 19613 3015 29 be be VB 19613 3015 30 successors successor NNS 19613 3015 31 of of IN 19613 3015 32 the the DT 19613 3015 33 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 3015 34 , , , 19613 3015 35 that that IN 19613 3015 36 , , , 19613 3015 37 moreover moreover RB 19613 3015 38 , , , 19613 3015 39 the the DT 19613 3015 40 attribute attribute NN 19613 3015 41 of of IN 19613 3015 42 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 3015 43 occupied occupy VBD 19613 3015 44 a a DT 19613 3015 45 prominent prominent JJ 19613 3015 46 position position NN 19613 3015 47 in in IN 19613 3015 48 the the DT 19613 3015 49 conception conception NN 19613 3015 50 of of IN 19613 3015 51 the the DT 19613 3015 52 episcopal episcopal NNP 19613 3015 53 office office NN 19613 3015 54 , , , 19613 3015 55 and and CC 19613 3015 56 that that IN 19613 3015 57 , , , 19613 3015 58 the the DT 19613 3015 59 metropolitan metropolitan JJ 19613 3015 60 unions union NNS 19613 3015 61 with with IN 19613 3015 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3015 63 presidents president NNS 19613 3015 64 and and CC 19613 3015 65 synods synod NNS 19613 3015 66 had have VBD 19613 3015 67 become become VBN 19613 3015 68 completely completely RB 19613 3015 69 naturalised naturalised JJ 19613 3015 70 -- -- : 19613 3015 71 in in IN 19613 3015 72 short short JJ 19613 3015 73 , , , 19613 3015 74 that that IN 19613 3015 75 the the DT 19613 3015 76 rigid rigid JJ 19613 3015 77 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 3015 78 and and CC 19613 3015 79 provincial provincial JJ 19613 3015 80 constitution constitution NN 19613 3015 81 of of IN 19613 3015 82 the the DT 19613 3015 83 Church Church NNP 19613 3015 84 had have VBD 19613 3015 85 become become VBN 19613 3015 86 an an DT 19613 3015 87 accomplished accomplished JJ 19613 3015 88 fact fact NN 19613 3015 89 , , , 19613 3015 90 so so IN 19613 3015 91 that that IN 19613 3015 92 , , , 19613 3015 93 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 3015 94 , , , 19613 3015 95 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3015 96 was be VBD 19613 3015 97 no no DT 19613 3015 98 longer long JJR 19613 3015 99 communities community NNS 19613 3015 100 , , , 19613 3015 101 but but CC 19613 3015 102 merely merely RB 19613 3015 103 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3015 104 that that WDT 19613 3015 105 had have VBD 19613 3015 106 dealings dealing NNS 19613 3015 107 with with IN 19613 3015 108 each each DT 19613 3015 109 other other JJ 19613 3015 110 , , , 19613 3015 111 then then RB 19613 3015 112 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3015 113 shall shall MD 19613 3015 114 see see VB 19613 3015 115 that that IN 19613 3015 116 a a DT 19613 3015 117 new new JJ 19613 3015 118 situation situation NN 19613 3015 119 was be VBD 19613 3015 120 thereby thereby RB 19613 3015 121 created create VBN 19613 3015 122 for for IN 19613 3015 123 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3015 124 , , , 19613 3015 125 that that RB 19613 3015 126 is is RB 19613 3015 127 , , , 19613 3015 128 for for IN 19613 3015 129 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3015 130 bishop bishop NN 19613 3015 131 . . . 19613 3016 1 In in IN 19613 3016 2 the the DT 19613 3016 3 West West NNP 19613 3016 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3016 5 was be VBD 19613 3016 6 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 3016 7 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 3016 8 through through IN 19613 3016 9 the the DT 19613 3016 10 coöperation coöperation NN 19613 3016 11 of of IN 19613 3016 12 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3016 13 that that WDT 19613 3016 14 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3016 15 found find VBD 19613 3016 16 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 3016 17 face face NN 19613 3016 18 to to IN 19613 3016 19 face face NN 19613 3016 20 with with IN 19613 3016 21 a a DT 19613 3016 22 completely completely RB 19613 3016 23 organised organise VBN 19613 3016 24 Church church NN 19613 3016 25 system system NN 19613 3016 26 . . . 19613 3017 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3017 2 behaviour behaviour NN 19613 3017 3 in in IN 19613 3017 4 the the DT 19613 3017 5 controversy controversy NN 19613 3017 6 about about IN 19613 3017 7 heretical heretical JJ 19613 3017 8 baptism baptism NN 19613 3017 9 proves prove VBZ 19613 3017 10 that that IN 19613 3017 11 in in IN 19613 3017 12 cases case NNS 19613 3017 13 of of IN 19613 3017 14 dispute dispute NN 19613 3017 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3017 16 was be VBD 19613 3017 17 resolved resolve VBN 19613 3017 18 to to TO 19613 3017 19 elevate elevate VB 19613 3017 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3017 21 theory theory NN 19613 3017 22 of of IN 19613 3017 23 the the DT 19613 3017 24 sovereign sovereign JJ 19613 3017 25 authority authority NN 19613 3017 26 of of IN 19613 3017 27 each each DT 19613 3017 28 bishop bishop NN 19613 3017 29 above above IN 19613 3017 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3017 31 theory theory NN 19613 3017 32 of of IN 19613 3017 33 the the DT 19613 3017 34 necessary necessary JJ 19613 3017 35 connection connection NN 19613 3017 36 with with IN 19613 3017 37 the the DT 19613 3017 38 _ _ NNP 19613 3017 39 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3017 40 Petri Petri NNP 19613 3017 41 _ _ NNP 19613 3017 42 . . . 19613 3018 1 But but CC 19613 3018 2 , , , 19613 3018 3 when when WRB 19613 3018 4 that that DT 19613 3018 5 levelling levelling NN 19613 3018 6 of of IN 19613 3018 7 the the DT 19613 3018 8 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 3018 9 came come VBD 19613 3018 10 about about IN 19613 3018 11 , , , 19613 3018 12 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3018 13 had have VBD 19613 3018 14 already already RB 19613 3018 15 acquired acquire VBN 19613 3018 16 rights right NNS 19613 3018 17 that that WDT 19613 3018 18 could could MD 19613 3018 19 no no RB 19613 3018 20 longer longer RB 19613 3018 21 be be VB 19613 3018 22 cancelled cancel VBN 19613 3018 23 . . . 19613 3019 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3019 2 337 337 CD 19613 3019 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3019 4 Besides besides RB 19613 3019 5 , , , 19613 3019 6 there there EX 19613 3019 7 was be VBD 19613 3019 8 one one CD 19613 3019 9 thing thing NN 19613 3019 10 that that WDT 19613 3019 11 could could MD 19613 3019 12 not not RB 19613 3019 13 be be VB 19613 3019 14 taken take VBN 19613 3019 15 from from IN 19613 3019 16 the the DT 19613 3019 17 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3019 18 Church Church NNP 19613 3019 19 , , , 19613 3019 20 nor nor CC 19613 3019 21 therefore therefore RB 19613 3019 22 from from IN 19613 3019 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3019 24 bishop bishop NN 19613 3019 25 , , , 19613 3019 26 even even RB 19613 3019 27 if if IN 19613 3019 28 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3019 29 were be VBD 19613 3019 30 denied deny VBN 19613 3019 31 the the DT 19613 3019 32 special special JJ 19613 3019 33 right right NN 19613 3019 34 to to IN 19613 3019 35 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3019 36 . . . 19613 3020 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 3020 2 . . NNP 19613 3020 3 , , , 19613 3020 4 viz viz NNP 19613 3020 5 . . NNP 19613 3020 6 , , , 19613 3020 7 the the DT 19613 3020 8 possession possession NN 19613 3020 9 of of IN 19613 3020 10 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3020 11 . . . 19613 3021 1 The the DT 19613 3021 2 site site NN 19613 3021 3 of of IN 19613 3021 4 the the DT 19613 3021 5 world world NN 19613 3021 6 's 's POS 19613 3021 7 metropolis metropolis NN 19613 3021 8 might may MD 19613 3021 9 be be VB 19613 3021 10 shifted shift VBN 19613 3021 11 , , , 19613 3021 12 but but CC 19613 3021 13 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3021 14 could could MD 19613 3021 15 not not RB 19613 3021 16 be be VB 19613 3021 17 removed remove VBN 19613 3021 18 . . . 19613 3022 1 In in IN 19613 3022 2 the the DT 19613 3022 3 long long JJ 19613 3022 4 run run NN 19613 3022 5 , , , 19613 3022 6 however however RB 19613 3022 7 , , , 19613 3022 8 the the DT 19613 3022 9 shifting shifting NN 19613 3022 10 of of IN 19613 3022 11 the the DT 19613 3022 12 capital capital NN 19613 3022 13 proved prove VBD 19613 3022 14 advantageous advantageous JJ 19613 3022 15 to to IN 19613 3022 16 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 3022 17 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3022 18 . . . 19613 3023 1 At at IN 19613 3023 2 the the DT 19613 3023 3 beginning beginning NN 19613 3023 4 of of IN 19613 3023 5 the the DT 19613 3023 6 great great JJ 19613 3023 7 epoch epoch NN 19613 3023 8 when when WRB 19613 3023 9 the the DT 19613 3023 10 alienation alienation NN 19613 3023 11 of of IN 19613 3023 12 East East NNP 19613 3023 13 from from IN 19613 3023 14 West West NNP 19613 3023 15 became become VBD 19613 3023 16 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 3023 17 and and CC 19613 3023 18 permanent permanent JJ 19613 3023 19 , , , 19613 3023 20 an an DT 19613 3023 21 emperor emperor NN 19613 3023 22 , , , 19613 3023 23 from from IN 19613 3023 24 political political JJ 19613 3023 25 grounds ground NNS 19613 3023 26 , , , 19613 3023 27 decided decide VBD 19613 3023 28 in in IN 19613 3023 29 favour favour NN 19613 3023 30 of of IN 19613 3023 31 that that DT 19613 3023 32 party party NN 19613 3023 33 in in IN 19613 3023 34 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 3023 35 " " '' 19613 3023 36 with with IN 19613 3023 37 whom whom WP 19613 3023 38 the the DT 19613 3023 39 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3023 40 in in IN 19613 3023 41 Italy Italy NNP 19613 3023 42 and and CC 19613 3023 43 the the DT 19613 3023 44 city city NN 19613 3023 45 of of IN 19613 3023 46 the the DT 19613 3023 47 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 3023 48 held hold VBN 19613 3023 49 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 3023 50 " " '' 19613 3023 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3023 52 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3023 53 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3023 54 : : : 19613 3023 55 hois hois NNP 19613 3023 56 an an DT 19613 3023 57 hoi hoi NNP 19613 3023 58 kata kata NN 19613 3023 59 tên tên NN 19613 3023 60 Italian italian JJ 19613 3023 61 kai kai NNP 19613 3023 62 tên tên NN 19613 3023 63 Rhômaiôn Rhômaiôn NNP 19613 3023 64 polin polin NNP 19613 3023 65 episkopoi episkopoi NNP 19613 3023 66 tou tou NNP 19613 3023 67 dogmatos dogmatos NNP 19613 3023 68 epistelloien][338 epistelloien][338 NNP 19613 3023 69 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3023 70 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3023 71 . . . 19613 3024 1 In in IN 19613 3024 2 this this DT 19613 3024 3 instance instance NN 19613 3024 4 the the DT 19613 3024 5 interest interest NN 19613 3024 6 of of IN 19613 3024 7 the the DT 19613 3024 8 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3024 9 Church Church NNP 19613 3024 10 and and CC 19613 3024 11 the the DT 19613 3024 12 interest interest NN 19613 3024 13 of of IN 19613 3024 14 the the DT 19613 3024 15 emperor emperor NN 19613 3024 16 coincided coincide VBD 19613 3024 17 . . . 19613 3025 1 But but CC 19613 3025 2 the the DT 19613 3025 3 Churches church NNS 19613 3025 4 in in IN 19613 3025 5 the the DT 19613 3025 6 various various JJ 19613 3025 7 provinces province NNS 19613 3025 8 , , , 19613 3025 9 being be VBG 19613 3025 10 now now RB 19613 3025 11 completely completely RB 19613 3025 12 organised organised JJ 19613 3025 13 and and CC 19613 3025 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 3025 15 seldom seldom RB 19613 3025 16 in in IN 19613 3025 17 need need NN 19613 3025 18 of of IN 19613 3025 19 any any DT 19613 3025 20 more more JJR 19613 3025 21 help help NN 19613 3025 22 from from IN 19613 3025 23 outside outside RB 19613 3025 24 , , , 19613 3025 25 were be VBD 19613 3025 26 henceforth henceforth RB 19613 3025 27 in in IN 19613 3025 28 a a DT 19613 3025 29 position position NN 19613 3025 30 to to TO 19613 3025 31 pursue pursue VB 19613 3025 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3025 33 own own JJ 19613 3025 34 interest interest NN 19613 3025 35 . . . 19613 3026 1 So so RB 19613 3026 2 the the DT 19613 3026 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 3026 4 of of IN 19613 3026 5 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3026 6 had have VBD 19613 3026 7 step step NN 19613 3026 8 by by IN 19613 3026 9 step step NN 19613 3026 10 to to TO 19613 3026 11 fight fight VB 19613 3026 12 for for IN 19613 3026 13 the the DT 19613 3026 14 new new JJ 19613 3026 15 authority authority NN 19613 3026 16 , , , 19613 3026 17 which which WDT 19613 3026 18 , , , 19613 3026 19 being be VBG 19613 3026 20 now now RB 19613 3026 21 based base VBN 19613 3026 22 on on IN 19613 3026 23 a a DT 19613 3026 24 purely purely RB 19613 3026 25 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 3026 26 theory theory NN 19613 3026 27 and and CC 19613 3026 28 being be VBG 19613 3026 29 forced force VBN 19613 3026 30 to to TO 19613 3026 31 repudiate repudiate VB 19613 3026 32 any any DT 19613 3026 33 empirical empirical JJ 19613 3026 34 foundation foundation NN 19613 3026 35 , , , 19613 3026 36 was be VBD 19613 3026 37 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 19613 3026 38 with with IN 19613 3026 39 the the DT 19613 3026 40 Church Church NNP 19613 3026 41 system system NN 19613 3026 42 that that IN 19613 3026 43 the the DT 19613 3026 44 Roman roman JJ 19613 3026 45 community community NN 19613 3026 46 more more JJR 19613 3026 47 than than IN 19613 3026 48 any any DT 19613 3026 49 other other JJ 19613 3026 50 had have VBD 19613 3026 51 helped help VBN 19613 3026 52 to to TO 19613 3026 53 build build VB 19613 3026 54 up up RP 19613 3026 55 . . . 19613 3027 1 The the DT 19613 3027 2 proposition proposition NN 19613 3027 3 " " `` 19613 3027 4 the the DT 19613 3027 5 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3027 6 Church Church NNP 19613 3027 7 always always RB 19613 3027 8 had have VBD 19613 3027 9 the the DT 19613 3027 10 primacy primacy NN 19613 3027 11 " " '' 19613 3027 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3027 13 " " '' 19613 3027 14 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3027 15 Romana Romana NNP 19613 3027 16 semper semper NN 19613 3027 17 habuit habuit NN 19613 3027 18 primatum primatum NN 19613 3027 19 " " '' 19613 3027 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3027 21 and and CC 19613 3027 22 the the DT 19613 3027 23 statement statement NN 19613 3027 24 that that IN 19613 3027 25 " " `` 19613 3027 26 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 3027 27 " " '' 19613 3027 28 virtually virtually RB 19613 3027 29 means mean VBZ 19613 3027 30 " " '' 19613 3027 31 Roman roman JJ 19613 3027 32 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3027 33 " " '' 19613 3027 34 are be VBP 19613 3027 35 gross gross JJ 19613 3027 36 fictions fiction NNS 19613 3027 37 , , , 19613 3027 38 when when WRB 19613 3027 39 devised devise VBN 19613 3027 40 in in IN 19613 3027 41 honour honour NN 19613 3027 42 of of IN 19613 3027 43 the the DT 19613 3027 44 temporary temporary JJ 19613 3027 45 occupant occupant NN 19613 3027 46 of of IN 19613 3027 47 the the DT 19613 3027 48 Roman Roman NNPS 19613 3027 49 see see VBP 19613 3027 50 and and CC 19613 3027 51 detached detach VBD 19613 3027 52 from from IN 19613 3027 53 the the DT 19613 3027 54 significance significance NN 19613 3027 55 of of IN 19613 3027 56 the the DT 19613 3027 57 Eternal Eternal NNP 19613 3027 58 City City NNP 19613 3027 59 in in IN 19613 3027 60 profane profane NN 19613 3027 61 history history NN 19613 3027 62 ; ; : 19613 3027 63 but but CC 19613 3027 64 , , , 19613 3027 65 applied apply VBD 19613 3027 66 to to IN 19613 3027 67 the the DT 19613 3027 68 _ _ NNP 19613 3027 69 Church Church NNP 19613 3027 70 _ _ NNP 19613 3027 71 of of IN 19613 3027 72 the the DT 19613 3027 73 imperial imperial JJ 19613 3027 74 capital capital NN 19613 3027 75 , , , 19613 3027 76 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3027 77 contain contain VBP 19613 3027 78 a a DT 19613 3027 79 truth truth NN 19613 3027 80 the the DT 19613 3027 81 denial denial NN 19613 3027 82 of of IN 19613 3027 83 which which WDT 19613 3027 84 is be VBZ 19613 3027 85 equivalent equivalent JJ 19613 3027 86 to to IN 19613 3027 87 renouncing renounce VBG 19613 3027 88 the the DT 19613 3027 89 attempt attempt NN 19613 3027 90 to to TO 19613 3027 91 explain explain VB 19613 3027 92 the the DT 19613 3027 93 process process NN 19613 3027 94 by by IN 19613 3027 95 which which WDT 19613 3027 96 the the DT 19613 3027 97 Church Church NNP 19613 3027 98 was be VBD 19613 3027 99 unified unify VBN 19613 3027 100 and and CC 19613 3027 101 catholicised catholicise VBN 19613 3027 102 . . . 19613 3028 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3028 2 339 339 CD 19613 3028 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3028 4 Footnotes footnote NNS 19613 3028 5 : : : 19613 3028 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3028 7 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3028 8 193 193 CD 19613 3028 9 : : : 19613 3028 10 See see VB 19613 3028 11 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 3028 12 , , , 19613 3028 13 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3028 14 . . . 19613 3029 1 ; ; : 19613 3029 2 Schwegler Schwegler NNP 19613 3029 3 . . . 19613 3030 1 Der Der NNP 19613 3030 2 Montanismus Montanismus NNP 19613 3030 3 , , , 19613 3030 4 1841 1841 CD 19613 3030 5 ; ; : 19613 3030 6 Gottwald Gottwald NNP 19613 3030 7 , , , 19613 3030 8 De De NNP 19613 3030 9 Montanismo Montanismo NNP 19613 3030 10 Tertulliani Tertulliani NNP 19613 3030 11 , , , 19613 3030 12 1862 1862 CD 19613 3030 13 ; ; : 19613 3030 14 Réville Réville NNP 19613 3030 15 , , , 19613 3030 16 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3030 17 . . . 19613 3031 1 et et FW 19613 3031 2 le le NNP 19613 3031 3 Montanisme Montanisme NNP 19613 3031 4 , , , 19613 3031 5 in in IN 19613 3031 6 the the DT 19613 3031 7 Revue Revue NNP 19613 3031 8 des des NNP 19613 3031 9 Deux Deux NNP 19613 3031 10 Mondes Mondes NNP 19613 3031 11 of of IN 19613 3031 12 1st 1st NNP 19613 3031 13 Novr Novr NNP 19613 3031 14 . . . 19613 3032 1 1864 1864 CD 19613 3032 2 ; ; : 19613 3032 3 Stroehlin Stroehlin NNP 19613 3032 4 , , , 19613 3032 5 Essai Essai NNP 19613 3032 6 sur sur FW 19613 3032 7 le le NNP 19613 3032 8 Montanisme Montanisme NNP 19613 3032 9 , , , 19613 3032 10 1870 1870 CD 19613 3032 11 ; ; : 19613 3032 12 De De NNP 19613 3032 13 Soyres Soyres NNP 19613 3032 14 , , , 19613 3032 15 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3032 16 and and CC 19613 3032 17 the the DT 19613 3032 18 Primitive Primitive NNP 19613 3032 19 Church Church NNP 19613 3032 20 , , , 19613 3032 21 1878 1878 CD 19613 3032 22 ; ; : 19613 3032 23 Cunningham Cunningham NNP 19613 3032 24 , , , 19613 3032 25 The the DT 19613 3032 26 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3032 27 of of IN 19613 3032 28 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3032 29 , , , 19613 3032 30 1880 1880 CD 19613 3032 31 ; ; : 19613 3032 32 Renan Renan NNP 19613 3032 33 , , , 19613 3032 34 Les Les NNP 19613 3032 35 Crises Crises NNP 19613 3032 36 du du VBP 19613 3032 37 Catholicisme Catholicisme NNP 19613 3032 38 Naissant Naissant NNP 19613 3032 39 in in IN 19613 3032 40 the the DT 19613 3032 41 Revue Revue NNP 19613 3032 42 des des NNP 19613 3032 43 Deux Deux NNP 19613 3032 44 Mondes Mondes NNP 19613 3032 45 of of IN 19613 3032 46 15th 15th JJ 19613 3032 47 Febr Febr NNP 19613 3032 48 . . . 19613 3033 1 1881 1881 CD 19613 3033 2 ; ; : 19613 3033 3 Renan Renan NNP 19613 3033 4 , , , 19613 3033 5 Marc Marc NNP 19613 3033 6 Aurèle Aurèle NNP 19613 3033 7 , , , 19613 3033 8 1882 1882 CD 19613 3033 9 , , , 19613 3033 10 p. p. NN 19613 3033 11 208 208 CD 19613 3033 12 ff ff NN 19613 3033 13 . . . 19613 3034 1 ; ; : 19613 3034 2 Bonwetsch Bonwetsch NNP 19613 3034 3 , , , 19613 3034 4 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 3034 5 des des NNP 19613 3034 6 Montanismus Montanismus NNP 19613 3034 7 , , , 19613 3034 8 1881 1881 CD 19613 3034 9 ; ; : 19613 3034 10 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 3034 11 , , , 19613 3034 12 Das Das NNP 19613 3034 13 Monchthum Monchthum NNP 19613 3034 14 , , , 19613 3034 15 seine seine NN 19613 3034 16 Ideale ideale JJ 19613 3034 17 und und JJ 19613 3034 18 seine seine NN 19613 3034 19 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 3034 20 , , , 19613 3034 21 3rd 3rd NN 19613 3034 22 . . . 19613 3035 1 ed ed NNP 19613 3035 2 . . NNP 19613 3035 3 , , , 19613 3035 4 1886 1886 CD 19613 3035 5 ; ; : 19613 3035 6 Belck Belck NNP 19613 3035 7 , , , 19613 3035 8 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 3035 9 des des FW 19613 3035 10 Montanismus Montanismus NNP 19613 3035 11 , , , 19613 3035 12 1883 1883 CD 19613 3035 13 ; ; : 19613 3035 14 Voigt Voigt NNP 19613 3035 15 , , , 19613 3035 16 Eine Eine NNP 19613 3035 17 verschollene verschollene NN 19613 3035 18 Urkunde Urkunde NNP 19613 3035 19 des des NNP 19613 3035 20 antimontanistischen antimontanistischen NNP 19613 3035 21 Kampfes Kampfes NNP 19613 3035 22 , , , 19613 3035 23 1891 1891 CD 19613 3035 24 . . . 19613 3036 1 Further further RB 19613 3036 2 the the DT 19613 3036 3 articles article NNS 19613 3036 4 on on IN 19613 3036 5 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3036 6 by by IN 19613 3036 7 Moller Moller NNP 19613 3036 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3036 9 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 3036 10 's 's POS 19613 3036 11 Real Real NNP 19613 3036 12 - - HYPH 19613 3036 13 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 3036 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3036 15 , , , 19613 3036 16 Salmon Salmon NNP 19613 3036 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3036 18 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 19613 3036 19 of of IN 19613 3036 20 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3036 21 Biography Biography NNP 19613 3036 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3036 23 , , , 19613 3036 24 and and CC 19613 3036 25 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 3036 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3036 27 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP 19613 3036 28 Britannica Britannica NNP 19613 3036 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3036 30 . . . 19613 3037 1 Weizsäcker weizsäcker NN 19613 3037 2 in in IN 19613 3037 3 the the DT 19613 3037 4 Theologische Theologische NNP 19613 3037 5 Litteraturzeitung Litteraturzeitung NNP 19613 3037 6 , , , 19613 3037 7 1882 1882 CD 19613 3037 8 , , , 19613 3037 9 no no UH 19613 3037 10 . . . 19613 3038 1 4 4 LS 19613 3038 2 ; ; : 19613 3038 3 Bonwetsch Bonwetsch NNP 19613 3038 4 , , , 19613 3038 5 Die Die NNP 19613 3038 6 Prophetie Prophetie NNP 19613 3038 7 i -PRON- PRP 19613 3038 8 m be VBP 19613 3038 9 apostolischen apostolischen NNP 19613 3038 10 und und VB 19613 3038 11 nachapostolischen nachapostolischen NNP 19613 3038 12 Zeitalter Zeitalter NNP 19613 3038 13 in in IN 19613 3038 14 the the DT 19613 3038 15 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 3038 16 fur fur NN 19613 3038 17 kirchliche kirchliche NN 19613 3038 18 Wissenschaft Wissenschaft NNP 19613 3038 19 und und JJ 19613 3038 20 kirchliches kirchliche NNS 19613 3038 21 Leben Leben NNP 19613 3038 22 , , , 19613 3038 23 1884 1884 CD 19613 3038 24 , , , 19613 3038 25 Parts Parts NNP 19613 3038 26 8 8 CD 19613 3038 27 , , , 19613 3038 28 9 9 CD 19613 3038 29 ; ; : 19613 3038 30 M. M. NNP 19613 3038 31 von von NNP 19613 3038 32 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 3038 33 , , , 19613 3038 34 Die Die NNP 19613 3038 35 ersten ersten VBD 19613 3038 36 Versuche Versuche NNP 19613 3038 37 zur zur NNP 19613 3038 38 Aufrichtung Aufrichtung NNP 19613 3038 39 des des NNP 19613 3038 40 wahren wahren IN 19613 3038 41 Christenthums Christenthums NNPS 19613 3038 42 in in IN 19613 3038 43 einer einer NN 19613 3038 44 Gemeinde Gemeinde NNP 19613 3038 45 von von NNP 19613 3038 46 Heiligen Heiligen NNP 19613 3038 47 , , , 19613 3038 48 Riga Riga NNP 19613 3038 49 , , , 19613 3038 50 1881 1881 CD 19613 3038 51 . . . 19613 3038 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3039 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3039 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3039 3 194 194 CD 19613 3039 4 : : : 19613 3039 5 In in IN 19613 3039 6 certain certain JJ 19613 3039 7 vital vital JJ 19613 3039 8 points point NNS 19613 3039 9 the the DT 19613 3039 10 conception conception NN 19613 3039 11 of of IN 19613 3039 12 the the DT 19613 3039 13 original original JJ 19613 3039 14 nature nature NN 19613 3039 15 and and CC 19613 3039 16 history history NN 19613 3039 17 of of IN 19613 3039 18 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3039 19 , , , 19613 3039 20 as as IN 19613 3039 21 sketched sketch VBN 19613 3039 22 in in IN 19613 3039 23 the the DT 19613 3039 24 following following JJ 19613 3039 25 account account NN 19613 3039 26 , , , 19613 3039 27 does do VBZ 19613 3039 28 not not RB 19613 3039 29 correspond correspond VB 19613 3039 30 with with IN 19613 3039 31 that that DT 19613 3039 32 traditionally traditionally RB 19613 3039 33 current current JJ 19613 3039 34 . . . 19613 3040 1 To to TO 19613 3040 2 establish establish VB 19613 3040 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3040 4 in in IN 19613 3040 5 detail detail NN 19613 3040 6 would would MD 19613 3040 7 lead lead VB 19613 3040 8 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3040 9 too too RB 19613 3040 10 far far RB 19613 3040 11 . . . 19613 3041 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3041 2 may may MD 19613 3041 3 be be VB 19613 3041 4 noted note VBN 19613 3041 5 that that IN 19613 3041 6 the the DT 19613 3041 7 mistakes mistake NNS 19613 3041 8 in in IN 19613 3041 9 estimating estimate VBG 19613 3041 10 the the DT 19613 3041 11 original original JJ 19613 3041 12 character character NN 19613 3041 13 of of IN 19613 3041 14 this this DT 19613 3041 15 movement movement NN 19613 3041 16 arise arise VB 19613 3041 17 from from IN 19613 3041 18 a a DT 19613 3041 19 superficial superficial JJ 19613 3041 20 examination examination NN 19613 3041 21 of of IN 19613 3041 22 the the DT 19613 3041 23 oracles oracle NNS 19613 3041 24 preserved preserve VBN 19613 3041 25 to to IN 19613 3041 26 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3041 27 and and CC 19613 3041 28 from from IN 19613 3041 29 the the DT 19613 3041 30 unjustifiable unjustifiable JJ 19613 3041 31 practice practice NN 19613 3041 32 of of IN 19613 3041 33 interpreting interpret VBG 19613 3041 34 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3041 35 in in IN 19613 3041 36 accordance accordance NN 19613 3041 37 with with IN 19613 3041 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3041 39 later later JJ 19613 3041 40 application application NN 19613 3041 41 in in IN 19613 3041 42 the the DT 19613 3041 43 circles circle NNS 19613 3041 44 of of IN 19613 3041 45 Western Western NNP 19613 3041 46 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3041 47 . . . 19613 3042 1 A a DT 19613 3042 2 completely completely RB 19613 3042 3 new new JJ 19613 3042 4 organisation organisation NN 19613 3042 5 of of IN 19613 3042 6 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 3042 7 , , , 19613 3042 8 beginning begin VBG 19613 3042 9 with with IN 19613 3042 10 the the DT 19613 3042 11 Church Church NNP 19613 3042 12 in in IN 19613 3042 13 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3042 14 , , , 19613 3042 15 to to TO 19613 3042 16 be be VB 19613 3042 17 brought bring VBN 19613 3042 18 about about RP 19613 3042 19 by by IN 19613 3042 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3042 21 being be VBG 19613 3042 22 detached detach VBN 19613 3042 23 from from IN 19613 3042 24 the the DT 19613 3042 25 bonds bond NNS 19613 3042 26 of of IN 19613 3042 27 the the DT 19613 3042 28 communities community NNS 19613 3042 29 and and CC 19613 3042 30 collected collect VBN 19613 3042 31 into into IN 19613 3042 32 one one CD 19613 3042 33 region region NN 19613 3042 34 , , , 19613 3042 35 was be VBD 19613 3042 36 the the DT 19613 3042 37 main main JJ 19613 3042 38 effort effort NN 19613 3042 39 of of IN 19613 3042 40 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3042 41 . . . 19613 3043 1 In in IN 19613 3043 2 this this DT 19613 3043 3 way way NN 19613 3043 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3043 5 expected expect VBD 19613 3043 6 to to TO 19613 3043 7 restore restore VB 19613 3043 8 to to IN 19613 3043 9 the the DT 19613 3043 10 Church Church NNP 19613 3043 11 a a DT 19613 3043 12 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 3043 13 character character NN 19613 3043 14 and and CC 19613 3043 15 fulfil fulfil VB 19613 3043 16 the the DT 19613 3043 17 promises promise NNS 19613 3043 18 contained contain VBN 19613 3043 19 in in IN 19613 3043 20 John John NNP 19613 3043 21 . . . 19613 3044 1 That that DT 19613 3044 2 is be VBZ 19613 3044 3 clear clear JJ 19613 3044 4 from from IN 19613 3044 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3044 6 . . NNP 19613 3044 7 , , , 19613 3044 8 V. V. NNP 19613 3044 9 16 16 CD 19613 3044 10 ff ff NN 19613 3044 11 . . . 19613 3045 1 as as RB 19613 3045 2 well well RB 19613 3045 3 as as IN 19613 3045 4 from from IN 19613 3045 5 the the DT 19613 3045 6 later later JJ 19613 3045 7 history history NN 19613 3045 8 of of IN 19613 3045 9 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3045 10 in in IN 19613 3045 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3045 12 native native JJ 19613 3045 13 land land NN 19613 3045 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3045 15 see see VB 19613 3045 16 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 3045 17 , , , 19613 3045 18 ep ep NNP 19613 3045 19 . . . 19613 3046 1 41 41 CD 19613 3046 2 ; ; : 19613 3046 3 Epiphan Epiphan NNP 19613 3046 4 . . NNP 19613 3046 5 , , , 19613 3046 6 H. H. NNP 19613 3046 7 49 49 CD 19613 3046 8 . . . 19613 3047 1 2 2 CD 19613 3047 2 etc etc FW 19613 3047 3 . . . 19613 3047 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3047 5 . . . 19613 3048 1 In in IN 19613 3048 2 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3048 3 , , , 19613 3048 4 however however RB 19613 3048 5 , , , 19613 3048 6 apart apart RB 19613 3048 7 from from IN 19613 3048 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3048 9 particular particular JJ 19613 3048 10 explanation explanation NN 19613 3048 11 in in IN 19613 3048 12 the the DT 19613 3048 13 case case NN 19613 3048 14 of of IN 19613 3048 15 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3048 16 , , , 19613 3048 17 the the DT 19613 3048 18 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 3048 19 to to TO 19613 3048 20 detach detach VB 19613 3048 21 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3048 22 from from IN 19613 3048 23 the the DT 19613 3048 24 local local JJ 19613 3048 25 Church Church NNP 19613 3048 26 unions union NNS 19613 3048 27 has have VBZ 19613 3048 28 so so RB 19613 3048 29 little little JJ 19613 3048 30 that that DT 19613 3048 31 is be VBZ 19613 3048 32 striking strike VBG 19613 3048 33 about about IN 19613 3048 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3048 35 , , , 19613 3048 36 that that IN 19613 3048 37 one one CD 19613 3048 38 rather rather RB 19613 3048 39 wonders wonder VBZ 19613 3048 40 at at IN 19613 3048 41 being be VBG 19613 3048 42 unable unable JJ 19613 3048 43 to to TO 19613 3048 44 point point VB 19613 3048 45 to to IN 19613 3048 46 any any DT 19613 3048 47 parallel parallel NN 19613 3048 48 in in IN 19613 3048 49 the the DT 19613 3048 50 earliest early JJS 19613 3048 51 history history NN 19613 3048 52 of of IN 19613 3048 53 the the DT 19613 3048 54 Church Church NNP 19613 3048 55 . . . 19613 3049 1 Wherever wherever WRB 19613 3049 2 religious religious JJ 19613 3049 3 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 3049 4 has have VBZ 19613 3049 5 been be VBN 19613 3049 6 strong strong JJ 19613 3049 7 , , , 19613 3049 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3049 9 has have VBZ 19613 3049 10 at at RB 19613 3049 11 all all DT 19613 3049 12 times time NNS 19613 3049 13 felt feel VBD 19613 3049 14 that that IN 19613 3049 15 nothing nothing NN 19613 3049 16 hinders hinder VBZ 19613 3049 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3049 18 effect effect NN 19613 3049 19 more more JJR 19613 3049 20 than than IN 19613 3049 21 family family NN 19613 3049 22 ties tie NNS 19613 3049 23 and and CC 19613 3049 24 home home NN 19613 3049 25 connections connection NNS 19613 3049 26 . . . 19613 3050 1 But but CC 19613 3050 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3050 3 is be VBZ 19613 3050 4 just just RB 19613 3050 5 from from IN 19613 3050 6 the the DT 19613 3050 7 absence absence NN 19613 3050 8 of of IN 19613 3050 9 similar similar JJ 19613 3050 10 undertakings undertaking NNS 19613 3050 11 in in IN 19613 3050 12 the the DT 19613 3050 13 earliest early JJS 19613 3050 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3050 15 that that IN 19613 3050 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3050 17 are be VBP 19613 3050 18 justified justify VBN 19613 3050 19 in in IN 19613 3050 20 concluding conclude VBG 19613 3050 21 that that IN 19613 3050 22 the the DT 19613 3050 23 strength strength NN 19613 3050 24 of of IN 19613 3050 25 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 3050 26 exaltation exaltation NN 19613 3050 27 is be VBZ 19613 3050 28 no no DT 19613 3050 29 standard standard NN 19613 3050 30 for for IN 19613 3050 31 the the DT 19613 3050 32 strength strength NN 19613 3050 33 of of IN 19613 3050 34 _ _ NNP 19613 3050 35 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3050 36 _ _ NNP 19613 3050 37 faith faith NN 19613 3050 38 . . . 19613 3051 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3051 2 Since since IN 19613 3051 3 these these DT 19613 3051 4 words word NNS 19613 3051 5 were be VBD 19613 3051 6 written write VBN 19613 3051 7 , , , 19613 3051 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3051 9 have have VBP 19613 3051 10 read read VBN 19613 3051 11 in in IN 19613 3051 12 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3051 13 ' ' POS 19613 3051 14 Commentary Commentary NNP 19613 3051 15 on on IN 19613 3051 16 Daniel Daniel NNP 19613 3051 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3051 18 see see VBP 19613 3051 19 Georgiades Georgiades NNP 19613 3051 20 in in IN 19613 3051 21 the the DT 19613 3051 22 journal journal NN 19613 3051 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3051 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3051 25 : : : 19613 3051 26 Ekkl Ekkl NNP 19613 3051 27 . . . 19613 3052 1 alêtheia alêtheia NNP 19613 3052 2 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3052 3 1885 1885 CD 19613 3052 4 , , , 19613 3052 5 p. p. NN 19613 3052 6 52 52 CD 19613 3052 7 sq sq NNP 19613 3052 8 . . NNP 19613 3052 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3053 1 very very RB 19613 3053 2 interesting interesting JJ 19613 3053 3 accounts account NNS 19613 3053 4 of of IN 19613 3053 5 such such JJ 19613 3053 6 undertakings undertaking NNS 19613 3053 7 in in IN 19613 3053 8 the the DT 19613 3053 9 time time NN 19613 3053 10 of of IN 19613 3053 11 Septimius Septimius NNP 19613 3053 12 Severus Severus NNP 19613 3053 13 . . . 19613 3054 1 A a DT 19613 3054 2 Syrian syrian JJ 19613 3054 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 3054 4 persuaded persuade VBD 19613 3054 5 many many JJ 19613 3054 6 brethren brother NNS 19613 3054 7 with with IN 19613 3054 8 wives wife NNS 19613 3054 9 and and CC 19613 3054 10 children child NNS 19613 3054 11 to to TO 19613 3054 12 go go VB 19613 3054 13 to to TO 19613 3054 14 meet meet VB 19613 3054 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3054 16 in in IN 19613 3054 17 the the DT 19613 3054 18 wilderness wilderness NN 19613 3054 19 ; ; , 19613 3054 20 and and CC 19613 3054 21 another another DT 19613 3054 22 in in IN 19613 3054 23 Pontus Pontus NNP 19613 3054 24 induced induce VBD 19613 3054 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3054 26 people people NNS 19613 3054 27 to to TO 19613 3054 28 sell sell VB 19613 3054 29 all all DT 19613 3054 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3054 31 possessions possession NNS 19613 3054 32 , , , 19613 3054 33 to to TO 19613 3054 34 cease cease VB 19613 3054 35 tilling till VBG 19613 3054 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3054 37 lands land NNS 19613 3054 38 , , , 19613 3054 39 to to TO 19613 3054 40 conclude conclude VB 19613 3054 41 no no DT 19613 3054 42 more more JJR 19613 3054 43 marriages marriage NNS 19613 3054 44 etc etc FW 19613 3054 45 . . . 19613 3054 46 , , , 19613 3054 47 because because IN 19613 3054 48 the the DT 19613 3054 49 coming coming NN 19613 3054 50 of of IN 19613 3054 51 the the DT 19613 3054 52 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3054 53 was be VBD 19613 3054 54 nigh nigh NN 19613 3054 55 at at IN 19613 3054 56 hand hand NN 19613 3054 57 . . . 19613 3054 58 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3054 59 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3055 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3055 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3055 3 195 195 CD 19613 3055 4 : : : 19613 3055 5 Oracle oracle NN 19613 3055 6 of of IN 19613 3055 7 Prisca Prisca NNP 19613 3055 8 in in IN 19613 3055 9 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 3055 10 . . . 19613 3056 1 H. H. NNP 19613 3056 2 49 49 CD 19613 3056 3 . . . 19613 3057 1 1 1 LS 19613 3057 2 . . . 19613 3057 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3058 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3058 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3058 3 196 196 CD 19613 3058 4 : : : 19613 3058 5 Even even RB 19613 3058 6 in in IN 19613 3058 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3058 8 original original JJ 19613 3058 9 home home NN 19613 3058 10 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3058 11 must must MD 19613 3058 12 have have VB 19613 3058 13 accommodated accommodate VBN 19613 3058 14 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3058 15 to to IN 19613 3058 16 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 3058 17 at at IN 19613 3058 18 a a DT 19613 3058 19 comparatively comparatively RB 19613 3058 20 early early JJ 19613 3058 21 date date NN 19613 3058 22 -- -- : 19613 3058 23 which which WDT 19613 3058 24 is be VBZ 19613 3058 25 not not RB 19613 3058 26 in in IN 19613 3058 27 the the DT 19613 3058 28 least least JJS 19613 3058 29 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 3058 30 . . . 19613 3059 1 No no RB 19613 3059 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 3059 3 the the DT 19613 3059 4 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3059 5 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3059 6 in in IN 19613 3059 7 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3059 8 and and CC 19613 3059 9 Phrygia Phrygia NNP 19613 3059 10 , , , 19613 3059 11 to to TO 19613 3059 12 which which WDT 19613 3059 13 the the DT 19613 3059 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 3059 15 of of IN 19613 3059 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3059 17 had have VBD 19613 3059 18 already already RB 19613 3059 19 issued issue VBN 19613 3059 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3059 21 literæ literæ NN 19613 3059 22 pacis pacis NNP 19613 3059 23 _ _ NNP 19613 3059 24 , , , 19613 3059 25 were be VBD 19613 3059 26 now now RB 19613 3059 27 very very RB 19613 3059 28 different different JJ 19613 3059 29 from from IN 19613 3059 30 the the DT 19613 3059 31 original original JJ 19613 3059 32 followers follower NNS 19613 3059 33 of of IN 19613 3059 34 the the DT 19613 3059 35 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3059 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3059 37 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3059 38 . . NNP 19613 3059 39 , , , 19613 3059 40 adv adv NNP 19613 3059 41 . . . 19613 3060 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 3060 2 . . . 19613 3061 1 1 1 LS 19613 3061 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3061 3 . . . 19613 3062 1 When when WRB 19613 3062 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3062 3 further further JJ 19613 3062 4 reports report VBZ 19613 3062 5 that that IN 19613 3062 6 Praxeas praxea NNS 19613 3062 7 at at IN 19613 3062 8 the the DT 19613 3062 9 last last JJ 19613 3062 10 moment moment NN 19613 3062 11 prevented prevent VBD 19613 3062 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3062 13 from from IN 19613 3062 14 being be VBG 19613 3062 15 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3062 16 by by IN 19613 3062 17 the the DT 19613 3062 18 bishop bishop NN 19613 3062 19 of of IN 19613 3062 20 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3062 21 , , , 19613 3062 22 " " '' 19613 3062 23 falsa falsa NNP 19613 3062 24 de de FW 19613 3062 25 ipsis ipsis NNP 19613 3062 26 prophetis prophetis NNP 19613 3062 27 et et NNP 19613 3062 28 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 3062 29 eorum eorum NNP 19613 3062 30 adseverando adseverando NNP 19613 3062 31 , , , 19613 3062 32 " " '' 19613 3062 33 the the DT 19613 3062 34 " " `` 19613 3062 35 falsehood falsehood NN 19613 3062 36 about about IN 19613 3062 37 the the DT 19613 3062 38 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3062 39 " " `` 19613 3062 40 may may MD 19613 3062 41 simply simply RB 19613 3062 42 have have VB 19613 3062 43 consisted consist VBN 19613 3062 44 in in IN 19613 3062 45 an an DT 19613 3062 46 account account NN 19613 3062 47 of of IN 19613 3062 48 the the DT 19613 3062 49 original original JJ 19613 3062 50 tendencies tendency NNS 19613 3062 51 of of IN 19613 3062 52 the the DT 19613 3062 53 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3062 54 sect sect NN 19613 3062 55 . . . 19613 3063 1 The the DT 19613 3063 2 whole whole JJ 19613 3063 3 unique unique JJ 19613 3063 4 history history NN 19613 3063 5 which which WDT 19613 3063 6 , , , 19613 3063 7 in in IN 19613 3063 8 spite spite NN 19613 3063 9 of of IN 19613 3063 10 this this DT 19613 3063 11 , , , 19613 3063 12 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3063 13 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 3063 14 passed pass VBD 19613 3063 15 through through RP 19613 3063 16 in in IN 19613 3063 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3063 18 original original JJ 19613 3063 19 home home NN 19613 3063 20 is be VBZ 19613 3063 21 , , , 19613 3063 22 however however RB 19613 3063 23 explained explain VBN 19613 3063 24 by by IN 19613 3063 25 the the DT 19613 3063 26 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 3063 27 that that IN 19613 3063 28 there there EX 19613 3063 29 were be VBD 19613 3063 30 districts district NNS 19613 3063 31 there there RB 19613 3063 32 , , , 19613 3063 33 where where WRB 19613 3063 34 all all DT 19613 3063 35 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3063 36 belonged belong VBD 19613 3063 37 to to IN 19613 3063 38 that that DT 19613 3063 39 sect sect NN 19613 3063 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3063 41 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 3063 42 . . NNP 19613 3063 43 , , , 19613 3063 44 H. H. NNP 19613 3063 45 51 51 CD 19613 3063 46 . . . 19613 3064 1 33 33 CD 19613 3064 2 ; ; : 19613 3064 3 cf cf NN 19613 3064 4 . . . 19613 3065 1 also also RB 19613 3065 2 the the DT 19613 3065 3 later later JJ 19613 3065 4 history history NN 19613 3065 5 of of IN 19613 3065 6 Novatianism Novatianism NNP 19613 3065 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3065 8 . . . 19613 3066 1 In in IN 19613 3066 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3066 3 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3066 4 Church Church NNP 19613 3066 5 organisation organisation NN 19613 3066 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3066 7 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 3066 8 , , , 19613 3066 9 stewards steward NNS 19613 3066 10 , , , 19613 3066 11 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3066 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3066 13 , , , 19613 3066 14 these these DT 19613 3066 15 sects sect NNS 19613 3066 16 preserved preserve VBD 19613 3066 17 a a DT 19613 3066 18 record record NN 19613 3066 19 of of IN 19613 3066 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3066 21 origin origin NN 19613 3066 22 . . . 19613 3066 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3067 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3067 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3067 3 197 197 CD 19613 3067 4 : : : 19613 3067 5 Special special JJ 19613 3067 6 weight weight NN 19613 3067 7 must must MD 19613 3067 8 be be VB 19613 3067 9 laid lay VBN 19613 3067 10 on on IN 19613 3067 11 this this DT 19613 3067 12 . . . 19613 3068 1 The the DT 19613 3068 2 fact fact NN 19613 3068 3 that that IN 19613 3068 4 whole whole JJ 19613 3068 5 communities community NNS 19613 3068 6 became become VBD 19613 3068 7 followers follower NNS 19613 3068 8 of of IN 19613 3068 9 the the DT 19613 3068 10 new new JJ 19613 3068 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3068 12 , , , 19613 3068 13 who who WP 19613 3068 14 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 3068 15 adhered adhere VBD 19613 3068 16 to to IN 19613 3068 17 no no DT 19613 3068 18 old old JJ 19613 3068 19 regulation regulation NN 19613 3068 20 , , , 19613 3068 21 must must MD 19613 3068 22 above above IN 19613 3068 23 all all DT 19613 3068 24 be be VB 19613 3068 25 taken take VBN 19613 3068 26 into into IN 19613 3068 27 account account NN 19613 3068 28 . . . 19613 3068 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3069 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3069 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3069 3 198 198 CD 19613 3069 4 : : : 19613 3069 5 See see VB 19613 3069 6 Oracles Oracles NNP 19613 3069 7 1 1 CD 19613 3069 8 , , , 19613 3069 9 3 3 CD 19613 3069 10 , , , 19613 3069 11 4 4 CD 19613 3069 12 , , , 19613 3069 13 5 5 CD 19613 3069 14 , , , 19613 3069 15 10 10 CD 19613 3069 16 , , , 19613 3069 17 12 12 CD 19613 3069 18 , , , 19613 3069 19 17 17 CD 19613 3069 20 , , , 19613 3069 21 18 18 CD 19613 3069 22 , , , 19613 3069 23 21 21 CD 19613 3069 24 in in IN 19613 3069 25 Bonwetsch Bonwetsch NNP 19613 3069 26 , , , 19613 3069 27 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3069 28 . . NNP 19613 3069 29 , , , 19613 3069 30 p. p. NN 19613 3069 31 197 197 CD 19613 3069 32 f. f. IN 19613 3069 33 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3069 34 can can MD 19613 3069 35 hardly hardly RB 19613 3069 36 have have VB 19613 3069 37 been be VBN 19613 3069 38 customary customary JJ 19613 3069 39 for for IN 19613 3069 40 Christian christian JJ 19613 3069 41 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3069 42 to to TO 19613 3069 43 speak speak VB 19613 3069 44 like like IN 19613 3069 45 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3069 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3069 47 Nos Nos NNP 19613 3069 48 . . . 19613 3070 1 3 3 LS 19613 3070 2 - - SYM 19613 3070 3 5 5 CD 19613 3070 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3070 5 : : : 19613 3070 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3070 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3070 8 : : : 19613 3070 9 egô egô NNP 19613 3070 10 kyrios kyrios NNPS 19613 3070 11 ho ho NNP 19613 3070 12 theos theos NNP 19613 3070 13 ho ho NNP 19613 3070 14 pantokratôr pantokratôr NNP 19613 3070 15 kataginomenos kataginomenos NNP 19613 3070 16 en en NNP 19613 3070 17 anthropô anthropô NNP 19613 3070 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3070 19 , , , 19613 3070 20 or or CC 19613 3070 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3070 22 Greek greek JJ 19613 3070 23 : : : 19613 3070 24 egô egô NNP 19613 3070 25 kyrios kyrios NNPS 19613 3070 26 ho ho NNP 19613 3070 27 theos theos NNP 19613 3070 28 patêr patêr NNP 19613 3070 29 êlthon êlthon NNP 19613 3070 30 , , , 19613 3070 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3070 32 or or CC 19613 3070 33 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3070 34 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3070 35 : : : 19613 3070 36 egô egô NNP 19613 3070 37 eimi eimi NNP 19613 3070 38 ho ho NNP 19613 3070 39 patêr patêr NNP 19613 3070 40 kai kai NNP 19613 3070 41 ho ho NNP 19613 3070 42 uios uios NNP 19613 3070 43 kai kai NNP 19613 3070 44 ho ho NNP 19613 3070 45 paraklêtos paraklêtos NNP 19613 3070 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3070 47 , , , 19613 3070 48 though though IN 19613 3070 49 Old Old NNP 19613 3070 50 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3070 51 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3070 52 takes take VBZ 19613 3070 53 an an DT 19613 3070 54 analogous analogous JJ 19613 3070 55 form form NN 19613 3070 56 . . . 19613 3071 1 Maximilla Maximilla NNP 19613 3071 2 says say VBZ 19613 3071 3 on on IN 19613 3071 4 one one CD 19613 3071 5 occasion occasion NN 19613 3071 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3071 7 No no UH 19613 3071 8 . . . 19613 3072 1 11 11 CD 19613 3072 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3072 3 ; ; : 19613 3072 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3072 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3072 6 : : : 19613 3072 7 apesteile apesteile VB 19613 3072 8 me -PRON- PRP 19613 3072 9 kyrios kyrios NNPS 19613 3072 10 toutou toutou FW 19613 3072 11 tou tou NNP 19613 3072 12 ponou ponou NNP 19613 3072 13 kai kai NNP 19613 3072 14 tês tês NNP 19613 3072 15 epangelias epangelias NNP 19613 3072 16 airetistên airetistên NNP 19613 3072 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3072 18 ; ; : 19613 3072 19 and and CC 19613 3072 20 a a DT 19613 3072 21 second second JJ 19613 3072 22 time time NN 19613 3072 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3072 24 No no UH 19613 3072 25 . . . 19613 3073 1 12 12 CD 19613 3073 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3073 3 : : : 19613 3073 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3073 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3073 6 : : : 19613 3073 7 diôkomai diôkomai NNP 19613 3073 8 hôs hôs NNP 19613 3073 9 lycos lycos NNP 19613 3073 10 ek ek NNP 19613 3073 11 probatôn probatôn NNP 19613 3073 12 ouk ouk NNP 19613 3073 13 eimi eimi NNP 19613 3073 14 lycos lycos NNP 19613 3073 15 ; ; : 19613 3073 16 rhêma rhêma NNP 19613 3073 17 eimi eimi NNP 19613 3073 18 kai kai NNP 19613 3073 19 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 3073 20 kai kai NNP 19613 3073 21 dynamis dynamis NNP 19613 3073 22 . . . 19613 3073 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3074 1 The the DT 19613 3074 2 two two CD 19613 3074 3 utterances utterance NNS 19613 3074 4 do do VBP 19613 3074 5 not not RB 19613 3074 6 exclude exclude VB 19613 3074 7 , , , 19613 3074 8 but but CC 19613 3074 9 include include VBP 19613 3074 10 , , , 19613 3074 11 one one CD 19613 3074 12 another another DT 19613 3074 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3074 14 cf cf NN 19613 3074 15 . . . 19613 3075 1 also also RB 19613 3075 2 No no UH 19613 3075 3 . . . 19613 3076 1 10 10 CD 19613 3076 2 : : : 19613 3076 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3076 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3076 5 : : : 19613 3076 6 emou emou NN 19613 3076 7 mê mê NNP 19613 3076 8 akousête akousête NNP 19613 3076 9 alla alla NN 19613 3076 10 Christou Christou NNP 19613 3076 11 akousate akousate VBP 19613 3076 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3076 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3076 14 . . . 19613 3077 1 From from IN 19613 3077 2 James James NNP 19613 3077 3 IV IV NNP 19613 3077 4 . . . 19613 3078 1 V. V. NNP 19613 3078 2 and and CC 19613 3078 3 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 3078 4 , , , 19613 3078 5 and and CC 19613 3078 6 from from IN 19613 3078 7 the the DT 19613 3078 8 Didache Didache NNP 19613 3078 9 , , , 19613 3078 10 on on IN 19613 3078 11 the the DT 19613 3078 12 other other JJ 19613 3078 13 hand hand NN 19613 3078 14 , , , 19613 3078 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3078 16 can can MD 19613 3078 17 see see VB 19613 3078 18 how how WRB 19613 3078 19 the the DT 19613 3078 20 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3078 21 of of IN 19613 3078 22 Christian christian JJ 19613 3078 23 communities community NNS 19613 3078 24 may may MD 19613 3078 25 have have VB 19613 3078 26 usually usually RB 19613 3078 27 spoken speak VBN 19613 3078 28 . . . 19613 3078 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3079 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3079 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3079 3 199 199 CD 19613 3079 4 : : : 19613 3079 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 3079 6 . . NNP 19613 3079 7 , , , 19613 3079 8 no no UH 19613 3079 9 . . . 19613 3080 1 9 9 CD 19613 3080 2 : : : 19613 3080 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3080 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3080 5 : : : 19613 3080 6 Christos christos NN 19613 3080 7 hen hen NNS 19613 3080 8 idea idea VBP 19613 3080 9 gynaikos gynaikos NNP 19613 3080 10 eschêmatismenos eschêmatismenos NNP 19613 3080 11 . . . 19613 3080 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3081 1 How how WRB 19613 3081 2 variable variable JJ 19613 3081 3 must must MD 19613 3081 4 the the DT 19613 3081 5 misbirths misbirth NNS 19613 3081 6 of of IN 19613 3081 7 the the DT 19613 3081 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 3081 9 imagination imagination NN 19613 3081 10 have have VBP 19613 3081 11 been be VBN 19613 3081 12 in in IN 19613 3081 13 this this DT 19613 3081 14 respect respect NN 19613 3081 15 also also RB 19613 3081 16 ! ! . 19613 3082 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 3082 2 almost almost RB 19613 3082 3 everything everything NN 19613 3082 4 of of IN 19613 3082 5 that that DT 19613 3082 6 kind kind NN 19613 3082 7 has have VBZ 19613 3082 8 been be VBN 19613 3082 9 lost lose VBN 19613 3082 10 to to IN 19613 3082 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3082 12 because because IN 19613 3082 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3082 14 has have VBZ 19613 3082 15 been be VBN 19613 3082 16 suppressed suppress VBN 19613 3082 17 . . . 19613 3083 1 The the DT 19613 3083 2 fragments fragment NNS 19613 3083 3 of of IN 19613 3083 4 the the DT 19613 3083 5 once once RB 19613 3083 6 highly highly RB 19613 3083 7 esteemed esteemed JJ 19613 3083 8 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 3083 9 of of IN 19613 3083 10 Peter Peter NNP 19613 3083 11 are be VBP 19613 3083 12 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3083 13 , , , 19613 3083 14 for for IN 19613 3083 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3083 16 still still RB 19613 3083 17 attest attest VBP 19613 3083 18 that that IN 19613 3083 19 the the DT 19613 3083 20 existing exist VBG 19613 3083 21 remains remain NNS 19613 3083 22 of of IN 19613 3083 23 early early JJ 19613 3083 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 3083 25 literature literature NN 19613 3083 26 are be VBP 19613 3083 27 not not RB 19613 3083 28 able able JJ 19613 3083 29 to to TO 19613 3083 30 give give VB 19613 3083 31 a a DT 19613 3083 32 correct correct JJ 19613 3083 33 picture picture NN 19613 3083 34 of of IN 19613 3083 35 the the DT 19613 3083 36 strength strength NN 19613 3083 37 of of IN 19613 3083 38 religious religious JJ 19613 3083 39 imagination imagination NN 19613 3083 40 in in IN 19613 3083 41 the the DT 19613 3083 42 first first JJ 19613 3083 43 and and CC 19613 3083 44 second second JJ 19613 3083 45 centuries century NNS 19613 3083 46 . . . 19613 3084 1 The the DT 19613 3084 2 passages passage NNS 19613 3084 3 where where WRB 19613 3084 4 Christophanies christophanie NNS 19613 3084 5 are be VBP 19613 3084 6 spoken speak VBN 19613 3084 7 of of IN 19613 3084 8 in in IN 19613 3084 9 the the DT 19613 3084 10 earliest early JJS 19613 3084 11 literature literature NN 19613 3084 12 would would MD 19613 3084 13 require require VB 19613 3084 14 to to TO 19613 3084 15 be be VB 19613 3084 16 collected collect VBN 19613 3084 17 . . . 19613 3085 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3085 2 would would MD 19613 3085 3 be be VB 19613 3085 4 shown show VBN 19613 3085 5 what what WP 19613 3085 6 naive naive JJ 19613 3085 7 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 3085 8 existed exist VBD 19613 3085 9 . . . 19613 3086 1 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 3086 2 appears appear VBZ 19613 3086 3 to to IN 19613 3086 4 believers believer NNS 19613 3086 5 as as IN 19613 3086 6 a a DT 19613 3086 7 child child NN 19613 3086 8 , , , 19613 3086 9 as as IN 19613 3086 10 a a DT 19613 3086 11 boy boy NN 19613 3086 12 , , , 19613 3086 13 as as IN 19613 3086 14 a a DT 19613 3086 15 youth youth NN 19613 3086 16 , , , 19613 3086 17 as as IN 19613 3086 18 Paul Paul NNP 19613 3086 19 etc etc FW 19613 3086 20 . . . 19613 3087 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 3087 2 , , , 19613 3087 3 glorified glorify VBN 19613 3087 4 men man NNS 19613 3087 5 appear appear VBP 19613 3087 6 in in IN 19613 3087 7 visions vision NNS 19613 3087 8 with with IN 19613 3087 9 the the DT 19613 3087 10 features feature NNS 19613 3087 11 of of IN 19613 3087 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3087 13 . . . 19613 3087 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3088 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3088 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3088 3 200 200 CD 19613 3088 4 : : : 19613 3088 5 See See NNP 19613 3088 6 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3088 7 . . NNP 19613 3088 8 , , , 19613 3088 9 H. H. NNP 19613 3088 10 E. E. NNP 19613 3088 11 V. V. NNP 19613 3088 12 16 16 CD 19613 3088 13 . . . 19613 3089 1 9 9 CD 19613 3089 2 . . . 19613 3090 1 In in IN 19613 3090 2 Oracle Oracle NNP 19613 3090 3 No no NN 19613 3090 4 . . . 19613 3091 1 2 2 CD 19613 3091 2 an an DT 19613 3091 3 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3091 4 promise promise NN 19613 3091 5 is be VBZ 19613 3091 6 repeated repeat VBN 19613 3091 7 in in IN 19613 3091 8 a a DT 19613 3091 9 heightened heighten VBN 19613 3091 10 form form NN 19613 3091 11 ; ; : 19613 3091 12 but but CC 19613 3091 13 see see VB 19613 3091 14 Papias Papias NNP 19613 3091 15 in in IN 19613 3091 16 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3091 17 . . . 19613 3091 18 , , , 19613 3091 19 V. V. NNP 19613 3091 20 33 33 CD 19613 3091 21 . . . 19613 3092 1 3 3 CD 19613 3092 2 f. f. NNP 19613 3092 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3092 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3092 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3092 6 201 201 CD 19613 3092 7 : : : 19613 3092 8 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3092 9 may may MD 19613 3092 10 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 19613 3092 11 act act VB 19613 3092 12 on on IN 19613 3092 13 the the DT 19613 3092 14 principle principle NN 19613 3092 15 that that IN 19613 3092 16 the the DT 19613 3092 17 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3092 18 elements element NNS 19613 3092 19 , , , 19613 3092 20 as as IN 19613 3092 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3092 22 appear appear VBP 19613 3092 23 in in IN 19613 3092 24 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3092 25 , , , 19613 3092 26 are be VBP 19613 3092 27 , , , 19613 3092 28 in in IN 19613 3092 29 all all DT 19613 3092 30 cases case NNS 19613 3092 31 , , , 19613 3092 32 found find VBD 19613 3092 33 not not RB 19613 3092 34 in in IN 19613 3092 35 a a DT 19613 3092 36 strengthened strengthen VBN 19613 3092 37 , , , 19613 3092 38 but but CC 19613 3092 39 a a DT 19613 3092 40 weakened weakened JJ 19613 3092 41 , , , 19613 3092 42 form form NN 19613 3092 43 . . . 19613 3093 1 So so CC 19613 3093 2 , , , 19613 3093 3 when when WRB 19613 3093 4 even even RB 19613 3093 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3093 6 still still RB 19613 3093 7 asserts assert VBZ 19613 3093 8 that that IN 19613 3093 9 the the DT 19613 3093 10 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3093 11 in in IN 19613 3093 12 the the DT 19613 3093 13 new new JJ 19613 3093 14 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3093 15 could could MD 19613 3093 16 overturn overturn VB 19613 3093 17 or or CC 19613 3093 18 change change NN 19613 3093 19 , , , 19613 3093 20 and and CC 19613 3093 21 actually actually RB 19613 3093 22 did do VBD 19613 3093 23 change change VB 19613 3093 24 , , , 19613 3093 25 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3093 26 of of IN 19613 3093 27 the the DT 19613 3093 28 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 3093 29 , , , 19613 3093 30 there there EX 19613 3093 31 is be VBZ 19613 3093 32 no no DT 19613 3093 33 doubt doubt NN 19613 3093 34 that that IN 19613 3093 35 the the DT 19613 3093 36 new new JJ 19613 3093 37 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3093 38 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3093 39 did do VBD 19613 3093 40 not not RB 19613 3093 41 adhere adhere VB 19613 3093 42 to to IN 19613 3093 43 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 3093 44 dicta dicta NNP 19613 3093 45 and and CC 19613 3093 46 had have VBD 19613 3093 47 no no DT 19613 3093 48 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 3093 49 in in IN 19613 3093 50 deviating deviate VBG 19613 3093 51 from from IN 19613 3093 52 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3093 53 . . . 19613 3094 1 Cf Cf NNP 19613 3094 2 . . NNP 19613 3094 3 , , , 19613 3094 4 moreover moreover RB 19613 3094 5 , , , 19613 3094 6 the the DT 19613 3094 7 direct direct JJ 19613 3094 8 declarations declaration NNS 19613 3094 9 on on IN 19613 3094 10 this this DT 19613 3094 11 point point NN 19613 3094 12 in in IN 19613 3094 13 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3094 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3094 15 Syntagma Syntagma NNP 19613 3094 16 and and CC 19613 3094 17 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3094 18 . . . 19613 3095 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 3095 2 . . . 19613 3096 1 19 19 CD 19613 3096 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3096 3 and and CC 19613 3096 4 in in IN 19613 3096 5 Didymus Didymus NNP 19613 3096 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3096 7 de de NNP 19613 3096 8 trin trin NNP 19613 3096 9 . . . 19613 3097 1 III iii CD 19613 3097 2 . . . 19613 3098 1 41 41 CD 19613 3098 2 . . . 19613 3099 1 2 2 LS 19613 3099 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3099 3 . . . 19613 3099 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3100 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3100 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3100 3 202 202 CD 19613 3100 4 : : : 19613 3100 5 The the DT 19613 3100 6 precepts precept NNS 19613 3100 7 for for IN 19613 3100 8 a a DT 19613 3100 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 3100 10 life life NN 19613 3100 11 , , , 19613 3100 12 if if IN 19613 3100 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3100 14 may may MD 19613 3100 15 so so RB 19613 3100 16 speak speak VB 19613 3100 17 , , , 19613 3100 18 given give VBN 19613 3100 19 by by IN 19613 3100 20 the the DT 19613 3100 21 new new JJ 19613 3100 22 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3100 23 , , , 19613 3100 24 can can MD 19613 3100 25 not not RB 19613 3100 26 be be VB 19613 3100 27 determined determine VBN 19613 3100 28 from from IN 19613 3100 29 the the DT 19613 3100 30 compromises compromise NNS 19613 3100 31 on on IN 19613 3100 32 which which WDT 19613 3100 33 the the DT 19613 3100 34 discipline discipline NN 19613 3100 35 of of IN 19613 3100 36 the the DT 19613 3100 37 later later JJ 19613 3100 38 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3100 39 societies society NNS 19613 3100 40 of of IN 19613 3100 41 the the DT 19613 3100 42 Empire Empire NNP 19613 3100 43 were be VBD 19613 3100 44 based base VBN 19613 3100 45 . . . 19613 3101 1 Here here RB 19613 3101 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3101 3 sought seek VBD 19613 3101 4 for for IN 19613 3101 5 a a DT 19613 3101 6 narrow narrow JJ 19613 3101 7 line line NN 19613 3101 8 between between IN 19613 3101 9 the the DT 19613 3101 10 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 3101 11 and and CC 19613 3101 12 Encratite Encratite NNP 19613 3101 13 mode mode NN 19613 3101 14 of of IN 19613 3101 15 life life NN 19613 3101 16 and and CC 19613 3101 17 the the DT 19613 3101 18 common common JJ 19613 3101 19 church church NN 19613 3101 20 practice practice NN 19613 3101 21 , , , 19613 3101 22 and and CC 19613 3101 23 had have VBD 19613 3101 24 no no RB 19613 3101 25 longer long JJR 19613 3101 26 the the DT 19613 3101 27 courage courage NN 19613 3101 28 and and CC 19613 3101 29 the the DT 19613 3101 30 candour candour NN 19613 3101 31 to to TO 19613 3101 32 proclaim proclaim VB 19613 3101 33 the the DT 19613 3101 34 " " `` 19613 3101 35 e e NNP 19613 3101 36 sæculo sæculo NNP 19613 3101 37 excedere excedere NNP 19613 3101 38 . . . 19613 3101 39 " " '' 19613 3102 1 Sexual sexual JJ 19613 3102 2 purity purity NN 19613 3102 3 and and CC 19613 3102 4 the the DT 19613 3102 5 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 3102 6 of of IN 19613 3102 7 the the DT 19613 3102 8 enjoyments enjoyment NNS 19613 3102 9 of of IN 19613 3102 10 life life NN 19613 3102 11 were be VBD 19613 3102 12 the the DT 19613 3102 13 demands demand NNS 19613 3102 14 of of IN 19613 3102 15 the the DT 19613 3102 16 new new JJ 19613 3102 17 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3102 18 . . . 19613 3103 1 But but CC 19613 3103 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3103 3 is be VBZ 19613 3103 4 hardly hardly RB 19613 3103 5 likely likely JJ 19613 3103 6 that that IN 19613 3103 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3103 8 prescribed prescribe VBD 19613 3103 9 precise precise JJ 19613 3103 10 " " `` 19613 3103 11 laws law NNS 19613 3103 12 , , , 19613 3103 13 " " '' 19613 3103 14 for for IN 19613 3103 15 the the DT 19613 3103 16 primary primary JJ 19613 3103 17 matter matter NN 19613 3103 18 was be VBD 19613 3103 19 not not RB 19613 3103 20 asceticism asceticism JJ 19613 3103 21 , , , 19613 3103 22 but but CC 19613 3103 23 the the DT 19613 3103 24 realising realising NN 19613 3103 25 of of IN 19613 3103 26 a a DT 19613 3103 27 promise promise NN 19613 3103 28 . . . 19613 3104 1 In in IN 19613 3104 2 later later JJ 19613 3104 3 days day NNS 19613 3104 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3104 5 was be VBD 19613 3104 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 3104 7 possible possible JJ 19613 3104 8 to to TO 19613 3104 9 conceive conceive VB 19613 3104 10 the the DT 19613 3104 11 most most RBS 19613 3104 12 extreme extreme JJ 19613 3104 13 demands demand NNS 19613 3104 14 as as IN 19613 3104 15 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3104 16 referring refer VBG 19613 3104 17 to to IN 19613 3104 18 none none NN 19613 3104 19 but but CC 19613 3104 20 the the DT 19613 3104 21 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3104 22 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3104 23 , , , 19613 3104 24 and and CC 19613 3104 25 to to TO 19613 3104 26 tone tone VB 19613 3104 27 down down RP 19613 3104 28 the the DT 19613 3104 29 oracles oracle NNS 19613 3104 30 in in IN 19613 3104 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3104 32 application application NN 19613 3104 33 to to IN 19613 3104 34 believers believer NNS 19613 3104 35 . . . 19613 3105 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3105 2 is be VBZ 19613 3105 3 said say VBN 19613 3105 4 of of IN 19613 3105 5 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3105 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3105 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3105 8 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3105 9 . . NNP 19613 3105 10 , , , 19613 3105 11 H. H. NNP 19613 3105 12 E. E. NNP 19613 3105 13 V. V. NNP 19613 3105 14 18 18 CD 19613 3105 15 . . . 19613 3106 1 2 2 LS 19613 3106 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3106 3 : : : 19613 3106 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3106 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3106 6 : : : 19613 3106 7 ho ho NNP 19613 3106 8 didaxas didaxas NNP 19613 3106 9 lyseis lyseis NNP 19613 3106 10 gamôn gamôn NNP 19613 3106 11 , , , 19613 3106 12 ho ho NNP 19613 3106 13 nêsteias nêsteias NNP 19613 3106 14 nomothetêsas nomothetêsas NNP 19613 3106 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3106 16 ; ; : 19613 3106 17 Prisca Prisca NNP 19613 3106 18 was be VBD 19613 3106 19 a a DT 19613 3106 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3106 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3106 22 : : : 19613 3106 23 parthenos parthenos NN 19613 3106 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3106 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3106 26 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3106 27 . . . 19613 3107 1 § § ADD 19613 3107 2 3 3 CD 19613 3107 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3107 4 ; ; : 19613 3107 5 Proculus Proculus NNP 19613 3107 6 , , , 19613 3107 7 the the DT 19613 3107 8 chief chief NN 19613 3107 9 of of IN 19613 3107 10 the the DT 19613 3107 11 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3107 12 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3107 13 , , , 19613 3107 14 " " `` 19613 3107 15 virginis virginis NN 19613 3107 16 senectæ senectæ NN 19613 3107 17 " " '' 19613 3107 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3107 19 Tert Tert NNP 19613 3107 20 . . . 19613 3107 21 , , , 19613 3107 22 adv adv NNP 19613 3107 23 . . . 19613 3108 1 Val Val NNP 19613 3108 2 . . . 19613 3109 1 5 5 LS 19613 3109 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3109 3 . . . 19613 3110 1 The the DT 19613 3110 2 oracle oracle NN 19613 3110 3 of of IN 19613 3110 4 Prisca Prisca NNP 19613 3110 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3110 6 No no UH 19613 3110 7 . . . 19613 3111 1 8) 8) CD 19613 3111 2 declares declare VBZ 19613 3111 3 that that DT 19613 3111 4 sexual sexual JJ 19613 3111 5 purity purity NN 19613 3111 6 is be VBZ 19613 3111 7 the the DT 19613 3111 8 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 3111 9 condition condition NN 19613 3111 10 for for IN 19613 3111 11 the the DT 19613 3111 12 oracles oracle NNS 19613 3111 13 and and CC 19613 3111 14 visions vision NNS 19613 3111 15 of of IN 19613 3111 16 God God NNP 19613 3111 17 ; ; : 19613 3111 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3111 19 is be VBZ 19613 3111 20 presupposed presuppose VBN 19613 3111 21 in in IN 19613 3111 22 the the DT 19613 3111 23 case case NN 19613 3111 24 of of IN 19613 3111 25 every every DT 19613 3111 26 " " `` 19613 3111 27 sanctus sanctus NN 19613 3111 28 minister minister NN 19613 3111 29 . . . 19613 3111 30 " " '' 19613 3112 1 Finally finally RB 19613 3112 2 , , , 19613 3112 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3112 4 tells tell VBZ 19613 3112 5 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3112 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3112 7 in in IN 19613 3112 8 Titum Titum NNP 19613 3112 9 , , , 19613 3112 10 Opp Opp NNP 19613 3112 11 . . . 19613 3113 1 IV IV NNP 19613 3113 2 . . . 19613 3114 1 696 696 CD 19613 3114 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3114 3 that that WDT 19613 3114 4 the the DT 19613 3114 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3114 6 older old JJR 19613 3114 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3114 8 Cataphrygians cataphrygian NNS 19613 3114 9 said say VBD 19613 3114 10 : : : 19613 3114 11 " " `` 19613 3114 12 ne ne NNP 19613 3114 13 accedas accedas NNP 19613 3114 14 ad ad NN 19613 3114 15 me -PRON- PRP 19613 3114 16 , , , 19613 3114 17 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 3114 18 mundus mundus NNP 19613 3114 19 sum sum NN 19613 3114 20 ; ; : 19613 3114 21 non non AFX 19613 3114 22 enim enim NNP 19613 3114 23 accepi accepi NNP 19613 3114 24 uxorem uxorem NNP 19613 3114 25 , , , 19613 3114 26 nec nec NNP 19613 3114 27 est est NNP 19613 3114 28 sepulcrum sepulcrum NNP 19613 3114 29 patens paten VBZ 19613 3114 30 guttur guttur NNP 19613 3114 31 menin menin NNP 19613 3114 32 , , , 19613 3114 33 sed sed NNP 19613 3114 34 sum sum NNP 19613 3114 35 Nazarenus Nazarenus NNP 19613 3114 36 dei dei VBD 19613 3114 37 non non AFX 19613 3114 38 bibens bibens NNP 19613 3114 39 vinum vinum NNP 19613 3114 40 sicut sicut NNP 19613 3114 41 illi illi NN 19613 3114 42 . . . 19613 3114 43 " " '' 19613 3115 1 But but CC 19613 3115 2 an an DT 19613 3115 3 express express JJ 19613 3115 4 legal legal JJ 19613 3115 5 direction direction NN 19613 3115 6 to to TO 19613 3115 7 abolish abolish VB 19613 3115 8 marriage marriage NN 19613 3115 9 can can MD 19613 3115 10 not not RB 19613 3115 11 have have VB 19613 3115 12 existed exist VBN 19613 3115 13 in in IN 19613 3115 14 the the DT 19613 3115 15 collection collection NN 19613 3115 16 of of IN 19613 3115 17 oracles oracle NNS 19613 3115 18 possessed possess VBN 19613 3115 19 by by IN 19613 3115 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3115 21 . . . 19613 3116 1 But but CC 19613 3116 2 who who WP 19613 3116 3 can can MD 19613 3116 4 guarantee guarantee VB 19613 3116 5 that that IN 19613 3116 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3116 7 were be VBD 19613 3116 8 not not RB 19613 3116 9 already already RB 19613 3116 10 corrected correct VBN 19613 3116 11 ? ? . 19613 3117 1 Such such PDT 19613 3117 2 an an DT 19613 3117 3 assumption assumption NN 19613 3117 4 , , , 19613 3117 5 however however RB 19613 3117 6 , , , 19613 3117 7 is be VBZ 19613 3117 8 not not RB 19613 3117 9 necessary necessary JJ 19613 3117 10 . . . 19613 3117 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3118 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3118 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3118 3 203 203 CD 19613 3118 4 : : : 19613 3118 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3118 6 . . NNP 19613 3118 7 , , , 19613 3118 8 V. V. NNP 19613 3118 9 16 16 CD 19613 3118 10 . . . 19613 3119 1 9 9 LS 19613 3119 2 : : : 19613 3119 3 V. v. NN 19613 3119 4 18 18 CD 19613 3119 5 . . . 19613 3120 1 5 5 CD 19613 3120 2 . . . 19613 3120 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3121 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3121 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3121 3 204 204 CD 19613 3121 4 : : : 19613 3121 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3121 6 will will MD 19613 3121 7 not not RB 19613 3121 8 do do VB 19613 3121 9 simply simply RB 19613 3121 10 to to TO 19613 3121 11 place place VB 19613 3121 12 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3121 13 and and CC 19613 3121 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3121 15 two two CD 19613 3121 16 female female JJ 19613 3121 17 associates associate NNS 19613 3121 18 in in IN 19613 3121 19 the the DT 19613 3121 20 same same JJ 19613 3121 21 category category NN 19613 3121 22 as as IN 19613 3121 23 the the DT 19613 3121 24 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3121 25 of of IN 19613 3121 26 primitive primitive JJ 19613 3121 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 3121 28 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3121 29 . . . 19613 3122 1 The the DT 19613 3122 2 claim claim NN 19613 3122 3 that that IN 19613 3122 4 the the DT 19613 3122 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3122 6 had have VBD 19613 3122 7 descended descend VBN 19613 3122 8 upon upon IN 19613 3122 9 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3122 10 in in IN 19613 3122 11 unique unique JJ 19613 3122 12 fashion fashion NN 19613 3122 13 must must MD 19613 3122 14 have have VB 19613 3122 15 been be VBN 19613 3122 16 put put VBN 19613 3122 17 forth forth RP 19613 3122 18 by by IN 19613 3122 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3122 20 with with IN 19613 3122 21 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 19613 3122 22 clearness clearness NN 19613 3122 23 . . . 19613 3123 1 If if IN 19613 3123 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3123 3 apply apply VBP 19613 3123 4 the the DT 19613 3123 5 principle principle NN 19613 3123 6 laid lay VBD 19613 3123 7 down down RP 19613 3123 8 on on IN 19613 3123 9 p. p. NN 19613 3123 10 98 98 CD 19613 3123 11 , , , 19613 3123 12 note note VBP 19613 3123 13 3 3 CD 19613 3123 14 , , , 19613 3123 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3123 16 will will MD 19613 3123 17 find find VB 19613 3123 18 that that DT 19613 3123 19 -- -- : 19613 3123 20 apart apart RB 19613 3123 21 from from IN 19613 3123 22 the the DT 19613 3123 23 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3123 24 ' ' POS 19613 3123 25 own own JJ 19613 3123 26 utterances utterance NNS 19613 3123 27 -- -- : 19613 3123 28 this this DT 19613 3123 29 is be VBZ 19613 3123 30 still still RB 19613 3123 31 clearly clearly RB 19613 3123 32 manifest manif JJS 19613 3123 33 from from IN 19613 3123 34 the the DT 19613 3123 35 works work NNS 19613 3123 36 of of IN 19613 3123 37 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3123 38 . . . 19613 3124 1 A a DT 19613 3124 2 consideration consideration NN 19613 3124 3 of of IN 19613 3124 4 the the DT 19613 3124 5 following follow VBG 19613 3124 6 facts fact NNS 19613 3124 7 will will MD 19613 3124 8 remove remove VB 19613 3124 9 all all RB 19613 3124 10 doubt doubt RB 19613 3124 11 as as IN 19613 3124 12 to to IN 19613 3124 13 the the DT 19613 3124 14 claim claim NN 19613 3124 15 of of IN 19613 3124 16 the the DT 19613 3124 17 new new JJ 19613 3124 18 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3124 19 to to IN 19613 3124 20 the the DT 19613 3124 21 possession possession NN 19613 3124 22 of of IN 19613 3124 23 an an DT 19613 3124 24 unique unique JJ 19613 3124 25 mission mission NN 19613 3124 26 , , , 19613 3124 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3124 28 1 1 LS 19613 3124 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3124 30 From from IN 19613 3124 31 the the DT 19613 3124 32 beginning beginning NN 19613 3124 33 both both DT 19613 3124 34 opponents opponent NNS 19613 3124 35 and and CC 19613 3124 36 followers follower NNS 19613 3124 37 constantly constantly RB 19613 3124 38 applied apply VBD 19613 3124 39 the the DT 19613 3124 40 title title NN 19613 3124 41 " " `` 19613 3124 42 New New NNP 19613 3124 43 Prophecy Prophecy NNP 19613 3124 44 " " '' 19613 3124 45 to to IN 19613 3124 46 the the DT 19613 3124 47 phenomenon phenomenon NN 19613 3124 48 in in IN 19613 3124 49 question question NN 19613 3124 50 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3124 51 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3124 52 . . NNP 19613 3124 53 , , , 19613 3124 54 V. V. NNP 19613 3124 55 16 16 CD 19613 3124 56 . . . 19613 3125 1 4 4 LS 19613 3125 2 : : : 19613 3125 3 V. V. NNP 19613 3125 4 19 19 CD 19613 3125 5 . . . 19613 3126 1 2 2 LS 19613 3126 2 ; ; : 19613 3126 3 Clem Clem NNP 19613 3126 4 . . . 19613 3126 5 , , , 19613 3126 6 Strom Strom NNP 19613 3126 7 . . . 19613 3127 1 IV IV NNP 19613 3127 2 . . . 19613 3128 1 13 13 CD 19613 3128 2 . . . 19613 3129 1 93 93 CD 19613 3129 2 ; ; : 19613 3129 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3129 4 . . NNP 19613 3129 5 , , , 19613 3129 6 monog monog NNP 19613 3129 7 . . . 19613 3130 1 14 14 CD 19613 3130 2 , , , 19613 3130 3 ieiun ieiun JJ 19613 3130 4 . . . 19613 3131 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3131 2 , , , 19613 3131 3 resurr resurr VBZ 19613 3131 4 . . . 19613 3132 1 63 63 CD 19613 3132 2 , , , 19613 3132 3 Marc Marc NNP 19613 3132 4 . . . 19613 3133 1 III iii CD 19613 3133 2 . . . 19613 3134 1 24 24 CD 19613 3134 2 . . . 19613 3134 3 : : : 19613 3134 4 IV IV NNP 19613 3134 5 . . . 19613 3135 1 22 22 CD 19613 3135 2 , , , 19613 3135 3 Prax Prax NNP 19613 3135 4 . . . 19613 3136 1 30 30 CD 19613 3136 2 ; ; : 19613 3136 3 Firmil Firmil NNP 19613 3136 4 . . . 19613 3137 1 ep ep NNP 19613 3137 2 . . . 19613 3138 1 75 75 CD 19613 3138 2 . . . 19613 3139 1 7 7 LS 19613 3139 2 ; ; : 19613 3139 3 alii alii NNP 19613 3139 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3139 5 . . . 19613 3140 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3140 2 2 2 LS 19613 3140 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3140 4 Similarly similarly RB 19613 3140 5 , , , 19613 3140 6 the the DT 19613 3140 7 divine divine JJ 19613 3140 8 afflatus afflatus NNP 19613 3140 9 was be VBD 19613 3140 10 , , , 19613 3140 11 from from IN 19613 3140 12 the the DT 19613 3140 13 first first JJ 19613 3140 14 , , , 19613 3140 15 constantly constantly RB 19613 3140 16 designated designate VBN 19613 3140 17 as as IN 19613 3140 18 the the DT 19613 3140 19 " " `` 19613 3140 20 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3140 21 " " '' 19613 3140 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3140 23 Orac Orac NNP 19613 3140 24 . . . 19613 3141 1 no no UH 19613 3141 2 . . . 19613 3142 1 5 5 LS 19613 3142 2 ; ; : 19613 3142 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3142 4 . . . 19613 3143 1 passim passim NNP 19613 3143 2 ; ; : 19613 3143 3 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 3143 4 . . . 19613 3144 1 passim passim NNP 19613 3144 2 ; ; : 19613 3144 3 Didymus Didymus NNP 19613 3144 4 etc etc FW 19613 3144 5 . . . 19613 3144 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3144 7 . . . 19613 3145 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3145 2 3 3 LS 19613 3145 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3145 4 Even even RB 19613 3145 5 in in IN 19613 3145 6 the the DT 19613 3145 7 third third JJ 19613 3145 8 century century NN 19613 3145 9 the the DT 19613 3145 10 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3145 11 congregations congregation NNS 19613 3145 12 of of IN 19613 3145 13 the the DT 19613 3145 14 Empire Empire NNP 19613 3145 15 must must MD 19613 3145 16 still still RB 19613 3145 17 have have VB 19613 3145 18 doubted doubt VBN 19613 3145 19 whether whether IN 19613 3145 20 the the DT 19613 3145 21 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 3145 22 had have VBD 19613 3145 23 possessed possess VBN 19613 3145 24 this this DT 19613 3145 25 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3145 26 or or CC 19613 3145 27 not not RB 19613 3145 28 , , , 19613 3145 29 or or CC 19613 3145 30 at at IN 19613 3145 31 least least JJS 19613 3145 32 whether whether IN 19613 3145 33 this this DT 19613 3145 34 had have VBD 19613 3145 35 been be VBN 19613 3145 36 the the DT 19613 3145 37 case case NN 19613 3145 38 in in IN 19613 3145 39 the the DT 19613 3145 40 full full JJ 19613 3145 41 sense sense NN 19613 3145 42 . . . 19613 3146 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3146 2 identifies identify VBZ 19613 3146 3 the the DT 19613 3146 4 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3146 5 and and CC 19613 3146 6 the the DT 19613 3146 7 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3146 8 and and CC 19613 3146 9 declares declare VBZ 19613 3146 10 that that IN 19613 3146 11 the the DT 19613 3146 12 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 3146 13 possessed possess VBD 19613 3146 14 the the DT 19613 3146 15 latter latter JJ 19613 3146 16 in in IN 19613 3146 17 full full JJ 19613 3146 18 measure measure NN 19613 3146 19 -- -- : 19613 3146 20 in in IN 19613 3146 21 fact fact NN 19613 3146 22 as as IN 19613 3146 23 a a DT 19613 3146 24 Catholic catholic NN 19613 3146 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3146 26 could could MD 19613 3146 27 not not RB 19613 3146 28 do do VB 19613 3146 29 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 3146 30 . . . 19613 3147 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 3147 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3147 3 calls call VBZ 19613 3147 4 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3147 5 etc etc FW 19613 3147 6 . . . 19613 3148 1 " " `` 19613 3148 2 prophetæ prophetæ NNP 19613 3148 3 proprii proprii NNP 19613 3148 4 " " '' 19613 3148 5 of of IN 19613 3148 6 the the DT 19613 3148 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3148 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3148 9 pudic pudic JJ 19613 3148 10 . . . 19613 3149 1 12 12 CD 19613 3149 2 ; ; : 19613 3149 3 see see VB 19613 3149 4 Acta Acta NNP 19613 3149 5 Perpet Perpet NNP 19613 3149 6 . . . 19613 3150 1 21 21 CD 19613 3150 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3150 3 . . . 19613 3151 1 On on IN 19613 3151 2 the the DT 19613 3151 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 3151 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3151 5 find find VBP 19613 3151 6 in in IN 19613 3151 7 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3151 8 . . . 19613 3152 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 3152 2 . . . 19613 3153 1 19 19 CD 19613 3153 2 : : : 19613 3153 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3153 4 Greek greek JJ 19613 3153 5 : : : 19613 3153 6 huper huper NNP 19613 3153 7 de de FW 19613 3153 8 apostolous apostolous NNP 19613 3153 9 kai kai NNP 19613 3153 10 pan pan NNP 19613 3153 11 charisma charisma NNP 19613 3153 12 tauta tauta NNP 19613 3153 13 ta ta NNP 19613 3153 14 gunaia gunaia NNP 19613 3153 15 doxazouin doxazouin NNP 19613 3153 16 , , , 19613 3153 17 hôs hôs NNP 19613 3153 18 tolman tolman NNP 19613 3153 19 pleion pleion NN 19613 3153 20 ti ti IN 19613 3153 21 Christou Christou NNP 19613 3153 22 en en IN 19613 3153 23 toutois toutois NNP 19613 3153 24 legein legein NNP 19613 3153 25 tinas tinas NNP 19613 3153 26 autôn autôn NNP 19613 3153 27 gegoneai gegoneai NNP 19613 3153 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3153 29 . . . 19613 3154 1 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 3154 2 - - HYPH 19613 3154 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3154 4 says say VBZ 19613 3154 5 : : : 19613 3154 6 " " `` 19613 3154 7 in in IN 19613 3154 8 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 3154 9 quidem quidem NNP 19613 3154 10 dicunt dicunt NN 19613 3154 11 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 3154 12 sanctum sanctum NNP 19613 3154 13 fuisse fuisse NNP 19613 3154 14 , , , 19613 3154 15 paracletum paracletum JJ 19613 3154 16 non non AFX 19613 3154 17 fuisse fuisse NNP 19613 3154 18 , , , 19613 3154 19 et et NNP 19613 3154 20 paracletum paracletum JJ 19613 3154 21 plura plura NNP 19613 3154 22 in in IN 19613 3154 23 Montano Montano NNP 19613 3154 24 dixisse dixisse NN 19613 3154 25 quam quam NNP 19613 3154 26 Christum Christum NNP 19613 3154 27 in in IN 19613 3154 28 evangelio evangelio NNP 19613 3154 29 protulisse protulisse NNP 19613 3154 30 . . . 19613 3154 31 " " '' 19613 3155 1 In in IN 19613 3155 2 Didymus Didymus NNP 19613 3155 3 , , , 19613 3155 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3155 5 . . NNP 19613 3155 6 , , , 19613 3155 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3155 8 read read VBP 19613 3155 9 : : : 19613 3155 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3155 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3155 12 : : : 19613 3155 13 tou tou NNP 19613 3155 14 apostolou apostolou NNP 19613 3155 15 grapsantos grapsantos NNP 19613 3155 16 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 3155 17 . . NNP 19613 3155 18 , , , 19613 3155 19 ekeinoi ekeinoi NNP 19613 3155 20 legousin legousin NNP 19613 3155 21 ton ton NN 19613 3155 22 Montanon Montanon NNP 19613 3155 23 elêluthenai elêluthenai VBZ 19613 3155 24 kai kai NNP 19613 3155 25 eschêkenai eschêkenai NNP 19613 3155 26 to to IN 19613 3155 27 teleion teleion NN 19613 3155 28 to to IN 19613 3155 29 tou tou NNP 19613 3155 30 paraklêton paraklêton NNP 19613 3155 31 , , , 19613 3155 32 tout tout JJ 19613 3155 33 ' ' '' 19613 3155 34 estin estin NNP 19613 3155 35 to to IN 19613 3155 36 tou tou NNP 19613 3155 37 agion agion NNP 19613 3155 38 pneumatos pneumatos NNP 19613 3155 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3155 40 . . . 19613 3156 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3156 2 4 4 LS 19613 3156 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3156 4 Lastly lastly RB 19613 3156 5 , , , 19613 3156 6 the the DT 19613 3156 7 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3156 8 asserted assert VBD 19613 3156 9 that that IN 19613 3156 10 the the DT 19613 3156 11 prediction prediction NN 19613 3156 12 contained contain VBN 19613 3156 13 in in IN 19613 3156 14 John John NNP 19613 3156 15 XIV XIV NNP 19613 3156 16 . . . 19613 3157 1 ff ff NNP 19613 3157 2 . . . 19613 3158 1 had have VBD 19613 3158 2 been be VBN 19613 3158 3 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 3158 4 in in IN 19613 3158 5 the the DT 19613 3158 6 new new JJ 19613 3158 7 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3158 8 , , , 19613 3158 9 and and CC 19613 3158 10 that that IN 19613 3158 11 from from IN 19613 3158 12 the the DT 19613 3158 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 3158 14 , , , 19613 3158 15 as as IN 19613 3158 16 is be VBZ 19613 3158 17 denoted denote VBN 19613 3158 18 by by IN 19613 3158 19 the the DT 19613 3158 20 very very JJ 19613 3158 21 expression expression NN 19613 3158 22 " " `` 19613 3158 23 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3158 24 . . . 19613 3158 25 " " '' 19613 3159 1 What what WDT 19613 3159 2 sort sort NN 19613 3159 3 of of IN 19613 3159 4 mission mission NN 19613 3159 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3159 6 ascribed ascribe VBD 19613 3159 7 to to IN 19613 3159 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3159 9 is be VBZ 19613 3159 10 seen see VBN 19613 3159 11 from from IN 19613 3159 12 the the DT 19613 3159 13 last last JJ 19613 3159 14 quoted quote VBN 19613 3159 15 passage passage NN 19613 3159 16 , , , 19613 3159 17 for for IN 19613 3159 18 the the DT 19613 3159 19 promises promise NNS 19613 3159 20 contained contain VBN 19613 3159 21 in in IN 19613 3159 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3159 23 must must MD 19613 3159 24 be be VB 19613 3159 25 regarded regard VBN 19613 3159 26 as as IN 19613 3159 27 the the DT 19613 3159 28 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 3159 29 carrying carry VBG 19613 3159 30 out out IN 19613 3159 31 of of IN 19613 3159 32 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3159 33 ' ' '' 19613 3159 34 programme programme NN 19613 3159 35 . . . 19613 3160 1 If if IN 19613 3160 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3160 3 read read VBP 19613 3160 4 attentively attentively RB 19613 3160 5 John John NNP 19613 3160 6 XIV XIV NNP 19613 3160 7 . . . 19613 3161 1 16 16 CD 19613 3161 2 - - SYM 19613 3161 3 21 21 CD 19613 3161 4 , , , 19613 3161 5 23 23 CD 19613 3161 6 , , , 19613 3161 7 26 26 CD 19613 3161 8 : : : 19613 3161 9 XV XV NNP 19613 3161 10 . . . 19613 3162 1 20 20 CD 19613 3162 2 - - SYM 19613 3162 3 26 26 CD 19613 3162 4 : : : 19613 3162 5 XVI XVI NNP 19613 3162 6 . . . 19613 3163 1 7 7 CD 19613 3163 2 - - SYM 19613 3163 3 15 15 CD 19613 3163 4 , , , 19613 3163 5 25 25 CD 19613 3163 6 as as RB 19613 3163 7 well well RB 19613 3163 8 as as IN 19613 3163 9 XVII XVII NNP 19613 3163 10 . . . 19613 3164 1 and and CC 19613 3164 2 X. X. NNP 19613 3164 3 ; ; : 19613 3164 4 if if IN 19613 3164 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3164 6 compare compare VBP 19613 3164 7 the the DT 19613 3164 8 oracles oracle NNS 19613 3164 9 of of IN 19613 3164 10 the the DT 19613 3164 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3164 12 still still RB 19613 3164 13 preserved preserve VBN 19613 3164 14 to to IN 19613 3164 15 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3164 16 ; ; : 19613 3164 17 if if IN 19613 3164 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3164 19 consider consider VBP 19613 3164 20 the the DT 19613 3164 21 attempt attempt NN 19613 3164 22 of of IN 19613 3164 23 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3164 24 to to TO 19613 3164 25 gather gather VB 19613 3164 26 the the DT 19613 3164 27 scattered scatter VBN 19613 3164 28 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3164 29 and and CC 19613 3164 30 really really RB 19613 3164 31 form form VB 19613 3164 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3164 33 into into IN 19613 3164 34 a a DT 19613 3164 35 flock flock NN 19613 3164 36 , , , 19613 3164 37 and and CC 19613 3164 38 also also RB 19613 3164 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3164 40 claim claim NN 19613 3164 41 to to TO 19613 3164 42 be be VB 19613 3164 43 the the DT 19613 3164 44 bearer bearer NN 19613 3164 45 of of IN 19613 3164 46 the the DT 19613 3164 47 greatest great JJS 19613 3164 48 and and CC 19613 3164 49 last last JJ 19613 3164 50 revelations revelation NNS 19613 3164 51 that that WDT 19613 3164 52 lead lead VBP 19613 3164 53 to to IN 19613 3164 54 all all DT 19613 3164 55 truth truth NN 19613 3164 56 ; ; : 19613 3164 57 and and CC 19613 3164 58 , , , 19613 3164 59 finally finally RB 19613 3164 60 , , , 19613 3164 61 if if IN 19613 3164 62 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3164 63 call call VBP 19613 3164 64 to to TO 19613 3164 65 mind mind NN 19613 3164 66 that that IN 19613 3164 67 in in IN 19613 3164 68 those those DT 19613 3164 69 Johannine Johannine NNP 19613 3164 70 discourses discourse VBZ 19613 3164 71 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3164 72 designated designate VBD 19613 3164 73 the the DT 19613 3164 74 coming coming NN 19613 3164 75 of of IN 19613 3164 76 the the DT 19613 3164 77 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3164 78 as as IN 19613 3164 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3164 80 own own JJ 19613 3164 81 coming come VBG 19613 3164 82 in in IN 19613 3164 83 the the DT 19613 3164 84 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3164 85 and and CC 19613 3164 86 spoke speak VBD 19613 3164 87 of of IN 19613 3164 88 an an DT 19613 3164 89 immanence immanence NN 19613 3164 90 and and CC 19613 3164 91 unity unity NN 19613 3164 92 of of IN 19613 3164 93 Father Father NNP 19613 3164 94 , , , 19613 3164 95 Son Son NNP 19613 3164 96 , , , 19613 3164 97 and and CC 19613 3164 98 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3164 99 , , , 19613 3164 100 which which WDT 19613 3164 101 one one PRP 19613 3164 102 finds find VBZ 19613 3164 103 re re JJ 19613 3164 104 - - VBN 19613 3164 105 echoed echoed JJ 19613 3164 106 in in IN 19613 3164 107 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3164 108 ' ' '' 19613 3164 109 Oracle Oracle NNP 19613 3164 110 No no UH 19613 3164 111 . . . 19613 3165 1 V. V. NNP 19613 3165 2 , , , 19613 3165 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3165 4 can can MD 19613 3165 5 not not RB 19613 3165 6 avoid avoid VB 19613 3165 7 concluding conclude VBG 19613 3165 8 that that IN 19613 3165 9 the the DT 19613 3165 10 latter latter NN 19613 3165 11 's 's POS 19613 3165 12 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 3165 13 is be VBZ 19613 3165 14 based base VBN 19613 3165 15 on on IN 19613 3165 16 the the DT 19613 3165 17 impression impression NN 19613 3165 18 made make VBN 19613 3165 19 on on IN 19613 3165 20 excited excited JJ 19613 3165 21 and and CC 19613 3165 22 impatient impatient JJ 19613 3165 23 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3165 24 by by IN 19613 3165 25 the the DT 19613 3165 26 promises promise NNS 19613 3165 27 contained contain VBN 19613 3165 28 in in IN 19613 3165 29 the the DT 19613 3165 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3165 31 of of IN 19613 3165 32 John John NNP 19613 3165 33 , , , 19613 3165 34 understood understand VBD 19613 3165 35 in in IN 19613 3165 36 an an DT 19613 3165 37 apocalyptic apocalyptic JJ 19613 3165 38 and and CC 19613 3165 39 realistic realistic JJ 19613 3165 40 sense sense NN 19613 3165 41 , , , 19613 3165 42 and and CC 19613 3165 43 also also RB 19613 3165 44 by by IN 19613 3165 45 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3165 46 . . . 19613 3166 1 XXIII XXIII NNP 19613 3166 2 . . . 19613 3167 1 34 34 CD 19613 3167 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3167 3 see see VB 19613 3167 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3167 5 . . NNP 19613 3167 6 , , , 19613 3167 7 V. V. NNP 19613 3167 8 16 16 CD 19613 3167 9 . . . 19613 3168 1 12 12 CD 19613 3168 2 sq sq NNP 19613 3168 3 . . NNP 19613 3168 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3168 5 . . . 19613 3169 1 The the DT 19613 3169 2 correctness correctness NN 19613 3169 3 of of IN 19613 3169 4 this this DT 19613 3169 5 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 3169 6 is be VBZ 19613 3169 7 proved prove VBN 19613 3169 8 by by IN 19613 3169 9 the the DT 19613 3169 10 fact fact NN 19613 3169 11 that that IN 19613 3169 12 the the DT 19613 3169 13 first first JJ 19613 3169 14 decided decide VBN 19613 3169 15 opponents opponent NNS 19613 3169 16 of of IN 19613 3169 17 the the DT 19613 3169 18 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3169 19 in in IN 19613 3169 20 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3169 21 -- -- : 19613 3169 22 the the DT 19613 3169 23 so so RB 19613 3169 24 - - HYPH 19613 3169 25 called call VBN 19613 3169 26 " " `` 19613 3169 27 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 3169 28 " " '' 19613 3169 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3169 30 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 3169 31 . . NNP 19613 3169 32 , , , 19613 3169 33 H. H. NNP 19613 3169 34 51)--rejected 51)--rejected CD 19613 3169 35 both both CC 19613 3169 36 the the DT 19613 3169 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3169 38 and and CC 19613 3169 39 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 3169 40 of of IN 19613 3169 41 John John NNP 19613 3169 42 , , , 19613 3169 43 that that RB 19613 3169 44 is is RB 19613 3169 45 , , , 19613 3169 46 regarded regard VBD 19613 3169 47 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3169 48 as as IN 19613 3169 49 written write VBN 19613 3169 50 by by IN 19613 3169 51 some some DT 19613 3169 52 one one NN 19613 3169 53 else else RB 19613 3169 54 . . . 19613 3170 1 Montanism montanism NN 19613 3170 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 3170 3 shows show VBZ 19613 3170 4 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3170 5 the the DT 19613 3170 6 first first JJ 19613 3170 7 and and CC 19613 3170 8 -- -- : 19613 3170 9 up up RB 19613 3170 10 till till IN 19613 3170 11 about about RB 19613 3170 12 180 180 CD 19613 3170 13 - - : 19613 3170 14 -really -really NN 19613 3170 15 the the DT 19613 3170 16 only only JJ 19613 3170 17 impression impression NN 19613 3170 18 made make VBN 19613 3170 19 by by IN 19613 3170 20 the the DT 19613 3170 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3170 22 of of IN 19613 3170 23 John John NNP 19613 3170 24 on on IN 19613 3170 25 non non JJ 19613 3170 26 - - JJ 19613 3170 27 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 3170 28 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 3170 29 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3170 30 ; ; : 19613 3170 31 and and CC 19613 3170 32 what what WP 19613 3170 33 a a DT 19613 3170 34 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3170 35 one one NN 19613 3170 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3170 37 was be VBD 19613 3170 38 ! ! . 19613 3171 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3171 2 has have VBZ 19613 3171 3 a a DT 19613 3171 4 parallel parallel NN 19613 3171 5 in in IN 19613 3171 6 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 3171 7 's 's POS 19613 3171 8 conception conception NN 19613 3171 9 of of IN 19613 3171 10 Paulinism paulinism NN 19613 3171 11 . . . 19613 3172 1 Here here RB 19613 3172 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3172 3 obtain obtain VBP 19613 3172 4 glimpses glimpse NNS 19613 3172 5 of of IN 19613 3172 6 a a DT 19613 3172 7 state state NN 19613 3172 8 of of IN 19613 3172 9 matters matter NNS 19613 3172 10 which which WDT 19613 3172 11 probably probably RB 19613 3172 12 explains explain VBZ 19613 3172 13 why why WRB 19613 3172 14 these these DT 19613 3172 15 writings writing NNS 19613 3172 16 were be VBD 19613 3172 17 made make VBN 19613 3172 18 innocuous innocuous JJ 19613 3172 19 in in IN 19613 3172 20 the the DT 19613 3172 21 canon canon NN 19613 3172 22 . . . 19613 3173 1 To to IN 19613 3173 2 the the DT 19613 3173 3 view view NN 19613 3173 4 advanced advance VBN 19613 3173 5 here here RB 19613 3173 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3173 7 can can MD 19613 3173 8 not not RB 19613 3173 9 be be VB 19613 3173 10 objected object VBN 19613 3173 11 that that IN 19613 3173 12 the the DT 19613 3173 13 later later JJ 19613 3173 14 adherents adherent NNS 19613 3173 15 of of IN 19613 3173 16 the the DT 19613 3173 17 new new JJ 19613 3173 18 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3173 19 founded found VBD 19613 3173 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3173 21 claims claim NNS 19613 3173 22 on on IN 19613 3173 23 the the DT 19613 3173 24 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3173 25 gift gift NN 19613 3173 26 of of IN 19613 3173 27 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3173 28 in in IN 19613 3173 29 the the DT 19613 3173 30 Church Church NNP 19613 3173 31 , , , 19613 3173 32 or or CC 19613 3173 33 on on IN 19613 3173 34 a a DT 19613 3173 35 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 3173 36 succession succession NN 19613 3173 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3173 38 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3173 39 , , , 19613 3173 40 H. H. NNP 19613 3173 41 E. E. NNP 19613 3173 42 V. V. NNP 19613 3173 43 17 17 CD 19613 3173 44 . . . 19613 3174 1 4 4 LS 19613 3174 2 ; ; : 19613 3174 3 Proculus proculus NN 19613 3174 4 in in IN 19613 3174 5 the the DT 19613 3174 6 same same JJ 19613 3174 7 author author NN 19613 3174 8 , , , 19613 3174 9 II II NNP 19613 3174 10 . . . 19613 3175 1 25 25 CD 19613 3175 2 . . . 19613 3176 1 7 7 LS 19613 3176 2 : : : 19613 3176 3 III iii CD 19613 3176 4 . . . 19613 3177 1 31 31 CD 19613 3177 2 . . . 19613 3178 1 4 4 LS 19613 3178 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3178 3 , , , 19613 3178 4 nor nor CC 19613 3178 5 that that IN 19613 3178 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3178 7 , , , 19613 3178 8 when when WRB 19613 3178 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3178 10 suits suit VBZ 19613 3178 11 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3178 12 , , , 19613 3178 13 simply simply RB 19613 3178 14 regards regard VBZ 19613 3178 15 the the DT 19613 3178 16 new new JJ 19613 3178 17 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3178 18 as as IN 19613 3178 19 a a DT 19613 3178 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3178 21 restitutio restitutio NN 19613 3178 22 _ _ NNP 19613 3178 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3178 24 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3178 25 , , , 19613 3178 26 in in IN 19613 3178 27 Monog Monog NNP 19613 3178 28 . . . 19613 3179 1 4 4 LS 19613 3179 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3179 3 ; ; : 19613 3179 4 for for IN 19613 3179 5 these these DT 19613 3179 6 assumptions assumption NNS 19613 3179 7 merely merely RB 19613 3179 8 represent represent VBP 19613 3179 9 the the DT 19613 3179 10 unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 19613 3179 11 attempt attempt NN 19613 3179 12 to to TO 19613 3179 13 legitimise legitimise VB 19613 3179 14 this this DT 19613 3179 15 phenomenon phenomenon NN 19613 3179 16 within within IN 19613 3179 17 the the DT 19613 3179 18 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3179 19 Church Church NNP 19613 3179 20 . . . 19613 3180 1 In in IN 19613 3180 2 proof proof NN 19613 3180 3 of of IN 19613 3180 4 the the DT 19613 3180 5 fact fact NN 19613 3180 6 that that IN 19613 3180 7 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3180 8 appealed appeal VBD 19613 3180 9 to to IN 19613 3180 10 the the DT 19613 3180 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3180 12 of of IN 19613 3180 13 John John NNP 19613 3180 14 see see VB 19613 3180 15 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 3180 16 , , , 19613 3180 17 Ep Ep NNP 19613 3180 18 . . . 19613 3181 1 41 41 CD 19613 3181 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3181 3 Migne Migne NNP 19613 3181 4 I. I. NNP 19613 3181 5 p. p. NN 19613 3181 6 474 474 CD 19613 3181 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3181 8 , , , 19613 3181 9 which which WDT 19613 3181 10 begins begin VBZ 19613 3181 11 with with IN 19613 3181 12 the the DT 19613 3181 13 words word NNS 19613 3181 14 : : : 19613 3181 15 " " `` 19613 3181 16 Testimonia Testimonia NNP 19613 3181 17 de de NNP 19613 3181 18 Johannis Johannis NNP 19613 3181 19 evangelio evangelio NN 19613 3181 20 congregata congregata NN 19613 3181 21 , , , 19613 3181 22 quæ quæ NNP 19613 3181 23 tibi tibi NNP 19613 3181 24 quidam quidam NNP 19613 3181 25 Montani Montani NNP 19613 3181 26 sectator sectator NN 19613 3181 27 ingessit ingessit NN 19613 3181 28 , , , 19613 3181 29 in in IN 19613 3181 30 quibus quibus NNP 19613 3181 31 salvator salvator NNP 19613 3181 32 noster noster NNP 19613 3181 33 se se NNP 19613 3181 34 ad ad NN 19613 3181 35 patrem patrem NNP 19613 3181 36 iturum iturum NNP 19613 3181 37 missurumque missurumque NNP 19613 3181 38 paracletum paracletum NNP 19613 3181 39 pollicetur pollicetur NNP 19613 3181 40 etc etc FW 19613 3181 41 . . . 19613 3181 42 " " '' 19613 3182 1 In in IN 19613 3182 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 3182 3 to to IN 19613 3182 4 this this DT 19613 3182 5 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 3182 6 argues argue VBZ 19613 3182 7 that that IN 19613 3182 8 the the DT 19613 3182 9 promises promise NNS 19613 3182 10 about about IN 19613 3182 11 the the DT 19613 3182 12 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3182 13 are be VBP 19613 3182 14 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 3182 15 in in IN 19613 3182 16 Acts Acts NNP 19613 3182 17 II II NNP 19613 3182 18 . . NNP 19613 3182 19 , , , 19613 3182 20 as as IN 19613 3182 21 Peter Peter NNP 19613 3182 22 said say VBD 19613 3182 23 in in IN 19613 3182 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3182 25 speech speech NN 19613 3182 26 , , , 19613 3182 27 and and CC 19613 3182 28 then then RB 19613 3182 29 continues continue VBZ 19613 3182 30 as as IN 19613 3182 31 follows follow VBZ 19613 3182 32 : : : 19613 3182 33 " " `` 19613 3182 34 Quodsi Quodsi NNP 19613 3182 35 voluerint voluerint NN 19613 3182 36 respondere respondere , 19613 3182 37 et et NNP 19613 3182 38 Philippi Philippi NNP 19613 3182 39 deinceps deincep VBZ 19613 3182 40 quattuor quattuor CC 19613 3182 41 filias filias NNP 19613 3182 42 prophetasse prophetasse NNP 19613 3182 43 et et NNP 19613 3182 44 prophetam prophetam NNP 19613 3182 45 Agabum Agabum NNP 19613 3182 46 reperiri reperiri NNP 19613 3182 47 et et FW 19613 3182 48 in in IN 19613 3182 49 divisionibus divisionibus NNP 19613 3182 50 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 3182 51 inter inter NNP 19613 3182 52 apostolos apostolos NNP 19613 3182 53 et et NNP 19613 3182 54 doctores doctores NNP 19613 3182 55 et et NNP 19613 3182 56 prophetas prophetas NN 19613 3182 57 quoque quoque NNP 19613 3182 58 apostolo apostolo NNP 19613 3182 59 scribente scribente JJ 19613 3182 60 formatos formatos NN 19613 3182 61 . . . 19613 3183 1 etc etc FW 19613 3183 2 . . . 19613 3183 3 " " '' 19613 3183 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3184 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3184 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3184 3 205 205 CD 19613 3184 4 : : : 19613 3184 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3184 6 are be VBP 19613 3184 7 assured assure VBN 19613 3184 8 of of IN 19613 3184 9 this this DT 19613 3184 10 not not RB 19613 3184 11 only only RB 19613 3184 12 by by IN 19613 3184 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3184 14 , , , 19613 3184 15 but but CC 19613 3184 16 also also RB 19613 3184 17 by by IN 19613 3184 18 the the DT 19613 3184 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 3184 20 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3184 21 Proculus Proculus NNP 19613 3184 22 , , , 19613 3184 23 who who WP 19613 3184 24 , , , 19613 3184 25 like like IN 19613 3184 26 the the DT 19613 3184 27 former former JJ 19613 3184 28 , , , 19613 3184 29 argued argue VBD 19613 3184 30 against against IN 19613 3184 31 heretics heretic NNS 19613 3184 32 , , , 19613 3184 33 and and CC 19613 3184 34 by by IN 19613 3184 35 the the DT 19613 3184 36 testimony testimony NN 19613 3184 37 of of IN 19613 3184 38 the the DT 19613 3184 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3184 40 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 3184 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3184 42 see see VB 19613 3184 43 , , , 19613 3184 44 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3184 45 , , , 19613 3184 46 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3184 47 . . . 19613 3185 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 3185 2 . . . 19613 3186 1 19 19 CD 19613 3186 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3186 3 . . . 19613 3187 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3187 2 was be VBD 19613 3187 3 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 3187 4 on on IN 19613 3187 5 the the DT 19613 3187 6 ground ground NN 19613 3187 7 of of IN 19613 3187 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3187 9 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 3187 10 that that IN 19613 3187 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3187 12 urged urge VBD 19613 3187 13 the the DT 19613 3187 14 claim claim NN 19613 3187 15 of of IN 19613 3187 16 the the DT 19613 3187 17 new new JJ 19613 3187 18 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3187 19 to to IN 19613 3187 20 a a DT 19613 3187 21 hearing hearing NN 19613 3187 22 ; ; : 19613 3187 23 and and CC 19613 3187 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3187 25 was be VBD 19613 3187 26 , , , 19613 3187 27 above above IN 19613 3187 28 all all DT 19613 3187 29 , , , 19613 3187 30 as as IN 19613 3187 31 a a DT 19613 3187 32 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3187 33 that that IN 19613 3187 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3187 35 felt feel VBD 19613 3187 36 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3187 37 capable capable JJ 19613 3187 38 of of IN 19613 3187 39 combating combat VBG 19613 3187 40 the the DT 19613 3187 41 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 3187 42 , , , 19613 3187 43 since since IN 19613 3187 44 the the DT 19613 3187 45 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3187 46 not not RB 19613 3187 47 only only RB 19613 3187 48 confirmed confirm VBD 19613 3187 49 the the DT 19613 3187 50 _ _ NNP 19613 3187 51 regula regula NN 19613 3187 52 _ _ NNP 19613 3187 53 , , , 19613 3187 54 but but CC 19613 3187 55 also also RB 19613 3187 56 by by IN 19613 3187 57 unequivocal unequivocal JJ 19613 3187 58 utterances utterance NNS 19613 3187 59 cleared clear VBD 19613 3187 60 up up RP 19613 3187 61 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 19613 3187 62 and and CC 19613 3187 63 obscure obscure JJ 19613 3187 64 passages passage NNS 19613 3187 65 in in IN 19613 3187 66 the the DT 19613 3187 67 Holy Holy NNP 19613 3187 68 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 3187 69 , , , 19613 3187 70 and and CC 19613 3187 71 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3187 72 as as IN 19613 3187 73 was be VBD 19613 3187 74 asserted assert VBN 19613 3187 75 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3187 76 completely completely RB 19613 3187 77 rejected reject VBN 19613 3187 78 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 3187 79 like like IN 19613 3187 80 the the DT 19613 3187 81 Monarchian Monarchian NNP 19613 3187 82 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3187 83 see see VB 19613 3187 84 fuga fuga NNP 19613 3187 85 1 1 CD 19613 3187 86 , , , 19613 3187 87 14 14 CD 19613 3187 88 ; ; : 19613 3187 89 corona corona NN 19613 3187 90 4 4 CD 19613 3187 91 ; ; , 19613 3187 92 virg virg NNS 19613 3187 93 . . . 19613 3188 1 vel vel NNP 19613 3188 2 . . . 19613 3189 1 1 1 LS 19613 3189 2 : : : 19613 3189 3 Prax Prax NNP 19613 3189 4 . . . 19613 3190 1 2 2 CD 19613 3190 2 , , , 19613 3190 3 13 13 CD 19613 3190 4 , , , 19613 3190 5 30 30 CD 19613 3190 6 ; ; : 19613 3190 7 resurr resurr NNP 19613 3190 8 . . . 19613 3191 1 63 63 CD 19613 3191 2 ; ; : 19613 3191 3 pud pud NNP 19613 3191 4 . . . 19613 3192 1 1 1 LS 19613 3192 2 ; ; : 19613 3192 3 monog monog NN 19613 3192 4 . . . 19613 3193 1 2 2 LS 19613 3193 2 ; ; : 19613 3193 3 ieiun ieiun JJ 19613 3193 4 . . . 19613 3194 1 10 10 CD 19613 3194 2 , , , 19613 3194 3 II II NNP 19613 3194 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3194 5 . . . 19613 3195 1 Besides besides RB 19613 3195 2 , , , 19613 3195 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3195 4 see see VBP 19613 3195 5 from from IN 19613 3195 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3195 7 's 's POS 19613 3195 8 writings writing NNS 19613 3195 9 that that IN 19613 3195 10 the the DT 19613 3195 11 secession secession NN 19613 3195 12 of of IN 19613 3195 13 the the DT 19613 3195 14 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3195 15 conventicles conventicle NNS 19613 3195 16 from from IN 19613 3195 17 the the DT 19613 3195 18 Church Church NNP 19613 3195 19 was be VBD 19613 3195 20 forced force VBN 19613 3195 21 upon upon IN 19613 3195 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3195 23 . . . 19613 3195 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3196 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3196 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3196 3 206 206 CD 19613 3196 4 : : : 19613 3196 5 The the DT 19613 3196 6 question question NN 19613 3196 7 as as IN 19613 3196 8 to to IN 19613 3196 9 whether whether IN 19613 3196 10 the the DT 19613 3196 11 new new JJ 19613 3196 12 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3196 13 had have VBD 19613 3196 14 or or CC 19613 3196 15 had have VBD 19613 3196 16 not not RB 19613 3196 17 to to TO 19613 3196 18 be be VB 19613 3196 19 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3196 20 as as IN 19613 3196 21 such such JJ 19613 3196 22 became become VBD 19613 3196 23 the the DT 19613 3196 24 decisive decisive JJ 19613 3196 25 one one CD 19613 3196 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3196 27 fuga fuga NNP 19613 3196 28 1 1 CD 19613 3196 29 , , , 19613 3196 30 14 14 CD 19613 3196 31 ; ; : 19613 3196 32 coron coron NNP 19613 3196 33 . . . 19613 3197 1 1 1 LS 19613 3197 2 ; ; : 19613 3197 3 virg virg NNS 19613 3197 4 . . . 19613 3198 1 vel vel NNP 19613 3198 2 . . . 19613 3199 1 1 1 LS 19613 3199 2 ; ; : 19613 3199 3 Prax Prax NNP 19613 3199 4 . . . 19613 3200 1 1 1 LS 19613 3200 2 : : : 19613 3200 3 pudic pudic JJ 19613 3200 4 . . . 19613 3201 1 11 11 CD 19613 3201 2 ; ; : 19613 3201 3 monog monog NN 19613 3201 4 . . . 19613 3202 1 1 1 LS 19613 3202 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3202 3 . . . 19613 3203 1 This this DT 19613 3203 2 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3203 3 was be VBD 19613 3203 4 recorded record VBN 19613 3203 5 in in IN 19613 3203 6 writing writing NN 19613 3203 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3203 8 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3203 9 . . NNP 19613 3203 10 , , , 19613 3203 11 V. V. NNP 19613 3203 12 18 18 CD 19613 3203 13 . . . 19613 3204 1 1 1 LS 19613 3204 2 ; ; : 19613 3204 3 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 3204 4 . . NNP 19613 3204 5 , , , 19613 3204 6 H. H. NNP 19613 3204 7 48 48 CD 19613 3204 8 . . . 19613 3205 1 10 10 LS 19613 3205 2 ; ; : 19613 3205 3 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3205 4 . . NNP 19613 3205 5 , , , 19613 3205 6 VI VI NNP 19613 3205 7 . . . 19613 3206 1 20 20 CD 19613 3206 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3206 3 . . . 19613 3207 1 The the DT 19613 3207 2 putting putting NN 19613 3207 3 of of IN 19613 3207 4 this this DT 19613 3207 5 question question NN 19613 3207 6 , , , 19613 3207 7 however however RB 19613 3207 8 , , , 19613 3207 9 denoted denote VBD 19613 3207 10 a a DT 19613 3207 11 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 3207 12 weakening weakening NN 19613 3207 13 of of IN 19613 3207 14 conviction conviction NN 19613 3207 15 , , , 19613 3207 16 which which WDT 19613 3207 17 was be VBD 19613 3207 18 accompanied accompany VBN 19613 3207 19 by by IN 19613 3207 20 a a DT 19613 3207 21 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 3207 22 falling fall VBG 19613 3207 23 off off RP 19613 3207 24 in in IN 19613 3207 25 the the DT 19613 3207 26 application application NN 19613 3207 27 of of IN 19613 3207 28 the the DT 19613 3207 29 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 3207 30 utterances utterance NNS 19613 3207 31 . . . 19613 3207 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3208 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3208 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3208 3 207 207 CD 19613 3208 4 : : : 19613 3208 5 The the DT 19613 3208 6 situation situation NN 19613 3208 7 that that WDT 19613 3208 8 preceded precede VBD 19613 3208 9 the the DT 19613 3208 10 acceptance acceptance NN 19613 3208 11 of of IN 19613 3208 12 the the DT 19613 3208 13 new new JJ 19613 3208 14 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3208 15 in in IN 19613 3208 16 a a DT 19613 3208 17 portion portion NN 19613 3208 18 of of IN 19613 3208 19 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 3208 20 may may MD 19613 3208 21 be be VB 19613 3208 22 studied study VBN 19613 3208 23 in in IN 19613 3208 24 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3208 25 's 's POS 19613 3208 26 writings writing NNS 19613 3208 27 " " `` 19613 3208 28 de de FW 19613 3208 29 idolol idolol NNP 19613 3208 30 . . . 19613 3208 31 " " '' 19613 3209 1 and and CC 19613 3209 2 " " `` 19613 3209 3 de de FW 19613 3209 4 spectac spectac NNP 19613 3209 5 . . . 19613 3209 6 " " '' 19613 3210 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3210 2 had have VBD 19613 3210 3 already already RB 19613 3210 4 been be VBN 19613 3210 5 conceived conceive VBN 19613 3210 6 as as IN 19613 3210 7 a a DT 19613 3210 8 _ _ NNP 19613 3210 9 nova nova NN 19613 3210 10 lex lex NNP 19613 3210 11 _ _ NNP 19613 3210 12 throughout throughout IN 19613 3210 13 the the DT 19613 3210 14 whole whole JJ 19613 3210 15 Church Church NNP 19613 3210 16 , , , 19613 3210 17 and and CC 19613 3210 18 this this DT 19613 3210 19 _ _ NNP 19613 3210 20 lex lex NN 19613 3210 21 _ _ NNP 19613 3210 22 had have VBD 19613 3210 23 , , , 19613 3210 24 moreover moreover RB 19613 3210 25 , , , 19613 3210 26 been be VBN 19613 3210 27 clearly clearly RB 19613 3210 28 defined define VBN 19613 3210 29 in in IN 19613 3210 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3210 31 bearing bearing NN 19613 3210 32 on on IN 19613 3210 33 the the DT 19613 3210 34 faith faith NN 19613 3210 35 . . . 19613 3211 1 But but CC 19613 3211 2 , , , 19613 3211 3 as as IN 19613 3211 4 regards regard VBZ 19613 3211 5 outward outward JJ 19613 3211 6 conduct conduct NN 19613 3211 7 , , , 19613 3211 8 there there EX 19613 3211 9 was be VBD 19613 3211 10 no no DT 19613 3211 11 definite definite JJ 19613 3211 12 _ _ NNP 19613 3211 13 lex lex NNP 19613 3211 14 _ _ NNP 19613 3211 15 , , , 19613 3211 16 and and CC 19613 3211 17 arguments argument NNS 19613 3211 18 in in IN 19613 3211 19 favour favour NN 19613 3211 20 both both DT 19613 3211 21 of of IN 19613 3211 22 strictness strictness NN 19613 3211 23 and and CC 19613 3211 24 of of IN 19613 3211 25 laxity laxity NN 19613 3211 26 were be VBD 19613 3211 27 brought bring VBN 19613 3211 28 forward forward RB 19613 3211 29 from from IN 19613 3211 30 the the DT 19613 3211 31 Holy Holy NNP 19613 3211 32 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 3211 33 . . . 19613 3212 1 No no DT 19613 3212 2 divine divine JJ 19613 3212 3 ordinances ordinance NNS 19613 3212 4 about about IN 19613 3212 5 morality morality NN 19613 3212 6 could could MD 19613 3212 7 be be VB 19613 3212 8 adduced adduce VBN 19613 3212 9 against against IN 19613 3212 10 the the DT 19613 3212 11 progressive progressive JJ 19613 3212 12 secularising secularising NN 19613 3212 13 of of IN 19613 3212 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3212 15 ; ; : 19613 3212 16 but but CC 19613 3212 17 there there EX 19613 3212 18 was be VBD 19613 3212 19 need need NN 19613 3212 20 of of IN 19613 3212 21 statutory statutory JJ 19613 3212 22 commandments commandment NNS 19613 3212 23 by by IN 19613 3212 24 which which WDT 19613 3212 25 all all PDT 19613 3212 26 the the DT 19613 3212 27 limits limit NNS 19613 3212 28 were be VBD 19613 3212 29 clearly clearly RB 19613 3212 30 defined define VBN 19613 3212 31 . . . 19613 3213 1 In in IN 19613 3213 2 this this DT 19613 3213 3 state state NN 19613 3213 4 of of IN 19613 3213 5 perplexity perplexity NN 19613 3213 6 the the DT 19613 3213 7 oracles oracle NNS 19613 3213 8 of of IN 19613 3213 9 the the DT 19613 3213 10 new new JJ 19613 3213 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3213 12 were be VBD 19613 3213 13 gladly gladly RB 19613 3213 14 welcomed welcome VBN 19613 3213 15 ; ; : 19613 3213 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3213 17 were be VBD 19613 3213 18 utilised utilise VBN 19613 3213 19 in in IN 19613 3213 20 order order NN 19613 3213 21 to to TO 19613 3213 22 justify justify VB 19613 3213 23 and and CC 19613 3213 24 invest invest VB 19613 3213 25 with with IN 19613 3213 26 divine divine JJ 19613 3213 27 authority authority NN 19613 3213 28 a a DT 19613 3213 29 reaction reaction NN 19613 3213 30 of of IN 19613 3213 31 a a DT 19613 3213 32 moderate moderate JJ 19613 3213 33 kind kind NN 19613 3213 34 . . . 19613 3214 1 More More JJR 19613 3214 2 than than IN 19613 3214 3 that that DT 19613 3214 4 -- -- : 19613 3214 5 as as IN 19613 3214 6 may may MD 19613 3214 7 be be VB 19613 3214 8 inferred infer VBN 19613 3214 9 from from IN 19613 3214 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3214 11 's 's POS 19613 3214 12 unwilling unwilling JJ 19613 3214 13 confession confession NN 19613 3214 14 -- -- : 19613 3214 15 could could MD 19613 3214 16 not not RB 19613 3214 17 be be VB 19613 3214 18 attained attain VBN 19613 3214 19 ; ; : 19613 3214 20 but but CC 19613 3214 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3214 22 is be VBZ 19613 3214 23 well well RB 19613 3214 24 known know VBN 19613 3214 25 that that IN 19613 3214 26 even even RB 19613 3214 27 this this DT 19613 3214 28 result result NN 19613 3214 29 was be VBD 19613 3214 30 not not RB 19613 3214 31 reached reach VBN 19613 3214 32 . . . 19613 3215 1 Thus thus RB 19613 3215 2 the the DT 19613 3215 3 Phrygian phrygian JJ 19613 3215 4 movement movement NN 19613 3215 5 was be VBD 19613 3215 6 employed employ VBN 19613 3215 7 in in IN 19613 3215 8 support support NN 19613 3215 9 of of IN 19613 3215 10 undertakings undertaking NNS 19613 3215 11 , , , 19613 3215 12 that that WDT 19613 3215 13 had have VBD 19613 3215 14 no no DT 19613 3215 15 real real JJ 19613 3215 16 connection connection NN 19613 3215 17 with with IN 19613 3215 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3215 19 . . . 19613 3216 1 But but CC 19613 3216 2 this this DT 19613 3216 3 was be VBD 19613 3216 4 the the DT 19613 3216 5 form form NN 19613 3216 6 in in IN 19613 3216 7 which which WDT 19613 3216 8 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3216 9 first first RB 19613 3216 10 became become VBD 19613 3216 11 a a DT 19613 3216 12 factor factor NN 19613 3216 13 in in IN 19613 3216 14 the the DT 19613 3216 15 history history NN 19613 3216 16 of of IN 19613 3216 17 the the DT 19613 3216 18 Church Church NNP 19613 3216 19 . . . 19613 3217 1 To to TO 19613 3217 2 what what WDT 19613 3217 3 extent extent NN 19613 3217 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3217 5 had have VBD 19613 3217 6 been be VBN 19613 3217 7 so so RB 19613 3217 8 before before RB 19613 3217 9 , , , 19613 3217 10 particularly particularly RB 19613 3217 11 as as IN 19613 3217 12 regards regard VBZ 19613 3217 13 the the DT 19613 3217 14 creation creation NN 19613 3217 15 of of IN 19613 3217 16 a a DT 19613 3217 17 New New NNP 19613 3217 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3217 19 canon canon NN 19613 3217 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3217 21 in in IN 19613 3217 22 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3217 23 Minor Minor NNP 19613 3217 24 and and CC 19613 3217 25 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3217 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3217 27 , , , 19613 3217 28 can can MD 19613 3217 29 not not RB 19613 3217 30 be be VB 19613 3217 31 made make VBN 19613 3217 32 out out RP 19613 3217 33 with with IN 19613 3217 34 certainty certainty NN 19613 3217 35 . . . 19613 3217 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3218 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3218 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3218 3 208 208 CD 19613 3218 4 : : : 19613 3218 5 See see VB 19613 3218 6 Bonwetsch Bonwetsch NNP 19613 3218 7 , , , 19613 3218 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3218 9 . . NNP 19613 3218 10 , , , 19613 3218 11 p. p. NN 19613 3219 1 82 82 CD 19613 3219 2 - - SYM 19613 3219 3 108 108 CD 19613 3219 4 . . . 19613 3219 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3220 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3220 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3220 3 209 209 CD 19613 3220 4 : : : 19613 3220 5 This this DT 19613 3220 6 is be VBZ 19613 3220 7 the the DT 19613 3220 8 point point NN 19613 3220 9 about about IN 19613 3220 10 which which WDT 19613 3220 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3220 12 's 's POS 19613 3220 13 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 3220 14 are be VBP 19613 3220 15 greatest great JJS 19613 3220 16 . . . 19613 3221 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 3221 2 is be VBZ 19613 3221 3 expressly expressly RB 19613 3221 4 repudiated repudiate VBN 19613 3221 5 in in IN 19613 3221 6 de de NNP 19613 3221 7 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3221 8 . . . 19613 3222 1 15 15 CD 19613 3222 2 . . . 19613 3222 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3223 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3223 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3223 3 210 210 CD 19613 3223 4 : : : 19613 3223 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3223 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3223 7 de de FW 19613 3223 8 monog monog NNP 19613 3223 9 . . . 19613 3223 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3224 1 is be VBZ 19613 3224 2 not not RB 19613 3224 3 deterred deter VBN 19613 3224 4 by by IN 19613 3224 5 such such PDT 19613 3224 6 a a DT 19613 3224 7 limitation limitation NN 19613 3224 8 : : : 19613 3224 9 " " `` 19613 3224 10 qui qui NNP 19613 3224 11 potest potest NNP 19613 3224 12 capere capere NNP 19613 3224 13 capiat capiat NN 19613 3224 14 , , , 19613 3224 15 inquit inquit NN 19613 3224 16 , , , 19613 3224 17 i -PRON- PRP 19613 3224 18 d d VBD 19613 3224 19 est est NNP 19613 3224 20 qui qui VBD 19613 3224 21 non non PRP$ 19613 3224 22 potest potest NNP 19613 3224 23 discedat discedat NN 19613 3224 24 . . . 19613 3224 25 " " '' 19613 3224 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3225 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3225 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3225 3 211 211 CD 19613 3225 4 : : : 19613 3225 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3225 6 is be VBZ 19613 3225 7 very very RB 19613 3225 8 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3225 9 , , , 19613 3225 10 but but CC 19613 3225 11 at at IN 19613 3225 12 the the DT 19613 3225 13 same same JJ 19613 3225 14 time time NN 19613 3225 15 very very RB 19613 3225 16 painful painful JJ 19613 3225 17 , , , 19613 3225 18 to to TO 19613 3225 19 trace trace VB 19613 3225 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3225 21 's 's POS 19613 3225 22 endeavours endeavour NNS 19613 3225 23 to to TO 19613 3225 24 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 3225 25 the the DT 19613 3225 26 irreconcilable irreconcilable JJ 19613 3225 27 , , , 19613 3225 28 in in IN 19613 3225 29 other other JJ 19613 3225 30 words word NNS 19613 3225 31 , , , 19613 3225 32 to to TO 19613 3225 33 show show VB 19613 3225 34 that that IN 19613 3225 35 the the DT 19613 3225 36 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3225 37 is be VBZ 19613 3225 38 new new JJ 19613 3225 39 and and CC 19613 3225 40 yet yet RB 19613 3225 41 not not RB 19613 3225 42 so so RB 19613 3225 43 ; ; : 19613 3225 44 that that IN 19613 3225 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3225 46 does do VBZ 19613 3225 47 not not RB 19613 3225 48 impair impair VB 19613 3225 49 the the DT 19613 3225 50 full full JJ 19613 3225 51 authority authority NN 19613 3225 52 of of IN 19613 3225 53 the the DT 19613 3225 54 New New NNP 19613 3225 55 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3225 56 and and CC 19613 3225 57 yet yet RB 19613 3225 58 supersedes supersede VBZ 19613 3225 59 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3225 60 . . . 19613 3226 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 3226 2 is be VBZ 19613 3226 3 forced force VBN 19613 3226 4 to to TO 19613 3226 5 maintain maintain VB 19613 3226 6 the the DT 19613 3226 7 theory theory NN 19613 3226 8 that that IN 19613 3226 9 the the DT 19613 3226 10 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3226 11 stands stand VBZ 19613 3226 12 in in IN 19613 3226 13 the the DT 19613 3226 14 same same JJ 19613 3226 15 relation relation NN 19613 3226 16 to to IN 19613 3226 17 the the DT 19613 3226 18 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 3226 19 as as IN 19613 3226 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3226 21 does do VBZ 19613 3226 22 to to IN 19613 3226 23 Moses Moses NNP 19613 3226 24 , , , 19613 3226 25 and and CC 19613 3226 26 that that IN 19613 3226 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3226 28 abrogates abrogate VBZ 19613 3226 29 the the DT 19613 3226 30 concessions concession NNS 19613 3226 31 made make VBN 19613 3226 32 by by IN 19613 3226 33 the the DT 19613 3226 34 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 3226 35 and and CC 19613 3226 36 even even RB 19613 3226 37 by by IN 19613 3226 38 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3226 39 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3226 40 ; ; : 19613 3226 41 whilst whilst IN 19613 3226 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3226 43 is be VBZ 19613 3226 44 at at IN 19613 3226 45 the the DT 19613 3226 46 same same JJ 19613 3226 47 time time NN 19613 3226 48 obliged oblige VBD 19613 3226 49 to to TO 19613 3226 50 reassert reassert VB 19613 3226 51 the the DT 19613 3226 52 sufficiency sufficiency NN 19613 3226 53 of of IN 19613 3226 54 both both DT 19613 3226 55 Testaments testament NNS 19613 3226 56 . . . 19613 3227 1 In in IN 19613 3227 2 connection connection NN 19613 3227 3 with with IN 19613 3227 4 this this DT 19613 3227 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3227 6 hit hit VBD 19613 3227 7 upon upon IN 19613 3227 8 the the DT 19613 3227 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3227 10 theory theory NN 19613 3227 11 of of IN 19613 3227 12 stages stage NNS 19613 3227 13 in in IN 19613 3227 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 3227 15 -- -- : 19613 3227 16 a a DT 19613 3227 17 theory theory NN 19613 3227 18 which which WDT 19613 3227 19 , , , 19613 3227 20 were be VBD 19613 3227 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3227 22 not not RB 19613 3227 23 a a DT 19613 3227 24 mere mere JJ 19613 3227 25 expedient expedient NN 19613 3227 26 in in IN 19613 3227 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3227 28 case case NN 19613 3227 29 , , , 19613 3227 30 one one PRP 19613 3227 31 might may MD 19613 3227 32 regard regard VB 19613 3227 33 as as IN 19613 3227 34 the the DT 19613 3227 35 first first JJ 19613 3227 36 faint faint JJ 19613 3227 37 trace trace NN 19613 3227 38 of of IN 19613 3227 39 a a DT 19613 3227 40 historical historical JJ 19613 3227 41 view view NN 19613 3227 42 of of IN 19613 3227 43 the the DT 19613 3227 44 question question NN 19613 3227 45 . . . 19613 3228 1 Still still RB 19613 3228 2 , , , 19613 3228 3 this this DT 19613 3228 4 is be VBZ 19613 3228 5 another another DT 19613 3228 6 case case NN 19613 3228 7 of of IN 19613 3228 8 a a DT 19613 3228 9 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 3228 10 , , , 19613 3228 11 furnishing furnish VBG 19613 3228 12 theology theology NN 19613 3228 13 with with IN 19613 3228 14 a a DT 19613 3228 15 conception conception NN 19613 3228 16 that that IN 19613 3228 17 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3228 18 has have VBZ 19613 3228 19 cautiously cautiously RB 19613 3228 20 employed employ VBN 19613 3228 21 in in IN 19613 3228 22 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 3228 23 times time NNS 19613 3228 24 , , , 19613 3228 25 when when WRB 19613 3228 26 brought bring VBD 19613 3228 27 face face NN 19613 3228 28 to to IN 19613 3228 29 face face NN 19613 3228 30 with with IN 19613 3228 31 certain certain JJ 19613 3228 32 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 3228 33 ; ; : 19613 3228 34 see see VB 19613 3228 35 virg virg NNS 19613 3228 36 . . . 19613 3229 1 vel vel NNP 19613 3229 2 . . . 19613 3230 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3230 2 ; ; : 19613 3230 3 exhort exhort NN 19613 3230 4 . . . 19613 3231 1 6 6 CD 19613 3231 2 ; ; : 19613 3231 3 monog monog NN 19613 3231 4 . . . 19613 3232 1 2 2 CD 19613 3232 2 , , , 19613 3232 3 3 3 CD 19613 3232 4 , , , 19613 3232 5 14 14 CD 19613 3232 6 ; ; : 19613 3232 7 resurr resurr NNP 19613 3232 8 . . . 19613 3233 1 63 63 CD 19613 3233 2 . . . 19613 3234 1 For for IN 19613 3234 2 the the DT 19613 3234 3 rest rest NN 19613 3234 4 , , , 19613 3234 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3234 6 is be VBZ 19613 3234 7 at at IN 19613 3234 8 bottom bottom NN 19613 3234 9 a a DT 19613 3234 10 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3234 11 of of IN 19613 3234 12 the the DT 19613 3234 13 old old JJ 19613 3234 14 stamp stamp NN 19613 3234 15 ; ; : 19613 3234 16 the the DT 19613 3234 17 theory theory NN 19613 3234 18 of of IN 19613 3234 19 any any DT 19613 3234 20 sort sort NN 19613 3234 21 of of IN 19613 3234 22 finality finality NN 19613 3234 23 in in IN 19613 3234 24 revelation revelation NN 19613 3234 25 is be VBZ 19613 3234 26 of of IN 19613 3234 27 no no DT 19613 3234 28 use use NN 19613 3234 29 to to IN 19613 3234 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3234 31 except except IN 19613 3234 32 in in IN 19613 3234 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3234 34 bearing bearing NN 19613 3234 35 on on IN 19613 3234 36 heresy heresy NN 19613 3234 37 ; ; : 19613 3234 38 for for IN 19613 3234 39 the the DT 19613 3234 40 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3234 41 continually continually RB 19613 3234 42 guides guide VBZ 19613 3234 43 to to IN 19613 3234 44 all all DT 19613 3234 45 truth truth NN 19613 3234 46 and and CC 19613 3234 47 works work NNS 19613 3234 48 wherever wherever WRB 19613 3234 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3234 50 will will MD 19613 3234 51 . . . 19613 3235 1 Similarly similarly RB 19613 3235 2 , , , 19613 3235 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3235 4 only only JJ 19613 3235 5 reason reason NN 19613 3235 6 for for IN 19613 3235 7 not not RB 19613 3235 8 being be VBG 19613 3235 9 an an DT 19613 3235 10 Encratite Encratite NNP 19613 3235 11 is be VBZ 19613 3235 12 that that IN 19613 3235 13 this this DT 19613 3235 14 mode mode NN 19613 3235 15 of of IN 19613 3235 16 life life NN 19613 3235 17 had have VBD 19613 3235 18 already already RB 19613 3235 19 been be VBN 19613 3235 20 adopted adopt VBN 19613 3235 21 by by IN 19613 3235 22 heretics heretic NNS 19613 3235 23 , , , 19613 3235 24 and and CC 19613 3235 25 become become VB 19613 3235 26 associated associate VBN 19613 3235 27 with with IN 19613 3235 28 dualism dualism NN 19613 3235 29 . . . 19613 3236 1 But but CC 19613 3236 2 the the DT 19613 3236 3 conviction conviction NN 19613 3236 4 that that IN 19613 3236 5 all all DT 19613 3236 6 religion religion NN 19613 3236 7 must must MD 19613 3236 8 have have VB 19613 3236 9 the the DT 19613 3236 10 character character NN 19613 3236 11 of of IN 19613 3236 12 a a DT 19613 3236 13 fixed fix VBN 19613 3236 14 _ _ NNP 19613 3236 15 law law NN 19613 3236 16 _ _ NN 19613 3236 17 and and CC 19613 3236 18 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 3236 19 definite definite JJ 19613 3236 20 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3236 21 -- -- : 19613 3236 22 a a DT 19613 3236 23 belief belief NN 19613 3236 24 not not RB 19613 3236 25 emanating emanate VBG 19613 3236 26 from from IN 19613 3236 27 primitive primitive JJ 19613 3236 28 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3236 29 , , , 19613 3236 30 but but CC 19613 3236 31 from from IN 19613 3236 32 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3236 33 -- -- : 19613 3236 34 bound bind VBD 19613 3236 35 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3236 36 to to IN 19613 3236 37 the the DT 19613 3236 38 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3236 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3236 40 . . . 19613 3237 1 Besides besides IN 19613 3237 2 , , , 19613 3237 3 the the DT 19613 3237 4 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 3237 5 with with IN 19613 3237 6 which which WDT 19613 3237 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3237 8 struggled struggle VBD 19613 3237 9 were be VBD 19613 3237 10 by by IN 19613 3237 11 no no DT 19613 3237 12 means means NN 19613 3237 13 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3237 14 to to IN 19613 3237 15 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3237 16 ; ; : 19613 3237 17 in in IN 19613 3237 18 so so RB 19613 3237 19 far far RB 19613 3237 20 as as IN 19613 3237 21 the the DT 19613 3237 22 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3237 23 societies society NNS 19613 3237 24 accepted accept VBD 19613 3237 25 the the DT 19613 3237 26 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 3237 27 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3237 28 , , , 19613 3237 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3237 30 weighed weigh VBD 19613 3237 31 on on IN 19613 3237 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3237 33 all all DT 19613 3237 34 , , , 19613 3237 35 and and CC 19613 3237 36 in in IN 19613 3237 37 all all DT 19613 3237 38 probability probability NN 19613 3237 39 crushed crush VBD 19613 3237 40 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3237 41 out out IN 19613 3237 42 of of IN 19613 3237 43 existence existence NN 19613 3237 44 . . . 19613 3238 1 In in IN 19613 3238 2 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3238 3 Minor Minor NNP 19613 3238 4 , , , 19613 3238 5 where where WRB 19613 3238 6 the the DT 19613 3238 7 breach breach NN 19613 3238 8 took take VBD 19613 3238 9 place place NN 19613 3238 10 earlier early RBR 19613 3238 11 , , , 19613 3238 12 the the DT 19613 3238 13 sect sect NN 19613 3238 14 held hold VBD 19613 3238 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3238 16 ground ground NN 19613 3238 17 longer long RBR 19613 3238 18 . . . 19613 3239 1 In in IN 19613 3239 2 North North NNP 19613 3239 3 Africa Africa NNP 19613 3239 4 the the DT 19613 3239 5 residuum residuum NN 19613 3239 6 was be VBD 19613 3239 7 a a DT 19613 3239 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3239 9 propensity propensity NN 19613 3239 10 to to IN 19613 3239 11 visions vision NNS 19613 3239 12 , , , 19613 3239 13 holy holy JJ 19613 3239 14 dreams dream NNS 19613 3239 15 , , , 19613 3239 16 and and CC 19613 3239 17 the the DT 19613 3239 18 like like JJ 19613 3239 19 . . . 19613 3240 1 The the DT 19613 3240 2 feature feature NN 19613 3240 3 which which WDT 19613 3240 4 forms form VBZ 19613 3240 5 the the DT 19613 3240 6 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3240 7 characteristic characteristic NN 19613 3240 8 of of IN 19613 3240 9 the the DT 19613 3240 10 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 3240 11 of of IN 19613 3240 12 Perpetua Perpetua NNP 19613 3240 13 and and CC 19613 3240 14 Felicitas Felicitas NNP 19613 3240 15 is be VBZ 19613 3240 16 still still RB 19613 3240 17 found find VBN 19613 3240 18 in in IN 19613 3240 19 a a DT 19613 3240 20 similar similar JJ 19613 3240 21 shape shape NN 19613 3240 22 in in IN 19613 3240 23 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3240 24 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3240 25 , , , 19613 3240 26 who who WP 19613 3240 27 makes make VBZ 19613 3240 28 powerful powerful JJ 19613 3240 29 use use NN 19613 3240 30 of of IN 19613 3240 31 visions vision NNS 19613 3240 32 and and CC 19613 3240 33 dreams dream NNS 19613 3240 34 ; ; : 19613 3240 35 and and CC 19613 3240 36 in in IN 19613 3240 37 the the DT 19613 3240 38 genuine genuine JJ 19613 3240 39 African african JJ 19613 3240 40 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 3240 41 of of IN 19613 3240 42 the the DT 19613 3240 43 Martyrs Martyrs NNPS 19613 3240 44 , , , 19613 3240 45 dating date VBG 19613 3240 46 from from IN 19613 3240 47 Valerian Valerian NNP 19613 3240 48 's 's POS 19613 3240 49 time time NN 19613 3240 50 , , , 19613 3240 51 which which WDT 19613 3240 52 are be VBP 19613 3240 53 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 3240 54 little little RB 19613 3240 55 studied studied JJ 19613 3240 56 . . . 19613 3241 1 See see VB 19613 3241 2 , , , 19613 3241 3 above above IN 19613 3241 4 all all DT 19613 3241 5 , , , 19613 3241 6 the the DT 19613 3241 7 Acta Acta NNP 19613 3241 8 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 19613 3241 9 , , , 19613 3241 10 Mariani Mariani NNP 19613 3241 11 etc etc FW 19613 3241 12 . . FW 19613 3241 13 , , , 19613 3241 14 and and CC 19613 3241 15 the the DT 19613 3241 16 Acta Acta NNP 19613 3241 17 Montani Montani NNP 19613 3241 18 , , , 19613 3241 19 Lucii Lucii NNP 19613 3241 20 etc etc FW 19613 3241 21 . . . 19613 3242 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3242 2 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 19613 3242 3 , , , 19613 3242 4 Acta Acta NNP 19613 3242 5 Mart Mart NNP 19613 3242 6 . . . 19613 3243 1 edit edit NNP 19613 3243 2 Ratisb Ratisb NNP 19613 3243 3 . . . 19613 3244 1 1859 1859 CD 19613 3244 2 , , , 19613 3244 3 p. p. NN 19613 3244 4 268 268 CD 19613 3244 5 sq sq NNP 19613 3244 6 . . NNP 19613 3244 7 , , , 19613 3244 8 p. p. NN 19613 3244 9 275 275 CD 19613 3244 10 sq sq NNP 19613 3244 11 . . NNP 19613 3244 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3244 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3245 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3245 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3245 3 212 212 CD 19613 3245 4 : : : 19613 3245 5 Nothing nothing NN 19613 3245 6 is be VBZ 19613 3245 7 known know VBN 19613 3245 8 of of IN 19613 3245 9 attempts attempt NNS 19613 3245 10 at at IN 19613 3245 11 a a DT 19613 3245 12 formal formal JJ 19613 3245 13 incorporation incorporation NN 19613 3245 14 of of IN 19613 3245 15 the the DT 19613 3245 16 Oracles Oracles NNP 19613 3245 17 with with IN 19613 3245 18 the the DT 19613 3245 19 New New NNP 19613 3245 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3245 21 . . . 19613 3246 1 Besides besides IN 19613 3246 2 , , , 19613 3246 3 the the DT 19613 3246 4 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3246 5 could could MD 19613 3246 6 dispense dispense VB 19613 3246 7 with with IN 19613 3246 8 this this DT 19613 3246 9 because because IN 19613 3246 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3246 11 distinguished distinguish VBD 19613 3246 12 the the DT 19613 3246 13 commandments commandment NNS 19613 3246 14 of of IN 19613 3246 15 the the DT 19613 3246 16 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3246 17 as as IN 19613 3246 18 " " `` 19613 3246 19 novissima novissima NNP 19613 3246 20 lex lex NNP 19613 3246 21 " " '' 19613 3246 22 from from IN 19613 3246 23 the the DT 19613 3246 24 " " `` 19613 3246 25 novum novum NN 19613 3246 26 testamentum testamentum NN 19613 3246 27 . . . 19613 3246 28 " " '' 19613 3247 1 The the DT 19613 3247 2 preface preface NN 19613 3247 3 to to IN 19613 3247 4 the the DT 19613 3247 5 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3247 6 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 3247 7 of of IN 19613 3247 8 Perpetua Perpetua NNP 19613 3247 9 and and CC 19613 3247 10 Felicitas Felicitas NNP 19613 3247 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3247 12 was be VBD 19613 3247 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3247 14 the the DT 19613 3247 15 author author NN 19613 3247 16 ? ? . 19613 3247 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3248 1 showed show VBD 19613 3248 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 3248 3 the the DT 19613 3248 4 high high JJ 19613 3248 5 value value NN 19613 3248 6 attached attach VBN 19613 3248 7 to to IN 19613 3248 8 the the DT 19613 3248 9 visions vision NNS 19613 3248 10 of of IN 19613 3248 11 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 3248 12 . . . 19613 3249 1 In in IN 19613 3249 2 so so RB 19613 3249 3 far far RB 19613 3249 4 as as IN 19613 3249 5 these these DT 19613 3249 6 were be VBD 19613 3249 7 to to TO 19613 3249 8 be be VB 19613 3249 9 read read VBN 19613 3249 10 in in IN 19613 3249 11 the the DT 19613 3249 12 Churches church NNS 19613 3249 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3249 14 were be VBD 19613 3249 15 meant mean VBN 19613 3249 16 to to TO 19613 3249 17 be be VB 19613 3249 18 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 3249 19 as as IN 19613 3249 20 an an DT 19613 3249 21 " " `` 19613 3249 22 instrumentum instrumentum JJ 19613 3249 23 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NN 19613 3249 24 " " '' 19613 3249 25 in in IN 19613 3249 26 the the DT 19613 3249 27 wider wide JJR 19613 3249 28 sense sense NN 19613 3249 29 . . . 19613 3249 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3250 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3250 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3250 3 213 213 CD 19613 3250 4 : : : 19613 3250 5 Here here RB 19613 3250 6 the the DT 19613 3250 7 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3250 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3250 9 occupy occupy VBP 19613 3250 10 the the DT 19613 3250 11 foreground foreground NN 19613 3250 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3250 13 there there EX 19613 3250 14 are be VBP 19613 3250 15 complaints complaint NNS 19613 3250 16 about about IN 19613 3250 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3250 18 cowardice cowardice NN 19613 3250 19 and and CC 19613 3250 20 serving serve VBG 19613 3250 21 of of IN 19613 3250 22 two two CD 19613 3250 23 masters master NNS 19613 3250 24 in in IN 19613 3250 25 the the DT 19613 3250 26 treatise treatise NN 19613 3250 27 _ _ NNP 19613 3250 28 de de NNP 19613 3250 29 fugo fugo NNP 19613 3250 30 _ _ NNP 19613 3250 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3250 32 . . . 19613 3251 1 But but CC 19613 3251 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3251 3 would would MD 19613 3251 4 be be VB 19613 3251 5 very very RB 19613 3251 6 unjust unjust JJ 19613 3251 7 simply simply RB 19613 3251 8 to to TO 19613 3251 9 find find VB 19613 3251 10 fault fault NN 19613 3251 11 with with IN 19613 3251 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3251 13 as as IN 19613 3251 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3251 15 does do VBZ 19613 3251 16 . . . 19613 3252 1 Two two CD 19613 3252 2 interests interest NNS 19613 3252 3 combined combine VBN 19613 3252 4 to to TO 19613 3252 5 influence influence VB 19613 3252 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3252 7 conduct conduct NN 19613 3252 8 ; ; : 19613 3252 9 for for IN 19613 3252 10 if if IN 19613 3252 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3252 12 drew draw VBD 19613 3252 13 the the DT 19613 3252 14 reins rein NNS 19613 3252 15 tight tight JJ 19613 3252 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3252 17 gave give VBD 19613 3252 18 over over IN 19613 3252 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3252 20 flock flock NN 19613 3252 21 to to TO 19613 3252 22 heresy heresy VB 19613 3252 23 or or CC 19613 3252 24 heathenism heathenism NN 19613 3252 25 . . . 19613 3253 1 This this DT 19613 3253 2 situation situation NN 19613 3253 3 is be VBZ 19613 3253 4 already already RB 19613 3253 5 evident evident JJ 19613 3253 6 in in IN 19613 3253 7 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 3253 8 and and CC 19613 3253 9 dominates dominate VBZ 19613 3253 10 the the DT 19613 3253 11 resolutions resolution NNS 19613 3253 12 of of IN 19613 3253 13 the the DT 19613 3253 14 Church Church NNP 19613 3253 15 leaders leader NNS 19613 3253 16 in in IN 19613 3253 17 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 3253 18 generations generation NNS 19613 3253 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3253 20 see see VB 19613 3253 21 below below RB 19613 3253 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3253 23 . . . 19613 3253 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3254 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3254 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3254 3 214 214 CD 19613 3254 4 : : : 19613 3254 5 The the DT 19613 3254 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 3254 7 of of IN 19613 3254 8 " " `` 19613 3254 9 Spiritales Spiritales NNPS 19613 3254 10 " " '' 19613 3254 11 and and CC 19613 3254 12 " " `` 19613 3254 13 Psychici Psychici NNP 19613 3254 14 " " '' 19613 3254 15 on on IN 19613 3254 16 the the DT 19613 3254 17 part part NN 19613 3254 18 of of IN 19613 3254 19 the the DT 19613 3254 20 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3254 21 is be VBZ 19613 3254 22 not not RB 19613 3254 23 confined confine VBN 19613 3254 24 to to IN 19613 3254 25 the the DT 19613 3254 26 West West NNP 19613 3254 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3254 28 see see VB 19613 3254 29 Clem Clem NNP 19613 3254 30 . . . 19613 3254 31 , , , 19613 3254 32 Strom Strom NNP 19613 3254 33 . . . 19613 3255 1 IV IV NNP 19613 3255 2 . . . 19613 3256 1 13 13 CD 19613 3256 2 . . . 19613 3257 1 93 93 CD 19613 3257 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3257 3 ; ; : 19613 3257 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3257 5 find find VBP 19613 3257 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3257 7 very very RB 19613 3257 8 frequently frequently RB 19613 3257 9 in in IN 19613 3257 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3257 11 . . . 19613 3258 1 In in IN 19613 3258 2 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3258 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3258 4 did do VBD 19613 3258 5 not not RB 19613 3258 6 yet yet RB 19613 3258 7 lead lead VB 19613 3258 8 to to IN 19613 3258 9 the the DT 19613 3258 10 formal formal JJ 19613 3258 11 breach breach NN 19613 3258 12 with with IN 19613 3258 13 the the DT 19613 3258 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3258 15 Church Church NNP 19613 3258 16 . . . 19613 3258 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3259 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3259 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3259 3 215 215 CD 19613 3259 4 : : : 19613 3259 5 A a DT 19613 3259 6 contrast contrast NN 19613 3259 7 to to IN 19613 3259 8 the the DT 19613 3259 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3259 10 and and CC 19613 3259 11 the the DT 19613 3259 12 regular regular JJ 19613 3259 13 congregational congregational JJ 19613 3259 14 offices office NNS 19613 3259 15 existed exist VBD 19613 3259 16 in in IN 19613 3259 17 primitive primitive JJ 19613 3259 18 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3259 19 . . . 19613 3260 1 This this DT 19613 3260 2 was be VBD 19613 3260 3 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 3260 4 in in IN 19613 3260 5 a a DT 19613 3260 6 weakened weaken VBN 19613 3260 7 form form NN 19613 3260 8 to to IN 19613 3260 9 the the DT 19613 3260 10 later later JJ 19613 3260 11 adherents adherent NNS 19613 3260 12 of of IN 19613 3260 13 the the DT 19613 3260 14 new new JJ 19613 3260 15 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3260 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3260 17 cf cf NN 19613 3260 18 . . . 19613 3261 1 the the DT 19613 3261 2 Gallic Gallic NNP 19613 3261 3 confessors confessor NNS 19613 3261 4 ' ' POS 19613 3261 5 strange strange JJ 19613 3261 6 letter letter NN 19613 3261 7 of of IN 19613 3261 8 recommendation recommendation NN 19613 3261 9 on on IN 19613 3261 10 behalf behalf NN 19613 3261 11 of of IN 19613 3261 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3261 13 in in IN 19613 3261 14 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3261 15 . . NNP 19613 3261 16 , , , 19613 3261 17 H. H. NNP 19613 3261 18 E. E. NNP 19613 3261 19 V. V. NNP 19613 3261 20 4 4 CD 19613 3261 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3261 22 , , , 19613 3261 23 and and CC 19613 3261 24 finally finally RB 19613 3261 25 broke break VBD 19613 3261 26 forth forth RB 19613 3261 27 with with IN 19613 3261 28 renewed renew VBN 19613 3261 29 vigour vigour NN 19613 3261 30 in in IN 19613 3261 31 opposition opposition NN 19613 3261 32 to to IN 19613 3261 33 the the DT 19613 3261 34 measures measure NNS 19613 3261 35 of of IN 19613 3261 36 the the DT 19613 3261 37 lax lax NNP 19613 3261 38 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3261 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3261 40 de de FW 19613 3261 41 pudic pudic JJ 19613 3261 42 . . . 19613 3262 1 21 21 LS 19613 3262 2 ; ; : 19613 3262 3 de de FW 19613 3262 4 exhort exhort NN 19613 3262 5 . . . 19613 3263 1 7 7 LS 19613 3263 2 ; ; : 19613 3263 3 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3263 4 against against IN 19613 3263 5 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3263 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3263 7 . . . 19613 3264 1 The the DT 19613 3264 2 _ _ NNP 19613 3264 3 ecclesia ecclesia NN 19613 3264 4 _ _ NNP 19613 3264 5 , , , 19613 3264 6 represented represent VBN 19613 3264 7 as as IN 19613 3264 8 _ _ NNP 19613 3264 9 numerus numerus NNP 19613 3264 10 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 3264 11 _ _ NNP 19613 3264 12 , , , 19613 3264 13 no no RB 19613 3264 14 longer long RBR 19613 3264 15 preserved preserve VBD 19613 3264 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3264 17 prestige prestige NN 19613 3264 18 in in IN 19613 3264 19 the the DT 19613 3264 20 eyes eye NNS 19613 3264 21 of of IN 19613 3264 22 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3264 23 . . . 19613 3264 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3265 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3265 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3265 3 216 216 CD 19613 3265 4 : : : 19613 3265 5 See see VB 19613 3265 6 here here RB 19613 3265 7 particularly particularly RB 19613 3265 8 , , , 19613 3265 9 de de NNP 19613 3265 10 pudicitia pudicitia NNP 19613 3265 11 1 1 CD 19613 3265 12 , , , 19613 3265 13 where where WRB 19613 3265 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3265 15 sees see VBZ 19613 3265 16 the the DT 19613 3265 17 virginity virginity NN 19613 3265 18 of of IN 19613 3265 19 the the DT 19613 3265 20 Church Church NNP 19613 3265 21 not not RB 19613 3265 22 in in IN 19613 3265 23 pure pure JJ 19613 3265 24 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 3265 25 , , , 19613 3265 26 but but CC 19613 3265 27 in in IN 19613 3265 28 strict strict JJ 19613 3265 29 precepts precept NNS 19613 3265 30 for for IN 19613 3265 31 a a DT 19613 3265 32 holy holy JJ 19613 3265 33 life life NN 19613 3265 34 . . . 19613 3266 1 As as IN 19613 3266 2 will will MD 19613 3266 3 have have VB 19613 3266 4 been be VBN 19613 3266 5 seen see VBN 19613 3266 6 in in IN 19613 3266 7 this this DT 19613 3266 8 account account NN 19613 3266 9 , , , 19613 3266 10 the the DT 19613 3266 11 oft oft RB 19613 3266 12 debated debate VBN 19613 3266 13 question question NN 19613 3266 14 as as IN 19613 3266 15 to to IN 19613 3266 16 whether whether IN 19613 3266 17 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3266 18 was be VBD 19613 3266 19 an an DT 19613 3266 20 innovation innovation NN 19613 3266 21 or or CC 19613 3266 22 merely merely RB 19613 3266 23 a a DT 19613 3266 24 reaction reaction NN 19613 3266 25 does do VBZ 19613 3266 26 not not RB 19613 3266 27 admit admit VB 19613 3266 28 of of IN 19613 3266 29 a a DT 19613 3266 30 simple simple JJ 19613 3266 31 answer answer NN 19613 3266 32 . . . 19613 3267 1 In in IN 19613 3267 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3267 3 original original JJ 19613 3267 4 shape shape NN 19613 3267 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3267 6 was be VBD 19613 3267 7 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 3267 8 an an DT 19613 3267 9 innovation innovation NN 19613 3267 10 ; ; : 19613 3267 11 but but CC 19613 3267 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3267 13 existed exist VBD 19613 3267 14 at at IN 19613 3267 15 the the DT 19613 3267 16 end end NN 19613 3267 17 of of IN 19613 3267 18 a a DT 19613 3267 19 period period NN 19613 3267 20 when when WRB 19613 3267 21 one one PRP 19613 3267 22 can can MD 19613 3267 23 not not RB 19613 3267 24 very very RB 19613 3267 25 well well RB 19613 3267 26 speak speak NN 19613 3267 27 of of IN 19613 3267 28 innovations innovation NNS 19613 3267 29 , , , 19613 3267 30 because because IN 19613 3267 31 no no DT 19613 3267 32 bounds bound NNS 19613 3267 33 had have VBD 19613 3267 34 yet yet RB 19613 3267 35 been be VBN 19613 3267 36 set set VBN 19613 3267 37 to to IN 19613 3267 38 subjective subjective JJ 19613 3267 39 religiosity religiosity NN 19613 3267 40 . . . 19613 3268 1 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3268 2 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 3268 3 went go VBD 19613 3268 4 further far RBR 19613 3268 5 than than IN 19613 3268 6 any any DT 19613 3268 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 3268 8 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3268 9 known know VBN 19613 3268 10 to to IN 19613 3268 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3268 12 ; ; : 19613 3268 13 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 3268 14 , , , 19613 3268 15 too too RB 19613 3268 16 , , , 19613 3268 17 no no RB 19613 3268 18 doubt doubt RB 19613 3268 19 gave give VBD 19613 3268 20 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 3268 21 , , , 19613 3268 22 as as IN 19613 3268 23 a a DT 19613 3268 24 prophet prophet NN 19613 3268 25 , , , 19613 3268 26 which which WDT 19613 3268 27 gave give VBD 19613 3268 28 rise rise NN 19613 3268 29 to to IN 19613 3268 30 innovations innovation NNS 19613 3268 31 in in IN 19613 3268 32 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 3268 33 ; ; : 19613 3268 34 but but CC 19613 3268 35 these these DT 19613 3268 36 fell fall VBD 19613 3268 37 short short RB 19613 3268 38 of of IN 19613 3268 39 Montanus Montanus NNP 19613 3268 40 ' ' '' 19613 3268 41 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 3268 42 . . . 19613 3269 1 In in IN 19613 3269 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3269 3 later later JJ 19613 3269 4 shape shape NN 19613 3269 5 , , , 19613 3269 6 however however RB 19613 3269 7 , , , 19613 3269 8 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3269 9 was be VBD 19613 3269 10 to to IN 19613 3269 11 all all DT 19613 3269 12 intents intent NNS 19613 3269 13 and and CC 19613 3269 14 purposes purpose VBZ 19613 3269 15 a a DT 19613 3269 16 reaction reaction NN 19613 3269 17 , , , 19613 3269 18 which which WDT 19613 3269 19 aimed aim VBD 19613 3269 20 at at IN 19613 3269 21 maintaining maintain VBG 19613 3269 22 or or CC 19613 3269 23 reviving revive VBG 19613 3269 24 an an DT 19613 3269 25 older old JJR 19613 3269 26 state state NN 19613 3269 27 of of IN 19613 3269 28 things thing NNS 19613 3269 29 . . . 19613 3270 1 So so RB 19613 3270 2 far far RB 19613 3270 3 , , , 19613 3270 4 however however RB 19613 3270 5 , , , 19613 3270 6 as as IN 19613 3270 7 this this DT 19613 3270 8 was be VBD 19613 3270 9 to to TO 19613 3270 10 be be VB 19613 3270 11 done do VBN 19613 3270 12 by by IN 19613 3270 13 legislation legislation NN 19613 3270 14 , , , 19613 3270 15 by by IN 19613 3270 16 a a DT 19613 3270 17 _ _ NNP 19613 3270 18 novissima novissima NNP 19613 3270 19 lex lex NNP 19613 3270 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3270 21 , , , 19613 3270 22 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3270 23 have have VBP 19613 3270 24 an an DT 19613 3270 25 evident evident JJ 19613 3270 26 innovation innovation NN 19613 3270 27 analogous analogous JJ 19613 3270 28 to to IN 19613 3270 29 the the DT 19613 3270 30 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 3270 31 development development NN 19613 3270 32 . . . 19613 3271 1 Whereas whereas IN 19613 3271 2 in in IN 19613 3271 3 former former JJ 19613 3271 4 times time NNS 19613 3271 5 exalted exalted JJ 19613 3271 6 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 3271 7 had have VBD 19613 3271 8 of of IN 19613 3271 9 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3271 10 , , , 19613 3271 11 as as IN 19613 3271 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3271 13 were be VBD 19613 3271 14 , , , 19613 3271 15 given give VBN 19613 3271 16 rise rise NN 19613 3271 17 to to IN 19613 3271 18 strict strict JJ 19613 3271 19 principles principle NNS 19613 3271 20 of of IN 19613 3271 21 conduct conduct NN 19613 3271 22 among among IN 19613 3271 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3271 24 other other JJ 19613 3271 25 results result NNS 19613 3271 26 , , , 19613 3271 27 these these DT 19613 3271 28 principles principle NNS 19613 3271 29 , , , 19613 3271 30 formulated formulate VBN 19613 3271 31 with with IN 19613 3271 32 exactness exactness NN 19613 3271 33 and and CC 19613 3271 34 detail detail NN 19613 3271 35 , , , 19613 3271 36 were be VBD 19613 3271 37 now now RB 19613 3271 38 meant mean VBN 19613 3271 39 to to TO 19613 3271 40 preserve preserve VB 19613 3271 41 or or CC 19613 3271 42 produce produce VB 19613 3271 43 that that DT 19613 3271 44 original original JJ 19613 3271 45 mode mode NN 19613 3271 46 of of IN 19613 3271 47 life life NN 19613 3271 48 . . . 19613 3272 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 3272 2 , , , 19613 3272 3 as as RB 19613 3272 4 soon soon RB 19613 3272 5 as as IN 19613 3272 6 the the DT 19613 3272 7 New New NNP 19613 3272 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3272 9 was be VBD 19613 3272 10 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3272 11 , , , 19613 3272 12 the the DT 19613 3272 13 conception conception NN 19613 3272 14 of of IN 19613 3272 15 a a DT 19613 3272 16 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 3272 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 3272 18 through through IN 19613 3272 19 the the DT 19613 3272 20 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 3272 21 was be VBD 19613 3272 22 a a DT 19613 3272 23 highly highly RB 19613 3272 24 questionable questionable JJ 19613 3272 25 and and CC 19613 3272 26 strange strange JJ 19613 3272 27 innovation innovation NN 19613 3272 28 . . . 19613 3273 1 But but CC 19613 3273 2 for for IN 19613 3273 3 those those DT 19613 3273 4 who who WP 19613 3273 5 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 3273 6 the the DT 19613 3273 7 new new JJ 19613 3273 8 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3273 9 all all PDT 19613 3273 10 this this DT 19613 3273 11 was be VBD 19613 3273 12 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 3273 13 nothing nothing NN 19613 3273 14 but but IN 19613 3273 15 a a DT 19613 3273 16 means means NN 19613 3273 17 . . . 19613 3274 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3274 2 practical practical JJ 19613 3274 3 tendency tendency NN 19613 3274 4 , , , 19613 3274 5 based base VBN 19613 3274 6 as as IN 19613 3274 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3274 8 was be VBD 19613 3274 9 on on IN 19613 3274 10 the the DT 19613 3274 11 conviction conviction NN 19613 3274 12 that that IN 19613 3274 13 the the DT 19613 3274 14 Church Church NNP 19613 3274 15 abandons abandon VBZ 19613 3274 16 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3274 17 character character NN 19613 3274 18 if if IN 19613 3274 19 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3274 20 does do VBZ 19613 3274 21 not not RB 19613 3274 22 resist resist VB 19613 3274 23 gross gross JJ 19613 3274 24 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 3274 25 at at IN 19613 3274 26 least least JJS 19613 3274 27 , , , 19613 3274 28 was be VBD 19613 3274 29 no no DT 19613 3274 30 innovation innovation NN 19613 3274 31 , , , 19613 3274 32 but but CC 19613 3274 33 a a DT 19613 3274 34 defence defence NN 19613 3274 35 of of IN 19613 3274 36 the the DT 19613 3274 37 most most RBS 19613 3274 38 elementary elementary JJ 19613 3274 39 requirements requirement NNS 19613 3274 40 of of IN 19613 3274 41 primitive primitive JJ 19613 3274 42 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3274 43 in in IN 19613 3274 44 opposition opposition NN 19613 3274 45 to to IN 19613 3274 46 a a DT 19613 3274 47 Church church NN 19613 3274 48 that that WDT 19613 3274 49 was be VBD 19613 3274 50 always always RB 19613 3274 51 more more RBR 19613 3274 52 and and CC 19613 3274 53 more more RBR 19613 3274 54 becoming become VBG 19613 3274 55 a a DT 19613 3274 56 new new JJ 19613 3274 57 thing thing NN 19613 3274 58 . . . 19613 3274 59 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3275 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3275 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3275 3 217 217 CD 19613 3275 4 : : : 19613 3275 5 There there EX 19613 3275 6 were be VBD 19613 3275 7 of of IN 19613 3275 8 course course NN 19613 3275 9 a a DT 19613 3275 10 great great JJ 19613 3275 11 many many JJ 19613 3275 12 intermediate intermediate JJ 19613 3275 13 stages stage NNS 19613 3275 14 between between IN 19613 3275 15 the the DT 19613 3275 16 extremes extreme NNS 19613 3275 17 of of IN 19613 3275 18 laxity laxity NN 19613 3275 19 and and CC 19613 3275 20 rigour rigour NN 19613 3275 21 , , , 19613 3275 22 and and CC 19613 3275 23 the the DT 19613 3275 24 new new JJ 19613 3275 25 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3275 26 was be VBD 19613 3275 27 by by IN 19613 3275 28 no no DT 19613 3275 29 means means NN 19613 3275 30 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3275 31 by by IN 19613 3275 32 all all PDT 19613 3275 33 those those DT 19613 3275 34 who who WP 19613 3275 35 had have VBD 19613 3275 36 strict strict JJ 19613 3275 37 views view NNS 19613 3275 38 as as IN 19613 3275 39 to to IN 19613 3275 40 the the DT 19613 3275 41 principles principle NNS 19613 3275 42 of of IN 19613 3275 43 Christian christian JJ 19613 3275 44 polity polity NN 19613 3275 45 ; ; : 19613 3275 46 see see VB 19613 3275 47 the the DT 19613 3275 48 letters letter NNS 19613 3275 49 of of IN 19613 3275 50 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 3275 51 of of IN 19613 3275 52 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 3275 53 in in IN 19613 3275 54 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3275 55 . . NNP 19613 3275 56 , , , 19613 3275 57 H. H. NNP 19613 3275 58 E. E. NNP 19613 3275 59 IV IV NNP 19613 3275 60 . . . 19613 3276 1 23 23 CD 19613 3276 2 . . . 19613 3277 1 Melito Melito NNP 19613 3277 2 , , , 19613 3277 3 the the DT 19613 3277 4 prophet prophet NN 19613 3277 5 , , , 19613 3277 6 eunuch eunuch NNP 19613 3277 7 , , , 19613 3277 8 and and CC 19613 3277 9 bishop bishop NNP 19613 3277 10 , , , 19613 3277 11 must must MD 19613 3277 12 also also RB 19613 3277 13 be be VB 19613 3277 14 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 3277 15 as as IN 19613 3277 16 one one CD 19613 3277 17 of of IN 19613 3277 18 the the DT 19613 3277 19 stricter strict JJR 19613 3277 20 party party NN 19613 3277 21 , , , 19613 3277 22 but but CC 19613 3277 23 not not RB 19613 3277 24 as as IN 19613 3277 25 a a DT 19613 3277 26 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3277 27 . . . 19613 3278 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3278 2 must must MD 19613 3278 3 judge judge VB 19613 3278 4 similarly similarly RB 19613 3278 5 of of IN 19613 3278 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3278 7 . . . 19613 3278 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3279 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3279 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3279 3 218 218 CD 19613 3279 4 : : : 19613 3279 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3279 6 . . NNP 19613 3279 7 , , , 19613 3279 8 H. H. NNP 19613 3279 9 E. E. NNP 19613 3279 10 V. V. NNP 19613 3279 11 16 16 CD 19613 3279 12 . . . 19613 3280 1 17 17 CD 19613 3280 2 . . . 19613 3281 1 The the DT 19613 3281 2 life life NN 19613 3281 3 of of IN 19613 3281 4 the the DT 19613 3281 5 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3281 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3281 7 was be VBD 19613 3281 8 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 3281 9 subjected subject VBN 19613 3281 10 to to IN 19613 3281 11 sharp sharp JJ 19613 3281 12 criticism criticism NN 19613 3281 13 . . . 19613 3281 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3282 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3282 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3282 3 219 219 CD 19613 3282 4 : : : 19613 3282 5 This this DT 19613 3282 6 was be VBD 19613 3282 7 first first RB 19613 3282 8 done do VBN 19613 3282 9 by by IN 19613 3282 10 the the DT 19613 3282 11 so so RB 19613 3282 12 - - HYPH 19613 3282 13 called call VBN 19613 3282 14 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 3282 15 who who WP 19613 3282 16 , , , 19613 3282 17 however however RB 19613 3282 18 , , , 19613 3282 19 had have VBD 19613 3282 20 to to TO 19613 3282 21 be be VB 19613 3282 22 repudiated repudiate VBN 19613 3282 23 . . . 19613 3282 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3283 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3283 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3283 3 220 220 CD 19613 3283 4 : : : 19613 3283 5 De De NNP 19613 3283 6 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3283 7 . . . 19613 3284 1 12 12 CD 19613 3284 2 , , , 19613 3284 3 16 16 CD 19613 3284 4 . . . 19613 3284 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3285 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3285 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3285 3 221 221 CD 19613 3285 4 : : : 19613 3285 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3285 6 protested protest VBD 19613 3285 7 against against IN 19613 3285 8 this this DT 19613 3285 9 in in IN 19613 3285 10 the the DT 19613 3285 11 most most RBS 19613 3285 12 energetic energetic JJ 19613 3285 13 manner manner NN 19613 3285 14 . . . 19613 3285 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3286 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3286 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3286 3 222 222 CD 19613 3286 4 : : : 19613 3286 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3286 6 is be VBZ 19613 3286 7 well well RB 19613 3286 8 known know VBN 19613 3286 9 that that IN 19613 3286 10 in in IN 19613 3286 11 the the DT 19613 3286 12 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3286 13 century century NN 19613 3286 14 the the DT 19613 3286 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 3286 16 of of IN 19613 3286 17 John John NNP 19613 3286 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3286 19 was be VBD 19613 3286 20 viewed view VBN 19613 3286 21 with with IN 19613 3286 22 suspicion suspicion NN 19613 3286 23 and and CC 19613 3286 24 removed remove VBN 19613 3286 25 from from IN 19613 3286 26 the the DT 19613 3286 27 canon canon NN 19613 3286 28 in in IN 19613 3286 29 wide wide JJ 19613 3286 30 circles circle NNS 19613 3286 31 in in IN 19613 3286 32 the the DT 19613 3286 33 East East NNP 19613 3286 34 . . . 19613 3286 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3287 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3287 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3287 3 223 223 CD 19613 3287 4 : : : 19613 3287 5 In in IN 19613 3287 6 the the DT 19613 3287 7 West West NNP 19613 3287 8 the the DT 19613 3287 9 Chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 3287 10 hopes hope NNS 19613 3287 11 were be VBD 19613 3287 12 little little JJ 19613 3287 13 or or CC 19613 3287 14 not not RB 19613 3287 15 at at RB 19613 3287 16 all all RB 19613 3287 17 affected affect VBN 19613 3287 18 by by IN 19613 3287 19 the the DT 19613 3287 20 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3287 21 struggle struggle NN 19613 3287 22 . . . 19613 3288 1 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 3288 2 prevailed prevail VBD 19613 3288 3 there there RB 19613 3288 4 in in IN 19613 3288 5 unimpaired unimpaired JJ 19613 3288 6 strength strength NN 19613 3288 7 as as RB 19613 3288 8 late late RB 19613 3288 9 as as IN 19613 3288 10 the the DT 19613 3288 11 4th 4th JJ 19613 3288 12 century century NN 19613 3288 13 . . . 19613 3289 1 In in IN 19613 3289 2 the the DT 19613 3289 3 East East NNP 19613 3289 4 , , , 19613 3289 5 on on IN 19613 3289 6 the the DT 19613 3289 7 contrary contrary NN 19613 3289 8 , , , 19613 3289 9 the the DT 19613 3289 10 apocalyptic apocalyptic JJ 19613 3289 11 expectations expectation NNS 19613 3289 12 were be VBD 19613 3289 13 immediately immediately RB 19613 3289 14 weakened weaken VBN 19613 3289 15 by by IN 19613 3289 16 the the DT 19613 3289 17 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3289 18 crisis crisis NN 19613 3289 19 . . . 19613 3290 1 But but CC 19613 3290 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3290 3 was be VBD 19613 3290 4 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 3290 5 theology theology NN 19613 3290 6 that that IN 19613 3290 7 first first RB 19613 3290 8 proved prove VBD 19613 3290 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3290 10 mortal mortal JJ 19613 3290 11 enemy enemy NN 19613 3290 12 . . . 19613 3291 1 In in IN 19613 3291 2 the the DT 19613 3291 3 rural rural JJ 19613 3291 4 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3291 5 of of IN 19613 3291 6 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 3291 7 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 3291 8 was be VBD 19613 3291 9 still still RB 19613 3291 10 widely widely RB 19613 3291 11 prevalent prevalent JJ 19613 3291 12 after after IN 19613 3291 13 the the DT 19613 3291 14 middle middle NN 19613 3291 15 of of IN 19613 3291 16 the the DT 19613 3291 17 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3291 18 century century NN 19613 3291 19 ; ; : 19613 3291 20 see see VB 19613 3291 21 the the DT 19613 3291 22 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3291 23 24th 24th JJ 19613 3291 24 chapter chapter NN 19613 3291 25 of of IN 19613 3291 26 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 3291 27 ' ' POS 19613 3291 28 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 3291 29 History History NNP 19613 3291 30 , , , 19613 3291 31 Book Book NNP 19613 3291 32 VII VII NNP 19613 3291 33 . . . 19613 3292 1 " " `` 19613 3292 2 Some some DT 19613 3292 3 of of IN 19613 3292 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3292 5 teachers teacher NNS 19613 3292 6 , , , 19613 3292 7 " " '' 19613 3292 8 says say VBZ 19613 3292 9 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 3292 10 , , , 19613 3292 11 " " `` 19613 3292 12 look look VB 19613 3292 13 on on IN 19613 3292 14 the the DT 19613 3292 15 Law Law NNP 19613 3292 16 and and CC 19613 3292 17 the the DT 19613 3292 18 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 3292 19 as as IN 19613 3292 20 nothing nothing NN 19613 3292 21 , , , 19613 3292 22 neglect neglect VB 19613 3292 23 to to TO 19613 3292 24 obey obey VB 19613 3292 25 the the DT 19613 3292 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3292 27 , , , 19613 3292 28 esteem esteem VB 19613 3292 29 the the DT 19613 3292 30 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 3292 31 of of IN 19613 3292 32 the the DT 19613 3292 33 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 3292 34 as as IN 19613 3292 35 little little JJ 19613 3292 36 worth worth JJ 19613 3292 37 , , , 19613 3292 38 but but CC 19613 3292 39 , , , 19613 3292 40 on on IN 19613 3292 41 the the DT 19613 3292 42 contrary contrary NN 19613 3292 43 , , , 19613 3292 44 declare declare VB 19613 3292 45 the the DT 19613 3292 46 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 3292 47 contained contain VBN 19613 3292 48 in in IN 19613 3292 49 the the DT 19613 3292 50 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 3292 51 of of IN 19613 3292 52 John John NNP 19613 3292 53 to to TO 19613 3292 54 be be VB 19613 3292 55 a a DT 19613 3292 56 great great JJ 19613 3292 57 and and CC 19613 3292 58 a a DT 19613 3292 59 hidden hide VBN 19613 3292 60 mystery mystery NN 19613 3292 61 . . . 19613 3292 62 " " '' 19613 3293 1 There there EX 19613 3293 2 were be VBD 19613 3293 3 even even RB 19613 3293 4 temporary temporary JJ 19613 3293 5 disruptions disruption NNS 19613 3293 6 in in IN 19613 3293 7 the the DT 19613 3293 8 Egyptian Egyptian NNP 19613 3293 9 Church Church NNP 19613 3293 10 on on IN 19613 3293 11 account account NN 19613 3293 12 of of IN 19613 3293 13 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 3293 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3293 15 see see VB 19613 3293 16 Chap Chap NNP 19613 3293 17 . . . 19613 3294 1 24 24 CD 19613 3294 2 . . . 19613 3295 1 6 6 LS 19613 3295 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3295 3 . . . 19613 3295 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3296 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3296 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3296 3 224 224 CD 19613 3296 4 : : : 19613 3296 5 " " `` 19613 3296 6 Lex Lex NNP 19613 3296 7 et et NNP 19613 3296 8 prophetæ prophetæ NNS 19613 3296 9 usque usque NNP 19613 3296 10 ad ad NN 19613 3296 11 Johannem Johannem NNP 19613 3296 12 " " `` 19613 3296 13 now now RB 19613 3296 14 became become VBD 19613 3296 15 the the DT 19613 3296 16 motto motto NN 19613 3296 17 . . . 19613 3297 1 Churchmen churchman NNS 19613 3297 2 spoke speak VBD 19613 3297 3 of of IN 19613 3297 4 a a DT 19613 3297 5 " " `` 19613 3297 6 completus completus NN 19613 3297 7 numerus numerus NNP 19613 3297 8 prophetarum prophetarum NNP 19613 3297 9 " " '' 19613 3297 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3297 11 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 3297 12 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 3297 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3297 14 , , , 19613 3297 15 and and CC 19613 3297 16 formulated formulate VBD 19613 3297 17 the the DT 19613 3297 18 proposition proposition NN 19613 3297 19 that that IN 19613 3297 20 the the DT 19613 3297 21 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3297 22 corresponded correspond VBD 19613 3297 23 to to IN 19613 3297 24 the the DT 19613 3297 25 pre pre JJ 19613 3297 26 - - JJ 19613 3297 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 3297 28 stage stage NN 19613 3297 29 of of IN 19613 3297 30 revelation revelation NN 19613 3297 31 , , , 19613 3297 32 but but CC 19613 3297 33 the the DT 19613 3297 34 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 3297 35 to to IN 19613 3297 36 the the DT 19613 3297 37 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3297 38 ; ; : 19613 3297 39 and and CC 19613 3297 40 that that IN 19613 3297 41 in in IN 19613 3297 42 addition addition NN 19613 3297 43 to to IN 19613 3297 44 this this DT 19613 3297 45 the the DT 19613 3297 46 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 3297 47 age age NN 19613 3297 48 was be VBD 19613 3297 49 also also RB 19613 3297 50 particularly particularly RB 19613 3297 51 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 3297 52 by by IN 19613 3297 53 gifts gift NNS 19613 3297 54 of of IN 19613 3297 55 the the DT 19613 3297 56 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3297 57 . . . 19613 3298 1 " " `` 19613 3298 2 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 3298 3 and and CC 19613 3298 4 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 3298 5 " " '' 19613 3298 6 now now RB 19613 3298 7 replaced replace VBN 19613 3298 8 " " `` 19613 3298 9 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 3298 10 , , , 19613 3298 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3298 12 , , , 19613 3298 13 and and CC 19613 3298 14 teachers teacher NNS 19613 3298 15 , , , 19613 3298 16 " " '' 19613 3298 17 as as IN 19613 3298 18 the the DT 19613 3298 19 court court NN 19613 3298 20 of of IN 19613 3298 21 appeal appeal NN 19613 3298 22 . . . 19613 3299 1 Under under IN 19613 3299 2 such such JJ 19613 3299 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 3299 4 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3299 5 might may MD 19613 3299 6 still still RB 19613 3299 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 3299 8 exist exist VB 19613 3299 9 ; ; : 19613 3299 10 but but CC 19613 3299 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3299 12 could could MD 19613 3299 13 no no RB 19613 3299 14 longer longer RB 19613 3299 15 be be VB 19613 3299 16 of of IN 19613 3299 17 a a DT 19613 3299 18 kind kind RB 19613 3299 19 capable capable JJ 19613 3299 20 of of IN 19613 3299 21 ranking rank VBG 19613 3299 22 , , , 19613 3299 23 in in IN 19613 3299 24 the the DT 19613 3299 25 remotest remotest NN 19613 3299 26 degree degree NN 19613 3299 27 , , , 19613 3299 28 with with IN 19613 3299 29 the the DT 19613 3299 30 authority authority NN 19613 3299 31 of of IN 19613 3299 32 the the DT 19613 3299 33 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 3299 34 in in IN 19613 3299 35 point point NN 19613 3299 36 of of IN 19613 3299 37 importance importance NN 19613 3299 38 . . . 19613 3300 1 Hence hence RB 19613 3300 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3300 3 was be VBD 19613 3300 4 driven drive VBN 19613 3300 5 into into IN 19613 3300 6 a a DT 19613 3300 7 corner corner NN 19613 3300 8 , , , 19613 3300 9 became become VBD 19613 3300 10 extinct extinct JJ 19613 3300 11 , , , 19613 3300 12 or or CC 19613 3300 13 at at IN 19613 3300 14 most most RBS 19613 3300 15 served serve VBN 19613 3300 16 only only RB 19613 3300 17 to to TO 19613 3300 18 support support VB 19613 3300 19 the the DT 19613 3300 20 measures measure NNS 19613 3300 21 of of IN 19613 3300 22 the the DT 19613 3300 23 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3300 24 . . . 19613 3301 1 In in IN 19613 3301 2 order order NN 19613 3301 3 to to TO 19613 3301 4 estimate estimate VB 19613 3301 5 the the DT 19613 3301 6 great great JJ 19613 3301 7 revolution revolution NN 19613 3301 8 in in IN 19613 3301 9 the the DT 19613 3301 10 spirit spirit NN 19613 3301 11 of of IN 19613 3301 12 the the DT 19613 3301 13 times time NNS 19613 3301 14 let let VB 19613 3301 15 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3301 16 compare compare VB 19613 3301 17 the the DT 19613 3301 18 utterances utterance NNS 19613 3301 19 of of IN 19613 3301 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3301 21 and and CC 19613 3301 22 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3301 23 about about IN 19613 3301 24 gifts gift NNS 19613 3301 25 of of IN 19613 3301 26 the the DT 19613 3301 27 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3301 28 and and CC 19613 3301 29 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3301 30 . . . 19613 3302 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3302 2 still still RB 19613 3302 3 expressed express VBD 19613 3302 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3302 5 exactly exactly RB 19613 3302 6 like like IN 19613 3302 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 3302 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3302 9 Dial Dial NNP 19613 3302 10 . . . 19613 3303 1 39 39 CD 19613 3303 2 , , , 19613 3303 3 81 81 CD 19613 3303 4 , , , 19613 3303 5 82 82 CD 19613 3303 6 , , , 19613 3303 7 88 88 CD 19613 3303 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3303 9 ; ; : 19613 3303 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3303 11 says say VBZ 19613 3303 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3303 13 II II NNP 19613 3303 14 . . . 19613 3304 1 32 32 CD 19613 3304 2 . . . 19613 3305 1 4 4 LS 19613 3305 2 : : : 19613 3305 3 V. V. NNP 19613 3305 4 6 6 CD 19613 3305 5 . . . 19613 3306 1 1 1 LS 19613 3306 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3306 3 : : : 19613 3306 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3306 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3306 6 : : : 19613 3306 7 kathôs kathôs NNP 19613 3306 8 kai kai NNP 19613 3306 9 pollôn pollôn NNP 19613 3306 10 akouomen akouomen NNP 19613 3306 11 adelphôn adelphôn NNP 19613 3306 12 hen hen NNP 19613 3306 13 tê tê NNP 19613 3306 14 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 3306 15 prophêtika prophêtika VB 19613 3306 16 charismata charismata NNP 19613 3306 17 echontôn echontôn NNP 19613 3306 18 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 3306 19 . . . 19613 3306 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3307 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3307 2 on on IN 19613 3307 3 the the DT 19613 3307 4 contrary contrary NN 19613 3307 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3307 6 see see VB 19613 3307 7 numerous numerous JJ 19613 3307 8 passages passage NNS 19613 3307 9 , , , 19613 3307 10 especially especially RB 19613 3307 11 in in IN 19613 3307 12 the the DT 19613 3307 13 treatise treatise NN 19613 3307 14 c. c. . 19613 3308 1 Cels cel NNS 19613 3308 2 . . . 19613 3309 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3309 2 , , , 19613 3309 3 looks look VBZ 19613 3309 4 back back RB 19613 3309 5 to to IN 19613 3309 6 a a DT 19613 3309 7 period period NN 19613 3309 8 after after IN 19613 3309 9 which which WDT 19613 3309 10 the the DT 19613 3309 11 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3309 12 's 's POS 19613 3309 13 gifts gift NNS 19613 3309 14 in in IN 19613 3309 15 the the DT 19613 3309 16 Church Church NNP 19613 3309 17 ceased cease VBD 19613 3309 18 . . . 19613 3310 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3310 2 is be VBZ 19613 3310 3 also also RB 19613 3310 4 a a DT 19613 3310 5 very very RB 19613 3310 6 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 3310 7 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 3310 8 that that WDT 19613 3310 9 along along IN 19613 3310 10 with with IN 19613 3310 11 the the DT 19613 3310 12 naturalisation naturalisation NN 19613 3310 13 of of IN 19613 3310 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3310 15 in in IN 19613 3310 16 the the DT 19613 3310 17 world world NN 19613 3310 18 , , , 19613 3310 19 the the DT 19613 3310 20 disappearance disappearance NN 19613 3310 21 of of IN 19613 3310 22 charisms charism NNS 19613 3310 23 , , , 19613 3310 24 and and CC 19613 3310 25 the the DT 19613 3310 26 struggle struggle NN 19613 3310 27 against against IN 19613 3310 28 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 3310 29 , , , 19613 3310 30 a a DT 19613 3310 31 strictly strictly RB 19613 3310 32 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 3310 33 mode mode NN 19613 3310 34 of of IN 19613 3310 35 life life NN 19613 3310 36 came come VBD 19613 3310 37 to to TO 19613 3310 38 be be VB 19613 3310 39 viewed view VBN 19613 3310 40 with with IN 19613 3310 41 suspicion suspicion NN 19613 3310 42 . . . 19613 3311 1 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3311 2 . . NNP 19613 3311 3 , , , 19613 3311 4 H. H. NNP 19613 3311 5 E. E. NNP 19613 3311 6 V. V. NNP 19613 3311 7 3 3 CD 19613 3311 8 is be VBZ 19613 3311 9 especially especially RB 19613 3311 10 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3311 11 on on IN 19613 3311 12 this this DT 19613 3311 13 point point NN 19613 3311 14 . . . 19613 3312 1 Here here RB 19613 3312 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3312 3 is be VBZ 19613 3312 4 revealed reveal VBN 19613 3312 5 to to IN 19613 3312 6 the the DT 19613 3312 7 confessor confessor NN 19613 3312 8 Attalus Attalus NNP 19613 3312 9 that that IN 19613 3312 10 the the DT 19613 3312 11 confessor confessor NN 19613 3312 12 Alcibiades Alcibiades NNPS 19613 3312 13 , , , 19613 3312 14 who who WP 19613 3312 15 even even RB 19613 3312 16 in in IN 19613 3312 17 captivity captivity NN 19613 3312 18 continued continue VBD 19613 3312 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3312 20 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 3312 21 practice practice NN 19613 3312 22 of of IN 19613 3312 23 living live VBG 19613 3312 24 on on IN 19613 3312 25 nothing nothing NN 19613 3312 26 but but IN 19613 3312 27 bread bread NN 19613 3312 28 and and CC 19613 3312 29 water water NN 19613 3312 30 , , , 19613 3312 31 was be VBD 19613 3312 32 wrong wrong JJ 19613 3312 33 in in IN 19613 3312 34 refraining refrain VBG 19613 3312 35 from from IN 19613 3312 36 that that DT 19613 3312 37 which which WDT 19613 3312 38 God God NNP 19613 3312 39 had have VBD 19613 3312 40 created create VBN 19613 3312 41 and and CC 19613 3312 42 thus thus RB 19613 3312 43 become become VB 19613 3312 44 a a DT 19613 3312 45 " " `` 19613 3312 46 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3312 47 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3312 48 : : : 19613 3312 49 typos typos NNP 19613 3312 50 skandalou skandalou NNP 19613 3312 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3312 52 " " `` 19613 3312 53 to to IN 19613 3312 54 others other NNS 19613 3312 55 . . . 19613 3313 1 Alcibiades alcibiade NNS 19613 3313 2 changed change VBD 19613 3313 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3313 4 mode mode NN 19613 3313 5 of of IN 19613 3313 6 life life NN 19613 3313 7 . . . 19613 3314 1 In in IN 19613 3314 2 Africa Africa NNP 19613 3314 3 , , , 19613 3314 4 however however RB 19613 3314 5 , , , 19613 3314 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3314 7 see see VB 19613 3314 8 above above RB 19613 3314 9 , , , 19613 3314 10 p. p. NN 19613 3314 11 103 103 CD 19613 3314 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3314 13 dreams dream NNS 19613 3314 14 and and CC 19613 3314 15 visions vision NNS 19613 3314 16 still still RB 19613 3314 17 retained retain VBD 19613 3314 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3314 19 authority authority NN 19613 3314 20 in in IN 19613 3314 21 the the DT 19613 3314 22 Church Church NNP 19613 3314 23 as as IN 19613 3314 24 important important JJ 19613 3314 25 means mean NNS 19613 3314 26 of of IN 19613 3314 27 solving solve VBG 19613 3314 28 perplexities perplexity NNS 19613 3314 29 . . . 19613 3314 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3315 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3315 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3315 3 225 225 CD 19613 3315 4 : : : 19613 3315 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3315 6 , , , 19613 3315 7 adv adv NN 19613 3315 8 . . . 19613 3316 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 3316 2 . . . 19613 3317 1 IV IV NNP 19613 3317 2 . . . 19613 3318 1 9 9 CD 19613 3318 2 , , , 19613 3318 3 enumerates enumerate VBZ 19613 3318 4 " " `` 19613 3318 5 septem septem NNP 19613 3318 6 maculas maculas NNP 19613 3318 7 capitalium capitalium NNP 19613 3318 8 delictorum delictorum NN 19613 3318 9 , , , 19613 3318 10 " " '' 19613 3318 11 namely namely RB 19613 3318 12 , , , 19613 3318 13 " " '' 19613 3318 14 idololatria idololatria NNP 19613 3318 15 , , , 19613 3318 16 " " '' 19613 3318 17 " " `` 19613 3318 18 blasphemia blasphemia NN 19613 3318 19 , , , 19613 3318 20 " " '' 19613 3318 21 " " `` 19613 3318 22 homicidium homicidium NN 19613 3318 23 , , , 19613 3318 24 " " '' 19613 3318 25 " " `` 19613 3318 26 adulterium adulterium NN 19613 3318 27 , , , 19613 3318 28 " " '' 19613 3318 29 " " `` 19613 3318 30 stuprum stuprum NN 19613 3318 31 , , , 19613 3318 32 " " '' 19613 3318 33 " " `` 19613 3318 34 falsum falsum NN 19613 3318 35 testimonium testimonium NN 19613 3318 36 , , , 19613 3318 37 " " '' 19613 3318 38 " " `` 19613 3318 39 fraus fraus NN 19613 3318 40 . . . 19613 3318 41 " " '' 19613 3319 1 The the DT 19613 3319 2 stricter strict JJR 19613 3319 3 treatment treatment NN 19613 3319 4 probably probably RB 19613 3319 5 applied apply VBD 19613 3319 6 to to IN 19613 3319 7 all all PDT 19613 3319 8 these these DT 19613 3319 9 seven seven CD 19613 3319 10 offences offence NNS 19613 3319 11 . . . 19613 3320 1 So so RB 19613 3320 2 far far RB 19613 3320 3 as as IN 19613 3320 4 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3320 5 know know VBP 19613 3320 6 , , , 19613 3320 7 the the DT 19613 3320 8 lapse lapse NN 19613 3320 9 into into IN 19613 3320 10 heresy heresy NN 19613 3320 11 was be VBD 19613 3320 12 not not RB 19613 3320 13 placed place VBN 19613 3320 14 in in IN 19613 3320 15 the the DT 19613 3320 16 same same JJ 19613 3320 17 category category NN 19613 3320 18 in in IN 19613 3320 19 the the DT 19613 3320 20 first first JJ 19613 3320 21 centuries century NNS 19613 3320 22 ; ; : 19613 3320 23 see see VB 19613 3320 24 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3320 25 . . . 19613 3321 1 III iii CD 19613 3321 2 . . . 19613 3322 1 4 4 LS 19613 3322 2 . . . 19613 3323 1 2 2 LS 19613 3323 2 : : : 19613 3323 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3323 4 . . NNP 19613 3323 5 , , , 19613 3323 6 de de NNP 19613 3323 7 præscr præscr NNP 19613 3323 8 . . . 19613 3324 1 30 30 CD 19613 3324 2 and and CC 19613 3324 3 , , , 19613 3324 4 above above IN 19613 3324 5 all all DT 19613 3324 6 , , , 19613 3324 7 de de FW 19613 3324 8 pudic pudic JJ 19613 3324 9 . . . 19613 3325 1 19 19 CD 19613 3325 2 init init NN 19613 3325 3 . . . 19613 3326 1 ; ; : 19613 3326 2 the the DT 19613 3326 3 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 3326 4 writer writer NN 19613 3326 5 in in IN 19613 3326 6 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3326 7 . . NNP 19613 3326 8 , , , 19613 3326 9 H. H. NNP 19613 3326 10 E. E. NNP 19613 3326 11 V. V. NNP 19613 3326 12 28 28 CD 19613 3326 13 . . . 19613 3327 1 12 12 CD 19613 3327 2 , , , 19613 3327 3 from from IN 19613 3327 4 which which WDT 19613 3327 5 passages passage NNS 19613 3327 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3327 7 is be VBZ 19613 3327 8 evident evident JJ 19613 3327 9 that that IN 19613 3327 10 repentant repentant JJ 19613 3327 11 heretics heretic NNS 19613 3327 12 were be VBD 19613 3327 13 readmitted readmitte VBN 19613 3327 14 . . . 19613 3327 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3328 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3328 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3328 3 226 226 CD 19613 3328 4 : : : 19613 3328 5 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 3328 6 based base VBD 19613 3328 7 the the DT 19613 3328 8 admissibility admissibility NN 19613 3328 9 of of IN 19613 3328 10 a a DT 19613 3328 11 second second JJ 19613 3328 12 atonement atonement NN 19613 3328 13 on on IN 19613 3328 14 a a DT 19613 3328 15 definite definite JJ 19613 3328 16 divine divine JJ 19613 3328 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 3328 18 to to IN 19613 3328 19 this this DT 19613 3328 20 effect effect NN 19613 3328 21 , , , 19613 3328 22 and and CC 19613 3328 23 did do VBD 19613 3328 24 not not RB 19613 3328 25 expressly expressly RB 19613 3328 26 discuss discuss VB 19613 3328 27 the the DT 19613 3328 28 admission admission NN 19613 3328 29 of of IN 19613 3328 30 gross gross JJ 19613 3328 31 sinners sinner NNS 19613 3328 32 into into IN 19613 3328 33 the the DT 19613 3328 34 Church Church NNP 19613 3328 35 generally generally RB 19613 3328 36 , , , 19613 3328 37 but but CC 19613 3328 38 treated treat VBN 19613 3328 39 of of IN 19613 3328 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3328 41 reception reception NN 19613 3328 42 into into IN 19613 3328 43 that that DT 19613 3328 44 of of IN 19613 3328 45 the the DT 19613 3328 46 last last JJ 19613 3328 47 days day NNS 19613 3328 48 , , , 19613 3328 49 which which WDT 19613 3328 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3328 51 believed believe VBD 19613 3328 52 had have VBD 19613 3328 53 already already RB 19613 3328 54 arrived arrive VBN 19613 3328 55 . . . 19613 3329 1 See see VB 19613 3329 2 particulars particular NNS 19613 3329 3 on on IN 19613 3329 4 this this DT 19613 3329 5 point point NN 19613 3329 6 in in IN 19613 3329 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3329 8 article article NN 19613 3329 9 " " `` 19613 3329 10 Lapsi Lapsi NNP 19613 3329 11 , , , 19613 3329 12 " " '' 19613 3329 13 in in IN 19613 3329 14 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 3329 15 's 's POS 19613 3329 16 Real Real NNP 19613 3329 17 - - HYPH 19613 3329 18 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 3329 19 , , , 19613 3329 20 2 2 CD 19613 3329 21 ed ed NN 19613 3329 22 . . . 19613 3330 1 Cf cf NN 19613 3330 2 . . . 19613 3331 1 Preuschen Preuschen NNP 19613 3331 2 , , , 19613 3331 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3331 4 's 's POS 19613 3331 5 Schriften Schriften NNP 19613 3331 6 de de IN 19613 3331 7 pænit pænit NN 19613 3331 8 . . . 19613 3332 1 et et NNP 19613 3332 2 de de FW 19613 3332 3 pudic pudic NNP 19613 3332 4 . . . 19613 3333 1 mit mit NNP 19613 3333 2 Rücksicht Rücksicht NNP 19613 3333 3 auf auf NN 19613 3333 4 die die VBP 19613 3333 5 Bussdisciplin Bussdisciplin NNP 19613 3333 6 , , , 19613 3333 7 1890 1890 CD 19613 3333 8 ; ; : 19613 3333 9 Rolffs Rolffs NNP 19613 3333 10 , , , 19613 3333 11 Indulgenz Indulgenz NNP 19613 3333 12 - - HYPH 19613 3333 13 Edict Edict NNP 19613 3333 14 des des NNP 19613 3333 15 Kallistus Kallistus NNP 19613 3333 16 , , , 19613 3333 17 1893 1893 CD 19613 3333 18 . . . 19613 3333 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3334 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3334 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3334 3 227 227 CD 19613 3334 4 : : : 19613 3334 5 In in IN 19613 3334 6 the the DT 19613 3334 7 work work NN 19613 3334 8 de de IN 19613 3334 9 pænit pænit NN 19613 3334 10 . . . 19613 3335 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3335 2 7 7 CD 19613 3335 3 ff ff NN 19613 3335 4 . . . 19613 3335 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3336 1 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 3336 2 treats treat VBZ 19613 3336 3 this this DT 19613 3336 4 as as IN 19613 3336 5 a a DT 19613 3336 6 fixed fix VBN 19613 3336 7 Church Church NNP 19613 3336 8 regulation regulation NN 19613 3336 9 . . . 19613 3337 1 K. K. NNP 19613 3337 2 Müller Müller NNP 19613 3337 3 , , , 19613 3337 4 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 3337 5 I. I. NNP 19613 3338 1 1892 1892 CD 19613 3338 2 , , , 19613 3338 3 p. p. NN 19613 3338 4 114 114 CD 19613 3338 5 , , , 19613 3338 6 rightly rightly RB 19613 3338 7 remarks remark VBZ 19613 3338 8 : : : 19613 3338 9 " " `` 19613 3338 10 He -PRON- PRP 19613 3338 11 who who WP 19613 3338 12 desired desire VBD 19613 3338 13 this this DT 19613 3338 14 expiation expiation NN 19613 3338 15 continued continue VBN 19613 3338 16 in in IN 19613 3338 17 the the DT 19613 3338 18 wider wide JJR 19613 3338 19 circle circle NN 19613 3338 20 of of IN 19613 3338 21 the the DT 19613 3338 22 Church Church NNP 19613 3338 23 , , , 19613 3338 24 in in IN 19613 3338 25 her -PRON- PRP 19613 3338 26 ' ' `` 19613 3338 27 antechamber antechamber NN 19613 3338 28 ' ' '' 19613 3338 29 indeed indeed RB 19613 3338 30 , , , 19613 3338 31 but but CC 19613 3338 32 as as IN 19613 3338 33 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3338 34 member member NN 19613 3338 35 in in IN 19613 3338 36 the the DT 19613 3338 37 wider wide JJR 19613 3338 38 sense sense NN 19613 3338 39 . . . 19613 3339 1 This this DT 19613 3339 2 , , , 19613 3339 3 however however RB 19613 3339 4 , , , 19613 3339 5 did do VBD 19613 3339 6 not not RB 19613 3339 7 exclude exclude VB 19613 3339 8 the the DT 19613 3339 9 possibility possibility NN 19613 3339 10 of of IN 19613 3339 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3339 12 being be VBG 19613 3339 13 received receive VBN 19613 3339 14 again again RB 19613 3339 15 , , , 19613 3339 16 even even RB 19613 3339 17 in in IN 19613 3339 18 this this DT 19613 3339 19 world world NN 19613 3339 20 , , , 19613 3339 21 into into IN 19613 3339 22 the the DT 19613 3339 23 ranks rank NNS 19613 3339 24 of of IN 19613 3339 25 those those DT 19613 3339 26 possessing possess VBG 19613 3339 27 full full JJ 19613 3339 28 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3339 29 privileges,--after privileges,--after NNP 19613 3339 30 the the DT 19613 3339 31 performance performance NN 19613 3339 32 of of IN 19613 3339 33 penance penance NNP 19613 3339 34 or or CC 19613 3339 35 _ _ NNP 19613 3339 36 exhomologesis exhomologesis NN 19613 3339 37 _ _ NNP 19613 3339 38 . . . 19613 3340 1 But but CC 19613 3340 2 there there EX 19613 3340 3 was be VBD 19613 3340 4 no no DT 19613 3340 5 kind kind NN 19613 3340 6 of of RB 19613 3340 7 certainty certainty NN 19613 3340 8 as as IN 19613 3340 9 to to IN 19613 3340 10 that that DT 19613 3340 11 taking take VBG 19613 3340 12 place place NN 19613 3340 13 . . . 19613 3341 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 19613 3341 2 this this DT 19613 3341 3 _ _ NNP 19613 3341 4 exhomologesis exhomologesis NN 19613 3341 5 _ _ NNP 19613 3341 6 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3341 7 underwent undergo VBD 19613 3341 8 a a DT 19613 3341 9 transformation transformation NN 19613 3341 10 which which WDT 19613 3341 11 in in IN 19613 3341 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3341 13 includes include VBZ 19613 3341 14 a a DT 19613 3341 15 whole whole JJ 19613 3341 16 series series NN 19613 3341 17 of of IN 19613 3341 18 basal basal JJ 19613 3341 19 religious religious JJ 19613 3341 20 ideas idea NNS 19613 3341 21 . . . 19613 3342 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3342 2 is be VBZ 19613 3342 3 no no RB 19613 3342 4 longer long RBR 19613 3342 5 a a DT 19613 3342 6 mere mere JJ 19613 3342 7 expression expression NN 19613 3342 8 of of IN 19613 3342 9 inward inward JJ 19613 3342 10 feeling feeling NN 19613 3342 11 , , , 19613 3342 12 confession confession NN 19613 3342 13 to to IN 19613 3342 14 God God NNP 19613 3342 15 and and CC 19613 3342 16 the the DT 19613 3342 17 brethren brother NNS 19613 3342 18 , , , 19613 3342 19 but but CC 19613 3342 20 is be VBZ 19613 3342 21 essentially essentially RB 19613 3342 22 performance performance NN 19613 3342 23 . . . 19613 3343 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3343 2 is be VBZ 19613 3343 3 the the DT 19613 3343 4 actual actual JJ 19613 3343 5 attestation attestation NN 19613 3343 6 of of IN 19613 3343 7 heartfelt heartfelt JJ 19613 3343 8 sorrow sorrow NN 19613 3343 9 , , , 19613 3343 10 the the DT 19613 3343 11 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 3343 12 to to TO 19613 3343 13 satisfy satisfy VB 19613 3343 14 God God NNP 19613 3343 15 by by IN 19613 3343 16 works work NNS 19613 3343 17 of of IN 19613 3343 18 self self NN 19613 3343 19 - - HYPH 19613 3343 20 humiliation humiliation NN 19613 3343 21 and and CC 19613 3343 22 abnegation abnegation NN 19613 3343 23 , , , 19613 3343 24 which which WDT 19613 3343 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3343 26 can can MD 19613 3343 27 accept accept VB 19613 3343 28 as as IN 19613 3343 29 a a DT 19613 3343 30 voluntarily voluntarily RB 19613 3343 31 endured endure VBN 19613 3343 32 punishment punishment NN 19613 3343 33 and and CC 19613 3343 34 therefore therefore RB 19613 3343 35 as as IN 19613 3343 36 a a DT 19613 3343 37 substitute substitute NN 19613 3343 38 for for IN 19613 3343 39 the the DT 19613 3343 40 penalty penalty NN 19613 3343 41 that that WDT 19613 3343 42 naturally naturally RB 19613 3343 43 awaits await VBZ 19613 3343 44 the the DT 19613 3343 45 sinner sinner NN 19613 3343 46 . . . 19613 3344 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3344 2 is be VBZ 19613 3344 3 thus thus RB 19613 3344 4 the the DT 19613 3344 5 means mean NNS 19613 3344 6 of of IN 19613 3344 7 pacifying pacify VBG 19613 3344 8 God God NNP 19613 3344 9 , , , 19613 3344 10 appeasing appease VBG 19613 3344 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3344 12 anger anger NN 19613 3344 13 , , , 19613 3344 14 and and CC 19613 3344 15 gaining gain VBG 19613 3344 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3344 17 favour favour NN 19613 3344 18 again again RB 19613 3344 19 -- -- : 19613 3344 20 with with IN 19613 3344 21 the the DT 19613 3344 22 consequent consequent JJ 19613 3344 23 possibility possibility NN 19613 3344 24 of of IN 19613 3344 25 readmission readmission NN 19613 3344 26 into into IN 19613 3344 27 the the DT 19613 3344 28 Church Church NNP 19613 3344 29 . . . 19613 3345 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3345 2 say say VBP 19613 3345 3 the the DT 19613 3345 4 _ _ NNP 19613 3345 5 possibility possibility NN 19613 3345 6 _ _ NNP 19613 3345 7 , , , 19613 3345 8 for for IN 19613 3345 9 readmission readmission NN 19613 3345 10 does do VBZ 19613 3345 11 not not RB 19613 3345 12 always always RB 19613 3345 13 follow follow VB 19613 3345 14 . . . 19613 3346 1 Participation participation NN 19613 3346 2 in in IN 19613 3346 3 the the DT 19613 3346 4 future future JJ 19613 3346 5 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 3346 6 may may MD 19613 3346 7 be be VB 19613 3346 8 hoped hope VBN 19613 3346 9 for for IN 19613 3346 10 even even RB 19613 3346 11 by by IN 19613 3346 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3346 13 who who WP 19613 3346 14 in in IN 19613 3346 15 this this DT 19613 3346 16 world world NN 19613 3346 17 is be VBZ 19613 3346 18 shut shut VBN 19613 3346 19 out out RP 19613 3346 20 from from IN 19613 3346 21 full full JJ 19613 3346 22 citizenship citizenship NN 19613 3346 23 and and CC 19613 3346 24 merely merely RB 19613 3346 25 remains remain VBZ 19613 3346 26 in in IN 19613 3346 27 the the DT 19613 3346 28 ranks rank NNS 19613 3346 29 of of IN 19613 3346 30 the the DT 19613 3346 31 penitent penitent NN 19613 3346 32 . . . 19613 3347 1 In in IN 19613 3347 2 all all DT 19613 3347 3 probability probability NN 19613 3347 4 then then RB 19613 3347 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3347 6 still still RB 19613 3347 7 continued continue VBD 19613 3347 8 the the DT 19613 3347 9 rule rule NN 19613 3347 10 for for IN 19613 3347 11 a a DT 19613 3347 12 person person NN 19613 3347 13 to to TO 19613 3347 14 remain remain VB 19613 3347 15 till till IN 19613 3347 16 death death NN 19613 3347 17 in in IN 19613 3347 18 a a DT 19613 3347 19 state state NN 19613 3347 20 of of IN 19613 3347 21 penance penance NN 19613 3347 22 or or CC 19613 3347 23 _ _ NNP 19613 3347 24 exhomologesis exhomologesis NN 19613 3347 25 _ _ NNP 19613 3347 26 . . . 19613 3348 1 For for IN 19613 3348 2 readmission readmission NN 19613 3348 3 continued continue VBD 19613 3348 4 to to TO 19613 3348 5 involve involve VB 19613 3348 6 the the DT 19613 3348 7 assumption assumption NN 19613 3348 8 that that IN 19613 3348 9 the the DT 19613 3348 10 Church Church NNP 19613 3348 11 had have VBD 19613 3348 12 in in IN 19613 3348 13 some some DT 19613 3348 14 way way NN 19613 3348 15 or or CC 19613 3348 16 other other JJ 19613 3348 17 become become VBP 19613 3348 18 _ _ NNP 19613 3348 19 certain certain JJ 19613 3348 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3348 21 that that IN 19613 3348 22 God God NNP 19613 3348 23 had have VBD 19613 3348 24 forgiven forgive VBN 19613 3348 25 the the DT 19613 3348 26 sinner sinner NN 19613 3348 27 , , , 19613 3348 28 or or CC 19613 3348 29 in in IN 19613 3348 30 other other JJ 19613 3348 31 words word NNS 19613 3348 32 that that WDT 19613 3348 33 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3348 34 had have VBD 19613 3348 35 power power NN 19613 3348 36 to to TO 19613 3348 37 grant grant VB 19613 3348 38 this this DT 19613 3348 39 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 3348 40 in in IN 19613 3348 41 virtue virtue NN 19613 3348 42 of of IN 19613 3348 43 the the DT 19613 3348 44 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3348 45 dwelling dwell VBG 19613 3348 46 in in IN 19613 3348 47 her -PRON- PRP 19613 3348 48 , , , 19613 3348 49 and and CC 19613 3348 50 that that IN 19613 3348 51 this this DT 19613 3348 52 readmission readmission NN 19613 3348 53 therefore therefore RB 19613 3348 54 involved involve VBD 19613 3348 55 no no DT 19613 3348 56 violation violation NN 19613 3348 57 of of IN 19613 3348 58 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3348 59 holiness holiness NN 19613 3348 60 . . . 19613 3348 61 " " '' 19613 3349 1 In in IN 19613 3349 2 such such JJ 19613 3349 3 instances instance NNS 19613 3349 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3349 5 is be VBZ 19613 3349 6 first first JJ 19613 3349 7 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3349 8 and and CC 19613 3349 9 then then RB 19613 3349 10 martyrs martyr VBZ 19613 3349 11 that that WDT 19613 3349 12 appear appear VBP 19613 3349 13 as as IN 19613 3349 14 organs organ NNS 19613 3349 15 of of IN 19613 3349 16 the the DT 19613 3349 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3349 18 , , , 19613 3349 19 till till IN 19613 3349 20 at at IN 19613 3349 21 last last JJ 19613 3349 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3349 23 is be VBZ 19613 3349 24 no no RB 19613 3349 25 longer long RBR 19613 3349 26 the the DT 19613 3349 27 inspired inspire VBN 19613 3349 28 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3349 29 , , , 19613 3349 30 but but CC 19613 3349 31 the the DT 19613 3349 32 professional professional JJ 19613 3349 33 medium medium NN 19613 3349 34 of of IN 19613 3349 35 the the DT 19613 3349 36 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3349 37 , , , 19613 3349 38 viz viz NNP 19613 3349 39 . . NNP 19613 3349 40 , , , 19613 3349 41 the the DT 19613 3349 42 priest priest NN 19613 3349 43 , , , 19613 3349 44 who who WP 19613 3349 45 decides decide VBZ 19613 3349 46 everything everything NN 19613 3349 47 . . . 19613 3349 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3350 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3350 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3350 3 228 228 CD 19613 3350 4 : : : 19613 3350 5 In in IN 19613 3350 6 the the DT 19613 3350 7 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3350 8 century century NN 19613 3350 9 even even RB 19613 3350 10 endeavours endeavour VBZ 19613 3350 11 at at IN 19613 3350 12 a a DT 19613 3350 13 formal formal JJ 19613 3350 14 repetition repetition NN 19613 3350 15 of of IN 19613 3350 16 baptism baptism NN 19613 3350 17 were be VBD 19613 3350 18 not not RB 19613 3350 19 wholly wholly RB 19613 3350 20 lacking lacking JJ 19613 3350 21 . . . 19613 3351 1 In in IN 19613 3351 2 Marcionite marcionite JJ 19613 3351 3 congregations congregation NNS 19613 3351 4 repetition repetition NN 19613 3351 5 of of IN 19613 3351 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 3351 7 is be VBZ 19613 3351 8 said say VBN 19613 3351 9 to to TO 19613 3351 10 have have VB 19613 3351 11 taken take VBN 19613 3351 12 place place NN 19613 3351 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3351 14 on on IN 19613 3351 15 the the DT 19613 3351 16 Elkesaites Elkesaites NNPS 19613 3351 17 see see VBP 19613 3351 18 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3351 19 . . . 19613 3352 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3352 2 p. p. NNP 19613 3352 3 308 308 CD 19613 3352 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3352 5 . . . 19613 3353 1 One one PRP 19613 3353 2 can can MD 19613 3353 3 only only RB 19613 3353 4 wonder wonder VB 19613 3353 5 that that IN 19613 3353 6 there there EX 19613 3353 7 is be VBZ 19613 3353 8 not not RB 19613 3353 9 more more RBR 19613 3353 10 frequent frequent JJ 19613 3353 11 mention mention NN 19613 3353 12 of of IN 19613 3353 13 such such JJ 19613 3353 14 attempts attempt NNS 19613 3353 15 . . . 19613 3354 1 The the DT 19613 3354 2 assertion assertion NN 19613 3354 3 of of IN 19613 3354 4 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3354 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3354 6 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3354 7 . . . 19613 3355 1 IX ix NN 19613 3355 2 . . . 19613 3356 1 12 12 CD 19613 3356 2 fin fin NNP 19613 3356 3 . . . 19613 3356 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3357 1 is be VBZ 19613 3357 2 enigmatical enigmatical JJ 19613 3357 3 : : : 19613 3357 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3357 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3357 6 : : : 19613 3357 7 Epi Epi NNP 19613 3357 8 Kallistou Kallistou NNP 19613 3357 9 protô protô VB 19613 3357 10 tetolmêtai tetolmêtai NNP 19613 3357 11 deuteron deuteron NNP 19613 3357 12 autois autois NNP 19613 3357 13 baptisma baptisma NNP 19613 3357 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3357 15 . . . 19613 3357 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3358 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3358 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3358 3 229 229 CD 19613 3358 4 : : : 19613 3358 5 See See NNP 19613 3358 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3358 7 . . NNP 19613 3358 8 , , , 19613 3358 9 de de NNP 19613 3358 10 pudic pudic NNP 19613 3358 11 . . . 19613 3359 1 12 12 CD 19613 3359 2 : : : 19613 3359 3 " " `` 19613 3359 4 hinc hinc NNP 19613 3359 5 est est NNP 19613 3359 6 quod quod NNP 19613 3359 7 neque neque NNP 19613 3359 8 idololatriæ idololatriæ NNP 19613 3359 9 neque neque NNP 19613 3359 10 sanguini sanguini NNP 19613 3359 11 pax pax NNP 19613 3359 12 ab ab NNP 19613 3359 13 ecclesiis ecclesiis NNP 19613 3359 14 redditur redditur NNP 19613 3359 15 . . . 19613 3359 16 " " '' 19613 3360 1 Orig Orig NNP 19613 3360 2 . . . 19613 3360 3 , , , 19613 3360 4 de de FW 19613 3360 5 orat orat NNP 19613 3360 6 . . . 19613 3361 1 28 28 CD 19613 3361 2 fin fin NNP 19613 3361 3 ; ; : 19613 3361 4 c. c. NNP 19613 3361 5 Cels Cels NNP 19613 3361 6 . . . 19613 3362 1 III iii CD 19613 3362 2 . . . 19613 3363 1 50 50 CD 19613 3363 2 . . . 19613 3363 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3364 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3364 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3364 3 230 230 CD 19613 3364 4 : : : 19613 3364 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3364 6 is be VBZ 19613 3364 7 only only RB 19613 3364 8 of of IN 19613 3364 9 whoremongers whoremonger NNS 19613 3364 10 and and CC 19613 3364 11 idolaters idolater NNS 19613 3364 12 that that IN 19613 3364 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3364 14 expressly expressly RB 19613 3364 15 speaks speak VBZ 19613 3364 16 in in IN 19613 3364 17 de de NNP 19613 3364 18 pudic pudic NNP 19613 3364 19 . . . 19613 3365 1 c. c. NNP 19613 3365 2 I. I. NNP 19613 3366 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3366 2 must must MD 19613 3366 3 interpret interpret VB 19613 3366 4 in in IN 19613 3366 5 accordance accordance NN 19613 3366 6 with with IN 19613 3366 7 this this DT 19613 3366 8 the the DT 19613 3366 9 following follow VBG 19613 3366 10 statement statement NN 19613 3366 11 by by IN 19613 3366 12 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3366 13 in in IN 19613 3366 14 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3366 15 . . . 19613 3367 1 IX ix NN 19613 3367 2 . . . 19613 3368 1 12 12 CD 19613 3368 2 : : : 19613 3368 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3368 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3368 5 : : : 19613 3368 6 Kallistos kallistos NN 19613 3368 7 prôtos prôto NNS 19613 3368 8 ta ta NNP 19613 3368 9 pros pro NNS 19613 3368 10 tas tas NNP 19613 3368 11 hêdonas hêdonas NNP 19613 3368 12 tois tois NNP 19613 3368 13 anthrôpois anthrôpois NNP 19613 3368 14 synchôrein synchôrein NNP 19613 3368 15 epenoêse epenoêse NNP 19613 3368 16 , , , 19613 3368 17 legôn legôn VBZ 19613 3368 18 pasin pasin NNP 19613 3368 19 hup hup NNP 19613 3368 20 ' ' POS 19613 3368 21 autou autou NNP 19613 3368 22 aphiesthai aphiesthai NNP 19613 3368 23 hamartias hamartias NNP 19613 3368 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3368 25 . . . 19613 3369 1 The the DT 19613 3369 2 aim aim NN 19613 3369 3 of of IN 19613 3369 4 this this DT 19613 3369 5 measure measure NN 19613 3369 6 is be VBZ 19613 3369 7 still still RB 19613 3369 8 clear clear JJ 19613 3369 9 from from IN 19613 3369 10 the the DT 19613 3369 11 account account NN 19613 3369 12 of of IN 19613 3369 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3369 14 given give VBN 19613 3369 15 by by IN 19613 3369 16 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3369 17 , , , 19613 3369 18 though though IN 19613 3369 19 this this DT 19613 3369 20 indeed indeed RB 19613 3369 21 is be VBZ 19613 3369 22 written write VBN 19613 3369 23 in in IN 19613 3369 24 a a DT 19613 3369 25 hostile hostile JJ 19613 3369 26 spirit spirit NN 19613 3369 27 . . . 19613 3370 1 Roman roman JJ 19613 3370 2 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3370 3 were be VBD 19613 3370 4 then then RB 19613 3370 5 split split VBN 19613 3370 6 into into IN 19613 3370 7 at at RB 19613 3370 8 least least RBS 19613 3370 9 five five CD 19613 3370 10 different different JJ 19613 3370 11 sects sect NNS 19613 3370 12 , , , 19613 3370 13 and and CC 19613 3370 14 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3370 15 left leave VBD 19613 3370 16 nothing nothing NN 19613 3370 17 undone undo VBN 19613 3370 18 to to TO 19613 3370 19 break break VB 19613 3370 20 up up RP 19613 3370 21 the the DT 19613 3370 22 unfriendly unfriendly JJ 19613 3370 23 parties party NNS 19613 3370 24 and and CC 19613 3370 25 enlarge enlarge VB 19613 3370 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3370 27 own own JJ 19613 3370 28 . . . 19613 3371 1 In in IN 19613 3371 2 all all DT 19613 3371 3 probability probability NN 19613 3371 4 , , , 19613 3371 5 too too RB 19613 3371 6 , , , 19613 3371 7 the the DT 19613 3371 8 energetic energetic JJ 19613 3371 9 bishop bishop NN 19613 3371 10 met meet VBD 19613 3371 11 with with IN 19613 3371 12 a a DT 19613 3371 13 certain certain JJ 19613 3371 14 measure measure NN 19613 3371 15 of of IN 19613 3371 16 success success NN 19613 3371 17 . . . 19613 3372 1 From from IN 19613 3372 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3372 3 . . NNP 19613 3372 4 , , , 19613 3372 5 H. H. NNP 19613 3372 6 E. E. NNP 19613 3372 7 IV IV NNP 19613 3372 8 . . . 19613 3373 1 23 23 CD 19613 3373 2 . . . 19613 3374 1 6 6 CD 19613 3374 2 , , , 19613 3374 3 one one PRP 19613 3374 4 might may MD 19613 3374 5 be be VB 19613 3374 6 inclined incline VBN 19613 3374 7 to to TO 19613 3374 8 conclude conclude VB 19613 3374 9 that that DT 19613 3374 10 , , , 19613 3374 11 even even RB 19613 3374 12 in in IN 19613 3374 13 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 3374 14 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 19613 3374 15 ' ' POS 19613 3374 16 time time NN 19613 3374 17 , , , 19613 3374 18 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 3374 19 of of IN 19613 3374 20 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 3374 21 had have VBD 19613 3374 22 issued issue VBN 19613 3374 23 lax lax JJ 19613 3374 24 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 3374 25 similar similar JJ 19613 3374 26 to to IN 19613 3374 27 those those DT 19613 3374 28 of of IN 19613 3374 29 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3374 30 . . . 19613 3375 1 But but CC 19613 3375 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3375 3 must must MD 19613 3375 4 not not RB 19613 3375 5 be be VB 19613 3375 6 forgotten forget VBN 19613 3375 7 that that IN 19613 3375 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3375 9 have have VBP 19613 3375 10 nothing nothing NN 19613 3375 11 but but IN 19613 3375 12 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 3375 13 ' ' POS 19613 3375 14 report report NN 19613 3375 15 ; ; : 19613 3375 16 and and CC 19613 3375 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3375 18 is be VBZ 19613 3375 19 just just RB 19613 3375 20 in in IN 19613 3375 21 questions question NNS 19613 3375 22 of of IN 19613 3375 23 this this DT 19613 3375 24 kind kind NN 19613 3375 25 that that WDT 19613 3375 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3375 27 accounts account NNS 19613 3375 28 are be VBP 19613 3375 29 not not RB 19613 3375 30 reliable reliable JJ 19613 3375 31 . . . 19613 3375 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3376 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3376 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3376 3 231 231 CD 19613 3376 4 : : : 19613 3376 5 No no RB 19613 3376 6 doubt doubt RB 19613 3376 7 persecutions persecution NNS 19613 3376 8 were be VBD 19613 3376 9 practically practically RB 19613 3376 10 unknown unknown JJ 19613 3376 11 in in IN 19613 3376 12 the the DT 19613 3376 13 period period NN 19613 3376 14 between between IN 19613 3376 15 220 220 CD 19613 3376 16 and and CC 19613 3376 17 260 260 CD 19613 3376 18 . . . 19613 3376 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3377 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3377 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3377 3 232 232 CD 19613 3377 4 : : : 19613 3377 5 See See NNP 19613 3377 6 Cypr Cypr NNPS 19613 3377 7 . . . 19613 3377 8 , , , 19613 3377 9 de de NNP 19613 3377 10 lapsis lapsis NNP 19613 3377 11 . . . 19613 3377 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3378 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3378 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3378 3 233 233 CD 19613 3378 4 : : : 19613 3378 5 What what WDT 19613 3378 6 scruples scruple NNS 19613 3378 7 were be VBD 19613 3378 8 caused cause VBN 19613 3378 9 by by IN 19613 3378 10 this this DT 19613 3378 11 innovation innovation NN 19613 3378 12 is be VBZ 19613 3378 13 shown show VBN 19613 3378 14 by by IN 19613 3378 15 the the DT 19613 3378 16 first first JJ 19613 3378 17 40 40 CD 19613 3378 18 letters letter NNS 19613 3378 19 in in IN 19613 3378 20 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3378 21 's 's POS 19613 3378 22 collection collection NN 19613 3378 23 . . . 19613 3379 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 3379 2 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3379 3 had have VBD 19613 3379 4 to to TO 19613 3379 5 struggle struggle VB 19613 3379 6 with with IN 19613 3379 7 painful painful JJ 19613 3379 8 doubts doubt NNS 19613 3379 9 . . . 19613 3379 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3380 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3380 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3380 3 234 234 CD 19613 3380 4 : : : 19613 3380 5 Apart apart RB 19613 3380 6 from from IN 19613 3380 7 some some DT 19613 3380 8 epistles epistle NNS 19613 3380 9 of of IN 19613 3380 10 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3380 11 , , , 19613 3380 12 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 3380 13 , , , 19613 3380 14 H. H. NNP 19613 3380 15 E. E. NNP 19613 3380 16 V. V. NNP 19613 3380 17 22 22 CD 19613 3380 18 , , , 19613 3380 19 is be VBZ 19613 3380 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3380 21 chief chief JJ 19613 3380 22 source source NN 19613 3380 23 of of IN 19613 3380 24 information information NN 19613 3380 25 on on IN 19613 3380 26 this this DT 19613 3380 27 point point NN 19613 3380 28 . . . 19613 3381 1 See see VB 19613 3381 2 also also RB 19613 3381 3 Conc Conc NNP 19613 3381 4 . . . 19613 3382 1 Illib Illib NNS 19613 3382 2 . . . 19613 3383 1 can can MD 19613 3383 2 . . . 19613 3384 1 1 1 CD 19613 3384 2 , , , 19613 3384 3 2 2 CD 19613 3384 4 , , , 19613 3384 5 6 6 CD 19613 3384 6 - - SYM 19613 3384 7 8 8 CD 19613 3384 8 , , , 19613 3384 9 12 12 CD 19613 3384 10 , , , 19613 3384 11 17 17 CD 19613 3384 12 , , , 19613 3384 13 18 18 CD 19613 3384 14 - - SYM 19613 3384 15 47 47 CD 19613 3384 16 , , , 19613 3384 17 70 70 CD 19613 3384 18 - - SYM 19613 3384 19 73 73 CD 19613 3384 20 , , , 19613 3384 21 75 75 CD 19613 3384 22 . . . 19613 3384 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3385 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3385 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3385 3 235 235 CD 19613 3385 4 : : : 19613 3385 5 See see VB 19613 3385 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3385 7 article article NN 19613 3385 8 " " `` 19613 3385 9 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3385 10 " " '' 19613 3385 11 in in IN 19613 3385 12 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 3385 13 's 's POS 19613 3385 14 Real Real NNP 19613 3385 15 - - HYPH 19613 3385 16 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 3385 17 , , , 19613 3385 18 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3385 19 ed ed NN 19613 3385 20 . . . 19613 3386 1 One one PRP 19613 3386 2 might may MD 19613 3386 3 be be VB 19613 3386 4 tempted tempt VBN 19613 3386 5 to to TO 19613 3386 6 assume assume VB 19613 3386 7 that that IN 19613 3386 8 the the DT 19613 3386 9 introduction introduction NN 19613 3386 10 of of IN 19613 3386 11 the the DT 19613 3386 12 practice practice NN 19613 3386 13 of of IN 19613 3386 14 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 3386 15 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 3386 16 of of IN 19613 3386 17 sins sin NNS 19613 3386 18 was be VBD 19613 3386 19 an an DT 19613 3386 20 " " `` 19613 3386 21 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3386 22 reaction reaction NN 19613 3386 23 " " '' 19613 3386 24 against against IN 19613 3386 25 the the DT 19613 3386 26 merciless merciless JJ 19613 3386 27 legalism legalism NN 19613 3386 28 which which WDT 19613 3386 29 , , , 19613 3386 30 in in IN 19613 3386 31 the the DT 19613 3386 32 case case NN 19613 3386 33 of of IN 19613 3386 34 the the DT 19613 3386 35 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 3386 36 Church Church NNP 19613 3386 37 indeed indeed RB 19613 3386 38 , , , 19613 3386 39 had have VBD 19613 3386 40 established establish VBN 19613 3386 41 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3386 42 from from IN 19613 3386 43 the the DT 19613 3386 44 beginning beginning NN 19613 3386 45 . . . 19613 3387 1 As as IN 19613 3387 2 a a DT 19613 3387 3 matter matter NN 19613 3387 4 of of IN 19613 3387 5 fact fact NN 19613 3387 6 the the DT 19613 3387 7 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3387 8 and and CC 19613 3387 9 the the DT 19613 3387 10 laxer laxer NNP 19613 3387 11 party party NNP 19613 3387 12 appealed appeal VBD 19613 3387 13 to to IN 19613 3387 14 the the DT 19613 3387 15 New New NNP 19613 3387 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3387 17 in in IN 19613 3387 18 justification justification NN 19613 3387 19 of of IN 19613 3387 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3387 21 practice practice NN 19613 3387 22 . . . 19613 3388 1 This this DT 19613 3388 2 had have VBD 19613 3388 3 already already RB 19613 3388 4 been be VBN 19613 3388 5 done do VBN 19613 3388 6 by by IN 19613 3388 7 the the DT 19613 3388 8 followers follower NNS 19613 3388 9 of of IN 19613 3388 10 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3388 11 and and CC 19613 3388 12 by by IN 19613 3388 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3388 14 . . . 19613 3389 1 See see VB 19613 3389 2 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3389 3 . . . 19613 3390 1 IX ix NN 19613 3390 2 . . . 19613 3391 1 12 12 CD 19613 3391 2 : : : 19613 3391 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3391 4 Greek greek NN 19613 3391 5 : : : 19613 3391 6 phaskontes phaskonte VBZ 19613 3391 7 Christon Christon NNP 19613 3391 8 aphienai aphienai NN 19613 3391 9 tois tois NNP 19613 3391 10 eudokousi eudokousi NN 19613 3391 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3391 12 ; ; : 19613 3391 13 Rom Rom NNP 19613 3391 14 . . . 19613 3392 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 3392 2 . . . 19613 3393 1 4 4 LS 19613 3393 2 and and CC 19613 3393 3 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3393 4 . . . 19613 3394 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 3394 2 . . . 19613 3395 1 29 29 CD 19613 3395 2 were be VBD 19613 3395 3 also also RB 19613 3395 4 quoted quote VBN 19613 3395 5 . . . 19613 3396 1 Before before IN 19613 3396 2 this this DT 19613 3396 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3396 4 's 's POS 19613 3396 5 opponents opponent NNS 19613 3396 6 who who WP 19613 3396 7 favoured favour VBD 19613 3396 8 laxity laxity NN 19613 3396 9 had have VBD 19613 3396 10 appealed appeal VBN 19613 3396 11 exactly exactly RB 19613 3396 12 in in IN 19613 3396 13 the the DT 19613 3396 14 same same JJ 19613 3396 15 way way NN 19613 3396 16 to to IN 19613 3396 17 numerous numerous JJ 19613 3396 18 Bible Bible NNP 19613 3396 19 texts text NNS 19613 3396 20 , , , 19613 3396 21 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3396 22 , , , 19613 3396 23 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3396 24 . . . 19613 3397 1 X. X. NNP 19613 3398 1 23 23 CD 19613 3398 2 : : : 19613 3398 3 XI XI NNP 19613 3398 4 . . . 19613 3399 1 19 19 CD 19613 3399 2 etc etc FW 19613 3399 3 . . . 19613 3399 4 , , , 19613 3399 5 see see VB 19613 3399 6 de de IN 19613 3399 7 monog monog NNP 19613 3399 8 , , , 19613 3399 9 de de NNP 19613 3399 10 pudic pudic NNP 19613 3399 11 . . NNP 19613 3399 12 , , , 19613 3399 13 de de NNP 19613 3399 14 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3399 15 . . . 19613 3400 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3400 2 is be VBZ 19613 3400 3 also also RB 19613 3400 4 able able JJ 19613 3400 5 to to TO 19613 3400 6 quote quote VB 19613 3400 7 many many JJ 19613 3400 8 passages passage NNS 19613 3400 9 from from IN 19613 3400 10 the the DT 19613 3400 11 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 3400 12 . . . 19613 3401 1 However however RB 19613 3401 2 , , , 19613 3401 3 as as IN 19613 3401 4 the the DT 19613 3401 5 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3401 6 and and CC 19613 3401 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3401 8 party party NN 19613 3401 9 did do VBD 19613 3401 10 not not RB 19613 3401 11 modify modify VB 19613 3401 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3401 13 conception conception NN 19613 3401 14 of of IN 19613 3401 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 3401 16 , , , 19613 3401 17 but but CC 19613 3401 18 rather rather RB 19613 3401 19 maintained maintain VBD 19613 3401 20 in in IN 19613 3401 21 principle principle NN 19613 3401 22 , , , 19613 3401 23 as as IN 19613 3401 24 before before RB 19613 3401 25 , , , 19613 3401 26 that that IN 19613 3401 27 baptism baptism NN 19613 3401 28 imposes impose VBZ 19613 3401 29 only only RB 19613 3401 30 obligations obligation NNS 19613 3401 31 for for IN 19613 3401 32 the the DT 19613 3401 33 future future NN 19613 3401 34 , , , 19613 3401 35 the the DT 19613 3401 36 " " `` 19613 3401 37 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3401 38 reaction reaction NN 19613 3401 39 " " '' 19613 3401 40 must must MD 19613 3401 41 not not RB 19613 3401 42 be be VB 19613 3401 43 estimated estimate VBN 19613 3401 44 very very RB 19613 3401 45 highly highly RB 19613 3401 46 ; ; : 19613 3401 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3401 48 see see VB 19613 3401 49 below below RB 19613 3401 50 , , , 19613 3401 51 p. p. NN 19613 3401 52 117 117 CD 19613 3401 53 , , , 19613 3401 54 and and CC 19613 3401 55 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3401 56 essay essay NN 19613 3401 57 in in IN 19613 3401 58 the the DT 19613 3401 59 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 3401 60 fur fur NN 19613 3401 61 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 3401 62 und und NN 19613 3401 63 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 3401 64 , , , 19613 3401 65 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3401 66 . . . 19613 3402 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3402 2 , , , 19613 3402 3 " " '' 19613 3402 4 Die die VB 19613 3402 5 ehre ehre NNP 19613 3402 6 von von NNP 19613 3402 7 der der IN 19613 3402 8 Seligkeit Seligkeit NNP 19613 3402 9 allein allein NN 19613 3402 10 durch durch NN 19613 3402 11 den den NN 19613 3402 12 Glauben Glauben NNP 19613 3402 13 in in IN 19613 3402 14 der der NN 19613 3402 15 alten alten VB 19613 3402 16 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 3402 17 . . . 19613 3402 18 " " '' 19613 3402 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3402 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3403 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3403 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3403 3 236 236 CD 19613 3403 4 : : : 19613 3403 5 The the DT 19613 3403 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 3403 7 of of IN 19613 3403 8 sins sin NNS 19613 3403 9 committed commit VBN 19613 3403 10 against against IN 19613 3403 11 God God NNP 19613 3403 12 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3403 13 , , , 19613 3403 14 as as IN 19613 3403 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3403 16 find find VBP 19613 3403 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3403 18 in in IN 19613 3403 19 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3403 20 , , , 19613 3403 21 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3403 22 , , , 19613 3403 23 and and CC 19613 3403 24 other other JJ 19613 3403 25 Fathers father NNS 19613 3403 26 , , , 19613 3403 27 remains remain VBZ 19613 3403 28 involved involved JJ 19613 3403 29 in in IN 19613 3403 30 an an DT 19613 3403 31 obscurity obscurity NN 19613 3403 32 that that WDT 19613 3403 33 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3403 34 can can MD 19613 3403 35 not not RB 19613 3403 36 clear clear VB 19613 3403 37 up up RP 19613 3403 38 . . . 19613 3403 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3404 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3404 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3404 3 237 237 CD 19613 3404 4 : : : 19613 3404 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3404 6 never never RB 19613 3404 7 expelled expel VBD 19613 3404 8 any any DT 19613 3404 9 one one CD 19613 3404 10 from from IN 19613 3404 11 the the DT 19613 3404 12 Church Church NNP 19613 3404 13 , , , 19613 3404 14 unless unless IN 19613 3404 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3404 16 had have VBD 19613 3404 17 attacked attack VBN 19613 3404 18 the the DT 19613 3404 19 authority authority NN 19613 3404 20 of of IN 19613 3404 21 the the DT 19613 3404 22 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3404 23 , , , 19613 3404 24 and and CC 19613 3404 25 thus thus RB 19613 3404 26 in in IN 19613 3404 27 the the DT 19613 3404 28 opinion opinion NN 19613 3404 29 of of IN 19613 3404 30 this this DT 19613 3404 31 Father Father NNP 19613 3404 32 placed place VBD 19613 3404 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3404 34 outside outside IN 19613 3404 35 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3404 36 pale pale NN 19613 3404 37 by by IN 19613 3404 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3404 39 own own JJ 19613 3404 40 act act NN 19613 3404 41 . . . 19613 3404 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3405 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3405 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3405 3 238 238 CD 19613 3405 4 : : : 19613 3405 5 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 3405 6 . . . 19613 3405 7 , , , 19613 3405 8 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3405 9 . . . 19613 3406 1 IX ix NN 19613 3406 2 . . . 19613 3407 1 12 12 CD 19613 3407 2 : : : 19613 3407 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3407 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3407 5 : : : 19613 3407 6 Kai Kai NNP 19613 3407 7 parabolên parabolên NN 19613 3407 8 tôn tôn NNS 19613 3407 9 zizaniôn zizaniôn NNP 19613 3407 10 pros pros NNP 19613 3407 11 touto touto NNP 19613 3407 12 ephê ephê NNP 19613 3407 13 ho ho NNP 19613 3407 14 Kallistos Kallistos NNP 19613 3407 15 legesthai legesthai NNP 19613 3407 16 . . . 19613 3408 1 Aphete Aphete NNP 19613 3408 2 ta ta NNP 19613 3408 3 zizania zizania NNP 19613 3408 4 sunauxein sunauxein NNP 19613 3408 5 tô tô NNP 19613 3408 6 sitô sitô NNP 19613 3408 7 , , , 19613 3408 8 toutestin toutestin NN 19613 3408 9 en en IN 19613 3408 10 tê tê NNP 19613 3408 11 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 3408 12 tous tous JJ 19613 3408 13 hamartanontas hamartanontas NNP 19613 3408 14 . . . 19613 3409 1 Alla Alla NNP 19613 3409 2 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 3 tên tên NNP 19613 3409 4 kibôton kibôton NNP 19613 3409 5 tou tou NNP 19613 3409 6 Nôe Nôe NNP 19613 3409 7 eis eis NNP 19613 3409 8 homoiôma homoiôma NNP 19613 3409 9 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3409 10 ephê ephê NNP 19613 3409 11 gegonenai gegonenai NNP 19613 3409 12 , , , 19613 3409 13 en en IN 19613 3409 14 hê hê NNP 19613 3409 15 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 16 kunes kunes NNP 19613 3409 17 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 18 lykoi lykoi NNP 19613 3409 19 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 20 korakes korakes NNP 19613 3409 21 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 22 panta panta NNP 19613 3409 23 ta ta NNP 19613 3409 24 kathara kathara NNP 19613 3409 25 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 26 akatharta akatharta NNP 19613 3409 27 ; ; : 19613 3409 28 houtô houtô NNP 19613 3409 29 phaskôn phaskôn NNP 19613 3409 30 dein dein NNP 19613 3409 31 einai einai NNP 19613 3409 32 en en IN 19613 3409 33 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 3409 34 homoiôs homoiôs NNP 19613 3409 35 , , , 19613 3409 36 kai kai NNP 19613 3409 37 hosa hosa NNP 19613 3409 38 pros pros NNP 19613 3409 39 touto touto NNP 19613 3409 40 dynatos dynatos NNP 19613 3409 41 ên ên NNP 19613 3409 42 synagein synagein NNP 19613 3409 43 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 3409 44 hêrmêneusen hêrmêneusen NNP 19613 3409 45 . . . 19613 3409 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3410 1 From from IN 19613 3410 2 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3410 3 . . NNP 19613 3410 4 , , , 19613 3410 5 de de FW 19613 3410 6 idolol idolol NNP 19613 3410 7 . . . 19613 3411 1 24 24 CD 19613 3411 2 , , , 19613 3411 3 one one PRP 19613 3411 4 can can MD 19613 3411 5 not not RB 19613 3411 6 help help VB 19613 3411 7 assuming assume VBG 19613 3411 8 that that IN 19613 3411 9 even even RB 19613 3411 10 before before IN 19613 3411 11 the the DT 19613 3411 12 year year NN 19613 3411 13 200 200 CD 19613 3411 14 the the DT 19613 3411 15 laxer laxer NNP 19613 3411 16 sort sort RB 19613 3411 17 in in IN 19613 3411 18 Carthage carthage NN 19613 3411 19 had have VBD 19613 3411 20 already already RB 19613 3411 21 appealed appeal VBN 19613 3411 22 to to IN 19613 3411 23 the the DT 19613 3411 24 Ark. Arkansas NNP 19613 3412 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3412 2 " " `` 19613 3412 3 Viderimus Viderimus NNP 19613 3412 4 si si NNP 19613 3412 5 secundum secundum NNP 19613 3412 6 arcæ arcæ NNP 19613 3412 7 typum typum VBD 19613 3412 8 et et NNP 19613 3412 9 corvus corvus NNP 19613 3412 10 et et NNP 19613 3412 11 milvus milvu VBD 19613 3412 12 et et NNP 19613 3412 13 lupus lupus NNP 19613 3412 14 et et FW 19613 3412 15 canis canis FW 19613 3412 16 et et FW 19613 3412 17 serpens serpen VBZ 19613 3412 18 in in IN 19613 3412 19 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3412 20 erit erit NNP 19613 3412 21 . . . 19613 3413 1 Certe Certe NNP 19613 3413 2 idololatres idololatre VBZ 19613 3413 3 in in IN 19613 3413 4 arcæ arcæ NNP 19613 3413 5 typo typo NNP 19613 3413 6 non non AFX 19613 3413 7 habetur habetur NN 19613 3413 8 . . . 19613 3414 1 Quod quod NN 19613 3414 2 in in IN 19613 3414 3 arca arca NNS 19613 3414 4 non non AFX 19613 3414 5 fuit fuit NN 19613 3414 6 , , , 19613 3414 7 in in IN 19613 3414 8 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3414 9 non non AFX 19613 3414 10 sit sit NN 19613 3414 11 " " '' 19613 3414 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3414 13 . . . 19613 3415 1 But but CC 19613 3415 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3415 3 do do VBP 19613 3415 4 not not RB 19613 3415 5 know know VB 19613 3415 6 what what WDT 19613 3415 7 form form NN 19613 3415 8 this this DT 19613 3415 9 took take VBD 19613 3415 10 and and CC 19613 3415 11 what what WP 19613 3415 12 inferences inference NNS 19613 3415 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3415 14 drew draw VBD 19613 3415 15 . . . 19613 3416 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 3416 2 , , , 19613 3416 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3416 4 have have VBP 19613 3416 5 here here RB 19613 3416 6 a a DT 19613 3416 7 very very RB 19613 3416 8 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3416 9 example example NN 19613 3416 10 of of IN 19613 3416 11 the the DT 19613 3416 12 multitudinous multitudinous JJ 19613 3416 13 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 3416 14 in in IN 19613 3416 15 which which WDT 19613 3416 16 the the DT 19613 3416 17 Fathers father NNS 19613 3416 18 were be VBD 19613 3416 19 involved involve VBN 19613 3416 20 by by IN 19613 3416 21 typology typology NN 19613 3416 22 : : : 19613 3416 23 the the DT 19613 3416 24 Ark Ark NNP 19613 3416 25 is be VBZ 19613 3416 26 the the DT 19613 3416 27 Church Church NNP 19613 3416 28 , , , 19613 3416 29 hence hence RB 19613 3416 30 the the DT 19613 3416 31 dogs dog NNS 19613 3416 32 and and CC 19613 3416 33 snakes snake NNS 19613 3416 34 are be VBP 19613 3416 35 men man NNS 19613 3416 36 . . . 19613 3417 1 To to TO 19613 3417 2 solve solve VB 19613 3417 3 these these DT 19613 3417 4 problems problem NNS 19613 3417 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3417 6 required require VBD 19613 3417 7 an an DT 19613 3417 8 abnormal abnormal JJ 19613 3417 9 degree degree NN 19613 3417 10 of of IN 19613 3417 11 acuteness acuteness NN 19613 3417 12 and and CC 19613 3417 13 wit wit NN 19613 3417 14 , , , 19613 3417 15 especially especially RB 19613 3417 16 as as IN 19613 3417 17 each each DT 19613 3417 18 solution solution NN 19613 3417 19 always always RB 19613 3417 20 started start VBD 19613 3417 21 fresh fresh JJ 19613 3417 22 questions question NNS 19613 3417 23 . . . 19613 3418 1 Orig Orig NNP 19613 3418 2 . . . 19613 3419 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3419 2 Hom hom UH 19613 3419 3 . . . 19613 3420 1 II ii CD 19613 3420 2 . . . 19613 3421 1 in in IN 19613 3421 2 Genes Genes NNP 19613 3421 3 . . . 19613 3422 1 III III NNP 19613 3422 2 . . . 19613 3422 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3423 1 also also RB 19613 3423 2 viewed view VBD 19613 3423 3 the the DT 19613 3423 4 Ark Ark NNP 19613 3423 5 as as IN 19613 3423 6 the the DT 19613 3423 7 type type NN 19613 3423 8 of of IN 19613 3423 9 the the DT 19613 3423 10 Church Church NNP 19613 3423 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3423 12 the the DT 19613 3423 13 working working NN 19613 3423 14 out out IN 19613 3423 15 of of IN 19613 3423 16 the the DT 19613 3423 17 image image NN 19613 3423 18 in in IN 19613 3423 19 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3423 20 . . . 19613 3424 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3424 2 in in IN 19613 3424 3 Ezech Ezech NNP 19613 3424 4 . . . 19613 3424 5 , , , 19613 3424 6 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 3424 7 . . . 19613 3425 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 3425 2 . . . 19613 3426 1 p. p. NN 19613 3426 2 24 24 CD 19613 3426 3 sq sq NNP 19613 3426 4 . . NNP 19613 3426 5 , , , 19613 3426 6 is be VBZ 19613 3426 7 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3426 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3426 9 ; ; : 19613 3426 10 but but CC 19613 3426 11 apparently apparently RB 19613 3426 12 in in IN 19613 3426 13 the the DT 19613 3426 14 wild wild JJ 19613 3426 15 animals animal NNS 19613 3426 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3426 17 rather rather RB 19613 3426 18 sees see VBZ 19613 3426 19 the the DT 19613 3426 20 simple simple JJ 19613 3426 21 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3426 22 who who WP 19613 3426 23 are be VBP 19613 3426 24 not not RB 19613 3426 25 yet yet RB 19613 3426 26 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 3426 27 trained train VBN 19613 3426 28 -- -- : 19613 3426 29 at at IN 19613 3426 30 any any DT 19613 3426 31 rate rate NN 19613 3426 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3426 33 does do VBZ 19613 3426 34 not not RB 19613 3426 35 refer refer VB 19613 3426 36 to to IN 19613 3426 37 the the DT 19613 3426 38 whoremongers whoremonger NNS 19613 3426 39 and and CC 19613 3426 40 adulterers adulterer NNS 19613 3426 41 who who WP 19613 3426 42 must must MD 19613 3426 43 be be VB 19613 3426 44 tolerated tolerate VBN 19613 3426 45 in in IN 19613 3426 46 the the DT 19613 3426 47 Church Church NNP 19613 3426 48 . . . 19613 3427 1 The the DT 19613 3427 2 Roman roman JJ 19613 3427 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 3427 4 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 3427 5 again again RB 19613 3427 6 , , , 19613 3427 7 positively positively RB 19613 3427 8 insisted insist VBD 19613 3427 9 on on IN 19613 3427 10 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3427 11 ' ' POS 19613 3427 12 conception conception NN 19613 3427 13 of of IN 19613 3427 14 the the DT 19613 3427 15 Church Church NNP 19613 3427 16 , , , 19613 3427 17 whereas whereas IN 19613 3427 18 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 3427 19 followed follow VBD 19613 3427 20 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3427 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3427 22 see see VB 19613 3427 23 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3427 24 . . NNP 19613 3427 25 , , , 19613 3427 26 H. H. NNP 19613 3427 27 E. E. NNP 19613 3427 28 VI VI NNP 19613 3427 29 . . . 19613 3428 1 43 43 CD 19613 3428 2 . . . 19613 3429 1 10 10 LS 19613 3429 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3429 3 , , , 19613 3429 4 who who WP 19613 3429 5 never never RB 19613 3429 6 declared declare VBD 19613 3429 7 sinners sinner NNS 19613 3429 8 to to TO 19613 3429 9 be be VB 19613 3429 10 a a DT 19613 3429 11 necessary necessary JJ 19613 3429 12 part part NN 19613 3429 13 of of IN 19613 3429 14 the the DT 19613 3429 15 Church Church NNP 19613 3429 16 in in IN 19613 3429 17 the the DT 19613 3429 18 same same JJ 19613 3429 19 fashion fashion NN 19613 3429 20 as as IN 19613 3429 21 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3429 22 did do VBD 19613 3429 23 . . . 19613 3430 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3430 2 See see VB 19613 3430 3 the the DT 19613 3430 4 following follow VBG 19613 3430 5 note note NN 19613 3430 6 and and CC 19613 3430 7 Cyp Cyp NNP 19613 3430 8 . . NNP 19613 3430 9 , , , 19613 3430 10 epp epp NNP 19613 3430 11 . . . 19613 3431 1 67 67 CD 19613 3431 2 . . . 19613 3432 1 6 6 CD 19613 3432 2 ; ; SYM 19613 3432 3 68 68 CD 19613 3432 4 . . . 19613 3433 1 5 5 LS 19613 3433 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3433 3 . . . 19613 3433 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3434 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3434 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3434 3 239 239 CD 19613 3434 4 : : : 19613 3434 5 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3434 6 . . NNP 19613 3434 7 , , , 19613 3434 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3434 9 . . . 19613 3435 1 : : : 19613 3435 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3435 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3435 4 : : : 19613 3435 5 Kallistos Kallistos NNP 19613 3435 6 edogmatisen edogmatisen NNP 19613 3435 7 hopôs hopôs NN 19613 3435 8 ei ei NNP 19613 3435 9 episkopos episkopos NNP 19613 3435 10 hamartoi hamartoi NNP 19613 3435 11 ti ti NNP 19613 3435 12 , , , 19613 3435 13 ei ei NNP 19613 3435 14 kai kai NNP 19613 3435 15 pros pros NNP 19613 3435 16 thanaton thanaton NNP 19613 3435 17 , , , 19613 3435 18 mê mê NNP 19613 3435 19 dein dein NNP 19613 3435 20 katatithesthai katatithesthai NNP 19613 3435 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3435 22 . . . 19613 3436 1 That that IN 19613 3436 2 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3436 3 is be VBZ 19613 3436 4 not not RB 19613 3436 5 exaggerating exaggerate VBG 19613 3436 6 here here RB 19613 3436 7 is be VBZ 19613 3436 8 evident evident JJ 19613 3436 9 from from IN 19613 3436 10 Cyp Cyp NNP 19613 3436 11 . . NNP 19613 3436 12 , , , 19613 3436 13 epp epp NNP 19613 3436 14 . . . 19613 3437 1 67 67 CD 19613 3437 2 , , , 19613 3437 3 68 68 CD 19613 3437 4 ; ; : 19613 3437 5 for for IN 19613 3437 6 these these DT 19613 3437 7 passages passage NNS 19613 3437 8 make make VBP 19613 3437 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3437 10 very very RB 19613 3437 11 probable probable JJ 19613 3437 12 that that IN 19613 3437 13 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 3437 14 also also RB 19613 3437 15 assumed assume VBD 19613 3437 16 the the DT 19613 3437 17 irremovability irremovability NN 19613 3437 18 of of IN 19613 3437 19 a a DT 19613 3437 20 bishop bishop NN 19613 3437 21 on on IN 19613 3437 22 account account NN 19613 3437 23 of of IN 19613 3437 24 gross gross JJ 19613 3437 25 sins sin NNS 19613 3437 26 or or CC 19613 3437 27 other other JJ 19613 3437 28 failings failing NNS 19613 3437 29 . . . 19613 3437 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3438 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3438 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3438 3 240 240 CD 19613 3438 4 : : : 19613 3438 5 See see VB 19613 3438 6 Cypr Cypr NNPS 19613 3438 7 . . . 19613 3438 8 , , , 19613 3438 9 epp epp NNP 19613 3438 10 . . . 19613 3439 1 65 65 CD 19613 3439 2 , , , 19613 3439 3 66 66 CD 19613 3439 4 , , , 19613 3439 5 68 68 CD 19613 3439 6 ; ; : 19613 3439 7 also also RB 19613 3439 8 55 55 CD 19613 3439 9 . . . 19613 3440 1 11 11 CD 19613 3440 2 . . . 19613 3440 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3441 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3441 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3441 3 241 241 CD 19613 3441 4 : : : 19613 3441 5 This this DT 19613 3441 6 is be VBZ 19613 3441 7 asserted assert VBN 19613 3441 8 by by IN 19613 3441 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3441 10 in in IN 19613 3441 11 epp epp NNP 19613 3441 12 . . . 19613 3442 1 65 65 CD 19613 3442 2 . . . 19613 3443 1 4 4 CD 19613 3443 2 and and CC 19613 3443 3 67 67 CD 19613 3443 4 . . . 19613 3444 1 3 3 LS 19613 3444 2 ; ; : 19613 3444 3 but but CC 19613 3444 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3444 5 even even RB 19613 3444 6 goes go VBZ 19613 3444 7 on on RP 19613 3444 8 to to TO 19613 3444 9 declare declare VB 19613 3444 10 that that IN 19613 3444 11 everyone everyone NN 19613 3444 12 is be VBZ 19613 3444 13 polluted polluted JJ 19613 3444 14 that that WDT 19613 3444 15 has have VBZ 19613 3444 16 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 3444 17 with with IN 19613 3444 18 an an DT 19613 3444 19 impure impure NN 19613 3444 20 priest priest NN 19613 3444 21 , , , 19613 3444 22 and and CC 19613 3444 23 takes take VBZ 19613 3444 24 part part NN 19613 3444 25 in in IN 19613 3444 26 the the DT 19613 3444 27 offering offering NN 19613 3444 28 celebrated celebrate VBN 19613 3444 29 by by IN 19613 3444 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3444 31 . . . 19613 3444 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3445 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3445 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3445 3 242 242 CD 19613 3445 4 : : : 19613 3445 5 On on IN 19613 3445 6 this this DT 19613 3445 7 point point NN 19613 3445 8 the the DT 19613 3445 9 greatest great JJS 19613 3445 10 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 3445 11 prevails prevail VBZ 19613 3445 12 in in IN 19613 3445 13 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3445 14 . . . 19613 3446 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 19613 3446 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3446 3 says say VBZ 19613 3446 4 that that IN 19613 3446 5 God God NNP 19613 3446 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3446 7 installs install VBZ 19613 3446 8 the the DT 19613 3446 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3446 10 , , , 19613 3446 11 and and CC 19613 3446 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3446 13 is be VBZ 19613 3446 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 3446 15 a a DT 19613 3446 16 deadly deadly JJ 19613 3446 17 sin sin NN 19613 3446 18 against against IN 19613 3446 19 God God NNP 19613 3446 20 to to TO 19613 3446 21 criticise criticise VB 19613 3446 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3446 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3446 24 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3446 25 , , , 19613 3446 26 in in IN 19613 3446 27 ep ep NNP 19613 3446 28 . . . 19613 3447 1 66 66 CD 19613 3447 2 . . . 19613 3448 1 1 1 LS 19613 3448 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3448 3 ; ; : 19613 3448 4 on on IN 19613 3448 5 other other JJ 19613 3448 6 occasions occasion NNS 19613 3448 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3448 8 remembers remember VBZ 19613 3448 9 that that IN 19613 3448 10 the the DT 19613 3448 11 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3448 12 have have VBP 19613 3448 13 been be VBN 19613 3448 14 ordained ordain VBN 19613 3448 15 by by IN 19613 3448 16 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3448 17 ; ; : 19613 3448 18 and and CC 19613 3448 19 again again RB 19613 3448 20 , , , 19613 3448 21 as as IN 19613 3448 22 in in IN 19613 3448 23 ep ep NNP 19613 3448 24 . . . 19613 3449 1 67 67 CD 19613 3449 2 . . . 19613 3450 1 3 3 CD 19613 3450 2 , , , 19613 3450 3 4 4 CD 19613 3450 4 , , , 19613 3450 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3450 6 appears appear VBZ 19613 3450 7 to to TO 19613 3450 8 acknowledge acknowledge VB 19613 3450 9 the the DT 19613 3450 10 community community NN 19613 3450 11 's 's POS 19613 3450 12 right right NN 19613 3450 13 to to TO 19613 3450 14 choose choose VB 19613 3450 15 and and CC 19613 3450 16 control control VB 19613 3450 17 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3450 18 . . . 19613 3451 1 Cf cf NN 19613 3451 2 . . . 19613 3452 1 the the DT 19613 3452 2 sections section NNS 19613 3452 3 referring refer VBG 19613 3452 4 to to IN 19613 3452 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3452 6 in in IN 19613 3452 7 Reuter Reuter NNP 19613 3452 8 's 's POS 19613 3452 9 " " `` 19613 3452 10 Augustinische Augustinische NNP 19613 3452 11 Studien Studien NNP 19613 3452 12 " " '' 19613 3452 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3452 14 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 3452 15 für für NN 19613 3452 16 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 3452 17 , , , 19613 3452 18 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3452 19 . . . 19613 3453 1 VII VII NNP 19613 3453 2 . . NNP 19613 3453 3 , , , 19613 3453 4 p. p. NN 19613 3453 5 199 199 CD 19613 3453 6 ff ff NNP 19613 3453 7 . . NNP 19613 3453 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3453 9 . . . 19613 3453 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3454 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3454 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3454 3 243 243 CD 19613 3454 4 : : : 19613 3454 5 The the DT 19613 3454 6 Donatists Donatists NNPS 19613 3454 7 were be VBD 19613 3454 8 quite quite RB 19613 3454 9 justified justify VBN 19613 3454 10 in in IN 19613 3454 11 appealing appeal VBG 19613 3454 12 to to IN 19613 3454 13 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3454 14 , , , 19613 3454 15 that that RB 19613 3454 16 is is RB 19613 3454 17 , , , 19613 3454 18 in in IN 19613 3454 19 one one CD 19613 3454 20 of of IN 19613 3454 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3454 22 two two CD 19613 3454 23 aspects aspect NNS 19613 3454 24 . . . 19613 3454 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3455 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3455 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3455 3 244 244 CD 19613 3455 4 : : : 19613 3455 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3455 6 not not RB 19613 3455 7 only only RB 19613 3455 8 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 3455 9 between between IN 19613 3455 10 different different JJ 19613 3455 11 groups group NNS 19613 3455 12 within within IN 19613 3455 13 the the DT 19613 3455 14 Church Church NNP 19613 3455 15 as as IN 19613 3455 16 judged judge VBN 19613 3455 17 by by IN 19613 3455 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3455 19 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 3455 20 understanding understanding NN 19613 3455 21 and and CC 19613 3455 22 moral moral JJ 19613 3455 23 development development NN 19613 3455 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3455 25 Comm Comm NNP 19613 3455 26 . . . 19613 3456 1 in in IN 19613 3456 2 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3456 3 . . . 19613 3457 1 Tom Tom NNP 19613 3457 2 . . . 19613 3458 1 XI XI NNP 19613 3458 2 . . . 19613 3459 1 at at IN 19613 3459 2 Chap Chap NNP 19613 3459 3 . . . 19613 3460 1 XV XV NNP 19613 3460 2 . . . 19613 3461 1 29 29 CD 19613 3461 2 ; ; : 19613 3461 3 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3461 4 . . . 19613 3462 1 II ii CD 19613 3462 2 . . . 19613 3463 1 in in IN 19613 3463 2 Genes Genes NNP 19613 3463 3 . . . 19613 3464 1 Chap Chap NNP 19613 3464 2 . . . 19613 3465 1 3 3 LS 19613 3465 2 ; ; : 19613 3465 3 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3465 4 . . . 19613 3466 1 in in IN 19613 3466 2 Cantic Cantic NNP 19613 3466 3 . . . 19613 3467 1 Tom Tom NNP 19613 3467 2 . . . 19613 3468 1 I. i. NN 19613 3468 2 at at IN 19613 3468 3 Chap Chap NNP 19613 3468 4 . . . 19613 3469 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3470 1 4 4 LS 19613 3470 2 : : : 19613 3470 3 " " `` 19613 3470 4 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3470 5 una una NNP 19613 3470 6 quidem quidem NNP 19613 3470 7 est est NNP 19613 3470 8 , , , 19613 3470 9 cum cum NNP 19613 3470 10 perfecta perfecta NNP 19613 3470 11 est est NNP 19613 3470 12 ; ; : 19613 3470 13 multæ multæ NNP 19613 3470 14 vero vero NNP 19613 3470 15 sunt sunt NNP 19613 3470 16 adolescentulæ adolescentulæ NNP 19613 3470 17 , , , 19613 3470 18 cum cum NNP 19613 3470 19 adhuc adhuc NNP 19613 3470 20 instruuntur instruuntur NNP 19613 3470 21 et et NNP 19613 3470 22 proficiunt proficiunt NN 19613 3470 23 " " '' 19613 3470 24 ; ; : 19613 3470 25 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3470 26 . . . 19613 3471 1 III iii CD 19613 3471 2 . . . 19613 3472 1 in in IN 19613 3472 2 Levit Levit NNP 19613 3472 3 . . . 19613 3473 1 Chap Chap NNP 19613 3473 2 . . . 19613 3474 1 iii iii NNP 19613 3474 2 . . . 19613 3475 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3475 2 , , , 19613 3475 3 but but CC 19613 3475 4 also also RB 19613 3475 5 between between IN 19613 3475 6 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 3475 7 and and CC 19613 3475 8 carnal carnal JJ 19613 3475 9 members member NNS 19613 3475 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3475 11 Hom hom UH 19613 3475 12 . . . 19613 3476 1 XXVI XXVI NNP 19613 3476 2 . . . 19613 3477 1 in in IN 19613 3477 2 Num Num NNP 19613 3477 3 . . . 19613 3478 1 Chap Chap NNP 19613 3478 2 . . . 19613 3479 1 vii vii NNP 19613 3479 2 . . . 19613 3479 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3480 1 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 3480 2 , , , 19613 3480 3 between between IN 19613 3480 4 true true JJ 19613 3480 5 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3480 6 and and CC 19613 3480 7 those those DT 19613 3480 8 who who WP 19613 3480 9 only only RB 19613 3480 10 bear bear VBP 19613 3480 11 that that DT 19613 3480 12 name name NN 19613 3480 13 without without IN 19613 3480 14 heartfelt heartfelt JJ 19613 3480 15 faith faith NN 19613 3480 16 -- -- : 19613 3480 17 who who WP 19613 3480 18 outwardly outwardly RB 19613 3480 19 take take VBP 19613 3480 20 part part NN 19613 3480 21 in in IN 19613 3480 22 everything everything NN 19613 3480 23 , , , 19613 3480 24 but but CC 19613 3480 25 bring bring VB 19613 3480 26 forth forth RP 19613 3480 27 fruits fruit NNS 19613 3480 28 neither neither CC 19613 3480 29 in in IN 19613 3480 30 belief belief NN 19613 3480 31 nor nor CC 19613 3480 32 conduct conduct NN 19613 3480 33 . . . 19613 3481 1 Such such JJ 19613 3481 2 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3481 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3481 4 as as IN 19613 3481 5 little little JJ 19613 3481 6 views view NNS 19613 3481 7 as as IN 19613 3481 8 belonging belong VBG 19613 3481 9 to to IN 19613 3481 10 the the DT 19613 3481 11 Church Church NNP 19613 3481 12 as as IN 19613 3481 13 does do VBZ 19613 3481 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3481 15 of of IN 19613 3481 16 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 3481 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3481 18 see see VB 19613 3481 19 Strom Strom NNP 19613 3481 20 . . . 19613 3482 1 VII VII NNP 19613 3482 2 . . . 19613 3483 1 14 14 CD 19613 3483 2 . . . 19613 3484 1 87 87 CD 19613 3484 2 , , , 19613 3484 3 88 88 CD 19613 3484 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3484 5 . . . 19613 3485 1 To to IN 19613 3485 2 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3485 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3485 4 are be VBP 19613 3485 5 like like IN 19613 3485 6 the the DT 19613 3485 7 Jebusites Jebusites NNPS 19613 3485 8 who who WP 19613 3485 9 were be VBD 19613 3485 10 left leave VBN 19613 3485 11 in in IN 19613 3485 12 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 3485 13 : : : 19613 3485 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3485 15 have have VBP 19613 3485 16 no no DT 19613 3485 17 part part NN 19613 3485 18 in in IN 19613 3485 19 the the DT 19613 3485 20 promises promise NNS 19613 3485 21 of of IN 19613 3485 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3485 23 , , , 19613 3485 24 but but CC 19613 3485 25 are be VBP 19613 3485 26 lost lose VBN 19613 3485 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3485 28 Comm Comm NNP 19613 3485 29 . . . 19613 3486 1 in in IN 19613 3486 2 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3486 3 . . . 19613 3487 1 T. T. NNP 19613 3487 2 XII XII NNP 19613 3487 3 . . . 19613 3488 1 c. c. NNP 19613 3489 1 xii xii NNP 19613 3489 2 . . . 19613 3489 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3489 4 . . . 19613 3490 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3490 2 is be VBZ 19613 3490 3 the the DT 19613 3490 4 Church Church NNP 19613 3490 5 's 's POS 19613 3490 6 task task NN 19613 3490 7 to to TO 19613 3490 8 remove remove VB 19613 3490 9 such such JJ 19613 3490 10 members member NNS 19613 3490 11 , , , 19613 3490 12 whence whence NN 19613 3490 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3490 14 see see VBP 19613 3490 15 that that IN 19613 3490 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3490 17 was be VBD 19613 3490 18 far far RB 19613 3490 19 from from IN 19613 3490 20 sharing share VBG 19613 3490 21 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3490 22 ' ' POS 19613 3490 23 view view NN 19613 3490 24 of of IN 19613 3490 25 the the DT 19613 3490 26 Church Church NNP 19613 3490 27 as as IN 19613 3490 28 a a DT 19613 3490 29 _ _ NNP 19613 3490 30 corpus corpus NN 19613 3490 31 permixtum permixtum NN 19613 3490 32 _ _ NNP 19613 3490 33 ; ; : 19613 3490 34 but but CC 19613 3490 35 to to TO 19613 3490 36 carry carry VB 19613 3490 37 out out RP 19613 3490 38 this this DT 19613 3490 39 process process NN 19613 3490 40 so so RB 19613 3490 41 perfectly perfectly RB 19613 3490 42 that that IN 19613 3490 43 only only RB 19613 3490 44 the the DT 19613 3490 45 holy holy JJ 19613 3490 46 and and CC 19613 3490 47 the the DT 19613 3490 48 saved save VBN 19613 3490 49 remain remain VBP 19613 3490 50 is be VBZ 19613 3490 51 a a DT 19613 3490 52 work work NN 19613 3490 53 beyond beyond IN 19613 3490 54 the the DT 19613 3490 55 powers power NNS 19613 3490 56 of of IN 19613 3490 57 human human JJ 19613 3490 58 sagacity sagacity NN 19613 3490 59 . . . 19613 3491 1 One one PRP 19613 3491 2 must must MD 19613 3491 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 3491 4 content content VB 19613 3491 5 oneself oneself PRP 19613 3491 6 with with IN 19613 3491 7 expelling expel VBG 19613 3491 8 notorious notorious JJ 19613 3491 9 sinners sinner NNS 19613 3491 10 ; ; : 19613 3491 11 see see VB 19613 3491 12 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3491 13 . . . 19613 3492 1 XXI XXI NNP 19613 3492 2 . . . 19613 3493 1 in in IN 19613 3493 2 Jos Jos NNP 19613 3493 3 . . NNP 19613 3493 4 , , , 19613 3493 5 c. c. NNP 19613 3493 6 i. i. NNP 19613 3493 7 : : : 19613 3493 8 " " `` 19613 3493 9 sunt sunt NNP 19613 3493 10 qui qui NNP 19613 3493 11 ignobilem ignobilem NNP 19613 3493 12 et et NNP 19613 3493 13 degenerem degenerem VBP 19613 3493 14 vitam vitam NNP 19613 3493 15 ducunt ducunt NNP 19613 3493 16 , , , 19613 3493 17 qui qui NNP 19613 3493 18 et et NNP 19613 3493 19 fide fide NNP 19613 3493 20 et et NNP 19613 3493 21 actibus actibus NNP 19613 3493 22 et et NNP 19613 3493 23 omni omni NNP 19613 3493 24 conversatione conversatione NNP 19613 3493 25 sua sua NNP 19613 3493 26 perversi perversi NNP 19613 3493 27 sunt sunt NNP 19613 3493 28 . . . 19613 3494 1 Neque Neque NNP 19613 3494 2 enim enim NNP 19613 3494 3 possibile possibile NNP 19613 3494 4 est est NNP 19613 3494 5 , , , 19613 3494 6 ad ad NN 19613 3494 7 liquidum liquidum NNP 19613 3494 8 purgari purgari NNP 19613 3494 9 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 3494 10 , , , 19613 3494 11 dum dum NNP 19613 3494 12 in in IN 19613 3494 13 terris terris NNP 19613 3494 14 est est NNP 19613 3494 15 , , , 19613 3494 16 ita ita NNP 19613 3494 17 ut ut NNP 19613 3494 18 neque neque NNP 19613 3494 19 impius impius NNP 19613 3494 20 in in IN 19613 3494 21 ea ea NNP 19613 3494 22 quisquam quisquam NNP 19613 3494 23 , , , 19613 3494 24 neque neque NNP 19613 3494 25 peccator peccator NNP 19613 3494 26 residere residere RB 19613 3494 27 videatur videatur NNP 19613 3494 28 , , , 19613 3494 29 sed sed NNP 19613 3494 30 sint sint NN 19613 3494 31 in in IN 19613 3494 32 ea ea NNP 19613 3494 33 omnes omne NNS 19613 3494 34 sancti sancti NNP 19613 3494 35 et et NNP 19613 3494 36 beati beati RB 19613 3494 37 , , , 19613 3494 38 et et FW 19613 3494 39 in in IN 19613 3494 40 quibus quibus NNP 19613 3494 41 nulla nulla NNP 19613 3494 42 prorsus prorsus NNP 19613 3494 43 peccati peccati NNP 19613 3494 44 macula macula NNP 19613 3494 45 deprehendatur deprehendatur NNP 19613 3494 46 . . . 19613 3495 1 Sed Sed NNP 19613 3495 2 sicut sicut NNP 19613 3495 3 dicitur dicitur NNP 19613 3495 4 de de NNP 19613 3495 5 zizaniis zizaniis NNP 19613 3495 6 : : : 19613 3495 7 Ne Ne NNP 19613 3495 8 forte forte NNP 19613 3495 9 eradicantes eradicante VBZ 19613 3495 10 zizania zizania NNP 19613 3495 11 simul simul VBZ 19613 3495 12 eradicetis eradicetis NNP 19613 3495 13 et et NNP 19613 3495 14 triticum triticum NNP 19613 3495 15 , , , 19613 3495 16 ita ita NNP 19613 3495 17 etiam etiam NNP 19613 3495 18 super super NNP 19613 3495 19 iis iis NNP 19613 3495 20 dici dici JJ 19613 3495 21 potest potest RB 19613 3495 22 , , , 19613 3495 23 in in IN 19613 3495 24 quibus quibus NNP 19613 3495 25 vel vel NNP 19613 3495 26 dubia dubia NNP 19613 3495 27 vel vel NNP 19613 3495 28 occulta occulta NNP 19613 3495 29 peccata peccata NNP 19613 3495 30 sunt sunt NNP 19613 3495 31 .... .... . 19613 3495 32 Eos Eos NNP 19613 3495 33 saltem saltem NN 19613 3495 34 eiiciamus eiiciamus NNP 19613 3495 35 quos quos NNP 19613 3495 36 possumus possumus NNP 19613 3495 37 , , , 19613 3495 38 quorum quorum NNP 19613 3495 39 peccata peccata NNP 19613 3495 40 manifesta manifesta NNP 19613 3495 41 sunt sunt NN 19613 3495 42 . . . 19613 3496 1 Ubi ubi VB 19613 3496 2 enim enim NN 19613 3496 3 peccatum peccatum NN 19613 3496 4 non non AFX 19613 3496 5 est est NNP 19613 3496 6 evidens eviden NNS 19613 3496 7 , , , 19613 3496 8 eiicere eiicere NNP 19613 3496 9 de de NNP 19613 3496 10 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3496 11 neminem neminem NNP 19613 3496 12 possumus possumus NNP 19613 3496 13 . . . 19613 3496 14 " " '' 19613 3497 1 In in IN 19613 3497 2 this this DT 19613 3497 3 way way NN 19613 3497 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 3497 5 very very RB 19613 3497 6 many many JJ 19613 3497 7 wicked wicked JJ 19613 3497 8 people people NNS 19613 3497 9 remain remain VBP 19613 3497 10 in in IN 19613 3497 11 the the DT 19613 3497 12 Church Church NNP 19613 3497 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3497 14 Comm Comm NNP 19613 3497 15 . . . 19613 3498 1 in in IN 19613 3498 2 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3498 3 . . . 19613 3499 1 T. T. NNP 19613 3499 2 X. X. NNP 19613 3499 3 at at IN 19613 3499 4 c. c. NNP 19613 3499 5 xiii xiii NNP 19613 3499 6 . . . 19613 3500 1 47 47 CD 19613 3500 2 f. f. NN 19613 3500 3 : : : 19613 3500 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3500 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3500 6 : : : 19613 3500 7 mê mê NNP 19613 3500 8 xenizometha xenizometha NNP 19613 3500 9 , , , 19613 3500 10 ean ean NNP 19613 3500 11 horômen horômen NNP 19613 3500 12 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 3500 13 ta ta NNP 19613 3500 14 athroismata athroismata NNP 19613 3500 15 peplêrômena peplêrômena NNP 19613 3500 16 kai kai NNP 19613 3500 17 ponêrôn ponêrôn NNP 19613 3500 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3500 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3500 20 ; ; : 19613 3500 21 _ _ NNP 19613 3500 22 but but CC 19613 3500 23 in in IN 19613 3500 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3500 25 work work NN 19613 3500 26 against against IN 19613 3500 27 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 3500 28 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3500 29 already already RB 19613 3500 30 propounded propound VBD 19613 3500 31 that that IN 19613 3500 32 empiric empiric NN 19613 3500 33 and and CC 19613 3500 34 relative relative JJ 19613 3500 35 theory theory NN 19613 3500 36 of of IN 19613 3500 37 the the DT 19613 3500 38 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3500 39 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3500 40 which which WDT 19613 3500 41 views view VBZ 19613 3500 42 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3500 43 as as RB 19613 3500 44 simply simply RB 19613 3500 45 " " `` 19613 3500 46 better well JJR 19613 3500 47 " " '' 19613 3500 48 than than IN 19613 3500 49 the the DT 19613 3500 50 societies society NNS 19613 3500 51 and and CC 19613 3500 52 civic civic JJ 19613 3500 53 communities community NNS 19613 3500 54 existing exist VBG 19613 3500 55 alongside alongside IN 19613 3500 56 of of IN 19613 3500 57 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3500 58 _ _ NNP 19613 3500 59 . . . 19613 3501 1 The the DT 19613 3501 2 29th 29th JJ 19613 3501 3 and and CC 19613 3501 4 30th 30th JJ 19613 3501 5 chapters chapter NNS 19613 3501 6 of of IN 19613 3501 7 the the DT 19613 3501 8 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3501 9 book book NN 19613 3501 10 against against IN 19613 3501 11 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 3501 12 , , , 19613 3501 13 in in IN 19613 3501 14 which which WDT 19613 3501 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3501 16 compares compare VBZ 19613 3501 17 the the DT 19613 3501 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3501 19 with with IN 19613 3501 20 the the DT 19613 3501 21 other other JJ 19613 3501 22 population population NN 19613 3501 23 of of IN 19613 3501 24 Athens Athens NNP 19613 3501 25 , , , 19613 3501 26 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 3501 27 , , , 19613 3501 28 and and CC 19613 3501 29 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 3501 30 , , , 19613 3501 31 and and CC 19613 3501 32 the the DT 19613 3501 33 heads head NNS 19613 3501 34 of of IN 19613 3501 35 congregations congregation NNS 19613 3501 36 with with IN 19613 3501 37 the the DT 19613 3501 38 councillors councillor NNS 19613 3501 39 and and CC 19613 3501 40 mayors mayor NNS 19613 3501 41 of of IN 19613 3501 42 these these DT 19613 3501 43 cities city NNS 19613 3501 44 , , , 19613 3501 45 are be VBP 19613 3501 46 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 3501 47 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3501 48 and and CC 19613 3501 49 attest attest VBP 19613 3501 50 the the DT 19613 3501 51 revolution revolution NN 19613 3501 52 of of IN 19613 3501 53 the the DT 19613 3501 54 times time NNS 19613 3501 55 . . . 19613 3502 1 In in IN 19613 3502 2 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 3502 3 , , , 19613 3502 4 however however RB 19613 3502 5 , , , 19613 3502 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3502 7 must must MD 19613 3502 8 point point VB 19613 3502 9 out out RP 19613 3502 10 that that IN 19613 3502 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3502 12 expressly expressly RB 19613 3502 13 asserts assert VBZ 19613 3502 14 that that IN 19613 3502 15 a a DT 19613 3502 16 person person NN 19613 3502 17 unjustly unjustly RB 19613 3502 18 excommunicated excommunicate VBD 19613 3502 19 remains remain VBZ 19613 3502 20 a a DT 19613 3502 21 member member NN 19613 3502 22 of of IN 19613 3502 23 the the DT 19613 3502 24 Church Church NNP 19613 3502 25 in in IN 19613 3502 26 God God NNP 19613 3502 27 's 's POS 19613 3502 28 eyes eye NNS 19613 3502 29 ; ; : 19613 3502 30 see see VB 19613 3502 31 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3502 32 . . . 19613 3503 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 3503 2 . . . 19613 3504 1 in in IN 19613 3504 2 Levit Levit NNP 19613 3504 3 . . . 19613 3505 1 c. c. NNP 19613 3506 1 iii iii NNP 19613 3506 2 . . . 19613 3507 1 : : : 19613 3507 2 " " `` 19613 3507 3 ita ita NNP 19613 3507 4 fit fit NNP 19613 3507 5 , , , 19613 3507 6 ut ut UH 19613 3507 7 interdum interdum NNP 19613 3507 8 ille ille NNP 19613 3507 9 qui qui NNP 19613 3507 10 foras foras NNP 19613 3507 11 mittitur mittitur NNP 19613 3507 12 intussit intussit NN 19613 3507 13 , , , 19613 3507 14 et et NNP 19613 3507 15 ille ille NNP 19613 3507 16 foris foris NNP 19613 3507 17 , , , 19613 3507 18 qui qui NNP 19613 3507 19 intus intus NNP 19613 3507 20 videtur videtur NNP 19613 3507 21 retineri retineri NN 19613 3507 22 . . . 19613 3507 23 " " '' 19613 3508 1 Döllinger Döllinger NNP 19613 3508 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3508 3 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3508 4 and and CC 19613 3508 5 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3508 6 , , , 19613 3508 7 page page NN 19613 3508 8 254 254 CD 19613 3508 9 ff ff NN 19613 3508 10 . . . 19613 3508 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3509 1 has have VBZ 19613 3509 2 correctly correctly RB 19613 3509 3 concluded conclude VBN 19613 3509 4 that that IN 19613 3509 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3509 6 followed follow VBD 19613 3509 7 the the DT 19613 3509 8 disputes dispute NNS 19613 3509 9 between between IN 19613 3509 10 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3509 11 and and CC 19613 3509 12 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3509 13 in in IN 19613 3509 14 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3509 15 , , , 19613 3509 16 and and CC 19613 3509 17 took take VBD 19613 3509 18 the the DT 19613 3509 19 side side NN 19613 3509 20 of of IN 19613 3509 21 the the DT 19613 3509 22 former former JJ 19613 3509 23 . . . 19613 3510 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3510 2 's 's POS 19613 3510 3 trenchant trenchant JJ 19613 3510 4 remarks remark NNS 19613 3510 5 about about IN 19613 3510 6 the the DT 19613 3510 7 pride pride NN 19613 3510 8 and and CC 19613 3510 9 arrogance arrogance NN 19613 3510 10 of of IN 19613 3510 11 the the DT 19613 3510 12 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3510 13 of of IN 19613 3510 14 large large JJ 19613 3510 15 towns town NNS 19613 3510 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3510 17 in in IN 19613 3510 18 Matth Matth NNP 19613 3510 19 . . . 19613 3511 1 XI XI NNP 19613 3511 2 . . . 19613 3512 1 9 9 CD 19613 3512 2 . . . 19613 3513 1 15 15 CD 19613 3513 2 ; ; : 19613 3513 3 XII XII NNP 19613 3513 4 . . . 19613 3514 1 9 9 CD 19613 3514 2 - - SYM 19613 3514 3 14 14 CD 19613 3514 4 ; ; : 19613 3514 5 XVI XVI NNP 19613 3514 6 . . . 19613 3515 1 8 8 LS 19613 3515 2 . . . 19613 3516 1 22 22 CD 19613 3516 2 and and CC 19613 3516 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 3516 4 , , , 19613 3516 5 e.g. e.g. NNP 19613 3516 6 , , , 19613 3516 7 de de FW 19613 3516 8 orat orat NNP 19613 3516 9 . . . 19613 3517 1 28 28 CD 19613 3517 2 , , , 19613 3517 3 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3517 4 . . . 19613 3518 1 VI VI NNP 19613 3518 2 . . . 19613 3519 1 in in IN 19613 3519 2 Isai Isai NNP 19613 3519 3 c. c. NNP 19613 3519 4 i. i. NNP 19613 3519 5 , , , 19613 3519 6 in in IN 19613 3519 7 Joh Joh NNP 19613 3519 8 . . . 19613 3520 1 X. X. NNP 19613 3521 1 16 16 CD 19613 3521 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3521 3 , , , 19613 3521 4 and and CC 19613 3521 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3521 6 denunciation denunciation NN 19613 3521 7 of of IN 19613 3521 8 such such JJ 19613 3521 9 of of IN 19613 3521 10 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3521 11 as as IN 19613 3521 12 , , , 19613 3521 13 in in IN 19613 3521 14 order order NN 19613 3521 15 to to TO 19613 3521 16 glorify glorify VB 19613 3521 17 God God NNP 19613 3521 18 , , , 19613 3521 19 assume assume VB 19613 3521 20 a a DT 19613 3521 21 mere mere JJ 19613 3521 22 distinction distinction NN 19613 3521 23 of of IN 19613 3521 24 names name NNS 19613 3521 25 between between IN 19613 3521 26 Father Father NNP 19613 3521 27 and and CC 19613 3521 28 Son Son NNP 19613 3521 29 , , , 19613 3521 30 are be VBP 19613 3521 31 also also RB 19613 3521 32 correctly correctly RB 19613 3521 33 regarded regard VBN 19613 3521 34 by by IN 19613 3521 35 Langen Langen NNP 19613 3521 36 as as IN 19613 3521 37 specially specially RB 19613 3521 38 referring refer VBG 19613 3521 39 to to IN 19613 3521 40 the the DT 19613 3521 41 Roman roman JJ 19613 3521 42 ecclesiastics ecclesiastic NNS 19613 3521 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3521 44 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 3521 45 der der NNP 19613 3521 46 römischen römischen NNP 19613 3521 47 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 3521 48 I. I. NNP 19613 3521 49 p. p. NN 19613 3521 50 242 242 CD 19613 3521 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3521 52 . . . 19613 3522 1 Thus thus RB 19613 3522 2 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 3522 3 was be VBD 19613 3522 4 opposed oppose VBN 19613 3522 5 by by IN 19613 3522 6 the the DT 19613 3522 7 three three CD 19613 3522 8 greatest great JJS 19613 3522 9 theologians theologian NNS 19613 3522 10 of of IN 19613 3522 11 the the DT 19613 3522 12 age age NN 19613 3522 13 -- -- : 19613 3522 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3522 15 , , , 19613 3522 16 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3522 17 , , , 19613 3522 18 and and CC 19613 3522 19 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3522 20 . . . 19613 3522 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3523 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3523 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3523 3 245 245 CD 19613 3523 4 : : : 19613 3523 5 If if IN 19613 3523 6 , , , 19613 3523 7 in in IN 19613 3523 8 assuming assume VBG 19613 3523 9 the the DT 19613 3523 10 irremovability irremovability NN 19613 3523 11 of of IN 19613 3523 12 a a DT 19613 3523 13 bishop bishop NN 19613 3523 14 even even RB 19613 3523 15 in in IN 19613 3523 16 case case NN 19613 3523 17 of of IN 19613 3523 18 mortal mortal JJ 19613 3523 19 sin sin NN 19613 3523 20 , , , 19613 3523 21 the the DT 19613 3523 22 Roman roman JJ 19613 3523 23 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3523 24 went go VBD 19613 3523 25 beyond beyond IN 19613 3523 26 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3523 27 , , , 19613 3523 28 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3523 29 drew draw VBD 19613 3523 30 from from IN 19613 3523 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3523 32 conception conception NN 19613 3523 33 of of IN 19613 3523 34 the the DT 19613 3523 35 Church Church NNP 19613 3523 36 a a DT 19613 3523 37 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 3523 38 which which WDT 19613 3523 39 the the DT 19613 3523 40 former former JJ 19613 3523 41 rejected reject VBD 19613 3523 42 , , , 19613 3523 43 viz viz NNP 19613 3523 44 . . NNP 19613 3523 45 , , , 19613 3523 46 the the DT 19613 3523 47 invalidity invalidity NN 19613 3523 48 of of IN 19613 3523 49 baptism baptism NN 19613 3523 50 administered administer VBN 19613 3523 51 by by IN 19613 3523 52 non non JJ 19613 3523 53 - - NNS 19613 3523 54 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 3523 55 . . . 19613 3524 1 Here here RB 19613 3524 2 , , , 19613 3524 3 in in IN 19613 3524 4 all all DT 19613 3524 5 likelihood likelihood NN 19613 3524 6 , , , 19613 3524 7 the the DT 19613 3524 8 Roman roman JJ 19613 3524 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3524 10 were be VBD 19613 3524 11 only only RB 19613 3524 12 determined determine VBN 19613 3524 13 by by IN 19613 3524 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3524 15 interest interest NN 19613 3524 16 in in IN 19613 3524 17 smoothing smooth VBG 19613 3524 18 the the DT 19613 3524 19 way way NN 19613 3524 20 to to IN 19613 3524 21 a a DT 19613 3524 22 return return NN 19613 3524 23 or or CC 19613 3524 24 admission admission NN 19613 3524 25 to to IN 19613 3524 26 the the DT 19613 3524 27 Church Church NNP 19613 3524 28 in in IN 19613 3524 29 the the DT 19613 3524 30 case case NN 19613 3524 31 of of IN 19613 3524 32 non non JJ 19613 3524 33 - - NNS 19613 3524 34 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 3524 35 . . . 19613 3525 1 In in IN 19613 3525 2 this this DT 19613 3525 3 instance instance NN 19613 3525 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3525 5 were be VBD 19613 3525 6 again again RB 19613 3525 7 induced induce VBN 19613 3525 8 to to TO 19613 3525 9 adhere adhere VB 19613 3525 10 to to IN 19613 3525 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3525 12 old old JJ 19613 3525 13 practice practice NN 19613 3525 14 from from IN 19613 3525 15 a a DT 19613 3525 16 consideration consideration NN 19613 3525 17 of of IN 19613 3525 18 the the DT 19613 3525 19 catholicity catholicity NN 19613 3525 20 of of IN 19613 3525 21 the the DT 19613 3525 22 Church Church NNP 19613 3525 23 . . . 19613 3526 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3526 2 redounds redound VBZ 19613 3526 3 to to IN 19613 3526 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3526 5 's 's POS 19613 3526 6 credit credit NN 19613 3526 7 that that WDT 19613 3526 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3526 9 drew draw VBD 19613 3526 10 and and CC 19613 3526 11 firmly firmly RB 19613 3526 12 maintained maintain VBD 19613 3526 13 the the DT 19613 3526 14 undeniable undeniable JJ 19613 3526 15 inferences inference NNS 19613 3526 16 from from IN 19613 3526 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3526 18 own own JJ 19613 3526 19 theory theory NN 19613 3526 20 in in IN 19613 3526 21 spite spite NN 19613 3526 22 of of IN 19613 3526 23 tradition tradition NN 19613 3526 24 . . . 19613 3527 1 The the DT 19613 3527 2 matter matter NN 19613 3527 3 never never RB 19613 3527 4 led lead VBD 19613 3527 5 to to IN 19613 3527 6 a a DT 19613 3527 7 great great JJ 19613 3527 8 _ _ NNP 19613 3527 9 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 3527 10 _ _ NNP 19613 3527 11 controversy controversy NN 19613 3527 12 . . . 19613 3527 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3528 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3528 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3528 3 246 246 CD 19613 3528 4 : : : 19613 3528 5 As as IN 19613 3528 6 to to IN 19613 3528 7 the the DT 19613 3528 8 events event NNS 19613 3528 9 during during IN 19613 3528 10 the the DT 19613 3528 11 vacancy vacancy NN 19613 3528 12 in in IN 19613 3528 13 the the DT 19613 3528 14 Roman Roman NNPS 19613 3528 15 see see VBP 19613 3528 16 immediately immediately RB 19613 3528 17 before before IN 19613 3528 18 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3528 19 's 's POS 19613 3528 20 schism schism NN 19613 3528 21 , , , 19613 3528 22 and and CC 19613 3528 23 the the DT 19613 3528 24 part part NN 19613 3528 25 then then RB 19613 3528 26 played play VBN 19613 3528 27 by by IN 19613 3528 28 the the DT 19613 3528 29 latter latter JJ 19613 3528 30 , , , 19613 3528 31 who who WP 19613 3528 32 was be VBD 19613 3528 33 still still RB 19613 3528 34 a a DT 19613 3528 35 member member NN 19613 3528 36 of of IN 19613 3528 37 the the DT 19613 3528 38 Church Church NNP 19613 3528 39 , , , 19613 3528 40 see see VB 19613 3528 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3528 42 essay essay NN 19613 3528 43 : : : 19613 3528 44 " " `` 19613 3528 45 Die Die NNP 19613 3528 46 Briefe Briefe NNP 19613 3528 47 des des NNP 19613 3528 48 römischen römischen NNP 19613 3528 49 Klerus Klerus NNP 19613 3528 50 aus aus NN 19613 3528 51 der der VBD 19613 3528 52 Zeit Zeit NNP 19613 3528 53 . . . 19613 3529 1 der der NNP 19613 3529 2 Sedisvacanz Sedisvacanz NNP 19613 3529 3 i -PRON- PRP 19613 3529 4 m be VBP 19613 3529 5 Jahre Jahre NNP 19613 3529 6 250 250 CD 19613 3529 7 " " '' 19613 3529 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3529 9 Abhandl Abhandl NNP 19613 3529 10 . . . 19613 3530 1 f. f. NNP 19613 3530 2 Weizsäcker Weizsäcker NNP 19613 3530 3 , , , 19613 3530 4 1892 1892 CD 19613 3530 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3530 6 . . . 19613 3530 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3531 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3531 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3531 3 247 247 CD 19613 3531 4 : : : 19613 3531 5 So so RB 19613 3531 6 far far RB 19613 3531 7 as as IN 19613 3531 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3531 9 are be VBP 19613 3531 10 able able JJ 19613 3531 11 to to TO 19613 3531 12 judge judge VB 19613 3531 13 , , , 19613 3531 14 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3531 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3531 16 did do VBD 19613 3531 17 not not RB 19613 3531 18 extend extend VB 19613 3531 19 the the DT 19613 3531 20 severer severer NN 19613 3531 21 treatment treatment NN 19613 3531 22 to to IN 19613 3531 23 all all DT 19613 3531 24 gross gross JJ 19613 3531 25 sinners sinner NNS 19613 3531 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3531 27 see see VB 19613 3531 28 ep ep NNP 19613 3531 29 . . . 19613 3532 1 55 55 CD 19613 3532 2 . . . 19613 3533 1 26 26 CD 19613 3533 2 , , , 19613 3533 3 27 27 CD 19613 3533 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3533 5 ; ; : 19613 3533 6 but but CC 19613 3533 7 only only RB 19613 3533 8 decreed decreed VBP 19613 3533 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3533 10 in in IN 19613 3533 11 the the DT 19613 3533 12 case case NN 19613 3533 13 of of IN 19613 3533 14 the the DT 19613 3533 15 lapsed lapse VBN 19613 3533 16 . . . 19613 3534 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3534 2 is be VBZ 19613 3534 3 , , , 19613 3534 4 however however RB 19613 3534 5 , , , 19613 3534 6 very very RB 19613 3534 7 probable probable JJ 19613 3534 8 that that IN 19613 3534 9 in in IN 19613 3534 10 the the DT 19613 3534 11 later later JJ 19613 3534 12 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3534 13 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3534 14 no no DT 19613 3534 15 mortal mortal JJ 19613 3534 16 sinner sinner NN 19613 3534 17 was be VBD 19613 3534 18 absolved absolve VBN 19613 3534 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3534 20 see see VB 19613 3534 21 , , , 19613 3534 22 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3534 23 , , , 19613 3534 24 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 3534 25 , , , 19613 3534 26 H. H. NNP 19613 3534 27 E. E. NNP 19613 3534 28 I. I. NNP 19613 3535 1 10 10 LS 19613 3535 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3535 3 . . . 19613 3536 1 The the DT 19613 3536 2 statement statement NN 19613 3536 3 of of IN 19613 3536 4 Ambrosius Ambrosius NNP 19613 3536 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3536 6 de de FW 19613 3536 7 pænit pænit NNP 19613 3536 8 . . . 19613 3537 1 III iii CD 19613 3537 2 . . . 19613 3538 1 3 3 LS 19613 3538 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3538 3 that that IN 19613 3538 4 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3538 5 made make VBD 19613 3538 6 no no DT 19613 3538 7 difference difference NN 19613 3538 8 between between IN 19613 3538 9 gross gross JJ 19613 3538 10 and and CC 19613 3538 11 lesser less JJR 19613 3538 12 sins sin NNS 19613 3538 13 and and CC 19613 3538 14 equally equally RB 19613 3538 15 refused refuse VBD 19613 3538 16 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 3538 17 to to IN 19613 3538 18 transgressors transgressor NNS 19613 3538 19 of of IN 19613 3538 20 every every DT 19613 3538 21 kind kind NN 19613 3538 22 distorts distort VBZ 19613 3538 23 the the DT 19613 3538 24 truth truth NN 19613 3538 25 as as RB 19613 3538 26 much much RB 19613 3538 27 as as IN 19613 3538 28 did do VBD 19613 3538 29 the the DT 19613 3538 30 old old JJ 19613 3538 31 reproach reproach NN 19613 3538 32 laid lay VBN 19613 3538 33 to to IN 19613 3538 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3538 35 charge charge NN 19613 3538 36 , , , 19613 3538 37 viz viz NNP 19613 3538 38 . . NNP 19613 3538 39 , , , 19613 3538 40 that that IN 19613 3538 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3538 42 as as IN 19613 3538 43 " " `` 19613 3538 44 a a DT 19613 3538 45 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 3538 46 " " '' 19613 3538 47 made make VBD 19613 3538 48 no no DT 19613 3538 49 distinction distinction NN 19613 3538 50 between between IN 19613 3538 51 sins sin NNS 19613 3538 52 . . . 19613 3539 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 3539 2 , , , 19613 3539 3 in in IN 19613 3539 4 excluding exclude VBG 19613 3539 5 gross gross JJ 19613 3539 6 sinners sinner NNS 19613 3539 7 , , , 19613 3539 8 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3539 9 's 's POS 19613 3539 10 followers follower NNS 19613 3539 11 did do VBD 19613 3539 12 not not RB 19613 3539 13 mean mean VB 19613 3539 14 to to TO 19613 3539 15 abandon abandon VB 19613 3539 16 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3539 17 , , , 19613 3539 18 but but CC 19613 3539 19 to to TO 19613 3539 20 leave leave VB 19613 3539 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3539 22 under under IN 19613 3539 23 the the DT 19613 3539 24 discipline discipline NN 19613 3539 25 and and CC 19613 3539 26 intercession intercession NN 19613 3539 27 of of IN 19613 3539 28 the the DT 19613 3539 29 Church Church NNP 19613 3539 30 . . . 19613 3539 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3540 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3540 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3540 3 248 248 CD 19613 3540 4 : : : 19613 3540 5 The the DT 19613 3540 6 title title NN 19613 3540 7 of of IN 19613 3540 8 the the DT 19613 3540 9 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3540 10 life life NN 19613 3540 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3540 12 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3540 13 perfection perfection NN 19613 3540 14 , , , 19613 3540 15 imitation imitation NN 19613 3540 16 of of IN 19613 3540 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3540 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3540 19 in in IN 19613 3540 20 contrast contrast NN 19613 3540 21 to to IN 19613 3540 22 that that DT 19613 3540 23 of of IN 19613 3540 24 ordinary ordinary JJ 19613 3540 25 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3540 26 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3540 27 , , , 19613 3540 28 a a DT 19613 3540 29 designation designation NN 19613 3540 30 which which WDT 19613 3540 31 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3540 32 first first RB 19613 3540 33 find find VBP 19613 3540 34 among among IN 19613 3540 35 the the DT 19613 3540 36 Encratites Encratites NNPS 19613 3540 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3540 38 see see VB 19613 3540 39 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3540 40 . . . 19613 3541 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3541 2 p. p. NNP 19613 3541 3 237 237 CD 19613 3541 4 , , , 19613 3541 5 note note VB 19613 3541 6 3 3 CD 19613 3541 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3541 8 and and CC 19613 3541 9 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 3541 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3541 11 see see VB 19613 3541 12 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3541 13 . . NNP 19613 3541 14 , , , 19613 3541 15 adv adv NNP 19613 3541 16 . . . 19613 3542 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 3542 2 . . . 19613 3543 1 IV IV NNP 19613 3543 2 . . . 19613 3544 1 14 14 CD 19613 3544 2 : : : 19613 3544 3 " " `` 19613 3544 4 Venio Venio NNP 19613 3544 5 nunc nunc JJ 19613 3544 6 ad ad NN 19613 3544 7 ordinarias ordinaria NNS 19613 3544 8 sententias sententias VBP 19613 3544 9 Marcionis Marcionis NNP 19613 3544 10 , , , 19613 3544 11 per per IN 19613 3544 12 quas quas NNP 19613 3544 13 proprietatem proprietatem NNP 19613 3544 14 doctrinæ doctrinæ NNS 19613 3544 15 suæ suæ VBP 19613 3544 16 inducit inducit NNP 19613 3544 17 ad ad NN 19613 3544 18 edictum edictum NN 19613 3544 19 , , , 19613 3544 20 ut ut NNP 19613 3544 21 ita ita NNP 19613 3544 22 dixerim dixerim NNP 19613 3544 23 , , , 19613 3544 24 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3544 25 , , , 19613 3544 26 Beati Beati NNPS 19613 3544 27 mendici mendici IN 19613 3544 28 etc etc FW 19613 3544 29 . . . 19613 3545 1 ") ") `` 19613 3545 2 , , , 19613 3545 3 and and CC 19613 3545 4 then then RB 19613 3545 5 in in IN 19613 3545 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3545 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3545 8 in in IN 19613 3545 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3545 10 pre pre JJ 19613 3545 11 - - JJ 19613 3545 12 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3545 13 period period NN 19613 3545 14 , , , 19613 3545 15 see see VB 19613 3545 16 ad ad NN 19613 3545 17 mart mart NNP 19613 3545 18 . . NNP 19613 3545 19 , , , 19613 3545 20 de de NNP 19613 3545 21 patient patient NNP 19613 3545 22 . . NNP 19613 3545 23 , , , 19613 3545 24 de de NNP 19613 3545 25 pænit pænit NNP 19613 3545 26 . . NNP 19613 3545 27 , , , 19613 3545 28 de de NNP 19613 3545 29 idolol idolol NNP 19613 3545 30 . . . 19613 3546 1 ; ; : 19613 3546 2 in in IN 19613 3546 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3546 4 later later JJ 19613 3546 5 career career NN 19613 3546 6 , , , 19613 3546 7 see see VB 19613 3546 8 de de NNP 19613 3546 9 coron coron NNP 19613 3546 10 . . . 19613 3547 1 8 8 CD 19613 3547 2 , , , 19613 3547 3 9 9 CD 19613 3547 4 , , , 19613 3547 5 13 13 CD 19613 3547 6 , , , 19613 3547 7 14 14 CD 19613 3547 8 ; ; : 19613 3547 9 de de NNP 19613 3547 10 fuga fuga NNP 19613 3547 11 8 8 CD 19613 3547 12 , , , 19613 3547 13 13 13 CD 19613 3547 14 ; ; : 19613 3547 15 de de NNP 19613 3547 16 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3547 17 . . . 19613 3548 1 6 6 CD 19613 3548 2 , , , 19613 3548 3 8 8 CD 19613 3548 4 , , , 19613 3548 5 15 15 CD 19613 3548 6 ; ; : 19613 3548 7 de de NNP 19613 3548 8 monog monog NNP 19613 3548 9 . . . 19613 3549 1 3 3 CD 19613 3549 2 , , , 19613 3549 3 5 5 CD 19613 3549 4 , , , 19613 3549 5 11 11 CD 19613 3549 6 ; ; : 19613 3549 7 see see VB 19613 3549 8 Aubé Aubé NNP 19613 3549 9 , , , 19613 3549 10 Les Les NNP 19613 3549 11 Chrétiens Chrétiens NNP 19613 3549 12 dans dan NNS 19613 3549 13 l'empire l'empire NNP 19613 3549 14 Romain Romain NNP 19613 3549 15 de de NNP 19613 3549 16 la la NNP 19613 3549 17 fin fin NNP 19613 3549 18 des des NNP 19613 3549 19 Antonins Antonins NNP 19613 3549 20 , , , 19613 3549 21 1881 1881 CD 19613 3549 22 , , , 19613 3549 23 p. p. NN 19613 3549 24 237 237 CD 19613 3549 25 ff ff NN 19613 3549 26 . . . 19613 3550 1 : : : 19613 3550 2 " " `` 19613 3550 3 Chrétiens Chrétiens NNP 19613 3550 4 intransigeants intransigeant NNS 19613 3550 5 et et FW 19613 3550 6 Chrétiens Chrétiens NNP 19613 3550 7 opportunistes opportuniste NNS 19613 3550 8 " " '' 19613 3550 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3550 10 was be VBD 19613 3550 11 expressly expressly RB 19613 3550 12 claimed claim VBN 19613 3550 13 by by IN 19613 3550 14 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3550 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3550 16 Cypr Cypr NNP 19613 3550 17 . . . 19613 3550 18 , , , 19613 3550 19 ep ep NNP 19613 3550 20 . . . 19613 3551 1 44 44 CD 19613 3551 2 . . . 19613 3552 1 3 3 LS 19613 3552 2 : : : 19613 3552 3 " " `` 19613 3552 4 si si FW 19613 3552 5 Novatiani Novatiani NNP 19613 3552 6 se se NNP 19613 3552 7 adsertores adsertore NNS 19613 3552 8 evangelii evangelii VBP 19613 3552 9 et et NNP 19613 3552 10 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3552 11 esse esse NNP 19613 3552 12 confitentur confitentur NNP 19613 3552 13 " " '' 19613 3552 14 ; ; : 19613 3552 15 46 46 CD 19613 3552 16 . . . 19613 3553 1 2 2 LS 19613 3553 2 : : : 19613 3553 3 " " `` 19613 3553 4 nec nec NNP 19613 3553 5 putetis putetis NNP 19613 3553 6 , , , 19613 3553 7 sic sic VBP 19613 3553 8 vos vos JJ 19613 3553 9 evangelium evangelium NN 19613 3553 10 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3553 11 adserere adserere NN 19613 3553 12 " " '' 19613 3553 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3553 14 . . . 19613 3554 1 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 3554 2 in in IN 19613 3554 3 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 3554 4 , , , 19613 3554 5 H. H. NNP 19613 3554 6 E. E. NNP 19613 3554 7 VI VI NNP 19613 3554 8 . . . 19613 3555 1 43 43 CD 19613 3555 2 . . . 19613 3556 1 II II NNP 19613 3556 2 calls call VBZ 19613 3556 3 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3556 4 : : : 19613 3556 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3556 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3556 7 : : : 19613 3556 8 ho ho NNP 19613 3556 9 ekdikêtês ekdikêtês NNP 19613 3556 10 tou tou NNP 19613 3556 11 euangeliou euangeliou NNP 19613 3556 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3556 13 . . . 19613 3557 1 This this DT 19613 3557 2 is be VBZ 19613 3557 3 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 3557 4 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3557 5 , , , 19613 3557 6 and and CC 19613 3557 7 all all PDT 19613 3557 8 the the DT 19613 3557 9 more more RBR 19613 3557 10 so so RB 19613 3557 11 when when WRB 19613 3557 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3557 13 note note VBP 19613 3557 14 that that IN 19613 3557 15 , , , 19613 3557 16 even even RB 19613 3557 17 as as IN 19613 3557 18 far far RB 19613 3557 19 back back RB 19613 3557 20 as as IN 19613 3557 21 the the DT 19613 3557 22 end end NN 19613 3557 23 of of IN 19613 3557 24 the the DT 19613 3557 25 second second JJ 19613 3557 26 century century NN 19613 3557 27 , , , 19613 3557 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3557 29 was be VBD 19613 3557 30 not not RB 19613 3557 31 the the DT 19613 3557 32 " " `` 19613 3557 33 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3557 34 , , , 19613 3557 35 " " '' 19613 3557 36 but but CC 19613 3557 37 the the DT 19613 3557 38 lax lax NN 19613 3557 39 , , , 19613 3557 40 who who WP 19613 3557 41 declared declare VBD 19613 3557 42 the the DT 19613 3557 43 claims claim NNS 19613 3557 44 of of IN 19613 3557 45 the the DT 19613 3557 46 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3557 47 to to TO 19613 3557 48 be be VB 19613 3557 49 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 3557 50 if if IN 19613 3557 51 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3557 52 kept keep VBD 19613 3557 53 God God NNP 19613 3557 54 in in IN 19613 3557 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3557 56 hearts heart NNS 19613 3557 57 , , , 19613 3557 58 but but CC 19613 3557 59 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 3557 60 lived live VBD 19613 3557 61 in in IN 19613 3557 62 entire entire JJ 19613 3557 63 conformity conformity NN 19613 3557 64 with with IN 19613 3557 65 the the DT 19613 3557 66 world world NN 19613 3557 67 . . . 19613 3558 1 See see VB 19613 3558 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3558 3 , , , 19613 3558 4 de de NNP 19613 3558 5 spec spec NNP 19613 3558 6 . . . 19613 3559 1 1 1 LS 19613 3559 2 ; ; : 19613 3559 3 de de NNP 19613 3559 4 pænit pænit NNP 19613 3559 5 . . . 19613 3560 1 5 5 CD 19613 3560 2 : : : 19613 3560 3 " " `` 19613 3560 4 Sed Sed NNP 19613 3560 5 aiunt aiunt NN 19613 3560 6 quidam quidam NNP 19613 3560 7 , , , 19613 3560 8 satis satis NNP 19613 3560 9 deum deum NNP 19613 3560 10 habere habere NNP 19613 3560 11 , , , 19613 3560 12 si si NNP 19613 3560 13 corde corde NNP 19613 3560 14 et et NNP 19613 3560 15 animo animo NNP 19613 3560 16 suspiciatur suspiciatur NNP 19613 3560 17 , , , 19613 3560 18 licet licet NN 19613 3560 19 actu actu NNP 19613 3560 20 minus minus CC 19613 3560 21 fiat fiat NNP 19613 3560 22 ; ; , 19613 3560 23 itaque itaque NNP 19613 3560 24 se se NNP 19613 3560 25 salvo salvo NNP 19613 3560 26 metu metu JJ 19613 3560 27 et et NNP 19613 3560 28 fide fide NNP 19613 3560 29 peccare peccare NNP 19613 3560 30 , , , 19613 3560 31 hoc hoc FW 19613 3560 32 est est NNP 19613 3560 33 salva salva NNP 19613 3560 34 castitate castitate NNP 19613 3560 35 matrimonia matrimonia NNP 19613 3560 36 violare violare NNP 19613 3560 37 etc etc FW 19613 3560 38 . . . 19613 3561 1 " " `` 19613 3561 2 : : : 19613 3561 3 de de NNP 19613 3561 4 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3561 5 . . . 19613 3562 1 2 2 LS 19613 3562 2 : : : 19613 3562 3 " " `` 19613 3562 4 Et et NN 19613 3562 5 scimus scimus NN 19613 3562 6 , , , 19613 3562 7 quales quales NNP 19613 3562 8 sint sint NNP 19613 3562 9 carnalium carnalium NNP 19613 3562 10 commodorum commodorum NNP 19613 3562 11 suasoriæ suasoriæ NNP 19613 3562 12 , , , 19613 3562 13 quam quam NNP 19613 3562 14 facile facile NNP 19613 3562 15 dicatur dicatur NNP 19613 3562 16 : : : 19613 3562 17 Opus opus NN 19613 3562 18 est est NN 19613 3562 19 de de IN 19613 3562 20 totis totis NN 19613 3562 21 præcordiis præcordiis NNP 19613 3562 22 credam credam NNP 19613 3562 23 , , , 19613 3562 24 diligam diligam NNP 19613 3562 25 deum deum NNP 19613 3562 26 et et NNP 19613 3562 27 proximum proximum NN 19613 3562 28 tanquam tanquam VB 19613 3562 29 me -PRON- PRP 19613 3562 30 . . . 19613 3563 1 In in IN 19613 3563 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3563 3 enim enim JJ 19613 3563 4 duobus duobus NNP 19613 3563 5 præceptis præceptis NNP 19613 3563 6 tota tota NNP 19613 3563 7 lex lex NNP 19613 3563 8 pendet pendet NNP 19613 3563 9 et et NNP 19613 3563 10 prophetæ prophetæ NNP 19613 3563 11 , , , 19613 3563 12 non non JJ 19613 3563 13 in in IN 19613 3563 14 pulmonum pulmonum JJ 19613 3563 15 et et FW 19613 3563 16 intestinorum intestinorum NNP 19613 3563 17 meorum meorum NNP 19613 3563 18 inanitate inanitate NN 19613 3563 19 . . . 19613 3563 20 " " '' 19613 3564 1 The the DT 19613 3564 2 Valentinian Valentinian NNP 19613 3564 3 Heracleon Heracleon NNP 19613 3564 4 was be VBD 19613 3564 5 similarly similarly RB 19613 3564 6 understood understand VBN 19613 3564 7 , , , 19613 3564 8 see see VB 19613 3564 9 above above IN 19613 3564 10 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3564 11 . . . 19613 3565 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3565 2 p. p. NN 19613 3566 1 262 262 CD 19613 3566 2 . . . 19613 3566 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3567 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3567 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3567 3 249 249 CD 19613 3567 4 : : : 19613 3567 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3567 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3567 7 de de FW 19613 3567 8 pud pud NNP 19613 3567 9 . . . 19613 3568 1 22 22 CD 19613 3568 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3568 3 had have VBD 19613 3568 4 already already RB 19613 3568 5 protested protest VBN 19613 3568 6 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 3568 7 against against IN 19613 3568 8 such such JJ 19613 3568 9 injustice injustice NN 19613 3568 10 . . . 19613 3568 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3569 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3569 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3569 3 250 250 CD 19613 3569 4 : : : 19613 3569 5 From from IN 19613 3569 6 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 3569 7 ' ' POS 19613 3569 8 Ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 3569 9 History history NN 19613 3569 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3569 11 can can MD 19613 3569 12 form form VB 19613 3569 13 a a DT 19613 3569 14 good good JJ 19613 3569 15 idea idea NN 19613 3569 16 of of IN 19613 3569 17 the the DT 19613 3569 18 state state NN 19613 3569 19 of of IN 19613 3569 20 the the DT 19613 3569 21 Novatian novatian JJ 19613 3569 22 communities community NNS 19613 3569 23 in in IN 19613 3569 24 Constantinople Constantinople NNP 19613 3569 25 and and CC 19613 3569 26 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3569 27 Minor Minor NNP 19613 3569 28 . . . 19613 3570 1 On on IN 19613 3570 2 the the DT 19613 3570 3 later later JJ 19613 3570 4 history history NN 19613 3570 5 of of IN 19613 3570 6 the the DT 19613 3570 7 Catharist Catharist NNP 19613 3570 8 Church Church NNP 19613 3570 9 see see VBP 19613 3570 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3570 11 article article NN 19613 3570 12 " " `` 19613 3570 13 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3570 14 , , , 19613 3570 15 " " '' 19613 3570 16 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3570 17 . . NNP 19613 3570 18 , , , 19613 3570 19 667 667 CD 19613 3570 20 ff ff NN 19613 3570 21 . . . 19613 3571 1 The the DT 19613 3571 2 most most RBS 19613 3571 3 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3571 4 feature feature NN 19613 3571 5 of of IN 19613 3571 6 this this DT 19613 3571 7 history history NN 19613 3571 8 is be VBZ 19613 3571 9 the the DT 19613 3571 10 amalgamation amalgamation NN 19613 3571 11 of of IN 19613 3571 12 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3571 13 's 's POS 19613 3571 14 adherents adherent NNS 19613 3571 15 in in IN 19613 3571 16 Asia Asia NNP 19613 3571 17 Minor Minor NNP 19613 3571 18 with with IN 19613 3571 19 the the DT 19613 3571 20 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 3571 21 and and CC 19613 3571 22 the the DT 19613 3571 23 absence absence NN 19613 3571 24 of of IN 19613 3571 25 distinction distinction NN 19613 3571 26 between between IN 19613 3571 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3571 28 manner manner NN 19613 3571 29 of of IN 19613 3571 30 life life NN 19613 3571 31 and and CC 19613 3571 32 that that DT 19613 3571 33 of of IN 19613 3571 34 the the DT 19613 3571 35 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 3571 36 . . . 19613 3572 1 In in IN 19613 3572 2 the the DT 19613 3572 3 4th 4th JJ 19613 3572 4 century century NN 19613 3572 5 of of IN 19613 3572 6 course course NN 19613 3572 7 the the DT 19613 3572 8 Novatians Novatians NNPS 19613 3572 9 were be VBD 19613 3572 10 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 3572 11 very very RB 19613 3572 12 bitterly bitterly RB 19613 3572 13 attacked attack VBN 19613 3572 14 . . . 19613 3572 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3573 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3573 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3573 3 251 251 CD 19613 3573 4 : : : 19613 3573 5 This this DT 19613 3573 6 indeed indeed RB 19613 3573 7 was be VBD 19613 3573 8 disputed dispute VBN 19613 3573 9 by by IN 19613 3573 10 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3573 11 and and CC 19613 3573 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3573 13 . . . 19613 3573 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3574 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3574 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3574 3 252 252 CD 19613 3574 4 : : : 19613 3574 5 This this DT 19613 3574 6 last last JJ 19613 3574 7 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 3574 8 was be VBD 19613 3574 9 come come VBN 19613 3574 10 to to IN 19613 3574 11 after after IN 19613 3574 12 painful painful JJ 19613 3574 13 scruples scruple NNS 19613 3574 14 , , , 19613 3574 15 particularly particularly RB 19613 3574 16 in in IN 19613 3574 17 the the DT 19613 3574 18 East East NNP 19613 3574 19 -- -- : 19613 3574 20 as as IN 19613 3574 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3574 22 may may MD 19613 3574 23 learn learn VB 19613 3574 24 from from IN 19613 3574 25 the the DT 19613 3574 26 6th 6th JJ 19613 3574 27 and and CC 19613 3574 28 7th 7th JJ 19613 3574 29 books book NNS 19613 3574 30 of of IN 19613 3574 31 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 3574 32 ' ' POS 19613 3574 33 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 3574 34 History history NN 19613 3574 35 . . . 19613 3575 1 For for IN 19613 3575 2 a a DT 19613 3575 3 time time NN 19613 3575 4 the the DT 19613 3575 5 majority majority NN 19613 3575 6 of of IN 19613 3575 7 the the DT 19613 3575 8 Oriental oriental JJ 19613 3575 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3575 10 adopted adopt VBD 19613 3575 11 an an DT 19613 3575 12 attitude attitude NN 19613 3575 13 favourable favourable JJ 19613 3575 14 to to IN 19613 3575 15 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3575 16 and and CC 19613 3575 17 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 19613 3575 18 to to IN 19613 3575 19 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 3575 20 and and CC 19613 3575 21 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3575 22 . . . 19613 3576 1 Then then RB 19613 3576 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3576 3 espoused espouse VBD 19613 3576 4 the the DT 19613 3576 5 cause cause NN 19613 3576 6 of of IN 19613 3576 7 the the DT 19613 3576 8 latter latter JJ 19613 3576 9 , , , 19613 3576 10 though though IN 19613 3576 11 without without IN 19613 3576 12 adopting adopt VBG 19613 3576 13 the the DT 19613 3576 14 milder milder NN 19613 3576 15 discipline discipline NN 19613 3576 16 in in IN 19613 3576 17 all all DT 19613 3576 18 cases case NNS 19613 3576 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3576 20 see see VB 19613 3576 21 the the DT 19613 3576 22 canons canon NNS 19613 3576 23 of of IN 19613 3576 24 Ancyra Ancyra NNP 19613 3576 25 and and CC 19613 3576 26 Neocæsarea Neocæsarea NNP 19613 3576 27 IV IV NNP 19613 3576 28 . . . 19613 3577 1 sæc sæc NNP 19613 3577 2 . . . 19613 3578 1 init init NNP 19613 3578 2 . . . 19613 3578 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3578 4 . . . 19613 3579 1 Throughout throughout IN 19613 3579 2 the the DT 19613 3579 3 East East NNP 19613 3579 4 the the DT 19613 3579 5 whole whole JJ 19613 3579 6 question question NN 19613 3579 7 became become VBD 19613 3579 8 involved involved JJ 19613 3579 9 in in IN 19613 3579 10 confusion confusion NN 19613 3579 11 , , , 19613 3579 12 and and CC 19613 3579 13 was be VBD 19613 3579 14 not not RB 19613 3579 15 decided decide VBN 19613 3579 16 in in IN 19613 3579 17 accordance accordance NN 19613 3579 18 with with IN 19613 3579 19 clear clear JJ 19613 3579 20 principles principle NNS 19613 3579 21 . . . 19613 3580 1 In in IN 19613 3580 2 giving give VBG 19613 3580 3 up up RP 19613 3580 4 the the DT 19613 3580 5 last last JJ 19613 3580 6 remnant remnant NN 19613 3580 7 of of IN 19613 3580 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3580 9 exclusiveness exclusiveness NN 19613 3580 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3580 11 the the DT 19613 3580 12 canons canon NNS 19613 3580 13 of of IN 19613 3580 14 Elvira Elvira NNP 19613 3580 15 are be VBP 19613 3580 16 still still RB 19613 3580 17 very very RB 19613 3580 18 strict strict JJ 19613 3580 19 while while IN 19613 3580 20 those those DT 19613 3580 21 of of IN 19613 3580 22 Arles arle NNS 19613 3580 23 are be VBP 19613 3580 24 lax lax JJ 19613 3580 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3580 26 , , , 19613 3580 27 the the DT 19613 3580 28 Church Church NNP 19613 3580 29 became become VBD 19613 3580 30 " " `` 19613 3580 31 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3580 32 " " '' 19613 3580 33 in in IN 19613 3580 34 quite quite PDT 19613 3580 35 a a DT 19613 3580 36 special special JJ 19613 3580 37 sense sense NN 19613 3580 38 , , , 19613 3580 39 in in IN 19613 3580 40 other other JJ 19613 3580 41 words word NNS 19613 3580 42 , , , 19613 3580 43 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3580 44 became become VBD 19613 3580 45 a a DT 19613 3580 46 community community NN 19613 3580 47 where where WRB 19613 3580 48 everyone everyone NN 19613 3580 49 could could MD 19613 3580 50 find find VB 19613 3580 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3580 52 place place NN 19613 3580 53 , , , 19613 3580 54 provided provide VBN 19613 3580 55 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3580 56 submitted submit VBD 19613 3580 57 to to IN 19613 3580 58 certain certain JJ 19613 3580 59 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3580 60 and and CC 19613 3580 61 rules rule NNS 19613 3580 62 . . . 19613 3581 1 Then then RB 19613 3581 2 , , , 19613 3581 3 and and CC 19613 3581 4 not not RB 19613 3581 5 till till IN 19613 3581 6 then then RB 19613 3581 7 , , , 19613 3581 8 was be VBD 19613 3581 9 the the DT 19613 3581 10 Church Church NNP 19613 3581 11 's 's POS 19613 3581 12 pre pre JJ 19613 3581 13 - - JJ 19613 3581 14 eminent eminent JJ 19613 3581 15 importance importance NN 19613 3581 16 for for IN 19613 3581 17 society society NN 19613 3581 18 and and CC 19613 3581 19 the the DT 19613 3581 20 state state NN 19613 3581 21 assured assure VBD 19613 3581 22 . . . 19613 3582 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3582 2 was be VBD 19613 3582 3 no no RB 19613 3582 4 longer long RBR 19613 3582 5 variance variance NN 19613 3582 6 , , , 19613 3582 7 and and CC 19613 3582 8 no no RB 19613 3582 9 longer long RBR 19613 3582 10 the the DT 19613 3582 11 sword sword NN 19613 3582 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3582 13 Matt Matt NNP 19613 3582 14 . . . 19613 3583 1 X. X. NNP 19613 3584 1 34 34 CD 19613 3584 2 , , , 19613 3584 3 35 35 CD 19613 3584 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3584 5 , , , 19613 3584 6 but but CC 19613 3584 7 peace peace NN 19613 3584 8 and and CC 19613 3584 9 safety safety NN 19613 3584 10 that that WDT 19613 3584 11 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3584 12 brought bring VBD 19613 3584 13 ; ; : 19613 3584 14 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3584 15 was be VBD 19613 3584 16 now now RB 19613 3584 17 capable capable JJ 19613 3584 18 of of IN 19613 3584 19 becoming become VBG 19613 3584 20 an an DT 19613 3584 21 educative educative NN 19613 3584 22 or or CC 19613 3584 23 , , , 19613 3584 24 since since IN 19613 3584 25 there there EX 19613 3584 26 was be VBD 19613 3584 27 little little RB 19613 3584 28 more more JJR 19613 3584 29 to to TO 19613 3584 30 educate educate VB 19613 3584 31 in in IN 19613 3584 32 the the DT 19613 3584 33 older old JJR 19613 3584 34 society society NN 19613 3584 35 , , , 19613 3584 36 a a DT 19613 3584 37 conservative conservative JJ 19613 3584 38 power power NN 19613 3584 39 . . . 19613 3585 1 At at IN 19613 3585 2 an an DT 19613 3585 3 earlier early JJR 19613 3585 4 date date NN 19613 3585 5 the the DT 19613 3585 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 3585 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3585 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 3585 9 , , , 19613 3585 10 Melito Melito NNP 19613 3585 11 , , , 19613 3585 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3585 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3585 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3585 15 had have VBD 19613 3585 16 already already RB 19613 3585 17 extolled extoll VBN 19613 3585 18 her -PRON- PRP 19613 3585 19 as as RB 19613 3585 20 such such JJ 19613 3585 21 , , , 19613 3585 22 but but CC 19613 3585 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3585 24 was be VBD 19613 3585 25 not not RB 19613 3585 26 till till IN 19613 3585 27 now now RB 19613 3585 28 that that IN 19613 3585 29 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3585 30 really really RB 19613 3585 31 possessed possess VBD 19613 3585 32 this this DT 19613 3585 33 capacity capacity NN 19613 3585 34 . . . 19613 3586 1 Among among IN 19613 3586 2 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3586 3 , , , 19613 3586 4 first first RB 19613 3586 5 the the DT 19613 3586 6 Encratites Encratites NNPS 19613 3586 7 and and CC 19613 3586 8 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 3586 9 , , , 19613 3586 10 next next IN 19613 3586 11 the the DT 19613 3586 12 adherents adherent NNS 19613 3586 13 of of IN 19613 3586 14 the the DT 19613 3586 15 new new JJ 19613 3586 16 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 3586 17 , , , 19613 3586 18 and and CC 19613 3586 19 lastly lastly RB 19613 3586 20 the the DT 19613 3586 21 Novatians Novatians NNPS 19613 3586 22 had have VBD 19613 3586 23 by by IN 19613 3586 24 turns turn NNS 19613 3586 25 opposed oppose VBN 19613 3586 26 the the DT 19613 3586 27 naturalisation naturalisation NN 19613 3586 28 of of IN 19613 3586 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3586 30 religion religion NN 19613 3586 31 in in IN 19613 3586 32 the the DT 19613 3586 33 world world NN 19613 3586 34 and and CC 19613 3586 35 the the DT 19613 3586 36 transformation transformation NN 19613 3586 37 of of IN 19613 3586 38 the the DT 19613 3586 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3586 40 into into IN 19613 3586 41 a a DT 19613 3586 42 political political JJ 19613 3586 43 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 3586 44 . . . 19613 3587 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3587 2 demands demand NNS 19613 3587 3 had have VBD 19613 3587 4 progressively progressively RB 19613 3587 5 become become VBN 19613 3587 6 less less RBR 19613 3587 7 exacting exacting JJ 19613 3587 8 , , , 19613 3587 9 whence whence NN 19613 3587 10 also also RB 19613 3587 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3587 12 internal internal JJ 19613 3587 13 vigour vigour NN 19613 3587 14 had have VBD 19613 3587 15 grown grow VBN 19613 3587 16 ever ever RB 19613 3587 17 weaker weak JJR 19613 3587 18 . . . 19613 3588 1 But but CC 19613 3588 2 , , , 19613 3588 3 in in IN 19613 3588 4 view view NN 19613 3588 5 of of IN 19613 3588 6 the the DT 19613 3588 7 continuous continuous JJ 19613 3588 8 secularising secularising NN 19613 3588 9 of of IN 19613 3588 10 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 3588 11 , , , 19613 3588 12 the the DT 19613 3588 13 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3588 14 demands demand NNS 19613 3588 15 at at IN 19613 3588 16 the the DT 19613 3588 17 beginning beginning NN 19613 3588 18 of of IN 19613 3588 19 the the DT 19613 3588 20 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3588 21 century century NN 19613 3588 22 already already RB 19613 3588 23 denoted denote VBD 19613 3588 24 no no DT 19613 3588 25 less less JJR 19613 3588 26 than than IN 19613 3588 27 those those DT 19613 3588 28 of of IN 19613 3588 29 the the DT 19613 3588 30 Encratites Encratites NNPS 19613 3588 31 about about IN 19613 3588 32 the the DT 19613 3588 33 middle middle NN 19613 3588 34 of of IN 19613 3588 35 the the DT 19613 3588 36 second second JJ 19613 3588 37 , , , 19613 3588 38 and and CC 19613 3588 39 no no DT 19613 3588 40 more more JJR 19613 3588 41 than than IN 19613 3588 42 those those DT 19613 3588 43 of of IN 19613 3588 44 the the DT 19613 3588 45 Novatians Novatians NNPS 19613 3588 46 about about IN 19613 3588 47 the the DT 19613 3588 48 middle middle NN 19613 3588 49 of of IN 19613 3588 50 the the DT 19613 3588 51 third third JJ 19613 3588 52 . . . 19613 3589 1 The the DT 19613 3589 2 Church Church NNP 19613 3589 3 resolutely resolutely RB 19613 3589 4 declared declare VBD 19613 3589 5 war war NN 19613 3589 6 on on IN 19613 3589 7 all all PDT 19613 3589 8 these these DT 19613 3589 9 attempts attempt NNS 19613 3589 10 to to TO 19613 3589 11 elevate elevate VB 19613 3589 12 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3589 13 perfection perfection NN 19613 3589 14 to to IN 19613 3589 15 an an DT 19613 3589 16 inflexible inflexible JJ 19613 3589 17 law law NN 19613 3589 18 for for IN 19613 3589 19 all all DT 19613 3589 20 , , , 19613 3589 21 and and CC 19613 3589 22 overthrew overthrow VBD 19613 3589 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3589 24 opponents opponent NNS 19613 3589 25 . . . 19613 3590 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 3590 2 pressed press VBD 19613 3590 3 on on RP 19613 3590 4 in in IN 19613 3590 5 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3590 6 world world NN 19613 3590 7 - - HYPH 19613 3590 8 wide wide JJ 19613 3590 9 mission mission NN 19613 3590 10 and and CC 19613 3590 11 appeased appease VBD 19613 3590 12 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3590 13 conscience conscience NN 19613 3590 14 by by IN 19613 3590 15 allowing allow VBG 19613 3590 16 a a DT 19613 3590 17 twofold twofold JJ 19613 3590 18 morality morality NN 19613 3590 19 within within IN 19613 3590 20 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3590 21 bounds bound NNS 19613 3590 22 . . . 19613 3591 1 Thus thus RB 19613 3591 2 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3591 3 created create VBD 19613 3591 4 the the DT 19613 3591 5 conditions condition NNS 19613 3591 6 which which WDT 19613 3591 7 enabled enable VBD 19613 3591 8 the the DT 19613 3591 9 ideal ideal NN 19613 3591 10 of of IN 19613 3591 11 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 3591 12 perfection perfection NN 19613 3591 13 to to TO 19613 3591 14 be be VB 19613 3591 15 realised realise VBN 19613 3591 16 in in IN 19613 3591 17 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3591 18 own own JJ 19613 3591 19 midst midst NN 19613 3591 20 , , , 19613 3591 21 in in IN 19613 3591 22 the the DT 19613 3591 23 form form NN 19613 3591 24 of of IN 19613 3591 25 monasticism monasticism NN 19613 3591 26 , , , 19613 3591 27 without without IN 19613 3591 28 threatening threaten VBG 19613 3591 29 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3591 30 existence existence NN 19613 3591 31 . . . 19613 3592 1 " " `` 19613 3592 2 What what WP 19613 3592 3 is be VBZ 19613 3592 4 monasticism monasticism NN 19613 3592 5 but but CC 19613 3592 6 an an DT 19613 3592 7 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 3592 8 institution institution NN 19613 3592 9 that that WDT 19613 3592 10 makes make VBZ 19613 3592 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3592 12 possible possible JJ 19613 3592 13 to to TO 19613 3592 14 separate separate VB 19613 3592 15 oneself oneself PRP 19613 3592 16 from from IN 19613 3592 17 the the DT 19613 3592 18 world world NN 19613 3592 19 and and CC 19613 3592 20 to to TO 19613 3592 21 remain remain VB 19613 3592 22 in in IN 19613 3592 23 the the DT 19613 3592 24 Church Church NNP 19613 3592 25 , , , 19613 3592 26 to to TO 19613 3592 27 separate separate VB 19613 3592 28 oneself oneself PRP 19613 3592 29 from from IN 19613 3592 30 the the DT 19613 3592 31 outward outward JJ 19613 3592 32 Church Church NNP 19613 3592 33 without without IN 19613 3592 34 renouncing renounce VBG 19613 3592 35 her -PRON- PRP 19613 3592 36 , , , 19613 3592 37 to to TO 19613 3592 38 set set VB 19613 3592 39 oneself oneself PRP 19613 3592 40 apart apart RB 19613 3592 41 for for IN 19613 3592 42 purposes purpose NNS 19613 3592 43 of of IN 19613 3592 44 sanctification sanctification NN 19613 3592 45 and and CC 19613 3592 46 yet yet RB 19613 3592 47 to to TO 19613 3592 48 claim claim VB 19613 3592 49 the the DT 19613 3592 50 highest high JJS 19613 3592 51 rank rank NN 19613 3592 52 among among IN 19613 3592 53 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3592 54 members member NNS 19613 3592 55 , , , 19613 3592 56 to to TO 19613 3592 57 form form VB 19613 3592 58 a a DT 19613 3592 59 brotherhood brotherhood NN 19613 3592 60 and and CC 19613 3592 61 yet yet RB 19613 3592 62 to to TO 19613 3592 63 further further VB 19613 3592 64 the the DT 19613 3592 65 interests interest NNS 19613 3592 66 of of IN 19613 3592 67 the the DT 19613 3592 68 Church Church NNP 19613 3592 69 ? ? . 19613 3592 70 " " '' 19613 3593 1 In in IN 19613 3593 2 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 3593 3 times time NNS 19613 3593 4 great great JJ 19613 3593 5 Church Church NNP 19613 3593 6 movements movement NNS 19613 3593 7 , , , 19613 3593 8 such such JJ 19613 3593 9 as as IN 19613 3593 10 the the DT 19613 3593 11 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 3593 12 and and CC 19613 3593 13 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3593 14 , , , 19613 3593 15 only only RB 19613 3593 16 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 3593 17 in in IN 19613 3593 18 attaining attain VBG 19613 3593 19 local local JJ 19613 3593 20 or or CC 19613 3593 21 provincial provincial JJ 19613 3593 22 importance importance NN 19613 3593 23 . . . 19613 3594 1 See see VB 19613 3594 2 the the DT 19613 3594 3 movement movement NN 19613 3594 4 at at IN 19613 3594 5 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3594 6 at at IN 19613 3594 7 the the DT 19613 3594 8 beginning beginning NN 19613 3594 9 of of IN 19613 3594 10 the the DT 19613 3594 11 4th 4th JJ 19613 3594 12 century century NN 19613 3594 13 , , , 19613 3594 14 of of IN 19613 3594 15 which which WDT 19613 3594 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3594 17 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 3594 18 know know VBP 19613 3594 19 so so RB 19613 3594 20 little little JJ 19613 3594 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3594 22 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 19613 3594 23 , , , 19613 3594 24 Chronologie Chronologie NNP 19613 3594 25 der der VBP 19613 3594 26 römischen römischen NNP 19613 3594 27 Bischofe Bischofe NNP 19613 3594 28 , , , 19613 3594 29 pp pp NNP 19613 3594 30 . . . 19613 3595 1 250 250 CD 19613 3595 2 - - SYM 19613 3595 3 255 255 CD 19613 3595 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3595 5 , , , 19613 3595 6 the the DT 19613 3595 7 Donatist Donatist NNP 19613 3595 8 Revolution Revolution NNP 19613 3595 9 , , , 19613 3595 10 and and CC 19613 3595 11 the the DT 19613 3595 12 Audiani Audiani NNP 19613 3595 13 in in IN 19613 3595 14 the the DT 19613 3595 15 East East NNP 19613 3595 16 . . . 19613 3595 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3596 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3596 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3596 3 253 253 CD 19613 3596 4 : : : 19613 3596 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3596 6 is be VBZ 19613 3596 7 a a DT 19613 3596 8 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 3596 9 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 3596 10 that that WDT 19613 3596 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3596 12 's 's POS 19613 3596 13 de de NNP 19613 3596 14 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3596 15 . . . 19613 3597 1 does do VBZ 19613 3597 2 _ _ NNP 19613 3597 3 not not RB 19613 3597 4 _ _ NNP 19613 3597 5 assume assume NN 19613 3597 6 that that IN 19613 3597 7 the the DT 19613 3597 8 great great JJ 19613 3597 9 mass mass NN 19613 3597 10 of of IN 19613 3597 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3597 12 possess possess VBP 19613 3597 13 an an DT 19613 3597 14 actual actual JJ 19613 3597 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 3597 16 of of IN 19613 3597 17 the the DT 19613 3597 18 Bible Bible NNP 19613 3597 19 . . . 19613 3597 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3598 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3598 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3598 3 254 254 CD 19613 3598 4 : : : 19613 3598 5 The the DT 19613 3598 6 condition condition NN 19613 3598 7 of of IN 19613 3598 8 the the DT 19613 3598 9 constitution constitution NN 19613 3598 10 of of IN 19613 3598 11 the the DT 19613 3598 12 Church Church NNP 19613 3598 13 about about IN 19613 3598 14 the the DT 19613 3598 15 middle middle NN 19613 3598 16 of of IN 19613 3598 17 the the DT 19613 3598 18 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3598 19 century century NN 19613 3598 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3598 21 in in IN 19613 3598 22 accordance accordance NN 19613 3598 23 with with IN 19613 3598 24 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3598 25 's 's POS 19613 3598 26 epistles epistle NNS 19613 3598 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3598 28 is be VBZ 19613 3598 29 described describe VBN 19613 3598 30 by by IN 19613 3598 31 Otto Otto NNP 19613 3598 32 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 3598 33 , , , 19613 3598 34 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3598 35 . . NNP 19613 3598 36 , , , 19613 3598 37 pp pp NNP 19613 3598 38 . . . 19613 3599 1 142 142 CD 19613 3599 2 - - SYM 19613 3599 3 237 237 CD 19613 3599 4 . . . 19613 3600 1 Parallels parallel NNS 19613 3600 2 to to IN 19613 3600 3 the the DT 19613 3600 4 provincial provincial JJ 19613 3600 5 and and CC 19613 3600 6 communal communal JJ 19613 3600 7 constitution constitution NN 19613 3600 8 of of IN 19613 3600 9 secular secular JJ 19613 3600 10 society society NN 19613 3600 11 are be VBP 19613 3600 12 to to TO 19613 3600 13 be be VB 19613 3600 14 found find VBN 19613 3600 15 throughout throughout IN 19613 3600 16 . . . 19613 3600 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3601 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3601 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3601 3 255 255 CD 19613 3601 4 : : : 19613 3601 5 To to TO 19613 3601 6 how how WRB 19613 3601 7 great great JJ 19613 3601 8 an an DT 19613 3601 9 extent extent NN 19613 3601 10 the the DT 19613 3601 11 Church Church NNP 19613 3601 12 in in IN 19613 3601 13 Decius Decius NNP 19613 3601 14 ' ' POS 19613 3601 15 time time NN 19613 3601 16 was be VBD 19613 3601 17 already already RB 19613 3601 18 a a DT 19613 3601 19 state state NN 19613 3601 20 within within IN 19613 3601 21 the the DT 19613 3601 22 state state NN 19613 3601 23 is be VBZ 19613 3601 24 shown show VBN 19613 3601 25 by by IN 19613 3601 26 a a DT 19613 3601 27 piece piece NN 19613 3601 28 of of IN 19613 3601 29 information information NN 19613 3601 30 given give VBN 19613 3601 31 in in IN 19613 3601 32 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3601 33 's 's POS 19613 3601 34 55th 55th JJ 19613 3601 35 epistle epistle NN 19613 3601 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3601 37 c. c. NNP 19613 3602 1 9 9 CD 19613 3602 2 . . . 19613 3603 1 ): ): LS 19613 3603 2 " " `` 19613 3603 3 Cornelius cornelius NN 19613 3603 4 sedit sedit NN 19613 3603 5 intrepidus intrepidus NN 19613 3603 6 Romæ Romæ NNP 19613 3603 7 in in IN 19613 3603 8 sacerdotali sacerdotali NNP 19613 3603 9 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3603 10 eo eo NNP 19613 3603 11 tempore tempore VBD 19613 3603 12 : : : 19613 3603 13 cum cum NNP 19613 3603 14 tyrannus tyrannus NNP 19613 3603 15 infestus infestus NNP 19613 3603 16 sacerdotibus sacerdotibus NNP 19613 3603 17 dei dei NNP 19613 3603 18 fanda fanda NNP 19613 3603 19 adque adque NNP 19613 3603 20 infanda infanda NNP 19613 3603 21 comminaretur comminaretur NNP 19613 3603 22 , , , 19613 3603 23 cum cum NNP 19613 3603 24 multo multo NNP 19613 3603 25 patientius patientius NNP 19613 3603 26 et et NNP 19613 3603 27 tolerabilius tolerabilius NNP 19613 3603 28 audiret audiret NNP 19613 3603 29 levari levari NNP 19613 3603 30 adversus adversus NNP 19613 3603 31 se se NNP 19613 3603 32 æmulum æmulum NNP 19613 3603 33 principem principem NNP 19613 3603 34 quam quam NNP 19613 3603 35 constitui constitui NNS 19613 3603 36 Romæ Romæ NNP 19613 3603 37 dei dei NNP 19613 3603 38 sacerdotem sacerdotem NN 19613 3603 39 . . . 19613 3603 40 " " '' 19613 3604 1 On on IN 19613 3604 2 the the DT 19613 3604 3 other other JJ 19613 3604 4 hand hand NN 19613 3604 5 the the DT 19613 3604 6 legislation legislation NN 19613 3604 7 with with IN 19613 3604 8 regard regard NN 19613 3604 9 to to IN 19613 3604 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 3604 11 flamens flamen NNS 19613 3604 12 adopted adopt VBN 19613 3604 13 by by IN 19613 3604 14 the the DT 19613 3604 15 Council Council NNP 19613 3604 16 of of IN 19613 3604 17 Elvira Elvira NNP 19613 3604 18 , , , 19613 3604 19 which which WDT 19613 3604 20 , , , 19613 3604 21 as as IN 19613 3604 22 Duchesne Duchesne NNP 19613 3604 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3604 24 Mélanges Mélanges NNPS 19613 3604 25 Renier Renier NNP 19613 3604 26 : : : 19613 3604 27 Le Le NNP 19613 3604 28 Concile Concile NNP 19613 3604 29 d'Elvire d'Elvire NNP 19613 3604 30 et et FW 19613 3604 31 les les FW 19613 3604 32 flamines flamines NNP 19613 3604 33 chrétiens chrétien VBZ 19613 3604 34 , , , 19613 3604 35 1886 1886 CD 19613 3604 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3604 37 has have VBZ 19613 3604 38 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 19613 3604 39 , , , 19613 3604 40 most most RBS 19613 3604 41 probably probably RB 19613 3604 42 dates date VBZ 19613 3604 43 from from IN 19613 3604 44 before before IN 19613 3604 45 the the DT 19613 3604 46 Diocletian diocletian JJ 19613 3604 47 persecution persecution NN 19613 3604 48 of of IN 19613 3604 49 300 300 CD 19613 3604 50 , , , 19613 3604 51 shows show VBZ 19613 3604 52 how how WRB 19613 3604 53 closely closely RB 19613 3604 54 the the DT 19613 3604 55 discipline discipline NN 19613 3604 56 of of IN 19613 3604 57 the the DT 19613 3604 58 Church Church NNP 19613 3604 59 had have VBD 19613 3604 60 already already RB 19613 3604 61 been be VBN 19613 3604 62 adapted adapt VBN 19613 3604 63 to to IN 19613 3604 64 the the DT 19613 3604 65 heathen heathen NNP 19613 3604 66 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3604 67 in in IN 19613 3604 68 the the DT 19613 3604 69 Empire empire NN 19613 3604 70 . . . 19613 3605 1 In in IN 19613 3605 2 addition addition NN 19613 3605 3 to to IN 19613 3605 4 this this DT 19613 3605 5 there there EX 19613 3605 6 was be VBD 19613 3605 7 no no DT 19613 3605 8 lack lack NN 19613 3605 9 of of IN 19613 3605 10 syncretist syncretist JJ 19613 3605 11 systems system NNS 19613 3605 12 within within IN 19613 3605 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3605 14 as as RB 19613 3605 15 early early RB 19613 3605 16 as as IN 19613 3605 17 the the DT 19613 3605 18 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3605 19 century century NN 19613 3605 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3605 21 see see VB 19613 3605 22 the the DT 19613 3605 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3605 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3605 25 : : : 19613 3605 26 Kestoi Kestoi NNP 19613 3605 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3605 28 of of IN 19613 3605 29 Julius Julius NNP 19613 3605 30 Africanus Africanus NNP 19613 3605 31 , , , 19613 3605 32 and and CC 19613 3605 33 other other JJ 19613 3605 34 examples example NNS 19613 3605 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3605 36 . . . 19613 3606 1 Much much JJ 19613 3606 2 information information NN 19613 3606 3 on on IN 19613 3606 4 this this DT 19613 3606 5 point point NN 19613 3606 6 is be VBZ 19613 3606 7 to to TO 19613 3606 8 be be VB 19613 3606 9 derived derive VBN 19613 3606 10 from from IN 19613 3606 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3606 12 's 's POS 19613 3606 13 works work NNS 19613 3606 14 and and CC 19613 3606 15 also also RB 19613 3606 16 , , , 19613 3606 17 in in IN 19613 3606 18 many many JJ 19613 3606 19 respects respect NNS 19613 3606 20 , , , 19613 3606 21 from from IN 19613 3606 22 the the DT 19613 3606 23 attitude attitude NN 19613 3606 24 of of IN 19613 3606 25 this this DT 19613 3606 26 author author NN 19613 3606 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3606 28 . . . 19613 3607 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3607 2 may may MD 19613 3607 3 also also RB 19613 3607 4 refer refer VB 19613 3607 5 to to IN 19613 3607 6 relic- relic- NN 19613 3607 7 and and CC 19613 3607 8 hero hero NN 19613 3607 9 - - HYPH 19613 3607 10 worship worship NN 19613 3607 11 , , , 19613 3607 12 the the DT 19613 3607 13 foundation foundation NN 19613 3607 14 of of IN 19613 3607 15 which which WDT 19613 3607 16 was be VBD 19613 3607 17 already already RB 19613 3607 18 laid lay VBN 19613 3607 19 in in IN 19613 3607 20 the the DT 19613 3607 21 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3607 22 century century NN 19613 3607 23 , , , 19613 3607 24 though though IN 19613 3607 25 the the DT 19613 3607 26 " " `` 19613 3607 27 religion religion NN 19613 3607 28 of of IN 19613 3607 29 the the DT 19613 3607 30 second second JJ 19613 3607 31 order order NN 19613 3607 32 " " '' 19613 3607 33 did do VBD 19613 3607 34 not not RB 19613 3607 35 become become VB 19613 3607 36 a a DT 19613 3607 37 recognised recognise VBN 19613 3607 38 power power NN 19613 3607 39 in in IN 19613 3607 40 the the DT 19613 3607 41 Church Church NNP 19613 3607 42 or or CC 19613 3607 43 force force VB 19613 3607 44 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3607 45 into into IN 19613 3607 46 the the DT 19613 3607 47 official official JJ 19613 3607 48 religion religion NN 19613 3607 49 till till IN 19613 3607 50 the the DT 19613 3607 51 4th 4th NN 19613 3607 52 . . . 19613 3607 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3608 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3608 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3608 3 256 256 CD 19613 3608 4 : : : 19613 3608 5 See see VB 19613 3608 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3608 7 's 's POS 19613 3608 8 frightful frightful JJ 19613 3608 9 accusations accusation NNS 19613 3608 10 in in IN 19613 3608 11 de de NNP 19613 3608 12 pudic pudic JJ 19613 3608 13 . . . 19613 3609 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3609 2 10 10 CD 19613 3609 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3609 4 and and CC 19613 3609 5 de de NNP 19613 3609 6 ieiun ieiun NNP 19613 3609 7 . . . 19613 3610 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3610 2 fin fin NNP 19613 3610 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3610 4 against against IN 19613 3610 5 the the DT 19613 3610 6 " " `` 19613 3610 7 Psychici Psychici NNP 19613 3610 8 " " '' 19613 3610 9 , , , 19613 3610 10 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 3610 11 , , , 19613 3610 12 the the DT 19613 3610 13 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3610 14 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3610 15 . . . 19613 3611 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 3611 2 says say VBZ 19613 3611 3 that that IN 19613 3611 4 with with IN 19613 3611 5 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3611 6 the the DT 19613 3611 7 saying saying NN 19613 3611 8 had have VBD 19613 3611 9 really really RB 19613 3611 10 come come VBN 19613 3611 11 to to TO 19613 3611 12 signify signify VB 19613 3611 13 " " `` 19613 3611 14 peccando peccando NNP 19613 3611 15 promeremur promeremur NNP 19613 3611 16 , , , 19613 3611 17 " " '' 19613 3611 18 by by IN 19613 3611 19 which which WDT 19613 3611 20 , , , 19613 3611 21 however however RB 19613 3611 22 , , , 19613 3611 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3611 24 does do VBZ 19613 3611 25 not not RB 19613 3611 26 mean mean VB 19613 3611 27 the the DT 19613 3611 28 Augustinian Augustinian NNP 19613 3611 29 : : : 19613 3611 30 " " `` 19613 3611 31 o o NNP 19613 3611 32 felix felix NNP 19613 3611 33 culpa culpa NN 19613 3611 34 . . . 19613 3611 35 " " '' 19613 3611 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3612 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3612 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3612 3 257 257 CD 19613 3612 4 : : : 19613 3612 5 The the DT 19613 3612 6 relation relation NN 19613 3612 7 of of IN 19613 3612 8 this this DT 19613 3612 9 Church Church NNP 19613 3612 10 to to TO 19613 3612 11 theology theology VB 19613 3612 12 , , , 19613 3612 13 what what WP 19613 3612 14 theology theology NN 19613 3612 15 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3612 16 required require VBD 19613 3612 17 and and CC 19613 3612 18 what what WP 19613 3612 19 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3612 20 rejected reject VBD 19613 3612 21 , , , 19613 3612 22 and and CC 19613 3612 23 , , , 19613 3612 24 moreover moreover RB 19613 3612 25 , , , 19613 3612 26 to to IN 19613 3612 27 what what WDT 19613 3612 28 extent extent NN 19613 3612 29 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3612 30 rejected reject VBD 19613 3612 31 the the DT 19613 3612 32 kind kind NN 19613 3612 33 that that WDT 19613 3612 34 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3612 35 accepted accept VBD 19613 3612 36 may may MD 19613 3612 37 be be VB 19613 3612 38 seen see VBN 19613 3612 39 by by IN 19613 3612 40 reference reference NN 19613 3612 41 to to IN 19613 3612 42 chap chap NNP 19613 3612 43 . . . 19613 3613 1 5 5 CD 19613 3613 2 ff ff NN 19613 3613 3 . . . 19613 3614 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3614 2 may may MD 19613 3614 3 here here RB 19613 3614 4 also also RB 19613 3614 5 direct direct VB 19613 3614 6 attention attention NN 19613 3614 7 to to IN 19613 3614 8 the the DT 19613 3614 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 3614 10 position position NN 19613 3614 11 of of IN 19613 3614 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3614 13 in in IN 19613 3614 14 the the DT 19613 3614 15 Church Church NNP 19613 3614 16 as as RB 19613 3614 17 well well RB 19613 3614 18 as as IN 19613 3614 19 to to IN 19613 3614 20 that that DT 19613 3614 21 of of IN 19613 3614 22 Lucian lucian JJ 19613 3614 23 the the DT 19613 3614 24 Martyr Martyr NNP 19613 3614 25 , , , 19613 3614 26 concerning concern VBG 19613 3614 27 whom whom WP 19613 3614 28 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 3614 29 of of IN 19613 3614 30 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 3614 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3614 32 Theoderet Theoderet NNP 19613 3614 33 , , , 19613 3614 34 H. H. NNP 19613 3614 35 E. E. NNP 19613 3614 36 I. I. NNP 19613 3615 1 3 3 LS 19613 3615 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3615 3 remarks remark VBZ 19613 3615 4 that that IN 19613 3615 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3615 6 was be VBD 19613 3615 7 a a DT 19613 3615 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3615 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3615 10 : : : 19613 3615 11 aposunagôgos aposunagôgos RB 19613 3615 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3615 13 in in IN 19613 3615 14 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 3615 15 for for IN 19613 3615 16 a a DT 19613 3615 17 long long JJ 19613 3615 18 time time NN 19613 3615 19 , , , 19613 3615 20 namely namely RB 19613 3615 21 , , , 19613 3615 22 during during IN 19613 3615 23 the the DT 19613 3615 24 rule rule NN 19613 3615 25 of of IN 19613 3615 26 three three CD 19613 3615 27 successive successive JJ 19613 3615 28 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3615 29 . . . 19613 3615 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3616 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3616 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3616 3 258 258 CD 19613 3616 4 : : : 19613 3616 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3616 6 have have VBP 19613 3616 7 already already RB 19613 3616 8 referred refer VBN 19613 3616 9 to to IN 19613 3616 10 the the DT 19613 3616 11 passage passage NN 19613 3616 12 above above RB 19613 3616 13 . . . 19613 3617 1 On on IN 19613 3617 2 account account NN 19613 3617 3 of of IN 19613 3617 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3617 5 importance importance NN 19613 3617 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3617 7 may may MD 19613 3617 8 quote quote VB 19613 3617 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3617 10 here here RB 19613 3617 11 : : : 19613 3617 12 " " `` 19613 3617 13 According accord VBG 19613 3617 14 to to IN 19613 3617 15 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 3617 16 Apollo Apollo NNP 19613 3617 17 required require VBD 19613 3617 18 the the DT 19613 3617 19 Metapontines Metapontines NNPS 19613 3617 20 to to TO 19613 3617 21 regard regard VB 19613 3617 22 Aristeas aristea NNS 19613 3617 23 as as IN 19613 3617 24 a a DT 19613 3617 25 god god NN 19613 3617 26 ; ; : 19613 3617 27 but but CC 19613 3617 28 in in IN 19613 3617 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3617 30 eyes eye NNS 19613 3617 31 the the DT 19613 3617 32 latter latter NN 19613 3617 33 was be VBD 19613 3617 34 but but CC 19613 3617 35 a a DT 19613 3617 36 man man NN 19613 3617 37 and and CC 19613 3617 38 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 3617 39 not not RB 19613 3617 40 a a DT 19613 3617 41 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 3617 42 one one CD 19613 3617 43 ... ... . 19613 3618 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 3618 2 would would MD 19613 3618 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 3618 4 not not RB 19613 3618 5 obey obey VB 19613 3618 6 Apollo Apollo NNP 19613 3618 7 , , , 19613 3618 8 and and CC 19613 3618 9 thus thus RB 19613 3618 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3618 11 happened happen VBD 19613 3618 12 that that IN 19613 3618 13 no no DT 19613 3618 14 one one NN 19613 3618 15 believed believe VBD 19613 3618 16 in in IN 19613 3618 17 the the DT 19613 3618 18 divinity divinity NN 19613 3618 19 of of IN 19613 3618 20 Aristeas Aristeas NNP 19613 3618 21 . . . 19613 3619 1 But but CC 19613 3619 2 with with IN 19613 3619 3 regard regard NN 19613 3619 4 to to IN 19613 3619 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 3619 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3619 7 may may MD 19613 3619 8 say say VB 19613 3619 9 that that IN 19613 3619 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3619 11 proved prove VBD 19613 3619 12 a a DT 19613 3619 13 blessing blessing NN 19613 3619 14 to to IN 19613 3619 15 the the DT 19613 3619 16 human human JJ 19613 3619 17 race race NN 19613 3619 18 to to TO 19613 3619 19 acknowledge acknowledge VB 19613 3619 20 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3619 21 as as IN 19613 3619 22 the the DT 19613 3619 23 Son Son NNP 19613 3619 24 of of IN 19613 3619 25 God God NNP 19613 3619 26 , , , 19613 3619 27 as as IN 19613 3619 28 God God NNP 19613 3619 29 who who WP 19613 3619 30 appeared appear VBD 19613 3619 31 on on IN 19613 3619 32 earth earth NN 19613 3619 33 united unite VBN 19613 3619 34 with with IN 19613 3619 35 body body NN 19613 3619 36 and and CC 19613 3619 37 soul soul NN 19613 3619 38 . . . 19613 3619 39 " " '' 19613 3620 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3620 2 then then RB 19613 3620 3 says say VBZ 19613 3620 4 that that IN 19613 3620 5 the the DT 19613 3620 6 demons demon NNS 19613 3620 7 counterworked counterworke VBD 19613 3620 8 this this DT 19613 3620 9 belief belief NN 19613 3620 10 , , , 19613 3620 11 and and CC 19613 3620 12 continues continue VBZ 19613 3620 13 : : : 19613 3620 14 " " `` 19613 3620 15 But but CC 19613 3620 16 God God NNP 19613 3620 17 who who WP 19613 3620 18 had have VBD 19613 3620 19 sent send VBN 19613 3620 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 3620 21 on on IN 19613 3620 22 earth earth NN 19613 3620 23 brought bring VBN 19613 3620 24 to to IN 19613 3620 25 nought nought NN 19613 3620 26 all all PDT 19613 3620 27 the the DT 19613 3620 28 snares snare NNS 19613 3620 29 and and CC 19613 3620 30 plots plot NNS 19613 3620 31 of of IN 19613 3620 32 the the DT 19613 3620 33 demons demon NNS 19613 3620 34 and and CC 19613 3620 35 aided aid VBN 19613 3620 36 in in IN 19613 3620 37 the the DT 19613 3620 38 victory victory NN 19613 3620 39 of of IN 19613 3620 40 the the DT 19613 3620 41 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 3620 42 of of IN 19613 3620 43 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 3620 44 throughout throughout IN 19613 3620 45 the the DT 19613 3620 46 whole whole JJ 19613 3620 47 earth earth NN 19613 3620 48 in in IN 19613 3620 49 order order NN 19613 3620 50 to to TO 19613 3620 51 promote promote VB 19613 3620 52 the the DT 19613 3620 53 conversion conversion NN 19613 3620 54 and and CC 19613 3620 55 amelioration amelioration NN 19613 3620 56 of of IN 19613 3620 57 men man NNS 19613 3620 58 ; ; : 19613 3620 59 and and CC 19613 3620 60 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 3620 61 brought bring VBD 19613 3620 62 about about RP 19613 3620 63 the the DT 19613 3620 64 establishment establishment NN 19613 3620 65 of of IN 19613 3620 66 Churches church NNS 19613 3620 67 which which WDT 19613 3620 68 are be VBP 19613 3620 69 ruled rule VBN 19613 3620 70 by by IN 19613 3620 71 other other JJ 19613 3620 72 laws law NNS 19613 3620 73 than than IN 19613 3620 74 those those DT 19613 3620 75 that that WDT 19613 3620 76 regulate regulate VBP 19613 3620 77 the the DT 19613 3620 78 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3620 79 of of IN 19613 3620 80 the the DT 19613 3620 81 superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 3620 82 , , , 19613 3620 83 the the DT 19613 3620 84 dissolute dissolute NN 19613 3620 85 and and CC 19613 3620 86 the the DT 19613 3620 87 unbelieving unbelieving JJ 19613 3620 88 . . . 19613 3621 1 For for IN 19613 3621 2 of of IN 19613 3621 3 such such JJ 19613 3621 4 people people NNS 19613 3621 5 the the DT 19613 3621 6 civil civil JJ 19613 3621 7 population population NN 19613 3621 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3621 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3621 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3621 11 : : : 19613 3621 12 politeuomena politeuomena VB 19613 3621 13 en en IN 19613 3621 14 tais tais NNP 19613 3621 15 ekklêsiais ekklêsiais NNP 19613 3621 16 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3621 17 poleôn poleôn NNP 19613 3621 18 plêthê plêthê NNP 19613 3621 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3621 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3621 21 of of IN 19613 3621 22 the the DT 19613 3621 23 towns town NNS 19613 3621 24 almost almost RB 19613 3621 25 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 3621 26 consists consist VBZ 19613 3621 27 . . . 19613 3621 28 " " '' 19613 3622 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3622 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3622 3 : : : 19613 3622 4 Hai Hai NNP 19613 3622 5 de de NNP 19613 3622 6 tou tou NNP 19613 3622 7 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3622 8 Christô Christô NNP 19613 3622 9 mathêteuthesai mathêteuthesai NNP 19613 3622 10 ekklêsiai ekklêsiai NNP 19613 3622 11 , , , 19613 3622 12 sunezetazomenai sunezetazomenai NNP 19613 3622 13 tais tais NNP 19613 3622 14 ôn ôn NNP 19613 3622 15 paroikousi paroikousi NNP 19613 3622 16 dêmôn dêmôn NNP 19613 3622 17 ekklêsiais ekklêsiais NNP 19613 3622 18 , , , 19613 3622 19 hôs hôs NNP 19613 3622 20 phôtêres phôtêre VBZ 19613 3622 21 eisin eisin NNP 19613 3622 22 en en FW 19613 3622 23 kosmô kosmô FW 19613 3622 24 . . . 19613 3623 1 tis tis NNP 19613 3623 2 gar gar NNP 19613 3623 3 ouk ouk NNP 19613 3623 4 an an DT 19613 3623 5 homologêsai homologêsai NNP 19613 3623 6 , , , 19613 3623 7 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 8 tous tous JJ 19613 3623 9 cheirous cheirous JJ 19613 3623 10 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 11 apo apo NNP 19613 3623 12 tês tês NNP 19613 3623 13 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 14 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 15 sugkrisei sugkrisei NNP 19613 3623 16 beltionôn beltionôn NNP 19613 3623 17 elattous elattous JJ 19613 3623 18 pollô pollô NN 19613 3623 19 kreittous kreittous JJ 19613 3623 20 tugxhanein tugxhanein NNP 19613 3623 21 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 22 en en NNP 19613 3623 23 tois tois NNP 19613 3623 24 demois demois NNP 19613 3623 25 ekklêsiôn ekklêsiôn NNP 19613 3623 26 ; ; : 19613 3623 27 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 3623 28 men man NNS 19613 3623 29 gar gar NNP 19613 3623 30 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 31 theou theou NNP 19613 3623 32 , , , 19613 3623 33 pher pher NNP 19613 3623 34 ' ' `` 19613 3623 35 eipein eipein NNP 19613 3623 36 , , , 19613 3623 37 hê hê NNP 19613 3623 38 Athênaesi Athênaesi NNP 19613 3623 39 praeia praeia NN 19613 3623 40 tis tis NNP 19613 3623 41 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 42 eustathês eustathês NN 19613 3623 43 , , , 19613 3623 44 hate hate VBP 19613 3623 45 Theô Theô NNP 19613 3623 46 areskein areskein NNP 19613 3623 47 tô tô CC 19613 3623 48 epi epi NNP 19613 3623 49 pasi pasi NNP 19613 3623 50 boulomenê boulomenê NN 19613 3623 51 ; ; : 19613 3623 52 hê hê VB 19613 3623 53 d d VBN 19613 3623 54 ' ' '' 19613 3623 55 Athênaiôn Athênaiôn NNP 19613 3623 56 ekklêsia ekklêsia NN 19613 3623 57 stasiôdês stasiôdês NN 19613 3623 58 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 59 oudamôs oudamôs JJ 19613 3623 60 paraballomenê paraballomenê NN 19613 3623 61 tê tê XX 19613 3623 62 ekei ekei NNP 19613 3623 63 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 3623 64 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 65 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3623 66 ; ; : 19613 3623 67 to to IN 19613 3623 68 d d NN 19613 3623 69 ' ' POS 19613 3623 70 auto auto NN 19613 3623 71 ereis ereis NNP 19613 3623 72 , , , 19613 3623 73 peri peri NNP 19613 3623 74 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 75 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 76 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3623 77 tês tês NNP 19613 3623 78 en en IN 19613 3623 79 Korinthô Korinthô NNP 19613 3623 80 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 81 tês tês NNP 19613 3623 82 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 83 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 84 dêmon dêmon NNP 19613 3623 85 Korinthiôn Korinthiôn NNP 19613 3623 86 ; ; : 19613 3623 87 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 88 , , , 19613 3623 89 pher pher NNP 19613 3623 90 ' ' `` 19613 3623 91 eipein eipein NNP 19613 3623 92 , , , 19613 3623 93 peri peri NNP 19613 3623 94 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 95 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 96 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3623 97 tês tês NNP 19613 3623 98 en en NNP 19613 3623 99 Alexandreia Alexandreia NNP 19613 3623 100 , , , 19613 3623 101 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 102 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 103 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 104 Alexandreôn Alexandreôn NNP 19613 3623 105 dêmou dêmou NN 19613 3623 106 , , , 19613 3623 107 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 108 ean ean NNP 19613 3623 109 eugnômôn eugnômôn NNP 19613 3623 110 hê hê NNP 19613 3623 111 ho ho NNP 19613 3623 112 toutou toutou NNP 19613 3623 113 akouôn akouôn NNP 19613 3623 114 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 115 philalêthôs philalêthôs NNP 19613 3623 116 exetazê exetazê NNP 19613 3623 117 ta ta NNP 19613 3623 118 pragmata pragmata NNP 19613 3623 119 , , , 19613 3623 120 thaumasetai thaumasetai NNP 19613 3623 121 ton ton NN 19613 3623 122 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 123 bouleusamenon bouleusamenon NNP 19613 3623 124 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 125 anousai anousai NNP 19613 3623 126 dunêthenta dunêthenta NNP 19613 3623 127 pantachou pantachou NNP 19613 3623 128 sustêsasthai sustêsasthai NNP 19613 3623 129 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 130 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 131 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3623 132 , , , 19613 3623 133 paroikousas paroikousas NNP 19613 3623 134 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 135 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 136 kath kath NNP 19613 3623 137 ' ' '' 19613 3623 138 ' ' '' 19613 3623 139 ekastên ekastên NNP 19613 3623 140 polin polin NNP 19613 3623 141 dêmôn dêmôn NNP 19613 3623 142 houtô houtô NNP 19613 3623 143 de de NNP 19613 3623 144 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 145 boulên boulên NN 19613 3623 146 ekklêsias ekklêsias NN 19613 3623 147 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3623 148 boulê boulê NN 19613 3623 149 tê tê DT 19613 3623 150 kath kath NNP 19613 3623 151 ' ' POS 19613 3623 152 hekastên hekastên NNP 19613 3623 153 polin polin NNP 19613 3623 154 sunexetazôn sunexetazôn NNP 19613 3623 155 heurois heurois NNP 19613 3623 156 an an DT 19613 3623 157 hoti hoti NNP 19613 3623 158 tines tine NNS 19613 3623 159 men men NNPS 19613 3623 160 tês tês NNP 19613 3623 161 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 162 bouleutai bouleutai NNP 19613 3623 163 exioi exioi NNP 19613 3623 164 eisi]--[Greek eisi]--[Greek NNP 19613 3623 165 : : : 19613 3623 166 ei ei NNP 19613 3623 167 tis tis NNP 19613 3623 168 estin estin NNP 19613 3623 169 en en NNP 19613 3623 170 tô tô NNP 19613 3623 171 panti panti NNP 19613 3623 172 polis polis NNP 19613 3623 173 tou tou NNP 19613 3623 174 Theou]--[Greek Theou]--[Greek NNP 19613 3623 175 : : : 19613 3623 176 en en IN 19613 3623 177 ekeinê ekeinê NNP 19613 3623 178 politeuesthai politeuesthai NNP 19613 3623 179 hoi hoi NNP 19613 3623 180 de de FW 19613 3623 181 pantachou pantachou NNP 19613 3623 182 bouleutai bouleutai NNP 19613 3623 183 ouden ouden NNP 19613 3623 184 exion exion NNP 19613 3623 185 tês tês NNP 19613 3623 186 ek ek NNP 19613 3623 187 katataxeôs katataxeôs NNP 19613 3623 188 huperochês huperochês NNP 19613 3623 189 , , , 19613 3623 190 hên hên NNP 19613 3623 191 huperechein huperechein NNP 19613 3623 192 dokousi dokousi NNP 19613 3623 193 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 194 politôn politôn NNP 19613 3623 195 , , , 19613 3623 196 pherousin pherousin NNP 19613 3623 197 en en IN 19613 3623 198 tois tois NNP 19613 3623 199 heautôn heautôn NNP 19613 3623 200 êthesin êthesin JJ 19613 3623 201 ; ; : 19613 3623 202 houtô houtô NNP 19613 3623 203 de de NNP 19613 3623 204 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 205 archonta archonta NNP 19613 3623 206 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 207 hekastês hekastês NNP 19613 3623 208 poleôs poleôs NNP 19613 3623 209 archonti archonti NNP 19613 3623 210 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 211 en en NNP 19613 3623 212 tê tê DT 19613 3623 213 polei polei NNP 19613 3623 214 sugkroteon sugkroteon NNP 19613 3623 215 ; ; : 19613 3623 216 hina hina NNP 19613 3623 217 katanoêsus katanoêsus NNP 19613 3623 218 , , , 19613 3623 219 hoti hoti NNP 19613 3623 220 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 221 epi epi NNP 19613 3623 222 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 223 sphodra sphodra NNP 19613 3623 224 apotugchanomenoô apotugchanomenoô NNP 19613 3623 225 bouletôn bouletôn NNP 19613 3623 226 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 227 archontôn archontôn NNP 19613 3623 228 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3623 229 Theou Theou NNP 19613 3623 230 , , , 19613 3623 231 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 232 rhathumoteron rhathumoteron NNP 19613 3623 233 para para NNP 19613 3623 234 tous tous NNP 19613 3623 235 eutonôterôs eutonôterôs NNP 19613 3623 236 biountas biountas NNP 19613 3623 237 ouden ouden NNP 19613 3623 238 êtton êtton NNP 19613 3623 239 estin estin NNP 19613 3623 240 heurein heurein NNP 19613 3623 241 hôs hôs NNP 19613 3623 242 epipan epipan NNP 19613 3623 243 huperochên huperochên NNP 19613 3623 244 tên tên NNP 19613 3623 245 en en IN 19613 3623 246 tê tê NNP 19613 3623 247 epi epi NNP 19613 3623 248 tas tas NNP 19613 3623 249 aretas aretas NNP 19613 3623 250 prokopê prokopê NNP 19613 3623 251 para para NNP 19613 3623 252 ta ta NNP 19613 3623 253 êthê êthê NNP 19613 3623 254 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3623 255 en en IN 19613 3623 256 tais tais NNP 19613 3623 257 polesi polesi NNP 19613 3623 258 bouleutôn bouleutôn NNP 19613 3623 259 kai kai NNP 19613 3623 260 archontôn archontôn NNP 19613 3623 261 . . . 19613 3623 262 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3623 263 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3624 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3624 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3624 3 259 259 CD 19613 3624 4 : : : 19613 3624 5 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 3624 6 , , , 19613 3624 7 Entstehung Entstehung NNP 19613 3624 8 der der NN 19613 3624 9 altkatholischen altkatholischen NNP 19613 3624 10 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 3624 11 pp pp NNP 19613 3624 12 . . . 19613 3625 1 362 362 CD 19613 3625 2 , , , 19613 3625 3 368 368 CD 19613 3625 4 , , , 19613 3625 5 394 394 CD 19613 3625 6 , , , 19613 3625 7 461 461 CD 19613 3625 8 , , , 19613 3625 9 555 555 CD 19613 3625 10 , , , 19613 3625 11 560 560 CD 19613 3625 12 , , , 19613 3625 13 576 576 CD 19613 3625 14 . . . 19613 3626 1 Otto Otto NNP 19613 3626 2 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 19613 3626 3 , , , 19613 3626 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3626 5 . . NNP 19613 3626 6 , , , 19613 3626 7 pp pp NNP 19613 3626 8 . . . 19613 3627 1 208 208 CD 19613 3627 2 , , , 19613 3627 3 218 218 CD 19613 3627 4 , , , 19613 3627 5 231 231 CD 19613 3627 6 . . . 19613 3628 1 Hatch Hatch NNP 19613 3628 2 " " `` 19613 3628 3 Organisation Organisation NNP 19613 3628 4 of of IN 19613 3628 5 the the DT 19613 3628 6 early early JJ 19613 3628 7 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3628 8 Church Church NNP 19613 3628 9 , , , 19613 3628 10 " " '' 19613 3628 11 Lectures lecture NNS 19613 3628 12 5 5 CD 19613 3628 13 and and CC 19613 3628 14 6 6 CD 19613 3628 15 ; ; : 19613 3628 16 i -PRON- PRP 19613 3628 17 d d VBD 19613 3628 18 . . . 19613 3628 19 , , , 19613 3628 20 Art art NN 19613 3628 21 . . . 19613 3629 1 " " `` 19613 3629 2 Ordination ordination NN 19613 3629 3 , , , 19613 3629 4 " " '' 19613 3629 5 " " `` 19613 3629 6 Priest Priest NNP 19613 3629 7 , , , 19613 3629 8 " " '' 19613 3629 9 in in IN 19613 3629 10 the the DT 19613 3629 11 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 19613 3629 12 of of IN 19613 3629 13 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3629 14 Antiquities Antiquities NNPS 19613 3629 15 . . . 19613 3630 1 Hauck Hauck NNP 19613 3630 2 , , , 19613 3630 3 Art art NN 19613 3630 4 . . . 19613 3631 1 " " `` 19613 3631 2 Priester Priester NNP 19613 3631 3 " " '' 19613 3631 4 in in IN 19613 3631 5 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 3631 6 's 's POS 19613 3631 7 Real Real NNP 19613 3631 8 - - HYPH 19613 3631 9 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 3631 10 , , , 19613 3631 11 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3631 12 ed ed NN 19613 3631 13 . . . 19613 3632 1 Voigt Voigt NNP 19613 3632 2 , , , 19613 3632 3 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3632 4 . . NNP 19613 3632 5 , , , 19613 3632 6 p. p. NN 19613 3632 7 175 175 CD 19613 3632 8 ff ff NN 19613 3632 9 . . . 19613 3633 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 3633 2 , , , 19613 3633 3 Kirchenrecht Kirchenrecht NNP 19613 3633 4 I. I. NNP 19613 3633 5 p. p. NN 19613 3633 6 205 205 CD 19613 3633 7 ff ff NN 19613 3633 8 . . . 19613 3634 1 Louw Louw NNP 19613 3634 2 , , , 19613 3634 3 Het Het NNP 19613 3634 4 ontstaan ontstaan NN 19613 3634 5 van van NNP 19613 3634 6 het het NNP 19613 3634 7 Priesterschap Priesterschap NNP 19613 3634 8 in in IN 19613 3634 9 de de NNP 19613 3634 10 christ christ NNP 19613 3634 11 . . . 19613 3635 1 Kerk Kerk NNP 19613 3635 2 , , , 19613 3635 3 Utrecht Utrecht NNP 19613 3635 4 , , , 19613 3635 5 1892 1892 CD 19613 3635 6 . . . 19613 3635 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3636 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3636 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3636 3 260 260 CD 19613 3636 4 : : : 19613 3636 5 Clement clement NN 19613 3636 6 of of IN 19613 3636 7 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3636 8 was be VBD 19613 3636 9 the the DT 19613 3636 10 first first JJ 19613 3636 11 to to TO 19613 3636 12 compare compare VB 19613 3636 13 the the DT 19613 3636 14 conductors conductor NNS 19613 3636 15 of of IN 19613 3636 16 public public JJ 19613 3636 17 worship worship NN 19613 3636 18 in in IN 19613 3636 19 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3636 20 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3636 21 with with IN 19613 3636 22 the the DT 19613 3636 23 priests priest NNS 19613 3636 24 and and CC 19613 3636 25 Levites Levites NNPS 19613 3636 26 , , , 19613 3636 27 and and CC 19613 3636 28 the the DT 19613 3636 29 author author NN 19613 3636 30 of of IN 19613 3636 31 the the DT 19613 3636 32 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3636 33 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3636 34 : : : 19613 3636 35 Didachê didachê NN 19613 3636 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3636 37 was be VBD 19613 3636 38 the the DT 19613 3636 39 first first JJ 19613 3636 40 to to TO 19613 3636 41 liken liken VB 19613 3636 42 the the DT 19613 3636 43 Christian christian JJ 19613 3636 44 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3636 45 to to IN 19613 3636 46 the the DT 19613 3636 47 high high JJ 19613 3636 48 priests priest NNS 19613 3636 49 . . . 19613 3637 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3637 2 can can MD 19613 3637 3 not not RB 19613 3637 4 , , , 19613 3637 5 however however RB 19613 3637 6 , , , 19613 3637 7 be be VB 19613 3637 8 shown show VBN 19613 3637 9 that that IN 19613 3637 10 there there EX 19613 3637 11 were be VBD 19613 3637 12 any any DT 19613 3637 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 3637 14 circles circle NNS 19613 3637 15 where where WRB 19613 3637 16 the the DT 19613 3637 17 leaders leader NNS 19613 3637 18 were be VBD 19613 3637 19 directly directly RB 19613 3637 20 styled style VBN 19613 3637 21 " " `` 19613 3637 22 priests priest NNS 19613 3637 23 " " '' 19613 3637 24 before before IN 19613 3637 25 the the DT 19613 3637 26 last last JJ 19613 3637 27 quarter quarter NN 19613 3637 28 of of IN 19613 3637 29 the the DT 19613 3637 30 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3637 31 century century NN 19613 3637 32 . . . 19613 3638 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3638 2 can can MD 19613 3638 3 by by IN 19613 3638 4 no no DT 19613 3638 5 means means NN 19613 3638 6 fall fall VB 19613 3638 7 back back RB 19613 3638 8 on on IN 19613 3638 9 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 3638 10 , , , 19613 3638 11 Philad Philad NNP 19613 3638 12 . . . 19613 3639 1 9 9 CD 19613 3639 2 , , , 19613 3639 3 nor nor CC 19613 3639 4 on on IN 19613 3639 5 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3639 6 . . . 19613 3639 7 , , , 19613 3639 8 IV IV NNP 19613 3639 9 . . . 19613 3640 1 8 8 LS 19613 3640 2 . . . 19613 3641 1 3 3 LS 19613 3641 2 , , , 19613 3641 3 which which WDT 19613 3641 4 passage passage NN 19613 3641 5 is be VBZ 19613 3641 6 rather rather RB 19613 3641 7 to to TO 19613 3641 8 be be VB 19613 3641 9 compared compare VBN 19613 3641 10 with with IN 19613 3641 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3641 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3641 13 : : : 19613 3641 14 Did do VBD 19613 3641 15 . . . 19613 3641 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3642 1 13 13 CD 19613 3642 2 . . . 19613 3643 1 3 3 LS 19613 3643 2 . . . 19613 3644 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3644 2 is be VBZ 19613 3644 3 again again RB 19613 3644 4 different different JJ 19613 3644 5 in in IN 19613 3644 6 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 3644 7 circles circle NNS 19613 3644 8 , , , 19613 3644 9 which which WDT 19613 3644 10 in in IN 19613 3644 11 this this DT 19613 3644 12 case case NN 19613 3644 13 , , , 19613 3644 14 too too RB 19613 3644 15 , , , 19613 3644 16 anticipated anticipate VBD 19613 3644 17 the the DT 19613 3644 18 secularising secularising NN 19613 3644 19 process process NN 19613 3644 20 : : : 19613 3644 21 read read VB 19613 3644 22 for for IN 19613 3644 23 example example NN 19613 3644 24 the the DT 19613 3644 25 description description NN 19613 3644 26 of of IN 19613 3644 27 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 3644 28 in in IN 19613 3644 29 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3644 30 . . . 19613 3644 31 , , , 19613 3644 32 I. I. NNP 19613 3645 1 13 13 CD 19613 3645 2 . . . 19613 3646 1 Here here RB 19613 3646 2 , , , 19613 3646 3 _ _ NNP 19613 3646 4 mutatis mutatis NN 19613 3646 5 mutandis mutandis NN 19613 3646 6 _ _ NNP 19613 3646 7 , , , 19613 3646 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3646 9 have have VBP 19613 3646 10 the the DT 19613 3646 11 later later JJ 19613 3646 12 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 3646 13 bishop bishop NN 19613 3646 14 , , , 19613 3646 15 who who WP 19613 3646 16 alone alone RB 19613 3646 17 is be VBZ 19613 3646 18 able able JJ 19613 3646 19 to to TO 19613 3646 20 perform perform VB 19613 3646 21 a a DT 19613 3646 22 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 3646 23 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3646 24 to to IN 19613 3646 25 whose whose WP$ 19613 3646 26 person person NN 19613 3646 27 powers power NNS 19613 3646 28 of of IN 19613 3646 29 grace grace NN 19613 3646 30 are be VBP 19613 3646 31 attached attach VBN 19613 3646 32 -- -- : 19613 3646 33 the the DT 19613 3646 34 formula formula NN 19613 3646 35 of of IN 19613 3646 36 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 3646 37 was be VBD 19613 3646 38 : : : 19613 3646 39 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3646 40 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3646 41 : : : 19613 3646 42 metadounai metadounai NNP 19613 3646 43 soi soi NN 19613 3646 44 thelô thelô NNP 19613 3646 45 tês tês NNP 19613 3646 46 emês emês NNP 19613 3646 47 charitos charitos NNP 19613 3646 48 ... ... : 19613 3646 49 lambane lambane NNP 19613 3646 50 ap ap NNP 19613 3646 51 ' ' POS 19613 3646 52 emou emou NN 19613 3646 53 kai kai NNP 19613 3646 54 di di NNP 19613 3646 55 ' ' POS 19613 3646 56 emou emou NNP 19613 3646 57 charin charin NNP 19613 3646 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3646 59 , , , 19613 3646 60 and and CC 19613 3646 61 through through IN 19613 3646 62 whose whose WP$ 19613 3646 63 instrumentality instrumentality NN 19613 3646 64 union union NN 19613 3646 65 with with IN 19613 3646 66 God God NNP 19613 3646 67 can can MD 19613 3646 68 alone alone RB 19613 3646 69 be be VB 19613 3646 70 attained attain VBN 19613 3646 71 : : : 19613 3646 72 the the DT 19613 3646 73 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3646 74 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3646 75 : : : 19613 3646 76 apolutrôsis apolutrôsis NN 19613 3646 77 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3646 78 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3646 79 I. i. NN 19613 3647 1 21 21 CD 19613 3647 2 . . . 19613 3647 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3648 1 is be VBZ 19613 3648 2 only only RB 19613 3648 3 conferred confer VBN 19613 3648 4 through through IN 19613 3648 5 the the DT 19613 3648 6 mystagogue mystagogue NN 19613 3648 7 . . . 19613 3649 1 Much much JJ 19613 3649 2 of of IN 19613 3649 3 a a DT 19613 3649 4 similar similar JJ 19613 3649 5 nature nature NN 19613 3649 6 is be VBZ 19613 3649 7 to to TO 19613 3649 8 be be VB 19613 3649 9 found find VBN 19613 3649 10 , , , 19613 3649 11 and and CC 19613 3649 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3649 13 can can MD 19613 3649 14 expressly expressly RB 19613 3649 15 say say VB 19613 3649 16 that that IN 19613 3649 17 the the DT 19613 3649 18 distinction distinction NN 19613 3649 19 between between IN 19613 3649 20 priestly priestly JJ 19613 3649 21 mystagogues mystagogue NNS 19613 3649 22 and and CC 19613 3649 23 laymen layman NNS 19613 3649 24 was be VBD 19613 3649 25 of of IN 19613 3649 26 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 3649 27 importance importance NN 19613 3649 28 in in IN 19613 3649 29 many many JJ 19613 3649 30 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 3649 31 societies society NNS 19613 3649 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3649 33 see see VB 19613 3649 34 also also RB 19613 3649 35 the the DT 19613 3649 36 writings writing NNS 19613 3649 37 of of IN 19613 3649 38 the the DT 19613 3649 39 Coptic Coptic NNP 19613 3649 40 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 3649 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3649 42 ; ; : 19613 3649 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3649 44 was be VBD 19613 3649 45 different different JJ 19613 3649 46 in in IN 19613 3649 47 the the DT 19613 3649 48 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 3649 49 Church Church NNP 19613 3649 50 . . . 19613 3650 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3650 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3650 3 de de FW 19613 3650 4 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3650 5 . . . 19613 3651 1 17 17 CD 19613 3651 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3651 3 was be VBD 19613 3651 4 the the DT 19613 3651 5 first first JJ 19613 3651 6 to to TO 19613 3651 7 call call VB 19613 3651 8 the the DT 19613 3651 9 bishop bishop NN 19613 3651 10 " " `` 19613 3651 11 summus summus NNP 19613 3651 12 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 3651 13 , , , 19613 3651 14 " " '' 19613 3651 15 and and CC 19613 3651 16 the the DT 19613 3651 17 older old JJR 19613 3651 18 opinion opinion NN 19613 3651 19 that that IN 19613 3651 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3651 21 merely merely RB 19613 3651 22 " " `` 19613 3651 23 played play VBD 19613 3651 24 " " '' 19613 3651 25 with with IN 19613 3651 26 the the DT 19613 3651 27 idea idea NN 19613 3651 28 is be VBZ 19613 3651 29 untenable untenable JJ 19613 3651 30 , , , 19613 3651 31 and and CC 19613 3651 32 refuted refute VBN 19613 3651 33 by by IN 19613 3651 34 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 3651 35 - - HYPH 19613 3651 36 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3651 37 , , , 19613 3651 38 de de FW 19613 3651 39 aleat aleat FW 19613 3651 40 . . . 19613 3652 1 2 2 CD 19613 3652 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3652 3 " " `` 19613 3652 4 sacerdotalis sacerdotalis NNP 19613 3652 5 dignitas dignitas NNP 19613 3652 6 " " '' 19613 3652 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3652 8 . . . 19613 3653 1 In in IN 19613 3653 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3653 3 Antimontanist antimontanist JJ 19613 3653 4 writings writing NNS 19613 3653 5 the the DT 19613 3653 6 former former NN 19613 3653 7 has have VBZ 19613 3653 8 repeatedly repeatedly RB 19613 3653 9 repudiated repudiate VBN 19613 3653 10 any any DT 19613 3653 11 distinction distinction NN 19613 3653 12 in in IN 19613 3653 13 principle principle NN 19613 3653 14 of of IN 19613 3653 15 a a DT 19613 3653 16 particular particular JJ 19613 3653 17 priestly priestly JJ 19613 3653 18 class class NN 19613 3653 19 among among IN 19613 3653 20 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3653 21 , , , 19613 3653 22 as as RB 19613 3653 23 well well RB 19613 3653 24 as as IN 19613 3653 25 the the DT 19613 3653 26 application application NN 19613 3653 27 of of IN 19613 3653 28 certain certain JJ 19613 3653 29 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 3653 30 to to IN 19613 3653 31 this this DT 19613 3653 32 order order NN 19613 3653 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3653 34 de de FW 19613 3653 35 exhort exhort NN 19613 3653 36 . . . 19613 3654 1 7 7 LS 19613 3654 2 : : : 19613 3654 3 " " `` 19613 3654 4 nonne nonne NNP 19613 3654 5 et et NNP 19613 3654 6 laici laici NNP 19613 3654 7 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 3654 8 sumus sumus NNP 19613 3654 9 ? ? . 19613 3655 1 ... ... NFP 19613 3655 2 adeo adeo NNP 19613 3655 3 ubi ubi NNP 19613 3655 4 ecclesiastici ecclesiastici NNP 19613 3655 5 ordinis ordinis NNP 19613 3655 6 non non NNP 19613 3655 7 est est NNP 19613 3655 8 consessus consessus NNP 19613 3655 9 , , , 19613 3655 10 et et NNP 19613 3655 11 offeis offeis NNP 19613 3655 12 et et NNP 19613 3655 13 tinguis tinguis NNP 19613 3655 14 et et NNP 19613 3655 15 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 3655 16 es es NNP 19613 3655 17 tibi tibi NNP 19613 3655 18 solus solus NNP 19613 3655 19 , , , 19613 3655 20 sed sed NNP 19613 3655 21 ubi ubi NNP 19613 3655 22 tres tre NNS 19613 3655 23 , , , 19613 3655 24 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3655 25 est est NNP 19613 3655 26 , , , 19613 3655 27 licet licet NN 19613 3655 28 laici laici NNS 19613 3655 29 . . . 19613 3656 1 " " `` 19613 3656 2 ; ; : 19613 3656 3 de de NNP 19613 3656 4 monog monog NNP 19613 3656 5 . . . 19613 3657 1 7 7 LS 19613 3657 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3657 3 . . . 19613 3658 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3658 2 may may MD 19613 3658 3 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 3658 4 infer infer VB 19613 3658 5 from from IN 19613 3658 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3658 7 works work NNS 19613 3658 8 that that IN 19613 3658 9 before before IN 19613 3658 10 about about IN 19613 3658 11 the the DT 19613 3658 12 year year NN 19613 3658 13 200 200 CD 19613 3658 14 , , , 19613 3658 15 the the DT 19613 3658 16 name name NN 19613 3658 17 " " `` 19613 3658 18 priest priest NN 19613 3658 19 " " '' 19613 3658 20 was be VBD 19613 3658 21 not not RB 19613 3658 22 yet yet RB 19613 3658 23 universally universally RB 19613 3658 24 applied apply VBN 19613 3658 25 to to IN 19613 3658 26 bishop bishop NN 19613 3658 27 and and CC 19613 3658 28 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 3658 29 in in IN 19613 3658 30 Carthage carthage NN 19613 3658 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3658 32 but but CC 19613 3658 33 see see VB 19613 3658 34 after after IN 19613 3658 35 this this DT 19613 3658 36 de de NNP 19613 3658 37 præscr præscr NNS 19613 3658 38 . . . 19613 3659 1 29 29 CD 19613 3659 2 , , , 19613 3659 3 41 41 CD 19613 3659 4 : : : 19613 3659 5 sacerdotalia sacerdotalia NNP 19613 3659 6 munera munera NNP 19613 3659 7 ; ; : 19613 3659 8 de de NNP 19613 3659 9 pud pud NNP 19613 3659 10 . . . 19613 3660 1 1 1 CD 19613 3660 2 , , , 19613 3660 3 21 21 CD 19613 3660 4 ; ; : 19613 3660 5 de de NNP 19613 3660 6 monog monog NNP 19613 3660 7 . . . 19613 3661 1 12 12 CD 19613 3661 2 : : : 19613 3661 3 disciplina disciplina NNP 19613 3661 4 sacerd sacerd NNP 19613 3661 5 . . . 19613 3662 1 ; ; : 19613 3662 2 de de NNP 19613 3662 3 exhort exhort NN 19613 3662 4 . . . 19613 3663 1 7 7 LS 19613 3663 2 : : : 19613 3663 3 sacerdotalis sacerdotalis NNP 19613 3663 4 ordo ordo NNP 19613 3663 5 , , , 19613 3663 6 ibid ibid NNP 19613 3663 7 . . . 19613 3664 1 11 11 CD 19613 3664 2 " " `` 19613 3664 3 et et NN 19613 3664 4 offeres offer VBZ 19613 3664 5 pro pro NNP 19613 3664 6 duabus duabus NNP 19613 3664 7 uxoribus uxoribus NN 19613 3664 8 , , , 19613 3664 9 et et NNP 19613 3664 10 commendabis commendabis NNP 19613 3664 11 illas illas NNP 19613 3664 12 duas duas NNP 19613 3664 13 per per IN 19613 3664 14 sacerdotem sacerdotem FW 19613 3664 15 de de FW 19613 3664 16 monogamia monogamia NNP 19613 3664 17 ordinatum ordinatum RB 19613 3664 18 ; ; : 19613 3664 19 " " `` 19613 3664 20 de de FW 19613 3664 21 virg virg NNS 19613 3664 22 . . . 19613 3665 1 vel vel NNP 19613 3665 2 . . . 19613 3666 1 9 9 CD 19613 3666 2 : : : 19613 3666 3 sacerdotale sacerdotale JJ 19613 3666 4 officium officium NN 19613 3666 5 ; ; : 19613 3666 6 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 3666 7 . . . 19613 3667 1 7 7 LS 19613 3667 2 : : : 19613 3667 3 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 3667 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3667 5 . . . 19613 3668 1 The the DT 19613 3668 2 latest late JJS 19613 3668 3 writings writing NNS 19613 3668 4 of of IN 19613 3668 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3668 6 show show VBP 19613 3668 7 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3668 8 indeed indeed RB 19613 3668 9 that that IN 19613 3668 10 the the DT 19613 3668 11 name name NN 19613 3668 12 and and CC 19613 3668 13 the the DT 19613 3668 14 conception conception NN 19613 3668 15 which which WDT 19613 3668 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3668 17 represents represent VBZ 19613 3668 18 were be VBD 19613 3668 19 already already RB 19613 3668 20 prevalent prevalent JJ 19613 3668 21 . . . 19613 3669 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3669 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3669 3 Philos Philos NNP 19613 3669 4 . . . 19613 3670 1 præf præf NNP 19613 3670 2 . . . 19613 3671 1 : : : 19613 3671 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3671 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3671 4 : : : 19613 3671 5 hôn hôn NNP 19613 3671 6 hêmeis hêmeis NNP 19613 3671 7 diadochoi diadochoi NNP 19613 3671 8 tugchanontes tugchanonte VBZ 19613 3671 9 tês tês NNP 19613 3671 10 te te NNP 19613 3671 11 autês autês NNP 19613 3671 12 charitos charitos NNP 19613 3671 13 metechontes metechonte NNS 19613 3671 14 archierateias archierateias NNP 19613 3671 15 kai kai NNP 19613 3671 16 didaskalias didaskalias NNP 19613 3671 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3671 18 , , , 19613 3671 19 see see VB 19613 3671 20 also also RB 19613 3671 21 the the DT 19613 3671 22 Arabian arabian JJ 19613 3671 23 canons canon NNS 19613 3671 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3671 25 expressly expressly RB 19613 3671 26 claimed claim VBD 19613 3671 27 high high JJ 19613 3671 28 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 3671 29 for for IN 19613 3671 30 the the DT 19613 3671 31 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3671 32 , , , 19613 3671 33 and and CC 19613 3671 34 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3671 35 thought think VBD 19613 3671 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3671 37 was be VBD 19613 3671 38 justified justify VBN 19613 3671 39 in in IN 19613 3671 40 giving give VBG 19613 3671 41 the the DT 19613 3671 42 name name NN 19613 3671 43 of of IN 19613 3671 44 " " `` 19613 3671 45 Priests Priests NNPS 19613 3671 46 and and CC 19613 3671 47 Levites Levites NNPS 19613 3671 48 " " '' 19613 3671 49 to to IN 19613 3671 50 those those DT 19613 3671 51 who who WP 19613 3671 52 conducted conduct VBD 19613 3671 53 public public JJ 19613 3671 54 worship worship NN 19613 3671 55 among among IN 19613 3671 56 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3671 57 . . . 19613 3672 1 This this DT 19613 3672 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3672 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 3672 4 did do VBD 19613 3672 5 with with IN 19613 3672 6 reserve reserve NN 19613 3672 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3672 8 see see VB 19613 3672 9 many many JJ 19613 3672 10 passages passage NNS 19613 3672 11 , , , 19613 3672 12 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3672 13 , , , 19613 3672 14 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3672 15 . . . 19613 3673 1 II ii CD 19613 3673 2 . . . 19613 3674 1 in in IN 19613 3674 2 Num Num NNP 19613 3674 3 . . . 19613 3674 4 , , , 19613 3674 5 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3674 6 . . . 19613 3675 1 II ii CD 19613 3675 2 . . . 19613 3676 1 p. p. NN 19613 3676 2 278 278 CD 19613 3676 3 ; ; : 19613 3676 4 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3676 5 . . . 19613 3677 1 VI VI NNP 19613 3677 2 . . . 19613 3678 1 in in IN 19613 3678 2 Lev Lev NNP 19613 3678 3 . . . 19613 3678 4 , , , 19613 3678 5 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3678 6 . . . 19613 3679 1 II ii CD 19613 3679 2 . . . 19613 3680 1 p. p. NN 19613 3680 2 211 211 CD 19613 3680 3 ; ; : 19613 3680 4 Comment Comment NNP 19613 3680 5 , , , 19613 3680 6 in in IN 19613 3680 7 Joh Joh NNP 19613 3680 8 . . NNP 19613 3680 9 , , , 19613 3680 10 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3680 11 . . . 19613 3681 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3682 1 3 3 LS 19613 3682 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3682 3 , , , 19613 3682 4 but but CC 19613 3682 5 yet yet RB 19613 3682 6 to to IN 19613 3682 7 a a DT 19613 3682 8 far far RB 19613 3682 9 greater great JJR 19613 3682 10 extent extent NN 19613 3682 11 than than IN 19613 3682 12 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3682 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3682 14 see see VB 19613 3682 15 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 3682 16 , , , 19613 3682 17 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3682 18 . . NNP 19613 3682 19 , , , 19613 3682 20 p. p. NN 19613 3682 21 214 214 CD 19613 3682 22 f. f. NNP 19613 3682 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3682 24 . . . 19613 3683 1 In in IN 19613 3683 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3683 3 and and CC 19613 3683 4 the the DT 19613 3683 5 literature literature NN 19613 3683 6 of of IN 19613 3683 7 the the DT 19613 3683 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3683 9 Church Church NNP 19613 3683 10 in in IN 19613 3683 11 the the DT 19613 3683 12 immediately immediately RB 19613 3683 13 following follow VBG 19613 3683 14 period period NN 19613 3683 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3683 16 find find VBP 19613 3683 17 the the DT 19613 3683 18 designation designation NN 19613 3683 19 " " `` 19613 3683 20 priest priest NN 19613 3683 21 " " '' 19613 3683 22 as as IN 19613 3683 23 the the DT 19613 3683 24 regular regular JJ 19613 3683 25 and and CC 19613 3683 26 most most RBS 19613 3683 27 customary customary JJ 19613 3683 28 name name NN 19613 3683 29 for for IN 19613 3683 30 the the DT 19613 3683 31 bishop bishop NN 19613 3683 32 and and CC 19613 3683 33 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 3683 34 . . . 19613 3684 1 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3684 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3684 3 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 3684 4 , , , 19613 3684 5 de de NNP 19613 3684 6 vir vir NNP 19613 3684 7 . . . 19613 3685 1 inl inl UH 19613 3685 2 . . . 19613 3686 1 70 70 CD 19613 3686 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3686 3 wrote write VBD 19613 3686 4 a a DT 19613 3686 5 treatise treatise NN 19613 3686 6 _ _ NNP 19613 3686 7 de de NNP 19613 3686 8 sacerdote sacerdote NNP 19613 3686 9 _ _ NNP 19613 3686 10 and and CC 19613 3686 11 another another DT 19613 3686 12 _ _ NNP 19613 3686 13 de de NNP 19613 3686 14 ordinatione ordinatione NNP 19613 3686 15 _ _ NNP 19613 3686 16 . . . 19613 3687 1 The the DT 19613 3687 2 notable notable JJ 19613 3687 3 and and CC 19613 3687 4 momentous momentous JJ 19613 3687 5 change change NN 19613 3687 6 of of IN 19613 3687 7 conception conception NN 19613 3687 8 expressed express VBN 19613 3687 9 in in IN 19613 3687 10 the the DT 19613 3687 11 idea idea NN 19613 3687 12 can can MD 19613 3687 13 be be VB 19613 3687 14 traced trace VBN 19613 3687 15 by by IN 19613 3687 16 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3687 17 through through IN 19613 3687 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3687 19 preparatory preparatory JJ 19613 3687 20 stages stage NNS 19613 3687 21 almost almost RB 19613 3687 22 as as RB 19613 3687 23 little little JJ 19613 3687 24 as as IN 19613 3687 25 the the DT 19613 3687 26 theory theory NN 19613 3687 27 of of IN 19613 3687 28 the the DT 19613 3687 29 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 3687 30 succession succession NN 19613 3687 31 of of IN 19613 3687 32 the the DT 19613 3687 33 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3687 34 . . . 19613 3688 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3688 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3688 3 IV IV NNP 19613 3688 4 . . . 19613 3689 1 8 8 LS 19613 3689 2 . . . 19613 3690 1 3 3 CD 19613 3690 2 , , , 19613 3690 3 17 17 CD 19613 3690 4 . . . 19613 3691 1 5 5 CD 19613 3691 2 , , , 19613 3691 3 18 18 CD 19613 3691 4 . . . 19613 3692 1 1 1 LS 19613 3692 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3692 3 and and CC 19613 3692 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3692 5 , , , 19613 3692 6 when when IN 19613 3692 7 compared compare VBN 19613 3692 8 with with IN 19613 3692 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3692 10 , , , 19613 3692 11 appear appear VBP 19613 3692 12 here here RB 19613 3692 13 as as IN 19613 3692 14 representatives representative NNS 19613 3692 15 of of IN 19613 3692 16 primitive primitive JJ 19613 3692 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3692 18 . . . 19613 3693 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 3693 2 firmly firmly RB 19613 3693 3 assert assert VBP 19613 3693 4 the the DT 19613 3693 5 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 3693 6 of of IN 19613 3693 7 the the DT 19613 3693 8 whole whole JJ 19613 3693 9 congregation congregation NN 19613 3693 10 . . . 19613 3694 1 That that IN 19613 3694 2 the the DT 19613 3694 3 laity laity NN 19613 3694 4 had have VBD 19613 3694 5 as as RB 19613 3694 6 great great JJ 19613 3694 7 a a DT 19613 3694 8 share share NN 19613 3694 9 as as IN 19613 3694 10 the the DT 19613 3694 11 leaders leader NNS 19613 3694 12 of of IN 19613 3694 13 the the DT 19613 3694 14 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 3694 15 in in IN 19613 3694 16 the the DT 19613 3694 17 transformation transformation NN 19613 3694 18 of of IN 19613 3694 19 the the DT 19613 3694 20 latter latter JJ 19613 3694 21 into into IN 19613 3694 22 Priests Priests NNP 19613 3694 23 is be VBZ 19613 3694 24 moreover moreover RB 19613 3694 25 shown show VBN 19613 3694 26 by by IN 19613 3694 27 the the DT 19613 3694 28 bitter bitter JJ 19613 3694 29 saying saying NN 19613 3694 30 of of IN 19613 3694 31 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3694 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3694 33 de de FW 19613 3694 34 monog monog NNP 19613 3694 35 . . . 19613 3695 1 12 12 CD 19613 3695 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3695 3 : : : 19613 3695 4 " " `` 19613 3695 5 Sed Sed NNP 19613 3695 6 cum cum NNP 19613 3695 7 extollimur extollimur NNP 19613 3695 8 et et NNP 19613 3695 9 inflamur inflamur NNP 19613 3695 10 adversus adversus NNP 19613 3695 11 clerum clerum NNP 19613 3695 12 , , , 19613 3695 13 tunc tunc NNP 19613 3695 14 unum unum NNP 19613 3695 15 omnes omnes NNP 19613 3695 16 sumus sumus NNP 19613 3695 17 , , , 19613 3695 18 tunc tunc NNP 19613 3695 19 omnes omnes NNP 19613 3695 20 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 3695 21 , , , 19613 3695 22 quia quia NNP 19613 3695 23 ' ' `` 19613 3695 24 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 3695 25 nos nos NNP 19613 3695 26 deo deo NNP 19613 3695 27 et et NNP 19613 3695 28 patri patri NN 19613 3695 29 fecit fecit NNP 19613 3695 30 ' ' '' 19613 3695 31 . . . 19613 3696 1 Cum Cum NNP 19613 3696 2 ad ad NN 19613 3696 3 peræquationem peræquationem NNP 19613 3696 4 disciplinæ disciplinæ VBP 19613 3696 5 sacerdotalis sacerdotalis NNP 19613 3696 6 provocamur provocamur NNP 19613 3696 7 , , , 19613 3696 8 deponimus deponimus NNP 19613 3696 9 infulas infulas NNP 19613 3696 10 . . . 19613 3696 11 " " '' 19613 3696 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3697 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3697 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3697 3 261 261 CD 19613 3697 4 : : : 19613 3697 5 See see VB 19613 3697 6 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 3697 7 , , , 19613 3697 8 I. I. NNP 19613 3697 9 p. p. NN 19613 3698 1 207 207 CD 19613 3698 2 . . . 19613 3698 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3699 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3699 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3699 3 262 262 CD 19613 3699 4 : : : 19613 3699 5 The the DT 19613 3699 6 " " `` 19613 3699 7 deservire deservire NNP 19613 3699 8 altari altari NNP 19613 3699 9 et et NNP 19613 3699 10 sacrificia sacrificia NNP 19613 3699 11 divina divina NNP 19613 3699 12 celebrare celebrare NNP 19613 3699 13 " " '' 19613 3699 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3699 15 Cypr Cypr NNS 19613 3699 16 . . . 19613 3700 1 ep ep NNP 19613 3700 2 . . . 19613 3701 1 67 67 CD 19613 3701 2 . . . 19613 3702 1 1 1 LS 19613 3702 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3702 3 is be VBZ 19613 3702 4 the the DT 19613 3702 5 distinctive distinctive JJ 19613 3702 6 function function NN 19613 3702 7 of of IN 19613 3702 8 the the DT 19613 3702 9 _ _ NNP 19613 3702 10 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 3702 11 dei dei NNP 19613 3702 12 _ _ NNP 19613 3702 13 . . . 19613 3703 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3703 2 may may MD 19613 3703 3 further further RB 19613 3703 4 be be VB 19613 3703 5 said say VBN 19613 3703 6 , , , 19613 3703 7 however however RB 19613 3703 8 , , , 19613 3703 9 that that IN 19613 3703 10 _ _ NNP 19613 3703 11 all all DT 19613 3703 12 _ _ NNP 19613 3703 13 ceremonies ceremony NNS 19613 3703 14 of of IN 19613 3703 15 public public JJ 19613 3703 16 worship worship NN 19613 3703 17 properly properly RB 19613 3703 18 belong belong VB 19613 3703 19 to to IN 19613 3703 20 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3703 21 , , , 19613 3703 22 and and CC 19613 3703 23 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3703 24 has have VBZ 19613 3703 25 moreover moreover RB 19613 3703 26 contrived contrive VBN 19613 3703 27 to to TO 19613 3703 28 show show VB 19613 3703 29 that that IN 19613 3703 30 this this DT 19613 3703 31 function function NN 19613 3703 32 of of IN 19613 3703 33 the the DT 19613 3703 34 bishop bishop NN 19613 3703 35 as as IN 19613 3703 36 leader leader NN 19613 3703 37 of of IN 19613 3703 38 the the DT 19613 3703 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3703 40 follows follow VBZ 19613 3703 41 from from IN 19613 3703 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3703 43 priestly priestly RB 19613 3703 44 attributes attribute NNS 19613 3703 45 ; ; : 19613 3703 46 for for IN 19613 3703 47 as as IN 19613 3703 48 priest priest NN 19613 3703 49 the the DT 19613 3703 50 bishop bishop NN 19613 3703 51 is be VBZ 19613 3703 52 _ _ NNP 19613 3703 53 antistes antiste VBZ 19613 3703 54 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3703 55 _ _ NNP 19613 3703 56 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3703 57 dei dei NNP 19613 3703 58 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3703 59 ; ; : 19613 3703 60 see see VB 19613 3703 61 epp epp NNP 19613 3703 62 . . . 19613 3704 1 59 59 CD 19613 3704 2 . . . 19613 3705 1 18 18 CD 19613 3705 2 : : : 19613 3705 3 61 61 CD 19613 3705 4 . . . 19613 3706 1 2 2 CD 19613 3706 2 : : SYM 19613 3706 3 63 63 CD 19613 3706 4 . . . 19613 3707 1 14 14 CD 19613 3707 2 : : : 19613 3707 3 66 66 CD 19613 3707 4 . . . 19613 3708 1 5 5 CD 19613 3708 2 , , , 19613 3708 3 and and CC 19613 3708 4 this this DT 19613 3708 5 is be VBZ 19613 3708 6 the the DT 19613 3708 7 basis basis NN 19613 3708 8 of of IN 19613 3708 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3708 10 right right NN 19613 3708 11 and and CC 19613 3708 12 duty duty NN 19613 3708 13 to to TO 19613 3708 14 preserve preserve VB 19613 3708 15 the the DT 19613 3708 16 _ _ NNP 19613 3708 17 lex lex NN 19613 3708 18 evangelica evangelica NN 19613 3708 19 _ _ NNP 19613 3708 20 and and CC 19613 3708 21 the the DT 19613 3708 22 _ _ NNP 19613 3708 23 traditio traditio NNP 19613 3708 24 dominica dominica NNP 19613 3708 25 _ _ NNP 19613 3708 26 in in IN 19613 3708 27 every every DT 19613 3708 28 respect respect NN 19613 3708 29 . . . 19613 3709 1 As as IN 19613 3709 2 _ _ NNP 19613 3709 3 antistes antiste VBZ 19613 3709 4 dei dei NNP 19613 3709 5 _ _ NNP 19613 3709 6 however however RB 19613 3709 7 , , , 19613 3709 8 an an DT 19613 3709 9 attribute attribute NN 19613 3709 10 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 3709 11 on on IN 19613 3709 12 the the DT 19613 3709 13 bishop bishop NN 19613 3709 14 by by IN 19613 3709 15 the the DT 19613 3709 16 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 3709 17 succession succession NN 19613 3709 18 and and CC 19613 3709 19 the the DT 19613 3709 20 laying laying NN 19613 3709 21 on on RP 19613 3709 22 of of IN 19613 3709 23 hands hand NNS 19613 3709 24 , , , 19613 3709 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3709 26 has have VBZ 19613 3709 27 also also RB 19613 3709 28 received receive VBN 19613 3709 29 the the DT 19613 3709 30 power power NN 19613 3709 31 of of IN 19613 3709 32 the the DT 19613 3709 33 keys key NNS 19613 3709 34 , , , 19613 3709 35 which which WDT 19613 3709 36 confers confer VBZ 19613 3709 37 the the DT 19613 3709 38 right right NN 19613 3709 39 to to TO 19613 3709 40 judge judge VB 19613 3709 41 in in IN 19613 3709 42 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3709 43 's 's POS 19613 3709 44 stead stead NN 19613 3709 45 and and CC 19613 3709 46 to to TO 19613 3709 47 grant grant VB 19613 3709 48 or or CC 19613 3709 49 refuse refuse VB 19613 3709 50 the the DT 19613 3709 51 divine divine JJ 19613 3709 52 grace grace NN 19613 3709 53 . . . 19613 3710 1 In in IN 19613 3710 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3710 3 's 's POS 19613 3710 4 conception conception NN 19613 3710 5 of of IN 19613 3710 6 the the DT 19613 3710 7 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 3710 8 office office NN 19613 3710 9 the the DT 19613 3710 10 _ _ NNP 19613 3710 11 successio successio NN 19613 3710 12 apostolica apostolica NNP 19613 3710 13 _ _ NNP 19613 3710 14 and and CC 19613 3710 15 the the DT 19613 3710 16 position position NN 19613 3710 17 of of IN 19613 3710 18 vicegerent vicegerent NN 19613 3710 19 of of IN 19613 3710 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3710 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3710 22 of of IN 19613 3710 23 God God NNP 19613 3710 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3710 25 counterbalance counterbalance VB 19613 3710 26 each each DT 19613 3710 27 other other JJ 19613 3710 28 ; ; : 19613 3710 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3710 30 also also RB 19613 3710 31 tried try VBD 19613 3710 32 to to TO 19613 3710 33 amalgamate amalgamate VB 19613 3710 34 both both DT 19613 3710 35 elements element NNS 19613 3710 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3710 37 ep ep NNP 19613 3710 38 . . . 19613 3711 1 55 55 CD 19613 3711 2 . . . 19613 3712 1 8 8 LS 19613 3712 2 : : : 19613 3712 3 " " `` 19613 3712 4 cathedra cathedra NNP 19613 3712 5 sacerdotalis sacerdotalis NNP 19613 3712 6 " " '' 19613 3712 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3712 8 . . . 19613 3713 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3713 2 is be VBZ 19613 3713 3 evident evident JJ 19613 3713 4 that that IN 19613 3713 5 as as RB 19613 3713 6 far far RB 19613 3713 7 as as IN 19613 3713 8 the the DT 19613 3713 9 inner inner JJ 19613 3713 10 life life NN 19613 3713 11 of of IN 19613 3713 12 each each DT 19613 3713 13 church church NN 19613 3713 14 was be VBD 19613 3713 15 concerned concern VBN 19613 3713 16 , , , 19613 3713 17 the the DT 19613 3713 18 latter latter JJ 19613 3713 19 and and CC 19613 3713 20 newer new JJR 19613 3713 21 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 3713 22 proved prove VBD 19613 3713 23 the the DT 19613 3713 24 more more RBR 19613 3713 25 important important JJ 19613 3713 26 feature feature NN 19613 3713 27 . . . 19613 3714 1 In in IN 19613 3714 2 the the DT 19613 3714 3 East East NNP 19613 3714 4 , , , 19613 3714 5 where where WRB 19613 3714 6 the the DT 19613 3714 7 thought thought NN 19613 3714 8 of of IN 19613 3714 9 the the DT 19613 3714 10 apostolical apostolical JJ 19613 3714 11 succession succession NN 19613 3714 12 of of IN 19613 3714 13 the the DT 19613 3714 14 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3714 15 never never RB 19613 3714 16 received receive VBD 19613 3714 17 such such JJ 19613 3714 18 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 3714 19 expression expression NN 19613 3714 20 as as IN 19613 3714 21 in in IN 19613 3714 22 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3714 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3714 24 was be VBD 19613 3714 25 just just RB 19613 3714 26 this this DT 19613 3714 27 latter latter JJ 19613 3714 28 element element NN 19613 3714 29 that that WDT 19613 3714 30 was be VBD 19613 3714 31 almost almost RB 19613 3714 32 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 3714 33 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 3714 34 from from IN 19613 3714 35 the the DT 19613 3714 36 end end NN 19613 3714 37 of of IN 19613 3714 38 the the DT 19613 3714 39 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3714 40 century century NN 19613 3714 41 . . . 19613 3715 1 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 3715 2 led lead VBD 19613 3715 3 the the DT 19613 3715 4 way way NN 19613 3715 5 when when WRB 19613 3715 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3715 7 compared compare VBD 19613 3715 8 the the DT 19613 3715 9 bishop bishop NN 19613 3715 10 , , , 19613 3715 11 in in IN 19613 3715 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3715 13 position position NN 19613 3715 14 towards towards IN 19613 3715 15 the the DT 19613 3715 16 individual individual JJ 19613 3715 17 community community NN 19613 3715 18 , , , 19613 3715 19 with with IN 19613 3715 20 God God NNP 19613 3715 21 and and CC 19613 3715 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3715 23 . . . 19613 3716 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 3716 2 , , , 19613 3716 3 however however RB 19613 3716 4 , , , 19613 3716 5 is be VBZ 19613 3716 6 dealing deal VBG 19613 3716 7 in in IN 19613 3716 8 images image NNS 19613 3716 9 , , , 19613 3716 10 but but CC 19613 3716 11 at at IN 19613 3716 12 a a DT 19613 3716 13 later later JJ 19613 3716 14 period period NN 19613 3716 15 the the DT 19613 3716 16 question question NN 19613 3716 17 is be VBZ 19613 3716 18 about about IN 19613 3716 19 realities reality NNS 19613 3716 20 based base VBN 19613 3716 21 on on IN 19613 3716 22 a a DT 19613 3716 23 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 3716 24 transference transference NN 19613 3716 25 . . . 19613 3716 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3717 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3717 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3717 3 263 263 CD 19613 3717 4 : : : 19613 3717 5 Soon soon RB 19613 3717 6 after after IN 19613 3717 7 the the DT 19613 3717 8 creation creation NN 19613 3717 9 of of IN 19613 3717 10 a a DT 19613 3717 11 professional professional JJ 19613 3717 12 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 3717 13 , , , 19613 3717 14 there there EX 19613 3717 15 also also RB 19613 3717 16 arose arise VBD 19613 3717 17 a a DT 19613 3717 18 class class NN 19613 3717 19 of of IN 19613 3717 20 inferior inferior JJ 19613 3717 21 clergy clergy NNS 19613 3717 22 . . . 19613 3718 1 This this DT 19613 3718 2 was be VBD 19613 3718 3 first first RB 19613 3718 4 the the DT 19613 3718 5 case case NN 19613 3718 6 in in IN 19613 3718 7 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3718 8 . . . 19613 3719 1 This this DT 19613 3719 2 development development NN 19613 3719 3 was be VBD 19613 3719 4 not not RB 19613 3719 5 uninfluenced uninfluenced JJ 19613 3719 6 by by IN 19613 3719 7 the the DT 19613 3719 8 heathen heathen NNP 19613 3719 9 priesthood priesthood NNP 19613 3719 10 , , , 19613 3719 11 and and CC 19613 3719 12 the the DT 19613 3719 13 temple temple NNP 19613 3719 14 service service NNP 19613 3719 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3719 16 see see VB 19613 3719 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3719 18 article article NN 19613 3719 19 in in IN 19613 3719 20 Texte Texte NNP 19613 3719 21 und und NN 19613 3719 22 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 3719 23 II II NNP 19613 3719 24 . . . 19613 3720 1 5 5 LS 19613 3720 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3720 3 . . . 19613 3721 1 Yet yet CC 19613 3721 2 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 3721 3 , , , 19613 3721 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3721 5 . . NNP 19613 3721 6 , , , 19613 3721 7 p. p. NN 19613 3721 8 128 128 CD 19613 3721 9 ff ff NNP 19613 3721 10 . . NNP 19613 3721 11 , , , 19613 3721 12 has have VBZ 19613 3721 13 disputed dispute VBN 19613 3721 14 this this DT 19613 3721 15 , , , 19613 3721 16 and and CC 19613 3721 17 proposed propose VBN 19613 3721 18 modifications modification NNS 19613 3721 19 , , , 19613 3721 20 worth worth JJ 19613 3721 21 considering consider VBG 19613 3721 22 , , , 19613 3721 23 in in IN 19613 3721 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3721 25 view view NN 19613 3721 26 of of IN 19613 3721 27 the the DT 19613 3721 28 origin origin NN 19613 3721 29 of of IN 19613 3721 30 the the DT 19613 3721 31 _ _ NNP 19613 3721 32 ordines ordine NNS 19613 3721 33 minores minores NNPS 19613 3721 34 _ _ NNP 19613 3721 35 . . . 19613 3721 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3722 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3722 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3722 3 264 264 CD 19613 3722 4 : : : 19613 3722 5 Along along IN 19613 3722 6 with with IN 19613 3722 7 the the DT 19613 3722 8 sacerdotal sacerdotal JJ 19613 3722 9 laws law NNS 19613 3722 10 , , , 19613 3722 11 strictly strictly RB 19613 3722 12 so so RB 19613 3722 13 called call VBN 19613 3722 14 , , , 19613 3722 15 which which WDT 19613 3722 16 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3722 17 already already RB 19613 3722 18 understood understand VBD 19613 3722 19 to to TO 19613 3722 20 apply apply VB 19613 3722 21 in in IN 19613 3722 22 a a DT 19613 3722 23 frightful frightful JJ 19613 3722 24 manner manner NN 19613 3722 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3722 26 see see VB 19613 3722 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3722 28 appeal appeal NN 19613 3722 29 to to IN 19613 3722 30 Deut Deut NNP 19613 3722 31 . . . 19613 3723 1 XVII XVII NNP 19613 3723 2 . . . 19613 3724 1 12 12 CD 19613 3724 2 ; ; SYM 19613 3724 3 1 1 CD 19613 3724 4 Sam Sam NNP 19613 3724 5 . . . 19613 3725 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 3725 2 . . . 19613 3726 1 7 7 LS 19613 3726 2 ; ; : 19613 3726 3 Luke Luke NNP 19613 3726 4 X. X. NNP 19613 3727 1 16 16 CD 19613 3727 2 ; ; : 19613 3727 3 John John NNP 19613 3727 4 XVIII XVIII NNP 19613 3727 5 . . . 19613 3728 1 22 22 CD 19613 3728 2 f. f. NNS 19613 3728 3 ; ; : 19613 3728 4 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 3728 5 XXIII XXIII NNP 19613 3728 6 . . . 19613 3729 1 4 4 LS 19613 3729 2 - - SYM 19613 3729 3 5 5 CD 19613 3729 4 in in IN 19613 3729 5 epp epp NN 19613 3729 6 . . . 19613 3730 1 3 3 LS 19613 3730 2 . . . 19613 3731 1 43 43 CD 19613 3731 2 , , , 19613 3731 3 59 59 CD 19613 3731 4 . . . 19613 3732 1 66 66 CD 19613 3732 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3732 3 , , , 19613 3732 4 other other JJ 19613 3732 5 Old Old NNP 19613 3732 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3732 7 commandments commandment NNS 19613 3732 8 could could MD 19613 3732 9 not not RB 19613 3732 10 fail fail VB 19613 3732 11 to to TO 19613 3732 12 be be VB 19613 3732 13 introduced introduce VBN 19613 3732 14 . . . 19613 3733 1 Thus thus RB 19613 3733 2 the the DT 19613 3733 3 commandment commandment NN 19613 3733 4 of of IN 19613 3733 5 tithes tithe NNS 19613 3733 6 , , , 19613 3733 7 which which WDT 19613 3733 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3733 9 had have VBD 19613 3733 10 still still RB 19613 3733 11 asserted assert VBN 19613 3733 12 to to TO 19613 3733 13 be be VB 19613 3733 14 abolished abolish VBN 19613 3733 15 , , , 19613 3733 16 was be VBD 19613 3733 17 now now RB 19613 3733 18 for for IN 19613 3733 19 the the DT 19613 3733 20 first first JJ 19613 3733 21 time time NN 19613 3733 22 established establish VBN 19613 3733 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3733 24 see see VB 19613 3733 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3733 26 ; ; : 19613 3733 27 Constit Constit NNP 19613 3733 28 . . . 19613 3734 1 Apost apost UH 19613 3734 2 . . . 19613 3735 1 and and CC 19613 3735 2 _ _ NNP 19613 3735 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3735 4 _ _ NNP 19613 3735 5 remarks remark VBZ 19613 3735 6 on on IN 19613 3735 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3735 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3735 9 : : : 19613 3735 10 Did do VBD 19613 3735 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3735 12 . . . 19613 3736 1 c. c. NNP 19613 3736 2 13 13 CD 19613 3736 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3736 4 ; ; : 19613 3736 5 and and CC 19613 3736 6 hence hence RB 19613 3736 7 Mosaic Mosaic NNP 19613 3736 8 regulations regulation NNS 19613 3736 9 as as IN 19613 3736 10 to to IN 19613 3736 11 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 3736 12 cleanness cleanness NN 19613 3736 13 were be VBD 19613 3736 14 adopted adopt VBN 19613 3736 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3736 16 see see VB 19613 3736 17 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 3736 18 . . . 19613 3737 1 Canones Canones NNP 19613 3737 2 arab arab NNP 19613 3737 3 . . . 19613 3738 1 17 17 CD 19613 3738 2 ; ; : 19613 3738 3 Dionys dionys NN 19613 3738 4 . . . 19613 3739 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 3739 2 . . NNP 19613 3739 3 , , , 19613 3739 4 ep ep NNP 19613 3739 5 . . . 19613 3740 1 canon canon NNP 19613 3740 2 . . . 19613 3740 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3740 4 . . . 19613 3741 1 Constantine constantine NN 19613 3741 2 was be VBD 19613 3741 3 the the DT 19613 3741 4 first first JJ 19613 3741 5 to to TO 19613 3741 6 base base VB 19613 3741 7 the the DT 19613 3741 8 observance observance NN 19613 3741 9 of of IN 19613 3741 10 Sunday Sunday NNP 19613 3741 11 on on IN 19613 3741 12 the the DT 19613 3741 13 commandment commandment NN 19613 3741 14 as as IN 19613 3741 15 to to IN 19613 3741 16 the the DT 19613 3741 17 Sabbath Sabbath NNP 19613 3741 18 . . . 19613 3742 1 Besides besides RB 19613 3742 2 , , , 19613 3742 3 the the DT 19613 3742 4 West West NNP 19613 3742 5 was be VBD 19613 3742 6 always always RB 19613 3742 7 more more JJR 19613 3742 8 hesitating hesitating NN 19613 3742 9 in in IN 19613 3742 10 this this DT 19613 3742 11 respect respect NN 19613 3742 12 than than IN 19613 3742 13 the the DT 19613 3742 14 East East NNP 19613 3742 15 . . . 19613 3743 1 In in IN 19613 3743 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3743 3 's 's POS 19613 3743 4 time time NN 19613 3743 5 , , , 19613 3743 6 however however RB 19613 3743 7 , , , 19613 3743 8 the the DT 19613 3743 9 classification classification NN 19613 3743 10 and and CC 19613 3743 11 dignity dignity NN 19613 3743 12 of of IN 19613 3743 13 the the DT 19613 3743 14 clergy clergy NNS 19613 3743 15 were be VBD 19613 3743 16 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 3743 17 upheld uphold VBN 19613 3743 18 by by IN 19613 3743 19 an an DT 19613 3743 20 appeal appeal NN 19613 3743 21 to to IN 19613 3743 22 Old Old NNP 19613 3743 23 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3743 24 commandments commandment NNS 19613 3743 25 , , , 19613 3743 26 though though IN 19613 3743 27 reservations reservation NNS 19613 3743 28 still still RB 19613 3743 29 continued continue VBD 19613 3743 30 to to TO 19613 3743 31 be be VB 19613 3743 32 made make VBN 19613 3743 33 here here RB 19613 3743 34 and and CC 19613 3743 35 there there RB 19613 3743 36 . . . 19613 3743 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3744 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3744 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3744 3 265 265 CD 19613 3744 4 : : : 19613 3744 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3744 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3744 7 de de FW 19613 3744 8 pud pud NNP 19613 3744 9 . . . 19613 3745 1 I i NN 19613 3745 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3745 3 sneeringly sneeringly RB 19613 3745 4 named name VBD 19613 3745 5 the the DT 19613 3745 6 bishop bishop NN 19613 3745 7 of of IN 19613 3745 8 Rome Rome NNP 19613 3745 9 " " '' 19613 3745 10 pontifex pontifex NNP 19613 3745 11 maximus maximus NNP 19613 3745 12 , , , 19613 3745 13 " " '' 19613 3745 14 thereby thereby RB 19613 3745 15 proving prove VBG 19613 3745 16 that that IN 19613 3745 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3745 18 clearly clearly RB 19613 3745 19 recognised recognise VBD 19613 3745 20 the the DT 19613 3745 21 heathen heathen NN 19613 3745 22 colouring colour VBG 19613 3745 23 given give VBN 19613 3745 24 to to IN 19613 3745 25 the the DT 19613 3745 26 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 3745 27 office office NN 19613 3745 28 . . . 19613 3746 1 With with IN 19613 3746 2 the the DT 19613 3746 3 picture picture NN 19613 3746 4 of of IN 19613 3746 5 the the DT 19613 3746 6 bishop bishop NN 19613 3746 7 drawn draw VBN 19613 3746 8 by by IN 19613 3746 9 the the DT 19613 3746 10 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 3746 11 constitutions constitution NNS 19613 3746 12 may may MD 19613 3746 13 be be VB 19613 3746 14 compared compare VBN 19613 3746 15 the the DT 19613 3746 16 ill ill JJ 19613 3746 17 - - HYPH 19613 3746 18 natured natured JJ 19613 3746 19 descriptions description NNS 19613 3746 20 of of IN 19613 3746 21 Paul Paul NNP 19613 3746 22 of of IN 19613 3746 23 Samosata Samosata NNP 19613 3746 24 in in IN 19613 3746 25 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3746 26 . . NNP 19613 3746 27 , , , 19613 3746 28 VII VII NNP 19613 3746 29 . . . 19613 3747 1 30 30 CD 19613 3747 2 . . . 19613 3747 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3748 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3748 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3748 3 266 266 CD 19613 3748 4 : : : 19613 3748 5 Yet yet CC 19613 3748 6 this this DT 19613 3748 7 influence influence NN 19613 3748 8 , , , 19613 3748 9 in in IN 19613 3748 10 a a DT 19613 3748 11 direct direct JJ 19613 3748 12 form form NN 19613 3748 13 at at IN 19613 3748 14 least least JJS 19613 3748 15 , , , 19613 3748 16 can can MD 19613 3748 17 only only RB 19613 3748 18 be be VB 19613 3748 19 made make VBN 19613 3748 20 out out RP 19613 3748 21 at at IN 19613 3748 22 a a DT 19613 3748 23 comparatively comparatively RB 19613 3748 24 late late JJ 19613 3748 25 period period NN 19613 3748 26 . . . 19613 3749 1 But but CC 19613 3749 2 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 3749 3 , , , 19613 3749 4 from from IN 19613 3749 5 the the DT 19613 3749 6 middle middle NN 19613 3749 7 of of IN 19613 3749 8 the the DT 19613 3749 9 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 3749 10 century century NN 19613 3749 11 the the DT 19613 3749 12 priests priest NNS 19613 3749 13 alone alone RB 19613 3749 14 are be VBP 19613 3749 15 possessed possess VBN 19613 3749 16 of of IN 19613 3749 17 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 3749 18 . . . 19613 3750 1 As as IN 19613 3750 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3750 3 Greek greek JJ 19613 3750 4 : : : 19613 3750 5 mathêsis mathêsis NN 19613 3750 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3750 7 and and CC 19613 3750 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3750 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3750 10 : : : 19613 3750 11 mystagôgia mystagôgia NN 19613 3750 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3750 13 are be VBP 19613 3750 14 inseparably inseparably RB 19613 3750 15 connected connect VBN 19613 3750 16 in in IN 19613 3750 17 the the DT 19613 3750 18 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 3750 19 and and CC 19613 3750 20 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 3750 21 societies society NNS 19613 3750 22 , , , 19613 3750 23 and and CC 19613 3750 24 the the DT 19613 3750 25 mystagogue mystagogue NN 19613 3750 26 was be VBD 19613 3750 27 at at IN 19613 3750 28 once once RB 19613 3750 29 knowing know VBG 19613 3750 30 one one CD 19613 3750 31 and and CC 19613 3750 32 priest priest NN 19613 3750 33 , , , 19613 3750 34 so so RB 19613 3750 35 also also RB 19613 3750 36 in in IN 19613 3750 37 the the DT 19613 3750 38 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 3750 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3750 40 the the DT 19613 3750 41 priest priest NN 19613 3750 42 is be VBZ 19613 3750 43 accounted account VBN 19613 3750 44 the the DT 19613 3750 45 knowing know VBG 19613 3750 46 one one CD 19613 3750 47 . . . 19613 3751 1 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 3751 2 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3751 3 became become VBD 19613 3751 4 a a DT 19613 3751 5 mystery mystery NN 19613 3751 6 to to IN 19613 3751 7 an an DT 19613 3751 8 increasing increase VBG 19613 3751 9 extent extent NN 19613 3751 10 . . . 19613 3751 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3752 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3752 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3752 3 267 267 CD 19613 3752 4 : : : 19613 3752 5 Examples example NNS 19613 3752 6 are be VBP 19613 3752 7 found find VBN 19613 3752 8 in in IN 19613 3752 9 epp epp NNP 19613 3752 10 . . . 19613 3753 1 1 1 CD 19613 3753 2 , , , 19613 3753 3 3 3 CD 19613 3753 4 , , , 19613 3753 5 4 4 CD 19613 3753 6 , , , 19613 3753 7 33 33 CD 19613 3753 8 , , , 19613 3753 9 43 43 CD 19613 3753 10 , , , 19613 3753 11 54 54 CD 19613 3753 12 , , , 19613 3753 13 57 57 CD 19613 3753 14 , , , 19613 3753 15 59 59 CD 19613 3753 16 , , , 19613 3753 17 65 65 CD 19613 3753 18 , , , 19613 3753 19 66 66 CD 19613 3753 20 . . . 19613 3754 1 But but CC 19613 3754 2 see see VB 19613 3754 3 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3754 4 . . . 19613 3754 5 , , , 19613 3754 6 IV IV NNP 19613 3754 7 . . . 19613 3755 1 26 26 CD 19613 3755 2 . . . 19613 3756 1 2 2 LS 19613 3756 2 , , , 19613 3756 3 who who WP 19613 3756 4 is be VBZ 19613 3756 5 little little JJ 19613 3756 6 behind behind IN 19613 3756 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3756 8 here here RB 19613 3756 9 , , , 19613 3756 10 especially especially RB 19613 3756 11 when when WRB 19613 3756 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3756 13 threatens threaten VBZ 19613 3756 14 offenders offender NNS 19613 3756 15 with with IN 19613 3756 16 the the DT 19613 3756 17 fate fate NN 19613 3756 18 of of IN 19613 3756 19 Dathan Dathan NNP 19613 3756 20 and and CC 19613 3756 21 Abiram Abiram NNP 19613 3756 22 . . . 19613 3757 1 One one CD 19613 3757 2 of of IN 19613 3757 3 the the DT 19613 3757 4 immediate immediate JJ 19613 3757 5 results result NNS 19613 3757 6 of of IN 19613 3757 7 the the DT 19613 3757 8 formation formation NN 19613 3757 9 of of IN 19613 3757 10 a a DT 19613 3757 11 priestly priestly JJ 19613 3757 12 and and CC 19613 3757 13 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 3757 14 class class NN 19613 3757 15 was be VBD 19613 3757 16 that that IN 19613 3757 17 the the DT 19613 3757 18 independent independent JJ 19613 3757 19 " " `` 19613 3757 20 teachers teacher NNS 19613 3757 21 " " '' 19613 3757 22 now now RB 19613 3757 23 shared share VBD 19613 3757 24 the the DT 19613 3757 25 fate fate NN 19613 3757 26 of of IN 19613 3757 27 the the DT 19613 3757 28 old old JJ 19613 3757 29 " " `` 19613 3757 30 prophets prophet NNS 19613 3757 31 " " '' 19613 3757 32 and and CC 19613 3757 33 became become VBD 19613 3757 34 extinct extinct JJ 19613 3757 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3757 36 see see VB 19613 3757 37 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3757 38 edition edition NN 19613 3757 39 of of IN 19613 3757 40 the the DT 19613 3757 41 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3757 42 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3757 43 : : : 19613 3757 44 Didachê didachê NN 19613 3757 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3757 46 , , , 19613 3757 47 prolegg prolegg NN 19613 3757 48 . . . 19613 3758 1 pp pp NNP 19613 3758 2 . . . 19613 3759 1 131 131 CD 19613 3759 2 - - SYM 19613 3759 3 137 137 CD 19613 3759 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3759 5 . . . 19613 3760 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3760 2 is be VBZ 19613 3760 3 an an DT 19613 3760 4 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3760 5 fact fact NN 19613 3760 6 that that IN 19613 3760 7 Theoktistus Theoktistus NNP 19613 3760 8 of of IN 19613 3760 9 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 19613 3760 10 and and CC 19613 3760 11 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 3760 12 of of IN 19613 3760 13 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 3760 14 in in IN 19613 3760 15 order order NN 19613 3760 16 to to TO 19613 3760 17 prove prove VB 19613 3760 18 in in IN 19613 3760 19 opposition opposition NN 19613 3760 20 to to IN 19613 3760 21 Demetrius Demetrius NNP 19613 3760 22 that that DT 19613 3760 23 independent independent JJ 19613 3760 24 teachers teacher NNS 19613 3760 25 were be VBD 19613 3760 26 still still RB 19613 3760 27 tolerated tolerate VBN 19613 3760 28 , , , 19613 3760 29 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 3760 30 , , , 19613 3760 31 allowed allow VBN 19613 3760 32 to to TO 19613 3760 33 speak speak VB 19613 3760 34 in in IN 19613 3760 35 public public JJ 19613 3760 36 meetings meeting NNS 19613 3760 37 of of IN 19613 3760 38 the the DT 19613 3760 39 Church Church NNP 19613 3760 40 , , , 19613 3760 41 could could MD 19613 3760 42 only only RB 19613 3760 43 appeal appeal VB 19613 3760 44 to to IN 19613 3760 45 the the DT 19613 3760 46 practice practice NN 19613 3760 47 of of IN 19613 3760 48 Phrygia Phrygia NNP 19613 3760 49 and and CC 19613 3760 50 Lycaonia Lycaonia NNP 19613 3760 51 , , , 19613 3760 52 that that RB 19613 3760 53 is is RB 19613 3760 54 , , , 19613 3760 55 to to IN 19613 3760 56 the the DT 19613 3760 57 habit habit NN 19613 3760 58 of of IN 19613 3760 59 outlying outlying JJ 19613 3760 60 provinces province NNS 19613 3760 61 where where WRB 19613 3760 62 , , , 19613 3760 63 besides besides RB 19613 3760 64 , , , 19613 3760 65 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 3760 66 had have VBD 19613 3760 67 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3760 68 original original JJ 19613 3760 69 seat seat NN 19613 3760 70 . . . 19613 3761 1 Euelpis Euelpis NNP 19613 3761 2 in in IN 19613 3761 3 Laranda Laranda NNP 19613 3761 4 , , , 19613 3761 5 Paulinus Paulinus NNP 19613 3761 6 in in IN 19613 3761 7 Iconium Iconium NNP 19613 3761 8 , , , 19613 3761 9 and and CC 19613 3761 10 Theodorus Theodorus NNP 19613 3761 11 in in IN 19613 3761 12 Synnada Synnada NNP 19613 3761 13 , , , 19613 3761 14 who who WP 19613 3761 15 flourished flourish VBD 19613 3761 16 about about RB 19613 3761 17 216 216 CD 19613 3761 18 , , , 19613 3761 19 are be VBP 19613 3761 20 in in IN 19613 3761 21 addition addition NN 19613 3761 22 to to IN 19613 3761 23 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3761 24 the the DT 19613 3761 25 last last JJ 19613 3761 26 independent independent JJ 19613 3761 27 teachers teacher NNS 19613 3761 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3761 29 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 3761 30 , , , 19613 3761 31 outside outside IN 19613 3761 32 the the DT 19613 3761 33 ranks rank NNS 19613 3761 34 of of IN 19613 3761 35 the the DT 19613 3761 36 clergy clergy NN 19613 3761 37 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3761 38 known know VBN 19613 3761 39 to to IN 19613 3761 40 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3761 41 in in IN 19613 3761 42 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 3761 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3761 44 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3761 45 . . NNP 19613 3761 46 , , , 19613 3761 47 H. H. NNP 19613 3761 48 E. E. NNP 19613 3761 49 VI VI NNP 19613 3761 50 . . . 19613 3762 1 19 19 CD 19613 3762 2 fin fin NNP 19613 3762 3 . . . 19613 3762 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3762 5 . . . 19613 3762 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3763 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3763 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3763 3 268 268 CD 19613 3763 4 : : : 19613 3763 5 See see VB 19613 3763 6 Döllinger döllinger NN 19613 3763 7 , , , 19613 3763 8 Die die VB 19613 3763 9 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 3763 10 von von NNP 19613 3763 11 der der VBP 19613 3763 12 Eucharistie Eucharistie NNP 19613 3763 13 in in IN 19613 3763 14 den den NNP 19613 3763 15 ersten ersten VBN 19613 3763 16 drei drei NN 19613 3763 17 Jahrhunderten Jahrhunderten NNP 19613 3763 18 , , , 19613 3763 19 1826 1826 CD 19613 3763 20 . . . 19613 3764 1 Höfling höfle VBG 19613 3764 2 , , , 19613 3764 3 Die Die NNP 19613 3764 4 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 3764 5 der der XX 19613 3764 6 ältesten ältesten VBN 19613 3764 7 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 3764 8 vom vom NNP 19613 3764 9 Opfer Opfer NNP 19613 3764 10 , , , 19613 3764 11 p. p. NN 19613 3764 12 71 71 CD 19613 3764 13 ff ff NN 19613 3764 14 . . . 19613 3765 1 Th th UH 19613 3765 2 . . . 19613 3766 1 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 3766 2 , , , 19613 3766 3 Der Der NNP 19613 3766 4 christliche christliche NN 19613 3766 5 Gemeindegottesdienst Gemeindegottesdienst NNP 19613 3766 6 i -PRON- PRP 19613 3766 7 m be VBP 19613 3766 8 apostolischen apostolischen NNP 19613 3766 9 und und NNP 19613 3766 10 altkatholischen altkatholischen NNP 19613 3766 11 Zeitalter Zeitalter NNP 19613 3766 12 , , , 19613 3766 13 p. p. NN 19613 3766 14 342 342 CD 19613 3766 15 ff ff NN 19613 3766 16 . . . 19613 3767 1 Steitz Steitz NNP 19613 3767 2 , , , 19613 3767 3 Art art NN 19613 3767 4 . . . 19613 3768 1 " " `` 19613 3768 2 Messe Messe NNP 19613 3768 3 " " '' 19613 3768 4 in in IN 19613 3768 5 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 3768 6 's 's POS 19613 3768 7 Real Real NNP 19613 3768 8 - - HYPH 19613 3768 9 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 3768 10 , , , 19613 3768 11 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3768 12 ed ed NN 19613 3768 13 . . . 19613 3769 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3769 2 is be VBZ 19613 3769 3 idle idle JJ 19613 3769 4 to to TO 19613 3769 5 enquire enquire VB 19613 3769 6 whether whether IN 19613 3769 7 the the DT 19613 3769 8 conception conception NN 19613 3769 9 of of IN 19613 3769 10 the the DT 19613 3769 11 " " `` 19613 3769 12 sacerdotium sacerdotium NN 19613 3769 13 " " '' 19613 3769 14 or or CC 19613 3769 15 that that DT 19613 3769 16 of of IN 19613 3769 17 the the DT 19613 3769 18 " " `` 19613 3769 19 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3769 20 " " '' 19613 3769 21 was be VBD 19613 3769 22 first first RB 19613 3769 23 altered alter VBN 19613 3769 24 , , , 19613 3769 25 because because IN 19613 3769 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3769 27 are be VBP 19613 3769 28 correlative correlative JJ 19613 3769 29 ideas idea NNS 19613 3769 30 . . . 19613 3769 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3770 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3770 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3770 3 269 269 CD 19613 3770 4 : : : 19613 3770 5 See see VB 19613 3770 6 the the DT 19613 3770 7 proof proof JJ 19613 3770 8 passages passage NNS 19613 3770 9 in in IN 19613 3770 10 Höfling Höfling NNP 19613 3770 11 , , , 19613 3770 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3770 13 . . NNP 19613 3770 14 , , , 19613 3770 15 who who WP 19613 3770 16 has have VBZ 19613 3770 17 also also RB 19613 3770 18 treated treat VBN 19613 3770 19 in in IN 19613 3770 20 detail detail NN 19613 3770 21 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3770 22 and and CC 19613 3770 23 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3770 24 's 's POS 19613 3770 25 idea idea NN 19613 3770 26 of of IN 19613 3770 27 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3770 28 , , , 19613 3770 29 and and CC 19613 3770 30 cf cf NN 19613 3770 31 . . . 19613 3771 1 the the DT 19613 3771 2 beautiful beautiful JJ 19613 3771 3 saying saying NN 19613 3771 4 of of IN 19613 3771 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3771 6 IV IV NNP 19613 3771 7 . . . 19613 3772 1 18 18 CD 19613 3772 2 . . . 19613 3773 1 3 3 LS 19613 3773 2 : : : 19613 3773 3 " " `` 19613 3773 4 Non Non NNP 19613 3773 5 sacrificia sacrificia NNP 19613 3773 6 sanctificant sanctificant JJ 19613 3773 7 hominem hominem NNP 19613 3773 8 ; ; : 19613 3773 9 non non NNP 19613 3773 10 enim enim NNP 19613 3773 11 indiget indiget VBP 19613 3773 12 sacrificio sacrificio NNP 19613 3773 13 deus deus NNP 19613 3773 14 ; ; : 19613 3773 15 sed sed NNP 19613 3773 16 conscientia conscientia NNP 19613 3773 17 eius eius NNP 19613 3773 18 qui qui NNP 19613 3773 19 offert offert NNP 19613 3773 20 sanctificat sanctificat NNP 19613 3773 21 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3773 22 , , , 19613 3773 23 pura pura NNP 19613 3773 24 exsistens exsisten NNS 19613 3773 25 , , , 19613 3773 26 et et NNP 19613 3773 27 præstat præstat NNP 19613 3773 28 acceptare acceptare NNP 19613 3773 29 deum deum NNP 19613 3773 30 quasi quasi NNP 19613 3773 31 ab ab NNP 19613 3773 32 amico amico NNP 19613 3773 33 " " '' 19613 3773 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3773 35 on on IN 19613 3773 36 the the DT 19613 3773 37 offering offering NN 19613 3773 38 in in IN 19613 3773 39 the the DT 19613 3773 40 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3773 41 's 's POS 19613 3773 42 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3773 43 see see VB 19613 3773 44 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3773 45 . . . 19613 3774 1 IV IV NNP 19613 3774 2 . . . 19613 3775 1 17 17 CD 19613 3775 2 . . . 19613 3776 1 5 5 CD 19613 3776 2 , , , 19613 3776 3 18 18 CD 19613 3776 4 . . . 19613 3777 1 1 1 LS 19613 3777 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3777 3 ; ; : 19613 3777 4 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3777 5 . . NNP 19613 3777 6 , , , 19613 3777 7 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 3777 8 . . . 19613 3778 1 30 30 CD 19613 3778 2 ; ; : 19613 3778 3 de de FW 19613 3778 4 orat orat NNP 19613 3778 5 . . . 19613 3779 1 28 28 CD 19613 3779 2 ; ; : 19613 3779 3 adv adv NN 19613 3779 4 . . . 19613 3780 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 3780 2 . . . 19613 3781 1 III iii CD 19613 3781 2 . . . 19613 3782 1 22 22 CD 19613 3782 2 ; ; : 19613 3782 3 IV IV NNP 19613 3782 4 . . . 19613 3783 1 1 1 CD 19613 3783 2 , , , 19613 3783 3 35 35 CD 19613 3783 4 : : : 19613 3783 5 adv adv NN 19613 3783 6 . . . 19613 3784 1 Jud jud UH 19613 3784 2 . . . 19613 3785 1 5 5 LS 19613 3785 2 ; ; : 19613 3785 3 de de NNP 19613 3785 4 virg virg NNS 19613 3785 5 . . . 19613 3786 1 vel vel NNP 19613 3786 2 . . . 19613 3787 1 13 13 CD 19613 3787 2 . . . 19613 3787 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3788 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3788 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3788 3 270 270 CD 19613 3788 4 : : : 19613 3788 5 Cf cf NN 19613 3788 6 . . . 19613 3789 1 specially specially RB 19613 3789 2 the the DT 19613 3789 3 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 3789 4 writings writing NNS 19613 3789 5 ; ; : 19613 3789 6 the the DT 19613 3789 7 treatise treatise NNP 19613 3789 8 _ _ NNP 19613 3789 9 de de NNP 19613 3789 10 ieiunio ieiunio NNP 19613 3789 11 _ _ NNP 19613 3789 12 is be VBZ 19613 3789 13 the the DT 19613 3789 14 most most RBS 19613 3789 15 important important JJ 19613 3789 16 among among IN 19613 3789 17 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3789 18 in in IN 19613 3789 19 this this DT 19613 3789 20 case case NN 19613 3789 21 ; ; : 19613 3789 22 see see VB 19613 3789 23 cc cc NNP 19613 3789 24 . . . 19613 3790 1 7 7 CD 19613 3790 2 , , , 19613 3790 3 16 16 CD 19613 3790 4 ; ; : 19613 3790 5 de de NNP 19613 3790 6 resurr resurr NNP 19613 3790 7 . . . 19613 3791 1 8 8 LS 19613 3791 2 . . . 19613 3792 1 On on IN 19613 3792 2 the the DT 19613 3792 3 use use NN 19613 3792 4 of of IN 19613 3792 5 the the DT 19613 3792 6 word word NN 19613 3792 7 " " `` 19613 3792 8 satisfacere satisfacere NN 19613 3792 9 " " '' 19613 3792 10 and and CC 19613 3792 11 the the DT 19613 3792 12 new new JJ 19613 3792 13 ideas idea NNS 19613 3792 14 on on IN 19613 3792 15 the the DT 19613 3792 16 point point NN 19613 3792 17 which which WDT 19613 3792 18 arose arise VBD 19613 3792 19 in in IN 19613 3792 20 the the DT 19613 3792 21 West West NNP 19613 3792 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3792 23 cf cf NN 19613 3792 24 . . . 19613 3793 1 also also RB 19613 3793 2 the the DT 19613 3793 3 word word NN 19613 3793 4 " " `` 19613 3793 5 meritum meritum NN 19613 3793 6 " " '' 19613 3793 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3793 8 see see VB 19613 3793 9 below below IN 19613 3793 10 chap chap NNP 19613 3793 11 . . . 19613 3794 1 5 5 CD 19613 3794 2 . . . 19613 3795 1 2 2 CD 19613 3795 2 and and CC 19613 3795 3 the the DT 19613 3795 4 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3795 5 chap chap NN 19613 3795 6 . . . 19613 3796 1 of of IN 19613 3796 2 the the DT 19613 3796 3 5th 5th JJ 19613 3796 4 Vol Vol NNP 19613 3796 5 . . . 19613 3797 1 Note note VB 19613 3797 2 that that IN 19613 3797 3 the the DT 19613 3797 4 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3797 5 Ep Ep NNP 19613 3797 6 . . . 19613 3798 1 of of IN 19613 3798 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3798 3 already already RB 19613 3798 4 contains contain VBZ 19613 3798 5 the the DT 19613 3798 6 sayings saying NNS 19613 3798 7 : : : 19613 3798 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3798 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3798 10 : : : 19613 3798 11 kalon kalon NNP 19613 3798 12 eleêmounê eleêmounê NNP 19613 3798 13 hôs hôs NNP 19613 3798 14 metanoia metanoia NN 19613 3798 15 hamartias hamartia NNS 19613 3798 16 kreissôn kreissôn NNP 19613 3798 17 nêsteia nêsteia NNP 19613 3798 18 proseuchês proseuchês NNP 19613 3798 19 , , , 19613 3798 20 eleêmosunê eleêmosunê NNP 19613 3798 21 de de FW 19613 3798 22 amphoterôn amphoterôn NNP 19613 3798 23 ... ... : 19613 3798 24 eleêmosunê eleêmosunê NNP 19613 3798 25 gar gar NNP 19613 3798 26 kouphisma kouphisma NNP 19613 3798 27 hamartias hamartia VBZ 19613 3798 28 ginetai ginetai NNP 19613 3798 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3798 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3798 31 16 16 CD 19613 3798 32 . . . 19613 3799 1 4 4 LS 19613 3799 2 ; ; : 19613 3799 3 similar similar JJ 19613 3799 4 expressions expression NNS 19613 3799 5 occur occur VBP 19613 3799 6 in in IN 19613 3799 7 the the DT 19613 3799 8 " " `` 19613 3799 9 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 3799 10 " " '' 19613 3799 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3799 12 . . . 19613 3800 1 But but CC 19613 3800 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3800 3 only only RB 19613 3800 4 show show VBP 19613 3800 5 how how WRB 19613 3800 6 far far RB 19613 3800 7 back back RB 19613 3800 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3800 9 find find VBP 19613 3800 10 the the DT 19613 3800 11 origin origin NN 19613 3800 12 of of IN 19613 3800 13 these these DT 19613 3800 14 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 3800 15 borrowed borrow VBN 19613 3800 16 from from IN 19613 3800 17 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 3800 18 proverbial proverbial JJ 19613 3800 19 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 3800 20 . . . 19613 3801 1 One one PRP 19613 3801 2 can can MD 19613 3801 3 not not RB 19613 3801 4 say say VB 19613 3801 5 that that IN 19613 3801 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3801 7 had have VBD 19613 3801 8 no no DT 19613 3801 9 effect effect NN 19613 3801 10 at at RB 19613 3801 11 all all RB 19613 3801 12 on on IN 19613 3801 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 3801 14 life life NN 19613 3801 15 in in IN 19613 3801 16 the the DT 19613 3801 17 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3801 18 century century NN 19613 3801 19 ; ; : 19613 3801 20 but but CC 19613 3801 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3801 22 do do VBP 19613 3801 23 not not RB 19613 3801 24 yet yet RB 19613 3801 25 find find VB 19613 3801 26 the the DT 19613 3801 27 idea idea NN 19613 3801 28 that that IN 19613 3801 29 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 3801 30 performances performance NNS 19613 3801 31 are be VBP 19613 3801 32 a a DT 19613 3801 33 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3801 34 offered offer VBN 19613 3801 35 to to IN 19613 3801 36 a a DT 19613 3801 37 wrathful wrathful JJ 19613 3801 38 God God NNP 19613 3801 39 . . . 19613 3802 1 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 19613 3802 2 seems seem VBZ 19613 3802 3 to to TO 19613 3802 4 have have VB 19613 3802 5 been be VBN 19613 3802 6 earliest early RBS 19613 3802 7 viewed view VBN 19613 3802 8 as as IN 19613 3802 9 a a DT 19613 3802 10 performance performance NN 19613 3802 11 which which WDT 19613 3802 12 expiated expiate VBD 19613 3802 13 sins sin NNS 19613 3802 14 . . . 19613 3803 1 In in IN 19613 3803 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3803 3 's 's POS 19613 3803 4 time time NN 19613 3803 5 the the DT 19613 3803 6 theory theory NN 19613 3803 7 , , , 19613 3803 8 that that IN 19613 3803 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3803 10 was be VBD 19613 3803 11 on on IN 19613 3803 12 a a DT 19613 3803 13 level level NN 19613 3803 14 with with IN 19613 3803 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 3803 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3803 17 see see VB 19613 3803 18 Melito Melito NNP 19613 3803 19 , , , 19613 3803 20 12 12 CD 19613 3803 21 . . . 19613 3804 1 Fragment fragment NN 19613 3804 2 in in IN 19613 3804 3 Otto Otto NNP 19613 3804 4 , , , 19613 3804 5 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 3804 6 Apol Apol NNP 19613 3804 7 . . . 19613 3805 1 IX ix NN 19613 3805 2 . . . 19613 3806 1 p. p. NN 19613 3806 2 418 418 CD 19613 3806 3 : : : 19613 3806 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3806 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3806 6 : : : 19613 3806 7 duo duo NN 19613 3806 8 sunestê sunestê NNP 19613 3806 9 ta ta NNP 19613 3806 10 aphesin aphesin NNP 19613 3806 11 amartêmata amartêmata NNP 19613 3806 12 parechomena parechomena NNP 19613 3806 13 , , , 19613 3806 14 pathos pathos NNP 19613 3806 15 dia dia NN 19613 3806 16 Christon Christon NNP 19613 3806 17 kai kai NNP 19613 3806 18 baptisma baptisma NN 19613 3806 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3806 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3806 21 , , , 19613 3806 22 had have VBD 19613 3806 23 long long RB 19613 3806 24 been be VBN 19613 3806 25 universally universally RB 19613 3806 26 diffused diffused JJ 19613 3806 27 and and CC 19613 3806 28 was be VBD 19613 3806 29 also also RB 19613 3806 30 exegetically exegetically RB 19613 3806 31 grounded ground VBN 19613 3806 32 . . . 19613 3807 1 In in IN 19613 3807 2 fact fact NN 19613 3807 3 , , , 19613 3807 4 men man NNS 19613 3807 5 went go VBD 19613 3807 6 a a DT 19613 3807 7 step step NN 19613 3807 8 further far RBR 19613 3807 9 and and CC 19613 3807 10 asserted assert VBD 19613 3807 11 that that IN 19613 3807 12 the the DT 19613 3807 13 merits merit NNS 19613 3807 14 of of IN 19613 3807 15 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 3807 16 could could MD 19613 3807 17 also also RB 19613 3807 18 benefit benefit VB 19613 3807 19 others other NNS 19613 3807 20 . . . 19613 3808 1 This this DT 19613 3808 2 view view NN 19613 3808 3 had have VBD 19613 3808 4 likewise likewise RB 19613 3808 5 become become VBN 19613 3808 6 established establish VBN 19613 3808 7 long long RB 19613 3808 8 before before IN 19613 3808 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3808 10 's 's POS 19613 3808 11 day day NN 19613 3808 12 , , , 19613 3808 13 but but CC 19613 3808 14 was be VBD 19613 3808 15 opposed oppose VBN 19613 3808 16 by by IN 19613 3808 17 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3808 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3808 19 de de FW 19613 3808 20 pudic pudic NNP 19613 3808 21 22 22 CD 19613 3808 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3808 23 , , , 19613 3808 24 when when WRB 19613 3808 25 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 3808 26 abused abuse VBD 19613 3808 27 the the DT 19613 3808 28 powers power NNS 19613 3808 29 universally universally RB 19613 3808 30 conceded concede VBD 19613 3808 31 to to IN 19613 3808 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3808 33 . . . 19613 3809 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3809 2 went go VBD 19613 3809 3 furthest furthest RB 19613 3809 4 here here RB 19613 3809 5 ; ; : 19613 3809 6 see see VB 19613 3809 7 exhort exhort NN 19613 3809 8 . . . 19613 3810 1 ad ad NN 19613 3810 2 mart mart NNP 19613 3810 3 . . . 19613 3811 1 50 50 CD 19613 3811 2 : : : 19613 3811 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3811 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3811 5 : : : 19613 3811 6 hôsper hôsper NNP 19613 3811 7 timiô timiô NNP 19613 3811 8 haimati haimati NNP 19613 3811 9 tou tou NNP 19613 3811 10 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 3811 11 êgorasthêmen êgorasthêman NNS 19613 3811 12 ... ... NFP 19613 3811 13 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 3811 14 tô tô NNP 19613 3811 15 timiô timiô NNP 19613 3811 16 haimati haimati NNP 19613 3811 17 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3811 18 marturôn marturôn NNP 19613 3811 19 agorasthêsontai agorasthêsontai NNP 19613 3811 20 tines tines NNP 19613 3811 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3811 22 ; ; : 19613 3811 23 Hom Hom NNP 19613 3811 24 . . . 19613 3812 1 X. X. NNP 19613 3812 2 in in IN 19613 3812 3 Num Num NNP 19613 3812 4 . . . 19613 3813 1 c. c. NNP 19613 3814 1 II ii CD 19613 3814 2 . . . 19613 3815 1 : : : 19613 3815 2 " " `` 19613 3815 3 ne ne NNP 19613 3815 4 forte forte NNP 19613 3815 5 , , , 19613 3815 6 ex ex NNP 19613 3815 7 quo quo NNP 19613 3815 8 martyres martyres NNP 19613 3815 9 non non AFX 19613 3815 10 fiunt fiunt NNP 19613 3815 11 et et NNP 19613 3815 12 hostiæ hostiæ NNP 19613 3815 13 sanctorum sanctorum NNP 19613 3815 14 non non AFX 19613 3815 15 offeruntur offeruntur JJ 19613 3815 16 pro pro JJ 19613 3815 17 peccatis peccatis JJ 19613 3815 18 nostris nostris RB 19613 3815 19 , , , 19613 3815 20 peccatorum peccatorum NNP 19613 3815 21 nostrorum nostrorum NNP 19613 3815 22 remissionem remissionem NNP 19613 3815 23 non non NNP 19613 3815 24 mereamur mereamur NN 19613 3815 25 . . . 19613 3815 26 " " '' 19613 3816 1 The the DT 19613 3816 2 origin origin NN 19613 3816 3 of of IN 19613 3816 4 this this DT 19613 3816 5 thought thought NN 19613 3816 6 is be VBZ 19613 3816 7 , , , 19613 3816 8 on on IN 19613 3816 9 the the DT 19613 3816 10 one one CD 19613 3816 11 hand hand NN 19613 3816 12 , , , 19613 3816 13 to to TO 19613 3816 14 be be VB 19613 3816 15 sought seek VBN 19613 3816 16 for for IN 19613 3816 17 in in IN 19613 3816 18 the the DT 19613 3816 19 wide wide RB 19613 3816 20 - - HYPH 19613 3816 21 spread spread VBN 19613 3816 22 notion notion NN 19613 3816 23 that that IN 19613 3816 24 the the DT 19613 3816 25 sufferings suffering NNS 19613 3816 26 of of IN 19613 3816 27 an an DT 19613 3816 28 innocent innocent JJ 19613 3816 29 man man NN 19613 3816 30 benefit benefit NN 19613 3816 31 others other NNS 19613 3816 32 , , , 19613 3816 33 and and CC 19613 3816 34 , , , 19613 3816 35 on on IN 19613 3816 36 the the DT 19613 3816 37 other other JJ 19613 3816 38 , , , 19613 3816 39 in in IN 19613 3816 40 the the DT 19613 3816 41 belief belief NN 19613 3816 42 that that IN 19613 3816 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3816 44 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3816 45 suffered suffer VBD 19613 3816 46 in in IN 19613 3816 47 the the DT 19613 3816 48 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 3816 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3816 50 see see VB 19613 3816 51 , , , 19613 3816 52 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 3816 53 , , , 19613 3816 54 ep ep NNP 19613 3816 55 . . . 19613 3817 1 Lugd lugd VB 19613 3817 2 . . . 19613 3818 1 in in IN 19613 3818 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3818 3 . . NNP 19613 3818 4 , , , 19613 3818 5 H. H. NNP 19613 3818 6 E. E. NNP 19613 3818 7 V. V. NNP 19613 3818 8 1 1 CD 19613 3818 9 . . . 19613 3819 1 23 23 CD 19613 3819 2 , , , 19613 3819 3 41 41 CD 19613 3819 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3819 5 . . . 19613 3819 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3820 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3820 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3820 3 271 271 CD 19613 3820 4 : : : 19613 3820 5 In in IN 19613 3820 6 the the DT 19613 3820 7 East East NNP 19613 3820 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3820 9 was be VBD 19613 3820 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3820 11 who who WP 19613 3820 12 introduced introduce VBD 19613 3820 13 into into IN 19613 3820 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3820 15 the the DT 19613 3820 16 rich rich JJ 19613 3820 17 treasure treasure NN 19613 3820 18 of of IN 19613 3820 19 ancient ancient JJ 19613 3820 20 ideas idea NNS 19613 3820 21 that that WDT 19613 3820 22 had have VBD 19613 3820 23 become become VBN 19613 3820 24 associated associate VBN 19613 3820 25 with with IN 19613 3820 26 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 19613 3820 27 . . . 19613 3821 1 See see VB 19613 3821 2 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 3821 3 's 's POS 19613 3821 4 beautiful beautiful JJ 19613 3821 5 account account NN 19613 3821 6 in in IN 19613 3821 7 " " `` 19613 3821 8 The the DT 19613 3821 9 Christian Christian NNP 19613 3821 10 Platonists Platonists NNPS 19613 3821 11 of of IN 19613 3821 12 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 3821 13 , , , 19613 3821 14 " " '' 19613 3821 15 Lect Lect NNP 19613 3821 16 . . . 19613 3822 1 IV.-VI iv.-vi NN 19613 3822 2 . . . 19613 3822 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3823 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3823 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3823 3 272 272 CD 19613 3823 4 : : : 19613 3823 5 Moreover moreover RB 19613 3823 6 , , , 19613 3823 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3823 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3823 9 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 3823 10 . . . 19613 3824 1 6 6 LS 19613 3824 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3824 3 had have VBD 19613 3824 4 already already RB 19613 3824 5 said say VBN 19613 3824 6 : : : 19613 3824 7 " " `` 19613 3824 8 Quomodo quomodo JJ 19613 3824 9 multæ multæ NN 19613 3824 10 mansiones mansione NNS 19613 3824 11 apud apud NNPS 19613 3824 12 patrem patrem NN 19613 3824 13 , , , 19613 3824 14 si si VBP 19613 3824 15 non non AFX 19613 3824 16 pro pro FW 19613 3824 17 varietate varietate NN 19613 3824 18 meritorum meritorum NN 19613 3824 19 . . . 19613 3824 20 " " '' 19613 3824 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3825 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3825 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3825 3 273 273 CD 19613 3825 4 : : : 19613 3825 5 See see VB 19613 3825 6 c. c. NN 19613 3825 7 1 1 CD 19613 3825 8 : : : 19613 3825 9 " " `` 19613 3825 10 Nam Nam NNP 19613 3825 11 cum cum NNP 19613 3825 12 dominus dominus NN 19613 3825 13 adveniens adveniens NNP 19613 3825 14 sanasset sanasset NNP 19613 3825 15 illa illa NNP 19613 3825 16 , , , 19613 3825 17 quæ quæ NNP 19613 3825 18 Adam Adam NNP 19613 3825 19 portaverit portaverit NN 19613 3825 20 vulnera vulnera NNP 19613 3825 21 et et NNP 19613 3825 22 venena venena NNP 19613 3825 23 serpentis serpentis NNP 19613 3825 24 antiqua antiqua NNP 19613 3825 25 curasset curasset NNP 19613 3825 26 , , , 19613 3825 27 legem legem NNP 19613 3825 28 dedit dedit NNP 19613 3825 29 sano sano NNP 19613 3825 30 et et NNP 19613 3825 31 præcepit præcepit NNP 19613 3825 32 , , , 19613 3825 33 ne ne NNP 19613 3825 34 ultra ultra NNP 19613 3825 35 iam iam NNP 19613 3825 36 peccaret peccaret NNP 19613 3825 37 , , , 19613 3825 38 ne ne NNP 19613 3825 39 quid quid NNP 19613 3825 40 peccanti peccanti NNP 19613 3825 41 gravius gravius NNP 19613 3825 42 eveniret eveniret NNP 19613 3825 43 : : : 19613 3825 44 coartati coartati NNP 19613 3825 45 eramus eramus NNP 19613 3825 46 et et NNP 19613 3825 47 in in IN 19613 3825 48 augustum augustum NNP 19613 3825 49 innocentiæ innocentiæ NNP 19613 3825 50 præscriptione præscriptione NNP 19613 3825 51 conclusi conclusi NNP 19613 3825 52 , , , 19613 3825 53 nec nec NNP 19613 3825 54 haberet haberet NNP 19613 3825 55 quid quid NNP 19613 3825 56 fragilitatis fragilitatis NNP 19613 3825 57 humanæ humanæ NNP 19613 3825 58 infirmitas infirmitas NNP 19613 3825 59 adque adque NNP 19613 3825 60 imbecillitas imbecillitas NNP 19613 3825 61 faceret faceret NNP 19613 3825 62 , , , 19613 3825 63 nisi nisi NNP 19613 3825 64 iterum iterum NNP 19613 3825 65 pietas pietas NNP 19613 3825 66 divina divina NNP 19613 3825 67 subveniens subveniens NNP 19613 3825 68 iustitiæ iustitiæ NNP 19613 3825 69 et et NNP 19613 3825 70 misericordiæ misericordiæ NNP 19613 3825 71 operibus operibus NNP 19613 3825 72 ostensis ostensis NNP 19613 3825 73 viam viam NNP 19613 3825 74 quandam quandam NNP 19613 3825 75 tuendæ tuendæ NNP 19613 3825 76 salutis salutis NNP 19613 3825 77 aperiret aperiret NN 19613 3825 78 , , , 19613 3825 79 ut ut UH 19613 3825 80 sordes sorde VBZ 19613 3825 81 postmodum postmodum NN 19613 3825 82 quascumque quascumque NNP 19613 3825 83 contrahimus contrahimus NNP 19613 3825 84 eleemosynis eleemosynis NNP 19613 3825 85 abluamus abluamus NNP 19613 3825 86 . . . 19613 3825 87 " " '' 19613 3826 1 c. c. NNP 19613 3826 2 2 2 CD 19613 3826 3 : : : 19613 3826 4 " " `` 19613 3826 5 sicut sicut NNP 19613 3826 6 lavacro lavacro NNP 19613 3826 7 aquæ aquæ NNP 19613 3826 8 salutaris salutaris NNP 19613 3826 9 gehennæ gehennæ NNP 19613 3826 10 ignis ignis NNP 19613 3826 11 extinguitur extinguitur NNP 19613 3826 12 , , , 19613 3826 13 ita ita NNP 19613 3826 14 eleemosynis eleemosynis NNP 19613 3826 15 adque adque NNP 19613 3826 16 operationibus operationibus NNP 19613 3826 17 iustus iustus NNP 19613 3826 18 delictorum delictorum NNP 19613 3826 19 flamma flamma NNP 19613 3826 20 sopitur sopitur NNP 19613 3826 21 , , , 19613 3826 22 et et NNP 19613 3826 23 quia quia NN 19613 3826 24 semel semel VBP 19613 3826 25 in in IN 19613 3826 26 baptismo baptismo NNP 19613 3826 27 remissa remissa NNP 19613 3826 28 peccatorum peccatorum NNP 19613 3826 29 datur datur NNP 19613 3826 30 , , , 19613 3826 31 adsidua adsidua NNP 19613 3826 32 et et NNP 19613 3826 33 iugis iugis NNP 19613 3826 34 operatic operatic NNP 19613 3826 35 baptismi baptismi NNP 19613 3826 36 instar instar NNP 19613 3826 37 imitata imitata NNP 19613 3826 38 dei dei NNP 19613 3826 39 rursus rursus NNP 19613 3826 40 indulgentiam indulgentiam NNP 19613 3826 41 largiatur largiatur NNP 19613 3826 42 . . . 19613 3826 43 " " '' 19613 3827 1 5 5 CD 19613 3827 2 , , , 19613 3827 3 6 6 CD 19613 3827 4 , , , 19613 3827 5 9 9 CD 19613 3827 6 . . . 19613 3828 1 In in IN 19613 3828 2 c. c. NN 19613 3828 3 18 18 CD 19613 3828 4 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3828 5 already already RB 19613 3828 6 established establish VBD 19613 3828 7 an an DT 19613 3828 8 arithmetical arithmetical JJ 19613 3828 9 relation relation NN 19613 3828 10 between between IN 19613 3828 11 the the DT 19613 3828 12 number number NN 19613 3828 13 of of IN 19613 3828 14 alms alm NNS 19613 3828 15 - - HYPH 19613 3828 16 offerings offering NNS 19613 3828 17 and and CC 19613 3828 18 the the DT 19613 3828 19 blotting blotting NN 19613 3828 20 out out IN 19613 3828 21 of of IN 19613 3828 22 sins sin NNS 19613 3828 23 , , , 19613 3828 24 and and CC 19613 3828 25 in in IN 19613 3828 26 c. c. NNP 19613 3828 27 21 21 CD 19613 3828 28 , , , 19613 3828 29 in in IN 19613 3828 30 accordance accordance NN 19613 3828 31 with with IN 19613 3828 32 an an DT 19613 3828 33 ancient ancient JJ 19613 3828 34 idea idea NN 19613 3828 35 which which WDT 19613 3828 36 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3828 37 and and CC 19613 3828 38 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 3828 39 Felix Felix NNP 19613 3828 40 , , , 19613 3828 41 however however RB 19613 3828 42 , , , 19613 3828 43 only only RB 19613 3828 44 applied apply VBN 19613 3828 45 to to IN 19613 3828 46 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 3828 47 , , , 19613 3828 48 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3828 49 describes describe VBZ 19613 3828 50 the the DT 19613 3828 51 giving giving NN 19613 3828 52 of of IN 19613 3828 53 alms alm NNS 19613 3828 54 as as IN 19613 3828 55 a a DT 19613 3828 56 spectacle spectacle NN 19613 3828 57 for for IN 19613 3828 58 God God NNP 19613 3828 59 and and CC 19613 3828 60 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3828 61 . . . 19613 3829 1 In in IN 19613 3829 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3829 3 's 's POS 19613 3829 4 epistles epistle NNS 19613 3829 5 " " `` 19613 3829 6 satisfacere satisfacere JJR 19613 3829 7 deo deo NNP 19613 3829 8 " " '' 19613 3829 9 is be VBZ 19613 3829 10 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 3829 11 frequent frequent JJ 19613 3829 12 . . . 19613 3830 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3830 2 is be VBZ 19613 3830 3 almost almost RB 19613 3830 4 still still RB 19613 3830 5 more more RBR 19613 3830 6 important important JJ 19613 3830 7 to to TO 19613 3830 8 note note VB 19613 3830 9 the the DT 19613 3830 10 frequent frequent JJ 19613 3830 11 use use NN 19613 3830 12 of of IN 19613 3830 13 the the DT 19613 3830 14 expression expression NN 19613 3830 15 " " `` 19613 3830 16 promereri promereri NNP 19613 3830 17 deum deum NNP 19613 3830 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3830 19 iudicem iudicem UH 19613 3830 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3830 21 " " '' 19613 3830 22 in in IN 19613 3830 23 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3830 24 . . . 19613 3831 1 See see VB 19613 3831 2 de de NNP 19613 3831 3 unitate unitate NNP 19613 3831 4 15 15 CD 19613 3831 5 : : : 19613 3831 6 " " `` 19613 3831 7 iustitia iustitia NNP 19613 3831 8 opus opus NNP 19613 3831 9 est est NNP 19613 3831 10 , , , 19613 3831 11 ut ut NNP 19613 3831 12 promereri promereri NNP 19613 3831 13 quis quis NNP 19613 3831 14 possit possit NNP 19613 3831 15 deum deum NNP 19613 3831 16 iudicem iudicem NNP 19613 3831 17 : : : 19613 3831 18 præceptis præceptis NNP 19613 3831 19 eius eius NNP 19613 3831 20 et et NNP 19613 3831 21 monitis monitis NNP 19613 3831 22 obtemperandum obtemperandum NNP 19613 3831 23 est est NNP 19613 3831 24 , , , 19613 3831 25 ut ut UH 19613 3831 26 accipiant accipiant NNP 19613 3831 27 merita merita NNP 19613 3831 28 nostra nostra NNP 19613 3831 29 mercedem mercedem NNP 19613 3831 30 . . . 19613 3831 31 " " '' 19613 3832 1 18 18 CD 19613 3832 2 ; ; : 19613 3832 3 de de NNP 19613 3832 4 lapsis lapsis NNP 19613 3832 5 31 31 CD 19613 3832 6 ; ; : 19613 3832 7 de de FW 19613 3832 8 orat orat NNP 19613 3832 9 . . . 19613 3833 1 8 8 CD 19613 3833 2 , , , 19613 3833 3 32 32 CD 19613 3833 4 , , , 19613 3833 5 36 36 CD 19613 3833 6 ; ; : 19613 3833 7 de de NNP 19613 3833 8 mortal mortal NNP 19613 3833 9 . . . 19613 3834 1 10 10 CD 19613 3834 2 ; ; : 19613 3834 3 de de FW 19613 3834 4 op op NN 19613 3834 5 . . . 19613 3835 1 11 11 CD 19613 3835 2 , , , 19613 3835 3 14 14 CD 19613 3835 4 , , , 19613 3835 5 15 15 CD 19613 3835 6 , , , 19613 3835 7 26 26 CD 19613 3835 8 ; ; : 19613 3835 9 de de FW 19613 3835 10 bono bono FW 19613 3835 11 pat pat NNP 19613 3835 12 . . . 19613 3836 1 18 18 CD 19613 3836 2 ; ; : 19613 3836 3 ep ep ADD 19613 3836 4 . . . 19613 3837 1 62 62 CD 19613 3837 2 . . . 19613 3838 1 2 2 LS 19613 3838 2 : : SYM 19613 3838 3 73 73 CD 19613 3838 4 . . . 19613 3839 1 10 10 CD 19613 3839 2 . . . 19613 3840 1 Here here RB 19613 3840 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3840 3 is be VBZ 19613 3840 4 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 3840 5 assumed assume VBN 19613 3840 6 that that IN 19613 3840 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3840 8 acquire acquire VBP 19613 3840 9 God God NNP 19613 3840 10 's 's POS 19613 3840 11 favour favour NN 19613 3840 12 by by IN 19613 3840 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3840 14 works work NNS 19613 3840 15 . . . 19613 3840 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3841 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3841 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3841 3 274 274 CD 19613 3841 4 : : : 19613 3841 5 Baptism baptism NN 19613 3841 6 with with IN 19613 3841 7 blood blood NN 19613 3841 8 is be VBZ 19613 3841 9 not not RB 19613 3841 10 referred refer VBN 19613 3841 11 to to IN 19613 3841 12 here here RB 19613 3841 13 . . . 19613 3841 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3842 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3842 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3842 3 275 275 CD 19613 3842 4 : : : 19613 3842 5 With with IN 19613 3842 6 modifications modification NNS 19613 3842 7 , , , 19613 3842 8 this this DT 19613 3842 9 has have VBZ 19613 3842 10 still still RB 19613 3842 11 continued continue VBN 19613 3842 12 to to TO 19613 3842 13 be be VB 19613 3842 14 the the DT 19613 3842 15 case case NN 19613 3842 16 beyond beyond IN 19613 3842 17 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 3842 18 's 's POS 19613 3842 19 time time NN 19613 3842 20 down down RP 19613 3842 21 to to IN 19613 3842 22 the the DT 19613 3842 23 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 19613 3842 24 of of IN 19613 3842 25 the the DT 19613 3842 26 present present JJ 19613 3842 27 day day NN 19613 3842 28 . . . 19613 3843 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3843 2 is be VBZ 19613 3843 3 the the DT 19613 3843 4 father father NN 19613 3843 5 of of IN 19613 3843 6 the the DT 19613 3843 7 Romish romish JJ 19613 3843 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 3843 9 of of IN 19613 3843 10 good good JJ 19613 3843 11 works work NNS 19613 3843 12 and and CC 19613 3843 13 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3843 14 . . . 19613 3844 1 Yet yet RB 19613 3844 2 is be VBZ 19613 3844 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3844 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3844 5 that that IN 19613 3844 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3844 7 was be VBD 19613 3844 8 not not RB 19613 3844 9 yet yet RB 19613 3844 10 familiar familiar JJ 19613 3844 11 with with IN 19613 3844 12 the the DT 19613 3844 13 theory theory NN 19613 3844 14 according accord VBG 19613 3844 15 to to IN 19613 3844 16 which which WDT 19613 3844 17 man man NN 19613 3844 18 _ _ NNP 19613 3844 19 must must MD 19613 3844 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3844 21 acquire acquire VB 19613 3844 22 _ _ NNP 19613 3844 23 merita merita NNP 19613 3844 24 _ _ NNP 19613 3844 25 . . . 19613 3845 1 In in IN 19613 3845 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3845 3 mind mind NN 19613 3845 4 " " `` 19613 3845 5 merits merit NNS 19613 3845 6 " " '' 19613 3845 7 and and CC 19613 3845 8 " " `` 19613 3845 9 blessedness blessedness NN 19613 3845 10 " " '' 19613 3845 11 are be VBP 19613 3845 12 not not RB 19613 3845 13 yet yet RB 19613 3845 14 rigidly rigidly RB 19613 3845 15 correlated correlate VBN 19613 3845 16 ideas idea NNS 19613 3845 17 ; ; : 19613 3845 18 but but CC 19613 3845 19 the the DT 19613 3845 20 rudiments rudiment NNS 19613 3845 21 of of IN 19613 3845 22 this this DT 19613 3845 23 view view NN 19613 3845 24 are be VBP 19613 3845 25 also also RB 19613 3845 26 found find VBN 19613 3845 27 in in IN 19613 3845 28 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3845 29 ; ; : 19613 3845 30 cf cf NNP 19613 3845 31 . . . 19613 3846 1 de de NNP 19613 3846 2 unit unit NN 19613 3846 3 . . . 19613 3847 1 15 15 CD 19613 3847 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3847 3 see see VB 19613 3847 4 p. p. NN 19613 3847 5 134 134 CD 19613 3847 6 , , , 19613 3847 7 note note VBP 19613 3847 8 3 3 CD 19613 3847 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3847 10 . . . 19613 3847 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3848 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3848 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3848 3 276 276 CD 19613 3848 4 : : : 19613 3848 5 " " `` 19613 3848 6 Sacrificare Sacrificare NNP 19613 3848 7 , , , 19613 3848 8 " " '' 19613 3848 9 " " `` 19613 3848 10 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3848 11 celebrare celebrare NN 19613 3848 12 , , , 19613 3848 13 " " '' 19613 3848 14 in in IN 19613 3848 15 all all DT 19613 3848 16 passages passage NNS 19613 3848 17 where where WRB 19613 3848 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3848 19 are be VBP 19613 3848 20 unaccompanied unaccompanied JJ 19613 3848 21 by by IN 19613 3848 22 any any DT 19613 3848 23 qualifying qualifying NN 19613 3848 24 words word NNS 19613 3848 25 , , , 19613 3848 26 mean mean VB 19613 3848 27 to to TO 19613 3848 28 celebrate celebrate VB 19613 3848 29 the the DT 19613 3848 30 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3848 31 's 's POS 19613 3848 32 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3848 33 . . . 19613 3849 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3849 2 has have VBZ 19613 3849 3 never never RB 19613 3849 4 called call VBN 19613 3849 5 prayer prayer NN 19613 3849 6 a a DT 19613 3849 7 " " `` 19613 3849 8 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3849 9 " " '' 19613 3849 10 without without IN 19613 3849 11 qualifying qualify VBG 19613 3849 12 terms term NNS 19613 3849 13 ; ; , 19613 3849 14 on on IN 19613 3849 15 the the DT 19613 3849 16 contrary contrary NN 19613 3849 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3849 18 collocates collocate VBZ 19613 3849 19 " " `` 19613 3849 20 preces prece NNS 19613 3849 21 " " '' 19613 3849 22 and and CC 19613 3849 23 " " `` 19613 3849 24 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3849 25 , , , 19613 3849 26 " " '' 19613 3849 27 and and CC 19613 3849 28 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 3849 29 also also RB 19613 3849 30 " " `` 19613 3849 31 oblatio oblatio NN 19613 3849 32 " " '' 19613 3849 33 and and CC 19613 3849 34 " " `` 19613 3849 35 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3849 36 . . . 19613 3849 37 " " '' 19613 3850 1 The the DT 19613 3850 2 former former JJ 19613 3850 3 is be VBZ 19613 3850 4 then then RB 19613 3850 5 the the DT 19613 3850 6 offering offering NN 19613 3850 7 of of IN 19613 3850 8 the the DT 19613 3850 9 laity laity NN 19613 3850 10 and and CC 19613 3850 11 the the DT 19613 3850 12 latter latter JJ 19613 3850 13 of of IN 19613 3850 14 the the DT 19613 3850 15 priests priest NNS 19613 3850 16 . . . 19613 3850 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3851 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3851 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3851 3 277 277 CD 19613 3851 4 : : : 19613 3851 5 Cf cf NN 19613 3851 6 . . . 19613 3852 1 the the DT 19613 3852 2 whole whole JJ 19613 3852 3 63rd 63rd JJ 19613 3852 4 epistle epistle NN 19613 3852 5 and and CC 19613 3852 6 above above IN 19613 3852 7 all all DT 19613 3852 8 c. c. NN 19613 3852 9 7 7 CD 19613 3852 10 : : : 19613 3852 11 " " `` 19613 3852 12 Et Et NNP 19613 3852 13 quia quia NN 19613 3852 14 passionis passionis NNP 19613 3852 15 eius eius NNP 19613 3852 16 mentionem mentionem NNP 19613 3852 17 in in IN 19613 3852 18 sacrificiis sacrificiis NNP 19613 3852 19 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 3852 20 facimus facimus NNP 19613 3852 21 , , , 19613 3852 22 passio passio NNP 19613 3852 23 est est NNP 19613 3852 24 enim enim NNP 19613 3852 25 domini domini NNP 19613 3852 26 sacrificium sacrificium NNP 19613 3852 27 quod quod NNP 19613 3852 28 offerrimus offerrimus NNP 19613 3852 29 , , , 19613 3852 30 nihil nihil NNP 19613 3852 31 aliud aliud NNP 19613 3852 32 quam quam NNP 19613 3852 33 quod quod NNP 19613 3852 34 ille ille NNP 19613 3852 35 fecit fecit NNP 19613 3852 36 facere facere NNP 19613 3852 37 debemus debemus NNP 19613 3852 38 ; ; : 19613 3852 39 " " `` 19613 3852 40 c. c. NNP 19613 3852 41 9 9 CD 19613 3852 42 . . . 19613 3852 43 : : : 19613 3852 44 " " `` 19613 3852 45 unde unde NNP 19613 3852 46 apparet apparet NNP 19613 3852 47 sanguinem sanguinem NNP 19613 3852 48 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3852 49 non non NNP 19613 3852 50 offerri offerri NNP 19613 3852 51 , , , 19613 3852 52 si si NNP 19613 3852 53 desit desit NNP 19613 3852 54 vinum vinum NNP 19613 3852 55 calici calici NNP 19613 3852 56 . . . 19613 3852 57 " " '' 19613 3853 1 13 13 CD 19613 3853 2 ; ; : 19613 3853 3 de de NNP 19613 3853 4 unit unit NN 19613 3853 5 . . . 19613 3854 1 17 17 CD 19613 3854 2 : : : 19613 3854 3 " " `` 19613 3854 4 dominicæ dominicæ NNP 19613 3854 5 hostiæ hostiæ NNP 19613 3854 6 veritatem veritatem NNP 19613 3854 7 per per IN 19613 3854 8 falsa falsa FW 19613 3854 9 sacrificia sacrificia NNP 19613 3854 10 profanare profanare NNP 19613 3854 11 ; ; : 19613 3854 12 " " '' 19613 3854 13 ep ep NNP 19613 3854 14 . . . 19613 3855 1 63 63 CD 19613 3855 2 . . . 19613 3856 1 4 4 LS 19613 3856 2 : : : 19613 3856 3 " " `` 19613 3856 4 sacramentum sacramentum NNP 19613 3856 5 sacrificii sacrificii NNP 19613 3856 6 dominici dominici NNP 19613 3856 7 . . . 19613 3856 8 " " '' 19613 3857 1 The the DT 19613 3857 2 transference transference NN 19613 3857 3 of of IN 19613 3857 4 the the DT 19613 3857 5 sacrificial sacrificial JJ 19613 3857 6 idea idea NN 19613 3857 7 to to IN 19613 3857 8 the the DT 19613 3857 9 consecrated consecrate VBN 19613 3857 10 elements element NNS 19613 3857 11 , , , 19613 3857 12 which which WDT 19613 3857 13 , , , 19613 3857 14 in in IN 19613 3857 15 all all DT 19613 3857 16 probability probability NN 19613 3857 17 , , , 19613 3857 18 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3857 19 already already RB 19613 3857 20 found find VBD 19613 3857 21 in in IN 19613 3857 22 existence existence NN 19613 3857 23 , , , 19613 3857 24 is be VBZ 19613 3857 25 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 3857 26 based base VBN 19613 3857 27 on on IN 19613 3857 28 the the DT 19613 3857 29 effort effort NN 19613 3857 30 to to TO 19613 3857 31 include include VB 19613 3857 32 the the DT 19613 3857 33 element element NN 19613 3857 34 of of IN 19613 3857 35 mystery mystery NN 19613 3857 36 and and CC 19613 3857 37 magic magic NN 19613 3857 38 in in IN 19613 3857 39 the the DT 19613 3857 40 specifically specifically RB 19613 3857 41 sacerdotal sacerdotal JJ 19613 3857 42 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 3857 43 of of IN 19613 3857 44 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3857 45 , , , 19613 3857 46 and and CC 19613 3857 47 to to TO 19613 3857 48 make make VB 19613 3857 49 the the DT 19613 3857 50 Christian christian JJ 19613 3857 51 offering offering NN 19613 3857 52 assume assume NN 19613 3857 53 , , , 19613 3857 54 though though IN 19613 3857 55 not not RB 19613 3857 56 visibly visibly RB 19613 3857 57 , , , 19613 3857 58 the the DT 19613 3857 59 form form NN 19613 3857 60 of of IN 19613 3857 61 a a DT 19613 3857 62 bloody bloody JJ 19613 3857 63 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3857 64 , , , 19613 3857 65 such such JJ 19613 3857 66 as as IN 19613 3857 67 secularised secularise VBN 19613 3857 68 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 3857 69 desired desire VBD 19613 3857 70 . . . 19613 3858 1 This this DT 19613 3858 2 transference transference NN 19613 3858 3 , , , 19613 3858 4 however however RB 19613 3858 5 , , , 19613 3858 6 was be VBD 19613 3858 7 the the DT 19613 3858 8 result result NN 19613 3858 9 of of IN 19613 3858 10 two two CD 19613 3858 11 causes cause NNS 19613 3858 12 . . . 19613 3859 1 The the DT 19613 3859 2 first first JJ 19613 3859 3 has have VBZ 19613 3859 4 been be VBN 19613 3859 5 already already RB 19613 3859 6 rightly rightly RB 19613 3859 7 stated state VBN 19613 3859 8 by by IN 19613 3859 9 Ernesti Ernesti NNP 19613 3859 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3859 11 Antimur Antimur NNP 19613 3859 12 . . . 19613 3860 1 p. p. NN 19613 3860 2 94 94 CD 19613 3860 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3860 4 in in IN 19613 3860 5 the the DT 19613 3860 6 words word NNS 19613 3860 7 : : : 19613 3860 8 " " `` 19613 3860 9 quia quia NNP 19613 3860 10 eucharistia eucharistia NN 19613 3860 11 habet habet NN 19613 3860 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3860 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3860 14 : : : 19613 3860 15 anamnêsin anamnêsin NN 19613 3860 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3860 17 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3860 18 mortui mortui NNP 19613 3860 19 et et NNP 19613 3860 20 sacrificii sacrificii NNP 19613 3860 21 eius eius NNP 19613 3860 22 in in IN 19613 3860 23 cruce cruce NNP 19613 3860 24 peracti peracti NN 19613 3860 25 , , , 19613 3860 26 propter propter NNP 19613 3860 27 ea ea NNP 19613 3860 28 paullatim paullatim NNP 19613 3860 29 coepta coepta NNP 19613 3860 30 est est NNP 19613 3860 31 tota tota NNP 19613 3860 32 eucharistia eucharistia NNP 19613 3860 33 sacrificium sacrificium NNP 19613 3860 34 dici dici NNP 19613 3860 35 . . . 19613 3860 36 " " '' 19613 3861 1 In in IN 19613 3861 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3861 3 's 's POS 19613 3861 4 63rd 63rd JJ 19613 3861 5 epistle epistle NN 19613 3861 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3861 7 is be VBZ 19613 3861 8 still still RB 19613 3861 9 observable observable JJ 19613 3861 10 how how WRB 19613 3861 11 the the DT 19613 3861 12 " " `` 19613 3861 13 calicem calicem NNS 19613 3861 14 in in IN 19613 3861 15 commemorationem commemorationem NNP 19613 3861 16 domini domini NNP 19613 3861 17 et et NNP 19613 3861 18 passionis passionis NNP 19613 3861 19 eius eius NNP 19613 3861 20 offerre offerre NNP 19613 3861 21 " " `` 19613 3861 22 passes pass VBZ 19613 3861 23 over over RP 19613 3861 24 into into IN 19613 3861 25 the the DT 19613 3861 26 " " `` 19613 3861 27 sanguinem sanguinem JJ 19613 3861 28 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3861 29 offerre offerre JJ 19613 3861 30 , , , 19613 3861 31 " " `` 19613 3861 32 see see VB 19613 3861 33 also also RB 19613 3861 34 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3861 35 . . . 19613 3862 1 demonstr demonstr NNP 19613 3862 2 . . . 19613 3863 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3864 1 13 13 CD 19613 3864 2 : : : 19613 3864 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3864 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3864 5 : : : 19613 3864 6 mnêmên mnêmên NNP 19613 3864 7 tês tês NNP 19613 3864 8 thysias thysias NNP 19613 3864 9 Christou Christou NNP 19613 3864 10 prospherein prospherein NN 19613 3864 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3864 12 and and CC 19613 3864 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3864 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3864 15 : : : 19613 3864 16 tên tên NNP 19613 3864 17 ensarkon ensarkon NNP 19613 3864 18 tou tou NNP 19613 3864 19 Christou Christou NNP 19613 3864 20 parousian parousian NN 19613 3864 21 kai kai NNP 19613 3864 22 to to TO 19613 3864 23 katartisthen katartisthen NNP 19613 3864 24 autou autou NNP 19613 3864 25 sôma sôma NNP 19613 3864 26 prospherein prospherein NNP 19613 3864 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3864 28 . . . 19613 3865 1 The the DT 19613 3865 2 other other JJ 19613 3865 3 cause cause NN 19613 3865 4 has have VBZ 19613 3865 5 been be VBN 19613 3865 6 specially specially RB 19613 3865 7 pointed point VBN 19613 3865 8 out out RP 19613 3865 9 by by IN 19613 3865 10 Theodore Theodore NNP 19613 3865 11 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 3865 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3865 13 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3865 14 . . NNP 19613 3865 15 , , , 19613 3865 16 p. p. NN 19613 3865 17 409 409 CD 19613 3865 18 f. f. NNP 19613 3865 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3865 20 . . . 19613 3866 1 In in IN 19613 3866 2 ep ep NNP 19613 3866 3 . . . 19613 3867 1 63 63 CD 19613 3867 2 . . . 19613 3868 1 2 2 LS 19613 3868 2 and and CC 19613 3868 3 in in IN 19613 3868 4 many many JJ 19613 3868 5 other other JJ 19613 3868 6 passages passage NNS 19613 3868 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3868 8 expresses express VBZ 19613 3868 9 the the DT 19613 3868 10 thought thought NN 19613 3868 11 " " '' 19613 3868 12 that that IN 19613 3868 13 in in IN 19613 3868 14 the the DT 19613 3868 15 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3868 16 's 's POS 19613 3868 17 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3868 18 nothing nothing NN 19613 3868 19 else else RB 19613 3868 20 is be VBZ 19613 3868 21 done do VBN 19613 3868 22 _ _ NNP 19613 3868 23 by by IN 19613 3868 24 _ _ NNP 19613 3868 25 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3868 26 but but CC 19613 3868 27 what what WP 19613 3868 28 the the DT 19613 3868 29 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3868 30 has have VBZ 19613 3868 31 first first RB 19613 3868 32 done do VBN 19613 3868 33 _ _ NNP 19613 3868 34 for for IN 19613 3868 35 _ _ NNP 19613 3868 36 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3868 37 . . . 19613 3868 38 " " '' 19613 3869 1 But but CC 19613 3869 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3869 3 says say VBZ 19613 3869 4 that that IN 19613 3869 5 at at IN 19613 3869 6 the the DT 19613 3869 7 institution institution NN 19613 3869 8 of of IN 19613 3869 9 the the DT 19613 3869 10 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3869 11 the the DT 19613 3869 12 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3869 13 first first RB 19613 3869 14 offered offer VBD 19613 3869 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3869 16 as as IN 19613 3869 17 a a DT 19613 3869 18 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3869 19 to to IN 19613 3869 20 God God NNP 19613 3869 21 the the DT 19613 3869 22 Father Father NNP 19613 3869 23 . . . 19613 3870 1 Consequently consequently RB 19613 3870 2 the the DT 19613 3870 3 priest priest NN 19613 3870 4 officiating officiate VBG 19613 3870 5 in in IN 19613 3870 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3870 7 's 's POS 19613 3870 8 stead stead NN 19613 3870 9 only only RB 19613 3870 10 presents present VBZ 19613 3870 11 a a DT 19613 3870 12 true true JJ 19613 3870 13 and and CC 19613 3870 14 perfect perfect JJ 19613 3870 15 offering offering NN 19613 3870 16 when when WRB 19613 3870 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3870 18 imitates imitate VBZ 19613 3870 19 what what WP 19613 3870 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3870 21 has have VBZ 19613 3870 22 done do VBN 19613 3870 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3870 24 c. c. NNP 19613 3870 25 14 14 CD 19613 3870 26 : : : 19613 3870 27 " " `` 19613 3870 28 si si IN 19613 3870 29 Christus Christus NNP 19613 3870 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 3870 31 dominus dominus NN 19613 3870 32 et et NNP 19613 3870 33 deus deus NNP 19613 3870 34 noster noster NNP 19613 3870 35 ipse ipse NNP 19613 3870 36 est est NNP 19613 3870 37 summus summus NNP 19613 3870 38 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 3870 39 dei dei NNP 19613 3870 40 patris patris NNP 19613 3870 41 et et NNP 19613 3870 42 sacrificiam sacrificiam NNP 19613 3870 43 patri patri NNP 19613 3870 44 se se NNP 19613 3870 45 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 3870 46 obtulit obtulit NNP 19613 3870 47 et et FW 19613 3870 48 hoc hoc FW 19613 3870 49 fieri fieri NNP 19613 3870 50 in in IN 19613 3870 51 sui sui NNP 19613 3870 52 commemorationem commemorationem NNP 19613 3870 53 præcepit præcepit NNP 19613 3870 54 , , , 19613 3870 55 utique utique NNP 19613 3870 56 ille ille NNP 19613 3870 57 sacerdos sacerdos NNP 19613 3870 58 vice vice NNP 19613 3870 59 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3870 60 vere vere RB 19613 3870 61 fungitur fungitur NN 19613 3870 62 , , , 19613 3870 63 qui qui UH 19613 3870 64 i -PRON- PRP 19613 3870 65 d d VBD 19613 3870 66 quod quod NN 19613 3870 67 Christus Christus NNP 19613 3870 68 fecit fecit NN 19613 3870 69 imitatur imitatur NN 19613 3870 70 et et NN 19613 3870 71 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3870 72 verum verum NNP 19613 3870 73 et et NNP 19613 3870 74 plenum plenum NNP 19613 3870 75 tunc tunc NNP 19613 3870 76 offert offert NNP 19613 3870 77 in in IN 19613 3870 78 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3870 79 deo deo NNP 19613 3870 80 patri patri NNP 19613 3870 81 , , , 19613 3870 82 si si NNP 19613 3870 83 sic sic NNP 19613 3870 84 incipiat incipiat NNP 19613 3870 85 offerre offerre NNP 19613 3870 86 secundum secundum NN 19613 3870 87 quod quod NN 19613 3870 88 ipsum ipsum NN 19613 3870 89 Christum Christum NNP 19613 3870 90 videat videat NN 19613 3870 91 obtulisse obtulisse NN 19613 3870 92 " " '' 19613 3870 93 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3870 94 . . . 19613 3871 1 This this DT 19613 3871 2 brings bring VBZ 19613 3871 3 us -PRON- PRP 19613 3871 4 to to IN 19613 3871 5 the the DT 19613 3871 6 conception conception NN 19613 3871 7 of of IN 19613 3871 8 the the DT 19613 3871 9 repetition repetition NN 19613 3871 10 of of IN 19613 3871 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3871 12 's 's POS 19613 3871 13 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3871 14 by by IN 19613 3871 15 the the DT 19613 3871 16 priest priest NN 19613 3871 17 . . . 19613 3872 1 But but CC 19613 3872 2 in in IN 19613 3872 3 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3872 4 's 's POS 19613 3872 5 case case NN 19613 3872 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 7 was be VBD 19613 3872 8 still still RB 19613 3872 9 , , , 19613 3872 10 so so RB 19613 3872 11 to to TO 19613 3872 12 speak speak VB 19613 3872 13 , , , 19613 3872 14 only only RB 19613 3872 15 a a DT 19613 3872 16 notion notion NN 19613 3872 17 verging verge VBG 19613 3872 18 on on IN 19613 3872 19 that that DT 19613 3872 20 idea idea NN 19613 3872 21 , , , 19613 3872 22 that that RB 19613 3872 23 is is RB 19613 3872 24 , , , 19613 3872 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 26 only only RB 19613 3872 27 leads lead VBZ 19613 3872 28 up up RP 19613 3872 29 to to IN 19613 3872 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 31 , , , 19613 3872 32 abstains abstain VBZ 19613 3872 33 from from IN 19613 3872 34 formulating formulate VBG 19613 3872 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 36 with with IN 19613 3872 37 precision precision NN 19613 3872 38 , , , 19613 3872 39 or or CC 19613 3872 40 drawing draw VBG 19613 3872 41 any any DT 19613 3872 42 further further JJ 19613 3872 43 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 3872 44 from from IN 19613 3872 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 46 , , , 19613 3872 47 and and CC 19613 3872 48 even even RB 19613 3872 49 threatens threaten VBZ 19613 3872 50 the the DT 19613 3872 51 idea idea NN 19613 3872 52 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 53 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 3872 54 as as IN 19613 3872 55 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 56 still still RB 19613 3872 57 appears appear VBZ 19613 3872 58 to to TO 19613 3872 59 conceive conceive VB 19613 3872 60 the the DT 19613 3872 61 " " `` 19613 3872 62 calicem calicem NNS 19613 3872 63 in in IN 19613 3872 64 commemorationem commemorationem NNP 19613 3872 65 domini domini NNP 19613 3872 66 et et NNP 19613 3872 67 passionis passionis NNP 19613 3872 68 eius eius NNP 19613 3872 69 offerre offerre NNP 19613 3872 70 " " `` 19613 3872 71 as as RB 19613 3872 72 identical identical JJ 19613 3872 73 with with IN 19613 3872 74 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3872 75 . . . 19613 3873 1 As as RB 19613 3873 2 far far RB 19613 3873 3 as as IN 19613 3873 4 the the DT 19613 3873 5 East East NNP 19613 3873 6 is be VBZ 19613 3873 7 concerned concern VBN 19613 3873 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3873 9 find find VBP 19613 3873 10 in in IN 19613 3873 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3873 12 no no DT 19613 3873 13 trace trace NN 19613 3873 14 of of IN 19613 3873 15 the the DT 19613 3873 16 assumption assumption NN 19613 3873 17 of of IN 19613 3873 18 a a DT 19613 3873 19 repeated repeat VBN 19613 3873 20 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3873 21 of of IN 19613 3873 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3873 23 . . . 19613 3874 1 But but CC 19613 3874 2 in in IN 19613 3874 3 the the DT 19613 3874 4 original original NN 19613 3874 5 of of IN 19613 3874 6 the the DT 19613 3874 7 first first JJ 19613 3874 8 6 6 CD 19613 3874 9 books book NNS 19613 3874 10 of of IN 19613 3874 11 the the DT 19613 3874 12 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 3874 13 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 3874 14 this this DT 19613 3874 15 conception conception NN 19613 3874 16 is be VBZ 19613 3874 17 also also RB 19613 3874 18 wanting want VBG 19613 3874 19 , , , 19613 3874 20 although although IN 19613 3874 21 the the DT 19613 3874 22 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3874 23 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 3874 24 has have VBZ 19613 3874 25 assumed assume VBN 19613 3874 26 an an DT 19613 3874 27 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 3874 28 sacerdotal sacerdotal JJ 19613 3874 29 character character NN 19613 3874 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3874 31 see see VB 19613 3874 32 II II NNP 19613 3874 33 . . . 19613 3875 1 25 25 CD 19613 3875 2 : : : 19613 3875 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3875 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3875 5 : : : 19613 3875 6 hai hai NNP 19613 3875 7 tote tote NNP 19613 3875 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3875 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3875 10 in in IN 19613 3875 11 the the DT 19613 3875 12 old old JJ 19613 3875 13 covenant covenant NN 19613 3875 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3875 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3875 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3875 17 : : : 19613 3875 18 thusiai thusiai NNP 19613 3875 19 , , , 19613 3875 20 nun nun NNP 19613 3875 21 euchai euchai NNP 19613 3875 22 kai kai NNP 19613 3875 23 deêseis deêseis NNP 19613 3875 24 kai kai NNP 19613 3875 25 eucharistiai eucharistiai NNP 19613 3875 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3875 27 . . . 19613 3876 1 II ii CD 19613 3876 2 . . . 19613 3877 1 53 53 CD 19613 3877 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3877 3 . . . 19613 3878 1 The the DT 19613 3878 2 passage passage NN 19613 3878 3 VI VI NNP 19613 3878 4 . . . 19613 3879 1 23 23 CD 19613 3879 2 : : : 19613 3879 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3879 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3879 5 : : : 19613 3879 6 anti anti NNP 19613 3879 7 thusias thusias NNP 19613 3879 8 tês tês NNP 19613 3879 9 di di NNP 19613 3879 10 ' ' POS 19613 3879 11 haimatôn haimatôn NNP 19613 3879 12 tên tên NNP 19613 3879 13 logikên logikên NNP 19613 3879 14 kai kai NNP 19613 3879 15 anaimakton anaimakton NNP 19613 3879 16 kai kai NNP 19613 3879 17 tên tên NNP 19613 3879 18 mustikên mustikên NNP 19613 3879 19 , , , 19613 3879 20 hêtis hêtis NNP 19613 3879 21 eis eis NNP 19613 3879 22 ton ton NNP 19613 3879 23 thanaton thanaton NNP 19613 3879 24 tou tou NNP 19613 3879 25 kuriou kuriou NNP 19613 3879 26 symbolôn symbolôn NNP 19613 3879 27 charin charin NNP 19613 3879 28 epiteleitai epiteleitai NNP 19613 3879 29 tou tou NNP 19613 3879 30 sômatos sômatos NNP 19613 3879 31 autou autou NNP 19613 3879 32 kai kai NNP 19613 3879 33 tou tou NNP 19613 3879 34 haimatos haimatos NNP 19613 3879 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3879 36 does do VBZ 19613 3879 37 not not RB 19613 3879 38 belong belong VB 19613 3879 39 to to IN 19613 3879 40 the the DT 19613 3879 41 original original JJ 19613 3879 42 document document NN 19613 3879 43 , , , 19613 3879 44 but but CC 19613 3879 45 to to IN 19613 3879 46 the the DT 19613 3879 47 interpolator interpolator NN 19613 3879 48 . . . 19613 3880 1 With with IN 19613 3880 2 the the DT 19613 3880 3 exception exception NN 19613 3880 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 3880 5 of of IN 19613 3880 6 one one CD 19613 3880 7 passage passage NN 19613 3880 8 in in IN 19613 3880 9 the the DT 19613 3880 10 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 3880 11 Church Church NNP 19613 3880 12 order order NN 19613 3880 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3880 14 printed print VBN 19613 3880 15 in in IN 19613 3880 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3880 17 edition edition NN 19613 3880 18 of of IN 19613 3880 19 the the DT 19613 3880 20 Didache Didache NNP 19613 3880 21 prolegg prolegg NN 19613 3880 22 . . . 19613 3881 1 p. p. NN 19613 3881 2 236 236 CD 19613 3881 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3881 4 viz viz NN 19613 3881 5 . . . 19613 3882 1 : : : 19613 3882 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3882 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3882 4 : : : 19613 3882 5 hê hê NNP 19613 3882 6 prosphora prosphora NNP 19613 3882 7 tou tou NNP 19613 3882 8 sômatos sômatos NNP 19613 3882 9 kai kai NNP 19613 3882 10 tou tou NNP 19613 3882 11 haimatos haimatos NNP 19613 3882 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3882 13 , , , 19613 3882 14 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3882 15 possess possess VBP 19613 3882 16 no no DT 19613 3882 17 proofs proof NNS 19613 3882 18 that that IN 19613 3882 19 there there EX 19613 3882 20 was be VBD 19613 3882 21 any any DT 19613 3882 22 mention mention NN 19613 3882 23 in in IN 19613 3882 24 the the DT 19613 3882 25 East East NNP 19613 3882 26 before before IN 19613 3882 27 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 3882 28 ' ' POS 19613 3882 29 time time NN 19613 3882 30 of of IN 19613 3882 31 a a DT 19613 3882 32 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3882 33 of of IN 19613 3882 34 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3882 35 's 's POS 19613 3882 36 body body NN 19613 3882 37 in in IN 19613 3882 38 the the DT 19613 3882 39 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3882 40 's 's POS 19613 3882 41 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3882 42 . . . 19613 3883 1 From from IN 19613 3883 2 this this DT 19613 3883 3 , , , 19613 3883 4 however however RB 19613 3883 5 , , , 19613 3883 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3883 7 must must MD 19613 3883 8 by by IN 19613 3883 9 no no DT 19613 3883 10 means mean NNS 19613 3883 11 conclude conclude VB 19613 3883 12 that that IN 19613 3883 13 the the DT 19613 3883 14 mystic mystic JJ 19613 3883 15 feature feature NN 19613 3883 16 in in IN 19613 3883 17 the the DT 19613 3883 18 celebration celebration NN 19613 3883 19 of of IN 19613 3883 20 the the DT 19613 3883 21 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 3883 22 had have VBD 19613 3883 23 been be VBN 19613 3883 24 less less RBR 19613 3883 25 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 3883 26 there there RB 19613 3883 27 . . . 19613 3883 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3884 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3884 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3884 3 278 278 CD 19613 3884 4 : : : 19613 3884 5 In in IN 19613 3884 6 ep ep NNP 19613 3884 7 . . . 19613 3885 1 63 63 CD 19613 3885 2 . . . 19613 3886 1 13 13 CD 19613 3886 2 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3886 3 has have VBZ 19613 3886 4 illustrated illustrate VBN 19613 3886 5 the the DT 19613 3886 6 incorporation incorporation NN 19613 3886 7 of of IN 19613 3886 8 the the DT 19613 3886 9 community community NN 19613 3886 10 with with IN 19613 3886 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3886 12 by by IN 19613 3886 13 the the DT 19613 3886 14 mixture mixture NN 19613 3886 15 of of IN 19613 3886 16 wine wine NN 19613 3886 17 and and CC 19613 3886 18 water water NN 19613 3886 19 in in IN 19613 3886 20 the the DT 19613 3886 21 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3886 22 , , , 19613 3886 23 because because IN 19613 3886 24 the the DT 19613 3886 25 special special JJ 19613 3886 26 aim aim NN 19613 3886 27 of of IN 19613 3886 28 the the DT 19613 3886 29 epistle epistle NN 19613 3886 30 required require VBD 19613 3886 31 this this DT 19613 3886 32 : : : 19613 3886 33 " " `` 19613 3886 34 Videmus Videmus NNP 19613 3886 35 in in IN 19613 3886 36 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3886 37 populum populum NNP 19613 3886 38 intellegi intellegi NNP 19613 3886 39 , , , 19613 3886 40 in in IN 19613 3886 41 vino vino JJ 19613 3886 42 vero vero NN 19613 3886 43 ostendi ostendi VBD 19613 3886 44 sanguinem sanguinem NNP 19613 3886 45 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3886 46 ; ; : 19613 3886 47 quando quando NNP 19613 3886 48 autem autem NNP 19613 3886 49 in in IN 19613 3886 50 calice calice NNP 19613 3886 51 vino vino NNP 19613 3886 52 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3886 53 miscetur miscetur NNP 19613 3886 54 , , , 19613 3886 55 Christo Christo NNP 19613 3886 56 populus populus NN 19613 3886 57 adunatur adunatur NN 19613 3886 58 et et NN 19613 3886 59 credentium credentium NN 19613 3886 60 plebs plebs NNP 19613 3886 61 ei ei NNP 19613 3886 62 in in IN 19613 3886 63 quem quem NNP 19613 3886 64 credidit credidit NNP 19613 3886 65 copulatur copulatur NNP 19613 3886 66 et et NNP 19613 3886 67 iungitur iungitur NNP 19613 3886 68 etc etc FW 19613 3886 69 . . . 19613 3886 70 " " '' 19613 3887 1 The the DT 19613 3887 2 special special JJ 19613 3887 3 mention mention NN 19613 3887 4 of of IN 19613 3887 5 the the DT 19613 3887 6 offerers offerer NNS 19613 3887 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3887 8 see see VB 19613 3887 9 already already RB 19613 3887 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3887 11 's 's POS 19613 3887 12 works work NNS 19613 3887 13 : : : 19613 3887 14 de de NNP 19613 3887 15 corona corona NNP 19613 3887 16 3 3 CD 19613 3887 17 , , , 19613 3887 18 de de FW 19613 3887 19 exhort exhort NN 19613 3887 20 . . . 19613 3888 1 cast cast NNP 19613 3888 2 . . . 19613 3889 1 II II NNP 19613 3889 2 , , , 19613 3889 3 and and CC 19613 3889 4 de de NNP 19613 3889 5 monog monog NNP 19613 3889 6 . . . 19613 3890 1 10 10 LS 19613 3890 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3890 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 3890 4 means mean VBZ 19613 3890 5 that that IN 19613 3890 6 the the DT 19613 3890 7 latter latter JJ 19613 3890 8 commend commend VB 19613 3890 9 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3890 10 to to IN 19613 3890 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 3890 12 as as IN 19613 3890 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3890 14 own own JJ 19613 3890 15 people people NNS 19613 3890 16 , , , 19613 3890 17 or or CC 19613 3890 18 are be VBP 19613 3890 19 recommended recommend VBN 19613 3890 20 to to IN 19613 3890 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 3890 22 as as IN 19613 3890 23 such such JJ 19613 3890 24 . . . 19613 3891 1 On on IN 19613 3891 2 the the DT 19613 3891 3 Praxis praxi NNS 19613 3891 4 see see VB 19613 3891 5 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3891 6 ep ep VB 19613 3891 7 . . . 19613 3892 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3893 1 2 2 LS 19613 3893 2 " " `` 19613 3893 3 ... ... : 19613 3893 4 si si NNP 19613 3893 5 quis quis NNP 19613 3893 6 hoc hoc FW 19613 3893 7 fecisset fecisset NNP 19613 3893 8 . . . 19613 3894 1 non non JJ 19613 3894 2 offerretur offerretur NNP 19613 3894 3 pro pro NNP 19613 3894 4 eo eo NNP 19613 3894 5 nee nee JJ 19613 3894 6 sacrificium sacrificium NN 19613 3894 7 pro pro FW 19613 3894 8 dormitione dormitione NNP 19613 3894 9 eius eius NNP 19613 3894 10 celebraretur celebraretur NNP 19613 3894 11 ; ; : 19613 3894 12 " " `` 19613 3894 13 62 62 CD 19613 3894 14 . . . 19613 3895 1 5 5 CD 19613 3895 2 : : : 19613 3895 3 " " `` 19613 3895 4 ut ut FW 19613 3895 5 fratres fratre VBZ 19613 3895 6 nostros nostro NNS 19613 3895 7 in in IN 19613 3895 8 mente mente NNP 19613 3895 9 habeatis habeatis NNP 19613 3895 10 orationibus orationibus NNP 19613 3895 11 vestris vestris NNP 19613 3895 12 et et NNP 19613 3895 13 eis eis NNP 19613 3895 14 vicem vicem NNP 19613 3895 15 boni boni NNP 19613 3895 16 operis operis NNP 19613 3895 17 in in IN 19613 3895 18 sacrificiis sacrificiis NNP 19613 3895 19 et et NNP 19613 3895 20 precibus precibus NNP 19613 3895 21 repræsentetis repræsentetis NNP 19613 3895 22 , , , 19613 3895 23 subdidi subdidi NNP 19613 3895 24 nomina nomina NNP 19613 3895 25 singulorum singulorum NNP 19613 3895 26 . . . 19613 3895 27 " " '' 19613 3895 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3896 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3896 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3896 3 279 279 CD 19613 3896 4 : : : 19613 3896 5 Much much RB 19613 3896 6 as as IN 19613 3896 7 the the DT 19613 3896 8 use use NN 19613 3896 9 of of IN 19613 3896 10 the the DT 19613 3896 11 word word NN 19613 3896 12 " " `` 19613 3896 13 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 3896 14 " " '' 19613 3896 15 in in IN 19613 3896 16 the the DT 19613 3896 17 Western Western NNP 19613 3896 18 Church Church NNP 19613 3896 19 from from IN 19613 3896 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3896 21 to to IN 19613 3896 22 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 3896 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3896 24 Hahn Hahn NNP 19613 3896 25 , , , 19613 3896 26 Die die VB 19613 3896 27 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 3896 28 von von NNP 19613 3896 29 den den NN 19613 3896 30 Sacramenten Sacramenten NNP 19613 3896 31 , , , 19613 3896 32 1864 1864 CD 19613 3896 33 , , , 19613 3896 34 p. p. NN 19613 3896 35 5 5 CD 19613 3896 36 ff ff NN 19613 3896 37 . . . 19613 3896 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3897 1 differs differ NNS 19613 3897 2 from from IN 19613 3897 3 that that DT 19613 3897 4 in in IN 19613 3897 5 the the DT 19613 3897 6 classic classic JJ 19613 3897 7 Romish romish JJ 19613 3897 8 use use NN 19613 3897 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3897 10 is be VBZ 19613 3897 11 of of IN 19613 3897 12 small small JJ 19613 3897 13 interest interest NN 19613 3897 14 in in IN 19613 3897 15 the the DT 19613 3897 16 history history NN 19613 3897 17 of of IN 19613 3897 18 dogma dogma NN 19613 3897 19 to to TO 19613 3897 20 trace trace VB 19613 3897 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3897 22 various various JJ 19613 3897 23 details detail NNS 19613 3897 24 . . . 19613 3898 1 In in IN 19613 3898 2 the the DT 19613 3898 3 old old JJ 19613 3898 4 Latin Latin NNP 19613 3898 5 Bible Bible NNP 19613 3898 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3898 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3898 8 : : : 19613 3898 9 mystêrion mystêrion NN 19613 3898 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3898 11 was be VBD 19613 3898 12 translated translate VBN 19613 3898 13 " " `` 19613 3898 14 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 3898 15 " " '' 19613 3898 16 and and CC 19613 3898 17 thus thus RB 19613 3898 18 the the DT 19613 3898 19 new new JJ 19613 3898 20 signification signification NN 19613 3898 21 " " '' 19613 3898 22 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 3898 23 , , , 19613 3898 24 holy holy JJ 19613 3898 25 ordinance ordinance NN 19613 3898 26 or or CC 19613 3898 27 thing thing NN 19613 3898 28 " " '' 19613 3898 29 was be VBD 19613 3898 30 added add VBN 19613 3898 31 to to IN 19613 3898 32 the the DT 19613 3898 33 meaning meaning NN 19613 3898 34 " " `` 19613 3898 35 oath oath NN 19613 3898 36 , , , 19613 3898 37 " " '' 19613 3898 38 " " `` 19613 3898 39 sacred sacred JJ 19613 3898 40 obligation obligation NN 19613 3898 41 . . . 19613 3898 42 " " '' 19613 3899 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 3899 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3899 3 already already RB 19613 3899 4 used use VBD 19613 3899 5 the the DT 19613 3899 6 word word NN 19613 3899 7 to to TO 19613 3899 8 denote denote VB 19613 3899 9 sacred sacred JJ 19613 3899 10 facts fact NNS 19613 3899 11 , , , 19613 3899 12 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 3899 13 and and CC 19613 3899 14 salutary salutary JJ 19613 3899 15 signs sign NNS 19613 3899 16 and and CC 19613 3899 17 vehicles vehicle NNS 19613 3899 18 , , , 19613 3899 19 and and CC 19613 3899 20 also also RB 19613 3899 21 holy holy JJ 19613 3899 22 acts act NNS 19613 3899 23 . . . 19613 3900 1 Everything everything NN 19613 3900 2 in in IN 19613 3900 3 any any DT 19613 3900 4 way way NN 19613 3900 5 connected connect VBN 19613 3900 6 with with IN 19613 3900 7 the the DT 19613 3900 8 Deity Deity NNP 19613 3900 9 and and CC 19613 3900 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3900 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 3900 12 , , , 19613 3900 13 and and CC 19613 3900 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 3900 15 , , , 19613 3900 16 for for IN 19613 3900 17 example example NN 19613 3900 18 , , , 19613 3900 19 the the DT 19613 3900 20 content content NN 19613 3900 21 of of IN 19613 3900 22 revelation revelation NN 19613 3900 23 as as IN 19613 3900 24 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 3900 25 , , , 19613 3900 26 is be VBZ 19613 3900 27 designated designate VBN 19613 3900 28 " " `` 19613 3900 29 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 3900 30 ; ; : 19613 3900 31 " " '' 19613 3900 32 and and CC 19613 3900 33 the the DT 19613 3900 34 word word NN 19613 3900 35 is be VBZ 19613 3900 36 also also RB 19613 3900 37 applied apply VBN 19613 3900 38 to to IN 19613 3900 39 the the DT 19613 3900 40 symbolical symbolical JJ 19613 3900 41 which which WDT 19613 3900 42 is be VBZ 19613 3900 43 always always RB 19613 3900 44 something something NN 19613 3900 45 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 3900 46 and and CC 19613 3900 47 holy holy JJ 19613 3900 48 . . . 19613 3901 1 Alongside alongside IN 19613 3901 2 of of IN 19613 3901 3 this this DT 19613 3901 4 the the DT 19613 3901 5 old old JJ 19613 3901 6 meaning meaning NN 19613 3901 7 " " `` 19613 3901 8 sacred sacred JJ 19613 3901 9 obligation obligation NN 19613 3901 10 " " '' 19613 3901 11 still still RB 19613 3901 12 remains remain VBZ 19613 3901 13 in in IN 19613 3901 14 force force NN 19613 3901 15 . . . 19613 3902 1 If if IN 19613 3902 2 , , , 19613 3902 3 because because IN 19613 3902 4 of of IN 19613 3902 5 this this DT 19613 3902 6 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 3902 7 use use NN 19613 3902 8 , , , 19613 3902 9 further further JJ 19613 3902 10 discussion discussion NN 19613 3902 11 of of IN 19613 3902 12 the the DT 19613 3902 13 word word NN 19613 3902 14 is be VBZ 19613 3902 15 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19613 3902 16 , , , 19613 3902 17 the the DT 19613 3902 18 fact fact NN 19613 3902 19 that that IN 19613 3902 20 revelation revelation NN 19613 3902 21 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3902 22 as as RB 19613 3902 23 well well RB 19613 3902 24 as as IN 19613 3902 25 everything everything NN 19613 3902 26 connected connect VBN 19613 3902 27 with with IN 19613 3902 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3902 29 was be VBD 19613 3902 30 expressly expressly RB 19613 3902 31 designated designate VBN 19613 3902 32 as as IN 19613 3902 33 a a DT 19613 3902 34 " " `` 19613 3902 35 mystery mystery NN 19613 3902 36 " " '' 19613 3902 37 is be VBZ 19613 3902 38 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 3902 39 of of IN 19613 3902 40 importance importance NN 19613 3902 41 in in IN 19613 3902 42 the the DT 19613 3902 43 history history NN 19613 3902 44 of of IN 19613 3902 45 dogma dogma NN 19613 3902 46 . . . 19613 3903 1 This this DT 19613 3903 2 usage usage NN 19613 3903 3 of of IN 19613 3903 4 the the DT 19613 3903 5 word word NN 19613 3903 6 is be VBZ 19613 3903 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 3903 8 not not RB 19613 3903 9 removed remove VBN 19613 3903 10 from from IN 19613 3903 11 the the DT 19613 3903 12 original original JJ 19613 3903 13 one one NN 19613 3903 14 so so RB 19613 3903 15 long long RB 19613 3903 16 as as IN 19613 3903 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3903 18 was be VBD 19613 3903 19 merely merely RB 19613 3903 20 meant mean VBN 19613 3903 21 to to TO 19613 3903 22 denote denote VB 19613 3903 23 the the DT 19613 3903 24 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 3903 25 origin origin NN 19613 3903 26 and and CC 19613 3903 27 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 3903 28 nature nature NN 19613 3903 29 of of IN 19613 3903 30 the the DT 19613 3903 31 objects object NNS 19613 3903 32 in in IN 19613 3903 33 question question NN 19613 3903 34 ; ; : 19613 3903 35 but but CC 19613 3903 36 more more JJR 19613 3903 37 than than IN 19613 3903 38 this this DT 19613 3903 39 was be VBD 19613 3903 40 now now RB 19613 3903 41 intended intend VBN 19613 3903 42 ; ; : 19613 3903 43 " " `` 19613 3903 44 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 3903 45 " " '' 19613 3903 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3903 47 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3903 48 Greek greek JJ 19613 3903 49 : : : 19613 3903 50 mystêrion mystêrion NN 19613 3903 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3903 52 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3903 53 was be VBD 19613 3903 54 rather rather RB 19613 3903 55 intended intend VBN 19613 3903 56 to to TO 19613 3903 57 represent represent VB 19613 3903 58 the the DT 19613 3903 59 holy holy JJ 19613 3903 60 thing thing NN 19613 3903 61 that that WDT 19613 3903 62 was be VBD 19613 3903 63 revealed reveal VBN 19613 3903 64 as as IN 19613 3903 65 something something NN 19613 3903 66 relatively relatively RB 19613 3903 67 concealed conceal VBN 19613 3903 68 . . . 19613 3904 1 This this DT 19613 3904 2 conception conception NN 19613 3904 3 , , , 19613 3904 4 however however RB 19613 3904 5 , , , 19613 3904 6 is be VBZ 19613 3904 7 opposed opposed JJ 19613 3904 8 to to IN 19613 3904 9 the the DT 19613 3904 10 Judæo judæo JJ 19613 3904 11 - - HYPH 19613 3904 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 3904 13 idea idea NN 19613 3904 14 of of IN 19613 3904 15 revelation revelation NN 19613 3904 16 , , , 19613 3904 17 and and CC 19613 3904 18 is be VBZ 19613 3904 19 thus thus RB 19613 3904 20 to to TO 19613 3904 21 be be VB 19613 3904 22 regarded regard VBN 19613 3904 23 as as IN 19613 3904 24 an an DT 19613 3904 25 introduction introduction NN 19613 3904 26 of of IN 19613 3904 27 the the DT 19613 3904 28 Greek greek JJ 19613 3904 29 notion notion NN 19613 3904 30 . . . 19613 3905 1 Probst Probst NNP 19613 3905 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3905 3 Sacramente Sacramente NNP 19613 3905 4 und und JJ 19613 3905 5 Sacramentalia Sacramentalia NNP 19613 3905 6 , , , 19613 3905 7 1872 1872 CD 19613 3905 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3905 9 thinks think VBZ 19613 3905 10 differently differently RB 19613 3905 11 . . . 19613 3906 1 That that DT 19613 3906 2 which which WDT 19613 3906 3 is be VBZ 19613 3906 4 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 3906 5 and and CC 19613 3906 6 dark dark JJ 19613 3906 7 appears appear VBZ 19613 3906 8 to to TO 19613 3906 9 be be VB 19613 3906 10 such such PDT 19613 3906 11 an an DT 19613 3906 12 essential essential JJ 19613 3906 13 attribute attribute NN 19613 3906 14 of of IN 19613 3906 15 the the DT 19613 3906 16 divine divine JJ 19613 3906 17 , , , 19613 3906 18 that that IN 19613 3906 19 even even RB 19613 3906 20 the the DT 19613 3906 21 obscurities obscurity NNS 19613 3906 22 of of IN 19613 3906 23 the the DT 19613 3906 24 New New NNP 19613 3906 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 3906 26 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 3906 27 were be VBD 19613 3906 28 now now RB 19613 3906 29 justified justified JJ 19613 3906 30 because because IN 19613 3906 31 these these DT 19613 3906 32 writings writing NNS 19613 3906 33 were be VBD 19613 3906 34 regarded regard VBN 19613 3906 35 as as IN 19613 3906 36 altogether altogether RB 19613 3906 37 " " `` 19613 3906 38 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 3906 39 . . . 19613 3906 40 " " '' 19613 3907 1 See see VB 19613 3907 2 Iren Iren NNP 19613 3907 3 . . . 19613 3908 1 II ii CD 19613 3908 2 . . . 19613 3909 1 28 28 CD 19613 3909 2 . . . 19613 3910 1 1 1 CD 19613 3910 2 - - SYM 19613 3910 3 3 3 CD 19613 3910 4 . . . 19613 3911 1 Tert tert NN 19613 3911 2 . . . 19613 3912 1 de de NNP 19613 3912 2 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3912 3 . . . 19613 3913 1 2 2 LS 19613 3913 2 : : : 19613 3913 3 " " `` 19613 3913 4 deus deus NNP 19613 3913 5 in in IN 19613 3913 6 stultitia stultitia NNP 19613 3913 7 et et NNP 19613 3913 8 impossibilitate impossibilitate NNP 19613 3913 9 materias materias NNP 19613 3913 10 operationis operationis NNP 19613 3913 11 suæ suæ NNP 19613 3913 12 instituit instituit NN 19613 3913 13 . . . 19613 3913 14 " " '' 19613 3913 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3914 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3914 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 3914 3 280 280 CD 19613 3914 4 : : : 19613 3914 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 3914 6 have have VBP 19613 3914 7 explained explain VBN 19613 3914 8 above above IN 19613 3914 9 that that IN 19613 3914 10 the the DT 19613 3914 11 Church Church NNP 19613 3914 12 already already RB 19613 3914 13 possessed possess VBD 19613 3914 14 this this DT 19613 3914 15 means mean NNS 19613 3914 16 of of IN 19613 3914 17 grace grace NN 19613 3914 18 , , , 19613 3914 19 in in IN 19613 3914 20 so so RB 19613 3914 21 far far RB 19613 3914 22 as as IN 19613 3914 23 she -PRON- PRP 19613 3914 24 had have VBD 19613 3914 25 occasionally occasionally RB 19613 3914 26 absolved absolve VBN 19613 3914 27 mortal mortal JJ 19613 3914 28 sinners sinner NNS 19613 3914 29 , , , 19613 3914 30 even even RB 19613 3914 31 at at IN 19613 3914 32 an an DT 19613 3914 33 earlier early JJR 19613 3914 34 period period NN 19613 3914 35 ; ; : 19613 3914 36 but but CC 19613 3914 37 this this DT 19613 3914 38 possession possession NN 19613 3914 39 was be VBD 19613 3914 40 quite quite RB 19613 3914 41 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 3914 42 and and CC 19613 3914 43 , , , 19613 3914 44 strictly strictly RB 19613 3914 45 speaking speak VBG 19613 3914 46 , , , 19613 3914 47 was be VBD 19613 3914 48 not not RB 19613 3914 49 a a DT 19613 3914 50 possession possession NN 19613 3914 51 at at RB 19613 3914 52 all all RB 19613 3914 53 , , , 19613 3914 54 for for IN 19613 3914 55 in in IN 19613 3914 56 such such JJ 19613 3914 57 cases case NNS 19613 3914 58 the the DT 19613 3914 59 early early JJ 19613 3914 60 Church Church NNP 19613 3914 61 merely merely RB 19613 3914 62 followed follow VBD 19613 3914 63 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 3914 64 directions direction NNS 19613 3914 65 of of IN 19613 3914 66 the the DT 19613 3914 67 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3914 68 . . . 19613 3914 69 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3915 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3915 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3915 3 281 281 CD 19613 3915 4 : : : 19613 3915 5 Höfling höfle VBG 19613 3915 6 , , , 19613 3915 7 Das Das NNP 19613 3915 8 Sacrament Sacrament NNP 19613 3915 9 der der VBP 19613 3915 10 Taufe Taufe NNP 19613 3915 11 , , , 19613 3915 12 2 2 CD 19613 3915 13 Vols Vols NNP 19613 3915 14 . . NNP 19613 3915 15 , , , 19613 3915 16 1846 1846 CD 19613 3915 17 . . . 19613 3916 1 Steitz Steitz NNP 19613 3916 2 , , , 19613 3916 3 Art art NN 19613 3916 4 . . . 19613 3917 1 " " `` 19613 3917 2 Taufe Taufe NNP 19613 3917 3 " " '' 19613 3917 4 in in IN 19613 3917 5 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 3917 6 's 's POS 19613 3917 7 Real Real NNP 19613 3917 8 - - HYPH 19613 3917 9 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 3917 10 . . . 19613 3918 1 Walch Walch NNP 19613 3918 2 , , , 19613 3918 3 Hist Hist NNP 19613 3918 4 . . . 19613 3919 1 pædobaptismi pædobaptismi NNP 19613 3919 2 quattuor quattuor NNP 19613 3919 3 priorum priorum NNP 19613 3919 4 sæculorum sæculorum NNP 19613 3919 5 , , , 19613 3919 6 1739 1739 CD 19613 3919 7 . . . 19613 3919 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3920 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3920 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3920 3 282 282 CD 19613 3920 4 : : : 19613 3920 5 In in IN 19613 3920 6 de de FW 19613 3920 7 bono bono FW 19613 3920 8 pudic pudic FW 19613 3920 9 . . . 19613 3921 1 2 2 LS 19613 3921 2 : : : 19613 3921 3 " " `` 19613 3921 4 renati renati NNP 19613 3921 5 ex ex NNP 19613 3921 6 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3921 7 et et FW 19613 3921 8 pudicitia pudicitia NN 19613 3921 9 , , , 19613 3921 10 " " `` 19613 3921 11 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 3921 12 - - HYPH 19613 3921 13 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3921 14 expresses express VBZ 19613 3921 15 an an DT 19613 3921 16 idea idea NN 19613 3921 17 , , , 19613 3921 18 which which WDT 19613 3921 19 , , , 19613 3921 20 though though IN 19613 3921 21 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3921 22 , , , 19613 3921 23 is be VBZ 19613 3921 24 not not RB 19613 3921 25 confined confine VBN 19613 3921 26 to to IN 19613 3921 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3921 28 . . . 19613 3921 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3922 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3922 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3922 3 283 283 CD 19613 3922 4 : : : 19613 3922 5 But but CC 19613 3922 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3922 7 says say VBZ 19613 3922 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3922 9 de de FW 19613 3922 10 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3922 11 . . . 19613 3923 1 6 6 LS 19613 3923 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3923 3 : : : 19613 3923 4 " " `` 19613 3923 5 Non non JJ 19613 3923 6 quod quod NN 19613 3923 7 in in IN 19613 3923 8 aquis aquis NNP 19613 3923 9 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 3923 10 sanctum sanctum NNP 19613 3923 11 consequamur consequamur NNP 19613 3923 12 , , , 19613 3923 13 sed se VBN 19613 3923 14 in in IN 19613 3923 15 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3923 16 emundati emundati NNP 19613 3923 17 sub sub NNP 19613 3923 18 angelo angelo NNP 19613 3923 19 spiritui spiritui NNP 19613 3923 20 sancto sancto NNP 19613 3923 21 præparamur præparamur NNP 19613 3923 22 . . . 19613 3923 23 " " '' 19613 3923 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3924 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3924 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3924 3 284 284 CD 19613 3924 4 : : : 19613 3924 5 The the DT 19613 3924 6 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 3924 7 of of IN 19613 3924 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3924 9 of of IN 19613 3924 10 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 3924 11 in in IN 19613 3924 12 Pædag Pædag NNP 19613 3924 13 . . . 19613 3925 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3925 2 , , , 19613 3925 3 6 6 CD 19613 3925 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3925 5 baptism baptism NN 19613 3925 6 and and CC 19613 3925 7 sonship sonship NN 19613 3925 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3925 9 are be VBP 19613 3925 10 very very RB 19613 3925 11 important important JJ 19613 3925 12 , , , 19613 3925 13 but but CC 19613 3925 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3925 15 did do VBD 19613 3925 16 not not RB 19613 3925 17 follow follow VB 19613 3925 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 3925 19 up up RP 19613 3925 20 . . . 19613 3926 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3926 2 is be VBZ 19613 3926 3 deserving deserve VBG 19613 3926 4 of of IN 19613 3926 5 note note NN 19613 3926 6 that that IN 19613 3926 7 the the DT 19613 3926 8 positive positive JJ 19613 3926 9 effects effect NNS 19613 3926 10 of of IN 19613 3926 11 baptism baptism NN 19613 3926 12 were be VBD 19613 3926 13 more more RBR 19613 3926 14 strongly strongly RB 19613 3926 15 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 3926 16 in in IN 19613 3926 17 the the DT 19613 3926 18 East East NNP 19613 3926 19 than than IN 19613 3926 20 in in IN 19613 3926 21 the the DT 19613 3926 22 West West NNP 19613 3926 23 . . . 19613 3927 1 But but CC 19613 3927 2 , , , 19613 3927 3 on on IN 19613 3927 4 the the DT 19613 3927 5 other other JJ 19613 3927 6 hand hand NN 19613 3927 7 , , , 19613 3927 8 the the DT 19613 3927 9 conception conception NN 19613 3927 10 is be VBZ 19613 3927 11 more more RBR 19613 3927 12 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 3927 13 in in IN 19613 3927 14 the the DT 19613 3927 15 former former JJ 19613 3927 16 region region NN 19613 3927 17 . . . 19613 3927 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3928 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3928 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3928 3 285 285 CD 19613 3928 4 : : : 19613 3928 5 See see VB 19613 3928 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3928 7 , , , 19613 3928 8 de de FW 19613 3928 9 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3928 10 . . . 19613 3929 1 7 7 CD 19613 3929 2 ff ff NN 19613 3929 3 . . . 19613 3930 1 ; ; : 19613 3930 2 Cypr Cypr NNP 19613 3930 3 . . . 19613 3930 4 , , , 19613 3930 5 ep ep NNP 19613 3930 6 . . . 19613 3931 1 70 70 CD 19613 3931 2 . . . 19613 3932 1 2 2 LS 19613 3932 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3932 3 " " `` 19613 3932 4 ungi ungi NNP 19613 3932 5 quoque quoque NNP 19613 3932 6 necesse necesse NNP 19613 3932 7 est est NNP 19613 3932 8 eum eum NNP 19613 3932 9 qui qui NNP 19613 3932 10 baptizatus baptizatus NNP 19613 3932 11 est est NNP 19613 3932 12 , , , 19613 3932 13 ut ut NNP 19613 3932 14 accepto accepto NNP 19613 3932 15 chrismate chrismate NN 19613 3932 16 , , , 19613 3932 17 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 3932 18 , , , 19613 3932 19 unctione unctione NNP 19613 3932 20 esse esse NNP 19613 3932 21 unctus unctus NNP 19613 3932 22 dei dei NNP 19613 3932 23 et et NNP 19613 3932 24 habere habere NNP 19613 3932 25 in in IN 19613 3932 26 se se NNP 19613 3932 27 gratiam gratiam NNP 19613 3932 28 Christi Christi NNP 19613 3932 29 possit possit NN 19613 3932 30 " " '' 19613 3932 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3932 32 , , , 19613 3932 33 74 74 CD 19613 3932 34 . . . 19613 3933 1 5 5 CD 19613 3933 2 etc etc FW 19613 3933 3 . . . 19613 3934 1 " " `` 19613 3934 2 Chrism chrism NN 19613 3934 3 " " '' 19613 3934 4 is be VBZ 19613 3934 5 already already RB 19613 3934 6 found find VBN 19613 3934 7 in in IN 19613 3934 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3934 9 as as RB 19613 3934 10 well well RB 19613 3934 11 as as IN 19613 3934 12 the the DT 19613 3934 13 laying laying NN 19613 3934 14 on on RP 19613 3934 15 of of IN 19613 3934 16 hands hand NNS 19613 3934 17 . . . 19613 3935 1 The the DT 19613 3935 2 Roman roman JJ 19613 3935 3 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 3935 4 bishop bishop NN 19613 3935 5 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 3935 6 in in IN 19613 3935 7 the the DT 19613 3935 8 notorious notorious JJ 19613 3935 9 epistle epistle NN 19613 3935 10 to to IN 19613 3935 11 Fabius Fabius NNP 19613 3935 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3935 13 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3935 14 . . NNP 19613 3935 15 , , , 19613 3935 16 H. H. NNP 19613 3935 17 E. E. NNP 19613 3935 18 VI VI NNP 19613 3935 19 . . . 19613 3936 1 43 43 CD 19613 3936 2 . . . 19613 3937 1 15 15 CD 19613 3937 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3937 3 , , , 19613 3937 4 already already RB 19613 3937 5 traces trace VBZ 19613 3937 6 the the DT 19613 3937 7 rites rite NNS 19613 3937 8 which which WDT 19613 3937 9 accompany accompany VBP 19613 3937 10 baptism baptism NN 19613 3937 11 to to IN 19613 3937 12 an an DT 19613 3937 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 3937 14 canon canon NN 19613 3937 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3937 16 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 3937 17 one one CD 19613 3937 18 from from IN 19613 3937 19 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 3937 20 ' ' POS 19613 3937 21 collection collection NN 19613 3937 22 : : : 19613 3937 23 see see VB 19613 3937 24 can can MD 19613 3937 25 . . . 19613 3938 1 arab arab NNP 19613 3938 2 . . . 19613 3939 1 19 19 CD 19613 3939 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3939 3 . . . 19613 3940 1 After after IN 19613 3940 2 relating relate VBG 19613 3940 3 that that IN 19613 3940 4 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 3940 5 in in IN 19613 3940 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3940 7 illness illness NN 19613 3940 8 had have VBD 19613 3940 9 only only RB 19613 3940 10 received receive VBN 19613 3940 11 clinical clinical JJ 19613 3940 12 baptism baptism NN 19613 3940 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3940 14 writes write VBZ 19613 3940 15 : : : 19613 3940 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3940 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3940 18 : : : 19613 3940 19 ou ou NNP 19613 3940 20 mên mên NNP 19613 3940 21 oude oude NNP 19613 3940 22 tôn tôn NNP 19613 3940 23 loipôn loipôn NNP 19613 3940 24 etuche etuche NNP 19613 3940 25 , , , 19613 3940 26 diaphugôn diaphugôn NNP 19613 3940 27 tên tên NNP 19613 3940 28 noson noson NNP 19613 3940 29 , , , 19613 3940 30 hôn hôn NNP 19613 3940 31 chrê chrê NNP 19613 3940 32 metalambanein metalambanein NNP 19613 3940 33 kata kata NNP 19613 3940 34 ton ton NNP 19613 3940 35 tês tês NNP 19613 3940 36 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 3940 37 kanona kanona NNP 19613 3940 38 , , , 19613 3940 39 tou tou NNP 19613 3940 40 te te NNP 19613 3940 41 sphragisthênai sphragisthênai NNP 19613 3940 42 hupo hupo NNP 19613 3940 43 tou tou NNP 19613 3940 44 episkopou episkopou NNP 19613 3940 45 . . . 19613 3940 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3941 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3941 2 is be VBZ 19613 3941 3 also also RB 19613 3941 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3941 5 that that IN 19613 3941 6 one one CD 19613 3941 7 of of IN 19613 3941 8 the the DT 19613 3941 9 bishops bishop NNS 19613 3941 10 who who WP 19613 3941 11 voted vote VBD 19613 3941 12 about about IN 19613 3941 13 heretic heretic JJ 19613 3941 14 baptism baptism NN 19613 3941 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3941 16 Sentent sentent NN 19613 3941 17 . . . 19613 3942 1 episcop episcop RB 19613 3942 2 . . . 19613 3942 3 , , , 19613 3942 4 Cypr Cypr NNP 19613 3942 5 . . . 19613 3942 6 , , , 19613 3942 7 opp opp NNP 19613 3942 8 . . . 19613 3943 1 ed ed NNP 19613 3943 2 . . . 19613 3944 1 Hartel Hartel NNP 19613 3944 2 I. I. NNP 19613 3944 3 p. p. NN 19613 3944 4 439 439 CD 19613 3944 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3944 6 calls call VBZ 19613 3944 7 the the DT 19613 3944 8 laying laying NN 19613 3944 9 on on RP 19613 3944 10 of of IN 19613 3944 11 hands hand NNS 19613 3944 12 a a DT 19613 3944 13 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 3944 14 like like IN 19613 3944 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 3944 16 : : : 19613 3944 17 " " `` 19613 3944 18 neque neque NNP 19613 3944 19 enim enim NNP 19613 3944 20 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 3944 21 sine sine NNP 19613 3944 22 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3944 23 separatim separatim NNP 19613 3944 24 operari operari NNP 19613 3944 25 potest potest NNP 19613 3944 26 nec nec NNP 19613 3944 27 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3944 28 sine sine NNP 19613 3944 29 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 3944 30 male male NNP 19613 3944 31 ergo ergo NNP 19613 3944 32 sibi sibi NNP 19613 3944 33 quidem quidem NNP 19613 3944 34 interpretantur interpretantur NNP 19613 3944 35 ut ut UH 19613 3944 36 dicant dicant JJ 19613 3944 37 , , , 19613 3944 38 quod quod NN 19613 3944 39 per per IN 19613 3944 40 manus manus NN 19613 3944 41 impositionem impositionem NNP 19613 3944 42 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 3944 43 sanctum sanctum NNP 19613 3944 44 accipiant accipiant NNP 19613 3944 45 et et NNP 19613 3944 46 sic sic NNP 19613 3944 47 recipiantur recipiantur NNP 19613 3944 48 , , , 19613 3944 49 cum cum NNP 19613 3944 50 manifestum manifestum NN 19613 3944 51 sit sit NNP 19613 3944 52 _ _ NNP 19613 3944 53 utroque utroque JJ 19613 3944 54 sacramento sacramento NNP 19613 3944 55 _ _ NNP 19613 3944 56 debere debere NNP 19613 3944 57 eos eos NNP 19613 3944 58 renasci renasci NNP 19613 3944 59 in in IN 19613 3944 60 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 3944 61 catholica catholica NNP 19613 3944 62 . . . 19613 3944 63 " " '' 19613 3945 1 Among among IN 19613 3945 2 other other JJ 19613 3945 3 particulars particular NNS 19613 3945 4 found find VBN 19613 3945 5 in in IN 19613 3945 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3945 7 's 's POS 19613 3945 8 work work NN 19613 3945 9 on on IN 19613 3945 10 baptism baptism NN 19613 3945 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3945 12 cc cc NNP 19613 3945 13 . . . 19613 3946 1 I. I. NNP 19613 3947 1 12 12 CD 19613 3947 2 seq seq NN 19613 3947 3 . . . 19613 3947 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3948 1 it -PRON- PRP 19613 3948 2 may may MD 19613 3948 3 moreover moreover RB 19613 3948 4 be be VB 19613 3948 5 seen see VBN 19613 3948 6 that that IN 19613 3948 7 there there EX 19613 3948 8 were be VBD 19613 3948 9 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 3948 10 about about IN 19613 3948 11 the the DT 19613 3948 12 year year NN 19613 3948 13 200 200 CD 19613 3948 14 , , , 19613 3948 15 who who WP 19613 3948 16 questioned question VBD 19613 3948 17 the the DT 19613 3948 18 indispensability indispensability NN 19613 3948 19 of of IN 19613 3948 20 baptism baptism NN 19613 3948 21 to to IN 19613 3948 22 salvation salvation NN 19613 3948 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3948 24 baptismus baptismus NNP 19613 3948 25 non non AFX 19613 3948 26 est est NNP 19613 3948 27 necessarius necessarius NNP 19613 3948 28 , , , 19613 3948 29 quibus quibus NNP 19613 3948 30 fides fides NNP 19613 3948 31 satis satis NNP 19613 3948 32 est est NNP 19613 3948 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3948 34 . . . 19613 3949 1 The the DT 19613 3949 2 assumption assumption NN 19613 3949 3 that that IN 19613 3949 4 martyrdom martyrdom NN 19613 3949 5 replaces replace VBZ 19613 3949 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 3949 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3949 8 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3949 9 . . NNP 19613 3949 10 , , , 19613 3949 11 de de NNP 19613 3949 12 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3949 13 . . . 19613 3950 1 16 16 CD 19613 3950 2 ; ; : 19613 3950 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3950 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3950 5 , , , 19613 3950 6 is be VBZ 19613 3950 7 in in IN 19613 3950 8 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3950 9 a a DT 19613 3950 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 3950 11 proof proof NN 19613 3950 12 that that IN 19613 3950 13 the the DT 19613 3950 14 ideas idea NNS 19613 3950 15 of of IN 19613 3950 16 the the DT 19613 3950 17 " " `` 19613 3950 18 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 3950 19 " " '' 19613 3950 20 were be VBD 19613 3950 21 still still RB 19613 3950 22 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 3950 23 . . . 19613 3951 1 As as IN 19613 3951 2 to to IN 19613 3951 3 the the DT 19613 3951 4 objection objection NN 19613 3951 5 that that WDT 19613 3951 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 3951 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 3951 8 had have VBD 19613 3951 9 not not RB 19613 3951 10 baptised baptise VBN 19613 3951 11 and and CC 19613 3951 12 that that IN 19613 3951 13 the the DT 19613 3951 14 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 3951 15 had have VBD 19613 3951 16 not not RB 19613 3951 17 received receive VBN 19613 3951 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 3951 19 baptism baptism NN 19613 3951 20 see see VBP 19613 3951 21 Tert Tert NNP 19613 3951 22 . . . 19613 3951 23 , , , 19613 3951 24 de de NNP 19613 3951 25 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3951 26 . . . 19613 3952 1 11 11 CD 19613 3952 2 , , , 19613 3952 3 12 12 CD 19613 3952 4 . . . 19613 3952 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3953 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3953 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3953 3 286 286 CD 19613 3953 4 : : : 19613 3953 5 In in IN 19613 3953 6 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3953 7 the the DT 19613 3953 8 performance performance NN 19613 3953 9 of of IN 19613 3953 10 this this DT 19613 3953 11 rite rite NN 19613 3953 12 seemed seem VBD 19613 3953 13 too too RB 19613 3953 14 simple simple JJ 19613 3953 15 to to IN 19613 3953 16 those those DT 19613 3953 17 who who WP 19613 3953 18 sought seek VBD 19613 3953 19 eagerly eagerly RB 19613 3953 20 for for IN 19613 3953 21 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 3953 22 . . . 19613 3954 1 See see VB 19613 3954 2 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3954 3 . . NNP 19613 3954 4 , , , 19613 3954 5 de de NNP 19613 3954 6 bapt bapt NNP 19613 3954 7 . . . 19613 3955 1 2 2 LS 19613 3955 2 : : : 19613 3955 3 " " `` 19613 3955 4 Nihil nihil JJ 19613 3955 5 adeo adeo NN 19613 3955 6 est est NNP 19613 3955 7 quod quod NNP 19613 3955 8 obduret obduret NNP 19613 3955 9 mentes mentes NNP 19613 3955 10 hominum hominum NNP 19613 3955 11 quam quam NNP 19613 3955 12 simplicitas simplicitas NNP 19613 3955 13 divinorum divinorum NNP 19613 3955 14 operum operum NNP 19613 3955 15 , , , 19613 3955 16 quæ quæ NNP 19613 3955 17 in in IN 19613 3955 18 actu actu NNP 19613 3955 19 videtur videtur NNP 19613 3955 20 , , , 19613 3955 21 et et NNP 19613 3955 22 magnificentia magnificentia NN 19613 3955 23 , , , 19613 3955 24 quæ quæ NNP 19613 3955 25 in in IN 19613 3955 26 effecta effecta NNP 19613 3955 27 repromittitur repromittitur NNP 19613 3955 28 , , , 19613 3955 29 ut ut UH 19613 3955 30 hinc hinc NNP 19613 3955 31 quoque quoque NNP 19613 3955 32 , , , 19613 3955 33 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 3955 34 tanta tanta NNP 19613 3955 35 simplicitate simplicitate NN 19613 3955 36 , , , 19613 3955 37 sine sine NNP 19613 3955 38 pompa pompa NNP 19613 3955 39 , , , 19613 3955 40 sine sine NNP 19613 3955 41 apparatu apparatu NNP 19613 3955 42 novo novo NNP 19613 3955 43 aliquo aliquo NNP 19613 3955 44 , , , 19613 3955 45 denique denique NN 19613 3955 46 sine sine NNP 19613 3955 47 sumptu sumptu NNP 19613 3955 48 homo homo NNP 19613 3955 49 in in IN 19613 3955 50 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3955 51 demissus demissus NNP 19613 3955 52 et et NNP 19613 3955 53 inter inter NNP 19613 3955 54 pauca pauca NNP 19613 3955 55 verba verba NNP 19613 3955 56 tinctus tinctus NNP 19613 3955 57 non non AFX 19613 3955 58 multo multo NNP 19613 3955 59 vel vel NNP 19613 3955 60 nihilo nihilo NNP 19613 3955 61 mundior mundior NNP 19613 3955 62 resurgit resurgit NNP 19613 3955 63 , , , 19613 3955 64 eo eo NNP 19613 3955 65 incredibilis incredibilis NNP 19613 3955 66 existimetur existimetur NNP 19613 3955 67 consecutio consecutio NNP 19613 3955 68 æternitatis æternitatis NN 19613 3955 69 . . . 19613 3956 1 Mentior Mentior NNP 19613 3956 2 , , , 19613 3956 3 si si IN 19613 3956 4 non non NNP 19613 3956 5 e e NNP 19613 3956 6 contrario contrario NNP 19613 3956 7 idolorum idolorum NNP 19613 3956 8 solemnia solemnia NNP 19613 3956 9 vel vel NNP 19613 3956 10 arcana arcana NNP 19613 3956 11 de de NNP 19613 3956 12 suggestu suggestu NNP 19613 3956 13 et et NNP 19613 3956 14 apparatu apparatu NNP 19613 3956 15 deque deque NNP 19613 3956 16 sumptu sumptu NNP 19613 3956 17 fidem fidem NN 19613 3956 18 at at IN 19613 3956 19 auctoritatem auctoritatem NNP 19613 3956 20 sibi sibi NNP 19613 3956 21 exstruunt exstruunt NNP 19613 3956 22 . . . 19613 3956 23 " " '' 19613 3956 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3957 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3957 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3957 3 287 287 CD 19613 3957 4 : : : 19613 3957 5 But but CC 19613 3957 6 see see VB 19613 3957 7 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 3957 8 . . NNP 19613 3957 9 , , , 19613 3957 10 H. H. NNP 19613 3957 11 E. E. NNP 19613 3957 12 VI VI NNP 19613 3957 13 . . . 19613 3958 1 43 43 CD 19613 3958 2 . . . 19613 3959 1 15 15 CD 19613 3959 2 , , , 19613 3959 3 who who WP 19613 3959 4 says say VBZ 19613 3959 5 that that IN 19613 3959 6 only only RB 19613 3959 7 the the DT 19613 3959 8 laying laying NN 19613 3959 9 on on RP 19613 3959 10 of of IN 19613 3959 11 hands hand NNS 19613 3959 12 on on IN 19613 3959 13 the the DT 19613 3959 14 part part NN 19613 3959 15 of of IN 19613 3959 16 the the DT 19613 3959 17 bishop bishop NN 19613 3959 18 communicates communicate VBZ 19613 3959 19 the the DT 19613 3959 20 Holy Holy NNP 19613 3959 21 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3959 22 , , , 19613 3959 23 and and CC 19613 3959 24 this this DT 19613 3959 25 ceremony ceremony NN 19613 3959 26 _ _ NNP 19613 3959 27 must must MD 19613 3959 28 _ _ NNP 19613 3959 29 therefore therefore RB 19613 3959 30 follow follow VB 19613 3959 31 baptism baptism NN 19613 3959 32 . . . 19613 3960 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3960 2 is be VBZ 19613 3960 3 probable probable JJ 19613 3960 4 that that IN 19613 3960 5 confirmation confirmation NN 19613 3960 6 as as IN 19613 3960 7 a a DT 19613 3960 8 specific specific JJ 19613 3960 9 act act NN 19613 3960 10 did do VBD 19613 3960 11 not not RB 19613 3960 12 become become VB 19613 3960 13 detached detach VBN 19613 3960 14 from from IN 19613 3960 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 3960 16 in in IN 19613 3960 17 the the DT 19613 3960 18 West West NNP 19613 3960 19 till till IN 19613 3960 20 shortly shortly RB 19613 3960 21 before before IN 19613 3960 22 the the DT 19613 3960 23 middle middle NN 19613 3960 24 of of IN 19613 3960 25 the the DT 19613 3960 26 third third JJ 19613 3960 27 century century NN 19613 3960 28 . . . 19613 3961 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 19613 3961 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 3961 3 may may MD 19613 3961 4 assume assume VB 19613 3961 5 that that IN 19613 3961 6 the the DT 19613 3961 7 Mithras Mithras NNP 19613 3961 8 cult cult NN 19613 3961 9 had have VBD 19613 3961 10 an an DT 19613 3961 11 influence influence NN 19613 3961 12 here here RB 19613 3961 13 . . . 19613 3961 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3962 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3962 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3962 3 288 288 CD 19613 3962 4 : : : 19613 3962 5 See see VB 19613 3962 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3962 7 's 's POS 19613 3962 8 superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 3962 9 remarks remark NNS 19613 3962 10 in in IN 19613 3962 11 de de NNP 19613 3962 12 bap bap NNP 19613 3962 13 . . . 19613 3963 1 3 3 CD 19613 3963 2 - - SYM 19613 3963 3 9 9 CD 19613 3963 4 to to IN 19613 3963 5 the the DT 19613 3963 6 effect effect NN 19613 3963 7 that that DT 19613 3963 8 water water NN 19613 3963 9 is be VBZ 19613 3963 10 the the DT 19613 3963 11 element element NN 19613 3963 12 of of IN 19613 3963 13 the the DT 19613 3963 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 3963 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 3963 16 and and CC 19613 3963 17 of of IN 19613 3963 18 unclean unclean JJ 19613 3963 19 Spirits Spirits NNPS 19613 3963 20 etc etc FW 19613 3963 21 . . . 19613 3964 1 Melito Melito NNP 19613 3964 2 also also RB 19613 3964 3 makes make VBZ 19613 3964 4 a a DT 19613 3964 5 similar similar JJ 19613 3964 6 statement statement NN 19613 3964 7 in in IN 19613 3964 8 the the DT 19613 3964 9 fragment fragment NN 19613 3964 10 of of IN 19613 3964 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3964 12 treatise treatise NN 19613 3964 13 on on IN 19613 3964 14 baptism baptism NN 19613 3964 15 in in IN 19613 3964 16 Pitra Pitra NNP 19613 3964 17 , , , 19613 3964 18 Anal Anal NNP 19613 3964 19 , , , 19613 3964 20 Sacra Sacra NNP 19613 3964 21 II II NNP 19613 3964 22 . . NNP 19613 3964 23 , , , 19613 3964 24 p. p. NN 19613 3964 25 3 3 CD 19613 3964 26 sq sq NNP 19613 3964 27 . . . 19613 3965 1 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 3965 2 , , , 19613 3965 3 ep ep NNP 19613 3965 4 . . . 19613 3966 1 70 70 CD 19613 3966 2 . . . 19613 3967 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 3967 2 , , , 19613 3967 3 uses use VBZ 19613 3967 4 the the DT 19613 3967 5 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 3967 6 words word NNS 19613 3967 7 : : : 19613 3967 8 " " `` 19613 3967 9 oportet oportet VB 19613 3967 10 veio veio NNP 19613 3967 11 mundari mundari NNP 19613 3967 12 et et NNP 19613 3967 13 sanctificari sanctificari NNP 19613 3967 14 aquam aquam NNP 19613 3967 15 prius prius NNP 19613 3967 16 a a DT 19613 3967 17 _ _ NNP 19613 3967 18 sacer sacer NN 19613 3967 19 dote dote NN 19613 3967 20 _ _ NNP 19613 3967 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3967 22 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 3967 23 . . . 19613 3968 1 still still RB 19613 3968 2 knows know VBZ 19613 3968 3 nothing nothing NN 19613 3968 4 of of IN 19613 3968 5 this this DT 19613 3968 6 : : : 19613 3968 7 c. c. NNP 19613 3968 8 17 17 CD 19613 3968 9 : : : 19613 3968 10 etiam etiam NNP 19613 3968 11 laicis laicis NNP 19613 3968 12 ius ius NNP 19613 3968 13 est est NNP 19613 3968 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3968 15 , , , 19613 3968 16 ut ut UH 19613 3968 17 possit possit NNP 19613 3968 18 baptismo baptismo NNP 19613 3968 19 suo suo NNP 19613 3968 20 peccata peccata NNP 19613 3968 21 hominis hominis NNP 19613 3968 22 qui qui NNP 19613 3968 23 baptizatur baptizatur NNP 19613 3968 24 abluere abluere NNP 19613 3968 25 . . . 19613 3968 26 " " '' 19613 3969 1 Ep Ep NNP 19613 3969 2 . . . 19613 3970 1 74 74 CD 19613 3970 2 . . . 19613 3971 1 5 5 CD 19613 3971 2 : : : 19613 3971 3 " " `` 19613 3971 4 peccata peccata NNP 19613 3971 5 purgare purgare NNP 19613 3971 6 et et NNP 19613 3971 7 hominem hominem NNP 19613 3971 8 sanctificare sanctificare NNP 19613 3971 9 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3971 10 sola sola NNP 19613 3971 11 non non NNP 19613 3971 12 potest potest NNP 19613 3971 13 , , , 19613 3971 14 nisi nisi NNP 19613 3971 15 habeat habeat NNP 19613 3971 16 et et NNP 19613 3971 17 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 3971 18 sanctum sanctum NN 19613 3971 19 . . . 19613 3971 20 " " '' 19613 3972 1 Clem Clem NNP 19613 3972 2 . . . 19613 3973 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 3973 2 . . . 19613 3974 1 Protrept Protrept NNP 19613 3974 2 . . . 19613 3975 1 10.99 10.99 CD 19613 3975 2 : : : 19613 3975 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3975 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3975 5 : : : 19613 3975 6 labete labete JJ 19613 3975 7 hudôr hudôr NNP 19613 3975 8 logikos logikos NNP 19613 3975 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3975 10 . . . 19613 3975 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3976 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3976 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3976 3 289 289 CD 19613 3976 4 : : : 19613 3976 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 3976 6 was be VBD 19613 3976 7 easy easy JJ 19613 3976 8 for for IN 19613 3976 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 3976 10 to to TO 19613 3976 11 justify justify VB 19613 3976 12 child child NN 19613 3976 13 baptism baptism NN 19613 3976 14 , , , 19613 3976 15 as as IN 19613 3976 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 3976 17 recognised recognise VBD 19613 3976 18 something something NN 19613 3976 19 sinful sinful JJ 19613 3976 20 in in IN 19613 3976 21 corporeal corporeal JJ 19613 3976 22 birth birth NN 19613 3976 23 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 3976 24 , , , 19613 3976 25 and and CC 19613 3976 26 believed believe VBD 19613 3976 27 in in IN 19613 3976 28 sin sin NN 19613 3976 29 which which WDT 19613 3976 30 had have VBD 19613 3976 31 been be VBN 19613 3976 32 committed commit VBN 19613 3976 33 in in IN 19613 3976 34 a a DT 19613 3976 35 former former JJ 19613 3976 36 life life NN 19613 3976 37 . . . 19613 3977 1 The the DT 19613 3977 2 earliest early JJS 19613 3977 3 justification justification NN 19613 3977 4 of of IN 19613 3977 5 child child NN 19613 3977 6 baptism baptism NN 19613 3977 7 may may MD 19613 3977 8 therefore therefore RB 19613 3977 9 be be VB 19613 3977 10 traced trace VBN 19613 3977 11 back back RB 19613 3977 12 to to IN 19613 3977 13 a a DT 19613 3977 14 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 3977 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 3977 16 . . . 19613 3977 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3978 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3978 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3978 3 290 290 CD 19613 3978 4 : : : 19613 3978 5 _ _ NNP 19613 3978 6 Translator Translator NNP 19613 3978 7 's 's POS 19613 3978 8 note note NN 19613 3978 9 . . . 19613 3978 10 _ _ NNP 19613 3978 11 The the DT 19613 3978 12 following follow VBG 19613 3978 13 is be VBZ 19613 3978 14 the the DT 19613 3978 15 original original JJ 19613 3978 16 Latin Latin NNP 19613 3978 17 , , , 19613 3978 18 as as IN 19613 3978 19 quoted quote VBN 19613 3978 20 by by IN 19613 3978 21 Prof. Prof. NNP 19613 3978 22 Harnack Harnack NNP 19613 3978 23 : : : 19613 3978 24 " " `` 19613 3978 25 Cunctatio Cunctatio NNP 19613 3978 26 baptismi baptismi NNP 19613 3978 27 utilior utilior NN 19613 3978 28 est est NNP 19613 3978 29 , , , 19613 3978 30 præcipue præcipue RB 19613 3978 31 circa circa NNP 19613 3978 32 parvulos parvulos NNP 19613 3978 33 . . . 19613 3979 1 Quid quid JJ 19613 3979 2 enim enim NNP 19613 3979 3 necesse necesse NNP 19613 3979 4 , , , 19613 3979 5 sponsores sponsor VBZ 19613 3979 6 etiam etiam NNP 19613 3979 7 periculo periculo NNP 19613 3979 8 ingeri ingeri NNP 19613 3979 9 ... ... : 19613 3979 10 veniant veniant NNP 19613 3979 11 ergo ergo NNP 19613 3979 12 parvuli parvuli NNP 19613 3979 13 , , , 19613 3979 14 dum dum NNP 19613 3979 15 adolescunt adolescunt NNP 19613 3979 16 ; ; : 19613 3979 17 veniant veniant JJ 19613 3979 18 dum dum NNP 19613 3979 19 discunt discunt NN 19613 3979 20 , , , 19613 3979 21 dum dum NNP 19613 3979 22 quo quo NNP 19613 3979 23 veniant veniant NNP 19613 3979 24 docentur docentur NNP 19613 3979 25 ; ; : 19613 3979 26 fiant fiant NN 19613 3979 27 Christiani Christiani NNP 19613 3979 28 , , , 19613 3979 29 cum cum NNP 19613 3979 30 Christum Christum NNP 19613 3979 31 nosse nosse IN 19613 3979 32 potuerint potuerint NN 19613 3979 33 . . . 19613 3980 1 Quid Quid NNP 19613 3980 2 festinat festinat NN 19613 3980 3 innocens innocen VBZ 19613 3980 4 ætas ætas NNP 19613 3980 5 ad ad NN 19613 3980 6 remissionem remissionem NNP 19613 3980 7 peccatorum peccatorum NNP 19613 3980 8 ? ? . 19613 3981 1 Cautius Cautius NNP 19613 3981 2 agetur agetur RB 19613 3981 3 in in IN 19613 3981 4 sæcularibus sæcularibus NNP 19613 3981 5 , , , 19613 3981 6 ut ut NNP 19613 3981 7 cui cui NNP 19613 3981 8 substantia substantia NNP 19613 3981 9 terrena terrena NNP 19613 3981 10 non non NNP 19613 3981 11 creditur creditur NNP 19613 3981 12 , , , 19613 3981 13 divina divina NNP 19613 3981 14 credatur credatur NNP 19613 3981 15 ... ... : 19613 3981 16 Si si NN 19613 3981 17 qui qui NN 19613 3981 18 pondus pondus NNP 19613 3981 19 intelligant intelligant JJ 19613 3981 20 baptismi baptismi NNP 19613 3981 21 , , , 19613 3981 22 magis magis NNP 19613 3981 23 timebunt timebunt NNP 19613 3981 24 consecutionem consecutionem NNP 19613 3981 25 quam quam NNP 19613 3981 26 dilationem dilationem NNP 19613 3981 27 . . . 19613 3981 28 " " '' 19613 3981 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3982 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3982 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3982 3 291 291 CD 19613 3982 4 : : : 19613 3982 5 Under under IN 19613 3982 6 such such JJ 19613 3982 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 3982 8 the the DT 19613 3982 9 recollection recollection NN 19613 3982 10 of of IN 19613 3982 11 the the DT 19613 3982 12 significance significance NN 19613 3982 13 of of IN 19613 3982 14 baptism baptism NN 19613 3982 15 in in IN 19613 3982 16 the the DT 19613 3982 17 establishment establishment NN 19613 3982 18 of of IN 19613 3982 19 the the DT 19613 3982 20 Church Church NNP 19613 3982 21 fell fall VBD 19613 3982 22 more more RBR 19613 3982 23 and and CC 19613 3982 24 more more RBR 19613 3982 25 into into IN 19613 3982 26 the the DT 19613 3982 27 background background NN 19613 3982 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3982 29 see see VB 19613 3982 30 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 3982 31 : : : 19613 3982 32 " " `` 19613 3982 33 the the DT 19613 3982 34 Church Church NNP 19613 3982 35 rests rest VBZ 19613 3982 36 like like IN 19613 3982 37 the the DT 19613 3982 38 world world NN 19613 3982 39 upon upon IN 19613 3982 40 water water NN 19613 3982 41 ; ; : 19613 3982 42 " " `` 19613 3982 43 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 3982 44 III III NNP 19613 3982 45 . . . 19613 3983 1 17 17 CD 19613 3983 2 . . . 19613 3984 1 2 2 LS 19613 3984 2 : : : 19613 3984 3 " " `` 19613 3984 4 Sicut Sicut NNP 19613 3984 5 de de NNP 19613 3984 6 arido arido NNP 19613 3984 7 tritico tritico NNP 19613 3984 8 massa massa NNP 19613 3984 9 una una NNP 19613 3984 10 non non AFX 19613 3984 11 fieri fieri JJ 19613 3984 12 potest potest NN 19613 3984 13 sine sine NNP 19613 3984 14 humore humore NNP 19613 3984 15 neque neque NNP 19613 3984 16 unus unus NNP 19613 3984 17 panis panis NNP 19613 3984 18 , , , 19613 3984 19 ita ita NNP 19613 3984 20 nec nec NNP 19613 3984 21 nos nos NNP 19613 3984 22 multi multi NNP 19613 3984 23 unum unum NNP 19613 3984 24 fieri fieri JJ 19613 3984 25 in in IN 19613 3984 26 Christo Christo NNP 19613 3984 27 Iesu Iesu NNP 19613 3984 28 poteramus poteramus NNP 19613 3984 29 sine sine NN 19613 3984 30 aqua aqua NNP 19613 3984 31 quæ quæ NNP 19613 3984 32 de de FW 19613 3984 33 coelo coelo NNP 19613 3984 34 est est NNP 19613 3984 35 . . . 19613 3985 1 Et Et NNP 19613 3985 2 sicut sicut NN 19613 3985 3 aricla aricla VBZ 19613 3985 4 terra terra NN 19613 3985 5 , , , 19613 3985 6 si si VBP 19613 3985 7 non non AFX 19613 3985 8 percipiat percipiat JJ 19613 3985 9 humorem humorem NN 19613 3985 10 , , , 19613 3985 11 non non JJ 19613 3985 12 fructificat fructificat NNP 19613 3985 13 : : : 19613 3985 14 sic sic NN 19613 3985 15 et et FW 19613 3985 16 nos nos NNP 19613 3985 17 lignum lignum NNP 19613 3985 18 aridum aridum NN 19613 3985 19 exsistentes exsistentes NNP 19613 3985 20 primum primum NNP 19613 3985 21 , , , 19613 3985 22 nunquam nunquam NNP 19613 3985 23 fructificaremus fructificaremus NNP 19613 3985 24 vitam vitam NNP 19613 3985 25 sine sine NNP 19613 3985 26 superna superna NNP 19613 3985 27 voluntaria voluntaria NNP 19613 3985 28 pluvia pluvia NNP 19613 3985 29 . . . 19613 3986 1 Corpora Corpora NNP 19613 3986 2 unim unim NNP 19613 3986 3 nostra nostra NNP 19613 3986 4 per per IN 19613 3986 5 lavacrum lavacrum NNP 19613 3986 6 illam illam NNP 19613 3986 7 quæ quæ NNP 19613 3986 8 est est NNP 19613 3986 9 ad ad NN 19613 3986 10 incorruptionem incorruptionem NNP 19613 3986 11 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 3986 12 acceperunt acceperunt NNP 19613 3986 13 , , , 19613 3986 14 animæ animæ NNP 19613 3986 15 autem autem NN 19613 3986 16 per per IN 19613 3986 17 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 3986 18 " " '' 19613 3986 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3986 20 . . . 19613 3987 1 The the DT 19613 3987 2 unbaptised unbaptised JJ 19613 3987 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3987 4 catechumens catechumens NNP 19613 3987 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3987 6 also also RB 19613 3987 7 belong belong VBP 19613 3987 8 to to IN 19613 3987 9 the the DT 19613 3987 10 Church Church NNP 19613 3987 11 , , , 19613 3987 12 when when WRB 19613 3987 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3987 14 commit commit VBP 19613 3987 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 3987 16 to to IN 19613 3987 17 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 3987 18 guidance guidance NN 19613 3987 19 and and CC 19613 3987 20 prayers prayer NNS 19613 3987 21 . . . 19613 3988 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 3988 2 baptism baptism NN 19613 3988 3 ceased cease VBD 19613 3988 4 more more JJR 19613 3988 5 and and CC 19613 3988 6 more more JJR 19613 3988 7 to to TO 19613 3988 8 be be VB 19613 3988 9 regarded regard VBN 19613 3988 10 as as IN 19613 3988 11 an an DT 19613 3988 12 act act NN 19613 3988 13 of of IN 19613 3988 14 initiation initiation NN 19613 3988 15 , , , 19613 3988 16 and and CC 19613 3988 17 only only RB 19613 3988 18 recovered recover VBD 19613 3988 19 this this DT 19613 3988 20 character character NN 19613 3988 21 in in IN 19613 3988 22 the the DT 19613 3988 23 course course NN 19613 3988 24 of of IN 19613 3988 25 the the DT 19613 3988 26 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 3988 27 centuries century NNS 19613 3988 28 . . . 19613 3989 1 In in IN 19613 3989 2 this this DT 19613 3989 3 connection connection NN 19613 3989 4 the the DT 19613 3989 5 7th 7th JJ 19613 3989 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3989 7 spurious spurious JJ 19613 3989 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3989 9 canon canon NN 19613 3989 10 of of IN 19613 3989 11 Constantinople Constantinople NNP 19613 3989 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3989 13 381 381 CD 19613 3989 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 3989 15 is be VBZ 19613 3989 16 instructive instructive JJ 19613 3989 17 : : : 19613 3989 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3989 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 3989 20 : : : 19613 3989 21 kai kai NNP 19613 3989 22 tên tên NNP 19613 3989 23 prôtên prôtên NNP 19613 3989 24 hêmeran hêmeran NNP 19613 3989 25 poioumen poiouman NNS 19613 3989 26 autous autous JJ 19613 3989 27 Christianous Christianous NNP 19613 3989 28 , , , 19613 3989 29 tên tên NNP 19613 3989 30 de de NNP 19613 3989 31 deuteran deuteran NNP 19613 3989 32 katêchoumenous katêchoumenous NNP 19613 3989 33 , , , 19613 3989 34 eita eita NNP 19613 3989 35 tên tên NNP 19613 3989 36 tritên tritên NNP 19613 3989 37 exorkizomen exorkizomen NNPS 19613 3989 38 autous autous JJ 19613 3989 39 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 3989 40 . . . 19613 3989 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3989 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3990 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3990 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3990 3 292 292 CD 19613 3990 4 : : : 19613 3990 5 Döllinger döllinger NN 19613 3990 6 , , , 19613 3990 7 Die Die NNP 19613 3990 8 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 3990 9 von von NNP 19613 3990 10 der der VBP 19613 3990 11 Eucharistie Eucharistie NNP 19613 3990 12 in in IN 19613 3990 13 dem dem NNP 19613 3990 14 ersten ersten VBN 19613 3990 15 3 3 CD 19613 3990 16 Jahrhunderten Jahrhunderten NNP 19613 3990 17 , , , 19613 3990 18 1826 1826 CD 19613 3990 19 . . . 19613 3991 1 Engelhardt Engelhardt VBN 19613 3991 2 in in IN 19613 3991 3 the the DT 19613 3991 4 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 3991 5 fur fur NN 19613 3991 6 die die NN 19613 3991 7 hist hist NN 19613 3991 8 . . . 19613 3992 1 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 3992 2 , , , 19613 3992 3 1842 1842 CD 19613 3992 4 , , , 19613 3992 5 I. I. NNP 19613 3992 6 Kahnis Kahnis NNP 19613 3992 7 , , , 19613 3992 8 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 3992 9 vom vom VBZ 19613 3992 10 Abendmahl Abendmahl NNP 19613 3992 11 , , , 19613 3992 12 1851 1851 CD 19613 3992 13 . . . 19613 3993 1 Ruckert Ruckert NNP 19613 3993 2 , , , 19613 3993 3 Das Das NNP 19613 3993 4 Abendmahl Abendmahl NNP 19613 3993 5 , , , 19613 3993 6 sein sein NNP 19613 3993 7 Wesen Wesen NNP 19613 3993 8 und und JJ 19613 3993 9 seine seine NN 19613 3993 10 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 3993 11 , , , 19613 3993 12 1856 1856 CD 19613 3993 13 . . . 19613 3994 1 Leimbach Leimbach NNP 19613 3994 2 , , , 19613 3994 3 Beitrage Beitrage NNP 19613 3994 4 zur zur NN 19613 3994 5 Abendmahlslehre Abendmahlslehre NNP 19613 3994 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 3994 7 's 's POS 19613 3994 8 , , , 19613 3994 9 1874 1874 CD 19613 3994 10 . . . 19613 3995 1 Steitz steitz RB 19613 3995 2 , , , 19613 3995 3 Die die VB 19613 3995 4 Abendmahlslehre Abendmahlslehre NNP 19613 3995 5 der der NN 19613 3995 6 griechischen griechischen NNP 19613 3995 7 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 3995 8 , , , 19613 3995 9 in in IN 19613 3995 10 the the DT 19613 3995 11 Jahrbucher Jahrbucher NNP 19613 3995 12 fur fur NN 19613 3995 13 deutsche deutsche NN 19613 3995 14 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 3995 15 , , , 19613 3995 16 1864 1864 CD 19613 3995 17 - - SYM 19613 3995 18 1868 1868 CD 19613 3995 19 ; ; : 19613 3995 20 cf cf NN 19613 3995 21 . . . 19613 3996 1 also also RB 19613 3996 2 the the DT 19613 3996 3 works work NNS 19613 3996 4 of of IN 19613 3996 5 Probst Probst NNP 19613 3996 6 . . . 19613 3997 1 Whilst whilst IN 19613 3997 2 Eucharist Eucharist NNP 19613 3997 3 and and CC 19613 3997 4 love love NN 19613 3997 5 feast feast NN 19613 3997 6 had have VBD 19613 3997 7 already already RB 19613 3997 8 been be VBN 19613 3997 9 separated separate VBN 19613 3997 10 from from IN 19613 3997 11 the the DT 19613 3997 12 middle middle NN 19613 3997 13 of of IN 19613 3997 14 the the DT 19613 3997 15 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 3997 16 century century NN 19613 3997 17 in in IN 19613 3997 18 the the DT 19613 3997 19 West West NNP 19613 3997 20 , , , 19613 3997 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 3997 22 were be VBD 19613 3997 23 still still RB 19613 3997 24 united united JJ 19613 3997 25 in in IN 19613 3997 26 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 3997 27 in in IN 19613 3997 28 Clement Clement NNP 19613 3997 29 's 's POS 19613 3997 30 time time NN 19613 3997 31 ; ; : 19613 3997 32 see see VB 19613 3997 33 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 3997 34 , , , 19613 3997 35 l.c l.c NNP 19613 3997 36 . . NNP 19613 3997 37 , , , 19613 3997 38 p. p. NN 19613 3998 1 103 103 CD 19613 3998 2 . . . 19613 3998 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 3999 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 3999 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 3999 3 293 293 CD 19613 3999 4 : : : 19613 3999 5 The the DT 19613 3999 6 collocation collocation NN 19613 3999 7 of of IN 19613 3999 8 baptism baptism NN 19613 3999 9 and and CC 19613 3999 10 the the DT 19613 3999 11 Lord Lord NNP 19613 3999 12 's 's POS 19613 3999 13 Supper Supper NNP 19613 3999 14 , , , 19613 3999 15 which which WDT 19613 3999 16 , , , 19613 3999 17 as as IN 19613 3999 18 the the DT 19613 3999 19 early early JJ 19613 3999 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 3999 21 monuments monument NNS 19613 3999 22 prove prove VBP 19613 3999 23 , , , 19613 3999 24 was be VBD 19613 3999 25 a a DT 19613 3999 26 very very RB 19613 3999 27 familiar familiar JJ 19613 3999 28 practice practice NN 19613 3999 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 3999 30 Tert tert NN 19613 3999 31 . . . 19613 4000 1 adv adv NNP 19613 4000 2 . . . 19613 4001 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 4001 2 . . . 19613 4002 1 IV IV NNP 19613 4002 2 . . . 19613 4003 1 34 34 CD 19613 4003 2 : : : 19613 4003 3 " " `` 19613 4003 4 sacramentum sacramentum NNP 19613 4003 5 baptismi baptismi NNP 19613 4003 6 et et NNP 19613 4003 7 eucharistiæ eucharistiæ NN 19613 4003 8 ; ; : 19613 4003 9 " " `` 19613 4003 10 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 4003 11 . . . 19613 4003 12 , , , 19613 4003 13 can can MD 19613 4003 14 . . . 19613 4004 1 arab arab NNP 19613 4004 2 . . . 19613 4005 1 38 38 CD 19613 4005 2 : : : 19613 4005 3 " " `` 19613 4005 4 baptizatus baptizatus NNP 19613 4005 5 et et NNP 19613 4005 6 corpore corpore NNP 19613 4005 7 Christi Christi NNP 19613 4005 8 pastus pastus NN 19613 4005 9 " " '' 19613 4005 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4005 11 , , , 19613 4005 12 was be VBD 19613 4005 13 , , , 19613 4005 14 so so RB 19613 4005 15 far far RB 19613 4005 16 as as IN 19613 4005 17 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4005 18 know know VBP 19613 4005 19 , , , 19613 4005 20 justified justify VBN 19613 4005 21 by by IN 19613 4005 22 no no DT 19613 4005 23 Church Church NNP 19613 4005 24 Father Father NNP 19613 4005 25 on on IN 19613 4005 26 internal internal JJ 19613 4005 27 grounds ground NNS 19613 4005 28 . . . 19613 4006 1 Considering consider VBG 19613 4006 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4006 3 conception conception NN 19613 4006 4 of of IN 19613 4006 5 the the DT 19613 4006 6 holy holy JJ 19613 4006 7 ordinances ordinance NNS 19613 4006 8 this this DT 19613 4006 9 is be VBZ 19613 4006 10 not not RB 19613 4006 11 surprising surprising JJ 19613 4006 12 . . . 19613 4007 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4007 2 were be VBD 19613 4007 3 classed class VBN 19613 4007 4 together together RB 19613 4007 5 because because IN 19613 4007 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4007 7 were be VBD 19613 4007 8 instituted institute VBN 19613 4007 9 by by IN 19613 4007 10 the the DT 19613 4007 11 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4007 12 , , , 19613 4007 13 and and CC 19613 4007 14 because because IN 19613 4007 15 the the DT 19613 4007 16 elements element NNS 19613 4007 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4007 18 water water NN 19613 4007 19 , , , 19613 4007 20 wine wine NN 19613 4007 21 , , , 19613 4007 22 bread bread NN 19613 4007 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4007 24 afforded afford VBD 19613 4007 25 much much JJ 19613 4007 26 common common JJ 19613 4007 27 ground ground NN 19613 4007 28 for for IN 19613 4007 29 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 4007 30 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 4007 31 . . . 19613 4007 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4008 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4008 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4008 3 294 294 CD 19613 4008 4 : : : 19613 4008 5 The the DT 19613 4008 6 story story NN 19613 4008 7 related relate VBN 19613 4008 8 by by IN 19613 4008 9 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4008 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4008 11 in in IN 19613 4008 12 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4008 13 . . NNP 19613 4008 14 , , , 19613 4008 15 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4008 16 . . NNP 19613 4008 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4009 1 is be VBZ 19613 4009 2 especially especially RB 19613 4009 3 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 4009 4 , , , 19613 4009 5 as as IN 19613 4009 6 the the DT 19613 4009 7 narrator narrator NN 19613 4009 8 was be VBD 19613 4009 9 an an DT 19613 4009 10 extreme extreme JJ 19613 4009 11 spiritualist spiritualist NN 19613 4009 12 . . . 19613 4010 1 How how WRB 19613 4010 2 did do VBD 19613 4010 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4010 4 stand stand VB 19613 4010 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 4010 6 with with IN 19613 4010 7 the the DT 19613 4010 8 dry dry JJ 19613 4010 9 tree tree NN 19613 4010 10 ? ? . 19613 4011 1 Besides besides RB 19613 4011 2 , , , 19613 4011 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 4011 4 . . . 19613 4012 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4012 2 de de FW 19613 4012 3 corona corona NNP 19613 4012 4 3 3 CD 19613 4012 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4012 6 says say VBZ 19613 4012 7 : : : 19613 4012 8 " " `` 19613 4012 9 Calicis Calicis NNP 19613 4012 10 aut aut NN 19613 4012 11 panis panis NN 19613 4012 12 nostri nostri NNP 19613 4012 13 aliquid aliquid NNP 19613 4012 14 decuti decuti NNP 19613 4012 15 in in IN 19613 4012 16 terram terram NNP 19613 4012 17 anxie anxie NNP 19613 4012 18 patimur patimur NNP 19613 4012 19 " " '' 19613 4012 20 . . . 19613 4013 1 Superstitious superstitious JJ 19613 4013 2 reverence reverence NN 19613 4013 3 for for IN 19613 4013 4 the the DT 19613 4013 5 sacrament sacrament NN 19613 4013 6 _ _ NNP 19613 4013 7 ante ante NNP 19613 4013 8 et et NNP 19613 4013 9 extra extra JJ 19613 4013 10 usum usum NNP 19613 4013 11 _ _ NNP 19613 4013 12 is be VBZ 19613 4013 13 a a DT 19613 4013 14 very very RB 19613 4013 15 old old JJ 19613 4013 16 habit habit NN 19613 4013 17 of of IN 19613 4013 18 mind mind NN 19613 4013 19 in in IN 19613 4013 20 the the DT 19613 4013 21 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 4013 22 Church Church NNP 19613 4013 23 . . . 19613 4013 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4014 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4014 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4014 3 295 295 CD 19613 4014 4 : : : 19613 4014 5 Leimbach Leimbach NNP 19613 4014 6 's 's POS 19613 4014 7 investigations investigation NNS 19613 4014 8 of of IN 19613 4014 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4014 10 's 's POS 19613 4014 11 use use NN 19613 4014 12 of of IN 19613 4014 13 words word NNS 19613 4014 14 have have VBP 19613 4014 15 placed place VBN 19613 4014 16 this this DT 19613 4014 17 beyond beyond IN 19613 4014 18 doubt doubt NN 19613 4014 19 ; ; : 19613 4014 20 see see VB 19613 4014 21 de de FW 19613 4014 22 orat orat NNP 19613 4014 23 . . . 19613 4015 1 6 6 CD 19613 4015 2 ; ; : 19613 4015 3 adv adv NN 19613 4015 4 . . . 19613 4016 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 4016 2 . . . 19613 4017 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4018 1 14 14 CD 19613 4018 2 : : : 19613 4018 3 IV IV NNP 19613 4018 4 . . . 19613 4019 1 40 40 CD 19613 4019 2 : : : 19613 4019 3 III iii CD 19613 4019 4 . . . 19613 4020 1 19 19 CD 19613 4020 2 ; ; : 19613 4020 3 de de NNP 19613 4020 4 resuri resuri NNP 19613 4020 5 . . . 19613 4021 1 8 8 LS 19613 4021 2 . . . 19613 4021 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4022 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4022 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4022 3 296 296 CD 19613 4022 4 : : : 19613 4022 5 The the DT 19613 4022 6 chief chief JJ 19613 4022 7 passages passage NNS 19613 4022 8 referring refer VBG 19613 4022 9 to to IN 19613 4022 10 the the DT 19613 4022 11 Supper Supper NNP 19613 4022 12 in in IN 19613 4022 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4022 14 are be VBP 19613 4022 15 Protrept Protrept NNP 19613 4022 16 . . . 19613 4023 1 12 12 CD 19613 4023 2 . . . 19613 4024 1 120 120 CD 19613 4024 2 ; ; : 19613 4024 3 Pæd pæd NN 19613 4024 4 . . . 19613 4025 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4026 1 6 6 CD 19613 4026 2 . . . 19613 4027 1 43 43 CD 19613 4027 2 : : : 19613 4027 3 II ii CD 19613 4027 4 . . . 19613 4028 1 2 2 LS 19613 4028 2 . . . 19613 4029 1 19 19 CD 19613 4029 2 sq sq NN 19613 4029 3 . . . 19613 4030 1 : : : 19613 4030 2 I. I. NNP 19613 4031 1 5 5 CD 19613 4031 2 . . . 19613 4032 1 15 15 CD 19613 4032 2 : : : 19613 4032 3 I. i. NN 19613 4033 1 6 6 CD 19613 4033 2 . . . 19613 4034 1 38 38 CD 19613 4034 2 , , , 19613 4034 3 40 40 CD 19613 4034 4 ; ; : 19613 4034 5 Quis Quis NNP 19613 4034 6 div div NNP 19613 4034 7 . . . 19613 4035 1 23 23 LS 19613 4035 2 ; ; : 19613 4035 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 4035 4 . . . 19613 4036 1 V. V. NNP 19613 4036 2 10 10 CD 19613 4036 3 . . . 19613 4037 1 66 66 CD 19613 4037 2 : : : 19613 4037 3 I. i. NN 19613 4038 1 10 10 CD 19613 4038 2 . . . 19613 4039 1 46 46 CD 19613 4039 2 : : : 19613 4039 3 I. i. NN 19613 4040 1 19 19 CD 19613 4040 2 . . . 19613 4041 1 96 96 CD 19613 4041 2 : : : 19613 4041 3 VI VI NNP 19613 4041 4 . . . 19613 4042 1 14 14 CD 19613 4042 2 . . . 19613 4043 1 113 113 CD 19613 4043 2 : : : 19613 4043 3 V. V. NNP 19613 4043 4 II II NNP 19613 4043 5 . . . 19613 4044 1 70 70 CD 19613 4044 2 . . . 19613 4045 1 Clement clement NN 19613 4045 2 thinks think VBZ 19613 4045 3 as as RB 19613 4045 4 little little JJ 19613 4045 5 of of IN 19613 4045 6 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4045 7 of of IN 19613 4045 8 sins sin NNS 19613 4045 9 in in IN 19613 4045 10 connection connection NN 19613 4045 11 with with IN 19613 4045 12 the the DT 19613 4045 13 Supper Supper NNP 19613 4045 14 as as IN 19613 4045 15 does do VBZ 19613 4045 16 the the DT 19613 4045 17 author author NN 19613 4045 18 of of IN 19613 4045 19 the the DT 19613 4045 20 Didache Didache NNP 19613 4045 21 or or CC 19613 4045 22 the the DT 19613 4045 23 other other JJ 19613 4045 24 Fathers father NNS 19613 4045 25 ; ; : 19613 4045 26 this this DT 19613 4045 27 feast feast NN 19613 4045 28 is be VBZ 19613 4045 29 rather rather RB 19613 4045 30 meant mean VBN 19613 4045 31 to to TO 19613 4045 32 bestow bestow VB 19613 4045 33 an an DT 19613 4045 34 initiation initiation NN 19613 4045 35 into into IN 19613 4045 36 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4045 37 and and CC 19613 4045 38 immortality immortality NN 19613 4045 39 . . . 19613 4046 1 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4046 2 had have VBD 19613 4046 3 already already RB 19613 4046 4 said say VBN 19613 4046 5 , , , 19613 4046 6 " " `` 19613 4046 7 the the DT 19613 4046 8 body body NN 19613 4046 9 is be VBZ 19613 4046 10 faith faith NN 19613 4046 11 , , , 19613 4046 12 the the DT 19613 4046 13 blood blood NN 19613 4046 14 is be VBZ 19613 4046 15 hope hope NN 19613 4046 16 . . . 19613 4046 17 " " '' 19613 4047 1 This this DT 19613 4047 2 is be VBZ 19613 4047 3 also also RB 19613 4047 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4047 5 's 's POS 19613 4047 6 opinion opinion NN 19613 4047 7 ; ; : 19613 4047 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4047 9 also also RB 19613 4047 10 knows know VBZ 19613 4047 11 of of IN 19613 4047 12 a a DT 19613 4047 13 transubstantiation transubstantiation NN 19613 4047 14 , , , 19613 4047 15 not not RB 19613 4047 16 , , , 19613 4047 17 however however RB 19613 4047 18 , , , 19613 4047 19 into into IN 19613 4047 20 the the DT 19613 4047 21 real real JJ 19613 4047 22 body body NN 19613 4047 23 of of IN 19613 4047 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4047 25 , , , 19613 4047 26 but but CC 19613 4047 27 into into IN 19613 4047 28 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 4047 29 powers power NNS 19613 4047 30 . . . 19613 4048 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4048 2 teaching teaching NN 19613 4048 3 was be VBD 19613 4048 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 4048 5 that that DT 19613 4048 6 of of IN 19613 4048 7 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 4048 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4048 9 see see VB 19613 4048 10 the the DT 19613 4048 11 Exc Exc NNP 19613 4048 12 . . . 19613 4049 1 ex ex NNP 19613 4049 2 . . . 19613 4050 1 Theod Theod NNP 19613 4050 2 . . . 19613 4051 1 § § ADD 19613 4051 2 82 82 CD 19613 4051 3 , , , 19613 4051 4 already already RB 19613 4051 5 given give VBN 19613 4051 6 on on IN 19613 4051 7 Vol Vol NNP 19613 4051 8 . . . 19613 4052 1 i. i. NNP 19613 4052 2 p. p. NN 19613 4052 3 263 263 CD 19613 4052 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4052 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 4052 6 . . . 19613 4053 1 V. V. NNP 19613 4053 2 11 11 CD 19613 4053 3 . . . 19613 4054 1 70 70 CD 19613 4054 2 : : : 19613 4054 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4054 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4054 5 : : : 19613 4054 6 logikon logikon NNP 19613 4054 7 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 4054 8 brôma brôma NNP 19613 4054 9 hê hê NNP 19613 4054 10 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 4054 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4054 12 ; ; : 19613 4054 13 I. i. NN 19613 4055 1 20 20 CD 19613 4055 2 . . . 19613 4056 1 46 46 CD 19613 4056 2 : : : 19613 4056 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4056 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4056 5 : : : 19613 4056 6 hina hina NNP 19613 4056 7 dê dê NNP 19613 4056 8 phagômen phagômen NNP 19613 4056 9 logikôs logikôs NNP 19613 4056 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4056 11 ; ; : 19613 4056 12 V. V. NNP 19613 4056 13 10 10 CD 19613 4056 14 . . . 19613 4057 1 66 66 CD 19613 4057 2 : : : 19613 4057 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4057 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4057 5 : : : 19613 4057 6 brôsis brôsis NN 19613 4057 7 gar gar NNP 19613 4057 8 kai kai NNP 19613 4057 9 posis posis NNP 19613 4057 10 tou tou NNP 19613 4057 11 theiou theiou NNP 19613 4057 12 logou logou NNP 19613 4057 13 hê hê NNP 19613 4057 14 gnôsis gnôsis NNP 19613 4057 15 esti esti NNP 19613 4057 16 tês tês NNP 19613 4057 17 theias theias NNP 19613 4057 18 ousias ousias NNP 19613 4057 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4057 20 . . . 19613 4058 1 Adumbrat Adumbrat NNP 19613 4058 2 . . . 19613 4059 1 in in IN 19613 4059 2 epp epp NNP 19613 4059 3 . . . 19613 4060 1 Joh Joh NNP 19613 4060 2 . . . 19613 4061 1 : : : 19613 4061 2 " " `` 19613 4061 3 sanguis sanguis NNP 19613 4061 4 quod quod NNP 19613 4061 5 est est NNP 19613 4061 6 cognitio cognitio NNP 19613 4061 7 " " '' 19613 4061 8 ; ; : 19613 4061 9 see see VB 19613 4061 10 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 4061 11 , , , 19613 4061 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4061 13 . . NNP 19613 4061 14 , , , 19613 4061 15 p. p. NN 19613 4061 16 106 106 CD 19613 4061 17 ff ff NNP 19613 4061 18 . . . 19613 4061 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4062 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4062 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4062 3 297 297 CD 19613 4062 4 : : : 19613 4062 5 Orig Orig NNP 19613 4062 6 . . . 19613 4063 1 in in IN 19613 4063 2 Matth Matth NNP 19613 4063 3 . . . 19613 4064 1 Comment comment NN 19613 4064 2 . . . 19613 4065 1 ser ser NNP 19613 4065 2 . . . 19613 4066 1 85 85 CD 19613 4066 2 : : : 19613 4066 3 " " `` 19613 4066 4 Panis Panis NNP 19613 4066 5 iste iste NN 19613 4066 6 , , , 19613 4066 7 quem quem NNP 19613 4066 8 deus deus NNP 19613 4066 9 verbum verbum NNP 19613 4066 10 corpus corpus NNP 19613 4066 11 suum suum NNP 19613 4066 12 esse esse NNP 19613 4066 13 fatetur fatetur NNP 19613 4066 14 , , , 19613 4066 15 verbum verbum NNP 19613 4066 16 est est NNP 19613 4066 17 nutritorium nutritorium NNP 19613 4066 18 animarum animarum NNP 19613 4066 19 , , , 19613 4066 20 verbum verbum NNP 19613 4066 21 de de NNP 19613 4066 22 deo deo NNP 19613 4066 23 verbo verbo NNP 19613 4066 24 procedens procedens NNP 19613 4066 25 et et NNP 19613 4066 26 panis panis FW 19613 4066 27 de de FW 19613 4066 28 pane pane NNP 19613 4066 29 coe'esti coe'esti NNP 19613 4066 30 ... ... . 19613 4067 1 Non Non NNP 19613 4067 2 enim enim NNP 19613 4067 3 panem panem NN 19613 4067 4 illum illum NNP 19613 4067 5 visibilem visibilem NNP 19613 4067 6 , , , 19613 4067 7 quem quem NNP 19613 4067 8 tenebat tenebat NNP 19613 4067 9 in in IN 19613 4067 10 manibus manibus NNP 19613 4067 11 , , , 19613 4067 12 corpus corpus NNP 19613 4067 13 suum suum NNP 19613 4067 14 dicebat dicebat NNP 19613 4067 15 deus deus NNP 19613 4067 16 verbum verbum NNP 19613 4067 17 , , , 19613 4067 18 sed sed NNP 19613 4067 19 verbum verbum NNP 19613 4067 20 , , , 19613 4067 21 in in IN 19613 4067 22 cuius cuius NNP 19613 4067 23 mysterio mysterio NNP 19613 4067 24 fuerat fuerat NNP 19613 4067 25 panis panis NNP 19613 4067 26 ille ille NNP 19613 4067 27 frangendus frangendus NNP 19613 4067 28 ; ; : 19613 4067 29 nec nec NNP 19613 4067 30 potum potum NNP 19613 4067 31 illum illum NNP 19613 4067 32 visibilem visibilem NNP 19613 4067 33 sanguinem sanguinem NNP 19613 4067 34 suum suum NNP 19613 4067 35 dicebat dicebat NNP 19613 4067 36 , , , 19613 4067 37 sed sed NNP 19613 4067 38 verbum verbum NNP 19613 4067 39 in in IN 19613 4067 40 cuius cuius NNP 19613 4067 41 mysterio mysterio NNP 19613 4067 42 potus potus NNP 19613 4067 43 ille ille NNP 19613 4067 44 fuerat fuerat NNP 19613 4067 45 effundendus effundendus NNP 19613 4067 46 ; ; : 19613 4067 47 " " `` 19613 4067 48 see see VB 19613 4067 49 in in IN 19613 4067 50 Matt Matt NNP 19613 4067 51 . . . 19613 4068 1 XI XI NNP 19613 4068 2 . . . 19613 4069 1 14 14 CD 19613 4069 2 ; ; : 19613 4069 3 c. c. NN 19613 4069 4 Cels Cels NNP 19613 4069 5 . . . 19613 4070 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 4070 2 . . . 19613 4071 1 33 33 CD 19613 4071 2 . . . 19613 4072 1 Hom hom UH 19613 4072 2 . . . 19613 4073 1 XVI XVI NNP 19613 4073 2 . . . 19613 4074 1 9 9 CD 19613 4074 2 in in IN 19613 4074 3 Num Num NNP 19613 4074 4 . . . 19613 4075 1 On on IN 19613 4075 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4075 3 's 's POS 19613 4075 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4075 5 of of IN 19613 4075 6 the the DT 19613 4075 7 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4075 8 's 's POS 19613 4075 9 Supper Supper NNP 19613 4075 10 see see VB 19613 4075 11 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 4075 12 , , , 19613 4075 13 p. p. NN 19613 4075 14 219 219 CD 19613 4075 15 ff ff NN 19613 4075 16 . . . 19613 4075 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4076 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4076 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4076 3 298 298 CD 19613 4076 4 : : : 19613 4076 5 The the DT 19613 4076 6 conception conception NN 19613 4076 7 of of IN 19613 4076 8 the the DT 19613 4076 9 Supper Supper NNP 19613 4076 10 as as IN 19613 4076 11 _ _ NNP 19613 4076 12 viaticum viaticum NNP 19613 4076 13 mortis mortis NNP 19613 4076 14 _ _ NNP 19613 4076 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4076 16 fixed fix VBN 19613 4076 17 by by IN 19613 4076 18 the the DT 19613 4076 19 13th 13th JJ 19613 4076 20 canon canon NN 19613 4076 21 of of IN 19613 4076 22 Nicæa Nicæa NNP 19613 4076 23 : : : 19613 4076 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4076 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4076 26 : : : 19613 4076 27 peri peri NNP 19613 4076 28 de de NNP 19613 4076 29 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4076 30 exodeuontôn exodeuontôn NNP 19613 4076 31 ho ho NNP 19613 4076 32 palaios palaios NNP 19613 4076 33 kai kai NNP 19613 4076 34 kanonikos kanonikos NNP 19613 4076 35 nomos nomos NNP 19613 4076 36 phulachthêsetai phulachthêsetai NNP 19613 4076 37 kai kai NNP 19613 4076 38 nun nun NNP 19613 4076 39 , , , 19613 4076 40 hôste hôste NNP 19613 4076 41 eitis eitis NNP 19613 4076 42 exodeuoi exodeuoi NNP 19613 4076 43 , , , 19613 4076 44 tou tou NNP 19613 4076 45 teleutaiou teleutaiou NNP 19613 4076 46 kai kai NNP 19613 4076 47 anagkaiotatou anagkaiotatou NNP 19613 4076 48 ephodiou ephodiou NNP 19613 4076 49 mê mê NNP 19613 4076 50 apostereisthai apostereisthai NNP 19613 4076 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4076 52 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4076 53 , , , 19613 4076 54 a a DT 19613 4076 55 conception conception NN 19613 4076 56 which which WDT 19613 4076 57 is be VBZ 19613 4076 58 genuinely genuinely RB 19613 4076 59 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 19613 4076 60 and and CC 19613 4076 61 which which WDT 19613 4076 62 was be VBD 19613 4076 63 strengthened strengthen VBN 19613 4076 64 by by IN 19613 4076 65 the the DT 19613 4076 66 idea idea NN 19613 4076 67 that that IN 19613 4076 68 the the DT 19613 4076 69 Supper Supper NNP 19613 4076 70 was be VBD 19613 4076 71 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4076 72 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4076 73 : : : 19613 4076 74 pharmakon pharmakon NNP 19613 4076 75 athanasias athanasias NNP 19613 4076 76 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4076 77 , , , 19613 4076 78 the the DT 19613 4076 79 practice practice NN 19613 4076 80 of of IN 19613 4076 81 benediction benediction NN 19613 4076 82 , , , 19613 4076 83 and and CC 19613 4076 84 much much RB 19613 4076 85 else else RB 19613 4076 86 in in IN 19613 4076 87 theory theory NN 19613 4076 88 and and CC 19613 4076 89 practice practice NN 19613 4076 90 connected connect VBN 19613 4076 91 with with IN 19613 4076 92 the the DT 19613 4076 93 Eucharist eucharist NN 19613 4076 94 reveal reveal VB 19613 4076 95 the the DT 19613 4076 96 influence influence NN 19613 4076 97 of of IN 19613 4076 98 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 4076 99 . . . 19613 4077 1 See see VB 19613 4077 2 the the DT 19613 4077 3 relative relative JJ 19613 4077 4 articles article NNS 19613 4077 5 in in IN 19613 4077 6 Smith Smith NNP 19613 4077 7 and and CC 19613 4077 8 Cheetham Cheetham NNP 19613 4077 9 's 's POS 19613 4077 10 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 19613 4077 11 of of IN 19613 4077 12 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4077 13 Antiquities Antiquities NNPS 19613 4077 14 . . . 19613 4077 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4078 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4078 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4078 3 299 299 CD 19613 4078 4 : : : 19613 4078 5 The the DT 19613 4078 6 fullest full JJS 19613 4078 7 account account NN 19613 4078 8 of of IN 19613 4078 9 the the DT 19613 4078 10 " " `` 19613 4078 11 history history NN 19613 4078 12 of of IN 19613 4078 13 the the DT 19613 4078 14 Romish Romish NNP 19613 4078 15 Church Church NNP 19613 4078 16 down down RP 19613 4078 17 to to IN 19613 4078 18 the the DT 19613 4078 19 pontificate pontificate NN 19613 4078 20 of of IN 19613 4078 21 Leo Leo NNP 19613 4078 22 I. I. NNP 19613 4078 23 " " '' 19613 4079 1 has have VBZ 19613 4079 2 been be VBN 19613 4079 3 given give VBN 19613 4079 4 by by IN 19613 4079 5 Langen Langen NNP 19613 4079 6 , , , 19613 4079 7 1881 1881 CD 19613 4079 8 ; ; : 19613 4079 9 but but CC 19613 4079 10 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4079 11 can can MD 19613 4079 12 in in IN 19613 4079 13 no no DT 19613 4079 14 respect respect NN 19613 4079 15 agree agree VB 19613 4079 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4079 17 see see VB 19613 4079 18 Theol Theol NNP 19613 4079 19 . . . 19613 4080 1 Lit Lit NNP 19613 4080 2 . . . 19613 4081 1 Ztg Ztg NNP 19613 4081 2 . . . 19613 4082 1 1891 1891 CD 19613 4082 2 , , , 19613 4082 3 No no UH 19613 4082 4 . . . 19613 4083 1 6 6 LS 19613 4083 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4083 3 with with IN 19613 4083 4 the the DT 19613 4083 5 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 19613 4083 6 about about IN 19613 4083 7 the the DT 19613 4083 8 primacy primacy NN 19613 4083 9 as as IN 19613 4083 10 propounded propound VBN 19613 4083 11 by by IN 19613 4083 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4083 13 in in IN 19613 4083 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4083 15 treatise treatise NN 19613 4083 16 on on IN 19613 4083 17 the the DT 19613 4083 18 Clementine Clementine NNP 19613 4083 19 romances romance NNS 19613 4083 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4083 21 1890 1890 CD 19613 4083 22 , , , 19613 4083 23 see see VBP 19613 4083 24 especially especially RB 19613 4083 25 p. p. NN 19613 4083 26 163 163 CD 19613 4083 27 ff ff NN 19613 4083 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4083 29 . . . 19613 4084 1 The the DT 19613 4084 2 collection collection NN 19613 4084 3 of of IN 19613 4084 4 passages passage NNS 19613 4084 5 given give VBN 19613 4084 6 by by IN 19613 4084 7 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 4084 8 , , , 19613 4084 9 " " '' 19613 4084 10 Quellen Quellen NNP 19613 4084 11 zur zur NNP 19613 4084 12 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 4084 13 des des NNP 19613 4084 14 Taufsymbols Taufsymbols NNP 19613 4084 15 , , , 19613 4084 16 " " `` 19613 4084 17 Vol Vol NNP 19613 4084 18 . . . 19613 4085 1 III III NNP 19613 4085 2 . . NNP 19613 4085 3 , , , 19613 4085 4 deserves deserve VBZ 19613 4085 5 special special JJ 19613 4085 6 recognition recognition NN 19613 4085 7 . . . 19613 4086 1 See see VB 19613 4086 2 also also RB 19613 4086 3 the the DT 19613 4086 4 sections section NNS 19613 4086 5 bearing bear VBG 19613 4086 6 on on IN 19613 4086 7 this this DT 19613 4086 8 subject subject NN 19613 4086 9 in in IN 19613 4086 10 Renan Renan NNP 19613 4086 11 's 's POS 19613 4086 12 " " `` 19613 4086 13 Origines Origines NNPS 19613 4086 14 du du NNP 19613 4086 15 Christianisme Christianisme NNP 19613 4086 16 , , , 19613 4086 17 " " `` 19613 4086 18 Vols vol NNS 19613 4086 19 . . . 19613 4087 1 V.-VII V.-VII NNP 19613 4087 2 . . . 19613 4088 1 especially especially RB 19613 4088 2 VII VII NNP 19613 4088 3 . . NNP 19613 4088 4 , , , 19613 4088 5 chaps chaps NNP 19613 4088 6 . . . 19613 4089 1 5 5 CD 19613 4089 2 , , , 19613 4089 3 12 12 CD 19613 4089 4 , , , 19613 4089 5 23 23 CD 19613 4089 6 . . . 19613 4090 1 Sohm sohm VB 19613 4090 2 in in IN 19613 4090 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4090 4 " " `` 19613 4090 5 Kirchenrecht Kirchenrecht NNP 19613 4090 6 " " '' 19613 4090 7 I. i. NN 19613 4091 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4091 2 see see VB 19613 4091 3 especially especially RB 19613 4091 4 pp pp NNP 19613 4091 5 . . . 19613 4092 1 164 164 NNP 19613 4092 2 ff ff NNP 19613 4092 3 . . NNP 19613 4092 4 , , , 19613 4092 5 350 350 CD 19613 4092 6 ff ff NNP 19613 4092 7 . . NNP 19613 4092 8 , , , 19613 4092 9 377 377 CD 19613 4092 10 ff ff NNP 19613 4092 11 . . . 19613 4092 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4093 1 has have VBZ 19613 4093 2 adopted adopt VBN 19613 4093 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4093 4 conception conception NN 19613 4093 5 of of IN 19613 4093 6 " " `` 19613 4093 7 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 4093 8 " " '' 19613 4093 9 and and CC 19613 4093 10 " " `` 19613 4093 11 Roman roman JJ 19613 4093 12 , , , 19613 4093 13 " " '' 19613 4093 14 and and CC 19613 4093 15 made make VBD 19613 4093 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4093 17 the the DT 19613 4093 18 basis basis NN 19613 4093 19 of of IN 19613 4093 20 further further JJ 19613 4093 21 investigations investigation NNS 19613 4093 22 . . . 19613 4094 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4094 2 estimates estimate VBZ 19613 4094 3 the the DT 19613 4094 4 importance importance NN 19613 4094 5 of of IN 19613 4094 6 the the DT 19613 4094 7 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4094 8 Church Church NNP 19613 4094 9 still still RB 19613 4094 10 more more RBR 19613 4094 11 highly highly RB 19613 4094 12 , , , 19613 4094 13 in in IN 19613 4094 14 so so RB 19613 4094 15 far far RB 19613 4094 16 as as IN 19613 4094 17 , , , 19613 4094 18 according accord VBG 19613 4094 19 to to IN 19613 4094 20 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4094 21 , , , 19613 4094 22 she -PRON- PRP 19613 4094 23 was be VBD 19613 4094 24 the the DT 19613 4094 25 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 4094 26 originator originator NN 19613 4094 27 of of IN 19613 4094 28 Church Church NNP 19613 4094 29 law law NN 19613 4094 30 as as RB 19613 4094 31 well well RB 19613 4094 32 as as IN 19613 4094 33 of of IN 19613 4094 34 the the DT 19613 4094 35 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 4094 36 form form NN 19613 4094 37 of of IN 19613 4094 38 Church Church NNP 19613 4094 39 constitution constitution NN 19613 4094 40 ; ; : 19613 4094 41 and and CC 19613 4094 42 on on IN 19613 4094 43 page page NN 19613 4094 44 381 381 CD 19613 4094 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4094 46 flatly flatly RB 19613 4094 47 says say VBZ 19613 4094 48 : : : 19613 4094 49 " " `` 19613 4094 50 The the DT 19613 4094 51 whole whole JJ 19613 4094 52 Church Church NNP 19613 4094 53 constitution constitution NN 19613 4094 54 with with IN 19613 4094 55 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4094 56 claim claim NN 19613 4094 57 to to TO 19613 4094 58 be be VB 19613 4094 59 founded found VBN 19613 4094 60 on on IN 19613 4094 61 divine divine JJ 19613 4094 62 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 4094 63 was be VBD 19613 4094 64 first first RB 19613 4094 65 developed develop VBN 19613 4094 66 in in IN 19613 4094 67 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4094 68 and and CC 19613 4094 69 then then RB 19613 4094 70 transferred transfer VBD 19613 4094 71 from from IN 19613 4094 72 her -PRON- PRP 19613 4094 73 to to IN 19613 4094 74 the the DT 19613 4094 75 other other JJ 19613 4094 76 communities community NNS 19613 4094 77 . . . 19613 4094 78 " " '' 19613 4095 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4095 2 think think VBP 19613 4095 3 this this DT 19613 4095 4 is be VBZ 19613 4095 5 an an DT 19613 4095 6 exaggeration exaggeration NN 19613 4095 7 . . . 19613 4096 1 Tschirn Tschirn NNP 19613 4096 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4096 3 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 4096 4 für für NN 19613 4096 5 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 4096 6 , , , 19613 4096 7 XII XII NNP 19613 4096 8 . . . 19613 4097 1 p. p. NN 19613 4097 2 215 215 CD 19613 4097 3 ff ff NN 19613 4097 4 . . . 19613 4097 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4098 1 has have VBZ 19613 4098 2 discussed discuss VBN 19613 4098 3 the the DT 19613 4098 4 origin origin NN 19613 4098 5 of of IN 19613 4098 6 the the DT 19613 4098 7 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4098 8 Church Church NNP 19613 4098 9 in in IN 19613 4098 10 the the DT 19613 4098 11 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 4098 12 century century NN 19613 4098 13 . . . 19613 4099 1 Much much RB 19613 4099 2 that that DT 19613 4099 3 was be VBD 19613 4099 4 the the DT 19613 4099 5 common common JJ 19613 4099 6 property property NN 19613 4099 7 of of IN 19613 4099 8 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 4099 9 , , , 19613 4099 10 or or CC 19613 4099 11 is be VBZ 19613 4099 12 found find VBN 19613 4099 13 in in IN 19613 4099 14 every every DT 19613 4099 15 religion religion NN 19613 4099 16 as as IN 19613 4099 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4099 18 becomes become VBZ 19613 4099 19 older old JJR 19613 4099 20 , , , 19613 4099 21 is be VBZ 19613 4099 22 regarded regard VBN 19613 4099 23 by by IN 19613 4099 24 this this DT 19613 4099 25 author author NN 19613 4099 26 as as IN 19613 4099 27 specifically specifically RB 19613 4099 28 Roman roman JJ 19613 4099 29 . . . 19613 4099 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4100 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4100 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4100 3 300 300 CD 19613 4100 4 : : : 19613 4100 5 No no RB 19613 4100 6 doubt doubt RB 19613 4100 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4100 8 must must MD 19613 4100 9 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 4100 10 two two CD 19613 4100 11 halves half NNS 19613 4100 12 in in IN 19613 4100 13 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 4100 14 . . . 19613 4101 1 The the DT 19613 4101 2 first first JJ 19613 4101 3 , , , 19613 4101 4 the the DT 19613 4101 5 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4101 6 West West NNP 19613 4101 7 , , , 19613 4101 8 includes include VBZ 19613 4101 9 the the DT 19613 4101 10 west west JJ 19613 4101 11 coast coast NN 19613 4101 12 of of IN 19613 4101 13 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4101 14 Minor Minor NNP 19613 4101 15 , , , 19613 4101 16 Greece Greece NNP 19613 4101 17 , , , 19613 4101 18 and and CC 19613 4101 19 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4101 20 together together RB 19613 4101 21 with with IN 19613 4101 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4101 23 daughter daughter NN 19613 4101 24 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4101 25 , , , 19613 4101 26 that that RB 19613 4101 27 is is RB 19613 4101 28 , , , 19613 4101 29 above above IN 19613 4101 30 all all DT 19613 4101 31 , , , 19613 4101 32 Gaul Gaul NNP 19613 4101 33 and and CC 19613 4101 34 North North NNP 19613 4101 35 Africa Africa NNP 19613 4101 36 . . . 19613 4102 1 The the DT 19613 4102 2 second second JJ 19613 4102 3 or or CC 19613 4102 4 eastern eastern JJ 19613 4102 5 portion portion NN 19613 4102 6 embraces embrace VBZ 19613 4102 7 Palestine Palestine NNP 19613 4102 8 , , , 19613 4102 9 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 4102 10 , , , 19613 4102 11 Syria Syria NNP 19613 4102 12 , , , 19613 4102 13 and and CC 19613 4102 14 the the DT 19613 4102 15 east east JJ 19613 4102 16 part part NN 19613 4102 17 of of IN 19613 4102 18 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4102 19 Minor Minor NNP 19613 4102 20 . . . 19613 4103 1 A a DT 19613 4103 2 displacement displacement NN 19613 4103 3 gradually gradually RB 19613 4103 4 arose arise VBD 19613 4103 5 in in IN 19613 4103 6 the the DT 19613 4103 7 course course NN 19613 4103 8 of of IN 19613 4103 9 the the DT 19613 4103 10 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4103 11 century century NN 19613 4103 12 . . . 19613 4104 1 In in IN 19613 4104 2 the the DT 19613 4104 3 West West NNP 19613 4104 4 the the DT 19613 4104 5 most most RBS 19613 4104 6 important important JJ 19613 4104 7 centres centre NNS 19613 4104 8 are be VBP 19613 4104 9 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 19613 4104 10 , , , 19613 4104 11 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 19613 4104 12 , , , 19613 4104 13 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 4104 14 , , , 19613 4104 15 and and CC 19613 4104 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4104 17 , , , 19613 4104 18 cities city NNS 19613 4104 19 with with IN 19613 4104 20 a a DT 19613 4104 21 Greek greek JJ 19613 4104 22 and and CC 19613 4104 23 Oriental oriental JJ 19613 4104 24 population population NN 19613 4104 25 . . . 19613 4105 1 Even even RB 19613 4105 2 in in IN 19613 4105 3 Carthage carthage NN 19613 4105 4 the the DT 19613 4105 5 original original JJ 19613 4105 6 speech speech NN 19613 4105 7 of of IN 19613 4105 8 the the DT 19613 4105 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 4105 10 community community NN 19613 4105 11 was be VBD 19613 4105 12 probably probably RB 19613 4105 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4105 14 . . . 19613 4105 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4106 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4106 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4106 3 301 301 CD 19613 4106 4 : : : 19613 4106 5 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4106 6 was be VBD 19613 4106 7 the the DT 19613 4106 8 first first JJ 19613 4106 9 city city NN 19613 4106 10 in in IN 19613 4106 11 the the DT 19613 4106 12 Empire Empire NNP 19613 4106 13 , , , 19613 4106 14 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4106 15 the the DT 19613 4106 16 second second NN 19613 4106 17 . . . 19613 4107 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4107 2 were be VBD 19613 4107 3 the the DT 19613 4107 4 metropolitan metropolitan JJ 19613 4107 5 cities city NNS 19613 4107 6 of of IN 19613 4107 7 the the DT 19613 4107 8 world world NN 19613 4107 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4107 10 see see VB 19613 4107 11 the the DT 19613 4107 12 inscription inscription NN 19613 4107 13 in in IN 19613 4107 14 Kaibel Kaibel NNP 19613 4107 15 , , , 19613 4107 16 No no UH 19613 4107 17 . . . 19613 4108 1 1561 1561 CD 19613 4108 2 , , , 19613 4108 3 p. p. NN 19613 4108 4 407 407 CD 19613 4108 5 : : : 19613 4108 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4108 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4108 8 : : : 19613 4108 9 threpse threpse NN 19613 4108 10 m m NN 19613 4108 11 ' ' `` 19613 4108 12 Alexandreia Alexandreia NNP 19613 4108 13 , , , 19613 4108 14 metoikon metoikon VB 19613 4108 15 ethapse ethapse NNP 19613 4108 16 de de NNP 19613 4108 17 Rhomê Rhomê NNP 19613 4108 18 , , , 19613 4108 19 hai hai NNP 19613 4108 20 kosmou kosmou NNP 19613 4108 21 kai kai NNP 19613 4108 22 gês gês NNP 19613 4108 23 , , , 19613 4108 24 ô ô NNP 19613 4108 25 xene xene NNP 19613 4108 26 , , , 19613 4108 27 mêtropoleis mêtropoleis NNP 19613 4108 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4108 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4108 30 . . . 19613 4109 1 This this DT 19613 4109 2 is be VBZ 19613 4109 3 reflected reflect VBN 19613 4109 4 in in IN 19613 4109 5 the the DT 19613 4109 6 history history NN 19613 4109 7 of of IN 19613 4109 8 the the DT 19613 4109 9 Church Church NNP 19613 4109 10 ; ; : 19613 4109 11 first first JJ 19613 4109 12 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4109 13 appears appear VBZ 19613 4109 14 , , , 19613 4109 15 then then RB 19613 4109 16 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4109 17 . . . 19613 4110 1 The the DT 19613 4110 2 significance significance NN 19613 4110 3 of of IN 19613 4110 4 the the DT 19613 4110 5 great great JJ 19613 4110 6 towns town NNS 19613 4110 7 for for IN 19613 4110 8 the the DT 19613 4110 9 history history NN 19613 4110 10 of of IN 19613 4110 11 dogma dogma NN 19613 4110 12 and and CC 19613 4110 13 of of IN 19613 4110 14 the the DT 19613 4110 15 Church Church NNP 19613 4110 16 will will MD 19613 4110 17 be be VB 19613 4110 18 treated treat VBN 19613 4110 19 of of IN 19613 4110 20 in in IN 19613 4110 21 a a DT 19613 4110 22 future future JJ 19613 4110 23 volume volume NN 19613 4110 24 . . . 19613 4111 1 Abercius Abercius NNP 19613 4111 2 of of IN 19613 4111 3 Hieropolis Hieropolis NNP 19613 4111 4 , , , 19613 4111 5 according accord VBG 19613 4111 6 to to IN 19613 4111 7 the the DT 19613 4111 8 common common JJ 19613 4111 9 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 4111 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4111 11 inscription inscription NN 19613 4111 12 V. V. NNP 19613 4111 13 7 7 CD 19613 4111 14 f. f. NNS 19613 4111 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4111 16 designates designate VBZ 19613 4111 17 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4111 18 as as IN 19613 4111 19 " " `` 19613 4111 20 queen queen NN 19613 4111 21 . . . 19613 4111 22 " " '' 19613 4112 1 This this DT 19613 4112 2 was be VBD 19613 4112 3 a a DT 19613 4112 4 customary customary JJ 19613 4112 5 appellation appellation NN 19613 4112 6 ; ; : 19613 4112 7 see see VB 19613 4112 8 Eunap Eunap NNP 19613 4112 9 . . . 19613 4112 10 , , , 19613 4112 11 vita vita NNP 19613 4112 12 Prohaer Prohaer NNP 19613 4112 13 . . . 19613 4113 1 p. p. NN 19613 4113 2 90 90 CD 19613 4113 3 : : : 19613 4113 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4113 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4113 6 : : : 19613 4113 7 hê hê NNP 19613 4113 8 basileuousa basileuousa VBN 19613 4113 9 Rhômê Rhômê NNP 19613 4113 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4113 11 . . . 19613 4113 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4114 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4114 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4114 3 302 302 CD 19613 4114 4 : : : 19613 4114 5 In in IN 19613 4114 6 this this DT 19613 4114 7 connection connection NN 19613 4114 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4114 9 need need VBP 19613 4114 10 only only RB 19613 4114 11 keep keep VB 19613 4114 12 in in IN 19613 4114 13 mind mind NN 19613 4114 14 the the DT 19613 4114 15 following follow VBG 19613 4114 16 summary summary NN 19613 4114 17 of of IN 19613 4114 18 facts fact NNS 19613 4114 19 . . . 19613 4115 1 Up up IN 19613 4115 2 to to IN 19613 4115 3 the the DT 19613 4115 4 end end NN 19613 4115 5 of of IN 19613 4115 6 the the DT 19613 4115 7 second second JJ 19613 4115 8 century century NN 19613 4115 9 the the DT 19613 4115 10 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 4115 11 Church Church NNP 19613 4115 12 had have VBD 19613 4115 13 none none NN 19613 4115 14 of of IN 19613 4115 15 the the DT 19613 4115 16 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 4115 17 and and CC 19613 4115 18 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 4115 19 standards standard NNS 19613 4115 20 , , , 19613 4115 21 and and CC 19613 4115 22 none none NN 19613 4115 23 of of IN 19613 4115 24 the the DT 19613 4115 25 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 4115 26 institutions institution NNS 19613 4115 27 as as IN 19613 4115 28 found find VBN 19613 4115 29 in in IN 19613 4115 30 the the DT 19613 4115 31 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4115 32 Church Church NNP 19613 4115 33 ; ; : 19613 4115 34 but but CC 19613 4115 35 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4115 36 writer writer NN 19613 4115 37 , , , 19613 4115 38 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4115 39 , , , 19613 4115 40 was be VBD 19613 4115 41 also also RB 19613 4115 42 " " `` 19613 4115 43 as as RB 19613 4115 44 little little JJ 19613 4115 45 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 4115 46 with with IN 19613 4115 47 the the DT 19613 4115 48 West West NNP 19613 4115 49 as as IN 19613 4115 50 Homer Homer NNP 19613 4115 51 . . . 19613 4115 52 " " '' 19613 4116 1 In in IN 19613 4116 2 the the DT 19613 4116 3 course course NN 19613 4116 4 of of IN 19613 4116 5 the the DT 19613 4116 6 first first JJ 19613 4116 7 half half NN 19613 4116 8 of of IN 19613 4116 9 the the DT 19613 4116 10 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4116 11 century century NN 19613 4116 12 she -PRON- PRP 19613 4116 13 received receive VBD 19613 4116 14 those those DT 19613 4116 15 standards standard NNS 19613 4116 16 and and CC 19613 4116 17 institutions institution NNS 19613 4116 18 ; ; : 19613 4116 19 but but CC 19613 4116 20 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4116 21 writer writer NN 19613 4116 22 , , , 19613 4116 23 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4116 24 , , , 19613 4116 25 also also RB 19613 4116 26 travelled travel VBD 19613 4116 27 to to IN 19613 4116 28 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4116 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4116 30 in in IN 19613 4116 31 order order NN 19613 4116 32 to to TO 19613 4116 33 see see VB 19613 4116 34 " " `` 19613 4116 35 the the DT 19613 4116 36 very very RB 19613 4116 37 old old JJ 19613 4116 38 " " '' 19613 4116 39 church church NN 19613 4116 40 and and CC 19613 4116 41 formed form VBD 19613 4116 42 a a DT 19613 4116 43 connection connection NN 19613 4116 44 with with IN 19613 4116 45 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4116 46 ; ; : 19613 4116 47 and and CC 19613 4116 48 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4116 49 bishop bishop NN 19613 4116 50 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4116 51 carried carry VBD 19613 4116 52 on on IN 19613 4116 53 a a DT 19613 4116 54 correspondence correspondence NN 19613 4116 55 with with IN 19613 4116 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4116 57 Roman roman JJ 19613 4116 58 colleague colleague NN 19613 4116 59 , , , 19613 4116 60 who who WP 19613 4116 61 also also RB 19613 4116 62 made make VBD 19613 4116 63 common common JJ 19613 4116 64 cause cause VB 19613 4116 65 with with IN 19613 4116 66 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4116 67 . . . 19613 4117 1 Similar similar JJ 19613 4117 2 particulars particular NNS 19613 4117 3 may may MD 19613 4117 4 also also RB 19613 4117 5 be be VB 19613 4117 6 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 4117 7 with with IN 19613 4117 8 regard regard NN 19613 4117 9 to to IN 19613 4117 10 the the DT 19613 4117 11 Syrian Syrian NNP 19613 4117 12 Church Church NNP 19613 4117 13 . . . 19613 4117 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4118 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4118 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4118 3 303 303 CD 19613 4118 4 : : : 19613 4118 5 See see VB 19613 4118 6 the the DT 19613 4118 7 proofs proof NNS 19613 4118 8 in in IN 19613 4118 9 the the DT 19613 4118 10 two two CD 19613 4118 11 preceding precede VBG 19613 4118 12 chapters chapter NNS 19613 4118 13 . . . 19613 4119 1 Note note VB 19613 4119 2 also also RB 19613 4119 3 that that IN 19613 4119 4 these these DT 19613 4119 5 elements element NNS 19613 4119 6 have have VBP 19613 4119 7 an an DT 19613 4119 8 inward inward JJ 19613 4119 9 connection connection NN 19613 4119 10 . . . 19613 4120 1 So so RB 19613 4120 2 long long RB 19613 4120 3 as as IN 19613 4120 4 one one PRP 19613 4120 5 was be VBD 19613 4120 6 lacking lack VBG 19613 4120 7 , , , 19613 4120 8 all all DT 19613 4120 9 were be VBD 19613 4120 10 , , , 19613 4120 11 and and CC 19613 4120 12 whenever whenever WRB 19613 4120 13 one one PRP 19613 4120 14 was be VBD 19613 4120 15 present present JJ 19613 4120 16 , , , 19613 4120 17 all all PDT 19613 4120 18 the the DT 19613 4120 19 others other NNS 19613 4120 20 immediately immediately RB 19613 4120 21 made make VBD 19613 4120 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4120 23 appearance appearance NN 19613 4120 24 . . . 19613 4120 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4121 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4121 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4121 3 304 304 CD 19613 4121 4 : : : 19613 4121 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4121 6 already already RB 19613 4121 7 says say VBZ 19613 4121 8 that that IN 19613 4121 9 the the DT 19613 4121 10 Roman roman JJ 19613 4121 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4121 12 are be VBP 19613 4121 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4121 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4121 15 : : : 19613 4121 16 apodiulismenoi apodiulismenoi NNP 19613 4121 17 apo apo NNP 19613 4121 18 pantos pantos NNP 19613 4121 19 allotrion allotrion NNP 19613 4121 20 chrômatos chrômatos NNP 19613 4121 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4121 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4121 23 Rom Rom NNP 19613 4121 24 . . . 19613 4122 1 inscr inscr NNP 19613 4122 2 . . . 19613 4123 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4123 2 ; ; : 19613 4123 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4123 4 uses use VBZ 19613 4123 5 this this DT 19613 4123 6 expression expression NN 19613 4123 7 of of IN 19613 4123 8 no no DT 19613 4123 9 others other NNS 19613 4123 10 . . . 19613 4124 1 Similar similar JJ 19613 4124 2 remarks remark NNS 19613 4124 3 are be VBP 19613 4124 4 not not RB 19613 4124 5 quite quite RB 19613 4124 6 rare rare JJ 19613 4124 7 at at IN 19613 4124 8 a a DT 19613 4124 9 later later JJ 19613 4124 10 period period NN 19613 4124 11 ; ; : 19613 4124 12 see see VB 19613 4124 13 , , , 19613 4124 14 for for IN 19613 4124 15 instance instance NN 19613 4124 16 , , , 19613 4124 17 the the DT 19613 4124 18 oft oft RB 19613 4124 19 - - HYPH 19613 4124 20 repeated repeat VBN 19613 4124 21 eulogy eulogy NN 19613 4124 22 that that IN 19613 4124 23 no no DT 19613 4124 24 heresy heresy NN 19613 4124 25 ever ever RB 19613 4124 26 arose arise VBD 19613 4124 27 in in IN 19613 4124 28 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4124 29 . . . 19613 4125 1 At at IN 19613 4125 2 a a DT 19613 4125 3 time time NN 19613 4125 4 when when WRB 19613 4125 5 this this DT 19613 4125 6 city city NN 19613 4125 7 had have VBD 19613 4125 8 long long RB 19613 4125 9 employed employ VBN 19613 4125 10 the the DT 19613 4125 11 standard standard NN 19613 4125 12 of of IN 19613 4125 13 the the DT 19613 4125 14 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 4125 15 rule rule NN 19613 4125 16 of of IN 19613 4125 17 faith faith NN 19613 4125 18 with with IN 19613 4125 19 complete complete JJ 19613 4125 20 confidence confidence NN 19613 4125 21 , , , 19613 4125 22 namely namely RB 19613 4125 23 , , , 19613 4125 24 at at IN 19613 4125 25 the the DT 19613 4125 26 beginning beginning NN 19613 4125 27 of of IN 19613 4125 28 the the DT 19613 4125 29 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4125 30 century century NN 19613 4125 31 , , , 19613 4125 32 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4125 33 hear hear VBP 19613 4125 34 that that IN 19613 4125 35 a a DT 19613 4125 36 lady lady NN 19613 4125 37 of of IN 19613 4125 38 rank rank NN 19613 4125 39 in in IN 19613 4125 40 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4125 41 , , , 19613 4125 42 who who WP 19613 4125 43 was be VBD 19613 4125 44 at at IN 19613 4125 45 any any DT 19613 4125 46 rate rate NN 19613 4125 47 a a DT 19613 4125 48 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4125 49 , , , 19613 4125 50 lodged lodge VBN 19613 4125 51 and and CC 19613 4125 52 entertained entertain VBD 19613 4125 53 in in IN 19613 4125 54 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4125 55 house house NN 19613 4125 56 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4125 57 , , , 19613 4125 58 then then RB 19613 4125 59 a a DT 19613 4125 60 young young JJ 19613 4125 61 man man NN 19613 4125 62 , , , 19613 4125 63 and and CC 19613 4125 64 a a DT 19613 4125 65 famous famous JJ 19613 4125 66 heretic heretic NN 19613 4125 67 . . . 19613 4126 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4126 2 See See NNP 19613 4126 3 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4126 4 . . NNP 19613 4126 5 , , , 19613 4126 6 H. H. NNP 19613 4126 7 E. E. NNP 19613 4126 8 VI VI NNP 19613 4126 9 . . . 19613 4127 1 2 2 LS 19613 4127 2 . . . 19613 4128 1 13 13 CD 19613 4128 2 , , , 19613 4128 3 14 14 CD 19613 4128 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4128 5 . . . 19613 4129 1 The the DT 19613 4129 2 lectures lecture NNS 19613 4129 3 on on IN 19613 4129 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4129 5 delivered deliver VBN 19613 4129 6 by by IN 19613 4129 7 this this DT 19613 4129 8 heretic heretic NN 19613 4129 9 and and CC 19613 4129 10 the the DT 19613 4129 11 conventicles conventicle NNS 19613 4129 12 over over IN 19613 4129 13 which which WDT 19613 4129 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4129 15 presided preside VBD 19613 4129 16 were be VBD 19613 4129 17 attended attend VBN 19613 4129 18 by by IN 19613 4129 19 a a DT 19613 4129 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4129 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4129 22 : : : 19613 4129 23 murion murion NN 19613 4129 24 plêthos plêthos NNP 19613 4129 25 ou ou NNP 19613 4129 26 monon monon NNP 19613 4129 27 hairetikôn hairetikôn NN 19613 4129 28 , , , 19613 4129 29 alla alla NNP 19613 4129 30 kai kai NNP 19613 4129 31 hêmetephôn hêmetephôn NN 19613 4129 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4129 33 . . . 19613 4130 1 That that DT 19613 4130 2 is be VBZ 19613 4130 3 a a DT 19613 4130 4 very very RB 19613 4130 5 valuable valuable JJ 19613 4130 6 piece piece NN 19613 4130 7 of of IN 19613 4130 8 information information NN 19613 4130 9 which which WDT 19613 4130 10 shows show VBZ 19613 4130 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4130 12 a a DT 19613 4130 13 state state NN 19613 4130 14 of of IN 19613 4130 15 things thing NNS 19613 4130 16 in in IN 19613 4130 17 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4130 18 that that WDT 19613 4130 19 would would MD 19613 4130 20 have have VB 19613 4130 21 been be VBN 19613 4130 22 impossible impossible JJ 19613 4130 23 in in IN 19613 4130 24 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4130 25 at at IN 19613 4130 26 the the DT 19613 4130 27 same same JJ 19613 4130 28 period period NN 19613 4130 29 . . . 19613 4131 1 See see VB 19613 4131 2 , , , 19613 4131 3 besides besides RB 19613 4131 4 , , , 19613 4131 5 Dionys dionys NN 19613 4131 6 . . . 19613 4132 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 4132 2 , , , 19613 4132 3 in in IN 19613 4132 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4132 5 . . NNP 19613 4132 6 , , , 19613 4132 7 H. H. NNP 19613 4132 8 E. E. NNP 19613 4132 9 VII VII NNP 19613 4132 10 . . . 19613 4133 1 7 7 LS 19613 4133 2 . . . 19613 4133 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4134 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4134 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4134 3 305 305 CD 19613 4134 4 : : : 19613 4134 5 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4134 6 must must MD 19613 4134 7 here here RB 19613 4134 8 refrain refrain VB 19613 4134 9 from from IN 19613 4134 10 proving prove VBG 19613 4134 11 the the DT 19613 4134 12 last last JJ 19613 4134 13 assertion assertion NN 19613 4134 14 . . . 19613 4135 1 The the DT 19613 4135 2 possibility possibility NN 19613 4135 3 of of IN 19613 4135 4 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4135 5 Minor Minor NNP 19613 4135 6 having have VBG 19613 4135 7 had have VBD 19613 4135 8 a a DT 19613 4135 9 considerable considerable JJ 19613 4135 10 share share NN 19613 4135 11 , , , 19613 4135 12 or or CC 19613 4135 13 having have VBG 19613 4135 14 led lead VBN 19613 4135 15 the the DT 19613 4135 16 way way NN 19613 4135 17 , , , 19613 4135 18 in in IN 19613 4135 19 the the DT 19613 4135 20 formation formation NN 19613 4135 21 of of IN 19613 4135 22 the the DT 19613 4135 23 canon canon NN 19613 4135 24 must must MD 19613 4135 25 be be VB 19613 4135 26 left leave VBN 19613 4135 27 an an DT 19613 4135 28 open open JJ 19613 4135 29 question question NN 19613 4135 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4135 31 cf cf NN 19613 4135 32 . . . 19613 4136 1 what what WP 19613 4136 2 Melito Melito NNP 19613 4136 3 says say VBZ 19613 4136 4 , , , 19613 4136 5 and and CC 19613 4136 6 the the DT 19613 4136 7 use use NN 19613 4136 8 made make VBN 19613 4136 9 of of IN 19613 4136 10 New New NNP 19613 4136 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4136 12 writings writing NNS 19613 4136 13 in in IN 19613 4136 14 the the DT 19613 4136 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 4136 16 of of IN 19613 4136 17 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 4136 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4136 19 . . . 19613 4137 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4137 2 will will MD 19613 4137 3 , , , 19613 4137 4 however however RB 19613 4137 5 , , , 19613 4137 6 be be VB 19613 4137 7 constrained constrain VBN 19613 4137 8 to to TO 19613 4137 9 lay lay VB 19613 4137 10 the the DT 19613 4137 11 chief chief JJ 19613 4137 12 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 4137 13 on on IN 19613 4137 14 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4137 15 , , , 19613 4137 16 for for IN 19613 4137 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4137 18 must must MD 19613 4137 19 not not RB 19613 4137 20 be be VB 19613 4137 21 forgotten forget VBN 19613 4137 22 that that IN 19613 4137 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4137 24 had have VBD 19613 4137 25 the the DT 19613 4137 26 closest close JJS 19613 4137 27 connection connection NN 19613 4137 28 with with IN 19613 4137 29 the the DT 19613 4137 30 Church Church NNP 19613 4137 31 of of IN 19613 4137 32 that that DT 19613 4137 33 city city NN 19613 4137 34 , , , 19613 4137 35 as as IN 19613 4137 36 is be VBZ 19613 4137 37 proved prove VBN 19613 4137 38 by by IN 19613 4137 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4137 40 great great JJ 19613 4137 41 work work NN 19613 4137 42 , , , 19613 4137 43 and and CC 19613 4137 44 that that IN 19613 4137 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4137 46 lived live VBD 19613 4137 47 there there RB 19613 4137 48 before before IN 19613 4137 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4137 50 came come VBD 19613 4137 51 to to IN 19613 4137 52 Gaul Gaul NNP 19613 4137 53 . . . 19613 4138 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4138 2 , , , 19613 4138 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4138 4 is be VBZ 19613 4138 5 a a DT 19613 4138 6 fact fact NN 19613 4138 7 deserving deserving NN 19613 4138 8 of of IN 19613 4138 9 the the DT 19613 4138 10 greatest great JJS 19613 4138 11 attention attention NN 19613 4138 12 that that WDT 19613 4138 13 the the DT 19613 4138 14 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 4138 15 and and CC 19613 4138 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4138 17 decided decide VBN 19613 4138 18 opponents opponent NNS 19613 4138 19 in in IN 19613 4138 20 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4138 21 , , , 19613 4138 22 the the DT 19613 4138 23 so so RB 19613 4138 24 - - HYPH 19613 4138 25 called call VBN 19613 4138 26 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 4138 27 , , , 19613 4138 28 had have VBD 19613 4138 29 no no DT 19613 4138 30 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4138 31 _ _ NNP 19613 4138 32 canon canon NNP 19613 4138 33 _ _ NNP 19613 4138 34 before before IN 19613 4138 35 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4138 36 , , , 19613 4138 37 though though IN 19613 4138 38 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4138 39 may may MD 19613 4138 40 all all RB 19613 4138 41 have have VB 19613 4138 42 possessed possess VBN 19613 4138 43 the the DT 19613 4138 44 universally universally RB 19613 4138 45 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 4138 46 books book NNS 19613 4138 47 of of IN 19613 4138 48 the the DT 19613 4138 49 Romish romish JJ 19613 4138 50 canon canon NN 19613 4138 51 , , , 19613 4138 52 and and CC 19613 4138 53 none none NN 19613 4138 54 other other JJ 19613 4138 55 , , , 19613 4138 56 in in IN 19613 4138 57 the the DT 19613 4138 58 shape shape NN 19613 4138 59 of of IN 19613 4138 60 _ _ NNP 19613 4138 61 books book NNS 19613 4138 62 read read VBN 19613 4138 63 in in IN 19613 4138 64 the the DT 19613 4138 65 churches church NNS 19613 4138 66 _ _ NNP 19613 4138 67 . . . 19613 4138 68 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4139 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4139 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4139 3 306 306 CD 19613 4139 4 : : : 19613 4139 5 See see VB 19613 4139 6 the the DT 19613 4139 7 Prolegg Prolegg NNP 19613 4139 8 . . . 19613 4140 1 of of IN 19613 4140 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 19613 4140 3 and and CC 19613 4140 4 Hort Hort NNP 19613 4140 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4140 6 these these DT 19613 4140 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 4140 8 give give VBP 19613 4140 9 an an DT 19613 4140 10 opposite opposite JJ 19613 4140 11 judgment judgment NN 19613 4140 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4140 13 , , , 19613 4140 14 and and CC 19613 4140 15 cf cf NN 19613 4140 16 . . . 19613 4141 1 Harris Harris NNP 19613 4141 2 , , , 19613 4141 3 _ _ NNP 19613 4141 4 Codex Codex NNP 19613 4141 5 Bezae Bezae NNPS 19613 4141 6 . . . 19613 4142 1 A a DT 19613 4142 2 study study NN 19613 4142 3 of of IN 19613 4142 4 the the DT 19613 4142 5 so so RB 19613 4142 6 - - HYPH 19613 4142 7 called call VBN 19613 4142 8 Western western JJ 19613 4142 9 text text NN 19613 4142 10 of of IN 19613 4142 11 the the DT 19613 4142 12 New New NNP 19613 4142 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4142 14 _ _ NNP 19613 4142 15 1891 1891 CD 19613 4142 16 . . . 19613 4143 1 An an DT 19613 4143 2 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 19613 4143 3 study study NN 19613 4143 4 of of IN 19613 4143 5 the the DT 19613 4143 6 oldest old JJS 19613 4143 7 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 19613 4143 8 has have VBZ 19613 4143 9 already already RB 19613 4143 10 led lead VBN 19613 4143 11 to to IN 19613 4143 12 important important JJ 19613 4143 13 cases case NNS 19613 4143 14 of of IN 19613 4143 15 agreement agreement NN 19613 4143 16 between between IN 19613 4143 17 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4143 18 and and CC 19613 4143 19 the the DT 19613 4143 20 East East NNP 19613 4143 21 , , , 19613 4143 22 and and CC 19613 4143 23 promises promise NNS 19613 4143 24 still still RB 19613 4143 25 further further JJ 19613 4143 26 revelations revelation NNS 19613 4143 27 . . . 19613 4144 1 See see UH 19613 4144 2 Duchesne Duchesne NNP 19613 4144 3 , , , 19613 4144 4 " " '' 19613 4144 5 Les Les NNP 19613 4144 6 Sources Sources NNP 19613 4144 7 du du VBP 19613 4144 8 Martyrologe Martyrologe NNP 19613 4144 9 Hieron Hieron NNP 19613 4144 10 . . . 19613 4144 11 " " '' 19613 4145 1 1885 1885 CD 19613 4145 2 . . . 19613 4146 1 Egli egli UH 19613 4146 2 , , , 19613 4146 3 " " '' 19613 4146 4 Altchristliche Altchristliche NNP 19613 4146 5 Studien Studien NNP 19613 4146 6 , , , 19613 4146 7 Martyrien Martyrien NNP 19613 4146 8 und und JJ 19613 4146 9 Martyrologieen Martyrologieen NNP 19613 4146 10 ältester ältester NN 19613 4146 11 Zeit Zeit NNP 19613 4146 12 . . . 19613 4146 13 " " '' 19613 4147 1 1887 1887 CD 19613 4147 2 ; ; : 19613 4147 3 the the DT 19613 4147 4 same same JJ 19613 4147 5 writer writer NN 19613 4147 6 in in IN 19613 4147 7 the the DT 19613 4147 8 " " `` 19613 4147 9 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 4147 10 für für NN 19613 4147 11 wissenschaftliche wissenschaftliche NN 19613 4147 12 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 4147 13 " " '' 19613 4147 14 , , , 19613 4147 15 1891 1891 CD 19613 4147 16 , , , 19613 4147 17 p. p. NN 19613 4147 18 273 273 CD 19613 4147 19 ff ff NNP 19613 4147 20 . . . 19613 4147 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4148 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4148 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4148 3 307 307 CD 19613 4148 4 : : : 19613 4148 5 On on IN 19613 4148 6 the the DT 19613 4148 7 relations relation NNS 19613 4148 8 between between IN 19613 4148 9 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 4148 10 and and CC 19613 4148 11 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4148 12 see see VBP 19613 4148 13 the the DT 19613 4148 14 end end NN 19613 4148 15 of of IN 19613 4148 16 the the DT 19613 4148 17 Excursus Excursus NNP 19613 4148 18 . . . 19613 4148 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4149 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4149 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4149 3 308 308 CD 19613 4149 4 : : : 19613 4149 5 See see VB 19613 4149 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4149 7 treatise treatise NN 19613 4149 8 " " '' 19613 4149 9 Die die VB 19613 4149 10 ältesten ältesten JJ 19613 4149 11 christlichen christlichen NNP 19613 4149 12 Datirungen Datirungen NNP 19613 4149 13 und und NN 19613 4149 14 die die VBP 19613 4149 15 Anfánge anfánge JJ 19613 4149 16 einer einer NN 19613 4149 17 bischòflichen bischòflichen NNP 19613 4149 18 Chronographie Chronographie NNP 19613 4149 19 in in IN 19613 4149 20 Rom Rom NNP 19613 4149 21 . . . 19613 4149 22 " " '' 19613 4150 1 in in IN 19613 4150 2 the the DT 19613 4150 3 report report NN 19613 4150 4 of of IN 19613 4150 5 the the DT 19613 4150 6 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 4150 7 of of IN 19613 4150 8 the the DT 19613 4150 9 Royal Royal NNP 19613 4150 10 Prussian Prussian NNP 19613 4150 11 Academy Academy NNP 19613 4150 12 of of IN 19613 4150 13 Science Science NNP 19613 4150 14 , , , 19613 4150 15 1892 1892 CD 19613 4150 16 , , , 19613 4150 17 pp pp NNP 19613 4150 18 . . . 19613 4151 1 617 617 CD 19613 4151 2 - - SYM 19613 4151 3 658 658 CD 19613 4151 4 . . . 19613 4152 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4152 2 think think VBP 19613 4152 3 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4152 4 have have VBP 19613 4152 5 there there RB 19613 4152 6 proved prove VBN 19613 4152 7 that that IN 19613 4152 8 , , , 19613 4152 9 in in IN 19613 4152 10 the the DT 19613 4152 11 time time NN 19613 4152 12 of of IN 19613 4152 13 Soter Soter NNP 19613 4152 14 , , , 19613 4152 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4152 16 already already RB 19613 4152 17 possessed possess VBD 19613 4152 18 a a DT 19613 4152 19 figured figured JJ 19613 4152 20 list list NN 19613 4152 21 of of IN 19613 4152 22 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4152 23 , , , 19613 4152 24 in in IN 19613 4152 25 which which WDT 19613 4152 26 important important JJ 19613 4152 27 events event NNS 19613 4152 28 were be VBD 19613 4152 29 also also RB 19613 4152 30 entered enter VBN 19613 4152 31 . . . 19613 4152 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4153 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4153 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4153 3 309 309 CD 19613 4153 4 : : : 19613 4153 5 That that IN 19613 4153 6 the the DT 19613 4153 7 idea idea NN 19613 4153 8 of of IN 19613 4153 9 the the DT 19613 4153 10 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 4153 11 succession succession NN 19613 4153 12 of of IN 19613 4153 13 the the DT 19613 4153 14 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4153 15 was be VBD 19613 4153 16 first first RB 19613 4153 17 turned turn VBN 19613 4153 18 to to IN 19613 4153 19 account account NN 19613 4153 20 or or CC 19613 4153 21 appeared appear VBD 19613 4153 22 in in IN 19613 4153 23 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4153 24 is be VBZ 19613 4153 25 all all PDT 19613 4153 26 the the DT 19613 4153 27 more more RBR 19613 4153 28 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 4153 29 , , , 19613 4153 30 because because IN 19613 4153 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4153 32 was be VBD 19613 4153 33 not not RB 19613 4153 34 in in IN 19613 4153 35 that that DT 19613 4153 36 city city NN 19613 4153 37 , , , 19613 4153 38 but but CC 19613 4153 39 rather rather RB 19613 4153 40 in in IN 19613 4153 41 the the DT 19613 4153 42 East East NNP 19613 4153 43 , , , 19613 4153 44 that that IN 19613 4153 45 the the DT 19613 4153 46 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 4153 47 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 4153 48 was be VBD 19613 4153 49 first first RB 19613 4153 50 consolidated consolidate VBN 19613 4153 51 . . . 19613 4154 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4154 2 Cf cf NN 19613 4154 3 . . . 19613 4155 1 the the DT 19613 4155 2 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 4155 3 of of IN 19613 4155 4 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 4155 5 and and CC 19613 4155 6 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4155 7 ' ' POS 19613 4155 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 4155 9 to to IN 19613 4155 10 the the DT 19613 4155 11 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 4155 12 with with IN 19613 4155 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4155 14 other other JJ 19613 4155 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 4155 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4155 17 . . . 19613 4156 1 There there EX 19613 4156 2 must must MD 19613 4156 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 4156 4 have have VB 19613 4156 5 been be VBN 19613 4156 6 a a DT 19613 4156 7 very very RB 19613 4156 8 rapid rapid JJ 19613 4156 9 development development NN 19613 4156 10 of of IN 19613 4156 11 the the DT 19613 4156 12 constitution constitution NN 19613 4156 13 in in IN 19613 4156 14 the the DT 19613 4156 15 time time NN 19613 4156 16 between between IN 19613 4156 17 Hyginus Hyginus NNP 19613 4156 18 and and CC 19613 4156 19 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4156 20 . . . 19613 4157 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 4157 2 , , , 19613 4157 3 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4157 4 . . NNP 19613 4157 5 , , , 19613 4157 6 tries try VBZ 19613 4157 7 to to TO 19613 4157 8 show show VB 19613 4157 9 that that IN 19613 4157 10 the the DT 19613 4157 11 monarchical monarchical JJ 19613 4157 12 episcopate episcopate NN 19613 4157 13 arose arise VBD 19613 4157 14 in in IN 19613 4157 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4157 16 immediately immediately RB 19613 4157 17 after after IN 19613 4157 18 the the DT 19613 4157 19 composition composition NN 19613 4157 20 of of IN 19613 4157 21 the the DT 19613 4157 22 First First NNP 19613 4157 23 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 4157 24 of of IN 19613 4157 25 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4157 26 , , , 19613 4157 27 and and CC 19613 4157 28 as as IN 19613 4157 29 a a DT 19613 4157 30 result result NN 19613 4157 31 of of IN 19613 4157 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4157 33 ; ; : 19613 4157 34 and and CC 19613 4157 35 that that IN 19613 4157 36 this this DT 19613 4157 37 city city NN 19613 4157 38 was be VBD 19613 4157 39 the the DT 19613 4157 40 centre centre NN 19613 4157 41 from from IN 19613 4157 42 which which WDT 19613 4157 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4157 44 spread spread VBD 19613 4157 45 throughout throughout IN 19613 4157 46 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 4157 47 . . . 19613 4157 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4158 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4158 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4158 3 310 310 CD 19613 4158 4 : : : 19613 4158 5 See see VB 19613 4158 6 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 4158 7 - - HYPH 19613 4158 8 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 4158 9 's 's POS 19613 4158 10 work work NN 19613 4158 11 " " `` 19613 4158 12 de de FW 19613 4158 13 aleat aleat FW 19613 4158 14 " " '' 19613 4158 15 which which WDT 19613 4158 16 , , , 19613 4158 17 in in IN 19613 4158 18 spite spite NN 19613 4158 19 of of IN 19613 4158 20 remarks remark NNS 19613 4158 21 to to IN 19613 4158 22 the the DT 19613 4158 23 contrary contrary NN 19613 4158 24 , , , 19613 4158 25 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4158 26 am be VBP 19613 4158 27 inclined inclined JJ 19613 4158 28 to to TO 19613 4158 29 regard regard VB 19613 4158 30 as as IN 19613 4158 31 written write VBN 19613 4158 32 by by IN 19613 4158 33 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4158 34 ; ; : 19613 4158 35 cf cf NNP 19613 4158 36 . . . 19613 4159 1 " " `` 19613 4159 2 Texte Texte NNP 19613 4159 3 und und NN 19613 4159 4 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 4159 5 " " `` 19613 4159 6 V. V. NNP 19613 4159 7 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4159 8 ; ; : 19613 4159 9 see see VB 19613 4159 10 c. c. IN 19613 4159 11 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4159 12 of of IN 19613 4159 13 this this DT 19613 4159 14 writing writing NN 19613 4159 15 : : : 19613 4159 16 " " `` 19613 4159 17 et et FW 19613 4159 18 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 4159 19 in in IN 19613 4159 20 nobis nobis NNP 19613 4159 21 divina divina NNP 19613 4159 22 et et NNP 19613 4159 23 paterna paterna NNP 19613 4159 24 pietas pietas NNP 19613 4159 25 apostolatus apostolatus NNP 19613 4159 26 ducatum ducatum NNP 19613 4159 27 contulit contulit NNP 19613 4159 28 et et NNP 19613 4159 29 vicariam vicariam NNP 19613 4159 30 domini domini NNP 19613 4159 31 sedem sedem NNP 19613 4159 32 cælesti cælesti NNP 19613 4159 33 dignatione dignatione NNP 19613 4159 34 ordinavit ordinavit NNP 19613 4159 35 et et NNP 19613 4159 36 originem originem NNP 19613 4159 37 authentici authentici NNP 19613 4159 38 apostolatus apostolatus NNP 19613 4159 39 , , , 19613 4159 40 super super RB 19613 4159 41 quem quem NNP 19613 4159 42 Christus Christus NNP 19613 4159 43 fundavit fundavit NN 19613 4159 44 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 4159 45 , , , 19613 4159 46 in in IN 19613 4159 47 superiore superiore NNP 19613 4159 48 nostro nostro NNP 19613 4159 49 portamus portamus NNP 19613 4159 50 . . . 19613 4159 51 " " '' 19613 4159 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4160 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4160 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4160 3 311 311 CD 19613 4160 4 : : : 19613 4160 5 See see VB 19613 4160 6 report report NN 19613 4160 7 of of IN 19613 4160 8 the the DT 19613 4160 9 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 4160 10 of of IN 19613 4160 11 the the DT 19613 4160 12 Royal Royal NNP 19613 4160 13 Prussian Prussian NNP 19613 4160 14 Academy Academy NNP 19613 4160 15 of of IN 19613 4160 16 Science Science NNP 19613 4160 17 , , , 19613 4160 18 1892 1892 CD 19613 4160 19 , , , 19613 4160 20 p. p. NN 19613 4160 21 622 622 CD 19613 4160 22 ff ff NN 19613 4160 23 . . . 19613 4161 1 To to IN 19613 4161 2 the the DT 19613 4161 3 material material NN 19613 4161 4 found find VBD 19613 4161 5 there there EX 19613 4161 6 must must MD 19613 4161 7 be be VB 19613 4161 8 added add VBN 19613 4161 9 a a DT 19613 4161 10 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 4161 11 passage passage NN 19613 4161 12 given give VBN 19613 4161 13 by by IN 19613 4161 14 Nestle Nestle NNP 19613 4161 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4161 16 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 4161 17 fur fur NN 19613 4161 18 wissenschaftliche wissenschaftliche NN 19613 4161 19 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 4161 20 , , , 19613 4161 21 1893 1893 CD 19613 4161 22 , , , 19613 4161 23 p. p. NN 19613 4161 24 437 437 CD 19613 4161 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4161 26 , , , 19613 4161 27 where where WRB 19613 4161 28 the the DT 19613 4161 29 dates date NNS 19613 4161 30 are be VBP 19613 4161 31 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 4161 32 after after IN 19613 4161 33 Sixtus Sixtus NNP 19613 4161 34 I. I. NNP 19613 4161 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4162 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4162 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4162 3 312 312 CD 19613 4162 4 : : : 19613 4162 5 Cf cf NN 19613 4162 6 . . . 19613 4163 1 the the DT 19613 4163 2 8th 8th JJ 19613 4163 3 book book NN 19613 4163 4 of of IN 19613 4163 5 the the DT 19613 4163 6 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 4163 7 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 4163 8 with with IN 19613 4163 9 the the DT 19613 4163 10 articles article NNS 19613 4163 11 referring refer VBG 19613 4163 12 to to IN 19613 4163 13 the the DT 19613 4163 14 regulation regulation NN 19613 4163 15 of of IN 19613 4163 16 the the DT 19613 4163 17 Church Church NNP 19613 4163 18 , , , 19613 4163 19 which which WDT 19613 4163 20 in in IN 19613 4163 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4163 22 MSS MSS NNP 19613 4163 23 . . . 19613 4164 1 bear bear VB 19613 4164 2 the the DT 19613 4164 3 name name NN 19613 4164 4 of of IN 19613 4164 5 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4164 6 . . . 19613 4165 1 Compare compare VB 19613 4165 2 also also RB 19613 4165 3 the the DT 19613 4165 4 Arabian arabian JJ 19613 4165 5 Canones Canones NNP 19613 4165 6 Hippolyti Hippolyti NNP 19613 4165 7 , , , 19613 4165 8 edited edit VBN 19613 4165 9 by by IN 19613 4165 10 Haneberg Haneberg NNP 19613 4165 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4165 12 1870 1870 CD 19613 4165 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4165 14 and and CC 19613 4165 15 commented comment VBN 19613 4165 16 on on IN 19613 4165 17 by by IN 19613 4165 18 Achelis Achelis NNP 19613 4165 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4165 20 Texte Texte NNP 19613 4165 21 und und NN 19613 4165 22 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 4165 23 VI VI NNP 19613 4165 24 . . . 19613 4166 1 4 4 LS 19613 4166 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4166 3 . . . 19613 4167 1 Apart apart RB 19613 4167 2 from from IN 19613 4167 3 the the DT 19613 4167 4 additions addition NNS 19613 4167 5 and and CC 19613 4167 6 alterations alteration NNS 19613 4167 7 , , , 19613 4167 8 which which WDT 19613 4167 9 are be VBP 19613 4167 10 no no RB 19613 4167 11 doubt doubt RB 19613 4167 12 very very RB 19613 4167 13 extensive extensive JJ 19613 4167 14 , , , 19613 4167 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4167 16 is be VBZ 19613 4167 17 hardly hardly RB 19613 4167 18 likely likely JJ 19613 4167 19 that that IN 19613 4167 20 the the DT 19613 4167 21 name name NN 19613 4167 22 of of IN 19613 4167 23 the the DT 19613 4167 24 Roman roman JJ 19613 4167 25 bishop bishop NN 19613 4167 26 is be VBZ 19613 4167 27 wrongly wrongly RB 19613 4167 28 assigned assign VBN 19613 4167 29 to to IN 19613 4167 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4167 31 . . . 19613 4168 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4168 2 must must MD 19613 4168 3 further further RB 19613 4168 4 remember remember VB 19613 4168 5 the the DT 19613 4168 6 importance importance NN 19613 4168 7 assigned assign VBN 19613 4168 8 by by IN 19613 4168 9 the the DT 19613 4168 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 4168 11 of of IN 19613 4168 12 the the DT 19613 4168 13 Eastern eastern JJ 19613 4168 14 and and CC 19613 4168 15 Western western JJ 19613 4168 16 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4168 17 to to IN 19613 4168 18 one one CD 19613 4168 19 of of IN 19613 4168 20 the the DT 19613 4168 21 earliest early JJS 19613 4168 22 Roman roman JJ 19613 4168 23 " " '' 19613 4168 24 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4168 25 , , , 19613 4168 26 " " '' 19613 4168 27 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4168 28 , , , 19613 4168 29 as as IN 19613 4168 30 the the DT 19613 4168 31 confidant confidant NN 19613 4168 32 and and CC 19613 4168 33 secretary secretary NN 19613 4168 34 of of IN 19613 4168 35 the the DT 19613 4168 36 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 4168 37 and and CC 19613 4168 38 as as IN 19613 4168 39 the the DT 19613 4168 40 composer composer NN 19613 4168 41 and and CC 19613 4168 42 arranger arranger NN 19613 4168 43 of of IN 19613 4168 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4168 45 laws law NNS 19613 4168 46 . . . 19613 4168 47 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4169 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4169 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4169 3 313 313 CD 19613 4169 4 : : : 19613 4169 5 See see VB 19613 4169 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4169 7 proofs proof NNS 19613 4169 8 in in IN 19613 4169 9 " " `` 19613 4169 10 Texte Texte NNP 19613 4169 11 und und NN 19613 4169 12 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 4169 13 , , , 19613 4169 14 " " '' 19613 4169 15 Vol Vol NNP 19613 4169 16 . . . 19613 4170 1 II II NNP 19613 4170 2 . . NNP 19613 4170 3 , , , 19613 4170 4 Part Part NNP 19613 4170 5 5 5 CD 19613 4170 6 . . . 19613 4171 1 The the DT 19613 4171 2 canons canon NNS 19613 4171 3 of of IN 19613 4171 4 the the DT 19613 4171 5 Council Council NNP 19613 4171 6 of of IN 19613 4171 7 Nicæa Nicæa NNP 19613 4171 8 presuppose presuppose VB 19613 4171 9 the the DT 19613 4171 10 distinction distinction NN 19613 4171 11 of of IN 19613 4171 12 higher high JJR 19613 4171 13 and and CC 19613 4171 14 lower low JJR 19613 4171 15 clergy clergy NNS 19613 4171 16 for for IN 19613 4171 17 the the DT 19613 4171 18 whole whole JJ 19613 4171 19 Church Church NNP 19613 4171 20 . . . 19613 4171 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4172 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4172 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4172 3 314 314 CD 19613 4172 4 : : : 19613 4172 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4172 6 see see VBP 19613 4172 7 this this DT 19613 4172 8 from from IN 19613 4172 9 the the DT 19613 4172 10 Easter Easter NNP 19613 4172 11 controversy controversy NN 19613 4172 12 , , , 19613 4172 13 but but CC 19613 4172 14 there there EX 19613 4172 15 are be VBP 19613 4172 16 proofs proof NNS 19613 4172 17 of of IN 19613 4172 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4172 19 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 4172 20 , , , 19613 4172 21 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 4172 22 , , , 19613 4172 23 in in IN 19613 4172 24 the the DT 19613 4172 25 collection collection NN 19613 4172 26 of of IN 19613 4172 27 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 4172 28 's 's POS 19613 4172 29 epistles epistle NNS 19613 4172 30 . . . 19613 4173 1 The the DT 19613 4173 2 Roman roman JJ 19613 4173 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 4173 4 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 4173 5 informs inform VBZ 19613 4173 6 Fabius Fabius NNP 19613 4173 7 , , , 19613 4173 8 bishop bishop NN 19613 4173 9 of of IN 19613 4173 10 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4173 11 , , , 19613 4173 12 of of IN 19613 4173 13 the the DT 19613 4173 14 resolutions resolution NNS 19613 4173 15 of of IN 19613 4173 16 the the DT 19613 4173 17 Italian italian JJ 19613 4173 18 , , , 19613 4173 19 African african JJ 19613 4173 20 , , , 19613 4173 21 and and CC 19613 4173 22 other other JJ 19613 4173 23 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4173 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4173 25 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4173 26 . . NNP 19613 4173 27 , , , 19613 4173 28 H. H. NNP 19613 4173 29 E. E. NNP 19613 4173 30 VI VI NNP 19613 4173 31 . . . 19613 4174 1 43 43 CD 19613 4174 2 . . . 19613 4175 1 3 3 LS 19613 4175 2 : : : 19613 4175 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4175 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4175 5 : : : 19613 4175 6 êlthon êlthon NNP 19613 4175 7 eis eis NNP 19613 4175 8 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 4175 9 epistolai epistolai VBP 19613 4175 10 Kornêliou Kornêliou NNP 19613 4175 11 Rhômaiôn Rhômaiôn NNP 19613 4175 12 episkopou episkopou JJ 19613 4175 13 pros pro NNS 19613 4175 14 ... ... : 19613 4175 15 phabion phabion NN 19613 4175 16 , , , 19613 4175 17 dêlousai dêlousai NNP 19613 4175 18 ta ta NNP 19613 4175 19 peri peri NNP 19613 4175 20 tês tês NNP 19613 4175 21 Rhômaiôn Rhômaiôn NNP 19613 4175 22 sunodou sunodou NN 19613 4175 23 , , , 19613 4175 24 kai kai NNP 19613 4175 25 ta ta NNP 19613 4175 26 doxanta doxanta NNP 19613 4175 27 pasi pasi NNP 19613 4175 28 tois tois NNP 19613 4175 29 kata kata NNP 19613 4175 30 tên tên NNP 19613 4175 31 Italian italian JJ 19613 4175 32 kai kai NNP 19613 4175 33 Aphrikên Aphrikên NNP 19613 4175 34 kai kai NNP 19613 4175 35 tas tas NNP 19613 4175 36 autophi autophi NNP 19613 4175 37 chôras chôras NNP 19613 4175 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4175 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4175 40 . . . 19613 4176 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4176 2 must must MD 19613 4176 3 not not RB 19613 4176 4 forget forget VB 19613 4176 5 , , , 19613 4176 6 however however RB 19613 4176 7 , , , 19613 4176 8 that that IN 19613 4176 9 there there EX 19613 4176 10 were be VBD 19613 4176 11 also also RB 19613 4176 12 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4176 13 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 4176 14 who who WP 19613 4176 15 conducted conduct VBD 19613 4176 16 a a DT 19613 4176 17 so so RB 19613 4176 18 - - HYPH 19613 4176 19 called call VBN 19613 4176 20 oecumenical oecumenical JJ 19613 4176 21 correspondence correspondence NN 19613 4176 22 and and CC 19613 4176 23 enjoyed enjoy VBD 19613 4176 24 great great JJ 19613 4176 25 influence influence NN 19613 4176 26 , , , 19613 4176 27 as as IN 19613 4176 28 , , , 19613 4176 29 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 4176 30 , , , 19613 4176 31 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4176 32 of of IN 19613 4176 33 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 4176 34 and and CC 19613 4176 35 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4176 36 of of IN 19613 4176 37 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4176 38 . . . 19613 4177 1 In in IN 19613 4177 2 matters matter NNS 19613 4177 3 relating relate VBG 19613 4177 4 to to TO 19613 4177 5 penance penance VB 19613 4177 6 the the DT 19613 4177 7 latter latter JJ 19613 4177 8 wrote write VBD 19613 4177 9 to to IN 19613 4177 10 a a DT 19613 4177 11 great great JJ 19613 4177 12 many many JJ 19613 4177 13 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4177 14 , , , 19613 4177 15 even even RB 19613 4177 16 as as RB 19613 4177 17 far far RB 19613 4177 18 as as IN 19613 4177 19 Armenia Armenia NNP 19613 4177 20 , , , 19613 4177 21 and and CC 19613 4177 22 sent send VBD 19613 4177 23 many many JJ 19613 4177 24 letters letter NNS 19613 4177 25 to to IN 19613 4177 26 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4177 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4177 28 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4177 29 . . NNP 19613 4177 30 , , , 19613 4177 31 H. H. NNP 19613 4177 32 E. E. NNP 19613 4177 33 VI VI NNP 19613 4177 34 . . . 19613 4178 1 46 46 CD 19613 4178 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4178 3 . . . 19613 4179 1 The the DT 19613 4179 2 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 4179 3 theologian theologian NN 19613 4179 4 , , , 19613 4179 5 Dittrich Dittrich NNP 19613 4179 6 -- -- : 19613 4179 7 before before IN 19613 4179 8 the the DT 19613 4179 9 Vatican Vatican NNP 19613 4179 10 Decree Decree NNP 19613 4179 11 , , , 19613 4179 12 no no RB 19613 4179 13 doubt doubt NN 19613 4179 14 -- -- : 19613 4179 15 has have VBZ 19613 4179 16 spoken speak VBN 19613 4179 17 of of IN 19613 4179 18 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4179 19 in in IN 19613 4179 20 the the DT 19613 4179 21 following follow VBG 19613 4179 22 terms term NNS 19613 4179 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4179 24 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4179 25 von von NNP 19613 4179 26 Alexandrien Alexandrien NNP 19613 4179 27 , , , 19613 4179 28 1867 1867 CD 19613 4179 29 , , , 19613 4179 30 p. p. NN 19613 4179 31 26 26 CD 19613 4179 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4179 33 : : : 19613 4179 34 " " `` 19613 4179 35 As as IN 19613 4179 36 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4179 37 participated participate VBD 19613 4179 38 in in IN 19613 4179 39 the the DT 19613 4179 40 power power NN 19613 4179 41 , , , 19613 4179 42 so so RB 19613 4179 43 also also RB 19613 4179 44 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4179 45 shared share VBD 19613 4179 46 in in IN 19613 4179 47 the the DT 19613 4179 48 task task NN 19613 4179 49 of of IN 19613 4179 50 the the DT 19613 4179 51 primateship primateship NN 19613 4179 52 . . . 19613 4179 53 " " '' 19613 4180 1 " " `` 19613 4180 2 Along along IN 19613 4180 3 with with IN 19613 4180 4 the the DT 19613 4180 5 Roman roman JJ 19613 4180 6 bishop bishop NN 19613 4180 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4180 8 was be VBD 19613 4180 9 , , , 19613 4180 10 above above IN 19613 4180 11 all all DT 19613 4180 12 , , , 19613 4180 13 called call VBN 19613 4180 14 upon upon IN 19613 4180 15 to to TO 19613 4180 16 guard guard VB 19613 4180 17 the the DT 19613 4180 18 interests interest NNS 19613 4180 19 of of IN 19613 4180 20 the the DT 19613 4180 21 whole whole JJ 19613 4180 22 Church Church NNP 19613 4180 23 . . . 19613 4180 24 " " '' 19613 4180 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4181 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4181 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4181 3 315 315 CD 19613 4181 4 : : : 19613 4181 5 This this DT 19613 4181 6 conception conception NN 19613 4181 7 , , , 19613 4181 8 as as RB 19613 4181 9 well well RB 19613 4181 10 as as IN 19613 4181 11 the the DT 19613 4181 12 ideas idea NNS 19613 4181 13 contained contain VBN 19613 4181 14 in in IN 19613 4181 15 this this DT 19613 4181 16 Excursus Excursus NNP 19613 4181 17 generally generally RB 19613 4181 18 , , , 19613 4181 19 is be VBZ 19613 4181 20 now now RB 19613 4181 21 entirely entirely RB 19613 4181 22 shared share VBN 19613 4181 23 by by IN 19613 4181 24 Weingarten Weingarten NNP 19613 4181 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4181 26 Zeittafeln Zeittafeln NNP 19613 4181 27 , , , 19613 4181 28 3rd 3rd NN 19613 4181 29 . . . 19613 4182 1 ed ed NNP 19613 4182 2 . . NNP 19613 4182 3 , , , 19613 4182 4 1888 1888 CD 19613 4182 5 , , , 19613 4182 6 pp pp NNP 19613 4182 7 . . . 19613 4183 1 12 12 CD 19613 4183 2 , , , 19613 4183 3 21 21 CD 19613 4183 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4183 5 : : : 19613 4183 6 " " `` 19613 4183 7 The the DT 19613 4183 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 4183 9 Church Church NNP 19613 4183 10 is be VBZ 19613 4183 11 essentially essentially RB 19613 4183 12 the the DT 19613 4183 13 work work NN 19613 4183 14 of of IN 19613 4183 15 those those DT 19613 4183 16 of of IN 19613 4183 17 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4183 18 and and CC 19613 4183 19 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4183 20 Minor Minor NNP 19613 4183 21 . . . 19613 4184 1 The the DT 19613 4184 2 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 4184 3 Church Church NNP 19613 4184 4 and and CC 19613 4184 5 theology theology NN 19613 4184 6 do do VBP 19613 4184 7 not not RB 19613 4184 8 completely completely RB 19613 4184 9 adapt adapt VB 19613 4184 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4184 11 to to IN 19613 4184 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4184 13 till till IN 19613 4184 14 the the DT 19613 4184 15 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4184 16 century century NN 19613 4184 17 . . . 19613 4185 1 The the DT 19613 4185 2 metropolitan metropolitan JJ 19613 4185 3 community community NN 19613 4185 4 becomes become VBZ 19613 4185 5 the the DT 19613 4185 6 ideal ideal JJ 19613 4185 7 centre centre NN 19613 4185 8 of of IN 19613 4185 9 the the DT 19613 4185 10 Great Great NNP 19613 4185 11 Church Church NNP 19613 4185 12 " " '' 19613 4185 13 ... ... : 19613 4185 14 " " '' 19613 4185 15 The the DT 19613 4185 16 primacy primacy NN 19613 4185 17 of of IN 19613 4185 18 the the DT 19613 4185 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4185 20 Church Church NNP 19613 4185 21 is be VBZ 19613 4185 22 essentially essentially RB 19613 4185 23 the the DT 19613 4185 24 transference transference NN 19613 4185 25 to to IN 19613 4185 26 her -PRON- PRP 19613 4185 27 of of IN 19613 4185 28 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4185 29 's 's POS 19613 4185 30 central central JJ 19613 4185 31 position position NN 19613 4185 32 in in IN 19613 4185 33 the the DT 19613 4185 34 religion religion NN 19613 4185 35 of of IN 19613 4185 36 the the DT 19613 4185 37 heathen heathen NNP 19613 4185 38 world world NN 19613 4185 39 during during IN 19613 4185 40 the the DT 19613 4185 41 Empire Empire NNP 19613 4185 42 : : : 19613 4185 43 _ _ NNP 19613 4185 44 urbs urb VBZ 19613 4185 45 æterna æterna NNP 19613 4185 46 urbs urbs NNP 19613 4185 47 sacra sacra NNP 19613 4185 48 _ _ NNP 19613 4185 49 . . . 19613 4185 50 " " '' 19613 4185 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4186 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4186 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4186 3 316 316 CD 19613 4186 4 : : : 19613 4186 5 This this DT 19613 4186 6 is be VBZ 19613 4186 7 also also RB 19613 4186 8 admitted admit VBN 19613 4186 9 by by IN 19613 4186 10 Langen Langen NNP 19613 4186 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4186 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4186 13 . . NNP 19613 4186 14 , , , 19613 4186 15 184 184 CD 19613 4186 16 f. f. NNP 19613 4186 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4186 18 , , , 19613 4186 19 who who WP 19613 4186 20 even even RB 19613 4186 21 declares declare VBZ 19613 4186 22 that that IN 19613 4186 23 this this DT 19613 4186 24 precedence precedence NN 19613 4186 25 existed exist VBD 19613 4186 26 from from IN 19613 4186 27 the the DT 19613 4186 28 beginning beginning NN 19613 4186 29 . . . 19613 4186 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4187 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4187 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4187 3 317 317 CD 19613 4187 4 : : : 19613 4187 5 Cf cf NN 19613 4187 6 . . . 19613 4188 1 chaps chaps NNP 19613 4188 2 . . . 19613 4189 1 59 59 CD 19613 4189 2 and and CC 19613 4189 3 62 62 CD 19613 4189 4 , , , 19613 4189 5 but but CC 19613 4189 6 more more RBR 19613 4189 7 especially especially RB 19613 4189 8 63 63 CD 19613 4189 9 . . . 19613 4189 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4190 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4190 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4190 3 318 318 CD 19613 4190 4 : : : 19613 4190 5 At at IN 19613 4190 6 that that DT 19613 4190 7 time time NN 19613 4190 8 the the DT 19613 4190 9 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4190 10 Church Church NNP 19613 4190 11 did do VBD 19613 4190 12 not not RB 19613 4190 13 confine confine VB 19613 4190 14 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 4190 15 to to IN 19613 4190 16 a a DT 19613 4190 17 letter letter NN 19613 4190 18 ; ; : 19613 4190 19 she -PRON- PRP 19613 4190 20 sent send VBD 19613 4190 21 ambassadors ambassador NNS 19613 4190 22 to to IN 19613 4190 23 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 4190 24 , , , 19613 4190 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4190 26 Greek greek JJ 19613 4190 27 : : : 19613 4190 28 hoitines hoitine NNS 19613 4190 29 martures marture VBZ 19613 4190 30 esontai esontai NNP 19613 4190 31 metaxu metaxu NNP 19613 4190 32 humôn humôn NNP 19613 4190 33 kai kai NNP 19613 4190 34 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 4190 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4190 36 . . . 19613 4191 1 Note note VB 19613 4191 2 carefully carefully RB 19613 4191 3 also also RB 19613 4191 4 the the DT 19613 4191 5 position position NN 19613 4191 6 of of IN 19613 4191 7 the the DT 19613 4191 8 Corinthian corinthian JJ 19613 4191 9 community community NN 19613 4191 10 with with IN 19613 4191 11 which which WDT 19613 4191 12 the the DT 19613 4191 13 Roman roman JJ 19613 4191 14 one one NN 19613 4191 15 interfered interfere VBD 19613 4191 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4191 17 see see VB 19613 4191 18 on on IN 19613 4191 19 this this DT 19613 4191 20 point point NN 19613 4191 21 Wrede Wrede NNP 19613 4191 22 , , , 19613 4191 23 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 4191 24 zum zum NN 19613 4191 25 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4191 26 Clemensbrief Clemensbrief NNP 19613 4191 27 , , , 19613 4191 28 1891 1891 CD 19613 4191 29 . . . 19613 4191 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4191 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4192 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4192 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 4192 3 319 319 CD 19613 4192 4 : : : 19613 4192 5 In in IN 19613 4192 6 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4192 7 , , , 19613 4192 8 Rom Rom NNP 19613 4192 9 . . . 19613 4193 1 inscr inscr NNP 19613 4193 2 . . . 19613 4193 3 , , , 19613 4193 4 the the DT 19613 4193 5 verb verb NN 19613 4193 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4193 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4193 8 : : : 19613 4193 9 prokathêmai prokathêmai NNP 19613 4193 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4193 11 is be VBZ 19613 4193 12 twice twice RB 19613 4193 13 used use VBN 19613 4193 14 about about IN 19613 4193 15 the the DT 19613 4193 16 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4193 17 Church Church NNP 19613 4193 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4193 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4193 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4193 21 : : : 19613 4193 22 prokathêtai prokathêtai FW 19613 4193 23 en en FW 19613 4193 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4193 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4193 26 to to TO 19613 4193 27 be be VB 19613 4193 28 understood understand VBN 19613 4193 29 in in IN 19613 4193 30 a a DT 19613 4193 31 local local JJ 19613 4193 32 sense sense NN 19613 4193 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4193 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4193 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4193 36 : : : 19613 4193 37 topôi topôi NNP 19613 4193 38 khôrion khôrion NNP 19613 4193 39 Rhômaiôn]--[Greek Rhômaiôn]--[Greek NNP 19613 4193 40 : : : 19613 4193 41 prokathêmenê prokathêmenê NNP 19613 4193 42 tês tês NNP 19613 4193 43 agapês agapês NNP 19613 4193 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4193 45 = = SYM 19613 4193 46 presiding preside VBG 19613 4193 47 in in RP 19613 4193 48 , , , 19613 4193 49 or or CC 19613 4193 50 having have VBG 19613 4193 51 the the DT 19613 4193 52 guardianship guardianship NN 19613 4193 53 of of IN 19613 4193 54 , , , 19613 4193 55 love love NN 19613 4193 56 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4193 57 . . . 19613 4194 1 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4194 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4194 3 Magn Magn NNP 19613 4194 4 . . . 19613 4195 1 6 6 LS 19613 4195 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4195 3 , , , 19613 4195 4 uses use VBZ 19613 4195 5 the the DT 19613 4195 6 same same JJ 19613 4195 7 verb verb NN 19613 4195 8 to to TO 19613 4195 9 denote denote VB 19613 4195 10 the the DT 19613 4195 11 dignity dignity NN 19613 4195 12 of of IN 19613 4195 13 the the DT 19613 4195 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 4195 15 or or CC 19613 4195 16 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 4195 17 in in IN 19613 4195 18 relation relation NN 19613 4195 19 to to IN 19613 4195 20 the the DT 19613 4195 21 community community NN 19613 4195 22 . . . 19613 4196 1 See see VB 19613 4196 2 , , , 19613 4196 3 besides besides RB 19613 4196 4 , , , 19613 4196 5 the the DT 19613 4196 6 important important JJ 19613 4196 7 testimony testimony NN 19613 4196 8 in in IN 19613 4196 9 Rom Rom NNP 19613 4196 10 . . . 19613 4197 1 II ii CD 19613 4197 2 . . . 19613 4198 1 : : : 19613 4198 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4198 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4198 4 : : : 19613 4198 5 allous allous JJ 19613 4198 6 edidaxate edidaxate NN 19613 4198 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4198 8 . . . 19613 4199 1 Finally finally RB 19613 4199 2 , , , 19613 4199 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4199 4 must must MD 19613 4199 5 be be VB 19613 4199 6 also also RB 19613 4199 7 noted note VBN 19613 4199 8 that that IN 19613 4199 9 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4199 10 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 4199 11 an an DT 19613 4199 12 extensive extensive JJ 19613 4199 13 influence influence NN 19613 4199 14 on on IN 19613 4199 15 the the DT 19613 4199 16 part part NN 19613 4199 17 of of IN 19613 4199 18 individual individual JJ 19613 4199 19 members member NNS 19613 4199 20 of of IN 19613 4199 21 the the DT 19613 4199 22 Church Church NNP 19613 4199 23 in in IN 19613 4199 24 the the DT 19613 4199 25 higher high JJR 19613 4199 26 spheres sphere NNS 19613 4199 27 of of IN 19613 4199 28 government government NN 19613 4199 29 . . . 19613 4200 1 Fifty fifty CD 19613 4200 2 years year NNS 19613 4200 3 later later RBR 19613 4200 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4200 5 have have VBP 19613 4200 6 a a DT 19613 4200 7 memorable memorable JJ 19613 4200 8 proof proof NN 19613 4200 9 of of IN 19613 4200 10 this this DT 19613 4200 11 in in IN 19613 4200 12 the the DT 19613 4200 13 Marcia Marcia NNP 19613 4200 14 - - HYPH 19613 4200 15 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4200 16 episode episode NN 19613 4200 17 . . . 19613 4201 1 Lastly lastly RB 19613 4201 2 , , , 19613 4201 3 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4201 4 is be VBZ 19613 4201 5 convinced convince VBN 19613 4201 6 that that IN 19613 4201 7 the the DT 19613 4201 8 Church Church NNP 19613 4201 9 will will MD 19613 4201 10 interfeie interfeie VB 19613 4201 11 quite quite RB 19613 4201 12 as as RB 19613 4201 13 energetically energetically RB 19613 4201 14 on on IN 19613 4201 15 behalf behalf NN 19613 4201 16 of of IN 19613 4201 17 a a DT 19613 4201 18 foreign foreign JJ 19613 4201 19 brother brother NN 19613 4201 20 as as IN 19613 4201 21 on on IN 19613 4201 22 behalf behalf NN 19613 4201 23 of of IN 19613 4201 24 one one CD 19613 4201 25 of of IN 19613 4201 26 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4201 27 own own JJ 19613 4201 28 number number NN 19613 4201 29 . . . 19613 4202 1 In in IN 19613 4202 2 the the DT 19613 4202 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 4202 4 of of IN 19613 4202 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4202 6 to to IN 19613 4202 7 James James NNP 19613 4202 8 , , , 19613 4202 9 c. c. NNP 19613 4202 10 2 2 CD 19613 4202 11 , , , 19613 4202 12 the the DT 19613 4202 13 Roman roman JJ 19613 4202 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 4202 15 is be VBZ 19613 4202 16 called call VBN 19613 4202 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4202 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4202 19 : : : 19613 4202 20 ho ho NNP 19613 4202 21 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 4202 22 prokathezomenos prokathezomenos NNP 19613 4202 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4202 24 . . . 19613 4202 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4203 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4203 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4203 3 320 320 CD 19613 4203 4 : : : 19613 4203 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4203 6 . . NNP 19613 4203 7 , , , 19613 4203 8 H. H. NNP 19613 4203 9 E. E. NNP 19613 4203 10 IV IV NNP 19613 4203 11 . . . 19613 4204 1 23 23 CD 19613 4204 2 . . . 19613 4205 1 9 9 CD 19613 4205 2 - - SYM 19613 4205 3 12 12 CD 19613 4205 4 ; ; : 19613 4205 5 cf cf NNP 19613 4205 6 . . NNP 19613 4205 7 , , , 19613 4205 8 above above IN 19613 4205 9 all all DT 19613 4205 10 , , , 19613 4205 11 the the DT 19613 4205 12 words word NNS 19613 4205 13 : : : 19613 4205 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4205 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4205 16 : : : 19613 4205 17 Ex ex NN 19613 4205 18 archês archês NN 19613 4205 19 humin humin NN 19613 4205 20 ethos ethos NN 19613 4205 21 esti esti NNP 19613 4205 22 touto touto NNP 19613 4205 23 , , , 19613 4205 24 pantas pantas NNP 19613 4205 25 men man NNS 19613 4205 26 adelphous adelphous JJ 19613 4205 27 poikiôs poikiôs NNP 19613 4205 28 euergetein euergetein NNP 19613 4205 29 , , , 19613 4205 30 ekklêsiais ekklêsiais NNP 19613 4205 31 te te NNP 19613 4205 32 pollais pollais NNP 19613 4205 33 tais tais NNP 19613 4205 34 kata kata NNP 19613 4205 35 pasan pasan NNP 19613 4205 36 polin polin NNP 19613 4205 37 ephodia ephodia NNP 19613 4205 38 pempein pempein NNP 19613 4205 39 ... ... : 19613 4205 40 patroparadoton patroparadoton NN 19613 4205 41 ethos ethos NN 19613 4205 42 Rhômaiôn Rhômaiôn NNP 19613 4205 43 Rômaioi Rômaioi NNP 19613 4205 44 diaphulattontes diaphulattonte NNS 19613 4205 45 . . . 19613 4205 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4206 1 Note note VB 19613 4206 2 here here RB 19613 4206 3 the the DT 19613 4206 4 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 4206 5 laid lay VBN 19613 4206 6 on on IN 19613 4206 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4206 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4206 9 : : : 19613 4206 10 Rômaioi Rômaioi NNP 19613 4206 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4206 12 . . . 19613 4206 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4207 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4207 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4207 3 321 321 CD 19613 4207 4 : : : 19613 4207 5 According accord VBG 19613 4207 6 to to IN 19613 4207 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4207 8 a a DT 19613 4207 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4207 10 significance significance NN 19613 4207 11 belongs belong VBZ 19613 4207 12 to to IN 19613 4207 13 the the DT 19613 4207 14 old old JJ 19613 4207 15 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 4207 16 Church Church NNP 19613 4207 17 , , , 19613 4207 18 in in IN 19613 4207 19 so so RB 19613 4207 20 far far RB 19613 4207 21 as as IN 19613 4207 22 all all PDT 19613 4207 23 the the DT 19613 4207 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 4207 25 congregations congregation NNS 19613 4207 26 sprang spring VBD 19613 4207 27 from from IN 19613 4207 28 her -PRON- PRP 19613 4207 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4207 30 III iii CD 19613 4207 31 . . . 19613 4208 1 12 12 CD 19613 4208 2 . . . 19613 4209 1 5 5 CD 19613 4209 2 : : : 19613 4209 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4209 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4209 5 : : : 19613 4209 6 autai autai NNP 19613 4209 7 phônai phônai NNP 19613 4209 8 tês tês NNP 19613 4209 9 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 4209 10 , , , 19613 4209 11 ex ex FW 19613 4209 12 hês hês FW 19613 4209 13 pasa pasa NNP 19613 4209 14 eschêken eschêken NNP 19613 4209 15 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 4209 16 tês tês NNP 19613 4209 17 archên archên NNP 19613 4209 18 autai autai NNP 19613 4209 19 phônai phônai NNP 19613 4209 20 tês tês NNP 19613 4209 21 mêtropoleôs mêtropoleôs NNP 19613 4209 22 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4209 23 tês tês NNP 19613 4209 24 kainês kainês NNP 19613 4209 25 diathêkês diathêkês NNP 19613 4209 26 politôn politôn NNP 19613 4209 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4209 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4209 29 . . . 19613 4210 1 For for IN 19613 4210 2 obvious obvious JJ 19613 4210 3 reasons reason NNS 19613 4210 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4210 5 did do VBD 19613 4210 6 not not RB 19613 4210 7 speak speak VB 19613 4210 8 of of IN 19613 4210 9 the the DT 19613 4210 10 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 4210 11 Church Church NNP 19613 4210 12 of of IN 19613 4210 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4210 14 own own JJ 19613 4210 15 time time NN 19613 4210 16 . . . 19613 4211 1 Hence hence RB 19613 4211 2 that that DT 19613 4211 3 passage passage NN 19613 4211 4 can can MD 19613 4211 5 not not RB 19613 4211 6 be be VB 19613 4211 7 utilised utilise VBN 19613 4211 8 . . . 19613 4211 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4212 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4212 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4212 3 322 322 CD 19613 4212 4 : : : 19613 4212 5 Iren iren JJ 19613 4212 6 . . . 19613 4213 1 III iii CD 19613 4213 2 . . . 19613 4214 1 3 3 LS 19613 4214 2 . . . 19613 4214 3 i i PRP 19613 4214 4 : : : 19613 4214 5 " " `` 19613 4214 6 Sed Sed NNP 19613 4214 7 quomiam quomiam NNP 19613 4214 8 valde valde NN 19613 4214 9 longum longum NNP 19613 4214 10 est est NNP 19613 4214 11 , , , 19613 4214 12 in in IN 19613 4214 13 hoc hoc FW 19613 4214 14 tali tali NNP 19613 4214 15 volumine volumine NNP 19613 4214 16 omnium omnium NN 19613 4214 17 ecclesiarum ecclesiarum NN 19613 4214 18 enumerare enumerare NN 19613 4214 19 successiones successione NNS 19613 4214 20 , , , 19613 4214 21 maximæ maximæ NNP 19613 4214 22 et et NNP 19613 4214 23 antiquissimæ antiquissimæ NNP 19613 4214 24 et et NNP 19613 4214 25 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 4214 26 cognitæ cognitæ NNP 19613 4214 27 , , , 19613 4214 28 a a DT 19613 4214 29 gloriosissimis gloriosissimis NN 19613 4214 30 duobus duobus NN 19613 4214 31 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 4214 32 Paulo Paulo NNP 19613 4214 33 et et FW 19613 4214 34 Petro Petro NNP 19613 4214 35 Romæ Romæ NNP 19613 4214 36 fundatæ fundatæ UH 19613 4214 37 et et NNP 19613 4214 38 constitutæ constitutæ NNP 19613 4214 39 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 4214 40 , , , 19613 4214 41 eam eam NNP 19613 4214 42 quam quam NNP 19613 4214 43 habet habet NNP 19613 4214 44 ab ab NNP 19613 4214 45 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 4214 46 traditionem traditionem NNP 19613 4214 47 et et NNP 19613 4214 48 annuutiatam annuutiatam NNP 19613 4214 49 hominibus hominibus NNP 19613 4214 50 fidem fidem NNP 19613 4214 51 , , , 19613 4214 52 per per IN 19613 4214 53 successiones successione NNS 19613 4214 54 episcoporum episcoporum NNP 19613 4214 55 pervenientem pervenientem NN 19613 4214 56 usque usque NNP 19613 4214 57 ad ad NN 19613 4214 58 nos nos NNP 19613 4214 59 indicantes indicante VBZ 19613 4214 60 confundimus confundimus VBP 19613 4214 61 omnes omne NNS 19613 4214 62 eos eos NNP 19613 4214 63 , , , 19613 4214 64 qui qui NNP 19613 4214 65 quoquo quoquo NNP 19613 4214 66 modo modo NNP 19613 4214 67 vel vel NNP 19613 4214 68 per per IN 19613 4214 69 sibiplacentiam sibiplacentiam NNP 19613 4214 70 malam malam NNP 19613 4214 71 vel vel NNP 19613 4214 72 vanam vanam NNP 19613 4214 73 gloriam gloriam NNP 19613 4214 74 vel vel NNP 19613 4214 75 per per IN 19613 4214 76 cæcitatem cæcitatem NNP 19613 4214 77 et et NNP 19613 4214 78 malam malam NNP 19613 4214 79 sententiam sententiam NNP 19613 4214 80 , , , 19613 4214 81 præterquam præterquam NNP 19613 4214 82 oportet oportet NNP 19613 4214 83 , , , 19613 4214 84 colligunt colligunt NNP 19613 4214 85 . . . 19613 4215 1 Ad ad NN 19613 4215 2 hanc hanc NN 19613 4215 3 enim enim NNP 19613 4215 4 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 4215 5 propter propter NNP 19613 4215 6 potentiorem potentiorem NNP 19613 4215 7 principalitatem principalitatem NNP 19613 4215 8 necesse necesse NNP 19613 4215 9 est est NNP 19613 4215 10 omnem omnem NNP 19613 4215 11 convenire convenire NNP 19613 4215 12 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 4215 13 , , , 19613 4215 14 hoc hoc FW 19613 4215 15 est est NNP 19613 4215 16 , , , 19613 4215 17 eos eos NNP 19613 4215 18 qui qui NN 19613 4215 19 sunt sunt NN 19613 4215 20 undique undique NN 19613 4215 21 fideles fidele NNS 19613 4215 22 , , , 19613 4215 23 in in IN 19613 4215 24 qua qua NNP 19613 4215 25 semper semper NNP 19613 4215 26 ab ab NNP 19613 4215 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4215 28 , , , 19613 4215 29 qui qui NNP 19613 4215 30 sunt sunt NN 19613 4215 31 undique undique NN 19613 4215 32 , , , 19613 4215 33 conservata conservata NNS 19613 4215 34 est est VBP 19613 4215 35 ea ea NNP 19613 4215 36 quæ quæ NNP 19613 4215 37 est est NNP 19613 4215 38 ab ab NNP 19613 4215 39 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 4215 40 traditio traditio NNP 19613 4215 41 . . . 19613 4215 42 " " '' 19613 4216 1 On on IN 19613 4216 2 this this DT 19613 4216 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4216 4 may may MD 19613 4216 5 remark remark VB 19613 4216 6 as as IN 19613 4216 7 follows follow VBZ 19613 4216 8 : : : 19613 4216 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4216 10 1 1 LS 19613 4216 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4216 12 The the DT 19613 4216 13 special special JJ 19613 4216 14 importance importance NN 19613 4216 15 which which WDT 19613 4216 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4216 17 claims claim VBZ 19613 4216 18 for for IN 19613 4216 19 the the DT 19613 4216 20 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4216 21 Church Church NNP 19613 4216 22 -- -- : 19613 4216 23 for for IN 19613 4216 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4216 25 is be VBZ 19613 4216 26 only only RB 19613 4216 27 referring refer VBG 19613 4216 28 to to IN 19613 4216 29 her -PRON- PRP 19613 4216 30 -- -- : 19613 4216 31 is be VBZ 19613 4216 32 not not RB 19613 4216 33 merely merely RB 19613 4216 34 based base VBN 19613 4216 35 by by IN 19613 4216 36 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4216 37 on on IN 19613 4216 38 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4216 39 assumed assume VBN 19613 4216 40 foundation foundation NN 19613 4216 41 by by IN 19613 4216 42 Peter Peter NNP 19613 4216 43 and and CC 19613 4216 44 Paul Paul NNP 19613 4216 45 , , , 19613 4216 46 but but CC 19613 4216 47 on on IN 19613 4216 48 a a DT 19613 4216 49 combination combination NN 19613 4216 50 of of IN 19613 4216 51 the the DT 19613 4216 52 four four CD 19613 4216 53 attributes attributes NNPS 19613 4216 54 " " `` 19613 4216 55 maxima maxima NN 19613 4216 56 , , , 19613 4216 57 " " '' 19613 4216 58 " " `` 19613 4216 59 antiquissima antiquissima NNP 19613 4216 60 " " '' 19613 4216 61 etc etc FW 19613 4216 62 . . . 19613 4217 1 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4217 2 of of IN 19613 4217 3 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 4217 4 also also RB 19613 4217 5 made make VBD 19613 4217 6 this this DT 19613 4217 7 assumption assumption NN 19613 4217 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4217 9 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4217 10 . . NNP 19613 4217 11 , , , 19613 4217 12 II II NNP 19613 4217 13 . . . 19613 4218 1 25 25 CD 19613 4218 2 . . . 19613 4219 1 8) 8) CD 19613 4219 2 , , , 19613 4219 3 but but CC 19613 4219 4 applied apply VBD 19613 4219 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4219 6 quite quite RB 19613 4219 7 as as RB 19613 4219 8 much much JJ 19613 4219 9 to to IN 19613 4219 10 the the DT 19613 4219 11 Corinthian Corinthian NNP 19613 4219 12 Church Church NNP 19613 4219 13 . . . 19613 4220 1 As as IN 19613 4220 2 regards regard VBZ 19613 4220 3 capability capability NN 19613 4220 4 of of IN 19613 4220 5 proving prove VBG 19613 4220 6 the the DT 19613 4220 7 truth truth NN 19613 4220 8 of of IN 19613 4220 9 the the DT 19613 4220 10 Church Church NNP 19613 4220 11 's 's POS 19613 4220 12 faith faith NN 19613 4220 13 , , , 19613 4220 14 all all PDT 19613 4220 15 the the DT 19613 4220 16 communities community NNS 19613 4220 17 founded found VBN 19613 4220 18 by by IN 19613 4220 19 the the DT 19613 4220 20 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 4220 21 possess possess VBP 19613 4220 22 _ _ NNP 19613 4220 23 principalitas principalitas NNP 19613 4220 24 _ _ NNP 19613 4220 25 in in IN 19613 4220 26 relation relation NN 19613 4220 27 to to IN 19613 4220 28 the the DT 19613 4220 29 others other NNS 19613 4220 30 ; ; : 19613 4220 31 but but CC 19613 4220 32 the the DT 19613 4220 33 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4220 34 Church Church NNP 19613 4220 35 has have VBZ 19613 4220 36 the the DT 19613 4220 37 _ _ NNP 19613 4220 38 potentior potentior JJ 19613 4220 39 principalitas principalitas NNP 19613 4220 40 _ _ NNP 19613 4220 41 , , , 19613 4220 42 in in IN 19613 4220 43 so so RB 19613 4220 44 far far RB 19613 4220 45 as as IN 19613 4220 46 she -PRON- PRP 19613 4220 47 excels excel VBZ 19613 4220 48 all all PDT 19613 4220 49 the the DT 19613 4220 50 rest rest NN 19613 4220 51 in in IN 19613 4220 52 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4220 53 qualities quality NNS 19613 4220 54 of of IN 19613 4220 55 _ _ NNP 19613 4220 56 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 4220 57 maxima maxima NNP 19613 4220 58 et et NNP 19613 4220 59 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 4220 60 cognita cognita NNP 19613 4220 61 _ _ NNP 19613 4220 62 etc etc FW 19613 4220 63 . . . 19613 4221 1 Principalitas Principalitas NNP 19613 4221 2 = = NFP 19613 4221 3 " " `` 19613 4221 4 sovereign sovereign JJ 19613 4221 5 authority authority NN 19613 4221 6 , , , 19613 4221 7 " " '' 19613 4221 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4221 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4221 10 : : : 19613 4221 11 authentia authentia NN 19613 4221 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4221 13 , , , 19613 4221 14 for for IN 19613 4221 15 this this DT 19613 4221 16 was be VBD 19613 4221 17 probably probably RB 19613 4221 18 the the DT 19613 4221 19 word word NN 19613 4221 20 in in IN 19613 4221 21 the the DT 19613 4221 22 original original JJ 19613 4221 23 text text NN 19613 4221 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4221 25 see see VB 19613 4221 26 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 4221 27 of of IN 19613 4221 28 the the DT 19613 4221 29 Royal Royal NNP 19613 4221 30 Prussian Prussian NNP 19613 4221 31 Academy Academy NNP 19613 4221 32 of of IN 19613 4221 33 Science Science NNP 19613 4221 34 , , , 19613 4221 35 9th 9th JJ 19613 4221 36 Nov. November NNP 19613 4221 37 , , , 19613 4221 38 1893 1893 CD 19613 4221 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4221 40 . . . 19613 4222 1 In in IN 19613 4222 2 common common JJ 19613 4222 3 with with IN 19613 4222 4 most most JJS 19613 4222 5 scholars scholar NNS 19613 4222 6 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4222 7 used use VBD 19613 4222 8 to to TO 19613 4222 9 think think VB 19613 4222 10 that that IN 19613 4222 11 the the DT 19613 4222 12 " " `` 19613 4222 13 in in IN 19613 4222 14 qua qua NNP 19613 4222 15 " " '' 19613 4222 16 refers refer VBZ 19613 4222 17 to to IN 19613 4222 18 " " `` 19613 4222 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4222 20 Church Church NNP 19613 4222 21 ; ; : 19613 4222 22 " " `` 19613 4222 23 but but CC 19613 4222 24 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4222 25 have have VBP 19613 4222 26 now now RB 19613 4222 27 convinced convince VBN 19613 4222 28 myself -PRON- PRP 19613 4222 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4222 30 see see VB 19613 4222 31 the the DT 19613 4222 32 treatise treatise NN 19613 4222 33 just just RB 19613 4222 34 cited cite VBD 19613 4222 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4222 36 that that IN 19613 4222 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4222 38 relates relate VBZ 19613 4222 39 to to IN 19613 4222 40 " " `` 19613 4222 41 omnem omnem NN 19613 4222 42 ecclesiam ecclesiam NN 19613 4222 43 , , , 19613 4222 44 " " '' 19613 4222 45 and and CC 19613 4222 46 that that IN 19613 4222 47 the the DT 19613 4222 48 clause clause NN 19613 4222 49 introduced introduce VBN 19613 4222 50 by by IN 19613 4222 51 " " `` 19613 4222 52 in in IN 19613 4222 53 qua qua NNP 19613 4222 54 " " '' 19613 4222 55 merely merely RB 19613 4222 56 asserts assert VBZ 19613 4222 57 that that IN 19613 4222 58 every every DT 19613 4222 59 church church NN 19613 4222 60 , , , 19613 4222 61 _ _ NNP 19613 4222 62 in in IN 19613 4222 63 so so RB 19613 4222 64 far far RB 19613 4222 65 as as IN 19613 4222 66 she -PRON- PRP 19613 4222 67 is be VBZ 19613 4222 68 faithful faithful JJ 19613 4222 69 to to IN 19613 4222 70 tradition tradition NN 19613 4222 71 , , , 19613 4222 72 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4222 73 , , , 19613 4222 74 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 4222 75 _ _ NNP 19613 4222 76 , , , 19613 4222 77 must must MD 19613 4222 78 as as IN 19613 4222 79 a a DT 19613 4222 80 matter matter NN 19613 4222 81 of of IN 19613 4222 82 course course NN 19613 4222 83 agree agree VBP 19613 4222 84 with with IN 19613 4222 85 that that DT 19613 4222 86 of of IN 19613 4222 87 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4222 88 . . . 19613 4223 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4223 2 2 2 LS 19613 4223 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4223 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4223 5 asserts assert VBZ 19613 4223 6 that that IN 19613 4223 7 every every DT 19613 4223 8 Church Church NNP 19613 4223 9 , , , 19613 4223 10 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4223 11 , , , 19613 4223 12 believers believer NNS 19613 4223 13 in in IN 19613 4223 14 all all DT 19613 4223 15 parts part NNS 19613 4223 16 of of IN 19613 4223 17 the the DT 19613 4223 18 world world NN 19613 4223 19 , , , 19613 4223 20 must must MD 19613 4223 21 agree agree VB 19613 4223 22 with with IN 19613 4223 23 this this DT 19613 4223 24 Church Church NNP 19613 4223 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4223 26 " " `` 19613 4223 27 convenire convenire NN 19613 4223 28 " " '' 19613 4223 29 is be VBZ 19613 4223 30 to to TO 19613 4223 31 be be VB 19613 4223 32 understood understand VBN 19613 4223 33 in in IN 19613 4223 34 a a DT 19613 4223 35 figurative figurative JJ 19613 4223 36 sense sense NN 19613 4223 37 ; ; : 19613 4223 38 the the DT 19613 4223 39 literal literal JJ 19613 4223 40 acceptation acceptation NN 19613 4223 41 " " '' 19613 4223 42 every every DT 19613 4223 43 Church Church NNP 19613 4223 44 must must MD 19613 4223 45 come come VB 19613 4223 46 to to IN 19613 4223 47 that that DT 19613 4223 48 of of IN 19613 4223 49 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4223 50 " " '' 19613 4223 51 is be VBZ 19613 4223 52 not not RB 19613 4223 53 admissible admissible JJ 19613 4223 54 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4223 55 . . . 19613 4224 1 However however RB 19613 4224 2 , , , 19613 4224 3 this this DT 19613 4224 4 " " `` 19613 4224 5 must must MD 19613 4224 6 " " `` 19613 4224 7 is be VBZ 19613 4224 8 not not RB 19613 4224 9 meant mean VBN 19613 4224 10 as as IN 19613 4224 11 an an DT 19613 4224 12 imperative imperative NN 19613 4224 13 , , , 19613 4224 14 but but CC 19613 4224 15 = = NFP 19613 4224 16 = = NFP 19613 4224 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4224 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4224 19 : : : 19613 4224 20 anagkê anagkê NNP 19613 4224 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4224 22 = = NFP 19613 4224 23 = = NFP 19613 4224 24 " " `` 19613 4224 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4224 26 can can MD 19613 4224 27 not not RB 19613 4224 28 be be VB 19613 4224 29 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 4224 30 . . . 19613 4224 31 " " '' 19613 4225 1 In in IN 19613 4225 2 reference reference NN 19613 4225 3 to to IN 19613 4225 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4225 5 principalitas principalitas NNP 19613 4225 6 _ _ NNP 19613 4225 7 = = SYM 19613 4225 8 = = NFP 19613 4225 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4225 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4225 11 : : : 19613 4225 12 authentia authentia NN 19613 4225 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4225 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4225 15 see see VB 19613 4225 16 I. I. NNP 19613 4226 1 31 31 CD 19613 4226 2 . . . 19613 4227 1 1 1 LS 19613 4227 2 : : : 19613 4227 3 I. i. NN 19613 4228 1 26 26 CD 19613 4228 2 . . . 19613 4229 1 1 1 LS 19613 4229 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4229 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4229 4 must must MD 19613 4229 5 be be VB 19613 4229 6 remembered remember VBN 19613 4229 7 that that IN 19613 4229 8 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4229 9 of of IN 19613 4229 10 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4229 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4229 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4229 13 . . NNP 19613 4229 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4230 1 speaks speak VBZ 19613 4230 2 of of IN 19613 4230 3 the the DT 19613 4230 4 " " `` 19613 4230 5 origo origo NNP 19613 4230 6 _ _ NNP 19613 4230 7 authentici authentici VBZ 19613 4230 8 _ _ NNP 19613 4230 9 apostolatus apostolatus NN 19613 4230 10 , , , 19613 4230 11 " " '' 19613 4230 12 and and CC 19613 4230 13 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 4230 14 remarks remark NNS 19613 4230 15 of of IN 19613 4230 16 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 4230 17 when when WRB 19613 4230 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4230 19 apostatised apostatise VBD 19613 4230 20 at at IN 19613 4230 21 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4230 22 , , , 19613 4230 23 " " '' 19613 4230 24 ab ab NNP 19613 4230 25 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 4230 26 _ _ NNP 19613 4230 27 authenticæ authenticæ NNP 19613 4230 28 _ _ NNP 19613 4230 29 regulæ regulæ NN 19613 4230 30 abrupit abrupit NN 19613 4230 31 " " '' 19613 4230 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4230 33 adv adv NN 19613 4230 34 . . . 19613 4231 1 Valent Valent NNP 19613 4231 2 . . . 19613 4232 1 4 4 LS 19613 4232 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4232 3 . . . 19613 4232 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4233 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4233 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4233 3 323 323 CD 19613 4233 4 : : : 19613 4233 5 Beyond beyond IN 19613 4233 6 doubt doubt VB 19613 4233 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4233 8 " " `` 19613 4233 9 convenire convenire NN 19613 4233 10 necesse necesse NNP 19613 4233 11 est est NNP 19613 4233 12 " " `` 19613 4233 13 is be VBZ 19613 4233 14 founded found VBN 19613 4233 15 on on IN 19613 4233 16 actual actual JJ 19613 4233 17 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 4233 18 . . . 19613 4233 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4234 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4234 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4234 3 324 324 CD 19613 4234 4 : : : 19613 4234 5 On on IN 19613 4234 6 other other JJ 19613 4234 7 important important JJ 19613 4234 8 journeys journey NNS 19613 4234 9 of of IN 19613 4234 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 4234 11 men man NNS 19613 4234 12 and and CC 19613 4234 13 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4234 14 to to IN 19613 4234 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4234 16 in in IN 19613 4234 17 the the DT 19613 4234 18 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 4234 19 and and CC 19613 4234 20 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4234 21 centuries century NNS 19613 4234 22 see see VBP 19613 4234 23 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 4234 24 , , , 19613 4234 25 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4234 26 . . . 19613 4235 1 Above above IN 19613 4235 2 all all DT 19613 4235 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4235 4 may may MD 19613 4235 5 call call VB 19613 4235 6 attention attention NN 19613 4235 7 to to IN 19613 4235 8 the the DT 19613 4235 9 journey journey NN 19613 4235 10 of of IN 19613 4235 11 Abercius Abercius NNP 19613 4235 12 of of IN 19613 4235 13 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 19613 4235 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4235 15 not not RB 19613 4235 16 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 19613 4235 17 on on IN 19613 4235 18 the the DT 19613 4235 19 Meander Meander NNP 19613 4235 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4235 21 about about RB 19613 4235 22 200 200 CD 19613 4235 23 or or CC 19613 4235 24 even even RB 19613 4235 25 earlier early RBR 19613 4235 26 . . . 19613 4236 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4236 2 historical historical JJ 19613 4236 3 reality reality NN 19613 4236 4 is be VBZ 19613 4236 5 not not RB 19613 4236 6 to to TO 19613 4236 7 be be VB 19613 4236 8 questioned question VBN 19613 4236 9 . . . 19613 4237 1 See see VB 19613 4237 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4237 3 words word NNS 19613 4237 4 in in IN 19613 4237 5 the the DT 19613 4237 6 epitaph epitaph NN 19613 4237 7 composed compose VBN 19613 4237 8 by by IN 19613 4237 9 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4237 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4237 11 V. V. NNP 19613 4237 12 7 7 CD 19613 4237 13 f. f. NNP 19613 4237 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4237 15 : : : 19613 4237 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4237 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4237 18 : : : 19613 4237 19 eis eis NNP 19613 4237 20 Rhômên Rhômên NNP 19613 4237 21 hos hos NN 19613 4237 22 epempsen epempsen NNP 19613 4237 23 emen emen NNP 19613 4237 24 basilêan basilêan NNP 19613 4237 25 athrêsai athrêsai NNP 19613 4237 26 kai kai NNP 19613 4237 27 basilissan basilissan NNP 19613 4237 28 idein idein NNP 19613 4237 29 chrusostolon chrusostolon NNP 19613 4237 30 chrusopedilon chrusopedilon NNP 19613 4237 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4237 32 . . . 19613 4238 1 However however RB 19613 4238 2 , , , 19613 4238 3 Ficker Ficker NNP 19613 4238 4 raises raise VBZ 19613 4238 5 very very RB 19613 4238 6 serious serious JJ 19613 4238 7 objections objection NNS 19613 4238 8 to to IN 19613 4238 9 the the DT 19613 4238 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 4238 11 origin origin NN 19613 4238 12 of of IN 19613 4238 13 the the DT 19613 4238 14 inscription inscription NN 19613 4238 15 . . . 19613 4238 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4239 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4239 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 4239 3 325 325 CD 19613 4239 4 : : : 19613 4239 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4239 6 can can MD 19613 4239 7 not not RB 19613 4239 8 here here RB 19613 4239 9 discuss discuss VB 19613 4239 10 how how WRB 19613 4239 11 this this DT 19613 4239 12 tradition tradition NN 19613 4239 13 arose arise VBD 19613 4239 14 ; ; : 19613 4239 15 in in IN 19613 4239 16 all all DT 19613 4239 17 likelihood likelihood NN 19613 4239 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4239 19 already already RB 19613 4239 20 expresses express VBZ 19613 4239 21 the the DT 19613 4239 22 position position NN 19613 4239 23 which which WDT 19613 4239 24 the the DT 19613 4239 25 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4239 26 Church Church NNP 19613 4239 27 very very RB 19613 4239 28 speedily speedily RB 19613 4239 29 attained attain VBD 19613 4239 30 in in IN 19613 4239 31 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 4239 32 . . . 19613 4240 1 See see VB 19613 4240 2 Renan Renan NNP 19613 4240 3 , , , 19613 4240 4 Orig Orig NNP 19613 4240 5 . . . 19613 4240 6 , , , 19613 4240 7 Vol Vol NNP 19613 4240 8 . . . 19613 4241 1 VII VII NNP 19613 4241 2 . . NNP 19613 4241 3 , , , 19613 4241 4 p. p. NN 19613 4241 5 70 70 CD 19613 4241 6 : : : 19613 4241 7 " " `` 19613 4241 8 Pierre Pierre NNP 19613 4241 9 el el NNP 19613 4241 10 Paul Paul NNP 19613 4241 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4241 12 léconciliés léconciliés NNP 19613 4241 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4241 14 , , , 19613 4241 15 voilà voilà NNP 19613 4241 16 le le NNP 19613 4241 17 chef chef NNP 19613 4241 18 - - HYPH 19613 4241 19 d'oeuvre d'oeuvre NNP 19613 4241 20 qui qui NNP 19613 4241 21 fondait fondait NNP 19613 4241 22 la la NNP 19613 4241 23 suprématie suprématie NNP 19613 4241 24 ecclésiastique ecclésiastique NNP 19613 4241 25 de de IN 19613 4241 26 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4241 27 dans dan NNS 19613 4241 28 làvenir làvenir NN 19613 4241 29 . . . 19613 4242 1 Une Une NNP 19613 4242 2 nouvelle nouvelle NNP 19613 4242 3 qualité qualité NNP 19613 4242 4 mythique mythique NNP 19613 4242 5 lemplagait lemplagait NNP 19613 4242 6 celle celle NNP 19613 4242 7 de de NNP 19613 4242 8 Romulus Romulus NNP 19613 4242 9 et et FW 19613 4242 10 Remus Remus NNP 19613 4242 11 . . . 19613 4242 12 " " '' 19613 4243 1 But but CC 19613 4243 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4243 3 is be VBZ 19613 4243 4 highly highly RB 19613 4243 5 probable probable JJ 19613 4243 6 that that IN 19613 4243 7 Peter Peter NNP 19613 4243 8 was be VBD 19613 4243 9 really really RB 19613 4243 10 in in IN 19613 4243 11 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4243 12 like like IN 19613 4243 13 Paul Paul NNP 19613 4243 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4243 15 see see UH 19613 4243 16 1 1 CD 19613 4243 17 Clem Clem NNP 19613 4243 18 . . . 19613 4244 1 V. V. NNP 19613 4244 2 , , , 19613 4244 3 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4244 4 ad ad NN 19613 4244 5 Rom rom NN 19613 4244 6 . . . 19613 4245 1 IV IV NNP 19613 4245 2 . . . 19613 4246 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4246 2 ; ; : 19613 4246 3 both both DT 19613 4246 4 really really RB 19613 4246 5 performed perform VBD 19613 4246 6 important important JJ 19613 4246 7 services service NNS 19613 4246 8 to to IN 19613 4246 9 the the DT 19613 4246 10 Church Church NNP 19613 4246 11 there there RB 19613 4246 12 , , , 19613 4246 13 and and CC 19613 4246 14 died die VBD 19613 4246 15 as as IN 19613 4246 16 martyrs martyr NNS 19613 4246 17 in in IN 19613 4246 18 that that DT 19613 4246 19 city city NN 19613 4246 20 . . . 19613 4246 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4247 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4247 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4247 3 326 326 CD 19613 4247 4 : : : 19613 4247 5 The the DT 19613 4247 6 wealth wealth NN 19613 4247 7 of of IN 19613 4247 8 the the DT 19613 4247 9 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4247 10 Church Church NNP 19613 4247 11 is be VBZ 19613 4247 12 also also RB 19613 4247 13 illustrated illustrate VBN 19613 4247 14 by by IN 19613 4247 15 the the DT 19613 4247 16 present present NN 19613 4247 17 of of IN 19613 4247 18 200,000 200,000 CD 19613 4247 19 sesterces sesterce NNS 19613 4247 20 brought bring VBD 19613 4247 21 her -PRON- PRP 19613 4247 22 by by IN 19613 4247 23 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 4247 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4247 25 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 4247 26 . . NNP 19613 4247 27 , , , 19613 4247 28 de de NNP 19613 4247 29 præse præse NNP 19613 4247 30 . . . 19613 4248 1 30 30 CD 19613 4248 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4248 3 . . . 19613 4249 1 The the DT 19613 4249 2 " " `` 19613 4249 3 Shepherd Shepherd NNP 19613 4249 4 " " '' 19613 4249 5 also also RB 19613 4249 6 contains contain VBZ 19613 4249 7 instructive instructive JJ 19613 4249 8 particulars particular NNS 19613 4249 9 with with IN 19613 4249 10 regard regard NN 19613 4249 11 to to IN 19613 4249 12 this this DT 19613 4249 13 . . . 19613 4250 1 As as RB 19613 4250 2 far far RB 19613 4250 3 as as IN 19613 4250 4 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4250 5 influence influence NN 19613 4250 6 is be VBZ 19613 4250 7 concerned concern VBN 19613 4250 8 , , , 19613 4250 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4250 10 possess possess VBP 19613 4250 11 various various JJ 19613 4250 12 testimonies testimony NNS 19613 4250 13 from from IN 19613 4250 14 Philipp Philipp NNP 19613 4250 15 . . . 19613 4251 1 IV IV NNP 19613 4251 2 . . . 19613 4252 1 22 22 CD 19613 4252 2 down down IN 19613 4252 3 to to IN 19613 4252 4 the the DT 19613 4252 5 famous famous JJ 19613 4252 6 account account NN 19613 4252 7 by by IN 19613 4252 8 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4252 9 of of IN 19613 4252 10 the the DT 19613 4252 11 relations relation NNS 19613 4252 12 of of IN 19613 4252 13 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4252 14 to to IN 19613 4252 15 Marcia Marcia NNP 19613 4252 16 . . . 19613 4253 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4253 2 may may MD 19613 4253 3 call call VB 19613 4253 4 special special JJ 19613 4253 5 attention attention NN 19613 4253 6 to to IN 19613 4253 7 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 4253 8 ' ' POS 19613 4253 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 4253 10 to to IN 19613 4253 11 the the DT 19613 4253 12 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 4253 13 . . . 19613 4253 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4254 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4254 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 4254 3 327 327 CD 19613 4254 4 : : : 19613 4254 5 See see VB 19613 4254 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4254 7 , , , 19613 4254 8 adv adv NN 19613 4254 9 . . . 19613 4255 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 4255 2 . . . 19613 4256 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4256 2 ; ; : 19613 4256 3 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4256 4 . . NNP 19613 4256 5 , , , 19613 4256 6 H. H. NNP 19613 4256 7 E. E. NNP 19613 4256 8 V. V. NNP 19613 4256 9 3 3 CD 19613 4256 10 , , , 19613 4256 11 4 4 CD 19613 4256 12 . . . 19613 4257 1 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 19613 4257 2 of of IN 19613 4257 3 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4257 4 Biography Biography NNP 19613 4257 5 III III NNP 19613 4257 6 . . NNP 19613 4257 7 , , , 19613 4257 8 p. p. NN 19613 4258 1 937 937 CD 19613 4258 2 . . . 19613 4258 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4259 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4259 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4259 3 328 328 CD 19613 4259 4 : : : 19613 4259 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4259 6 , , , 19613 4259 7 H.E. H.E. NNP 19613 4260 1 V. V. NNP 19613 4260 2 24 24 CD 19613 4260 3 . . . 19613 4261 1 9 9 CD 19613 4261 2 : : : 19613 4261 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4261 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4261 5 : : : 19613 4261 6 epi epi NNP 19613 4261 7 toutois toutois NNP 19613 4261 8 ho ho NNP 19613 4261 9 men man NNS 19613 4261 10 tês tês NNP 19613 4261 11 Rhômaiôn Rhômaiôn NNP 19613 4261 12 proestôs proestôs NN 19613 4261 13 Biktôr Biktôr NNP 19613 4261 14 athroôs athroôs VBP 19613 4261 15 tês tês NNP 19613 4261 16 Asias Asias NNP 19613 4261 17 pasês pasês NNP 19613 4261 18 hama hama NNP 19613 4261 19 tais tais NNP 19613 4261 20 homorois homorois NNP 19613 4261 21 ekklêsiais ekklêsiais NNP 19613 4261 22 tas tas NNP 19613 4261 23 paroikias paroikias NNP 19613 4261 24 apotemnein apotemnein NNP 19613 4261 25 hôsan hôsan NNP 19613 4261 26 heterodoxousas heterodoxousas NNP 19613 4261 27 , , , 19613 4261 28 tês tês NNP 19613 4261 29 koinês koinês NNP 19613 4261 30 henôseôs henôseôs NN 19613 4261 31 peiratai peiratai NNP 19613 4261 32 , , , 19613 4261 33 kai kai NNP 19613 4261 34 stêliteuei stêliteuei NNP 19613 4261 35 ge ge NNP 19613 4261 36 dia dia NNP 19613 4261 37 grammatôn grammatôn NNP 19613 4261 38 , , , 19613 4261 39 akoinônêtous akoinônêtous JJ 19613 4261 40 pantas pantas NNP 19613 4261 41 ardên ardên NNS 19613 4261 42 tous tous JJ 19613 4261 43 ekeise ekeise NNP 19613 4261 44 anakêruttôn anakêruttôn NNS 19613 4261 45 adelphous adelphous JJ 19613 4261 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4261 47 . . . 19613 4262 1 Stress stress NN 19613 4262 2 should should MD 19613 4262 3 be be VB 19613 4262 4 laid lay VBN 19613 4262 5 on on IN 19613 4262 6 two two CD 19613 4262 7 points point NNS 19613 4262 8 here here RB 19613 4262 9 : : : 19613 4262 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4262 11 1 1 LS 19613 4262 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4262 13 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4262 14 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 4262 15 that that IN 19613 4262 16 the the DT 19613 4262 17 people people NNS 19613 4262 18 of of IN 19613 4262 19 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4262 20 Minor Minor NNP 19613 4262 21 were be VBD 19613 4262 22 to to TO 19613 4262 23 be be VB 19613 4262 24 excluded exclude VBN 19613 4262 25 from from IN 19613 4262 26 the the DT 19613 4262 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4262 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4262 29 : : : 19613 4262 30 koinê koinê NNP 19613 4262 31 henôsis henôsis NNP 19613 4262 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4262 33 , , , 19613 4262 34 and and CC 19613 4262 35 not not RB 19613 4262 36 merely merely RB 19613 4262 37 from from IN 19613 4262 38 the the DT 19613 4262 39 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 4262 40 of of IN 19613 4262 41 the the DT 19613 4262 42 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4262 43 Church Church NNP 19613 4262 44 ; ; : 19613 4262 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4262 46 2 2 LS 19613 4262 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4262 48 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4262 49 based base VBD 19613 4262 50 the the DT 19613 4262 51 excommunication excommunication NN 19613 4262 52 on on IN 19613 4262 53 the the DT 19613 4262 54 alleged allege VBN 19613 4262 55 heterodoxy heterodoxy NN 19613 4262 56 of of IN 19613 4262 57 those those DT 19613 4262 58 Churches church NNS 19613 4262 59 . . . 19613 4263 1 See see VB 19613 4263 2 Heinichen Heinichen NNP 19613 4263 3 , , , 19613 4263 4 Melet Melet NNP 19613 4263 5 . . . 19613 4264 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 4264 2 , , , 19613 4264 3 on on IN 19613 4264 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4264 5 . . NNP 19613 4264 6 , , , 19613 4264 7 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4264 8 . . . 19613 4265 1 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4265 2 's 's POS 19613 4265 3 action action NN 19613 4265 4 is be VBZ 19613 4265 5 parallelled parallel VBN 19613 4265 6 by by IN 19613 4265 7 that that DT 19613 4265 8 of of IN 19613 4265 9 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 4265 10 . . . 19613 4266 1 Firmilian Firmilian NNP 19613 4266 2 says say VBZ 19613 4266 3 to to IN 19613 4266 4 the the DT 19613 4266 5 latter latter JJ 19613 4266 6 : : : 19613 4266 7 " " `` 19613 4266 8 Dum Dum NNP 19613 4266 9 enim enim NN 19613 4266 10 putas putas NNP 19613 4266 11 , , , 19613 4266 12 omnes omnes NNP 19613 4266 13 abs abs NNP 19613 4266 14 te te NNP 19613 4266 15 abstineri abstineri NNP 19613 4266 16 posse posse NNP 19613 4266 17 , , , 19613 4266 18 solum solum NNP 19613 4266 19 te te NNP 19613 4266 20 ab ab NNP 19613 4266 21 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 4266 22 abstinuisti abstinuisti NNP 19613 4266 23 . . . 19613 4266 24 " " '' 19613 4267 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4267 2 is be VBZ 19613 4267 3 a a DT 19613 4267 4 very very RB 19613 4267 5 instructive instructive JJ 19613 4267 6 fact fact NN 19613 4267 7 that that IN 19613 4267 8 in in IN 19613 4267 9 the the DT 19613 4267 10 4th 4th JJ 19613 4267 11 century century NN 19613 4267 12 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4267 13 also also RB 19613 4267 14 made make VBD 19613 4267 15 the the DT 19613 4267 16 attempt attempt NN 19613 4267 17 to to TO 19613 4267 18 have have VB 19613 4267 19 Sabbath Sabbath NNP 19613 4267 20 fasting fast VBG 19613 4267 21 established establish VBN 19613 4267 22 as as IN 19613 4267 23 an an DT 19613 4267 24 _ _ NNP 19613 4267 25 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 4267 26 _ _ NNP 19613 4267 27 custom custom NN 19613 4267 28 . . . 19613 4268 1 See see VB 19613 4268 2 the the DT 19613 4268 3 interesting interesting JJ 19613 4268 4 work work NN 19613 4268 5 confuted confute VBN 19613 4268 6 by by IN 19613 4268 7 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 4268 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4268 9 ep ep NNP 19613 4268 10 . . . 19613 4269 1 36 36 CD 19613 4269 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4269 3 , , , 19613 4269 4 a a DT 19613 4269 5 writing writing NN 19613 4269 6 which which WDT 19613 4269 7 emanates emanate VBZ 19613 4269 8 from from IN 19613 4269 9 a a DT 19613 4269 10 Roman roman JJ 19613 4269 11 author author NN 19613 4269 12 who who WP 19613 4269 13 is be VBZ 19613 4269 14 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 4269 15 unknown unknown JJ 19613 4269 16 to to IN 19613 4269 17 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4269 18 . . . 19613 4270 1 Cf cf NN 19613 4270 2 . . . 19613 4271 1 also also RB 19613 4271 2 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 4271 3 's 's POS 19613 4271 4 54th 54th JJ 19613 4271 5 and and CC 19613 4271 6 55th 55th JJ 19613 4271 7 epistles epistle NNS 19613 4271 8 . . . 19613 4271 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4272 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4272 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4272 3 329 329 CD 19613 4272 4 : : : 19613 4272 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4272 6 also also RB 19613 4272 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4272 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 4272 9 . . . 19613 4273 1 § § ADD 19613 4273 2 11 11 CD 19613 4273 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4273 4 does do VBZ 19613 4273 5 not not RB 19613 4273 6 appear appear VB 19613 4273 7 to to TO 19613 4273 8 have have VB 19613 4273 9 questioned question VBN 19613 4273 10 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4273 11 's 's POS 19613 4273 12 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 4273 13 as as IN 19613 4273 14 such such JJ 19613 4273 15 , , , 19613 4273 16 but but CC 19613 4273 17 as as IN 19613 4273 18 applied apply VBN 19613 4273 19 to to IN 19613 4273 20 this this DT 19613 4273 21 particular particular JJ 19613 4273 22 case case NN 19613 4273 23 . . . 19613 4273 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4274 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4274 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4274 3 330 330 CD 19613 4274 4 : : : 19613 4274 5 See See NNP 19613 4274 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 4274 7 . . NNP 19613 4274 8 , , , 19613 4274 9 de de FW 19613 4274 10 orat orat NNP 19613 4274 11 . . . 19613 4275 1 22 22 CD 19613 4275 2 : : : 19613 4275 3 " " `` 19613 4275 4 Sed Sed NNP 19613 4275 5 non non AFX 19613 4275 6 putet putet NN 19613 4275 7 institutionem institutionem NNP 19613 4275 8 unusquisque unusquisque NNP 19613 4275 9 antecessoris antecessoris NNP 19613 4275 10 commovendam commovendam NNP 19613 4275 11 . . . 19613 4275 12 " " '' 19613 4276 1 De De NNP 19613 4276 2 virg virg NNS 19613 4276 3 . . . 19613 4277 1 vel vel NNP 19613 4277 2 . . . 19613 4278 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4278 2 : : : 19613 4278 3 " " `` 19613 4278 4 Paracletus Paracletus NNP 19613 4278 5 solus solus JJ 19613 4278 6 antecessor antecessor NN 19613 4278 7 , , , 19613 4278 8 quia quia NNP 19613 4278 9 solus solu NNS 19613 4278 10 post post NNP 19613 4278 11 Christum Christum NNP 19613 4278 12 ; ; : 19613 4278 13 " " `` 19613 4278 14 2 2 CD 19613 4278 15 : : : 19613 4278 16 " " `` 19613 4278 17 Eas Eas NNP 19613 4278 18 ego ego NN 19613 4278 19 ecclesias ecclesias NNP 19613 4278 20 proposui proposui NNP 19613 4278 21 , , , 19613 4278 22 quas quas NNP 19613 4278 23 et et NNP 19613 4278 24 ipsi ipsi NNP 19613 4278 25 apostolici apostolici NNP 19613 4278 26 viri viri NNP 19613 4278 27 condiderunt condiderunt NNP 19613 4278 28 , , , 19613 4278 29 et et NNP 19613 4278 30 puto puto NNP 19613 4278 31 ante ante NNP 19613 4278 32 quosdam quosdam NNP 19613 4278 33 ; ; : 19613 4278 34 " " `` 19613 4278 35 3 3 CD 19613 4278 36 : : : 19613 4278 37 " " `` 19613 4278 38 Sed Sed NNP 19613 4278 39 nec nec NNP 19613 4278 40 inter inter NNP 19613 4278 41 consuetudines consuetudines NNP 19613 4278 42 dispicere dispicere NNP 19613 4278 43 voluerunt voluerunt NNP 19613 4278 44 illi illi NNP 19613 4278 45 sanctissimi sanctissimi NNP 19613 4278 46 antecessores antecessores NNP 19613 4278 47 . . . 19613 4278 48 " " '' 19613 4279 1 This this DT 19613 4279 2 is be VBZ 19613 4279 3 also also RB 19613 4279 4 the the DT 19613 4279 5 question question NN 19613 4279 6 referred refer VBD 19613 4279 7 to to IN 19613 4279 8 in in IN 19613 4279 9 the the DT 19613 4279 10 important important JJ 19613 4279 11 remark remark NN 19613 4279 12 in in IN 19613 4279 13 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 4279 14 , , , 19613 4279 15 de de NNP 19613 4279 16 vir vir NNP 19613 4279 17 . . . 19613 4280 1 inl inl UH 19613 4280 2 . . . 19613 4281 1 53 53 CD 19613 4281 2 : : : 19613 4281 3 " " `` 19613 4281 4 Tertullianus tertullianus NN 19613 4281 5 ad ad NN 19613 4281 6 mediam mediam NN 19613 4281 7 ætatem ætatem NN 19613 4281 8 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 4281 9 fuit fuit NN 19613 4281 10 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NNP 19613 4281 11 Africanæ Africanæ NNP 19613 4281 12 , , , 19613 4281 13 invidia invidia NNP 19613 4281 14 postea postea NNP 19613 4281 15 et et NNP 19613 4281 16 contumeliis contumeliis NN 19613 4281 17 clericorum clericorum NNP 19613 4281 18 Romanæ Romanæ NNP 19613 4281 19 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ JJ 19613 4281 20 ad ad NN 19613 4281 21 Montani Montani NNP 19613 4281 22 dogma dogma NN 19613 4281 23 delapsus delapsus JJ 19613 4281 24 . . . 19613 4281 25 " " '' 19613 4281 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4282 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4282 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4282 3 331 331 CD 19613 4282 4 : : : 19613 4282 5 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 4282 6 acted act VBD 19613 4282 7 like like IN 19613 4282 8 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4282 9 and and CC 19613 4282 10 excluded exclude VBD 19613 4282 11 almost almost RB 19613 4282 12 all all PDT 19613 4282 13 the the DT 19613 4282 14 East East NNP 19613 4282 15 from from IN 19613 4282 16 the the DT 19613 4282 17 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 4282 18 of of IN 19613 4282 19 the the DT 19613 4282 20 Church Church NNP 19613 4282 21 ; ; : 19613 4282 22 see see VB 19613 4282 23 in in IN 19613 4282 24 addition addition NN 19613 4282 25 to to IN 19613 4282 26 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 4282 27 's 's POS 19613 4282 28 epistles epistle NNS 19613 4282 29 that that IN 19613 4282 30 of of IN 19613 4282 31 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4282 32 of of IN 19613 4282 33 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4282 34 in in IN 19613 4282 35 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4282 36 . . NNP 19613 4282 37 , , , 19613 4282 38 H. H. NNP 19613 4282 39 E. E. NNP 19613 4282 40 VII VII NNP 19613 4282 41 . . . 19613 4283 1 5 5 CD 19613 4283 2 . . . 19613 4284 1 In in IN 19613 4284 2 reference reference NN 19613 4284 3 to to IN 19613 4284 4 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4284 5 , , , 19613 4284 6 see see VB 19613 4284 7 Philosoph Philosoph NNP 19613 4284 8 . . . 19613 4285 1 l. l. NNP 19613 4285 2 IX IX NNP 19613 4285 3 . . . 19613 4286 1 In in IN 19613 4286 2 regard regard NN 19613 4286 3 to to IN 19613 4286 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4286 5 , , , 19613 4286 6 see see VB 19613 4286 7 the the DT 19613 4286 8 allusions allusion NNS 19613 4286 9 in in IN 19613 4286 10 de de FW 19613 4286 11 orat orat NNP 19613 4286 12 . . . 19613 4287 1 28 28 CD 19613 4287 2 fin fin NNP 19613 4287 3 . . . 19613 4288 1 ; ; : 19613 4288 2 in in IN 19613 4288 3 Matth Matth NNP 19613 4288 4 . . . 19613 4289 1 XI XI NNP 19613 4289 2 . . . 19613 4290 1 9 9 CD 19613 4290 2 , , , 19613 4290 3 15 15 CD 19613 4290 4 : : : 19613 4290 5 XII XII NNP 19613 4290 6 . . . 19613 4291 1 9 9 CD 19613 4291 2 - - SYM 19613 4291 3 14 14 CD 19613 4291 4 : : : 19613 4291 5 XVI XVI NNP 19613 4291 6 . . . 19613 4292 1 8 8 CD 19613 4292 2 , , , 19613 4292 3 22 22 CD 19613 4292 4 : : : 19613 4292 5 XVII XVII NNP 19613 4292 6 . . . 19613 4293 1 14 14 CD 19613 4293 2 ; ; : 19613 4293 3 in in IN 19613 4293 4 Joh Joh NNP 19613 4293 5 . . . 19613 4294 1 X. X. NNP 19613 4295 1 16 16 LS 19613 4295 2 ; ; : 19613 4295 3 Rom Rom NNP 19613 4295 4 . . . 19613 4296 1 VI VI NNP 19613 4296 2 in in IN 19613 4296 3 Isai Isai NNP 19613 4296 4 . . . 19613 4297 1 c. c. NNP 19613 4297 2 1 1 CD 19613 4297 3 . . . 19613 4298 1 With with IN 19613 4298 2 regard regard NN 19613 4298 3 to to IN 19613 4298 4 Philosoph Philosoph NNP 19613 4298 5 . . . 19613 4299 1 IX ix NN 19613 4299 2 . . . 19613 4300 1 12 12 CD 19613 4300 2 , , , 19613 4300 3 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 4300 4 rightly rightly RB 19613 4300 5 remarks remark VBZ 19613 4300 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4300 7 p. p. NN 19613 4300 8 389 389 CD 19613 4300 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4300 10 : : : 19613 4300 11 " " `` 19613 4300 12 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4300 13 is be VBZ 19613 4300 14 clear clear JJ 19613 4300 15 that that IN 19613 4300 16 the the DT 19613 4300 17 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 4300 18 was be VBD 19613 4300 19 laid lay VBN 19613 4300 20 on on IN 19613 4300 21 the the DT 19613 4300 22 Roman roman JJ 19613 4300 23 bishop bishop NN 19613 4300 24 not not RB 19613 4300 25 merely merely RB 19613 4300 26 in in IN 19613 4300 27 several several JJ 19613 4300 28 cases case NNS 19613 4300 29 where where WRB 19613 4300 30 married married JJ 19613 4300 31 men man NNS 19613 4300 32 were be VBD 19613 4300 33 made make VBN 19613 4300 34 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 4300 35 and and CC 19613 4300 36 deacons deacon NNS 19613 4300 37 , , , 19613 4300 38 but but CC 19613 4300 39 also also RB 19613 4300 40 when when WRB 19613 4300 41 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4300 42 were be VBD 19613 4300 43 appointed appoint VBN 19613 4300 44 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4300 45 ; ; : 19613 4300 46 and and CC 19613 4300 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4300 48 is be VBZ 19613 4300 49 also also RB 19613 4300 50 evident evident JJ 19613 4300 51 that that IN 19613 4300 52 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4300 53 appears appear VBZ 19613 4300 54 just just RB 19613 4300 55 as as IN 19613 4300 56 responsible responsible JJ 19613 4300 57 when when WRB 19613 4300 58 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4300 59 are be VBP 19613 4300 60 not not RB 19613 4300 61 deposed depose VBN 19613 4300 62 in in IN 19613 4300 63 consequence consequence NN 19613 4300 64 of of IN 19613 4300 65 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4300 66 marrying marrying NN 19613 4300 67 . . . 19613 4300 68 " " '' 19613 4301 1 One one PRP 19613 4301 2 can can MD 19613 4301 3 not not RB 19613 4301 4 help help VB 19613 4301 5 concluding conclude VBG 19613 4301 6 that that IN 19613 4301 7 the the DT 19613 4301 8 Roman roman JJ 19613 4301 9 bishop bishop NN 19613 4301 10 has have VBZ 19613 4301 11 the the DT 19613 4301 12 power power NN 19613 4301 13 of of IN 19613 4301 14 appointing appoint VBG 19613 4301 15 and and CC 19613 4301 16 deposing deposing NN 19613 4301 17 not not RB 19613 4301 18 merely merely RB 19613 4301 19 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 4301 20 and and CC 19613 4301 21 deacons deacon NNS 19613 4301 22 , , , 19613 4301 23 but but CC 19613 4301 24 also also RB 19613 4301 25 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4301 26 . . . 19613 4302 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4302 2 , , , 19613 4302 3 the the DT 19613 4302 4 impression impression NN 19613 4302 5 is be VBZ 19613 4302 6 conveyed convey VBN 19613 4302 7 that that IN 19613 4302 8 this this DT 19613 4302 9 appointment appointment NN 19613 4302 10 and and CC 19613 4302 11 deposition deposition NN 19613 4302 12 of of IN 19613 4302 13 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4302 14 takes take VBZ 19613 4302 15 place place NN 19613 4302 16 in in IN 19613 4302 17 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4302 18 , , , 19613 4302 19 for for IN 19613 4302 20 the the DT 19613 4302 21 passage passage NN 19613 4302 22 contains contain VBZ 19613 4302 23 a a DT 19613 4302 24 description description NN 19613 4302 25 of of IN 19613 4302 26 existent existent NN 19613 4302 27 conditions condition NNS 19613 4302 28 in in IN 19613 4302 29 the the DT 19613 4302 30 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4302 31 Church Church NNP 19613 4302 32 . . . 19613 4303 1 Other other JJ 19613 4303 2 communities community NNS 19613 4303 3 may may MD 19613 4303 4 be be VB 19613 4303 5 deprived deprive VBN 19613 4303 6 of of IN 19613 4303 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4303 8 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4303 9 by by IN 19613 4303 10 an an DT 19613 4303 11 order order NN 19613 4303 12 from from IN 19613 4303 13 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4303 14 , , , 19613 4303 15 and and CC 19613 4303 16 a a DT 19613 4303 17 bishop bishop NN 19613 4303 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4303 19 chosen choose VBN 19613 4303 20 in in IN 19613 4303 21 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4303 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4303 23 may may MD 19613 4303 24 be be VB 19613 4303 25 sent send VBN 19613 4303 26 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4303 27 . . . 19613 4304 1 The the DT 19613 4304 2 words word NNS 19613 4304 3 of of IN 19613 4304 4 the the DT 19613 4304 5 passage passage NN 19613 4304 6 are be VBP 19613 4304 7 : : : 19613 4304 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4304 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4304 10 : : : 19613 4304 11 epi epi NNP 19613 4304 12 kallistou kallistou NNP 19613 4304 13 êrxanto êrxanto IN 19613 4304 14 episkopoi episkopoi NNP 19613 4304 15 kai kai NNP 19613 4304 16 presbuteroi presbuteroi NNP 19613 4304 17 kai kai NNP 19613 4304 18 diakonoi diakonoi NNP 19613 4304 19 digamoi digamoi NNP 19613 4304 20 kai kai NNP 19613 4304 21 trigamoi trigamoi NNP 19613 4304 22 kathistasthai kathistasthai NNP 19613 4304 23 eis eis NNP 19613 4304 24 klêrous klêrous NNP 19613 4304 25 ei ei NNP 19613 4304 26 de de NNP 19613 4304 27 kai kai NNP 19613 4304 28 tis tis NNP 19613 4304 29 en en IN 19613 4304 30 klêrô klêrô NNP 19613 4304 31 ôn ôn NNP 19613 4304 32 gamoiê gamoiê NNP 19613 4304 33 , , , 19613 4304 34 menein menein NNP 19613 4304 35 ton ton NNP 19613 4304 36 toiouton toiouton NNP 19613 4304 37 en en NNP 19613 4304 38 tô tô NNP 19613 4304 39 klêrô klêrô NNP 19613 4304 40 hôs hôs NNP 19613 4304 41 mê mê NNP 19613 4304 42 hêmartêkota hêmartêkota NNP 19613 4304 43 . . . 19613 4304 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4304 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4305 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4305 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4305 3 332 332 CD 19613 4305 4 : : : 19613 4305 5 In in IN 19613 4305 6 the the DT 19613 4305 7 treatise treatise NN 19613 4305 8 " " `` 19613 4305 9 Die Die NNP 19613 4305 10 Briefe Briefe NNP 19613 4305 11 des des NNP 19613 4305 12 romischen romischen NN 19613 4305 13 Klerus Klerus NNP 19613 4305 14 aus aus NN 19613 4305 15 der der VBD 19613 4305 16 Zeit Zeit NNP 19613 4305 17 der der NN 19613 4305 18 Sedisvacanz Sedisvacanz NNP 19613 4305 19 i -PRON- PRP 19613 4305 20 m be VBP 19613 4305 21 Jahre Jahre NNP 19613 4305 22 250 250 CD 19613 4305 23 " " '' 19613 4305 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4305 25 Abhandlungen Abhandlungen NNP 19613 4305 26 fur fur NN 19613 4305 27 Weizsäcker Weizsäcker NNP 19613 4305 28 , , , 19613 4305 29 1892 1892 CD 19613 4305 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4305 31 , , , 19613 4305 32 I -PRON- PRP 19613 4305 33 have have VBP 19613 4305 34 shown show VBN 19613 4305 35 how how WRB 19613 4305 36 the the DT 19613 4305 37 Roman roman JJ 19613 4305 38 clergy clergy NNS 19613 4305 39 kept keep VBD 19613 4305 40 the the DT 19613 4305 41 revenue revenue NN 19613 4305 42 of of IN 19613 4305 43 the the DT 19613 4305 44 Church Church NNP 19613 4305 45 and and CC 19613 4305 46 of of IN 19613 4305 47 the the DT 19613 4305 48 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4305 49 in in IN 19613 4305 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4305 51 hands hand NNS 19613 4305 52 , , , 19613 4305 53 though though IN 19613 4305 54 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4305 55 had have VBD 19613 4305 56 no no DT 19613 4305 57 bishop bishop NN 19613 4305 58 . . . 19613 4306 1 What what WDT 19613 4306 2 language language NN 19613 4306 3 the the DT 19613 4306 4 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 4306 5 used use VBN 19613 4306 6 in in IN 19613 4306 7 epistles epistle NNS 19613 4306 8 8 8 CD 19613 4306 9 , , , 19613 4306 10 30 30 CD 19613 4306 11 , , , 19613 4306 12 36 36 CD 19613 4306 13 of of IN 19613 4306 14 the the DT 19613 4306 15 Cyprian cyprian JJ 19613 4306 16 collection collection NN 19613 4306 17 , , , 19613 4306 18 and and CC 19613 4306 19 how how WRB 19613 4306 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4306 21 interfered interfere VBD 19613 4306 22 in in IN 19613 4306 23 the the DT 19613 4306 24 affairs affair NNS 19613 4306 25 of of IN 19613 4306 26 the the DT 19613 4306 27 Carthaginian Carthaginian NNP 19613 4306 28 Church Church NNP 19613 4306 29 ! ! . 19613 4307 1 Beyond beyond IN 19613 4307 2 doubt doubt NN 19613 4307 3 the the DT 19613 4307 4 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4307 5 _ _ NNP 19613 4307 6 Church Church NNP 19613 4307 7 _ _ NNP 19613 4307 8 possessed possess VBD 19613 4307 9 an an DT 19613 4307 10 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 4307 11 primacy primacy NN 19613 4307 12 in in IN 19613 4307 13 the the DT 19613 4307 14 year year NN 19613 4307 15 250 250 CD 19613 4307 16 ; ; : 19613 4307 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4307 18 was be VBD 19613 4307 19 the the DT 19613 4307 20 primacy primacy NN 19613 4307 21 of of IN 19613 4307 22 active active JJ 19613 4307 23 participation participation NN 19613 4307 24 and and CC 19613 4307 25 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 4307 26 duty duty NN 19613 4307 27 . . . 19613 4308 1 As as IN 19613 4308 2 yet yet RB 19613 4308 3 there there EX 19613 4308 4 was be VBD 19613 4308 5 no no DT 19613 4308 6 recognised recognise VBN 19613 4308 7 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 4308 8 or or CC 19613 4308 9 historic historic JJ 19613 4308 10 foundation foundation NN 19613 4308 11 assigned assign VBN 19613 4308 12 for for IN 19613 4308 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4308 14 ; ; : 19613 4308 15 in in IN 19613 4308 16 fact fact NN 19613 4308 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4308 18 is be VBZ 19613 4308 19 highly highly RB 19613 4308 20 probable probable JJ 19613 4308 21 that that IN 19613 4308 22 this this DT 19613 4308 23 theory theory NN 19613 4308 24 was be VBD 19613 4308 25 still still RB 19613 4308 26 shaky shaky JJ 19613 4308 27 and and CC 19613 4308 28 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 4308 29 in in IN 19613 4308 30 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4308 31 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 4308 32 . . . 19613 4309 1 The the DT 19613 4309 2 college college NN 19613 4309 3 of of IN 19613 4309 4 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 4309 5 and and CC 19613 4309 6 deacons deacon NNS 19613 4309 7 feels feel VBZ 19613 4309 8 and and CC 19613 4309 9 speaks speak VBZ 19613 4309 10 as as IN 19613 4309 11 if if IN 19613 4309 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4309 13 were be VBD 19613 4309 14 the the DT 19613 4309 15 bishop bishop NN 19613 4309 16 . . . 19613 4310 1 For for IN 19613 4310 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4310 3 was be VBD 19613 4310 4 not not RB 19613 4310 5 on on IN 19613 4310 6 the the DT 19613 4310 7 bishop bishop NN 19613 4310 8 that that IN 19613 4310 9 the the DT 19613 4310 10 incomparable incomparable JJ 19613 4310 11 prestige prestige NN 19613 4310 12 of of IN 19613 4310 13 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4310 14 was be VBD 19613 4310 15 based base VBN 19613 4310 16 -- -- : 19613 4310 17 at at IN 19613 4310 18 least least JJS 19613 4310 19 this this DT 19613 4310 20 claim claim NN 19613 4310 21 was be VBD 19613 4310 22 not not RB 19613 4310 23 yet yet RB 19613 4310 24 made make VBN 19613 4310 25 with with IN 19613 4310 26 any any DT 19613 4310 27 confidence,--but confidence,--but NNP 19613 4310 28 on on IN 19613 4310 29 the the DT 19613 4310 30 _ _ NNP 19613 4310 31 city city NN 19613 4310 32 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4310 33 _ _ NNP 19613 4310 34 , , , 19613 4310 35 on on IN 19613 4310 36 the the DT 19613 4310 37 origin origin NN 19613 4310 38 and and CC 19613 4310 39 history history NN 19613 4310 40 , , , 19613 4310 41 the the DT 19613 4310 42 faith faith NN 19613 4310 43 and and CC 19613 4310 44 love love NN 19613 4310 45 , , , 19613 4310 46 the the DT 19613 4310 47 earnestness earnestness NN 19613 4310 48 and and CC 19613 4310 49 zeal zeal NNP 19613 4310 50 _ _ NNP 19613 4310 51 of of IN 19613 4310 52 the the DT 19613 4310 53 whole whole JJ 19613 4310 54 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4310 55 Church Church NNP 19613 4310 56 and and CC 19613 4310 57 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4310 58 clergy clergy NNP 19613 4310 59 _ _ NNP 19613 4310 60 . . . 19613 4310 61 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4311 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4311 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 4311 3 333 333 CD 19613 4311 4 : : : 19613 4311 5 In in IN 19613 4311 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4311 7 , , , 19613 4311 8 de de FW 19613 4311 9 præsc præsc FW 19613 4311 10 . . . 19613 4312 1 36 36 CD 19613 4312 2 , , , 19613 4312 3 the the DT 19613 4312 4 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4312 5 are be VBP 19613 4312 6 not not RB 19613 4312 7 mentioned mention VBN 19613 4312 8 . . . 19613 4313 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4313 2 also also RB 19613 4313 3 , , , 19613 4313 4 like like IN 19613 4313 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4313 6 , , , 19613 4313 7 cites cite VBZ 19613 4313 8 the the DT 19613 4313 9 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4313 10 Church Church NNP 19613 4313 11 as as IN 19613 4313 12 one one CD 19613 4313 13 amongst amongst IN 19613 4313 14 others other NNS 19613 4313 15 . . . 19613 4314 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4314 2 have have VBP 19613 4314 3 already already RB 19613 4314 4 remarked remark VBN 19613 4314 5 that that IN 19613 4314 6 in in IN 19613 4314 7 the the DT 19613 4314 8 scheme scheme NN 19613 4314 9 of of IN 19613 4314 10 proof proof NN 19613 4314 11 from from IN 19613 4314 12 prescription prescription NN 19613 4314 13 no no DT 19613 4314 14 higher high JJR 19613 4314 15 rank rank NN 19613 4314 16 could could MD 19613 4314 17 be be VB 19613 4314 18 assigned assign VBN 19613 4314 19 to to IN 19613 4314 20 the the DT 19613 4314 21 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4314 22 Church Church NNP 19613 4314 23 than than IN 19613 4314 24 to to IN 19613 4314 25 any any DT 19613 4314 26 other other JJ 19613 4314 27 of of IN 19613 4314 28 the the DT 19613 4314 29 group group NN 19613 4314 30 founded found VBN 19613 4314 31 by by IN 19613 4314 32 the the DT 19613 4314 33 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 4314 34 . . . 19613 4315 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4315 2 continues continue VBZ 19613 4315 3 to to TO 19613 4315 4 maintain maintain VB 19613 4315 5 this this DT 19613 4315 6 position position NN 19613 4315 7 , , , 19613 4315 8 but but CC 19613 4315 9 expressly expressly RB 19613 4315 10 remarks remark VBZ 19613 4315 11 that that IN 19613 4315 12 the the DT 19613 4315 13 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4315 14 Church Church NNP 19613 4315 15 has have VBZ 19613 4315 16 special special JJ 19613 4315 17 authority authority NN 19613 4315 18 for for IN 19613 4315 19 the the DT 19613 4315 20 Carthaginian Carthaginian NNP 19613 4315 21 , , , 19613 4315 22 because because IN 19613 4315 23 Carthage carthage NN 19613 4315 24 had have VBD 19613 4315 25 received receive VBN 19613 4315 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4315 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4315 28 from from IN 19613 4315 29 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4315 30 . . . 19613 4316 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4316 2 expresses express VBZ 19613 4316 3 the the DT 19613 4316 4 special special JJ 19613 4316 5 relationship relationship NN 19613 4316 6 between between IN 19613 4316 7 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4316 8 and and CC 19613 4316 9 Carthage Carthage NNP 19613 4316 10 in in IN 19613 4316 11 the the DT 19613 4316 12 following following JJ 19613 4316 13 terms term NNS 19613 4316 14 : : : 19613 4316 15 " " `` 19613 4316 16 Si si IN 19613 4316 17 autem autem NN 19613 4316 18 Italiæ Italiæ NNP 19613 4316 19 adiaces adiace NNS 19613 4316 20 habes habe NNS 19613 4316 21 Romam Romam NNP 19613 4316 22 , , , 19613 4316 23 unde unde JJ 19613 4316 24 nobis nobis NNP 19613 4316 25 quoque quoque NNP 19613 4316 26 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 19613 4316 27 præsto præsto NNP 19613 4316 28 est est NNP 19613 4316 29 . . . 19613 4316 30 " " '' 19613 4317 1 With with IN 19613 4317 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4317 3 , , , 19613 4317 4 then then RB 19613 4317 5 , , , 19613 4317 6 the the DT 19613 4317 7 _ _ NNP 19613 4317 8 de de FW 19613 4317 9 facto facto FW 19613 4317 10 _ _ NNP 19613 4317 11 position position NN 19613 4317 12 of of IN 19613 4317 13 the the DT 19613 4317 14 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4317 15 Church Church NNP 19613 4317 16 in in IN 19613 4317 17 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 4317 18 did do VBD 19613 4317 19 not not RB 19613 4317 20 lead lead VB 19613 4317 21 to to IN 19613 4317 22 the the DT 19613 4317 23 same same JJ 19613 4317 24 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 4317 25 in in IN 19613 4317 26 the the DT 19613 4317 27 scheme scheme NN 19613 4317 28 of of IN 19613 4317 29 proof proof NN 19613 4317 30 from from IN 19613 4317 31 prescription prescription NN 19613 4317 32 as as IN 19613 4317 33 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4317 34 found find VBD 19613 4317 35 in in IN 19613 4317 36 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4317 37 . . . 19613 4318 1 But but CC 19613 4318 2 in in IN 19613 4318 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4318 4 case case NN 19613 4318 5 also also RB 19613 4318 6 that that DT 19613 4318 7 position position NN 19613 4318 8 is be VBZ 19613 4318 9 indicated indicate VBN 19613 4318 10 by by IN 19613 4318 11 the the DT 19613 4318 12 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 19613 4318 13 ardour ardour NN 19613 4318 14 with with IN 19613 4318 15 which which WDT 19613 4318 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4318 17 speaks speak VBZ 19613 4318 18 of of IN 19613 4318 19 the the DT 19613 4318 20 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4318 21 Church Church NNP 19613 4318 22 , , , 19613 4318 23 whereas whereas IN 19613 4318 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4318 25 does do VBZ 19613 4318 26 nothing nothing NN 19613 4318 27 more more JJR 19613 4318 28 than than IN 19613 4318 29 mention mention VB 19613 4318 30 Corinth Corinth NNP 19613 4318 31 , , , 19613 4318 32 Philippi Philippi NNP 19613 4318 33 , , , 19613 4318 34 Thessalonica Thessalonica NNP 19613 4318 35 , , , 19613 4318 36 and and CC 19613 4318 37 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 19613 4318 38 . . . 19613 4319 1 Even even RB 19613 4319 2 at at IN 19613 4319 3 that that DT 19613 4319 4 time time NN 19613 4319 5 , , , 19613 4319 6 moreover moreover RB 19613 4319 7 , , , 19613 4319 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4319 9 had have VBD 19613 4319 10 ground grind VBN 19613 4319 11 enough enough RB 19613 4319 12 for for IN 19613 4319 13 a a DT 19613 4319 14 more more RBR 19613 4319 15 reserved reserved JJ 19613 4319 16 attitude attitude NN 19613 4319 17 towards towards IN 19613 4319 18 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4319 19 , , , 19613 4319 20 though though IN 19613 4319 21 in in IN 19613 4319 22 the the DT 19613 4319 23 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 4319 24 struggle struggle NN 19613 4319 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4319 26 could could MD 19613 4319 27 not not RB 19613 4319 28 dispense dispense VB 19613 4319 29 with with IN 19613 4319 30 the the DT 19613 4319 31 tradition tradition NN 19613 4319 32 of of IN 19613 4319 33 the the DT 19613 4319 34 Roman roman JJ 19613 4319 35 community community NN 19613 4319 36 . . . 19613 4320 1 In in IN 19613 4320 2 the the DT 19613 4320 3 veil veil JJ 19613 4320 4 dispute dispute NN 19613 4320 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4320 6 de de FW 19613 4320 7 virg virg NNS 19613 4320 8 . . . 19613 4321 1 vel vel NNP 19613 4321 2 . . . 19613 4322 1 2 2 LS 19613 4322 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4322 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4322 4 opposed oppose VBD 19613 4322 5 the the DT 19613 4322 6 authority authority NN 19613 4322 7 of of IN 19613 4322 8 the the DT 19613 4322 9 Greek greek JJ 19613 4322 10 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 4322 11 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4322 12 to to IN 19613 4322 13 that that DT 19613 4322 14 of of IN 19613 4322 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4322 16 . . . 19613 4323 1 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 4323 2 had have VBD 19613 4323 3 done do VBN 19613 4323 4 the the DT 19613 4323 5 same same JJ 19613 4323 6 against against IN 19613 4323 7 Anicetus Anicetus NNP 19613 4323 8 , , , 19613 4323 9 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 19613 4323 10 against against IN 19613 4323 11 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4323 12 , , , 19613 4323 13 Proculus Proculus NNP 19613 4323 14 against against IN 19613 4323 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4323 16 Roman roman JJ 19613 4323 17 opponents opponent NNS 19613 4323 18 . . . 19613 4324 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 4324 2 , , , 19613 4324 3 Praxeas Praxeas NNPS 19613 4324 4 in in IN 19613 4324 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4324 6 appeal appeal NN 19613 4324 7 to to IN 19613 4324 8 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 19613 4324 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4324 10 c. c. NNP 19613 4324 11 1 1 CD 19613 4324 12 . . . 19613 4324 13 : : : 19613 4324 14 " " `` 19613 4324 15 præcessorum præcessorum NNP 19613 4324 16 auctoritates auctoritates NNPS 19613 4324 17 " " '' 19613 4324 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4324 19 , , , 19613 4324 20 Caius Caius NNP 19613 4324 21 when when WRB 19613 4324 22 contending contend VBG 19613 4324 23 with with IN 19613 4324 24 Proculus Proculus NNP 19613 4324 25 , , , 19613 4324 26 the the DT 19613 4324 27 Carthaginian carthaginian JJ 19613 4324 28 clergy clergy NN 19613 4324 29 when when WRB 19613 4324 30 opposing oppose VBG 19613 4324 31 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4324 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4324 33 in in IN 19613 4324 34 the the DT 19613 4324 35 veil veil JJ 19613 4324 36 dispute dispute NN 19613 4324 37 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4324 38 , , , 19613 4324 39 and and CC 19613 4324 40 Victor Victor NNP 19613 4324 41 when when WRB 19613 4324 42 contending contend VBG 19613 4324 43 with with IN 19613 4324 44 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 19613 4324 45 set set VBD 19613 4324 46 the the DT 19613 4324 47 authority authority NN 19613 4324 48 of of IN 19613 4324 49 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4324 50 against against IN 19613 4324 51 that that DT 19613 4324 52 of of IN 19613 4324 53 the the DT 19613 4324 54 Greek greek JJ 19613 4324 55 apostolic apostolic NN 19613 4324 56 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4324 57 . . . 19613 4325 1 These these DT 19613 4325 2 struggles struggle NNS 19613 4325 3 at at IN 19613 4325 4 the the DT 19613 4325 5 transition transition NN 19613 4325 6 from from IN 19613 4325 7 the the DT 19613 4325 8 and and CC 19613 4325 9 to to IN 19613 4325 10 the the DT 19613 4325 11 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4325 12 century century NN 19613 4325 13 are be VBP 19613 4325 14 of of IN 19613 4325 15 the the DT 19613 4325 16 utmost utmost JJ 19613 4325 17 importance importance NN 19613 4325 18 . . . 19613 4326 1 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4326 2 was be VBD 19613 4326 3 here here RB 19613 4326 4 seeking seek VBG 19613 4326 5 to to TO 19613 4326 6 overthrow overthrow VB 19613 4326 7 the the DT 19613 4326 8 authority authority NN 19613 4326 9 of of IN 19613 4326 10 the the DT 19613 4326 11 only only JJ 19613 4326 12 group group NN 19613 4326 13 of of IN 19613 4326 14 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4326 15 able able JJ 19613 4326 16 to to TO 19613 4326 17 enter enter VB 19613 4326 18 into into IN 19613 4326 19 rivalry rivalry NN 19613 4326 20 with with IN 19613 4326 21 her -PRON- PRP 19613 4326 22 those those DT 19613 4326 23 of of IN 19613 4326 24 Asia Asia NNP 19613 4326 25 Minor Minor NNP 19613 4326 26 , , , 19613 4326 27 and and CC 19613 4326 28 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 4326 29 in in IN 19613 4326 30 the the DT 19613 4326 31 attempt attempt NN 19613 4326 32 . . . 19613 4326 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4327 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4327 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4327 3 334 334 CD 19613 4327 4 : : : 19613 4327 5 De De NNP 19613 4327 6 pudic pudic JJ 19613 4327 7 . . . 19613 4328 1 21 21 CD 19613 4328 2 : : : 19613 4328 3 " " `` 19613 4328 4 De De NNP 19613 4328 5 tua tua NNP 19613 4328 6 nunc nunc JJ 19613 4328 7 sententia sententia NNP 19613 4328 8 quæro quæro NNP 19613 4328 9 , , , 19613 4328 10 unde unde NNP 19613 4328 11 hoc hoc FW 19613 4328 12 ius ius NNP 19613 4328 13 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ JJ 19613 4328 14 usurpes usurpe NNS 19613 4328 15 . . . 19613 4329 1 Si si NN 19613 4329 2 quia quia NN 19613 4329 3 dixerit dixerit NNP 19613 4329 4 Petro Petro NNP 19613 4329 5 dominus dominus NN 19613 4329 6 : : : 19613 4329 7 Super Super NNP 19613 4329 8 hanc hanc NN 19613 4329 9 petram petram NN 19613 4329 10 ædificabo ædificabo NNP 19613 4329 11 ecclesiam ecclesiam NNP 19613 4329 12 meam meam NNP 19613 4329 13 , , , 19613 4329 14 tibi tibi NNP 19613 4329 15 dedi dedi NN 19613 4329 16 claves clave VBZ 19613 4329 17 regni regni NNP 19613 4329 18 cælestis cælestis NNP 19613 4329 19 , , , 19613 4329 20 vel vel NNP 19613 4329 21 , , , 19613 4329 22 Quæcumque Quæcumque NNP 19613 4329 23 alligaveris alligaveris NNP 19613 4329 24 vel vel NNP 19613 4329 25 solveris solveris NNP 19613 4329 26 in in IN 19613 4329 27 terra terra NNP 19613 4329 28 , , , 19613 4329 29 erunt erunt NNP 19613 4329 30 alligata alligata NNP 19613 4329 31 vel vel NNP 19613 4329 32 soluta soluta NNP 19613 4329 33 in in IN 19613 4329 34 coelis coelis NNP 19613 4329 35 , , , 19613 4329 36 i -PRON- PRP 19613 4329 37 d d NNP 19613 4329 38 circo circo NNP 19613 4329 39 præsumis præsumis NNP 19613 4329 40 et et FW 19613 4329 41 ad ad NN 19613 4329 42 te te NNP 19613 4329 43 derivasse derivasse NNP 19613 4329 44 solvendi solvendi NNP 19613 4329 45 et et NNP 19613 4329 46 alligandi alligandi NNP 19613 4329 47 potestatem potestatem NN 19613 4329 48 ? ? . 19613 4329 49 " " '' 19613 4330 1 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 4330 2 did do VBD 19613 4330 3 the the DT 19613 4330 4 same same JJ 19613 4330 5 ; ; : 19613 4330 6 see see VB 19613 4330 7 Firmilian Firmilian NNP 19613 4330 8 in in IN 19613 4330 9 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 4330 10 ep ep NNP 19613 4330 11 . . . 19613 4331 1 75 75 CD 19613 4331 2 . . . 19613 4332 1 With with IN 19613 4332 2 this this DT 19613 4332 3 should should MD 19613 4332 4 be be VB 19613 4332 5 compared compare VBN 19613 4332 6 the the DT 19613 4332 7 description description NN 19613 4332 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 4332 9 of of IN 19613 4332 10 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4332 11 gives give VBZ 19613 4332 12 in in IN 19613 4332 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4332 14 epistles epistle NNS 19613 4332 15 to to IN 19613 4332 16 James James NNP 19613 4332 17 of of IN 19613 4332 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4332 19 own own JJ 19613 4332 20 installation installation NN 19613 4332 21 by by IN 19613 4332 22 Peter Peter NNP 19613 4332 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4332 24 c. c. NNP 19613 4332 25 2 2 CD 19613 4332 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4332 27 . . . 19613 4333 1 The the DT 19613 4333 2 following follow VBG 19613 4333 3 words word NNS 19613 4333 4 are be VBP 19613 4333 5 put put VBN 19613 4333 6 in in IN 19613 4333 7 Peter Peter NNP 19613 4333 8 's 's POS 19613 4333 9 mouth mouth NN 19613 4333 10 : : : 19613 4333 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4333 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4333 13 : : : 19613 4333 14 klêmenta klêmenta NNP 19613 4333 15 touton touton NNP 19613 4333 16 episkopon episkopon NNP 19613 4333 17 humin humin NNP 19613 4333 18 cheirontonô cheirontonô NNP 19613 4333 19 , , , 19613 4333 20 hô hô NNP 19613 4333 21 tên tên NNP 19613 4333 22 emên emên NNP 19613 4333 23 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4333 24 logôn logôn NNP 19613 4333 25 pisteuô pisteuô VBZ 19613 4333 26 kathedran kathedran NNP 19613 4333 27 ... ... : 19613 4333 28 dia dia NNP 19613 4333 29 autô autô NNP 19613 4333 30 metadidômi metadidômi NNP 19613 4333 31 tên tên NNP 19613 4333 32 exousian exousian NNP 19613 4333 33 tou tou NNP 19613 4333 34 desmeuein desmeuein NNP 19613 4333 35 kai kai NNP 19613 4333 36 luein luein NNP 19613 4333 37 , , , 19613 4333 38 hina hina NNP 19613 4333 39 peri peri NNP 19613 4333 40 pantos pantos NNP 19613 4333 41 ou ou NNP 19613 4333 42 an an DT 19613 4333 43 cheirotonêsê cheirotonêsê NN 19613 4333 44 epi epi NNP 19613 4333 45 gês gês NNP 19613 4333 46 estai estai NNP 19613 4333 47 dedogmatismenon dedogmatismenon NNP 19613 4333 48 en en IN 19613 4333 49 ouranois ouranois NNP 19613 4333 50 . . . 19613 4334 1 dêsei dêsei NNP 19613 4334 2 gar gar NNP 19613 4334 3 ho ho NNP 19613 4334 4 dei dei NNP 19613 4334 5 dethênai dethênai NNP 19613 4334 6 kai kai NNP 19613 4334 7 lusei lusei NNP 19613 4334 8 ho ho NNP 19613 4334 9 dei dei NNP 19613 4334 10 luthênai luthênai NNP 19613 4334 11 , , , 19613 4334 12 hôs hôs NNP 19613 4334 13 ton ton NN 19613 4334 14 tês tês NNP 19613 4334 15 ekklêsias ekklêsias NNP 19613 4334 16 eidôs eidôs NNP 19613 4334 17 kanona kanona NNP 19613 4334 18 . . . 19613 4334 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4334 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4335 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4335 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4335 3 335 335 CD 19613 4335 4 : : : 19613 4335 5 See see VB 19613 4335 6 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4335 7 of of IN 19613 4335 8 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 4335 9 's 's POS 19613 4335 10 letter letter NN 19613 4335 11 to to IN 19613 4335 12 the the DT 19613 4335 13 Roman roman JJ 19613 4335 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 4335 15 Stephen Stephen NNP 19613 4335 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4335 17 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4335 18 . . NNP 19613 4335 19 , , , 19613 4335 20 H. H. NNP 19613 4335 21 E. E. NNP 19613 4335 22 VII VII NNP 19613 4335 23 . . . 19613 4336 1 5 5 CD 19613 4336 2 . . . 19613 4337 1 2 2 LS 19613 4337 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4337 3 : : : 19613 4337 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4337 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4337 6 : : : 19613 4337 7 Hai Hai NNP 19613 4337 8 mentoi mentoi NNP 19613 4337 9 Suriai Suriai NNP 19613 4337 10 holai holai NNP 19613 4337 11 kai kai NNP 19613 4337 12 hê hê NNP 19613 4337 13 Arabia Arabia NNP 19613 4337 14 , , , 19613 4337 15 ois ois NNP 19613 4337 16 eparkeite eparkeite NNP 19613 4337 17 hekastote hekastote NNP 19613 4337 18 kai kai NNP 19613 4337 19 ois ois NNP 19613 4337 20 nun nun NNP 19613 4337 21 epesteilate epesteilate NN 19613 4337 22 . . . 19613 4337 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4337 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4338 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4338 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4338 3 336 336 CD 19613 4338 4 : : : 19613 4338 5 In in IN 19613 4338 6 the the DT 19613 4338 7 case case NN 19613 4338 8 of of IN 19613 4338 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4338 10 's 's POS 19613 4338 11 condemnation condemnation NN 19613 4338 12 the the DT 19613 4338 13 decision decision NN 19613 4338 14 of of IN 19613 4338 15 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4338 16 seems seem VBZ 19613 4338 17 to to TO 19613 4338 18 have have VB 19613 4338 19 been be VBN 19613 4338 20 of of IN 19613 4338 21 special special JJ 19613 4338 22 importance importance NN 19613 4338 23 . . . 19613 4339 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4339 2 sought seek VBD 19613 4339 3 to to TO 19613 4339 4 defend defend VB 19613 4339 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4339 6 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 4339 7 in in IN 19613 4339 8 a a DT 19613 4339 9 letter letter NN 19613 4339 10 written write VBN 19613 4339 11 by by IN 19613 4339 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4339 13 own own JJ 19613 4339 14 hand hand NN 19613 4339 15 to to IN 19613 4339 16 the the DT 19613 4339 17 Roman roman JJ 19613 4339 18 bishop bishop NN 19613 4339 19 Fabian Fabian NNP 19613 4339 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4339 21 see see VB 19613 4339 22 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4339 23 . . NNP 19613 4339 24 , , , 19613 4339 25 H. H. NNP 19613 4339 26 E. E. NNP 19613 4339 27 VI VI NNP 19613 4339 28 . . . 19613 4340 1 36 36 CD 19613 4340 2 ; ; : 19613 4340 3 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 4340 4 , , , 19613 4340 5 ep ep NNP 19613 4340 6 . . . 19613 4341 1 84 84 CD 19613 4341 2 . . . 19613 4342 1 10 10 LS 19613 4342 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4342 3 . . . 19613 4343 1 The the DT 19613 4343 2 Roman roman JJ 19613 4343 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 4343 4 Pontian Pontian NNP 19613 4343 5 had have VBD 19613 4343 6 previously previously RB 19613 4343 7 condemned condemn VBN 19613 4343 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4343 9 after after IN 19613 4343 10 summoning summon VBG 19613 4343 11 a a DT 19613 4343 12 " " `` 19613 4343 13 senate senate NNP 19613 4343 14 ; ; : 19613 4343 15 " " '' 19613 4343 16 see see VB 19613 4343 17 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 4343 18 , , , 19613 4343 19 ep ep NNP 19613 4343 20 . . . 19613 4344 1 33 33 CD 19613 4344 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4344 3 Döllinger Döllinger NNP 19613 4344 4 , , , 19613 4344 5 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4344 6 and and CC 19613 4344 7 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 4344 8 , , , 19613 4344 9 p. p. NN 19613 4344 10 259 259 CD 19613 4344 11 f. f. NN 19613 4344 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4344 13 . . . 19613 4345 1 Further further RB 19613 4345 2 , , , 19613 4345 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4345 4 is be VBZ 19613 4345 5 an an DT 19613 4345 6 important important JJ 19613 4345 7 fact fact NN 19613 4345 8 that that IN 19613 4345 9 a a DT 19613 4345 10 deputation deputation NN 19613 4345 11 of of IN 19613 4345 12 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 4345 13 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4345 14 , , , 19613 4345 15 who who WP 19613 4345 16 did do VBD 19613 4345 17 not not RB 19613 4345 18 agree agree VB 19613 4345 19 with with IN 19613 4345 20 the the DT 19613 4345 21 Christology christology NN 19613 4345 22 of of IN 19613 4345 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4345 24 bishop bishop NN 19613 4345 25 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4345 26 , , , 19613 4345 27 repaired repair VBN 19613 4345 28 to to IN 19613 4345 29 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4345 30 to to IN 19613 4345 31 the the DT 19613 4345 32 _ _ NNP 19613 4345 33 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4345 34 _ _ NNP 19613 4345 35 bishop bishop NN 19613 4345 36 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4345 37 and and CC 19613 4345 38 formally formally RB 19613 4345 39 accused accuse VBD 19613 4345 40 the the DT 19613 4345 41 first first JJ 19613 4345 42 named name VBN 19613 4345 43 prelate prelate NN 19613 4345 44 . . . 19613 4346 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4346 2 is be VBZ 19613 4346 3 also also RB 19613 4346 4 significant significant JJ 19613 4346 5 that that IN 19613 4346 6 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 4346 7 received receive VBD 19613 4346 8 this this DT 19613 4346 9 complaint complaint NN 19613 4346 10 and and CC 19613 4346 11 brought bring VBD 19613 4346 12 the the DT 19613 4346 13 matter matter NN 19613 4346 14 up up RP 19613 4346 15 at at IN 19613 4346 16 a a DT 19613 4346 17 Roman roman JJ 19613 4346 18 synod synod NN 19613 4346 19 . . . 19613 4347 1 No no DT 19613 4347 2 objection objection NN 19613 4347 3 was be VBD 19613 4347 4 taken take VBN 19613 4347 5 to to IN 19613 4347 6 this this DT 19613 4347 7 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 4347 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4347 9 Athanas Athanas NNP 19613 4347 10 . . . 19613 4347 11 , , , 19613 4347 12 de de NNP 19613 4347 13 synod synod NNP 19613 4347 14 . . . 19613 4347 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4347 16 . . . 19613 4348 1 This this DT 19613 4348 2 information information NN 19613 4348 3 is be VBZ 19613 4348 4 very very RB 19613 4348 5 instructive instructive JJ 19613 4348 6 , , , 19613 4348 7 for for IN 19613 4348 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4348 9 proves prove VBZ 19613 4348 10 that that IN 19613 4348 11 the the DT 19613 4348 12 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4348 13 Church Church NNP 19613 4348 14 was be VBD 19613 4348 15 ever ever RB 19613 4348 16 regarded regard VBN 19613 4348 17 as as RB 19613 4348 18 specially specially RB 19613 4348 19 charged charge VBN 19613 4348 20 with with IN 19613 4348 21 watching watch VBG 19613 4348 22 over over IN 19613 4348 23 the the DT 19613 4348 24 observance observance NN 19613 4348 25 of of IN 19613 4348 26 the the DT 19613 4348 27 conditions condition NNS 19613 4348 28 of of IN 19613 4348 29 the the DT 19613 4348 30 general general NNP 19613 4348 31 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical NNP 19613 4348 32 federation federation NNP 19613 4348 33 , , , 19613 4348 34 the the DT 19613 4348 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4348 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4348 37 : : : 19613 4348 38 koinê koinê NNP 19613 4348 39 henôsis henôsis NNP 19613 4348 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4348 41 . . . 19613 4349 1 As as IN 19613 4349 2 to to IN 19613 4349 3 the the DT 19613 4349 4 fact fact NN 19613 4349 5 that that IN 19613 4349 6 in in IN 19613 4349 7 circular circular JJ 19613 4349 8 letters letter NNS 19613 4349 9 , , , 19613 4349 10 not not RB 19613 4349 11 excepting except VBG 19613 4349 12 Eastern eastern JJ 19613 4349 13 ones one NNS 19613 4349 14 , , , 19613 4349 15 the the DT 19613 4349 16 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4349 17 Church Church NNP 19613 4349 18 was be VBD 19613 4349 19 put put VBN 19613 4349 20 at at IN 19613 4349 21 the the DT 19613 4349 22 head head NN 19613 4349 23 of of IN 19613 4349 24 the the DT 19613 4349 25 address address NN 19613 4349 26 , , , 19613 4349 27 see see VB 19613 4349 28 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4349 29 . . NNP 19613 4349 30 , , , 19613 4349 31 H. H. NNP 19613 4349 32 E. E. NNP 19613 4349 33 VII VII NNP 19613 4349 34 . . . 19613 4350 1 30 30 CD 19613 4350 2 . . . 19613 4351 1 How how WRB 19613 4351 2 frequently frequently RB 19613 4351 3 foreign foreign JJ 19613 4351 4 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4351 5 came come VBD 19613 4351 6 to to IN 19613 4351 7 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4351 8 is be VBZ 19613 4351 9 shown show VBN 19613 4351 10 by by IN 19613 4351 11 the the DT 19613 4351 12 19th 19th JJ 19613 4351 13 canon canon NN 19613 4351 14 of of IN 19613 4351 15 Arles Arles NNP 19613 4351 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4351 17 A.D. A.D. NNP 19613 4351 18 314 314 CD 19613 4351 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4351 20 : : : 19613 4351 21 " " `` 19613 4351 22 De De NNP 19613 4351 23 episcopis episcopis NN 19613 4351 24 peregrinis peregrini NNS 19613 4351 25 , , , 19613 4351 26 qui qui VBN 19613 4351 27 in in IN 19613 4351 28 urbem urbem NNS 19613 4351 29 solent solent NN 19613 4351 30 venire venire NNP 19613 4351 31 , , , 19613 4351 32 placuit placuit NN 19613 4351 33 iis iis NNP 19613 4351 34 locum locum NNP 19613 4351 35 dari dari NNP 19613 4351 36 ut ut UH 19613 4351 37 offerant offerant JJ 19613 4351 38 . . . 19613 4351 39 " " '' 19613 4352 1 The the DT 19613 4352 2 first first JJ 19613 4352 3 canon canon NN 19613 4352 4 is be VBZ 19613 4352 5 also also RB 19613 4352 6 important important JJ 19613 4352 7 in in IN 19613 4352 8 deciding decide VBG 19613 4352 9 the the DT 19613 4352 10 special special JJ 19613 4352 11 position position NN 19613 4352 12 of of IN 19613 4352 13 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4352 14 . . . 19613 4352 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4353 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4353 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4353 3 337 337 CD 19613 4353 4 : : : 19613 4353 5 Peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4353 6 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 4353 7 , , , 19613 4353 8 which which WDT 19613 4353 9 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 4353 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4353 11 can can MD 19613 4353 12 not not RB 19613 4353 13 quite quite RB 19613 4353 14 explain explain VB 19613 4353 15 , , , 19613 4353 16 are be VBP 19613 4353 17 connected connect VBN 19613 4353 18 with with IN 19613 4353 19 the the DT 19613 4353 20 cases case NNS 19613 4353 21 discussed discuss VBN 19613 4353 22 by by IN 19613 4353 23 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 4353 24 in in IN 19613 4353 25 epp epp NNP 19613 4353 26 . . . 19613 4354 1 67 67 CD 19613 4354 2 and and CC 19613 4354 3 68 68 CD 19613 4354 4 . . . 19613 4355 1 The the DT 19613 4355 2 Roman roman JJ 19613 4355 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 4355 4 must must MD 19613 4355 5 have have VB 19613 4355 6 had have VBN 19613 4355 7 the the DT 19613 4355 8 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 4355 9 power power NN 19613 4355 10 of of IN 19613 4355 11 dealing deal VBG 19613 4355 12 with with IN 19613 4355 13 the the DT 19613 4355 14 bishop bishop NN 19613 4355 15 of of IN 19613 4355 16 Arles Arles NNPS 19613 4355 17 , , , 19613 4355 18 whereas whereas IN 19613 4355 19 the the DT 19613 4355 20 Gallic Gallic NNP 19613 4355 21 prelates prelate NNS 19613 4355 22 had have VBD 19613 4355 23 not not RB 19613 4355 24 this this DT 19613 4355 25 right right NN 19613 4355 26 . . . 19613 4356 1 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 4356 2 , , , 19613 4356 3 p. p. NN 19613 4356 4 391 391 CD 19613 4356 5 ff ff NNP 19613 4356 6 . . NNP 19613 4356 7 , , , 19613 4356 8 assumes assume VBZ 19613 4356 9 that that IN 19613 4356 10 the the DT 19613 4356 11 Roman roman JJ 19613 4356 12 bishop bishop NN 19613 4356 13 alone alone RB 19613 4356 14 -- -- : 19613 4356 15 not not RB 19613 4356 16 Cyprian cyprian JJ 19613 4356 17 or or CC 19613 4356 18 the the DT 19613 4356 19 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4356 20 of of IN 19613 4356 21 Gaul Gaul NNP 19613 4356 22 -- -- : 19613 4356 23 had have VBD 19613 4356 24 authority authority NN 19613 4356 25 to to TO 19613 4356 26 exclude exclude VB 19613 4356 27 the the DT 19613 4356 28 bishop bishop NN 19613 4356 29 of of IN 19613 4356 30 Arles Arles NNPS 19613 4356 31 from from IN 19613 4356 32 the the DT 19613 4356 33 general general JJ 19613 4356 34 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 4356 35 of of IN 19613 4356 36 the the DT 19613 4356 37 Church Church NNP 19613 4356 38 , , , 19613 4356 39 but but CC 19613 4356 40 that that IN 19613 4356 41 , , , 19613 4356 42 as as RB 19613 4356 43 far far RB 19613 4356 44 as as IN 19613 4356 45 the the DT 19613 4356 46 Gallic Gallic NNP 19613 4356 47 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4356 48 were be VBD 19613 4356 49 concerned concern VBN 19613 4356 50 , , , 19613 4356 51 such such PDT 19613 4356 52 an an DT 19613 4356 53 excommunication excommunication NN 19613 4356 54 possessed possess VBD 19613 4356 55 no no DT 19613 4356 56 legal legal JJ 19613 4356 57 effect effect NN 19613 4356 58 , , , 19613 4356 59 but but CC 19613 4356 60 only only RB 19613 4356 61 a a DT 19613 4356 62 moral moral JJ 19613 4356 63 one one NN 19613 4356 64 , , , 19613 4356 65 because because IN 19613 4356 66 in in IN 19613 4356 67 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4356 68 case case NN 19613 4356 69 the the DT 19613 4356 70 bishop bishop NN 19613 4356 71 of of IN 19613 4356 72 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4356 73 had have VBD 19613 4356 74 only only RB 19613 4356 75 a a DT 19613 4356 76 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4356 77 authority authority NN 19613 4356 78 and and CC 19613 4356 79 no no DT 19613 4356 80 legal legal JJ 19613 4356 81 power power NN 19613 4356 82 . . . 19613 4357 1 Further further RB 19613 4357 2 , , , 19613 4357 3 two two CD 19613 4357 4 Spanish spanish JJ 19613 4357 5 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4357 6 publicly publicly RB 19613 4357 7 appealed appeal VBD 19613 4357 8 to to IN 19613 4357 9 the the DT 19613 4357 10 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4357 11 see see VB 19613 4357 12 against against IN 19613 4357 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4357 14 deposition deposition NN 19613 4357 15 , , , 19613 4357 16 and and CC 19613 4357 17 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 4357 18 regarded regard VBD 19613 4357 19 this this DT 19613 4357 20 appeal appeal NN 19613 4357 21 as as IN 19613 4357 22 in in IN 19613 4357 23 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4357 24 correct correct JJ 19613 4357 25 . . . 19613 4358 1 Finally finally RB 19613 4358 2 , , , 19613 4358 3 Cornelius Cornelius NNP 19613 4358 4 says say VBZ 19613 4358 5 of of IN 19613 4358 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4358 7 in in IN 19613 4358 8 a a DT 19613 4358 9 letter letter NN 19613 4358 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4358 11 in in IN 19613 4358 12 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4358 13 . . NNP 19613 4358 14 , , , 19613 4358 15 H. H. NNP 19613 4358 16 E. E. NNP 19613 4358 17 VI VI NNP 19613 4358 18 . . . 19613 4359 1 43 43 CD 19613 4359 2 . . . 19613 4360 1 10 10 CD 19613 4360 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4360 3 : : : 19613 4360 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4360 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4360 6 : : : 19613 4360 7 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4360 8 loipôn loipôn NNP 19613 4360 9 episkopôn episkopôn NNP 19613 4360 10 diadochous diadochous NNP 19613 4360 11 eis eis NNP 19613 4360 12 tous tous NNP 19613 4360 13 topous topous NNP 19613 4360 14 , , , 19613 4360 15 en en NNP 19613 4360 16 hois hois NNP 19613 4360 17 êsan êsan NNP 19613 4360 18 , , , 19613 4360 19 cheirotonêsantes cheirotonêsante VBZ 19613 4360 20 apestalkamen apestalkaman NNS 19613 4360 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4360 22 . . . 19613 4361 1 This this DT 19613 4361 2 quotation quotation NN 19613 4361 3 refers refer VBZ 19613 4361 4 to to IN 19613 4361 5 Italy Italy NNP 19613 4361 6 , , , 19613 4361 7 and and CC 19613 4361 8 the the DT 19613 4361 9 passage passage NN 19613 4361 10 , , , 19613 4361 11 which which WDT 19613 4361 12 must must MD 19613 4361 13 be be VB 19613 4361 14 read read VBN 19613 4361 15 connectedly connectedly RB 19613 4361 16 , , , 19613 4361 17 makes make VBZ 19613 4361 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4361 19 plain plain JJ 19613 4361 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4361 21 see see VB 19613 4361 22 , , , 19613 4361 23 besides besides RB 19613 4361 24 , , , 19613 4361 25 the the DT 19613 4361 26 quotation quotation NN 19613 4361 27 in in IN 19613 4361 28 reference reference NN 19613 4361 29 to to IN 19613 4361 30 Calixtus Calixtus NNP 19613 4361 31 given give VBN 19613 4361 32 above above RB 19613 4361 33 on on IN 19613 4361 34 p. p. NN 19613 4361 35 162 162 CD 19613 4361 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4361 37 , , , 19613 4361 38 that that IN 19613 4361 39 , , , 19613 4361 40 before before IN 19613 4361 41 the the DT 19613 4361 42 middle middle NN 19613 4361 43 of of IN 19613 4361 44 the the DT 19613 4361 45 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4361 46 century century NN 19613 4361 47 , , , 19613 4361 48 the the DT 19613 4361 49 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4361 50 Church Church NNP 19613 4361 51 already already RB 19613 4361 52 possessed possess VBD 19613 4361 53 a a DT 19613 4361 54 legal legal JJ 19613 4361 55 right right NN 19613 4361 56 of of IN 19613 4361 57 excommunication excommunication NN 19613 4361 58 and and CC 19613 4361 59 the the DT 19613 4361 60 recognised recognise VBN 19613 4361 61 power power NN 19613 4361 62 of of IN 19613 4361 63 making make VBG 19613 4361 64 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4361 65 appointments appointment NNS 19613 4361 66 as as RB 19613 4361 67 far far RB 19613 4361 68 as as IN 19613 4361 69 the the DT 19613 4361 70 communities community NNS 19613 4361 71 and and CC 19613 4361 72 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4361 73 in in IN 19613 4361 74 Italy Italy NNP 19613 4361 75 were be VBD 19613 4361 76 concerned concern VBN 19613 4361 77 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4361 78 see see VB 19613 4361 79 Sohm Sohm NNP 19613 4361 80 , , , 19613 4361 81 p. p. NN 19613 4361 82 389 389 CD 19613 4361 83 ff ff NN 19613 4361 84 . . . 19613 4361 85 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4361 86 . . . 19613 4361 87 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4362 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4362 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4362 3 338 338 CD 19613 4362 4 : : : 19613 4362 5 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4362 6 . . NNP 19613 4362 7 , , , 19613 4362 8 H. H. NNP 19613 4362 9 E. E. NNP 19613 4362 10 VII VII NNP 19613 4362 11 . . . 19613 4363 1 30 30 CD 19613 4363 2 . . . 19613 4364 1 19 19 CD 19613 4364 2 . . . 19613 4365 1 The the DT 19613 4365 2 Church Church NNP 19613 4365 3 of of IN 19613 4365 4 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4365 5 sought seek VBD 19613 4365 6 to to TO 19613 4365 7 enter enter VB 19613 4365 8 upon upon IN 19613 4365 9 an an DT 19613 4365 10 independent independent JJ 19613 4365 11 line line NN 19613 4365 12 of of IN 19613 4365 13 development development NN 19613 4365 14 under under IN 19613 4365 15 Paul Paul NNP 19613 4365 16 of of IN 19613 4365 17 Samosata Samosata NNP 19613 4365 18 . . . 19613 4366 1 Paul Paul NNP 19613 4366 2 's 's POS 19613 4366 3 fall fall NN 19613 4366 4 was be VBD 19613 4366 5 the the DT 19613 4366 6 victory victory NN 19613 4366 7 of of IN 19613 4366 8 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4366 9 . . . 19613 4367 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4367 2 may may MD 19613 4367 3 suppose suppose VB 19613 4367 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4367 5 to to TO 19613 4367 6 be be VB 19613 4367 7 highly highly RB 19613 4367 8 probable probable JJ 19613 4367 9 , , , 19613 4367 10 though though RB 19613 4367 11 to to IN 19613 4367 12 the the DT 19613 4367 13 best good JJS 19613 4367 14 of of IN 19613 4367 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4367 16 belief belief NN 19613 4367 17 there there EX 19613 4367 18 is be VBZ 19613 4367 19 for for IN 19613 4367 20 the the DT 19613 4367 21 present present JJ 19613 4367 22 no no DT 19613 4367 23 sure sure JJ 19613 4367 24 proof proof NN 19613 4367 25 , , , 19613 4367 26 that that IN 19613 4367 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4367 28 was be VBD 19613 4367 29 not not RB 19613 4367 30 till till IN 19613 4367 31 then then RB 19613 4367 32 that that IN 19613 4367 33 the the DT 19613 4367 34 Roman roman JJ 19613 4367 35 standards standard NNS 19613 4367 36 and and CC 19613 4367 37 sacraments sacrament NNS 19613 4367 38 , , , 19613 4367 39 catholic catholic NNP 19613 4367 40 and and CC 19613 4367 41 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 4367 42 collection collection NN 19613 4367 43 of of IN 19613 4367 44 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 4367 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4367 46 see see VB 19613 4367 47 , , , 19613 4367 48 on on IN 19613 4367 49 the the DT 19613 4367 50 contrary contrary NN 19613 4367 51 , , , 19613 4367 52 the the DT 19613 4367 53 use use NN 19613 4367 54 of of IN 19613 4367 55 Scripture scripture NN 19613 4367 56 in in IN 19613 4367 57 the the DT 19613 4367 58 Didaskalia Didaskalia NNP 19613 4367 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4367 60 , , , 19613 4367 61 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 4367 62 rule rule NN 19613 4367 63 of of IN 19613 4367 64 faith faith NN 19613 4367 65 , , , 19613 4367 66 and and CC 19613 4367 67 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 4367 68 episcopacy episcopacy NNP 19613 4367 69 attained attain VBD 19613 4367 70 supremacy supremacy NN 19613 4367 71 in in IN 19613 4367 72 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4367 73 ; ; : 19613 4367 74 but but CC 19613 4367 75 that that IN 19613 4367 76 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4367 77 began begin VBD 19613 4367 78 to to TO 19613 4367 79 be be VB 19613 4367 80 introduced introduce VBN 19613 4367 81 into into IN 19613 4367 82 that that DT 19613 4367 83 city city NN 19613 4367 84 about about IN 19613 4367 85 the the DT 19613 4367 86 time time NN 19613 4367 87 of of IN 19613 4367 88 Serapion Serapion NNP 19613 4367 89 's 's POS 19613 4367 90 bishopric bishopric NN 19613 4367 91 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4367 92 that that RB 19613 4367 93 is is RB 19613 4367 94 , , , 19613 4367 95 during during IN 19613 4367 96 the the DT 19613 4367 97 Easter Easter NNP 19613 4367 98 controversy controversy NN 19613 4367 99 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4367 100 . . . 19613 4368 1 The the DT 19613 4368 2 old old JJ 19613 4368 3 records record NNS 19613 4368 4 of of IN 19613 4368 5 the the DT 19613 4368 6 Church Church NNP 19613 4368 7 of of IN 19613 4368 8 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 4368 9 have have VBP 19613 4368 10 an an DT 19613 4368 11 important important JJ 19613 4368 12 bearing bearing NN 19613 4368 13 on on IN 19613 4368 14 this this DT 19613 4368 15 point point NN 19613 4368 16 ; ; : 19613 4368 17 and and CC 19613 4368 18 from from IN 19613 4368 19 these these DT 19613 4368 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4368 21 is be VBZ 19613 4368 22 evident evident JJ 19613 4368 23 that that IN 19613 4368 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4368 25 constitution constitution NN 19613 4368 26 did do VBD 19613 4368 27 not not RB 19613 4368 28 begin begin VB 19613 4368 29 to to TO 19613 4368 30 assume assume VB 19613 4368 31 a a DT 19613 4368 32 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 4368 33 form form NN 19613 4368 34 till till IN 19613 4368 35 the the DT 19613 4368 36 beginning beginning NN 19613 4368 37 of of IN 19613 4368 38 the the DT 19613 4368 39 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 4368 40 century century NN 19613 4368 41 , , , 19613 4368 42 and and CC 19613 4368 43 that that IN 19613 4368 44 as as IN 19613 4368 45 the the DT 19613 4368 46 result result NN 19613 4368 47 of of IN 19613 4368 48 connection connection NN 19613 4368 49 with with IN 19613 4368 50 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4368 51 . . . 19613 4369 1 See see VB 19613 4369 2 _ _ NNP 19613 4369 3 the the DT 19613 4369 4 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 4369 5 of of IN 19613 4369 6 Addai Addai NNP 19613 4369 7 _ _ NNP 19613 4369 8 by by IN 19613 4369 9 Phillips Phillips NNP 19613 4369 10 , , , 19613 4369 11 p. p. NN 19613 4369 12 50 50 CD 19613 4369 13 : : : 19613 4369 14 " " `` 19613 4369 15 Palut palut VB 19613 4369 16 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4369 17 went go VBD 19613 4369 18 to to IN 19613 4369 19 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4369 20 and and CC 19613 4369 21 received receive VBD 19613 4369 22 the the DT 19613 4369 23 hand hand NN 19613 4369 24 of of IN 19613 4369 25 the the DT 19613 4369 26 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 4369 27 from from IN 19613 4369 28 Serapion Serapion NNP 19613 4369 29 , , , 19613 4369 30 bishop bishop NN 19613 4369 31 of of IN 19613 4369 32 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4369 33 . . . 19613 4370 1 Serapion serapion NN 19613 4370 2 , , , 19613 4370 3 bishop bishop NN 19613 4370 4 of of IN 19613 4370 5 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4370 6 , , , 19613 4370 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4370 8 also also RB 19613 4370 9 received receive VBD 19613 4370 10 the the DT 19613 4370 11 hand hand NN 19613 4370 12 from from IN 19613 4370 13 Zephyrinus Zephyrinus NNP 19613 4370 14 , , , 19613 4370 15 bishop bishop NN 19613 4370 16 of of IN 19613 4370 17 the the DT 19613 4370 18 city city NN 19613 4370 19 of of IN 19613 4370 20 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4370 21 , , , 19613 4370 22 from from IN 19613 4370 23 the the DT 19613 4370 24 succession succession NN 19613 4370 25 of of IN 19613 4370 26 the the DT 19613 4370 27 hand hand NN 19613 4370 28 of of IN 19613 4370 29 the the DT 19613 4370 30 priesthood priesthood NN 19613 4370 31 of of IN 19613 4370 32 Simon Simon NNP 19613 4370 33 Cephas Cephas NNP 19613 4370 34 , , , 19613 4370 35 which which WDT 19613 4370 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4370 37 received receive VBD 19613 4370 38 from from IN 19613 4370 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4370 40 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4370 41 , , , 19613 4370 42 who who WP 19613 4370 43 was be VBD 19613 4370 44 there there RB 19613 4370 45 bishop bishop NN 19613 4370 46 of of IN 19613 4370 47 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4370 48 25 25 CD 19613 4370 49 years year NNS 19613 4370 50 , , , 19613 4370 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4370 52 sic sic NN 19613 4370 53 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4370 54 in in IN 19613 4370 55 the the DT 19613 4370 56 days day NNS 19613 4370 57 of of IN 19613 4370 58 the the DT 19613 4370 59 Cæsar Cæsar NNP 19613 4370 60 , , , 19613 4370 61 who who WP 19613 4370 62 reigned reign VBD 19613 4370 63 there there RB 19613 4370 64 13 13 CD 19613 4370 65 years year NNS 19613 4370 66 . . . 19613 4370 67 " " '' 19613 4371 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4371 2 See see VB 19613 4371 3 also also RB 19613 4371 4 Tixeront Tixeront NNP 19613 4371 5 , , , 19613 4371 6 _ _ NNP 19613 4371 7 Edesse Edesse NNP 19613 4371 8 _ _ NNP 19613 4371 9 , , , 19613 4371 10 pp pp NNP 19613 4371 11 . . . 19613 4372 1 149 149 CD 19613 4372 2 , , , 19613 4372 3 152 152 CD 19613 4372 4 . . . 19613 4372 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4373 1 Cf cf NN 19613 4373 2 . . . 19613 4374 1 with with IN 19613 4374 2 this this DT 19613 4374 3 the the DT 19613 4374 4 prominence prominence NN 19613 4374 5 given give VBN 19613 4374 6 in in IN 19613 4374 7 the the DT 19613 4374 8 Acts Acts NNPS 19613 4374 9 of of IN 19613 4374 10 Scharbil Scharbil NNP 19613 4374 11 and and CC 19613 4374 12 Barsamya Barsamya NNP 19613 4374 13 to to IN 19613 4374 14 the the DT 19613 4374 15 fact fact NN 19613 4374 16 that that IN 19613 4374 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4374 18 were be VBD 19613 4374 19 contemporaries contemporary NNS 19613 4374 20 of of IN 19613 4374 21 Fabian fabian JJ 19613 4374 22 , , , 19613 4374 23 bishop bishop NN 19613 4374 24 of of IN 19613 4374 25 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4374 26 . . . 19613 4375 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4375 2 read read VBD 19613 4375 3 there there RB 19613 4375 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4375 5 see see VB 19613 4375 6 Rubens Rubens NNP 19613 4375 7 Duval Duval NNP 19613 4375 8 , , , 19613 4375 9 Les Les NNP 19613 4375 10 Actes Actes NNP 19613 4375 11 de de NNP 19613 4375 12 Scharbil Scharbil NNP 19613 4375 13 et et NN 19613 4375 14 les les FW 19613 4375 15 Actes Actes NNP 19613 4375 16 de de FW 19613 4375 17 Barsamya Barsamya NNP 19613 4375 18 , , , 19613 4375 19 Paris Paris NNP 19613 4375 20 , , , 19613 4375 21 1889 1889 CD 19613 4375 22 , , , 19613 4375 23 and and CC 19613 4375 24 Histoire Histoire NNP 19613 4375 25 d'Eclesse d'Eclesse NNP 19613 4375 26 , , , 19613 4375 27 p. p. NN 19613 4375 28 130 130 CD 19613 4375 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4375 30 : : : 19613 4375 31 " " `` 19613 4375 32 Barsamya Barsamya NNP 19613 4375 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4375 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4375 35 was be VBD 19613 4375 36 bishop bishop NN 19613 4375 37 of of IN 19613 4375 38 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 4375 39 at at IN 19613 4375 40 the the DT 19613 4375 41 time time NN 19613 4375 42 of of IN 19613 4375 43 Decius Decius NNP 19613 4375 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4375 45 lived live VBD 19613 4375 46 at at IN 19613 4375 47 the the DT 19613 4375 48 time time NN 19613 4375 49 of of IN 19613 4375 50 Fabian Fabian NNP 19613 4375 51 , , , 19613 4375 52 bishop bishop NN 19613 4375 53 of of IN 19613 4375 54 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4375 55 . . . 19613 4376 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4376 2 had have VBD 19613 4376 3 received receive VBN 19613 4376 4 the the DT 19613 4376 5 laying laying NN 19613 4376 6 on on RP 19613 4376 7 of of IN 19613 4376 8 hands hand NNS 19613 4376 9 from from IN 19613 4376 10 Abschelama Abschelama NNP 19613 4376 11 , , , 19613 4376 12 who who WP 19613 4376 13 had have VBD 19613 4376 14 received receive VBN 19613 4376 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4376 16 from from IN 19613 4376 17 Palut Palut NNP 19613 4376 18 . . . 19613 4377 1 Palut Palut NNP 19613 4377 2 had have VBD 19613 4377 3 been be VBN 19613 4377 4 consecrated consecrate VBN 19613 4377 5 by by IN 19613 4377 6 Serapion serapion NN 19613 4377 7 , , , 19613 4377 8 bishop bishop NN 19613 4377 9 of of IN 19613 4377 10 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4377 11 , , , 19613 4377 12 and and CC 19613 4377 13 the the DT 19613 4377 14 latter latter JJ 19613 4377 15 had have VBD 19613 4377 16 been be VBN 19613 4377 17 consecrated consecrate VBN 19613 4377 18 by by IN 19613 4377 19 Zephyrinus Zephyrinus NNP 19613 4377 20 , , , 19613 4377 21 bishop bishop NN 19613 4377 22 of of IN 19613 4377 23 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4377 24 . . . 19613 4377 25 " " '' 19613 4378 1 As as IN 19613 4378 2 regards regard VBZ 19613 4378 3 the the DT 19613 4378 4 relation relation NN 19613 4378 5 of of IN 19613 4378 6 the the DT 19613 4378 7 State State NNP 19613 4378 8 of of IN 19613 4378 9 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4378 10 to to IN 19613 4378 11 the the DT 19613 4378 12 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4378 13 Church Church NNP 19613 4378 14 , , , 19613 4378 15 that that RB 19613 4378 16 is is RB 19613 4378 17 , , , 19613 4378 18 to to IN 19613 4378 19 the the DT 19613 4378 20 Roman roman JJ 19613 4378 21 bishop bishop NN 19613 4378 22 , , , 19613 4378 23 who who WP 19613 4378 24 by by IN 19613 4378 25 the the DT 19613 4378 26 year year NN 19613 4378 27 250 250 CD 19613 4378 28 had have VBD 19613 4378 29 already already RB 19613 4378 30 become become VBN 19613 4378 31 a a DT 19613 4378 32 sort sort NN 19613 4378 33 of of IN 19613 4378 34 _ _ NNP 19613 4378 35 præfectus præfectus NN 19613 4378 36 urbis urbis JJ 19613 4378 37 _ _ NNP 19613 4378 38 , , , 19613 4378 39 with with IN 19613 4378 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4378 41 district district NN 19613 4378 42 superintendents superintendent NNS 19613 4378 43 , , , 19613 4378 44 the the DT 19613 4378 45 deacons deacon NNS 19613 4378 46 , , , 19613 4378 47 and and CC 19613 4378 48 in in IN 19613 4378 49 fact fact NN 19613 4378 50 a a DT 19613 4378 51 sort sort NN 19613 4378 52 of of IN 19613 4378 53 _ _ NNP 19613 4378 54 princeps princep NNS 19613 4378 55 æmulus æmulu VBD 19613 4378 56 _ _ NNP 19613 4378 57 , , , 19613 4378 58 cf cf NNP 19613 4378 59 . . . 19613 4379 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4379 2 1 1 LS 19613 4379 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4379 4 the the DT 19613 4379 5 recorded record VBN 19613 4379 6 comments comment NNS 19613 4379 7 of of IN 19613 4379 8 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 4379 9 Severus Severus NNP 19613 4379 10 on on IN 19613 4379 11 the the DT 19613 4379 12 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4379 13 , , , 19613 4379 14 and and CC 19613 4379 15 especially especially RB 19613 4379 16 those those DT 19613 4379 17 on on IN 19613 4379 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4379 19 organisation organisation NN 19613 4379 20 ; ; : 19613 4379 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4379 22 2 2 LS 19613 4379 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4379 24 the the DT 19613 4379 25 edict edict NN 19613 4379 26 of of IN 19613 4379 27 Maximinus Maximinus NNP 19613 4379 28 Thrax Thrax NNP 19613 4379 29 and and CC 19613 4379 30 the the DT 19613 4379 31 banishment banishment NN 19613 4379 32 of of IN 19613 4379 33 the the DT 19613 4379 34 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4379 35 Pontian Pontian NNP 19613 4379 36 and and CC 19613 4379 37 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4379 38 ; ; : 19613 4379 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4379 40 3 3 LS 19613 4379 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4379 42 the the DT 19613 4379 43 attitude attitude NN 19613 4379 44 of of IN 19613 4379 45 Philip Philip NNP 19613 4379 46 the the DT 19613 4379 47 Arabian Arabian NNP 19613 4379 48 ; ; : 19613 4379 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4379 50 4 4 LS 19613 4379 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4379 52 the the DT 19613 4379 53 remarks remark NNS 19613 4379 54 of of IN 19613 4379 55 Decius Decius NNP 19613 4379 56 in in IN 19613 4379 57 Cyp Cyp NNP 19613 4379 58 . . . 19613 4380 1 ep ep NNP 19613 4380 2 . . . 19613 4381 1 55 55 CD 19613 4381 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4381 3 see see VB 19613 4381 4 above above IN 19613 4381 5 p. p. NN 19613 4381 6 124 124 CD 19613 4381 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4381 8 and and CC 19613 4381 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4381 10 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 4381 11 against against IN 19613 4381 12 the the DT 19613 4381 13 Roman roman JJ 19613 4381 14 bishops bishop NNS 19613 4381 15 , , , 19613 4381 16 and and CC 19613 4381 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4381 18 5 5 LS 19613 4381 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4381 20 the the DT 19613 4381 21 attitude attitude NN 19613 4381 22 of of IN 19613 4381 23 Aurelian Aurelian NNP 19613 4381 24 in in IN 19613 4381 25 Antioch Antioch NNP 19613 4381 26 . . . 19613 4382 1 On on IN 19613 4382 2 the the DT 19613 4382 3 extent extent NN 19613 4382 4 and and CC 19613 4382 5 organisation organisation NN 19613 4382 6 of of IN 19613 4382 7 the the DT 19613 4382 8 Roman Roman NNP 19613 4382 9 Church Church NNP 19613 4382 10 about about RB 19613 4382 11 250 250 CD 19613 4382 12 see see NN 19613 4382 13 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 4382 14 . . NNP 19613 4382 15 , , , 19613 4382 16 H. H. NNP 19613 4382 17 E. E. NNP 19613 4382 18 VI VI NNP 19613 4382 19 . . . 19613 4383 1 43 43 CD 19613 4383 2 . . . 19613 4383 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4384 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4384 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 4384 3 339 339 CD 19613 4384 4 : : : 19613 4384 5 The the DT 19613 4384 6 memorable memorable JJ 19613 4384 7 words word NNS 19613 4384 8 in in IN 19613 4384 9 the the DT 19613 4384 10 lately lately RB 19613 4384 11 discovered discover VBN 19613 4384 12 appeal appeal NN 19613 4384 13 by by IN 19613 4384 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 4384 15 of of IN 19613 4384 16 Dorylæum Dorylæum NNP 19613 4384 17 to to IN 19613 4384 18 Leo Leo NNP 19613 4384 19 I. I. NNP 19613 4385 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4385 2 Neues Neues NNP 19613 4385 3 Archiv Archiv NNP 19613 4385 4 . . . 19613 4385 5 , , , 19613 4385 6 Vol Vol NNP 19613 4385 7 . . . 19613 4386 1 XI XI NNP 19613 4386 2 . . . 19613 4386 3 , , , 19613 4386 4 part part NN 19613 4386 5 2 2 CD 19613 4386 6 , , , 19613 4386 7 p. p. NN 19613 4386 8 364 364 CD 19613 4386 9 f. f. NNS 19613 4386 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4386 11 are be VBP 19613 4386 12 no no DT 19613 4386 13 mere mere JJ 19613 4386 14 flattery flattery NN 19613 4386 15 , , , 19613 4386 16 and and CC 19613 4386 17 the the DT 19613 4386 18 fifth fifth JJ 19613 4386 19 century century NN 19613 4386 20 is be VBZ 19613 4386 21 not not RB 19613 4386 22 the the DT 19613 4386 23 first first JJ 19613 4386 24 to to TO 19613 4386 25 which which WDT 19613 4386 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4386 27 are be VBP 19613 4386 28 applicable applicable JJ 19613 4386 29 : : : 19613 4386 30 " " `` 19613 4386 31 Curavit curavit NN 19613 4386 32 desuper desuper NN 19613 4386 33 et et FW 19613 4386 34 ab ab NNP 19613 4386 35 exordio exordio NNP 19613 4386 36 consuevit consuevit NNP 19613 4386 37 thronus thronus NNP 19613 4386 38 apostolicus apostolicus NNP 19613 4386 39 iniqua iniqua NNP 19613 4386 40 perferentes perferentes NNP 19613 4386 41 defensare defensare VBP 19613 4386 42 et et NNP 19613 4386 43 eos eos NN 19613 4386 44 qui qui VBP 19613 4386 45 in in IN 19613 4386 46 evitabiles evitabiles NNP 19613 4386 47 factiones factione NNS 19613 4386 48 inciderunt inciderunt NNP 19613 4386 49 , , , 19613 4386 50 adiuvare adiuvare NNP 19613 4386 51 et et NNP 19613 4386 52 humi humi NNP 19613 4386 53 iacentes iacente VBZ 19613 4386 54 erigere erigere RB 19613 4386 55 , , , 19613 4386 56 secundum secundum NN 19613 4386 57 possibilitatem possibilitatem NNP 19613 4386 58 , , , 19613 4386 59 quam quam NNP 19613 4386 60 habetis habetis NNP 19613 4386 61 ; ; : 19613 4386 62 causa causa NNP 19613 4386 63 autem autem NNP 19613 4386 64 rei rei NNP 19613 4386 65 , , , 19613 4386 66 quod quod NNP 19613 4386 67 sensum sensum NNP 19613 4386 68 rectum rectum NNP 19613 4386 69 tenetis tenetis NNP 19613 4386 70 et et NNP 19613 4386 71 inconcussam inconcussam NNP 19613 4386 72 servatis servatis NNP 19613 4386 73 erga erga NNP 19613 4386 74 dominum dominum NN 19613 4386 75 nostrum nostrum NNP 19613 4386 76 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 4386 77 Christum Christum NNP 19613 4386 78 fidem fidem NN 19613 4386 79 , , , 19613 4386 80 nec nec NNP 19613 4386 81 non non AFX 19613 4386 82 etiam etiam NNP 19613 4386 83 indissimulatam indissimulatam NNP 19613 4386 84 universis universis NNP 19613 4386 85 fratribus fratribus NNP 19613 4386 86 et et NNP 19613 4386 87 omnibus omnibus NN 19613 4386 88 in in IN 19613 4386 89 nomine nomine NN 19613 4386 90 Christi Christi NNP 19613 4386 91 vocatis vocatis VBP 19613 4386 92 tribuitis tribuitis NN 19613 4386 93 caritatem caritatem NN 19613 4386 94 , , , 19613 4386 95 etc etc FW 19613 4386 96 . . . 19613 4386 97 " " '' 19613 4387 1 See see VB 19613 4387 2 also also RB 19613 4387 3 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 19613 4387 4 's 's POS 19613 4387 5 letters letter NNS 19613 4387 6 addressed address VBD 19613 4387 7 to to IN 19613 4387 8 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4387 9 . . . 19613 4387 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4388 1 II ii CD 19613 4388 2 . . . 19613 4389 1 FIXING FIXING NNP 19613 4389 2 AND and CC 19613 4389 3 GRADUAL gradual NN 19613 4389 4 HELLENISING HELLENISING NNP 19613 4389 5 OF of IN 19613 4389 6 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 4389 7 AS as IN 19613 4389 8 A a DT 19613 4389 9 SYSTEM system NN 19613 4389 10 OF of IN 19613 4389 11 DOCTRINE DOCTRINE NNP 19613 4389 12 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 4389 13 IV IV NNP 19613 4389 14 . . . 19613 4390 1 ECCLESIASTICAL ecclesiastical NN 19613 4390 2 CHRISTIANITY CHRISTIANITY NNP 19613 4390 3 AND and CC 19613 4390 4 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 19613 4390 5 . . . 19613 4391 1 THE the DT 19613 4391 2 APOLOGISTS APOLOGISTS NNP 19613 4391 3 . . . 19613 4392 1 1 1 LS 19613 4392 2 . . . 19613 4393 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4393 2 Introduction._[340 Introduction._[340 NNP 19613 4393 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4393 4 The the DT 19613 4393 5 object object NN 19613 4393 6 of of IN 19613 4393 7 the the DT 19613 4393 8 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4393 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4393 10 , , , 19613 4393 11 some some DT 19613 4393 12 of of IN 19613 4393 13 whom whom WP 19613 4393 14 filled fill VBD 19613 4393 15 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4393 16 offices office NNS 19613 4393 17 and and CC 19613 4393 18 in in IN 19613 4393 19 various various JJ 19613 4393 20 ways way NNS 19613 4393 21 promoted promote VBD 19613 4393 22 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4393 23 progress,[341 progress,[341 NN 19613 4393 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4393 25 was be VBD 19613 4393 26 , , , 19613 4393 27 as as IN 19613 4393 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4393 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4393 30 explained explain VBD 19613 4393 31 , , , 19613 4393 32 to to TO 19613 4393 33 uphold uphold VB 19613 4393 34 the the DT 19613 4393 35 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4393 36 professed profess VBN 19613 4393 37 by by IN 19613 4393 38 the the DT 19613 4393 39 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4393 40 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4393 41 and and CC 19613 4393 42 publicly publicly RB 19613 4393 43 preached preach VBN 19613 4393 44 . . . 19613 4394 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4394 2 were be VBD 19613 4394 3 convinced convince VBN 19613 4394 4 that that IN 19613 4394 5 the the DT 19613 4394 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 4394 7 faith faith NN 19613 4394 8 was be VBD 19613 4394 9 founded found VBN 19613 4394 10 on on IN 19613 4394 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 4394 12 and and CC 19613 4394 13 that that IN 19613 4394 14 only only RB 19613 4394 15 a a DT 19613 4394 16 mind mind NN 19613 4394 17 enlightened enlighten VBN 19613 4394 18 by by IN 19613 4394 19 God God NNP 19613 4394 20 could could MD 19613 4394 21 grasp grasp VB 19613 4394 22 and and CC 19613 4394 23 maintain maintain VB 19613 4394 24 the the DT 19613 4394 25 faith faith NN 19613 4394 26 . . . 19613 4395 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4395 2 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 4395 3 the the DT 19613 4395 4 Old Old NNP 19613 4395 5 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4395 6 to to TO 19613 4395 7 be be VB 19613 4395 8 the the DT 19613 4395 9 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 4395 10 source source NN 19613 4395 11 of of IN 19613 4395 12 God God NNP 19613 4395 13 's 's POS 19613 4395 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 4395 15 , , , 19613 4395 16 maintained maintain VBD 19613 4395 17 that that IN 19613 4395 18 the the DT 19613 4395 19 whole whole JJ 19613 4395 20 human human JJ 19613 4395 21 race race NN 19613 4395 22 was be VBD 19613 4395 23 meant mean VBN 19613 4395 24 to to TO 19613 4395 25 be be VB 19613 4395 26 reached reach VBN 19613 4395 27 by by IN 19613 4395 28 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4395 29 , , , 19613 4395 30 and and CC 19613 4395 31 adhered adhere VBN 19613 4395 32 to to IN 19613 4395 33 the the DT 19613 4395 34 early early JJ 19613 4395 35 Christian christian JJ 19613 4395 36 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 4395 37 . . . 19613 4396 1 These these DT 19613 4396 2 views view NNS 19613 4396 3 as as RB 19613 4396 4 well well RB 19613 4396 5 as as IN 19613 4396 6 the the DT 19613 4396 7 strong strong JJ 19613 4396 8 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 4396 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4396 10 laid lay VBD 19613 4396 11 upon upon IN 19613 4396 12 human human JJ 19613 4396 13 freedom freedom NN 19613 4396 14 and and CC 19613 4396 15 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 4396 16 , , , 19613 4396 17 enabled enable VBD 19613 4396 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4396 19 to to TO 19613 4396 20 attain attain VB 19613 4396 21 a a DT 19613 4396 22 firm firm JJ 19613 4396 23 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 4396 24 in in IN 19613 4396 25 opposition opposition NN 19613 4396 26 to to IN 19613 4396 27 " " `` 19613 4396 28 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 4396 29 , , , 19613 4396 30 " " '' 19613 4396 31 and and CC 19613 4396 32 to to TO 19613 4396 33 preserve preserve VB 19613 4396 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4396 35 position position NN 19613 4396 36 within within IN 19613 4396 37 the the DT 19613 4396 38 Christian christian JJ 19613 4396 39 communities community NNS 19613 4396 40 , , , 19613 4396 41 whose whose WP$ 19613 4396 42 moral moral JJ 19613 4396 43 purity purity NN 19613 4396 44 and and CC 19613 4396 45 strength strength NN 19613 4396 46 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4396 47 regarded regard VBD 19613 4396 48 as as IN 19613 4396 49 a a DT 19613 4396 50 strong strong JJ 19613 4396 51 proof proof NN 19613 4396 52 of of IN 19613 4396 53 the the DT 19613 4396 54 truth truth NN 19613 4396 55 of of IN 19613 4396 56 this this DT 19613 4396 57 faith faith NN 19613 4396 58 . . . 19613 4397 1 In in IN 19613 4397 2 the the DT 19613 4397 3 endeavours endeavour NNS 19613 4397 4 of of IN 19613 4397 5 the the DT 19613 4397 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4397 7 to to TO 19613 4397 8 explain explain VB 19613 4397 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4397 10 to to IN 19613 4397 11 the the DT 19613 4397 12 cultured cultured JJ 19613 4397 13 world world NN 19613 4397 14 , , , 19613 4397 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4397 16 have have VBP 19613 4397 17 before before IN 19613 4397 18 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4397 19 the the DT 19613 4397 20 attempts attempt NNS 19613 4397 21 of of IN 19613 4397 22 Greek greek JJ 19613 4397 23 churchmen churchman NNS 19613 4397 24 to to TO 19613 4397 25 represent represent VB 19613 4397 26 the the DT 19613 4397 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 4397 28 religion religion NN 19613 4397 29 as as IN 19613 4397 30 a a DT 19613 4397 31 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4397 32 , , , 19613 4397 33 and and CC 19613 4397 34 to to TO 19613 4397 35 convince convince VB 19613 4397 36 outsiders outsider NNS 19613 4397 37 that that IN 19613 4397 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4397 39 was be VBD 19613 4397 40 the the DT 19613 4397 41 highest high JJS 19613 4397 42 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4397 43 and and CC 19613 4397 44 the the DT 19613 4397 45 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4397 46 truth truth NN 19613 4397 47 . . . 19613 4398 1 These these DT 19613 4398 2 efforts effort NNS 19613 4398 3 were be VBD 19613 4398 4 not not RB 19613 4398 5 rejected reject VBN 19613 4398 6 by by IN 19613 4398 7 the the DT 19613 4398 8 Churches church NNS 19613 4398 9 like like IN 19613 4398 10 those those DT 19613 4398 11 of of IN 19613 4398 12 the the DT 19613 4398 13 so so RB 19613 4398 14 - - HYPH 19613 4398 15 called call VBN 19613 4398 16 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4398 17 , , , 19613 4398 18 but but CC 19613 4398 19 rather rather RB 19613 4398 20 became become VBD 19613 4398 21 in in IN 19613 4398 22 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 4398 23 times time NNS 19613 4398 24 the the DT 19613 4398 25 foundation foundation NN 19613 4398 26 of of IN 19613 4398 27 the the DT 19613 4398 28 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4398 29 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 4398 30 . . . 19613 4399 1 The the DT 19613 4399 2 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 4399 3 speculations speculation NNS 19613 4399 4 were be VBD 19613 4399 5 repudiated repudiate VBN 19613 4399 6 , , , 19613 4399 7 whereas whereas IN 19613 4399 8 those those DT 19613 4399 9 of of IN 19613 4399 10 the the DT 19613 4399 11 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4399 12 were be VBD 19613 4399 13 accepted accept VBN 19613 4399 14 . . . 19613 4400 1 The the DT 19613 4400 2 manner manner NN 19613 4400 3 in in IN 19613 4400 4 which which WDT 19613 4400 5 the the DT 19613 4400 6 latter latter JJ 19613 4400 7 set set VBD 19613 4400 8 forth forth RP 19613 4400 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4400 10 as as IN 19613 4400 11 a a DT 19613 4400 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4400 13 met meet VBD 19613 4400 14 with with IN 19613 4400 15 approval approval NN 19613 4400 16 . . . 19613 4401 1 What what WP 19613 4401 2 were be VBD 19613 4401 3 the the DT 19613 4401 4 conditions condition NNS 19613 4401 5 under under IN 19613 4401 6 which which WDT 19613 4401 7 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4401 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4401 9 and and CC 19613 4401 10 Greek greek JJ 19613 4401 11 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4401 12 concluded conclude VBD 19613 4401 13 the the DT 19613 4401 14 alliance alliance NN 19613 4401 15 which which WDT 19613 4401 16 has have VBZ 19613 4401 17 found find VBN 19613 4401 18 a a DT 19613 4401 19 place place NN 19613 4401 20 in in IN 19613 4401 21 the the DT 19613 4401 22 history history NN 19613 4401 23 of of IN 19613 4401 24 the the DT 19613 4401 25 world world NN 19613 4401 26 ? ? . 19613 4402 1 How how WRB 19613 4402 2 did do VBD 19613 4402 3 this this DT 19613 4402 4 union union NN 19613 4402 5 attain attain VB 19613 4402 6 acceptance acceptance NN 19613 4402 7 and and CC 19613 4402 8 permanence permanence NN 19613 4402 9 , , , 19613 4402 10 whilst whilst IN 19613 4402 11 " " `` 19613 4402 12 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 4402 13 " " '' 19613 4402 14 was be VBD 19613 4402 15 at at IN 19613 4402 16 first first RB 19613 4402 17 rejected reject VBN 19613 4402 18 ? ? . 19613 4403 1 These these DT 19613 4403 2 are be VBP 19613 4403 3 the the DT 19613 4403 4 two two CD 19613 4403 5 great great JJ 19613 4403 6 questions question NNS 19613 4403 7 the the DT 19613 4403 8 correct correct JJ 19613 4403 9 answers answer NNS 19613 4403 10 to to TO 19613 4403 11 which which WDT 19613 4403 12 are be VBP 19613 4403 13 of of IN 19613 4403 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4403 15 importance importance NN 19613 4403 16 for for IN 19613 4403 17 the the DT 19613 4403 18 understanding understanding NN 19613 4403 19 of of IN 19613 4403 20 the the DT 19613 4403 21 history history NN 19613 4403 22 of of IN 19613 4403 23 Christian christian JJ 19613 4403 24 dogma dogma NN 19613 4403 25 . . . 19613 4404 1 The the DT 19613 4404 2 answers answer NNS 19613 4404 3 to to IN 19613 4404 4 these these DT 19613 4404 5 questions question NNS 19613 4404 6 appear appear VBP 19613 4404 7 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 19613 4404 8 . . . 19613 4405 1 The the DT 19613 4405 2 these these DT 19613 4405 3 s s NNS 19613 4405 4 of of IN 19613 4405 5 the the DT 19613 4405 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4405 7 finally finally RB 19613 4405 8 overcame overcome VBD 19613 4405 9 all all DT 19613 4405 10 scruples scruple NNS 19613 4405 11 in in IN 19613 4405 12 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4405 13 circles circle NNS 19613 4405 14 and and CC 19613 4405 15 were be VBD 19613 4405 16 accepted accept VBN 19613 4405 17 by by IN 19613 4405 18 the the DT 19613 4405 19 Græco Græco NNP 19613 4405 20 - - HYPH 19613 4405 21 Roman roman JJ 19613 4405 22 world world NN 19613 4405 23 , , , 19613 4405 24 because because IN 19613 4405 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4405 26 made make VBD 19613 4405 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4405 28 _ _ NNP 19613 4405 29 rational rational JJ 19613 4405 30 _ _ NNP 19613 4405 31 without without IN 19613 4405 32 taking take VBG 19613 4405 33 from from IN 19613 4405 34 , , , 19613 4405 35 or or CC 19613 4405 36 adding add VBG 19613 4405 37 to to IN 19613 4405 38 , , , 19613 4405 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4405 40 traditional traditional JJ 19613 4405 41 historic historic JJ 19613 4405 42 material material NN 19613 4405 43 . . . 19613 4406 1 The the DT 19613 4406 2 secret secret NN 19613 4406 3 of of IN 19613 4406 4 the the DT 19613 4406 5 epoch epoch NN 19613 4406 6 - - HYPH 19613 4406 7 making make VBG 19613 4406 8 success success NN 19613 4406 9 of of IN 19613 4406 10 the the DT 19613 4406 11 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 4406 12 theology theology NN 19613 4406 13 is be VBZ 19613 4406 14 thus thus RB 19613 4406 15 explained explain VBN 19613 4406 16 : : : 19613 4406 17 These these DT 19613 4406 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 4406 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4406 20 formulated formulate VBD 19613 4406 21 the the DT 19613 4406 22 content content NN 19613 4406 23 of of IN 19613 4406 24 the the DT 19613 4406 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 4406 26 in in IN 19613 4406 27 a a DT 19613 4406 28 manner manner NN 19613 4406 29 which which WDT 19613 4406 30 appealed appeal VBD 19613 4406 31 to to IN 19613 4406 32 the the DT 19613 4406 33 common common JJ 19613 4406 34 sense sense NN 19613 4406 35 of of IN 19613 4406 36 all all PDT 19613 4406 37 the the DT 19613 4406 38 serious serious JJ 19613 4406 39 thinkers thinker NNS 19613 4406 40 and and CC 19613 4406 41 intelligent intelligent JJ 19613 4406 42 men man NNS 19613 4406 43 of of IN 19613 4406 44 the the DT 19613 4406 45 age age NN 19613 4406 46 . . . 19613 4407 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4407 2 , , , 19613 4407 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4407 4 contrived contrive VBD 19613 4407 5 to to TO 19613 4407 6 use use VB 19613 4407 7 the the DT 19613 4407 8 positive positive JJ 19613 4407 9 material material NN 19613 4407 10 of of IN 19613 4407 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 4407 12 , , , 19613 4407 13 including include VBG 19613 4407 14 the the DT 19613 4407 15 life life NN 19613 4407 16 and and CC 19613 4407 17 worship worship NN 19613 4407 18 of of IN 19613 4407 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4407 20 , , , 19613 4407 21 in in IN 19613 4407 22 such such PDT 19613 4407 23 a a DT 19613 4407 24 way way NN 19613 4407 25 as as IN 19613 4407 26 to to TO 19613 4407 27 furnish furnish VB 19613 4407 28 this this DT 19613 4407 29 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4407 30 religion religion NN 19613 4407 31 with with IN 19613 4407 32 a a DT 19613 4407 33 confirmation confirmation NN 19613 4407 34 and and CC 19613 4407 35 proof proof NN 19613 4407 36 that that WDT 19613 4407 37 had have VBD 19613 4407 38 hitherto hitherto VBN 19613 4407 39 been be VBN 19613 4407 40 eagerly eagerly RB 19613 4407 41 sought seek VBN 19613 4407 42 , , , 19613 4407 43 but but CC 19613 4407 44 sought seek VBN 19613 4407 45 in in IN 19613 4407 46 vain vain JJ 19613 4407 47 . . . 19613 4408 1 In in IN 19613 4408 2 the the DT 19613 4408 3 theology theology NN 19613 4408 4 of of IN 19613 4408 5 the the DT 19613 4408 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4408 7 , , , 19613 4408 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4408 9 , , , 19613 4408 10 as as IN 19613 4408 11 the the DT 19613 4408 12 religious religious JJ 19613 4408 13 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 4408 14 directly directly RB 19613 4408 15 emanating emanate VBG 19613 4408 16 from from IN 19613 4408 17 God God NNP 19613 4408 18 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4408 19 , , , 19613 4408 20 is be VBZ 19613 4408 21 most most RBS 19613 4408 22 sharply sharply RB 19613 4408 23 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 4408 24 with with IN 19613 4408 25 all all DT 19613 4408 26 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4408 27 , , , 19613 4408 28 natural natural JJ 19613 4408 29 religion religion NN 19613 4408 30 , , , 19613 4408 31 and and CC 19613 4408 32 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 4408 33 . . . 19613 4409 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4409 2 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 4409 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4409 4 in in IN 19613 4409 5 the the DT 19613 4409 6 most most RBS 19613 4409 7 emphatic emphatic JJ 19613 4409 8 manner manner NN 19613 4409 9 as as IN 19613 4409 10 the the DT 19613 4409 11 religion religion NN 19613 4409 12 of of IN 19613 4409 13 the the DT 19613 4409 14 spirit spirit NN 19613 4409 15 , , , 19613 4409 16 of of IN 19613 4409 17 freedom freedom NN 19613 4409 18 , , , 19613 4409 19 and and CC 19613 4409 20 of of IN 19613 4409 21 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4409 22 morality morality NN 19613 4409 23 . . . 19613 4410 1 Almost almost RB 19613 4410 2 the the DT 19613 4410 3 whole whole JJ 19613 4410 4 positive positive JJ 19613 4410 5 material material NN 19613 4410 6 of of IN 19613 4410 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4410 8 is be VBZ 19613 4410 9 embodied embody VBN 19613 4410 10 in in IN 19613 4410 11 the the DT 19613 4410 12 story story NN 19613 4410 13 which which WDT 19613 4410 14 relates relate VBZ 19613 4410 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4410 16 entrance entrance NN 19613 4410 17 into into IN 19613 4410 18 the the DT 19613 4410 19 world world NN 19613 4410 20 , , , 19613 4410 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4410 22 spread spread NN 19613 4410 23 , , , 19613 4410 24 and and CC 19613 4410 25 the the DT 19613 4410 26 proof proof NN 19613 4410 27 of of IN 19613 4410 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4410 29 truth truth NN 19613 4410 30 . . . 19613 4411 1 The the DT 19613 4411 2 religion religion NN 19613 4411 3 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4411 4 , , , 19613 4411 5 on on IN 19613 4411 6 the the DT 19613 4411 7 other other JJ 19613 4411 8 hand hand NN 19613 4411 9 , , , 19613 4411 10 appears appear VBZ 19613 4411 11 as as IN 19613 4411 12 the the DT 19613 4411 13 truth truth NN 19613 4411 14 that that WDT 19613 4411 15 is be VBZ 19613 4411 16 surely surely RB 19613 4411 17 attested attest VBN 19613 4411 18 and and CC 19613 4411 19 accords accord NNS 19613 4411 20 with with IN 19613 4411 21 reason reason NN 19613 4411 22 -- -- : 19613 4411 23 a a DT 19613 4411 24 truth truth NN 19613 4411 25 the the DT 19613 4411 26 content content NN 19613 4411 27 of of IN 19613 4411 28 which which WDT 19613 4411 29 is be VBZ 19613 4411 30 not not RB 19613 4411 31 primarily primarily RB 19613 4411 32 dependent dependent JJ 19613 4411 33 on on IN 19613 4411 34 historical historical JJ 19613 4411 35 facts fact NNS 19613 4411 36 and and CC 19613 4411 37 finally finally RB 19613 4411 38 overthrows overthrow VBZ 19613 4411 39 all all DT 19613 4411 40 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4411 41 . . . 19613 4412 1 Now now RB 19613 4412 2 this this DT 19613 4412 3 was be VBD 19613 4412 4 the the DT 19613 4412 5 very very JJ 19613 4412 6 thing thing NN 19613 4412 7 required require VBN 19613 4412 8 . . . 19613 4413 1 In in IN 19613 4413 2 the the DT 19613 4413 3 second second JJ 19613 4413 4 century century NN 19613 4413 5 of of IN 19613 4413 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4413 7 era era NN 19613 4413 8 a a DT 19613 4413 9 great great JJ 19613 4413 10 many many JJ 19613 4413 11 needs need NNS 19613 4413 12 and and CC 19613 4413 13 aspirations aspiration NNS 19613 4413 14 were be VBD 19613 4413 15 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 4413 16 making make VBG 19613 4413 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4413 18 felt feel VBD 19613 4413 19 in in IN 19613 4413 20 the the DT 19613 4413 21 sphere sphere NN 19613 4413 22 of of IN 19613 4413 23 religion religion NN 19613 4413 24 and and CC 19613 4413 25 morals moral NNS 19613 4413 26 . . . 19613 4414 1 " " `` 19613 4414 2 Gnosticism gnosticism NN 19613 4414 3 " " '' 19613 4414 4 and and CC 19613 4414 5 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 4414 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4414 7 prove prove VBP 19613 4414 8 the the DT 19613 4414 9 variety variety NN 19613 4414 10 and and CC 19613 4414 11 depth depth NN 19613 4414 12 of of IN 19613 4414 13 the the DT 19613 4414 14 needs need NNS 19613 4414 15 then then RB 19613 4414 16 asserting assert VBG 19613 4414 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4414 18 within within IN 19613 4414 19 the the DT 19613 4414 20 space space NN 19613 4414 21 that that WDT 19613 4414 22 the the DT 19613 4414 23 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 4414 24 historian historian NN 19613 4414 25 is be VBZ 19613 4414 26 able able JJ 19613 4414 27 to to TO 19613 4414 28 survey survey VB 19613 4414 29 . . . 19613 4415 1 Mightier mighty JJR 19613 4415 2 than than IN 19613 4415 3 all all DT 19613 4415 4 others other NNS 19613 4415 5 , , , 19613 4415 6 however however RB 19613 4415 7 , , , 19613 4415 8 was be VBD 19613 4415 9 the the DT 19613 4415 10 longing longing NN 19613 4415 11 men man NNS 19613 4415 12 felt feel VBD 19613 4415 13 to to TO 19613 4415 14 free free VB 19613 4415 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4415 16 from from IN 19613 4415 17 the the DT 19613 4415 18 burden burden NN 19613 4415 19 of of IN 19613 4415 20 the the DT 19613 4415 21 past past NN 19613 4415 22 , , , 19613 4415 23 to to TO 19613 4415 24 cast cast VB 19613 4415 25 away away RB 19613 4415 26 the the DT 19613 4415 27 rubbish rubbish NN 19613 4415 28 of of IN 19613 4415 29 cults cult NNS 19613 4415 30 and and CC 19613 4415 31 of of IN 19613 4415 32 unmeaning unmeane VBG 19613 4415 33 religious religious JJ 19613 4415 34 ceremonies ceremony NNS 19613 4415 35 , , , 19613 4415 36 and and CC 19613 4415 37 to to TO 19613 4415 38 be be VB 19613 4415 39 assured assure VBN 19613 4415 40 that that IN 19613 4415 41 the the DT 19613 4415 42 results result NNS 19613 4415 43 of of IN 19613 4415 44 religious religious JJ 19613 4415 45 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4415 46 , , , 19613 4415 47 those those DT 19613 4415 48 great great JJ 19613 4415 49 and and CC 19613 4415 50 simple simple JJ 19613 4415 51 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4415 52 of of IN 19613 4415 53 virtue virtue NN 19613 4415 54 and and CC 19613 4415 55 immortality immortality NN 19613 4415 56 and and CC 19613 4415 57 of of IN 19613 4415 58 the the DT 19613 4415 59 God God NNP 19613 4415 60 who who WP 19613 4415 61 is be VBZ 19613 4415 62 a a DT 19613 4415 63 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4415 64 , , , 19613 4415 65 were be VBD 19613 4415 66 certain certain JJ 19613 4415 67 truths truth NNS 19613 4415 68 . . . 19613 4416 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4416 2 who who WP 19613 4416 3 brought bring VBD 19613 4416 4 the the DT 19613 4416 5 message message NN 19613 4416 6 that that IN 19613 4416 7 these these DT 19613 4416 8 ideas idea NNS 19613 4416 9 were be VBD 19613 4416 10 realities reality NNS 19613 4416 11 , , , 19613 4416 12 and and CC 19613 4416 13 who who WP 19613 4416 14 , , , 19613 4416 15 on on IN 19613 4416 16 the the DT 19613 4416 17 strength strength NN 19613 4416 18 of of IN 19613 4416 19 these these DT 19613 4416 20 realities reality NNS 19613 4416 21 , , , 19613 4416 22 declared declare VBD 19613 4416 23 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4416 24 and and CC 19613 4416 25 the the DT 19613 4416 26 worship worship NN 19613 4416 27 of of IN 19613 4416 28 idols idol NNS 19613 4416 29 to to TO 19613 4416 30 be be VB 19613 4416 31 obsolete obsolete JJ 19613 4416 32 , , , 19613 4416 33 had have VBD 19613 4416 34 the the DT 19613 4416 35 mightiest mighty JJS 19613 4416 36 forces force NNS 19613 4416 37 on on IN 19613 4416 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4416 39 side side NN 19613 4416 40 ; ; : 19613 4416 41 for for IN 19613 4416 42 the the DT 19613 4416 43 times time NNS 19613 4416 44 were be VBD 19613 4416 45 now now RB 19613 4416 46 ripe ripe JJ 19613 4416 47 for for IN 19613 4416 48 this this DT 19613 4416 49 preaching preaching NN 19613 4416 50 . . . 19613 4417 1 What what WP 19613 4417 2 formed form VBD 19613 4417 3 the the DT 19613 4417 4 strength strength NN 19613 4417 5 of of IN 19613 4417 6 the the DT 19613 4417 7 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 4417 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4417 9 was be VBD 19613 4417 10 the the DT 19613 4417 11 proclamation proclamation NN 19613 4417 12 that that IN 19613 4417 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4417 14 both both DT 19613 4417 15 contained contain VBD 19613 4417 16 the the DT 19613 4417 17 highest high JJS 19613 4417 18 truth truth NN 19613 4417 19 , , , 19613 4417 20 as as IN 19613 4417 21 men man NNS 19613 4417 22 already already RB 19613 4417 23 supposed suppose VBD 19613 4417 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4417 25 to to TO 19613 4417 26 be be VB 19613 4417 27 and and CC 19613 4417 28 as as IN 19613 4417 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4417 30 had have VBD 19613 4417 31 discovered discover VBN 19613 4417 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4417 33 in in IN 19613 4417 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4417 35 own own JJ 19613 4417 36 minds mind NNS 19613 4417 37 , , , 19613 4417 38 and and CC 19613 4417 39 the the DT 19613 4417 40 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 4417 41 reliable reliable JJ 19613 4417 42 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 4417 43 that that WDT 19613 4417 44 was be VBD 19613 4417 45 desired desire VBN 19613 4417 46 for for IN 19613 4417 47 this this DT 19613 4417 48 truth truth NN 19613 4417 49 . . . 19613 4418 1 To to IN 19613 4418 2 the the DT 19613 4418 3 quality quality NN 19613 4418 4 which which WDT 19613 4418 5 makes make VBZ 19613 4418 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4418 7 appear appear VB 19613 4418 8 meagre meagre NNP 19613 4418 9 to to IN 19613 4418 10 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4418 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4418 12 owed owe VBD 19613 4418 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4418 14 impressiveness impressiveness NN 19613 4418 15 . . . 19613 4419 1 The the DT 19613 4419 2 fact fact NN 19613 4419 3 of of IN 19613 4419 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4419 5 falling fall VBG 19613 4419 6 in in RP 19613 4419 7 with with IN 19613 4419 8 the the DT 19613 4419 9 general general JJ 19613 4419 10 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4419 11 current current NN 19613 4419 12 of of IN 19613 4419 13 the the DT 19613 4419 14 time time NN 19613 4419 15 and and CC 19613 4419 16 making make VBG 19613 4419 17 no no DT 19613 4419 18 attempt attempt NN 19613 4419 19 to to TO 19613 4419 20 satisfy satisfy VB 19613 4419 21 special special JJ 19613 4419 22 and and CC 19613 4419 23 deeper deep JJR 19613 4419 24 needs need NNS 19613 4419 25 enabled enable VBD 19613 4419 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4419 27 to to TO 19613 4419 28 plead plead VB 19613 4419 29 the the DT 19613 4419 30 cause cause NN 19613 4419 31 of of IN 19613 4419 32 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4419 33 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 4419 34 and and CC 19613 4419 35 to to TO 19613 4419 36 oppose oppose VB 19613 4419 37 the the DT 19613 4419 38 worship worship NN 19613 4419 39 of of IN 19613 4419 40 idols idol NNS 19613 4419 41 in in IN 19613 4419 42 the the DT 19613 4419 43 manner manner NN 19613 4419 44 most most RBS 19613 4419 45 easily easily RB 19613 4419 46 understood understand VBN 19613 4419 47 . . . 19613 4420 1 As as IN 19613 4420 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4420 3 did do VBD 19613 4420 4 not not RB 19613 4420 5 require require VB 19613 4420 6 historic historic JJ 19613 4420 7 and and CC 19613 4420 8 positive positive JJ 19613 4420 9 material material NN 19613 4420 10 to to TO 19613 4420 11 describe describe VB 19613 4420 12 the the DT 19613 4420 13 nature nature NN 19613 4420 14 of of IN 19613 4420 15 religion religion NN 19613 4420 16 and and CC 19613 4420 17 morality morality NN 19613 4420 18 , , , 19613 4420 19 this this DT 19613 4420 20 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4420 21 enabled enable VBD 19613 4420 22 the the DT 19613 4420 23 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4420 24 to to TO 19613 4420 25 demonstrate demonstrate VB 19613 4420 26 the the DT 19613 4420 27 worthlessness worthlessness NN 19613 4420 28 of of IN 19613 4420 29 the the DT 19613 4420 30 traditional traditional JJ 19613 4420 31 religion religion NN 19613 4420 32 and and CC 19613 4420 33 worship worship NN 19613 4420 34 of of IN 19613 4420 35 the the DT 19613 4420 36 different different JJ 19613 4420 37 nations nation NNS 19613 4420 38 . . . 19613 4421 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4421 2 342 342 CD 19613 4421 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4421 4 The the DT 19613 4421 5 same same JJ 19613 4421 6 cause cause NN 19613 4421 7 , , , 19613 4421 8 however however RB 19613 4421 9 , , , 19613 4421 10 made make VBD 19613 4421 11 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4421 12 take take VB 19613 4421 13 up up RP 19613 4421 14 the the DT 19613 4421 15 conservative conservative JJ 19613 4421 16 position position NN 19613 4421 17 with with IN 19613 4421 18 regard regard NN 19613 4421 19 to to IN 19613 4421 20 the the DT 19613 4421 21 historical historical JJ 19613 4421 22 traditions tradition NNS 19613 4421 23 of of IN 19613 4421 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4421 25 . . . 19613 4422 1 These these DT 19613 4422 2 were be VBD 19613 4422 3 not not RB 19613 4422 4 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 4422 5 tested test VBN 19613 4422 6 as as IN 19613 4422 7 to to IN 19613 4422 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4422 9 content content NN 19613 4422 10 , , , 19613 4422 11 for for IN 19613 4422 12 this this DT 19613 4422 13 was be VBD 19613 4422 14 taken take VBN 19613 4422 15 for for IN 19613 4422 16 granted grant VBN 19613 4422 17 , , , 19613 4422 18 no no RB 19613 4422 19 matter matter RB 19613 4422 20 how how WRB 19613 4422 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4422 22 might may MD 19613 4422 23 be be VB 19613 4422 24 worded word VBN 19613 4422 25 ; ; : 19613 4422 26 but but CC 19613 4422 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4422 28 were be VBD 19613 4422 29 used use VBN 19613 4422 30 to to TO 19613 4422 31 give give VB 19613 4422 32 an an DT 19613 4422 33 assurance assurance NN 19613 4422 34 of of IN 19613 4422 35 the the DT 19613 4422 36 truth truth NN 19613 4422 37 , , , 19613 4422 38 and and CC 19613 4422 39 to to TO 19613 4422 40 prove prove VB 19613 4422 41 that that IN 19613 4422 42 the the DT 19613 4422 43 religion religion NN 19613 4422 44 of of IN 19613 4422 45 the the DT 19613 4422 46 spirit spirit NN 19613 4422 47 was be VBD 19613 4422 48 not not RB 19613 4422 49 founded found VBN 19613 4422 50 on on IN 19613 4422 51 human human JJ 19613 4422 52 opinion opinion NN 19613 4422 53 , , , 19613 4422 54 but but CC 19613 4422 55 on on IN 19613 4422 56 divine divine JJ 19613 4422 57 revelation revelation NN 19613 4422 58 . . . 19613 4423 1 The the DT 19613 4423 2 only only JJ 19613 4423 3 really really RB 19613 4423 4 important important JJ 19613 4423 5 consideration consideration NN 19613 4423 6 in in IN 19613 4423 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4423 8 is be VBZ 19613 4423 9 that that IN 19613 4423 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4423 11 is be VBZ 19613 4423 12 _ _ NNP 19613 4423 13 revelation revelation NN 19613 4423 14 , , , 19613 4423 15 real real JJ 19613 4423 16 revelation revelation NN 19613 4423 17 _ _ NNP 19613 4423 18 . . . 19613 4424 1 The the DT 19613 4424 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4424 3 had have VBD 19613 4424 4 no no DT 19613 4424 5 doubt doubt NN 19613 4424 6 as as IN 19613 4424 7 to to IN 19613 4424 8 what what WP 19613 4424 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4424 10 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 4424 11 , , , 19613 4424 12 and and CC 19613 4424 13 therefore therefore RB 19613 4424 14 any any DT 19613 4424 15 investigation investigation NN 19613 4424 16 was be VBD 19613 4424 17 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 19613 4424 18 . . . 19613 4425 1 The the DT 19613 4425 2 result result NN 19613 4425 3 of of IN 19613 4425 4 Greek greek JJ 19613 4425 5 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4425 6 , , , 19613 4425 7 the the DT 19613 4425 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4425 9 of of IN 19613 4425 10 Plato Plato NNP 19613 4425 11 and and CC 19613 4425 12 Zeno Zeno NNP 19613 4425 13 , , , 19613 4425 14 as as IN 19613 4425 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4425 16 had have VBD 19613 4425 17 further further RB 19613 4425 18 developed develop VBN 19613 4425 19 in in IN 19613 4425 20 the the DT 19613 4425 21 empires empire NNS 19613 4425 22 of of IN 19613 4425 23 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 4425 24 the the DT 19613 4425 25 Great great JJ 19613 4425 26 and and CC 19613 4425 27 the the DT 19613 4425 28 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 4425 29 , , , 19613 4425 30 was be VBD 19613 4425 31 to to TO 19613 4425 32 attain attain VB 19613 4425 33 victory victory NN 19613 4425 34 and and CC 19613 4425 35 permanence permanence NN 19613 4425 36 by by IN 19613 4425 37 the the DT 19613 4425 38 aid aid NN 19613 4425 39 of of IN 19613 4425 40 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4425 41 . . . 19613 4426 1 Thus thus RB 19613 4426 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4426 3 view view VBP 19613 4426 4 the the DT 19613 4426 5 progress progress NN 19613 4426 6 of of IN 19613 4426 7 this this DT 19613 4426 8 development development NN 19613 4426 9 to to IN 19613 4426 10 - - HYPH 19613 4426 11 day,[343 day,[343 NNP 19613 4426 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4426 13 and and CC 19613 4426 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4426 15 really really RB 19613 4426 16 proved prove VBD 19613 4426 17 to to TO 19613 4426 18 be be VB 19613 4426 19 the the DT 19613 4426 20 force force NN 19613 4426 21 from from IN 19613 4426 22 which which WDT 19613 4426 23 that that DT 19613 4426 24 religious religious JJ 19613 4426 25 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4426 26 , , , 19613 4426 27 viewed view VBD 19613 4426 28 as as IN 19613 4426 29 a a DT 19613 4426 30 theory theory NN 19613 4426 31 of of IN 19613 4426 32 the the DT 19613 4426 33 world world NN 19613 4426 34 and and CC 19613 4426 35 system system NN 19613 4426 36 of of IN 19613 4426 37 morality morality NN 19613 4426 38 , , , 19613 4426 39 first first RB 19613 4426 40 received receive VBD 19613 4426 41 the the DT 19613 4426 42 courage courage NN 19613 4426 43 to to TO 19613 4426 44 free free VB 19613 4426 45 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4426 46 from from IN 19613 4426 47 the the DT 19613 4426 48 polytheistic polytheistic JJ 19613 4426 49 past past NN 19613 4426 50 and and CC 19613 4426 51 descend descend VBP 19613 4426 52 from from IN 19613 4426 53 the the DT 19613 4426 54 circles circle NNS 19613 4426 55 of of IN 19613 4426 56 the the DT 19613 4426 57 learned learn VBN 19613 4426 58 to to IN 19613 4426 59 the the DT 19613 4426 60 common common JJ 19613 4426 61 people people NNS 19613 4426 62 . . . 19613 4427 1 This this DT 19613 4427 2 constitutes constitute VBZ 19613 4427 3 the the DT 19613 4427 4 deepest deep JJS 19613 4427 5 distinction distinction NN 19613 4427 6 between between IN 19613 4427 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 4427 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4427 9 like like IN 19613 4427 10 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4427 11 and and CC 19613 4427 12 those those DT 19613 4427 13 of of IN 19613 4427 14 the the DT 19613 4427 15 type type NN 19613 4427 16 of of IN 19613 4427 17 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 4427 18 . . . 19613 4428 1 The the DT 19613 4428 2 latter latter JJ 19613 4428 3 sought seek VBD 19613 4428 4 for for IN 19613 4428 5 a a DT 19613 4428 6 _ _ NNP 19613 4428 7 religion religion NN 19613 4428 8 _ _ NNP 19613 4428 9 ; ; : 19613 4428 10 the the DT 19613 4428 11 former former JJ 19613 4428 12 , , , 19613 4428 13 though though IN 19613 4428 14 indeed indeed RB 19613 4428 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4428 16 were be VBD 19613 4428 17 not not RB 19613 4428 18 very very RB 19613 4428 19 clear clear JJ 19613 4428 20 about about IN 19613 4428 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4428 22 own own JJ 19613 4428 23 purpose purpose NN 19613 4428 24 , , , 19613 4428 25 sought seek VBD 19613 4428 26 _ _ NNP 19613 4428 27 assurance assurance NN 19613 4428 28 _ _ NNP 19613 4428 29 as as IN 19613 4428 30 to to IN 19613 4428 31 a a DT 19613 4428 32 theistic theistic JJ 19613 4428 33 and and CC 19613 4428 34 moral moral JJ 19613 4428 35 conception conception NN 19613 4428 36 of of IN 19613 4428 37 the the DT 19613 4428 38 world world NN 19613 4428 39 which which WDT 19613 4428 40 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4428 41 already already RB 19613 4428 42 possessed possess VBD 19613 4428 43 . . . 19613 4429 1 At at IN 19613 4429 2 first first RB 19613 4429 3 the the DT 19613 4429 4 complexus complexus NN 19613 4429 5 of of IN 19613 4429 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 4429 7 tradition tradition NN 19613 4429 8 , , , 19613 4429 9 which which WDT 19613 4429 10 must must MD 19613 4429 11 have have VB 19613 4429 12 possessed possess VBN 19613 4429 13 many many JJ 19613 4429 14 features feature NNS 19613 4429 15 of of IN 19613 4429 16 attraction attraction NN 19613 4429 17 for for IN 19613 4429 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4429 19 , , , 19613 4429 20 was be VBD 19613 4429 21 something something NN 19613 4429 22 foreign foreign JJ 19613 4429 23 to to IN 19613 4429 24 both both DT 19613 4429 25 . . . 19613 4430 1 The the DT 19613 4430 2 latter latter JJ 19613 4430 3 , , , 19613 4430 4 however however RB 19613 4430 5 , , , 19613 4430 6 sought seek VBD 19613 4430 7 to to TO 19613 4430 8 make make VB 19613 4430 9 this this DT 19613 4430 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 4430 11 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 4430 12 . . . 19613 4431 1 For for IN 19613 4431 2 the the DT 19613 4431 3 former former JJ 19613 4431 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4431 5 was be VBD 19613 4431 6 enough enough JJ 19613 4431 7 that that IN 19613 4431 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4431 9 had have VBD 19613 4431 10 here here RB 19613 4431 11 a a DT 19613 4431 12 revelation revelation NN 19613 4431 13 before before IN 19613 4431 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4431 15 ; ; : 19613 4431 16 that that IN 19613 4431 17 this this DT 19613 4431 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 4431 19 also also RB 19613 4431 20 bore bear VBD 19613 4431 21 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 19613 4431 22 testimony testimony NN 19613 4431 23 to to IN 19613 4431 24 the the DT 19613 4431 25 one one NN 19613 4431 26 God God NNP 19613 4431 27 , , , 19613 4431 28 who who WP 19613 4431 29 was be VBD 19613 4431 30 a a DT 19613 4431 31 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4431 32 , , , 19613 4431 33 to to TO 19613 4431 34 virtue virtue VB 19613 4431 35 , , , 19613 4431 36 and and CC 19613 4431 37 to to IN 19613 4431 38 immortality immortality NN 19613 4431 39 ; ; : 19613 4431 40 and and CC 19613 4431 41 that that IN 19613 4431 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4431 43 was be VBD 19613 4431 44 capable capable JJ 19613 4431 45 of of IN 19613 4431 46 convincing convince VBG 19613 4431 47 men man NNS 19613 4431 48 and and CC 19613 4431 49 of of IN 19613 4431 50 leading lead VBG 19613 4431 51 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4431 52 to to IN 19613 4431 53 a a DT 19613 4431 54 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4431 55 life life NN 19613 4431 56 . . . 19613 4432 1 Viewed Viewed NNP 19613 4432 2 superficially superficially RB 19613 4432 3 , , , 19613 4432 4 the the DT 19613 4432 5 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4432 6 were be VBD 19613 4432 7 no no RB 19613 4432 8 doubt doubt RB 19613 4432 9 the the DT 19613 4432 10 conservatives conservative NNS 19613 4432 11 ; ; : 19613 4432 12 but but CC 19613 4432 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4432 14 were be VBD 19613 4432 15 so so RB 19613 4432 16 , , , 19613 4432 17 because because IN 19613 4432 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4432 19 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 4432 20 in in IN 19613 4432 21 any any DT 19613 4432 22 respect respect NN 19613 4432 23 meddled meddle VBN 19613 4432 24 with with IN 19613 4432 25 the the DT 19613 4432 26 contents content NNS 19613 4432 27 of of IN 19613 4432 28 tradition tradition NN 19613 4432 29 . . . 19613 4433 1 The the DT 19613 4433 2 " " `` 19613 4433 3 Gnostics Gnostics NNP 19613 4433 4 , , , 19613 4433 5 " " '' 19613 4433 6 on on IN 19613 4433 7 the the DT 19613 4433 8 contrary contrary NN 19613 4433 9 , , , 19613 4433 10 sought seek VBD 19613 4433 11 to to TO 19613 4433 12 understand understand VB 19613 4433 13 what what WP 19613 4433 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4433 15 read read VBP 19613 4433 16 and and CC 19613 4433 17 to to TO 19613 4433 18 investigate investigate VB 19613 4433 19 the the DT 19613 4433 20 truth truth NN 19613 4433 21 of of IN 19613 4433 22 the the DT 19613 4433 23 message message NN 19613 4433 24 of of IN 19613 4433 25 which which WDT 19613 4433 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4433 27 heard hear VBD 19613 4433 28 . . . 19613 4434 1 The the DT 19613 4434 2 most most RBS 19613 4434 3 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 4434 4 feature feature NN 19613 4434 5 is be VBZ 19613 4434 6 the the DT 19613 4434 7 attitude attitude NN 19613 4434 8 of of IN 19613 4434 9 each each DT 19613 4434 10 to to IN 19613 4434 11 the the DT 19613 4434 12 Old Old NNP 19613 4434 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4434 14 . . . 19613 4435 1 The the DT 19613 4435 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4435 3 were be VBD 19613 4435 4 content content JJ 19613 4435 5 to to TO 19613 4435 6 have have VB 19613 4435 7 found find VBN 19613 4435 8 in in IN 19613 4435 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4435 10 an an DT 19613 4435 11 ancient ancient JJ 19613 4435 12 source source NN 19613 4435 13 of of IN 19613 4435 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 4435 15 , , , 19613 4435 16 and and CC 19613 4435 17 viewed view VBD 19613 4435 18 the the DT 19613 4435 19 book book NN 19613 4435 20 as as IN 19613 4435 21 a a DT 19613 4435 22 testimony testimony NN 19613 4435 23 to to IN 19613 4435 24 the the DT 19613 4435 25 truth truth NN 19613 4435 26 , , , 19613 4435 27 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4435 28 , , , 19613 4435 29 to to IN 19613 4435 30 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4435 31 and and CC 19613 4435 32 virtue virtue VB 19613 4435 33 ; ; : 19613 4435 34 the the DT 19613 4435 35 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4435 36 investigated investigate VBD 19613 4435 37 this this DT 19613 4435 38 document document NN 19613 4435 39 and and CC 19613 4435 40 examined examine VBD 19613 4435 41 to to IN 19613 4435 42 what what WDT 19613 4435 43 extent extent NN 19613 4435 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4435 45 agreed agree VBD 19613 4435 46 with with IN 19613 4435 47 the the DT 19613 4435 48 new new JJ 19613 4435 49 impressions impression NNS 19613 4435 50 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4435 51 had have VBD 19613 4435 52 received receive VBN 19613 4435 53 from from IN 19613 4435 54 the the DT 19613 4435 55 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 4435 56 . . . 19613 4436 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4436 2 may may MD 19613 4436 3 sum sum VB 19613 4436 4 up up RP 19613 4436 5 as as IN 19613 4436 6 follows follow VBZ 19613 4436 7 : : : 19613 4436 8 The the DT 19613 4436 9 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4436 10 sought seek VBD 19613 4436 11 to to TO 19613 4436 12 determine determine VB 19613 4436 13 what what WP 19613 4436 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4436 15 is be VBZ 19613 4436 16 as as IN 19613 4436 17 a a DT 19613 4436 18 religion religion NN 19613 4436 19 , , , 19613 4436 20 and and CC 19613 4436 21 , , , 19613 4436 22 as as IN 19613 4436 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4436 24 were be VBD 19613 4436 25 convinced convince VBN 19613 4436 26 of of IN 19613 4436 27 the the DT 19613 4436 28 absoluteness absoluteness NN 19613 4436 29 of of IN 19613 4436 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4436 31 , , , 19613 4436 32 this this DT 19613 4436 33 process process NN 19613 4436 34 led lead VBD 19613 4436 35 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4436 36 to to TO 19613 4436 37 incorporate incorporate VB 19613 4436 38 with with IN 19613 4436 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4436 40 all all DT 19613 4436 41 that that WDT 19613 4436 42 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4436 43 looked look VBD 19613 4436 44 on on RP 19613 4436 45 as as IN 19613 4436 46 sublime sublime JJ 19613 4436 47 and and CC 19613 4436 48 holy holy JJ 19613 4436 49 and and CC 19613 4436 50 to to TO 19613 4436 51 remove remove VB 19613 4436 52 everything everything NN 19613 4436 53 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4436 54 recognised recognise VBD 19613 4436 55 to to TO 19613 4436 56 be be VB 19613 4436 57 inferior inferior JJ 19613 4436 58 . . . 19613 4437 1 The the DT 19613 4437 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4437 3 , , , 19613 4437 4 again again RB 19613 4437 5 , , , 19613 4437 6 strove strove VB 19613 4437 7 to to TO 19613 4437 8 discover discover VB 19613 4437 9 an an DT 19613 4437 10 authority authority NN 19613 4437 11 for for IN 19613 4437 12 religious religious JJ 19613 4437 13 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 4437 14 and and CC 19613 4437 15 morality morality NN 19613 4437 16 and and CC 19613 4437 17 to to TO 19613 4437 18 find find VB 19613 4437 19 the the DT 19613 4437 20 confirmation confirmation NN 19613 4437 21 of of IN 19613 4437 22 a a DT 19613 4437 23 theory theory NN 19613 4437 24 of of IN 19613 4437 25 the the DT 19613 4437 26 universe universe NN 19613 4437 27 , , , 19613 4437 28 which which WDT 19613 4437 29 , , , 19613 4437 30 if if IN 19613 4437 31 true true JJ 19613 4437 32 , , , 19613 4437 33 contained contain VBN 19613 4437 34 for for IN 19613 4437 35 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4437 36 the the DT 19613 4437 37 certainty certainty NN 19613 4437 38 of of IN 19613 4437 39 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4437 40 life life NN 19613 4437 41 ; ; : 19613 4437 42 and and CC 19613 4437 43 this this DT 19613 4437 44 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4437 45 found find VBD 19613 4437 46 in in IN 19613 4437 47 the the DT 19613 4437 48 Christian christian JJ 19613 4437 49 tradition tradition NN 19613 4437 50 . . . 19613 4438 1 At at IN 19613 4438 2 bottom bottom NN 19613 4438 3 this this DT 19613 4438 4 contrast contrast NN 19613 4438 5 is be VBZ 19613 4438 6 a a DT 19613 4438 7 picture picture NN 19613 4438 8 of of IN 19613 4438 9 the the DT 19613 4438 10 great great JJ 19613 4438 11 discord discord NN 19613 4438 12 existing exist VBG 19613 4438 13 in in IN 19613 4438 14 the the DT 19613 4438 15 religious religious JJ 19613 4438 16 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4438 17 of of IN 19613 4438 18 the the DT 19613 4438 19 age age NN 19613 4438 20 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4438 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4438 22 see see VB 19613 4438 23 p. p. NN 19613 4438 24 129 129 CD 19613 4438 25 , , , 19613 4438 26 vol vol NNP 19613 4438 27 . . . 19613 4439 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4439 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4439 3 . . . 19613 4440 1 No no DT 19613 4440 2 one one NN 19613 4440 3 denied deny VBD 19613 4440 4 the the DT 19613 4440 5 fact fact NN 19613 4440 6 that that IN 19613 4440 7 all all DT 19613 4440 8 truth truth NN 19613 4440 9 was be VBD 19613 4440 10 divine divine JJ 19613 4440 11 , , , 19613 4440 12 that that RB 19613 4440 13 is is RB 19613 4440 14 , , , 19613 4440 15 was be VBD 19613 4440 16 founded found VBN 19613 4440 17 on on IN 19613 4440 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 4440 19 . . . 19613 4441 1 The the DT 19613 4441 2 great great JJ 19613 4441 3 question question NN 19613 4441 4 , , , 19613 4441 5 however however RB 19613 4441 6 , , , 19613 4441 7 was be VBD 19613 4441 8 whether whether IN 19613 4441 9 every every DT 19613 4441 10 man man NN 19613 4441 11 possessed possess VBD 19613 4441 12 this this DT 19613 4441 13 truth truth NN 19613 4441 14 as as IN 19613 4441 15 a a DT 19613 4441 16 slumbering slumbering JJ 19613 4441 17 capacity capacity NN 19613 4441 18 that that WDT 19613 4441 19 only only RB 19613 4441 20 required require VBD 19613 4441 21 to to TO 19613 4441 22 be be VB 19613 4441 23 awakened awaken VBN 19613 4441 24 ; ; : 19613 4441 25 whether whether IN 19613 4441 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4441 27 was be VBD 19613 4441 28 rational rational JJ 19613 4441 29 , , , 19613 4441 30 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4441 31 , , , 19613 4441 32 merely merely RB 19613 4441 33 moral moral JJ 19613 4441 34 truth truth NN 19613 4441 35 , , , 19613 4441 36 or or CC 19613 4441 37 must must MD 19613 4441 38 be be VB 19613 4441 39 above above IN 19613 4441 40 that that IN 19613 4441 41 which which WDT 19613 4441 42 is be VBZ 19613 4441 43 moral moral JJ 19613 4441 44 , , , 19613 4441 45 that that RB 19613 4441 46 is is RB 19613 4441 47 , , , 19613 4441 48 of of IN 19613 4441 49 a a DT 19613 4441 50 religious religious JJ 19613 4441 51 nature nature NN 19613 4441 52 ; ; : 19613 4441 53 whether whether IN 19613 4441 54 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4441 55 must must MD 19613 4441 56 carry carry VB 19613 4441 57 man man NN 19613 4441 58 beyond beyond IN 19613 4441 59 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4441 60 ; ; : 19613 4441 61 and and CC 19613 4441 62 whether whether IN 19613 4441 63 a a DT 19613 4441 64 real real JJ 19613 4441 65 redemption redemption NN 19613 4441 66 was be VBD 19613 4441 67 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4441 68 . . . 19613 4442 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4442 2 is be VBZ 19613 4442 3 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 4442 4 the the DT 19613 4442 5 dispute dispute NN 19613 4442 6 between between IN 19613 4442 7 morality morality NN 19613 4442 8 and and CC 19613 4442 9 religion religion NN 19613 4442 10 , , , 19613 4442 11 which which WDT 19613 4442 12 appears appear VBZ 19613 4442 13 as as IN 19613 4442 14 an an DT 19613 4442 15 unsettled unsettled JJ 19613 4442 16 problem problem NN 19613 4442 17 in in IN 19613 4442 18 the the DT 19613 4442 19 these these DT 19613 4442 20 s s NNS 19613 4442 21 of of IN 19613 4442 22 the the DT 19613 4442 23 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 4442 24 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4442 25 and and CC 19613 4442 26 in in IN 19613 4442 27 the the DT 19613 4442 28 whole whole JJ 19613 4442 29 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4442 30 conceptions conception NNS 19613 4442 31 then then RB 19613 4442 32 current current JJ 19613 4442 33 among among IN 19613 4442 34 the the DT 19613 4442 35 educated educate VBN 19613 4442 36 , , , 19613 4442 37 and and CC 19613 4442 38 which which WDT 19613 4442 39 recurs recur VBZ 19613 4442 40 in in IN 19613 4442 41 the the DT 19613 4442 42 contrast contrast NN 19613 4442 43 between between IN 19613 4442 44 the the DT 19613 4442 45 Apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 4442 46 and and CC 19613 4442 47 the the DT 19613 4442 48 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 4442 49 theology theology NN 19613 4442 50 . . . 19613 4443 1 And and CC 19613 4443 2 , , , 19613 4443 3 as as IN 19613 4443 4 in in IN 19613 4443 5 the the DT 19613 4443 6 former former JJ 19613 4443 7 case case NN 19613 4443 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4443 9 meet meet VBP 19613 4443 10 with with IN 19613 4443 11 the the DT 19613 4443 12 most most RBS 19613 4443 13 varied varied JJ 19613 4443 14 shades shade NNS 19613 4443 15 and and CC 19613 4443 16 transitions transition NNS 19613 4443 17 , , , 19613 4443 18 for for IN 19613 4443 19 no no DT 19613 4443 20 one one CD 19613 4443 21 writer writer NN 19613 4443 22 has have VBZ 19613 4443 23 developed develop VBN 19613 4443 24 a a DT 19613 4443 25 consistent consistent JJ 19613 4443 26 theory theory NN 19613 4443 27 , , , 19613 4443 28 so so RB 19613 4443 29 also also RB 19613 4443 30 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4443 31 find find VBP 19613 4443 32 a a DT 19613 4443 33 similar similar JJ 19613 4443 34 state state NN 19613 4443 35 of of IN 19613 4443 36 things thing NNS 19613 4443 37 in in IN 19613 4443 38 the the DT 19613 4443 39 latter;[344 latter;[344 NNS 19613 4443 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4443 41 for for IN 19613 4443 42 no no DT 19613 4443 43 Apologist apologist NN 19613 4443 44 quite quite RB 19613 4443 45 left leave VBN 19613 4443 46 out out IN 19613 4443 47 of of IN 19613 4443 48 sight sight NN 19613 4443 49 the the DT 19613 4443 50 idea idea NN 19613 4443 51 of of IN 19613 4443 52 redemption redemption NN 19613 4443 53 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4443 54 deliverance deliverance NN 19613 4443 55 from from IN 19613 4443 56 the the DT 19613 4443 57 dominion dominion NN 19613 4443 58 of of IN 19613 4443 59 demons demon NNS 19613 4443 60 can can MD 19613 4443 61 only only RB 19613 4443 62 be be VB 19613 4443 63 effected effect VBN 19613 4443 64 by by IN 19613 4443 65 the the DT 19613 4443 66 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4443 67 , , , 19613 4443 68 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4443 69 , , , 19613 4443 70 God God NNP 19613 4443 71 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4443 72 . . . 19613 4444 1 Wherever wherever WRB 19613 4444 2 the the DT 19613 4444 3 idea idea NN 19613 4444 4 of of IN 19613 4444 5 freedom freedom NN 19613 4444 6 is be VBZ 19613 4444 7 strongly strongly RB 19613 4444 8 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 4444 9 , , , 19613 4444 10 the the DT 19613 4444 11 religious religious JJ 19613 4444 12 element element NN 19613 4444 13 , , , 19613 4444 14 in in IN 19613 4444 15 the the DT 19613 4444 16 strict strict JJ 19613 4444 17 sense sense NN 19613 4444 18 of of IN 19613 4444 19 the the DT 19613 4444 20 word word NN 19613 4444 21 , , , 19613 4444 22 appears appear VBZ 19613 4444 23 in in IN 19613 4444 24 jeopardy jeopardy NN 19613 4444 25 . . . 19613 4445 1 This this DT 19613 4445 2 is be VBZ 19613 4445 3 the the DT 19613 4445 4 case case NN 19613 4445 5 with with IN 19613 4445 6 the the DT 19613 4445 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4445 8 throughout throughout IN 19613 4445 9 . . . 19613 4446 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 4446 2 , , , 19613 4446 3 wherever wherever WRB 19613 4446 4 redemption redemption NN 19613 4446 5 forms form VBZ 19613 4446 6 the the DT 19613 4446 7 central central JJ 19613 4446 8 thought thought NN 19613 4446 9 , , , 19613 4446 10 need need NN 19613 4446 11 is be VBZ 19613 4446 12 felt feel VBN 19613 4446 13 of of IN 19613 4446 14 a a DT 19613 4446 15 suprarational suprarational JJ 19613 4446 16 truth truth NN 19613 4446 17 , , , 19613 4446 18 which which WDT 19613 4446 19 no no RB 19613 4446 20 longer long RBR 19613 4446 21 views view VBZ 19613 4446 22 morality morality NN 19613 4446 23 as as IN 19613 4446 24 the the DT 19613 4446 25 only only JJ 19613 4446 26 aim aim NN 19613 4446 27 , , , 19613 4446 28 and and CC 19613 4446 29 which which WDT 19613 4446 30 , , , 19613 4446 31 again again RB 19613 4446 32 , , , 19613 4446 33 requires require VBZ 19613 4446 34 particular particular JJ 19613 4446 35 media medium NNS 19613 4446 36 , , , 19613 4446 37 a a DT 19613 4446 38 sacred sacred JJ 19613 4446 39 history history NN 19613 4446 40 and and CC 19613 4446 41 sacred sacred JJ 19613 4446 42 symbols symbol NNS 19613 4446 43 . . . 19613 4447 1 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4447 2 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 4447 3 , , , 19613 4447 4 in in IN 19613 4447 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4447 6 logical logical JJ 19613 4447 7 development development NN 19613 4447 8 , , , 19613 4447 9 is be VBZ 19613 4447 10 menaced menace VBN 19613 4447 11 wherever wherever WRB 19613 4447 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4447 13 meet meet VBP 19613 4447 14 the the DT 19613 4447 15 perception perception NN 19613 4447 16 that that IN 19613 4447 17 the the DT 19613 4447 18 course course NN 19613 4447 19 of of IN 19613 4447 20 the the DT 19613 4447 21 world world NN 19613 4447 22 must must MD 19613 4447 23 in in IN 19613 4447 24 some some DT 19613 4447 25 way way NN 19613 4447 26 be be VB 19613 4447 27 helped help VBN 19613 4447 28 , , , 19613 4447 29 and and CC 19613 4447 30 wherever wherever WRB 19613 4447 31 the the DT 19613 4447 32 contrast contrast NN 19613 4447 33 between between IN 19613 4447 34 reason reason NN 19613 4447 35 and and CC 19613 4447 36 sensuousness sensuousness NN 19613 4447 37 , , , 19613 4447 38 that that IN 19613 4447 39 the the DT 19613 4447 40 old old JJ 19613 4447 41 Stoa Stoa NNP 19613 4447 42 had have VBD 19613 4447 43 confused confuse VBN 19613 4447 44 , , , 19613 4447 45 is be VBZ 19613 4447 46 clearly clearly RB 19613 4447 47 felt feel VBN 19613 4447 48 to to TO 19613 4447 49 be be VB 19613 4447 50 an an DT 19613 4447 51 unendurable unendurable JJ 19613 4447 52 state state NN 19613 4447 53 of of IN 19613 4447 54 antagonism antagonism NN 19613 4447 55 that that DT 19613 4447 56 man man NN 19613 4447 57 can can MD 19613 4447 58 not not RB 19613 4447 59 remove remove VB 19613 4447 60 by by IN 19613 4447 61 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4447 62 own own JJ 19613 4447 63 unaided unaided JJ 19613 4447 64 efforts effort NNS 19613 4447 65 . . . 19613 4448 1 The the DT 19613 4448 2 need need NN 19613 4448 3 of of IN 19613 4448 4 a a DT 19613 4448 5 revelation revelation NN 19613 4448 6 had have VBD 19613 4448 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4448 8 starting starting NN 19613 4448 9 - - HYPH 19613 4448 10 point point NN 19613 4448 11 in in IN 19613 4448 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4448 13 here here RB 19613 4448 14 . . . 19613 4449 1 The the DT 19613 4449 2 judgment judgment NN 19613 4449 3 of of IN 19613 4449 4 oneself oneself PRP 19613 4449 5 and and CC 19613 4449 6 of of IN 19613 4449 7 the the DT 19613 4449 8 world world NN 19613 4449 9 to to TO 19613 4449 10 which which WDT 19613 4449 11 Platonism Platonism NNP 19613 4449 12 led lead VBD 19613 4449 13 , , , 19613 4449 14 the the DT 19613 4449 15 self self NN 19613 4449 16 - - HYPH 19613 4449 17 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 4449 18 which which WDT 19613 4449 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4449 20 awakened awaken VBD 19613 4449 21 by by IN 19613 4449 22 the the DT 19613 4449 23 detachment detachment NN 19613 4449 24 of of IN 19613 4449 25 man man NN 19613 4449 26 from from IN 19613 4449 27 nature nature NN 19613 4449 28 , , , 19613 4449 29 and and CC 19613 4449 30 the the DT 19613 4449 31 contrasts contrast NNS 19613 4449 32 which which WDT 19613 4449 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4449 34 revealed reveal VBD 19613 4449 35 led lead VBN 19613 4449 36 of of IN 19613 4449 37 necessity necessity NN 19613 4449 38 to to IN 19613 4449 39 that that DT 19613 4449 40 frame frame NN 19613 4449 41 of of IN 19613 4449 42 mind mind NN 19613 4449 43 which which WDT 19613 4449 44 manifested manifest VBD 19613 4449 45 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4449 46 in in IN 19613 4449 47 the the DT 19613 4449 48 craving craving NN 19613 4449 49 for for IN 19613 4449 50 a a DT 19613 4449 51 revelation revelation NN 19613 4449 52 . . . 19613 4450 1 The the DT 19613 4450 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4450 3 felt feel VBD 19613 4450 4 this this DT 19613 4450 5 . . . 19613 4451 1 But but CC 19613 4451 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4451 3 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 4451 4 gave give VBD 19613 4451 5 a a DT 19613 4451 6 strange strange JJ 19613 4451 7 turn turn NN 19613 4451 8 to to IN 19613 4451 9 the the DT 19613 4451 10 satisfaction satisfaction NN 19613 4451 11 of of IN 19613 4451 12 that that DT 19613 4451 13 need need NN 19613 4451 14 . . . 19613 4452 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4452 2 was be VBD 19613 4452 3 not not RB 19613 4452 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4452 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 4452 6 ideas idea NNS 19613 4452 7 which which WDT 19613 4452 8 first first RB 19613 4452 9 involved involve VBD 19613 4452 10 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4452 11 in in IN 19613 4452 12 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 4452 13 . . . 19613 4453 1 At at IN 19613 4453 2 the the DT 19613 4453 3 time time NN 19613 4453 4 when when WRB 19613 4453 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4453 6 appeared appear VBD 19613 4453 7 on on IN 19613 4453 8 the the DT 19613 4453 9 scene scene NN 19613 4453 10 , , , 19613 4453 11 the the DT 19613 4453 12 Platonic platonic JJ 19613 4453 13 and and CC 19613 4453 14 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4453 15 systems system NNS 19613 4453 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4453 17 were be VBD 19613 4453 18 already already RB 19613 4453 19 so so RB 19613 4453 20 complicated complicated JJ 19613 4453 21 that that IN 19613 4453 22 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4453 23 did do VBD 19613 4453 24 not not RB 19613 4453 25 find find VB 19613 4453 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4453 27 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 4453 28 seriously seriously RB 19613 4453 29 increased increase VBN 19613 4453 30 by by IN 19613 4453 31 a a DT 19613 4453 32 consideration consideration NN 19613 4453 33 of of IN 19613 4453 34 the the DT 19613 4453 35 Christian christian JJ 19613 4453 36 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4453 37 . . . 19613 4454 1 As as IN 19613 4454 2 _ _ NNP 19613 4454 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4454 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4454 5 , , , 19613 4454 6 however however RB 19613 4454 7 , , , 19613 4454 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4454 9 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 4454 10 took take VBD 19613 4454 11 the the DT 19613 4454 12 part part NN 19613 4454 13 of of IN 19613 4454 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4454 15 because because IN 19613 4454 16 , , , 19613 4454 17 according accord VBG 19613 4454 18 to to IN 19613 4454 19 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4454 20 , , , 19613 4454 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4454 22 was be VBD 19613 4454 23 the the DT 19613 4454 24 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4454 25 of of IN 19613 4454 26 reason reason NN 19613 4454 27 and and CC 19613 4454 28 freedom freedom NN 19613 4454 29 . . . 19613 4455 1 The the DT 19613 4455 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 4455 3 was be VBD 19613 4455 4 hellenised hellenise VBN 19613 4455 5 in in IN 19613 4455 6 the the DT 19613 4455 7 second second JJ 19613 4455 8 century century NN 19613 4455 9 in in IN 19613 4455 10 so so RB 19613 4455 11 far far RB 19613 4455 12 as as IN 19613 4455 13 the the DT 19613 4455 14 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4455 15 in in IN 19613 4455 16 various various JJ 19613 4455 17 ways way NNS 19613 4455 18 transformed transform VBD 19613 4455 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4455 20 into into IN 19613 4455 21 a a DT 19613 4455 22 Hellenic hellenic JJ 19613 4455 23 religion religion NN 19613 4455 24 for for IN 19613 4455 25 the the DT 19613 4455 26 educated educate VBN 19613 4455 27 . . . 19613 4456 1 The the DT 19613 4456 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4456 3 used use VBD 19613 4456 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4456 5 -- -- : 19613 4456 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4456 7 may may MD 19613 4456 8 almost almost RB 19613 4456 9 say say VB 19613 4456 10 inadvertently inadvertently RB 19613 4456 11 -- -- : 19613 4456 12 to to TO 19613 4456 13 overthrow overthrow VB 19613 4456 14 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4456 15 by by IN 19613 4456 16 maintaining maintain VBG 19613 4456 17 that that IN 19613 4456 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4456 19 was be VBD 19613 4456 20 the the DT 19613 4456 21 realisation realisation NN 19613 4456 22 of of IN 19613 4456 23 an an DT 19613 4456 24 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 4456 25 moral moral JJ 19613 4456 26 theism theism NN 19613 4456 27 . . . 19613 4457 1 The the DT 19613 4457 2 Christian christian JJ 19613 4457 3 religion religion NN 19613 4457 4 was be VBD 19613 4457 5 not not RB 19613 4457 6 the the DT 19613 4457 7 first first JJ 19613 4457 8 to to TO 19613 4457 9 experience experience VB 19613 4457 10 this this DT 19613 4457 11 twofold twofold JJ 19613 4457 12 destiny destiny NN 19613 4457 13 on on IN 19613 4457 14 Græco Græco NNP 19613 4457 15 - - HYPH 19613 4457 16 Roman roman JJ 19613 4457 17 soil soil NN 19613 4457 18 . . . 19613 4458 1 A a DT 19613 4458 2 glance glance NN 19613 4458 3 at at IN 19613 4458 4 the the DT 19613 4458 5 history history NN 19613 4458 6 of of IN 19613 4458 7 the the DT 19613 4458 8 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 4458 9 religion religion NN 19613 4458 10 shows show VBZ 19613 4458 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4458 12 a a DT 19613 4458 13 parallel parallel JJ 19613 4458 14 development development NN 19613 4458 15 ; ; : 19613 4458 16 in in IN 19613 4458 17 fact fact NN 19613 4458 18 , , , 19613 4458 19 both both CC 19613 4458 20 the the DT 19613 4458 21 speculations speculation NNS 19613 4458 22 of of IN 19613 4458 23 the the DT 19613 4458 24 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4458 25 and and CC 19613 4458 26 the the DT 19613 4458 27 theories theory NNS 19613 4458 28 of of IN 19613 4458 29 the the DT 19613 4458 30 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4458 31 were be VBD 19613 4458 32 foreshadowed foreshadow VBN 19613 4458 33 in in IN 19613 4458 34 the the DT 19613 4458 35 theology theology NN 19613 4458 36 of of IN 19613 4458 37 the the DT 19613 4458 38 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 4458 39 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 4458 40 , , , 19613 4458 41 and and CC 19613 4458 42 particularly particularly RB 19613 4458 43 in in IN 19613 4458 44 that that DT 19613 4458 45 of of IN 19613 4458 46 Philo Philo NNP 19613 4458 47 . . . 19613 4459 1 Here here RB 19613 4459 2 also also RB 19613 4459 3 the the DT 19613 4459 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 4459 5 merely merely RB 19613 4459 6 entered enter VBD 19613 4459 7 upon upon IN 19613 4459 8 the the DT 19613 4459 9 heritage heritage NN 19613 4459 10 of of IN 19613 4459 11 Judaism Judaism NNP 19613 4459 12 . . . 19613 4460 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4460 2 345 345 CD 19613 4460 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4460 4 Three three CD 19613 4460 5 centuries century NNS 19613 4460 6 before before IN 19613 4460 7 the the DT 19613 4460 8 appearance appearance NN 19613 4460 9 of of IN 19613 4460 10 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4460 11 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4460 12 , , , 19613 4460 13 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 4460 14 , , , 19613 4460 15 who who WP 19613 4460 16 had have VBD 19613 4460 17 received receive VBN 19613 4460 18 a a DT 19613 4460 19 Hellenic hellenic JJ 19613 4460 20 training training NN 19613 4460 21 , , , 19613 4460 22 had have VBD 19613 4460 23 already already RB 19613 4460 24 set set VBN 19613 4460 25 forth forth RP 19613 4460 26 the the DT 19613 4460 27 religion religion NN 19613 4460 28 of of IN 19613 4460 29 Jehovah Jehovah NNP 19613 4460 30 to to IN 19613 4460 31 the the DT 19613 4460 32 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4460 33 in in IN 19613 4460 34 that that DT 19613 4460 35 remarkably remarkably RB 19613 4460 36 summary summary VBP 19613 4460 37 and and CC 19613 4460 38 spiritualised spiritualise VBN 19613 4460 39 form form NN 19613 4460 40 which which WDT 19613 4460 41 represents represent VBZ 19613 4460 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4460 43 as as IN 19613 4460 44 the the DT 19613 4460 45 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4460 46 and and CC 19613 4460 47 highest high JJS 19613 4460 48 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4460 49 , , , 19613 4460 50 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4460 51 , , , 19613 4460 52 the the DT 19613 4460 53 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4460 54 of of IN 19613 4460 55 God God NNP 19613 4460 56 , , , 19613 4460 57 of of IN 19613 4460 58 virtue virtue NN 19613 4460 59 , , , 19613 4460 60 and and CC 19613 4460 61 of of IN 19613 4460 62 recompense recompense NN 19613 4460 63 in in IN 19613 4460 64 the the DT 19613 4460 65 next next JJ 19613 4460 66 world world NN 19613 4460 67 . . . 19613 4461 1 Here here RB 19613 4461 2 these these DT 19613 4461 3 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 4461 4 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4461 5 had have VBD 19613 4461 6 already already RB 19613 4461 7 transformed transform VBN 19613 4461 8 all all PDT 19613 4461 9 the the DT 19613 4461 10 positive positive JJ 19613 4461 11 and and CC 19613 4461 12 historic historic JJ 19613 4461 13 elements element NNS 19613 4461 14 of of IN 19613 4461 15 the the DT 19613 4461 16 national national JJ 19613 4461 17 religion religion NN 19613 4461 18 into into IN 19613 4461 19 parts part NNS 19613 4461 20 of of IN 19613 4461 21 a a DT 19613 4461 22 huge huge JJ 19613 4461 23 system system NN 19613 4461 24 for for IN 19613 4461 25 proving prove VBG 19613 4461 26 the the DT 19613 4461 27 truth truth NN 19613 4461 28 of of IN 19613 4461 29 that that DT 19613 4461 30 theism theism NN 19613 4461 31 . . . 19613 4462 1 The the DT 19613 4462 2 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4462 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4462 4 adopted adopt VBD 19613 4462 5 this this DT 19613 4462 6 method method NN 19613 4462 7 , , , 19613 4462 8 for for IN 19613 4462 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4462 10 can can MD 19613 4462 11 hardly hardly RB 19613 4462 12 be be VB 19613 4462 13 said say VBN 19613 4462 14 to to TO 19613 4462 15 have have VB 19613 4462 16 invented invent VBN 19613 4462 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4462 18 anew anew RB 19613 4462 19 . . . 19613 4463 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4463 2 346 346 CD 19613 4463 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4463 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4463 5 see see VBP 19613 4463 6 from from IN 19613 4463 7 the the DT 19613 4463 8 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 4463 9 Sibylline Sibylline NNP 19613 4463 10 oracles oracle VBZ 19613 4463 11 how how WRB 19613 4463 12 wide wide RB 19613 4463 13 - - HYPH 19613 4463 14 spread spread NN 19613 4463 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4463 16 was be VBD 19613 4463 17 . . . 19613 4464 1 Philo Philo NNP 19613 4464 2 , , , 19613 4464 3 however however RB 19613 4464 4 , , , 19613 4464 5 was be VBD 19613 4464 6 not not RB 19613 4464 7 only only RB 19613 4464 8 a a DT 19613 4464 9 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 4464 10 rationalist rationalist NN 19613 4464 11 , , , 19613 4464 12 but but CC 19613 4464 13 a a DT 19613 4464 14 hyper hyper JJ 19613 4464 15 - - JJ 19613 4464 16 Platonic platonic JJ 19613 4464 17 religious religious JJ 19613 4464 18 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4464 19 . . . 19613 4465 1 In in IN 19613 4465 2 like like JJ 19613 4465 3 manner manner NN 19613 4465 4 , , , 19613 4465 5 the the DT 19613 4465 6 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4465 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4465 8 did do VBD 19613 4465 9 not not RB 19613 4465 10 altogether altogether RB 19613 4465 11 lack lack VB 19613 4465 12 this this DT 19613 4465 13 element element NN 19613 4465 14 , , , 19613 4465 15 though though IN 19613 4465 16 in in IN 19613 4465 17 some some DT 19613 4465 18 isolated isolate VBN 19613 4465 19 cases case NNS 19613 4465 20 among among IN 19613 4465 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4465 22 there there EX 19613 4465 23 are be VBP 19613 4465 24 hardly hardly RB 19613 4465 25 any any DT 19613 4465 26 traces trace NNS 19613 4465 27 of of IN 19613 4465 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4465 29 . . . 19613 4466 1 This this DT 19613 4466 2 feature feature NN 19613 4466 3 is be VBZ 19613 4466 4 most most RBS 19613 4466 5 fully fully RB 19613 4466 6 represented represent VBN 19613 4466 7 among among IN 19613 4466 8 the the DT 19613 4466 9 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4466 10 . . . 19613 4467 1 This this DT 19613 4467 2 transformation transformation NN 19613 4467 3 of of IN 19613 4467 4 religion religion NN 19613 4467 5 into into IN 19613 4467 6 a a DT 19613 4467 7 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 4467 8 system system NN 19613 4467 9 would would MD 19613 4467 10 not not RB 19613 4467 11 have have VB 19613 4467 12 been be VBN 19613 4467 13 possible possible JJ 19613 4467 14 had have VBD 19613 4467 15 not not RB 19613 4467 16 Greek greek JJ 19613 4467 17 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4467 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4467 19 happened happen VBD 19613 4467 20 to to TO 19613 4467 21 be be VB 19613 4467 22 in in IN 19613 4467 23 process process NN 19613 4467 24 of of IN 19613 4467 25 development development NN 19613 4467 26 into into IN 19613 4467 27 a a DT 19613 4467 28 religion religion NN 19613 4467 29 . . . 19613 4468 1 Such such PDT 19613 4468 2 a a DT 19613 4468 3 transformation transformation NN 19613 4468 4 was be VBD 19613 4468 5 certainly certainly RB 19613 4468 6 very very RB 19613 4468 7 foreign foreign JJ 19613 4468 8 to to IN 19613 4468 9 the the DT 19613 4468 10 really really RB 19613 4468 11 classical classical JJ 19613 4468 12 time time NN 19613 4468 13 of of IN 19613 4468 14 Greece Greece NNP 19613 4468 15 and and CC 19613 4468 16 Rome Rome NNP 19613 4468 17 . . . 19613 4469 1 The the DT 19613 4469 2 pious pious JJ 19613 4469 3 belief belief NN 19613 4469 4 in in IN 19613 4469 5 the the DT 19613 4469 6 efficacy efficacy NN 19613 4469 7 and and CC 19613 4469 8 power power NN 19613 4469 9 of of IN 19613 4469 10 the the DT 19613 4469 11 gods god NNS 19613 4469 12 and and CC 19613 4469 13 in in IN 19613 4469 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4469 15 appearances appearance NNS 19613 4469 16 and and CC 19613 4469 17 manifestations manifestation NNS 19613 4469 18 , , , 19613 4469 19 as as RB 19613 4469 20 well well RB 19613 4469 21 as as IN 19613 4469 22 the the DT 19613 4469 23 traditional traditional JJ 19613 4469 24 worship worship NN 19613 4469 25 , , , 19613 4469 26 could could MD 19613 4469 27 have have VB 19613 4469 28 no no DT 19613 4469 29 bond bond NN 19613 4469 30 of of IN 19613 4469 31 union union NN 19613 4469 32 with with IN 19613 4469 33 speculations speculation NNS 19613 4469 34 concerning concern VBG 19613 4469 35 the the DT 19613 4469 36 essence essence NN 19613 4469 37 and and CC 19613 4469 38 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 4469 39 cause cause NN 19613 4469 40 of of IN 19613 4469 41 things thing NNS 19613 4469 42 . . . 19613 4470 1 The the DT 19613 4470 2 idea idea NN 19613 4470 3 of of IN 19613 4470 4 a a DT 19613 4470 5 religious religious JJ 19613 4470 6 dogma dogma NN 19613 4470 7 which which WDT 19613 4470 8 was be VBD 19613 4470 9 at at IN 19613 4470 10 once once RB 19613 4470 11 to to TO 19613 4470 12 furnish furnish VB 19613 4470 13 a a DT 19613 4470 14 correct correct JJ 19613 4470 15 theory theory NN 19613 4470 16 of of IN 19613 4470 17 the the DT 19613 4470 18 world world NN 19613 4470 19 and and CC 19613 4470 20 a a DT 19613 4470 21 principle principle NN 19613 4470 22 of of IN 19613 4470 23 conduct conduct NN 19613 4470 24 was be VBD 19613 4470 25 from from IN 19613 4470 26 this this DT 19613 4470 27 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 4470 28 completely completely RB 19613 4470 29 unintelligible unintelligible JJ 19613 4470 30 . . . 19613 4471 1 But but CC 19613 4471 2 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4471 3 , , , 19613 4471 4 particularly particularly RB 19613 4471 5 in in IN 19613 4471 6 the the DT 19613 4471 7 Stoa Stoa NNP 19613 4471 8 , , , 19613 4471 9 set set VBN 19613 4471 10 out out RP 19613 4471 11 in in IN 19613 4471 12 search search NN 19613 4471 13 of of IN 19613 4471 14 this this DT 19613 4471 15 idea idea NN 19613 4471 16 , , , 19613 4471 17 and and CC 19613 4471 18 , , , 19613 4471 19 after after IN 19613 4471 20 further further JJ 19613 4471 21 developments development NNS 19613 4471 22 , , , 19613 4471 23 sought seek VBN 19613 4471 24 for for IN 19613 4471 25 one one CD 19613 4471 26 special special JJ 19613 4471 27 religion religion NN 19613 4471 28 with with IN 19613 4471 29 which which WDT 19613 4471 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4471 31 could could MD 19613 4471 32 agree agree VB 19613 4471 33 or or CC 19613 4471 34 through through IN 19613 4471 35 which which WDT 19613 4471 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4471 37 could could MD 19613 4471 38 at at IN 19613 4471 39 least least RBS 19613 4471 40 attain attain VB 19613 4471 41 certainty certainty NN 19613 4471 42 . . . 19613 4472 1 The the DT 19613 4472 2 meagre meagre JJ 19613 4472 3 cults cult NNS 19613 4472 4 of of IN 19613 4472 5 the the DT 19613 4472 6 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4472 7 and and CC 19613 4472 8 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 4472 9 were be VBD 19613 4472 10 unsuited unsuited JJ 19613 4472 11 for for IN 19613 4472 12 this this DT 19613 4472 13 . . . 19613 4473 1 So so IN 19613 4473 2 men man NNS 19613 4473 3 turned turn VBD 19613 4473 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4473 5 eyes eye NNS 19613 4473 6 towards towards IN 19613 4473 7 the the DT 19613 4473 8 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4473 9 . . . 19613 4474 1 Nothing nothing NN 19613 4474 2 more more RBR 19613 4474 3 clearly clearly RB 19613 4474 4 characterises characterise VBZ 19613 4474 5 the the DT 19613 4474 6 position position NN 19613 4474 7 of of IN 19613 4474 8 things thing NNS 19613 4474 9 in in IN 19613 4474 10 the the DT 19613 4474 11 second second JJ 19613 4474 12 century century NN 19613 4474 13 than than IN 19613 4474 14 the the DT 19613 4474 15 agreement agreement NN 19613 4474 16 between between IN 19613 4474 17 two two CD 19613 4474 18 men man NNS 19613 4474 19 so so RB 19613 4474 20 radically radically RB 19613 4474 21 different different JJ 19613 4474 22 as as IN 19613 4474 23 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4474 24 and and CC 19613 4474 25 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 4474 26 . . . 19613 4475 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4475 2 emphatically emphatically RB 19613 4475 3 declares declare VBZ 19613 4475 4 that that IN 19613 4475 5 salvation salvation NN 19613 4475 6 comes come VBZ 19613 4475 7 from from IN 19613 4475 8 the the DT 19613 4475 9 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4475 10 , , , 19613 4475 11 and and CC 19613 4475 12 to to IN 19613 4475 13 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 4475 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4475 15 is be VBZ 19613 4475 16 also also RB 19613 4475 17 a a DT 19613 4475 18 " " `` 19613 4475 19 truism truism NN 19613 4475 20 " " '' 19613 4475 21 that that IN 19613 4475 22 the the DT 19613 4475 23 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4475 24 have have VBP 19613 4475 25 more more JJR 19613 4475 26 capacity capacity NN 19613 4475 27 than than IN 19613 4475 28 the the DT 19613 4475 29 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4475 30 for for IN 19613 4475 31 discovering discover VBG 19613 4475 32 valuable valuable JJ 19613 4475 33 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4475 34 . . . 19613 4476 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4476 2 347 347 CD 19613 4476 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4476 4 Everything everything NN 19613 4476 5 was be VBD 19613 4476 6 in in IN 19613 4476 7 fact fact NN 19613 4476 8 prepared prepare VBN 19613 4476 9 , , , 19613 4476 10 and and CC 19613 4476 11 nothing nothing NN 19613 4476 12 was be VBD 19613 4476 13 wanting want VBG 19613 4476 14 . . . 19613 4477 1 About about IN 19613 4477 2 the the DT 19613 4477 3 middle middle NN 19613 4477 4 of of IN 19613 4477 5 the the DT 19613 4477 6 second second JJ 19613 4477 7 century century NN 19613 4477 8 , , , 19613 4477 9 however however RB 19613 4477 10 , , , 19613 4477 11 the the DT 19613 4477 12 moral moral JJ 19613 4477 13 and and CC 19613 4477 14 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 19613 4477 15 element element NN 19613 4477 16 in in IN 19613 4477 17 the the DT 19613 4477 18 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4477 19 and and CC 19613 4477 20 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4477 21 culture culture NN 19613 4477 22 of of IN 19613 4477 23 the the DT 19613 4477 24 time time NN 19613 4477 25 was be VBD 19613 4477 26 still still RB 19613 4477 27 more more RBR 19613 4477 28 powerful powerful JJ 19613 4477 29 than than IN 19613 4477 30 the the DT 19613 4477 31 religious religious JJ 19613 4477 32 and and CC 19613 4477 33 mystic mystic JJ 19613 4477 34 ; ; : 19613 4477 35 for for IN 19613 4477 36 Neoplatonism Neoplatonism NNP 19613 4477 37 , , , 19613 4477 38 which which WDT 19613 4477 39 under under IN 19613 4477 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4477 41 outward outward JJ 19613 4477 42 coverings covering NNS 19613 4477 43 concealed conceal VBD 19613 4477 44 the the DT 19613 4477 45 aspiration aspiration NN 19613 4477 46 after after IN 19613 4477 47 religion religion NN 19613 4477 48 and and CC 19613 4477 49 the the DT 19613 4477 50 living live VBG 19613 4477 51 God God NNP 19613 4477 52 , , , 19613 4477 53 was be VBD 19613 4477 54 only only RB 19613 4477 55 in in IN 19613 4477 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4477 57 first first JJ 19613 4477 58 beginnings beginning NNS 19613 4477 59 . . . 19613 4478 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4478 2 was be VBD 19613 4478 3 not not RB 19613 4478 4 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 4478 5 in in IN 19613 4478 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 4478 7 circles circle NNS 19613 4478 8 . . . 19613 4479 1 The the DT 19613 4479 2 " " `` 19613 4479 3 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4479 4 " " '' 19613 4479 5 were be VBD 19613 4479 6 in in IN 19613 4479 7 the the DT 19613 4479 8 minority minority NN 19613 4479 9 . . . 19613 4480 1 What what WP 19613 4480 2 the the DT 19613 4480 3 great great JJ 19613 4480 4 majority majority NN 19613 4480 5 of of IN 19613 4480 6 the the DT 19613 4480 7 Church Church NNP 19613 4480 8 felt feel VBD 19613 4480 9 to to TO 19613 4480 10 be be VB 19613 4480 11 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 4480 12 and and CC 19613 4480 13 edifying edify VBG 19613 4480 14 above above IN 19613 4480 15 everything everything NN 19613 4480 16 else else RB 19613 4480 17 was be VBD 19613 4480 18 an an DT 19613 4480 19 earnest earnest JJ 19613 4480 20 moralism moralism NN 19613 4480 21 . . . 19613 4481 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4481 2 348 348 CD 19613 4481 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4481 4 New New NNP 19613 4481 5 and and CC 19613 4481 6 strange strange JJ 19613 4481 7 as as IN 19613 4481 8 the the DT 19613 4481 9 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 4481 10 to to TO 19613 4481 11 represent represent VB 19613 4481 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4481 13 as as IN 19613 4481 14 a a DT 19613 4481 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4481 16 might may MD 19613 4481 17 seem seem VB 19613 4481 18 at at IN 19613 4481 19 first first RB 19613 4481 20 , , , 19613 4481 21 the the DT 19613 4481 22 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4481 23 , , , 19613 4481 24 so so RB 19613 4481 25 far far RB 19613 4481 26 as as IN 19613 4481 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4481 28 were be VBD 19613 4481 29 understood understand VBN 19613 4481 30 , , , 19613 4481 31 appeared appear VBD 19613 4481 32 to to TO 19613 4481 33 advance advance VB 19613 4481 34 nothing nothing NN 19613 4481 35 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 19613 4481 36 with with IN 19613 4481 37 Christian christian JJ 19613 4481 38 common common JJ 19613 4481 39 sense sense NN 19613 4481 40 . . . 19613 4482 1 Besides besides RB 19613 4482 2 , , , 19613 4482 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4482 4 did do VBD 19613 4482 5 not not RB 19613 4482 6 question question VB 19613 4482 7 authorities authority NNS 19613 4482 8 , , , 19613 4482 9 but but CC 19613 4482 10 rather rather RB 19613 4482 11 supported support VBD 19613 4482 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4482 13 , , , 19613 4482 14 and and CC 19613 4482 15 introduced introduce VBD 19613 4482 16 no no DT 19613 4482 17 foreign foreign JJ 19613 4482 18 positive positive JJ 19613 4482 19 materials material NNS 19613 4482 20 . . . 19613 4483 1 For for IN 19613 4483 2 all all PDT 19613 4483 3 these these DT 19613 4483 4 reasons reason NNS 19613 4483 5 , , , 19613 4483 6 and and CC 19613 4483 7 also also RB 19613 4483 8 because because IN 19613 4483 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4483 10 writings writing NNS 19613 4483 11 were be VBD 19613 4483 12 not not RB 19613 4483 13 at at IN 19613 4483 14 first first RB 19613 4483 15 addressed address VBN 19613 4483 16 to to IN 19613 4483 17 the the DT 19613 4483 18 communities community NNS 19613 4483 19 , , , 19613 4483 20 but but CC 19613 4483 21 only only RB 19613 4483 22 to to IN 19613 4483 23 outsiders outsider NNS 19613 4483 24 , , , 19613 4483 25 the the DT 19613 4483 26 marvellous marvellous JJ 19613 4483 27 attempt attempt NN 19613 4483 28 to to TO 19613 4483 29 present present VB 19613 4483 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4483 31 to to IN 19613 4483 32 the the DT 19613 4483 33 world world NN 19613 4483 34 as as IN 19613 4483 35 the the DT 19613 4483 36 religion religion NN 19613 4483 37 which which WDT 19613 4483 38 is be VBZ 19613 4483 39 the the DT 19613 4483 40 true true JJ 19613 4483 41 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4483 42 , , , 19613 4483 43 and and CC 19613 4483 44 as as IN 19613 4483 45 the the DT 19613 4483 46 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4483 47 which which WDT 19613 4483 48 is be VBZ 19613 4483 49 the the DT 19613 4483 50 true true JJ 19613 4483 51 religion religion NN 19613 4483 52 , , , 19613 4483 53 remained remain VBD 19613 4483 54 unopposed unopposed JJ 19613 4483 55 in in IN 19613 4483 56 the the DT 19613 4483 57 Church Church NNP 19613 4483 58 . . . 19613 4484 1 But but CC 19613 4484 2 in in IN 19613 4484 3 what what WDT 19613 4484 4 sense sense NN 19613 4484 5 was be VBD 19613 4484 6 the the DT 19613 4484 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 4484 8 religion religion NN 19613 4484 9 set set VBD 19613 4484 10 forth forth RP 19613 4484 11 as as IN 19613 4484 12 a a DT 19613 4484 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4484 14 ? ? . 19613 4485 1 An an DT 19613 4485 2 exact exact JJ 19613 4485 3 answer answer NN 19613 4485 4 to to IN 19613 4485 5 this this DT 19613 4485 6 question question NN 19613 4485 7 is be VBZ 19613 4485 8 of of IN 19613 4485 9 the the DT 19613 4485 10 highest high JJS 19613 4485 11 interest interest NN 19613 4485 12 as as IN 19613 4485 13 regards regard VBZ 19613 4485 14 the the DT 19613 4485 15 history history NN 19613 4485 16 of of IN 19613 4485 17 Christian christian JJ 19613 4485 18 dogma dogma NN 19613 4485 19 . . . 19613 4486 1 2 2 LS 19613 4486 2 . . . 19613 4487 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4487 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4487 3 as as IN 19613 4487 4 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 4487 5 and and CC 19613 4487 6 as as IN 19613 4487 7 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 4487 8 _ _ NNP 19613 4487 9 . . . 19613 4488 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4488 2 was be VBD 19613 4488 3 a a DT 19613 4488 4 new new JJ 19613 4488 5 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 4488 6 and and CC 19613 4488 7 one one CD 19613 4488 8 of of IN 19613 4488 9 permanent permanent JJ 19613 4488 10 importance importance NN 19613 4488 11 to to IN 19613 4488 12 a a DT 19613 4488 13 tradition tradition NN 19613 4488 14 hitherto hitherto VBN 19613 4488 15 so so RB 19613 4488 16 little little JJ 19613 4488 17 concerned concerned JJ 19613 4488 18 for for IN 19613 4488 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4488 20 own own JJ 19613 4488 21 vindication vindication NN 19613 4488 22 , , , 19613 4488 23 when when WRB 19613 4488 24 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 19613 4488 25 and and CC 19613 4488 26 the the DT 19613 4488 27 Athenian athenian JJ 19613 4488 28 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4488 29 , , , 19613 4488 30 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 4488 31 , , , 19613 4488 32 presented present VBD 19613 4488 33 treatises treatise NNS 19613 4488 34 in in IN 19613 4488 35 defence defence NN 19613 4488 36 of of IN 19613 4488 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4488 38 to to IN 19613 4488 39 the the DT 19613 4488 40 emperor emperor NN 19613 4488 41 . . . 19613 4489 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4489 2 349 349 CD 19613 4489 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4489 4 About about RB 19613 4489 5 a a DT 19613 4489 6 century century NN 19613 4489 7 had have VBD 19613 4489 8 elapsed elapse VBN 19613 4489 9 since since IN 19613 4489 10 the the DT 19613 4489 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 4489 12 of of IN 19613 4489 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4489 14 had have VBD 19613 4489 15 begun begin VBN 19613 4489 16 to to TO 19613 4489 17 be be VB 19613 4489 18 preached preach VBN 19613 4489 19 . . . 19613 4490 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4490 2 may may MD 19613 4490 3 be be VB 19613 4490 4 said say VBN 19613 4490 5 that that IN 19613 4490 6 the the DT 19613 4490 7 Apology Apology NNP 19613 4490 8 of of IN 19613 4490 9 Aristides Aristides NNPS 19613 4490 10 was be VBD 19613 4490 11 a a DT 19613 4490 12 most most RBS 19613 4490 13 significant significant JJ 19613 4490 14 opening opening NN 19613 4490 15 to to IN 19613 4490 16 the the DT 19613 4490 17 second second JJ 19613 4490 18 century century NN 19613 4490 19 , , , 19613 4490 20 whilst whilst IN 19613 4490 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4490 22 find find VBP 19613 4490 23 Origen Origen NNP 19613 4490 24 at at IN 19613 4490 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4490 26 close close NN 19613 4490 27 . . . 19613 4491 1 Marcianus Marcianus NNP 19613 4491 2 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 4491 3 expressly expressly RB 19613 4491 4 designates designate VBZ 19613 4491 5 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4491 6 in in IN 19613 4491 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4491 8 pamphlet pamphlet NN 19613 4491 9 as as IN 19613 4491 10 a a DT 19613 4491 11 _ _ NNP 19613 4491 12 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4491 13 of of IN 19613 4491 14 the the DT 19613 4491 15 Athenians Athenians NNPS 19613 4491 16 _ _ NNP 19613 4491 17 . . . 19613 4492 1 Since since IN 19613 4492 2 the the DT 19613 4492 3 days day NNS 19613 4492 4 when when WRB 19613 4492 5 the the DT 19613 4492 6 words word NNS 19613 4492 7 were be VBD 19613 4492 8 written write VBN 19613 4492 9 : : : 19613 4492 10 " " `` 19613 4492 11 Beware beware VB 19613 4492 12 lest lest IN 19613 4492 13 any any DT 19613 4492 14 man man NN 19613 4492 15 spoil spoil VB 19613 4492 16 you -PRON- PRP 19613 4492 17 through through IN 19613 4492 18 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4492 19 and and CC 19613 4492 20 vain vain JJ 19613 4492 21 deceit deceit NN 19613 4492 22 " " '' 19613 4492 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4492 24 Col Col NNP 19613 4492 25 . . NNP 19613 4492 26 II ii CD 19613 4492 27 . . . 19613 4493 1 8) 8) CD 19613 4493 2 , , , 19613 4493 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4493 4 had have VBD 19613 4493 5 constantly constantly RB 19613 4493 6 been be VBN 19613 4493 7 repeated repeat VBN 19613 4493 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4493 9 see see VB 19613 4493 10 , , , 19613 4493 11 as as IN 19613 4493 12 evidence evidence NN 19613 4493 13 , , , 19613 4493 14 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 4493 15 , , , 19613 4493 16 passim passim NN 19613 4493 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4493 18 that that IN 19613 4493 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 4493 20 preaching preaching NN 19613 4493 21 and and CC 19613 4493 22 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4493 23 were be VBD 19613 4493 24 things thing NNS 19613 4493 25 entirely entirely RB 19613 4493 26 different different JJ 19613 4493 27 , , , 19613 4493 28 that that IN 19613 4493 29 God God NNP 19613 4493 30 had have VBD 19613 4493 31 chosen choose VBN 19613 4493 32 the the DT 19613 4493 33 fools fool NNS 19613 4493 34 , , , 19613 4493 35 and and CC 19613 4493 36 that that DT 19613 4493 37 man man NN 19613 4493 38 's 's POS 19613 4493 39 duty duty NN 19613 4493 40 was be VBD 19613 4493 41 not not RB 19613 4493 42 to to TO 19613 4493 43 investigate investigate VB 19613 4493 44 and and CC 19613 4493 45 seek seek VB 19613 4493 46 , , , 19613 4493 47 but but CC 19613 4493 48 to to TO 19613 4493 49 believe believe VB 19613 4493 50 and and CC 19613 4493 51 hope hope VB 19613 4493 52 . . . 19613 4494 1 Now now RB 19613 4494 2 a a DT 19613 4494 3 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4494 4 , , , 19613 4494 5 as as IN 19613 4494 6 such such JJ 19613 4494 7 , , , 19613 4494 8 pleaded plead VBD 19613 4494 9 the the DT 19613 4494 10 cause cause NN 19613 4494 11 of of IN 19613 4494 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4494 13 . . . 19613 4495 1 In in IN 19613 4495 2 the the DT 19613 4495 3 summary summary NN 19613 4495 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4495 5 gave give VBD 19613 4495 6 of of IN 19613 4495 7 the the DT 19613 4495 8 content content NN 19613 4495 9 of of IN 19613 4495 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4495 11 at at IN 19613 4495 12 the the DT 19613 4495 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 4495 14 of of IN 19613 4495 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4495 16 address address NN 19613 4495 17 , , , 19613 4495 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4495 19 really really RB 19613 4495 20 spoke speak VBD 19613 4495 21 as as IN 19613 4495 22 a a DT 19613 4495 23 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4495 24 and and CC 19613 4495 25 represented represent VBD 19613 4495 26 this this DT 19613 4495 27 faith faith NN 19613 4495 28 as as IN 19613 4495 29 a a DT 19613 4495 30 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4495 31 . . . 19613 4496 1 By by IN 19613 4496 2 expounding expound VBG 19613 4496 3 pure pure JJ 19613 4496 4 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 4496 5 and and CC 19613 4496 6 giving give VBG 19613 4496 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4496 8 the the DT 19613 4496 9 main main JJ 19613 4496 10 place place NN 19613 4496 11 in in IN 19613 4496 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4496 13 argument argument NN 19613 4496 14 , , , 19613 4496 15 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 4496 16 gave give VBD 19613 4496 17 supreme supreme JJ 19613 4496 18 prominence prominence NN 19613 4496 19 to to IN 19613 4496 20 the the DT 19613 4496 21 very very JJ 19613 4496 22 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4496 23 which which WDT 19613 4496 24 simple simple JJ 19613 4496 25 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4496 26 also also RB 19613 4496 27 prized prize VBD 19613 4496 28 as as IN 19613 4496 29 the the DT 19613 4496 30 most most RBS 19613 4496 31 important important JJ 19613 4496 32 . . . 19613 4497 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4497 2 350 350 CD 19613 4497 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4497 4 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4497 5 , , , 19613 4497 6 in in IN 19613 4497 7 emphasing emphase VBG 19613 4497 8 not not RB 19613 4497 9 only only RB 19613 4497 10 the the DT 19613 4497 11 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 4497 12 character character NN 19613 4497 13 of of IN 19613 4497 14 the the DT 19613 4497 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 4497 16 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4497 17 revealed reveal VBN 19613 4497 18 by by IN 19613 4497 19 the the DT 19613 4497 20 Son Son NNP 19613 4497 21 of of IN 19613 4497 22 the the DT 19613 4497 23 Most most RBS 19613 4497 24 High high JJ 19613 4497 25 God God NNP 19613 4497 26 , , , 19613 4497 27 but but CC 19613 4497 28 also also RB 19613 4497 29 the the DT 19613 4497 30 continuous continuous JJ 19613 4497 31 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 4497 32 of of IN 19613 4497 33 believers believer NNS 19613 4497 34 -- -- : 19613 4497 35 the the DT 19613 4497 36 new new JJ 19613 4497 37 _ _ NNP 19613 4497 38 race race NN 19613 4497 39 _ _ NNP 19613 4497 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4497 41 not not RB 19613 4497 42 a a DT 19613 4497 43 new new JJ 19613 4497 44 _ _ NNP 19613 4497 45 school_)--he school_)--he NNP 19613 4497 46 confessed confess VBD 19613 4497 47 in in IN 19613 4497 48 the the DT 19613 4497 49 most most RBS 19613 4497 50 express express JJ 19613 4497 51 way way NN 19613 4497 52 the the DT 19613 4497 53 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4497 54 nature nature NN 19613 4497 55 of of IN 19613 4497 56 this this DT 19613 4497 57 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4497 58 as as IN 19613 4497 59 a a DT 19613 4497 60 divine divine JJ 19613 4497 61 truth truth NN 19613 4497 62 . . . 19613 4498 1 According accord VBG 19613 4498 2 to to IN 19613 4498 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4498 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4498 5 is be VBZ 19613 4498 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4498 7 because because IN 19613 4498 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4498 9 content content NN 19613 4498 10 is be VBZ 19613 4498 11 in in IN 19613 4498 12 accordance accordance NN 19613 4498 13 with with IN 19613 4498 14 reason reason NN 19613 4498 15 , , , 19613 4498 16 and and CC 19613 4498 17 because because IN 19613 4498 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4498 19 gives give VBZ 19613 4498 20 a a DT 19613 4498 21 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 19613 4498 22 and and CC 19613 4498 23 universally universally RB 19613 4498 24 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 4498 25 answer answer NN 19613 4498 26 to to IN 19613 4498 27 the the DT 19613 4498 28 questions question NNS 19613 4498 29 with with IN 19613 4498 30 which which WDT 19613 4498 31 all all DT 19613 4498 32 real real JJ 19613 4498 33 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4498 34 have have VBP 19613 4498 35 concerned concern VBN 19613 4498 36 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4498 37 . . . 19613 4499 1 But but CC 19613 4499 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4499 3 is be VBZ 19613 4499 4 no no DT 19613 4499 5 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4499 6 , , , 19613 4499 7 in in IN 19613 4499 8 fact fact NN 19613 4499 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4499 10 is be VBZ 19613 4499 11 really really RB 19613 4499 12 the the DT 19613 4499 13 complete complete JJ 19613 4499 14 opposite opposite NN 19613 4499 15 of of IN 19613 4499 16 this this DT 19613 4499 17 , , , 19613 4499 18 in in IN 19613 4499 19 so so RB 19613 4499 20 far far RB 19613 4499 21 as as IN 19613 4499 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4499 23 proceeds proceed VBZ 19613 4499 24 from from IN 19613 4499 25 revelation revelation NN 19613 4499 26 and and CC 19613 4499 27 is be VBZ 19613 4499 28 propagated propagate VBN 19613 4499 29 by by IN 19613 4499 30 the the DT 19613 4499 31 agency agency NN 19613 4499 32 of of IN 19613 4499 33 God God NNP 19613 4499 34 , , , 19613 4499 35 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4499 36 , , , 19613 4499 37 has have VBZ 19613 4499 38 a a DT 19613 4499 39 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 4499 40 and and CC 19613 4499 41 divine divine JJ 19613 4499 42 origin origin NN 19613 4499 43 , , , 19613 4499 44 on on IN 19613 4499 45 which which WDT 19613 4499 46 alone alone RB 19613 4499 47 the the DT 19613 4499 48 truth truth NN 19613 4499 49 and and CC 19613 4499 50 certainty certainty NN 19613 4499 51 of of IN 19613 4499 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4499 53 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4499 54 finally finally RB 19613 4499 55 depend depend VBP 19613 4499 56 . . . 19613 4500 1 This this DT 19613 4500 2 contrast contrast NN 19613 4500 3 to to IN 19613 4500 4 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4500 5 is be VBZ 19613 4500 6 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 4500 7 shown show VBN 19613 4500 8 in in IN 19613 4500 9 the the DT 19613 4500 10 unphilosophical unphilosophical JJ 19613 4500 11 form form NN 19613 4500 12 in in IN 19613 4500 13 which which WDT 19613 4500 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4500 15 was be VBD 19613 4500 16 first first RB 19613 4500 17 preached preach VBN 19613 4500 18 to to IN 19613 4500 19 the the DT 19613 4500 20 world world NN 19613 4500 21 . . . 19613 4501 1 That that DT 19613 4501 2 is be VBZ 19613 4501 3 the the DT 19613 4501 4 thesis thesis NN 19613 4501 5 maintained maintain VBN 19613 4501 6 by by IN 19613 4501 7 all all PDT 19613 4501 8 the the DT 19613 4501 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4501 10 from from IN 19613 4501 11 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4501 12 to to IN 19613 4501 13 Tertullian,[351 tertullian,[351 CD 19613 4501 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4501 15 and and CC 19613 4501 16 which which WDT 19613 4501 17 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 4501 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4501 19 before before IN 19613 4501 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4501 21 propounded propound VBD 19613 4501 22 and and CC 19613 4501 23 defended defend VBN 19613 4501 24 . . . 19613 4502 1 This this DT 19613 4502 2 proposition proposition NN 19613 4502 3 may may MD 19613 4502 4 certainly certainly RB 19613 4502 5 be be VB 19613 4502 6 expressed express VBN 19613 4502 7 in in IN 19613 4502 8 a a DT 19613 4502 9 great great JJ 19613 4502 10 variety variety NN 19613 4502 11 of of IN 19613 4502 12 ways way NNS 19613 4502 13 . . . 19613 4503 1 In in IN 19613 4503 2 the the DT 19613 4503 3 first first JJ 19613 4503 4 place place NN 19613 4503 5 , , , 19613 4503 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4503 7 is be VBZ 19613 4503 8 important important JJ 19613 4503 9 whether whether IN 19613 4503 10 the the DT 19613 4503 11 first first JJ 19613 4503 12 or or CC 19613 4503 13 second second JJ 19613 4503 14 half half NN 19613 4503 15 is be VBZ 19613 4503 16 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 4503 17 , , , 19613 4503 18 and and CC 19613 4503 19 secondly secondly RB 19613 4503 20 , , , 19613 4503 21 whether whether IN 19613 4503 22 that that DT 19613 4503 23 which which WDT 19613 4503 24 is be VBZ 19613 4503 25 " " `` 19613 4503 26 universally universally RB 19613 4503 27 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 4503 28 " " '' 19613 4503 29 is be VBZ 19613 4503 30 to to TO 19613 4503 31 be be VB 19613 4503 32 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 4503 33 as as IN 19613 4503 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4503 35 at at RB 19613 4503 36 all all RB 19613 4503 37 , , , 19613 4503 38 or or CC 19613 4503 39 is be VBZ 19613 4503 40 to to TO 19613 4503 41 be be VB 19613 4503 42 separated separate VBN 19613 4503 43 from from IN 19613 4503 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4503 45 as as IN 19613 4503 46 that that DT 19613 4503 47 which which WDT 19613 4503 48 comes come VBZ 19613 4503 49 by by IN 19613 4503 50 " " `` 19613 4503 51 nature nature NN 19613 4503 52 . . . 19613 4503 53 " " '' 19613 4504 1 Finally finally RB 19613 4504 2 , , , 19613 4504 3 the the DT 19613 4504 4 attitude attitude NN 19613 4504 5 to to TO 19613 4504 6 be be VB 19613 4504 7 taken take VBN 19613 4504 8 up up RP 19613 4504 9 towards towards IN 19613 4504 10 the the DT 19613 4504 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 4504 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4504 13 is be VBZ 19613 4504 14 left leave VBN 19613 4504 15 an an DT 19613 4504 16 open open JJ 19613 4504 17 question question NN 19613 4504 18 , , , 19613 4504 19 so so IN 19613 4504 20 that that IN 19613 4504 21 the the DT 19613 4504 22 thesis thesis NN 19613 4504 23 , , , 19613 4504 24 taking take VBG 19613 4504 25 up up RP 19613 4504 26 this this DT 19613 4504 27 attitude attitude NN 19613 4504 28 as as IN 19613 4504 29 a a DT 19613 4504 30 starting starting NN 19613 4504 31 - - HYPH 19613 4504 32 point point NN 19613 4504 33 , , , 19613 4504 34 may may MD 19613 4504 35 again again RB 19613 4504 36 assume assume VB 19613 4504 37 various various JJ 19613 4504 38 forms form NNS 19613 4504 39 . . . 19613 4505 1 But but CC 19613 4505 2 was be VBD 19613 4505 3 the the DT 19613 4505 4 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 4505 5 which which WDT 19613 4505 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4505 7 contains contain VBZ 19613 4505 8 not not RB 19613 4505 9 felt feel VBN 19613 4505 10 ? ? . 19613 4506 1 The the DT 19613 4506 2 content content NN 19613 4506 3 of of IN 19613 4506 4 revelation revelation NN 19613 4506 5 is be VBZ 19613 4506 6 to to TO 19613 4506 7 be be VB 19613 4506 8 rational rational JJ 19613 4506 9 ; ; : 19613 4506 10 but but CC 19613 4506 11 does do VBZ 19613 4506 12 that that DT 19613 4506 13 which which WDT 19613 4506 14 is be VBZ 19613 4506 15 rational rational JJ 19613 4506 16 require require VBP 19613 4506 17 a a DT 19613 4506 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 4506 19 ? ? . 19613 4507 1 How how WRB 19613 4507 2 the the DT 19613 4507 3 proposition proposition NN 19613 4507 4 was be VBD 19613 4507 5 understood understand VBN 19613 4507 6 by by IN 19613 4507 7 the the DT 19613 4507 8 different different JJ 19613 4507 9 Apologists apologist NNS 19613 4507 10 requires require VBZ 19613 4507 11 examination examination NN 19613 4507 12 . . . 19613 4508 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4508 2 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 4508 3 . . . 19613 4508 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4508 5 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4508 6 first first RB 19613 4508 7 gives give VBZ 19613 4508 8 an an DT 19613 4508 9 exposition exposition NN 19613 4508 10 of of IN 19613 4508 11 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 4508 12 and and CC 19613 4508 13 the the DT 19613 4508 14 monotheistic monotheistic JJ 19613 4508 15 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4508 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4508 17 God God NNP 19613 4508 18 as as IN 19613 4508 19 creator creator NN 19613 4508 20 and and CC 19613 4508 21 mover mover NN 19613 4508 22 of of IN 19613 4508 23 the the DT 19613 4508 24 universe universe NN 19613 4508 25 , , , 19613 4508 26 as as IN 19613 4508 27 the the DT 19613 4508 28 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4508 29 , , , 19613 4508 30 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4508 31 , , , 19613 4508 32 almighty almighty JJ 19613 4508 33 Being Being NNP 19613 4508 34 , , , 19613 4508 35 whom whom WP 19613 4508 36 all all DT 19613 4508 37 things thing NNS 19613 4508 38 need need VBP 19613 4508 39 , , , 19613 4508 40 and and CC 19613 4508 41 who who WP 19613 4508 42 requires require VBZ 19613 4508 43 nothing nothing NN 19613 4508 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4508 45 . . . 19613 4509 1 In in IN 19613 4509 2 the the DT 19613 4509 3 second second JJ 19613 4509 4 chapter chapter NN 19613 4509 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4509 6 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 4509 7 , , , 19613 4509 8 according accord VBG 19613 4509 9 to to IN 19613 4509 10 the the DT 19613 4509 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 4509 12 text text NN 19613 4509 13 , , , 19613 4509 14 three three CD 19613 4509 15 , , , 19613 4509 16 and and CC 19613 4509 17 , , , 19613 4509 18 according accord VBG 19613 4509 19 to to IN 19613 4509 20 the the DT 19613 4509 21 Syriac Syriac NNP 19613 4509 22 , , , 19613 4509 23 four four CD 19613 4509 24 classes class NNS 19613 4509 25 of of IN 19613 4509 26 men man NNS 19613 4509 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4509 28 in in IN 19613 4509 29 the the DT 19613 4509 30 Greek greek JJ 19613 4509 31 text text NN 19613 4509 32 polytheists polytheist NNS 19613 4509 33 , , , 19613 4509 34 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 4509 35 , , , 19613 4509 36 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4509 37 , , , 19613 4509 38 the the DT 19613 4509 39 polytheists polytheist NNS 19613 4509 40 being be VBG 19613 4509 41 divided divide VBN 19613 4509 42 into into IN 19613 4509 43 Chaldeans Chaldeans NNPS 19613 4509 44 , , , 19613 4509 45 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4509 46 , , , 19613 4509 47 and and CC 19613 4509 48 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 19613 4509 49 ; ; : 19613 4509 50 in in IN 19613 4509 51 the the DT 19613 4509 52 Syriac Syriac NNP 19613 4509 53 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4509 54 , , , 19613 4509 55 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4509 56 , , , 19613 4509 57 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 4509 58 , , , 19613 4509 59 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4509 60 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4509 61 , , , 19613 4509 62 and and CC 19613 4509 63 gives give VBZ 19613 4509 64 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4509 65 origin origin NN 19613 4509 66 . . . 19613 4510 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4510 2 derives derive VBZ 19613 4510 3 the the DT 19613 4510 4 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4510 5 from from IN 19613 4510 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4510 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4510 8 and and CC 19613 4510 9 reproduces reproduce VBZ 19613 4510 10 the the DT 19613 4510 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4510 12 _ _ NNP 19613 4510 13 kerygma kerygma NNP 19613 4510 14 _ _ NNP 19613 4510 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4510 16 Son Son NNP 19613 4510 17 of of IN 19613 4510 18 the the DT 19613 4510 19 Most most RBS 19613 4510 20 High high JJ 19613 4510 21 God God NNP 19613 4510 22 , , , 19613 4510 23 birth birth NN 19613 4510 24 from from IN 19613 4510 25 the the DT 19613 4510 26 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 4510 27 , , , 19613 4510 28 12 12 CD 19613 4510 29 disciples disciple NNS 19613 4510 30 , , , 19613 4510 31 death death NN 19613 4510 32 on on IN 19613 4510 33 the the DT 19613 4510 34 cross cross NN 19613 4510 35 , , , 19613 4510 36 burial burial NN 19613 4510 37 , , , 19613 4510 38 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 4510 39 , , , 19613 4510 40 ascension ascension NN 19613 4510 41 , , , 19613 4510 42 missionary missionary JJ 19613 4510 43 labours labour NNS 19613 4510 44 of of IN 19613 4510 45 the the DT 19613 4510 46 12 12 CD 19613 4510 47 disciples disciple NNS 19613 4510 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4510 49 . . . 19613 4511 1 After after IN 19613 4511 2 this this DT 19613 4511 3 , , , 19613 4511 4 beginning begin VBG 19613 4511 5 with with IN 19613 4511 6 the the DT 19613 4511 7 third third JJ 19613 4511 8 chapter chapter NN 19613 4511 9 , , , 19613 4511 10 follows follow VBZ 19613 4511 11 a a DT 19613 4511 12 criticism criticism NN 19613 4511 13 of of IN 19613 4511 14 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4511 15 , , , 19613 4511 16 that that RB 19613 4511 17 is is RB 19613 4511 18 , , , 19613 4511 19 the the DT 19613 4511 20 false false JJ 19613 4511 21 theology theology NN 19613 4511 22 of of IN 19613 4511 23 the the DT 19613 4511 24 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4511 25 , , , 19613 4511 26 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4511 27 , , , 19613 4511 28 and and CC 19613 4511 29 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 19613 4511 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4511 31 down down RB 19613 4511 32 to to TO 19613 4511 33 chapter chapter NN 19613 4511 34 12 12 CD 19613 4511 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4511 36 . . . 19613 4512 1 In in IN 19613 4512 2 the the DT 19613 4512 3 13th 13th JJ 19613 4512 4 chapter chapter NN 19613 4512 5 the the DT 19613 4512 6 Greek greek JJ 19613 4512 7 authors author NNS 19613 4512 8 and and CC 19613 4512 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4512 10 are be VBP 19613 4512 11 criticised criticise VBN 19613 4512 12 , , , 19613 4512 13 and and CC 19613 4512 14 the the DT 19613 4512 15 Greek greek JJ 19613 4512 16 myths myth NNS 19613 4512 17 , , , 19613 4512 18 as as IN 19613 4512 19 such such JJ 19613 4512 20 , , , 19613 4512 21 are be VBP 19613 4512 22 shown show VBN 19613 4512 23 to to TO 19613 4512 24 be be VB 19613 4512 25 false false JJ 19613 4512 26 . . . 19613 4513 1 In in IN 19613 4513 2 the the DT 19613 4513 3 14th 14th JJ 19613 4513 4 chapter chapter NN 19613 4513 5 the the DT 19613 4513 6 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 4513 7 are be VBP 19613 4513 8 introduced introduce VBN 19613 4513 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4513 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4513 11 are be VBP 19613 4513 12 monotheists monotheist NNS 19613 4513 13 and and CC 19613 4513 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4513 15 ethical ethical JJ 19613 4513 16 system system NN 19613 4513 17 is be VBZ 19613 4513 18 praised praise VBN 19613 4513 19 ; ; : 19613 4513 20 but but CC 19613 4513 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4513 22 are be VBP 19613 4513 23 then then RB 19613 4513 24 reproached reproach VBN 19613 4513 25 with with IN 19613 4513 26 worshipping worshipping NN 19613 4513 27 of of IN 19613 4513 28 angels angel NNS 19613 4513 29 and and CC 19613 4513 30 a a DT 19613 4513 31 false false JJ 19613 4513 32 ceremonial ceremonial NN 19613 4513 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4513 34 . . . 19613 4514 1 In in IN 19613 4514 2 the the DT 19613 4514 3 15th 15th JJ 19613 4514 4 chapter chapter NN 19613 4514 5 follows follow VBZ 19613 4514 6 a a DT 19613 4514 7 description description NN 19613 4514 8 of of IN 19613 4514 9 the the DT 19613 4514 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4514 11 , , , 19613 4514 12 _ _ NNP 19613 4514 13 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4514 14 _ _ NNP 19613 4514 15 , , , 19613 4514 16 above above IN 19613 4514 17 all all DT 19613 4514 18 , , , 19613 4514 19 of of IN 19613 4514 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4514 21 pure pure JJ 19613 4514 22 , , , 19613 4514 23 holy holy JJ 19613 4514 24 life life NN 19613 4514 25 . . . 19613 4515 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4515 2 is be VBZ 19613 4515 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4515 4 who who WP 19613 4515 5 have have VBP 19613 4515 6 found find VBN 19613 4515 7 the the DT 19613 4515 8 truth truth NN 19613 4515 9 , , , 19613 4515 10 because because IN 19613 4515 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4515 12 know know VBP 19613 4515 13 the the DT 19613 4515 14 creator creator NN 19613 4515 15 of of IN 19613 4515 16 heaven heaven NNP 19613 4515 17 and and CC 19613 4515 18 earth earth NN 19613 4515 19 . . . 19613 4516 1 This this DT 19613 4516 2 description description NN 19613 4516 3 is be VBZ 19613 4516 4 continued continue VBN 19613 4516 5 in in IN 19613 4516 6 chapters chapter NNS 19613 4516 7 16 16 CD 19613 4516 8 and and CC 19613 4516 9 17 17 CD 19613 4516 10 : : : 19613 4516 11 " " `` 19613 4516 12 This this DT 19613 4516 13 people people NNS 19613 4516 14 is be VBZ 19613 4516 15 new new JJ 19613 4516 16 and and CC 19613 4516 17 there there EX 19613 4516 18 is be VBZ 19613 4516 19 a a DT 19613 4516 20 divine divine JJ 19613 4516 21 admixture admixture NN 19613 4516 22 in in IN 19613 4516 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4516 24 . . . 19613 4516 25 " " '' 19613 4517 1 The the DT 19613 4517 2 Christian christian JJ 19613 4517 3 writings writing NNS 19613 4517 4 are be VBP 19613 4517 5 recommended recommend VBN 19613 4517 6 to to IN 19613 4517 7 the the DT 19613 4517 8 emperor emperor NN 19613 4517 9 . . . 19613 4518 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4518 2 Justin._[352 Justin._[352 NNP 19613 4518 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4518 4 In in IN 19613 4518 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4518 6 treatise treatise NN 19613 4518 7 addressed address VBD 19613 4518 8 to to IN 19613 4518 9 the the DT 19613 4518 10 emperor emperor NN 19613 4518 11 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4518 12 did do VBD 19613 4518 13 not not RB 19613 4518 14 call call VB 19613 4518 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4518 16 a a DT 19613 4518 17 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4518 18 as as IN 19613 4518 19 Aristides aristide NNS 19613 4518 20 had have VBD 19613 4518 21 done do VBN 19613 4518 22 . . . 19613 4519 1 In in IN 19613 4519 2 espousing espouse VBG 19613 4519 3 the the DT 19613 4519 4 cause cause NN 19613 4519 5 of of IN 19613 4519 6 the the DT 19613 4519 7 hated hate VBN 19613 4519 8 and and CC 19613 4519 9 despised despise VBD 19613 4519 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4519 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4519 12 represented represent VBD 19613 4519 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4519 14 as as IN 19613 4519 15 a a DT 19613 4519 16 simple simple JJ 19613 4519 17 member member NN 19613 4519 18 of of IN 19613 4519 19 that that DT 19613 4519 20 sect sect NN 19613 4519 21 . . . 19613 4520 1 But but CC 19613 4520 2 in in IN 19613 4520 3 the the DT 19613 4520 4 very very RB 19613 4520 5 first first JJ 19613 4520 6 sentence sentence NN 19613 4520 7 of of IN 19613 4520 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4520 9 Apology Apology NNP 19613 4520 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4520 11 takes take VBZ 19613 4520 12 up up RP 19613 4520 13 the the DT 19613 4520 14 ground ground NN 19613 4520 15 of of IN 19613 4520 16 piety piety NN 19613 4520 17 and and CC 19613 4520 18 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4520 19 , , , 19613 4520 20 the the DT 19613 4520 21 very very JJ 19613 4520 22 ground ground NN 19613 4520 23 taken take VBN 19613 4520 24 up up RP 19613 4520 25 by by IN 19613 4520 26 the the DT 19613 4520 27 pious pious JJ 19613 4520 28 and and CC 19613 4520 29 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4520 30 emperors emperor NNS 19613 4520 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4520 32 , , , 19613 4520 33 according accord VBG 19613 4520 34 to to IN 19613 4520 35 the the DT 19613 4520 36 judgment judgment NN 19613 4520 37 of of IN 19613 4520 38 the the DT 19613 4520 39 time time NN 19613 4520 40 and and CC 19613 4520 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4520 42 own own JJ 19613 4520 43 intention intention NN 19613 4520 44 . . . 19613 4521 1 In in IN 19613 4521 2 addressing address VBG 19613 4521 3 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4521 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4521 5 appeals appeal VBZ 19613 4521 6 to to IN 19613 4521 7 the the DT 19613 4521 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4521 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4521 10 : : : 19613 4521 11 logos logos NNP 19613 4521 12 sôphrôn sôphrôn NN 19613 4521 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4521 14 in in IN 19613 4521 15 a a DT 19613 4521 16 purely purely RB 19613 4521 17 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4521 18 fashion fashion NN 19613 4521 19 . . . 19613 4522 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4522 2 opposes oppose VBZ 19613 4522 3 the the DT 19613 4522 4 truth truth NN 19613 4522 5 -- -- : 19613 4522 6 also also RB 19613 4522 7 in in IN 19613 4522 8 the the DT 19613 4522 9 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 4522 10 manner manner NN 19613 4522 11 -- -- : 19613 4522 12 to to IN 19613 4522 13 the the DT 19613 4522 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4522 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4522 16 : : : 19613 4522 17 doxais doxais NNP 19613 4522 18 palaiôn palaiôn NN 19613 4522 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4522 20 . . . 19613 4523 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4523 2 353 353 CD 19613 4523 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4523 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4523 5 was be VBD 19613 4523 6 not not RB 19613 4523 7 to to TO 19613 4523 8 be be VB 19613 4523 9 a a DT 19613 4523 10 mere mere JJ 19613 4523 11 _ _ NNP 19613 4523 12 captatio captatio NN 19613 4523 13 benevolentiæ benevolentiæ NN 19613 4523 14 _ _ NNP 19613 4523 15 . . . 19613 4524 1 In in IN 19613 4524 2 that that DT 19613 4524 3 case case NN 19613 4524 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4524 5 would would MD 19613 4524 6 not not RB 19613 4524 7 have have VB 19613 4524 8 added add VBN 19613 4524 9 : : : 19613 4524 10 " " `` 19613 4524 11 That that IN 19613 4524 12 ye ye NNP 19613 4524 13 are be VBP 19613 4524 14 pious pious JJ 19613 4524 15 and and CC 19613 4524 16 wise wise JJ 19613 4524 17 and and CC 19613 4524 18 guardians guardian NNS 19613 4524 19 of of IN 19613 4524 20 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4524 21 and and CC 19613 4524 22 friends friend NNS 19613 4524 23 of of IN 19613 4524 24 culture culture NN 19613 4524 25 , , , 19613 4524 26 ye ye NNP 19613 4524 27 hear hear VBP 19613 4524 28 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 4524 29 . . . 19613 4525 1 Whether whether IN 19613 4525 2 ye ye NNP 19613 4525 3 are be VBP 19613 4525 4 so so RB 19613 4525 5 , , , 19613 4525 6 however however RB 19613 4525 7 , , , 19613 4525 8 will will MD 19613 4525 9 be be VB 19613 4525 10 shown show VBN 19613 4525 11 . . . 19613 4526 1 " " `` 19613 4526 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4526 3 354 354 CD 19613 4526 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4526 5 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4526 6 whole whole JJ 19613 4526 7 exordium exordium NN 19613 4526 8 is be VBZ 19613 4526 9 calculated calculate VBN 19613 4526 10 to to TO 19613 4526 11 prove prove VB 19613 4526 12 to to IN 19613 4526 13 the the DT 19613 4526 14 emperors emperor NNS 19613 4526 15 that that IN 19613 4526 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4526 17 are be VBP 19613 4526 18 in in IN 19613 4526 19 danger danger NN 19613 4526 20 of of IN 19613 4526 21 repeating repeat VBG 19613 4526 22 a a DT 19613 4526 23 hundredfold hundredfold NN 19613 4526 24 the the DT 19613 4526 25 crime crime NN 19613 4526 26 which which WDT 19613 4526 27 the the DT 19613 4526 28 judges judge NNS 19613 4526 29 of of IN 19613 4526 30 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4526 31 had have VBD 19613 4526 32 committed commit VBN 19613 4526 33 . . . 19613 4527 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4527 2 355 355 CD 19613 4527 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4527 4 Like like IN 19613 4527 5 a a DT 19613 4527 6 second second JJ 19613 4527 7 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4527 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4527 9 speaks speak VBZ 19613 4527 10 to to IN 19613 4527 11 the the DT 19613 4527 12 emperors emperor NNS 19613 4527 13 in in IN 19613 4527 14 the the DT 19613 4527 15 name name NN 19613 4527 16 of of IN 19613 4527 17 all all DT 19613 4527 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4527 19 . . . 19613 4528 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4528 2 are be VBP 19613 4528 3 to to TO 19613 4528 4 hear hear VB 19613 4528 5 the the DT 19613 4528 6 convictions conviction NNS 19613 4528 7 of of IN 19613 4528 8 the the DT 19613 4528 9 wisest wise JJS 19613 4528 10 of of IN 19613 4528 11 the the DT 19613 4528 12 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4528 13 from from IN 19613 4528 14 the the DT 19613 4528 15 mouth mouth NN 19613 4528 16 of of IN 19613 4528 17 the the DT 19613 4528 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4528 19 . . . 19613 4529 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4529 2 wishes wish VBZ 19613 4529 3 to to TO 19613 4529 4 enlighten enlighten VB 19613 4529 5 the the DT 19613 4529 6 emperor emperor NN 19613 4529 7 with with IN 19613 4529 8 regard regard NN 19613 4529 9 to to IN 19613 4529 10 the the DT 19613 4529 11 life life NN 19613 4529 12 and and CC 19613 4529 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4529 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4529 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4529 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4529 17 : : : 19613 4529 18 bios bios NNP 19613 4529 19 kai kai NNP 19613 4529 20 mathêmata mathêmata NNP 19613 4529 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4529 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4529 23 of of IN 19613 4529 24 the the DT 19613 4529 25 latter latter JJ 19613 4529 26 . . . 19613 4530 1 Nothing nothing NN 19613 4530 2 is be VBZ 19613 4530 3 to to TO 19613 4530 4 be be VB 19613 4530 5 concealed conceal VBN 19613 4530 6 , , , 19613 4530 7 for for IN 19613 4530 8 there there EX 19613 4530 9 is be VBZ 19613 4530 10 nothing nothing NN 19613 4530 11 to to TO 19613 4530 12 conceal conceal VB 19613 4530 13 . . . 19613 4531 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4531 2 kept keep VBD 19613 4531 3 this this DT 19613 4531 4 promise promise NN 19613 4531 5 better well RBR 19613 4531 6 than than IN 19613 4531 7 any any DT 19613 4531 8 of of IN 19613 4531 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4531 10 successors successor NNS 19613 4531 11 . . . 19613 4532 1 For for IN 19613 4532 2 that that DT 19613 4532 3 very very JJ 19613 4532 4 reason reason NN 19613 4532 5 also also RB 19613 4532 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4532 7 did do VBD 19613 4532 8 not not RB 19613 4532 9 depict depict VB 19613 4532 10 the the DT 19613 4532 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4532 12 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 4532 13 as as IN 19613 4532 14 schools school NNS 19613 4532 15 of of IN 19613 4532 16 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4532 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4532 18 cc cc NNP 19613 4532 19 . . . 19613 4533 1 61 61 CD 19613 4533 2 - - SYM 19613 4533 3 67 67 CD 19613 4533 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4533 5 . . . 19613 4534 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4534 2 , , , 19613 4534 3 in in IN 19613 4534 4 the the DT 19613 4534 5 first first JJ 19613 4534 6 passage passage NN 19613 4534 7 where where WRB 19613 4534 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4534 9 speaks speak VBZ 19613 4534 10 of of IN 19613 4534 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4534 12 philosophers,[356 philosophers,[356 NNP 19613 4534 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4534 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4534 15 is be VBZ 19613 4534 16 merely merely RB 19613 4534 17 drawing draw VBG 19613 4534 18 a a DT 19613 4534 19 parallel parallel NN 19613 4534 20 . . . 19613 4535 1 According accord VBG 19613 4535 2 to to IN 19613 4535 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4535 4 there there EX 19613 4535 5 are be VBP 19613 4535 6 bad bad JJ 19613 4535 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4535 8 and and CC 19613 4535 9 seeming seeming JJ 19613 4535 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4535 11 , , , 19613 4535 12 just just RB 19613 4535 13 as as IN 19613 4535 14 there there EX 19613 4535 15 are be VBP 19613 4535 16 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4535 17 who who WP 19613 4535 18 are be VBP 19613 4535 19 only only RB 19613 4535 20 so so RB 19613 4535 21 in in IN 19613 4535 22 name name NN 19613 4535 23 and and CC 19613 4535 24 outward outward NNP 19613 4535 25 show show NN 19613 4535 26 . . . 19613 4536 1 Such such JJ 19613 4536 2 men man NNS 19613 4536 3 , , , 19613 4536 4 too too RB 19613 4536 5 , , , 19613 4536 6 were be VBD 19613 4536 7 in in IN 19613 4536 8 early early JJ 19613 4536 9 times time NNS 19613 4536 10 called call VBN 19613 4536 11 " " `` 19613 4536 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4536 13 " " '' 19613 4536 14 even even RB 19613 4536 15 when when WRB 19613 4536 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4536 17 preached preach VBD 19613 4536 18 atheism atheism NN 19613 4536 19 . . . 19613 4537 1 To to IN 19613 4537 2 all all DT 19613 4537 3 appearance appearance NN 19613 4537 4 , , , 19613 4537 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 4537 6 , , , 19613 4537 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4537 8 does do VBZ 19613 4537 9 _ _ NNP 19613 4537 10 not not RB 19613 4537 11 _ _ NNP 19613 4537 12 desire desire NN 19613 4537 13 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4537 14 to to TO 19613 4537 15 be be VB 19613 4537 16 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 4537 17 as as IN 19613 4537 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4537 19 . . . 19613 4538 1 But but CC 19613 4538 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4538 3 is be VBZ 19613 4538 4 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4538 5 significant significant JJ 19613 4538 6 that that IN 19613 4538 7 , , , 19613 4538 8 in in IN 19613 4538 9 the the DT 19613 4538 10 case case NN 19613 4538 11 of of IN 19613 4538 12 the the DT 19613 4538 13 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4538 14 , , , 19613 4538 15 a a DT 19613 4538 16 phenomenon phenomenon NN 19613 4538 17 is be VBZ 19613 4538 18 being be VBG 19613 4538 19 repeated repeat VBN 19613 4538 20 which which WDT 19613 4538 21 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 4538 22 is be VBZ 19613 4538 23 only only RB 19613 4538 24 observed observe VBN 19613 4538 25 in in IN 19613 4538 26 the the DT 19613 4538 27 case case NN 19613 4538 28 of of IN 19613 4538 29 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4538 30 ; ; : 19613 4538 31 and and CC 19613 4538 32 how how WRB 19613 4538 33 were be VBD 19613 4538 34 those those DT 19613 4538 35 whom whom WP 19613 4538 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4538 37 was be VBD 19613 4538 38 addressing address VBG 19613 4538 39 to to TO 19613 4538 40 understand understand VB 19613 4538 41 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4538 42 ? ? . 19613 4539 1 In in IN 19613 4539 2 the the DT 19613 4539 3 same same JJ 19613 4539 4 passage passage NN 19613 4539 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4539 6 speaks speak VBZ 19613 4539 7 for for IN 19613 4539 8 the the DT 19613 4539 9 first first JJ 19613 4539 10 time time NN 19613 4539 11 of of IN 19613 4539 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4539 13 . . . 19613 4540 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4540 2 introduces introduce VBZ 19613 4540 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4540 4 with with IN 19613 4540 5 the the DT 19613 4540 6 plain plain JJ 19613 4540 7 and and CC 19613 4540 8 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 4540 9 formula formula NN 19613 4540 10 : : : 19613 4540 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4540 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4540 13 : : : 19613 4540 14 ho ho NNP 19613 4540 15 didaskalos didaskalos NNP 19613 4540 16 Christos Christos NNP 19613 4540 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4540 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4540 19 " " `` 19613 4540 20 the the DT 19613 4540 21 teacher teacher NN 19613 4540 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4540 23 " " '' 19613 4540 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4540 25 . . . 19613 4541 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4541 2 357 357 CD 19613 4541 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4541 4 Immediately immediately RB 19613 4541 5 thereafter thereafter RB 19613 4541 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4541 7 praises praise VBZ 19613 4541 8 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4541 9 because because IN 19613 4541 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4541 11 had have VBD 19613 4541 12 exposed expose VBN 19613 4541 13 the the DT 19613 4541 14 worthlessness worthlessness NN 19613 4541 15 and and CC 19613 4541 16 deceit deceit NN 19613 4541 17 of of IN 19613 4541 18 the the DT 19613 4541 19 evil evil JJ 19613 4541 20 demons demon NNS 19613 4541 21 , , , 19613 4541 22 and and CC 19613 4541 23 traces trace VBZ 19613 4541 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4541 25 death death NN 19613 4541 26 to to IN 19613 4541 27 the the DT 19613 4541 28 same same JJ 19613 4541 29 causes cause NNS 19613 4541 30 which which WDT 19613 4541 31 are be VBP 19613 4541 32 now now RB 19613 4541 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4541 34 says say VBZ 19613 4541 35 bringing bring VBG 19613 4541 36 about about RP 19613 4541 37 the the DT 19613 4541 38 condemnation condemnation NN 19613 4541 39 of of IN 19613 4541 40 the the DT 19613 4541 41 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4541 42 . . . 19613 4542 1 Now now RB 19613 4542 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4542 3 can can MD 19613 4542 4 make make VB 19613 4542 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4542 6 final final JJ 19613 4542 7 assertion assertion NN 19613 4542 8 . . . 19613 4543 1 In in IN 19613 4543 2 virtue virtue NN 19613 4543 3 of of IN 19613 4543 4 " " `` 19613 4543 5 reason reason NN 19613 4543 6 " " '' 19613 4543 7 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4543 8 exposed expose VBD 19613 4543 9 superstition superstition NN 19613 4543 10 ; ; : 19613 4543 11 in in IN 19613 4543 12 virtue virtue NN 19613 4543 13 of of IN 19613 4543 14 the the DT 19613 4543 15 same same JJ 19613 4543 16 reason reason NN 19613 4543 17 , , , 19613 4543 18 this this DT 19613 4543 19 was be VBD 19613 4543 20 done do VBN 19613 4543 21 by by IN 19613 4543 22 the the DT 19613 4543 23 teacher teacher NN 19613 4543 24 whom whom WP 19613 4543 25 the the DT 19613 4543 26 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4543 27 follow follow VBP 19613 4543 28 . . . 19613 4544 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4544 2 But but CC 19613 4544 3 this this DT 19613 4544 4 teacher teacher NN 19613 4544 5 was be VBD 19613 4544 6 reason reason NN 19613 4544 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4544 8 ; ; : 19613 4544 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4544 10 was be VBD 19613 4544 11 visible visible JJ 19613 4544 12 in in IN 19613 4544 13 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4544 14 , , , 19613 4544 15 and and CC 19613 4544 16 indeed indeed RB 19613 4544 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4544 18 appeared appear VBD 19613 4544 19 bodily bodily RB 19613 4544 20 in in IN 19613 4544 21 him._[358 him._[358 NNP 19613 4544 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4544 23 Is be VBZ 19613 4544 24 this this DT 19613 4544 25 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4544 26 or or CC 19613 4544 27 is be VBZ 19613 4544 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4544 29 myth myth JJ 19613 4544 30 ? ? . 19613 4545 1 The the DT 19613 4545 2 greatest great JJS 19613 4545 3 paradox paradox NN 19613 4545 4 the the DT 19613 4545 5 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 4545 6 has have VBZ 19613 4545 7 to to TO 19613 4545 8 assert assert VB 19613 4545 9 is be VBZ 19613 4545 10 connected connect VBN 19613 4545 11 by by IN 19613 4545 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4545 13 with with IN 19613 4545 14 the the DT 19613 4545 15 most most RBS 19613 4545 16 impressive impressive JJ 19613 4545 17 remembrance remembrance NN 19613 4545 18 possessed possess VBN 19613 4545 19 by by IN 19613 4545 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4545 21 readers reader NNS 19613 4545 22 as as IN 19613 4545 23 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4545 24 . . . 19613 4546 1 In in IN 19613 4546 2 the the DT 19613 4546 3 same same JJ 19613 4546 4 sentence sentence NN 19613 4546 5 where where WRB 19613 4546 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4546 7 represents represent VBZ 19613 4546 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4546 9 as as IN 19613 4546 10 the the DT 19613 4546 11 Socrates Socrates NNPS 19613 4546 12 of of IN 19613 4546 13 the the DT 19613 4546 14 barbarians,[359 barbarians,[359 NN 19613 4546 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4546 16 and and CC 19613 4546 17 consequently consequently RB 19613 4546 18 makes make VBZ 19613 4546 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4546 20 out out RP 19613 4546 21 to to TO 19613 4546 22 be be VB 19613 4546 23 a a DT 19613 4546 24 Socratic socratic JJ 19613 4546 25 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4546 26 , , , 19613 4546 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4546 28 propounds propound VBZ 19613 4546 29 the the DT 19613 4546 30 unheard unheard NN 19613 4546 31 of of IN 19613 4546 32 theory theory NN 19613 4546 33 _ _ IN 19613 4546 34 that that IN 19613 4546 35 the the DT 19613 4546 36 teacher teacher NN 19613 4546 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4546 38 is be VBZ 19613 4546 39 the the DT 19613 4546 40 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 4546 41 reason reason NN 19613 4546 42 of of IN 19613 4546 43 God God NNP 19613 4546 44 _ _ NNP 19613 4546 45 . . . 19613 4547 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4547 2 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 4547 3 tried try VBD 19613 4547 4 to to TO 19613 4547 5 soften soften VB 19613 4547 6 the the DT 19613 4547 7 effect effect NN 19613 4547 8 of of IN 19613 4547 9 this this DT 19613 4547 10 conviction conviction NN 19613 4547 11 or or CC 19613 4547 12 explain explain VB 19613 4547 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4547 14 in in IN 19613 4547 15 a a DT 19613 4547 16 way way NN 19613 4547 17 adapted adapt VBN 19613 4547 18 to to IN 19613 4547 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4547 20 readers reader NNS 19613 4547 21 . . . 19613 4548 1 Nor nor CC 19613 4548 2 did do VBD 19613 4548 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4548 4 conceal conceal VB 19613 4548 5 from from IN 19613 4548 6 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4548 7 that that IN 19613 4548 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4548 9 assertion assertion NN 19613 4548 10 admits admit NNS 19613 4548 11 of of IN 19613 4548 12 no no DT 19613 4548 13 speculative speculative JJ 19613 4548 14 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 4548 15 . . . 19613 4549 1 That that DT 19613 4549 2 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4549 3 can can MD 19613 4549 4 only only RB 19613 4549 5 deal deal VB 19613 4549 6 with with IN 19613 4549 7 things thing NNS 19613 4549 8 which which WDT 19613 4549 9 ever ever RB 19613 4549 10 are be VBP 19613 4549 11 , , , 19613 4549 12 because because IN 19613 4549 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4549 14 ever ever RB 19613 4549 15 were be VBD 19613 4549 16 , , , 19613 4549 17 since since IN 19613 4549 18 this this DT 19613 4549 19 world world NN 19613 4549 20 began begin VBD 19613 4549 21 , , , 19613 4549 22 is be VBZ 19613 4549 23 a a DT 19613 4549 24 fact fact NN 19613 4549 25 about about IN 19613 4549 26 which which WDT 19613 4549 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4549 28 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4549 29 is be VBZ 19613 4549 30 perfectly perfectly RB 19613 4549 31 clear clear JJ 19613 4549 32 . . . 19613 4550 1 No no DT 19613 4550 2 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 4550 3 could could MD 19613 4550 4 have have VB 19613 4550 5 felt feel VBN 19613 4550 6 more more RBR 19613 4550 7 strongly strongly RB 19613 4550 8 than than IN 19613 4550 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4550 10 how how WRB 19613 4550 11 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 19613 4550 12 is be VBZ 19613 4550 13 the the DT 19613 4550 14 assertion assertion NN 19613 4550 15 that that IN 19613 4550 16 a a DT 19613 4550 17 thing thing NN 19613 4550 18 is be VBZ 19613 4550 19 of of IN 19613 4550 20 value value NN 19613 4550 21 which which WDT 19613 4550 22 has have VBZ 19613 4550 23 happened happen VBN 19613 4550 24 only only RB 19613 4550 25 once once RB 19613 4550 26 . . . 19613 4551 1 Certain certain JJ 19613 4551 2 as as IN 19613 4551 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4551 4 is be VBZ 19613 4551 5 that that IN 19613 4551 6 the the DT 19613 4551 7 " " `` 19613 4551 8 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4551 9 " " '' 19613 4551 10 emperors emperor NNS 19613 4551 11 will will MD 19613 4551 12 regard regard VB 19613 4551 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4551 14 as as IN 19613 4551 15 a a DT 19613 4551 16 rational rational JJ 19613 4551 17 assumption assumption NN 19613 4551 18 that that IN 19613 4551 19 " " `` 19613 4551 20 Reason reason NN 19613 4551 21 " " '' 19613 4551 22 is be VBZ 19613 4551 23 the the DT 19613 4551 24 Son Son NNP 19613 4551 25 of of IN 19613 4551 26 God,[360 God,[360 NNP 19613 4551 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4551 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4551 29 knows know VBZ 19613 4551 30 equally equally RB 19613 4551 31 well well RB 19613 4551 32 that that IN 19613 4551 33 no no DT 19613 4551 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4551 35 will will MD 19613 4551 36 bear bear VB 19613 4551 37 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4551 38 out out RP 19613 4551 39 in in IN 19613 4551 40 that that DT 19613 4551 41 other other JJ 19613 4551 42 assertion assertion NN 19613 4551 43 , , , 19613 4551 44 and and CC 19613 4551 45 that that IN 19613 4551 46 such such PDT 19613 4551 47 a a DT 19613 4551 48 statement statement NN 19613 4551 49 is be VBZ 19613 4551 50 seemingly seemingly RB 19613 4551 51 akin akin JJ 19613 4551 52 to to IN 19613 4551 53 the the DT 19613 4551 54 contemptible contemptible JJ 19613 4551 55 myths myth NNS 19613 4551 56 of of IN 19613 4551 57 the the DT 19613 4551 58 evil evil JJ 19613 4551 59 demons demon NNS 19613 4551 60 . . . 19613 4552 1 But but CC 19613 4552 2 there there EX 19613 4552 3 is be VBZ 19613 4552 4 certainly certainly RB 19613 4552 5 a a DT 19613 4552 6 proof proof NN 19613 4552 7 which which WDT 19613 4552 8 , , , 19613 4552 9 if if IN 19613 4552 10 not not RB 19613 4552 11 speculative speculative JJ 19613 4552 12 , , , 19613 4552 13 is be VBZ 19613 4552 14 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4552 15 sure sure JJ 19613 4552 16 . . . 19613 4553 1 The the DT 19613 4553 2 same same JJ 19613 4553 3 ancient ancient JJ 19613 4553 4 documents document NNS 19613 4553 5 , , , 19613 4553 6 which which WDT 19613 4553 7 contain contain VBP 19613 4553 8 the the DT 19613 4553 9 Socratic socratic JJ 19613 4553 10 and and CC 19613 4553 11 super super JJ 19613 4553 12 - - JJ 19613 4553 13 Socratic socratic JJ 19613 4553 14 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4553 15 of of IN 19613 4553 16 the the DT 19613 4553 17 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4553 18 , , , 19613 4553 19 bear bear VB 19613 4553 20 witness witness NN 19613 4553 21 through through IN 19613 4553 22 prophecies prophecy NNS 19613 4553 23 , , , 19613 4553 24 which which WDT 19613 4553 25 , , , 19613 4553 26 just just RB 19613 4553 27 because because IN 19613 4553 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4553 29 are be VBP 19613 4553 30 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4553 31 , , , 19613 4553 32 admit admit VBP 19613 4553 33 of of IN 19613 4553 34 no no DT 19613 4553 35 doubt doubt NN 19613 4553 36 , , , 19613 4553 37 that that IN 19613 4553 38 the the DT 19613 4553 39 teacher teacher NN 19613 4553 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4553 41 is be VBZ 19613 4553 42 the the DT 19613 4553 43 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 4553 44 reason reason NN 19613 4553 45 ; ; : 19613 4553 46 for for IN 19613 4553 47 history history NN 19613 4553 48 confirms confirm VBZ 19613 4553 49 the the DT 19613 4553 50 word word NN 19613 4553 51 of of IN 19613 4553 52 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 4553 53 even even RB 19613 4553 54 in in IN 19613 4553 55 the the DT 19613 4553 56 minutest minute JJS 19613 4553 57 details detail NNS 19613 4553 58 . . . 19613 4554 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4554 2 , , , 19613 4554 3 in in IN 19613 4554 4 so so RB 19613 4554 5 far far RB 19613 4554 6 as as IN 19613 4554 7 these these DT 19613 4554 8 writings writing NNS 19613 4554 9 are be VBP 19613 4554 10 in in IN 19613 4554 11 the the DT 19613 4554 12 lawful lawful JJ 19613 4554 13 possession possession NN 19613 4554 14 of of IN 19613 4554 15 the the DT 19613 4554 16 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4554 17 , , , 19613 4554 18 and and CC 19613 4554 19 announced announce VBD 19613 4554 20 at at IN 19613 4554 21 the the DT 19613 4554 22 very very JJ 19613 4554 23 beginning beginning NN 19613 4554 24 of of IN 19613 4554 25 things thing NNS 19613 4554 26 that that WDT 19613 4554 27 this this DT 19613 4554 28 community community NN 19613 4554 29 would would MD 19613 4554 30 appear appear VB 19613 4554 31 on on IN 19613 4554 32 the the DT 19613 4554 33 earth earth NN 19613 4554 34 , , , 19613 4554 35 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4554 36 testify testify VBP 19613 4554 37 that that IN 19613 4554 38 the the DT 19613 4554 39 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4554 40 may may MD 19613 4554 41 in in IN 19613 4554 42 a a DT 19613 4554 43 certain certain JJ 19613 4554 44 fashion fashion NN 19613 4554 45 date date NN 19613 4554 46 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4554 47 back back RB 19613 4554 48 to to IN 19613 4554 49 the the DT 19613 4554 50 beginning beginning NN 19613 4554 51 of of IN 19613 4554 52 the the DT 19613 4554 53 world world NN 19613 4554 54 , , , 19613 4554 55 because because IN 19613 4554 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4554 57 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4554 58 is be VBZ 19613 4554 59 as as RB 19613 4554 60 old old JJ 19613 4554 61 as as IN 19613 4554 62 the the DT 19613 4554 63 earth earth NN 19613 4554 64 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4554 65 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4554 66 this this DT 19613 4554 67 thought thought NN 19613 4554 68 is be VBZ 19613 4554 69 still still RB 19613 4554 70 wanting want VBG 19613 4554 71 in in IN 19613 4554 72 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 4554 73 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4554 74 . . . 19613 4555 1 The the DT 19613 4555 2 new new JJ 19613 4555 3 Socrates Socrates NNPS 19613 4555 4 who who WP 19613 4555 5 appeared appear VBD 19613 4555 6 among among IN 19613 4555 7 the the DT 19613 4555 8 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4555 9 is be VBZ 19613 4555 10 therefore therefore RB 19613 4555 11 quite quite RB 19613 4555 12 different different JJ 19613 4555 13 from from IN 19613 4555 14 the the DT 19613 4555 15 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4555 16 of of IN 19613 4555 17 the the DT 19613 4555 18 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4555 19 , , , 19613 4555 20 and and CC 19613 4555 21 for for IN 19613 4555 22 that that DT 19613 4555 23 reason reason NN 19613 4555 24 also also RB 19613 4555 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4555 26 followers follower NNS 19613 4555 27 are be VBP 19613 4555 28 not not RB 19613 4555 29 to to TO 19613 4555 30 be be VB 19613 4555 31 compared compare VBN 19613 4555 32 with with IN 19613 4555 33 the the DT 19613 4555 34 disciples disciple NNS 19613 4555 35 of of IN 19613 4555 36 the the DT 19613 4555 37 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4555 38 . . . 19613 4556 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4556 2 361 361 CD 19613 4556 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4556 4 From from IN 19613 4556 5 the the DT 19613 4556 6 very very JJ 19613 4556 7 beginning beginning NN 19613 4556 8 of of IN 19613 4556 9 things thing NNS 19613 4556 10 a a DT 19613 4556 11 world world NN 19613 4556 12 - - HYPH 19613 4556 13 historical historical JJ 19613 4556 14 dispensation dispensation NN 19613 4556 15 of of IN 19613 4556 16 God God NNP 19613 4556 17 announced announce VBD 19613 4556 18 this this DT 19613 4556 19 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4556 20 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4556 21 through through IN 19613 4556 22 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4556 23 , , , 19613 4556 24 and and CC 19613 4556 25 prepared prepare VBD 19613 4556 26 the the DT 19613 4556 27 visible visible JJ 19613 4556 28 appearance appearance NN 19613 4556 29 of of IN 19613 4556 30 reason reason NN 19613 4556 31 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4556 32 . . . 19613 4557 1 The the DT 19613 4557 2 same same JJ 19613 4557 3 reason reason NN 19613 4557 4 which which WDT 19613 4557 5 created create VBD 19613 4557 6 and and CC 19613 4557 7 arranged arrange VBD 19613 4557 8 the the DT 19613 4557 9 world world NN 19613 4557 10 took take VBD 19613 4557 11 human human JJ 19613 4557 12 form form NN 19613 4557 13 in in IN 19613 4557 14 order order NN 19613 4557 15 to to TO 19613 4557 16 draw draw VB 19613 4557 17 the the DT 19613 4557 18 whole whole NN 19613 4557 19 of of IN 19613 4557 20 humanity humanity NN 19613 4557 21 to to IN 19613 4557 22 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4557 23 . . . 19613 4558 1 Every every DT 19613 4558 2 precaution precaution NN 19613 4558 3 has have VBZ 19613 4558 4 been be VBN 19613 4558 5 taken take VBN 19613 4558 6 to to TO 19613 4558 7 make make VB 19613 4558 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4558 9 easy easy JJ 19613 4558 10 for for IN 19613 4558 11 any any DT 19613 4558 12 one one CD 19613 4558 13 , , , 19613 4558 14 be be VB 19613 4558 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4558 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4558 17 or or CC 19613 4558 18 barbarian barbarian NNP 19613 4558 19 , , , 19613 4558 20 educated educated JJ 19613 4558 21 or or CC 19613 4558 22 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 4558 23 , , , 19613 4558 24 to to TO 19613 4558 25 grasp grasp VB 19613 4558 26 all all PDT 19613 4558 27 the the DT 19613 4558 28 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4558 29 of of IN 19613 4558 30 this this DT 19613 4558 31 reason reason NN 19613 4558 32 , , , 19613 4558 33 to to TO 19613 4558 34 verify verify VB 19613 4558 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4558 36 truth truth NN 19613 4558 37 , , , 19613 4558 38 and and CC 19613 4558 39 test test VB 19613 4558 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4558 41 power power NN 19613 4558 42 in in IN 19613 4558 43 life life NN 19613 4558 44 . . . 19613 4559 1 What what WDT 19613 4559 2 further further JJ 19613 4559 3 importance importance NN 19613 4559 4 can can MD 19613 4559 5 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4559 6 have have VB 19613 4559 7 side side NN 19613 4559 8 by by IN 19613 4559 9 side side NN 19613 4559 10 with with IN 19613 4559 11 this this DT 19613 4559 12 , , , 19613 4559 13 how how WRB 19613 4559 14 can can MD 19613 4559 15 one one PRP 19613 4559 16 think think VB 19613 4559 17 of of IN 19613 4559 18 calling call VBG 19613 4559 19 this this DT 19613 4559 20 a a DT 19613 4559 21 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4559 22 ? ? . 19613 4560 1 And and CC 19613 4560 2 yet yet RB 19613 4560 3 the the DT 19613 4560 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4560 5 of of IN 19613 4560 6 the the DT 19613 4560 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4560 8 can can MD 19613 4560 9 only only RB 19613 4560 10 be be VB 19613 4560 11 compared compare VBN 19613 4560 12 with with IN 19613 4560 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4560 14 . . . 19613 4561 1 For for IN 19613 4561 2 , , , 19613 4561 3 so so RB 19613 4561 4 far far RB 19613 4561 5 as as IN 19613 4561 6 the the DT 19613 4561 7 latter latter NN 19613 4561 8 is be VBZ 19613 4561 9 genuine genuine JJ 19613 4561 10 , , , 19613 4561 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4561 12 is be VBZ 19613 4561 13 also also RB 19613 4561 14 guided guide VBN 19613 4561 15 by by IN 19613 4561 16 the the DT 19613 4561 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4561 18 ; ; : 19613 4561 19 and and CC 19613 4561 20 , , , 19613 4561 21 conversely conversely RB 19613 4561 22 , , , 19613 4561 23 what what WP 19613 4561 24 the the DT 19613 4561 25 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4561 26 teach teach VBP 19613 4561 27 concerning concern VBG 19613 4561 28 the the DT 19613 4561 29 Father Father NNP 19613 4561 30 of of IN 19613 4561 31 the the DT 19613 4561 32 world world NN 19613 4561 33 , , , 19613 4561 34 the the DT 19613 4561 35 destiny destiny NN 19613 4561 36 of of IN 19613 4561 37 man man NN 19613 4561 38 , , , 19613 4561 39 the the DT 19613 4561 40 nobility nobility NN 19613 4561 41 of of IN 19613 4561 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4561 43 nature nature NN 19613 4561 44 , , , 19613 4561 45 freedom freedom NN 19613 4561 46 and and CC 19613 4561 47 virtue virtue NN 19613 4561 48 , , , 19613 4561 49 justice justice NN 19613 4561 50 and and CC 19613 4561 51 recompense recompense NN 19613 4561 52 , , , 19613 4561 53 has have VBZ 19613 4561 54 also also RB 19613 4561 55 been be VBN 19613 4561 56 attested attest VBN 19613 4561 57 by by IN 19613 4561 58 the the DT 19613 4561 59 wisest wise JJS 19613 4561 60 of of IN 19613 4561 61 the the DT 19613 4561 62 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4561 63 . . . 19613 4562 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4562 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 4562 3 only only RB 19613 4562 4 stammered stammer VBD 19613 4562 5 , , , 19613 4562 6 whereas whereas IN 19613 4562 7 the the DT 19613 4562 8 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4562 9 speak speak VBP 19613 4562 10 . . . 19613 4563 1 These these DT 19613 4563 2 , , , 19613 4563 3 however however RB 19613 4563 4 , , , 19613 4563 5 use use VB 19613 4563 6 no no DT 19613 4563 7 unintelligible unintelligible JJ 19613 4563 8 and and CC 19613 4563 9 unheard unheard JJ 19613 4563 10 - - HYPH 19613 4563 11 of of JJ 19613 4563 12 language language NN 19613 4563 13 , , , 19613 4563 14 but but CC 19613 4563 15 speak speak VB 19613 4563 16 with with IN 19613 4563 17 the the DT 19613 4563 18 words word NNS 19613 4563 19 and and CC 19613 4563 20 through through IN 19613 4563 21 the the DT 19613 4563 22 power power NN 19613 4563 23 of of IN 19613 4563 24 reason reason NN 19613 4563 25 . . . 19613 4564 1 The the DT 19613 4564 2 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 4564 3 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 4564 4 , , , 19613 4564 5 carried carry VBN 19613 4564 6 out out RP 19613 4564 7 by by IN 19613 4564 8 the the DT 19613 4564 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4564 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4564 11 , , , 19613 4564 12 through through IN 19613 4564 13 which which WDT 19613 4564 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4564 15 ennobled ennoble VBD 19613 4564 16 the the DT 19613 4564 17 human human JJ 19613 4564 18 race race NN 19613 4564 19 by by IN 19613 4564 20 restoring restore VBG 19613 4564 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4564 22 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 4564 23 of of IN 19613 4564 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4564 25 own own JJ 19613 4564 26 nobility nobility NN 19613 4564 27 , , , 19613 4564 28 compels compel VBZ 19613 4564 29 no no DT 19613 4564 30 one one NN 19613 4564 31 henceforth henceforth RB 19613 4564 32 to to TO 19613 4564 33 regard regard VB 19613 4564 34 the the DT 19613 4564 35 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4564 36 as as IN 19613 4564 37 the the DT 19613 4564 38 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 19613 4564 39 or or CC 19613 4564 40 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4564 41 as as IN 19613 4564 42 folly folly NNP 19613 4564 43 . . . 19613 4565 1 But but CC 19613 4565 2 is be VBZ 19613 4565 3 the the DT 19613 4565 4 Christian christian JJ 19613 4565 5 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4565 6 not not RB 19613 4565 7 of of IN 19613 4565 8 divine divine JJ 19613 4565 9 origin origin NN 19613 4565 10 ? ? . 19613 4566 1 How how WRB 19613 4566 2 can can MD 19613 4566 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4566 4 in in IN 19613 4566 5 that that DT 19613 4566 6 case case NN 19613 4566 7 be be VB 19613 4566 8 natural natural JJ 19613 4566 9 , , , 19613 4566 10 and and CC 19613 4566 11 what what WDT 19613 4566 12 connection connection NN 19613 4566 13 can can MD 19613 4566 14 exist exist VB 19613 4566 15 between between IN 19613 4566 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4566 17 and and CC 19613 4566 18 the the DT 19613 4566 19 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4566 20 of of IN 19613 4566 21 the the DT 19613 4566 22 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4566 23 ? ? . 19613 4567 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4567 2 bestowed bestow VBD 19613 4567 3 the the DT 19613 4567 4 closest close JJS 19613 4567 5 attention attention NN 19613 4567 6 on on IN 19613 4567 7 this this DT 19613 4567 8 question question NN 19613 4567 9 , , , 19613 4567 10 but but CC 19613 4567 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4567 12 never never RB 19613 4567 13 for for IN 19613 4567 14 a a DT 19613 4567 15 moment moment NN 19613 4567 16 doubted doubt VBD 19613 4567 17 what what WP 19613 4567 18 the the DT 19613 4567 19 answer answer NN 19613 4567 20 must must MD 19613 4567 21 be be VB 19613 4567 22 . . . 19613 4568 1 Wherever wherever WRB 19613 4568 2 the the DT 19613 4568 3 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4568 4 has have VBZ 19613 4568 5 revealed reveal VBN 19613 4568 6 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4568 7 , , , 19613 4568 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4568 9 has have VBZ 19613 4568 10 always always RB 19613 4568 11 been be VBN 19613 4568 12 through through IN 19613 4568 13 the the DT 19613 4568 14 operation operation NN 19613 4568 15 of of IN 19613 4568 16 the the DT 19613 4568 17 _ _ NNP 19613 4568 18 divine divine JJ 19613 4568 19 _ _ NNP 19613 4568 20 reason reason NN 19613 4568 21 . . . 19613 4569 1 For for IN 19613 4569 2 man man NN 19613 4569 3 's 's POS 19613 4569 4 lofty lofty JJ 19613 4569 5 endowment endowment NN 19613 4569 6 consists consist VBZ 19613 4569 7 in in IN 19613 4569 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4569 9 having have VBG 19613 4569 10 had have VBN 19613 4569 11 a a DT 19613 4569 12 portion portion NN 19613 4569 13 of of IN 19613 4569 14 the the DT 19613 4569 15 divine divine JJ 19613 4569 16 reason reason NN 19613 4569 17 implanted implant VBN 19613 4569 18 within within IN 19613 4569 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4569 20 , , , 19613 4569 21 and and CC 19613 4569 22 in in IN 19613 4569 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4569 24 consequent consequent JJ 19613 4569 25 capacity capacity NN 19613 4569 26 of of IN 19613 4569 27 attaining attain VBG 19613 4569 28 a a DT 19613 4569 29 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4569 30 of of IN 19613 4569 31 divine divine JJ 19613 4569 32 things thing NNS 19613 4569 33 , , , 19613 4569 34 though though IN 19613 4569 35 not not RB 19613 4569 36 a a DT 19613 4569 37 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4569 38 and and CC 19613 4569 39 clear clear JJ 19613 4569 40 one one CD 19613 4569 41 , , , 19613 4569 42 by by IN 19613 4569 43 dint dint NN 19613 4569 44 of of IN 19613 4569 45 persistent persistent JJ 19613 4569 46 efforts effort NNS 19613 4569 47 after after IN 19613 4569 48 truth truth NN 19613 4569 49 and and CC 19613 4569 50 virtue virtue NN 19613 4569 51 . . . 19613 4570 1 When when WRB 19613 4570 2 man man NN 19613 4570 3 remembers remember VBZ 19613 4570 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4570 5 real real JJ 19613 4570 6 nature nature NN 19613 4570 7 and and CC 19613 4570 8 destination destination NN 19613 4570 9 , , , 19613 4570 10 that that RB 19613 4570 11 is is RB 19613 4570 12 , , , 19613 4570 13 when when WRB 19613 4570 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4570 15 comes come VBZ 19613 4570 16 to to IN 19613 4570 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4570 18 , , , 19613 4570 19 the the DT 19613 4570 20 divine divine JJ 19613 4570 21 reason reason NN 19613 4570 22 is be VBZ 19613 4570 23 already already RB 19613 4570 24 revealing reveal VBG 19613 4570 25 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4570 26 in in IN 19613 4570 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4570 28 and and CC 19613 4570 29 through through IN 19613 4570 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4570 31 . . . 19613 4571 1 As as IN 19613 4571 2 man man NN 19613 4571 3 's 's POS 19613 4571 4 possession possession NN 19613 4571 5 conferred confer VBN 19613 4571 6 on on IN 19613 4571 7 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4571 8 at at IN 19613 4571 9 the the DT 19613 4571 10 creation creation NN 19613 4571 11 , , , 19613 4571 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4571 13 is be VBZ 19613 4571 14 at at IN 19613 4571 15 once once RB 19613 4571 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4571 17 most most RBS 19613 4571 18 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4571 19 property property NN 19613 4571 20 , , , 19613 4571 21 and and CC 19613 4571 22 the the DT 19613 4571 23 power power NN 19613 4571 24 which which WDT 19613 4571 25 dominates dominate VBZ 19613 4571 26 and and CC 19613 4571 27 determines determine VBZ 19613 4571 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4571 29 nature nature NN 19613 4571 30 . . . 19613 4572 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4572 2 362 362 CD 19613 4572 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4572 4 All all DT 19613 4572 5 that that WDT 19613 4572 6 is be VBZ 19613 4572 7 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4572 8 is be VBZ 19613 4572 9 based base VBN 19613 4572 10 on on IN 19613 4572 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 4572 12 . . . 19613 4573 1 In in IN 19613 4573 2 order order NN 19613 4573 3 to to TO 19613 4573 4 accomplish accomplish VB 19613 4573 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4573 6 true true JJ 19613 4573 7 destiny destiny NN 19613 4573 8 man man NN 19613 4573 9 requires require VBZ 19613 4573 10 from from IN 19613 4573 11 the the DT 19613 4573 12 beginning beginning NN 19613 4573 13 the the DT 19613 4573 14 inward inward JJ 19613 4573 15 working work VBG 19613 4573 16 of of IN 19613 4573 17 that that DT 19613 4573 18 divine divine JJ 19613 4573 19 reason reason NN 19613 4573 20 which which WDT 19613 4573 21 has have VBZ 19613 4573 22 created create VBN 19613 4573 23 the the DT 19613 4573 24 world world NN 19613 4573 25 for for IN 19613 4573 26 the the DT 19613 4573 27 sake sake NN 19613 4573 28 of of IN 19613 4573 29 man man NN 19613 4573 30 , , , 19613 4573 31 and and CC 19613 4573 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 4573 33 wishes wish VBZ 19613 4573 34 to to TO 19613 4573 35 raise raise VB 19613 4573 36 man man NN 19613 4573 37 beyond beyond IN 19613 4573 38 the the DT 19613 4573 39 world world NN 19613 4573 40 to to IN 19613 4573 41 God God NNP 19613 4573 42 . . . 19613 4574 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4574 2 363 363 CD 19613 4574 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4574 4 Apparently apparently RB 19613 4574 5 no no DT 19613 4574 6 one one PRP 19613 4574 7 could could MD 19613 4574 8 speak speak VB 19613 4574 9 in in IN 19613 4574 10 a a DT 19613 4574 11 more more RBR 19613 4574 12 stoical stoical JJ 19613 4574 13 fashion fashion NN 19613 4574 14 . . . 19613 4575 1 But but CC 19613 4575 2 this this DT 19613 4575 3 train train NN 19613 4575 4 of of IN 19613 4575 5 thought thought NN 19613 4575 6 is be VBZ 19613 4575 7 supplemented supplement VBN 19613 4575 8 by by IN 19613 4575 9 something something NN 19613 4575 10 which which WDT 19613 4575 11 limits limit VBZ 19613 4575 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4575 13 . . . 19613 4576 1 Revelation revelation NN 19613 4576 2 does do VBZ 19613 4576 3 retain retain VB 19613 4576 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4576 5 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4576 6 and and CC 19613 4576 7 unique unique JJ 19613 4576 8 significance significance NN 19613 4576 9 . . . 19613 4577 1 For for IN 19613 4577 2 no no DT 19613 4577 3 one one NN 19613 4577 4 who who WP 19613 4577 5 merely merely RB 19613 4577 6 possessed possess VBD 19613 4577 7 the the DT 19613 4577 8 " " `` 19613 4577 9 seed seed NN 19613 4577 10 of of IN 19613 4577 11 the the DT 19613 4577 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4577 13 " " '' 19613 4577 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4577 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4577 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4577 17 : : : 19613 4577 18 sperma sperma NNP 19613 4577 19 tou tou NNP 19613 4577 20 logou logou NNP 19613 4577 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4577 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4577 23 , , , 19613 4577 24 though though IN 19613 4577 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4577 26 may may MD 19613 4577 27 have have VB 19613 4577 28 been be VBN 19613 4577 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4577 30 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 4577 31 guide guide NN 19613 4577 32 to to TO 19613 4577 33 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4577 34 and and CC 19613 4577 35 conduct conduct NN 19613 4577 36 , , , 19613 4577 37 was be VBD 19613 4577 38 ever ever RB 19613 4577 39 able able JJ 19613 4577 40 to to TO 19613 4577 41 grasp grasp VB 19613 4577 42 the the DT 19613 4577 43 whole whole JJ 19613 4577 44 truth truth NN 19613 4577 45 and and CC 19613 4577 46 impart impart VB 19613 4577 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4577 48 in in IN 19613 4577 49 a a DT 19613 4577 50 convincing convincing JJ 19613 4577 51 manner manner NN 19613 4577 52 . . . 19613 4578 1 Though though IN 19613 4578 2 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4578 3 and and CC 19613 4578 4 Heraclitus Heraclitus NNP 19613 4578 5 may may MD 19613 4578 6 in in IN 19613 4578 7 a a DT 19613 4578 8 way way NN 19613 4578 9 be be VB 19613 4578 10 called call VBN 19613 4578 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4578 12 , , , 19613 4578 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4578 14 can can MD 19613 4578 15 not not RB 19613 4578 16 be be VB 19613 4578 17 so so RB 19613 4578 18 designated designate VBN 19613 4578 19 in in IN 19613 4578 20 any any DT 19613 4578 21 real real JJ 19613 4578 22 sense sense NN 19613 4578 23 . . . 19613 4579 1 Reason reason NN 19613 4579 2 is be VBZ 19613 4579 3 clogged clog VBN 19613 4579 4 with with IN 19613 4579 5 unreasonableness unreasonableness JJ 19613 4579 6 , , , 19613 4579 7 and and CC 19613 4579 8 the the DT 19613 4579 9 certainty certainty NN 19613 4579 10 of of IN 19613 4579 11 truth truth NN 19613 4579 12 is be VBZ 19613 4579 13 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 4579 14 wherever wherever WRB 19613 4579 15 the the DT 19613 4579 16 whole whole JJ 19613 4579 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4579 18 has have VBZ 19613 4579 19 not not RB 19613 4579 20 been be VBN 19613 4579 21 acting act VBG 19613 4579 22 ; ; : 19613 4579 23 for for IN 19613 4579 24 man man NN 19613 4579 25 's 's POS 19613 4579 26 natural natural JJ 19613 4579 27 endowment endowment NN 19613 4579 28 with with IN 19613 4579 29 reason reason NN 19613 4579 30 is be VBZ 19613 4579 31 too too RB 19613 4579 32 weak weak JJ 19613 4579 33 to to TO 19613 4579 34 oppose oppose VB 19613 4579 35 the the DT 19613 4579 36 powers power NNS 19613 4579 37 of of IN 19613 4579 38 evil evil NN 19613 4579 39 and and CC 19613 4579 40 of of IN 19613 4579 41 sense sense NN 19613 4579 42 that that IN 19613 4579 43 work work VBP 19613 4579 44 in in IN 19613 4579 45 the the DT 19613 4579 46 world world NN 19613 4579 47 , , , 19613 4579 48 namely namely RB 19613 4579 49 , , , 19613 4579 50 the the DT 19613 4579 51 demons demon NNS 19613 4579 52 . . . 19613 4580 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4580 2 must must MD 19613 4580 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 4580 4 believe believe VB 19613 4580 5 in in IN 19613 4580 6 the the DT 19613 4580 7 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4580 8 in in IN 19613 4580 9 whom whom WP 19613 4580 10 the the DT 19613 4580 11 whole whole JJ 19613 4580 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4580 13 spoke speak VBD 19613 4580 14 . . . 19613 4581 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4581 2 who who WP 19613 4581 3 does do VBZ 19613 4581 4 that that DT 19613 4581 5 must must MD 19613 4581 6 also also RB 19613 4581 7 of of IN 19613 4581 8 necessity necessity NN 19613 4581 9 believe believe VB 19613 4581 10 in in IN 19613 4581 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4581 12 ; ; : 19613 4581 13 for for IN 19613 4581 14 the the DT 19613 4581 15 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4581 16 clearly clearly RB 19613 4581 17 pointed point VBD 19613 4581 18 to to IN 19613 4581 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4581 20 as as IN 19613 4581 21 the the DT 19613 4581 22 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4581 23 embodiment embodiment NN 19613 4581 24 of of IN 19613 4581 25 the the DT 19613 4581 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4581 27 . . . 19613 4582 1 Measured measure VBN 19613 4582 2 by by IN 19613 4582 3 the the DT 19613 4582 4 fulness fulness NN 19613 4582 5 , , , 19613 4582 6 clearness clearness NN 19613 4582 7 , , , 19613 4582 8 and and CC 19613 4582 9 certainty certainty NN 19613 4582 10 of of IN 19613 4582 11 the the DT 19613 4582 12 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4582 13 imparted impart VBN 19613 4582 14 by by IN 19613 4582 15 the the DT 19613 4582 16 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4582 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4582 18 , , , 19613 4582 19 all all DT 19613 4582 20 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4582 21 independent independent JJ 19613 4582 22 of of IN 19613 4582 23 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4582 24 appears appear VBZ 19613 4582 25 as as RB 19613 4582 26 merely merely RB 19613 4582 27 human human JJ 19613 4582 28 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4582 29 , , , 19613 4582 30 even even RB 19613 4582 31 when when WRB 19613 4582 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4582 33 emanates emanate VBZ 19613 4582 34 from from IN 19613 4582 35 the the DT 19613 4582 36 seed seed NN 19613 4582 37 of of IN 19613 4582 38 the the DT 19613 4582 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4582 40 . . . 19613 4583 1 The the DT 19613 4583 2 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4583 3 argument argument NN 19613 4583 4 is be VBZ 19613 4583 5 consequently consequently RB 19613 4583 6 untenable untenable JJ 19613 4583 7 . . . 19613 4584 1 Men men NN 19613 4584 2 blind blind JJ 19613 4584 3 and and CC 19613 4584 4 kept keep VBD 19613 4584 5 in in IN 19613 4584 6 bondage bondage NN 19613 4584 7 by by IN 19613 4584 8 the the DT 19613 4584 9 demons demon NNS 19613 4584 10 require require VBP 19613 4584 11 to to TO 19613 4584 12 be be VB 19613 4584 13 aided aid VBN 19613 4584 14 by by IN 19613 4584 15 a a DT 19613 4584 16 special special JJ 19613 4584 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 4584 18 . . . 19613 4585 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4585 2 is be VBZ 19613 4585 3 true true JJ 19613 4585 4 that that IN 19613 4585 5 this this DT 19613 4585 6 revelation revelation NN 19613 4585 7 is be VBZ 19613 4585 8 nothing nothing NN 19613 4585 9 new new JJ 19613 4585 10 , , , 19613 4585 11 and and CC 19613 4585 12 in in IN 19613 4585 13 so so RB 19613 4585 14 far far RB 19613 4585 15 as as IN 19613 4585 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4585 17 has have VBZ 19613 4585 18 always always RB 19613 4585 19 existed exist VBN 19613 4585 20 , , , 19613 4585 21 and and CC 19613 4585 22 never never RB 19613 4585 23 varied vary VBD 19613 4585 24 in in IN 19613 4585 25 character character NN 19613 4585 26 , , , 19613 4585 27 from from IN 19613 4585 28 the the DT 19613 4585 29 beginning beginning NN 19613 4585 30 of of IN 19613 4585 31 the the DT 19613 4585 32 world world NN 19613 4585 33 , , , 19613 4585 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4585 35 is be VBZ 19613 4585 36 in in IN 19613 4585 37 this this DT 19613 4585 38 sense sense NN 19613 4585 39 nothing nothing NN 19613 4585 40 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 4585 41 . . . 19613 4586 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4586 2 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4586 3 is be VBZ 19613 4586 4 the the DT 19613 4586 5 divine divine JJ 19613 4586 6 help help NN 19613 4586 7 granted grant VBN 19613 4586 8 to to IN 19613 4586 9 man man NN 19613 4586 10 , , , 19613 4586 11 who who WP 19613 4586 12 has have VBZ 19613 4586 13 fallen fall VBN 19613 4586 14 under under IN 19613 4586 15 the the DT 19613 4586 16 power power NN 19613 4586 17 of of IN 19613 4586 18 the the DT 19613 4586 19 demons demon NNS 19613 4586 20 , , , 19613 4586 21 and and CC 19613 4586 22 enabling enable VBG 19613 4586 23 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4586 24 to to TO 19613 4586 25 follow follow VB 19613 4586 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4586 27 reason reason NN 19613 4586 28 and and CC 19613 4586 29 freedom freedom NN 19613 4586 30 to to TO 19613 4586 31 do do VB 19613 4586 32 what what WP 19613 4586 33 is be VBZ 19613 4586 34 good good JJ 19613 4586 35 . . . 19613 4587 1 By by IN 19613 4587 2 the the DT 19613 4587 3 appearance appearance NN 19613 4587 4 of of IN 19613 4587 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4587 6 this this DT 19613 4587 7 help help NN 19613 4587 8 became become VBD 19613 4587 9 accessible accessible JJ 19613 4587 10 to to IN 19613 4587 11 all all DT 19613 4587 12 men man NNS 19613 4587 13 . . . 19613 4587 14 _ _ NNP 19613 4587 15 The the DT 19613 4587 16 dominion dominion NN 19613 4587 17 of of IN 19613 4587 18 demons demon NNS 19613 4587 19 and and CC 19613 4587 20 revelation revelation NN 19613 4587 21 are be VBP 19613 4587 22 the the DT 19613 4587 23 two two CD 19613 4587 24 correlated correlate VBN 19613 4587 25 ideas idea NNS 19613 4587 26 . . . 19613 4588 1 If if IN 19613 4588 2 the the DT 19613 4588 3 former former JJ 19613 4588 4 did do VBD 19613 4588 5 not not RB 19613 4588 6 exist exist VB 19613 4588 7 , , , 19613 4588 8 the the DT 19613 4588 9 latter latter JJ 19613 4588 10 would would MD 19613 4588 11 not not RB 19613 4588 12 be be VB 19613 4588 13 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4588 14 . . . 19613 4589 1 According accord VBG 19613 4589 2 as as IN 19613 4589 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4589 4 form form VBP 19613 4589 5 a a DT 19613 4589 6 lower low JJR 19613 4589 7 or or CC 19613 4589 8 higher high JJR 19613 4589 9 estimate estimate NN 19613 4589 10 of of IN 19613 4589 11 the the DT 19613 4589 12 pernicious pernicious JJ 19613 4589 13 results result NNS 19613 4589 14 of of IN 19613 4589 15 that that DT 19613 4589 16 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4589 17 , , , 19613 4589 18 the the DT 19613 4589 19 value value NN 19613 4589 20 of of IN 19613 4589 21 revelation revelation NN 19613 4589 22 rises rise NNS 19613 4589 23 or or CC 19613 4589 24 sinks sink NNS 19613 4589 25 . . . 19613 4590 1 This this DT 19613 4590 2 revelation revelation NN 19613 4590 3 can can MD 19613 4590 4 not not RB 19613 4590 5 do do VB 19613 4590 6 less less JJR 19613 4590 7 than than IN 19613 4590 8 give give VB 19613 4590 9 the the DT 19613 4590 10 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4590 11 assurance assurance NN 19613 4590 12 of of IN 19613 4590 13 the the DT 19613 4590 14 truth truth NN 19613 4590 15 , , , 19613 4590 16 and and CC 19613 4590 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4590 18 can can MD 19613 4590 19 not not RB 19613 4590 20 do do VB 19613 4590 21 more more JJR 19613 4590 22 than than IN 19613 4590 23 impart impart VB 19613 4590 24 the the DT 19613 4590 25 power power NN 19613 4590 26 that that WDT 19613 4590 27 develops develop VBZ 19613 4590 28 and and CC 19613 4590 29 matures mature VBZ 19613 4590 30 the the DT 19613 4590 31 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 4590 32 natural natural JJ 19613 4590 33 endowment endowment NN 19613 4590 34 of of IN 19613 4590 35 man man NN 19613 4590 36 and and CC 19613 4590 37 frees free VBZ 19613 4590 38 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4590 39 from from IN 19613 4590 40 the the DT 19613 4590 41 dominion dominion NN 19613 4590 42 of of IN 19613 4590 43 the the DT 19613 4590 44 demons demon NNS 19613 4590 45 . . . 19613 4591 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4591 2 the the DT 19613 4591 3 teaching teaching NN 19613 4591 4 of of IN 19613 4591 5 the the DT 19613 4591 6 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4591 7 and and CC 19613 4591 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4591 9 is be VBZ 19613 4591 10 related relate VBN 19613 4591 11 even even RB 19613 4591 12 to to IN 19613 4591 13 the the DT 19613 4591 14 very very RB 19613 4591 15 highest high JJS 19613 4591 16 human human JJ 19613 4591 17 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4591 18 as as IN 19613 4591 19 the the DT 19613 4591 20 whole whole NN 19613 4591 21 is be VBZ 19613 4591 22 to to IN 19613 4591 23 the the DT 19613 4591 24 part,[364 part,[364 NN 19613 4591 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4591 26 or or CC 19613 4591 27 as as IN 19613 4591 28 the the DT 19613 4591 29 certain certain JJ 19613 4591 30 is be VBZ 19613 4591 31 to to IN 19613 4591 32 the the DT 19613 4591 33 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 4591 34 ; ; : 19613 4591 35 and and CC 19613 4591 36 hence hence RB 19613 4591 37 also also RB 19613 4591 38 as as IN 19613 4591 39 the the DT 19613 4591 40 permanent permanent JJ 19613 4591 41 is be VBZ 19613 4591 42 to to IN 19613 4591 43 the the DT 19613 4591 44 transient transient NN 19613 4591 45 . . . 19613 4592 1 For for IN 19613 4592 2 the the DT 19613 4592 3 final final JJ 19613 4592 4 stage stage NN 19613 4592 5 has have VBZ 19613 4592 6 now now RB 19613 4592 7 arrived arrive VBN 19613 4592 8 and and CC 19613 4592 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4592 10 is be VBZ 19613 4592 11 destined destine VBN 19613 4592 12 to to TO 19613 4592 13 put put VB 19613 4592 14 an an DT 19613 4592 15 end end NN 19613 4592 16 to to IN 19613 4592 17 natural natural JJ 19613 4592 18 human human JJ 19613 4592 19 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4592 20 . . . 19613 4593 1 When when WRB 19613 4593 2 the the DT 19613 4593 3 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4593 4 work work NN 19613 4593 5 is be VBZ 19613 4593 6 there there RB 19613 4593 7 , , , 19613 4593 8 the the DT 19613 4593 9 fragmentary fragmentary NN 19613 4593 10 must must MD 19613 4593 11 cease cease VB 19613 4593 12 . . . 19613 4594 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4594 2 gave give VBD 19613 4594 3 the the DT 19613 4594 4 clearest clear JJS 19613 4594 5 expression expression NN 19613 4594 6 to to IN 19613 4594 7 this this DT 19613 4594 8 conviction conviction NN 19613 4594 9 . . . 19613 4595 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4595 2 , , , 19613 4595 3 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4595 4 , , , 19613 4595 5 the the DT 19613 4595 6 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4595 7 teaching teaching NN 19613 4595 8 attested attest VBN 19613 4595 9 by by IN 19613 4595 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4595 11 and and CC 19613 4595 12 accessible accessible JJ 19613 4595 13 to to IN 19613 4595 14 all all DT 19613 4595 15 , , , 19613 4595 16 puts put VBZ 19613 4595 17 an an DT 19613 4595 18 end end NN 19613 4595 19 to to IN 19613 4595 20 the the DT 19613 4595 21 human human JJ 19613 4595 22 systems system NNS 19613 4595 23 of of IN 19613 4595 24 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4595 25 that that IN 19613 4595 26 from from IN 19613 4595 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4595 28 close close JJ 19613 4595 29 affinity affinity NN 19613 4595 30 to to IN 19613 4595 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4595 32 may may MD 19613 4595 33 be be VB 19613 4595 34 called call VBN 19613 4595 35 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4595 36 , , , 19613 4595 37 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 4595 38 as as IN 19613 4595 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4595 40 effects effect VBZ 19613 4595 41 all all DT 19613 4595 42 and and CC 19613 4595 43 more more RBR 19613 4595 44 than than IN 19613 4595 45 all all DT 19613 4595 46 that that WDT 19613 4595 47 these these DT 19613 4595 48 systems system NNS 19613 4595 49 have have VBP 19613 4595 50 done do VBN 19613 4595 51 , , , 19613 4595 52 and and CC 19613 4595 53 inasmuch inasmuch VB 19613 4595 54 as as IN 19613 4595 55 the the DT 19613 4595 56 speculations speculation NNS 19613 4595 57 of of IN 19613 4595 58 the the DT 19613 4595 59 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4595 60 , , , 19613 4595 61 which which WDT 19613 4595 62 are be VBP 19613 4595 63 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 4595 64 and and CC 19613 4595 65 mingled mingle VBN 19613 4595 66 with with IN 19613 4595 67 error error NN 19613 4595 68 , , , 19613 4595 69 are be VBP 19613 4595 70 transformed transform VBN 19613 4595 71 by by IN 19613 4595 72 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4595 73 into into IN 19613 4595 74 dogmas dogmas NNP 19613 4595 75 of of IN 19613 4595 76 indubitable indubitable JJ 19613 4595 77 certainty certainty NN 19613 4595 78 . . . 19613 4596 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4596 2 365 365 CD 19613 4596 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4596 4 The the DT 19613 4596 5 practical practical JJ 19613 4596 6 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 4596 7 drawn draw VBN 19613 4596 8 in in IN 19613 4596 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4596 10 's 's POS 19613 4596 11 treatise treatise NN 19613 4596 12 from from IN 19613 4596 13 this this DT 19613 4596 14 exposition exposition NN 19613 4596 15 is be VBZ 19613 4596 16 that that IN 19613 4596 17 the the DT 19613 4596 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4596 19 are be VBP 19613 4596 20 at at IN 19613 4596 21 least least JJS 19613 4596 22 entitled entitle VBN 19613 4596 23 to to TO 19613 4596 24 ask ask VB 19613 4596 25 the the DT 19613 4596 26 authorities authority NNS 19613 4596 27 to to TO 19613 4596 28 treat treat VB 19613 4596 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4596 30 as as IN 19613 4596 31 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4596 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4596 33 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4596 34 . . . 19613 4597 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4598 1 7 7 CD 19613 4598 2 , , , 19613 4598 3 20 20 CD 19613 4598 4 : : : 19613 4598 5 II ii CD 19613 4598 6 . . . 19613 4599 1 15 15 CD 19613 4599 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4599 3 . . . 19613 4600 1 This this DT 19613 4600 2 demand demand NN 19613 4600 3 , , , 19613 4600 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4600 5 says say VBZ 19613 4600 6 , , , 19613 4600 7 is be VBZ 19613 4600 8 the the DT 19613 4600 9 more more RBR 19613 4600 10 justifiable justifiable JJ 19613 4600 11 because because IN 19613 4600 12 the the DT 19613 4600 13 freedom freedom NN 19613 4600 14 of of IN 19613 4600 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4600 16 is be VBZ 19613 4600 17 enjoyed enjoy VBN 19613 4600 18 even even RB 19613 4600 19 by by IN 19613 4600 20 such such JJ 19613 4600 21 people people NNS 19613 4600 22 as as RB 19613 4600 23 merely merely RB 19613 4600 24 bear bear VBP 19613 4600 25 the the DT 19613 4600 26 name name NN 19613 4600 27 , , , 19613 4600 28 whereas whereas IN 19613 4600 29 in in IN 19613 4600 30 reality reality NN 19613 4600 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4600 32 set set VBD 19613 4600 33 forth forth RP 19613 4600 34 immoral immoral JJ 19613 4600 35 and and CC 19613 4600 36 pernicious pernicious JJ 19613 4600 37 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4600 38 . . . 19613 4601 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4601 2 366 366 CD 19613 4601 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4601 4 In in IN 19613 4601 5 the the DT 19613 4601 6 dialogue dialogue NN 19613 4601 7 with with IN 19613 4601 8 the the DT 19613 4601 9 Jew Jew NNP 19613 4601 10 Trypho Trypho NNP 19613 4601 11 , , , 19613 4601 12 which which WDT 19613 4601 13 is be VBZ 19613 4601 14 likewise likewise RB 19613 4601 15 meant mean VBN 19613 4601 16 for for IN 19613 4601 17 heathen heathen NNP 19613 4601 18 readers reader NNS 19613 4601 19 , , , 19613 4601 20 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4601 21 ceased cease VBD 19613 4601 22 to to TO 19613 4601 23 employ employ VB 19613 4601 24 the the DT 19613 4601 25 idea idea NN 19613 4601 26 of of IN 19613 4601 27 the the DT 19613 4601 28 existence existence NN 19613 4601 29 of of IN 19613 4601 30 a a DT 19613 4601 31 " " `` 19613 4601 32 seed seed NN 19613 4601 33 of of IN 19613 4601 34 the the DT 19613 4601 35 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4601 36 implanted implant VBN 19613 4601 37 by by IN 19613 4601 38 nature nature NN 19613 4601 39 " " '' 19613 4601 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4601 41 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4601 42 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4601 43 : : : 19613 4601 44 sperma sperma NNP 19613 4601 45 logou logou NNP 19613 4601 46 emphuton emphuton NNP 19613 4601 47 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4601 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4601 49 in in IN 19613 4601 50 every every DT 19613 4601 51 man man NN 19613 4601 52 . . . 19613 4602 1 From from IN 19613 4602 2 this this DT 19613 4602 3 fact fact NN 19613 4602 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4602 5 recognise recognise VBP 19613 4602 6 that that IN 19613 4602 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4602 8 did do VBD 19613 4602 9 not not RB 19613 4602 10 consider consider VB 19613 4602 11 the the DT 19613 4602 12 notion notion NN 19613 4602 13 of of IN 19613 4602 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4602 15 importance importance NN 19613 4602 16 . . . 19613 4603 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4603 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 4603 3 calls call VBZ 19613 4603 4 the the DT 19613 4603 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 4603 6 religion religion NN 19613 4603 7 a a DT 19613 4603 8 philosophy;[367 philosophy;[367 NN 19613 4603 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4603 10 but but CC 19613 4603 11 , , , 19613 4603 12 in in IN 19613 4603 13 so so RB 19613 4603 14 far far RB 19613 4603 15 as as IN 19613 4603 16 this this DT 19613 4603 17 is be VBZ 19613 4603 18 the the DT 19613 4603 19 case case NN 19613 4603 20 , , , 19613 4603 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4603 22 is be VBZ 19613 4603 23 " " `` 19613 4603 24 the the DT 19613 4603 25 only only JJ 19613 4603 26 sure sure JJ 19613 4603 27 and and CC 19613 4603 28 saving save VBG 19613 4603 29 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4603 30 . . . 19613 4603 31 " " '' 19613 4604 1 No no RB 19613 4604 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 4604 3 the the DT 19613 4604 4 so so RB 19613 4604 5 - - HYPH 19613 4604 6 called call VBN 19613 4604 7 philosophies philosophy NNS 19613 4604 8 put put VBD 19613 4604 9 the the DT 19613 4604 10 right right JJ 19613 4604 11 questions question NNS 19613 4604 12 , , , 19613 4604 13 but but CC 19613 4604 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4604 15 are be VBP 19613 4604 16 incapable incapable JJ 19613 4604 17 of of IN 19613 4604 18 giving give VBG 19613 4604 19 correct correct JJ 19613 4604 20 answers answer NNS 19613 4604 21 . . . 19613 4605 1 For for IN 19613 4605 2 the the DT 19613 4605 3 Deity Deity NNP 19613 4605 4 , , , 19613 4605 5 who who WP 19613 4605 6 embraces embrace VBZ 19613 4605 7 all all DT 19613 4605 8 true true JJ 19613 4605 9 being being NN 19613 4605 10 , , , 19613 4605 11 and and CC 19613 4605 12 a a DT 19613 4605 13 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4605 14 of of IN 19613 4605 15 whom whom WP 19613 4605 16 alone alone RB 19613 4605 17 makes make VBZ 19613 4605 18 salvation salvation NN 19613 4605 19 possible possible JJ 19613 4605 20 , , , 19613 4605 21 is be VBZ 19613 4605 22 only only RB 19613 4605 23 known know VBN 19613 4605 24 in in IN 19613 4605 25 proportion proportion NN 19613 4605 26 as as IN 19613 4605 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4605 28 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 4605 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4605 30 . . . 19613 4606 1 True true JJ 19613 4606 2 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4606 3 is be VBZ 19613 4606 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 4606 5 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 4606 6 based base VBN 19613 4606 7 on on IN 19613 4606 8 revelation revelation NN 19613 4606 9 . . . 19613 4607 1 Hence hence RB 19613 4607 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4607 3 is be VBZ 19613 4607 4 opposed opposed JJ 19613 4607 5 to to IN 19613 4607 6 every every DT 19613 4607 7 human human JJ 19613 4607 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4607 9 , , , 19613 4607 10 because because IN 19613 4607 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 4607 12 was be VBD 19613 4607 13 only only RB 19613 4607 14 given give VBN 19613 4607 15 in in IN 19613 4607 16 the the DT 19613 4607 17 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4607 18 and and CC 19613 4607 19 in in IN 19613 4607 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4607 21 . . . 19613 4608 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4608 2 368 368 CD 19613 4608 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4608 4 The the DT 19613 4608 5 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4608 6 is be VBZ 19613 4608 7 _ _ NNP 19613 4608 8 the the DT 19613 4608 9 _ _ NNP 19613 4608 10 philosopher,[369 philosopher,[369 NN 19613 4608 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4608 12 because because IN 19613 4608 13 the the DT 19613 4608 14 followers follower NNS 19613 4608 15 of of IN 19613 4608 16 Plato Plato NNP 19613 4608 17 and and CC 19613 4608 18 the the DT 19613 4608 19 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 4608 20 are be VBP 19613 4608 21 virtually virtually RB 19613 4608 22 no no DT 19613 4608 23 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4608 24 . . . 19613 4609 1 In in IN 19613 4609 2 applying apply VBG 19613 4609 3 the the DT 19613 4609 4 title title NN 19613 4609 5 " " `` 19613 4609 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4609 7 " " '' 19613 4609 8 to to IN 19613 4609 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4609 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4609 11 therefore therefore RB 19613 4609 12 does do VBZ 19613 4609 13 not not RB 19613 4609 14 mean mean VB 19613 4609 15 to to TO 19613 4609 16 bring bring VB 19613 4609 17 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4609 18 and and CC 19613 4609 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4609 20 more more RBR 19613 4609 21 closely closely RB 19613 4609 22 together together RB 19613 4609 23 . . . 19613 4610 1 No no RB 19613 4610 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 4610 3 , , , 19613 4610 4 however however RB 19613 4610 5 , , , 19613 4610 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4610 7 asserts assert VBZ 19613 4610 8 that that IN 19613 4610 9 the the DT 19613 4610 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 4610 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4610 12 , , , 19613 4610 13 which which WDT 19613 4610 14 is be VBZ 19613 4610 15 founded found VBN 19613 4610 16 on on IN 19613 4610 17 the the DT 19613 4610 18 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4610 19 of of IN 19613 4610 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4610 21 and and CC 19613 4610 22 leads lead VBZ 19613 4610 23 to to IN 19613 4610 24 blessedness,[370 blessedness,[370 NNP 19613 4610 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4610 26 is be VBZ 19613 4610 27 in in IN 19613 4610 28 accordance accordance NN 19613 4610 29 with with IN 19613 4610 30 reason reason NN 19613 4610 31 . . . 19613 4611 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4611 2 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 4611 3 . . . 19613 4611 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4611 5 The the DT 19613 4611 6 petition petition NN 19613 4611 7 on on IN 19613 4611 8 behalf behalf NN 19613 4611 9 of of IN 19613 4611 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4611 11 , , , 19613 4611 12 which which WDT 19613 4611 13 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 4611 14 , , , 19613 4611 15 " " '' 19613 4611 16 the the DT 19613 4611 17 Christian christian JJ 19613 4611 18 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 4611 19 of of IN 19613 4611 20 Athens Athens NNP 19613 4611 21 , , , 19613 4611 22 " " '' 19613 4611 23 presented present VBN 19613 4611 24 , , , 19613 4611 25 to to IN 19613 4611 26 the the DT 19613 4611 27 emperors emperor NNS 19613 4611 28 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 4611 29 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 19613 4611 30 and and CC 19613 4611 31 Commodus Commodus NNP 19613 4611 32 , , , 19613 4611 33 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 4611 34 expressly expressly RB 19613 4611 35 designates designate VBZ 19613 4611 36 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4611 37 as as IN 19613 4611 38 a a DT 19613 4611 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4611 40 , , , 19613 4611 41 and and CC 19613 4611 42 still still RB 19613 4611 43 less less JJR 19613 4611 44 does do VBZ 19613 4611 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4611 46 style style VB 19613 4611 47 the the DT 19613 4611 48 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4611 49 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4611 50 . . . 19613 4612 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4612 2 371 371 CD 19613 4612 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4612 4 But but CC 19613 4612 5 , , , 19613 4612 6 at at IN 19613 4612 7 the the DT 19613 4612 8 very very JJ 19613 4612 9 beginning beginning NN 19613 4612 10 of of IN 19613 4612 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4612 12 writing write VBG 19613 4612 13 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 4612 14 also also RB 19613 4612 15 claims claim VBZ 19613 4612 16 for for IN 19613 4612 17 the the DT 19613 4612 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 4612 19 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4612 20 the the DT 19613 4612 21 toleration toleration NN 19613 4612 22 granted grant VBN 19613 4612 23 by by IN 19613 4612 24 the the DT 19613 4612 25 state state NN 19613 4612 26 to to IN 19613 4612 27 all all DT 19613 4612 28 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 4612 29 tenets tenet NNS 19613 4612 30 . . . 19613 4613 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4613 2 372 372 CD 19613 4613 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4613 4 In in IN 19613 4613 5 support support NN 19613 4613 6 of of IN 19613 4613 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4613 8 claim claim NN 19613 4613 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4613 10 argues argue VBZ 19613 4613 11 that that IN 19613 4613 12 the the DT 19613 4613 13 state state NN 19613 4613 14 punishes punish VBZ 19613 4613 15 nothing nothing NN 19613 4613 16 but but IN 19613 4613 17 practical practical JJ 19613 4613 18 atheism,[373 atheism,[373 NNP 19613 4613 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4613 20 and and CC 19613 4613 21 that that IN 19613 4613 22 the the DT 19613 4613 23 " " `` 19613 4613 24 atheism atheism NN 19613 4613 25 " " '' 19613 4613 26 of of IN 19613 4613 27 the the DT 19613 4613 28 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4613 29 is be VBZ 19613 4613 30 a a DT 19613 4613 31 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4613 32 about about IN 19613 4613 33 God God NNP 19613 4613 34 such such JJ 19613 4613 35 as as IN 19613 4613 36 had have VBD 19613 4613 37 been be VBN 19613 4613 38 propounded propound VBN 19613 4613 39 by by IN 19613 4613 40 the the DT 19613 4613 41 most most RBS 19613 4613 42 distinguished distinguished JJ 19613 4613 43 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4613 44 -- -- : 19613 4613 45 Pythagoreans Pythagoreans NNPS 19613 4613 46 , , , 19613 4613 47 Platonists Platonists NNPS 19613 4613 48 , , , 19613 4613 49 Peripatetics Peripatetics NNPS 19613 4613 50 , , , 19613 4613 51 and and CC 19613 4613 52 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 4613 53 -- -- : 19613 4613 54 who who WP 19613 4613 55 , , , 19613 4613 56 moreover moreover RB 19613 4613 57 , , , 19613 4613 58 were be VBD 19613 4613 59 permitted permit VBN 19613 4613 60 to to TO 19613 4613 61 write write VB 19613 4613 62 whatsoever whatsoever RB 19613 4613 63 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4613 64 pleased please VBD 19613 4613 65 on on IN 19613 4613 66 the the DT 19613 4613 67 subject subject NN 19613 4613 68 of of IN 19613 4613 69 the the DT 19613 4613 70 " " `` 19613 4613 71 Deity deity NN 19613 4613 72 . . . 19613 4614 1 " " `` 19613 4614 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4614 3 374 374 CD 19613 4614 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4614 5 The the DT 19613 4614 6 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 4614 7 concedes concede VBZ 19613 4614 8 even even RB 19613 4614 9 more more JJR 19613 4614 10 : : : 19613 4614 11 " " `` 19613 4614 12 If if IN 19613 4614 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4614 14 did do VBD 19613 4614 15 not not RB 19613 4614 16 also also RB 19613 4614 17 acknowledge acknowledge VB 19613 4614 18 the the DT 19613 4614 19 existence existence NN 19613 4614 20 of of IN 19613 4614 21 one one CD 19613 4614 22 God God NNP 19613 4614 23 , , , 19613 4614 24 if if IN 19613 4614 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4614 26 did do VBD 19613 4614 27 not not RB 19613 4614 28 also also RB 19613 4614 29 conceive conceive VB 19613 4614 30 the the DT 19613 4614 31 gods god NNS 19613 4614 32 in in IN 19613 4614 33 question question NN 19613 4614 34 to to TO 19613 4614 35 be be VB 19613 4614 36 partly partly RB 19613 4614 37 demons demon NNS 19613 4614 38 , , , 19613 4614 39 partly partly RB 19613 4614 40 matter matter RB 19613 4614 41 , , , 19613 4614 42 partly partly RB 19613 4614 43 of of IN 19613 4614 44 human human JJ 19613 4614 45 birth birth NN 19613 4614 46 , , , 19613 4614 47 then then RB 19613 4614 48 certainly certainly RB 19613 4614 49 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4614 50 would would MD 19613 4614 51 be be VB 19613 4614 52 justly justly RB 19613 4614 53 expelled expel VBN 19613 4614 54 as as IN 19613 4614 55 aliens alien NNS 19613 4614 56 . . . 19613 4615 1 " " `` 19613 4615 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4615 3 375 375 CD 19613 4615 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4615 5 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4615 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 4615 7 takes take VBZ 19613 4615 8 up up RP 19613 4615 9 the the DT 19613 4615 10 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 4615 11 that that IN 19613 4615 12 the the DT 19613 4615 13 state state NN 19613 4615 14 is be VBZ 19613 4615 15 justified justify VBN 19613 4615 16 in in IN 19613 4615 17 refusing refuse VBG 19613 4615 18 to to TO 19613 4615 19 tolerate tolerate VB 19613 4615 20 people people NNS 19613 4615 21 with with IN 19613 4615 22 completely completely RB 19613 4615 23 new new JJ 19613 4615 24 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4615 25 . . . 19613 4616 1 When when WRB 19613 4616 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4616 3 add add VBP 19613 4616 4 that that IN 19613 4616 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4616 6 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 4616 7 assumes assume VBZ 19613 4616 8 that that IN 19613 4616 9 the the DT 19613 4616 10 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4616 11 and and CC 19613 4616 12 piety piety NN 19613 4616 13 of of IN 19613 4616 14 the the DT 19613 4616 15 emperors emperor NNS 19613 4616 16 are be VBP 19613 4616 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 4616 18 to to TO 19613 4616 19 test test VB 19613 4616 20 and and CC 19613 4616 21 approve[376 approve[376 LS 19613 4616 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4616 23 the the DT 19613 4616 24 truth truth NN 19613 4616 25 of of IN 19613 4616 26 the the DT 19613 4616 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 4616 28 teaching teaching NN 19613 4616 29 , , , 19613 4616 30 that that IN 19613 4616 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4616 32 merely merely RB 19613 4616 33 represents represent VBZ 19613 4616 34 this this DT 19613 4616 35 faith faith NN 19613 4616 36 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4616 37 as as IN 19613 4616 38 the the DT 19613 4616 39 _ _ NNP 19613 4616 40 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4616 41 _ _ NNP 19613 4616 42 doctrine,[377 doctrine,[377 NNP 19613 4616 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4616 44 and and CC 19613 4616 45 that that IN 19613 4616 46 , , , 19613 4616 47 with with IN 19613 4616 48 the the DT 19613 4616 49 exception exception NN 19613 4616 50 of of IN 19613 4616 51 the the DT 19613 4616 52 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 4616 53 of of IN 19613 4616 54 the the DT 19613 4616 55 body body NN 19613 4616 56 , , , 19613 4616 57 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4616 58 leaves leave VBZ 19613 4616 59 all all PDT 19613 4616 60 the the DT 19613 4616 61 positive positive JJ 19613 4616 62 and and CC 19613 4616 63 objectionable objectionable JJ 19613 4616 64 tenets tenet NNS 19613 4616 65 of of IN 19613 4616 66 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4616 67 out out IN 19613 4616 68 of of IN 19613 4616 69 account,[378 account,[378 NNP 19613 4616 70 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4616 71 there there EX 19613 4616 72 is be VBZ 19613 4616 73 ground ground NN 19613 4616 74 for for IN 19613 4616 75 thinking think VBG 19613 4616 76 that that IN 19613 4616 77 this this DT 19613 4616 78 Apologist apologist NN 19613 4616 79 differs differ VBZ 19613 4616 80 essentially essentially RB 19613 4616 81 from from IN 19613 4616 82 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4616 83 in in IN 19613 4616 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4616 85 conception conception NN 19613 4616 86 of of IN 19613 4616 87 the the DT 19613 4616 88 relation relation NN 19613 4616 89 of of IN 19613 4616 90 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4616 91 to to IN 19613 4616 92 secular secular JJ 19613 4616 93 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4616 94 . . . 19613 4617 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4617 2 , , , 19613 4617 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4617 4 is be VBZ 19613 4617 5 not not RB 19613 4617 6 to to TO 19613 4617 7 be be VB 19613 4617 8 denied deny VBN 19613 4617 9 that that IN 19613 4617 10 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 4617 11 views view VBZ 19613 4617 12 the the DT 19613 4617 13 revelation revelation NN 19613 4617 14 in in IN 19613 4617 15 the the DT 19613 4617 16 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4617 17 and and CC 19613 4617 18 in in IN 19613 4617 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4617 20 as as IN 19613 4617 21 completely completely RB 19613 4617 22 identical identical JJ 19613 4617 23 . . . 19613 4618 1 But but CC 19613 4618 2 in in IN 19613 4618 3 one one CD 19613 4618 4 very very RB 19613 4618 5 essential essential JJ 19613 4618 6 point point NN 19613 4618 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4618 8 agrees agree VBZ 19613 4618 9 with with IN 19613 4618 10 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4618 11 ; ; : 19613 4618 12 and and CC 19613 4618 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4618 14 has have VBZ 19613 4618 15 even even RB 19613 4618 16 expressed express VBN 19613 4618 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4618 18 still still RB 19613 4618 19 more more RBR 19613 4618 20 plainly plainly RB 19613 4618 21 than than IN 19613 4618 22 the the DT 19613 4618 23 latter latter JJ 19613 4618 24 , , , 19613 4618 25 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 4618 26 as as IN 19613 4618 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4618 28 does do VBZ 19613 4618 29 not not RB 19613 4618 30 introduce introduce VB 19613 4618 31 the the DT 19613 4618 32 assumption assumption NN 19613 4618 33 of of IN 19613 4618 34 a a DT 19613 4618 35 " " `` 19613 4618 36 seed seed NN 19613 4618 37 of of IN 19613 4618 38 the the DT 19613 4618 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4618 40 implanted implant VBN 19613 4618 41 by by IN 19613 4618 42 nature nature NN 19613 4618 43 " " '' 19613 4618 44 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4618 45 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4618 46 : : : 19613 4618 47 sperma sperma NNP 19613 4618 48 logou logou NNP 19613 4618 49 emphuton emphuton NNP 19613 4618 50 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4618 51 . . . 19613 4619 1 The the DT 19613 4619 2 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4619 3 , , , 19613 4619 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4619 5 says say VBZ 19613 4619 6 , , , 19613 4619 7 were be VBD 19613 4619 8 incapable incapable JJ 19613 4619 9 of of IN 19613 4619 10 knowing know VBG 19613 4619 11 the the DT 19613 4619 12 full full JJ 19613 4619 13 truth truth NN 19613 4619 14 , , , 19613 4619 15 since since IN 19613 4619 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4619 17 was be VBD 19613 4619 18 not not RB 19613 4619 19 from from IN 19613 4619 20 God God NNP 19613 4619 21 , , , 19613 4619 22 but but CC 19613 4619 23 rather rather RB 19613 4619 24 from from IN 19613 4619 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4619 26 , , , 19613 4619 27 that that IN 19613 4619 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4619 29 wished wish VBD 19613 4619 30 to to TO 19613 4619 31 learn learn VB 19613 4619 32 about about IN 19613 4619 33 God God NNP 19613 4619 34 . . . 19613 4620 1 True true JJ 19613 4620 2 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4620 3 , , , 19613 4620 4 however however RB 19613 4620 5 , , , 19613 4620 6 can can MD 19613 4620 7 only only RB 19613 4620 8 be be VB 19613 4620 9 learned learn VBN 19613 4620 10 from from IN 19613 4620 11 God God NNP 19613 4620 12 , , , 19613 4620 13 that that RB 19613 4620 14 is is RB 19613 4620 15 , , , 19613 4620 16 from from IN 19613 4620 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4620 18 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4620 19 ; ; : 19613 4620 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4620 21 depends depend VBZ 19613 4620 22 solely solely RB 19613 4620 23 on on IN 19613 4620 24 revelation revelation NN 19613 4620 25 . . . 19613 4621 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4621 2 379 379 CD 19613 4621 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4621 4 Here here RB 19613 4621 5 also also RB 19613 4621 6 then then RB 19613 4621 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4621 8 have have VBP 19613 4621 9 a a DT 19613 4621 10 repetition repetition NN 19613 4621 11 of of IN 19613 4621 12 the the DT 19613 4621 13 thought thought NN 19613 4621 14 that that WDT 19613 4621 15 the the DT 19613 4621 16 truly truly RB 19613 4621 17 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4621 18 is be VBZ 19613 4621 19 of of IN 19613 4621 20 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 4621 21 origin origin NN 19613 4621 22 . . . 19613 4622 1 Such such JJ 19613 4622 2 is be VBZ 19613 4622 3 the the DT 19613 4622 4 importance importance NN 19613 4622 5 attached attach VBN 19613 4622 6 by by IN 19613 4622 7 Athenagoras athenagora NNS 19613 4622 8 to to IN 19613 4622 9 this this DT 19613 4622 10 proposition proposition NN 19613 4622 11 , , , 19613 4622 12 that that IN 19613 4622 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4622 14 declares declare VBZ 19613 4622 15 any any DT 19613 4622 16 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 4622 17 of of IN 19613 4622 18 the the DT 19613 4622 19 " " `` 19613 4622 20 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4622 21 " " '' 19613 4622 22 to to TO 19613 4622 23 be be VB 19613 4622 24 insufficient insufficient JJ 19613 4622 25 , , , 19613 4622 26 no no RB 19613 4622 27 matter matter RB 19613 4622 28 how how WRB 19613 4622 29 luminous luminous JJ 19613 4622 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4622 31 may may MD 19613 4622 32 appear appear VB 19613 4622 33 . . . 19613 4623 1 Even even RB 19613 4623 2 that that DT 19613 4623 3 which which WDT 19613 4623 4 is be VBZ 19613 4623 5 most most RBS 19613 4623 6 evidently evidently RB 19613 4623 7 true true JJ 19613 4623 8 -- -- : 19613 4623 9 e.g e.g NNP 19613 4623 10 . . NNP 19613 4623 11 , , , 19613 4623 12 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 4623 13 -- -- : 19613 4623 14 is be VBZ 19613 4623 15 not not RB 19613 4623 16 raised raise VBN 19613 4623 17 from from IN 19613 4623 18 the the DT 19613 4623 19 domain domain NN 19613 4623 20 of of IN 19613 4623 21 mere mere JJ 19613 4623 22 human human JJ 19613 4623 23 opinion opinion NN 19613 4623 24 into into IN 19613 4623 25 the the DT 19613 4623 26 sphere sphere NN 19613 4623 27 of of IN 19613 4623 28 undoubted undoubted JJ 19613 4623 29 certainty certainty NN 19613 4623 30 till till IN 19613 4623 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4623 32 can can MD 19613 4623 33 be be VB 19613 4623 34 confirmed confirm VBN 19613 4623 35 by by IN 19613 4623 36 revelation revelation NN 19613 4623 37 . . . 19613 4624 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4624 2 380 380 CD 19613 4624 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4624 4 This this DT 19613 4624 5 can can MD 19613 4624 6 be be VB 19613 4624 7 done do VBN 19613 4624 8 by by IN 19613 4624 9 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4624 10 alone alone RB 19613 4624 11 . . . 19613 4625 1 Hence hence RB 19613 4625 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4625 3 are be VBP 19613 4625 4 very very RB 19613 4625 5 different different JJ 19613 4625 6 from from IN 19613 4625 7 the the DT 19613 4625 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4625 9 , , , 19613 4625 10 just just RB 19613 4625 11 as as IN 19613 4625 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4625 13 are be VBP 19613 4625 14 also also RB 19613 4625 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 4625 16 from from IN 19613 4625 17 these these DT 19613 4625 18 by by IN 19613 4625 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4625 20 manner manner NN 19613 4625 21 of of IN 19613 4625 22 life life NN 19613 4625 23 . . . 19613 4626 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4626 2 381 381 CD 19613 4626 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4626 4 All all PDT 19613 4626 5 the the DT 19613 4626 6 praises praise NNS 19613 4626 7 which which WDT 19613 4626 8 Athenagoras athenagora VBZ 19613 4626 9 from from IN 19613 4626 10 time time NN 19613 4626 11 to to IN 19613 4626 12 time time NN 19613 4626 13 bestows bestow NNS 19613 4626 14 on on IN 19613 4626 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4626 16 , , , 19613 4626 17 particularly particularly RB 19613 4626 18 Plato,[382 plato,[382 NN 19613 4626 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4626 20 are be VBP 19613 4626 21 consequently consequently RB 19613 4626 22 to to TO 19613 4626 23 be be VB 19613 4626 24 understood understand VBN 19613 4626 25 in in IN 19613 4626 26 a a DT 19613 4626 27 merely merely RB 19613 4626 28 relative relative JJ 19613 4626 29 sense sense NN 19613 4626 30 . . . 19613 4627 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4627 2 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 4627 3 object object NN 19613 4627 4 is be VBZ 19613 4627 5 only only RB 19613 4627 6 to to TO 19613 4627 7 establish establish VB 19613 4627 8 the the DT 19613 4627 9 claim claim NN 19613 4627 10 made make VBN 19613 4627 11 by by IN 19613 4627 12 the the DT 19613 4627 13 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 4627 14 with with IN 19613 4627 15 regard regard NN 19613 4627 16 to to IN 19613 4627 17 the the DT 19613 4627 18 treatment treatment NN 19613 4627 19 of of IN 19613 4627 20 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4627 21 by by IN 19613 4627 22 the the DT 19613 4627 23 state state NN 19613 4627 24 ; ; : 19613 4627 25 but but CC 19613 4627 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4627 27 are be VBP 19613 4627 28 not not RB 19613 4627 29 really really RB 19613 4627 30 meant mean VBN 19613 4627 31 to to TO 19613 4627 32 bring bring VB 19613 4627 33 the the DT 19613 4627 34 former former JJ 19613 4627 35 into into IN 19613 4627 36 closer close JJR 19613 4627 37 relationship relationship NN 19613 4627 38 to to IN 19613 4627 39 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4627 40 . . . 19613 4628 1 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 4628 2 also also RB 19613 4628 3 holds hold VBZ 19613 4628 4 the the DT 19613 4628 5 theory theory NN 19613 4628 6 that that IN 19613 4628 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4628 8 are be VBP 19613 4628 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4628 10 , , , 19613 4628 11 in in IN 19613 4628 12 so so RB 19613 4628 13 far far RB 19613 4628 14 as as IN 19613 4628 15 the the DT 19613 4628 16 " " `` 19613 4628 17 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4628 18 " " '' 19613 4628 19 are be VBP 19613 4628 20 not not RB 19613 4628 21 such such JJ 19613 4628 22 in in IN 19613 4628 23 any any DT 19613 4628 24 true true JJ 19613 4628 25 sense sense NN 19613 4628 26 . . . 19613 4629 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4629 2 is be VBZ 19613 4629 3 only only RB 19613 4629 4 the the DT 19613 4629 5 problems problem NNS 19613 4629 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4629 7 set set VBP 19613 4629 8 that that WDT 19613 4629 9 connect connect VBP 19613 4629 10 the the DT 19613 4629 11 two two CD 19613 4629 12 . . . 19613 4630 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4630 2 exhibits exhibit VBZ 19613 4630 3 less less RBR 19613 4630 4 clearness clearness JJ 19613 4630 5 than than IN 19613 4630 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4630 7 in in IN 19613 4630 8 tracing trace VBG 19613 4630 9 the the DT 19613 4630 10 necessity necessity NN 19613 4630 11 of of IN 19613 4630 12 revelation revelation NN 19613 4630 13 to to IN 19613 4630 14 the the DT 19613 4630 15 fact fact NN 19613 4630 16 that that IN 19613 4630 17 the the DT 19613 4630 18 demon demon NN 19613 4630 19 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4630 20 , , , 19613 4630 21 which which WDT 19613 4630 22 , , , 19613 4630 23 above above IN 19613 4630 24 all all DT 19613 4630 25 , , , 19613 4630 26 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 4630 27 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4630 28 in in IN 19613 4630 29 polytheism,[383 polytheism,[383 NN 19613 4630 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4630 31 can can MD 19613 4630 32 only only RB 19613 4630 33 be be VB 19613 4630 34 overthrown overthrow VBN 19613 4630 35 by by IN 19613 4630 36 revelation revelation NN 19613 4630 37 ; ; : 19613 4630 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4630 39 rather rather RB 19613 4630 40 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 4630 41 the the DT 19613 4630 42 other other JJ 19613 4630 43 thought thought NN 19613 4630 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4630 45 cc cc NNP 19613 4630 46 . . . 19613 4631 1 7 7 CD 19613 4631 2 , , , 19613 4631 3 9 9 CD 19613 4631 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4631 5 that that IN 19613 4631 6 the the DT 19613 4631 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4631 8 attestation attestation NN 19613 4631 9 of of IN 19613 4631 10 the the DT 19613 4631 11 truth truth NN 19613 4631 12 can can MD 19613 4631 13 only only RB 19613 4631 14 be be VB 19613 4631 15 given give VBN 19613 4631 16 in in IN 19613 4631 17 this this DT 19613 4631 18 way way NN 19613 4631 19 . . . 19613 4632 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4632 2 384 384 CD 19613 4632 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4632 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4632 5 Tatian's_[385 Tatian's_[385 NNP 19613 4632 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4632 7 chief chief JJ 19613 4632 8 aim aim NN 19613 4632 9 was be VBD 19613 4632 10 not not RB 19613 4632 11 to to TO 19613 4632 12 bring bring VB 19613 4632 13 about about RP 19613 4632 14 a a DT 19613 4632 15 juster juster NN 19613 4632 16 treatment treatment NN 19613 4632 17 of of IN 19613 4632 18 the the DT 19613 4632 19 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4632 20 . . . 19613 4633 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4633 2 386 386 CD 19613 4633 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4633 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4633 5 wished wish VBD 19613 4633 6 to to TO 19613 4633 7 represent represent VB 19613 4633 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4633 9 cause cause NN 19613 4633 10 as as IN 19613 4633 11 the the DT 19613 4633 12 good good JJ 19613 4633 13 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 4633 14 with with IN 19613 4633 15 the the DT 19613 4633 16 bad bad JJ 19613 4633 17 , , , 19613 4633 18 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4633 19 as as IN 19613 4633 20 opposed oppose VBN 19613 4633 21 to to TO 19613 4633 22 error error NN 19613 4633 23 , , , 19613 4633 24 truth truth NN 19613 4633 25 in in IN 19613 4633 26 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 4633 27 to to IN 19613 4633 28 outward outward JJ 19613 4633 29 seeming seeming NNP 19613 4633 30 , , , 19613 4633 31 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 19613 4633 32 , , , 19613 4633 33 and and CC 19613 4633 34 pretentious pretentious JJ 19613 4633 35 emptiness emptiness NN 19613 4633 36 . . . 19613 4634 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4634 2 " " `` 19613 4634 3 Address address NN 19613 4634 4 to to IN 19613 4634 5 the the DT 19613 4634 6 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4634 7 " " '' 19613 4634 8 begins begin VBZ 19613 4634 9 with with IN 19613 4634 10 a a DT 19613 4634 11 violent violent JJ 19613 4634 12 polemic polemic NN 19613 4634 13 against against IN 19613 4634 14 all all DT 19613 4634 15 Greek greek JJ 19613 4634 16 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4634 17 . . . 19613 4635 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4635 2 merely merely RB 19613 4635 3 acted act VBD 19613 4635 4 up up RP 19613 4635 5 to to IN 19613 4635 6 a a DT 19613 4635 7 judgment judgment NN 19613 4635 8 of of IN 19613 4635 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4635 10 and and CC 19613 4635 11 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4635 12 which which WDT 19613 4635 13 in in IN 19613 4635 14 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4635 15 's 's POS 19613 4635 16 case case NN 19613 4635 17 is be VBZ 19613 4635 18 still still RB 19613 4635 19 concealed conceal VBN 19613 4635 20 . . . 19613 4636 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4636 2 387 387 CD 19613 4636 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4636 4 Hence hence RB 19613 4636 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4636 6 was be VBD 19613 4636 7 not not RB 19613 4636 8 possible possible JJ 19613 4636 9 for for IN 19613 4636 10 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4636 11 to to TO 19613 4636 12 think think VB 19613 4636 13 of of IN 19613 4636 14 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 19613 4636 15 analogies analogy NNS 19613 4636 16 between between IN 19613 4636 17 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4636 18 and and CC 19613 4636 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4636 20 . . . 19613 4637 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4637 2 also also RB 19613 4637 3 no no RB 19613 4637 4 doubt doubt RB 19613 4637 5 views view VBZ 19613 4637 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4637 7 as as IN 19613 4637 8 " " `` 19613 4637 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 4637 10 ; ; : 19613 4637 11 " " '' 19613 4637 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4637 13 who who WP 19613 4637 14 lives live VBZ 19613 4637 15 virtuously virtuously RB 19613 4637 16 and and CC 19613 4637 17 follows follow VBZ 19613 4637 18 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4637 19 receives receive VBZ 19613 4637 20 it;[388 it;[388 NN 19613 4637 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4637 22 but but CC 19613 4637 23 yet yet RB 19613 4637 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4637 25 is be VBZ 19613 4637 26 too too RB 19613 4637 27 sublime sublime JJ 19613 4637 28 to to TO 19613 4637 29 be be VB 19613 4637 30 grasped grasp VBN 19613 4637 31 by by IN 19613 4637 32 earthly earthly JJ 19613 4637 33 perception perception NN 19613 4637 34 . . . 19613 4638 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4638 2 389 389 CD 19613 4638 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4638 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4638 5 is be VBZ 19613 4638 6 a a DT 19613 4638 7 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 4638 8 thing thing NN 19613 4638 9 which which WDT 19613 4638 10 depends depend VBZ 19613 4638 11 on on IN 19613 4638 12 the the DT 19613 4638 13 communication communication NN 19613 4638 14 of of IN 19613 4638 15 the the DT 19613 4638 16 " " `` 19613 4638 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4638 18 , , , 19613 4638 19 " " '' 19613 4638 20 and and CC 19613 4638 21 hence hence RB 19613 4638 22 can can MD 19613 4638 23 only only RB 19613 4638 24 be be VB 19613 4638 25 known know VBN 19613 4638 26 by by IN 19613 4638 27 revelation revelation NN 19613 4638 28 . . . 19613 4639 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4639 2 390 390 CD 19613 4639 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4639 4 But but CC 19613 4639 5 yet yet RB 19613 4639 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4639 7 is be VBZ 19613 4639 8 a a DT 19613 4639 9 " " `` 19613 4639 10 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4639 11 " " '' 19613 4639 12 with with IN 19613 4639 13 definite definite JJ 19613 4639 14 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4639 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4639 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4639 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4639 18 : : : 19613 4639 19 dogmata]);[391 dogmata]);[391 NNP 19613 4639 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4639 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4639 22 brings bring VBZ 19613 4639 23 nothing nothing NN 19613 4639 24 new new JJ 19613 4639 25 , , , 19613 4639 26 but but CC 19613 4639 27 only only RB 19613 4639 28 such such JJ 19613 4639 29 blessings blessing NNS 19613 4639 30 as as IN 19613 4639 31 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4639 32 have have VBP 19613 4639 33 already already RB 19613 4639 34 received receive VBN 19613 4639 35 , , , 19613 4639 36 but but CC 19613 4639 37 could could MD 19613 4639 38 not not RB 19613 4639 39 retain[392 retain[392 . 19613 4639 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4639 41 owing owe VBG 19613 4639 42 to to IN 19613 4639 43 the the DT 19613 4639 44 power power NN 19613 4639 45 of of IN 19613 4639 46 error error NN 19613 4639 47 , , , 19613 4639 48 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4639 49 , , , 19613 4639 50 the the DT 19613 4639 51 dominion dominion NN 19613 4639 52 of of IN 19613 4639 53 the the DT 19613 4639 54 demons demon NNS 19613 4639 55 . . . 19613 4640 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4640 2 393 393 CD 19613 4640 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4640 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4640 5 is be VBZ 19613 4640 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 4640 7 the the DT 19613 4640 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4640 9 in in IN 19613 4640 10 which which WDT 19613 4640 11 , , , 19613 4640 12 by by IN 19613 4640 13 virtue virtue NN 19613 4640 14 of of IN 19613 4640 15 the the DT 19613 4640 16 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4640 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 4640 18 through through IN 19613 4640 19 the the DT 19613 4640 20 prophets,[394 prophets,[394 NN 19613 4640 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4640 22 the the DT 19613 4640 23 rational rational JJ 19613 4640 24 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4640 25 that that WDT 19613 4640 26 leads lead VBZ 19613 4640 27 to to IN 19613 4640 28 life[395 life[395 NNP 19613 4640 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4640 30 is be VBZ 19613 4640 31 restored restore VBN 19613 4640 32 . . . 19613 4641 1 This this DT 19613 4641 2 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4641 3 was be VBD 19613 4641 4 no no RB 19613 4641 5 less less RBR 19613 4641 6 obscured obscure VBN 19613 4641 7 among among IN 19613 4641 8 the the DT 19613 4641 9 Greek greek JJ 19613 4641 10 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4641 11 than than IN 19613 4641 12 among among IN 19613 4641 13 the the DT 19613 4641 14 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4641 15 generally generally RB 19613 4641 16 . . . 19613 4642 1 In in IN 19613 4642 2 so so RB 19613 4642 3 far far RB 19613 4642 4 as as IN 19613 4642 5 revelation revelation NN 19613 4642 6 took take VBD 19613 4642 7 place place NN 19613 4642 8 among among IN 19613 4642 9 the the DT 19613 4642 10 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4642 11 from from IN 19613 4642 12 the the DT 19613 4642 13 remotest remotest NN 19613 4642 14 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 4642 15 , , , 19613 4642 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4642 17 may may MD 19613 4642 18 also also RB 19613 4642 19 be be VB 19613 4642 20 called call VBN 19613 4642 21 the the DT 19613 4642 22 barbarian barbarian JJ 19613 4642 23 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4642 24 . . . 19613 4643 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4643 2 396 396 CD 19613 4643 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4643 4 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4643 5 truth truth NN 19613 4643 6 is be VBZ 19613 4643 7 proved prove VBN 19613 4643 8 by by IN 19613 4643 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4643 10 ancient ancient JJ 19613 4643 11 date[397 date[397 NN 19613 4643 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4643 13 as as RB 19613 4643 14 well well RB 19613 4643 15 as as IN 19613 4643 16 by by IN 19613 4643 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4643 18 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 4643 19 form form NN 19613 4643 20 , , , 19613 4643 21 which which WDT 19613 4643 22 enables enable VBZ 19613 4643 23 even even RB 19613 4643 24 the the DT 19613 4643 25 most most RBS 19613 4643 26 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 4643 27 person person NN 19613 4643 28 that that WDT 19613 4643 29 is be VBZ 19613 4643 30 initiated initiate VBN 19613 4643 31 in in IN 19613 4643 32 it[398 it[398 NNP 19613 4643 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4643 34 to to TO 19613 4643 35 understand understand VB 19613 4643 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4643 37 perfectly perfectly RB 19613 4643 38 . . . 19613 4644 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4644 2 399 399 CD 19613 4644 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4644 4 Finally finally RB 19613 4644 5 , , , 19613 4644 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4644 7 also also RB 19613 4644 8 states state VBZ 19613 4644 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4644 10 c. c. NNP 19613 4644 11 40 40 CD 19613 4644 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4644 13 that that IN 19613 4644 14 the the DT 19613 4644 15 Greek greek JJ 19613 4644 16 sophists sophist NNS 19613 4644 17 have have VBP 19613 4644 18 read read VBN 19613 4644 19 the the DT 19613 4644 20 writings writing NNS 19613 4644 21 of of IN 19613 4644 22 Moses Moses NNP 19613 4644 23 and and CC 19613 4644 24 the the DT 19613 4644 25 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4644 26 , , , 19613 4644 27 and and CC 19613 4644 28 reproduced reproduce VBD 19613 4644 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4644 30 in in IN 19613 4644 31 a a DT 19613 4644 32 distorted distort VBN 19613 4644 33 form form NN 19613 4644 34 . . . 19613 4645 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4645 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 4645 3 maintains maintain VBZ 19613 4645 4 the the DT 19613 4645 5 very very JJ 19613 4645 6 opposite opposite NN 19613 4645 7 of of IN 19613 4645 8 what what WP 19613 4645 9 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 4645 10 took take VBD 19613 4645 11 upon upon IN 19613 4645 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4645 13 to to TO 19613 4645 14 demonstrate demonstrate VB 19613 4645 15 when when WRB 19613 4645 16 venturing venture VBG 19613 4645 17 to to TO 19613 4645 18 derive derive VB 19613 4645 19 certain certain JJ 19613 4645 20 sayings saying NNS 19613 4645 21 and and CC 19613 4645 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4645 23 of of IN 19613 4645 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4645 25 and and CC 19613 4645 26 the the DT 19613 4645 27 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4645 28 from from IN 19613 4645 29 the the DT 19613 4645 30 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4645 31 . . . 19613 4646 1 Both both DT 19613 4646 2 credit credit NN 19613 4646 3 the the DT 19613 4646 4 plagiarists plagiarist NNS 19613 4646 5 with with IN 19613 4646 6 intentional intentional JJ 19613 4646 7 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 19613 4646 8 or or CC 19613 4646 9 gross gross JJ 19613 4646 10 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 19613 4646 11 . . . 19613 4647 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4647 2 judged judge VBD 19613 4647 3 more more RBR 19613 4647 4 charitably charitably RB 19613 4647 5 . . . 19613 4648 1 To to IN 19613 4648 2 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4648 3 , , , 19613 4648 4 on on IN 19613 4648 5 the the DT 19613 4648 6 contrary contrary NN 19613 4648 7 , , , 19613 4648 8 the the DT 19613 4648 9 mythology mythology NN 19613 4648 10 of of IN 19613 4648 11 the the DT 19613 4648 12 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4648 13 did do VBD 19613 4648 14 not not RB 19613 4648 15 appear appear VB 19613 4648 16 worse bad JJR 19613 4648 17 than than IN 19613 4648 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4648 19 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4648 20 ; ; : 19613 4648 21 in in IN 19613 4648 22 both both DT 19613 4648 23 cases case NNS 19613 4648 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4648 25 saw see VBD 19613 4648 26 imitations imitation NNS 19613 4648 27 and and CC 19613 4648 28 intentional intentional JJ 19613 4648 29 corruption corruption NN 19613 4648 30 of of IN 19613 4648 31 the the DT 19613 4648 32 truth truth NN 19613 4648 33 . . . 19613 4649 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4649 2 400 400 CD 19613 4649 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4649 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4649 5 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 4649 6 _ _ NNP 19613 4649 7 agrees agree VBZ 19613 4649 8 with with IN 19613 4649 9 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4649 10 , , , 19613 4649 11 in in IN 19613 4649 12 so so RB 19613 4649 13 far far RB 19613 4649 14 as as IN 19613 4649 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4649 16 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 4649 17 appears appear VBZ 19613 4649 18 to to TO 19613 4649 19 contrast contrast VB 19613 4649 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4649 21 with with IN 19613 4649 22 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4649 23 . . . 19613 4650 1 The the DT 19613 4650 2 religious religious JJ 19613 4650 3 and and CC 19613 4650 4 moral moral JJ 19613 4650 5 culture culture NN 19613 4650 6 of of IN 19613 4650 7 the the DT 19613 4650 8 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4650 9 is be VBZ 19613 4650 10 derived derive VBN 19613 4650 11 from from IN 19613 4650 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4650 13 poets poet NNS 19613 4650 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4650 15 historians historian NNS 19613 4650 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4650 17 and and CC 19613 4650 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4650 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4650 20 ad ad NN 19613 4650 21 Autol Autol NNP 19613 4650 22 . . . 19613 4651 1 II ii CD 19613 4651 2 . . . 19613 4652 1 3 3 CD 19613 4652 2 fin fin NNP 19613 4652 3 . . . 19613 4653 1 and and CC 19613 4653 2 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 4653 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4653 4 . . . 19613 4654 1 However however RB 19613 4654 2 , , , 19613 4654 3 not not RB 19613 4654 4 only only RB 19613 4654 5 do do VBP 19613 4654 6 poets poet NNS 19613 4654 7 and and CC 19613 4654 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4654 9 contradict contradict VBP 19613 4654 10 each each DT 19613 4654 11 other other JJ 19613 4654 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4654 13 II ii CD 19613 4654 14 . . . 19613 4655 1 5 5 LS 19613 4655 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4655 3 ; ; : 19613 4655 4 but but CC 19613 4655 5 the the DT 19613 4655 6 latter latter NN 19613 4655 7 also also RB 19613 4655 8 do do VBP 19613 4655 9 not not RB 19613 4655 10 agree agree VB 19613 4655 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4655 12 II ii CD 19613 4655 13 . . . 19613 4656 1 4 4 LS 19613 4656 2 . . . 19613 4657 1 8 8 LS 19613 4657 2 : : : 19613 4657 3 III iii CD 19613 4657 4 . . . 19613 4658 1 7 7 LS 19613 4658 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4658 3 , , , 19613 4658 4 nay nay NN 19613 4658 5 , , , 19613 4658 6 many many JJ 19613 4658 7 contradict contradict VBP 19613 4658 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4658 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4658 10 III iii CD 19613 4658 11 . . . 19613 4659 1 3 3 LS 19613 4659 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4659 3 . . . 19613 4660 1 Not not RB 19613 4660 2 a a DT 19613 4660 3 single single JJ 19613 4660 4 one one CD 19613 4660 5 of of IN 19613 4660 6 the the DT 19613 4660 7 so so RB 19613 4660 8 - - HYPH 19613 4660 9 called call VBN 19613 4660 10 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4660 11 , , , 19613 4660 12 however however RB 19613 4660 13 , , , 19613 4660 14 is be VBZ 19613 4660 15 to to TO 19613 4660 16 be be VB 19613 4660 17 taken take VBN 19613 4660 18 seriously;[401 seriously;[401 LS 19613 4660 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4660 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4660 21 have have VBP 19613 4660 22 devised devise VBN 19613 4660 23 myths myth NNS 19613 4660 24 and and CC 19613 4660 25 follies folly NNS 19613 4660 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4660 27 II II NNP 19613 4660 28 . . . 19613 4661 1 8) 8) CD 19613 4661 2 ; ; : 19613 4661 3 everything everything NN 19613 4661 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4661 5 have have VBP 19613 4661 6 set set VBN 19613 4661 7 forth forth RB 19613 4661 8 is be VBZ 19613 4661 9 useless useless JJ 19613 4661 10 and and CC 19613 4661 11 godless godless NN 19613 4661 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4661 13 III iii CD 19613 4661 14 . . . 19613 4662 1 2 2 LS 19613 4662 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4662 3 ; ; : 19613 4662 4 vain vain JJ 19613 4662 5 and and CC 19613 4662 6 worthless worthless JJ 19613 4662 7 fame fame NN 19613 4662 8 was be VBD 19613 4662 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4662 10 aim aim NN 19613 4662 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4662 12 III iii CD 19613 4662 13 . . . 19613 4663 1 3 3 LS 19613 4663 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4663 3 . . . 19613 4664 1 But but CC 19613 4664 2 God God NNP 19613 4664 3 knew know VBD 19613 4664 4 beforehand beforehand RB 19613 4664 5 the the DT 19613 4664 6 " " `` 19613 4664 7 drivellings drivelling NNS 19613 4664 8 of of IN 19613 4664 9 these these DT 19613 4664 10 hollow hollow JJ 19613 4664 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4664 12 " " '' 19613 4664 13 and and CC 19613 4664 14 made make VBD 19613 4664 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4664 16 preparations preparation NNS 19613 4664 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4664 18 II ii CD 19613 4664 19 . . . 19613 4665 1 15 15 CD 19613 4665 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4665 3 . . . 19613 4666 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4666 2 of of IN 19613 4666 3 old old JJ 19613 4666 4 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 4666 5 the the DT 19613 4666 6 truth truth NN 19613 4666 7 by by IN 19613 4666 8 the the DT 19613 4666 9 mouth mouth NN 19613 4666 10 of of IN 19613 4666 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4666 12 , , , 19613 4666 13 and and CC 19613 4666 14 these these DT 19613 4666 15 deposited deposit VBD 19613 4666 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4666 17 in in IN 19613 4666 18 holy holy JJ 19613 4666 19 writings writing NNS 19613 4666 20 . . . 19613 4667 1 This this DT 19613 4667 2 truth truth NN 19613 4667 3 refers refer VBZ 19613 4667 4 to to IN 19613 4667 5 the the DT 19613 4667 6 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4667 7 of of IN 19613 4667 8 God God NNP 19613 4667 9 , , , 19613 4667 10 the the DT 19613 4667 11 origin origin NN 19613 4667 12 and and CC 19613 4667 13 history history NN 19613 4667 14 of of IN 19613 4667 15 the the DT 19613 4667 16 world world NN 19613 4667 17 , , , 19613 4667 18 as as RB 19613 4667 19 well well RB 19613 4667 20 as as IN 19613 4667 21 to to IN 19613 4667 22 a a DT 19613 4667 23 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4667 24 life life NN 19613 4667 25 . . . 19613 4668 1 The the DT 19613 4668 2 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4668 3 testimony testimony NN 19613 4668 4 in in IN 19613 4668 5 regard regard NN 19613 4668 6 to to IN 19613 4668 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4668 8 was be VBD 19613 4668 9 continued continue VBN 19613 4668 10 in in IN 19613 4668 11 the the DT 19613 4668 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 4668 13 . . . 19613 4669 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4669 2 402 402 CD 19613 4669 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4669 4 Revelation revelation NN 19613 4669 5 , , , 19613 4669 6 however however RB 19613 4669 7 , , , 19613 4669 8 is be VBZ 19613 4669 9 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4669 10 because because IN 19613 4669 11 this this DT 19613 4669 12 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4669 13 of of IN 19613 4669 14 the the DT 19613 4669 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4669 16 and and CC 19613 4669 17 poets poet NNS 19613 4669 18 is be VBZ 19613 4669 19 really really RB 19613 4669 20 demon demon NN 19613 4669 21 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4669 22 , , , 19613 4669 23 for for IN 19613 4669 24 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4669 25 were be VBD 19613 4669 26 inspired inspire VBN 19613 4669 27 by by IN 19613 4669 28 devils devil NNS 19613 4669 29 . . . 19613 4670 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4670 2 403 403 CD 19613 4670 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4670 4 Thus thus RB 19613 4670 5 the the DT 19613 4670 6 most most RBS 19613 4670 7 extreme extreme JJ 19613 4670 8 contrasts contrast NNS 19613 4670 9 appear appear VBP 19613 4670 10 to to TO 19613 4670 11 exist exist VB 19613 4670 12 here here RB 19613 4670 13 . . . 19613 4671 1 Still still RB 19613 4671 2 , , , 19613 4671 3 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 4671 4 is be VBZ 19613 4671 5 constrained constrain VBN 19613 4671 6 to to TO 19613 4671 7 confess confess VB 19613 4671 8 that that DT 19613 4671 9 truth truth NN 19613 4671 10 was be VBD 19613 4671 11 not not RB 19613 4671 12 only only RB 19613 4671 13 announced announce VBN 19613 4671 14 by by IN 19613 4671 15 the the DT 19613 4671 16 Sibyl Sibyl NNP 19613 4671 17 , , , 19613 4671 18 to to TO 19613 4671 19 whom whom WP 19613 4671 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4671 21 remarks remark NNS 19613 4671 22 do do VBP 19613 4671 23 not not RB 19613 4671 24 apply apply VB 19613 4671 25 , , , 19613 4671 26 for for IN 19613 4671 27 she -PRON- PRP 19613 4671 28 is be VBZ 19613 4671 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4671 30 II II NNP 19613 4671 31 . . . 19613 4672 1 36 36 CD 19613 4672 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4672 3 : : : 19613 4672 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4672 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4672 6 : : : 19613 4672 7 en en IN 19613 4672 8 Ellêsin Ellêsin NNP 19613 4672 9 kai kai NNP 19613 4672 10 en en NNP 19613 4672 11 tois tois FW 19613 4672 12 loipois loipois FW 19613 4672 13 ethnetin ethnetin NNP 19613 4672 14 genomenê genomenê NN 19613 4672 15 prophêtis prophêtis NN 19613 4672 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4672 17 , , , 19613 4672 18 but but CC 19613 4672 19 that that IN 19613 4672 20 poets poet NNS 19613 4672 21 and and CC 19613 4672 22 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4672 23 , , , 19613 4672 24 " " '' 19613 4672 25 though though IN 19613 4672 26 against against IN 19613 4672 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4672 28 will will NN 19613 4672 29 , , , 19613 4672 30 " " '' 19613 4672 31 also also RB 19613 4672 32 gave give VBD 19613 4672 33 clear clear JJ 19613 4672 34 utterances utterance NNS 19613 4672 35 regarding regard VBG 19613 4672 36 the the DT 19613 4672 37 justice justice NN 19613 4672 38 , , , 19613 4672 39 the the DT 19613 4672 40 judgment judgment NN 19613 4672 41 , , , 19613 4672 42 and and CC 19613 4672 43 the the DT 19613 4672 44 punishments punishment NNS 19613 4672 45 of of IN 19613 4672 46 God God NNP 19613 4672 47 , , , 19613 4672 48 as as RB 19613 4672 49 well well RB 19613 4672 50 as as IN 19613 4672 51 regarding regard VBG 19613 4672 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4672 53 providence providence NN 19613 4672 54 in in IN 19613 4672 55 respect respect NN 19613 4672 56 to to IN 19613 4672 57 the the DT 19613 4672 58 living living NN 19613 4672 59 and and CC 19613 4672 60 the the DT 19613 4672 61 dead dead JJ 19613 4672 62 , , , 19613 4672 63 or or CC 19613 4672 64 , , , 19613 4672 65 in in IN 19613 4672 66 other other JJ 19613 4672 67 words word NNS 19613 4672 68 , , , 19613 4672 69 about about IN 19613 4672 70 the the DT 19613 4672 71 most most RBS 19613 4672 72 important important JJ 19613 4672 73 points point NNS 19613 4672 74 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4672 75 II II NNP 19613 4672 76 . . . 19613 4673 1 37 37 CD 19613 4673 2 , , , 19613 4673 3 38 38 CD 19613 4673 4 , , , 19613 4673 5 8 8 CD 19613 4673 6 fin fin NN 19613 4673 7 . . . 19613 4673 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4673 9 . . . 19613 4674 1 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 4674 2 gives give VBZ 19613 4674 3 a a DT 19613 4674 4 double double JJ 19613 4674 5 explanation explanation NN 19613 4674 6 of of IN 19613 4674 7 this this DT 19613 4674 8 fact fact NN 19613 4674 9 . . . 19613 4675 1 On on IN 19613 4675 2 the the DT 19613 4675 3 one one CD 19613 4675 4 hand hand NN 19613 4675 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4675 6 ascribes ascribe VBZ 19613 4675 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4675 8 to to IN 19613 4675 9 the the DT 19613 4675 10 imitation imitation NN 19613 4675 11 of of IN 19613 4675 12 holy holy JJ 19613 4675 13 writings writing NNS 19613 4675 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4675 15 II II NNP 19613 4675 16 . . . 19613 4676 1 12 12 CD 19613 4676 2 , , , 19613 4676 3 37 37 CD 19613 4676 4 : : : 19613 4676 5 I. i. NN 19613 4677 1 14 14 CD 19613 4677 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4677 3 , , , 19613 4677 4 and and CC 19613 4677 5 on on IN 19613 4677 6 the the DT 19613 4677 7 other other JJ 19613 4677 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4677 9 admits admit VBZ 19613 4677 10 that that IN 19613 4677 11 those those DT 19613 4677 12 writers writer NNS 19613 4677 13 , , , 19613 4677 14 when when WRB 19613 4677 15 the the DT 19613 4677 16 demons demon NNS 19613 4677 17 abandoned abandon VBD 19613 4677 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4677 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4677 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4677 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4677 22 : : : 19613 4677 23 tê tê NNP 19613 4677 24 psychê psychê NNP 19613 4677 25 eknêpsantes eknêpsante VBZ 19613 4677 26 ex ex NNP 19613 4677 27 autôn autôn NNP 19613 4677 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4677 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4677 30 , , , 19613 4677 31 of of IN 19613 4677 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4677 33 displayed display VBD 19613 4677 34 a a DT 19613 4677 35 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4677 36 of of IN 19613 4677 37 the the DT 19613 4677 38 divine divine JJ 19613 4677 39 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4677 40 , , , 19613 4677 41 the the DT 19613 4677 42 judgment judgment NN 19613 4677 43 etc etc FW 19613 4677 44 . . . 19613 4677 45 , , , 19613 4677 46 which which WDT 19613 4677 47 agrees agree VBZ 19613 4677 48 with with IN 19613 4677 49 the the DT 19613 4677 50 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4677 51 of of IN 19613 4677 52 the the DT 19613 4677 53 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4677 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4677 55 II II NNP 19613 4677 56 . . . 19613 4678 1 8) 8) CD 19613 4678 2 . . . 19613 4679 1 This this DT 19613 4679 2 admission admission NN 19613 4679 3 need nee MD 19613 4679 4 not not RB 19613 4679 5 cause cause VB 19613 4679 6 astonishment astonishment NN 19613 4679 7 ; ; : 19613 4679 8 for for IN 19613 4679 9 the the DT 19613 4679 10 freedom freedom NN 19613 4679 11 and and CC 19613 4679 12 control control NN 19613 4679 13 of of IN 19613 4679 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4679 15 own own JJ 19613 4679 16 destiny destiny NN 19613 4679 17 with with IN 19613 4679 18 which which WDT 19613 4679 19 man man NN 19613 4679 20 is be VBZ 19613 4679 21 endowed endow VBN 19613 4679 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4679 23 II II NNP 19613 4679 24 . . . 19613 4680 1 27 27 CD 19613 4680 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4680 3 must must MD 19613 4680 4 infallibly infallibly RB 19613 4680 5 lead lead VB 19613 4680 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4680 7 to to TO 19613 4680 8 correct correct VB 19613 4680 9 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4680 10 and and CC 19613 4680 11 obedience obedience NN 19613 4680 12 to to IN 19613 4680 13 God God NNP 19613 4680 14 , , , 19613 4680 15 as as RB 19613 4680 16 soon soon RB 19613 4680 17 as as IN 19613 4680 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4680 19 is be VBZ 19613 4680 20 no no RB 19613 4680 21 longer longer RB 19613 4680 22 under under IN 19613 4680 23 the the DT 19613 4680 24 sway sway NN 19613 4680 25 of of IN 19613 4680 26 the the DT 19613 4680 27 demons demon NNS 19613 4680 28 . . . 19613 4681 1 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 4681 2 did do VBD 19613 4681 3 not not RB 19613 4681 4 apply apply VB 19613 4681 5 the the DT 19613 4681 6 title title NN 19613 4681 7 of of IN 19613 4681 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4681 9 to to IN 19613 4681 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 4681 11 truth truth NN 19613 4681 12 , , , 19613 4681 13 this this DT 19613 4681 14 title title NN 19613 4681 15 being be VBG 19613 4681 16 in in IN 19613 4681 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4681 18 view view NN 19613 4681 19 discredited discredit VBD 19613 4681 20 ; ; : 19613 4681 21 but but CC 19613 4681 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4681 23 is be VBZ 19613 4681 24 to to IN 19613 4681 25 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4681 26 the the DT 19613 4681 27 " " `` 19613 4681 28 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4681 29 of of IN 19613 4681 30 God God NNP 19613 4681 31 , , , 19613 4681 32 " " '' 19613 4681 33 which which WDT 19613 4681 34 by by IN 19613 4681 35 luminous luminous JJ 19613 4681 36 proofs proof NNS 19613 4681 37 convinces convince VBZ 19613 4681 38 the the DT 19613 4681 39 men man NNS 19613 4681 40 who who WP 19613 4681 41 reflect reflect VBP 19613 4681 42 on on IN 19613 4681 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4681 44 own own JJ 19613 4681 45 nature nature NN 19613 4681 46 . . . 19613 4682 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4682 2 404 404 CD 19613 4682 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4682 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4682 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4682 6 and and CC 19613 4682 7 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4682 8 Felix._[405 Felix._[405 NNPS 19613 4682 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4682 10 Whilst whilst UH 19613 4682 11 , , , 19613 4682 12 in in IN 19613 4682 13 the the DT 19613 4682 14 case case NN 19613 4682 15 of of IN 19613 4682 16 the the DT 19613 4682 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4682 18 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4682 19 , , , 19613 4682 20 the the DT 19613 4682 21 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 4682 22 of of IN 19613 4682 23 revelation revelation NN 19613 4682 24 appears appear VBZ 19613 4682 25 conditioned condition VBN 19613 4682 26 by by IN 19613 4682 27 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4682 28 scepticism scepticism NN 19613 4682 29 on on IN 19613 4682 30 the the DT 19613 4682 31 one one CD 19613 4682 32 hand hand NN 19613 4682 33 , , , 19613 4682 34 and and CC 19613 4682 35 by by IN 19613 4682 36 the the DT 19613 4682 37 strong strong JJ 19613 4682 38 impression impression NN 19613 4682 39 of of IN 19613 4682 40 the the DT 19613 4682 41 dominion dominion NN 19613 4682 42 of of IN 19613 4682 43 the the DT 19613 4682 44 demons demon NNS 19613 4682 45 on on IN 19613 4682 46 the the DT 19613 4682 47 other other JJ 19613 4682 48 , , , 19613 4682 49 the the DT 19613 4682 50 sceptical sceptical JJ 19613 4682 51 element element NN 19613 4682 52 is be VBZ 19613 4682 53 not not RB 19613 4682 54 only only RB 19613 4682 55 wanting want VBG 19613 4682 56 in in IN 19613 4682 57 the the DT 19613 4682 58 Latin Latin NNP 19613 4682 59 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4682 60 , , , 19613 4682 61 but but CC 19613 4682 62 the the DT 19613 4682 63 Christian christian JJ 19613 4682 64 truth truth NN 19613 4682 65 is be VBZ 19613 4682 66 even even RB 19613 4682 67 placed place VBN 19613 4682 68 in in IN 19613 4682 69 direct direct JJ 19613 4682 70 opposition opposition NN 19613 4682 71 to to IN 19613 4682 72 the the DT 19613 4682 73 sceptical sceptical JJ 19613 4682 74 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4682 75 and and CC 19613 4682 76 on on IN 19613 4682 77 the the DT 19613 4682 78 side side NN 19613 4682 79 of of IN 19613 4682 80 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4682 81 dogmatism dogmatism NN 19613 4682 82 , , , 19613 4682 83 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4682 84 , , , 19613 4682 85 Stoicism Stoicism NNP 19613 4682 86 . . . 19613 4683 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4683 2 406 406 CD 19613 4683 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4683 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4683 5 the the DT 19613 4683 6 observations observation NNS 19613 4683 7 of of IN 19613 4683 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4683 9 and and CC 19613 4683 10 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4683 11 Felix Felix NNP 19613 4683 12 with with IN 19613 4683 13 regard regard NN 19613 4683 14 to to IN 19613 4683 15 the the DT 19613 4683 16 essence essence NN 19613 4683 17 of of IN 19613 4683 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4683 19 , , , 19613 4683 20 viewed view VBD 19613 4683 21 as as IN 19613 4683 22 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4683 23 and and CC 19613 4683 24 as as IN 19613 4683 25 revelation revelation NN 19613 4683 26 , , , 19613 4683 27 are be VBP 19613 4683 28 at at IN 19613 4683 29 bottom bottom NN 19613 4683 30 completely completely RB 19613 4683 31 identical identical JJ 19613 4683 32 with with IN 19613 4683 33 the the DT 19613 4683 34 conception conception NN 19613 4683 35 of of IN 19613 4683 36 the the DT 19613 4683 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4683 38 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4683 39 , , , 19613 4683 40 although although IN 19613 4683 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4683 42 is be VBZ 19613 4683 43 undeniable undeniable JJ 19613 4683 44 that that IN 19613 4683 45 in in IN 19613 4683 46 the the DT 19613 4683 47 former former JJ 19613 4683 48 case case NN 19613 4683 49 the the DT 19613 4683 50 revealed revealed JJ 19613 4683 51 character character NN 19613 4683 52 of of IN 19613 4683 53 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4683 54 is be VBZ 19613 4683 55 placed place VBN 19613 4683 56 in in IN 19613 4683 57 the the DT 19613 4683 58 background background NN 19613 4683 59 . . . 19613 4684 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4684 2 407 407 CD 19613 4684 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4684 4 The the DT 19613 4684 5 recognition recognition NN 19613 4684 6 of of IN 19613 4684 7 this this DT 19613 4684 8 fact fact NN 19613 4684 9 is be VBZ 19613 4684 10 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 4684 11 instructive instructive JJ 19613 4684 12 , , , 19613 4684 13 for for IN 19613 4684 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4684 15 proves prove VBZ 19613 4684 16 that that IN 19613 4684 17 the the DT 19613 4684 18 conception conception NN 19613 4684 19 of of IN 19613 4684 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4684 21 set set VBN 19613 4684 22 forth forth RP 19613 4684 23 by by IN 19613 4684 24 the the DT 19613 4684 25 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4684 26 was be VBD 19613 4684 27 not not RB 19613 4684 28 an an DT 19613 4684 29 individual individual JJ 19613 4684 30 one one NN 19613 4684 31 , , , 19613 4684 32 but but CC 19613 4684 33 the the DT 19613 4684 34 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4684 35 expression expression NN 19613 4684 36 of of IN 19613 4684 37 the the DT 19613 4684 38 conviction conviction NN 19613 4684 39 that that IN 19613 4684 40 Christian christian JJ 19613 4684 41 truth truth NN 19613 4684 42 contains contain VBZ 19613 4684 43 the the DT 19613 4684 44 completion completion NN 19613 4684 45 and and CC 19613 4684 46 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 4684 47 of of IN 19613 4684 48 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4684 49 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4684 50 . . . 19613 4685 1 To to IN 19613 4685 2 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4685 3 Felix Felix NNP 19613 4685 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4685 5 and and CC 19613 4685 6 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 4685 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4685 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 4685 9 truth truth NN 19613 4685 10 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 4685 11 presents present VBZ 19613 4685 12 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4685 13 as as IN 19613 4685 14 the the DT 19613 4685 15 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4685 16 implanted implant VBN 19613 4685 17 by by IN 19613 4685 18 nature nature NN 19613 4685 19 in in IN 19613 4685 20 every every DT 19613 4685 21 man man NN 19613 4685 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4685 23 Oct. October NNP 19613 4685 24 16 16 CD 19613 4685 25 . . . 19613 4686 1 5 5 LS 19613 4686 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4686 3 . . . 19613 4687 1 In in IN 19613 4687 2 so so RB 19613 4687 3 far far RB 19613 4687 4 as as IN 19613 4687 5 man man NN 19613 4687 6 possesses possess VBZ 19613 4687 7 reason reason NN 19613 4687 8 and and CC 19613 4687 9 speech speech NN 19613 4687 10 and and CC 19613 4687 11 accomplishes accomplish VBZ 19613 4687 12 the the DT 19613 4687 13 task task NN 19613 4687 14 of of IN 19613 4687 15 the the DT 19613 4687 16 " " `` 19613 4687 17 examination examination NN 19613 4687 18 of of IN 19613 4687 19 the the DT 19613 4687 20 universe universe NN 19613 4687 21 " " '' 19613 4687 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4687 23 " " `` 19613 4687 24 inquisitio inquisitio VBG 19613 4687 25 universitatis universitatis NN 19613 4687 26 " " '' 19613 4687 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4687 28 , , , 19613 4687 29 conditioned condition VBN 19613 4687 30 by by IN 19613 4687 31 this this DT 19613 4687 32 gift gift NN 19613 4687 33 , , , 19613 4687 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4687 35 has have VBZ 19613 4687 36 the the DT 19613 4687 37 Christian christian JJ 19613 4687 38 truth truth NN 19613 4687 39 , , , 19613 4687 40 that that RB 19613 4687 41 is is RB 19613 4687 42 , , , 19613 4687 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4687 44 finds find VBZ 19613 4687 45 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4687 46 in in IN 19613 4687 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4687 48 own own JJ 19613 4687 49 constitution constitution NN 19613 4687 50 , , , 19613 4687 51 and and CC 19613 4687 52 in in IN 19613 4687 53 the the DT 19613 4687 54 rational rational JJ 19613 4687 55 order order NN 19613 4687 56 of of IN 19613 4687 57 the the DT 19613 4687 58 world world NN 19613 4687 59 . . . 19613 4688 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4688 2 , , , 19613 4688 3 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4688 4 is be VBZ 19613 4688 5 also also RB 19613 4688 6 able able JJ 19613 4688 7 to to TO 19613 4688 8 demonstrate demonstrate VB 19613 4688 9 the the DT 19613 4688 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 4688 11 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4688 12 by by IN 19613 4688 13 means mean NNS 19613 4688 14 of of IN 19613 4688 15 the the DT 19613 4688 16 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4688 17 principle principle NN 19613 4688 18 of of IN 19613 4688 19 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4688 20 , , , 19613 4688 21 and and CC 19613 4688 22 arrives arrive VBZ 19613 4688 23 at at IN 19613 4688 24 the the DT 19613 4688 25 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 4688 26 that that IN 19613 4688 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4688 28 is be VBZ 19613 4688 29 a a DT 19613 4688 30 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4688 31 , , , 19613 4688 32 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4688 33 , , , 19613 4688 34 the the DT 19613 4688 35 true true JJ 19613 4688 36 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4688 37 , , , 19613 4688 38 and and CC 19613 4688 39 that that IN 19613 4688 40 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4688 41 are be VBP 19613 4688 42 to to TO 19613 4688 43 be be VB 19613 4688 44 considered consider VBN 19613 4688 45 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4688 46 in in IN 19613 4688 47 proportion proportion NN 19613 4688 48 as as IN 19613 4688 49 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4688 50 have have VBP 19613 4688 51 discovered discover VBN 19613 4688 52 the the DT 19613 4688 53 truth truth NN 19613 4688 54 . . . 19613 4689 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4689 2 408 408 CD 19613 4689 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4689 4 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4689 5 , , , 19613 4689 6 as as IN 19613 4689 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4689 8 represented represent VBD 19613 4689 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 4689 10 ethics ethic NNS 19613 4689 11 to to TO 19613 4689 12 be be VB 19613 4689 13 the the DT 19613 4689 14 expression expression NN 19613 4689 15 of of IN 19613 4689 16 the the DT 19613 4689 17 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 4689 18 , , , 19613 4689 19 and and CC 19613 4689 20 depicted depict VBD 19613 4689 21 the the DT 19613 4689 22 Christian christian JJ 19613 4689 23 bond bond NN 19613 4689 24 of of IN 19613 4689 25 brotherhood brotherhood NN 19613 4689 26 as as IN 19613 4689 27 a a DT 19613 4689 28 cosmopolitan cosmopolitan JJ 19613 4689 29 union union NN 19613 4689 30 of of IN 19613 4689 31 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4689 32 , , , 19613 4689 33 who who WP 19613 4689 34 have have VBP 19613 4689 35 become become VBN 19613 4689 36 conscious conscious JJ 19613 4689 37 of of IN 19613 4689 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4689 39 natural natural JJ 19613 4689 40 similarity,[409 similarity,[409 NN 19613 4689 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4689 42 the the DT 19613 4689 43 revealed reveal VBN 19613 4689 44 character character NN 19613 4689 45 of of IN 19613 4689 46 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4689 47 appears appear VBZ 19613 4689 48 to to TO 19613 4689 49 be be VB 19613 4689 50 entirely entirely RB 19613 4689 51 given give VBN 19613 4689 52 up up RP 19613 4689 53 . . . 19613 4690 1 This this DT 19613 4690 2 religion religion NN 19613 4690 3 is be VBZ 19613 4690 4 natural natural JJ 19613 4690 5 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 4690 6 , , , 19613 4690 7 the the DT 19613 4690 8 revelation revelation NN 19613 4690 9 of of IN 19613 4690 10 a a DT 19613 4690 11 truth truth NN 19613 4690 12 contained contain VBN 19613 4690 13 in in IN 19613 4690 14 the the DT 19613 4690 15 world world NN 19613 4690 16 and and CC 19613 4690 17 in in IN 19613 4690 18 man man NN 19613 4690 19 , , , 19613 4690 20 the the DT 19613 4690 21 discovery discovery NN 19613 4690 22 of of IN 19613 4690 23 the the DT 19613 4690 24 one one NN 19613 4690 25 God God NNP 19613 4690 26 from from IN 19613 4690 27 the the DT 19613 4690 28 open open JJ 19613 4690 29 book book NN 19613 4690 30 of of IN 19613 4690 31 creation creation NN 19613 4690 32 . . . 19613 4691 1 The the DT 19613 4691 2 difference difference NN 19613 4691 3 between between IN 19613 4691 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4691 5 and and CC 19613 4691 6 an an DT 19613 4691 7 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 4691 8 like like IN 19613 4691 9 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4691 10 seems seem VBZ 19613 4691 11 here here RB 19613 4691 12 to to TO 19613 4691 13 be be VB 19613 4691 14 a a DT 19613 4691 15 radical radical JJ 19613 4691 16 one one NN 19613 4691 17 . . . 19613 4692 1 But but CC 19613 4692 2 , , , 19613 4692 3 if if IN 19613 4692 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4692 5 look look VBP 19613 4692 6 more more RBR 19613 4692 7 closely closely RB 19613 4692 8 , , , 19613 4692 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4692 10 find find VBP 19613 4692 11 that that IN 19613 4692 12 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4692 13 -- -- : 19613 4692 14 and and CC 19613 4692 15 not not RB 19613 4692 16 less less RBR 19613 4692 17 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4692 18 -- -- : 19613 4692 19 has have VBZ 19613 4692 20 abandoned abandon VBN 19613 4692 21 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4692 22 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 4692 23 in in IN 19613 4692 24 vital vital JJ 19613 4692 25 points point NNS 19613 4692 26 . . . 19613 4693 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4693 2 may may MD 19613 4693 3 regard regard VB 19613 4693 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4693 5 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 4693 6 aim aim NN 19613 4693 7 as as IN 19613 4693 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4693 9 excuse excuse NN 19613 4693 10 for for IN 19613 4693 11 clearly clearly RB 19613 4693 12 drawing draw VBG 19613 4693 13 the the DT 19613 4693 14 logical logical JJ 19613 4693 15 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 4693 16 from from IN 19613 4693 17 these these DT 19613 4693 18 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 19613 4693 19 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4693 20 . . . 19613 4694 1 However however RB 19613 4694 2 , , , 19613 4694 3 these these DT 19613 4694 4 deviations deviation NNS 19613 4694 5 of of IN 19613 4694 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4694 7 from from IN 19613 4694 8 the the DT 19613 4694 9 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4694 10 of of IN 19613 4694 11 the the DT 19613 4694 12 Stoa Stoa NNP 19613 4694 13 are be VBP 19613 4694 14 not not RB 19613 4694 15 merely merely RB 19613 4694 16 prompted prompt VBN 19613 4694 17 by by IN 19613 4694 18 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4694 19 , , , 19613 4694 20 but but CC 19613 4694 21 rather rather RB 19613 4694 22 have have VBP 19613 4694 23 already already RB 19613 4694 24 become become VBN 19613 4694 25 an an DT 19613 4694 26 essential essential JJ 19613 4694 27 component component NN 19613 4694 28 of of IN 19613 4694 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4694 30 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4694 31 theory theory NN 19613 4694 32 of of IN 19613 4694 33 the the DT 19613 4694 34 world world NN 19613 4694 35 . . . 19613 4695 1 In in IN 19613 4695 2 the the DT 19613 4695 3 first first JJ 19613 4695 4 place place NN 19613 4695 5 , , , 19613 4695 6 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4695 7 developed develop VBD 19613 4695 8 a a DT 19613 4695 9 detailed detailed JJ 19613 4695 10 theory theory NN 19613 4695 11 of of IN 19613 4695 12 the the DT 19613 4695 13 pernicious pernicious JJ 19613 4695 14 activity activity NN 19613 4695 15 of of IN 19613 4695 16 the the DT 19613 4695 17 demons demon NNS 19613 4695 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4695 19 cc cc NNP 19613 4695 20 . . . 19613 4696 1 26 26 CD 19613 4696 2 , , , 19613 4696 3 27 27 CD 19613 4696 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4696 5 . . . 19613 4697 1 This this DT 19613 4697 2 was be VBD 19613 4697 3 a a DT 19613 4697 4 confession confession NN 19613 4697 5 that that WDT 19613 4697 6 human human JJ 19613 4697 7 nature nature NN 19613 4697 8 was be VBD 19613 4697 9 not not RB 19613 4697 10 what what WP 19613 4697 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4697 12 ought ought MD 19613 4697 13 to to TO 19613 4697 14 be be VB 19613 4697 15 , , , 19613 4697 16 because because IN 19613 4697 17 an an DT 19613 4697 18 evil evil JJ 19613 4697 19 element element NN 19613 4697 20 had have VBD 19613 4697 21 penetrated penetrate VBN 19613 4697 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4697 23 from from IN 19613 4697 24 without without IN 19613 4697 25 . . . 19613 4698 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 4698 2 , , , 19613 4698 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4698 4 no no RB 19613 4698 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 4698 6 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 4698 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4698 8 I. i. NN 19613 4699 1 4 4 CD 19613 4699 2 : : SYM 19613 4699 3 16 16 CD 19613 4699 4 . . . 19613 4700 1 5 5 LS 19613 4700 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4700 3 the the DT 19613 4700 4 natural natural JJ 19613 4700 5 light light NN 19613 4700 6 of of IN 19613 4700 7 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4700 8 in in IN 19613 4700 9 humanity humanity NN 19613 4700 10 , , , 19613 4700 11 but but CC 19613 4700 12 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4700 13 remarked remark VBN 19613 4700 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4700 15 32 32 CD 19613 4700 16 . . . 19613 4701 1 9 9 LS 19613 4701 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4701 3 that that IN 19613 4701 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4701 5 thoughts thought NNS 19613 4701 6 are be VBP 19613 4701 7 darkness darkness NN 19613 4701 8 when when WRB 19613 4701 9 measured measure VBN 19613 4701 10 by by IN 19613 4701 11 the the DT 19613 4701 12 clearness clearness NN 19613 4701 13 of of IN 19613 4701 14 God God NNP 19613 4701 15 . . . 19613 4702 1 Finally finally RB 19613 4702 2 , , , 19613 4702 3 and and CC 19613 4702 4 this this DT 19613 4702 5 is be VBZ 19613 4702 6 the the DT 19613 4702 7 most most RBS 19613 4702 8 essential essential JJ 19613 4702 9 point point NN 19613 4702 10 , , , 19613 4702 11 after after IN 19613 4702 12 appealing appeal VBG 19613 4702 13 to to IN 19613 4702 14 various various JJ 19613 4702 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4702 16 when when WRB 19613 4702 17 expounding expound VBG 19613 4702 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4702 19 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4702 20 of of IN 19613 4702 21 the the DT 19613 4702 22 final final JJ 19613 4702 23 conflagration conflagration NN 19613 4702 24 of of IN 19613 4702 25 the the DT 19613 4702 26 world world NN 19613 4702 27 , , , 19613 4702 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4702 29 suddenly suddenly RB 19613 4702 30 repudiated repudiate VBD 19613 4702 31 this this DT 19613 4702 32 tribunal tribunal NN 19613 4702 33 , , , 19613 4702 34 declaring declare VBG 19613 4702 35 that that IN 19613 4702 36 the the DT 19613 4702 37 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4702 38 follow follow VBP 19613 4702 39 the the DT 19613 4702 40 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4702 41 , , , 19613 4702 42 and and CC 19613 4702 43 that that IN 19613 4702 44 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4702 45 " " `` 19613 4702 46 have have VBP 19613 4702 47 formed form VBN 19613 4702 48 this this DT 19613 4702 49 shadowy shadowy JJ 19613 4702 50 picture picture NN 19613 4702 51 of of IN 19613 4702 52 distorted distorted JJ 19613 4702 53 truth truth NN 19613 4702 54 in in IN 19613 4702 55 imitation imitation NN 19613 4702 56 of of IN 19613 4702 57 the the DT 19613 4702 58 divine divine JJ 19613 4702 59 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4702 60 of of IN 19613 4702 61 the the DT 19613 4702 62 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4702 63 . . . 19613 4702 64 " " '' 19613 4703 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4703 2 34 34 CD 19613 4703 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4703 4 Here here RB 19613 4703 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4703 6 have have VBP 19613 4703 7 now now RB 19613 4703 8 a a DT 19613 4703 9 union union NN 19613 4703 10 of of IN 19613 4703 11 all all PDT 19613 4703 12 the the DT 19613 4703 13 elements element NNS 19613 4703 14 already already RB 19613 4703 15 found find VBN 19613 4703 16 in in IN 19613 4703 17 the the DT 19613 4703 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4703 19 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4703 20 ; ; : 19613 4703 21 only only RB 19613 4703 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4703 23 are be VBP 19613 4703 24 , , , 19613 4703 25 as as IN 19613 4703 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4703 27 were be VBD 19613 4703 28 , , , 19613 4703 29 hid hide VBD 19613 4703 30 in in IN 19613 4703 31 the the DT 19613 4703 32 case case NN 19613 4703 33 of of IN 19613 4703 34 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4703 35 . . . 19613 4704 1 But but CC 19613 4704 2 the the DT 19613 4704 3 final final JJ 19613 4704 4 proof proof NN 19613 4704 5 that that IN 19613 4704 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4704 7 agreed agree VBD 19613 4704 8 with with IN 19613 4704 9 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4704 10 in in IN 19613 4704 11 the the DT 19613 4704 12 main main NN 19613 4704 13 is be VBZ 19613 4704 14 found find VBN 19613 4704 15 in in IN 19613 4704 16 the the DT 19613 4704 17 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 4704 18 contemptuous contemptuous JJ 19613 4704 19 judgment judgment NN 19613 4704 20 which which WDT 19613 4704 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4704 22 in in IN 19613 4704 23 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 4704 24 passed pass VBD 19613 4704 25 on on IN 19613 4704 26 all all DT 19613 4704 27 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4704 28 and and CC 19613 4704 29 indeed indeed RB 19613 4704 30 on on IN 19613 4704 31 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4704 32 generally generally RB 19613 4704 33 . . . 19613 4705 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4705 2 410 410 CD 19613 4705 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4705 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4705 5 34 34 CD 19613 4705 6 . . . 19613 4706 1 5 5 CD 19613 4706 2 : : SYM 19613 4706 3 38 38 CD 19613 4706 4 . . . 19613 4707 1 5 5 LS 19613 4707 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4707 3 This this DT 19613 4707 4 judgment judgment NN 19613 4707 5 is be VBZ 19613 4707 6 not not RB 19613 4707 7 to to TO 19613 4707 8 be be VB 19613 4707 9 explained explain VBN 19613 4707 10 , , , 19613 4707 11 as as IN 19613 4707 12 in in IN 19613 4707 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4707 14 's 's POS 19613 4707 15 case case NN 19613 4707 16 , , , 19613 4707 17 by by IN 19613 4707 18 the the DT 19613 4707 19 fact fact NN 19613 4707 20 that that IN 19613 4707 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4707 22 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4707 23 opinions opinion NNS 19613 4707 24 led lead VBD 19613 4707 25 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4707 26 to to TO 19613 4707 27 oppose oppose VB 19613 4707 28 natural natural JJ 19613 4707 29 perception perception NN 19613 4707 30 to to IN 19613 4707 31 all all DT 19613 4707 32 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4707 33 theory theory NN 19613 4707 34 -- -- : 19613 4707 35 for for IN 19613 4707 36 this this DT 19613 4707 37 , , , 19613 4707 38 at at IN 19613 4707 39 most most RBS 19613 4707 40 , , , 19613 4707 41 can can MD 19613 4707 42 not not RB 19613 4707 43 have have VB 19613 4707 44 been be VBN 19613 4707 45 more more JJR 19613 4707 46 than than IN 19613 4707 47 a a DT 19613 4707 48 secondary secondary JJ 19613 4707 49 contributing contributing NN 19613 4707 50 cause,[411 cause,[411 NN 19613 4707 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4707 52 but but CC 19613 4707 53 by by IN 19613 4707 54 the the DT 19613 4707 55 fact fact NN 19613 4707 56 that that IN 19613 4707 57 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4707 58 is be VBZ 19613 4707 59 conscious conscious JJ 19613 4707 60 of of IN 19613 4707 61 following follow VBG 19613 4707 62 _ _ NNP 19613 4707 63 revealed reveal VBD 19613 4707 64 _ _ NNP 19613 4707 65 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4707 66 . . . 19613 4708 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4708 2 412 412 CD 19613 4708 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4708 4 Revelation revelation NN 19613 4708 5 is be VBZ 19613 4708 6 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4708 7 because because IN 19613 4708 8 mankind mankind NN 19613 4708 9 must must MD 19613 4708 10 be be VB 19613 4708 11 aided aid VBN 19613 4708 12 from from IN 19613 4708 13 without without IN 19613 4708 14 , , , 19613 4708 15 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4708 16 , , , 19613 4708 17 by by IN 19613 4708 18 God God NNP 19613 4708 19 . . . 19613 4709 1 In in IN 19613 4709 2 this this DT 19613 4709 3 idea idea NN 19613 4709 4 man man NN 19613 4709 5 's 's POS 19613 4709 6 need need NN 19613 4709 7 of of IN 19613 4709 8 redemption redemption NN 19613 4709 9 is be VBZ 19613 4709 10 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 4709 11 , , , 19613 4709 12 though though IN 19613 4709 13 not not RB 19613 4709 14 to to IN 19613 4709 15 the the DT 19613 4709 16 same same JJ 19613 4709 17 extent extent NN 19613 4709 18 as as IN 19613 4709 19 by by IN 19613 4709 20 Seneca Seneca NNP 19613 4709 21 and and CC 19613 4709 22 Epictetus Epictetus NNP 19613 4709 23 . . . 19613 4710 1 But but CC 19613 4710 2 no no DT 19613 4710 3 sooner soon RBR 19613 4710 4 does do VBZ 19613 4710 5 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 4710 6 perceive perceive VB 19613 4710 7 the the DT 19613 4710 8 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4710 9 of of IN 19613 4710 10 the the DT 19613 4710 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4710 12 to to TO 19613 4710 13 be be VB 19613 4710 14 divine divine JJ 19613 4710 15 truth truth NN 19613 4710 16 than than IN 19613 4710 17 man man NN 19613 4710 18 's 's POS 19613 4710 19 natural natural JJ 19613 4710 20 endowment endowment NN 19613 4710 21 and and CC 19613 4710 22 the the DT 19613 4710 23 speculation speculation NN 19613 4710 24 of of IN 19613 4710 25 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4710 26 sink sink VBP 19613 4710 27 for for IN 19613 4710 28 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4710 29 into into IN 19613 4710 30 darkness darkness NN 19613 4710 31 . . . 19613 4711 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4711 2 is be VBZ 19613 4711 3 the the DT 19613 4711 4 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4711 5 which which WDT 19613 4711 6 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4711 7 sought seek VBD 19613 4711 8 , , , 19613 4711 9 but but CC 19613 4711 10 were be VBD 19613 4711 11 not not RB 19613 4711 12 able able JJ 19613 4711 13 to to TO 19613 4711 14 find find VB 19613 4711 15 . . . 19613 4712 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4712 2 413 413 CD 19613 4712 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4712 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4712 5 may may MD 19613 4712 6 sum sum VB 19613 4712 7 up up RP 19613 4712 8 the the DT 19613 4712 9 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4712 10 of of IN 19613 4712 11 the the DT 19613 4712 12 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4712 13 as as IN 19613 4712 14 follows follow VBZ 19613 4712 15 : : : 19613 4712 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4712 17 1 1 LS 19613 4712 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4712 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4712 20 is be VBZ 19613 4712 21 revelation revelation NN 19613 4712 22 , , , 19613 4712 23 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4712 24 , , , 19613 4712 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4712 26 is be VBZ 19613 4712 27 the the DT 19613 4712 28 divine divine JJ 19613 4712 29 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4712 30 , , , 19613 4712 31 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 4712 32 of of IN 19613 4712 33 old old JJ 19613 4712 34 by by IN 19613 4712 35 the the DT 19613 4712 36 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4712 37 and and CC 19613 4712 38 , , , 19613 4712 39 by by IN 19613 4712 40 reason reason NN 19613 4712 41 of of IN 19613 4712 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4712 43 origin origin NN 19613 4712 44 , , , 19613 4712 45 possessing possess VBG 19613 4712 46 an an DT 19613 4712 47 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4712 48 certainty certainty NN 19613 4712 49 which which WDT 19613 4712 50 can can MD 19613 4712 51 also also RB 19613 4712 52 be be VB 19613 4712 53 recognised recognise VBN 19613 4712 54 in in IN 19613 4712 55 the the DT 19613 4712 56 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 4712 57 of of IN 19613 4712 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4712 59 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4712 60 . . . 19613 4713 1 As as IN 19613 4713 2 divine divine JJ 19613 4713 3 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4713 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4713 5 is be VBZ 19613 4713 6 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 4713 7 with with IN 19613 4713 8 , , , 19613 4713 9 and and CC 19613 4713 10 puts put VBZ 19613 4713 11 an an DT 19613 4713 12 end end NN 19613 4713 13 to to IN 19613 4713 14 , , , 19613 4713 15 all all DT 19613 4713 16 natural natural JJ 19613 4713 17 and and CC 19613 4713 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4713 19 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4713 20 . . . 19613 4714 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4714 2 2 2 LS 19613 4714 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4714 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4714 5 is be VBZ 19613 4714 6 the the DT 19613 4714 7 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 4714 8 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 4714 9 to to IN 19613 4714 10 the the DT 19613 4714 11 natural natural JJ 19613 4714 12 but but CC 19613 4714 13 impaired impaired JJ 19613 4714 14 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4714 15 of of IN 19613 4714 16 man man NN 19613 4714 17 . . . 19613 4715 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4715 2 414 414 CD 19613 4715 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4715 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4715 5 embraces embrace VBZ 19613 4715 6 all all PDT 19613 4715 7 the the DT 19613 4715 8 elements element NNS 19613 4715 9 of of IN 19613 4715 10 truth truth NN 19613 4715 11 in in IN 19613 4715 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4715 13 , , , 19613 4715 14 whence whence NN 19613 4715 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4715 16 is be VBZ 19613 4715 17 _ _ NNP 19613 4715 18 the the DT 19613 4715 19 _ _ NNP 19613 4715 20 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4715 21 ; ; : 19613 4715 22 and and CC 19613 4715 23 helps help VBZ 19613 4715 24 man man NN 19613 4715 25 to to TO 19613 4715 26 realise realise VB 19613 4715 27 the the DT 19613 4715 28 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4715 29 with with IN 19613 4715 30 which which WDT 19613 4715 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4715 32 is be VBZ 19613 4715 33 naturally naturally RB 19613 4715 34 endowed endow VBN 19613 4715 35 . . . 19613 4716 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4716 2 3 3 LS 19613 4716 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4716 4 Revelation revelation NN 19613 4716 5 of of IN 19613 4716 6 the the DT 19613 4716 7 rational rational NN 19613 4716 8 was be VBD 19613 4716 9 and and CC 19613 4716 10 is be VBZ 19613 4716 11 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4716 12 , , , 19613 4716 13 because because IN 19613 4716 14 man man NN 19613 4716 15 has have VBZ 19613 4716 16 fallen fall VBN 19613 4716 17 under under IN 19613 4716 18 the the DT 19613 4716 19 sway sway NN 19613 4716 20 of of IN 19613 4716 21 the the DT 19613 4716 22 demons demon NNS 19613 4716 23 . . . 19613 4717 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4717 2 4 4 LS 19613 4717 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4717 4 The the DT 19613 4717 5 efforts effort NNS 19613 4717 6 of of IN 19613 4717 7 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4717 8 to to TO 19613 4717 9 ascertain ascertain VB 19613 4717 10 the the DT 19613 4717 11 right right JJ 19613 4717 12 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4717 13 were be VBD 19613 4717 14 in in IN 19613 4717 15 vain vain JJ 19613 4717 16 ; ; : 19613 4717 17 and and CC 19613 4717 18 this this DT 19613 4717 19 is be VBZ 19613 4717 20 , , , 19613 4717 21 above above IN 19613 4717 22 all all DT 19613 4717 23 , , , 19613 4717 24 shown show VBN 19613 4717 25 by by IN 19613 4717 26 the the DT 19613 4717 27 fact fact NN 19613 4717 28 that that IN 19613 4717 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4717 30 neither neither CC 19613 4717 31 overthrew overthrew JJ 19613 4717 32 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4717 33 nor nor CC 19613 4717 34 brought bring VBD 19613 4717 35 about about RP 19613 4717 36 a a DT 19613 4717 37 really really RB 19613 4717 38 moral moral JJ 19613 4717 39 life life NN 19613 4717 40 . . . 19613 4718 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4718 2 , , , 19613 4718 3 so so RB 19613 4718 4 far far RB 19613 4718 5 as as IN 19613 4718 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 7 discovered discover VBD 19613 4718 8 the the DT 19613 4718 9 truth truth NN 19613 4718 10 , , , 19613 4718 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 12 owed owe VBD 19613 4718 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 14 to to IN 19613 4718 15 the the DT 19613 4718 16 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4718 17 from from IN 19613 4718 18 whom whom WP 19613 4718 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 20 borrowed borrow VBD 19613 4718 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 22 ; ; : 19613 4718 23 at at IN 19613 4718 24 least least JJS 19613 4718 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 26 is be VBZ 19613 4718 27 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 4718 28 whether whether IN 19613 4718 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4718 30 even even RB 19613 4718 31 attained attain VBD 19613 4718 32 a a DT 19613 4718 33 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4718 34 of of IN 19613 4718 35 fragments fragment NNS 19613 4718 36 of of IN 19613 4718 37 the the DT 19613 4718 38 truth truth NN 19613 4718 39 by by IN 19613 4718 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4718 41 own own JJ 19613 4718 42 independent independent JJ 19613 4718 43 efforts effort NNS 19613 4718 44 . . . 19613 4719 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4719 2 415 415 CD 19613 4719 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4719 4 But but CC 19613 4719 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4719 6 is be VBZ 19613 4719 7 certain certain JJ 19613 4719 8 that that IN 19613 4719 9 many many JJ 19613 4719 10 seeming seeming JJ 19613 4719 11 truths truth NNS 19613 4719 12 in in IN 19613 4719 13 the the DT 19613 4719 14 writings writing NNS 19613 4719 15 of of IN 19613 4719 16 the the DT 19613 4719 17 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4719 18 were be VBD 19613 4719 19 imitations imitation NNS 19613 4719 20 of of IN 19613 4719 21 the the DT 19613 4719 22 truth truth NN 19613 4719 23 by by IN 19613 4719 24 evil evil JJ 19613 4719 25 demons demon NNS 19613 4719 26 . . . 19613 4720 1 This this DT 19613 4720 2 is be VBZ 19613 4720 3 the the DT 19613 4720 4 origin origin NN 19613 4720 5 of of IN 19613 4720 6 all all DT 19613 4720 7 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4720 8 , , , 19613 4720 9 which which WDT 19613 4720 10 is be VBZ 19613 4720 11 , , , 19613 4720 12 moreover moreover RB 19613 4720 13 , , , 19613 4720 14 to to IN 19613 4720 15 some some DT 19613 4720 16 extent extent NN 19613 4720 17 an an DT 19613 4720 18 imitation imitation NN 19613 4720 19 of of IN 19613 4720 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 4720 21 institutions institution NNS 19613 4720 22 . . . 19613 4721 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4721 2 5 5 LS 19613 4721 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4721 4 The the DT 19613 4721 5 confession confession NN 19613 4721 6 of of IN 19613 4721 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4721 8 is be VBZ 19613 4721 9 simply simply RB 19613 4721 10 included include VBN 19613 4721 11 in in IN 19613 4721 12 the the DT 19613 4721 13 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 4721 14 of of IN 19613 4721 15 the the DT 19613 4721 16 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4721 17 of of IN 19613 4721 18 the the DT 19613 4721 19 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4721 20 ; ; : 19613 4721 21 the the DT 19613 4721 22 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4721 23 of of IN 19613 4721 24 the the DT 19613 4721 25 truth truth NN 19613 4721 26 did do VBD 19613 4721 27 not not RB 19613 4721 28 receive receive VB 19613 4721 29 a a DT 19613 4721 30 new new JJ 19613 4721 31 content content NN 19613 4721 32 through through IN 19613 4721 33 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4721 34 ; ; : 19613 4721 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4721 36 only only RB 19613 4721 37 made make VBD 19613 4721 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4721 39 accessible accessible JJ 19613 4721 40 to to IN 19613 4721 41 the the DT 19613 4721 42 world world NN 19613 4721 43 and and CC 19613 4721 44 strengthened strengthen VBD 19613 4721 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4721 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4721 47 victory victory NN 19613 4721 48 over over IN 19613 4721 49 the the DT 19613 4721 50 demons demon NNS 19613 4721 51 ; ; : 19613 4721 52 special special JJ 19613 4721 53 features feature NNS 19613 4721 54 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 4721 55 by by IN 19613 4721 56 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4721 57 and and CC 19613 4721 58 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4721 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4721 60 . . . 19613 4722 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4722 2 6 6 LS 19613 4722 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4722 4 The the DT 19613 4722 5 practical practical JJ 19613 4722 6 test test NN 19613 4722 7 of of IN 19613 4722 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4722 9 is be VBZ 19613 4722 10 first first RB 19613 4722 11 contained contain VBN 19613 4722 12 in in IN 19613 4722 13 the the DT 19613 4722 14 fact fact NN 19613 4722 15 that that IN 19613 4722 16 all all DT 19613 4722 17 persons person NNS 19613 4722 18 are be VBP 19613 4722 19 able able JJ 19613 4722 20 to to TO 19613 4722 21 grasp grasp VB 19613 4722 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4722 23 , , , 19613 4722 24 for for IN 19613 4722 25 women woman NNS 19613 4722 26 and and CC 19613 4722 27 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 4722 28 men man NNS 19613 4722 29 here here RB 19613 4722 30 become become VBP 19613 4722 31 veritable veritable JJ 19613 4722 32 sages sage NNS 19613 4722 33 ; ; : 19613 4722 34 secondly secondly RB 19613 4722 35 in in IN 19613 4722 36 the the DT 19613 4722 37 fact fact NN 19613 4722 38 that that IN 19613 4722 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4722 40 has have VBZ 19613 4722 41 the the DT 19613 4722 42 power power NN 19613 4722 43 of of IN 19613 4722 44 producing produce VBG 19613 4722 45 a a DT 19613 4722 46 holy holy JJ 19613 4722 47 life life NN 19613 4722 48 , , , 19613 4722 49 and and CC 19613 4722 50 of of IN 19613 4722 51 overthrowing overthrow VBG 19613 4722 52 the the DT 19613 4722 53 tyranny tyranny NN 19613 4722 54 of of IN 19613 4722 55 the the DT 19613 4722 56 demons demon NNS 19613 4722 57 . . . 19613 4723 1 In in IN 19613 4723 2 the the DT 19613 4723 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4723 4 , , , 19613 4723 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 4723 6 , , , 19613 4723 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4723 8 served serve VBD 19613 4723 9 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4723 10 heir heir VBP 19613 4723 11 to to IN 19613 4723 12 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 4723 13 , , , 19613 4723 14 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4723 15 , , , 19613 4723 16 to to IN 19613 4723 17 the the DT 19613 4723 18 result result NN 19613 4723 19 of of IN 19613 4723 20 the the DT 19613 4723 21 monotheistic monotheistic JJ 19613 4723 22 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4723 23 and and CC 19613 4723 24 ethics ethic NNS 19613 4723 25 of of IN 19613 4723 26 the the DT 19613 4723 27 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4723 28 : : : 19613 4723 29 " " `` 19613 4723 30 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4723 31 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4723 32 : : : 19613 4723 33 Osa osa VB 19613 4723 34 oun oun NNP 19613 4723 35 para para NNP 19613 4723 36 pasikalôs pasikalôs NNP 19613 4723 37 eirêtai eirêtai NNP 19613 4723 38 , , , 19613 4723 39 hêmôn hêmôn VB 19613 4723 40 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4723 41 Christianôn Christianôn NNP 19613 4723 42 esti esti NN 19613 4723 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4723 44 " " '' 19613 4723 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4723 46 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4723 47 , , , 19613 4723 48 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4723 49 . . . 19613 4724 1 II ii CD 19613 4724 2 . . . 19613 4725 1 13 13 CD 19613 4725 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4725 3 . . . 19613 4726 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4726 2 traced trace VBD 19613 4726 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4726 4 origin origin NN 19613 4726 5 back back RB 19613 4726 6 to to IN 19613 4726 7 the the DT 19613 4726 8 beginning beginning NN 19613 4726 9 of of IN 19613 4726 10 the the DT 19613 4726 11 world world NN 19613 4726 12 . . . 19613 4727 1 Everything everything NN 19613 4727 2 true true JJ 19613 4727 3 and and CC 19613 4727 4 good good JJ 19613 4727 5 which which WDT 19613 4727 6 elevates elevate VBZ 19613 4727 7 mankind mankind NN 19613 4727 8 springs spring NNS 19613 4727 9 from from IN 19613 4727 10 divine divine JJ 19613 4727 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 4727 12 , , , 19613 4727 13 and and CC 19613 4727 14 is be VBZ 19613 4727 15 at at IN 19613 4727 16 the the DT 19613 4727 17 same same JJ 19613 4727 18 time time NN 19613 4727 19 genuinely genuinely RB 19613 4727 20 human human JJ 19613 4727 21 , , , 19613 4727 22 because because IN 19613 4727 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4727 24 is be VBZ 19613 4727 25 a a DT 19613 4727 26 clear clear JJ 19613 4727 27 expression expression NN 19613 4727 28 of of IN 19613 4727 29 what what WP 19613 4727 30 man man NN 19613 4727 31 finds find VBZ 19613 4727 32 within within IN 19613 4727 33 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4727 34 and and CC 19613 4727 35 of of IN 19613 4727 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4727 37 destination destination NN 19613 4727 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4727 39 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4727 40 , , , 19613 4727 41 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4727 42 . . . 19613 4728 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4729 1 46 46 CD 19613 4729 2 : : : 19613 4729 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4729 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4729 5 : : : 19613 4729 6 hoi hoi NNP 19613 4729 7 meta meta JJ 19613 4729 8 logou logou NN 19613 4729 9 biôsantes biôsante VBZ 19613 4729 10 Christianoi Christianoi NNP 19613 4729 11 eisi eisi RB 19613 4729 12 , , , 19613 4729 13 kan kan NNP 19613 4729 14 atheoi atheoi NNP 19613 4729 15 enomisthêsan enomisthêsan NNP 19613 4729 16 , , , 19613 4729 17 oion oion NN 19613 4729 18 en en IN 19613 4729 19 Hellêsi Hellêsi NNP 19613 4729 20 men man NNS 19613 4729 21 Sôkratês Sôkratês NNP 19613 4729 22 kai kai NNP 19613 4729 23 Êrakleitos Êrakleitos NNP 19613 4729 24 kai kai NNP 19613 4729 25 oi oi NNP 19613 4729 26 omoioi omoioi NNP 19613 4729 27 autois autois NNP 19613 4729 28 , , , 19613 4729 29 en en IN 19613 4729 30 barbarois barbarois NNP 19613 4729 31 de de NNP 19613 4729 32 Abraam Abraam NNP 19613 4729 33 k.t.l k.t.l JJ 19613 4729 34 . . . 19613 4730 1 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4730 2 , , , 19613 4730 3 " " `` 19613 4730 4 those those DT 19613 4730 5 that that WDT 19613 4730 6 have have VBP 19613 4730 7 lived live VBN 19613 4730 8 with with IN 19613 4730 9 reason reason NN 19613 4730 10 are be VBP 19613 4730 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4730 12 , , , 19613 4730 13 even even RB 19613 4730 14 though though IN 19613 4730 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4730 16 were be VBD 19613 4730 17 accounted account VBN 19613 4730 18 atheists atheist NNS 19613 4730 19 , , , 19613 4730 20 such such JJ 19613 4730 21 as as IN 19613 4730 22 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 4730 23 and and CC 19613 4730 24 Heraclitus Heraclitus NNP 19613 4730 25 and and CC 19613 4730 26 those those DT 19613 4730 27 similar similar JJ 19613 4730 28 to to IN 19613 4730 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4730 30 among among IN 19613 4730 31 the the DT 19613 4730 32 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4730 33 , , , 19613 4730 34 and and CC 19613 4730 35 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 4730 36 etc etc FW 19613 4730 37 . . . 19613 4731 1 among among IN 19613 4731 2 the the DT 19613 4731 3 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4731 4 " " '' 19613 4731 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4731 6 . . . 19613 4732 1 But but CC 19613 4732 2 everything everything NN 19613 4732 3 true true JJ 19613 4732 4 and and CC 19613 4732 5 good good JJ 19613 4732 6 is be VBZ 19613 4732 7 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4732 8 , , , 19613 4732 9 for for IN 19613 4732 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4732 11 is be VBZ 19613 4732 12 nothing nothing NN 19613 4732 13 else else RB 19613 4732 14 than than IN 19613 4732 15 the the DT 19613 4732 16 teaching teaching NN 19613 4732 17 of of IN 19613 4732 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 4732 19 . . . 19613 4733 1 No no DT 19613 4733 2 second second JJ 19613 4733 3 formula formula NN 19613 4733 4 can can MD 19613 4733 5 be be VB 19613 4733 6 imagined imagine VBN 19613 4733 7 in in IN 19613 4733 8 which which WDT 19613 4733 9 the the DT 19613 4733 10 claim claim NN 19613 4733 11 of of IN 19613 4733 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4733 13 to to TO 19613 4733 14 be be VB 19613 4733 15 the the DT 19613 4733 16 religion religion NN 19613 4733 17 of of IN 19613 4733 18 the the DT 19613 4733 19 world world NN 19613 4733 20 is be VBZ 19613 4733 21 so so RB 19613 4733 22 powerfully powerfully RB 19613 4733 23 expressed express VBN 19613 4733 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4733 25 hence hence RB 19613 4733 26 also also RB 19613 4733 27 the the DT 19613 4733 28 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 4733 29 of of IN 19613 4733 30 the the DT 19613 4733 31 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4733 32 to to TO 19613 4733 33 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 4733 34 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4733 35 and and CC 19613 4733 36 the the DT 19613 4733 37 Empire empire NN 19613 4733 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4733 39 , , , 19613 4733 40 nor nor CC 19613 4733 41 , , , 19613 4733 42 on on IN 19613 4733 43 the the DT 19613 4733 44 other other JJ 19613 4733 45 hand hand NN 19613 4733 46 , , , 19613 4733 47 can can MD 19613 4733 48 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4733 49 conceive conceive VB 19613 4733 50 of of IN 19613 4733 51 one one CD 19613 4733 52 where where WRB 19613 4733 53 the the DT 19613 4733 54 specific specific JJ 19613 4733 55 content content NN 19613 4733 56 of of IN 19613 4733 57 traditional traditional JJ 19613 4733 58 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4733 59 is be VBZ 19613 4733 60 so so RB 19613 4733 61 thoroughly thoroughly RB 19613 4733 62 neutralised neutralise VBN 19613 4733 63 as as IN 19613 4733 64 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4733 65 is be VBZ 19613 4733 66 here here RB 19613 4733 67 . . . 19613 4734 1 But but CC 19613 4734 2 the the DT 19613 4734 3 really really RB 19613 4734 4 epoch epoch NN 19613 4734 5 - - HYPH 19613 4734 6 making make VBG 19613 4734 7 feature feature NN 19613 4734 8 is be VBZ 19613 4734 9 the the DT 19613 4734 10 fact fact NN 19613 4734 11 that that IN 19613 4734 12 the the DT 19613 4734 13 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 4734 14 culture culture NN 19613 4734 15 of of IN 19613 4734 16 mankind mankind NN 19613 4734 17 now now RB 19613 4734 18 appears appear VBZ 19613 4734 19 reconciled reconcile VBN 19613 4734 20 and and CC 19613 4734 21 united unite VBN 19613 4734 22 with with IN 19613 4734 23 religion religion NN 19613 4734 24 . . . 19613 4735 1 The the DT 19613 4735 2 " " `` 19613 4735 3 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 4735 4 " " '' 19613 4735 5 are be VBP 19613 4735 6 the the DT 19613 4735 7 expression expression NN 19613 4735 8 of of IN 19613 4735 9 this this DT 19613 4735 10 . . . 19613 4736 1 Finally finally RB 19613 4736 2 , , , 19613 4736 3 these these DT 19613 4736 4 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4736 5 presuppositions presupposition NNS 19613 4736 6 also also RB 19613 4736 7 result result VBP 19613 4736 8 in in IN 19613 4736 9 a a DT 19613 4736 10 quite quite RB 19613 4736 11 definite definite JJ 19613 4736 12 idea idea NN 19613 4736 13 of of IN 19613 4736 14 the the DT 19613 4736 15 essence essence NN 19613 4736 16 of of IN 19613 4736 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 4736 18 and and CC 19613 4736 19 of of IN 19613 4736 20 the the DT 19613 4736 21 content content NN 19613 4736 22 of of IN 19613 4736 23 reason reason NN 19613 4736 24 . . . 19613 4737 1 The the DT 19613 4737 2 essence essence NN 19613 4737 3 of of IN 19613 4737 4 revelation revelation NN 19613 4737 5 consists consist VBZ 19613 4737 6 in in IN 19613 4737 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4737 8 form form NN 19613 4737 9 : : : 19613 4737 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4737 11 is be VBZ 19613 4737 12 divine divine JJ 19613 4737 13 communication communication NN 19613 4737 14 through through IN 19613 4737 15 a a DT 19613 4737 16 miraculous miraculous JJ 19613 4737 17 inward inward NN 19613 4737 18 working work VBG 19613 4737 19 . . . 19613 4738 1 All all PDT 19613 4738 2 the the DT 19613 4738 3 media medium NNS 19613 4738 4 of of IN 19613 4738 5 revelation revelation NN 19613 4738 6 are be VBP 19613 4738 7 passive passive JJ 19613 4738 8 organs organ NNS 19613 4738 9 of of IN 19613 4738 10 the the DT 19613 4738 11 Holy Holy NNP 19613 4738 12 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4738 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4738 14 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 4738 15 . . . 19613 4739 1 Supplic Supplic NNP 19613 4739 2 . . . 19613 4740 1 7 7 LS 19613 4740 2 ; ; : 19613 4740 3 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 4740 4 - - HYPH 19613 4740 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4740 6 , , , 19613 4740 7 Cohort Cohort NNP 19613 4740 8 . . . 19613 4741 1 8 8 LS 19613 4741 2 ; ; : 19613 4741 3 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4741 4 , , , 19613 4741 5 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 19613 4741 6 115 115 CD 19613 4741 7 . . . 19613 4742 1 7 7 LS 19613 4742 2 ; ; : 19613 4742 3 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4742 4 . . . 19613 4743 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4744 1 31 31 CD 19613 4744 2 , , , 19613 4744 3 33 33 CD 19613 4744 4 , , , 19613 4744 5 36 36 CD 19613 4744 6 ; ; : 19613 4744 7 etc etc FW 19613 4744 8 . . . 19613 4745 1 ; ; : 19613 4745 2 see see VB 19613 4745 3 also also RB 19613 4745 4 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 4745 5 , , , 19613 4745 6 de de NNP 19613 4745 7 Christo Christo NNP 19613 4745 8 et et NNP 19613 4745 9 Antichr Antichr NNP 19613 4745 10 . . . 19613 4746 1 2 2 LS 19613 4746 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4746 3 . . . 19613 4747 1 These these DT 19613 4747 2 were be VBD 19613 4747 3 not not RB 19613 4747 4 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 4747 5 at at IN 19613 4747 6 all all DT 19613 4747 7 times time NNS 19613 4747 8 in in IN 19613 4747 9 a a DT 19613 4747 10 state state NN 19613 4747 11 of of IN 19613 4747 12 ecstasy ecstasy NN 19613 4747 13 , , , 19613 4747 14 when when WRB 19613 4747 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4747 16 received receive VBD 19613 4747 17 the the DT 19613 4747 18 revelations revelation NNS 19613 4747 19 ; ; : 19613 4747 20 but but CC 19613 4747 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4747 22 were be VBD 19613 4747 23 no no RB 19613 4747 24 doubt doubt NN 19613 4747 25 in in IN 19613 4747 26 a a DT 19613 4747 27 condition condition NN 19613 4747 28 of of IN 19613 4747 29 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4747 30 receptivity receptivity NN 19613 4747 31 . . . 19613 4748 1 The the DT 19613 4748 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4748 3 had have VBD 19613 4748 4 no no DT 19613 4748 5 other other JJ 19613 4748 6 idea idea NN 19613 4748 7 of of IN 19613 4748 8 revelation revelation NN 19613 4748 9 . . . 19613 4749 1 What what WP 19613 4749 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4749 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 4749 4 viewed view VBD 19613 4749 5 as as IN 19613 4749 6 the the DT 19613 4749 7 really really RB 19613 4749 8 decisive decisive JJ 19613 4749 9 proof proof NN 19613 4749 10 of of IN 19613 4749 11 the the DT 19613 4749 12 reality reality NN 19613 4749 13 of of IN 19613 4749 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 4749 15 is be VBZ 19613 4749 16 the the DT 19613 4749 17 prediction prediction NN 19613 4749 18 of of IN 19613 4749 19 the the DT 19613 4749 20 future future NN 19613 4749 21 , , , 19613 4749 22 for for IN 19613 4749 23 the the DT 19613 4749 24 human human JJ 19613 4749 25 mind mind NN 19613 4749 26 does do VBZ 19613 4749 27 not not RB 19613 4749 28 possess possess VB 19613 4749 29 this this DT 19613 4749 30 power power NN 19613 4749 31 . . . 19613 4750 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4750 2 was be VBD 19613 4750 3 only only RB 19613 4750 4 in in IN 19613 4750 5 connection connection NN 19613 4750 6 with with IN 19613 4750 7 this this DT 19613 4750 8 proof proof NN 19613 4750 9 that that IN 19613 4750 10 the the DT 19613 4750 11 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4750 12 considered consider VBD 19613 4750 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4750 14 important important JJ 19613 4750 15 to to TO 19613 4750 16 show show VB 19613 4750 17 what what WP 19613 4750 18 Moses Moses NNP 19613 4750 19 , , , 19613 4750 20 David David NNP 19613 4750 21 , , , 19613 4750 22 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 19613 4750 23 , , , 19613 4750 24 etc etc FW 19613 4750 25 . . . 19613 4750 26 , , , 19613 4750 27 had have VBD 19613 4750 28 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 4750 29 in in IN 19613 4750 30 the the DT 19613 4750 31 Old Old NNP 19613 4750 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4750 33 , , , 19613 4750 34 that that RB 19613 4750 35 is is RB 19613 4750 36 , , , 19613 4750 37 these these DT 19613 4750 38 names name NNS 19613 4750 39 have have VBP 19613 4750 40 only only RB 19613 4750 41 a a DT 19613 4750 42 _ _ NNP 19613 4750 43 chronological chronological JJ 19613 4750 44 _ _ NNP 19613 4750 45 significance significance NN 19613 4750 46 . . . 19613 4751 1 This this DT 19613 4751 2 also also RB 19613 4751 3 explains explain VBZ 19613 4751 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4751 5 interest interest NN 19613 4751 6 in in IN 19613 4751 7 a a DT 19613 4751 8 history history NN 19613 4751 9 of of IN 19613 4751 10 the the DT 19613 4751 11 world world NN 19613 4751 12 , , , 19613 4751 13 in in IN 19613 4751 14 so so RB 19613 4751 15 far far RB 19613 4751 16 as as IN 19613 4751 17 this this DT 19613 4751 18 interest interest NN 19613 4751 19 originated originate VBD 19613 4751 20 in in IN 19613 4751 21 the the DT 19613 4751 22 effort effort NN 19613 4751 23 to to TO 19613 4751 24 trace trace VB 19613 4751 25 the the DT 19613 4751 26 chain chain NN 19613 4751 27 of of IN 19613 4751 28 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4751 29 up up IN 19613 4751 30 to to IN 19613 4751 31 the the DT 19613 4751 32 beginning beginning NN 19613 4751 33 of of IN 19613 4751 34 history history NN 19613 4751 35 , , , 19613 4751 36 and and CC 19613 4751 37 to to TO 19613 4751 38 prove prove VB 19613 4751 39 the the DT 19613 4751 40 higher high JJR 19613 4751 41 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 4751 42 of of IN 19613 4751 43 revealed reveal VBN 19613 4751 44 truth truth NN 19613 4751 45 as as IN 19613 4751 46 compared compare VBN 19613 4751 47 with with IN 19613 4751 48 all all DT 19613 4751 49 human human JJ 19613 4751 50 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4751 51 and and CC 19613 4751 52 errors error NNS 19613 4751 53 , , , 19613 4751 54 particularly particularly RB 19613 4751 55 as as IN 19613 4751 56 found find VBN 19613 4751 57 among among IN 19613 4751 58 the the DT 19613 4751 59 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4751 60 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4751 61 clear clear JJ 19613 4751 62 traces trace NNS 19613 4751 63 in in IN 19613 4751 64 Justin,[416 Justin,[416 NNP 19613 4751 65 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4751 66 first first RB 19613 4751 67 detailed detailed JJ 19613 4751 68 argument argument NN 19613 4751 69 in in IN 19613 4751 70 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4751 71 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4751 72 . . . 19613 4752 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4752 2 417 417 CD 19613 4752 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4752 4 If if IN 19613 4752 5 , , , 19613 4752 6 however however RB 19613 4752 7 , , , 19613 4752 8 strictly strictly RB 19613 4752 9 speaking speak VBG 19613 4752 10 , , , 19613 4752 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4752 12 is be VBZ 19613 4752 13 only only RB 19613 4752 14 the the DT 19613 4752 15 form form NN 19613 4752 16 and and CC 19613 4752 17 not not RB 19613 4752 18 the the DT 19613 4752 19 content content NN 19613 4752 20 of of IN 19613 4752 21 revelation revelation NN 19613 4752 22 that that WDT 19613 4752 23 is be VBZ 19613 4752 24 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 4752 25 in in IN 19613 4752 26 so so RB 19613 4752 27 far far RB 19613 4752 28 as as IN 19613 4752 29 this this DT 19613 4752 30 content content NN 19613 4752 31 coincides coincide VBZ 19613 4752 32 with with IN 19613 4752 33 that that DT 19613 4752 34 of of IN 19613 4752 35 reason reason NN 19613 4752 36 , , , 19613 4752 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4752 38 is be VBZ 19613 4752 39 evident evident JJ 19613 4752 40 that that IN 19613 4752 41 the the DT 19613 4752 42 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4752 43 simply simply RB 19613 4752 44 took take VBD 19613 4752 45 the the DT 19613 4752 46 content content NN 19613 4752 47 of of IN 19613 4752 48 the the DT 19613 4752 49 latter latter JJ 19613 4752 50 for for IN 19613 4752 51 granted grant VBN 19613 4752 52 and and CC 19613 4752 53 stated state VBD 19613 4752 54 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4752 55 dogmatically dogmatically RB 19613 4752 56 . . . 19613 4753 1 So so CC 19613 4753 2 , , , 19613 4753 3 whether whether IN 19613 4753 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4753 5 expressed express VBD 19613 4753 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4753 7 in in IN 19613 4753 8 strictly strictly RB 19613 4753 9 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4753 10 fashion fashion NN 19613 4753 11 or or CC 19613 4753 12 not not RB 19613 4753 13 , , , 19613 4753 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4753 15 all all DT 19613 4753 16 essentially essentially RB 19613 4753 17 agree agree VBP 19613 4753 18 in in IN 19613 4753 19 the the DT 19613 4753 20 assumption assumption NN 19613 4753 21 that that IN 19613 4753 22 true true JJ 19613 4753 23 religion religion NN 19613 4753 24 and and CC 19613 4753 25 morality morality NN 19613 4753 26 are be VBP 19613 4753 27 the the DT 19613 4753 28 natural natural JJ 19613 4753 29 content content NN 19613 4753 30 of of IN 19613 4753 31 reason reason NN 19613 4753 32 . . . 19613 4754 1 Even even RB 19613 4754 2 Tatian tatian JJ 19613 4754 3 forms form NNS 19613 4754 4 no no DT 19613 4754 5 exception exception NN 19613 4754 6 , , , 19613 4754 7 though though IN 19613 4754 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4754 9 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4754 10 protests protest VBZ 19613 4754 11 against against IN 19613 4754 12 the the DT 19613 4754 13 idea idea NN 19613 4754 14 . . . 19613 4755 1 3 3 LS 19613 4755 2 . . . 19613 4756 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4756 2 The the DT 19613 4756 3 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4756 4 of of IN 19613 4756 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4756 6 as as IN 19613 4756 7 the the DT 19613 4756 8 revealed revealed JJ 19613 4756 9 and and CC 19613 4756 10 rational rational JJ 19613 4756 11 religion religion NN 19613 4756 12 . . . 19613 4756 13 _ _ NNP 19613 4756 14 The the DT 19613 4756 15 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4756 16 frequently frequently RB 19613 4756 17 spoke speak VBD 19613 4756 18 of of IN 19613 4756 19 the the DT 19613 4756 20 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4756 21 or or CC 19613 4756 22 " " `` 19613 4756 23 dogmas dogmas FW 19613 4756 24 " " '' 19613 4756 25 of of IN 19613 4756 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4756 27 ; ; : 19613 4756 28 and and CC 19613 4756 29 the the DT 19613 4756 30 whole whole JJ 19613 4756 31 content content NN 19613 4756 32 of of IN 19613 4756 33 this this DT 19613 4756 34 religion religion NN 19613 4756 35 as as IN 19613 4756 36 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4756 37 is be VBZ 19613 4756 38 included include VBN 19613 4756 39 in in IN 19613 4756 40 these these DT 19613 4756 41 dogmas dogma NNS 19613 4756 42 . . . 19613 4757 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4757 2 418 418 CD 19613 4757 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4757 4 According accord VBG 19613 4757 5 to to IN 19613 4757 6 what what WP 19613 4757 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4757 8 have have VBP 19613 4757 9 already already RB 19613 4757 10 set set VBN 19613 4757 11 forth forth RB 19613 4757 12 there there EX 19613 4757 13 can can MD 19613 4757 14 be be VB 19613 4757 15 no no DT 19613 4757 16 doubt doubt NN 19613 4757 17 about about IN 19613 4757 18 the the DT 19613 4757 19 character character NN 19613 4757 20 of of IN 19613 4757 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 4757 22 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 4757 23 . . . 19613 4758 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4758 2 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4758 3 are be VBP 19613 4758 4 the the DT 19613 4758 5 rational rational JJ 19613 4758 6 truths truth NNS 19613 4758 7 , , , 19613 4758 8 revealed reveal VBN 19613 4758 9 by by IN 19613 4758 10 the the DT 19613 4758 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4758 12 in in IN 19613 4758 13 the the DT 19613 4758 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 4758 15 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 4758 16 , , , 19613 4758 17 and and CC 19613 4758 18 summarised summarise VBD 19613 4758 19 in in IN 19613 4758 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4758 21 _ _ NNP 19613 4758 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4758 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4758 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4758 25 : : : 19613 4758 26 christos christos NNP 19613 4758 27 logos logos NNP 19613 4758 28 kai kai NNP 19613 4758 29 nomos nomos NNP 19613 4758 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4758 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4758 32 , , , 19613 4758 33 _ _ NNP 19613 4758 34 which which WDT 19613 4758 35 in in IN 19613 4758 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4758 37 unity unity NN 19613 4758 38 represent represent VBP 19613 4758 39 the the DT 19613 4758 40 divine divine JJ 19613 4758 41 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4758 42 , , , 19613 4758 43 and and CC 19613 4758 44 the the DT 19613 4758 45 recognition recognition NN 19613 4758 46 of of IN 19613 4758 47 which which WDT 19613 4758 48 leads lead VBZ 19613 4758 49 to to TO 19613 4758 50 virtue virtue VB 19613 4758 51 and and CC 19613 4758 52 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4758 53 life life NN 19613 4758 54 . . . 19613 4758 55 _ _ NNP 19613 4758 56 The the DT 19613 4758 57 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4758 58 considered consider VBD 19613 4758 59 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4758 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4758 61 chief chief JJ 19613 4758 62 task task NN 19613 4758 63 to to TO 19613 4758 64 set set VB 19613 4758 65 forth forth RP 19613 4758 66 these these DT 19613 4758 67 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4758 68 , , , 19613 4758 69 and and CC 19613 4758 70 hence hence RB 19613 4758 71 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4758 72 can can MD 19613 4758 73 be be VB 19613 4758 74 reproduced reproduce VBN 19613 4758 75 with with IN 19613 4758 76 all all DT 19613 4758 77 desirable desirable JJ 19613 4758 78 clearness clearness NN 19613 4758 79 . . . 19613 4759 1 The the DT 19613 4759 2 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 4759 3 scheme scheme NN 19613 4759 4 of of IN 19613 4759 5 the the DT 19613 4759 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4759 7 may may MD 19613 4759 8 therefore therefore RB 19613 4759 9 be be VB 19613 4759 10 divided divide VBN 19613 4759 11 into into IN 19613 4759 12 three three CD 19613 4759 13 component component NN 19613 4759 14 parts part NNS 19613 4759 15 . . . 19613 4760 1 These these DT 19613 4760 2 are be VBP 19613 4760 3 : : : 19613 4760 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4760 5 A a NN 19613 4760 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4760 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4760 8 viewed view VBD 19613 4760 9 as as IN 19613 4760 10 monotheistic monotheistic JJ 19613 4760 11 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4760 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4760 13 God God NNP 19613 4760 14 as as IN 19613 4760 15 the the DT 19613 4760 16 Father Father NNP 19613 4760 17 of of IN 19613 4760 18 the the DT 19613 4760 19 world world NN 19613 4760 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4760 21 ; ; , 19613 4760 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4760 23 B b NN 19613 4760 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4760 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4760 26 as as IN 19613 4760 27 the the DT 19613 4760 28 highest high JJS 19613 4760 29 morality morality NN 19613 4760 30 and and CC 19613 4760 31 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4760 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4760 33 God God NNP 19613 4760 34 as as IN 19613 4760 35 the the DT 19613 4760 36 judge judge NN 19613 4760 37 who who WP 19613 4760 38 rewards reward VBZ 19613 4760 39 goodness goodness NN 19613 4760 40 and and CC 19613 4760 41 punishes punish VBZ 19613 4760 42 wickedness wickedness NN 19613 4760 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4760 44 ; ; : 19613 4760 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4760 46 C C NNP 19613 4760 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4760 48 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4760 49 regarded regard VBD 19613 4760 50 as as IN 19613 4760 51 redemption redemption NN 19613 4760 52 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4760 53 God God NNP 19613 4760 54 as as IN 19613 4760 55 the the DT 19613 4760 56 Good Good NNP 19613 4760 57 One One NNP 19613 4760 58 who who WP 19613 4760 59 assists assist VBZ 19613 4760 60 man man VBP 19613 4760 61 and and CC 19613 4760 62 rescues rescue VBZ 19613 4760 63 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4760 64 from from IN 19613 4760 65 the the DT 19613 4760 66 power power NN 19613 4760 67 of of IN 19613 4760 68 the the DT 19613 4760 69 demons demon NNS 19613 4760 70 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4760 71 . . . 19613 4761 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4761 2 419 419 CD 19613 4761 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4761 4 Whilst whilst IN 19613 4761 5 the the DT 19613 4761 6 first first JJ 19613 4761 7 two two CD 19613 4761 8 ideas idea NNS 19613 4761 9 are be VBP 19613 4761 10 expressed express VBN 19613 4761 11 in in IN 19613 4761 12 a a DT 19613 4761 13 clear clear JJ 19613 4761 14 and and CC 19613 4761 15 precise precise JJ 19613 4761 16 manner manner NN 19613 4761 17 , , , 19613 4761 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4761 19 is be VBZ 19613 4761 20 equally equally RB 19613 4761 21 true true JJ 19613 4761 22 that that IN 19613 4761 23 the the DT 19613 4761 24 third third JJ 19613 4761 25 is be VBZ 19613 4761 26 not not RB 19613 4761 27 worked work VBN 19613 4761 28 out out RP 19613 4761 29 in in IN 19613 4761 30 a a DT 19613 4761 31 lucid lucid JJ 19613 4761 32 fashion fashion NN 19613 4761 33 . . . 19613 4762 1 This this DT 19613 4762 2 , , , 19613 4762 3 as as IN 19613 4762 4 will will MD 19613 4762 5 afterwards afterwards RB 19613 4762 6 be be VB 19613 4762 7 seen see VBN 19613 4762 8 , , , 19613 4762 9 is be VBZ 19613 4762 10 , , , 19613 4762 11 on on IN 19613 4762 12 the the DT 19613 4762 13 one one CD 19613 4762 14 hand hand NN 19613 4762 15 , , , 19613 4762 16 the the DT 19613 4762 17 result result NN 19613 4762 18 of of IN 19613 4762 19 the the DT 19613 4762 20 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4762 21 ' ' POS 19613 4762 22 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4762 23 of of IN 19613 4762 24 freedom freedom NN 19613 4762 25 , , , 19613 4762 26 and and CC 19613 4762 27 , , , 19613 4762 28 on on IN 19613 4762 29 the the DT 19613 4762 30 other other JJ 19613 4762 31 , , , 19613 4762 32 of of IN 19613 4762 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4762 34 inability inability NN 19613 4762 35 to to TO 19613 4762 36 discover discover VB 19613 4762 37 a a DT 19613 4762 38 specific specific JJ 19613 4762 39 significance significance NN 19613 4762 40 for for IN 19613 4762 41 the the DT 19613 4762 42 _ _ NNP 19613 4762 43 person person NN 19613 4762 44 _ _ XX 19613 4762 45 of of IN 19613 4762 46 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4762 47 within within IN 19613 4762 48 the the DT 19613 4762 49 sphere sphere NN 19613 4762 50 of of IN 19613 4762 51 revelation revelation NN 19613 4762 52 . . . 19613 4763 1 Both both DT 19613 4763 2 facts fact NNS 19613 4763 3 again again RB 19613 4763 4 are be VBP 19613 4763 5 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 4763 6 to to TO 19613 4763 7 be be VB 19613 4763 8 explained explain VBN 19613 4763 9 from from IN 19613 4763 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4763 11 moralism moralism NN 19613 4763 12 . . . 19613 4764 1 The the DT 19613 4764 2 essential essential JJ 19613 4764 3 content content NN 19613 4764 4 of of IN 19613 4764 5 revealed reveal VBN 19613 4764 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4764 7 is be VBZ 19613 4764 8 viewed view VBN 19613 4764 9 by by IN 19613 4764 10 the the DT 19613 4764 11 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4764 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4764 13 see see VB 19613 4764 14 A a NN 19613 4764 15 , , , 19613 4764 16 B b NN 19613 4764 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4764 18 as as IN 19613 4764 19 comprised comprise VBN 19613 4764 20 in in IN 19613 4764 21 three three CD 19613 4764 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4764 23 . . . 19613 4765 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4765 2 420 420 CD 19613 4765 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4765 4 First first RB 19613 4765 5 , , , 19613 4765 6 there there EX 19613 4765 7 is be VBZ 19613 4765 8 one one CD 19613 4765 9 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4765 10 and and CC 19613 4765 11 inexpressibly inexpressibly RB 19613 4765 12 exalted exalt VBD 19613 4765 13 God God NNP 19613 4765 14 , , , 19613 4765 15 who who WP 19613 4765 16 is be VBZ 19613 4765 17 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4765 18 and and CC 19613 4765 19 Father Father NNP 19613 4765 20 of of IN 19613 4765 21 the the DT 19613 4765 22 world world NN 19613 4765 23 . . . 19613 4766 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 4766 2 , , , 19613 4766 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4766 4 requires require VBZ 19613 4766 5 a a DT 19613 4766 6 holy holy JJ 19613 4766 7 life life NN 19613 4766 8 . . . 19613 4767 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 4767 2 , , , 19613 4767 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4767 4 will will MD 19613 4767 5 at at IN 19613 4767 6 last last JJ 19613 4767 7 sit sit NN 19613 4767 8 in in IN 19613 4767 9 judgment judgment NN 19613 4767 10 , , , 19613 4767 11 and and CC 19613 4767 12 will will MD 19613 4767 13 reward reward VB 19613 4767 14 the the DT 19613 4767 15 good good NN 19613 4767 16 with with IN 19613 4767 17 immortality immortality NN 19613 4767 18 and and CC 19613 4767 19 punish punish VB 19613 4767 20 the the DT 19613 4767 21 wicked wicked JJ 19613 4767 22 with with IN 19613 4767 23 death death NN 19613 4767 24 . . . 19613 4768 1 The the DT 19613 4768 2 teaching teaching NN 19613 4768 3 concerning concern VBG 19613 4768 4 God God NNP 19613 4768 5 , , , 19613 4768 6 virtue virtue NN 19613 4768 7 , , , 19613 4768 8 and and CC 19613 4768 9 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4768 10 reward reward NN 19613 4768 11 is be VBZ 19613 4768 12 traced trace VBN 19613 4768 13 to to IN 19613 4768 14 the the DT 19613 4768 15 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4768 16 and and CC 19613 4768 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4768 18 ; ; : 19613 4768 19 but but CC 19613 4768 20 the the DT 19613 4768 21 bringing bringing NN 19613 4768 22 about about IN 19613 4768 23 of of IN 19613 4768 24 a a DT 19613 4768 25 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4768 26 life life NN 19613 4768 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4768 28 of of IN 19613 4768 29 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4768 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4768 31 has have VBZ 19613 4768 32 been be VBN 19613 4768 33 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 4768 34 left leave VBN 19613 4768 35 by by IN 19613 4768 36 God God NNP 19613 4768 37 to to IN 19613 4768 38 men man NNS 19613 4768 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4768 40 ; ; : 19613 4768 41 for for IN 19613 4768 42 God God NNP 19613 4768 43 has have VBZ 19613 4768 44 created create VBN 19613 4768 45 man man NN 19613 4768 46 free free JJ 19613 4768 47 , , , 19613 4768 48 and and CC 19613 4768 49 virtue virtue NN 19613 4768 50 can can MD 19613 4768 51 only only RB 19613 4768 52 be be VB 19613 4768 53 acquired acquire VBN 19613 4768 54 by by IN 19613 4768 55 man man NN 19613 4768 56 's 's POS 19613 4768 57 own own JJ 19613 4768 58 efforts effort NNS 19613 4768 59 . . . 19613 4769 1 The the DT 19613 4769 2 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4769 3 and and CC 19613 4769 4 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4769 5 are be VBP 19613 4769 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 4769 7 a a DT 19613 4769 8 source source NN 19613 4769 9 of of IN 19613 4769 10 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4769 11 in in IN 19613 4769 12 so so RB 19613 4769 13 far far RB 19613 4769 14 as as IN 19613 4769 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4769 16 are be VBP 19613 4769 17 teachers teacher NNS 19613 4769 18 . . . 19613 4770 1 But but CC 19613 4770 2 as as IN 19613 4770 3 God God NNP 19613 4770 4 , , , 19613 4770 5 that that RB 19613 4770 6 is is RB 19613 4770 7 , , , 19613 4770 8 the the DT 19613 4770 9 divine divine JJ 19613 4770 10 Word Word NNP 19613 4770 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4770 12 which which WDT 19613 4770 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4770 14 need need VBP 19613 4770 15 not not RB 19613 4770 16 here here RB 19613 4770 17 discuss discuss VB 19613 4770 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4770 19 has have VBZ 19613 4770 20 spoken speak VBN 19613 4770 21 in in IN 19613 4770 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4770 23 , , , 19613 4770 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4770 25 is be VBZ 19613 4770 26 to to TO 19613 4770 27 be be VB 19613 4770 28 defined define VBN 19613 4770 29 as as IN 19613 4770 30 the the DT 19613 4770 31 Knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4770 32 of of IN 19613 4770 33 God God NNP 19613 4770 34 , , , 19613 4770 35 mediated mediate VBN 19613 4770 36 by by IN 19613 4770 37 the the DT 19613 4770 38 Deity Deity NNP 19613 4770 39 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4770 40 , , , 19613 4770 41 and and CC 19613 4770 42 as as IN 19613 4770 43 a a DT 19613 4770 44 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4770 45 walk walk NN 19613 4770 46 in in IN 19613 4770 47 the the DT 19613 4770 48 longing longing NN 19613 4770 49 after after IN 19613 4770 50 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4770 51 and and CC 19613 4770 52 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4770 53 life life NN 19613 4770 54 with with IN 19613 4770 55 God God NNP 19613 4770 56 , , , 19613 4770 57 as as RB 19613 4770 58 well well RB 19613 4770 59 as as IN 19613 4770 60 in in IN 19613 4770 61 the the DT 19613 4770 62 sure sure JJ 19613 4770 63 hope hope NN 19613 4770 64 of of IN 19613 4770 65 this this DT 19613 4770 66 imperishable imperishable JJ 19613 4770 67 reward reward NN 19613 4770 68 . . . 19613 4771 1 By by IN 19613 4771 2 knowing know VBG 19613 4771 3 what what WP 19613 4771 4 is be VBZ 19613 4771 5 true true JJ 19613 4771 6 and and CC 19613 4771 7 doing do VBG 19613 4771 8 what what WP 19613 4771 9 is be VBZ 19613 4771 10 good good JJ 19613 4771 11 man man NN 19613 4771 12 becomes become VBZ 19613 4771 13 righteous righteous JJ 19613 4771 14 and and CC 19613 4771 15 a a DT 19613 4771 16 partaker partaker NN 19613 4771 17 of of IN 19613 4771 18 the the DT 19613 4771 19 highest high JJS 19613 4771 20 bliss bliss NN 19613 4771 21 . . . 19613 4772 1 This this DT 19613 4772 2 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4772 3 , , , 19613 4772 4 which which WDT 19613 4772 5 has have VBZ 19613 4772 6 the the DT 19613 4772 7 character character NN 19613 4772 8 of of IN 19613 4772 9 divine divine JJ 19613 4772 10 instruction,[421 instruction,[421 NNP 19613 4772 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4772 12 rests rest NNS 19613 4772 13 on on IN 19613 4772 14 faith faith NN 19613 4772 15 in in IN 19613 4772 16 the the DT 19613 4772 17 divine divine JJ 19613 4772 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 4772 19 . . . 19613 4773 1 This this DT 19613 4773 2 revelation revelation NN 19613 4773 3 has have VBZ 19613 4773 4 the the DT 19613 4773 5 nature nature NN 19613 4773 6 and and CC 19613 4773 7 power power NN 19613 4773 8 of of IN 19613 4773 9 redemption redemption NN 19613 4773 10 in in IN 19613 4773 11 so so RB 19613 4773 12 far far RB 19613 4773 13 as as IN 19613 4773 14 the the DT 19613 4773 15 fact fact NN 19613 4773 16 is be VBZ 19613 4773 17 undoubted undoubted JJ 19613 4773 18 that that IN 19613 4773 19 without without IN 19613 4773 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4773 21 men man NNS 19613 4773 22 can can MD 19613 4773 23 not not RB 19613 4773 24 free free VB 19613 4773 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4773 26 from from IN 19613 4773 27 the the DT 19613 4773 28 tyranny tyranny NN 19613 4773 29 of of IN 19613 4773 30 the the DT 19613 4773 31 demons demon NNS 19613 4773 32 , , , 19613 4773 33 whilst whilst IN 19613 4773 34 believers believer NNS 19613 4773 35 in in IN 19613 4773 36 revelation revelation NN 19613 4773 37 are be VBP 19613 4773 38 enabled enable VBN 19613 4773 39 by by IN 19613 4773 40 the the DT 19613 4773 41 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4773 42 of of IN 19613 4773 43 God God NNP 19613 4773 44 to to TO 19613 4773 45 put put VB 19613 4773 46 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4773 47 to to IN 19613 4773 48 flight flight NN 19613 4773 49 . . . 19613 4774 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4774 2 , , , 19613 4774 3 the the DT 19613 4774 4 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 4774 5 of of IN 19613 4774 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 4774 7 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4774 8 theoretically theoretically RB 19613 4774 9 contain contain VBP 19613 4774 10 the the DT 19613 4774 11 monotheistic monotheistic JJ 19613 4774 12 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4774 13 , , , 19613 4774 14 and and CC 19613 4774 15 practically practically RB 19613 4774 16 the the DT 19613 4774 17 rules rule NNS 19613 4774 18 for for IN 19613 4774 19 a a DT 19613 4774 20 holy holy JJ 19613 4774 21 life life NN 19613 4774 22 , , , 19613 4774 23 which which WDT 19613 4774 24 appears appear VBZ 19613 4774 25 as as IN 19613 4774 26 a a DT 19613 4774 27 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 4774 28 of of IN 19613 4774 29 the the DT 19613 4774 30 world world NN 19613 4774 31 and and CC 19613 4774 32 as as IN 19613 4774 33 a a DT 19613 4774 34 new new JJ 19613 4774 35 order order NN 19613 4774 36 of of IN 19613 4774 37 society society NN 19613 4774 38 . . . 19613 4775 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4775 2 422 422 CD 19613 4775 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4775 4 The the DT 19613 4775 5 goal goal NN 19613 4775 6 is be VBZ 19613 4775 7 immortal immortal JJ 19613 4775 8 life life NN 19613 4775 9 , , , 19613 4775 10 which which WDT 19613 4775 11 consists consist VBZ 19613 4775 12 in in IN 19613 4775 13 the the DT 19613 4775 14 full full JJ 19613 4775 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4775 16 and and CC 19613 4775 17 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 4775 18 of of IN 19613 4775 19 God God NNP 19613 4775 20 . . . 19613 4776 1 The the DT 19613 4776 2 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 4776 3 of of IN 19613 4776 4 revelation revelation NN 19613 4776 5 lie lie NN 19613 4776 6 between between IN 19613 4776 7 the the DT 19613 4776 8 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4776 9 and and CC 19613 4776 10 ethics ethic NNS 19613 4776 11 ; ; : 19613 4776 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4776 13 are be VBP 19613 4776 14 indefinitely indefinitely RB 19613 4776 15 expressed express VBN 19613 4776 16 so so RB 19613 4776 17 far far RB 19613 4776 18 as as IN 19613 4776 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4776 20 contain contain VBP 19613 4776 21 the the DT 19613 4776 22 idea idea NN 19613 4776 23 of of IN 19613 4776 24 salvation salvation NN 19613 4776 25 ; ; : 19613 4776 26 but but CC 19613 4776 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4776 28 are be VBP 19613 4776 29 very very RB 19613 4776 30 precisely precisely RB 19613 4776 31 worded word VBN 19613 4776 32 in in RP 19613 4776 33 so so RB 19613 4776 34 far far RB 19613 4776 35 as as IN 19613 4776 36 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4776 37 guarantee guarantee VBP 19613 4776 38 the the DT 19613 4776 39 truth truth NN 19613 4776 40 of of IN 19613 4776 41 the the DT 19613 4776 42 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4776 43 and and CC 19613 4776 44 ethics ethic NNS 19613 4776 45 . . . 19613 4777 1 1 1 LS 19613 4777 2 . . . 19613 4778 1 The the DT 19613 4778 2 dogmas dogma NNS 19613 4778 3 which which WDT 19613 4778 4 express express VBP 19613 4778 5 the the DT 19613 4778 6 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4778 7 of of IN 19613 4778 8 God God NNP 19613 4778 9 and and CC 19613 4778 10 the the DT 19613 4778 11 world world NN 19613 4778 12 are be VBP 19613 4778 13 dominated dominate VBN 19613 4778 14 by by IN 19613 4778 15 the the DT 19613 4778 16 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4778 17 idea idea NN 19613 4778 18 that that IN 19613 4778 19 the the DT 19613 4778 20 world world NN 19613 4778 21 as as IN 19613 4778 22 the the DT 19613 4778 23 created create VBN 19613 4778 24 , , , 19613 4778 25 conditioned condition VBD 19613 4778 26 , , , 19613 4778 27 and and CC 19613 4778 28 transient transient NN 19613 4778 29 is be VBZ 19613 4778 30 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 4778 31 with with IN 19613 4778 32 something something NN 19613 4778 33 self self NN 19613 4778 34 - - HYPH 19613 4778 35 existing exist VBG 19613 4778 36 , , , 19613 4778 37 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 4778 38 and and CC 19613 4778 39 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4778 40 , , , 19613 4778 41 which which WDT 19613 4778 42 is be VBZ 19613 4778 43 the the DT 19613 4778 44 first first JJ 19613 4778 45 cause cause NN 19613 4778 46 of of IN 19613 4778 47 the the DT 19613 4778 48 world world NN 19613 4778 49 . . . 19613 4779 1 This this DT 19613 4779 2 self self NN 19613 4779 3 - - HYPH 19613 4779 4 existing exist VBG 19613 4779 5 Being being NN 19613 4779 6 has have VBZ 19613 4779 7 none none NN 19613 4779 8 of of IN 19613 4779 9 the the DT 19613 4779 10 attributes attribute NNS 19613 4779 11 which which WDT 19613 4779 12 belong belong VBP 19613 4779 13 to to IN 19613 4779 14 the the DT 19613 4779 15 world world NN 19613 4779 16 ; ; : 19613 4779 17 hence hence RB 19613 4779 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4779 19 is be VBZ 19613 4779 20 exalted exalted JJ 19613 4779 21 above above IN 19613 4779 22 every every DT 19613 4779 23 name name NN 19613 4779 24 and and CC 19613 4779 25 has have VBZ 19613 4779 26 in in IN 19613 4779 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4779 28 no no DT 19613 4779 29 distinctions distinction NNS 19613 4779 30 . . . 19613 4780 1 This this DT 19613 4780 2 implies imply VBZ 19613 4780 3 , , , 19613 4780 4 first first RB 19613 4780 5 , , , 19613 4780 6 the the DT 19613 4780 7 unity unity NN 19613 4780 8 and and CC 19613 4780 9 uniqueness uniqueness NN 19613 4780 10 of of IN 19613 4780 11 this this DT 19613 4780 12 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4780 13 Being being NN 19613 4780 14 ; ; : 19613 4780 15 secondly secondly RB 19613 4780 16 , , , 19613 4780 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4780 18 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4780 19 nature nature NN 19613 4780 20 , , , 19613 4780 21 for for IN 19613 4780 22 everything everything NN 19613 4780 23 bodily bodily RB 19613 4780 24 is be VBZ 19613 4780 25 subject subject JJ 19613 4780 26 to to IN 19613 4780 27 change change NN 19613 4780 28 ; ; : 19613 4780 29 and and CC 19613 4780 30 , , , 19613 4780 31 finally finally RB 19613 4780 32 , , , 19613 4780 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4780 34 perfection perfection NN 19613 4780 35 , , , 19613 4780 36 for for IN 19613 4780 37 the the DT 19613 4780 38 self self NN 19613 4780 39 - - HYPH 19613 4780 40 existent existent NN 19613 4780 41 and and CC 19613 4780 42 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4780 43 requires require VBZ 19613 4780 44 nothing nothing NN 19613 4780 45 . . . 19613 4781 1 Since since IN 19613 4781 2 , , , 19613 4781 3 however however RB 19613 4781 4 , , , 19613 4781 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4781 6 is be VBZ 19613 4781 7 the the DT 19613 4781 8 cause cause NN 19613 4781 9 of of IN 19613 4781 10 all all DT 19613 4781 11 being be VBG 19613 4781 12 , , , 19613 4781 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4781 14 being be VBG 19613 4781 15 unconditioned unconditioned JJ 19613 4781 16 , , , 19613 4781 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4781 18 is be VBZ 19613 4781 19 the the DT 19613 4781 20 fulness fulness NN 19613 4781 21 of of IN 19613 4781 22 all all DT 19613 4781 23 being be VBG 19613 4781 24 or or CC 19613 4781 25 true true JJ 19613 4781 26 being be VBG 19613 4781 27 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4781 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4781 29 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4781 30 5 5 CD 19613 4781 31 : : : 19613 4781 32 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4781 33 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4781 34 : : : 19613 4781 35 katho katho NNP 19613 4781 36 pasa pasa NNP 19613 4781 37 dunamis dunamis NNP 19613 4781 38 oratôn oratôn NNP 19613 4781 39 te te NNP 19613 4781 40 kai kai NNP 19613 4781 41 aoratôn aoratôn NNP 19613 4781 42 autos autos NNPS 19613 4781 43 hupostasis hupostasis NNP 19613 4781 44 ên ên NNP 19613 4781 45 , , , 19613 4781 46 sun sun NNP 19613 4781 47 autô autô NNP 19613 4781 48 ta ta NNP 19613 4781 49 panta panta NNP 19613 4781 50 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4781 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4781 52 . . . 19613 4782 1 As as IN 19613 4782 2 the the DT 19613 4782 3 living live VBG 19613 4782 4 and and CC 19613 4782 5 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4782 6 Being being NN 19613 4782 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4782 8 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 4782 9 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4782 10 in in IN 19613 4782 11 free free JJ 19613 4782 12 creations creation NNS 19613 4782 13 , , , 19613 4782 14 which which WDT 19613 4782 15 make make VBP 19613 4782 16 known know VBN 19613 4782 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4782 18 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 4782 19 and and CC 19613 4782 20 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 4782 21 , , , 19613 4782 22 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4782 23 , , , 19613 4782 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4782 25 operative operative JJ 19613 4782 26 reason reason NN 19613 4782 27 . . . 19613 4783 1 These these DT 19613 4783 2 creations creation NNS 19613 4783 3 are be VBP 19613 4783 4 , , , 19613 4783 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 4783 6 , , , 19613 4783 7 a a DT 19613 4783 8 proof proof NN 19613 4783 9 of of IN 19613 4783 10 the the DT 19613 4783 11 goodness goodness NN 19613 4783 12 of of IN 19613 4783 13 the the DT 19613 4783 14 Deity Deity NNP 19613 4783 15 , , , 19613 4783 16 for for IN 19613 4783 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4783 18 can can MD 19613 4783 19 be be VB 19613 4783 20 no no DT 19613 4783 21 result result NN 19613 4783 22 of of IN 19613 4783 23 necessities necessity NNS 19613 4783 24 , , , 19613 4783 25 in in IN 19613 4783 26 so so RB 19613 4783 27 far far RB 19613 4783 28 as as IN 19613 4783 29 God God NNP 19613 4783 30 is be VBZ 19613 4783 31 in in IN 19613 4783 32 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4783 33 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4783 34 . . . 19613 4784 1 Just just RB 19613 4784 2 because because IN 19613 4784 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4784 4 is be VBZ 19613 4784 5 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4784 6 , , , 19613 4784 7 the the DT 19613 4784 8 Eternal Eternal NNP 19613 4784 9 Essence Essence NNP 19613 4784 10 is be VBZ 19613 4784 11 also also RB 19613 4784 12 the the DT 19613 4784 13 Father Father NNP 19613 4784 14 of of IN 19613 4784 15 all all DT 19613 4784 16 virtues virtue NNS 19613 4784 17 , , , 19613 4784 18 in in IN 19613 4784 19 so so RB 19613 4784 20 far far RB 19613 4784 21 as as IN 19613 4784 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4784 23 contains contain VBZ 19613 4784 24 no no DT 19613 4784 25 admixture admixture NN 19613 4784 26 of of IN 19613 4784 27 what what WP 19613 4784 28 is be VBZ 19613 4784 29 defective defective JJ 19613 4784 30 . . . 19613 4785 1 These these DT 19613 4785 2 virtues virtue NNS 19613 4785 3 include include VBP 19613 4785 4 both both CC 19613 4785 5 the the DT 19613 4785 6 goodness goodness NN 19613 4785 7 which which WDT 19613 4785 8 manifests manifest VBZ 19613 4785 9 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4785 10 in in IN 19613 4785 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4785 12 creations creation NNS 19613 4785 13 , , , 19613 4785 14 and and CC 19613 4785 15 the the DT 19613 4785 16 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4785 17 which which WDT 19613 4785 18 gives give VBZ 19613 4785 19 to to IN 19613 4785 20 the the DT 19613 4785 21 creature creature NN 19613 4785 22 what what WP 19613 4785 23 belongs belong VBZ 19613 4785 24 to to IN 19613 4785 25 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4785 26 , , , 19613 4785 27 in in IN 19613 4785 28 accordance accordance NN 19613 4785 29 with with IN 19613 4785 30 the the DT 19613 4785 31 position position NN 19613 4785 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4785 33 has have VBZ 19613 4785 34 received receive VBN 19613 4785 35 . . . 19613 4786 1 On on IN 19613 4786 2 the the DT 19613 4786 3 basis basis NN 19613 4786 4 of of IN 19613 4786 5 this this DT 19613 4786 6 train train NN 19613 4786 7 of of IN 19613 4786 8 thought thought NN 19613 4786 9 the the DT 19613 4786 10 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4786 11 lay lie VBD 19613 4786 12 down down RP 19613 4786 13 the the DT 19613 4786 14 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 4786 15 of of IN 19613 4786 16 the the DT 19613 4786 17 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 4786 18 of of IN 19613 4786 19 God God NNP 19613 4786 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4786 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4786 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4786 23 : : : 19613 4786 24 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4786 25 holôn holôn NNP 19613 4786 26 to to IN 19613 4786 27 monarchikon monarchikon NNP 19613 4786 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4786 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4786 30 , , , 19613 4786 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4786 32 supramundaneness supramundaneness NN 19613 4786 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4786 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4786 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4786 36 : : : 19613 4786 37 to to TO 19613 4786 38 arrêton arrêton NNP 19613 4786 39 , , , 19613 4786 40 to to IN 19613 4786 41 anekphraston anekphraston NNP 19613 4786 42 , , , 19613 4786 43 to to IN 19613 4786 44 achôrêton achôrêton NNP 19613 4786 45 , , , 19613 4786 46 to to IN 19613 4786 47 akatalêpton akatalêpton NNP 19613 4786 48 , , , 19613 4786 49 to to IN 19613 4786 50 aperinoêton aperinoêton NNP 19613 4786 51 , , , 19613 4786 52 to to IN 19613 4786 53 asugkriton asugkriton NNP 19613 4786 54 , , , 19613 4786 55 to to IN 19613 4786 56 asymbibaston asymbibaston NNP 19613 4786 57 , , , 19613 4786 58 to to IN 19613 4786 59 anekdiêgêton anekdiêgêton NNP 19613 4786 60 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4786 61 ; ; : 19613 4786 62 see see VB 19613 4786 63 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4786 64 , , , 19613 4786 65 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4786 66 . . . 19613 4787 1 II ii CD 19613 4787 2 . . . 19613 4788 1 6 6 LS 19613 4788 2 ; ; : 19613 4788 3 Theoph Theoph NNS 19613 4788 4 . . . 19613 4789 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4790 1 3 3 LS 19613 4790 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 3 ; ; : 19613 4790 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 5 unity unity NN 19613 4790 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 9 : : : 19613 4790 10 eis eis NNP 19613 4790 11 Theos Theos NNP 19613 4790 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 14 ; ; : 19613 4790 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 16 having have VBG 19613 4790 17 no no DT 19613 4790 18 beginning beginning NN 19613 4790 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 22 : : : 19613 4790 23 anarchos anarchos NNP 19613 4790 24 , , , 19613 4790 25 hoti hoti NNP 19613 4790 26 agenêtos agenêtos NNP 19613 4790 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 29 ; ; : 19613 4790 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 31 eternity eternity NN 19613 4790 32 and and CC 19613 4790 33 unchangeableness unchangeableness NN 19613 4790 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 37 : : : 19613 4790 38 analloiôtos analloiôtos NNP 19613 4790 39 kathoti kathoti NNP 19613 4790 40 athanatos athanatos NNP 19613 4790 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 43 ; ; : 19613 4790 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 45 perfection perfection NN 19613 4790 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 47 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 48 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 49 : : : 19613 4790 50 teleios teleio NNS 19613 4790 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 52 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 53 ; ; : 19613 4790 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 55 need need NN 19613 4790 56 of of IN 19613 4790 57 nothing nothing NN 19613 4790 58 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 59 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 60 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 61 : : : 19613 4790 62 aprosdeês aprosdeês NNP 19613 4790 63 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 64 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 65 ; ; : 19613 4790 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 67 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4790 68 nature nature NN 19613 4790 69 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 70 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 71 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 72 : : : 19613 4790 73 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 4790 74 ho ho NNP 19613 4790 75 Theos Theos NNP 19613 4790 76 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 77 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 78 ; ; : 19613 4790 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 80 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4790 81 causality causality NN 19613 4790 82 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 83 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 84 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 85 : : : 19613 4790 86 autos auto NNS 19613 4790 87 hyparchôn hyparchôn NNP 19613 4790 88 tou tou NNP 19613 4790 89 pantos pantos NNP 19613 4790 90 hê hê NNP 19613 4790 91 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 4790 92 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 93 , , , 19613 4790 94 the the DT 19613 4790 95 motionless motionless JJ 19613 4790 96 mover mover NN 19613 4790 97 , , , 19613 4790 98 see see VB 19613 4790 99 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 4790 100 c. c. NN 19613 4790 101 1 1 CD 19613 4790 102 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 103 ; ; : 19613 4790 104 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 105 creative creative JJ 19613 4790 106 activity activity NN 19613 4790 107 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 108 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 109 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 110 : : : 19613 4790 111 ktistês ktistês NNP 19613 4790 112 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4790 113 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 4790 114 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 115 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 116 ; ; : 19613 4790 117 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 118 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4790 119 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 120 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 121 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 122 : : : 19613 4790 123 despotês despotês NNP 19613 4790 124 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4790 125 holôn holôn NNP 19613 4790 126 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 127 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 128 ; ; : 19613 4790 129 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 130 fatherhood fatherhood NN 19613 4790 131 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 132 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 133 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 134 : : : 19613 4790 135 patêr patêr NNP 19613 4790 136 dia dia NNP 19613 4790 137 to to IN 19613 4790 138 einai einai NNP 19613 4790 139 auton auton NNP 19613 4790 140 pro pro FW 19613 4790 141 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4790 142 holôn holôn NNP 19613 4790 143 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 144 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 145 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 146 reason reason NN 19613 4790 147 - - HYPH 19613 4790 148 power power NN 19613 4790 149 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 150 God God NNP 19613 4790 151 as as IN 19613 4790 152 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 153 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 154 : : : 19613 4790 155 logos logo NNS 19613 4790 156 , , , 19613 4790 157 nous nous JJ 19613 4790 158 , , , 19613 4790 159 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 4790 160 , , , 19613 4790 161 sophia sophia NNP 19613 4790 162 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 163 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 164 ; ; : 19613 4790 165 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 166 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 4790 167 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 168 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 169 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 170 : : : 19613 4790 171 pantokratôr pantokratôr NNP 19613 4790 172 hoti hoti NNP 19613 4790 173 autos auto NNS 19613 4790 174 ta ta NNP 19613 4790 175 panta panta NNP 19613 4790 176 kratei kratei NNP 19613 4790 177 kai kai NNP 19613 4790 178 emperiechei emperiechei NNP 19613 4790 179 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 180 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 181 ; ; : 19613 4790 182 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4790 183 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4790 184 and and CC 19613 4790 185 goodness goodness NN 19613 4790 186 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4790 187 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4790 188 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4790 189 : : : 19613 4790 190 patêr patêr NNP 19613 4790 191 tês tês NNP 19613 4790 192 dikaiosunês dikaiosunês NNP 19613 4790 193 kai kai NNP 19613 4790 194 pasôn pasôn NNP 19613 4790 195 tôn tôn NNP 19613 4790 196 aretôn aretôn NNP 19613 4790 197 chrêstotês chrêstotês NNP 19613 4790 198 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4790 199 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4790 200 . . . 19613 4791 1 These these DT 19613 4791 2 dogmas dogma NNS 19613 4791 3 are be VBP 19613 4791 4 set set VBN 19613 4791 5 forth forth RP 19613 4791 6 by by IN 19613 4791 7 one one CD 19613 4791 8 Apologist apologist NN 19613 4791 9 in in IN 19613 4791 10 a a DT 19613 4791 11 more more RBR 19613 4791 12 detailed detailed JJ 19613 4791 13 , , , 19613 4791 14 and and CC 19613 4791 15 by by IN 19613 4791 16 another another DT 19613 4791 17 in in IN 19613 4791 18 a a DT 19613 4791 19 more more RBR 19613 4791 20 concise concise JJ 19613 4791 21 form form NN 19613 4791 22 , , , 19613 4791 23 but but CC 19613 4791 24 three three CD 19613 4791 25 points point NNS 19613 4791 26 are be VBP 19613 4791 27 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 4791 28 by by IN 19613 4791 29 all all DT 19613 4791 30 . . . 19613 4792 1 First first RB 19613 4792 2 , , , 19613 4792 3 God God NNP 19613 4792 4 is be VBZ 19613 4792 5 primarily primarily RB 19613 4792 6 to to TO 19613 4792 7 be be VB 19613 4792 8 conceived conceive VBN 19613 4792 9 as as IN 19613 4792 10 the the DT 19613 4792 11 First First NNP 19613 4792 12 Cause Cause NNP 19613 4792 13 . . . 19613 4793 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 4793 2 , , , 19613 4793 3 the the DT 19613 4793 4 principle principle NN 19613 4793 5 of of IN 19613 4793 6 moral moral JJ 19613 4793 7 good good NN 19613 4793 8 is be VBZ 19613 4793 9 also also RB 19613 4793 10 the the DT 19613 4793 11 principle principle NN 19613 4793 12 of of IN 19613 4793 13 the the DT 19613 4793 14 world world NN 19613 4793 15 . . . 19613 4794 1 Thirdly thirdly RB 19613 4794 2 , , , 19613 4794 3 the the DT 19613 4794 4 principle principle NN 19613 4794 5 of of IN 19613 4794 6 the the DT 19613 4794 7 world world NN 19613 4794 8 , , , 19613 4794 9 that that RB 19613 4794 10 is is RB 19613 4794 11 , , , 19613 4794 12 the the DT 19613 4794 13 Deity Deity NNP 19613 4794 14 , , , 19613 4794 15 as as IN 19613 4794 16 being be VBG 19613 4794 17 the the DT 19613 4794 18 immortal immortal JJ 19613 4794 19 and and CC 19613 4794 20 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4794 21 , , , 19613 4794 22 forms form VBZ 19613 4794 23 the the DT 19613 4794 24 contrast contrast NN 19613 4794 25 to to IN 19613 4794 26 the the DT 19613 4794 27 world world NN 19613 4794 28 which which WDT 19613 4794 29 is be VBZ 19613 4794 30 the the DT 19613 4794 31 transient transient NN 19613 4794 32 . . . 19613 4795 1 In in IN 19613 4795 2 the the DT 19613 4795 3 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4795 4 of of IN 19613 4795 5 the the DT 19613 4795 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4795 7 the the DT 19613 4795 8 two two CD 19613 4795 9 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4795 10 ideas idea NNS 19613 4795 11 are be VBP 19613 4795 12 that that IN 19613 4795 13 God God NNP 19613 4795 14 is be VBZ 19613 4795 15 the the DT 19613 4795 16 Father Father NNP 19613 4795 17 and and CC 19613 4795 18 Creator Creator NNP 19613 4795 19 of of IN 19613 4795 20 the the DT 19613 4795 21 world world NN 19613 4795 22 , , , 19613 4795 23 but but CC 19613 4795 24 that that IN 19613 4795 25 , , , 19613 4795 26 as as IN 19613 4795 27 uncreated uncreated JJ 19613 4795 28 and and CC 19613 4795 29 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4795 30 , , , 19613 4795 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4795 32 is be VBZ 19613 4795 33 also also RB 19613 4795 34 the the DT 19613 4795 35 complete complete JJ 19613 4795 36 contrast contrast NN 19613 4795 37 to to IN 19613 4795 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4795 39 . . . 19613 4796 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4796 2 423 423 CD 19613 4796 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4796 4 These these DT 19613 4796 5 dogmas dogma NNS 19613 4796 6 about about IN 19613 4796 7 God God NNP 19613 4796 8 were be VBD 19613 4796 9 not not RB 19613 4796 10 determined determine VBN 19613 4796 11 by by IN 19613 4796 12 the the DT 19613 4796 13 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4796 14 from from IN 19613 4796 15 the the DT 19613 4796 16 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 4796 17 of of IN 19613 4796 18 the the DT 19613 4796 19 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4796 20 Church Church NNP 19613 4796 21 which which WDT 19613 4796 22 is be VBZ 19613 4796 23 awaiting await VBG 19613 4796 24 an an DT 19613 4796 25 introduction introduction NN 19613 4796 26 into into IN 19613 4796 27 the the DT 19613 4796 28 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 4796 29 of of IN 19613 4796 30 God God NNP 19613 4796 31 ; ; : 19613 4796 32 but but CC 19613 4796 33 were be VBD 19613 4796 34 deduced deduce VBN 19613 4796 35 from from IN 19613 4796 36 a a DT 19613 4796 37 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 4796 38 of of IN 19613 4796 39 the the DT 19613 4796 40 world world NN 19613 4796 41 on on IN 19613 4796 42 the the DT 19613 4796 43 one one CD 19613 4796 44 hand hand NN 19613 4796 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4796 46 see see VB 19613 4796 47 particularly particularly RB 19613 4796 48 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4796 49 , , , 19613 4796 50 4 4 CD 19613 4796 51 ; ; : 19613 4796 52 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 4796 53 , , , 19613 4796 54 I. i. NN 19613 4797 1 5 5 CD 19613 4797 2 , , , 19613 4797 3 6 6 CD 19613 4797 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4797 5 , , , 19613 4797 6 and and CC 19613 4797 7 of of IN 19613 4797 8 the the DT 19613 4797 9 moral moral JJ 19613 4797 10 nature nature NN 19613 4797 11 of of IN 19613 4797 12 man man NN 19613 4797 13 on on IN 19613 4797 14 the the DT 19613 4797 15 other other JJ 19613 4797 16 . . . 19613 4798 1 But but CC 19613 4798 2 , , , 19613 4798 3 in in IN 19613 4798 4 so so RB 19613 4798 5 far far RB 19613 4798 6 as as IN 19613 4798 7 the the DT 19613 4798 8 latter latter NN 19613 4798 9 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4798 10 belongs belong VBZ 19613 4798 11 to to IN 19613 4798 12 the the DT 19613 4798 13 sphere sphere NN 19613 4798 14 of of IN 19613 4798 15 created create VBN 19613 4798 16 things thing NNS 19613 4798 17 , , , 19613 4798 18 the the DT 19613 4798 19 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 4798 20 is be VBZ 19613 4798 21 the the DT 19613 4798 22 starting starting NN 19613 4798 23 - - HYPH 19613 4798 24 point point NN 19613 4798 25 of of IN 19613 4798 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4798 27 speculations speculation NNS 19613 4798 28 . . . 19613 4799 1 This this DT 19613 4799 2 is be VBZ 19613 4799 3 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 4799 4 dominated dominate VBN 19613 4799 5 by by IN 19613 4799 6 reason reason NN 19613 4799 7 and and CC 19613 4799 8 order;[424 order;[424 LS 19613 4799 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4799 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4799 11 bears bear VBZ 19613 4799 12 the the DT 19613 4799 13 impress impress NN 19613 4799 14 of of IN 19613 4799 15 the the DT 19613 4799 16 divine divine JJ 19613 4799 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4799 18 , , , 19613 4799 19 and and CC 19613 4799 20 that that IN 19613 4799 21 in in IN 19613 4799 22 a a DT 19613 4799 23 double double JJ 19613 4799 24 sense sense NN 19613 4799 25 . . . 19613 4800 1 On on IN 19613 4800 2 the the DT 19613 4800 3 one one CD 19613 4800 4 hand hand NN 19613 4800 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4800 6 appears appear VBZ 19613 4800 7 as as IN 19613 4800 8 the the DT 19613 4800 9 copy copy NN 19613 4800 10 of of IN 19613 4800 11 a a DT 19613 4800 12 higher high JJR 19613 4800 13 , , , 19613 4800 14 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4800 15 world world NN 19613 4800 16 , , , 19613 4800 17 for for IN 19613 4800 18 if if IN 19613 4800 19 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4800 20 imagine imagine VBP 19613 4800 21 transient transient JJ 19613 4800 22 and and CC 19613 4800 23 changeable changeable JJ 19613 4800 24 matter matter NN 19613 4800 25 removed remove VBN 19613 4800 26 , , , 19613 4800 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4800 28 is be VBZ 19613 4800 29 a a DT 19613 4800 30 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 4800 31 complex complex NN 19613 4800 32 of of IN 19613 4800 33 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4800 34 forces force NNS 19613 4800 35 ; ; : 19613 4800 36 on on IN 19613 4800 37 the the DT 19613 4800 38 other other JJ 19613 4800 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4800 40 presents present VBZ 19613 4800 41 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4800 42 as as IN 19613 4800 43 the the DT 19613 4800 44 finite finite JJ 19613 4800 45 product product NN 19613 4800 46 of of IN 19613 4800 47 a a DT 19613 4800 48 rational rational JJ 19613 4800 49 will will NN 19613 4800 50 . . . 19613 4801 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 4801 2 , , , 19613 4801 3 the the DT 19613 4801 4 matter matter NN 19613 4801 5 which which WDT 19613 4801 6 lies lie VBZ 19613 4801 7 at at IN 19613 4801 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4801 9 basis basis NN 19613 4801 10 is be VBZ 19613 4801 11 nothing nothing NN 19613 4801 12 bad bad JJ 19613 4801 13 , , , 19613 4801 14 but but CC 19613 4801 15 an an DT 19613 4801 16 indifferent indifferent JJ 19613 4801 17 substance substance NN 19613 4801 18 created create VBN 19613 4801 19 by by IN 19613 4801 20 God,[425 God,[425 NNP 19613 4801 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4801 22 though though IN 19613 4801 23 indeed indeed RB 19613 4801 24 perishable perishable JJ 19613 4801 25 . . . 19613 4802 1 In in IN 19613 4802 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4802 3 constitution constitution NN 19613 4802 4 the the DT 19613 4802 5 world world NN 19613 4802 6 is be VBZ 19613 4802 7 in in IN 19613 4802 8 every every DT 19613 4802 9 respect respect NN 19613 4802 10 a a DT 19613 4802 11 structure structure NN 19613 4802 12 worthy worthy JJ 19613 4802 13 of of IN 19613 4802 14 God God NNP 19613 4802 15 . . . 19613 4803 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4803 2 426 426 CD 19613 4803 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4803 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4803 5 , , , 19613 4803 6 according accord VBG 19613 4803 7 to to IN 19613 4803 8 the the DT 19613 4803 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4803 10 , , , 19613 4803 11 the the DT 19613 4803 12 direct direct JJ 19613 4803 13 author author NN 19613 4803 14 of of IN 19613 4803 15 the the DT 19613 4803 16 world world NN 19613 4803 17 was be VBD 19613 4803 18 not not RB 19613 4803 19 God God NNP 19613 4803 20 , , , 19613 4803 21 but but CC 19613 4803 22 the the DT 19613 4803 23 personified personified JJ 19613 4803 24 power power NN 19613 4803 25 of of IN 19613 4803 26 reason reason NN 19613 4803 27 which which WDT 19613 4803 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4803 29 perceived perceive VBD 19613 4803 30 in in IN 19613 4803 31 the the DT 19613 4803 32 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 4803 33 and and CC 19613 4803 34 represented represent VBD 19613 4803 35 as as IN 19613 4803 36 the the DT 19613 4803 37 immediate immediate JJ 19613 4803 38 source source NN 19613 4803 39 of of IN 19613 4803 40 the the DT 19613 4803 41 universe universe NN 19613 4803 42 . . . 19613 4804 1 The the DT 19613 4804 2 motive motive NN 19613 4804 3 for for IN 19613 4804 4 this this DT 19613 4804 5 dogma dogma NN 19613 4804 6 and and CC 19613 4804 7 the the DT 19613 4804 8 interest interest NN 19613 4804 9 in in IN 19613 4804 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4804 11 would would MD 19613 4804 12 be be VB 19613 4804 13 wrongly wrongly RB 19613 4804 14 determined determine VBN 19613 4804 15 by by IN 19613 4804 16 alleging allege VBG 19613 4804 17 that that IN 19613 4804 18 the the DT 19613 4804 19 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4804 20 purposely purposely RB 19613 4804 21 introduced introduce VBD 19613 4804 22 the the DT 19613 4804 23 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4804 24 in in IN 19613 4804 25 order order NN 19613 4804 26 to to TO 19613 4804 27 separate separate VB 19613 4804 28 God God NNP 19613 4804 29 from from IN 19613 4804 30 matter matter NN 19613 4804 31 , , , 19613 4804 32 because because IN 19613 4804 33 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4804 34 regarded regard VBD 19613 4804 35 this this DT 19613 4804 36 as as IN 19613 4804 37 something something NN 19613 4804 38 bad bad JJ 19613 4804 39 . . . 19613 4805 1 This this DT 19613 4805 2 idea idea NN 19613 4805 3 of of IN 19613 4805 4 Philo Philo NNP 19613 4805 5 's 's POS 19613 4805 6 can can MD 19613 4805 7 not not RB 19613 4805 8 at at IN 19613 4805 9 least least JJS 19613 4805 10 have have VBP 19613 4805 11 been be VBN 19613 4805 12 adopted adopt VBN 19613 4805 13 by by IN 19613 4805 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4805 15 as as IN 19613 4805 16 the the DT 19613 4805 17 result result NN 19613 4805 18 of of IN 19613 4805 19 conscious conscious JJ 19613 4805 20 reflection reflection NN 19613 4805 21 , , , 19613 4805 22 for for IN 19613 4805 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4805 24 does do VBZ 19613 4805 25 not not RB 19613 4805 26 agree agree VB 19613 4805 27 with with IN 19613 4805 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4805 29 conception conception NN 19613 4805 30 of of IN 19613 4805 31 matter matter NN 19613 4805 32 ; ; : 19613 4805 33 nor nor CC 19613 4805 34 is be VBZ 19613 4805 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4805 36 compatible compatible JJ 19613 4805 37 with with IN 19613 4805 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4805 39 idea idea NN 19613 4805 40 of of IN 19613 4805 41 God God NNP 19613 4805 42 and and CC 19613 4805 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4805 44 belief belief NN 19613 4805 45 in in IN 19613 4805 46 Providence Providence NNP 19613 4805 47 , , , 19613 4805 48 which which WDT 19613 4805 49 is be VBZ 19613 4805 50 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 4805 51 firmly firmly RB 19613 4805 52 maintained maintain VBN 19613 4805 53 . . . 19613 4806 1 Still still RB 19613 4806 2 less less JJR 19613 4806 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 4806 4 can can MD 19613 4806 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4806 6 be be VB 19613 4806 7 shown show VBN 19613 4806 8 that that IN 19613 4806 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4806 10 were be VBD 19613 4806 11 all all DT 19613 4806 12 impelled impel VBN 19613 4806 13 to to IN 19613 4806 14 this this DT 19613 4806 15 dogma dogma NN 19613 4806 16 from from IN 19613 4806 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4806 18 view view NN 19613 4806 19 of of IN 19613 4806 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4806 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4806 22 , , , 19613 4806 23 since since IN 19613 4806 24 in in IN 19613 4806 25 this this DT 19613 4806 26 connection connection NN 19613 4806 27 , , , 19613 4806 28 with with IN 19613 4806 29 the the DT 19613 4806 30 exception exception NN 19613 4806 31 of of IN 19613 4806 32 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4806 33 and and CC 19613 4806 34 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4806 35 , , , 19613 4806 36 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4806 37 manifested manifest VBD 19613 4806 38 no no DT 19613 4806 39 specific specific JJ 19613 4806 40 interest interest NN 19613 4806 41 in in IN 19613 4806 42 the the DT 19613 4806 43 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 4806 44 of of IN 19613 4806 45 the the DT 19613 4806 46 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4806 47 in in IN 19613 4806 48 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4806 49 . . . 19613 4807 1 The the DT 19613 4807 2 adoption adoption NN 19613 4807 3 of of IN 19613 4807 4 the the DT 19613 4807 5 dogma dogma NN 19613 4807 6 of of IN 19613 4807 7 the the DT 19613 4807 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4807 9 is be VBZ 19613 4807 10 rather rather RB 19613 4807 11 to to TO 19613 4807 12 be be VB 19613 4807 13 explained explain VBN 19613 4807 14 thus thus RB 19613 4807 15 : : : 19613 4807 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4807 17 1 1 LS 19613 4807 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4807 19 The the DT 19613 4807 20 idea idea NN 19613 4807 21 of of IN 19613 4807 22 God God NNP 19613 4807 23 , , , 19613 4807 24 derived derive VBN 19613 4807 25 by by IN 19613 4807 26 abstraction abstraction NN 19613 4807 27 from from IN 19613 4807 28 the the DT 19613 4807 29 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 4807 30 , , , 19613 4807 31 did do VBD 19613 4807 32 indeed indeed RB 19613 4807 33 , , , 19613 4807 34 like like IN 19613 4807 35 that that DT 19613 4807 36 of of IN 19613 4807 37 the the DT 19613 4807 38 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 4807 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4807 40 , , , 19613 4807 41 involve involve VBP 19613 4807 42 the the DT 19613 4807 43 element element NN 19613 4807 44 of of IN 19613 4807 45 unity unity NN 19613 4807 46 and and CC 19613 4807 47 spirituality spirituality NN 19613 4807 48 , , , 19613 4807 49 which which WDT 19613 4807 50 implied imply VBD 19613 4807 51 a a DT 19613 4807 52 sort sort NN 19613 4807 53 of of IN 19613 4807 54 personality personality NN 19613 4807 55 ; ; : 19613 4807 56 but but CC 19613 4807 57 the the DT 19613 4807 58 fulness fulness NN 19613 4807 59 of of IN 19613 4807 60 all all DT 19613 4807 61 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4807 62 forces force NNS 19613 4807 63 , , , 19613 4807 64 the the DT 19613 4807 65 essence essence NN 19613 4807 66 of of IN 19613 4807 67 everything everything NN 19613 4807 68 imperishable imperishable JJ 19613 4807 69 were be VBD 19613 4807 70 quite quite RB 19613 4807 71 as as RB 19613 4807 72 essential essential JJ 19613 4807 73 features feature NNS 19613 4807 74 of of IN 19613 4807 75 the the DT 19613 4807 76 conception conception NN 19613 4807 77 ; ; : 19613 4807 78 for for IN 19613 4807 79 in in IN 19613 4807 80 spite spite NN 19613 4807 81 of of IN 19613 4807 82 the the DT 19613 4807 83 transcendence transcendence NN 19613 4807 84 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 4807 85 from from IN 19613 4807 86 the the DT 19613 4807 87 notion notion NN 19613 4807 88 of of IN 19613 4807 89 God God NNP 19613 4807 90 , , , 19613 4807 91 this this DT 19613 4807 92 idea idea NN 19613 4807 93 was be VBD 19613 4807 94 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4807 95 meant mean VBN 19613 4807 96 to to TO 19613 4807 97 explain explain VB 19613 4807 98 the the DT 19613 4807 99 world world NN 19613 4807 100 . . . 19613 4808 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4808 2 427 427 CD 19613 4808 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4808 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4808 5 , , , 19613 4808 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4808 7 required require VBD 19613 4808 8 a a DT 19613 4808 9 formula formula NN 19613 4808 10 capable capable JJ 19613 4808 11 of of IN 19613 4808 12 expressing express VBG 19613 4808 13 the the DT 19613 4808 14 transcendent transcendent NN 19613 4808 15 and and CC 19613 4808 16 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 4808 17 nature nature NN 19613 4808 18 of of IN 19613 4808 19 God God NNP 19613 4808 20 on on IN 19613 4808 21 the the DT 19613 4808 22 one one CD 19613 4808 23 hand hand NN 19613 4808 24 , , , 19613 4808 25 and and CC 19613 4808 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4808 27 fulness fulness NN 19613 4808 28 of of IN 19613 4808 29 creative creative JJ 19613 4808 30 and and CC 19613 4808 31 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4808 32 powers power NNS 19613 4808 33 on on IN 19613 4808 34 the the DT 19613 4808 35 other other JJ 19613 4808 36 . . . 19613 4809 1 But but CC 19613 4809 2 the the DT 19613 4809 3 latter latter JJ 19613 4809 4 attributes attribute VBZ 19613 4809 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4809 6 had have VBD 19613 4809 7 again again RB 19613 4809 8 to to TO 19613 4809 9 be be VB 19613 4809 10 comprehended comprehend VBN 19613 4809 11 in in IN 19613 4809 12 a a DT 19613 4809 13 unity unity NN 19613 4809 14 , , , 19613 4809 15 because because IN 19613 4809 16 the the DT 19613 4809 17 law law NN 19613 4809 18 of of IN 19613 4809 19 the the DT 19613 4809 20 cosmos cosmos NN 19613 4809 21 bore bear VBD 19613 4809 22 the the DT 19613 4809 23 appearance appearance NN 19613 4809 24 of of IN 19613 4809 25 a a DT 19613 4809 26 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 4809 27 one one NN 19613 4809 28 . . . 19613 4810 1 From from IN 19613 4810 2 this this DT 19613 4810 3 arose arise VBD 19613 4810 4 the the DT 19613 4810 5 idea idea NN 19613 4810 6 of of IN 19613 4810 7 the the DT 19613 4810 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4810 9 , , , 19613 4810 10 and and CC 19613 4810 11 indeed indeed RB 19613 4810 12 the the DT 19613 4810 13 latter latter JJ 19613 4810 14 was be VBD 19613 4810 15 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 4810 16 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 4810 17 from from IN 19613 4810 18 God God NNP 19613 4810 19 as as IN 19613 4810 20 a a DT 19613 4810 21 separate separate JJ 19613 4810 22 existence existence NN 19613 4810 23 , , , 19613 4810 24 as as RB 19613 4810 25 soon soon RB 19613 4810 26 as as IN 19613 4810 27 the the DT 19613 4810 28 realisation realisation NN 19613 4810 29 of of IN 19613 4810 30 the the DT 19613 4810 31 powers power NNS 19613 4810 32 residing reside VBG 19613 4810 33 in in IN 19613 4810 34 God God NNP 19613 4810 35 was be VBD 19613 4810 36 represented represent VBN 19613 4810 37 as as IN 19613 4810 38 beginning begin VBG 19613 4810 39 . . . 19613 4811 1 _ _ NNP 19613 4811 2 The the DT 19613 4811 3 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4811 4 is be VBZ 19613 4811 5 the the DT 19613 4811 6 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 4811 7 of of IN 19613 4811 8 the the DT 19613 4811 9 operative operative JJ 19613 4811 10 power power NN 19613 4811 11 of of IN 19613 4811 12 reason reason NN 19613 4811 13 , , , 19613 4811 14 which which WDT 19613 4811 15 at at IN 19613 4811 16 once once RB 19613 4811 17 preserves preserve NNS 19613 4811 18 the the DT 19613 4811 19 unity unity NN 19613 4811 20 and and CC 19613 4811 21 unchangeableness unchangeableness NN 19613 4811 22 of of IN 19613 4811 23 God God NNP 19613 4811 24 in in IN 19613 4811 25 spite spite NN 19613 4811 26 of of IN 19613 4811 27 the the DT 19613 4811 28 exercise exercise NN 19613 4811 29 of of IN 19613 4811 30 the the DT 19613 4811 31 powers power NNS 19613 4811 32 residing reside VBG 19613 4811 33 in in IN 19613 4811 34 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4811 35 , , , 19613 4811 36 and and CC 19613 4811 37 renders render VBZ 19613 4811 38 this this DT 19613 4811 39 very very JJ 19613 4811 40 exercise exercise NN 19613 4811 41 possible possible JJ 19613 4811 42 . . . 19613 4811 43 _ _ NNP 19613 4811 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4811 45 2 2 CD 19613 4811 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4811 47 Though though IN 19613 4811 48 the the DT 19613 4811 49 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4811 50 believed believe VBD 19613 4811 51 in in IN 19613 4811 52 the the DT 19613 4811 53 divine divine JJ 19613 4811 54 origin origin NN 19613 4811 55 of of IN 19613 4811 56 the the DT 19613 4811 57 revelation revelation NN 19613 4811 58 given give VBN 19613 4811 59 to to IN 19613 4811 60 the the DT 19613 4811 61 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4811 62 , , , 19613 4811 63 on on IN 19613 4811 64 which which WDT 19613 4811 65 all all DT 19613 4811 66 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4811 67 of of IN 19613 4811 68 truth truth NN 19613 4811 69 is be VBZ 19613 4811 70 based base VBN 19613 4811 71 , , , 19613 4811 72 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4811 73 could could MD 19613 4811 74 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4811 75 not not RB 19613 4811 76 be be VB 19613 4811 77 induced induce VBN 19613 4811 78 by by IN 19613 4811 79 this this DT 19613 4811 80 idea idea NN 19613 4811 81 to to TO 19613 4811 82 represent represent VB 19613 4811 83 God God NNP 19613 4811 84 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4811 85 as as IN 19613 4811 86 a a DT 19613 4811 87 direct direct JJ 19613 4811 88 actor actor NN 19613 4811 89 . . . 19613 4812 1 For for IN 19613 4812 2 that that DT 19613 4812 3 revelation revelation NN 19613 4812 4 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 4812 5 a a DT 19613 4812 6 speaker speaker NN 19613 4812 7 and and CC 19613 4812 8 a a DT 19613 4812 9 spoken speak VBN 19613 4812 10 word word NN 19613 4812 11 ; ; : 19613 4812 12 but but CC 19613 4812 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4812 14 would would MD 19613 4812 15 be be VB 19613 4812 16 an an DT 19613 4812 17 impossible impossible JJ 19613 4812 18 thought thought NN 19613 4812 19 to to TO 19613 4812 20 make make VB 19613 4812 21 the the DT 19613 4812 22 fulness fulness NN 19613 4812 23 of of IN 19613 4812 24 all all DT 19613 4812 25 essence essence NN 19613 4812 26 and and CC 19613 4812 27 the the DT 19613 4812 28 first first JJ 19613 4812 29 cause cause NN 19613 4812 30 of of IN 19613 4812 31 all all DT 19613 4812 32 things thing NNS 19613 4812 33 speak speak VBP 19613 4812 34 . . . 19613 4813 1 The the DT 19613 4813 2 Deity deity NN 19613 4813 3 can can MD 19613 4813 4 not not RB 19613 4813 5 be be VB 19613 4813 6 a a DT 19613 4813 7 speaking speaking NN 19613 4813 8 and and CC 19613 4813 9 still still RB 19613 4813 10 less less RBR 19613 4813 11 a a DT 19613 4813 12 visible visible JJ 19613 4813 13 person person NN 19613 4813 14 , , , 19613 4813 15 yet yet CC 19613 4813 16 according accord VBG 19613 4813 17 to to IN 19613 4813 18 the the DT 19613 4813 19 testimony testimony NN 19613 4813 20 of of IN 19613 4813 21 the the DT 19613 4813 22 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4813 23 , , , 19613 4813 24 a a DT 19613 4813 25 Divine Divine NNP 19613 4813 26 Person person NN 19613 4813 27 was be VBD 19613 4813 28 seen see VBN 19613 4813 29 by by IN 19613 4813 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4813 31 . . . 19613 4814 1 The the DT 19613 4814 2 Divine Divine NNP 19613 4814 3 Being Being NNP 19613 4814 4 who who WP 19613 4814 5 makes make VBZ 19613 4814 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4814 7 known know VBN 19613 4814 8 on on IN 19613 4814 9 earth earth NN 19613 4814 10 in in IN 19613 4814 11 audible audible JJ 19613 4814 12 and and CC 19613 4814 13 visible visible JJ 19613 4814 14 fashion fashion NN 19613 4814 15 can can MD 19613 4814 16 only only RB 19613 4814 17 be be VB 19613 4814 18 the the DT 19613 4814 19 Divine Divine NNP 19613 4814 20 Word Word NNP 19613 4814 21 . . . 19613 4815 1 As as IN 19613 4815 2 , , , 19613 4815 3 however however RB 19613 4815 4 , , , 19613 4815 5 according accord VBG 19613 4815 6 to to IN 19613 4815 7 the the DT 19613 4815 8 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4815 9 view view NN 19613 4815 10 of of IN 19613 4815 11 the the DT 19613 4815 12 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4815 13 the the DT 19613 4815 14 principle principle NN 19613 4815 15 of of IN 19613 4815 16 religion religion NN 19613 4815 17 , , , 19613 4815 18 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4815 19 , , , 19613 4815 20 of of IN 19613 4815 21 the the DT 19613 4815 22 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4815 23 of of IN 19613 4815 24 the the DT 19613 4815 25 truth truth NN 19613 4815 26 , , , 19613 4815 27 is be VBZ 19613 4815 28 also also RB 19613 4815 29 the the DT 19613 4815 30 principle principle NN 19613 4815 31 of of IN 19613 4815 32 the the DT 19613 4815 33 world world NN 19613 4815 34 , , , 19613 4815 35 so so IN 19613 4815 36 that that IN 19613 4815 37 Divine Divine NNP 19613 4815 38 Word Word NNP 19613 4815 39 , , , 19613 4815 40 which which WDT 19613 4815 41 imparts impart VBZ 19613 4815 42 the the DT 19613 4815 43 right right JJ 19613 4815 44 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4815 45 of of IN 19613 4815 46 the the DT 19613 4815 47 world world NN 19613 4815 48 , , , 19613 4815 49 must must MD 19613 4815 50 be be VB 19613 4815 51 identical identical JJ 19613 4815 52 with with IN 19613 4815 53 the the DT 19613 4815 54 Divine Divine NNP 19613 4815 55 Reason Reason NNP 19613 4815 56 which which WDT 19613 4815 57 produced produce VBD 19613 4815 58 the the DT 19613 4815 59 world world NN 19613 4815 60 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4815 61 . . . 19613 4816 1 In in IN 19613 4816 2 other other JJ 19613 4816 3 words word NNS 19613 4816 4 , , , 19613 4816 5 the the DT 19613 4816 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4816 7 is be VBZ 19613 4816 8 not not RB 19613 4816 9 only only RB 19613 4816 10 the the DT 19613 4816 11 creative creative JJ 19613 4816 12 Reason reason NN 19613 4816 13 of of IN 19613 4816 14 God God NNP 19613 4816 15 , , , 19613 4816 16 but but CC 19613 4816 17 also also RB 19613 4816 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4816 19 revealing revealing JJ 19613 4816 20 Word word NN 19613 4816 21 . . . 19613 4817 1 This this DT 19613 4817 2 explains explain VBZ 19613 4817 3 the the DT 19613 4817 4 motive motive NN 19613 4817 5 and and CC 19613 4817 6 aim aim NN 19613 4817 7 of of IN 19613 4817 8 the the DT 19613 4817 9 dogma dogma NN 19613 4817 10 of of IN 19613 4817 11 the the DT 19613 4817 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4817 13 . . . 19613 4818 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4818 2 need need VBP 19613 4818 3 not not RB 19613 4818 4 specially specially RB 19613 4818 5 point point VB 19613 4818 6 out out RP 19613 4818 7 that that IN 19613 4818 8 nothing nothing NN 19613 4818 9 more more JJR 19613 4818 10 than than IN 19613 4818 11 the the DT 19613 4818 12 precision precision NN 19613 4818 13 and and CC 19613 4818 14 certainty certainty NN 19613 4818 15 of of IN 19613 4818 16 the the DT 19613 4818 17 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4818 18 ' ' POS 19613 4818 19 manner manner NN 19613 4818 20 of of IN 19613 4818 21 statement statement NN 19613 4818 22 is be VBZ 19613 4818 23 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4818 24 here here RB 19613 4818 25 ; ; : 19613 4818 26 the the DT 19613 4818 27 train train NN 19613 4818 28 of of IN 19613 4818 29 thought thought NN 19613 4818 30 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4818 31 belongs belong VBZ 19613 4818 32 to to IN 19613 4818 33 Greek greek JJ 19613 4818 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4818 35 . . . 19613 4819 1 But but CC 19613 4819 2 that that DT 19613 4819 3 very very JJ 19613 4819 4 confidence confidence NN 19613 4819 5 is be VBZ 19613 4819 6 the the DT 19613 4819 7 most most RBS 19613 4819 8 essential essential JJ 19613 4819 9 feature feature NN 19613 4819 10 of of IN 19613 4819 11 the the DT 19613 4819 12 case case NN 19613 4819 13 ; ; : 19613 4819 14 for for IN 19613 4819 15 in in IN 19613 4819 16 fact fact NN 19613 4819 17 the the DT 19613 4819 18 firm firm JJ 19613 4819 19 belief belief NN 19613 4819 20 that that IN 19613 4819 21 the the DT 19613 4819 22 principle principle NN 19613 4819 23 of of IN 19613 4819 24 the the DT 19613 4819 25 world world NN 19613 4819 26 is be VBZ 19613 4819 27 also also RB 19613 4819 28 that that DT 19613 4819 29 of of IN 19613 4819 30 revelation revelation NN 19613 4819 31 represents represent VBZ 19613 4819 32 an an DT 19613 4819 33 important important JJ 19613 4819 34 early early JJ 19613 4819 35 - - HYPH 19613 4819 36 Christian christian JJ 19613 4819 37 idea idea NN 19613 4819 38 , , , 19613 4819 39 though though IN 19613 4819 40 indeed indeed RB 19613 4819 41 in in IN 19613 4819 42 the the DT 19613 4819 43 form form NN 19613 4819 44 of of IN 19613 4819 45 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4819 46 reflection reflection NN 19613 4819 47 . . . 19613 4820 1 To to IN 19613 4820 2 the the DT 19613 4820 3 majority majority NN 19613 4820 4 of of IN 19613 4820 5 the the DT 19613 4820 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4820 7 the the DT 19613 4820 8 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 4820 9 content content NN 19613 4820 10 of of IN 19613 4820 11 the the DT 19613 4820 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 4820 13 faith faith NN 19613 4820 14 is be VBZ 19613 4820 15 completely completely RB 19613 4820 16 exhausted exhausted JJ 19613 4820 17 in in IN 19613 4820 18 this this DT 19613 4820 19 proposition proposition NN 19613 4820 20 . . . 19613 4821 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4821 2 required require VBD 19613 4821 3 no no DT 19613 4821 4 particular particular JJ 19613 4821 5 Christology Christology NNP 19613 4821 6 , , , 19613 4821 7 for for IN 19613 4821 8 in in IN 19613 4821 9 every every DT 19613 4821 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 4821 11 of of IN 19613 4821 12 God God NNP 19613 4821 13 by by IN 19613 4821 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4821 15 Word Word NNP 19613 4821 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4821 17 already already RB 19613 4821 18 recognised recognise VBD 19613 4821 19 a a DT 19613 4821 20 proof proof NN 19613 4821 21 of of IN 19613 4821 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4821 23 existence existence NN 19613 4821 24 not not RB 19613 4821 25 to to TO 19613 4821 26 be be VB 19613 4821 27 surpassed surpass VBN 19613 4821 28 , , , 19613 4821 29 and and CC 19613 4821 30 consequently consequently RB 19613 4821 31 regarded regard VBD 19613 4821 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4821 33 as as IN 19613 4821 34 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4821 35 _ _ NNP 19613 4821 36 in in IN 19613 4821 37 nuce nuce NN 19613 4821 38 _ _ NNP 19613 4821 39 . . . 19613 4822 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4822 2 428 428 CD 19613 4822 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4822 4 But but CC 19613 4822 5 the the DT 19613 4822 6 fact fact NN 19613 4822 7 that that IN 19613 4822 8 the the DT 19613 4822 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4822 10 made make VBD 19613 4822 11 a a DT 19613 4822 12 distinction distinction NN 19613 4822 13 _ _ NNP 19613 4822 14 in in IN 19613 4822 15 thesi thesi NNP 19613 4822 16 _ _ NNP 19613 4822 17 between between IN 19613 4822 18 the the DT 19613 4822 19 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4822 20 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4822 21 of of IN 19613 4822 22 God God NNP 19613 4822 23 and and CC 19613 4822 24 the the DT 19613 4822 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4822 26 , , , 19613 4822 27 without without IN 19613 4822 28 being be VBG 19613 4822 29 able able JJ 19613 4822 30 to to TO 19613 4822 31 make make VB 19613 4822 32 any any DT 19613 4822 33 use use NN 19613 4822 34 of of IN 19613 4822 35 this this DT 19613 4822 36 distinction distinction NN 19613 4822 37 , , , 19613 4822 38 is be VBZ 19613 4822 39 a a DT 19613 4822 40 very very RB 19613 4822 41 clear clear JJ 19613 4822 42 instance instance NN 19613 4822 43 of of IN 19613 4822 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4822 45 dependence dependence NN 19613 4822 46 on on IN 19613 4822 47 the the DT 19613 4822 48 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 4822 49 of of IN 19613 4822 50 the the DT 19613 4822 51 Church Church NNP 19613 4822 52 's 's POS 19613 4822 53 faith faith NN 19613 4822 54 . . . 19613 4823 1 Indeed indeed RB 19613 4823 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4823 3 conception conception NN 19613 4823 4 of of IN 19613 4823 5 the the DT 19613 4823 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4823 7 continually continually RB 19613 4823 8 compelled compel VBD 19613 4823 9 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4823 10 to to TO 19613 4823 11 identify identify VB 19613 4823 12 the the DT 19613 4823 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4823 14 and and CC 19613 4823 15 the the DT 19613 4823 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4823 17 , , , 19613 4823 18 just just RB 19613 4823 19 as as IN 19613 4823 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4823 21 not not RB 19613 4823 22 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 4823 23 define define VB 19613 4823 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4823 25 as as IN 19613 4823 26 the the DT 19613 4823 27 belief belief NN 19613 4823 28 in in IN 19613 4823 29 the the DT 19613 4823 30 true true JJ 19613 4823 31 God God NNP 19613 4823 32 and and CC 19613 4823 33 in in IN 19613 4823 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4823 35 Son Son NNP 19613 4823 36 , , , 19613 4823 37 without without IN 19613 4823 38 mentioning mention VBG 19613 4823 39 the the DT 19613 4823 40 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4823 41 . . . 19613 4824 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4824 2 429 429 CD 19613 4824 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4824 4 Further further RB 19613 4824 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4824 6 dependence dependence NN 19613 4824 7 on on IN 19613 4824 8 the the DT 19613 4824 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 4824 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 4824 11 is be VBZ 19613 4824 12 shown show VBN 19613 4824 13 in in IN 19613 4824 14 the the DT 19613 4824 15 fact fact NN 19613 4824 16 that that IN 19613 4824 17 the the DT 19613 4824 18 most most JJS 19613 4824 19 of of IN 19613 4824 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4824 21 expressly expressly RB 19613 4824 22 designated designate VBD 19613 4824 23 the the DT 19613 4824 24 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4824 25 as as IN 19613 4824 26 the the DT 19613 4824 27 _ _ NNP 19613 4824 28 Son Son NNP 19613 4824 29 _ _ NNP 19613 4824 30 of of IN 19613 4824 31 God God NNP 19613 4824 32 . . . 19613 4825 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4825 2 430 430 CD 19613 4825 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4825 4 The the DT 19613 4825 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4825 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4825 7 of of IN 19613 4825 8 the the DT 19613 4825 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4825 10 is be VBZ 19613 4825 11 an an DT 19613 4825 12 essentially essentially RB 19613 4825 13 unanimous unanimous JJ 19613 4825 14 one one CD 19613 4825 15 . . . 19613 4826 1 Since since IN 19613 4826 2 God God NNP 19613 4826 3 can can MD 19613 4826 4 not not RB 19613 4826 5 be be VB 19613 4826 6 conceived conceive VBN 19613 4826 7 as as IN 19613 4826 8 without without IN 19613 4826 9 reason reason NN 19613 4826 10 , , , 19613 4826 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4826 12 Greek greek JJ 19613 4826 13 : : : 19613 4826 14 alogos alogo NNS 19613 4826 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4826 16 , , , 19613 4826 17 but but CC 19613 4826 18 as as IN 19613 4826 19 the the DT 19613 4826 20 fulness fulness NN 19613 4826 21 of of IN 19613 4826 22 all all DT 19613 4826 23 reason,[431 reason,[431 NNP 19613 4826 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4826 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4826 26 has have VBZ 19613 4826 27 always always RB 19613 4826 28 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4826 29 in in IN 19613 4826 30 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4826 31 . . . 19613 4827 1 This this DT 19613 4827 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4827 3 is be VBZ 19613 4827 4 on on IN 19613 4827 5 the the DT 19613 4827 6 one one CD 19613 4827 7 hand hand NN 19613 4827 8 the the DT 19613 4827 9 divine divine JJ 19613 4827 10 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 4827 11 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4827 12 , , , 19613 4827 13 and and CC 19613 4827 14 on on IN 19613 4827 15 the the DT 19613 4827 16 other other JJ 19613 4827 17 the the DT 19613 4827 18 power power NN 19613 4827 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4827 20 idea idea NN 19613 4827 21 and and CC 19613 4827 22 energy energy NN 19613 4827 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4827 24 to to TO 19613 4827 25 which which WDT 19613 4827 26 the the DT 19613 4827 27 world world NN 19613 4827 28 is be VBZ 19613 4827 29 due due JJ 19613 4827 30 ; ; : 19613 4827 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4827 32 is be VBZ 19613 4827 33 not not RB 19613 4827 34 separate separate JJ 19613 4827 35 from from IN 19613 4827 36 God God NNP 19613 4827 37 , , , 19613 4827 38 but but CC 19613 4827 39 is be VBZ 19613 4827 40 contained contain VBN 19613 4827 41 in in IN 19613 4827 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4827 43 essence essence NN 19613 4827 44 . . . 19613 4828 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4828 2 432 432 CD 19613 4828 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4828 4 For for IN 19613 4828 5 the the DT 19613 4828 6 sake sake NN 19613 4828 7 of of IN 19613 4828 8 the the DT 19613 4828 9 creation creation NN 19613 4828 10 God God NNP 19613 4828 11 produced produce VBD 19613 4828 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4828 13 sent send VBN 19613 4828 14 forth forth RB 19613 4828 15 , , , 19613 4828 16 projected project VBN 19613 4828 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4828 18 the the DT 19613 4828 19 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4828 20 from from IN 19613 4828 21 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4828 22 , , , 19613 4828 23 that that RB 19613 4828 24 is is RB 19613 4828 25 , , , 19613 4828 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4828 27 engendered[433 engendered[433 , 19613 4828 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4828 29 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4828 30 from from IN 19613 4828 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4828 32 essence essence NN 19613 4828 33 by by IN 19613 4828 34 a a DT 19613 4828 35 free free JJ 19613 4828 36 and and CC 19613 4828 37 simple simple JJ 19613 4828 38 act act NN 19613 4828 39 of of IN 19613 4828 40 will will NN 19613 4828 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4828 42 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4828 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4828 44 : : : 19613 4828 45 Theos theos RB 19613 4828 46 ek ek IN 19613 4828 47 Theou Theou NNP 19613 4828 48 pephukôs pephukôs NN 19613 4828 49 ex ex NNP 19613 4828 50 heautou heautou NN 19613 4828 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4828 52 . . . 19613 4829 1 Dial dial NN 19613 4829 2 . . . 19613 4830 1 61 61 CD 19613 4830 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4830 3 . . . 19613 4831 1 Then then RB 19613 4831 2 for for IN 19613 4831 3 the the DT 19613 4831 4 first first JJ 19613 4831 5 time time NN 19613 4831 6 the the DT 19613 4831 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4831 8 became become VBD 19613 4831 9 a a DT 19613 4831 10 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 4831 11 separate separate JJ 19613 4831 12 from from IN 19613 4831 13 God God NNP 19613 4831 14 , , , 19613 4831 15 or or CC 19613 4831 16 , , , 19613 4831 17 in in IN 19613 4831 18 other other JJ 19613 4831 19 words word NNS 19613 4831 20 , , , 19613 4831 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4831 22 first first RB 19613 4831 23 came come VBD 19613 4831 24 into into IN 19613 4831 25 existence existence NN 19613 4831 26 ; ; , 19613 4831 27 and and CC 19613 4831 28 , , , 19613 4831 29 in in IN 19613 4831 30 virtue virtue NN 19613 4831 31 of of IN 19613 4831 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4831 33 origin origin NN 19613 4831 34 , , , 19613 4831 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4831 36 possesses possess VBZ 19613 4831 37 the the DT 19613 4831 38 following follow VBG 19613 4831 39 distinctive distinctive JJ 19613 4831 40 features:[434 features:[434 NNP 19613 4831 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4831 42 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4831 43 1 1 LS 19613 4831 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4831 45 The the DT 19613 4831 46 inner inner JJ 19613 4831 47 essence essence NN 19613 4831 48 of of IN 19613 4831 49 the the DT 19613 4831 50 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4831 51 is be VBZ 19613 4831 52 identical identical JJ 19613 4831 53 with with IN 19613 4831 54 the the DT 19613 4831 55 essence essence NN 19613 4831 56 of of IN 19613 4831 57 God God NNP 19613 4831 58 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4831 59 ; ; : 19613 4831 60 for for IN 19613 4831 61 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4831 62 is be VBZ 19613 4831 63 the the DT 19613 4831 64 product product NN 19613 4831 65 of of IN 19613 4831 66 self self NN 19613 4831 67 - - HYPH 19613 4831 68 separation separation NN 19613 4831 69 in in IN 19613 4831 70 God God NNP 19613 4831 71 , , , 19613 4831 72 willed will VBD 19613 4831 73 and and CC 19613 4831 74 brought bring VBN 19613 4831 75 about about RP 19613 4831 76 by by IN 19613 4831 77 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4831 78 . . . 19613 4832 1 Further further RB 19613 4832 2 , , , 19613 4832 3 the the DT 19613 4832 4 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4832 5 is be VBZ 19613 4832 6 not not RB 19613 4832 7 cut cut VBN 19613 4832 8 off off RP 19613 4832 9 and and CC 19613 4832 10 separated separate VBN 19613 4832 11 from from IN 19613 4832 12 God God NNP 19613 4832 13 , , , 19613 4832 14 nor nor CC 19613 4832 15 is be VBZ 19613 4832 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4832 17 a a DT 19613 4832 18 mere mere JJ 19613 4832 19 modality modality NN 19613 4832 20 in in IN 19613 4832 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4832 22 . . . 19613 4833 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4833 2 is be VBZ 19613 4833 3 rather rather RB 19613 4833 4 the the DT 19613 4833 5 independent independent JJ 19613 4833 6 product product NN 19613 4833 7 of of IN 19613 4833 8 the the DT 19613 4833 9 self self NN 19613 4833 10 - - HYPH 19613 4833 11 unfolding unfolding JJ 19613 4833 12 of of IN 19613 4833 13 God God NNP 19613 4833 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4833 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4833 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4833 17 : : : 19613 4833 18 oikonomia oikonomia NN 19613 4833 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4833 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4833 21 , , , 19613 4833 22 which which WDT 19613 4833 23 product product NN 19613 4833 24 , , , 19613 4833 25 though though IN 19613 4833 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4833 27 is be VBZ 19613 4833 28 the the DT 19613 4833 29 epitome epitome NN 19613 4833 30 of of IN 19613 4833 31 divine divine JJ 19613 4833 32 reason reason NN 19613 4833 33 , , , 19613 4833 34 has have VBZ 19613 4833 35 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4833 36 not not RB 19613 4833 37 stripped strip VBN 19613 4833 38 the the DT 19613 4833 39 Father Father NNP 19613 4833 40 of of IN 19613 4833 41 this this DT 19613 4833 42 attribute attribute NN 19613 4833 43 . . . 19613 4834 1 The the DT 19613 4834 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4834 3 is be VBZ 19613 4834 4 the the DT 19613 4834 5 revelation revelation NN 19613 4834 6 of of IN 19613 4834 7 God God NNP 19613 4834 8 , , , 19613 4834 9 and and CC 19613 4834 10 the the DT 19613 4834 11 visible visible JJ 19613 4834 12 God God NNP 19613 4834 13 . . . 19613 4835 1 Consequently consequently RB 19613 4835 2 the the DT 19613 4835 3 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4835 4 is be VBZ 19613 4835 5 really really RB 19613 4835 6 God God NNP 19613 4835 7 and and CC 19613 4835 8 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4835 9 , , , 19613 4835 10 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4835 11 , , , 19613 4835 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4835 13 possesses possess VBZ 19613 4835 14 the the DT 19613 4835 15 divine divine JJ 19613 4835 16 nature nature NN 19613 4835 17 in in IN 19613 4835 18 virtue virtue NN 19613 4835 19 of of IN 19613 4835 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4835 21 essence essence NN 19613 4835 22 . . . 19613 4836 1 The the DT 19613 4836 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4836 3 , , , 19613 4836 4 however however RB 19613 4836 5 , , , 19613 4836 6 only only RB 19613 4836 7 know know VB 19613 4836 8 of of IN 19613 4836 9 one one CD 19613 4836 10 kind kind NN 19613 4836 11 of of IN 19613 4836 12 divine divine JJ 19613 4836 13 nature nature NN 19613 4836 14 and and CC 19613 4836 15 this this DT 19613 4836 16 is be VBZ 19613 4836 17 that that DT 19613 4836 18 which which WDT 19613 4836 19 belongs belong VBZ 19613 4836 20 to to IN 19613 4836 21 the the DT 19613 4836 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4836 23 . . . 19613 4837 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4837 2 2 2 LS 19613 4837 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4837 4 From from IN 19613 4837 5 the the DT 19613 4837 6 moment moment NN 19613 4837 7 when when WRB 19613 4837 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4837 9 was be VBD 19613 4837 10 begotten beget VBN 19613 4837 11 the the DT 19613 4837 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4837 13 is be VBZ 19613 4837 14 a a DT 19613 4837 15 being be VBG 19613 4837 16 distinct distinct JJ 19613 4837 17 from from IN 19613 4837 18 the the DT 19613 4837 19 Father Father NNP 19613 4837 20 ; ; : 19613 4837 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4837 22 is be VBZ 19613 4837 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4837 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4837 25 : : : 19613 4837 26 arithmô arithmô NNP 19613 4837 27 eteron eteron NNP 19613 4837 28 ti ti NNP 19613 4837 29 , , , 19613 4837 30 Theos Theos NNP 19613 4837 31 heteros hetero NNS 19613 4837 32 , , , 19613 4837 33 Theos Theos NNP 19613 4837 34 deuteros deuteros NNP 19613 4837 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4837 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4837 37 " " `` 19613 4837 38 something something NN 19613 4837 39 different different JJ 19613 4837 40 in in IN 19613 4837 41 number number NN 19613 4837 42 , , , 19613 4837 43 another another DT 19613 4837 44 God God NNP 19613 4837 45 , , , 19613 4837 46 a a DT 19613 4837 47 second second JJ 19613 4837 48 God God NNP 19613 4837 49 . . . 19613 4837 50 " " '' 19613 4837 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4838 1 But but CC 19613 4838 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4838 3 personality personality NN 19613 4838 4 only only RB 19613 4838 5 dates date VBZ 19613 4838 6 from from IN 19613 4838 7 that that DT 19613 4838 8 moment moment NN 19613 4838 9 . . . 19613 4839 1 " " `` 19613 4839 2 Fuit fuit NN 19613 4839 3 tempus tempus NN 19613 4839 4 , , , 19613 4839 5 cum cum NNP 19613 4839 6 patri patri NNP 19613 4839 7 filius filius NNP 19613 4839 8 non non NNP 19613 4839 9 fuit fuit NN 19613 4839 10 , , , 19613 4839 11 " " '' 19613 4839 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4839 13 " " `` 19613 4839 14 there there EX 19613 4839 15 was be VBD 19613 4839 16 a a DT 19613 4839 17 time time NN 19613 4839 18 when when WRB 19613 4839 19 the the DT 19613 4839 20 Father Father NNP 19613 4839 21 had have VBD 19613 4839 22 no no DT 19613 4839 23 Son Son NNP 19613 4839 24 , , , 19613 4839 25 " " '' 19613 4839 26 so so RB 19613 4839 27 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 4839 28 , , , 19613 4839 29 adv adv NN 19613 4839 30 . . . 19613 4840 1 Hermog hermog NN 19613 4840 2 . . . 19613 4841 1 3 3 LS 19613 4841 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4841 3 . . . 19613 4842 1 The the DT 19613 4842 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4842 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4842 4 : : : 19613 4842 5 logos logos NNP 19613 4842 6 prophorikos prophorikos NN 19613 4842 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4842 8 is be VBZ 19613 4842 9 for for IN 19613 4842 10 the the DT 19613 4842 11 first first JJ 19613 4842 12 time time NN 19613 4842 13 a a DT 19613 4842 14 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 4842 15 distinct distinct JJ 19613 4842 16 from from IN 19613 4842 17 the the DT 19613 4842 18 Father Father NNP 19613 4842 19 , , , 19613 4842 20 the the DT 19613 4842 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4842 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4842 23 : : : 19613 4842 24 logos logos NNP 19613 4842 25 endiathetos endiathetos NNP 19613 4842 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4842 27 is be VBZ 19613 4842 28 not not RB 19613 4842 29 . . . 19613 4843 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4843 2 435 435 CD 19613 4843 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4843 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4843 5 3 3 LS 19613 4843 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4843 7 The the DT 19613 4843 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4843 9 has have VBZ 19613 4843 10 an an DT 19613 4843 11 origin origin NN 19613 4843 12 , , , 19613 4843 13 the the DT 19613 4843 14 Father Father NNP 19613 4843 15 has have VBZ 19613 4843 16 not not RB 19613 4843 17 ; ; : 19613 4843 18 hence hence RB 19613 4843 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4843 20 follows follow VBZ 19613 4843 21 that that IN 19613 4843 22 in in IN 19613 4843 23 relation relation NN 19613 4843 24 to to IN 19613 4843 25 God God NNP 19613 4843 26 the the DT 19613 4843 27 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4843 28 is be VBZ 19613 4843 29 a a DT 19613 4843 30 creature creature NN 19613 4843 31 ; ; : 19613 4843 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4843 33 is be VBZ 19613 4843 34 the the DT 19613 4843 35 begotten begotten NN 19613 4843 36 , , , 19613 4843 37 that that RB 19613 4843 38 is is RB 19613 4843 39 , , , 19613 4843 40 the the DT 19613 4843 41 created create VBN 19613 4843 42 God God NNP 19613 4843 43 , , , 19613 4843 44 the the DT 19613 4843 45 God God NNP 19613 4843 46 who who WP 19613 4843 47 has have VBZ 19613 4843 48 a a DT 19613 4843 49 beginning beginning NN 19613 4843 50 . . . 19613 4844 1 Wherefore Wherefore VBN 19613 4844 2 in in IN 19613 4844 3 rank rank NN 19613 4844 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4844 5 is be VBZ 19613 4844 6 below below IN 19613 4844 7 God God NNP 19613 4844 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4844 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4844 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4844 11 : : : 19613 4844 12 en en NNP 19613 4844 13 deutera deutera FW 19613 4844 14 chôra]--[Greek chôra]--[Greek NNP 19613 4844 15 : : : 19613 4844 16 deuteros deuteros NNP 19613 4844 17 Theos Theos NNP 19613 4844 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4844 19 , , , 19613 4844 20 " " `` 19613 4844 21 in in IN 19613 4844 22 the the DT 19613 4844 23 second second JJ 19613 4844 24 place place NN 19613 4844 25 , , , 19613 4844 26 and and CC 19613 4844 27 a a DT 19613 4844 28 second second JJ 19613 4844 29 God God NNP 19613 4844 30 " " '' 19613 4844 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4844 32 , , , 19613 4844 33 the the DT 19613 4844 34 messenger messenger NN 19613 4844 35 and and CC 19613 4844 36 servant servant NN 19613 4844 37 of of IN 19613 4844 38 God God NNP 19613 4844 39 . . . 19613 4845 1 The the DT 19613 4845 2 subordination subordination NN 19613 4845 3 of of IN 19613 4845 4 the the DT 19613 4845 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4845 6 is be VBZ 19613 4845 7 not not RB 19613 4845 8 founded found VBN 19613 4845 9 on on IN 19613 4845 10 the the DT 19613 4845 11 content content NN 19613 4845 12 of of IN 19613 4845 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4845 14 essence essence NN 19613 4845 15 , , , 19613 4845 16 but but CC 19613 4845 17 on on IN 19613 4845 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4845 19 origin origin NN 19613 4845 20 . . . 19613 4846 1 In in IN 19613 4846 2 relation relation NN 19613 4846 3 to to IN 19613 4846 4 the the DT 19613 4846 5 creatures creature NNS 19613 4846 6 , , , 19613 4846 7 however however RB 19613 4846 8 , , , 19613 4846 9 the the DT 19613 4846 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4846 11 is be VBZ 19613 4846 12 the the DT 19613 4846 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4846 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4846 15 : : : 19613 4846 16 archê archê NNP 19613 4846 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4846 18 , , , 19613 4846 19 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4846 20 , , , 19613 4846 21 not not RB 19613 4846 22 only only RB 19613 4846 23 the the DT 19613 4846 24 beginning beginning NN 19613 4846 25 but but CC 19613 4846 26 the the DT 19613 4846 27 principle principle NN 19613 4846 28 of of IN 19613 4846 29 the the DT 19613 4846 30 vitality vitality NN 19613 4846 31 and and CC 19613 4846 32 form form NN 19613 4846 33 of of IN 19613 4846 34 everything everything NN 19613 4846 35 that that WDT 19613 4846 36 is be VBZ 19613 4846 37 to to TO 19613 4846 38 receive receive VB 19613 4846 39 being be VBG 19613 4846 40 . . . 19613 4847 1 As as IN 19613 4847 2 an an DT 19613 4847 3 emanation emanation NN 19613 4847 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4847 5 the the DT 19613 4847 6 begotten begotten NN 19613 4847 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4847 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4847 9 is be VBZ 19613 4847 10 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 4847 11 from from IN 19613 4847 12 all all DT 19613 4847 13 creatures creature NNS 19613 4847 14 , , , 19613 4847 15 for for IN 19613 4847 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4847 17 alone alone RB 19613 4847 18 is be VBZ 19613 4847 19 the the DT 19613 4847 20 Son;[436 Son;[436 NNP 19613 4847 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4847 22 but but CC 19613 4847 23 , , , 19613 4847 24 as as IN 19613 4847 25 having have VBG 19613 4847 26 a a DT 19613 4847 27 beginning beginning NN 19613 4847 28 , , , 19613 4847 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4847 30 again again RB 19613 4847 31 stands stand VBZ 19613 4847 32 on on IN 19613 4847 33 a a DT 19613 4847 34 level level NN 19613 4847 35 with with IN 19613 4847 36 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4847 37 . . . 19613 4848 1 Hence hence RB 19613 4848 2 the the DT 19613 4848 3 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 19613 4848 4 expression expression NN 19613 4848 5 , , , 19613 4848 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4848 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4848 8 : : : 19613 4848 9 ergon ergon NNP 19613 4848 10 prôtotokon prôtotokon NNP 19613 4848 11 tou tou NNP 19613 4848 12 patros patros NNP 19613 4848 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4848 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4848 15 " " `` 19613 4848 16 first first JJ 19613 4848 17 begotten begotten JJ 19613 4848 18 work work NN 19613 4848 19 of of IN 19613 4848 20 the the DT 19613 4848 21 Father Father NNP 19613 4848 22 " " '' 19613 4848 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4848 24 , , , 19613 4848 25 is be VBZ 19613 4848 26 here here RB 19613 4848 27 the the DT 19613 4848 28 most most RBS 19613 4848 29 appropriate appropriate JJ 19613 4848 30 designation designation NN 19613 4848 31 . . . 19613 4849 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4849 2 4 4 LS 19613 4849 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4849 4 In in IN 19613 4849 5 virtue virtue NN 19613 4849 6 of of IN 19613 4849 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4849 8 finite finite JJ 19613 4849 9 origin origin NN 19613 4849 10 , , , 19613 4849 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4849 12 is be VBZ 19613 4849 13 possible possible JJ 19613 4849 14 and and CC 19613 4849 15 proper proper JJ 19613 4849 16 for for IN 19613 4849 17 the the DT 19613 4849 18 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4849 19 to to TO 19613 4849 20 enter enter VB 19613 4849 21 into into IN 19613 4849 22 the the DT 19613 4849 23 finite finite NN 19613 4849 24 , , , 19613 4849 25 to to TO 19613 4849 26 act act VB 19613 4849 27 , , , 19613 4849 28 to to TO 19613 4849 29 speak speak VB 19613 4849 30 , , , 19613 4849 31 and and CC 19613 4849 32 to to TO 19613 4849 33 appear appear VB 19613 4849 34 . . . 19613 4850 1 As as IN 19613 4850 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4850 3 arose arise VBD 19613 4850 4 for for IN 19613 4850 5 the the DT 19613 4850 6 sake sake NN 19613 4850 7 of of IN 19613 4850 8 the the DT 19613 4850 9 creation creation NN 19613 4850 10 of of IN 19613 4850 11 the the DT 19613 4850 12 world world NN 19613 4850 13 , , , 19613 4850 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4850 15 has have VBZ 19613 4850 16 the the DT 19613 4850 17 capacity capacity NN 19613 4850 18 of of IN 19613 4850 19 personal personal JJ 19613 4850 20 and and CC 19613 4850 21 direct direct JJ 19613 4850 22 revelation revelation NN 19613 4850 23 which which WDT 19613 4850 24 does do VBZ 19613 4850 25 not not RB 19613 4850 26 belong belong VB 19613 4850 27 to to IN 19613 4850 28 the the DT 19613 4850 29 infinite infinite JJ 19613 4850 30 God God NNP 19613 4850 31 ; ; : 19613 4850 32 nay nay NNP 19613 4850 33 , , , 19613 4850 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4850 35 whole whole JJ 19613 4850 36 essence essence NN 19613 4850 37 consists consist VBZ 19613 4850 38 in in IN 19613 4850 39 the the DT 19613 4850 40 very very JJ 19613 4850 41 fact fact NN 19613 4850 42 that that IN 19613 4850 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4850 44 is be VBZ 19613 4850 45 thought thought NN 19613 4850 46 , , , 19613 4850 47 word word NN 19613 4850 48 , , , 19613 4850 49 and and CC 19613 4850 50 deed deed NN 19613 4850 51 . . . 19613 4851 1 Behind behind IN 19613 4851 2 this this DT 19613 4851 3 active active JJ 19613 4851 4 substitute substitute NN 19613 4851 5 and and CC 19613 4851 6 vicegerent vicegerent NN 19613 4851 7 , , , 19613 4851 8 the the DT 19613 4851 9 Father Father NNP 19613 4851 10 stands stand VBZ 19613 4851 11 in in IN 19613 4851 12 the the DT 19613 4851 13 darkness darkness NN 19613 4851 14 of of IN 19613 4851 15 the the DT 19613 4851 16 incomprehensible incomprehensible NN 19613 4851 17 , , , 19613 4851 18 and and CC 19613 4851 19 in in IN 19613 4851 20 the the DT 19613 4851 21 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 19613 4851 22 light light NN 19613 4851 23 of of IN 19613 4851 24 perfection perfection NN 19613 4851 25 as as IN 19613 4851 26 the the DT 19613 4851 27 hidden hidden JJ 19613 4851 28 , , , 19613 4851 29 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 4851 30 God God NNP 19613 4851 31 . . . 19613 4852 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4852 2 437 437 CD 19613 4852 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4852 4 With with IN 19613 4852 5 the the DT 19613 4852 6 issuing issuing NN 19613 4852 7 forth forth RB 19613 4852 8 of of IN 19613 4852 9 the the DT 19613 4852 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4852 11 from from IN 19613 4852 12 God God NNP 19613 4852 13 began begin VBD 19613 4852 14 the the DT 19613 4852 15 realisation realisation NN 19613 4852 16 of of IN 19613 4852 17 the the DT 19613 4852 18 idea idea NN 19613 4852 19 of of IN 19613 4852 20 the the DT 19613 4852 21 world world NN 19613 4852 22 . . . 19613 4853 1 The the DT 19613 4853 2 world world NN 19613 4853 3 as as IN 19613 4853 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4853 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4853 6 : : : 19613 4853 7 kosmos kosmos NNP 19613 4853 8 noêtos noêtos NNP 19613 4853 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4853 10 is be VBZ 19613 4853 11 contained contain VBN 19613 4853 12 in in IN 19613 4853 13 the the DT 19613 4853 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4853 15 . . . 19613 4854 1 But but CC 19613 4854 2 the the DT 19613 4854 3 world world NN 19613 4854 4 is be VBZ 19613 4854 5 material material JJ 19613 4854 6 and and CC 19613 4854 7 manifold manifold NN 19613 4854 8 , , , 19613 4854 9 the the DT 19613 4854 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4854 11 is be VBZ 19613 4854 12 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 4854 13 and and CC 19613 4854 14 one one CD 19613 4854 15 . . . 19613 4855 1 Therefore therefore RB 19613 4855 2 the the DT 19613 4855 3 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4855 4 is be VBZ 19613 4855 5 not not RB 19613 4855 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4855 7 the the DT 19613 4855 8 world world NN 19613 4855 9 , , , 19613 4855 10 but but CC 19613 4855 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4855 12 is be VBZ 19613 4855 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4855 14 creator creator NN 19613 4855 15 and and CC 19613 4855 16 in in IN 19613 4855 17 a a DT 19613 4855 18 certain certain JJ 19613 4855 19 fashion fashion NN 19613 4855 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4855 21 archetype archetype NN 19613 4855 22 . . . 19613 4856 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4856 2 and and CC 19613 4856 3 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4856 4 used use VBD 19613 4856 5 the the DT 19613 4856 6 expression expression NN 19613 4856 7 " " `` 19613 4856 8 beget beget NN 19613 4856 9 " " '' 19613 4856 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4856 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4856 12 : : : 19613 4856 13 gennan gennan NNP 19613 4856 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4856 15 for for IN 19613 4856 16 the the DT 19613 4856 17 creation creation NN 19613 4856 18 of of IN 19613 4856 19 the the DT 19613 4856 20 world world NN 19613 4856 21 , , , 19613 4856 22 but but CC 19613 4856 23 in in IN 19613 4856 24 connections connection NNS 19613 4856 25 which which WDT 19613 4856 26 do do VBP 19613 4856 27 not not RB 19613 4856 28 admit admit VB 19613 4856 29 of of IN 19613 4856 30 any any DT 19613 4856 31 importance importance NN 19613 4856 32 being be VBG 19613 4856 33 attached attach VBN 19613 4856 34 to to IN 19613 4856 35 this this DT 19613 4856 36 use use NN 19613 4856 37 . . . 19613 4857 1 The the DT 19613 4857 2 world world NN 19613 4857 3 was be VBD 19613 4857 4 created create VBN 19613 4857 5 out out IN 19613 4857 6 of of IN 19613 4857 7 nothing nothing NN 19613 4857 8 after after IN 19613 4857 9 a a DT 19613 4857 10 host host NN 19613 4857 11 of of IN 19613 4857 12 spirits spirit NNS 19613 4857 13 , , , 19613 4857 14 as as IN 19613 4857 15 is be VBZ 19613 4857 16 assumed assume VBN 19613 4857 17 by by IN 19613 4857 18 most most JJS 19613 4857 19 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4857 20 , , , 19613 4857 21 had have VBD 19613 4857 22 been be VBN 19613 4857 23 created create VBN 19613 4857 24 along along IN 19613 4857 25 with with IN 19613 4857 26 heaven heaven NNP 19613 4857 27 , , , 19613 4857 28 which which WDT 19613 4857 29 is be VBZ 19613 4857 30 a a DT 19613 4857 31 higher high JJR 19613 4857 32 , , , 19613 4857 33 glorious glorious JJ 19613 4857 34 world world NN 19613 4857 35 . . . 19613 4858 1 The the DT 19613 4858 2 purpose purpose NN 19613 4858 3 of of IN 19613 4858 4 the the DT 19613 4858 5 creation creation NN 19613 4858 6 of of IN 19613 4858 7 the the DT 19613 4858 8 world world NN 19613 4858 9 was be VBD 19613 4858 10 and and CC 19613 4858 11 is be VBZ 19613 4858 12 the the DT 19613 4858 13 production production NN 19613 4858 14 of of IN 19613 4858 15 men man NNS 19613 4858 16 , , , 19613 4858 17 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4858 18 , , , 19613 4858 19 beings being NNS 19613 4858 20 possessed possess VBN 19613 4858 21 of of IN 19613 4858 22 soul soul NN 19613 4858 23 and and CC 19613 4858 24 body body NN 19613 4858 25 , , , 19613 4858 26 endowed endow VBN 19613 4858 27 with with IN 19613 4858 28 reason reason NN 19613 4858 29 and and CC 19613 4858 30 freedom freedom NN 19613 4858 31 , , , 19613 4858 32 and and CC 19613 4858 33 therefore therefore RB 19613 4858 34 made make VBN 19613 4858 35 in in IN 19613 4858 36 the the DT 19613 4858 37 image image NN 19613 4858 38 of of IN 19613 4858 39 God God NNP 19613 4858 40 ; ; : 19613 4858 41 beings being NNS 19613 4858 42 who who WP 19613 4858 43 are be VBP 19613 4858 44 to to TO 19613 4858 45 partake partake VB 19613 4858 46 of of IN 19613 4858 47 the the DT 19613 4858 48 blessedness blessedness NN 19613 4858 49 and and CC 19613 4858 50 perfection perfection NN 19613 4858 51 of of IN 19613 4858 52 God God NNP 19613 4858 53 . . . 19613 4859 1 Everything everything NN 19613 4859 2 is be VBZ 19613 4859 3 created create VBN 19613 4859 4 for for IN 19613 4859 5 man man NN 19613 4859 6 's 's POS 19613 4859 7 sake sake NN 19613 4859 8 , , , 19613 4859 9 and and CC 19613 4859 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4859 11 own own JJ 19613 4859 12 creation creation NN 19613 4859 13 is be VBZ 19613 4859 14 a a DT 19613 4859 15 proof proof NN 19613 4859 16 of of IN 19613 4859 17 the the DT 19613 4859 18 goodness goodness NN 19613 4859 19 of of IN 19613 4859 20 God God NNP 19613 4859 21 . . . 19613 4860 1 As as IN 19613 4860 2 beings being NNS 19613 4860 3 possessed possess VBN 19613 4860 4 of of IN 19613 4860 5 soul soul NN 19613 4860 6 and and CC 19613 4860 7 body body NN 19613 4860 8 , , , 19613 4860 9 men man NNS 19613 4860 10 are be VBP 19613 4860 11 neither neither CC 19613 4860 12 mortal mortal JJ 19613 4860 13 nor nor CC 19613 4860 14 immortal immortal JJ 19613 4860 15 , , , 19613 4860 16 but but CC 19613 4860 17 capable capable JJ 19613 4860 18 either either CC 19613 4860 19 of of IN 19613 4860 20 death death NN 19613 4860 21 or or CC 19613 4860 22 immortality immortality NN 19613 4860 23 . . . 19613 4861 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4861 2 438 438 CD 19613 4861 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4861 4 The the DT 19613 4861 5 condition condition NN 19613 4861 6 on on IN 19613 4861 7 which which WDT 19613 4861 8 men man NNS 19613 4861 9 can can MD 19613 4861 10 attain attain VB 19613 4861 11 the the DT 19613 4861 12 latter latter JJ 19613 4861 13 introduces introduce VBZ 19613 4861 14 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4861 15 to to IN 19613 4861 16 ethics ethic NNS 19613 4861 17 . . . 19613 4862 1 The the DT 19613 4862 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4862 3 , , , 19613 4862 4 that that IN 19613 4862 5 God God NNP 19613 4862 6 is be VBZ 19613 4862 7 also also RB 19613 4862 8 the the DT 19613 4862 9 absolute absolute JJ 19613 4862 10 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4862 11 of of IN 19613 4862 12 matter matter NN 19613 4862 13 ; ; : 19613 4862 14 that that DT 19613 4862 15 evil evil NN 19613 4862 16 can can MD 19613 4862 17 not not RB 19613 4862 18 be be VB 19613 4862 19 a a DT 19613 4862 20 quality quality NN 19613 4862 21 of of IN 19613 4862 22 matter matter NN 19613 4862 23 , , , 19613 4862 24 but but CC 19613 4862 25 rather rather RB 19613 4862 26 arose arise VBD 19613 4862 27 in in IN 19613 4862 28 time time NN 19613 4862 29 and and CC 19613 4862 30 from from IN 19613 4862 31 the the DT 19613 4862 32 free free JJ 19613 4862 33 decision decision NN 19613 4862 34 of of IN 19613 4862 35 the the DT 19613 4862 36 spirits spirit NNS 19613 4862 37 or or CC 19613 4862 38 angels angel NNS 19613 4862 39 ; ; : 19613 4862 40 and and CC 19613 4862 41 finally finally RB 19613 4862 42 that that IN 19613 4862 43 the the DT 19613 4862 44 world world NN 19613 4862 45 will will MD 19613 4862 46 have have VB 19613 4862 47 an an DT 19613 4862 48 end end NN 19613 4862 49 , , , 19613 4862 50 but but CC 19613 4862 51 God God NNP 19613 4862 52 can can MD 19613 4862 53 call call VB 19613 4862 54 the the DT 19613 4862 55 destroyed destroy VBN 19613 4862 56 material material NN 19613 4862 57 into into IN 19613 4862 58 existence existence NN 19613 4862 59 , , , 19613 4862 60 just just RB 19613 4862 61 as as IN 19613 4862 62 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4862 63 once once RB 19613 4862 64 created create VBD 19613 4862 65 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4862 66 out out IN 19613 4862 67 of of IN 19613 4862 68 nothing nothing NN 19613 4862 69 , , , 19613 4862 70 appear appear VB 19613 4862 71 in in IN 19613 4862 72 principle principle NN 19613 4862 73 to to TO 19613 4862 74 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 4862 75 the the DT 19613 4862 76 dualism dualism NN 19613 4862 77 in in IN 19613 4862 78 the the DT 19613 4862 79 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4862 80 . . . 19613 4863 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4863 2 have have VBP 19613 4863 3 the the DT 19613 4863 4 less less JJR 19613 4863 5 occasion occasion NN 19613 4863 6 to to TO 19613 4863 7 give give VB 19613 4863 8 the the DT 19613 4863 9 details detail NNS 19613 4863 10 here here RB 19613 4863 11 , , , 19613 4863 12 because because IN 19613 4863 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4863 14 are be VBP 19613 4863 15 known know VBN 19613 4863 16 from from IN 19613 4863 17 the the DT 19613 4863 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4863 19 systems system NNS 19613 4863 20 of of IN 19613 4863 21 the the DT 19613 4863 22 period period NN 19613 4863 23 , , , 19613 4863 24 especially especially RB 19613 4863 25 Philo Philo NNP 19613 4863 26 's 's POS 19613 4863 27 , , , 19613 4863 28 and and CC 19613 4863 29 vary vary VBP 19613 4863 30 in in IN 19613 4863 31 manifold manifold JJ 19613 4863 32 ways way NNS 19613 4863 33 . . . 19613 4864 1 All all PDT 19613 4864 2 the the DT 19613 4864 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4864 4 , , , 19613 4864 5 however however RB 19613 4864 6 , , , 19613 4864 7 are be VBP 19613 4864 8 imbued imbue VBN 19613 4864 9 with with IN 19613 4864 10 the the DT 19613 4864 11 idea idea NN 19613 4864 12 that that IN 19613 4864 13 this this DT 19613 4864 14 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4864 15 of of IN 19613 4864 16 God God NNP 19613 4864 17 and and CC 19613 4864 18 the the DT 19613 4864 19 world world NN 19613 4864 20 , , , 19613 4864 21 the the DT 19613 4864 22 genesis genesis NN 19613 4864 23 of of IN 19613 4864 24 the the DT 19613 4864 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4864 26 and and CC 19613 4864 27 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 4864 28 , , , 19613 4864 29 are be VBP 19613 4864 30 the the DT 19613 4864 31 most most RBS 19613 4864 32 essential essential JJ 19613 4864 33 part part NN 19613 4864 34 of of IN 19613 4864 35 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4864 36 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4864 37 . . . 19613 4865 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4865 2 439 439 CD 19613 4865 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4865 4 This this DT 19613 4865 5 conception conception NN 19613 4865 6 is be VBZ 19613 4865 7 really really RB 19613 4865 8 not not RB 19613 4865 9 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 4865 10 to to IN 19613 4865 11 the the DT 19613 4865 12 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4865 13 : : : 19613 4865 14 in in IN 19613 4865 15 the the DT 19613 4865 16 second second JJ 19613 4865 17 century century NN 19613 4865 18 the the DT 19613 4865 19 great great JJ 19613 4865 20 majority majority NN 19613 4865 21 of of IN 19613 4865 22 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4865 23 , , , 19613 4865 24 in in IN 19613 4865 25 so so RB 19613 4865 26 far far RB 19613 4865 27 as as IN 19613 4865 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4865 29 reflected reflect VBD 19613 4865 30 at at RB 19613 4865 31 all all RB 19613 4865 32 , , , 19613 4865 33 regarded regard VBN 19613 4865 34 the the DT 19613 4865 35 monotheistic monotheistic JJ 19613 4865 36 explanation explanation NN 19613 4865 37 of of IN 19613 4865 38 the the DT 19613 4865 39 world world NN 19613 4865 40 as as IN 19613 4865 41 a a DT 19613 4865 42 main main JJ 19613 4865 43 part part NN 19613 4865 44 of of IN 19613 4865 45 the the DT 19613 4865 46 Christian christian JJ 19613 4865 47 religion religion NN 19613 4865 48 . . . 19613 4866 1 The the DT 19613 4866 2 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 4866 3 view view NN 19613 4866 4 of of IN 19613 4866 5 the the DT 19613 4866 6 world world NN 19613 4866 7 as as IN 19613 4866 8 a a DT 19613 4866 9 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 4866 10 whole whole NN 19613 4866 11 , , , 19613 4866 12 of of IN 19613 4866 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4866 14 order order NN 19613 4866 15 , , , 19613 4866 16 regularity regularity NN 19613 4866 17 and and CC 19613 4866 18 beauty beauty NN 19613 4866 19 ; ; : 19613 4866 20 the the DT 19613 4866 21 certainty certainty NN 19613 4866 22 that that IN 19613 4866 23 all all PDT 19613 4866 24 this this DT 19613 4866 25 had have VBD 19613 4866 26 been be VBN 19613 4866 27 called call VBN 19613 4866 28 into into IN 19613 4866 29 existence existence NN 19613 4866 30 by by IN 19613 4866 31 an an DT 19613 4866 32 Almighty Almighty NNP 19613 4866 33 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4866 34 ; ; : 19613 4866 35 the the DT 19613 4866 36 sure sure JJ 19613 4866 37 hope hope NN 19613 4866 38 that that IN 19613 4866 39 heaven heaven NNP 19613 4866 40 and and CC 19613 4866 41 earth earth NN 19613 4866 42 will will MD 19613 4866 43 pass pass VB 19613 4866 44 away away RB 19613 4866 45 , , , 19613 4866 46 but but CC 19613 4866 47 will will MD 19613 4866 48 give give VB 19613 4866 49 place place NN 19613 4866 50 to to IN 19613 4866 51 a a DT 19613 4866 52 still still RB 19613 4866 53 more more RBR 19613 4866 54 glorious glorious JJ 19613 4866 55 structure structure NN 19613 4866 56 , , , 19613 4866 57 were be VBD 19613 4866 58 always always RB 19613 4866 59 present present JJ 19613 4866 60 , , , 19613 4866 61 and and CC 19613 4866 62 put put VBD 19613 4866 63 an an DT 19613 4866 64 end end NN 19613 4866 65 to to IN 19613 4866 66 the the DT 19613 4866 67 bright bright JJ 19613 4866 68 and and CC 19613 4866 69 gorgeously gorgeously RB 19613 4866 70 coloured colour VBN 19613 4866 71 , , , 19613 4866 72 but but CC 19613 4866 73 phantastic phantastic JJ 19613 4866 74 and and CC 19613 4866 75 vague vague JJ 19613 4866 76 , , , 19613 4866 77 cosmogonies cosmogony NNS 19613 4866 78 and and CC 19613 4866 79 theogonies theogony NNS 19613 4866 80 of of IN 19613 4866 81 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 4866 82 . . . 19613 4867 1 2 2 LS 19613 4867 2 . . . 19613 4868 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4868 2 clear clear JJ 19613 4868 3 system system NN 19613 4868 4 of of IN 19613 4868 5 morality morality NN 19613 4868 6 is be VBZ 19613 4868 7 in in IN 19613 4868 8 keeping keep VBG 19613 4868 9 with with IN 19613 4868 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4868 11 relatively relatively RB 19613 4868 12 simple simple JJ 19613 4868 13 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4868 14 . . . 19613 4869 1 In in IN 19613 4869 2 giving give VBG 19613 4869 3 man man NN 19613 4869 4 reason reason NN 19613 4869 5 and and CC 19613 4869 6 freedom freedom NN 19613 4869 7 as as IN 19613 4869 8 an an DT 19613 4869 9 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 4869 10 possession possession NN 19613 4869 11 God God NNP 19613 4869 12 destined destine VBD 19613 4869 13 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4869 14 for for IN 19613 4869 15 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 4869 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4869 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4869 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4869 19 : : : 19613 4869 20 athanasia athanasia NNP 19613 4869 21 , , , 19613 4869 22 aphtharsia aphtharsia NNP 19613 4869 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4869 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4869 25 , , , 19613 4869 26 by by IN 19613 4869 27 the the DT 19613 4869 28 attainment attainment NN 19613 4869 29 of of IN 19613 4869 30 which which WDT 19613 4869 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4869 32 was be VBD 19613 4869 33 to to TO 19613 4869 34 become become VB 19613 4869 35 a a DT 19613 4869 36 being be VBG 19613 4869 37 similar similar JJ 19613 4869 38 to to IN 19613 4869 39 God God NNP 19613 4869 40 . . . 19613 4870 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4870 2 440 440 CD 19613 4870 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4870 4 To to IN 19613 4870 5 the the DT 19613 4870 6 gift gift NN 19613 4870 7 of of IN 19613 4870 8 imperishability imperishability NN 19613 4870 9 God God NNP 19613 4870 10 , , , 19613 4870 11 however however RB 19613 4870 12 , , , 19613 4870 13 attached attach VBD 19613 4870 14 the the DT 19613 4870 15 condition condition NN 19613 4870 16 of of IN 19613 4870 17 man man NN 19613 4870 18 's 's POS 19613 4870 19 preserving preserve VBG 19613 4870 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4870 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4870 22 : : : 19613 4870 23 ta ta NNP 19613 4870 24 tês tês NNP 19613 4870 25 athanasias athanasias NNP 19613 4870 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4870 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4870 28 " " `` 19613 4870 29 the the DT 19613 4870 30 things thing NNS 19613 4870 31 of of IN 19613 4870 32 immortality immortality NN 19613 4870 33 " " '' 19613 4870 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4870 35 , , , 19613 4870 36 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4870 37 , , , 19613 4870 38 preserving preserve VBG 19613 4870 39 the the DT 19613 4870 40 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4870 41 of of IN 19613 4870 42 God God NNP 19613 4870 43 and and CC 19613 4870 44 maintaining maintain VBG 19613 4870 45 a a DT 19613 4870 46 holy holy JJ 19613 4870 47 walk walk NN 19613 4870 48 in in IN 19613 4870 49 imitation imitation NN 19613 4870 50 of of IN 19613 4870 51 the the DT 19613 4870 52 divine divine JJ 19613 4870 53 perfection perfection NN 19613 4870 54 . . . 19613 4871 1 This this DT 19613 4871 2 demand demand NN 19613 4871 3 is be VBZ 19613 4871 4 as as RB 19613 4871 5 natural natural JJ 19613 4871 6 as as IN 19613 4871 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4871 8 is be VBZ 19613 4871 9 just just RB 19613 4871 10 ; ; : 19613 4871 11 moreover moreover RB 19613 4871 12 , , , 19613 4871 13 nobody nobody NN 19613 4871 14 can can MD 19613 4871 15 fulfil fulfil VB 19613 4871 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4871 17 in in IN 19613 4871 18 man man NN 19613 4871 19 's 's POS 19613 4871 20 stead stead NN 19613 4871 21 , , , 19613 4871 22 for for IN 19613 4871 23 an an DT 19613 4871 24 essential essential JJ 19613 4871 25 feature feature NN 19613 4871 26 of of IN 19613 4871 27 virtue virtue NN 19613 4871 28 is be VBZ 19613 4871 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4871 30 being be VBG 19613 4871 31 free free JJ 19613 4871 32 , , , 19613 4871 33 independent independent JJ 19613 4871 34 action action NN 19613 4871 35 . . . 19613 4872 1 Man man NN 19613 4872 2 must must MD 19613 4872 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 4872 4 determine determine VB 19613 4872 5 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4872 6 to to TO 19613 4872 7 virtue virtue VB 19613 4872 8 by by IN 19613 4872 9 the the DT 19613 4872 10 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4872 11 that that IN 19613 4872 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4872 13 is be VBZ 19613 4872 14 only only RB 19613 4872 15 in in IN 19613 4872 16 this this DT 19613 4872 17 way way NN 19613 4872 18 obedient obedient JJ 19613 4872 19 to to IN 19613 4872 20 the the DT 19613 4872 21 Father Father NNP 19613 4872 22 of of IN 19613 4872 23 the the DT 19613 4872 24 world world NN 19613 4872 25 and and CC 19613 4872 26 able able JJ 19613 4872 27 to to TO 19613 4872 28 reckon reckon VB 19613 4872 29 on on IN 19613 4872 30 the the DT 19613 4872 31 gift gift NN 19613 4872 32 of of IN 19613 4872 33 immortality immortality NN 19613 4872 34 . . . 19613 4873 1 The the DT 19613 4873 2 conception conception NN 19613 4873 3 of of IN 19613 4873 4 the the DT 19613 4873 5 content content NN 19613 4873 6 of of IN 19613 4873 7 virtue virtue NN 19613 4873 8 , , , 19613 4873 9 however however RB 19613 4873 10 , , , 19613 4873 11 contains contain VBZ 19613 4873 12 an an DT 19613 4873 13 element element NN 19613 4873 14 which which WDT 19613 4873 15 can can MD 19613 4873 16 not not RB 19613 4873 17 be be VB 19613 4873 18 clearly clearly RB 19613 4873 19 apprehended apprehend VBN 19613 4873 20 from from IN 19613 4873 21 the the DT 19613 4873 22 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 4873 23 ; ; : 19613 4873 24 moral moral JJ 19613 4873 25 goodness goodness NN 19613 4873 26 consists consist VBZ 19613 4873 27 in in IN 19613 4873 28 letting let VBG 19613 4873 29 oneself oneself PRP 19613 4873 30 be be VB 19613 4873 31 influenced influence VBN 19613 4873 32 in in IN 19613 4873 33 no no DT 19613 4873 34 way way NN 19613 4873 35 by by IN 19613 4873 36 the the DT 19613 4873 37 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 4873 38 , , , 19613 4873 39 but but CC 19613 4873 40 in in IN 19613 4873 41 living living NN 19613 4873 42 solely solely RB 19613 4873 43 , , , 19613 4873 44 after after IN 19613 4873 45 the the DT 19613 4873 46 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4873 47 , , , 19613 4873 48 and and CC 19613 4873 49 imitating imitate VBG 19613 4873 50 the the DT 19613 4873 51 perfection perfection NN 19613 4873 52 and and CC 19613 4873 53 purity purity NN 19613 4873 54 of of IN 19613 4873 55 God God NNP 19613 4873 56 . . . 19613 4874 1 Moral moral JJ 19613 4874 2 badness badness NN 19613 4874 3 is be VBZ 19613 4874 4 giving give VBG 19613 4874 5 way way NN 19613 4874 6 to to IN 19613 4874 7 any any DT 19613 4874 8 affection affection NN 19613 4874 9 resulting result VBG 19613 4874 10 from from IN 19613 4874 11 the the DT 19613 4874 12 natural natural JJ 19613 4874 13 basis basis NN 19613 4874 14 of of IN 19613 4874 15 man man NN 19613 4874 16 . . . 19613 4875 1 The the DT 19613 4875 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4875 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 19613 4875 4 believe believe VBP 19613 4875 5 that that DT 19613 4875 6 virtue virtue NN 19613 4875 7 consists consist VBZ 19613 4875 8 negatively negatively RB 19613 4875 9 in in IN 19613 4875 10 man man NN 19613 4875 11 's 's POS 19613 4875 12 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 4875 13 of of IN 19613 4875 14 what what WP 19613 4875 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4875 16 natural natural JJ 19613 4875 17 constitution constitution NN 19613 4875 18 of of IN 19613 4875 19 soul soul NN 19613 4875 20 and and CC 19613 4875 21 body body NN 19613 4875 22 demands demand NNS 19613 4875 23 or or CC 19613 4875 24 impels impel VBZ 19613 4875 25 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4875 26 to to TO 19613 4875 27 . . . 19613 4876 1 Some some DT 19613 4876 2 express express VBP 19613 4876 3 this this DT 19613 4876 4 thought thought NN 19613 4876 5 in in IN 19613 4876 6 a a DT 19613 4876 7 more more RBR 19613 4876 8 pregnant pregnant JJ 19613 4876 9 and and CC 19613 4876 10 unvarnished unvarnished JJ 19613 4876 11 fashion fashion NN 19613 4876 12 , , , 19613 4876 13 others other NNS 19613 4876 14 in in IN 19613 4876 15 a a DT 19613 4876 16 milder milder NN 19613 4876 17 way way NN 19613 4876 18 . . . 19613 4877 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4877 2 , , , 19613 4877 3 for for IN 19613 4877 4 instance instance NN 19613 4877 5 , , , 19613 4877 6 says say VBZ 19613 4877 7 that that IN 19613 4877 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4877 9 must must MD 19613 4877 10 divest divest VB 19613 4877 11 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4877 12 of of IN 19613 4877 13 the the DT 19613 4877 14 human human JJ 19613 4877 15 nature nature NN 19613 4877 16 within within IN 19613 4877 17 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4877 18 ; ; : 19613 4877 19 but but CC 19613 4877 20 in in IN 19613 4877 21 truth truth NN 19613 4877 22 the the DT 19613 4877 23 idea idea NN 19613 4877 24 is be VBZ 19613 4877 25 the the DT 19613 4877 26 same same JJ 19613 4877 27 in in IN 19613 4877 28 all all DT 19613 4877 29 . . . 19613 4878 1 The the DT 19613 4878 2 moral moral JJ 19613 4878 3 law law NN 19613 4878 4 of of IN 19613 4878 5 nature nature NN 19613 4878 6 of of IN 19613 4878 7 which which WDT 19613 4878 8 the the DT 19613 4878 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4878 10 speak speak VBP 19613 4878 11 , , , 19613 4878 12 and and CC 19613 4878 13 which which WDT 19613 4878 14 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4878 15 find find VBP 19613 4878 16 reproduced reproduce VBN 19613 4878 17 in in IN 19613 4878 18 the the DT 19613 4878 19 clearest clear JJS 19613 4878 20 and and CC 19613 4878 21 most most RBS 19613 4878 22 beautiful beautiful JJ 19613 4878 23 way way NN 19613 4878 24 in in IN 19613 4878 25 the the DT 19613 4878 26 sayings saying NNS 19613 4878 27 of of IN 19613 4878 28 Jesus,[441 Jesus,[441 NNP 19613 4878 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4878 30 calls call VBZ 19613 4878 31 upon upon IN 19613 4878 32 man man NN 19613 4878 33 to to TO 19613 4878 34 raise raise VB 19613 4878 35 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4878 36 above above IN 19613 4878 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4878 38 nature nature NN 19613 4878 39 and and CC 19613 4878 40 to to TO 19613 4878 41 enter enter VB 19613 4878 42 into into IN 19613 4878 43 a a DT 19613 4878 44 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 4878 45 union union NN 19613 4878 46 with with IN 19613 4878 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4878 48 fellow fellow JJ 19613 4878 49 - - HYPH 19613 4878 50 man man NN 19613 4878 51 which which WDT 19613 4878 52 is be VBZ 19613 4878 53 something something NN 19613 4878 54 higher high JJR 19613 4878 55 than than IN 19613 4878 56 natural natural JJ 19613 4878 57 connections connection NNS 19613 4878 58 . . . 19613 4879 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4879 2 is be VBZ 19613 4879 3 not not RB 19613 4879 4 so so RB 19613 4879 5 much much RB 19613 4879 6 the the DT 19613 4879 7 law law NN 19613 4879 8 of of IN 19613 4879 9 love love NN 19613 4879 10 that that WDT 19613 4879 11 is be VBZ 19613 4879 12 to to TO 19613 4879 13 rule rule VB 19613 4879 14 everything everything NN 19613 4879 15 , , , 19613 4879 16 for for IN 19613 4879 17 love love NN 19613 4879 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4879 19 is be VBZ 19613 4879 20 only only RB 19613 4879 21 a a DT 19613 4879 22 phase phase NN 19613 4879 23 of of IN 19613 4879 24 a a DT 19613 4879 25 higher high JJR 19613 4879 26 law law NN 19613 4879 27 ; ; : 19613 4879 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4879 29 is be VBZ 19613 4879 30 the the DT 19613 4879 31 law law NN 19613 4879 32 governing govern VBG 19613 4879 33 the the DT 19613 4879 34 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4879 35 and and CC 19613 4879 36 sublime sublime JJ 19613 4879 37 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4879 38 , , , 19613 4879 39 who who WP 19613 4879 40 , , , 19613 4879 41 as as IN 19613 4879 42 being be VBG 19613 4879 43 the the DT 19613 4879 44 most most RBS 19613 4879 45 exalted exalted JJ 19613 4879 46 existence existence NN 19613 4879 47 on on IN 19613 4879 48 this this DT 19613 4879 49 earth earth NN 19613 4879 50 , , , 19613 4879 51 is be VBZ 19613 4879 52 too too RB 19613 4879 53 noble noble JJ 19613 4879 54 for for IN 19613 4879 55 the the DT 19613 4879 56 world world NN 19613 4879 57 . . . 19613 4880 1 Raised raise VBD 19613 4880 2 already already RB 19613 4880 3 in in IN 19613 4880 4 this this DT 19613 4880 5 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4880 6 beyond beyond IN 19613 4880 7 time time NN 19613 4880 8 and and CC 19613 4880 9 space space NN 19613 4880 10 , , , 19613 4880 11 beyond beyond IN 19613 4880 12 the the DT 19613 4880 13 partial partial NN 19613 4880 14 and and CC 19613 4880 15 the the DT 19613 4880 16 finite finite NNP 19613 4880 17 , , , 19613 4880 18 the the DT 19613 4880 19 man man NN 19613 4880 20 of of IN 19613 4880 21 God God NNP 19613 4880 22 , , , 19613 4880 23 even even RB 19613 4880 24 while while IN 19613 4880 25 upon upon IN 19613 4880 26 the the DT 19613 4880 27 earth earth NN 19613 4880 28 , , , 19613 4880 29 is be VBZ 19613 4880 30 to to TO 19613 4880 31 hasten hasten VB 19613 4880 32 to to IN 19613 4880 33 the the DT 19613 4880 34 Father Father NNP 19613 4880 35 of of IN 19613 4880 36 Light Light NNP 19613 4880 37 . . . 19613 4881 1 By by IN 19613 4881 2 equanimity equanimity NN 19613 4881 3 , , , 19613 4881 4 absence absence NN 19613 4881 5 of of IN 19613 4881 6 desires desire NNS 19613 4881 7 , , , 19613 4881 8 purity purity NN 19613 4881 9 , , , 19613 4881 10 and and CC 19613 4881 11 goodness goodness NN 19613 4881 12 , , , 19613 4881 13 which which WDT 19613 4881 14 are be VBP 19613 4881 15 the the DT 19613 4881 16 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4881 17 results result NNS 19613 4881 18 of of IN 19613 4881 19 clear clear JJ 19613 4881 20 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4881 21 , , , 19613 4881 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4881 23 is be VBZ 19613 4881 24 to to TO 19613 4881 25 show show VB 19613 4881 26 that that IN 19613 4881 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4881 28 has have VBZ 19613 4881 29 already already RB 19613 4881 30 risen rise VBN 19613 4881 31 above above IN 19613 4881 32 the the DT 19613 4881 33 transient transient NN 19613 4881 34 through through IN 19613 4881 35 gazing gaze VBG 19613 4881 36 on on IN 19613 4881 37 the the DT 19613 4881 38 imperishable imperishable JJ 19613 4881 39 and and CC 19613 4881 40 through through IN 19613 4881 41 the the DT 19613 4881 42 enjoyment enjoyment NN 19613 4881 43 of of IN 19613 4881 44 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4881 45 , , , 19613 4881 46 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 4881 47 though though IN 19613 4881 48 the the DT 19613 4881 49 latter latter NN 19613 4881 50 still still RB 19613 4881 51 be be VBP 19613 4881 52 . . . 19613 4882 1 If if IN 19613 4882 2 thus thus RB 19613 4882 3 , , , 19613 4882 4 a a DT 19613 4882 5 suffering suffer VBG 19613 4882 6 hero hero NN 19613 4882 7 , , , 19613 4882 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4882 9 has have VBZ 19613 4882 10 stood stand VBN 19613 4882 11 the the DT 19613 4882 12 test test NN 19613 4882 13 on on IN 19613 4882 14 earth earth NN 19613 4882 15 , , , 19613 4882 16 if if IN 19613 4882 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4882 18 has have VBZ 19613 4882 19 become become VBN 19613 4882 20 dead dead JJ 19613 4882 21 to to IN 19613 4882 22 the the DT 19613 4882 23 world,[442 world,[442 NN 19613 4882 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4882 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4882 26 may may MD 19613 4882 27 be be VB 19613 4882 28 sure sure JJ 19613 4882 29 that that IN 19613 4882 30 in in IN 19613 4882 31 the the DT 19613 4882 32 life life NN 19613 4882 33 to to TO 19613 4882 34 come come VB 19613 4882 35 God God NNP 19613 4882 36 will will MD 19613 4882 37 bestow bestow VB 19613 4882 38 on on IN 19613 4882 39 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4882 40 the the DT 19613 4882 41 gift gift NN 19613 4882 42 of of IN 19613 4882 43 immortality immortality NN 19613 4882 44 , , , 19613 4882 45 which which WDT 19613 4882 46 includes include VBZ 19613 4882 47 the the DT 19613 4882 48 direct direct JJ 19613 4882 49 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 4882 50 of of IN 19613 4882 51 God God NNP 19613 4882 52 together together RB 19613 4882 53 with with IN 19613 4882 54 the the DT 19613 4882 55 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4882 56 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4882 57 that that WDT 19613 4882 58 flows flow VBZ 19613 4882 59 from from IN 19613 4882 60 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4882 61 . . . 19613 4883 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4883 2 443 443 CD 19613 4883 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4883 4 Conversely conversely RB 19613 4883 5 , , , 19613 4883 6 the the DT 19613 4883 7 vicious vicious JJ 19613 4883 8 man man NN 19613 4883 9 is be VBZ 19613 4883 10 given give VBN 19613 4883 11 over over RP 19613 4883 12 to to IN 19613 4883 13 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4883 14 death death NN 19613 4883 15 , , , 19613 4883 16 and and CC 19613 4883 17 in in IN 19613 4883 18 this this DT 19613 4883 19 punishment punishment NN 19613 4883 20 the the DT 19613 4883 21 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4883 22 of of IN 19613 4883 23 God God NNP 19613 4883 24 is be VBZ 19613 4883 25 quite quite RB 19613 4883 26 as as RB 19613 4883 27 plainly plainly RB 19613 4883 28 manifested manifest VBN 19613 4883 29 , , , 19613 4883 30 as as IN 19613 4883 31 in in IN 19613 4883 32 the the DT 19613 4883 33 reward reward NN 19613 4883 34 of of IN 19613 4883 35 everlasting everlasting JJ 19613 4883 36 life life NN 19613 4883 37 . . . 19613 4884 1 3 3 LS 19613 4884 2 . . . 19613 4885 1 While while IN 19613 4885 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4885 3 is be VBZ 19613 4885 4 certain certain JJ 19613 4885 5 that that IN 19613 4885 6 virtue virtue NN 19613 4885 7 is be VBZ 19613 4885 8 a a DT 19613 4885 9 matter matter NN 19613 4885 10 of of IN 19613 4885 11 freedom freedom NN 19613 4885 12 , , , 19613 4885 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4885 14 is be VBZ 19613 4885 15 just just RB 19613 4885 16 as as RB 19613 4885 17 sure sure JJ 19613 4885 18 that that IN 19613 4885 19 no no DT 19613 4885 20 soul soul NN 19613 4885 21 is be VBZ 19613 4885 22 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4885 23 unless unless IN 19613 4885 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4885 25 follows follow VBZ 19613 4885 26 the the DT 19613 4885 27 will will NN 19613 4885 28 of of IN 19613 4885 29 God God NNP 19613 4885 30 , , , 19613 4885 31 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4885 32 , , , 19613 4885 33 knows know VBZ 19613 4885 34 and and CC 19613 4885 35 judges judge NNS 19613 4885 36 of of IN 19613 4885 37 God God NNP 19613 4885 38 and and CC 19613 4885 39 all all DT 19613 4885 40 things thing NNS 19613 4885 41 as as IN 19613 4885 42 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4885 43 must must MD 19613 4885 44 be be VB 19613 4885 45 known know VBN 19613 4885 46 and and CC 19613 4885 47 judged judge VBN 19613 4885 48 of of IN 19613 4885 49 ; ; : 19613 4885 50 and and CC 19613 4885 51 fulfils fulfil VBZ 19613 4885 52 the the DT 19613 4885 53 commandments commandment NNS 19613 4885 54 of of IN 19613 4885 55 God God NNP 19613 4885 56 . . . 19613 4886 1 This this DT 19613 4886 2 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 4886 3 a a DT 19613 4886 4 revelation revelation NN 19613 4886 5 of of IN 19613 4886 6 God God NNP 19613 4886 7 through through IN 19613 4886 8 the the DT 19613 4886 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4886 10 . . . 19613 4887 1 A a DT 19613 4887 2 revelation revelation NN 19613 4887 3 of of IN 19613 4887 4 God God NNP 19613 4887 5 , , , 19613 4887 6 complete complete JJ 19613 4887 7 in in IN 19613 4887 8 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4887 9 and and CC 19613 4887 10 mediated mediate VBN 19613 4887 11 by by IN 19613 4887 12 the the DT 19613 4887 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4887 14 , , , 19613 4887 15 is be VBZ 19613 4887 16 found find VBN 19613 4887 17 in in IN 19613 4887 18 the the DT 19613 4887 19 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 4887 20 and and CC 19613 4887 21 in in IN 19613 4887 22 the the DT 19613 4887 23 constitution constitution NNP 19613 4887 24 of of IN 19613 4887 25 man man NN 19613 4887 26 , , , 19613 4887 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4887 28 being be VBG 19613 4887 29 created create VBN 19613 4887 30 in in IN 19613 4887 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4887 32 Maker maker NN 19613 4887 33 's 's POS 19613 4887 34 image image NN 19613 4887 35 . . . 19613 4888 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4888 2 444 444 CD 19613 4888 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4888 4 But but CC 19613 4888 5 experience experience NN 19613 4888 6 has have VBZ 19613 4888 7 shown show VBN 19613 4888 8 that that IN 19613 4888 9 this this DT 19613 4888 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 4888 11 is be VBZ 19613 4888 12 insufficient insufficient JJ 19613 4888 13 to to TO 19613 4888 14 enable enable VB 19613 4888 15 men man NNS 19613 4888 16 to to TO 19613 4888 17 retain retain VB 19613 4888 18 clear clear JJ 19613 4888 19 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4888 20 . . . 19613 4889 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4889 2 yielded yield VBD 19613 4889 3 to to IN 19613 4889 4 the the DT 19613 4889 5 seduction seduction NN 19613 4889 6 of of IN 19613 4889 7 evil evil JJ 19613 4889 8 demons demon NNS 19613 4889 9 , , , 19613 4889 10 who who WP 19613 4889 11 , , , 19613 4889 12 by by IN 19613 4889 13 God God NNP 19613 4889 14 's 's POS 19613 4889 15 sufferance sufferance NN 19613 4889 16 , , , 19613 4889 17 took take VBD 19613 4889 18 possession possession NN 19613 4889 19 of of IN 19613 4889 20 the the DT 19613 4889 21 world world NN 19613 4889 22 , , , 19613 4889 23 and and CC 19613 4889 24 availed avail VBD 19613 4889 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4889 26 of of IN 19613 4889 27 man man NN 19613 4889 28 's 's POS 19613 4889 29 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 4889 30 side side NN 19613 4889 31 to to TO 19613 4889 32 draw draw VB 19613 4889 33 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4889 34 away away RB 19613 4889 35 from from IN 19613 4889 36 the the DT 19613 4889 37 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 4889 38 of of IN 19613 4889 39 the the DT 19613 4889 40 divine divine JJ 19613 4889 41 and and CC 19613 4889 42 lead lead VBP 19613 4889 43 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4889 44 to to IN 19613 4889 45 the the DT 19613 4889 46 earthly earthly JJ 19613 4889 47 . . . 19613 4890 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4890 2 445 445 CD 19613 4890 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4890 4 The the DT 19613 4890 5 results result NNS 19613 4890 6 of of IN 19613 4890 7 this this DT 19613 4890 8 temptation temptation NN 19613 4890 9 appeared appear VBD 19613 4890 10 in in IN 19613 4890 11 the the DT 19613 4890 12 facts fact NNS 19613 4890 13 that that WDT 19613 4890 14 humanity humanity NN 19613 4890 15 as as IN 19613 4890 16 a a DT 19613 4890 17 whole whole NN 19613 4890 18 fell fall VBD 19613 4890 19 a a DT 19613 4890 20 prey prey NN 19613 4890 21 to to IN 19613 4890 22 error error NN 19613 4890 23 , , , 19613 4890 24 was be VBD 19613 4890 25 subjected subject VBN 19613 4890 26 to to IN 19613 4890 27 the the DT 19613 4890 28 bonds bond NNS 19613 4890 29 of of IN 19613 4890 30 the the DT 19613 4890 31 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 4890 32 and and CC 19613 4890 33 of of IN 19613 4890 34 the the DT 19613 4890 35 demons demon NNS 19613 4890 36 , , , 19613 4890 37 and and CC 19613 4890 38 therefore therefore RB 19613 4890 39 became become VBD 19613 4890 40 doomed doom VBN 19613 4890 41 to to IN 19613 4890 42 death death NN 19613 4890 43 , , , 19613 4890 44 which which WDT 19613 4890 45 is be VBZ 19613 4890 46 at at IN 19613 4890 47 once once RB 19613 4890 48 a a DT 19613 4890 49 punishment punishment NN 19613 4890 50 and and CC 19613 4890 51 the the DT 19613 4890 52 natural natural JJ 19613 4890 53 consequence consequence NN 19613 4890 54 of of IN 19613 4890 55 want want NN 19613 4890 56 of of IN 19613 4890 57 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4890 58 of of IN 19613 4890 59 God God NNP 19613 4890 60 . . . 19613 4891 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4891 2 446 446 CD 19613 4891 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4891 4 Hence hence RB 19613 4891 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4891 6 required require VBD 19613 4891 7 fresh fresh JJ 19613 4891 8 efforts effort NNS 19613 4891 9 of of IN 19613 4891 10 the the DT 19613 4891 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4891 12 to to TO 19613 4891 13 free free JJ 19613 4891 14 men man NNS 19613 4891 15 from from IN 19613 4891 16 a a DT 19613 4891 17 state state NN 19613 4891 18 which which WDT 19613 4891 19 is be VBZ 19613 4891 20 indeed indeed RB 19613 4891 21 in in IN 19613 4891 22 no no DT 19613 4891 23 instance instance NN 19613 4891 24 an an DT 19613 4891 25 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 4891 26 necessity necessity NN 19613 4891 27 , , , 19613 4891 28 though though IN 19613 4891 29 a a DT 19613 4891 30 sad sad JJ 19613 4891 31 fact fact NN 19613 4891 32 in in IN 19613 4891 33 the the DT 19613 4891 34 case case NN 19613 4891 35 of of IN 19613 4891 36 almost almost RB 19613 4891 37 all all DT 19613 4891 38 . . . 19613 4892 1 For for IN 19613 4892 2 very very RB 19613 4892 3 few few JJ 19613 4892 4 are be VBP 19613 4892 5 now now RB 19613 4892 6 able able JJ 19613 4892 7 to to TO 19613 4892 8 recognise recognise VB 19613 4892 9 the the DT 19613 4892 10 one one CD 19613 4892 11 true true JJ 19613 4892 12 God God NNP 19613 4892 13 from from IN 19613 4892 14 the the DT 19613 4892 15 order order NN 19613 4892 16 of of IN 19613 4892 17 the the DT 19613 4892 18 universe universe NN 19613 4892 19 and and CC 19613 4892 20 from from IN 19613 4892 21 the the DT 19613 4892 22 moral moral JJ 19613 4892 23 law law NN 19613 4892 24 implanted implant VBN 19613 4892 25 in in IN 19613 4892 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4892 27 ; ; : 19613 4892 28 nor nor CC 19613 4892 29 can can MD 19613 4892 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4892 31 withstand withstand VB 19613 4892 32 the the DT 19613 4892 33 power power NN 19613 4892 34 of of IN 19613 4892 35 the the DT 19613 4892 36 demons demon NNS 19613 4892 37 ruling rule VBG 19613 4892 38 in in IN 19613 4892 39 the the DT 19613 4892 40 world world NN 19613 4892 41 and and CC 19613 4892 42 use use VB 19613 4892 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4892 44 freedom freedom NN 19613 4892 45 to to TO 19613 4892 46 imitate imitate VB 19613 4892 47 the the DT 19613 4892 48 virtues virtue NNS 19613 4892 49 of of IN 19613 4892 50 God God NNP 19613 4892 51 . . . 19613 4893 1 Therefore therefore RB 19613 4893 2 the the DT 19613 4893 3 Almighty Almighty NNP 19613 4893 4 in in IN 19613 4893 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4893 6 goodness goodness NN 19613 4893 7 employed employ VBN 19613 4893 8 new new JJ 19613 4893 9 means mean NNS 19613 4893 10 through through IN 19613 4893 11 the the DT 19613 4893 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4893 13 to to TO 19613 4893 14 call call VB 19613 4893 15 men man NNS 19613 4893 16 back back RB 19613 4893 17 from from IN 19613 4893 18 the the DT 19613 4893 19 error error NN 19613 4893 20 of of IN 19613 4893 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4893 22 ways way NNS 19613 4893 23 , , , 19613 4893 24 to to TO 19613 4893 25 overthrow overthrow VB 19613 4893 26 the the DT 19613 4893 27 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4893 28 of of IN 19613 4893 29 the the DT 19613 4893 30 demons demon NNS 19613 4893 31 upon upon IN 19613 4893 32 earth earth NN 19613 4893 33 , , , 19613 4893 34 and and CC 19613 4893 35 to to TO 19613 4893 36 correct correct VB 19613 4893 37 the the DT 19613 4893 38 disturbed disturbed JJ 19613 4893 39 course course NN 19613 4893 40 of of IN 19613 4893 41 the the DT 19613 4893 42 world world NN 19613 4893 43 before before IN 19613 4893 44 the the DT 19613 4893 45 end end NN 19613 4893 46 has have VBZ 19613 4893 47 yet yet RB 19613 4893 48 come come VBN 19613 4893 49 . . . 19613 4894 1 From from IN 19613 4894 2 the the DT 19613 4894 3 earliest early JJS 19613 4894 4 times time NNS 19613 4894 5 the the DT 19613 4894 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4894 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4894 8 the the DT 19613 4894 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 4894 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4894 11 has have VBZ 19613 4894 12 descended descend VBN 19613 4894 13 on on IN 19613 4894 14 such such JJ 19613 4894 15 men man NNS 19613 4894 16 as as IN 19613 4894 17 preserved preserve VBD 19613 4894 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4894 19 souls soul NNS 19613 4894 20 pure pure JJ 19613 4894 21 , , , 19613 4894 22 and and CC 19613 4894 23 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 4894 24 on on IN 19613 4894 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4894 26 , , , 19613 4894 27 through through IN 19613 4894 28 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 4894 29 , , , 19613 4894 30 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4894 31 of of IN 19613 4894 32 the the DT 19613 4894 33 truth truth NN 19613 4894 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4894 35 with with IN 19613 4894 36 reference reference NN 19613 4894 37 to to IN 19613 4894 38 God God NNP 19613 4894 39 , , , 19613 4894 40 freedom freedom NN 19613 4894 41 , , , 19613 4894 42 virtue virtue NN 19613 4894 43 , , , 19613 4894 44 the the DT 19613 4894 45 demons demon NNS 19613 4894 46 , , , 19613 4894 47 the the DT 19613 4894 48 origin origin NN 19613 4894 49 of of IN 19613 4894 50 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 4894 51 , , , 19613 4894 52 the the DT 19613 4894 53 judgment judgment NN 19613 4894 54 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4894 55 to to TO 19613 4894 56 be be VB 19613 4894 57 imparted impart VBN 19613 4894 58 by by IN 19613 4894 59 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4894 60 to to IN 19613 4894 61 others other NNS 19613 4894 62 . . . 19613 4895 1 These these DT 19613 4895 2 are be VBP 19613 4895 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4895 4 " " `` 19613 4895 5 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4895 6 . . . 19613 4895 7 " " '' 19613 4896 1 Such such JJ 19613 4896 2 men man NNS 19613 4896 3 are be VBP 19613 4896 4 rare rare JJ 19613 4896 5 among among IN 19613 4896 6 the the DT 19613 4896 7 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 4896 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4896 9 and and CC 19613 4896 10 according accord VBG 19613 4896 11 to to IN 19613 4896 12 some some DT 19613 4896 13 not not RB 19613 4896 14 found find VBN 19613 4896 15 at at RB 19613 4896 16 all all RB 19613 4896 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4896 18 , , , 19613 4896 19 but but CC 19613 4896 20 numerous numerous JJ 19613 4896 21 among among IN 19613 4896 22 the the DT 19613 4896 23 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 4896 24 , , , 19613 4896 25 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4896 26 , , , 19613 4896 27 among among IN 19613 4896 28 the the DT 19613 4896 29 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 4896 30 people people NNS 19613 4896 31 . . . 19613 4897 1 Taught teach VBN 19613 4897 2 by by IN 19613 4897 3 God God NNP 19613 4897 4 , , , 19613 4897 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4897 6 announced announce VBD 19613 4897 7 the the DT 19613 4897 8 truth truth NN 19613 4897 9 about about IN 19613 4897 10 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4897 11 , , , 19613 4897 12 and and CC 19613 4897 13 under under IN 19613 4897 14 the the DT 19613 4897 15 promptings prompting NNS 19613 4897 16 of of IN 19613 4897 17 the the DT 19613 4897 18 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4897 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4897 20 also also RB 19613 4897 21 committed commit VBD 19613 4897 22 the the DT 19613 4897 23 revelations revelation NNS 19613 4897 24 to to IN 19613 4897 25 writings writing NNS 19613 4897 26 , , , 19613 4897 27 which which WDT 19613 4897 28 therefore therefore RB 19613 4897 29 , , , 19613 4897 30 as as IN 19613 4897 31 being be VBG 19613 4897 32 inspired inspire VBN 19613 4897 33 , , , 19613 4897 34 are be VBP 19613 4897 35 an an DT 19613 4897 36 authentic authentic JJ 19613 4897 37 record record NN 19613 4897 38 of of IN 19613 4897 39 the the DT 19613 4897 40 whole whole JJ 19613 4897 41 truth truth NN 19613 4897 42 . . . 19613 4898 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4898 2 447 447 CD 19613 4898 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4898 4 To to IN 19613 4898 5 some some DT 19613 4898 6 of of IN 19613 4898 7 the the DT 19613 4898 8 most most RBS 19613 4898 9 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4898 10 among among IN 19613 4898 11 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4898 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4898 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4898 14 even even RB 19613 4898 15 appeared appear VBD 19613 4898 16 in in IN 19613 4898 17 human human JJ 19613 4898 18 form form NN 19613 4898 19 and and CC 19613 4898 20 gave give VBD 19613 4898 21 directions direction NNS 19613 4898 22 . . . 19613 4899 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4899 2 then then RB 19613 4899 3 is be VBZ 19613 4899 4 a a DT 19613 4899 5 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4899 6 , , , 19613 4899 7 who who WP 19613 4899 8 receives receive VBZ 19613 4899 9 and and CC 19613 4899 10 follows follow VBZ 19613 4899 11 these these DT 19613 4899 12 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4899 13 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4899 14 , , , 19613 4899 15 that that WDT 19613 4899 16 have have VBP 19613 4899 17 ever ever RB 19613 4899 18 been be VBN 19613 4899 19 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 4899 20 afresh afresh RB 19613 4899 21 from from IN 19613 4899 22 the the DT 19613 4899 23 beginning beginning NN 19613 4899 24 of of IN 19613 4899 25 the the DT 19613 4899 26 world world NN 19613 4899 27 down down RP 19613 4899 28 to to IN 19613 4899 29 the the DT 19613 4899 30 present present JJ 19613 4899 31 time time NN 19613 4899 32 , , , 19613 4899 33 and and CC 19613 4899 34 are be VBP 19613 4899 35 summed sum VBN 19613 4899 36 up up RP 19613 4899 37 in in IN 19613 4899 38 the the DT 19613 4899 39 Old Old NNP 19613 4899 40 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4899 41 . . . 19613 4900 1 Such such PDT 19613 4900 2 a a DT 19613 4900 3 one one NN 19613 4900 4 is be VBZ 19613 4900 5 enabled enable VBN 19613 4900 6 even even RB 19613 4900 7 now now RB 19613 4900 8 to to TO 19613 4900 9 rescue rescue VB 19613 4900 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4900 11 soul soul NN 19613 4900 12 from from IN 19613 4900 13 the the DT 19613 4900 14 rule rule NN 19613 4900 15 of of IN 19613 4900 16 the the DT 19613 4900 17 demons demon NNS 19613 4900 18 , , , 19613 4900 19 and and CC 19613 4900 20 may may MD 19613 4900 21 confidently confidently RB 19613 4900 22 expect expect VB 19613 4900 23 the the DT 19613 4900 24 gift gift NN 19613 4900 25 of of IN 19613 4900 26 immortality immortality NN 19613 4900 27 . . . 19613 4901 1 With with IN 19613 4901 2 the the DT 19613 4901 3 majority majority NN 19613 4901 4 of of IN 19613 4901 5 the the DT 19613 4901 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4901 7 " " `` 19613 4901 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4901 9 " " '' 19613 4901 10 seems seem VBZ 19613 4901 11 to to TO 19613 4901 12 be be VB 19613 4901 13 exhausted exhaust VBN 19613 4901 14 in in IN 19613 4901 15 these these DT 19613 4901 16 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4901 17 ; ; : 19613 4901 18 in in IN 19613 4901 19 fact fact NN 19613 4901 20 , , , 19613 4901 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4901 22 do do VBP 19613 4901 23 not not RB 19613 4901 24 even even RB 19613 4901 25 consider consider VB 19613 4901 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4901 27 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4901 28 to to TO 19613 4901 29 mention mention VB 19613 4901 30 _ _ NNP 19613 4901 31 ex ex NNP 19613 4901 32 professo professo JJ 19613 4901 33 _ _ IN 19613 4901 34 the the DT 19613 4901 35 appearance appearance NN 19613 4901 36 of of IN 19613 4901 37 the the DT 19613 4901 38 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4901 39 in in IN 19613 4901 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4901 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4901 42 see see VB 19613 4901 43 above above RB 19613 4901 44 , , , 19613 4901 45 p. p. NN 19613 4901 46 189 189 CD 19613 4901 47 ff ff NNP 19613 4901 48 . . NNP 19613 4901 49 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4901 50 . . . 19613 4902 1 But but CC 19613 4902 2 , , , 19613 4902 3 while while IN 19613 4902 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4902 5 is be VBZ 19613 4902 6 certain certain JJ 19613 4902 7 that that IN 19613 4902 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4902 9 all all DT 19613 4902 10 recognised recognise VBD 19613 4902 11 that that IN 19613 4902 12 the the DT 19613 4902 13 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4902 14 of of IN 19613 4902 15 the the DT 19613 4902 16 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4902 17 contained contain VBD 19613 4902 18 the the DT 19613 4902 19 full full JJ 19613 4902 20 revelation revelation NN 19613 4902 21 of of IN 19613 4902 22 the the DT 19613 4902 23 truth truth NN 19613 4902 24 , , , 19613 4902 25 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4902 26 would would MD 19613 4902 27 be be VB 19613 4902 28 quite quite RB 19613 4902 29 wrong wrong JJ 19613 4902 30 in in IN 19613 4902 31 assuming assume VBG 19613 4902 32 that that IN 19613 4902 33 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4902 34 view view VBP 19613 4902 35 the the DT 19613 4902 36 appearance appearance NN 19613 4902 37 and and CC 19613 4902 38 history history NN 19613 4902 39 of of IN 19613 4902 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4902 41 as as IN 19613 4902 42 of of IN 19613 4902 43 no no DT 19613 4902 44 significance significance NN 19613 4902 45 . . . 19613 4903 1 In in IN 19613 4903 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4903 3 presentations presentation NNS 19613 4903 4 some some DT 19613 4903 5 of of IN 19613 4903 6 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4903 7 no no RB 19613 4903 8 doubt doubt RB 19613 4903 9 contented content VBD 19613 4903 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4903 11 with with IN 19613 4903 12 setting set VBG 19613 4903 13 forth forth RP 19613 4903 14 the the DT 19613 4903 15 most most RBS 19613 4903 16 rational rational JJ 19613 4903 17 and and CC 19613 4903 18 simple simple JJ 19613 4903 19 elements element NNS 19613 4903 20 , , , 19613 4903 21 and and CC 19613 4903 22 therefore therefore RB 19613 4903 23 took take VBD 19613 4903 24 almost almost RB 19613 4903 25 no no DT 19613 4903 26 notice notice NN 19613 4903 27 of of IN 19613 4903 28 the the DT 19613 4903 29 historical historical JJ 19613 4903 30 ; ; : 19613 4903 31 but but CC 19613 4903 32 even even RB 19613 4903 33 in in IN 19613 4903 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4903 35 case case NN 19613 4903 36 certain certain JJ 19613 4903 37 indications indication NNS 19613 4903 38 show show VBP 19613 4903 39 that that IN 19613 4903 40 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4903 41 regarded regard VBD 19613 4903 42 the the DT 19613 4903 43 manifestation manifestation NN 19613 4903 44 of of IN 19613 4903 45 the the DT 19613 4903 46 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4903 47 in in IN 19613 4903 48 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4903 49 as as IN 19613 4903 50 of of IN 19613 4903 51 special special JJ 19613 4903 52 moment moment NN 19613 4903 53 . . . 19613 4904 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4904 2 448 448 CD 19613 4904 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4904 4 For for IN 19613 4904 5 the the DT 19613 4904 6 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4904 7 utterances utterance NNS 19613 4904 8 , , , 19613 4904 9 as as IN 19613 4904 10 found find VBN 19613 4904 11 from from IN 19613 4904 12 the the DT 19613 4904 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 4904 14 , , , 19613 4904 15 require require VB 19613 4904 16 an an DT 19613 4904 17 attestation attestation NN 19613 4904 18 , , , 19613 4904 19 the the DT 19613 4904 20 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4904 21 teaching teaching NN 19613 4904 22 requires require VBZ 19613 4904 23 a a DT 19613 4904 24 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 4904 25 , , , 19613 4904 26 so so IN 19613 4904 27 that that IN 19613 4904 28 misguided misguided JJ 19613 4904 29 humanity humanity NN 19613 4904 30 may may MD 19613 4904 31 accept accept VB 19613 4904 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4904 33 and and CC 19613 4904 34 no no RB 19613 4904 35 longer longer RB 19613 4904 36 take take VB 19613 4904 37 error error NN 19613 4904 38 for for IN 19613 4904 39 truth truth NN 19613 4904 40 and and CC 19613 4904 41 truth truth NN 19613 4904 42 for for IN 19613 4904 43 error error NN 19613 4904 44 . . . 19613 4905 1 The the DT 19613 4905 2 strongest strong JJS 19613 4905 3 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 4905 4 imaginable imaginable NN 19613 4905 5 is be VBZ 19613 4905 6 found find VBN 19613 4905 7 in in IN 19613 4905 8 the the DT 19613 4905 9 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 4905 10 of of IN 19613 4905 11 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 4905 12 . . . 19613 4906 1 Since since IN 19613 4906 2 no no DT 19613 4906 3 man man NN 19613 4906 4 is be VBZ 19613 4906 5 able able JJ 19613 4906 6 to to TO 19613 4906 7 foretell foretell VB 19613 4906 8 what what WP 19613 4906 9 is be VBZ 19613 4906 10 to to TO 19613 4906 11 come come VB 19613 4906 12 , , , 19613 4906 13 the the DT 19613 4906 14 prediction prediction NN 19613 4906 15 of of IN 19613 4906 16 the the DT 19613 4906 17 future future NN 19613 4906 18 accompanying accompany VBG 19613 4906 19 a a DT 19613 4906 20 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 4906 21 proves prove VBZ 19613 4906 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4906 23 divine divine JJ 19613 4906 24 origin origin NN 19613 4906 25 . . . 19613 4907 1 God God NNP 19613 4907 2 , , , 19613 4907 3 in in IN 19613 4907 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4907 5 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 4907 6 goodness goodness NN 19613 4907 7 , , , 19613 4907 8 not not RB 19613 4907 9 only only RB 19613 4907 10 inspired inspire VBD 19613 4907 11 the the DT 19613 4907 12 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4907 13 , , , 19613 4907 14 through through IN 19613 4907 15 the the DT 19613 4907 16 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4907 17 , , , 19613 4907 18 with with IN 19613 4907 19 the the DT 19613 4907 20 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4907 21 of of IN 19613 4907 22 truth truth NN 19613 4907 23 , , , 19613 4907 24 but but CC 19613 4907 25 has have VBZ 19613 4907 26 from from IN 19613 4907 27 the the DT 19613 4907 28 beginning beginning NN 19613 4907 29 put put VBD 19613 4907 30 numerous numerous JJ 19613 4907 31 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4907 32 in in IN 19613 4907 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4907 34 mouth mouth NN 19613 4907 35 . . . 19613 4908 1 These these DT 19613 4908 2 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4908 3 were be VBD 19613 4908 4 detailed detailed JJ 19613 4908 5 and and CC 19613 4908 6 manifold manifold JJ 19613 4908 7 ; ; : 19613 4908 8 the the DT 19613 4908 9 great great JJ 19613 4908 10 majority majority NN 19613 4908 11 of of IN 19613 4908 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4908 13 referred refer VBD 19613 4908 14 to to IN 19613 4908 15 a a DT 19613 4908 16 more more RBR 19613 4908 17 prolonged prolonged JJ 19613 4908 18 appearance appearance NN 19613 4908 19 of of IN 19613 4908 20 the the DT 19613 4908 21 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4908 22 in in IN 19613 4908 23 human human JJ 19613 4908 24 form form NN 19613 4908 25 at at IN 19613 4908 26 the the DT 19613 4908 27 end end NN 19613 4908 28 of of IN 19613 4908 29 history history NN 19613 4908 30 , , , 19613 4908 31 and and CC 19613 4908 32 to to IN 19613 4908 33 a a DT 19613 4908 34 future future JJ 19613 4908 35 judgment judgment NN 19613 4908 36 . . . 19613 4909 1 Now now RB 19613 4909 2 , , , 19613 4909 3 so so RB 19613 4909 4 long long RB 19613 4909 5 as as IN 19613 4909 6 the the DT 19613 4909 7 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4909 8 had have VBD 19613 4909 9 not not RB 19613 4909 10 yet yet RB 19613 4909 11 come come VBN 19613 4909 12 to to TO 19613 4909 13 pass pass VB 19613 4909 14 , , , 19613 4909 15 the the DT 19613 4909 16 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4909 17 of of IN 19613 4909 18 the the DT 19613 4909 19 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4909 20 were be VBD 19613 4909 21 not not RB 19613 4909 22 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 4909 23 impressive impressive JJ 19613 4909 24 , , , 19613 4909 25 for for IN 19613 4909 26 the the DT 19613 4909 27 only only JJ 19613 4909 28 sure sure JJ 19613 4909 29 witness witness NN 19613 4909 30 of of IN 19613 4909 31 the the DT 19613 4909 32 truth truth NN 19613 4909 33 is be VBZ 19613 4909 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4909 35 outward outward JJ 19613 4909 36 attestation attestation NN 19613 4909 37 . . . 19613 4910 1 In in IN 19613 4910 2 the the DT 19613 4910 3 history history NN 19613 4910 4 of of IN 19613 4910 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4910 6 , , , 19613 4910 7 however however RB 19613 4910 8 , , , 19613 4910 9 the the DT 19613 4910 10 majority majority NN 19613 4910 11 of of IN 19613 4910 12 these these DT 19613 4910 13 prophecies prophecy NNS 19613 4910 14 were be VBD 19613 4910 15 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 4910 16 in in IN 19613 4910 17 the the DT 19613 4910 18 most most RBS 19613 4910 19 striking striking JJ 19613 4910 20 fashion fashion NN 19613 4910 21 , , , 19613 4910 22 and and CC 19613 4910 23 this this DT 19613 4910 24 not not RB 19613 4910 25 only only RB 19613 4910 26 guarantees guarantee VBZ 19613 4910 27 the the DT 19613 4910 28 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 4910 29 of of IN 19613 4910 30 the the DT 19613 4910 31 relatively relatively RB 19613 4910 32 small small JJ 19613 4910 33 remainder remainder NN 19613 4910 34 not not RB 19613 4910 35 yet yet RB 19613 4910 36 come come VBN 19613 4910 37 to to TO 19613 4910 38 pass pass VB 19613 4910 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4910 40 judgment judgment NN 19613 4910 41 , , , 19613 4910 42 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 4910 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4910 44 , , , 19613 4910 45 but but CC 19613 4910 46 also also RB 19613 4910 47 settles settle VBZ 19613 4910 48 beyond beyond RB 19613 4910 49 all all RB 19613 4910 50 doubt doubt NN 19613 4910 51 the the DT 19613 4910 52 truth truth NN 19613 4910 53 of of IN 19613 4910 54 the the DT 19613 4910 55 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4910 56 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4910 57 about about IN 19613 4910 58 God God NNP 19613 4910 59 , , , 19613 4910 60 freedom freedom NN 19613 4910 61 , , , 19613 4910 62 virtue virtue NN 19613 4910 63 , , , 19613 4910 64 immortality immortality NN 19613 4910 65 , , , 19613 4910 66 etc etc FW 19613 4910 67 . . . 19613 4911 1 In in IN 19613 4911 2 the the DT 19613 4911 3 scheme scheme NN 19613 4911 4 of of IN 19613 4911 5 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 4911 6 and and CC 19613 4911 7 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 4911 8 even even RB 19613 4911 9 the the DT 19613 4911 10 irrational irrational JJ 19613 4911 11 becomes become VBZ 19613 4911 12 rational rational JJ 19613 4911 13 ; ; : 19613 4911 14 for for IN 19613 4911 15 the the DT 19613 4911 16 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 4911 17 of of IN 19613 4911 18 a a DT 19613 4911 19 prediction prediction NN 19613 4911 20 is be VBZ 19613 4911 21 not not RB 19613 4911 22 a a DT 19613 4911 23 proof proof NN 19613 4911 24 of of IN 19613 4911 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4911 26 divine divine JJ 19613 4911 27 origin origin NN 19613 4911 28 unless unless IN 19613 4911 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4911 30 refers refer VBZ 19613 4911 31 to to IN 19613 4911 32 something something NN 19613 4911 33 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 4911 34 . . . 19613 4912 1 Any any DT 19613 4912 2 one one NN 19613 4912 3 can can MD 19613 4912 4 predict predict VB 19613 4912 5 regular regular JJ 19613 4912 6 occurrences occurrence NNS 19613 4912 7 which which WDT 19613 4912 8 always always RB 19613 4912 9 take take VBP 19613 4912 10 place place NN 19613 4912 11 . . . 19613 4913 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4913 2 , , , 19613 4913 3 a a DT 19613 4913 4 part part NN 19613 4913 5 of of IN 19613 4913 6 what what WP 19613 4913 7 was be VBD 19613 4913 8 predicted predict VBN 19613 4913 9 had have VBD 19613 4913 10 to to TO 19613 4913 11 be be VB 19613 4913 12 irrational irrational JJ 19613 4913 13 . . . 19613 4914 1 Every every DT 19613 4914 2 particular particular JJ 19613 4914 3 in in IN 19613 4914 4 the the DT 19613 4914 5 history history NN 19613 4914 6 of of IN 19613 4914 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4914 8 has have VBZ 19613 4914 9 therefore therefore RB 19613 4914 10 a a DT 19613 4914 11 significance significance NN 19613 4914 12 , , , 19613 4914 13 not not RB 19613 4914 14 as as IN 19613 4914 15 regards regard VBZ 19613 4914 16 the the DT 19613 4914 17 future future NN 19613 4914 18 , , , 19613 4914 19 but but CC 19613 4914 20 as as IN 19613 4914 21 regards regard VBZ 19613 4914 22 the the DT 19613 4914 23 past past NN 19613 4914 24 . . . 19613 4915 1 Here here RB 19613 4915 2 everything everything NN 19613 4915 3 happened happen VBD 19613 4915 4 " " `` 19613 4915 5 that that IN 19613 4915 6 the the DT 19613 4915 7 word word NN 19613 4915 8 of of IN 19613 4915 9 the the DT 19613 4915 10 prophet prophet NN 19613 4915 11 might may MD 19613 4915 12 be be VB 19613 4915 13 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 4915 14 . . . 19613 4915 15 " " '' 19613 4916 1 Because because IN 19613 4916 2 the the DT 19613 4916 3 prophet prophet NN 19613 4916 4 had have VBD 19613 4916 5 said say VBN 19613 4916 6 so so RB 19613 4916 7 , , , 19613 4916 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4916 9 had have VBD 19613 4916 10 to to TO 19613 4916 11 happen happen VB 19613 4916 12 . . . 19613 4917 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4917 2 's 's POS 19613 4917 3 destiny destiny NN 19613 4917 4 attests attest VBZ 19613 4917 5 the the DT 19613 4917 6 ancient ancient JJ 19613 4917 7 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4917 8 of of IN 19613 4917 9 the the DT 19613 4917 10 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4917 11 . . . 19613 4918 1 Everything everything NN 19613 4918 2 , , , 19613 4918 3 however however RB 19613 4918 4 , , , 19613 4918 5 depends depend VBZ 19613 4918 6 on on IN 19613 4918 7 this this DT 19613 4918 8 attestation attestation NN 19613 4918 9 , , , 19613 4918 10 for for IN 19613 4918 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4918 12 was be VBD 19613 4918 13 no no RB 19613 4918 14 longer long JJR 19613 4918 15 the the DT 19613 4918 16 full full JJ 19613 4918 17 truth truth NN 19613 4918 18 that that WDT 19613 4918 19 was be VBD 19613 4918 20 wanting want VBG 19613 4918 21 , , , 19613 4918 22 but but CC 19613 4918 23 a a DT 19613 4918 24 convincing convincing JJ 19613 4918 25 proof proof NN 19613 4918 26 that that IN 19613 4918 27 the the DT 19613 4918 28 truth truth NN 19613 4918 29 was be VBD 19613 4918 30 a a DT 19613 4918 31 reality reality NN 19613 4918 32 and and CC 19613 4918 33 not not RB 19613 4918 34 a a DT 19613 4918 35 fancy fancy NN 19613 4918 36 . . . 19613 4919 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4919 2 449 449 CD 19613 4919 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4919 4 But but CC 19613 4919 5 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 4919 6 testifies testifie NNS 19613 4919 7 that that IN 19613 4919 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4919 9 is be VBZ 19613 4919 10 the the DT 19613 4919 11 ambassador ambassador NN 19613 4919 12 of of IN 19613 4919 13 God God NNP 19613 4919 14 , , , 19613 4919 15 the the DT 19613 4919 16 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4919 17 that that WDT 19613 4919 18 has have VBZ 19613 4919 19 appeared appear VBN 19613 4919 20 in in IN 19613 4919 21 human human JJ 19613 4919 22 form form NN 19613 4919 23 , , , 19613 4919 24 and and CC 19613 4919 25 the the DT 19613 4919 26 Son Son NNP 19613 4919 27 of of IN 19613 4919 28 God God NNP 19613 4919 29 . . . 19613 4920 1 If if IN 19613 4920 2 the the DT 19613 4920 3 future future JJ 19613 4920 4 destiny destiny NN 19613 4920 5 of of IN 19613 4920 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4920 7 is be VBZ 19613 4920 8 recorded record VBN 19613 4920 9 in in IN 19613 4920 10 the the DT 19613 4920 11 Old Old NNP 19613 4920 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4920 13 down down IN 19613 4920 14 to to IN 19613 4920 15 the the DT 19613 4920 16 smallest small JJS 19613 4920 17 particular particular JJ 19613 4920 18 , , , 19613 4920 19 and and CC 19613 4920 20 the the DT 19613 4920 21 book book NN 19613 4920 22 at at IN 19613 4920 23 the the DT 19613 4920 24 same same JJ 19613 4920 25 time time NN 19613 4920 26 declares declare VBZ 19613 4920 27 that that IN 19613 4920 28 this this DT 19613 4920 29 predicted predict VBD 19613 4920 30 One one CD 19613 4920 31 is be VBZ 19613 4920 32 the the DT 19613 4920 33 Son Son NNP 19613 4920 34 of of IN 19613 4920 35 God God NNP 19613 4920 36 and and CC 19613 4920 37 will will MD 19613 4920 38 be be VB 19613 4920 39 crucified crucify VBN 19613 4920 40 , , , 19613 4920 41 then then RB 19613 4920 42 the the DT 19613 4920 43 paying paying NN 19613 4920 44 of of IN 19613 4920 45 divine divine JJ 19613 4920 46 honours honour NNS 19613 4920 47 to to IN 19613 4920 48 this this DT 19613 4920 49 crucified crucified JJ 19613 4920 50 man man NN 19613 4920 51 , , , 19613 4920 52 to to TO 19613 4920 53 whom whom WP 19613 4920 54 all all PDT 19613 4920 55 the the DT 19613 4920 56 features feature NNS 19613 4920 57 of of IN 19613 4920 58 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 4920 59 apply apply NN 19613 4920 60 , , , 19613 4920 61 is be VBZ 19613 4920 62 completely completely RB 19613 4920 63 justified justified JJ 19613 4920 64 . . . 19613 4921 1 The the DT 19613 4921 2 stage stage NN 19613 4921 3 marked mark VBN 19613 4921 4 by by IN 19613 4921 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4921 6 in in IN 19613 4921 7 the the DT 19613 4921 8 history history NN 19613 4921 9 of of IN 19613 4921 10 God God NNP 19613 4921 11 's 's POS 19613 4921 12 revelation revelation NN 19613 4921 13 , , , 19613 4921 14 the the DT 19613 4921 15 content content NN 19613 4921 16 of of IN 19613 4921 17 which which WDT 19613 4921 18 is be VBZ 19613 4921 19 always always RB 19613 4921 20 the the DT 19613 4921 21 same same JJ 19613 4921 22 , , , 19613 4921 23 is be VBZ 19613 4921 24 therefore therefore RB 19613 4921 25 the the DT 19613 4921 26 highest high JJS 19613 4921 27 and and CC 19613 4921 28 last last JJ 19613 4921 29 , , , 19613 4921 30 because because IN 19613 4921 31 in in IN 19613 4921 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4921 33 the the DT 19613 4921 34 " " `` 19613 4921 35 truth truth NN 19613 4921 36 along along IN 19613 4921 37 with with IN 19613 4921 38 the the DT 19613 4921 39 proof proof NN 19613 4921 40 " " '' 19613 4921 41 has have VBZ 19613 4921 42 appeared appear VBN 19613 4921 43 . . . 19613 4922 1 This this DT 19613 4922 2 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 4922 3 explains explain VBZ 19613 4922 4 why why WRB 19613 4922 5 the the DT 19613 4922 6 truth truth NN 19613 4922 7 is be VBZ 19613 4922 8 so so RB 19613 4922 9 much much RB 19613 4922 10 more more RBR 19613 4922 11 impressive impressive JJ 19613 4922 12 and and CC 19613 4922 13 convinces convince VBZ 19613 4922 14 more more JJR 19613 4922 15 men man NNS 19613 4922 16 than than IN 19613 4922 17 formerly formerly RB 19613 4922 18 , , , 19613 4922 19 especially especially RB 19613 4922 20 since since IN 19613 4922 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4922 22 has have VBZ 19613 4922 23 also also RB 19613 4922 24 made make VBN 19613 4922 25 special special JJ 19613 4922 26 provision provision NN 19613 4922 27 for for IN 19613 4922 28 the the DT 19613 4922 29 spread spread NN 19613 4922 30 of of IN 19613 4922 31 the the DT 19613 4922 32 truth truth NN 19613 4922 33 and and CC 19613 4922 34 is be VBZ 19613 4922 35 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4922 36 an an DT 19613 4922 37 unequalled unequalled JJ 19613 4922 38 exemplification exemplification NN 19613 4922 39 of of IN 19613 4922 40 a a DT 19613 4922 41 virtuous virtuous JJ 19613 4922 42 life life NN 19613 4922 43 , , , 19613 4922 44 the the DT 19613 4922 45 principles principle NNS 19613 4922 46 of of IN 19613 4922 47 which which WDT 19613 4922 48 have have VBP 19613 4922 49 now now RB 19613 4922 50 become become VBN 19613 4922 51 known know VBN 19613 4922 52 in in IN 19613 4922 53 the the DT 19613 4922 54 whole whole JJ 19613 4922 55 world world NN 19613 4922 56 through through IN 19613 4922 57 the the DT 19613 4922 58 spread spread NN 19613 4922 59 of of IN 19613 4922 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4922 61 precepts precept NNS 19613 4922 62 . . . 19613 4923 1 These these DT 19613 4923 2 statements statement NNS 19613 4923 3 exhaust exhaust VBP 19613 4923 4 the the DT 19613 4923 5 arguments argument NNS 19613 4923 6 in in IN 19613 4923 7 most most JJS 19613 4923 8 of of IN 19613 4923 9 the the DT 19613 4923 10 Apologies Apologies NNPS 19613 4923 11 ; ; : 19613 4923 12 and and CC 19613 4923 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4923 14 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4923 15 seem seem VBP 19613 4923 16 neither neither CC 19613 4923 17 to to TO 19613 4923 18 have have VB 19613 4923 19 contemplated contemplate VBN 19613 4923 20 a a DT 19613 4923 21 redemption redemption NN 19613 4923 22 by by IN 19613 4923 23 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4923 24 in in IN 19613 4923 25 the the DT 19613 4923 26 stricter strict JJR 19613 4923 27 sense sense NN 19613 4923 28 of of IN 19613 4923 29 the the DT 19613 4923 30 word word NN 19613 4923 31 , , , 19613 4923 32 nor nor CC 19613 4923 33 to to TO 19613 4923 34 have have VB 19613 4923 35 assumed assume VBN 19613 4923 36 the the DT 19613 4923 37 unique unique JJ 19613 4923 38 nature nature NN 19613 4923 39 of of IN 19613 4923 40 the the DT 19613 4923 41 appearance appearance NN 19613 4923 42 of of IN 19613 4923 43 the the DT 19613 4923 44 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4923 45 in in IN 19613 4923 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4923 47 . . . 19613 4924 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4924 2 accomplished accomplish VBD 19613 4924 3 salvation salvation NN 19613 4924 4 as as IN 19613 4924 5 a a DT 19613 4924 6 divine divine JJ 19613 4924 7 _ _ NNP 19613 4924 8 teacher teacher NN 19613 4924 9 _ _ NNP 19613 4924 10 , , , 19613 4924 11 that that DT 19613 4924 12 is be VBZ 19613 4924 13 to to TO 19613 4924 14 say say VB 19613 4924 15 , , , 19613 4924 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4924 17 teaching teaching NN 19613 4924 18 brings bring VBZ 19613 4924 19 about about IN 19613 4924 20 the the DT 19613 4924 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4924 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4924 23 : : : 19613 4924 24 allagê allagê NNP 19613 4924 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4924 26 and and CC 19613 4924 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4924 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4924 29 : : : 19613 4924 30 epangôgê epangôgê NN 19613 4924 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4924 32 of of IN 19613 4924 33 the the DT 19613 4924 34 human human JJ 19613 4924 35 race race NN 19613 4924 36 , , , 19613 4924 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4924 38 restoration restoration NN 19613 4924 39 to to IN 19613 4924 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4924 41 original original JJ 19613 4924 42 destination destination NN 19613 4924 43 . . . 19613 4925 1 This this DT 19613 4925 2 also also RB 19613 4925 3 seems seem VBZ 19613 4925 4 to to TO 19613 4925 5 suffice suffice VB 19613 4925 6 as as IN 19613 4925 7 regards regard NNS 19613 4925 8 demon demon NN 19613 4925 9 rule rule NN 19613 4925 10 . . . 19613 4926 1 Logically logically RB 19613 4926 2 considered consider VBN 19613 4926 3 , , , 19613 4926 4 the the DT 19613 4926 5 individual individual JJ 19613 4926 6 portions portion NNS 19613 4926 7 of of IN 19613 4926 8 the the DT 19613 4926 9 history history NN 19613 4926 10 of of IN 19613 4926 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4926 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4926 13 of of IN 19613 4926 14 the the DT 19613 4926 15 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 4926 16 confession confession NN 19613 4926 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4926 18 have have VBP 19613 4926 19 no no DT 19613 4926 20 direct direct JJ 19613 4926 21 significance significance NN 19613 4926 22 in in IN 19613 4926 23 respect respect NN 19613 4926 24 to to IN 19613 4926 25 salvation salvation NN 19613 4926 26 . . . 19613 4927 1 Hence hence RB 19613 4927 2 the the DT 19613 4927 3 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4927 4 of of IN 19613 4927 5 the the DT 19613 4927 6 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4927 7 seem seem VBP 19613 4927 8 to to TO 19613 4927 9 fall fall VB 19613 4927 10 into into IN 19613 4927 11 two two CD 19613 4927 12 groups group NNS 19613 4927 13 having have VBG 19613 4927 14 no no DT 19613 4927 15 inward inward JJ 19613 4927 16 connection connection NN 19613 4927 17 , , , 19613 4927 18 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4927 19 , , , 19613 4927 20 the the DT 19613 4927 21 propositions proposition NNS 19613 4927 22 treating treat VBG 19613 4927 23 of of IN 19613 4927 24 the the DT 19613 4927 25 rational rational JJ 19613 4927 26 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4927 27 of of IN 19613 4927 28 God God NNP 19613 4927 29 , , , 19613 4927 30 and and CC 19613 4927 31 the the DT 19613 4927 32 predicted predict VBN 19613 4927 33 and and CC 19613 4927 34 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 4927 35 historical historical JJ 19613 4927 36 facts fact NNS 19613 4927 37 which which WDT 19613 4927 38 prove prove VBP 19613 4927 39 those those DT 19613 4927 40 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4927 41 and and CC 19613 4927 42 the the DT 19613 4927 43 believing believe VBG 19613 4927 44 hopes hope NNS 19613 4927 45 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4927 46 include include VBP 19613 4927 47 . . . 19613 4928 1 But but CC 19613 4928 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4928 3 at at IN 19613 4928 4 least least JJS 19613 4928 5 gave give VBD 19613 4928 6 token token NN 19613 4928 7 of of IN 19613 4928 8 a a DT 19613 4928 9 manifest manif JJS 19613 4928 10 effort effort NN 19613 4928 11 to to TO 19613 4928 12 combine combine VB 19613 4928 13 the the DT 19613 4928 14 historical historical JJ 19613 4928 15 statements statement NNS 19613 4928 16 regarding regard VBG 19613 4928 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4928 18 with with IN 19613 4928 19 the the DT 19613 4928 20 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4928 21 and and CC 19613 4928 22 moral moral JJ 19613 4928 23 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4928 24 of of IN 19613 4928 25 salvation salvation NN 19613 4928 26 and and CC 19613 4928 27 to to TO 19613 4928 28 conceive conceive VB 19613 4928 29 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4928 30 as as IN 19613 4928 31 the the DT 19613 4928 32 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 4928 33 . . . 19613 4929 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4929 2 450 450 CD 19613 4929 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4929 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4929 5 , , , 19613 4929 6 if if IN 19613 4929 7 the the DT 19613 4929 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 4929 9 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 4929 10 of of IN 19613 4929 11 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 4929 12 times time NNS 19613 4929 13 is be VBZ 19613 4929 14 found find VBN 19613 4929 15 in in IN 19613 4929 16 the the DT 19613 4929 17 connection connection NN 19613 4929 18 of of IN 19613 4929 19 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4929 20 theology theology NN 19613 4929 21 with with IN 19613 4929 22 the the DT 19613 4929 23 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 4929 24 confession confession NN 19613 4929 25 , , , 19613 4929 26 that that RB 19613 4929 27 is is RB 19613 4929 28 , , , 19613 4929 29 in in IN 19613 4929 30 the the DT 19613 4929 31 " " `` 19613 4929 32 scientific scientific JJ 19613 4929 33 theology theology NN 19613 4929 34 of of IN 19613 4929 35 facts fact NNS 19613 4929 36 , , , 19613 4929 37 " " `` 19613 4929 38 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4929 39 is be VBZ 19613 4929 40 , , , 19613 4929 41 in in IN 19613 4929 42 a a DT 19613 4929 43 certain certain JJ 19613 4929 44 fashion fashion NN 19613 4929 45 , , , 19613 4929 46 the the DT 19613 4929 47 first first JJ 19613 4929 48 framer framer NN 19613 4929 49 of of IN 19613 4929 50 Church Church NNP 19613 4929 51 dogma dogma NN 19613 4929 52 , , , 19613 4929 53 though though IN 19613 4929 54 no no DT 19613 4929 55 doubt doubt NN 19613 4929 56 in in IN 19613 4929 57 a a DT 19613 4929 58 very very RB 19613 4929 59 tentative tentative JJ 19613 4929 60 way way NN 19613 4929 61 . . . 19613 4930 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4930 2 1 1 LS 19613 4930 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4930 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4930 5 tried try VBD 19613 4930 6 to to TO 19613 4930 7 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 4930 8 between between IN 19613 4930 9 the the DT 19613 4930 10 appearance appearance NN 19613 4930 11 of of IN 19613 4930 12 the the DT 19613 4930 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4930 14 in in IN 19613 4930 15 pre pre JJ 19613 4930 16 - - JJ 19613 4930 17 Christian christian JJ 19613 4930 18 times time NNS 19613 4930 19 and and CC 19613 4930 20 in in IN 19613 4930 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4930 22 ; ; : 19613 4930 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4930 24 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 4930 25 the the DT 19613 4930 26 fact fact NN 19613 4930 27 that that IN 19613 4930 28 the the DT 19613 4930 29 whole whole JJ 19613 4930 30 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4930 31 appeared appear VBD 19613 4930 32 only only RB 19613 4930 33 in in IN 19613 4930 34 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4930 35 , , , 19613 4930 36 and and CC 19613 4930 37 that that IN 19613 4930 38 the the DT 19613 4930 39 manner manner NN 19613 4930 40 of of IN 19613 4930 41 this this DT 19613 4930 42 appearance appearance NN 19613 4930 43 has have VBZ 19613 4930 44 no no DT 19613 4930 45 counterpart counterpart NN 19613 4930 46 in in IN 19613 4930 47 the the DT 19613 4930 48 past past NN 19613 4930 49 . . . 19613 4931 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4931 2 2 2 LS 19613 4931 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4931 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4931 5 showed show VBD 19613 4931 6 in in IN 19613 4931 7 the the DT 19613 4931 8 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 19613 4931 9 that that WDT 19613 4931 10 , , , 19613 4931 11 independently independently RB 19613 4931 12 of of IN 19613 4931 13 the the DT 19613 4931 14 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 4931 15 of of IN 19613 4931 16 the the DT 19613 4931 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4931 18 , , , 19613 4931 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4931 20 was be VBD 19613 4931 21 firmly firmly RB 19613 4931 22 convinced convinced JJ 19613 4931 23 of of IN 19613 4931 24 the the DT 19613 4931 25 divinity divinity NN 19613 4931 26 of of IN 19613 4931 27 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4931 28 on on IN 19613 4931 29 the the DT 19613 4931 30 ground ground NN 19613 4931 31 of of IN 19613 4931 32 predictions prediction NNS 19613 4931 33 and and CC 19613 4931 34 of of IN 19613 4931 35 the the DT 19613 4931 36 impression impression NN 19613 4931 37 made make VBN 19613 4931 38 by by IN 19613 4931 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4931 40 personality personality NN 19613 4931 41 . . . 19613 4932 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4932 2 451 451 CD 19613 4932 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4932 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4932 5 3 3 LS 19613 4932 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4932 7 In in IN 19613 4932 8 addition addition NN 19613 4932 9 to to IN 19613 4932 10 the the DT 19613 4932 11 story story NN 19613 4932 12 of of IN 19613 4932 13 the the DT 19613 4932 14 exaltation exaltation NN 19613 4932 15 of of IN 19613 4932 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4932 17 , , , 19613 4932 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4932 19 also also RB 19613 4932 20 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 4932 21 other other JJ 19613 4932 22 portions portion NNS 19613 4932 23 of of IN 19613 4932 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4932 25 history history NN 19613 4932 26 , , , 19613 4932 27 especially especially RB 19613 4932 28 the the DT 19613 4932 29 death death NN 19613 4932 30 on on IN 19613 4932 31 the the DT 19613 4932 32 cross cross NN 19613 4932 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4932 34 together together RB 19613 4932 35 with with IN 19613 4932 36 baptism baptism NN 19613 4932 37 and and CC 19613 4932 38 the the DT 19613 4932 39 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4932 40 's 's POS 19613 4932 41 Supper supper NN 19613 4932 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4932 43 and and CC 19613 4932 44 tried try VBD 19613 4932 45 to to TO 19613 4932 46 give give VB 19613 4932 47 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4932 48 a a DT 19613 4932 49 positive positive JJ 19613 4932 50 significance significance NN 19613 4932 51 . . . 19613 4933 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4933 2 452 452 CD 19613 4933 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4933 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4933 5 adopted adopt VBD 19613 4933 6 the the DT 19613 4933 7 common common JJ 19613 4933 8 Christian Christian NNP 19613 4933 9 saying say VBG 19613 4933 10 that that IN 19613 4933 11 the the DT 19613 4933 12 blood blood NN 19613 4933 13 of of IN 19613 4933 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4933 15 cleanses cleanse VBZ 19613 4933 16 believers believer NNS 19613 4933 17 and and CC 19613 4933 18 men man NNS 19613 4933 19 are be VBP 19613 4933 20 healed heal VBN 19613 4933 21 through through IN 19613 4933 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4933 23 wounds wound NNS 19613 4933 24 ; ; : 19613 4933 25 and and CC 19613 4933 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4933 27 tried try VBD 19613 4933 28 to to TO 19613 4933 29 give give VB 19613 4933 30 a a DT 19613 4933 31 mystic mystic JJ 19613 4933 32 significance significance NN 19613 4933 33 to to IN 19613 4933 34 the the DT 19613 4933 35 cross cross NN 19613 4933 36 . . . 19613 4934 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4934 2 4 4 LS 19613 4934 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4934 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 4934 5 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4934 6 spoke speak VBD 19613 4934 7 of of IN 19613 4934 8 the the DT 19613 4934 9 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4934 10 of of IN 19613 4934 11 sins sin NNS 19613 4934 12 through through IN 19613 4934 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4934 14 and and CC 19613 4934 15 confessed confess VBD 19613 4934 16 that that IN 19613 4934 17 men man NNS 19613 4934 18 are be VBP 19613 4934 19 changed change VBN 19613 4934 20 , , , 19613 4934 21 through through IN 19613 4934 22 the the DT 19613 4934 23 new new JJ 19613 4934 24 birth birth NN 19613 4934 25 in in IN 19613 4934 26 baptism baptism NN 19613 4934 27 , , , 19613 4934 28 from from IN 19613 4934 29 children child NNS 19613 4934 30 of of IN 19613 4934 31 necessity necessity NN 19613 4934 32 and and CC 19613 4934 33 ignorance ignorance NN 19613 4934 34 into into IN 19613 4934 35 children child NNS 19613 4934 36 of of IN 19613 4934 37 purpose purpose NN 19613 4934 38 and and CC 19613 4934 39 understanding understanding NN 19613 4934 40 and and CC 19613 4934 41 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4934 42 of of IN 19613 4934 43 sins sin NNS 19613 4934 44 . . . 19613 4935 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4935 2 453 453 CD 19613 4935 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4935 4 Von Von NNP 19613 4935 5 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 4935 6 has have VBZ 19613 4935 7 , , , 19613 4935 8 however however RB 19613 4935 9 , , , 19613 4935 10 quite quite RB 19613 4935 11 rightly rightly RB 19613 4935 12 noticed notice VBD 19613 4935 13 that that IN 19613 4935 14 these these DT 19613 4935 15 are be VBP 19613 4935 16 mere mere JJ 19613 4935 17 words word NNS 19613 4935 18 which which WDT 19613 4935 19 have have VBP 19613 4935 20 nothing nothing NN 19613 4935 21 at at RB 19613 4935 22 all all RB 19613 4935 23 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 4935 24 to to IN 19613 4935 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4935 26 in in IN 19613 4935 27 the the DT 19613 4935 28 general general JJ 19613 4935 29 system system NN 19613 4935 30 of of IN 19613 4935 31 thought thought NN 19613 4935 32 , , , 19613 4935 33 because because IN 19613 4935 34 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4935 35 remains remain VBZ 19613 4935 36 convinced convinced JJ 19613 4935 37 that that IN 19613 4935 38 the the DT 19613 4935 39 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4935 40 of of IN 19613 4935 41 the the DT 19613 4935 42 true true JJ 19613 4935 43 God God NNP 19613 4935 44 , , , 19613 4935 45 of of IN 19613 4935 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4935 47 will will NN 19613 4935 48 , , , 19613 4935 49 and and CC 19613 4935 50 of of IN 19613 4935 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4935 52 promises promise NNS 19613 4935 53 , , , 19613 4935 54 or or CC 19613 4935 55 the the DT 19613 4935 56 certainty certainty NN 19613 4935 57 that that IN 19613 4935 58 God God NNP 19613 4935 59 will will MD 19613 4935 60 always always RB 19613 4935 61 grant grant VB 19613 4935 62 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4935 63 to to IN 19613 4935 64 the the DT 19613 4935 65 repentant repentant JJ 19613 4935 66 and and CC 19613 4935 67 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4935 68 life life NN 19613 4935 69 to to IN 19613 4935 70 the the DT 19613 4935 71 righteous righteous JJ 19613 4935 72 , , , 19613 4935 73 is be VBZ 19613 4935 74 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 4935 75 to to TO 19613 4935 76 convert convert VB 19613 4935 77 the the DT 19613 4935 78 man man NN 19613 4935 79 who who WP 19613 4935 80 is be VBZ 19613 4935 81 master master NN 19613 4935 82 of of IN 19613 4935 83 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4935 84 . . . 19613 4936 1 Owing owe VBG 19613 4936 2 to to IN 19613 4936 3 the the DT 19613 4936 4 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4936 5 conviction conviction NN 19613 4936 6 which which WDT 19613 4936 7 is be VBZ 19613 4936 8 expressed express VBN 19613 4936 9 in in IN 19613 4936 10 the the DT 19613 4936 11 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 4936 12 , , , 19613 4936 13 " " '' 19613 4936 14 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4936 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4936 16 , , , 19613 4936 17 " " '' 19613 4936 18 " " `` 19613 4936 19 divine divine JJ 19613 4936 20 teacher teacher NN 19613 4936 21 , , , 19613 4936 22 " " '' 19613 4936 23 " " `` 19613 4936 24 new new JJ 19613 4936 25 law law NN 19613 4936 26 , , , 19613 4936 27 " " '' 19613 4936 28 " " `` 19613 4936 29 freedom freedom NN 19613 4936 30 , , , 19613 4936 31 " " '' 19613 4936 32 " " `` 19613 4936 33 repentance repentance NN 19613 4936 34 , , , 19613 4936 35 " " '' 19613 4936 36 " " `` 19613 4936 37 sinless sinless JJ 19613 4936 38 life life NN 19613 4936 39 , , , 19613 4936 40 " " '' 19613 4936 41 " " `` 19613 4936 42 sure sure JJ 19613 4936 43 hope hope NN 19613 4936 44 , , , 19613 4936 45 " " '' 19613 4936 46 " " `` 19613 4936 47 reward reward NN 19613 4936 48 , , , 19613 4936 49 " " '' 19613 4936 50 " " `` 19613 4936 51 immortality immortality NN 19613 4936 52 , , , 19613 4936 53 " " '' 19613 4936 54 the the DT 19613 4936 55 ideas idea NNS 19613 4936 56 , , , 19613 4936 57 " " '' 19613 4936 58 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4936 59 of of IN 19613 4936 60 sins sin NNS 19613 4936 61 , , , 19613 4936 62 " " '' 19613 4936 63 " " `` 19613 4936 64 redemption redemption NN 19613 4936 65 , , , 19613 4936 66 " " '' 19613 4936 67 " " `` 19613 4936 68 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 4936 69 , , , 19613 4936 70 " " '' 19613 4936 71 " " `` 19613 4936 72 new new JJ 19613 4936 73 birth birth NN 19613 4936 74 , , , 19613 4936 75 " " '' 19613 4936 76 " " `` 19613 4936 77 faith faith NN 19613 4936 78 " " '' 19613 4936 79 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4936 80 in in IN 19613 4936 81 the the DT 19613 4936 82 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 4936 83 sense sense NN 19613 4936 84 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4936 85 must must MD 19613 4936 86 remain remain VB 19613 4936 87 words,[454 words,[454 NNP 19613 4936 88 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4936 89 or or CC 19613 4936 90 be be VB 19613 4936 91 relegated relegate VBN 19613 4936 92 to to IN 19613 4936 93 the the DT 19613 4936 94 sphere sphere NN 19613 4936 95 of of IN 19613 4936 96 magic magic NN 19613 4936 97 and and CC 19613 4936 98 mystery mystery NN 19613 4936 99 . . . 19613 4937 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4937 2 455 455 CD 19613 4937 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4937 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 4937 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4937 6 must must MD 19613 4937 7 not not RB 19613 4937 8 on on IN 19613 4937 9 that that DT 19613 4937 10 account account NN 19613 4937 11 overlook overlook VBP 19613 4937 12 the the DT 19613 4937 13 intention intention NN 19613 4937 14 . . . 19613 4938 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4938 2 tried try VBD 19613 4938 3 to to TO 19613 4938 4 see see VB 19613 4938 5 the the DT 19613 4938 6 divine divine JJ 19613 4938 7 revelation revelation NN 19613 4938 8 not not RB 19613 4938 9 only only RB 19613 4938 10 in in IN 19613 4938 11 the the DT 19613 4938 12 sayings saying NNS 19613 4938 13 of of IN 19613 4938 14 the the DT 19613 4938 15 prophets prophet NNS 19613 4938 16 , , , 19613 4938 17 but but CC 19613 4938 18 in in IN 19613 4938 19 unique unique JJ 19613 4938 20 fashion fashion NN 19613 4938 21 in in IN 19613 4938 22 the the DT 19613 4938 23 person person NN 19613 4938 24 of of IN 19613 4938 25 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4938 26 , , , 19613 4938 27 and and CC 19613 4938 28 to to TO 19613 4938 29 conceive conceive VB 19613 4938 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4938 31 not not RB 19613 4938 32 only only RB 19613 4938 33 as as IN 19613 4938 34 the the DT 19613 4938 35 divine divine JJ 19613 4938 36 teacher teacher NN 19613 4938 37 , , , 19613 4938 38 but but CC 19613 4938 39 also also RB 19613 4938 40 as as IN 19613 4938 41 the the DT 19613 4938 42 " " `` 19613 4938 43 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4938 44 and and CC 19613 4938 45 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 4938 46 . . . 19613 4938 47 " " '' 19613 4939 1 In in IN 19613 4939 2 two two CD 19613 4939 3 points point NNS 19613 4939 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4939 5 actually actually RB 19613 4939 6 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 4939 7 in in IN 19613 4939 8 this this DT 19613 4939 9 . . . 19613 4940 1 By by IN 19613 4940 2 the the DT 19613 4940 3 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 4940 4 and and CC 19613 4940 5 exaltation exaltation NN 19613 4940 6 of of IN 19613 4940 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4940 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4940 9 proved prove VBD 19613 4940 10 that that IN 19613 4940 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4940 12 , , , 19613 4940 13 the the DT 19613 4940 14 divine divine JJ 19613 4940 15 teacher teacher NN 19613 4940 16 , , , 19613 4940 17 is be VBZ 19613 4940 18 also also RB 19613 4940 19 the the DT 19613 4940 20 future future JJ 19613 4940 21 judge judge NN 19613 4940 22 and and CC 19613 4940 23 bestower bestower NN 19613 4940 24 of of IN 19613 4940 25 reward reward NN 19613 4940 26 . . . 19613 4941 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4941 2 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 4941 3 is be VBZ 19613 4941 4 able able JJ 19613 4941 5 to to TO 19613 4941 6 give give VB 19613 4941 7 what what WP 19613 4941 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4941 9 has have VBZ 19613 4941 10 promised promise VBN 19613 4941 11 -- -- : 19613 4941 12 a a DT 19613 4941 13 life life NN 19613 4941 14 after after IN 19613 4941 15 death death NN 19613 4941 16 free free JJ 19613 4941 17 from from IN 19613 4941 18 sufferings suffering NNS 19613 4941 19 and and CC 19613 4941 20 sins sin NNS 19613 4941 21 , , , 19613 4941 22 that that RB 19613 4941 23 is be VBZ 19613 4941 24 the the DT 19613 4941 25 first first JJ 19613 4941 26 point point NN 19613 4941 27 . . . 19613 4942 1 The the DT 19613 4942 2 other other JJ 19613 4942 3 thing thing NN 19613 4942 4 , , , 19613 4942 5 however however RB 19613 4942 6 , , , 19613 4942 7 which which WDT 19613 4942 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4942 9 very very RB 19613 4942 10 strongly strongly RB 19613 4942 11 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 4942 12 is be VBZ 19613 4942 13 that that IN 19613 4942 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4942 15 is be VBZ 19613 4942 16 even even RB 19613 4942 17 now now RB 19613 4942 18 reigning reign VBG 19613 4942 19 in in IN 19613 4942 20 heaven heaven NNP 19613 4942 21 , , , 19613 4942 22 and and CC 19613 4942 23 shows show VBZ 19613 4942 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4942 25 future future JJ 19613 4942 26 visible visible JJ 19613 4942 27 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4942 28 of of IN 19613 4942 29 the the DT 19613 4942 30 world world NN 19613 4942 31 by by IN 19613 4942 32 giving give VBG 19613 4942 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4942 34 own own JJ 19613 4942 35 people people NNS 19613 4942 36 the the DT 19613 4942 37 power power NN 19613 4942 38 to to TO 19613 4942 39 cast cast VB 19613 4942 40 out out RP 19613 4942 41 and and CC 19613 4942 42 vanquish vanquish VB 19613 4942 43 the the DT 19613 4942 44 demons demon NNS 19613 4942 45 in in IN 19613 4942 46 and and CC 19613 4942 47 by by IN 19613 4942 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4942 49 name name NN 19613 4942 50 . . . 19613 4943 1 Even even RB 19613 4943 2 at at IN 19613 4943 3 the the DT 19613 4943 4 present present JJ 19613 4943 5 time time NN 19613 4943 6 the the DT 19613 4943 7 latter latter JJ 19613 4943 8 are be VBP 19613 4943 9 put put VBN 19613 4943 10 to to IN 19613 4943 11 flight flight NN 19613 4943 12 by by IN 19613 4943 13 believers believer NNS 19613 4943 14 in in IN 19613 4943 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4943 16 . . . 19613 4944 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4944 2 456 456 CD 19613 4944 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4944 4 So so RB 19613 4944 5 the the DT 19613 4944 6 redemption redemption NN 19613 4944 7 is be VBZ 19613 4944 8 no no DT 19613 4944 9 mere mere JJ 19613 4944 10 future future JJ 19613 4944 11 one one CD 19613 4944 12 ; ; : 19613 4944 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4944 14 is be VBZ 19613 4944 15 even even RB 19613 4944 16 now now RB 19613 4944 17 taking take VBG 19613 4944 18 place place NN 19613 4944 19 , , , 19613 4944 20 and and CC 19613 4944 21 the the DT 19613 4944 22 revelation revelation NN 19613 4944 23 of of IN 19613 4944 24 the the DT 19613 4944 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4944 26 in in IN 19613 4944 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4944 28 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4944 29 is be VBZ 19613 4944 30 not not RB 19613 4944 31 merely merely RB 19613 4944 32 intended intend VBN 19613 4944 33 to to TO 19613 4944 34 prove prove VB 19613 4944 35 the the DT 19613 4944 36 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4944 37 of of IN 19613 4944 38 the the DT 19613 4944 39 rational rational JJ 19613 4944 40 religion religion NN 19613 4944 41 , , , 19613 4944 42 but but CC 19613 4944 43 denotes denote VBZ 19613 4944 44 a a DT 19613 4944 45 real real JJ 19613 4944 46 redemption redemption NN 19613 4944 47 , , , 19613 4944 48 that that RB 19613 4944 49 is is RB 19613 4944 50 , , , 19613 4944 51 a a DT 19613 4944 52 new new JJ 19613 4944 53 beginning beginning NN 19613 4944 54 , , , 19613 4944 55 in in IN 19613 4944 56 so so RB 19613 4944 57 far far RB 19613 4944 58 as as IN 19613 4944 59 the the DT 19613 4944 60 power power NN 19613 4944 61 of of IN 19613 4944 62 the the DT 19613 4944 63 demons demon NNS 19613 4944 64 on on IN 19613 4944 65 earth earth NN 19613 4944 66 is be VBZ 19613 4944 67 overthrown overthrow VBN 19613 4944 68 through through IN 19613 4944 69 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4944 70 and and CC 19613 4944 71 in in IN 19613 4944 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4944 73 strength strength NN 19613 4944 74 . . . 19613 4945 1 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 4945 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4945 3 , , , 19613 4945 4 the the DT 19613 4945 5 teacher teacher NN 19613 4945 6 of of IN 19613 4945 7 the the DT 19613 4945 8 whole whole JJ 19613 4945 9 truth truth NN 19613 4945 10 and and CC 19613 4945 11 of of IN 19613 4945 12 a a DT 19613 4945 13 new new JJ 19613 4945 14 law law NN 19613 4945 15 , , , 19613 4945 16 which which WDT 19613 4945 17 is be VBZ 19613 4945 18 the the DT 19613 4945 19 rational rational JJ 19613 4945 20 , , , 19613 4945 21 the the DT 19613 4945 22 oldest old JJS 19613 4945 23 , , , 19613 4945 24 and and CC 19613 4945 25 the the DT 19613 4945 26 divine divine JJ 19613 4945 27 , , , 19613 4945 28 the the DT 19613 4945 29 only only JJ 19613 4945 30 being be VBG 19613 4945 31 who who WP 19613 4945 32 has have VBZ 19613 4945 33 understood understand VBN 19613 4945 34 how how WRB 19613 4945 35 to to TO 19613 4945 36 call call VB 19613 4945 37 men man NNS 19613 4945 38 from from IN 19613 4945 39 all all PDT 19613 4945 40 the the DT 19613 4945 41 different different JJ 19613 4945 42 nations nation NNS 19613 4945 43 and and CC 19613 4945 44 in in IN 19613 4945 45 all all DT 19613 4945 46 stages stage NNS 19613 4945 47 of of IN 19613 4945 48 culture culture NN 19613 4945 49 into into IN 19613 4945 50 a a DT 19613 4945 51 union union NN 19613 4945 52 of of IN 19613 4945 53 holy holy JJ 19613 4945 54 life life NN 19613 4945 55 , , , 19613 4945 56 the the DT 19613 4945 57 inspiring inspire VBG 19613 4945 58 One one CD 19613 4945 59 , , , 19613 4945 60 for for IN 19613 4945 61 whom whom WP 19613 4945 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4945 63 disciples disciple NNS 19613 4945 64 go go VBP 19613 4945 65 to to IN 19613 4945 66 death death NN 19613 4945 67 , , , 19613 4945 68 the the DT 19613 4945 69 mighty mighty JJ 19613 4945 70 One one CD 19613 4945 71 , , , 19613 4945 72 through through IN 19613 4945 73 whose whose WP$ 19613 4945 74 name name NN 19613 4945 75 the the DT 19613 4945 76 demons demon NNS 19613 4945 77 are be VBP 19613 4945 78 cast cast VBN 19613 4945 79 out out RP 19613 4945 80 , , , 19613 4945 81 the the DT 19613 4945 82 risen rise VBN 19613 4945 83 One one CD 19613 4945 84 , , , 19613 4945 85 who who WP 19613 4945 86 will will MD 19613 4945 87 one one CD 19613 4945 88 day day NN 19613 4945 89 reward reward NN 19613 4945 90 and and CC 19613 4945 91 punish punish NN 19613 4945 92 as as IN 19613 4945 93 judge judge NN 19613 4945 94 , , , 19613 4945 95 must must MD 19613 4945 96 be be VB 19613 4945 97 identical identical JJ 19613 4945 98 with with IN 19613 4945 99 the the DT 19613 4945 100 Son Son NNP 19613 4945 101 of of IN 19613 4945 102 God God NNP 19613 4945 103 , , , 19613 4945 104 who who WP 19613 4945 105 is be VBZ 19613 4945 106 the the DT 19613 4945 107 divine divine JJ 19613 4945 108 reason reason NN 19613 4945 109 and and CC 19613 4945 110 the the DT 19613 4945 111 divine divine JJ 19613 4945 112 power power NN 19613 4945 113 . . . 19613 4946 1 In in IN 19613 4946 2 this this DT 19613 4946 3 belief belief NN 19613 4946 4 which which WDT 19613 4946 5 accompanies accompany VBZ 19613 4946 6 the the DT 19613 4946 7 confession confession NN 19613 4946 8 of of IN 19613 4946 9 the the DT 19613 4946 10 one one NN 19613 4946 11 God God NNP 19613 4946 12 , , , 19613 4946 13 creator creator NN 19613 4946 14 of of IN 19613 4946 15 heaven heaven NNP 19613 4946 16 and and CC 19613 4946 17 earth earth NN 19613 4946 18 , , , 19613 4946 19 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4946 20 finds find VBZ 19613 4946 21 the the DT 19613 4946 22 special special JJ 19613 4946 23 content content NN 19613 4946 24 of of IN 19613 4946 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4946 26 , , , 19613 4946 27 which which WDT 19613 4946 28 the the DT 19613 4946 29 later later JJ 19613 4946 30 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4946 31 , , , 19613 4946 32 with with IN 19613 4946 33 the the DT 19613 4946 34 probable probable JJ 19613 4946 35 exception exception NN 19613 4946 36 of of IN 19613 4946 37 Melito Melito NNP 19613 4946 38 , , , 19613 4946 39 reproduced reproduce VBN 19613 4946 40 in in IN 19613 4946 41 a a DT 19613 4946 42 much much RB 19613 4946 43 more more RBR 19613 4946 44 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 4946 45 and and CC 19613 4946 46 meagre meagre JJ 19613 4946 47 form form NN 19613 4946 48 . . . 19613 4947 1 One one CD 19613 4947 2 thing thing NN 19613 4947 3 , , , 19613 4947 4 however however RB 19613 4947 5 , , , 19613 4947 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4947 7 in in IN 19613 4947 8 all all DT 19613 4947 9 probability probability NN 19613 4947 10 did do VBD 19613 4947 11 not not RB 19613 4947 12 formulate formulate VB 19613 4947 13 with with IN 19613 4947 14 precision precision NN 19613 4947 15 , , , 19613 4947 16 viz viz NNP 19613 4947 17 . . NNP 19613 4947 18 , , , 19613 4947 19 the the DT 19613 4947 20 proposition proposition NN 19613 4947 21 that that IN 19613 4947 22 the the DT 19613 4947 23 special special JJ 19613 4947 24 result result NN 19613 4947 25 of of IN 19613 4947 26 salvation salvation NN 19613 4947 27 , , , 19613 4947 28 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4947 29 , , , 19613 4947 30 immortality immortality NN 19613 4947 31 , , , 19613 4947 32 was be VBD 19613 4947 33 involved involve VBN 19613 4947 34 in in IN 19613 4947 35 the the DT 19613 4947 36 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 4947 37 of of IN 19613 4947 38 the the DT 19613 4947 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4947 40 , , , 19613 4947 41 in in IN 19613 4947 42 so so RB 19613 4947 43 far far RB 19613 4947 44 as as IN 19613 4947 45 that that DT 19613 4947 46 act act NN 19613 4947 47 brought bring VBD 19613 4947 48 about about RP 19613 4947 49 a a DT 19613 4947 50 real real JJ 19613 4947 51 secret secret JJ 19613 4947 52 transformation transformation NN 19613 4947 53 of of IN 19613 4947 54 the the DT 19613 4947 55 whole whole JJ 19613 4947 56 mortal mortal JJ 19613 4947 57 nature nature NN 19613 4947 58 of of IN 19613 4947 59 man man NN 19613 4947 60 . . . 19613 4948 1 With with IN 19613 4948 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4948 3 , , , 19613 4948 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 4948 5 , , , 19613 4948 6 as as IN 19613 4948 7 with with IN 19613 4948 8 the the DT 19613 4948 9 other other JJ 19613 4948 10 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4948 11 , , , 19613 4948 12 the the DT 19613 4948 13 " " `` 19613 4948 14 salvation salvation NN 19613 4948 15 " " '' 19613 4948 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4948 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4948 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4948 19 : : : 19613 4948 20 sôtêria sôtêria NNP 19613 4948 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4948 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4948 23 consists consist VBZ 19613 4948 24 essentially essentially RB 19613 4948 25 in in IN 19613 4948 26 the the DT 19613 4948 27 apportioning apportioning NN 19613 4948 28 of of IN 19613 4948 29 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4948 30 life life NN 19613 4948 31 to to IN 19613 4948 32 the the DT 19613 4948 33 world world NN 19613 4948 34 , , , 19613 4948 35 which which WDT 19613 4948 36 has have VBZ 19613 4948 37 been be VBN 19613 4948 38 created create VBN 19613 4948 39 mortal mortal JJ 19613 4948 40 and and CC 19613 4948 41 in in IN 19613 4948 42 consequence consequence NN 19613 4948 43 of of IN 19613 4948 44 sin sin NN 19613 4948 45 has have VBZ 19613 4948 46 fallen fall VBN 19613 4948 47 a a DT 19613 4948 48 prey prey NN 19613 4948 49 to to IN 19613 4948 50 the the DT 19613 4948 51 natural natural JJ 19613 4948 52 destiny destiny NN 19613 4948 53 of of IN 19613 4948 54 " " `` 19613 4948 55 death death NN 19613 4948 56 ; ; : 19613 4948 57 " " '' 19613 4948 58 and and CC 19613 4948 59 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4948 60 is be VBZ 19613 4948 61 regarded regard VBN 19613 4948 62 as as IN 19613 4948 63 the the DT 19613 4948 64 bestower bestower NN 19613 4948 65 of of IN 19613 4948 66 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 4948 67 who who WP 19613 4948 68 thus thus RB 19613 4948 69 brings bring VBZ 19613 4948 70 the the DT 19613 4948 71 creation creation NN 19613 4948 72 to to IN 19613 4948 73 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4948 74 goal goal NN 19613 4948 75 ; ; : 19613 4948 76 but but CC 19613 4948 77 as as IN 19613 4948 78 a a DT 19613 4948 79 rule rule NN 19613 4948 80 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4948 81 does do VBZ 19613 4948 82 not not RB 19613 4948 83 go go VB 19613 4948 84 beyond beyond IN 19613 4948 85 this this DT 19613 4948 86 thought thought NN 19613 4948 87 . . . 19613 4949 1 Yet yet CC 19613 4949 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4949 3 certainly certainly RB 19613 4949 4 find find VBP 19613 4949 5 hints hint NNS 19613 4949 6 pointing point VBG 19613 4949 7 to to IN 19613 4949 8 the the DT 19613 4949 9 notion notion NN 19613 4949 10 of of IN 19613 4949 11 a a DT 19613 4949 12 physical physical JJ 19613 4949 13 and and CC 19613 4949 14 magical magical JJ 19613 4949 15 redemption redemption NN 19613 4949 16 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 4949 17 at at IN 19613 4949 18 the the DT 19613 4949 19 moment moment NN 19613 4949 20 of of IN 19613 4949 21 the the DT 19613 4949 22 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 4949 23 . . . 19613 4950 1 See see VB 19613 4950 2 particularly particularly RB 19613 4950 3 the the DT 19613 4950 4 fragment fragment NN 19613 4950 5 in in IN 19613 4950 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 4950 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4950 8 already already RB 19613 4950 9 quoted quote VBN 19613 4950 10 on on IN 19613 4950 11 page page NN 19613 4950 12 220 220 CD 19613 4950 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4950 14 , , , 19613 4950 15 which which WDT 19613 4950 16 may may MD 19613 4950 17 be be VB 19613 4950 18 thus thus RB 19613 4950 19 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 4950 20 , , , 19613 4950 21 and and CC 19613 4950 22 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4950 23 . . . 19613 4951 1 I. I. NNP 19613 4952 1 66 66 CD 19613 4952 2 . . . 19613 4953 1 This this DT 19613 4953 2 conception conception NN 19613 4953 3 , , , 19613 4953 4 in in IN 19613 4953 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4953 6 most most RBS 19613 4953 7 complete complete JJ 19613 4953 8 shape shape NN 19613 4953 9 , , , 19613 4953 10 would would MD 19613 4953 11 have have VB 19613 4953 12 to to TO 19613 4953 13 be be VB 19613 4953 14 attributed attribute VBN 19613 4953 15 to to IN 19613 4953 16 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4953 17 if if IN 19613 4953 18 the the DT 19613 4953 19 fragment fragment NN 19613 4953 20 V. V. NNP 19613 4953 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4953 22 Otto Otto NNP 19613 4953 23 , , , 19613 4953 24 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 4953 25 Apol Apol NNP 19613 4953 26 . . . 19613 4954 1 III iii CD 19613 4954 2 . . . 19613 4955 1 p. p. NN 19613 4955 2 256 256 CD 19613 4955 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4955 4 were be VBD 19613 4955 5 genuine genuine JJ 19613 4955 6 . . . 19613 4956 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4956 2 457 457 CD 19613 4956 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4956 4 But but CC 19613 4956 5 the the DT 19613 4956 6 precise precise JJ 19613 4956 7 form form NN 19613 4956 8 of of IN 19613 4956 9 the the DT 19613 4956 10 presentation presentation NN 19613 4956 11 makes make VBZ 19613 4956 12 this this DT 19613 4956 13 very very RB 19613 4956 14 improbable improbable JJ 19613 4956 15 . . . 19613 4957 1 The the DT 19613 4957 2 question question NN 19613 4957 3 as as IN 19613 4957 4 to to IN 19613 4957 5 how how WRB 19613 4957 6 , , , 19613 4957 7 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4957 8 , , , 19613 4957 9 in in IN 19613 4957 10 what what WDT 19613 4957 11 conceivable conceivable JJ 19613 4957 12 way way NN 19613 4957 13 , , , 19613 4957 14 immortality immortality NN 19613 4957 15 can can MD 19613 4957 16 be be VB 19613 4957 17 imparted impart VBN 19613 4957 18 to to IN 19613 4957 19 the the DT 19613 4957 20 mortal mortal JJ 19613 4957 21 nature nature NN 19613 4957 22 as as IN 19613 4957 23 yet yet RB 19613 4957 24 received receive VBN 19613 4957 25 little little JJ 19613 4957 26 attention attention NN 19613 4957 27 from from IN 19613 4957 28 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4957 29 and and CC 19613 4957 30 the the DT 19613 4957 31 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4957 32 : : : 19613 4957 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4957 34 is be VBZ 19613 4957 35 the the DT 19613 4957 36 necessary necessary JJ 19613 4957 37 result result NN 19613 4957 38 of of IN 19613 4957 39 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4957 40 and and CC 19613 4957 41 virtue virtue NN 19613 4957 42 . . . 19613 4958 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4958 2 great great JJ 19613 4958 3 object object NN 19613 4958 4 was be VBD 19613 4958 5 to to TO 19613 4958 6 assure assure VB 19613 4958 7 the the DT 19613 4958 8 belief belief NN 19613 4958 9 in in IN 19613 4958 10 immortality immortality NN 19613 4958 11 . . . 19613 4959 1 " " `` 19613 4959 2 Religion religion NN 19613 4959 3 and and CC 19613 4959 4 morality morality NN 19613 4959 5 depend depend VBP 19613 4959 6 on on IN 19613 4959 7 the the DT 19613 4959 8 belief belief NN 19613 4959 9 in in IN 19613 4959 10 immortality immortality NN 19613 4959 11 or or CC 19613 4959 12 the the DT 19613 4959 13 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 4959 14 from from IN 19613 4959 15 the the DT 19613 4959 16 dead dead NN 19613 4959 17 . . . 19613 4960 1 The the DT 19613 4960 2 fact fact NN 19613 4960 3 that that IN 19613 4960 4 the the DT 19613 4960 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 4960 6 religion religion NN 19613 4960 7 , , , 19613 4960 8 as as IN 19613 4960 9 faith faith NN 19613 4960 10 in in IN 19613 4960 11 the the DT 19613 4960 12 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 4960 13 Son Son NNP 19613 4960 14 of of IN 19613 4960 15 God God NNP 19613 4960 16 the the DT 19613 4960 17 creator creator NN 19613 4960 18 , , , 19613 4960 19 leads lead VBZ 19613 4960 20 to to IN 19613 4960 21 the the DT 19613 4960 22 assurance assurance NN 19613 4960 23 that that IN 19613 4960 24 the the DT 19613 4960 25 maker maker NN 19613 4960 26 of of IN 19613 4960 27 all all DT 19613 4960 28 things thing NNS 19613 4960 29 will will MD 19613 4960 30 reward reward VB 19613 4960 31 piety piety NN 19613 4960 32 and and CC 19613 4960 33 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4960 34 with with IN 19613 4960 35 the the DT 19613 4960 36 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 4960 37 of of IN 19613 4960 38 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4960 39 and and CC 19613 4960 40 immortal immortal JJ 19613 4960 41 life life NN 19613 4960 42 , , , 19613 4960 43 is be VBZ 19613 4960 44 the the DT 19613 4960 45 essential essential JJ 19613 4960 46 advantage advantage NN 19613 4960 47 possessed possess VBN 19613 4960 48 by by IN 19613 4960 49 the the DT 19613 4960 50 Christian christian JJ 19613 4960 51 religion religion NN 19613 4960 52 over over IN 19613 4960 53 all all DT 19613 4960 54 others other NNS 19613 4960 55 . . . 19613 4961 1 The the DT 19613 4961 2 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4961 3 of of IN 19613 4961 4 the the DT 19613 4961 5 heathen heathen NN 19613 4961 6 was be VBD 19613 4961 7 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 4961 8 in in IN 19613 4961 9 spite spite NN 19613 4961 10 of of IN 19613 4961 11 all all DT 19613 4961 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4961 13 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4961 14 of of IN 19613 4961 15 good good JJ 19613 4961 16 and and CC 19613 4961 17 evil evil NN 19613 4961 18 , , , 19613 4961 19 because because IN 19613 4961 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4961 21 lacked lack VBD 19613 4961 22 the the DT 19613 4961 23 certain certain JJ 19613 4961 24 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4961 25 that that WDT 19613 4961 26 the the DT 19613 4961 27 creator creator NN 19613 4961 28 makes make VBZ 19613 4961 29 the the DT 19613 4961 30 just just RB 19613 4961 31 immortal immortal JJ 19613 4961 32 and and CC 19613 4961 33 will will MD 19613 4961 34 consign consign VB 19613 4961 35 the the DT 19613 4961 36 unjust unjust JJ 19613 4961 37 to to IN 19613 4961 38 eternal eternal JJ 19613 4961 39 torment torment NN 19613 4961 40 . . . 19613 4961 41 " " '' 19613 4962 1 The the DT 19613 4962 2 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 4962 3 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 4962 4 of of IN 19613 4962 5 God God NNP 19613 4962 6 , , , 19613 4962 7 virtue virtue NN 19613 4962 8 , , , 19613 4962 9 and and CC 19613 4962 10 immortality immortality NN 19613 4962 11 became become VBD 19613 4962 12 through through IN 19613 4962 13 the the DT 19613 4962 14 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4962 15 the the DT 19613 4962 16 certain certain JJ 19613 4962 17 content content NN 19613 4962 18 of of IN 19613 4962 19 a a DT 19613 4962 20 world world NN 19613 4962 21 - - HYPH 19613 4962 22 wide wide JJ 19613 4962 23 religion religion NN 19613 4962 24 , , , 19613 4962 25 which which WDT 19613 4962 26 is be VBZ 19613 4962 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 4962 28 because because IN 19613 4962 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4962 30 guarantees guarantee VBZ 19613 4962 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4962 32 certainty certainty NN 19613 4962 33 . . . 19613 4963 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4963 2 made make VBD 19613 4963 3 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4963 4 a a DT 19613 4963 5 deistical deistical JJ 19613 4963 6 religion religion NN 19613 4963 7 for for IN 19613 4963 8 the the DT 19613 4963 9 whole whole JJ 19613 4963 10 world world NN 19613 4963 11 without without IN 19613 4963 12 abandoning abandon VBG 19613 4963 13 in in IN 19613 4963 14 word word NN 19613 4963 15 at at IN 19613 4963 16 least least JJS 19613 4963 17 the the DT 19613 4963 18 old old JJ 19613 4963 19 " " `` 19613 4963 20 teachings teaching NNS 19613 4963 21 and and CC 19613 4963 22 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4963 23 " " '' 19613 4963 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4963 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4963 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4963 27 : : : 19613 4963 28 didagmata didagmata NNP 19613 4963 29 kai kai NNP 19613 4963 30 mathêmata mathêmata NNP 19613 4963 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4963 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4963 33 of of IN 19613 4963 34 the the DT 19613 4963 35 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 4963 36 . . . 19613 4964 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 4964 2 thus thus RB 19613 4964 3 marked mark VBD 19613 4964 4 out out RP 19613 4964 5 the the DT 19613 4964 6 task task NN 19613 4964 7 of of IN 19613 4964 8 " " `` 19613 4964 9 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 4964 10 " " '' 19613 4964 11 and and CC 19613 4964 12 , , , 19613 4964 13 so so RB 19613 4964 14 to to TO 19613 4964 15 speak speak VB 19613 4964 16 , , , 19613 4964 17 wrote write VBD 19613 4964 18 the the DT 19613 4964 19 prolegomena prolegomena NN 19613 4964 20 for for IN 19613 4964 21 every every DT 19613 4964 22 future future JJ 19613 4964 23 theological theological JJ 19613 4964 24 system system NN 19613 4964 25 in in IN 19613 4964 26 the the DT 19613 4964 27 Church Church NNP 19613 4964 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4964 29 see see VB 19613 4964 30 Von Von NNP 19613 4964 31 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 4964 32 's 's POS 19613 4964 33 concluding conclude VBG 19613 4964 34 observations observation NNS 19613 4964 35 in in IN 19613 4964 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4964 37 " " `` 19613 4964 38 Christenthum Christenthum NNP 19613 4964 39 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4964 40 's 's POS 19613 4964 41 " " `` 19613 4964 42 pp pp NN 19613 4964 43 . . . 19613 4965 1 447 447 CD 19613 4965 2 - - SYM 19613 4965 3 490 490 CD 19613 4965 4 , , , 19613 4965 5 also also RB 19613 4965 6 Overbeck overbeck VB 19613 4965 7 in in IN 19613 4965 8 the the DT 19613 4965 9 Historische Historische NNP 19613 4965 10 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 4965 11 , , , 19613 4965 12 1880 1880 CD 19613 4965 13 , , , 19613 4965 14 pp pp NNP 19613 4965 15 . . . 19613 4966 1 499 499 CD 19613 4966 2 - - SYM 19613 4966 3 505 505 CD 19613 4966 4 . . . 19613 4966 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4967 1 At at IN 19613 4967 2 the the DT 19613 4967 3 same same JJ 19613 4967 4 time time NN 19613 4967 5 , , , 19613 4967 6 however however RB 19613 4967 7 , , , 19613 4967 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4967 9 adhered adhere VBD 19613 4967 10 to to IN 19613 4967 11 the the DT 19613 4967 12 early early JJ 19613 4967 13 - - HYPH 19613 4967 14 Christian christian JJ 19613 4967 15 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 4967 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4967 17 see see VB 19613 4967 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4967 19 , , , 19613 4967 20 Melito Melito NNP 19613 4967 21 , , , 19613 4967 22 and and CC 19613 4967 23 , , , 19613 4967 24 with with IN 19613 4967 25 reference reference NN 19613 4967 26 to to IN 19613 4967 27 the the DT 19613 4967 28 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 4967 29 of of IN 19613 4967 30 the the DT 19613 4967 31 flesh flesh NN 19613 4967 32 , , , 19613 4967 33 the the DT 19613 4967 34 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4967 35 generally generally RB 19613 4967 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4967 37 , , , 19613 4967 38 and and CC 19613 4967 39 thus thus RB 19613 4967 40 did do VBD 19613 4967 41 not not RB 19613 4967 42 belie belie VB 19613 4967 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4967 44 connection connection NN 19613 4967 45 with with IN 19613 4967 46 early early JJ 19613 4967 47 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4967 48 . . . 19613 4968 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4968 2 458 458 CD 19613 4968 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4968 4 _ _ NNP 19613 4968 5 Interpretation Interpretation NNP 19613 4968 6 and and CC 19613 4968 7 Criticism Criticism NNP 19613 4968 8 , , , 19613 4968 9 especially especially RB 19613 4968 10 of of IN 19613 4968 11 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4968 12 's 's POS 19613 4968 13 Doctrines Doctrines NNPS 19613 4968 14 . . . 19613 4968 15 _ _ NNP 19613 4968 16 1 1 CD 19613 4968 17 . . . 19613 4969 1 The the DT 19613 4969 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 4969 3 assumption assumption NN 19613 4969 4 of of IN 19613 4969 5 all all PDT 19613 4969 6 the the DT 19613 4969 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4969 8 is be VBZ 19613 4969 9 that that IN 19613 4969 10 there there EX 19613 4969 11 can can MD 19613 4969 12 only only RB 19613 4969 13 be be VB 19613 4969 14 one one CD 19613 4969 15 and and CC 19613 4969 16 the the DT 19613 4969 17 same same JJ 19613 4969 18 relation relation NN 19613 4969 19 on on IN 19613 4969 20 earth earth NN 19613 4969 21 between between IN 19613 4969 22 God God NNP 19613 4969 23 and and CC 19613 4969 24 free free JJ 19613 4969 25 man man NN 19613 4969 26 , , , 19613 4969 27 and and CC 19613 4969 28 that that IN 19613 4969 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4969 30 has have VBZ 19613 4969 31 been be VBN 19613 4969 32 conditioned condition VBN 19613 4969 33 by by IN 19613 4969 34 the the DT 19613 4969 35 creation creation NN 19613 4969 36 . . . 19613 4970 1 This this DT 19613 4970 2 thought thought NN 19613 4970 3 , , , 19613 4970 4 which which WDT 19613 4970 5 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 4970 6 the the DT 19613 4970 7 idea idea NN 19613 4970 8 of of IN 19613 4970 9 God God NNP 19613 4970 10 's 's POS 19613 4970 11 unchangeableness unchangeableness NN 19613 4970 12 , , , 19613 4970 13 at at IN 19613 4970 14 bottom bottom JJ 19613 4970 15 neutralises neutralise NNS 19613 4970 16 every every DT 19613 4970 17 quasi quasi JJ 19613 4970 18 - - JJ 19613 4970 19 historical historical JJ 19613 4970 20 and and CC 19613 4970 21 mythological mythological JJ 19613 4970 22 consideration consideration NN 19613 4970 23 . . . 19613 4971 1 According accord VBG 19613 4971 2 to to IN 19613 4971 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4971 4 grace grace NN 19613 4971 5 can can MD 19613 4971 6 be be VB 19613 4971 7 nothing nothing NN 19613 4971 8 else else RB 19613 4971 9 than than IN 19613 4971 10 the the DT 19613 4971 11 stimulation stimulation NN 19613 4971 12 of of IN 19613 4971 13 the the DT 19613 4971 14 powers power NNS 19613 4971 15 of of IN 19613 4971 16 reason reason NN 19613 4971 17 existent existent NN 19613 4971 18 in in IN 19613 4971 19 man man NN 19613 4971 20 ; ; : 19613 4971 21 revelation revelation NN 19613 4971 22 is be VBZ 19613 4971 23 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 4971 24 only only RB 19613 4971 25 in in IN 19613 4971 26 respect respect NN 19613 4971 27 of of IN 19613 4971 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4971 29 form form NN 19613 4971 30 , , , 19613 4971 31 and and CC 19613 4971 32 the the DT 19613 4971 33 redemption redemption NN 19613 4971 34 merely merely RB 19613 4971 35 enables enable VBZ 19613 4971 36 us -PRON- PRP 19613 4971 37 to to TO 19613 4971 38 redeem redeem VB 19613 4971 39 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 4971 40 , , , 19613 4971 41 just just RB 19613 4971 42 as as IN 19613 4971 43 this this DT 19613 4971 44 possibility possibility NN 19613 4971 45 was be VBD 19613 4971 46 given give VBN 19613 4971 47 at at IN 19613 4971 48 the the DT 19613 4971 49 creation creation NN 19613 4971 50 . . . 19613 4972 1 Sin sin NN 19613 4972 2 , , , 19613 4972 3 which which WDT 19613 4972 4 arose arise VBD 19613 4972 5 through through IN 19613 4972 6 temptation temptation NN 19613 4972 7 , , , 19613 4972 8 appears appear VBZ 19613 4972 9 on on IN 19613 4972 10 the the DT 19613 4972 11 one one CD 19613 4972 12 hand hand NN 19613 4972 13 as as IN 19613 4972 14 error error NN 19613 4972 15 which which WDT 19613 4972 16 must must MD 19613 4972 17 almost almost RB 19613 4972 18 of of IN 19613 4972 19 necessity necessity NN 19613 4972 20 have have VBP 19613 4972 21 arisen arise VBN 19613 4972 22 so so RB 19613 4972 23 long long RB 19613 4972 24 as as IN 19613 4972 25 man man NN 19613 4972 26 only only RB 19613 4972 27 possessed possess VBD 19613 4972 28 the the DT 19613 4972 29 " " `` 19613 4972 30 germs germ NNS 19613 4972 31 of of IN 19613 4972 32 the the DT 19613 4972 33 Logos Logos NNP 19613 4972 34 " " '' 19613 4972 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4972 36 [ [ -LRB- 19613 4972 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 4972 38 : : : 19613 4972 39 spermata spermata NNP 19613 4972 40 tou tou NNP 19613 4972 41 logou logou NNP 19613 4972 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 4972 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4972 44 and and CC 19613 4972 45 on on IN 19613 4972 46 the the DT 19613 4972 47 other other JJ 19613 4972 48 as as IN 19613 4972 49 the the DT 19613 4972 50 dominion dominion NN 19613 4972 51 of of IN 19613 4972 52 sensuousness sensuousness NN 19613 4972 53 , , , 19613 4972 54 which which WDT 19613 4972 55 was be VBD 19613 4972 56 nearly nearly RB 19613 4972 57 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 4972 58 since since IN 19613 4972 59 earthly earthly JJ 19613 4972 60 material material NN 19613 4972 61 clothes clothe VBZ 19613 4972 62 the the DT 19613 4972 63 soul soul NN 19613 4972 64 and and CC 19613 4972 65 mighty mighty JJ 19613 4972 66 demons demon NNS 19613 4972 67 have have VBP 19613 4972 68 possession possession NN 19613 4972 69 of of IN 19613 4972 70 the the DT 19613 4972 71 world world NN 19613 4972 72 . . . 19613 4973 1 The the DT 19613 4973 2 mythological mythological JJ 19613 4973 3 idea idea NN 19613 4973 4 of of IN 19613 4973 5 the the DT 19613 4973 6 invading invade VBG 19613 4973 7 sway sway NN 19613 4973 8 of of IN 19613 4973 9 the the DT 19613 4973 10 demons demon NNS 19613 4973 11 is be VBZ 19613 4973 12 really really RB 19613 4973 13 the the DT 19613 4973 14 only only JJ 19613 4973 15 interruption interruption NN 19613 4973 16 of of IN 19613 4973 17 the the DT 19613 4973 18 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 19613 4973 19 scheme scheme NN 19613 4973 20 . . . 19613 4974 1 So so RB 19613 4974 2 far far RB 19613 4974 3 as as IN 19613 4974 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 4974 5 is be VBZ 19613 4974 6 something something NN 19613 4974 7 different different JJ 19613 4974 8 from from IN 19613 4974 9 morality morality NN 19613 4974 10 , , , 19613 4974 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4974 12 is be VBZ 19613 4974 13 the the DT 19613 4974 14 antithesis antithesis NN 19613 4974 15 of of IN 19613 4974 16 the the DT 19613 4974 17 service service NN 19613 4974 18 and and CC 19613 4974 19 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 4974 20 of of IN 19613 4974 21 the the DT 19613 4974 22 demons demon NNS 19613 4974 23 . . . 19613 4975 1 Hence hence RB 19613 4975 2 the the DT 19613 4975 3 idea idea NN 19613 4975 4 that that IN 19613 4975 5 the the DT 19613 4975 6 course course NN 19613 4975 7 of of IN 19613 4975 8 the the DT 19613 4975 9 world world NN 19613 4975 10 and and CC 19613 4975 11 mankind mankind NN 19613 4975 12 require require VBP 19613 4975 13 in in IN 19613 4975 14 some some DT 19613 4975 15 measure measure NN 19613 4975 16 to to TO 19613 4975 17 be be VB 19613 4975 18 helped help VBN 19613 4975 19 is be VBZ 19613 4975 20 the the DT 19613 4975 21 narrow narrow JJ 19613 4975 22 foundation foundation NN 19613 4975 23 of of IN 19613 4975 24 the the DT 19613 4975 25 thought thought NN 19613 4975 26 of of IN 19613 4975 27 revelation revelation NN 19613 4975 28 or or CC 19613 4975 29 redemption redemption NN 19613 4975 30 . . . 19613 4976 1 The the DT 19613 4976 2 necessity necessity NN 19613 4976 3 of of IN 19613 4976 4 revelation revelation NN 19613 4976 5 and and CC 19613 4976 6 redemption redemption NN 19613 4976 7 was be VBD 19613 4976 8 expressed express VBN 19613 4976 9 in in IN 19613 4976 10 a a DT 19613 4976 11 much much RB 19613 4976 12 stronger strong JJR 19613 4976 13 and and CC 19613 4976 14 more more RBR 19613 4976 15 decisive decisive JJ 19613 4976 16 way way NN 19613 4976 17 by by IN 19613 4976 18 many many JJ 19613 4976 19 heathen heathen NNP 19613 4976 20 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 4976 21 of of IN 19613 4976 22 the the DT 19613 4976 23 same same JJ 19613 4976 24 period period NN 19613 4976 25 . . . 19613 4977 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 4977 2 , , , 19613 4977 3 not not RB 19613 4977 4 only only RB 19613 4977 5 did do VBD 19613 4977 6 these these DT 19613 4977 7 long long JJ 19613 4977 8 for for IN 19613 4977 9 a a DT 19613 4977 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 4977 11 which which WDT 19613 4977 12 would would MD 19613 4977 13 give give VB 19613 4977 14 a a DT 19613 4977 15 fresh fresh JJ 19613 4977 16 attestation attestation NN 19613 4977 17 to to IN 19613 4977 18 old old JJ 19613 4977 19 truth truth NN 19613 4977 20 , , , 19613 4977 21 but but CC 19613 4977 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4977 23 yearned yearn VBD 19613 4977 24 for for IN 19613 4977 25 a a DT 19613 4977 26 force force NN 19613 4977 27 , , , 19613 4977 28 a a DT 19613 4977 29 real real JJ 19613 4977 30 redemption redemption NN 19613 4977 31 , , , 19613 4977 32 a a DT 19613 4977 33 _ _ NNP 19613 4977 34 præsens præsen VBZ 19613 4977 35 numen numan NNS 19613 4977 36 _ _ NNP 19613 4977 37 , , , 19613 4977 38 and and CC 19613 4977 39 some some DT 19613 4977 40 new new JJ 19613 4977 41 thing thing NN 19613 4977 42 . . . 19613 4978 1 Still still RB 19613 4978 2 more more RBR 19613 4978 3 powerful powerful JJ 19613 4978 4 was be VBD 19613 4978 5 this this DT 19613 4978 6 longing longing NN 19613 4978 7 in in IN 19613 4978 8 the the DT 19613 4978 9 case case NN 19613 4978 10 of of IN 19613 4978 11 the the DT 19613 4978 12 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 4978 13 and and CC 19613 4978 14 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 4978 15 ; ; : 19613 4978 16 compare compare VB 19613 4978 17 the the DT 19613 4978 18 latter latter NN 19613 4978 19 's 's POS 19613 4978 20 idea idea NN 19613 4978 21 of of IN 19613 4978 22 revelation revelation NN 19613 4978 23 with with IN 19613 4978 24 that that DT 19613 4978 25 of of IN 19613 4978 26 the the DT 19613 4978 27 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4978 28 . . . 19613 4979 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 4979 2 is be VBZ 19613 4979 3 probable probable JJ 19613 4979 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 4979 5 that that IN 19613 4979 6 the the DT 19613 4979 7 thought thought NN 19613 4979 8 of of IN 19613 4979 9 redemption redemption NN 19613 4979 10 would would MD 19613 4979 11 have have VB 19613 4979 12 found find VBN 19613 4979 13 stronger strong JJR 19613 4979 14 expression expression NN 19613 4979 15 among among IN 19613 4979 16 them -PRON- PRP 19613 4979 17 also also RB 19613 4979 18 , , , 19613 4979 19 had have VBD 19613 4979 20 not not RB 19613 4979 21 the the DT 19613 4979 22 task task NN 19613 4979 23 of of IN 19613 4979 24 _ _ NNP 19613 4979 25 proof proof NN 19613 4979 26 _ _ NNP 19613 4979 27 , , , 19613 4979 28 which which WDT 19613 4979 29 could could MD 19613 4979 30 be be VB 19613 4979 31 best well RBS 19613 4979 32 discharged discharge VBN 19613 4979 33 by by IN 19613 4979 34 the the DT 19613 4979 35 aid aid NN 19613 4979 36 of of IN 19613 4979 37 the the DT 19613 4979 38 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 4979 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4979 40 , , , 19613 4979 41 demanded demand VBD 19613 4979 42 religious religious JJ 19613 4979 43 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 4979 44 . . . 19613 4980 1 But but CC 19613 4980 2 , , , 19613 4980 3 admitting admit VBG 19613 4980 4 this this DT 19613 4980 5 , , , 19613 4980 6 the the DT 19613 4980 7 determination determination NN 19613 4980 8 of of IN 19613 4980 9 the the DT 19613 4980 10 highest high JJS 19613 4980 11 good good JJ 19613 4980 12 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 4980 13 involved involve VBD 19613 4980 14 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 4980 15 and and CC 19613 4980 16 moralism moralism NN 19613 4980 17 . . . 19613 4981 1 For for IN 19613 4981 2 immortality immortality NN 19613 4981 3 is be VBZ 19613 4981 4 the the DT 19613 4981 5 highest high JJS 19613 4981 6 good good JJ 19613 4981 7 , , , 19613 4981 8 in in IN 19613 4981 9 so so RB 19613 4981 10 far far RB 19613 4981 11 as as IN 19613 4981 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4981 13 is be VBZ 19613 4981 14 perfect perfect JJ 19613 4981 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4981 16 -- -- : 19613 4981 17 which which WDT 19613 4981 18 is be VBZ 19613 4981 19 , , , 19613 4981 20 moreover moreover RB 19613 4981 21 , , , 19613 4981 22 conceived conceive VBD 19613 4981 23 as as IN 19613 4981 24 being be VBG 19613 4981 25 of of IN 19613 4981 26 a a DT 19613 4981 27 rational rational JJ 19613 4981 28 kind,--that kind,--that NNP 19613 4981 29 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 4981 30 leads lead VBZ 19613 4981 31 to to IN 19613 4981 32 immortality immortality NN 19613 4981 33 . . . 19613 4982 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 4982 2 can can MD 19613 4982 3 only only RB 19613 4982 4 find find VB 19613 4982 5 traces trace NNS 19613 4982 6 of of IN 19613 4982 7 the the DT 19613 4982 8 converse converse NN 19613 4982 9 idea idea NN 19613 4982 10 , , , 19613 4982 11 according accord VBG 19613 4982 12 to to IN 19613 4982 13 which which WDT 19613 4982 14 the the DT 19613 4982 15 change change NN 19613 4982 16 into into IN 19613 4982 17 the the DT 19613 4982 18 immortal immortal JJ 19613 4982 19 condition condition NN 19613 4982 20 is be VBZ 19613 4982 21 the the DT 19613 4982 22 _ _ NNP 19613 4982 23 prius prius NNP 19613 4982 24 _ _ NNP 19613 4982 25 and and CC 19613 4982 26 the the DT 19613 4982 27 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4982 28 the the DT 19613 4982 29 _ _ NNP 19613 4982 30 posterius posterius NN 19613 4982 31 _ _ NNP 19613 4982 32 . . . 19613 4983 1 But but CC 19613 4983 2 , , , 19613 4983 3 where where WRB 19613 4983 4 this this DT 19613 4983 5 conception conception NN 19613 4983 6 is be VBZ 19613 4983 7 the the DT 19613 4983 8 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 4983 9 one one CD 19613 4983 10 , , , 19613 4983 11 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 4983 12 intellectualism intellectualism NN 19613 4983 13 is be VBZ 19613 4983 14 broken break VBN 19613 4983 15 through through RP 19613 4983 16 , , , 19613 4983 17 and and CC 19613 4983 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 4983 19 can can MD 19613 4983 20 now now RB 19613 4983 21 point point VB 19613 4983 22 to to IN 19613 4983 23 a a DT 19613 4983 24 specific specific JJ 19613 4983 25 , , , 19613 4983 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 4983 27 blessing blessing NN 19613 4983 28 of of IN 19613 4983 29 salvation salvation NN 19613 4983 30 , , , 19613 4983 31 produced produce VBN 19613 4983 32 by by IN 19613 4983 33 revelation revelation NN 19613 4983 34 and and CC 19613 4983 35 redemption redemption NN 19613 4983 36 . . . 19613 4984 1 Corresponding correspond VBG 19613 4984 2 to to IN 19613 4984 3 the the DT 19613 4984 4 general general JJ 19613 4984 5 development development NN 19613 4984 6 of of IN 19613 4984 7 religious religious JJ 19613 4984 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 4984 9 from from IN 19613 4984 10 moralism moralism NN 19613 4984 11 into into IN 19613 4984 12 mysticism mysticism NN 19613 4984 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4984 14 transition transition NN 19613 4984 15 from from IN 19613 4984 16 the the DT 19613 4984 17 second second JJ 19613 4984 18 to to IN 19613 4984 19 the the DT 19613 4984 20 third third JJ 19613 4984 21 century century NN 19613 4984 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4984 23 , , , 19613 4984 24 a a DT 19613 4984 25 displacement displacement NN 19613 4984 26 in in IN 19613 4984 27 this this DT 19613 4984 28 direction direction NN 19613 4984 29 can can MD 19613 4984 30 also also RB 19613 4984 31 be be VB 19613 4984 32 noticed notice VBN 19613 4984 33 in in IN 19613 4984 34 the the DT 19613 4984 35 history history NN 19613 4984 36 of of IN 19613 4984 37 Greek greek JJ 19613 4984 38 apologetics apologetic NNS 19613 4984 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4984 40 in in IN 19613 4984 41 the the DT 19613 4984 42 West West NNP 19613 4984 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4984 44 was be VBD 19613 4984 45 different different JJ 19613 4984 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4984 47 ; ; : 19613 4984 48 but but CC 19613 4984 49 this this DT 19613 4984 50 displacement displacement NN 19613 4984 51 was be VBD 19613 4984 52 never never RB 19613 4984 53 considerable considerable JJ 19613 4984 54 and and CC 19613 4984 55 therefore therefore RB 19613 4984 56 can can MD 19613 4984 57 not not RB 19613 4984 58 be be VB 19613 4984 59 clearly clearly RB 19613 4984 60 traced trace VBN 19613 4984 61 . . . 19613 4985 1 Even even RB 19613 4985 2 later later RB 19613 4985 3 on on IN 19613 4985 4 under under IN 19613 4985 5 altered alter VBN 19613 4985 6 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 4985 7 , , , 19613 4985 8 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 4985 9 science science NN 19613 4985 10 adhered adhere VBN 19613 4985 11 in in IN 19613 4985 12 every every DT 19613 4985 13 respect respect NN 19613 4985 14 to to IN 19613 4985 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4985 16 old old JJ 19613 4985 17 method method NN 19613 4985 18 , , , 19613 4985 19 as as IN 19613 4985 20 being be VBG 19613 4985 21 the the DT 19613 4985 22 most most RBS 19613 4985 23 suitable suitable JJ 19613 4985 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4985 25 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 4985 26 , , , 19613 4985 27 morality morality NN 19613 4985 28 , , , 19613 4985 29 proof proof NN 19613 4985 30 from from IN 19613 4985 31 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 4985 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4985 33 , , , 19613 4985 34 a a DT 19613 4985 35 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 4985 36 which which WDT 19613 4985 37 is be VBZ 19613 4985 38 evident evident JJ 19613 4985 39 , , , 19613 4985 40 for for IN 19613 4985 41 example example NN 19613 4985 42 , , , 19613 4985 43 from from IN 19613 4985 44 the the DT 19613 4985 45 almost almost RB 19613 4985 46 complete complete JJ 19613 4985 47 disregard disregard NN 19613 4985 48 of of IN 19613 4985 49 the the DT 19613 4985 50 New New NNP 19613 4985 51 Testament Testament NNP 19613 4985 52 canon canon NN 19613 4985 53 of of IN 19613 4985 54 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 4985 55 and and CC 19613 4985 56 from from IN 19613 4985 57 other other JJ 19613 4985 58 considerations consideration NNS 19613 4985 59 besides besides RB 19613 4985 60 . . . 19613 4986 1 2 2 LS 19613 4986 2 . . . 19613 4987 1 In in IN 19613 4987 2 so so RB 19613 4987 3 far far RB 19613 4987 4 as as IN 19613 4987 5 the the DT 19613 4987 6 possibility possibility NN 19613 4987 7 of of IN 19613 4987 8 virtue virtue NN 19613 4987 9 and and CC 19613 4987 10 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 4987 11 has have VBZ 19613 4987 12 been be VBN 19613 4987 13 implanted implant VBN 19613 4987 14 by by IN 19613 4987 15 God God NNP 19613 4987 16 in in IN 19613 4987 17 men man NNS 19613 4987 18 , , , 19613 4987 19 and and CC 19613 4987 20 in in IN 19613 4987 21 so so RB 19613 4987 22 far far RB 19613 4987 23 as as IN 19613 4987 24 -- -- : 19613 4987 25 apart apart RB 19613 4987 26 from from IN 19613 4987 27 trifling trifling NN 19613 4987 28 exceptions exception NNS 19613 4987 29 -- -- : 19613 4987 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4987 31 can can MD 19613 4987 32 actually actually RB 19613 4987 33 succeed succeed VB 19613 4987 34 in in IN 19613 4987 35 doing do VBG 19613 4987 36 what what WP 19613 4987 37 is be VBZ 19613 4987 38 good good JJ 19613 4987 39 only only RB 19613 4987 40 through through IN 19613 4987 41 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 4987 42 , , , 19613 4987 43 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4987 44 , , , 19613 4987 45 divine divine JJ 19613 4987 46 , , , 19613 4987 47 revelations revelation NNS 19613 4987 48 and and CC 19613 4987 49 exhortations exhortation NNS 19613 4987 50 , , , 19613 4987 51 some some DT 19613 4987 52 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4987 53 , , , 19613 4987 54 following follow VBG 19613 4987 55 the the DT 19613 4987 56 early early JJ 19613 4987 57 Christian christian JJ 19613 4987 58 tradition tradition NN 19613 4987 59 , , , 19613 4987 60 here here RB 19613 4987 61 and and CC 19613 4987 62 there there EX 19613 4987 63 designate designate VBP 19613 4987 64 the the DT 19613 4987 65 transformation transformation NN 19613 4987 66 of of IN 19613 4987 67 the the DT 19613 4987 68 sinner sinner NN 19613 4987 69 into into IN 19613 4987 70 a a DT 19613 4987 71 righteous righteous JJ 19613 4987 72 man man NN 19613 4987 73 as as IN 19613 4987 74 a a DT 19613 4987 75 work work NN 19613 4987 76 of of IN 19613 4987 77 God God NNP 19613 4987 78 , , , 19613 4987 79 and and CC 19613 4987 80 speak speak VB 19613 4987 81 of of IN 19613 4987 82 renewal renewal NN 19613 4987 83 and and CC 19613 4987 84 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 4987 85 . . . 19613 4988 1 The the DT 19613 4988 2 latter latter JJ 19613 4988 3 , , , 19613 4988 4 however however RB 19613 4988 5 , , , 19613 4988 6 as as IN 19613 4988 7 a a DT 19613 4988 8 real real JJ 19613 4988 9 fact fact NN 19613 4988 10 , , , 19613 4988 11 is be VBZ 19613 4988 12 identical identical JJ 19613 4988 13 with with IN 19613 4988 14 the the DT 19613 4988 15 repentance repentance NN 19613 4988 16 which which WDT 19613 4988 17 , , , 19613 4988 18 as as IN 19613 4988 19 a a DT 19613 4988 20 turning turning NN 19613 4988 21 from from IN 19613 4988 22 sin sin NN 19613 4988 23 and and CC 19613 4988 24 turning turn VBG 19613 4988 25 to to IN 19613 4988 26 God God NNP 19613 4988 27 , , , 19613 4988 28 is be VBZ 19613 4988 29 a a DT 19613 4988 30 matter matter NN 19613 4988 31 of of IN 19613 4988 32 free free JJ 19613 4988 33 will will NN 19613 4988 34 . . . 19613 4989 1 As as IN 19613 4989 2 in in IN 19613 4989 3 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4989 4 , , , 19613 4989 5 so so RB 19613 4989 6 also also RB 19613 4989 7 in in IN 19613 4989 8 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4989 9 , , , 19613 4989 10 the the DT 19613 4989 11 idea idea NN 19613 4989 12 of of IN 19613 4989 13 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 4989 14 is be VBZ 19613 4989 15 exhausted exhaust VBN 19613 4989 16 in in IN 19613 4989 17 the the DT 19613 4989 18 divine divine JJ 19613 4989 19 call call NN 19613 4989 20 to to IN 19613 4989 21 repentance repentance NN 19613 4989 22 . . . 19613 4990 1 The the DT 19613 4990 2 conception conception NN 19613 4990 3 of of IN 19613 4990 4 the the DT 19613 4990 5 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4990 6 of of IN 19613 4990 7 sins sin NNS 19613 4990 8 is be VBZ 19613 4990 9 also also RB 19613 4990 10 determined determine VBN 19613 4990 11 in in IN 19613 4990 12 accordance accordance NN 19613 4990 13 with with IN 19613 4990 14 this this DT 19613 4990 15 . . . 19613 4991 1 Only only RB 19613 4991 2 those those DT 19613 4991 3 sins sin NNS 19613 4991 4 can can MD 19613 4991 5 be be VB 19613 4991 6 forgiven forgive VBN 19613 4991 7 , , , 19613 4991 8 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4991 9 , , , 19613 4991 10 overlooked overlook VBN 19613 4991 11 , , , 19613 4991 12 which which WDT 19613 4991 13 are be VBP 19613 4991 14 really really RB 19613 4991 15 none none NN 19613 4991 16 , , , 19613 4991 17 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 4991 18 , , , 19613 4991 19 which which WDT 19613 4991 20 were be VBD 19613 4991 21 committed commit VBN 19613 4991 22 in in IN 19613 4991 23 a a DT 19613 4991 24 state state NN 19613 4991 25 of of IN 19613 4991 26 error error NN 19613 4991 27 and and CC 19613 4991 28 bondage bondage VB 19613 4991 29 to to IN 19613 4991 30 the the DT 19613 4991 31 demons demon NNS 19613 4991 32 , , , 19613 4991 33 and and CC 19613 4991 34 were be VBD 19613 4991 35 well well RB 19613 4991 36 - - HYPH 19613 4991 37 nigh nigh NN 19613 4991 38 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 4991 39 . . . 19613 4992 1 The the DT 19613 4992 2 blotting blotting NN 19613 4992 3 out out IN 19613 4992 4 of of IN 19613 4992 5 these these DT 19613 4992 6 sins sin NNS 19613 4992 7 is be VBZ 19613 4992 8 effected effect VBN 19613 4992 9 in in IN 19613 4992 10 baptism baptism NN 19613 4992 11 , , , 19613 4992 12 " " '' 19613 4992 13 which which WDT 19613 4992 14 is be VBZ 19613 4992 15 the the DT 19613 4992 16 bath bath NN 19613 4992 17 of of IN 19613 4992 18 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 4992 19 in in IN 19613 4992 20 so so RB 19613 4992 21 far far RB 19613 4992 22 as as IN 19613 4992 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4992 24 is be VBZ 19613 4992 25 the the DT 19613 4992 26 voluntary voluntary JJ 19613 4992 27 consecration consecration NN 19613 4992 28 of of IN 19613 4992 29 one one PRP 19613 4992 30 's 's POS 19613 4992 31 own own JJ 19613 4992 32 person person NN 19613 4992 33 . . . 19613 4993 1 The the DT 19613 4993 2 cleansing cleansing NN 19613 4993 3 which which WDT 19613 4993 4 takes take VBZ 19613 4993 5 place place NN 19613 4993 6 is be VBZ 19613 4993 7 God God NNP 19613 4993 8 's 's POS 19613 4993 9 work work NN 19613 4993 10 in in IN 19613 4993 11 so so RB 19613 4993 12 far far RB 19613 4993 13 as as IN 19613 4993 14 baptism baptism NN 19613 4993 15 was be VBD 19613 4993 16 instituted institute VBN 19613 4993 17 by by IN 19613 4993 18 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4993 19 , , , 19613 4993 20 but but CC 19613 4993 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4993 22 is be VBZ 19613 4993 23 effected effect VBN 19613 4993 24 by by IN 19613 4993 25 the the DT 19613 4993 26 man man NN 19613 4993 27 who who WP 19613 4993 28 in in IN 19613 4993 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4993 30 change change NN 19613 4993 31 of of IN 19613 4993 32 mind mind NN 19613 4993 33 lays lay VBZ 19613 4993 34 aside aside RB 19613 4993 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4993 36 sins sin NNS 19613 4993 37 . . . 19613 4994 1 The the DT 19613 4994 2 name name NN 19613 4994 3 of of IN 19613 4994 4 God God NNP 19613 4994 5 is be VBZ 19613 4994 6 pronounced pronounce VBN 19613 4994 7 above above IN 19613 4994 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 4994 9 who who WP 19613 4994 10 repents repent VBZ 19613 4994 11 of of IN 19613 4994 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4994 13 transgressions transgression NNS 19613 4994 14 , , , 19613 4994 15 that that IN 19613 4994 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 4994 17 may may MD 19613 4994 18 receive receive VB 19613 4994 19 freedom freedom NN 19613 4994 20 , , , 19613 4994 21 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4994 22 , , , 19613 4994 23 and and CC 19613 4994 24 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 4994 25 of of IN 19613 4994 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 4994 27 previous previous JJ 19613 4994 28 sins sin NNS 19613 4994 29 , , , 19613 4994 30 but but CC 19613 4994 31 this this DT 19613 4994 32 effects effect VBZ 19613 4994 33 a a DT 19613 4994 34 change change NN 19613 4994 35 only only RB 19613 4994 36 denoting denote VBG 19613 4994 37 the the DT 19613 4994 38 new new JJ 19613 4994 39 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 4994 40 to to TO 19613 4994 41 which which WDT 19613 4994 42 the the DT 19613 4994 43 baptised baptise VBN 19613 4994 44 person person NN 19613 4994 45 has have VBZ 19613 4994 46 attained attain VBN 19613 4994 47 . . . 19613 4994 48 " " '' 19613 4995 1 If if IN 19613 4995 2 , , , 19613 4995 3 as as IN 19613 4995 4 all all PDT 19613 4995 5 this this DT 19613 4995 6 seems seem VBZ 19613 4995 7 to to TO 19613 4995 8 show show VB 19613 4995 9 , , , 19613 4995 10 the the DT 19613 4995 11 thought thought NN 19613 4995 12 of of IN 19613 4995 13 a a DT 19613 4995 14 specific specific JJ 19613 4995 15 grace grace NN 19613 4995 16 of of IN 19613 4995 17 God God NNP 19613 4995 18 in in IN 19613 4995 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 4995 20 appears appear VBZ 19613 4995 21 virtually virtually RB 19613 4995 22 neutralised neutralise VBN 19613 4995 23 , , , 19613 4995 24 the the DT 19613 4995 25 adherence adherence NN 19613 4995 26 to to IN 19613 4995 27 the the DT 19613 4995 28 language language NN 19613 4995 29 of of IN 19613 4995 30 the the DT 19613 4995 31 cultus cultus NN 19613 4995 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4995 33 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4995 34 and and CC 19613 4995 35 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 4995 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4995 37 and and CC 19613 4995 38 Justin Justin NNP 19613 4995 39 's 's POS 19613 4995 40 conception conception NN 19613 4995 41 of of IN 19613 4995 42 the the DT 19613 4995 43 Lord Lord NNP 19613 4995 44 's 's POS 19613 4995 45 Supper Supper NNP 19613 4995 46 show show NN 19613 4995 47 that that IN 19613 4995 48 the the DT 19613 4995 49 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 4995 50 strove strove VBP 19613 4995 51 to to TO 19613 4995 52 get get VB 19613 4995 53 beyond beyond IN 19613 4995 54 moralism moralism NN 19613 4995 55 , , , 19613 4995 56 that that RB 19613 4995 57 is is RB 19613 4995 58 , , , 19613 4995 59 they -PRON- PRP 19613 4995 60 tried try VBD 19613 4995 61 to to TO 19613 4995 62 supplement supplement VB 19613 4995 63 it -PRON- PRP 19613 4995 64 through through IN 19613 4995 65 the the DT 19613 4995 66 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 4995 67 . . . 19613 4996 1 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 4996 2 's 's POS 19613 4996 3 assertion assertion NN 19613 4996 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 4996 5 de de FW 19613 4996 6 predest predest NNP 19613 4996 7 . . . 19613 4997 1 sanct sanct JJ 19613 4997 2 . . . 19613 4998 1 27 27 CD 19613 4998 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 4998 3 that that IN 19613 4998 4 the the DT 19613 4998 5 faith faith NN 19613 4998 6 of of IN 19613 4998 7 the the DT 19613 4998 8 old old JJ 19613 4998 9 Church Church NNP 19613 4998 10 in in IN 19613 4998 11 the the DT 19613 4998 12 efficacy efficacy NN 19613 4998 13 of of IN 19613 4998 14 divine divine JJ 19613 4998 15 grace grace NN 19613 4998 16 was be VBD 19613 4998 17 not not RB 19613 4998 18 so so RB 19613 4998 19 much much RB 19613 4998 20 expressed express VBN 19613 4998 21 in in IN 19613 4998 22 the the DT 19613 4998 23 _ _ NNP 19613 4998 24 opuscula opuscula NN 19613 4998 25 _ _ NNP 19613 4998 26 as as IN 19613 4998 27 in in IN 19613 4998 28 the the DT 19613 4998 29 _ _ NNP 19613 4998 30 prayers prayer NNS 19613 4998 31 _ _ NNP 19613 4998 32 , , , 19613 4998 33 shows show VBZ 19613 4998 34 correct correct JJ 19613 4998 35 insight insight NN 19613 4998 36 . . . 19613 4999 1 3 3 LS 19613 4999 2 . . . 19613 5000 1 All all PDT 19613 5000 2 the the DT 19613 5000 3 demands demand NNS 19613 5000 4 , , , 19613 5000 5 the the DT 19613 5000 6 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 5000 7 of of IN 19613 5000 8 which which WDT 19613 5000 9 constitutes constitute VBZ 19613 5000 10 the the DT 19613 5000 11 virtue virtue NN 19613 5000 12 and and CC 19613 5000 13 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 5000 14 of of IN 19613 5000 15 men man NNS 19613 5000 16 , , , 19613 5000 17 are be VBP 19613 5000 18 summed sum VBN 19613 5000 19 up up RP 19613 5000 20 under under IN 19613 5000 21 the the DT 19613 5000 22 title title NN 19613 5000 23 of of IN 19613 5000 24 _ _ NNP 19613 5000 25 the the DT 19613 5000 26 new new JJ 19613 5000 27 law law NN 19613 5000 28 _ _ NNP 19613 5000 29 . . . 19613 5001 1 In in IN 19613 5001 2 virtue virtue NN 19613 5001 3 of of IN 19613 5001 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5001 5 eternally eternally RB 19613 5001 6 valid valid JJ 19613 5001 7 content content NN 19613 5001 8 this this DT 19613 5001 9 new new JJ 19613 5001 10 law law NN 19613 5001 11 is be VBZ 19613 5001 12 in in IN 19613 5001 13 reality reality NN 19613 5001 14 the the DT 19613 5001 15 oldest old JJS 19613 5001 16 ; ; : 19613 5001 17 but but CC 19613 5001 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5001 19 is be VBZ 19613 5001 20 new new JJ 19613 5001 21 because because IN 19613 5001 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5001 23 and and CC 19613 5001 24 the the DT 19613 5001 25 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5001 26 were be VBD 19613 5001 27 preceded precede VBN 19613 5001 28 by by IN 19613 5001 29 Moses Moses NNP 19613 5001 30 , , , 19613 5001 31 who who WP 19613 5001 32 inculcated inculcate VBD 19613 5001 33 on on IN 19613 5001 34 the the DT 19613 5001 35 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 5001 36 in in IN 19613 5001 37 a a DT 19613 5001 38 transient transient JJ 19613 5001 39 form form NN 19613 5001 40 that that WDT 19613 5001 41 which which WDT 19613 5001 42 was be VBD 19613 5001 43 eternally eternally RB 19613 5001 44 valid valid JJ 19613 5001 45 . . . 19613 5002 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5002 2 is be VBZ 19613 5002 3 also also RB 19613 5002 4 new new JJ 19613 5002 5 because because IN 19613 5002 6 , , , 19613 5002 7 being be VBG 19613 5002 8 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 5002 9 by by IN 19613 5002 10 the the DT 19613 5002 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5002 12 that that WDT 19613 5002 13 appeared appear VBD 19613 5002 14 in in IN 19613 5002 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5002 16 , , , 19613 5002 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5002 18 announced announce VBD 19613 5002 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5002 20 presence presence NN 19613 5002 21 with with IN 19613 5002 22 the the DT 19613 5002 23 utmost utmost JJ 19613 5002 24 impressiveness impressiveness NN 19613 5002 25 and and CC 19613 5002 26 undoubted undoubted JJ 19613 5002 27 authority authority NN 19613 5002 28 , , , 19613 5002 29 and and CC 19613 5002 30 contains contain VBZ 19613 5002 31 the the DT 19613 5002 32 promise promise NN 19613 5002 33 of of IN 19613 5002 34 reward reward NN 19613 5002 35 in in IN 19613 5002 36 terms term NNS 19613 5002 37 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 5002 38 by by IN 19613 5002 39 the the DT 19613 5002 40 strongest strong JJS 19613 5002 41 proof proof NN 19613 5002 42 -- -- : 19613 5002 43 the the DT 19613 5002 44 proof proof NN 19613 5002 45 from from IN 19613 5002 46 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 5002 47 . . . 19613 5003 1 The the DT 19613 5003 2 old old JJ 19613 5003 3 law law NN 19613 5003 4 is be VBZ 19613 5003 5 consequently consequently RB 19613 5003 6 a a DT 19613 5003 7 new new JJ 19613 5003 8 one one NN 19613 5003 9 because because IN 19613 5003 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5003 11 appears appear VBZ 19613 5003 12 now now RB 19613 5003 13 for for IN 19613 5003 14 the the DT 19613 5003 15 first first JJ 19613 5003 16 time time NN 19613 5003 17 as as IN 19613 5003 18 purely purely RB 19613 5003 19 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 5003 20 , , , 19613 5003 21 perfect perfect JJ 19613 5003 22 , , , 19613 5003 23 and and CC 19613 5003 24 final final JJ 19613 5003 25 . . . 19613 5004 1 The the DT 19613 5004 2 commandment commandment NN 19613 5004 3 of of IN 19613 5004 4 love love NN 19613 5004 5 to to IN 19613 5004 6 one one NN 19613 5004 7 's 's POS 19613 5004 8 neighbour neighbour NN 19613 5004 9 also also RB 19613 5004 10 belongs belong VBZ 19613 5004 11 to to IN 19613 5004 12 the the DT 19613 5004 13 law law NN 19613 5004 14 ; ; : 19613 5004 15 but but CC 19613 5004 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5004 17 does do VBZ 19613 5004 18 not not RB 19613 5004 19 form form VB 19613 5004 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5004 21 essence essence NN 19613 5004 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5004 23 still still RB 19613 5004 24 less less JJR 19613 5004 25 love love NN 19613 5004 26 to to IN 19613 5004 27 God God NNP 19613 5004 28 , , , 19613 5004 29 the the DT 19613 5004 30 place place NN 19613 5004 31 of of IN 19613 5004 32 which which WDT 19613 5004 33 is be VBZ 19613 5004 34 taken take VBN 19613 5004 35 by by IN 19613 5004 36 faith faith NN 19613 5004 37 , , , 19613 5004 38 obedience obedience NN 19613 5004 39 , , , 19613 5004 40 and and CC 19613 5004 41 imitation imitation NN 19613 5004 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5004 43 . . . 19613 5005 1 The the DT 19613 5005 2 content content NN 19613 5005 3 of of IN 19613 5005 4 all all DT 19613 5005 5 moral moral JJ 19613 5005 6 demands demand NNS 19613 5005 7 is be VBZ 19613 5005 8 comprehended comprehend VBN 19613 5005 9 in in IN 19613 5005 10 the the DT 19613 5005 11 commandment commandment NN 19613 5005 12 of of IN 19613 5005 13 perfect perfect JJ 19613 5005 14 , , , 19613 5005 15 active active JJ 19613 5005 16 holiness holiness NN 19613 5005 17 , , , 19613 5005 18 which which WDT 19613 5005 19 is be VBZ 19613 5005 20 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 5005 21 by by IN 19613 5005 22 the the DT 19613 5005 23 complete complete JJ 19613 5005 24 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 5005 25 of of IN 19613 5005 26 all all DT 19613 5005 27 earthly earthly JJ 19613 5005 28 blessings blessing NNS 19613 5005 29 , , , 19613 5005 30 even even RB 19613 5005 31 of of IN 19613 5005 32 life life NN 19613 5005 33 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5005 34 . . . 19613 5006 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5006 2 preached preach VBD 19613 5006 3 this this DT 19613 5006 4 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 5006 5 in in IN 19613 5006 6 a a DT 19613 5006 7 specially specially RB 19613 5006 8 powerful powerful JJ 19613 5006 9 manner manner NN 19613 5006 10 . . . 19613 5007 1 There there EX 19613 5007 2 is be VBZ 19613 5007 3 no no DT 19613 5007 4 need need NN 19613 5007 5 to to TO 19613 5007 6 prove prove VB 19613 5007 7 that that IN 19613 5007 8 no no DT 19613 5007 9 remains remain NNS 19613 5007 10 of of IN 19613 5007 11 Judæo Judæo NNP 19613 5007 12 - - HYPH 19613 5007 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5007 14 are be VBP 19613 5007 15 to to TO 19613 5007 16 be be VB 19613 5007 17 recognised recognise VBN 19613 5007 18 in in IN 19613 5007 19 these these DT 19613 5007 20 ideas idea NNS 19613 5007 21 about about IN 19613 5007 22 the the DT 19613 5007 23 new new JJ 19613 5007 24 law law NN 19613 5007 25 . . . 19613 5008 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5008 2 is be VBZ 19613 5008 3 not not RB 19613 5008 4 Judæo Judæo NNP 19613 5008 5 - - HYPH 19613 5008 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5008 7 that that WDT 19613 5008 8 lies lie VBZ 19613 5008 9 behind behind IN 19613 5008 10 the the DT 19613 5008 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5008 12 and and CC 19613 5008 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5008 14 of of IN 19613 5008 15 the the DT 19613 5008 16 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5008 17 , , , 19613 5008 18 but but CC 19613 5008 19 Greek greek JJ 19613 5008 20 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5008 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5008 22 Platonic platonic JJ 19613 5008 23 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 19613 5008 24 , , , 19613 5008 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5008 26 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5008 27 of of IN 19613 5008 28 the the DT 19613 5008 29 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5008 30 , , , 19613 5008 31 Platonic Platonic NNP 19613 5008 32 and and CC 19613 5008 33 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 5008 34 ethics ethic NNS 19613 5008 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5008 36 , , , 19613 5008 37 the the DT 19613 5008 38 Alexandrine alexandrine JJ 19613 5008 39 - - HYPH 19613 5008 40 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 5008 41 apologetics apologetic NNS 19613 5008 42 , , , 19613 5008 43 the the DT 19613 5008 44 maxims maxim NNS 19613 5008 45 of of IN 19613 5008 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5008 47 , , , 19613 5008 48 and and CC 19613 5008 49 the the DT 19613 5008 50 religious religious JJ 19613 5008 51 speech speech NN 19613 5008 52 of of IN 19613 5008 53 the the DT 19613 5008 54 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5008 55 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 5008 56 . . . 19613 5009 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5009 2 is be VBZ 19613 5009 3 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5009 4 from from IN 19613 5009 5 Philo Philo NNP 19613 5009 6 by by IN 19613 5009 7 the the DT 19613 5009 8 sure sure JJ 19613 5009 9 conviction conviction NN 19613 5009 10 of of IN 19613 5009 11 the the DT 19613 5009 12 living live VBG 19613 5009 13 power power NN 19613 5009 14 of of IN 19613 5009 15 God God NNP 19613 5009 16 , , , 19613 5009 17 the the DT 19613 5009 18 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5009 19 and and CC 19613 5009 20 Lord Lord NNP 19613 5009 21 of of IN 19613 5009 22 the the DT 19613 5009 23 world world NN 19613 5009 24 , , , 19613 5009 25 and and CC 19613 5009 26 the the DT 19613 5009 27 steadfast steadfast JJ 19613 5009 28 confidence confidence NN 19613 5009 29 in in IN 19613 5009 30 the the DT 19613 5009 31 reality reality NN 19613 5009 32 of of IN 19613 5009 33 all all PDT 19613 5009 34 the the DT 19613 5009 35 ideals ideal NNS 19613 5009 36 which which WDT 19613 5009 37 is be VBZ 19613 5009 38 derived derive VBN 19613 5009 39 from from IN 19613 5009 40 the the DT 19613 5009 41 person person NN 19613 5009 42 of of IN 19613 5009 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5009 44 . . . 19613 5010 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5010 2 ought ought MD 19613 5010 3 not not RB 19613 5010 4 , , , 19613 5010 5 however however RB 19613 5010 6 , , , 19613 5010 7 to to TO 19613 5010 8 blame blame VB 19613 5010 9 the the DT 19613 5010 10 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5010 11 because because IN 19613 5010 12 to to IN 19613 5010 13 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5010 14 nearly nearly RB 19613 5010 15 everything everything NN 19613 5010 16 historical historical JJ 19613 5010 17 was be VBD 19613 5010 18 at at IN 19613 5010 19 bottom bottom NN 19613 5010 20 only only RB 19613 5010 21 a a DT 19613 5010 22 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 5010 23 of of IN 19613 5010 24 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5010 25 and and CC 19613 5010 26 hopes hope NNS 19613 5010 27 . . . 19613 5011 1 As as IN 19613 5011 2 a a DT 19613 5011 3 matter matter NN 19613 5011 4 of of IN 19613 5011 5 fact fact NN 19613 5011 6 , , , 19613 5011 7 the the DT 19613 5011 8 assurance assurance NN 19613 5011 9 is be VBZ 19613 5011 10 not not RB 19613 5011 11 less less RBR 19613 5011 12 important important JJ 19613 5011 13 than than IN 19613 5011 14 the the DT 19613 5011 15 content content NN 19613 5011 16 . . . 19613 5012 1 By by IN 19613 5012 2 dint dint NN 19613 5012 3 of of IN 19613 5012 4 thinking think VBG 19613 5012 5 one one PRP 19613 5012 6 can can MD 19613 5012 7 conceive conceive VB 19613 5012 8 the the DT 19613 5012 9 highest high JJS 19613 5012 10 truth truth NN 19613 5012 11 , , , 19613 5012 12 but but CC 19613 5012 13 one one PRP 19613 5012 14 can can MD 19613 5012 15 not not RB 19613 5012 16 in in IN 19613 5012 17 this this DT 19613 5012 18 way way NN 19613 5012 19 make make VB 19613 5012 20 out out RP 19613 5012 21 the the DT 19613 5012 22 certainty certainty NN 19613 5012 23 of of IN 19613 5012 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5012 25 reality reality NN 19613 5012 26 . . . 19613 5013 1 No no DT 19613 5013 2 positive positive JJ 19613 5013 3 religion religion NN 19613 5013 4 can can MD 19613 5013 5 do do VB 19613 5013 6 more more JJR 19613 5013 7 for for IN 19613 5013 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5013 9 followers follower NNS 19613 5013 10 than than IN 19613 5013 11 faith faith NN 19613 5013 12 in in IN 19613 5013 13 the the DT 19613 5013 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 5013 15 through through IN 19613 5013 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5013 17 and and CC 19613 5013 18 the the DT 19613 5013 19 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5013 20 did do VBD 19613 5013 21 for for IN 19613 5013 22 the the DT 19613 5013 23 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5013 24 . . . 19613 5014 1 Although although IN 19613 5014 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5014 3 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 5014 4 proved prove VBD 19613 5014 5 to to IN 19613 5014 6 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5014 7 the the DT 19613 5014 8 truth truth NN 19613 5014 9 of of IN 19613 5014 10 that that DT 19613 5014 11 which which WDT 19613 5014 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5014 13 call call VBP 19613 5014 14 natural natural JJ 19613 5014 15 theology theology NN 19613 5014 16 and and CC 19613 5014 17 which which WDT 19613 5014 18 was be VBD 19613 5014 19 the the DT 19613 5014 20 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 5014 21 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5014 22 of of IN 19613 5014 23 the the DT 19613 5014 24 age age NN 19613 5014 25 , , , 19613 5014 26 so so IN 19613 5014 27 that that IN 19613 5014 28 the the DT 19613 5014 29 Church Church NNP 19613 5014 30 appears appear VBZ 19613 5014 31 as as IN 19613 5014 32 the the DT 19613 5014 33 great great JJ 19613 5014 34 insurance insurance NN 19613 5014 35 society society NN 19613 5014 36 for for IN 19613 5014 37 the the DT 19613 5014 38 ideas idea NNS 19613 5014 39 of of IN 19613 5014 40 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5014 41 and and CC 19613 5014 42 Zeno Zeno NNP 19613 5014 43 , , , 19613 5014 44 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5014 45 ought ought MD 19613 5014 46 not not RB 19613 5014 47 at at IN 19613 5014 48 the the DT 19613 5014 49 same same JJ 19613 5014 50 time time NN 19613 5014 51 to to TO 19613 5014 52 forget forget VB 19613 5014 53 that that IN 19613 5014 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5014 55 idea idea NN 19613 5014 56 of of IN 19613 5014 57 a a DT 19613 5014 58 divine divine JJ 19613 5014 59 spirit spirit NN 19613 5014 60 working work VBG 19613 5014 61 upon upon IN 19613 5014 62 earth earth NN 19613 5014 63 was be VBD 19613 5014 64 a a DT 19613 5014 65 far far RB 19613 5014 66 more more RBR 19613 5014 67 lively lively JJ 19613 5014 68 and and CC 19613 5014 69 worthy worthy JJ 19613 5014 70 one one CD 19613 5014 71 than than IN 19613 5014 72 in in IN 19613 5014 73 the the DT 19613 5014 74 case case NN 19613 5014 75 of of IN 19613 5014 76 the the DT 19613 5014 77 Greek greek JJ 19613 5014 78 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5014 79 . . . 19613 5015 1 4 4 LS 19613 5015 2 . . . 19613 5016 1 By by IN 19613 5016 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5016 3 intellectualism intellectualism NN 19613 5016 4 and and CC 19613 5016 5 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 5016 6 theories theory NNS 19613 5016 7 the the DT 19613 5016 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5016 9 founded found VBD 19613 5016 10 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 5016 11 and and CC 19613 5016 12 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 5016 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5016 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5016 15 Loofs Loofs NNP 19613 5016 16 : : : 19613 5016 17 " " `` 19613 5016 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5016 19 laid lay VBD 19613 5016 20 the the DT 19613 5016 21 foundation foundation NN 19613 5016 22 for for IN 19613 5016 23 the the DT 19613 5016 24 conversion conversion NN 19613 5016 25 of of IN 19613 5016 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5016 27 into into IN 19613 5016 28 a a DT 19613 5016 29 revealed reveal VBN 19613 5016 30 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5016 31 . . . 19613 5017 1 " " `` 19613 5017 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5017 3 459 459 CD 19613 5017 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5017 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5017 6 If if IN 19613 5017 7 about about IN 19613 5017 8 the the DT 19613 5017 9 middle middle NN 19613 5017 10 of of IN 19613 5017 11 the the DT 19613 5017 12 second second JJ 19613 5017 13 century century NN 19613 5017 14 the the DT 19613 5017 15 short short JJ 19613 5017 16 confession confession NN 19613 5017 17 of of IN 19613 5017 18 the the DT 19613 5017 19 Lord Lord NNP 19613 5017 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5017 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5017 22 was be VBD 19613 5017 23 regarded regard VBN 19613 5017 24 as as IN 19613 5017 25 a a DT 19613 5017 26 watchword watchword NN 19613 5017 27 , , , 19613 5017 28 passport passport NN 19613 5017 29 , , , 19613 5017 30 and and CC 19613 5017 31 _ _ NNP 19613 5017 32 tessera tessera NNP 19613 5017 33 hospitalitas hospitalitas NNP 19613 5017 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5017 35 signum signum JJ 19613 5017 36 et et NNP 19613 5017 37 vinculum vinculum NN 19613 5017 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5017 39 _ _ NNP 19613 5017 40 , , , 19613 5017 41 and and CC 19613 5017 42 if if IN 19613 5017 43 even even RB 19613 5017 44 in in IN 19613 5017 45 lay lay JJ 19613 5017 46 and and CC 19613 5017 47 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 5017 48 circles circle NNS 19613 5017 49 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5017 50 was be VBD 19613 5017 51 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5017 52 as as IN 19613 5017 53 " " `` 19613 5017 54 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5017 55 " " '' 19613 5017 56 in in IN 19613 5017 57 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 5017 58 to to TO 19613 5017 59 heresy heresy VB 19613 5017 60 , , , 19613 5017 61 this this DT 19613 5017 62 transformation transformation NN 19613 5017 63 must must MD 19613 5017 64 have have VB 19613 5017 65 been be VBN 19613 5017 66 accelerated accelerate VBN 19613 5017 67 through through IN 19613 5017 68 men man NNS 19613 5017 69 , , , 19613 5017 70 who who WP 19613 5017 71 essentially essentially RB 19613 5017 72 conceived conceive VBD 19613 5017 73 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5017 74 as as IN 19613 5017 75 the the DT 19613 5017 76 " " `` 19613 5017 77 divine divine JJ 19613 5017 78 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5017 79 , , , 19613 5017 80 " " '' 19613 5017 81 and and CC 19613 5017 82 by by IN 19613 5017 83 whom whom WP 19613 5017 84 all all PDT 19613 5017 85 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5017 86 distinctive distinctive JJ 19613 5017 87 features feature NNS 19613 5017 88 were be VBD 19613 5017 89 subordinated subordinate VBN 19613 5017 90 to to IN 19613 5017 91 this this DT 19613 5017 92 conception conception NN 19613 5017 93 or or CC 19613 5017 94 neutralised neutralise VBN 19613 5017 95 . . . 19613 5018 1 As as IN 19613 5018 2 the the DT 19613 5018 3 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 5018 4 schools school NNS 19613 5018 5 are be VBP 19613 5018 6 held hold VBN 19613 5018 7 together together RB 19613 5018 8 by by IN 19613 5018 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5018 10 " " `` 19613 5018 11 laws law NNS 19613 5018 12 " " '' 19613 5018 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5018 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5018 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5018 16 : : : 19613 5018 17 nomoi nomoi NNP 19613 5018 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5018 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5018 20 as as IN 19613 5018 21 the the DT 19613 5018 22 " " `` 19613 5018 23 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 5018 24 " " '' 19613 5018 25 form form VB 19613 5018 26 the the DT 19613 5018 27 real real JJ 19613 5018 28 bond bond NN 19613 5018 29 between between IN 19613 5018 30 the the DT 19613 5018 31 " " `` 19613 5018 32 friends friend NNS 19613 5018 33 , , , 19613 5018 34 " " '' 19613 5018 35 and and CC 19613 5018 36 as as IN 19613 5018 37 , , , 19613 5018 38 in in IN 19613 5018 39 addition addition NN 19613 5018 40 to to IN 19613 5018 41 this this DT 19613 5018 42 , , , 19613 5018 43 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5018 44 are be VBP 19613 5018 45 united unite VBN 19613 5018 46 by by IN 19613 5018 47 veneration veneration NN 19613 5018 48 for for IN 19613 5018 49 the the DT 19613 5018 50 founder founder NN 19613 5018 51 , , , 19613 5018 52 so so RB 19613 5018 53 also also RB 19613 5018 54 the the DT 19613 5018 55 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5018 56 Church Church NNP 19613 5018 57 appeared appear VBD 19613 5018 58 to to IN 19613 5018 59 the the DT 19613 5018 60 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5018 61 as as IN 19613 5018 62 a a DT 19613 5018 63 universal universal JJ 19613 5018 64 league league NN 19613 5018 65 established establish VBN 19613 5018 66 by by IN 19613 5018 67 a a DT 19613 5018 68 divine divine JJ 19613 5018 69 founder founder NN 19613 5018 70 and and CC 19613 5018 71 resting rest VBG 19613 5018 72 _ _ NNP 19613 5018 73 on on IN 19613 5018 74 the the DT 19613 5018 75 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 5018 76 of of IN 19613 5018 77 the the DT 19613 5018 78 perfectly perfectly RB 19613 5018 79 known know VBN 19613 5018 80 truth truth NN 19613 5018 81 _ _ NNP 19613 5018 82 , , , 19613 5018 83 a a DT 19613 5018 84 league league NN 19613 5018 85 the the DT 19613 5018 86 members member NNS 19613 5018 87 of of IN 19613 5018 88 which which WDT 19613 5018 89 possess possess VBP 19613 5018 90 definite definite JJ 19613 5018 91 laws law NNS 19613 5018 92 , , , 19613 5018 93 viz viz NNP 19613 5018 94 . . NNP 19613 5018 95 , , , 19613 5018 96 the the DT 19613 5018 97 eternal eternal JJ 19613 5018 98 laws law NNS 19613 5018 99 of of IN 19613 5018 100 nature nature NN 19613 5018 101 for for IN 19613 5018 102 everything everything NN 19613 5018 103 moral moral JJ 19613 5018 104 , , , 19613 5018 105 and and CC 19613 5018 106 unite unite VB 19613 5018 107 in in IN 19613 5018 108 common common JJ 19613 5018 109 veneration veneration NN 19613 5018 110 for for IN 19613 5018 111 the the DT 19613 5018 112 Divine Divine NNP 19613 5018 113 Master Master NNP 19613 5018 114 . . . 19613 5019 1 In in IN 19613 5019 2 the the DT 19613 5019 3 " " `` 19613 5019 4 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 5019 5 " " '' 19613 5019 6 of of IN 19613 5019 7 the the DT 19613 5019 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5019 9 , , , 19613 5019 10 however however RB 19613 5019 11 , , , 19613 5019 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5019 13 find find VBP 19613 5019 14 nothing nothing NN 19613 5019 15 more more JJR 19613 5019 16 than than IN 19613 5019 17 traces trace NNS 19613 5019 18 of of IN 19613 5019 19 the the DT 19613 5019 20 fusion fusion NN 19613 5019 21 of of IN 19613 5019 22 the the DT 19613 5019 23 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5019 24 and and CC 19613 5019 25 historical historical JJ 19613 5019 26 elements element NNS 19613 5019 27 ; ; : 19613 5019 28 in in IN 19613 5019 29 the the DT 19613 5019 30 main main JJ 19613 5019 31 both both DT 19613 5019 32 exist exist VBP 19613 5019 33 separately separately RB 19613 5019 34 side side NN 19613 5019 35 by by IN 19613 5019 36 side side NN 19613 5019 37 . . . 19613 5020 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5020 2 was be VBD 19613 5020 3 not not RB 19613 5020 4 till till IN 19613 5020 5 long long RB 19613 5020 6 after after IN 19613 5020 7 this this DT 19613 5020 8 that that IN 19613 5020 9 intellectualism intellectualism NN 19613 5020 10 gained gain VBD 19613 5020 11 the the DT 19613 5020 12 victory victory NN 19613 5020 13 in in IN 19613 5020 14 a a DT 19613 5020 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5020 16 represented represent VBN 19613 5020 17 by by IN 19613 5020 18 the the DT 19613 5020 19 clergy clergy NN 19613 5020 20 . . . 19613 5021 1 What what WP 19613 5021 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5021 3 here here RB 19613 5021 4 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 5021 5 understand understand VBP 19613 5021 6 by by IN 19613 5021 7 " " `` 19613 5021 8 intellectualism intellectualism NN 19613 5021 9 " " '' 19613 5021 10 is be VBZ 19613 5021 11 the the DT 19613 5021 12 placing placing NN 19613 5021 13 of of IN 19613 5021 14 the the DT 19613 5021 15 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5021 16 conception conception NN 19613 5021 17 of of IN 19613 5021 18 the the DT 19613 5021 19 world world NN 19613 5021 20 behind behind IN 19613 5021 21 the the DT 19613 5021 22 commandments commandment NNS 19613 5021 23 of of IN 19613 5021 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 5021 25 morality morality NN 19613 5021 26 and and CC 19613 5021 27 behind behind IN 19613 5021 28 the the DT 19613 5021 29 hopes hope NNS 19613 5021 30 and and CC 19613 5021 31 faith faith NN 19613 5021 32 of of IN 19613 5021 33 the the DT 19613 5021 34 Christian christian JJ 19613 5021 35 religion religion NN 19613 5021 36 , , , 19613 5021 37 and and CC 19613 5021 38 the the DT 19613 5021 39 connecting connecting NN 19613 5021 40 of of IN 19613 5021 41 the the DT 19613 5021 42 two two CD 19613 5021 43 things thing NNS 19613 5021 44 in in IN 19613 5021 45 such such PDT 19613 5021 46 a a DT 19613 5021 47 way way NN 19613 5021 48 that that IN 19613 5021 49 this this DT 19613 5021 50 conception conception NN 19613 5021 51 appeared appear VBD 19613 5021 52 as as IN 19613 5021 53 the the DT 19613 5021 54 foundation foundation NN 19613 5021 55 of of IN 19613 5021 56 these these DT 19613 5021 57 commandments commandment NNS 19613 5021 58 and and CC 19613 5021 59 hopes hope NNS 19613 5021 60 . . . 19613 5022 1 Thus thus RB 19613 5022 2 was be VBD 19613 5022 3 created create VBN 19613 5022 4 the the DT 19613 5022 5 future future JJ 19613 5022 6 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 5022 7 in in IN 19613 5022 8 the the DT 19613 5022 9 form form NN 19613 5022 10 which which WDT 19613 5022 11 still still RB 19613 5022 12 prevails prevail VBZ 19613 5022 13 in in IN 19613 5022 14 the the DT 19613 5022 15 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 5022 16 and and CC 19613 5022 17 which which WDT 19613 5022 18 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 5022 19 the the DT 19613 5022 20 Platonic platonic JJ 19613 5022 21 and and CC 19613 5022 22 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 5022 23 conception conception NN 19613 5022 24 of of IN 19613 5022 25 the the DT 19613 5022 26 world world NN 19613 5022 27 long long RB 19613 5022 28 ago ago RB 19613 5022 29 overthrown overthrow VBN 19613 5022 30 by by IN 19613 5022 31 science science NN 19613 5022 32 . . . 19613 5023 1 The the DT 19613 5023 2 attempt attempt NN 19613 5023 3 made make VBN 19613 5023 4 at at IN 19613 5023 5 the the DT 19613 5023 6 beginning beginning NN 19613 5023 7 of of IN 19613 5023 8 the the DT 19613 5023 9 Reformation Reformation NNP 19613 5023 10 to to TO 19613 5023 11 free free VB 19613 5023 12 the the DT 19613 5023 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 5023 14 faith faith NN 19613 5023 15 from from IN 19613 5023 16 this this DT 19613 5023 17 amalgamation amalgamation NN 19613 5023 18 remained remain VBD 19613 5023 19 at at IN 19613 5023 20 first first RB 19613 5023 21 without without IN 19613 5023 22 success success NN 19613 5023 23 . . . 19613 5024 1 Footnotes footnote NNS 19613 5024 2 : : : 19613 5024 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5024 4 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5024 5 340 340 CD 19613 5024 6 : : : 19613 5024 7 Edition edition NN 19613 5024 8 by by IN 19613 5024 9 Otto Otto NNP 19613 5024 10 , , , 19613 5024 11 9 9 CD 19613 5024 12 Vols Vols NNP 19613 5024 13 . . NNP 19613 5024 14 , , , 19613 5024 15 1876 1876 CD 19613 5024 16 f. f. NNP 19613 5024 17 New New NNP 19613 5024 18 edition edition NN 19613 5024 19 of of IN 19613 5024 20 the the DT 19613 5024 21 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5024 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5024 23 unfinished unfinished JJ 19613 5024 24 ; ; : 19613 5024 25 only only RB 19613 5024 26 Tatian tatian JJ 19613 5024 27 and and CC 19613 5024 28 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 5024 29 by by IN 19613 5024 30 Schwarz Schwarz NNP 19613 5024 31 have have VBP 19613 5024 32 yet yet RB 19613 5024 33 appeared appear VBN 19613 5024 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5024 35 in in IN 19613 5024 36 the the DT 19613 5024 37 Texte Texte NNP 19613 5024 38 und und NN 19613 5024 39 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 5024 40 zur zur NN 19613 5024 41 altchristlichen altchristlichen NNP 19613 5024 42 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 5024 43 - - HYPH 19613 5024 44 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 5024 45 , , , 19613 5024 46 Vol Vol NNP 19613 5024 47 . . . 19613 5025 1 IV IV NNP 19613 5025 2 . . . 19613 5026 1 Tzschirner Tzschirner NNP 19613 5026 2 , , , 19613 5026 3 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 5026 4 der der VBD 19613 5026 5 Apologetik Apologetik NNP 19613 5026 6 , , , 19613 5026 7 1st 1st JJ 19613 5026 8 part part NN 19613 5026 9 , , , 19613 5026 10 1805 1805 CD 19613 5026 11 ; ; : 19613 5026 12 i -PRON- PRP 19613 5026 13 d d NNP 19613 5026 14 . . NNP 19613 5026 15 , , , 19613 5026 16 Der Der NNP 19613 5026 17 Fall Fall NNP 19613 5026 18 des des NNP 19613 5026 19 Heidenthums heidenthum NNS 19613 5026 20 , , , 19613 5026 21 1829 1829 CD 19613 5026 22 . . . 19613 5027 1 Ehlers ehler NNS 19613 5027 2 , , , 19613 5027 3 Vis Vis NNP 19613 5027 4 atque atque NN 19613 5027 5 potestas potestas NN 19613 5027 6 , , , 19613 5027 7 quam quam NNP 19613 5027 8 philosophia philosophia NNP 19613 5027 9 antiqua antiqua NNP 19613 5027 10 , , , 19613 5027 11 imprimis imprimis NNP 19613 5027 12 Platonica Platonica NNP 19613 5027 13 et et NNP 19613 5027 14 Stoica Stoica NNP 19613 5027 15 in in IN 19613 5027 16 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 5027 17 apologetarum apologetarum NNP 19613 5027 18 habuerit habuerit NNP 19613 5027 19 , , , 19613 5027 20 1859 1859 CD 19613 5027 21 . . . 19613 5027 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5028 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5028 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5028 3 341 341 CD 19613 5028 4 : : : 19613 5028 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5028 6 is be VBZ 19613 5028 7 intrinsically intrinsically RB 19613 5028 8 probable probable JJ 19613 5028 9 that that IN 19613 5028 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5028 11 works work NNS 19613 5028 12 directly directly RB 19613 5028 13 addressed address VBD 19613 5028 14 to to IN 19613 5028 15 the the DT 19613 5028 16 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5028 17 Church Church NNP 19613 5028 18 gave give VBD 19613 5028 19 a a DT 19613 5028 20 more more RBR 19613 5028 21 full full JJ 19613 5028 22 exposition exposition NN 19613 5028 23 of of IN 19613 5028 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5028 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5028 26 than than IN 19613 5028 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5028 28 find find VBP 19613 5028 29 in in IN 19613 5028 30 the the DT 19613 5028 31 Apologies Apologies NNPS 19613 5028 32 . . . 19613 5029 1 This this DT 19613 5029 2 can can MD 19613 5029 3 moreover moreover RB 19613 5029 4 be be VB 19613 5029 5 proved prove VBN 19613 5029 6 with with IN 19613 5029 7 certainty certainty NN 19613 5029 8 from from IN 19613 5029 9 the the DT 19613 5029 10 fragments fragment NNS 19613 5029 11 of of IN 19613 5029 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5029 13 's 's POS 19613 5029 14 , , , 19613 5029 15 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5029 16 's 's POS 19613 5029 17 and and CC 19613 5029 18 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5029 19 's 's POS 19613 5029 20 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 5029 21 writings writing NNS 19613 5029 22 . . . 19613 5030 1 But but CC 19613 5030 2 , , , 19613 5030 3 whilst whilst IN 19613 5030 4 recognising recognise VBG 19613 5030 5 this this DT 19613 5030 6 fact fact NN 19613 5030 7 , , , 19613 5030 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5030 9 must must MD 19613 5030 10 not not RB 19613 5030 11 make make VB 19613 5030 12 the the DT 19613 5030 13 erroneous erroneous JJ 19613 5030 14 assumption assumption NN 19613 5030 15 that that IN 19613 5030 16 the the DT 19613 5030 17 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5030 18 conceptions conception NNS 19613 5030 19 and and CC 19613 5030 20 interests interest NNS 19613 5030 21 of of IN 19613 5030 22 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5030 23 and and CC 19613 5030 24 the the DT 19613 5030 25 rest rest NN 19613 5030 26 were be VBD 19613 5030 27 in in IN 19613 5030 28 reality reality NN 19613 5030 29 other other JJ 19613 5030 30 than than IN 19613 5030 31 may may MD 19613 5030 32 be be VB 19613 5030 33 inferred infer VBN 19613 5030 34 from from IN 19613 5030 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5030 36 Apologies Apologies NNPS 19613 5030 37 . . . 19613 5030 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5031 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5031 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5031 3 342 342 CD 19613 5031 4 : : : 19613 5031 5 That that RB 19613 5031 6 is is RB 19613 5031 7 , , , 19613 5031 8 so so RB 19613 5031 9 far far RB 19613 5031 10 as as IN 19613 5031 11 these these DT 19613 5031 12 were be VBD 19613 5031 13 clearly clearly RB 19613 5031 14 connected connect VBN 19613 5031 15 with with IN 19613 5031 16 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 5031 17 . . . 19613 5032 1 Where where WRB 19613 5032 2 this this DT 19613 5032 3 was be VBD 19613 5032 4 not not RB 19613 5032 5 the the DT 19613 5032 6 case case NN 19613 5032 7 or or CC 19613 5032 8 seemed seem VBD 19613 5032 9 not not RB 19613 5032 10 to to TO 19613 5032 11 be be VB 19613 5032 12 so so RB 19613 5032 13 , , , 19613 5032 14 national national JJ 19613 5032 15 traditions tradition NNS 19613 5032 16 , , , 19613 5032 17 both both CC 19613 5032 18 the the DT 19613 5032 19 true true JJ 19613 5032 20 and and CC 19613 5032 21 the the DT 19613 5032 22 spurious spurious JJ 19613 5032 23 , , , 19613 5032 24 were be VBD 19613 5032 25 readily readily RB 19613 5032 26 and and CC 19613 5032 27 joyfully joyfully RB 19613 5032 28 admitted admit VBN 19613 5032 29 into into IN 19613 5032 30 the the DT 19613 5032 31 _ _ NNP 19613 5032 32 catalogus catalogus NN 19613 5032 33 testimoniorum testimoniorum NN 19613 5032 34 _ _ NNP 19613 5032 35 of of IN 19613 5032 36 revealed reveal VBN 19613 5032 37 truth truth NN 19613 5032 38 . . . 19613 5032 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5033 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5033 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5033 3 343 343 CD 19613 5033 4 : : : 19613 5033 5 Though though IN 19613 5033 6 these these DT 19613 5033 7 words word NNS 19613 5033 8 were be VBD 19613 5033 9 already already RB 19613 5033 10 found find VBN 19613 5033 11 in in IN 19613 5033 12 the the DT 19613 5033 13 first first JJ 19613 5033 14 edition edition NN 19613 5033 15 , , , 19613 5033 16 Clemen Clemen NNP 19613 5033 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5033 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5033 19 1890 1890 CD 19613 5033 20 , , , 19613 5033 21 p. p. NN 19613 5033 22 56 56 CD 19613 5033 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5033 24 has have VBZ 19613 5033 25 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 19613 5033 26 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5033 27 so so RB 19613 5033 28 far far RB 19613 5033 29 as as IN 19613 5033 30 to to TO 19613 5033 31 think think VB 19613 5033 32 that that IN 19613 5033 33 I -PRON- PRP 19613 5033 34 spoke speak VBD 19613 5033 35 here here RB 19613 5033 36 of of IN 19613 5033 37 conscious conscious JJ 19613 5033 38 intention intention NN 19613 5033 39 on on IN 19613 5033 40 the the DT 19613 5033 41 part part NN 19613 5033 42 of of IN 19613 5033 43 the the DT 19613 5033 44 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5033 45 . . . 19613 5034 1 Such such JJ 19613 5034 2 nonsense nonsense NN 19613 5034 3 of of IN 19613 5034 4 course course NN 19613 5034 5 never never RB 19613 5034 6 occurred occur VBD 19613 5034 7 to to IN 19613 5034 8 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5034 9 . . . 19613 5034 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5035 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5035 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5035 3 344 344 CD 19613 5035 4 : : : 19613 5035 5 Note note VB 19613 5035 6 here here RB 19613 5035 7 particularly particularly RB 19613 5035 8 the the DT 19613 5035 9 attitude attitude NN 19613 5035 10 of of IN 19613 5035 11 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5035 12 , , , 19613 5035 13 who who WP 19613 5035 14 has have VBZ 19613 5035 15 already already RB 19613 5035 16 introduced introduce VBN 19613 5035 17 a a DT 19613 5035 18 certain certain JJ 19613 5035 19 amount amount NN 19613 5035 20 of of IN 19613 5035 21 the the DT 19613 5035 22 " " `` 19613 5035 23 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5035 24 " " '' 19613 5035 25 element element NN 19613 5035 26 into into IN 19613 5035 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5035 28 " " `` 19613 5035 29 Oratio Oratio NNP 19613 5035 30 ad ad NN 19613 5035 31 Græcos græcos NN 19613 5035 32 , , , 19613 5035 33 " " '' 19613 5035 34 although although IN 19613 5035 35 , , , 19613 5035 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5035 37 adheres adhere VBZ 19613 5035 38 in in IN 19613 5035 39 the the DT 19613 5035 40 main main JJ 19613 5035 41 to to IN 19613 5035 42 the the DT 19613 5035 43 ordinary ordinary JJ 19613 5035 44 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5035 45 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5035 46 . . . 19613 5035 47 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5036 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5036 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5036 3 345 345 CD 19613 5036 4 : : : 19613 5036 5 Since since IN 19613 5036 6 the the DT 19613 5036 7 time time NN 19613 5036 8 of of IN 19613 5036 9 Josephus Josephus NNP 19613 5036 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5036 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5036 12 had have VBD 19613 5036 13 ever ever RB 19613 5036 14 more more RBR 19613 5036 15 and and CC 19613 5036 16 more more RBR 19613 5036 17 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 5036 18 the the DT 19613 5036 19 " " `` 19613 5036 20 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5036 21 " " '' 19613 5036 22 character character NN 19613 5036 23 of of IN 19613 5036 24 Judaism Judaism NNP 19613 5036 25 ; ; : 19613 5036 26 see see VB 19613 5036 27 Porphyr Porphyr NNP 19613 5036 28 . . . 19613 5036 29 , , , 19613 5036 30 de de NNP 19613 5036 31 abstin abstin NNP 19613 5036 32 . . . 19613 5037 1 anim anim NNP 19613 5037 2 . . . 19613 5038 1 II ii CD 19613 5038 2 . . . 19613 5039 1 26 26 CD 19613 5039 2 , , , 19613 5039 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5039 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5039 5 : : : 19613 5039 6 hate hate VB 19613 5039 7 philosophoi philosophoi JJ 19613 5039 8 to to IN 19613 5039 9 genos genos JJ 19613 5039 10 ontes onte NNS 19613 5039 11 . . . 19613 5039 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5039 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5040 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5040 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5040 3 346 346 CD 19613 5040 4 : : : 19613 5040 5 On on IN 19613 5040 6 the the DT 19613 5040 7 relation relation NN 19613 5040 8 of of IN 19613 5040 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 5040 10 literature literature NN 19613 5040 11 to to IN 19613 5040 12 the the DT 19613 5040 13 writings writing NNS 19613 5040 14 of of IN 19613 5040 15 Philo Philo NNP 19613 5040 16 , , , 19613 5040 17 of of IN 19613 5040 18 Siegfried Siegfried NNP 19613 5040 19 , , , 19613 5040 20 Philo Philo NNP 19613 5040 21 von von NNP 19613 5040 22 Alexandrien Alexandrien NNP 19613 5040 23 , , , 19613 5040 24 p. p. NN 19613 5040 25 303 303 CD 19613 5040 26 f. f. NN 19613 5040 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5040 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5040 29 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5040 30 347 347 CD 19613 5040 31 : : : 19613 5040 32 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5040 33 is be VBZ 19613 5040 34 very very RB 19613 5040 35 instructive instructive JJ 19613 5040 36 to to TO 19613 5040 37 find find VB 19613 5040 38 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 5040 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5040 40 Origen Origen NNP 19613 5040 41 , , , 19613 5040 42 c. c. NN 19613 5040 43 Cels Cels NNP 19613 5040 44 . . . 19613 5041 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5042 1 2 2 LS 19613 5042 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5042 3 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 5042 4 to to TO 19613 5042 5 say say VB 19613 5042 6 that that IN 19613 5042 7 the the DT 19613 5042 8 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5042 9 understood understand VBD 19613 5042 10 better better RB 19613 5042 11 how how WRB 19613 5042 12 to to TO 19613 5042 13 judge judge VB 19613 5042 14 , , , 19613 5042 15 to to TO 19613 5042 16 investigate investigate VB 19613 5042 17 , , , 19613 5042 18 and and CC 19613 5042 19 to to TO 19613 5042 20 perfect perfect VB 19613 5042 21 the the DT 19613 5042 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5042 23 devised devise VBN 19613 5042 24 by by IN 19613 5042 25 the the DT 19613 5042 26 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 5042 27 , , , 19613 5042 28 and and CC 19613 5042 29 to to TO 19613 5042 30 apply apply VB 19613 5042 31 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5042 32 to to IN 19613 5042 33 the the DT 19613 5042 34 practice practice NN 19613 5042 35 of of IN 19613 5042 36 virtue virtue NN 19613 5042 37 . . . 19613 5043 1 This this DT 19613 5043 2 is be VBZ 19613 5043 3 quite quite RB 19613 5043 4 in in IN 19613 5043 5 accordance accordance NN 19613 5043 6 with with IN 19613 5043 7 the the DT 19613 5043 8 idea idea NN 19613 5043 9 of of IN 19613 5043 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 5043 11 , , , 19613 5043 12 who who WP 19613 5043 13 makes make VBZ 19613 5043 14 the the DT 19613 5043 15 following follow VBG 19613 5043 16 remarks remark NNS 19613 5043 17 on on IN 19613 5043 18 this this DT 19613 5043 19 point point NN 19613 5043 20 : : : 19613 5043 21 " " `` 19613 5043 22 When when WRB 19613 5043 23 a a DT 19613 5043 24 man man NN 19613 5043 25 trained train VBN 19613 5043 26 in in IN 19613 5043 27 the the DT 19613 5043 28 schools school NNS 19613 5043 29 and and CC 19613 5043 30 sciences science NNS 19613 5043 31 of of IN 19613 5043 32 the the DT 19613 5043 33 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5043 34 becomes become VBZ 19613 5043 35 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 5043 36 with with IN 19613 5043 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5043 38 faith faith NN 19613 5043 39 , , , 19613 5043 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5043 41 will will MD 19613 5043 42 not not RB 19613 5043 43 only only RB 19613 5043 44 recognise recognise VB 19613 5043 45 and and CC 19613 5043 46 declare declare VB 19613 5043 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5043 48 to to TO 19613 5043 49 be be VB 19613 5043 50 true true JJ 19613 5043 51 , , , 19613 5043 52 but but CC 19613 5043 53 also also RB 19613 5043 54 by by IN 19613 5043 55 means mean NNS 19613 5043 56 of of IN 19613 5043 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5043 58 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5043 59 training training NN 19613 5043 60 and and CC 19613 5043 61 skill skill NN 19613 5043 62 reduce reduce VBP 19613 5043 63 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5043 64 to to IN 19613 5043 65 a a DT 19613 5043 66 system system NN 19613 5043 67 and and CC 19613 5043 68 supplement supplement VB 19613 5043 69 what what WP 19613 5043 70 seems seem VBZ 19613 5043 71 to to IN 19613 5043 72 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5043 73 defective defective JJ 19613 5043 74 in in IN 19613 5043 75 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5043 76 , , , 19613 5043 77 when when WRB 19613 5043 78 tested test VBN 19613 5043 79 by by IN 19613 5043 80 the the DT 19613 5043 81 Greek greek JJ 19613 5043 82 method method NN 19613 5043 83 of of IN 19613 5043 84 exposition exposition NN 19613 5043 85 and and CC 19613 5043 86 proof proof NN 19613 5043 87 , , , 19613 5043 88 thus thus RB 19613 5043 89 at at IN 19613 5043 90 the the DT 19613 5043 91 same same JJ 19613 5043 92 time time NN 19613 5043 93 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 19613 5043 94 the the DT 19613 5043 95 truth truth NN 19613 5043 96 of of IN 19613 5043 97 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5043 98 . . . 19613 5043 99 " " '' 19613 5043 100 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5044 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5044 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5044 3 348 348 CD 19613 5044 4 : : : 19613 5044 5 See see VB 19613 5044 6 the the DT 19613 5044 7 section section NN 19613 5044 8 " " `` 19613 5044 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5044 10 und und NN 19613 5044 11 die die VBP 19613 5044 12 apostolischen apostolischen NNP 19613 5044 13 Váter Váter NNP 19613 5044 14 " " '' 19613 5044 15 in in IN 19613 5044 16 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 5044 17 's 's POS 19613 5044 18 " " `` 19613 5044 19 Christenthum Christenthum NNP 19613 5044 20 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5044 21 's 's POS 19613 5044 22 des des NNP 19613 5044 23 Martyrers Martyrers NNP 19613 5044 24 , , , 19613 5044 25 " " '' 19613 5044 26 p. p. NN 19613 5044 27 375 375 CD 19613 5044 28 ff ff NN 19613 5044 29 . . NNP 19613 5044 30 , , , 19613 5044 31 and and CC 19613 5044 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5044 33 article article NN 19613 5044 34 on on IN 19613 5044 35 the the DT 19613 5044 36 so so RB 19613 5044 37 - - HYPH 19613 5044 38 called call VBN 19613 5044 39 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 5044 40 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 5044 41 of of IN 19613 5044 42 Clement Clement NNP 19613 5044 43 to to IN 19613 5044 44 the the DT 19613 5044 45 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 19613 5044 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5044 47 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 5044 48 für für NN 19613 5044 49 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 5044 50 I. I. NNP 19613 5044 51 p. p. NN 19613 5044 52 329 329 CD 19613 5044 53 ff ff NNP 19613 5044 54 . . . 19613 5044 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5044 56 . . . 19613 5045 1 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 5045 2 , , , 19613 5045 3 who who WP 19613 5045 4 on on IN 19613 5045 5 the the DT 19613 5045 6 whole whole NN 19613 5045 7 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 5045 8 the the DT 19613 5045 9 correspondences correspondence NNS 19613 5045 10 , , , 19613 5045 11 has have VBZ 19613 5045 12 rather rather RB 19613 5045 13 under- under- JJ 19613 5045 14 than than IN 19613 5045 15 over over RB 19613 5045 16 - - HYPH 19613 5045 17 estimated estimate VBN 19613 5045 18 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5045 19 . . . 19613 5046 1 If if IN 19613 5046 2 the the DT 19613 5046 3 reader reader NN 19613 5046 4 compares compare VBZ 19613 5046 5 the the DT 19613 5046 6 exposition exposition NN 19613 5046 7 given give VBN 19613 5046 8 in in IN 19613 5046 9 Book Book NNP 19613 5046 10 I. I. NNP 19613 5046 11 , , , 19613 5046 12 chap chap NNP 19613 5046 13 . . . 19613 5047 1 3 3 LS 19613 5047 2 , , , 19613 5047 3 with with IN 19613 5047 4 the the DT 19613 5047 5 theology theology NN 19613 5047 6 of of IN 19613 5047 7 the the DT 19613 5047 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5047 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5047 10 see see VB 19613 5047 11 sub sub NN 19613 5047 12 . . . 19613 5048 1 3 3 LS 19613 5048 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5048 3 , , , 19613 5048 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5048 5 will will MD 19613 5048 6 find find VB 19613 5048 7 proof proof NN 19613 5048 8 of of IN 19613 5048 9 the the DT 19613 5048 10 intimate intimate JJ 19613 5048 11 relationship relationship NN 19613 5048 12 that that WDT 19613 5048 13 may may MD 19613 5048 14 be be VB 19613 5048 15 traced trace VBN 19613 5048 16 here here RB 19613 5048 17 . . . 19613 5048 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5049 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5049 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5049 3 349 349 CD 19613 5049 4 : : : 19613 5049 5 See See NNP 19613 5049 6 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 5049 7 . . NNP 19613 5049 8 , , , 19613 5049 9 H. H. NNP 19613 5049 10 E. E. NNP 19613 5049 11 IV IV NNP 19613 5049 12 . . . 19613 5050 1 3 3 LS 19613 5050 2 . . . 19613 5051 1 Only only RB 19613 5051 2 one one CD 19613 5051 3 sentence sentence NN 19613 5051 4 of of IN 19613 5051 5 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 19613 5051 6 ' ' POS 19613 5051 7 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5051 8 is be VBZ 19613 5051 9 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5051 10 ; ; : 19613 5051 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5051 12 have have VBP 19613 5051 13 now now RB 19613 5051 14 that that DT 19613 5051 15 of of IN 19613 5051 16 Aristides aristide NNS 19613 5051 17 in in IN 19613 5051 18 the the DT 19613 5051 19 Syriac Syriac NNP 19613 5051 20 language language NN 19613 5051 21 ; ; : 19613 5051 22 moreover moreover RB 19613 5051 23 , , , 19613 5051 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5051 25 is be VBZ 19613 5051 26 proved prove VBN 19613 5051 27 to to TO 19613 5051 28 have have VB 19613 5051 29 existed exist VBN 19613 5051 30 in in IN 19613 5051 31 the the DT 19613 5051 32 original original JJ 19613 5051 33 language language NN 19613 5051 34 in in IN 19613 5051 35 the the DT 19613 5051 36 Historia Historia NNP 19613 5051 37 Barlaam Barlaam NNP 19613 5051 38 et et NNP 19613 5051 39 Joasaph Joasaph NNP 19613 5051 40 ; ; : 19613 5051 41 finally finally RB 19613 5051 42 , , , 19613 5051 43 a a DT 19613 5051 44 considerable considerable JJ 19613 5051 45 fragment fragment NN 19613 5051 46 of of IN 19613 5051 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5051 48 is be VBZ 19613 5051 49 found find VBN 19613 5051 50 in in IN 19613 5051 51 Armenian Armenian NNP 19613 5051 52 . . . 19613 5052 1 See see VB 19613 5052 2 an an DT 19613 5052 3 English english JJ 19613 5052 4 edition edition NN 19613 5052 5 by by IN 19613 5052 6 Harris Harris NNP 19613 5052 7 and and CC 19613 5052 8 Robinson Robinson NNP 19613 5052 9 in in IN 19613 5052 10 the the DT 19613 5052 11 Texts Texts NNP 19613 5052 12 and and CC 19613 5052 13 Studies Studies NNPS 19613 5052 14 I. I. NNP 19613 5053 1 1891 1891 CD 19613 5053 2 . . . 19613 5054 1 German german JJ 19613 5054 2 translation translation NN 19613 5054 3 and and CC 19613 5054 4 commentary commentary NN 19613 5054 5 by by IN 19613 5054 6 Raabe Raabe NNP 19613 5054 7 in in IN 19613 5054 8 the the DT 19613 5054 9 Texte Texte NNP 19613 5054 10 und und NN 19613 5054 11 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 5054 12 IX IX NNP 19613 5054 13 . . . 19613 5055 1 1892 1892 CD 19613 5055 2 . . . 19613 5056 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 19613 5056 2 says say VBZ 19613 5056 3 that that IN 19613 5056 4 the the DT 19613 5056 5 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5056 6 was be VBD 19613 5056 7 handed hand VBN 19613 5056 8 in in RP 19613 5056 9 to to IN 19613 5056 10 the the DT 19613 5056 11 emperor emperor NN 19613 5056 12 Hadrian Hadrian NNP 19613 5056 13 ; ; : 19613 5056 14 but but CC 19613 5056 15 the the DT 19613 5056 16 superscription superscription NN 19613 5056 17 in in IN 19613 5056 18 Syriac Syriac NNP 19613 5056 19 is be VBZ 19613 5056 20 addressed address VBN 19613 5056 21 to to IN 19613 5056 22 the the DT 19613 5056 23 emperor emperor NN 19613 5056 24 Titus Titus NNP 19613 5056 25 Hadrianus Hadrianus NNP 19613 5056 26 Antoninus Antoninus NNP 19613 5056 27 . . . 19613 5056 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5057 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5057 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5057 3 350 350 CD 19613 5057 4 : : : 19613 5057 5 See see VB 19613 5057 6 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 5057 7 , , , 19613 5057 8 Mand Mand NNP 19613 5057 9 I. I. NNP 19613 5057 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5058 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5058 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5058 3 351 351 CD 19613 5058 4 : : : 19613 5058 5 With with IN 19613 5058 6 reservations reservation NNS 19613 5058 7 this this DT 19613 5058 8 also also RB 19613 5058 9 holds hold VBZ 19613 5058 10 good good JJ 19613 5058 11 of of IN 19613 5058 12 the the DT 19613 5058 13 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 5058 14 . . . 19613 5059 1 See see VB 19613 5059 2 particularly particularly RB 19613 5059 3 Orig Orig NNP 19613 5059 4 . . . 19613 5059 5 , , , 19613 5059 6 c. c. NNP 19613 5059 7 Cels Cels NNP 19613 5059 8 . . . 19613 5060 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5061 1 62 62 CD 19613 5061 2 . . . 19613 5061 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5062 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5062 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5062 3 352 352 CD 19613 5062 4 : : : 19613 5062 5 Semisch Semisch NNP 19613 5062 6 , , , 19613 5062 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5062 8 der der VBD 19613 5062 9 Martyrer Martyrer NNP 19613 5062 10 , , , 19613 5062 11 2 2 CD 19613 5062 12 Vols Vols NNP 19613 5062 13 , , , 19613 5062 14 1840 1840 CD 19613 5062 15 f. f. NN 19613 5062 16 Aubé Aubé NNP 19613 5062 17 , , , 19613 5062 18 S S NNP 19613 5062 19 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5062 20 , , , 19613 5062 21 philosophe philosophe VB 19613 5062 22 et et FW 19613 5062 23 martyre martyre JJ 19613 5062 24 , , , 19613 5062 25 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 5062 26 reprint reprint NN 19613 5062 27 , , , 19613 5062 28 1875 1875 CD 19613 5062 29 . . . 19613 5063 1 Weizsäcker Weizsäcker NNP 19613 5063 2 , , , 19613 5063 3 Die die VB 19613 5063 4 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 5063 5 des des NNP 19613 5063 6 Martyrers Martyrers NNP 19613 5063 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5063 8 's 's POS 19613 5063 9 in in IN 19613 5063 10 the the DT 19613 5063 11 Jahrbuch Jahrbuch NNP 19613 5063 12 fur fur NN 19613 5063 13 deutsche deutsche NN 19613 5063 14 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 5063 15 , , , 19613 5063 16 1867 1867 CD 19613 5063 17 , , , 19613 5063 18 p. p. NN 19613 5063 19 60 60 CD 19613 5063 20 ff ff NNS 19613 5063 21 . . . 19613 5064 1 Von Von NNP 19613 5064 2 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 5064 3 , , , 19613 5064 4 Christenthum Christenthum NNP 19613 5064 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5064 6 's 's POS 19613 5064 7 , , , 19613 5064 8 1878 1878 CD 19613 5064 9 ; ; : 19613 5064 10 i -PRON- PRP 19613 5064 11 d d VBN 19613 5064 12 , , , 19613 5064 13 " " `` 19613 5064 14 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5064 15 , , , 19613 5064 16 " " '' 19613 5064 17 in in IN 19613 5064 18 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 5064 19 's 's POS 19613 5064 20 Real Real NNP 19613 5064 21 - - HYPH 19613 5064 22 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 5064 23 . . . 19613 5065 1 Stählin Stählin NNP 19613 5065 2 , , , 19613 5065 3 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5065 4 der der VBD 19613 5065 5 Martyrer Martyrer NNP 19613 5065 6 , , , 19613 5065 7 1880 1880 CD 19613 5065 8 Clemen Clemen NNPS 19613 5065 9 , , , 19613 5065 10 Die die VB 19613 5065 11 religionsphilosophische religionsphilosophische NNP 19613 5065 12 Bedeutung Bedeutung NNP 19613 5065 13 des des NNP 19613 5065 14 stoisch stoisch NNP 19613 5065 15 - - HYPH 19613 5065 16 christlichen christlichen NNP 19613 5065 17 Eudamonismus Eudamonismus NNP 19613 5065 18 in in IN 19613 5065 19 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5065 20 's 's POS 19613 5065 21 Apologie Apologie NNP 19613 5065 22 , , , 19613 5065 23 1890 1890 CD 19613 5065 24 . . . 19613 5066 1 Flemming flemme VBG 19613 5066 2 , , , 19613 5066 3 zur zur NNP 19613 5066 4 Beurtheilung Beurtheilung NNP 19613 5066 5 des des NNP 19613 5066 6 Christenthums Christenthums NNP 19613 5066 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5066 8 's 's POS 19613 5066 9 des des NNP 19613 5066 10 Martyrers Martyrers NNP 19613 5066 11 , , , 19613 5066 12 1893 1893 CD 19613 5066 13 . . . 19613 5067 1 Duncker Duncker NNP 19613 5067 2 , , , 19613 5067 3 Logoslehre Logoslehre NNP 19613 5067 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5067 5 's 's POS 19613 5067 6 , , , 19613 5067 7 1848 1848 CD 19613 5067 8 . . . 19613 5068 1 Bosse Bosse NNP 19613 5068 2 , , , 19613 5068 3 Der Der NNP 19613 5068 4 prae prae NN 19613 5068 5 istente istente JJ 19613 5068 6 Christus Christus NNP 19613 5068 7 des des FW 19613 5068 8 Justinus Justinus NNP 19613 5068 9 , , , 19613 5068 10 1891 1891 CD 19613 5068 11 . . . 19613 5068 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5069 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5069 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5069 3 353 353 CD 19613 5069 4 : : : 19613 5069 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5069 6 . . . 19613 5070 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5071 1 2 2 CD 19613 5071 2 , , , 19613 5071 3 p. p. NN 19613 5071 4 6 6 CD 19613 5071 5 , , , 19613 5071 6 ed ed NN 19613 5071 7 . . . 19613 5072 1 Otto Otto NNP 19613 5072 2 . . . 19613 5072 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5073 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5073 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5073 3 354 354 CD 19613 5073 4 : : : 19613 5073 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5073 6 . . . 19613 5074 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5075 1 2 2 CD 19613 5075 2 , , , 19613 5075 3 p. p. NN 19613 5075 4 6 6 CD 19613 5075 5 , , , 19613 5075 6 sq sq NNP 19613 5075 7 . . . 19613 5075 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5076 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5076 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5076 3 355 355 CD 19613 5076 4 : : : 19613 5076 5 See see VB 19613 5076 6 the the DT 19613 5076 7 numerous numerous JJ 19613 5076 8 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5076 9 quotations quotation NNS 19613 5076 10 and and CC 19613 5076 11 allusions allusion NNS 19613 5076 12 in in IN 19613 5076 13 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5076 14 's 's POS 19613 5076 15 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5076 16 pointed point VBD 19613 5076 17 out out RP 19613 5076 18 by by IN 19613 5076 19 Otto Otto NNP 19613 5076 20 . . . 19613 5077 1 Above above IN 19613 5077 2 all all DT 19613 5077 3 , , , 19613 5077 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5077 5 made make VBD 19613 5077 6 an an DT 19613 5077 7 extensive extensive JJ 19613 5077 8 use use NN 19613 5077 9 of of IN 19613 5077 10 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5077 11 's 's POS 19613 5077 12 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5077 13 of of IN 19613 5077 14 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 5077 15 . . . 19613 5077 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5078 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5078 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5078 3 356 356 CD 19613 5078 4 : : : 19613 5078 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5078 6 . . . 19613 5079 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5080 1 4 4 LS 19613 5080 2 . . . 19613 5080 3 p. p. NN 19613 5080 4 16 16 CD 19613 5080 5 , , , 19613 5080 6 also also RB 19613 5080 7 I. I. NNP 19613 5081 1 7 7 CD 19613 5081 2 , , , 19613 5081 3 p. p. NN 19613 5081 4 24 24 CD 19613 5081 5 sq sq NN 19613 5081 6 : : : 19613 5081 7 I. I. NNP 19613 5082 1 26 26 CD 19613 5082 2 . . . 19613 5082 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5083 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5083 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5083 3 357 357 CD 19613 5083 4 : : : 19613 5083 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5083 6 . . . 19613 5084 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5085 1 4 4 LS 19613 5085 2 , , , 19613 5085 3 p. p. NN 19613 5086 1 14 14 CD 19613 5086 2 . . . 19613 5086 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5087 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5087 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5087 3 358 358 CD 19613 5087 4 : : : 19613 5087 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5087 6 . . . 19613 5088 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5089 1 5 5 CD 19613 5089 2 , , , 19613 5089 3 p. p. NN 19613 5089 4 18 18 CD 19613 5089 5 sq sq NNP 19613 5089 6 . . NNP 19613 5089 7 , , , 19613 5089 8 see see VB 19613 5089 9 also also RB 19613 5089 10 I. I. NNP 19613 5090 1 14 14 CD 19613 5090 2 fin fin NNP 19613 5090 3 . . . 19613 5091 1 : : : 19613 5091 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5091 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5091 4 : : : 19613 5091 5 ou ou NNP 19613 5091 6 sophistês sophistês NNP 19613 5091 7 hupêrchen hupêrchen NNP 19613 5091 8 alla alla NN 19613 5091 9 dunamis dunami NNS 19613 5091 10 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5091 11 ho ho NNP 19613 5091 12 logos logos NNP 19613 5091 13 autou autou NNP 19613 5091 14 ên ên NNP 19613 5091 15 . . . 19613 5091 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5091 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5092 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5092 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5092 3 359 359 CD 19613 5092 4 : : : 19613 5092 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 5092 6 . . . 19613 5093 1 : : : 19613 5093 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5093 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5093 4 : : : 19613 5093 5 ou ou NNP 19613 5093 6 gar gar NNP 19613 5093 7 monon monon NNP 19613 5093 8 en en IN 19613 5093 9 Hellêsi Hellêsi NNP 19613 5093 10 dia dia VB 19613 5093 11 Sôkratous Sôkratous NNP 19613 5093 12 hupo hupo NNP 19613 5093 13 logou logou NN 19613 5093 14 êlegchthêtauta êlegchthêtauta NNP 19613 5093 15 , , , 19613 5093 16 alla alla NN 19613 5093 17 kai kai NNP 19613 5093 18 en en IN 19613 5093 19 barbarois barbarois NNP 19613 5093 20 hup hup NNP 19613 5093 21 ' ' '' 19613 5093 22 autou autou NNP 19613 5093 23 tou tou NNP 19613 5093 24 logou logou NNP 19613 5093 25 morphôthentos morphôthentos NNP 19613 5093 26 kai kai NNP 19613 5093 27 anthrôpou anthrôpou NNP 19613 5093 28 kai kai NNP 19613 5093 29 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 5093 30 Christou Christou NNP 19613 5093 31 klêthenos klêthenos NN 19613 5093 32 . . . 19613 5093 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5093 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5094 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5094 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5094 3 360 360 CD 19613 5094 4 : : : 19613 5094 5 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 5094 6 also also RB 19613 5094 7 admits admit VBZ 19613 5094 8 this this DT 19613 5094 9 , , , 19613 5094 10 or or CC 19613 5094 11 rather rather RB 19613 5094 12 makes make VBZ 19613 5094 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5094 14 Jew Jew NNP 19613 5094 15 acknowledge acknowledge VB 19613 5094 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5094 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5094 18 Orig Orig NNP 19613 5094 19 . . . 19613 5094 20 , , , 19613 5094 21 c. c. NNP 19613 5094 22 Cels Cels NNP 19613 5094 23 . . . 19613 5095 1 II ii CD 19613 5095 2 . . . 19613 5096 1 31 31 CD 19613 5096 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5096 3 . . . 19613 5097 1 In in IN 19613 5097 2 Book Book NNP 19613 5097 3 VI VI NNP 19613 5097 4 . . . 19613 5098 1 47 47 CD 19613 5098 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5098 3 adopts adopt VBZ 19613 5098 4 the the DT 19613 5098 5 proposition proposition NN 19613 5098 6 of of IN 19613 5098 7 the the DT 19613 5098 8 " " `` 19613 5098 9 ancients ancient NNS 19613 5098 10 " " '' 19613 5098 11 that that IN 19613 5098 12 the the DT 19613 5098 13 world world NN 19613 5098 14 is be VBZ 19613 5098 15 the the DT 19613 5098 16 Son Son NNP 19613 5098 17 of of IN 19613 5098 18 God God NNP 19613 5098 19 . . . 19613 5098 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5099 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5099 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5099 3 361 361 CD 19613 5099 4 : : : 19613 5099 5 See see VB 19613 5099 6 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5099 7 . . . 19613 5100 1 II ii CD 19613 5100 2 . . . 19613 5101 1 10 10 CD 19613 5101 2 fin fin NN 19613 5101 3 . . . 19613 5102 1 : : : 19613 5102 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5102 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5102 4 : : : 19613 5102 5 Sôkratei Sôkratei NNP 19613 5102 6 oudeis oudeis NNP 19613 5102 7 epeisthê epeisthê NNP 19613 5102 8 huper huper NNP 19613 5102 9 toutou toutou NNP 19613 5102 10 tou tou NNP 19613 5102 11 dogmatos dogmatos NNP 19613 5102 12 apothnêskin apothnêskin NNP 19613 5102 13 Christô Christô NNP 19613 5102 14 de de NNP 19613 5102 15 tô tô NNP 19613 5102 16 kai kai NNP 19613 5102 17 hupo hupo NNP 19613 5102 18 Sôkratous Sôkratous NNP 19613 5102 19 apo apo VBZ 19613 5102 20 merous merous JJ 19613 5102 21 gnôsthenti gnôsthenti NN 19613 5102 22 ... ... NFP 19613 5102 23 ou ou NNP 19613 5102 24 philosophoi philosophoi NNP 19613 5102 25 oude oude NNP 19613 5102 26 philologoi philologoi NNP 19613 5102 27 monon monon NNP 19613 5102 28 epeisthêsan epeisthêsan NNP 19613 5102 29 . . . 19613 5102 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5102 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5103 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5103 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5103 3 362 362 CD 19613 5103 4 : : : 19613 5103 5 The the DT 19613 5103 6 utterances utterance NNS 19613 5103 7 of of IN 19613 5103 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5103 9 do do VBP 19613 5103 10 not not RB 19613 5103 11 clearly clearly RB 19613 5103 12 indicate indicate VB 19613 5103 13 whether whether IN 19613 5103 14 the the DT 19613 5103 15 non non JJ 19613 5103 16 - - JJ 19613 5103 17 Christian christian JJ 19613 5103 18 portion portion NN 19613 5103 19 of of IN 19613 5103 20 mankind mankind NN 19613 5103 21 has have VBZ 19613 5103 22 only only RB 19613 5103 23 a a DT 19613 5103 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5103 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5103 26 : : : 19613 5103 27 sperma sperma NNP 19613 5103 28 tou tou NNP 19613 5103 29 logon logon NNP 19613 5103 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5103 31 as as IN 19613 5103 32 a a DT 19613 5103 33 natural natural JJ 19613 5103 34 possession possession NN 19613 5103 35 , , , 19613 5103 36 or or CC 19613 5103 37 whether whether IN 19613 5103 38 this this DT 19613 5103 39 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5103 40 Greek greek JJ 19613 5103 41 : : : 19613 5103 42 sperma sperma NNP 19613 5103 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5103 44 has have VBZ 19613 5103 45 in in IN 19613 5103 46 some some DT 19613 5103 47 cases case NNS 19613 5103 48 been be VBN 19613 5103 49 enhanced enhance VBN 19613 5103 50 by by IN 19613 5103 51 the the DT 19613 5103 52 inward inward JJ 19613 5103 53 workings working NNS 19613 5103 54 of of IN 19613 5103 55 the the DT 19613 5103 56 whole whole JJ 19613 5103 57 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5103 58 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5103 59 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 5103 60 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5103 61 . . . 19613 5104 1 This this DT 19613 5104 2 ambiguity ambiguity NN 19613 5104 3 , , , 19613 5104 4 however however RB 19613 5104 5 , , , 19613 5104 6 arises arise VBZ 19613 5104 7 from from IN 19613 5104 8 the the DT 19613 5104 9 fact fact NN 19613 5104 10 that that IN 19613 5104 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5104 12 did do VBD 19613 5104 13 not not RB 19613 5104 14 further further RB 19613 5104 15 discuss discuss VB 19613 5104 16 the the DT 19613 5104 17 relation relation NN 19613 5104 18 between between IN 19613 5104 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5104 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5104 21 : : : 19613 5104 22 ho ho NNP 19613 5104 23 logos logo NNS 19613 5104 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5104 25 and and CC 19613 5104 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5104 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5104 28 : : : 19613 5104 29 to to TO 19613 5104 30 sperma sperma NNP 19613 5104 31 tou tou NNP 19613 5104 32 logou logou NNP 19613 5104 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5104 34 and and CC 19613 5104 35 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5104 36 need need VBP 19613 5104 37 not not RB 19613 5104 38 therefore therefore RB 19613 5104 39 attempt attempt VB 19613 5104 40 to to TO 19613 5104 41 remove remove VB 19613 5104 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5104 43 . . . 19613 5105 1 On on IN 19613 5105 2 the the DT 19613 5105 3 one one CD 19613 5105 4 hand hand NN 19613 5105 5 , , , 19613 5105 6 the the DT 19613 5105 7 excellent excellent JJ 19613 5105 8 discoveries discovery NNS 19613 5105 9 of of IN 19613 5105 10 poets poet NNS 19613 5105 11 and and CC 19613 5105 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5105 13 are be VBP 19613 5105 14 simply simply RB 19613 5105 15 traced trace VBN 19613 5105 16 to to IN 19613 5105 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5105 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5105 19 : : : 19613 5105 20 to to IN 19613 5105 21 emphuton emphuton NNP 19613 5105 22 panti panti NNP 19613 5105 23 genei genei NNP 19613 5105 24 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 5105 25 sperma sperma NNP 19613 5105 26 tou tou NNP 19613 5105 27 logou logou NNP 19613 5105 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5105 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5105 30 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5105 31 . . . 19613 5106 1 II ii CD 19613 5106 2 . . . 19613 5107 1 8) 8) CD 19613 5107 2 , , , 19613 5107 3 the the DT 19613 5107 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5107 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5107 6 : : : 19613 5107 7 meros meros NNP 19613 5107 8 spermatikou spermatikou NNP 19613 5107 9 logou logou NNP 19613 5107 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5107 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5107 12 ibid ibid NNP 19613 5107 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5107 14 which which WDT 19613 5107 15 was be VBD 19613 5107 16 implanted implant VBN 19613 5107 17 at at IN 19613 5107 18 the the DT 19613 5107 19 creation creation NN 19613 5107 20 , , , 19613 5107 21 and and CC 19613 5107 22 on on IN 19613 5107 23 which which WDT 19613 5107 24 the the DT 19613 5107 25 human human JJ 19613 5107 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5107 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5107 28 : : : 19613 5107 29 heuresis heuresis NN 19613 5107 30 kai kai NNP 19613 5107 31 theôria theôria NN 19613 5107 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5107 33 depend depend VB 19613 5107 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5107 35 II ii CD 19613 5107 36 . . . 19613 5108 1 10 10 LS 19613 5108 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5108 3 . . . 19613 5109 1 In in IN 19613 5109 2 this this DT 19613 5109 3 sense sense NN 19613 5109 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5109 5 may may MD 19613 5109 6 be be VB 19613 5109 7 said say VBN 19613 5109 8 of of IN 19613 5109 9 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5109 10 all all DT 19613 5109 11 that that WDT 19613 5109 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5109 13 " " `` 19613 5109 14 in in IN 19613 5109 15 human human JJ 19613 5109 16 fashion fashion NN 19613 5109 17 attempted attempt VBD 19613 5109 18 to to TO 19613 5109 19 understand understand VB 19613 5109 20 and and CC 19613 5109 21 prove prove VB 19613 5109 22 things thing NNS 19613 5109 23 by by IN 19613 5109 24 means mean NNS 19613 5109 25 of of IN 19613 5109 26 reason reason NN 19613 5109 27 ; ; : 19613 5109 28 " " '' 19613 5109 29 and and CC 19613 5109 30 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 5109 31 is be VBZ 19613 5109 32 merely merely RB 19613 5109 33 viewed view VBN 19613 5109 34 as as IN 19613 5109 35 the the DT 19613 5109 36 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5109 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5109 38 : : : 19613 5109 39 pantôn pantôn NNS 19613 5109 40 eutonôteros eutonôteros NNP 19613 5109 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5109 42 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5109 43 ibid ibid NNP 19613 5109 44 . . . 19613 5110 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5110 2 , , , 19613 5110 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5110 4 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5110 5 also also RB 19613 5110 6 , , , 19613 5110 7 like like IN 19613 5110 8 all all DT 19613 5110 9 pre pre JJ 19613 5110 10 - - JJ 19613 5110 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 5110 12 systems system NNS 19613 5110 13 , , , 19613 5110 14 being be VBG 19613 5110 15 a a DT 19613 5110 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5110 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5110 18 : : : 19613 5110 19 philosophia philosophia NN 19613 5110 20 anthrôpeios anthrôpeios NNP 19613 5110 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5110 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5110 23 II ii CD 19613 5110 24 . . . 19613 5111 1 15 15 CD 19613 5111 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5111 3 . . . 19613 5112 1 But but CC 19613 5112 2 on on IN 19613 5112 3 the the DT 19613 5112 4 other other JJ 19613 5112 5 hand hand NN 19613 5112 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5112 7 was be VBD 19613 5112 8 known know VBN 19613 5112 9 by by IN 19613 5112 10 Socrates Socrates NNPS 19613 5112 11 though though IN 19613 5112 12 only only RB 19613 5112 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5112 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5112 15 : : : 19613 5112 16 apo apo NNP 19613 5112 17 merous merous JJ 19613 5112 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5112 19 ; ; : 19613 5112 20 for for IN 19613 5112 21 " " `` 19613 5112 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5112 23 was be VBD 19613 5112 24 and and CC 19613 5112 25 is be VBZ 19613 5112 26 the the DT 19613 5112 27 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5112 28 who who WP 19613 5112 29 dwells dwell VBZ 19613 5112 30 in in IN 19613 5112 31 every every DT 19613 5112 32 man man NN 19613 5112 33 . . . 19613 5112 34 " " '' 19613 5113 1 Further further RB 19613 5113 2 , , , 19613 5113 3 according accord VBG 19613 5113 4 to to IN 19613 5113 5 the the DT 19613 5113 6 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 5113 7 , , , 19613 5113 8 the the DT 19613 5113 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5113 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5113 11 : : : 19613 5113 12 meros meros NNP 19613 5113 13 tou tou NNP 19613 5113 14 spermatikou spermatikou NNP 19613 5113 15 theiou theiou NNP 19613 5113 16 logou logou NNP 19613 5113 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5113 18 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 5113 19 the the DT 19613 5113 20 power power NN 19613 5113 21 of of IN 19613 5113 22 recognising recognise VBG 19613 5113 23 whatever whatever WDT 19613 5113 24 is be VBZ 19613 5113 25 related relate VBN 19613 5113 26 to to IN 19613 5113 27 the the DT 19613 5113 28 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5113 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5113 30 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5113 31 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5113 32 : : : 19613 5113 33 to to IN 19613 5113 34 sungenes sungene NNS 19613 5113 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5113 36 II II NNP 19613 5113 37 . . . 19613 5114 1 13 13 CD 19613 5114 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5114 3 . . . 19613 5115 1 Consequently consequently RB 19613 5115 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5115 3 may may MD 19613 5115 4 not not RB 19613 5115 5 only only RB 19613 5115 6 be be VB 19613 5115 7 said say VBN 19613 5115 8 : : : 19613 5115 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5115 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5115 11 : : : 19613 5115 12 hosa hosa NNP 19613 5115 13 para para NNP 19613 5115 14 pasi pasi NNP 19613 5115 15 kalôs kalôs NNP 19613 5115 16 eirêtai eirêtai NNP 19613 5115 17 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 5115 18 , , , 19613 5115 19 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5115 20 Christianôn Christianôn NNP 19613 5115 21 esti esti NN 19613 5115 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5115 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5115 24 ibid ibid NNP 19613 5115 25 . . . 19613 5116 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5116 2 , , , 19613 5116 3 but but CC 19613 5116 4 , , , 19613 5116 5 on on IN 19613 5116 6 the the DT 19613 5116 7 strength strength NN 19613 5116 8 of of IN 19613 5116 9 the the DT 19613 5116 10 " " `` 19613 5116 11 participation participation NN 19613 5116 12 " " '' 19613 5116 13 in in IN 19613 5116 14 reason reason NN 19613 5116 15 conferred confer VBN 19613 5116 16 on on IN 19613 5116 17 all all DT 19613 5116 18 , , , 19613 5116 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5116 20 may may MD 19613 5116 21 be be VB 19613 5116 22 asserted assert VBN 19613 5116 23 that that IN 19613 5116 24 all all DT 19613 5116 25 who who WP 19613 5116 26 have have VBP 19613 5116 27 lived live VBN 19613 5116 28 with with IN 19613 5116 29 the the DT 19613 5116 30 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5116 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5116 32 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5116 33 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5116 34 : : : 19613 5116 35 meta meta JJ 19613 5116 36 logou])--an logou])--an NNP 19613 5116 37 expression expression NN 19613 5116 38 which which WDT 19613 5116 39 must must MD 19613 5116 40 have have VB 19613 5116 41 been be VBN 19613 5116 42 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 19613 5116 43 -- -- : 19613 5116 44 were be VBD 19613 5116 45 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5116 46 . . . 19613 5117 1 Among among IN 19613 5117 2 the the DT 19613 5117 3 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5117 4 this this DT 19613 5117 5 specially specially RB 19613 5117 6 applies apply VBZ 19613 5117 7 to to IN 19613 5117 8 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 5117 9 and and CC 19613 5117 10 Heraclitus Heraclitus NNP 19613 5117 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5117 12 I. I. NNP 19613 5118 1 46 46 CD 19613 5118 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5118 3 . . . 19613 5119 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 5119 2 , , , 19613 5119 3 the the DT 19613 5119 4 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5119 5 implanted implant VBD 19613 5119 6 in in IN 19613 5119 7 man man NN 19613 5119 8 does do VBZ 19613 5119 9 not not RB 19613 5119 10 belong belong VB 19613 5119 11 to to IN 19613 5119 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5119 13 nature nature NN 19613 5119 14 in in IN 19613 5119 15 such such PDT 19613 5119 16 a a DT 19613 5119 17 sense sense NN 19613 5119 18 as as IN 19613 5119 19 to to TO 19613 5119 20 prevent prevent VB 19613 5119 21 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5119 22 saying say VBG 19613 5119 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5119 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5119 25 : : : 19613 5119 26 upo upo NNP 19613 5119 27 logou logou NNP 19613 5119 28 dia dia NNP 19613 5119 29 Sôkratous sôkratous JJ 19613 5119 30 êlegchthê êlegchthê NN 19613 5119 31 k.t.l k.t.l NN 19613 5119 32 . . . 19613 5119 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5120 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5120 2 I. I. NNP 19613 5121 1 5 5 LS 19613 5121 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5121 3 . . . 19613 5122 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5122 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5122 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5122 4 : : : 19613 5122 5 autos auto NNS 19613 5122 6 ho ho NNP 19613 5122 7 logos logos NNP 19613 5122 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5122 9 did do VBD 19613 5122 10 not not RB 19613 5122 11 act act VB 19613 5122 12 in in IN 19613 5122 13 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 5122 14 , , , 19613 5122 15 for for IN 19613 5122 16 this this DT 19613 5122 17 only only RB 19613 5122 18 appeared appear VBD 19613 5122 19 in in IN 19613 5122 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5122 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5122 22 ibid ibid NNP 19613 5122 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5122 24 . . . 19613 5123 1 Hence hence RB 19613 5123 2 the the DT 19613 5123 3 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 5123 4 aspect aspect NN 19613 5123 5 of of IN 19613 5123 6 the the DT 19613 5123 7 case case NN 19613 5123 8 in in IN 19613 5123 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5123 10 was be VBD 19613 5123 11 that that DT 19613 5123 12 to to TO 19613 5123 13 which which WDT 19613 5123 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5123 15 gave give VBD 19613 5123 16 expression expression NN 19613 5123 17 at at IN 19613 5123 18 the the DT 19613 5123 19 close close NN 19613 5123 20 of of IN 19613 5123 21 the the DT 19613 5123 22 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 5123 23 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5123 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5123 25 II II NNP 19613 5123 26 . . . 19613 5124 1 15 15 CD 19613 5124 2 : : : 19613 5124 3 alongside alongside IN 19613 5124 4 of of IN 19613 5124 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5124 6 there there EX 19613 5124 7 is be VBZ 19613 5124 8 only only RB 19613 5124 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5124 10 human human JJ 19613 5124 11 _ _ NNP 19613 5124 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5124 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5124 14 , , , 19613 5124 15 and and CC 19613 5124 16 which which WDT 19613 5124 17 , , , 19613 5124 18 not not RB 19613 5124 19 without without IN 19613 5124 20 regard regard NN 19613 5124 21 for for IN 19613 5124 22 the the DT 19613 5124 23 opposite opposite JJ 19613 5124 24 view view NN 19613 5124 25 , , , 19613 5124 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5124 27 thus thus RB 19613 5124 28 formulated formulate VBD 19613 5124 29 in in IN 19613 5124 30 II II NNP 19613 5124 31 . . . 19613 5125 1 13 13 CD 19613 5125 2 fin fin NN 19613 5125 3 . . . 19613 5126 1 : : : 19613 5126 2 All all DT 19613 5126 3 non non JJ 19613 5126 4 - - JJ 19613 5126 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 5126 6 authors author NNS 19613 5126 7 were be VBD 19613 5126 8 able able JJ 19613 5126 9 to to TO 19613 5126 10 attain attain VB 19613 5126 11 a a DT 19613 5126 12 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5126 13 of of IN 19613 5126 14 true true JJ 19613 5126 15 being being NN 19613 5126 16 , , , 19613 5126 17 though though IN 19613 5126 18 only only RB 19613 5126 19 darkly darkly RB 19613 5126 20 , , , 19613 5126 21 by by IN 19613 5126 22 means mean NNS 19613 5126 23 of of IN 19613 5126 24 the the DT 19613 5126 25 seed seed NN 19613 5126 26 of of IN 19613 5126 27 the the DT 19613 5126 28 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5126 29 naturally naturally RB 19613 5126 30 implanted implant VBD 19613 5126 31 within within IN 19613 5126 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5126 33 . . . 19613 5127 1 For for IN 19613 5127 2 the the DT 19613 5127 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5127 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5127 5 : : : 19613 5127 6 spora spora NN 19613 5127 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5127 8 and and CC 19613 5127 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5127 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5127 11 : : : 19613 5127 12 mimêma mimêma NN 19613 5127 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5127 14 of of IN 19613 5127 15 a a DT 19613 5127 16 thing thing NN 19613 5127 17 , , , 19613 5127 18 which which WDT 19613 5127 19 are be VBP 19613 5127 20 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 5127 21 in in IN 19613 5127 22 proportion proportion NN 19613 5127 23 to to IN 19613 5127 24 one one NN 19613 5127 25 's 's POS 19613 5127 26 receptivity receptivity NN 19613 5127 27 , , , 19613 5127 28 are be VBP 19613 5127 29 quite quite RB 19613 5127 30 different different JJ 19613 5127 31 from from IN 19613 5127 32 the the DT 19613 5127 33 thing thing NN 19613 5127 34 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5127 35 , , , 19613 5127 36 which which WDT 19613 5127 37 divine divine JJ 19613 5127 38 grace grace NN 19613 5127 39 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 5127 40 on on IN 19613 5127 41 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5127 42 for for IN 19613 5127 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5127 44 possession possession NN 19613 5127 45 and and CC 19613 5127 46 imitation imitation NN 19613 5127 47 . . . 19613 5127 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5128 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5128 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5128 3 363 363 CD 19613 5128 4 : : : 19613 5128 5 " " `` 19613 5128 6 For for IN 19613 5128 7 the the DT 19613 5128 8 sake sake NN 19613 5128 9 of of IN 19613 5128 10 man man NN 19613 5128 11 " " '' 19613 5128 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5128 13 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 5128 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5128 15 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5128 16 . . . 19613 5129 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5130 1 10 10 CD 19613 5130 2 : : : 19613 5130 3 II ii CD 19613 5130 4 . . . 19613 5131 1 4 4 CD 19613 5131 2 , , , 19613 5131 3 5 5 CD 19613 5131 4 ; ; : 19613 5131 5 Dial dial NN 19613 5131 6 . . . 19613 5132 1 41 41 CD 19613 5132 2 , , , 19613 5132 3 p. p. NN 19613 5132 4 260 260 CD 19613 5132 5 , , , 19613 5132 6 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5132 7 I. I. NNP 19613 5133 1 8 8 LS 19613 5133 2 : : : 19613 5133 3 " " `` 19613 5133 4 Longing long VBG 19613 5133 5 for for IN 19613 5133 6 the the DT 19613 5133 7 eternal eternal JJ 19613 5133 8 and and CC 19613 5133 9 pure pure JJ 19613 5133 10 life life NN 19613 5133 11 , , , 19613 5133 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5133 13 strive strive VBP 19613 5133 14 to to TO 19613 5133 15 abide abide VB 19613 5133 16 in in IN 19613 5133 17 the the DT 19613 5133 18 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 5133 19 of of IN 19613 5133 20 God God NNP 19613 5133 21 , , , 19613 5133 22 the the DT 19613 5133 23 Father Father NNP 19613 5133 24 and and CC 19613 5133 25 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5133 26 of of IN 19613 5133 27 all all DT 19613 5133 28 things thing NNS 19613 5133 29 , , , 19613 5133 30 and and CC 19613 5133 31 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5133 32 hasten hasten VBP 19613 5133 33 to to TO 19613 5133 34 make make VB 19613 5133 35 confession confession NN 19613 5133 36 , , , 19613 5133 37 because because IN 19613 5133 38 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5133 39 are be VBP 19613 5133 40 convinced convinced JJ 19613 5133 41 and and CC 19613 5133 42 firmly firmly RB 19613 5133 43 believe believe VB 19613 5133 44 that that IN 19613 5133 45 that that DT 19613 5133 46 happiness happiness NN 19613 5133 47 is be VBZ 19613 5133 48 really really RB 19613 5133 49 attainable attainable JJ 19613 5133 50 . . . 19613 5133 51 " " '' 19613 5134 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5134 2 is be VBZ 19613 5134 3 frequently frequently RB 19613 5134 4 asserted assert VBN 19613 5134 5 that that IN 19613 5134 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5134 7 is be VBZ 19613 5134 8 the the DT 19613 5134 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5134 10 which which WDT 19613 5134 11 produces produce VBZ 19613 5134 12 such such JJ 19613 5134 13 conviction conviction NN 19613 5134 14 and and CC 19613 5134 15 awakens awaken VBZ 19613 5134 16 courage courage NN 19613 5134 17 and and CC 19613 5134 18 strength strength NN 19613 5134 19 . . . 19613 5134 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5135 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5135 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5135 3 364 364 CD 19613 5135 4 : : : 19613 5135 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5135 6 has have VBZ 19613 5135 7 destroyed destroy VBN 19613 5135 8 the the DT 19613 5135 9 force force NN 19613 5135 10 of of IN 19613 5135 11 this this DT 19613 5135 12 argument argument NN 19613 5135 13 in in IN 19613 5135 14 two two CD 19613 5135 15 passages passage NNS 19613 5135 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5135 17 I. I. NNP 19613 5136 1 44 44 CD 19613 5136 2 , , , 19613 5136 3 59 59 CD 19613 5136 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5136 5 by by IN 19613 5136 6 tracing trace VBG 19613 5136 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5136 8 like like IN 19613 5136 9 the the DT 19613 5136 10 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 5136 11 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 5136 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5136 13 all all DT 19613 5136 14 true true JJ 19613 5136 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5136 16 of of IN 19613 5136 17 the the DT 19613 5136 18 poets poet NNS 19613 5136 19 and and CC 19613 5136 20 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5136 21 to to IN 19613 5136 22 borrowing borrow VBG 19613 5136 23 from from IN 19613 5136 24 the the DT 19613 5136 25 books book NNS 19613 5136 26 of of IN 19613 5136 27 the the DT 19613 5136 28 Old Old NNP 19613 5136 29 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5136 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5136 31 Moses Moses NNP 19613 5136 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5136 33 . . . 19613 5137 1 Of of IN 19613 5137 2 what what WDT 19613 5137 3 further further JJ 19613 5137 4 use use NN 19613 5137 5 then then RB 19613 5137 6 is be VBZ 19613 5137 7 the the DT 19613 5137 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5137 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5137 10 : : : 19613 5137 11 sperma sperma NNP 19613 5137 12 logos logos NNP 19613 5137 13 emphuton emphuton NNP 19613 5137 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5137 15 ? ? . 19613 5138 1 Did do VBD 19613 5138 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5138 3 not not RB 19613 5138 4 really really RB 19613 5138 5 take take VB 19613 5138 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5138 7 seriously seriously RB 19613 5138 8 ? ? . 19613 5139 1 Did do VBD 19613 5139 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5139 3 merely merely RB 19613 5139 4 wish wish VB 19613 5139 5 to to TO 19613 5139 6 suit suit VB 19613 5139 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5139 8 to to IN 19613 5139 9 those those DT 19613 5139 10 whom whom WP 19613 5139 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5139 12 was be VBD 19613 5139 13 addressing address VBG 19613 5139 14 ? ? . 19613 5140 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5140 2 are be VBP 19613 5140 3 not not RB 19613 5140 4 justified justify VBN 19613 5140 5 in in IN 19613 5140 6 asserting assert VBG 19613 5140 7 this this DT 19613 5140 8 . . . 19613 5141 1 Probably probably RB 19613 5141 2 , , , 19613 5141 3 however however RB 19613 5141 4 , , , 19613 5141 5 the the DT 19613 5141 6 adoption adoption NN 19613 5141 7 of of IN 19613 5141 8 that that DT 19613 5141 9 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 5141 10 view view NN 19613 5141 11 of of IN 19613 5141 12 the the DT 19613 5141 13 history history NN 19613 5141 14 of of IN 19613 5141 15 the the DT 19613 5141 16 world world NN 19613 5141 17 is be VBZ 19613 5141 18 a a DT 19613 5141 19 proof proof NN 19613 5141 20 that that IN 19613 5141 21 the the DT 19613 5141 22 results result NNS 19613 5141 23 of of IN 19613 5141 24 the the DT 19613 5141 25 demon demon NN 19613 5141 26 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 5141 27 were be VBD 19613 5141 28 in in IN 19613 5141 29 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5141 30 's 's POS 19613 5141 31 estimation estimation NN 19613 5141 32 so so RB 19613 5141 33 serious serious JJ 19613 5141 34 that that IN 19613 5141 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5141 36 no no RB 19613 5141 37 longer long RBR 19613 5141 38 expected expect VBD 19613 5141 39 anything anything NN 19613 5141 40 from from IN 19613 5141 41 the the DT 19613 5141 42 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5141 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5141 44 : : : 19613 5141 45 sperma sperma NNP 19613 5141 46 logos logos NNP 19613 5141 47 emphuton emphuton NNP 19613 5141 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5141 49 when when WRB 19613 5141 50 left leave VBN 19613 5141 51 to to IN 19613 5141 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5141 53 own own JJ 19613 5141 54 resources resource NNS 19613 5141 55 ; ; : 19613 5141 56 and and CC 19613 5141 57 therefore therefore RB 19613 5141 58 regarded regard VBD 19613 5141 59 truth truth NN 19613 5141 60 and and CC 19613 5141 61 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 5141 62 revelation revelation NN 19613 5141 63 as as IN 19613 5141 64 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 5141 65 . . . 19613 5142 1 But but CC 19613 5142 2 this this DT 19613 5142 3 view view NN 19613 5142 4 is be VBZ 19613 5142 5 not not RB 19613 5142 6 the the DT 19613 5142 7 essential essential JJ 19613 5142 8 one one NN 19613 5142 9 in in IN 19613 5142 10 the the DT 19613 5142 11 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5142 12 . . . 19613 5143 1 That that DT 19613 5143 2 assumption assumption NN 19613 5143 3 of of IN 19613 5143 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5143 5 's 's POS 19613 5143 6 is be VBZ 19613 5143 7 evidently evidently RB 19613 5143 8 dependent dependent JJ 19613 5143 9 on on IN 19613 5143 10 a a DT 19613 5143 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 5143 12 , , , 19613 5143 13 whilst whilst IN 19613 5143 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5143 15 real real JJ 19613 5143 16 opinion opinion NN 19613 5143 17 was be VBD 19613 5143 18 more more JJR 19613 5143 19 " " `` 19613 5143 20 liberal liberal JJ 19613 5143 21 . . . 19613 5143 22 " " '' 19613 5143 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5144 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5144 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5144 3 365 365 CD 19613 5144 4 : : : 19613 5144 5 Compare compare VB 19613 5144 6 with with IN 19613 5144 7 this this DT 19613 5144 8 the the DT 19613 5144 9 following follow VBG 19613 5144 10 passages passage NNS 19613 5144 11 : : : 19613 5144 12 In in IN 19613 5144 13 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5144 14 . . . 19613 5145 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5146 1 20 20 CD 19613 5146 2 are be VBP 19613 5146 3 enumerated enumerate VBN 19613 5146 4 a a DT 19613 5146 5 series series NN 19613 5146 6 of of IN 19613 5146 7 the the DT 19613 5146 8 most most RBS 19613 5146 9 important important JJ 19613 5146 10 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5146 11 common common JJ 19613 5146 12 to to IN 19613 5146 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5146 14 and and CC 19613 5146 15 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5146 16 . . . 19613 5147 1 Then then RB 19613 5147 2 follow follow VB 19613 5147 3 the the DT 19613 5147 4 words word NNS 19613 5147 5 : : : 19613 5147 6 " " `` 19613 5147 7 If if IN 19613 5147 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5147 9 then then RB 19613 5147 10 in in IN 19613 5147 11 particular particular JJ 19613 5147 12 respects respect NNS 19613 5147 13 even even RB 19613 5147 14 teach teach VBP 19613 5147 15 something something NN 19613 5147 16 similar similar JJ 19613 5147 17 to to IN 19613 5147 18 the the DT 19613 5147 19 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5147 20 of of IN 19613 5147 21 the the DT 19613 5147 22 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5147 23 honoured honour VBD 19613 5147 24 among among IN 19613 5147 25 you -PRON- PRP 19613 5147 26 , , , 19613 5147 27 though though IN 19613 5147 28 in in IN 19613 5147 29 many many JJ 19613 5147 30 cases case NNS 19613 5147 31 in in IN 19613 5147 32 a a DT 19613 5147 33 divine divine JJ 19613 5147 34 and and CC 19613 5147 35 more more JJR 19613 5147 36 sublime sublime JJ 19613 5147 37 way way NN 19613 5147 38 ; ; : 19613 5147 39 and and CC 19613 5147 40 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5147 41 indeed indeed RB 19613 5147 42 alone alone RB 19613 5147 43 do do VBP 19613 5147 44 so so RB 19613 5147 45 in in IN 19613 5147 46 such such PDT 19613 5147 47 a a DT 19613 5147 48 way way NN 19613 5147 49 that that WDT 19613 5147 50 the the DT 19613 5147 51 matter matter NN 19613 5147 52 is be VBZ 19613 5147 53 proved prove VBN 19613 5147 54 etc etc FW 19613 5147 55 . . . 19613 5147 56 " " '' 19613 5148 1 In in IN 19613 5148 2 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5148 3 . . . 19613 5149 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5150 1 44 44 CD 19613 5150 2 : : : 19613 5150 3 II ii CD 19613 5150 4 . . . 19613 5151 1 10 10 CD 19613 5151 2 . . . 19613 5152 1 13 13 CD 19613 5152 2 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 5152 3 , , , 19613 5152 4 error error NN 19613 5152 5 , , , 19613 5152 6 and and CC 19613 5152 7 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 5152 8 are be VBP 19613 5152 9 shown show VBN 19613 5152 10 to to TO 19613 5152 11 exist exist VB 19613 5152 12 in in IN 19613 5152 13 the the DT 19613 5152 14 case case NN 19613 5152 15 of of IN 19613 5152 16 the the DT 19613 5152 17 greatest great JJS 19613 5152 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5152 19 . . . 19613 5153 1 The the DT 19613 5153 2 Christian christian JJ 19613 5153 3 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5153 4 are be VBP 19613 5153 5 more more RBR 19613 5153 6 sublime sublime JJ 19613 5153 7 than than IN 19613 5153 8 all all DT 19613 5153 9 human human JJ 19613 5153 10 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5153 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5153 12 II II NNP 19613 5153 13 . . . 19613 5154 1 15 15 CD 19613 5154 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5154 3 . . . 19613 5155 1 " " `` 19613 5155 2 Our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5155 3 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5155 4 are be VBP 19613 5155 5 evidently evidently RB 19613 5155 6 more more RBR 19613 5155 7 sublime sublime JJ 19613 5155 8 than than IN 19613 5155 9 any any DT 19613 5155 10 human human JJ 19613 5155 11 teaching teaching NN 19613 5155 12 , , , 19613 5155 13 because because IN 19613 5155 14 the the DT 19613 5155 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5155 16 who who WP 19613 5155 17 appeared appear VBD 19613 5155 18 for for IN 19613 5155 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5155 20 sakes sake NNS 19613 5155 21 was be VBD 19613 5155 22 the the DT 19613 5155 23 whole whole JJ 19613 5155 24 fulness fulness NN 19613 5155 25 of of IN 19613 5155 26 reason reason NN 19613 5155 27 " " '' 19613 5155 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5155 29 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5155 30 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5155 31 : : : 19613 5155 32 to to TO 19613 5155 33 logikon logikon VB 19613 5155 34 to to IN 19613 5155 35 holon holon NNP 19613 5155 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5155 37 , , , 19613 5155 38 II II NNP 19613 5155 39 . . . 19613 5156 1 10 10 LS 19613 5156 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5156 3 . . . 19613 5157 1 " " `` 19613 5157 2 The the DT 19613 5157 3 principles principle NNS 19613 5157 4 of of IN 19613 5157 5 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5157 6 are be VBP 19613 5157 7 not not RB 19613 5157 8 foreign foreign JJ 19613 5157 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5157 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5157 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5157 12 : : : 19613 5157 13 allotria allotria NNP 19613 5157 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5157 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5157 16 to to IN 19613 5157 17 the the DT 19613 5157 18 teaching teaching NN 19613 5157 19 of of IN 19613 5157 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5157 21 , , , 19613 5157 22 but but CC 19613 5157 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5157 24 do do VBP 19613 5157 25 not not RB 19613 5157 26 agree agree VB 19613 5157 27 in in IN 19613 5157 28 every every DT 19613 5157 29 respect respect NN 19613 5157 30 . . . 19613 5158 1 The the DT 19613 5158 2 same same JJ 19613 5158 3 holds hold VBZ 19613 5158 4 good good NN 19613 5158 5 of of IN 19613 5158 6 the the DT 19613 5158 7 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5158 8 " " '' 19613 5158 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5158 10 II ii CD 19613 5158 11 . . . 19613 5159 1 13 13 CD 19613 5159 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5159 3 . . . 19613 5160 1 " " `` 19613 5160 2 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5160 3 must must MD 19613 5160 4 go go VB 19613 5160 5 forth forth RB 19613 5160 6 from from IN 19613 5160 7 the the DT 19613 5160 8 school school NN 19613 5160 9 of of IN 19613 5160 10 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5160 11 " " '' 19613 5160 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5160 13 II ii CD 19613 5160 14 . . . 19613 5161 1 12 12 CD 19613 5161 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5161 3 . . . 19613 5162 1 " " `` 19613 5162 2 Socrates socrate NNS 19613 5162 3 convinced convince VBD 19613 5162 4 no no DT 19613 5162 5 one one NN 19613 5162 6 in in IN 19613 5162 7 such such PDT 19613 5162 8 a a DT 19613 5162 9 way way NN 19613 5162 10 that that IN 19613 5162 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5162 12 would would MD 19613 5162 13 have have VB 19613 5162 14 been be VBN 19613 5162 15 willing willing JJ 19613 5162 16 to to TO 19613 5162 17 die die VB 19613 5162 18 for for IN 19613 5162 19 the the DT 19613 5162 20 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5162 21 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 5162 22 by by IN 19613 5162 23 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5162 24 ; ; : 19613 5162 25 whereas whereas IN 19613 5162 26 not not RB 19613 5162 27 only only RB 19613 5162 28 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5162 29 and and CC 19613 5162 30 philologers philologer NNS 19613 5162 31 , , , 19613 5162 32 but but CC 19613 5162 33 also also RB 19613 5162 34 artisans artisan NNS 19613 5162 35 and and CC 19613 5162 36 quite quite RB 19613 5162 37 common common JJ 19613 5162 38 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 5162 39 people people NNS 19613 5162 40 have have VBP 19613 5162 41 believed believe VBN 19613 5162 42 in in IN 19613 5162 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5162 44 " " '' 19613 5162 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5162 46 II ii CD 19613 5162 47 . . . 19613 5163 1 10 10 LS 19613 5163 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5163 3 . . . 19613 5164 1 These these DT 19613 5164 2 are be VBP 19613 5164 3 the the DT 19613 5164 4 very very JJ 19613 5164 5 people people NNS 19613 5164 6 -- -- : 19613 5164 7 and and CC 19613 5164 8 that that DT 19613 5164 9 is be VBZ 19613 5164 10 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 5164 11 the the DT 19613 5164 12 strongest strong JJS 19613 5164 13 contrast contrast NN 19613 5164 14 found find VBN 19613 5164 15 between between IN 19613 5164 16 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5164 17 and and CC 19613 5164 18 Logos Logos NNPS 19613 5164 19 in in IN 19613 5164 20 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5164 21 -- -- : 19613 5164 22 among among IN 19613 5164 23 whom whom WP 19613 5164 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5164 25 is be VBZ 19613 5164 26 universally universally RB 19613 5164 27 said say VBN 19613 5164 28 of of IN 19613 5164 29 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5164 30 : : : 19613 5164 31 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5164 32 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5164 33 : : : 19613 5164 34 dunamis dunamis NNP 19613 5164 35 esti esti NNP 19613 5164 36 tou tou NNP 19613 5164 37 arrêtou arrêtou NNP 19613 5164 38 patros patros NNP 19613 5164 39 kai kai NNP 19613 5164 40 ouchi ouchi NNP 19613 5164 41 anthrôpeiou anthrôpeiou NNP 19613 5164 42 logou logou NNP 19613 5164 43 kataskeuê kataskeuê NNP 19613 5164 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5164 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5164 46 see see VB 19613 5164 47 also also RB 19613 5164 48 I. I. NNP 19613 5165 1 14 14 CD 19613 5165 2 and and CC 19613 5165 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 5165 4 . . . 19613 5165 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5165 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5166 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5166 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5166 3 366 366 CD 19613 5166 4 : : : 19613 5166 5 In in IN 19613 5166 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5166 7 's 's POS 19613 5166 8 estimate estimate NN 19613 5166 9 of of IN 19613 5166 10 the the DT 19613 5166 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 5166 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5166 13 two two CD 19613 5166 14 other other JJ 19613 5166 15 points point NNS 19613 5166 16 deserve deserve VBP 19613 5166 17 notice notice NN 19613 5166 18 . . . 19613 5167 1 In in IN 19613 5167 2 the the DT 19613 5167 3 first first JJ 19613 5167 4 place place NN 19613 5167 5 , , , 19613 5167 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5167 7 draws draw VBZ 19613 5167 8 a a DT 19613 5167 9 very very RB 19613 5167 10 sharp sharp JJ 19613 5167 11 distinction distinction NN 19613 5167 12 between between IN 19613 5167 13 real real JJ 19613 5167 14 and and CC 19613 5167 15 nominal nominal JJ 19613 5167 16 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5167 17 . . . 19613 5168 1 By by IN 19613 5168 2 the the DT 19613 5168 3 latter latter JJ 19613 5168 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5168 5 specially specially RB 19613 5168 6 means mean VBZ 19613 5168 7 the the DT 19613 5168 8 Epicureans Epicureans NNPS 19613 5168 9 . . . 19613 5169 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 5169 2 are be VBP 19613 5169 3 no no RB 19613 5169 4 doubt doubt RB 19613 5169 5 referred refer VBN 19613 5169 6 to to IN 19613 5169 7 in in IN 19613 5169 8 I. I. NNP 19613 5170 1 4 4 CD 19613 5170 2 , , , 19613 5170 3 7 7 CD 19613 5170 4 , , , 19613 5170 5 26 26 CD 19613 5170 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5170 7 I. i. NN 19613 5171 1 14 14 CD 19613 5171 2 : : : 19613 5171 3 Atheists atheist NNS 19613 5171 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5171 5 . . . 19613 5172 1 Epicurus Epicurus NNP 19613 5172 2 and and CC 19613 5172 3 Sardanapalus Sardanapalus NNP 19613 5172 4 are be VBP 19613 5172 5 classed class VBN 19613 5172 6 together together RB 19613 5172 7 in in IN 19613 5172 8 II II NNP 19613 5172 9 . . . 19613 5173 1 7 7 LS 19613 5173 2 ; ; : 19613 5173 3 Epicurus Epicurus NNP 19613 5173 4 and and CC 19613 5173 5 the the DT 19613 5173 6 immoral immoral JJ 19613 5173 7 poets poet NNS 19613 5173 8 in in IN 19613 5173 9 II II NNP 19613 5173 10 . . . 19613 5174 1 12 12 CD 19613 5174 2 ; ; : 19613 5174 3 and and CC 19613 5174 4 in in IN 19613 5174 5 the the DT 19613 5174 6 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 5174 7 of of IN 19613 5174 8 II II NNP 19613 5174 9 , , , 19613 5174 10 15 15 CD 19613 5174 11 the the DT 19613 5174 12 same same JJ 19613 5174 13 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 5174 14 is be VBZ 19613 5174 15 ranked rank VBN 19613 5174 16 with with IN 19613 5174 17 the the DT 19613 5174 18 worst bad JJS 19613 5174 19 society society NN 19613 5174 20 . . . 19613 5175 1 But but CC 19613 5175 2 according accord VBG 19613 5175 3 to to IN 19613 5175 4 II II NNP 19613 5175 5 . . . 19613 5176 1 3 3 CD 19613 5176 2 fin fin NNP 19613 5176 3 . . . 19613 5177 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5177 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5177 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5177 4 : : : 19613 5177 5 adunaton adunaton NNP 19613 5177 6 Kunikô Kunikô NNP 19613 5177 7 , , , 19613 5177 8 adiaphoron adiaphoron NNP 19613 5177 9 to to IN 19613 5177 10 telos telos NNP 19613 5177 11 prothemenô prothemenô NNP 19613 5177 12 , , , 19613 5177 13 to to IN 19613 5177 14 agathon agathon NNP 19613 5177 15 eidenai eidenai NNP 19613 5177 16 plên plên NNP 19613 5177 17 adikphorias adikphorias NNP 19613 5177 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5177 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5177 20 the the DT 19613 5177 21 Cynics Cynics NNPS 19613 5177 22 also also RB 19613 5177 23 seem seem VBP 19613 5177 24 to to TO 19613 5177 25 be be VB 19613 5177 26 outside outside IN 19613 5177 27 the the DT 19613 5177 28 circle circle NN 19613 5177 29 of of IN 19613 5177 30 real real JJ 19613 5177 31 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5177 32 . . . 19613 5178 1 This this DT 19613 5178 2 is be VBZ 19613 5178 3 composed compose VBN 19613 5178 4 principally principally RB 19613 5178 5 of of IN 19613 5178 6 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 5178 7 , , , 19613 5178 8 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5178 9 , , , 19613 5178 10 the the DT 19613 5178 11 Platonists Platonists NNPS 19613 5178 12 and and CC 19613 5178 13 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5178 14 , , , 19613 5178 15 together together RB 19613 5178 16 with with IN 19613 5178 17 Heraclitus Heraclitus NNP 19613 5178 18 and and CC 19613 5178 19 others other NNS 19613 5178 20 . . . 19613 5179 1 Some some DT 19613 5179 2 of of IN 19613 5179 3 these these DT 19613 5179 4 understood understand VBD 19613 5179 5 one one CD 19613 5179 6 set set NN 19613 5179 7 of of IN 19613 5179 8 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5179 9 more more RBR 19613 5179 10 correctly correctly RB 19613 5179 11 , , , 19613 5179 12 others other NNS 19613 5179 13 another another DT 19613 5179 14 series series NN 19613 5179 15 . . . 19613 5180 1 The the DT 19613 5180 2 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5180 3 excelled excel VBD 19613 5180 4 in in IN 19613 5180 5 ethics ethic NNS 19613 5180 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5180 7 II II NNP 19613 5180 8 . . . 19613 5181 1 7 7 LS 19613 5181 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5181 3 ; ; : 19613 5181 4 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5181 5 described describe VBD 19613 5181 6 the the DT 19613 5181 7 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5181 8 and and CC 19613 5181 9 the the DT 19613 5181 10 world world NN 19613 5181 11 more more RBR 19613 5181 12 correctly correctly RB 19613 5181 13 . . . 19613 5182 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5182 2 is be VBZ 19613 5182 3 , , , 19613 5182 4 however however RB 19613 5182 5 , , , 19613 5182 6 worthy worthy JJ 19613 5182 7 of of IN 19613 5182 8 note note NN 19613 5182 9 -- -- : 19613 5182 10 and and CC 19613 5182 11 this this DT 19613 5182 12 is be VBZ 19613 5182 13 the the DT 19613 5182 14 second second JJ 19613 5182 15 point point NN 19613 5182 16 -- -- : 19613 5182 17 that that IN 19613 5182 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5182 19 in in IN 19613 5182 20 principle principle NN 19613 5182 21 conceived conceive VBD 19613 5182 22 the the DT 19613 5182 23 Greek greek JJ 19613 5182 24 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5182 25 as as IN 19613 5182 26 a a DT 19613 5182 27 unity unity NN 19613 5182 28 , , , 19613 5182 29 and and CC 19613 5182 30 that that IN 19613 5182 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5182 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 5182 33 saw see VBD 19613 5182 34 in in IN 19613 5182 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5182 36 very very JJ 19613 5182 37 deviations deviation NNS 19613 5182 38 from from IN 19613 5182 39 one one CD 19613 5182 40 another another DT 19613 5182 41 a a DT 19613 5182 42 proof proof NN 19613 5182 43 of of IN 19613 5182 44 the the DT 19613 5182 45 imperfection imperfection NN 19613 5182 46 of of IN 19613 5182 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5182 48 teaching teaching NN 19613 5182 49 . . . 19613 5183 1 In in IN 19613 5183 2 so so RB 19613 5183 3 far far RB 19613 5183 4 as as IN 19613 5183 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5183 6 are be VBP 19613 5183 7 all all DT 19613 5183 8 included include VBN 19613 5183 9 under under IN 19613 5183 10 the the DT 19613 5183 11 collective collective JJ 19613 5183 12 idea idea NN 19613 5183 13 " " `` 19613 5183 14 human human JJ 19613 5183 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5183 16 , , , 19613 5183 17 " " '' 19613 5183 18 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5183 19 is be VBZ 19613 5183 20 characterised characterise VBN 19613 5183 21 by by IN 19613 5183 22 the the DT 19613 5183 23 conflicting conflict VBG 19613 5183 24 opinions opinion NNS 19613 5183 25 found find VBN 19613 5183 26 within within IN 19613 5183 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5183 28 . . . 19613 5184 1 This this DT 19613 5184 2 view view NN 19613 5184 3 was be VBD 19613 5184 4 suggested suggest VBN 19613 5184 5 to to IN 19613 5184 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5184 7 by by IN 19613 5184 8 the the DT 19613 5184 9 fact fact NN 19613 5184 10 that that IN 19613 5184 11 the the DT 19613 5184 12 highest high JJS 19613 5184 13 truth truth NN 19613 5184 14 , , , 19613 5184 15 which which WDT 19613 5184 16 is be VBZ 19613 5184 17 at at IN 19613 5184 18 once once RB 19613 5184 19 allied ally VBN 19613 5184 20 and and CC 19613 5184 21 opposed oppose VBN 19613 5184 22 to to IN 19613 5184 23 human human JJ 19613 5184 24 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5184 25 , , , 19613 5184 26 was be VBD 19613 5184 27 found find VBN 19613 5184 28 by by IN 19613 5184 29 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5184 30 among among IN 19613 5184 31 an an DT 19613 5184 32 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 5184 33 circle circle NN 19613 5184 34 of of IN 19613 5184 35 fellow fellow NN 19613 5184 36 - - HYPH 19613 5184 37 believers believer NNS 19613 5184 38 . . . 19613 5185 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5185 2 showed show VBD 19613 5185 3 great great JJ 19613 5185 4 skill skill NN 19613 5185 5 in in IN 19613 5185 6 selecting select VBG 19613 5185 7 from from IN 19613 5185 8 the the DT 19613 5185 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 5185 10 the the DT 19613 5185 11 passages passage NNS 19613 5185 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5185 13 I. I. NNP 19613 5186 1 15 15 CD 19613 5186 2 - - SYM 19613 5186 3 17 17 CD 19613 5186 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5186 5 , , , 19613 5186 6 that that WDT 19613 5186 7 prove prove VBP 19613 5186 8 the the DT 19613 5186 9 " " `` 19613 5186 10 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5186 11 " " '' 19613 5186 12 life life NN 19613 5186 13 of of IN 19613 5186 14 the the DT 19613 5186 15 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5186 16 as as IN 19613 5186 17 described describe VBN 19613 5186 18 by by IN 19613 5186 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5186 20 in in IN 19613 5186 21 c. c. NNP 19613 5186 22 14 14 CD 19613 5186 23 . . . 19613 5187 1 Here here RB 19613 5187 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5187 3 can can MD 19613 5187 4 not not RB 19613 5187 5 be be VB 19613 5187 6 acquitted acquit VBN 19613 5187 7 of of IN 19613 5187 8 colouring colour VBG 19613 5187 9 the the DT 19613 5187 10 facts fact NNS 19613 5187 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5187 12 cf cf NN 19613 5187 13 . . . 19613 5188 1 Aristides aristide NNS 19613 5188 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5188 3 nor nor CC 19613 5188 4 of of IN 19613 5188 5 exaggeration exaggeration NN 19613 5188 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5188 7 see see VB 19613 5188 8 , , , 19613 5188 9 for for IN 19613 5188 10 instance instance NN 19613 5188 11 , , , 19613 5188 12 the the DT 19613 5188 13 unqualified unqualified JJ 19613 5188 14 statement statement NN 19613 5188 15 : : : 19613 5188 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5188 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5188 18 : : : 19613 5188 19 ha ha NNP 19613 5188 20 echomen echomen NNP 19613 5188 21 eis eis NNP 19613 5188 22 koinon koinon NNP 19613 5188 23 pherontes pheronte VBZ 19613 5188 24 kai kai NNP 19613 5188 25 panti panti NNP 19613 5188 26 deomenô deomenô NNP 19613 5188 27 koinônountes koinônountes NNP 19613 5188 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5188 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5188 30 . . . 19613 5189 1 The the DT 19613 5189 2 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5189 3 emperors emperor NNS 19613 5189 4 were be VBD 19613 5189 5 meant mean VBN 19613 5189 6 here here RB 19613 5189 7 to to TO 19613 5189 8 think think VB 19613 5189 9 of of IN 19613 5189 10 the the DT 19613 5189 11 " " `` 19613 5189 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5189 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5189 14 : : : 19613 5189 15 philois philois NNP 19613 5189 16 panta panta NNP 19613 5189 17 koina koina NNP 19613 5189 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5189 19 . . . 19613 5189 20 " " '' 19613 5190 1 Yet yet CC 19613 5190 2 in in IN 19613 5190 3 I. i. NN 19613 5191 1 67 67 CD 19613 5191 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5191 3 corrected correct VBD 19613 5191 4 exaggerations exaggeration NNS 19613 5191 5 in in IN 19613 5191 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5191 7 description description NN 19613 5191 8 . . . 19613 5192 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5192 2 's 's POS 19613 5192 3 reference reference NN 19613 5192 4 to to IN 19613 5192 5 the the DT 19613 5192 6 invaluable invaluable JJ 19613 5192 7 benefits benefit NNS 19613 5192 8 which which WDT 19613 5192 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5192 10 confers confer NNS 19613 5192 11 on on IN 19613 5192 12 the the DT 19613 5192 13 state state NN 19613 5192 14 deserves deserve VBZ 19613 5192 15 notice notice NN 19613 5192 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5192 17 see see VB 19613 5192 18 particularly particularly RB 19613 5192 19 I. I. NNP 19613 5193 1 12 12 CD 19613 5193 2 , , , 19613 5193 3 17 17 CD 19613 5193 4 . . . 19613 5193 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5194 1 The the DT 19613 5194 2 later later JJ 19613 5194 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5194 4 make make VBP 19613 5194 5 a a DT 19613 5194 6 similar similar JJ 19613 5194 7 remark remark NN 19613 5194 8 . . . 19613 5194 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5195 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5195 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5195 3 367 367 CD 19613 5195 4 : : : 19613 5195 5 Dialogue dialogue NN 19613 5195 6 8 8 CD 19613 5195 7 . . . 19613 5196 1 The the DT 19613 5196 2 dialogue dialogue NN 19613 5196 3 takes take VBZ 19613 5196 4 up up RP 19613 5196 5 a a DT 19613 5196 6 more more RBR 19613 5196 7 positive positive JJ 19613 5196 8 attitude attitude NN 19613 5196 9 than than IN 19613 5196 10 the the DT 19613 5196 11 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5196 12 , , , 19613 5196 13 both both CC 19613 5196 14 as as IN 19613 5196 15 a a DT 19613 5196 16 whole whole NN 19613 5196 17 and and CC 19613 5196 18 in in IN 19613 5196 19 detail detail NN 19613 5196 20 . . . 19613 5197 1 If if IN 19613 5197 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5197 3 consider consider VBP 19613 5197 4 that that IN 19613 5197 5 both both DT 19613 5197 6 works work NNS 19613 5197 7 are be VBP 19613 5197 8 also also RB 19613 5197 9 meant mean VBN 19613 5197 10 for for IN 19613 5197 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5197 12 , , , 19613 5197 13 and and CC 19613 5197 14 that that IN 19613 5197 15 , , , 19613 5197 16 on on IN 19613 5197 17 the the DT 19613 5197 18 other other JJ 19613 5197 19 hand hand NN 19613 5197 20 , , , 19613 5197 21 the the DT 19613 5197 22 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 19613 5197 23 as as RB 19613 5197 24 well well RB 19613 5197 25 as as IN 19613 5197 26 the the DT 19613 5197 27 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5197 28 appeals appeal VBZ 19613 5197 29 to to IN 19613 5197 30 the the DT 19613 5197 31 cultured cultured NNP 19613 5197 32 heathen heathen NNP 19613 5197 33 public public NNP 19613 5197 34 , , , 19613 5197 35 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5197 36 may may MD 19613 5197 37 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 5197 38 assume assume VB 19613 5197 39 that that IN 19613 5197 40 the the DT 19613 5197 41 two two CD 19613 5197 42 writings writing NNS 19613 5197 43 were be VBD 19613 5197 44 meant mean VBN 19613 5197 45 to to TO 19613 5197 46 present present VB 19613 5197 47 a a DT 19613 5197 48 graduated graduated JJ 19613 5197 49 system system NN 19613 5197 50 of of IN 19613 5197 51 Christian christian JJ 19613 5197 52 instruction instruction NN 19613 5197 53 . . . 19613 5198 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5198 2 In in IN 19613 5198 3 one one CD 19613 5198 4 passage passage NN 19613 5198 5 the the DT 19613 5198 6 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 19613 5198 7 expressly expressly RB 19613 5198 8 refers refer VBZ 19613 5198 9 to to IN 19613 5198 10 the the DT 19613 5198 11 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5198 12 . . . 19613 5198 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5199 1 From from IN 19613 5199 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5199 3 's 's POS 19613 5199 4 time time NN 19613 5199 5 onward onward RB 19613 5199 6 the the DT 19613 5199 7 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5199 8 polemic polemic NN 19613 5199 9 of of IN 19613 5199 10 the the DT 19613 5199 11 early early JJ 19613 5199 12 Church Church NNP 19613 5199 13 appears appear VBZ 19613 5199 14 to to TO 19613 5199 15 have have VB 19613 5199 16 adhered adhere VBN 19613 5199 17 throughout throughout IN 19613 5199 18 to to IN 19613 5199 19 the the DT 19613 5199 20 same same JJ 19613 5199 21 method method NN 19613 5199 22 . . . 19613 5200 1 This this DT 19613 5200 2 consisted consist VBD 19613 5200 3 in in IN 19613 5200 4 giving give VBG 19613 5200 5 the the DT 19613 5200 6 polemical polemical JJ 19613 5200 7 writings writing NNS 19613 5200 8 directed direct VBN 19613 5200 9 against against IN 19613 5200 10 the the DT 19613 5200 11 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5200 12 the the DT 19613 5200 13 form form NN 19613 5200 14 of of IN 19613 5200 15 an an DT 19613 5200 16 introduction introduction NN 19613 5200 17 to to IN 19613 5200 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 5200 19 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5200 20 , , , 19613 5200 21 and and CC 19613 5200 22 in in IN 19613 5200 23 continuing continue VBG 19613 5200 24 this this DT 19613 5200 25 instruction instruction NN 19613 5200 26 still still RB 19613 5200 27 further far RBR 19613 5200 28 in in IN 19613 5200 29 those those DT 19613 5200 30 directed direct VBN 19613 5200 31 against against IN 19613 5200 32 the the DT 19613 5200 33 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 5200 34 . . . 19613 5200 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5201 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5201 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5201 3 368 368 CD 19613 5201 4 : : : 19613 5201 5 Dial dial NN 19613 5201 6 . . . 19613 5202 1 2 2 LS 19613 5202 2 . . . 19613 5202 3 sq sq NNP 19613 5202 4 . . . 19613 5203 1 That that IN 19613 5203 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5203 3 's 's POS 19613 5203 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5203 5 is be VBZ 19613 5203 6 founded found VBN 19613 5203 7 on on IN 19613 5203 8 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 5203 9 scepticism scepticism NN 19613 5203 10 is be VBZ 19613 5203 11 clearly clearly RB 19613 5203 12 shown show VBN 19613 5203 13 by by IN 19613 5203 14 the the DT 19613 5203 15 introduction introduction NN 19613 5203 16 to to IN 19613 5203 17 the the DT 19613 5203 18 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 19613 5203 19 . . . 19613 5203 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5204 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5204 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5204 3 369 369 CD 19613 5204 4 : : : 19613 5204 5 Dial dial NN 19613 5204 6 . . . 19613 5205 1 8 8 CD 19613 5205 2 : : : 19613 5205 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5205 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5205 5 : : : 19613 5205 6 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 5205 7 dê dê NNP 19613 5205 8 kai kai NNP 19613 5205 9 dia dia NNP 19613 5205 10 tauta tauta NNP 19613 5205 11 philosophos philosophos NNP 19613 5205 12 egô egô NNP 19613 5205 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5205 14 . . . 19613 5205 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5206 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5206 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5206 3 370 370 CD 19613 5206 4 : : : 19613 5206 5 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5206 6 . . NNP 19613 5206 7 , , , 19613 5206 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 5206 9 . . . 19613 5207 1 : : : 19613 5207 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5207 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5207 4 : : : 19613 5207 5 parestin parestin NNP 19613 5207 6 soi soi NN 19613 5207 7 ton ton NN 19613 5207 8 Christon Christon NNP 19613 5207 9 tou tou NN 19613 5207 10 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5207 11 epignonti epignonti NNP 19613 5207 12 kai kai NNP 19613 5207 13 teleiô teleiô NNP 19613 5207 14 genomenô genomenô NNP 19613 5207 15 eudaimonein eudaimonein NNP 19613 5207 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5207 17 . . . 19613 5207 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5208 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5208 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5208 3 371 371 CD 19613 5208 4 : : : 19613 5208 5 See see VB 19613 5208 6 particularly particularly RB 19613 5208 7 the the DT 19613 5208 8 closing closing NN 19613 5208 9 chapter chapter NN 19613 5208 10 . . . 19613 5208 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5209 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5209 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5209 3 372 372 CD 19613 5209 4 : : : 19613 5209 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5209 6 . . . 19613 5210 1 2 2 LS 19613 5210 2 , , , 19613 5210 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5210 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5210 5 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5210 6 373 373 CD 19613 5210 7 : : : 19613 5210 8 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5210 9 . . . 19613 5211 1 4 4 LS 19613 5211 2 . . . 19613 5211 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5212 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5212 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5212 3 374 374 CD 19613 5212 4 : : : 19613 5212 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5212 6 . . . 19613 5213 1 5 5 CD 19613 5213 2 - - SYM 19613 5213 3 7 7 CD 19613 5213 4 . . . 19613 5213 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5214 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5214 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5214 3 375 375 CD 19613 5214 4 : : : 19613 5214 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5214 6 . . . 19613 5215 1 24 24 CD 19613 5215 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5215 3 see see VB 19613 5215 4 also also RB 19613 5215 5 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 5215 6 c. c. IN 19613 5216 1 13 13 CD 19613 5216 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5216 3 . . . 19613 5216 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5217 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5217 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5217 3 376 376 CD 19613 5217 4 : : : 19613 5217 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5217 6 , , , 19613 5217 7 7 7 CD 19613 5217 8 fin fin NN 19613 5217 9 . . . 19613 5218 1 and and CC 19613 5218 2 many many JJ 19613 5218 3 other other JJ 19613 5218 4 places place NNS 19613 5218 5 . . . 19613 5218 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5219 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5219 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5219 3 377 377 CD 19613 5219 4 : : : 19613 5219 5 _ _ NNP 19613 5219 6 E.g. E.g. NNP 19613 5219 7 _ _ NNP 19613 5219 8 , , , 19613 5219 9 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5219 10 . . . 19613 5220 1 8 8 LS 19613 5220 2 . . . 19613 5221 1 35 35 CD 19613 5221 2 fin fin NNP 19613 5221 3 . . . 19613 5221 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5222 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5222 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5222 3 378 378 CD 19613 5222 4 : : : 19613 5222 5 The the DT 19613 5222 6 Crucified Crucified NNP 19613 5222 7 Man Man NNP 19613 5222 8 , , , 19613 5222 9 the the DT 19613 5222 10 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5222 11 of of IN 19613 5222 12 the the DT 19613 5222 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5222 14 etc etc FW 19613 5222 15 . . . 19613 5223 1 are be VBP 19613 5223 2 wanting want VBG 19613 5223 3 . . . 19613 5224 1 Nothing nothing NN 19613 5224 2 at at RB 19613 5224 3 all all RB 19613 5224 4 is be VBZ 19613 5224 5 said say VBN 19613 5224 6 about about IN 19613 5224 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5224 8 . . . 19613 5224 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5225 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5225 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5225 3 379 379 CD 19613 5225 4 : : : 19613 5225 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5225 6 . . . 19613 5226 1 7 7 LS 19613 5226 2 . . . 19613 5226 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5227 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5227 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5227 3 380 380 CD 19613 5227 4 : : : 19613 5227 5 Cf cf NN 19613 5227 6 . . . 19613 5228 1 the the DT 19613 5228 2 arguments argument NNS 19613 5228 3 in in IN 19613 5228 4 c. c. NNP 19613 5228 5 8 8 CD 19613 5228 6 with with IN 19613 5228 7 c. c. NN 19613 5228 8 9 9 CD 19613 5228 9 init init NN 19613 5228 10 . . . 19613 5228 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5229 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5229 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5229 3 381 381 CD 19613 5229 4 : : : 19613 5229 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5229 6 . . . 19613 5230 1 11 11 CD 19613 5230 2 . . . 19613 5230 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5231 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5231 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5231 3 382 382 CD 19613 5231 4 : : : 19613 5231 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5231 6 . . . 19613 5232 1 23 23 CD 19613 5232 2 . . . 19613 5232 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5233 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5233 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5233 3 383 383 CD 19613 5233 4 : : : 19613 5233 5 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5233 6 . . . 19613 5234 1 18 18 CD 19613 5234 2 , , , 19613 5234 3 23 23 CD 19613 5234 4 - - SYM 19613 5234 5 27 27 CD 19613 5234 6 . . . 19613 5235 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5235 2 , , , 19613 5235 3 however however RB 19613 5235 4 , , , 19613 5235 5 as as RB 19613 5235 6 well well RB 19613 5235 7 as as IN 19613 5235 8 the the DT 19613 5235 9 others other NNS 19613 5235 10 , , , 19613 5235 11 sets set VBZ 19613 5235 12 forth forth RB 19613 5235 13 the the DT 19613 5235 14 demon demon NN 19613 5235 15 theory theory NN 19613 5235 16 in in IN 19613 5235 17 detail detail NN 19613 5235 18 . . . 19613 5235 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5236 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5236 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5236 3 384 384 CD 19613 5236 4 : : : 19613 5236 5 The the DT 19613 5236 6 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5236 7 which which WDT 19613 5236 8 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 19613 5236 9 addressed address VBD 19613 5236 10 to to IN 19613 5236 11 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 5236 12 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 19613 5236 13 and and CC 19613 5236 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5236 15 fellow fellow JJ 19613 5236 16 - - HYPH 19613 5236 17 emperor emperor NN 19613 5236 18 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 5236 19 bore bear VBD 19613 5236 20 the the DT 19613 5236 21 title title NN 19613 5236 22 : : : 19613 5236 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5236 24 Greek greek JJ 19613 5236 25 : : : 19613 5236 26 huper huper JJ 19613 5236 27 tês tês NN 19613 5236 28 kata kata NNP 19613 5236 29 Christianous christianous JJ 19613 5236 30 philosophias philosophias NN 19613 5236 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5236 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5236 33 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 5236 34 . . NNP 19613 5236 35 , , , 19613 5236 36 H. H. NNP 19613 5236 37 E. E. NNP 19613 5236 38 V. V. NNP 19613 5236 39 17 17 CD 19613 5236 40 . . . 19613 5237 1 5 5 LS 19613 5237 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5237 3 . . . 19613 5238 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5238 2 is be VBZ 19613 5238 3 certain certain JJ 19613 5238 4 that that IN 19613 5238 5 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5238 6 in in IN 19613 5238 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5238 8 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5238 9 designated designate VBD 19613 5238 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5238 11 as as IN 19613 5238 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5238 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5238 14 : : : 19613 5238 15 hê hê VB 19613 5238 16 kath kath NNP 19613 5238 17 ' ' POS 19613 5238 18 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 5238 19 philosophia philosophia NN 19613 5238 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5238 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5238 22 l.c l.c NNP 19613 5238 23 . . NNP 19613 5238 24 , , , 19613 5238 25 IV IV NNP 19613 5238 26 . . . 19613 5239 1 26 26 CD 19613 5239 2 . . . 19613 5240 1 7 7 LS 19613 5240 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5240 3 . . . 19613 5241 1 But but CC 19613 5241 2 , , , 19613 5241 3 while while IN 19613 5241 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5241 5 is be VBZ 19613 5241 6 undeniable undeniable JJ 19613 5241 7 that that IN 19613 5241 8 this this DT 19613 5241 9 writer writer NN 19613 5241 10 attempted attempt VBD 19613 5241 11 , , , 19613 5241 12 to to IN 19613 5241 13 a a DT 19613 5241 14 hitherto hitherto JJ 19613 5241 15 unexampled unexampled JJ 19613 5241 16 extent extent NN 19613 5241 17 , , , 19613 5241 18 to to TO 19613 5241 19 represent represent VB 19613 5241 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5241 21 as as IN 19613 5241 22 adapted adapt VBN 19613 5241 23 to to IN 19613 5241 24 the the DT 19613 5241 25 Empire Empire NNP 19613 5241 26 , , , 19613 5241 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5241 28 must must MD 19613 5241 29 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5241 30 beware beware VB 19613 5241 31 of of IN 19613 5241 32 laying lay VBG 19613 5241 33 undue undue JJ 19613 5241 34 weight weight NN 19613 5241 35 on on IN 19613 5241 36 the the DT 19613 5241 37 expression expression NN 19613 5241 38 " " `` 19613 5241 39 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5241 40 . . . 19613 5241 41 " " '' 19613 5242 1 What what WP 19613 5242 2 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5242 3 means mean VBZ 19613 5242 4 chiefly chiefly RB 19613 5242 5 to to TO 19613 5242 6 emphasise emphasise VB 19613 5242 7 is be VBZ 19613 5242 8 the the DT 19613 5242 9 fact fact NN 19613 5242 10 that that IN 19613 5242 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5242 12 , , , 19613 5242 13 which which WDT 19613 5242 14 in in IN 19613 5242 15 former former JJ 19613 5242 16 times time NNS 19613 5242 17 had have VBD 19613 5242 18 developed develop VBN 19613 5242 19 into into IN 19613 5242 20 strength strength NN 19613 5242 21 among among IN 19613 5242 22 the the DT 19613 5242 23 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 5242 24 , , , 19613 5242 25 began begin VBD 19613 5242 26 to to TO 19613 5242 27 flourish flourish VB 19613 5242 28 in in IN 19613 5242 29 the the DT 19613 5242 30 provinces province NNS 19613 5242 31 of of IN 19613 5242 32 the the DT 19613 5242 33 Empire empire NN 19613 5242 34 simultaneously simultaneously RB 19613 5242 35 with with IN 19613 5242 36 the the DT 19613 5242 37 rise rise NN 19613 5242 38 of of IN 19613 5242 39 the the DT 19613 5242 40 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 5242 41 under under IN 19613 5242 42 Augustus Augustus NNP 19613 5242 43 , , , 19613 5242 44 that that IN 19613 5242 45 as as IN 19613 5242 46 foster foster NN 19613 5242 47 - - HYPH 19613 5242 48 sister sister NN 19613 5242 49 of of IN 19613 5242 50 the the DT 19613 5242 51 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 5242 52 , , , 19613 5242 53 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5242 54 increased increase VBD 19613 5242 55 in in IN 19613 5242 56 strength strength NN 19613 5242 57 with with IN 19613 5242 58 the the DT 19613 5242 59 latter latter JJ 19613 5242 60 , , , 19613 5242 61 and and CC 19613 5242 62 that that IN 19613 5242 63 this this DT 19613 5242 64 mutual mutual JJ 19613 5242 65 relation relation NN 19613 5242 66 of of IN 19613 5242 67 the the DT 19613 5242 68 two two CD 19613 5242 69 institutions institution NNS 19613 5242 70 had have VBD 19613 5242 71 given give VBN 19613 5242 72 prosperity prosperity NN 19613 5242 73 and and CC 19613 5242 74 splendour splendour NN 19613 5242 75 to to IN 19613 5242 76 the the DT 19613 5242 77 state state NN 19613 5242 78 . . . 19613 5243 1 When when WRB 19613 5243 2 in in IN 19613 5243 3 the the DT 19613 5243 4 fragments fragment NNS 19613 5243 5 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5243 6 to to IN 19613 5243 7 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5243 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5243 9 twice twice RB 19613 5243 10 , , , 19613 5243 11 in in IN 19613 5243 12 this this DT 19613 5243 13 connection connection NN 19613 5243 14 , , , 19613 5243 15 calls call VBZ 19613 5243 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5243 17 " " '' 19613 5243 18 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5243 19 , , , 19613 5243 20 " " '' 19613 5243 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5243 22 must must MD 19613 5243 23 note note VB 19613 5243 24 that that IN 19613 5243 25 this this DT 19613 5243 26 expression expression NN 19613 5243 27 alternates alternate NNS 19613 5243 28 with with IN 19613 5243 29 the the DT 19613 5243 30 other other JJ 19613 5243 31 " " `` 19613 5243 32 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5243 33 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5243 34 : : : 19613 5243 35 ho ho NNP 19613 5243 36 kath kath NNP 19613 5243 37 ' ' POS 19613 5243 38 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 5243 39 logos logos NNP 19613 5243 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5243 41 " " `` 19613 5243 42 , , , 19613 5243 43 and and CC 19613 5243 44 that that IN 19613 5243 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5243 46 uses use VBZ 19613 5243 47 the the DT 19613 5243 48 formula formula NN 19613 5243 49 : : : 19613 5243 50 " " `` 19613 5243 51 Thy thy NN 19613 5243 52 forefathers forefather NNS 19613 5243 53 held hold VBD 19613 5243 54 this this DT 19613 5243 55 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5243 56 in in IN 19613 5243 57 honour honour NN 19613 5243 58 along along IN 19613 5243 59 with with IN 19613 5243 60 the the DT 19613 5243 61 other other JJ 19613 5243 62 cults cult NNS 19613 5243 63 " " '' 19613 5243 64 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5243 65 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5243 66 : : : 19613 5243 67 pros pro NNS 19613 5243 68 tais tais NNP 19613 5243 69 allais allais NNP 19613 5243 70 thrêskeichis thrêskeichis DT 19613 5243 71 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5243 72 . . . 19613 5244 1 This this DT 19613 5244 2 excludes exclude VBZ 19613 5244 3 the the DT 19613 5244 4 assumption assumption NN 19613 5244 5 that that IN 19613 5244 6 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5244 7 in in IN 19613 5244 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5244 9 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5244 10 merely merely RB 19613 5244 11 represented represent VBD 19613 5244 12 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5244 13 as as IN 19613 5244 14 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5244 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5244 16 see see VB 19613 5244 17 also also RB 19613 5244 18 IV IV NNP 19613 5244 19 . . . 19613 5245 1 26 26 CD 19613 5245 2 . . . 19613 5246 1 5 5 CD 19613 5246 2 , , , 19613 5246 3 where where WRB 19613 5246 4 the the DT 19613 5246 5 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5246 6 are be VBP 19613 5246 7 called call VBN 19613 5246 8 " " `` 19613 5246 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5246 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5246 11 : : : 19613 5246 12 to to TO 19613 5246 13 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5246 14 theosebôn theosebôn NNP 19613 5246 15 genos genos NNP 19613 5246 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5246 17 " " '' 19613 5246 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5246 19 . . . 19613 5247 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5247 2 also also RB 19613 5247 3 wrote write VBD 19613 5247 4 a a DT 19613 5247 5 treatise treatise NN 19613 5247 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5247 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5247 8 : : : 19613 5247 9 peri peri NNP 19613 5247 10 ktiseôs ktiseôs NNP 19613 5247 11 kai kai NNP 19613 5247 12 geneseôs geneseôs NN 19613 5247 13 Christou Christou NNP 19613 5247 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5247 15 . . . 19613 5248 1 In in IN 19613 5248 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5248 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5248 4 fragment fragment NN 19613 5248 5 in in IN 19613 5248 6 the the DT 19613 5248 7 Chron Chron NNP 19613 5248 8 . . . 19613 5249 1 Pasch Pasch NNP 19613 5249 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5249 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5249 4 called call VBD 19613 5249 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5249 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5249 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5249 8 : : : 19613 5249 9 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5249 10 logos logo VBZ 19613 5249 11 pro pro JJ 19613 5249 12 aiônôn aiônôn NN 19613 5249 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5249 14 . . . 19613 5249 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5250 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5250 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5250 3 385 385 CD 19613 5250 4 : : : 19613 5250 5 See see VB 19613 5250 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5250 7 treatise treatise NN 19613 5250 8 " " '' 19613 5250 9 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5250 10 's 's POS 19613 5250 11 Rede Rede NNP 19613 5250 12 an an DT 19613 5250 13 die die NN 19613 5250 14 Griechen Griechen NNP 19613 5250 15 übers über NNS 19613 5250 16 . . . 19613 5250 17 " " '' 19613 5251 1 1884 1884 CD 19613 5251 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5251 3 Giessener Giessener NNP 19613 5251 4 Programm Programm NNP 19613 5251 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5251 6 . . . 19613 5252 1 Daniel Daniel NNP 19613 5252 2 , , , 19613 5252 3 Tatianus Tatianus NNP 19613 5252 4 , , , 19613 5252 5 1837 1837 CD 19613 5252 6 . . . 19613 5253 1 Steuer Steuer NNP 19613 5253 2 , , , 19613 5253 3 Die die VBP 19613 5253 4 Gottes- Gottes- NNP 19613 5253 5 und und NN 19613 5253 6 Logoslehre Logoslehre NNP 19613 5253 7 des des FW 19613 5253 8 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5253 9 , , , 19613 5253 10 1893 1893 CD 19613 5253 11 . . . 19613 5253 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5254 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5254 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5254 3 386 386 CD 19613 5254 4 : : : 19613 5254 5 But but CC 19613 5254 6 see see VB 19613 5254 7 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5254 8 . . . 19613 5255 1 4 4 CD 19613 5255 2 init init NN 19613 5255 3 . . . 19613 5255 4 , , , 19613 5255 5 24 24 CD 19613 5255 6 fin fin NN 19613 5255 7 . . . 19613 5255 8 , , , 19613 5255 9 25 25 CD 19613 5255 10 fin fin NN 19613 5255 11 . . NNP 19613 5255 12 , , , 19613 5255 13 27 27 CD 19613 5255 14 init init NN 19613 5255 15 . . . 19613 5255 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5256 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5256 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5256 3 387 387 CD 19613 5256 4 : : : 19613 5256 5 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5256 6 not not RB 19613 5256 7 only only RB 19613 5256 8 accentuated accentuate VBD 19613 5256 9 the the DT 19613 5256 10 disagreement disagreement NN 19613 5256 11 of of IN 19613 5256 12 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5256 13 more more RBR 19613 5256 14 strongly strongly RB 19613 5256 15 than than IN 19613 5256 16 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5256 17 , , , 19613 5256 18 but but CC 19613 5256 19 insisted insist VBD 19613 5256 20 more more RBR 19613 5256 21 energetically energetically RB 19613 5256 22 than than IN 19613 5256 23 that that DT 19613 5256 24 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 5256 25 on on IN 19613 5256 26 the the DT 19613 5256 27 necessity necessity NN 19613 5256 28 of of IN 19613 5256 29 viewing view VBG 19613 5256 30 the the DT 19613 5256 31 practical practical JJ 19613 5256 32 fruits fruit NNS 19613 5256 33 of of IN 19613 5256 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5256 35 in in IN 19613 5256 36 life life NN 19613 5256 37 as as IN 19613 5256 38 a a DT 19613 5256 39 criterion criterion NN 19613 5256 40 ; ; : 19613 5256 41 see see VB 19613 5256 42 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5256 43 . . . 19613 5257 1 2 2 CD 19613 5257 2 , , , 19613 5257 3 3 3 CD 19613 5257 4 , , , 19613 5257 5 19 19 CD 19613 5257 6 , , , 19613 5257 7 25 25 CD 19613 5257 8 . . . 19613 5258 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5258 2 Socrates Socrates NNPS 19613 5258 3 still still RB 19613 5258 4 found find VBD 19613 5258 5 grace grace NN 19613 5258 6 in in IN 19613 5258 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5258 8 eyes eye NNS 19613 5258 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5258 10 c. c. NNP 19613 5258 11 3 3 CD 19613 5258 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5258 13 . . . 19613 5259 1 With with IN 19613 5259 2 regard regard NN 19613 5259 3 to to IN 19613 5259 4 other other JJ 19613 5259 5 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5259 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5259 7 listened listen VBD 19613 5259 8 to to IN 19613 5259 9 foolish foolish JJ 19613 5259 10 and and CC 19613 5259 11 slanderous slanderous JJ 19613 5259 12 gossip gossip NN 19613 5259 13 . . . 19613 5259 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5260 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5260 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5260 3 388 388 CD 19613 5260 4 : : : 19613 5260 5 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5260 6 . . . 19613 5261 1 13 13 CD 19613 5261 2 , , , 19613 5261 3 15 15 CD 19613 5261 4 fin fin NN 19613 5261 5 . . . 19613 5261 6 , , , 19613 5261 7 20 20 CD 19613 5261 8 . . . 19613 5262 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5262 2 also also RB 19613 5262 3 gave give VBD 19613 5262 4 credence credence NN 19613 5262 5 to to IN 19613 5262 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5262 7 because because IN 19613 5262 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5262 9 imparts impart VBZ 19613 5262 10 such such PDT 19613 5262 11 an an DT 19613 5262 12 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 5262 13 picture picture NN 19613 5262 14 of of IN 19613 5262 15 the the DT 19613 5262 16 creation creation NN 19613 5262 17 of of IN 19613 5262 18 the the DT 19613 5262 19 world world NN 19613 5262 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5262 21 c. c. NNP 19613 5263 1 29 29 CD 19613 5263 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5263 3 . . . 19613 5263 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5264 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5264 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5264 3 389 389 CD 19613 5264 4 : : : 19613 5264 5 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5264 6 . . . 19613 5265 1 12 12 CD 19613 5265 2 : : : 19613 5265 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5265 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5265 5 : : : 19613 5265 6 ta ta NNP 19613 5265 7 tês tês NNP 19613 5265 8 hêmeteras hêmeteras NNP 19613 5265 9 paideias paideias NNP 19613 5265 10 estin estin NNP 19613 5265 11 anôterô anôterô NNP 19613 5265 12 tês tês NNP 19613 5265 13 kosmikês kosmikês NNP 19613 5265 14 katalêpseôs katalêpseôs NNP 19613 5265 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5265 16 . . . 19613 5266 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5266 2 troubled trouble VBD 19613 5266 3 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5266 4 very very RB 19613 5266 5 little little JJ 19613 5266 6 with with IN 19613 5266 7 giving give VBG 19613 5266 8 demonstrations demonstration NNS 19613 5266 9 . . . 19613 5267 1 No no DT 19613 5267 2 other other JJ 19613 5267 3 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 5267 4 made make VBD 19613 5267 5 such such JJ 19613 5267 6 bold bold JJ 19613 5267 7 assertions assertion NNS 19613 5267 8 . . . 19613 5267 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5268 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5268 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5268 3 390 390 CD 19613 5268 4 : : : 19613 5268 5 See see VB 19613 5268 6 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5268 7 . . . 19613 5269 1 12 12 CD 19613 5269 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5269 3 p. p. NN 19613 5269 4 54 54 CD 19613 5269 5 fin fin NN 19613 5269 6 . . . 19613 5270 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 2 , , , 19613 5270 3 20 20 CD 19613 5270 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5270 5 p. p. NN 19613 5270 6 90 90 CD 19613 5270 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 8 , , , 19613 5270 9 25 25 CD 19613 5270 10 fin fin NN 19613 5270 11 . . . 19613 5270 12 , , , 19613 5270 13 26 26 CD 19613 5270 14 fin fin NN 19613 5270 15 . . . 19613 5270 16 , , , 19613 5270 17 29 29 CD 19613 5270 18 , , , 19613 5270 19 30 30 CD 19613 5270 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5270 21 p. p. NN 19613 5270 22 116 116 CD 19613 5270 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 24 , , , 19613 5270 25 13 13 CD 19613 5270 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5270 27 p. p. NN 19613 5270 28 62 62 CD 19613 5270 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 30 , , , 19613 5270 31 15 15 CD 19613 5270 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5270 33 p. p. NN 19613 5270 34 70 70 CD 19613 5270 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 36 , , , 19613 5270 37 36 36 CD 19613 5270 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5270 39 p. p. NN 19613 5270 40 142 142 CD 19613 5270 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 42 , , , 19613 5270 43 40 40 CD 19613 5270 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5270 45 p. p. NN 19613 5270 46 152 152 CD 19613 5270 47 sq sq NNP 19613 5270 48 . . NNP 19613 5270 49 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5270 50 . . . 19613 5271 1 The the DT 19613 5271 2 section section NN 19613 5271 3 cc cc NN 19613 5271 4 . . . 19613 5272 1 12 12 CD 19613 5272 2 - - SYM 19613 5272 3 15 15 CD 19613 5272 4 of of IN 19613 5272 5 the the DT 19613 5272 6 Oratio Oratio NNP 19613 5272 7 is be VBZ 19613 5272 8 very very RB 19613 5272 9 important important JJ 19613 5272 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5272 11 see see VB 19613 5272 12 also also RB 19613 5272 13 c. c. NNP 19613 5272 14 7 7 CD 19613 5272 15 ff ff NNP 19613 5272 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5272 17 ; ; : 19613 5272 18 for for IN 19613 5272 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5272 20 shows show VBZ 19613 5272 21 that that IN 19613 5272 22 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5272 23 denied deny VBD 19613 5272 24 the the DT 19613 5272 25 natural natural JJ 19613 5272 26 immortality immortality NN 19613 5272 27 of of IN 19613 5272 28 the the DT 19613 5272 29 soul soul NN 19613 5272 30 , , , 19613 5272 31 declared declare VBD 19613 5272 32 the the DT 19613 5272 33 soul soul NN 19613 5272 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5272 35 the the DT 19613 5272 36 material material NN 19613 5272 37 spirit spirit NN 19613 5272 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5272 39 to to TO 19613 5272 40 be be VB 19613 5272 41 something something NN 19613 5272 42 inherent inherent JJ 19613 5272 43 in in IN 19613 5272 44 all all DT 19613 5272 45 matter matter NN 19613 5272 46 , , , 19613 5272 47 and and CC 19613 5272 48 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5272 49 looked look VBD 19613 5272 50 on on IN 19613 5272 51 the the DT 19613 5272 52 distinction distinction NN 19613 5272 53 between between IN 19613 5272 54 men man NNS 19613 5272 55 and and CC 19613 5272 56 animals animal NNS 19613 5272 57 in in IN 19613 5272 58 respect respect NN 19613 5272 59 of of IN 19613 5272 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5272 61 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 5272 62 natural natural JJ 19613 5272 63 constitution constitution NN 19613 5272 64 as as IN 19613 5272 65 only only RB 19613 5272 66 one one CD 19613 5272 67 of of IN 19613 5272 68 degree degree NN 19613 5272 69 . . . 19613 5273 1 According accord VBG 19613 5273 2 to to IN 19613 5273 3 this this DT 19613 5273 4 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 5273 5 the the DT 19613 5273 6 dignity dignity NN 19613 5273 7 of of IN 19613 5273 8 man man NN 19613 5273 9 does do VBZ 19613 5273 10 not not RB 19613 5273 11 consist consist VB 19613 5273 12 in in IN 19613 5273 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5273 14 natural natural JJ 19613 5273 15 endowments endowment NNS 19613 5273 16 : : : 19613 5273 17 but but CC 19613 5273 18 in in IN 19613 5273 19 the the DT 19613 5273 20 union union NN 19613 5273 21 of of IN 19613 5273 22 the the DT 19613 5273 23 human human JJ 19613 5273 24 soul soul NN 19613 5273 25 with with IN 19613 5273 26 the the DT 19613 5273 27 divine divine JJ 19613 5273 28 spirit spirit NN 19613 5273 29 , , , 19613 5273 30 for for IN 19613 5273 31 which which WDT 19613 5273 32 union union NN 19613 5273 33 indeed indeed RB 19613 5273 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5273 35 was be VBD 19613 5273 36 planned plan VBN 19613 5273 37 . . . 19613 5274 1 But but CC 19613 5274 2 , , , 19613 5274 3 in in IN 19613 5274 4 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5274 5 's 's POS 19613 5274 6 opinion opinion NN 19613 5274 7 , , , 19613 5274 8 man man NN 19613 5274 9 lost lose VBN 19613 5274 10 this this DT 19613 5274 11 union union NN 19613 5274 12 by by IN 19613 5274 13 falling fall VBG 19613 5274 14 under under IN 19613 5274 15 the the DT 19613 5274 16 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 5274 17 of of IN 19613 5274 18 the the DT 19613 5274 19 demons demon NNS 19613 5274 20 . . . 19613 5275 1 The the DT 19613 5275 2 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5275 3 of of IN 19613 5275 4 God God NNP 19613 5275 5 has have VBZ 19613 5275 6 left leave VBN 19613 5275 7 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5275 8 , , , 19613 5275 9 and and CC 19613 5275 10 consequently consequently RB 19613 5275 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5275 12 has have VBZ 19613 5275 13 fallen fall VBN 19613 5275 14 back back RB 19613 5275 15 to to IN 19613 5275 16 the the DT 19613 5275 17 level level NN 19613 5275 18 of of IN 19613 5275 19 the the DT 19613 5275 20 beasts beast NNS 19613 5275 21 . . . 19613 5276 1 So so CC 19613 5276 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5276 3 is be VBZ 19613 5276 4 man man NN 19613 5276 5 's 's POS 19613 5276 6 task task NN 19613 5276 7 to to TO 19613 5276 8 unite unite VB 19613 5276 9 the the DT 19613 5276 10 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5276 11 again again RB 19613 5276 12 with with IN 19613 5276 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5276 14 , , , 19613 5276 15 and and CC 19613 5276 16 thereby thereby RB 19613 5276 17 recover recover VBP 19613 5276 18 that that IN 19613 5276 19 religious religious JJ 19613 5276 20 principle principle NN 19613 5276 21 on on IN 19613 5276 22 which which WDT 19613 5276 23 all all DT 19613 5276 24 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 5276 25 and and CC 19613 5276 26 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5276 27 rest rest NN 19613 5276 28 . . . 19613 5277 1 This this DT 19613 5277 2 anthropology anthropology NN 19613 5277 3 is be VBZ 19613 5277 4 opposed opposed JJ 19613 5277 5 to to IN 19613 5277 6 that that DT 19613 5277 7 of of IN 19613 5277 8 the the DT 19613 5277 9 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5277 10 and and CC 19613 5277 11 related relate VBN 19613 5277 12 to to IN 19613 5277 13 the the DT 19613 5277 14 " " `` 19613 5277 15 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5277 16 " " '' 19613 5277 17 theory theory NN 19613 5277 18 . . . 19613 5278 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5278 2 follows follow VBZ 19613 5278 3 from from IN 19613 5278 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5278 5 that that DT 19613 5278 6 man man NN 19613 5278 7 , , , 19613 5278 8 in in IN 19613 5278 9 order order NN 19613 5278 10 to to TO 19613 5278 11 reach reach VB 19613 5278 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5278 13 destination destination NN 19613 5278 14 , , , 19613 5278 15 must must MD 19613 5278 16 raise raise VB 19613 5278 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5278 18 above above IN 19613 5278 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5278 20 natural natural JJ 19613 5278 21 endowment endowment NN 19613 5278 22 ; ; : 19613 5278 23 see see NNP 19613 5278 24 c. c. NNP 19613 5278 25 15 15 CD 19613 5278 26 : : : 19613 5278 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5278 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5278 29 : : : 19613 5278 30 anthrôpon anthrôpon IN 19613 5278 31 legô legô JJ 19613 5278 32 ton ton NN 19613 5278 33 porrô porrô JJ 19613 5278 34 men man NNS 19613 5278 35 anthrôptêtos anthrôptêtos NNP 19613 5278 36 pros pro NNS 19613 5278 37 auton auton NNP 19613 5278 38 de de NNP 19613 5278 39 ton ton NNP 19613 5278 40 Theon Theon NNP 19613 5278 41 kechôrêkota kechôrêkota NNP 19613 5278 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5278 43 . . . 19613 5279 1 But but CC 19613 5279 2 with with IN 19613 5279 3 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5279 4 this this DT 19613 5279 5 conception conception NN 19613 5279 6 is be VBZ 19613 5279 7 burdened burden VBN 19613 5279 8 with with IN 19613 5279 9 radical radical JJ 19613 5279 10 inconsistency inconsistency NN 19613 5279 11 ; ; : 19613 5279 12 for for IN 19613 5279 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5279 14 assumes assume VBZ 19613 5279 15 that that IN 19613 5279 16 the the DT 19613 5279 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5279 18 reunites reunite VBZ 19613 5279 19 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5279 20 with with IN 19613 5279 21 every every DT 19613 5279 22 man man NN 19613 5279 23 who who WP 19613 5279 24 rightly rightly RB 19613 5279 25 uses use VBZ 19613 5279 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5279 27 freedom freedom NN 19613 5279 28 , , , 19613 5279 29 and and CC 19613 5279 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5279 31 thinks think VBZ 19613 5279 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5279 33 still still RB 19613 5279 34 possible possible JJ 19613 5279 35 for for IN 19613 5279 36 every every DT 19613 5279 37 person person NN 19613 5279 38 to to TO 19613 5279 39 use use VB 19613 5279 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5279 41 freedom freedom NN 19613 5279 42 aright aright NN 19613 5279 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5279 44 11 11 CD 19613 5279 45 fin fin NN 19613 5279 46 . . . 19613 5279 47 , , , 19613 5279 48 13 13 CD 19613 5279 49 fin fin NN 19613 5279 50 . . NNP 19613 5279 51 , , , 19613 5279 52 15 15 CD 19613 5279 53 fin fin NN 19613 5279 54 . . . 19613 5279 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5280 1 So so CC 19613 5280 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5280 3 is be VBZ 19613 5280 4 after after RB 19613 5280 5 all all RB 19613 5280 6 a a DT 19613 5280 7 mere mere JJ 19613 5280 8 assertion assertion NN 19613 5280 9 that that IN 19613 5280 10 the the DT 19613 5280 11 natural natural JJ 19613 5280 12 man man NN 19613 5280 13 is be VBZ 19613 5280 14 only only RB 19613 5280 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5280 16 from from IN 19613 5280 17 the the DT 19613 5280 18 beast beast NN 19613 5280 19 by by IN 19613 5280 20 speech speech NN 19613 5280 21 . . . 19613 5281 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5281 2 is be VBZ 19613 5281 3 also also RB 19613 5281 4 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5281 5 from from IN 19613 5281 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5281 7 by by IN 19613 5281 8 freedom freedom NN 19613 5281 9 . . . 19613 5282 1 And and CC 19613 5282 2 further far RBR 19613 5282 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5282 4 is be VBZ 19613 5282 5 only only RB 19613 5282 6 in in IN 19613 5282 7 appearance appearance NN 19613 5282 8 that that IN 19613 5282 9 the the DT 19613 5282 10 blessing blessing NN 19613 5282 11 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 5282 12 in in IN 19613 5282 13 the the DT 19613 5282 14 " " `` 19613 5282 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5282 16 " " '' 19613 5282 17 is be VBZ 19613 5282 18 a a DT 19613 5282 19 _ _ NNP 19613 5282 20 donum donum NN 19613 5282 21 superadditum superadditum NN 19613 5282 22 et et NNP 19613 5282 23 supernaturale supernaturale NNP 19613 5282 24 _ _ NNP 19613 5282 25 . . . 19613 5283 1 For for IN 19613 5283 2 if if IN 19613 5283 3 a a DT 19613 5283 4 proper proper JJ 19613 5283 5 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 19613 5283 6 use use NN 19613 5283 7 of of IN 19613 5283 8 freedom freedom NN 19613 5283 9 infallibly infallibly RB 19613 5283 10 leads lead VBZ 19613 5283 11 to to IN 19613 5283 12 the the DT 19613 5283 13 return return NN 19613 5283 14 of of IN 19613 5283 15 the the DT 19613 5283 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5283 17 , , , 19613 5283 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5283 19 is be VBZ 19613 5283 20 evident evident JJ 19613 5283 21 that that IN 19613 5283 22 the the DT 19613 5283 23 decision decision NN 19613 5283 24 and and CC 19613 5283 25 consequently consequently RB 19613 5283 26 the the DT 19613 5283 27 realisation realisation NN 19613 5283 28 of of IN 19613 5283 29 man man NN 19613 5283 30 's 's POS 19613 5283 31 destination destination NN 19613 5283 32 depend depend VBP 19613 5283 33 on on IN 19613 5283 34 human human JJ 19613 5283 35 freedom freedom NN 19613 5283 36 . . . 19613 5284 1 That that RB 19613 5284 2 is is RB 19613 5284 3 , , , 19613 5284 4 however however RB 19613 5284 5 , , , 19613 5284 6 the the DT 19613 5284 7 proposition proposition NN 19613 5284 8 which which WDT 19613 5284 9 all all PDT 19613 5284 10 the the DT 19613 5284 11 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5284 12 maintained maintain VBD 19613 5284 13 . . . 19613 5285 1 But but CC 19613 5285 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 5285 3 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5285 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5285 5 in in IN 19613 5285 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5285 7 latter latter JJ 19613 5285 8 days day NNS 19613 5285 9 seems seem VBZ 19613 5285 10 to to TO 19613 5285 11 have have VB 19613 5285 12 observed observe VBN 19613 5285 13 the the DT 19613 5285 14 inconsistency inconsistency NN 19613 5285 15 in in IN 19613 5285 16 which which WDT 19613 5285 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5285 18 had have VBD 19613 5285 19 become become VBN 19613 5285 20 involved involved JJ 19613 5285 21 and and CC 19613 5285 22 to to TO 19613 5285 23 have have VB 19613 5285 24 solved solve VBN 19613 5285 25 the the DT 19613 5285 26 problem problem NN 19613 5285 27 in in IN 19613 5285 28 the the DT 19613 5285 29 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 5285 30 , , , 19613 5285 31 that that RB 19613 5285 32 is is RB 19613 5285 33 , , , 19613 5285 34 the the DT 19613 5285 35 religious religious JJ 19613 5285 36 sense sense NN 19613 5285 37 . . . 19613 5286 1 In in IN 19613 5286 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5286 3 eyes eye NNS 19613 5286 4 , , , 19613 5286 5 of of IN 19613 5286 6 course course NN 19613 5286 7 , , , 19613 5286 8 the the DT 19613 5286 9 ordinary ordinary JJ 19613 5286 10 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5286 11 is be VBZ 19613 5286 12 a a DT 19613 5286 13 useless useless JJ 19613 5286 14 and and CC 19613 5286 15 pernicious pernicious JJ 19613 5286 16 art art NN 19613 5286 17 ; ; : 19613 5286 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5286 19 make make VBP 19613 5286 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5286 21 own own JJ 19613 5286 22 opinions opinion NNS 19613 5286 23 laws law NNS 19613 5286 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5286 25 c. c. NNP 19613 5286 26 27 27 CD 19613 5286 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5286 28 ; ; : 19613 5286 29 whereas whereas IN 19613 5286 30 of of IN 19613 5286 31 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5286 32 the the DT 19613 5286 33 following follow VBG 19613 5286 34 holds hold VBZ 19613 5286 35 good good JJ 19613 5286 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5286 37 c. c. NNP 19613 5286 38 32 32 CD 19613 5286 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5286 40 : : : 19613 5286 41 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5286 42 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5286 43 : : : 19613 5286 44 logou logou NNP 19613 5286 45 tou tou NNP 19613 5286 46 dêmosiou dêmosiou NNP 19613 5286 47 kai kai NNP 19613 5286 48 epigeiou epigeiou NNP 19613 5286 49 kechôrismenoi kechôrismenoi NNP 19613 5286 50 kai kai NNP 19613 5286 51 peithomenoi peithomenoi NNP 19613 5286 52 theou theou NNP 19613 5286 53 parangelmasi parangelmasi NNP 19613 5286 54 kai kai NNP 19613 5286 55 nomô nomô NNP 19613 5286 56 patros patros NNP 19613 5286 57 aphtharsias aphtharsias NNP 19613 5286 58 hepomenoi hepomenoi NNP 19613 5286 59 , , , 19613 5286 60 pan pan VBP 19613 5286 61 to to IN 19613 5286 62 en en NNP 19613 5286 63 doxê doxê NNP 19613 5286 64 keimenon keimenon NNP 19613 5286 65 anthrôpinê anthrôpinê NNP 19613 5286 66 paraitoumetha paraitoumetha NNP 19613 5286 67 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5286 68 . . . 19613 5286 69 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5287 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5287 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5287 3 391 391 CD 19613 5287 4 : : : 19613 5287 5 C. C. NNP 19613 5287 6 31 31 CD 19613 5287 7 . . . 19613 5288 1 init init NNP 19613 5288 2 . . . 19613 5289 1 : : : 19613 5289 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5289 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5289 4 : : : 19613 5289 5 hê hê NNP 19613 5289 6 hêmetera hêmetera NNP 19613 5289 7 philosophia philosophia NNP 19613 5289 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5289 9 . . . 19613 5290 1 32 32 CD 19613 5290 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5290 3 p. p. NN 19613 5290 4 128 128 CD 19613 5290 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5290 6 : : : 19613 5290 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5290 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5290 9 : : : 19613 5290 10 hoi hoi NNP 19613 5290 11 boulomenoi boulomenoi NNP 19613 5290 12 philosophein philosophein NNP 19613 5290 13 par par NNP 19613 5290 14 ' ' POS 19613 5290 15 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 5290 16 anthrôpoi anthrôpoi NNP 19613 5290 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5290 18 . . . 19613 5291 1 In in IN 19613 5291 2 c. c. NNP 19613 5291 3 33 33 CD 19613 5291 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5291 5 p. p. NN 19613 5291 6 130 130 CD 19613 5291 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5291 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 5291 9 women woman NNS 19613 5291 10 are be VBP 19613 5291 11 designated designate VBN 19613 5291 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5291 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5291 14 : : : 19613 5291 15 hai hai VB 19613 5291 16 par par NNP 19613 5291 17 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 5291 18 philosophousai philosophousai NNP 19613 5291 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5291 20 . . . 19613 5292 1 C. C. NNP 19613 5292 2 35 35 CD 19613 5292 3 : : : 19613 5292 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5292 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5292 6 : : : 19613 5292 7 hê hê VB 19613 5292 8 kath kath NNP 19613 5292 9 ' ' POS 19613 5292 10 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 5292 11 barbaros barbaros NNP 19613 5292 12 philosophia philosophia NNP 19613 5292 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5292 14 . . . 19613 5293 1 40 40 CD 19613 5293 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5293 3 p. p. NN 19613 5293 4 152 152 CD 19613 5293 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5293 6 : : : 19613 5293 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5293 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5293 9 : : : 19613 5293 10 hoi hoi NNP 19613 5293 11 kata kata NN 19613 5293 12 Môusea Môusea NNP 19613 5293 13 kai kai NNP 19613 5293 14 homoiôs homoiôs NNP 19613 5293 15 autô autô NNP 19613 5293 16 philosophountes philosophountes NNP 19613 5293 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5293 18 . . . 19613 5294 1 42 42 CD 19613 5294 2 : : : 19613 5294 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5294 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5294 5 : : : 19613 5294 6 ho ho NNP 19613 5294 7 kata kata NNP 19613 5294 8 barbarous barbarous JJ 19613 5294 9 philosophôn philosophôn NN 19613 5294 10 Tatianos Tatianos NNP 19613 5294 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5294 12 . . . 19613 5295 1 The the DT 19613 5295 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5295 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5295 4 : : : 19613 5295 5 dogmata dogmata NN 19613 5295 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5295 7 of of IN 19613 5295 8 the the DT 19613 5295 9 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5295 10 : : : 19613 5295 11 c. c. NN 19613 5295 12 1 1 CD 19613 5295 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5295 14 p. p. NN 19613 5295 15 2 2 CD 19613 5295 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5295 17 , , , 19613 5295 18 12 12 CD 19613 5295 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5295 20 p. p. NN 19613 5295 21 58 58 CD 19613 5295 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5295 23 , , , 19613 5295 24 19 19 CD 19613 5295 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5295 26 p. p. NN 19613 5295 27 86 86 CD 19613 5295 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5295 29 , , , 19613 5295 30 24 24 CD 19613 5295 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5295 32 p. p. NN 19613 5295 33 102 102 CD 19613 5295 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5295 35 , , , 19613 5295 36 27 27 CD 19613 5295 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5295 38 p. p. NN 19613 5295 39 108 108 CD 19613 5295 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5295 41 , , , 19613 5295 42 35 35 CD 19613 5295 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5295 44 p. p. NN 19613 5295 45 138 138 CD 19613 5295 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5295 47 , , , 19613 5295 48 40 40 CD 19613 5295 49 , , , 19613 5295 50 42 42 CD 19613 5295 51 . . . 19613 5296 1 But but CC 19613 5296 2 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5296 3 pretty pretty RB 19613 5296 4 frequently frequently RB 19613 5296 5 calls call VBZ 19613 5296 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5296 7 " " '' 19613 5296 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5296 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5296 10 : : : 19613 5296 11 hê hê VB 19613 5296 12 hêmetera hêmetera NNP 19613 5296 13 paideia paideia NNP 19613 5296 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5296 15 " " '' 19613 5296 16 , , , 19613 5296 17 once once RB 19613 5296 18 also also RB 19613 5296 19 " " `` 19613 5296 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5296 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5296 22 : : : 19613 5296 23 nomothesia nomothesia NNP 19613 5296 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5296 25 " " '' 19613 5296 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5296 27 12 12 CD 19613 5296 28 ; ; : 19613 5296 29 cf cf NN 19613 5296 30 . . . 19613 5297 1 40 40 CD 19613 5297 2 : : : 19613 5297 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5297 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5297 5 : : : 19613 5297 6 hoi hoi NNP 19613 5297 7 hêmeteroi hêmeteroi JJ 19613 5297 8 nomoi nomoi NNP 19613 5297 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5297 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5297 11 , , , 19613 5297 12 and and CC 19613 5297 13 often often RB 19613 5297 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5297 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5297 16 : : : 19613 5297 17 politeia politeia NN 19613 5297 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5297 19 . . . 19613 5297 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5298 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5298 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5298 3 392 392 CD 19613 5298 4 : : : 19613 5298 5 See see VB 19613 5298 6 , , , 19613 5298 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 5298 8 , , , 19613 5298 9 c. c. NNP 19613 5298 10 29 29 CD 19613 5298 11 fin fin NN 19613 5298 12 . . . 19613 5299 1 : : : 19613 5299 2 the the DT 19613 5299 3 Christian christian JJ 19613 5299 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5299 5 gives give VBZ 19613 5299 6 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5299 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5299 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5299 9 : : : 19613 5299 10 ouch ouch NNP 19613 5299 11 hoper hoper NNP 19613 5299 12 mê mê NNP 19613 5299 13 elabomen elabomen NNP 19613 5299 14 , , , 19613 5299 15 all all DT 19613 5299 16 ' ' `` 19613 5299 17 hoper hoper NNP 19613 5299 18 labontes labontes NNPS 19613 5299 19 hupo hupo NNP 19613 5299 20 tês tês NNP 19613 5299 21 planês planês NNP 19613 5299 22 echein echein NNP 19613 5299 23 ekoluthêmen ekoluthêmen NNP 19613 5299 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5299 25 . . . 19613 5299 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5300 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5300 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5300 3 393 393 CD 19613 5300 4 : : : 19613 5300 5 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5300 6 gave give VBD 19613 5300 7 still still RB 19613 5300 8 stronger strong JJR 19613 5300 9 expression expression NN 19613 5300 10 than than IN 19613 5300 11 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5300 12 to to IN 19613 5300 13 the the DT 19613 5300 14 opinion opinion NN 19613 5300 15 that that IN 19613 5300 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5300 17 is be VBZ 19613 5300 18 the the DT 19613 5300 19 demons demon NNS 19613 5300 20 who who WP 19613 5300 21 have have VBP 19613 5300 22 misled mislead VBN 19613 5300 23 men man NNS 19613 5300 24 and and CC 19613 5300 25 rule rule VB 19613 5300 26 the the DT 19613 5300 27 world world NN 19613 5300 28 , , , 19613 5300 29 and and CC 19613 5300 30 that that IN 19613 5300 31 revelation revelation NN 19613 5300 32 through through IN 19613 5300 33 the the DT 19613 5300 34 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5300 35 is be VBZ 19613 5300 36 opposed oppose VBN 19613 5300 37 to to IN 19613 5300 38 this this DT 19613 5300 39 demon demon NN 19613 5300 40 rule rule NN 19613 5300 41 ; ; : 19613 5300 42 see see VB 19613 5300 43 c. c. NNP 19613 5300 44 7 7 CD 19613 5300 45 ff ff NNP 19613 5300 46 . . . 19613 5301 1 The the DT 19613 5301 2 demons demon NNS 19613 5301 3 have have VBP 19613 5301 4 fixed fix VBN 19613 5301 5 the the DT 19613 5301 6 laws law NNS 19613 5301 7 of of IN 19613 5301 8 death death NN 19613 5301 9 ; ; : 19613 5301 10 see see VB 19613 5301 11 c. c. NNP 19613 5301 12 15 15 CD 19613 5301 13 fin fin NN 19613 5301 14 . . . 19613 5302 1 and and CC 19613 5302 2 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 5302 3 . . . 19613 5302 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5303 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5303 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5303 3 394 394 CD 19613 5303 4 : : : 19613 5303 5 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5303 6 also also RB 19613 5303 7 can can MD 19613 5303 8 not not RB 19613 5303 9 at at IN 19613 5303 10 bottom bottom JJ 19613 5303 11 distinguish distinguish NN 19613 5303 12 between between IN 19613 5303 13 revelation revelation NN 19613 5303 14 through through IN 19613 5303 15 the the DT 19613 5303 16 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5303 17 and and CC 19613 5303 18 through through IN 19613 5303 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5303 20 . . . 19613 5304 1 See see VB 19613 5304 2 the the DT 19613 5304 3 description description NN 19613 5304 4 of of IN 19613 5304 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5304 6 conversion conversion NN 19613 5304 7 in in IN 19613 5304 8 c. c. NNP 19613 5304 9 29 29 CD 19613 5304 10 . . . 19613 5304 11 where where WRB 19613 5304 12 only only RB 19613 5304 13 the the DT 19613 5304 14 Old Old NNP 19613 5304 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5304 16 writings writing NNS 19613 5304 17 are be VBP 19613 5304 18 named name VBN 19613 5304 19 , , , 19613 5304 20 and and CC 19613 5304 21 c. c. NNP 19613 5304 22 13 13 CD 19613 5304 23 fin fin NN 19613 5304 24 . . . 19613 5304 25 , , , 19613 5304 26 20 20 CD 19613 5304 27 fin fin NN 19613 5304 28 .. .. NFP 19613 5304 29 12 12 CD 19613 5304 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5304 31 p. p. NN 19613 5304 32 54 54 CD 19613 5304 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5304 34 etc etc FW 19613 5304 35 . . . 19613 5304 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5305 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5305 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5305 3 395 395 CD 19613 5305 4 : : : 19613 5305 5 Knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5305 6 and and CC 19613 5305 7 life life NN 19613 5305 8 appear appear VBP 19613 5305 9 in in IN 19613 5305 10 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5305 11 most most RBS 19613 5305 12 closely closely RB 19613 5305 13 connected connected JJ 19613 5305 14 . . . 19613 5306 1 See see VB 19613 5306 2 , , , 19613 5306 3 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 5306 4 , , , 19613 5306 5 c. c. NNP 19613 5306 6 13 13 CD 19613 5306 7 init init NN 19613 5306 8 . . . 19613 5307 1 : : : 19613 5307 2 " " `` 19613 5307 3 In in IN 19613 5307 4 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5307 5 the the DT 19613 5307 6 soul soul NN 19613 5307 7 is be VBZ 19613 5307 8 not not RB 19613 5307 9 immortal immortal JJ 19613 5307 10 , , , 19613 5307 11 but but CC 19613 5307 12 mortal mortal JJ 19613 5307 13 ; ; : 19613 5307 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5307 15 is be VBZ 19613 5307 16 also also RB 19613 5307 17 possible possible JJ 19613 5307 18 , , , 19613 5307 19 however however RB 19613 5307 20 , , , 19613 5307 21 that that IN 19613 5307 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5307 23 may may MD 19613 5307 24 not not RB 19613 5307 25 die die VB 19613 5307 26 . . . 19613 5308 1 If if IN 19613 5308 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5308 3 has have VBZ 19613 5308 4 not not RB 19613 5308 5 attained attain VBN 19613 5308 6 a a DT 19613 5308 7 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5308 8 of of IN 19613 5308 9 that that DT 19613 5308 10 truth truth NN 19613 5308 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5308 12 dies die VBZ 19613 5308 13 and and CC 19613 5308 14 is be VBZ 19613 5308 15 dissolved dissolve VBN 19613 5308 16 with with IN 19613 5308 17 the the DT 19613 5308 18 body body NN 19613 5308 19 ; ; : 19613 5308 20 but but CC 19613 5308 21 later later RBR 19613 5308 22 , , , 19613 5308 23 at at IN 19613 5308 24 the the DT 19613 5308 25 end end NN 19613 5308 26 of of IN 19613 5308 27 the the DT 19613 5308 28 world world NN 19613 5308 29 , , , 19613 5308 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5308 31 will will MD 19613 5308 32 rise rise VB 19613 5308 33 again again RB 19613 5308 34 with with IN 19613 5308 35 the the DT 19613 5308 36 body body NN 19613 5308 37 in in IN 19613 5308 38 order order NN 19613 5308 39 to to TO 19613 5308 40 receive receive VB 19613 5308 41 death death NN 19613 5308 42 in in IN 19613 5308 43 endless endless JJ 19613 5308 44 duration duration NN 19613 5308 45 as as IN 19613 5308 46 a a DT 19613 5308 47 punishment punishment NN 19613 5308 48 . . . 19613 5309 1 On on IN 19613 5309 2 the the DT 19613 5309 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 5309 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5309 5 does do VBZ 19613 5309 6 not not RB 19613 5309 7 die die VB 19613 5309 8 , , , 19613 5309 9 though though IN 19613 5309 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5309 11 is be VBZ 19613 5309 12 dissolved dissolve VBN 19613 5309 13 for for IN 19613 5309 14 a a DT 19613 5309 15 time time NN 19613 5309 16 , , , 19613 5309 17 if if IN 19613 5309 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5309 19 is be VBZ 19613 5309 20 equipped equip VBN 19613 5309 21 with with IN 19613 5309 22 the the DT 19613 5309 23 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5309 24 of of IN 19613 5309 25 God God NNP 19613 5309 26 . . . 19613 5309 27 " " '' 19613 5309 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5310 3 396 396 CD 19613 5310 4 : : : 19613 5310 5 Barbarian Barbarian NNP 19613 5310 6 : : : 19613 5310 7 the the DT 19613 5310 8 Christian christian JJ 19613 5310 9 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5310 10 are be VBP 19613 5310 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 13 : : : 19613 5310 14 ta ta NNP 19613 5310 15 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5310 16 barbarôn barbarôn NNP 19613 5310 17 dogmata dogmata NNP 19613 5310 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 20 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 21 1 1 CD 19613 5310 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 23 : : : 19613 5310 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 26 : : : 19613 5310 27 kath kath NNP 19613 5310 28 ' ' POS 19613 5310 29 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 5310 30 barbaros barbaros NNP 19613 5310 31 philosophia philosophia NNP 19613 5310 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 34 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 35 35 35 CD 19613 5310 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 37 ; ; : 19613 5310 38 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 39 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 40 : : : 19613 5310 41 hê hê NNP 19613 5310 42 barbarikê barbarikê NNP 19613 5310 43 nomothesia nomothesia NNP 19613 5310 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 46 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 47 12 12 CD 19613 5310 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 49 ; ; : 19613 5310 50 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 51 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 52 : : : 19613 5310 53 graphai graphai NNP 19613 5310 54 barbarikai barbarikai NNP 19613 5310 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 56 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 57 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 58 29 29 CD 19613 5310 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 60 ; ; : 19613 5310 61 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 62 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 63 : : : 19613 5310 64 kainotomein kainotomein NNP 19613 5310 65 ta ta NNP 19613 5310 66 barbarôn barbarôn NNP 19613 5310 67 dogmata dogmata NNP 19613 5310 68 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 69 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 70 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 71 35 35 CD 19613 5310 72 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 73 ; ; : 19613 5310 74 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 75 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 76 : : : 19613 5310 77 ho ho NNP 19613 5310 78 kata kata NNP 19613 5310 79 barbarous barbarous JJ 19613 5310 80 philosophôn philosophôn NN 19613 5310 81 Tatianos Tatianos NNP 19613 5310 82 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 83 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 84 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 85 42 42 CD 19613 5310 86 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 87 ; ; : 19613 5310 88 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5310 89 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5310 90 : : : 19613 5310 91 Môusês Môusês NNP 19613 5310 92 pasês pasês NNP 19613 5310 93 barbarou barbarou JJ 19613 5310 94 philosophias philosophias NNP 19613 5310 95 archêgos archêgo NNS 19613 5310 96 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5310 97 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5310 98 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 99 31 31 CD 19613 5310 100 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5310 101 ; ; : 19613 5310 102 see see VB 19613 5310 103 also also RB 19613 5310 104 c. c. NNP 19613 5310 105 30 30 CD 19613 5310 106 , , , 19613 5310 107 32 32 CD 19613 5310 108 . . . 19613 5311 1 In in IN 19613 5311 2 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5311 3 's 's POS 19613 5311 4 view view NN 19613 5311 5 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 5311 6 and and CC 19613 5311 7 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5311 8 are be VBP 19613 5311 9 the the DT 19613 5311 10 decisive decisive JJ 19613 5311 11 contrasts contrast NNS 19613 5311 12 in in IN 19613 5311 13 history history NN 19613 5311 14 . . . 19613 5311 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5312 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5312 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5312 3 397 397 CD 19613 5312 4 : : : 19613 5312 5 See see VB 19613 5312 6 the the DT 19613 5312 7 proof proof NN 19613 5312 8 from from IN 19613 5312 9 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 5312 10 , , , 19613 5312 11 c. c. NNP 19613 5312 12 31 31 CD 19613 5312 13 ff ff NNP 19613 5312 14 . . . 19613 5312 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5313 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5313 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5313 3 398 398 CD 19613 5313 4 : : : 19613 5313 5 C. C. NNP 19613 5313 6 30 30 CD 19613 5313 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5313 8 p. p. NN 19613 5313 9 114 114 CD 19613 5313 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5313 11 : : : 19613 5313 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5313 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5313 14 : : : 19613 5313 15 toutôn toutôn NNS 19613 5313 16 oun oun NNP 19613 5313 17 tên tên NNP 19613 5313 18 katalêpsin katalêpsin NNP 19613 5313 19 memuêmenos memuêmenos NNP 19613 5313 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5313 21 . . . 19613 5313 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5314 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5314 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5314 3 399 399 CD 19613 5314 4 : : : 19613 5314 5 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5314 6 's 's POS 19613 5314 7 own own JJ 19613 5314 8 confession confession NN 19613 5314 9 is be VBZ 19613 5314 10 very very RB 19613 5314 11 important important JJ 19613 5314 12 here here RB 19613 5314 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5314 14 c. c. NNP 19613 5314 15 26 26 CD 19613 5314 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5314 17 : : : 19613 5314 18 " " `` 19613 5314 19 Whilst whilst IN 19613 5314 20 I -PRON- PRP 19613 5314 21 was be VBD 19613 5314 22 reflecting reflect VBG 19613 5314 23 on on IN 19613 5314 24 what what WP 19613 5314 25 was be VBD 19613 5314 26 good good JJ 19613 5314 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5314 28 happened happen VBD 19613 5314 29 that that IN 19613 5314 30 there there EX 19613 5314 31 fell fall VBD 19613 5314 32 into into IN 19613 5314 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5314 34 hands hand NNS 19613 5314 35 certain certain JJ 19613 5314 36 writings writing NNS 19613 5314 37 of of IN 19613 5314 38 the the DT 19613 5314 39 barbarians barbarian NNS 19613 5314 40 , , , 19613 5314 41 too too RB 19613 5314 42 old old JJ 19613 5314 43 to to TO 19613 5314 44 be be VB 19613 5314 45 compared compare VBN 19613 5314 46 with with IN 19613 5314 47 the the DT 19613 5314 48 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5314 49 of of IN 19613 5314 50 the the DT 19613 5314 51 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5314 52 , , , 19613 5314 53 too too RB 19613 5314 54 divine divine JJ 19613 5314 55 to to TO 19613 5314 56 be be VB 19613 5314 57 compared compare VBN 19613 5314 58 with with IN 19613 5314 59 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5314 60 errors error NNS 19613 5314 61 . . . 19613 5315 1 And and CC 19613 5315 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5315 3 chanced chance VBD 19613 5315 4 that that IN 19613 5315 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5315 6 convinced convince VBD 19613 5315 7 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5315 8 through through IN 19613 5315 9 the the DT 19613 5315 10 plainness plainness NN 19613 5315 11 of of IN 19613 5315 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5315 13 expressions expression NNS 19613 5315 14 , , , 19613 5315 15 through through IN 19613 5315 16 the the DT 19613 5315 17 unartificial unartificial JJ 19613 5315 18 nature nature NN 19613 5315 19 of of IN 19613 5315 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5315 21 language language NN 19613 5315 22 , , , 19613 5315 23 through through IN 19613 5315 24 the the DT 19613 5315 25 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 5315 26 representation representation NN 19613 5315 27 of of IN 19613 5315 28 the the DT 19613 5315 29 creation creation NN 19613 5315 30 of of IN 19613 5315 31 the the DT 19613 5315 32 world world NN 19613 5315 33 , , , 19613 5315 34 through through IN 19613 5315 35 the the DT 19613 5315 36 prediction prediction NN 19613 5315 37 of of IN 19613 5315 38 the the DT 19613 5315 39 future future NN 19613 5315 40 , , , 19613 5315 41 the the DT 19613 5315 42 excellence excellence NN 19613 5315 43 of of IN 19613 5315 44 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5315 45 precepts precept NNS 19613 5315 46 , , , 19613 5315 47 and and CC 19613 5315 48 the the DT 19613 5315 49 summing sum VBG 19613 5315 50 up up RP 19613 5315 51 of of IN 19613 5315 52 all all DT 19613 5315 53 kinds kind NNS 19613 5315 54 under under IN 19613 5315 55 one one CD 19613 5315 56 head head NN 19613 5315 57 . . . 19613 5316 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5316 2 soul soul NN 19613 5316 3 was be VBD 19613 5316 4 instructed instruct VBN 19613 5316 5 by by IN 19613 5316 6 God God NNP 19613 5316 7 and and CC 19613 5316 8 I -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 9 recognised recognise VBD 19613 5316 10 that that IN 19613 5316 11 those those DT 19613 5316 12 Greek greek JJ 19613 5316 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5316 14 lead lead VBP 19613 5316 15 to to IN 19613 5316 16 perdition perdition NN 19613 5316 17 , , , 19613 5316 18 whereas whereas IN 19613 5316 19 the the DT 19613 5316 20 others other NNS 19613 5316 21 abolish abolish VBP 19613 5316 22 the the DT 19613 5316 23 slavery slavery NN 19613 5316 24 to to TO 19613 5316 25 which which WDT 19613 5316 26 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 27 are be VBP 19613 5316 28 subjected subject VBN 19613 5316 29 in in IN 19613 5316 30 the the DT 19613 5316 31 world world NN 19613 5316 32 , , , 19613 5316 33 and and CC 19613 5316 34 rescue rescue VB 19613 5316 35 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 36 from from IN 19613 5316 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5316 38 many many JJ 19613 5316 39 lords lord NNS 19613 5316 40 and and CC 19613 5316 41 tyrants tyrant NNS 19613 5316 42 , , , 19613 5316 43 though though IN 19613 5316 44 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 45 do do VBP 19613 5316 46 not not RB 19613 5316 47 give give VB 19613 5316 48 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 49 blessings blessing NNS 19613 5316 50 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 51 had have VBD 19613 5316 52 not not RB 19613 5316 53 already already RB 19613 5316 54 received receive VBN 19613 5316 55 , , , 19613 5316 56 but but CC 19613 5316 57 rather rather RB 19613 5316 58 such such JJ 19613 5316 59 as as IN 19613 5316 60 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5316 61 had have VBD 19613 5316 62 indeed indeed RB 19613 5316 63 obtained obtain VBN 19613 5316 64 , , , 19613 5316 65 but but CC 19613 5316 66 were be VBD 19613 5316 67 not not RB 19613 5316 68 able able JJ 19613 5316 69 to to TO 19613 5316 70 retain retain VB 19613 5316 71 in in IN 19613 5316 72 consequence consequence NN 19613 5316 73 of of IN 19613 5316 74 error error NN 19613 5316 75 . . . 19613 5316 76 " " '' 19613 5317 1 Here here RB 19613 5317 2 the the DT 19613 5317 3 whole whole JJ 19613 5317 4 theology theology NN 19613 5317 5 of of IN 19613 5317 6 the the DT 19613 5317 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5317 8 is be VBZ 19613 5317 9 contained contain VBN 19613 5317 10 _ _ NNP 19613 5317 11 in in IN 19613 5317 12 nuce nuce NN 19613 5317 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5317 14 ; ; : 19613 5317 15 see see VB 19613 5317 16 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5317 17 , , , 19613 5317 18 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5317 19 . . . 19613 5318 1 7 7 CD 19613 5318 2 - - SYM 19613 5318 3 8 8 CD 19613 5318 4 . . . 19613 5319 1 In in IN 19613 5319 2 Chaps Chaps NNP 19613 5319 3 . . . 19613 5320 1 32 32 CD 19613 5320 2 , , , 19613 5320 3 33 33 CD 19613 5320 4 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5320 5 strongly strongly RB 19613 5320 6 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 5320 7 the the DT 19613 5320 8 fact fact NN 19613 5320 9 that that IN 19613 5320 10 the the DT 19613 5320 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 5320 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5320 13 is be VBZ 19613 5320 14 accessible accessible JJ 19613 5320 15 even even RB 19613 5320 16 to to IN 19613 5320 17 the the DT 19613 5320 18 most most RBS 19613 5320 19 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 5320 20 ; ; : 19613 5320 21 see see VB 19613 5320 22 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5320 23 , , , 19613 5320 24 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5320 25 . . . 19613 5321 1 II ii CD 19613 5321 2 . . . 19613 5322 1 10 10 CD 19613 5322 2 ; ; : 19613 5322 3 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 5322 4 . . . 19613 5323 1 11 11 CD 19613 5323 2 etc etc FW 19613 5323 3 . . . 19613 5323 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5324 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5324 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5324 3 400 400 CD 19613 5324 4 : : : 19613 5324 5 The the DT 19613 5324 6 unknown unknown JJ 19613 5324 7 author author NN 19613 5324 8 of of IN 19613 5324 9 the the DT 19613 5324 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5324 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5324 12 : : : 19613 5324 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5324 14 pros pro NNS 19613 5324 15 Ellênas Ellênas NNP 19613 5324 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5324 17 also also RB 19613 5324 18 formed form VBD 19613 5324 19 the the DT 19613 5324 20 same same JJ 19613 5324 21 judgment judgment NN 19613 5324 22 as as IN 19613 5324 23 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5324 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5324 25 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 5325 1 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 5325 2 . . . 19613 5325 3 , , , 19613 5325 4 T. t. NN 19613 5326 1 III III NNP 19613 5326 2 . . NNP 19613 5326 3 , , , 19613 5326 4 p. p. NN 19613 5326 5 2 2 CD 19613 5326 6 sq sq NNP 19613 5326 7 . . NNP 19613 5326 8 , , , 19613 5326 9 ed ed NNP 19613 5326 10 . . . 19613 5327 1 Otto Otto NNP 19613 5327 2 ; ; : 19613 5327 3 a a DT 19613 5327 4 Syrian syrian JJ 19613 5327 5 translation translation NN 19613 5327 6 , , , 19613 5327 7 greatly greatly RB 19613 5327 8 amplified amplified JJ 19613 5327 9 , , , 19613 5327 10 is be VBZ 19613 5327 11 found find VBN 19613 5327 12 in in IN 19613 5327 13 the the DT 19613 5327 14 Cod cod NN 19613 5327 15 . . . 19613 5328 1 Nitr Nitr NNP 19613 5328 2 . . . 19613 5329 1 Mus mus NN 19613 5329 2 . . . 19613 5330 1 Britt Britt NNP 19613 5330 2 . . . 19613 5331 1 Add add VB 19613 5331 2 . . . 19613 5332 1 14658 14658 CD 19613 5332 2 . . . 19613 5333 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5333 2 was be VBD 19613 5333 3 published publish VBN 19613 5333 4 by by IN 19613 5333 5 Cureton Cureton NNP 19613 5333 6 , , , 19613 5333 7 Spic Spic NNP 19613 5333 8 . . . 19613 5334 1 Syr Syr NNP 19613 5334 2 . . NNP 19613 5334 3 , , , 19613 5334 4 p. p. NN 19613 5334 5 38 38 CD 19613 5334 6 sq sq NN 19613 5334 7 . . . 19613 5335 1 with with IN 19613 5335 2 an an DT 19613 5335 3 English english JJ 19613 5335 4 translation translation NN 19613 5335 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5335 6 . . . 19613 5336 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5336 2 is be VBZ 19613 5336 3 an an DT 19613 5336 4 incomparable incomparable JJ 19613 5336 5 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 5336 6 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 5336 7 , , , 19613 5336 8 the the DT 19613 5336 9 teacher teacher NN 19613 5336 10 of of IN 19613 5336 11 which which WDT 19613 5336 12 is be VBZ 19613 5336 13 the the DT 19613 5336 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5336 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5336 16 . . . 19613 5337 1 " " `` 19613 5337 2 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5337 3 produces produce VBZ 19613 5337 4 neither neither CC 19613 5337 5 poets poet NNS 19613 5337 6 , , , 19613 5337 7 nor nor CC 19613 5337 8 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5337 9 , , , 19613 5337 10 nor nor CC 19613 5337 11 rhetoricians rhetorician NNS 19613 5337 12 ; ; : 19613 5337 13 but but CC 19613 5337 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5337 15 makes make VBZ 19613 5337 16 mortals mortal NNS 19613 5337 17 immortal immortal JJ 19613 5337 18 and and CC 19613 5337 19 men man NNS 19613 5337 20 gods god NNS 19613 5337 21 , , , 19613 5337 22 and and CC 19613 5337 23 leads lead VBZ 19613 5337 24 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5337 25 away away RB 19613 5337 26 upwards upwards RB 19613 5337 27 from from IN 19613 5337 28 the the DT 19613 5337 29 earth earth NN 19613 5337 30 into into IN 19613 5337 31 super super JJ 19613 5337 32 - - JJ 19613 5337 33 Olympian olympian JJ 19613 5337 34 regions region NNS 19613 5337 35 . . . 19613 5337 36 " " '' 19613 5338 1 Through through IN 19613 5338 2 Christian christian JJ 19613 5338 3 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5338 4 the the DT 19613 5338 5 soul soul NN 19613 5338 6 returns return NNS 19613 5338 7 to to IN 19613 5338 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5338 9 Creator creator NN 19613 5338 10 : : : 19613 5338 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5338 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5338 13 : : : 19613 5338 14 dei dei NNP 19613 5338 15 gar gar NNP 19613 5338 16 apokatatathênai apokatatathênai NNP 19613 5338 17 othen othen NNP 19613 5338 18 apestê apestê NNP 19613 5338 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5338 20 . . . 19613 5338 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5339 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5339 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5339 3 401 401 CD 19613 5339 4 : : : 19613 5339 5 Nor nor CC 19613 5339 6 is be VBZ 19613 5339 7 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5339 8 " " '' 19613 5339 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5339 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5339 11 : : : 19613 5339 12 ho ho NNP 19613 5339 13 dokôn dokôn VB 19613 5339 14 en en IN 19613 5339 15 autois autois NNP 19613 5339 16 semnoteron semnoteron NNP 19613 5339 17 pephilosophêkenai pephilosophêkenai NNP 19613 5339 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5339 19 " " `` 19613 5339 20 any any DT 19613 5339 21 better well JJR 19613 5339 22 than than IN 19613 5339 23 Epicurus Epicurus NNP 19613 5339 24 and and CC 19613 5339 25 the the DT 19613 5339 26 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5339 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5339 28 III iii CD 19613 5339 29 . . . 19613 5340 1 6 6 LS 19613 5340 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5340 3 . . . 19613 5341 1 Correct correct JJ 19613 5341 2 views view NNS 19613 5341 3 which which WDT 19613 5341 4 are be VBP 19613 5341 5 found find VBN 19613 5341 6 in in IN 19613 5341 7 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5341 8 in in IN 19613 5341 9 a a DT 19613 5341 10 greater great JJR 19613 5341 11 measure measure NN 19613 5341 12 than than IN 19613 5341 13 in in IN 19613 5341 14 the the DT 19613 5341 15 others other NNS 19613 5341 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5341 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5341 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5341 19 : : : 19613 5341 20 ho ho XX 19613 5341 21 dokôn dokôn VB 19613 5341 22 Hellênôn Hellênôn NNP 19613 5341 23 sophôteros sophôtero NNS 19613 5341 24 gegenêsthai gegenêsthai NN 19613 5341 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5341 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5341 27 , , , 19613 5341 28 did do VBD 19613 5341 29 not not RB 19613 5341 30 prevent prevent VB 19613 5341 31 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5341 32 from from IN 19613 5341 33 giving give VBG 19613 5341 34 way way NN 19613 5341 35 to to IN 19613 5341 36 the the DT 19613 5341 37 stupidest stupid JJS 19613 5341 38 babbling babbling NN 19613 5341 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5341 40 III iii CD 19613 5341 41 . . . 19613 5342 1 16 16 CD 19613 5342 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5342 3 . . . 19613 5343 1 Although although IN 19613 5343 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5343 3 knew know VBD 19613 5343 4 that that IN 19613 5343 5 the the DT 19613 5343 6 full full JJ 19613 5343 7 truth truth NN 19613 5343 8 can can MD 19613 5343 9 only only RB 19613 5343 10 be be VB 19613 5343 11 learned learn VBN 19613 5343 12 from from IN 19613 5343 13 God God NNP 19613 5343 14 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5343 15 through through IN 19613 5343 16 the the DT 19613 5343 17 law law NN 19613 5343 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5343 19 III iii CD 19613 5343 20 . . . 19613 5344 1 17 17 CD 19613 5344 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5344 3 , , , 19613 5344 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5344 5 indulged indulge VBD 19613 5344 6 in in IN 19613 5344 7 the the DT 19613 5344 8 most most RBS 19613 5344 9 foolish foolish JJ 19613 5344 10 guesses guess NNS 19613 5344 11 concerning concern VBG 19613 5344 12 the the DT 19613 5344 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 5344 14 of of IN 19613 5344 15 history history NN 19613 5344 16 . . . 19613 5345 1 But but CC 19613 5345 2 where where WRB 19613 5345 3 guesses guess NNS 19613 5345 4 find find VBP 19613 5345 5 a a DT 19613 5345 6 place place NN 19613 5345 7 , , , 19613 5345 8 truth truth NN 19613 5345 9 is be VBZ 19613 5345 10 not not RB 19613 5345 11 to to TO 19613 5345 12 be be VB 19613 5345 13 found find VBN 19613 5345 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5345 15 III iii CD 19613 5345 16 . . . 19613 5346 1 16 16 CD 19613 5346 2 : : : 19613 5346 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5346 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5346 5 : : : 19613 5346 6 ei ei NNP 19613 5346 7 de de NNP 19613 5346 8 eikasmô eikasmô NNP 19613 5346 9 , , , 19613 5346 10 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5346 11 ara ara NNP 19613 5346 12 alêthê alêthê NNP 19613 5346 13 estin estin NNP 19613 5346 14 ta ta NNP 19613 5346 15 hup hup NNP 19613 5346 16 ' ' POS 19613 5346 17 autou autou NNP 19613 5346 18 eirêmena eirêmena NNP 19613 5346 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5346 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5346 21 . . . 19613 5346 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5347 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5347 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5347 3 402 402 CD 19613 5347 4 : : : 19613 5347 5 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5347 6 confesses confess VBZ 19613 5347 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5347 8 I. i. NN 19613 5348 1 14 14 LS 19613 5348 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5348 3 exactly exactly RB 19613 5348 4 as as IN 19613 5348 5 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5348 6 does do VBZ 19613 5348 7 : : : 19613 5348 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5348 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5348 10 : : : 19613 5348 11 kai kai NNP 19613 5348 12 gar gar NNP 19613 5348 13 egô egô NNP 19613 5348 14 êpistoun êpistoun NNP 19613 5348 15 touto touto NNP 19613 5348 16 esesthai esesthai NNP 19613 5348 17 , , , 19613 5348 18 alla alla NN 19613 5348 19 nun nun VBP 19613 5348 20 katanoêsas katanoêsas NNP 19613 5348 21 auta auta NNP 19613 5348 22 pisteuô pisteuô NNP 19613 5348 23 , , , 19613 5348 24 hama hama NNP 19613 5348 25 kai kai NNP 19613 5348 26 epituchôn epituchôn NNP 19613 5348 27 hierais hierais NNP 19613 5348 28 graphais graphais NNP 19613 5348 29 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5348 30 agiôn agiôn NNP 19613 5348 31 prophêtôn prophêtôn NNS 19613 5348 32 , , , 19613 5348 33 hoi hoi NNP 19613 5348 34 kai kai NNP 19613 5348 35 proeipon proeipon NN 19613 5348 36 dia dia NN 19613 5348 37 pneumatos pneumatos NN 19613 5348 38 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5348 39 ti ti NNP 19613 5348 40 progegonota progegonota NNP 19613 5348 41 ô ô NNP 19613 5348 42 tropô tropô NNP 19613 5348 43 gegonen gegonen NNP 19613 5348 44 kai kai NNP 19613 5348 45 ta ta NNP 19613 5348 46 enestôta enestôta NNP 19613 5348 47 tini tini NNP 19613 5348 48 tropô tropô NNP 19613 5348 49 ginetai ginetai NNP 19613 5348 50 , , , 19613 5348 51 kai kai NNP 19613 5348 52 ta ta NNP 19613 5348 53 eperchomena eperchomena NNP 19613 5348 54 poia poia NNP 19613 5348 55 taxei taxei NNP 19613 5348 56 apartisthêsetai apartisthêsetai NNP 19613 5348 57 . . . 19613 5349 1 Apodeixin apodeixin VB 19613 5349 2 oun oun NNP 19613 5349 3 labôn labôn NNP 19613 5349 4 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5349 5 ginomenôn ginomenôn NNP 19613 5349 6 kai kai NNP 19613 5349 7 proanapephônêmenôn proanapephônêmenôn NNP 19613 5349 8 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5349 9 apistô apistô NNP 19613 5349 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5349 11 ; ; : 19613 5349 12 see see VB 19613 5349 13 also also RB 19613 5349 14 II II NNP 19613 5349 15 . . . 19613 5350 1 8 8 CD 19613 5350 2 - - SYM 19613 5350 3 10 10 CD 19613 5350 4 , , , 19613 5350 5 22 22 CD 19613 5350 6 , , , 19613 5350 7 30 30 CD 19613 5350 8 , , , 19613 5350 9 33 33 CD 19613 5350 10 - - SYM 19613 5350 11 35 35 CD 19613 5350 12 : : : 19613 5350 13 III iii CD 19613 5350 14 . . . 19613 5351 1 10 10 CD 19613 5351 2 , , , 19613 5351 3 11 11 CD 19613 5351 4 , , , 19613 5351 5 17 17 CD 19613 5351 6 . . . 19613 5352 1 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5352 2 merely merely RB 19613 5352 3 looks look VBZ 19613 5352 4 on on IN 19613 5352 5 the the DT 19613 5352 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 5352 7 as as IN 19613 5352 8 a a DT 19613 5352 9 continuation continuation NN 19613 5352 10 of of IN 19613 5352 11 the the DT 19613 5352 12 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 5352 13 revelations revelation NNS 19613 5352 14 and and CC 19613 5352 15 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 5352 16 . . . 19613 5353 1 Of of IN 19613 5353 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5353 3 , , , 19613 5353 4 however however RB 19613 5353 5 , , , 19613 5353 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5353 7 did do VBD 19613 5353 8 not not RB 19613 5353 9 speak speak VB 19613 5353 10 at at RB 19613 5353 11 all all RB 19613 5353 12 , , , 19613 5353 13 but but CC 19613 5353 14 only only RB 19613 5353 15 of of IN 19613 5353 16 the the DT 19613 5353 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5353 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5353 19 Pneuma Pneuma NNP 19613 5353 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5353 21 , , , 19613 5353 22 which which WDT 19613 5353 23 has have VBZ 19613 5353 24 operated operate VBN 19613 5353 25 from from IN 19613 5353 26 the the DT 19613 5353 27 beginning beginning NN 19613 5353 28 . . . 19613 5354 1 To to IN 19613 5354 2 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5354 3 the the DT 19613 5354 4 first first JJ 19613 5354 5 chapters chapter NNS 19613 5354 6 of of IN 19613 5354 7 Genesis Genesis NNP 19613 5354 8 already already RB 19613 5354 9 contain contain VBP 19613 5354 10 the the DT 19613 5354 11 sum sum NN 19613 5354 12 of of IN 19613 5354 13 all all DT 19613 5354 14 Christian christian JJ 19613 5354 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5354 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5354 17 II ii CD 19613 5354 18 . . . 19613 5355 1 10 10 CD 19613 5355 2 - - SYM 19613 5355 3 32 32 CD 19613 5355 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5355 5 . . . 19613 5355 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5356 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5356 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5356 3 403 403 CD 19613 5356 4 : : : 19613 5356 5 See see VB 19613 5356 6 II II NNP 19613 5356 7 . . . 19613 5357 1 8 8 CD 19613 5357 2 : : : 19613 5357 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5357 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5357 5 : : : 19613 5357 6 hupo hupo NNP 19613 5357 7 daimonôn daimonôn NNP 19613 5357 8 de de NNP 19613 5357 9 empneusthentes empneusthentes NNP 19613 5357 10 kai kai NNP 19613 5357 11 hup hup NNP 19613 5357 12 ' ' POS 19613 5357 13 autôn autôn NNP 19613 5357 14 phusiôthentes phusiôthentes NNPS 19613 5357 15 ha ha UH 19613 5357 16 eipon eipon NNP 19613 5357 17 di di NNP 19613 5357 18 ' ' '' 19613 5357 19 autôn autôn NNP 19613 5357 20 eipon eipon NNP 19613 5357 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5357 22 . . . 19613 5357 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5358 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5358 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5358 3 404 404 CD 19613 5358 4 : : : 19613 5358 5 The the DT 19613 5358 6 unknown unknown JJ 19613 5358 7 author author NN 19613 5358 8 of of IN 19613 5358 9 the the DT 19613 5358 10 work work NN 19613 5358 11 _ _ NNP 19613 5358 12 de de NNP 19613 5358 13 resurrectione resurrectione NN 19613 5358 14 _ _ NNP 19613 5358 15 , , , 19613 5358 16 which which WDT 19613 5358 17 goes go VBZ 19613 5358 18 under under IN 19613 5358 19 the the DT 19613 5358 20 name name NN 19613 5358 21 of of IN 19613 5358 22 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5358 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5358 24 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 5359 1 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5359 2 . . . 19613 5359 3 , , , 19613 5359 4 Vol Vol NNP 19613 5359 5 . . . 19613 5360 1 III III NNP 19613 5360 2 . . . 19613 5360 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5361 1 has have VBZ 19613 5361 2 given give VBN 19613 5361 3 a a DT 19613 5361 4 surprising surprising JJ 19613 5361 5 expression expression NN 19613 5361 6 to to IN 19613 5361 7 the the DT 19613 5361 8 thought thought NN 19613 5361 9 that that IN 19613 5361 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5361 11 is be VBZ 19613 5361 12 simply simply RB 19613 5361 13 impossible impossible JJ 19613 5361 14 to to TO 19613 5361 15 give give VB 19613 5361 16 a a DT 19613 5361 17 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 5361 18 of of IN 19613 5361 19 truth truth NN 19613 5361 20 . . . 19613 5362 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5362 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5362 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5362 4 : : : 19613 5362 5 O o NN 19613 5362 6 men man NNS 19613 5362 7 tês tês NNP 19613 5362 8 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 5362 9 logos logos NNP 19613 5362 10 estin estin NNP 19613 5362 11 eleutheroste eleutheroste NNP 19613 5362 12 kai kai NNP 19613 5362 13 autexousios autexousios NNP 19613 5362 14 , , , 19613 5362 15 upo upo NNP 19613 5362 16 mêdemian mêdemian NNP 19613 5362 17 basanon basanon NNP 19613 5362 18 elegchou elegchou NNP 19613 5362 19 thelôn thelôn NNP 19613 5362 20 piptein piptein NNP 19613 5362 21 mêde mêde NNP 19613 5362 22 tên tên NNP 19613 5362 23 para para NNP 19613 5362 24 tois tois NNP 19613 5362 25 akouousi akouousi NNP 19613 5362 26 di di NNP 19613 5362 27 ' ' POS 19613 5362 28 apodeixeôs apodeixeôs NN 19613 5362 29 exetasin exetasin NNP 19613 5362 30 hupomenein hupomenein NNP 19613 5362 31 . . . 19613 5363 1 To to TO 19613 5363 2 gar gar VB 19613 5363 3 eugenes eugenes NNP 19613 5363 4 autou autou NNP 19613 5363 5 kai kai NNP 19613 5363 6 pepoithos pepoithos NNP 19613 5363 7 autô autô NNP 19613 5363 8 tô tô NNP 19613 5363 9 pempsanti pempsanti NNP 19613 5363 10 pisteuesthai pisteuesthai NNP 19613 5363 11 thelei thelei NNP 19613 5363 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5363 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5363 14 . . . 19613 5364 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5364 2 inveighs inveigh VBZ 19613 5364 3 in in IN 19613 5364 4 the the DT 19613 5364 5 beginning beginning NN 19613 5364 6 of of IN 19613 5364 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5364 8 treatise treatise NN 19613 5364 9 against against IN 19613 5364 10 all all DT 19613 5364 11 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 5364 12 , , , 19613 5364 13 and and CC 19613 5364 14 on on IN 19613 5364 15 the the DT 19613 5364 16 one one CD 19613 5364 17 hand hand NN 19613 5364 18 professes profess VBZ 19613 5364 19 a a DT 19613 5364 20 sort sort NN 19613 5364 21 of of IN 19613 5364 22 materialistic materialistic JJ 19613 5364 23 theory theory NN 19613 5364 24 of of IN 19613 5364 25 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5364 26 , , , 19613 5364 27 whilst whilst IN 19613 5364 28 on on IN 19613 5364 29 the the DT 19613 5364 30 other other JJ 19613 5364 31 , , , 19613 5364 32 for for IN 19613 5364 33 that that DT 19613 5364 34 very very JJ 19613 5364 35 reason reason NN 19613 5364 36 , , , 19613 5364 37 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5364 38 believes believe VBZ 19613 5364 39 in in IN 19613 5364 40 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 5364 41 and and CC 19613 5364 42 the the DT 19613 5364 43 authority authority NN 19613 5364 44 of of IN 19613 5364 45 revelation revelation NN 19613 5364 46 ; ; : 19613 5364 47 for for IN 19613 5364 48 all all DT 19613 5364 49 truth truth NN 19613 5364 50 originates originate VBZ 19613 5364 51 with with IN 19613 5364 52 revelation revelation NN 19613 5364 53 , , , 19613 5364 54 since since IN 19613 5364 55 God God NNP 19613 5364 56 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5364 57 and and CC 19613 5364 58 God God NNP 19613 5364 59 alone alone RB 19613 5364 60 is be VBZ 19613 5364 61 the the DT 19613 5364 62 truth truth NN 19613 5364 63 . . . 19613 5365 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5365 2 revealed reveal VBD 19613 5365 3 this this DT 19613 5365 4 truth truth NN 19613 5365 5 and and CC 19613 5365 6 is be VBZ 19613 5365 7 for for IN 19613 5365 8 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5365 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5365 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5365 11 : : : 19613 5365 12 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5365 13 olôn olôn NNP 19613 5365 14 pistis pistis NN 19613 5365 15 kai kai NNP 19613 5365 16 apodeixis apodeixis NNP 19613 5365 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5365 18 . . . 19613 5366 1 But but CC 19613 5366 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5366 3 is be VBZ 19613 5366 4 far far RB 19613 5366 5 from from IN 19613 5366 6 probable probable JJ 19613 5366 7 that that IN 19613 5366 8 the the DT 19613 5366 9 author author NN 19613 5366 10 would would MD 19613 5366 11 really really RB 19613 5366 12 have have VB 19613 5366 13 carried carry VBN 19613 5366 14 this this DT 19613 5366 15 proposition proposition NN 19613 5366 16 to to IN 19613 5366 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5366 18 logical logical JJ 19613 5366 19 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 5366 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5366 21 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5366 22 , , , 19613 5366 23 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5366 24 . . . 19613 5367 1 3 3 CD 19613 5367 2 ff ff NNP 19613 5367 3 . . . 19613 5368 1 made make VBN 19613 5368 2 a a DT 19613 5368 3 similar similar JJ 19613 5368 4 start start NN 19613 5368 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5368 6 . . . 19613 5369 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5369 2 wishes wish VBZ 19613 5369 3 to to TO 19613 5369 4 meet meet VB 19613 5369 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5369 6 adversaries adversary NNS 19613 5369 7 " " `` 19613 5369 8 armed arm VBN 19613 5369 9 with with IN 19613 5369 10 the the DT 19613 5369 11 arguments argument NNS 19613 5369 12 of of IN 19613 5369 13 faith faith NN 19613 5369 14 which which WDT 19613 5369 15 are be VBP 19613 5369 16 unconquered unconquere VBN 19613 5369 17 " " '' 19613 5369 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5369 19 c. c. NNP 19613 5369 20 1 1 CD 19613 5369 21 , , , 19613 5369 22 p. p. NN 19613 5369 23 214 214 CD 19613 5369 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5369 25 , , , 19613 5369 26 but but CC 19613 5369 27 the the DT 19613 5369 28 arguments argument NNS 19613 5369 29 of of IN 19613 5369 30 faith faith NN 19613 5369 31 are be VBP 19613 5369 32 still still RB 19613 5369 33 the the DT 19613 5369 34 arguments argument NNS 19613 5369 35 of of IN 19613 5369 36 reason reason NN 19613 5369 37 . . . 19613 5370 1 Among among IN 19613 5370 2 these these DT 19613 5370 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5370 4 regarded regard VBD 19613 5370 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5370 6 as as RB 19613 5370 7 most most RBS 19613 5370 8 important important JJ 19613 5370 9 that that IN 19613 5370 10 even even RB 19613 5370 11 according accord VBG 19613 5370 12 to to IN 19613 5370 13 the the DT 19613 5370 14 theories theory NNS 19613 5370 15 about about IN 19613 5370 16 the the DT 19613 5370 17 world world NN 19613 5370 18 , , , 19613 5370 19 that that RB 19613 5370 20 is is RB 19613 5370 21 , , , 19613 5370 22 about about IN 19613 5370 23 God God NNP 19613 5370 24 and and CC 19613 5370 25 matter matter NN 19613 5370 26 , , , 19613 5370 27 held hold VBN 19613 5370 28 by by IN 19613 5370 29 the the DT 19613 5370 30 " " `` 19613 5370 31 so so RB 19613 5370 32 - - HYPH 19613 5370 33 called call VBN 19613 5370 34 sages sage NNS 19613 5370 35 , , , 19613 5370 36 " " `` 19613 5370 37 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5370 38 , , , 19613 5370 39 Epicurus Epicurus NNP 19613 5370 40 , , , 19613 5370 41 and and CC 19613 5370 42 the the DT 19613 5370 43 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5370 44 , , , 19613 5370 45 the the DT 19613 5370 46 assumption assumption NN 19613 5370 47 of of IN 19613 5370 48 a a DT 19613 5370 49 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 5370 50 of of IN 19613 5370 51 the the DT 19613 5370 52 flesh flesh NN 19613 5370 53 is be VBZ 19613 5370 54 not not RB 19613 5370 55 irrational irrational JJ 19613 5370 56 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5370 57 c. c. NNP 19613 5370 58 6 6 CD 19613 5370 59 , , , 19613 5370 60 p. p. NN 19613 5370 61 228 228 CD 19613 5370 62 f. f. NNS 19613 5370 63 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5370 64 . . . 19613 5371 1 Some some DT 19613 5371 2 of of IN 19613 5371 3 these these DT 19613 5371 4 , , , 19613 5371 5 viz viz NN 19613 5371 6 . . NNP 19613 5371 7 , , , 19613 5371 8 Pythagoras Pythagoras NNP 19613 5371 9 and and CC 19613 5371 10 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5371 11 , , , 19613 5371 12 also also RB 19613 5371 13 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 5371 14 the the DT 19613 5371 15 immortality immortality NN 19613 5371 16 of of IN 19613 5371 17 the the DT 19613 5371 18 soul soul NN 19613 5371 19 . . . 19613 5372 1 But but CC 19613 5372 2 , , , 19613 5372 3 for for IN 19613 5372 4 that that DT 19613 5372 5 very very JJ 19613 5372 6 reason reason NN 19613 5372 7 , , , 19613 5372 8 this this DT 19613 5372 9 view view NN 19613 5372 10 is be VBZ 19613 5372 11 not not RB 19613 5372 12 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 5372 13 , , , 19613 5372 14 " " '' 19613 5372 15 for for IN 19613 5372 16 if if IN 19613 5372 17 the the DT 19613 5372 18 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 5372 19 had have VBD 19613 5372 20 only only RB 19613 5372 21 brought bring VBN 19613 5372 22 the the DT 19613 5372 23 message message NN 19613 5372 24 of of IN 19613 5372 25 the the DT 19613 5372 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5372 27 eternal eternal JJ 19613 5372 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5372 29 life life NN 19613 5372 30 of of IN 19613 5372 31 the the DT 19613 5372 32 soul soul NN 19613 5372 33 what what WDT 19613 5372 34 new new JJ 19613 5372 35 thing thing NN 19613 5372 36 would would MD 19613 5372 37 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5372 38 have have VB 19613 5372 39 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 5372 40 in in IN 19613 5372 41 addition addition NN 19613 5372 42 to to IN 19613 5372 43 what what WP 19613 5372 44 had have VBD 19613 5372 45 been be VBN 19613 5372 46 made make VBN 19613 5372 47 known known JJ 19613 5372 48 by by IN 19613 5372 49 Pythagoras Pythagoras NNP 19613 5372 50 , , , 19613 5372 51 Plato Plato NNP 19613 5372 52 , , , 19613 5372 53 and and CC 19613 5372 54 the the DT 19613 5372 55 band band NN 19613 5372 56 of of IN 19613 5372 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5372 58 adherents adherent NNS 19613 5372 59 ? ? . 19613 5372 60 " " '' 19613 5373 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5373 2 c. c. NNP 19613 5373 3 10 10 CD 19613 5373 4 , , , 19613 5373 5 p. p. NN 19613 5374 1 246 246 CD 19613 5374 2 . . . 19613 5374 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5375 1 This this DT 19613 5375 2 remark remark NN 19613 5375 3 is be VBZ 19613 5375 4 very very RB 19613 5375 5 instructive instructive JJ 19613 5375 6 , , , 19613 5375 7 for for IN 19613 5375 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5375 9 shows show VBZ 19613 5375 10 what what WP 19613 5375 11 considerations consideration NNS 19613 5375 12 led lead VBD 19613 5375 13 the the DT 19613 5375 14 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5375 15 to to TO 19613 5375 16 adhere adhere VB 19613 5375 17 to to IN 19613 5375 18 the the DT 19613 5375 19 belief belief NN 19613 5375 20 in in IN 19613 5375 21 the the DT 19613 5375 22 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 5375 23 of of IN 19613 5375 24 the the DT 19613 5375 25 body body NN 19613 5375 26 . . . 19613 5376 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 5376 2 , , , 19613 5376 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5376 4 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 5376 5 fur fur NN 19613 5376 6 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 5376 7 , , , 19613 5376 8 Vol Vol NNP 19613 5376 9 . . . 19613 5377 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 5377 2 . . . 19613 5377 3 , , , 19613 5377 4 pp pp NNP 19613 5377 5 . . . 19613 5378 1 1 1 CD 19613 5378 2 f. f. NNP 19613 5378 3 , , , 19613 5378 4 20 20 CD 19613 5378 5 f. f. NNS 19613 5378 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5378 7 has have VBZ 19613 5378 8 lately lately RB 19613 5378 9 reassigned reassign VBN 19613 5378 10 to to IN 19613 5378 11 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5378 12 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5378 13 the the DT 19613 5378 14 fragment fragment NN 19613 5378 15 de de FW 19613 5378 16 resurr resurr NNP 19613 5378 17 . . . 19613 5379 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5379 2 argument argument NN 19613 5379 3 , , , 19613 5379 4 though though IN 19613 5379 5 displaying display VBG 19613 5379 6 great great JJ 19613 5379 7 plausibility plausibility NN 19613 5379 8 , , , 19613 5379 9 has have VBZ 19613 5379 10 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5379 11 not not RB 19613 5379 12 fully fully RB 19613 5379 13 convinced convince VBD 19613 5379 14 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5379 15 . . . 19613 5380 1 The the DT 19613 5380 2 question question NN 19613 5380 3 is be VBZ 19613 5380 4 of of IN 19613 5380 5 great great JJ 19613 5380 6 importance importance NN 19613 5380 7 for for IN 19613 5380 8 fixing fix VBG 19613 5380 9 the the DT 19613 5380 10 relation relation NN 19613 5380 11 of of IN 19613 5380 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5380 13 to to IN 19613 5380 14 Paul Paul NNP 19613 5380 15 . . . 19613 5381 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 5381 2 shall shall MD 19613 5381 3 not not RB 19613 5381 4 discuss discuss VB 19613 5381 5 Hermias Hermias NNP 19613 5381 6 ' ' POS 19613 5381 7 " " `` 19613 5381 8 Irrisio Irrisio NNP 19613 5381 9 Gentilium Gentilium NNP 19613 5381 10 Philosophorum Philosophorum NNP 19613 5381 11 , , , 19613 5381 12 " " '' 19613 5381 13 as as IN 19613 5381 14 the the DT 19613 5381 15 period period NN 19613 5381 16 when when WRB 19613 5381 17 this this DT 19613 5381 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 5381 19 disputant disputant NN 19613 5381 20 flourished flourish VBD 19613 5381 21 is be VBZ 19613 5381 22 quite quite RB 19613 5381 23 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 5381 24 . . . 19613 5382 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5382 2 still still RB 19613 5382 3 possess possess VBP 19613 5382 4 an an DT 19613 5382 5 early early JJ 19613 5382 6 - - HYPH 19613 5382 7 Church Church NNP 19613 5382 8 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5382 9 in in IN 19613 5382 10 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 5382 11 - - HYPH 19613 5382 12 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5382 13 's 's POS 19613 5382 14 " " `` 19613 5382 15 Oratio Oratio NNP 19613 5382 16 ad ad NN 19613 5382 17 Antoninum Antoninum NNP 19613 5382 18 Cæsarem Cæsarem NNP 19613 5382 19 " " '' 19613 5382 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5382 21 Otto Otto NNP 19613 5382 22 , , , 19613 5382 23 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 5382 24 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5382 25 . . . 19613 5383 1 IX IX NNP 19613 5383 2 . . NNP 19613 5383 3 , , , 19613 5383 4 p. p. NN 19613 5383 5 423 423 CD 19613 5383 6 sq sq NNP 19613 5383 7 . . NNP 19613 5383 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5383 9 . . . 19613 5384 1 This this DT 19613 5384 2 book book NN 19613 5384 3 is be VBZ 19613 5384 4 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5384 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5384 6 written write VBN 19613 5384 7 ? ? . 19613 5384 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5385 1 in in IN 19613 5385 2 the the DT 19613 5385 3 Syrian syrian JJ 19613 5385 4 language language NN 19613 5385 5 and and CC 19613 5385 6 was be VBD 19613 5385 7 addressed address VBN 19613 5385 8 to to IN 19613 5385 9 Caracalla Caracalla NNP 19613 5385 10 or or CC 19613 5385 11 Heliogabalus Heliogabalus NNP 19613 5385 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5385 13 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5385 14 in in IN 19613 5385 15 the the DT 19613 5385 16 Cod cod NN 19613 5385 17 . . . 19613 5386 1 Nitr Nitr NNP 19613 5386 2 . . . 19613 5387 1 Mus mus NN 19613 5387 2 . . . 19613 5388 1 Britt Britt NNP 19613 5388 2 . . . 19613 5389 1 Add add VB 19613 5389 2 . . . 19613 5390 1 14658 14658 CD 19613 5390 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5390 3 . . . 19613 5391 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5391 2 is be VBZ 19613 5391 3 probably probably RB 19613 5391 4 dependent dependent JJ 19613 5391 5 on on IN 19613 5391 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5391 7 , , , 19613 5391 8 but but CC 19613 5391 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5391 10 is be VBZ 19613 5391 11 less less RBR 19613 5391 12 polished polished JJ 19613 5391 13 and and CC 19613 5391 14 more more RBR 19613 5391 15 violent violent JJ 19613 5391 16 than than IN 19613 5391 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5391 18 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5391 19 . . . 19613 5391 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5392 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5392 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5392 3 405 405 CD 19613 5392 4 : : : 19613 5392 5 Massebieau Massebieau NNP 19613 5392 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5392 7 Revue Revue NNP 19613 5392 8 de de NNP 19613 5392 9 l'histoire l'histoire FW 19613 5392 10 des des NNP 19613 5392 11 religions religion NNS 19613 5392 12 , , , 19613 5392 13 1887 1887 CD 19613 5392 14 , , , 19613 5392 15 Vol Vol NNP 19613 5392 16 . . . 19613 5393 1 XV XV NNP 19613 5393 2 . . . 19613 5394 1 No no UH 19613 5394 2 . . . 19613 5395 1 3 3 LS 19613 5395 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5395 3 has have VBZ 19613 5395 4 convinced convince VBN 19613 5395 5 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5395 6 that that IN 19613 5395 7 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5395 8 wrote write VBD 19613 5395 9 at at IN 19613 5395 10 a a DT 19613 5395 11 later later JJ 19613 5395 12 period period NN 19613 5395 13 than than IN 19613 5395 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5395 15 and and CC 19613 5395 16 made make VBD 19613 5395 17 use use NN 19613 5395 18 of of IN 19613 5395 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5395 20 works work NNS 19613 5395 21 . . . 19613 5395 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5396 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5396 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5396 3 406 406 CD 19613 5396 4 : : : 19613 5396 5 Cf Cf NNP 19613 5396 6 . . . 19613 5397 1 the the DT 19613 5397 2 plan plan NN 19613 5397 3 of of IN 19613 5397 4 the the DT 19613 5397 5 " " `` 19613 5397 6 Octavius Octavius NNP 19613 5397 7 . . . 19613 5397 8 " " '' 19613 5398 1 The the DT 19613 5398 2 champion champion NN 19613 5398 3 of of IN 19613 5398 4 heathenism heathenism NN 19613 5398 5 here here RB 19613 5398 6 opposed oppose VBD 19613 5398 7 to to IN 19613 5398 8 the the DT 19613 5398 9 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5398 10 is be VBZ 19613 5398 11 a a DT 19613 5398 12 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 5398 13 representing represent VBG 19613 5398 14 the the DT 19613 5398 15 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 5398 16 of of IN 19613 5398 17 the the DT 19613 5398 18 middle middle JJ 19613 5398 19 Academy Academy NNP 19613 5398 20 . . . 19613 5399 1 This this DT 19613 5399 2 presupposes presuppose VBZ 19613 5399 3 , , , 19613 5399 4 as as IN 19613 5399 5 a a DT 19613 5399 6 matter matter NN 19613 5399 7 of of IN 19613 5399 8 course course NN 19613 5399 9 , , , 19613 5399 10 that that IN 19613 5399 11 the the DT 19613 5399 12 latter latter JJ 19613 5399 13 undertakes undertake VBZ 19613 5399 14 the the DT 19613 5399 15 defence defence NN 19613 5399 16 of of IN 19613 5399 17 the the DT 19613 5399 18 Stoical stoical JJ 19613 5399 19 position position NN 19613 5399 20 . . . 19613 5400 1 See see VB 19613 5400 2 , , , 19613 5400 3 besides besides RB 19613 5400 4 , , , 19613 5400 5 the the DT 19613 5400 6 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 5400 7 arguments argument NNS 19613 5400 8 in in IN 19613 5400 9 the the DT 19613 5400 10 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5400 11 of of IN 19613 5400 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5400 13 , , , 19613 5400 14 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 5400 15 , , , 19613 5400 16 c. c. NNP 19613 5400 17 17 17 CD 19613 5400 18 , , , 19613 5400 19 as as RB 19613 5400 20 well well RB 19613 5400 21 as as IN 19613 5400 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5400 23 tractate tractate NN 19613 5400 24 : : : 19613 5400 25 " " `` 19613 5400 26 de de FW 19613 5400 27 testimonio testimonio NNP 19613 5400 28 animæ animæ NN 19613 5400 29 naturaliter naturaliter NN 19613 5400 30 Christianæ Christianæ NNP 19613 5400 31 . . . 19613 5400 32 " " '' 19613 5401 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5401 2 need need VBP 19613 5401 3 merely merely RB 19613 5401 4 mention mention VB 19613 5401 5 that that IN 19613 5401 6 the the DT 19613 5401 7 work work NN 19613 5401 8 of of IN 19613 5401 9 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5401 10 is be VBZ 19613 5401 11 throughout throughout IN 19613 5401 12 dependent dependent JJ 19613 5401 13 on on IN 19613 5401 14 Cicero Cicero NNP 19613 5401 15 's 's POS 19613 5401 16 book book NN 19613 5401 17 , , , 19613 5401 18 " " '' 19613 5401 19 de de FW 19613 5401 20 natura natura NNP 19613 5401 21 deorum deorum NNP 19613 5401 22 . . . 19613 5401 23 " " '' 19613 5402 1 In in IN 19613 5402 2 this this DT 19613 5402 3 treatise treatise NN 19613 5402 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5402 5 takes take VBZ 19613 5402 6 up up RP 19613 5402 7 a a DT 19613 5402 8 position position NN 19613 5402 9 more more RBR 19613 5402 10 nearly nearly RB 19613 5402 11 akin akin JJ 19613 5402 12 to to IN 19613 5402 13 heathen heathen NNP 19613 5402 14 syncretism syncretism NN 19613 5402 15 than than IN 19613 5402 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5402 17 . . . 19613 5402 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5403 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5403 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5403 3 407 407 CD 19613 5403 4 : : : 19613 5403 5 In in IN 19613 5403 6 R. R. NNP 19613 5403 7 Kühn Kühn NNP 19613 5403 8 's 's POS 19613 5403 9 investigation investigation NN 19613 5403 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5403 11 " " `` 19613 5403 12 Der Der NNP 19613 5403 13 Octavius Octavius NNP 19613 5403 14 des des NNP 19613 5403 15 Min Min NNP 19613 5403 16 . . . 19613 5404 1 Felix Felix NNP 19613 5404 2 , , , 19613 5404 3 " " '' 19613 5404 4 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 19613 5404 5 , , , 19613 5404 6 1882)--the 1882)--the DT 19613 5404 7 best good JJS 19613 5404 8 special special JJ 19613 5404 9 work work NN 19613 5404 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5404 11 possess possess VBP 19613 5404 12 on on IN 19613 5404 13 an an DT 19613 5404 14 early early JJ 19613 5404 15 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5404 16 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5404 17 from from IN 19613 5404 18 the the DT 19613 5404 19 point point NN 19613 5404 20 of of IN 19613 5404 21 view view NN 19613 5404 22 of of IN 19613 5404 23 the the DT 19613 5404 24 history history NN 19613 5404 25 of of IN 19613 5404 26 dogma dogma NN 19613 5404 27 -- -- : 19613 5404 28 based base VBN 19613 5404 29 on on IN 19613 5404 30 a a DT 19613 5404 31 very very RB 19613 5404 32 careful careful JJ 19613 5404 33 analysis analysis NN 19613 5404 34 of of IN 19613 5404 35 the the DT 19613 5404 36 Octavius Octavius NNP 19613 5404 37 , , , 19613 5404 38 more more JJR 19613 5404 39 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 5404 40 is be VBZ 19613 5404 41 laid lay VBN 19613 5404 42 on on IN 19613 5404 43 the the DT 19613 5404 44 difference difference NN 19613 5404 45 than than IN 19613 5404 46 on on IN 19613 5404 47 the the DT 19613 5404 48 agreement agreement NN 19613 5404 49 between between IN 19613 5404 50 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5404 51 and and CC 19613 5404 52 the the DT 19613 5404 53 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5404 54 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5404 55 . . . 19613 5405 1 The the DT 19613 5405 2 author author NN 19613 5405 3 's 's POS 19613 5405 4 exposition exposition NN 19613 5405 5 requires require VBZ 19613 5405 6 to to TO 19613 5405 7 be be VB 19613 5405 8 supplemented supplement VBN 19613 5405 9 in in IN 19613 5405 10 the the DT 19613 5405 11 latter latter JJ 19613 5405 12 respect respect NN 19613 5405 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5405 14 see see VB 19613 5405 15 Theologische Theologische NNP 19613 5405 16 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 5405 17 - - HYPH 19613 5405 18 Zeitung Zeitung NNP 19613 5405 19 , , , 19613 5405 20 1883 1883 CD 19613 5405 21 , , , 19613 5405 22 No no UH 19613 5405 23 . . . 19613 5406 1 6 6 LS 19613 5406 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5406 3 . . . 19613 5406 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5407 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5407 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5407 3 408 408 CD 19613 5407 4 : : : 19613 5407 5 C. C. NNP 19613 5407 6 20 20 CD 19613 5407 7 : : : 19613 5407 8 " " `` 19613 5407 9 Exposui Exposui NNP 19613 5407 10 opiniones opinione VBZ 19613 5407 11 omnium omnium NN 19613 5407 12 ferme ferme NNP 19613 5407 13 philosophorum philosophorum NNP 19613 5407 14 .... .... NFP 19613 5407 15 ut ut NNP 19613 5407 16 quivis quivis NNP 19613 5407 17 arbitretur arbitretur NNP 19613 5407 18 , , , 19613 5407 19 aut aut NNP 19613 5407 20 nunc nunc NNP 19613 5407 21 Christianos Christianos NNP 19613 5407 22 philosophos philosophos VBP 19613 5407 23 esse esse NNP 19613 5407 24 aut aut NNP 19613 5407 25 philosophos philosophos NNP 19613 5407 26 fuisse fuisse NNP 19613 5407 27 jam jam NNP 19613 5407 28 tunc tunc NNP 19613 5407 29 Christianos Christianos NNP 19613 5407 30 . . . 19613 5407 31 " " '' 19613 5407 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5408 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5408 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5408 3 409 409 CD 19613 5408 4 : : : 19613 5408 5 See see VB 19613 5408 6 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5408 7 , , , 19613 5408 8 31 31 CD 19613 5408 9 ff ff NN 19613 5408 10 . . . 19613 5409 1 A a DT 19613 5409 2 quite quite RB 19613 5409 3 similar similar JJ 19613 5409 4 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 5409 5 is be VBZ 19613 5409 6 already already RB 19613 5409 7 found find VBN 19613 5409 8 in in IN 19613 5409 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5409 10 , , , 19613 5409 11 who who WP 19613 5409 12 in in IN 19613 5409 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5409 14 _ _ NNP 19613 5409 15 Apologeticum Apologeticum NNP 19613 5409 16 _ _ NNP 19613 5409 17 has have VBZ 19613 5409 18 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 5409 19 given give VBN 19613 5409 20 a a DT 19613 5409 21 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 5409 22 colouring colouring NN 19613 5409 23 to to IN 19613 5409 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 5409 25 ethics ethic NNS 19613 5409 26 and and CC 19613 5409 27 rules rule NNS 19613 5409 28 of of IN 19613 5409 29 life life NN 19613 5409 30 , , , 19613 5409 31 and and CC 19613 5409 32 in in IN 19613 5409 33 c. c. NNP 19613 5409 34 39 39 CD 19613 5409 35 has have VBZ 19613 5409 36 drawn draw VBN 19613 5409 37 a a DT 19613 5409 38 complete complete JJ 19613 5409 39 veil veil NN 19613 5409 40 over over IN 19613 5409 41 the the DT 19613 5409 42 peculiarity peculiarity NN 19613 5409 43 of of IN 19613 5409 44 the the DT 19613 5409 45 Christian christian JJ 19613 5409 46 societies society NNS 19613 5409 47 . . . 19613 5409 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5410 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5410 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5410 3 410 410 CD 19613 5410 4 : : : 19613 5410 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5410 6 has have VBZ 19613 5410 7 done do VBN 19613 5410 8 exactly exactly RB 19613 5410 9 the the DT 19613 5410 10 same same JJ 19613 5410 11 thing thing NN 19613 5410 12 ; ; : 19613 5410 13 see see VB 19613 5410 14 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 5410 15 . . . 19613 5411 1 46 46 CD 19613 5411 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5411 3 and and CC 19613 5411 4 de de NNP 19613 5411 5 præscr præscr NNS 19613 5411 6 . . . 19613 5412 1 7 7 LS 19613 5412 2 . . . 19613 5412 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5412 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5413 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5413 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5413 3 411 411 CD 19613 5413 4 : : : 19613 5413 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 5413 6 . . NNP 19613 5413 7 , , , 19613 5413 8 de de NNP 19613 5413 9 testim testim NNP 19613 5413 10 . . . 19613 5414 1 I. i. NN 19613 5414 2 : : : 19613 5414 3 " " `` 19613 5414 4 Sed Sed NNP 19613 5414 5 non non AFX 19613 5414 6 eam eam NNP 19613 5414 7 te te NNP 19613 5414 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5414 9 animam animam NN 19613 5414 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5414 11 advoco advoco RB 19613 5414 12 , , , 19613 5414 13 quæ quæ NNP 19613 5414 14 scholis scholis NNP 19613 5414 15 formata formata NNP 19613 5414 16 , , , 19613 5414 17 bibliothecis bibliothecis NNP 19613 5414 18 exercitata exercitata NNP 19613 5414 19 , , , 19613 5414 20 academiis academiis JJ 19613 5414 21 et et NNP 19613 5414 22 porticibus porticibus NNP 19613 5414 23 Atticis Atticis NNP 19613 5414 24 pasta pasta NN 19613 5414 25 sapientiam sapientiam NNP 19613 5414 26 ructas ructas NNP 19613 5414 27 . . . 19613 5415 1 Te Te NNP 19613 5415 2 simplicem simplicem NNP 19613 5415 3 et et NNP 19613 5415 4 rudem rudem NNP 19613 5415 5 et et NNP 19613 5415 6 impoliitam impoliitam NNP 19613 5415 7 et et NNP 19613 5415 8 idioticam idioticam NNP 19613 5415 9 compello compello NNP 19613 5415 10 , , , 19613 5415 11 qualem qualem NNP 19613 5415 12 te te NNP 19613 5415 13 habent habent NNP 19613 5415 14 qui qui NNP 19613 5415 15 te te NNP 19613 5415 16 solam solam NNP 19613 5415 17 habent habent NNP 19613 5415 18 ... ... . 19613 5415 19 Imperitia Imperitia NNP 19613 5415 20 tua tua NNP 19613 5415 21 mihi mihi NN 19613 5415 22 opus opus NN 19613 5415 23 est est NNP 19613 5415 24 , , , 19613 5415 25 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 5415 26 aliquantulæ aliquantulæ NN 19613 5415 27 peritiæ peritiæ NNP 19613 5415 28 tuæ tuæ CC 19613 5415 29 nemo nemo NN 19613 5415 30 credit credit NN 19613 5415 31 . . . 19613 5415 32 " " '' 19613 5415 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5416 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5416 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5416 3 412 412 CD 19613 5416 4 : : : 19613 5416 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 5416 6 . . . 19613 5416 7 , , , 19613 5416 8 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5416 9 . . . 19613 5417 1 46 46 CD 19613 5417 2 : : : 19613 5417 3 " " `` 19613 5417 4 Quid Quid NNP 19613 5417 5 simile simile NN 19613 5417 6 philosophus philosophus NN 19613 5417 7 et et FW 19613 5417 8 Christianas Christianas NNP 19613 5417 9 ? ? . 19613 5418 1 Græciæ Græciæ NNP 19613 5418 2 discipulus discipulus NNP 19613 5418 3 et et NN 19613 5418 4 coeli coeli VBZ 19613 5418 5 ? ? . 19613 5418 6 " " '' 19613 5419 1 de de NNP 19613 5419 2 præscr præscr NNP 19613 5419 3 . . . 19613 5420 1 7 7 LS 19613 5420 2 : : : 19613 5420 3 " " `` 19613 5420 4 Quid Quid NNP 19613 5420 5 ergo ergo NN 19613 5420 6 Athenis Athenis NNP 19613 5420 7 et et FW 19613 5420 8 Hierosolymis Hierosolymis NNP 19613 5420 9 ? ? . 19613 5421 1 Quid quid VB 19613 5421 2 academiæ academiæ NNP 19613 5421 3 et et NN 19613 5421 4 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ JJ 19613 5421 5 ? ? . 19613 5421 6 " " '' 19613 5422 1 Minuc Minuc NNP 19613 5422 2 . . . 19613 5423 1 38.5 38.5 CD 19613 5423 2 : : : 19613 5423 3 " " `` 19613 5423 4 Philosophorum Philosophorum NNP 19613 5423 5 supercilia supercilia NN 19613 5423 6 contemnimus contemnimus NN 19613 5423 7 , , , 19613 5423 8 quos quos NNP 19613 5423 9 corruptores corruptore VBZ 19613 5423 10 et et NNP 19613 5423 11 adulteros adulteros NNP 19613 5423 12 novimus novimus NNP 19613 5423 13 ... ... : 19613 5423 14 nos nos NNP 19613 5423 15 , , , 19613 5423 16 qui qui VBD 19613 5423 17 non non NNP 19613 5423 18 habitu habitu NNP 19613 5423 19 sapientiam sapientiam NNP 19613 5423 20 sed sed NNP 19613 5423 21 mente mente NNP 19613 5423 22 præferimus præferimus NN 19613 5423 23 , , , 19613 5423 24 non non AFX 19613 5423 25 eloquimur eloquimur NNP 19613 5423 26 magna magna NNPS 19613 5423 27 sed sed NNP 19613 5423 28 vivimus vivimus NNP 19613 5423 29 , , , 19613 5423 30 gloriamur gloriamur NNP 19613 5423 31 nos nos NNP 19613 5423 32 consecutos consecutos NNP 19613 5423 33 , , , 19613 5423 34 quod quod NN 19613 5423 35 illi illi NN 19613 5423 36 summa summa RBR 19613 5423 37 intentione intentione NNP 19613 5423 38 quæsiverunt quæsiverunt NNP 19613 5423 39 nec nec NNP 19613 5423 40 invenire invenire NNP 19613 5423 41 potuerunt potuerunt NN 19613 5423 42 . . . 19613 5424 1 Quid Quid NNP 19613 5424 2 ingrati ingrati NNP 19613 5424 3 sumus sumus NNP 19613 5424 4 , , , 19613 5424 5 quid quid NNP 19613 5424 6 nobis nobis NNP 19613 5424 7 invidemus invidemus NNP 19613 5424 8 , , , 19613 5424 9 si si NNP 19613 5424 10 veritas veritas NNP 19613 5424 11 divinitatis divinitatis VBP 19613 5424 12 nostri nostri NNP 19613 5424 13 temporis temporis NNP 19613 5424 14 ælate ælate VBP 19613 5424 15 maturuit maturuit NN 19613 5424 16 ? ? . 19613 5424 17 " " '' 19613 5424 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5425 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5425 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5425 3 413 413 CD 19613 5425 4 : : : 19613 5425 5 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5425 6 did do VBD 19613 5425 7 not not RB 19613 5425 8 enter enter VB 19613 5425 9 closely closely RB 19613 5425 10 into into IN 19613 5425 11 the the DT 19613 5425 12 significance significance NN 19613 5425 13 of of IN 19613 5425 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5425 15 any any DT 19613 5425 16 more more JJR 19613 5425 17 than than IN 19613 5425 18 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5425 19 , , , 19613 5425 20 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 5425 21 , , , 19613 5425 22 and and CC 19613 5425 23 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5425 24 ; ; : 19613 5425 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5425 26 merely merely RB 19613 5425 27 touched touch VBD 19613 5425 28 upon upon IN 19613 5425 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5425 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5425 31 9 9 CD 19613 5425 32 . . . 19613 5426 1 4 4 CD 19613 5426 2 : : SYM 19613 5426 3 29 29 CD 19613 5426 4 . . . 19613 5427 1 2 2 LS 19613 5427 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5427 3 . . . 19613 5428 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5428 2 also also RB 19613 5428 3 viewed view VBD 19613 5428 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5428 5 as as IN 19613 5428 6 the the DT 19613 5428 7 teaching teaching NN 19613 5428 8 of of IN 19613 5428 9 the the DT 19613 5428 10 Prophets prophet NNS 19613 5428 11 ; ; : 19613 5428 12 whoever whoever WP 19613 5428 13 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 19613 5428 14 the the DT 19613 5428 15 latter latter JJ 19613 5428 16 must must NN 19613 5428 17 of of IN 19613 5428 18 necessity necessity NN 19613 5428 19 adore adore VB 19613 5428 20 the the DT 19613 5428 21 crucified crucified JJ 19613 5428 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5428 23 . . . 19613 5429 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5429 2 was be VBD 19613 5429 3 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5429 4 the the DT 19613 5429 5 first first JJ 19613 5429 6 Apologist apologist NN 19613 5429 7 after after IN 19613 5429 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5429 9 who who WP 19613 5429 10 again again RB 19613 5429 11 considered consider VBD 19613 5429 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5429 13 necessary necessary JJ 19613 5429 14 to to TO 19613 5429 15 give give VB 19613 5429 16 a a DT 19613 5429 17 detailed detailed JJ 19613 5429 18 account account NN 19613 5429 19 of of IN 19613 5429 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5429 21 as as IN 19613 5429 22 the the DT 19613 5429 23 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5429 24 of of IN 19613 5429 25 the the DT 19613 5429 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5429 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5429 28 see see VB 19613 5429 29 the the DT 19613 5429 30 21st 21st JJ 19613 5429 31 chapter chapter NN 19613 5429 32 of of IN 19613 5429 33 the the DT 19613 5429 34 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5429 35 in in IN 19613 5429 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5429 37 relation relation NN 19613 5429 38 to to IN 19613 5429 39 chaps chap NNS 19613 5429 40 . . . 19613 5430 1 17 17 CD 19613 5430 2 - - SYM 19613 5430 3 20 20 CD 19613 5430 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5430 5 . . . 19613 5430 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5431 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5431 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5431 3 414 414 CD 19613 5431 4 : : : 19613 5431 5 Among among IN 19613 5431 6 the the DT 19613 5431 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5431 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5431 9 the the DT 19613 5431 10 unknown unknown JJ 19613 5431 11 author author NN 19613 5431 12 of of IN 19613 5431 13 the the DT 19613 5431 14 work work NN 19613 5431 15 " " '' 19613 5431 16 de de NNP 19613 5431 17 Monarchia Monarchia NNP 19613 5431 18 , , , 19613 5431 19 " " '' 19613 5431 20 which which WDT 19613 5431 21 bears bear VBZ 19613 5431 22 the the DT 19613 5431 23 name name NN 19613 5431 24 of of IN 19613 5431 25 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5431 26 , , , 19613 5431 27 has have VBZ 19613 5431 28 given give VBN 19613 5431 29 clearest clear JJS 19613 5431 30 expression expression NN 19613 5431 31 to to IN 19613 5431 32 this this DT 19613 5431 33 conception conception NN 19613 5431 34 . . . 19613 5432 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5432 2 is be VBZ 19613 5432 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 5432 4 most most RBS 19613 5432 5 akin akin JJ 19613 5432 6 to to IN 19613 5432 7 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5432 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5432 9 see see VB 19613 5432 10 chap chap NNP 19613 5432 11 . . . 19613 5433 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5433 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5433 3 . . . 19613 5434 1 Here here RB 19613 5434 2 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 5434 3 is be VBZ 19613 5434 4 designated designate VBN 19613 5434 5 as as IN 19613 5434 6 the the DT 19613 5434 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5434 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5434 9 : : : 19613 5434 10 katholikê katholikê NNP 19613 5434 11 doxa doxa NNP 19613 5434 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5434 13 which which WDT 19613 5434 14 has have VBZ 19613 5434 15 fallen fall VBN 19613 5434 16 into into IN 19613 5434 17 oblivion oblivion NN 19613 5434 18 through through IN 19613 5434 19 bad bad JJ 19613 5434 20 habit habit NN 19613 5434 21 ; ; : 19613 5434 22 for for IN 19613 5434 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5434 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5434 25 : : : 19613 5434 26 tês tês NNP 19613 5434 27 anthrôpinês anthrôpinês NNP 19613 5434 28 phuseôs phuseôs NN 19613 5434 29 to to IN 19613 5434 30 kat kat NNP 19613 5434 31 ' ' '' 19613 5434 32 archên archên NNP 19613 5434 33 suzugian suzugian NNP 19613 5434 34 suneseôs suneseôs NNP 19613 5434 35 kai kai NNP 19613 5434 36 sôtêrias sôtêrias NNP 19613 5434 37 labousês labousês NNP 19613 5434 38 eis eis NNP 19613 5434 39 epignôsin epignôsin NNP 19613 5434 40 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 5434 41 thrêskeias thrêskeias NNP 19613 5434 42 te te NNP 19613 5434 43 tês tês NNP 19613 5434 44 eis eis NNP 19613 5434 45 ton ton NNP 19613 5434 46 hena hena NNP 19613 5434 47 kai kai NNP 19613 5434 48 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 5434 49 despotên despotên NNP 19613 5434 50 . . . 19613 5434 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5435 1 According accord VBG 19613 5435 2 to to IN 19613 5435 3 this this DT 19613 5435 4 , , , 19613 5435 5 then then RB 19613 5435 6 , , , 19613 5435 7 only only RB 19613 5435 8 an an DT 19613 5435 9 awakening awakening NN 19613 5435 10 is be VBZ 19613 5435 11 required require VBN 19613 5435 12 . . . 19613 5435 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5436 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5436 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5436 3 415 415 CD 19613 5436 4 : : : 19613 5436 5 But but CC 19613 5436 6 almost almost RB 19613 5436 7 all all PDT 19613 5436 8 the the DT 19613 5436 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5436 10 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 5436 11 that that IN 19613 5436 12 heathendom heathendom NN 19613 5436 13 possessed possess VBD 19613 5436 14 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5436 15 . . . 19613 5437 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 5437 2 recognise recognise VBP 19613 5437 3 these these DT 19613 5437 4 in in IN 19613 5437 5 the the DT 19613 5437 6 Sibyls Sibyls NNP 19613 5437 7 and and CC 19613 5437 8 the the DT 19613 5437 9 old old JJ 19613 5437 10 poets poet NNS 19613 5437 11 . . . 19613 5438 1 The the DT 19613 5438 2 author author NN 19613 5438 3 of of IN 19613 5438 4 the the DT 19613 5438 5 work work NN 19613 5438 6 " " '' 19613 5438 7 de de NNP 19613 5438 8 Monarchia Monarchia NNP 19613 5438 9 " " '' 19613 5438 10 expressed express VBD 19613 5438 11 the the DT 19613 5438 12 most most RBS 19613 5438 13 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 5438 14 views view NNS 19613 5438 15 in in IN 19613 5438 16 regard regard NN 19613 5438 17 to to IN 19613 5438 18 this this DT 19613 5438 19 . . . 19613 5439 1 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 5439 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5439 3 Vis Vis NNP 19613 5439 4 . . . 19613 5440 1 II ii CD 19613 5440 2 . . . 19613 5441 1 4 4 LS 19613 5441 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5441 3 , , , 19613 5441 4 however however RB 19613 5441 5 , , , 19613 5441 6 shows show VBZ 19613 5441 7 that that IN 19613 5441 8 the the DT 19613 5441 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5441 10 owed owe VBD 19613 5441 11 this this DT 19613 5441 12 notion notion NN 19613 5441 13 also also RB 19613 5441 14 to to IN 19613 5441 15 an an DT 19613 5441 16 idea idea NN 19613 5441 17 that that WDT 19613 5441 18 was be VBD 19613 5441 19 widespread widespread JJ 19613 5441 20 among among IN 19613 5441 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 5441 22 people people NNS 19613 5441 23 . . . 19613 5441 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5442 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5442 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5442 3 416 416 CD 19613 5442 4 : : : 19613 5442 5 See see VB 19613 5442 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5442 7 , , , 19613 5442 8 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5442 9 . . . 19613 5443 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5444 1 31 31 CD 19613 5444 2 , , , 19613 5444 3 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5444 4 . . . 19613 5445 1 7 7 CD 19613 5445 2 , , , 19613 5445 3 p. p. NN 19613 5445 4 30 30 CD 19613 5445 5 etc etc FW 19613 5445 6 . . . 19613 5445 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5446 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5446 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5446 3 417 417 CD 19613 5446 4 : : : 19613 5446 5 See see VB 19613 5446 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5446 7 , , , 19613 5446 8 c. c. NNP 19613 5446 9 31 31 CD 19613 5446 10 ff ff NNP 19613 5446 11 . . . 19613 5446 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5447 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5447 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5447 3 418 418 CD 19613 5447 4 : : : 19613 5447 5 In in IN 19613 5447 6 the the DT 19613 5447 7 New New NNP 19613 5447 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5447 9 the the DT 19613 5447 10 content content NN 19613 5447 11 of of IN 19613 5447 12 the the DT 19613 5447 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 5447 14 faith faith NN 19613 5447 15 is be VBZ 19613 5447 16 now now RB 19613 5447 17 here here RB 19613 5447 18 designated designate VBN 19613 5447 19 as as IN 19613 5447 20 dogma dogma NN 19613 5447 21 . . . 19613 5448 1 In in IN 19613 5448 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 5448 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5448 4 I. i. NN 19613 5449 1 11 11 CD 19613 5449 2 . . . 19613 5450 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5450 2 , , , 19613 5450 3 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 5450 4 , , , 19613 5450 5 and and CC 19613 5450 6 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 5450 7 the the DT 19613 5450 8 word word NN 19613 5450 9 is be VBZ 19613 5450 10 not not RB 19613 5450 11 found find VBN 19613 5450 12 at at RB 19613 5450 13 all all RB 19613 5450 14 ; ; : 19613 5450 15 yet yet CC 19613 5450 16 Clement Clement NNP 19613 5450 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5450 18 I. I. NNP 19613 5451 1 20 20 CD 19613 5451 2 . . . 19613 5452 1 4 4 CD 19613 5452 2 , , , 19613 5452 3 27 27 CD 19613 5452 4 . . . 19613 5453 1 5 5 LS 19613 5453 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5453 3 called call VBD 19613 5453 4 the the DT 19613 5453 5 divine divine JJ 19613 5453 6 order order NN 19613 5453 7 of of IN 19613 5453 8 nature nature NN 19613 5453 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5453 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5453 11 : : : 19613 5453 12 ta ta NNP 19613 5453 13 dedogmatismena dedogmatismena NNP 19613 5453 14 hupo hupo VBD 19613 5453 15 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5453 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5453 17 . . . 19613 5454 1 In in IN 19613 5454 2 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 5454 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5454 4 ad ad NN 19613 5454 5 Magn Magn NNP 19613 5454 6 . . . 19613 5455 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 5455 2 . . . 19613 5456 1 1 1 LS 19613 5456 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5456 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5456 4 read read VBP 19613 5456 5 : : : 19613 5456 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5456 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5456 8 : : : 19613 5456 9 spoudazete spoudazete NN 19613 5456 10 oun oun NNP 19613 5456 11 bebaiôthênai bebaiôthênai NNP 19613 5456 12 en en NNP 19613 5456 13 tois tois NNP 19613 5456 14 dogmasin dogmasin NNP 19613 5456 15 tou tou NNP 19613 5456 16 kuriou kuriou NNP 19613 5456 17 kai kai NNP 19613 5456 18 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5456 19 apostolôn apostolôn NNP 19613 5456 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5456 21 , , , 19613 5456 22 but but CC 19613 5456 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5456 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5456 25 : : : 19613 5456 26 dogmata dogmata NN 19613 5456 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5456 28 here here RB 19613 5456 29 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 5456 30 mean mean VBP 19613 5456 31 the the DT 19613 5456 32 rules rule NNS 19613 5456 33 of of IN 19613 5456 34 life life NN 19613 5456 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5456 36 see see VB 19613 5456 37 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 5456 38 on on IN 19613 5456 39 this this DT 19613 5456 40 passage passage NN 19613 5456 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5456 42 , , , 19613 5456 43 and and CC 19613 5456 44 this this DT 19613 5456 45 is be VBZ 19613 5456 46 also also RB 19613 5456 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5456 48 signification signification NN 19613 5456 49 in in IN 19613 5456 50 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5456 51 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5456 52 : : : 19613 5456 53 Didachê didachê NN 19613 5456 54 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5456 55 XI XI NNP 19613 5456 56 . . . 19613 5457 1 3 3 LS 19613 5457 2 . . . 19613 5458 1 In in IN 19613 5458 2 the the DT 19613 5458 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 5458 4 of of IN 19613 5458 5 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 5458 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5458 7 read read VBD 19613 5458 8 in in IN 19613 5458 9 several several JJ 19613 5458 10 passages passage NNS 19613 5458 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5458 12 I. I. NNP 19613 5459 1 6 6 LS 19613 5459 2 : : : 19613 5459 3 IX ix NN 19613 5459 4 . . . 19613 5460 1 7 7 LS 19613 5460 2 : : : 19613 5460 3 X. x. NN 19613 5461 1 1 1 CD 19613 5461 2 , , , 19613 5461 3 9 9 CD 19613 5461 4 f. f. NN 19613 5461 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5461 6 of of IN 19613 5461 7 " " `` 19613 5461 8 dogmas dogmas NNP 19613 5461 9 of of IN 19613 5461 10 the the DT 19613 5461 11 Lord Lord NNP 19613 5461 12 ; ; : 19613 5461 13 " " `` 19613 5461 14 but but CC 19613 5461 15 by by IN 19613 5461 16 these these DT 19613 5461 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5461 18 means mean VBZ 19613 5461 19 partly partly RB 19613 5461 20 particular particular JJ 19613 5461 21 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 5461 22 , , , 19613 5461 23 partly partly RB 19613 5461 24 divine divine JJ 19613 5461 25 dispensations dispensation NNS 19613 5461 26 . . . 19613 5462 1 Hence hence RB 19613 5462 2 the the DT 19613 5462 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5462 4 are be VBP 19613 5462 5 the the DT 19613 5462 6 first first JJ 19613 5462 7 to to TO 19613 5462 8 apply apply VB 19613 5462 9 the the DT 19613 5462 10 word word NN 19613 5462 11 to to IN 19613 5462 12 the the DT 19613 5462 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 5462 14 faith faith NN 19613 5462 15 , , , 19613 5462 16 in in IN 19613 5462 17 accordance accordance NN 19613 5462 18 with with IN 19613 5462 19 the the DT 19613 5462 20 language language NN 19613 5462 21 of of IN 19613 5462 22 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5462 23 . . . 19613 5463 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 5463 2 are be VBP 19613 5463 3 also also RB 19613 5463 4 the the DT 19613 5463 5 first first JJ 19613 5463 6 who who WP 19613 5463 7 employed employ VBD 19613 5463 8 the the DT 19613 5463 9 ideas idea NNS 19613 5463 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5463 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5463 12 : : : 19613 5463 13 theologein theologein NN 19613 5463 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5463 15 and and CC 19613 5463 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5463 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5463 18 : : : 19613 5463 19 theologia theologia NN 19613 5463 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5463 21 . . . 19613 5464 1 The the DT 19613 5464 2 latter latter JJ 19613 5464 3 word word NN 19613 5464 4 is be VBZ 19613 5464 5 twice twice RB 19613 5464 6 found find VBN 19613 5464 7 in in IN 19613 5464 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5464 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5464 10 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5464 11 . . . 19613 5465 1 56 56 LS 19613 5465 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5465 3 in in IN 19613 5465 4 the the DT 19613 5465 5 sense sense NN 19613 5465 6 of of IN 19613 5465 7 " " `` 19613 5465 8 aliquem aliquem NNP 19613 5465 9 nominare nominare NNP 19613 5465 10 deum deum NNP 19613 5465 11 . . . 19613 5465 12 " " '' 19613 5466 1 In in IN 19613 5466 2 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5466 3 . . . 19613 5467 1 113 113 CD 19613 5467 2 , , , 19613 5467 3 however however RB 19613 5467 4 , , , 19613 5467 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5467 6 has have VBZ 19613 5467 7 the the DT 19613 5467 8 more more RBR 19613 5467 9 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 5467 10 sense sense NN 19613 5467 11 of of IN 19613 5467 12 " " `` 19613 5467 13 to to TO 19613 5467 14 make make VB 19613 5467 15 religio religio JJ 19613 5467 16 - - HYPH 19613 5467 17 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5467 18 investigations investigation NNS 19613 5467 19 . . . 19613 5467 20 " " '' 19613 5468 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5468 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5468 3 10 10 CD 19613 5468 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5468 5 also also RB 19613 5468 6 used use VBD 19613 5468 7 the the DT 19613 5468 8 word word NN 19613 5468 9 in in IN 19613 5468 10 the the DT 19613 5468 11 first first JJ 19613 5468 12 sense sense NN 19613 5468 13 ; ; : 19613 5468 14 on on IN 19613 5468 15 the the DT 19613 5468 16 contrary contrary NN 19613 5468 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5468 18 entitled entitle VBD 19613 5468 19 a a DT 19613 5468 20 book book NN 19613 5468 21 of of IN 19613 5468 22 which which WDT 19613 5468 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5468 24 was be VBD 19613 5468 25 the the DT 19613 5468 26 author author NN 19613 5468 27 " " '' 19613 5468 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5468 29 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5468 30 : : : 19613 5468 31 pros pro NNS 19613 5468 32 tous tous JJ 19613 5468 33 apophênamenous apophênamenous JJ 19613 5468 34 ta ta NNP 19613 5468 35 peri peri NN 19613 5468 36 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5468 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5468 38 " " `` 19613 5468 39 and and CC 19613 5468 40 not not RB 19613 5468 41 " " '' 19613 5468 42 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5468 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5468 44 : : : 19613 5468 45 pros pro NNS 19613 5468 46 tous tous JJ 19613 5468 47 theologountas theologountas NNP 19613 5468 48 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5468 49 " " '' 19613 5468 50 . . . 19613 5469 1 In in IN 19613 5469 2 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 5469 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5469 4 Suppl Suppl NNP 19613 5469 5 . . . 19613 5470 1 10 10 LS 19613 5470 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5470 3 theology theology NN 19613 5470 4 is be VBZ 19613 5470 5 the the DT 19613 5470 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5470 7 of of IN 19613 5470 8 God God NNP 19613 5470 9 and and CC 19613 5470 10 of of IN 19613 5470 11 all all DT 19613 5470 12 beings being NNS 19613 5470 13 to to TO 19613 5470 14 whom whom WP 19613 5470 15 the the DT 19613 5470 16 predicate predicate NN 19613 5470 17 " " `` 19613 5470 18 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5470 19 " " '' 19613 5470 20 belongs belong VBZ 19613 5470 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5470 22 see see VB 19613 5470 23 also also RB 19613 5470 24 20 20 CD 19613 5470 25 , , , 19613 5470 26 22 22 CD 19613 5470 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5470 28 . . . 19613 5471 1 That that DT 19613 5471 2 is be VBZ 19613 5471 3 the the DT 19613 5471 4 old old JJ 19613 5471 5 usage usage NN 19613 5471 6 of of IN 19613 5471 7 the the DT 19613 5471 8 word word NN 19613 5471 9 . . . 19613 5472 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5472 2 was be VBD 19613 5472 3 thus thus RB 19613 5472 4 employed employ VBN 19613 5472 5 by by IN 19613 5472 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5472 7 in in IN 19613 5472 8 ad ad NN 19613 5472 9 nat nat NN 19613 5472 10 . . . 19613 5473 1 II ii CD 19613 5473 2 . . . 19613 5474 1 1 1 LS 19613 5474 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5474 3 the the DT 19613 5474 4 threefold threefold JJ 19613 5474 5 division division NN 19613 5474 6 of of IN 19613 5474 7 theology theology NN 19613 5474 8 ; ; : 19613 5474 9 in in IN 19613 5474 10 II II NNP 19613 5474 11 . . . 19613 5475 1 2 2 CD 19613 5475 2 , , , 19613 5475 3 3 3 CD 19613 5475 4 the the DT 19613 5475 5 expression expression NN 19613 5475 6 " " `` 19613 5475 7 theologia theologia NNP 19613 5475 8 physica physica NNP 19613 5475 9 , , , 19613 5475 10 mythica mythica NNP 19613 5475 11 " " `` 19613 5475 12 refers refer VBZ 19613 5475 13 to to IN 19613 5475 14 this this DT 19613 5475 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5475 16 ; ; : 19613 5475 17 Cohort cohort NN 19613 5475 18 , , , 19613 5475 19 ad ad NN 19613 5475 20 Gr Gr NNP 19613 5475 21 . . . 19613 5476 1 3 3 CD 19613 5476 2 , , , 19613 5476 3 22 22 CD 19613 5476 4 . . . 19613 5477 1 The the DT 19613 5477 2 anonymous anonymous JJ 19613 5477 3 writer writer NN 19613 5477 4 in in IN 19613 5477 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 5477 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5477 7 H. H. NNP 19613 5477 8 E. E. NNP 19613 5477 9 V. V. NNP 19613 5477 10 28 28 CD 19613 5477 11 . . . 19613 5478 1 4 4 CD 19613 5478 2 , , , 19613 5478 3 5 5 CD 19613 5478 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5478 5 is be VBZ 19613 5478 6 instructive instructive JJ 19613 5478 7 on on IN 19613 5478 8 the the DT 19613 5478 9 point point NN 19613 5478 10 . . . 19613 5479 1 Brilliant brilliant JJ 19613 5479 2 demonstrations demonstration NNS 19613 5479 3 of of IN 19613 5479 4 the the DT 19613 5479 5 ancient ancient JJ 19613 5479 6 use use NN 19613 5479 7 of of IN 19613 5479 8 the the DT 19613 5479 9 word word NN 19613 5479 10 " " `` 19613 5479 11 theology theology NN 19613 5479 12 " " '' 19613 5479 13 are be VBP 19613 5479 14 found find VBN 19613 5479 15 in in IN 19613 5479 16 Natorp Natorp NNP 19613 5479 17 , , , 19613 5479 18 Thema Thema NNP 19613 5479 19 und und JJ 19613 5479 20 Disposition Disposition NNP 19613 5479 21 der der NN 19613 5479 22 aristotelischen aristotelischen NNP 19613 5479 23 Metaphysik Metaphysik NNP 19613 5479 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5479 25 Philosophische Philosophische NNP 19613 5479 26 Monatshefte Monatshefte NNP 19613 5479 27 , , , 19613 5479 28 1887 1887 CD 19613 5479 29 , , , 19613 5479 30 Parts Parts NNP 19613 5479 31 I -PRON- PRP 19613 5479 32 and and CC 19613 5479 33 2 2 CD 19613 5479 34 , , , 19613 5479 35 pp pp NNP 19613 5479 36 . . . 19613 5480 1 55 55 CD 19613 5480 2 - - SYM 19613 5480 3 64 64 CD 19613 5480 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5480 5 . . . 19613 5481 1 The the DT 19613 5481 2 title title NN 19613 5481 3 " " `` 19613 5481 4 theology theology NN 19613 5481 5 , , , 19613 5481 6 " " '' 19613 5481 7 as as IN 19613 5481 8 applied apply VBN 19613 5481 9 to to IN 19613 5481 10 a a DT 19613 5481 11 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 5481 12 discipline discipline NN 19613 5481 13 , , , 19613 5481 14 was be VBD 19613 5481 15 first first RB 19613 5481 16 used use VBN 19613 5481 17 by by IN 19613 5481 18 the the DT 19613 5481 19 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5481 20 ; ; : 19613 5481 21 the the DT 19613 5481 22 old old JJ 19613 5481 23 poets poet NNS 19613 5481 24 were be VBD 19613 5481 25 previously previously RB 19613 5481 26 called call VBN 19613 5481 27 " " `` 19613 5481 28 theologians theologian NNS 19613 5481 29 , , , 19613 5481 30 " " '' 19613 5481 31 and and CC 19613 5481 32 the the DT 19613 5481 33 " " `` 19613 5481 34 theological theological JJ 19613 5481 35 " " '' 19613 5481 36 stage stage NN 19613 5481 37 was be VBD 19613 5481 38 the the DT 19613 5481 39 prescientific prescientific NN 19613 5481 40 one one CD 19613 5481 41 which which WDT 19613 5481 42 is be VBZ 19613 5481 43 even even RB 19613 5481 44 earlier early JJR 19613 5481 45 than than IN 19613 5481 46 the the DT 19613 5481 47 " " `` 19613 5481 48 childhood childhood NN 19613 5481 49 " " '' 19613 5481 50 of of IN 19613 5481 51 " " `` 19613 5481 52 physicists physicist NNS 19613 5481 53 " " '' 19613 5481 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5481 55 so so RB 19613 5481 56 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 19613 5481 57 speaks speak VBZ 19613 5481 58 throughout throughout IN 19613 5481 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5481 60 . . . 19613 5482 1 To to IN 19613 5482 2 the the DT 19613 5482 3 Fathers father NNS 19613 5482 4 of of IN 19613 5482 5 the the DT 19613 5482 6 Church Church NNP 19613 5482 7 also also RB 19613 5482 8 the the DT 19613 5482 9 old old JJ 19613 5482 10 poets poet NNS 19613 5482 11 are be VBP 19613 5482 12 still still RB 19613 5482 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5482 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5482 15 : : : 19613 5482 16 hoi hoi NNP 19613 5482 17 palaioi palaioi NNP 19613 5482 18 theologoi theologoi NN 19613 5482 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5482 20 . . . 19613 5483 1 But but CC 19613 5483 2 side side NN 19613 5483 3 by by IN 19613 5483 4 side side NN 19613 5483 5 with with IN 19613 5483 6 this this DT 19613 5483 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5483 8 have have VBP 19613 5483 9 an an DT 19613 5483 10 adoption adoption NN 19613 5483 11 of of IN 19613 5483 12 the the DT 19613 5483 13 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 5483 14 view view NN 19613 5483 15 that that IN 19613 5483 16 there there EX 19613 5483 17 is be VBZ 19613 5483 18 also also RB 19613 5483 19 a a DT 19613 5483 20 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5483 21 theology theology NN 19613 5483 22 , , , 19613 5483 23 because because IN 19613 5483 24 the the DT 19613 5483 25 teaching teaching NN 19613 5483 26 of of IN 19613 5483 27 the the DT 19613 5483 28 old old JJ 19613 5483 29 poets poet NNS 19613 5483 30 concerning concern VBG 19613 5483 31 the the DT 19613 5483 32 gods god NNS 19613 5483 33 conceals conceal NNS 19613 5483 34 under under IN 19613 5483 35 the the DT 19613 5483 36 veil veil NN 19613 5483 37 of of IN 19613 5483 38 myth myth VB 19613 5483 39 a a DT 19613 5483 40 treasure treasure NN 19613 5483 41 of of IN 19613 5483 42 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5483 43 truth truth NN 19613 5483 44 . . . 19613 5484 1 In in IN 19613 5484 2 the the DT 19613 5484 3 Stoa Stoa NNP 19613 5484 4 arose arise VBD 19613 5484 5 the the DT 19613 5484 6 " " `` 19613 5484 7 impossible impossible JJ 19613 5484 8 idea idea NN 19613 5484 9 of of IN 19613 5484 10 a a DT 19613 5484 11 ' ' `` 19613 5484 12 theology theology NN 19613 5484 13 ' ' '' 19613 5484 14 which which WDT 19613 5484 15 is be VBZ 19613 5484 16 to to TO 19613 5484 17 be be VB 19613 5484 18 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5484 19 , , , 19613 5484 20 that that RB 19613 5484 21 is is RB 19613 5484 22 , , , 19613 5484 23 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5484 24 based base VBN 19613 5484 25 on on IN 19613 5484 26 reason reason NN 19613 5484 27 , , , 19613 5484 28 and and CC 19613 5484 29 yet yet RB 19613 5484 30 to to TO 19613 5484 31 have have VB 19613 5484 32 positive positive JJ 19613 5484 33 religion religion NN 19613 5484 34 as as IN 19613 5484 35 the the DT 19613 5484 36 foundation foundation NN 19613 5484 37 of of IN 19613 5484 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5484 39 certainty certainty NN 19613 5484 40 . . . 19613 5484 41 " " '' 19613 5485 1 The the DT 19613 5485 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5485 3 accepted accept VBD 19613 5485 4 this this DT 19613 5485 5 , , , 19613 5485 6 but but CC 19613 5485 7 added add VBD 19613 5485 8 to to IN 19613 5485 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5485 10 the the DT 19613 5485 11 distinction distinction NN 19613 5485 12 of of IN 19613 5485 13 a a DT 19613 5485 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5485 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5485 16 : : : 19613 5485 17 kosmikê kosmikê NNP 19613 5485 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5485 19 and and CC 19613 5485 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5485 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5485 22 : : : 19613 5485 23 theologikê theologikê NNP 19613 5485 24 sophia sophia NNP 19613 5485 25 . . . 19613 5485 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5485 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5486 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5486 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5486 3 419 419 CD 19613 5486 4 : : : 19613 5486 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5486 6 has have VBZ 19613 5486 7 a a DT 19613 5486 8 relation relation NN 19613 5486 9 to to IN 19613 5486 10 all all DT 19613 5486 11 three three CD 19613 5486 12 parts part NNS 19613 5486 13 of of IN 19613 5486 14 the the DT 19613 5486 15 scheme scheme NN 19613 5486 16 , , , 19613 5486 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5486 18 1 1 LS 19613 5486 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5486 20 as as IN 19613 5486 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5486 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5486 23 : : : 19613 5486 24 logos logo NNS 19613 5486 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5486 26 ; ; , 19613 5486 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5486 28 2 2 LS 19613 5486 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5486 30 as as IN 19613 5486 31 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5486 32 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5486 33 : : : 19613 5486 34 nomos nomo NNS 19613 5486 35 , , , 19613 5486 36 nomothetês nomothetês NNP 19613 5486 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5486 38 , , , 19613 5486 39 and and CC 19613 5486 40 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5486 41 Greek greek JJ 19613 5486 42 : : : 19613 5486 43 kritês kritês NN 19613 5486 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5486 45 ; ; , 19613 5486 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5486 47 3 3 LS 19613 5486 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5486 49 as as IN 19613 5486 50 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5486 51 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5486 52 : : : 19613 5486 53 didaskalos didaskalos NNP 19613 5486 54 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5486 55 and and CC 19613 5486 56 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5486 57 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5486 58 : : : 19613 5486 59 sotêr sotêr NNP 19613 5486 60 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5486 61 . . . 19613 5486 62 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5487 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5487 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5487 3 420 420 CD 19613 5487 4 : : : 19613 5487 5 In in IN 19613 5487 6 the the DT 19613 5487 7 reproduction reproduction NN 19613 5487 8 of of IN 19613 5487 9 the the DT 19613 5487 10 apologetical apologetical JJ 19613 5487 11 theology theology NN 19613 5487 12 historians historians NNPS 19613 5487 13 of of IN 19613 5487 14 dogma dogma NNP 19613 5487 15 have have VBP 19613 5487 16 preferred prefer VBN 19613 5487 17 to to TO 19613 5487 18 follow follow VB 19613 5487 19 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5487 20 ; ; : 19613 5487 21 but but CC 19613 5487 22 here here RB 19613 5487 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5487 24 have have VBP 19613 5487 25 constantly constantly RB 19613 5487 26 overlooked overlook VBN 19613 5487 27 the the DT 19613 5487 28 fact fact NN 19613 5487 29 that that IN 19613 5487 30 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5487 31 was be VBD 19613 5487 32 the the DT 19613 5487 33 most most RBS 19613 5487 34 Christian christian JJ 19613 5487 35 among among IN 19613 5487 36 the the DT 19613 5487 37 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5487 38 , , , 19613 5487 39 and and CC 19613 5487 40 that that IN 19613 5487 41 the the DT 19613 5487 42 features feature NNS 19613 5487 43 of of IN 19613 5487 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5487 45 teaching teaching NN 19613 5487 46 to to TO 19613 5487 47 which which WDT 19613 5487 48 particular particular JJ 19613 5487 49 value value NN 19613 5487 50 is be VBZ 19613 5487 51 rightly rightly RB 19613 5487 52 attached attach VBN 19613 5487 53 , , , 19613 5487 54 are be VBP 19613 5487 55 either either RB 19613 5487 56 not not RB 19613 5487 57 found find VBN 19613 5487 58 in in IN 19613 5487 59 the the DT 19613 5487 60 others other NNS 19613 5487 61 at at RB 19613 5487 62 all all RB 19613 5487 63 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5487 64 with with IN 19613 5487 65 the the DT 19613 5487 66 exception exception NN 19613 5487 67 of of IN 19613 5487 68 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5487 69 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5487 70 , , , 19613 5487 71 or or CC 19613 5487 72 else else RB 19613 5487 73 in in IN 19613 5487 74 quite quite JJ 19613 5487 75 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 5487 76 form form NN 19613 5487 77 . . . 19613 5488 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5488 2 is be VBZ 19613 5488 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 5488 4 proper proper JJ 19613 5488 5 to to TO 19613 5488 6 put put VB 19613 5488 7 the the DT 19613 5488 8 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5488 9 common common JJ 19613 5488 10 to to IN 19613 5488 11 all all PDT 19613 5488 12 the the DT 19613 5488 13 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5488 14 in in IN 19613 5488 15 the the DT 19613 5488 16 foreground foreground NN 19613 5488 17 , , , 19613 5488 18 and and CC 19613 5488 19 to to TO 19613 5488 20 describe describe VB 19613 5488 21 what what WP 19613 5488 22 is be VBZ 19613 5488 23 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 5488 24 to to IN 19613 5488 25 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5488 26 as as IN 19613 5488 27 such such JJ 19613 5488 28 , , , 19613 5488 29 so so RB 19613 5488 30 far far RB 19613 5488 31 as as IN 19613 5488 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5488 33 agree agree VBP 19613 5488 34 with with IN 19613 5488 35 New New NNP 19613 5488 36 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5488 37 teachings teaching NNS 19613 5488 38 or or CC 19613 5488 39 contains contain VBZ 19613 5488 40 an an DT 19613 5488 41 anticipation anticipation NN 19613 5488 42 of of IN 19613 5488 43 the the DT 19613 5488 44 future future JJ 19613 5488 45 tenor tenor NN 19613 5488 46 of of IN 19613 5488 47 dogma dogma NN 19613 5488 48 . . . 19613 5488 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5489 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5489 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5489 3 421 421 CD 19613 5489 4 : : : 19613 5489 5 Cicero Cicero NNP 19613 5489 6 's 's POS 19613 5489 7 proposition proposition NN 19613 5489 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5489 9 de de FW 19613 5489 10 nat nat NNP 19613 5489 11 . . . 19613 5490 1 deor deor JJ 19613 5490 2 . . . 19613 5491 1 II ii CD 19613 5491 2 . . . 19613 5492 1 66 66 CD 19613 5492 2 . . . 19613 5493 1 167 167 CD 19613 5493 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5493 3 : : : 19613 5493 4 " " `` 19613 5493 5 nemo nemo NNP 19613 5493 6 vir vir NNP 19613 5493 7 magnus magnus NNP 19613 5493 8 sine sine NNP 19613 5493 9 aliquo aliquo NNP 19613 5493 10 afflatu afflatu NNP 19613 5493 11 divino divino NNP 19613 5493 12 unquam unquam NNP 19613 5493 13 fuit fuit NN 19613 5493 14 , , , 19613 5493 15 " " '' 19613 5493 16 which which WDT 19613 5493 17 was be VBD 19613 5493 18 the the DT 19613 5493 19 property property NN 19613 5493 20 of of IN 19613 5493 21 all all PDT 19613 5493 22 the the DT 19613 5493 23 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 5493 24 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 5493 25 of of IN 19613 5493 26 the the DT 19613 5493 27 age age NN 19613 5493 28 , , , 19613 5493 29 is be VBZ 19613 5493 30 found find VBN 19613 5493 31 in in IN 19613 5493 32 the the DT 19613 5493 33 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5493 34 reproduced reproduce VBN 19613 5493 35 in in IN 19613 5493 36 the the DT 19613 5493 37 most most RBS 19613 5493 38 various various JJ 19613 5493 39 forms form NNS 19613 5493 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5493 41 see see VB 19613 5493 42 , , , 19613 5493 43 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 5493 44 , , , 19613 5493 45 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5493 46 29 29 CD 19613 5493 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5493 48 . . . 19613 5494 1 That that IN 19613 5494 2 all all DT 19613 5494 3 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5494 4 of of IN 19613 5494 5 the the DT 19613 5494 6 truth truth NN 19613 5494 7 , , , 19613 5494 8 both both CC 19613 5494 9 among among IN 19613 5494 10 the the DT 19613 5494 11 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5494 12 and and CC 19613 5494 13 those those DT 19613 5494 14 who who WP 19613 5494 15 follow follow VBP 19613 5494 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5494 17 teaching teaching NN 19613 5494 18 , , , 19613 5494 19 is be VBZ 19613 5494 20 derived derive VBN 19613 5494 21 from from IN 19613 5494 22 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 5494 23 was be VBD 19613 5494 24 in in IN 19613 5494 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5494 26 eyes eye NNS 19613 5494 27 a a DT 19613 5494 28 matter matter NN 19613 5494 29 of of IN 19613 5494 30 certainty certainty NN 19613 5494 31 . . . 19613 5495 1 But but CC 19613 5495 2 here here RB 19613 5495 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5495 4 were be VBD 19613 5495 5 only only RB 19613 5495 6 able able JJ 19613 5495 7 to to TO 19613 5495 8 frame frame VB 19613 5495 9 a a DT 19613 5495 10 theory theory NN 19613 5495 11 in in IN 19613 5495 12 the the DT 19613 5495 13 case case NN 19613 5495 14 of of IN 19613 5495 15 the the DT 19613 5495 16 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5495 17 ; ; : 19613 5495 18 for for IN 19613 5495 19 such such PDT 19613 5495 20 a a DT 19613 5495 21 theory theory NN 19613 5495 22 strictly strictly RB 19613 5495 23 applied apply VBN 19613 5495 24 to to IN 19613 5495 25 all all DT 19613 5495 26 would would MD 19613 5495 27 have have VB 19613 5495 28 threatened threaten VBN 19613 5495 29 the the DT 19613 5495 30 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 19613 5495 31 character character NN 19613 5495 32 of of IN 19613 5495 33 the the DT 19613 5495 34 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5495 35 of of IN 19613 5495 36 the the DT 19613 5495 37 truth truth NN 19613 5495 38 . . . 19613 5495 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5496 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5496 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5496 3 422 422 CD 19613 5496 4 : : : 19613 5496 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5496 6 , , , 19613 5496 7 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5496 8 . . . 19613 5497 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5498 1 3 3 LS 19613 5498 2 : : : 19613 5498 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5498 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5498 5 : : : 19613 5498 6 Hêmeteron Hêmeteron NNP 19613 5498 7 oun oun NNP 19613 5498 8 ergon ergon NNP 19613 5498 9 kai kai NNP 19613 5498 10 biou biou NNP 19613 5498 11 kai kai NNP 19613 5498 12 mathêmatôn mathêmatôn NNP 19613 5498 13 tên tên NNP 19613 5498 14 episkepsin episkepsin NNP 19613 5498 15 pasi pasi NNP 19613 5498 16 parechein parechein NN 19613 5498 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5498 18 . . . 19613 5498 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5499 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5499 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5499 3 423 423 CD 19613 5499 4 : : : 19613 5499 5 See see VB 19613 5499 6 the the DT 19613 5499 7 exposition exposition NN 19613 5499 8 of of IN 19613 5499 9 the the DT 19613 5499 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5499 11 of of IN 19613 5499 12 God God NNP 19613 5499 13 in in IN 19613 5499 14 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 5499 15 with with IN 19613 5499 16 the the DT 19613 5499 17 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 5499 18 found find VBN 19613 5499 19 in in IN 19613 5499 20 all all PDT 19613 5499 21 the the DT 19613 5499 22 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5499 23 , , , 19613 5499 24 that that IN 19613 5499 25 God God NNP 19613 5499 26 requires require VBZ 19613 5499 27 no no DT 19613 5499 28 offerings offering NNS 19613 5499 29 and and CC 19613 5499 30 presents present NNS 19613 5499 31 . . . 19613 5499 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5500 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5500 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5500 3 424 424 CD 19613 5500 4 : : : 19613 5500 5 Even even RB 19613 5500 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5500 7 says say VBZ 19613 5500 8 in in IN 19613 5500 9 c. c. NNP 19613 5500 10 19 19 CD 19613 5500 11 : : : 19613 5500 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5500 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5500 14 : : : 19613 5500 15 Kosmou kosmou NN 19613 5500 16 men man NNS 19613 5500 17 gar gar NNP 19613 5500 18 ê ê NNP 19613 5500 19 kataskeuê kataskeuê NNP 19613 5500 20 kalê kalê NNP 19613 5500 21 , , , 19613 5500 22 to to IN 19613 5500 23 de de NNP 19613 5500 24 en en NNP 19613 5500 25 autô autô NNP 19613 5500 26 politeuma politeuma NNP 19613 5500 27 phaulon phaulon NNP 19613 5500 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5500 29 . . . 19613 5500 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5501 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5501 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5501 3 425 425 CD 19613 5501 4 : : : 19613 5501 5 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5501 6 5 5 CD 19613 5501 7 : : : 19613 5501 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5501 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5501 10 : : : 19613 5501 11 Oute Oute NNP 19613 5501 12 anarchos anarchos NNP 19613 5501 13 ê ê DT 19613 5501 14 hulê hulê NNP 19613 5501 15 kathaper kathaper NNP 19613 5501 16 ho ho NNP 19613 5501 17 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5501 18 , , , 19613 5501 19 oude oude NN 19613 5501 20 dia dia NN 19613 5501 21 to to IN 19613 5501 22 anarchon anarchon NNP 19613 5501 23 kai kai NNP 19613 5501 24 autê autê NNP 19613 5501 25 isodunamos isodunamos NNP 19613 5501 26 tô tô NNP 19613 5501 27 Theô Theô NNP 19613 5501 28 gennêtê gennêtê JJ 19613 5501 29 de de NNP 19613 5501 30 kai kai NNP 19613 5501 31 ouch ouch NNP 19613 5501 32 hupo hupo NNP 19613 5501 33 tou tou NNP 19613 5501 34 allou allou NNP 19613 5501 35 gegonuia gegonuia NNP 19613 5501 36 monon monon NNP 19613 5501 37 de de NNP 19613 5501 38 hupo hupo NNP 19613 5501 39 tou tou NNP 19613 5501 40 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 5501 41 dêmiourgou dêmiourgou NNP 19613 5501 42 probeblêmenê probeblêmenê NNP 19613 5501 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5501 44 . . . 19613 5502 1 12 12 CD 19613 5502 2 . . . 19613 5503 1 Even even RB 19613 5503 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5503 3 does do VBZ 19613 5503 4 not not RB 19613 5503 5 seem seem VB 19613 5503 6 to to TO 19613 5503 7 have have VB 19613 5503 8 taught teach VBN 19613 5503 9 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 5503 10 , , , 19613 5503 11 though though IN 19613 5503 12 that that DT 19613 5503 13 is be VBZ 19613 5503 14 not not RB 19613 5503 15 quite quite RB 19613 5503 16 certain certain JJ 19613 5503 17 ; ; : 19613 5503 18 see see VB 19613 5503 19 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5503 20 . . . 19613 5504 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5505 1 10 10 CD 19613 5505 2 , , , 19613 5505 3 59 59 CD 19613 5505 4 , , , 19613 5505 5 64 64 CD 19613 5505 6 , , , 19613 5505 7 67 67 CD 19613 5505 8 : : : 19613 5505 9 II ii CD 19613 5505 10 . . . 19613 5506 1 6 6 CD 19613 5506 2 . . . 19613 5507 1 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5507 2 I. I. NNP 19613 5508 1 4 4 LS 19613 5508 2 : : : 19613 5508 3 II ii CD 19613 5508 4 . . . 19613 5509 1 4 4 CD 19613 5509 2 , , , 19613 5509 3 10 10 CD 19613 5509 4 , , , 19613 5509 5 13 13 CD 19613 5509 6 says say VBZ 19613 5509 7 very very RB 19613 5509 8 plainly plainly RB 19613 5509 9 : : : 19613 5509 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5509 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5509 12 : : : 19613 5509 13 ex ex NNP 19613 5509 14 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5509 15 ontôn ontôn NNP 19613 5509 16 ta ta NNP 19613 5509 17 panta panta NNP 19613 5509 18 epoiêsen epoiêsen NNP 19613 5509 19 .... .... NFP 19613 5509 20 ti ti NNP 19613 5509 21 de de NNP 19613 5509 22 mega mega NNP 19613 5509 23 , , , 19613 5509 24 ei ei NNP 19613 5509 25 ho ho NNP 19613 5509 26 theos theos NNP 19613 5509 27 ex ex FW 19613 5509 28 hupokeimenês hupokeimenês NNP 19613 5509 29 hulês hulês NNPS 19613 5509 30 epoiei epoiei NNP 19613 5509 31 ton ton NNP 19613 5509 32 kosmon kosmon NNP 19613 5509 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5509 34 . . . 19613 5509 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5510 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5510 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5510 3 426 426 CD 19613 5510 4 : : : 19613 5510 5 Hence hence RB 19613 5510 6 the the DT 19613 5510 7 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5510 8 of of IN 19613 5510 9 God God NNP 19613 5510 10 and and CC 19613 5510 11 the the DT 19613 5510 12 right right JJ 19613 5510 13 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5510 14 of of IN 19613 5510 15 the the DT 19613 5510 16 world world NN 19613 5510 17 are be VBP 19613 5510 18 most most RBS 19613 5510 19 closely closely RB 19613 5510 20 connected connected JJ 19613 5510 21 ; ; : 19613 5510 22 see see VB 19613 5510 23 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5510 24 27 27 CD 19613 5510 25 : : : 19613 5510 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5510 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5510 28 : : : 19613 5510 29 hê hê VB 19613 5510 30 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5510 31 katalêpsis katalêpsis NN 19613 5510 32 ên ên NNP 19613 5510 33 echô echô NNP 19613 5510 34 peri peri NNP 19613 5510 35 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5510 36 holôn holôn NNP 19613 5510 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5510 38 . . . 19613 5510 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5511 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5511 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5511 3 427 427 CD 19613 5511 4 : : : 19613 5511 5 The the DT 19613 5511 6 beginning beginning NN 19613 5511 7 of of IN 19613 5511 8 the the DT 19613 5511 9 fifth fifth JJ 19613 5511 10 chapter chapter NN 19613 5511 11 of of IN 19613 5511 12 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5511 13 's 's POS 19613 5511 14 Oration Oration NNP 19613 5511 15 is be VBZ 19613 5511 16 specially specially RB 19613 5511 17 instructive instructive JJ 19613 5511 18 here here RB 19613 5511 19 . . . 19613 5511 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5512 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5512 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5512 3 428 428 CD 19613 5512 4 : : : 19613 5512 5 According accord VBG 19613 5512 6 to to IN 19613 5512 7 what what WP 19613 5512 8 has have VBZ 19613 5512 9 been be VBN 19613 5512 10 set set VBN 19613 5512 11 forth forth RP 19613 5512 12 in in IN 19613 5512 13 the the DT 19613 5512 14 text text NN 19613 5512 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5512 16 is be VBZ 19613 5512 17 incorrect incorrect JJ 19613 5512 18 to to TO 19613 5512 19 assert assert VB 19613 5512 20 that that IN 19613 5512 21 the the DT 19613 5512 22 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5512 23 adopted adopt VBD 19613 5512 24 the the DT 19613 5512 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5512 26 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5512 27 in in IN 19613 5512 28 order order NN 19613 5512 29 to to TO 19613 5512 30 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 5512 31 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 5512 32 with with IN 19613 5512 33 the the DT 19613 5512 34 divine divine JJ 19613 5512 35 honours honour NNS 19613 5512 36 paid pay VBN 19613 5512 37 to to IN 19613 5512 38 the the DT 19613 5512 39 crucified crucify VBN 19613 5512 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5512 41 . . . 19613 5513 1 The the DT 19613 5513 2 truth truth NN 19613 5513 3 rather rather RB 19613 5513 4 is be VBZ 19613 5513 5 that that IN 19613 5513 6 the the DT 19613 5513 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5513 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5513 9 was be VBD 19613 5513 10 already already RB 19613 5513 11 part part NN 19613 5513 12 of of IN 19613 5513 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5513 14 creed creed NN 19613 5513 15 before before IN 19613 5513 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5513 17 gave give VBD 19613 5513 18 any any DT 19613 5513 19 consideration consideration NN 19613 5513 20 to to IN 19613 5513 21 the the DT 19613 5513 22 person person NN 19613 5513 23 of of IN 19613 5513 24 the the DT 19613 5513 25 historical historical JJ 19613 5513 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5513 27 , , , 19613 5513 28 and and CC 19613 5513 29 _ _ NNP 19613 5513 30 vice vice NN 19613 5513 31 versâ versâ NN 19613 5513 32 _ _ NNP 19613 5513 33 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5513 34 's 's POS 19613 5513 35 right right NN 19613 5513 36 to to TO 19613 5513 37 divine divine JJ 19613 5513 38 honours honour NNS 19613 5513 39 was be VBD 19613 5513 40 to to IN 19613 5513 41 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5513 42 a a DT 19613 5513 43 matter matter NN 19613 5513 44 of of IN 19613 5513 45 certainty certainty NN 19613 5513 46 independently independently RB 19613 5513 47 of of IN 19613 5513 48 the the DT 19613 5513 49 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5513 50 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5513 51 . . . 19613 5513 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5514 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5514 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5514 3 429 429 CD 19613 5514 4 : : : 19613 5514 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5514 6 find find VBP 19613 5514 7 the the DT 19613 5514 8 distinction distinction NN 19613 5514 9 of of IN 19613 5514 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5514 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5514 12 Son Son NNP 19613 5514 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5514 14 and and CC 19613 5514 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5514 16 in in IN 19613 5514 17 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5514 18 , , , 19613 5514 19 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5514 20 . . . 19613 5515 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5516 1 5 5 CD 19613 5516 2 , , , 19613 5516 3 and and CC 19613 5516 4 in in IN 19613 5516 5 every every DT 19613 5516 6 case case NN 19613 5516 7 where where WRB 19613 5516 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5516 9 quotes quote VBZ 19613 5516 10 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5516 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5516 12 if if IN 19613 5516 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5516 14 are be VBP 19613 5516 15 not not RB 19613 5516 16 to to TO 19613 5516 17 assume assume VB 19613 5516 18 the the DT 19613 5516 19 existence existence NN 19613 5516 20 of of IN 19613 5516 21 interpolation interpolation NN 19613 5516 22 in in IN 19613 5516 23 the the DT 19613 5516 24 text text NN 19613 5516 25 , , , 19613 5516 26 which which WDT 19613 5516 27 seems seem VBZ 19613 5516 28 to to IN 19613 5516 29 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5516 30 not not RB 19613 5516 31 improbable improbable JJ 19613 5516 32 ; ; : 19613 5516 33 see see VB 19613 5516 34 now now RB 19613 5516 35 also also RB 19613 5516 36 Cramer Cramer NNP 19613 5516 37 in in IN 19613 5516 38 the the DT 19613 5516 39 Theologische Theologische NNP 19613 5516 40 Studien Studien NNP 19613 5516 41 , , , 19613 5516 42 1893 1893 CD 19613 5516 43 . . . 19613 5516 44 pp pp NNP 19613 5516 45 . . . 19613 5517 1 17 17 CD 19613 5517 2 ff ff NNP 19613 5517 3 . . NNP 19613 5517 4 , , , 19613 5517 5 138 138 CD 19613 5517 6 ff ff NNS 19613 5517 7 . . . 19613 5517 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5517 9 . . . 19613 5518 1 In in IN 19613 5518 2 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5518 3 13 13 CD 19613 5518 4 fin fin NN 19613 5518 5 . . . 19613 5519 1 the the DT 19613 5519 2 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5519 3 is be VBZ 19613 5519 4 represented represent VBN 19613 5519 5 as as IN 19613 5519 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5519 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5519 8 : : : 19613 5519 9 ho ho NNP 19613 5519 10 diakonos diakonos NNP 19613 5519 11 tou tou NNP 19613 5519 12 peponthotos peponthoto NNS 19613 5519 13 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5519 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5519 15 . . . 19613 5520 1 The the DT 19613 5520 2 conception conception NN 19613 5520 3 in in IN 19613 5520 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5520 5 , , , 19613 5520 6 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5520 7 . . . 19613 5521 1 116 116 CD 19613 5521 2 , , , 19613 5521 3 is be VBZ 19613 5521 4 similar similar JJ 19613 5521 5 . . . 19613 5522 1 Father Father NNP 19613 5522 2 , , , 19613 5522 3 Word Word NNP 19613 5522 4 , , , 19613 5522 5 and and CC 19613 5522 6 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 5522 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5522 8 are be VBP 19613 5522 9 spoken speak VBN 19613 5522 10 of of IN 19613 5522 11 in in IN 19613 5522 12 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 5522 13 . . . 19613 5523 1 10 10 CD 19613 5523 2 . . . 19613 5524 1 The the DT 19613 5524 2 express express JJ 19613 5524 3 designation designation NN 19613 5524 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5524 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5524 6 : : : 19613 5524 7 trias tria NNS 19613 5524 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5524 9 is be VBZ 19613 5524 10 first first RB 19613 5524 11 found find VBN 19613 5524 12 in in IN 19613 5524 13 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5524 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5524 15 but but CC 19613 5524 16 see see VB 19613 5524 17 the the DT 19613 5524 18 Excerpta Excerpta NNP 19613 5524 19 ex ex NNP 19613 5524 20 Theodoto Theodoto NNP 19613 5524 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5524 22 ; ; : 19613 5524 23 see see VB 19613 5524 24 II II NNP 19613 5524 25 . . . 19613 5525 1 15 15 CD 19613 5525 2 : : : 19613 5525 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5525 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5525 5 : : : 19613 5525 6 hai hai NNP 19613 5525 7 treis treis NNP 19613 5525 8 hêmerai hêmerai NNP 19613 5525 9 tupoi tupoi NNP 19613 5525 10 heisin heisin NNP 19613 5525 11 tês tês NNP 19613 5525 12 triados triados NNP 19613 5525 13 , , , 19613 5525 14 tou tou NNP 19613 5525 15 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5525 16 kai kai NNP 19613 5525 17 tou tou NNP 19613 5525 18 logou logou NNP 19613 5525 19 autou autou NNP 19613 5525 20 kai kai NNP 19613 5525 21 tês tês NNP 19613 5525 22 sophias sophias NNP 19613 5525 23 autou autou NNP 19613 5525 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5525 25 ; ; : 19613 5525 26 see see VB 19613 5525 27 II II NNP 19613 5525 28 . . . 19613 5526 1 10 10 CD 19613 5526 2 , , , 19613 5526 3 18 18 CD 19613 5526 4 . . . 19613 5527 1 But but CC 19613 5527 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5527 3 is be VBZ 19613 5527 4 just just RB 19613 5527 5 in in IN 19613 5527 6 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5527 7 that that WDT 19613 5527 8 the the DT 19613 5527 9 difficulty difficulty NN 19613 5527 10 of of IN 19613 5527 11 deciding decide VBG 19613 5527 12 between between IN 19613 5527 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5527 14 and and CC 19613 5527 15 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 19613 5527 16 appears appear VBZ 19613 5527 17 with with IN 19613 5527 18 special special JJ 19613 5527 19 plainness plainness NN 19613 5527 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5527 21 II II NNP 19613 5527 22 . . . 19613 5528 1 10 10 LS 19613 5528 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5528 3 . . . 19613 5529 1 The the DT 19613 5529 2 interposition interposition NN 19613 5529 3 of of IN 19613 5529 4 the the DT 19613 5529 5 host host NN 19613 5529 6 of of IN 19613 5529 7 good good JJ 19613 5529 8 angels angel NNS 19613 5529 9 between between IN 19613 5529 10 Son Son NNP 19613 5529 11 and and CC 19613 5529 12 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5529 13 found find VBD 19613 5529 14 in in IN 19613 5529 15 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5529 16 , , , 19613 5529 17 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5529 18 . . . 19613 5530 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5531 1 5 5 LS 19613 5531 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5531 3 see see VB 19613 5531 4 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 5531 5 . . . 19613 5532 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5532 2 , , , 19613 5532 3 is be VBZ 19613 5532 4 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 5532 5 striking striking JJ 19613 5532 6 . . . 19613 5533 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5533 2 have have VBP 19613 5533 3 , , , 19613 5533 4 however however RB 19613 5533 5 , , , 19613 5533 6 to to TO 19613 5533 7 notice notice VB 19613 5533 8 , , , 19613 5533 9 provided provide VBN 19613 5533 10 the the DT 19613 5533 11 text text NN 19613 5533 12 is be VBZ 19613 5533 13 right right JJ 19613 5533 14 , , , 19613 5533 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5533 16 1 1 LS 19613 5533 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5533 18 that that IN 19613 5533 19 this this DT 19613 5533 20 interposition interposition NN 19613 5533 21 is be VBZ 19613 5533 22 only only RB 19613 5533 23 found find VBN 19613 5533 24 in in IN 19613 5533 25 a a DT 19613 5533 26 single single JJ 19613 5533 27 passage passage NN 19613 5533 28 , , , 19613 5533 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5533 30 2 2 LS 19613 5533 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5533 32 that that IN 19613 5533 33 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5533 34 wished wish VBD 19613 5533 35 to to TO 19613 5533 36 refute refute VB 19613 5533 37 the the DT 19613 5533 38 reproach reproach NN 19613 5533 39 of of IN 19613 5533 40 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5533 41 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5533 42 : : : 19613 5533 43 atheotês atheotês NN 19613 5533 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5533 45 , , , 19613 5533 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5533 47 3 3 LS 19613 5533 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5533 49 that that IN 19613 5533 50 the the DT 19613 5533 51 placing placing NN 19613 5533 52 of of IN 19613 5533 53 the the DT 19613 5533 54 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5533 55 after after IN 19613 5533 56 the the DT 19613 5533 57 angels angel NNS 19613 5533 58 does do VBZ 19613 5533 59 not not RB 19613 5533 60 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5533 61 imply imply VB 19613 5533 62 a a DT 19613 5533 63 position position NN 19613 5533 64 inferior inferior JJ 19613 5533 65 to to IN 19613 5533 66 theirs -PRON- PRP 19613 5533 67 , , , 19613 5533 68 but but CC 19613 5533 69 merely merely RB 19613 5533 70 a a DT 19613 5533 71 subordination subordination NN 19613 5533 72 to to IN 19613 5533 73 the the DT 19613 5533 74 Son Son NNP 19613 5533 75 and and CC 19613 5533 76 the the DT 19613 5533 77 Father Father NNP 19613 5533 78 common common JJ 19613 5533 79 to to IN 19613 5533 80 the the DT 19613 5533 81 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5533 82 and and CC 19613 5533 83 the the DT 19613 5533 84 angels angel NNS 19613 5533 85 , , , 19613 5533 86 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5533 87 4 4 LS 19613 5533 88 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5533 89 that that IN 19613 5533 90 the the DT 19613 5533 91 good good JJ 19613 5533 92 angels angel NNS 19613 5533 93 were be VBD 19613 5533 94 also also RB 19613 5533 95 invoked invoke VBN 19613 5533 96 by by IN 19613 5533 97 the the DT 19613 5533 98 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5533 99 , , , 19613 5533 100 because because IN 19613 5533 101 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5533 102 were be VBD 19613 5533 103 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5533 104 as as IN 19613 5533 105 mediators mediator NNS 19613 5533 106 of of IN 19613 5533 107 prayer prayer NN 19613 5533 108 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5533 109 see see VB 19613 5533 110 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5533 111 remark remark NN 19613 5533 112 on on IN 19613 5533 113 I. I. NNP 19613 5533 114 Clem Clem NNP 19613 5533 115 , , , 19613 5533 116 ad ad NN 19613 5533 117 Corinth corinth NN 19613 5533 118 . . . 19613 5534 1 LVI LVI NNP 19613 5534 2 . . . 19613 5535 1 1 1 LS 19613 5535 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5535 3 ; ; : 19613 5535 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5535 5 might may MD 19613 5535 6 have have VB 19613 5535 7 found find VBN 19613 5535 8 a a DT 19613 5535 9 place place NN 19613 5535 10 here here RB 19613 5535 11 just just RB 19613 5535 12 for for IN 19613 5535 13 this this DT 19613 5535 14 latter latter JJ 19613 5535 15 reason reason NN 19613 5535 16 . . . 19613 5536 1 On on IN 19613 5536 2 the the DT 19613 5536 3 significance significance NN 19613 5536 4 of of IN 19613 5536 5 the the DT 19613 5536 6 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5536 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5536 8 in in IN 19613 5536 9 the the DT 19613 5536 10 theology theology NN 19613 5536 11 of of IN 19613 5536 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5536 13 , , , 19613 5536 14 see see VB 19613 5536 15 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 5536 16 's 's POS 19613 5536 17 Marcellus Marcellus NNP 19613 5536 18 of of IN 19613 5536 19 Ancyra Ancyra NNP 19613 5536 20 , , , 19613 5536 21 p. p. NN 19613 5536 22 228 228 CD 19613 5536 23 : : : 19613 5536 24 " " `` 19613 5536 25 If if IN 19613 5536 26 there there EX 19613 5536 27 be be VBP 19613 5536 28 any any DT 19613 5536 29 one one CD 19613 5536 30 theologian theologian NN 19613 5536 31 of of IN 19613 5536 32 the the DT 19613 5536 33 early early JJ 19613 5536 34 Church church NN 19613 5536 35 who who WP 19613 5536 36 might may MD 19613 5536 37 be be VB 19613 5536 38 regarded regard VBN 19613 5536 39 as as IN 19613 5536 40 depriving deprive VBG 19613 5536 41 the the DT 19613 5536 42 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5536 43 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5536 44 of of IN 19613 5536 45 all all DT 19613 5536 46 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5536 47 _ _ NNP 19613 5536 48 raison raison NNP 19613 5536 49 d'etre d'etre NNP 19613 5536 50 _ _ NNP 19613 5536 51 at at IN 19613 5536 52 least least JJS 19613 5536 53 on on IN 19613 5536 54 the the DT 19613 5536 55 ground ground NN 19613 5536 56 of of IN 19613 5536 57 having have VBG 19613 5536 58 no no DT 19613 5536 59 distinctive distinctive JJ 19613 5536 60 activity activity NN 19613 5536 61 , , , 19613 5536 62 and and CC 19613 5536 63 the the DT 19613 5536 64 Father Father NNP 19613 5536 65 of of IN 19613 5536 66 all all DT 19613 5536 67 share share NN 19613 5536 68 in in IN 19613 5536 69 revelation revelation NN 19613 5536 70 , , , 19613 5536 71 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5536 72 is be VBZ 19613 5536 73 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5536 74 . . . 19613 5536 75 " " '' 19613 5537 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5537 2 can can MD 19613 5537 3 not not RB 19613 5537 4 at at IN 19613 5537 5 bottom bottom NN 19613 5537 6 say say VB 19613 5537 7 that that IN 19613 5537 8 the the DT 19613 5537 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5537 10 possessed possess VBD 19613 5537 11 a a DT 19613 5537 12 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5537 13 of of IN 19613 5537 14 the the DT 19613 5537 15 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 5537 16 . . . 19613 5537 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5538 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5538 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5538 3 430 430 CD 19613 5538 4 : : : 19613 5538 5 To to TO 19613 5538 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5538 7 the the DT 19613 5538 8 name name NN 19613 5538 9 of of IN 19613 5538 10 the the DT 19613 5538 11 Son Son NNP 19613 5538 12 is be VBZ 19613 5538 13 the the DT 19613 5538 14 most most RBS 19613 5538 15 important important JJ 19613 5538 16 ; ; : 19613 5538 17 see see VB 19613 5538 18 also also RB 19613 5538 19 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 5538 20 . . . 19613 5539 1 10 10 CD 19613 5539 2 . . . 19613 5540 1 The the DT 19613 5540 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5540 3 had have VBD 19613 5540 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 5540 5 been be VBN 19613 5540 6 already already RB 19613 5540 7 called call VBN 19613 5540 8 the the DT 19613 5540 9 Son Son NNP 19613 5540 10 of of IN 19613 5540 11 God God NNP 19613 5540 12 by by IN 19613 5540 13 Philo Philo NNP 19613 5540 14 , , , 19613 5540 15 and and CC 19613 5540 16 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 5540 17 expressly expressly RB 19613 5540 18 says say VBZ 19613 5540 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5540 20 Orig Orig NNP 19613 5540 21 . . . 19613 5540 22 , , , 19613 5540 23 c. c. NNP 19613 5540 24 Cels Cels NNP 19613 5540 25 . . . 19613 5541 1 II ii CD 19613 5541 2 . . . 19613 5542 1 31 31 CD 19613 5542 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5542 3 ; ; : 19613 5542 4 " " `` 19613 5542 5 If if IN 19613 5542 6 according accord VBG 19613 5542 7 to to IN 19613 5542 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5542 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5542 10 the the DT 19613 5542 11 Word Word NNP 19613 5542 12 is be VBZ 19613 5542 13 really really RB 19613 5542 14 the the DT 19613 5542 15 Son Son NNP 19613 5542 16 of of IN 19613 5542 17 God God NNP 19613 5542 18 then then RB 19613 5542 19 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5542 20 agree agree VBP 19613 5542 21 with with IN 19613 5542 22 you -PRON- PRP 19613 5542 23 ; ; : 19613 5542 24 " " '' 19613 5542 25 but but CC 19613 5542 26 the the DT 19613 5542 27 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5542 28 are be VBP 19613 5542 29 the the DT 19613 5542 30 first first JJ 19613 5542 31 to to TO 19613 5542 32 attach attach VB 19613 5542 33 the the DT 19613 5542 34 name name NN 19613 5542 35 of of IN 19613 5542 36 Son Son NNP 19613 5542 37 to to IN 19613 5542 38 the the DT 19613 5542 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5542 40 as as IN 19613 5542 41 a a DT 19613 5542 42 proper proper JJ 19613 5542 43 designation designation NN 19613 5542 44 . . . 19613 5543 1 If if IN 19613 5543 2 , , , 19613 5543 3 however however RB 19613 5543 4 , , , 19613 5543 5 the the DT 19613 5543 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5543 7 is be VBZ 19613 5543 8 intrinsically intrinsically RB 19613 5543 9 the the DT 19613 5543 10 Son Son NNP 19613 5543 11 of of IN 19613 5543 12 God God NNP 19613 5543 13 , , , 19613 5543 14 then then RB 19613 5543 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5543 16 is be VBZ 19613 5543 17 the the DT 19613 5543 18 Son Son NNP 19613 5543 19 of of IN 19613 5543 20 God God NNP 19613 5543 21 , , , 19613 5543 22 not not RB 19613 5543 23 because because IN 19613 5543 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5543 25 is be VBZ 19613 5543 26 the the DT 19613 5543 27 begotten begotten NN 19613 5543 28 of of IN 19613 5543 29 God God NNP 19613 5543 30 in in IN 19613 5543 31 the the DT 19613 5543 32 flesh flesh NN 19613 5543 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5543 34 early early JJ 19613 5543 35 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5543 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5543 37 , , , 19613 5543 38 but but CC 19613 5543 39 because because IN 19613 5543 40 the the DT 19613 5543 41 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 5543 42 being being NN 19613 5543 43 existing exist VBG 19613 5543 44 in in IN 19613 5543 45 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5543 46 is be VBZ 19613 5543 47 the the DT 19613 5543 48 antemundane antemundane JJ 19613 5543 49 reproduction reproduction NN 19613 5543 50 of of IN 19613 5543 51 God God NNP 19613 5543 52 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5543 53 see see VB 19613 5543 54 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5543 55 , , , 19613 5543 56 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5543 57 . . . 19613 5544 1 II ii CD 19613 5544 2 . . . 19613 5545 1 6 6 CD 19613 5545 2 : : : 19613 5545 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5545 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5545 5 : : : 19613 5545 6 ho ho NNP 19613 5545 7 huios huios NNP 19613 5545 8 tou tou NNP 19613 5545 9 patros patros NNP 19613 5545 10 kai kai NNP 19613 5545 11 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5545 12 , , , 19613 5545 13 ho ho NNP 19613 5545 14 monos monos NNP 19613 5545 15 legomenos legomenos NNP 19613 5545 16 kuriôs kuriôs NNP 19613 5545 17 huios])--a huios])--a NNP 19613 5545 18 momentous momentous JJ 19613 5545 19 expression expression NN 19613 5545 20 . . . 19613 5545 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5546 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5546 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5546 3 431 431 CD 19613 5546 4 : : : 19613 5546 5 Athenag Athenag NNP 19613 5546 6 . . . 19613 5546 7 , , , 19613 5546 8 10 10 CD 19613 5546 9 ; ; : 19613 5546 10 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5546 11 , , , 19613 5546 12 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5546 13 . . . 19613 5547 1 5 5 CD 19613 5547 2 . . . 19613 5547 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5548 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5548 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5548 3 432 432 CD 19613 5548 4 : : : 19613 5548 5 The the DT 19613 5548 6 clearest clear JJS 19613 5548 7 expression expression NN 19613 5548 8 of of IN 19613 5548 9 this this DT 19613 5548 10 is be VBZ 19613 5548 11 in in IN 19613 5548 12 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5548 13 5 5 CD 19613 5548 14 , , , 19613 5548 15 which which WDT 19613 5548 16 passage passage NN 19613 5548 17 is be VBZ 19613 5548 18 also also RB 19613 5548 19 to to TO 19613 5548 20 be be VB 19613 5548 21 compared compare VBN 19613 5548 22 with with IN 19613 5548 23 the the DT 19613 5548 24 following follow VBG 19613 5548 25 : : : 19613 5548 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5548 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5548 28 : : : 19613 5548 29 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5548 30 ên ên NNP 19613 5548 31 en en IN 19613 5548 32 archê archê NNP 19613 5548 33 , , , 19613 5548 34 tên tên NNP 19613 5548 35 de de NNP 19613 5548 36 archên archên NNP 19613 5548 37 logou logou NNP 19613 5548 38 dunamin dunamin NNP 19613 5548 39 pareilêphamen pareilêphaman NNS 19613 5548 40 . . . 19613 5549 1 Ho Ho NNP 19613 5549 2 gar gar NNP 19613 5549 3 despotês despotês NNP 19613 5549 4 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5549 5 holôn holôn NNP 19613 5549 6 , , , 19613 5549 7 autos autos NNP 19613 5549 8 huparchôn huparchôn NNP 19613 5549 9 tou tou NNP 19613 5549 10 pantos pantos NNP 19613 5549 11 hê hê NNP 19613 5549 12 hupostasis hupostasis NN 19613 5549 13 , , , 19613 5549 14 kata kata NNP 19613 5549 15 men man NNS 19613 5549 16 tên tên NNP 19613 5549 17 mêdepô mêdepô NNP 19613 5549 18 gegenêmenên gegenêmenên NNP 19613 5549 19 poiêsin poiêsin NNP 19613 5549 20 monos monos NNP 19613 5549 21 ên ên NNP 19613 5549 22 , , , 19613 5549 23 katho katho NNP 19613 5549 24 de de NNP 19613 5549 25 pasa pasa NNP 19613 5549 26 dunamis dunamis NNP 19613 5549 27 , , , 19613 5549 28 horatôn horatôn NNP 19613 5549 29 te te NNP 19613 5549 30 kai kai NNP 19613 5549 31 aoratôn aoratôn NNP 19613 5549 32 autos autos NNPS 19613 5549 33 hupostasis hupostasis NNP 19613 5549 34 ên ên NNP 19613 5549 35 , , , 19613 5549 36 sun sun NNP 19613 5549 37 autô autô NNP 19613 5549 38 ta ta NNP 19613 5549 39 panta panta NNP 19613 5549 40 sun sun NNP 19613 5549 41 autô autô NNP 19613 5549 42 dia dia NNP 19613 5549 43 logikês logikês NNP 19613 5549 44 dunameôs dunameôs NNP 19613 5549 45 autos auto NNS 19613 5549 46 kai kai NNP 19613 5549 47 ho ho NNP 19613 5549 48 logos logos NNP 19613 5549 49 , , , 19613 5549 50 hos hos NN 19613 5549 51 ên ên NNP 19613 5549 52 auto auto NN 19613 5549 53 , , , 19613 5549 54 hupestêse hupestêse NNP 19613 5549 55 . . . 19613 5550 1 Thelêmati Thelêmati NNP 19613 5550 2 de de NNP 19613 5550 3 tês tês NNP 19613 5550 4 aplotêtos aplotêtos NNP 19613 5550 5 autou autou NNP 19613 5550 6 propêda propêda NNP 19613 5550 7 logos logos NNP 19613 5550 8 , , , 19613 5550 9 ho ho NNP 19613 5550 10 de de NNP 19613 5550 11 logos logos NNP 19613 5550 12 , , , 19613 5550 13 ou ou NNP 19613 5550 14 kata kata NNP 19613 5550 15 kenou kenou NNP 19613 5550 16 chôrêsas chôrêsas NNP 19613 5550 17 , , , 19613 5550 18 ergon ergon NNP 19613 5550 19 prôtotokon prôtotokon NNP 19613 5550 20 tou tou NNP 19613 5550 21 patros patros NNP 19613 5550 22 ginetai ginetai NNP 19613 5550 23 . . . 19613 5551 1 Touton Touton NNP 19613 5551 2 ismen isman NNS 19613 5551 3 tou tou NNP 19613 5551 4 kosmou kosmou NNP 19613 5551 5 tên tên NNP 19613 5551 6 archên archên NNP 19613 5551 7 . . . 19613 5552 1 Gegone Gegone NNP 19613 5552 2 de de NNP 19613 5552 3 kata kata NNP 19613 5552 4 merismon merismon NNP 19613 5552 5 , , , 19613 5552 6 ou ou NNP 19613 5552 7 kata kata NNP 19613 5552 8 apokopên apokopên NNP 19613 5552 9 to to TO 19613 5552 10 gar gar NNP 19613 5552 11 apotmêthen apotmêthen NNP 19613 5552 12 tou tou NNP 19613 5552 13 prôtou prôtou NNP 19613 5552 14 kechôristai kechôristai NNP 19613 5552 15 , , , 19613 5552 16 to to IN 19613 5552 17 de de NNP 19613 5552 18 meriothen meriothen NNP 19613 5552 19 oikonomas oikonomas NNP 19613 5552 20 tên tên NNP 19613 5552 21 hairesin hairesin NNP 19613 5552 22 proslabon proslabon NNP 19613 5552 23 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5552 24 endea endea NNP 19613 5552 25 ton ton NNP 19613 5552 26 hothen hothen NNP 19613 5552 27 eilêptai eilêptai NNP 19613 5552 28 pepoiêken pepoiêken VBN 19613 5552 29 . . . 19613 5553 1 Ôsper ôsper NN 19613 5553 2 gar gar NN 19613 5553 3 aro aro NNP 19613 5553 4 mias mias NNP 19613 5553 5 dados dados NNP 19613 5553 6 anaptetai anaptetai NNP 19613 5553 7 men man NNS 19613 5553 8 pura pura NNP 19613 5553 9 polla polla NN 19613 5553 10 , , , 19613 5553 11 tês tês NNP 19613 5553 12 de de NNP 19613 5553 13 prôtês prôtês NNP 19613 5553 14 dados dados NNP 19613 5553 15 dia dia NNP 19613 5553 16 tên tên NNP 19613 5553 17 exapsin exapsin NNP 19613 5553 18 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5553 19 pollôn pollôn NNP 19613 5553 20 dadôn dadôn NNP 19613 5553 21 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5553 22 elattoutai elattoutai NN 19613 5553 23 to to IN 19613 5553 24 phôs phôs NNP 19613 5553 25 , , , 19613 5553 26 houtô houtô NNP 19613 5553 27 kai kai NNP 19613 5553 28 ho ho NNP 19613 5553 29 logos logos NNP 19613 5553 30 proelthôn proelthôn NN 19613 5553 31 ek ek NNP 19613 5553 32 tês tês NNP 19613 5553 33 tou tou NNP 19613 5553 34 patros patros NNP 19613 5553 35 dunameôs dunameôs NNP 19613 5553 36 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5553 37 alogon alogon NNP 19613 5553 38 pepoiêke pepoiêke NNP 19613 5553 39 ton ton NNP 19613 5553 40 gegennêkota gegennêkota NNP 19613 5553 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5553 42 . . . 19613 5554 1 In in IN 19613 5554 2 the the DT 19613 5554 3 identification identification NN 19613 5554 4 of of IN 19613 5554 5 the the DT 19613 5554 6 divine divine JJ 19613 5554 7 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 5554 8 , , , 19613 5554 9 that that RB 19613 5554 10 is is RB 19613 5554 11 , , , 19613 5554 12 the the DT 19613 5554 13 power power NN 19613 5554 14 of of IN 19613 5554 15 God God NNP 19613 5554 16 , , , 19613 5554 17 with with IN 19613 5554 18 the the DT 19613 5554 19 force force NN 19613 5554 20 to to TO 19613 5554 21 which which WDT 19613 5554 22 the the DT 19613 5554 23 world world NN 19613 5554 24 is be VBZ 19613 5554 25 due due JJ 19613 5554 26 the the DT 19613 5554 27 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 19613 5554 28 basis basis NN 19613 5554 29 of of IN 19613 5554 30 the the DT 19613 5554 31 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5554 32 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5554 33 is be VBZ 19613 5554 34 most most RBS 19613 5554 35 clearly clearly RB 19613 5554 36 shown show VBN 19613 5554 37 . . . 19613 5555 1 Cf cf NN 19613 5555 2 . . . 19613 5556 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5556 2 , , , 19613 5556 3 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5556 4 . . . 19613 5557 1 128 128 CD 19613 5557 2 , , , 19613 5557 3 129 129 CD 19613 5557 4 . . . 19613 5557 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5558 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5558 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5558 3 433 433 CD 19613 5558 4 : : : 19613 5558 5 The the DT 19613 5558 6 word word NN 19613 5558 7 " " `` 19613 5558 8 beget beget NN 19613 5558 9 " " '' 19613 5558 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5558 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5558 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5558 13 : : : 19613 5558 14 gennan gennan NNP 19613 5558 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5558 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5558 17 is be VBZ 19613 5558 18 used use VBN 19613 5558 19 by by IN 19613 5558 20 the the DT 19613 5558 21 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5558 22 , , , 19613 5558 23 especially especially RB 19613 5558 24 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5558 25 , , , 19613 5558 26 because because IN 19613 5558 27 the the DT 19613 5558 28 name name NN 19613 5558 29 " " `` 19613 5558 30 Son Son NNP 19613 5558 31 " " '' 19613 5558 32 was be VBD 19613 5558 33 the the DT 19613 5558 34 recognised recognised JJ 19613 5558 35 expression expression NN 19613 5558 36 for for IN 19613 5558 37 the the DT 19613 5558 38 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5558 39 . . . 19613 5559 1 No no RB 19613 5559 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 5559 3 the the DT 19613 5559 4 words word NNS 19613 5559 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5559 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5559 7 : : : 19613 5559 8 exereugesthai exereugesthai NNP 19613 5559 9 , , , 19613 5559 10 proballesthai proballesthai NNP 19613 5559 11 , , , 19613 5559 12 proerchesthai proerchesthai NNP 19613 5559 13 , , , 19613 5559 14 propêdan propêdan NNP 19613 5559 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5559 16 and and CC 19613 5559 17 the the DT 19613 5559 18 like like UH 19613 5559 19 express express VB 19613 5559 20 the the DT 19613 5559 21 physical physical JJ 19613 5559 22 process process NN 19613 5559 23 more more RBR 19613 5559 24 exactly exactly RB 19613 5559 25 in in IN 19613 5559 26 the the DT 19613 5559 27 sense sense NN 19613 5559 28 of of IN 19613 5559 29 the the DT 19613 5559 30 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5559 31 . . . 19613 5560 1 On on IN 19613 5560 2 the the DT 19613 5560 3 other other JJ 19613 5560 4 hand hand NN 19613 5560 5 , , , 19613 5560 6 however however RB 19613 5560 7 , , , 19613 5560 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5560 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5560 10 : : : 19613 5560 11 gennan gennan NNP 19613 5560 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5560 13 appears appear VBZ 19613 5560 14 the the DT 19613 5560 15 more more RBR 19613 5560 16 appropriate appropriate JJ 19613 5560 17 word word NN 19613 5560 18 in in IN 19613 5560 19 so so RB 19613 5560 20 far far RB 19613 5560 21 as as IN 19613 5560 22 the the DT 19613 5560 23 relation relation NN 19613 5560 24 of of IN 19613 5560 25 the the DT 19613 5560 26 essence essence NN 19613 5560 27 of of IN 19613 5560 28 the the DT 19613 5560 29 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5560 30 to to IN 19613 5560 31 the the DT 19613 5560 32 essence essence NN 19613 5560 33 of of IN 19613 5560 34 God God NNP 19613 5560 35 is be VBZ 19613 5560 36 most most RBS 19613 5560 37 clearly clearly RB 19613 5560 38 shown show VBN 19613 5560 39 by by IN 19613 5560 40 the the DT 19613 5560 41 name name NN 19613 5560 42 " " `` 19613 5560 43 Son Son NNP 19613 5560 44 . . . 19613 5560 45 " " '' 19613 5560 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5561 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5561 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5561 3 434 434 CD 19613 5561 4 : : : 19613 5561 5 None none NN 19613 5561 6 of of IN 19613 5561 7 the the DT 19613 5561 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5561 9 has have VBZ 19613 5561 10 precisely precisely RB 19613 5561 11 defined define VBN 19613 5561 12 the the DT 19613 5561 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5561 14 idea idea NN 19613 5561 15 . . . 19613 5562 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 5562 2 , , , 19613 5562 3 l.c l.c NNP 19613 5562 4 . . NNP 19613 5562 5 , , , 19613 5562 6 p. p. NN 19613 5562 7 233 233 CD 19613 5562 8 , , , 19613 5562 9 correctly correctly RB 19613 5562 10 remarks remark VBZ 19613 5562 11 : : : 19613 5562 12 " " `` 19613 5562 13 Whilst whilst IN 19613 5562 14 the the DT 19613 5562 15 distinction distinction NN 19613 5562 16 drawn draw VBN 19613 5562 17 between between IN 19613 5562 18 the the DT 19613 5562 19 hitherto hitherto NNP 19613 5562 20 unspoken unspoken NN 19613 5562 21 and and CC 19613 5562 22 the the DT 19613 5562 23 spoken speak VBN 19613 5562 24 word word NN 19613 5562 25 of of IN 19613 5562 26 the the DT 19613 5562 27 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5562 28 makes make VBZ 19613 5562 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5562 30 appear appear VB 19613 5562 31 as as IN 19613 5562 32 the the DT 19613 5562 33 thought thought NN 19613 5562 34 of of IN 19613 5562 35 the the DT 19613 5562 36 world world NN 19613 5562 37 within within IN 19613 5562 38 the the DT 19613 5562 39 mind mind NN 19613 5562 40 of of IN 19613 5562 41 God God NNP 19613 5562 42 , , , 19613 5562 43 yet yet CC 19613 5562 44 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5562 45 is be VBZ 19613 5562 46 also also RB 19613 5562 47 to to TO 19613 5562 48 be be VB 19613 5562 49 something something NN 19613 5562 50 real real JJ 19613 5562 51 which which WDT 19613 5562 52 only only RB 19613 5562 53 requires require VBZ 19613 5562 54 to to TO 19613 5562 55 enter enter VB 19613 5562 56 into into IN 19613 5562 57 a a DT 19613 5562 58 new new JJ 19613 5562 59 relation relation NN 19613 5562 60 to to IN 19613 5562 61 God God NNP 19613 5562 62 to to TO 19613 5562 63 become become VB 19613 5562 64 an an DT 19613 5562 65 active active JJ 19613 5562 66 force force NN 19613 5562 67 . . . 19613 5563 1 Then then RB 19613 5563 2 again again RB 19613 5563 3 this this DT 19613 5563 4 Word Word NNP 19613 5563 5 is be VBZ 19613 5563 6 not not RB 19613 5563 7 to to TO 19613 5563 8 be be VB 19613 5563 9 the the DT 19613 5563 10 thought thought NN 19613 5563 11 that that WDT 19613 5563 12 God God NNP 19613 5563 13 thinks think VBZ 19613 5563 14 , , , 19613 5563 15 but but CC 19613 5563 16 the the DT 19613 5563 17 thought thought NN 19613 5563 18 that that WDT 19613 5563 19 thinks think VBZ 19613 5563 20 in in IN 19613 5563 21 God God NNP 19613 5563 22 . . . 19613 5564 1 And and CC 19613 5564 2 again again RB 19613 5564 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5564 4 is be VBZ 19613 5564 5 to to TO 19613 5564 6 be be VB 19613 5564 7 a a DT 19613 5564 8 something something NN 19613 5564 9 , , , 19613 5564 10 or or CC 19613 5564 11 an an DT 19613 5564 12 Ego Ego NNP 19613 5564 13 , , , 19613 5564 14 in in IN 19613 5564 15 God God NNP 19613 5564 16 's 's POS 19613 5564 17 thinking thinking NN 19613 5564 18 essence essence NN 19613 5564 19 , , , 19613 5564 20 which which WDT 19613 5564 21 enters enter VBZ 19613 5564 22 into into IN 19613 5564 23 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 19613 5564 24 intercourse intercourse NN 19613 5564 25 with with IN 19613 5564 26 something something NN 19613 5564 27 else else RB 19613 5564 28 in in IN 19613 5564 29 God God NNP 19613 5564 30 ; ; : 19613 5564 31 occasionally occasionally RB 19613 5564 32 also also RB 19613 5564 33 the the DT 19613 5564 34 reason reason NN 19613 5564 35 of of IN 19613 5564 36 God God NNP 19613 5564 37 which which WDT 19613 5564 38 is be VBZ 19613 5564 39 in in IN 19613 5564 40 a a DT 19613 5564 41 state state NN 19613 5564 42 of of IN 19613 5564 43 active active JJ 19613 5564 44 exercise exercise NN 19613 5564 45 and and CC 19613 5564 46 without without IN 19613 5564 47 which which WDT 19613 5564 48 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5564 49 would would MD 19613 5564 50 not not RB 19613 5564 51 be be VB 19613 5564 52 rational rational JJ 19613 5564 53 . . . 19613 5564 54 " " '' 19613 5565 1 Considering consider VBG 19613 5565 2 this this DT 19613 5565 3 evident evident JJ 19613 5565 4 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 5565 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5565 6 appears appear VBZ 19613 5565 7 to to IN 19613 5565 8 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5565 9 a a DT 19613 5565 10 very very RB 19613 5565 11 dubious dubious JJ 19613 5565 12 proceeding proceeding NN 19613 5565 13 to to TO 19613 5565 14 differentiate differentiate VB 19613 5565 15 the the DT 19613 5565 16 conceptions conception NNS 19613 5565 17 of of IN 19613 5565 18 the the DT 19613 5565 19 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5565 20 in in IN 19613 5565 21 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5565 22 , , , 19613 5565 23 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 5565 24 , , , 19613 5565 25 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5565 26 , , , 19613 5565 27 and and CC 19613 5565 28 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5565 29 , , , 19613 5565 30 as as IN 19613 5565 31 is be VBZ 19613 5565 32 usually usually RB 19613 5565 33 done do VBN 19613 5565 34 . . . 19613 5566 1 If if IN 19613 5566 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5566 3 consider consider VBP 19613 5566 4 that that IN 19613 5566 5 no no DT 19613 5566 6 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 5566 7 wrote write VBD 19613 5566 8 a a DT 19613 5566 9 special special JJ 19613 5566 10 treatise treatise NN 19613 5566 11 on on IN 19613 5566 12 the the DT 19613 5566 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5566 14 , , , 19613 5566 15 that that IN 19613 5566 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5566 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5566 18 c. c. NNP 19613 5566 19 5 5 CD 19613 5566 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5566 21 is be VBZ 19613 5566 22 really really RB 19613 5566 23 the the DT 19613 5566 24 only only JJ 19613 5566 25 one one CD 19613 5566 26 from from IN 19613 5566 27 whom whom WP 19613 5566 28 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5566 29 have have VBP 19613 5566 30 any any DT 19613 5566 31 precise precise JJ 19613 5566 32 statements statement NNS 19613 5566 33 , , , 19613 5566 34 and and CC 19613 5566 35 that that IN 19613 5566 36 the the DT 19613 5566 37 elements element NNS 19613 5566 38 of of IN 19613 5566 39 the the DT 19613 5566 40 conception conception NN 19613 5566 41 are be VBP 19613 5566 42 the the DT 19613 5566 43 same same JJ 19613 5566 44 in in IN 19613 5566 45 all all DT 19613 5566 46 , , , 19613 5566 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5566 48 appears appear VBZ 19613 5566 49 inadvisable inadvisable JJ 19613 5566 50 to to TO 19613 5566 51 lay lay VB 19613 5566 52 so so RB 19613 5566 53 great great JJ 19613 5566 54 stress stress NN 19613 5566 55 on on IN 19613 5566 56 the the DT 19613 5566 57 difference difference NN 19613 5566 58 as as IN 19613 5566 59 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 5566 60 , , , 19613 5566 61 for for IN 19613 5566 62 instance instance NN 19613 5566 63 , , , 19613 5566 64 has have VBZ 19613 5566 65 done do VBN 19613 5566 66 in in IN 19613 5566 67 the the DT 19613 5566 68 book book NN 19613 5566 69 already already RB 19613 5566 70 referred refer VBD 19613 5566 71 to to IN 19613 5566 72 , , , 19613 5566 73 p. p. NN 19613 5566 74 232 232 CD 19613 5566 75 f. f. NNS 19613 5566 76 Hardly hardly RB 19613 5566 77 any any DT 19613 5566 78 real real JJ 19613 5566 79 difference difference NN 19613 5566 80 can can MD 19613 5566 81 have have VB 19613 5566 82 existed exist VBN 19613 5566 83 between between IN 19613 5566 84 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5566 85 , , , 19613 5566 86 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5566 87 , , , 19613 5566 88 and and CC 19613 5566 89 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5566 90 in in IN 19613 5566 91 the the DT 19613 5566 92 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5566 93 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5566 94 proper proper JJ 19613 5566 95 . . . 19613 5567 1 On on IN 19613 5567 2 the the DT 19613 5567 3 other other JJ 19613 5567 4 hand hand NN 19613 5567 5 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 5567 6 certainly certainly RB 19613 5567 7 seems seem VBZ 19613 5567 8 to to TO 19613 5567 9 have have VB 19613 5567 10 tried try VBN 19613 5567 11 to to TO 19613 5567 12 eliminate eliminate VB 19613 5567 13 the the DT 19613 5567 14 appearance appearance NN 19613 5567 15 of of IN 19613 5567 16 the the DT 19613 5567 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5567 18 in in IN 19613 5567 19 time time NN 19613 5567 20 , , , 19613 5567 21 and and CC 19613 5567 22 to to TO 19613 5567 23 emphasise emphasise VB 19613 5567 24 the the DT 19613 5567 25 eternal eternal JJ 19613 5567 26 nature nature NN 19613 5567 27 of of IN 19613 5567 28 the the DT 19613 5567 29 divine divine JJ 19613 5567 30 relationships relationship NNS 19613 5567 31 , , , 19613 5567 32 without without RB 19613 5567 33 , , , 19613 5567 34 however however RB 19613 5567 35 , , , 19613 5567 36 reaching reach VBG 19613 5567 37 the the DT 19613 5567 38 position position NN 19613 5567 39 which which WDT 19613 5567 40 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5567 41 took take VBD 19613 5567 42 up up RP 19613 5567 43 here here RB 19613 5567 44 . . . 19613 5567 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5568 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5568 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5568 3 435 435 CD 19613 5568 4 : : : 19613 5568 5 This this DT 19613 5568 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 5568 7 is be VBZ 19613 5568 8 only only RB 19613 5568 9 found find VBN 19613 5568 10 in in IN 19613 5568 11 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5568 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5568 13 II II NNP 19613 5568 14 . . . 19613 5569 1 10 10 CD 19613 5569 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5569 3 ; ; : 19613 5569 4 but but CC 19613 5569 5 the the DT 19613 5569 6 idea idea NN 19613 5569 7 exists exist VBZ 19613 5569 8 in in IN 19613 5569 9 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5569 10 and and CC 19613 5569 11 probably probably RB 19613 5569 12 also also RB 19613 5569 13 in in IN 19613 5569 14 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5569 15 , , , 19613 5569 16 though though IN 19613 5569 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5569 18 is be VBZ 19613 5569 19 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 5569 20 whether whether IN 19613 5569 21 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5569 22 regarded regard VBD 19613 5569 23 the the DT 19613 5569 24 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5569 25 as as IN 19613 5569 26 having have VBG 19613 5569 27 any any DT 19613 5569 28 sort sort NN 19613 5569 29 of of IN 19613 5569 30 being be VBG 19613 5569 31 before before IN 19613 5569 32 the the DT 19613 5569 33 moment moment NN 19613 5569 34 of of IN 19613 5569 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5569 36 begetting begetting NN 19613 5569 37 . . . 19613 5569 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5570 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5570 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5570 3 436 436 CD 19613 5570 4 : : : 19613 5570 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5570 6 , , , 19613 5570 7 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5570 8 . . . 19613 5571 1 II ii CD 19613 5571 2 . . . 19613 5572 1 6 6 CD 19613 5572 2 . . . 19613 5572 3 , , , 19613 5572 4 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5572 5 . . . 19613 5573 1 61 61 CD 19613 5573 2 . . . 19613 5574 1 The the DT 19613 5574 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5574 3 is be VBZ 19613 5574 4 not not RB 19613 5574 5 produced produce VBN 19613 5574 6 out out IN 19613 5574 7 of of IN 19613 5574 8 nothing nothing NN 19613 5574 9 , , , 19613 5574 10 like like IN 19613 5574 11 the the DT 19613 5574 12 rest rest NN 19613 5574 13 of of IN 19613 5574 14 the the DT 19613 5574 15 creatures creature NNS 19613 5574 16 . . . 19613 5575 1 Yet yet CC 19613 5575 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5575 3 is be VBZ 19613 5575 4 evident evident JJ 19613 5575 5 that that IN 19613 5575 6 the the DT 19613 5575 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5575 8 did do VBD 19613 5575 9 not not RB 19613 5575 10 yet yet RB 19613 5575 11 sharply sharply RB 19613 5575 12 and and CC 19613 5575 13 precisely precisely RB 19613 5575 14 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 5575 15 between between IN 19613 5575 16 begetting beget VBG 19613 5575 17 and and CC 19613 5575 18 creating create VBG 19613 5575 19 , , , 19613 5575 20 as as IN 19613 5575 21 the the DT 19613 5575 22 later later JJ 19613 5575 23 theologians theologian NNS 19613 5575 24 did do VBD 19613 5575 25 ; ; : 19613 5575 26 though though IN 19613 5575 27 some some DT 19613 5575 28 of of IN 19613 5575 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5575 30 certainly certainly RB 19613 5575 31 felt feel VBD 19613 5575 32 the the DT 19613 5575 33 necessity necessity NN 19613 5575 34 for for IN 19613 5575 35 a a DT 19613 5575 36 distinction distinction NN 19613 5575 37 . . . 19613 5575 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5576 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5576 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5576 3 437 437 CD 19613 5576 4 : : : 19613 5576 5 All all PDT 19613 5576 6 the the DT 19613 5576 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5576 8 tacitly tacitly RB 19613 5576 9 assume assume VBP 19613 5576 10 that that IN 19613 5576 11 the the DT 19613 5576 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5576 13 in in IN 19613 5576 14 virtue virtue NN 19613 5576 15 of of IN 19613 5576 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5576 17 origin origin NN 19613 5576 18 has have VBZ 19613 5576 19 the the DT 19613 5576 20 capacity capacity NN 19613 5576 21 of of IN 19613 5576 22 entering enter VBG 19613 5576 23 the the DT 19613 5576 24 finite finite NN 19613 5576 25 . . . 19613 5577 1 The the DT 19613 5577 2 distinction distinction NN 19613 5577 3 which which WDT 19613 5577 4 here here RB 19613 5577 5 exists exist VBZ 19613 5577 6 between between IN 19613 5577 7 Father Father NNP 19613 5577 8 and and CC 19613 5577 9 Son Son NNP 19613 5577 10 is be VBZ 19613 5577 11 very very RB 19613 5577 12 pregnantly pregnantly RB 19613 5577 13 expressed express VBN 19613 5577 14 by by IN 19613 5577 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5577 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5577 17 adv adv NN 19613 5577 18 . . . 19613 5578 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 5578 2 . . . 19613 5579 1 II ii CD 19613 5579 2 . . . 19613 5580 1 27 27 CD 19613 5580 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5580 3 : : : 19613 5580 4 " " `` 19613 5580 5 Igitur Igitur NNP 19613 5580 6 quæcumque quæcumque NNP 19613 5580 7 exigitis exigitis NN 19613 5580 8 deo deo NNP 19613 5580 9 digna digna NNP 19613 5580 10 , , , 19613 5580 11 habebuntur habebuntur NN 19613 5580 12 in in IN 19613 5580 13 patre patre NNP 19613 5580 14 invisibili invisibili NNP 19613 5580 15 incongressibilique incongressibilique NNP 19613 5580 16 et et NNP 19613 5580 17 placido placido NNP 19613 5580 18 et et NNP 19613 5580 19 , , , 19613 5580 20 ut ut NNP 19613 5580 21 ita ita NNP 19613 5580 22 dixerim dixerim NNP 19613 5580 23 , , , 19613 5580 24 philosophorum philosophorum NNP 19613 5580 25 deo deo NNP 19613 5580 26 . . . 19613 5581 1 Quæcumque Quæcumque NNP 19613 5581 2 autem autem NNP 19613 5581 3 ut ut NNP 19613 5581 4 indigna indigna NNP 19613 5581 5 reprehenditis reprehenditis NNP 19613 5581 6 deputabuntur deputabuntur NNP 19613 5581 7 in in IN 19613 5581 8 filio filio NNP 19613 5581 9 et et NNP 19613 5581 10 viso viso NNP 19613 5581 11 et et NNP 19613 5581 12 audito audito NNP 19613 5581 13 et et NNP 19613 5581 14 congresso congresso NNP 19613 5581 15 , , , 19613 5581 16 arbitro arbitro NNP 19613 5581 17 patris patris NNP 19613 5581 18 et et NNP 19613 5581 19 ministro ministro NNP 19613 5581 20 . . . 19613 5581 21 " " '' 19613 5582 1 But but CC 19613 5582 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5582 3 ought ought MD 19613 5582 4 not not RB 19613 5582 5 to to TO 19613 5582 6 charge charge VB 19613 5582 7 the the DT 19613 5582 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5582 9 with with IN 19613 5582 10 the the DT 19613 5582 11 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 5582 12 that that IN 19613 5582 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5582 14 was be VBD 19613 5582 15 an an DT 19613 5582 16 inward inward JJ 19613 5582 17 necessity necessity NN 19613 5582 18 for for IN 19613 5582 19 the the DT 19613 5582 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5582 21 to to TO 19613 5582 22 become become VB 19613 5582 23 man man NN 19613 5582 24 . . . 19613 5583 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5583 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5583 3 hovers hover NNS 19613 5583 4 , , , 19613 5583 5 as as IN 19613 5583 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5583 7 were be VBD 19613 5583 8 , , , 19613 5583 9 between between IN 19613 5583 10 God God NNP 19613 5583 11 and and CC 19613 5583 12 the the DT 19613 5583 13 world world NN 19613 5583 14 , , , 19613 5583 15 so so IN 19613 5583 16 that that IN 19613 5583 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5583 18 appears appear VBZ 19613 5583 19 as as IN 19613 5583 20 the the DT 19613 5583 21 highest high JJS 19613 5583 22 creature creature NN 19613 5583 23 , , , 19613 5583 24 in in IN 19613 5583 25 so so RB 19613 5583 26 far far RB 19613 5583 27 as as IN 19613 5583 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5583 29 is be VBZ 19613 5583 30 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5583 31 as as IN 19613 5583 32 the the DT 19613 5583 33 production production NN 19613 5583 34 of of IN 19613 5583 35 God God NNP 19613 5583 36 ; ; : 19613 5583 37 and and CC 19613 5583 38 again again RB 19613 5583 39 seems seem VBZ 19613 5583 40 to to TO 19613 5583 41 be be VB 19613 5583 42 merged merge VBN 19613 5583 43 in in IN 19613 5583 44 God God NNP 19613 5583 45 , , , 19613 5583 46 in in IN 19613 5583 47 so so RB 19613 5583 48 far far RB 19613 5583 49 as as IN 19613 5583 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5583 51 is be VBZ 19613 5583 52 looked look VBN 19613 5583 53 upon upon IN 19613 5583 54 as as IN 19613 5583 55 the the DT 19613 5583 56 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 5583 57 and and CC 19613 5583 58 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 5583 59 force force NN 19613 5583 60 of of IN 19613 5583 61 God God NNP 19613 5583 62 . . . 19613 5584 1 To to IN 19613 5584 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5584 3 , , , 19613 5584 4 however however RB 19613 5584 5 , , , 19613 5584 6 the the DT 19613 5584 7 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5584 8 is be VBZ 19613 5584 9 irrational irrational JJ 19613 5584 10 , , , 19613 5584 11 and and CC 19613 5584 12 the the DT 19613 5584 13 rest rest NN 19613 5584 14 of of IN 19613 5584 15 the the DT 19613 5584 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5584 17 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5584 18 are be VBP 19613 5584 19 silent silent JJ 19613 5584 20 about about IN 19613 5584 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5584 22 . . . 19613 5584 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5585 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5585 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5585 3 438 438 CD 19613 5585 4 : : : 19613 5585 5 The the DT 19613 5585 6 most most JJS 19613 5585 7 of of IN 19613 5585 8 the the DT 19613 5585 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5585 10 argue argue VBP 19613 5585 11 against against IN 19613 5585 12 the the DT 19613 5585 13 conception conception NN 19613 5585 14 of of IN 19613 5585 15 the the DT 19613 5585 16 natural natural JJ 19613 5585 17 immortality immortality NN 19613 5585 18 of of IN 19613 5585 19 the the DT 19613 5585 20 human human JJ 19613 5585 21 soul soul NN 19613 5585 22 ; ; : 19613 5585 23 see see VB 19613 5585 24 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5585 25 13 13 CD 19613 5585 26 ; ; : 19613 5585 27 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5585 28 , , , 19613 5585 29 Dial Dial NNP 19613 5585 30 . . . 19613 5586 1 5 5 LS 19613 5586 2 ; ; : 19613 5586 3 Theoph Theoph NNS 19613 5586 4 . . . 19613 5587 1 II ii CD 19613 5587 2 . . . 19613 5588 1 27 27 CD 19613 5588 2 . . . 19613 5588 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5589 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5589 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5589 3 439 439 CD 19613 5589 4 : : : 19613 5589 5 The the DT 19613 5589 6 first first JJ 19613 5589 7 chapter chapter NN 19613 5589 8 of of IN 19613 5589 9 Genesis Genesis NNP 19613 5589 10 represented represent VBD 19613 5589 11 to to IN 19613 5589 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5589 13 the the DT 19613 5589 14 sum sum NN 19613 5589 15 of of IN 19613 5589 16 all all DT 19613 5589 17 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 5589 18 , , , 19613 5589 19 and and CC 19613 5589 20 therefore therefore RB 19613 5589 21 of of IN 19613 5589 22 all all DT 19613 5589 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5589 24 . . . 19613 5590 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 19613 5590 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5590 3 had have VBD 19613 5590 4 already already RB 19613 5590 5 written write VBN 19613 5590 6 a a DT 19613 5590 7 commentary commentary NN 19613 5590 8 to to IN 19613 5590 9 the the DT 19613 5590 10 Hexaëmeron Hexaëmeron NNP 19613 5590 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5590 12 see see VB 19613 5590 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5590 14 Texte Texte NNP 19613 5590 15 und und NN 19613 5590 16 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 5590 17 I. i. NN 19613 5591 1 1 1 CD 19613 5591 2 , , , 19613 5591 3 2 2 CD 19613 5591 4 , , , 19613 5591 5 p. p. NN 19613 5591 6 169 169 CD 19613 5591 7 f. f. NNS 19613 5591 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5591 9 . . . 19613 5592 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5592 2 is be VBZ 19613 5592 3 certain certain JJ 19613 5592 4 that that IN 19613 5592 5 in in IN 19613 5592 6 the the DT 19613 5592 7 second second JJ 19613 5592 8 century century NN 19613 5592 9 Rhodon Rhodon NNP 19613 5592 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5592 11 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 5592 12 . . NNP 19613 5592 13 , , , 19613 5592 14 H. H. NNP 19613 5592 15 E. E. NNP 19613 5592 16 V. V. NNP 19613 5592 17 13 13 CD 19613 5592 18 . . . 19613 5593 1 8) 8) CD 19613 5593 2 , , , 19613 5593 3 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5593 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5593 5 see see VB 19613 5593 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5593 7 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 5593 8 Book Book NNP 19613 5593 9 ad ad NN 19613 5593 10 Autol Autol NNP 19613 5593 11 . . . 19613 5594 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5594 2 , , , 19613 5594 3 Candidus Candidus NNP 19613 5594 4 , , , 19613 5594 5 and and CC 19613 5594 6 Apion Apion NNP 19613 5594 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5594 8 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 5594 9 . . NNP 19613 5594 10 , , , 19613 5594 11 H. H. NNP 19613 5594 12 E. E. NNP 19613 5594 13 V. V. NNP 19613 5594 14 27 27 CD 19613 5594 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5594 16 composed compose VBD 19613 5594 17 such such JJ 19613 5594 18 . . . 19613 5595 1 The the DT 19613 5595 2 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5595 3 also also RB 19613 5595 4 occupied occupy VBD 19613 5595 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5595 6 a a DT 19613 5595 7 great great JJ 19613 5595 8 deal deal NN 19613 5595 9 with with IN 19613 5595 10 Gen. Gen. NNP 19613 5596 1 I.-III I.-III : 19613 5596 2 . . . 19613 5597 1 ; ; : 19613 5597 2 see see VB 19613 5597 3 , , , 19613 5597 4 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 5597 5 , , , 19613 5597 6 Marcus Marcus NNP 19613 5597 7 in in IN 19613 5597 8 Iren Iren NNP 19613 5597 9 . . . 19613 5598 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5599 1 18 18 CD 19613 5599 2 . . . 19613 5599 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5600 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5600 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5600 3 440 440 CD 19613 5600 4 : : : 19613 5600 5 See see VB 19613 5600 6 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5600 7 ad ad NN 19613 5600 8 Aut Aut NNP 19613 5600 9 . . . 19613 5601 1 II ii CD 19613 5601 2 . . . 19613 5602 1 27 27 CD 19613 5602 2 : : : 19613 5602 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5602 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5602 5 : : : 19613 5602 6 Ei Ei NNP 19613 5602 7 gar gar NNP 19613 5602 8 ho ho NNP 19613 5602 9 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5602 10 athanaton athanaton NNP 19613 5602 11 ton ton NN 19613 5602 12 anthrôpon anthrôpon IN 19613 5602 13 ap ap NNP 19613 5602 14 ' ' POS 19613 5602 15 archês archês JJ 19613 5602 16 pepoiêkei pepoiêkei NNS 19613 5602 17 , , , 19613 5602 18 Theon Theon NNP 19613 5602 19 auton auton NNP 19613 5602 20 pepoiêkei pepoiêkei VBZ 19613 5602 21 ; ; : 19613 5602 22 palin palin NNP 19613 5602 23 ei ei NNP 19613 5602 24 thnêton thnêton NNP 19613 5602 25 auton auton NNP 19613 5602 26 pepoiêkei pepoiêkei VBZ 19613 5602 27 edokei edokei VBZ 19613 5602 28 an an DT 19613 5602 29 ho ho NNP 19613 5602 30 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5602 31 aitios aitio NNS 19613 5602 32 einai einai NNP 19613 5602 33 tou tou NNP 19613 5602 34 thanatou thanatou NNP 19613 5602 35 autou autou NNP 19613 5602 36 . . . 19613 5603 1 Oute Oute NNP 19613 5603 2 oun oun NNP 19613 5603 3 athanaton athanaton NNP 19613 5603 4 auton auton NNP 19613 5603 5 epoiêsen epoiêsen NNP 19613 5603 6 oute oute NNP 19613 5603 7 mên mên NNP 19613 5603 8 thnêton thnêton NNP 19613 5603 9 , , , 19613 5603 10 alla alla NN 19613 5603 11 dektikon dektikon NNP 19613 5603 12 amphoterôn amphoterôn NNP 19613 5603 13 , , , 19613 5603 14 hina hina NNP 19613 5603 15 , , , 19613 5603 16 ei ei NNP 19613 5603 17 rhepsê rhepsê NNP 19613 5603 18 epi epi NNP 19613 5603 19 ta ta NNP 19613 5603 20 tês tês NNP 19613 5603 21 athanasias athanasias NNP 19613 5603 22 têrêsas têrêsas NNP 19613 5603 23 tên tên NNP 19613 5603 24 entolên entolên NNP 19613 5603 25 tou tou NNP 19613 5603 26 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5603 27 , , , 19613 5603 28 misthon misthon NNP 19613 5603 29 komisêtai komisêtai NNP 19613 5603 30 par par NNP 19613 5603 31 ' ' '' 19613 5603 32 autou autou NNP 19613 5603 33 tên tên NNP 19613 5603 34 athanasian athanasian NNP 19613 5603 35 kai kai NNP 19613 5603 36 genêtai genêtai NNP 19613 5603 37 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5603 38 , , , 19613 5603 39 ei ei NNP 19613 5603 40 d d NNP 19613 5603 41 ' ' '' 19613 5603 42 au au NNP 19613 5603 43 trapê trapê NNP 19613 5603 44 epi epi NNP 19613 5603 45 ta ta NNP 19613 5603 46 tou tou NNP 19613 5603 47 thanatou thanatou NNP 19613 5603 48 pragmata pragmata NNP 19613 5603 49 parakousas parakousas NN 19613 5603 50 tou tou NNP 19613 5603 51 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5603 52 , , , 19613 5603 53 autos auto NNS 19613 5603 54 eautô eautô NNP 19613 5603 55 aitios aitios NNP 19613 5603 56 ê ê NNP 19613 5603 57 tou tou NNP 19613 5603 58 thanatou thanatou NNP 19613 5603 59 . . . 19613 5603 60 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5603 61 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5604 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5604 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5604 3 441 441 CD 19613 5604 4 : : : 19613 5604 5 See see VB 19613 5604 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5604 7 , , , 19613 5604 8 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5604 9 . . . 19613 5605 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5606 1 14 14 CD 19613 5606 2 ff ff NNP 19613 5606 3 . . . 19613 5607 1 and and CC 19613 5607 2 the the DT 19613 5607 3 parallel parallel JJ 19613 5607 4 passages passage NNS 19613 5607 5 in in IN 19613 5607 6 the the DT 19613 5607 7 other other JJ 19613 5607 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5607 9 . . . 19613 5607 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5608 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5608 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5608 3 442 442 CD 19613 5608 4 : : : 19613 5608 5 See see VB 19613 5608 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5608 7 , , , 19613 5608 8 Orat Orat NNP 19613 5608 9 . . . 19613 5609 1 II ii CD 19613 5609 2 . . . 19613 5610 1 and and CC 19613 5610 2 many many JJ 19613 5610 3 other other JJ 19613 5610 4 passages passage NNS 19613 5610 5 . . . 19613 5610 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5611 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5611 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5611 3 443 443 CD 19613 5611 4 : : : 19613 5611 5 Along along IN 19613 5611 6 with with IN 19613 5611 7 this this DT 19613 5611 8 the the DT 19613 5611 9 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5611 10 emphasise emphasise VBP 19613 5611 11 the the DT 19613 5611 12 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 5611 13 of of IN 19613 5611 14 the the DT 19613 5611 15 flesh flesh NN 19613 5611 16 in in IN 19613 5611 17 the the DT 19613 5611 18 strongest strong JJS 19613 5611 19 way way NN 19613 5611 20 as as IN 19613 5611 21 the the DT 19613 5611 22 specific specific JJ 19613 5611 23 article article NN 19613 5611 24 of of IN 19613 5611 25 Christian christian JJ 19613 5611 26 anticipation anticipation NN 19613 5611 27 , , , 19613 5611 28 and and CC 19613 5611 29 prove prove VB 19613 5611 30 the the DT 19613 5611 31 possibility possibility NN 19613 5611 32 of of IN 19613 5611 33 realising realise VBG 19613 5611 34 this this DT 19613 5611 35 irrational irrational JJ 19613 5611 36 hope hope NN 19613 5611 37 . . . 19613 5612 1 Yet yet CC 19613 5612 2 to to IN 19613 5612 3 the the DT 19613 5612 4 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5612 5 the the DT 19613 5612 6 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 5612 7 ground ground NN 19613 5612 8 of of IN 19613 5612 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5612 10 trust trust NN 19613 5612 11 in in IN 19613 5612 12 this this DT 19613 5612 13 early early JJ 19613 5612 14 - - HYPH 19613 5612 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 5612 16 idea idea NN 19613 5612 17 is be VBZ 19613 5612 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5612 19 reliance reliance NN 19613 5612 20 on on IN 19613 5612 21 the the DT 19613 5612 22 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 5612 23 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 5612 24 of of IN 19613 5612 25 God God NNP 19613 5612 26 and and CC 19613 5612 27 this this DT 19613 5612 28 confidence confidence NN 19613 5612 29 is be VBZ 19613 5612 30 a a DT 19613 5612 31 proof proof NN 19613 5612 32 of of IN 19613 5612 33 the the DT 19613 5612 34 vividness vividness NN 19613 5612 35 of of IN 19613 5612 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5612 37 idea idea NN 19613 5612 38 of of IN 19613 5612 39 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5612 40 . . . 19613 5613 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5613 2 this this DT 19613 5613 3 conception conception NN 19613 5613 4 assumes assume VBZ 19613 5613 5 that that IN 19613 5613 6 in in IN 19613 5613 7 the the DT 19613 5613 8 other other JJ 19613 5613 9 world world NN 19613 5613 10 there there EX 19613 5613 11 will will MD 19613 5613 12 be be VB 19613 5613 13 a a DT 19613 5613 14 return return NN 19613 5613 15 of of IN 19613 5613 16 the the DT 19613 5613 17 flesh flesh NN 19613 5613 18 , , , 19613 5613 19 which which WDT 19613 5613 20 on on IN 19613 5613 21 this this DT 19613 5613 22 side side NN 19613 5613 23 the the DT 19613 5613 24 grave grave NN 19613 5613 25 had have VBD 19613 5613 26 to to TO 19613 5613 27 be be VB 19613 5613 28 overcome overcome VBN 19613 5613 29 and and CC 19613 5613 30 regarded regard VBN 19613 5613 31 as as IN 19613 5613 32 non non JJ 19613 5613 33 - - JJ 19613 5613 34 existent existent NN 19613 5613 35 . . . 19613 5614 1 A a DT 19613 5614 2 clearly clearly RB 19613 5614 3 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 5614 4 element element NN 19613 5614 5 is be VBZ 19613 5614 6 found find VBN 19613 5614 7 only only RB 19613 5614 8 in in IN 19613 5614 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5614 10 . . . 19613 5614 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5615 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5615 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5615 3 444 444 CD 19613 5615 4 : : : 19613 5615 5 No no DT 19613 5615 6 uniform uniform JJ 19613 5615 7 conception conception NN 19613 5615 8 of of IN 19613 5615 9 this this DT 19613 5615 10 is be VBZ 19613 5615 11 found find VBN 19613 5615 12 in in IN 19613 5615 13 the the DT 19613 5615 14 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5615 15 ; ; : 19613 5615 16 see see VB 19613 5615 17 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 5615 18 , , , 19613 5615 19 Die die VB 19613 5615 20 Christliche Christliche NNP 19613 5615 21 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 5615 22 von von NNP 19613 5615 23 der der XX 19613 5615 24 menschlichen menschlichen NNP 19613 5615 25 Vollkommenheit Vollkommenheit NNP 19613 5615 26 1882 1882 CD 19613 5615 27 , , , 19613 5615 28 pp pp NNP 19613 5615 29 . . . 19613 5616 1 8 8 CD 19613 5616 2 - - SYM 19613 5616 3 20 20 CD 19613 5616 4 . . . 19613 5617 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5617 2 speaks speak VBZ 19613 5617 3 only only RB 19613 5617 4 of of IN 19613 5617 5 a a DT 19613 5617 6 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 5617 7 destination destination NN 19613 5617 8 for for IN 19613 5617 9 which which WDT 19613 5617 10 man man NN 19613 5617 11 is be VBZ 19613 5617 12 naturally naturally RB 19613 5617 13 adapted adapt VBN 19613 5617 14 . . . 19613 5618 1 With with IN 19613 5618 2 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5618 3 and and CC 19613 5618 4 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5618 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5618 6 is be VBZ 19613 5618 7 different different JJ 19613 5618 8 . . . 19613 5618 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5619 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5619 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5619 3 445 445 CD 19613 5619 4 : : : 19613 5619 5 The the DT 19613 5619 6 idea idea NN 19613 5619 7 that that IN 19613 5619 8 the the DT 19613 5619 9 demon demon NN 19613 5619 10 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 5619 11 has have VBZ 19613 5619 12 led lead VBN 19613 5619 13 to to IN 19613 5619 14 some some DT 19613 5619 15 change change NN 19613 5619 16 in in IN 19613 5619 17 the the DT 19613 5619 18 psychological psychological JJ 19613 5619 19 condition condition NN 19613 5619 20 and and CC 19613 5619 21 capacities capacity NNS 19613 5619 22 of of IN 19613 5619 23 man man NN 19613 5619 24 is be VBZ 19613 5619 25 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 5619 26 unknown unknown JJ 19613 5619 27 to to IN 19613 5619 28 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5619 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5619 30 see see VB 19613 5619 31 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 5619 32 , , , 19613 5619 33 l.c l.c NNP 19613 5619 34 . . NNP 19613 5619 35 , , , 19613 5619 36 p. p. NN 19613 5619 37 11 11 CD 19613 5619 38 f. f. NNP 19613 5619 39 , , , 19613 5619 40 who who WP 19613 5619 41 has have VBZ 19613 5619 42 successfully successfully RB 19613 5619 43 defended defend VBN 19613 5619 44 the the DT 19613 5619 45 correct correct JJ 19613 5619 46 view view NN 19613 5619 47 in in IN 19613 5619 48 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 5619 49 's 's POS 19613 5619 50 " " `` 19613 5619 51 Das Das NNP 19613 5619 52 Christenthum Christenthum NNP 19613 5619 53 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5619 54 's 's POS 19613 5619 55 des des NNP 19613 5619 56 Märtyrers Märtyrers NNP 19613 5619 57 " " '' 19613 5619 58 pp pp NNP 19613 5619 59 . . . 19613 5620 1 92 92 CD 19613 5620 2 f. f. NNP 19613 5620 3 151 151 CD 19613 5620 4 . . . 19613 5620 5 f. f. NNP 19613 5620 6 266 266 CD 19613 5620 7 f. f. NNP 19613 5620 8 , , , 19613 5620 9 against against IN 19613 5620 10 Stählin Stählin NNP 19613 5620 11 , , , 19613 5620 12 " " `` 19613 5620 13 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5620 14 der der VBD 19613 5620 15 Märtyrer Märtyrer NNP 19613 5620 16 und und RB 19613 5620 17 sein sein NNP 19613 5620 18 neuester neuester NNP 19613 5620 19 Beurtheiler Beurtheiler NNP 19613 5620 20 " " '' 19613 5620 21 1880 1880 CD 19613 5620 22 , , , 19613 5620 23 p. p. NN 19613 5620 24 16 16 CD 19613 5620 25 f. f. NNP 19613 5620 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5620 27 . . . 19613 5621 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5621 2 expressed express VBD 19613 5621 3 a a DT 19613 5621 4 different different JJ 19613 5621 5 opinion opinion NN 19613 5621 6 , , , 19613 5621 7 which which WDT 19613 5621 8 , , , 19613 5621 9 however however RB 19613 5621 10 , , , 19613 5621 11 involved involve VBD 19613 5621 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5621 13 in in IN 19613 5621 14 evident evident JJ 19613 5621 15 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 5621 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5621 17 see see VB 19613 5621 18 above above RB 19613 5621 19 , , , 19613 5621 20 p. p. NN 19613 5621 21 191 191 CD 19613 5621 22 ff ff NNP 19613 5621 23 . . . 19613 5621 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5621 25 . . . 19613 5622 1 The the DT 19613 5622 2 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5622 3 theology theology NN 19613 5622 4 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5622 5 adhered adhere VBD 19613 5622 6 to to IN 19613 5622 7 the the DT 19613 5622 8 two two CD 19613 5622 9 following follow VBG 19613 5622 10 propositions proposition NNS 19613 5622 11 : : : 19613 5622 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5622 13 1 1 LS 19613 5622 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5622 15 The the DT 19613 5622 16 freedom freedom NN 19613 5622 17 to to TO 19613 5622 18 do do VB 19613 5622 19 what what WP 19613 5622 20 is be VBZ 19613 5622 21 good good JJ 19613 5622 22 is be VBZ 19613 5622 23 not not RB 19613 5622 24 lost lose VBN 19613 5622 25 and and CC 19613 5622 26 can can MD 19613 5622 27 not not RB 19613 5622 28 be be VB 19613 5622 29 . . . 19613 5623 1 This this DT 19613 5623 2 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5623 3 was be VBD 19613 5623 4 opposed opposed JJ 19613 5623 5 to to IN 19613 5623 6 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 5623 7 determinism determinism NN 19613 5623 8 and and CC 19613 5623 9 popular popular JJ 19613 5623 10 fatalism fatalism NN 19613 5623 11 . . . 19613 5624 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5624 2 2 2 LS 19613 5624 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5624 4 The the DT 19613 5624 5 desires desire NNS 19613 5624 6 of of IN 19613 5624 7 the the DT 19613 5624 8 flesh flesh NN 19613 5624 9 resulting result VBG 19613 5624 10 from from IN 19613 5624 11 the the DT 19613 5624 12 constitution constitution NNP 19613 5624 13 of of IN 19613 5624 14 man man NN 19613 5624 15 only only RB 19613 5624 16 become become VB 19613 5624 17 evil evil NN 19613 5624 18 when when WRB 19613 5624 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5624 20 destroy destroy VBP 19613 5624 21 or or CC 19613 5624 22 endanger endanger VBP 19613 5624 23 the the DT 19613 5624 24 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 5624 25 of of IN 19613 5624 26 reason reason NN 19613 5624 27 . . . 19613 5625 1 The the DT 19613 5625 2 formal formal JJ 19613 5625 3 _ _ NNP 19613 5625 4 liberum liberum NN 19613 5625 5 arbitrium arbitrium NN 19613 5625 6 _ _ NNP 19613 5625 7 explains explain VBZ 19613 5625 8 the the DT 19613 5625 9 possibility possibility NN 19613 5625 10 of of IN 19613 5625 11 sin sin NN 19613 5625 12 , , , 19613 5625 13 whilst whilst IN 19613 5625 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5625 15 actual actual JJ 19613 5625 16 existence existence NN 19613 5625 17 is be VBZ 19613 5625 18 accounted account VBN 19613 5625 19 for for IN 19613 5625 20 by by IN 19613 5625 21 the the DT 19613 5625 22 desire desire NN 19613 5625 23 that that WDT 19613 5625 24 is be VBZ 19613 5625 25 excited excite VBN 19613 5625 26 by by IN 19613 5625 27 the the DT 19613 5625 28 demons demon NNS 19613 5625 29 . . . 19613 5626 1 The the DT 19613 5626 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5626 3 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 19613 5626 4 the the DT 19613 5626 5 universality universality NN 19613 5626 6 of of IN 19613 5626 7 sin sin NN 19613 5626 8 and and CC 19613 5626 9 death death NN 19613 5626 10 , , , 19613 5626 11 but but CC 19613 5626 12 refused refuse VBD 19613 5626 13 to to TO 19613 5626 14 admit admit VB 19613 5626 15 the the DT 19613 5626 16 necessity necessity NN 19613 5626 17 of of IN 19613 5626 18 the the DT 19613 5626 19 former former JJ 19613 5626 20 in in IN 19613 5626 21 order order NN 19613 5626 22 not not RB 19613 5626 23 to to TO 19613 5626 24 call call VB 19613 5626 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5626 26 guilty guilty JJ 19613 5626 27 character character NN 19613 5626 28 in in IN 19613 5626 29 question question NN 19613 5626 30 . . . 19613 5627 1 On on IN 19613 5627 2 the the DT 19613 5627 3 other other JJ 19613 5627 4 hand hand NN 19613 5627 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5627 6 are be VBP 19613 5627 7 deeply deeply RB 19613 5627 8 imbued imbue VBN 19613 5627 9 with with IN 19613 5627 10 the the DT 19613 5627 11 idea idea NN 19613 5627 12 that that IN 19613 5627 13 the the DT 19613 5627 14 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 5627 15 of of IN 19613 5627 16 death death NN 19613 5627 17 is be VBZ 19613 5627 18 the the DT 19613 5627 19 most most RBS 19613 5627 20 powerful powerful JJ 19613 5627 21 factor factor NN 19613 5627 22 in in IN 19613 5627 23 the the DT 19613 5627 24 perpetuation perpetuation NN 19613 5627 25 of of IN 19613 5627 26 sin sin NN 19613 5627 27 . . . 19613 5628 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5628 2 believing believe VBG 19613 5628 3 conviction conviction NN 19613 5628 4 of of IN 19613 5628 5 the the DT 19613 5628 6 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 5628 7 of of IN 19613 5628 8 God God NNP 19613 5628 9 , , , 19613 5628 10 as as RB 19613 5628 11 well well RB 19613 5628 12 as as IN 19613 5628 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5628 14 moral moral JJ 19613 5628 15 conviction conviction NN 19613 5628 16 of of IN 19613 5628 17 the the DT 19613 5628 18 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 5628 19 of of IN 19613 5628 20 man man NN 19613 5628 21 , , , 19613 5628 22 protected protect VBD 19613 5628 23 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5628 24 in in IN 19613 5628 25 theory theory NN 19613 5628 26 from from IN 19613 5628 27 a a DT 19613 5628 28 strictly strictly RB 19613 5628 29 dualistic dualistic JJ 19613 5628 30 conception conception NN 19613 5628 31 of of IN 19613 5628 32 the the DT 19613 5628 33 world world NN 19613 5628 34 . . . 19613 5629 1 At at IN 19613 5629 2 the the DT 19613 5629 3 same same JJ 19613 5629 4 time time NN 19613 5629 5 , , , 19613 5629 6 like like IN 19613 5629 7 all all DT 19613 5629 8 who who WP 19613 5629 9 separate separate VBP 19613 5629 10 nature nature NN 19613 5629 11 and and CC 19613 5629 12 morality morality NN 19613 5629 13 in in IN 19613 5629 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5629 15 ethical ethical JJ 19613 5629 16 system system NN 19613 5629 17 , , , 19613 5629 18 though though IN 19613 5629 19 in in IN 19613 5629 20 other other JJ 19613 5629 21 respects respect NNS 19613 5629 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5629 23 do do VBP 19613 5629 24 not not RB 19613 5629 25 do do VB 19613 5629 26 so so RB 19613 5629 27 , , , 19613 5629 28 the the DT 19613 5629 29 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5629 30 were be VBD 19613 5629 31 obliged oblige VBN 19613 5629 32 in in IN 19613 5629 33 practice practice NN 19613 5629 34 to to TO 19613 5629 35 be be VB 19613 5629 36 dualists dualist NNS 19613 5629 37 . . . 19613 5629 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5630 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5630 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5630 3 446 446 CD 19613 5630 4 : : : 19613 5630 5 Death death NN 19613 5630 6 is be VBZ 19613 5630 7 accounted account VBN 19613 5630 8 the the DT 19613 5630 9 worst bad JJS 19613 5630 10 evil evil NN 19613 5630 11 . . . 19613 5631 1 When when WRB 19613 5631 2 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5631 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5631 4 II II NNP 19613 5631 5 . . . 19613 5632 1 26 26 CD 19613 5632 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5632 3 represents represent VBZ 19613 5632 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5632 5 as as IN 19613 5632 6 a a DT 19613 5632 7 blessing blessing NN 19613 5632 8 , , , 19613 5632 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5632 10 must must MD 19613 5632 11 consider consider VB 19613 5632 12 that that IN 19613 5632 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5632 14 is be VBZ 19613 5632 15 arguing argue VBG 19613 5632 16 against against IN 19613 5632 17 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5632 18 . . . 19613 5633 1 Polytheism polytheism NN 19613 5633 2 is be VBZ 19613 5633 3 traced trace VBN 19613 5633 4 to to IN 19613 5633 5 the the DT 19613 5633 6 demons demon NNS 19613 5633 7 ; ; : 19613 5633 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5633 9 are be VBP 19613 5633 10 accounted account VBN 19613 5633 11 the the DT 19613 5633 12 authors author NNS 19613 5633 13 of of IN 19613 5633 14 the the DT 19613 5633 15 fables fable NNS 19613 5633 16 about about IN 19613 5633 17 the the DT 19613 5633 18 gods god NNS 19613 5633 19 ; ; : 19613 5633 20 the the DT 19613 5633 21 shameful shameful JJ 19613 5633 22 actions action NNS 19613 5633 23 of of IN 19613 5633 24 the the DT 19613 5633 25 latter latter JJ 19613 5633 26 are be VBP 19613 5633 27 partly partly RB 19613 5633 28 the the DT 19613 5633 29 deeds deed NNS 19613 5633 30 of of IN 19613 5633 31 demons demon NNS 19613 5633 32 and and CC 19613 5633 33 partly partly RB 19613 5633 34 lies lie VBZ 19613 5633 35 . . . 19613 5633 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5634 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5634 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5634 3 447 447 CD 19613 5634 4 : : : 19613 5634 5 The The NNP 19613 5634 6 Old Old NNP 19613 5634 7 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5634 8 therefore therefore RB 19613 5634 9 is be VBZ 19613 5634 10 not not RB 19613 5634 11 primarily primarily RB 19613 5634 12 viewed view VBN 19613 5634 13 as as IN 19613 5634 14 the the DT 19613 5634 15 book book NN 19613 5634 16 of of IN 19613 5634 17 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 5634 18 or or CC 19613 5634 19 of of IN 19613 5634 20 preparation preparation NN 19613 5634 21 for for IN 19613 5634 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5634 23 , , , 19613 5634 24 but but CC 19613 5634 25 as as IN 19613 5634 26 the the DT 19613 5634 27 book book NN 19613 5634 28 of of IN 19613 5634 29 the the DT 19613 5634 30 full full JJ 19613 5634 31 revelation revelation NN 19613 5634 32 which which WDT 19613 5634 33 can can MD 19613 5634 34 not not RB 19613 5634 35 be be VB 19613 5634 36 surpassed surpass VBN 19613 5634 37 . . . 19613 5635 1 In in IN 19613 5635 2 point point NN 19613 5635 3 of of IN 19613 5635 4 content content NN 19613 5635 5 the the DT 19613 5635 6 teaching teaching NN 19613 5635 7 of of IN 19613 5635 8 the the DT 19613 5635 9 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5635 10 and and CC 19613 5635 11 of of IN 19613 5635 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5635 13 is be VBZ 19613 5635 14 completely completely RB 19613 5635 15 identical identical JJ 19613 5635 16 . . . 19613 5636 1 The the DT 19613 5636 2 prophetical prophetical JJ 19613 5636 3 details detail NNS 19613 5636 4 in in IN 19613 5636 5 the the DT 19613 5636 6 Old Old NNP 19613 5636 7 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5636 8 serve serve VBP 19613 5636 9 only only RB 19613 5636 10 to to TO 19613 5636 11 attest attest VB 19613 5636 12 the the DT 19613 5636 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5636 14 one one CD 19613 5636 15 _ _ NNP 19613 5636 16 truth truth NN 19613 5636 17 . . . 19613 5637 1 The the DT 19613 5637 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5637 3 confess confess NN 19613 5637 4 that that IN 19613 5637 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5637 6 were be VBD 19613 5637 7 converted convert VBN 19613 5637 8 to to IN 19613 5637 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5637 10 by by IN 19613 5637 11 reading read VBG 19613 5637 12 the the DT 19613 5637 13 Old Old NNP 19613 5637 14 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5637 15 . . . 19613 5638 1 Cf cf NN 19613 5638 2 . . . 19613 5639 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5639 2 's 's POS 19613 5639 3 and and CC 19613 5639 4 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5639 5 's 's POS 19613 5639 6 confessions confession NNS 19613 5639 7 . . . 19613 5640 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 19613 5640 2 Commodian Commodian NNP 19613 5640 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5640 4 Instruct Instruct NNP 19613 5640 5 . . . 19613 5641 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5642 1 1 1 LS 19613 5642 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5642 3 is be VBZ 19613 5642 4 also also RB 19613 5642 5 be be VB 19613 5642 6 understood understand VBN 19613 5642 7 thus thus RB 19613 5642 8 . . . 19613 5642 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5643 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5643 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5643 3 448 448 CD 19613 5643 4 : : : 19613 5643 5 The the DT 19613 5643 6 _ _ NNP 19613 5643 7 Oratio Oratio NNP 19613 5643 8 _ _ NNP 19613 5643 9 of of IN 19613 5643 10 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5643 11 is be VBZ 19613 5643 12 very very RB 19613 5643 13 instructive instructive JJ 19613 5643 14 in in IN 19613 5643 15 this this DT 19613 5643 16 respect respect NN 19613 5643 17 . . . 19613 5644 1 In in IN 19613 5644 2 this this DT 19613 5644 3 book book NN 19613 5644 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5644 5 has have VBZ 19613 5644 6 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 5644 7 spoken speak VBN 19613 5644 8 _ _ NNP 19613 5644 9 ex ex NNP 19613 5644 10 professo professo NNP 19613 5644 11 _ _ NNP 19613 5644 12 of of IN 19613 5644 13 the the DT 19613 5644 14 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5644 15 of of IN 19613 5644 16 the the DT 19613 5644 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5644 18 in in IN 19613 5644 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5644 20 ; ; : 19613 5644 21 but but CC 19613 5644 22 in in IN 19613 5644 23 c. c. NNP 19613 5644 24 13 13 CD 19613 5644 25 fin fin NN 19613 5644 26 . . . 19613 5645 1 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5645 2 calls call VBZ 19613 5645 3 the the DT 19613 5645 4 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5645 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5645 6 " " '' 19613 5645 7 the the DT 19613 5645 8 servant servant NN 19613 5645 9 of of IN 19613 5645 10 God God NNP 19613 5645 11 who who WP 19613 5645 12 has have VBZ 19613 5645 13 suffered suffer VBN 19613 5645 14 , , , 19613 5645 15 " " '' 19613 5645 16 and and CC 19613 5645 17 in in IN 19613 5645 18 c. c. NNP 19613 5645 19 21 21 CD 19613 5645 20 init init NN 19613 5645 21 . . . 19613 5646 1 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5646 2 says say VBZ 19613 5646 3 : : : 19613 5646 4 " " `` 19613 5646 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5646 6 are be VBP 19613 5646 7 not not RB 19613 5646 8 fools fool NNS 19613 5646 9 and and CC 19613 5646 10 do do VBP 19613 5646 11 not not RB 19613 5646 12 adduce adduce VB 19613 5646 13 anything anything NN 19613 5646 14 stupid stupid JJ 19613 5646 15 , , , 19613 5646 16 when when WRB 19613 5646 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5646 18 proclaim proclaim VBP 19613 5646 19 that that IN 19613 5646 20 God God NNP 19613 5646 21 has have VBZ 19613 5646 22 appeared appear VBN 19613 5646 23 in in IN 19613 5646 24 human human JJ 19613 5646 25 form form NN 19613 5646 26 . . . 19613 5646 27 " " '' 19613 5647 1 Similar similar JJ 19613 5647 2 expressions expression NNS 19613 5647 3 are be VBP 19613 5647 4 found find VBN 19613 5647 5 in in IN 19613 5647 6 Minucius Minucius NNP 19613 5647 7 Felix Felix NNP 19613 5647 8 . . . 19613 5648 1 In in IN 19613 5648 2 no no DT 19613 5648 3 part part NN 19613 5648 4 of of IN 19613 5648 5 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 5648 6 ' ' POS 19613 5648 7 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5648 8 is be VBZ 19613 5648 9 there there EX 19613 5648 10 any any DT 19613 5648 11 mention mention NN 19613 5648 12 of of IN 19613 5648 13 the the DT 19613 5648 14 pre pre JJ 19613 5648 15 - - JJ 19613 5648 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 5648 17 appearance appearance NN 19613 5648 18 of of IN 19613 5648 19 the the DT 19613 5648 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5648 21 . . . 19613 5649 1 The the DT 19613 5649 2 writer writer NN 19613 5649 3 merely merely RB 19613 5649 4 speaks speak VBZ 19613 5649 5 of of IN 19613 5649 6 the the DT 19613 5649 7 revelation revelation NN 19613 5649 8 of of IN 19613 5649 9 the the DT 19613 5649 10 Son Son NNP 19613 5649 11 of of IN 19613 5649 12 God God NNP 19613 5649 13 in in IN 19613 5649 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5649 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5649 16 . . . 19613 5649 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5650 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5650 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5650 3 449 449 CD 19613 5650 4 : : : 19613 5650 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5650 6 seldom seldom RB 19613 5650 7 receive receive VBP 19613 5650 8 an an DT 19613 5650 9 answer answer NN 19613 5650 10 to to IN 19613 5650 11 the the DT 19613 5650 12 question question NN 19613 5650 13 as as IN 19613 5650 14 to to IN 19613 5650 15 why why WRB 19613 5650 16 this this DT 19613 5650 17 or or CC 19613 5650 18 that that DT 19613 5650 19 particular particular JJ 19613 5650 20 occurrence occurrence NN 19613 5650 21 should should MD 19613 5650 22 have have VB 19613 5650 23 been be VBN 19613 5650 24 prophesied prophesy VBN 19613 5650 25 . . . 19613 5651 1 According accord VBG 19613 5651 2 to to IN 19613 5651 3 the the DT 19613 5651 4 ideas idea NNS 19613 5651 5 of of IN 19613 5651 6 the the DT 19613 5651 7 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5651 8 , , , 19613 5651 9 however however RB 19613 5651 10 , , , 19613 5651 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5651 12 have have VBP 19613 5651 13 hardly hardly RB 19613 5651 14 a a DT 19613 5651 15 right right NN 19613 5651 16 to to TO 19613 5651 17 put put VB 19613 5651 18 that that DT 19613 5651 19 question question NN 19613 5651 20 ; ; : 19613 5651 21 for for IN 19613 5651 22 , , , 19613 5651 23 since since IN 19613 5651 24 the the DT 19613 5651 25 value value NN 19613 5651 26 of of IN 19613 5651 27 the the DT 19613 5651 28 historical historical JJ 19613 5651 29 consists consist VBZ 19613 5651 30 in in IN 19613 5651 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5651 32 having have VBG 19613 5651 33 been be VBN 19613 5651 34 predicted predict VBN 19613 5651 35 , , , 19613 5651 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5651 37 content content NN 19613 5651 38 is be VBZ 19613 5651 39 of of IN 19613 5651 40 no no DT 19613 5651 41 importance importance NN 19613 5651 42 . . . 19613 5652 1 The the DT 19613 5652 2 fact fact NN 19613 5652 3 that that IN 19613 5652 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5652 5 finds find VBZ 19613 5652 6 the the DT 19613 5652 7 she she JJ 19613 5652 8 - - HYPH 19613 5652 9 ass as NNS 19613 5652 10 bound bind VBN 19613 5652 11 to to IN 19613 5652 12 a a DT 19613 5652 13 vine vine NN 19613 5652 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5652 15 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5652 16 , , , 19613 5652 17 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5652 18 . . . 19613 5653 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5654 1 32 32 CD 19613 5654 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5654 3 is be VBZ 19613 5654 4 virtually virtually RB 19613 5654 5 quite quite RB 19613 5654 6 as as RB 19613 5654 7 important important JJ 19613 5654 8 as as IN 19613 5654 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5654 10 being be VBG 19613 5654 11 born bear VBN 19613 5654 12 of of IN 19613 5654 13 a a DT 19613 5654 14 virgin virgin NN 19613 5654 15 . . . 19613 5655 1 Both both DT 19613 5655 2 occurrences occurrence NNS 19613 5655 3 attest attest VBP 19613 5655 4 the the DT 19613 5655 5 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 5655 6 teachings teaching NNS 19613 5655 7 of of IN 19613 5655 8 God God NNP 19613 5655 9 , , , 19613 5655 10 freedom freedom NN 19613 5655 11 , , , 19613 5655 12 etc etc FW 19613 5655 13 . . . 19613 5655 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5656 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5656 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5656 3 450 450 CD 19613 5656 4 : : : 19613 5656 5 In in IN 19613 5656 6 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5656 7 's 's POS 19613 5656 8 polemical polemical JJ 19613 5656 9 works work NNS 19613 5656 10 this this DT 19613 5656 11 must must MD 19613 5656 12 have have VB 19613 5656 13 appeared appear VBN 19613 5656 14 in in IN 19613 5656 15 a a DT 19613 5656 16 still still RB 19613 5656 17 more more RBR 19613 5656 18 striking striking JJ 19613 5656 19 way way NN 19613 5656 20 . . . 19613 5657 1 Thus thus RB 19613 5657 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5657 3 find find VBP 19613 5657 4 in in IN 19613 5657 5 a a DT 19613 5657 6 fragment fragment NN 19613 5657 7 of of IN 19613 5657 8 the the DT 19613 5657 9 treatise treatise NN 19613 5657 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5657 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5657 12 : : : 19613 5657 13 pros pro NNS 19613 5657 14 Markiôna Markiôna NNP 19613 5657 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5657 16 , , , 19613 5657 17 quoted quote VBN 19613 5657 18 by by IN 19613 5657 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5657 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5657 21 IV IV NNP 19613 5657 22 . . . 19613 5658 1 6 6 CD 19613 5658 2 . . . 19613 5659 1 2 2 LS 19613 5659 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5659 3 , , , 19613 5659 4 the the DT 19613 5659 5 sentence sentence NN 19613 5659 6 " " `` 19613 5659 7 unigenitus unigenitus NNP 19613 5659 8 filius filius NNP 19613 5659 9 venit venit NNP 19613 5659 10 ad ad NN 19613 5659 11 nos nos NNP 19613 5659 12 , , , 19613 5659 13 suum suum NNP 19613 5659 14 plasma plasma NNP 19613 5659 15 in in IN 19613 5659 16 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 5659 17 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 5659 18 . . . 19613 5659 19 " " '' 19613 5660 1 So so RB 19613 5660 2 the the DT 19613 5660 3 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 5660 4 of of IN 19613 5660 5 the the DT 19613 5660 6 _ _ NNP 19613 5660 7 recapitulatio recapitulatio NN 19613 5660 8 per per IN 19613 5660 9 Christum Christum NNP 19613 5660 10 _ _ NNP 19613 5660 11 already already RB 19613 5660 12 appeared appear VBD 19613 5660 13 in in IN 19613 5660 14 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5660 15 . . . 19613 5661 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5661 2 Vide vide NN 19613 5661 3 also also RB 19613 5661 4 Dial dial VB 19613 5661 5 . . . 19613 5662 1 c. c. NN 19613 5662 2 Tryph Tryph NNP 19613 5662 3 . . . 19613 5663 1 100 100 CD 19613 5663 2 . . . 19613 5663 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5664 1 If if IN 19613 5664 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5664 3 compare compare VBP 19613 5664 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5664 5 's 's POS 19613 5664 6 _ _ NNP 19613 5664 7 Apologeticum Apologeticum NNP 19613 5664 8 _ _ NNP 19613 5664 9 with with IN 19613 5664 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5664 11 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 5664 12 writings writing NNS 19613 5664 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5664 14 easily easily RB 19613 5664 15 see see VBP 19613 5664 16 how how WRB 19613 5664 17 impossible impossible JJ 19613 5664 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5664 19 is be VBZ 19613 5664 20 to to TO 19613 5664 21 determine determine VB 19613 5664 22 from from IN 19613 5664 23 that that DT 19613 5664 24 work work NN 19613 5664 25 the the DT 19613 5664 26 extent extent NN 19613 5664 27 of of IN 19613 5664 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5664 29 Christian christian JJ 19613 5664 30 faith faith NN 19613 5664 31 and and CC 19613 5664 32 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5664 33 . . . 19613 5665 1 The the DT 19613 5665 2 same same JJ 19613 5665 3 is be VBZ 19613 5665 4 probably probably RB 19613 5665 5 the the DT 19613 5665 6 case case NN 19613 5665 7 , , , 19613 5665 8 though though IN 19613 5665 9 to to IN 19613 5665 10 a a DT 19613 5665 11 less less JJR 19613 5665 12 extent extent NN 19613 5665 13 , , , 19613 5665 14 with with IN 19613 5665 15 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5665 16 's 's POS 19613 5665 17 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5665 18 writings writing NNS 19613 5665 19 . . . 19613 5665 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5666 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5666 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5666 3 451 451 CD 19613 5666 4 : : : 19613 5666 5 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5666 6 do do VBP 19613 5666 7 not not RB 19613 5666 8 place place VB 19613 5666 9 a a DT 19613 5666 10 man man NN 19613 5666 11 alongside alongside IN 19613 5666 12 of of IN 19613 5666 13 God God NNP 19613 5666 14 , , , 19613 5666 15 for for IN 19613 5666 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5666 17 is be VBZ 19613 5666 18 God God NNP 19613 5666 19 , , , 19613 5666 20 though though IN 19613 5666 21 indeed indeed RB 19613 5666 22 a a DT 19613 5666 23 second second JJ 19613 5666 24 God God NNP 19613 5666 25 . . . 19613 5667 1 There there EX 19613 5667 2 is be VBZ 19613 5667 3 no no DT 19613 5667 4 question question NN 19613 5667 5 of of IN 19613 5667 6 two two CD 19613 5667 7 natures nature NNS 19613 5667 8 . . . 19613 5668 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5668 2 is be VBZ 19613 5668 3 not not RB 19613 5668 4 the the DT 19613 5668 5 divine divine JJ 19613 5668 6 nature nature NN 19613 5668 7 that that WDT 19613 5668 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5668 9 has have VBZ 19613 5668 10 insufficiently insufficiently RB 19613 5668 11 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 5668 12 -- -- : 19613 5668 13 or or CC 19613 5668 14 at at IN 19613 5668 15 least least JJS 19613 5668 16 this this DT 19613 5668 17 is be VBZ 19613 5668 18 only only RB 19613 5668 19 the the DT 19613 5668 20 case case NN 19613 5668 21 in in RB 19613 5668 22 so so RB 19613 5668 23 far far RB 19613 5668 24 as as IN 19613 5668 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5668 26 is be VBZ 19613 5668 27 a a DT 19613 5668 28 second second JJ 19613 5668 29 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5668 30 -- -- : 19613 5668 31 but but CC 19613 5668 32 the the DT 19613 5668 33 human human JJ 19613 5668 34 nature nature NN 19613 5668 35 ; ; : 19613 5668 36 see see VB 19613 5668 37 Schultz Schultz NNP 19613 5668 38 , , , 19613 5668 39 Gottheit Gottheit NNP 19613 5668 40 Christi Christi NNP 19613 5668 41 , , , 19613 5668 42 p. p. NN 19613 5668 43 39 39 CD 19613 5668 44 ff ff NN 19613 5668 45 . . . 19613 5668 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5669 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5669 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5669 3 452 452 CD 19613 5669 4 : : : 19613 5669 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5669 6 find find VBP 19613 5669 7 allusions allusion NNS 19613 5669 8 in in IN 19613 5669 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5669 10 where where WRB 19613 5669 11 the the DT 19613 5669 12 various various JJ 19613 5669 13 incidents incident NNS 19613 5669 14 in in IN 19613 5669 15 the the DT 19613 5669 16 history history NN 19613 5669 17 of of IN 19613 5669 18 the the DT 19613 5669 19 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 5669 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5669 21 are be VBP 19613 5669 22 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5669 23 as as IN 19613 5669 24 a a DT 19613 5669 25 series series NN 19613 5669 26 of of IN 19613 5669 27 arrangements arrangement NNS 19613 5669 28 meant mean VBN 19613 5669 29 to to TO 19613 5669 30 form form VB 19613 5669 31 part part NN 19613 5669 32 of of IN 19613 5669 33 the the DT 19613 5669 34 history history NN 19613 5669 35 of of IN 19613 5669 36 salvation salvation NN 19613 5669 37 , , , 19613 5669 38 to to TO 19613 5669 39 paralyse paralyse VB 19613 5669 40 mankind mankind NN 19613 5669 41 's 's POS 19613 5669 42 sinful sinful JJ 19613 5669 43 history history NN 19613 5669 44 , , , 19613 5669 45 and and CC 19613 5669 46 to to TO 19613 5669 47 regenerate regenerate VB 19613 5669 48 humanity humanity NN 19613 5669 49 . . . 19613 5670 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5670 2 is be VBZ 19613 5670 3 thus thus RB 19613 5670 4 a a DT 19613 5670 5 forerunner forerunner NN 19613 5670 6 of of IN 19613 5670 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5670 8 and and CC 19613 5670 9 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5670 10 . . . 19613 5670 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5671 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5671 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5671 3 453 453 CD 19613 5671 4 : : : 19613 5671 5 Even even RB 19613 5671 6 the the DT 19613 5671 7 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 5671 8 of of IN 19613 5671 9 the the DT 19613 5671 10 definite definite JJ 19613 5671 11 number number NN 19613 5671 12 of of IN 19613 5671 13 the the DT 19613 5671 14 elect elect NN 19613 5671 15 , , , 19613 5671 16 which which WDT 19613 5671 17 must must MD 19613 5671 18 be be VB 19613 5671 19 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 5671 20 , , , 19613 5671 21 is be VBZ 19613 5671 22 found find VBN 19613 5671 23 in in IN 19613 5671 24 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5671 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5671 26 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5671 27 . . . 19613 5672 1 I. I. NNP 19613 5673 1 28 28 CD 19613 5673 2 , , , 19613 5673 3 45 45 CD 19613 5673 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5673 5 . . . 19613 5674 1 For for IN 19613 5674 2 that that DT 19613 5674 3 reason reason NN 19613 5674 4 the the DT 19613 5674 5 judgment judgment NN 19613 5674 6 is be VBZ 19613 5674 7 put put VBN 19613 5674 8 off off RP 19613 5674 9 by by IN 19613 5674 10 God God NNP 19613 5674 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5674 12 II II NNP 19613 5674 13 . . . 19613 5675 1 7 7 LS 19613 5675 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5675 3 . . . 19613 5676 1 The the DT 19613 5676 2 Apology Apology NNP 19613 5676 3 of of IN 19613 5676 4 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 5676 5 contains contain VBZ 19613 5676 6 a a DT 19613 5676 7 short short JJ 19613 5676 8 account account NN 19613 5676 9 of of IN 19613 5676 10 the the DT 19613 5676 11 history history NN 19613 5676 12 of of IN 19613 5676 13 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5676 14 ; ; : 19613 5676 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5676 16 conception conception NN 19613 5676 17 , , , 19613 5676 18 birth birth NN 19613 5676 19 , , , 19613 5676 20 preaching preaching NN 19613 5676 21 , , , 19613 5676 22 choice choice NN 19613 5676 23 of of IN 19613 5676 24 the the DT 19613 5676 25 12 12 CD 19613 5676 26 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 5676 27 , , , 19613 5676 28 crucifixion crucifixion NN 19613 5676 29 , , , 19613 5676 30 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 5676 31 , , , 19613 5676 32 ascension ascension NN 19613 5676 33 , , , 19613 5676 34 sending send VBG 19613 5676 35 out out IN 19613 5676 36 of of IN 19613 5676 37 the the DT 19613 5676 38 12 12 CD 19613 5676 39 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 5676 40 are be VBP 19613 5676 41 mentioned mention VBN 19613 5676 42 . . . 19613 5676 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5677 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5677 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5677 3 454 454 CD 19613 5677 4 : : : 19613 5677 5 " " `` 19613 5677 6 To to IN 19613 5677 7 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5677 8 faith faith NN 19613 5677 9 is be VBZ 19613 5677 10 only only RB 19613 5677 11 an an DT 19613 5677 12 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 5677 13 of of IN 19613 5677 14 the the DT 19613 5677 15 mission mission NN 19613 5677 16 and and CC 19613 5677 17 Sonship Sonship NNP 19613 5677 18 of of IN 19613 5677 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5677 20 and and CC 19613 5677 21 a a DT 19613 5677 22 conviction conviction NN 19613 5677 23 of of IN 19613 5677 24 the the DT 19613 5677 25 truth truth NN 19613 5677 26 of of IN 19613 5677 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5677 28 teaching teaching NN 19613 5677 29 . . . 19613 5678 1 Faith faith NN 19613 5678 2 does do VBZ 19613 5678 3 not not RB 19613 5678 4 justify justify VB 19613 5678 5 , , , 19613 5678 6 but but CC 19613 5678 7 is be VBZ 19613 5678 8 merely merely RB 19613 5678 9 a a DT 19613 5678 10 presupposition presupposition NN 19613 5678 11 of of IN 19613 5678 12 the the DT 19613 5678 13 justification justification NN 19613 5678 14 which which WDT 19613 5678 15 is be VBZ 19613 5678 16 effected effect VBN 19613 5678 17 through through IN 19613 5678 18 repentance repentance NN 19613 5678 19 , , , 19613 5678 20 change change NN 19613 5678 21 of of IN 19613 5678 22 mind mind NN 19613 5678 23 , , , 19613 5678 24 and and CC 19613 5678 25 sinless sinless VB 19613 5678 26 life life NN 19613 5678 27 . . . 19613 5679 1 Only only RB 19613 5679 2 in in IN 19613 5679 3 so so RB 19613 5679 4 far far RB 19613 5679 5 as as IN 19613 5679 6 faith faith NN 19613 5679 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5679 8 is be VBZ 19613 5679 9 already already RB 19613 5679 10 a a DT 19613 5679 11 free free JJ 19613 5679 12 decision decision NN 19613 5679 13 to to TO 19613 5679 14 serve serve VB 19613 5679 15 God God NNP 19613 5679 16 has have VBZ 19613 5679 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5679 18 the the DT 19613 5679 19 value value NN 19613 5679 20 of of IN 19613 5679 21 a a DT 19613 5679 22 saving save VBG 19613 5679 23 act act NN 19613 5679 24 , , , 19613 5679 25 which which WDT 19613 5679 26 is be VBZ 19613 5679 27 indeed indeed RB 19613 5679 28 of of IN 19613 5679 29 such such JJ 19613 5679 30 significance significance NN 19613 5679 31 that that IN 19613 5679 32 one one PRP 19613 5679 33 can can MD 19613 5679 34 say say VB 19613 5679 35 , , , 19613 5679 36 ' ' '' 19613 5679 37 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 5679 38 was be VBD 19613 5679 39 justified justify VBN 19613 5679 40 by by IN 19613 5679 41 faith faith NN 19613 5679 42 . . . 19613 5679 43 ' ' '' 19613 5680 1 In in IN 19613 5680 2 reality reality NN 19613 5680 3 , , , 19613 5680 4 however however RB 19613 5680 5 , , , 19613 5680 6 this this DT 19613 5680 7 took take VBD 19613 5680 8 place place NN 19613 5680 9 through through IN 19613 5680 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5680 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 5680 12 : : : 19613 5680 13 metanoia metanoia NN 19613 5680 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5680 15 . . . 19613 5680 16 " " '' 19613 5681 1 The the DT 19613 5681 2 idea idea NN 19613 5681 3 of of IN 19613 5681 4 the the DT 19613 5681 5 new new JJ 19613 5681 6 birth birth NN 19613 5681 7 is be VBZ 19613 5681 8 exhausted exhaust VBN 19613 5681 9 in in IN 19613 5681 10 the the DT 19613 5681 11 thought thought NN 19613 5681 12 : : : 19613 5681 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5681 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5681 15 : : : 19613 5681 16 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5681 17 kalei kalei NNP 19613 5681 18 eis eis NNP 19613 5681 19 metanoian metanoian NNP 19613 5681 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5681 21 , , , 19613 5681 22 that that DT 19613 5681 23 of of IN 19613 5681 24 the the DT 19613 5681 25 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 5681 26 of of IN 19613 5681 27 sins sin NNS 19613 5681 28 in in IN 19613 5681 29 the the DT 19613 5681 30 idea idea NN 19613 5681 31 : : : 19613 5681 32 " " `` 19613 5681 33 God God NNP 19613 5681 34 is be VBZ 19613 5681 35 so so RB 19613 5681 36 good good JJ 19613 5681 37 that that IN 19613 5681 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5681 39 overlooks overlook VBZ 19613 5681 40 sins sin NNS 19613 5681 41 committed commit VBN 19613 5681 42 in in IN 19613 5681 43 a a DT 19613 5681 44 state state NN 19613 5681 45 of of IN 19613 5681 46 ignorance ignorance NN 19613 5681 47 , , , 19613 5681 48 if if IN 19613 5681 49 man man NN 19613 5681 50 has have VBZ 19613 5681 51 changed change VBN 19613 5681 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5681 53 mind mind NN 19613 5681 54 . . . 19613 5681 55 " " '' 19613 5682 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5682 2 , , , 19613 5682 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5682 4 is be VBZ 19613 5682 5 the the DT 19613 5682 6 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 5682 7 in in IN 19613 5682 8 so so RB 19613 5682 9 far far RB 19613 5682 10 as as IN 19613 5682 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5682 12 has have VBZ 19613 5682 13 brought bring VBN 19613 5682 14 about about RP 19613 5682 15 all all PDT 19613 5682 16 the the DT 19613 5682 17 conditions condition NNS 19613 5682 18 which which WDT 19613 5682 19 make make VBP 19613 5682 20 for for IN 19613 5682 21 repentance repentance NN 19613 5682 22 . . . 19613 5682 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5683 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5683 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5683 3 455 455 CD 19613 5683 4 : : : 19613 5683 5 This this DT 19613 5683 6 is be VBZ 19613 5683 7 in in IN 19613 5683 8 fact fact NN 19613 5683 9 already already RB 19613 5683 10 the the DT 19613 5683 11 case case NN 19613 5683 12 in in IN 19613 5683 13 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5683 14 here here RB 19613 5683 15 and and CC 19613 5683 16 there there RB 19613 5683 17 , , , 19613 5683 18 but but CC 19613 5683 19 in in IN 19613 5683 20 the the DT 19613 5683 21 main main NN 19613 5683 22 there there EX 19613 5683 23 are be VBP 19613 5683 24 as as RB 19613 5683 25 yet yet RB 19613 5683 26 mere mere JJ 19613 5683 27 traces trace NNS 19613 5683 28 of of IN 19613 5683 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5683 30 : : : 19613 5683 31 the the DT 19613 5683 32 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5683 33 are be VBP 19613 5683 34 no no DT 19613 5683 35 mystics mystic NNS 19613 5683 36 . . . 19613 5683 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5684 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5684 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5684 3 456 456 CD 19613 5684 4 : : : 19613 5684 5 If if IN 19613 5684 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5684 7 consider consider VBP 19613 5684 8 how how WRB 19613 5684 9 largely largely RB 19613 5684 10 the the DT 19613 5684 11 demons demon NNS 19613 5684 12 bulked bulk VBD 19613 5684 13 in in IN 19613 5684 14 the the DT 19613 5684 15 ideas idea NNS 19613 5684 16 of of IN 19613 5684 17 the the DT 19613 5684 18 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5684 19 , , , 19613 5684 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5684 21 must must MD 19613 5684 22 rate rate VB 19613 5684 23 very very RB 19613 5684 24 highly highly RB 19613 5684 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5684 26 conviction conviction NN 19613 5684 27 of of IN 19613 5684 28 the the DT 19613 5684 29 redeeming redeem VBG 19613 5684 30 power power NN 19613 5684 31 of of IN 19613 5684 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5684 33 and and CC 19613 5684 34 of of IN 19613 5684 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5684 36 name name NN 19613 5684 37 , , , 19613 5684 38 a a DT 19613 5684 39 power power NN 19613 5684 40 continuously continuously RB 19613 5684 41 shown show VBN 19613 5684 42 in in IN 19613 5684 43 the the DT 19613 5684 44 victories victory NNS 19613 5684 45 over over IN 19613 5684 46 the the DT 19613 5684 47 demons demon NNS 19613 5684 48 . . . 19613 5685 1 See see VB 19613 5685 2 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5685 3 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5685 4 . . . 19613 5686 1 II ii CD 19613 5686 2 . . . 19613 5687 1 6 6 CD 19613 5687 2 , , , 19613 5687 3 8 8 CD 19613 5687 4 ; ; : 19613 5687 5 Dial dial NN 19613 5687 6 . . . 19613 5688 1 II II NNP 19613 5688 2 , , , 19613 5688 3 30 30 CD 19613 5688 4 , , , 19613 5688 5 35 35 CD 19613 5688 6 , , , 19613 5688 7 39 39 CD 19613 5688 8 , , , 19613 5688 9 76 76 CD 19613 5688 10 , , , 19613 5688 11 85 85 CD 19613 5688 12 , , , 19613 5688 13 111 111 CD 19613 5688 14 , , , 19613 5688 15 121 121 CD 19613 5688 16 ; ; : 19613 5688 17 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 5688 18 . . NNP 19613 5688 19 , , , 19613 5688 20 Apol Apol NNP 19613 5688 21 . . . 19613 5689 1 23 23 CD 19613 5689 2 , , , 19613 5689 3 27 27 CD 19613 5689 4 , , , 19613 5689 5 32 32 CD 19613 5689 6 , , , 19613 5689 7 37 37 CD 19613 5689 8 etc etc NN 19613 5689 9 . . . 19613 5690 1 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5690 2 also also RB 19613 5690 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5690 4 16 16 CD 19613 5690 5 fin fin NN 19613 5690 6 . . . 19613 5690 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5691 1 confirms confirm VBZ 19613 5691 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5691 3 , , , 19613 5691 4 and and CC 19613 5691 5 c. c. NNP 19613 5691 6 12 12 CD 19613 5691 7 , , , 19613 5691 8 p. p. NN 19613 5691 9 56 56 CD 19613 5691 10 , , , 19613 5691 11 line line NN 19613 5691 12 7 7 CD 19613 5691 13 ff ff NN 19613 5691 14 . . . 19613 5692 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5692 2 ed ed NNP 19613 5692 3 . . . 19613 5693 1 Otto Otto NNP 19613 5693 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5693 3 does do VBZ 19613 5693 4 not not RB 19613 5693 5 contradict contradict VB 19613 5693 6 this this DT 19613 5693 7 . . . 19613 5693 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5694 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5694 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 5694 3 457 457 CD 19613 5694 4 : : : 19613 5694 5 Von Von NNP 19613 5694 6 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 5694 7 , , , 19613 5694 8 Christenthum Christenthum NNP 19613 5694 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5694 10 's 's POS 19613 5694 11 , , , 19613 5694 12 p. p. NN 19613 5694 13 432 432 CD 19613 5694 14 f. f. NNS 19613 5694 15 , , , 19613 5694 16 has have VBZ 19613 5694 17 pronounced pronounce VBN 19613 5694 18 against against IN 19613 5694 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5694 20 genuineness genuineness NN 19613 5694 21 ; ; : 19613 5694 22 see see VB 19613 5694 23 also also RB 19613 5694 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5694 25 Texte Texte NNP 19613 5694 26 und und NN 19613 5694 27 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 5694 28 I. i. NN 19613 5695 1 1 1 CD 19613 5695 2 , , , 19613 5695 3 2 2 CD 19613 5695 4 , , , 19613 5695 5 p. p. NN 19613 5695 6 158 158 CD 19613 5695 7 . . . 19613 5696 1 In in IN 19613 5696 2 favour favour NN 19613 5696 3 of of IN 19613 5696 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5696 5 genuineness genuineness NN 19613 5696 6 see see VB 19613 5696 7 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 19613 5696 8 , , , 19613 5696 9 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 5696 10 für für NN 19613 5696 11 wissenschaftliche wissenschaftliche IN 19613 5696 12 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 5696 13 , , , 19613 5696 14 1883 1883 CD 19613 5696 15 , , , 19613 5696 16 p. p. NN 19613 5696 17 26 26 CD 19613 5696 18 f. f. NN 19613 5696 19 The the DT 19613 5696 20 fragment fragment NN 19613 5696 21 is be VBZ 19613 5696 22 worded word VBN 19613 5696 23 as as IN 19613 5696 24 follows follow VBZ 19613 5696 25 : : : 19613 5696 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5696 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5696 28 : : : 19613 5696 29 Plasas Plasas NNP 19613 5696 30 ho ho RP 19613 5696 31 Theos Theos NNP 19613 5696 32 kat kat NNP 19613 5696 33 ' ' '' 19613 5696 34 archas archas NNP 19613 5696 35 ton ton NN 19613 5696 36 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 5696 37 tês tês NNP 19613 5696 38 gnômês gnômês NNP 19613 5696 39 autou autou NNP 19613 5696 40 ta ta NNP 19613 5696 41 tês tês NNP 19613 5696 42 phuseôs phuseôs NNP 19613 5696 43 apêôrêsen apêôrêsen NNP 19613 5696 44 entolê entolê NNP 19613 5696 45 mia mia NNP 19613 5696 46 poiêsamenos poiêsamenos NNP 19613 5696 47 tên tên NNP 19613 5696 48 diapeiran diapeiran NNP 19613 5696 49 . . . 19613 5697 1 Phulaxanta Phulaxanta NNP 19613 5697 2 men man NNS 19613 5697 3 gar gar NNP 19613 5697 4 tautên tautên NNP 19613 5697 5 tês tês NNP 19613 5697 6 athantou athantou NNP 19613 5697 7 lêxeôs lêxeôs VB 19613 5697 8 pepoiêken pepoiêken JJ 19613 5697 9 esesthai esesthai NNP 19613 5697 10 , , , 19613 5697 11 parabanta parabanta NNP 19613 5697 12 de de NNP 19613 5697 13 tês tês NNP 19613 5697 14 enantias enantias NNP 19613 5697 15 . . . 19613 5698 1 Outô Outô NNP 19613 5698 2 gegonôs gegonôs NNP 19613 5698 3 ho ho NNP 19613 5698 4 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 5698 5 kai kai NNP 19613 5698 6 pros pros NNP 19613 5698 7 tên tên NNP 19613 5698 8 parabasin parabasin NNP 19613 5698 9 euthus euthus NNP 19613 5698 10 elthôn elthôn NNP 19613 5698 11 tên tên NNP 19613 5698 12 phthoran phthoran NNP 19613 5698 13 phusikôs phusikôs NNP 19613 5698 14 eisedexato eisedexato NNP 19613 5698 15 . . . 19613 5699 1 Phusei Phusei NNP 19613 5699 2 de de NNP 19613 5699 3 tês tês NNP 19613 5699 4 phthoras phthoras NNP 19613 5699 5 prosgenomenês prosgenomenês NNP 19613 5699 6 anankaion anankaion NNP 19613 5699 7 ên ên NNP 19613 5699 8 hoti hoti NNP 19613 5699 9 sôsai sôsai NNP 19613 5699 10 boulomenos boulomenos NNP 19613 5699 11 ên ên NNP 19613 5699 12 tên tên NNP 19613 5699 13 phthoropoion phthoropoion NNP 19613 5699 14 ousian ousian NNP 19613 5699 15 aphanisas aphanisas NNP 19613 5699 16 . . . 19613 5700 1 Touto Touto NNP 19613 5700 2 de de NNP 19613 5700 3 ouk ouk NNP 19613 5700 4 ên ên NNP 19613 5700 5 heteros heteros NNP 19613 5700 6 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 5700 7 , , , 19613 5700 8 ei ei NNP 19613 5700 9 mêper mêper NNP 19613 5700 10 hê hê NNP 19613 5700 11 kata kata NNP 19613 5700 12 phusin phusin NNP 19613 5700 13 zôê zôê NNP 19613 5700 14 proseplakê proseplakê NNP 19613 5700 15 tô tô NNP 19613 5700 16 tên tên NNP 19613 5700 17 phthoran phthoran NNP 19613 5700 18 dexamenô dexamenô NNP 19613 5700 19 , , , 19613 5700 20 aphanizousa aphanizousa NNP 19613 5700 21 men man NNS 19613 5700 22 tên tên NNP 19613 5700 23 phthoran phthoran NNP 19613 5700 24 , , , 19613 5700 25 athanaton athanaton NNP 19613 5700 26 de de NNP 19613 5700 27 tou tou NNP 19613 5700 28 loipou loipou NNP 19613 5700 29 to to TO 19613 5700 30 dexamenon dexamenon VB 19613 5700 31 diatêrousa diatêrousa NNP 19613 5700 32 . . . 19613 5701 1 Dia Dia NNP 19613 5701 2 touto touto NNP 19613 5701 3 ton ton NN 19613 5701 4 logon logon NNP 19613 5701 5 edeêsen edeêsen NNP 19613 5701 6 en en IN 19613 5701 7 sômati sômati NNS 19613 5701 8 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 5701 9 , , , 19613 5701 10 hina hina NNP 19613 5701 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5701 12 tou tou NNP 19613 5701 13 thanatou thanatou NNP 19613 5701 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5701 15 tês tês NNP 19613 5701 16 kata kata NNP 19613 5701 17 phusin phusin NNP 19613 5701 18 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 5701 19 phthoras phthoras NNP 19613 5701 20 eleutherôsê eleutherôsê NNP 19613 5701 21 . . . 19613 5702 1 Ei Ei NNP 19613 5702 2 gar gar NNP 19613 5702 3 , , , 19613 5702 4 hôs hôs UH 19613 5702 5 phate phate NN 19613 5702 6 , , , 19613 5702 7 neumati neumati NNP 19613 5702 8 monon monon NNP 19613 5702 9 ton ton NN 19613 5702 10 thanaton thanaton NNP 19613 5702 11 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 5702 12 apekôlusen apekôlusen NNP 19613 5702 13 , , , 19613 5702 14 ou ou NNP 19613 5702 15 prosêi prosêi NNP 19613 5702 16 men man NNS 19613 5702 17 dia dia NNP 19613 5702 18 tên tên NNP 19613 5702 19 boulêsin boulêsin NNP 19613 5702 20 ho ho NNP 19613 5702 21 thanatos thanatos NNP 19613 5702 22 , , , 19613 5702 23 ouden ouden NNP 19613 5702 24 de de NNP 19613 5702 25 êtton êtton NNP 19613 5702 26 phthartoi phthartoi VBD 19613 5702 27 palin palin NNP 19613 5702 28 êmen êman NNS 19613 5702 29 phuikên phuikên NNS 19613 5702 30 en en IN 19613 5702 31 heautois heautois NNP 19613 5702 32 tên tên NNP 19613 5702 33 phthoran phthoran NNP 19613 5702 34 peripherontes peripherontes NNP 19613 5702 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5702 36 . . . 19613 5702 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5703 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5703 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5703 3 458 458 CD 19613 5703 4 : : : 19613 5703 5 Weizsäcker Weizsäcker NNP 19613 5703 6 , , , 19613 5703 7 Jahrbücher Jahrbücher NNP 19613 5703 8 fur fur NN 19613 5703 9 deutsche deutsche NN 19613 5703 10 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 5703 11 , , , 19613 5703 12 1867 1867 CD 19613 5703 13 , , , 19613 5703 14 p. p. NN 19613 5703 15 119 119 CD 19613 5703 16 , , , 19613 5703 17 has have VBZ 19613 5703 18 with with IN 19613 5703 19 good good JJ 19613 5703 20 reason reason NN 19613 5703 21 strongly strongly RB 19613 5703 22 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 5703 23 this this DT 19613 5703 24 element element NN 19613 5703 25 . . . 19613 5704 1 See see VB 19613 5704 2 also also RB 19613 5704 3 Stählin Stählin NNP 19613 5704 4 , , , 19613 5704 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5704 6 der der VBD 19613 5704 7 Martyrer Martyrer NNP 19613 5704 8 , , , 19613 5704 9 1880 1880 CD 19613 5704 10 , , , 19613 5704 11 p. p. NN 19613 5704 12 63 63 CD 19613 5704 13 f. f. NNP 19613 5704 14 , , , 19613 5704 15 whose whose WP$ 19613 5704 16 criticism criticism NN 19613 5704 17 of of IN 19613 5704 18 Von Von NNP 19613 5704 19 Engelhardt Engelhardt NNP 19613 5704 20 's 's POS 19613 5704 21 book book NN 19613 5704 22 contains contain VBZ 19613 5704 23 much much JJ 19613 5704 24 that that WDT 19613 5704 25 is be VBZ 19613 5704 26 worthy worthy JJ 19613 5704 27 of of IN 19613 5704 28 note note NN 19613 5704 29 , , , 19613 5704 30 though though IN 19613 5704 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5704 32 appears appear VBZ 19613 5704 33 to to IN 19613 5704 34 me -PRON- PRP 19613 5704 35 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 19613 5704 36 in in IN 19613 5704 37 the the DT 19613 5704 38 main main NN 19613 5704 39 . . . 19613 5704 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5705 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5705 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 5705 3 459 459 CD 19613 5705 4 : : : 19613 5705 5 Loofs Loofs NNP 19613 5705 6 continues continue VBZ 19613 5705 7 : : : 19613 5705 8 " " `` 19613 5705 9 The the DT 19613 5705 10 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5705 11 , , , 19613 5705 12 viewing view VBG 19613 5705 13 the the DT 19613 5705 14 transference transference NN 19613 5705 15 of of IN 19613 5705 16 the the DT 19613 5705 17 concept concept NN 19613 5705 18 ' ' `` 19613 5705 19 Son Son NNP 19613 5705 20 ' ' '' 19613 5705 21 to to IN 19613 5705 22 the the DT 19613 5705 23 preëxistent preëxistent JJ 19613 5705 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5705 25 as as IN 19613 5705 26 a a DT 19613 5705 27 matter matter NN 19613 5705 28 of of IN 19613 5705 29 course course NN 19613 5705 30 , , , 19613 5705 31 enabled enable VBD 19613 5705 32 the the DT 19613 5705 33 Christological christological JJ 19613 5705 34 problem problem NN 19613 5705 35 of of IN 19613 5705 36 the the DT 19613 5705 37 4th 4th JJ 19613 5705 38 century century NN 19613 5705 39 to to TO 19613 5705 40 be be VB 19613 5705 41 started start VBN 19613 5705 42 . . . 19613 5706 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 5706 2 removed remove VBD 19613 5706 3 the the DT 19613 5706 4 point point NN 19613 5706 5 of of IN 19613 5706 6 departure departure NN 19613 5706 7 of of IN 19613 5706 8 the the DT 19613 5706 9 Christological christological JJ 19613 5706 10 speculation speculation NN 19613 5706 11 from from IN 19613 5706 12 the the DT 19613 5706 13 historical historical JJ 19613 5706 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5706 15 back back RB 19613 5706 16 into into IN 19613 5706 17 the the DT 19613 5706 18 preëxistence preëxistence NN 19613 5706 19 and and CC 19613 5706 20 depreciated depreciate VBD 19613 5706 21 the the DT 19613 5706 22 importance importance NN 19613 5706 23 of of IN 19613 5706 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5706 25 ' ' POS 19613 5706 26 life life NN 19613 5706 27 as as IN 19613 5706 28 compared compare VBN 19613 5706 29 with with IN 19613 5706 30 the the DT 19613 5706 31 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5706 32 . . . 19613 5707 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 5707 2 connected connect VBD 19613 5707 3 the the DT 19613 5707 4 Christology Christology NNP 19613 5707 5 with with IN 19613 5707 6 the the DT 19613 5707 7 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 5707 8 , , , 19613 5707 9 but but CC 19613 5707 10 were be VBD 19613 5707 11 not not RB 19613 5707 12 able able JJ 19613 5707 13 to to TO 19613 5707 14 combine combine VB 19613 5707 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5707 16 with with IN 19613 5707 17 the the DT 19613 5707 18 scheme scheme NN 19613 5707 19 of of IN 19613 5707 20 salvation salvation NN 19613 5707 21 . . . 19613 5708 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5708 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5708 3 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5708 4 is be VBZ 19613 5708 5 not not RB 19613 5708 6 a a DT 19613 5708 7 ' ' `` 19613 5708 8 higher high JJR 19613 5708 9 ' ' '' 19613 5708 10 Christology christology NN 19613 5708 11 than than IN 19613 5708 12 the the DT 19613 5708 13 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 5708 14 form form NN 19613 5708 15 ; ; : 19613 5708 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5708 17 rather rather RB 19613 5708 18 lags lag VBZ 19613 5708 19 behind behind IN 19613 5708 20 the the DT 19613 5708 21 genuine genuine JJ 19613 5708 22 Christian christian JJ 19613 5708 23 estimate estimate NN 19613 5708 24 of of IN 19613 5708 25 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5708 26 . . . 19613 5709 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5709 2 is be VBZ 19613 5709 3 not not RB 19613 5709 4 God God NNP 19613 5709 5 who who WP 19613 5709 6 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 5709 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5709 8 in in IN 19613 5709 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5709 10 , , , 19613 5709 11 but but CC 19613 5709 12 the the DT 19613 5709 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5709 14 , , , 19613 5709 15 the the DT 19613 5709 16 depotentiated depotentiate VBN 19613 5709 17 God God NNP 19613 5709 18 , , , 19613 5709 19 who who WP 19613 5709 20 _ _ VBP 19613 5709 21 as as IN 19613 5709 22 God God NNP 19613 5709 23 _ _ NNP 19613 5709 24 is be VBZ 19613 5709 25 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 5709 26 to to IN 19613 5709 27 the the DT 19613 5709 28 supreme supreme JJ 19613 5709 29 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5709 30 . . . 19613 5709 31 " " '' 19613 5709 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5710 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 5710 2 V. V. NNP 19613 5710 3 THE the DT 19613 5710 4 BEGINNINGS BEGINNINGS NNP 19613 5710 5 OF of IN 19613 5710 6 AN an DT 19613 5710 7 ECCLESIASTICO ECCLESIASTICO NNP 19613 5710 8 - - HYPH 19613 5710 9 THEOLOGICAL THEOLOGICAL NNP 19613 5710 10 INTERPRETATION interpretation NN 19613 5710 11 AND and CC 19613 5710 12 REVISION revision NN 19613 5710 13 OF of IN 19613 5710 14 THE the DT 19613 5710 15 RULE rule NN 19613 5710 16 OF of IN 19613 5710 17 FAITH faith NN 19613 5710 18 IN in IN 19613 5710 19 OPPOSITION opposition NN 19613 5710 20 TO to IN 19613 5710 21 GNOSTICISM GNOSTICISM NNP 19613 5710 22 ON on IN 19613 5710 23 THE the DT 19613 5710 24 BASIS basi NNS 19613 5710 25 OF of IN 19613 5710 26 THE the DT 19613 5710 27 NEW new JJ 19613 5710 28 TESTAMENT testament NN 19613 5710 29 AND and CC 19613 5710 30 THE the DT 19613 5710 31 CHRISTIAN CHRISTIAN NNP 19613 5710 32 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 19613 5710 33 OF of IN 19613 5710 34 THE the DT 19613 5710 35 APOLOGISTS APOLOGISTS NNP 19613 5710 36 : : : 19613 5710 37 MELITO MELITO NNP 19613 5710 38 , , , 19613 5710 39 IRENÆUS IRENÆUS NNP 19613 5710 40 , , , 19613 5710 41 TERTULLIAN TERTULLIAN NNP 19613 5710 42 , , , 19613 5710 43 HIPPOLYTUS HIPPOLYTUS NNP 19613 5710 44 , , , 19613 5710 45 NOVATIAN NOVATIAN NNP 19613 5710 46 . . . 19613 5711 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5711 2 460 460 CD 19613 5711 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5711 4 1 1 CD 19613 5711 5 . . . 19613 5712 1 _ _ NNP 19613 5712 2 The the DT 19613 5712 3 theological theological JJ 19613 5712 4 position position NN 19613 5712 5 of of IN 19613 5712 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5712 7 and and CC 19613 5712 8 the the DT 19613 5712 9 later later JJ 19613 5712 10 contemporary contemporary JJ 19613 5712 11 Church Church NNP 19613 5712 12 teachers teacher NNS 19613 5712 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5712 14 . . . 19613 5713 1 Gnosticism gnosticism NN 19613 5713 2 and and CC 19613 5713 3 the the DT 19613 5713 4 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 5713 5 Church Church NNP 19613 5713 6 had have VBD 19613 5713 7 compelled compel VBN 19613 5713 8 orthodox orthodox NN 19613 5713 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5713 10 to to TO 19613 5713 11 make make VB 19613 5713 12 a a DT 19613 5713 13 selection selection NN 19613 5713 14 from from IN 19613 5713 15 tradition tradition NN 19613 5713 16 and and CC 19613 5713 17 to to TO 19613 5713 18 make make VB 19613 5713 19 this this DT 19613 5713 20 binding bind VBG 19613 5713 21 on on IN 19613 5713 22 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5713 23 as as IN 19613 5713 24 an an DT 19613 5713 25 apostolical apostolical JJ 19613 5713 26 law law NN 19613 5713 27 . . . 19613 5714 1 Everything everything NN 19613 5714 2 that that WDT 19613 5714 3 laid lay VBD 19613 5714 4 claim claim NN 19613 5714 5 to to IN 19613 5714 6 validity validity NN 19613 5714 7 had have VBD 19613 5714 8 henceforth henceforth RB 19613 5714 9 to to TO 19613 5714 10 be be VB 19613 5714 11 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 5714 12 by by IN 19613 5714 13 the the DT 19613 5714 14 faith faith NN 19613 5714 15 , , , 19613 5714 16 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5714 17 , , , 19613 5714 18 the the DT 19613 5714 19 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 5714 20 confession confession NN 19613 5714 21 and and CC 19613 5714 22 the the DT 19613 5714 23 New New NNP 19613 5714 24 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5714 25 canon canon NN 19613 5714 26 of of IN 19613 5714 27 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5714 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5714 29 see see VB 19613 5714 30 above above RB 19613 5714 31 , , , 19613 5714 32 chap chap NNP 19613 5714 33 . . . 19613 5715 1 2 2 LS 19613 5715 2 , , , 19613 5715 3 under under IN 19613 5715 4 A a NN 19613 5715 5 and and CC 19613 5715 6 B b NN 19613 5715 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5715 8 . . . 19613 5716 1 However however RB 19613 5716 2 , , , 19613 5716 3 mere mere JJ 19613 5716 4 " " `` 19613 5716 5 prescriptions prescription NNS 19613 5716 6 " " '' 19613 5716 7 could could MD 19613 5716 8 no no RB 19613 5716 9 longer long RBR 19613 5716 10 suffice suffice VB 19613 5716 11 here here RB 19613 5716 12 . . . 19613 5717 1 But but CC 19613 5717 2 the the DT 19613 5717 3 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 5717 4 confession confession NN 19613 5717 5 was be VBD 19613 5717 6 no no DT 19613 5717 7 " " `` 19613 5717 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5717 9 ; ; : 19613 5717 10 " " `` 19613 5717 11 if if IN 19613 5717 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5717 13 was be VBD 19613 5717 14 to to TO 19613 5717 15 be be VB 19613 5717 16 transformed transform VBN 19613 5717 17 into into IN 19613 5717 18 such such JJ 19613 5717 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5717 20 required require VBD 19613 5717 21 an an DT 19613 5717 22 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 5717 23 . . . 19613 5718 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5718 2 have have VBP 19613 5718 3 shown show VBN 19613 5718 4 above above IN 19613 5718 5 that that IN 19613 5718 6 the the DT 19613 5718 7 _ _ NNP 19613 5718 8 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 5718 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5718 10 baptismal baptismal NNP 19613 5718 11 confession confession NN 19613 5718 12 was be VBD 19613 5718 13 instituted institute VBN 19613 5718 14 as as IN 19613 5718 15 the the DT 19613 5718 16 guide guide NN 19613 5718 17 for for IN 19613 5718 18 the the DT 19613 5718 19 faith faith NN 19613 5718 20 . . . 19613 5719 1 This this DT 19613 5719 2 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 5719 3 took take VBD 19613 5719 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5719 5 _ _ NNP 19613 5719 6 matter matter NN 19613 5719 7 _ _ NNP 19613 5719 8 from from IN 19613 5719 9 the the DT 19613 5719 10 sacred sacred JJ 19613 5719 11 books book NNS 19613 5719 12 of of IN 19613 5719 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5719 14 both both DT 19613 5719 15 _ _ NNP 19613 5719 16 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 5719 17 . . . 19613 5720 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5720 2 owed owe VBD 19613 5720 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5720 4 guiding guide VBG 19613 5720 5 lines line NNS 19613 5720 6 , , , 19613 5720 7 however however RB 19613 5720 8 , , , 19613 5720 9 on on IN 19613 5720 10 the the DT 19613 5720 11 one one CD 19613 5720 12 hand hand NN 19613 5720 13 to to IN 19613 5720 14 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5720 15 theology theology NN 19613 5720 16 , , , 19613 5720 17 as as IN 19613 5720 18 set set VBN 19613 5720 19 forth forth RP 19613 5720 20 by by IN 19613 5720 21 the the DT 19613 5720 22 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5720 23 , , , 19613 5720 24 and and CC 19613 5720 25 on on IN 19613 5720 26 the the DT 19613 5720 27 other other JJ 19613 5720 28 to to IN 19613 5720 29 the the DT 19613 5720 30 earnest earnest JJ 19613 5720 31 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 5720 32 to to TO 19613 5720 33 maintain maintain VB 19613 5720 34 and and CC 19613 5720 35 defend defend VB 19613 5720 36 against against IN 19613 5720 37 all all DT 19613 5720 38 attacks attack NNS 19613 5720 39 the the DT 19613 5720 40 traditional traditional JJ 19613 5720 41 convictions conviction NNS 19613 5720 42 and and CC 19613 5720 43 hopes hope NNS 19613 5720 44 of of IN 19613 5720 45 believers believer NNS 19613 5720 46 , , , 19613 5720 47 as as IN 19613 5720 48 professed profess VBN 19613 5720 49 in in IN 19613 5720 50 the the DT 19613 5720 51 past past JJ 19613 5720 52 generation generation NN 19613 5720 53 by by IN 19613 5720 54 the the DT 19613 5720 55 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 5720 56 forefathers forefather NNS 19613 5720 57 of of IN 19613 5720 58 the the DT 19613 5720 59 Church Church NNP 19613 5720 60 . . . 19613 5721 1 In in IN 19613 5721 2 addition addition NN 19613 5721 3 to to IN 19613 5721 4 this this DT 19613 5721 5 , , , 19613 5721 6 certain certain JJ 19613 5721 7 interests interest NNS 19613 5721 8 , , , 19613 5721 9 which which WDT 19613 5721 10 had have VBD 19613 5721 11 found find VBN 19613 5721 12 expression expression NN 19613 5721 13 in in IN 19613 5721 14 the the DT 19613 5721 15 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5721 16 of of IN 19613 5721 17 the the DT 19613 5721 18 so so RB 19613 5721 19 - - HYPH 19613 5721 20 called call VBN 19613 5721 21 Gnostics gnostic NNS 19613 5721 22 , , , 19613 5721 23 were be VBD 19613 5721 24 adopted adopt VBN 19613 5721 25 in in IN 19613 5721 26 an an DT 19613 5721 27 increasing increase VBG 19613 5721 28 degree degree NN 19613 5721 29 among among IN 19613 5721 30 all all DT 19613 5721 31 thinking think VBG 19613 5721 32 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5721 33 , , , 19613 5721 34 and and CC 19613 5721 35 also also RB 19613 5721 36 could could MD 19613 5721 37 not not RB 19613 5721 38 but but RB 19613 5721 39 influence influence VB 19613 5721 40 the the DT 19613 5721 41 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5721 42 teachers teacher NNS 19613 5721 43 . . . 19613 5722 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5722 2 461 461 CD 19613 5722 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5722 4 The the DT 19613 5722 5 theological theological JJ 19613 5722 6 labours labour VBZ 19613 5722 7 , , , 19613 5722 8 thus thus RB 19613 5722 9 initiated initiate VBN 19613 5722 10 , , , 19613 5722 11 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5722 12 bear bear VB 19613 5722 13 the the DT 19613 5722 14 impress impress NN 19613 5722 15 of of IN 19613 5722 16 great great JJ 19613 5722 17 uniqueness uniqueness NN 19613 5722 18 and and CC 19613 5722 19 complexity complexity NN 19613 5722 20 . . . 19613 5723 1 In in IN 19613 5723 2 the the DT 19613 5723 3 first first JJ 19613 5723 4 place place NN 19613 5723 5 , , , 19613 5723 6 the the DT 19613 5723 7 old old JJ 19613 5723 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 5723 9 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 5723 10 , , , 19613 5723 11 Melito,[462 melito,[462 NN 19613 5723 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5723 13 Rhodon,[463 rhodon,[463 CD 19613 5723 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5723 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5723 16 , , , 19613 5723 17 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5723 18 , , , 19613 5723 19 and and CC 19613 5723 20 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5723 21 were be VBD 19613 5723 22 in in IN 19613 5723 23 every every DT 19613 5723 24 case case NN 19613 5723 25 convinced convince VBD 19613 5723 26 that that IN 19613 5723 27 all all DT 19613 5723 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5723 29 expositions exposition NNS 19613 5723 30 contained contain VBD 19613 5723 31 the the DT 19613 5723 32 universal universal JJ 19613 5723 33 Church Church NNP 19613 5723 34 faith faith NN 19613 5723 35 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5723 36 and and CC 19613 5723 37 nothing nothing NN 19613 5723 38 else else RB 19613 5723 39 . . . 19613 5724 1 Though though IN 19613 5724 2 the the DT 19613 5724 3 faith faith NN 19613 5724 4 is be VBZ 19613 5724 5 identical identical JJ 19613 5724 6 with with IN 19613 5724 7 the the DT 19613 5724 8 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 5724 9 confession confession NN 19613 5724 10 , , , 19613 5724 11 yet yet CC 19613 5724 12 every every DT 19613 5724 13 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 5724 14 of of IN 19613 5724 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5724 16 derived derive VBD 19613 5724 17 from from IN 19613 5724 18 the the DT 19613 5724 19 New New NNP 19613 5724 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5724 21 is be VBZ 19613 5724 22 no no DT 19613 5724 23 less less RBR 19613 5724 24 certain certain JJ 19613 5724 25 than than IN 19613 5724 26 the the DT 19613 5724 27 shortest short JJS 19613 5724 28 formula formula NN 19613 5724 29 . . . 19613 5725 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5725 2 464 464 CD 19613 5725 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5725 4 The the DT 19613 5725 5 creation creation NN 19613 5725 6 of of IN 19613 5725 7 the the DT 19613 5725 8 New New NNP 19613 5725 9 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5725 10 furnished furnish VBD 19613 5725 11 all all DT 19613 5725 12 at at IN 19613 5725 13 once once RB 19613 5725 14 a a DT 19613 5725 15 quite quite RB 19613 5725 16 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 5725 17 multitude multitude NN 19613 5725 18 of of IN 19613 5725 19 conceptions conception NNS 19613 5725 20 , , , 19613 5725 21 the the DT 19613 5725 22 whole whole NN 19613 5725 23 of of IN 19613 5725 24 which which WDT 19613 5725 25 appeared appear VBD 19613 5725 26 as as IN 19613 5725 27 " " `` 19613 5725 28 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5725 29 " " '' 19613 5725 30 and and CC 19613 5725 31 offered offer VBD 19613 5725 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5725 33 for for IN 19613 5725 34 incorporation incorporation NN 19613 5725 35 with with IN 19613 5725 36 the the DT 19613 5725 37 " " `` 19613 5725 38 faith faith NN 19613 5725 39 . . . 19613 5726 1 " " `` 19613 5726 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5726 3 465 465 CD 19613 5726 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5726 5 The the DT 19613 5726 6 limits limit NNS 19613 5726 7 of of IN 19613 5726 8 the the DT 19613 5726 9 latter latter JJ 19613 5726 10 therefore therefore RB 19613 5726 11 seem seem VBP 19613 5726 12 to to TO 19613 5726 13 be be VB 19613 5726 14 indefinitely indefinitely RB 19613 5726 15 extended extend VBN 19613 5726 16 , , , 19613 5726 17 whilst whilst RB 19613 5726 18 on on IN 19613 5726 19 the the DT 19613 5726 20 other other JJ 19613 5726 21 hand hand NN 19613 5726 22 tradition tradition NN 19613 5726 23 , , , 19613 5726 24 and and CC 19613 5726 25 polemics polemic NNS 19613 5726 26 too too RB 19613 5726 27 in in IN 19613 5726 28 many many JJ 19613 5726 29 cases case NNS 19613 5726 30 , , , 19613 5726 31 demanded demand VBD 19613 5726 32 an an DT 19613 5726 33 adherence adherence NN 19613 5726 34 to to IN 19613 5726 35 the the DT 19613 5726 36 shortest short JJS 19613 5726 37 formula formula NN 19613 5726 38 . . . 19613 5727 1 The the DT 19613 5727 2 oscillation oscillation NN 19613 5727 3 between between IN 19613 5727 4 this this DT 19613 5727 5 brief brief JJ 19613 5727 6 formula formula NN 19613 5727 7 , , , 19613 5727 8 the the DT 19613 5727 9 contents content NNS 19613 5727 10 of of IN 19613 5727 11 which which WDT 19613 5727 12 , , , 19613 5727 13 as as IN 19613 5727 14 a a DT 19613 5727 15 rule rule NN 19613 5727 16 , , , 19613 5727 17 did do VBD 19613 5727 18 not not RB 19613 5727 19 suffice suffice VB 19613 5727 20 , , , 19613 5727 21 and and CC 19613 5727 22 that that DT 19613 5727 23 fulness fulness NN 19613 5727 24 , , , 19613 5727 25 which which WDT 19613 5727 26 admitted admit VBD 19613 5727 27 of of IN 19613 5727 28 no no DT 19613 5727 29 bounds bound NNS 19613 5727 30 at at RB 19613 5727 31 all all RB 19613 5727 32 , , , 19613 5727 33 is be VBZ 19613 5727 34 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 5727 35 of of IN 19613 5727 36 the the DT 19613 5727 37 old old JJ 19613 5727 38 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 5727 39 Fathers father NNS 19613 5727 40 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5727 41 have have VBP 19613 5727 42 mentioned mention VBN 19613 5727 43 . . . 19613 5728 1 In in IN 19613 5728 2 the the DT 19613 5728 3 second second JJ 19613 5728 4 place place NN 19613 5728 5 , , , 19613 5728 6 these these DT 19613 5728 7 fathers father NNS 19613 5728 8 felt feel VBD 19613 5728 9 quite quite RB 19613 5728 10 as as RB 19613 5728 11 much much JJ 19613 5728 12 need need NN 19613 5728 13 of of IN 19613 5728 14 a a DT 19613 5728 15 rational rational JJ 19613 5728 16 proof proof NN 19613 5728 17 in in IN 19613 5728 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5728 19 arguments argument NNS 19613 5728 20 with with IN 19613 5728 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5728 22 christian christian JJ 19613 5728 23 opponents opponent NNS 19613 5728 24 , , , 19613 5728 25 as as IN 19613 5728 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5728 27 did do VBD 19613 5728 28 while while IN 19613 5728 29 contending contend VBG 19613 5728 30 with with IN 19613 5728 31 the the DT 19613 5728 32 heathen;[466 heathen;[466 NNPS 19613 5728 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5728 34 and and CC 19613 5728 35 , , , 19613 5728 36 being be VBG 19613 5728 37 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5728 38 children child NNS 19613 5728 39 of of IN 19613 5728 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5728 41 time time NN 19613 5728 42 , , , 19613 5728 43 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5728 44 required require VBD 19613 5728 45 this this DT 19613 5728 46 proof proof NN 19613 5728 47 for for IN 19613 5728 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5728 49 own own JJ 19613 5728 50 assurance assurance NN 19613 5728 51 and and CC 19613 5728 52 that that IN 19613 5728 53 of of IN 19613 5728 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5728 55 fellow fellow NN 19613 5728 56 - - HYPH 19613 5728 57 believers believer NNS 19613 5728 58 . . . 19613 5729 1 The the DT 19613 5729 2 epoch epoch NN 19613 5729 3 in in IN 19613 5729 4 which which WDT 19613 5729 5 men man NNS 19613 5729 6 appealed appeal VBD 19613 5729 7 to to IN 19613 5729 8 charisms charism NNS 19613 5729 9 , , , 19613 5729 10 and and CC 19613 5729 11 " " `` 19613 5729 12 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5729 13 " " '' 19613 5729 14 counted count VBN 19613 5729 15 as as RB 19613 5729 16 much much RB 19613 5729 17 as as IN 19613 5729 18 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 5729 19 and and CC 19613 5729 20 vision vision NN 19613 5729 21 , , , 19613 5729 22 because because IN 19613 5729 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5729 24 was be VBD 19613 5729 25 still still RB 19613 5729 26 of of IN 19613 5729 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5729 28 same same JJ 19613 5729 29 nature nature NN 19613 5729 30 , , , 19613 5729 31 was be VBD 19613 5729 32 in in IN 19613 5729 33 the the DT 19613 5729 34 main main JJ 19613 5729 35 a a DT 19613 5729 36 thing thing NN 19613 5729 37 of of IN 19613 5729 38 the the DT 19613 5729 39 past past NN 19613 5729 40 . . . 19613 5730 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5730 2 467 467 CD 19613 5730 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5730 4 Tradition Tradition NNP 19613 5730 5 and and CC 19613 5730 6 reason reason NN 19613 5730 7 had have VBD 19613 5730 8 taken take VBN 19613 5730 9 the the DT 19613 5730 10 place place NN 19613 5730 11 of of IN 19613 5730 12 charisms charism NNS 19613 5730 13 as as IN 19613 5730 14 courts court NNS 19613 5730 15 of of IN 19613 5730 16 appeal appeal NN 19613 5730 17 . . . 19613 5731 1 But but CC 19613 5731 2 this this DT 19613 5731 3 change change NN 19613 5731 4 had have VBD 19613 5731 5 neither neither CC 19613 5731 6 come come VBN 19613 5731 7 to to TO 19613 5731 8 be be VB 19613 5731 9 clearly clearly RB 19613 5731 10 recognized,[468 recognized,[468 VBN 19613 5731 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5731 12 nor nor CC 19613 5731 13 was be VBD 19613 5731 14 the the DT 19613 5731 15 right right NN 19613 5731 16 and and CC 19613 5731 17 scope scope NN 19613 5731 18 of of IN 19613 5731 19 rational rational JJ 19613 5731 20 theology theology NN 19613 5731 21 alongside alongside RB 19613 5731 22 of of IN 19613 5731 23 tradition tradition NN 19613 5731 24 felt feel VBD 19613 5731 25 to to TO 19613 5731 26 be be VB 19613 5731 27 a a DT 19613 5731 28 problem problem NN 19613 5731 29 . . . 19613 5732 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5732 2 can can MD 19613 5732 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 5732 4 trace trace VB 19613 5732 5 the the DT 19613 5732 6 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 5732 7 of of IN 19613 5732 8 the the DT 19613 5732 9 danger danger NN 19613 5732 10 in in IN 19613 5732 11 attempting attempt VBG 19613 5732 12 to to TO 19613 5732 13 introduce introduce VB 19613 5732 14 new new JJ 19613 5732 15 _ _ NNP 19613 5732 16 termini termini NN 19613 5732 17 _ _ NNP 19613 5732 18 and and CC 19613 5732 19 regulations regulation NNS 19613 5732 20 not not RB 19613 5732 21 prescribed prescribe VBN 19613 5732 22 by by IN 19613 5732 23 the the DT 19613 5732 24 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5732 25 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 5732 26 . . . 19613 5733 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5733 2 469 469 CD 19613 5733 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5733 4 The the DT 19613 5733 5 bishops bishop NNS 19613 5733 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5733 7 in in IN 19613 5733 8 fact fact NN 19613 5733 9 encouraged encourage VBD 19613 5733 10 this this DT 19613 5733 11 apprehension apprehension NN 19613 5733 12 in in IN 19613 5733 13 order order NN 19613 5733 14 to to TO 19613 5733 15 warn warn VB 19613 5733 16 people people NNS 19613 5733 17 against against IN 19613 5733 18 the the DT 19613 5733 19 Gnostics,[470 Gnostics,[470 NNP 19613 5733 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5733 21 and and CC 19613 5733 22 after after IN 19613 5733 23 the the DT 19613 5733 24 deluge deluge NN 19613 5733 25 of of IN 19613 5733 26 heresy heresy NN 19613 5733 27 , , , 19613 5733 28 representatives representative NNS 19613 5733 29 of of IN 19613 5733 30 Church Church NNP 19613 5733 31 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 5733 32 looked look VBD 19613 5733 33 with with IN 19613 5733 34 distrust distrust NN 19613 5733 35 on on IN 19613 5733 36 every every DT 19613 5733 37 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 5733 38 - - HYPH 19613 5733 39 theological theological JJ 19613 5733 40 formula formula NN 19613 5733 41 . . . 19613 5734 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5734 2 471 471 CD 19613 5734 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5734 4 Such such JJ 19613 5734 5 propositions proposition NNS 19613 5734 6 of of IN 19613 5734 7 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 19613 5734 8 theology theology NN 19613 5734 9 as as IN 19613 5734 10 were be VBD 19613 5734 11 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 5734 12 required require VBN 19613 5734 13 , , , 19613 5734 14 were be VBD 19613 5734 15 , , , 19613 5734 16 however however RB 19613 5734 17 , , , 19613 5734 18 placed place VBN 19613 5734 19 by by IN 19613 5734 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5734 21 and and CC 19613 5734 22 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5734 23 on on IN 19613 5734 24 the the DT 19613 5734 25 same same JJ 19613 5734 26 level level NN 19613 5734 27 as as IN 19613 5734 28 the the DT 19613 5734 29 hallowed hallowed JJ 19613 5734 30 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5734 31 of of IN 19613 5734 32 tradition tradition NN 19613 5734 33 , , , 19613 5734 34 and and CC 19613 5734 35 were be VBD 19613 5734 36 not not RB 19613 5734 37 viewed view VBN 19613 5734 38 by by IN 19613 5734 39 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5734 40 as as IN 19613 5734 41 something something NN 19613 5734 42 of of IN 19613 5734 43 a a DT 19613 5734 44 different different JJ 19613 5734 45 nature nature NN 19613 5734 46 . . . 19613 5735 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5735 2 uttered uttered JJ 19613 5735 3 most most RBS 19613 5735 4 urgent urgent JJ 19613 5735 5 warnings warning NNS 19613 5735 6 against against IN 19613 5735 7 subtle subtle JJ 19613 5735 8 speculations;[472 speculations;[472 NNPS 19613 5735 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5735 10 but but CC 19613 5735 11 yet yet RB 19613 5735 12 , , , 19613 5735 13 in in IN 19613 5735 14 the the DT 19613 5735 15 naivest naive JJS 19613 5735 16 way way NN 19613 5735 17 , , , 19613 5735 18 associated associate VBN 19613 5735 19 with with IN 19613 5735 20 the the DT 19613 5735 21 faithfully faithfully RB 19613 5735 22 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5735 23 traditional traditional JJ 19613 5735 24 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5735 25 and and CC 19613 5735 26 fancies fancy NNS 19613 5735 27 of of IN 19613 5735 28 the the DT 19613 5735 29 faith faith NN 19613 5735 30 theories theory NNS 19613 5735 31 which which WDT 19613 5735 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5735 33 likewise likewise RB 19613 5735 34 regarded regard VBD 19613 5735 35 as as IN 19613 5735 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 5735 37 and and CC 19613 5735 38 which which WDT 19613 5735 39 , , , 19613 5735 40 in in IN 19613 5735 41 point point NN 19613 5735 42 of of IN 19613 5735 43 form form NN 19613 5735 44 , , , 19613 5735 45 did do VBD 19613 5735 46 not not RB 19613 5735 47 differ differ VB 19613 5735 48 from from IN 19613 5735 49 those those DT 19613 5735 50 of of IN 19613 5735 51 the the DT 19613 5735 52 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5735 53 or or CC 19613 5735 54 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5735 55 . . . 19613 5736 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5736 2 473 473 CD 19613 5736 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5736 4 The the DT 19613 5736 5 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5736 6 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 5736 7 of of IN 19613 5736 8 the the DT 19613 5736 9 New New NNP 19613 5736 10 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5736 11 were be VBD 19613 5736 12 the the DT 19613 5736 13 basis basis NN 19613 5736 14 on on IN 19613 5736 15 which which WDT 19613 5736 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5736 17 set set VBD 19613 5736 18 forth forth RP 19613 5736 19 the the DT 19613 5736 20 most most RBS 19613 5736 21 important important JJ 19613 5736 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5736 23 of of IN 19613 5736 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5736 25 . . . 19613 5737 1 Some some DT 19613 5737 2 of of IN 19613 5737 3 these these DT 19613 5737 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5737 5 stated state VBD 19613 5737 6 as as IN 19613 5737 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5737 8 had have VBD 19613 5737 9 been be VBN 19613 5737 10 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5737 11 by by IN 19613 5737 12 the the DT 19613 5737 13 oldest old JJS 19613 5737 14 tradition tradition NN 19613 5737 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5737 16 see see VB 19613 5737 17 the the DT 19613 5737 18 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 5737 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5737 20 , , , 19613 5737 21 others other NNS 19613 5737 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5737 23 adapted adapt VBD 19613 5737 24 to to IN 19613 5737 25 the the DT 19613 5737 26 new new JJ 19613 5737 27 necessities necessity NNS 19613 5737 28 . . . 19613 5738 1 The the DT 19613 5738 2 qualitative qualitative JJ 19613 5738 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 5738 4 between between IN 19613 5738 5 the the DT 19613 5738 6 _ _ NNP 19613 5738 7 fides fide NNS 19613 5738 8 credenda credenda NNP 19613 5738 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5738 10 and and CC 19613 5738 11 theology theology NN 19613 5738 12 was be VBD 19613 5738 13 noticed notice VBN 19613 5738 14 neither neither CC 19613 5738 15 by by IN 19613 5738 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5738 17 nor nor CC 19613 5738 18 by by IN 19613 5738 19 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5738 20 and and CC 19613 5738 21 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5738 22 . . . 19613 5739 1 According accord VBG 19613 5739 2 to to IN 19613 5739 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5739 4 I. I. NNP 19613 5740 1 10 10 CD 19613 5740 2 . . . 19613 5741 1 3 3 LS 19613 5741 2 this this DT 19613 5741 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 5741 4 is be VBZ 19613 5741 5 merely merely RB 19613 5741 6 quantitative quantitative JJ 19613 5741 7 . . . 19613 5742 1 Here here RB 19613 5742 2 faith faith NN 19613 5742 3 and and CC 19613 5742 4 theological theological JJ 19613 5742 5 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5742 6 are be VBP 19613 5742 7 still still RB 19613 5742 8 completely completely RB 19613 5742 9 intermixed intermixed JJ 19613 5742 10 . . . 19613 5743 1 Whilst whilst IN 19613 5743 2 stating state VBG 19613 5743 3 and and CC 19613 5743 4 establishing establish VBG 19613 5743 5 the the DT 19613 5743 6 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5743 7 of of IN 19613 5743 8 tradition tradition NN 19613 5743 9 with with IN 19613 5743 10 the the DT 19613 5743 11 help help NN 19613 5743 12 of of IN 19613 5743 13 the the DT 19613 5743 14 New New NNP 19613 5743 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5743 16 , , , 19613 5743 17 and and CC 19613 5743 18 revising revise VBG 19613 5743 19 and and CC 19613 5743 20 fixing fix VBG 19613 5743 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5743 22 by by IN 19613 5743 23 means mean NNS 19613 5743 24 of of IN 19613 5743 25 intelligent intelligent JJ 19613 5743 26 deduction deduction NN 19613 5743 27 , , , 19613 5743 28 the the DT 19613 5743 29 Fathers father NNS 19613 5743 30 think think VBP 19613 5743 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5743 32 are be VBP 19613 5743 33 setting set VBG 19613 5743 34 forth forth RP 19613 5743 35 the the DT 19613 5743 36 faith faith NN 19613 5743 37 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5743 38 and and CC 19613 5743 39 nothing nothing NN 19613 5743 40 else else RB 19613 5743 41 . . . 19613 5744 1 Anything anything NN 19613 5744 2 more more JJR 19613 5744 3 than than IN 19613 5744 4 this this DT 19613 5744 5 is be VBZ 19613 5744 6 only only RB 19613 5744 7 curiosity curiosity NN 19613 5744 8 not not RB 19613 5744 9 unattended unattende VBN 19613 5744 10 with with IN 19613 5744 11 danger danger NN 19613 5744 12 to to IN 19613 5744 13 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5744 14 . . . 19613 5745 1 Theology Theology NNP 19613 5745 2 is be VBZ 19613 5745 3 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 5745 4 faith faith NN 19613 5745 5 . . . 19613 5746 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5746 2 474 474 CD 19613 5746 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5746 4 Corresponding correspond VBG 19613 5746 5 to to IN 19613 5746 6 the the DT 19613 5746 7 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 5746 8 confession confession NN 19613 5746 9 there there RB 19613 5746 10 thus thus RB 19613 5746 11 arose arise VBD 19613 5746 12 at at IN 19613 5746 13 the the DT 19613 5746 14 first first JJ 19613 5746 15 a a DT 19613 5746 16 loose loose JJ 19613 5746 17 system system NN 19613 5746 18 of of IN 19613 5746 19 dogmas dogmas NNP 19613 5746 20 which which WDT 19613 5746 21 were be VBD 19613 5746 22 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5746 23 devoid devoid JJ 19613 5746 24 of of IN 19613 5746 25 strict strict JJ 19613 5746 26 style style NN 19613 5746 27 , , , 19613 5746 28 definite definite JJ 19613 5746 29 principle principle NN 19613 5746 30 , , , 19613 5746 31 or or CC 19613 5746 32 fixed fixed JJ 19613 5746 33 and and CC 19613 5746 34 harmonious harmonious JJ 19613 5746 35 aim aim NN 19613 5746 36 . . . 19613 5747 1 In in IN 19613 5747 2 this this DT 19613 5747 3 form form NN 19613 5747 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5747 5 find find VBP 19613 5747 6 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5747 7 with with IN 19613 5747 8 special special JJ 19613 5747 9 plainness plainness NN 19613 5747 10 in in IN 19613 5747 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5747 12 . . . 19613 5748 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5748 2 475 475 CD 19613 5748 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5748 4 This this DT 19613 5748 5 writer writer NN 19613 5748 6 was be VBD 19613 5748 7 still still RB 19613 5748 8 completely completely RB 19613 5748 9 incapable incapable JJ 19613 5748 10 of of IN 19613 5748 11 inwardly inwardly RB 19613 5748 12 connecting connect VBG 19613 5748 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5748 14 rational rational JJ 19613 5748 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5748 16 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 5748 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5748 18 theology theology NN 19613 5748 19 , , , 19613 5748 20 as as IN 19613 5748 21 developed develop VBN 19613 5748 22 by by IN 19613 5748 23 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5748 24 for for IN 19613 5748 25 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5748 26 purposes purpose NNS 19613 5748 27 , , , 19613 5748 28 with with IN 19613 5748 29 the the DT 19613 5748 30 Christological christological JJ 19613 5748 31 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5748 32 of of IN 19613 5748 33 the the DT 19613 5748 34 _ _ NNP 19613 5748 35 regula regula NN 19613 5748 36 fidei fidei NNP 19613 5748 37 _ _ NNP 19613 5748 38 , , , 19613 5748 39 which which WDT 19613 5748 40 , , , 19613 5748 41 after after IN 19613 5748 42 the the DT 19613 5748 43 example example NN 19613 5748 44 of of IN 19613 5748 45 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5748 46 , , , 19613 5748 47 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5748 48 constructed construct VBD 19613 5748 49 and and CC 19613 5748 50 defended defend VBN 19613 5748 51 from from IN 19613 5748 52 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5748 53 and and CC 19613 5748 54 tradition tradition NN 19613 5748 55 in in IN 19613 5748 56 opposition opposition NN 19613 5748 57 to to TO 19613 5748 58 heresy heresy VB 19613 5748 59 . . . 19613 5749 1 Whenever whenever WRB 19613 5749 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5749 3 attempts attempt VBZ 19613 5749 4 in in IN 19613 5749 5 any any DT 19613 5749 6 place place NN 19613 5749 7 to to TO 19613 5749 8 prove prove VB 19613 5749 9 the the DT 19613 5749 10 _ _ NNP 19613 5749 11 intrinsic intrinsic NN 19613 5749 12 _ _ NNP 19613 5749 13 necessity necessity NN 19613 5749 14 of of IN 19613 5749 15 these these DT 19613 5749 16 dogmas dogma NNS 19613 5749 17 , , , 19613 5749 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5749 19 seldom seldom RB 19613 5749 20 gets get VBZ 19613 5749 21 beyond beyond IN 19613 5749 22 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 19613 5749 23 statements statement NNS 19613 5749 24 , , , 19613 5749 25 holy holy JJ 19613 5749 26 paradoxes paradox NNS 19613 5749 27 , , , 19613 5749 28 or or CC 19613 5749 29 juristic juristic JJ 19613 5749 30 forms form NNS 19613 5749 31 . . . 19613 5750 1 As as IN 19613 5750 2 a a DT 19613 5750 3 systematic systematic JJ 19613 5750 4 thinker thinker NN 19613 5750 5 , , , 19613 5750 6 a a DT 19613 5750 7 cosmologist cosmologist NN 19613 5750 8 , , , 19613 5750 9 moralist moralist NN 19613 5750 10 , , , 19613 5750 11 and and CC 19613 5750 12 jurist jurist NN 19613 5750 13 rather rather RB 19613 5750 14 than than IN 19613 5750 15 a a DT 19613 5750 16 theosophist theosophist NN 19613 5750 17 , , , 19613 5750 18 as as IN 19613 5750 19 a a DT 19613 5750 20 churchman churchman NN 19613 5750 21 , , , 19613 5750 22 a a DT 19613 5750 23 masterly masterly JJ 19613 5750 24 defender defender NN 19613 5750 25 of of IN 19613 5750 26 tradition tradition NN 19613 5750 27 , , , 19613 5750 28 as as IN 19613 5750 29 a a DT 19613 5750 30 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5750 31 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 5750 32 guided guide VBN 19613 5750 33 in in IN 19613 5750 34 practical practical JJ 19613 5750 35 life life NN 19613 5750 36 by by IN 19613 5750 37 the the DT 19613 5750 38 strict strict JJ 19613 5750 39 precepts precept NNS 19613 5750 40 and and CC 19613 5750 41 hopes hope NNS 19613 5750 42 of of IN 19613 5750 43 the the DT 19613 5750 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 5750 45 , , , 19613 5750 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5750 47 theology theology NN 19613 5750 48 , , , 19613 5750 49 if if IN 19613 5750 50 by by IN 19613 5750 51 that that DT 19613 5750 52 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5750 53 understand understand VBP 19613 5750 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5750 55 collective collective JJ 19613 5750 56 theological theological JJ 19613 5750 57 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 5750 58 , , , 19613 5750 59 is be VBZ 19613 5750 60 completely completely RB 19613 5750 61 devoid devoid JJ 19613 5750 62 of of IN 19613 5750 63 unity unity NN 19613 5750 64 , , , 19613 5750 65 and and CC 19613 5750 66 can can MD 19613 5750 67 only only RB 19613 5750 68 be be VB 19613 5750 69 termed term VBN 19613 5750 70 a a DT 19613 5750 71 mixture mixture NN 19613 5750 72 of of IN 19613 5750 73 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 19613 5750 74 and and CC 19613 5750 75 , , , 19613 5750 76 not not RB 19613 5750 77 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 5750 78 , , , 19613 5750 79 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 5750 80 propositions proposition NNS 19613 5750 81 , , , 19613 5750 82 which which WDT 19613 5750 83 admit admit VBP 19613 5750 84 of of IN 19613 5750 85 no no DT 19613 5750 86 comparison comparison NN 19613 5750 87 with with IN 19613 5750 88 the the DT 19613 5750 89 older old JJR 19613 5750 90 theology theology NN 19613 5750 91 of of IN 19613 5750 92 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 5750 93 or or CC 19613 5750 94 the the DT 19613 5750 95 later later JJ 19613 5750 96 system system NN 19613 5750 97 of of IN 19613 5750 98 Origen Origen NNP 19613 5750 99 . . . 19613 5751 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5751 2 476 476 CD 19613 5751 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5751 4 To to IN 19613 5751 5 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 5751 6 everything everything NN 19613 5751 7 lies lie VBZ 19613 5751 8 side side NN 19613 5751 9 by by IN 19613 5751 10 side side NN 19613 5751 11 ; ; : 19613 5751 12 problems problem NNS 19613 5751 13 which which WDT 19613 5751 14 chance chance VBP 19613 5751 15 to to TO 19613 5751 16 turn turn VB 19613 5751 17 up up RP 19613 5751 18 are be VBP 19613 5751 19 just just RB 19613 5751 20 as as RB 19613 5751 21 quickly quickly RB 19613 5751 22 solved solve VBN 19613 5751 23 . . . 19613 5752 1 The the DT 19613 5752 2 specific specific JJ 19613 5752 3 faith faith NN 19613 5752 4 of of IN 19613 5752 5 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5752 6 is be VBZ 19613 5752 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 5752 8 no no RB 19613 5752 9 longer long RBR 19613 5752 10 , , , 19613 5752 11 as as IN 19613 5752 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5752 13 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 5752 14 seems seem VBZ 19613 5752 15 to to TO 19613 5752 16 be be VB 19613 5752 17 in in IN 19613 5752 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5752 19 's 's POS 19613 5752 20 case case NN 19613 5752 21 , , , 19613 5752 22 a a DT 19613 5752 23 great great JJ 19613 5752 24 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 5752 25 of of IN 19613 5752 26 proof proof NN 19613 5752 27 for for IN 19613 5752 28 the the DT 19613 5752 29 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5752 30 of of IN 19613 5752 31 the the DT 19613 5752 32 only only JJ 19613 5752 33 true true JJ 19613 5752 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 5752 35 ; ; : 19613 5752 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5752 37 rather rather RB 19613 5752 38 stands stand VBZ 19613 5752 39 , , , 19613 5752 40 in in IN 19613 5752 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5752 42 own own JJ 19613 5752 43 independent independent JJ 19613 5752 44 value value NN 19613 5752 45 , , , 19613 5752 46 side side NN 19613 5752 47 by by IN 19613 5752 48 side side NN 19613 5752 49 with with IN 19613 5752 50 these these DT 19613 5752 51 , , , 19613 5752 52 partly partly RB 19613 5752 53 in in IN 19613 5752 54 a a DT 19613 5752 55 crude crude NN 19613 5752 56 , , , 19613 5752 57 partly partly RB 19613 5752 58 in in IN 19613 5752 59 a a DT 19613 5752 60 developed develop VBN 19613 5752 61 form form NN 19613 5752 62 ; ; : 19613 5752 63 but but CC 19613 5752 64 inner inner JJ 19613 5752 65 principles principle NNS 19613 5752 66 and and CC 19613 5752 67 aims aim NNS 19613 5752 68 are be VBP 19613 5752 69 nearly nearly RB 19613 5752 70 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 5752 71 sought seek VBN 19613 5752 72 for for IN 19613 5752 73 in in IN 19613 5752 74 vain vain JJ 19613 5752 75 . . . 19613 5753 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5753 2 477 477 CD 19613 5753 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5753 4 In in IN 19613 5753 5 spite spite NN 19613 5753 6 of of IN 19613 5753 7 this this DT 19613 5753 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5753 9 possesses possess VBZ 19613 5753 10 inestimable inestimable JJ 19613 5753 11 importance importance NN 19613 5753 12 in in IN 19613 5753 13 the the DT 19613 5753 14 history history NN 19613 5753 15 of of IN 19613 5753 16 dogma dogma NN 19613 5753 17 ; ; : 19613 5753 18 for for IN 19613 5753 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5753 20 developed develop VBD 19613 5753 21 and and CC 19613 5753 22 created create VBD 19613 5753 23 , , , 19613 5753 24 in in IN 19613 5753 25 a a DT 19613 5753 26 disconnected disconnected JJ 19613 5753 27 form form NN 19613 5753 28 and and CC 19613 5753 29 partly partly RB 19613 5753 30 in in IN 19613 5753 31 the the DT 19613 5753 32 shape shape NN 19613 5753 33 of of IN 19613 5753 34 legal legal JJ 19613 5753 35 propositions proposition NNS 19613 5753 36 , , , 19613 5753 37 a a DT 19613 5753 38 series series NN 19613 5753 39 of of IN 19613 5753 40 the the DT 19613 5753 41 most most RBS 19613 5753 42 important important JJ 19613 5753 43 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 5753 44 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5753 45 , , , 19613 5753 46 which which WDT 19613 5753 47 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 5753 48 , , , 19613 5753 49 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 5753 50 , , , 19613 5753 51 Hosius Hosius NNP 19613 5753 52 , , , 19613 5753 53 and and CC 19613 5753 54 the the DT 19613 5753 55 Roman roman JJ 19613 5753 56 bishops bishop NNS 19613 5753 57 of of IN 19613 5753 58 the the DT 19613 5753 59 fourth fourth JJ 19613 5753 60 century century NN 19613 5753 61 , , , 19613 5753 62 Ambrosius Ambrosius NNP 19613 5753 63 and and CC 19613 5753 64 Leo Leo NNP 19613 5753 65 I. I. NNP 19613 5753 66 , , , 19613 5753 67 introduced introduce VBN 19613 5753 68 into into IN 19613 5753 69 the the DT 19613 5753 70 general general JJ 19613 5753 71 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 5753 72 system system NN 19613 5753 73 of of IN 19613 5753 74 the the DT 19613 5753 75 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 5753 76 Church Church NNP 19613 5753 77 . . . 19613 5754 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5754 2 founded found VBD 19613 5754 3 the the DT 19613 5754 4 terminology terminology NN 19613 5754 5 both both DT 19613 5754 6 of of IN 19613 5754 7 the the DT 19613 5754 8 trinitarian trinitarian NNP 19613 5754 9 and and CC 19613 5754 10 of of IN 19613 5754 11 the the DT 19613 5754 12 Christological christological JJ 19613 5754 13 dogma dogma NN 19613 5754 14 ; ; : 19613 5754 15 and and CC 19613 5754 16 in in IN 19613 5754 17 addition addition NN 19613 5754 18 to to IN 19613 5754 19 this this DT 19613 5754 20 was be VBD 19613 5754 21 the the DT 19613 5754 22 first first JJ 19613 5754 23 to to TO 19613 5754 24 give give VB 19613 5754 25 currency currency NN 19613 5754 26 to to IN 19613 5754 27 a a DT 19613 5754 28 series series NN 19613 5754 29 of of IN 19613 5754 30 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 5754 31 concepts concept NNS 19613 5754 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5754 33 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 34 satisfacere satisfacere NNP 19613 5754 35 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 36 , , , 19613 5754 37 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 38 meritum meritum NN 19613 5754 39 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 40 , , , 19613 5754 41 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 42 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 5754 43 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 44 , , , 19613 5754 45 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 46 vitium vitium NN 19613 5754 47 originis originis NN 19613 5754 48 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 49 etc etc FW 19613 5754 50 . . . 19613 5754 51 , , , 19613 5754 52 etc etc FW 19613 5754 53 . . . 19613 5754 54 _ _ NNP 19613 5754 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5754 56 . . . 19613 5755 1 Finally finally RB 19613 5755 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5755 3 was be VBD 19613 5755 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5755 5 who who WP 19613 5755 6 at at IN 19613 5755 7 the the DT 19613 5755 8 very very RB 19613 5755 9 outset outset NN 19613 5755 10 imparted impart VBD 19613 5755 11 to to IN 19613 5755 12 the the DT 19613 5755 13 type type NN 19613 5755 14 of of IN 19613 5755 15 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 5755 16 that that WDT 19613 5755 17 arose arise VBD 19613 5755 18 in in IN 19613 5755 19 the the DT 19613 5755 20 West West NNP 19613 5755 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5755 22 momentous momentous JJ 19613 5755 23 bias bias NN 19613 5755 24 in in IN 19613 5755 25 the the DT 19613 5755 26 direction direction NN 19613 5755 27 of of IN 19613 5755 28 _ _ NNP 19613 5755 29 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 19613 5755 30 et et NN 19613 5755 31 ratio ratio NN 19613 5755 32 _ _ NNP 19613 5755 33 , , , 19613 5755 34 and and CC 19613 5755 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5755 36 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 5755 37 tendency tendency NN 19613 5755 38 to to TO 19613 5755 39 assume assume VB 19613 5755 40 a a DT 19613 5755 41 legal legal JJ 19613 5755 42 character character NN 19613 5755 43 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5755 44 _ _ NNP 19613 5755 45 lex lex NNP 19613 5755 46 _ _ NNP 19613 5755 47 , , , 19613 5755 48 formal formal JJ 19613 5755 49 and and CC 19613 5755 50 material material NN 19613 5755 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5755 52 , , , 19613 5755 53 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 19613 5755 54 which which WDT 19613 5755 55 were be VBD 19613 5755 56 to to TO 19613 5755 57 become become VB 19613 5755 58 more more RBR 19613 5755 59 and and CC 19613 5755 60 more more RBR 19613 5755 61 clearly clearly RB 19613 5755 62 marked mark VBN 19613 5755 63 as as IN 19613 5755 64 time time NN 19613 5755 65 went go VBD 19613 5755 66 on on RP 19613 5755 67 . . . 19613 5756 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5756 2 478 478 CD 19613 5756 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5756 4 But but CC 19613 5756 5 , , , 19613 5756 6 great great JJ 19613 5756 7 as as IN 19613 5756 8 is be VBZ 19613 5756 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5756 10 importance importance NN 19613 5756 11 in in IN 19613 5756 12 this this DT 19613 5756 13 respect respect NN 19613 5756 14 , , , 19613 5756 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5756 16 has have VBZ 19613 5756 17 no no DT 19613 5756 18 connection connection NN 19613 5756 19 at at RB 19613 5756 20 all all RB 19613 5756 21 with with IN 19613 5756 22 the the DT 19613 5756 23 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5756 24 conception conception NN 19613 5756 25 of of IN 19613 5756 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5756 27 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 5756 28 to to IN 19613 5756 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5756 30 , , , 19613 5756 31 for for IN 19613 5756 32 , , , 19613 5756 33 as as IN 19613 5756 34 a a DT 19613 5756 35 matter matter NN 19613 5756 36 of of IN 19613 5756 37 fact fact NN 19613 5756 38 , , , 19613 5756 39 this this DT 19613 5756 40 was be VBD 19613 5756 41 already already RB 19613 5756 42 out out IN 19613 5756 43 of of IN 19613 5756 44 date date NN 19613 5756 45 at at IN 19613 5756 46 the the DT 19613 5756 47 time time NN 19613 5756 48 when when WRB 19613 5756 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5756 50 lived live VBD 19613 5756 51 . . . 19613 5757 1 What what WP 19613 5757 2 influenced influence VBD 19613 5757 3 the the DT 19613 5757 4 history history NN 19613 5757 5 of of IN 19613 5757 6 dogma dogma NN 19613 5757 7 was be VBD 19613 5757 8 not not RB 19613 5757 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5757 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5757 11 , , , 19613 5757 12 but but CC 19613 5757 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5757 14 masterly masterly JJ 19613 5757 15 power power NN 19613 5757 16 of of IN 19613 5757 17 framing frame VBG 19613 5757 18 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5757 19 . . . 19613 5758 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5758 2 is be VBZ 19613 5758 3 different different JJ 19613 5758 4 with with IN 19613 5758 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5758 6 . . . 19613 5759 1 The the DT 19613 5759 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5759 3 of of IN 19613 5759 4 this this DT 19613 5759 5 man man NN 19613 5759 6 proved prove VBD 19613 5759 7 a a DT 19613 5759 8 decisive decisive JJ 19613 5759 9 factor factor NN 19613 5759 10 in in IN 19613 5759 11 the the DT 19613 5759 12 history history NN 19613 5759 13 of of IN 19613 5759 14 dogma dogma NN 19613 5759 15 in in IN 19613 5759 16 respect respect NN 19613 5759 17 of of IN 19613 5759 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5759 19 content content NN 19613 5759 20 . . . 19613 5760 1 If if IN 19613 5760 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5760 3 supplied supply VBD 19613 5760 4 the the DT 19613 5760 5 future future JJ 19613 5760 6 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 5760 7 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 5760 8 with with IN 19613 5760 9 the the DT 19613 5760 10 most most RBS 19613 5760 11 important important JJ 19613 5760 12 part part NN 19613 5760 13 of of IN 19613 5760 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5760 15 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5760 16 , , , 19613 5760 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5760 18 clearly clearly RB 19613 5760 19 sketched sketch VBD 19613 5760 20 for for IN 19613 5760 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5760 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5760 23 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5760 24 idea idea NN 19613 5760 25 , , , 19613 5760 26 by by IN 19613 5760 27 combining combine VBG 19613 5760 28 the the DT 19613 5760 29 ancient ancient JJ 19613 5760 30 notion notion NN 19613 5760 31 of of IN 19613 5760 32 salvation salvation NN 19613 5760 33 with with IN 19613 5760 34 New New NNP 19613 5760 35 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5760 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5760 37 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 5760 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5760 39 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5760 40 . . . 19613 5761 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5761 2 479 479 CD 19613 5761 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5761 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5761 5 , , , 19613 5761 6 as as RB 19613 5761 7 far far RB 19613 5761 8 as as IN 19613 5761 9 the the DT 19613 5761 10 essence essence NN 19613 5761 11 of of IN 19613 5761 12 the the DT 19613 5761 13 matter matter NN 19613 5761 14 is be VBZ 19613 5761 15 concerned concern VBN 19613 5761 16 , , , 19613 5761 17 the the DT 19613 5761 18 great great JJ 19613 5761 19 work work NN 19613 5761 20 of of IN 19613 5761 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5761 22 is be VBZ 19613 5761 23 far far RB 19613 5761 24 superior superior JJ 19613 5761 25 to to IN 19613 5761 26 the the DT 19613 5761 27 theological theological JJ 19613 5761 28 writings writing NNS 19613 5761 29 of of IN 19613 5761 30 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5761 31 . . . 19613 5762 1 This this DT 19613 5762 2 appears appear VBZ 19613 5762 3 already already RB 19613 5762 4 in in IN 19613 5762 5 the the DT 19613 5762 6 task task NN 19613 5762 7 , , , 19613 5762 8 voluntarily voluntarily RB 19613 5762 9 undertaken undertake VBN 19613 5762 10 by by IN 19613 5762 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5762 12 , , , 19613 5762 13 of of IN 19613 5762 14 giving give VBG 19613 5762 15 a a DT 19613 5762 16 relatively relatively RB 19613 5762 17 complete complete JJ 19613 5762 18 exposition exposition NN 19613 5762 19 of of IN 19613 5762 20 the the DT 19613 5762 21 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5762 22 of of IN 19613 5762 23 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5762 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5762 25 on on IN 19613 5762 26 the the DT 19613 5762 27 basis basis NN 19613 5762 28 of of IN 19613 5762 29 the the DT 19613 5762 30 New New NNP 19613 5762 31 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5762 32 , , , 19613 5762 33 in in IN 19613 5762 34 opposition opposition NN 19613 5762 35 to to TO 19613 5762 36 heresy heresy VB 19613 5762 37 . . . 19613 5763 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5763 2 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 5763 3 betrayed betray VBD 19613 5763 4 a a DT 19613 5763 5 similar similar JJ 19613 5763 6 systematic systematic JJ 19613 5763 7 necessity necessity NN 19613 5763 8 , , , 19613 5763 9 which which WDT 19613 5763 10 indeed indeed RB 19613 5763 11 , , , 19613 5763 12 in in IN 19613 5763 13 the the DT 19613 5763 14 case case NN 19613 5763 15 of of IN 19613 5763 16 the the DT 19613 5763 17 Gallic Gallic NNP 19613 5763 18 bishop bishop NN 19613 5763 19 too too RB 19613 5763 20 , , , 19613 5763 21 only only RB 19613 5763 22 made make VBD 19613 5763 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5763 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 5763 25 as as IN 19613 5763 26 the the DT 19613 5763 27 result result NN 19613 5763 28 of of IN 19613 5763 29 polemical polemical JJ 19613 5763 30 motives motive NNS 19613 5763 31 . . . 19613 5764 1 But but CC 19613 5764 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5764 3 to to IN 19613 5764 4 a a DT 19613 5764 5 certain certain JJ 19613 5764 6 degree degree NN 19613 5764 7 succeeded succeed VBN 19613 5764 8 in in IN 19613 5764 9 amalgamating amalgamate VBG 19613 5764 10 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 5764 11 theology theology NN 19613 5764 12 and and CC 19613 5764 13 the the DT 19613 5764 14 statements statement NNS 19613 5764 15 of of IN 19613 5764 16 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5764 17 tradition tradition NN 19613 5764 18 viewed view VBN 19613 5764 19 as as IN 19613 5764 20 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5764 21 . . . 19613 5765 1 This this DT 19613 5765 2 result result NN 19613 5765 3 followed follow VBD 19613 5765 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5765 5 1 1 CD 19613 5765 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5765 7 because because IN 19613 5765 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5765 9 never never RB 19613 5765 10 lost lose VBD 19613 5765 11 sight sight NN 19613 5765 12 of of IN 19613 5765 13 a a DT 19613 5765 14 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5765 15 idea idea NN 19613 5765 16 to to TO 19613 5765 17 which which WDT 19613 5765 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5765 19 tried try VBD 19613 5765 20 to to TO 19613 5765 21 refer refer VB 19613 5765 22 everything everything NN 19613 5765 23 , , , 19613 5765 24 and and CC 19613 5765 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5765 26 2 2 LS 19613 5765 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5765 28 because because IN 19613 5765 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5765 30 was be VBD 19613 5765 31 directed direct VBN 19613 5765 32 by by IN 19613 5765 33 a a DT 19613 5765 34 confident confident JJ 19613 5765 35 view view NN 19613 5765 36 of of IN 19613 5765 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5765 38 as as IN 19613 5765 39 a a DT 19613 5765 40 religion religion NN 19613 5765 41 , , , 19613 5765 42 that that RB 19613 5765 43 is is RB 19613 5765 44 , , , 19613 5765 45 a a DT 19613 5765 46 theory theory NN 19613 5765 47 of of IN 19613 5765 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5765 49 purpose purpose NN 19613 5765 50 . . . 19613 5766 1 The the DT 19613 5766 2 first first JJ 19613 5766 3 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5766 4 idea idea NN 19613 5766 5 , , , 19613 5766 6 in in IN 19613 5766 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5766 8 all all RB 19613 5766 9 - - HYPH 19613 5766 10 dominating dominate VBG 19613 5766 11 importance importance NN 19613 5766 12 , , , 19613 5766 13 was be VBD 19613 5766 14 suggested suggest VBN 19613 5766 15 to to IN 19613 5766 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5766 17 by by IN 19613 5766 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5766 19 opposition opposition NN 19613 5766 20 to to IN 19613 5766 21 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 5766 22 . . . 19613 5767 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5767 2 is be VBZ 19613 5767 3 the the DT 19613 5767 4 conviction conviction NN 19613 5767 5 that that IN 19613 5767 6 the the DT 19613 5767 7 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5767 8 of of IN 19613 5767 9 the the DT 19613 5767 10 world world NN 19613 5767 11 and and CC 19613 5767 12 the the DT 19613 5767 13 supreme supreme JJ 19613 5767 14 God God NNP 19613 5767 15 are be VBP 19613 5767 16 one one CD 19613 5767 17 and and CC 19613 5767 18 the the DT 19613 5767 19 same same JJ 19613 5767 20 . . . 19613 5768 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5768 2 480 480 CD 19613 5768 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5768 4 The the DT 19613 5768 5 other other JJ 19613 5768 6 theory theory NN 19613 5768 7 as as IN 19613 5768 8 to to IN 19613 5768 9 the the DT 19613 5768 10 aim aim NN 19613 5768 11 of of IN 19613 5768 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5768 13 , , , 19613 5768 14 however however RB 19613 5768 15 , , , 19613 5768 16 is be VBZ 19613 5768 17 shared share VBN 19613 5768 18 by by IN 19613 5768 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5768 20 with with IN 19613 5768 21 Paul Paul NNP 19613 5768 22 , , , 19613 5768 23 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 5768 24 , , , 19613 5768 25 and and CC 19613 5768 26 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5768 27 . . . 19613 5769 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5769 2 is be VBZ 19613 5769 3 the the DT 19613 5769 4 conviction conviction NN 19613 5769 5 that that IN 19613 5769 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5769 7 is be VBZ 19613 5769 8 real real JJ 19613 5769 9 redemption redemption NN 19613 5769 10 , , , 19613 5769 11 and and CC 19613 5769 12 that that IN 19613 5769 13 this this DT 19613 5769 14 redemption redemption NN 19613 5769 15 was be VBD 19613 5769 16 only only RB 19613 5769 17 effected effect VBN 19613 5769 18 by by IN 19613 5769 19 the the DT 19613 5769 20 appearance appearance NN 19613 5769 21 of of IN 19613 5769 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5769 23 . . . 19613 5770 1 The the DT 19613 5770 2 working working NN 19613 5770 3 out out IN 19613 5770 4 of of IN 19613 5770 5 these these DT 19613 5770 6 two two CD 19613 5770 7 ideas idea NNS 19613 5770 8 is be VBZ 19613 5770 9 the the DT 19613 5770 10 most most RBS 19613 5770 11 important important JJ 19613 5770 12 feature feature NN 19613 5770 13 in in IN 19613 5770 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5770 15 ' ' POS 19613 5770 16 book book NN 19613 5770 17 . . . 19613 5771 1 As as IN 19613 5771 2 yet yet RB 19613 5771 3 , , , 19613 5771 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 5771 5 , , , 19613 5771 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5771 7 by by IN 19613 5771 8 no no DT 19613 5771 9 means means NN 19613 5771 10 really really RB 19613 5771 11 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 5771 12 in in IN 19613 5771 13 completely completely RB 19613 5771 14 adapting adapt VBG 19613 5771 15 to to IN 19613 5771 16 these these DT 19613 5771 17 two two CD 19613 5771 18 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5771 19 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5771 20 all all PDT 19613 5771 21 the the DT 19613 5771 22 materials material NNS 19613 5771 23 to to TO 19613 5771 24 be be VB 19613 5771 25 taken take VBN 19613 5771 26 from from IN 19613 5771 27 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5771 28 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 5771 29 and and CC 19613 5771 30 found find VBD 19613 5771 31 in in IN 19613 5771 32 the the DT 19613 5771 33 rule rule NN 19613 5771 34 of of IN 19613 5771 35 faith faith NN 19613 5771 36 ; ; : 19613 5771 37 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5771 38 only only RB 19613 5771 39 thought think VBD 19613 5771 40 with with IN 19613 5771 41 systematic systematic JJ 19613 5771 42 clearness clearness NN 19613 5771 43 within within IN 19613 5771 44 the the DT 19613 5771 45 scheme scheme NN 19613 5771 46 of of IN 19613 5771 47 the the DT 19613 5771 48 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5771 49 . . . 19613 5772 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5772 2 archaic archaic JJ 19613 5772 3 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 5772 4 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 5772 5 are be VBP 19613 5772 6 of of IN 19613 5772 7 a a DT 19613 5772 8 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 19613 5772 9 nature nature NN 19613 5772 10 , , , 19613 5772 11 and and CC 19613 5772 12 a a DT 19613 5772 13 great great JJ 19613 5772 14 deal deal NN 19613 5772 15 of of IN 19613 5772 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5772 17 material material NN 19613 5772 18 , , , 19613 5772 19 as as IN 19613 5772 20 , , , 19613 5772 21 for for IN 19613 5772 22 instance instance NN 19613 5772 23 , , , 19613 5772 24 Pauline pauline JJ 19613 5772 25 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5772 26 and and CC 19613 5772 27 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5772 28 , , , 19613 5772 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5772 30 completely completely RB 19613 5772 31 emptied empty VBD 19613 5772 32 of of IN 19613 5772 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5772 34 content content NN 19613 5772 35 , , , 19613 5772 36 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 5772 37 as as IN 19613 5772 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5772 39 merely merely RB 19613 5772 40 contrived contrive VBD 19613 5772 41 to to TO 19613 5772 42 turn turn VB 19613 5772 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5772 44 into into IN 19613 5772 45 a a DT 19613 5772 46 testimony testimony NN 19613 5772 47 of of IN 19613 5772 48 the the DT 19613 5772 49 oneness oneness NN 19613 5772 50 and and CC 19613 5772 51 absolute absolute JJ 19613 5772 52 causality causality NN 19613 5772 53 of of IN 19613 5772 54 God God NNP 19613 5772 55 the the DT 19613 5772 56 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5772 57 ; ; : 19613 5772 58 but but CC 19613 5772 59 the the DT 19613 5772 60 repetition repetition NN 19613 5772 61 of of IN 19613 5772 62 the the DT 19613 5772 63 same same JJ 19613 5772 64 main main JJ 19613 5772 65 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5772 66 to to IN 19613 5772 67 an an DT 19613 5772 68 extent extent NN 19613 5772 69 that that WDT 19613 5772 70 is be VBZ 19613 5772 71 wearisome wearisome VBN 19613 5772 72 to to IN 19613 5772 73 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5772 74 , , , 19613 5772 75 and and CC 19613 5772 76 the the DT 19613 5772 77 attempt attempt NN 19613 5772 78 to to TO 19613 5772 79 refer refer VB 19613 5772 80 everything everything NN 19613 5772 81 to to IN 19613 5772 82 these these DT 19613 5772 83 , , , 19613 5772 84 unmistakably unmistakably RB 19613 5772 85 constitute constitute VB 19613 5772 86 the the DT 19613 5772 87 success success NN 19613 5772 88 of of IN 19613 5772 89 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5772 90 work work NN 19613 5772 91 . . . 19613 5773 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5773 2 481 481 CD 19613 5773 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5773 4 God God NNP 19613 5773 5 the the DT 19613 5773 6 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5773 7 and and CC 19613 5773 8 the the DT 19613 5773 9 one one NN 19613 5773 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5773 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5773 12 are be VBP 19613 5773 13 really really RB 19613 5773 14 the the DT 19613 5773 15 middle middle JJ 19613 5773 16 points point NNS 19613 5773 17 of of IN 19613 5773 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5773 19 theological theological JJ 19613 5773 20 system system NN 19613 5773 21 , , , 19613 5773 22 and and CC 19613 5773 23 in in IN 19613 5773 24 this this DT 19613 5773 25 way way NN 19613 5773 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5773 27 tried try VBD 19613 5773 28 to to TO 19613 5773 29 assign assign VB 19613 5773 30 an an DT 19613 5773 31 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 19613 5773 32 significance significance NN 19613 5773 33 to to IN 19613 5773 34 the the DT 19613 5773 35 several several JJ 19613 5773 36 historical historical JJ 19613 5773 37 statements statement NNS 19613 5773 38 of of IN 19613 5773 39 the the DT 19613 5773 40 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 5773 41 confession confession NN 19613 5773 42 . . . 19613 5774 1 Looked look VBN 19613 5774 2 at at IN 19613 5774 3 from from IN 19613 5774 4 this this DT 19613 5774 5 point point NN 19613 5774 6 of of IN 19613 5774 7 view view NN 19613 5774 8 , , , 19613 5774 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5774 10 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5774 11 were be VBD 19613 5774 12 almost almost RB 19613 5774 13 of of IN 19613 5774 14 an an DT 19613 5774 15 identical identical JJ 19613 5774 16 nature nature NN 19613 5774 17 with with IN 19613 5774 18 the the DT 19613 5774 19 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 5774 20 . . . 19613 5775 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5775 2 482 482 CD 19613 5775 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5775 4 But but CC 19613 5775 5 , , , 19613 5775 6 while while IN 19613 5775 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5775 8 conceives conceive VBZ 19613 5775 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5775 10 as as IN 19613 5775 11 an an DT 19613 5775 12 explanation explanation NN 19613 5775 13 of of IN 19613 5775 14 the the DT 19613 5775 15 world world NN 19613 5775 16 and and CC 19613 5775 17 as as IN 19613 5775 18 redemption redemption NN 19613 5775 19 , , , 19613 5775 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5775 21 Christocentric Christocentric NNP 19613 5775 22 teaching teaching NN 19613 5775 23 was be VBD 19613 5775 24 opposed opposed JJ 19613 5775 25 to to IN 19613 5775 26 that that DT 19613 5775 27 of of IN 19613 5775 28 the the DT 19613 5775 29 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5775 30 . . . 19613 5776 1 Since since IN 19613 5776 2 the the DT 19613 5776 3 latter latter NN 19613 5776 4 started start VBD 19613 5776 5 with with IN 19613 5776 6 the the DT 19613 5776 7 conception conception NN 19613 5776 8 of of IN 19613 5776 9 an an DT 19613 5776 10 original original JJ 19613 5776 11 dualism dualism NN 19613 5776 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5776 13 saw see VBD 19613 5776 14 in in IN 19613 5776 15 the the DT 19613 5776 16 empiric empiric NN 19613 5776 17 world world NN 19613 5776 18 a a DT 19613 5776 19 faulty faulty JJ 19613 5776 20 combination combination NN 19613 5776 21 of of IN 19613 5776 22 opposing oppose VBG 19613 5776 23 elements,[483 elements,[483 NN 19613 5776 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5776 25 and and CC 19613 5776 26 therefore therefore RB 19613 5776 27 recognised recognise VBD 19613 5776 28 in in IN 19613 5776 29 the the DT 19613 5776 30 redemption redemption NN 19613 5776 31 by by IN 19613 5776 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5776 33 the the DT 19613 5776 34 separation separation NN 19613 5776 35 of of IN 19613 5776 36 what what WP 19613 5776 37 was be VBD 19613 5776 38 unnaturally unnaturally RB 19613 5776 39 united united JJ 19613 5776 40 . . . 19613 5777 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5777 2 , , , 19613 5777 3 on on IN 19613 5777 4 the the DT 19613 5777 5 contrary contrary NN 19613 5777 6 , , , 19613 5777 7 who who WP 19613 5777 8 began begin VBD 19613 5777 9 with with IN 19613 5777 10 the the DT 19613 5777 11 idea idea NN 19613 5777 12 of of IN 19613 5777 13 the the DT 19613 5777 14 absolute absolute JJ 19613 5777 15 causality causality NN 19613 5777 16 of of IN 19613 5777 17 God God NNP 19613 5777 18 the the DT 19613 5777 19 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5777 20 , , , 19613 5777 21 saw see VBD 19613 5777 22 in in IN 19613 5777 23 the the DT 19613 5777 24 empiric empiric NNP 19613 5777 25 world world NN 19613 5777 26 faulty faulty JJ 19613 5777 27 estrangements estrangement NNS 19613 5777 28 and and CC 19613 5777 29 separations separation NNS 19613 5777 30 , , , 19613 5777 31 and and CC 19613 5777 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 5777 33 viewed view VBD 19613 5777 34 the the DT 19613 5777 35 redemption redemption NN 19613 5777 36 by by IN 19613 5777 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5777 38 as as IN 19613 5777 39 the the DT 19613 5777 40 reunion reunion NN 19613 5777 41 of of IN 19613 5777 42 things thing NNS 19613 5777 43 unnaturally unnaturally RB 19613 5777 44 separated separate VBN 19613 5777 45 -- -- : 19613 5777 46 the the DT 19613 5777 47 " " `` 19613 5777 48 recapitulatio recapitulatio NN 19613 5777 49 " " '' 19613 5777 50 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5777 51 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5777 52 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5777 53 : : : 19613 5777 54 anakephalaiôsis anakephalaiôsis NN 19613 5777 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5777 56 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5777 57 . . . 19613 5778 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5778 2 484 484 CD 19613 5778 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5778 4 This this DT 19613 5778 5 speculative speculative JJ 19613 5778 6 thought thought NN 19613 5778 7 , , , 19613 5778 8 which which WDT 19613 5778 9 involved involve VBD 19613 5778 10 the the DT 19613 5778 11 highest high JJS 19613 5778 12 imaginable imaginable JJ 19613 5778 13 optimism optimism NN 19613 5778 14 in in IN 19613 5778 15 contrast contrast NN 19613 5778 16 to to IN 19613 5778 17 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5778 18 pessimism pessimism NN 19613 5778 19 , , , 19613 5778 20 brought bring VBD 19613 5778 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5778 22 into into IN 19613 5778 23 touch touch NN 19613 5778 24 with with IN 19613 5778 25 certain certain JJ 19613 5778 26 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 5778 27 trains train NNS 19613 5778 28 of of IN 19613 5778 29 thought,[485 thought,[485 NNP 19613 5778 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5778 31 and and CC 19613 5778 32 enabled enable VBD 19613 5778 33 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5778 34 to to TO 19613 5778 35 adhere adhere VB 19613 5778 36 to to IN 19613 5778 37 the the DT 19613 5778 38 theology theology NN 19613 5778 39 of of IN 19613 5778 40 the the DT 19613 5778 41 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5778 42 . . . 19613 5779 1 At at IN 19613 5779 2 the the DT 19613 5779 3 same same JJ 19613 5779 4 time time NN 19613 5779 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5779 6 opened open VBD 19613 5779 7 up up RP 19613 5779 8 a a DT 19613 5779 9 view view NN 19613 5779 10 of of IN 19613 5779 11 the the DT 19613 5779 12 person person NN 19613 5779 13 of of IN 19613 5779 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5779 15 , , , 19613 5779 16 which which WDT 19613 5779 17 supplemented supplement VBD 19613 5779 18 the the DT 19613 5779 19 great great JJ 19613 5779 20 defect defect NN 19613 5779 21 of of IN 19613 5779 22 that that DT 19613 5779 23 theology,[486 theology,[486 NNP 19613 5779 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5779 25 surpassed surpass VBD 19613 5779 26 the the DT 19613 5779 27 Christology Christology NNP 19613 5779 28 of of IN 19613 5779 29 the the DT 19613 5779 30 Gnostics,[487 gnostics,[487 NN 19613 5779 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5779 32 and and CC 19613 5779 33 made make VBD 19613 5779 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5779 35 possible possible JJ 19613 5779 36 to to TO 19613 5779 37 utilise utilise VB 19613 5779 38 the the DT 19613 5779 39 Christological christological JJ 19613 5779 40 statements statement NNS 19613 5779 41 contained contain VBN 19613 5779 42 in in IN 19613 5779 43 certain certain JJ 19613 5779 44 books book NNS 19613 5779 45 of of IN 19613 5779 46 the the DT 19613 5779 47 New New NNP 19613 5779 48 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5779 49 . . . 19613 5780 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5780 2 488 488 CD 19613 5780 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5780 4 So so RB 19613 5780 5 far far RB 19613 5780 6 as as IN 19613 5780 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5780 8 know know VBP 19613 5780 9 at at IN 19613 5780 10 least least JJS 19613 5780 11 , , , 19613 5780 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5780 13 is be VBZ 19613 5780 14 the the DT 19613 5780 15 first first JJ 19613 5780 16 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5780 17 theologian theologian NN 19613 5780 18 after after IN 19613 5780 19 the the DT 19613 5780 20 time time NN 19613 5780 21 of of IN 19613 5780 22 the the DT 19613 5780 23 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5780 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5780 25 see see VB 19613 5780 26 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 5780 27 before before IN 19613 5780 28 that that DT 19613 5780 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5780 30 who who WP 19613 5780 31 assigned assign VBD 19613 5780 32 a a DT 19613 5780 33 quite quite RB 19613 5780 34 specific specific JJ 19613 5780 35 significance significance NN 19613 5780 36 to to IN 19613 5780 37 the the DT 19613 5780 38 person person NN 19613 5780 39 of of IN 19613 5780 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5780 41 and and CC 19613 5780 42 in in IN 19613 5780 43 fact fact NN 19613 5780 44 regarded regard VBD 19613 5780 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5780 46 as as IN 19613 5780 47 the the DT 19613 5780 48 vital vital JJ 19613 5780 49 factor factor NN 19613 5780 50 . . . 19613 5781 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5781 2 489 489 CD 19613 5781 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5781 4 That that DT 19613 5781 5 was be VBD 19613 5781 6 possible possible JJ 19613 5781 7 for for IN 19613 5781 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5781 9 because because IN 19613 5781 10 of of IN 19613 5781 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5781 12 realistic realistic JJ 19613 5781 13 view view NN 19613 5781 14 of of IN 19613 5781 15 redemption redemption NN 19613 5781 16 . . . 19613 5782 1 Here here RB 19613 5782 2 , , , 19613 5782 3 however however RB 19613 5782 4 , , , 19613 5782 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5782 6 did do VBD 19613 5782 7 not not RB 19613 5782 8 fall fall VB 19613 5782 9 into into IN 19613 5782 10 the the DT 19613 5782 11 abyss abyss NN 19613 5782 12 of of IN 19613 5782 13 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 5782 14 , , , 19613 5782 15 because because IN 19613 5782 16 , , , 19613 5782 17 as as IN 19613 5782 18 a a DT 19613 5782 19 disciple disciple NN 19613 5782 20 of of IN 19613 5782 21 the the DT 19613 5782 22 " " `` 19613 5782 23 elders elder NNS 19613 5782 24 " " '' 19613 5782 25 , , , 19613 5782 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5782 27 adhered adhere VBD 19613 5782 28 to to IN 19613 5782 29 the the DT 19613 5782 30 early early JJ 19613 5782 31 - - HYPH 19613 5782 32 Christian christian JJ 19613 5782 33 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 5782 34 , , , 19613 5782 35 and and CC 19613 5782 36 because because IN 19613 5782 37 , , , 19613 5782 38 as as IN 19613 5782 39 a a DT 19613 5782 40 follower follower NN 19613 5782 41 of of IN 19613 5782 42 the the DT 19613 5782 43 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5782 44 , , , 19613 5782 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5782 46 held hold VBD 19613 5782 47 , , , 19613 5782 48 along along IN 19613 5782 49 with with IN 19613 5782 50 the the DT 19613 5782 51 realistic realistic JJ 19613 5782 52 conception conception NN 19613 5782 53 of of IN 19613 5782 54 salvation salvation NN 19613 5782 55 , , , 19613 5782 56 the the DT 19613 5782 57 other other JJ 19613 5782 58 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 19613 5782 59 theory theory NN 19613 5782 60 that that IN 19613 5782 61 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5782 62 , , , 19613 5782 63 as as IN 19613 5782 64 the the DT 19613 5782 65 teacher teacher NN 19613 5782 66 , , , 19613 5782 67 imparts impart VBZ 19613 5782 68 to to IN 19613 5782 69 men man NNS 19613 5782 70 , , , 19613 5782 71 who who WP 19613 5782 72 are be VBP 19613 5782 73 free free JJ 19613 5782 74 and and CC 19613 5782 75 naturally naturally RB 19613 5782 76 constituted constituted JJ 19613 5782 77 for for IN 19613 5782 78 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 5782 79 with with IN 19613 5782 80 God God NNP 19613 5782 81 , , , 19613 5782 82 the the DT 19613 5782 83 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5782 84 which which WDT 19613 5782 85 enables enable VBZ 19613 5782 86 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5782 87 to to TO 19613 5782 88 imitate imitate VB 19613 5782 89 God God NNP 19613 5782 90 , , , 19613 5782 91 and and CC 19613 5782 92 thus thus RB 19613 5782 93 by by IN 19613 5782 94 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5782 95 own own JJ 19613 5782 96 act act NN 19613 5782 97 to to TO 19613 5782 98 attain attain VB 19613 5782 99 communion communion NN 19613 5782 100 with with IN 19613 5782 101 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5782 102 . . . 19613 5783 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5783 2 to to IN 19613 5783 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5783 4 the the DT 19613 5783 5 pith pith NN 19613 5783 6 of of IN 19613 5783 7 the the DT 19613 5783 8 matter matter NN 19613 5783 9 is be VBZ 19613 5783 10 already already RB 19613 5783 11 found find VBN 19613 5783 12 in in IN 19613 5783 13 the the DT 19613 5783 14 idea idea NN 19613 5783 15 that that IN 19613 5783 16 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5783 17 is be VBZ 19613 5783 18 real real JJ 19613 5783 19 redemption redemption NN 19613 5783 20 , , , 19613 5783 21 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5783 22 , , , 19613 5783 23 that that IN 19613 5783 24 the the DT 19613 5783 25 highest high JJS 19613 5783 26 blessing blessing NN 19613 5783 27 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 5783 28 in in IN 19613 5783 29 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5783 30 is be VBZ 19613 5783 31 the the DT 19613 5783 32 deification deification NN 19613 5783 33 of of IN 19613 5783 34 human human JJ 19613 5783 35 nature nature NN 19613 5783 36 through through IN 19613 5783 37 the the DT 19613 5783 38 gift gift NN 19613 5783 39 of of IN 19613 5783 40 immortality immortality NN 19613 5783 41 , , , 19613 5783 42 and and CC 19613 5783 43 that that IN 19613 5783 44 this this DT 19613 5783 45 deification deification NN 19613 5783 46 includes include VBZ 19613 5783 47 the the DT 19613 5783 48 full full JJ 19613 5783 49 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5783 50 and and CC 19613 5783 51 enjoying enjoying NN 19613 5783 52 of of IN 19613 5783 53 God God NNP 19613 5783 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5783 55 visio visio NNP 19613 5783 56 dei dei NNP 19613 5783 57 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5783 58 . . . 19613 5784 1 This this DT 19613 5784 2 conception conception NN 19613 5784 3 suggested suggest VBD 19613 5784 4 to to IN 19613 5784 5 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5784 6 the the DT 19613 5784 7 question question NN 19613 5784 8 as as IN 19613 5784 9 to to IN 19613 5784 10 the the DT 19613 5784 11 cause cause NN 19613 5784 12 of of IN 19613 5784 13 the the DT 19613 5784 14 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5784 15 as as RB 19613 5784 16 well well RB 19613 5784 17 as as IN 19613 5784 18 the the DT 19613 5784 19 answer answer NN 19613 5784 20 to to IN 19613 5784 21 the the DT 19613 5784 22 same same JJ 19613 5784 23 . . . 19613 5785 1 The the DT 19613 5785 2 question question NN 19613 5785 3 " " `` 19613 5785 4 cur cur NN 19613 5785 5 deus deus NNP 19613 5785 6 -- -- : 19613 5785 7 homo homo NN 19613 5785 8 " " '' 19613 5785 9 , , , 19613 5785 10 which which WDT 19613 5785 11 was be VBD 19613 5785 12 by by IN 19613 5785 13 no no DT 19613 5785 14 means means NN 19613 5785 15 clearly clearly RB 19613 5785 16 formulated formulate VBN 19613 5785 17 in in IN 19613 5785 18 the the DT 19613 5785 19 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5785 20 writings writing NNS 19613 5785 21 , , , 19613 5785 22 in in IN 19613 5785 23 so so RB 19613 5785 24 far far RB 19613 5785 25 as as IN 19613 5785 26 in in IN 19613 5785 27 these these DT 19613 5785 28 " " `` 19613 5785 29 homo homo NN 19613 5785 30 " " '' 19613 5785 31 only only RB 19613 5785 32 meant mean VBN 19613 5785 33 _ _ NNP 19613 5785 34 appearance appearance NN 19613 5785 35 _ _ NNP 19613 5785 36 among among IN 19613 5785 37 men man NNS 19613 5785 38 , , , 19613 5785 39 and and CC 19613 5785 40 the the DT 19613 5785 41 " " `` 19613 5785 42 why why WRB 19613 5785 43 " " '' 19613 5785 44 was be VBD 19613 5785 45 answered answer VBN 19613 5785 46 by by IN 19613 5785 47 referring refer VBG 19613 5785 48 to to IN 19613 5785 49 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 5785 50 and and CC 19613 5785 51 the the DT 19613 5785 52 necessity necessity NN 19613 5785 53 of of IN 19613 5785 54 divine divine JJ 19613 5785 55 teaching teaching NN 19613 5785 56 , , , 19613 5785 57 was be VBD 19613 5785 58 by by IN 19613 5785 59 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5785 60 made make VBD 19613 5785 61 the the DT 19613 5785 62 central central JJ 19613 5785 63 point point NN 19613 5785 64 . . . 19613 5786 1 The the DT 19613 5786 2 reasons reason NNS 19613 5786 3 why why WRB 19613 5786 4 the the DT 19613 5786 5 answer answer NN 19613 5786 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5786 7 gave give VBD 19613 5786 8 was be VBD 19613 5786 9 so so RB 19613 5786 10 highly highly RB 19613 5786 11 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 19613 5786 12 may may MD 19613 5786 13 be be VB 19613 5786 14 stated state VBN 19613 5786 15 as as IN 19613 5786 16 follows follow VBZ 19613 5786 17 : : : 19613 5786 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5786 19 1 1 LS 19613 5786 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5786 21 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5786 22 proved prove VBD 19613 5786 23 that that IN 19613 5786 24 the the DT 19613 5786 25 Christian christian JJ 19613 5786 26 blessing blessing NN 19613 5786 27 of of IN 19613 5786 28 salvation salvation NN 19613 5786 29 was be VBD 19613 5786 30 of of IN 19613 5786 31 a a DT 19613 5786 32 specific specific JJ 19613 5786 33 kind kind NN 19613 5786 34 . . . 19613 5787 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5787 2 2 2 LS 19613 5787 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5787 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5787 5 was be VBD 19613 5787 6 similar similar JJ 19613 5787 7 in in IN 19613 5787 8 point point NN 19613 5787 9 of of IN 19613 5787 10 form form NN 19613 5787 11 to to IN 19613 5787 12 the the DT 19613 5787 13 so so RB 19613 5787 14 - - HYPH 19613 5787 15 called call VBN 19613 5787 16 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5787 17 conception conception NN 19613 5787 18 of of IN 19613 5787 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5787 20 , , , 19613 5787 21 and and CC 19613 5787 22 even even RB 19613 5787 23 surpassed surpass VBD 19613 5787 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5787 25 as as IN 19613 5787 26 regards regard VBZ 19613 5787 27 the the DT 19613 5787 28 promised promise VBN 19613 5787 29 extent extent NN 19613 5787 30 of of IN 19613 5787 31 the the DT 19613 5787 32 sphere sphere NN 19613 5787 33 included include VBN 19613 5787 34 in in IN 19613 5787 35 the the DT 19613 5787 36 deification deification NN 19613 5787 37 . . . 19613 5788 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5788 2 3 3 LS 19613 5788 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5788 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5788 5 harmonised harmonise VBD 19613 5788 6 with with IN 19613 5788 7 the the DT 19613 5788 8 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 5788 9 tendency tendency NN 19613 5788 10 of of IN 19613 5788 11 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 5788 12 , , , 19613 5788 13 and and CC 19613 5788 14 at at IN 19613 5788 15 the the DT 19613 5788 16 same same JJ 19613 5788 17 time time NN 19613 5788 18 was be VBD 19613 5788 19 fitted fit VBN 19613 5788 20 to to TO 19613 5788 21 replace replace VB 19613 5788 22 the the DT 19613 5788 23 material material NN 19613 5788 24 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 5788 25 expectations expectation NNS 19613 5788 26 that that WDT 19613 5788 27 were be VBD 19613 5788 28 fading fade VBG 19613 5788 29 away away RB 19613 5788 30 . . . 19613 5789 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5789 2 4 4 LS 19613 5789 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5789 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5789 5 was be VBD 19613 5789 6 in in IN 19613 5789 7 keeping keep VBG 19613 5789 8 with with IN 19613 5789 9 the the DT 19613 5789 10 mystic mystic JJ 19613 5789 11 and and CC 19613 5789 12 Neoplatonic Neoplatonic NNP 19613 5789 13 current current NN 19613 5789 14 of of IN 19613 5789 15 the the DT 19613 5789 16 time time NN 19613 5789 17 , , , 19613 5789 18 and and CC 19613 5789 19 afforded afford VBD 19613 5789 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5789 21 the the DT 19613 5789 22 highest high JJS 19613 5789 23 imaginable imaginable JJ 19613 5789 24 satisfaction satisfaction NN 19613 5789 25 . . . 19613 5790 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5790 2 5 5 CD 19613 5790 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5790 4 For for IN 19613 5790 5 the the DT 19613 5790 6 vanishing vanish VBG 19613 5790 7 trust trust NN 19613 5790 8 in in IN 19613 5790 9 the the DT 19613 5790 10 possibility possibility NN 19613 5790 11 of of IN 19613 5790 12 attaining attain VBG 19613 5790 13 the the DT 19613 5790 14 highest high JJS 19613 5790 15 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5790 16 by by IN 19613 5790 17 the the DT 19613 5790 18 aid aid NN 19613 5790 19 of of IN 19613 5790 20 reason reason NN 19613 5790 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5790 22 substituted substitute VBD 19613 5790 23 the the DT 19613 5790 24 sure sure JJ 19613 5790 25 hope hope NN 19613 5790 26 of of IN 19613 5790 27 a a DT 19613 5790 28 supernatural supernatural JJ 19613 5790 29 transformation transformation NN 19613 5790 30 of of IN 19613 5790 31 human human JJ 19613 5790 32 nature nature NN 19613 5790 33 which which WDT 19613 5790 34 would would MD 19613 5790 35 even even RB 19613 5790 36 enable enable VB 19613 5790 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5790 38 to to TO 19613 5790 39 appropriate appropriate VB 19613 5790 40 that that IN 19613 5790 41 which which WDT 19613 5790 42 is be VBZ 19613 5790 43 above above IN 19613 5790 44 reason reason NN 19613 5790 45 . . . 19613 5791 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5791 2 6 6 CD 19613 5791 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5791 4 Lastly lastly RB 19613 5791 5 , , , 19613 5791 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5791 7 provided provide VBD 19613 5791 8 the the DT 19613 5791 9 traditional traditional JJ 19613 5791 10 historical historical JJ 19613 5791 11 utterances utterance NNS 19613 5791 12 respecting respect VBG 19613 5791 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5791 14 , , , 19613 5791 15 as as RB 19613 5791 16 well well RB 19613 5791 17 as as IN 19613 5791 18 the the DT 19613 5791 19 whole whole JJ 19613 5791 20 preceding precede VBG 19613 5791 21 course course NN 19613 5791 22 of of IN 19613 5791 23 history history NN 19613 5791 24 , , , 19613 5791 25 with with IN 19613 5791 26 a a DT 19613 5791 27 firm firm JJ 19613 5791 28 foundation foundation NN 19613 5791 29 and and CC 19613 5791 30 a a DT 19613 5791 31 definite definite JJ 19613 5791 32 aim aim NN 19613 5791 33 , , , 19613 5791 34 and and CC 19613 5791 35 made make VBD 19613 5791 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5791 37 possible possible JJ 19613 5791 38 to to TO 19613 5791 39 conceive conceive VB 19613 5791 40 a a DT 19613 5791 41 history history NN 19613 5791 42 of of IN 19613 5791 43 salvation salvation NN 19613 5791 44 unfolding unfold VBG 19613 5791 45 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5791 46 by by IN 19613 5791 47 degrees degree NNS 19613 5791 48 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5791 49 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5791 50 : : : 19613 5791 51 oikonomia oikonomia NNP 19613 5791 52 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5791 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5791 54 . . . 19613 5792 1 According accord VBG 19613 5792 2 to to IN 19613 5792 3 this this DT 19613 5792 4 conception conception NN 19613 5792 5 the the DT 19613 5792 6 central central JJ 19613 5792 7 point point NN 19613 5792 8 of of IN 19613 5792 9 history history NN 19613 5792 10 was be VBD 19613 5792 11 no no RB 19613 5792 12 longer long RBR 19613 5792 13 the the DT 19613 5792 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5792 15 as as IN 19613 5792 16 such such JJ 19613 5792 17 , , , 19613 5792 18 but but CC 19613 5792 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5792 20 as as IN 19613 5792 21 the the DT 19613 5792 22 _ _ NNP 19613 5792 23 incarnate incarnate VBP 19613 5792 24 God God NNP 19613 5792 25 _ _ NNP 19613 5792 26 , , , 19613 5792 27 while while IN 19613 5792 28 at at IN 19613 5792 29 the the DT 19613 5792 30 same same JJ 19613 5792 31 time time NN 19613 5792 32 the the DT 19613 5792 33 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 5792 34 interest interest NN 19613 5792 35 was be VBD 19613 5792 36 balanced balance VBN 19613 5792 37 by by IN 19613 5792 38 a a DT 19613 5792 39 really really RB 19613 5792 40 religious religious JJ 19613 5792 41 one one NN 19613 5792 42 . . . 19613 5793 1 An an DT 19613 5793 2 approach approach NN 19613 5793 3 was be VBD 19613 5793 4 thus thus RB 19613 5793 5 made make VBN 19613 5793 6 to to IN 19613 5793 7 the the DT 19613 5793 8 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 5793 9 theology theology NN 19613 5793 10 , , , 19613 5793 11 though though IN 19613 5793 12 indeed indeed RB 19613 5793 13 in in IN 19613 5793 14 a a DT 19613 5793 15 very very RB 19613 5793 16 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 5793 17 way way NN 19613 5793 18 and and CC 19613 5793 19 to to IN 19613 5793 20 some some DT 19613 5793 21 extent extent NN 19613 5793 22 only only RB 19613 5793 23 in in IN 19613 5793 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 5793 25 . . . 19613 5794 1 A a DT 19613 5794 2 more more RBR 19613 5794 3 exact exact JJ 19613 5794 4 representation representation NN 19613 5794 5 of of IN 19613 5794 6 salvation salvation NN 19613 5794 7 through through IN 19613 5794 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5794 9 has have VBZ 19613 5794 10 , , , 19613 5794 11 however however RB 19613 5794 12 , , , 19613 5794 13 been be VBN 19613 5794 14 given give VBN 19613 5794 15 by by IN 19613 5794 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5794 17 as as IN 19613 5794 18 follows follow VBZ 19613 5794 19 : : : 19613 5794 20 Incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 5794 21 is be VBZ 19613 5794 22 a a DT 19613 5794 23 _ _ NNP 19613 5794 24 habitus habitus NN 19613 5794 25 _ _ NN 19613 5794 26 which which WDT 19613 5794 27 is be VBZ 19613 5794 28 the the DT 19613 5794 29 opposite opposite NN 19613 5794 30 of of IN 19613 5794 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5794 32 present present JJ 19613 5794 33 one one NN 19613 5794 34 and and CC 19613 5794 35 indeed indeed RB 19613 5794 36 of of IN 19613 5794 37 man man NN 19613 5794 38 's 's POS 19613 5794 39 natural natural JJ 19613 5794 40 condition condition NN 19613 5794 41 . . . 19613 5795 1 For for IN 19613 5795 2 immortality immortality NN 19613 5795 3 is be VBZ 19613 5795 4 at at IN 19613 5795 5 once once IN 19613 5795 6 God God NNP 19613 5795 7 's 's POS 19613 5795 8 manner manner NN 19613 5795 9 of of IN 19613 5795 10 existence existence NN 19613 5795 11 and and CC 19613 5795 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5795 13 attribute attribute NN 19613 5795 14 ; ; : 19613 5795 15 as as IN 19613 5795 16 a a DT 19613 5795 17 created create VBN 19613 5795 18 being be VBG 19613 5795 19 man man NN 19613 5795 20 is be VBZ 19613 5795 21 only only RB 19613 5795 22 " " `` 19613 5795 23 capable capable JJ 19613 5795 24 of of IN 19613 5795 25 incorruption incorruption NN 19613 5795 26 and and CC 19613 5795 27 immortality immortality NN 19613 5795 28 " " '' 19613 5795 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5795 30 " " `` 19613 5795 31 _ _ NNP 19613 5795 32 capax capax NNP 19613 5795 33 incorruptionis incorruptionis NNP 19613 5795 34 et et FW 19613 5795 35 immortalitatis_");[490 immortalitatis_");[490 FW 19613 5795 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5795 37 thanks thank NNS 19613 5795 38 to to IN 19613 5795 39 the the DT 19613 5795 40 divine divine JJ 19613 5795 41 goodness goodness NN 19613 5795 42 , , , 19613 5795 43 however however RB 19613 5795 44 , , , 19613 5795 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5795 46 is be VBZ 19613 5795 47 intended intend VBN 19613 5795 48 for for IN 19613 5795 49 the the DT 19613 5795 50 same same JJ 19613 5795 51 , , , 19613 5795 52 and and CC 19613 5795 53 yet yet RB 19613 5795 54 is be VBZ 19613 5795 55 empirically empirically RB 19613 5795 56 " " `` 19613 5795 57 subjected subject VBN 19613 5795 58 to to IN 19613 5795 59 the the DT 19613 5795 60 power power NN 19613 5795 61 of of IN 19613 5795 62 death death NN 19613 5795 63 " " '' 19613 5795 64 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5795 65 " " `` 19613 5795 66 sub sub VB 19613 5795 67 condicione condicione NN 19613 5795 68 mortis mortis NN 19613 5795 69 " " '' 19613 5795 70 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5795 71 . . . 19613 5796 1 Now now RB 19613 5796 2 the the DT 19613 5796 3 sole sole JJ 19613 5796 4 way way NN 19613 5796 5 in in IN 19613 5796 6 which which WDT 19613 5796 7 immortality immortality NN 19613 5796 8 as as IN 19613 5796 9 a a DT 19613 5796 10 physical physical JJ 19613 5796 11 condition condition NN 19613 5796 12 can can MD 19613 5796 13 be be VB 19613 5796 14 obtained obtain VBN 19613 5796 15 is be VBZ 19613 5796 16 by by IN 19613 5796 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5796 18 possessor possessor NN 19613 5796 19 uniting unite VBG 19613 5796 20 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5796 21 _ _ IN 19613 5796 22 realiter realit JJR 19613 5796 23 _ _ NNP 19613 5796 24 with with IN 19613 5796 25 human human JJ 19613 5796 26 nature nature NN 19613 5796 27 , , , 19613 5796 28 in in IN 19613 5796 29 order order NN 19613 5796 30 to to TO 19613 5796 31 deify deify VB 19613 5796 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5796 33 " " '' 19613 5796 34 by by IN 19613 5796 35 adoption adoption NN 19613 5796 36 " " '' 19613 5796 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5796 38 " " `` 19613 5796 39 _ _ NNP 19613 5796 40 per per IN 19613 5796 41 adoptionem adoptionem NN 19613 5796 42 _ _ NNP 19613 5796 43 " " '' 19613 5796 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5796 45 , , , 19613 5796 46 such such JJ 19613 5796 47 is be VBZ 19613 5796 48 the the DT 19613 5796 49 technical technical JJ 19613 5796 50 term term NN 19613 5796 51 of of IN 19613 5796 52 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5796 53 . . . 19613 5797 1 The the DT 19613 5797 2 deity deity NN 19613 5797 3 must must MD 19613 5797 4 become become VB 19613 5797 5 what what WP 19613 5797 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5797 7 are be VBP 19613 5797 8 in in IN 19613 5797 9 order order NN 19613 5797 10 that that IN 19613 5797 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5797 12 may may MD 19613 5797 13 become become VB 19613 5797 14 what what WP 19613 5797 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5797 16 is be VBZ 19613 5797 17 . . . 19613 5798 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5798 2 , , , 19613 5798 3 if if IN 19613 5798 4 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5798 5 is be VBZ 19613 5798 6 to to TO 19613 5798 7 be be VB 19613 5798 8 the the DT 19613 5798 9 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 5798 10 , , , 19613 5798 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5798 12 must must MD 19613 5798 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5798 14 be be VB 19613 5798 15 God God NNP 19613 5798 16 , , , 19613 5798 17 and and CC 19613 5798 18 all all PDT 19613 5798 19 the the DT 19613 5798 20 stress stress NN 19613 5798 21 must must MD 19613 5798 22 fall fall VB 19613 5798 23 upon upon IN 19613 5798 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5798 25 birth birth NN 19613 5798 26 as as IN 19613 5798 27 man man NN 19613 5798 28 . . . 19613 5799 1 " " `` 19613 5799 2 By by IN 19613 5799 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5799 4 birth birth NN 19613 5799 5 as as IN 19613 5799 6 man man NN 19613 5799 7 the the DT 19613 5799 8 eternal eternal JJ 19613 5799 9 Word Word NNP 19613 5799 10 of of IN 19613 5799 11 God God NNP 19613 5799 12 guarantees guarantee VBZ 19613 5799 13 the the DT 19613 5799 14 inheritance inheritance NN 19613 5799 15 of of IN 19613 5799 16 life life NN 19613 5799 17 to to IN 19613 5799 18 those those DT 19613 5799 19 who who WP 19613 5799 20 in in IN 19613 5799 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5799 22 natural natural JJ 19613 5799 23 birth birth NN 19613 5799 24 have have VBP 19613 5799 25 inherited inherit VBN 19613 5799 26 death death NN 19613 5799 27 . . . 19613 5800 1 " " `` 19613 5800 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5800 3 491 491 CD 19613 5800 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5800 5 But but CC 19613 5800 6 this this DT 19613 5800 7 work work NN 19613 5800 8 of of IN 19613 5800 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5800 10 can can MD 19613 5800 11 be be VB 19613 5800 12 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5800 13 as as IN 19613 5800 14 _ _ NNP 19613 5800 15 recapitulatio recapitulatio NN 19613 5800 16 _ _ NNP 19613 5800 17 because because IN 19613 5800 18 God God NNP 19613 5800 19 the the DT 19613 5800 20 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 5800 21 is be VBZ 19613 5800 22 identical identical JJ 19613 5800 23 with with IN 19613 5800 24 God God NNP 19613 5800 25 the the DT 19613 5800 26 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5800 27 ; ; : 19613 5800 28 and and CC 19613 5800 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5800 30 consequently consequently RB 19613 5800 31 brings bring VBZ 19613 5800 32 about about RP 19613 5800 33 a a DT 19613 5800 34 final final JJ 19613 5800 35 condition condition NN 19613 5800 36 which which WDT 19613 5800 37 existed exist VBD 19613 5800 38 from from IN 19613 5800 39 the the DT 19613 5800 40 beginning beginning NN 19613 5800 41 in in IN 19613 5800 42 God God NNP 19613 5800 43 's 's POS 19613 5800 44 plan plan NN 19613 5800 45 , , , 19613 5800 46 but but CC 19613 5800 47 could could MD 19613 5800 48 not not RB 19613 5800 49 be be VB 19613 5800 50 immediately immediately RB 19613 5800 51 realised realise VBN 19613 5800 52 in in IN 19613 5800 53 consequence consequence NN 19613 5800 54 of of IN 19613 5800 55 the the DT 19613 5800 56 entrance entrance NN 19613 5800 57 of of IN 19613 5800 58 sin sin NN 19613 5800 59 . . . 19613 5801 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5801 2 is be VBZ 19613 5801 3 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 5801 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5801 5 ' ' POS 19613 5801 6 highest high JJS 19613 5801 7 merit merit NN 19613 5801 8 , , , 19613 5801 9 from from IN 19613 5801 10 a a DT 19613 5801 11 historical historical JJ 19613 5801 12 and and CC 19613 5801 13 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5801 14 point point NN 19613 5801 15 of of IN 19613 5801 16 view view NN 19613 5801 17 , , , 19613 5801 18 to to TO 19613 5801 19 have have VB 19613 5801 20 worked work VBN 19613 5801 21 out out RP 19613 5801 22 this this DT 19613 5801 23 thought thought NN 19613 5801 24 in in IN 19613 5801 25 pregnant pregnant JJ 19613 5801 26 fashion fashion NN 19613 5801 27 and and CC 19613 5801 28 with with IN 19613 5801 29 the the DT 19613 5801 30 simplest simple JJS 19613 5801 31 means mean NNS 19613 5801 32 , , , 19613 5801 33 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5801 34 , , , 19613 5801 35 without without IN 19613 5801 36 the the DT 19613 5801 37 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 5801 38 of of IN 19613 5801 39 the the DT 19613 5801 40 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5801 41 , , , 19613 5801 42 but but CC 19613 5801 43 rather rather RB 19613 5801 44 by by IN 19613 5801 45 the the DT 19613 5801 46 aid aid NN 19613 5801 47 of of IN 19613 5801 48 simple simple JJ 19613 5801 49 and and CC 19613 5801 50 essentially essentially RB 19613 5801 51 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 5801 52 ideas idea NNS 19613 5801 53 . . . 19613 5802 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 5802 2 , , , 19613 5802 3 a a DT 19613 5802 4 few few JJ 19613 5802 5 decades decade NNS 19613 5802 6 later later RB 19613 5802 7 , , , 19613 5802 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5802 9 and and CC 19613 5802 10 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5802 11 , , , 19613 5802 12 an an DT 19613 5802 13 author author NN 19613 5802 14 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 5802 15 so so RB 19613 5802 16 little little RB 19613 5802 17 known known JJ 19613 5802 18 to to IN 19613 5802 19 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5802 20 , , , 19613 5802 21 were be VBD 19613 5802 22 already already RB 19613 5802 23 credited credit VBN 19613 5802 24 with with IN 19613 5802 25 this this DT 19613 5802 26 merit merit NN 19613 5802 27 . . . 19613 5803 1 For for IN 19613 5803 2 the the DT 19613 5803 3 author author NN 19613 5803 4 of of IN 19613 5803 5 the the DT 19613 5803 6 so so RB 19613 5803 7 - - HYPH 19613 5803 8 called call VBN 19613 5803 9 " " `` 19613 5803 10 Little little JJ 19613 5803 11 Labyrinth Labyrinth NNP 19613 5803 12 " " '' 19613 5803 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5803 14 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 5803 15 . . NNP 19613 5803 16 , , , 19613 5803 17 H. H. NNP 19613 5803 18 E. E. NNP 19613 5803 19 V. V. NNP 19613 5803 20 28 28 CD 19613 5803 21 . . . 19613 5804 1 5 5 LS 19613 5804 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5804 3 can can MD 19613 5804 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 5804 5 boast boast VB 19613 5804 6 with with IN 19613 5804 7 regard regard NN 19613 5804 8 to to IN 19613 5804 9 the the DT 19613 5804 10 works work NNS 19613 5804 11 of of IN 19613 5804 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 5804 13 , , , 19613 5804 14 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 19613 5804 15 , , , 19613 5804 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5804 17 , , , 19613 5804 18 Clement Clement NNP 19613 5804 19 , , , 19613 5804 20 etc etc FW 19613 5804 21 . . FW 19613 5804 22 , , , 19613 5804 23 that that IN 19613 5804 24 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5804 25 declared declare VBD 19613 5804 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5804 27 to to TO 19613 5804 28 be be VB 19613 5804 29 God God NNP 19613 5804 30 , , , 19613 5804 31 but but CC 19613 5804 32 then then RB 19613 5804 33 continues continue VBZ 19613 5804 34 : : : 19613 5804 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5804 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5804 37 : : : 19613 5804 38 Ta Ta NNP 19613 5804 39 Eirênaiou Eirênaiou NNP 19613 5804 40 te te NNP 19613 5804 41 kai kai NNP 19613 5804 42 Melitônos Melitônos NNP 19613 5804 43 kai kai NNP 19613 5804 44 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5804 45 loipôn loipôn NNP 19613 5804 46 tis tis NNP 19613 5804 47 agnoei agnoei NNP 19613 5804 48 biblia biblia NNP 19613 5804 49 , , , 19613 5804 50 theon theon NNP 19613 5804 51 kai kai NNP 19613 5804 52 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 5804 53 katangellonta katangellonta NNP 19613 5804 54 ton ton VB 19613 5804 55 Christon Christon NNP 19613 5804 56 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5804 57 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5804 58 " " `` 19613 5804 59 Who who WP 19613 5804 60 is be VBZ 19613 5804 61 ignorant ignorant JJ 19613 5804 62 of of IN 19613 5804 63 the the DT 19613 5804 64 books book NNS 19613 5804 65 of of IN 19613 5804 66 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5804 67 , , , 19613 5804 68 Melito Melito NNP 19613 5804 69 , , , 19613 5804 70 and and CC 19613 5804 71 the the DT 19613 5804 72 rest rest NN 19613 5804 73 , , , 19613 5804 74 which which WDT 19613 5804 75 proclaim proclaim VBP 19613 5804 76 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5804 77 to to TO 19613 5804 78 be be VB 19613 5804 79 God God NNP 19613 5804 80 and and CC 19613 5804 81 man man NN 19613 5804 82 " " '' 19613 5804 83 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5804 84 . . . 19613 5805 1 The the DT 19613 5805 2 progress progress NN 19613 5805 3 in in IN 19613 5805 4 theological theological JJ 19613 5805 5 views view NNS 19613 5805 6 is be VBZ 19613 5805 7 very very RB 19613 5805 8 precisely precisely RB 19613 5805 9 and and CC 19613 5805 10 appropriately appropriately RB 19613 5805 11 expressed express VBN 19613 5805 12 in in IN 19613 5805 13 these these DT 19613 5805 14 words word NNS 19613 5805 15 . . . 19613 5806 1 The the DT 19613 5806 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5806 3 also also RB 19613 5806 4 professed profess VBD 19613 5806 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5806 6 belief belief NN 19613 5806 7 in in IN 19613 5806 8 the the DT 19613 5806 9 full full JJ 19613 5806 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 5806 11 of of IN 19613 5806 12 God God NNP 19613 5806 13 upon upon IN 19613 5806 14 earth earth NN 19613 5806 15 , , , 19613 5806 16 that that RB 19613 5806 17 is is RB 19613 5806 18 , , , 19613 5806 19 in in IN 19613 5806 20 revelation revelation NN 19613 5806 21 as as IN 19613 5806 22 the the DT 19613 5806 23 teaching teaching NN 19613 5806 24 which which WDT 19613 5806 25 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5806 26 leads lead VBZ 19613 5806 27 to to IN 19613 5806 28 immortality;[492 immortality;[492 NNPS 19613 5806 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5806 30 but but CC 19613 5806 31 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5806 32 is be VBZ 19613 5806 33 the the DT 19613 5806 34 first first JJ 19613 5806 35 to to TO 19613 5806 36 whom whom WP 19613 5806 37 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5806 38 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5806 39 , , , 19613 5806 40 God God NNP 19613 5806 41 and and CC 19613 5806 42 man man NN 19613 5806 43 , , , 19613 5806 44 is be VBZ 19613 5806 45 the the DT 19613 5806 46 centre centre NN 19613 5806 47 of of IN 19613 5806 48 history history NN 19613 5806 49 and and CC 19613 5806 50 faith faith NN 19613 5806 51 . . . 19613 5807 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5807 2 493 493 CD 19613 5807 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5807 4 Following follow VBG 19613 5807 5 the the DT 19613 5807 6 method method NN 19613 5807 7 of of IN 19613 5807 8 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 5807 9 , , , 19613 5807 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5807 11 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 5807 12 in in IN 19613 5807 13 sketching sketch VBG 19613 5807 14 a a DT 19613 5807 15 history history NN 19613 5807 16 of of IN 19613 5807 17 salvation salvation NN 19613 5807 18 , , , 19613 5807 19 the the DT 19613 5807 20 gradual gradual JJ 19613 5807 21 realising realising NN 19613 5807 22 of of IN 19613 5807 23 the the DT 19613 5807 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5807 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5807 26 : : : 19613 5807 27 oikonomia oikonomia NN 19613 5807 28 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5807 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5807 30 culminating culminate VBG 19613 5807 31 in in IN 19613 5807 32 the the DT 19613 5807 33 deification deification NN 19613 5807 34 of of IN 19613 5807 35 believing believe VBG 19613 5807 36 humanity humanity NN 19613 5807 37 , , , 19613 5807 38 but but CC 19613 5807 39 here here RB 19613 5807 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5807 41 always always RB 19613 5807 42 managed manage VBD 19613 5807 43 to to TO 19613 5807 44 keep keep VB 19613 5807 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5807 46 language language NN 19613 5807 47 essentially essentially RB 19613 5807 48 within within IN 19613 5807 49 the the DT 19613 5807 50 limits limit NNS 19613 5807 51 of of IN 19613 5807 52 the the DT 19613 5807 53 Biblical Biblical NNP 19613 5807 54 . . . 19613 5808 1 The the DT 19613 5808 2 various various JJ 19613 5808 3 acting act VBG 19613 5808 4 æons æon NNS 19613 5808 5 of of IN 19613 5808 6 the the DT 19613 5808 7 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5808 8 became become VBD 19613 5808 9 to to IN 19613 5808 10 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5808 11 different different JJ 19613 5808 12 stages stage NNS 19613 5808 13 in in IN 19613 5808 14 the the DT 19613 5808 15 saving save VBG 19613 5808 16 work work NN 19613 5808 17 of of IN 19613 5808 18 the the DT 19613 5808 19 one one CD 19613 5808 20 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5808 21 and and CC 19613 5808 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5808 23 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5808 24 . . . 19613 5809 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5809 2 system system NN 19613 5809 3 seemed seem VBD 19613 5809 4 to to TO 19613 5809 5 have have VB 19613 5809 6 absorbed absorb VBN 19613 5809 7 the the DT 19613 5809 8 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 5809 9 of of IN 19613 5809 10 the the DT 19613 5809 11 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5809 12 and and CC 19613 5809 13 the the DT 19613 5809 14 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 5809 15 simplicity simplicity NN 19613 5809 16 of of IN 19613 5809 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5809 18 moral moral JJ 19613 5809 19 theology theology NN 19613 5809 20 , , , 19613 5809 21 just just RB 19613 5809 22 as as RB 19613 5809 23 much much RB 19613 5809 24 as as IN 19613 5809 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5809 26 did do VBD 19613 5809 27 the the DT 19613 5809 28 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5809 29 dualism dualism NN 19613 5809 30 with with IN 19613 5809 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5809 32 particoloured particoloured JJ 19613 5809 33 mythology mythology NN 19613 5809 34 . . . 19613 5810 1 Revelation revelation NN 19613 5810 2 had have VBD 19613 5810 3 become become VBN 19613 5810 4 history history NN 19613 5810 5 , , , 19613 5810 6 the the DT 19613 5810 7 history history NN 19613 5810 8 of of IN 19613 5810 9 salvation salvation NN 19613 5810 10 ; ; : 19613 5810 11 and and CC 19613 5810 12 dogmatics dogmatic NNS 19613 5810 13 had have VBD 19613 5810 14 in in IN 19613 5810 15 a a DT 19613 5810 16 certain certain JJ 19613 5810 17 fashion fashion NN 19613 5810 18 become become VBP 19613 5810 19 a a DT 19613 5810 20 way way NN 19613 5810 21 of of IN 19613 5810 22 looking look VBG 19613 5810 23 at at IN 19613 5810 24 history history NN 19613 5810 25 , , , 19613 5810 26 the the DT 19613 5810 27 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5810 28 of of IN 19613 5810 29 God God NNP 19613 5810 30 's 's POS 19613 5810 31 ways way NNS 19613 5810 32 of of IN 19613 5810 33 salvation salvation NN 19613 5810 34 that that WDT 19613 5810 35 lead lead VBP 19613 5810 36 historically historically RB 19613 5810 37 to to IN 19613 5810 38 an an DT 19613 5810 39 appointed appoint VBN 19613 5810 40 goal goal NN 19613 5810 41 . . . 19613 5811 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5811 2 494 494 CD 19613 5811 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5811 4 But but CC 19613 5811 5 , , , 19613 5811 6 as as IN 19613 5811 7 this this DT 19613 5811 8 realistic realistic JJ 19613 5811 9 , , , 19613 5811 10 quasi quasi JJ 19613 5811 11 - - JJ 19613 5811 12 historical historical JJ 19613 5811 13 view view NN 19613 5811 14 of of IN 19613 5811 15 the the DT 19613 5811 16 subject subject NN 19613 5811 17 was be VBD 19613 5811 18 by by IN 19613 5811 19 no no DT 19613 5811 20 means means NN 19613 5811 21 completely completely RB 19613 5811 22 worked work VBD 19613 5811 23 out out RP 19613 5811 24 by by IN 19613 5811 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5811 26 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5811 27 , , , 19613 5811 28 since since IN 19613 5811 29 the the DT 19613 5811 30 theory theory NN 19613 5811 31 of of IN 19613 5811 32 human human JJ 19613 5811 33 freedom freedom NN 19613 5811 34 did do VBD 19613 5811 35 not not RB 19613 5811 36 admit admit VB 19613 5811 37 of of IN 19613 5811 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5811 39 logical logical JJ 19613 5811 40 development development NN 19613 5811 41 , , , 19613 5811 42 and and CC 19613 5811 43 since since IN 19613 5811 44 the the DT 19613 5811 45 New New NNP 19613 5811 46 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5811 47 also also RB 19613 5811 48 pointed point VBD 19613 5811 49 in in IN 19613 5811 50 other other JJ 19613 5811 51 directions direction NNS 19613 5811 52 , , , 19613 5811 53 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5811 54 did do VBD 19613 5811 55 not not RB 19613 5811 56 yet yet RB 19613 5811 57 become become VBN 19613 5811 58 the the DT 19613 5811 59 predominating predominate VBG 19613 5811 60 one one NN 19613 5811 61 even even RB 19613 5811 62 in in IN 19613 5811 63 the the DT 19613 5811 64 third third JJ 19613 5811 65 century century NN 19613 5811 66 , , , 19613 5811 67 nor nor CC 19613 5811 68 was be VBD 19613 5811 69 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5811 70 consistently consistently RB 19613 5811 71 carried carry VBN 19613 5811 72 out out RP 19613 5811 73 by by IN 19613 5811 74 any any DT 19613 5811 75 one one CD 19613 5811 76 teacher teacher NN 19613 5811 77 . . . 19613 5812 1 The the DT 19613 5812 2 two two CD 19613 5812 3 conceptions conception NNS 19613 5812 4 opposed oppose VBN 19613 5812 5 to to IN 19613 5812 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5812 7 , , , 19613 5812 8 that that DT 19613 5812 9 of of IN 19613 5812 10 the the DT 19613 5812 11 early early JJ 19613 5812 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 5812 13 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 5812 14 and and CC 19613 5812 15 the the DT 19613 5812 16 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 19613 5812 17 one one NN 19613 5812 18 , , , 19613 5812 19 were be VBD 19613 5812 20 still still RB 19613 5812 21 in in IN 19613 5812 22 vogue vogue NN 19613 5812 23 . . . 19613 5813 1 The the DT 19613 5813 2 two two CD 19613 5813 3 latter latter JJ 19613 5813 4 were be VBD 19613 5813 5 closely closely RB 19613 5813 6 connected connect VBN 19613 5813 7 in in IN 19613 5813 8 the the DT 19613 5813 9 third third JJ 19613 5813 10 century century NN 19613 5813 11 , , , 19613 5813 12 especially especially RB 19613 5813 13 in in IN 19613 5813 14 the the DT 19613 5813 15 West West NNP 19613 5813 16 , , , 19613 5813 17 whilst whilst IN 19613 5813 18 the the DT 19613 5813 19 mystic mystic JJ 19613 5813 20 and and CC 19613 5813 21 realistic realistic JJ 19613 5813 22 view view NN 19613 5813 23 was be VBD 19613 5813 24 almost almost RB 19613 5813 25 completely completely RB 19613 5813 26 lacking lack VBG 19613 5813 27 there there RB 19613 5813 28 . . . 19613 5814 1 In in IN 19613 5814 2 this this DT 19613 5814 3 respect respect NN 19613 5814 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5814 5 adopted adopt VBD 19613 5814 6 but but CC 19613 5814 7 little little JJ 19613 5814 8 from from IN 19613 5814 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5814 10 . . . 19613 5815 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5815 2 also also RB 19613 5815 3 lagged lag VBD 19613 5815 4 behind behind IN 19613 5815 5 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5815 6 . . . 19613 5816 1 Teachers teacher NNS 19613 5816 2 like like IN 19613 5816 3 Commodian Commodian NNP 19613 5816 4 , , , 19613 5816 5 Arnobius Arnobius NNP 19613 5816 6 , , , 19613 5816 7 and and CC 19613 5816 8 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 19613 5816 9 , , , 19613 5816 10 however however RB 19613 5816 11 , , , 19613 5816 12 wrote write VBD 19613 5816 13 as as IN 19613 5816 14 if if IN 19613 5816 15 there there EX 19613 5816 16 had have VBD 19613 5816 17 been be VBN 19613 5816 18 no no DT 19613 5816 19 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5816 20 movement movement NN 19613 5816 21 at at RB 19613 5816 22 all all RB 19613 5816 23 , , , 19613 5816 24 and and CC 19613 5816 25 as as IN 19613 5816 26 if if IN 19613 5816 27 no no DT 19613 5816 28 Antignostic Antignostic NNP 19613 5816 29 Church Church NNP 19613 5816 30 theology theology NN 19613 5816 31 existed exist VBD 19613 5816 32 . . . 19613 5817 1 The the DT 19613 5817 2 immediate immediate JJ 19613 5817 3 result result NN 19613 5817 4 of of IN 19613 5817 5 the the DT 19613 5817 6 work work NN 19613 5817 7 carried carry VBN 19613 5817 8 on on RP 19613 5817 9 by by IN 19613 5817 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5817 11 and and CC 19613 5817 12 the the DT 19613 5817 13 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 5817 14 teachers teacher NNS 19613 5817 15 in in IN 19613 5817 16 the the DT 19613 5817 17 Church Church NNP 19613 5817 18 consisted consist VBD 19613 5817 19 in in IN 19613 5817 20 the the DT 19613 5817 21 fixing fixing NN 19613 5817 22 of of IN 19613 5817 23 tradition tradition NN 19613 5817 24 and and CC 19613 5817 25 in in IN 19613 5817 26 the the DT 19613 5817 27 intelligent intelligent JJ 19613 5817 28 treatment treatment NN 19613 5817 29 of of IN 19613 5817 30 individual individual JJ 19613 5817 31 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 5817 32 , , , 19613 5817 33 which which WDT 19613 5817 34 gradually gradually RB 19613 5817 35 became become VBD 19613 5817 36 established establish VBN 19613 5817 37 . . . 19613 5818 1 The the DT 19613 5818 2 most most RBS 19613 5818 3 important important JJ 19613 5818 4 will will MD 19613 5818 5 be be VB 19613 5818 6 set set VBN 19613 5818 7 forth forth RP 19613 5818 8 in in IN 19613 5818 9 what what WP 19613 5818 10 follows follow VBZ 19613 5818 11 . . . 19613 5819 1 On on IN 19613 5819 2 the the DT 19613 5819 3 most most RBS 19613 5819 4 vital vital JJ 19613 5819 5 point point NN 19613 5819 6 , , , 19613 5819 7 the the DT 19613 5819 8 introduction introduction NN 19613 5819 9 of of IN 19613 5819 10 the the DT 19613 5819 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5819 12 Christology Christology NNP 19613 5819 13 into into IN 19613 5819 14 the the DT 19613 5819 15 Church Church NNP 19613 5819 16 's 's POS 19613 5819 17 rule rule NN 19613 5819 18 of of IN 19613 5819 19 faith faith NN 19613 5819 20 , , , 19613 5819 21 see see VB 19613 5819 22 Chapter Chapter NNP 19613 5819 23 7 7 CD 19613 5819 24 . . . 19613 5820 1 The the DT 19613 5820 2 manner manner NN 19613 5820 3 in in IN 19613 5820 4 which which WDT 19613 5820 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5820 6 undertook undertake VBD 19613 5820 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5820 8 great great JJ 19613 5820 9 task task NN 19613 5820 10 of of IN 19613 5820 11 expounding expound VBG 19613 5820 12 and and CC 19613 5820 13 defending defend VBG 19613 5820 14 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 5820 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5820 16 in in IN 19613 5820 17 opposition opposition NN 19613 5820 18 to to IN 19613 5820 19 the the DT 19613 5820 20 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5820 21 form form NN 19613 5820 22 was be VBD 19613 5820 23 already already RB 19613 5820 24 a a DT 19613 5820 25 prediction prediction NN 19613 5820 26 of of IN 19613 5820 27 the the DT 19613 5820 28 future future NN 19613 5820 29 . . . 19613 5821 1 The the DT 19613 5821 2 oldest old JJS 19613 5821 3 Christian christian JJ 19613 5821 4 motives motive NNS 19613 5821 5 and and CC 19613 5821 6 hopes hope NNS 19613 5821 7 ; ; : 19613 5821 8 the the DT 19613 5821 9 letter letter NN 19613 5821 10 of of IN 19613 5821 11 both both DT 19613 5821 12 Testaments testament NNS 19613 5821 13 , , , 19613 5821 14 including include VBG 19613 5821 15 even even RB 19613 5821 16 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 5821 17 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5821 18 ; ; , 19613 5821 19 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 5821 20 and and CC 19613 5821 21 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5821 22 elements element NNS 19613 5821 23 , , , 19613 5821 24 the the DT 19613 5821 25 result result NN 19613 5821 26 of of IN 19613 5821 27 the the DT 19613 5821 28 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5821 29 ' ' POS 19613 5821 30 labours labour NNS 19613 5821 31 ; ; : 19613 5821 32 and and CC 19613 5821 33 realistic realistic JJ 19613 5821 34 and and CC 19613 5821 35 mystical mystical JJ 19613 5821 36 features feature NNS 19613 5821 37 balance balance VBP 19613 5821 38 each each DT 19613 5821 39 other other JJ 19613 5821 40 in in IN 19613 5821 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5821 42 treatment treatment NN 19613 5821 43 . . . 19613 5822 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5822 2 glides glide VBZ 19613 5822 3 over over RP 19613 5822 4 from from IN 19613 5822 5 the the DT 19613 5822 6 one one NN 19613 5822 7 to to IN 19613 5822 8 the the DT 19613 5822 9 other other JJ 19613 5822 10 ; ; : 19613 5822 11 limits limit VBZ 19613 5822 12 the the DT 19613 5822 13 one one NN 19613 5822 14 by by IN 19613 5822 15 the the DT 19613 5822 16 other other JJ 19613 5822 17 ; ; : 19613 5822 18 plays play VBZ 19613 5822 19 off off RP 19613 5822 20 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5822 21 against against IN 19613 5822 22 reason reason NN 19613 5822 23 , , , 19613 5822 24 tradition tradition NN 19613 5822 25 against against IN 19613 5822 26 the the DT 19613 5822 27 obscurity obscurity NN 19613 5822 28 of of IN 19613 5822 29 the the DT 19613 5822 30 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 5822 31 ; ; : 19613 5822 32 and and CC 19613 5822 33 combats combat VBZ 19613 5822 34 fantastic fantastic JJ 19613 5822 35 speculation speculation NN 19613 5822 36 by by IN 19613 5822 37 an an DT 19613 5822 38 appeal appeal NN 19613 5822 39 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 5822 40 to to IN 19613 5822 41 reason reason NN 19613 5822 42 , , , 19613 5822 43 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 5822 44 to to IN 19613 5822 45 the the DT 19613 5822 46 limits limit NNS 19613 5822 47 of of IN 19613 5822 48 human human JJ 19613 5822 49 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5822 50 . . . 19613 5823 1 Behind behind IN 19613 5823 2 all all PDT 19613 5823 3 this this DT 19613 5823 4 and and CC 19613 5823 5 dominating dominate VBG 19613 5823 6 everything everything NN 19613 5823 7 , , , 19613 5823 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5823 9 find find VBP 19613 5823 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5823 11 firm firm JJ 19613 5823 12 belief belief NN 19613 5823 13 in in IN 19613 5823 14 the the DT 19613 5823 15 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 5823 16 of of IN 19613 5823 17 divine divine JJ 19613 5823 18 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 5823 19 on on IN 19613 5823 20 believers believer NNS 19613 5823 21 through through IN 19613 5823 22 the the DT 19613 5823 23 work work NN 19613 5823 24 of of IN 19613 5823 25 the the DT 19613 5823 26 God God NNP 19613 5823 27 - - HYPH 19613 5823 28 man man NNP 19613 5823 29 . . . 19613 5824 1 This this DT 19613 5824 2 eclectic eclectic JJ 19613 5824 3 method method NN 19613 5824 4 did do VBD 19613 5824 5 not not RB 19613 5824 6 arise arise VB 19613 5824 7 from from IN 19613 5824 8 shrewd shrewd JJ 19613 5824 9 calculation calculation NN 19613 5824 10 . . . 19613 5825 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5825 2 was be VBD 19613 5825 3 equally equally RB 19613 5825 4 the the DT 19613 5825 5 result result NN 19613 5825 6 of of IN 19613 5825 7 a a DT 19613 5825 8 rare rare JJ 19613 5825 9 capacity capacity NN 19613 5825 10 for for IN 19613 5825 11 appropriating appropriate VBG 19613 5825 12 the the DT 19613 5825 13 feelings feeling NNS 19613 5825 14 and and CC 19613 5825 15 ideas idea NNS 19613 5825 16 of of IN 19613 5825 17 others other NNS 19613 5825 18 , , , 19613 5825 19 combined combine VBN 19613 5825 20 with with IN 19613 5825 21 the the DT 19613 5825 22 conservative conservative JJ 19613 5825 23 instincts instinct NNS 19613 5825 24 that that WDT 19613 5825 25 guided guide VBD 19613 5825 26 the the DT 19613 5825 27 great great JJ 19613 5825 28 teacher teacher NN 19613 5825 29 , , , 19613 5825 30 and and CC 19613 5825 31 the the DT 19613 5825 32 consequence consequence NN 19613 5825 33 of of IN 19613 5825 34 a a DT 19613 5825 35 happy happy JJ 19613 5825 36 blindness blindness NN 19613 5825 37 to to IN 19613 5825 38 the the DT 19613 5825 39 gulf gulf NNP 19613 5825 40 which which WDT 19613 5825 41 lay lie VBD 19613 5825 42 between between IN 19613 5825 43 the the DT 19613 5825 44 Christian christian JJ 19613 5825 45 tradition tradition NN 19613 5825 46 and and CC 19613 5825 47 the the DT 19613 5825 48 world world NN 19613 5825 49 of of IN 19613 5825 50 ideas idea NNS 19613 5825 51 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 5825 52 at at IN 19613 5825 53 that that DT 19613 5825 54 time time NN 19613 5825 55 . . . 19613 5826 1 Still still RB 19613 5826 2 unconscious unconscious JJ 19613 5826 3 of of IN 19613 5826 4 the the DT 19613 5826 5 greatest great JJS 19613 5826 6 problem problem NN 19613 5826 7 , , , 19613 5826 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5826 9 with with IN 19613 5826 10 inward inward JJ 19613 5826 11 sincerity sincerity NN 19613 5826 12 sketched sketch VBD 19613 5826 13 out out RP 19613 5826 14 that that IN 19613 5826 15 future future JJ 19613 5826 16 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 5826 17 method method NN 19613 5826 18 according accord VBG 19613 5826 19 to to IN 19613 5826 20 which which WDT 19613 5826 21 the the DT 19613 5826 22 theology theology NN 19613 5826 23 compiled compile VBN 19613 5826 24 by by IN 19613 5826 25 an an DT 19613 5826 26 eclectic eclectic JJ 19613 5826 27 process process NN 19613 5826 28 is be VBZ 19613 5826 29 to to TO 19613 5826 30 be be VB 19613 5826 31 nothing nothing NN 19613 5826 32 else else RB 19613 5826 33 than than IN 19613 5826 34 the the DT 19613 5826 35 simple simple JJ 19613 5826 36 faith faith NN 19613 5826 37 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5826 38 , , , 19613 5826 39 this this DT 19613 5826 40 being be VBG 19613 5826 41 merely merely RB 19613 5826 42 illustrated illustrate VBN 19613 5826 43 and and CC 19613 5826 44 explained explain VBD 19613 5826 45 , , , 19613 5826 46 developed develop VBN 19613 5826 47 and and CC 19613 5826 48 by by IN 19613 5826 49 that that DT 19613 5826 50 very very JJ 19613 5826 51 process process NN 19613 5826 52 established establish VBN 19613 5826 53 , , , 19613 5826 54 as as RB 19613 5826 55 far far RB 19613 5826 56 as as IN 19613 5826 57 " " `` 19613 5826 58 stands stand VBZ 19613 5826 59 in in IN 19613 5826 60 the the DT 19613 5826 61 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5826 62 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 5826 63 , , , 19613 5826 64 " " '' 19613 5826 65 and and CC 19613 5826 66 -- -- : 19613 5826 67 let let VB 19613 5826 68 us -PRON- PRP 19613 5826 69 add add VB 19613 5826 70 -- -- : 19613 5826 71 as as RB 19613 5826 72 far far RB 19613 5826 73 as as IN 19613 5826 74 reason reason NN 19613 5826 75 requires require VBZ 19613 5826 76 . . . 19613 5827 1 But but CC 19613 5827 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5827 3 was be VBD 19613 5827 4 already already RB 19613 5827 5 obliged oblige VBN 19613 5827 6 to to TO 19613 5827 7 decline decline VB 19613 5827 8 answering answer VBG 19613 5827 9 the the DT 19613 5827 10 question question NN 19613 5827 11 as as IN 19613 5827 12 to to IN 19613 5827 13 how how WRB 19613 5827 14 far far RB 19613 5827 15 unexplained unexplained JJ 19613 5827 16 faith faith NN 19613 5827 17 can can MD 19613 5827 18 be be VB 19613 5827 19 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 5827 20 for for IN 19613 5827 21 most most JJS 19613 5827 22 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 5827 23 , , , 19613 5827 24 though though IN 19613 5827 25 nothing nothing NN 19613 5827 26 but but IN 19613 5827 27 this this DT 19613 5827 28 explanation explanation NN 19613 5827 29 can can MD 19613 5827 30 solve solve VB 19613 5827 31 the the DT 19613 5827 32 great great JJ 19613 5827 33 problems problem NNS 19613 5827 34 , , , 19613 5827 35 " " '' 19613 5827 36 why why WRB 19613 5827 37 more more JJR 19613 5827 38 covenants covenant NNS 19613 5827 39 than than IN 19613 5827 40 one one CD 19613 5827 41 were be VBD 19613 5827 42 given give VBN 19613 5827 43 to to IN 19613 5827 44 mankind mankind NN 19613 5827 45 , , , 19613 5827 46 what what WP 19613 5827 47 was be VBD 19613 5827 48 the the DT 19613 5827 49 character character NN 19613 5827 50 of of IN 19613 5827 51 each each DT 19613 5827 52 covenant covenant NN 19613 5827 53 , , , 19613 5827 54 why why WRB 19613 5827 55 God God NNP 19613 5827 56 shut shut VBD 19613 5827 57 up up RP 19613 5827 58 every every DT 19613 5827 59 man man NN 19613 5827 60 unto unto IN 19613 5827 61 unbelief unbelief NN 19613 5827 62 , , , 19613 5827 63 why why WRB 19613 5827 64 the the DT 19613 5827 65 Word Word NNP 19613 5827 66 became become VBD 19613 5827 67 flesh flesh NN 19613 5827 68 and and CC 19613 5827 69 suffered suffer VBD 19613 5827 70 , , , 19613 5827 71 why why WRB 19613 5827 72 the the DT 19613 5827 73 advent advent NN 19613 5827 74 of of IN 19613 5827 75 the the DT 19613 5827 76 Son Son NNP 19613 5827 77 of of IN 19613 5827 78 God God NNP 19613 5827 79 only only RB 19613 5827 80 took take VBD 19613 5827 81 place place NN 19613 5827 82 in in IN 19613 5827 83 the the DT 19613 5827 84 last last JJ 19613 5827 85 times time NNS 19613 5827 86 etc etc FW 19613 5827 87 . . . 19613 5827 88 " " '' 19613 5828 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5828 2 I. I. NNP 19613 5829 1 10 10 CD 19613 5829 2 . . . 19613 5830 1 3 3 LS 19613 5830 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5830 3 . . . 19613 5831 1 The the DT 19613 5831 2 relation relation NN 19613 5831 3 of of IN 19613 5831 4 faith faith NN 19613 5831 5 and and CC 19613 5831 6 theological theological JJ 19613 5831 7 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 5831 8 was be VBD 19613 5831 9 fixed fix VBN 19613 5831 10 by by IN 19613 5831 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5831 12 to to IN 19613 5831 13 the the DT 19613 5831 14 effect effect NN 19613 5831 15 that that WDT 19613 5831 16 the the DT 19613 5831 17 latter latter NN 19613 5831 18 is be VBZ 19613 5831 19 simply simply RB 19613 5831 20 a a DT 19613 5831 21 continuation continuation NN 19613 5831 22 of of IN 19613 5831 23 the the DT 19613 5831 24 former former JJ 19613 5831 25 . . . 19613 5832 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5832 2 495 495 CD 19613 5832 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5832 4 At at IN 19613 5832 5 the the DT 19613 5832 6 same same JJ 19613 5832 7 time time NN 19613 5832 8 , , , 19613 5832 9 however however RB 19613 5832 10 , , , 19613 5832 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5832 12 did do VBD 19613 5832 13 not not RB 19613 5832 14 clearly clearly RB 19613 5832 15 show show VB 19613 5832 16 how how WRB 19613 5832 17 the the DT 19613 5832 18 collection collection NN 19613 5832 19 of of IN 19613 5832 20 historical historical JJ 19613 5832 21 statements statement NNS 19613 5832 22 found find VBN 19613 5832 23 in in IN 19613 5832 24 the the DT 19613 5832 25 confession confession NN 19613 5832 26 can can MD 19613 5832 27 of of IN 19613 5832 28 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5832 29 guarantee guarantee VB 19613 5832 30 a a DT 19613 5832 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 5832 32 and and CC 19613 5832 33 tenable tenable JJ 19613 5832 34 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5832 35 of of IN 19613 5832 36 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5832 37 . . . 19613 5833 1 Here here RB 19613 5833 2 the the DT 19613 5833 3 speculative speculative JJ 19613 5833 4 theories theory NNS 19613 5833 5 are be VBP 19613 5833 6 as as IN 19613 5833 7 a a DT 19613 5833 8 matter matter NN 19613 5833 9 of of IN 19613 5833 10 fact fact NN 19613 5833 11 quite quite RB 19613 5833 12 imbedded imbed VBN 19613 5833 13 in in IN 19613 5833 14 the the DT 19613 5833 15 historical historical JJ 19613 5833 16 propositions proposition NNS 19613 5833 17 of of IN 19613 5833 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 5833 19 . . . 19613 5834 1 Will Will MD 19613 5834 2 these these DT 19613 5834 3 obscurities obscurity NNS 19613 5834 4 remain remain VB 19613 5834 5 when when WRB 19613 5834 6 once once RB 19613 5834 7 the the DT 19613 5834 8 Church Church NNP 19613 5834 9 is be VBZ 19613 5834 10 forced force VBN 19613 5834 11 to to TO 19613 5834 12 compete compete VB 19613 5834 13 in in IN 19613 5834 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5834 15 theological theological JJ 19613 5834 16 system system NN 19613 5834 17 with with IN 19613 5834 18 the the DT 19613 5834 19 whole whole JJ 19613 5834 20 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5834 21 science science NN 19613 5834 22 of of IN 19613 5834 23 the the DT 19613 5834 24 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 5834 25 , , , 19613 5834 26 or or CC 19613 5834 27 may may MD 19613 5834 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5834 29 be be VB 19613 5834 30 expected expect VBN 19613 5834 31 that that IN 19613 5834 32 , , , 19613 5834 33 instead instead RB 19613 5834 34 of of IN 19613 5834 35 this this DT 19613 5834 36 system system NN 19613 5834 37 of of IN 19613 5834 38 eclecticism eclecticism NN 19613 5834 39 and and CC 19613 5834 40 compromise compromise NN 19613 5834 41 , , , 19613 5834 42 a a DT 19613 5834 43 method method NN 19613 5834 44 will will MD 19613 5834 45 find find VB 19613 5834 46 acceptance acceptance NN 19613 5834 47 which which WDT 19613 5834 48 , , , 19613 5834 49 distinguishing distinguish VBG 19613 5834 50 between between IN 19613 5834 51 faith faith NN 19613 5834 52 and and CC 19613 5834 53 theology theology NN 19613 5834 54 , , , 19613 5834 55 will will MD 19613 5834 56 interpret interpret VB 19613 5834 57 in in IN 19613 5834 58 a a DT 19613 5834 59 new new JJ 19613 5834 60 and and CC 19613 5834 61 speculative speculative JJ 19613 5834 62 sense sense NN 19613 5834 63 the the DT 19613 5834 64 whole whole JJ 19613 5834 65 complex complex NN 19613 5834 66 of of IN 19613 5834 67 tradition tradition NN 19613 5834 68 ? ? . 19613 5835 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5835 2 ' ' POS 19613 5835 3 process process NN 19613 5835 4 has have VBZ 19613 5835 5 at at IN 19613 5835 6 least least JJS 19613 5835 7 this this DT 19613 5835 8 one one CD 19613 5835 9 advantage advantage NN 19613 5835 10 over over IN 19613 5835 11 the the DT 19613 5835 12 other other JJ 19613 5835 13 method method NN 19613 5835 14 : : : 19613 5835 15 according accord VBG 19613 5835 16 to to IN 19613 5835 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5835 18 everything everything NN 19613 5835 19 can can MD 19613 5835 20 be be VB 19613 5835 21 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 5835 22 part part NN 19613 5835 23 of of IN 19613 5835 24 the the DT 19613 5835 25 faith faith NN 19613 5835 26 , , , 19613 5835 27 providing provide VBG 19613 5835 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5835 29 bears bear VBZ 19613 5835 30 the the DT 19613 5835 31 stamp stamp NN 19613 5835 32 of of IN 19613 5835 33 truth truth NN 19613 5835 34 , , , 19613 5835 35 without without IN 19613 5835 36 the the DT 19613 5835 37 faith faith NN 19613 5835 38 seeming seem VBG 19613 5835 39 to to TO 19613 5835 40 alter alter VB 19613 5835 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5835 42 nature nature NN 19613 5835 43 . . . 19613 5836 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5836 2 is be VBZ 19613 5836 3 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 5836 4 in in IN 19613 5836 5 the the DT 19613 5836 6 theology theology NN 19613 5836 7 of of IN 19613 5836 8 facts fact NNS 19613 5836 9 which which WDT 19613 5836 10 the the DT 19613 5836 11 faith faith NN 19613 5836 12 here here RB 19613 5836 13 appears appear VBZ 19613 5836 14 to to TO 19613 5836 15 be be VB 19613 5836 16 . . . 19613 5837 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5837 2 496 496 CD 19613 5837 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5837 4 The the DT 19613 5837 5 latter latter JJ 19613 5837 6 , , , 19613 5837 7 however however RB 19613 5837 8 , , , 19613 5837 9 imperceptibly imperceptibly RB 19613 5837 10 becomes become VBZ 19613 5837 11 a a DT 19613 5837 12 revealed revealed JJ 19613 5837 13 system system NN 19613 5837 14 of of IN 19613 5837 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5837 16 and and CC 19613 5837 17 history history NN 19613 5837 18 ; ; , 19613 5837 19 and and CC 19613 5837 20 though though IN 19613 5837 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5837 22 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5837 23 always always RB 19613 5837 24 seeks seek VBZ 19613 5837 25 to to TO 19613 5837 26 refer refer VB 19613 5837 27 everything everything NN 19613 5837 28 again again RB 19613 5837 29 to to IN 19613 5837 30 the the DT 19613 5837 31 " " `` 19613 5837 32 simple simple JJ 19613 5837 33 faith faith NN 19613 5837 34 " " '' 19613 5837 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5837 36 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5837 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5837 38 : : : 19613 5837 39 philê philê NNP 19613 5837 40 pistis pistis NN 19613 5837 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5837 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5837 43 , , , 19613 5837 44 and and CC 19613 5837 45 to to IN 19613 5837 46 believing believe VBG 19613 5837 47 simplicity simplicity NN 19613 5837 48 , , , 19613 5837 49 that that RB 19613 5837 50 is is RB 19613 5837 51 , , , 19613 5837 52 to to IN 19613 5837 53 the the DT 19613 5837 54 belief belief NN 19613 5837 55 in in IN 19613 5837 56 the the DT 19613 5837 57 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5837 58 and and CC 19613 5837 59 the the DT 19613 5837 60 Son Son NNP 19613 5837 61 of of IN 19613 5837 62 God God NNP 19613 5837 63 who who WP 19613 5837 64 became become VBD 19613 5837 65 man man NN 19613 5837 66 , , , 19613 5837 67 yet yet CC 19613 5837 68 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5837 69 was be VBD 19613 5837 70 not not RB 19613 5837 71 in in IN 19613 5837 72 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5837 73 power power NN 19613 5837 74 to to TO 19613 5837 75 stop stop VB 19613 5837 76 the the DT 19613 5837 77 development development NN 19613 5837 78 destined destine VBN 19613 5837 79 to to TO 19613 5837 80 transform transform VB 19613 5837 81 the the DT 19613 5837 82 faith faith NN 19613 5837 83 into into IN 19613 5837 84 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5837 85 of of IN 19613 5837 86 a a DT 19613 5837 87 theological theological JJ 19613 5837 88 system system NN 19613 5837 89 . . . 19613 5838 1 The the DT 19613 5838 2 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 5838 3 hellenising hellenising NN 19613 5838 4 of of IN 19613 5838 5 the the DT 19613 5838 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 5838 7 , , , 19613 5838 8 brought bring VBN 19613 5838 9 about about RP 19613 5838 10 by by IN 19613 5838 11 the the DT 19613 5838 12 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5838 13 systems system NNS 19613 5838 14 , , , 19613 5838 15 was be VBD 19613 5838 16 averted avert VBN 19613 5838 17 by by IN 19613 5838 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5838 19 and and CC 19613 5838 20 the the DT 19613 5838 21 later later JJ 19613 5838 22 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5838 23 teachers teacher NNS 19613 5838 24 by by IN 19613 5838 25 preserving preserve VBG 19613 5838 26 a a DT 19613 5838 27 great great JJ 19613 5838 28 portion portion NN 19613 5838 29 of of IN 19613 5838 30 the the DT 19613 5838 31 early early JJ 19613 5838 32 Christian christian JJ 19613 5838 33 tradition tradition NN 19613 5838 34 , , , 19613 5838 35 partly partly RB 19613 5838 36 as as IN 19613 5838 37 regards regard VBZ 19613 5838 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5838 39 letter letter NN 19613 5838 40 , , , 19613 5838 41 partly partly RB 19613 5838 42 as as IN 19613 5838 43 regards regard VBZ 19613 5838 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5838 45 spirit spirit NN 19613 5838 46 , , , 19613 5838 47 and and CC 19613 5838 48 thus thus RB 19613 5838 49 rescuing rescue VBG 19613 5838 50 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5838 51 for for IN 19613 5838 52 the the DT 19613 5838 53 future future NN 19613 5838 54 . . . 19613 5839 1 But but CC 19613 5839 2 the the DT 19613 5839 3 price price NN 19613 5839 4 of of IN 19613 5839 5 this this DT 19613 5839 6 preservation preservation NN 19613 5839 7 was be VBD 19613 5839 8 the the DT 19613 5839 9 adoption adoption NN 19613 5839 10 of of IN 19613 5839 11 a a DT 19613 5839 12 series series NN 19613 5839 13 of of IN 19613 5839 14 " " `` 19613 5839 15 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5839 16 " " '' 19613 5839 17 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5839 18 . . . 19613 5840 1 Churchmen churchman NNS 19613 5840 2 , , , 19613 5840 3 though though RB 19613 5840 4 with with IN 19613 5840 5 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 5840 6 , , , 19613 5840 7 adopted adopt VBD 19613 5840 8 the the DT 19613 5840 9 adversary adversary NN 19613 5840 10 's 's POS 19613 5840 11 way way NN 19613 5840 12 of of IN 19613 5840 13 looking look VBG 19613 5840 14 at at IN 19613 5840 15 things thing NNS 19613 5840 16 , , , 19613 5840 17 and and CC 19613 5840 18 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5840 19 did do VBD 19613 5840 20 so so RB 19613 5840 21 , , , 19613 5840 22 because because IN 19613 5840 23 as as IN 19613 5840 24 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5840 25 became become VBD 19613 5840 26 ever ever RB 19613 5840 27 further far RBR 19613 5840 28 and and CC 19613 5840 29 further further RB 19613 5840 30 removed remove VBN 19613 5840 31 from from IN 19613 5840 32 the the DT 19613 5840 33 early early JJ 19613 5840 34 - - HYPH 19613 5840 35 Christian christian JJ 19613 5840 36 feelings feeling NNS 19613 5840 37 and and CC 19613 5840 38 thoughts thought NNS 19613 5840 39 , , , 19613 5840 40 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5840 41 had have VBD 19613 5840 42 always always RB 19613 5840 43 more more RBR 19613 5840 44 and and CC 19613 5840 45 more more RBR 19613 5840 46 lost lose VBN 19613 5840 47 every every DT 19613 5840 48 other other JJ 19613 5840 49 point point NN 19613 5840 50 of of IN 19613 5840 51 view view NN 19613 5840 52 . . . 19613 5841 1 The the DT 19613 5841 2 old old JJ 19613 5841 3 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 5841 4 Fathers father NNS 19613 5841 5 permanently permanently RB 19613 5841 6 settled settle VBD 19613 5841 7 a a DT 19613 5841 8 great great JJ 19613 5841 9 part part NN 19613 5841 10 of of IN 19613 5841 11 early early JJ 19613 5841 12 tradition tradition NN 19613 5841 13 for for IN 19613 5841 14 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 5841 15 , , , 19613 5841 16 but but CC 19613 5841 17 at at IN 19613 5841 18 the the DT 19613 5841 19 same same JJ 19613 5841 20 time time NN 19613 5841 21 promoted promote VBD 19613 5841 22 the the DT 19613 5841 23 gradual gradual JJ 19613 5841 24 hellenising hellenising NN 19613 5841 25 of of IN 19613 5841 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5841 27 . . . 19613 5842 1 2 2 LS 19613 5842 2 . . . 19613 5843 1 _ _ NNP 19613 5843 2 The the DT 19613 5843 3 Doctrines Doctrines NNPS 19613 5843 4 of of IN 19613 5843 5 the the DT 19613 5843 6 Church Church NNP 19613 5843 7 . . . 19613 5843 8 _ _ NNP 19613 5843 9 In in IN 19613 5843 10 the the DT 19613 5843 11 following following JJ 19613 5843 12 section section NN 19613 5843 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5843 14 do do VBP 19613 5843 15 not not RB 19613 5843 16 intend intend VB 19613 5843 17 to to TO 19613 5843 18 give give VB 19613 5843 19 a a DT 19613 5843 20 presentation presentation NN 19613 5843 21 of of IN 19613 5843 22 the the DT 19613 5843 23 theology theology NN 19613 5843 24 of of IN 19613 5843 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5843 26 and and CC 19613 5843 27 the the DT 19613 5843 28 other other JJ 19613 5843 29 Antignostic Antignostic NNP 19613 5843 30 Church Church NNP 19613 5843 31 teachers teacher NNS 19613 5843 32 , , , 19613 5843 33 but but CC 19613 5843 34 merely merely RB 19613 5843 35 to to TO 19613 5843 36 set set VB 19613 5843 37 forth forth RP 19613 5843 38 those those DT 19613 5843 39 points point NNS 19613 5843 40 of of IN 19613 5843 41 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5843 42 to to TO 19613 5843 43 which which WDT 19613 5843 44 the the DT 19613 5843 45 teachings teaching NNS 19613 5843 46 of of IN 19613 5843 47 these these DT 19613 5843 48 men man NNS 19613 5843 49 gave give VBD 19613 5843 50 currency currency NN 19613 5843 51 in in IN 19613 5843 52 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 5843 53 times time NNS 19613 5843 54 . . . 19613 5844 1 Against against IN 19613 5844 2 the the DT 19613 5844 3 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5844 4 theses[497 theses[497 NN 19613 5844 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5844 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5844 7 and and CC 19613 5844 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5844 9 successors successor NNS 19613 5844 10 , , , 19613 5844 11 apart apart RB 19613 5844 12 from from IN 19613 5844 13 the the DT 19613 5844 14 proof proof NN 19613 5844 15 from from IN 19613 5844 16 prescription prescription NN 19613 5844 17 , , , 19613 5844 18 adduced adduce VBD 19613 5844 19 the the DT 19613 5844 20 following follow VBG 19613 5844 21 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 19613 5844 22 considerations consideration NNS 19613 5844 23 : : : 19613 5844 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5844 25 1 1 LS 19613 5844 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5844 27 In in IN 19613 5844 28 the the DT 19613 5844 29 case case NN 19613 5844 30 of of IN 19613 5844 31 the the DT 19613 5844 32 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5844 33 and and CC 19613 5844 34 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5844 35 the the DT 19613 5844 36 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5844 37 lacks lack VBZ 19613 5844 38 absoluteness absoluteness JJ 19613 5844 39 , , , 19613 5844 40 because because IN 19613 5844 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5844 42 does do VBZ 19613 5844 43 not not RB 19613 5844 44 embrace embrace VB 19613 5844 45 everything everything NN 19613 5844 46 , , , 19613 5844 47 that that RB 19613 5844 48 is is RB 19613 5844 49 , , , 19613 5844 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5844 51 is be VBZ 19613 5844 52 bounded bound VBN 19613 5844 53 by by IN 19613 5844 54 the the DT 19613 5844 55 _ _ NNP 19613 5844 56 kenoma kenoma NN 19613 5844 57 _ _ NNP 19613 5844 58 or or CC 19613 5844 59 by by IN 19613 5844 60 the the DT 19613 5844 61 sphere sphere NN 19613 5844 62 of of IN 19613 5844 63 a a DT 19613 5844 64 second second JJ 19613 5844 65 God God NNP 19613 5844 66 ; ; : 19613 5844 67 and and CC 19613 5844 68 also also RB 19613 5844 69 because because IN 19613 5844 70 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5844 71 omnipresence omnipresence NN 19613 5844 72 , , , 19613 5844 73 omniscience omniscience NN 19613 5844 74 , , , 19613 5844 75 and and CC 19613 5844 76 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 5844 77 have have VB 19613 5844 78 a a DT 19613 5844 79 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 5844 80 limitation limitation NN 19613 5844 81 . . . 19613 5845 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5845 2 498 498 CD 19613 5845 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5845 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5845 5 2 2 LS 19613 5845 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5845 7 The the DT 19613 5845 8 assumption assumption NN 19613 5845 9 of of IN 19613 5845 10 divine divine JJ 19613 5845 11 emanations emanation NNS 19613 5845 12 and and CC 19613 5845 13 of of IN 19613 5845 14 a a DT 19613 5845 15 differentiated differentiated JJ 19613 5845 16 divine divine JJ 19613 5845 17 _ _ NNP 19613 5845 18 pleroma pleroma NN 19613 5845 19 _ _ NNP 19613 5845 20 represents represent VBZ 19613 5845 21 the the DT 19613 5845 22 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5845 23 as as IN 19613 5845 24 a a DT 19613 5845 25 composite composite JJ 19613 5845 26 , , , 19613 5845 27 i.e i.e NNP 19613 5845 28 . . NNP 19613 5845 29 ,[499 ,[499 , 19613 5845 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5845 31 finite finite JJ 19613 5845 32 being being NN 19613 5845 33 ; ; : 19613 5845 34 and and CC 19613 5845 35 , , , 19613 5845 36 moreover moreover RB 19613 5845 37 , , , 19613 5845 38 the the DT 19613 5845 39 personification personification NN 19613 5845 40 of of IN 19613 5845 41 the the DT 19613 5845 42 divine divine JJ 19613 5845 43 qualities quality NNS 19613 5845 44 is be VBZ 19613 5845 45 a a DT 19613 5845 46 mythological mythological JJ 19613 5845 47 freak freak NN 19613 5845 48 , , , 19613 5845 49 the the DT 19613 5845 50 folly folly NN 19613 5845 51 of of IN 19613 5845 52 which which WDT 19613 5845 53 is be VBZ 19613 5845 54 evident evident JJ 19613 5845 55 as as RB 19613 5845 56 soon soon RB 19613 5845 57 as as IN 19613 5845 58 one one CD 19613 5845 59 also also RB 19613 5845 60 makes make VBZ 19613 5845 61 the the DT 19613 5845 62 attempt attempt NN 19613 5845 63 to to TO 19613 5845 64 personify personify VB 19613 5845 65 the the DT 19613 5845 66 affections affection NNS 19613 5845 67 and and CC 19613 5845 68 qualities quality NNS 19613 5845 69 of of IN 19613 5845 70 man man NN 19613 5845 71 in in IN 19613 5845 72 a a DT 19613 5845 73 similar similar JJ 19613 5845 74 way way NN 19613 5845 75 . . . 19613 5846 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5846 2 500 500 CD 19613 5846 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5846 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5846 5 3 3 LS 19613 5846 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5846 7 The the DT 19613 5846 8 attempt attempt NN 19613 5846 9 to to TO 19613 5846 10 make make VB 19613 5846 11 out out RP 19613 5846 12 conditions condition NNS 19613 5846 13 existing exist VBG 19613 5846 14 within within IN 19613 5846 15 the the DT 19613 5846 16 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5846 17 is be VBZ 19613 5846 18 in in IN 19613 5846 19 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5846 20 absurd absurd JJ 19613 5846 21 and and CC 19613 5846 22 audacious audacious JJ 19613 5846 23 . . . 19613 5847 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5847 2 501 501 CD 19613 5847 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5847 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5847 5 4 4 LS 19613 5847 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5847 7 The the DT 19613 5847 8 theory theory NN 19613 5847 9 of of IN 19613 5847 10 the the DT 19613 5847 11 passion passion NN 19613 5847 12 and and CC 19613 5847 13 ignorance ignorance NN 19613 5847 14 of of IN 19613 5847 15 Sophia Sophia NNP 19613 5847 16 introduces introduce VBZ 19613 5847 17 sin sin NN 19613 5847 18 into into IN 19613 5847 19 the the DT 19613 5847 20 pleroma pleroma NN 19613 5847 21 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5847 22 , , , 19613 5847 23 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5847 24 , , , 19613 5847 25 into into IN 19613 5847 26 the the DT 19613 5847 27 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5847 28 . . . 19613 5848 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5848 2 502 502 CD 19613 5848 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5848 4 With with IN 19613 5848 5 this this DT 19613 5848 6 the the DT 19613 5848 7 weightiest weighty JJS 19613 5848 8 argument argument NN 19613 5848 9 against against IN 19613 5848 10 the the DT 19613 5848 11 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5848 12 cosmogony cosmogony NN 19613 5848 13 is be VBZ 19613 5848 14 already already RB 19613 5848 15 mentioned mention VBN 19613 5848 16 . . . 19613 5849 1 A a DT 19613 5849 2 further further JJ 19613 5849 3 argument argument NN 19613 5849 4 against against IN 19613 5849 5 the the DT 19613 5849 6 system system NN 19613 5849 7 is be VBZ 19613 5849 8 that that IN 19613 5849 9 the the DT 19613 5849 10 world world NN 19613 5849 11 and and CC 19613 5849 12 mankind mankind NN 19613 5849 13 would would MD 19613 5849 14 have have VB 19613 5849 15 been be VBN 19613 5849 16 incapable incapable JJ 19613 5849 17 of of IN 19613 5849 18 improvement improvement NN 19613 5849 19 , , , 19613 5849 20 if if IN 19613 5849 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5849 22 had have VBD 19613 5849 23 owed owe VBN 19613 5849 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5849 25 origin origin NN 19613 5849 26 to to TO 19613 5849 27 ignorance ignorance VB 19613 5849 28 and and CC 19613 5849 29 sin sin VB 19613 5849 30 . . . 19613 5850 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5850 2 503 503 CD 19613 5850 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5850 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5850 5 and and CC 19613 5850 6 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 5850 7 employ employ NN 19613 5850 8 lengthy lengthy JJ 19613 5850 9 arguments argument NNS 19613 5850 10 to to TO 19613 5850 11 show show VB 19613 5850 12 that that IN 19613 5850 13 a a DT 19613 5850 14 God God NNP 19613 5850 15 who who WP 19613 5850 16 has have VBZ 19613 5850 17 created create VBN 19613 5850 18 nothing nothing NN 19613 5850 19 is be VBZ 19613 5850 20 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 19613 5850 21 , , , 19613 5850 22 and and CC 19613 5850 23 that that IN 19613 5850 24 a a DT 19613 5850 25 Demiurge demiurge NN 19613 5850 26 occupying occupy VBG 19613 5850 27 a a DT 19613 5850 28 position position NN 19613 5850 29 alongside alongside IN 19613 5850 30 of of IN 19613 5850 31 or or CC 19613 5850 32 below below IN 19613 5850 33 the the DT 19613 5850 34 Supreme Supreme NNP 19613 5850 35 Being Being NNP 19613 5850 36 is be VBZ 19613 5850 37 self self NN 19613 5850 38 - - HYPH 19613 5850 39 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 5850 40 , , , 19613 5850 41 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 5850 42 as as IN 19613 5850 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5850 44 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 5850 45 appears appear VBZ 19613 5850 46 higher high JJR 19613 5850 47 than than IN 19613 5850 48 this this DT 19613 5850 49 Supreme Supreme NNP 19613 5850 50 Being Being NNP 19613 5850 51 , , , 19613 5850 52 and and CC 19613 5850 53 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 5850 54 so so RB 19613 5850 55 weak weak JJ 19613 5850 56 and and CC 19613 5850 57 limited limited JJ 19613 5850 58 that that IN 19613 5850 59 one one PRP 19613 5850 60 can can MD 19613 5850 61 no no RB 19613 5850 62 longer long RBR 19613 5850 63 look look VB 19613 5850 64 on on IN 19613 5850 65 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5850 66 as as IN 19613 5850 67 a a DT 19613 5850 68 God God NNP 19613 5850 69 . . . 19613 5851 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5851 2 504 504 CD 19613 5851 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5851 4 The the DT 19613 5851 5 Fathers father NNS 19613 5851 6 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 5851 7 argue argue VBP 19613 5851 8 on on IN 19613 5851 9 behalf behalf NN 19613 5851 10 of of IN 19613 5851 11 the the DT 19613 5851 12 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 5851 13 Demiurge Demiurge NNP 19613 5851 14 and and CC 19613 5851 15 against against IN 19613 5851 16 the the DT 19613 5851 17 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5851 18 supreme supreme NN 19613 5851 19 God God NNP 19613 5851 20 . . . 19613 5852 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5852 2 never never RB 19613 5852 3 occurs occur VBZ 19613 5852 4 to to IN 19613 5852 5 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5852 6 to to TO 19613 5852 7 proceed proceed VB 19613 5852 8 in in IN 19613 5852 9 the the DT 19613 5852 10 opposite opposite JJ 19613 5852 11 way way NN 19613 5852 12 and and CC 19613 5852 13 prove prove VB 19613 5852 14 that that IN 19613 5852 15 the the DT 19613 5852 16 supreme supreme JJ 19613 5852 17 God God NNP 19613 5852 18 may may MD 19613 5852 19 be be VB 19613 5852 20 the the DT 19613 5852 21 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5852 22 . . . 19613 5853 1 All all DT 19613 5853 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5853 3 efforts effort NNS 19613 5853 4 are be VBP 19613 5853 5 rather rather RB 19613 5853 6 directed direct VBN 19613 5853 7 to to TO 19613 5853 8 show show VB 19613 5853 9 that that IN 19613 5853 10 the the DT 19613 5853 11 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5853 12 of of IN 19613 5853 13 the the DT 19613 5853 14 world world NN 19613 5853 15 is be VBZ 19613 5853 16 the the DT 19613 5853 17 only only JJ 19613 5853 18 and and CC 19613 5853 19 supreme supreme JJ 19613 5853 20 God God NNP 19613 5853 21 , , , 19613 5853 22 and and CC 19613 5853 23 that that IN 19613 5853 24 there there EX 19613 5853 25 can can MD 19613 5853 26 be be VB 19613 5853 27 no no DT 19613 5853 28 other other JJ 19613 5853 29 above above IN 19613 5853 30 this this DT 19613 5853 31 one one NN 19613 5853 32 . . . 19613 5854 1 This this DT 19613 5854 2 attitude attitude NN 19613 5854 3 of of IN 19613 5854 4 the the DT 19613 5854 5 Fathers father NNS 19613 5854 6 is be VBZ 19613 5854 7 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 5854 8 ; ; : 19613 5854 9 for for IN 19613 5854 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5854 11 proves prove VBZ 19613 5854 12 that that IN 19613 5854 13 the the DT 19613 5854 14 apologetico apologetico JJ 19613 5854 15 - - HYPH 19613 5854 16 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5854 17 theology theology NN 19613 5854 18 was be VBD 19613 5854 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5854 20 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5854 21 assumption assumption NN 19613 5854 22 . . . 19613 5855 1 The the DT 19613 5855 2 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 5855 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5855 4 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 5855 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5855 6 supreme supreme NNP 19613 5855 7 God God NNP 19613 5855 8 is be VBZ 19613 5855 9 the the DT 19613 5855 10 God God NNP 19613 5855 11 of of IN 19613 5855 12 religion religion NN 19613 5855 13 , , , 19613 5855 14 the the DT 19613 5855 15 God God NNP 19613 5855 16 of of IN 19613 5855 17 redemption redemption NN 19613 5855 18 ; ; : 19613 5855 19 the the DT 19613 5855 20 Demiurge demiurge NN 19613 5855 21 is be VBZ 19613 5855 22 the the DT 19613 5855 23 being be VBG 19613 5855 24 required require VBN 19613 5855 25 to to TO 19613 5855 26 explain explain VB 19613 5855 27 the the DT 19613 5855 28 world world NN 19613 5855 29 . . . 19613 5856 1 The the DT 19613 5856 2 intervention intervention NN 19613 5856 3 of of IN 19613 5856 4 the the DT 19613 5856 5 Fathers father NNS 19613 5856 6 on on IN 19613 5856 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5856 8 behalf behalf NN 19613 5856 9 , , , 19613 5856 10 that that RB 19613 5856 11 is is RB 19613 5856 12 , , , 19613 5856 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5856 14 assuming assume VBG 19613 5856 15 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5856 16 as as IN 19613 5856 17 the the DT 19613 5856 18 basis basis NN 19613 5856 19 of of IN 19613 5856 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5856 21 arguments argument NNS 19613 5856 22 , , , 19613 5856 23 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 5856 24 what what WP 19613 5856 25 was be VBD 19613 5856 26 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5856 27 and and CC 19613 5856 28 what what WP 19613 5856 29 was be VBD 19613 5856 30 accidental accidental JJ 19613 5856 31 in in IN 19613 5856 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5856 33 religious religious JJ 19613 5856 34 teaching teaching NN 19613 5856 35 . . . 19613 5857 1 At at IN 19613 5857 2 the the DT 19613 5857 3 same same JJ 19613 5857 4 time time NN 19613 5857 5 , , , 19613 5857 6 however however RB 19613 5857 7 , , , 19613 5857 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5857 9 shows show VBZ 19613 5857 10 plainly plainly RB 19613 5857 11 that that IN 19613 5857 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5857 13 did do VBD 19613 5857 14 not not RB 19613 5857 15 understand understand VB 19613 5857 16 or or CC 19613 5857 17 did do VBD 19613 5857 18 not not RB 19613 5857 19 feel feel VB 19613 5857 20 the the DT 19613 5857 21 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 5857 22 problem problem NN 19613 5857 23 that that WDT 19613 5857 24 troubled trouble VBD 19613 5857 25 and and CC 19613 5857 26 perplexed perplex VBD 19613 5857 27 the the DT 19613 5857 28 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5857 29 and and CC 19613 5857 30 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5857 31 , , , 19613 5857 32 viz viz NN 19613 5857 33 . . NNP 19613 5857 34 , , , 19613 5857 35 the the DT 19613 5857 36 qualitative qualitative JJ 19613 5857 37 distinction distinction NN 19613 5857 38 between between IN 19613 5857 39 the the DT 19613 5857 40 spheres sphere NNS 19613 5857 41 of of IN 19613 5857 42 creation creation NN 19613 5857 43 and and CC 19613 5857 44 redemption redemption NN 19613 5857 45 . . . 19613 5858 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 5858 2 think think VBP 19613 5858 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5858 4 have have VBP 19613 5858 5 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 5858 6 explained explain VBN 19613 5858 7 this this DT 19613 5858 8 distinction distinction NN 19613 5858 9 by by IN 19613 5858 10 the the DT 19613 5858 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5858 12 of of IN 19613 5858 13 human human JJ 19613 5858 14 freedom freedom NN 19613 5858 15 and and CC 19613 5858 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5858 17 consequences consequence NNS 19613 5858 18 . . . 19613 5859 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5859 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5859 3 whole whole JJ 19613 5859 4 mode mode NN 19613 5859 5 of of IN 19613 5859 6 argument argument NN 19613 5859 7 against against IN 19613 5859 8 the the DT 19613 5859 9 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5859 10 and and CC 19613 5859 11 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5859 12 is be VBZ 19613 5859 13 , , , 19613 5859 14 in in IN 19613 5859 15 point point NN 19613 5859 16 of of IN 19613 5859 17 content content NN 19613 5859 18 , , , 19613 5859 19 of of IN 19613 5859 20 an an DT 19613 5859 21 abstract abstract JJ 19613 5859 22 , , , 19613 5859 23 philosophico philosophico NN 19613 5859 24 - - HYPH 19613 5859 25 rational rational JJ 19613 5859 26 kind kind NN 19613 5859 27 . . . 19613 5860 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5860 2 505 505 CD 19613 5860 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5860 4 As as IN 19613 5860 5 a a DT 19613 5860 6 rule rule NN 19613 5860 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5860 8 do do VBP 19613 5860 9 not not RB 19613 5860 10 here here RB 19613 5860 11 carry carry VB 19613 5860 12 on on RP 19613 5860 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5860 14 controversy controversy NN 19613 5860 15 with with IN 19613 5860 16 the the DT 19613 5860 17 aid aid NN 19613 5860 18 of of IN 19613 5860 19 reasons reason NNS 19613 5860 20 taken take VBN 19613 5860 21 from from IN 19613 5860 22 the the DT 19613 5860 23 deeper deep JJR 19613 5860 24 views view NNS 19613 5860 25 of of IN 19613 5860 26 religion religion NN 19613 5860 27 . . . 19613 5861 1 As as RB 19613 5861 2 soon soon RB 19613 5861 3 as as IN 19613 5861 4 the the DT 19613 5861 5 rational rational JJ 19613 5861 6 argument argument NN 19613 5861 7 fails fail VBZ 19613 5861 8 , , , 19613 5861 9 however however RB 19613 5861 10 , , , 19613 5861 11 there there EX 19613 5861 12 is be VBZ 19613 5861 13 really really RB 19613 5861 14 an an DT 19613 5861 15 entire entire JJ 19613 5861 16 end end NN 19613 5861 17 to to IN 19613 5861 18 the the DT 19613 5861 19 refutation refutation NN 19613 5861 20 from from IN 19613 5861 21 inner inner JJ 19613 5861 22 grounds ground NNS 19613 5861 23 , , , 19613 5861 24 at at IN 19613 5861 25 least least JJS 19613 5861 26 in in IN 19613 5861 27 the the DT 19613 5861 28 case case NN 19613 5861 29 of of IN 19613 5861 30 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5861 31 ; ; : 19613 5861 32 and and CC 19613 5861 33 the the DT 19613 5861 34 contest contest NN 19613 5861 35 is be VBZ 19613 5861 36 shifted shift VBN 19613 5861 37 into into IN 19613 5861 38 the the DT 19613 5861 39 sphere sphere NN 19613 5861 40 of of IN 19613 5861 41 the the DT 19613 5861 42 rule rule NN 19613 5861 43 of of IN 19613 5861 44 faith faith NN 19613 5861 45 and and CC 19613 5861 46 the the DT 19613 5861 47 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5861 48 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 5861 49 . . . 19613 5862 1 Hence hence RB 19613 5862 2 , , , 19613 5862 3 for for IN 19613 5862 4 example example NN 19613 5862 5 , , , 19613 5862 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5862 7 have have VBP 19613 5862 8 not not RB 19613 5862 9 succeeded succeed VBN 19613 5862 10 in in IN 19613 5862 11 making make VBG 19613 5862 12 much much JJ 19613 5862 13 impression impression NN 19613 5862 14 on on IN 19613 5862 15 the the DT 19613 5862 16 heretical heretical JJ 19613 5862 17 Christology Christology NNP 19613 5862 18 from from IN 19613 5862 19 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 5862 20 considerations consideration NNS 19613 5862 21 , , , 19613 5862 22 though though IN 19613 5862 23 in in IN 19613 5862 24 this this DT 19613 5862 25 respect respect NN 19613 5862 26 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5862 27 was be VBD 19613 5862 28 still still RB 19613 5862 29 very very RB 19613 5862 30 much much RB 19613 5862 31 more more RBR 19613 5862 32 successful successful JJ 19613 5862 33 than than IN 19613 5862 34 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5862 35 . . . 19613 5863 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5863 2 506 506 CD 19613 5863 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5863 4 Besides besides RB 19613 5863 5 , , , 19613 5863 6 in in IN 19613 5863 7 adv adv NN 19613 5863 8 . . . 19613 5864 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 5864 2 . . . 19613 5865 1 II ii CD 19613 5865 2 . . . 19613 5866 1 27 27 CD 19613 5866 2 , , , 19613 5866 3 the the DT 19613 5866 4 latter latter JJ 19613 5866 5 betrayed betray VBD 19613 5866 6 what what WDT 19613 5866 7 interest interest NN 19613 5866 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5866 9 took take VBD 19613 5866 10 in in RP 19613 5866 11 the the DT 19613 5866 12 preëxistent preëxistent NN 19613 5866 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5866 14 as as IN 19613 5866 15 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5866 16 from from IN 19613 5866 17 God God NNP 19613 5866 18 the the DT 19613 5866 19 Father Father NNP 19613 5866 20 . . . 19613 5867 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5867 2 is be VBZ 19613 5867 3 not not RB 19613 5867 4 expedient expedient JJ 19613 5867 5 to to TO 19613 5867 6 separate separate VB 19613 5867 7 the the DT 19613 5867 8 arguments argument NNS 19613 5867 9 advanced advance VBN 19613 5867 10 by by IN 19613 5867 11 the the DT 19613 5867 12 Fathers father NNS 19613 5867 13 against against IN 19613 5867 14 the the DT 19613 5867 15 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5867 16 from from IN 19613 5867 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5867 18 own own JJ 19613 5867 19 positive positive JJ 19613 5867 20 teachings teaching NNS 19613 5867 21 , , , 19613 5867 22 for for IN 19613 5867 23 these these DT 19613 5867 24 are be VBP 19613 5867 25 throughout throughout IN 19613 5867 26 dependent dependent JJ 19613 5867 27 on on IN 19613 5867 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5867 29 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 5867 30 attitude attitude NN 19613 5867 31 within within IN 19613 5867 32 the the DT 19613 5867 33 sphere sphere NN 19613 5867 34 of of IN 19613 5867 35 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5867 36 and and CC 19613 5867 37 tradition tradition NN 19613 5867 38 . . . 19613 5868 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5868 2 and and CC 19613 5868 3 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5868 4 have have VBP 19613 5868 5 been be VBN 19613 5868 6 rightly rightly RB 19613 5868 7 named name VBN 19613 5868 8 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5868 9 theologians theologian NNS 19613 5868 10 ; ; : 19613 5868 11 but but CC 19613 5868 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5868 13 is be VBZ 19613 5868 14 a a DT 19613 5868 15 strange strange JJ 19613 5868 16 infatuation infatuation NN 19613 5868 17 to to TO 19613 5868 18 think think VB 19613 5868 19 that that IN 19613 5868 20 this this DT 19613 5868 21 designation designation NN 19613 5868 22 characterises characterise VBZ 19613 5868 23 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5868 24 as as IN 19613 5868 25 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 5868 26 . . . 19613 5869 1 If if IN 19613 5869 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 5869 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5869 4 here here RB 19613 5869 5 understand understand VBP 19613 5869 6 " " `` 19613 5869 7 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 5869 8 " " '' 19613 5869 9 in in IN 19613 5869 10 the the DT 19613 5869 11 vulgar vulgar JJ 19613 5869 12 sense sense NN 19613 5869 13 , , , 19613 5869 14 the the DT 19613 5869 15 term term NN 19613 5869 16 may may MD 19613 5869 17 be be VB 19613 5869 18 correct correct JJ 19613 5869 19 , , , 19613 5869 20 only only RB 19613 5869 21 in in IN 19613 5869 22 this this DT 19613 5869 23 case case NN 19613 5869 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5869 25 means mean VBZ 19613 5869 26 exactly exactly RB 19613 5869 27 the the DT 19613 5869 28 same same JJ 19613 5869 29 as as IN 19613 5869 30 " " `` 19613 5869 31 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 5869 32 . . . 19613 5869 33 " " '' 19613 5870 1 But but CC 19613 5870 2 if if IN 19613 5870 3 " " `` 19613 5870 4 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 5870 5 " " '' 19613 5870 6 signifies signifie NNS 19613 5870 7 " " '' 19613 5870 8 early early RB 19613 5870 9 - - HYPH 19613 5870 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 5870 11 , , , 19613 5870 12 " " '' 19613 5870 13 then then RB 19613 5870 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5870 15 must must MD 19613 5870 16 be be VB 19613 5870 17 said say VBN 19613 5870 18 that that IN 19613 5870 19 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5870 20 theology theology NN 19613 5870 21 was be VBD 19613 5870 22 not not RB 19613 5870 23 the the DT 19613 5870 24 primary primary JJ 19613 5870 25 means mean NNS 19613 5870 26 of of IN 19613 5870 27 preserving preserve VBG 19613 5870 28 the the DT 19613 5870 29 ideas idea NNS 19613 5870 30 of of IN 19613 5870 31 primitive primitive JJ 19613 5870 32 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 5870 33 ; ; : 19613 5870 34 for for IN 19613 5870 35 , , , 19613 5870 36 as as IN 19613 5870 37 the the DT 19613 5870 38 New New NNP 19613 5870 39 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5870 40 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 5870 41 were be VBD 19613 5870 42 also also RB 19613 5870 43 regarded regard VBN 19613 5870 44 as as IN 19613 5870 45 _ _ NNP 19613 5870 46 inspired inspire VBD 19613 5870 47 _ _ NNP 19613 5870 48 documents document NNS 19613 5870 49 and and CC 19613 5870 50 were be VBD 19613 5870 51 to to TO 19613 5870 52 be be VB 19613 5870 53 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 5870 54 according accord VBG 19613 5870 55 to to IN 19613 5870 56 the the DT 19613 5870 57 _ _ NNP 19613 5870 58 regula regula NN 19613 5870 59 _ _ NNP 19613 5870 60 , , , 19613 5870 61 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5870 62 content content NN 19613 5870 63 was be VBD 19613 5870 64 just just RB 19613 5870 65 for for IN 19613 5870 66 that that DT 19613 5870 67 reason reason NN 19613 5870 68 apt apt JJ 19613 5870 69 to to TO 19613 5870 70 be be VB 19613 5870 71 obscured obscure VBN 19613 5870 72 . . . 19613 5871 1 Both both DT 19613 5871 2 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5871 3 and and CC 19613 5871 4 the the DT 19613 5871 5 chiefs chief NNS 19613 5871 6 of of IN 19613 5871 7 the the DT 19613 5871 8 Valentinian Valentinian NNP 19613 5871 9 school school NN 19613 5871 10 had have VBD 19613 5871 11 also also RB 19613 5871 12 been be VBN 19613 5871 13 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5871 14 theologians theologian NNS 19613 5871 15 . . . 19613 5872 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5872 2 and and CC 19613 5872 3 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5872 4 merely merely RB 19613 5872 5 followed follow VBD 19613 5872 6 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5872 7 . . . 19613 5873 1 Now now RB 19613 5873 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5873 3 is be VBZ 19613 5873 4 true true JJ 19613 5873 5 that that IN 19613 5873 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5873 7 very very RB 19613 5873 8 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 5873 9 argued argue VBD 19613 5873 10 against against IN 19613 5873 11 the the DT 19613 5873 12 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 19613 5873 13 method method NN 19613 5873 14 of of IN 19613 5873 15 interpreting interpret VBG 19613 5873 16 the the DT 19613 5873 17 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 5873 18 adopted adopt VBN 19613 5873 19 by by IN 19613 5873 20 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 5873 21 , , , 19613 5873 22 and and CC 19613 5873 23 compared compare VBD 19613 5873 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5873 25 to to IN 19613 5873 26 the the DT 19613 5873 27 process process NN 19613 5873 28 of of IN 19613 5873 29 forming form VBG 19613 5873 30 the the DT 19613 5873 31 mosaic mosaic JJ 19613 5873 32 picture picture NN 19613 5873 33 of of IN 19613 5873 34 a a DT 19613 5873 35 king king NN 19613 5873 36 into into IN 19613 5873 37 the the DT 19613 5873 38 mosaic mosaic JJ 19613 5873 39 picture picture NN 19613 5873 40 of of IN 19613 5873 41 a a DT 19613 5873 42 fox fox NN 19613 5873 43 , , , 19613 5873 44 and and CC 19613 5873 45 the the DT 19613 5873 46 poems poem NNS 19613 5873 47 of of IN 19613 5873 48 Homer Homer NNP 19613 5873 49 into into IN 19613 5873 50 any any DT 19613 5873 51 others other NNS 19613 5873 52 one one PRP 19613 5873 53 might may MD 19613 5873 54 choose;[507 choose;[507 VB 19613 5873 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5873 56 but but CC 19613 5873 57 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5873 58 just just RB 19613 5873 59 as as RB 19613 5873 60 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 5873 61 protested protest VBN 19613 5873 62 against against IN 19613 5873 63 the the DT 19613 5873 64 rejection rejection NN 19613 5873 65 by by IN 19613 5873 66 Apelles Apelles NNP 19613 5873 67 and and CC 19613 5873 68 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5873 69 of of IN 19613 5873 70 the the DT 19613 5873 71 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 5873 72 method method NN 19613 5873 73 of of IN 19613 5873 74 interpretation,[508 interpretation,[508 NN 19613 5873 75 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5873 76 and and CC 19613 5873 77 therefore therefore RB 19613 5873 78 were be VBD 19613 5873 79 not not RB 19613 5873 80 able able JJ 19613 5873 81 to to TO 19613 5873 82 set set VB 19613 5873 83 up up RP 19613 5873 84 a a DT 19613 5873 85 canon canon NN 19613 5873 86 really really RB 19613 5873 87 capable capable JJ 19613 5873 88 of of IN 19613 5873 89 distinguishing distinguish VBG 19613 5873 90 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5873 91 own own JJ 19613 5873 92 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 5873 93 from from IN 19613 5873 94 that that DT 19613 5873 95 of of IN 19613 5873 96 the the DT 19613 5873 97 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5873 98 . . . 19613 5874 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5874 2 509 509 CD 19613 5874 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5874 4 The the DT 19613 5874 5 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5874 6 theology theology NN 19613 5874 7 of of IN 19613 5874 8 the the DT 19613 5874 9 old old JJ 19613 5874 10 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 5874 11 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 5874 12 has have VBZ 19613 5874 13 a a DT 19613 5874 14 twofold twofold JJ 19613 5874 15 aspect aspect NN 19613 5874 16 . . . 19613 5875 1 The the DT 19613 5875 2 religion religion NN 19613 5875 3 of of IN 19613 5875 4 the the DT 19613 5875 5 Scripture scripture NN 19613 5875 6 is be VBZ 19613 5875 7 no no RB 19613 5875 8 longer long RBR 19613 5875 9 the the DT 19613 5875 10 original original JJ 19613 5875 11 form form NN 19613 5875 12 ; ; : 19613 5875 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5875 14 is be VBZ 19613 5875 15 the the DT 19613 5875 16 mediated mediate VBN 19613 5875 17 , , , 19613 5875 18 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5875 19 one one NN 19613 5875 20 to to TO 19613 5875 21 be be VB 19613 5875 22 constructed construct VBN 19613 5875 23 by by IN 19613 5875 24 a a DT 19613 5875 25 learned learned JJ 19613 5875 26 process process NN 19613 5875 27 ; ; : 19613 5875 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5875 29 is be VBZ 19613 5875 30 , , , 19613 5875 31 on on IN 19613 5875 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5875 33 part part NN 19613 5875 34 , , , 19613 5875 35 the the DT 19613 5875 36 strongest strong JJS 19613 5875 37 symptom symptom NN 19613 5875 38 of of IN 19613 5875 39 the the DT 19613 5875 40 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 5875 41 that that WDT 19613 5875 42 has have VBZ 19613 5875 43 begun begin VBN 19613 5875 44 . . . 19613 5876 1 In in IN 19613 5876 2 a a DT 19613 5876 3 word word NN 19613 5876 4 , , , 19613 5876 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5876 6 is be VBZ 19613 5876 7 the the DT 19613 5876 8 religion religion NN 19613 5876 9 of of IN 19613 5876 10 the the DT 19613 5876 11 school school NN 19613 5876 12 , , , 19613 5876 13 first first RB 19613 5876 14 the the DT 19613 5876 15 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 5876 16 then then RB 19613 5876 17 the the DT 19613 5876 18 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical NN 19613 5876 19 . . . 19613 5877 1 But but CC 19613 5877 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5877 3 may may MD 19613 5877 4 , , , 19613 5877 5 on on IN 19613 5877 6 the the DT 19613 5877 7 other other JJ 19613 5877 8 hand hand NN 19613 5877 9 , , , 19613 5877 10 be be VB 19613 5877 11 a a DT 19613 5877 12 wholesome wholesome JJ 19613 5877 13 reaction reaction NN 19613 5877 14 against against IN 19613 5877 15 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 19613 5877 16 excess excess JJ 19613 5877 17 and and CC 19613 5877 18 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 5877 19 frigidity frigidity NN 19613 5877 20 ; ; : 19613 5877 21 and and CC 19613 5877 22 the the DT 19613 5877 23 correct correct JJ 19613 5877 24 sense sense NN 19613 5877 25 of of IN 19613 5877 26 the the DT 19613 5877 27 letter letter NN 19613 5877 28 will will MD 19613 5877 29 from from IN 19613 5877 30 the the DT 19613 5877 31 first first JJ 19613 5877 32 obtain obtain NN 19613 5877 33 imperceptible imperceptible JJ 19613 5877 34 recognition recognition NN 19613 5877 35 in in IN 19613 5877 36 opposition opposition NN 19613 5877 37 to to IN 19613 5877 38 the the DT 19613 5877 39 " " `` 19613 5877 40 spirit spirit NN 19613 5877 41 " " '' 19613 5877 42 arbitrarily arbitrarily RB 19613 5877 43 read read VBP 19613 5877 44 into into IN 19613 5877 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5877 46 , , , 19613 5877 47 and and CC 19613 5877 48 at at IN 19613 5877 49 length length NN 19613 5877 50 banish banish NN 19613 5877 51 this this DT 19613 5877 52 " " `` 19613 5877 53 spirit spirit NN 19613 5877 54 " " '' 19613 5877 55 completely completely RB 19613 5877 56 . . . 19613 5878 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5878 2 certainly certainly RB 19613 5878 3 tried try VBD 19613 5878 4 to to TO 19613 5878 5 mark mark VB 19613 5878 6 off off RP 19613 5878 7 the the DT 19613 5878 8 Church Church NNP 19613 5878 9 use use NN 19613 5878 10 of of IN 19613 5878 11 the the DT 19613 5878 12 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 5878 13 as as IN 19613 5878 14 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5878 15 from from IN 19613 5878 16 the the DT 19613 5878 17 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5878 18 practice practice NN 19613 5878 19 . . . 19613 5879 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5879 2 rejects reject VBZ 19613 5879 3 the the DT 19613 5879 4 accommodation accommodation NN 19613 5879 5 theory theory NN 19613 5879 6 of of IN 19613 5879 7 which which WDT 19613 5879 8 some some DT 19613 5879 9 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5879 10 availed avail VBD 19613 5879 11 themselves;[510 themselves;[510 NNS 19613 5879 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5879 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5879 14 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 5879 15 more more RBR 19613 5879 16 strongly strongly RB 19613 5879 17 than than IN 19613 5879 18 these these DT 19613 5879 19 the the DT 19613 5879 20 absolute absolute JJ 19613 5879 21 sufficiency sufficiency NN 19613 5879 22 of of IN 19613 5879 23 the the DT 19613 5879 24 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 5879 25 by by IN 19613 5879 26 repudiating repudiate VBG 19613 5879 27 all all DT 19613 5879 28 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 5879 29 doctrines;[511 doctrines;[511 NNP 19613 5879 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5879 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5879 32 rejects reject VBZ 19613 5879 33 all all DT 19613 5879 34 distinction distinction NN 19613 5879 35 between between IN 19613 5879 36 different different JJ 19613 5879 37 kinds kind NNS 19613 5879 38 of of IN 19613 5879 39 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 5879 40 in in IN 19613 5879 41 the the DT 19613 5879 42 sacred sacred JJ 19613 5879 43 books;[512 books;[512 : 19613 5879 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5879 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5879 46 lays lay VBZ 19613 5879 47 down down IN 19613 5879 48 the the DT 19613 5879 49 maxim maxim NN 19613 5879 50 that that IN 19613 5879 51 the the DT 19613 5879 52 obscure obscure JJ 19613 5879 53 passages passage NNS 19613 5879 54 are be VBP 19613 5879 55 to to TO 19613 5879 56 be be VB 19613 5879 57 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 5879 58 from from IN 19613 5879 59 the the DT 19613 5879 60 clear clear JJ 19613 5879 61 ones one NNS 19613 5879 62 , , , 19613 5879 63 not not RB 19613 5879 64 vice vice NN 19613 5879 65 versa;[513 versa;[513 NNS 19613 5879 66 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5879 67 but but CC 19613 5879 68 this this DT 19613 5879 69 principle principle NN 19613 5879 70 being be VBG 19613 5879 71 in in IN 19613 5879 72 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5879 73 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 19613 5879 74 , , , 19613 5879 75 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5879 76 is be VBZ 19613 5879 77 rendered render VBN 19613 5879 78 quite quite RB 19613 5879 79 unequivocal unequivocal JJ 19613 5879 80 by by IN 19613 5879 81 the the DT 19613 5879 82 injunction injunction NN 19613 5879 83 to to TO 19613 5879 84 interpret interpret VB 19613 5879 85 everything everything NN 19613 5879 86 according accord VBG 19613 5879 87 to to IN 19613 5879 88 the the DT 19613 5879 89 rule rule NN 19613 5879 90 of of IN 19613 5879 91 faith[514 faith[514 NNP 19613 5879 92 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5879 93 and and CC 19613 5879 94 , , , 19613 5879 95 in in IN 19613 5879 96 the the DT 19613 5879 97 case case NN 19613 5879 98 of of IN 19613 5879 99 all all DT 19613 5879 100 objectionable objectionable JJ 19613 5879 101 passages passage NNS 19613 5879 102 , , , 19613 5879 103 to to TO 19613 5879 104 seek seek VB 19613 5879 105 the the DT 19613 5879 106 type type NN 19613 5879 107 . . . 19613 5880 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5880 2 515 515 CD 19613 5880 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5880 4 Not not RB 19613 5880 5 only only RB 19613 5880 6 did do VBD 19613 5880 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5880 8 explain explain VB 19613 5880 9 the the DT 19613 5880 10 Old Old NNP 19613 5880 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5880 12 allegorically allegorically RB 19613 5880 13 , , , 19613 5880 14 in in IN 19613 5880 15 accordance accordance NN 19613 5880 16 with with IN 19613 5880 17 traditional traditional JJ 19613 5880 18 usage;[516 usage;[516 NNS 19613 5880 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5880 20 but but CC 19613 5880 21 according accord VBG 19613 5880 22 to to IN 19613 5880 23 the the DT 19613 5880 24 principle principle NN 19613 5880 25 : : : 19613 5880 26 " " `` 19613 5880 27 with with IN 19613 5880 28 God God NNP 19613 5880 29 there there EX 19613 5880 30 is be VBZ 19613 5880 31 nothing nothing NN 19613 5880 32 without without IN 19613 5880 33 purpose purpose NN 19613 5880 34 or or CC 19613 5880 35 due due JJ 19613 5880 36 signification signification NN 19613 5880 37 " " '' 19613 5880 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5880 39 " " `` 19613 5880 40 nihil nihil NNP 19613 5880 41 vacuum vacuum NNP 19613 5880 42 neque neque NNP 19613 5880 43 sine sine NNP 19613 5880 44 signo signo NNP 19613 5880 45 apud apud NNP 19613 5880 46 deum deum NNP 19613 5880 47 " " '' 19613 5880 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5880 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5880 50 IV IV NNP 19613 5880 51 . . . 19613 5881 1 21 21 CD 19613 5881 2 . . . 19613 5882 1 3 3 LS 19613 5882 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5882 3 , , , 19613 5882 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5882 5 was be VBD 19613 5882 6 also also RB 19613 5882 7 the the DT 19613 5882 8 first first JJ 19613 5882 9 to to TO 19613 5882 10 apply apply VB 19613 5882 11 the the DT 19613 5882 12 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5882 13 and and CC 19613 5882 14 mystical mystical JJ 19613 5882 15 explanation explanation NN 19613 5882 16 to to IN 19613 5882 17 the the DT 19613 5882 18 New New NNP 19613 5882 19 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5882 20 , , , 19613 5882 21 and and CC 19613 5882 22 was be VBD 19613 5882 23 consequently consequently RB 19613 5882 24 obliged oblige VBN 19613 5882 25 to to TO 19613 5882 26 adopt adopt VB 19613 5882 27 the the DT 19613 5882 28 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5882 29 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 5882 30 , , , 19613 5882 31 which which WDT 19613 5882 32 was be VBD 19613 5882 33 imperative imperative JJ 19613 5882 34 as as RB 19613 5882 35 soon soon RB 19613 5882 36 as as IN 19613 5882 37 the the DT 19613 5882 38 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 5882 39 writings writing NNS 19613 5882 40 were be VBD 19613 5882 41 viewed view VBN 19613 5882 42 as as IN 19613 5882 43 a a DT 19613 5882 44 New New NNP 19613 5882 45 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5882 46 . . . 19613 5883 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5883 2 regards regard VBZ 19613 5883 3 the the DT 19613 5883 4 fact fact NN 19613 5883 5 of of IN 19613 5883 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5883 7 handing hand VBG 19613 5883 8 round round JJ 19613 5883 9 food food NN 19613 5883 10 to to IN 19613 5883 11 those those DT 19613 5883 12 _ _ NNP 19613 5883 13 lying lie VBG 19613 5883 14 _ _ NNP 19613 5883 15 at at IN 19613 5883 16 table table NN 19613 5883 17 as as IN 19613 5883 18 signifying signify VBG 19613 5883 19 that that IN 19613 5883 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5883 21 also also RB 19613 5883 22 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 5883 23 life life NN 19613 5883 24 on on IN 19613 5883 25 the the DT 19613 5883 26 long long JJ 19613 5883 27 dead dead JJ 19613 5883 28 generations;[517 generations;[517 NNS 19613 5883 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5883 30 and and CC 19613 5883 31 , , , 19613 5883 32 in in IN 19613 5883 33 the the DT 19613 5883 34 parable parable NN 19613 5883 35 of of IN 19613 5883 36 the the DT 19613 5883 37 Samaritan Samaritan NNP 19613 5883 38 , , , 19613 5883 39 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5883 40 interprets interpret VBZ 19613 5883 41 the the DT 19613 5883 42 host host NN 19613 5883 43 as as IN 19613 5883 44 the the DT 19613 5883 45 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5883 46 and and CC 19613 5883 47 the the DT 19613 5883 48 two two CD 19613 5883 49 denarii denarii NN 19613 5883 50 as as IN 19613 5883 51 the the DT 19613 5883 52 Father Father NNP 19613 5883 53 and and CC 19613 5883 54 Son Son NNP 19613 5883 55 . . . 19613 5884 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5884 2 518 518 CD 19613 5884 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5884 4 To to IN 19613 5884 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5884 6 and and CC 19613 5884 7 also also RB 19613 5884 8 to to IN 19613 5884 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5884 10 and and CC 19613 5884 11 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5884 12 all all DT 19613 5884 13 numbers number NNS 19613 5884 14 , , , 19613 5884 15 incidental incidental JJ 19613 5884 16 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 5884 17 , , , 19613 5884 18 etc etc FW 19613 5884 19 . . FW 19613 5884 20 , , , 19613 5884 21 in in IN 19613 5884 22 the the DT 19613 5884 23 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5884 24 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 5884 25 are be VBP 19613 5884 26 virtually virtually RB 19613 5884 27 as as RB 19613 5884 28 significant significant JJ 19613 5884 29 as as IN 19613 5884 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5884 31 are be VBP 19613 5884 32 to to IN 19613 5884 33 the the DT 19613 5884 34 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5884 35 , , , 19613 5884 36 and and CC 19613 5884 37 hence hence RB 19613 5884 38 the the DT 19613 5884 39 only only JJ 19613 5884 40 question question NN 19613 5884 41 is be VBZ 19613 5884 42 what what WP 19613 5884 43 hidden hide VBN 19613 5884 44 meaning meaning NN 19613 5884 45 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5884 46 are be VBP 19613 5884 47 to to TO 19613 5884 48 give give VB 19613 5884 49 to to IN 19613 5884 50 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5884 51 . . . 19613 5885 1 " " `` 19613 5885 2 Gnosticism gnosticism NN 19613 5885 3 " " '' 19613 5885 4 is be VBZ 19613 5885 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 5885 6 here here RB 19613 5885 7 adopted adopt VBN 19613 5885 8 by by IN 19613 5885 9 the the DT 19613 5885 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 5885 11 teachers teacher NNS 19613 5885 12 in in IN 19613 5885 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5885 14 full full JJ 19613 5885 15 extent extent NN 19613 5885 16 , , , 19613 5885 17 proving prove VBG 19613 5885 18 that that IN 19613 5885 19 this this DT 19613 5885 20 " " `` 19613 5885 21 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 5885 22 " " '' 19613 5885 23 is be VBZ 19613 5885 24 nothing nothing NN 19613 5885 25 else else RB 19613 5885 26 than than IN 19613 5885 27 the the DT 19613 5885 28 learned learned JJ 19613 5885 29 construction construction NN 19613 5885 30 of of IN 19613 5885 31 religion religion NN 19613 5885 32 with with IN 19613 5885 33 the the DT 19613 5885 34 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5885 35 means mean NNS 19613 5885 36 of of IN 19613 5885 37 those those DT 19613 5885 38 days day NNS 19613 5885 39 . . . 19613 5886 1 As as RB 19613 5886 2 soon soon RB 19613 5886 3 as as IN 19613 5886 4 Churchmen churchman NNS 19613 5886 5 were be VBD 19613 5886 6 forced force VBN 19613 5886 7 to to TO 19613 5886 8 bring bring VB 19613 5886 9 forward forward RB 19613 5886 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5886 11 proofs proof NNS 19613 5886 12 and and CC 19613 5886 13 proceed proceed VB 19613 5886 14 to to TO 19613 5886 15 put put VB 19613 5886 16 the the DT 19613 5886 17 same same JJ 19613 5886 18 questions question NNS 19613 5886 19 as as IN 19613 5886 20 the the DT 19613 5886 21 " " `` 19613 5886 22 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5886 23 , , , 19613 5886 24 " " '' 19613 5886 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5886 26 were be VBD 19613 5886 27 obliged oblige VBN 19613 5886 28 to to TO 19613 5886 29 work work VB 19613 5886 30 by by IN 19613 5886 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5886 32 method method NN 19613 5886 33 . . . 19613 5887 1 Allegory allegory NN 19613 5887 2 , , , 19613 5887 3 however however RB 19613 5887 4 , , , 19613 5887 5 was be VBD 19613 5887 6 required require VBN 19613 5887 7 in in IN 19613 5887 8 order order NN 19613 5887 9 to to TO 19613 5887 10 establish establish VB 19613 5887 11 the the DT 19613 5887 12 continuity continuity NN 19613 5887 13 of of IN 19613 5887 14 the the DT 19613 5887 15 tradition tradition NN 19613 5887 16 from from IN 19613 5887 17 Adam Adam NNP 19613 5887 18 down down RP 19613 5887 19 to to IN 19613 5887 20 the the DT 19613 5887 21 present present JJ 19613 5887 22 time time NN 19613 5887 23 -- -- : 19613 5887 24 not not RB 19613 5887 25 merely merely RB 19613 5887 26 down down IN 19613 5887 27 to to IN 19613 5887 28 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5887 29 -- -- : 19613 5887 30 against against IN 19613 5887 31 the the DT 19613 5887 32 attacks attack NNS 19613 5887 33 of of IN 19613 5887 34 the the DT 19613 5887 35 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5887 36 and and CC 19613 5887 37 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5887 38 . . . 19613 5888 1 By by IN 19613 5888 2 establishing establish VBG 19613 5888 3 this this DT 19613 5888 4 continuity continuity NN 19613 5888 5 a a DT 19613 5888 6 historical historical JJ 19613 5888 7 truth truth NN 19613 5888 8 was be VBD 19613 5888 9 really really RB 19613 5888 10 also also RB 19613 5888 11 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5888 12 . . . 19613 5889 1 For for IN 19613 5889 2 the the DT 19613 5889 3 rest rest NN 19613 5889 4 , , , 19613 5889 5 the the DT 19613 5889 6 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 5889 7 of of IN 19613 5889 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5889 9 , , , 19613 5889 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5889 11 , , , 19613 5889 12 and and CC 19613 5889 13 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5889 14 were be VBD 19613 5889 15 to to IN 19613 5889 16 such such PDT 19613 5889 17 an an DT 19613 5889 18 extent extent NN 19613 5889 19 borrowed borrow VBN 19613 5889 20 from from IN 19613 5889 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5889 22 opponents opponent NNS 19613 5889 23 that that IN 19613 5889 24 there there EX 19613 5889 25 is be VBZ 19613 5889 26 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 5889 27 a a DT 19613 5889 28 problem problem NN 19613 5889 29 that that WDT 19613 5889 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5889 31 propounded propound VBD 19613 5889 32 and and CC 19613 5889 33 discussed discuss VBD 19613 5889 34 as as IN 19613 5889 35 the the DT 19613 5889 36 result result NN 19613 5889 37 of of IN 19613 5889 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5889 39 own own JJ 19613 5889 40 thirst thirst NN 19613 5889 41 for for IN 19613 5889 42 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5889 43 . . . 19613 5890 1 This this DT 19613 5890 2 fact fact NN 19613 5890 3 not not RB 19613 5890 4 only only RB 19613 5890 5 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5890 6 to to IN 19613 5890 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5890 8 works work NNS 19613 5890 9 an an DT 19613 5890 10 early early JJ 19613 5890 11 - - HYPH 19613 5890 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 5890 13 character character NN 19613 5890 14 as as IN 19613 5890 15 compared compare VBN 19613 5890 16 with with IN 19613 5890 17 those those DT 19613 5890 18 of of IN 19613 5890 19 the the DT 19613 5890 20 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 5890 21 , , , 19613 5890 22 but but CC 19613 5890 23 also also RB 19613 5890 24 explains explain VBZ 19613 5890 25 why why WRB 19613 5890 26 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5890 27 frequently frequently RB 19613 5890 28 stop stop VBP 19613 5890 29 in in IN 19613 5890 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5890 31 positive positive JJ 19613 5890 32 teachings teaching NNS 19613 5890 33 , , , 19613 5890 34 when when WRB 19613 5890 35 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5890 36 believe believe VBP 19613 5890 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5890 38 have have VBP 19613 5890 39 confuted confute VBN 19613 5890 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5890 41 adversaries adversary NNS 19613 5890 42 . . . 19613 5891 1 Thus thus RB 19613 5891 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5891 3 find find VBP 19613 5891 4 neither neither CC 19613 5891 5 in in IN 19613 5891 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5891 7 nor nor CC 19613 5891 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5891 9 a a DT 19613 5891 10 discussion discussion NN 19613 5891 11 of of IN 19613 5891 12 the the DT 19613 5891 13 relation relation NN 19613 5891 14 of of IN 19613 5891 15 the the DT 19613 5891 16 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 5891 17 to to IN 19613 5891 18 the the DT 19613 5891 19 rule rule NN 19613 5891 20 of of IN 19613 5891 21 faith faith NN 19613 5891 22 . . . 19613 5892 1 From from IN 19613 5892 2 the the DT 19613 5892 3 way way NN 19613 5892 4 in in IN 19613 5892 5 which which WDT 19613 5892 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5892 7 appeal appeal VBP 19613 5892 8 to to IN 19613 5892 9 both both DT 19613 5892 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5892 11 can can MD 19613 5892 12 deduce deduce VB 19613 5892 13 a a DT 19613 5892 14 series series NN 19613 5892 15 of of IN 19613 5892 16 important important JJ 19613 5892 17 problems problem NNS 19613 5892 18 , , , 19613 5892 19 which which WDT 19613 5892 20 , , , 19613 5892 21 however however RB 19613 5892 22 , , , 19613 5892 23 the the DT 19613 5892 24 Fathers father NNS 19613 5892 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5892 26 did do VBD 19613 5892 27 not not RB 19613 5892 28 formulate formulate VB 19613 5892 29 and and CC 19613 5892 30 consequently consequently RB 19613 5892 31 did do VBD 19613 5892 32 not not RB 19613 5892 33 answer answer VB 19613 5892 34 . . . 19613 5893 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5893 2 519 519 CD 19613 5893 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5893 4 _ _ NNP 19613 5893 5 The the DT 19613 5893 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5893 7 of of IN 19613 5893 8 God God NNP 19613 5893 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5893 10 was be VBD 19613 5893 11 fixed fix VBN 19613 5893 12 by by IN 19613 5893 13 the the DT 19613 5893 14 old old JJ 19613 5893 15 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 5893 16 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 5893 17 for for IN 19613 5893 18 the the DT 19613 5893 19 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 5893 20 of of IN 19613 5893 21 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 5893 22 centuries century NNS 19613 5893 23 , , , 19613 5893 24 and and CC 19613 5893 25 in in IN 19613 5893 26 fact fact NN 19613 5893 27 both both CC 19613 5893 28 the the DT 19613 5893 29 methodic methodic JJ 19613 5893 30 directions direction NNS 19613 5893 31 for for IN 19613 5893 32 forming form VBG 19613 5893 33 the the DT 19613 5893 34 idea idea NN 19613 5893 35 of of IN 19613 5893 36 God God NNP 19613 5893 37 and and CC 19613 5893 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5893 39 results result NNS 19613 5893 40 remained remain VBD 19613 5893 41 unchanged unchanged JJ 19613 5893 42 . . . 19613 5894 1 With with IN 19613 5894 2 respect respect NN 19613 5894 3 to to IN 19613 5894 4 the the DT 19613 5894 5 former former JJ 19613 5894 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5894 7 occupy occupy VBP 19613 5894 8 a a DT 19613 5894 9 middle middle JJ 19613 5894 10 position position NN 19613 5894 11 between between IN 19613 5894 12 the the DT 19613 5894 13 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 5894 14 of of IN 19613 5894 15 all all DT 19613 5894 16 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5894 17 -- -- : 19613 5894 18 for for IN 19613 5894 19 God God NNP 19613 5894 20 is be VBZ 19613 5894 21 not not RB 19613 5894 22 abyss abyss NN 19613 5894 23 and and CC 19613 5894 24 silence silence VB 19613 5894 25 -- -- : 19613 5894 26 and and CC 19613 5894 27 the the DT 19613 5894 28 attempt attempt NN 19613 5894 29 to to TO 19613 5894 30 fathom fathom VB 19613 5894 31 the the DT 19613 5894 32 depths depth NNS 19613 5894 33 of of IN 19613 5894 34 the the DT 19613 5894 35 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5894 36 . . . 19613 5895 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5895 2 520 520 CD 19613 5895 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5895 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5895 5 , , , 19613 5895 6 influenced influence VBN 19613 5895 7 by by IN 19613 5895 8 the the DT 19613 5895 9 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 5895 10 , , , 19613 5895 11 strongly strongly RB 19613 5895 12 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 5895 13 the the DT 19613 5895 14 possibility possibility NN 19613 5895 15 of of IN 19613 5895 16 attaining attain VBG 19613 5895 17 a a DT 19613 5895 18 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5895 19 of of IN 19613 5895 20 God God NNP 19613 5895 21 . . . 19613 5896 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5896 2 , , , 19613 5896 3 following follow VBG 19613 5896 4 out out RP 19613 5896 5 an an DT 19613 5896 6 idea idea NN 19613 5896 7 which which WDT 19613 5896 8 seems seem VBZ 19613 5896 9 to to TO 19613 5896 10 anticipate anticipate VB 19613 5896 11 the the DT 19613 5896 12 mysticism mysticism NN 19613 5896 13 of of IN 19613 5896 14 later later JJ 19613 5896 15 theologians theologian NNS 19613 5896 16 , , , 19613 5896 17 made make VBD 19613 5896 18 love love NN 19613 5896 19 a a DT 19613 5896 20 preliminary preliminary JJ 19613 5896 21 condition condition NN 19613 5896 22 of of IN 19613 5896 23 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5896 24 and and CC 19613 5896 25 plainly plainly RB 19613 5896 26 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 5896 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5896 28 as as IN 19613 5896 29 the the DT 19613 5896 30 principle principle NN 19613 5896 31 of of IN 19613 5896 32 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5896 33 . . . 19613 5897 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5897 2 521 521 CD 19613 5897 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5897 4 God God NNP 19613 5897 5 can can MD 19613 5897 6 be be VB 19613 5897 7 known know VBN 19613 5897 8 from from IN 19613 5897 9 revelation,[522 revelation,[522 NNP 19613 5897 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5897 11 because because IN 19613 5897 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5897 13 has have VBZ 19613 5897 14 really really RB 19613 5897 15 revealed reveal VBN 19613 5897 16 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5897 17 , , , 19613 5897 18 that that RB 19613 5897 19 is is RB 19613 5897 20 , , , 19613 5897 21 both both CC 19613 5897 22 by by IN 19613 5897 23 the the DT 19613 5897 24 creation creation NN 19613 5897 25 and and CC 19613 5897 26 the the DT 19613 5897 27 word word NN 19613 5897 28 of of IN 19613 5897 29 revelation revelation NN 19613 5897 30 . . . 19613 5898 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5898 2 also also RB 19613 5898 3 taught teach VBD 19613 5898 4 that that IN 19613 5898 5 a a DT 19613 5898 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 5898 7 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5898 8 of of IN 19613 5898 9 God God NNP 19613 5898 10 , , , 19613 5898 11 as as IN 19613 5898 12 the the DT 19613 5898 13 creator creator NN 19613 5898 14 and and CC 19613 5898 15 guide guide NN 19613 5898 16 , , , 19613 5898 17 can can MD 19613 5898 18 be be VB 19613 5898 19 obtained obtain VBN 19613 5898 20 from from IN 19613 5898 21 the the DT 19613 5898 22 creation creation NN 19613 5898 23 , , , 19613 5898 24 and and CC 19613 5898 25 indeed indeed RB 19613 5898 26 this this DT 19613 5898 27 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5898 28 always always RB 19613 5898 29 continues continue VBZ 19613 5898 30 , , , 19613 5898 31 so so IN 19613 5898 32 that that IN 19613 5898 33 all all DT 19613 5898 34 men man NNS 19613 5898 35 are be VBP 19613 5898 36 without without IN 19613 5898 37 excuse excuse NN 19613 5898 38 . . . 19613 5899 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5899 2 523 523 CD 19613 5899 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5899 4 In in IN 19613 5899 5 this this DT 19613 5899 6 case case NN 19613 5899 7 the the DT 19613 5899 8 prophets prophet NNS 19613 5899 9 , , , 19613 5899 10 the the DT 19613 5899 11 Lord Lord NNP 19613 5899 12 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5899 13 , , , 19613 5899 14 the the DT 19613 5899 15 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 5899 16 , , , 19613 5899 17 and and CC 19613 5899 18 the the DT 19613 5899 19 Church Church NNP 19613 5899 20 teach teach VBP 19613 5899 21 no no RB 19613 5899 22 more more JJR 19613 5899 23 and and CC 19613 5899 24 nothing nothing NN 19613 5899 25 else else RB 19613 5899 26 than than IN 19613 5899 27 what what WP 19613 5899 28 must must MD 19613 5899 29 be be VB 19613 5899 30 already already RB 19613 5899 31 plain plain JJ 19613 5899 32 to to IN 19613 5899 33 the the DT 19613 5899 34 natural natural JJ 19613 5899 35 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 5899 36 . . . 19613 5900 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5900 2 certainly certainly RB 19613 5900 3 did do VBD 19613 5900 4 not not RB 19613 5900 5 succeed succeed VB 19613 5900 6 in in IN 19613 5900 7 reconciling reconcile VBG 19613 5900 8 this this DT 19613 5900 9 proposition proposition NN 19613 5900 10 with with IN 19613 5900 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5900 12 former former JJ 19613 5900 13 assertion assertion NN 19613 5900 14 that that IN 19613 5900 15 the the DT 19613 5900 16 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 5900 17 of of IN 19613 5900 18 God God NNP 19613 5900 19 springs spring NNS 19613 5900 20 from from IN 19613 5900 21 love love NN 19613 5900 22 resting rest VBG 19613 5900 23 on on IN 19613 5900 24 revelation revelation NN 19613 5900 25 . . . 19613 5901 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5901 2 also also RB 19613 5901 3 starts start VBZ 19613 5901 4 , , , 19613 5901 5 as as IN 19613 5901 6 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 5901 7 and and CC 19613 5901 8 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 5901 9 , , , 19613 5901 10 with with IN 19613 5901 11 the the DT 19613 5901 12 God God NNP 19613 5901 13 who who WP 19613 5901 14 is be VBZ 19613 5901 15 the the DT 19613 5901 16 First first JJ 19613 5901 17 Cause Cause NNP 19613 5901 18 . . . 19613 5902 1 Every every DT 19613 5902 2 God God NNP 19613 5902 3 who who WP 19613 5902 4 is be VBZ 19613 5902 5 not not RB 19613 5902 6 that that DT 19613 5902 7 is be VBZ 19613 5902 8 a a DT 19613 5902 9 phantom;[524 phantom;[524 NNP 19613 5902 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5902 11 and and CC 19613 5902 12 every every DT 19613 5902 13 sublime sublime JJ 19613 5902 14 religious religious JJ 19613 5902 15 state state NN 19613 5902 16 of of IN 19613 5902 17 mind mind NN 19613 5902 18 which which WDT 19613 5902 19 does do VBZ 19613 5902 20 not not RB 19613 5902 21 include include VB 19613 5902 22 the the DT 19613 5902 23 feeling feeling NN 19613 5902 24 of of IN 19613 5902 25 dependence dependence NN 19613 5902 26 upon upon IN 19613 5902 27 God God NNP 19613 5902 28 as as IN 19613 5902 29 the the DT 19613 5902 30 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5902 31 is be VBZ 19613 5902 32 a a DT 19613 5902 33 deception deception NN 19613 5902 34 . . . 19613 5903 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5903 2 is be VBZ 19613 5903 3 the the DT 19613 5903 4 extremest extreme JJS 19613 5903 5 blasphemy blasphemy NN 19613 5903 6 to to TO 19613 5903 7 degrade degrade VB 19613 5903 8 God God NNP 19613 5903 9 the the DT 19613 5903 10 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5903 11 , , , 19613 5903 12 and and CC 19613 5903 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5903 14 is be VBZ 19613 5903 15 the the DT 19613 5903 16 most most RBS 19613 5903 17 frightful frightful JJ 19613 5903 18 machination machination NN 19613 5903 19 of of IN 19613 5903 20 the the DT 19613 5903 21 devil devil NN 19613 5903 22 that that WDT 19613 5903 23 has have VBZ 19613 5903 24 produced produce VBN 19613 5903 25 the the DT 19613 5903 26 _ _ NNP 19613 5903 27 blasphemia blasphemia NN 19613 5903 28 creatoris creatoris NNP 19613 5903 29 _ _ NNP 19613 5903 30 . . . 19613 5904 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5904 2 525 525 CD 19613 5904 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5904 4 Like like IN 19613 5904 5 the the DT 19613 5904 6 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5904 7 , , , 19613 5904 8 the the DT 19613 5904 9 early early JJ 19613 5904 10 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 5904 11 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 5904 12 confess confess VB 19613 5904 13 that that IN 19613 5904 14 the the DT 19613 5904 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5904 16 of of IN 19613 5904 17 God God NNP 19613 5904 18 the the DT 19613 5904 19 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5904 20 is be VBZ 19613 5904 21 the the DT 19613 5904 22 first first JJ 19613 5904 23 and and CC 19613 5904 24 most most RBS 19613 5904 25 important important JJ 19613 5904 26 of of IN 19613 5904 27 the the DT 19613 5904 28 main main JJ 19613 5904 29 articles article NNS 19613 5904 30 of of IN 19613 5904 31 Christian Christian NNP 19613 5904 32 faith;[526 faith;[526 LS 19613 5904 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5904 34 the the DT 19613 5904 35 belief belief NN 19613 5904 36 in in IN 19613 5904 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5904 38 oneness oneness NN 19613 5904 39 as as RB 19613 5904 40 well well RB 19613 5904 41 as as IN 19613 5904 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5904 43 absoluteness absoluteness NN 19613 5904 44 is be VBZ 19613 5904 45 the the DT 19613 5904 46 main main JJ 19613 5904 47 point point NN 19613 5904 48 . . . 19613 5905 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5905 2 527 527 CD 19613 5905 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5905 4 God God NNP 19613 5905 5 is be VBZ 19613 5905 6 all all RB 19613 5905 7 light light JJ 19613 5905 8 , , , 19613 5905 9 all all DT 19613 5905 10 understanding understanding NN 19613 5905 11 , , , 19613 5905 12 all all DT 19613 5905 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5905 14 , , , 19613 5905 15 all all DT 19613 5905 16 active active JJ 19613 5905 17 spirit;[528 spirit;[528 : 19613 5905 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5905 19 everything everything NN 19613 5905 20 anthropopathic anthropopathic JJ 19613 5905 21 and and CC 19613 5905 22 anthropomorphic anthropomorphic JJ 19613 5905 23 is be VBZ 19613 5905 24 to to TO 19613 5905 25 be be VB 19613 5905 26 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5905 27 as as RB 19613 5905 28 incompatible incompatible JJ 19613 5905 29 with with IN 19613 5905 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5905 31 nature nature NN 19613 5905 32 . . . 19613 5906 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5906 2 529 529 CD 19613 5906 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5906 4 The the DT 19613 5906 5 early early JJ 19613 5906 6 - - HYPH 19613 5906 7 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 5906 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5906 9 of of IN 19613 5906 10 God God NNP 19613 5906 11 shows show VBZ 19613 5906 12 an an DT 19613 5906 13 advance advance NN 19613 5906 14 beyond beyond IN 19613 5906 15 that that DT 19613 5906 16 of of IN 19613 5906 17 the the DT 19613 5906 18 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5906 19 , , , 19613 5906 20 in in IN 19613 5906 21 so so RB 19613 5906 22 far far RB 19613 5906 23 as as IN 19613 5906 24 God God NNP 19613 5906 25 's 's POS 19613 5906 26 attributes attribute NNS 19613 5906 27 of of IN 19613 5906 28 goodness goodness NN 19613 5906 29 and and CC 19613 5906 30 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 5906 31 are be VBP 19613 5906 32 expressly expressly RB 19613 5906 33 discussed discuss VBN 19613 5906 34 , , , 19613 5906 35 and and CC 19613 5906 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5906 37 is be VBZ 19613 5906 38 proved prove VBN 19613 5906 39 in in IN 19613 5906 40 opposition opposition NN 19613 5906 41 to to IN 19613 5906 42 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5906 43 that that IN 19613 5906 44 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5906 45 are be VBP 19613 5906 46 not not RB 19613 5906 47 mutually mutually RB 19613 5906 48 exclusive exclusive JJ 19613 5906 49 , , , 19613 5906 50 but but CC 19613 5906 51 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5906 52 involve involve VBP 19613 5906 53 each each DT 19613 5906 54 other other JJ 19613 5906 55 . . . 19613 5907 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5907 2 530 530 CD 19613 5907 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5907 4 In in IN 19613 5907 5 the the DT 19613 5907 6 case case NN 19613 5907 7 of of IN 19613 5907 8 the the DT 19613 5907 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5907 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5907 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5907 12 _ _ NNP 19613 5907 13 also also RB 19613 5907 14 , , , 19613 5907 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5907 16 and and CC 19613 5907 17 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5907 18 simply simply RB 19613 5907 19 adopted adopt VBD 19613 5907 20 and and CC 19613 5907 21 developed develop VBD 19613 5907 22 that that DT 19613 5907 23 of of IN 19613 5907 24 the the DT 19613 5907 25 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5907 26 , , , 19613 5907 27 whilst whilst IN 19613 5907 28 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5907 29 struck strike VBD 19613 5907 30 out out RP 19613 5907 31 a a DT 19613 5907 32 path path NN 19613 5907 33 of of IN 19613 5907 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5907 35 own own JJ 19613 5907 36 . . . 19613 5908 1 In in IN 19613 5908 2 the the DT 19613 5908 3 _ _ NNP 19613 5908 4 Apologeticum Apologeticum NNP 19613 5908 5 _ _ NNP 19613 5908 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5908 7 c. c. NNP 19613 5908 8 21 21 CD 19613 5908 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5908 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5908 11 set set VBD 19613 5908 12 forth forth RP 19613 5908 13 the the DT 19613 5908 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5908 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5908 16 as as IN 19613 5908 17 laid lay VBN 19613 5908 18 down down RP 19613 5908 19 by by IN 19613 5908 20 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5908 21 , , , 19613 5908 22 the the DT 19613 5908 23 only only JJ 19613 5908 24 noteworthy noteworthy JJ 19613 5908 25 difference difference NN 19613 5908 26 between between IN 19613 5908 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5908 28 and and CC 19613 5908 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5908 30 predecessor predecessor NN 19613 5908 31 consisting consist VBG 19613 5908 32 in in IN 19613 5908 33 the the DT 19613 5908 34 fact fact NN 19613 5908 35 that that IN 19613 5908 36 the the DT 19613 5908 37 appearance appearance NN 19613 5908 38 of of IN 19613 5908 39 the the DT 19613 5908 40 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5908 41 in in IN 19613 5908 42 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5908 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5908 44 was be VBD 19613 5908 45 the the DT 19613 5908 46 uniform uniform JJ 19613 5908 47 aim aim NN 19613 5908 48 of of IN 19613 5908 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5908 50 presentation presentation NN 19613 5908 51 . . . 19613 5909 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5909 2 531 531 CD 19613 5909 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5909 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5909 5 fully fully RB 19613 5909 6 explained explain VBD 19613 5909 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5909 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5909 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5909 10 in in IN 19613 5909 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5909 12 work work NN 19613 5909 13 against against IN 19613 5909 14 the the DT 19613 5909 15 Monarchian monarchian JJ 19613 5909 16 Praxeas Praxeas NNP 19613 5909 17 . . . 19613 5910 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5910 2 532 532 CD 19613 5910 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5910 4 Here here RB 19613 5910 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5910 6 created create VBD 19613 5910 7 the the DT 19613 5910 8 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 5910 9 of of IN 19613 5910 10 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 5910 11 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 5910 12 by by IN 19613 5910 13 introducing introduce VBG 19613 5910 14 the the DT 19613 5910 15 ideas idea NNS 19613 5910 16 " " `` 19613 5910 17 substance substance NN 19613 5910 18 " " '' 19613 5910 19 and and CC 19613 5910 20 " " `` 19613 5910 21 person person NN 19613 5910 22 " " '' 19613 5910 23 and and CC 19613 5910 24 by by IN 19613 5910 25 framing frame VBG 19613 5910 26 , , , 19613 5910 27 despite despite IN 19613 5910 28 of of IN 19613 5910 29 the the DT 19613 5910 30 most most RBS 19613 5910 31 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 5910 32 subordinationism subordinationism NN 19613 5910 33 and and CC 19613 5910 34 a a DT 19613 5910 35 purely purely RB 19613 5910 36 economical economical JJ 19613 5910 37 conception conception NN 19613 5910 38 of of IN 19613 5910 39 the the DT 19613 5910 40 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 5910 41 , , , 19613 5910 42 definitions definition NNS 19613 5910 43 of of IN 19613 5910 44 the the DT 19613 5910 45 relations relation NNS 19613 5910 46 between between IN 19613 5910 47 the the DT 19613 5910 48 persons person NNS 19613 5910 49 which which WDT 19613 5910 50 could could MD 19613 5910 51 be be VB 19613 5910 52 fully fully RB 19613 5910 53 adopted adopt VBN 19613 5910 54 in in IN 19613 5910 55 the the DT 19613 5910 56 Nicene nicene JJ 19613 5910 57 creed creed NN 19613 5910 58 . . . 19613 5911 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5911 2 533 533 CD 19613 5911 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5911 4 Here here RB 19613 5911 5 also also RB 19613 5911 6 the the DT 19613 5911 7 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5911 8 and and CC 19613 5911 9 cosmological cosmological JJ 19613 5911 10 interest interest NN 19613 5911 11 prevails prevail VBZ 19613 5911 12 ; ; : 19613 5911 13 the the DT 19613 5911 14 history history NN 19613 5911 15 of of IN 19613 5911 16 salvation salvation NN 19613 5911 17 appears appear VBZ 19613 5911 18 only only RB 19613 5911 19 to to TO 19613 5911 20 be be VB 19613 5911 21 the the DT 19613 5911 22 continuation continuation NN 19613 5911 23 of of IN 19613 5911 24 that that DT 19613 5911 25 of of IN 19613 5911 26 the the DT 19613 5911 27 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 5911 28 . . . 19613 5912 1 This this DT 19613 5912 2 system system NN 19613 5912 3 is be VBZ 19613 5912 4 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5912 5 from from IN 19613 5912 6 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 5912 7 by by IN 19613 5912 8 the the DT 19613 5912 9 history history NN 19613 5912 10 of of IN 19613 5912 11 redemption redemption NN 19613 5912 12 appearing appear VBG 19613 5912 13 as as IN 19613 5912 14 the the DT 19613 5912 15 natural natural JJ 19613 5912 16 continuation continuation NN 19613 5912 17 of of IN 19613 5912 18 the the DT 19613 5912 19 history history NN 19613 5912 20 of of IN 19613 5912 21 creation creation NN 19613 5912 22 and and CC 19613 5912 23 not not RB 19613 5912 24 simply simply RB 19613 5912 25 as as IN 19613 5912 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5912 27 correction correction NN 19613 5912 28 . . . 19613 5913 1 The the DT 19613 5913 2 thought thought NN 19613 5913 3 that that IN 19613 5913 4 the the DT 19613 5913 5 unity unity NN 19613 5913 6 of of IN 19613 5913 7 the the DT 19613 5913 8 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5913 9 is be VBZ 19613 5913 10 shown show VBN 19613 5913 11 in in IN 19613 5913 12 the the DT 19613 5913 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5913 14 una una NNP 19613 5913 15 substantia substantia NNS 19613 5913 16 _ _ NNP 19613 5913 17 and and CC 19613 5913 18 the the DT 19613 5913 19 _ _ NNP 19613 5913 20 una una NNP 19613 5913 21 dominatio dominatio NN 19613 5913 22 _ _ NNP 19613 5913 23 was be VBD 19613 5913 24 worked work VBN 19613 5913 25 out out RP 19613 5913 26 by by IN 19613 5913 27 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5913 28 with with IN 19613 5913 29 admirable admirable JJ 19613 5913 30 clearness clearness NN 19613 5913 31 . . . 19613 5914 1 According accord VBG 19613 5914 2 to to IN 19613 5914 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5914 4 the the DT 19613 5914 5 unfolding unfolding NN 19613 5914 6 of of IN 19613 5914 7 this this DT 19613 5914 8 one one CD 19613 5914 9 substance substance NN 19613 5914 10 into into IN 19613 5914 11 several several JJ 19613 5914 12 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 5914 13 embodiments embodiment NNS 19613 5914 14 , , , 19613 5914 15 or or CC 19613 5914 16 the the DT 19613 5914 17 administration administration NN 19613 5914 18 of of IN 19613 5914 19 the the DT 19613 5914 20 divine divine JJ 19613 5914 21 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 5914 22 by by IN 19613 5914 23 emanated emanate VBN 19613 5914 24 _ _ NNP 19613 5914 25 persons person NNS 19613 5914 26 _ _ NNP 19613 5914 27 can can MD 19613 5914 28 not not RB 19613 5914 29 endanger endanger VB 19613 5914 30 the the DT 19613 5914 31 unity unity NN 19613 5914 32 ; ; : 19613 5914 33 the the DT 19613 5914 34 " " `` 19613 5914 35 arrangement arrangement NN 19613 5914 36 of of IN 19613 5914 37 the the DT 19613 5914 38 unity unity NN 19613 5914 39 when when WRB 19613 5914 40 the the DT 19613 5914 41 unity unity NN 19613 5914 42 evolves evolve VBZ 19613 5914 43 the the DT 19613 5914 44 trinity trinity NN 19613 5914 45 from from IN 19613 5914 46 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5914 47 " " '' 19613 5914 48 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5914 49 " " `` 19613 5914 50 dispositio dispositio NNP 19613 5914 51 unitatis unitatis NNP 19613 5914 52 , , , 19613 5914 53 quando quando NNP 19613 5914 54 unitas unitas NNP 19613 5914 55 ex ex NNP 19613 5914 56 semetipsa semetipsa NNP 19613 5914 57 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5914 58 trinitatem trinitatem NN 19613 5914 59 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5914 60 derivat derivat NN 19613 5914 61 " " '' 19613 5914 62 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5914 63 does do VBZ 19613 5914 64 not not RB 19613 5914 65 abolish abolish VB 19613 5914 66 the the DT 19613 5914 67 unity unity NN 19613 5914 68 , , , 19613 5914 69 and and CC 19613 5914 70 , , , 19613 5914 71 moreover moreover RB 19613 5914 72 , , , 19613 5914 73 the the DT 19613 5914 74 Son Son NNP 19613 5914 75 will will MD 19613 5914 76 some some DT 19613 5914 77 day day NN 19613 5914 78 subject subject VB 19613 5914 79 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5914 80 to to IN 19613 5914 81 the the DT 19613 5914 82 Father Father NNP 19613 5914 83 , , , 19613 5914 84 so so IN 19613 5914 85 that that IN 19613 5914 86 God God NNP 19613 5914 87 will will MD 19613 5914 88 be be VB 19613 5914 89 all all DT 19613 5914 90 in in RB 19613 5914 91 all all DT 19613 5914 92 . . . 19613 5915 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5915 2 534 534 CD 19613 5915 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5915 4 Here here RB 19613 5915 5 then then RB 19613 5915 6 the the DT 19613 5915 7 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5915 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5915 9 of of IN 19613 5915 10 æons æon NNS 19613 5915 11 is be VBZ 19613 5915 12 adopted adopt VBN 19613 5915 13 in in IN 19613 5915 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5915 15 complete complete JJ 19613 5915 16 form form NN 19613 5915 17 , , , 19613 5915 18 and and CC 19613 5915 19 in in IN 19613 5915 20 fact fact NN 19613 5915 21 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5915 22 , , , 19613 5915 23 who who WP 19613 5915 24 in in IN 19613 5915 25 this this DT 19613 5915 26 respect respect NN 19613 5915 27 agrees agree VBZ 19613 5915 28 with with IN 19613 5915 29 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5915 30 , , , 19613 5915 31 has have VBZ 19613 5915 32 certified certify VBN 19613 5915 33 that that IN 19613 5915 34 the the DT 19613 5915 35 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 5915 36 " " `` 19613 5915 37 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 19613 5915 38 that that IN 19613 5915 39 the the DT 19613 5915 40 one one NN 19613 5915 41 is be VBZ 19613 5915 42 the the DT 19613 5915 43 originator originator NN 19613 5915 44 of of IN 19613 5915 45 all all DT 19613 5915 46 " " '' 19613 5915 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5915 48 " " '' 19613 5915 49 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5915 50 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5915 51 : : : 19613 5915 52 ton ton NNP 19613 5915 53 hena hena NNP 19613 5915 54 homologousin homologousin NNP 19613 5915 55 aition aition NNP 19613 5915 56 tôn tôn NNP 19613 5915 57 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 5915 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5915 59 " " '' 19613 5915 60 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5915 61 , , , 19613 5915 62 because because IN 19613 5915 63 with with IN 19613 5915 64 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5915 65 also also RB 19613 5915 66 , , , 19613 5915 67 " " `` 19613 5915 68 the the DT 19613 5915 69 whole whole NN 19613 5915 70 goes go VBZ 19613 5915 71 back back RB 19613 5915 72 to to IN 19613 5915 73 one one CD 19613 5915 74 " " '' 19613 5915 75 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5915 76 " " '' 19613 5915 77 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5915 78 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5915 79 : : : 19613 5915 80 to to TO 19613 5915 81 pan pan VB 19613 5915 82 eis eis NNP 19613 5915 83 hena hena NNP 19613 5915 84 anatrechei anatrechei NNP 19613 5915 85 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5915 86 " " `` 19613 5915 87 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5915 88 . . . 19613 5916 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5916 2 535 535 CD 19613 5916 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5916 4 The the DT 19613 5916 5 only only JJ 19613 5916 6 difference difference NN 19613 5916 7 is be VBZ 19613 5916 8 that that IN 19613 5916 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5916 10 and and CC 19613 5916 11 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5916 12 limit limit VB 19613 5916 13 the the DT 19613 5916 14 " " `` 19613 5916 15 economy economy NN 19613 5916 16 of of IN 19613 5916 17 God God NNP 19613 5916 18 " " '' 19613 5916 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5916 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5916 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5916 22 : : : 19613 5916 23 oikonomia oikonomia NN 19613 5916 24 tou tou NNP 19613 5916 25 Theou Theou NNP 19613 5916 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5916 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5916 28 to to IN 19613 5916 29 Father Father NNP 19613 5916 30 , , , 19613 5916 31 Son Son NNP 19613 5916 32 , , , 19613 5916 33 and and CC 19613 5916 34 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5916 35 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 5916 36 , , , 19613 5916 37 while while IN 19613 5916 38 the the DT 19613 5916 39 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5916 40 exceed exceed VBP 19613 5916 41 this this DT 19613 5916 42 number number NN 19613 5916 43 . . . 19613 5917 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5917 2 536 536 CD 19613 5917 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5917 4 According accord VBG 19613 5917 5 to to IN 19613 5917 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5917 7 " " `` 19613 5917 8 a a DT 19613 5917 9 rational rational JJ 19613 5917 10 conception conception NN 19613 5917 11 of of IN 19613 5917 12 the the DT 19613 5917 13 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 5917 14 constitutes constitute VBZ 19613 5917 15 truth truth NN 19613 5917 16 , , , 19613 5917 17 an an DT 19613 5917 18 irrational irrational JJ 19613 5917 19 idea idea NN 19613 5917 20 of of IN 19613 5917 21 the the DT 19613 5917 22 unity unity NN 19613 5917 23 makes make VBZ 19613 5917 24 heresy heresy NN 19613 5917 25 " " '' 19613 5917 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5917 27 " " `` 19613 5917 28 trinitas trinitas NNP 19613 5917 29 rationaliter rationaliter NNP 19613 5917 30 expensa expensa NNP 19613 5917 31 veritatem veritatem NNP 19613 5917 32 constituit constituit NNP 19613 5917 33 , , , 19613 5917 34 unitas unitas NNP 19613 5917 35 irrationaliter irrationaliter NNP 19613 5917 36 collecta collecta NNP 19613 5917 37 hæresim hæresim NNP 19613 5917 38 facit facit NNP 19613 5917 39 " " '' 19613 5917 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5917 41 is be VBZ 19613 5917 42 already already RB 19613 5917 43 the the DT 19613 5917 44 watchword watchword NN 19613 5917 45 of of IN 19613 5917 46 the the DT 19613 5917 47 Christian christian JJ 19613 5917 48 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 5917 49 . . . 19613 5918 1 Now now RB 19613 5918 2 what what WP 19613 5918 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5918 4 considers consider VBZ 19613 5918 5 a a DT 19613 5918 6 rational rational JJ 19613 5918 7 conception conception NN 19613 5918 8 is be VBZ 19613 5918 9 keeping keep VBG 19613 5918 10 in in IN 19613 5918 11 view view NN 19613 5918 12 the the DT 19613 5918 13 different different JJ 19613 5918 14 stages stage NNS 19613 5918 15 of of IN 19613 5918 16 God God NNP 19613 5918 17 's 's POS 19613 5918 18 economy economy NN 19613 5918 19 , , , 19613 5918 20 and and CC 19613 5918 21 distinguishing distinguish VBG 19613 5918 22 between between IN 19613 5918 23 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 24 dispositio dispositio NN 19613 5918 25 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 26 , , , 19613 5918 27 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 28 distinctio distinctio NN 19613 5918 29 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 30 , , , 19613 5918 31 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 32 numerus numerus NNP 19613 5918 33 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 34 on on IN 19613 5918 35 the the DT 19613 5918 36 one one CD 19613 5918 37 hand hand NN 19613 5918 38 and and CC 19613 5918 39 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 40 divisio divisio NNP 19613 5918 41 _ _ NNP 19613 5918 42 on on IN 19613 5918 43 the the DT 19613 5918 44 other other JJ 19613 5918 45 . . . 19613 5919 1 At at IN 19613 5919 2 the the DT 19613 5919 3 beginning beginning NN 19613 5919 4 God God NNP 19613 5919 5 was be VBD 19613 5919 6 alone alone JJ 19613 5919 7 , , , 19613 5919 8 but but CC 19613 5919 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5919 10 ratio ratio NN 19613 5919 11 _ _ NNP 19613 5919 12 and and CC 19613 5919 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5919 14 sermo sermo NN 19613 5919 15 _ _ NNP 19613 5919 16 existed exist VBD 19613 5919 17 within within IN 19613 5919 18 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5919 19 . . . 19613 5920 1 In in IN 19613 5920 2 a a DT 19613 5920 3 certain certain JJ 19613 5920 4 sense sense NN 19613 5920 5 then then RB 19613 5920 6 , , , 19613 5920 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5920 8 was be VBD 19613 5920 9 never never RB 19613 5920 10 alone alone JJ 19613 5920 11 , , , 19613 5920 12 for for IN 19613 5920 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5920 14 thought think VBD 19613 5920 15 and and CC 19613 5920 16 spoke speak VBD 19613 5920 17 inwardly inwardly RB 19613 5920 18 . . . 19613 5921 1 If if IN 19613 5921 2 even even RB 19613 5921 3 men man NNS 19613 5921 4 can can MD 19613 5921 5 carry carry VB 19613 5921 6 on on RP 19613 5921 7 conversations conversation NNS 19613 5921 8 with with IN 19613 5921 9 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5921 10 and and CC 19613 5921 11 make make VB 19613 5921 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 5921 13 objects object NNS 19613 5921 14 of of IN 19613 5921 15 reflection reflection NN 19613 5921 16 , , , 19613 5921 17 how how WRB 19613 5921 18 much much RB 19613 5921 19 more more JJR 19613 5921 20 is be VBZ 19613 5921 21 this this DT 19613 5921 22 possible possible JJ 19613 5921 23 with with IN 19613 5921 24 God God NNP 19613 5921 25 . . . 19613 5922 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5922 2 537 537 CD 19613 5922 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5922 4 But but CC 19613 5922 5 as as RB 19613 5922 6 yet yet RB 19613 5922 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5922 8 was be VBD 19613 5922 9 the the DT 19613 5922 10 only only JJ 19613 5922 11 _ _ NNP 19613 5922 12 person person NN 19613 5922 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5922 14 . . . 19613 5923 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5923 2 538 538 CD 19613 5923 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5923 4 The the DT 19613 5923 5 moment moment NN 19613 5923 6 , , , 19613 5923 7 however however RB 19613 5923 8 , , , 19613 5923 9 that that IN 19613 5923 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5923 11 chose choose VBD 19613 5923 12 to to TO 19613 5923 13 reveal reveal VB 19613 5923 14 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5923 15 and and CC 19613 5923 16 sent send VBD 19613 5923 17 forth forth RB 19613 5923 18 from from IN 19613 5923 19 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5923 20 the the DT 19613 5923 21 word word NN 19613 5923 22 of of IN 19613 5923 23 creation creation NN 19613 5923 24 , , , 19613 5923 25 the the DT 19613 5923 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5923 27 came come VBD 19613 5923 28 into into IN 19613 5923 29 existence existence NN 19613 5923 30 as as IN 19613 5923 31 a a DT 19613 5923 32 real real JJ 19613 5923 33 being being NN 19613 5923 34 , , , 19613 5923 35 before before IN 19613 5923 36 the the DT 19613 5923 37 world world NN 19613 5923 38 and and CC 19613 5923 39 for for IN 19613 5923 40 the the DT 19613 5923 41 sake sake NN 19613 5923 42 of of IN 19613 5923 43 the the DT 19613 5923 44 world world NN 19613 5923 45 . . . 19613 5924 1 For for IN 19613 5924 2 " " `` 19613 5924 3 that that WDT 19613 5924 4 which which WDT 19613 5924 5 proceeds proceed VBZ 19613 5924 6 from from IN 19613 5924 7 such such PDT 19613 5924 8 a a DT 19613 5924 9 great great JJ 19613 5924 10 substance substance NN 19613 5924 11 and and CC 19613 5924 12 has have VBZ 19613 5924 13 created create VBN 19613 5924 14 such such JJ 19613 5924 15 substances substance NNS 19613 5924 16 can can MD 19613 5924 17 not not RB 19613 5924 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5924 19 be be VB 19613 5924 20 devoid devoid JJ 19613 5924 21 of of IN 19613 5924 22 substance substance NN 19613 5924 23 . . . 19613 5924 24 " " '' 19613 5925 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5925 2 is be VBZ 19613 5925 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 5925 4 to to TO 19613 5925 5 be be VB 19613 5925 6 conceived conceive VBN 19613 5925 7 as as RB 19613 5925 8 permanently permanently RB 19613 5925 9 separate separate JJ 19613 5925 10 from from IN 19613 5925 11 God God NNP 19613 5925 12 " " `` 19613 5925 13 secundus secundus VB 19613 5925 14 a a DT 19613 5925 15 deo deo NNP 19613 5925 16 consititutus consititutus NN 19613 5925 17 , , , 19613 5925 18 perseverans perseveran NNS 19613 5925 19 in in IN 19613 5925 20 sua sua NN 19613 5925 21 forma forma NNP 19613 5925 22 " " '' 19613 5925 23 ; ; : 19613 5925 24 but but CC 19613 5925 25 as as IN 19613 5925 26 unity unity NN 19613 5925 27 of of IN 19613 5925 28 substance substance NN 19613 5925 29 is be VBZ 19613 5925 30 to to TO 19613 5925 31 be be VB 19613 5925 32 preserved preserve VBN 19613 5925 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5925 34 " " `` 19613 5925 35 _ _ NNP 19613 5925 36 alius alius NNP 19613 5925 37 pater pater NNP 19613 5925 38 , , , 19613 5925 39 alius alius NNP 19613 5925 40 filius filius NNP 19613 5925 41 , , , 19613 5925 42 alius alius NNP 19613 5925 43 non non AFX 19613 5925 44 aliud_"--"_ego aliud_"--"_ego NNP 19613 5925 45 et et FW 19613 5925 46 pater pater NNP 19613 5925 47 unum unum NNP 19613 5925 48 sumus sumus NNP 19613 5925 49 ad ad NN 19613 5925 50 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 5925 51 unitatem unitatem VB 19613 5925 52 , , , 19613 5925 53 non non AFX 19613 5925 54 ad ad NN 19613 5925 55 numeri numeri NNP 19613 5925 56 singularitatem singularitatem NNP 19613 5925 57 dictum dictum NNP 19613 5925 58 est_"--"_tres est_"--"_tres NNP 19613 5925 59 unum unum NN 19613 5925 60 sunt sunt NN 19613 5925 61 , , , 19613 5925 62 non non AFX 19613 5925 63 unus_"--"the unus_"--"the PRP$ 19613 5925 64 Father Father NNP 19613 5925 65 is be VBZ 19613 5925 66 one one CD 19613 5925 67 person person NN 19613 5925 68 and and CC 19613 5925 69 the the DT 19613 5925 70 Son Son NNP 19613 5925 71 is be VBZ 19613 5925 72 another another DT 19613 5925 73 , , , 19613 5925 74 different different JJ 19613 5925 75 persons person NNS 19613 5925 76 not not RB 19613 5925 77 different different JJ 19613 5925 78 things thing NNS 19613 5925 79 " " '' 19613 5925 80 , , , 19613 5925 81 " " `` 19613 5925 82 _ _ NNP 19613 5925 83 I I NNP 19613 5925 84 and and CC 19613 5925 85 the the DT 19613 5925 86 Father Father NNP 19613 5925 87 are be VBP 19613 5925 88 one one CD 19613 5925 89 _ _ NNP 19613 5925 90 refers refer VBZ 19613 5925 91 to to IN 19613 5925 92 unity unity NN 19613 5925 93 of of IN 19613 5925 94 substance substance NN 19613 5925 95 , , , 19613 5925 96 not not RB 19613 5925 97 to to TO 19613 5925 98 singleness singleness NN 19613 5925 99 in in IN 19613 5925 100 number"--"the number"--"the NNP 19613 5925 101 three three CD 19613 5925 102 are be VBP 19613 5925 103 one one CD 19613 5925 104 thing thing NN 19613 5925 105 not not RB 19613 5925 106 one one CD 19613 5925 107 person person NN 19613 5925 108 " " '' 19613 5925 109 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5925 110 , , , 19613 5925 111 the the DT 19613 5925 112 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5925 113 must must MD 19613 5925 114 be be VB 19613 5925 115 related relate VBN 19613 5925 116 to to IN 19613 5925 117 the the DT 19613 5925 118 Father Father NNP 19613 5925 119 as as IN 19613 5925 120 the the DT 19613 5925 121 ray ray NN 19613 5925 122 to to IN 19613 5925 123 the the DT 19613 5925 124 sun sun NN 19613 5925 125 , , , 19613 5925 126 as as IN 19613 5925 127 the the DT 19613 5925 128 stream stream NN 19613 5925 129 to to IN 19613 5925 130 the the DT 19613 5925 131 source source NN 19613 5925 132 , , , 19613 5925 133 as as IN 19613 5925 134 the the DT 19613 5925 135 stem stem NN 19613 5925 136 to to IN 19613 5925 137 the the DT 19613 5925 138 root root NN 19613 5925 139 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5925 140 see see VB 19613 5925 141 also also RB 19613 5925 142 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5925 143 , , , 19613 5925 144 c. c. NN 19613 5925 145 Noëtum Noëtum NNP 19613 5925 146 10 10 CD 19613 5925 147 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5925 148 . . . 19613 5926 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5926 2 539 539 CD 19613 5926 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5926 4 For for IN 19613 5926 5 that that DT 19613 5926 6 very very JJ 19613 5926 7 reason reason NN 19613 5926 8 " " `` 19613 5926 9 Son Son NNP 19613 5926 10 " " '' 19613 5926 11 is be VBZ 19613 5926 12 the the DT 19613 5926 13 most most RBS 19613 5926 14 suitable suitable JJ 19613 5926 15 expression expression NN 19613 5926 16 for for IN 19613 5926 17 the the DT 19613 5926 18 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5926 19 that that WDT 19613 5926 20 has have VBZ 19613 5926 21 emanated emanate VBN 19613 5926 22 in in IN 19613 5926 23 this this DT 19613 5926 24 way way NN 19613 5926 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5926 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5926 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5926 28 : : : 19613 5926 29 kata kata NNP 19613 5926 30 merismon merismon NNP 19613 5926 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5926 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5926 33 . . . 19613 5927 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 5927 2 , , , 19613 5927 3 since since IN 19613 5927 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5927 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5927 6 as as RB 19613 5927 7 well well RB 19613 5927 8 as as IN 19613 5927 9 the the DT 19613 5927 10 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5927 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5927 12 has have VBZ 19613 5927 13 the the DT 19613 5927 14 same same JJ 19613 5927 15 substance substance NN 19613 5927 16 as as IN 19613 5927 17 the the DT 19613 5927 18 Father Father NNP 19613 5927 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5927 20 " " `` 19613 5927 21 unius unius NNP 19613 5927 22 substantia substantia NNP 19613 5927 23 " " '' 19613 5927 24 = = NFP 19613 5927 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5927 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5927 27 : : : 19613 5927 28 homoousios homoousio NNS 19613 5927 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5927 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5927 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5927 32 has have VBZ 19613 5927 33 also also RB 19613 5927 34 the the DT 19613 5927 35 same same JJ 19613 5927 36 _ _ NNP 19613 5927 37 power_[540 power_[540 NNP 19613 5927 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5927 39 as as IN 19613 5927 40 regards regard VBZ 19613 5927 41 the the DT 19613 5927 42 world world NN 19613 5927 43 . . . 19613 5928 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5928 2 has have VBZ 19613 5928 3 all all DT 19613 5928 4 might may MD 19613 5928 5 in in IN 19613 5928 6 heaven heaven NNP 19613 5928 7 and and CC 19613 5928 8 earth earth NN 19613 5928 9 , , , 19613 5928 10 and and CC 19613 5928 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5928 12 has have VBZ 19613 5928 13 had have VBN 19613 5928 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5928 15 _ _ NNP 19613 5928 16 ab ab NNP 19613 5928 17 initio initio NNP 19613 5928 18 _ _ NNP 19613 5928 19 , , , 19613 5928 20 from from IN 19613 5928 21 the the DT 19613 5928 22 very very JJ 19613 5928 23 beginning beginning NN 19613 5928 24 of of IN 19613 5928 25 time time NN 19613 5928 26 . . . 19613 5929 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5929 2 541 541 CD 19613 5929 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5929 4 On on IN 19613 5929 5 the the DT 19613 5929 6 other other JJ 19613 5929 7 hand hand NN 19613 5929 8 this this DT 19613 5929 9 same same JJ 19613 5929 10 Son Son NNP 19613 5929 11 is be VBZ 19613 5929 12 only only RB 19613 5929 13 a a DT 19613 5929 14 part part NN 19613 5929 15 and and CC 19613 5929 16 offshoot offshoot NN 19613 5929 17 ; ; : 19613 5929 18 the the DT 19613 5929 19 Father Father NNP 19613 5929 20 is be VBZ 19613 5929 21 the the DT 19613 5929 22 whole whole NN 19613 5929 23 ; ; : 19613 5929 24 and and CC 19613 5929 25 in in IN 19613 5929 26 this this DT 19613 5929 27 the the DT 19613 5929 28 mystery mystery NN 19613 5929 29 of of IN 19613 5929 30 the the DT 19613 5929 31 economy economy NN 19613 5929 32 consists consist VBZ 19613 5929 33 . . . 19613 5930 1 What what WP 19613 5930 2 the the DT 19613 5930 3 Son Son NNP 19613 5930 4 possesses possess VBZ 19613 5930 5 has have VBZ 19613 5930 6 been be VBN 19613 5930 7 given give VBN 19613 5930 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5930 9 by by IN 19613 5930 10 the the DT 19613 5930 11 Father Father NNP 19613 5930 12 ; ; : 19613 5930 13 the the DT 19613 5930 14 Father Father NNP 19613 5930 15 is be VBZ 19613 5930 16 therefore therefore RB 19613 5930 17 greater great JJR 19613 5930 18 than than IN 19613 5930 19 the the DT 19613 5930 20 Son Son NNP 19613 5930 21 ; ; : 19613 5930 22 the the DT 19613 5930 23 Son Son NNP 19613 5930 24 is be VBZ 19613 5930 25 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 5930 26 to to IN 19613 5930 27 the the DT 19613 5930 28 Father Father NNP 19613 5930 29 . . . 19613 5931 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5931 2 542 542 CD 19613 5931 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5931 4 " " `` 19613 5931 5 Pater Pater NNP 19613 5931 6 tota tota NNP 19613 5931 7 substantia substantia NNP 19613 5931 8 est est NNP 19613 5931 9 , , , 19613 5931 10 filius filius NNP 19613 5931 11 vero vero NNP 19613 5931 12 derivatio derivatio NNP 19613 5931 13 totius totius NNP 19613 5931 14 et et NNP 19613 5931 15 portio portio NNP 19613 5931 16 " " '' 19613 5931 17 . . . 19613 5932 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5932 2 543 543 CD 19613 5932 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5932 4 This this DT 19613 5932 5 paradox paradox NN 19613 5932 6 is be VBZ 19613 5932 7 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 5932 8 based base VBN 19613 5932 9 on on IN 19613 5932 10 a a DT 19613 5932 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 5932 12 axiom axiom NN 19613 5932 13 of of IN 19613 5932 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5932 15 : : : 19613 5932 16 the the DT 19613 5932 17 whole whole JJ 19613 5932 18 fulness fulness NN 19613 5932 19 of of IN 19613 5932 20 the the DT 19613 5932 21 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5932 22 , , , 19613 5932 23 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5932 24 , , , 19613 5932 25 the the DT 19613 5932 26 Father Father NNP 19613 5932 27 , , , 19613 5932 28 is be VBZ 19613 5932 29 incapable incapable JJ 19613 5932 30 of of IN 19613 5932 31 entering enter VBG 19613 5932 32 into into IN 19613 5932 33 the the DT 19613 5932 34 finite finite NN 19613 5932 35 , , , 19613 5932 36 whence whence NN 19613 5932 37 also also RB 19613 5932 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5932 39 must must MD 19613 5932 40 always always RB 19613 5932 41 remain remain VB 19613 5932 42 invisible invisible JJ 19613 5932 43 , , , 19613 5932 44 unapproachable unapproachable JJ 19613 5932 45 , , , 19613 5932 46 and and CC 19613 5932 47 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 19613 5932 48 . . . 19613 5933 1 The the DT 19613 5933 2 Divine Divine NNP 19613 5933 3 Being Being NNP 19613 5933 4 that that WDT 19613 5933 5 appears appear VBZ 19613 5933 6 and and CC 19613 5933 7 works work VBZ 19613 5933 8 on on IN 19613 5933 9 earth earth NN 19613 5933 10 can can MD 19613 5933 11 never never RB 19613 5933 12 be be VB 19613 5933 13 anything anything NN 19613 5933 14 but but IN 19613 5933 15 a a DT 19613 5933 16 part part NN 19613 5933 17 of of IN 19613 5933 18 the the DT 19613 5933 19 transcendent transcendent NN 19613 5933 20 Deity deity NN 19613 5933 21 . . . 19613 5934 1 This this DT 19613 5934 2 Being being NN 19613 5934 3 must must MD 19613 5934 4 be be VB 19613 5934 5 a a DT 19613 5934 6 derived derive VBN 19613 5934 7 existence existence NN 19613 5934 8 , , , 19613 5934 9 which which WDT 19613 5934 10 has have VBZ 19613 5934 11 already already RB 19613 5934 12 in in IN 19613 5934 13 some some DT 19613 5934 14 fashion fashion NN 19613 5934 15 a a DT 19613 5934 16 finite finite JJ 19613 5934 17 element element NN 19613 5934 18 in in IN 19613 5934 19 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5934 20 , , , 19613 5934 21 because because IN 19613 5934 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5934 23 is be VBZ 19613 5934 24 the the DT 19613 5934 25 hypostatised hypostatised JJ 19613 5934 26 Word word NN 19613 5934 27 of of IN 19613 5934 28 creation creation NN 19613 5934 29 , , , 19613 5934 30 which which WDT 19613 5934 31 has have VBZ 19613 5934 32 an an DT 19613 5934 33 origin origin NN 19613 5934 34 . . . 19613 5935 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5935 2 544 544 CD 19613 5935 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5935 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5935 5 would would MD 19613 5935 6 assert assert VB 19613 5935 7 too too RB 19613 5935 8 much much RB 19613 5935 9 , , , 19613 5935 10 were be VBD 19613 5935 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5935 12 to to TO 19613 5935 13 say say VB 19613 5935 14 that that IN 19613 5935 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5935 16 meant mean VBD 19613 5935 17 that that IN 19613 5935 18 the the DT 19613 5935 19 Son Son NNP 19613 5935 20 was be VBD 19613 5935 21 simply simply RB 19613 5935 22 the the DT 19613 5935 23 world world NN 19613 5935 24 - - HYPH 19613 5935 25 thought think VBD 19613 5935 26 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5935 27 ; ; : 19613 5935 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5935 29 insistance insistance NN 19613 5935 30 on on IN 19613 5935 31 the the DT 19613 5935 32 " " `` 19613 5935 33 unius unius NN 19613 5935 34 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 5935 35 " " '' 19613 5935 36 disproves disprove VBZ 19613 5935 37 this this DT 19613 5935 38 . . . 19613 5936 1 But but CC 19613 5936 2 no no DT 19613 5936 3 doubt doubt RB 19613 5936 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5936 5 regards regard VBZ 19613 5936 6 the the DT 19613 5936 7 Son Son NNP 19613 5936 8 as as IN 19613 5936 9 the the DT 19613 5936 10 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5936 11 depotentiated depotentiate VBD 19613 5936 12 for for IN 19613 5936 13 the the DT 19613 5936 14 sake sake NN 19613 5936 15 of of IN 19613 5936 16 self self NN 19613 5936 17 - - HYPH 19613 5936 18 communication communication NN 19613 5936 19 ; ; : 19613 5936 20 the the DT 19613 5936 21 Deity deity NN 19613 5936 22 adapted adapt VBD 19613 5936 23 to to IN 19613 5936 24 the the DT 19613 5936 25 world world NN 19613 5936 26 , , , 19613 5936 27 whose whose WP$ 19613 5936 28 sphere sphere NN 19613 5936 29 coincides coincide VBZ 19613 5936 30 with with IN 19613 5936 31 the the DT 19613 5936 32 world world NN 19613 5936 33 - - HYPH 19613 5936 34 thought think VBN 19613 5936 35 , , , 19613 5936 36 and and CC 19613 5936 37 whose whose WP$ 19613 5936 38 power power NN 19613 5936 39 is be VBZ 19613 5936 40 identical identical JJ 19613 5936 41 with with IN 19613 5936 42 that that DT 19613 5936 43 necessary necessary JJ 19613 5936 44 for for IN 19613 5936 45 the the DT 19613 5936 46 world world NN 19613 5936 47 . . . 19613 5937 1 From from IN 19613 5937 2 the the DT 19613 5937 3 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 5937 4 of of IN 19613 5937 5 humanity humanity NN 19613 5937 6 this this DT 19613 5937 7 Deity deity NN 19613 5937 8 is be VBZ 19613 5937 9 God God NNP 19613 5937 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5937 11 , , , 19613 5937 12 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5937 13 , , , 19613 5937 14 a a DT 19613 5937 15 God God NNP 19613 5937 16 whom whom WP 19613 5937 17 men man NNS 19613 5937 18 can can MD 19613 5937 19 apprehend apprehend VB 19613 5937 20 and and CC 19613 5937 21 who who WP 19613 5937 22 can can MD 19613 5937 23 apprehend apprehend VB 19613 5937 24 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5937 25 ; ; : 19613 5937 26 but but CC 19613 5937 27 from from IN 19613 5937 28 God God NNP 19613 5937 29 's 's POS 19613 5937 30 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 5937 31 , , , 19613 5937 32 which which WDT 19613 5937 33 speculation speculation NN 19613 5937 34 can can MD 19613 5937 35 fix fix VB 19613 5937 36 but but CC 19613 5937 37 not not RB 19613 5937 38 fathom fathom VB 19613 5937 39 , , , 19613 5937 40 this this DT 19613 5937 41 Deity deity NN 19613 5937 42 is be VBZ 19613 5937 43 a a DT 19613 5937 44 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 5937 45 , , , 19613 5937 46 nay nay NN 19613 5937 47 , , , 19613 5937 48 even even RB 19613 5937 49 a a DT 19613 5937 50 temporary temporary JJ 19613 5937 51 one one NN 19613 5937 52 . . . 19613 5938 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5938 2 and and CC 19613 5938 3 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5938 4 know know VBP 19613 5938 5 as as RB 19613 5938 6 little little JJ 19613 5938 7 of of IN 19613 5938 8 an an DT 19613 5938 9 immanent immanent NN 19613 5938 10 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 5938 11 as as IN 19613 5938 12 the the DT 19613 5938 13 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5938 14 ; ; : 19613 5938 15 the the DT 19613 5938 16 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 5938 17 only only RB 19613 5938 18 _ _ NNP 19613 5938 19 appears appear VBZ 19613 5938 20 _ _ NNP 19613 5938 21 such such JJ 19613 5938 22 , , , 19613 5938 23 because because IN 19613 5938 24 the the DT 19613 5938 25 unity unity NN 19613 5938 26 of of IN 19613 5938 27 the the DT 19613 5938 28 substance substance NN 19613 5938 29 is be VBZ 19613 5938 30 very very RB 19613 5938 31 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 5938 32 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 5938 33 ; ; : 19613 5938 34 but but CC 19613 5938 35 in in IN 19613 5938 36 truth truth NN 19613 5938 37 the the DT 19613 5938 38 Trinitarian Trinitarian NNP 19613 5938 39 process process NN 19613 5938 40 as as IN 19613 5938 41 in in IN 19613 5938 42 the the DT 19613 5938 43 case case NN 19613 5938 44 of of IN 19613 5938 45 the the DT 19613 5938 46 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 5938 47 , , , 19613 5938 48 is be VBZ 19613 5938 49 simply simply RB 19613 5938 50 the the DT 19613 5938 51 background background NN 19613 5938 52 of of IN 19613 5938 53 the the DT 19613 5938 54 process process NN 19613 5938 55 that that WDT 19613 5938 56 produces produce VBZ 19613 5938 57 the the DT 19613 5938 58 history history NN 19613 5938 59 of of IN 19613 5938 60 the the DT 19613 5938 61 world world NN 19613 5938 62 and and CC 19613 5938 63 of of IN 19613 5938 64 salvation salvation NN 19613 5938 65 . . . 19613 5939 1 This this DT 19613 5939 2 is be VBZ 19613 5939 3 first first RB 19613 5939 4 of of IN 19613 5939 5 all all DT 19613 5939 6 shown show VBN 19613 5939 7 by by IN 19613 5939 8 the the DT 19613 5939 9 fact fact NN 19613 5939 10 that that IN 19613 5939 11 in in IN 19613 5939 12 course course NN 19613 5939 13 of of IN 19613 5939 14 the the DT 19613 5939 15 process process NN 19613 5939 16 of of IN 19613 5939 17 the the DT 19613 5939 18 world world NN 19613 5939 19 and and CC 19613 5939 20 of of IN 19613 5939 21 salvation salvation NN 19613 5939 22 the the DT 19613 5939 23 Son Son NNP 19613 5939 24 grows grow VBZ 19613 5939 25 in in IN 19613 5939 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5939 27 sonship sonship NN 19613 5939 28 , , , 19613 5939 29 that that RB 19613 5939 30 is is RB 19613 5939 31 , , , 19613 5939 32 goes go VBZ 19613 5939 33 through through IN 19613 5939 34 a a DT 19613 5939 35 finite finite JJ 19613 5939 36 process;[545 process;[545 NNP 19613 5939 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5939 38 and and CC 19613 5939 39 secondly secondly RB 19613 5939 40 by by IN 19613 5939 41 the the DT 19613 5939 42 fact fact NN 19613 5939 43 that that IN 19613 5939 44 the the DT 19613 5939 45 Son Son NNP 19613 5939 46 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5939 47 will will MD 19613 5939 48 one one CD 19613 5939 49 day day NN 19613 5939 50 restore restore VB 19613 5939 51 the the DT 19613 5939 52 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 5939 53 to to IN 19613 5939 54 the the DT 19613 5939 55 Father Father NNP 19613 5939 56 . . . 19613 5940 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5940 2 546 546 CD 19613 5940 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5940 4 These these DT 19613 5940 5 words word NNS 19613 5940 6 no no DT 19613 5940 7 doubt doubt RB 19613 5940 8 are be VBP 19613 5940 9 again again RB 19613 5940 10 spoken speak VBN 19613 5940 11 not not RB 19613 5940 12 from from IN 19613 5940 13 the the DT 19613 5940 14 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 5940 15 of of IN 19613 5940 16 man man NN 19613 5940 17 , , , 19613 5940 18 but but CC 19613 5940 19 from from IN 19613 5940 20 that that DT 19613 5940 21 of of IN 19613 5940 22 God God NNP 19613 5940 23 ; ; : 19613 5940 24 for for IN 19613 5940 25 so so RB 19613 5940 26 long long RB 19613 5940 27 as as IN 19613 5940 28 history history NN 19613 5940 29 lasts last VBZ 19613 5940 30 " " `` 19613 5940 31 the the DT 19613 5940 32 Son Son NNP 19613 5940 33 continues continue VBZ 19613 5940 34 in in IN 19613 5940 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5940 36 form form NN 19613 5940 37 . . . 19613 5940 38 " " '' 19613 5941 1 In in IN 19613 5941 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5941 3 point point NN 19613 5941 4 of of IN 19613 5941 5 departure departure NN 19613 5941 6 , , , 19613 5941 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5941 8 plan plan NN 19613 5941 9 , , , 19613 5941 10 and and CC 19613 5941 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5941 12 details detail NNS 19613 5941 13 this this DT 19613 5941 14 whole whole JJ 19613 5941 15 exposition exposition NN 19613 5941 16 is be VBZ 19613 5941 17 not not RB 19613 5941 18 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 5941 19 from from IN 19613 5941 20 the the DT 19613 5941 21 teachings teaching NNS 19613 5941 22 of of IN 19613 5941 23 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 19613 5941 24 and and CC 19613 5941 25 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 5941 26 Greek greek JJ 19613 5941 27 philosophers,[547 philosophers,[547 NN 19613 5941 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5941 29 but but CC 19613 5941 30 merely merely RB 19613 5941 31 differs differ VBZ 19613 5941 32 in in IN 19613 5941 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5941 34 aim aim NN 19613 5941 35 . . . 19613 5942 1 In in IN 19613 5942 2 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5942 3 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 5942 4 unfitted unfitted JJ 19613 5942 5 to to TO 19613 5942 6 preserve preserve VB 19613 5942 7 the the DT 19613 5942 8 primitive primitive JJ 19613 5942 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 5942 10 belief belief NN 19613 5942 11 in in IN 19613 5942 12 God God NNP 19613 5942 13 the the DT 19613 5942 14 Father Father NNP 19613 5942 15 and and CC 19613 5942 16 the the DT 19613 5942 17 Lord Lord NNP 19613 5942 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5942 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5942 20 , , , 19613 5942 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5942 22 importance importance NN 19613 5942 23 consists consist VBZ 19613 5942 24 in in IN 19613 5942 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5942 26 identification identification NN 19613 5942 27 of of IN 19613 5942 28 the the DT 19613 5942 29 historical historical JJ 19613 5942 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5942 31 with with IN 19613 5942 32 this this DT 19613 5942 33 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5942 34 . . . 19613 5943 1 By by IN 19613 5943 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5943 3 aid aid NN 19613 5943 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5943 5 united unite VBD 19613 5943 6 the the DT 19613 5943 7 scientific scientific JJ 19613 5943 8 , , , 19613 5943 9 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 5943 10 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 5943 11 with with IN 19613 5943 12 the the DT 19613 5943 13 utterances utterance NNS 19613 5943 14 of of IN 19613 5943 15 early early JJ 19613 5943 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 5943 17 tradition tradition NN 19613 5943 18 about about IN 19613 5943 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5943 20 in in IN 19613 5943 21 such such PDT 19613 5943 22 a a DT 19613 5943 23 way way NN 19613 5943 24 as as IN 19613 5943 25 to to TO 19613 5943 26 make make VB 19613 5943 27 the the DT 19613 5943 28 two two CD 19613 5943 29 , , , 19613 5943 30 as as IN 19613 5943 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5943 32 were be VBD 19613 5943 33 , , , 19613 5943 34 appear appear VB 19613 5943 35 the the DT 19613 5943 36 totally totally RB 19613 5943 37 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 19613 5943 38 wings wing NNS 19613 5943 39 of of IN 19613 5943 40 one one CD 19613 5943 41 and and CC 19613 5943 42 the the DT 19613 5943 43 same same JJ 19613 5943 44 building,[548 building,[548 NN 19613 5943 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5943 46 With with IN 19613 5943 47 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 5943 48 versatility versatility NN 19613 5943 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5943 50 contrived contrive VBD 19613 5943 51 to to TO 19613 5943 52 make make VB 19613 5943 53 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5943 54 at at IN 19613 5943 55 home home NN 19613 5943 56 in in IN 19613 5943 57 both both DT 19613 5943 58 wings wing NNS 19613 5943 59 . . . 19613 5944 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5944 2 is be VBZ 19613 5944 3 essentially essentially RB 19613 5944 4 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 5944 5 with with IN 19613 5944 6 the the DT 19613 5944 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5944 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5944 9 of of IN 19613 5944 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5944 11 . . . 19613 5945 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5945 2 549 549 CD 19613 5945 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5945 4 Whereas Whereas NNP 19613 5945 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5945 6 and and CC 19613 5945 7 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5945 8 developed develop VBD 19613 5945 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5945 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5945 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5945 12 without without IN 19613 5945 13 reference reference NN 19613 5945 14 to to IN 19613 5945 15 the the DT 19613 5945 16 historical historical JJ 19613 5945 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5945 18 , , , 19613 5945 19 the the DT 19613 5945 20 truth truth NN 19613 5945 21 rather rather RB 19613 5945 22 being be VBG 19613 5945 23 that that IN 19613 5945 24 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5945 25 simply simply RB 19613 5945 26 add add VBP 19613 5945 27 the the DT 19613 5945 28 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5945 29 to to IN 19613 5945 30 the the DT 19613 5945 31 already already RB 19613 5945 32 existing exist VBG 19613 5945 33 theory theory NN 19613 5945 34 of of IN 19613 5945 35 the the DT 19613 5945 36 subject subject NN 19613 5945 37 , , , 19613 5945 38 there there EX 19613 5945 39 is be VBZ 19613 5945 40 no no DT 19613 5945 41 doubt doubt NN 19613 5945 42 that that IN 19613 5945 43 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5945 44 , , , 19613 5945 45 as as IN 19613 5945 46 a a DT 19613 5945 47 rule rule NN 19613 5945 48 , , , 19613 5945 49 made make VBD 19613 5945 50 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5945 51 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5945 52 , , , 19613 5945 53 whom whom WP 19613 5945 54 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5945 55 views view VBZ 19613 5945 56 as as IN 19613 5945 57 God God NNP 19613 5945 58 and and CC 19613 5945 59 man man NN 19613 5945 60 , , , 19613 5945 61 the the DT 19613 5945 62 _ _ NNP 19613 5945 63 starting starting NN 19613 5945 64 - - HYPH 19613 5945 65 point point NN 19613 5945 66 _ _ NNP 19613 5945 67 of of IN 19613 5945 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5945 69 speculation speculation NN 19613 5945 70 . . . 19613 5946 1 Here here RB 19613 5946 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5946 3 followed follow VBD 19613 5946 4 the the DT 19613 5946 5 Fourth Fourth NNP 19613 5946 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 5946 7 and and CC 19613 5946 8 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 5946 9 . . . 19613 5947 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5947 2 is be VBZ 19613 5947 3 of of IN 19613 5947 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5947 5 that that IN 19613 5947 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5947 7 almost almost RB 19613 5947 8 always always RB 19613 5947 9 thinks think VBZ 19613 5947 10 when when WRB 19613 5947 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5947 12 speaks speak VBZ 19613 5947 13 of of IN 19613 5947 14 the the DT 19613 5947 15 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5947 16 or or CC 19613 5947 17 of of IN 19613 5947 18 the the DT 19613 5947 19 Son Son NNP 19613 5947 20 of of IN 19613 5947 21 God God NNP 19613 5947 22 ; ; : 19613 5947 23 and and CC 19613 5947 24 therefore therefore RB 19613 5947 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5947 26 does do VBZ 19613 5947 27 not not RB 19613 5947 28 identify identify VB 19613 5947 29 the the DT 19613 5947 30 divine divine JJ 19613 5947 31 element element NN 19613 5947 32 in in IN 19613 5947 33 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5947 34 or or CC 19613 5947 35 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5947 36 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5947 37 with with IN 19613 5947 38 the the DT 19613 5947 39 world world NN 19613 5947 40 idea idea NN 19613 5947 41 or or CC 19613 5947 42 the the DT 19613 5947 43 creating create VBG 19613 5947 44 Word word NN 19613 5947 45 or or CC 19613 5947 46 the the DT 19613 5947 47 Reason Reason NNP 19613 5947 48 of of IN 19613 5947 49 God God NNP 19613 5947 50 . . . 19613 5948 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5948 2 550 550 CD 19613 5948 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5948 4 That that IN 19613 5948 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5948 6 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 5948 7 makes make VBZ 19613 5948 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5948 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5948 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5948 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 5948 12 : : : 19613 5948 13 monogenês monogenês NNP 19613 5948 14 , , , 19613 5948 15 prôtotokos prôtotokos NNP 19613 5948 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5948 17 , , , 19613 5948 18 " " `` 19613 5948 19 only only RB 19613 5948 20 begotten begotten VBP 19613 5948 21 , , , 19613 5948 22 " " '' 19613 5948 23 " " `` 19613 5948 24 first first RB 19613 5948 25 born bear VBN 19613 5948 26 " " '' 19613 5948 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5948 28 the the DT 19613 5948 29 regular regular JJ 19613 5948 30 designation designation NN 19613 5948 31 of of IN 19613 5948 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5948 33 as as IN 19613 5948 34 the the DT 19613 5948 35 preëxistent preëxistent NN 19613 5948 36 One one PRP 19613 5948 37 can can MD 19613 5948 38 only only RB 19613 5948 39 be be VB 19613 5948 40 explained explain VBN 19613 5948 41 from from IN 19613 5948 42 the the DT 19613 5948 43 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5948 44 tradition tradition NN 19613 5948 45 which which WDT 19613 5948 46 in in IN 19613 5948 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5948 48 time time NN 19613 5948 49 was be VBD 19613 5948 50 already already RB 19613 5948 51 recognised recognise VBN 19613 5948 52 as as IN 19613 5948 53 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 5948 54 by by IN 19613 5948 55 Christian christian JJ 19613 5948 56 scholars scholar NNS 19613 5948 57 , , , 19613 5948 58 and and CC 19613 5948 59 moreover moreover RB 19613 5948 60 appeared appear VBD 19613 5948 61 justified justify VBN 19613 5948 62 and and CC 19613 5948 63 required require VBN 19613 5948 64 by by IN 19613 5948 65 John John NNP 19613 5948 66 I. I. NNP 19613 5949 1 1 1 LS 19613 5949 2 . . . 19613 5950 1 Since since IN 19613 5950 2 both both CC 19613 5950 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5950 4 and and CC 19613 5950 5 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 5950 6 consider consider VBP 19613 5950 7 redemption redemption NN 19613 5950 8 to to TO 19613 5950 9 be be VB 19613 5950 10 the the DT 19613 5950 11 special special JJ 19613 5950 12 work work NN 19613 5950 13 of of IN 19613 5950 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5950 15 , , , 19613 5950 16 the the DT 19613 5950 17 cosmological cosmological JJ 19613 5950 18 interest interest NN 19613 5950 19 in in IN 19613 5950 20 the the DT 19613 5950 21 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5950 22 of of IN 19613 5950 23 the the DT 19613 5950 24 second second JJ 19613 5950 25 God God NNP 19613 5950 26 becomes become VBZ 19613 5950 27 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 5950 28 to to IN 19613 5950 29 the the DT 19613 5950 30 soteriological soteriological NN 19613 5950 31 . . . 19613 5951 1 As as IN 19613 5951 2 , , , 19613 5951 3 however however RB 19613 5951 4 , , , 19613 5951 5 in in IN 19613 5951 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5951 7 ' ' POS 19613 5951 8 system system NN 19613 5951 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5951 10 in in IN 19613 5951 11 opposition opposition NN 19613 5951 12 to to IN 19613 5951 13 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 5951 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5951 15 this this DT 19613 5951 16 real real JJ 19613 5951 17 redemption redemption NN 19613 5951 18 is be VBZ 19613 5951 19 to to TO 19613 5951 20 be be VB 19613 5951 21 imagined imagine VBN 19613 5951 22 as as IN 19613 5951 23 _ _ NNP 19613 5951 24 recapitulatio recapitulatio NN 19613 5951 25 _ _ NNP 19613 5951 26 of of IN 19613 5951 27 the the DT 19613 5951 28 creation creation NN 19613 5951 29 , , , 19613 5951 30 redemption redemption NN 19613 5951 31 and and CC 19613 5951 32 creation creation NN 19613 5951 33 are be VBP 19613 5951 34 not not RB 19613 5951 35 opposed opposed JJ 19613 5951 36 to to IN 19613 5951 37 each each DT 19613 5951 38 other other JJ 19613 5951 39 as as IN 19613 5951 40 antitheses antithesis NNS 19613 5951 41 ; ; : 19613 5951 42 and and CC 19613 5951 43 therefore therefore RB 19613 5951 44 the the DT 19613 5951 45 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 5951 46 has have VBZ 19613 5951 47 also also RB 19613 5951 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5951 49 place place NN 19613 5951 50 in in IN 19613 5951 51 the the DT 19613 5951 52 history history NN 19613 5951 53 of of IN 19613 5951 54 creation creation NN 19613 5951 55 . . . 19613 5952 1 In in IN 19613 5952 2 a a DT 19613 5952 3 certain certain JJ 19613 5952 4 sense sense NN 19613 5952 5 then then RB 19613 5952 6 the the DT 19613 5952 7 Christology Christology NNP 19613 5952 8 of of IN 19613 5952 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5952 10 occupies occupy VBZ 19613 5952 11 a a DT 19613 5952 12 middle middle JJ 19613 5952 13 position position NN 19613 5952 14 between between IN 19613 5952 15 the the DT 19613 5952 16 Christology Christology NNP 19613 5952 17 of of IN 19613 5952 18 the the DT 19613 5952 19 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 5952 20 and and CC 19613 5952 21 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5952 22 on on IN 19613 5952 23 the the DT 19613 5952 24 one one CD 19613 5952 25 hand hand NN 19613 5952 26 and and CC 19613 5952 27 the the DT 19613 5952 28 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5952 29 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 5952 30 of of IN 19613 5952 31 the the DT 19613 5952 32 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5952 33 on on IN 19613 5952 34 the the DT 19613 5952 35 other other JJ 19613 5952 36 . . . 19613 5953 1 The the DT 19613 5953 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5953 3 have have VBP 19613 5953 4 a a DT 19613 5953 5 cosmological cosmological JJ 19613 5953 6 interest interest NN 19613 5953 7 , , , 19613 5953 8 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5953 9 only only RB 19613 5953 10 a a DT 19613 5953 11 soteriological soteriological JJ 19613 5953 12 , , , 19613 5953 13 whereas whereas IN 19613 5953 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5953 15 has have VBZ 19613 5953 16 both both DT 19613 5953 17 ; ; : 19613 5953 18 the the DT 19613 5953 19 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5953 20 base base VBP 19613 5953 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5953 22 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5953 23 on on IN 19613 5953 24 the the DT 19613 5953 25 Old Old NNP 19613 5953 26 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5953 27 , , , 19613 5953 28 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 5953 29 on on IN 19613 5953 30 a a DT 19613 5953 31 New New NNP 19613 5953 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 5953 33 , , , 19613 5953 34 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5953 35 on on IN 19613 5953 36 both both DT 19613 5953 37 Old Old NNP 19613 5953 38 and and CC 19613 5953 39 New New NNP 19613 5953 40 . . . 19613 5954 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5954 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 5954 3 refused refuse VBD 19613 5954 4 to to TO 19613 5954 5 investigate investigate VB 19613 5954 6 what what WP 19613 5954 7 the the DT 19613 5954 8 divine divine JJ 19613 5954 9 element element NN 19613 5954 10 in in IN 19613 5954 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5954 12 is be VBZ 19613 5954 13 , , , 19613 5954 14 and and CC 19613 5954 15 why why WRB 19613 5954 16 another another DT 19613 5954 17 deity deity NN 19613 5954 18 stands stand VBZ 19613 5954 19 alongside alongside RB 19613 5954 20 of of IN 19613 5954 21 the the DT 19613 5954 22 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5954 23 of of IN 19613 5954 24 the the DT 19613 5954 25 Father Father NNP 19613 5954 26 . . . 19613 5955 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5955 2 confesses confess VBZ 19613 5955 3 that that IN 19613 5955 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5955 5 here here RB 19613 5955 6 simply simply RB 19613 5955 7 keeps keep VBZ 19613 5955 8 to to IN 19613 5955 9 the the DT 19613 5955 10 rule rule NN 19613 5955 11 of of IN 19613 5955 12 faith faith NN 19613 5955 13 and and CC 19613 5955 14 the the DT 19613 5955 15 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5955 16 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 5955 17 , , , 19613 5955 18 and and CC 19613 5955 19 declines decline VBZ 19613 5955 20 speculative speculative JJ 19613 5955 21 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 5955 22 on on IN 19613 5955 23 principle principle NN 19613 5955 24 . . . 19613 5956 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5956 2 does do VBZ 19613 5956 3 not not RB 19613 5956 4 admit admit VB 19613 5956 5 the the DT 19613 5956 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 5956 7 of of IN 19613 5956 8 a a DT 19613 5956 9 Word Word NNP 19613 5956 10 existing exist VBG 19613 5956 11 in in IN 19613 5956 12 God God NNP 19613 5956 13 and and CC 19613 5956 14 one one CD 19613 5956 15 coming come VBG 19613 5956 16 forth forth RB 19613 5956 17 from from IN 19613 5956 18 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5956 19 , , , 19613 5956 20 and and CC 19613 5956 21 opposes oppose VBZ 19613 5956 22 not not RB 19613 5956 23 only only RB 19613 5956 24 ideas idea NNS 19613 5956 25 of of IN 19613 5956 26 emanation emanation NN 19613 5956 27 in in IN 19613 5956 28 general general JJ 19613 5956 29 , , , 19613 5956 30 but but CC 19613 5956 31 also also RB 19613 5956 32 the the DT 19613 5956 33 opinion opinion NN 19613 5956 34 that that IN 19613 5956 35 the the DT 19613 5956 36 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5956 37 issued issue VBD 19613 5956 38 forth forth RB 19613 5956 39 at at IN 19613 5956 40 a a DT 19613 5956 41 definite definite JJ 19613 5956 42 point point NN 19613 5956 43 of of IN 19613 5956 44 time time NN 19613 5956 45 . . . 19613 5957 1 Nor nor CC 19613 5957 2 will will MD 19613 5957 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5957 4 allow allow VB 19613 5957 5 the the DT 19613 5957 6 designation designation NN 19613 5957 7 " " `` 19613 5957 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5957 9 " " '' 19613 5957 10 to to TO 19613 5957 11 be be VB 19613 5957 12 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 5957 13 in in IN 19613 5957 14 the the DT 19613 5957 15 sense sense NN 19613 5957 16 of of IN 19613 5957 17 the the DT 19613 5957 18 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5957 19 being be VBG 19613 5957 20 the the DT 19613 5957 21 inward inward JJ 19613 5957 22 Reason reason NN 19613 5957 23 or or CC 19613 5957 24 the the DT 19613 5957 25 spoken speak VBN 19613 5957 26 Word Word NNP 19613 5957 27 of of IN 19613 5957 28 God God NNP 19613 5957 29 . . . 19613 5958 1 God God NNP 19613 5958 2 is be VBZ 19613 5958 3 a a DT 19613 5958 4 simple simple JJ 19613 5958 5 essence essence NN 19613 5958 6 and and CC 19613 5958 7 always always RB 19613 5958 8 remains remain VBZ 19613 5958 9 in in IN 19613 5958 10 the the DT 19613 5958 11 same same JJ 19613 5958 12 state state NN 19613 5958 13 ; ; : 19613 5958 14 besides besides IN 19613 5958 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5958 16 ought ought MD 19613 5958 17 not not RB 19613 5958 18 to to TO 19613 5958 19 hypostatise hypostatise VB 19613 5958 20 qualities quality NNS 19613 5958 21 . . . 19613 5959 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5959 2 551 551 CD 19613 5959 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5959 4 Nevertheless Nevertheless NNP 19613 5959 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5959 6 , , , 19613 5959 7 too too RB 19613 5959 8 , , , 19613 5959 9 calls call VBZ 19613 5959 10 the the DT 19613 5959 11 preëxistent preëxistent NN 19613 5959 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5959 13 the the DT 19613 5959 14 Son Son NNP 19613 5959 15 of of IN 19613 5959 16 God God NNP 19613 5959 17 , , , 19613 5959 18 and and CC 19613 5959 19 strictly strictly RB 19613 5959 20 maintains maintain VBZ 19613 5959 21 the the DT 19613 5959 22 personal personal JJ 19613 5959 23 distinction distinction NN 19613 5959 24 between between IN 19613 5959 25 Father Father NNP 19613 5959 26 and and CC 19613 5959 27 Son Son NNP 19613 5959 28 . . . 19613 5960 1 What what WP 19613 5960 2 makes make VBZ 19613 5960 3 the the DT 19613 5960 4 opposite opposite JJ 19613 5960 5 appear appear VB 19613 5960 6 to to TO 19613 5960 7 be be VB 19613 5960 8 the the DT 19613 5960 9 case case NN 19613 5960 10 is be VBZ 19613 5960 11 the the DT 19613 5960 12 fact fact NN 19613 5960 13 that that IN 19613 5960 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5960 15 does do VBZ 19613 5960 16 not not RB 19613 5960 17 utilise utilise VB 19613 5960 18 the the DT 19613 5960 19 distinction distinction NN 19613 5960 20 in in IN 19613 5960 21 the the DT 19613 5960 22 interest interest NN 19613 5960 23 of of IN 19613 5960 24 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 5960 25 . . . 19613 5961 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5961 2 552 552 CD 19613 5961 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5961 4 In in IN 19613 5961 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5961 6 ' ' POS 19613 5961 7 sense sense NN 19613 5961 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5961 9 shall shall MD 19613 5961 10 have have VB 19613 5961 11 to to TO 19613 5961 12 say say VB 19613 5961 13 : : : 19613 5961 14 The the DT 19613 5961 15 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5961 16 is be VBZ 19613 5961 17 the the DT 19613 5961 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 5961 19 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 5961 20 of of IN 19613 5961 21 the the DT 19613 5961 22 Father Father NNP 19613 5961 23 , , , 19613 5961 24 " " '' 19613 5961 25 the the DT 19613 5961 26 self self NN 19613 5961 27 - - HYPH 19613 5961 28 revelation revelation NN 19613 5961 29 of of IN 19613 5961 30 the the DT 19613 5961 31 self self NN 19613 5961 32 - - HYPH 19613 5961 33 conscious conscious JJ 19613 5961 34 God God NNP 19613 5961 35 , , , 19613 5961 36 " " '' 19613 5961 37 and and CC 19613 5961 38 indeed indeed RB 19613 5961 39 the the DT 19613 5961 40 eternal eternal JJ 19613 5961 41 self self NN 19613 5961 42 - - HYPH 19613 5961 43 revelation revelation NN 19613 5961 44 . . . 19613 5962 1 For for IN 19613 5962 2 according accord VBG 19613 5962 3 to to IN 19613 5962 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5962 5 the the DT 19613 5962 6 Son Son NNP 19613 5962 7 _ _ NNP 19613 5962 8 always always RB 19613 5962 9 _ _ NNP 19613 5962 10 existed exist VBD 19613 5962 11 with with IN 19613 5962 12 God God NNP 19613 5962 13 , , , 19613 5962 14 _ _ NNP 19613 5962 15 always always RB 19613 5962 16 _ _ NNP 19613 5962 17 revealed reveal VBD 19613 5962 18 the the DT 19613 5962 19 Father Father NNP 19613 5962 20 , , , 19613 5962 21 and and CC 19613 5962 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5962 23 was be VBD 19613 5962 24 always always RB 19613 5962 25 the the DT 19613 5962 26 _ _ NNP 19613 5962 27 full full JJ 19613 5962 28 _ _ NNP 19613 5962 29 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5962 30 that that IN 19613 5962 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5962 32 revealed reveal VBD 19613 5962 33 in in IN 19613 5962 34 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5962 35 . . . 19613 5963 1 In in IN 19613 5963 2 other other JJ 19613 5963 3 words word NNS 19613 5963 4 , , , 19613 5963 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5963 6 is be VBZ 19613 5963 7 God God NNP 19613 5963 8 in in IN 19613 5963 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5963 10 specific specific JJ 19613 5963 11 nature nature NN 19613 5963 12 , , , 19613 5963 13 _ _ NNP 19613 5963 14 truly truly RB 19613 5963 15 _ _ NNP 19613 5963 16 God God NNP 19613 5963 17 , , , 19613 5963 18 and and CC 19613 5963 19 there there EX 19613 5963 20 is be VBZ 19613 5963 21 no no DT 19613 5963 22 distinction distinction NN 19613 5963 23 of of IN 19613 5963 24 essence essence NN 19613 5963 25 between between IN 19613 5963 26 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5963 27 and and CC 19613 5963 28 God God NNP 19613 5963 29 . . . 19613 5964 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5964 2 553 553 CD 19613 5964 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5964 4 Now now RB 19613 5964 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5964 6 might may MD 19613 5964 7 conclude conclude VB 19613 5964 8 from from IN 19613 5964 9 the the DT 19613 5964 10 strong strong JJ 19613 5964 11 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 5964 12 laid lay VBN 19613 5964 13 on on RP 19613 5964 14 " " `` 19613 5964 15 always always RB 19613 5964 16 " " '' 19613 5964 17 that that IN 19613 5964 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5964 19 conceived conceive VBD 19613 5964 20 a a DT 19613 5964 21 relationship relationship NN 19613 5964 22 of of IN 19613 5964 23 Father Father NNP 19613 5964 24 and and CC 19613 5964 25 Son Son NNP 19613 5964 26 in in IN 19613 5964 27 the the DT 19613 5964 28 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5964 29 , , , 19613 5964 30 conditioned condition VBN 19613 5964 31 by by IN 19613 5964 32 the the DT 19613 5964 33 essence essence NN 19613 5964 34 of of IN 19613 5964 35 God God NNP 19613 5964 36 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5964 37 and and CC 19613 5964 38 existing exist VBG 19613 5964 39 independently independently RB 19613 5964 40 of of IN 19613 5964 41 revelation revelation NN 19613 5964 42 . . . 19613 5965 1 But but CC 19613 5965 2 the the DT 19613 5965 3 second second JJ 19613 5965 4 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 5965 5 is be VBZ 19613 5965 6 viewed view VBN 19613 5965 7 by by IN 19613 5965 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5965 9 as as IN 19613 5965 10 existing exist VBG 19613 5965 11 from from IN 19613 5965 12 all all DT 19613 5965 13 eternity eternity NN 19613 5965 14 , , , 19613 5965 15 just just RB 19613 5965 16 as as RB 19613 5965 17 much much JJ 19613 5965 18 in in IN 19613 5965 19 the the DT 19613 5965 20 quality quality NN 19613 5965 21 of of IN 19613 5965 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5965 23 as as IN 19613 5965 24 in in IN 19613 5965 25 that that DT 19613 5965 26 of of IN 19613 5965 27 Son Son NNP 19613 5965 28 , , , 19613 5965 29 and and CC 19613 5965 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5965 31 very very JJ 19613 5965 32 statement statement NN 19613 5965 33 that that IN 19613 5965 34 the the DT 19613 5965 35 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5965 36 has have VBZ 19613 5965 37 revealed reveal VBN 19613 5965 38 the the DT 19613 5965 39 Father Father NNP 19613 5965 40 from from IN 19613 5965 41 the the DT 19613 5965 42 beginning beginning NN 19613 5965 43 shows show VBZ 19613 5965 44 that that IN 19613 5965 45 this this DT 19613 5965 46 relationship relationship NN 19613 5965 47 is be VBZ 19613 5965 48 always always RB 19613 5965 49 within within IN 19613 5965 50 the the DT 19613 5965 51 sphere sphere NN 19613 5965 52 of of IN 19613 5965 53 revelation revelation NN 19613 5965 54 . . . 19613 5966 1 The the DT 19613 5966 2 Son Son NNP 19613 5966 3 then then RB 19613 5966 4 exists exist VBZ 19613 5966 5 because because IN 19613 5966 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5966 7 gives give VBZ 19613 5966 8 a a DT 19613 5966 9 revelation revelation NN 19613 5966 10 . . . 19613 5967 1 Little little RB 19613 5967 2 interested interested JJ 19613 5967 3 as as IN 19613 5967 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5967 5 is be VBZ 19613 5967 6 in in IN 19613 5967 7 saying say VBG 19613 5967 8 anything anything NN 19613 5967 9 about about IN 19613 5967 10 the the DT 19613 5967 11 Son Son NNP 19613 5967 12 , , , 19613 5967 13 apart apart RB 19613 5967 14 from from IN 19613 5967 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5967 16 historical historical JJ 19613 5967 17 mission mission NN 19613 5967 18 , , , 19613 5967 19 naïvely naïvely RB 19613 5967 20 as as IN 19613 5967 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5967 22 extols extol VBZ 19613 5967 23 the the DT 19613 5967 24 Father Father NNP 19613 5967 25 as as IN 19613 5967 26 the the DT 19613 5967 27 direct direct JJ 19613 5967 28 Creator Creator NNP 19613 5967 29 of of IN 19613 5967 30 the the DT 19613 5967 31 universe universe NN 19613 5967 32 , , , 19613 5967 33 and and CC 19613 5967 34 anxious anxious JJ 19613 5967 35 as as IN 19613 5967 36 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5967 37 is be VBZ 19613 5967 38 to to TO 19613 5967 39 repress repress VB 19613 5967 40 all all DT 19613 5967 41 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5967 42 that that WDT 19613 5967 43 lead lead VBP 19613 5967 44 beyond beyond IN 19613 5967 45 the the DT 19613 5967 46 Holy Holy NNP 19613 5967 47 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 5967 48 , , , 19613 5967 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5967 50 could could MD 19613 5967 51 not not RB 19613 5967 52 altogether altogether RB 19613 5967 53 avoid avoid VB 19613 5967 54 reflecting reflect VBG 19613 5967 55 on on IN 19613 5967 56 the the DT 19613 5967 57 problems problem NNS 19613 5967 58 : : : 19613 5967 59 why why WRB 19613 5967 60 there there EX 19613 5967 61 is be VBZ 19613 5967 62 a a DT 19613 5967 63 second second JJ 19613 5967 64 deity deity NN 19613 5967 65 alongside alongside RB 19613 5967 66 of of IN 19613 5967 67 God God NNP 19613 5967 68 , , , 19613 5967 69 and and CC 19613 5967 70 how how WRB 19613 5967 71 the the DT 19613 5967 72 two two CD 19613 5967 73 are be VBP 19613 5967 74 related relate VBN 19613 5967 75 to to IN 19613 5967 76 one one CD 19613 5967 77 another another DT 19613 5967 78 . . . 19613 5968 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5968 2 incidental incidental JJ 19613 5968 3 answers answer NNS 19613 5968 4 are be VBP 19613 5968 5 not not RB 19613 5968 6 essentially essentially RB 19613 5968 7 different different JJ 19613 5968 8 from from IN 19613 5968 9 those those DT 19613 5968 10 of of IN 19613 5968 11 the the DT 19613 5968 12 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5968 13 and and CC 19613 5968 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5968 15 ; ; : 19613 5968 16 the the DT 19613 5968 17 only only JJ 19613 5968 18 distinction distinction NN 19613 5968 19 is be VBZ 19613 5968 20 this this DT 19613 5968 21 incidental incidental JJ 19613 5968 22 character character NN 19613 5968 23 . . . 19613 5969 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5969 2 too too RB 19613 5969 3 looked look VBD 19613 5969 4 on on IN 19613 5969 5 the the DT 19613 5969 6 Son Son NNP 19613 5969 7 as as IN 19613 5969 8 " " `` 19613 5969 9 the the DT 19613 5969 10 hand hand NN 19613 5969 11 of of IN 19613 5969 12 God God NNP 19613 5969 13 , , , 19613 5969 14 " " '' 19613 5969 15 the the DT 19613 5969 16 mediator mediator NN 19613 5969 17 of of IN 19613 5969 18 creation creation NN 19613 5969 19 ; ; : 19613 5969 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5969 21 also also RB 19613 5969 22 seems seem VBZ 19613 5969 23 in in IN 19613 5969 24 one one CD 19613 5969 25 passage passage NN 19613 5969 26 to to TO 19613 5969 27 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 5969 28 Father Father NNP 19613 5969 29 and and CC 19613 5969 30 Son Son NNP 19613 5969 31 as as IN 19613 5969 32 the the DT 19613 5969 33 naturally naturally RB 19613 5969 34 invisible invisible JJ 19613 5969 35 and and CC 19613 5969 36 visible visible JJ 19613 5969 37 elements element NNS 19613 5969 38 of of IN 19613 5969 39 God God NNP 19613 5969 40 ; ; : 19613 5969 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5969 42 too too RB 19613 5969 43 views view VBZ 19613 5969 44 the the DT 19613 5969 45 Father Father NNP 19613 5969 46 as as IN 19613 5969 47 the the DT 19613 5969 48 one one NN 19613 5969 49 who who WP 19613 5969 50 dominates dominate VBZ 19613 5969 51 all all DT 19613 5969 52 , , , 19613 5969 53 the the DT 19613 5969 54 head head NN 19613 5969 55 of of IN 19613 5969 56 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5969 57 , , , 19613 5969 58 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5969 59 , , , 19613 5969 60 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5969 61 who who WP 19613 5969 62 bears bear VBZ 19613 5969 63 the the DT 19613 5969 64 creation creation NN 19613 5969 65 and and CC 19613 5969 66 _ _ NNP 19613 5969 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5969 68 _ _ NNP 19613 5969 69 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5969 70 . . . 19613 5970 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5970 2 554 554 CD 19613 5970 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5970 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5970 5 had have VBD 19613 5970 6 no no DT 19613 5970 7 opportunity opportunity NN 19613 5970 8 of of IN 19613 5970 9 writing writing NN 19613 5970 10 against against IN 19613 5970 11 the the DT 19613 5970 12 Monarchians Monarchians NNPS 19613 5970 13 , , , 19613 5970 14 and and CC 19613 5970 15 unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 5970 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5970 17 possess possess VBP 19613 5970 18 no no DT 19613 5970 19 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5970 20 writings writing NNS 19613 5970 21 of of IN 19613 5970 22 his -PRON- PRP 19613 5970 23 . . . 19613 5971 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5971 2 can can MD 19613 5971 3 not not RB 19613 5971 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 5971 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5971 6 determined determine VBD 19613 5971 7 how how WRB 19613 5971 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5971 9 would would MD 19613 5971 10 have have VB 19613 5971 11 written write VBN 19613 5971 12 , , , 19613 5971 13 if if IN 19613 5971 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5971 15 had have VBD 19613 5971 16 had have VBN 19613 5971 17 less less JJR 19613 5971 18 occasion occasion NN 19613 5971 19 to to TO 19613 5971 20 avoid avoid VB 19613 5971 21 the the DT 19613 5971 22 danger danger NN 19613 5971 23 of of IN 19613 5971 24 being be VBG 19613 5971 25 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5971 26 led lead VBN 19613 5971 27 into into IN 19613 5971 28 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 5971 29 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5971 30 about about IN 19613 5971 31 æons æon NNS 19613 5971 32 . . . 19613 5972 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5972 2 has have VBZ 19613 5972 3 been be VBN 19613 5972 4 correctly correctly RB 19613 5972 5 remarked remark VBN 19613 5972 6 that that IN 19613 5972 7 with with IN 19613 5972 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5972 9 the the DT 19613 5972 10 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 5972 11 and and CC 19613 5972 12 the the DT 19613 5972 13 divine divine JJ 19613 5972 14 personality personality NN 19613 5972 15 of of IN 19613 5972 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5972 17 merely merely RB 19613 5972 18 exist exist VBP 19613 5972 19 beside beside IN 19613 5972 20 each each DT 19613 5972 21 other other JJ 19613 5972 22 . . . 19613 5973 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 5973 2 did do VBD 19613 5973 3 not not RB 19613 5973 4 want want VB 19613 5973 5 to to TO 19613 5973 6 weigh weigh VB 19613 5973 7 the the DT 19613 5973 8 different different JJ 19613 5973 9 problems problem NNS 19613 5973 10 , , , 19613 5973 11 because because IN 19613 5973 12 , , , 19613 5973 13 influenced influence VBN 19613 5973 14 as as IN 19613 5973 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5973 16 was be VBD 19613 5973 17 by by IN 19613 5973 18 the the DT 19613 5973 19 lingering linger VBG 19613 5973 20 effects effect NNS 19613 5973 21 of of IN 19613 5973 22 an an DT 19613 5973 23 early early JJ 19613 5973 24 - - HYPH 19613 5973 25 Christian christian JJ 19613 5973 26 , , , 19613 5973 27 anti anti JJ 19613 5973 28 - - JJ 19613 5973 29 theological theological JJ 19613 5973 30 interest interest NN 19613 5973 31 , , , 19613 5973 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5973 33 regarded regard VBD 19613 5973 34 the the DT 19613 5973 35 results result NNS 19613 5973 36 of of IN 19613 5973 37 this this DT 19613 5973 38 reflection reflection NN 19613 5973 39 as as IN 19613 5973 40 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 5973 41 ; ; : 19613 5973 42 but but CC 19613 5973 43 , , , 19613 5973 44 as as IN 19613 5973 45 a a DT 19613 5973 46 matter matter NN 19613 5973 47 of of IN 19613 5973 48 fact fact NN 19613 5973 49 , , , 19613 5973 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5973 51 did do VBD 19613 5973 52 not not RB 19613 5973 53 really really RB 19613 5973 54 correct correct VB 19613 5973 55 the the DT 19613 5973 56 premises premise NNS 19613 5973 57 of of IN 19613 5973 58 the the DT 19613 5973 59 problems problem NNS 19613 5973 60 by by IN 19613 5973 61 rejecting reject VBG 19613 5973 62 the the DT 19613 5973 63 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 5973 64 . . . 19613 5974 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 5974 2 may may MD 19613 5974 3 evidently evidently RB 19613 5974 4 assume assume VB 19613 5974 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5974 6 with with IN 19613 5974 7 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 5974 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5974 9 that that IN 19613 5974 10 , , , 19613 5974 11 according accord VBG 19613 5974 12 to to IN 19613 5974 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5974 14 , , , 19613 5974 15 " " '' 19613 5974 16 God God NNP 19613 5974 17 placed place VBD 19613 5974 18 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 5974 19 in in IN 19613 5974 20 the the DT 19613 5974 21 relationship relationship NN 19613 5974 22 of of IN 19613 5974 23 Father Father NNP 19613 5974 24 to to IN 19613 5974 25 Son Son NNP 19613 5974 26 , , , 19613 5974 27 in in IN 19613 5974 28 order order NN 19613 5974 29 to to TO 19613 5974 30 create create VB 19613 5974 31 after after IN 19613 5974 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5974 33 image image NN 19613 5974 34 and and CC 19613 5974 35 in in IN 19613 5974 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5974 37 likeness likeness NN 19613 5974 38 the the DT 19613 5974 39 man man NN 19613 5974 40 who who WP 19613 5974 41 was be VBD 19613 5974 42 to to TO 19613 5974 43 become become VB 19613 5974 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5974 45 Son;"[555 son;"[555 NN 19613 5974 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5974 47 but but CC 19613 5974 48 we -PRON- PRP 19613 5974 49 ought ought MD 19613 5974 50 not not RB 19613 5974 51 to to TO 19613 5974 52 ask ask VB 19613 5974 53 if if IN 19613 5974 54 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5974 55 understood understand VBD 19613 5974 56 the the DT 19613 5974 57 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5974 58 as as IN 19613 5974 59 a a DT 19613 5974 60 definite definite JJ 19613 5974 61 purpose purpose NN 19613 5974 62 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 5974 63 involved involve VBN 19613 5974 64 in in IN 19613 5974 65 the the DT 19613 5974 66 Sonship Sonship NNP 19613 5974 67 , , , 19613 5974 68 as as IN 19613 5974 69 this this DT 19613 5974 70 question question NN 19613 5974 71 falls fall VBZ 19613 5974 72 outside outside IN 19613 5974 73 the the DT 19613 5974 74 sphere sphere NN 19613 5974 75 of of IN 19613 5974 76 Patristic patristic JJ 19613 5974 77 thinking thinking NN 19613 5974 78 . . . 19613 5975 1 No no RB 19613 5975 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 5975 3 the the DT 19613 5975 4 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 5975 5 constantly constantly RB 19613 5975 6 formed form VBD 19613 5975 7 the the DT 19613 5975 8 preëminent preëminent NN 19613 5975 9 interest interest NN 19613 5975 10 of of IN 19613 5975 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5975 12 , , , 19613 5975 13 and and CC 19613 5975 14 owing owe VBG 19613 5975 15 to to IN 19613 5975 16 this this DT 19613 5975 17 interest interest NN 19613 5975 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5975 19 was be VBD 19613 5975 20 able able JJ 19613 5975 21 to to TO 19613 5975 22 put put VB 19613 5975 23 aside aside RB 19613 5975 24 or or CC 19613 5975 25 throw throw VB 19613 5975 26 a a DT 19613 5975 27 veil veil NN 19613 5975 28 over over IN 19613 5975 29 the the DT 19613 5975 30 mythological mythological JJ 19613 5975 31 speculations speculation NNS 19613 5975 32 of of IN 19613 5975 33 the the DT 19613 5975 34 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5975 35 regarding regard VBG 19613 5975 36 the the DT 19613 5975 37 Logos Logos NNP 19613 5975 38 , , , 19613 5975 39 and and CC 19613 5975 40 to to TO 19613 5975 41 proceed proceed VB 19613 5975 42 at at IN 19613 5975 43 once once RB 19613 5975 44 to to IN 19613 5975 45 the the DT 19613 5975 46 soteriological soteriological JJ 19613 5975 47 question question NN 19613 5975 48 . . . 19613 5976 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5976 2 556 556 CD 19613 5976 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5976 4 Nothing nothing NN 19613 5976 5 is be VBZ 19613 5976 6 more more RBR 19613 5976 7 instructive instructive JJ 19613 5976 8 than than IN 19613 5976 9 an an DT 19613 5976 10 examination examination NN 19613 5976 11 of of IN 19613 5976 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5976 13 ' ' POS 19613 5976 14 views view NNS 19613 5976 15 with with IN 19613 5976 16 regard regard NN 19613 5976 17 to to IN 19613 5976 18 the the DT 19613 5976 19 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 20 destination destination NN 19613 5976 21 of of IN 19613 5976 22 man man NN 19613 5976 23 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 24 , , , 19613 5976 25 the the DT 19613 5976 26 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 27 original original JJ 19613 5976 28 state state NN 19613 5976 29 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 30 , , , 19613 5976 31 the the DT 19613 5976 32 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 33 fall fall NN 19613 5976 34 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 35 , , , 19613 5976 36 and and CC 19613 5976 37 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 38 sin sin NN 19613 5976 39 _ _ NNP 19613 5976 40 ; ; : 19613 5976 41 because because IN 19613 5976 42 the the DT 19613 5976 43 heterogeneous heterogeneous JJ 19613 5976 44 elements element NNS 19613 5976 45 of of IN 19613 5976 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5976 47 " " `` 19613 5976 48 theology theology NN 19613 5976 49 , , , 19613 5976 50 " " '' 19613 5976 51 the the DT 19613 5976 52 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5976 53 and and CC 19613 5976 54 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 5976 55 the the DT 19613 5976 56 realistic realistic JJ 19613 5976 57 , , , 19613 5976 58 and and CC 19613 5976 59 the the DT 19613 5976 60 Biblical Biblical NNP 19613 5976 61 ( ( -LRB- 19613 5976 62 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 5976 63 ) ) -RRB- 19613 5976 64 , , , 19613 5976 65 are be VBP 19613 5976 66 specially specially RB 19613 5976 67 apparent apparent JJ 19613 5976 68 here here RB 19613 5976 69 , , , 19613 5976 70 and and CC 19613 5976 71 the the DT 19613 5976 72 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 19613 5976 73 into into IN 19613 5976 74 which which WDT 19613 5976 75 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5976 76 was be VBD 19613 5976 77 led lead VBN 19613 5976 78 are be VBP 19613 5976 79 very very RB 19613 5976 80 plain plain JJ 19613 5976 81 . . . 19613 5977 1 But but CC 19613 5977 2 these these DT 19613 5977 3 very very JJ 19613 5977 4 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 5977 5 were be VBD 19613 5977 6 never never RB 19613 5977 7 eliminated eliminate VBN 19613 5977 8 from from IN 19613 5977 9 the the DT 19613 5977 10 Church Church NNP 19613 5977 11 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 5977 12 system system NN 19613 5977 13 of of IN 19613 5977 14 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 5977 15 centuries century NNS 19613 5977 16 and and CC 19613 5977 17 did do VBD 19613 5977 18 not not RB 19613 5977 19 admit admit VB 19613 5977 20 of of IN 19613 5977 21 being be VBG 19613 5977 22 removed remove VBN 19613 5977 23 ; ; : 19613 5977 24 hence hence RB 19613 5977 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5977 26 attitude attitude NN 19613 5977 27 on on IN 19613 5977 28 these these DT 19613 5977 29 points point NNS 19613 5977 30 is be VBZ 19613 5977 31 typical typical JJ 19613 5977 32 . . . 19613 5978 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5978 2 557 557 CD 19613 5978 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5978 4 The the DT 19613 5978 5 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 5978 6 and and CC 19613 5978 7 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 5978 8 train train NN 19613 5978 9 of of IN 19613 5978 10 thought thought NN 19613 5978 11 is be VBZ 19613 5978 12 alone alone RB 19613 5978 13 developed develop VBN 19613 5978 14 with with IN 19613 5978 15 systematic systematic JJ 19613 5978 16 clearness clearness NN 19613 5978 17 . . . 19613 5979 1 Everything everything NN 19613 5979 2 created create VBN 19613 5979 3 is be VBZ 19613 5979 4 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 5979 5 , , , 19613 5979 6 just just RB 19613 5979 7 from from IN 19613 5979 8 the the DT 19613 5979 9 very very JJ 19613 5979 10 fact fact NN 19613 5979 11 of of IN 19613 5979 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5979 13 having have VBG 19613 5979 14 had have VBN 19613 5979 15 a a DT 19613 5979 16 beginning beginning NN 19613 5979 17 ; ; : 19613 5979 18 therefore therefore RB 19613 5979 19 man man NN 19613 5979 20 also also RB 19613 5979 21 . . . 19613 5980 1 The the DT 19613 5980 2 Deity Deity NNP 19613 5980 3 is be VBZ 19613 5980 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 5980 5 capable capable JJ 19613 5980 6 of of IN 19613 5980 7 bestowing bestow VBG 19613 5980 8 perfection perfection NN 19613 5980 9 on on IN 19613 5980 10 man man NN 19613 5980 11 from from IN 19613 5980 12 the the DT 19613 5980 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 5980 14 , , , 19613 5980 15 but but CC 19613 5980 16 the the DT 19613 5980 17 latter latter JJ 19613 5980 18 was be VBD 19613 5980 19 incapable incapable JJ 19613 5980 20 of of IN 19613 5980 21 grasping grasp VBG 19613 5980 22 or or CC 19613 5980 23 retaining retain VBG 19613 5980 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5980 25 from from IN 19613 5980 26 the the DT 19613 5980 27 first first JJ 19613 5980 28 . . . 19613 5981 1 Hence hence RB 19613 5981 2 perfection perfection NN 19613 5981 3 , , , 19613 5981 4 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5981 5 , , , 19613 5981 6 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 5981 7 , , , 19613 5981 8 which which WDT 19613 5981 9 consists consist VBZ 19613 5981 10 in in IN 19613 5981 11 the the DT 19613 5981 12 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 5981 13 of of IN 19613 5981 14 God God NNP 19613 5981 15 and and CC 19613 5981 16 is be VBZ 19613 5981 17 conditional conditional JJ 19613 5981 18 on on IN 19613 5981 19 voluntary voluntary JJ 19613 5981 20 obedience obedience NN 19613 5981 21 , , , 19613 5981 22 could could MD 19613 5981 23 only only RB 19613 5981 24 be be VB 19613 5981 25 the the DT 19613 5981 26 _ _ NNP 19613 5981 27 destination destination NN 19613 5981 28 _ _ NNP 19613 5981 29 of of IN 19613 5981 30 man man NN 19613 5981 31 , , , 19613 5981 32 and and CC 19613 5981 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5981 34 must must MD 19613 5981 35 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 5981 36 have have VB 19613 5981 37 been be VBN 19613 5981 38 made make VBN 19613 5981 39 _ _ NNP 19613 5981 40 capable capable JJ 19613 5981 41 _ _ NNP 19613 5981 42 of of IN 19613 5981 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 5981 44 . . . 19613 5982 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5982 2 558 558 CD 19613 5982 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5982 4 That that IN 19613 5982 5 destination destination NN 19613 5982 6 is be VBZ 19613 5982 7 realised realise VBN 19613 5982 8 through through IN 19613 5982 9 the the DT 19613 5982 10 guidance guidance NN 19613 5982 11 of of IN 19613 5982 12 God God NNP 19613 5982 13 and and CC 19613 5982 14 the the DT 19613 5982 15 free free JJ 19613 5982 16 decision decision NN 19613 5982 17 of of IN 19613 5982 18 man man NN 19613 5982 19 , , , 19613 5982 20 for for IN 19613 5982 21 goodness goodness NN 19613 5982 22 not not RB 19613 5982 23 arising arise VBG 19613 5982 24 from from IN 19613 5982 25 free free JJ 19613 5982 26 choice choice NN 19613 5982 27 has have VBZ 19613 5982 28 no no DT 19613 5982 29 value value NN 19613 5982 30 . . . 19613 5983 1 The the DT 19613 5983 2 capacity capacity NN 19613 5983 3 in in IN 19613 5983 4 question question NN 19613 5983 5 is be VBZ 19613 5983 6 on on IN 19613 5983 7 the the DT 19613 5983 8 one one CD 19613 5983 9 hand hand NN 19613 5983 10 involved involve VBN 19613 5983 11 in in IN 19613 5983 12 man man NN 19613 5983 13 's 's POS 19613 5983 14 possession possession NN 19613 5983 15 of of IN 19613 5983 16 the the DT 19613 5983 17 divine divine JJ 19613 5983 18 image image NN 19613 5983 19 , , , 19613 5983 20 which which WDT 19613 5983 21 , , , 19613 5983 22 however however RB 19613 5983 23 , , , 19613 5983 24 is be VBZ 19613 5983 25 only only RB 19613 5983 26 realised realise VBN 19613 5983 27 in in IN 19613 5983 28 the the DT 19613 5983 29 body body NN 19613 5983 30 and and CC 19613 5983 31 is be VBZ 19613 5983 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 5983 33 at at IN 19613 5983 34 bottom bottom NN 19613 5983 35 a a DT 19613 5983 36 matter matter NN 19613 5983 37 of of IN 19613 5983 38 indifference indifference NN 19613 5983 39 ; ; , 19613 5983 40 and and CC 19613 5983 41 , , , 19613 5983 42 on on IN 19613 5983 43 the the DT 19613 5983 44 other other JJ 19613 5983 45 , , , 19613 5983 46 in in IN 19613 5983 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5983 48 likeness likeness NN 19613 5983 49 to to IN 19613 5983 50 God God NNP 19613 5983 51 , , , 19613 5983 52 which which WDT 19613 5983 53 consists consist VBZ 19613 5983 54 in in IN 19613 5983 55 the the DT 19613 5983 56 union union NN 19613 5983 57 of of IN 19613 5983 58 the the DT 19613 5983 59 soul soul NN 19613 5983 60 with with IN 19613 5983 61 God God NNP 19613 5983 62 's 's POS 19613 5983 63 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5983 64 , , , 19613 5983 65 but but CC 19613 5983 66 only only RB 19613 5983 67 comes come VBZ 19613 5983 68 about about IN 19613 5983 69 when when WRB 19613 5983 70 man man NN 19613 5983 71 is be VBZ 19613 5983 72 obedient obedient JJ 19613 5983 73 to to IN 19613 5983 74 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5983 75 . . . 19613 5984 1 Along along IN 19613 5984 2 with with IN 19613 5984 3 this this DT 19613 5984 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5984 5 has have VBZ 19613 5984 6 also also RB 19613 5984 7 the the DT 19613 5984 8 idea idea NN 19613 5984 9 that that IN 19613 5984 10 man man NN 19613 5984 11 's 's POS 19613 5984 12 likeness likeness NN 19613 5984 13 consists consist VBZ 19613 5984 14 in in IN 19613 5984 15 freedom freedom NN 19613 5984 16 . . . 19613 5985 1 Now now RB 19613 5985 2 , , , 19613 5985 3 as as IN 19613 5985 4 man man NN 19613 5985 5 became become VBD 19613 5985 6 disobedient disobedient JJ 19613 5985 7 immediately immediately RB 19613 5985 8 after after IN 19613 5985 9 the the DT 19613 5985 10 creation creation NN 19613 5985 11 , , , 19613 5985 12 this this DT 19613 5985 13 likeness likeness NN 19613 5985 14 to to IN 19613 5985 15 God God NNP 19613 5985 16 did do VBD 19613 5985 17 not not RB 19613 5985 18 become become VB 19613 5985 19 perfect perfect JJ 19613 5985 20 . . . 19613 5986 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5986 2 559 559 CD 19613 5986 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5986 4 Through through IN 19613 5986 5 the the DT 19613 5986 6 fall fall NN 19613 5986 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5986 8 lost lose VBD 19613 5986 9 the the DT 19613 5986 10 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 5986 11 with with IN 19613 5986 12 God God NNP 19613 5986 13 to to TO 19613 5986 14 which which WDT 19613 5986 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5986 16 was be VBD 19613 5986 17 destined destine VBN 19613 5986 18 , , , 19613 5986 19 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5986 20 , , , 19613 5986 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5986 22 is be VBZ 19613 5986 23 forfeit forfeit NN 19613 5986 24 to to IN 19613 5986 25 death death NN 19613 5986 26 . . . 19613 5987 1 This this DT 19613 5987 2 death death NN 19613 5987 3 was be VBD 19613 5987 4 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 5987 5 to to IN 19613 5987 6 Adam Adam NNP 19613 5987 7 's 's POS 19613 5987 8 whole whole JJ 19613 5987 9 posterity posterity NN 19613 5987 10 . . . 19613 5988 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5988 2 560 560 CD 19613 5988 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5988 4 Here here RB 19613 5988 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5988 6 followed follow VBD 19613 5988 7 sayings saying NNS 19613 5988 8 of of IN 19613 5988 9 Paul Paul NNP 19613 5988 10 , , , 19613 5988 11 but but CC 19613 5988 12 adopted adopt VBD 19613 5988 13 the the DT 19613 5988 14 words word NNS 19613 5988 15 rather rather RB 19613 5988 16 than than IN 19613 5988 17 the the DT 19613 5988 18 sense sense NN 19613 5988 19 ; ; : 19613 5988 20 for for IN 19613 5988 21 , , , 19613 5988 22 in in IN 19613 5988 23 the the DT 19613 5988 24 first first JJ 19613 5988 25 place place NN 19613 5988 26 , , , 19613 5988 27 like like IN 19613 5988 28 the the DT 19613 5988 29 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 5988 30 , , , 19613 5988 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5988 32 very very RB 19613 5988 33 strongly strongly RB 19613 5988 34 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 5988 35 the the DT 19613 5988 36 elements element NNS 19613 5988 37 that that WDT 19613 5988 38 palliate palliate VBP 19613 5988 39 man man NN 19613 5988 40 's 's POS 19613 5988 41 fall[561 fall[561 NN 19613 5988 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5988 43 and and CC 19613 5988 44 , , , 19613 5988 45 secondly secondly RB 19613 5988 46 , , , 19613 5988 47 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5988 48 contemplates contemplate VBZ 19613 5988 49 the the DT 19613 5988 50 fall fall NN 19613 5988 51 as as IN 19613 5988 52 having have VBG 19613 5988 53 a a DT 19613 5988 54 teleological teleological JJ 19613 5988 55 significance significance NN 19613 5988 56 . . . 19613 5989 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5989 2 is be VBZ 19613 5989 3 the the DT 19613 5989 4 fall fall NN 19613 5989 5 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5989 6 and and CC 19613 5989 7 not not RB 19613 5989 8 , , , 19613 5989 9 as as IN 19613 5989 10 in in IN 19613 5989 11 Paul Paul NNP 19613 5989 12 's 's POS 19613 5989 13 case case NN 19613 5989 14 , , , 19613 5989 15 the the DT 19613 5989 16 consequences consequence NNS 19613 5989 17 of of IN 19613 5989 18 the the DT 19613 5989 19 fall fall NN 19613 5989 20 , , , 19613 5989 21 that that IN 19613 5989 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5989 23 thus thus RB 19613 5989 24 views view VBZ 19613 5989 25 ; ; , 19613 5989 26 for for IN 19613 5989 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5989 28 says say VBZ 19613 5989 29 that that IN 19613 5989 30 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 5989 31 was be VBD 19613 5989 32 conducive conducive JJ 19613 5989 33 to to IN 19613 5989 34 man man NN 19613 5989 35 's 's POS 19613 5989 36 development development NN 19613 5989 37 . . . 19613 5990 1 Man man NN 19613 5990 2 had have VBD 19613 5990 3 to to TO 19613 5990 4 learn learn VB 19613 5990 5 by by IN 19613 5990 6 experience experience NN 19613 5990 7 that that IN 19613 5990 8 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 5990 9 entails entail VBZ 19613 5990 10 death death NN 19613 5990 11 , , , 19613 5990 12 in in IN 19613 5990 13 order order NN 19613 5990 14 that that IN 19613 5990 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5990 16 might may MD 19613 5990 17 acquire acquire VB 19613 5990 18 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 5990 19 and and CC 19613 5990 20 choose choose VB 19613 5990 21 freely freely RB 19613 5990 22 to to TO 19613 5990 23 fulfil fulfil VB 19613 5990 24 the the DT 19613 5990 25 commandments commandment NNS 19613 5990 26 of of IN 19613 5990 27 God God NNP 19613 5990 28 . . . 19613 5991 1 Further further RB 19613 5991 2 , , , 19613 5991 3 man man NN 19613 5991 4 was be VBD 19613 5991 5 obliged oblige VBN 19613 5991 6 to to TO 19613 5991 7 learn learn VB 19613 5991 8 through through IN 19613 5991 9 the the DT 19613 5991 10 fall fall NN 19613 5991 11 that that DT 19613 5991 12 goodness goodness NN 19613 5991 13 and and CC 19613 5991 14 life life NN 19613 5991 15 do do VBP 19613 5991 16 not not RB 19613 5991 17 belong belong VB 19613 5991 18 to to IN 19613 5991 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 5991 20 by by IN 19613 5991 21 nature nature NN 19613 5991 22 as as IN 19613 5991 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5991 24 do do VBP 19613 5991 25 to to IN 19613 5991 26 God God NNP 19613 5991 27 . . . 19613 5992 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5992 2 562 562 CD 19613 5992 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5992 4 Here here RB 19613 5992 5 life life NN 19613 5992 6 and and CC 19613 5992 7 death death NN 19613 5992 8 are be VBP 19613 5992 9 always always RB 19613 5992 10 the the DT 19613 5992 11 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 5992 12 question question NN 19613 5992 13 to to IN 19613 5992 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5992 15 . . . 19613 5993 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 5993 2 is be VBZ 19613 5993 3 only only RB 19613 5993 4 when when WRB 19613 5993 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5993 6 quotes quote VBZ 19613 5993 7 sayings saying NNS 19613 5993 8 of of IN 19613 5993 9 Paul Paul NNP 19613 5993 10 that that IN 19613 5993 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5993 12 remembers remember VBZ 19613 5993 13 sin sin NN 19613 5993 14 in in IN 19613 5993 15 connection connection NN 19613 5993 16 with with IN 19613 5993 17 redemption redemption NN 19613 5993 18 ; ; , 19613 5993 19 and and CC 19613 5993 20 ethical ethical JJ 19613 5993 21 consequences consequence NNS 19613 5993 22 of of IN 19613 5993 23 the the DT 19613 5993 24 fall fall NN 19613 5993 25 are be VBP 19613 5993 26 not not RB 19613 5993 27 mentioned mention VBN 19613 5993 28 in in IN 19613 5993 29 this this DT 19613 5993 30 connection connection NN 19613 5993 31 . . . 19613 5994 1 " " `` 19613 5994 2 The the DT 19613 5994 3 original original JJ 19613 5994 4 destination destination NN 19613 5994 5 of of IN 19613 5994 6 man man NN 19613 5994 7 was be VBD 19613 5994 8 not not RB 19613 5994 9 abrogated abrogate VBN 19613 5994 10 by by IN 19613 5994 11 the the DT 19613 5994 12 fall fall NN 19613 5994 13 , , , 19613 5994 14 the the DT 19613 5994 15 truth truth NN 19613 5994 16 rather rather RB 19613 5994 17 being be VBG 19613 5994 18 that that IN 19613 5994 19 the the DT 19613 5994 20 fall fall NN 19613 5994 21 was be VBD 19613 5994 22 intended intend VBN 19613 5994 23 as as IN 19613 5994 24 a a DT 19613 5994 25 means means NN 19613 5994 26 of of IN 19613 5994 27 leading lead VBG 19613 5994 28 men man NNS 19613 5994 29 to to TO 19613 5994 30 attain attain VB 19613 5994 31 this this DT 19613 5994 32 perfection perfection NN 19613 5994 33 to to TO 19613 5994 34 which which WDT 19613 5994 35 they -PRON- PRP 19613 5994 36 were be VBD 19613 5994 37 destined destine VBN 19613 5994 38 . . . 19613 5995 1 " " `` 19613 5995 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5995 3 563 563 CD 19613 5995 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5995 5 Moreover moreover RB 19613 5995 6 , , , 19613 5995 7 the the DT 19613 5995 8 goodness goodness NN 19613 5995 9 of of IN 19613 5995 10 God God NNP 19613 5995 11 immediately immediately RB 19613 5995 12 showed show VBD 19613 5995 13 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5995 14 both both DT 19613 5995 15 in in IN 19613 5995 16 the the DT 19613 5995 17 removal removal NN 19613 5995 18 of of IN 19613 5995 19 the the DT 19613 5995 20 tree tree NN 19613 5995 21 of of IN 19613 5995 22 life life NN 19613 5995 23 and and CC 19613 5995 24 in in IN 19613 5995 25 the the DT 19613 5995 26 sentence sentence NN 19613 5995 27 of of IN 19613 5995 28 temporal temporal JJ 19613 5995 29 death death NN 19613 5995 30 . . . 19613 5996 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5996 2 564 564 CD 19613 5996 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5996 4 What what WDT 19613 5996 5 significance significance NN 19613 5996 6 belongs belong VBZ 19613 5996 7 to to IN 19613 5996 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 5996 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 5996 10 within within IN 19613 5996 11 this this DT 19613 5996 12 conception conception NN 19613 5996 13 is be VBZ 19613 5996 14 clear clear JJ 19613 5996 15 : : : 19613 5996 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5996 17 is be VBZ 19613 5996 18 the the DT 19613 5996 19 man man NN 19613 5996 20 who who WP 19613 5996 21 first first RB 19613 5996 22 realised realise VBD 19613 5996 23 in in IN 19613 5996 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5996 25 person person NN 19613 5996 26 the the DT 19613 5996 27 destination destination NN 19613 5996 28 of of IN 19613 5996 29 humanity humanity NN 19613 5996 30 ; ; : 19613 5996 31 the the DT 19613 5996 32 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 5996 33 of of IN 19613 5996 34 God God NNP 19613 5996 35 became become VBD 19613 5996 36 united united JJ 19613 5996 37 with with IN 19613 5996 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5996 39 soul soul NN 19613 5996 40 and and CC 19613 5996 41 accustomed accustom VBD 19613 5996 42 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 5996 43 to to TO 19613 5996 44 dwell dwell VB 19613 5996 45 in in IN 19613 5996 46 men man NNS 19613 5996 47 . . . 19613 5997 1 But but CC 19613 5997 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 5997 3 is be VBZ 19613 5997 4 also also RB 19613 5997 5 the the DT 19613 5997 6 teacher teacher NN 19613 5997 7 who who WP 19613 5997 8 reforms reform VBZ 19613 5997 9 mankind mankind NN 19613 5997 10 by by IN 19613 5997 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5997 12 preaching preaching NN 19613 5997 13 , , , 19613 5997 14 calls call VBZ 19613 5997 15 upon upon IN 19613 5997 16 them -PRON- PRP 19613 5997 17 to to TO 19613 5997 18 direct direct VB 19613 5997 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 5997 20 still still RB 19613 5997 21 existing exist VBG 19613 5997 22 freedom freedom NN 19613 5997 23 to to IN 19613 5997 24 obedience obedience NN 19613 5997 25 to to IN 19613 5997 26 the the DT 19613 5997 27 divine divine JJ 19613 5997 28 commandments commandment NNS 19613 5997 29 , , , 19613 5997 30 thereby thereby RB 19613 5997 31 restoring restore VBG 19613 5997 32 , , , 19613 5997 33 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 5997 34 , , , 19613 5997 35 strengthening strengthening NN 19613 5997 36 , , , 19613 5997 37 freedom freedom NN 19613 5997 38 , , , 19613 5997 39 so so IN 19613 5997 40 that that IN 19613 5997 41 humanity humanity NN 19613 5997 42 is be VBZ 19613 5997 43 thus thus RB 19613 5997 44 rendered render VBN 19613 5997 45 capable capable JJ 19613 5997 46 of of IN 19613 5997 47 receiving receive VBG 19613 5997 48 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 5997 49 . . . 19613 5998 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 5998 2 565 565 CD 19613 5998 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5998 4 One one PRP 19613 5998 5 can can MD 19613 5998 6 plainly plainly RB 19613 5998 7 see see VB 19613 5998 8 that that IN 19613 5998 9 this this DT 19613 5998 10 is be VBZ 19613 5998 11 the the DT 19613 5998 12 idea idea NN 19613 5998 13 of of IN 19613 5998 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 5998 15 and and CC 19613 5998 16 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 5998 17 , , , 19613 5998 18 with with IN 19613 5998 19 which which WDT 19613 5998 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 5998 21 has have VBZ 19613 5998 22 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 5998 23 utterances utterance NNS 19613 5998 24 of of IN 19613 5998 25 Paul Paul NNP 19613 5998 26 . . . 19613 5999 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 5999 2 and and CC 19613 5999 3 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 5999 4 taught teach VBD 19613 5999 5 essentially essentially RB 19613 5999 6 the the DT 19613 5999 7 same same JJ 19613 5999 8 doctrine;[566 doctrine;[566 CD 19613 5999 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 5999 10 only only RB 19613 5999 11 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 5999 12 beheld beheld NN 19613 5999 13 the the DT 19613 5999 14 image image NN 19613 5999 15 and and CC 19613 5999 16 likeness likeness NN 19613 5999 17 of of IN 19613 5999 18 God God NNP 19613 5999 19 expressly expressly RB 19613 5999 20 and and CC 19613 5999 21 exclusively exclusively RB 19613 5999 22 in in IN 19613 5999 23 the the DT 19613 5999 24 fact fact NN 19613 5999 25 that that IN 19613 5999 26 man man NN 19613 5999 27 's 's POS 19613 5999 28 will will NN 19613 5999 29 and and CC 19613 5999 30 capacity capacity NN 19613 5999 31 are be VBP 19613 5999 32 free free JJ 19613 5999 33 , , , 19613 5999 34 and and CC 19613 5999 35 based base VBN 19613 5999 36 on on IN 19613 5999 37 this this DT 19613 5999 38 freedom freedom NN 19613 5999 39 an an DT 19613 5999 40 argument argument NN 19613 5999 41 in in IN 19613 5999 42 justification justification NN 19613 5999 43 of of IN 19613 5999 44 God God NNP 19613 5999 45 's 's POS 19613 5999 46 ways way NNS 19613 5999 47 . . . 19613 6000 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6000 2 567 567 CD 19613 6000 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6000 4 But but CC 19613 6000 5 , , , 19613 6000 6 in in IN 19613 6000 7 addition addition NN 19613 6000 8 to to IN 19613 6000 9 this this DT 19613 6000 10 , , , 19613 6000 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6000 12 developed develop VBD 19613 6000 13 a a DT 19613 6000 14 second second JJ 19613 6000 15 train train NN 19613 6000 16 of of IN 19613 6000 17 thought thought NN 19613 6000 18 . . . 19613 6001 1 This this DT 19613 6001 2 was be VBD 19613 6001 3 the the DT 19613 6001 4 outcome outcome NN 19613 6001 5 of of IN 19613 6001 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6001 7 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6001 8 and and CC 19613 6001 9 realistic realistic JJ 19613 6001 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6001 11 of of IN 19613 6001 12 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6001 13 , , , 19613 6001 14 and and CC 19613 6001 15 evinces evince NNS 19613 6001 16 clear clear VBP 19613 6001 17 traces trace NNS 19613 6001 18 of of IN 19613 6001 19 the the DT 19613 6001 20 influence influence NN 19613 6001 21 of of IN 19613 6001 22 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 6001 23 theology theology NN 19613 6001 24 . . . 19613 6002 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6002 2 is be VBZ 19613 6002 3 , , , 19613 6002 4 however however RB 19613 6002 5 , , , 19613 6002 6 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 19613 6002 7 with with IN 19613 6002 8 the the DT 19613 6002 9 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 6002 10 teachings teaching NNS 19613 6002 11 unfolded unfold VBD 19613 6002 12 above above RB 19613 6002 13 , , , 19613 6002 14 and and CC 19613 6002 15 could could MD 19613 6002 16 only only RB 19613 6002 17 be be VB 19613 6002 18 united united JJ 19613 6002 19 with with IN 19613 6002 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6002 21 at at IN 19613 6002 22 a a DT 19613 6002 23 few few JJ 19613 6002 24 points point NNS 19613 6002 25 . . . 19613 6003 1 To to IN 19613 6003 2 the the DT 19613 6003 3 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 6003 4 the the DT 19613 6003 5 proposition proposition NN 19613 6003 6 : : : 19613 6003 7 " " `` 19613 6003 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6003 9 is be VBZ 19613 6003 10 impossible impossible JJ 19613 6003 11 to to TO 19613 6003 12 learn learn VB 19613 6003 13 to to TO 19613 6003 14 know know VB 19613 6003 15 God God NNP 19613 6003 16 without without IN 19613 6003 17 the the DT 19613 6003 18 help help NN 19613 6003 19 of of IN 19613 6003 20 God God NNP 19613 6003 21 " " '' 19613 6003 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6003 23 " " `` 19613 6003 24 impossibile impossibile JJ 19613 6003 25 est est NNP 19613 6003 26 sine sine NNP 19613 6003 27 deo deo NNP 19613 6003 28 discere discere NNP 19613 6003 29 deum deum NNP 19613 6003 30 " " '' 19613 6003 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6003 32 was be VBD 19613 6003 33 a a DT 19613 6003 34 conviction conviction NN 19613 6003 35 which which WDT 19613 6003 36 , , , 19613 6003 37 with with IN 19613 6003 38 the the DT 19613 6003 39 exception exception NN 19613 6003 40 of of IN 19613 6003 41 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6003 42 , , , 19613 6003 43 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6003 44 subordinated subordinate VBD 19613 6003 45 to to IN 19613 6003 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6003 47 moralism moralism NN 19613 6003 48 and and CC 19613 6003 49 to to TO 19613 6003 50 which which WDT 19613 6003 51 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6003 52 did do VBD 19613 6003 53 not not RB 19613 6003 54 give give VB 19613 6003 55 a a DT 19613 6003 56 specifically specifically RB 19613 6003 57 Christological christological JJ 19613 6003 58 signification signification NN 19613 6003 59 . . . 19613 6004 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6004 2 understood understand VBD 19613 6004 3 this this DT 19613 6004 4 proposition proposition NN 19613 6004 5 in in IN 19613 6004 6 a a DT 19613 6004 7 Christological Christological NNP 19613 6004 8 sense,[568 sense,[568 NN 19613 6004 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6004 10 and and CC 19613 6004 11 at at IN 19613 6004 12 the the DT 19613 6004 13 same same JJ 19613 6004 14 time time NN 19613 6004 15 conceived conceive VBD 19613 6004 16 the the DT 19613 6004 17 blessing blessing NN 19613 6004 18 of of IN 19613 6004 19 salvation salvation NN 19613 6004 20 imparted impart VBN 19613 6004 21 by by IN 19613 6004 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6004 23 not not RB 19613 6004 24 only only RB 19613 6004 25 as as IN 19613 6004 26 the the DT 19613 6004 27 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 6004 28 consisting consist VBG 19613 6004 29 in in IN 19613 6004 30 the the DT 19613 6004 31 beholding beholding NN 19613 6004 32 of of IN 19613 6004 33 God God NNP 19613 6004 34 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 6004 35 on on IN 19613 6004 36 obedience obedience NN 19613 6004 37 IV IV NNP 19613 6004 38 . . . 19613 6005 1 20 20 CD 19613 6005 2 . . . 19613 6006 1 5 5 CD 19613 6006 2 - - SYM 19613 6006 3 7 7 CD 19613 6006 4 : : : 19613 6006 5 IV IV NNP 19613 6006 6 . . . 19613 6007 1 38 38 CD 19613 6007 2 , , , 19613 6007 3 but but CC 19613 6007 4 also also RB 19613 6007 5 as as IN 19613 6007 6 the the DT 19613 6007 7 divine divine JJ 19613 6007 8 sonship sonship NN 19613 6007 9 which which WDT 19613 6007 10 has have VBZ 19613 6007 11 been be VBN 19613 6007 12 won win VBN 19613 6007 13 for for IN 19613 6007 14 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6007 15 by by IN 19613 6007 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6007 17 and and CC 19613 6007 18 which which WDT 19613 6007 19 is be VBZ 19613 6007 20 realised realise VBN 19613 6007 21 in in IN 19613 6007 22 constant constant JJ 19613 6007 23 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 6007 24 with with IN 19613 6007 25 God God NNP 19613 6007 26 and and CC 19613 6007 27 dependence dependence NN 19613 6007 28 on on IN 19613 6007 29 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6007 30 . . . 19613 6008 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6008 2 569 569 CD 19613 6008 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6008 4 No no RB 19613 6008 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 6008 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6008 7 also also RB 19613 6008 8 viewed view VBD 19613 6008 9 this this DT 19613 6008 10 divine divine JJ 19613 6008 11 sonship sonship NN 19613 6008 12 as as IN 19613 6008 13 consisting consist VBG 19613 6008 14 in in IN 19613 6008 15 the the DT 19613 6008 16 transformation transformation NN 19613 6008 17 of of IN 19613 6008 18 human human JJ 19613 6008 19 nature nature NN 19613 6008 20 ; ; : 19613 6008 21 but but CC 19613 6008 22 the the DT 19613 6008 23 point point NN 19613 6008 24 of of IN 19613 6008 25 immediate immediate JJ 19613 6008 26 importance importance NN 19613 6008 27 here here RB 19613 6008 28 is be VBZ 19613 6008 29 that that IN 19613 6008 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6008 31 is be VBZ 19613 6008 32 no no DT 19613 6008 33 longer long RBR 19613 6008 34 human human JJ 19613 6008 35 freedom freedom NN 19613 6008 36 but but CC 19613 6008 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6008 38 that that WDT 19613 6008 39 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6008 40 contemplated contemplate VBD 19613 6008 41 in in IN 19613 6008 42 this this DT 19613 6008 43 connection connection NN 19613 6008 44 . . . 19613 6009 1 Corresponding correspond VBG 19613 6009 2 to to IN 19613 6009 3 this this DT 19613 6009 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6009 5 has have VBZ 19613 6009 6 now now RB 19613 6009 7 also also RB 19613 6009 8 a a DT 19613 6009 9 different different JJ 19613 6009 10 idea idea NN 19613 6009 11 of of IN 19613 6009 12 the the DT 19613 6009 13 original original JJ 19613 6009 14 destination destination NN 19613 6009 15 of of IN 19613 6009 16 man man NN 19613 6009 17 , , , 19613 6009 18 of of IN 19613 6009 19 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6009 20 , , , 19613 6009 21 and and CC 19613 6009 22 of of IN 19613 6009 23 the the DT 19613 6009 24 results result NNS 19613 6009 25 of of IN 19613 6009 26 the the DT 19613 6009 27 fall fall NN 19613 6009 28 . . . 19613 6010 1 Here here RB 19613 6010 2 comes come VBZ 19613 6010 3 in in IN 19613 6010 4 the the DT 19613 6010 5 mystical mystical JJ 19613 6010 6 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6010 7 - - HYPH 19613 6010 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6010 9 speculation speculation NN 19613 6010 10 , , , 19613 6010 11 in in IN 19613 6010 12 accordance accordance NN 19613 6010 13 with with IN 19613 6010 14 the the DT 19613 6010 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 6010 16 to to IN 19613 6010 17 the the DT 19613 6010 18 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 19613 6010 19 and and CC 19613 6010 20 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 19613 6010 21 . . . 19613 6011 1 Everything everything NN 19613 6011 2 , , , 19613 6011 3 that that RB 19613 6011 4 is is RB 19613 6011 5 , , , 19613 6011 6 the the DT 19613 6011 7 " " `` 19613 6011 8 longa longa NNP 19613 6011 9 hominum hominum NNP 19613 6011 10 expositio expositio NN 19613 6011 11 , , , 19613 6011 12 " " `` 19613 6011 13 was be VBD 19613 6011 14 recapitulated recapitulate VBN 19613 6011 15 by by IN 19613 6011 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6011 17 in in IN 19613 6011 18 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6011 19 ; ; : 19613 6011 20 in in IN 19613 6011 21 other other JJ 19613 6011 22 words word NNS 19613 6011 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6011 24 restored restore VBD 19613 6011 25 humanity humanity NN 19613 6011 26 _ _ NNP 19613 6011 27 to to IN 19613 6011 28 what what WP 19613 6011 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6011 30 originally originally RB 19613 6011 31 was be VBD 19613 6011 32 _ _ NNP 19613 6011 33 and and CC 19613 6011 34 again again RB 19613 6011 35 included include VBN 19613 6011 36 under under IN 19613 6011 37 one one CD 19613 6011 38 head head NN 19613 6011 39 what what WP 19613 6011 40 was be VBD 19613 6011 41 divided divide VBN 19613 6011 42 . . . 19613 6012 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6012 2 570 570 CD 19613 6012 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6012 4 If if IN 19613 6012 5 humanity humanity NN 19613 6012 6 is be VBZ 19613 6012 7 restored restore VBN 19613 6012 8 , , , 19613 6012 9 then then RB 19613 6012 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6012 11 must must MD 19613 6012 12 have have VB 19613 6012 13 lost lose VBN 19613 6012 14 something something NN 19613 6012 15 before before RB 19613 6012 16 and and CC 19613 6012 17 been be VBN 19613 6012 18 originally originally RB 19613 6012 19 in in IN 19613 6012 20 good good JJ 19613 6012 21 condition condition NN 19613 6012 22 . . . 19613 6013 1 In in IN 19613 6013 2 complete complete JJ 19613 6013 3 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 6013 4 to to IN 19613 6013 5 the the DT 19613 6013 6 other other JJ 19613 6013 7 teachings teaching NNS 19613 6013 8 quoted quote VBN 19613 6013 9 above above RB 19613 6013 10 , , , 19613 6013 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6013 12 now now RB 19613 6013 13 says say VBZ 19613 6013 14 : : : 19613 6013 15 " " `` 19613 6013 16 What what WP 19613 6013 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6013 18 had have VBD 19613 6013 19 lost lose VBN 19613 6013 20 in in IN 19613 6013 21 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6013 22 , , , 19613 6013 23 namely namely RB 19613 6013 24 , , , 19613 6013 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6013 26 possession possession NN 19613 6013 27 of of IN 19613 6013 28 the the DT 19613 6013 29 image image NN 19613 6013 30 and and CC 19613 6013 31 likeness likeness NN 19613 6013 32 of of IN 19613 6013 33 God God NNP 19613 6013 34 , , , 19613 6013 35 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6013 36 recover recover VBP 19613 6013 37 in in IN 19613 6013 38 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6013 39 . . . 19613 6014 1 " " `` 19613 6014 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6014 3 571 571 CD 19613 6014 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6014 5 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6014 6 , , , 19613 6014 7 however however RB 19613 6014 8 , , , 19613 6014 9 is be VBZ 19613 6014 10 humanity humanity NN 19613 6014 11 ; ; : 19613 6014 12 in in IN 19613 6014 13 other other JJ 19613 6014 14 words word NNS 19613 6014 15 , , , 19613 6014 16 as as IN 19613 6014 17 all all DT 19613 6014 18 humanity humanity NN 19613 6014 19 is be VBZ 19613 6014 20 united united JJ 19613 6014 21 and and CC 19613 6014 22 renewed renew VBN 19613 6014 23 through through IN 19613 6014 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6014 25 so so RB 19613 6014 26 also also RB 19613 6014 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6014 28 was be VBD 19613 6014 29 already already RB 19613 6014 30 summarised summarise VBN 19613 6014 31 in in IN 19613 6014 32 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6014 33 . . . 19613 6015 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 6015 2 " " `` 19613 6015 3 the the DT 19613 6015 4 sin sin NN 19613 6015 5 of of IN 19613 6015 6 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 6015 7 and and CC 19613 6015 8 the the DT 19613 6015 9 loss loss NN 19613 6015 10 of of IN 19613 6015 11 salvation salvation NN 19613 6015 12 which which WDT 19613 6015 13 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6015 14 consequently consequently RB 19613 6015 15 suffered suffer VBD 19613 6015 16 may may MD 19613 6015 17 now now RB 19613 6015 18 be be VB 19613 6015 19 viewed view VBN 19613 6015 20 as as IN 19613 6015 21 belonging belong VBG 19613 6015 22 to to IN 19613 6015 23 all all DT 19613 6015 24 mankind mankind NN 19613 6015 25 summed sum VBD 19613 6015 26 up up RP 19613 6015 27 in in IN 19613 6015 28 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6015 29 , , , 19613 6015 30 in in IN 19613 6015 31 like like IN 19613 6015 32 manner manner NN 19613 6015 33 as as IN 19613 6015 34 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6015 35 's 's POS 19613 6015 36 obedience obedience NN 19613 6015 37 and and CC 19613 6015 38 possession possession NN 19613 6015 39 of of IN 19613 6015 40 salvation salvation NN 19613 6015 41 are be VBP 19613 6015 42 the the DT 19613 6015 43 property property NN 19613 6015 44 of of IN 19613 6015 45 all all DT 19613 6015 46 mankind mankind NN 19613 6015 47 united unite VBN 19613 6015 48 under under IN 19613 6015 49 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6015 50 as as IN 19613 6015 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6015 52 head head NN 19613 6015 53 . . . 19613 6016 1 " " `` 19613 6016 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6016 3 572 572 CD 19613 6016 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6016 5 In in IN 19613 6016 6 the the DT 19613 6016 7 first first JJ 19613 6016 8 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6016 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6016 10 offended offend VBD 19613 6016 11 God God NNP 19613 6016 12 by by IN 19613 6016 13 not not RB 19613 6016 14 fulfilling fulfil VBG 19613 6016 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6016 16 commandments commandment NNS 19613 6016 17 ; ; : 19613 6016 18 in in IN 19613 6016 19 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6016 20 humanity humanity NN 19613 6016 21 became become VBD 19613 6016 22 disobedient disobedient JJ 19613 6016 23 , , , 19613 6016 24 wounded wounded JJ 19613 6016 25 , , , 19613 6016 26 sinful sinful JJ 19613 6016 27 , , , 19613 6016 28 bereft bereft NN 19613 6016 29 of of IN 19613 6016 30 life life NN 19613 6016 31 ; ; : 19613 6016 32 through through IN 19613 6016 33 Eve Eve NNP 19613 6016 34 mankind mankind NN 19613 6016 35 became become VBD 19613 6016 36 forfeit forfeit NN 19613 6016 37 to to IN 19613 6016 38 death death NN 19613 6016 39 ; ; : 19613 6016 40 through through IN 19613 6016 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6016 42 victory victory NN 19613 6016 43 over over IN 19613 6016 44 the the DT 19613 6016 45 first first JJ 19613 6016 46 man man NN 19613 6016 47 death death NN 19613 6016 48 descended descend VBN 19613 6016 49 upon upon IN 19613 6016 50 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6016 51 all all DT 19613 6016 52 , , , 19613 6016 53 and and CC 19613 6016 54 the the DT 19613 6016 55 devil devil NN 19613 6016 56 carried carry VBD 19613 6016 57 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6016 58 all all DT 19613 6016 59 away away RB 19613 6016 60 captive captive JJ 19613 6016 61 etc etc FW 19613 6016 62 . . . 19613 6017 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6017 2 573 573 CD 19613 6017 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6017 4 Here here RB 19613 6017 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6017 6 always always RB 19613 6017 7 means mean VBZ 19613 6017 8 that that IN 19613 6017 9 in in IN 19613 6017 10 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6017 11 , , , 19613 6017 12 who who WP 19613 6017 13 represents represent VBZ 19613 6017 14 all all DT 19613 6017 15 mankind mankind NN 19613 6017 16 as as IN 19613 6017 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6017 18 head head NN 19613 6017 19 , , , 19613 6017 20 the the DT 19613 6017 21 latter latter JJ 19613 6017 22 became become VBD 19613 6017 23 doomed doom VBN 19613 6017 24 to to IN 19613 6017 25 death death NN 19613 6017 26 . . . 19613 6018 1 In in IN 19613 6018 2 this this DT 19613 6018 3 instance instance NN 19613 6018 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6018 5 did do VBD 19613 6018 6 not not RB 19613 6018 7 think think VB 19613 6018 8 of of IN 19613 6018 9 a a DT 19613 6018 10 hereditary hereditary JJ 19613 6018 11 transmission transmission NN 19613 6018 12 , , , 19613 6018 13 but but CC 19613 6018 14 of of IN 19613 6018 15 a a DT 19613 6018 16 mystic mystic JJ 19613 6018 17 unity[574 unity[574 NN 19613 6018 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6018 19 as as IN 19613 6018 20 in in IN 19613 6018 21 the the DT 19613 6018 22 case case NN 19613 6018 23 of of IN 19613 6018 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6018 25 , , , 19613 6018 26 viewed view VBD 19613 6018 27 as as IN 19613 6018 28 the the DT 19613 6018 29 second second JJ 19613 6018 30 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6018 31 . . . 19613 6019 1 The the DT 19613 6019 2 teachings teaching NNS 19613 6019 3 in in IN 19613 6019 4 III III NNP 19613 6019 5 . . . 19613 6020 1 21 21 CD 19613 6020 2 . . . 19613 6021 1 10 10 CD 19613 6021 2 - - SYM 19613 6021 3 23[575 23[575 CD 19613 6021 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6021 5 show show VB 19613 6021 6 what what WP 19613 6021 7 an an DT 19613 6021 8 almost almost RB 19613 6021 9 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 19613 6021 10 shape shape NN 19613 6021 11 the the DT 19613 6021 12 religious religious JJ 19613 6021 13 quasi quasi JJ 19613 6021 14 - - JJ 19613 6021 15 historical historical JJ 19613 6021 16 idea idea NN 19613 6021 17 assumed assume VBN 19613 6021 18 in in IN 19613 6021 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6021 20 ' ' POS 19613 6021 21 mind mind NN 19613 6021 22 . . . 19613 6022 1 This this DT 19613 6022 2 is be VBZ 19613 6022 3 , , , 19613 6022 4 however however RB 19613 6022 5 , , , 19613 6022 6 more more RBR 19613 6022 7 especially especially RB 19613 6022 8 evident evident JJ 19613 6022 9 from from IN 19613 6022 10 the the DT 19613 6022 11 assertion assertion NN 19613 6022 12 , , , 19613 6022 13 in in IN 19613 6022 14 opposition opposition NN 19613 6022 15 to to IN 19613 6022 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 6022 17 , , , 19613 6022 18 that that IN 19613 6022 19 unless unless IN 19613 6022 20 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6022 21 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6022 22 had have VBD 19613 6022 23 been be VBN 19613 6022 24 saved save VBN 19613 6022 25 by by IN 19613 6022 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6022 27 , , , 19613 6022 28 God God NNP 19613 6022 29 would would MD 19613 6022 30 have have VB 19613 6022 31 been be VBN 19613 6022 32 overcome overcome VBN 19613 6022 33 by by IN 19613 6022 34 the the DT 19613 6022 35 devil devil NN 19613 6022 36 . . . 19613 6023 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6023 2 576 576 CD 19613 6023 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6023 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6023 5 was be VBD 19613 6023 6 merely merely RB 19613 6023 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6023 8 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 6023 9 train train NN 19613 6023 10 of of IN 19613 6023 11 thought thought NN 19613 6023 12 that that WDT 19613 6023 13 saved save VBD 19613 6023 14 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6023 15 from from IN 19613 6023 16 the the DT 19613 6023 17 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 6023 18 that that IN 19613 6023 19 there there EX 19613 6023 20 is be VBZ 19613 6023 21 a a DT 19613 6023 22 restoration restoration NN 19613 6023 23 of of IN 19613 6023 24 _ _ NNP 19613 6023 25 all all DT 19613 6023 26 _ _ NNP 19613 6023 27 individual individual JJ 19613 6023 28 men man NNS 19613 6023 29 . . . 19613 6024 1 This this DT 19613 6024 2 conception conception NN 19613 6024 3 of of IN 19613 6024 4 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6024 5 as as IN 19613 6024 6 the the DT 19613 6024 7 representative representative NN 19613 6024 8 of of IN 19613 6024 9 humanity humanity NN 19613 6024 10 corresponds correspond NNS 19613 6024 11 to to IN 19613 6024 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6024 13 ' ' POS 19613 6024 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6024 15 of of IN 19613 6024 16 the the DT 19613 6024 17 God God NNP 19613 6024 18 - - HYPH 19613 6024 19 man man NNP 19613 6024 20 . . . 19613 6025 1 The the DT 19613 6025 2 historical historical JJ 19613 6025 3 importance importance NN 19613 6025 4 of of IN 19613 6025 5 this this DT 19613 6025 6 author author NN 19613 6025 7 lies lie VBZ 19613 6025 8 in in IN 19613 6025 9 the the DT 19613 6025 10 development development NN 19613 6025 11 of of IN 19613 6025 12 the the DT 19613 6025 13 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6025 14 . . . 19613 6026 1 At at IN 19613 6026 2 the the DT 19613 6026 3 present present JJ 19613 6026 4 day day NN 19613 6026 5 , , , 19613 6026 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6026 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6026 8 , , , 19613 6026 9 so so RB 19613 6026 10 far far RB 19613 6026 11 as as IN 19613 6026 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6026 13 seriously seriously RB 19613 6026 14 believes believe VBZ 19613 6026 15 in in IN 19613 6026 16 the the DT 19613 6026 17 unity unity NN 19613 6026 18 of of IN 19613 6026 19 the the DT 19613 6026 20 divine divine JJ 19613 6026 21 and and CC 19613 6026 22 human human JJ 19613 6026 23 in in IN 19613 6026 24 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6026 25 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6026 26 and and CC 19613 6026 27 deduces deduce VBZ 19613 6026 28 the the DT 19613 6026 29 divine divine JJ 19613 6026 30 manhood manhood NN 19613 6026 31 from from IN 19613 6026 32 the the DT 19613 6026 33 work work NN 19613 6026 34 of of IN 19613 6026 35 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6026 36 as as IN 19613 6026 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6026 38 deification deification NN 19613 6026 39 , , , 19613 6026 40 still still RB 19613 6026 41 occupies occupy VBZ 19613 6026 42 the the DT 19613 6026 43 same same JJ 19613 6026 44 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 6026 45 as as IN 19613 6026 46 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6026 47 did do VBD 19613 6026 48 . . . 19613 6027 1 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 6027 2 by by IN 19613 6027 3 no no DT 19613 6027 4 means means NN 19613 6027 5 matched match VBD 19613 6027 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6027 7 here here RB 19613 6027 8 ; ; : 19613 6027 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6027 10 too too RB 19613 6027 11 has have VBZ 19613 6027 12 the the DT 19613 6027 13 formula formula NN 19613 6027 14 in in IN 19613 6027 15 a a DT 19613 6027 16 few few JJ 19613 6027 17 passages passage NNS 19613 6027 18 , , , 19613 6027 19 but but CC 19613 6027 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6027 21 can can MD 19613 6027 22 not not RB 19613 6027 23 , , , 19613 6027 24 like like IN 19613 6027 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6027 26 , , , 19613 6027 27 account account VBP 19613 6027 28 for for IN 19613 6027 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6027 30 content content NN 19613 6027 31 . . . 19613 6028 1 On on IN 19613 6028 2 the the DT 19613 6028 3 other other JJ 19613 6028 4 hand hand NN 19613 6028 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6028 6 owe owe VBP 19613 6028 7 to to IN 19613 6028 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6028 9 the the DT 19613 6028 10 idea idea NN 19613 6028 11 of of IN 19613 6028 12 the the DT 19613 6028 13 " " `` 19613 6028 14 two two CD 19613 6028 15 natures nature NNS 19613 6028 16 , , , 19613 6028 17 " " '' 19613 6028 18 which which WDT 19613 6028 19 remain remain VBP 19613 6028 20 in in IN 19613 6028 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6028 22 integrity integrity NN 19613 6028 23 -- -- : 19613 6028 24 that that IN 19613 6028 25 formula formula NN 19613 6028 26 which which WDT 19613 6028 27 owes owe VBZ 19613 6028 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6028 29 adoption adoption NN 19613 6028 30 to to IN 19613 6028 31 the the DT 19613 6028 32 influence influence NN 19613 6028 33 of of IN 19613 6028 34 Leo Leo NNP 19613 6028 35 I. I. NNP 19613 6028 36 and and CC 19613 6028 37 at at IN 19613 6028 38 bottom bottom JJ 19613 6028 39 contradicts contradict NNS 19613 6028 40 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6028 41 ' ' POS 19613 6028 42 thought think VBD 19613 6028 43 " " '' 19613 6028 44 the the DT 19613 6028 45 Son Son NNP 19613 6028 46 of of IN 19613 6028 47 God God NNP 19613 6028 48 became become VBD 19613 6028 49 the the DT 19613 6028 50 Son Son NNP 19613 6028 51 of of IN 19613 6028 52 man man NN 19613 6028 53 , , , 19613 6028 54 " " '' 19613 6028 55 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6028 56 " " `` 19613 6028 57 filius filius NNP 19613 6028 58 dei dei NNP 19613 6028 59 factus factus NNP 19613 6028 60 filius filius NNP 19613 6028 61 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6028 62 " " '' 19613 6028 63 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6028 64 . . . 19613 6029 1 Finally finally RB 19613 6029 2 , , , 19613 6029 3 the the DT 19613 6029 4 manner manner NN 19613 6029 5 in in IN 19613 6029 6 which which WDT 19613 6029 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6029 8 tried try VBD 19613 6029 9 to to TO 19613 6029 10 interpret interpret VB 19613 6029 11 the the DT 19613 6029 12 historical historical JJ 19613 6029 13 utterances utterance NNS 19613 6029 14 about about IN 19613 6029 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6029 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6029 17 from from IN 19613 6029 18 the the DT 19613 6029 19 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 6029 20 of of IN 19613 6029 21 the the DT 19613 6029 22 Divine divine JJ 19613 6029 23 manhood manhood NN 19613 6029 24 idea idea NN 19613 6029 25 , , , 19613 6029 26 and and CC 19613 6029 27 to to TO 19613 6029 28 give give VB 19613 6029 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6029 30 a a DT 19613 6029 31 significance significance NN 19613 6029 32 in in IN 19613 6029 33 regard regard NN 19613 6029 34 to to IN 19613 6029 35 salvation salvation NN 19613 6029 36 is be VBZ 19613 6029 37 also also RB 19613 6029 38 an an DT 19613 6029 39 epoch epoch NN 19613 6029 40 - - HYPH 19613 6029 41 making make VBG 19613 6029 42 fact fact NN 19613 6029 43 . . . 19613 6030 1 " " `` 19613 6030 2 Filius Filius NNP 19613 6030 3 dei dei NNP 19613 6030 4 filius filius NNP 19613 6030 5 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6030 6 factus factus NN 19613 6030 7 , , , 19613 6030 8 " " '' 19613 6030 9 " " `` 19613 6030 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6030 11 is be VBZ 19613 6030 12 one one CD 19613 6030 13 and and CC 19613 6030 14 the the DT 19613 6030 15 same same JJ 19613 6030 16 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6030 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6030 18 , , , 19613 6030 19 not not RB 19613 6030 20 a a DT 19613 6030 21 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6030 22 and and CC 19613 6030 23 a a DT 19613 6030 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6030 25 , , , 19613 6030 26 nor nor CC 19613 6030 27 a a DT 19613 6030 28 mere mere JJ 19613 6030 29 temporary temporary JJ 19613 6030 30 union union NN 19613 6030 31 of of IN 19613 6030 32 an an DT 19613 6030 33 æon æon NN 19613 6030 34 and and CC 19613 6030 35 a a DT 19613 6030 36 man man NN 19613 6030 37 , , , 19613 6030 38 but but CC 19613 6030 39 one one CD 19613 6030 40 and and CC 19613 6030 41 the the DT 19613 6030 42 same same JJ 19613 6030 43 person person NN 19613 6030 44 , , , 19613 6030 45 who who WP 19613 6030 46 created create VBD 19613 6030 47 the the DT 19613 6030 48 world world NN 19613 6030 49 , , , 19613 6030 50 was be VBD 19613 6030 51 born bear VBN 19613 6030 52 , , , 19613 6030 53 suffered suffer VBN 19613 6030 54 , , , 19613 6030 55 and and CC 19613 6030 56 ascended"--this ascended"--this RB 19613 6030 57 along along IN 19613 6030 58 with with IN 19613 6030 59 the the DT 19613 6030 60 dogma dogma NN 19613 6030 61 of of IN 19613 6030 62 God God NNP 19613 6030 63 the the DT 19613 6030 64 Creator Creator NNP 19613 6030 65 is be VBZ 19613 6030 66 the the DT 19613 6030 67 cardinal cardinal JJ 19613 6030 68 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6030 69 of of IN 19613 6030 70 Irenæus:[577 Irenæus:[577 NNP 19613 6030 71 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6030 72 " " `` 19613 6030 73 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6030 74 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6030 75 truly truly RB 19613 6030 76 man man VBP 19613 6030 77 and and CC 19613 6030 78 truly truly RB 19613 6030 79 God God NNP 19613 6030 80 " " '' 19613 6030 81 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6030 82 " " `` 19613 6030 83 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6030 84 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6030 85 , , , 19613 6030 86 vere vere NNP 19613 6030 87 homo homo NNP 19613 6030 88 , , , 19613 6030 89 vere vere NNP 19613 6030 90 deus deus NNP 19613 6030 91 " " '' 19613 6030 92 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6030 93 . . . 19613 6031 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6031 2 578 578 CD 19613 6031 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6031 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6031 5 is be VBZ 19613 6031 6 only only RB 19613 6031 7 the the DT 19613 6031 8 Church Church NNP 19613 6031 9 that that WDT 19613 6031 10 adheres adhere VBZ 19613 6031 11 to to IN 19613 6031 12 this this DT 19613 6031 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6031 14 , , , 19613 6031 15 for for IN 19613 6031 16 " " `` 19613 6031 17 none none NN 19613 6031 18 of of IN 19613 6031 19 the the DT 19613 6031 20 heretics heretic NNS 19613 6031 21 hold hold VBP 19613 6031 22 the the DT 19613 6031 23 opinion opinion NN 19613 6031 24 that that IN 19613 6031 25 the the DT 19613 6031 26 Word Word NNP 19613 6031 27 of of IN 19613 6031 28 God God NNP 19613 6031 29 became become VBD 19613 6031 30 flesh flesh NN 19613 6031 31 " " '' 19613 6031 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6031 33 " " `` 19613 6031 34 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6031 35 nullam nullam JJ 19613 6031 36 sententiam sententiam NNP 19613 6031 37 hæreticorum hæreticorum NNP 19613 6031 38 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6031 39 dei dei NNP 19613 6031 40 caro caro NNP 19613 6031 41 factum factum NNP 19613 6031 42 est est IN 19613 6031 43 " " '' 19613 6031 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6031 45 . . . 19613 6032 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6032 2 579 579 CD 19613 6032 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6032 4 What what WP 19613 6032 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 6032 6 has have VBZ 19613 6032 7 to to TO 19613 6032 8 be be VB 19613 6032 9 shown show VBN 19613 6032 10 is be VBZ 19613 6032 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6032 12 1 1 LS 19613 6032 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6032 14 that that WDT 19613 6032 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6032 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6032 17 is be VBZ 19613 6032 18 really really RB 19613 6032 19 the the DT 19613 6032 20 Word Word NNP 19613 6032 21 of of IN 19613 6032 22 God God NNP 19613 6032 23 , , , 19613 6032 24 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6032 25 , , , 19613 6032 26 is be VBZ 19613 6032 27 God God NNP 19613 6032 28 , , , 19613 6032 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6032 30 2 2 LS 19613 6032 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6032 32 that that IN 19613 6032 33 this this DT 19613 6032 34 Word Word NNP 19613 6032 35 really really RB 19613 6032 36 became become VBD 19613 6032 37 man man NN 19613 6032 38 and and CC 19613 6032 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6032 40 3 3 LS 19613 6032 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6032 42 that that IN 19613 6032 43 the the DT 19613 6032 44 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 6032 45 Word Word NNP 19613 6032 46 is be VBZ 19613 6032 47 an an DT 19613 6032 48 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 6032 49 unity unity NN 19613 6032 50 . . . 19613 6033 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6033 2 maintains maintain VBZ 19613 6033 3 the the DT 19613 6033 4 first first JJ 19613 6033 5 statement statement NN 19613 6033 6 as as RB 19613 6033 7 well well RB 19613 6033 8 against against IN 19613 6033 9 the the DT 19613 6033 10 " " `` 19613 6033 11 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 19613 6033 12 " " '' 19613 6033 13 as as IN 19613 6033 14 against against IN 19613 6033 15 the the DT 19613 6033 16 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 6033 17 who who WP 19613 6033 18 thought think VBD 19613 6033 19 that that IN 19613 6033 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6033 21 's 's POS 19613 6033 22 advent advent NN 19613 6033 23 was be VBD 19613 6033 24 the the DT 19613 6033 25 descent descent NN 19613 6033 26 of of IN 19613 6033 27 one one CD 19613 6033 28 of of IN 19613 6033 29 the the DT 19613 6033 30 many many JJ 19613 6033 31 æons æon NNS 19613 6033 32 . . . 19613 6034 1 In in IN 19613 6034 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 6034 3 to to IN 19613 6034 4 the the DT 19613 6034 5 Ebionites Ebionites NNPS 19613 6034 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6034 7 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 6034 8 the the DT 19613 6034 9 distinction distinction NN 19613 6034 10 between between IN 19613 6034 11 natural natural JJ 19613 6034 12 and and CC 19613 6034 13 adopted adopt VBD 19613 6034 14 Sonship Sonship NNP 19613 6034 15 , , , 19613 6034 16 appeals appeal NNS 19613 6034 17 to to IN 19613 6034 18 the the DT 19613 6034 19 Old Old NNP 19613 6034 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6034 21 testimony testimony NN 19613 6034 22 in in IN 19613 6034 23 favour favour NN 19613 6034 24 of of IN 19613 6034 25 the the DT 19613 6034 26 divinity divinity NN 19613 6034 27 of of IN 19613 6034 28 Christ,[580 Christ,[580 NNP 19613 6034 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6034 30 and and CC 19613 6034 31 moreover moreover RB 19613 6034 32 argues argue VBZ 19613 6034 33 that that IN 19613 6034 34 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6034 35 would would MD 19613 6034 36 still still RB 19613 6034 37 be be VB 19613 6034 38 in in IN 19613 6034 39 the the DT 19613 6034 40 bondage bondage NN 19613 6034 41 of of IN 19613 6034 42 the the DT 19613 6034 43 old old JJ 19613 6034 44 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 6034 45 , , , 19613 6034 46 if if IN 19613 6034 47 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6034 48 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6034 49 had have VBD 19613 6034 50 only only RB 19613 6034 51 been be VBN 19613 6034 52 a a DT 19613 6034 53 man man NN 19613 6034 54 . . . 19613 6035 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6035 2 581 581 CD 19613 6035 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6035 4 In in IN 19613 6035 5 this this DT 19613 6035 6 connection connection NN 19613 6035 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6035 8 also also RB 19613 6035 9 discussed discuss VBD 19613 6035 10 the the DT 19613 6035 11 birth birth NN 19613 6035 12 from from IN 19613 6035 13 the the DT 19613 6035 14 virgin virgin NN 19613 6035 15 . . . 19613 6036 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6036 2 582 582 CD 19613 6036 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6036 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6036 5 not not RB 19613 6036 6 only only RB 19613 6036 7 proved prove VBD 19613 6036 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6036 9 from from IN 19613 6036 10 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 6036 11 , , , 19613 6036 12 but but CC 19613 6036 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6036 14 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6036 15 theory theory NN 19613 6036 16 also also RB 19613 6036 17 suggested suggest VBD 19613 6036 18 to to IN 19613 6036 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6036 20 a a DT 19613 6036 21 parallel parallel NN 19613 6036 22 between between IN 19613 6036 23 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6036 24 and and CC 19613 6036 25 Eve Eve NNP 19613 6036 26 on on IN 19613 6036 27 the the DT 19613 6036 28 one one CD 19613 6036 29 hand hand NN 19613 6036 30 and and CC 19613 6036 31 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6036 32 and and CC 19613 6036 33 Mary Mary NNP 19613 6036 34 on on IN 19613 6036 35 the the DT 19613 6036 36 other other JJ 19613 6036 37 , , , 19613 6036 38 which which WDT 19613 6036 39 included include VBD 19613 6036 40 the the DT 19613 6036 41 birth birth NN 19613 6036 42 from from IN 19613 6036 43 the the DT 19613 6036 44 virgin virgin NN 19613 6036 45 . . . 19613 6037 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6037 2 583 583 CD 19613 6037 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6037 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6037 5 argues argue VBZ 19613 6037 6 in in IN 19613 6037 7 opposition opposition NN 19613 6037 8 to to IN 19613 6037 9 the the DT 19613 6037 10 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 6037 11 that that IN 19613 6037 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6037 13 was be VBD 19613 6037 14 really really RB 19613 6037 15 the the DT 19613 6037 16 eternal eternal JJ 19613 6037 17 Word Word NNP 19613 6037 18 of of IN 19613 6037 19 God God NNP 19613 6037 20 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6037 21 , , , 19613 6037 22 who who WP 19613 6037 23 was be VBD 19613 6037 24 always always RB 19613 6037 25 with with IN 19613 6037 26 God God NNP 19613 6037 27 and and CC 19613 6037 28 always always RB 19613 6037 29 present present JJ 19613 6037 30 to to IN 19613 6037 31 the the DT 19613 6037 32 human human JJ 19613 6037 33 race race NN 19613 6037 34 , , , 19613 6037 35 that that WDT 19613 6037 36 descended descend VBD 19613 6037 37 . . . 19613 6038 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6038 2 584 584 CD 19613 6038 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6038 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6038 5 who who WP 19613 6038 6 became become VBD 19613 6038 7 man man NN 19613 6038 8 was be VBD 19613 6038 9 not not RB 19613 6038 10 a a DT 19613 6038 11 being be VBG 19613 6038 12 foreign foreign JJ 19613 6038 13 to to IN 19613 6038 14 the the DT 19613 6038 15 world world NN 19613 6038 16 -- -- : 19613 6038 17 this this DT 19613 6038 18 is be VBZ 19613 6038 19 said say VBN 19613 6038 20 in in IN 19613 6038 21 opposition opposition NN 19613 6038 22 to to IN 19613 6038 23 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6038 24 -- -- : 19613 6038 25 but but CC 19613 6038 26 the the DT 19613 6038 27 Lord Lord NNP 19613 6038 28 of of IN 19613 6038 29 the the DT 19613 6038 30 world world NN 19613 6038 31 and and CC 19613 6038 32 humanity humanity NN 19613 6038 33 , , , 19613 6038 34 the the DT 19613 6038 35 Son Son NNP 19613 6038 36 of of IN 19613 6038 37 God God NNP 19613 6038 38 , , , 19613 6038 39 and and CC 19613 6038 40 none none NN 19613 6038 41 other other JJ 19613 6038 42 . . . 19613 6039 1 The the DT 19613 6039 2 reality reality NN 19613 6039 3 of of IN 19613 6039 4 the the DT 19613 6039 5 body body NN 19613 6039 6 of of IN 19613 6039 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6039 8 , , , 19613 6039 9 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6039 10 , , , 19613 6039 11 the the DT 19613 6039 12 essential essential JJ 19613 6039 13 identity identity NN 19613 6039 14 of of IN 19613 6039 15 the the DT 19613 6039 16 humanity humanity NN 19613 6039 17 of of IN 19613 6039 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6039 19 with with IN 19613 6039 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6039 21 own own JJ 19613 6039 22 , , , 19613 6039 23 was be VBD 19613 6039 24 continually continually RB 19613 6039 25 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 6039 26 by by IN 19613 6039 27 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6039 28 , , , 19613 6039 29 and and CC 19613 6039 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6039 31 views view VBZ 19613 6039 32 the the DT 19613 6039 33 whole whole JJ 19613 6039 34 work work NN 19613 6039 35 of of IN 19613 6039 36 salvation salvation NN 19613 6039 37 as as IN 19613 6039 38 dependent dependent JJ 19613 6039 39 on on IN 19613 6039 40 this this DT 19613 6039 41 identity identity NN 19613 6039 42 . . . 19613 6040 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6040 2 585 585 CD 19613 6040 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6040 4 In in IN 19613 6040 5 the the DT 19613 6040 6 latter latter NN 19613 6040 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6040 8 also also RB 19613 6040 9 includes include VBZ 19613 6040 10 the the DT 19613 6040 11 fact fact NN 19613 6040 12 that that IN 19613 6040 13 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6040 14 must must MD 19613 6040 15 have have VB 19613 6040 16 passed pass VBN 19613 6040 17 through through RP 19613 6040 18 and and CC 19613 6040 19 been be VBN 19613 6040 20 subjected subject VBN 19613 6040 21 to to IN 19613 6040 22 all all PDT 19613 6040 23 the the DT 19613 6040 24 conditions condition NNS 19613 6040 25 of of IN 19613 6040 26 a a DT 19613 6040 27 complete complete JJ 19613 6040 28 human human JJ 19613 6040 29 life life NN 19613 6040 30 from from IN 19613 6040 31 birth birth NN 19613 6040 32 to to IN 19613 6040 33 old old JJ 19613 6040 34 age age NN 19613 6040 35 and and CC 19613 6040 36 death death NN 19613 6040 37 . . . 19613 6041 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6041 2 586 586 CD 19613 6041 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6041 4 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6041 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6041 6 is be VBZ 19613 6041 7 therefore therefore RB 19613 6041 8 the the DT 19613 6041 9 Son Son NNP 19613 6041 10 of of IN 19613 6041 11 God God NNP 19613 6041 12 who who WP 19613 6041 13 has have VBZ 19613 6041 14 really really RB 19613 6041 15 become become VBN 19613 6041 16 the the DT 19613 6041 17 Son Son NNP 19613 6041 18 of of IN 19613 6041 19 man man NNP 19613 6041 20 ; ; : 19613 6041 21 and and CC 19613 6041 22 these these DT 19613 6041 23 are be VBP 19613 6041 24 not not RB 19613 6041 25 two two CD 19613 6041 26 Christs Christs NNPS 19613 6041 27 but but CC 19613 6041 28 one one CD 19613 6041 29 , , , 19613 6041 30 in in IN 19613 6041 31 whom whom WP 19613 6041 32 the the DT 19613 6041 33 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6041 34 is be VBZ 19613 6041 35 permanently permanently RB 19613 6041 36 united united JJ 19613 6041 37 with with IN 19613 6041 38 humanity humanity NN 19613 6041 39 . . . 19613 6042 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6042 2 587 587 CD 19613 6042 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6042 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6042 5 called call VBD 19613 6042 6 this this DT 19613 6042 7 union union NN 19613 6042 8 " " `` 19613 6042 9 union union NN 19613 6042 10 of of IN 19613 6042 11 the the DT 19613 6042 12 Word Word NNP 19613 6042 13 of of IN 19613 6042 14 God God NNP 19613 6042 15 with with IN 19613 6042 16 the the DT 19613 6042 17 creature creature NN 19613 6042 18 " " '' 19613 6042 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6042 20 " " `` 19613 6042 21 adunitio adunitio NNP 19613 6042 22 verbi verbi NNP 19613 6042 23 dei dei NNP 19613 6042 24 ad ad NNP 19613 6042 25 plasma")[588 plasma")[588 , 19613 6042 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6042 27 and and CC 19613 6042 28 " " `` 19613 6042 29 blending blending NN 19613 6042 30 and and CC 19613 6042 31 communion communion NN 19613 6042 32 of of IN 19613 6042 33 God God NNP 19613 6042 34 and and CC 19613 6042 35 man man NN 19613 6042 36 " " '' 19613 6042 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6042 38 " " '' 19613 6042 39 commixtio commixtio NNP 19613 6042 40 et et NNP 19613 6042 41 communio communio NNP 19613 6042 42 dei dei NNP 19613 6042 43 et et NNP 19613 6042 44 hominis")[589 hominis")[589 , 19613 6042 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6042 46 without without IN 19613 6042 47 thereby thereby RB 19613 6042 48 describing describe VBG 19613 6042 49 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6042 50 any any DT 19613 6042 51 more more RBR 19613 6042 52 clearly clearly RB 19613 6042 53 . . . 19613 6043 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6043 2 590 590 CD 19613 6043 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6043 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6043 5 views view VBZ 19613 6043 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6043 7 as as IN 19613 6043 8 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6043 9 , , , 19613 6043 10 for for IN 19613 6043 11 , , , 19613 6043 12 _ _ NNP 19613 6043 13 as as IN 19613 6043 14 a a DT 19613 6043 15 rule rule NN 19613 6043 16 _ _ NNP 19613 6043 17 , , , 19613 6043 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6043 19 will will MD 19613 6043 20 not not RB 19613 6043 21 listen listen VB 19613 6043 22 to to IN 19613 6043 23 any any DT 19613 6043 24 separation separation NN 19613 6043 25 of of IN 19613 6043 26 what what WP 19613 6043 27 was be VBD 19613 6043 28 done do VBN 19613 6043 29 by by IN 19613 6043 30 the the DT 19613 6043 31 man man NN 19613 6043 32 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6043 33 and and CC 19613 6043 34 by by IN 19613 6043 35 God God NNP 19613 6043 36 the the DT 19613 6043 37 Word Word NNP 19613 6043 38 . . . 19613 6044 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6044 2 591 591 CD 19613 6044 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6044 4 The the DT 19613 6044 5 explicit explicit JJ 19613 6044 6 formula formula NN 19613 6044 7 of of IN 19613 6044 8 two two CD 19613 6044 9 substances substance NNS 19613 6044 10 or or CC 19613 6044 11 natures nature NNS 19613 6044 12 in in IN 19613 6044 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6044 14 is be VBZ 19613 6044 15 not not RB 19613 6044 16 found find VBN 19613 6044 17 in in IN 19613 6044 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6044 19 ; ; : 19613 6044 20 but but CC 19613 6044 21 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6044 22 already already RB 19613 6044 23 used use VBD 19613 6044 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6044 25 . . . 19613 6045 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6045 2 never never RB 19613 6045 3 occurred occur VBD 19613 6045 4 to to IN 19613 6045 5 the the DT 19613 6045 6 former former JJ 19613 6045 7 , , , 19613 6045 8 just just RB 19613 6045 9 because because IN 19613 6045 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6045 11 was be VBD 19613 6045 12 not not RB 19613 6045 13 here here RB 19613 6045 14 speaking speak VBG 19613 6045 15 as as IN 19613 6045 16 a a DT 19613 6045 17 theologian theologian NN 19613 6045 18 , , , 19613 6045 19 but but CC 19613 6045 20 expressing express VBG 19613 6045 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6045 22 belief belief NN 19613 6045 23 . . . 19613 6046 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6046 2 592 592 CD 19613 6046 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6046 4 In in IN 19613 6046 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6046 6 utterances utterance NNS 19613 6046 7 about about IN 19613 6046 8 the the DT 19613 6046 9 God God NNP 19613 6046 10 - - HYPH 19613 6046 11 man man NN 19613 6046 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6046 13 closely closely RB 19613 6046 14 imitates imitate VBZ 19613 6046 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6046 16 . . . 19613 6047 1 Like like IN 19613 6047 2 the the DT 19613 6047 3 latter latter JJ 19613 6047 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6047 5 uses use VBZ 19613 6047 6 the the DT 19613 6047 7 expression expression NN 19613 6047 8 " " `` 19613 6047 9 man man NN 19613 6047 10 united unite VBN 19613 6047 11 with with IN 19613 6047 12 God God NNP 19613 6047 13 " " '' 19613 6047 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6047 15 " " `` 19613 6047 16 homo homo NNP 19613 6047 17 deo deo NNP 19613 6047 18 mixtus")[593 mixtus")[593 NNP 19613 6047 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6047 20 and and CC 19613 6047 21 like like IN 19613 6047 22 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6047 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6047 24 applies apply VBZ 19613 6047 25 the the DT 19613 6047 26 predicates predicate NNS 19613 6047 27 of of IN 19613 6047 28 the the DT 19613 6047 29 man man NN 19613 6047 30 to to IN 19613 6047 31 the the DT 19613 6047 32 Son Son NNP 19613 6047 33 of of IN 19613 6047 34 God God NNP 19613 6047 35 . . . 19613 6048 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6048 2 594 594 CD 19613 6048 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6048 4 But but CC 19613 6048 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6048 6 goes go VBZ 19613 6048 7 further far RBR 19613 6048 8 , , , 19613 6048 9 or or CC 19613 6048 10 rather rather RB 19613 6048 11 , , , 19613 6048 12 in in IN 19613 6048 13 the the DT 19613 6048 14 interest interest NN 19613 6048 15 of of IN 19613 6048 16 formal formal JJ 19613 6048 17 clearness clearness NN 19613 6048 18 , , , 19613 6048 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6048 20 expresses express VBZ 19613 6048 21 the the DT 19613 6048 22 mystery mystery NN 19613 6048 23 in in IN 19613 6048 24 a a DT 19613 6048 25 manner manner NN 19613 6048 26 which which WDT 19613 6048 27 shows show VBZ 19613 6048 28 that that IN 19613 6048 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6048 30 did do VBD 19613 6048 31 not not RB 19613 6048 32 fully fully RB 19613 6048 33 realise realise VB 19613 6048 34 the the DT 19613 6048 35 religious religious JJ 19613 6048 36 significance significance NN 19613 6048 37 of of IN 19613 6048 38 the the DT 19613 6048 39 proposition proposition NN 19613 6048 40 , , , 19613 6048 41 " " '' 19613 6048 42 the the DT 19613 6048 43 Son Son NNP 19613 6048 44 of of IN 19613 6048 45 God God NNP 19613 6048 46 made make VBD 19613 6048 47 Son Son NNP 19613 6048 48 of of IN 19613 6048 49 man man NN 19613 6048 50 " " '' 19613 6048 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6048 52 " " `` 19613 6048 53 filius filius NNP 19613 6048 54 dei dei NNP 19613 6048 55 filius filius NNP 19613 6048 56 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6048 57 factus factus NN 19613 6048 58 " " '' 19613 6048 59 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6048 60 . . . 19613 6049 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6049 2 speaks speak VBZ 19613 6049 3 of of IN 19613 6049 4 a a DT 19613 6049 5 " " `` 19613 6049 6 corporal corporal JJ 19613 6049 7 and and CC 19613 6049 8 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 6049 9 , , , 19613 6049 10 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6049 11 , , , 19613 6049 12 divine divine JJ 19613 6049 13 , , , 19613 6049 14 substance substance NN 19613 6049 15 of of IN 19613 6049 16 the the DT 19613 6049 17 Lord Lord NNP 19613 6049 18 " " '' 19613 6049 19 , , , 19613 6049 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6049 21 " " `` 19613 6049 22 corporalis corporalis NNP 19613 6049 23 et et NNP 19613 6049 24 spiritalis spiritalis NNP 19613 6049 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6049 26 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6049 27 , , , 19613 6049 28 divina divina NNP 19613 6049 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6049 30 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6049 31 domini")[595 domini")[595 NNP 19613 6049 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6049 33 of of IN 19613 6049 34 " " `` 19613 6049 35 either either DT 19613 6049 36 substance substance NN 19613 6049 37 of of IN 19613 6049 38 the the DT 19613 6049 39 flesh flesh NN 19613 6049 40 and and CC 19613 6049 41 spirit spirit NN 19613 6049 42 of of IN 19613 6049 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6049 44 " " '' 19613 6049 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6049 46 " " `` 19613 6049 47 utraque utraque NNP 19613 6049 48 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6049 49 et et NNP 19613 6049 50 carnis carnis NNP 19613 6049 51 et et FW 19613 6049 52 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 6049 53 Christi Christi NNP 19613 6049 54 " " '' 19613 6049 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6049 56 , , , 19613 6049 57 of of IN 19613 6049 58 the the DT 19613 6049 59 " " `` 19613 6049 60 creation creation NN 19613 6049 61 of of IN 19613 6049 62 two two CD 19613 6049 63 substances substance NNS 19613 6049 64 which which WDT 19613 6049 65 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6049 66 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6049 67 also also RB 19613 6049 68 possesses possess VBZ 19613 6049 69 , , , 19613 6049 70 " " '' 19613 6049 71 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6049 72 " " `` 19613 6049 73 conditio conditio NNP 19613 6049 74 duarum duarum NN 19613 6049 75 substantiarum substantiarum NN 19613 6049 76 , , , 19613 6049 77 quas quas NNP 19613 6049 78 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6049 79 et et NNP 19613 6049 80 ipse ipse NN 19613 6049 81 gestat")[596 gestat")[596 , 19613 6049 82 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6049 83 and and CC 19613 6049 84 of of IN 19613 6049 85 the the DT 19613 6049 86 " " `` 19613 6049 87 twofold twofold JJ 19613 6049 88 condition condition NN 19613 6049 89 not not RB 19613 6049 90 blended blend VBN 19613 6049 91 but but CC 19613 6049 92 united unite VBN 19613 6049 93 in in IN 19613 6049 94 one one CD 19613 6049 95 person person NN 19613 6049 96 -- -- : 19613 6049 97 God God NNP 19613 6049 98 and and CC 19613 6049 99 man man NN 19613 6049 100 " " '' 19613 6049 101 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6049 102 " " `` 19613 6049 103 duplex duplex JJ 19613 6049 104 status status NN 19613 6049 105 _ _ NNP 19613 6049 106 non non AFX 19613 6049 107 confusus confusus NNP 19613 6049 108 sed se VBD 19613 6049 109 conjunctus conjunctus NNP 19613 6049 110 _ _ NNP 19613 6049 111 in in IN 19613 6049 112 una una NNP 19613 6049 113 persona persona NN 19613 6049 114 -- -- : 19613 6049 115 deus deus NNP 19613 6049 116 et et NNP 19613 6049 117 homo homo NN 19613 6049 118 " " '' 19613 6049 119 . . . 19613 6050 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6050 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6050 3 597 597 CD 19613 6050 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6050 5 Here here RB 19613 6050 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6050 7 already already RB 19613 6050 8 have have VBP 19613 6050 9 in in IN 19613 6050 10 a a DT 19613 6050 11 complete complete JJ 19613 6050 12 form form NN 19613 6050 13 the the DT 19613 6050 14 later later JJ 19613 6050 15 Chalcedonian chalcedonian JJ 19613 6050 16 formula formula NN 19613 6050 17 of of IN 19613 6050 18 the the DT 19613 6050 19 two two CD 19613 6050 20 substances substance NNS 19613 6050 21 in in IN 19613 6050 22 one one CD 19613 6050 23 person person NN 19613 6050 24 . . . 19613 6051 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6051 2 598 598 CD 19613 6051 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6051 4 At at IN 19613 6051 5 the the DT 19613 6051 6 same same JJ 19613 6051 7 time time NN 19613 6051 8 , , , 19613 6051 9 however however RB 19613 6051 10 , , , 19613 6051 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6051 12 can can MD 19613 6051 13 clearly clearly RB 19613 6051 14 see see VB 19613 6051 15 that that IN 19613 6051 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6051 17 went go VBD 19613 6051 18 beyond beyond IN 19613 6051 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6051 20 in in IN 19613 6051 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6051 22 exposition exposition NN 19613 6051 23 . . . 19613 6052 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6052 2 599 599 CD 19613 6052 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6052 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6052 5 was be VBD 19613 6052 6 , , , 19613 6052 7 moreover moreover RB 19613 6052 8 , , , 19613 6052 9 impelled impel VBN 19613 6052 10 to to TO 19613 6052 11 combat combat VB 19613 6052 12 an an DT 19613 6052 13 antagonistic antagonistic JJ 19613 6052 14 principle principle NN 19613 6052 15 . . . 19613 6053 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6053 2 had have VBD 19613 6053 3 as as RB 19613 6053 4 yet yet RB 19613 6053 5 no no DT 19613 6053 6 occasion occasion NN 19613 6053 7 to to TO 19613 6053 8 explain explain VB 19613 6053 9 in in IN 19613 6053 10 detail detail NN 19613 6053 11 that that IN 19613 6053 12 the the DT 19613 6053 13 proposition proposition NN 19613 6053 14 " " `` 19613 6053 15 the the DT 19613 6053 16 Word Word NNP 19613 6053 17 became become VBD 19613 6053 18 flesh flesh NN 19613 6053 19 " " '' 19613 6053 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6053 21 " " `` 19613 6053 22 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6053 23 caro caro NNP 19613 6053 24 factum factum NNP 19613 6053 25 " " '' 19613 6053 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6053 27 denoted denote VBD 19613 6053 28 no no DT 19613 6053 29 transformation transformation NN 19613 6053 30 . . . 19613 6054 1 That that IN 19613 6054 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6054 3 excludes exclude VBZ 19613 6054 4 the the DT 19613 6054 5 idea idea NN 19613 6054 6 of of IN 19613 6054 7 change change NN 19613 6054 8 , , , 19613 6054 9 and and CC 19613 6054 10 that that IN 19613 6054 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6054 12 puts put VBZ 19613 6054 13 stress stress NN 19613 6054 14 on on IN 19613 6054 15 the the DT 19613 6054 16 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6054 17 ' ' POS 19613 6054 18 assumption assumption NN 19613 6054 19 of of IN 19613 6054 20 flesh flesh NN 19613 6054 21 from from IN 19613 6054 22 the the DT 19613 6054 23 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 6054 24 is be VBZ 19613 6054 25 shown show VBN 19613 6054 26 by by IN 19613 6054 27 many many JJ 19613 6054 28 passages passage NNS 19613 6054 29 . . . 19613 6055 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6055 2 600 600 CD 19613 6055 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6055 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6055 5 , , , 19613 6055 6 on on IN 19613 6055 7 the the DT 19613 6055 8 other other JJ 19613 6055 9 hand hand NN 19613 6055 10 , , , 19613 6055 11 was be VBD 19613 6055 12 in in IN 19613 6055 13 the the DT 19613 6055 14 first first JJ 19613 6055 15 place place NN 19613 6055 16 confronted confront VBN 19613 6055 17 by by IN 19613 6055 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6055 19 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 6055 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6055 21 opponents opponent NNS 19613 6055 22 who who WP 19613 6055 23 understood understand VBD 19613 6055 24 John John NNP 19613 6055 25 's 's POS 19613 6055 26 statement statement NN 19613 6055 27 in in IN 19613 6055 28 the the DT 19613 6055 29 sense sense NN 19613 6055 30 of of IN 19613 6055 31 the the DT 19613 6055 32 Word Word NNP 19613 6055 33 's 's POS 19613 6055 34 transforming transforming NN 19613 6055 35 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6055 36 into into IN 19613 6055 37 flesh flesh NN 19613 6055 38 , , , 19613 6055 39 and and CC 19613 6055 40 therefore therefore RB 19613 6055 41 argued argue VBD 19613 6055 42 against against IN 19613 6055 43 the the DT 19613 6055 44 " " `` 19613 6055 45 assumption assumption NN 19613 6055 46 of of IN 19613 6055 47 flesh flesh NN 19613 6055 48 from from IN 19613 6055 49 the the DT 19613 6055 50 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 6055 51 " " '' 19613 6055 52 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6055 53 " " `` 19613 6055 54 assumptio assumptio NN 19613 6055 55 carnis carnis NNP 19613 6055 56 ex ex NNP 19613 6055 57 virgine");[601 virgine");[601 NN 19613 6055 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6055 59 and and CC 19613 6055 60 , , , 19613 6055 61 in in IN 19613 6055 62 the the DT 19613 6055 63 second second JJ 19613 6055 64 place place NN 19613 6055 65 , , , 19613 6055 66 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6055 67 had have VBD 19613 6055 68 to to TO 19613 6055 69 do do VB 19613 6055 70 with with IN 19613 6055 71 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6055 72 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 6055 73 who who WP 19613 6055 74 indeed indeed RB 19613 6055 75 admitted admit VBD 19613 6055 76 the the DT 19613 6055 77 birth birth NN 19613 6055 78 from from IN 19613 6055 79 the the DT 19613 6055 80 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 6055 81 , , , 19613 6055 82 but but CC 19613 6055 83 likewise likewise RB 19613 6055 84 assumed assume VBD 19613 6055 85 a a DT 19613 6055 86 change change NN 19613 6055 87 of of IN 19613 6055 88 God God NNP 19613 6055 89 into into IN 19613 6055 90 flesh flesh NN 19613 6055 91 , , , 19613 6055 92 and and CC 19613 6055 93 declared declare VBD 19613 6055 94 the the DT 19613 6055 95 God God NNP 19613 6055 96 thus thus RB 19613 6055 97 invested invest VBN 19613 6055 98 with with IN 19613 6055 99 flesh flesh NN 19613 6055 100 to to TO 19613 6055 101 be be VB 19613 6055 102 the the DT 19613 6055 103 Son Son NNP 19613 6055 104 . . . 19613 6056 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6056 2 602 602 CD 19613 6056 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6056 4 In in IN 19613 6056 5 this this DT 19613 6056 6 connection connection NN 19613 6056 7 the the DT 19613 6056 8 same same JJ 19613 6056 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6056 10 , , , 19613 6056 11 who who WP 19613 6056 12 in in IN 19613 6056 13 the the DT 19613 6056 14 Church Church NNP 19613 6056 15 laid lay VBD 19613 6056 16 great great JJ 19613 6056 17 weight weight NN 19613 6056 18 on on IN 19613 6056 19 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6056 20 like like IN 19613 6056 21 " " '' 19613 6056 22 the the DT 19613 6056 23 crucified crucify VBN 19613 6056 24 God God NNP 19613 6056 25 , , , 19613 6056 26 " " '' 19613 6056 27 " " `` 19613 6056 28 God God NNP 19613 6056 29 consented consent VBD 19613 6056 30 to to TO 19613 6056 31 be be VB 19613 6056 32 born bear VBN 19613 6056 33 " " '' 19613 6056 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6056 35 " " `` 19613 6056 36 deus deus NNP 19613 6056 37 crucifixus crucifixus NNP 19613 6056 38 , , , 19613 6056 39 " " '' 19613 6056 40 " " `` 19613 6056 41 nasci nasci NNP 19613 6056 42 se se NNP 19613 6056 43 voluit voluit NNP 19613 6056 44 deus deus NNP 19613 6056 45 " " '' 19613 6056 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6056 47 and and CC 19613 6056 48 who who WP 19613 6056 49 , , , 19613 6056 50 impelled impel VBN 19613 6056 51 by by IN 19613 6056 52 opposition opposition NN 19613 6056 53 to to IN 19613 6056 54 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6056 55 and and CC 19613 6056 56 by by IN 19613 6056 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6056 58 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 6056 59 interest interest NN 19613 6056 60 , , , 19613 6056 61 distinguished distinguish VBD 19613 6056 62 the the DT 19613 6056 63 Son Son NNP 19613 6056 64 as as IN 19613 6056 65 capable capable JJ 19613 6056 66 of of IN 19613 6056 67 suffering suffer VBG 19613 6056 68 from from IN 19613 6056 69 God God NNP 19613 6056 70 the the DT 19613 6056 71 Father Father NNP 19613 6056 72 who who WP 19613 6056 73 is be VBZ 19613 6056 74 impassible impassible JJ 19613 6056 75 , , , 19613 6056 76 and and CC 19613 6056 77 imputed impute VBD 19613 6056 78 to to IN 19613 6056 79 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6056 80 human human JJ 19613 6056 81 weaknesses weakness NNS 19613 6056 82 -- -- : 19613 6056 83 which which WDT 19613 6056 84 was be VBD 19613 6056 85 already already RB 19613 6056 86 a a DT 19613 6056 87 further further RB 19613 6056 88 step,--sharply step,--sharply RB 19613 6056 89 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 6056 90 the the DT 19613 6056 91 " " `` 19613 6056 92 distinct distinct JJ 19613 6056 93 function function NN 19613 6056 94 " " '' 19613 6056 95 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6056 96 " " `` 19613 6056 97 distincte distincte NNS 19613 6056 98 agere agere RB 19613 6056 99 " " '' 19613 6056 100 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6056 101 of of IN 19613 6056 102 the the DT 19613 6056 103 two two CD 19613 6056 104 substances substance NNS 19613 6056 105 in in IN 19613 6056 106 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6056 107 and and CC 19613 6056 108 thus thus RB 19613 6056 109 separated separate VBD 19613 6056 110 the the DT 19613 6056 111 persons person NNS 19613 6056 112 . . . 19613 6057 1 With with IN 19613 6057 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6057 3 the the DT 19613 6057 4 interest interest NN 19613 6057 5 in in IN 19613 6057 6 the the DT 19613 6057 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6057 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6057 9 , , , 19613 6057 10 on on IN 19613 6057 11 the the DT 19613 6057 12 one one CD 19613 6057 13 hand hand NN 19613 6057 14 , , , 19613 6057 15 and and CC 19613 6057 16 in in IN 19613 6057 17 the the DT 19613 6057 18 real real JJ 19613 6057 19 humanity humanity NN 19613 6057 20 , , , 19613 6057 21 on on IN 19613 6057 22 the the DT 19613 6057 23 other other JJ 19613 6057 24 , , , 19613 6057 25 laid lay VBD 19613 6057 26 the the DT 19613 6057 27 basis basis NN 19613 6057 28 of of IN 19613 6057 29 that that DT 19613 6057 30 conception conception NN 19613 6057 31 of of IN 19613 6057 32 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6057 33 in in IN 19613 6057 34 accordance accordance NN 19613 6057 35 with with IN 19613 6057 36 which which WDT 19613 6057 37 the the DT 19613 6057 38 unity unity NN 19613 6057 39 of of IN 19613 6057 40 the the DT 19613 6057 41 person person NN 19613 6057 42 is be VBZ 19613 6057 43 nothing nothing NN 19613 6057 44 more more JJR 19613 6057 45 than than IN 19613 6057 46 an an DT 19613 6057 47 assertion assertion NN 19613 6057 48 . . . 19613 6058 1 The the DT 19613 6058 2 " " `` 19613 6058 3 deus deu VBZ 19613 6058 4 factus factus NN 19613 6058 5 homo homo NN 19613 6058 6 " " '' 19613 6058 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6058 8 " " `` 19613 6058 9 verbum verbum NN 19613 6058 10 caro caro NNP 19613 6058 11 factus factus NN 19613 6058 12 " " '' 19613 6058 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6058 14 presents present VBZ 19613 6058 15 quite quite RB 19613 6058 16 insuperable insuperable JJ 19613 6058 17 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 6058 18 , , , 19613 6058 19 as as RB 19613 6058 20 soon soon RB 19613 6058 21 as as IN 19613 6058 22 " " `` 19613 6058 23 theology theology NN 19613 6058 24 " " '' 19613 6058 25 can can MD 19613 6058 26 no no RB 19613 6058 27 longer longer RB 19613 6058 28 be be VB 19613 6058 29 banished banish VBN 19613 6058 30 . . . 19613 6059 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6059 2 smoothed smooth VBD 19613 6059 3 over over IN 19613 6059 4 these these DT 19613 6059 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 6059 6 by by IN 19613 6059 7 juristic juristic JJ 19613 6059 8 distinctions distinction NNS 19613 6059 9 , , , 19613 6059 10 for for IN 19613 6059 11 all all PDT 19613 6059 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6059 13 elucidations elucidation NNS 19613 6059 14 of of IN 19613 6059 15 " " `` 19613 6059 16 substance substance NN 19613 6059 17 " " '' 19613 6059 18 and and CC 19613 6059 19 " " `` 19613 6059 20 person person NN 19613 6059 21 " " '' 19613 6059 22 are be VBP 19613 6059 23 of of IN 19613 6059 24 this this DT 19613 6059 25 nature nature NN 19613 6059 26 . . . 19613 6060 1 A a DT 19613 6060 2 somewhat somewhat RB 19613 6060 3 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 19613 6060 4 result result NN 19613 6060 5 of of IN 19613 6060 6 the the DT 19613 6060 7 defence defence NN 19613 6060 8 of of IN 19613 6060 9 the the DT 19613 6060 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6060 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6060 12 in in IN 19613 6060 13 the the DT 19613 6060 14 struggle struggle NN 19613 6060 15 against against IN 19613 6060 16 the the DT 19613 6060 17 " " `` 19613 6060 18 Patripassians Patripassians NNPS 19613 6060 19 " " '' 19613 6060 20 was be VBD 19613 6060 21 the the DT 19613 6060 22 increased increased JJ 19613 6060 23 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 6060 24 that that WDT 19613 6060 25 now now RB 19613 6060 26 began begin VBD 19613 6060 27 to to TO 19613 6060 28 be be VB 19613 6060 29 laid lay VBN 19613 6060 30 on on IN 19613 6060 31 the the DT 19613 6060 32 integrity integrity NN 19613 6060 33 and and CC 19613 6060 34 independence independence NN 19613 6060 35 of of IN 19613 6060 36 the the DT 19613 6060 37 human human JJ 19613 6060 38 nature nature NN 19613 6060 39 in in IN 19613 6060 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6060 41 . . . 19613 6061 1 If if IN 19613 6061 2 the the DT 19613 6061 3 only only JJ 19613 6061 4 essential essential JJ 19613 6061 5 result result NN 19613 6061 6 of of IN 19613 6061 7 the the DT 19613 6061 8 struggle struggle NN 19613 6061 9 with with IN 19613 6061 10 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 6061 11 was be VBD 19613 6061 12 to to TO 19613 6061 13 assert assert VB 19613 6061 14 the the DT 19613 6061 15 substantial substantial JJ 19613 6061 16 reality reality NN 19613 6061 17 of of IN 19613 6061 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6061 19 's 's POS 19613 6061 20 body body NN 19613 6061 21 , , , 19613 6061 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6061 23 was be VBD 19613 6061 24 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6061 25 who who WP 19613 6061 26 distinguished distinguish VBD 19613 6061 27 what what WP 19613 6061 28 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6061 29 did do VBD 19613 6061 30 as as IN 19613 6061 31 man man NN 19613 6061 32 from from IN 19613 6061 33 what what WP 19613 6061 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6061 35 did do VBD 19613 6061 36 as as IN 19613 6061 37 God God NNP 19613 6061 38 in in IN 19613 6061 39 order order NN 19613 6061 40 to to TO 19613 6061 41 prove prove VB 19613 6061 42 that that IN 19613 6061 43 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6061 44 was be VBD 19613 6061 45 not not RB 19613 6061 46 a a DT 19613 6061 47 _ _ NNP 19613 6061 48 tertium tertium NN 19613 6061 49 quid quid NN 19613 6061 50 _ _ NNP 19613 6061 51 . . . 19613 6062 1 The the DT 19613 6062 2 discriminating discriminating JJ 19613 6062 3 intellect intellect NN 19613 6062 4 which which WDT 19613 6062 5 was be VBD 19613 6062 6 forced force VBN 19613 6062 7 to to TO 19613 6062 8 receive receive VB 19613 6062 9 a a DT 19613 6062 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6062 11 as as IN 19613 6062 12 a a DT 19613 6062 13 problem problem NN 19613 6062 14 could could MD 19613 6062 15 not not RB 19613 6062 16 proceed proceed VB 19613 6062 17 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 6062 18 . . . 19613 6063 1 But but CC 19613 6063 2 , , , 19613 6063 3 even even RB 19613 6063 4 before before IN 19613 6063 5 the the DT 19613 6063 6 struggle struggle NN 19613 6063 7 with with IN 19613 6063 8 Modalism Modalism NNP 19613 6063 9 , , , 19613 6063 10 elements element NNS 19613 6063 11 were be VBD 19613 6063 12 present present JJ 19613 6063 13 which which WDT 19613 6063 14 repressed repress VBD 19613 6063 15 the the DT 19613 6063 16 naïve naïve JJ 19613 6063 17 confidence confidence NN 19613 6063 18 of of IN 19613 6063 19 the the DT 19613 6063 20 utterances utterance NNS 19613 6063 21 about about IN 19613 6063 22 the the DT 19613 6063 23 God God NNP 19613 6063 24 - - HYPH 19613 6063 25 man man NNP 19613 6063 26 . . . 19613 6064 1 If if IN 19613 6064 2 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6064 3 judge judge VBP 19613 6064 4 rightly rightly RB 19613 6064 5 , , , 19613 6064 6 there there EX 19613 6064 7 were be VBD 19613 6064 8 two two CD 19613 6064 9 features feature NNS 19613 6064 10 in in IN 19613 6064 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6064 12 both both DT 19613 6064 13 of of IN 19613 6064 14 which which WDT 19613 6064 15 resulted result VBD 19613 6064 16 in in IN 19613 6064 17 a a DT 19613 6064 18 splitting splitting NN 19613 6064 19 up up RP 19613 6064 20 of of IN 19613 6064 21 the the DT 19613 6064 22 conception conception NN 19613 6064 23 of of IN 19613 6064 24 the the DT 19613 6064 25 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6064 26 unity unity NN 19613 6064 27 of of IN 19613 6064 28 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6064 29 's 's POS 19613 6064 30 person person NN 19613 6064 31 . . . 19613 6065 1 The the DT 19613 6065 2 first first JJ 19613 6065 3 was be VBD 19613 6065 4 the the DT 19613 6065 5 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 6065 6 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 6065 7 of of IN 19613 6065 8 the the DT 19613 6065 9 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6065 10 humanity humanity NN 19613 6065 11 of of IN 19613 6065 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6065 13 , , , 19613 6065 14 the the DT 19613 6065 15 second second JJ 19613 6065 16 was be VBD 19613 6065 17 found find VBN 19613 6065 18 in in IN 19613 6065 19 certain certain JJ 19613 6065 20 Old Old NNP 19613 6065 21 and and CC 19613 6065 22 New New NNP 19613 6065 23 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6065 24 texts text NNS 19613 6065 25 and and CC 19613 6065 26 the the DT 19613 6065 27 tradition tradition NN 19613 6065 28 connected connect VBN 19613 6065 29 with with IN 19613 6065 30 these these DT 19613 6065 31 . . . 19613 6066 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6066 2 603 603 CD 19613 6066 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6066 4 With with IN 19613 6066 5 regard regard NN 19613 6066 6 to to IN 19613 6066 7 the the DT 19613 6066 8 first first JJ 19613 6066 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6066 10 may may MD 19613 6066 11 point point VB 19613 6066 12 out out RP 19613 6066 13 that that IN 19613 6066 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6066 15 indeed indeed RB 19613 6066 16 regarded regard VBD 19613 6066 17 the the DT 19613 6066 18 union union NN 19613 6066 19 of of IN 19613 6066 20 the the DT 19613 6066 21 human human JJ 19613 6066 22 and and CC 19613 6066 23 divine divine JJ 19613 6066 24 as as IN 19613 6066 25 possible possible JJ 19613 6066 26 only only RB 19613 6066 27 because because IN 19613 6066 28 man man NN 19613 6066 29 , , , 19613 6066 30 fashioned fashion VBN 19613 6066 31 from from IN 19613 6066 32 the the DT 19613 6066 33 beginning beginning NN 19613 6066 34 by by RB 19613 6066 35 and and CC 19613 6066 36 after after IN 19613 6066 37 the the DT 19613 6066 38 pattern pattern NN 19613 6066 39 of of IN 19613 6066 40 the the DT 19613 6066 41 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6066 42 , , , 19613 6066 43 was be VBD 19613 6066 44 an an DT 19613 6066 45 image image NN 19613 6066 46 of of IN 19613 6066 47 the the DT 19613 6066 48 latter latter JJ 19613 6066 49 and and CC 19613 6066 50 destined destine VBN 19613 6066 51 for for IN 19613 6066 52 union union NN 19613 6066 53 with with IN 19613 6066 54 God God NNP 19613 6066 55 . . . 19613 6067 1 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6067 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6067 3 is be VBZ 19613 6067 4 the the DT 19613 6067 5 realisation realisation NN 19613 6067 6 of of IN 19613 6067 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6067 8 possession possession NN 19613 6067 9 of of IN 19613 6067 10 God God NNP 19613 6067 11 's 's POS 19613 6067 12 image;[604 image;[604 NNPS 19613 6067 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6067 14 but but CC 19613 6067 15 this this DT 19613 6067 16 thought thought NN 19613 6067 17 , , , 19613 6067 18 if if IN 19613 6067 19 no no DT 19613 6067 20 further further RB 19613 6067 21 developed develop VBN 19613 6067 22 , , , 19613 6067 23 may may MD 19613 6067 24 be be VB 19613 6067 25 still still RB 19613 6067 26 united united JJ 19613 6067 27 with with IN 19613 6067 28 the the DT 19613 6067 29 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6067 30 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6067 31 in in IN 19613 6067 32 such such PDT 19613 6067 33 a a DT 19613 6067 34 way way NN 19613 6067 35 that that IN 19613 6067 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6067 37 does do VBZ 19613 6067 38 not not RB 19613 6067 39 interfere interfere VB 19613 6067 40 with with IN 19613 6067 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6067 42 , , , 19613 6067 43 but but CC 19613 6067 44 serves serve VBZ 19613 6067 45 to to TO 19613 6067 46 confirm confirm VB 19613 6067 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6067 48 . . . 19613 6068 1 The the DT 19613 6068 2 case case NN 19613 6068 3 becomes become VBZ 19613 6068 4 different different JJ 19613 6068 5 when when WRB 19613 6068 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6068 7 is be VBZ 19613 6068 8 not not RB 19613 6068 9 only only RB 19613 6068 10 shown show VBN 19613 6068 11 that that IN 19613 6068 12 the the DT 19613 6068 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6068 14 was be VBD 19613 6068 15 always always RB 19613 6068 16 at at IN 19613 6068 17 work work NN 19613 6068 18 in in IN 19613 6068 19 the the DT 19613 6068 20 human human JJ 19613 6068 21 race race NN 19613 6068 22 , , , 19613 6068 23 but but CC 19613 6068 24 that that DT 19613 6068 25 humanity humanity NN 19613 6068 26 was be VBD 19613 6068 27 gradually gradually RB 19613 6068 28 more more RBR 19613 6068 29 and and CC 19613 6068 30 more more RBR 19613 6068 31 accustomed accustomed JJ 19613 6068 32 by by IN 19613 6068 33 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6068 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6068 35 in in IN 19613 6068 36 the the DT 19613 6068 37 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 6068 38 and and CC 19613 6068 39 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6068 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6068 41 to to IN 19613 6068 42 communion communion NN 19613 6068 43 with with IN 19613 6068 44 God,[605 God,[605 NNP 19613 6068 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6068 46 till till IN 19613 6068 47 at at IN 19613 6068 48 last last JJ 19613 6068 49 the the DT 19613 6068 50 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6068 51 man man NN 19613 6068 52 appeared appear VBD 19613 6068 53 in in IN 19613 6068 54 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6068 55 . . . 19613 6069 1 For for IN 19613 6069 2 in in IN 19613 6069 3 this this DT 19613 6069 4 view view NN 19613 6069 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6069 6 might may MD 19613 6069 7 appear appear VB 19613 6069 8 as as IN 19613 6069 9 if if IN 19613 6069 10 the the DT 19613 6069 11 really really RB 19613 6069 12 essential essential JJ 19613 6069 13 element element NN 19613 6069 14 in in IN 19613 6069 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6069 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6069 17 were be VBD 19613 6069 18 not not RB 19613 6069 19 the the DT 19613 6069 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6069 21 , , , 19613 6069 22 who who WP 19613 6069 23 has have VBZ 19613 6069 24 become become VBN 19613 6069 25 the the DT 19613 6069 26 new new JJ 19613 6069 27 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6069 28 , , , 19613 6069 29 but but CC 19613 6069 30 the the DT 19613 6069 31 new new JJ 19613 6069 32 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6069 33 , , , 19613 6069 34 who who WP 19613 6069 35 possesses possess VBZ 19613 6069 36 the the DT 19613 6069 37 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6069 38 . . . 19613 6070 1 That that IN 19613 6070 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6070 3 , , , 19613 6070 4 in in IN 19613 6070 5 explaining explain VBG 19613 6070 6 the the DT 19613 6070 7 life life NN 19613 6070 8 of of IN 19613 6070 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6070 10 as as IN 19613 6070 11 that that DT 19613 6070 12 of of IN 19613 6070 13 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6070 14 according accord VBG 19613 6070 15 to to IN 19613 6070 16 the the DT 19613 6070 17 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6070 18 theory theory NN 19613 6070 19 , , , 19613 6070 20 here here RB 19613 6070 21 and and CC 19613 6070 22 there there EX 19613 6070 23 expresses express VBZ 19613 6070 24 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6070 25 as as IN 19613 6070 26 if if IN 19613 6070 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6070 28 were be VBD 19613 6070 29 speaking speak VBG 19613 6070 30 of of IN 19613 6070 31 the the DT 19613 6070 32 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6070 33 man man NN 19613 6070 34 , , , 19613 6070 35 is be VBZ 19613 6070 36 undeniable undeniable JJ 19613 6070 37 : : : 19613 6070 38 If if IN 19613 6070 39 the the DT 19613 6070 40 acts act NNS 19613 6070 41 of of IN 19613 6070 42 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6070 43 are be VBP 19613 6070 44 really really RB 19613 6070 45 to to TO 19613 6070 46 be be VB 19613 6070 47 what what WP 19613 6070 48 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6070 49 seem seem VBP 19613 6070 50 , , , 19613 6070 51 the the DT 19613 6070 52 man man NN 19613 6070 53 concerned concern VBN 19613 6070 54 in in IN 19613 6070 55 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6070 56 must must MD 19613 6070 57 be be VB 19613 6070 58 placed place VBN 19613 6070 59 in in IN 19613 6070 60 the the DT 19613 6070 61 foreground foreground NN 19613 6070 62 . . . 19613 6071 1 But but CC 19613 6071 2 how how WRB 19613 6071 3 little little JJ 19613 6071 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6071 5 thought think VBD 19613 6071 6 of of IN 19613 6071 7 simply simply RB 19613 6071 8 identifying identify VBG 19613 6071 9 the the DT 19613 6071 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6071 11 with with IN 19613 6071 12 the the DT 19613 6071 13 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6071 14 man man NN 19613 6071 15 is be VBZ 19613 6071 16 shown show VBN 19613 6071 17 by by IN 19613 6071 18 the the DT 19613 6071 19 passage passage NN 19613 6071 20 in in IN 19613 6071 21 III III NNP 19613 6071 22 . . . 19613 6072 1 19 19 CD 19613 6072 2 . . . 19613 6073 1 3 3 LS 19613 6073 2 where where WRB 19613 6073 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6073 4 writes write VBZ 19613 6073 5 : : : 19613 6073 6 " " `` 19613 6073 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6073 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6073 9 : : : 19613 6073 10 hôsper hôsper NNP 19613 6073 11 gar gar NNP 19613 6073 12 ên ên NNP 19613 6073 13 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 6073 14 hina hina NNP 19613 6073 15 peirasthê peirasthê NNP 19613 6073 16 , , , 19613 6073 17 houtô houtô NNP 19613 6073 18 kai kai NNP 19613 6073 19 logos logos NNP 19613 6073 20 hina hina NNP 19613 6073 21 doxasthê doxasthê NNP 19613 6073 22 . . . 19613 6074 1 êsychazontos êsychazontos NNP 19613 6074 2 men man NNS 19613 6074 3 tou tou NNP 19613 6074 4 logou logou NNP 19613 6074 5 en en NNP 19613 6074 6 tô tô NNP 19613 6074 7 peirazesthai peirazesthai NNP 19613 6074 8 kai kai NNP 19613 6074 9 staurousthai staurousthai NNP 19613 6074 10 kai kai NNP 19613 6074 11 apothnêskein apothnêskein NNP 19613 6074 12 sugginomenou sugginomenou NNP 19613 6074 13 de de FW 19613 6074 14 tô tô NNP 19613 6074 15 anthrôpô anthrôpô NNP 19613 6074 16 en en NNP 19613 6074 17 tô tô NNP 19613 6074 18 nikan nikan NNP 19613 6074 19 kai kai NNP 19613 6074 20 hypomenein hypomenein NNP 19613 6074 21 kai kai NNP 19613 6074 22 chrêsteuesthai chrêsteuesthai NNP 19613 6074 23 kai kai NNP 19613 6074 24 anistasthai anistasthai NNP 19613 6074 25 kai kai NNP 19613 6074 26 analambanesthai analambanesthai NNP 19613 6074 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6074 28 " " `` 19613 6074 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6074 30 " " `` 19613 6074 31 For for IN 19613 6074 32 as as IN 19613 6074 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6074 34 was be VBD 19613 6074 35 man man NN 19613 6074 36 that that IN 19613 6074 37 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6074 38 might may MD 19613 6074 39 be be VB 19613 6074 40 tempted tempt VBN 19613 6074 41 , , , 19613 6074 42 so so RB 19613 6074 43 also also RB 19613 6074 44 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6074 45 was be VBD 19613 6074 46 the the DT 19613 6074 47 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6074 48 that that WDT 19613 6074 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6074 50 might may MD 19613 6074 51 be be VB 19613 6074 52 glorified glorify VBN 19613 6074 53 . . . 19613 6075 1 The the DT 19613 6075 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6075 3 remained remain VBD 19613 6075 4 quiescent quiescent JJ 19613 6075 5 during during IN 19613 6075 6 the the DT 19613 6075 7 process process NN 19613 6075 8 of of IN 19613 6075 9 temptation temptation NN 19613 6075 10 , , , 19613 6075 11 crucifixion crucifixion NN 19613 6075 12 and and CC 19613 6075 13 death death NN 19613 6075 14 , , , 19613 6075 15 but but CC 19613 6075 16 aided aid VBD 19613 6075 17 the the DT 19613 6075 18 human human JJ 19613 6075 19 nature nature NN 19613 6075 20 when when WRB 19613 6075 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6075 22 conquered conquer VBD 19613 6075 23 , , , 19613 6075 24 and and CC 19613 6075 25 endured endure VBD 19613 6075 26 , , , 19613 6075 27 and and CC 19613 6075 28 performed perform VBD 19613 6075 29 deeds deed NNS 19613 6075 30 of of IN 19613 6075 31 kindness kindness NN 19613 6075 32 , , , 19613 6075 33 and and CC 19613 6075 34 rose rise VBD 19613 6075 35 again again RB 19613 6075 36 from from IN 19613 6075 37 the the DT 19613 6075 38 dead dead NN 19613 6075 39 , , , 19613 6075 40 and and CC 19613 6075 41 was be VBD 19613 6075 42 received receive VBN 19613 6075 43 up up RP 19613 6075 44 into into IN 19613 6075 45 heaven heaven NNP 19613 6075 46 " " '' 19613 6075 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6075 48 . . . 19613 6076 1 From from IN 19613 6076 2 these these DT 19613 6076 3 words word NNS 19613 6076 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6076 5 is be VBZ 19613 6076 6 plain plain JJ 19613 6076 7 that that IN 19613 6076 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6076 9 preferred prefer VBD 19613 6076 10 to to TO 19613 6076 11 assume assume VB 19613 6076 12 that that IN 19613 6076 13 the the DT 19613 6076 14 divine divine JJ 19613 6076 15 and and CC 19613 6076 16 human human JJ 19613 6076 17 natures nature NNS 19613 6076 18 existed exist VBD 19613 6076 19 side side NN 19613 6076 20 by by IN 19613 6076 21 side side NN 19613 6076 22 , , , 19613 6076 23 and and CC 19613 6076 24 consequently consequently RB 19613 6076 25 to to TO 19613 6076 26 split split VB 19613 6076 27 up up RP 19613 6076 28 the the DT 19613 6076 29 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6076 30 unity unity NN 19613 6076 31 , , , 19613 6076 32 rather rather RB 19613 6076 33 than than IN 19613 6076 34 teach teach VB 19613 6076 35 a a DT 19613 6076 36 mere mere JJ 19613 6076 37 ideal ideal JJ 19613 6076 38 manhood manhood NN 19613 6076 39 which which WDT 19613 6076 40 would would MD 19613 6076 41 be be VB 19613 6076 42 at at IN 19613 6076 43 the the DT 19613 6076 44 same same JJ 19613 6076 45 time time NN 19613 6076 46 a a DT 19613 6076 47 divine divine JJ 19613 6076 48 manhood manhood NN 19613 6076 49 . . . 19613 6077 1 The the DT 19613 6077 2 " " `` 19613 6077 3 discrete discrete JJ 19613 6077 4 agere agere NN 19613 6077 5 " " '' 19613 6077 6 of of IN 19613 6077 7 the the DT 19613 6077 8 two two CD 19613 6077 9 natures nature NNS 19613 6077 10 proves prove VBZ 19613 6077 11 that that IN 19613 6077 12 to to IN 19613 6077 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6077 14 the the DT 19613 6077 15 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6077 16 manhood manhood NN 19613 6077 17 of of IN 19613 6077 18 the the DT 19613 6077 19 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 6077 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6077 21 was be VBD 19613 6077 22 merely merely RB 19613 6077 23 an an DT 19613 6077 24 incidental incidental JJ 19613 6077 25 quality quality NN 19613 6077 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6077 27 possessed possess VBD 19613 6077 28 . . . 19613 6078 1 In in IN 19613 6078 2 reality reality NN 19613 6078 3 the the DT 19613 6078 4 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6078 5 is be VBZ 19613 6078 6 the the DT 19613 6078 7 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6078 8 man man NN 19613 6078 9 in in RB 19613 6078 10 so so RB 19613 6078 11 far far RB 19613 6078 12 as as IN 19613 6078 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6078 14 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6078 15 creates create VBZ 19613 6078 16 the the DT 19613 6078 17 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6078 18 man man NN 19613 6078 19 and and CC 19613 6078 20 renders render VBZ 19613 6078 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6078 22 possible possible JJ 19613 6078 23 , , , 19613 6078 24 or or CC 19613 6078 25 the the DT 19613 6078 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6078 27 always always RB 19613 6078 28 exists exist VBZ 19613 6078 29 behind behind IN 19613 6078 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6078 31 the the DT 19613 6078 32 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6078 33 man man NN 19613 6078 34 . . . 19613 6079 1 But but CC 19613 6079 2 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 6079 3 this this DT 19613 6079 4 very very JJ 19613 6079 5 way way NN 19613 6079 6 of of IN 19613 6079 7 viewing view VBG 19613 6079 8 the the DT 19613 6079 9 humanity humanity NN 19613 6079 10 in in IN 19613 6079 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6079 12 already already RB 19613 6079 13 compelled compel VBD 19613 6079 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6079 15 to to TO 19613 6079 16 limit limit VB 19613 6079 17 the the DT 19613 6079 18 " " `` 19613 6079 19 deus deus NNP 19613 6079 20 crucifixus crucifixus NNP 19613 6079 21 " " '' 19613 6079 22 and and CC 19613 6079 23 to to TO 19613 6079 24 lay lay VB 19613 6079 25 the the DT 19613 6079 26 foundation foundation NN 19613 6079 27 for for IN 19613 6079 28 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6079 29 's 's POS 19613 6079 30 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6079 31 . . . 19613 6080 1 With with IN 19613 6080 2 regard regard NN 19613 6080 3 to to IN 19613 6080 4 the the DT 19613 6080 5 second second JJ 19613 6080 6 point point NN 19613 6080 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6080 8 may may MD 19613 6080 9 remark remark VB 19613 6080 10 that that IN 19613 6080 11 there there EX 19613 6080 12 were be VBD 19613 6080 13 not not RB 19613 6080 14 a a DT 19613 6080 15 few few JJ 19613 6080 16 passages passage NNS 19613 6080 17 in in IN 19613 6080 18 both both DT 19613 6080 19 Testaments testament NNS 19613 6080 20 where where WRB 19613 6080 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6080 22 appeared appear VBD 19613 6080 23 as as IN 19613 6080 24 the the DT 19613 6080 25 man man NN 19613 6080 26 chosen choose VBN 19613 6080 27 by by IN 19613 6080 28 God God NNP 19613 6080 29 and and CC 19613 6080 30 anointed anoint VBN 19613 6080 31 with with IN 19613 6080 32 the the DT 19613 6080 33 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6080 34 . . . 19613 6081 1 These these DT 19613 6081 2 as as RB 19613 6081 3 well well RB 19613 6081 4 as as IN 19613 6081 5 the the DT 19613 6081 6 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 6081 7 language language NN 19613 6081 8 of of IN 19613 6081 9 the the DT 19613 6081 10 Church Church NNP 19613 6081 11 were be VBD 19613 6081 12 the the DT 19613 6081 13 greatest great JJS 19613 6081 14 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 6081 15 in in IN 19613 6081 16 the the DT 19613 6081 17 way way NN 19613 6081 18 of of IN 19613 6081 19 the the DT 19613 6081 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6081 21 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6081 22 . . . 19613 6082 1 Of of IN 19613 6082 2 what what WDT 19613 6082 3 importance importance NN 19613 6082 4 is be VBZ 19613 6082 5 an an DT 19613 6082 6 anointing anointing NN 19613 6082 7 with with IN 19613 6082 8 the the DT 19613 6082 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6082 10 to to IN 19613 6082 11 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6082 12 who who WP 19613 6082 13 is be VBZ 19613 6082 14 God God NNP 19613 6082 15 ? ? . 19613 6083 1 What what WP 19613 6083 2 is be VBZ 19613 6083 3 the the DT 19613 6083 4 meaning meaning NN 19613 6083 5 of of IN 19613 6083 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6083 7 being be VBG 19613 6083 8 born bear VBN 19613 6083 9 by by IN 19613 6083 10 the the DT 19613 6083 11 power power NN 19613 6083 12 of of IN 19613 6083 13 the the DT 19613 6083 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6083 15 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 6083 16 ? ? . 19613 6084 1 Is be VBZ 19613 6084 2 this this DT 19613 6084 3 formula formula NN 19613 6084 4 compatible compatible JJ 19613 6084 5 with with IN 19613 6084 6 the the DT 19613 6084 7 other other JJ 19613 6084 8 , , , 19613 6084 9 that that IN 19613 6084 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6084 11 as as IN 19613 6084 12 the the DT 19613 6084 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6084 14 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6084 15 assumed assume VBD 19613 6084 16 flesh flesh NN 19613 6084 17 from from IN 19613 6084 18 the the DT 19613 6084 19 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 6084 20 etc etc FW 19613 6084 21 . . . 19613 6084 22 ? ? . 19613 6085 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6085 2 no no RB 19613 6085 3 doubt doubt RB 19613 6085 4 felt feel VBD 19613 6085 5 these these DT 19613 6085 6 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 6085 7 . . . 19613 6086 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6086 2 avoided avoid VBD 19613 6086 3 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6086 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6086 5 III iii CD 19613 6086 6 . . . 19613 6087 1 9 9 CD 19613 6087 2 . . . 19613 6088 1 3 3 LS 19613 6088 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6088 3 by by IN 19613 6088 4 referring refer VBG 19613 6088 5 the the DT 19613 6088 6 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 6088 7 of of IN 19613 6088 8 the the DT 19613 6088 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6088 10 at at IN 19613 6088 11 baptism baptism NN 19613 6088 12 merely merely RB 19613 6088 13 to to IN 19613 6088 14 the the DT 19613 6088 15 _ _ NNP 19613 6088 16 man man NN 19613 6088 17 _ _ NNP 19613 6088 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6088 19 , , , 19613 6088 20 and and CC 19613 6088 21 thus thus RB 19613 6088 22 gave give VBD 19613 6088 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6088 24 own own JJ 19613 6088 25 approval approval NN 19613 6088 26 to to IN 19613 6088 27 that that DT 19613 6088 28 separation separation NN 19613 6088 29 which which WDT 19613 6088 30 appeared appear VBD 19613 6088 31 to to IN 19613 6088 32 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6088 33 so so RB 19613 6088 34 reprehensible reprehensible JJ 19613 6088 35 in in IN 19613 6088 36 the the DT 19613 6088 37 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6088 38 . . . 19613 6089 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6089 2 606 606 CD 19613 6089 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6089 4 This this DT 19613 6089 5 separation separation NN 19613 6089 6 indeed indeed RB 19613 6089 7 rescued rescue VBN 19613 6089 8 to to IN 19613 6089 9 future future JJ 19613 6089 10 ages age NNS 19613 6089 11 the the DT 19613 6089 12 minimum minimum NN 19613 6089 13 of of IN 19613 6089 14 humanity humanity NN 19613 6089 15 that that WDT 19613 6089 16 was be VBD 19613 6089 17 to to TO 19613 6089 18 be be VB 19613 6089 19 retained retain VBN 19613 6089 20 in in IN 19613 6089 21 the the DT 19613 6089 22 person person NN 19613 6089 23 of of IN 19613 6089 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6089 25 , , , 19613 6089 26 but but CC 19613 6089 27 at at IN 19613 6089 28 the the DT 19613 6089 29 same same JJ 19613 6089 30 time time NN 19613 6089 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6089 32 laid lay VBD 19613 6089 33 the the DT 19613 6089 34 foundation foundation NN 19613 6089 35 of of IN 19613 6089 36 those those DT 19613 6089 37 differentiating differentiate VBG 19613 6089 38 speculations speculation NNS 19613 6089 39 , , , 19613 6089 40 which which WDT 19613 6089 41 in in IN 19613 6089 42 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 6089 43 times time NNS 19613 6089 44 became become VBD 19613 6089 45 the the DT 19613 6089 46 chief chief JJ 19613 6089 47 art art NN 19613 6089 48 and and CC 19613 6089 49 subject subject NN 19613 6089 50 of of IN 19613 6089 51 dispute dispute NN 19613 6089 52 among among IN 19613 6089 53 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6089 54 . . . 19613 6090 1 The the DT 19613 6090 2 fact fact NN 19613 6090 3 is be VBZ 19613 6090 4 that that IN 19613 6090 5 one one PRP 19613 6090 6 can can MD 19613 6090 7 not not RB 19613 6090 8 think think VB 19613 6090 9 in in IN 19613 6090 10 realistic realistic JJ 19613 6090 11 fashion fashion NN 19613 6090 12 of of IN 19613 6090 13 the the DT 19613 6090 14 " " `` 19613 6090 15 deus deus NNP 19613 6090 16 homo homo NN 19613 6090 17 factus factus NN 19613 6090 18 " " '' 19613 6090 19 without without IN 19613 6090 20 thinking think VBG 19613 6090 21 oneself oneself PRP 19613 6090 22 out out IN 19613 6090 23 of of IN 19613 6090 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6090 25 . . . 19613 6091 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6091 2 is be VBZ 19613 6091 3 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 6091 4 instructive instructive JJ 19613 6091 5 to to TO 19613 6091 6 find find VB 19613 6091 7 that that DT 19613 6091 8 , , , 19613 6091 9 in in IN 19613 6091 10 some some DT 19613 6091 11 passages passage NNS 19613 6091 12 , , , 19613 6091 13 even even RB 19613 6091 14 a a DT 19613 6091 15 man man NN 19613 6091 16 like like IN 19613 6091 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6091 18 was be VBD 19613 6091 19 obliged oblige VBN 19613 6091 20 to to TO 19613 6091 21 advance advance VB 19613 6091 22 from from IN 19613 6091 23 the the DT 19613 6091 24 creed creed NN 19613 6091 25 of of IN 19613 6091 26 the the DT 19613 6091 27 one one CD 19613 6091 28 God God NNP 19613 6091 29 - - HYPH 19613 6091 30 man man NN 19613 6091 31 to to IN 19613 6091 32 the the DT 19613 6091 33 assumption assumption NN 19613 6091 34 of of IN 19613 6091 35 two two CD 19613 6091 36 independent independent JJ 19613 6091 37 existences existence NNS 19613 6091 38 in in IN 19613 6091 39 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6091 40 , , , 19613 6091 41 an an DT 19613 6091 42 assumption assumption NN 19613 6091 43 which which WDT 19613 6091 44 in in IN 19613 6091 45 the the DT 19613 6091 46 earlier early JJR 19613 6091 47 period period NN 19613 6091 48 has have VBZ 19613 6091 49 only only RB 19613 6091 50 " " `` 19613 6091 51 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6091 52 " " '' 19613 6091 53 testimony testimony NN 19613 6091 54 in in IN 19613 6091 55 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6091 56 favour favour NN 19613 6091 57 . . . 19613 6092 1 Before before IN 19613 6092 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6092 3 ' ' POS 19613 6092 4 day day NN 19613 6092 5 , , , 19613 6092 6 in in IN 19613 6092 7 fact fact NN 19613 6092 8 , , , 19613 6092 9 none none NN 19613 6092 10 but but CC 19613 6092 11 these these DT 19613 6092 12 earliest early JJS 19613 6092 13 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6092 14 taught teach VBD 19613 6092 15 that that IN 19613 6092 16 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6092 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6092 18 had have VBD 19613 6092 19 two two CD 19613 6092 20 natures nature NNS 19613 6092 21 , , , 19613 6092 22 and and CC 19613 6092 23 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 6092 24 to to IN 19613 6092 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6092 26 particular particular JJ 19613 6092 27 actions action NNS 19613 6092 28 and and CC 19613 6092 29 experiences experience NNS 19613 6092 30 . . . 19613 6093 1 The the DT 19613 6093 2 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6093 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 6093 4 of of IN 19613 6093 5 the the DT 19613 6093 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6093 7 _ _ NNP 19613 6093 8 patibilis patibilis NNP 19613 6093 9 _ _ NNP 19613 6093 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6093 11 " " `` 19613 6093 12 capable capable JJ 19613 6093 13 of of IN 19613 6093 14 suffering suffer VBG 19613 6093 15 " " '' 19613 6093 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6093 17 and and CC 19613 6093 18 the the DT 19613 6093 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6093 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6093 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6093 22 : : : 19613 6093 23 apathês apathês NN 19613 6093 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6093 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6093 26 " " `` 19613 6093 27 impassible impassible JJ 19613 6093 28 " " '' 19613 6093 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6093 30 is be VBZ 19613 6093 31 essentially essentially RB 19613 6093 32 identical identical JJ 19613 6093 33 with with IN 19613 6093 34 the the DT 19613 6093 35 view view NN 19613 6093 36 set set VBN 19613 6093 37 forth forth RP 19613 6093 38 by by IN 19613 6093 39 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 6093 40 adv adv NN 19613 6093 41 . . . 19613 6094 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6094 2 . . . 19613 6094 3 , , , 19613 6094 4 and and CC 19613 6094 5 this this DT 19613 6094 6 proves prove VBZ 19613 6094 7 that that IN 19613 6094 8 the the DT 19613 6094 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6094 10 of of IN 19613 6094 11 the the DT 19613 6094 12 two two CD 19613 6094 13 natures nature NNS 19613 6094 14 is be VBZ 19613 6094 15 simply simply RB 19613 6094 16 nothing nothing NN 19613 6094 17 else else RB 19613 6094 18 than than IN 19613 6094 19 the the DT 19613 6094 20 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 6094 21 , , , 19613 6094 22 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6094 23 , , , 19613 6094 24 scientific scientific JJ 19613 6094 25 , , , 19613 6094 26 adaptation adaptation NN 19613 6094 27 of of IN 19613 6094 28 the the DT 19613 6094 29 formula formula NN 19613 6094 30 : : : 19613 6094 31 " " `` 19613 6094 32 filius filius NNP 19613 6094 33 dei dei NNP 19613 6094 34 filius filius NNP 19613 6094 35 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6094 36 factus factus NN 19613 6094 37 . . . 19613 6094 38 " " '' 19613 6095 1 No no RB 19613 6095 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 6095 3 the the DT 19613 6095 4 old old JJ 19613 6095 5 early early JJ 19613 6095 6 - - HYPH 19613 6095 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 6095 8 interest interest NN 19613 6095 9 still still RB 19613 6095 10 makes make VBZ 19613 6095 11 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6095 12 felt feel VBN 19613 6095 13 in in IN 19613 6095 14 the the DT 19613 6095 15 _ _ NNP 19613 6095 16 assertion assertion NN 19613 6095 17 _ _ NNP 19613 6095 18 of of IN 19613 6095 19 the the DT 19613 6095 20 one one CD 19613 6095 21 person person NN 19613 6095 22 . . . 19613 6096 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 6096 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6096 3 can can MD 19613 6096 4 have have VB 19613 6096 5 no no DT 19613 6096 6 historical historical JJ 19613 6096 7 understanding understanding NN 19613 6096 8 of of IN 19613 6096 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6096 10 's 's POS 19613 6096 11 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6096 12 or or CC 19613 6096 13 even even RB 19613 6096 14 of of IN 19613 6096 15 that that DT 19613 6096 16 of of IN 19613 6096 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6096 18 without without IN 19613 6096 19 taking take VBG 19613 6096 20 into into IN 19613 6096 21 account account NN 19613 6096 22 , , , 19613 6096 23 as as IN 19613 6096 24 has have VBZ 19613 6096 25 not not RB 19613 6096 26 yet yet RB 19613 6096 27 been be VBN 19613 6096 28 done do VBN 19613 6096 29 , , , 19613 6096 30 the the DT 19613 6096 31 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6096 32 distinction distinction NN 19613 6096 33 of of IN 19613 6096 34 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6096 35 and and CC 19613 6096 36 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6096 37 , , , 19613 6096 38 as as RB 19613 6096 39 well well RB 19613 6096 40 as as IN 19613 6096 41 those those DT 19613 6096 42 old old JJ 19613 6096 43 traditional traditional JJ 19613 6096 44 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6096 45 : : : 19613 6096 46 " " '' 19613 6096 47 deus deu VBZ 19613 6096 48 passus passus NNP 19613 6096 49 , , , 19613 6096 50 deus deus NNP 19613 6096 51 crucifixus crucifixus NNP 19613 6096 52 est est NNP 19613 6096 53 " " '' 19613 6096 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6096 55 " " `` 19613 6096 56 God God NNP 19613 6096 57 suffered suffer VBD 19613 6096 58 , , , 19613 6096 59 God God NNP 19613 6096 60 was be VBD 19613 6096 61 crucified crucify VBN 19613 6096 62 " " '' 19613 6096 63 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6096 64 . . . 19613 6097 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6097 2 607 607 CD 19613 6097 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6097 4 But but CC 19613 6097 5 beyond beyond IN 19613 6097 6 doubt doubt NN 19613 6097 7 the the DT 19613 6097 8 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 6097 9 conception conception NN 19613 6097 10 of of IN 19613 6097 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6097 12 in in IN 19613 6097 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6097 14 is be VBZ 19613 6097 15 the the DT 19613 6097 16 idea idea NN 19613 6097 17 that that IN 19613 6097 18 there there EX 19613 6097 19 was be VBD 19613 6097 20 the the DT 19613 6097 21 most most RBS 19613 6097 22 complete complete JJ 19613 6097 23 unity unity NN 19613 6097 24 between between IN 19613 6097 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6097 26 divine divine JJ 19613 6097 27 and and CC 19613 6097 28 human human JJ 19613 6097 29 natures nature NNS 19613 6097 30 ; ; : 19613 6097 31 for for IN 19613 6097 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6097 33 is be VBZ 19613 6097 34 the the DT 19613 6097 35 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6097 36 consequence consequence NN 19613 6097 37 of of IN 19613 6097 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6097 39 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6097 40 of of IN 19613 6097 41 redemption redemption NN 19613 6097 42 , , , 19613 6097 43 that that IN 19613 6097 44 " " `` 19613 6097 45 _ _ NNP 19613 6097 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6097 47 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6097 48 factus factus NN 19613 6097 49 est est NNP 19613 6097 50 , , , 19613 6097 51 quod quod NNP 19613 6097 52 sumus sumus NNP 19613 6097 53 nos nos NNP 19613 6097 54 , , , 19613 6097 55 uti uti NNP 19613 6097 56 nos nos NNP 19613 6097 57 perficeret perficeret NN 19613 6097 58 esse esse NNP 19613 6097 59 quod quod NNP 19613 6097 60 et et FW 19613 6097 61 ipse_"[608 ipse_"[608 FW 19613 6097 62 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6097 63 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6097 64 " " `` 19613 6097 65 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6097 66 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6097 67 became become VBD 19613 6097 68 what what WP 19613 6097 69 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6097 70 are be VBP 19613 6097 71 in in IN 19613 6097 72 order order NN 19613 6097 73 that that IN 19613 6097 74 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6097 75 might may MD 19613 6097 76 become become VB 19613 6097 77 what what WP 19613 6097 78 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6097 79 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6097 80 is be VBZ 19613 6097 81 " " `` 19613 6097 82 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6097 83 . . . 19613 6098 1 But but CC 19613 6098 2 , , , 19613 6098 3 in in IN 19613 6098 4 accordance accordance NN 19613 6098 5 with with IN 19613 6098 6 the the DT 19613 6098 7 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6098 8 theory theory NN 19613 6098 9 , , , 19613 6098 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6098 11 developed develop VBD 19613 6098 12 the the DT 19613 6098 13 " " `` 19613 6098 14 factus factus NN 19613 6098 15 est est NNP 19613 6098 16 quod quod NNP 19613 6098 17 sumus sumus NNP 19613 6098 18 nos nos NNP 19613 6098 19 " " '' 19613 6098 20 in in IN 19613 6098 21 such such PDT 19613 6098 22 a a DT 19613 6098 23 way way NN 19613 6098 24 that that WDT 19613 6098 25 the the DT 19613 6098 26 individual individual JJ 19613 6098 27 portions portion NNS 19613 6098 28 of of IN 19613 6098 29 the the DT 19613 6098 30 life life NN 19613 6098 31 of of IN 19613 6098 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6098 33 , , , 19613 6098 34 as as IN 19613 6098 35 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 6098 36 to to IN 19613 6098 37 what what WP 19613 6098 38 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6098 39 ought ought MD 19613 6098 40 to to TO 19613 6098 41 have have VB 19613 6098 42 done do VBN 19613 6098 43 but but CC 19613 6098 44 did do VBD 19613 6098 45 not not RB 19613 6098 46 do do VB 19613 6098 47 , , , 19613 6098 48 receive receive VB 19613 6098 49 the the DT 19613 6098 50 value value NN 19613 6098 51 of of IN 19613 6098 52 saving save VBG 19613 6098 53 acts act NNS 19613 6098 54 culminating culminate VBG 19613 6098 55 in in IN 19613 6098 56 the the DT 19613 6098 57 death death NN 19613 6098 58 on on IN 19613 6098 59 the the DT 19613 6098 60 cross cross NN 19613 6098 61 . . . 19613 6099 1 Thus thus RB 19613 6099 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6099 3 not not RB 19613 6099 4 only only RB 19613 6099 5 regards regard VBZ 19613 6099 6 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6099 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6099 8 as as IN 19613 6099 9 " " `` 19613 6099 10 salvation salvation NN 19613 6099 11 and and CC 19613 6099 12 saviour saviour JJ 19613 6099 13 and and CC 19613 6099 14 saving save VBG 19613 6099 15 " " '' 19613 6099 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6099 17 " " `` 19613 6099 18 salus salus NNP 19613 6099 19 et et NNP 19613 6099 20 salvator salvator NN 19613 6099 21 et et NNP 19613 6099 22 salutare"),[609 salutare"),[609 NNP 19613 6099 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6099 24 but but CC 19613 6099 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6099 26 also also RB 19613 6099 27 views view VBZ 19613 6099 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6099 29 whole whole JJ 19613 6099 30 life life NN 19613 6099 31 as as IN 19613 6099 32 a a DT 19613 6099 33 work work NN 19613 6099 34 of of IN 19613 6099 35 salvation salvation NN 19613 6099 36 . . . 19613 6100 1 All all DT 19613 6100 2 that that WDT 19613 6100 3 has have VBZ 19613 6100 4 taken take VBN 19613 6100 5 place place NN 19613 6100 6 between between IN 19613 6100 7 the the DT 19613 6100 8 conception conception NN 19613 6100 9 and and CC 19613 6100 10 the the DT 19613 6100 11 ascension ascension NN 19613 6100 12 is be VBZ 19613 6100 13 an an DT 19613 6100 14 inner inner JJ 19613 6100 15 necessity necessity NN 19613 6100 16 in in IN 19613 6100 17 this this DT 19613 6100 18 work work NN 19613 6100 19 of of IN 19613 6100 20 salvation salvation NN 19613 6100 21 . . . 19613 6101 1 This this DT 19613 6101 2 is be VBZ 19613 6101 3 a a DT 19613 6101 4 highly highly RB 19613 6101 5 significant significant JJ 19613 6101 6 advance advance NN 19613 6101 7 beyond beyond IN 19613 6101 8 the the DT 19613 6101 9 conception conception NN 19613 6101 10 of of IN 19613 6101 11 the the DT 19613 6101 12 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 6101 13 . . . 19613 6102 1 Whilst whilst IN 19613 6102 2 in in IN 19613 6102 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6102 4 case case NN 19613 6102 5 the the DT 19613 6102 6 history history NN 19613 6102 7 of of IN 19613 6102 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6102 9 seems seem VBZ 19613 6102 10 to to TO 19613 6102 11 derive derive VB 19613 6102 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6102 13 importance importance NN 19613 6102 14 almost almost RB 19613 6102 15 solely solely RB 19613 6102 16 from from IN 19613 6102 17 the the DT 19613 6102 18 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 6102 19 of of IN 19613 6102 20 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 6102 21 , , , 19613 6102 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6102 23 acquires acquire VBZ 19613 6102 24 in in IN 19613 6102 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6102 26 an an DT 19613 6102 27 independent independent JJ 19613 6102 28 and and CC 19613 6102 29 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 6102 30 significance significance NN 19613 6102 31 . . . 19613 6103 1 Here here RB 19613 6103 2 also also RB 19613 6103 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6103 4 recognise recognise VBP 19613 6103 5 the the DT 19613 6103 6 influence influence NN 19613 6103 7 of of IN 19613 6103 8 " " `` 19613 6103 9 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 6103 10 , , , 19613 6103 11 " " '' 19613 6103 12 nay nay NN 19613 6103 13 , , , 19613 6103 14 in in IN 19613 6103 15 many many JJ 19613 6103 16 places place NNS 19613 6103 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6103 18 uses use VBZ 19613 6103 19 the the DT 19613 6103 20 same same JJ 19613 6103 21 expressions expression NNS 19613 6103 22 as as IN 19613 6103 23 the the DT 19613 6103 24 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6103 25 , , , 19613 6103 26 when when WRB 19613 6103 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6103 28 sees see VBZ 19613 6103 29 salvation salvation NN 19613 6103 30 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 6103 31 , , , 19613 6103 32 on on IN 19613 6103 33 the the DT 19613 6103 34 one one CD 19613 6103 35 hand hand NN 19613 6103 36 , , , 19613 6103 37 in in IN 19613 6103 38 the the DT 19613 6103 39 mere mere JJ 19613 6103 40 appearance appearance NN 19613 6103 41 of of IN 19613 6103 42 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6103 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6103 44 as as IN 19613 6103 45 the the DT 19613 6103 46 second second JJ 19613 6103 47 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6103 48 , , , 19613 6103 49 and and CC 19613 6103 50 on on IN 19613 6103 51 the the DT 19613 6103 52 other other JJ 19613 6103 53 , , , 19613 6103 54 in in IN 19613 6103 55 the the DT 19613 6103 56 simple simple JJ 19613 6103 57 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 6103 58 of of IN 19613 6103 59 this this DT 19613 6103 60 appearance appearance NN 19613 6103 61 . . . 19613 6104 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6104 2 610 610 CD 19613 6104 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6104 4 But but CC 19613 6104 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6104 6 is be VBZ 19613 6104 7 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 6104 8 from from IN 19613 6104 9 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6104 10 by by IN 19613 6104 11 the the DT 19613 6104 12 fact fact NN 19613 6104 13 that that IN 19613 6104 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6104 15 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 6104 16 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 6104 17 the the DT 19613 6104 18 personal personal JJ 19613 6104 19 acts act NNS 19613 6104 20 of of IN 19613 6104 21 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6104 22 , , , 19613 6104 23 and and CC 19613 6104 24 that that IN 19613 6104 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6104 26 applies apply VBZ 19613 6104 27 the the DT 19613 6104 28 benefits benefit NNS 19613 6104 29 of of IN 19613 6104 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6104 31 's 's POS 19613 6104 32 work work NN 19613 6104 33 not not RB 19613 6104 34 to to IN 19613 6104 35 the the DT 19613 6104 36 " " `` 19613 6104 37 pneumatic pneumatic JJ 19613 6104 38 " " '' 19613 6104 39 _ _ NNP 19613 6104 40 ipso ipso NN 19613 6104 41 facto facto FW 19613 6104 42 _ _ NNP 19613 6104 43 , , , 19613 6104 44 but but CC 19613 6104 45 in in IN 19613 6104 46 principle principle NN 19613 6104 47 to to IN 19613 6104 48 all all DT 19613 6104 49 men man NNS 19613 6104 50 , , , 19613 6104 51 though though IN 19613 6104 52 practically practically RB 19613 6104 53 only only RB 19613 6104 54 to to IN 19613 6104 55 those those DT 19613 6104 56 who who WP 19613 6104 57 listen listen VBP 19613 6104 58 to to IN 19613 6104 59 the the DT 19613 6104 60 Saviour Saviour NNP 19613 6104 61 's 's POS 19613 6104 62 words word NNS 19613 6104 63 and and CC 19613 6104 64 adorn adorn VB 19613 6104 65 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6104 66 with with IN 19613 6104 67 works work NNS 19613 6104 68 of of IN 19613 6104 69 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 6104 70 . . . 19613 6105 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6105 2 611 611 CD 19613 6105 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6105 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6105 5 presented present VBD 19613 6105 6 this this DT 19613 6105 7 work work NN 19613 6105 8 of of IN 19613 6105 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6105 10 from from IN 19613 6105 11 various various JJ 19613 6105 12 points point NNS 19613 6105 13 of of IN 19613 6105 14 view view NN 19613 6105 15 . . . 19613 6106 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6106 2 regards regard VBZ 19613 6106 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6106 4 as as IN 19613 6106 5 the the DT 19613 6106 6 realisation realisation NN 19613 6106 7 of of IN 19613 6106 8 man man NN 19613 6106 9 's 's POS 19613 6106 10 original original JJ 19613 6106 11 destiny destiny NN 19613 6106 12 , , , 19613 6106 13 that that RB 19613 6106 14 is is RB 19613 6106 15 , , , 19613 6106 16 being be VBG 19613 6106 17 in in IN 19613 6106 18 communion communion NN 19613 6106 19 with with IN 19613 6106 20 God God NNP 19613 6106 21 , , , 19613 6106 22 contemplating contemplate VBG 19613 6106 23 God God NNP 19613 6106 24 , , , 19613 6106 25 being be VBG 19613 6106 26 imperishable imperishable JJ 19613 6106 27 like like IN 19613 6106 28 God God NNP 19613 6106 29 ; ; : 19613 6106 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6106 31 moreover moreover RB 19613 6106 32 views view VBZ 19613 6106 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6106 34 as as IN 19613 6106 35 the the DT 19613 6106 36 abolition abolition NN 19613 6106 37 of of IN 19613 6106 38 the the DT 19613 6106 39 consequences consequence NNS 19613 6106 40 of of IN 19613 6106 41 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6106 42 's 's POS 19613 6106 43 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 6106 44 , , , 19613 6106 45 and and CC 19613 6106 46 therefore therefore RB 19613 6106 47 as as IN 19613 6106 48 the the DT 19613 6106 49 redemption redemption NN 19613 6106 50 of of IN 19613 6106 51 men man NNS 19613 6106 52 from from IN 19613 6106 53 death death NN 19613 6106 54 and and CC 19613 6106 55 the the DT 19613 6106 56 dominion dominion NN 19613 6106 57 of of IN 19613 6106 58 the the DT 19613 6106 59 devil devil NN 19613 6106 60 ; ; : 19613 6106 61 and and CC 19613 6106 62 finally finally RB 19613 6106 63 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6106 64 looks look VBZ 19613 6106 65 upon upon IN 19613 6106 66 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6106 67 as as IN 19613 6106 68 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 6106 69 with with IN 19613 6106 70 God God NNP 19613 6106 71 . . . 19613 6107 1 In in IN 19613 6107 2 all all PDT 19613 6107 3 these these DT 19613 6107 4 conceptions conception NNS 19613 6107 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6107 6 fell fall VBD 19613 6107 7 back back RB 19613 6107 8 upon upon IN 19613 6107 9 the the DT 19613 6107 10 _ _ NNP 19613 6107 11 person person NN 19613 6107 12 _ _ NNP 19613 6107 13 of of IN 19613 6107 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6107 15 . . . 19613 6108 1 Here here RB 19613 6108 2 , , , 19613 6108 3 at at IN 19613 6108 4 the the DT 19613 6108 5 same same JJ 19613 6108 6 time time NN 19613 6108 7 , , , 19613 6108 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6108 9 is be VBZ 19613 6108 10 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 6108 11 determined determine VBN 19613 6108 12 by by IN 19613 6108 13 the the DT 19613 6108 14 content content NN 19613 6108 15 of of IN 19613 6108 16 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6108 17 passages passage NNS 19613 6108 18 ; ; : 19613 6108 19 in in IN 19613 6108 20 fact fact NN 19613 6108 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6108 22 is be VBZ 19613 6108 23 just just RB 19613 6108 24 the the DT 19613 6108 25 New New NNP 19613 6108 26 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6108 27 that that WDT 19613 6108 28 leads lead VBZ 19613 6108 29 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6108 30 to to IN 19613 6108 31 these these DT 19613 6108 32 considerations consideration NNS 19613 6108 33 , , , 19613 6108 34 as as IN 19613 6108 35 was be VBD 19613 6108 36 first first RB 19613 6108 37 the the DT 19613 6108 38 case case NN 19613 6108 39 with with IN 19613 6108 40 the the DT 19613 6108 41 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 6108 42 before before IN 19613 6108 43 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6108 44 . . . 19613 6109 1 How how WRB 19613 6109 2 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 6109 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6109 4 still still RB 19613 6109 5 is be VBZ 19613 6109 6 as as IN 19613 6109 7 to to IN 19613 6109 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6109 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6109 10 importance importance NN 19613 6109 11 is be VBZ 19613 6109 12 shown show VBN 19613 6109 13 by by IN 19613 6109 14 the the DT 19613 6109 15 fact fact NN 19613 6109 16 that that IN 19613 6109 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6109 18 has have VBZ 19613 6109 19 no no DT 19613 6109 20 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 6109 21 in in IN 19613 6109 22 reckoning reckon VBG 19613 6109 23 the the DT 19613 6109 24 question question NN 19613 6109 25 , , , 19613 6109 26 as as IN 19613 6109 27 to to IN 19613 6109 28 why why WRB 19613 6109 29 the the DT 19613 6109 30 Word Word NNP 19613 6109 31 of of IN 19613 6109 32 God God NNP 19613 6109 33 became become VBD 19613 6109 34 flesh flesh NN 19613 6109 35 and and CC 19613 6109 36 suffered suffer VBD 19613 6109 37 , , , 19613 6109 38 among among IN 19613 6109 39 the the DT 19613 6109 40 articles article NNS 19613 6109 41 that that WDT 19613 6109 42 are be VBP 19613 6109 43 a a DT 19613 6109 44 matter matter NN 19613 6109 45 of of IN 19613 6109 46 consideration consideration NN 19613 6109 47 for for IN 19613 6109 48 science science NN 19613 6109 49 , , , 19613 6109 50 but but CC 19613 6109 51 not not RB 19613 6109 52 for for IN 19613 6109 53 the the DT 19613 6109 54 simple simple JJ 19613 6109 55 faith faith NN 19613 6109 56 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6109 57 I. I. NNP 19613 6110 1 10 10 CD 19613 6110 2 . . . 19613 6111 1 3 3 LS 19613 6111 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6111 3 . . . 19613 6112 1 Here here RB 19613 6112 2 , , , 19613 6112 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 6112 4 , , , 19613 6112 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6112 6 still still RB 19613 6112 7 maintains maintain VBZ 19613 6112 8 the the DT 19613 6112 9 archaic archaic NN 19613 6112 10 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 6112 11 according accord VBG 19613 6112 12 to to IN 19613 6112 13 which which WDT 19613 6112 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6112 15 is be VBZ 19613 6112 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 6112 17 to to TO 19613 6112 18 adhere adhere VB 19613 6112 19 to to IN 19613 6112 20 the the DT 19613 6112 21 baptismal baptismal JJ 19613 6112 22 confession confession NN 19613 6112 23 and and CC 19613 6112 24 wait wait VB 19613 6112 25 for for IN 19613 6112 26 the the DT 19613 6112 27 second second JJ 19613 6112 28 coming coming NN 19613 6112 29 of of IN 19613 6112 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6112 31 along along IN 19613 6112 32 with with IN 19613 6112 33 the the DT 19613 6112 34 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 6112 35 of of IN 19613 6112 36 the the DT 19613 6112 37 body body NN 19613 6112 38 . . . 19613 6113 1 On on IN 19613 6113 2 the the DT 19613 6113 3 other other JJ 19613 6113 4 hand hand NN 19613 6113 5 , , , 19613 6113 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6113 7 did do VBD 19613 6113 8 not not RB 19613 6113 9 merely merely RB 19613 6113 10 confine confine VB 19613 6113 11 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6113 12 to to IN 19613 6113 13 describing describe VBG 19613 6113 14 the the DT 19613 6113 15 fact fact NN 19613 6113 16 of of IN 19613 6113 17 redemption redemption NN 19613 6113 18 , , , 19613 6113 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6113 20 content content NN 19613 6113 21 and and CC 19613 6113 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6113 23 consequences consequence NNS 19613 6113 24 ; ; : 19613 6113 25 but but CC 19613 6113 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6113 27 also also RB 19613 6113 28 attempted attempt VBD 19613 6113 29 to to TO 19613 6113 30 explain explain VB 19613 6113 31 the the DT 19613 6113 32 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 6113 33 nature nature NN 19613 6113 34 of of IN 19613 6113 35 this this DT 19613 6113 36 redemption redemption NN 19613 6113 37 from from IN 19613 6113 38 the the DT 19613 6113 39 essence essence NN 19613 6113 40 of of IN 19613 6113 41 God God NNP 19613 6113 42 and and CC 19613 6113 43 the the DT 19613 6113 44 incapacity incapacity NN 19613 6113 45 of of IN 19613 6113 46 man man NN 19613 6113 47 , , , 19613 6113 48 thus thus RB 19613 6113 49 solving solve VBG 19613 6113 50 the the DT 19613 6113 51 question question NN 19613 6113 52 " " `` 19613 6113 53 cur cur NNP 19613 6113 54 deus deus NNP 19613 6113 55 homo homo NN 19613 6113 56 " " '' 19613 6113 57 in in IN 19613 6113 58 the the DT 19613 6113 59 highest high JJS 19613 6113 60 sense sense NN 19613 6113 61 . . . 19613 6114 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6114 2 612 612 CD 19613 6114 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6114 4 Finally finally RB 19613 6114 5 , , , 19613 6114 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6114 7 adopted adopt VBD 19613 6114 8 from from IN 19613 6114 9 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6114 10 the the DT 19613 6114 11 thought thought NN 19613 6114 12 that that IN 19613 6114 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6114 14 's 's POS 19613 6114 15 real real JJ 19613 6114 16 work work NN 19613 6114 17 of of IN 19613 6114 18 salvation salvation NN 19613 6114 19 consists consist VBZ 19613 6114 20 in in IN 19613 6114 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6114 22 death death NN 19613 6114 23 on on IN 19613 6114 24 the the DT 19613 6114 25 cross cross NN 19613 6114 26 ; ; : 19613 6114 27 and and CC 19613 6114 28 so so RB 19613 6114 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6114 30 tried try VBD 19613 6114 31 to to TO 19613 6114 32 amalgamate amalgamate VB 19613 6114 33 the the DT 19613 6114 34 two two CD 19613 6114 35 propositions proposition NNS 19613 6114 36 , , , 19613 6114 37 " " '' 19613 6114 38 _ _ NNP 19613 6114 39 filius filius NNP 19613 6114 40 dei dei NNP 19613 6114 41 filius filius NNP 19613 6114 42 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6114 43 factus factus NNP 19613 6114 44 est est NNP 19613 6114 45 propter propter NN 19613 6114 46 nos nos NNP 19613 6114 47 _ _ NNP 19613 6114 48 " " '' 19613 6114 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6114 50 " " `` 19613 6114 51 the the DT 19613 6114 52 Son Son NNP 19613 6114 53 of of IN 19613 6114 54 God God NNP 19613 6114 55 became become VBD 19613 6114 56 Son Son NNP 19613 6114 57 of of IN 19613 6114 58 man man NN 19613 6114 59 for for IN 19613 6114 60 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6114 61 " " '' 19613 6114 62 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6114 63 and and CC 19613 6114 64 " " `` 19613 6114 65 filius filius NNP 19613 6114 66 dei dei NNP 19613 6114 67 passus passus NNP 19613 6114 68 est est NNP 19613 6114 69 propter propter NNP 19613 6114 70 nos nos NNP 19613 6114 71 " " '' 19613 6114 72 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6114 73 " " `` 19613 6114 74 the the DT 19613 6114 75 Son Son NNP 19613 6114 76 of of IN 19613 6114 77 God God NNP 19613 6114 78 suffered suffer VBD 19613 6114 79 for for IN 19613 6114 80 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6114 81 " " '' 19613 6114 82 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6114 83 as as IN 19613 6114 84 the the DT 19613 6114 85 most most RBS 19613 6114 86 vital vital JJ 19613 6114 87 ones one NNS 19613 6114 88 . . . 19613 6115 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6115 2 did do VBD 19613 6115 3 not not RB 19613 6115 4 , , , 19613 6115 5 however however RB 19613 6115 6 , , , 19613 6115 7 clearly clearly RB 19613 6115 8 show show VBP 19613 6115 9 which which WDT 19613 6115 10 of of IN 19613 6115 11 these these DT 19613 6115 12 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 6115 13 is be VBZ 19613 6115 14 the the DT 19613 6115 15 more more RBR 19613 6115 16 important important JJ 19613 6115 17 . . . 19613 6116 1 Here here RB 19613 6116 2 the the DT 19613 6116 3 speculation speculation NN 19613 6116 4 of of IN 19613 6116 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6116 6 is be VBZ 19613 6116 7 already already RB 19613 6116 8 involved involve VBN 19613 6116 9 in in IN 19613 6116 10 the the DT 19613 6116 11 same same JJ 19613 6116 12 ambiguity ambiguity NN 19613 6116 13 as as IN 19613 6116 14 was be VBD 19613 6116 15 destined destine VBN 19613 6116 16 to to TO 19613 6116 17 be be VB 19613 6116 18 the the DT 19613 6116 19 permanent permanent JJ 19613 6116 20 characteristic characteristic NN 19613 6116 21 of of IN 19613 6116 22 Church Church NNP 19613 6116 23 speculation speculation NN 19613 6116 24 as as IN 19613 6116 25 to to IN 19613 6116 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6116 27 's 's POS 19613 6116 28 work work NN 19613 6116 29 in in IN 19613 6116 30 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 6116 31 times time NNS 19613 6116 32 . . . 19613 6117 1 For for IN 19613 6117 2 on on IN 19613 6117 3 the the DT 19613 6117 4 one one CD 19613 6117 5 hand hand NN 19613 6117 6 , , , 19613 6117 7 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6117 8 led lead VBD 19613 6117 9 one one PRP 19613 6117 10 to to TO 19613 6117 11 lay lay VB 19613 6117 12 all all PDT 19613 6117 13 the the DT 19613 6117 14 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 6117 15 on on IN 19613 6117 16 the the DT 19613 6117 17 death death NN 19613 6117 18 on on IN 19613 6117 19 the the DT 19613 6117 20 cross cross NN 19613 6117 21 , , , 19613 6117 22 and and CC 19613 6117 23 on on IN 19613 6117 24 the the DT 19613 6117 25 other other JJ 19613 6117 26 , , , 19613 6117 27 the the DT 19613 6117 28 logical logical JJ 19613 6117 29 result result NN 19613 6117 30 of of IN 19613 6117 31 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 6117 32 thinking thinking NN 19613 6117 33 only only RB 19613 6117 34 pointed point VBD 19613 6117 35 to to IN 19613 6117 36 the the DT 19613 6117 37 appearance appearance NN 19613 6117 38 of of IN 19613 6117 39 God God NNP 19613 6117 40 in in IN 19613 6117 41 the the DT 19613 6117 42 flesh flesh NN 19613 6117 43 , , , 19613 6117 44 but but CC 19613 6117 45 not not RB 19613 6117 46 to to IN 19613 6117 47 a a DT 19613 6117 48 particular particular JJ 19613 6117 49 work work NN 19613 6117 50 of of IN 19613 6117 51 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6117 52 that that WDT 19613 6117 53 had have VBD 19613 6117 54 not not RB 19613 6117 55 been be VBN 19613 6117 56 already already RB 19613 6117 57 involved involve VBN 19613 6117 58 in in IN 19613 6117 59 the the DT 19613 6117 60 appearance appearance NN 19613 6117 61 of of IN 19613 6117 62 the the DT 19613 6117 63 Divine Divine NNP 19613 6117 64 Teacher Teacher NNP 19613 6117 65 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6117 66 . . . 19613 6118 1 Still still RB 19613 6118 2 , , , 19613 6118 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6118 4 contrived contrive VBD 19613 6118 5 to to TO 19613 6118 6 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 6118 7 the the DT 19613 6118 8 discrepancy discrepancy NN 19613 6118 9 better well RBR 19613 6118 10 than than IN 19613 6118 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6118 12 successors successor NNS 19613 6118 13 , , , 19613 6118 14 because because IN 19613 6118 15 , , , 19613 6118 16 being be VBG 19613 6118 17 in in IN 19613 6118 18 earnest earnest NN 19613 6118 19 with with IN 19613 6118 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6118 21 idea idea NN 19613 6118 22 of of IN 19613 6118 23 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6118 24 as as IN 19613 6118 25 the the DT 19613 6118 26 second second JJ 19613 6118 27 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6118 28 , , , 19613 6118 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6118 30 was be VBD 19613 6118 31 able able JJ 19613 6118 32 to to TO 19613 6118 33 contemplate contemplate VB 19613 6118 34 the the DT 19613 6118 35 whole whole JJ 19613 6118 36 life life NN 19613 6118 37 of of IN 19613 6118 38 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6118 39 as as IN 19613 6118 40 redemption redemption NN 19613 6118 41 in in IN 19613 6118 42 so so RB 19613 6118 43 far far RB 19613 6118 44 as as IN 19613 6118 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6118 46 conceived conceive VBD 19613 6118 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6118 48 as as IN 19613 6118 49 a a DT 19613 6118 50 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6118 51 . . . 19613 6119 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6119 2 see see VBP 19613 6119 3 this this DT 19613 6119 4 at at IN 19613 6119 5 once once RB 19613 6119 6 not not RB 19613 6119 7 only only RB 19613 6119 8 from from IN 19613 6119 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6119 10 conception conception NN 19613 6119 11 of of IN 19613 6119 12 the the DT 19613 6119 13 virgin virgin JJ 19613 6119 14 birth birth NN 19613 6119 15 as as IN 19613 6119 16 a a DT 19613 6119 17 fact fact NN 19613 6119 18 of of IN 19613 6119 19 salvation salvation NN 19613 6119 20 , , , 19613 6119 21 but but CC 19613 6119 22 also also RB 19613 6119 23 from from IN 19613 6119 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6119 25 way way NN 19613 6119 26 of of IN 19613 6119 27 describing describe VBG 19613 6119 28 redemption redemption NN 19613 6119 29 as as IN 19613 6119 30 deliverance deliverance NN 19613 6119 31 from from IN 19613 6119 32 the the DT 19613 6119 33 devil devil NN 19613 6119 34 . . . 19613 6120 1 For for IN 19613 6120 2 , , , 19613 6120 3 as as IN 19613 6120 4 the the DT 19613 6120 5 birth birth NN 19613 6120 6 of of IN 19613 6120 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6120 8 from from IN 19613 6120 9 the the DT 19613 6120 10 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 6120 11 Mary Mary NNP 19613 6120 12 is be VBZ 19613 6120 13 the the DT 19613 6120 14 recapitulating recapitulate VBG 19613 6120 15 counterpart counterpart NN 19613 6120 16 of of IN 19613 6120 17 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6120 18 's 's POS 19613 6120 19 birth birth NN 19613 6120 20 from from IN 19613 6120 21 the the DT 19613 6120 22 virgin virgin JJ 19613 6120 23 earth earth NN 19613 6120 24 , , , 19613 6120 25 and and CC 19613 6120 26 as as IN 19613 6120 27 the the DT 19613 6120 28 obedience obedience NN 19613 6120 29 of of IN 19613 6120 30 the the DT 19613 6120 31 mother mother NN 19613 6120 32 of of IN 19613 6120 33 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6120 34 is be VBZ 19613 6120 35 the the DT 19613 6120 36 counterpart counterpart NN 19613 6120 37 of of IN 19613 6120 38 Eve Eve NNP 19613 6120 39 's 's POS 19613 6120 40 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 6120 41 , , , 19613 6120 42 so so RB 19613 6120 43 the the DT 19613 6120 44 story story NN 19613 6120 45 of of IN 19613 6120 46 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6120 47 ' ' POS 19613 6120 48 temptation temptation NN 19613 6120 49 is be VBZ 19613 6120 50 to to IN 19613 6120 51 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6120 52 the the DT 19613 6120 53 recapitulating recapitulate VBG 19613 6120 54 counterpart counterpart NN 19613 6120 55 of of IN 19613 6120 56 the the DT 19613 6120 57 story story NN 19613 6120 58 of of IN 19613 6120 59 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6120 60 's 's POS 19613 6120 61 temptation temptation NN 19613 6120 62 . . . 19613 6121 1 In in IN 19613 6121 2 the the DT 19613 6121 3 way way NN 19613 6121 4 that that WDT 19613 6121 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6121 6 overcame overcome VBD 19613 6121 7 the the DT 19613 6121 8 temptation temptation NN 19613 6121 9 by by IN 19613 6121 10 the the DT 19613 6121 11 devil devil NN 19613 6121 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6121 13 Matt Matt NNP 19613 6121 14 . . . 19613 6122 1 IV IV NNP 19613 6122 2 . . . 19613 6122 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6123 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6123 2 already already RB 19613 6123 3 sees see VBZ 19613 6123 4 the the DT 19613 6123 5 redemption redemption NN 19613 6123 6 of of IN 19613 6123 7 mankind mankind NN 19613 6123 8 from from IN 19613 6123 9 Satan Satan NNP 19613 6123 10 ; ; : 19613 6123 11 even even RB 19613 6123 12 then then RB 19613 6123 13 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6123 14 bound bind VBD 19613 6123 15 the the DT 19613 6123 16 strong strong JJ 19613 6123 17 one one CD 19613 6123 18 . . . 19613 6124 1 But but CC 19613 6124 2 , , , 19613 6124 3 whereas whereas IN 19613 6124 4 the the DT 19613 6124 5 devil devil NN 19613 6124 6 seized seize VBD 19613 6124 7 upon upon IN 19613 6124 8 man man NN 19613 6124 9 unlawfully unlawfully RB 19613 6124 10 and and CC 19613 6124 11 deceitfully deceitfully RB 19613 6124 12 , , , 19613 6124 13 no no DT 19613 6124 14 injustice injustice NN 19613 6124 15 , , , 19613 6124 16 untruthfulness untruthfulness JJ 19613 6124 17 , , , 19613 6124 18 or or CC 19613 6124 19 violence violence NN 19613 6124 20 is be VBZ 19613 6124 21 displayed display VBN 19613 6124 22 in in IN 19613 6124 23 the the DT 19613 6124 24 means mean NNS 19613 6124 25 by by IN 19613 6124 26 which which WDT 19613 6124 27 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6124 28 resisted resist VBD 19613 6124 29 Satan Satan NNP 19613 6124 30 's 's POS 19613 6124 31 temptation temptation NN 19613 6124 32 . . . 19613 6125 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6125 2 613 613 CD 19613 6125 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6125 4 As as IN 19613 6125 5 yet yet RB 19613 6125 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6125 7 is be VBZ 19613 6125 8 quite quite RB 19613 6125 9 as as RB 19613 6125 10 free free JJ 19613 6125 11 from from IN 19613 6125 12 the the DT 19613 6125 13 thought thought NN 19613 6125 14 that that WDT 19613 6125 15 the the DT 19613 6125 16 devil devil NN 19613 6125 17 has have VBZ 19613 6125 18 real real JJ 19613 6125 19 rights right NNS 19613 6125 20 upon upon IN 19613 6125 21 man man NN 19613 6125 22 , , , 19613 6125 23 as as IN 19613 6125 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6125 25 is be VBZ 19613 6125 26 from from IN 19613 6125 27 the the DT 19613 6125 28 immoral immoral JJ 19613 6125 29 idea idea NN 19613 6125 30 that that WDT 19613 6125 31 God God NNP 19613 6125 32 accomplished accomplish VBD 19613 6125 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6125 34 work work NN 19613 6125 35 of of IN 19613 6125 36 redemption redemption NN 19613 6125 37 by by IN 19613 6125 38 an an DT 19613 6125 39 act act NN 19613 6125 40 of of IN 19613 6125 41 deceit deceit NN 19613 6125 42 . . . 19613 6126 1 But but CC 19613 6126 2 , , , 19613 6126 3 on on IN 19613 6126 4 the the DT 19613 6126 5 strength strength NN 19613 6126 6 of of IN 19613 6126 7 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 6126 8 passages passage NNS 19613 6126 9 , , , 19613 6126 10 many many JJ 19613 6126 11 of of IN 19613 6126 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6126 13 teachings teaching NNS 19613 6126 14 rather rather RB 19613 6126 15 view view VBP 19613 6126 16 redemption redemption NN 19613 6126 17 from from IN 19613 6126 18 the the DT 19613 6126 19 devil devil NN 19613 6126 20 as as IN 19613 6126 21 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 6126 22 by by IN 19613 6126 23 the the DT 19613 6126 24 _ _ NNP 19613 6126 25 death death NN 19613 6126 26 _ _ NNP 19613 6126 27 of of IN 19613 6126 28 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6126 29 , , , 19613 6126 30 and and CC 19613 6126 31 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 6126 32 represent represent VB 19613 6126 33 this this DT 19613 6126 34 death death NN 19613 6126 35 as as IN 19613 6126 36 a a DT 19613 6126 37 ransom ransom NN 19613 6126 38 paid pay VBN 19613 6126 39 to to IN 19613 6126 40 the the DT 19613 6126 41 " " `` 19613 6126 42 apostasy apostasy NN 19613 6126 43 " " '' 19613 6126 44 for for IN 19613 6126 45 men man NNS 19613 6126 46 who who WP 19613 6126 47 had have VBD 19613 6126 48 fallen fall VBN 19613 6126 49 into into IN 19613 6126 50 captivity captivity NN 19613 6126 51 . . . 19613 6127 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6127 2 did do VBD 19613 6127 3 not not RB 19613 6127 4 , , , 19613 6127 5 however however RB 19613 6127 6 , , , 19613 6127 7 develop develop VB 19613 6127 8 this this DT 19613 6127 9 thought thought NN 19613 6127 10 any any DT 19613 6127 11 further further RB 19613 6127 12 . . . 19613 6128 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6128 2 614 614 CD 19613 6128 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6128 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6128 5 idea idea NN 19613 6128 6 of of IN 19613 6128 7 the the DT 19613 6128 8 _ _ NNP 19613 6128 9 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 6128 10 _ _ XX 19613 6128 11 of of IN 19613 6128 12 God God NNP 19613 6128 13 is be VBZ 19613 6128 14 just just RB 19613 6128 15 as as RB 19613 6128 16 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 6128 17 , , , 19613 6128 18 and and CC 19613 6128 19 merely merely RB 19613 6128 20 suggested suggest VBN 19613 6128 21 by by IN 19613 6128 22 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6128 23 passages passage NNS 19613 6128 24 . . . 19613 6129 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6129 2 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 6129 3 saw see VBD 19613 6129 4 the the DT 19613 6129 5 means mean NNS 19613 6129 6 of of IN 19613 6129 7 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 6129 8 solely solely RB 19613 6129 9 in in IN 19613 6129 10 obedience obedience NN 19613 6129 11 and and CC 19613 6129 12 in in IN 19613 6129 13 the the DT 19613 6129 14 " " `` 19613 6129 15 righteous righteous JJ 19613 6129 16 flesh flesh NN 19613 6129 17 " " '' 19613 6129 18 as as IN 19613 6129 19 such such JJ 19613 6129 20 , , , 19613 6129 21 at at IN 19613 6129 22 other other JJ 19613 6129 23 times time NNS 19613 6129 24 in in IN 19613 6129 25 the the DT 19613 6129 26 " " `` 19613 6129 27 wood wood NN 19613 6129 28 . . . 19613 6129 29 " " '' 19613 6130 1 Here here RB 19613 6130 2 also also RB 19613 6130 3 the the DT 19613 6130 4 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6130 5 theory theory NN 19613 6130 6 again again RB 19613 6130 7 appears appear VBZ 19613 6130 8 : : : 19613 6130 9 through through IN 19613 6130 10 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 6130 11 at at IN 19613 6130 12 the the DT 19613 6130 13 tree tree NN 19613 6130 14 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6130 15 became become VBD 19613 6130 16 a a DT 19613 6130 17 debtor debtor NN 19613 6130 18 to to IN 19613 6130 19 God God NNP 19613 6130 20 , , , 19613 6130 21 and and CC 19613 6130 22 through through IN 19613 6130 23 obedience obedience NN 19613 6130 24 at at IN 19613 6130 25 the the DT 19613 6130 26 tree tree NN 19613 6130 27 God God NNP 19613 6130 28 is be VBZ 19613 6130 29 reconciled reconcile VBN 19613 6130 30 . . . 19613 6131 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6131 2 615 615 CD 19613 6131 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6131 4 But but CC 19613 6131 5 teachings teaching NNS 19613 6131 6 as as IN 19613 6131 7 to to IN 19613 6131 8 vicarious vicarious JJ 19613 6131 9 suffering suffering NN 19613 6131 10 on on IN 19613 6131 11 the the DT 19613 6131 12 part part NN 19613 6131 13 of of IN 19613 6131 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6131 15 are be VBP 19613 6131 16 not not RB 19613 6131 17 found find VBN 19613 6131 18 in in IN 19613 6131 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6131 20 , , , 19613 6131 21 and and CC 19613 6131 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6131 23 death death NN 19613 6131 24 is be VBZ 19613 6131 25 seldom seldom RB 19613 6131 26 presented present VBN 19613 6131 27 from from IN 19613 6131 28 the the DT 19613 6131 29 point point NN 19613 6131 30 of of IN 19613 6131 31 view view NN 19613 6131 32 of of IN 19613 6131 33 a a DT 19613 6131 34 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 6131 35 offered offer VBN 19613 6131 36 to to IN 19613 6131 37 God God NNP 19613 6131 38 . . . 19613 6132 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6132 2 616 616 CD 19613 6132 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6132 4 According accord VBG 19613 6132 5 to to IN 19613 6132 6 this this DT 19613 6132 7 author author NN 19613 6132 8 the the DT 19613 6132 9 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 6132 10 virtually virtually RB 19613 6132 11 consists consist VBZ 19613 6132 12 in in IN 19613 6132 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6132 14 's 's POS 19613 6132 15 restoring restore VBG 19613 6132 16 man man NN 19613 6132 17 to to IN 19613 6132 18 communion communion NN 19613 6132 19 and and CC 19613 6132 20 friendship friendship NN 19613 6132 21 with with IN 19613 6132 22 God God NNP 19613 6132 23 and and CC 19613 6132 24 procuring procuring NN 19613 6132 25 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 6132 26 of of IN 19613 6132 27 sins sin NNS 19613 6132 28 ; ; : 19613 6132 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6132 30 very very RB 19613 6132 31 seldom seldom RB 19613 6132 32 speaks speak VBZ 19613 6132 33 of of IN 19613 6132 34 God God NNP 19613 6132 35 being be VBG 19613 6132 36 offended offend VBN 19613 6132 37 through through IN 19613 6132 38 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6132 39 's 's POS 19613 6132 40 sin sin NN 19613 6132 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6132 42 V. V. NNP 19613 6132 43 16 16 CD 19613 6132 44 . . . 19613 6133 1 3 3 LS 19613 6133 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6133 3 . . . 19613 6134 1 But but CC 19613 6134 2 the the DT 19613 6134 3 incidental incidental JJ 19613 6134 4 mention mention NN 19613 6134 5 of of IN 19613 6134 6 the the DT 19613 6134 7 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 6134 8 of of IN 19613 6134 9 sins sin NNS 19613 6134 10 resulting result VBG 19613 6134 11 from from IN 19613 6134 12 the the DT 19613 6134 13 redemption redemption NN 19613 6134 14 by by IN 19613 6134 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6134 16 has have VBZ 19613 6134 17 not not RB 19613 6134 18 the the DT 19613 6134 19 meaning meaning NN 19613 6134 20 of of IN 19613 6134 21 an an DT 19613 6134 22 _ _ NNP 19613 6134 23 abolition abolition NN 19613 6134 24 _ _ NNP 19613 6134 25 of of IN 19613 6134 26 sin sin NN 19613 6134 27 . . . 19613 6135 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6135 2 connects connect VBZ 19613 6135 3 the the DT 19613 6135 4 redemption redemption NN 19613 6135 5 with with IN 19613 6135 6 this this DT 19613 6135 7 only only RB 19613 6135 8 in in IN 19613 6135 9 the the DT 19613 6135 10 form form NN 19613 6135 11 of of IN 19613 6135 12 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6135 13 and and CC 19613 6135 14 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 19613 6135 15 phrases phrase NNS 19613 6135 16 ; ; , 19613 6135 17 for for IN 19613 6135 18 the the DT 19613 6135 19 vital vital JJ 19613 6135 20 point point NN 19613 6135 21 with with IN 19613 6135 22 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6135 23 is be VBZ 19613 6135 24 the the DT 19613 6135 25 abolition abolition NN 19613 6135 26 of of IN 19613 6135 27 the the DT 19613 6135 28 _ _ NNP 19613 6135 29 consequences consequence NNS 19613 6135 30 _ _ NNP 19613 6135 31 of of IN 19613 6135 32 sin sin NN 19613 6135 33 , , , 19613 6135 34 and and CC 19613 6135 35 particularly particularly RB 19613 6135 36 of of IN 19613 6135 37 the the DT 19613 6135 38 sentence sentence NN 19613 6135 39 of of IN 19613 6135 40 death death NN 19613 6135 41 . . . 19613 6136 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6136 2 617 617 CD 19613 6136 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6136 4 Here here RB 19613 6136 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6136 6 have have VBP 19613 6136 7 the the DT 19613 6136 8 transition transition NN 19613 6136 9 to to IN 19613 6136 10 the the DT 19613 6136 11 conception conception NN 19613 6136 12 of of IN 19613 6136 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6136 14 's 's POS 19613 6136 15 work work NN 19613 6136 16 which which WDT 19613 6136 17 makes make VBZ 19613 6136 18 this this DT 19613 6136 19 appear appear VB 19613 6136 20 more more JJR 19613 6136 21 as as IN 19613 6136 22 a a DT 19613 6136 23 completion completion NN 19613 6136 24 than than IN 19613 6136 25 as as IN 19613 6136 26 a a DT 19613 6136 27 restoration restoration NN 19613 6136 28 . . . 19613 6137 1 In in IN 19613 6137 2 this this DT 19613 6137 3 connection connection NN 19613 6137 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6137 5 employed employ VBD 19613 6137 6 the the DT 19613 6137 7 following follow VBG 19613 6137 8 categories category NNS 19613 6137 9 : : : 19613 6137 10 _ _ XX 19613 6137 11 restoring restore VBG 19613 6137 12 of of IN 19613 6137 13 the the DT 19613 6137 14 likeness likeness NN 19613 6137 15 of of IN 19613 6137 16 God God NNP 19613 6137 17 in in IN 19613 6137 18 humanity humanity NN 19613 6137 19 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 20 ; ; : 19613 6137 21 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 22 abolition abolition NN 19613 6137 23 of of IN 19613 6137 24 death death NN 19613 6137 25 _ _ NN 19613 6137 26 ; ; : 19613 6137 27 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 28 connection connection NN 19613 6137 29 and and CC 19613 6137 30 union union NN 19613 6137 31 of of IN 19613 6137 32 man man NN 19613 6137 33 with with IN 19613 6137 34 God God NNP 19613 6137 35 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 36 ; ; : 19613 6137 37 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 38 adoption adoption NN 19613 6137 39 of of IN 19613 6137 40 men man NNS 19613 6137 41 as as IN 19613 6137 42 sons son NNS 19613 6137 43 of of IN 19613 6137 44 God God NNP 19613 6137 45 and and CC 19613 6137 46 as as IN 19613 6137 47 gods god NNS 19613 6137 48 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 49 ; ; : 19613 6137 50 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 51 imparting impart VBG 19613 6137 52 of of IN 19613 6137 53 the the DT 19613 6137 54 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6137 55 who who WP 19613 6137 56 now now RB 19613 6137 57 becomes become VBZ 19613 6137 58 accustomed accustom VBN 19613 6137 59 to to TO 19613 6137 60 abide abide VB 19613 6137 61 with with IN 19613 6137 62 men_;[618 men_;[618 NNP 19613 6137 63 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6137 64 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 65 imparting impart VBG 19613 6137 66 of of IN 19613 6137 67 a a DT 19613 6137 68 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6137 69 of of IN 19613 6137 70 God God NNP 19613 6137 71 culminating culminate VBG 19613 6137 72 in in IN 19613 6137 73 beholding behold VBG 19613 6137 74 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6137 75 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 76 ; ; : 19613 6137 77 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 78 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 6137 79 of of IN 19613 6137 80 everlasting everlasting JJ 19613 6137 81 life life NN 19613 6137 82 _ _ NNP 19613 6137 83 . . . 19613 6138 1 All all PDT 19613 6138 2 these these DT 19613 6138 3 are be VBP 19613 6138 4 only only RB 19613 6138 5 the the DT 19613 6138 6 different different JJ 19613 6138 7 aspects aspect NNS 19613 6138 8 of of IN 19613 6138 9 one one CD 19613 6138 10 and and CC 19613 6138 11 the the DT 19613 6138 12 same same JJ 19613 6138 13 blessing blessing NN 19613 6138 14 , , , 19613 6138 15 which which WDT 19613 6138 16 , , , 19613 6138 17 being be VBG 19613 6138 18 of of IN 19613 6138 19 a a DT 19613 6138 20 divine divine JJ 19613 6138 21 order order NN 19613 6138 22 , , , 19613 6138 23 could could MD 19613 6138 24 only only RB 19613 6138 25 be be VB 19613 6138 26 brought bring VBN 19613 6138 27 to to IN 19613 6138 28 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6138 29 and and CC 19613 6138 30 implanted implant VBD 19613 6138 31 in in IN 19613 6138 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6138 33 nature nature NN 19613 6138 34 by by IN 19613 6138 35 God God NNP 19613 6138 36 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6138 37 . . . 19613 6139 1 But but CC 19613 6139 2 inasmuch inasmuch VB 19613 6139 3 as as IN 19613 6139 4 this this DT 19613 6139 5 view view NN 19613 6139 6 represents represent VBZ 19613 6139 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6139 8 not not RB 19613 6139 9 as as IN 19613 6139 10 performing perform VBG 19613 6139 11 a a DT 19613 6139 12 reconciling reconcile VBG 19613 6139 13 but but CC 19613 6139 14 a a DT 19613 6139 15 perfecting perfecting NN 19613 6139 16 work work NN 19613 6139 17 , , , 19613 6139 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6139 19 _ _ NNP 19613 6139 20 acts act VBZ 19613 6139 21 _ _ NNP 19613 6139 22 are be VBP 19613 6139 23 thrust thrust VBN 19613 6139 24 more more RBR 19613 6139 25 into into IN 19613 6139 26 the the DT 19613 6139 27 background background NN 19613 6139 28 ; ; : 19613 6139 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6139 30 work work NN 19613 6139 31 is be VBZ 19613 6139 32 contained contain VBN 19613 6139 33 in in IN 19613 6139 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6139 35 constitution constitution NN 19613 6139 36 as as IN 19613 6139 37 the the DT 19613 6139 38 God God NNP 19613 6139 39 - - HYPH 19613 6139 40 man man NNP 19613 6139 41 . . . 19613 6140 1 Hence hence RB 19613 6140 2 this this DT 19613 6140 3 work work NN 19613 6140 4 has have VBZ 19613 6140 5 a a DT 19613 6140 6 universal universal JJ 19613 6140 7 significance significance NN 19613 6140 8 for for IN 19613 6140 9 all all DT 19613 6140 10 men man NNS 19613 6140 11 , , , 19613 6140 12 not not RB 19613 6140 13 only only RB 19613 6140 14 as as IN 19613 6140 15 regards regard VBZ 19613 6140 16 the the DT 19613 6140 17 present present NN 19613 6140 18 , , , 19613 6140 19 but but CC 19613 6140 20 as as IN 19613 6140 21 regards regard VBZ 19613 6140 22 the the DT 19613 6140 23 past past NN 19613 6140 24 from from IN 19613 6140 25 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6140 26 downwards downwards RB 19613 6140 27 , , , 19613 6140 28 in in IN 19613 6140 29 so so RB 19613 6140 30 far far RB 19613 6140 31 as as IN 19613 6140 32 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6140 33 " " `` 19613 6140 34 according accord VBG 19613 6140 35 to to IN 19613 6140 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6140 37 virtue virtue NN 19613 6140 38 in in IN 19613 6140 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6140 40 generation generation NN 19613 6140 41 have have VBP 19613 6140 42 not not RB 19613 6140 43 only only RB 19613 6140 44 feared fear VBN 19613 6140 45 but but CC 19613 6140 46 also also RB 19613 6140 47 loved love VBD 19613 6140 48 God God NNP 19613 6140 49 , , , 19613 6140 50 and and CC 19613 6140 51 have have VBP 19613 6140 52 behaved behave VBN 19613 6140 53 justly justly RB 19613 6140 54 and and CC 19613 6140 55 piously piously RB 19613 6140 56 towards towards IN 19613 6140 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6140 58 neighbours neighbour NNS 19613 6140 59 , , , 19613 6140 60 and and CC 19613 6140 61 have have VBP 19613 6140 62 longed long VBN 19613 6140 63 to to TO 19613 6140 64 see see VB 19613 6140 65 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6140 66 and and CC 19613 6140 67 to to TO 19613 6140 68 hear hear VB 19613 6140 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6140 70 voice voice NN 19613 6140 71 . . . 19613 6141 1 " " `` 19613 6141 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6141 3 619 619 CD 19613 6141 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6141 5 Those those DT 19613 6141 6 redeemed redeem VBN 19613 6141 7 by by IN 19613 6141 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6141 9 are be VBP 19613 6141 10 immediately immediately RB 19613 6141 11 joined join VBN 19613 6141 12 by by IN 19613 6141 13 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6141 14 into into IN 19613 6141 15 a a DT 19613 6141 16 unity unity NN 19613 6141 17 , , , 19613 6141 18 into into IN 19613 6141 19 the the DT 19613 6141 20 true true JJ 19613 6141 21 humanity humanity NN 19613 6141 22 , , , 19613 6141 23 the the DT 19613 6141 24 Church Church NNP 19613 6141 25 , , , 19613 6141 26 whose whose WP$ 19613 6141 27 head head NN 19613 6141 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6141 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6141 30 is be VBZ 19613 6141 31 . . . 19613 6142 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6142 2 620 620 CD 19613 6142 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6142 4 This this DT 19613 6142 5 Church Church NNP 19613 6142 6 is be VBZ 19613 6142 7 the the DT 19613 6142 8 communion communion NN 19613 6142 9 of of IN 19613 6142 10 the the DT 19613 6142 11 Sons Sons NNPS 19613 6142 12 of of IN 19613 6142 13 God God NNP 19613 6142 14 , , , 19613 6142 15 who who WP 19613 6142 16 have have VBP 19613 6142 17 attained attain VBN 19613 6142 18 to to IN 19613 6142 19 a a DT 19613 6142 20 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 6142 21 of of IN 19613 6142 22 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6142 23 and and CC 19613 6142 24 have have VBP 19613 6142 25 been be VBN 19613 6142 26 gifted gift VBN 19613 6142 27 with with IN 19613 6142 28 everlasting everlasting JJ 19613 6142 29 life life NN 19613 6142 30 . . . 19613 6143 1 In in IN 19613 6143 2 this this DT 19613 6143 3 the the DT 19613 6143 4 work work NN 19613 6143 5 of of IN 19613 6143 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6143 7 the the DT 19613 6143 8 God God NNP 19613 6143 9 - - HYPH 19613 6143 10 man man NNP 19613 6143 11 is be VBZ 19613 6143 12 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 6143 13 . . . 19613 6144 1 In in IN 19613 6144 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6144 3 and and CC 19613 6144 4 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6144 5 , , , 19613 6144 6 as as IN 19613 6144 7 the the DT 19613 6144 8 result result NN 19613 6144 9 of of IN 19613 6144 10 New New NNP 19613 6144 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6144 12 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 6144 13 , , , 19613 6144 14 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6144 15 again again RB 19613 6144 16 find find VBP 19613 6144 17 the the DT 19613 6144 18 same same JJ 19613 6144 19 aspects aspect NNS 19613 6144 20 of of IN 19613 6144 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6144 22 's 's POS 19613 6144 23 work work NN 19613 6144 24 as as IN 19613 6144 25 in in IN 19613 6144 26 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6144 27 , , , 19613 6144 28 only only RB 19613 6144 29 with with IN 19613 6144 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6144 31 the the DT 19613 6144 32 mystical mystical JJ 19613 6144 33 form form NN 19613 6144 34 of of IN 19613 6144 35 redemption redemption NN 19613 6144 36 recedes recede VBZ 19613 6144 37 into into IN 19613 6144 38 the the DT 19613 6144 39 background background NN 19613 6144 40 . . . 19613 6145 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6145 2 621 621 CD 19613 6145 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6145 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 6145 5 the the DT 19613 6145 6 _ _ NNP 19613 6145 7 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 6145 8 _ _ NNP 19613 6145 9 as as IN 19613 6145 10 set set VBN 19613 6145 11 forth forth RP 19613 6145 12 by by IN 19613 6145 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6145 14 in in IN 19613 6145 15 the the DT 19613 6145 16 fifth fifth JJ 19613 6145 17 Book Book NNP 19613 6145 18 by by IN 19613 6145 19 no no DT 19613 6145 20 means means NN 19613 6145 21 corresponds correspond NNS 19613 6145 22 to to IN 19613 6145 23 this this DT 19613 6145 24 conception conception NN 19613 6145 25 of of IN 19613 6145 26 the the DT 19613 6145 27 work work NN 19613 6145 28 of of IN 19613 6145 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6145 30 as as IN 19613 6145 31 a a DT 19613 6145 32 restoring restore VBG 19613 6145 33 and and CC 19613 6145 34 completing complete VBG 19613 6145 35 one one CD 19613 6145 36 ; ; : 19613 6145 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6145 38 rather rather RB 19613 6145 39 appears appear VBZ 19613 6145 40 as as IN 19613 6145 41 a a DT 19613 6145 42 remnant remnant NN 19613 6145 43 of of IN 19613 6145 44 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 6145 45 directly directly RB 19613 6145 46 opposed oppose VBN 19613 6145 47 to to IN 19613 6145 48 the the DT 19613 6145 49 speculative speculative JJ 19613 6145 50 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6145 51 of of IN 19613 6145 52 redemption redemption NN 19613 6145 53 , , , 19613 6145 54 but but CC 19613 6145 55 protected protect VBN 19613 6145 56 by by IN 19613 6145 57 the the DT 19613 6145 58 _ _ NNP 19613 6145 59 regula regula NN 19613 6145 60 fidei fidei NNP 19613 6145 61 _ _ NNP 19613 6145 62 , , , 19613 6145 63 the the DT 19613 6145 64 New New NNP 19613 6145 65 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6145 66 , , , 19613 6145 67 especially especially RB 19613 6145 68 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 6145 69 , , , 19613 6145 70 and and CC 19613 6145 71 the the DT 19613 6145 72 material material NN 19613 6145 73 hopes hope NNS 19613 6145 74 of of IN 19613 6145 75 the the DT 19613 6145 76 great great JJ 19613 6145 77 majority majority NN 19613 6145 78 of of IN 19613 6145 79 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 6145 80 . . . 19613 6146 1 But but CC 19613 6146 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6146 3 would would MD 19613 6146 4 be be VB 19613 6146 5 a a DT 19613 6146 6 great great JJ 19613 6146 7 mistake mistake NN 19613 6146 8 to to TO 19613 6146 9 assume assume VB 19613 6146 10 that that IN 19613 6146 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6146 12 merely merely RB 19613 6146 13 repeated repeat VBD 19613 6146 14 the the DT 19613 6146 15 hopes hope NNS 19613 6146 16 of of IN 19613 6146 17 an an DT 19613 6146 18 earthly earthly JJ 19613 6146 19 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6146 20 just just RB 19613 6146 21 because because IN 19613 6146 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6146 23 still still RB 19613 6146 24 found find VBD 19613 6146 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6146 26 in in IN 19613 6146 27 tradition tradition NN 19613 6146 28 , , , 19613 6146 29 and and CC 19613 6146 30 because because IN 19613 6146 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6146 32 were be VBD 19613 6146 33 completely completely RB 19613 6146 34 rejected reject VBN 19613 6146 35 by by IN 19613 6146 36 the the DT 19613 6146 37 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6146 38 and and CC 19613 6146 39 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 6146 40 by by IN 19613 6146 41 the the DT 19613 6146 42 _ _ NNP 19613 6146 43 regula regula NN 19613 6146 44 _ _ NNP 19613 6146 45 and and CC 19613 6146 46 the the DT 19613 6146 47 New New NNP 19613 6146 48 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6146 49 . . . 19613 6147 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6147 2 622 622 CD 19613 6147 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6147 4 The the DT 19613 6147 5 truth truth NN 19613 6147 6 rather rather RB 19613 6147 7 is be VBZ 19613 6147 8 that that IN 19613 6147 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6147 10 as as RB 19613 6147 11 well well RB 19613 6147 12 as as IN 19613 6147 13 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6147 14 , , , 19613 6147 15 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6147 16 , , , 19613 6147 17 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6147 18 , , , 19613 6147 19 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 19613 6147 20 , , , 19613 6147 21 Commodian Commodian NNP 19613 6147 22 , , , 19613 6147 23 and and CC 19613 6147 24 Victorinus Victorinus NNP 19613 6147 25 lived live VBD 19613 6147 26 in in IN 19613 6147 27 these these DT 19613 6147 28 hopes hope NNS 19613 6147 29 no no RB 19613 6147 30 less less JJR 19613 6147 31 than than IN 19613 6147 32 did do VBD 19613 6147 33 Papias Papias NNP 19613 6147 34 , , , 19613 6147 35 the the DT 19613 6147 36 Asia Asia NNP 19613 6147 37 Minor Minor NNP 19613 6147 38 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 19613 6147 39 and and CC 19613 6147 40 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6147 41 . . . 19613 6148 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6148 2 623 623 CD 19613 6148 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6148 4 But but CC 19613 6148 5 this this DT 19613 6148 6 is be VBZ 19613 6148 7 the the DT 19613 6148 8 clearest clear JJS 19613 6148 9 proof proof NN 19613 6148 10 that that IN 19613 6148 11 all all PDT 19613 6148 12 these these DT 19613 6148 13 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6148 14 were be VBD 19613 6148 15 but but CC 19613 6148 16 half half RB 19613 6148 17 - - HYPH 19613 6148 18 hearted hearted JJ 19613 6148 19 in in IN 19613 6148 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6148 21 theology theology NN 19613 6148 22 , , , 19613 6148 23 which which WDT 19613 6148 24 was be VBD 19613 6148 25 forced force VBN 19613 6148 26 upon upon IN 19613 6148 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6148 28 , , , 19613 6148 29 in in IN 19613 6148 30 defence defence NN 19613 6148 31 of of IN 19613 6148 32 the the DT 19613 6148 33 traditional traditional JJ 19613 6148 34 faith faith NN 19613 6148 35 , , , 19613 6148 36 by by IN 19613 6148 37 the the DT 19613 6148 38 historical historical JJ 19613 6148 39 situation situation NN 19613 6148 40 in in IN 19613 6148 41 which which WDT 19613 6148 42 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6148 43 found find VBD 19613 6148 44 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6148 45 . . . 19613 6149 1 The the DT 19613 6149 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6149 3 , , , 19613 6149 4 who who WP 19613 6149 5 will will MD 19613 6149 6 shortly shortly RB 19613 6149 7 come come VB 19613 6149 8 to to TO 19613 6149 9 overcome overcome VB 19613 6149 10 Antichrist antichrist NN 19613 6149 11 , , , 19613 6149 12 overthrow overthrow VB 19613 6149 13 the the DT 19613 6149 14 Roman roman JJ 19613 6149 15 empire empire NN 19613 6149 16 , , , 19613 6149 17 establish establish VB 19613 6149 18 in in IN 19613 6149 19 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 6149 20 a a DT 19613 6149 21 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6149 22 of of IN 19613 6149 23 glory glory NN 19613 6149 24 , , , 19613 6149 25 and and CC 19613 6149 26 feed feed VB 19613 6149 27 believers believer NNS 19613 6149 28 with with IN 19613 6149 29 the the DT 19613 6149 30 fat fat NN 19613 6149 31 of of IN 19613 6149 32 a a DT 19613 6149 33 miraculously miraculously RB 19613 6149 34 fruitful fruitful JJ 19613 6149 35 earth earth NN 19613 6149 36 , , , 19613 6149 37 is be VBZ 19613 6149 38 in in IN 19613 6149 39 fact fact NN 19613 6149 40 a a DT 19613 6149 41 quite quite RB 19613 6149 42 different different JJ 19613 6149 43 being being NN 19613 6149 44 from from IN 19613 6149 45 the the DT 19613 6149 46 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6149 47 who who WP 19613 6149 48 , , , 19613 6149 49 as as IN 19613 6149 50 the the DT 19613 6149 51 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 6149 52 God God NNP 19613 6149 53 , , , 19613 6149 54 has have VBZ 19613 6149 55 already already RB 19613 6149 56 virtually virtually RB 19613 6149 57 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 6149 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6149 59 work work NN 19613 6149 60 of of IN 19613 6149 61 imparting impart VBG 19613 6149 62 perfect perfect JJ 19613 6149 63 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6149 64 and and CC 19613 6149 65 filling fill VBG 19613 6149 66 mankind mankind NN 19613 6149 67 with with IN 19613 6149 68 divine divine JJ 19613 6149 69 life life NN 19613 6149 70 and and CC 19613 6149 71 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 6149 72 . . . 19613 6150 1 The the DT 19613 6150 2 fact fact NN 19613 6150 3 that that IN 19613 6150 4 the the DT 19613 6150 5 old old JJ 19613 6150 6 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6150 7 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 6150 8 have have VBP 19613 6150 9 both both DT 19613 6150 10 Christs Christs NNPS 19613 6150 11 shows show VBZ 19613 6150 12 more more RBR 19613 6150 13 clearly clearly RB 19613 6150 14 than than IN 19613 6150 15 any any DT 19613 6150 16 other other JJ 19613 6150 17 the the DT 19613 6150 18 middle middle JJ 19613 6150 19 position position NN 19613 6150 20 that that WDT 19613 6150 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6150 22 occupy occupy VBP 19613 6150 23 between between IN 19613 6150 24 the the DT 19613 6150 25 acutely acutely RB 19613 6150 26 hellenised hellenise VBN 19613 6150 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6150 28 of of IN 19613 6150 29 the the DT 19613 6150 30 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6150 31 , , , 19613 6150 32 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6150 33 , , , 19613 6150 34 the the DT 19613 6150 35 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6150 36 , , , 19613 6150 37 and and CC 19613 6150 38 the the DT 19613 6150 39 old old JJ 19613 6150 40 tradition tradition NN 19613 6150 41 of of IN 19613 6150 42 the the DT 19613 6150 43 Church Church NNP 19613 6150 44 . . . 19613 6151 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6151 2 have have VBP 19613 6151 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 6151 4 seen see VBN 19613 6151 5 that that IN 19613 6151 6 the the DT 19613 6151 7 twofold twofold JJ 19613 6151 8 conception conception NN 19613 6151 9 of of IN 19613 6151 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6151 11 and and CC 19613 6151 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6151 13 work work NN 19613 6151 14 dates date VBZ 19613 6151 15 back back RB 19613 6151 16 to to IN 19613 6151 17 the the DT 19613 6151 18 time time NN 19613 6151 19 of of IN 19613 6151 20 the the DT 19613 6151 21 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 6151 22 , , , 19613 6151 23 for for IN 19613 6151 24 there there EX 19613 6151 25 is be VBZ 19613 6151 26 a a DT 19613 6151 27 vast vast JJ 19613 6151 28 difference difference NN 19613 6151 29 between between IN 19613 6151 30 the the DT 19613 6151 31 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6151 32 of of IN 19613 6151 33 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6151 34 and and CC 19613 6151 35 the the DT 19613 6151 36 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6151 37 of of IN 19613 6151 38 the the DT 19613 6151 39 supposedly supposedly RB 19613 6151 40 inspired inspire VBN 19613 6151 41 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6151 42 Apocalypses apocalypse NNS 19613 6151 43 ; ; : 19613 6151 44 and and CC 19613 6151 45 also also RB 19613 6151 46 that that IN 19613 6151 47 the the DT 19613 6151 48 agency agency NN 19613 6151 49 in in IN 19613 6151 50 producing produce VBG 19613 6151 51 this this DT 19613 6151 52 conjunction conjunction NN 19613 6151 53 may may MD 19613 6151 54 be be VB 19613 6151 55 traced trace VBN 19613 6151 56 back back RB 19613 6151 57 to to IN 19613 6151 58 the the DT 19613 6151 59 oldest old JJS 19613 6151 60 time time NN 19613 6151 61 ; ; : 19613 6151 62 but but CC 19613 6151 63 the the DT 19613 6151 64 union union NN 19613 6151 65 of of IN 19613 6151 66 a a DT 19613 6151 67 precise precise JJ 19613 6151 68 Christological Christological NNP 19613 6151 69 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 6151 70 , , , 19613 6151 71 such such JJ 19613 6151 72 as as IN 19613 6151 73 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6151 74 find find VBP 19613 6151 75 in in IN 19613 6151 76 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6151 77 and and CC 19613 6151 78 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6151 79 , , , 19613 6151 80 with with IN 19613 6151 81 the the DT 19613 6151 82 retention retention NN 19613 6151 83 in in IN 19613 6151 84 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6151 85 integrity integrity NN 19613 6151 86 of of IN 19613 6151 87 the the DT 19613 6151 88 imaginative imaginative JJ 19613 6151 89 series series NN 19613 6151 90 of of IN 19613 6151 91 thoughts thought NNS 19613 6151 92 about about IN 19613 6151 93 Antichrist Antichrist NNP 19613 6151 94 , , , 19613 6151 95 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6151 96 as as IN 19613 6151 97 the the DT 19613 6151 98 warrior warrior NN 19613 6151 99 hero hero NN 19613 6151 100 , , , 19613 6151 101 the the DT 19613 6151 102 double double JJ 19613 6151 103 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 6151 104 , , , 19613 6151 105 and and CC 19613 6151 106 the the DT 19613 6151 107 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6151 108 of of IN 19613 6151 109 glory glory NN 19613 6151 110 in in IN 19613 6151 111 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 6151 112 , , , 19613 6151 113 is be VBZ 19613 6151 114 really really RB 19613 6151 115 a a DT 19613 6151 116 historical historical JJ 19613 6151 117 novelty novelty NN 19613 6151 118 . . . 19613 6152 1 There there EX 19613 6152 2 is be VBZ 19613 6152 3 , , , 19613 6152 4 however however RB 19613 6152 5 , , , 19613 6152 6 no no RB 19613 6152 7 doubt doubt RB 19613 6152 8 that that IN 19613 6152 9 the the DT 19613 6152 10 strength strength NN 19613 6152 11 of of IN 19613 6152 12 the the DT 19613 6152 13 old old JJ 19613 6152 14 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6152 15 theology theology NN 19613 6152 16 in in IN 19613 6152 17 opposition opposition NN 19613 6152 18 to to IN 19613 6152 19 the the DT 19613 6152 20 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6152 21 lies lie VBZ 19613 6152 22 in in IN 19613 6152 23 the the DT 19613 6152 24 accomplishment accomplishment NN 19613 6152 25 of of IN 19613 6152 26 this this DT 19613 6152 27 union union NN 19613 6152 28 , , , 19613 6152 29 which which WDT 19613 6152 30 , , , 19613 6152 31 on on IN 19613 6152 32 the the DT 19613 6152 33 basis basis NN 19613 6152 34 of of IN 19613 6152 35 the the DT 19613 6152 36 New New NNP 19613 6152 37 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6152 38 , , , 19613 6152 39 appeared appear VBD 19613 6152 40 to to IN 19613 6152 41 the the DT 19613 6152 42 Fathers father NNS 19613 6152 43 possible possible JJ 19613 6152 44 and and CC 19613 6152 45 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6152 46 . . . 19613 6153 1 For for IN 19613 6153 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6153 3 is be VBZ 19613 6153 4 not not RB 19613 6153 5 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6153 6 consistency consistency NN 19613 6153 7 that that WDT 19613 6153 8 secures secure VBZ 19613 6153 9 the the DT 19613 6153 10 future future NN 19613 6153 11 of of IN 19613 6153 12 a a DT 19613 6153 13 religious religious JJ 19613 6153 14 conception conception NN 19613 6153 15 within within IN 19613 6153 16 a a DT 19613 6153 17 church church NN 19613 6153 18 , , , 19613 6153 19 but but CC 19613 6153 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6153 21 elasticity elasticity NN 19613 6153 22 , , , 19613 6153 23 and and CC 19613 6153 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6153 25 richness richness NN 19613 6153 26 in in IN 19613 6153 27 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 19613 6153 28 trains train NNS 19613 6153 29 of of IN 19613 6153 30 thought thought NN 19613 6153 31 . . . 19613 6154 1 But but CC 19613 6154 2 no no DT 19613 6154 3 doubt doubt RB 19613 6154 4 this this DT 19613 6154 5 must must MD 19613 6154 6 be be VB 19613 6154 7 accompanied accompany VBN 19613 6154 8 by by IN 19613 6154 9 a a DT 19613 6154 10 firm firm JJ 19613 6154 11 foundation foundation NN 19613 6154 12 , , , 19613 6154 13 and and CC 19613 6154 14 this this DT 19613 6154 15 too too RB 19613 6154 16 the the DT 19613 6154 17 old old JJ 19613 6154 18 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6154 19 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 6154 20 possessed possess VBD 19613 6154 21 -- -- : 19613 6154 22 the the DT 19613 6154 23 church church NN 19613 6154 24 system system NN 19613 6154 25 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6154 26 . . . 19613 6155 1 As as IN 19613 6155 2 regards regard VBZ 19613 6155 3 the the DT 19613 6155 4 details detail NNS 19613 6155 5 of of IN 19613 6155 6 the the DT 19613 6155 7 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 6155 8 hopes hope NNS 19613 6155 9 , , , 19613 6155 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6155 11 were be VBD 19613 6155 12 fully fully RB 19613 6155 13 set set VBN 19613 6155 14 forth forth RP 19613 6155 15 by by IN 19613 6155 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6155 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6155 18 in in IN 19613 6155 19 Book Book NNP 19613 6155 20 V. V. NNP 19613 6155 21 Apart apart RB 19613 6155 22 from from IN 19613 6155 23 the the DT 19613 6155 24 belief belief NN 19613 6155 25 that that IN 19613 6155 26 the the DT 19613 6155 27 returning return VBG 19613 6155 28 Nero Nero NNP 19613 6155 29 would would MD 19613 6155 30 be be VB 19613 6155 31 the the DT 19613 6155 32 Antichrist Antichrist NNP 19613 6155 33 , , , 19613 6155 34 an an DT 19613 6155 35 idea idea NN 19613 6155 36 spread spread VBD 19613 6155 37 in in IN 19613 6155 38 the the DT 19613 6155 39 West West NNP 19613 6155 40 during during IN 19613 6155 41 the the DT 19613 6155 42 third third JJ 19613 6155 43 century century NN 19613 6155 44 by by IN 19613 6155 45 the the DT 19613 6155 46 Sibylline Sibylline NNP 19613 6155 47 verses verse NNS 19613 6155 48 and and CC 19613 6155 49 proved prove VBD 19613 6155 50 from from IN 19613 6155 51 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 6155 52 , , , 19613 6155 53 the the DT 19613 6155 54 later later JJ 19613 6155 55 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6155 56 who who WP 19613 6155 57 preached preach VBD 19613 6155 58 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 6155 59 hopes hope NNS 19613 6155 60 did do VBD 19613 6155 61 not not RB 19613 6155 62 seriously seriously RB 19613 6155 63 differ differ VB 19613 6155 64 from from IN 19613 6155 65 the the DT 19613 6155 66 Gallic Gallic NNP 19613 6155 67 bishop bishop NN 19613 6155 68 ; ; : 19613 6155 69 hence hence RB 19613 6155 70 the the DT 19613 6155 71 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6155 72 of of IN 19613 6155 73 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 6155 74 is be VBZ 19613 6155 75 in in IN 19613 6155 76 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6155 77 main main JJ 19613 6155 78 features feature NNS 19613 6155 79 the the DT 19613 6155 80 same same JJ 19613 6155 81 . . . 19613 6156 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6156 2 is be VBZ 19613 6156 3 enough enough RB 19613 6156 4 therefore therefore RB 19613 6156 5 to to TO 19613 6156 6 refer refer VB 19613 6156 7 to to IN 19613 6156 8 the the DT 19613 6156 9 fifth fifth JJ 19613 6156 10 Book Book NNP 19613 6156 11 of of IN 19613 6156 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6156 13 . . . 19613 6157 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6157 2 624 624 CD 19613 6157 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6157 4 There there EX 19613 6157 5 is be VBZ 19613 6157 6 no no DT 19613 6157 7 need need NN 19613 6157 8 to to TO 19613 6157 9 show show VB 19613 6157 10 in in IN 19613 6157 11 detail detail NN 19613 6157 12 that that IN 19613 6157 13 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6157 14 leads lead VBZ 19613 6157 15 to to IN 19613 6157 16 a a DT 19613 6157 17 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 6157 18 view view NN 19613 6157 19 of of IN 19613 6157 20 history history NN 19613 6157 21 , , , 19613 6157 22 which which WDT 19613 6157 23 is be VBZ 19613 6157 24 as as RB 19613 6157 25 much much RB 19613 6157 26 opposed opposed JJ 19613 6157 27 to to IN 19613 6157 28 that that DT 19613 6157 29 resulting result VBG 19613 6157 30 from from IN 19613 6157 31 the the DT 19613 6157 32 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6157 33 theory theory NN 19613 6157 34 of of IN 19613 6157 35 redemption redemption NN 19613 6157 36 , , , 19613 6157 37 as as IN 19613 6157 38 this this DT 19613 6157 39 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6157 40 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6157 41 forbids forbid VBZ 19613 6157 42 the the DT 19613 6157 43 hope hope NN 19613 6157 44 of of IN 19613 6157 45 a a DT 19613 6157 46 bliss bliss NN 19613 6157 47 to to TO 19613 6157 48 be be VB 19613 6157 49 realised realise VBN 19613 6157 50 in in IN 19613 6157 51 an an DT 19613 6157 52 earthly earthly JJ 19613 6157 53 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6157 54 of of IN 19613 6157 55 glory glory NN 19613 6157 56 . . . 19613 6158 1 This this DT 19613 6158 2 is be VBZ 19613 6158 3 not not RB 19613 6158 4 the the DT 19613 6158 5 proper proper JJ 19613 6158 6 place place NN 19613 6158 7 to to TO 19613 6158 8 demonstrate demonstrate VB 19613 6158 9 to to IN 19613 6158 10 what what WDT 19613 6158 11 extent extent NN 19613 6158 12 the the DT 19613 6158 13 two two CD 19613 6158 14 have have VBP 19613 6158 15 been be VBN 19613 6158 16 blended blend VBN 19613 6158 17 , , , 19613 6158 18 and and CC 19613 6158 19 how how WRB 19613 6158 20 the the DT 19613 6158 21 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 6158 22 scheme scheme NN 19613 6158 23 of of IN 19613 6158 24 history history NN 19613 6158 25 has have VBZ 19613 6158 26 been be VBN 19613 6158 27 emptied empty VBN 19613 6158 28 of of IN 19613 6158 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6158 30 content content NN 19613 6158 31 and and CC 19613 6158 32 utilised utilise VBN 19613 6158 33 in in IN 19613 6158 34 the the DT 19613 6158 35 service service NN 19613 6158 36 of of IN 19613 6158 37 theological theological JJ 19613 6158 38 apologetics apologetic NNS 19613 6158 39 . . . 19613 6159 1 But but CC 19613 6159 2 the the DT 19613 6159 3 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6159 4 were be VBD 19613 6159 5 not not RB 19613 6159 6 the the DT 19613 6159 7 only only JJ 19613 6159 8 opponents opponent NNS 19613 6159 9 of of IN 19613 6159 10 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6159 11 . . . 19613 6160 1 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6160 2 , , , 19613 6160 3 even even RB 19613 6160 4 in in IN 19613 6160 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6160 6 time time NN 19613 6160 7 , , , 19613 6160 8 knew know VBD 19613 6160 9 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 6160 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 6160 11 who who WP 19613 6160 12 refused refuse VBD 19613 6160 13 to to TO 19613 6160 14 believe believe VB 19613 6160 15 in in IN 19613 6160 16 an an DT 19613 6160 17 earthly earthly JJ 19613 6160 18 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6160 19 of of IN 19613 6160 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6160 21 in in IN 19613 6160 22 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 6160 23 , , , 19613 6160 24 and and CC 19613 6160 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6160 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6160 27 V. V. NNP 19613 6160 28 33 33 CD 19613 6160 29 ff ff NN 19613 6160 30 . . . 19613 6161 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6161 2 , , , 19613 6161 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6161 4 , , , 19613 6161 5 and and CC 19613 6161 6 Hippolytus[625 hippolytus[625 NN 19613 6161 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6161 8 expressly expressly RB 19613 6161 9 argued argue VBN 19613 6161 10 against against IN 19613 6161 11 these these DT 19613 6161 12 . . . 19613 6162 1 Soon soon RB 19613 6162 2 after after IN 19613 6162 3 the the DT 19613 6162 4 middle middle NN 19613 6162 5 of of IN 19613 6162 6 the the DT 19613 6162 7 second second JJ 19613 6162 8 century century NN 19613 6162 9 , , , 19613 6162 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6162 11 hear hear VBP 19613 6162 12 of of IN 19613 6162 13 an an DT 19613 6162 14 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6162 15 party party NN 19613 6162 16 in in IN 19613 6162 17 Asia Asia NNP 19613 6162 18 Minor Minor NNP 19613 6162 19 , , , 19613 6162 20 which which WDT 19613 6162 21 not not RB 19613 6162 22 only only RB 19613 6162 23 repudiated repudiate VBD 19613 6162 24 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6162 25 , , , 19613 6162 26 but but CC 19613 6162 27 also also RB 19613 6162 28 rejected reject VBD 19613 6162 29 the the DT 19613 6162 30 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 6162 31 of of IN 19613 6162 32 John John NNP 19613 6162 33 as as IN 19613 6162 34 an an DT 19613 6162 35 untrustworthy untrustworthy JJ 19613 6162 36 book book NN 19613 6162 37 , , , 19613 6162 38 and and CC 19613 6162 39 subjected subject VBD 19613 6162 40 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6162 41 to to IN 19613 6162 42 sharp sharp JJ 19613 6162 43 criticism criticism NN 19613 6162 44 . . . 19613 6163 1 These these DT 19613 6163 2 were be VBD 19613 6163 3 the the DT 19613 6163 4 so so RB 19613 6163 5 - - HYPH 19613 6163 6 called call VBN 19613 6163 7 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 6163 8 . . . 19613 6164 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6164 2 626 626 CD 19613 6164 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6164 4 But but CC 19613 6164 5 in in IN 19613 6164 6 the the DT 19613 6164 7 second second JJ 19613 6164 8 century century NN 19613 6164 9 such such JJ 19613 6164 10 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 6164 11 were be VBD 19613 6164 12 still still RB 19613 6164 13 in in IN 19613 6164 14 the the DT 19613 6164 15 minority minority NN 19613 6164 16 in in IN 19613 6164 17 the the DT 19613 6164 18 Church Church NNP 19613 6164 19 . . . 19613 6165 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6165 2 was be VBD 19613 6165 3 only only RB 19613 6165 4 in in IN 19613 6165 5 the the DT 19613 6165 6 course course NN 19613 6165 7 of of IN 19613 6165 8 the the DT 19613 6165 9 third third JJ 19613 6165 10 century century NN 19613 6165 11 that that WDT 19613 6165 12 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6165 13 was be VBD 19613 6165 14 almost almost RB 19613 6165 15 completely completely RB 19613 6165 16 ousted oust VBN 19613 6165 17 in in IN 19613 6165 18 the the DT 19613 6165 19 East East NNP 19613 6165 20 . . . 19613 6166 1 This this DT 19613 6166 2 was be VBD 19613 6166 3 the the DT 19613 6166 4 result result NN 19613 6166 5 of of IN 19613 6166 6 the the DT 19613 6166 7 Montanistic montanistic JJ 19613 6166 8 controversy controversy NN 19613 6166 9 and and CC 19613 6166 10 the the DT 19613 6166 11 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 6166 12 theology theology NN 19613 6166 13 . . . 19613 6167 1 In in IN 19613 6167 2 the the DT 19613 6167 3 West West NNP 19613 6167 4 , , , 19613 6167 5 however however RB 19613 6167 6 , , , 19613 6167 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6167 8 was be VBD 19613 6167 9 only only RB 19613 6167 10 threatened threaten VBN 19613 6167 11 . . . 19613 6168 1 In in IN 19613 6168 2 this this DT 19613 6168 3 Church Church NNP 19613 6168 4 the the DT 19613 6168 5 first first JJ 19613 6168 6 literary literary JJ 19613 6168 7 opponent opponent NN 19613 6168 8 of of IN 19613 6168 9 chiliasm chiliasm NNP 19613 6168 10 and and CC 19613 6168 11 of of IN 19613 6168 12 the the DT 19613 6168 13 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 6168 14 appears appear VBZ 19613 6168 15 to to TO 19613 6168 16 have have VB 19613 6168 17 been be VBN 19613 6168 18 the the DT 19613 6168 19 Roman Roman NNP 19613 6168 20 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 19613 6168 21 Caius Caius NNP 19613 6168 22 . . . 19613 6169 1 But but CC 19613 6169 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6169 3 polemic polemic NN 19613 6169 4 did do VBD 19613 6169 5 not not RB 19613 6169 6 prevail prevail VB 19613 6169 7 . . . 19613 6170 1 On on IN 19613 6170 2 the the DT 19613 6170 3 other other JJ 19613 6170 4 hand hand NN 19613 6170 5 the the DT 19613 6170 6 learned learn VBN 19613 6170 7 bishops bishop NNS 19613 6170 8 of of IN 19613 6170 9 the the DT 19613 6170 10 East East NNP 19613 6170 11 in in IN 19613 6170 12 the the DT 19613 6170 13 third third JJ 19613 6170 14 century century NN 19613 6170 15 used use VBD 19613 6170 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6170 17 utmost utmost JJ 19613 6170 18 efforts effort NNS 19613 6170 19 to to TO 19613 6170 20 combat combat VB 19613 6170 21 and and CC 19613 6170 22 extirpate extirpate NNP 19613 6170 23 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6170 24 . . . 19613 6171 1 The the DT 19613 6171 2 information information NN 19613 6171 3 given give VBN 19613 6171 4 to to IN 19613 6171 5 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6171 6 by by IN 19613 6171 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 6171 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6171 9 H. H. NNP 19613 6171 10 E. E. NNP 19613 6171 11 VII VII NNP 19613 6171 12 . . . 19613 6172 1 24 24 CD 19613 6172 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6172 3 , , , 19613 6172 4 from from IN 19613 6172 5 the the DT 19613 6172 6 letters letter NNS 19613 6172 7 of of IN 19613 6172 8 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 6172 9 of of IN 19613 6172 10 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 6172 11 , , , 19613 6172 12 about about IN 19613 6172 13 that that DT 19613 6172 14 father father NN 19613 6172 15 's 's POS 19613 6172 16 struggles struggle NNS 19613 6172 17 with with IN 19613 6172 18 whole whole JJ 19613 6172 19 communities community NNS 19613 6172 20 in in IN 19613 6172 21 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 6172 22 , , , 19613 6172 23 who who WP 19613 6172 24 would would MD 19613 6172 25 not not RB 19613 6172 26 give give VB 19613 6172 27 up up RP 19613 6172 28 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6172 29 , , , 19613 6172 30 is be VBZ 19613 6172 31 of of IN 19613 6172 32 the the DT 19613 6172 33 highest high JJS 19613 6172 34 interest interest NN 19613 6172 35 . . . 19613 6173 1 This this DT 19613 6173 2 account account NN 19613 6173 3 shews shew VBZ 19613 6173 4 that that IN 19613 6173 5 wherever wherever WRB 19613 6173 6 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 6173 7 theology theology NN 19613 6173 8 had have VBD 19613 6173 9 not not RB 19613 6173 10 yet yet RB 19613 6173 11 made make VBN 19613 6173 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6173 13 way way NN 19613 6173 14 the the DT 19613 6173 15 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 6173 16 hopes hope NNS 19613 6173 17 were be VBD 19613 6173 18 not not RB 19613 6173 19 only only RB 19613 6173 20 cherished cherish VBN 19613 6173 21 and and CC 19613 6173 22 defended defend VBN 19613 6173 23 against against IN 19613 6173 24 being be VBG 19613 6173 25 explained explain VBN 19613 6173 26 away away RB 19613 6173 27 , , , 19613 6173 28 but but CC 19613 6173 29 were be VBD 19613 6173 30 emphatically emphatically RB 19613 6173 31 regarded regard VBN 19613 6173 32 as as IN 19613 6173 33 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6173 34 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6173 35 . . . 19613 6174 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6174 2 627 627 CD 19613 6174 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6174 4 Cultured cultured JJ 19613 6174 5 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6174 6 were be VBD 19613 6174 7 able able JJ 19613 6174 8 to to TO 19613 6174 9 achieve achieve VB 19613 6174 10 the the DT 19613 6174 11 union union NN 19613 6174 12 of of IN 19613 6174 13 chiliasm chiliasm NNP 19613 6174 14 and and CC 19613 6174 15 religious religious JJ 19613 6174 16 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 6174 17 ; ; : 19613 6174 18 but but CC 19613 6174 19 the the DT 19613 6174 20 " " `` 19613 6174 21 simplices simplice NNS 19613 6174 22 et et NNP 19613 6174 23 idiotæ idiotæ NNP 19613 6174 24 " " `` 19613 6174 25 could could MD 19613 6174 26 only only RB 19613 6174 27 understand understand VB 19613 6174 28 the the DT 19613 6174 29 former former JJ 19613 6174 30 . . . 19613 6175 1 As as IN 19613 6175 2 the the DT 19613 6175 3 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 6175 4 hopes hope NNS 19613 6175 5 were be VBD 19613 6175 6 gradually gradually RB 19613 6175 7 obliged oblige VBN 19613 6175 8 to to IN 19613 6175 9 recede recede NNS 19613 6175 10 in in IN 19613 6175 11 exactly exactly RB 19613 6175 12 the the DT 19613 6175 13 same same JJ 19613 6175 14 proportion proportion NN 19613 6175 15 as as IN 19613 6175 16 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 6175 17 theology theology NN 19613 6175 18 became become VBD 19613 6175 19 naturalised naturalised JJ 19613 6175 20 , , , 19613 6175 21 so so RB 19613 6175 22 also also RB 19613 6175 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6175 24 subsidence subsidence NN 19613 6175 25 denotes denote VBZ 19613 6175 26 the the DT 19613 6175 27 progressive progressive JJ 19613 6175 28 tutelage tutelage NN 19613 6175 29 of of IN 19613 6175 30 the the DT 19613 6175 31 laity laity NN 19613 6175 32 . . . 19613 6176 1 The the DT 19613 6176 2 religion religion NN 19613 6176 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6176 4 understood understand VBD 19613 6176 5 was be VBD 19613 6176 6 taken take VBN 19613 6176 7 from from IN 19613 6176 8 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6176 9 , , , 19613 6176 10 and and CC 19613 6176 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6176 12 received receive VBD 19613 6176 13 in in IN 19613 6176 14 return return NN 19613 6176 15 a a DT 19613 6176 16 faith faith NN 19613 6176 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6176 18 could could MD 19613 6176 19 not not RB 19613 6176 20 understand understand VB 19613 6176 21 ; ; : 19613 6176 22 in in IN 19613 6176 23 other other JJ 19613 6176 24 words word NNS 19613 6176 25 , , , 19613 6176 26 the the DT 19613 6176 27 old old JJ 19613 6176 28 faith faith NN 19613 6176 29 and and CC 19613 6176 30 the the DT 19613 6176 31 old old JJ 19613 6176 32 hopes hope NNS 19613 6176 33 decayed decay VBD 19613 6176 34 of of IN 19613 6176 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6176 36 and and CC 19613 6176 37 the the DT 19613 6176 38 _ _ NNP 19613 6176 39 authority authority NN 19613 6176 40 _ _ NNP 19613 6176 41 of of IN 19613 6176 42 a a DT 19613 6176 43 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 6176 44 faith faith NN 19613 6176 45 took take VBD 19613 6176 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6176 47 place place NN 19613 6176 48 . . . 19613 6177 1 In in IN 19613 6177 2 this this DT 19613 6177 3 sense sense NN 19613 6177 4 the the DT 19613 6177 5 extirpation extirpation NN 19613 6177 6 or or CC 19613 6177 7 decay decay NN 19613 6177 8 of of IN 19613 6177 9 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6177 10 is be VBZ 19613 6177 11 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 6177 12 the the DT 19613 6177 13 most most RBS 19613 6177 14 momentous momentous JJ 19613 6177 15 fact fact NN 19613 6177 16 in in IN 19613 6177 17 the the DT 19613 6177 18 history history NN 19613 6177 19 of of IN 19613 6177 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6177 21 in in IN 19613 6177 22 the the DT 19613 6177 23 East East NNP 19613 6177 24 . . . 19613 6178 1 With with IN 19613 6178 2 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6178 3 men man NNS 19613 6178 4 also also RB 19613 6178 5 lost lose VBD 19613 6178 6 the the DT 19613 6178 7 living live VBG 19613 6178 8 faith faith NN 19613 6178 9 in in IN 19613 6178 10 the the DT 19613 6178 11 nearly nearly RB 19613 6178 12 impending impend VBG 19613 6178 13 return return NN 19613 6178 14 of of IN 19613 6178 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6178 16 , , , 19613 6178 17 and and CC 19613 6178 18 the the DT 19613 6178 19 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 6178 20 that that WDT 19613 6178 21 the the DT 19613 6178 22 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 6178 23 spirit spirit NN 19613 6178 24 with with IN 19613 6178 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6178 26 gifts gift NNS 19613 6178 27 is be VBZ 19613 6178 28 a a DT 19613 6178 29 real real JJ 19613 6178 30 possession possession NN 19613 6178 31 of of IN 19613 6178 32 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 6178 33 . . . 19613 6179 1 Such such JJ 19613 6179 2 of of IN 19613 6179 3 the the DT 19613 6179 4 old old JJ 19613 6179 5 hopes hope NNS 19613 6179 6 as as IN 19613 6179 7 remained remain VBN 19613 6179 8 were be VBD 19613 6179 9 at at IN 19613 6179 10 most most RBS 19613 6179 11 particoloured particoloure VBN 19613 6179 12 harmless harmless JJ 19613 6179 13 fancies fancy NNS 19613 6179 14 which which WDT 19613 6179 15 , , , 19613 6179 16 when when WRB 19613 6179 17 allowed allow VBN 19613 6179 18 by by IN 19613 6179 19 theology theology NN 19613 6179 20 , , , 19613 6179 21 were be VBD 19613 6179 22 permitted permit VBN 19613 6179 23 to to TO 19613 6179 24 be be VB 19613 6179 25 added add VBN 19613 6179 26 to to IN 19613 6179 27 dogmatics dogmatic NNS 19613 6179 28 . . . 19613 6180 1 In in IN 19613 6180 2 the the DT 19613 6180 3 West West NNP 19613 6180 4 , , , 19613 6180 5 on on IN 19613 6180 6 the the DT 19613 6180 7 contrary contrary NN 19613 6180 8 , , , 19613 6180 9 the the DT 19613 6180 10 millennial millennial JJ 19613 6180 11 hopes hope NNS 19613 6180 12 retained retain VBD 19613 6180 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6180 14 vigour vigour NN 19613 6180 15 during during IN 19613 6180 16 the the DT 19613 6180 17 whole whole JJ 19613 6180 18 third third JJ 19613 6180 19 century century NN 19613 6180 20 ; ; : 19613 6180 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6180 22 know know VBP 19613 6180 23 of of IN 19613 6180 24 no no DT 19613 6180 25 bishop bishop NN 19613 6180 26 there there RB 19613 6180 27 who who WP 19613 6180 28 would would MD 19613 6180 29 have have VB 19613 6180 30 opposed oppose VBN 19613 6180 31 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 6180 32 . . . 19613 6181 1 With with IN 19613 6181 2 this this DT 19613 6181 3 , , , 19613 6181 4 however however RB 19613 6181 5 , , , 19613 6181 6 was be VBD 19613 6181 7 preserved preserve VBN 19613 6181 8 a a DT 19613 6181 9 portion portion NN 19613 6181 10 of of IN 19613 6181 11 the the DT 19613 6181 12 earliest early JJS 19613 6181 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6181 14 which which WDT 19613 6181 15 was be VBD 19613 6181 16 to to TO 19613 6181 17 exercise exercise VB 19613 6181 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6181 19 effects effect NNS 19613 6181 20 far far RB 19613 6181 21 beyond beyond IN 19613 6181 22 the the DT 19613 6181 23 time time NN 19613 6181 24 of of IN 19613 6181 25 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 6181 26 . . . 19613 6182 1 Finally finally RB 19613 6182 2 , , , 19613 6182 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6182 4 have have VBP 19613 6182 5 still still RB 19613 6182 6 to to TO 19613 6182 7 treat treat VB 19613 6182 8 of of IN 19613 6182 9 the the DT 19613 6182 10 altered altered JJ 19613 6182 11 conceptions conception NNS 19613 6182 12 regarding regard VBG 19613 6182 13 the the DT 19613 6182 14 Old Old NNP 19613 6182 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6182 16 which which WDT 19613 6182 17 the the DT 19613 6182 18 creation creation NN 19613 6182 19 of of IN 19613 6182 20 the the DT 19613 6182 21 New New NNP 19613 6182 22 produced produce VBN 19613 6182 23 among among IN 19613 6182 24 the the DT 19613 6182 25 early early JJ 19613 6182 26 - - HYPH 19613 6182 27 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6182 28 Fathers father NNS 19613 6182 29 . . . 19613 6183 1 In in IN 19613 6183 2 the the DT 19613 6183 3 case case NN 19613 6183 4 of of IN 19613 6183 5 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 6183 6 and and CC 19613 6183 7 the the DT 19613 6183 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 6183 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6183 10 became become VBD 19613 6183 11 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 6183 12 with with IN 19613 6183 13 a a DT 19613 6183 14 theory theory NN 19613 6183 15 of of IN 19613 6183 16 the the DT 19613 6183 17 Old Old NNP 19613 6183 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6183 19 which which WDT 19613 6183 20 represented represent VBD 19613 6183 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6183 22 as as IN 19613 6183 23 the the DT 19613 6183 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 6183 25 book book NN 19613 6183 26 of of IN 19613 6183 27 revelation revelation NN 19613 6183 28 and and CC 19613 6183 29 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 6183 30 subjected subject VBD 19613 6183 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6183 32 throughout throughout RP 19613 6183 33 to to IN 19613 6183 34 an an DT 19613 6183 35 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 6183 36 process process NN 19613 6183 37 . . . 19613 6184 1 Here here RB 19613 6184 2 nothing nothing NN 19613 6184 3 specifically specifically RB 19613 6184 4 new new JJ 19613 6184 5 could could MD 19613 6184 6 be be VB 19613 6184 7 pointed point VBN 19613 6184 8 out out RP 19613 6184 9 as as IN 19613 6184 10 having have VBG 19613 6184 11 been be VBN 19613 6184 12 brought bring VBN 19613 6184 13 by by IN 19613 6184 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6184 15 . . . 19613 6185 1 Sharply sharply RB 19613 6185 2 opposed opposed JJ 19613 6185 3 to to IN 19613 6185 4 this this DT 19613 6185 5 conception conception NN 19613 6185 6 was be VBD 19613 6185 7 that that DT 19613 6185 8 of of IN 19613 6185 9 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6185 10 , , , 19613 6185 11 according accord VBG 19613 6185 12 to to IN 19613 6185 13 which which WDT 19613 6185 14 the the DT 19613 6185 15 whole whole JJ 19613 6185 16 Old Old NNP 19613 6185 17 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6185 18 was be VBD 19613 6185 19 regarded regard VBN 19613 6185 20 as as IN 19613 6185 21 the the DT 19613 6185 22 proclamation proclamation NN 19613 6185 23 of of IN 19613 6185 24 a a DT 19613 6185 25 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6185 26 God God NNP 19613 6185 27 hostile hostile JJ 19613 6185 28 to to IN 19613 6185 29 the the DT 19613 6185 30 God God NNP 19613 6185 31 of of IN 19613 6185 32 redemption redemption NN 19613 6185 33 . . . 19613 6186 1 The the DT 19613 6186 2 views view NNS 19613 6186 3 of of IN 19613 6186 4 the the DT 19613 6186 5 majority majority NN 19613 6186 6 of of IN 19613 6186 7 the the DT 19613 6186 8 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6186 9 occupied occupy VBD 19613 6186 10 a a DT 19613 6186 11 middle middle JJ 19613 6186 12 position position NN 19613 6186 13 between between IN 19613 6186 14 the the DT 19613 6186 15 two two CD 19613 6186 16 notions notion NNS 19613 6186 17 . . . 19613 6187 1 These these DT 19613 6187 2 distinguished distinguish VBD 19613 6187 3 different different JJ 19613 6187 4 components component NNS 19613 6187 5 of of IN 19613 6187 6 the the DT 19613 6187 7 Old Old NNP 19613 6187 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6187 9 , , , 19613 6187 10 some some DT 19613 6187 11 of of IN 19613 6187 12 which which WDT 19613 6187 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6187 14 traced trace VBD 19613 6187 15 to to IN 19613 6187 16 the the DT 19613 6187 17 supreme supreme JJ 19613 6187 18 God God NNP 19613 6187 19 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6187 20 and and CC 19613 6187 21 others other NNS 19613 6187 22 to to TO 19613 6187 23 intermediate intermediate VB 19613 6187 24 and and CC 19613 6187 25 malevolent malevolent JJ 19613 6187 26 beings being NNS 19613 6187 27 . . . 19613 6188 1 In in IN 19613 6188 2 this this DT 19613 6188 3 way way NN 19613 6188 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6188 5 both both DT 19613 6188 6 established establish VBD 19613 6188 7 a a DT 19613 6188 8 connection connection NN 19613 6188 9 between between IN 19613 6188 10 the the DT 19613 6188 11 Old Old NNP 19613 6188 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6188 13 , , , 19613 6188 14 and and CC 19613 6188 15 the the DT 19613 6188 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 6188 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 6188 18 and and CC 19613 6188 19 contrived contrive VBD 19613 6188 20 to to TO 19613 6188 21 show show VB 19613 6188 22 that that IN 19613 6188 23 the the DT 19613 6188 24 latter latter NN 19613 6188 25 contained contain VBD 19613 6188 26 a a DT 19613 6188 27 specific specific JJ 19613 6188 28 novelty novelty NN 19613 6188 29 . . . 19613 6189 1 This this DT 19613 6189 2 historico historico JJ 19613 6189 3 - - HYPH 19613 6189 4 critical critical JJ 19613 6189 5 conception conception NN 19613 6189 6 , , , 19613 6189 7 such such JJ 19613 6189 8 as as IN 19613 6189 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6189 10 specially specially RB 19613 6189 11 see see VBP 19613 6189 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6189 13 in in IN 19613 6189 14 the the DT 19613 6189 15 epistle epistle NN 19613 6189 16 of of IN 19613 6189 17 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 19613 6189 18 to to IN 19613 6189 19 Flora Flora NNP 19613 6189 20 , , , 19613 6189 21 could could MD 19613 6189 22 not not RB 19613 6189 23 be be VB 19613 6189 24 accepted accept VBN 19613 6189 25 by by IN 19613 6189 26 the the DT 19613 6189 27 Church Church NNP 19613 6189 28 because because IN 19613 6189 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6189 30 abolished abolish VBD 19613 6189 31 strict strict JJ 19613 6189 32 monotheism monotheism NN 19613 6189 33 and and CC 19613 6189 34 endangered endanger VBD 19613 6189 35 the the DT 19613 6189 36 proof proof NN 19613 6189 37 from from IN 19613 6189 38 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 6189 39 . . . 19613 6190 1 No no RB 19613 6190 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 6190 3 , , , 19613 6190 4 however however RB 19613 6190 5 , , , 19613 6190 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6190 7 already already RB 19613 6190 8 find find VBP 19613 6190 9 in in IN 19613 6190 10 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6190 11 and and CC 19613 6190 12 others other NNS 19613 6190 13 the the DT 19613 6190 14 beginning beginning NN 19613 6190 15 of of IN 19613 6190 16 a a DT 19613 6190 17 compromise compromise NN 19613 6190 18 , , , 19613 6190 19 in in IN 19613 6190 20 so so RB 19613 6190 21 far far RB 19613 6190 22 as as IN 19613 6190 23 a a DT 19613 6190 24 distinction distinction NN 19613 6190 25 was be VBD 19613 6190 26 made make VBN 19613 6190 27 between between IN 19613 6190 28 the the DT 19613 6190 29 moral moral JJ 19613 6190 30 law law NN 19613 6190 31 of of IN 19613 6190 32 nature nature NN 19613 6190 33 contained contain VBN 19613 6190 34 in in IN 19613 6190 35 the the DT 19613 6190 36 Old Old NNP 19613 6190 37 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6190 38 -- -- : 19613 6190 39 the the DT 19613 6190 40 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 19613 6190 41 -- -- : 19613 6190 42 and and CC 19613 6190 43 the the DT 19613 6190 44 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6190 45 law law NN 19613 6190 46 ; ; : 19613 6190 47 and and CC 19613 6190 48 in in IN 19613 6190 49 so so RB 19613 6190 50 far far RB 19613 6190 51 as as IN 19613 6190 52 the the DT 19613 6190 53 literal literal JJ 19613 6190 54 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6190 55 of of IN 19613 6190 56 the the DT 19613 6190 57 latter latter JJ 19613 6190 58 , , , 19613 6190 59 for for IN 19613 6190 60 which which WDT 19613 6190 61 a a DT 19613 6190 62 pedagogic pedagogic JJ 19613 6190 63 significance significance NN 19613 6190 64 was be VBD 19613 6190 65 claimed claim VBN 19613 6190 66 , , , 19613 6190 67 was be VBD 19613 6190 68 allowed allow VBN 19613 6190 69 in in IN 19613 6190 70 addition addition NN 19613 6190 71 to to IN 19613 6190 72 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6190 73 typical typical JJ 19613 6190 74 or or CC 19613 6190 75 Christian christian JJ 19613 6190 76 sense sense NN 19613 6190 77 . . . 19613 6191 1 With with IN 19613 6191 2 this this DT 19613 6191 3 theory theory NN 19613 6191 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6191 5 was be VBD 19613 6191 6 possible possible JJ 19613 6191 7 , , , 19613 6191 8 on on IN 19613 6191 9 the the DT 19613 6191 10 one one CD 19613 6191 11 hand hand NN 19613 6191 12 , , , 19613 6191 13 to to TO 19613 6191 14 do do VB 19613 6191 15 some some DT 19613 6191 16 sort sort NN 19613 6191 17 of of IN 19613 6191 18 justice justice NN 19613 6191 19 to to IN 19613 6191 20 the the DT 19613 6191 21 historical historical JJ 19613 6191 22 position position NN 19613 6191 23 of of IN 19613 6191 24 the the DT 19613 6191 25 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6191 26 people people NNS 19613 6191 27 , , , 19613 6191 28 and and CC 19613 6191 29 on on IN 19613 6191 30 the the DT 19613 6191 31 other other JJ 19613 6191 32 , , , 19613 6191 33 though though IN 19613 6191 34 indeed indeed RB 19613 6191 35 in in IN 19613 6191 36 a a DT 19613 6191 37 meagre meagre JJ 19613 6191 38 fashion fashion NN 19613 6191 39 , , , 19613 6191 40 to to TO 19613 6191 41 give give VB 19613 6191 42 expression expression NN 19613 6191 43 to to IN 19613 6191 44 the the DT 19613 6191 45 novelty novelty NN 19613 6191 46 of of IN 19613 6191 47 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6191 48 . . . 19613 6192 1 The the DT 19613 6192 2 latter latter NN 19613 6192 3 now now RB 19613 6192 4 appears appear VBZ 19613 6192 5 as as IN 19613 6192 6 the the DT 19613 6192 7 _ _ NNP 19613 6192 8 new new JJ 19613 6192 9 _ _ NNP 19613 6192 10 law law NN 19613 6192 11 or or CC 19613 6192 12 the the DT 19613 6192 13 law law NN 19613 6192 14 of of IN 19613 6192 15 freedom freedom NN 19613 6192 16 , , , 19613 6192 17 in in IN 19613 6192 18 so so RB 19613 6192 19 far far RB 19613 6192 20 as as IN 19613 6192 21 the the DT 19613 6192 22 moral moral JJ 19613 6192 23 law law NN 19613 6192 24 of of IN 19613 6192 25 nature nature NN 19613 6192 26 had have VBD 19613 6192 27 been be VBN 19613 6192 28 restored restore VBN 19613 6192 29 in in IN 19613 6192 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6192 31 full full JJ 19613 6192 32 purity purity NN 19613 6192 33 without without IN 19613 6192 34 the the DT 19613 6192 35 burden burden NN 19613 6192 36 of of IN 19613 6192 37 ceremonies ceremony NNS 19613 6192 38 , , , 19613 6192 39 and and CC 19613 6192 40 a a DT 19613 6192 41 particular particular JJ 19613 6192 42 historical historical JJ 19613 6192 43 relation relation NN 19613 6192 44 to to IN 19613 6192 45 God God NNP 19613 6192 46 was be VBD 19613 6192 47 allowed allow VBN 19613 6192 48 to to IN 19613 6192 49 the the DT 19613 6192 50 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6192 51 nation nation NN 19613 6192 52 , , , 19613 6192 53 though though IN 19613 6192 54 indeed indeed RB 19613 6192 55 more more RBR 19613 6192 56 a a DT 19613 6192 57 wrathful wrathful NN 19613 6192 58 than than IN 19613 6192 59 a a DT 19613 6192 60 covenant covenant NN 19613 6192 61 one one NN 19613 6192 62 . . . 19613 6193 1 For for IN 19613 6193 2 the the DT 19613 6193 3 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6193 4 regulations regulation NNS 19613 6193 5 were be VBD 19613 6193 6 conceived conceive VBN 19613 6193 7 partly partly RB 19613 6193 8 as as IN 19613 6193 9 tokens token NNS 19613 6193 10 of of IN 19613 6193 11 the the DT 19613 6193 12 judgment judgment NN 19613 6193 13 on on IN 19613 6193 14 Israel Israel NNP 19613 6193 15 , , , 19613 6193 16 partly partly RB 19613 6193 17 as as IN 19613 6193 18 concessions concession NNS 19613 6193 19 to to IN 19613 6193 20 the the DT 19613 6193 21 stiffneckedness stiffneckedness NN 19613 6193 22 of of IN 19613 6193 23 the the DT 19613 6193 24 people people NNS 19613 6193 25 in in IN 19613 6193 26 order order NN 19613 6193 27 to to TO 19613 6193 28 protect protect VB 19613 6193 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6193 30 from from IN 19613 6193 31 the the DT 19613 6193 32 worst bad JJS 19613 6193 33 evil evil NN 19613 6193 34 , , , 19613 6193 35 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 6193 36 . . . 19613 6194 1 Now now RB 19613 6194 2 the the DT 19613 6194 3 struggle struggle NN 19613 6194 4 with with IN 19613 6194 5 the the DT 19613 6194 6 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6194 7 and and CC 19613 6194 8 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6194 9 , , , 19613 6194 10 and and CC 19613 6194 11 the the DT 19613 6194 12 creation creation NN 19613 6194 13 of of IN 19613 6194 14 a a DT 19613 6194 15 New New NNP 19613 6194 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6194 17 had have VBD 19613 6194 18 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 6194 19 a a DT 19613 6194 20 double double JJ 19613 6194 21 consequence consequence NN 19613 6194 22 . . . 19613 6195 1 On on IN 19613 6195 2 the the DT 19613 6195 3 one one CD 19613 6195 4 hand hand NN 19613 6195 5 , , , 19613 6195 6 the the DT 19613 6195 7 proposition proposition NN 19613 6195 8 that that IN 19613 6195 9 the the DT 19613 6195 10 " " `` 19613 6195 11 Father Father NNP 19613 6195 12 of of IN 19613 6195 13 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6195 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6195 15 is be VBZ 19613 6195 16 the the DT 19613 6195 17 creator creator NN 19613 6195 18 of of IN 19613 6195 19 the the DT 19613 6195 20 world world NN 19613 6195 21 and and CC 19613 6195 22 the the DT 19613 6195 23 God God NNP 19613 6195 24 of of IN 19613 6195 25 the the DT 19613 6195 26 Old Old NNP 19613 6195 27 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6195 28 " " '' 19613 6195 29 required require VBD 19613 6195 30 the the DT 19613 6195 31 strictest strictest NN 19613 6195 32 adherence adherence NN 19613 6195 33 to to IN 19613 6195 34 the the DT 19613 6195 35 unity unity NN 19613 6195 36 of of IN 19613 6195 37 the the DT 19613 6195 38 two two CD 19613 6195 39 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6195 40 , , , 19613 6195 41 so so IN 19613 6195 42 that that IN 19613 6195 43 the the DT 19613 6195 44 traditional traditional JJ 19613 6195 45 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 6195 46 view view NN 19613 6195 47 of of IN 19613 6195 48 the the DT 19613 6195 49 older old JJR 19613 6195 50 book book NN 19613 6195 51 had have VBD 19613 6195 52 to to TO 19613 6195 53 undergo undergo VB 19613 6195 54 the the DT 19613 6195 55 most most RBS 19613 6195 56 rigid rigid JJ 19613 6195 57 development development NN 19613 6195 58 ; ; : 19613 6195 59 on on IN 19613 6195 60 the the DT 19613 6195 61 other other JJ 19613 6195 62 hand hand NN 19613 6195 63 , , , 19613 6195 64 as as RB 19613 6195 65 soon soon RB 19613 6195 66 as as IN 19613 6195 67 the the DT 19613 6195 68 New New NNP 19613 6195 69 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6195 70 was be VBD 19613 6195 71 created create VBN 19613 6195 72 , , , 19613 6195 73 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6195 74 was be VBD 19613 6195 75 impossible impossible JJ 19613 6195 76 to to TO 19613 6195 77 avoid avoid VB 19613 6195 78 seeing see VBG 19613 6195 79 that that IN 19613 6195 80 this this DT 19613 6195 81 book book NN 19613 6195 82 was be VBD 19613 6195 83 superior superior JJ 19613 6195 84 to to IN 19613 6195 85 the the DT 19613 6195 86 earlier early JJR 19613 6195 87 one one CD 19613 6195 88 , , , 19613 6195 89 and and CC 19613 6195 90 thus thus RB 19613 6195 91 the the DT 19613 6195 92 theory theory NN 19613 6195 93 of of IN 19613 6195 94 the the DT 19613 6195 95 novelty novelty NN 19613 6195 96 of of IN 19613 6195 97 the the DT 19613 6195 98 Christian christian JJ 19613 6195 99 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6195 100 worked work VBD 19613 6195 101 out out RP 19613 6195 102 by by IN 19613 6195 103 the the DT 19613 6195 104 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6195 105 and and CC 19613 6195 106 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6195 107 had have VBD 19613 6195 108 in in IN 19613 6195 109 some some DT 19613 6195 110 way way NN 19613 6195 111 or or CC 19613 6195 112 other other JJ 19613 6195 113 to to TO 19613 6195 114 be be VB 19613 6195 115 set set VBN 19613 6195 116 forth forth RP 19613 6195 117 and and CC 19613 6195 118 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 19613 6195 119 . . . 19613 6196 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6196 2 now now RB 19613 6196 3 see see VBP 19613 6196 4 the the DT 19613 6196 5 old old JJ 19613 6196 6 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6196 7 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 6196 8 engaged engage VBD 19613 6196 9 in in IN 19613 6196 10 the the DT 19613 6196 11 solution solution NN 19613 6196 12 of of IN 19613 6196 13 this this DT 19613 6196 14 twofold twofold JJ 19613 6196 15 problem problem NN 19613 6196 16 ; ; : 19613 6196 17 and and CC 19613 6196 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6196 19 method method NN 19613 6196 20 of of IN 19613 6196 21 accomplishing accomplish VBG 19613 6196 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6196 23 has have VBZ 19613 6196 24 continued continue VBN 19613 6196 25 to to TO 19613 6196 26 be be VB 19613 6196 27 the the DT 19613 6196 28 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 6196 29 one one CD 19613 6196 30 in in IN 19613 6196 31 all all DT 19613 6196 32 Churches church NNS 19613 6196 33 up up IN 19613 6196 34 to to IN 19613 6196 35 the the DT 19613 6196 36 present present JJ 19613 6196 37 time time NN 19613 6196 38 , , , 19613 6196 39 in in IN 19613 6196 40 so so RB 19613 6196 41 far far RB 19613 6196 42 as as IN 19613 6196 43 the the DT 19613 6196 44 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6196 45 and and CC 19613 6196 46 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 6196 47 practice practice NN 19613 6196 48 still still RB 19613 6196 49 continues continue VBZ 19613 6196 50 to to TO 19613 6196 51 exhibit exhibit VB 19613 6196 52 the the DT 19613 6196 53 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 19613 6196 54 of of IN 19613 6196 55 treating treat VBG 19613 6196 56 the the DT 19613 6196 57 Old Old NNP 19613 6196 58 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6196 59 as as IN 19613 6196 60 a a DT 19613 6196 61 Christian christian JJ 19613 6196 62 book book NN 19613 6196 63 in in IN 19613 6196 64 the the DT 19613 6196 65 strict strict JJ 19613 6196 66 sense sense NN 19613 6196 67 of of IN 19613 6196 68 the the DT 19613 6196 69 word word NN 19613 6196 70 and and CC 19613 6196 71 yet yet RB 19613 6196 72 elevating elevate VBG 19613 6196 73 the the DT 19613 6196 74 New New NNP 19613 6196 75 above above IN 19613 6196 76 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6196 77 , , , 19613 6196 78 of of IN 19613 6196 79 giving give VBG 19613 6196 80 a a DT 19613 6196 81 typical typical JJ 19613 6196 82 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6196 83 to to IN 19613 6196 84 the the DT 19613 6196 85 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6196 86 law law NN 19613 6196 87 and and CC 19613 6196 88 yet yet RB 19613 6196 89 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 19613 6196 90 that that IN 19613 6196 91 the the DT 19613 6196 92 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6196 93 people people NNS 19613 6196 94 had have VBD 19613 6196 95 a a DT 19613 6196 96 covenant covenant NN 19613 6196 97 with with IN 19613 6196 98 God God NNP 19613 6196 99 . . . 19613 6197 1 With with IN 19613 6197 2 regard regard NN 19613 6197 3 to to IN 19613 6197 4 the the DT 19613 6197 5 first first JJ 19613 6197 6 point point NN 19613 6197 7 , , , 19613 6197 8 viz viz NNP 19613 6197 9 . . NNP 19613 6197 10 , , , 19613 6197 11 the the DT 19613 6197 12 maintenance maintenance NN 19613 6197 13 of of IN 19613 6197 14 the the DT 19613 6197 15 unity unity NN 19613 6197 16 of of IN 19613 6197 17 the the DT 19613 6197 18 two two CD 19613 6197 19 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6197 20 , , , 19613 6197 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6197 22 and and CC 19613 6197 23 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6197 24 gave give VBD 19613 6197 25 a a DT 19613 6197 26 most most RBS 19613 6197 27 detailed detailed JJ 19613 6197 28 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 6197 29 of of IN 19613 6197 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6197 31 in in IN 19613 6197 32 opposition opposition NN 19613 6197 33 to to IN 19613 6197 34 Marcion,[628 marcion,[628 CD 19613 6197 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6197 36 and and CC 19613 6197 37 primarily primarily RB 19613 6197 38 indeed indeed RB 19613 6197 39 with with IN 19613 6197 40 the the DT 19613 6197 41 same same JJ 19613 6197 42 means mean NNS 19613 6197 43 as as IN 19613 6197 44 the the DT 19613 6197 45 older old JJR 19613 6197 46 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6197 47 had have VBD 19613 6197 48 already already RB 19613 6197 49 used use VBN 19613 6197 50 . . . 19613 6198 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6198 2 is be VBZ 19613 6198 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6198 4 that that WDT 19613 6198 5 prophesied prophesy VBD 19613 6198 6 and and CC 19613 6198 7 appeared appear VBD 19613 6198 8 in in IN 19613 6198 9 the the DT 19613 6198 10 Old Old NNP 19613 6198 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6198 12 ; ; : 19613 6198 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6198 14 is be VBZ 19613 6198 15 the the DT 19613 6198 16 householder householder NN 19613 6198 17 who who WP 19613 6198 18 produced produce VBD 19613 6198 19 both both DT 19613 6198 20 Old Old NNP 19613 6198 21 and and CC 19613 6198 22 New New NNP 19613 6198 23 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6198 24 . . . 19613 6199 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6199 2 629 629 CD 19613 6199 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6199 4 Moreover moreover RB 19613 6199 5 , , , 19613 6199 6 as as IN 19613 6199 7 the the DT 19613 6199 8 two two CD 19613 6199 9 have have VBP 19613 6199 10 the the DT 19613 6199 11 same same JJ 19613 6199 12 origin origin NN 19613 6199 13 , , , 19613 6199 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6199 15 meaning meaning NN 19613 6199 16 is be VBZ 19613 6199 17 also also RB 19613 6199 18 the the DT 19613 6199 19 same same JJ 19613 6199 20 . . . 19613 6200 1 Like like IN 19613 6200 2 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 6200 3 the the DT 19613 6200 4 early early JJ 19613 6200 5 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6200 6 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 6200 7 contrived contrive VBD 19613 6200 8 to to TO 19613 6200 9 give give VB 19613 6200 10 all all DT 19613 6200 11 passages passage NNS 19613 6200 12 in in IN 19613 6200 13 the the DT 19613 6200 14 Old Old NNP 19613 6200 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6200 16 a a DT 19613 6200 17 typical typical JJ 19613 6200 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 6200 19 sense sense NN 19613 6200 20 : : : 19613 6200 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6200 22 is be VBZ 19613 6200 23 the the DT 19613 6200 24 same same JJ 19613 6200 25 truth truth NN 19613 6200 26 which which WDT 19613 6200 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6200 28 can can MD 19613 6200 29 learn learn VB 19613 6200 30 from from IN 19613 6200 31 the the DT 19613 6200 32 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6200 33 and and CC 19613 6200 34 again again RB 19613 6200 35 from from IN 19613 6200 36 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6200 37 and and CC 19613 6200 38 the the DT 19613 6200 39 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 6200 40 . . . 19613 6201 1 With with IN 19613 6201 2 regard regard NN 19613 6201 3 to to IN 19613 6201 4 the the DT 19613 6201 5 Old Old NNP 19613 6201 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6201 7 the the DT 19613 6201 8 watchword watchword NN 19613 6201 9 is be VBZ 19613 6201 10 : : : 19613 6201 11 " " `` 19613 6201 12 Seek seek VB 19613 6201 13 the the DT 19613 6201 14 type type NN 19613 6201 15 " " '' 19613 6201 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6201 17 " " `` 19613 6201 18 Typum typum NN 19613 6201 19 quæras quæras FW 19613 6201 20 " " '' 19613 6201 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6201 22 . . . 19613 6202 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6202 2 630 630 CD 19613 6202 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6202 4 But but CC 19613 6202 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6202 6 went go VBD 19613 6202 7 a a DT 19613 6202 8 step step NN 19613 6202 9 further far RBR 19613 6202 10 still still RB 19613 6202 11 . . . 19613 6203 1 In in IN 19613 6203 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 6203 3 to to IN 19613 6203 4 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6203 5 's 's POS 19613 6203 6 antitheses antithesis NNS 19613 6203 7 and and CC 19613 6203 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6203 9 demonstration demonstration NN 19613 6203 10 that that IN 19613 6203 11 the the DT 19613 6203 12 God God NNP 19613 6203 13 of of IN 19613 6203 14 the the DT 19613 6203 15 Old Old NNP 19613 6203 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6203 17 is be VBZ 19613 6203 18 a a DT 19613 6203 19 petty petty JJ 19613 6203 20 being being NN 19613 6203 21 and and CC 19613 6203 22 has have VBZ 19613 6203 23 enjoined enjoin VBN 19613 6203 24 petty petty JJ 19613 6203 25 , , , 19613 6203 26 external external JJ 19613 6203 27 observances observance NNS 19613 6203 28 , , , 19613 6203 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6203 30 seek seek VBP 19613 6203 31 to to TO 19613 6203 32 show show VB 19613 6203 33 in in IN 19613 6203 34 syntheses synthesis NNS 19613 6203 35 that that WDT 19613 6203 36 the the DT 19613 6203 37 same same JJ 19613 6203 38 may may MD 19613 6203 39 be be VB 19613 6203 40 said say VBN 19613 6203 41 of of IN 19613 6203 42 the the DT 19613 6203 43 New New NNP 19613 6203 44 . . . 19613 6204 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6204 2 See see VB 19613 6204 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6204 4 IV IV NNP 19613 6204 5 . . . 19613 6205 1 21 21 CD 19613 6205 2 - - SYM 19613 6205 3 36 36 CD 19613 6205 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6205 5 . . . 19613 6206 1 The the DT 19613 6206 2 effort effort NN 19613 6206 3 of of IN 19613 6206 4 the the DT 19613 6206 5 older old JJR 19613 6206 6 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6206 7 to to TO 19613 6206 8 exclude exclude VB 19613 6206 9 everything everything NN 19613 6206 10 outward outward RB 19613 6206 11 and and CC 19613 6206 12 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6206 13 is be VBZ 19613 6206 14 no no RB 19613 6206 15 longer long RBR 19613 6206 16 met meet VBN 19613 6206 17 with with IN 19613 6206 18 to to IN 19613 6206 19 the the DT 19613 6206 20 same same JJ 19613 6206 21 extent extent NN 19613 6206 22 in in IN 19613 6206 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6206 24 and and CC 19613 6206 25 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6206 26 , , , 19613 6206 27 at at IN 19613 6206 28 least least JJS 19613 6206 29 when when WRB 19613 6206 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6206 31 are be VBP 19613 6206 32 arguing argue VBG 19613 6206 33 and and CC 19613 6206 34 defending defend VBG 19613 6206 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6206 36 position position NN 19613 6206 37 against against IN 19613 6206 38 the the DT 19613 6206 39 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6206 40 . . . 19613 6207 1 This this DT 19613 6207 2 has have VBZ 19613 6207 3 to to TO 19613 6207 4 be be VB 19613 6207 5 explained explain VBN 19613 6207 6 by by IN 19613 6207 7 two two CD 19613 6207 8 causes cause NNS 19613 6207 9 . . . 19613 6208 1 In in IN 19613 6208 2 the the DT 19613 6208 3 first first JJ 19613 6208 4 place place NN 19613 6208 5 Judaism Judaism NNP 19613 6208 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6208 7 and and CC 19613 6208 8 Jewish Jewish NNP 19613 6208 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6208 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6208 11 was be VBD 19613 6208 12 at at IN 19613 6208 13 bottom bottom NN 19613 6208 14 no no RB 19613 6208 15 longer long RBR 19613 6208 16 an an DT 19613 6208 17 enemy enemy NN 19613 6208 18 to to TO 19613 6208 19 be be VB 19613 6208 20 feared fear VBN 19613 6208 21 ; ; : 19613 6208 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6208 23 therefore therefore RB 19613 6208 24 ceased cease VBD 19613 6208 25 to to TO 19613 6208 26 make make VB 19613 6208 27 such such JJ 19613 6208 28 efforts effort NNS 19613 6208 29 to to TO 19613 6208 30 avoid avoid VB 19613 6208 31 the the DT 19613 6208 32 " " `` 19613 6208 33 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6208 34 " " '' 19613 6208 35 conception conception NN 19613 6208 36 of of IN 19613 6208 37 the the DT 19613 6208 38 Old Old NNP 19613 6208 39 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6208 40 . . . 19613 6209 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6209 2 , , , 19613 6209 3 for for IN 19613 6209 4 example example NN 19613 6209 5 , , , 19613 6209 6 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 6209 7 in in IN 19613 6209 8 the the DT 19613 6209 9 most most RBS 19613 6209 10 naïve naïve NNP 19613 6209 11 manner manner NN 19613 6209 12 the the DT 19613 6209 13 observance observance NN 19613 6209 14 of of IN 19613 6209 15 the the DT 19613 6209 16 Old Old NNP 19613 6209 17 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6209 18 law law NN 19613 6209 19 by by IN 19613 6209 20 the the DT 19613 6209 21 early early JJ 19613 6209 22 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 6209 23 and and CC 19613 6209 24 also also RB 19613 6209 25 by by IN 19613 6209 26 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6209 27 . . . 19613 6210 1 This this DT 19613 6210 2 is be VBZ 19613 6210 3 to to IN 19613 6210 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6210 5 a a DT 19613 6210 6 complete complete JJ 19613 6210 7 proof proof NN 19613 6210 8 that that IN 19613 6210 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6210 10 did do VBD 19613 6210 11 not not RB 19613 6210 12 separate separate VB 19613 6210 13 the the DT 19613 6210 14 Old Old NNP 19613 6210 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6210 16 God God NNP 19613 6210 17 from from IN 19613 6210 18 the the DT 19613 6210 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 6210 20 Deity deity NN 19613 6210 21 . . . 19613 6211 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6211 2 631 631 CD 19613 6211 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6211 4 In in IN 19613 6211 5 connection connection NN 19613 6211 6 with with IN 19613 6211 7 this this DT 19613 6211 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6211 9 observe observe VBP 19613 6211 10 that that IN 19613 6211 11 the the DT 19613 6211 12 radical radical JJ 19613 6211 13 antijudaism antijudaism NN 19613 6211 14 of of IN 19613 6211 15 the the DT 19613 6211 16 earliest early JJS 19613 6211 17 period period NN 19613 6211 18 more more RBR 19613 6211 19 and and CC 19613 6211 20 more more JJR 19613 6211 21 ceases cease NNS 19613 6211 22 . . . 19613 6212 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6212 2 and and CC 19613 6212 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6212 4 admitted admit VBD 19613 6212 5 that that IN 19613 6212 6 the the DT 19613 6212 7 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6212 8 nation nation NN 19613 6212 9 had have VBD 19613 6212 10 a a DT 19613 6212 11 covenant covenant NN 19613 6212 12 with with IN 19613 6212 13 God God NNP 19613 6212 14 and and CC 19613 6212 15 that that IN 19613 6212 16 the the DT 19613 6212 17 literal literal JJ 19613 6212 18 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6212 19 of of IN 19613 6212 20 the the DT 19613 6212 21 Old Old NNP 19613 6212 22 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6212 23 was be VBD 19613 6212 24 justifiable justifiable JJ 19613 6212 25 . . . 19613 6213 1 Both both DT 19613 6213 2 repeatedly repeatedly RB 19613 6213 3 testified testify VBD 19613 6213 4 that that IN 19613 6213 5 the the DT 19613 6213 6 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 6213 7 had have VBD 19613 6213 8 the the DT 19613 6213 9 right right JJ 19613 6213 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6213 11 and and CC 19613 6213 12 that that IN 19613 6213 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6213 14 only only RB 19613 6213 15 lacked lack VBD 19613 6213 16 the the DT 19613 6213 17 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6213 18 of of IN 19613 6213 19 the the DT 19613 6213 20 Son Son NNP 19613 6213 21 . . . 19613 6214 1 These these DT 19613 6214 2 thoughts thought NNS 19613 6214 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 6214 4 do do VBP 19613 6214 5 not not RB 19613 6214 6 attain attain VB 19613 6214 7 clear clear JJ 19613 6214 8 expression expression NN 19613 6214 9 with with IN 19613 6214 10 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6214 11 because because IN 19613 6214 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6214 13 works work NNS 19613 6214 14 contain contain VBP 19613 6214 15 no no DT 19613 6214 16 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6214 17 discussions discussion NNS 19613 6214 18 involving involve VBG 19613 6214 19 these these DT 19613 6214 20 principles principle NNS 19613 6214 21 . . . 19613 6215 1 In in IN 19613 6215 2 the the DT 19613 6215 3 second second JJ 19613 6215 4 place place NN 19613 6215 5 the the DT 19613 6215 6 Church Church NNP 19613 6215 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6215 8 had have VBD 19613 6215 9 become become VBN 19613 6215 10 an an DT 19613 6215 11 institution institution NN 19613 6215 12 where where WRB 19613 6215 13 sacred sacred JJ 19613 6215 14 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6215 15 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 6215 16 were be VBD 19613 6215 17 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6215 18 ; ; : 19613 6215 19 and and CC 19613 6215 20 , , , 19613 6215 21 in in IN 19613 6215 22 order order NN 19613 6215 23 to to TO 19613 6215 24 find find VB 19613 6215 25 a a DT 19613 6215 26 basis basis NN 19613 6215 27 for for IN 19613 6215 28 these these DT 19613 6215 29 , , , 19613 6215 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6215 31 had have VBD 19613 6215 32 to to TO 19613 6215 33 fall fall VB 19613 6215 34 back back RB 19613 6215 35 on on IN 19613 6215 36 Old Old NNP 19613 6215 37 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6215 38 commandments commandment NNS 19613 6215 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6215 40 see see VB 19613 6215 41 Vol Vol NNP 19613 6215 42 . . . 19613 6216 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6216 2 , , , 19613 6216 3 chap chap NNP 19613 6216 4 . . . 19613 6217 1 6 6 CD 19613 6217 2 , , , 19613 6217 3 p. p. NN 19613 6217 4 291 291 CD 19613 6217 5 ff ff NNP 19613 6217 6 . . NNP 19613 6217 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6217 8 . . . 19613 6218 1 In in IN 19613 6218 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6218 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6218 4 find find VBP 19613 6218 5 this this DT 19613 6218 6 only only RB 19613 6218 7 in in IN 19613 6218 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6218 9 most most JJS 19613 6218 10 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 6218 11 form;[632 form;[632 NNS 19613 6218 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6218 13 but but CC 19613 6218 14 in in IN 19613 6218 15 the the DT 19613 6218 16 course course NN 19613 6218 17 of of IN 19613 6218 18 the the DT 19613 6218 19 third third JJ 19613 6218 20 century century NN 19613 6218 21 these these DT 19613 6218 22 needs need NNS 19613 6218 23 grew grow VBD 19613 6218 24 mightily[633 mightily[633 NNP 19613 6218 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6218 26 and and CC 19613 6218 27 were be VBD 19613 6218 28 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 6218 29 . . . 19613 6219 1 In in IN 19613 6219 2 this this DT 19613 6219 3 way way NN 19613 6219 4 the the DT 19613 6219 5 Old Old NNP 19613 6219 6 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6219 7 threatened threaten VBD 19613 6219 8 to to TO 19613 6219 9 become become VB 19613 6219 10 an an DT 19613 6219 11 authentic authentic JJ 19613 6219 12 book book NN 19613 6219 13 of of IN 19613 6219 14 revelation revelation NN 19613 6219 15 to to IN 19613 6219 16 the the DT 19613 6219 17 Church Church NNP 19613 6219 18 , , , 19613 6219 19 and and CC 19613 6219 20 that that IN 19613 6219 21 in in IN 19613 6219 22 a a DT 19613 6219 23 quite quite RB 19613 6219 24 different different JJ 19613 6219 25 and and CC 19613 6219 26 much much RB 19613 6219 27 more more RBR 19613 6219 28 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 6219 29 sense sense NN 19613 6219 30 than than IN 19613 6219 31 was be VBD 19613 6219 32 formerly formerly RB 19613 6219 33 the the DT 19613 6219 34 case case NN 19613 6219 35 with with IN 19613 6219 36 the the DT 19613 6219 37 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 6219 38 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 6219 39 and and CC 19613 6219 40 the the DT 19613 6219 41 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 6219 42 . . . 19613 6220 1 With with IN 19613 6220 2 reference reference NN 19613 6220 3 to to IN 19613 6220 4 the the DT 19613 6220 5 second second JJ 19613 6220 6 point point NN 19613 6220 7 , , , 19613 6220 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6220 9 may may MD 19613 6220 10 remark remark VB 19613 6220 11 that that DT 19613 6220 12 just just RB 19613 6220 13 when when WRB 19613 6220 14 the the DT 19613 6220 15 decay decay NN 19613 6220 16 of of IN 19613 6220 17 antijudaism antijudaism NN 19613 6220 18 , , , 19613 6220 19 the the DT 19613 6220 20 polemic polemic NN 19613 6220 21 against against IN 19613 6220 22 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6220 23 , , , 19613 6220 24 and and CC 19613 6220 25 the the DT 19613 6220 26 new new JJ 19613 6220 27 needs need NNS 19613 6220 28 of of IN 19613 6220 29 the the DT 19613 6220 30 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6220 31 system system NN 19613 6220 32 threatened threaten VBD 19613 6220 33 the the DT 19613 6220 34 Church Church NNP 19613 6220 35 with with IN 19613 6220 36 an an DT 19613 6220 37 estimate estimate NN 19613 6220 38 of of IN 19613 6220 39 the the DT 19613 6220 40 Old Old NNP 19613 6220 41 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6220 42 hitherto hitherto VBD 19613 6220 43 unheard unheard JJ 19613 6220 44 of of IN 19613 6220 45 , , , 19613 6220 46 the the DT 19613 6220 47 latter latter JJ 19613 6220 48 was be VBD 19613 6220 49 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 6220 50 thrust thrust VBN 19613 6220 51 back back RB 19613 6220 52 by by IN 19613 6220 53 the the DT 19613 6220 54 creation creation NN 19613 6220 55 and and CC 19613 6220 56 authority authority NN 19613 6220 57 of of IN 19613 6220 58 the the DT 19613 6220 59 New New NNP 19613 6220 60 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6220 61 , , , 19613 6220 62 and and CC 19613 6220 63 this this DT 19613 6220 64 consequently consequently RB 19613 6220 65 revived revive VBD 19613 6220 66 the the DT 19613 6220 67 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 6220 68 position position NN 19613 6220 69 in in IN 19613 6220 70 which which WDT 19613 6220 71 the the DT 19613 6220 72 sacred sacred JJ 19613 6220 73 book book NN 19613 6220 74 was be VBD 19613 6220 75 henceforth henceforth RB 19613 6220 76 to to TO 19613 6220 77 remain remain VB 19613 6220 78 . . . 19613 6221 1 Here here RB 19613 6221 2 also also RB 19613 6221 3 , , , 19613 6221 4 as as IN 19613 6221 5 in in IN 19613 6221 6 every every DT 19613 6221 7 other other JJ 19613 6221 8 case case NN 19613 6221 9 , , , 19613 6221 10 the the DT 19613 6221 11 development development NN 19613 6221 12 in in IN 19613 6221 13 the the DT 19613 6221 14 Church Church NNP 19613 6221 15 ends end VBZ 19613 6221 16 with with IN 19613 6221 17 the the DT 19613 6221 18 _ _ NNP 19613 6221 19 complexus complexus NN 19613 6221 20 oppositorum oppositorum NNP 19613 6221 21 _ _ NNP 19613 6221 22 , , , 19613 6221 23 which which WDT 19613 6221 24 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 6221 25 allows allow VBZ 19613 6221 26 all all PDT 19613 6221 27 the the DT 19613 6221 28 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 6221 29 to to TO 19613 6221 30 be be VB 19613 6221 31 drawn draw VBN 19613 6221 32 , , , 19613 6221 33 but but CC 19613 6221 34 offers offer VBZ 19613 6221 35 the the DT 19613 6221 36 great great JJ 19613 6221 37 advantage advantage NN 19613 6221 38 of of IN 19613 6221 39 removing remove VBG 19613 6221 40 every every DT 19613 6221 41 perplexity perplexity NN 19613 6221 42 up up IN 19613 6221 43 to to IN 19613 6221 44 a a DT 19613 6221 45 certain certain JJ 19613 6221 46 point point NN 19613 6221 47 . . . 19613 6222 1 The the DT 19613 6222 2 early early JJ 19613 6222 3 - - HYPH 19613 6222 4 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6222 5 Fathers father NNS 19613 6222 6 adopted adopt VBN 19613 6222 7 from from IN 19613 6222 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6222 9 the the DT 19613 6222 10 distinction distinction NN 19613 6222 11 between between IN 19613 6222 12 the the DT 19613 6222 13 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 19613 6222 14 , , , 19613 6222 15 as as IN 19613 6222 16 the the DT 19613 6222 17 moral moral JJ 19613 6222 18 law law NN 19613 6222 19 of of IN 19613 6222 20 nature nature NN 19613 6222 21 , , , 19613 6222 22 and and CC 19613 6222 23 the the DT 19613 6222 24 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6222 25 law law NN 19613 6222 26 ; ; : 19613 6222 27 whilst whilst IN 19613 6222 28 the the DT 19613 6222 29 oldest old JJS 19613 6222 30 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6222 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6222 32 the the DT 19613 6222 33 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6222 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6222 35 and and CC 19613 6222 36 the the DT 19613 6222 37 New New NNP 19613 6222 38 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6222 39 suggested suggest VBD 19613 6222 40 to to IN 19613 6222 41 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6222 42 the the DT 19613 6222 43 thought thought NN 19613 6222 44 of of IN 19613 6222 45 the the DT 19613 6222 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6222 47 relative relative JJ 19613 6222 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6222 49 novelty novelty NN 19613 6222 50 of of IN 19613 6222 51 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6222 52 and and CC 19613 6222 53 therefore therefore RB 19613 6222 54 also also RB 19613 6222 55 of of IN 19613 6222 56 the the DT 19613 6222 57 New New NNP 19613 6222 58 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6222 59 . . . 19613 6223 1 Like like IN 19613 6223 2 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6223 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6223 4 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 6223 5 the the DT 19613 6223 6 literal literal JJ 19613 6223 7 sense sense NN 19613 6223 8 of of IN 19613 6223 9 the the DT 19613 6223 10 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6223 11 law law NN 19613 6223 12 and and CC 19613 6223 13 God God NNP 19613 6223 14 's 's POS 19613 6223 15 covenant covenant NN 19613 6223 16 with with IN 19613 6223 17 the the DT 19613 6223 18 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 6223 19 ; ; : 19613 6223 20 and and CC 19613 6223 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6223 22 sought seek VBD 19613 6223 23 to to TO 19613 6223 24 sum sum VB 19613 6223 25 up up RP 19613 6223 26 and and CC 19613 6223 27 harmonise harmonise VB 19613 6223 28 all all PDT 19613 6223 29 these these DT 19613 6223 30 features feature NNS 19613 6223 31 in in IN 19613 6223 32 the the DT 19613 6223 33 thought thought NN 19613 6223 34 of of IN 19613 6223 35 an an DT 19613 6223 36 economy economy NN 19613 6223 37 of of IN 19613 6223 38 salvation salvation NN 19613 6223 39 and and CC 19613 6223 40 of of IN 19613 6223 41 a a DT 19613 6223 42 history history NN 19613 6223 43 of of IN 19613 6223 44 salvation salvation NN 19613 6223 45 . . . 19613 6224 1 This this DT 19613 6224 2 economy economy NN 19613 6224 3 and and CC 19613 6224 4 history history NN 19613 6224 5 of of IN 19613 6224 6 salvation salvation NN 19613 6224 7 which which WDT 19613 6224 8 contained contain VBD 19613 6224 9 the the DT 19613 6224 10 conception conception NN 19613 6224 11 of of IN 19613 6224 12 a a DT 19613 6224 13 divine divine JJ 19613 6224 14 _ _ NNP 19613 6224 15 accommodation accommodation NN 19613 6224 16 and and CC 19613 6224 17 pedagogy pedagogy NN 19613 6224 18 _ _ NNP 19613 6224 19 , , , 19613 6224 20 and and CC 19613 6224 21 which which WDT 19613 6224 22 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 6224 23 distinguished distinguish VBD 19613 6224 24 between between IN 19613 6224 25 constituent constituent NN 19613 6224 26 parts part NNS 19613 6224 27 of of IN 19613 6224 28 different different JJ 19613 6224 29 degrees degree NNS 19613 6224 30 of of IN 19613 6224 31 value value NN 19613 6224 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6224 33 in in IN 19613 6224 34 the the DT 19613 6224 35 Old Old NNP 19613 6224 36 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6224 37 also also RB 19613 6224 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6224 39 , , , 19613 6224 40 is be VBZ 19613 6224 41 the the DT 19613 6224 42 great great JJ 19613 6224 43 result result NN 19613 6224 44 presented present VBN 19613 6224 45 in in IN 19613 6224 46 the the DT 19613 6224 47 main main JJ 19613 6224 48 work work NN 19613 6224 49 of of IN 19613 6224 50 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6224 51 and and CC 19613 6224 52 accepted accept VBN 19613 6224 53 by by IN 19613 6224 54 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6224 55 . . . 19613 6225 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6225 2 is be VBZ 19613 6225 3 to to TO 19613 6225 4 exist exist VB 19613 6225 5 beside beside IN 19613 6225 6 the the DT 19613 6225 7 proof proof NN 19613 6225 8 from from IN 19613 6225 9 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 6225 10 without without IN 19613 6225 11 modifying modify VBG 19613 6225 12 it;[634 it;[634 NN 19613 6225 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6225 14 and and CC 19613 6225 15 thus thus RB 19613 6225 16 appears appear VBZ 19613 6225 17 as as IN 19613 6225 18 something something NN 19613 6225 19 intermediate intermediate JJ 19613 6225 20 between between IN 19613 6225 21 the the DT 19613 6225 22 Valentinian Valentinian NNP 19613 6225 23 conception conception NN 19613 6225 24 that that WDT 19613 6225 25 destroyed destroy VBD 19613 6225 26 the the DT 19613 6225 27 unity unity NN 19613 6225 28 of of IN 19613 6225 29 origin origin NN 19613 6225 30 of of IN 19613 6225 31 the the DT 19613 6225 32 Old Old NNP 19613 6225 33 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6225 34 and and CC 19613 6225 35 the the DT 19613 6225 36 old old JJ 19613 6225 37 idea idea NN 19613 6225 38 which which WDT 19613 6225 39 neither neither CC 19613 6225 40 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 6225 41 various various JJ 19613 6225 42 constituents constituent NNS 19613 6225 43 in in IN 19613 6225 44 the the DT 19613 6225 45 book book NN 19613 6225 46 nor nor CC 19613 6225 47 recognised recognise VBD 19613 6225 48 the the DT 19613 6225 49 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 19613 6225 50 of of IN 19613 6225 51 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6225 52 . . . 19613 6226 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6226 2 are be VBP 19613 6226 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 6226 4 justified justified JJ 19613 6226 5 in in IN 19613 6226 6 regarding regard VBG 19613 6226 7 this this DT 19613 6226 8 history history NN 19613 6226 9 of of IN 19613 6226 10 salvation salvation NN 19613 6226 11 approved approve VBN 19613 6226 12 by by IN 19613 6226 13 the the DT 19613 6226 14 Church Church NNP 19613 6226 15 , , , 19613 6226 16 as as RB 19613 6226 17 well well RB 19613 6226 18 as as IN 19613 6226 19 the the DT 19613 6226 20 theological theological JJ 19613 6226 21 propositions proposition NNS 19613 6226 22 of of IN 19613 6226 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6226 24 and and CC 19613 6226 25 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6226 26 generally generally RB 19613 6226 27 , , , 19613 6226 28 as as IN 19613 6226 29 a a DT 19613 6226 30 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 6226 31 " " '' 19613 6226 32 toned tone VBD 19613 6226 33 down down RP 19613 6226 34 " " '' 19613 6226 35 and and CC 19613 6226 36 reconciled reconcile VBN 19613 6226 37 with with IN 19613 6226 38 Monotheism Monotheism NNP 19613 6226 39 . . . 19613 6227 1 This this DT 19613 6227 2 is be VBZ 19613 6227 3 shown show VBN 19613 6227 4 too too RB 19613 6227 5 in in IN 19613 6227 6 the the DT 19613 6227 7 faint faint JJ 19613 6227 8 gleam gleam NN 19613 6227 9 of of IN 19613 6227 10 a a DT 19613 6227 11 historical historical JJ 19613 6227 12 view view NN 19613 6227 13 that that WDT 19613 6227 14 still still RB 19613 6227 15 shines shine VBZ 19613 6227 16 forth forth RB 19613 6227 17 from from IN 19613 6227 18 this this DT 19613 6227 19 " " `` 19613 6227 20 history history NN 19613 6227 21 of of IN 19613 6227 22 salvation salvation NN 19613 6227 23 " " '' 19613 6227 24 as as IN 19613 6227 25 a a DT 19613 6227 26 remnant remnant NN 19613 6227 27 of of IN 19613 6227 28 that that DT 19613 6227 29 bright bright JJ 19613 6227 30 light light NN 19613 6227 31 which which WDT 19613 6227 32 may may MD 19613 6227 33 be be VB 19613 6227 34 recognised recognise VBN 19613 6227 35 in in IN 19613 6227 36 the the DT 19613 6227 37 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6227 38 conception conception NN 19613 6227 39 of of IN 19613 6227 40 the the DT 19613 6227 41 Old Old NNP 19613 6227 42 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6227 43 . . . 19613 6228 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6228 2 635 635 CD 19613 6228 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6228 4 Still still RB 19613 6228 5 , , , 19613 6228 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6228 7 is be VBZ 19613 6228 8 a a DT 19613 6228 9 striking striking JJ 19613 6228 10 advance advance NN 19613 6228 11 that that IN 19613 6228 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6228 13 has have VBZ 19613 6228 14 made make VBN 19613 6228 15 beyond beyond IN 19613 6228 16 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6228 17 and and CC 19613 6228 18 especially especially RB 19613 6228 19 beyond beyond IN 19613 6228 20 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 6228 21 . . . 19613 6229 1 No no RB 19613 6229 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 6229 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6229 4 is be VBZ 19613 6229 5 mythological mythological JJ 19613 6229 6 history history NN 19613 6229 7 that that WDT 19613 6229 8 appears appear VBZ 19613 6229 9 in in IN 19613 6229 10 this this DT 19613 6229 11 history history NN 19613 6229 12 of of IN 19613 6229 13 salvation salvation NN 19613 6229 14 and and CC 19613 6229 15 the the DT 19613 6229 16 recapitulating recapitulate VBG 19613 6229 17 story story NN 19613 6229 18 of of IN 19613 6229 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6229 20 with with IN 19613 6229 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6229 22 saving saving NN 19613 6229 23 facts fact NNS 19613 6229 24 that that WDT 19613 6229 25 is be VBZ 19613 6229 26 associated associate VBN 19613 6229 27 with with IN 19613 6229 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6229 29 ; ; : 19613 6229 30 and and CC 19613 6229 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6229 32 is be VBZ 19613 6229 33 a a DT 19613 6229 34 view view NN 19613 6229 35 that that WDT 19613 6229 36 is be VBZ 19613 6229 37 not not RB 19613 6229 38 even even RB 19613 6229 39 logically logically RB 19613 6229 40 worked work VBN 19613 6229 41 out out RP 19613 6229 42 , , , 19613 6229 43 but but CC 19613 6229 44 ever ever RB 19613 6229 45 and and CC 19613 6229 46 anon anon NNP 19613 6229 47 crossed cross VBD 19613 6229 48 by by IN 19613 6229 49 the the DT 19613 6229 50 proof proof NN 19613 6229 51 from from IN 19613 6229 52 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 6229 53 ; ; : 19613 6229 54 yet yet CC 19613 6229 55 for for IN 19613 6229 56 all all DT 19613 6229 57 that that WDT 19613 6229 58 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6229 59 is be VBZ 19613 6229 60 development development NN 19613 6229 61 and and CC 19613 6229 62 history history NN 19613 6229 63 . . . 19613 6230 1 The the DT 19613 6230 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 6230 3 features feature NNS 19613 6230 4 of of IN 19613 6230 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6230 6 ' ' POS 19613 6230 7 conception conception NN 19613 6230 8 are be VBP 19613 6230 9 as as IN 19613 6230 10 follow follow NN 19613 6230 11 : : : 19613 6230 12 The the DT 19613 6230 13 Mosaic Mosaic NNP 19613 6230 14 law law NN 19613 6230 15 and and CC 19613 6230 16 the the DT 19613 6230 17 New New NNP 19613 6230 18 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6230 19 dispensation dispensation NN 19613 6230 20 of of IN 19613 6230 21 grace grace NN 19613 6230 22 both both DT 19613 6230 23 emanated emanate VBD 19613 6230 24 from from IN 19613 6230 25 one one CD 19613 6230 26 and and CC 19613 6230 27 the the DT 19613 6230 28 same same JJ 19613 6230 29 God God NNP 19613 6230 30 , , , 19613 6230 31 _ _ NNP 19613 6230 32 and and CC 19613 6230 33 were be VBD 19613 6230 34 granted grant VBN 19613 6230 35 for for IN 19613 6230 36 the the DT 19613 6230 37 salvation salvation NN 19613 6230 38 of of IN 19613 6230 39 the the DT 19613 6230 40 human human JJ 19613 6230 41 race race NN 19613 6230 42 in in IN 19613 6230 43 a a DT 19613 6230 44 form form NN 19613 6230 45 appropriate appropriate JJ 19613 6230 46 to to IN 19613 6230 47 the the DT 19613 6230 48 times time NNS 19613 6230 49 _ _ NNP 19613 6230 50 . . . 19613 6231 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6231 2 636 636 CD 19613 6231 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6231 4 The the DT 19613 6231 5 two two CD 19613 6231 6 are be VBP 19613 6231 7 in in IN 19613 6231 8 part part NN 19613 6231 9 different different JJ 19613 6231 10 ; ; : 19613 6231 11 but but CC 19613 6231 12 the the DT 19613 6231 13 difference difference NN 19613 6231 14 must must MD 19613 6231 15 be be VB 19613 6231 16 conceived conceive VBN 19613 6231 17 as as IN 19613 6231 18 due due JJ 19613 6231 19 to to IN 19613 6231 20 causes[637 causes[637 NNP 19613 6231 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6231 22 that that WDT 19613 6231 23 do do VBP 19613 6231 24 not not RB 19613 6231 25 affect affect VB 19613 6231 26 the the DT 19613 6231 27 unity unity NN 19613 6231 28 of of IN 19613 6231 29 the the DT 19613 6231 30 author author NN 19613 6231 31 and and CC 19613 6231 32 of of IN 19613 6231 33 the the DT 19613 6231 34 main main JJ 19613 6231 35 points point NNS 19613 6231 36 . . . 19613 6232 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6232 2 638 638 CD 19613 6232 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6232 4 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6232 5 must must MD 19613 6232 6 make make VB 19613 6232 7 the the DT 19613 6232 8 nature nature NN 19613 6232 9 of of IN 19613 6232 10 God God NNP 19613 6232 11 and and CC 19613 6232 12 the the DT 19613 6232 13 nature nature NN 19613 6232 14 of of IN 19613 6232 15 man man NN 19613 6232 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6232 17 point point NN 19613 6232 18 of of IN 19613 6232 19 departure departure NN 19613 6232 20 . . . 19613 6233 1 God God NNP 19613 6233 2 is be VBZ 19613 6233 3 always always RB 19613 6233 4 the the DT 19613 6233 5 same same JJ 19613 6233 6 , , , 19613 6233 7 man man NN 19613 6233 8 is be VBZ 19613 6233 9 ever ever RB 19613 6233 10 advancing advance VBG 19613 6233 11 towards towards IN 19613 6233 12 God God NNP 19613 6233 13 ; ; : 19613 6233 14 God God NNP 19613 6233 15 is be VBZ 19613 6233 16 always always RB 19613 6233 17 the the DT 19613 6233 18 giver giver NN 19613 6233 19 , , , 19613 6233 20 man man NN 19613 6233 21 always always RB 19613 6233 22 the the DT 19613 6233 23 receiver;[639 receiver;[639 NNS 19613 6233 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6233 25 God God NNP 19613 6233 26 leads lead VBZ 19613 6233 27 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6233 28 ever ever RB 19613 6233 29 to to IN 19613 6233 30 the the DT 19613 6233 31 highest high JJS 19613 6233 32 goal goal NN 19613 6233 33 ; ; : 19613 6233 34 man man UH 19613 6233 35 , , , 19613 6233 36 however however RB 19613 6233 37 , , , 19613 6233 38 is be VBZ 19613 6233 39 not not RB 19613 6233 40 God God NNP 19613 6233 41 from from IN 19613 6233 42 the the DT 19613 6233 43 beginning beginning NN 19613 6233 44 , , , 19613 6233 45 but but CC 19613 6233 46 is be VBZ 19613 6233 47 destined destine VBN 19613 6233 48 to to IN 19613 6233 49 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 6233 50 , , , 19613 6233 51 which which WDT 19613 6233 52 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6233 53 is be VBZ 19613 6233 54 to to TO 19613 6233 55 attain attain VB 19613 6233 56 step step NN 19613 6233 57 by by IN 19613 6233 58 step step NN 19613 6233 59 , , , 19613 6233 60 advancing advance VBG 19613 6233 61 from from IN 19613 6233 62 the the DT 19613 6233 63 childhood childhood NN 19613 6233 64 stage stage NN 19613 6233 65 to to IN 19613 6233 66 perfection perfection NN 19613 6233 67 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6233 68 see see VB 19613 6233 69 above above RB 19613 6233 70 , , , 19613 6233 71 p. p. NN 19613 6233 72 267 267 CD 19613 6233 73 f. f. NNS 19613 6233 74 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6233 75 . . . 19613 6234 1 This this DT 19613 6234 2 progress progress NN 19613 6234 3 , , , 19613 6234 4 conditioned condition VBN 19613 6234 5 by by IN 19613 6234 6 the the DT 19613 6234 7 nature nature NN 19613 6234 8 and and CC 19613 6234 9 destination destination NN 19613 6234 10 of of IN 19613 6234 11 man man NN 19613 6234 12 , , , 19613 6234 13 is be VBZ 19613 6234 14 , , , 19613 6234 15 however however RB 19613 6234 16 , , , 19613 6234 17 dependent dependent JJ 19613 6234 18 on on IN 19613 6234 19 the the DT 19613 6234 20 revelation revelation NN 19613 6234 21 of of IN 19613 6234 22 God God NNP 19613 6234 23 by by IN 19613 6234 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6234 25 Son Son NNP 19613 6234 26 , , , 19613 6234 27 culminating culminate VBG 19613 6234 28 in in IN 19613 6234 29 the the DT 19613 6234 30 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6234 31 of of IN 19613 6234 32 the the DT 19613 6234 33 latter latter JJ 19613 6234 34 and and CC 19613 6234 35 closing close VBG 19613 6234 36 with with IN 19613 6234 37 the the DT 19613 6234 38 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 6234 39 bestowal bestowal NN 19613 6234 40 of of IN 19613 6234 41 the the DT 19613 6234 42 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6234 43 on on IN 19613 6234 44 the the DT 19613 6234 45 human human JJ 19613 6234 46 race race NN 19613 6234 47 . . . 19613 6235 1 In in IN 19613 6235 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6235 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 6235 4 the the DT 19613 6235 5 place place NN 19613 6235 6 of of IN 19613 6235 7 the the DT 19613 6235 8 many many JJ 19613 6235 9 different different JJ 19613 6235 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 6235 11 - - HYPH 19613 6235 12 hypostases hypostasis NNS 19613 6235 13 of of IN 19613 6235 14 the the DT 19613 6235 15 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 6235 16 is be VBZ 19613 6235 17 occupied occupy VBN 19613 6235 18 by by IN 19613 6235 19 the the DT 19613 6235 20 one one NN 19613 6235 21 God God NNP 19613 6235 22 , , , 19613 6235 23 who who WP 19613 6235 24 stoops stoop VBZ 19613 6235 25 to to IN 19613 6235 26 the the DT 19613 6235 27 level level NN 19613 6235 28 of of IN 19613 6235 29 developing develop VBG 19613 6235 30 humanity humanity NN 19613 6235 31 , , , 19613 6235 32 accommodates accommodate VBZ 19613 6235 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6235 34 to to IN 19613 6235 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6235 36 , , , 19613 6235 37 guides guide VBZ 19613 6235 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6235 39 , , , 19613 6235 40 and and CC 19613 6235 41 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 6235 42 on on IN 19613 6235 43 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6235 44 increasing increase VBG 19613 6235 45 revelations revelation NNS 19613 6235 46 of of IN 19613 6235 47 grace grace NN 19613 6235 48 . . . 19613 6236 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6236 2 640 640 CD 19613 6236 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6236 4 The the DT 19613 6236 5 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 6236 6 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6236 7 of of IN 19613 6236 8 God God NNP 19613 6236 9 and and CC 19613 6236 10 the the DT 19613 6236 11 moral moral JJ 19613 6236 12 law law NN 19613 6236 13 of of IN 19613 6236 14 nature nature NN 19613 6236 15 , , , 19613 6236 16 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6236 17 , , , 19613 6236 18 natural natural JJ 19613 6236 19 morality morality NN 19613 6236 20 , , , 19613 6236 21 were be VBD 19613 6236 22 already already RB 19613 6236 23 revealed reveal VBN 19613 6236 24 to to IN 19613 6236 25 man man NN 19613 6236 26 and and CC 19613 6236 27 placed place VBD 19613 6236 28 in in IN 19613 6236 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6236 30 heart[641 heart[641 NN 19613 6236 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6236 32 by by IN 19613 6236 33 the the DT 19613 6236 34 creator creator NN 19613 6236 35 . . . 19613 6237 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6237 2 who who WP 19613 6237 3 preserves preserve VBZ 19613 6237 4 these these DT 19613 6237 5 , , , 19613 6237 6 as as IN 19613 6237 7 for for IN 19613 6237 8 example example NN 19613 6237 9 the the DT 19613 6237 10 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 6237 11 did do VBD 19613 6237 12 , , , 19613 6237 13 is be VBZ 19613 6237 14 justified justify VBN 19613 6237 15 . . . 19613 6238 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6238 2 In in IN 19613 6238 3 this this DT 19613 6238 4 case case NN 19613 6238 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6238 6 leaves leave VBZ 19613 6238 7 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6238 8 's 's POS 19613 6238 9 sin sin NN 19613 6238 10 entirely entirely RB 19613 6238 11 out out IN 19613 6238 12 of of IN 19613 6238 13 sight sight NN 19613 6238 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6238 15 . . . 19613 6239 1 But but CC 19613 6239 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6239 3 was be VBD 19613 6239 4 God God NNP 19613 6239 5 's 's POS 19613 6239 6 will will NN 19613 6239 7 to to TO 19613 6239 8 bring bring VB 19613 6239 9 men man NNS 19613 6239 10 into into IN 19613 6239 11 a a DT 19613 6239 12 higher high JJR 19613 6239 13 union union NN 19613 6239 14 with with IN 19613 6239 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6239 16 ; ; : 19613 6239 17 wherefore wherefore VBD 19613 6239 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6239 19 Son Son NNP 19613 6239 20 descended descend VBD 19613 6239 21 to to IN 19613 6239 22 men man NNS 19613 6239 23 from from IN 19613 6239 24 the the DT 19613 6239 25 beginning beginning NN 19613 6239 26 and and CC 19613 6239 27 accustomed accustom VBD 19613 6239 28 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6239 29 to to TO 19613 6239 30 dwell dwell VB 19613 6239 31 among among IN 19613 6239 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6239 33 . . . 19613 6240 1 The the DT 19613 6240 2 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 6240 3 loved love VBD 19613 6240 4 God God NNP 19613 6240 5 and and CC 19613 6240 6 refrained refrain VBN 19613 6240 7 from from IN 19613 6240 8 injustice injustice NN 19613 6240 9 towards towards IN 19613 6240 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6240 11 neighbours neighbour NNS 19613 6240 12 ; ; : 19613 6240 13 hence hence RB 19613 6240 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6240 15 was be VBD 19613 6240 16 not not RB 19613 6240 17 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6240 18 that that IN 19613 6240 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6240 20 should should MD 19613 6240 21 be be VB 19613 6240 22 exhorted exhort VBN 19613 6240 23 with with IN 19613 6240 24 the the DT 19613 6240 25 strict strict JJ 19613 6240 26 letter letter NN 19613 6240 27 of of IN 19613 6240 28 the the DT 19613 6240 29 law law NN 19613 6240 30 , , , 19613 6240 31 since since IN 19613 6240 32 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6240 33 had have VBD 19613 6240 34 the the DT 19613 6240 35 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 6240 36 of of IN 19613 6240 37 the the DT 19613 6240 38 law law NN 19613 6240 39 in in IN 19613 6240 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6240 41 . . . 19613 6241 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6241 2 642 642 CD 19613 6241 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6241 4 But but CC 19613 6241 5 , , , 19613 6241 6 as as RB 19613 6241 7 far far RB 19613 6241 8 as as IN 19613 6241 9 the the DT 19613 6241 10 great great JJ 19613 6241 11 majority majority NN 19613 6241 12 of of IN 19613 6241 13 men man NNS 19613 6241 14 are be VBP 19613 6241 15 concerned concern VBN 19613 6241 16 , , , 19613 6241 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6241 18 wandered wander VBD 19613 6241 19 away away RB 19613 6241 20 from from IN 19613 6241 21 God God NNP 19613 6241 22 and and CC 19613 6241 23 fell fall VBD 19613 6241 24 into into IN 19613 6241 25 the the DT 19613 6241 26 sorriest sorry JJS 19613 6241 27 condition condition NN 19613 6241 28 . . . 19613 6242 1 From from IN 19613 6242 2 this this DT 19613 6242 3 moment moment NN 19613 6242 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6242 5 , , , 19613 6242 6 keeping keep VBG 19613 6242 7 strictly strictly RB 19613 6242 8 to to IN 19613 6242 9 the the DT 19613 6242 10 Old Old NNP 19613 6242 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6242 12 , , , 19613 6242 13 only only RB 19613 6242 14 concerns concern VBZ 19613 6242 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6242 16 with with IN 19613 6242 17 the the DT 19613 6242 18 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6242 19 people people NNS 19613 6242 20 . . . 19613 6243 1 These these DT 19613 6243 2 are be VBP 19613 6243 3 to to IN 19613 6243 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6243 5 the the DT 19613 6243 6 representatives representative NNS 19613 6243 7 of of IN 19613 6243 8 humanity humanity NN 19613 6243 9 . . . 19613 6244 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6244 2 is be VBZ 19613 6244 3 only only RB 19613 6244 4 at at IN 19613 6244 5 this this DT 19613 6244 6 period period NN 19613 6244 7 that that IN 19613 6244 8 the the DT 19613 6244 9 training training NN 19613 6244 10 of of IN 19613 6244 11 the the DT 19613 6244 12 human human JJ 19613 6244 13 race race NN 19613 6244 14 is be VBZ 19613 6244 15 given give VBN 19613 6244 16 to to IN 19613 6244 17 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6244 18 ; ; : 19613 6244 19 but but CC 19613 6244 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6244 21 is be VBZ 19613 6244 22 really really RB 19613 6244 23 the the DT 19613 6244 24 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6244 25 _ _ NNP 19613 6244 26 nation nation NN 19613 6244 27 _ _ IN 19613 6244 28 that that IN 19613 6244 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6244 30 keeps keep VBZ 19613 6244 31 in in IN 19613 6244 32 view view NN 19613 6244 33 , , , 19613 6244 34 and and CC 19613 6244 35 through through IN 19613 6244 36 this this DT 19613 6244 37 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6244 38 differs differ VBZ 19613 6244 39 very very RB 19613 6244 40 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 6244 41 from from IN 19613 6244 42 such such JJ 19613 6244 43 as as IN 19613 6244 44 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 6244 45 . . . 19613 6245 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6245 2 643 643 CD 19613 6245 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6245 4 When when WRB 19613 6245 5 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 6245 6 and and CC 19613 6245 7 love love NN 19613 6245 8 to to IN 19613 6245 9 God God NNP 19613 6245 10 died die VBD 19613 6245 11 out out RP 19613 6245 12 in in IN 19613 6245 13 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 6245 14 , , , 19613 6245 15 God God NNP 19613 6245 16 led lead VBD 19613 6245 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6245 18 people people NNS 19613 6245 19 forth forth RB 19613 6245 20 so so IN 19613 6245 21 that that DT 19613 6245 22 man man NN 19613 6245 23 might may MD 19613 6245 24 again again RB 19613 6245 25 become become VB 19613 6245 26 a a DT 19613 6245 27 disciple disciple NN 19613 6245 28 and and CC 19613 6245 29 imitator imitator NN 19613 6245 30 of of IN 19613 6245 31 God God NNP 19613 6245 32 . . . 19613 6246 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6246 2 gave give VBD 19613 6246 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6246 4 the the DT 19613 6246 5 written write VBN 19613 6246 6 law law NN 19613 6246 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6246 8 the the DT 19613 6246 9 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 19613 6246 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6246 11 , , , 19613 6246 12 which which WDT 19613 6246 13 contains contain VBZ 19613 6246 14 nothing nothing NN 19613 6246 15 else else RB 19613 6246 16 than than IN 19613 6246 17 the the DT 19613 6246 18 moral moral JJ 19613 6246 19 law law NN 19613 6246 20 of of IN 19613 6246 21 nature nature NN 19613 6246 22 that that WDT 19613 6246 23 had have VBD 19613 6246 24 fallen fall VBN 19613 6246 25 into into IN 19613 6246 26 oblivion oblivion NN 19613 6246 27 . . . 19613 6247 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6247 2 644 644 CD 19613 6247 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6247 4 But but CC 19613 6247 5 when when WRB 19613 6247 6 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6247 7 made make VBD 19613 6247 8 to to IN 19613 6247 9 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6247 10 a a DT 19613 6247 11 golden golden JJ 19613 6247 12 calf calf NN 19613 6247 13 and and CC 19613 6247 14 chose choose VBD 19613 6247 15 to to TO 19613 6247 16 be be VB 19613 6247 17 slaves slave NNS 19613 6247 18 rather rather RB 19613 6247 19 than than IN 19613 6247 20 free free JJ 19613 6247 21 men man NNS 19613 6247 22 , , , 19613 6247 23 then then RB 19613 6247 24 the the DT 19613 6247 25 Word Word NNP 19613 6247 26 , , , 19613 6247 27 through through IN 19613 6247 28 the the DT 19613 6247 29 instrumentality instrumentality NN 19613 6247 30 of of IN 19613 6247 31 Moses Moses NNP 19613 6247 32 , , , 19613 6247 33 gave give VBD 19613 6247 34 to to IN 19613 6247 35 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6247 36 , , , 19613 6247 37 as as IN 19613 6247 38 a a DT 19613 6247 39 particular particular JJ 19613 6247 40 addition addition NN 19613 6247 41 , , , 19613 6247 42 the the DT 19613 6247 43 commandments commandment NNS 19613 6247 44 of of IN 19613 6247 45 slavery slavery NN 19613 6247 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6247 47 the the DT 19613 6247 48 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6247 49 law law NN 19613 6247 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6247 51 in in IN 19613 6247 52 a a DT 19613 6247 53 form form NN 19613 6247 54 suitable suitable JJ 19613 6247 55 for for IN 19613 6247 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6247 57 training training NN 19613 6247 58 . . . 19613 6248 1 These these DT 19613 6248 2 were be VBD 19613 6248 3 bodily bodily JJ 19613 6248 4 commandments commandment NNS 19613 6248 5 of of IN 19613 6248 6 bondage bondage NN 19613 6248 7 which which WDT 19613 6248 8 did do VBD 19613 6248 9 not not RB 19613 6248 10 separate separate VB 19613 6248 11 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6248 12 from from IN 19613 6248 13 God God NNP 19613 6248 14 , , , 19613 6248 15 but but CC 19613 6248 16 held hold VBD 19613 6248 17 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6248 18 in in IN 19613 6248 19 the the DT 19613 6248 20 yoke yoke NN 19613 6248 21 . . . 19613 6249 1 The the DT 19613 6249 2 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6249 3 law law NN 19613 6249 4 was be VBD 19613 6249 5 thus thus RB 19613 6249 6 a a DT 19613 6249 7 pedagogic pedagogic JJ 19613 6249 8 means mean NNS 19613 6249 9 of of IN 19613 6249 10 preserving preserve VBG 19613 6249 11 the the DT 19613 6249 12 people people NNS 19613 6249 13 from from IN 19613 6249 14 idolatry idolatry NN 19613 6249 15 ; ; : 19613 6249 16 but but CC 19613 6249 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6249 18 was be VBD 19613 6249 19 at at IN 19613 6249 20 the the DT 19613 6249 21 same same JJ 19613 6249 22 time time NN 19613 6249 23 a a DT 19613 6249 24 type type NN 19613 6249 25 of of IN 19613 6249 26 the the DT 19613 6249 27 future future NN 19613 6249 28 . . . 19613 6250 1 Each each DT 19613 6250 2 constituent constituent NN 19613 6250 3 of of IN 19613 6250 4 the the DT 19613 6250 5 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6250 6 law law NN 19613 6250 7 has have VBZ 19613 6250 8 this this DT 19613 6250 9 double double JJ 19613 6250 10 signification signification NN 19613 6250 11 , , , 19613 6250 12 and and CC 19613 6250 13 both both DT 19613 6250 14 of of IN 19613 6250 15 these these DT 19613 6250 16 meanings meaning NNS 19613 6250 17 originate originate VBP 19613 6250 18 with with IN 19613 6250 19 God God NNP 19613 6250 20 , , , 19613 6250 21 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6250 22 , , , 19613 6250 23 with with IN 19613 6250 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6250 25 ; ; : 19613 6250 26 for for IN 19613 6250 27 " " `` 19613 6250 28 how how WRB 19613 6250 29 is be VBZ 19613 6250 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6250 31 the the DT 19613 6250 32 end end NN 19613 6250 33 of of IN 19613 6250 34 the the DT 19613 6250 35 law law NN 19613 6250 36 , , , 19613 6250 37 if if IN 19613 6250 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6250 39 be be VBP 19613 6250 40 not not RB 19613 6250 41 the the DT 19613 6250 42 beginning beginning NN 19613 6250 43 of of IN 19613 6250 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6250 45 ? ? . 19613 6250 46 " " '' 19613 6251 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6251 2 " " `` 19613 6251 3 quomodo quomodo NNP 19613 6251 4 finis finis NNP 19613 6251 5 legis legis NNP 19613 6251 6 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6251 7 , , , 19613 6251 8 si si VBP 19613 6251 9 non non AFX 19613 6251 10 et et FW 19613 6251 11 initium initium NNP 19613 6251 12 eius eius NNP 19613 6251 13 esset esset NNP 19613 6251 14 " " '' 19613 6251 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6251 16 IV IV NNP 19613 6251 17 . . . 19613 6252 1 12 12 CD 19613 6252 2 . . . 19613 6253 1 4 4 LS 19613 6253 2 . . . 19613 6254 1 Everything everything NN 19613 6254 2 in in IN 19613 6254 3 the the DT 19613 6254 4 law law NN 19613 6254 5 is be VBZ 19613 6254 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 6254 7 holy holy JJ 19613 6254 8 , , , 19613 6254 9 and and CC 19613 6254 10 moreover moreover RB 19613 6254 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6254 12 are be VBP 19613 6254 13 only only RB 19613 6254 14 entitled entitle VBN 19613 6254 15 to to TO 19613 6254 16 blame blame VB 19613 6254 17 such such JJ 19613 6254 18 portions portion NNS 19613 6254 19 of of IN 19613 6254 20 the the DT 19613 6254 21 history history NN 19613 6254 22 of of IN 19613 6254 23 the the DT 19613 6254 24 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6254 25 nation nation NN 19613 6254 26 as as IN 19613 6254 27 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6254 28 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 6254 29 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6254 30 condemns condemn VBZ 19613 6254 31 . . . 19613 6255 1 This this DT 19613 6255 2 nation nation NN 19613 6255 3 was be VBD 19613 6255 4 obliged oblige VBN 19613 6255 5 to to TO 19613 6255 6 circumcise circumcise VB 19613 6255 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6255 8 , , , 19613 6255 9 keep keep VB 19613 6255 10 Sabbaths Sabbaths NNPS 19613 6255 11 , , , 19613 6255 12 offer offer VB 19613 6255 13 up up RP 19613 6255 14 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 19613 6255 15 , , , 19613 6255 16 and and CC 19613 6255 17 do do VB 19613 6255 18 whatever whatever WDT 19613 6255 19 is be VBZ 19613 6255 20 related relate VBN 19613 6255 21 of of IN 19613 6255 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6255 23 , , , 19613 6255 24 so so RB 19613 6255 25 far far RB 19613 6255 26 as as IN 19613 6255 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6255 28 action action NN 19613 6255 29 is be VBZ 19613 6255 30 not not RB 19613 6255 31 censured censure VBN 19613 6255 32 . . . 19613 6256 1 All all PDT 19613 6256 2 this this DT 19613 6256 3 belonged belong VBD 19613 6256 4 to to IN 19613 6256 5 the the DT 19613 6256 6 state state NN 19613 6256 7 of of IN 19613 6256 8 bondage bondage NN 19613 6256 9 in in IN 19613 6256 10 which which WDT 19613 6256 11 men man NNS 19613 6256 12 had have VBD 19613 6256 13 a a DT 19613 6256 14 _ _ NNP 19613 6256 15 covenant covenant NN 19613 6256 16 _ _ NNP 19613 6256 17 with with IN 19613 6256 18 God God NNP 19613 6256 19 and and CC 19613 6256 20 in in IN 19613 6256 21 which which WDT 19613 6256 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6256 23 also also RB 19613 6256 24 possessed possess VBD 19613 6256 25 the the DT 19613 6256 26 right right JJ 19613 6256 27 faith faith NN 19613 6256 28 in in IN 19613 6256 29 the the DT 19613 6256 30 one one NN 19613 6256 31 God God NNP 19613 6256 32 and and CC 19613 6256 33 were be VBD 19613 6256 34 taught teach VBN 19613 6256 35 before before IN 19613 6256 36 hand hand NN 19613 6256 37 to to TO 19613 6256 38 follow follow VB 19613 6256 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6256 40 Son Son NNP 19613 6256 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6256 42 IV IV NNP 19613 6256 43 . . . 19613 6257 1 12 12 CD 19613 6257 2 , , , 19613 6257 3 5 5 CD 19613 6257 4 ; ; : 19613 6257 5 " " `` 19613 6257 6 lex lex NNP 19613 6257 7 prædocuit prædocuit NNP 19613 6257 8 hominem hominem NNP 19613 6257 9 sequi sequi NNP 19613 6257 10 oportere oportere NNP 19613 6257 11 Christum Christum NNP 19613 6257 12 " " '' 19613 6257 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6257 14 . . . 19613 6258 1 In in IN 19613 6258 2 addition addition NN 19613 6258 3 to to IN 19613 6258 4 this this DT 19613 6258 5 , , , 19613 6258 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6258 7 continually continually RB 19613 6258 8 manifested manifest VBD 19613 6258 9 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6258 10 to to IN 19613 6258 11 the the DT 19613 6258 12 people people NNS 19613 6258 13 in in IN 19613 6258 14 the the DT 19613 6258 15 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6258 16 , , , 19613 6258 17 through through IN 19613 6258 18 whom whom WP 19613 6258 19 also also RB 19613 6258 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6258 21 indicated indicate VBD 19613 6258 22 the the DT 19613 6258 23 future future NN 19613 6258 24 and and CC 19613 6258 25 prepared prepared JJ 19613 6258 26 men man NNS 19613 6258 27 for for IN 19613 6258 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6258 29 appearance appearance NN 19613 6258 30 . . . 19613 6259 1 In in IN 19613 6259 2 the the DT 19613 6259 3 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6259 4 the the DT 19613 6259 5 Son Son NNP 19613 6259 6 of of IN 19613 6259 7 God God NNP 19613 6259 8 accustomed accustom VBD 19613 6259 9 men man NNS 19613 6259 10 to to TO 19613 6259 11 be be VB 19613 6259 12 instruments instrument NNS 19613 6259 13 of of IN 19613 6259 14 the the DT 19613 6259 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6259 16 of of IN 19613 6259 17 God God NNP 19613 6259 18 and and CC 19613 6259 19 to to TO 19613 6259 20 have have VB 19613 6259 21 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 6259 22 with with IN 19613 6259 23 the the DT 19613 6259 24 Father Father NNP 19613 6259 25 in in IN 19613 6259 26 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6259 27 ; ; : 19613 6259 28 and and CC 19613 6259 29 in in IN 19613 6259 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6259 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6259 32 habituated habituate VBD 19613 6259 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6259 34 to to TO 19613 6259 35 enter enter VB 19613 6259 36 bodily bodily RB 19613 6259 37 into into IN 19613 6259 38 humanity humanity NN 19613 6259 39 . . . 19613 6260 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6260 2 645 645 CD 19613 6260 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6260 4 Hereupon Hereupon NNPS 19613 6260 5 began begin VBD 19613 6260 6 the the DT 19613 6260 7 last last JJ 19613 6260 8 stage stage NN 19613 6260 9 , , , 19613 6260 10 in in IN 19613 6260 11 which which WDT 19613 6260 12 men man NNS 19613 6260 13 , , , 19613 6260 14 being be VBG 19613 6260 15 now now RB 19613 6260 16 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 6260 17 trained train VBN 19613 6260 18 , , , 19613 6260 19 were be VBD 19613 6260 20 to to TO 19613 6260 21 receive receive VB 19613 6260 22 the the DT 19613 6260 23 " " `` 19613 6260 24 testamentum testamentum NN 19613 6260 25 libertatis libertatis NNP 19613 6260 26 " " '' 19613 6260 27 and and CC 19613 6260 28 be be VB 19613 6260 29 adopted adopt VBN 19613 6260 30 as as IN 19613 6260 31 Sons Sons NNPS 19613 6260 32 of of IN 19613 6260 33 God God NNP 19613 6260 34 . . . 19613 6261 1 By by IN 19613 6261 2 the the DT 19613 6261 3 union union NN 19613 6261 4 of of IN 19613 6261 5 the the DT 19613 6261 6 Son Son NNP 19613 6261 7 of of IN 19613 6261 8 God God NNP 19613 6261 9 with with IN 19613 6261 10 the the DT 19613 6261 11 flesh flesh NN 19613 6261 12 the the DT 19613 6261 13 _ _ NNP 19613 6261 14 agnitio agnitio NN 19613 6261 15 filii filii NNP 19613 6261 16 _ _ NNP 19613 6261 17 first first RB 19613 6261 18 became become VBD 19613 6261 19 possible possible JJ 19613 6261 20 to to IN 19613 6261 21 all all DT 19613 6261 22 ; ; : 19613 6261 23 that that DT 19613 6261 24 is be VBZ 19613 6261 25 the the DT 19613 6261 26 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 6261 27 novelty novelty NN 19613 6261 28 . . . 19613 6262 1 The the DT 19613 6262 2 next next JJ 19613 6262 3 problem problem NN 19613 6262 4 was be VBD 19613 6262 5 to to TO 19613 6262 6 restore restore VB 19613 6262 7 the the DT 19613 6262 8 law law NN 19613 6262 9 of of IN 19613 6262 10 freedom freedom NN 19613 6262 11 . . . 19613 6263 1 Here here RB 19613 6263 2 a a DT 19613 6263 3 threefold threefold JJ 19613 6263 4 process process NN 19613 6263 5 was be VBD 19613 6263 6 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6263 7 . . . 19613 6264 1 In in IN 19613 6264 2 the the DT 19613 6264 3 first first JJ 19613 6264 4 place place NN 19613 6264 5 the the DT 19613 6264 6 Law Law NNP 19613 6264 7 of of IN 19613 6264 8 Moses Moses NNP 19613 6264 9 , , , 19613 6264 10 the the DT 19613 6264 11 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 19613 6264 12 , , , 19613 6264 13 had have VBD 19613 6264 14 been be VBN 19613 6264 15 disfigured disfigure VBN 19613 6264 16 and and CC 19613 6264 17 blunted blunt VBN 19613 6264 18 by by IN 19613 6264 19 the the DT 19613 6264 20 " " `` 19613 6264 21 traditio traditio NNP 19613 6264 22 seniorum seniorum NN 19613 6264 23 " " '' 19613 6264 24 . . . 19613 6265 1 First first RB 19613 6265 2 of of IN 19613 6265 3 all all DT 19613 6265 4 then then RB 19613 6265 5 the the DT 19613 6265 6 pure pure JJ 19613 6265 7 moral moral JJ 19613 6265 8 law law NN 19613 6265 9 had have VBD 19613 6265 10 to to TO 19613 6265 11 be be VB 19613 6265 12 restored restore VBN 19613 6265 13 ; ; : 19613 6265 14 secondly secondly RB 19613 6265 15 , , , 19613 6265 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6265 17 was be VBD 19613 6265 18 now now RB 19613 6265 19 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6265 20 to to TO 19613 6265 21 extend extend VB 19613 6265 22 and and CC 19613 6265 23 fulfil fulfil VB 19613 6265 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6265 25 by by IN 19613 6265 26 expressly expressly RB 19613 6265 27 searching search VBG 19613 6265 28 out out RP 19613 6265 29 the the DT 19613 6265 30 inclinations inclination NNS 19613 6265 31 of of IN 19613 6265 32 the the DT 19613 6265 33 heart heart NN 19613 6265 34 in in IN 19613 6265 35 all all DT 19613 6265 36 cases case NNS 19613 6265 37 , , , 19613 6265 38 thus thus RB 19613 6265 39 unveiling unveil VBG 19613 6265 40 the the DT 19613 6265 41 law law NN 19613 6265 42 in in IN 19613 6265 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6265 44 whole whole JJ 19613 6265 45 severity severity NN 19613 6265 46 ; ; : 19613 6265 47 and and CC 19613 6265 48 lastly lastly RB 19613 6265 49 the the DT 19613 6265 50 _ _ NNP 19613 6265 51 particularia particularia NN 19613 6265 52 legis legis NNP 19613 6265 53 _ _ NNP 19613 6265 54 , , , 19613 6265 55 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6265 56 , , , 19613 6265 57 the the DT 19613 6265 58 law law NN 19613 6265 59 of of IN 19613 6265 60 bondage bondage NN 19613 6265 61 , , , 19613 6265 62 had have VBD 19613 6265 63 to to TO 19613 6265 64 be be VB 19613 6265 65 abolished abolish VBN 19613 6265 66 . . . 19613 6266 1 But but CC 19613 6266 2 in in IN 19613 6266 3 the the DT 19613 6266 4 latter latter JJ 19613 6266 5 connection connection NN 19613 6266 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6266 7 and and CC 19613 6266 8 the the DT 19613 6266 9 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 6266 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6266 11 avoided avoid VBD 19613 6266 12 every every DT 19613 6266 13 transgression transgression NN 19613 6266 14 of of IN 19613 6266 15 the the DT 19613 6266 16 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 6266 17 law law NN 19613 6266 18 , , , 19613 6266 19 in in IN 19613 6266 20 order order NN 19613 6266 21 to to TO 19613 6266 22 prove prove VB 19613 6266 23 that that IN 19613 6266 24 this this DT 19613 6266 25 also also RB 19613 6266 26 had have VBD 19613 6266 27 a a DT 19613 6266 28 divine divine JJ 19613 6266 29 origin origin NN 19613 6266 30 . . . 19613 6267 1 The the DT 19613 6267 2 non non JJ 19613 6267 3 - - JJ 19613 6267 4 observance observance NN 19613 6267 5 of of IN 19613 6267 6 this this DT 19613 6267 7 law law NN 19613 6267 8 was be VBD 19613 6267 9 first first RB 19613 6267 10 permitted permit VBN 19613 6267 11 to to IN 19613 6267 12 the the DT 19613 6267 13 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 6267 14 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 6267 15 . . . 19613 6268 1 Thus thus RB 19613 6268 2 , , , 19613 6268 3 no no RB 19613 6268 4 doubt doubt RB 19613 6268 5 , , , 19613 6268 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6268 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6268 8 is be VBZ 19613 6268 9 the the DT 19613 6268 10 end end NN 19613 6268 11 of of IN 19613 6268 12 the the DT 19613 6268 13 law law NN 19613 6268 14 , , , 19613 6268 15 but but CC 19613 6268 16 only only RB 19613 6268 17 in in IN 19613 6268 18 so so RB 19613 6268 19 far far RB 19613 6268 20 as as IN 19613 6268 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6268 22 has have VBZ 19613 6268 23 abolished abolish VBN 19613 6268 24 the the DT 19613 6268 25 law law NN 19613 6268 26 of of IN 19613 6268 27 bondage bondage NN 19613 6268 28 and and CC 19613 6268 29 restored restore VBD 19613 6268 30 the the DT 19613 6268 31 moral moral JJ 19613 6268 32 law law NN 19613 6268 33 in in IN 19613 6268 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6268 35 whole whole JJ 19613 6268 36 purity purity NN 19613 6268 37 and and CC 19613 6268 38 severity severity NN 19613 6268 39 , , , 19613 6268 40 and and CC 19613 6268 41 given give VBN 19613 6268 42 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6268 43 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6268 44 . . . 19613 6269 1 The the DT 19613 6269 2 question question NN 19613 6269 3 as as IN 19613 6269 4 to to IN 19613 6269 5 the the DT 19613 6269 6 difference difference NN 19613 6269 7 between between IN 19613 6269 8 the the DT 19613 6269 9 New New NNP 19613 6269 10 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6269 11 and and CC 19613 6269 12 the the DT 19613 6269 13 Old Old NNP 19613 6269 14 is be VBZ 19613 6269 15 therefore therefore RB 19613 6269 16 answered answer VBN 19613 6269 17 by by IN 19613 6269 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6269 19 in in IN 19613 6269 20 the the DT 19613 6269 21 following follow VBG 19613 6269 22 manner manner NN 19613 6269 23 . . . 19613 6270 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6270 2 consists consist VBZ 19613 6270 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6270 4 1 1 CD 19613 6270 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6270 6 in in IN 19613 6270 7 the the DT 19613 6270 8 _ _ NNP 19613 6270 9 agnitio agnitio NN 19613 6270 10 filii filii VBP 19613 6270 11 _ _ NNP 19613 6270 12 and and CC 19613 6270 13 consequent consequent JJ 19613 6270 14 transformation transformation NN 19613 6270 15 of of IN 19613 6270 16 the the DT 19613 6270 17 slaves slave NNS 19613 6270 18 into into IN 19613 6270 19 children child NNS 19613 6270 20 of of IN 19613 6270 21 God God NNP 19613 6270 22 ; ; : 19613 6270 23 and and CC 19613 6270 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6270 25 2 2 LS 19613 6270 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6270 27 in in IN 19613 6270 28 the the DT 19613 6270 29 restoration restoration NN 19613 6270 30 of of IN 19613 6270 31 the the DT 19613 6270 32 law law NN 19613 6270 33 , , , 19613 6270 34 which which WDT 19613 6270 35 is be VBZ 19613 6270 36 a a DT 19613 6270 37 law law NN 19613 6270 38 of of IN 19613 6270 39 freedom freedom NN 19613 6270 40 just just RB 19613 6270 41 because because IN 19613 6270 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6270 43 excludes exclude VBZ 19613 6270 44 bodily bodily JJ 19613 6270 45 commandments commandment NNS 19613 6270 46 , , , 19613 6270 47 and and CC 19613 6270 48 with with IN 19613 6270 49 stricter strict JJR 19613 6270 50 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6270 51 lays lay VBZ 19613 6270 52 the the DT 19613 6270 53 whole whole JJ 19613 6270 54 stress stress NN 19613 6270 55 on on IN 19613 6270 56 the the DT 19613 6270 57 inclinations inclination NNS 19613 6270 58 of of IN 19613 6270 59 the the DT 19613 6270 60 heart heart NN 19613 6270 61 . . . 19613 6271 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6271 2 646 646 CD 19613 6271 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6271 4 But but CC 19613 6271 5 in in IN 19613 6271 6 these these DT 19613 6271 7 two two CD 19613 6271 8 respects respect NNS 19613 6271 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6271 10 finds find VBZ 19613 6271 11 a a DT 19613 6271 12 real real JJ 19613 6271 13 addition addition NN 19613 6271 14 , , , 19613 6271 15 and and CC 19613 6271 16 hence hence RB 19613 6271 17 , , , 19613 6271 18 in in IN 19613 6271 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6271 20 opinion opinion NN 19613 6271 21 , , , 19613 6271 22 the the DT 19613 6271 23 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 6271 24 stand stand VBP 19613 6271 25 higher high JJR 19613 6271 26 than than IN 19613 6271 27 the the DT 19613 6271 28 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6271 29 . . . 19613 6272 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6272 2 proves prove VBZ 19613 6272 3 this this DT 19613 6272 4 higher high JJR 19613 6272 5 position position NN 19613 6272 6 of of IN 19613 6272 7 the the DT 19613 6272 8 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 6272 9 by by IN 19613 6272 10 a a DT 19613 6272 11 surprising surprising JJ 19613 6272 12 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6272 13 of of IN 19613 6272 14 1 1 CD 19613 6272 15 Cor Cor NNP 19613 6272 16 . . . 19613 6273 1 XII XII NNP 19613 6273 2 . . . 19613 6274 1 28 28 CD 19613 6274 2 , , , 19613 6274 3 conceiving conceive VBG 19613 6274 4 the the DT 19613 6274 5 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6274 6 named name VBN 19613 6274 7 in in IN 19613 6274 8 that that DT 19613 6274 9 passage passage NN 19613 6274 10 to to TO 19613 6274 11 be be VB 19613 6274 12 those those DT 19613 6274 13 of of IN 19613 6274 14 the the DT 19613 6274 15 Old Old NNP 19613 6274 16 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6274 17 . . . 19613 6275 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6275 2 647 647 CD 19613 6275 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6275 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6275 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 6275 6 views view VBZ 19613 6275 7 the the DT 19613 6275 8 two two CD 19613 6275 9 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6275 10 as as IN 19613 6275 11 of of IN 19613 6275 12 the the DT 19613 6275 13 same same JJ 19613 6275 14 nature nature NN 19613 6275 15 , , , 19613 6275 16 but but CC 19613 6275 17 " " `` 19613 6275 18 greater great JJR 19613 6275 19 is be VBZ 19613 6275 20 the the DT 19613 6275 21 legislation legislation NN 19613 6275 22 which which WDT 19613 6275 23 confers confer VBZ 19613 6275 24 liberty liberty NN 19613 6275 25 than than IN 19613 6275 26 that that DT 19613 6275 27 which which WDT 19613 6275 28 brings bring VBZ 19613 6275 29 bondage bondage NN 19613 6275 30 " " '' 19613 6275 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6275 32 " " `` 19613 6275 33 maior maior NNP 19613 6275 34 est est NNP 19613 6275 35 legisdatio legisdatio NNP 19613 6275 36 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6275 37 in in IN 19613 6275 38 libertatem libertatem NN 19613 6275 39 , , , 19613 6275 40 quam quam NNP 19613 6275 41 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6275 42 data data NNP 19613 6275 43 est est NNP 19613 6275 44 in in IN 19613 6275 45 servitutem servitutem NNP 19613 6275 46 " " '' 19613 6275 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6275 48 . . . 19613 6276 1 Through through IN 19613 6276 2 the the DT 19613 6276 3 two two CD 19613 6276 4 covenants covenant NNS 19613 6276 5 the the DT 19613 6276 6 accomplishment accomplishment NN 19613 6276 7 of of IN 19613 6276 8 salvation salvation NN 19613 6276 9 was be VBD 19613 6276 10 to to TO 19613 6276 11 be be VB 19613 6276 12 hastened hasten VBN 19613 6276 13 " " `` 19613 6276 14 for for IN 19613 6276 15 there there EX 19613 6276 16 is be VBZ 19613 6276 17 one one CD 19613 6276 18 salvation salvation NN 19613 6276 19 and and CC 19613 6276 20 one one CD 19613 6276 21 God God NNP 19613 6276 22 ; ; : 19613 6276 23 but but CC 19613 6276 24 the the DT 19613 6276 25 precepts precept NNS 19613 6276 26 that that WDT 19613 6276 27 form form VBP 19613 6276 28 man man NN 19613 6276 29 are be VBP 19613 6276 30 numerous numerous JJ 19613 6276 31 , , , 19613 6276 32 and and CC 19613 6276 33 the the DT 19613 6276 34 steps step NNS 19613 6276 35 that that WDT 19613 6276 36 lead lead VBP 19613 6276 37 man man NN 19613 6276 38 to to IN 19613 6276 39 God God NNP 19613 6276 40 are be VBP 19613 6276 41 not not RB 19613 6276 42 a a DT 19613 6276 43 few few JJ 19613 6276 44 ; ; : 19613 6276 45 " " '' 19613 6276 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6276 47 " " `` 19613 6276 48 una una NNP 19613 6276 49 est est NNP 19613 6276 50 enim enim NNP 19613 6276 51 salus salus NNP 19613 6276 52 et et NNP 19613 6276 53 unus unus JJ 19613 6276 54 deus deus NNP 19613 6276 55 ; ; : 19613 6276 56 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6276 57 autem autem NNP 19613 6276 58 formant formant NNP 19613 6276 59 hominem hominem NNP 19613 6276 60 , , , 19613 6276 61 præcepta præcepta NNP 19613 6276 62 multa multa NNP 19613 6276 63 et et NNP 19613 6276 64 non non NNP 19613 6276 65 pauci pauci NNP 19613 6276 66 gradus gradus NNP 19613 6276 67 , , , 19613 6276 68 qui qui NNP 19613 6276 69 adducunt adducunt NNP 19613 6276 70 hominem hominem NNP 19613 6276 71 ad ad NNP 19613 6276 72 deum deum NNP 19613 6276 73 " " '' 19613 6276 74 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6276 75 . . . 19613 6277 1 A a DT 19613 6277 2 worldly worldly JJ 19613 6277 3 king king NN 19613 6277 4 can can MD 19613 6277 5 increase increase VB 19613 6277 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6277 7 benefits benefit NNS 19613 6277 8 to to IN 19613 6277 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6277 10 subjects subject NNS 19613 6277 11 ; ; : 19613 6277 12 and and CC 19613 6277 13 should should MD 19613 6277 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6277 15 not not RB 19613 6277 16 also also RB 19613 6277 17 be be VB 19613 6277 18 lawful lawful JJ 19613 6277 19 for for IN 19613 6277 20 God God NNP 19613 6277 21 , , , 19613 6277 22 though though IN 19613 6277 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6277 24 is be VBZ 19613 6277 25 always always RB 19613 6277 26 the the DT 19613 6277 27 same same JJ 19613 6277 28 , , , 19613 6277 29 to to TO 19613 6277 30 honour honour VB 19613 6277 31 continually continually RB 19613 6277 32 with with IN 19613 6277 33 greater great JJR 19613 6277 34 gifts gift NNS 19613 6277 35 those those DT 19613 6277 36 who who WP 19613 6277 37 are be VBP 19613 6277 38 well well RB 19613 6277 39 pleasing pleasing JJ 19613 6277 40 to to IN 19613 6277 41 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6277 42 ? ? . 19613 6278 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6278 2 IV IV NNP 19613 6278 3 . . . 19613 6279 1 9 9 CD 19613 6279 2 . . . 19613 6280 1 3 3 LS 19613 6280 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6280 3 . . . 19613 6281 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6281 2 makes make VBZ 19613 6281 3 no no DT 19613 6281 4 direct direct JJ 19613 6281 5 statement statement NN 19613 6281 6 as as IN 19613 6281 7 to to IN 19613 6281 8 the the DT 19613 6281 9 further further JJ 19613 6281 10 importance importance NN 19613 6281 11 which which WDT 19613 6281 12 the the DT 19613 6281 13 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 6281 14 people people NNS 19613 6281 15 have have VBP 19613 6281 16 , , , 19613 6281 17 and and CC 19613 6281 18 in in IN 19613 6281 19 any any DT 19613 6281 20 case case NN 19613 6281 21 regards regard VBZ 19613 6281 22 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6281 23 as as IN 19613 6281 24 of of IN 19613 6281 25 no no DT 19613 6281 26 consequence consequence NN 19613 6281 27 after after IN 19613 6281 28 the the DT 19613 6281 29 appearance appearance NN 19613 6281 30 of of IN 19613 6281 31 the the DT 19613 6281 32 covenant covenant NN 19613 6281 33 of of IN 19613 6281 34 freedom freedom NN 19613 6281 35 . . . 19613 6282 1 Nor nor CC 19613 6282 2 does do VBZ 19613 6282 3 this this DT 19613 6282 4 nation nation NN 19613 6282 5 appear appear VB 19613 6282 6 any any DT 19613 6282 7 further further RB 19613 6282 8 even even RB 19613 6282 9 in in IN 19613 6282 10 the the DT 19613 6282 11 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 6282 12 train train NN 19613 6282 13 of of IN 19613 6282 14 thought thought NN 19613 6282 15 . . . 19613 6283 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6283 2 furnishes furnish VBZ 19613 6283 3 the the DT 19613 6283 4 Antichrist Antichrist NNP 19613 6283 5 and and CC 19613 6283 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6283 7 holy holy JJ 19613 6283 8 city city NN 19613 6283 9 becomes become VBZ 19613 6283 10 the the DT 19613 6283 11 capital capital NN 19613 6283 12 of of IN 19613 6283 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6283 14 's 's POS 19613 6283 15 earthly earthly JJ 19613 6283 16 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6283 17 ; ; : 19613 6283 18 but but CC 19613 6283 19 the the DT 19613 6283 20 nation nation NN 19613 6283 21 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6283 22 , , , 19613 6283 23 which which WDT 19613 6283 24 , , , 19613 6283 25 according accord VBG 19613 6283 26 to to IN 19613 6283 27 this this DT 19613 6283 28 theory theory NN 19613 6283 29 , , , 19613 6283 30 had have VBD 19613 6283 31 represented represent VBN 19613 6283 32 all all DT 19613 6283 33 mankind mankind NN 19613 6283 34 from from IN 19613 6283 35 Moses Moses NNP 19613 6283 36 to to IN 19613 6283 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6283 38 , , , 19613 6283 39 just just RB 19613 6283 40 as as IN 19613 6283 41 if if IN 19613 6283 42 all all DT 19613 6283 43 men man NNS 19613 6283 44 had have VBD 19613 6283 45 been be VBN 19613 6283 46 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 6283 47 , , , 19613 6283 48 now now RB 19613 6283 49 entirely entirely RB 19613 6283 50 disappears disappear VBZ 19613 6283 51 . . . 19613 6284 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6284 2 648 648 CD 19613 6284 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6284 4 This this DT 19613 6284 5 conception conception NN 19613 6284 6 , , , 19613 6284 7 in in IN 19613 6284 8 spite spite NN 19613 6284 9 of of IN 19613 6284 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6284 11 want want NN 19613 6284 12 of of IN 19613 6284 13 stringency stringency NN 19613 6284 14 , , , 19613 6284 15 made make VBD 19613 6284 16 an an DT 19613 6284 17 immense immense JJ 19613 6284 18 impression impression NN 19613 6284 19 , , , 19613 6284 20 and and CC 19613 6284 21 has have VBZ 19613 6284 22 continued continue VBN 19613 6284 23 to to TO 19613 6284 24 prevail prevail VB 19613 6284 25 down down RP 19613 6284 26 to to IN 19613 6284 27 the the DT 19613 6284 28 present present JJ 19613 6284 29 time time NN 19613 6284 30 . . . 19613 6285 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6285 2 has have VBZ 19613 6285 3 , , , 19613 6285 4 however however RB 19613 6285 5 , , , 19613 6285 6 been be VBN 19613 6285 7 modified modify VBN 19613 6285 8 by by IN 19613 6285 9 a a DT 19613 6285 10 combination combination NN 19613 6285 11 with with IN 19613 6285 12 the the DT 19613 6285 13 Augustinian augustinian JJ 19613 6285 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6285 15 of of IN 19613 6285 16 sin sin NN 19613 6285 17 and and CC 19613 6285 18 grace grace NN 19613 6285 19 . . . 19613 6286 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6286 2 was be VBD 19613 6286 3 soon soon RB 19613 6286 4 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 6286 5 as as IN 19613 6286 6 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6286 7 's 's POS 19613 6286 8 conception conception NN 19613 6286 9 , , , 19613 6286 10 to to TO 19613 6286 11 which which WDT 19613 6286 12 in in IN 19613 6286 13 fact fact NN 19613 6286 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6286 15 has have VBZ 19613 6286 16 a a DT 19613 6286 17 distant distant JJ 19613 6286 18 relationship relationship NN 19613 6286 19 . . . 19613 6287 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6287 2 had have VBD 19613 6287 3 already already RB 19613 6287 4 adopted adopt VBN 19613 6287 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6287 6 in in IN 19613 6287 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6287 8 essential essential JJ 19613 6287 9 features feature NNS 19613 6287 10 , , , 19613 6287 11 amplified amplify VBD 19613 6287 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6287 13 in in IN 19613 6287 14 some some DT 19613 6287 15 points point NNS 19613 6287 16 , , , 19613 6287 17 and and CC 19613 6287 18 , , , 19613 6287 19 in in IN 19613 6287 20 accordance accordance NN 19613 6287 21 with with IN 19613 6287 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6287 23 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 6287 24 ideas idea NNS 19613 6287 25 , , , 19613 6287 26 enriched enrich VBD 19613 6287 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6287 28 by by IN 19613 6287 29 adding add VBG 19613 6287 30 a a DT 19613 6287 31 fourth fourth JJ 19613 6287 32 stage stage NN 19613 6287 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6287 34 ab ab NNP 19613 6287 35 initio initio NN 19613 6287 36 -- -- : 19613 6287 37 Moses Moses NNP 19613 6287 38 -- -- : 19613 6287 39 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6287 40 -- -- : 19613 6287 41 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 6287 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6287 43 . . . 19613 6288 1 But but CC 19613 6288 2 this this DT 19613 6288 3 addition addition NN 19613 6288 4 was be VBD 19613 6288 5 not not RB 19613 6288 6 accepted accept VBN 19613 6288 7 by by IN 19613 6288 8 the the DT 19613 6288 9 Church Church NNP 19613 6288 10 . . . 19613 6289 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6289 2 649 649 CD 19613 6289 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6289 4 3 3 CD 19613 6289 5 . . . 19613 6290 1 _ _ NNP 19613 6290 2 Results Results NNP 19613 6290 3 to to IN 19613 6290 4 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6290 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6290 6 . . . 19613 6290 7 _ _ NNP 19613 6290 8 As as IN 19613 6290 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6290 10 have have VBP 19613 6290 11 shown show VBN 19613 6290 12 , , , 19613 6290 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6290 14 , , , 19613 6290 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6290 16 , , , 19613 6290 17 and and CC 19613 6290 18 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6290 19 had have VBD 19613 6290 20 no no RB 19613 6290 21 strictly strictly RB 19613 6290 22 systematised systematise VBN 19613 6290 23 theology theology NN 19613 6290 24 ; ; : 19613 6290 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6290 26 formulated formulate VBD 19613 6290 27 theological theological JJ 19613 6290 28 propositions proposition NNS 19613 6290 29 because because IN 19613 6290 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6290 31 opponents opponent NNS 19613 6290 32 were be VBD 19613 6290 33 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6290 34 . . . 19613 6291 1 Hence hence RB 19613 6291 2 the the DT 19613 6291 3 result result NN 19613 6291 4 of of IN 19613 6291 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6291 6 labours labour NNS 19613 6291 7 , , , 19613 6291 8 so so RB 19613 6291 9 far far RB 19613 6291 10 as as IN 19613 6291 11 this this DT 19613 6291 12 was be VBD 19613 6291 13 accepted accept VBN 19613 6291 14 by by IN 19613 6291 15 the the DT 19613 6291 16 Western Western NNP 19613 6291 17 Church Church NNP 19613 6291 18 of of IN 19613 6291 19 the the DT 19613 6291 20 third third JJ 19613 6291 21 century century NN 19613 6291 22 , , , 19613 6291 23 does do VBZ 19613 6291 24 not not RB 19613 6291 25 appear appear VB 19613 6291 26 in in IN 19613 6291 27 the the DT 19613 6291 28 adoption adoption NN 19613 6291 29 of of IN 19613 6291 30 a a DT 19613 6291 31 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6291 32 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 6291 33 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 6291 34 , , , 19613 6291 35 but but CC 19613 6291 36 in in IN 19613 6291 37 theological theological JJ 19613 6291 38 fragments fragment NNS 19613 6291 39 , , , 19613 6291 40 namely namely RB 19613 6291 41 , , , 19613 6291 42 the the DT 19613 6291 43 rule rule NN 19613 6291 44 of of IN 19613 6291 45 faith faith NN 19613 6291 46 fixed fix VBN 19613 6291 47 and and CC 19613 6291 48 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 6291 49 in in IN 19613 6291 50 an an DT 19613 6291 51 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 6291 52 sense[650 sense[650 NN 19613 6291 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6291 54 . . . 19613 6292 1 As as IN 19613 6292 2 yet yet RB 19613 6292 3 the the DT 19613 6292 4 rule rule NN 19613 6292 5 of of IN 19613 6292 6 faith faith NN 19613 6292 7 and and CC 19613 6292 8 theology theology NN 19613 6292 9 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 6292 10 came come VBD 19613 6292 11 into into IN 19613 6292 12 collision collision NN 19613 6292 13 in in IN 19613 6292 14 the the DT 19613 6292 15 Western western JJ 19613 6292 16 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 6292 17 of of IN 19613 6292 18 the the DT 19613 6292 19 third third JJ 19613 6292 20 century century NN 19613 6292 21 , , , 19613 6292 22 because because IN 19613 6292 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6292 24 and and CC 19613 6292 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6292 26 younger young JJR 19613 6292 27 contemporaries contemporary NNS 19613 6292 28 did do VBD 19613 6292 29 not not RB 19613 6292 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6292 31 notice notice VB 19613 6292 32 any any DT 19613 6292 33 such such JJ 19613 6292 34 discrepancies discrepancy NNS 19613 6292 35 , , , 19613 6292 36 but but CC 19613 6292 37 rather rather RB 19613 6292 38 imagined imagine VBD 19613 6292 39 all all PDT 19613 6292 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6292 41 teachings teaching NNS 19613 6292 42 to to TO 19613 6292 43 be be VB 19613 6292 44 expositions exposition NNS 19613 6292 45 of of IN 19613 6292 46 the the DT 19613 6292 47 faith faith NN 19613 6292 48 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6292 49 , , , 19613 6292 50 and and CC 19613 6292 51 did do VBD 19613 6292 52 not not RB 19613 6292 53 trouble trouble VB 19613 6292 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6292 55 heads head NNS 19613 6292 56 about about IN 19613 6292 57 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 19613 6292 58 . . . 19613 6293 1 If if IN 19613 6293 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6293 3 wish wish VBP 19613 6293 4 to to TO 19613 6293 5 form form VB 19613 6293 6 a a DT 19613 6293 7 notion notion NN 19613 6293 8 as as IN 19613 6293 9 to to IN 19613 6293 10 what what WDT 19613 6293 11 ideas idea NNS 19613 6293 12 had have VBD 19613 6293 13 become become VBN 19613 6293 14 universally universally RB 19613 6293 15 prevalent prevalent JJ 19613 6293 16 in in IN 19613 6293 17 the the DT 19613 6293 18 Church Church NNP 19613 6293 19 in in IN 19613 6293 20 the the DT 19613 6293 21 middle middle NN 19613 6293 22 of of IN 19613 6293 23 the the DT 19613 6293 24 third third JJ 19613 6293 25 century century NN 19613 6293 26 let let VBD 19613 6293 27 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6293 28 compare compare VB 19613 6293 29 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 6293 30 's 's POS 19613 6293 31 work work NN 19613 6293 32 " " `` 19613 6293 33 Testimonia Testimonia NNP 19613 6293 34 " " '' 19613 6293 35 , , , 19613 6293 36 written write VBN 19613 6293 37 for for IN 19613 6293 38 a a DT 19613 6293 39 layman layman NN 19613 6293 40 , , , 19613 6293 41 with with IN 19613 6293 42 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6293 43 's 's POS 19613 6293 44 work work NN 19613 6293 45 " " `` 19613 6293 46 De De NNP 19613 6293 47 Trinitate Trinitate NNP 19613 6293 48 " " '' 19613 6293 49 . . . 19613 6294 1 In in IN 19613 6294 2 the the DT 19613 6294 3 " " `` 19613 6294 4 Testimonia Testimonia NNP 19613 6294 5 " " '' 19613 6294 6 the the DT 19613 6294 7 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6294 8 of of IN 19613 6294 9 the the DT 19613 6294 10 two two CD 19613 6294 11 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6294 12 , , , 19613 6294 13 as as IN 19613 6294 14 developed develop VBN 19613 6294 15 by by IN 19613 6294 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6294 17 , , , 19613 6294 18 forms form VBZ 19613 6294 19 the the DT 19613 6294 20 framework framework NN 19613 6294 21 in in IN 19613 6294 22 which which WDT 19613 6294 23 the the DT 19613 6294 24 individual individual JJ 19613 6294 25 dogmas dogma NNS 19613 6294 26 are be VBP 19613 6294 27 set set VBN 19613 6294 28 . . . 19613 6295 1 The the DT 19613 6295 2 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6295 3 of of IN 19613 6295 4 God God NNP 19613 6295 5 , , , 19613 6295 6 which which WDT 19613 6295 7 should should MD 19613 6295 8 have have VB 19613 6295 9 been be VBN 19613 6295 10 placed place VBN 19613 6295 11 at at IN 19613 6295 12 the the DT 19613 6295 13 beginning beginning NN 19613 6295 14 , , , 19613 6295 15 has have VBZ 19613 6295 16 been be VBN 19613 6295 17 left leave VBN 19613 6295 18 out out RP 19613 6295 19 in in IN 19613 6295 20 this this DT 19613 6295 21 little little JJ 19613 6295 22 book book NN 19613 6295 23 probably probably RB 19613 6295 24 because because IN 19613 6295 25 the the DT 19613 6295 26 person person NN 19613 6295 27 addressed address VBD 19613 6295 28 required require VBD 19613 6295 29 no no DT 19613 6295 30 instruction instruction NN 19613 6295 31 on on IN 19613 6295 32 the the DT 19613 6295 33 point point NN 19613 6295 34 . . . 19613 6296 1 Some some DT 19613 6296 2 of of IN 19613 6296 3 the the DT 19613 6296 4 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 6296 5 already already RB 19613 6296 6 belong belong VB 19613 6296 7 to to IN 19613 6296 8 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 6296 9 theology theology NN 19613 6296 10 in in IN 19613 6296 11 the the DT 19613 6296 12 strict strict JJ 19613 6296 13 sense sense NN 19613 6296 14 of of IN 19613 6296 15 the the DT 19613 6296 16 word word NN 19613 6296 17 ; ; : 19613 6296 18 in in IN 19613 6296 19 others other NNS 19613 6296 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6296 21 have have VBP 19613 6296 22 merely merely RB 19613 6296 23 a a DT 19613 6296 24 precise precise JJ 19613 6296 25 assertion assertion NN 19613 6296 26 of of IN 19613 6296 27 the the DT 19613 6296 28 truth truth NN 19613 6296 29 of of IN 19613 6296 30 certain certain JJ 19613 6296 31 facts fact NNS 19613 6296 32 . . . 19613 6297 1 All all DT 19613 6297 2 propositions proposition NNS 19613 6297 3 are be VBP 19613 6297 4 , , , 19613 6297 5 however however RB 19613 6297 6 , , , 19613 6297 7 supported support VBN 19613 6297 8 by by IN 19613 6297 9 passages passage NNS 19613 6297 10 from from IN 19613 6297 11 the the DT 19613 6297 12 two two CD 19613 6297 13 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6297 14 and and CC 19613 6297 15 thereby thereby RB 19613 6297 16 proved prove VBN 19613 6297 17 . . . 19613 6298 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6298 2 651 651 CD 19613 6298 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6298 4 The the DT 19613 6298 5 theological theological JJ 19613 6298 6 counterpart counterpart NN 19613 6298 7 to to IN 19613 6298 8 this this DT 19613 6298 9 is be VBZ 19613 6298 10 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6298 11 's 's POS 19613 6298 12 work work NN 19613 6298 13 " " `` 19613 6298 14 De De NNP 19613 6298 15 Trinitate Trinitate NNP 19613 6298 16 " " '' 19613 6298 17 . . . 19613 6299 1 This this DT 19613 6299 2 first first JJ 19613 6299 3 great great JJ 19613 6299 4 Latin latin JJ 19613 6299 5 work work NN 19613 6299 6 that that WDT 19613 6299 7 appeared appear VBD 19613 6299 8 in in IN 19613 6299 9 Rome Rome NNP 19613 6299 10 is be VBZ 19613 6299 11 highly highly RB 19613 6299 12 important important JJ 19613 6299 13 . . . 19613 6300 1 In in IN 19613 6300 2 regard regard NN 19613 6300 3 to to TO 19613 6300 4 completeness completeness VB 19613 6300 5 , , , 19613 6300 6 extent extent NN 19613 6300 7 of of IN 19613 6300 8 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6300 9 proofs proof NNS 19613 6300 10 , , , 19613 6300 11 and and CC 19613 6300 12 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 6300 13 also also RB 19613 6300 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6300 15 influence influence NN 19613 6300 16 on on IN 19613 6300 17 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 6300 18 times time NNS 19613 6300 19 , , , 19613 6300 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6300 21 may may MD 19613 6300 22 in in IN 19613 6300 23 many many JJ 19613 6300 24 respects respect NNS 19613 6300 25 be be VB 19613 6300 26 compared compare VBN 19613 6300 27 with with IN 19613 6300 28 Origen Origen NNP 19613 6300 29 's 's POS 19613 6300 30 work work NN 19613 6300 31 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6300 32 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6300 33 : : : 19613 6300 34 peri peri NN 19613 6300 35 archôn archôn NN 19613 6300 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6300 37 . . . 19613 6301 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 19613 6301 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 6301 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6301 4 differs differ VBZ 19613 6301 5 as as RB 19613 6301 6 much much RB 19613 6301 7 from from IN 19613 6301 8 that that DT 19613 6301 9 work work NN 19613 6301 10 , , , 19613 6301 11 as as IN 19613 6301 12 the the DT 19613 6301 13 sober sober NNP 19613 6301 14 , , , 19613 6301 15 meagre meagre JJ 19613 6301 16 theology theology NN 19613 6301 17 of of IN 19613 6301 18 the the DT 19613 6301 19 West West NNP 19613 6301 20 , , , 19613 6301 21 devoid devoid JJ 19613 6301 22 of of IN 19613 6301 23 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 6301 24 and and CC 19613 6301 25 speculation speculation NN 19613 6301 26 , , , 19613 6301 27 differs differ NNS 19613 6301 28 in in IN 19613 6301 29 general general JJ 19613 6301 30 from from IN 19613 6301 31 that that DT 19613 6301 32 of of IN 19613 6301 33 the the DT 19613 6301 34 East East NNP 19613 6301 35 . . . 19613 6302 1 But but CC 19613 6302 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6302 3 sums sum VBZ 19613 6302 4 up up RP 19613 6302 5 in in IN 19613 6302 6 classic classic JJ 19613 6302 7 fashion fashion NN 19613 6302 8 the the DT 19613 6302 9 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 6302 10 of of IN 19613 6302 11 Western western JJ 19613 6302 12 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 6302 13 , , , 19613 6302 14 the the DT 19613 6302 15 main main JJ 19613 6302 16 features feature NNS 19613 6302 17 of of IN 19613 6302 18 which which WDT 19613 6302 19 were be VBD 19613 6302 20 sketched sketch VBN 19613 6302 21 by by IN 19613 6302 22 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6302 23 in in IN 19613 6302 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6302 25 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 6302 26 writings writing NNS 19613 6302 27 and and CC 19613 6302 28 the the DT 19613 6302 29 work work NN 19613 6302 30 against against IN 19613 6302 31 Praxeas Praxeas NNP 19613 6302 32 . . . 19613 6303 1 The the DT 19613 6303 2 old old JJ 19613 6303 3 Roman roman JJ 19613 6303 4 symbol symbol NN 19613 6303 5 forms form VBZ 19613 6303 6 the the DT 19613 6303 7 basis basis NN 19613 6303 8 of of IN 19613 6303 9 the the DT 19613 6303 10 work work NN 19613 6303 11 . . . 19613 6304 1 In in IN 19613 6304 2 accordance accordance NN 19613 6304 3 with with IN 19613 6304 4 this this DT 19613 6304 5 the the DT 19613 6304 6 author author NN 19613 6304 7 gives give VBZ 19613 6304 8 a a DT 19613 6304 9 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 6304 10 exposition exposition NN 19613 6304 11 of of IN 19613 6304 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6304 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6304 14 of of IN 19613 6304 15 God God NNP 19613 6304 16 in in IN 19613 6304 17 the the DT 19613 6304 18 first first JJ 19613 6304 19 eight eight CD 19613 6304 20 chapters chapter NNS 19613 6304 21 . . . 19613 6305 1 Chapters chapter NNS 19613 6305 2 9 9 CD 19613 6305 3 - - SYM 19613 6305 4 28 28 CD 19613 6305 5 form form NN 19613 6305 6 the the DT 19613 6305 7 main main JJ 19613 6305 8 portion portion NN 19613 6305 9 ; ; : 19613 6305 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6305 11 establish establish VBP 19613 6305 12 the the DT 19613 6305 13 correct correct JJ 19613 6305 14 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6305 15 in in IN 19613 6305 16 opposition opposition NN 19613 6305 17 to to IN 19613 6305 18 the the DT 19613 6305 19 heretics heretic NNS 19613 6305 20 who who WP 19613 6305 21 look look VBP 19613 6305 22 on on IN 19613 6305 23 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6305 24 as as IN 19613 6305 25 a a DT 19613 6305 26 mere mere JJ 19613 6305 27 man man NN 19613 6305 28 or or CC 19613 6305 29 as as IN 19613 6305 30 the the DT 19613 6305 31 Father Father NNP 19613 6305 32 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6305 33 ; ; : 19613 6305 34 the the DT 19613 6305 35 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6305 36 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 6305 37 furnish furnish VBP 19613 6305 38 the the DT 19613 6305 39 material material NN 19613 6305 40 for for IN 19613 6305 41 the the DT 19613 6305 42 proofs proof NNS 19613 6305 43 . . . 19613 6306 1 Chapter chapter NN 19613 6306 2 29 29 CD 19613 6306 3 treats treat NNS 19613 6306 4 of of IN 19613 6306 5 the the DT 19613 6306 6 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6306 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6306 8 . . . 19613 6307 1 Chapters chapter NNS 19613 6307 2 30 30 CD 19613 6307 3 and and CC 19613 6307 4 31 31 CD 19613 6307 5 contain contain VBP 19613 6307 6 the the DT 19613 6307 7 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 6307 8 and and CC 19613 6307 9 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 6307 10 . . . 19613 6308 1 The the DT 19613 6308 2 whole whole NN 19613 6308 3 is be VBZ 19613 6308 4 based base VBN 19613 6308 5 on on IN 19613 6308 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6308 7 's 's POS 19613 6308 8 treatise treatise NN 19613 6308 9 against against IN 19613 6308 10 Praxeas Praxeas NNP 19613 6308 11 . . . 19613 6309 1 No no DT 19613 6309 2 important important JJ 19613 6309 3 argument argument NN 19613 6309 4 in in IN 19613 6309 5 that that DT 19613 6309 6 work work NN 19613 6309 7 has have VBZ 19613 6309 8 escaped escape VBN 19613 6309 9 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6309 10 ; ; : 19613 6309 11 but but CC 19613 6309 12 everything everything NN 19613 6309 13 is be VBZ 19613 6309 14 extended extended JJ 19613 6309 15 , , , 19613 6309 16 and and CC 19613 6309 17 made make VBD 19613 6309 18 more more RBR 19613 6309 19 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6309 20 and and CC 19613 6309 21 polished polished JJ 19613 6309 22 . . . 19613 6310 1 No no DT 19613 6310 2 trace trace NN 19613 6310 3 of of IN 19613 6310 4 Platonism Platonism NNP 19613 6310 5 is be VBZ 19613 6310 6 to to TO 19613 6310 7 be be VB 19613 6310 8 found find VBN 19613 6310 9 in in IN 19613 6310 10 this this DT 19613 6310 11 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 6310 12 ; ; : 19613 6310 13 on on IN 19613 6310 14 the the DT 19613 6310 15 contrary contrary NN 19613 6310 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6310 17 employs employ VBZ 19613 6310 18 the the DT 19613 6310 19 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 6310 20 and and CC 19613 6310 21 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 19613 6310 22 syllogistic syllogistic JJ 19613 6310 23 and and CC 19613 6310 24 dialectic dialectic JJ 19613 6310 25 method method NN 19613 6310 26 used use VBN 19613 6310 27 also also RB 19613 6310 28 by by IN 19613 6310 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6310 30 Monarchian monarchian JJ 19613 6310 31 opponents opponent NNS 19613 6310 32 . . . 19613 6311 1 This this DT 19613 6311 2 plan plan NN 19613 6311 3 together together RB 19613 6311 4 with with IN 19613 6311 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6311 6 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6311 7 attitude attitude NN 19613 6311 8 gives give VBZ 19613 6311 9 the the DT 19613 6311 10 work work NN 19613 6311 11 great great JJ 19613 6311 12 outward outward NNP 19613 6311 13 completeness completeness NNP 19613 6311 14 and and CC 19613 6311 15 certainty certainty NN 19613 6311 16 . . . 19613 6312 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6312 2 can can MD 19613 6312 3 not not RB 19613 6312 4 help help VB 19613 6312 5 concluding conclude VBG 19613 6312 6 that that IN 19613 6312 7 this this DT 19613 6312 8 work work NN 19613 6312 9 must must MD 19613 6312 10 have have VB 19613 6312 11 made make VBN 19613 6312 12 a a DT 19613 6312 13 deep deep JJ 19613 6312 14 impression impression NN 19613 6312 15 wherever wherever WRB 19613 6312 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6312 17 was be VBD 19613 6312 18 read read VBN 19613 6312 19 , , , 19613 6312 20 although although IN 19613 6312 21 the the DT 19613 6312 22 real real JJ 19613 6312 23 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 6312 24 of of IN 19613 6312 25 the the DT 19613 6312 26 matter matter NN 19613 6312 27 are be VBP 19613 6312 28 not not RB 19613 6312 29 at at RB 19613 6312 30 all all RB 19613 6312 31 touched touch VBN 19613 6312 32 upon upon IN 19613 6312 33 , , , 19613 6312 34 but but CC 19613 6312 35 veiled veil VBN 19613 6312 36 by by IN 19613 6312 37 distinctions distinction NNS 19613 6312 38 and and CC 19613 6312 39 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6312 40 . . . 19613 6313 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6313 2 probably probably RB 19613 6313 3 contributed contribute VBD 19613 6313 4 not not RB 19613 6313 5 least least JJS 19613 6313 6 to to TO 19613 6313 7 make make VB 19613 6313 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6313 9 's 's POS 19613 6313 10 type type NN 19613 6313 11 of of IN 19613 6313 12 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6313 13 the the DT 19613 6313 14 universal universal JJ 19613 6313 15 Western western JJ 19613 6313 16 one one NN 19613 6313 17 . . . 19613 6314 1 This this DT 19613 6314 2 type type NN 19613 6314 3 , , , 19613 6314 4 however however RB 19613 6314 5 , , , 19613 6314 6 as as IN 19613 6314 7 will will MD 19613 6314 8 be be VB 19613 6314 9 set set VBN 19613 6314 10 forth forth RP 19613 6314 11 in in IN 19613 6314 12 greater great JJR 19613 6314 13 detail detail NN 19613 6314 14 hereafter hereafter RB 19613 6314 15 , , , 19613 6314 16 already already RB 19613 6314 17 approximates approximate VBZ 19613 6314 18 closely closely RB 19613 6314 19 to to IN 19613 6314 20 the the DT 19613 6314 21 resolutions resolution NNS 19613 6314 22 of of IN 19613 6314 23 Nicæa Nicæa NNP 19613 6314 24 and and CC 19613 6314 25 Chalcedon Chalcedon NNP 19613 6314 26 . . . 19613 6315 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6315 2 652 652 CD 19613 6315 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6315 4 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6315 5 adopted adopt VBD 19613 6315 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6315 7 's 's POS 19613 6315 8 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6315 9 " " `` 19613 6315 10 one one CD 19613 6315 11 substance substance NN 19613 6315 12 , , , 19613 6315 13 three three CD 19613 6315 14 persons person NNS 19613 6315 15 " " '' 19613 6315 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6315 17 " " `` 19613 6315 18 una una NNP 19613 6315 19 substantia substantia NNS 19613 6315 20 , , , 19613 6315 21 tres tre VBZ 19613 6315 22 personæ personæ NNP 19613 6315 23 " " '' 19613 6315 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6315 25 , , , 19613 6315 26 " " '' 19613 6315 27 from from IN 19613 6315 28 the the DT 19613 6315 29 substance substance NN 19613 6315 30 of of IN 19613 6315 31 God God NNP 19613 6315 32 " " '' 19613 6315 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6315 34 " " `` 19613 6315 35 ex ex NNP 19613 6315 36 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6315 37 dei dei NNP 19613 6315 38 " " '' 19613 6315 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6315 40 , , , 19613 6315 41 " " '' 19613 6315 42 always always RB 19613 6315 43 with with IN 19613 6315 44 the the DT 19613 6315 45 Father Father NNP 19613 6315 46 " " '' 19613 6315 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6315 48 " " `` 19613 6315 49 semper semper NN 19613 6315 50 apud apud NNP 19613 6315 51 patrem patrem NN 19613 6315 52 " " '' 19613 6315 53 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6315 54 , , , 19613 6315 55 " " '' 19613 6315 56 God God NNP 19613 6315 57 and and CC 19613 6315 58 man man NN 19613 6315 59 " " '' 19613 6315 60 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6315 61 " " '' 19613 6315 62 deus deus NNP 19613 6315 63 et et NNP 19613 6315 64 homo homo NN 19613 6315 65 " " '' 19613 6315 66 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6315 67 , , , 19613 6315 68 " " '' 19613 6315 69 two two CD 19613 6315 70 substances substance NNS 19613 6315 71 " " '' 19613 6315 72 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6315 73 " " `` 19613 6315 74 duæ duæ NNP 19613 6315 75 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 6315 76 " " '' 19613 6315 77 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6315 78 , , , 19613 6315 79 " " '' 19613 6315 80 one one CD 19613 6315 81 person person NN 19613 6315 82 " " '' 19613 6315 83 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6315 84 " " `` 19613 6315 85 una una NNP 19613 6315 86 persona persona NN 19613 6315 87 " " '' 19613 6315 88 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6315 89 , , , 19613 6315 90 as as RB 19613 6315 91 well well RB 19613 6315 92 as as IN 19613 6315 93 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6315 94 expressions expression NNS 19613 6315 95 for for IN 19613 6315 96 the the DT 19613 6315 97 union union NN 19613 6315 98 and and CC 19613 6315 99 separation separation NN 19613 6315 100 of of IN 19613 6315 101 the the DT 19613 6315 102 two two CD 19613 6315 103 natures nature NNS 19613 6315 104 adding add VBG 19613 6315 105 to to IN 19613 6315 106 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6315 107 similar similar JJ 19613 6315 108 ones one NNS 19613 6315 109 and and CC 19613 6315 110 giving give VBG 19613 6315 111 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6315 112 a a DT 19613 6315 113 wider wide JJR 19613 6315 114 extension extension NN 19613 6315 115 . . . 19613 6316 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6316 2 653 653 CD 19613 6316 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6316 4 Taking take VBG 19613 6316 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6316 6 book book NN 19613 6316 7 in in IN 19613 6316 8 all all DT 19613 6316 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6316 10 may may MD 19613 6316 11 see see VB 19613 6316 12 that that IN 19613 6316 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6316 14 thereby thereby RB 19613 6316 15 created create VBN 19613 6316 16 for for IN 19613 6316 17 the the DT 19613 6316 18 West West NNP 19613 6316 19 a a DT 19613 6316 20 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 6316 21 _ _ NNP 19613 6316 22 vademecum vademecum NN 19613 6316 23 _ _ NNP 19613 6316 24 , , , 19613 6316 25 which which WDT 19613 6316 26 , , , 19613 6316 27 from from IN 19613 6316 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6316 29 copious copious JJ 19613 6316 30 and and CC 19613 6316 31 well well RB 19613 6316 32 - - HYPH 19613 6316 33 selected select VBN 19613 6316 34 quotations quotation NNS 19613 6316 35 from from IN 19613 6316 36 Scripture scripture NN 19613 6316 37 , , , 19613 6316 38 must must MD 19613 6316 39 have have VB 19613 6316 40 been be VBN 19613 6316 41 of of IN 19613 6316 42 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 6316 43 service service NN 19613 6316 44 . . . 19613 6317 1 The the DT 19613 6317 2 most most RBS 19613 6317 3 important important JJ 19613 6317 4 articles article NNS 19613 6317 5 which which WDT 19613 6317 6 were be VBD 19613 6317 7 now now RB 19613 6317 8 fixed fix VBN 19613 6317 9 and and CC 19613 6317 10 transferred transfer VBN 19613 6317 11 to to IN 19613 6317 12 the the DT 19613 6317 13 general general JJ 19613 6317 14 creed creed NN 19613 6317 15 along along IN 19613 6317 16 with with IN 19613 6317 17 the the DT 19613 6317 18 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6317 19 proofs proof NNS 19613 6317 20 , , , 19613 6317 21 especially especially RB 19613 6317 22 in in IN 19613 6317 23 the the DT 19613 6317 24 West West NNP 19613 6317 25 , , , 19613 6317 26 were be VBD 19613 6317 27 : : : 19613 6317 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 29 1 1 LS 19613 6317 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 31 the the DT 19613 6317 32 unity unity NN 19613 6317 33 of of IN 19613 6317 34 God God NNP 19613 6317 35 , , , 19613 6317 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 37 2 2 LS 19613 6317 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 39 the the DT 19613 6317 40 identity identity NN 19613 6317 41 of of IN 19613 6317 42 the the DT 19613 6317 43 supreme supreme JJ 19613 6317 44 God God NNP 19613 6317 45 and and CC 19613 6317 46 the the DT 19613 6317 47 creator creator NN 19613 6317 48 of of IN 19613 6317 49 the the DT 19613 6317 50 world world NN 19613 6317 51 , , , 19613 6317 52 that that RB 19613 6317 53 is is RB 19613 6317 54 , , , 19613 6317 55 the the DT 19613 6317 56 identity identity NN 19613 6317 57 of of IN 19613 6317 58 the the DT 19613 6317 59 mediators mediator NNS 19613 6317 60 of of IN 19613 6317 61 creation creation NN 19613 6317 62 and and CC 19613 6317 63 redemption redemption NN 19613 6317 64 , , , 19613 6317 65 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 66 3 3 LS 19613 6317 67 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 68 the the DT 19613 6317 69 identity identity NN 19613 6317 70 of of IN 19613 6317 71 the the DT 19613 6317 72 supreme supreme JJ 19613 6317 73 God God NNP 19613 6317 74 with with IN 19613 6317 75 the the DT 19613 6317 76 God God NNP 19613 6317 77 of of IN 19613 6317 78 the the DT 19613 6317 79 Old Old NNP 19613 6317 80 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6317 81 , , , 19613 6317 82 and and CC 19613 6317 83 the the DT 19613 6317 84 declaration declaration NN 19613 6317 85 that that IN 19613 6317 86 the the DT 19613 6317 87 Old Old NNP 19613 6317 88 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6317 89 is be VBZ 19613 6317 90 God God NNP 19613 6317 91 's 's POS 19613 6317 92 book book NN 19613 6317 93 of of IN 19613 6317 94 revelation revelation NN 19613 6317 95 , , , 19613 6317 96 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 97 4 4 LS 19613 6317 98 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 99 the the DT 19613 6317 100 creation creation NN 19613 6317 101 of of IN 19613 6317 102 the the DT 19613 6317 103 world world NN 19613 6317 104 out out IN 19613 6317 105 of of IN 19613 6317 106 nothing nothing NN 19613 6317 107 , , , 19613 6317 108 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 109 5 5 LS 19613 6317 110 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 111 the the DT 19613 6317 112 unity unity NN 19613 6317 113 of of IN 19613 6317 114 the the DT 19613 6317 115 human human JJ 19613 6317 116 race race NN 19613 6317 117 , , , 19613 6317 118 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 119 6 6 LS 19613 6317 120 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 121 the the DT 19613 6317 122 origin origin NN 19613 6317 123 of of IN 19613 6317 124 evil evil NN 19613 6317 125 from from IN 19613 6317 126 freedom freedom NN 19613 6317 127 , , , 19613 6317 128 and and CC 19613 6317 129 the the DT 19613 6317 130 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 6317 131 nature nature NN 19613 6317 132 of of IN 19613 6317 133 freedom freedom NN 19613 6317 134 , , , 19613 6317 135 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 136 7 7 LS 19613 6317 137 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 138 the the DT 19613 6317 139 two two CD 19613 6317 140 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6317 141 , , , 19613 6317 142 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 143 8) 8) CD 19613 6317 144 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6317 145 as as IN 19613 6317 146 God God NNP 19613 6317 147 and and CC 19613 6317 148 Man Man NNP 19613 6317 149 , , , 19613 6317 150 the the DT 19613 6317 151 unity unity NN 19613 6317 152 of of IN 19613 6317 153 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6317 154 personality personality NN 19613 6317 155 , , , 19613 6317 156 the the DT 19613 6317 157 truth truth NN 19613 6317 158 of of IN 19613 6317 159 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6317 160 divinity divinity NN 19613 6317 161 , , , 19613 6317 162 the the DT 19613 6317 163 actuality actuality NN 19613 6317 164 of of IN 19613 6317 165 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6317 166 humanity humanity NN 19613 6317 167 , , , 19613 6317 168 the the DT 19613 6317 169 reality reality NN 19613 6317 170 of of IN 19613 6317 171 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6317 172 fate fate NN 19613 6317 173 , , , 19613 6317 174 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 175 9 9 LS 19613 6317 176 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 177 the the DT 19613 6317 178 redemption redemption NN 19613 6317 179 and and CC 19613 6317 180 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 6317 181 of of IN 19613 6317 182 a a DT 19613 6317 183 covenant covenant NN 19613 6317 184 through through IN 19613 6317 185 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6317 186 as as IN 19613 6317 187 the the DT 19613 6317 188 new new JJ 19613 6317 189 and and CC 19613 6317 190 crowning crowning JJ 19613 6317 191 manifestation manifestation NN 19613 6317 192 of of IN 19613 6317 193 God God NNP 19613 6317 194 's 's POS 19613 6317 195 grace grace NN 19613 6317 196 to to IN 19613 6317 197 all all DT 19613 6317 198 men man NNS 19613 6317 199 , , , 19613 6317 200 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6317 201 10 10 LS 19613 6317 202 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6317 203 the the DT 19613 6317 204 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 6317 205 of of IN 19613 6317 206 man man NN 19613 6317 207 in in IN 19613 6317 208 soul soul NN 19613 6317 209 and and CC 19613 6317 210 body body NN 19613 6317 211 . . . 19613 6318 1 But but CC 19613 6318 2 the the DT 19613 6318 3 transmission transmission NN 19613 6318 4 and and CC 19613 6318 5 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6318 6 of of IN 19613 6318 7 these these DT 19613 6318 8 propositions proposition NNS 19613 6318 9 , , , 19613 6318 10 by by IN 19613 6318 11 means mean NNS 19613 6318 12 of of IN 19613 6318 13 which which WDT 19613 6318 14 the the DT 19613 6318 15 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 6318 16 these these DT 19613 6318 17 s s NNPS 19613 6318 18 were be VBD 19613 6318 19 overthrown overthrow VBN 19613 6318 20 , , , 19613 6318 21 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 6318 22 involved involve VBD 19613 6318 23 the the DT 19613 6318 24 transmission transmission NN 19613 6318 25 of of IN 19613 6318 26 the the DT 19613 6318 27 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6318 28 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6318 29 ; ; : 19613 6318 30 for for IN 19613 6318 31 the the DT 19613 6318 32 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6318 33 of of IN 19613 6318 34 the the DT 19613 6318 35 revelation revelation NN 19613 6318 36 of of IN 19613 6318 37 God God NNP 19613 6318 38 and and CC 19613 6318 39 of of IN 19613 6318 40 the the DT 19613 6318 41 two two CD 19613 6318 42 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 6318 43 could could MD 19613 6318 44 not not RB 19613 6318 45 have have VB 19613 6318 46 prevailed prevail VBN 19613 6318 47 without without IN 19613 6318 48 this this DT 19613 6318 49 theory theory NN 19613 6318 50 . . . 19613 6319 1 How how WRB 19613 6319 2 this this DT 19613 6319 3 hypothesis hypothesis NN 19613 6319 4 gained gain VBD 19613 6319 5 acceptance acceptance NN 19613 6319 6 in in IN 19613 6319 7 the the DT 19613 6319 8 course course NN 19613 6319 9 of of IN 19613 6319 10 the the DT 19613 6319 11 third third JJ 19613 6319 12 century century NN 19613 6319 13 , , , 19613 6319 14 and and CC 19613 6319 15 how how WRB 19613 6319 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6319 17 was be VBD 19613 6319 18 the the DT 19613 6319 19 means mean NNS 19613 6319 20 of of IN 19613 6319 21 establishing establish VBG 19613 6319 22 and and CC 19613 6319 23 legitimising legitimise VBG 19613 6319 24 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 6319 25 theology theology NN 19613 6319 26 as as IN 19613 6319 27 part part NN 19613 6319 28 of of IN 19613 6319 29 the the DT 19613 6319 30 faith faith NN 19613 6319 31 , , , 19613 6319 32 will will MD 19613 6319 33 be be VB 19613 6319 34 shown show VBN 19613 6319 35 in in IN 19613 6319 36 the the DT 19613 6319 37 seventh seventh JJ 19613 6319 38 chapter chapter NN 19613 6319 39 . . . 19613 6320 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6320 2 may may MD 19613 6320 3 remark remark VB 19613 6320 4 in in IN 19613 6320 5 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 6320 6 that that IN 19613 6320 7 the the DT 19613 6320 8 religious religious JJ 19613 6320 9 hope hope NN 19613 6320 10 which which WDT 19613 6320 11 looked look VBD 19613 6320 12 forward forward RB 19613 6320 13 to to IN 19613 6320 14 an an DT 19613 6320 15 earthly earthly JJ 19613 6320 16 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 6320 17 of of IN 19613 6320 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6320 19 was be VBD 19613 6320 20 still still RB 19613 6320 21 the the DT 19613 6320 22 more more RBR 19613 6320 23 widely widely RB 19613 6320 24 diffused diffuse VBN 19613 6320 25 among among IN 19613 6320 26 the the DT 19613 6320 27 Churches Churches NNPS 19613 6320 28 of of IN 19613 6320 29 the the DT 19613 6320 30 third third JJ 19613 6320 31 century;[654 century;[654 NNS 19613 6320 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6320 33 but but CC 19613 6320 34 that that IN 19613 6320 35 the the DT 19613 6320 36 other other JJ 19613 6320 37 hope hope NN 19613 6320 38 , , , 19613 6320 39 viz viz NNP 19613 6320 40 . . NNP 19613 6320 41 , , , 19613 6320 42 that that DT 19613 6320 43 of of IN 19613 6320 44 being be VBG 19613 6320 45 deified deify VBN 19613 6320 46 , , , 19613 6320 47 was be VBD 19613 6320 48 gaining gain VBG 19613 6320 49 adherents adherent NNS 19613 6320 50 more more RBR 19613 6320 51 and and CC 19613 6320 52 more more RBR 19613 6320 53 . . . 19613 6321 1 The the DT 19613 6321 2 latter latter JJ 19613 6321 3 result result NN 19613 6321 4 was be VBD 19613 6321 5 due due JJ 19613 6321 6 to to IN 19613 6321 7 men man NNS 19613 6321 8 's 's POS 19613 6321 9 increasing increase VBG 19613 6321 10 indifference indifference NN 19613 6321 11 to to IN 19613 6321 12 daily daily JJ 19613 6321 13 life life NN 19613 6321 14 and and CC 19613 6321 15 growing grow VBG 19613 6321 16 aspiration aspiration NN 19613 6321 17 after after IN 19613 6321 18 a a DT 19613 6321 19 higher high JJR 19613 6321 20 one one CD 19613 6321 21 , , , 19613 6321 22 a a DT 19613 6321 23 longing longing NN 19613 6321 24 that that WDT 19613 6321 25 was be VBD 19613 6321 26 moreover moreover RB 19613 6321 27 nourished nourish VBN 19613 6321 28 among among IN 19613 6321 29 the the DT 19613 6321 30 more more RBR 19613 6321 31 cultured cultured JJ 19613 6321 32 by by IN 19613 6321 33 the the DT 19613 6321 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 6321 35 which which WDT 19613 6321 36 was be VBD 19613 6321 37 steadily steadily RB 19613 6321 38 gaining gain VBG 19613 6321 39 ground ground NN 19613 6321 40 . . . 19613 6322 1 The the DT 19613 6322 2 hope hope NN 19613 6322 3 of of IN 19613 6322 4 deification deification NN 19613 6322 5 is be VBZ 19613 6322 6 the the DT 19613 6322 7 expression expression NN 19613 6322 8 of of IN 19613 6322 9 the the DT 19613 6322 10 idea idea NN 19613 6322 11 that that IN 19613 6322 12 this this DT 19613 6322 13 world world NN 19613 6322 14 and and CC 19613 6322 15 human human JJ 19613 6322 16 nature nature NN 19613 6322 17 do do VBP 19613 6322 18 not not RB 19613 6322 19 correspond correspond VB 19613 6322 20 to to IN 19613 6322 21 that that DT 19613 6322 22 exalted exalted JJ 19613 6322 23 world world NN 19613 6322 24 which which WDT 19613 6322 25 man man NN 19613 6322 26 has have VBZ 19613 6322 27 built build VBN 19613 6322 28 up up RP 19613 6322 29 within within IN 19613 6322 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6322 31 own own JJ 19613 6322 32 mind mind NN 19613 6322 33 and and CC 19613 6322 34 which which WDT 19613 6322 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6322 36 may may MD 19613 6322 37 reasonably reasonably RB 19613 6322 38 demand demand VB 19613 6322 39 to to TO 19613 6322 40 be be VB 19613 6322 41 realised realise VBN 19613 6322 42 , , , 19613 6322 43 because because IN 19613 6322 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6322 45 is be VBZ 19613 6322 46 only only RB 19613 6322 47 in in IN 19613 6322 48 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6322 49 that that WDT 19613 6322 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6322 51 can can MD 19613 6322 52 come come VB 19613 6322 53 to to IN 19613 6322 54 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6322 55 . . . 19613 6323 1 The the DT 19613 6323 2 fact fact NN 19613 6323 3 that that IN 19613 6323 4 Christian christian JJ 19613 6323 5 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6323 6 like like IN 19613 6323 7 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 6323 8 , , , 19613 6323 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6323 10 , , , 19613 6323 11 and and CC 19613 6323 12 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6323 13 expressly expressly RB 19613 6323 14 declared declare VBD 19613 6323 15 this this DT 19613 6323 16 to to TO 19613 6323 17 be be VB 19613 6323 18 a a DT 19613 6323 19 legitimate legitimate JJ 19613 6323 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 6323 21 hope hope NN 19613 6323 22 and and CC 19613 6323 23 held hold VBD 19613 6323 24 out out RP 19613 6323 25 a a DT 19613 6323 26 sure sure JJ 19613 6323 27 prospect prospect NN 19613 6323 28 of of IN 19613 6323 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6323 30 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 6323 31 through through IN 19613 6323 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6323 33 , , , 19613 6323 34 must must MD 19613 6323 35 have have VB 19613 6323 36 given give VBN 19613 6323 37 the the DT 19613 6323 38 greatest great JJS 19613 6323 39 impulse impulse NN 19613 6323 40 to to IN 19613 6323 41 the the DT 19613 6323 42 spread spread NN 19613 6323 43 and and CC 19613 6323 44 adoption adoption NN 19613 6323 45 of of IN 19613 6323 46 this this DT 19613 6323 47 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6323 48 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6323 49 . . . 19613 6324 1 But but CC 19613 6324 2 , , , 19613 6324 3 when when WRB 19613 6324 4 the the DT 19613 6324 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 6324 6 religion religion NN 19613 6324 7 was be VBD 19613 6324 8 represented represent VBN 19613 6324 9 as as IN 19613 6324 10 the the DT 19613 6324 11 belief belief NN 19613 6324 12 in in IN 19613 6324 13 the the DT 19613 6324 14 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6324 15 of of IN 19613 6324 16 God God NNP 19613 6324 17 and and CC 19613 6324 18 as as IN 19613 6324 19 the the DT 19613 6324 20 sure sure JJ 19613 6324 21 hope hope NN 19613 6324 22 of of IN 19613 6324 23 the the DT 19613 6324 24 deification deification NN 19613 6324 25 of of IN 19613 6324 26 man man NN 19613 6324 27 , , , 19613 6324 28 a a DT 19613 6324 29 speculation speculation NN 19613 6324 30 that that WDT 19613 6324 31 had have VBD 19613 6324 32 originally originally RB 19613 6324 33 never never RB 19613 6324 34 got get VBN 19613 6324 35 beyond beyond IN 19613 6324 36 the the DT 19613 6324 37 fringe fringe NN 19613 6324 38 of of IN 19613 6324 39 religious religious JJ 19613 6324 40 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6324 41 was be VBD 19613 6324 42 made make VBN 19613 6324 43 the the DT 19613 6324 44 central central JJ 19613 6324 45 point point NN 19613 6324 46 of of IN 19613 6324 47 the the DT 19613 6324 48 system system NN 19613 6324 49 and and CC 19613 6324 50 the the DT 19613 6324 51 simple simple JJ 19613 6324 52 content content NN 19613 6324 53 of of IN 19613 6324 54 the the DT 19613 6324 55 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 6324 56 was be VBD 19613 6324 57 obscured obscure VBN 19613 6324 58 . . . 19613 6325 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6325 2 655 655 CD 19613 6325 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6325 4 Footnotes footnote NNS 19613 6325 5 : : : 19613 6325 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6325 7 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6325 8 460 460 CD 19613 6325 9 : : : 19613 6325 10 Authorities authority NNS 19613 6325 11 : : : 19613 6325 12 The the DT 19613 6325 13 works work NNS 19613 6325 14 of of IN 19613 6325 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6325 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6325 17 Stieren Stieren NNP 19613 6325 18 's 's POS 19613 6325 19 and and CC 19613 6325 20 Harvey Harvey NNP 19613 6325 21 's 's POS 19613 6325 22 editions edition NNS 19613 6325 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6325 24 , , , 19613 6325 25 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6325 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6325 27 Otto Otto NNP 19613 6325 28 , , , 19613 6325 29 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 6325 30 Apol Apol NNP 19613 6325 31 . . . 19613 6326 1 IX ix NN 19613 6326 2 . . . 19613 6327 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6327 2 , , , 19613 6327 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6327 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6327 5 Oehler Oehler NNP 19613 6327 6 's 's POS 19613 6327 7 and and CC 19613 6327 8 Reiflerscheid Reiflerscheid NNP 19613 6327 9 's 's POS 19613 6327 10 editions edition NNS 19613 6327 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6327 12 , , , 19613 6327 13 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6327 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6327 15 Fabricius Fabricius NNP 19613 6327 16 ' ' POS 19613 6327 17 , , , 19613 6327 18 Lagarde Lagarde NNP 19613 6327 19 's 's POS 19613 6327 20 , , , 19613 6327 21 Duncker Duncker NNP 19613 6327 22 's 's POS 19613 6327 23 and and CC 19613 6327 24 Schneidewin Schneidewin NNP 19613 6327 25 's 's POS 19613 6327 26 editions edition NNS 19613 6327 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6327 28 , , , 19613 6327 29 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 6327 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6327 31 Hartel Hartel NNP 19613 6327 32 's 's POS 19613 6327 33 edition edition NN 19613 6327 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6327 35 , , , 19613 6327 36 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6327 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6327 38 Jackson Jackson NNP 19613 6327 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6327 40 . . . 19613 6328 1 Biographies biography NNS 19613 6328 2 of of IN 19613 6328 3 Bohringer Bohringer NNP 19613 6328 4 , , , 19613 6328 5 Die Die NNP 19613 6328 6 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 6328 7 Christi Christi NNP 19613 6328 8 und und VBP 19613 6328 9 ihre ihre NN 19613 6328 10 Zeugen Zeugen NNP 19613 6328 11 , , , 19613 6328 12 1873 1873 CD 19613 6328 13 ff ff NNP 19613 6328 14 . . . 19613 6329 1 Werner Werner NNP 19613 6329 2 , , , 19613 6329 3 Der Der NNP 19613 6329 4 Paulinismus Paulinismus NNP 19613 6329 5 des des NNP 19613 6329 6 Irenäus Irenäus NNP 19613 6329 7 , , , 19613 6329 8 1889 1889 CD 19613 6329 9 . . . 19613 6330 1 Nöldechen Nöldechen NNP 19613 6330 2 , , , 19613 6330 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6330 4 , , , 19613 6330 5 1890 1890 CD 19613 6330 6 . . . 19613 6331 1 Döllinger döllinger NN 19613 6331 2 , , , 19613 6331 3 " " '' 19613 6331 4 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6331 5 und und VBD 19613 6331 6 Kallistus Kallistus NNP 19613 6331 7 , , , 19613 6331 8 " " '' 19613 6331 9 1853 1853 CD 19613 6331 10 . . . 19613 6332 1 Many many JJ 19613 6332 2 monographs monographs NN 19613 6332 3 on on IN 19613 6332 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6332 5 and and CC 19613 6332 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6332 7 . . . 19613 6332 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6333 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6333 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6333 3 461 461 CD 19613 6333 4 : : : 19613 6333 5 The the DT 19613 6333 6 following follow VBG 19613 6333 7 exposition exposition NN 19613 6333 8 will will MD 19613 6333 9 show show VB 19613 6333 10 how how WRB 19613 6333 11 much much JJ 19613 6333 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6333 13 and and CC 19613 6333 14 the the DT 19613 6333 15 later later JJ 19613 6333 16 old old JJ 19613 6333 17 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6333 18 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6333 19 learned learn VBN 19613 6333 20 from from IN 19613 6333 21 the the DT 19613 6333 22 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6333 23 . . . 19613 6334 1 As as IN 19613 6334 2 a a DT 19613 6334 3 matter matter NN 19613 6334 4 of of IN 19613 6334 5 fact fact NN 19613 6334 6 the the DT 19613 6334 7 theology theology NN 19613 6334 8 of of IN 19613 6334 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6334 10 remains remain VBZ 19613 6334 11 a a DT 19613 6334 12 riddle riddle NN 19613 6334 13 so so RB 19613 6334 14 long long RB 19613 6334 15 as as IN 19613 6334 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6334 17 try try VBP 19613 6334 18 to to TO 19613 6334 19 explain explain VB 19613 6334 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6334 21 merely merely RB 19613 6334 22 from from IN 19613 6334 23 the the DT 19613 6334 24 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 6334 25 and and CC 19613 6334 26 only only RB 19613 6334 27 consider consider VB 19613 6334 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6334 29 antithetical antithetical JJ 19613 6334 30 relations relation NNS 19613 6334 31 to to IN 19613 6334 32 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 6334 33 . . . 19613 6335 1 Little little JJ 19613 6335 2 as as IN 19613 6335 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6335 4 can can MD 19613 6335 5 understand understand VB 19613 6335 6 modern modern JJ 19613 6335 7 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 6335 8 theology theology NN 19613 6335 9 from from IN 19613 6335 10 a a DT 19613 6335 11 historical historical JJ 19613 6335 12 point point NN 19613 6335 13 of of IN 19613 6335 14 view view NN 19613 6335 15 -- -- : 19613 6335 16 if if IN 19613 6335 17 the the DT 19613 6335 18 comparison comparison NN 19613 6335 19 be be VB 19613 6335 20 here here RB 19613 6335 21 allowed allow VBN 19613 6335 22 -- -- : 19613 6335 23 without without IN 19613 6335 24 keeping keep VBG 19613 6335 25 in in IN 19613 6335 26 mind mind NN 19613 6335 27 what what WP 19613 6335 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6335 29 has have VBZ 19613 6335 30 adopted adopt VBN 19613 6335 31 from from IN 19613 6335 32 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 19613 6335 33 and and CC 19613 6335 34 Hegel Hegel NNP 19613 6335 35 , , , 19613 6335 36 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6335 37 can can MD 19613 6335 38 just just RB 19613 6335 39 as as RB 19613 6335 40 little little JJ 19613 6335 41 understand understand VB 19613 6335 42 the the DT 19613 6335 43 theology theology NN 19613 6335 44 of of IN 19613 6335 45 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6335 46 without without IN 19613 6335 47 taking take VBG 19613 6335 48 into into IN 19613 6335 49 account account NN 19613 6335 50 the the DT 19613 6335 51 schools school NNS 19613 6335 52 of of IN 19613 6335 53 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 6335 54 and and CC 19613 6335 55 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6335 56 . . . 19613 6335 57 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6336 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6336 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6336 3 462 462 CD 19613 6336 4 : : : 19613 6336 5 That that IN 19613 6336 6 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6336 7 is be VBZ 19613 6336 8 to to TO 19613 6336 9 be be VB 19613 6336 10 named name VBN 19613 6336 11 here here RB 19613 6336 12 follows follow VBZ 19613 6336 13 both both DT 19613 6336 14 from from IN 19613 6336 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 6336 16 , , , 19613 6336 17 H. H. NNP 19613 6336 18 E. E. NNP 19613 6336 19 V. V. NNP 19613 6336 20 28 28 CD 19613 6336 21 . . . 19613 6337 1 5 5 CD 19613 6337 2 , , , 19613 6337 3 and and CC 19613 6337 4 still still RB 19613 6337 5 more more RBR 19613 6337 6 plainly plainly RB 19613 6337 7 from from IN 19613 6337 8 what what WP 19613 6337 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6337 10 know know VBP 19613 6337 11 of of IN 19613 6337 12 the the DT 19613 6337 13 writings writing NNS 19613 6337 14 of of IN 19613 6337 15 this this DT 19613 6337 16 bishop bishop NN 19613 6337 17 ; ; : 19613 6337 18 see see VB 19613 6337 19 Texte Texte NNP 19613 6337 20 und und RP 19613 6337 21 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 6337 22 zur zur NNP 19613 6337 23 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 6337 24 der der VBD 19613 6337 25 altchristlichen altchristlichen NNP 19613 6337 26 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 6337 27 , , , 19613 6337 28 I. I. NNP 19613 6338 1 1 1 CD 19613 6338 2 , , , 19613 6338 3 2 2 CD 19613 6338 4 , , , 19613 6338 5 p. p. NN 19613 6338 6 24 24 CD 19613 6338 7 ff ff NN 19613 6338 8 . . . 19613 6339 1 The the DT 19613 6339 2 polemic polemic JJ 19613 6339 3 writings writing NNS 19613 6339 4 of of IN 19613 6339 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6339 6 and and CC 19613 6339 7 the the DT 19613 6339 8 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 6339 9 treatise treatise NN 19613 6339 10 of of IN 19613 6339 11 that that IN 19613 6339 12 " " `` 19613 6339 13 ancient ancient JJ 19613 6339 14 " " '' 19613 6339 15 quoted quote VBN 19613 6339 16 by by IN 19613 6339 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6339 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6339 19 see see VB 19613 6339 20 Patr Patr NNP 19613 6339 21 . . . 19613 6340 1 App App NNP 19613 6340 2 . . . 19613 6341 1 Opp Opp NNP 19613 6341 2 . . . 19613 6342 1 ed ed NNP 19613 6342 2 . . . 19613 6343 1 Gebhardt Gebhardt NNP 19613 6343 2 etc etc FW 19613 6343 3 . . . 19613 6344 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6345 1 2 2 CD 19613 6345 2 , , , 19613 6345 3 p. p. NN 19613 6345 4 105 105 CD 19613 6345 5 sq sq NNP 19613 6345 6 . . . 19613 6345 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6346 1 may may MD 19613 6346 2 in in IN 19613 6346 3 a a DT 19613 6346 4 certain certain JJ 19613 6346 5 sense sense NN 19613 6346 6 be be VB 19613 6346 7 viewed view VBN 19613 6346 8 as as IN 19613 6346 9 the the DT 19613 6346 10 precursors precursor NNS 19613 6346 11 of of IN 19613 6346 12 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6346 13 literature literature NN 19613 6346 14 . . . 19613 6347 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6347 2 have have VBP 19613 6347 3 no no DT 19613 6347 4 material material NN 19613 6347 5 for for IN 19613 6347 6 judging judge VBG 19613 6347 7 of of IN 19613 6347 8 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6347 9 with with IN 19613 6347 10 certainty certainty NN 19613 6347 11 . . . 19613 6348 1 The the DT 19613 6348 2 New New NNP 19613 6348 3 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6348 4 was be VBD 19613 6348 5 not not RB 19613 6348 6 yet yet RB 19613 6348 7 at at IN 19613 6348 8 the the DT 19613 6348 9 disposal disposal NN 19613 6348 10 of of IN 19613 6348 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6348 12 authors author NNS 19613 6348 13 , , , 19613 6348 14 and and CC 19613 6348 15 consequently consequently RB 19613 6348 16 there there EX 19613 6348 17 is be VBZ 19613 6348 18 a a DT 19613 6348 19 gap gap NN 19613 6348 20 between between IN 19613 6348 21 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6348 22 and and CC 19613 6348 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6348 24 . . . 19613 6348 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6349 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6349 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6349 3 463 463 CD 19613 6349 4 : : : 19613 6349 5 See see VB 19613 6349 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 6349 7 , , , 19613 6349 8 H. H. NNP 19613 6349 9 E. E. NNP 19613 6349 10 V. V. NNP 19613 6350 1 13 13 CD 19613 6350 2 . . . 19613 6350 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6351 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6351 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6351 3 464 464 CD 19613 6351 4 : : : 19613 6351 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6351 6 does do VBZ 19613 6351 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 6351 8 say say VB 19613 6351 9 in in IN 19613 6351 10 de de NNP 19613 6351 11 præscr præscr NNS 19613 6351 12 . . . 19613 6352 1 14 14 CD 19613 6352 2 : : : 19613 6352 3 " " `` 19613 6352 4 Ceterum Ceterum NNP 19613 6352 5 manente manente NN 19613 6352 6 forma forma NN 19613 6352 7 regulæ regulæ NN 19613 6352 8 fidei fidei NNP 19613 6352 9 in in IN 19613 6352 10 suo suo NNP 19613 6352 11 ordine ordine NNP 19613 6352 12 quantumlibet quantumlibet NNP 19613 6352 13 quæras quæras NNP 19613 6352 14 , , , 19613 6352 15 et et NNP 19613 6352 16 trades trade NNS 19613 6352 17 , , , 19613 6352 18 et et NNP 19613 6352 19 omnem omnem NNP 19613 6352 20 libidinem libidinem NNP 19613 6352 21 curiositatis curiositatis NNP 19613 6352 22 effundas effundas NNP 19613 6352 23 , , , 19613 6352 24 si si FW 19613 6352 25 quid quid NNP 19613 6352 26 tibi tibi NNP 19613 6352 27 videtur videtur NNP 19613 6352 28 vel vel NNP 19613 6352 29 ambiguitate ambiguitate NNP 19613 6352 30 pendere pendere NNP 19613 6352 31 vel vel NNP 19613 6352 32 obscuritate obscuritate NNP 19613 6352 33 obumbrari obumbrari NNP 19613 6352 34 " " '' 19613 6352 35 ; ; : 19613 6352 36 but but CC 19613 6352 37 the the DT 19613 6352 38 preceding precede VBG 19613 6352 39 exposition exposition NN 19613 6352 40 of of IN 19613 6352 41 the the DT 19613 6352 42 _ _ NNP 19613 6352 43 regula regula NN 19613 6352 44 _ _ NNP 19613 6352 45 shows show VBZ 19613 6352 46 that that IN 19613 6352 47 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 6352 48 any any DT 19613 6352 49 scope scope NN 19613 6352 50 remained remain VBD 19613 6352 51 for for IN 19613 6352 52 the the DT 19613 6352 53 " " `` 19613 6352 54 curiositas curiositas NNP 19613 6352 55 , , , 19613 6352 56 " " '' 19613 6352 57 and and CC 19613 6352 58 the the DT 19613 6352 59 one one NN 19613 6352 60 that that WDT 19613 6352 61 follows follow VBZ 19613 6352 62 proves prof NNS 19613 6352 63 that that IN 19613 6352 64 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6352 65 did do VBD 19613 6352 66 not not RB 19613 6352 67 mean mean VB 19613 6352 68 that that DT 19613 6352 69 freedom freedom NN 19613 6352 70 seriously seriously RB 19613 6352 71 . . . 19613 6352 72 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6353 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6353 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6353 3 465 465 CD 19613 6353 4 : : : 19613 6353 5 The the DT 19613 6353 6 most most RBS 19613 6353 7 important important JJ 19613 6353 8 point point NN 19613 6353 9 was be VBD 19613 6353 10 that that IN 19613 6353 11 the the DT 19613 6353 12 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 6353 13 theology theology NN 19613 6353 14 , , , 19613 6353 15 towards towards IN 19613 6353 16 which which WDT 19613 6353 17 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6353 18 , , , 19613 6353 19 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 6353 20 , , , 19613 6353 21 and and CC 19613 6353 22 Encratites Encratites NNPS 19613 6353 23 had have VBD 19613 6353 24 already already RB 19613 6353 25 taken take VBN 19613 6353 26 up up RP 19613 6353 27 a a DT 19613 6353 28 definite definite JJ 19613 6353 29 attitude attitude NN 19613 6353 30 , , , 19613 6353 31 could could MD 19613 6353 32 now now RB 19613 6353 33 no no RB 19613 6353 34 longer longer RB 19613 6353 35 be be VB 19613 6353 36 ignored ignore VBN 19613 6353 37 . . . 19613 6354 1 See see VB 19613 6354 2 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 6354 3 's 's POS 19613 6354 4 Basler Basler NNP 19613 6354 5 Univ.--Programm Univ.--Programm NNP 19613 6354 6 , , , 19613 6354 7 1877 1877 CD 19613 6354 8 . . . 19613 6355 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6355 2 immediately immediately RB 19613 6355 3 shows show VBZ 19613 6355 4 the the DT 19613 6355 5 influence influence NN 19613 6355 6 of of IN 19613 6355 7 Paulinism Paulinism NNP 19613 6355 8 very very RB 19613 6355 9 clearly clearly RB 19613 6355 10 . . . 19613 6355 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6356 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6356 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6356 3 466 466 CD 19613 6356 4 : : : 19613 6356 5 See see VB 19613 6356 6 what what WP 19613 6356 7 Rhodon Rhodon NNP 19613 6356 8 says say VBZ 19613 6356 9 about about IN 19613 6356 10 the the DT 19613 6356 11 issue issue NN 19613 6356 12 of of IN 19613 6356 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6356 14 conversation conversation NN 19613 6356 15 with with IN 19613 6356 16 Appelles Appelles NNP 19613 6356 17 in in IN 19613 6356 18 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 6356 19 . . NNP 19613 6356 20 , , , 19613 6356 21 H. H. NNP 19613 6356 22 E. E. NNP 19613 6356 23 V. V. NNP 19613 6356 24 13 13 CD 19613 6356 25 . . . 19613 6357 1 7 7 LS 19613 6357 2 : : : 19613 6357 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6357 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6357 5 : : : 19613 6357 6 egô egô NNP 19613 6357 7 de de NNP 19613 6357 8 gelasas gelasas NNP 19613 6357 9 kategnôn kategnôn NNP 19613 6357 10 autou autou NNP 19613 6357 11 , , , 19613 6357 12 dioti dioti NNP 19613 6357 13 dedaskalos dedaskalos NNP 19613 6357 14 einai einai NNP 19613 6357 15 legôn legôn NNP 19613 6357 16 oun oun NNP 19613 6357 17 êdei êdei NNP 19613 6357 18 to to TO 19613 6357 19 didaskomenon didaskomenon VB 19613 6357 20 hup hup NNP 19613 6357 21 ' ' POS 19613 6357 22 autou autou NNP 19613 6357 23 kratunein kratunein NNP 19613 6357 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6357 25 . . . 19613 6357 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6358 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6358 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6358 3 467 467 CD 19613 6358 4 : : : 19613 6358 5 On on IN 19613 6358 6 the the DT 19613 6358 7 old old JJ 19613 6358 8 " " `` 19613 6358 9 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6358 10 and and CC 19613 6358 11 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6358 12 " " `` 19613 6358 13 see see VBP 19613 6358 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6358 15 remarks remark NNS 19613 6358 16 on on IN 19613 6358 17 the the DT 19613 6358 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6358 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6358 20 : : : 19613 6358 21 Didachê didachê NN 19613 6358 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6358 23 , , , 19613 6358 24 c. c. NNP 19613 6358 25 11 11 CD 19613 6358 26 ff ff NNP 19613 6358 27 . . NNP 19613 6358 28 , , , 19613 6358 29 and and CC 19613 6358 30 the the DT 19613 6358 31 section section NN 19613 6358 32 , , , 19613 6358 33 pp pp NNP 19613 6358 34 . . . 19613 6359 1 93 93 CD 19613 6359 2 - - SYM 19613 6359 3 137 137 CD 19613 6359 4 , , , 19613 6359 5 of of IN 19613 6359 6 the the DT 19613 6359 7 prolegomena prolegomena NN 19613 6359 8 to to IN 19613 6359 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6359 10 edition edition NN 19613 6359 11 of of IN 19613 6359 12 this this DT 19613 6359 13 work work NN 19613 6359 14 . . . 19613 6360 1 The the DT 19613 6360 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6360 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6360 4 : : : 19613 6360 5 didaskaloi didaskaloi NNP 19613 6360 6 apostolikoi apostolikoi NNP 19613 6360 7 kai kai NNP 19613 6360 8 prophêtikoi prophêtikoi NNP 19613 6360 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6360 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6360 11 Ep Ep NNP 19613 6360 12 . . . 19613 6361 1 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 19613 6361 2 . . . 19613 6362 1 ap ap UH 19613 6362 2 . . . 19613 6363 1 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 6363 2 . . NNP 19613 6363 3 , , , 19613 6363 4 H. H. NNP 19613 6363 5 E. E. NNP 19613 6363 6 IV IV NNP 19613 6363 7 . . . 19613 6364 1 15 15 CD 19613 6364 2 . . . 19613 6365 1 39 39 LS 19613 6365 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6365 3 became become VBD 19613 6365 4 lay lie VBN 19613 6365 5 - - HYPH 19613 6365 6 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6365 7 who who WP 19613 6365 8 were be VBD 19613 6365 9 skilful skilful JJ 19613 6365 10 in in IN 19613 6365 11 the the DT 19613 6365 12 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 6365 13 of of IN 19613 6365 14 the the DT 19613 6365 15 sacred sacred JJ 19613 6365 16 traditions tradition NNS 19613 6365 17 . . . 19613 6365 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6366 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6366 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6366 3 468 468 CD 19613 6366 4 : : : 19613 6366 5 In in IN 19613 6366 6 the the DT 19613 6366 7 case case NN 19613 6366 8 of of IN 19613 6366 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6366 10 , , , 19613 6366 11 as as IN 19613 6366 12 is be VBZ 19613 6366 13 well well RB 19613 6366 14 known known JJ 19613 6366 15 , , , 19613 6366 16 there there EX 19613 6366 17 was be VBD 19613 6366 18 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 6366 19 no no DT 19613 6366 20 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 6366 21 of of IN 19613 6366 22 this this DT 19613 6366 23 , , , 19613 6366 24 as as IN 19613 6366 25 is be VBZ 19613 6366 26 well well RB 19613 6366 27 remarked remark VBN 19613 6366 28 by by IN 19613 6366 29 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 6366 30 in in IN 19613 6366 31 H. H. NNP 19613 6366 32 E. E. NNP 19613 6366 33 V. V. NNP 19613 6366 34 7 7 CD 19613 6366 35 . . . 19613 6367 1 In in IN 19613 6367 2 support support NN 19613 6367 3 of of IN 19613 6367 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6367 5 own own JJ 19613 6367 6 writings writing NNS 19613 6367 7 , , , 19613 6367 8 however however RB 19613 6367 9 , , , 19613 6367 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6367 11 appealed appeal VBD 19613 6367 12 to to IN 19613 6367 13 no no DT 19613 6367 14 charisms charism NNS 19613 6367 15 . . . 19613 6367 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6368 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6368 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6368 3 469 469 CD 19613 6368 4 : : : 19613 6368 5 See see VB 19613 6368 6 the the DT 19613 6368 7 passage passage NN 19613 6368 8 already already RB 19613 6368 9 quoted quote VBN 19613 6368 10 on on IN 19613 6368 11 p. p. NN 19613 6368 12 63 63 CD 19613 6368 13 , , , 19613 6368 14 note note VBP 19613 6368 15 1 1 CD 19613 6368 16 . . . 19613 6368 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6369 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6369 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6369 3 470 470 CD 19613 6369 4 : : : 19613 6369 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6369 6 and and CC 19613 6369 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6369 8 scoffed scoff VBD 19613 6369 9 at at IN 19613 6369 10 the the DT 19613 6369 11 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6369 12 terminology terminology NN 19613 6369 13 in in IN 19613 6369 14 the the DT 19613 6369 15 most most RBS 19613 6369 16 bitter bitter JJ 19613 6369 17 way way NN 19613 6369 18 . . . 19613 6369 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6370 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6370 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6370 3 471 471 CD 19613 6370 4 : : : 19613 6370 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6370 6 , , , 19613 6370 7 adv adv NN 19613 6370 8 . . . 19613 6371 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6371 2 . . . 19613 6372 1 3 3 LS 19613 6372 2 : : : 19613 6372 3 " " `` 19613 6372 4 Simplices Simplices NNPS 19613 6372 5 enim enim NNP 19613 6372 6 quique quique NN 19613 6372 7 , , , 19613 6372 8 ne ne NNP 19613 6372 9 dixerim dixerim NNP 19613 6372 10 imprudentes imprudentes NNPS 19613 6372 11 et et NNP 19613 6372 12 idiotæ idiotæ NNP 19613 6372 13 , , , 19613 6372 14 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6372 15 major major NNP 19613 6372 16 semper semper NNP 19613 6372 17 credentium credentium NN 19613 6372 18 pars par NNS 19613 6372 19 est est NNP 19613 6372 20 , , , 19613 6372 21 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 6372 22 et et NNP 19613 6372 23 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 6372 24 regula regula NNP 19613 6372 25 fidei fidei VBD 19613 6372 26 a a DT 19613 6372 27 pluribus pluribus NNP 19613 6372 28 diis diis NNP 19613 6372 29 sæculi sæculi NNP 19613 6372 30 ad ad NNP 19613 6372 31 unicum unicum NNP 19613 6372 32 et et NNP 19613 6372 33 verum verum NNP 19613 6372 34 deum deum NNP 19613 6372 35 transfert transfert NN 19613 6372 36 , , , 19613 6372 37 non non JJ 19613 6372 38 intellegentes intellegente VBZ 19613 6372 39 unicum unicum JJ 19613 6372 40 quidem quidem NN 19613 6372 41 , , , 19613 6372 42 sed sed NNP 19613 6372 43 cum cum NNP 19613 6372 44 sua sua NNP 19613 6372 45 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6372 46 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6372 47 : : : 19613 6372 48 oikonomia oikonomia NN 19613 6372 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6372 50 esse esse NNP 19613 6372 51 credendum credendum NNP 19613 6372 52 , , , 19613 6372 53 expavescunt expavescunt NN 19613 6372 54 ad ad NN 19613 6372 55 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6372 56 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6372 57 : : : 19613 6372 58 oikonomian oikonomian NNP 19613 6372 59 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6372 60 . . . 19613 6372 61 " " '' 19613 6373 1 Similar similar JJ 19613 6373 2 remarks remark NNS 19613 6373 3 often often RB 19613 6373 4 occur occur VBP 19613 6373 5 in in IN 19613 6373 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 6373 7 . . . 19613 6374 1 See see VB 19613 6374 2 also also RB 19613 6374 3 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 6374 4 . . . 19613 6374 5 , , , 19613 6374 6 c. c. NNP 19613 6374 7 Noet Noet NNP 19613 6374 8 11 11 CD 19613 6374 9 . . . 19613 6374 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6375 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6375 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6375 3 472 472 CD 19613 6375 4 : : : 19613 6375 5 The the DT 19613 6375 6 danger danger NN 19613 6375 7 of of IN 19613 6375 8 speculation speculation NN 19613 6375 9 and and CC 19613 6375 10 of of IN 19613 6375 11 the the DT 19613 6375 12 desire desire NN 19613 6375 13 to to TO 19613 6375 14 know know VB 19613 6375 15 everything everything NN 19613 6375 16 was be VBD 19613 6375 17 impressively impressively RB 19613 6375 18 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 6375 19 by by IN 19613 6375 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6375 21 , , , 19613 6375 22 II II NNP 19613 6375 23 . . . 19613 6376 1 25 25 CD 19613 6376 2 - - SYM 19613 6376 3 28 28 CD 19613 6376 4 . . . 19613 6377 1 As as IN 19613 6377 2 a a DT 19613 6377 3 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 6377 4 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6377 5 positivist positivist NN 19613 6377 6 and and CC 19613 6377 7 traditionalist traditionalist NN 19613 6377 8 , , , 19613 6377 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6377 10 seems seem VBZ 19613 6377 11 in in IN 19613 6377 12 these these DT 19613 6377 13 chapters chapter NNS 19613 6377 14 disposed dispose VBD 19613 6377 15 to to TO 19613 6377 16 admit admit VB 19613 6377 17 nothing nothing NN 19613 6377 18 but but IN 19613 6377 19 obedient obedient JJ 19613 6377 20 and and CC 19613 6377 21 acquiescent acquiescent JJ 19613 6377 22 faith faith NN 19613 6377 23 in in IN 19613 6377 24 the the DT 19613 6377 25 words word NNS 19613 6377 26 of of IN 19613 6377 27 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6377 28 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 6377 29 , , , 19613 6377 30 and and CC 19613 6377 31 even even RB 19613 6377 32 to to TO 19613 6377 33 reject reject VB 19613 6377 34 speculations speculation NNS 19613 6377 35 like like IN 19613 6377 36 those those DT 19613 6377 37 of of IN 19613 6377 38 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 6377 39 , , , 19613 6377 40 Orat Orat NNP 19613 6377 41 . . . 19613 6378 1 5 5 CD 19613 6378 2 . . . 19613 6379 1 Cf cf NN 19613 6379 2 . . . 19613 6380 1 the the DT 19613 6380 2 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 6380 3 II II NNP 19613 6380 4 . . . 19613 6381 1 25 25 CD 19613 6381 2 . . . 19613 6382 1 3 3 LS 19613 6382 2 : : : 19613 6382 3 " " `` 19613 6382 4 Si Si NNP 19613 6382 5 autem autem NNP 19613 6382 6 et et NNP 19613 6382 7 aliquis aliquis NN 19613 6382 8 non non NNP 19613 6382 9 invenerit invenerit NNP 19613 6382 10 causam causam NNP 19613 6382 11 omnium omnium NNP 19613 6382 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6382 13 requiruntur requiruntur NNP 19613 6382 14 , , , 19613 6382 15 cogitet cogitet NN 19613 6382 16 , , , 19613 6382 17 quia quia NNP 19613 6382 18 homo homo NNP 19613 6382 19 est est NNP 19613 6382 20 in in IN 19613 6382 21 infinitum infinitum JJ 19613 6382 22 minor minor JJ 19613 6382 23 deo deo NNP 19613 6382 24 et et NNP 19613 6382 25 qui qui NNP 19613 6382 26 ex ex NNP 19613 6382 27 parte parte NNP 19613 6382 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6382 29 cf cf NN 19613 6382 30 . . . 19613 6383 1 II ii CD 19613 6383 2 . . . 19613 6384 1 28 28 CD 19613 6384 2 . . . 19613 6384 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6385 1 acceperit acceperit NNP 19613 6385 2 gratiam gratiam NNP 19613 6385 3 et et NNP 19613 6385 4 qui qui NNP 19613 6385 5 nondum nondum NNP 19613 6385 6 æqualis æqualis NNP 19613 6385 7 vel vel NNP 19613 6385 8 similis similis NNP 19613 6385 9 sit sit VBP 19613 6385 10 factori factori NNP 19613 6385 11 " " '' 19613 6385 12 ; ; : 19613 6385 13 II II NNP 19613 6385 14 . . . 19613 6386 1 26 26 CD 19613 6386 2 . . . 19613 6387 1 1 1 LS 19613 6387 2 : : : 19613 6387 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6387 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6387 5 : : : 19613 6387 6 Ameinon ameinon VB 19613 6387 7 kai kai NNP 19613 6387 8 symphorôteron symphorôteron NN 19613 6387 9 idiôtas idiôtas NNP 19613 6387 10 kai kai NNP 19613 6387 11 oligomatheis oligomatheis NNP 19613 6387 12 huparchein huparchein NNP 19613 6387 13 , , , 19613 6387 14 kai kai NNP 19613 6387 15 dia dia NNP 19613 6387 16 tês tês NNP 19613 6387 17 agapês agapês NNP 19613 6387 18 plêsion plêsion NNP 19613 6387 19 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 6387 20 tou tou NNP 19613 6387 21 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6387 22 ê ê NNP 19613 6387 23 polymatheis polymatheis NNP 19613 6387 24 kai kai NNP 19613 6387 25 empeirous empeirous JJ 19613 6387 26 dokountas dokountas NNP 19613 6387 27 einai einai NNP 19613 6387 28 , , , 19613 6387 29 blasphêmous blasphêmous JJ 19613 6387 30 eis eis NNP 19613 6387 31 ton ton NN 19613 6387 32 heautôn heautôn NNP 19613 6387 33 heuriskesthai heuriskesthai NNP 19613 6387 34 despotên despotên NNP 19613 6387 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6387 36 , , , 19613 6387 37 and and CC 19613 6387 38 in in IN 19613 6387 39 addition addition NN 19613 6387 40 to to IN 19613 6387 41 this this DT 19613 6387 42 the the DT 19613 6387 43 close close NN 19613 6387 44 of of IN 19613 6387 45 the the DT 19613 6387 46 paragraph paragraph NN 19613 6387 47 , , , 19613 6387 48 II II NNP 19613 6387 49 . . . 19613 6388 1 27 27 CD 19613 6388 2 . . . 19613 6389 1 1 1 LS 19613 6389 2 : : : 19613 6389 3 Concerning concern VBG 19613 6389 4 the the DT 19613 6389 5 sphere sphere NN 19613 6389 6 within within IN 19613 6389 7 which which WDT 19613 6389 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6389 9 are be VBP 19613 6389 10 to to TO 19613 6389 11 search search VB 19613 6389 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6389 13 the the DT 19613 6389 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6389 15 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 6389 16 and and CC 19613 6389 17 " " `` 19613 6389 18 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6389 19 ante ante NNP 19613 6389 20 oculos oculos NNP 19613 6389 21 nostros nostros NNP 19613 6389 22 occurrunt occurrunt NN 19613 6389 23 " " '' 19613 6389 24 , , , 19613 6389 25 much much RB 19613 6389 26 remains remain VBZ 19613 6389 27 dark dark JJ 19613 6389 28 to to IN 19613 6389 29 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6389 30 even even RB 19613 6389 31 in in IN 19613 6389 32 the the DT 19613 6389 33 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6389 34 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 6389 35 II II NNP 19613 6389 36 . . . 19613 6390 1 28 28 CD 19613 6390 2 . . . 19613 6391 1 3 3 LS 19613 6391 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6391 3 ; ; : 19613 6391 4 II II NNP 19613 6391 5 . . . 19613 6392 1 28 28 CD 19613 6392 2 . . . 19613 6393 1 1 1 CD 19613 6393 2 f. f. NNP 19613 6393 3 on on IN 19613 6393 4 the the DT 19613 6393 5 canon canon NN 19613 6393 6 which which WDT 19613 6393 7 is be VBZ 19613 6393 8 to to TO 19613 6393 9 be be VB 19613 6393 10 observed observe VBN 19613 6393 11 in in IN 19613 6393 12 all all DT 19613 6393 13 investigations investigation NNS 19613 6393 14 , , , 19613 6393 15 namely namely RB 19613 6393 16 , , , 19613 6393 17 the the DT 19613 6393 18 confident confident JJ 19613 6393 19 faith faith NN 19613 6393 20 in in IN 19613 6393 21 God God NNP 19613 6393 22 the the DT 19613 6393 23 creator creator NN 19613 6393 24 , , , 19613 6393 25 as as IN 19613 6393 26 the the DT 19613 6393 27 supreme supreme NNP 19613 6393 28 and and CC 19613 6393 29 only only RB 19613 6393 30 Deity Deity NNP 19613 6393 31 ; ; : 19613 6393 32 II II NNP 19613 6393 33 . . . 19613 6394 1 28 28 CD 19613 6394 2 . . . 19613 6395 1 2 2 CD 19613 6395 2 - - SYM 19613 6395 3 7 7 CD 19613 6395 4 : : : 19613 6395 5 specification specification NN 19613 6395 6 of of IN 19613 6395 7 the the DT 19613 6395 8 great great JJ 19613 6395 9 problems problem NNS 19613 6395 10 whose whose WP$ 19613 6395 11 solution solution NN 19613 6395 12 is be VBZ 19613 6395 13 hid hide VBN 19613 6395 14 from from IN 19613 6395 15 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6395 16 , , , 19613 6395 17 viz viz NNP 19613 6395 18 . . NNP 19613 6395 19 , , , 19613 6395 20 the the DT 19613 6395 21 elementary elementary JJ 19613 6395 22 natural natural JJ 19613 6395 23 phenomena phenomenon NNS 19613 6395 24 , , , 19613 6395 25 the the DT 19613 6395 26 relation relation NN 19613 6395 27 of of IN 19613 6395 28 the the DT 19613 6395 29 Son Son NNP 19613 6395 30 to to IN 19613 6395 31 the the DT 19613 6395 32 Father Father NNP 19613 6395 33 , , , 19613 6395 34 that that RB 19613 6395 35 is is RB 19613 6395 36 , , , 19613 6395 37 the the DT 19613 6395 38 manner manner NN 19613 6395 39 in in IN 19613 6395 40 which which WDT 19613 6395 41 the the DT 19613 6395 42 Son Son NNP 19613 6395 43 was be VBD 19613 6395 44 begotten beget VBN 19613 6395 45 , , , 19613 6395 46 the the DT 19613 6395 47 way way NN 19613 6395 48 in in IN 19613 6395 49 which which WDT 19613 6395 50 matter matter NN 19613 6395 51 was be VBD 19613 6395 52 created create VBN 19613 6395 53 , , , 19613 6395 54 the the DT 19613 6395 55 cause cause NN 19613 6395 56 of of IN 19613 6395 57 evil evil NN 19613 6395 58 . . . 19613 6396 1 In in IN 19613 6396 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 6396 3 to to IN 19613 6396 4 the the DT 19613 6396 5 claim claim NN 19613 6396 6 to to IN 19613 6396 7 absolute absolute JJ 19613 6396 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6396 9 , , , 19613 6396 10 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6396 11 , , , 19613 6396 12 to to IN 19613 6396 13 the the DT 19613 6396 14 complete complete JJ 19613 6396 15 discovery discovery NN 19613 6396 16 of of IN 19613 6396 17 all all PDT 19613 6396 18 the the DT 19613 6396 19 processes process NNS 19613 6396 20 of of IN 19613 6396 21 causation causation NN 19613 6396 22 , , , 19613 6396 23 which which WDT 19613 6396 24 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6396 25 too too RB 19613 6396 26 alone alone RB 19613 6396 27 regards regard VBZ 19613 6396 28 as as IN 19613 6396 29 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6396 30 , , , 19613 6396 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6396 32 indeed indeed RB 19613 6396 33 pointed point VBD 19613 6396 34 out out RP 19613 6396 35 the the DT 19613 6396 36 limits limit NNS 19613 6396 37 of of IN 19613 6396 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6396 39 perception perception NN 19613 6396 40 , , , 19613 6396 41 supporting support VBG 19613 6396 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6396 43 statement statement NN 19613 6396 44 by by IN 19613 6396 45 Bible Bible NNP 19613 6396 46 passages passage NNS 19613 6396 47 . . . 19613 6397 1 But but CC 19613 6397 2 the the DT 19613 6397 3 ground ground NN 19613 6397 4 of of IN 19613 6397 5 these these DT 19613 6397 6 limits limit NNS 19613 6397 7 , , , 19613 6397 8 " " '' 19613 6397 9 ex ex NNP 19613 6397 10 parte parte NNP 19613 6397 11 accepimus accepimus NNP 19613 6397 12 gratiam gratiam NNP 19613 6397 13 , , , 19613 6397 14 " " `` 19613 6397 15 is be VBZ 19613 6397 16 not not RB 19613 6397 17 an an DT 19613 6397 18 early early JJ 19613 6397 19 - - HYPH 19613 6397 20 Christian christian JJ 19613 6397 21 one one NN 19613 6397 22 , , , 19613 6397 23 and and CC 19613 6397 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6397 25 shows show VBZ 19613 6397 26 at at IN 19613 6397 27 the the DT 19613 6397 28 same same JJ 19613 6397 29 time time NN 19613 6397 30 that that WDT 19613 6397 31 the the DT 19613 6397 32 bishop bishop NN 19613 6397 33 also also RB 19613 6397 34 viewed view VBD 19613 6397 35 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6397 36 as as IN 19613 6397 37 the the DT 19613 6397 38 goal goal NN 19613 6397 39 , , , 19613 6397 40 though though IN 19613 6397 41 indeed indeed RB 19613 6397 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6397 43 thought think VBD 19613 6397 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6397 45 could could MD 19613 6397 46 not not RB 19613 6397 47 be be VB 19613 6397 48 attained attain VBN 19613 6397 49 on on IN 19613 6397 50 earth earth NN 19613 6397 51 . . . 19613 6397 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6398 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6398 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6398 3 473 473 CD 19613 6398 4 : : : 19613 6398 5 The the DT 19613 6398 6 same same JJ 19613 6398 7 observation observation NN 19613 6398 8 applies apply VBZ 19613 6398 9 to to IN 19613 6398 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6398 11 , , , 19613 6398 12 Cf Cf NNP 19613 6398 13 . . . 19613 6399 1 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6399 2 point point NN 19613 6399 3 blank blank IN 19613 6399 4 repudiation repudiation NN 19613 6399 5 of of IN 19613 6399 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 6399 7 in in IN 19613 6399 8 de de NNP 19613 6399 9 præse præse NNP 19613 6399 10 . . . 19613 6400 1 7 7 CD 19613 6400 2 , , , 19613 6400 3 and and CC 19613 6400 4 the the DT 19613 6400 5 use use NN 19613 6400 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6400 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6400 8 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 6400 9 made make VBD 19613 6400 10 of of IN 19613 6400 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6400 12 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 6400 13 . . . 19613 6400 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6401 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6401 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6401 3 474 474 CD 19613 6401 4 : : : 19613 6401 5 In in IN 19613 6401 6 point point NN 19613 6401 7 of of IN 19613 6401 8 form form NN 19613 6401 9 this this DT 19613 6401 10 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 6401 11 is be VBZ 19613 6401 12 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 6401 13 from from IN 19613 6401 14 the the DT 19613 6401 15 ordinary ordinary JJ 19613 6401 16 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6401 17 position position NN 19613 6401 18 by by IN 19613 6401 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6401 20 renunciation renunciation NN 19613 6401 21 of of IN 19613 6401 22 absolute absolute JJ 19613 6401 23 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6401 24 , , , 19613 6401 25 and and CC 19613 6401 26 by by IN 19613 6401 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6401 28 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 6401 29 lack lack NN 19613 6401 30 of of IN 19613 6401 31 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6401 32 completeness completeness NN 19613 6401 33 . . . 19613 6402 1 That that DT 19613 6402 2 , , , 19613 6402 3 however however RB 19613 6402 4 , , , 19613 6402 5 is be VBZ 19613 6402 6 an an DT 19613 6402 7 important important JJ 19613 6402 8 distinction distinction NN 19613 6402 9 in in IN 19613 6402 10 favour favour NN 19613 6402 11 of of IN 19613 6402 12 the the DT 19613 6402 13 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6402 14 Fathers Fathers NNPS 19613 6402 15 . . . 19613 6403 1 According accord VBG 19613 6403 2 to to IN 19613 6403 3 what what WP 19613 6403 4 has have VBZ 19613 6403 5 been be VBN 19613 6403 6 set set VBN 19613 6403 7 forth forth RP 19613 6403 8 in in IN 19613 6403 9 the the DT 19613 6403 10 text text NN 19613 6403 11 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6403 12 can can MD 19613 6403 13 not not RB 19613 6403 14 agree agree VB 19613 6403 15 with with IN 19613 6403 16 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 6403 17 's 's POS 19613 6403 18 judgment judgment NN 19613 6403 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6403 20 Marcellus Marcellus NNP 19613 6403 21 of of IN 19613 6403 22 Ancyra Ancyra NNP 19613 6403 23 , , , 19613 6403 24 p. p. NN 19613 6403 25 235 235 CD 19613 6403 26 f. f. NNP 19613 6403 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6403 28 : : : 19613 6403 29 " " `` 19613 6403 30 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6403 31 is be VBZ 19613 6403 32 the the DT 19613 6403 33 first first JJ 19613 6403 34 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 6403 35 teacher teacher NN 19613 6403 36 who who WP 19613 6403 37 has have VBZ 19613 6403 38 grasped grasp VBN 19613 6403 39 the the DT 19613 6403 40 idea idea NN 19613 6403 41 of of IN 19613 6403 42 an an DT 19613 6403 43 independent independent JJ 19613 6403 44 science science NN 19613 6403 45 of of IN 19613 6403 46 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6403 47 , , , 19613 6403 48 of of IN 19613 6403 49 a a DT 19613 6403 50 theology theology NN 19613 6403 51 which which WDT 19613 6403 52 , , , 19613 6403 53 in in IN 19613 6403 54 spite spite NN 19613 6403 55 of of IN 19613 6403 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6403 57 width width NN 19613 6403 58 and and CC 19613 6403 59 magnitude magnitude NN 19613 6403 60 , , , 19613 6403 61 is be VBZ 19613 6403 62 a a DT 19613 6403 63 branch branch NN 19613 6403 64 of of IN 19613 6403 65 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6403 66 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 6403 67 from from IN 19613 6403 68 others other NNS 19613 6403 69 ; ; : 19613 6403 70 and and CC 19613 6403 71 was be VBD 19613 6403 72 also also RB 19613 6403 73 the the DT 19613 6403 74 first first JJ 19613 6403 75 to to TO 19613 6403 76 mark mark VB 19613 6403 77 out out RP 19613 6403 78 the the DT 19613 6403 79 paths path NNS 19613 6403 80 of of IN 19613 6403 81 this this DT 19613 6403 82 science science NN 19613 6403 83 . . . 19613 6403 84 " " '' 19613 6403 85 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6404 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6404 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6404 3 475 475 CD 19613 6404 4 : : : 19613 6404 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6404 6 seems seem VBZ 19613 6404 7 even even RB 19613 6404 8 to to TO 19613 6404 9 have have VB 19613 6404 10 had have VBN 19613 6404 11 no no DT 19613 6404 12 great great JJ 19613 6404 13 appreciation appreciation NN 19613 6404 14 for for IN 19613 6404 15 the the DT 19613 6404 16 degree degree NN 19613 6404 17 of of IN 19613 6404 18 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6404 19 exactness exactness NN 19613 6404 20 displayed display VBN 19613 6404 21 in in IN 19613 6404 22 the the DT 19613 6404 23 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 6404 24 of of IN 19613 6404 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6404 26 . . . 19613 6405 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6405 2 did do VBD 19613 6405 3 not not RB 19613 6405 4 reproduce reproduce VB 19613 6405 5 these these DT 19613 6405 6 arguments argument NNS 19613 6405 7 at at IN 19613 6405 8 least least JJS 19613 6405 9 , , , 19613 6405 10 but but CC 19613 6405 11 preferred preferred JJ 19613 6405 12 after after IN 19613 6405 13 considering consider VBG 19613 6405 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6405 15 to to TO 19613 6405 16 fall fall VB 19613 6405 17 back back RB 19613 6405 18 on on IN 19613 6405 19 the the DT 19613 6405 20 proof proof NN 19613 6405 21 from from IN 19613 6405 22 prescription prescription NN 19613 6405 23 . . . 19613 6405 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6406 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6406 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6406 3 476 476 CD 19613 6406 4 : : : 19613 6406 5 The the DT 19613 6406 6 more more RBR 19613 6406 7 closely closely RB 19613 6406 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6406 9 study study VBP 19613 6406 10 the the DT 19613 6406 11 writings writing NNS 19613 6406 12 of of IN 19613 6406 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6406 14 , , , 19613 6406 15 the the DT 19613 6406 16 more more RBR 19613 6406 17 frequently frequently RB 19613 6406 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6406 19 meet meet VBP 19613 6406 20 with with IN 19613 6406 21 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 19613 6406 22 , , , 19613 6406 23 and and CC 19613 6406 24 that that IN 19613 6406 25 in in IN 19613 6406 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6406 27 treatment treatment NN 19613 6406 28 both both DT 19613 6406 29 of of IN 19613 6406 30 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 19613 6406 31 and and CC 19613 6406 32 moral moral JJ 19613 6406 33 questions question NNS 19613 6406 34 . . . 19613 6407 1 Such such JJ 19613 6407 2 inconsistencies inconsistency NNS 19613 6407 3 could could MD 19613 6407 4 not not RB 19613 6407 5 but but RB 19613 6407 6 make make VB 19613 6407 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6407 8 appearance appearance NN 19613 6407 9 , , , 19613 6407 10 because because IN 19613 6407 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6407 12 's 's POS 19613 6407 13 dogmatising dogmatising NN 19613 6407 14 was be VBD 19613 6407 15 only only RB 19613 6407 16 incidental incidental JJ 19613 6407 17 . . . 19613 6408 1 As as RB 19613 6408 2 far far RB 19613 6408 3 as as IN 19613 6408 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6408 5 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6408 6 was be VBD 19613 6408 7 concerned concern VBN 19613 6408 8 , , , 19613 6408 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6408 10 did do VBD 19613 6408 11 not not RB 19613 6408 12 feel feel VB 19613 6408 13 the the DT 19613 6408 14 slightest slight JJS 19613 6408 15 necessity necessity NN 19613 6408 16 for for IN 19613 6408 17 a a DT 19613 6408 18 systematic systematic JJ 19613 6408 19 presentation presentation NN 19613 6408 20 of of IN 19613 6408 21 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 6408 22 . . . 19613 6408 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6409 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6409 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6409 3 477 477 CD 19613 6409 4 : : : 19613 6409 5 With with IN 19613 6409 6 reference reference NN 19613 6409 7 to to IN 19613 6409 8 certain certain JJ 19613 6409 9 articles article NNS 19613 6409 10 of of IN 19613 6409 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6409 12 , , , 19613 6409 13 however however RB 19613 6409 14 , , , 19613 6409 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6409 16 adopted adopt VBD 19613 6409 17 from from IN 19613 6409 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6409 19 some some DT 19613 6409 20 guiding guide VBG 19613 6409 21 principles principle NNS 19613 6409 22 and and CC 19613 6409 23 some some DT 19613 6409 24 points point NNS 19613 6409 25 of of IN 19613 6409 26 view view NN 19613 6409 27 arising arise VBG 19613 6409 28 from from IN 19613 6409 29 the the DT 19613 6409 30 nature nature NN 19613 6409 31 of of IN 19613 6409 32 faith faith NN 19613 6409 33 ; ; : 19613 6409 34 but but CC 19613 6409 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6409 36 almost almost RB 19613 6409 37 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 6409 38 changed change VBD 19613 6409 39 them -PRON- PRP 19613 6409 40 for for IN 19613 6409 41 the the DT 19613 6409 42 worse bad JJR 19613 6409 43 . . . 19613 6410 1 The the DT 19613 6410 2 fact fact NN 19613 6410 3 that that IN 19613 6410 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6410 5 was be VBD 19613 6410 6 capable capable JJ 19613 6410 7 of of IN 19613 6410 8 writing write VBG 19613 6410 9 a a DT 19613 6410 10 treatise treatise NN 19613 6410 11 like like IN 19613 6410 12 the the DT 19613 6410 13 de de NNP 19613 6410 14 præscr præscr NNP 19613 6410 15 . . . 19613 6411 1 hæret hæret NNP 19613 6411 2 . . . 19613 6411 3 , , , 19613 6411 4 in in IN 19613 6411 5 which which WDT 19613 6411 6 all all DT 19613 6411 7 proof proof NN 19613 6411 8 of of IN 19613 6411 9 the the DT 19613 6411 10 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 19613 6411 11 necessity necessity NN 19613 6411 12 and and CC 19613 6411 13 of of IN 19613 6411 14 the the DT 19613 6411 15 connection connection NN 19613 6411 16 of of IN 19613 6411 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6411 18 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 6411 19 is be VBZ 19613 6411 20 wanting want VBG 19613 6411 21 , , , 19613 6411 22 shows show VBZ 19613 6411 23 the the DT 19613 6411 24 limits limit NNS 19613 6411 25 of of IN 19613 6411 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6411 27 interests interest NNS 19613 6411 28 and and CC 19613 6411 29 of of IN 19613 6411 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6411 31 understanding understanding NN 19613 6411 32 . . . 19613 6411 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6412 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6412 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6412 3 478 478 CD 19613 6412 4 : : : 19613 6412 5 Further further JJ 19613 6412 6 references reference NNS 19613 6412 7 to to IN 19613 6412 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6412 9 in in IN 19613 6412 10 a a DT 19613 6412 11 future future JJ 19613 6412 12 volume volume NN 19613 6412 13 . . . 19613 6413 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6413 2 is be VBZ 19613 6413 3 at at IN 19613 6413 4 the the DT 19613 6413 5 same same JJ 19613 6413 6 time time NN 19613 6413 7 the the DT 19613 6413 8 first first JJ 19613 6413 9 Christian Christian NNP 19613 6413 10 _ _ NNP 19613 6413 11 individual individual NN 19613 6413 12 _ _ NNP 19613 6413 13 after after IN 19613 6413 14 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6413 15 , , , 19613 6413 16 of of IN 19613 6413 17 whose whose WP$ 19613 6413 18 inward inward JJ 19613 6413 19 life life NN 19613 6413 20 and and CC 19613 6413 21 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 19613 6413 22 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6413 23 can can MD 19613 6413 24 form form VB 19613 6413 25 a a DT 19613 6413 26 picture picture NN 19613 6413 27 to to IN 19613 6413 28 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 6413 29 . . . 19613 6414 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6414 2 writings writing NNS 19613 6414 3 bring bring VBP 19613 6414 4 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6414 5 near near IN 19613 6414 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6414 7 , , , 19613 6414 8 but but CC 19613 6414 9 that that DT 19613 6414 10 can can MD 19613 6414 11 not not RB 19613 6414 12 be be VB 19613 6414 13 said say VBN 19613 6414 14 of of IN 19613 6414 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6414 16 . . . 19613 6414 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6415 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6415 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6415 3 479 479 CD 19613 6415 4 : : : 19613 6415 5 Consequently consequently RB 19613 6415 6 the the DT 19613 6415 7 _ _ NNP 19613 6415 8 spirit spirit NN 19613 6415 9 _ _ NNP 19613 6415 10 of of IN 19613 6415 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6415 12 , , , 19613 6415 13 though though IN 19613 6415 14 indeed indeed RB 19613 6415 15 strongly strongly RB 19613 6415 16 modified modify VBN 19613 6415 17 by by IN 19613 6415 18 that that DT 19613 6415 19 of of IN 19613 6415 20 Origen Origen NNP 19613 6415 21 , , , 19613 6415 22 prevails prevail VBZ 19613 6415 23 in in IN 19613 6415 24 the the DT 19613 6415 25 later later JJ 19613 6415 26 Church Church NNP 19613 6415 27 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 6415 28 , , , 19613 6415 29 whilst whilst IN 19613 6415 30 that that DT 19613 6415 31 of of IN 19613 6415 32 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6415 33 is be VBZ 19613 6415 34 not not RB 19613 6415 35 to to TO 19613 6415 36 be be VB 19613 6415 37 traced trace VBN 19613 6415 38 there there RB 19613 6415 39 . . . 19613 6415 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6416 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6416 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6416 3 480 480 CD 19613 6416 4 : : : 19613 6416 5 The the DT 19613 6416 6 supreme supreme JJ 19613 6416 7 God God NNP 19613 6416 8 is be VBZ 19613 6416 9 the the DT 19613 6416 10 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6416 11 and and CC 19613 6416 12 Redeeming redeem VBG 19613 6416 13 One one CD 19613 6416 14 . . . 19613 6417 1 Hence hence RB 19613 6417 2 the the DT 19613 6417 3 identity identity NN 19613 6417 4 of of IN 19613 6417 5 the the DT 19613 6417 6 creator creator NN 19613 6417 7 of of IN 19613 6417 8 the the DT 19613 6417 9 world world NN 19613 6417 10 and and CC 19613 6417 11 the the DT 19613 6417 12 supreme supreme JJ 19613 6417 13 God God NNP 19613 6417 14 also also RB 19613 6417 15 denotes denote VBZ 19613 6417 16 the the DT 19613 6417 17 unity unity NN 19613 6417 18 of of IN 19613 6417 19 nature nature NN 19613 6417 20 , , , 19613 6417 21 morality morality NN 19613 6417 22 , , , 19613 6417 23 and and CC 19613 6417 24 revelation revelation NN 19613 6417 25 . . . 19613 6417 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6418 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6418 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6418 3 481 481 CD 19613 6418 4 : : : 19613 6418 5 What what WDT 19613 6418 6 success success NN 19613 6418 7 the the DT 19613 6418 8 early early JJ 19613 6418 9 - - HYPH 19613 6418 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 6418 11 writings writing NNS 19613 6418 12 of of IN 19613 6418 13 the the DT 19613 6418 14 second second JJ 19613 6418 15 century century NN 19613 6418 16 had have VBD 19613 6418 17 is be VBZ 19613 6418 18 almost almost RB 19613 6418 19 completely completely RB 19613 6418 20 unknown unknown JJ 19613 6418 21 to to IN 19613 6418 22 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6418 23 ; ; : 19613 6418 24 but but CC 19613 6418 25 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6418 26 are be VBP 19613 6418 27 justified justify VBN 19613 6418 28 in in IN 19613 6418 29 saying say VBG 19613 6418 30 that that IN 19613 6418 31 the the DT 19613 6418 32 five five CD 19613 6418 33 books book NNS 19613 6418 34 " " '' 19613 6418 35 adv adv NN 19613 6418 36 . . . 19613 6419 1 hæreses hærese NNS 19613 6419 2 " " `` 19613 6419 3 of of IN 19613 6419 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6419 5 were be VBD 19613 6419 6 successful successful JJ 19613 6419 7 , , , 19613 6419 8 for for IN 19613 6419 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6419 10 can can MD 19613 6419 11 prove prove VB 19613 6419 12 the the DT 19613 6419 13 favourable favourable JJ 19613 6419 14 reception reception NN 19613 6419 15 of of IN 19613 6419 16 this this DT 19613 6419 17 work work NN 19613 6419 18 and and CC 19613 6419 19 the the DT 19613 6419 20 effects effect NNS 19613 6419 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6419 22 had have VBD 19613 6419 23 in in IN 19613 6419 24 the the DT 19613 6419 25 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 6419 26 and and CC 19613 6419 27 4th 4th JJ 19613 6419 28 centuries century NNS 19613 6419 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6419 30 for for IN 19613 6419 31 instance instance NN 19613 6419 32 , , , 19613 6419 33 on on IN 19613 6419 34 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6419 35 , , , 19613 6419 36 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6419 37 , , , 19613 6419 38 Clement Clement NNP 19613 6419 39 of of IN 19613 6419 40 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 6419 41 , , , 19613 6419 42 Victorinus Victorinus NNP 19613 6419 43 , , , 19613 6419 44 Marcellus Marcellus NNP 19613 6419 45 of of IN 19613 6419 46 Ancyra Ancyra NNP 19613 6419 47 , , , 19613 6419 48 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 19613 6419 49 , , , 19613 6419 50 and and CC 19613 6419 51 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 6419 52 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 6419 53 of of IN 19613 6419 54 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 6419 55 and and CC 19613 6419 56 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 19613 6419 57 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6419 58 . . . 19613 6420 1 As as IN 19613 6420 2 is be VBZ 19613 6420 3 well well RB 19613 6420 4 known known JJ 19613 6420 5 , , , 19613 6420 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6420 7 no no RB 19613 6420 8 longer longer RB 19613 6420 9 possess possess VBP 19613 6420 10 a a DT 19613 6420 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 6420 12 manuscript manuscript NN 19613 6420 13 , , , 19613 6420 14 although although IN 19613 6420 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6420 16 can can MD 19613 6420 17 be be VB 19613 6420 18 proved prove VBN 19613 6420 19 that that IN 19613 6420 20 the the DT 19613 6420 21 work work NN 19613 6420 22 was be VBD 19613 6420 23 preserved preserve VBN 19613 6420 24 down down RP 19613 6420 25 to to IN 19613 6420 26 middle middle JJ 19613 6420 27 Byzantine byzantine JJ 19613 6420 28 times time NNS 19613 6420 29 , , , 19613 6420 30 and and CC 19613 6420 31 was be VBD 19613 6420 32 quoted quote VBN 19613 6420 33 with with IN 19613 6420 34 respect respect NN 19613 6420 35 . . . 19613 6421 1 The the DT 19613 6421 2 insufficient insufficient JJ 19613 6421 3 Christological Christological NNP 19613 6421 4 and and CC 19613 6421 5 especially especially RB 19613 6421 6 the the DT 19613 6421 7 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 6421 8 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 6421 9 spoiled spoil VBD 19613 6421 10 the the DT 19613 6421 11 enjoyment enjoyment NN 19613 6421 12 of of IN 19613 6421 13 the the DT 19613 6421 14 work work NN 19613 6421 15 in in IN 19613 6421 16 later late JJR 19613 6421 17 times time NNS 19613 6421 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6421 19 on on IN 19613 6421 20 the the DT 19613 6421 21 Latin Latin NNP 19613 6421 22 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6421 23 cf cf NN 19613 6421 24 . . . 19613 6422 1 the the DT 19613 6422 2 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 19613 6422 3 examination examination NN 19613 6422 4 of of IN 19613 6422 5 Loof Loof NNP 19613 6422 6 : : : 19613 6422 7 " " `` 19613 6422 8 The the DT 19613 6422 9 Manuscripts Manuscripts NNPS 19613 6422 10 of of IN 19613 6422 11 the the DT 19613 6422 12 Latin latin JJ 19613 6422 13 translation translation NN 19613 6422 14 of of IN 19613 6422 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6422 16 " " '' 19613 6422 17 , , , 19613 6422 18 in in IN 19613 6422 19 the the DT 19613 6422 20 " " `` 19613 6422 21 Studies Studies NNPS 19613 6422 22 of of IN 19613 6422 23 Church Church NNP 19613 6422 24 History History NNP 19613 6422 25 " " '' 19613 6422 26 dedicated dedicated JJ 19613 6422 27 to to IN 19613 6422 28 Reuter Reuter NNP 19613 6422 29 , , , 19613 6422 30 1887 1887 CD 19613 6422 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6422 32 . . . 19613 6423 1 The the DT 19613 6423 2 old old JJ 19613 6423 3 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6423 4 works work NNS 19613 6423 5 written write VBN 19613 6423 6 against against IN 19613 6423 7 heretics heretic NNS 19613 6423 8 by by IN 19613 6423 9 Rhodon Rhodon NNP 19613 6423 10 , , , 19613 6423 11 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6423 12 , , , 19613 6423 13 Miltiades Miltiades NNP 19613 6423 14 , , , 19613 6423 15 Proculus Proculus NNP 19613 6423 16 , , , 19613 6423 17 Modestus Modestus NNP 19613 6423 18 , , , 19613 6423 19 Musanus Musanus NNP 19613 6423 20 , , , 19613 6423 21 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 6423 22 , , , 19613 6423 23 Philip Philip NNP 19613 6423 24 of of IN 19613 6423 25 Gortyna Gortyna NNP 19613 6423 26 , , , 19613 6423 27 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6423 28 , , , 19613 6423 29 and and CC 19613 6423 30 others other NNS 19613 6423 31 have have VBP 19613 6423 32 all all DT 19613 6423 33 been be VBN 19613 6423 34 just just RB 19613 6423 35 as as RB 19613 6423 36 little little JJ 19613 6423 37 preserved preserved JJ 19613 6423 38 to to IN 19613 6423 39 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6423 40 as as IN 19613 6423 41 the the DT 19613 6423 42 oldest old JJS 19613 6423 43 book book NN 19613 6423 44 of of IN 19613 6423 45 this this DT 19613 6423 46 kind kind NN 19613 6423 47 , , , 19613 6423 48 the the DT 19613 6423 49 Syntagma Syntagma NNP 19613 6423 50 of of IN 19613 6423 51 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6423 52 against against IN 19613 6423 53 heresies heresy NNS 19613 6423 54 , , , 19613 6423 55 and and CC 19613 6423 56 the the DT 19613 6423 57 Memorabilia Memorabilia NNP 19613 6423 58 of of IN 19613 6423 59 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 19613 6423 60 . . . 19613 6424 1 If if IN 19613 6424 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6424 3 consider consider VBP 19613 6424 4 the the DT 19613 6424 5 criticism criticism NN 19613 6424 6 to to TO 19613 6424 7 which which WDT 19613 6424 8 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 6424 9 's 's POS 19613 6424 10 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6424 11 was be VBD 19613 6424 12 subjected subject VBN 19613 6424 13 by by IN 19613 6424 14 Arethas Arethas NNP 19613 6424 15 in in IN 19613 6424 16 the the DT 19613 6424 17 10th 10th JJ 19613 6424 18 century century NN 19613 6424 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6424 20 Oratio Oratio NNP 19613 6424 21 5 5 CD 19613 6424 22 ; ; : 19613 6424 23 see see VB 19613 6424 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6424 25 Texte Texte NNP 19613 6424 26 und und NN 19613 6424 27 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 6424 28 I. i. NN 19613 6425 1 1 1 CD 19613 6425 2 , , , 19613 6425 3 2 2 CD 19613 6425 4 p. p. NN 19613 6425 5 95 95 CD 19613 6425 6 ff ff NN 19613 6425 7 . . . 19613 6426 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6426 2 , , , 19613 6426 3 and and CC 19613 6426 4 the the DT 19613 6426 5 depreciatory depreciatory JJ 19613 6426 6 judgment judgment NN 19613 6426 7 passed pass VBN 19613 6426 8 on on IN 19613 6426 9 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 6426 10 from from IN 19613 6426 11 the the DT 19613 6426 12 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 6426 13 century century NN 19613 6426 14 downwards downwards RB 19613 6426 15 , , , 19613 6426 16 and and CC 19613 6426 17 if if IN 19613 6426 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6426 19 moreover moreover RB 19613 6426 20 reflect reflect VBP 19613 6426 21 that that IN 19613 6426 22 the the DT 19613 6426 23 older old JJR 19613 6426 24 polemical polemical JJ 19613 6426 25 works work NNS 19613 6426 26 directed direct VBN 19613 6426 27 against against IN 19613 6426 28 heretics heretic NNS 19613 6426 29 were be VBD 19613 6426 30 supplanted supplant VBN 19613 6426 31 by by IN 19613 6426 32 later later RB 19613 6426 33 detailed detailed JJ 19613 6426 34 ones one NNS 19613 6426 35 , , , 19613 6426 36 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6426 37 have have VBP 19613 6426 38 a a DT 19613 6426 39 summary summary NN 19613 6426 40 of of IN 19613 6426 41 the the DT 19613 6426 42 reasons reason NNS 19613 6426 43 for for IN 19613 6426 44 the the DT 19613 6426 45 loss loss NN 19613 6426 46 of of IN 19613 6426 47 that that DT 19613 6426 48 oldest old JJS 19613 6426 49 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 6426 50 literature literature NN 19613 6426 51 . . . 19613 6427 1 This this DT 19613 6427 2 loss loss NN 19613 6427 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 6427 4 makes make VBZ 19613 6427 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6427 6 impossible impossible JJ 19613 6427 7 for for IN 19613 6427 8 us -PRON- PRP 19613 6427 9 to to TO 19613 6427 10 form form VB 19613 6427 11 an an DT 19613 6427 12 exact exact JJ 19613 6427 13 estimate estimate NN 19613 6427 14 of of IN 19613 6427 15 the the DT 19613 6427 16 extent extent NN 19613 6427 17 and and CC 19613 6427 18 intensity intensity NN 19613 6427 19 of of IN 19613 6427 20 the the DT 19613 6427 21 effect effect NN 19613 6427 22 produced produce VBN 19613 6427 23 by by IN 19613 6427 24 any any DT 19613 6427 25 individual individual JJ 19613 6427 26 writing writing NN 19613 6427 27 , , , 19613 6427 28 even even RB 19613 6427 29 including include VBG 19613 6427 30 the the DT 19613 6427 31 great great JJ 19613 6427 32 work work NN 19613 6427 33 of of IN 19613 6427 34 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6427 35 . . . 19613 6427 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6428 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6428 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6428 3 482 482 CD 19613 6428 4 : : : 19613 6428 5 People People NNS 19613 6428 6 are be VBP 19613 6428 7 fond fond JJ 19613 6428 8 of of IN 19613 6428 9 speaking speak VBG 19613 6428 10 of of IN 19613 6428 11 the the DT 19613 6428 12 " " `` 19613 6428 13 Asia Asia NNP 19613 6428 14 Minor Minor NNP 19613 6428 15 " " '' 19613 6428 16 theology theology NN 19613 6428 17 of of IN 19613 6428 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6428 19 , , , 19613 6428 20 ascribe ascribe VB 19613 6428 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6428 22 already already RB 19613 6428 23 to to IN 19613 6428 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6428 25 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6428 26 , , , 19613 6428 27 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 6428 28 and and CC 19613 6428 29 the the DT 19613 6428 30 presbyters presbyter NNS 19613 6428 31 , , , 19613 6428 32 then then RB 19613 6428 33 ascend ascend VB 19613 6428 34 from from IN 19613 6428 35 these these DT 19613 6428 36 to to IN 19613 6428 37 the the DT 19613 6428 38 Apostle Apostle NNP 19613 6428 39 John John NNP 19613 6428 40 , , , 19613 6428 41 and and CC 19613 6428 42 complete complete JJ 19613 6428 43 , , , 19613 6428 44 though though IN 19613 6428 45 not not RB 19613 6428 46 without without IN 19613 6428 47 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 6428 48 , , , 19613 6428 49 the the DT 19613 6428 50 equation equation NN 19613 6428 51 : : : 19613 6428 52 John John NNP 19613 6428 53 -- -- : 19613 6428 54 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6428 55 . . . 19613 6429 1 By by IN 19613 6429 2 this this DT 19613 6429 3 speculation speculation NN 19613 6429 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6429 5 win win VBP 19613 6429 6 simply simply RB 19613 6429 7 everything everything NN 19613 6429 8 , , , 19613 6429 9 in in IN 19613 6429 10 so so RB 19613 6429 11 far far RB 19613 6429 12 as as IN 19613 6429 13 the the DT 19613 6429 14 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 6429 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6429 16 now now RB 19613 6429 17 appears appear VBZ 19613 6429 18 as as IN 19613 6429 19 the the DT 19613 6429 20 property property NN 19613 6429 21 of of IN 19613 6429 22 an an DT 19613 6429 23 " " `` 19613 6429 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 6429 25 " " '' 19613 6429 26 circle circle NN 19613 6429 27 , , , 19613 6429 28 and and CC 19613 6429 29 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 6429 30 and and CC 19613 6429 31 Antignosticism Antignosticism NNP 19613 6429 32 are be VBP 19613 6429 33 thus thus RB 19613 6429 34 eliminated eliminate VBN 19613 6429 35 . . . 19613 6430 1 But but CC 19613 6430 2 the the DT 19613 6430 3 following follow VBG 19613 6430 4 arguments argument NNS 19613 6430 5 may may MD 19613 6430 6 be be VB 19613 6430 7 urged urge VBN 19613 6430 8 against against IN 19613 6430 9 this this DT 19613 6430 10 theory theory NN 19613 6430 11 : : : 19613 6430 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6430 13 1 1 LS 19613 6430 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6430 15 What what WP 19613 6430 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6430 17 know know VBP 19613 6430 18 of of IN 19613 6430 19 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 19613 6430 20 by by IN 19613 6430 21 no no DT 19613 6430 22 means means NN 19613 6430 23 gives give VBZ 19613 6430 24 countenance countenance NN 19613 6430 25 to to IN 19613 6430 26 the the DT 19613 6430 27 supposition supposition NN 19613 6430 28 that that WDT 19613 6430 29 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6430 30 learned learn VBD 19613 6430 31 more more RBR 19613 6430 32 from from IN 19613 6430 33 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6430 34 and and CC 19613 6430 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6430 36 fellows fellow NNS 19613 6430 37 than than IN 19613 6430 38 a a DT 19613 6430 39 pious pious JJ 19613 6430 40 regard regard NN 19613 6430 41 for for IN 19613 6430 42 the the DT 19613 6430 43 Church Church NNP 19613 6430 44 tradition tradition NN 19613 6430 45 and and CC 19613 6430 46 a a DT 19613 6430 47 collection collection NN 19613 6430 48 of of IN 19613 6430 49 historical historical JJ 19613 6430 50 traditions tradition NNS 19613 6430 51 and and CC 19613 6430 52 principles principle NNS 19613 6430 53 . . . 19613 6431 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6431 2 2 2 LS 19613 6431 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6431 4 The the DT 19613 6431 5 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6431 6 of of IN 19613 6431 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6431 8 can can MD 19613 6431 9 not not RB 19613 6431 10 be be VB 19613 6431 11 separated separate VBN 19613 6431 12 from from IN 19613 6431 13 the the DT 19613 6431 14 received receive VBN 19613 6431 15 _ _ NNP 19613 6431 16 canon canon NNP 19613 6431 17 _ _ NNP 19613 6431 18 of of IN 19613 6431 19 New New NNP 19613 6431 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6431 21 writings writing NNS 19613 6431 22 ; ; : 19613 6431 23 but but CC 19613 6431 24 in in IN 19613 6431 25 the the DT 19613 6431 26 generation generation NN 19613 6431 27 before before IN 19613 6431 28 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6431 29 there there EX 19613 6431 30 was be VBD 19613 6431 31 as as RB 19613 6431 32 yet yet RB 19613 6431 33 no no DT 19613 6431 34 such such JJ 19613 6431 35 compilation compilation NN 19613 6431 36 . . . 19613 6432 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6432 2 3 3 LS 19613 6432 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6432 4 The the DT 19613 6432 5 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 6432 6 from from IN 19613 6432 7 whom whom WP 19613 6432 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6432 9 adopted adopt VBD 19613 6432 10 important important JJ 19613 6432 11 lines line NNS 19613 6432 12 of of IN 19613 6432 13 thought thought NN 19613 6432 14 in in IN 19613 6432 15 the the DT 19613 6432 16 4th 4th JJ 19613 6432 17 book book NN 19613 6432 18 did do VBD 19613 6432 19 not not RB 19613 6432 20 write write VB 19613 6432 21 till till IN 19613 6432 22 after after IN 19613 6432 23 the the DT 19613 6432 24 middle middle NN 19613 6432 25 of of IN 19613 6432 26 the the DT 19613 6432 27 second second JJ 19613 6432 28 century century NN 19613 6432 29 . . . 19613 6433 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6433 2 4 4 LS 19613 6433 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6433 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6433 5 owes owe VBZ 19613 6433 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6433 7 Christocentric Christocentric NNP 19613 6433 8 theology theology NN 19613 6433 9 , , , 19613 6433 10 so so RB 19613 6433 11 far far RB 19613 6433 12 as as IN 19613 6433 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6433 14 has have VBZ 19613 6433 15 such such PDT 19613 6433 16 a a DT 19613 6433 17 thing thing NN 19613 6433 18 , , , 19613 6433 19 to to IN 19613 6433 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6433 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6433 22 and and CC 19613 6433 23 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6433 24 ? ? . 19613 6433 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6433 26 . . . 19613 6433 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6434 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6434 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6434 3 483 483 CD 19613 6434 4 : : : 19613 6434 5 Marcion marcion NN 19613 6434 6 , , , 19613 6434 7 as as IN 19613 6434 8 is be VBZ 19613 6434 9 well well RB 19613 6434 10 known known JJ 19613 6434 11 , , , 19613 6434 12 went go VBD 19613 6434 13 still still RB 19613 6434 14 further further RB 19613 6434 15 in in IN 19613 6434 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6434 17 depreciatory depreciatory JJ 19613 6434 18 judgment judgment NN 19613 6434 19 of of IN 19613 6434 20 the the DT 19613 6434 21 world world NN 19613 6434 22 , , , 19613 6434 23 and and CC 19613 6434 24 therefore therefore RB 19613 6434 25 recognised recognise VBD 19613 6434 26 in in IN 19613 6434 27 the the DT 19613 6434 28 redemption redemption NN 19613 6434 29 through through IN 19613 6434 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6434 31 a a DT 19613 6434 32 pure pure JJ 19613 6434 33 act act NN 19613 6434 34 of of IN 19613 6434 35 grace grace NN 19613 6434 36 . . . 19613 6434 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6435 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6435 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6435 3 484 484 CD 19613 6435 4 : : : 19613 6435 5 See see VB 19613 6435 6 Molwitz Molwitz NNP 19613 6435 7 , , , 19613 6435 8 De De NNP 19613 6435 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6435 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6435 11 : : : 19613 6435 12 Anakephalaiôseôs Anakephalaiôseôs NNP 19613 6435 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6435 14 in in IN 19613 6435 15 Irenæi Irenæi NNP 19613 6435 16 theologia theologia NN 19613 6435 17 potestate potestate NN 19613 6435 18 , , , 19613 6435 19 Dresden Dresden NNP 19613 6435 20 , , , 19613 6435 21 1874 1874 CD 19613 6435 22 . . . 19613 6435 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6436 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6436 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6436 3 485 485 CD 19613 6436 4 : : : 19613 6436 5 See see VB 19613 6436 6 , , , 19613 6436 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 6436 8 , , , 19613 6436 9 the the DT 19613 6436 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 6436 11 to to IN 19613 6436 12 the the DT 19613 6436 13 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 19613 6436 14 and and CC 19613 6436 15 also also RB 19613 6436 16 the the DT 19613 6436 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 6436 18 to to IN 19613 6436 19 the the DT 19613 6436 20 Romans Romans NNPS 19613 6436 21 and and CC 19613 6436 22 Galatians Galatians NNPS 19613 6436 23 . . . 19613 6436 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6437 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6437 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6437 3 486 486 CD 19613 6437 4 : : : 19613 6437 5 But but CC 19613 6437 6 see see VB 19613 6437 7 the the DT 19613 6437 8 remark remark NN 19613 6437 9 made make VBN 19613 6437 10 above above RB 19613 6437 11 , , , 19613 6437 12 p. p. NN 19613 6437 13 220 220 CD 19613 6437 14 , , , 19613 6437 15 note note VB 19613 6437 16 1 1 CD 19613 6437 17 . . . 19613 6438 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6438 2 might may MD 19613 6438 3 without without IN 19613 6438 4 loss loss NN 19613 6438 5 give give VB 19613 6438 6 up up RP 19613 6438 7 the the DT 19613 6438 8 half half NN 19613 6438 9 of of IN 19613 6438 10 the the DT 19613 6438 11 Apologies Apologies NNPS 19613 6438 12 in in IN 19613 6438 13 return return NN 19613 6438 14 for for IN 19613 6438 15 the the DT 19613 6438 16 preservation preservation NN 19613 6438 17 of of IN 19613 6438 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6438 19 's 's POS 19613 6438 20 chief chief JJ 19613 6438 21 Antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 6438 22 work work NN 19613 6438 23 . . . 19613 6438 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6439 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6439 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6439 3 487 487 CD 19613 6439 4 : : : 19613 6439 5 According accord VBG 19613 6439 6 to to IN 19613 6439 7 the the DT 19613 6439 8 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 6439 9 Christology Christology NNP 19613 6439 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6439 11 merely merely RB 19613 6439 12 restores restore VBZ 19613 6439 13 the the DT 19613 6439 14 _ _ NNP 19613 6439 15 status status NN 19613 6439 16 quo quo NN 19613 6439 17 ante ante NNP 19613 6439 18 _ _ NNP 19613 6439 19 , , , 19613 6439 20 according accord VBG 19613 6439 21 to to IN 19613 6439 22 that that DT 19613 6439 23 of of IN 19613 6439 24 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6439 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6439 26 first first RB 19613 6439 27 and and CC 19613 6439 28 alone alone RB 19613 6439 29 realises realise VBZ 19613 6439 30 the the DT 19613 6439 31 hitherto hitherto JJ 19613 6439 32 unaccomplished unaccomplished JJ 19613 6439 33 destination destination NN 19613 6439 34 of of IN 19613 6439 35 humanity humanity NN 19613 6439 36 . . . 19613 6439 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6440 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6440 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6440 3 488 488 CD 19613 6440 4 : : : 19613 6440 5 According accord VBG 19613 6440 6 to to IN 19613 6440 7 the the DT 19613 6440 8 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6440 9 conception conception NN 19613 6440 10 the the DT 19613 6440 11 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6440 12 of of IN 19613 6440 13 the the DT 19613 6440 14 divine divine JJ 19613 6440 15 , , , 19613 6440 16 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6440 17 , , , 19613 6440 18 the the DT 19613 6440 19 fall fall NN 19613 6440 20 of of IN 19613 6440 21 _ _ NNP 19613 6440 22 Sophia Sophia NNP 19613 6440 23 _ _ NNP 19613 6440 24 , , , 19613 6440 25 contains contain VBZ 19613 6440 26 , , , 19613 6440 27 paradoxically paradoxically RB 19613 6440 28 expressed express VBN 19613 6440 29 , , , 19613 6440 30 the the DT 19613 6440 31 element element NN 19613 6440 32 of of IN 19613 6440 33 sin sin NN 19613 6440 34 ; ; : 19613 6440 35 according accord VBG 19613 6440 36 to to IN 19613 6440 37 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6440 38 ' ' POS 19613 6440 39 idea idea VB 19613 6440 40 the the DT 19613 6440 41 element element NN 19613 6440 42 of of IN 19613 6440 43 redemption redemption NN 19613 6440 44 . . . 19613 6441 1 Hence hence RB 19613 6441 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6441 3 must must MD 19613 6441 4 compare compare VB 19613 6441 5 not not RB 19613 6441 6 only only RB 19613 6441 7 the the DT 19613 6441 8 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 6441 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6441 10 , , , 19613 6441 11 but but CC 19613 6441 12 the the DT 19613 6441 13 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 6441 14 Sophia Sophia NNP 19613 6441 15 , , , 19613 6441 16 with with IN 19613 6441 17 the the DT 19613 6441 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6441 19 of of IN 19613 6441 20 the the DT 19613 6441 21 Church Church NNP 19613 6441 22 . . . 19613 6442 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6442 2 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6442 3 did do VBD 19613 6442 4 so so RB 19613 6442 5 in in IN 19613 6442 6 II II NNP 19613 6442 7 . . . 19613 6443 1 20 20 CD 19613 6443 2 . . . 19613 6444 1 3 3 LS 19613 6444 2 . . . 19613 6444 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6445 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6445 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6445 3 489 489 CD 19613 6445 4 : : : 19613 6445 5 After after IN 19613 6445 6 tracing trace VBG 19613 6445 7 in in IN 19613 6445 8 II II NNP 19613 6445 9 . . . 19613 6446 1 14 14 CD 19613 6446 2 the the DT 19613 6446 3 origin origin NN 19613 6446 4 of of IN 19613 6446 5 the the DT 19613 6446 6 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6446 7 theologoumena theologoumena NN 19613 6446 8 to to IN 19613 6446 9 the the DT 19613 6446 10 Greek greek JJ 19613 6446 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 6446 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6446 13 continues continue VBZ 19613 6446 14 § § ADD 19613 6446 15 7 7 CD 19613 6446 16 : : : 19613 6446 17 " " `` 19613 6446 18 Dicemus Dicemus NNP 19613 6446 19 autem autem NNP 19613 6446 20 adversus adversus NN 19613 6446 21 eos eos NNP 19613 6446 22 : : : 19613 6446 23 utramne utramne NN 19613 6446 24 hi hi NNP 19613 6446 25 omnes omnes NNP 19613 6446 26 qui qui NNP 19613 6446 27 prædicti prædicti NNP 19613 6446 28 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6446 29 , , , 19613 6446 30 cum cum NNP 19613 6446 31 quibus quibus NNP 19613 6446 32 eadem eadem NNP 19613 6446 33 dicentes dicente VBZ 19613 6446 34 arguimini arguimini NNP 19613 6446 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6446 36 Scil Scil NNP 19613 6446 37 . . . 19613 6447 1 " " `` 19613 6447 2 ye ye NNP 19613 6447 3 Gnostics Gnostics NNP 19613 6447 4 with with IN 19613 6447 5 the the DT 19613 6447 6 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 6447 7 " " '' 19613 6447 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6447 9 , , , 19613 6447 10 cognoverunt cognoverunt NNP 19613 6447 11 veritatem veritatem NNP 19613 6447 12 aut aut NNP 19613 6447 13 non non NNP 19613 6447 14 cognoverunt cognoverunt NN 19613 6447 15 ? ? . 19613 6448 1 Et et NN 19613 6448 2 si si UH 19613 6448 3 quidem quidem NNP 19613 6448 4 cognoverunt cognoverunt NNP 19613 6448 5 , , , 19613 6448 6 superflua superflua NNP 19613 6448 7 est est NNP 19613 6448 8 salvatoris salvatoris NNP 19613 6448 9 in in IN 19613 6448 10 hunc hunc JJ 19613 6448 11 mundum mundum NN 19613 6448 12 descensio descensio NNP 19613 6448 13 . . . 19613 6449 1 Ut Ut NNP 19613 6449 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6449 3 lege lege NN 19613 6449 4 " " `` 19613 6449 5 ad ad NN 19613 6449 6 " " '' 19613 6449 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6449 8 quid quid NNP 19613 6449 9 enim enim NNP 19613 6449 10 descendebat descendebat NN 19613 6449 11 ? ? . 19613 6449 12 " " '' 19613 6450 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6450 2 is be VBZ 19613 6450 3 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 6450 4 of of IN 19613 6450 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6450 6 not not RB 19613 6450 7 to to TO 19613 6450 8 ask ask VB 19613 6450 9 what what WP 19613 6450 10 is be VBZ 19613 6450 11 new new JJ 19613 6450 12 in in IN 19613 6450 13 the the DT 19613 6450 14 revelations revelation NNS 19613 6450 15 of of IN 19613 6450 16 God God NNP 19613 6450 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6450 18 through through IN 19613 6450 19 the the DT 19613 6450 20 prophets prophet NNS 19613 6450 21 and and CC 19613 6450 22 the the DT 19613 6450 23 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6450 24 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6450 25 , , , 19613 6450 26 but but CC 19613 6450 27 quite quite RB 19613 6450 28 definitely definitely RB 19613 6450 29 : : : 19613 6450 30 " " `` 19613 6450 31 Cur Cur NNP 19613 6450 32 descendit descendit NN 19613 6450 33 salvator salvator NN 19613 6450 34 in in IN 19613 6450 35 hunc hunc JJ 19613 6450 36 mundum mundum NN 19613 6450 37 ? ? . 19613 6450 38 " " '' 19613 6451 1 See see VB 19613 6451 2 also also RB 19613 6451 3 lib lib NNP 19613 6451 4 . . . 19613 6452 1 III iii CD 19613 6452 2 . . . 19613 6453 1 præf præf NNP 19613 6453 2 . . . 19613 6454 1 : : : 19613 6454 2 " " `` 19613 6454 3 veritas veritas NNP 19613 6454 4 , , , 19613 6454 5 hoc hoc FW 19613 6454 6 est est NNP 19613 6454 7 dei dei NNP 19613 6454 8 filii filii NNP 19613 6454 9 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 6454 10 " " '' 19613 6454 11 , , , 19613 6454 12 III III NNP 19613 6454 13 . . . 19613 6455 1 10 10 CD 19613 6455 2 . . . 19613 6456 1 3 3 LS 19613 6456 2 : : : 19613 6456 3 " " `` 19613 6456 4 Hæc Hæc NNP 19613 6456 5 est e JJS 19613 6456 6 salutis salutis NN 19613 6456 7 agnitio agnitio NN 19613 6456 8 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6456 9 deerat deerat NNP 19613 6456 10 eis eis NNP 19613 6456 11 , , , 19613 6456 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6456 13 est est NNP 19613 6456 14 filii filii VBP 19613 6456 15 del del NNP 19613 6456 16 agnitio agnitio NNP 19613 6456 17 ... ... : 19613 6456 18 agnitio agnitio NNP 19613 6456 19 salutis salutis NNP 19613 6456 20 erat erat NNP 19613 6456 21 agnitio agnitio NNP 19613 6456 22 filii filii NNP 19613 6456 23 dei dei NNP 19613 6456 24 , , , 19613 6456 25 qui qui NNP 19613 6456 26 et et NNP 19613 6456 27 salus salus NNP 19613 6456 28 et et NNP 19613 6456 29 salvator salvator NNP 19613 6456 30 et et NNP 19613 6456 31 salutare salutare NNP 19613 6456 32 vere vere NNP 19613 6456 33 et et NNP 19613 6456 34 dicitur dicitur NNP 19613 6456 35 et et FW 19613 6456 36 est est FW 19613 6456 37 . . . 19613 6456 38 " " '' 19613 6457 1 III iii CD 19613 6457 2 . . . 19613 6458 1 11 11 CD 19613 6458 2 . . . 19613 6459 1 3 3 LS 19613 6459 2 : : : 19613 6459 3 III iii CD 19613 6459 4 . . . 19613 6460 1 12 12 CD 19613 6460 2 . . . 19613 6461 1 7 7 LS 19613 6461 2 : : : 19613 6461 3 IV IV NNP 19613 6461 4 . . . 19613 6462 1 24 24 CD 19613 6462 2 . . . 19613 6462 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6463 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6463 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6463 3 490 490 CD 19613 6463 4 : : : 19613 6463 5 See see VB 19613 6463 6 II II NNP 19613 6463 7 . . . 19613 6464 1 24 24 CD 19613 6464 2 . . . 19613 6465 1 3 3 CD 19613 6465 2 , , , 19613 6465 3 4 4 CD 19613 6465 4 : : : 19613 6465 5 " " `` 19613 6465 6 Non Non NNP 19613 6465 7 enim enim NNP 19613 6465 8 ex ex NNP 19613 6465 9 nobis nobis NNP 19613 6465 10 neque neque NNP 19613 6465 11 ex ex NNP 19613 6465 12 nostra nostra NNP 19613 6465 13 natura natura NNP 19613 6465 14 vita vita NNP 19613 6465 15 est est NNP 19613 6465 16 ; ; : 19613 6465 17 sed sed NNP 19613 6465 18 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6465 19 gratiam gratiam NNP 19613 6465 20 dei dei NNP 19613 6465 21 datur datur NNP 19613 6465 22 . . . 19613 6465 23 " " '' 19613 6466 1 Cf cf NN 19613 6466 2 . . . 19613 6467 1 what what WP 19613 6467 2 follows follow VBZ 19613 6467 3 . . . 19613 6468 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6468 2 has have VBZ 19613 6468 3 in in IN 19613 6468 4 various various JJ 19613 6468 5 places place NNS 19613 6468 6 argued argue VBD 19613 6468 7 that that IN 19613 6468 8 human human JJ 19613 6468 9 nature nature NN 19613 6468 10 inclusive inclusive JJ 19613 6468 11 of of IN 19613 6468 12 the the DT 19613 6468 13 flesh flesh NN 19613 6468 14 is be VBZ 19613 6468 15 _ _ NNP 19613 6468 16 capax capax NNP 19613 6468 17 incorruptibilitatis incorruptibilitatis NN 19613 6468 18 _ _ NNP 19613 6468 19 , , , 19613 6468 20 and and CC 19613 6468 21 likewise likewise RB 19613 6468 22 that that DT 19613 6468 23 immortality immortality NN 19613 6468 24 is be VBZ 19613 6468 25 at at IN 19613 6468 26 once once RB 19613 6468 27 a a DT 19613 6468 28 free free JJ 19613 6468 29 gift gift NN 19613 6468 30 and and CC 19613 6468 31 the the DT 19613 6468 32 realisation realisation NN 19613 6468 33 of of IN 19613 6468 34 man man NN 19613 6468 35 's 's POS 19613 6468 36 destiny destiny NN 19613 6468 37 . . . 19613 6468 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6469 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6469 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6469 3 491 491 CD 19613 6469 4 : : : 19613 6469 5 Book book NN 19613 6469 6 V. v. NN 19613 6470 1 pref pref NNP 19613 6470 2 . . . 19613 6471 1 : : : 19613 6471 2 " " `` 19613 6471 3 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 6471 4 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6471 5 propter propter NN 19613 6471 6 immensam immensam NNP 19613 6471 7 suam suam NNP 19613 6471 8 dilectionem dilectionem NNP 19613 6471 9 factus factus NN 19613 6471 10 est est NNP 19613 6471 11 quod quod NNP 19613 6471 12 sumus sumus NNP 19613 6471 13 nos nos NNP 19613 6471 14 , , , 19613 6471 15 uti uti NNP 19613 6471 16 nos nos NNP 19613 6471 17 perficeret perficeret NNP 19613 6471 18 esse esse NNP 19613 6471 19 quod quod NNP 19613 6471 20 et et NNP 19613 6471 21 ipse ipse NNP 19613 6471 22 " " '' 19613 6471 23 : : : 19613 6471 24 III iii CD 19613 6471 25 . . . 19613 6472 1 6 6 CD 19613 6472 2 . . . 19613 6473 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6473 2 : : : 19613 6473 3 " " `` 19613 6473 4 Deus Deus NNP 19613 6473 5 stetit stetit JJ 19613 6473 6 in in IN 19613 6473 7 synagoga synagoga NN 19613 6473 8 deorum deorum NNP 19613 6473 9 ... ... : 19613 6473 10 de de NNP 19613 6473 11 patre patre NNP 19613 6473 12 et et NNP 19613 6473 13 filio filio NNP 19613 6473 14 et et NNP 19613 6473 15 de de FW 19613 6473 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6473 17 , , , 19613 6473 18 qui qui NNP 19613 6473 19 adoptionem adoptionem NNP 19613 6473 20 perceperunt perceperunt NN 19613 6473 21 , , , 19613 6473 22 dicit dicit NN 19613 6473 23 : : : 19613 6473 24 hi hi UH 19613 6473 25 autem autem NNP 19613 6473 26 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6473 27 ecclesia ecclesia NNP 19613 6473 28 . . . 19613 6474 1 Hæc Hæc NNP 19613 6474 2 enim enim NN 19613 6474 3 est est NNP 19613 6474 4 synagoga synagoga NNP 19613 6474 5 dei dei NNP 19613 6474 6 , , , 19613 6474 7 " " '' 19613 6474 8 etc etc FW 19613 6474 9 . . . 19613 6475 1 ; ; : 19613 6475 2 see see VB 19613 6475 3 also also RB 19613 6475 4 what what WP 19613 6475 5 follows follow VBZ 19613 6475 6 III iii CD 19613 6475 7 . . . 19613 6476 1 16 16 CD 19613 6476 2 . . . 19613 6477 1 3 3 LS 19613 6477 2 : : : 19613 6477 3 " " `` 19613 6477 4 Filius Filius NNP 19613 6477 5 dei dei NNP 19613 6477 6 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6477 7 filius filius NNP 19613 6477 8 factus factus NNP 19613 6477 9 , , , 19613 6477 10 ut ut UH 19613 6477 11 per per IN 19613 6477 12 eum eum NNP 19613 6477 13 adoptionem adoptionem NNP 19613 6477 14 percipiamus percipiamus NNP 19613 6477 15 portante portante NNP 19613 6477 16 homine homine NNP 19613 6477 17 et et NNP 19613 6477 18 capiente capiente NNP 19613 6477 19 et et FW 19613 6477 20 compleciente compleciente NNP 19613 6477 21 filium filium NNP 19613 6477 22 dei dei NNP 19613 6477 23 . . . 19613 6477 24 " " '' 19613 6478 1 III iii CD 19613 6478 2 . . . 19613 6479 1 16 16 CD 19613 6479 2 . . . 19613 6480 1 6 6 CD 19613 6480 2 : : : 19613 6480 3 " " `` 19613 6480 4 Dei Dei NNP 19613 6480 5 verbum verbum NN 19613 6480 6 unigenitus unigenitus NN 19613 6480 7 , , , 19613 6480 8 qui qui NNP 19613 6480 9 semper semper NNP 19613 6480 10 humano humano NNP 19613 6480 11 generi generi NNP 19613 6480 12 adest adest NNP 19613 6480 13 , , , 19613 6480 14 unitus unitus NNP 19613 6480 15 et et NNP 19613 6480 16 consparsus consparsus NNP 19613 6480 17 suo suo NNP 19613 6480 18 plasmati plasmati NNP 19613 6480 19 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6480 20 placitum placitum NNP 19613 6480 21 patris patris NNP 19613 6480 22 et et NNP 19613 6480 23 caro caro NNP 19613 6480 24 factus factus NN 19613 6480 25 , , , 19613 6480 26 ipse ipse NNP 19613 6480 27 est est NNP 19613 6480 28 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 6480 29 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6480 30 dominus dominus NN 19613 6480 31 noster noster NN 19613 6480 32 ... ... : 19613 6480 33 unus unus NNP 19613 6480 34 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 6480 35 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6480 36 , , , 19613 6480 37 veniens venien NNS 19613 6480 38 per per IN 19613 6480 39 universam universam NNP 19613 6480 40 dispositionem dispositionem NNP 19613 6480 41 et et NNP 19613 6480 42 omnia omnia NNP 19613 6480 43 in in IN 19613 6480 44 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 6480 45 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 6480 46 . . . 19613 6481 1 In in IN 19613 6481 2 omnibus omnibus JJ 19613 6481 3 autem autem NN 19613 6481 4 est est NNP 19613 6481 5 et et NNP 19613 6481 6 homo homo NNP 19613 6481 7 plasmatio plasmatio NNP 19613 6481 8 dei dei NNP 19613 6481 9 , , , 19613 6481 10 et et NNP 19613 6481 11 hominem hominem NNP 19613 6481 12 ergo ergo NNP 19613 6481 13 in in IN 19613 6481 14 semetipsum semetipsum NNP 19613 6481 15 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 6481 16 est est NNP 19613 6481 17 , , , 19613 6481 18 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 6481 19 visibilis visibilis NNP 19613 6481 20 factus factus NN 19613 6481 21 , , , 19613 6481 22 et et NNP 19613 6481 23 incomprehensibilis incomprehensibilis NNP 19613 6481 24 factus factus NNP 19613 6481 25 comprehensibilis comprehensibilis NNP 19613 6481 26 , , , 19613 6481 27 et et NNP 19613 6481 28 impassibilis impassibilis NNP 19613 6481 29 passibilis passibilis NNP 19613 6481 30 , , , 19613 6481 31 et et NNP 19613 6481 32 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6481 33 homo homo NNP 19613 6481 34 , , , 19613 6481 35 universa universa JJ 19613 6481 36 in in IN 19613 6481 37 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 6481 38 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 6481 39 ... ... : 19613 6481 40 in in IN 19613 6481 41 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 6481 42 primatum primatum NN 19613 6481 43 assumens assumen NNS 19613 6481 44 , , , 19613 6481 45 .. .. NFP 19613 6481 46 universa universa VB 19613 6481 47 attrahat attrahat NNP 19613 6481 48 ad ad NN 19613 6481 49 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 6481 50 apto apto NN 19613 6481 51 in in IN 19613 6481 52 tempore tempore NN 19613 6481 53 . . . 19613 6481 54 " " '' 19613 6482 1 III iii CD 19613 6482 2 . . . 19613 6483 1 18 18 CD 19613 6483 2 . . . 19613 6484 1 1 1 LS 19613 6484 2 : : : 19613 6484 3 " " `` 19613 6484 4 Quando Quando NNP 19613 6484 5 incarnatus incarnatus NN 19613 6484 6 est est NNP 19613 6484 7 filius filius NNP 19613 6484 8 homo homo NNP 19613 6484 9 et et NNP 19613 6484 10 homo homo NNP 19613 6484 11 factus factus NNP 19613 6484 12 longam longam NNP 19613 6484 13 hominum hominum NNP 19613 6484 14 expositionem expositionem NNP 19613 6484 15 in in IN 19613 6484 16 se se FW 19613 6484 17 ipso ipso FW 19613 6484 18 recapitulavit recapitulavit NNP 19613 6484 19 , , , 19613 6484 20 in in IN 19613 6484 21 compendio compendio NNP 19613 6484 22 nobis nobis NNP 19613 6484 23 salutem salutem NNP 19613 6484 24 præstans præstans NNPS 19613 6484 25 , , , 19613 6484 26 ut ut UH 19613 6484 27 quod quod NN 19613 6484 28 perdideramus perdideramus NNP 19613 6484 29 in in IN 19613 6484 30 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6484 31 i -PRON- PRP 19613 6484 32 d d VBN 19613 6484 33 est est NNP 19613 6484 34 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6484 35 imaginem imaginem NNP 19613 6484 36 et et NNP 19613 6484 37 similitudinem similitudinem NNP 19613 6484 38 esse esse NNP 19613 6484 39 dei dei NNP 19613 6484 40 , , , 19613 6484 41 hoc hoc FW 19613 6484 42 in in IN 19613 6484 43 Christo Christo NNP 19613 6484 44 Iesu Iesu NNP 19613 6484 45 reciperemus reciperemus NNP 19613 6484 46 . . . 19613 6484 47 " " '' 19613 6485 1 Cf cf NN 19613 6485 2 . . . 19613 6486 1 the the DT 19613 6486 2 whole whole JJ 19613 6486 3 18th 18th JJ 19613 6486 4 chapter chapter NN 19613 6486 5 where where WRB 19613 6486 6 the the DT 19613 6486 7 deepest deep JJS 19613 6486 8 thoughts thought NNS 19613 6486 9 of of IN 19613 6486 10 the the DT 19613 6486 11 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 6486 12 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 6486 13 of of IN 19613 6486 14 the the DT 19613 6486 15 death death NN 19613 6486 16 on on IN 19613 6486 17 the the DT 19613 6486 18 cross cross NN 19613 6486 19 are be VBP 19613 6486 20 amalgamated amalgamate VBN 19613 6486 21 with with IN 19613 6486 22 the the DT 19613 6486 23 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 6486 24 of of IN 19613 6486 25 the the DT 19613 6486 26 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6486 27 ; ; : 19613 6486 28 see see VB 19613 6486 29 especially especially RB 19613 6486 30 18 18 CD 19613 6486 31 . . . 19613 6487 1 6 6 CD 19613 6487 2 , , , 19613 6487 3 7 7 CD 19613 6487 4 : : : 19613 6487 5 " " `` 19613 6487 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6487 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6487 8 : : : 19613 6487 9 Ênôsen Ênôsen NNP 19613 6487 10 oun oun NNP 19613 6487 11 ton ton NN 19613 6487 12 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNS 19613 6487 13 tô tô NNP 19613 6487 14 Theô Theô NNP 19613 6487 15 . . . 19613 6488 1 Ei Ei NNP 19613 6488 2 gar gar NNP 19613 6488 3 mê mê NNP 19613 6488 4 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 6488 5 enikêsen enikêsen NNP 19613 6488 6 tên tên NNP 19613 6488 7 antipalon antipalon NNP 19613 6488 8 tou tou NNP 19613 6488 9 anthrôpou anthrôpou NNP 19613 6488 10 , , , 19613 6488 11 ouk ouk VBD 19613 6488 12 an an DT 19613 6488 13 dikaiôs dikaiôs NNP 19613 6488 14 enikêthê enikêthê NNP 19613 6488 15 ho ho NNP 19613 6488 16 echthros echthros NNP 19613 6488 17 . . . 19613 6489 1 Palin Palin NNP 19613 6489 2 te te NNP 19613 6489 3 , , , 19613 6489 4 ei ei NNP 19613 6489 5 mê mê NNP 19613 6489 6 ho ho NNP 19613 6489 7 Theos Theos NNP 19613 6489 8 edôrêsato edôrêsato NNP 19613 6489 9 tên tên NNP 19613 6489 10 sôtêrian sôtêrian NNP 19613 6489 11 , , , 19613 6489 12 ouk ouk VBD 19613 6489 13 an an DT 19613 6489 14 bebaiôs bebaiôs NNP 19613 6489 15 eschomen eschoman NNS 19613 6489 16 autên autên VBP 19613 6489 17 . . . 19613 6490 1 Kai Kai NNP 19613 6490 2 ei ei NNP 19613 6490 3 mê mê NNP 19613 6490 4 sunênôthê sunênôthê NNP 19613 6490 5 ho ho NNP 19613 6490 6 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 6490 7 tô tô NNP 19613 6490 8 Theô Theô NNP 19613 6490 9 , , , 19613 6490 10 ouk ouk VBD 19613 6490 11 an an DT 19613 6490 12 êdunêthê êdunêthê NN 19613 6490 13 metaschein metaschein NN 19613 6490 14 tês tês NN 19613 6490 15 aphtharsias aphtharsia NNS 19613 6490 16 . . . 19613 6491 1 Edei Edei NNP 19613 6491 2 gar gar NNP 19613 6491 3 ton ton NN 19613 6491 4 mesitên mesitên NN 19613 6491 5 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6491 6 te te NNP 19613 6491 7 kai kai NNP 19613 6491 8 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 6491 9 dia dia NNP 19613 6491 10 tês tês NNP 19613 6491 11 idias idias NNP 19613 6491 12 pros pro NNS 19613 6491 13 hekaterous hekaterous JJ 19613 6491 14 oikeiotêtos oikeiotêtos NNP 19613 6491 15 eis eis NNP 19613 6491 16 philian philian NNP 19613 6491 17 kai kai NNP 19613 6491 18 homonoian homonoian NNP 19613 6491 19 tous tous NNP 19613 6491 20 amphoterous amphoterous JJ 19613 6491 21 sunagôgein sunagôgein NN 19613 6491 22 ; ; : 19613 6491 23 kai kai NNP 19613 6491 24 Theô Theô NNP 19613 6491 25 men man NNS 19613 6491 26 parastêsai parastêsai NN 19613 6491 27 ton ton NN 19613 6491 28 antrôpon antrôpon IN 19613 6491 29 anthrôpois anthrôpois NNP 19613 6491 30 de de NNP 19613 6491 31 gnôrisai gnôrisai NNP 19613 6491 32 ton ton NN 19613 6491 33 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6491 34 . . . 19613 6491 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6492 1 Qua qua VB 19613 6492 2 enim enim NN 19613 6492 3 ratione ratione JJ 19613 6492 4 filiorum filiorum NNP 19613 6492 5 adoptionis adoptionis NNP 19613 6492 6 eius eius NNP 19613 6492 7 participes participes NNP 19613 6492 8 esse esse NNP 19613 6492 9 possemus possemus NNP 19613 6492 10 , , , 19613 6492 11 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6492 12 per per IN 19613 6492 13 filium filium NN 19613 6492 14 eam eam NN 19613 6492 15 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6492 16 est est NNP 19613 6492 17 ad ad NN 19613 6492 18 ipsura ipsura NNP 19613 6492 19 recepissemus recepissemus NNP 19613 6492 20 ab ab NNP 19613 6492 21 eo eo NNP 19613 6492 22 communionem communionem NNP 19613 6492 23 , , , 19613 6492 24 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6492 25 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6492 26 eius eius NNP 19613 6492 27 communicasset communicasset NNP 19613 6492 28 nobis nobis NNP 19613 6492 29 caro caro VBP 19613 6492 30 factum factum NN 19613 6492 31 ? ? . 19613 6493 1 Quapropter Quapropter NNP 19613 6493 2 et et NN 19613 6493 3 per per IN 19613 6493 4 omnem omnem NNP 19613 6493 5 venit venit NNP 19613 6493 6 ætatem ætatem NNP 19613 6493 7 , , , 19613 6493 8 omnibus omnibus NN 19613 6493 9 restituens restituen VBZ 19613 6493 10 eam eam NNP 19613 6493 11 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6493 12 est est NNP 19613 6493 13 ad ad NN 19613 6493 14 deum deum NN 19613 6493 15 communionem communionem NNP 19613 6493 16 . . . 19613 6493 17 " " '' 19613 6494 1 The the DT 19613 6494 2 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 6494 3 ideas idea NNS 19613 6494 4 about about IN 19613 6494 5 sin sin NN 19613 6494 6 , , , 19613 6494 7 law law NN 19613 6494 8 , , , 19613 6494 9 and and CC 19613 6494 10 bondage bondage NN 19613 6494 11 are be VBP 19613 6494 12 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 6494 13 by by IN 19613 6494 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6494 15 in in IN 19613 6494 16 what what WP 19613 6494 17 follows follow VBZ 19613 6494 18 . . . 19613 6495 1 The the DT 19613 6495 2 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 6495 3 in in IN 19613 6495 4 capp capp NNP 19613 6495 5 . . . 19613 6496 1 19 19 CD 19613 6496 2 - - SYM 19613 6496 3 23 23 CD 19613 6496 4 are be VBP 19613 6496 5 dominated dominate VBN 19613 6496 6 by by IN 19613 6496 7 the the DT 19613 6496 8 same same JJ 19613 6496 9 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 6496 10 idea idea NN 19613 6496 11 . . . 19613 6497 1 In in IN 19613 6497 2 cap cap NN 19613 6497 3 . . . 19613 6498 1 19 19 CD 19613 6498 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6498 3 turns turn VBZ 19613 6498 4 to to IN 19613 6498 5 those those DT 19613 6498 6 who who WP 19613 6498 7 hold hold VBP 19613 6498 8 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6498 9 to to TO 19613 6498 10 be be VB 19613 6498 11 a a DT 19613 6498 12 mere mere JJ 19613 6498 13 man man NN 19613 6498 14 , , , 19613 6498 15 " " '' 19613 6498 16 perseverantes perseverante VBZ 19613 6498 17 in in IN 19613 6498 18 servitute servitute JJ 19613 6498 19 pristinæ pristinæ NNS 19613 6498 20 inobedientiæ inobedientiæ NNP 19613 6498 21 moriuntur moriuntur NNP 19613 6498 22 , , , 19613 6498 23 nondum nondum NNP 19613 6498 24 commixti commixti NNP 19613 6498 25 verbo verbo NNP 19613 6498 26 dei dei NNP 19613 6498 27 patris patris NNP 19613 6498 28 neque neque NN 19613 6498 29 per per IN 19613 6498 30 filium filium NN 19613 6498 31 percipientes percipiente NNS 19613 6498 32 libertatem libertatem VBP 19613 6498 33 ... ... NFP 19613 6498 34 privantur privantur NNP 19613 6498 35 munere munere NNP 19613 6498 36 eius eius NNP 19613 6498 37 , , , 19613 6498 38 quod quod NNP 19613 6498 39 est est NNP 19613 6498 40 vita vita NNP 19613 6498 41 æsterna æsterna NNP 19613 6498 42 : : : 19613 6498 43 non non NNP 19613 6498 44 recipientes recipiente VBZ 19613 6498 45 autem autem NNP 19613 6498 46 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6498 47 incorruptionis incorruptionis NNP 19613 6498 48 perseverant perseverant NNP 19613 6498 49 in in IN 19613 6498 50 carne carne NNP 19613 6498 51 mortali mortali NNP 19613 6498 52 , , , 19613 6498 53 et et NNP 19613 6498 54 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6498 55 debitores debitore VBZ 19613 6498 56 mortis mortis NNP 19613 6498 57 , , , 19613 6498 58 antidotum antidotum IN 19613 6498 59 vitæ vitæ NNP 19613 6498 60 non non JJ 19613 6498 61 accipientes accipiente NNS 19613 6498 62 . . . 19613 6499 1 Ad ad NN 19613 6499 2 quos quos NN 19613 6499 3 verbum verbum NN 19613 6499 4 ait ait NN 19613 6499 5 , , , 19613 6499 6 suum suum VB 19613 6499 7 munus munus NNP 19613 6499 8 gratiæ gratiæ NNP 19613 6499 9 ? ? . 19613 6500 1 narrans narran NNS 19613 6500 2 : : : 19613 6500 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6500 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6500 5 : : : 19613 6500 6 Egô Egô NNP 19613 6500 7 eipa eipa NNP 19613 6500 8 , , , 19613 6500 9 huioi huioi NNP 19613 6500 10 hupsistou hupsistou NNP 19613 6500 11 este este NNP 19613 6500 12 pantes pantes NNPS 19613 6500 13 kai kai NNP 19613 6500 14 theoi theoi NNP 19613 6500 15 ; ; : 19613 6500 16 humeis humeis NNP 19613 6500 17 de de NNP 19613 6500 18 hôs hôs NNP 19613 6500 19 anthrôpoi anthrôpoi NNP 19613 6500 20 apothnêskete apothnêskete NN 19613 6500 21 . . . 19613 6501 1 Tauta tauta NN 19613 6501 2 legei legei JJ 19613 6501 3 pros pro NNS 19613 6501 4 tous tous JJ 19613 6501 5 mê mê NNP 19613 6501 6 dexamenous dexamenous NNP 19613 6501 7 tên tên NNP 19613 6501 8 dôrean dôrean NNP 19613 6501 9 tês tês NNP 19613 6501 10 huiothesias huiothesias NNP 19613 6501 11 , , , 19613 6501 12 all all DT 19613 6501 13 ' ' `` 19613 6501 14 atimazontas atimazontas NNP 19613 6501 15 tên tên NNP 19613 6501 16 sarkôsin sarkôsin NNP 19613 6501 17 tês tês NNP 19613 6501 18 katharas katharas NNP 19613 6501 19 gennêseôs gennêseôs NNP 19613 6501 20 tou tou NNP 19613 6501 21 logou logou NNP 19613 6501 22 tou tou NNP 19613 6501 23 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6501 24 ... ... : 19613 6501 25 Eis Eis NNP 19613 6501 26 touto touto NNP 19613 6501 27 gar gar NNP 19613 6501 28 ho ho NNP 19613 6501 29 logos logos NNP 19613 6501 30 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 6501 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6501 32 et et FW 19613 6501 33 qui qui NNP 19613 6501 34 filius filius NNP 19613 6501 35 dei dei NNP 19613 6501 36 est est NNP 19613 6501 37 filius filius NNP 19613 6501 38 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6501 39 factus factus NN 19613 6501 40 est est NNP 19613 6501 41 , , , 19613 6501 42 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6501 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6501 44 : : : 19613 6501 45 hina hina NNP 19613 6501 46 ho ho NNP 19613 6501 47 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 6501 48 ton ton NNP 19613 6501 49 logon logon NNP 19613 6501 50 chôrêsas chôrêsas NNP 19613 6501 51 kai kai NNP 19613 6501 52 tên tên NNP 19613 6501 53 huiothesian huiothesian NNP 19613 6501 54 labôn labôn NNP 19613 6501 55 huios huios NNPS 19613 6501 56 genêtai genêtai VBP 19613 6501 57 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6501 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6501 59 . . . 19613 6502 1 Non non JJ 19613 6502 2 enim enim NNP 19613 6502 3 poteramus poteramus NN 19613 6502 4 aliter aliter NN 19613 6502 5 incorruptelam incorruptelam NNP 19613 6502 6 et et FW 19613 6502 7 immortalitatem immortalitatem NNP 19613 6502 8 percipere percipere NNP 19613 6502 9 , , , 19613 6502 10 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6502 11 adunati adunati NNP 19613 6502 12 fuissemus fuissemus NNP 19613 6502 13 incorruptelæ incorruptelæ NNP 19613 6502 14 et et NNP 19613 6502 15 immortalitati immortalitati NNP 19613 6502 16 . . . 19613 6503 1 Quemadmodum Quemadmodum NNP 19613 6503 2 autem autem VB 19613 6503 3 adunari adunari NNP 19613 6503 4 possumus possumus NNP 19613 6503 5 incorruptelæ incorruptelæ NNP 19613 6503 6 et et NNP 19613 6503 7 immortalitati immortalitati NNP 19613 6503 8 , , , 19613 6503 9 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6503 10 prius prius NNP 19613 6503 11 incorruptela incorruptela NNP 19613 6503 12 et et NNP 19613 6503 13 immortalitas immortalitas NNP 19613 6503 14 facta facta NNP 19613 6503 15 fuisset fuisset VBP 19613 6503 16 i -PRON- PRP 19613 6503 17 d d VBN 19613 6503 18 quod quod NNP 19613 6503 19 et et FW 19613 6503 20 nos nos NNP 19613 6503 21 , , , 19613 6503 22 ut ut UH 19613 6503 23 absorbet*etur absorbet*etur NNP 19613 6503 24 quod quod NN 19613 6503 25 erat erat NNP 19613 6503 26 corruptibile corruptibile NN 19613 6503 27 ab ab NNP 19613 6503 28 incorruptela incorruptela NNP 19613 6503 29 et et NNP 19613 6503 30 quod quod NNP 19613 6503 31 erat erat NNP 19613 6503 32 mortale mortale NNP 19613 6503 33 ab ab NNP 19613 6503 34 immortalitate immortalitate JJ 19613 6503 35 , , , 19613 6503 36 ut ut UH 19613 6503 37 filiorum filiorum NNP 19613 6503 38 adoptionem adoptionem NNP 19613 6503 39 perciperemus perciperemus NNP 19613 6503 40 ? ? . 19613 6503 41 " " '' 19613 6504 1 III iii CD 19613 6504 2 . . . 19613 6505 1 21 21 CD 19613 6505 2 . . . 19613 6506 1 10 10 CD 19613 6506 2 : : : 19613 6506 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6506 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6506 5 : : : 19613 6506 6 Ei Ei NNP 19613 6506 7 toinun toinun VBZ 19613 6506 8 ho ho NNP 19613 6506 9 prôtos prôtos NNP 19613 6506 10 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6506 11 esche esche NN 19613 6506 12 patera patera NN 19613 6506 13 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 6506 14 kai kai NNP 19613 6506 15 ek ek NNP 19613 6506 16 spermatos spermatos NNP 19613 6506 17 egennêthê egennêthê NNP 19613 6506 18 , , , 19613 6506 19 eikos eikos NNP 19613 6506 20 ên ên NNP 19613 6506 21 kai kai NNP 19613 6506 22 deuteron deuteron NNP 19613 6506 23 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6506 24 legein legein NN 19613 6506 25 ex ex AFX 19613 6506 26 Iôsêph Iôsêph NNP 19613 6506 27 gegennêsthai gegennêsthai NN 19613 6506 28 . . . 19613 6507 1 Ei Ei NNP 19613 6507 2 de de NNP 19613 6507 3 ekeinos ekeinos NNP 19613 6507 4 ek ek IN 19613 6507 5 gês gês NNP 19613 6507 6 elêphthê elêphthê NNP 19613 6507 7 , , , 19613 6507 8 plastês plastês NNP 19613 6507 9 de de FW 19613 6507 10 autou autou NNP 19613 6507 11 ho ho NNP 19613 6507 12 Theos Theos NNP 19613 6507 13 , , , 19613 6507 14 edei edei NNP 19613 6507 15 kai kai NNP 19613 6507 16 ton ton NNP 19613 6507 17 anakephalaioumenon anakephalaioumenon NNP 19613 6507 18 eis eis NNP 19613 6507 19 auton auton NNP 19613 6507 20 hupo hupo NNP 19613 6507 21 tou tou NNP 19613 6507 22 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6507 23 peplasmenon peplasmenon NNP 19613 6507 24 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 6507 25 tên tên NNP 19613 6507 26 autên autên NNP 19613 6507 27 ekeinô ekeinô NNP 19613 6507 28 tês tês NNP 19613 6507 29 gennêseôs gennêseôs NNP 19613 6507 30 echein echein NNP 19613 6507 31 homoiotêta homoiotêta NNP 19613 6507 32 . . . 19613 6508 1 Eis Eis NNP 19613 6508 2 ti ti NNP 19613 6508 3 oun oun NNP 19613 6508 4 palin palin NNP 19613 6508 5 ouk ouk NNP 19613 6508 6 elabe elabe NNP 19613 6508 7 choun choun NNP 19613 6508 8 ho ho NNP 19613 6508 9 Theos Theos NNP 19613 6508 10 , , , 19613 6508 11 all all DT 19613 6508 12 ' ' '' 19613 6508 13 ek ek NNP 19613 6508 14 Marias Marias NNP 19613 6508 15 enêrgêse enêrgêse NNP 19613 6508 16 tên tên NNP 19613 6508 17 plasin plasin NNP 19613 6508 18 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 6508 19 . . . 19613 6509 1 Hina Hina NNP 19613 6509 2 mê mê NNP 19613 6509 3 allê allê NNP 19613 6509 4 plasis plasis NNP 19613 6509 5 genêtai genêtai NNP 19613 6509 6 mêde mêde NNP 19613 6509 7 allo allo NNP 19613 6509 8 to to TO 19613 6509 9 sôzomenon sôzomenon VB 19613 6509 10 ê ê NNP 19613 6509 11 , , , 19613 6509 12 all all DT 19613 6509 13 ' ' '' 19613 6509 14 autos auto NNS 19613 6509 15 ekeinos ekeinos NNP 19613 6509 16 anakephalaiôthê anakephalaiôthê NNP 19613 6509 17 têroumenês têroumenês NNP 19613 6509 18 tês tês NNP 19613 6509 19 homoiotêtos homoiotêtos NNP 19613 6509 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6509 21 ; ; : 19613 6509 22 III iii CD 19613 6509 23 . . . 19613 6510 1 23 23 CD 19613 6510 2 . . . 19613 6511 1 1 1 LS 19613 6511 2 : : : 19613 6511 3 IV IV NNP 19613 6511 4 . . . 19613 6512 1 38 38 CD 19613 6512 2 : : : 19613 6512 3 V. v. NN 19613 6512 4 36 36 CD 19613 6512 5 : : : 19613 6512 6 IV IV NNP 19613 6512 7 . . . 19613 6513 1 20 20 CD 19613 6513 2 : : : 19613 6513 3 V. V. NNP 19613 6513 4 16 16 CD 19613 6513 5 , , , 19613 6513 6 19 19 CD 19613 6513 7 - - SYM 19613 6513 8 21 21 CD 19613 6513 9 , , , 19613 6513 10 22 22 CD 19613 6513 11 . . . 19613 6514 1 In in IN 19613 6514 2 working work VBG 19613 6514 3 out out RP 19613 6514 4 this this DT 19613 6514 5 thought thought NN 19613 6514 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6514 7 verges verge NNS 19613 6514 8 here here RB 19613 6514 9 and and CC 19613 6514 10 there there RB 19613 6514 11 on on IN 19613 6514 12 soteriological soteriological JJ 19613 6514 13 naturalism naturalism NN 19613 6514 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6514 15 see see VB 19613 6514 16 especially especially RB 19613 6514 17 the the DT 19613 6514 18 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 6514 19 regarding regard VBG 19613 6514 20 the the DT 19613 6514 21 salvation salvation NN 19613 6514 22 of of IN 19613 6514 23 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6514 24 , , , 19613 6514 25 opposed oppose VBD 19613 6514 26 to to IN 19613 6514 27 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 6514 28 's 's POS 19613 6514 29 views view NNS 19613 6514 30 , , , 19613 6514 31 in in IN 19613 6514 32 III iii CD 19613 6514 33 . . . 19613 6515 1 23 23 CD 19613 6515 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6515 3 . . . 19613 6516 1 But but CC 19613 6516 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6516 3 does do VBZ 19613 6516 4 not not RB 19613 6516 5 fall fall VB 19613 6516 6 into into IN 19613 6516 7 this this DT 19613 6516 8 for for IN 19613 6516 9 two two CD 19613 6516 10 reasons reason NNS 19613 6516 11 . . . 19613 6517 1 In in IN 19613 6517 2 the the DT 19613 6517 3 first first JJ 19613 6517 4 place place NN 19613 6517 5 , , , 19613 6517 6 as as IN 19613 6517 7 regards regard VBZ 19613 6517 8 the the DT 19613 6517 9 history history NN 19613 6517 10 , , , 19613 6517 11 of of IN 19613 6517 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 6517 13 , , , 19613 6517 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6517 15 has have VBZ 19613 6517 16 been be VBN 19613 6517 17 taught teach VBN 19613 6517 18 by by IN 19613 6517 19 Paul Paul NNP 19613 6517 20 not not RB 19613 6517 21 to to TO 19613 6517 22 stop stop VB 19613 6517 23 at at IN 19613 6517 24 the the DT 19613 6517 25 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6517 26 , , , 19613 6517 27 but but CC 19613 6517 28 to to TO 19613 6517 29 view view VB 19613 6517 30 the the DT 19613 6517 31 work work NN 19613 6517 32 of of IN 19613 6517 33 salvation salvation NN 19613 6517 34 as as IN 19613 6517 35 only only RB 19613 6517 36 completed complete VBN 19613 6517 37 by by IN 19613 6517 38 the the DT 19613 6517 39 sufferings suffering NNS 19613 6517 40 and and CC 19613 6517 41 death death NN 19613 6517 42 of of IN 19613 6517 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6517 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6517 45 See see VB 19613 6517 46 II II NNP 19613 6517 47 . . . 19613 6518 1 20 20 CD 19613 6518 2 . . . 19613 6519 1 3 3 LS 19613 6519 2 : : : 19613 6519 3 " " `` 19613 6519 4 dominus dominus NNP 19613 6519 5 per per IN 19613 6519 6 passionem passionem FW 19613 6519 7 mortem mortem NNP 19613 6519 8 destruxit destruxit NNP 19613 6519 9 et et NNP 19613 6519 10 solvit solvit NNP 19613 6519 11 errorem errorem NNP 19613 6519 12 corruptionemque corruptionemque NNP 19613 6519 13 exterminavit exterminavit NNP 19613 6519 14 , , , 19613 6519 15 et et NNP 19613 6519 16 ignorantiam ignorantiam NNP 19613 6519 17 destruxit destruxit NNP 19613 6519 18 , , , 19613 6519 19 vitam vitam NNP 19613 6519 20 autem autem NNP 19613 6519 21 manifestavit manifestavit NNP 19613 6519 22 et et NNP 19613 6519 23 ostendit ostendit NNP 19613 6519 24 veritatem veritatem NNP 19613 6519 25 et et NNP 19613 6519 26 incorruptionem incorruptionem NNP 19613 6519 27 donavit donavit NNP 19613 6519 28 " " '' 19613 6519 29 ; ; : 19613 6519 30 III III NNP 19613 6519 31 . . . 19613 6520 1 16 16 CD 19613 6520 2 . . . 19613 6521 1 9 9 CD 19613 6521 2 : : : 19613 6521 3 III iii CD 19613 6521 4 . . . 19613 6522 1 18 18 CD 19613 6522 2 . . . 19613 6523 1 1 1 CD 19613 6523 2 - - SYM 19613 6523 3 7 7 CD 19613 6523 4 and and CC 19613 6523 5 many many JJ 19613 6523 6 other other JJ 19613 6523 7 passages passage NNS 19613 6523 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6523 9 , , , 19613 6523 10 that that RB 19613 6523 11 is is RB 19613 6523 12 , , , 19613 6523 13 to to TO 19613 6523 14 regard regard VB 19613 6523 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6523 16 as as IN 19613 6523 17 having have VBG 19613 6523 18 performed perform VBN 19613 6523 19 a a DT 19613 6523 20 _ _ NNP 19613 6523 21 work work NN 19613 6523 22 _ _ NNP 19613 6523 23 . . . 19613 6524 1 Secondly secondly RB 19613 6524 2 , , , 19613 6524 3 alongside alongside IN 19613 6524 4 of of IN 19613 6524 5 the the DT 19613 6524 6 deification deification NN 19613 6524 7 of of IN 19613 6524 8 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6524 9 's 's POS 19613 6524 10 children child NNS 19613 6524 11 , , , 19613 6524 12 viewed view VBD 19613 6524 13 as as IN 19613 6524 14 a a DT 19613 6524 15 mechanical mechanical JJ 19613 6524 16 result result NN 19613 6524 17 of of IN 19613 6524 18 the the DT 19613 6524 19 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6524 20 , , , 19613 6524 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6524 22 placed place VBD 19613 6524 23 the the DT 19613 6524 24 other other JJ 19613 6524 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6524 26 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 6524 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6524 28 thought thought NN 19613 6524 29 , , , 19613 6524 30 viz viz NNP 19613 6524 31 . . NNP 19613 6524 32 , , , 19613 6524 33 that that IN 19613 6524 34 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6524 35 , , , 19613 6524 36 as as IN 19613 6524 37 the the DT 19613 6524 38 teacher teacher NN 19613 6524 39 , , , 19613 6524 40 imparts impart VBZ 19613 6524 41 complete complete JJ 19613 6524 42 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6524 43 , , , 19613 6524 44 that that IN 19613 6524 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6524 46 has have VBZ 19613 6524 47 restored restore VBN 19613 6524 48 , , , 19613 6524 49 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6524 50 , , , 19613 6524 51 strengthened strengthen VBD 19613 6524 52 the the DT 19613 6524 53 freedom freedom NN 19613 6524 54 of of IN 19613 6524 55 man man NN 19613 6524 56 , , , 19613 6524 57 and and CC 19613 6524 58 that that IN 19613 6524 59 redemption redemption NN 19613 6524 60 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6524 61 by by IN 19613 6524 62 which which WDT 19613 6524 63 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6524 64 means mean VBZ 19613 6524 65 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 6524 66 with with IN 19613 6524 67 God God NNP 19613 6524 68 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6524 69 therefore therefore RB 19613 6524 70 takes take VBZ 19613 6524 71 place place NN 19613 6524 72 only only RB 19613 6524 73 in in IN 19613 6524 74 the the DT 19613 6524 75 case case NN 19613 6524 76 of of IN 19613 6524 77 those those DT 19613 6524 78 children child NNS 19613 6524 79 of of IN 19613 6524 80 Adam Adam NNP 19613 6524 81 that that WDT 19613 6524 82 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 19613 6524 83 the the DT 19613 6524 84 truth truth NN 19613 6524 85 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 6524 86 by by IN 19613 6524 87 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6524 88 and and CC 19613 6524 89 imitate imitate VB 19613 6524 90 the the DT 19613 6524 91 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 6524 92 in in IN 19613 6524 93 a a DT 19613 6524 94 holy holy JJ 19613 6524 95 life life NN 19613 6524 96 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6524 97 V. V. NNP 19613 6524 98 1 1 CD 19613 6524 99 . . . 19613 6525 1 1 1 LS 19613 6525 2 . . . 19613 6525 3 : : : 19613 6525 4 " " `` 19613 6525 5 Non non JJ 19613 6525 6 enim enim NN 19613 6525 7 aliter aliter VBP 19613 6525 8 nos nos NNP 19613 6525 9 discere discere NNP 19613 6525 10 poteramus poteramus NNP 19613 6525 11 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6525 12 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6525 13 dei dei NNP 19613 6525 14 , , , 19613 6525 15 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6525 16 magister magister NNP 19613 6525 17 noster noster NN 19613 6525 18 , , , 19613 6525 19 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6525 20 exsistens exsistens NNP 19613 6525 21 , , , 19613 6525 22 homo homo NN 19613 6525 23 factus factus NN 19613 6525 24 fuisset fuisset NN 19613 6525 25 . . . 19613 6526 1 Neque Neque NNP 19613 6526 2 enim enim NNP 19613 6526 3 alias alias NNP 19613 6526 4 poterat poterat NNP 19613 6526 5 enarrare enarrare NNP 19613 6526 6 nobis nobis NNP 19613 6526 7 , , , 19613 6526 8 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6526 9 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6526 10 patris patris NNP 19613 6526 11 , , , 19613 6526 12 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6526 13 proprium proprium NNP 19613 6526 14 ipsius ipsius NNP 19613 6526 15 verbum verbum NN 19613 6526 16 ... ... : 19613 6526 17 Neque Neque NNP 19613 6526 18 rursus rursus NNP 19613 6526 19 nos nos RB 19613 6526 20 aliter aliter VBP 19613 6526 21 discere discere NNP 19613 6526 22 poteramus poteramus NNP 19613 6526 23 , , , 19613 6526 24 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6526 25 magistrum magistrum NNP 19613 6526 26 nostrum nostrum NNP 19613 6526 27 videntes videntes NNP 19613 6526 28 et et NNP 19613 6526 29 per per IN 19613 6526 30 auditum auditum NN 19613 6526 31 nostrum nostrum NNP 19613 6526 32 vocem vocem NNP 19613 6526 33 eius eius NNP 19613 6526 34 percipientes percipiente NNS 19613 6526 35 , , , 19613 6526 36 ut ut UH 19613 6526 37 imitatores imitatores NNP 19613 6526 38 quidem quidem VBP 19613 6526 39 operum operum NN 19613 6526 40 , , , 19613 6526 41 factores factor VBZ 19613 6526 42 autem autem NNP 19613 6526 43 sermonum sermonum NNP 19613 6526 44 eius eius NNP 19613 6526 45 facti facti NNP 19613 6526 46 , , , 19613 6526 47 communionem communionem NNP 19613 6526 48 habeamus habeamus NNP 19613 6526 49 cum cum NNP 19613 6526 50 ipso ipso NNP 19613 6526 51 " " '' 19613 6526 52 , , , 19613 6526 53 and and CC 19613 6526 54 many many JJ 19613 6526 55 other other JJ 19613 6526 56 passages passage NNS 19613 6526 57 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6526 58 . . . 19613 6527 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6527 2 find find VBP 19613 6527 3 a a DT 19613 6527 4 combined combine VBN 19613 6527 5 formula formula NN 19613 6527 6 in in IN 19613 6527 7 III III NNP 19613 6527 8 . . . 19613 6528 1 5 5 CD 19613 6528 2 . . . 19613 6529 1 3 3 LS 19613 6529 2 : : : 19613 6529 3 " " `` 19613 6529 4 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6529 5 libertatem libertatem NN 19613 6529 6 hominibus hominibus NN 19613 6529 7 restauravit restauravit NNP 19613 6529 8 et et NNP 19613 6529 9 attribuit attribuit NN 19613 6529 10 incorruptelæ incorruptelæ NNP 19613 6529 11 hæreditatem hæreditatem NNP 19613 6529 12 . . . 19613 6529 13 " " '' 19613 6529 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6530 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6530 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6530 3 492 492 CD 19613 6530 4 : : : 19613 6530 5 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 19613 6530 6 also also RB 19613 6530 7 did do VBD 19613 6530 8 not not RB 19613 6530 9 see see VB 19613 6530 10 further far RBR 19613 6530 11 , , , 19613 6530 12 see see VB 19613 6530 13 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 6530 14 , , , 19613 6530 15 l.c l.c NNP 19613 6530 16 . . NNP 19613 6530 17 , , , 19613 6530 18 17 17 CD 19613 6530 19 ff ff NN 19613 6530 20 . . . 19613 6530 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6531 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6531 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6531 3 493 493 CD 19613 6531 4 : : : 19613 6531 5 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6531 6 's 's POS 19613 6531 7 teaching teaching NN 19613 6531 8 must must MD 19613 6531 9 have have VB 19613 6531 10 been be VBN 19613 6531 11 similar similar JJ 19613 6531 12 . . . 19613 6532 1 In in IN 19613 6532 2 a a DT 19613 6532 3 fragment fragment NN 19613 6532 4 attributed attribute VBN 19613 6532 5 to to IN 19613 6532 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6532 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6532 8 see see VB 19613 6532 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6532 10 Texte Texte NNP 19613 6532 11 und und NN 19613 6532 12 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 6532 13 I. i. NN 19613 6533 1 1 1 CD 19613 6533 2 , , , 19613 6533 3 2 2 CD 19613 6533 4 p. p. NN 19613 6533 5 255 255 CD 19613 6533 6 ff ff NNP 19613 6533 7 . . . 19613 6533 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6534 1 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6534 2 even even RB 19613 6534 3 find find VBP 19613 6534 4 the the DT 19613 6534 5 expression expression NN 19613 6534 6 " " '' 19613 6534 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6534 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6534 9 : : : 19613 6534 10 hai hai NN 19613 6534 11 duo duo NN 19613 6534 12 ousiai ousiai NNP 19613 6534 13 Christou Christou NNP 19613 6534 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6534 15 " " '' 19613 6534 16 . . . 19613 6535 1 The the DT 19613 6535 2 genuineness genuineness NN 19613 6535 3 of of IN 19613 6535 4 the the DT 19613 6535 5 fragment fragment NN 19613 6535 6 is be VBZ 19613 6535 7 indeed indeed RB 19613 6535 8 disputed dispute VBN 19613 6535 9 , , , 19613 6535 10 but but CC 19613 6535 11 , , , 19613 6535 12 as as IN 19613 6535 13 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6535 14 think think VBP 19613 6535 15 , , , 19613 6535 16 without without IN 19613 6535 17 grounds ground NNS 19613 6535 18 . . . 19613 6536 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6536 2 is be VBZ 19613 6536 3 certainly certainly RB 19613 6536 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 6536 5 that that IN 19613 6536 6 the the DT 19613 6536 7 formula formula NN 19613 6536 8 is be VBZ 19613 6536 9 not not RB 19613 6536 10 found find VBN 19613 6536 11 in in IN 19613 6536 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6536 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6536 14 see see VB 19613 6536 15 details detail NNS 19613 6536 16 below below RB 19613 6536 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6536 18 . . . 19613 6537 1 The the DT 19613 6537 2 first first JJ 19613 6537 3 Syriac Syriac NNP 19613 6537 4 fragment fragment NN 19613 6537 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6537 6 Otto Otto NNP 19613 6537 7 IX IX NNP 19613 6537 8 . . . 19613 6538 1 p. p. NN 19613 6538 2 419 419 CD 19613 6538 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6538 4 shows show VBZ 19613 6538 5 that that IN 19613 6538 6 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6538 7 also also RB 19613 6538 8 views view VBZ 19613 6538 9 redemption redemption NN 19613 6538 10 as as IN 19613 6538 11 reunion reunion NN 19613 6538 12 through through IN 19613 6538 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6538 14 . . . 19613 6538 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6539 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6539 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6539 3 494 494 CD 19613 6539 4 : : : 19613 6539 5 The the DT 19613 6539 6 conception conception NN 19613 6539 7 of of IN 19613 6539 8 the the DT 19613 6539 9 stage stage NN 19613 6539 10 by by IN 19613 6539 11 stage stage NN 19613 6539 12 development development NN 19613 6539 13 of of IN 19613 6539 14 the the DT 19613 6539 15 economy economy NN 19613 6539 16 of of IN 19613 6539 17 God God NNP 19613 6539 18 and and CC 19613 6539 19 the the DT 19613 6539 20 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 6539 21 idea idea NN 19613 6539 22 of of IN 19613 6539 23 " " `` 19613 6539 24 several several JJ 19613 6539 25 covenants covenant NNS 19613 6539 26 " " '' 19613 6539 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6539 28 I. i. NN 19613 6540 1 10 10 CD 19613 6540 2 . . . 19613 6541 1 3 3 LS 19613 6541 2 : : : 19613 6541 3 III iii CD 19613 6541 4 . . . 19613 6542 1 11 11 CD 19613 6542 2 - - SYM 19613 6542 3 15 15 CD 19613 6542 4 and and CC 19613 6542 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 6542 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6542 7 denote denote VB 19613 6542 8 a a DT 19613 6542 9 very very RB 19613 6542 10 considerable considerable JJ 19613 6542 11 advance advance NN 19613 6542 12 , , , 19613 6542 13 which which WDT 19613 6542 14 the the DT 19613 6542 15 Church Church NNP 19613 6542 16 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6542 17 owe owe VBP 19613 6542 18 to to IN 19613 6542 19 the the DT 19613 6542 20 controversy controversy NN 19613 6542 21 with with IN 19613 6542 22 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 6542 23 , , , 19613 6542 24 or or CC 19613 6542 25 to to IN 19613 6542 26 the the DT 19613 6542 27 example example NN 19613 6542 28 of of IN 19613 6542 29 the the DT 19613 6542 30 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6542 31 . . . 19613 6543 1 In in IN 19613 6543 2 this this DT 19613 6543 3 case case NN 19613 6543 4 the the DT 19613 6543 5 origin origin NN 19613 6543 6 of of IN 19613 6543 7 the the DT 19613 6543 8 idea idea NN 19613 6543 9 is be VBZ 19613 6543 10 quite quite RB 19613 6543 11 plain plain JJ 19613 6543 12 . . . 19613 6544 1 For for IN 19613 6544 2 details detail NNS 19613 6544 3 see see VBP 19613 6544 4 below below RB 19613 6544 5 . . . 19613 6544 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6545 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6545 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6545 3 495 495 CD 19613 6545 4 : : : 19613 6545 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6545 6 would would MD 19613 6545 7 seem seem VB 19613 6545 8 from from IN 19613 6545 9 some some DT 19613 6545 10 passages passage NNS 19613 6545 11 as as IN 19613 6545 12 if if IN 19613 6545 13 faith faith NN 19613 6545 14 and and CC 19613 6545 15 theological theological JJ 19613 6545 16 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6545 17 were be VBD 19613 6545 18 according accord VBG 19613 6545 19 to to IN 19613 6545 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6545 21 simply simply RB 19613 6545 22 related relate VBD 19613 6545 23 as as IN 19613 6545 24 the the DT 19613 6545 25 " " `` 19613 6545 26 is be VBZ 19613 6545 27 " " '' 19613 6545 28 and and CC 19613 6545 29 the the DT 19613 6545 30 " " `` 19613 6545 31 why why WRB 19613 6545 32 . . . 19613 6545 33 " " '' 19613 6546 1 As as IN 19613 6546 2 a a DT 19613 6546 3 matter matter NN 19613 6546 4 of of IN 19613 6546 5 fact fact NN 19613 6546 6 , , , 19613 6546 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6546 8 did do VBD 19613 6546 9 express express VB 19613 6546 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6546 11 so so IN 19613 6546 12 without without IN 19613 6546 13 being be VBG 19613 6546 14 really really RB 19613 6546 15 able able JJ 19613 6546 16 to to TO 19613 6546 17 maintain maintain VB 19613 6546 18 the the DT 19613 6546 19 relationship relationship NN 19613 6546 20 thus thus RB 19613 6546 21 fixed fix VBN 19613 6546 22 ; ; : 19613 6546 23 for for IN 19613 6546 24 faith faith NN 19613 6546 25 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6546 26 must must MD 19613 6546 27 also also RB 19613 6546 28 to to IN 19613 6546 29 some some DT 19613 6546 30 extent extent NN 19613 6546 31 include include VBP 19613 6546 32 a a DT 19613 6546 33 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6546 34 of of IN 19613 6546 35 the the DT 19613 6546 36 reason reason NN 19613 6546 37 and and CC 19613 6546 38 aim aim NN 19613 6546 39 of of IN 19613 6546 40 God God NNP 19613 6546 41 's 's POS 19613 6546 42 ways way NNS 19613 6546 43 of of IN 19613 6546 44 salvation salvation NN 19613 6546 45 . . . 19613 6547 1 Faith faith NN 19613 6547 2 and and CC 19613 6547 3 theological theological JJ 19613 6547 4 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6547 5 are be VBP 19613 6547 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 6547 7 , , , 19613 6547 8 after after RB 19613 6547 9 all all RB 19613 6547 10 , , , 19613 6547 11 closely closely RB 19613 6547 12 interwoven interwoven JJ 19613 6547 13 with with IN 19613 6547 14 each each DT 19613 6547 15 other other JJ 19613 6547 16 . . . 19613 6548 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6548 2 merely merely RB 19613 6548 3 sought seek VBD 19613 6548 4 for for IN 19613 6548 5 a a DT 19613 6548 6 clear clear JJ 19613 6548 7 distinction distinction NN 19613 6548 8 , , , 19613 6548 9 but but CC 19613 6548 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6548 11 was be VBD 19613 6548 12 impossible impossible JJ 19613 6548 13 for for IN 19613 6548 14 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6548 15 to to TO 19613 6548 16 find find VB 19613 6548 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6548 18 in in IN 19613 6548 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6548 20 way way NN 19613 6548 21 . . . 19613 6549 1 The the DT 19613 6549 2 truth truth NN 19613 6549 3 rather rather RB 19613 6549 4 is be VBZ 19613 6549 5 that that IN 19613 6549 6 the the DT 19613 6549 7 same same JJ 19613 6549 8 man man NN 19613 6549 9 , , , 19613 6549 10 who who WP 19613 6549 11 , , , 19613 6549 12 in in IN 19613 6549 13 opposition opposition NN 19613 6549 14 to to TO 19613 6549 15 heresy heresy VB 19613 6549 16 , , , 19613 6549 17 condemned condemn VBD 19613 6549 18 an an DT 19613 6549 19 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 19613 6549 20 estimate estimate NN 19613 6549 21 of of IN 19613 6549 22 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 6549 23 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6549 24 , , , 19613 6549 25 contributed contribute VBD 19613 6549 26 a a DT 19613 6549 27 great great JJ 19613 6549 28 deal deal NN 19613 6549 29 to to IN 19613 6549 30 the the DT 19613 6549 31 transformation transformation NN 19613 6549 32 of of IN 19613 6549 33 that that DT 19613 6549 34 faith faith NN 19613 6549 35 into into IN 19613 6549 36 a a DT 19613 6549 37 monistic monistic JJ 19613 6549 38 speculation speculation NN 19613 6549 39 . . . 19613 6549 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6550 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6550 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6550 3 496 496 CD 19613 6550 4 : : : 19613 6550 5 See see VB 19613 6550 6 1 1 CD 19613 6550 7 . . . 19613 6551 1 10 10 CD 19613 6551 2 . . . 19613 6552 1 2 2 LS 19613 6552 2 : : : 19613 6552 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6552 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6552 5 : : : 19613 6552 6 Kai Kai NNP 19613 6552 7 oute oute NN 19613 6552 8 ho ho NNP 19613 6552 9 panu panu NNP 19613 6552 10 dunatos dunato NNS 19613 6552 11 en en IN 19613 6552 12 logô logô NNP 19613 6552 13 tôn tôn NNP 19613 6552 14 en en IN 19613 6552 15 tais tais NNP 19613 6552 16 ekklêsiais ekklêsiais NNP 19613 6552 17 proestôtôn proestôtôn NNS 19613 6552 18 toutôn toutôn NNS 19613 6552 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6552 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6552 21 scil scil NN 19613 6552 22 . . . 19613 6553 1 than than IN 19613 6553 2 the the DT 19613 6553 3 regula regula NNP 19613 6553 4 sidei sidei NN 19613 6553 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6553 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6553 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6553 8 : : : 19613 6553 9 epei epei NNP 19613 6553 10 oudeis oudeis NNP 19613 6553 11 gar gar NNP 19613 6553 12 uper uper NNP 19613 6553 13 ton ton NNP 19613 6553 14 didaskalon didaskalon NNP 19613 6553 15 oute oute NNP 19613 6553 16 ho ho NNP 19613 6553 17 asthenês asthenês NNP 19613 6553 18 en en NNP 19613 6553 19 tô tô NNP 19613 6553 20 logô logô NNP 19613 6553 21 elattôsei elattôsei NNP 19613 6553 22 tên tên NNP 19613 6553 23 paradosin paradosin NNP 19613 6553 24 . . . 19613 6554 1 Mias Mias NNP 19613 6554 2 gar gar NNP 19613 6554 3 kai kai NNP 19613 6554 4 tês tês NNP 19613 6554 5 autês autês NNP 19613 6554 6 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 6554 7 ousês ousês RB 19613 6554 8 oute oute NNP 19613 6554 9 ho ho NNP 19613 6554 10 polu polu NNP 19613 6554 11 peri peri NNP 19613 6554 12 autês autês NNP 19613 6554 13 dunamenos dunamenos NNP 19613 6554 14 eipein eipein NNP 19613 6554 15 epleonasen epleonasen NNP 19613 6554 16 , , , 19613 6554 17 oute oute NNP 19613 6554 18 ho ho NNP 19613 6554 19 to to IN 19613 6554 20 oligon oligon NNP 19613 6554 21 êlattonêse êlattonêse NNP 19613 6554 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6554 23 . . . 19613 6554 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6555 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6555 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6555 3 497 497 CD 19613 6555 4 : : : 19613 6555 5 See see VB 19613 6555 6 Bohringer Bohringer NNP 19613 6555 7 's 's POS 19613 6555 8 careful careful JJ 19613 6555 9 reviews review NNS 19613 6555 10 of of IN 19613 6555 11 the the DT 19613 6555 12 theology theology NN 19613 6555 13 of of IN 19613 6555 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6555 15 and and CC 19613 6555 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6555 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6555 18 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 6555 19 in in IN 19613 6555 20 Biographien Biographien NNP 19613 6555 21 , , , 19613 6555 22 Vol Vol NNP 19613 6555 23 . . . 19613 6556 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6557 1 1st 1st NNP 19613 6557 2 section section NNP 19613 6557 3 , , , 19613 6557 4 1st 1st JJ 19613 6557 5 half half NN 19613 6557 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6557 7 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 6557 8 ed ed NN 19613 6557 9 . . . 19613 6558 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6558 2 , , , 19613 6558 3 pp pp NNP 19613 6558 4 . . . 19613 6559 1 378 378 CD 19613 6559 2 - - SYM 19613 6559 3 612 612 CD 19613 6559 4 , , , 19613 6559 5 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 6559 6 half half NN 19613 6559 7 , , , 19613 6559 8 pp pp NNP 19613 6559 9 . . . 19613 6560 1 484 484 CD 19613 6560 2 - - SYM 19613 6560 3 739 739 CD 19613 6560 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6560 5 . . . 19613 6560 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6561 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6561 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6561 3 498 498 CD 19613 6561 4 : : : 19613 6561 5 To to IN 19613 6561 6 the the DT 19613 6561 7 proof proof NN 19613 6561 8 from from IN 19613 6561 9 prescription prescription NN 19613 6561 10 belong belong VBP 19613 6561 11 the the DT 19613 6561 12 arguments argument NNS 19613 6561 13 derived derive VBN 19613 6561 14 from from IN 19613 6561 15 the the DT 19613 6561 16 novelty novelty JJ 19613 6561 17 and and CC 19613 6561 18 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 6561 19 multiplicity multiplicity NN 19613 6561 20 of of IN 19613 6561 21 the the DT 19613 6561 22 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6561 23 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 6561 24 as as RB 19613 6561 25 well well RB 19613 6561 26 as as IN 19613 6561 27 the the DT 19613 6561 28 proofs proof NNS 19613 6561 29 that that IN 19613 6561 30 Greek greek JJ 19613 6561 31 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 6561 32 is be VBZ 19613 6561 33 the the DT 19613 6561 34 original original JJ 19613 6561 35 source source NN 19613 6561 36 of of IN 19613 6561 37 heresy heresy NN 19613 6561 38 . . . 19613 6562 1 See see VB 19613 6562 2 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6562 3 . . . 19613 6563 1 II ii CD 19613 6563 2 . . . 19613 6564 1 14 14 CD 19613 6564 2 . . . 19613 6565 1 1 1 CD 19613 6565 2 - - SYM 19613 6565 3 6 6 CD 19613 6565 4 ; ; : 19613 6565 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6565 6 . . . 19613 6566 1 de de NNP 19613 6566 2 præscr præscr NNP 19613 6566 3 . . . 19613 6567 1 7 7 LS 19613 6567 2 ; ; : 19613 6567 3 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 6567 4 . . . 19613 6568 1 47 47 CD 19613 6568 2 and and CC 19613 6568 3 other other JJ 19613 6568 4 places place NNS 19613 6568 5 ; ; : 19613 6568 6 the the DT 19613 6568 7 Philosophoumena Philosophoumena NNP 19613 6568 8 of of IN 19613 6568 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6568 10 . . . 19613 6569 1 On on IN 19613 6569 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6569 3 ' ' POS 19613 6569 4 criticism criticism NN 19613 6569 5 of of IN 19613 6569 6 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 6569 7 theology theology NN 19613 6569 8 see see VB 19613 6569 9 Kunze Kunze NNP 19613 6569 10 , , , 19613 6569 11 Gotteslehre Gotteslehre NNP 19613 6569 12 des des NNP 19613 6569 13 Irenäus Irenäus NNP 19613 6569 14 , , , 19613 6569 15 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 19613 6569 16 , , , 19613 6569 17 1891 1891 CD 19613 6569 18 . . . 19613 6569 19 p. p. NN 19613 6569 20 8 8 CD 19613 6569 21 ff ff NNP 19613 6569 22 . . . 19613 6569 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6570 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6570 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6570 3 499 499 CD 19613 6570 4 : : : 19613 6570 5 See see VB 19613 6570 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6570 7 II II NNP 19613 6570 8 . . . 19613 6571 1 1 1 LS 19613 6571 2 . . . 19613 6572 1 2 2 CD 19613 6572 2 - - SYM 19613 6572 3 4 4 CD 19613 6572 4 : : : 19613 6572 5 II ii CD 19613 6572 6 . . . 19613 6573 1 31 31 CD 19613 6573 2 . . . 19613 6574 1 1 1 LS 19613 6574 2 . . . 19613 6575 1 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6575 2 . . NNP 19613 6575 3 , , , 19613 6575 4 adv adv NNP 19613 6575 5 . . . 19613 6576 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6576 2 . . . 19613 6577 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6578 1 2 2 CD 19613 6578 2 - - SYM 19613 6578 3 7 7 CD 19613 6578 4 . . . 19613 6579 1 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 6579 2 proves prove VBZ 19613 6579 3 that that IN 19613 6579 4 there there EX 19613 6579 5 can can MD 19613 6579 6 be be VB 19613 6579 7 neither neither CC 19613 6579 8 two two CD 19613 6579 9 morally morally RB 19613 6579 10 similar similar JJ 19613 6579 11 , , , 19613 6579 12 nor nor CC 19613 6579 13 two two CD 19613 6579 14 morally morally RB 19613 6579 15 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 19613 6579 16 Deities deity NNS 19613 6579 17 ; ; : 19613 6579 18 see see VB 19613 6579 19 also also RB 19613 6579 20 I. I. NNP 19613 6580 1 15 15 CD 19613 6580 2 . . . 19613 6580 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6581 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6581 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6581 3 500 500 CD 19613 6581 4 : : : 19613 6581 5 See see VB 19613 6581 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6581 7 II II NNP 19613 6581 8 . . . 19613 6582 1 13 13 CD 19613 6582 2 . . . 19613 6583 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6583 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6583 3 ad ad NN 19613 6583 4 Valent Valent NNP 19613 6583 5 . . . 19613 6584 1 4 4 LS 19613 6584 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6584 3 very very RB 19613 6584 4 appropriately appropriately RB 19613 6584 5 defined define VBD 19613 6584 6 the the DT 19613 6584 7 æons æon NNS 19613 6584 8 of of IN 19613 6584 9 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 19613 6584 10 as as IN 19613 6584 11 " " `` 19613 6584 12 personales personale NNS 19613 6584 13 substantias substantia NNS 19613 6584 14 extra extra JJ 19613 6584 15 deum deum NNP 19613 6584 16 determinatas determinata NNS 19613 6584 17 , , , 19613 6584 18 quas qua VBD 19613 6584 19 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 6584 20 in in IN 19613 6584 21 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 6584 22 summa summa JJR 19613 6584 23 divinitatis divinitatis NN 19613 6584 24 ut ut NNP 19613 6584 25 sensus sensus NNP 19613 6584 26 et et NNP 19613 6584 27 affectus affectus NNP 19613 6584 28 motus motus NNP 19613 6584 29 incluserat incluserat NNP 19613 6584 30 . . . 19613 6584 31 " " '' 19613 6584 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6585 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6585 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6585 3 501 501 CD 19613 6585 4 : : : 19613 6585 5 See See NNP 19613 6585 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6585 7 , , , 19613 6585 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 6585 9 . . NNP 19613 6585 10 , , , 19613 6585 11 and and CC 19613 6585 12 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 6585 13 in in IN 19613 6585 14 the the DT 19613 6585 15 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 6585 16 Book Book NNP 19613 6585 17 , , , 19613 6585 18 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6585 19 . . . 19613 6586 1 adv adv NNP 19613 6586 2 . . . 19613 6587 1 Valent Valent NNP 19613 6587 2 . . . 19613 6588 1 in in IN 19613 6588 2 several several JJ 19613 6588 3 passages passage NNS 19613 6588 4 . . . 19613 6589 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 6589 2 , , , 19613 6589 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6589 4 still still RB 19613 6589 5 treated treat VBD 19613 6589 6 the the DT 19613 6589 7 first first JJ 19613 6589 8 8 8 CD 19613 6589 9 Ptolemaic Ptolemaic NNP 19613 6589 10 æons æon NNS 19613 6589 11 with with IN 19613 6589 12 more more JJR 19613 6589 13 respect respect NN 19613 6589 14 than than IN 19613 6589 15 the the DT 19613 6589 16 22 22 CD 19613 6589 17 following following NN 19613 6589 18 , , , 19613 6589 19 because because IN 19613 6589 20 here here RB 19613 6589 21 at at IN 19613 6589 22 least least JJS 19613 6589 23 there there EX 19613 6589 24 was be VBD 19613 6589 25 some some DT 19613 6589 26 appearance appearance NN 19613 6589 27 of of IN 19613 6589 28 a a DT 19613 6589 29 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6589 30 foundation foundation NN 19613 6589 31 . . . 19613 6590 1 In in IN 19613 6590 2 confuting confute VBG 19613 6590 3 the the DT 19613 6590 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6590 5 of of IN 19613 6590 6 æons æon NNS 19613 6590 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6590 8 incidentally incidentally RB 19613 6590 9 raised raise VBD 19613 6590 10 several several JJ 19613 6590 11 questions question NNS 19613 6590 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6590 13 II ii CD 19613 6590 14 . . . 19613 6591 1 17 17 CD 19613 6591 2 . . . 19613 6592 1 2 2 LS 19613 6592 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6592 3 , , , 19613 6592 4 which which WDT 19613 6592 5 Church church NN 19613 6592 6 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6592 7 discussed discuss VBN 19613 6592 8 in in IN 19613 6592 9 later late JJR 19613 6592 10 times time NNS 19613 6592 11 , , , 19613 6592 12 with with IN 19613 6592 13 reference reference NN 19613 6592 14 to to IN 19613 6592 15 the the DT 19613 6592 16 Son Son NNP 19613 6592 17 and and CC 19613 6592 18 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6592 19 . . . 19613 6593 1 " " `` 19613 6593 2 Quæritur Quæritur NNP 19613 6593 3 quemadmodum quemadmodum NN 19613 6593 4 emissi emissi IN 19613 6593 5 sunt sunt NN 19613 6593 6 reliqui reliqui NN 19613 6593 7 æones æone NNS 19613 6593 8 ? ? . 19613 6594 1 Utrum Utrum NNP 19613 6594 2 uniti uniti NNP 19613 6594 3 ei ei NNP 19613 6594 4 qui qui NNP 19613 6594 5 emiserit emiserit NNP 19613 6594 6 , , , 19613 6594 7 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 6594 8 a a DT 19613 6594 9 sole sole JJ 19613 6594 10 radii radii NN 19613 6594 11 , , , 19613 6594 12 an an DT 19613 6594 13 efficabiliter efficabiliter NN 19613 6594 14 et et NN 19613 6594 15 partiliter partiliter NN 19613 6594 16 , , , 19613 6594 17 uti uti NNP 19613 6594 18 sit sit NNP 19613 6594 19 unusquisque unusquisque NNP 19613 6594 20 eorum eorum NNP 19613 6594 21 separatim separatim NNP 19613 6594 22 et et NNP 19613 6594 23 suam suam NNP 19613 6594 24 figurationem figurationem NNP 19613 6594 25 habens habens NNP 19613 6594 26 , , , 19613 6594 27 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 6594 28 ab ab NNP 19613 6594 29 homine homine NNP 19613 6594 30 homo homo NNP 19613 6594 31 ... ... . 19613 6594 32 Aut Aut NNP 19613 6594 33 secundum secundum NN 19613 6594 34 germinationem germinationem NN 19613 6594 35 , , , 19613 6594 36 quemabmodum quemabmodum NNP 19613 6594 37 ab ab NNP 19613 6594 38 arbore arbore NNP 19613 6594 39 rami rami NNP 19613 6594 40 ? ? . 19613 6595 1 Et Et NNP 19613 6595 2 utrum utrum NNP 19613 6595 3 eiusdem eiusdem NN 19613 6595 4 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 6595 5 exsistebant exsistebant VB 19613 6595 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6595 7 qui qui NN 19613 6595 8 se se FW 19613 6595 9 emiserunt emiserunt NNP 19613 6595 10 , , , 19613 6595 11 an an DT 19613 6595 12 ex ex NNP 19613 6595 13 altera altera NNP 19613 6595 14 quadam quadam NNP 19613 6595 15 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6595 16 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 6595 17 habentes habente VBZ 19613 6595 18 ? ? . 19613 6596 1 Et Et NNP 19613 6596 2 utrum utrum NNP 19613 6596 3 in in IN 19613 6596 4 eodem eodem NN 19613 6596 5 emissi emissi NNP 19613 6596 6 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6596 7 , , , 19613 6596 8 ut ut UH 19613 6596 9 eiusdem eiusdem NNP 19613 6596 10 temporis temporis NNP 19613 6596 11 essent essent NN 19613 6596 12 sibi sibi NN 19613 6596 13 ? ? . 19613 6596 14 ... ... . 19613 6597 1 Et Et NNP 19613 6597 2 utrum utrum NNP 19613 6597 3 simplices simplice VBZ 19613 6597 4 quidam quidam NNP 19613 6597 5 et et NNP 19613 6597 6 uniformes uniformes NNPS 19613 6597 7 et et NNP 19613 6597 8 undique undique JJ 19613 6597 9 sibi sibi NNP 19613 6597 10 æquales æquales NNPS 19613 6597 11 et et NNP 19613 6597 12 similes simile NNS 19613 6597 13 , , , 19613 6597 14 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 6597 15 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 6597 16 et et NNP 19613 6597 17 lumina lumina NNP 19613 6597 18 emissa emissa NNP 19613 6597 19 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6597 20 , , , 19613 6597 21 an an DT 19613 6597 22 compositi compositi NNP 19613 6597 23 et et NNP 19613 6597 24 differentes differente VBZ 19613 6597 25 " " '' 19613 6597 26 ? ? . 19613 6598 1 See see VB 19613 6598 2 also also RB 19613 6598 3 II II NNP 19613 6598 4 . . . 19613 6599 1 17 17 CD 19613 6599 2 . . . 19613 6600 1 4 4 LS 19613 6600 2 : : : 19613 6600 3 " " `` 19613 6600 4 Si Si NNP 19613 6600 5 autem autem NN 19613 6600 6 velut velut NN 19613 6600 7 a a DT 19613 6600 8 lumine lumine NNP 19613 6600 9 lumina lumina NNP 19613 6600 10 accensa accensa NNP 19613 6600 11 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6600 12 ... ... NFP 19613 6600 13 velut velut JJ 19613 6600 14 verbi verbi NN 19613 6600 15 gratia gratia NN 19613 6600 16 a a DT 19613 6600 17 facula facula NN 19613 6600 18 faculæ faculæ NN 19613 6600 19 , , , 19613 6600 20 generatione generatione NNP 19613 6600 21 quidem quidem NNP 19613 6600 22 et et NNP 19613 6600 23 magnitudine magnitudine NNP 19613 6600 24 fortasse fortasse NNP 19613 6600 25 distabunt distabunt NNP 19613 6600 26 ab ab NNP 19613 6600 27 invicem invicem NNP 19613 6600 28 ; ; : 19613 6600 29 eiusdem eiusdem NNP 19613 6600 30 autem autem NNP 19613 6600 31 substantive substantive JJ 19613 6600 32 cum cum NNP 19613 6600 33 sint sint NNP 19613 6600 34 cum cum NNP 19613 6600 35 principe principe NNP 19613 6600 36 emissionis emissionis NNP 19613 6600 37 ipsorum ipsorum NNP 19613 6600 38 , , , 19613 6600 39 aut aut NNP 19613 6600 40 omnes omnes NNP 19613 6600 41 impassibiles impassibiles NNP 19613 6600 42 perseverant perseverant JJ 19613 6600 43 aut aut NNP 19613 6600 44 et et NNP 19613 6600 45 pater pater NN 19613 6600 46 ipsorum ipsorum NNP 19613 6600 47 participabit participabit NNP 19613 6600 48 passiones passione NNS 19613 6600 49 . . . 19613 6601 1 Neque Neque NNP 19613 6601 2 enim enim NNP 19613 6601 3 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6601 4 postea postea NNP 19613 6601 5 accensa accensa NNP 19613 6601 6 est est NNP 19613 6601 7 facula facula NNP 19613 6601 8 , , , 19613 6601 9 alterum alterum NNP 19613 6601 10 lumen lumen NNP 19613 6601 11 habebit habebit NNP 19613 6601 12 quam quam NNP 19613 6601 13 illud illud NNP 19613 6601 14 quod quod NN 19613 6601 15 ante ante VB 19613 6601 16 eam eam NN 19613 6601 17 fuit fuit NN 19613 6601 18 . . . 19613 6601 19 " " '' 19613 6602 1 Here here RB 19613 6602 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6602 3 have have VBP 19613 6602 4 already already RB 19613 6602 5 a a DT 19613 6602 6 statement statement NN 19613 6602 7 of of IN 19613 6602 8 the the DT 19613 6602 9 logical logical JJ 19613 6602 10 reasons reason NNS 19613 6602 11 , , , 19613 6602 12 which which WDT 19613 6602 13 in in IN 19613 6602 14 later late JJR 19613 6602 15 times time NNS 19613 6602 16 were be VBD 19613 6602 17 urged urge VBN 19613 6602 18 against against IN 19613 6602 19 the the DT 19613 6602 20 Arian arian JJ 19613 6602 21 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6602 22 . . . 19613 6602 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6603 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6603 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6603 3 502 502 CD 19613 6603 4 : : : 19613 6603 5 See see VB 19613 6603 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6603 7 . . . 19613 6604 1 II ii CD 19613 6604 2 . . . 19613 6605 1 17 17 CD 19613 6605 2 . . . 19613 6606 1 5 5 CD 19613 6606 2 and and CC 19613 6606 3 II II NNP 19613 6606 4 . . . 19613 6607 1 18 18 CD 19613 6607 2 . . . 19613 6607 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6608 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6608 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6608 3 503 503 CD 19613 6608 4 : : : 19613 6608 5 See see VB 19613 6608 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6608 7 . . . 19613 6609 1 II ii CD 19613 6609 2 . . . 19613 6610 1 4 4 LS 19613 6610 2 . . . 19613 6611 1 2 2 LS 19613 6611 2 . . . 19613 6611 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6612 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6612 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6612 3 504 504 CD 19613 6612 4 : : : 19613 6612 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6612 6 in in IN 19613 6612 7 particular particular JJ 19613 6612 8 argued argue VBD 19613 6612 9 in in IN 19613 6612 10 great great JJ 19613 6612 11 detail detail NN 19613 6612 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6612 13 adv adv NNP 19613 6612 14 . . . 19613 6613 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6613 2 . . . 19613 6614 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6615 1 9 9 CD 19613 6615 2 - - SYM 19613 6615 3 19 19 CD 19613 6615 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6615 5 that that IN 19613 6615 6 every every DT 19613 6615 7 God God NNP 19613 6615 8 must must MD 19613 6615 9 , , , 19613 6615 10 above above IN 19613 6615 11 all all DT 19613 6615 12 , , , 19613 6615 13 have have VBP 19613 6615 14 revealed reveal VBN 19613 6615 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6615 16 as as IN 19613 6615 17 a a DT 19613 6615 18 creator creator NN 19613 6615 19 . . . 19613 6616 1 In in IN 19613 6616 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 6616 3 to to IN 19613 6616 4 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6616 5 's 's POS 19613 6616 6 rejection rejection NN 19613 6616 7 of of IN 19613 6616 8 all all DT 19613 6616 9 natural natural JJ 19613 6616 10 theology theology NN 19613 6616 11 , , , 19613 6616 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6616 13 represents represent VBZ 19613 6616 14 this this DT 19613 6616 15 science science NN 19613 6616 16 as as IN 19613 6616 17 the the DT 19613 6616 18 foundation foundation NN 19613 6616 19 of of IN 19613 6616 20 all all DT 19613 6616 21 religious religious JJ 19613 6616 22 belief belief NN 19613 6616 23 . . . 19613 6617 1 In in IN 19613 6617 2 this this DT 19613 6617 3 connection connection NN 19613 6617 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6617 5 eulogised eulogise VBD 19613 6617 6 the the DT 19613 6617 7 created create VBN 19613 6617 8 world world NN 19613 6617 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6617 10 I. I. NNP 19613 6618 1 13 13 CD 19613 6618 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6618 3 and and CC 19613 6618 4 at at IN 19613 6618 5 the the DT 19613 6618 6 same same JJ 19613 6618 7 time time NN 19613 6618 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6618 9 see see VB 19613 6618 10 also also RB 19613 6618 11 the the DT 19613 6618 12 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 6618 13 Book Book NNP 19613 6618 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6618 15 argued argue VBD 19613 6618 16 in in IN 19613 6618 17 favour favour NN 19613 6618 18 of of IN 19613 6618 19 the the DT 19613 6618 20 Demiurge demiurge NN 19613 6618 21 , , , 19613 6618 22 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6618 23 , , , 19613 6618 24 of of IN 19613 6618 25 the the DT 19613 6618 26 one one CD 19613 6618 27 true true JJ 19613 6618 28 God God NNP 19613 6618 29 . . . 19613 6619 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6619 2 urged urge VBD 19613 6619 3 a a DT 19613 6619 4 series series NN 19613 6619 5 of of IN 19613 6619 6 acute acute JJ 19613 6619 7 and and CC 19613 6619 8 weighty weighty JJ 19613 6619 9 objections objection NNS 19613 6619 10 to to IN 19613 6619 11 the the DT 19613 6619 12 cosmogony cosmogony NN 19613 6619 13 of of IN 19613 6619 14 the the DT 19613 6619 15 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 6619 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6619 17 see see VB 19613 6619 18 II II NNP 19613 6619 19 . . . 19613 6620 1 1 1 LS 19613 6620 2 - - SYM 19613 6620 3 5 5 CD 19613 6620 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6620 5 , , , 19613 6620 6 and and CC 19613 6620 7 showed show VBD 19613 6620 8 how how WRB 19613 6620 9 untenable untenable JJ 19613 6620 10 was be VBD 19613 6620 11 the the DT 19613 6620 12 idea idea NN 19613 6620 13 of of IN 19613 6620 14 the the DT 19613 6620 15 Demiurge Demiurge NNP 19613 6620 16 as as IN 19613 6620 17 an an DT 19613 6620 18 intermediate intermediate JJ 19613 6620 19 being being NN 19613 6620 20 . . . 19613 6621 1 The the DT 19613 6621 2 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 6621 3 that that WDT 19613 6621 4 the the DT 19613 6621 5 Supreme Supreme NNP 19613 6621 6 Being Being NNP 19613 6621 7 is be VBZ 19613 6621 8 unknown unknown JJ 19613 6621 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6621 10 II ii CD 19613 6621 11 . . . 19613 6622 1 6 6 LS 19613 6622 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6622 3 , , , 19613 6622 4 that that IN 19613 6622 5 the the DT 19613 6622 6 Demiurge demiurge NN 19613 6622 7 is be VBZ 19613 6622 8 the the DT 19613 6622 9 blind blind JJ 19613 6622 10 instrument instrument NN 19613 6622 11 of of IN 19613 6622 12 higher high JJR 19613 6622 13 æons æon NNS 19613 6622 14 , , , 19613 6622 15 that that IN 19613 6622 16 the the DT 19613 6622 17 world world NN 19613 6622 18 was be VBD 19613 6622 19 created create VBN 19613 6622 20 against against IN 19613 6622 21 the the DT 19613 6622 22 will will NN 19613 6622 23 of of IN 19613 6622 24 the the DT 19613 6622 25 Supreme Supreme NNP 19613 6622 26 God God NNP 19613 6622 27 , , , 19613 6622 28 and and CC 19613 6622 29 , , , 19613 6622 30 lastly lastly RB 19613 6622 31 , , , 19613 6622 32 that that IN 19613 6622 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6622 34 world world NN 19613 6622 35 is be VBZ 19613 6622 36 the the DT 19613 6622 37 imperfect imperfect JJ 19613 6622 38 copy copy NN 19613 6622 39 of of IN 19613 6622 40 a a DT 19613 6622 41 higher high JJR 19613 6622 42 one one CD 19613 6622 43 were be VBD 19613 6622 44 also also RB 19613 6622 45 opposed oppose VBN 19613 6622 46 by by IN 19613 6622 47 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6622 48 with with IN 19613 6622 49 rational rational JJ 19613 6622 50 arguments argument NNS 19613 6622 51 . . . 19613 6623 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6623 2 refutation refutation NN 19613 6623 3 of of IN 19613 6623 4 the the DT 19613 6623 5 last last JJ 19613 6623 6 conception conception NN 19613 6623 7 is be VBZ 19613 6623 8 specially specially RB 19613 6623 9 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 6623 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6623 11 II II NNP 19613 6623 12 . . . 19613 6624 1 7 7 LS 19613 6624 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6624 3 . . . 19613 6625 1 On on IN 19613 6625 2 the the DT 19613 6625 3 idea idea NN 19613 6625 4 that that WDT 19613 6625 5 God God NNP 19613 6625 6 did do VBD 19613 6625 7 not not RB 19613 6625 8 create create VB 19613 6625 9 the the DT 19613 6625 10 world world NN 19613 6625 11 from from IN 19613 6625 12 eternal eternal JJ 19613 6625 13 matter matter NN 19613 6625 14 see see VB 19613 6625 15 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6625 16 . . NNP 19613 6625 17 , , , 19613 6625 18 adv adv NNP 19613 6625 19 . . . 19613 6626 1 Hermog hermog NN 19613 6626 2 . . . 19613 6626 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6627 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6627 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6627 3 505 505 CD 19613 6627 4 : : : 19613 6627 5 But but CC 19613 6627 6 this this DT 19613 6627 7 very very JJ 19613 6627 8 method method NN 19613 6627 9 of of IN 19613 6627 10 argument argument NN 19613 6627 11 was be VBD 19613 6627 12 without without IN 19613 6627 13 doubt doubt NN 19613 6627 14 specially specially RB 19613 6627 15 impressive impressive JJ 19613 6627 16 in in IN 19613 6627 17 the the DT 19613 6627 18 case case NN 19613 6627 19 of of IN 19613 6627 20 the the DT 19613 6627 21 educated educate VBN 19613 6627 22 , , , 19613 6627 23 and and CC 19613 6627 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6627 25 is be VBZ 19613 6627 26 these these DT 19613 6627 27 alone alone JJ 19613 6627 28 of of IN 19613 6627 29 whom whom WP 19613 6627 30 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6627 31 are be VBP 19613 6627 32 here here RB 19613 6627 33 speaking speak VBG 19613 6627 34 . . . 19613 6628 1 On on IN 19613 6628 2 the the DT 19613 6628 3 decay decay NN 19613 6628 4 of of IN 19613 6628 5 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 6628 6 after after IN 19613 6628 7 the the DT 19613 6628 8 end end NN 19613 6628 9 of of IN 19613 6628 10 the the DT 19613 6628 11 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 6628 12 century century NN 19613 6628 13 , , , 19613 6628 14 see see VB 19613 6628 15 Renan Renan NNP 19613 6628 16 , , , 19613 6628 17 Origines Origines NNP 19613 6628 18 , , , 19613 6628 19 Vol Vol NNP 19613 6628 20 . . . 19613 6629 1 VII VII NNP 19613 6629 2 . . NNP 19613 6629 3 , , , 19613 6629 4 p. p. NN 19613 6629 5 113 113 CD 19613 6629 6 ff ff NNP 19613 6629 7 . . . 19613 6629 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6630 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6630 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6630 3 506 506 CD 19613 6630 4 : : : 19613 6630 5 See see VB 19613 6630 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6630 7 arguments argument NNS 19613 6630 8 that that IN 19613 6630 9 the the DT 19613 6630 10 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6630 11 merely merely RB 19613 6630 12 _ _ NNP 19613 6630 13 assert assert NN 19613 6630 14 _ _ NNP 19613 6630 15 that that IN 19613 6630 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6630 17 have have VBP 19613 6630 18 only only RB 19613 6630 19 one one CD 19613 6630 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6630 21 , , , 19613 6630 22 whereas whereas IN 19613 6630 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6630 24 actually actually RB 19613 6630 25 possess possess VBP 19613 6630 26 several several JJ 19613 6630 27 , , , 19613 6630 28 III iii CD 19613 6630 29 . . . 19613 6631 1 16 16 CD 19613 6631 2 . . . 19613 6632 1 1 1 CD 19613 6632 2 , , , 19613 6632 3 8 8 CD 19613 6632 4 and and CC 19613 6632 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 6632 6 . . . 19613 6632 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6633 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6633 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6633 3 507 507 CD 19613 6633 4 : : : 19613 6633 5 See see VB 19613 6633 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6633 7 . . . 19613 6633 8 , , , 19613 6633 9 I. I. NNP 19613 6634 1 9 9 CD 19613 6634 2 and and CC 19613 6634 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 6634 4 ; ; : 19613 6634 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6634 6 . . NNP 19613 6634 7 , , , 19613 6634 8 de de NNP 19613 6634 9 præscr præscr NNP 19613 6634 10 . . . 19613 6635 1 39 39 CD 19613 6635 2 , , , 19613 6635 3 adv adv NN 19613 6635 4 . . . 19613 6636 1 Valent Valent NNP 19613 6636 2 . . . 19613 6637 1 passim passim NNP 19613 6637 2 . . . 19613 6637 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6638 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6638 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6638 3 508 508 CD 19613 6638 4 : : : 19613 6638 5 See See NNP 19613 6638 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6638 7 . . NNP 19613 6638 8 , , , 19613 6638 9 adv adv NNP 19613 6638 10 . . . 19613 6639 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6639 2 . . . 19613 6640 1 II ii CD 19613 6640 2 . . . 19613 6641 1 19 19 CD 19613 6641 2 , , , 19613 6641 3 21 21 CD 19613 6641 4 , , , 19613 6641 5 22 22 CD 19613 6641 6 : : : 19613 6641 7 III iii CD 19613 6641 8 . . . 19613 6642 1 5 5 CD 19613 6642 2 , , , 19613 6642 3 6 6 CD 19613 6642 4 , , , 19613 6642 5 14 14 CD 19613 6642 6 , , , 19613 6642 7 19 19 CD 19613 6642 8 : : : 19613 6642 9 V. v. NN 19613 6642 10 1 1 CD 19613 6642 11 . . . 19613 6642 12 ; ; : 19613 6642 13 Orig Orig NNP 19613 6642 14 . . . 19613 6643 1 Comm Comm NNP 19613 6643 2 . . . 19613 6644 1 in in IN 19613 6644 2 Matth Matth NNP 19613 6644 3 . . NNP 19613 6644 4 , , , 19613 6644 5 T. T. NNP 19613 6644 6 XV XV NNP 19613 6644 7 . . . 19613 6645 1 3 3 LS 19613 6645 2 , , , 19613 6645 3 Opp Opp NNP 19613 6645 4 . . . 19613 6646 1 III III NNP 19613 6646 2 . . NNP 19613 6646 3 , , , 19613 6646 4 p. p. NN 19613 6646 5 655 655 CD 19613 6646 6 : : : 19613 6646 7 Comm Comm NNP 19613 6646 8 . . . 19613 6647 1 in in IN 19613 6647 2 ep ep NNP 19613 6647 3 . . . 19613 6648 1 ad ad NN 19613 6648 2 Rom Rom NNP 19613 6648 3 . . NNP 19613 6648 4 , , , 19613 6648 5 T. T. NNP 19613 6648 6 II II NNP 19613 6648 7 . . . 19613 6649 1 12 12 CD 19613 6649 2 . . . 19613 6650 1 Opp Opp NNP 19613 6650 2 . . . 19613 6651 1 IV IV NNP 19613 6651 2 . . NNP 19613 6651 3 , , , 19613 6651 4 p. p. NN 19613 6651 5 494 494 CD 19613 6651 6 sq sq NNP 19613 6651 7 . . . 19613 6652 1 ; ; : 19613 6652 2 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 6652 3 - - HYPH 19613 6652 4 Orig Orig NNP 19613 6652 5 . . . 19613 6653 1 Adamantius Adamantius NNP 19613 6653 2 , , , 19613 6653 3 De De NNP 19613 6653 4 recta recta NNP 19613 6653 5 in in IN 19613 6653 6 deum deum NN 19613 6653 7 fide fide NN 19613 6653 8 ; ; : 19613 6653 9 Orig Orig NNP 19613 6653 10 . . . 19613 6654 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6654 2 pp pp NNP 19613 6654 3 . . . 19613 6655 1 808 808 CD 19613 6655 2 , , , 19613 6655 3 817 817 CD 19613 6655 4 . . . 19613 6655 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6656 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6656 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6656 3 509 509 CD 19613 6656 4 : : : 19613 6656 5 For for IN 19613 6656 6 this this DT 19613 6656 7 reason reason NN 19613 6656 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6656 9 altogether altogether RB 19613 6656 10 forbade forbid VBD 19613 6656 11 exegetic exegetic JJ 19613 6656 12 disputes dispute NNS 19613 6656 13 with with IN 19613 6656 14 the the DT 19613 6656 15 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6656 16 , , , 19613 6656 17 see see VB 19613 6656 18 de de IN 19613 6656 19 præscr præscr NNS 19613 6656 20 . . . 19613 6657 1 16 16 CD 19613 6657 2 - - SYM 19613 6657 3 19 19 CD 19613 6657 4 : : : 19613 6657 5 " " `` 19613 6657 6 Ego ego VB 19613 6657 7 non non JJ 19613 6657 8 ad ad NN 19613 6657 9 scripturas scripturas NNP 19613 6657 10 provocandum provocandum NN 19613 6657 11 est est NNP 19613 6657 12 nec nec NNP 19613 6657 13 in in IN 19613 6657 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6657 15 constituendum constituendum NN 19613 6657 16 certamen certaman NNS 19613 6657 17 , , , 19613 6657 18 in in IN 19613 6657 19 quibus quibus NNP 19613 6657 20 aut aut NNP 19613 6657 21 milla milla NNP 19613 6657 22 aut aut NNP 19613 6657 23 incerta incerta NNP 19613 6657 24 victoria victoria NNP 19613 6657 25 est est NNP 19613 6657 26 aut aut NNP 19613 6657 27 parum parum NNP 19613 6657 28 certa certa NNP 19613 6657 29 . . . 19613 6657 30 " " '' 19613 6657 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6658 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6658 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6658 3 510 510 CD 19613 6658 4 : : : 19613 6658 5 See see VB 19613 6658 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6658 7 . . . 19613 6658 8 , , , 19613 6658 9 III iii CD 19613 6658 10 . . . 19613 6659 1 5 5 CD 19613 6659 2 . . . 19613 6660 1 1 1 LS 19613 6660 2 : : : 19613 6660 3 III iii CD 19613 6660 4 . . . 19613 6661 1 12 12 CD 19613 6661 2 . . . 19613 6662 1 6 6 LS 19613 6662 2 . . . 19613 6662 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6663 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6663 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6663 3 511 511 CD 19613 6663 4 : : : 19613 6663 5 See see VB 19613 6663 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6663 7 . . . 19613 6663 8 , , , 19613 6663 9 III iii CD 19613 6663 10 . . . 19613 6664 1 14 14 CD 19613 6664 2 . . . 19613 6665 1 2 2 LS 19613 6665 2 : : : 19613 6665 3 III iii CD 19613 6665 4 . . . 19613 6666 1 15 15 CD 19613 6666 2 . . . 19613 6667 1 1 1 LS 19613 6667 2 ; ; : 19613 6667 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6667 4 . . NNP 19613 6667 5 , , , 19613 6667 6 de de NNP 19613 6667 7 præscr præscr NNP 19613 6667 8 . . . 19613 6668 1 25 25 CD 19613 6668 2 : : : 19613 6668 3 " " `` 19613 6668 4 Scripturæ Scripturæ NNP 19613 6668 5 quidem quidem NNP 19613 6668 6 perfectæ perfectæ NNP 19613 6668 7 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6668 8 , , , 19613 6668 9 quippe quippe VB 19613 6668 10 a a DT 19613 6668 11 verbo verbo NN 19613 6668 12 dei dei NNP 19613 6668 13 et et NNP 19613 6668 14 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 6668 15 eius eius NNP 19613 6668 16 dictæ dictæ NNP 19613 6668 17 , , , 19613 6668 18 nos nos NNP 19613 6668 19 autem autem NNP 19613 6668 20 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6668 21 quod quod NNP 19613 6668 22 minores minores NNP 19613 6668 23 sumus sumus NNP 19613 6668 24 et et NNP 19613 6668 25 novissimi novissimi NNP 19613 6668 26 a a DT 19613 6668 27 verbo verbo NN 19613 6668 28 dei dei NNP 19613 6668 29 et et NNP 19613 6668 30 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 6668 31 eius eius NNP 19613 6668 32 , , , 19613 6668 33 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6668 34 hoc hoc FW 19613 6668 35 et et NNP 19613 6668 36 scientia scientia NNP 19613 6668 37 niysteriorum niysteriorum NNP 19613 6668 38 eius eius NNP 19613 6668 39 indigenus indigenus NNP 19613 6668 40 . . . 19613 6668 41 " " '' 19613 6668 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6669 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6669 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6669 3 512 512 CD 19613 6669 4 : : : 19613 6669 5 See see VB 19613 6669 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6669 7 . . . 19613 6670 1 II ii CD 19613 6670 2 . . . 19613 6671 1 35 35 CD 19613 6671 2 . . . 19613 6672 1 2 2 LS 19613 6672 2 : : : 19613 6672 3 IV IV NNP 19613 6672 4 . . . 19613 6673 1 34 34 CD 19613 6673 2 , , , 19613 6673 3 35 35 CD 19613 6673 4 and and CC 19613 6673 5 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 6673 6 . . . 19613 6674 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6674 2 also also RB 19613 6674 3 asserted assert VBD 19613 6674 4 that that IN 19613 6674 5 the the DT 19613 6674 6 translation translation NN 19613 6674 7 of of IN 19613 6674 8 the the DT 19613 6674 9 Septuagint Septuagint NNP 19613 6674 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6674 11 III iii CD 19613 6674 12 . . . 19613 6675 1 21 21 CD 19613 6675 2 . . . 19613 6676 1 4 4 LS 19613 6676 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6676 3 was be VBD 19613 6676 4 inspired inspire VBN 19613 6676 5 . . . 19613 6677 1 The the DT 19613 6677 2 repudiation repudiation NN 19613 6677 3 of of IN 19613 6677 4 different different JJ 19613 6677 5 kinds kind NNS 19613 6677 6 of of IN 19613 6677 7 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 6677 8 in in IN 19613 6677 9 the the DT 19613 6677 10 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 6677 11 likewise likewise RB 19613 6677 12 involved involve VBD 19613 6677 13 the the DT 19613 6677 14 rejection rejection NN 19613 6677 15 of of IN 19613 6677 16 all all PDT 19613 6677 17 the the DT 19613 6677 18 critical critical JJ 19613 6677 19 views view NNS 19613 6677 20 of of IN 19613 6677 21 the the DT 19613 6677 22 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 6677 23 that that WDT 19613 6677 24 were be VBD 19613 6677 25 concealed conceal VBN 19613 6677 26 behind behind IN 19613 6677 27 that that DT 19613 6677 28 assumption assumption NN 19613 6677 29 . . . 19613 6678 1 The the DT 19613 6678 2 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 6678 3 were be VBD 19613 6678 4 the the DT 19613 6678 5 first first JJ 19613 6678 6 who who WP 19613 6678 7 again again RB 19613 6678 8 to to IN 19613 6678 9 some some DT 19613 6678 10 extent extent NN 19613 6678 11 adopted adopt VBD 19613 6678 12 these these DT 19613 6678 13 critical critical JJ 19613 6678 14 principles principle NNS 19613 6678 15 . . . 19613 6678 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6679 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6679 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6679 3 513 513 CD 19613 6679 4 : : : 19613 6679 5 See see VB 19613 6679 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6679 7 . . . 19613 6680 1 II ii CD 19613 6680 2 . . . 19613 6681 1 10 10 CD 19613 6681 2 . . . 19613 6682 1 1 1 LS 19613 6682 2 : : : 19613 6682 3 II ii CD 19613 6682 4 . . . 19613 6683 1 27 27 CD 19613 6683 2 . . . 19613 6684 1 1 1 CD 19613 6684 2 , , , 19613 6684 3 2 2 CD 19613 6684 4 . . . 19613 6684 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6685 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6685 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6685 3 514 514 CD 19613 6685 4 : : : 19613 6685 5 See see VB 19613 6685 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6685 7 . . . 19613 6686 1 II ii CD 19613 6686 2 . . . 19613 6687 1 25 25 CD 19613 6687 2 . . . 19613 6688 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6688 2 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6689 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6689 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6689 3 515 515 CD 19613 6689 4 : : : 19613 6689 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6689 6 appropriates appropriate VBZ 19613 6689 7 the the DT 19613 6689 8 words word NNS 19613 6689 9 of of IN 19613 6689 10 an an DT 19613 6689 11 Asia Asia NNP 19613 6689 12 Minor Minor NNP 19613 6689 13 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 6689 14 when when WRB 19613 6689 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6689 16 says say VBZ 19613 6689 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6689 18 IV IV NNP 19613 6689 19 . . . 19613 6690 1 31 31 CD 19613 6690 2 . . . 19613 6691 1 1 1 LS 19613 6691 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6691 3 : : : 19613 6691 4 " " `` 19613 6691 5 De de VB 19613 6691 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6691 7 quidem quidem NN 19613 6691 8 delictis delictis NNP 19613 6691 9 , , , 19613 6691 10 de de NNP 19613 6691 11 quibus quibus NNP 19613 6691 12 ipsæ ipsæ NNP 19613 6691 13 scripturæ scripturæ NNPS 19613 6691 14 increpant increpant JJ 19613 6691 15 patriarchas patriarchas NNP 19613 6691 16 et et NN 19613 6691 17 prophetas prophetas NN 19613 6691 18 , , , 19613 6691 19 nos nos NNP 19613 6691 20 non non AFX 19613 6691 21 oportere oportere JJ 19613 6691 22 exprobare exprobare VBP 19613 6691 23 eis eis NNP 19613 6691 24 ... ... NFP 19613 6691 25 de de NNP 19613 6691 26 quibus quibus NNP 19613 6691 27 autem autem NNP 19613 6691 28 scripturæ scripturæ NNP 19613 6691 29 non non AFX 19613 6691 30 inciepant inciepant NN 19613 6691 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6691 32 scil scil NN 19613 6691 33 . . . 19613 6692 1 delictis delictis VB 19613 6692 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6692 3 , , , 19613 6692 4 sed sed NNP 19613 6692 5 simpliciter simpliciter NN 19613 6692 6 sunt sunt NN 19613 6692 7 positæ positæ NNP 19613 6692 8 , , , 19613 6692 9 nos nos NNP 19613 6692 10 non non AFX 19613 6692 11 debere debere NNP 19613 6692 12 fieri fieri NNP 19613 6692 13 accusatores accusatores NNPS 19613 6692 14 , , , 19613 6692 15 sed sed NNP 19613 6692 16 typum typum VBD 19613 6692 17 quærere quærere RB 19613 6692 18 . . . 19613 6692 19 " " '' 19613 6692 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6693 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6693 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6693 3 516 516 CD 19613 6693 4 : : : 19613 6693 5 See see VB 19613 6693 6 , , , 19613 6693 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 6693 8 , , , 19613 6693 9 IV IV NNP 19613 6693 10 . . . 19613 6694 1 20 20 CD 19613 6694 2 . . . 19613 6695 1 12 12 CD 19613 6695 2 where where WRB 19613 6695 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6695 4 declares declare VBZ 19613 6695 5 the the DT 19613 6695 6 three three CD 19613 6695 7 spies spy NNS 19613 6695 8 whom whom WP 19613 6695 9 Rahab Rahab NNP 19613 6695 10 entertained entertain VBD 19613 6695 11 to to TO 19613 6695 12 be be VB 19613 6695 13 Father Father NNP 19613 6695 14 , , , 19613 6695 15 Son Son NNP 19613 6695 16 . . . 19613 6696 1 and and CC 19613 6696 2 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6696 3 . . . 19613 6696 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6697 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6697 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6697 3 517 517 CD 19613 6697 4 : : : 19613 6697 5 See see VB 19613 6697 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6697 7 . . . 19613 6698 1 IV IV NNP 19613 6698 2 . . . 19613 6699 1 22 22 CD 19613 6699 2 . . . 19613 6700 1 1 1 LS 19613 6700 2 . . . 19613 6700 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6701 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6701 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6701 3 518 518 CD 19613 6701 4 : : : 19613 6701 5 See see VB 19613 6701 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6701 7 . . . 19613 6702 1 III iii CD 19613 6702 2 . . . 19613 6703 1 17 17 CD 19613 6703 2 . . . 19613 6704 1 3 3 LS 19613 6704 2 . . . 19613 6704 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6705 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6705 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6705 3 519 519 CD 19613 6705 4 : : : 19613 6705 5 Justin Justin NNP 19613 6705 6 had have VBD 19613 6705 7 already already RB 19613 6705 8 noted note VBN 19613 6705 9 certain certain JJ 19613 6705 10 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 19613 6705 11 of of IN 19613 6705 12 the the DT 19613 6705 13 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6705 14 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 6705 15 as as IN 19613 6705 16 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 6705 17 from from IN 19613 6705 18 profane profane NN 19613 6705 19 writings writing NNS 19613 6705 20 . . . 19613 6706 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6706 2 speaks speak VBZ 19613 6706 3 of of IN 19613 6706 4 two two CD 19613 6706 5 _ _ NNP 19613 6706 6 proprietates proprietate VBZ 19613 6706 7 iudaicæ iudaicæ NNS 19613 6706 8 literaturæ literaturæ NNP 19613 6706 9 _ _ NNP 19613 6706 10 in in IN 19613 6706 11 adv adv NN 19613 6706 12 . . . 19613 6707 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6707 2 . . . 19613 6708 1 III iii CD 19613 6708 2 . . . 19613 6709 1 5 5 CD 19613 6709 2 . . . 19613 6710 1 6 6 CD 19613 6710 2 . . . 19613 6711 1 But but CC 19613 6711 2 the the DT 19613 6711 3 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 6711 4 were be VBD 19613 6711 5 the the DT 19613 6711 6 first first JJ 19613 6711 7 to to TO 19613 6711 8 propound propound VB 19613 6711 9 any any DT 19613 6711 10 kind kind NN 19613 6711 11 of of IN 19613 6711 12 complete complete JJ 19613 6711 13 theories theory NNS 19613 6711 14 of of IN 19613 6711 15 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 6711 16 . . . 19613 6711 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6712 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6712 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6712 3 520 520 CD 19613 6712 4 : : : 19613 6712 5 See see VB 19613 6712 6 above above IN 19613 6712 7 p. p. NN 19613 6712 8 233 233 CD 19613 6712 9 , , , 19613 6712 10 note note VB 19613 6712 11 2 2 CD 19613 6712 12 , , , 19613 6712 13 Kunze Kunze NNP 19613 6712 14 , , , 19613 6712 15 l.c l.c NNP 19613 6712 16 . . NNP 19613 6712 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6713 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6713 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6713 3 521 521 CD 19613 6713 4 : : : 19613 6713 5 See see VB 19613 6713 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6713 7 , , , 19613 6713 8 II II NNP 19613 6713 9 . . . 19613 6714 1 26 26 CD 19613 6714 2 . . . 19613 6715 1 1 1 CD 19613 6715 2 , , , 19613 6715 3 13 13 CD 19613 6715 4 . . . 19613 6716 1 4 4 LS 19613 6716 2 : : : 19613 6716 3 " " `` 19613 6716 4 Sic Sic NNP 19613 6716 5 et et NNP 19613 6716 6 in in IN 19613 6716 7 reliquis reliquis NNP 19613 6716 8 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 6716 9 nulli nulli NNP 19613 6716 10 similis similis NNP 19613 6716 11 erit erit NNP 19613 6716 12 omnium omnium NNP 19613 6716 13 pater pater NN 19613 6716 14 hominum hominum NNP 19613 6716 15 pusillitati pusillitati NNP 19613 6716 16 : : : 19613 6716 17 et et NNP 19613 6716 18 dicitur dicitur NNP 19613 6716 19 quidem quidem NNP 19613 6716 20 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6716 21 hæc hæc NNP 19613 6716 22 propter propter NNP 19613 6716 23 delectionem delectionem NNP 19613 6716 24 , , , 19613 6716 25 sentitur sentitur NNP 19613 6716 26 autem autem NNP 19613 6716 27 super super NNP 19613 6716 28 hæc hæc NNP 19613 6716 29 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6716 30 magnitudinem magnitudinem NNP 19613 6716 31 . . . 19613 6716 32 " " '' 19613 6717 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6717 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 6717 3 says say VBZ 19613 6717 4 that that IN 19613 6717 5 God God NNP 19613 6717 6 can can MD 19613 6717 7 not not RB 19613 6717 8 be be VB 19613 6717 9 known know VBN 19613 6717 10 as as IN 19613 6717 11 regards regard VBZ 19613 6717 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6717 13 greatness greatness NN 19613 6717 14 , , , 19613 6717 15 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6718 1 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 6718 2 , , , 19613 6718 3 but but CC 19613 6718 4 that that IN 19613 6718 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6718 6 can can MD 19613 6718 7 be be VB 19613 6718 8 known know VBN 19613 6718 9 as as IN 19613 6718 10 regards regard VBZ 19613 6718 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6718 12 love love NN 19613 6718 13 , , , 19613 6718 14 IV IV NNP 19613 6718 15 . . . 19613 6719 1 20 20 CD 19613 6719 2 . . . 19613 6720 1 1 1 LS 19613 6720 2 : : : 19613 6720 3 " " `` 19613 6720 4 Igitur Igitur NNP 19613 6720 5 secundum secundum NN 19613 6720 6 magnitudem magnitudem NNP 19613 6720 7 non non AFX 19613 6720 8 est est NNP 19613 6720 9 cognoscere cognoscere NNP 19613 6720 10 deum deum NNP 19613 6720 11 , , , 19613 6720 12 impossibile impossibile JJ 19613 6720 13 est est NNP 19613 6720 14 enim enim NNP 19613 6720 15 mensurari mensurari NNP 19613 6720 16 patrem patrem NNP 19613 6720 17 ; ; : 19613 6720 18 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6720 19 autem autem NNP 19613 6720 20 dilectionem dilectionem NNP 19613 6720 21 eius eius NNP 19613 6720 22 -- -- : 19613 6720 23 hæc hæc NNP 19613 6720 24 est est NNP 19613 6720 25 enim enim NNP 19613 6720 26 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6720 27 nos nos NNP 19613 6720 28 per per IN 19613 6720 29 verbum verbum NNP 19613 6720 30 eius eius NNP 19613 6720 31 perducit perducit NNP 19613 6720 32 ad ad NNP 19613 6720 33 deum deum NNP 19613 6720 34 -- -- : 19613 6720 35 obedientes obediente VBZ 19613 6720 36 ei ei NNP 19613 6720 37 semper semper NNP 19613 6720 38 discimus discimus NNP 19613 6720 39 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 6720 40 est est NNP 19613 6720 41 tantus tantus NNP 19613 6720 42 deus deu VBZ 19613 6720 43 etc etc FW 19613 6720 44 . . . 19613 6721 1 " " `` 19613 6721 2 ; ; : 19613 6721 3 in in IN 19613 6721 4 IV IV NNP 19613 6721 5 . . . 19613 6722 1 20 20 CD 19613 6722 2 . . . 19613 6723 1 4 4 LS 19613 6723 2 the the DT 19613 6723 3 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6723 4 of of IN 19613 6723 5 God God NNP 19613 6723 6 " " '' 19613 6723 7 secundum secundum NN 19613 6723 8 dilectionem dilectionem NNP 19613 6723 9 " " '' 19613 6723 10 is be VBZ 19613 6723 11 more more RBR 19613 6723 12 closely closely RB 19613 6723 13 defined define VBN 19613 6723 14 by by IN 19613 6723 15 the the DT 19613 6723 16 words word NNS 19613 6723 17 " " `` 19613 6723 18 per per IN 19613 6723 19 verbum verbum NN 19613 6723 20 eius eius NN 19613 6723 21 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 6723 22 Christum Christum NNP 19613 6723 23 . . . 19613 6723 24 " " '' 19613 6724 1 The the DT 19613 6724 2 statements statement NNS 19613 6724 3 in in IN 19613 6724 4 § § CD 19613 6724 5 § § CD 19613 6724 6 5 5 CD 19613 6724 7 and and CC 19613 6724 8 6 6 CD 19613 6724 9 are be VBP 19613 6724 10 , , , 19613 6724 11 however however RB 19613 6724 12 , , , 19613 6724 13 specially specially RB 19613 6724 14 important important JJ 19613 6724 15 : : : 19613 6724 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6724 17 who who WP 19613 6724 18 are be VBP 19613 6724 19 pure pure JJ 19613 6724 20 in in IN 19613 6724 21 heart heart NN 19613 6724 22 will will MD 19613 6724 23 see see VB 19613 6724 24 God God NNP 19613 6724 25 . . . 19613 6725 1 God God NNP 19613 6725 2 's 's POS 19613 6725 3 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 6725 4 and and CC 19613 6725 5 goodness goodness NN 19613 6725 6 remove remove VBP 19613 6725 7 the the DT 19613 6725 8 impossibility impossibility NN 19613 6725 9 of of IN 19613 6725 10 man man NN 19613 6725 11 knowing know VBG 19613 6725 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6725 13 . . . 19613 6726 1 Man man NN 19613 6726 2 comes come VBZ 19613 6726 3 to to TO 19613 6726 4 know know VB 19613 6726 5 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6726 6 gradually gradually RB 19613 6726 7 , , , 19613 6726 8 in in IN 19613 6726 9 proportion proportion NN 19613 6726 10 as as IN 19613 6726 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6726 12 is be VBZ 19613 6726 13 revealed reveal VBN 19613 6726 14 and and CC 19613 6726 15 through through IN 19613 6726 16 love love NN 19613 6726 17 , , , 19613 6726 18 until until IN 19613 6726 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6726 20 beholds behold VBZ 19613 6726 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6726 22 in in IN 19613 6726 23 a a DT 19613 6726 24 state state NN 19613 6726 25 of of IN 19613 6726 26 perfection perfection NN 19613 6726 27 . . . 19613 6727 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6727 2 must must MD 19613 6727 3 be be VB 19613 6727 4 in in IN 19613 6727 5 God God NNP 19613 6727 6 in in IN 19613 6727 7 order order NN 19613 6727 8 to to TO 19613 6727 9 know know VB 19613 6727 10 God God NNP 19613 6727 11 : : : 19613 6727 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6727 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6727 14 : : : 19613 6727 15 hôsper hôsper NNP 19613 6727 16 hoi hoi NNP 19613 6727 17 blepontes bleponte NNS 19613 6727 18 to to TO 19613 6727 19 phôs phôs VB 19613 6727 20 entos entos NNP 19613 6727 21 eisi eisi NNP 19613 6727 22 tou tou NNP 19613 6727 23 phôtos phôtos NNP 19613 6727 24 kai kai NNP 19613 6727 25 tês tês NNP 19613 6727 26 lamprotêtos lamprotêtos NNP 19613 6727 27 autou autou NNP 19613 6727 28 metechousin metechousin NNP 19613 6727 29 , , , 19613 6727 30 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 6727 31 hoi hoi NNP 19613 6727 32 blepontes bleponte NNS 19613 6727 33 ton ton VBP 19613 6727 34 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6727 35 entos entos NNP 19613 6727 36 eisi eisi RB 19613 6727 37 tou tou NNP 19613 6727 38 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6727 39 , , , 19613 6727 40 metechontes metechonte NNS 19613 6727 41 autou autou VBZ 19613 6727 42 tês tês JJ 19613 6727 43 lamprotêtos lamprotêto NNS 19613 6727 44 . . . 19613 6728 1 Kai Kai NNP 19613 6728 2 dia dia NNP 19613 6728 3 touto touto NNP 19613 6728 4 ho ho NNP 19613 6728 5 achôrêtos achôrêtos NNP 19613 6728 6 kai kai NNP 19613 6728 7 akatalêptos akatalêptos NNP 19613 6728 8 kai kai NNP 19613 6728 9 aoratos aoratos NNP 19613 6728 10 horômenon horômenon NNP 19613 6728 11 heauton heauton NNP 19613 6728 12 ... ... NFP 19613 6728 13 tois tois NNP 19613 6728 14 pistois pistois NNP 19613 6728 15 pareschen pareschen NNP 19613 6728 16 , , , 19613 6728 17 hina hina NNP 19613 6728 18 zôopoiêsê zôopoiêsê NNP 19613 6728 19 tous tous NNP 19613 6728 20 chôrountas chôrountas NNP 19613 6728 21 kai kai NNP 19613 6728 22 blepontas blepontas NNP 19613 6728 23 auton auton NNP 19613 6728 24 dia dia NNP 19613 6728 25 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 6728 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6728 27 . . . 19613 6729 1 See see VB 19613 6729 2 also also RB 19613 6729 3 what what WP 19613 6729 4 follows follow VBZ 19613 6729 5 down down RP 19613 6729 6 to to IN 19613 6729 7 the the DT 19613 6729 8 words word NNS 19613 6729 9 : : : 19613 6729 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6729 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6729 12 : : : 19613 6729 13 metochê metochê NNP 19613 6729 14 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6729 15 esti esti NN 19613 6729 16 to to IN 19613 6729 17 ginôskein ginôskein NNP 19613 6729 18 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6729 19 kai kai NNP 19613 6729 20 apolauein apolauein NNP 19613 6729 21 tês tês NNP 19613 6729 22 chrêstotêtos chrêstotêtos NNP 19613 6729 23 autou autou NNP 19613 6729 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6729 25 , , , 19613 6729 26 et et NNP 19613 6729 27 homines homines NNP 19613 6729 28 igitur igitur NNP 19613 6729 29 videbunt videbunt NNP 19613 6729 30 deum deum NNP 19613 6729 31 , , , 19613 6729 32 ut ut UH 19613 6729 33 vivant vivant JJ 19613 6729 34 , , , 19613 6729 35 per per IN 19613 6729 36 visionem visionem NNP 19613 6729 37 immortales immortale NNS 19613 6729 38 facti facti NNP 19613 6729 39 et et FW 19613 6729 40 pertingentes pertingente NNS 19613 6729 41 usque usque JJ 19613 6729 42 in in IN 19613 6729 43 deum deum NN 19613 6729 44 . . . 19613 6730 1 Sentences sentence NNS 19613 6730 2 of of IN 19613 6730 3 this this DT 19613 6730 4 kind kind NN 19613 6730 5 where where WRB 19613 6730 6 rationalism rationalism NN 19613 6730 7 is be VBZ 19613 6730 8 neutralised neutralise VBN 19613 6730 9 by by IN 19613 6730 10 mysticism mysticism NN 19613 6730 11 we -PRON- PRP 19613 6730 12 seek seek VBP 19613 6730 13 for for IN 19613 6730 14 in in IN 19613 6730 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6730 16 in in IN 19613 6730 17 vain vain NN 19613 6730 18 . . . 19613 6730 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6731 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6731 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6731 3 522 522 CD 19613 6731 4 : : : 19613 6731 5 See see VB 19613 6731 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6731 7 . . . 19613 6731 8 , , , 19613 6731 9 IV IV NNP 19613 6731 10 . . . 19613 6732 1 6 6 CD 19613 6732 2 . . . 19613 6733 1 4 4 LS 19613 6733 2 : : : 19613 6733 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6733 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6733 5 : : : 19613 6733 6 Edidaxen Edidaxen NNP 19613 6733 7 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 6733 8 ho ho NNP 19613 6733 9 kurios kurio VBZ 19613 6733 10 , , , 19613 6733 11 hoti hoti NNP 19613 6733 12 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6733 13 eidenai eidenai NNP 19613 6733 14 oudeis oudeis UH 19613 6733 15 dunatai dunatai NN 19613 6733 16 , , , 19613 6733 17 mê mê NNP 19613 6733 18 ouchi ouchi JJ 19613 6733 19 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6733 20 didaxantos didaxanto NNS 19613 6733 21 , , , 19613 6733 22 toutestin toutestin NN 19613 6733 23 , , , 19613 6733 24 aneu aneu RB 19613 6733 25 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6733 26 mê mê NNP 19613 6733 27 ginôskesthai ginôskesthai NNP 19613 6733 28 ton ton NN 19613 6733 29 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6733 30 ; ; : 19613 6733 31 auto auto NN 19613 6733 32 de de NNP 19613 6733 33 to to IN 19613 6733 34 ginôskesthai ginôskesthai NNP 19613 6733 35 ton ton NNP 19613 6733 36 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6733 37 thelêma thelêma NNP 19613 6733 38 einai einai NNP 19613 6733 39 tou tou NNP 19613 6733 40 patros patros NNP 19613 6733 41 , , , 19613 6733 42 Gnôsontai Gnôsontai NNP 19613 6733 43 gar gar NNP 19613 6733 44 auton auton NNP 19613 6733 45 hois hois NNP 19613 6733 46 an an DT 19613 6733 47 apokalupsê apokalupsê NN 19613 6733 48 ho ho NNP 19613 6733 49 huios huios NNP 19613 6733 50 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6733 51 . . . 19613 6733 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6734 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6734 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6734 3 523 523 CD 19613 6734 4 : : : 19613 6734 5 Iren iren JJ 19613 6734 6 . . . 19613 6735 1 II ii CD 19613 6735 2 . . . 19613 6736 1 6 6 CD 19613 6736 2 . . . 19613 6737 1 1 1 CD 19613 6737 2 , , , 19613 6737 3 9 9 CD 19613 6737 4 . . . 19613 6738 1 1 1 CD 19613 6738 2 , , , 19613 6738 3 27 27 CD 19613 6738 4 . . . 19613 6739 1 2 2 LS 19613 6739 2 : : : 19613 6739 3 III iii CD 19613 6739 4 . . . 19613 6740 1 25 25 CD 19613 6740 2 . . . 19613 6741 1 1 1 LS 19613 6741 2 : : : 19613 6741 3 " " `` 19613 6741 4 Providentiam Providentiam NNP 19613 6741 5 habet habet NN 19613 6741 6 deus deu VBZ 19613 6741 7 omnium omnium NN 19613 6741 8 propter propter NN 19613 6741 9 hoc hoc FW 19613 6741 10 et et NNP 19613 6741 11 consilium consilium NN 19613 6741 12 dat dat NN 19613 6741 13 : : : 19613 6741 14 consilium consilium NN 19613 6741 15 autem autem NN 19613 6741 16 dans dan NNS 19613 6741 17 adest adest VBP 19613 6741 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6741 19 , , , 19613 6741 20 qui qui NNP 19613 6741 21 morum morum NNP 19613 6741 22 providentiam providentiam NNP 19613 6741 23 habent habent NNP 19613 6741 24 . . . 19613 6742 1 Necesse Necesse NNP 19613 6742 2 est est VBD 19613 6742 3 igitur igitur VB 19613 6742 4 ea ea NN 19613 6742 5 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6742 6 providentur providentur NNP 19613 6742 7 et et NNP 19613 6742 8 gubernantur gubernantur NNP 19613 6742 9 cognoscere cognoscere NNP 19613 6742 10 suum suum NNP 19613 6742 11 directorem directorem NNP 19613 6742 12 ; ; : 19613 6742 13 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6742 14 quidem quidem NNP 19613 6742 15 non non AFX 19613 6742 16 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6742 17 irrationalia irrationalia NNP 19613 6742 18 neque neque NNP 19613 6742 19 vana vana NNP 19613 6742 20 , , , 19613 6742 21 sed sed NNP 19613 6742 22 habent habent NNP 19613 6742 23 sensibilitatem sensibilitatem NNP 19613 6742 24 perceptam perceptam NNP 19613 6742 25 de de NNP 19613 6742 26 providentia providentia NNP 19613 6742 27 dei dei NNP 19613 6742 28 . . . 19613 6743 1 Et et NN 19613 6743 2 propter propter NN 19613 6743 3 hoc hoc FW 19613 6743 4 ethnicorum ethnicorum NNP 19613 6743 5 quidam quidam NNP 19613 6743 6 , , , 19613 6743 7 qui qui NNP 19613 6743 8 minus minus CC 19613 6743 9 illecebris illecebris NNP 19613 6743 10 ac ac NNP 19613 6743 11 voluptatibus voluptatibus NNP 19613 6743 12 servierunt servierunt NNP 19613 6743 13 , , , 19613 6743 14 et et FW 19613 6743 15 non non JJ 19613 6743 16 in in IN 19613 6743 17 tantum tantum NNP 19613 6743 18 superstitione superstitione NNP 19613 6743 19 idolorum idolorum NNP 19613 6743 20 coabducti coabducti NNP 19613 6743 21 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6743 22 , , , 19613 6743 23 providentia providentia NNP 19613 6743 24 eius eius NNP 19613 6743 25 moti moti NNP 19613 6743 26 licet licet NNP 19613 6743 27 tenuiter tenuiter NNP 19613 6743 28 , , , 19613 6743 29 tamen tamen NNP 19613 6743 30 conversi conversi NNP 19613 6743 31 sunt sunt NNP 19613 6743 32 , , , 19613 6743 33 ut ut UH 19613 6743 34 dicererit dicererit NNP 19613 6743 35 fabricatorem fabricatorem NNP 19613 6743 36 huiuss huiuss NNP 19613 6743 37 universitatis universitatis NNP 19613 6743 38 patrem patrem NN 19613 6743 39 omnium omnium NNP 19613 6743 40 providentem providentem NNP 19613 6743 41 et et NNP 19613 6743 42 disponentem disponentem NNP 19613 6743 43 secundum secundum NNP 19613 6743 44 nos nos NNP 19613 6743 45 mundum mundum NNP 19613 6743 46 . . . 19613 6743 47 " " '' 19613 6744 1 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6744 2 . . NNP 19613 6744 3 , , , 19613 6744 4 de de NNP 19613 6744 5 testim testim NNP 19613 6744 6 . . . 19613 6745 1 animæ animæ NNP 19613 6745 2 ; ; : 19613 6745 3 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 6745 4 . . . 19613 6746 1 17 17 CD 19613 6746 2 . . . 19613 6746 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6747 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6747 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6747 3 524 524 CD 19613 6747 4 : : : 19613 6747 5 See see VB 19613 6747 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6747 7 . . . 19613 6747 8 , , , 19613 6747 9 IV IV NNP 19613 6747 10 . . . 19613 6748 1 6 6 CD 19613 6748 2 . . . 19613 6749 1 2 2 LS 19613 6749 2 ; ; : 19613 6749 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6749 4 . . NNP 19613 6749 5 , , , 19613 6749 6 adv adv NNP 19613 6749 7 . . . 19613 6750 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6750 2 . . . 19613 6751 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6751 2 , , , 19613 6751 3 II II NNP 19613 6751 4 . . . 19613 6751 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6752 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6752 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6752 3 525 525 CD 19613 6752 4 : : : 19613 6752 5 See see VB 19613 6752 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6752 7 . . . 19613 6752 8 , , , 19613 6752 9 V. V. NNP 19613 6752 10 26 26 CD 19613 6752 11 . . . 19613 6753 1 2 2 LS 19613 6753 2 . . . 19613 6753 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6754 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6754 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6754 3 526 526 CD 19613 6754 4 : : : 19613 6754 5 See see VB 19613 6754 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6754 7 . . . 19613 6754 8 , , , 19613 6754 9 II II NNP 19613 6754 10 . . . 19613 6755 1 1 1 LS 19613 6755 2 . . . 19613 6756 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6756 2 and and CC 19613 6756 3 the the DT 19613 6756 4 Hymn Hymn NNP 19613 6756 5 II II NNP 19613 6756 6 . . . 19613 6757 1 30 30 CD 19613 6757 2 . . . 19613 6758 1 9 9 CD 19613 6758 2 . . . 19613 6758 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6759 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6759 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6759 3 527 527 CD 19613 6759 4 : : : 19613 6759 5 See see VB 19613 6759 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6759 7 . . . 19613 6759 8 , , , 19613 6759 9 III iii CD 19613 6759 10 . . . 19613 6760 1 8 8 LS 19613 6760 2 . . . 19613 6761 1 3 3 LS 19613 6761 2 . . . 19613 6762 1 Very very RB 19613 6762 2 pregnant pregnant JJ 19613 6762 3 are be VBP 19613 6762 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6762 5 ' ' POS 19613 6762 6 utterances utterance NNS 19613 6762 7 in in IN 19613 6762 8 II II NNP 19613 6762 9 . . . 19613 6763 1 34 34 CD 19613 6763 2 . . . 19613 6764 1 4 4 CD 19613 6764 2 and and CC 19613 6764 3 II II NNP 19613 6764 4 . . . 19613 6765 1 30 30 CD 19613 6765 2 . . . 19613 6766 1 9 9 LS 19613 6766 2 : : : 19613 6766 3 " " `` 19613 6766 4 Principari principari JJ 19613 6766 5 enim enim NNP 19613 6766 6 debet debet NN 19613 6766 7 in in IN 19613 6766 8 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 6766 9 et et NNP 19613 6766 10 dominari dominari NNP 19613 6766 11 voluntas voluntas NNP 19613 6766 12 dei dei NNP 19613 6766 13 , , , 19613 6766 14 reliqua reliqua NNP 19613 6766 15 autem autem NNP 19613 6766 16 omnia omnia NNP 19613 6766 17 huic huic NNP 19613 6766 18 cedere cedere NNP 19613 6766 19 et et NNP 19613 6766 20 subdita subdita NNP 19613 6766 21 esse esse NNP 19613 6766 22 et et NNP 19613 6766 23 in in IN 19613 6766 24 servitium servitium NN 19613 6766 25 dedita dedita NN 19613 6766 26 " " '' 19613 6766 27 ... ... : 19613 6766 28 " " '' 19613 6766 29 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6766 30 omnium omnium NNP 19613 6766 31 voluntas voluntas NNP 19613 6766 32 dei dei NNP 19613 6766 33 ; ; : 19613 6766 34 " " `` 19613 6766 35 see see VB 19613 6766 36 also also RB 19613 6766 37 the the DT 19613 6766 38 fragment fragment NN 19613 6766 39 V. V. NNP 19613 6766 40 in in IN 19613 6766 41 Harvey Harvey NNP 19613 6766 42 , , , 19613 6766 43 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6766 44 . . . 19613 6766 45 , , , 19613 6766 46 Opp Opp NNP 19613 6766 47 . . . 19613 6767 1 II ii CD 19613 6767 2 . . . 19613 6768 1 p. p. NN 19613 6768 2 477 477 CD 19613 6768 3 sq sq NN 19613 6768 4 . . . 19613 6769 1 Because because IN 19613 6769 2 everything everything NN 19613 6769 3 originates originate VBZ 19613 6769 4 with with IN 19613 6769 5 God God NNP 19613 6769 6 and and CC 19613 6769 7 the the DT 19613 6769 8 existence existence NN 19613 6769 9 of of IN 19613 6769 10 eternal eternal JJ 19613 6769 11 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 19613 6769 12 contrasts contrast NNS 19613 6769 13 is be VBZ 19613 6769 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 6769 15 impossible impossible JJ 19613 6769 16 the the DT 19613 6769 17 following following JJ 19613 6769 18 proposition proposition NN 19613 6769 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6769 20 IV IV NNP 19613 6769 21 . . . 19613 6770 1 2 2 CD 19613 6770 2 , , , 19613 6770 3 4 4 CD 19613 6770 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6770 5 , , , 19613 6770 6 which which WDT 19613 6770 7 is be VBZ 19613 6770 8 proved prove VBN 19613 6770 9 from from IN 19613 6770 10 the the DT 19613 6770 11 parable parable NN 19613 6770 12 of of IN 19613 6770 13 the the DT 19613 6770 14 rich rich JJ 19613 6770 15 man man NN 19613 6770 16 and and CC 19613 6770 17 Lazarus Lazarus NNP 19613 6770 18 , , , 19613 6770 19 holds hold VBZ 19613 6770 20 , , , 19613 6770 21 good good NN 19613 6770 22 : : : 19613 6770 23 " " `` 19613 6770 24 ex ex NNP 19613 6770 25 una una NNP 19613 6770 26 substantia substantia NNS 19613 6770 27 esse esse NNP 19613 6770 28 omnia omnia NNP 19613 6770 29 , , , 19613 6770 30 i -PRON- PRP 19613 6770 31 d d VBD 19613 6770 32 est est VBD 19613 6770 33 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 6770 34 et et NNP 19613 6770 35 Moysem Moysem NNP 19613 6770 36 et et NNP 19613 6770 37 prophetas prophetas NN 19613 6770 38 , , , 19613 6770 39 etiam etiam NNP 19613 6770 40 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 6770 41 dominum dominum NNP 19613 6770 42 . . . 19613 6770 43 " " '' 19613 6770 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6771 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6771 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6771 3 528 528 CD 19613 6771 4 : : : 19613 6771 5 See see VB 19613 6771 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6771 7 . . . 19613 6772 1 II ii CD 19613 6772 2 . . . 19613 6773 1 28 28 CD 19613 6773 2 . . . 19613 6774 1 4 4 CD 19613 6774 2 , , , 19613 6774 3 5 5 CD 19613 6774 4 : : : 19613 6774 5 IV IV NNP 19613 6774 6 . . . 19613 6775 1 11 11 CD 19613 6775 2 . . . 19613 6776 1 2 2 LS 19613 6776 2 . . . 19613 6776 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6777 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6777 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6777 3 529 529 CD 19613 6777 4 : : : 19613 6777 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6777 6 also also RB 19613 6777 7 makes make VBZ 19613 6777 8 the the DT 19613 6777 9 same same JJ 19613 6777 10 demand demand NN 19613 6777 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6777 12 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 6778 1 adv adv NNP 19613 6778 2 . . . 19613 6779 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6779 2 . . . 19613 6780 1 II ii CD 19613 6780 2 . . . 19613 6781 1 27 27 CD 19613 6781 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6781 3 ; ; : 19613 6781 4 for for IN 19613 6781 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6781 6 assertion assertion NN 19613 6781 7 " " `` 19613 6781 8 deum deum NNP 19613 6781 9 corpus corpus NNP 19613 6781 10 esse esse NN 19613 6781 11 " " '' 19613 6781 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6781 13 adv adv NNP 19613 6781 14 . . . 19613 6782 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6782 2 . . . 19613 6783 1 7 7 LS 19613 6783 2 : : : 19613 6783 3 " " `` 19613 6783 4 Quis Quis NNP 19613 6783 5 enim enim NNP 19613 6783 6 negabil negabil NNP 19613 6783 7 , , , 19613 6783 8 deum deum NNP 19613 6783 9 corpus corpus NNP 19613 6783 10 esse esse NNP 19613 6783 11 , , , 19613 6783 12 etsi etsi NNP 19613 6783 13 deus deus NNP 19613 6783 14 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 6783 15 est est NNP 19613 6783 16 ? ? . 19613 6784 1 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 6784 2 enim enim NNP 19613 6784 3 corpus corpus NNP 19613 6784 4 sui sui NNP 19613 6784 5 generis generis NNP 19613 6784 6 in in IN 19613 6784 7 sua sua NNP 19613 6784 8 effigie effigie NNP 19613 6784 9 " " '' 19613 6784 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6784 11 must must MD 19613 6784 12 be be VB 19613 6784 13 compared compare VBN 19613 6784 14 with with IN 19613 6784 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6784 16 realistic realistic JJ 19613 6784 17 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6784 18 of of IN 19613 6784 19 the the DT 19613 6784 20 soul soul NN 19613 6784 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6784 22 de de FW 19613 6784 23 anima anima NNP 19613 6784 24 6 6 CD 19613 6784 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6784 26 as as RB 19613 6784 27 well well RB 19613 6784 28 as as IN 19613 6784 29 with with IN 19613 6784 30 the the DT 19613 6784 31 proposition proposition NN 19613 6784 32 formulated formulate VBN 19613 6784 33 in in IN 19613 6784 34 de de NNP 19613 6784 35 carne carne NNP 19613 6784 36 11 11 CD 19613 6784 37 : : : 19613 6784 38 " " `` 19613 6784 39 omne omne NNP 19613 6784 40 quod quod NN 19613 6784 41 est est NNP 19613 6784 42 , , , 19613 6784 43 corpus corpus NNP 19613 6784 44 est est NNP 19613 6784 45 sui sui NNP 19613 6784 46 generis generis NNP 19613 6784 47 ; ; : 19613 6784 48 nihil nihil NNP 19613 6784 49 est est NNP 19613 6784 50 incorporale incorporale NNP 19613 6784 51 , , , 19613 6784 52 nisi nisi NNP 19613 6784 53 quod quod NN 19613 6784 54 non non AFX 19613 6784 55 est est NNP 19613 6784 56 . . . 19613 6784 57 " " '' 19613 6785 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6785 2 here here RB 19613 6785 3 followed follow VBD 19613 6785 4 a a DT 19613 6785 5 principle principle NN 19613 6785 6 of of IN 19613 6785 7 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 6785 8 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 6785 9 , , , 19613 6785 10 and and CC 19613 6785 11 in in IN 19613 6785 12 this this DT 19613 6785 13 case case NN 19613 6785 14 by by IN 19613 6785 15 no no DT 19613 6785 16 means means NN 19613 6785 17 wished wish VBD 19613 6785 18 to to TO 19613 6785 19 teach teach VB 19613 6785 20 that that IN 19613 6785 21 the the DT 19613 6785 22 Deity Deity NNP 19613 6785 23 has have VBZ 19613 6785 24 a a DT 19613 6785 25 human human JJ 19613 6785 26 form form NN 19613 6785 27 , , , 19613 6785 28 since since IN 19613 6785 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6785 30 recognised recognise VBD 19613 6785 31 that that DT 19613 6785 32 man man NN 19613 6785 33 's 's POS 19613 6785 34 likeness likeness NN 19613 6785 35 to to IN 19613 6785 36 God God NNP 19613 6785 37 consists consist VBZ 19613 6785 38 merely merely RB 19613 6785 39 in in IN 19613 6785 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6785 41 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 6785 42 qualities quality NNS 19613 6785 43 . . . 19613 6786 1 On on IN 19613 6786 2 the the DT 19613 6786 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 6786 4 _ _ NNP 19613 6786 5 Melito Melito NNP 19613 6786 6 _ _ NNP 19613 6786 7 ascribed ascribe VBD 19613 6786 8 to to IN 19613 6786 9 God God NNP 19613 6786 10 a a DT 19613 6786 11 corporeal corporeal JJ 19613 6786 12 existence existence NN 19613 6786 13 of of IN 19613 6786 14 a a DT 19613 6786 15 higher high JJR 19613 6786 16 type type NN 19613 6786 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6786 18 Eusebius eusebius NN 19613 6786 19 mentions mention VBZ 19613 6786 20 a a DT 19613 6786 21 work work NN 19613 6786 22 of of IN 19613 6786 23 this this DT 19613 6786 24 bishop bishop NN 19613 6786 25 under under IN 19613 6786 26 the the DT 19613 6786 27 title title NN 19613 6786 28 " " '' 19613 6786 29 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6786 30 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6786 31 : : : 19613 6786 32 ho ho NNP 19613 6786 33 peri peri NNP 19613 6786 34 ensômatou ensômatou VBZ 19613 6786 35 Theou Theou NNP 19613 6786 36 logos logos NNP 19613 6786 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6786 38 , , , 19613 6786 39 " " '' 19613 6786 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6786 41 and and CC 19613 6786 42 Origen Origen NNP 19613 6786 43 reckoned reckon VBD 19613 6786 44 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6786 45 among among IN 19613 6786 46 the the DT 19613 6786 47 teachers teacher NNS 19613 6786 48 who who WP 19613 6786 49 recognised recognise VBD 19613 6786 50 that that DT 19613 6786 51 man man NN 19613 6786 52 had have VBD 19613 6786 53 also also RB 19613 6786 54 a a DT 19613 6786 55 likeness likeness NN 19613 6786 56 to to IN 19613 6786 57 God God NNP 19613 6786 58 in in IN 19613 6786 59 form form NN 19613 6786 60 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6786 61 in in IN 19613 6786 62 body body NN 19613 6786 63 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6786 64 ; ; : 19613 6786 65 see see VB 19613 6786 66 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6786 67 Texte Texte NNP 19613 6786 68 und und NN 19613 6786 69 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 6786 70 I. i. NN 19613 6787 1 1 1 LS 19613 6787 2 . . . 19613 6788 1 2 2 CD 19613 6788 2 , , , 19613 6788 3 pp pp NNP 19613 6788 4 . . . 19613 6789 1 243 243 CD 19613 6789 2 , , , 19613 6789 3 248 248 CD 19613 6789 4 . . . 19613 6790 1 In in IN 19613 6790 2 the the DT 19613 6790 3 second second JJ 19613 6790 4 century century NN 19613 6790 5 the the DT 19613 6790 6 realistic realistic JJ 19613 6790 7 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 6790 8 ideas idea NNS 19613 6790 9 no no RB 19613 6790 10 doubt doubt RB 19613 6790 11 continued continue VBD 19613 6790 12 to to TO 19613 6790 13 foster foster VB 19613 6790 14 in in IN 19613 6790 15 wide wide JJ 19613 6790 16 circles circle NNS 19613 6790 17 the the DT 19613 6790 18 popular popular JJ 19613 6790 19 idea idea NN 19613 6790 20 that that WDT 19613 6790 21 God God NNP 19613 6790 22 had have VBD 19613 6790 23 a a DT 19613 6790 24 form form NN 19613 6790 25 and and CC 19613 6790 26 a a DT 19613 6790 27 kind kind NN 19613 6790 28 of of IN 19613 6790 29 corporeal corporeal JJ 19613 6790 30 existence existence NN 19613 6790 31 . . . 19613 6791 1 A a DT 19613 6791 2 middle middle JJ 19613 6791 3 position position NN 19613 6791 4 between between IN 19613 6791 5 these these DT 19613 6791 6 ideas idea NNS 19613 6791 7 and and CC 19613 6791 8 that that DT 19613 6791 9 of of IN 19613 6791 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6791 11 and and CC 19613 6791 12 the the DT 19613 6791 13 Stoics Stoics NNPS 19613 6791 14 seems seem VBZ 19613 6791 15 to to TO 19613 6791 16 have have VB 19613 6791 17 been be VBN 19613 6791 18 taken take VBN 19613 6791 19 up up RP 19613 6791 20 by by IN 19613 6791 21 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 19613 6791 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6791 23 _ _ NNP 19613 6791 24 Instit Instit NNP 19613 6791 25 . . . 19613 6792 1 div div NNP 19613 6792 2 . . . 19613 6792 3 _ _ NNP 19613 6792 4 VII VII NNP 19613 6792 5 . . . 19613 6793 1 9 9 CD 19613 6793 2 , , , 19613 6793 3 21 21 CD 19613 6793 4 ; ; : 19613 6793 5 de de NNP 19613 6793 6 ira ira NNP 19613 6793 7 dei dei NNP 19613 6793 8 2 2 CD 19613 6793 9 . . . 19613 6794 1 18 18 CD 19613 6794 2 . . . 19613 6794 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6794 4 . . . 19613 6794 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6795 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6795 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6795 3 530 530 CD 19613 6795 4 : : : 19613 6795 5 See see VB 19613 6795 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6795 7 . . . 19613 6795 8 , , , 19613 6795 9 III iii CD 19613 6795 10 . . . 19613 6796 1 25 25 CD 19613 6796 2 . . . 19613 6797 1 2 2 LS 19613 6797 2 ; ; : 19613 6797 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6797 4 . . NNP 19613 6797 5 , , , 19613 6797 6 adv adv NNP 19613 6797 7 . . . 19613 6798 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6798 2 . . . 19613 6799 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6800 1 23 23 CD 19613 6800 2 - - SYM 19613 6800 3 28 28 CD 19613 6800 4 : : : 19613 6800 5 II ii CD 19613 6800 6 . . . 19613 6801 1 11 11 CD 19613 6801 2 sq sq NN 19613 6801 3 . . . 19613 6802 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6802 2 briefly briefly RB 19613 6802 3 defined define VBD 19613 6802 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6802 5 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6802 6 of of IN 19613 6802 7 God God NNP 19613 6802 8 in in IN 19613 6802 9 Phil Phil NNP 19613 6802 10 . . . 19613 6803 1 X. X. NNP 19613 6804 1 32 32 CD 19613 6804 2 . . . 19613 6805 1 The the DT 19613 6805 2 advance advance NN 19613 6805 3 beyond beyond IN 19613 6805 4 the the DT 19613 6805 5 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 6805 6 ' ' POS 19613 6805 7 idea idea NN 19613 6805 8 of of IN 19613 6805 9 God God NNP 19613 6805 10 consists consist VBZ 19613 6805 11 not not RB 19613 6805 12 only only RB 19613 6805 13 in in IN 19613 6805 14 the the DT 19613 6805 15 thorough thorough JJ 19613 6805 16 discussion discussion NN 19613 6805 17 of of IN 19613 6805 18 God God NNP 19613 6805 19 's 's POS 19613 6805 20 attributes attribute NNS 19613 6805 21 of of IN 19613 6805 22 goodness goodness NN 19613 6805 23 and and CC 19613 6805 24 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 6805 25 , , , 19613 6805 26 but but CC 19613 6805 27 also also RB 19613 6805 28 in in IN 19613 6805 29 the the DT 19613 6805 30 view view NN 19613 6805 31 , , , 19613 6805 32 which which WDT 19613 6805 33 is be VBZ 19613 6805 34 now now RB 19613 6805 35 much much RB 19613 6805 36 more more RBR 19613 6805 37 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 6805 38 worked work VBN 19613 6805 39 out out RP 19613 6805 40 , , , 19613 6805 41 that that IN 19613 6805 42 the the DT 19613 6805 43 Almighty Almighty NNP 19613 6805 44 Creator Creator NNP 19613 6805 45 has have VBZ 19613 6805 46 no no DT 19613 6805 47 other other JJ 19613 6805 48 purpose purpose NN 19613 6805 49 in in IN 19613 6805 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6805 51 world world NN 19613 6805 52 than than IN 19613 6805 53 the the DT 19613 6805 54 salvation salvation NN 19613 6805 55 of of IN 19613 6805 56 mankind mankind NN 19613 6805 57 . . . 19613 6806 1 See see VB 19613 6806 2 the the DT 19613 6806 3 10th 10th JJ 19613 6806 4 Greek greek JJ 19613 6806 5 fragment fragment NN 19613 6806 6 of of IN 19613 6806 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6806 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6806 9 Harvey Harvey NNP 19613 6806 10 , , , 19613 6806 11 II II NNP 19613 6806 12 . . . 19613 6807 1 p. p. NN 19613 6807 2 480 480 CD 19613 6807 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6807 4 ; ; : 19613 6807 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6807 6 . . NNP 19613 6807 7 , , , 19613 6807 8 de de FW 19613 6807 9 orat orat NNP 19613 6807 10 . . . 19613 6808 1 4 4 LS 19613 6808 2 : : : 19613 6808 3 " " `` 19613 6808 4 Summa summa JJ 19613 6808 5 est est NNP 19613 6808 6 voluntatis voluntatis VB 19613 6808 7 dei dei NNP 19613 6808 8 salus salus NNP 19613 6808 9 eorum eorum NN 19613 6808 10 , , , 19613 6808 11 quos quos NNP 19613 6808 12 adoptavit adoptavit NNP 19613 6808 13 " " '' 19613 6808 14 ; ; : 19613 6808 15 de de NNP 19613 6808 16 paenit paenit NNP 19613 6808 17 . . . 19613 6809 1 2 2 LS 19613 6809 2 : : : 19613 6809 3 " " `` 19613 6809 4 Bonorum Bonorum NNP 19613 6809 5 dei dei NNP 19613 6809 6 unus unus IN 19613 6809 7 est est NNP 19613 6809 8 titulus titulus NN 19613 6809 9 , , , 19613 6809 10 salus salus NNP 19613 6809 11 hominum hominum NNP 19613 6809 12 " " '' 19613 6809 13 ; ; : 19613 6809 14 adv adv NNP 19613 6809 15 . . . 19613 6810 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6810 2 . . . 19613 6811 1 II ii CD 19613 6811 2 . . . 19613 6812 1 27 27 CD 19613 6812 2 : : : 19613 6812 3 " " `` 19613 6812 4 Nihil Nihil NNP 19613 6812 5 tam tam NNP 19613 6812 6 dignum dignum NNP 19613 6812 7 deo deo NNP 19613 6812 8 quam quam NNP 19613 6812 9 salus salus NNP 19613 6812 10 hominis hominis NNP 19613 6812 11 . . . 19613 6812 12 " " '' 19613 6813 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 6813 2 had have VBD 19613 6813 3 here here RB 19613 6813 4 undeniably undeniably RB 19613 6813 5 learned learn VBN 19613 6813 6 from from IN 19613 6813 7 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6813 8 ; ; : 19613 6813 9 see see VB 19613 6813 10 adv adv NN 19613 6813 11 . . . 19613 6814 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6814 2 . . . 19613 6815 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6816 1 17 17 CD 19613 6816 2 . . . 19613 6817 1 In in IN 19613 6817 2 the the DT 19613 6817 3 first first JJ 19613 6817 4 chapters chapter NNS 19613 6817 5 of of IN 19613 6817 6 the the DT 19613 6817 7 work work NN 19613 6817 8 de de FW 19613 6817 9 orat orat NNP 19613 6817 10 . . . 19613 6817 11 , , , 19613 6817 12 however however RB 19613 6817 13 , , , 19613 6817 14 in in IN 19613 6817 15 which which WDT 19613 6817 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6817 17 expounds expound VBZ 19613 6817 18 the the DT 19613 6817 19 Lord Lord NNP 19613 6817 20 's 's POS 19613 6817 21 Prayer prayer NN 19613 6817 22 , , , 19613 6817 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6817 24 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 6817 25 in in IN 19613 6817 26 unfolding unfold VBG 19613 6817 27 the the DT 19613 6817 28 meaning meaning NN 19613 6817 29 of of IN 19613 6817 30 the the DT 19613 6817 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 6817 32 in in IN 19613 6817 33 a a DT 19613 6817 34 way way NN 19613 6817 35 such such JJ 19613 6817 36 as as IN 19613 6817 37 was be VBD 19613 6817 38 never never RB 19613 6817 39 possible possible JJ 19613 6817 40 for for IN 19613 6817 41 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6817 42 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 6817 43 . . . 19613 6818 1 The the DT 19613 6818 2 like like JJ 19613 6818 3 remark remark NN 19613 6818 4 may may MD 19613 6818 5 be be VB 19613 6818 6 made make VBN 19613 6818 7 of of IN 19613 6818 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 6818 9 's 's POS 19613 6818 10 work work NN 19613 6818 11 de de FW 19613 6818 12 orat orat NNP 19613 6818 13 . . NNP 19613 6818 14 , , , 19613 6818 15 and and CC 19613 6818 16 , , , 19613 6818 17 in in IN 19613 6818 18 general general JJ 19613 6818 19 , , , 19613 6818 20 in in IN 19613 6818 21 the the DT 19613 6818 22 case case NN 19613 6818 23 of of IN 19613 6818 24 most most JJS 19613 6818 25 authors author NNS 19613 6818 26 who who WP 19613 6818 27 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 6818 28 the the DT 19613 6818 29 Lord Lord NNP 19613 6818 30 's 's POS 19613 6818 31 Prayer Prayer NNP 19613 6818 32 in in IN 19613 6818 33 the the DT 19613 6818 34 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 6818 35 period period NN 19613 6818 36 . . . 19613 6819 1 This this DT 19613 6819 2 prayer prayer NN 19613 6819 3 kept keep VBD 19613 6819 4 alive alive JJ 19613 6819 5 the the DT 19613 6819 6 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 6819 7 of of IN 19613 6819 8 the the DT 19613 6819 9 deepest deep JJS 19613 6819 10 meaning meaning NN 19613 6819 11 of of IN 19613 6819 12 the the DT 19613 6819 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 6819 14 . . . 19613 6819 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6820 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6820 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6820 3 531 531 CD 19613 6820 4 : : : 19613 6820 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 6820 6 . . . 19613 6821 1 21 21 CD 19613 6821 2 : : : 19613 6821 3 " " `` 19613 6821 4 Necesse Necesse NNP 19613 6821 5 et et NNP 19613 6821 6 igitur igitur NNP 19613 6821 7 pauca pauca NN 19613 6821 8 de de IN 19613 6821 9 Christo Christo NNP 19613 6821 10 ut ut UH 19613 6821 11 deo deo NN 19613 6821 12 ... ... : 19613 6821 13 Jam Jam NNP 19613 6821 14 ediximus ediximus NNP 19613 6821 15 deum deum NNP 19613 6821 16 universitatem universitatem NNP 19613 6821 17 hanc hanc NNP 19613 6821 18 mundi mundi NNP 19613 6821 19 verbo verbo NNP 19613 6821 20 et et NNP 19613 6821 21 ratione ratione JJ 19613 6821 22 et et NNP 19613 6821 23 virtute virtute JJ 19613 6821 24 molitum molitum NN 19613 6821 25 . . . 19613 6822 1 Apud Apud NNP 19613 6822 2 vestros vestros IN 19613 6822 3 quoque quoque NN 19613 6822 4 sapientes sapiente VBZ 19613 6822 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6822 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6822 7 : : : 19613 6822 8 Logon Logon NNP 19613 6822 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6822 10 , , , 19613 6822 11 i -PRON- PRP 19613 6822 12 d d VBD 19613 6822 13 est est NNP 19613 6822 14 sermonem sermonem NNP 19613 6822 15 et et NNP 19613 6822 16 rationem rationem NNP 19613 6822 17 , , , 19613 6822 18 constat constat NNP 19613 6822 19 artificem artificem NNP 19613 6822 20 videri videri NNP 19613 6822 21 universitatis universitatis NNP 19613 6822 22 . . . 19613 6822 23 " " '' 19613 6823 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6823 2 An an DT 19613 6823 3 appeal appeal NN 19613 6823 4 to to IN 19613 6823 5 Zeno Zeno NNP 19613 6823 6 and and CC 19613 6823 7 Cleanthes Cleanthes NNP 19613 6823 8 follows follow VBZ 19613 6823 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6823 10 . . . 19613 6824 1 " " `` 19613 6824 2 Et et NN 19613 6824 3 nos nos RB 19613 6824 4 autem autem NNP 19613 6824 5 sermoni sermoni NNP 19613 6824 6 atque atque NNP 19613 6824 7 rationi rationi NNP 19613 6824 8 itemque itemque NNP 19613 6824 9 virtuti virtuti NNP 19613 6824 10 , , , 19613 6824 11 per per IN 19613 6824 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6824 13 omnia omnia NNP 19613 6824 14 molitum molitum NNP 19613 6824 15 deum deum NNP 19613 6824 16 ediximus ediximus NNP 19613 6824 17 , , , 19613 6824 18 propriam propriam NNP 19613 6824 19 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 6824 20 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 6824 21 inscribimus inscribimus NNP 19613 6824 22 , , , 19613 6824 23 cui cui NNP 19613 6824 24 et et NNP 19613 6824 25 sermo sermo NNP 19613 6824 26 insit insit NNP 19613 6824 27 pronuntianti pronuntianti NNP 19613 6824 28 et et NNP 19613 6824 29 ratio ratio NN 19613 6824 30 adsit adsit NNP 19613 6824 31 disponenti disponenti NNP 19613 6824 32 et et NNP 19613 6824 33 virtus virtus NNP 19613 6824 34 præsit præsit NNP 19613 6824 35 perficienti perficienti NNP 19613 6824 36 . . . 19613 6825 1 Hunc Hunc NNP 19613 6825 2 ex ex NNP 19613 6825 3 deo deo NNP 19613 6825 4 prolatum prolatum NN 19613 6825 5 didicimus didicimus NNP 19613 6825 6 et et NNP 19613 6825 7 prolatione prolatione NNP 19613 6825 8 generatum generatum NNP 19613 6825 9 et et NNP 19613 6825 10 idcirco idcirco NNP 19613 6825 11 filium filium NNP 19613 6825 12 dei dei NNP 19613 6825 13 et et NNP 19613 6825 14 deum deum NNP 19613 6825 15 dictum dictum NNP 19613 6825 16 ex ex FW 19613 6825 17 unitate unitate JJ 19613 6825 18 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 6825 19 , , , 19613 6825 20 nam nam NNP 19613 6825 21 et et NNP 19613 6825 22 deus deus NNP 19613 6825 23 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 6825 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6825 25 that that RB 19613 6825 26 is is RB 19613 6825 27 , , , 19613 6825 28 the the DT 19613 6825 29 antemundane antemundane NN 19613 6825 30 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6825 31 is be VBZ 19613 6825 32 the the DT 19613 6825 33 Son Son NNP 19613 6825 34 of of IN 19613 6825 35 God God NNP 19613 6825 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6825 37 . . . 19613 6826 1 Et Et NNP 19613 6826 2 cum cum NNP 19613 6826 3 radius radius NNP 19613 6826 4 ex ex NNP 19613 6826 5 sole sole NNP 19613 6826 6 porrigitur porrigitur NNP 19613 6826 7 , , , 19613 6826 8 portio portio NNP 19613 6826 9 ex ex NNP 19613 6826 10 summa summa NNP 19613 6826 11 ; ; : 19613 6826 12 sed sed NNP 19613 6826 13 sol sol NNP 19613 6826 14 erit erit NNP 19613 6826 15 in in IN 19613 6826 16 radio radio NN 19613 6826 17 , , , 19613 6826 18 quia quia NNP 19613 6826 19 solis solis NNP 19613 6826 20 est est NNP 19613 6826 21 radius radius NNP 19613 6826 22 nec nec NNP 19613 6826 23 separatur separatur NNP 19613 6826 24 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6826 25 sed sed NNP 19613 6826 26 extenditur extenditur NNP 19613 6826 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6826 28 cf cf NN 19613 6826 29 . . . 19613 6827 1 adv adv NNP 19613 6827 2 . . . 19613 6828 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6828 2 . . . 19613 6829 1 8) 8) CD 19613 6829 2 . . . 19613 6830 1 Ita Ita NNP 19613 6830 2 de de NNP 19613 6830 3 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 6830 4 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 6830 5 et et FW 19613 6830 6 deo deo NNP 19613 6830 7 deus deus NNP 19613 6830 8 ut ut NNP 19613 6830 9 lumen lumen NNP 19613 6830 10 de de NNP 19613 6830 11 lumine lumine NNP 19613 6830 12 accensum accensum NNP 19613 6830 13 . . . 19613 6831 1 Manet manet NN 19613 6831 2 integra integra NNS 19613 6831 3 et et FW 19613 6831 4 indefecta indefecta NNP 19613 6831 5 materiæ materiæ NNP 19613 6831 6 matrix matrix NNP 19613 6831 7 , , , 19613 6831 8 etsi etsi NNP 19613 6831 9 plures plure VBZ 19613 6831 10 inde inde JJ 19613 6831 11 traduces traduce NNS 19613 6831 12 qualitatis qualitatis NNP 19613 6831 13 mutueris mutueris NNP 19613 6831 14 : : : 19613 6831 15 ita ita NNP 19613 6831 16 et et NNP 19613 6831 17 quod quod NN 19613 6831 18 de de NNP 19613 6831 19 deo deo NNP 19613 6831 20 profectum profectum NN 19613 6831 21 est est NNP 19613 6831 22 , , , 19613 6831 23 deus deus NNP 19613 6831 24 est est NNP 19613 6831 25 et et NNP 19613 6831 26 dei dei NNP 19613 6831 27 filius filius NNP 19613 6831 28 et et NNP 19613 6831 29 unus unus NNP 19613 6831 30 ambo ambo NNP 19613 6831 31 . . . 19613 6832 1 Ita Ita NNP 19613 6832 2 et et FW 19613 6832 3 de de IN 19613 6832 4 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 6832 5 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 6832 6 et et FW 19613 6832 7 de de NNP 19613 6832 8 deo deo NNP 19613 6832 9 deus deus NNP 19613 6832 10 modulo modulo NNP 19613 6832 11 alternum alternum NNP 19613 6832 12 numerum numerum NNP 19613 6832 13 , , , 19613 6832 14 gradu gradu NNP 19613 6832 15 non non NNP 19613 6832 16 statu statu NNP 19613 6832 17 fecit fecit NNP 19613 6832 18 , , , 19613 6832 19 et et FW 19613 6832 20 a a DT 19613 6832 21 matrice matrice NN 19613 6832 22 non non AFX 19613 6832 23 necessit necessit NN 19613 6832 24 sed sed NNP 19613 6832 25 excessit excessit NNP 19613 6832 26 . . . 19613 6833 1 Iste Iste NNP 19613 6833 2 igitur igitur NN 19613 6833 3 dei dei NNP 19613 6833 4 radius radius NN 19613 6833 5 , , , 19613 6833 6 ut ut NNP 19613 6833 7 retro retro NNP 19613 6833 8 semper semper NNP 19613 6833 9 prædicabatur prædicabatur NN 19613 6833 10 , , , 19613 6833 11 delapsus delapsus NNP 19613 6833 12 in in IN 19613 6833 13 virginem virginem NNP 19613 6833 14 quandam quandam NNP 19613 6833 15 et et NNP 19613 6833 16 in in IN 19613 6833 17 utero utero NNP 19613 6833 18 eius eius NNP 19613 6833 19 caro caro NNP 19613 6833 20 figuratus figuratus NNP 19613 6833 21 nascitur nascitur NNP 19613 6833 22 homo homo NNP 19613 6833 23 deo deo NNP 19613 6833 24 mixtus mixtus NNP 19613 6833 25 . . . 19613 6834 1 Caro Caro NNP 19613 6834 2 spiritu spiritu VBD 19613 6834 3 instructa instructa NN 19613 6834 4 nutritur nutritur NN 19613 6834 5 , , , 19613 6834 6 adolescit adolescit NNP 19613 6834 7 , , , 19613 6834 8 adfatur adfatur NN 19613 6834 9 , , , 19613 6834 10 docet docet NN 19613 6834 11 , , , 19613 6834 12 operatur operatur NN 19613 6834 13 et et NNP 19613 6834 14 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6834 15 est est VBD 19613 6834 16 . . . 19613 6834 17 " " '' 19613 6835 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6835 2 adds add VBZ 19613 6835 3 : : : 19613 6835 4 " " `` 19613 6835 5 Recipite Recipite NNP 19613 6835 6 interim interim JJ 19613 6835 7 hanc hanc NNP 19613 6835 8 fabulam fabulam NNP 19613 6835 9 , , , 19613 6835 10 similis similis NNP 19613 6835 11 est est NNP 19613 6835 12 vestris vestris NNP 19613 6835 13 . . . 19613 6835 14 " " '' 19613 6836 1 As as IN 19613 6836 2 a a DT 19613 6836 3 matter matter NN 19613 6836 4 of of IN 19613 6836 5 fact fact NN 19613 6836 6 the the DT 19613 6836 7 heathen heathen NN 19613 6836 8 must must MD 19613 6836 9 have have VB 19613 6836 10 viewed view VBN 19613 6836 11 this this DT 19613 6836 12 statement statement NN 19613 6836 13 as as IN 19613 6836 14 a a DT 19613 6836 15 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 6836 16 speculation speculation NN 19613 6836 17 with with IN 19613 6836 18 a a DT 19613 6836 19 mythological mythological JJ 19613 6836 20 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 6836 21 . . . 19613 6837 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6837 2 is be VBZ 19613 6837 3 very very RB 19613 6837 4 instructive instructive JJ 19613 6837 5 to to TO 19613 6837 6 ascertain ascertain VB 19613 6837 7 that that IN 19613 6837 8 in in IN 19613 6837 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6837 10 ' ' POS 19613 6837 11 book book NN 19613 6837 12 against against IN 19613 6837 13 Noëtus Noëtus NNP 19613 6837 14 " " `` 19613 6837 15 the the DT 19613 6837 16 setting setting NN 19613 6837 17 forth forth RB 19613 6837 18 of of IN 19613 6837 19 the the DT 19613 6837 20 truth truth NN 19613 6837 21 " " '' 19613 6837 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6837 23 c. c. NNP 19613 6837 24 10 10 CD 19613 6837 25 ff ff NNP 19613 6837 26 . . . 19613 6837 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6838 1 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6838 2 begins begin VBZ 19613 6838 3 with with IN 19613 6838 4 the the DT 19613 6838 5 proposition proposition NN 19613 6838 6 : : : 19613 6838 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6838 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6838 9 : : : 19613 6838 10 Theos Theos NNP 19613 6838 11 eboulêthê eboulêthê NNP 19613 6838 12 kosmon kosmon NNP 19613 6838 13 ktisai ktisai NNP 19613 6838 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6838 15 . . . 19613 6839 1 The the DT 19613 6839 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6839 3 whose whose WP$ 19613 6839 4 essence essence NN 19613 6839 5 and and CC 19613 6839 6 working working NN 19613 6839 7 are be VBP 19613 6839 8 described describe VBN 19613 6839 9 merely merely RB 19613 6839 10 went go VBD 19613 6839 11 forth forth RB 19613 6839 12 to to TO 19613 6839 13 realise realise VB 19613 6839 14 this this DT 19613 6839 15 intention intention NN 19613 6839 16 . . . 19613 6839 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6840 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6840 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6840 3 532 532 CD 19613 6840 4 : : : 19613 6840 5 See see VB 19613 6840 6 Hagemann Hagemann NNP 19613 6840 7 , , , 19613 6840 8 Die Die NNP 19613 6840 9 römische römische NN 19613 6840 10 Kirche Kirche NNP 19613 6840 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6840 12 1864 1864 CD 19613 6840 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6840 14 , , , 19613 6840 15 p. p. NN 19613 6840 16 172 172 CD 19613 6840 17 ff ff NNP 19613 6840 18 . . . 19613 6840 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6841 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6841 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6841 3 533 533 CD 19613 6841 4 : : : 19613 6841 5 See see VB 19613 6841 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6841 7 detailed detailed JJ 19613 6841 8 exposition exposition NN 19613 6841 9 of of IN 19613 6841 10 the the DT 19613 6841 11 _ _ NNP 19613 6841 12 orthodox orthodox NN 19613 6841 13 _ _ NNP 19613 6841 14 side side NN 19613 6841 15 of of IN 19613 6841 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6841 17 's 's POS 19613 6841 18 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6841 19 of of IN 19613 6841 20 the the DT 19613 6841 21 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 6841 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6841 23 " " `` 19613 6841 24 orthodox orthodox NN 19613 6841 25 " " '' 19613 6841 26 in in IN 19613 6841 27 the the DT 19613 6841 28 later later JJ 19613 6841 29 sense sense NN 19613 6841 30 of of IN 19613 6841 31 the the DT 19613 6841 32 word word NN 19613 6841 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6841 34 , , , 19613 6841 35 in in IN 19613 6841 36 Vol Vol NNP 19613 6841 37 . . . 19613 6842 1 IV IV NNP 19613 6842 2 . . . 19613 6843 1 There there RB 19613 6843 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6843 3 is be VBZ 19613 6843 4 also also RB 19613 6843 5 shown show VBN 19613 6843 6 that that IN 19613 6843 7 these these DT 19613 6843 8 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6843 9 were be VBD 19613 6843 10 due due JJ 19613 6843 11 to to IN 19613 6843 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6843 13 's 's POS 19613 6843 14 _ _ NNP 19613 6843 15 juristic juristic NN 19613 6843 16 _ _ NNP 19613 6843 17 bias bias NN 19613 6843 18 . . . 19613 6844 1 The the DT 19613 6844 2 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 6844 3 , , , 19613 6844 4 " " '' 19613 6844 5 una una NNP 19613 6844 6 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 7 substantia substantia NN 19613 6844 8 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 9 , , , 19613 6844 10 tres tre NNS 19613 6844 11 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 12 personæ personæ NN 19613 6844 13 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 14 " " `` 19613 6844 15 , , , 19613 6844 16 never never RB 19613 6844 17 alternates alternate NNS 19613 6844 18 in in IN 19613 6844 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6844 20 case case NN 19613 6844 21 with with IN 19613 6844 22 the the DT 19613 6844 23 others other NNS 19613 6844 24 , , , 19613 6844 25 " " '' 19613 6844 26 una una NNP 19613 6844 27 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 28 natura natura NNP 19613 6844 29 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 30 , , , 19613 6844 31 tres tre NNS 19613 6844 32 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 33 personæ personæ NN 19613 6844 34 _ _ NNP 19613 6844 35 " " '' 19613 6844 36 ; ; : 19613 6844 37 and and CC 19613 6844 38 so so RB 19613 6844 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6844 40 remained remain VBD 19613 6844 41 for for IN 19613 6844 42 a a DT 19613 6844 43 long long JJ 19613 6844 44 time time NN 19613 6844 45 in in IN 19613 6844 46 the the DT 19613 6844 47 West West NNP 19613 6844 48 ; ; : 19613 6844 49 they -PRON- PRP 19613 6844 50 did do VBD 19613 6844 51 not not RB 19613 6844 52 speak speak VB 19613 6844 53 of of IN 19613 6844 54 " " `` 19613 6844 55 natures nature NNS 19613 6844 56 " " '' 19613 6844 57 but but CC 19613 6844 58 of of IN 19613 6844 59 " " `` 19613 6844 60 substances substance NNS 19613 6844 61 " " '' 19613 6844 62 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6844 63 " " `` 19613 6844 64 nature nature NN 19613 6844 65 " " '' 19613 6844 66 in in IN 19613 6844 67 this this DT 19613 6844 68 connection connection NN 19613 6844 69 is be VBZ 19613 6844 70 very very RB 19613 6844 71 rare rare JJ 19613 6844 72 down down RP 19613 6844 73 to to IN 19613 6844 74 the the DT 19613 6844 75 5th 5th JJ 19613 6844 76 century century NN 19613 6844 77 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6844 78 . . . 19613 6845 1 What what WP 19613 6845 2 makes make VBZ 19613 6845 3 this this DT 19613 6845 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 6845 5 is be VBZ 19613 6845 6 the the DT 19613 6845 7 fact fact NN 19613 6845 8 that that IN 19613 6845 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6845 10 always always RB 19613 6845 11 uses use VBZ 19613 6845 12 " " `` 19613 6845 13 substance substance NN 19613 6845 14 " " '' 19613 6845 15 in in IN 19613 6845 16 the the DT 19613 6845 17 concrete concrete JJ 19613 6845 18 sense sense NN 19613 6845 19 " " `` 19613 6845 20 individual individual JJ 19613 6845 21 substance substance NN 19613 6845 22 " " '' 19613 6845 23 and and CC 19613 6845 24 has have VBZ 19613 6845 25 even even RB 19613 6845 26 expressed express VBN 19613 6845 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6845 28 precisely precisely RB 19613 6845 29 on on IN 19613 6845 30 the the DT 19613 6845 31 point point NN 19613 6845 32 . . . 19613 6846 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 6846 2 says say VBZ 19613 6846 3 in in IN 19613 6846 4 de de FW 19613 6846 5 anima anima NNP 19613 6846 6 32 32 CD 19613 6846 7 : : : 19613 6846 8 " " `` 19613 6846 9 aliud aliud NNPS 19613 6846 10 est est NNP 19613 6846 11 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6846 12 , , , 19613 6846 13 aliud aliud NNP 19613 6846 14 natura natura NNP 19613 6846 15 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 6846 16 ; ; , 19613 6846 17 siquidem siquidem NNP 19613 6846 18 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6846 19 propria propria NNP 19613 6846 20 est est NNP 19613 6846 21 rei rei NNP 19613 6846 22 cuiusque cuiusque NNP 19613 6846 23 , , , 19613 6846 24 natura natura NNP 19613 6846 25 vero vero NNP 19613 6846 26 potest potest NNP 19613 6846 27 esse esse NNP 19613 6846 28 communis communis NNP 19613 6846 29 . . . 19613 6847 1 Suscipe suscipe JJ 19613 6847 2 exemplum exemplum NN 19613 6847 3 : : : 19613 6847 4 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6847 5 est est NNP 19613 6847 6 lapis lapis NNP 19613 6847 7 , , , 19613 6847 8 ferrum ferrum NN 19613 6847 9 ; ; : 19613 6847 10 duritia duritia NNP 19613 6847 11 lapidis lapidis NNP 19613 6847 12 et et NNP 19613 6847 13 ferri ferri NNP 19613 6847 14 natura natura NNP 19613 6847 15 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 6847 16 est est NNP 19613 6847 17 . . . 19613 6848 1 Duritia Duritia NNP 19613 6848 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6848 3 natura natura NNP 19613 6848 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6848 5 communicat communicat NN 19613 6848 6 , , , 19613 6848 7 substantia substantia NN 19613 6848 8 discordat discordat NN 19613 6848 9 . . . 19613 6849 1 Mollitia mollitia NN 19613 6849 2 lanæ lanæ NN 19613 6849 3 , , , 19613 6849 4 mollitia mollitia NNP 19613 6849 5 plumæ plumæ NNP 19613 6849 6 pariant pariant NNP 19613 6849 7 naturalia naturalia NNP 19613 6849 8 eorum eorum NNP 19613 6849 9 , , , 19613 6849 10 substantiva substantiva FW 19613 6849 11 non non JJ 19613 6849 12 pariant pariant NN 19613 6849 13 ... ... . 19613 6850 1 Et et NN 19613 6850 2 tune tune NN 19613 6850 3 naturæ naturæ NNPS 19613 6850 4 similitudo similitudo NNP 19613 6850 5 notatur notatur NNP 19613 6850 6 , , , 19613 6850 7 cum cum NNP 19613 6850 8 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 6850 9 dissimilitudo dissimilitudo NNP 19613 6850 10 conspicitur conspicitur NN 19613 6850 11 . . . 19613 6851 1 Men men NN 19613 6851 2 and and CC 19613 6851 3 animals animal NNS 19613 6851 4 are be VBP 19613 6851 5 similar similar JJ 19613 6851 6 _ _ NNP 19613 6851 7 natura natura NNP 19613 6851 8 _ _ NNP 19613 6851 9 , , , 19613 6851 10 but but CC 19613 6851 11 not not RB 19613 6851 12 _ _ NNP 19613 6851 13 substantia substantia NN 19613 6851 14 _ _ NNP 19613 6851 15 . . . 19613 6851 16 " " '' 19613 6852 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 6852 2 see see VBP 19613 6852 3 that that IN 19613 6852 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6852 5 in in IN 19613 6852 6 so so RB 19613 6852 7 far far RB 19613 6852 8 as as IN 19613 6852 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6852 10 designated designate VBD 19613 6852 11 Father Father NNP 19613 6852 12 , , , 19613 6852 13 Son Son NNP 19613 6852 14 , , , 19613 6852 15 and and CC 19613 6852 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6852 17 as as IN 19613 6852 18 one one CD 19613 6852 19 substance substance NN 19613 6852 20 expressed express VBD 19613 6852 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6852 22 _ _ NNP 19613 6852 23 unity unity NN 19613 6852 24 _ _ NNP 19613 6852 25 as as RB 19613 6852 26 strongly strongly RB 19613 6852 27 as as IN 19613 6852 28 possible possible JJ 19613 6852 29 . . . 19613 6853 1 The the DT 19613 6853 2 only only JJ 19613 6853 3 idea idea NN 19613 6853 4 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 6853 5 to to IN 19613 6853 6 the the DT 19613 6853 7 majority majority NN 19613 6853 8 was be VBD 19613 6853 9 a a DT 19613 6853 10 juristic juristic JJ 19613 6853 11 and and CC 19613 6853 12 political political JJ 19613 6853 13 notion notion NN 19613 6853 14 , , , 19613 6853 15 viz viz NNP 19613 6853 16 . . NNP 19613 6853 17 , , , 19613 6853 18 that that IN 19613 6853 19 the the DT 19613 6853 20 Father Father NNP 19613 6853 21 , , , 19613 6853 22 who who WP 19613 6853 23 is be VBZ 19613 6853 24 the the DT 19613 6853 25 _ _ NNP 19613 6853 26 tota tota NNP 19613 6853 27 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6853 28 _ _ NNP 19613 6853 29 , , , 19613 6853 30 sends send VBZ 19613 6853 31 forth forth RB 19613 6853 32 officials official NNS 19613 6853 33 whom whom WP 19613 6853 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6853 35 entrusts entrust VBZ 19613 6853 36 with with IN 19613 6853 37 the the DT 19613 6853 38 administration administration NN 19613 6853 39 of of IN 19613 6853 40 the the DT 19613 6853 41 monarchy monarchy NN 19613 6853 42 . . . 19613 6854 1 The the DT 19613 6854 2 legal legal JJ 19613 6854 3 fiction fiction NN 19613 6854 4 attached attach VBN 19613 6854 5 to to IN 19613 6854 6 the the DT 19613 6854 7 concept concept NN 19613 6854 8 " " `` 19613 6854 9 person person NN 19613 6854 10 " " '' 19613 6854 11 aided aid VBN 19613 6854 12 in in IN 19613 6854 13 the the DT 19613 6854 14 matter matter NN 19613 6854 15 here here RB 19613 6854 16 . . . 19613 6854 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6855 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6855 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6855 3 534 534 CD 19613 6855 4 : : : 19613 6855 5 See see VB 19613 6855 6 adv adv NN 19613 6855 7 . . . 19613 6856 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6856 2 . . . 19613 6857 1 3 3 LS 19613 6857 2 : : : 19613 6857 3 " " `` 19613 6857 4 Igitur Igitur NNP 19613 6857 5 si si NNP 19613 6857 6 et et FW 19613 6857 7 monarchia monarchia NNP 19613 6857 8 divina divina NNP 19613 6857 9 per per IN 19613 6857 10 tot tot NNP 19613 6857 11 legiones legiones NNPS 19613 6857 12 et et NNP 19613 6857 13 exercitus exercitus NNP 19613 6857 14 angelorum angelorum NNP 19613 6857 15 administratur administratur NNP 19613 6857 16 , , , 19613 6857 17 sicut sicut NN 19613 6857 18 scriptum scriptum NN 19613 6857 19 est est NN 19613 6857 20 : : : 19613 6857 21 Milies milie NNS 19613 6857 22 centies centie VBZ 19613 6857 23 centena centena JJ 19613 6857 24 milia milium NNS 19613 6857 25 adsistebant adsistebant NNP 19613 6857 26 ei ei NNP 19613 6857 27 , , , 19613 6857 28 et et NNP 19613 6857 29 milies milie NNS 19613 6857 30 centena centena NNP 19613 6857 31 milia milia NNP 19613 6857 32 apparebant apparebant NNP 19613 6857 33 ei ei NNP 19613 6857 34 , , , 19613 6857 35 nec nec NNP 19613 6857 36 ideo ideo NNP 19613 6857 37 unius unius NNP 19613 6857 38 esse esse NNP 19613 6857 39 desiit desiit NNP 19613 6857 40 , , , 19613 6857 41 ut ut NNP 19613 6857 42 desinat desinat NNP 19613 6857 43 monarchia monarchia NNP 19613 6857 44 esse esse NNP 19613 6857 45 , , , 19613 6857 46 quia quia NNP 19613 6857 47 per per IN 19613 6857 48 tanta tanta NNP 19613 6857 49 milia milia NNP 19613 6857 50 virtutum virtutum NNP 19613 6857 51 procuratur procuratur NNP 19613 6857 52 : : : 19613 6857 53 quale quale NN 19613 6857 54 est est NNP 19613 6857 55 ut ut NNP 19613 6857 56 deus deus NNP 19613 6857 57 divisionem divisionem NNP 19613 6857 58 et et NNP 19613 6857 59 dispersionem dispersionem NNP 19613 6857 60 pati pati NNPS 19613 6857 61 videatur videatur NNP 19613 6857 62 in in IN 19613 6857 63 filio filio NNP 19613 6857 64 et et NNP 19613 6857 65 spiritu spiritu NNP 19613 6857 66 sancto sancto NNP 19613 6857 67 , , , 19613 6857 68 secundum secundum NN 19613 6857 69 et et NNP 19613 6857 70 tertium tertium NN 19613 6857 71 sortitis sortitis NNP 19613 6857 72 locum locum NNP 19613 6857 73 , , , 19613 6857 74 tam tam NNP 19613 6857 75 consortibus consortibus NNP 19613 6857 76 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 6857 77 patris patris NNP 19613 6857 78 , , , 19613 6857 79 quam quam NNP 19613 6857 80 non non AFX 19613 6857 81 patitur patitur NNP 19613 6857 82 in in IN 19613 6857 83 tot tot NNP 19613 6857 84 angelorum angelorum NNP 19613 6857 85 numero numero NNP 19613 6857 86 ? ? . 19613 6857 87 " " '' 19613 6858 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6858 2 ! ! . 19613 6858 3 ! ! . 19613 6858 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6859 1 c. c. NNP 19613 6859 2 4 4 CD 19613 6859 3 : : : 19613 6859 4 " " `` 19613 6859 5 Videmus Videmus NNP 19613 6859 6 igitur igitur NNP 19613 6859 7 non non NNP 19613 6859 8 obesse obesse NNP 19613 6859 9 monarchiæ monarchiæ NNP 19613 6859 10 filium filium NNP 19613 6859 11 , , , 19613 6859 12 etsi etsi NNP 19613 6859 13 hodie hodie NNP 19613 6859 14 apud apud NNP 19613 6859 15 filium filium NN 19613 6859 16 est est NNP 19613 6859 17 , , , 19613 6859 18 quia quia XX 19613 6859 19 et et NNP 19613 6859 20 in in IN 19613 6859 21 suo suo NNP 19613 6859 22 statu statu NNP 19613 6859 23 est est NNP 19613 6859 24 apud apud NNP 19613 6859 25 filium filium NNP 19613 6859 26 , , , 19613 6859 27 et et NNP 19613 6859 28 cum cum NNP 19613 6859 29 suo suo NNP 19613 6859 30 statu statu NNP 19613 6859 31 restituetur restituetur NNP 19613 6859 32 patri patri NNP 19613 6859 33 a a DT 19613 6859 34 filio filio NN 19613 6859 35 . . . 19613 6859 36 " " '' 19613 6860 1 L.c L.c NNP 19613 6860 2 . . . 19613 6861 1 : : : 19613 6861 2 " " `` 19613 6861 3 Monarchia Monarchia NNP 19613 6861 4 in in IN 19613 6861 5 tot tot NNP 19613 6861 6 nominibus nominibus NN 19613 6861 7 constituta constituta NN 19613 6861 8 est est NNP 19613 6861 9 , , , 19613 6861 10 in in IN 19613 6861 11 quot quot NNP 19613 6861 12 deus deus NNP 19613 6861 13 voluit voluit NNP 19613 6861 14 . . . 19613 6861 15 " " '' 19613 6861 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6862 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6862 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6862 3 535 535 CD 19613 6862 4 : : : 19613 6862 5 See see VB 19613 6862 6 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 6862 7 . . . 19613 6862 8 , , , 19613 6862 9 c. c. NNP 19613 6862 10 Noetum Noetum NNP 19613 6862 11 II II NNP 19613 6862 12 . . . 19613 6863 1 According accord VBG 19613 6863 2 to to IN 19613 6863 3 these these DT 19613 6863 4 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 6863 5 the the DT 19613 6863 6 unity unity NN 19613 6863 7 is be VBZ 19613 6863 8 sufficiently sufficiently RB 19613 6863 9 preserved preserve VBN 19613 6863 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6863 11 1 1 LS 19613 6863 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6863 13 if if IN 19613 6863 14 the the DT 19613 6863 15 separate separate JJ 19613 6863 16 persons person NNS 19613 6863 17 have have VBP 19613 6863 18 one one CD 19613 6863 19 and and CC 19613 6863 20 the the DT 19613 6863 21 same same JJ 19613 6863 22 substance substance NN 19613 6863 23 , , , 19613 6863 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6863 25 2 2 LS 19613 6863 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6863 27 if if IN 19613 6863 28 there there EX 19613 6863 29 is be VBZ 19613 6863 30 one one CD 19613 6863 31 possessor possessor NN 19613 6863 32 of of IN 19613 6863 33 the the DT 19613 6863 34 whole whole JJ 19613 6863 35 substance substance NN 19613 6863 36 , , , 19613 6863 37 _ _ NNP 19613 6863 38 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6863 39 _ _ NNP 19613 6863 40 , , , 19613 6863 41 if if IN 19613 6863 42 everything everything NN 19613 6863 43 proceeds proceed VBZ 19613 6863 44 from from IN 19613 6863 45 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6863 46 . . . 19613 6864 1 That that IN 19613 6864 2 this this DT 19613 6864 3 is be VBZ 19613 6864 4 a a DT 19613 6864 5 remnant remnant NN 19613 6864 6 of of IN 19613 6864 7 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 6864 8 ought ought MD 19613 6864 9 not not RB 19613 6864 10 to to TO 19613 6864 11 be be VB 19613 6864 12 disputed dispute VBN 19613 6864 13 . . . 19613 6864 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6865 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6865 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6865 3 536 536 CD 19613 6865 4 : : : 19613 6865 5 Adv Adv NNP 19613 6865 6 . . . 19613 6866 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6866 2 . . . 19613 6867 1 8 8 LS 19613 6867 2 : : : 19613 6867 3 " " `` 19613 6867 4 Hoc Hoc NNP 19613 6867 5 si si NN 19613 6867 6 qui qui NN 19613 6867 7 putaverit putaverit NN 19613 6867 8 , , , 19613 6867 9 me -PRON- PRP 19613 6867 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6867 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6867 12 : : : 19613 6867 13 probolên probolên NN 19613 6867 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6867 15 aliquam aliquam NNP 19613 6867 16 introducere introducere NNP 19613 6867 17 i -PRON- PRP 19613 6867 18 d d VBN 19613 6867 19 est est NNP 19613 6867 20 prolationem prolationem NNP 19613 6867 21 rei rei NNP 19613 6867 22 alterius alterius NNP 19613 6867 23 ex ex NNP 19613 6867 24 altera altera NNP 19613 6867 25 , , , 19613 6867 26 quod quod NN 19613 6867 27 facit facit JJ 19613 6867 28 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 6867 29 , , , 19613 6867 30 primo primo NNP 19613 6867 31 quidem quidem NNP 19613 6867 32 dicam dicam NNP 19613 6867 33 tibi tibi NN 19613 6867 34 , , , 19613 6867 35 non non AFX 19613 6867 36 ideo ideo NN 19613 6867 37 non non AFX 19613 6867 38 utatur utatur NNP 19613 6867 39 et et NNP 19613 6867 40 veritas verita VBD 19613 6867 41 vocabulo vocabulo NN 19613 6867 42 isto isto NNP 19613 6867 43 et et NNP 19613 6867 44 re re IN 19613 6867 45 ac ac IN 19613 6867 46 censu censu NNP 19613 6867 47 eius eius NNP 19613 6867 48 , , , 19613 6867 49 quia quia NNP 19613 6867 50 et et NNP 19613 6867 51 hæresis hæresis NNP 19613 6867 52 utitur utitur NNP 19613 6867 53 ; ; : 19613 6867 54 immo immo NNP 19613 6867 55 hæresis hæresis NN 19613 6867 56 potius potius NNP 19613 6867 57 ex ex NNP 19613 6867 58 veritate veritate NNP 19613 6867 59 accepit accepit NNP 19613 6867 60 quod quod NNP 19613 6867 61 ad ad NNP 19613 6867 62 mendacium mendacium NN 19613 6867 63 suum suum NNP 19613 6867 64 strueret strueret NNP 19613 6867 65 " " '' 19613 6867 66 ; ; : 19613 6867 67 cf cf NN 19613 6867 68 . . . 19613 6868 1 also also RB 19613 6868 2 what what WP 19613 6868 3 follows follow VBZ 19613 6868 4 . . . 19613 6869 1 Thus thus RB 19613 6869 2 far far RB 19613 6869 3 then then RB 19613 6869 4 theologians theologian NNS 19613 6869 5 had have VBD 19613 6869 6 got get VBN 19613 6869 7 already already RB 19613 6869 8 : : : 19613 6869 9 " " `` 19613 6869 10 The the DT 19613 6869 11 economy economy NN 19613 6869 12 is be VBZ 19613 6869 13 founded found VBN 19613 6869 14 on on IN 19613 6869 15 as as RB 19613 6869 16 many many JJ 19613 6869 17 names name NNS 19613 6869 18 as as IN 19613 6869 19 God God NNP 19613 6869 20 willed will VBD 19613 6869 21 " " '' 19613 6869 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6869 23 c. c. NNP 19613 6870 1 4 4 LS 19613 6870 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6870 3 . . . 19613 6870 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6871 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6871 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6871 3 537 537 CD 19613 6871 4 : : : 19613 6871 5 See see VB 19613 6871 6 adv adv NN 19613 6871 7 . . . 19613 6872 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6872 2 . . . 19613 6873 1 5 5 CD 19613 6873 2 . . . 19613 6873 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6874 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6874 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6874 3 538 538 CD 19613 6874 4 : : : 19613 6874 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6874 6 . . NNP 19613 6874 7 , , , 19613 6874 8 adv adv NNP 19613 6874 9 . . . 19613 6875 1 Hermog hermog NN 19613 6875 2 . . . 19613 6876 1 3 3 LS 19613 6876 2 : : : 19613 6876 3 " " `` 19613 6876 4 fuit fuit NN 19613 6876 5 tempus tempus NNP 19613 6876 6 , , , 19613 6876 7 cum cum NNP 19613 6876 8 ei ei NNP 19613 6876 9 filius filius NNP 19613 6876 10 non non NNP 19613 6876 11 fuit fuit NN 19613 6876 12 . . . 19613 6876 13 " " '' 19613 6876 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6877 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6877 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6877 3 539 539 CD 19613 6877 4 : : : 19613 6877 5 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6877 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6877 7 de de FW 19613 6877 8 trin trin NNP 19613 6877 9 . . . 19613 6878 1 23 23 LS 19613 6878 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6878 3 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 6878 4 very very RB 19613 6878 5 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 6878 6 between between IN 19613 6878 7 " " `` 19613 6878 8 factum factum JJ 19613 6878 9 esse esse NNP 19613 6878 10 " " '' 19613 6878 11 and and CC 19613 6878 12 " " `` 19613 6878 13 procedere procedere NN 19613 6878 14 " " '' 19613 6878 15 . . . 19613 6878 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6879 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6879 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6879 3 540 540 CD 19613 6879 4 : : : 19613 6879 5 Adv Adv NNP 19613 6879 6 . . . 19613 6880 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6880 2 . . . 19613 6881 1 2 2 LS 19613 6881 2 : : : 19613 6881 3 " " `` 19613 6881 4 Custodiatur Custodiatur NNP 19613 6881 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6881 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6881 7 : : : 19613 6881 8 oikonomias oikonomias NNP 19613 6881 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6881 10 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 6881 11 , , , 19613 6881 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 6881 13 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 6881 14 in in IN 19613 6881 15 trinitatem trinitatem NN 19613 6881 16 disponit disponit NNP 19613 6881 17 , , , 19613 6881 18 tres tre VBZ 19613 6881 19 dirigens dirigen NNS 19613 6881 20 , , , 19613 6881 21 tres tre NNS 19613 6881 22 autem autem VBP 19613 6881 23 non non AFX 19613 6881 24 statu statu NNP 19613 6881 25 , , , 19613 6881 26 sed sed NNP 19613 6881 27 gradu gradu NNP 19613 6881 28 , , , 19613 6881 29 nec nec NNP 19613 6881 30 substantia substantia NNP 19613 6881 31 , , , 19613 6881 32 sed sed NNP 19613 6881 33 forma forma NNP 19613 6881 34 , , , 19613 6881 35 nec nec NNP 19613 6881 36 potestate potestate NNP 19613 6881 37 , , , 19613 6881 38 sed sed NNP 19613 6881 39 specie specie NNP 19613 6881 40 , , , 19613 6881 41 unius unius NNP 19613 6881 42 autem autem NNP 19613 6881 43 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 6881 44 et et NNP 19613 6881 45 unius unius NNP 19613 6881 46 status status NNP 19613 6881 47 et et FW 19613 6881 48 potestatis potestatis NN 19613 6881 49 . . . 19613 6881 50 " " '' 19613 6881 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6882 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6882 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6882 3 541 541 CD 19613 6882 4 : : : 19613 6882 5 See see VB 19613 6882 6 the the DT 19613 6882 7 discussions discussion NNS 19613 6882 8 adv adv NN 19613 6882 9 . . . 19613 6883 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6883 2 . . . 19613 6884 1 16 16 CD 19613 6884 2 ff ff NNP 19613 6884 3 . . . 19613 6884 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6885 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6885 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6885 3 542 542 CD 19613 6885 4 : : : 19613 6885 5 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 6885 6 . . NNP 19613 6885 7 , , , 19613 6885 8 adv adv NNP 19613 6885 9 . . . 19613 6886 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6886 2 . . . 19613 6887 1 III iii CD 19613 6887 2 . . . 19613 6888 1 6 6 CD 19613 6888 2 : : : 19613 6888 3 " " `` 19613 6888 4 filius filius NNP 19613 6888 5 portio portio NNP 19613 6888 6 plenitudinis plenitudinis NNP 19613 6888 7 . . . 19613 6888 8 " " '' 19613 6889 1 In in IN 19613 6889 2 another another DT 19613 6889 3 passage passage NN 19613 6889 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6889 5 has have VBZ 19613 6889 6 ironically ironically RB 19613 6889 7 remarked remark VBN 19613 6889 8 in in IN 19613 6889 9 opposition opposition NN 19613 6889 10 to to IN 19613 6889 11 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6889 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6889 13 IV IV NNP 19613 6889 14 . . . 19613 6890 1 39 39 CD 19613 6890 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6890 3 : : : 19613 6890 4 " " `` 19613 6890 5 Nisi Nisi NNP 19613 6890 6 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 6890 7 Christum Christum NNP 19613 6890 8 non non AFX 19613 6890 9 subiectum subiectum NN 19613 6890 10 patri patri NN 19613 6890 11 infert infert NN 19613 6890 12 . . . 19613 6890 13 " " '' 19613 6890 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6891 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6891 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6891 3 543 543 CD 19613 6891 4 : : : 19613 6891 5 Adv Adv NNP 19613 6891 6 . . . 19613 6892 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6892 2 . . . 19613 6893 1 9 9 CD 19613 6893 2 . . . 19613 6893 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6894 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6894 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6894 3 544 544 CD 19613 6894 4 : : : 19613 6894 5 See see VB 19613 6894 6 the the DT 19613 6894 7 whole whole JJ 19613 6894 8 14th 14th JJ 19613 6894 9 chap chap NN 19613 6894 10 . . . 19613 6895 1 adv adv NNP 19613 6895 2 . . . 19613 6896 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6896 2 . . . 19613 6897 1 especially especially RB 19613 6897 2 the the DT 19613 6897 3 words word NNS 19613 6897 4 : : : 19613 6897 5 " " `` 19613 6897 6 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6897 7 am be VBP 19613 6897 8 ergo ergo NNP 19613 6897 9 alius alius NNP 19613 6897 10 erit erit NNP 19613 6897 11 qui qui NNP 19613 6897 12 videbatur videbatur NNP 19613 6897 13 , , , 19613 6897 14 quia quia NNP 19613 6897 15 non non AFX 19613 6897 16 potest potest NNP 19613 6897 17 idem idem NN 19613 6897 18 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 6897 19 definiri definiri NNP 19613 6897 20 qui qui NNP 19613 6897 21 videbatur videbatur NNP 19613 6897 22 , , , 19613 6897 23 et et NNP 19613 6897 24 consequens consequens NNP 19613 6897 25 erit erit NNP 19613 6897 26 , , , 19613 6897 27 ut ut UH 19613 6897 28 invisibilem invisibilem NNP 19613 6897 29 patrem patrem NNP 19613 6897 30 intellegamus intellegamus NNP 19613 6897 31 pro pro FW 19613 6897 32 plenitudine plenitudine NNP 19613 6897 33 maiestatis maiestatis NNP 19613 6897 34 , , , 19613 6897 35 visibilem visibilem NNP 19613 6897 36 vero vero NNP 19613 6897 37 filium filium NN 19613 6897 38 agnoscamus agnoscamus NNP 19613 6897 39 pro pro NNP 19613 6897 40 modulo modulo NNP 19613 6897 41 derivationis derivationis NNP 19613 6897 42 . . . 19613 6897 43 " " '' 19613 6898 1 One one PRP 19613 6898 2 can can MD 19613 6898 3 not not RB 19613 6898 4 look look VB 19613 6898 5 at at IN 19613 6898 6 the the DT 19613 6898 7 sun sun NN 19613 6898 8 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 6898 9 , , , 19613 6898 10 but but CC 19613 6898 11 , , , 19613 6898 12 " " '' 19613 6898 13 toleramus toleramus NNP 19613 6898 14 radium radium NNP 19613 6898 15 eius eius NNP 19613 6898 16 pro pro NNP 19613 6898 17 temperatura temperatura NNP 19613 6898 18 portionis portionis NNP 19613 6898 19 , , , 19613 6898 20 quæ quæ NN 19613 6898 21 in in IN 19613 6898 22 terram terram NNP 19613 6898 23 inde inde NNP 19613 6898 24 porrigitur porrigitur NNP 19613 6898 25 . . . 19613 6898 26 " " '' 19613 6899 1 The the DT 19613 6899 2 chapter chapter NN 19613 6899 3 also also RB 19613 6899 4 shows show VBZ 19613 6899 5 how how WRB 19613 6899 6 the the DT 19613 6899 7 Old Old NNP 19613 6899 8 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6899 9 theophanies theophany NNS 19613 6899 10 must must MD 19613 6899 11 have have VB 19613 6899 12 given give VBN 19613 6899 13 an an DT 19613 6899 14 impetus impetus NN 19613 6899 15 to to IN 19613 6899 16 the the DT 19613 6899 17 distinction distinction NN 19613 6899 18 between between IN 19613 6899 19 the the DT 19613 6899 20 Deity Deity NNP 19613 6899 21 as as IN 19613 6899 22 transcendent transcendent NN 19613 6899 23 and and CC 19613 6899 24 the the DT 19613 6899 25 Deity Deity NNP 19613 6899 26 as as IN 19613 6899 27 making make VBG 19613 6899 28 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6899 29 visible visible JJ 19613 6899 30 . . . 19613 6900 1 Adv Adv NNP 19613 6900 2 . . . 19613 6901 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6901 2 . . . 19613 6902 1 II ii CD 19613 6902 2 . . . 19613 6903 1 27 27 CD 19613 6903 2 : : : 19613 6903 3 " " `` 19613 6903 4 Quæcunque Quæcunque NNP 19613 6903 5 exigitis exigitis NNP 19613 6903 6 deo deo NNP 19613 6903 7 digna digna NNP 19613 6903 8 , , , 19613 6903 9 habebuntur habebuntur NN 19613 6903 10 in in IN 19613 6903 11 patre patre NNP 19613 6903 12 invisibili invisibili NNP 19613 6903 13 incongressibilique incongressibilique NNP 19613 6903 14 et et NNP 19613 6903 15 placido placido NNP 19613 6903 16 et et NNP 19613 6903 17 , , , 19613 6903 18 ut ut NNP 19613 6903 19 ita ita NNP 19613 6903 20 dixerim dixerim NNP 19613 6903 21 , , , 19613 6903 22 philosophorum philosophorum NNP 19613 6903 23 deo deo NNP 19613 6903 24 . . . 19613 6904 1 Quæcunque Quæcunque NNP 19613 6904 2 autem autem NNP 19613 6904 3 ut ut NNP 19613 6904 4 indigna indigna NNP 19613 6904 5 reprehenditis reprehenditis NNP 19613 6904 6 , , , 19613 6904 7 deputabuntur deputabuntur NNP 19613 6904 8 in in IN 19613 6904 9 filio filio NNP 19613 6904 10 et et NNP 19613 6904 11 viso viso NNP 19613 6904 12 et et NNP 19613 6904 13 audito audito NNP 19613 6904 14 et et NNP 19613 6904 15 congresso congresso NNP 19613 6904 16 , , , 19613 6904 17 arbitro arbitro NNP 19613 6904 18 patris patris NNP 19613 6904 19 et et NNP 19613 6904 20 ministro ministro NNP 19613 6904 21 , , , 19613 6904 22 miscente miscente NNP 19613 6904 23 in in IN 19613 6904 24 semetipso semetipso NNP 19613 6904 25 hominem hominem NNP 19613 6904 26 et et NNP 19613 6904 27 deum deum NNP 19613 6904 28 in in IN 19613 6904 29 virtutibus virtutibus NNP 19613 6904 30 deum deum NNP 19613 6904 31 , , , 19613 6904 32 in in IN 19613 6904 33 pusillitatibus pusillitatibus NNP 19613 6904 34 hominem hominem NNP 19613 6904 35 , , , 19613 6904 36 ut ut UH 19613 6904 37 tantum tantum NNP 19613 6904 38 homini homini NNP 19613 6904 39 conferat conferat NNP 19613 6904 40 quantum quantum NNP 19613 6904 41 deo deo NNP 19613 6904 42 detrahit detrahit NN 19613 6904 43 . . . 19613 6904 44 " " '' 19613 6905 1 In in IN 19613 6905 2 adv adv NN 19613 6905 3 . . . 19613 6906 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6906 2 . . . 19613 6907 1 29 29 CD 19613 6907 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6907 3 showed show VBD 19613 6907 4 in in IN 19613 6907 5 very very RB 19613 6907 6 precise precise JJ 19613 6907 7 terms term NNS 19613 6907 8 that that IN 19613 6907 9 the the DT 19613 6907 10 Father Father NNP 19613 6907 11 is be VBZ 19613 6907 12 by by IN 19613 6907 13 nature nature NN 19613 6907 14 impassible impassible JJ 19613 6907 15 , , , 19613 6907 16 but but CC 19613 6907 17 the the DT 19613 6907 18 Son Son NNP 19613 6907 19 is be VBZ 19613 6907 20 capable capable JJ 19613 6907 21 of of IN 19613 6907 22 suffering suffer VBG 19613 6907 23 . . . 19613 6908 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6908 2 does do VBZ 19613 6908 3 not not RB 19613 6908 4 share share VB 19613 6908 5 this this DT 19613 6908 6 opinion opinion NN 19613 6908 7 ; ; : 19613 6908 8 to to IN 19613 6908 9 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6908 10 the the DT 19613 6908 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6908 12 in in IN 19613 6908 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6908 14 is be VBZ 19613 6908 15 likewise likewise RB 19613 6908 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6908 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6908 18 : : : 19613 6908 19 apathês apathês NN 19613 6908 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6908 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6908 22 see see VB 19613 6908 23 c. c. NNP 19613 6908 24 Noetum Noetum NNP 19613 6908 25 15 15 CD 19613 6908 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6908 27 . . . 19613 6908 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6909 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6909 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 6909 3 545 545 CD 19613 6909 4 : : : 19613 6909 5 According accord VBG 19613 6909 6 to to IN 19613 6909 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6909 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6909 9 is be VBZ 19613 6909 10 certainly certainly RB 19613 6909 11 an an DT 19613 6909 12 _ _ NNP 19613 6909 13 essential essential JJ 19613 6909 14 part part NN 19613 6909 15 of of IN 19613 6909 16 the the DT 19613 6909 17 Son Son NNP 19613 6909 18 's 's POS 19613 6909 19 nature nature NN 19613 6909 20 _ _ NNP 19613 6909 21 to to TO 19613 6909 22 appear appear VB 19613 6909 23 , , , 19613 6909 24 teach teach VB 19613 6909 25 , , , 19613 6909 26 and and CC 19613 6909 27 thus thus RB 19613 6909 28 come come VB 19613 6909 29 into into IN 19613 6909 30 connection connection NN 19613 6909 31 with with IN 19613 6909 32 men man NNS 19613 6909 33 ; ; : 19613 6909 34 but but CC 19613 6909 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6909 36 neither neither CC 19613 6909 37 asserted assert VBD 19613 6909 38 the the DT 19613 6909 39 necessity necessity NN 19613 6909 40 of of IN 19613 6909 41 the the DT 19613 6909 42 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 6909 43 apart apart RB 19613 6909 44 from from IN 19613 6909 45 the the DT 19613 6909 46 faulty faulty JJ 19613 6909 47 development development NN 19613 6909 48 of of IN 19613 6909 49 mankind mankind NN 19613 6909 50 , , , 19613 6909 51 nor nor CC 19613 6909 52 can can MD 19613 6909 53 this this DT 19613 6909 54 view view NN 19613 6909 55 be be VB 19613 6909 56 inferred infer VBN 19613 6909 57 from from IN 19613 6909 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6909 59 premises premise NNS 19613 6909 60 . . . 19613 6909 61 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6910 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6910 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6910 3 546 546 CD 19613 6910 4 : : : 19613 6910 5 See see VB 19613 6910 6 adv adv NN 19613 6910 7 . . . 19613 6911 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6911 2 . . . 19613 6912 1 4 4 LS 19613 6912 2 . . . 19613 6912 3 the the DT 19613 6912 4 only only JJ 19613 6912 5 passage passage NN 19613 6912 6 , , , 19613 6912 7 however however RB 19613 6912 8 , , , 19613 6912 9 containing contain VBG 19613 6912 10 this this DT 19613 6912 11 idea idea NN 19613 6912 12 , , , 19613 6912 13 which which WDT 19613 6912 14 is be VBZ 19613 6912 15 derived derive VBN 19613 6912 16 from from IN 19613 6912 17 1 1 CD 19613 6912 18 Cor Cor NNP 19613 6912 19 . . . 19613 6913 1 XV XV NNP 19613 6913 2 . . . 19613 6913 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6914 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6914 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6914 3 547 547 CD 19613 6914 4 : : : 19613 6914 5 Cf Cf NNP 19613 6914 6 . . . 19613 6915 1 specially specially RB 19613 6915 2 the the DT 19613 6915 3 attempts attempt NNS 19613 6915 4 of of IN 19613 6915 5 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 19613 6915 6 to to TO 19613 6915 7 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 6915 8 the the DT 19613 6915 9 abstract abstract JJ 19613 6915 10 unity unity NN 19613 6915 11 which which WDT 19613 6915 12 is be VBZ 19613 6915 13 conceived conceive VBN 19613 6915 14 as as IN 19613 6915 15 the the DT 19613 6915 16 principle principle NN 19613 6915 17 of of IN 19613 6915 18 the the DT 19613 6915 19 universe universe NN 19613 6915 20 with with IN 19613 6915 21 the the DT 19613 6915 22 manifoldness manifoldness NN 19613 6915 23 and and CC 19613 6915 24 fulness fulness NN 19613 6915 25 of of IN 19613 6915 26 the the DT 19613 6915 27 real real JJ 19613 6915 28 and and CC 19613 6915 29 the the DT 19613 6915 30 particular particular JJ 19613 6915 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6915 32 Ennead Ennead NNP 19613 6915 33 . . . 19613 6916 1 lib lib NNP 19613 6916 2 . . . 19613 6917 1 III.-V. III.-V. NNP 19613 6917 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6917 3 . . . 19613 6918 1 Plotinus plotinus NN 19613 6918 2 employs employ VBZ 19613 6918 3 the the DT 19613 6918 4 subsidiary subsidiary JJ 19613 6918 5 notion notion NN 19613 6918 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6918 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6918 8 : : : 19613 6918 9 merismos merismos NNP 19613 6918 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6918 11 in in IN 19613 6918 12 the the DT 19613 6918 13 same same JJ 19613 6918 14 way way NN 19613 6918 15 as as IN 19613 6918 16 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6918 17 ; ; : 19613 6918 18 see see VB 19613 6918 19 Hagemann Hagemann NNP 19613 6918 20 l.c l.c NNP 19613 6918 21 . . . 19613 6919 1 p. p. NN 19613 6919 2 186 186 CD 19613 6919 3 f. f. NNP 19613 6919 4 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 19613 6919 5 would would MD 19613 6919 6 have have VB 19613 6919 7 agreed agree VBN 19613 6919 8 with with IN 19613 6919 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6919 10 's 's POS 19613 6919 11 proposition proposition NN 19613 6919 12 in in IN 19613 6919 13 adv adv NN 19613 6919 14 . . . 19613 6920 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6920 2 . . . 19613 6921 1 III iii CD 19613 6921 2 . . . 19613 6922 1 15 15 CD 19613 6922 2 : : : 19613 6922 3 " " `` 19613 6922 4 Dei Dei NNP 19613 6922 5 nomen noman NNS 19613 6922 6 quasi quasi NNP 19613 6922 7 naturale naturale JJ 19613 6922 8 divinitatis divinitatis NN 19613 6922 9 potest potest NNP 19613 6922 10 in in IN 19613 6922 11 omnes omnes NNP 19613 6922 12 communicari communicari NNP 19613 6922 13 quibus quibus NNP 19613 6922 14 divinitas divinitas NNP 19613 6922 15 vindicatur vindicatur NNP 19613 6922 16 . . . 19613 6922 17 " " '' 19613 6923 1 Plotinus plotinus NN 19613 6923 2 ' ' POS 19613 6923 3 idea idea NN 19613 6923 4 of of IN 19613 6923 5 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 6923 6 is be VBZ 19613 6923 7 also also RB 19613 6923 8 important important JJ 19613 6923 9 , , , 19613 6923 10 and and CC 19613 6923 11 this this DT 19613 6923 12 notion notion NN 19613 6923 13 requires require VBZ 19613 6923 14 exact exact JJ 19613 6923 15 examination examination NN 19613 6923 16 . . . 19613 6923 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6924 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6924 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6924 3 548 548 CD 19613 6924 4 : : : 19613 6924 5 Following follow VBG 19613 6924 6 the the DT 19613 6924 7 baptismal baptismal NN 19613 6924 8 confession confession NN 19613 6924 9 , , , 19613 6924 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6924 11 merely merely RB 19613 6924 12 treated treat VBD 19613 6924 13 the the DT 19613 6924 14 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6924 15 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 6924 16 according accord VBG 19613 6924 17 to to IN 19613 6924 18 the the DT 19613 6924 19 scheme scheme NN 19613 6924 20 of of IN 19613 6924 21 the the DT 19613 6924 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6924 23 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6924 24 without without IN 19613 6924 25 any any DT 19613 6924 26 trace trace NN 19613 6924 27 of of IN 19613 6924 28 independent independent JJ 19613 6924 29 interest interest NN 19613 6924 30 . . . 19613 6925 1 In in IN 19613 6925 2 accordance accordance NN 19613 6925 3 with with IN 19613 6925 4 this this DT 19613 6925 5 , , , 19613 6925 6 however however RB 19613 6925 7 , , , 19613 6925 8 the the DT 19613 6925 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6925 10 possesses possess VBZ 19613 6925 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6925 12 own own JJ 19613 6925 13 " " `` 19613 6925 14 numerus"--"tertium numerus"--"tertium NN 19613 6925 15 numen numan NNS 19613 6925 16 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 6925 17 et et NNP 19613 6925 18 tertium tertium NN 19613 6925 19 nomen nomen NNP 19613 6925 20 maiestatis",--and maiestatis",--and XX 19613 6925 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6925 22 is be VBZ 19613 6925 23 a a DT 19613 6925 24 person person NN 19613 6925 25 in in IN 19613 6925 26 the the DT 19613 6925 27 same same JJ 19613 6925 28 sense sense NN 19613 6925 29 as as IN 19613 6925 30 the the DT 19613 6925 31 Son Son NNP 19613 6925 32 , , , 19613 6925 33 to to IN 19613 6925 34 whom whom WP 19613 6925 35 , , , 19613 6925 36 however however RB 19613 6925 37 , , , 19613 6925 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6925 39 is be VBZ 19613 6925 40 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 6925 41 , , , 19613 6925 42 for for IN 19613 6925 43 the the DT 19613 6925 44 subordination subordination NN 19613 6925 45 is be VBZ 19613 6925 46 a a DT 19613 6925 47 necessary necessary JJ 19613 6925 48 result result NN 19613 6925 49 of of IN 19613 6925 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6925 51 later later JJ 19613 6925 52 origin origin NN 19613 6925 53 . . . 19613 6926 1 See see VB 19613 6926 2 cc cc NNP 19613 6926 3 . . . 19613 6927 1 2 2 CD 19613 6927 2 , , , 19613 6927 3 8 8 CD 19613 6927 4 : : : 19613 6927 5 " " `` 19613 6927 6 tertius tertius NNP 19613 6927 7 est e JJS 19613 6927 8 spiritus spiritus VBP 19613 6927 9 a a DT 19613 6927 10 deo deo NNP 19613 6927 11 et et NNP 19613 6927 12 filio filio NN 19613 6927 13 , , , 19613 6927 14 sicut sicut NN 19613 6927 15 tertius tertiu VBD 19613 6927 16 a a DT 19613 6927 17 radice radice NN 19613 6927 18 fructus fructus NN 19613 6927 19 a a DT 19613 6927 20 frutice frutice NN 19613 6927 21 , , , 19613 6927 22 et et FW 19613 6927 23 tertius tertiu VBD 19613 6927 24 a a DT 19613 6927 25 fonte fonte NNP 19613 6927 26 rivus rivus NNP 19613 6927 27 a a DT 19613 6927 28 flumine flumine NN 19613 6927 29 et et NN 19613 6927 30 tertius tertiu VBD 19613 6927 31 a a DT 19613 6927 32 sole sole JJ 19613 6927 33 apex apex NN 19613 6927 34 ex ex NNP 19613 6927 35 radio radio NN 19613 6927 36 . . . 19613 6928 1 Nihil Nihil NNP 19613 6928 2 tamen tamen VBZ 19613 6928 3 a a DT 19613 6928 4 matrice matrice NN 19613 6928 5 alienatur alienatur NN 19613 6928 6 a a DT 19613 6928 7 qua qua NN 19613 6928 8 proprietates proprietate NNS 19613 6928 9 suas suas NN 19613 6928 10 ducit ducit NN 19613 6928 11 . . . 19613 6929 1 Ita Ita NNP 19613 6929 2 trinitas trinita NNS 19613 6929 3 per per IN 19613 6929 4 consertos consertos NNP 19613 6929 5 et et NNP 19613 6929 6 connexos connexos NNP 19613 6929 7 gradus gradus NNP 19613 6929 8 a a DT 19613 6929 9 patre patre NN 19613 6929 10 decurrens decurren VBZ 19613 6929 11 et et NNP 19613 6929 12 monarchiæ monarchiæ NNP 19613 6929 13 nihil nihil NNP 19613 6929 14 obstrepit obstrepit NNP 19613 6929 15 et et NNP 19613 6929 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6929 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6929 18 : : : 19613 6929 19 oikonomias oikonomias NNP 19613 6929 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6929 21 statum statum NN 19613 6929 22 protegit protegit NN 19613 6929 23 " " '' 19613 6929 24 ; ; : 19613 6929 25 de de NNP 19613 6929 26 pudic pudic JJ 19613 6929 27 . . . 19613 6930 1 21 21 CD 19613 6930 2 . . . 19613 6931 1 In in IN 19613 6931 2 de de NNP 19613 6931 3 præscr præscr NNS 19613 6931 4 . . . 19613 6932 1 13 13 CD 19613 6932 2 the the DT 19613 6932 3 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6932 4 in in IN 19613 6932 5 relation relation NN 19613 6932 6 to to IN 19613 6932 7 the the DT 19613 6932 8 Son Son NNP 19613 6932 9 is be VBZ 19613 6932 10 called call VBN 19613 6932 11 " " `` 19613 6932 12 vicaria vicaria FW 19613 6932 13 vis vis FW 19613 6932 14 " " '' 19613 6932 15 . . . 19613 6933 1 The the DT 19613 6933 2 element element NN 19613 6933 3 of of IN 19613 6933 4 personality personality NN 19613 6933 5 in in IN 19613 6933 6 the the DT 19613 6933 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6933 8 is be VBZ 19613 6933 9 with with IN 19613 6933 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6933 11 merely merely RB 19613 6933 12 a a DT 19613 6933 13 result result NN 19613 6933 14 arising arise VBG 19613 6933 15 from from IN 19613 6933 16 logical logical JJ 19613 6933 17 deduction deduction NN 19613 6933 18 ; ; : 19613 6933 19 see see VB 19613 6933 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6933 21 successor successor NN 19613 6933 22 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6933 23 de de NNP 19613 6933 24 trin trin NNP 19613 6933 25 . . . 19613 6934 1 29 29 CD 19613 6934 2 . . . 19613 6935 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 6935 2 did do VBD 19613 6935 3 not not RB 19613 6935 4 attribute attribute VB 19613 6935 5 personality personality NN 19613 6935 6 to to IN 19613 6935 7 the the DT 19613 6935 8 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 6935 9 , , , 19613 6935 10 for for IN 19613 6935 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6935 12 says say VBZ 19613 6935 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6935 14 adv adv NNP 19613 6935 15 . . . 19613 6936 1 Noet Noet NNP 19613 6936 2 . . . 19613 6937 1 14 14 CD 19613 6937 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6937 3 : : : 19613 6937 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6937 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6937 6 : : : 19613 6937 7 Hena Hena NNP 19613 6937 8 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6937 9 erô erô NNP 19613 6937 10 , , , 19613 6937 11 prosôpa prosôpa NNP 19613 6937 12 de de FW 19613 6937 13 duo duo NNP 19613 6937 14 , , , 19613 6937 15 oikonomia oikonomia NNP 19613 6937 16 de de NNP 19613 6937 17 tritên tritên NNP 19613 6937 18 tên tên NNP 19613 6937 19 charin charin NNP 19613 6937 20 tou tou NNP 19613 6937 21 hagiou hagiou NNP 19613 6937 22 pneumatos pneumatos NNP 19613 6937 23 ; ; : 19613 6937 24 patêr patêr NN 19613 6937 25 men man NNS 19613 6937 26 gar gar NNP 19613 6937 27 eis eis NNP 19613 6937 28 , , , 19613 6937 29 prosôpa prosôpa NNP 19613 6937 30 de de FW 19613 6937 31 duo duo NNP 19613 6937 32 , , , 19613 6937 33 hoti hoti NNP 19613 6937 34 kai kai NNP 19613 6937 35 ho ho NNP 19613 6937 36 huios huios NNP 19613 6937 37 , , , 19613 6937 38 to to IN 19613 6937 39 de de NNP 19613 6937 40 triton triton NNP 19613 6937 41 to to IN 19613 6937 42 hagion hagion NNP 19613 6937 43 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 6937 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6937 45 . . . 19613 6938 1 In in IN 19613 6938 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6938 3 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6938 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6938 5 apart apart RB 19613 6938 6 from from IN 19613 6938 7 the the DT 19613 6938 8 express express JJ 19613 6938 9 emphasis emphasis NN 19613 6938 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6938 11 lays lay VBZ 19613 6938 12 on on IN 19613 6938 13 the the DT 19613 6938 14 creatureliness creatureliness NN 19613 6938 15 of of IN 19613 6938 16 the the DT 19613 6938 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6938 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6938 19 see see VB 19613 6938 20 Philos Philos NNP 19613 6938 21 . . . 19613 6939 1 X. X. NNP 19613 6940 1 33 33 CD 19613 6940 2 : : : 19613 6940 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6940 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6940 5 : : : 19613 6940 6 Ei Ei NNP 19613 6940 7 gar gar NN 19613 6940 8 Theon Theon NNP 19613 6940 9 se se NNP 19613 6940 10 êthelêse êthelêse NNP 19613 6940 11 poiêsai poiêsai NNP 19613 6940 12 ho ho NNP 19613 6940 13 Theos Theos NNP 19613 6940 14 , , , 19613 6940 15 edunato edunato NNP 19613 6940 16 ; ; : 19613 6940 17 echeis echeis NNP 19613 6940 18 tou tou NNP 19613 6940 19 logou logou NNP 19613 6940 20 to to IN 19613 6940 21 paradeigma paradeigma NNP 19613 6940 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6940 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6940 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6940 25 quite quite RB 19613 6940 26 agrees agree VBZ 19613 6940 27 with with IN 19613 6940 28 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6940 29 . . . 19613 6941 1 See see VB 19613 6941 2 ibid ibid NN 19613 6941 3 . . . 19613 6942 1 ; ; : 19613 6942 2 here here RB 19613 6942 3 the the DT 19613 6942 4 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6942 5 is be VBZ 19613 6942 6 called call VBN 19613 6942 7 before before IN 19613 6942 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6942 9 coming come VBG 19613 6942 10 forth forth RP 19613 6942 11 " " '' 19613 6942 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6942 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6942 14 : : : 19613 6942 15 endiathetos endiathetos NNP 19613 6942 16 tou tou NNP 19613 6942 17 pantos pantos NNP 19613 6942 18 logismos logismos NNP 19613 6942 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6942 20 " " '' 19613 6942 21 ; ; : 19613 6942 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 23 is be VBZ 19613 6942 24 produced produce VBN 19613 6942 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6942 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 6942 27 : : : 19613 6942 28 ek ek NNP 19613 6942 29 tôn tôn NNP 19613 6942 30 ontôn ontôn NNP 19613 6942 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6942 32 , , , 19613 6942 33 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 6942 34 , , , 19613 6942 35 from from IN 19613 6942 36 the the DT 19613 6942 37 Father Father NNP 19613 6942 38 who who WP 19613 6942 39 then then RB 19613 6942 40 alone alone RB 19613 6942 41 existed exist VBD 19613 6942 42 ; ; : 19613 6942 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6942 44 essence essence NN 19613 6942 45 is be VBZ 19613 6942 46 " " `` 19613 6942 47 that that IN 19613 6942 48 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 49 bears bear VBZ 19613 6942 50 in in IN 19613 6942 51 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 52 the the DT 19613 6942 53 will will NN 19613 6942 54 of of IN 19613 6942 55 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 56 who who WP 19613 6942 57 has have VBZ 19613 6942 58 begotten beget VBN 19613 6942 59 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 60 " " '' 19613 6942 61 or or CC 19613 6942 62 " " `` 19613 6942 63 that that IN 19613 6942 64 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 65 comprehends comprehend VBZ 19613 6942 66 in in IN 19613 6942 67 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 6942 68 the the DT 19613 6942 69 ideas idea NNS 19613 6942 70 previously previously RB 19613 6942 71 conceived conceive VBN 19613 6942 72 by by RB 19613 6942 73 and and CC 19613 6942 74 resting rest VBG 19613 6942 75 in in IN 19613 6942 76 the the DT 19613 6942 77 Father Father NNP 19613 6942 78 . . . 19613 6942 79 " " '' 19613 6943 1 Cyprian cyprian NN 19613 6943 2 in in IN 19613 6943 3 no no DT 19613 6943 4 part part NN 19613 6943 5 of of IN 19613 6943 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6943 7 writings writing NNS 19613 6943 8 took take VBD 19613 6943 9 occasion occasion NN 19613 6943 10 to to TO 19613 6943 11 set set VB 19613 6943 12 forth forth RP 19613 6943 13 the the DT 19613 6943 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6943 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6943 16 in in IN 19613 6943 17 a a DT 19613 6943 18 didactic didactic JJ 19613 6943 19 way way NN 19613 6943 20 ; ; : 19613 6943 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6943 22 simply simply RB 19613 6943 23 kept keep VBD 19613 6943 24 to to IN 19613 6943 25 the the DT 19613 6943 26 formula formula NN 19613 6943 27 : : : 19613 6943 28 " " `` 19613 6943 29 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6943 30 deus deu VBZ 19613 6943 31 et et NN 19613 6943 32 homo homo NN 19613 6943 33 " " '' 19613 6943 34 , , , 19613 6943 35 and and CC 19613 6943 36 to to IN 19613 6943 37 the the DT 19613 6943 38 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 6943 39 expressions expression NNS 19613 6943 40 which which WDT 19613 6943 41 were be VBD 19613 6943 42 understood understand VBN 19613 6943 43 in in IN 19613 6943 44 the the DT 19613 6943 45 sense sense NN 19613 6943 46 of of IN 19613 6943 47 divinity divinity NN 19613 6943 48 and and CC 19613 6943 49 preëxistence preëxistence NN 19613 6943 50 ; ; : 19613 6943 51 see see VB 19613 6943 52 Testim Testim NNP 19613 6943 53 . . . 19613 6944 1 II ii CD 19613 6944 2 . . . 19613 6945 1 1 1 CD 19613 6945 2 - - SYM 19613 6945 3 10 10 CD 19613 6945 4 . . . 19613 6946 1 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 19613 6946 2 was be VBD 19613 6946 3 still still RB 19613 6946 4 quite quite RB 19613 6946 5 confused confused JJ 19613 6946 6 in in IN 19613 6946 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6946 8 Trinitarian trinitarian JJ 19613 6946 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 6946 10 and and CC 19613 6946 11 , , , 19613 6946 12 in in IN 19613 6946 13 particular particular JJ 19613 6946 14 , , , 19613 6946 15 conceived conceive VBD 19613 6946 16 the the DT 19613 6946 17 Holy Holy NNP 19613 6946 18 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 6946 19 not not RB 19613 6946 20 as as IN 19613 6946 21 a a DT 19613 6946 22 person person NN 19613 6946 23 but but CC 19613 6946 24 as as IN 19613 6946 25 " " `` 19613 6946 26 sanctificatio sanctificatio NN 19613 6946 27 " " '' 19613 6946 28 proceeding proceed VBG 19613 6946 29 from from IN 19613 6946 30 the the DT 19613 6946 31 Father Father NNP 19613 6946 32 or or CC 19613 6946 33 from from IN 19613 6946 34 the the DT 19613 6946 35 Son Son NNP 19613 6946 36 . . . 19613 6947 1 On on IN 19613 6947 2 the the DT 19613 6947 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 6947 4 , , , 19613 6947 5 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 6947 6 , , , 19613 6947 7 in in IN 19613 6947 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 6947 9 work work NN 19613 6947 10 _ _ NNP 19613 6947 11 de de NNP 19613 6947 12 trinitate trinitate NNP 19613 6947 13 _ _ NNP 19613 6947 14 reproduced reproduce VBD 19613 6947 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6947 16 's 's POS 19613 6947 17 views view NNS 19613 6947 18 . . . 19613 6948 1 For for IN 19613 6948 2 details detail NNS 19613 6948 3 see see VBP 19613 6948 4 Dorner Dorner NNP 19613 6948 5 Entwickelungsgeschichte Entwickelungsgeschichte NNP 19613 6948 6 I. I. NNP 19613 6948 7 pp pp NNP 19613 6948 8 . . . 19613 6949 1 563 563 CD 19613 6949 2 - - SYM 19613 6949 3 634 634 CD 19613 6949 4 , , , 19613 6949 5 Kahnis Kahnis NNP 19613 6949 6 , , , 19613 6949 7 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 6949 8 vom vom NNS 19613 6949 9 heiligen heiligen NNP 19613 6949 10 Geiste Geiste NNP 19613 6949 11 ; ; : 19613 6949 12 Hagemann Hagemann NNP 19613 6949 13 , , , 19613 6949 14 l.c l.c NNP 19613 6949 15 . . NNP 19613 6949 16 , , , 19613 6949 17 p. p. NN 19613 6949 18 371 371 CD 19613 6949 19 ff ff NN 19613 6949 20 . . . 19613 6950 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 6950 2 is be VBZ 19613 6950 3 noteworthy noteworthy JJ 19613 6950 4 that that IN 19613 6950 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 6950 6 still still RB 19613 6950 7 very very RB 19613 6950 8 frequently frequently RB 19613 6950 9 called call VBD 19613 6950 10 the the DT 19613 6950 11 preëxistent preëxistent NN 19613 6950 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 6950 13 _ _ NNP 19613 6950 14 dei dei NNP 19613 6950 15 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 6950 16 _ _ NNP 19613 6950 17 ; ; : 19613 6950 18 see see VB 19613 6950 19 de de NNP 19613 6950 20 oral oral NNP 19613 6950 21 . . . 19613 6951 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 6951 2 : : : 19613 6951 3 " " `` 19613 6951 4 Dei Dei NNP 19613 6951 5 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 6951 6 et et FW 19613 6951 7 dei dei NNP 19613 6951 8 sermo sermo NNP 19613 6951 9 et et FW 19613 6951 10 dei dei NNP 19613 6951 11 ratio ratio NN 19613 6951 12 , , , 19613 6951 13 sermo sermo NNP 19613 6951 14 rationis rationis NNP 19613 6951 15 et et NNP 19613 6951 16 ratio ratio NN 19613 6951 17 sermonis sermonis NNP 19613 6951 18 et et NNP 19613 6951 19 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 6951 20 , , , 19613 6951 21 utrumque utrumque NNP 19613 6951 22 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 6951 23 Christus Christus NNP 19613 6951 24 . . . 19613 6951 25 " " '' 19613 6952 1 Apol Apol NNP 19613 6952 2 . . . 19613 6953 1 21 21 CD 19613 6953 2 : : : 19613 6953 3 adv adv NN 19613 6953 4 . . . 19613 6954 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 6954 2 . . . 19613 6955 1 26 26 CD 19613 6955 2 ; ; : 19613 6955 3 adv adv NN 19613 6955 4 . . . 19613 6956 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 6956 2 . . . 19613 6957 1 I. I. NNP 19613 6958 1 10 10 CD 19613 6958 2 : : : 19613 6958 3 III iii CD 19613 6958 4 . . . 19613 6959 1 6 6 CD 19613 6959 2 , , , 19613 6959 3 16 16 CD 19613 6959 4 : : : 19613 6959 5 IV IV NNP 19613 6959 6 . . . 19613 6960 1 21 21 CD 19613 6960 2 . . . 19613 6960 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6961 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6961 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6961 3 549 549 CD 19613 6961 4 : : : 19613 6961 5 See see VB 19613 6961 6 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 6961 7 , , , 19613 6961 8 Marcellus Marcellus NNP 19613 6961 9 of of IN 19613 6961 10 Ancyra Ancyra NNP 19613 6961 11 , , , 19613 6961 12 pp pp NNP 19613 6961 13 . . . 19613 6962 1 235 235 CD 19613 6962 2 - - SYM 19613 6962 3 244 244 CD 19613 6962 4 . . . 19613 6963 1 Duncker Duncker NNP 19613 6963 2 , , , 19613 6963 3 Des Des NNP 19613 6963 4 heiligen heiligen NN 19613 6963 5 Irenaus Irenaus NNP 19613 6963 6 Christologie Christologie NNP 19613 6963 7 , , , 19613 6963 8 1843 1843 CD 19613 6963 9 . . . 19613 6963 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6964 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6964 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6964 3 550 550 CD 19613 6964 4 : : : 19613 6964 5 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 6964 6 , , , 19613 6964 7 l.c l.c NNP 19613 6964 8 . . NNP 19613 6964 9 , , , 19613 6964 10 p. p. NN 19613 6965 1 238 238 CD 19613 6965 2 . . . 19613 6965 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6966 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6966 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6966 3 551 551 CD 19613 6966 4 : : : 19613 6966 5 See see VB 19613 6966 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 6966 7 . . . 19613 6966 8 , , , 19613 6966 9 II II NNP 19613 6966 10 . . . 19613 6967 1 13 13 CD 19613 6967 2 . . . 19613 6968 1 8 8 CD 19613 6968 2 : : : 19613 6968 3 II ii CD 19613 6968 4 . . . 19613 6969 1 28 28 CD 19613 6969 2 . . . 19613 6970 1 4 4 CD 19613 6970 2 - - SYM 19613 6970 3 9 9 CD 19613 6970 4 : : : 19613 6970 5 II ii CD 19613 6970 6 . . . 19613 6971 1 12 12 CD 19613 6971 2 . . . 19613 6972 1 2 2 LS 19613 6972 2 : : : 19613 6972 3 II ii CD 19613 6972 4 . . . 19613 6973 1 13 13 CD 19613 6973 2 . . . 19613 6974 1 2 2 CD 19613 6974 2 , , , 19613 6974 3 and and CC 19613 6974 4 also also RB 19613 6974 5 the the DT 19613 6974 6 important important JJ 19613 6974 7 passage passage NN 19613 6974 8 II ii CD 19613 6974 9 . . . 19613 6975 1 29 29 CD 19613 6975 2 . . . 19613 6976 1 3 3 CD 19613 6976 2 fin fin NNP 19613 6976 3 . . . 19613 6976 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6977 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6977 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6977 3 552 552 CD 19613 6977 4 : : : 19613 6977 5 A a DT 19613 6977 6 great great JJ 19613 6977 7 many many JJ 19613 6977 8 passages passage NNS 19613 6977 9 clearly clearly RB 19613 6977 10 show show VBP 19613 6977 11 that that IN 19613 6977 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6977 13 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 6977 14 distinguished distinguish VBD 19613 6977 15 the the DT 19613 6977 16 Son Son NNP 19613 6977 17 from from IN 19613 6977 18 the the DT 19613 6977 19 Father Father NNP 19613 6977 20 , , , 19613 6977 21 so so IN 19613 6977 22 that that IN 19613 6977 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 6977 24 is be VBZ 19613 6977 25 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 6977 26 incorrect incorrect JJ 19613 6977 27 to to TO 19613 6977 28 attribute attribute VB 19613 6977 29 modalistic modalistic JJ 19613 6977 30 ideas idea NNS 19613 6977 31 to to IN 19613 6977 32 him -PRON- PRP 19613 6977 33 . . . 19613 6978 1 See see VB 19613 6978 2 III iii CD 19613 6978 3 . . . 19613 6979 1 6 6 CD 19613 6979 2 . . . 19613 6980 1 1 1 CD 19613 6980 2 and and CC 19613 6980 3 all all PDT 19613 6980 4 the the DT 19613 6980 5 other other JJ 19613 6980 6 passages passage NNS 19613 6980 7 where where WRB 19613 6980 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 6980 9 refers refer VBZ 19613 6980 10 to to IN 19613 6980 11 the the DT 19613 6980 12 Old Old NNP 19613 6980 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 6980 14 theophanies theophany NNS 19613 6980 15 . . . 19613 6981 1 Such such JJ 19613 6981 2 are be VBP 19613 6981 3 III iii CD 19613 6981 4 . . . 19613 6982 1 6 6 CD 19613 6982 2 . . . 19613 6983 1 2 2 LS 19613 6983 2 : : : 19613 6983 3 IV IV NNP 19613 6983 4 . . . 19613 6984 1 5 5 CD 19613 6984 2 . . . 19613 6985 1 2 2 CD 19613 6985 2 fin fin NNP 19613 6985 3 . . . 19613 6986 1 : : : 19613 6986 2 IV IV NNP 19613 6986 3 . . . 19613 6987 1 7 7 LS 19613 6987 2 . . . 19613 6988 1 4 4 LS 19613 6988 2 , , , 19613 6988 3 where where WRB 19613 6988 4 the the DT 19613 6988 5 distinction distinction NN 19613 6988 6 is be VBZ 19613 6988 7 particularly particularly RB 19613 6988 8 plain plain JJ 19613 6988 9 : : : 19613 6988 10 IV IV NNP 19613 6988 11 . . . 19613 6989 1 17 17 CD 19613 6989 2 . . . 19613 6990 1 6 6 CD 19613 6990 2 : : : 19613 6990 3 II ii CD 19613 6990 4 . . . 19613 6991 1 28 28 CD 19613 6991 2 . . . 19613 6992 1 6 6 LS 19613 6992 2 . . . 19613 6992 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 6993 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 6993 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 6993 3 553 553 CD 19613 6993 4 : : : 19613 6993 5 The the DT 19613 6993 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 6993 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6993 8 Son Son NNP 19613 6993 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6993 10 is be VBZ 19613 6993 11 the the DT 19613 6993 12 administrator administrator NN 19613 6993 13 and and CC 19613 6993 14 bestower bestower NN 19613 6993 15 of of IN 19613 6993 16 the the DT 19613 6993 17 divine divine JJ 19613 6993 18 grace grace NN 19613 6993 19 as as IN 19613 6993 20 regards regard VBZ 19613 6993 21 humanity humanity NN 19613 6993 22 , , , 19613 6993 23 because because IN 19613 6993 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 6993 25 is be VBZ 19613 6993 26 the the DT 19613 6993 27 revealer revealer NN 19613 6993 28 of of IN 19613 6993 29 this this DT 19613 6993 30 grace grace NN 19613 6993 31 , , , 19613 6993 32 see see VB 19613 6993 33 IV IV NNP 19613 6993 34 . . . 19613 6994 1 6 6 CD 19613 6994 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 6994 3 § § CD 19613 6994 4 7 7 CD 19613 6994 5 : : : 19613 6994 6 " " `` 19613 6994 7 agnitio agnitio NNP 19613 6994 8 patris patris NNP 19613 6994 9 filius filius NNP 19613 6994 10 , , , 19613 6994 11 agnitio agnitio NNP 19613 6994 12 autem autem NNP 19613 6994 13 filii filii NNP 19613 6994 14 in in IN 19613 6994 15 patre patre NNP 19613 6994 16 et et NNP 19613 6994 17 per per IN 19613 6994 18 filium filium NN 19613 6994 19 revelata revelata NN 19613 6994 20 " " '' 19613 6994 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 6994 22 : : : 19613 6994 23 IV IV NNP 19613 6994 24 . . . 19613 6995 1 5 5 LS 19613 6995 2 : : : 19613 6995 3 IV IV NNP 19613 6995 4 . . . 19613 6996 1 16 16 CD 19613 6996 2 . . . 19613 6997 1 7 7 LS 19613 6997 2 : : : 19613 6997 3 IV IV NNP 19613 6997 4 . . . 19613 6998 1 20 20 CD 19613 6998 2 . . . 19613 6999 1 7 7 LS 19613 6999 2 . . . 19613 7000 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7000 2 has have VBZ 19613 7000 3 been be VBN 19613 7000 4 the the DT 19613 7000 5 revealer revealer NN 19613 7000 6 of of IN 19613 7000 7 God God NNP 19613 7000 8 from from IN 19613 7000 9 the the DT 19613 7000 10 beginning beginning NN 19613 7000 11 and and CC 19613 7000 12 always always RB 19613 7000 13 remains remain VBZ 19613 7000 14 so so RB 19613 7000 15 , , , 19613 7000 16 III iii CD 19613 7000 17 . . . 19613 7001 1 16 16 CD 19613 7001 2 . . . 19613 7002 1 6 6 LS 19613 7002 2 : : : 19613 7002 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7002 4 . . . 19613 7003 1 13 13 CD 19613 7003 2 . . . 19613 7004 1 4 4 CD 19613 7004 2 etc etc FW 19613 7004 3 . . . 19613 7005 1 : : : 19613 7005 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7005 3 is be VBZ 19613 7005 4 the the DT 19613 7005 5 antemundane antemundane NNP 19613 7005 6 revealer revealer NN 19613 7005 7 to to IN 19613 7005 8 the the DT 19613 7005 9 angel angel NN 19613 7005 10 world world NN 19613 7005 11 , , , 19613 7005 12 see see VB 19613 7005 13 II II NNP 19613 7005 14 . . . 19613 7006 1 30 30 CD 19613 7006 2 . . . 19613 7007 1 9 9 LS 19613 7007 2 : : : 19613 7007 3 " " `` 19613 7007 4 semper semper NNP 19613 7007 5 autem autem NNP 19613 7007 6 coëxsistens coëxsistens NNP 19613 7007 7 filius filius NNP 19613 7007 8 patri patri NNP 19613 7007 9 , , , 19613 7007 10 olim olim NNP 19613 7007 11 et et NNP 19613 7007 12 ab ab NNP 19613 7007 13 initio initio NNP 19613 7007 14 semper semper NNP 19613 7007 15 revelat revelat NNP 19613 7007 16 patrem patrem NN 19613 7007 17 et et NNP 19613 7007 18 angelis angelis NNP 19613 7007 19 et et NNP 19613 7007 20 archangelis archangelis NNP 19613 7007 21 et et NNP 19613 7007 22 potestatibus potestatibus NNP 19613 7007 23 et et FW 19613 7007 24 virtutibus virtutibus NNP 19613 7007 25 et et NNP 19613 7007 26 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 7007 27 , , , 19613 7007 28 quibus quibus NNP 19613 7007 29 vult vult NNP 19613 7007 30 revelari revelari JJ 19613 7007 31 deus deus NNP 19613 7007 32 ; ; : 19613 7007 33 " " `` 19613 7007 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7007 35 has have VBZ 19613 7007 36 always always RB 19613 7007 37 existed exist VBN 19613 7007 38 with with IN 19613 7007 39 the the DT 19613 7007 40 Father Father NNP 19613 7007 41 , , , 19613 7007 42 see see VB 19613 7007 43 II II NNP 19613 7007 44 . . . 19613 7008 1 30 30 CD 19613 7008 2 . . . 19613 7009 1 9 9 CD 19613 7009 2 : : : 19613 7009 3 III iii CD 19613 7009 4 . . . 19613 7010 1 18 18 CD 19613 7010 2 . . . 19613 7011 1 1 1 LS 19613 7011 2 : : : 19613 7011 3 " " `` 19613 7011 4 non non NNP 19613 7011 5 tunc tunc NNP 19613 7011 6 coepit coepit NNP 19613 7011 7 filius filius NNP 19613 7011 8 dei dei NNP 19613 7011 9 , , , 19613 7011 10 exsistens exsisten VBZ 19613 7011 11 semper semper NNP 19613 7011 12 apud apud NNP 19613 7011 13 patrem patrem NN 19613 7011 14 " " '' 19613 7011 15 ; ; : 19613 7011 16 IV IV NNP 19613 7011 17 . . . 19613 7012 1 20 20 CD 19613 7012 2 . . . 19613 7013 1 3 3 CD 19613 7013 2 , , , 19613 7013 3 7 7 CD 19613 7013 4 , , , 19613 7013 5 14 14 CD 19613 7013 6 . . . 19613 7014 1 1 1 LS 19613 7014 2 : : : 19613 7014 3 II ii CD 19613 7014 4 . . . 19613 7015 1 25 25 CD 19613 7015 2 . . . 19613 7016 1 3 3 LS 19613 7016 2 : : : 19613 7016 3 " " `` 19613 7016 4 non non AFX 19613 7016 5 enim enim NNP 19613 7016 6 infectus infectus NNP 19613 7016 7 es es NNP 19613 7016 8 , , , 19613 7016 9 o o NNP 19613 7016 10 homo homo NNP 19613 7016 11 , , , 19613 7016 12 neque neque NNP 19613 7016 13 semper semper NNP 19613 7016 14 coëxsistebas coëxsistebas NNP 19613 7016 15 deo deo NNP 19613 7016 16 , , , 19613 7016 17 sicut sicut NNP 19613 7016 18 proprium proprium NNP 19613 7016 19 eius eius NNP 19613 7016 20 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7016 21 . . . 19613 7016 22 " " '' 19613 7017 1 The the DT 19613 7017 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7017 3 is be VBZ 19613 7017 4 God God NNP 19613 7017 5 as as IN 19613 7017 6 God God NNP 19613 7017 7 , , , 19613 7017 8 nay nay NNP 19613 7017 9 , , , 19613 7017 10 for for IN 19613 7017 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7017 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7017 13 is be VBZ 19613 7017 14 God God NNP 19613 7017 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7017 16 , , , 19613 7017 17 in in IN 19613 7017 18 so so RB 19613 7017 19 far far RB 19613 7017 20 as as IN 19613 7017 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7017 22 work work NN 19613 7017 23 is be VBZ 19613 7017 24 the the DT 19613 7017 25 work work NN 19613 7017 26 of of IN 19613 7017 27 God God NNP 19613 7017 28 . . . 19613 7018 1 Thus thus RB 19613 7018 2 , , , 19613 7018 3 and and CC 19613 7018 4 not not RB 19613 7018 5 in in IN 19613 7018 6 a a DT 19613 7018 7 modalistic modalistic JJ 19613 7018 8 sense sense NN 19613 7018 9 , , , 19613 7018 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7018 11 must must MD 19613 7018 12 understand understand VB 19613 7018 13 passages passage NNS 19613 7018 14 like like IN 19613 7018 15 II ii CD 19613 7018 16 . . . 19613 7019 1 30 30 CD 19613 7019 2 . . . 19613 7020 1 9 9 LS 19613 7020 2 : : : 19613 7020 3 " " `` 19613 7020 4 fabricator fabricator NN 19613 7020 5 qui qui NNP 19613 7020 6 fecit fecit NN 19613 7020 7 mundum mundum NN 19613 7020 8 per per IN 19613 7020 9 semitipsum semitipsum NN 19613 7020 10 , , , 19613 7020 11 hoc hoc FW 19613 7020 12 est est NNP 19613 7020 13 per per IN 19613 7020 14 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7020 15 et et NNP 19613 7020 16 per per IN 19613 7020 17 sapientiam sapientiam NNP 19613 7020 18 suam suam NNP 19613 7020 19 , , , 19613 7020 20 " " '' 19613 7020 21 or or CC 19613 7020 22 hymnlike hymnlike NN 19613 7020 23 statements statement NNS 19613 7020 24 such such JJ 19613 7020 25 as as IN 19613 7020 26 III III NNP 19613 7020 27 . . . 19613 7021 1 16 16 CD 19613 7021 2 . . . 19613 7022 1 6 6 CD 19613 7022 2 : : : 19613 7022 3 " " `` 19613 7022 4 et et NNP 19613 7022 5 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7022 6 ergo ergo NNP 19613 7022 7 in in IN 19613 7022 8 semetipsum semetipsum NNP 19613 7022 9 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 7022 10 est est NNP 19613 7022 11 , , , 19613 7022 12 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 7022 13 visibilis visibilis NNP 19613 7022 14 factus factus NN 19613 7022 15 , , , 19613 7022 16 et et NNP 19613 7022 17 incomprehensibilis incomprehensibilis NNP 19613 7022 18 factus factus NNP 19613 7022 19 comprehensibilis comprehensibilis NNP 19613 7022 20 et et NNP 19613 7022 21 impassibilis impassibilis NNP 19613 7022 22 passibilis passibilis NNP 19613 7022 23 et et NNP 19613 7022 24 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7022 25 homo homo NNP 19613 7022 26 " " '' 19613 7022 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7022 28 see see VB 19613 7022 29 something something NN 19613 7022 30 similar similar JJ 19613 7022 31 in in IN 19613 7022 32 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 19613 7022 33 and and CC 19613 7022 34 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7022 35 , , , 19613 7022 36 Otto Otto NNP 19613 7022 37 , , , 19613 7022 38 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 7022 39 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 7022 40 . . . 19613 7023 1 IX ix NN 19613 7023 2 , , , 19613 7023 3 p. p. NN 19613 7023 4 419 419 CD 19613 7023 5 sq sq NNP 19613 7023 6 . . NNP 19613 7023 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7023 8 . . . 19613 7024 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7024 2 also also RB 19613 7024 3 says say VBZ 19613 7024 4 in in IN 19613 7024 5 III III NNP 19613 7024 6 . . . 19613 7025 1 6 6 CD 19613 7025 2 . . . 19613 7026 1 2 2 LS 19613 7026 2 : : : 19613 7026 3 " " `` 19613 7026 4 filius filius NNP 19613 7026 5 est est NNP 19613 7026 6 in in IN 19613 7026 7 patre patre NNP 19613 7026 8 et et NNP 19613 7026 9 habet habet NN 19613 7026 10 in in IN 19613 7026 11 se se NNP 19613 7026 12 patrem patrem NN 19613 7026 13 , , , 19613 7026 14 " " '' 19613 7026 15 III iii CD 19613 7026 16 . . . 19613 7027 1 6 6 CD 19613 7027 2 . . . 19613 7028 1 1 1 LS 19613 7028 2 . . . 19613 7028 3 : : : 19613 7028 4 " " `` 19613 7028 5 utrosque utrosque NNP 19613 7028 6 dei dei NNP 19613 7028 7 appellatione appellatione NNP 19613 7028 8 signavit signavit NNP 19613 7028 9 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 7028 10 , , , 19613 7028 11 et et NNP 19613 7028 12 eum eum NNP 19613 7028 13 qui qui NNP 19613 7028 14 ungitur ungitur NNP 19613 7028 15 filium filium NNP 19613 7028 16 et et NNP 19613 7028 17 eum eum NNP 19613 7028 18 , , , 19613 7028 19 qui qui NNP 19613 7028 20 ungit ungit NNP 19613 7028 21 , , , 19613 7028 22 i -PRON- PRP 19613 7028 23 d d VBN 19613 7028 24 est e JJS 19613 7028 25 patrem patrem NN 19613 7028 26 . . . 19613 7028 27 " " '' 19613 7029 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7029 2 not not RB 19613 7029 3 only only RB 19613 7029 4 says say VBZ 19613 7029 5 that that IN 19613 7029 6 the the DT 19613 7029 7 Son Son NNP 19613 7029 8 has have VBZ 19613 7029 9 revealed reveal VBN 19613 7029 10 the the DT 19613 7029 11 Father Father NNP 19613 7029 12 , , , 19613 7029 13 but but CC 19613 7029 14 that that IN 19613 7029 15 the the DT 19613 7029 16 Father Father NNP 19613 7029 17 has have VBZ 19613 7029 18 revealed reveal VBN 19613 7029 19 the the DT 19613 7029 20 Son Son NNP 19613 7029 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7029 22 IV IV NNP 19613 7029 23 . . . 19613 7030 1 6 6 CD 19613 7030 2 . . . 19613 7031 1 3 3 LS 19613 7031 2 : : : 19613 7031 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7031 4 . . . 19613 7032 1 7 7 LS 19613 7032 2 . . . 19613 7033 1 7 7 LS 19613 7033 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7033 3 . . . 19613 7034 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7034 2 applies apply VBZ 19613 7034 3 Old Old NNP 19613 7034 4 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7034 5 passages passage NNS 19613 7034 6 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 7034 7 to to IN 19613 7034 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7034 9 , , , 19613 7034 10 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 7034 11 to to IN 19613 7034 12 God God NNP 19613 7034 13 , , , 19613 7034 14 and and CC 19613 7034 15 hence hence RB 19613 7034 16 in in IN 19613 7034 17 some some DT 19613 7034 18 cases case NNS 19613 7034 19 calls call VBZ 19613 7034 20 the the DT 19613 7034 21 Father Father NNP 19613 7034 22 the the DT 19613 7034 23 creator creator NN 19613 7034 24 , , , 19613 7034 25 and and CC 19613 7034 26 in in IN 19613 7034 27 others other NNS 19613 7034 28 the the DT 19613 7034 29 Son Son NNP 19613 7034 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7034 31 " " `` 19613 7034 32 pater pater NNP 19613 7034 33 generis generis NNP 19613 7034 34 humani humani NNP 19613 7034 35 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7034 36 dei dei NNP 19613 7034 37 " " '' 19613 7034 38 , , , 19613 7034 39 IV IV NNP 19613 7034 40 . . . 19613 7035 1 31 31 CD 19613 7035 2 . . . 19613 7036 1 2 2 LS 19613 7036 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7036 3 . . . 19613 7037 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7037 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7037 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7037 4 . . . 19613 7038 1 4 4 LS 19613 7038 2 . . . 19613 7039 1 2 2 LS 19613 7039 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7039 3 appropriated appropriate VBD 19613 7039 4 the the DT 19613 7039 5 expression expression NN 19613 7039 6 of of IN 19613 7039 7 an an DT 19613 7039 8 ancient ancient JJ 19613 7039 9 " " `` 19613 7039 10 immensum immensum NN 19613 7039 11 patrem patrem NN 19613 7039 12 in in IN 19613 7039 13 filio filio NNP 19613 7039 14 mensuratum mensuratum NN 19613 7039 15 ; ; : 19613 7039 16 mensura mensura NNP 19613 7039 17 enim enim NNP 19613 7039 18 patris patris NNP 19613 7039 19 filius filius NNP 19613 7039 20 , , , 19613 7039 21 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 7039 22 et et NNP 19613 7039 23 capit capit NN 19613 7039 24 eum eum NNP 19613 7039 25 . . . 19613 7039 26 " " '' 19613 7040 1 This this DT 19613 7040 2 expression expression NN 19613 7040 3 is be VBZ 19613 7040 4 by by IN 19613 7040 5 no no DT 19613 7040 6 means mean NNS 19613 7040 7 intended intend VBN 19613 7040 8 to to TO 19613 7040 9 denote denote VB 19613 7040 10 a a DT 19613 7040 11 diminution diminution NN 19613 7040 12 , , , 19613 7040 13 but but CC 19613 7040 14 rather rather RB 19613 7040 15 to to TO 19613 7040 16 signify signify VB 19613 7040 17 the the DT 19613 7040 18 identity identity NN 19613 7040 19 of of IN 19613 7040 20 Father Father NNP 19613 7040 21 and and CC 19613 7040 22 Son Son NNP 19613 7040 23 . . . 19613 7041 1 In in IN 19613 7041 2 all all PDT 19613 7041 3 this this DT 19613 7041 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7041 5 adhered adhere VBD 19613 7041 6 to to IN 19613 7041 7 an an DT 19613 7041 8 ancient ancient JJ 19613 7041 9 tradition tradition NN 19613 7041 10 ; ; : 19613 7041 11 but but CC 19613 7041 12 these these DT 19613 7041 13 propositions proposition NNS 19613 7041 14 do do VBP 19613 7041 15 not not RB 19613 7041 16 admit admit VB 19613 7041 17 of of IN 19613 7041 18 being be VBG 19613 7041 19 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 7041 20 with with IN 19613 7041 21 a a DT 19613 7041 22 rational rational JJ 19613 7041 23 system system NN 19613 7041 24 . . . 19613 7041 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7042 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7042 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7042 3 554 554 CD 19613 7042 4 : : : 19613 7042 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7042 6 and and CC 19613 7042 7 Sophia Sophia NNP 19613 7042 8 are be VBP 19613 7042 9 the the DT 19613 7042 10 hands hand NNS 19613 7042 11 of of IN 19613 7042 12 God God NNP 19613 7042 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7042 14 III III NNP 19613 7042 15 . . . 19613 7043 1 21 21 CD 19613 7043 2 . . . 19613 7044 1 10 10 CD 19613 7044 2 : : : 19613 7044 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7044 4 . . . 19613 7045 1 20 20 CD 19613 7045 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7045 3 : : : 19613 7045 4 also also RB 19613 7045 5 IV IV NNP 19613 7045 6 . . . 19613 7046 1 6 6 CD 19613 7046 2 . . . 19613 7047 1 6 6 CD 19613 7047 2 : : : 19613 7047 3 " " `` 19613 7047 4 Invisibile Invisibile NNP 19613 7047 5 filii filii NN 19613 7047 6 pater pater NN 19613 7047 7 , , , 19613 7047 8 visibile visibile NNP 19613 7047 9 autem autem NNP 19613 7047 10 patris patris NNP 19613 7047 11 filius filius NNP 19613 7047 12 . . . 19613 7047 13 " " '' 19613 7048 1 Judging judge VBG 19613 7048 2 from from IN 19613 7048 3 this this DT 19613 7048 4 passage passage NN 19613 7048 5 , , , 19613 7048 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7048 7 is be VBZ 19613 7048 8 always always RB 19613 7048 9 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 7048 10 whether whether IN 19613 7048 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7048 12 , , , 19613 7048 13 like like IN 19613 7048 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7048 15 , , , 19613 7048 16 assumed assume VBD 19613 7048 17 that that IN 19613 7048 18 transcendency transcendency NN 19613 7048 19 belonged belong VBD 19613 7048 20 to to IN 19613 7048 21 the the DT 19613 7048 22 Father Father NNP 19613 7048 23 in in IN 19613 7048 24 a a DT 19613 7048 25 still still RB 19613 7048 26 higher high JJR 19613 7048 27 sense sense NN 19613 7048 28 than than IN 19613 7048 29 to to IN 19613 7048 30 the the DT 19613 7048 31 Son Son NNP 19613 7048 32 , , , 19613 7048 33 and and CC 19613 7048 34 that that IN 19613 7048 35 the the DT 19613 7048 36 nature nature NN 19613 7048 37 of of IN 19613 7048 38 the the DT 19613 7048 39 Son Son NNP 19613 7048 40 was be VBD 19613 7048 41 more more RBR 19613 7048 42 adapted adapted JJ 19613 7048 43 for for IN 19613 7048 44 entering enter VBG 19613 7048 45 the the DT 19613 7048 46 finite finite NN 19613 7048 47 than than IN 19613 7048 48 that that DT 19613 7048 49 of of IN 19613 7048 50 the the DT 19613 7048 51 Father Father NNP 19613 7048 52 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7048 53 on on IN 19613 7048 54 the the DT 19613 7048 55 contrary contrary NN 19613 7048 56 see see VB 19613 7048 57 IV IV NNP 19613 7048 58 . . . 19613 7049 1 20 20 CD 19613 7049 2 . . . 19613 7050 1 7 7 LS 19613 7050 2 and and CC 19613 7050 3 especially especially RB 19613 7050 4 IV IV NNP 19613 7050 5 . . . 19613 7051 1 24 24 CD 19613 7051 2 . . . 19613 7052 1 2 2 LS 19613 7052 2 : : : 19613 7052 3 " " `` 19613 7052 4 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7052 5 naturaliter naturaliter NNP 19613 7052 6 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7052 7 invisibile invisibile NN 19613 7052 8 " " '' 19613 7052 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7052 10 . . . 19613 7053 1 But but CC 19613 7053 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7053 3 ought ought MD 19613 7053 4 not not RB 19613 7053 5 to to TO 19613 7053 6 have have VB 19613 7053 7 been be VBN 19613 7053 8 denied deny VBN 19613 7053 9 that that IN 19613 7053 10 there there EX 19613 7053 11 are be VBP 19613 7053 12 passages passage NNS 19613 7053 13 , , , 19613 7053 14 in in IN 19613 7053 15 which which WDT 19613 7053 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7053 17 hints hint VBZ 19613 7053 18 at at IN 19613 7053 19 a a DT 19613 7053 20 subordination subordination NN 19613 7053 21 of of IN 19613 7053 22 the the DT 19613 7053 23 Son Son NNP 19613 7053 24 , , , 19613 7053 25 and and CC 19613 7053 26 deduces deduce VBZ 19613 7053 27 this this DT 19613 7053 28 from from IN 19613 7053 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7053 30 origin origin NN 19613 7053 31 . . . 19613 7054 1 See see VB 19613 7054 2 II II NNP 19613 7054 3 . . . 19613 7055 1 28 28 CD 19613 7055 2 . . . 19613 7056 1 8 8 LS 19613 7056 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7056 3 the the DT 19613 7056 4 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7056 5 of of IN 19613 7056 6 the the DT 19613 7056 7 Father Father NNP 19613 7056 8 reaches reach VBZ 19613 7056 9 further far RBR 19613 7056 10 than than IN 19613 7056 11 that that DT 19613 7056 12 of of IN 19613 7056 13 the the DT 19613 7056 14 Son Son NNP 19613 7056 15 and and CC 19613 7056 16 the the DT 19613 7056 17 Father Father NNP 19613 7056 18 is be VBZ 19613 7056 19 greater great JJR 19613 7056 20 than than IN 19613 7056 21 the the DT 19613 7056 22 Son Son NNP 19613 7056 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7056 24 ; ; : 19613 7056 25 III iii CD 19613 7056 26 . . . 19613 7057 1 6 6 CD 19613 7057 2 . . . 19613 7058 1 1 1 LS 19613 7058 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7058 3 the the DT 19613 7058 4 Son Son NNP 19613 7058 5 _ _ NNP 19613 7058 6 receives receive VBZ 19613 7058 7 _ _ NNP 19613 7058 8 from from IN 19613 7058 9 the the DT 19613 7058 10 Father Father NNP 19613 7058 11 the the DT 19613 7058 12 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 7058 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7058 14 ; ; : 19613 7058 15 IV IV NNP 19613 7058 16 . . . 19613 7059 1 17 17 CD 19613 7059 2 . . . 19613 7060 1 6 6 CD 19613 7060 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7060 3 a a DT 19613 7060 4 very very RB 19613 7060 5 important important JJ 19613 7060 6 passage passage NN 19613 7060 7 : : : 19613 7060 8 the the DT 19613 7060 9 Father Father NNP 19613 7060 10 owns own VBZ 19613 7060 11 the the DT 19613 7060 12 name name NN 19613 7060 13 of of IN 19613 7060 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7060 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7060 16 as as IN 19613 7060 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7060 18 , , , 19613 7060 19 first first RB 19613 7060 20 , , , 19613 7060 21 because because IN 19613 7060 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7060 23 is be VBZ 19613 7060 24 the the DT 19613 7060 25 name name NN 19613 7060 26 of of IN 19613 7060 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7060 28 Son Son NNP 19613 7060 29 , , , 19613 7060 30 and and CC 19613 7060 31 , , , 19613 7060 32 secondly secondly RB 19613 7060 33 , , , 19613 7060 34 because because IN 19613 7060 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7060 36 gave give VBD 19613 7060 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7060 38 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7060 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7060 40 ; ; : 19613 7060 41 V. V. NNP 19613 7060 42 18 18 CD 19613 7060 43 . . . 19613 7061 1 21 21 CD 19613 7061 2 , , , 19613 7061 3 3 3 CD 19613 7061 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7061 5 " " `` 19613 7061 6 pater pater NN 19613 7061 7 conditionem conditionem NNP 19613 7061 8 simul simul VBZ 19613 7061 9 et et NNP 19613 7061 10 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7061 11 suum suum NNP 19613 7061 12 portans"--"verbum portans"--"verbum NNP 19613 7061 13 portatum portatum NN 19613 7061 14 a a DT 19613 7061 15 patre"--"et patre"--"et NNP 19613 7061 16 sic sic NN 19613 7061 17 unus unus JJ 19613 7061 18 deus deus NNP 19613 7061 19 pater pater NNP 19613 7061 20 ostenditur ostenditur NNP 19613 7061 21 , , , 19613 7061 22 qui qui NNP 19613 7061 23 est est NNP 19613 7061 24 super sup AFX 19613 7061 25 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7061 26 et et NN 19613 7061 27 per per IN 19613 7061 28 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7061 29 et et NNP 19613 7061 30 in in IN 19613 7061 31 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 7061 32 ; ; : 19613 7061 33 super super NNP 19613 7061 34 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7061 35 pater pater NNP 19613 7061 36 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7061 37 et et NNP 19613 7061 38 ipse ipse NNP 19613 7061 39 est e JJS 19613 7061 40 caput caput VBD 19613 7061 41 Christi"--"verbum Christi"--"verbum NNP 19613 7061 42 universorum universorum NN 19613 7061 43 potestatem potestatem NN 19613 7061 44 habet habet VBD 19613 7061 45 a a DT 19613 7061 46 patre patre NN 19613 7061 47 " " '' 19613 7061 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7061 49 . . . 19613 7062 1 " " `` 19613 7062 2 This this DT 19613 7062 3 is be VBZ 19613 7062 4 not not RB 19613 7062 5 a a DT 19613 7062 6 subordination subordination NN 19613 7062 7 founded found VBN 19613 7062 8 on on IN 19613 7062 9 the the DT 19613 7062 10 nature nature NN 19613 7062 11 of of IN 19613 7062 12 the the DT 19613 7062 13 second second JJ 19613 7062 14 person person NN 19613 7062 15 , , , 19613 7062 16 but but CC 19613 7062 17 an an DT 19613 7062 18 inequality inequality NN 19613 7062 19 that that WDT 19613 7062 20 has have VBZ 19613 7062 21 arisen arise VBN 19613 7062 22 historically historically RB 19613 7062 23 , , , 19613 7062 24 " " '' 19613 7062 25 says say VBZ 19613 7062 26 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 7062 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7062 28 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7062 29 . . NNP 19613 7062 30 , , , 19613 7062 31 p. p. NNP 19613 7062 32 241 241 CD 19613 7062 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7062 34 ; ; : 19613 7062 35 but but CC 19613 7062 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7062 37 is be VBZ 19613 7062 38 doubtful doubtful JJ 19613 7062 39 whether whether IN 19613 7062 40 such such PDT 19613 7062 41 a a DT 19613 7062 42 distinction distinction NN 19613 7062 43 can can MD 19613 7062 44 be be VB 19613 7062 45 imputed impute VBN 19613 7062 46 to to IN 19613 7062 47 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7062 48 . . . 19613 7063 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7063 2 have have VBP 19613 7063 3 rather rather RB 19613 7063 4 simply simply RB 19613 7063 5 to to TO 19613 7063 6 recognise recognise VB 19613 7063 7 the the DT 19613 7063 8 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 7063 9 , , , 19613 7063 10 which which WDT 19613 7063 11 was be VBD 19613 7063 12 not not RB 19613 7063 13 felt feel VBN 19613 7063 14 by by IN 19613 7063 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7063 16 because because IN 19613 7063 17 , , , 19613 7063 18 in in IN 19613 7063 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7063 20 religious religious JJ 19613 7063 21 belief belief NN 19613 7063 22 , , , 19613 7063 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7063 24 places place VBZ 19613 7063 25 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7063 26 on on IN 19613 7063 27 a a DT 19613 7063 28 level level NN 19613 7063 29 with with IN 19613 7063 30 God God NNP 19613 7063 31 , , , 19613 7063 32 but but CC 19613 7063 33 , , , 19613 7063 34 as as IN 19613 7063 35 a a DT 19613 7063 36 theologian theologian NN 19613 7063 37 , , , 19613 7063 38 merely merely RB 19613 7063 39 touched touch VBD 19613 7063 40 on on IN 19613 7063 41 the the DT 19613 7063 42 problem problem NN 19613 7063 43 . . . 19613 7064 1 So so RB 19613 7064 2 also also RB 19613 7064 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7064 4 shows show VBZ 19613 7064 5 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 7064 6 unconcern unconcern JJ 19613 7064 7 as as IN 19613 7064 8 to to IN 19613 7064 9 the the DT 19613 7064 10 proof proof NN 19613 7064 11 of of IN 19613 7064 12 the the DT 19613 7064 13 unity unity NN 19613 7064 14 of of IN 19613 7064 15 God God NNP 19613 7064 16 in in IN 19613 7064 17 view view NN 19613 7064 18 of of IN 19613 7064 19 the the DT 19613 7064 20 distinction distinction NN 19613 7064 21 between between IN 19613 7064 22 Father Father NNP 19613 7064 23 and and CC 19613 7064 24 Son Son NNP 19613 7064 25 . . . 19613 7064 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7065 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7065 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7065 3 555 555 CD 19613 7065 4 : : : 19613 7065 5 Irenæus irenæus VB 19613 7065 6 very very RB 19613 7065 7 frequently frequently RB 19613 7065 8 emphasises emphasise VBZ 19613 7065 9 the the DT 19613 7065 10 idea idea NN 19613 7065 11 that that IN 19613 7065 12 the the DT 19613 7065 13 whole whole JJ 19613 7065 14 economy economy NN 19613 7065 15 of of IN 19613 7065 16 God God NNP 19613 7065 17 refers refer VBZ 19613 7065 18 to to IN 19613 7065 19 mankind mankind NN 19613 7065 20 , , , 19613 7065 21 see see VB 19613 7065 22 , , , 19613 7065 23 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7065 24 , , , 19613 7065 25 I. I. NNP 19613 7066 1 10 10 CD 19613 7066 2 . . . 19613 7067 1 3 3 LS 19613 7067 2 : : : 19613 7067 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7067 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7067 5 : : : 19613 7067 6 ekdiêgeisthai ekdiêgeisthai NNP 19613 7067 7 tên tên NNP 19613 7067 8 pragmateian pragmateian NNP 19613 7067 9 kai kai NNP 19613 7067 10 oikonomian oikonomian NNP 19613 7067 11 tou tou NNP 19613 7067 12 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7067 13 tên tên NNP 19613 7067 14 epi epi NNP 19613 7067 15 tê tê DT 19613 7067 16 anthrôpotêti anthrôpotêti NNP 19613 7067 17 genomenên genomenên NNP 19613 7067 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7067 19 , , , 19613 7067 20 IV IV NNP 19613 7067 21 , , , 19613 7067 22 20 20 CD 19613 7067 23 . . . 19613 7068 1 7 7 LS 19613 7068 2 : : : 19613 7068 3 " " `` 19613 7068 4 Verbum Verbum NNP 19613 7068 5 dispensator dispensator NN 19613 7068 6 paternæ paternæ NNP 19613 7068 7 gratiæ gratiæ NNP 19613 7068 8 factus factus NN 19613 7068 9 est est NNP 19613 7068 10 ad ad NN 19613 7068 11 utilitatem utilitatem NNP 19613 7068 12 hominum hominum NNP 19613 7068 13 , , , 19613 7068 14 propter propter NNP 19613 7068 15 quos quos NNP 19613 7068 16 fecit fecit NNP 19613 7068 17 tantas tantas NNP 19613 7068 18 dispositiones dispositione NNS 19613 7068 19 . . . 19613 7068 20 " " '' 19613 7069 1 God God NNP 19613 7069 2 became become VBD 19613 7069 3 a a DT 19613 7069 4 creator creator NN 19613 7069 5 out out IN 19613 7069 6 of of IN 19613 7069 7 goodness goodness NN 19613 7069 8 and and CC 19613 7069 9 love love NN 19613 7069 10 ; ; : 19613 7069 11 see see VB 19613 7069 12 the the DT 19613 7069 13 beautiful beautiful JJ 19613 7069 14 expression expression NN 19613 7069 15 in in IN 19613 7069 16 IV IV NNP 19613 7069 17 . . . 19613 7070 1 20 20 CD 19613 7070 2 . . . 19613 7071 1 7 7 LS 19613 7071 2 : : : 19613 7071 3 " " `` 19613 7071 4 Gloria Gloria NNP 19613 7071 5 dei dei NNP 19613 7071 6 vivens vivens NNP 19613 7071 7 homo homo NN 19613 7071 8 , , , 19613 7071 9 vita vita NNP 19613 7071 10 autem autem NNP 19613 7071 11 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7071 12 visio visio NNP 19613 7071 13 dei dei NNP 19613 7071 14 , , , 19613 7071 15 " " '' 19613 7071 16 or or CC 19613 7071 17 III III NNP 19613 7071 18 . . . 19613 7072 1 20 20 CD 19613 7072 2 . . . 19613 7073 1 2 2 LS 19613 7073 2 : : : 19613 7073 3 " " `` 19613 7073 4 Gloria Gloria NNP 19613 7073 5 hominis hominis NN 19613 7073 6 deus deus NN 19613 7073 7 , , , 19613 7073 8 operationes operatione NNS 19613 7073 9 vero vero NNP 19613 7073 10 dei dei NNP 19613 7073 11 et et NNP 19613 7073 12 omnis omnis NNP 19613 7073 13 sapientias sapientias NNP 19613 7073 14 eius eius NNP 19613 7073 15 et et NNP 19613 7073 16 virtutis virtutis NN 19613 7073 17 receptaculum receptaculum NNP 19613 7073 18 homo homo NNP 19613 7073 19 . . . 19613 7073 20 " " '' 19613 7074 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7074 2 29 29 CD 19613 7074 3 . . . 19613 7075 1 1 1 LS 19613 7075 2 : : : 19613 7075 3 " " `` 19613 7075 4 Non Non NNP 19613 7075 5 homo homo NN 19613 7075 6 propter propter NN 19613 7075 7 conditionem conditionem NNP 19613 7075 8 , , , 19613 7075 9 sed sed NNP 19613 7075 10 conditio conditio NNP 19613 7075 11 facta facta NNP 19613 7075 12 est est NNP 19613 7075 13 propter propter NNP 19613 7075 14 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7075 15 . . . 19613 7075 16 " " '' 19613 7075 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7076 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7076 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7076 3 556 556 CD 19613 7076 4 : : : 19613 7076 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7076 6 speaks speak VBZ 19613 7076 7 about about IN 19613 7076 8 the the DT 19613 7076 9 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7076 10 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7076 11 in in IN 19613 7076 12 numerous numerous JJ 19613 7076 13 passages passage NNS 19613 7076 14 . . . 19613 7077 1 No no RB 19613 7077 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 7077 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7077 4 firmly firmly RB 19613 7077 5 believes believe VBZ 19613 7077 6 in in IN 19613 7077 7 the the DT 19613 7077 8 distinction distinction NN 19613 7077 9 of of IN 19613 7077 10 the the DT 19613 7077 11 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7077 13 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7077 14 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 15 , , , 19613 7077 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 17 of of IN 19613 7077 18 God God NNP 19613 7077 19 , , , 19613 7077 20 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 21 of of IN 19613 7077 22 the the DT 19613 7077 23 Father Father NNP 19613 7077 24 , , , 19613 7077 25 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 26 of of IN 19613 7077 27 the the DT 19613 7077 28 Son Son NNP 19613 7077 29 , , , 19613 7077 30 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 7077 31 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 32 , , , 19613 7077 33 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 19613 7077 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7077 35 from from IN 19613 7077 36 the the DT 19613 7077 37 Father Father NNP 19613 7077 38 and and CC 19613 7077 39 Son Son NNP 19613 7077 40 , , , 19613 7077 41 and and CC 19613 7077 42 in in IN 19613 7077 43 a a DT 19613 7077 44 particular particular JJ 19613 7077 45 significance significance NN 19613 7077 46 belonging belong VBG 19613 7077 47 to to IN 19613 7077 48 the the DT 19613 7077 49 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7077 50 , , , 19613 7077 51 as as IN 19613 7077 52 these these DT 19613 7077 53 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 7077 54 are be VBP 19613 7077 55 found find VBN 19613 7077 56 in in IN 19613 7077 57 the the DT 19613 7077 58 _ _ NNP 19613 7077 59 regula regula NN 19613 7077 60 _ _ NNP 19613 7077 61 . . . 19613 7078 1 In in IN 19613 7078 2 general general JJ 19613 7078 3 the the DT 19613 7078 4 same same JJ 19613 7078 5 attributes attribute NNS 19613 7078 6 as as IN 19613 7078 7 are be VBP 19613 7078 8 assigned assign VBN 19613 7078 9 to to IN 19613 7078 10 the the DT 19613 7078 11 Son Son NNP 19613 7078 12 are be VBP 19613 7078 13 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 7078 14 applicable applicable JJ 19613 7078 15 to to IN 19613 7078 16 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7078 17 ; ; : 19613 7078 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7078 19 was be VBD 19613 7078 20 always always RB 19613 7078 21 with with IN 19613 7078 22 the the DT 19613 7078 23 Father Father NNP 19613 7078 24 before before IN 19613 7078 25 there there EX 19613 7078 26 was be VBD 19613 7078 27 any any DT 19613 7078 28 creation creation NN 19613 7078 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7078 30 IV IV NNP 19613 7078 31 . . . 19613 7079 1 20 20 CD 19613 7079 2 . . . 19613 7080 1 3 3 LS 19613 7080 2 ; ; : 19613 7080 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7080 4 applies apply VBZ 19613 7080 5 Prov Prov NNP 19613 7080 6 . . . 19613 7081 1 III iii CD 19613 7081 2 . . . 19613 7082 1 19 19 CD 19613 7082 2 : : : 19613 7082 3 VIII VIII NNP 19613 7082 4 . . . 19613 7083 1 22 22 CD 19613 7083 2 to to IN 19613 7083 3 the the DT 19613 7083 4 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7083 5 and and CC 19613 7083 6 not not RB 19613 7083 7 to to IN 19613 7083 8 the the DT 19613 7083 9 Son Son NNP 19613 7083 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7083 11 ; ; : 19613 7083 12 like like IN 19613 7083 13 the the DT 19613 7083 14 Son Son NNP 19613 7083 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7083 16 was be VBD 19613 7083 17 the the DT 19613 7083 18 instrument instrument NN 19613 7083 19 and and CC 19613 7083 20 hand hand NN 19613 7083 21 of of IN 19613 7083 22 the the DT 19613 7083 23 Father Father NNP 19613 7083 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7083 25 IV IV NNP 19613 7083 26 . . . 19613 7084 1 pref pref NNP 19613 7084 2 . . . 19613 7085 1 4 4 CD 19613 7085 2 , , , 19613 7085 3 20 20 CD 19613 7085 4 . . . 19613 7086 1 1 1 LS 19613 7086 2 : : : 19613 7086 3 V. V. NNP 19613 7086 4 6 6 CD 19613 7086 5 . . . 19613 7087 1 1 1 LS 19613 7087 2 . . . 19613 7087 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7087 4 . . . 19613 7088 1 That that IN 19613 7088 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7088 3 and and CC 19613 7088 4 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 19613 7088 5 are be VBP 19613 7088 6 to to TO 19613 7088 7 be be VB 19613 7088 8 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 7088 9 is be VBZ 19613 7088 10 clear clear JJ 19613 7088 11 from from IN 19613 7088 12 IV IV NNP 19613 7088 13 . . . 19613 7089 1 20 20 CD 19613 7089 2 . . . 19613 7090 1 1 1 CD 19613 7090 2 - - SYM 19613 7090 3 12 12 CD 19613 7090 4 and and CC 19613 7090 5 particularly particularly RB 19613 7090 6 from from IN 19613 7090 7 § § CD 19613 7090 8 12 12 CD 19613 7090 9 : : : 19613 7090 10 IV IV NNP 19613 7090 11 . . . 19613 7091 1 7 7 LS 19613 7091 2 . . . 19613 7092 1 4 4 LS 19613 7092 2 : : : 19613 7092 3 III iii CD 19613 7092 4 . . . 19613 7093 1 17 17 CD 19613 7093 2 . . . 19613 7094 1 3 3 LS 19613 7094 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7094 3 the the DT 19613 7094 4 host host NN 19613 7094 5 in in IN 19613 7094 6 the the DT 19613 7094 7 parable parable NN 19613 7094 8 of of IN 19613 7094 9 the the DT 19613 7094 10 Good Good NNP 19613 7094 11 Samaritan Samaritan NNP 19613 7094 12 is be VBZ 19613 7094 13 the the DT 19613 7094 14 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7094 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7094 16 . . . 19613 7095 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7095 2 also also RB 19613 7095 3 tried try VBD 19613 7095 4 by by IN 19613 7095 5 reference reference NN 19613 7095 6 to to IN 19613 7095 7 Scripture scripture NN 19613 7095 8 to to TO 19613 7095 9 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 7095 10 the the DT 19613 7095 11 work work NN 19613 7095 12 of of IN 19613 7095 13 the the DT 19613 7095 14 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7095 15 from from IN 19613 7095 16 that that DT 19613 7095 17 of of IN 19613 7095 18 the the DT 19613 7095 19 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7095 20 . . . 19613 7096 1 Thus thus RB 19613 7096 2 in in IN 19613 7096 3 the the DT 19613 7096 4 creation creation NN 19613 7096 5 , , , 19613 7096 6 the the DT 19613 7096 7 guidance guidance NN 19613 7096 8 of of IN 19613 7096 9 the the DT 19613 7096 10 world world NN 19613 7096 11 , , , 19613 7096 12 the the DT 19613 7096 13 Old Old NNP 19613 7096 14 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7096 15 history history NN 19613 7096 16 , , , 19613 7096 17 the the DT 19613 7096 18 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 7096 19 , , , 19613 7096 20 the the DT 19613 7096 21 baptism baptism NN 19613 7096 22 of of IN 19613 7096 23 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7096 24 , , , 19613 7096 25 the the DT 19613 7096 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7096 27 is be VBZ 19613 7096 28 the the DT 19613 7096 29 energy energy NN 19613 7096 30 , , , 19613 7096 31 the the DT 19613 7096 32 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7096 33 is be VBZ 19613 7096 34 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 7096 35 . . . 19613 7097 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7097 2 also also RB 19613 7097 3 alluded allude VBD 19613 7097 4 to to IN 19613 7097 5 a a DT 19613 7097 6 specific specific JJ 19613 7097 7 ministry ministry NN 19613 7097 8 of of IN 19613 7097 9 the the DT 19613 7097 10 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7097 11 in in IN 19613 7097 12 the the DT 19613 7097 13 sphere sphere NN 19613 7097 14 of of IN 19613 7097 15 the the DT 19613 7097 16 new new JJ 19613 7097 17 covenant covenant NN 19613 7097 18 . . . 19613 7098 1 The the DT 19613 7098 2 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7098 3 is be VBZ 19613 7098 4 the the DT 19613 7098 5 principle principle NN 19613 7098 6 of of IN 19613 7098 7 the the DT 19613 7098 8 new new JJ 19613 7098 9 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7098 10 in in IN 19613 7098 11 IV IV NNP 19613 7098 12 . . . 19613 7099 1 33 33 CD 19613 7099 2 . . . 19613 7100 1 1 1 CD 19613 7100 2 , , , 19613 7100 3 7 7 CD 19613 7100 4 , , , 19613 7100 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7100 6 of of IN 19613 7100 7 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 7100 8 with with IN 19613 7100 9 God God NNP 19613 7100 10 in in IN 19613 7100 11 V. V. NNP 19613 7100 12 I. I. NNP 19613 7101 1 1 1 CD 19613 7101 2 , , , 19613 7101 3 pledge pledge NN 19613 7101 4 of of IN 19613 7101 5 immortality immortality NN 19613 7101 6 in in IN 19613 7101 7 V. V. NNP 19613 7101 8 8 8 CD 19613 7101 9 . . . 19613 7102 1 1 1 LS 19613 7102 2 , , , 19613 7102 3 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7102 4 of of IN 19613 7102 5 life life NN 19613 7102 6 in in IN 19613 7102 7 V. V. NNP 19613 7102 8 18 18 CD 19613 7102 9 . . . 19613 7103 1 2 2 LS 19613 7103 2 . . . 19613 7104 1 But but CC 19613 7104 2 not not RB 19613 7104 3 only only RB 19613 7104 4 does do VBZ 19613 7104 5 the the DT 19613 7104 6 function function NN 19613 7104 7 of of IN 19613 7104 8 the the DT 19613 7104 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7104 10 remain remain VBP 19613 7104 11 very very RB 19613 7104 12 obscure obscure JJ 19613 7104 13 for for IN 19613 7104 14 all all PDT 19613 7104 15 that that DT 19613 7104 16 , , , 19613 7104 17 particularly particularly RB 19613 7104 18 in in IN 19613 7104 19 the the DT 19613 7104 20 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 7104 21 , , , 19613 7104 22 where where WRB 19613 7104 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7104 24 was be VBD 19613 7104 25 forced force VBN 19613 7104 26 by by IN 19613 7104 27 the the DT 19613 7104 28 canon canon NN 19613 7104 29 of of IN 19613 7104 30 the the DT 19613 7104 31 New New NNP 19613 7104 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7104 33 to to TO 19613 7104 34 unite unite VB 19613 7104 35 what what WP 19613 7104 36 could could MD 19613 7104 37 not not RB 19613 7104 38 be be VB 19613 7104 39 united united JJ 19613 7104 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7104 41 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7104 42 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 7104 43 and and CC 19613 7104 44 descent descent NN 19613 7104 45 of of IN 19613 7104 46 the the DT 19613 7104 47 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7104 48 upon upon IN 19613 7104 49 Mary Mary NNP 19613 7104 50 -- -- : 19613 7104 51 where where WRB 19613 7104 52 , , , 19613 7104 53 moreover moreover RB 19613 7104 54 , , , 19613 7104 55 the the DT 19613 7104 56 whole whole NN 19613 7104 57 of of IN 19613 7104 58 the the DT 19613 7104 59 Fathers father NNS 19613 7104 60 after after IN 19613 7104 61 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7104 62 launched launch VBD 19613 7104 63 forth forth RB 19613 7104 64 into into IN 19613 7104 65 the the DT 19613 7104 66 most most RBS 19613 7104 67 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 7104 68 speculations speculation NNS 19613 7104 69 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7104 70 , , , 19613 7104 71 but but CC 19613 7104 72 even even RB 19613 7104 73 the the DT 19613 7104 74 personality personality NN 19613 7104 75 of of IN 19613 7104 76 the the DT 19613 7104 77 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7104 78 vanishes vanishe NNS 19613 7104 79 with with IN 19613 7104 80 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7104 81 , , , 19613 7104 82 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7104 83 , , , 19613 7104 84 in in IN 19613 7104 85 III III NNP 19613 7104 86 . . . 19613 7105 1 18 18 CD 19613 7105 2 . . . 19613 7106 1 3 3 LS 19613 7106 2 : : : 19613 7106 3 " " `` 19613 7106 4 unguentem unguentem NNP 19613 7106 5 patrem patrem NN 19613 7106 6 et et NNP 19613 7106 7 unctum unctum NNP 19613 7106 8 filium filium NNP 19613 7106 9 et et NNP 19613 7106 10 unctionem unctionem NNP 19613 7106 11 , , , 19613 7106 12 qui qui NNP 19613 7106 13 est est NNP 19613 7106 14 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 7106 15 " " '' 19613 7106 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7106 17 on on IN 19613 7106 18 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 19613 7106 19 LXI LXI NNP 19613 7106 20 . . . 19613 7107 1 1 1 LS 19613 7107 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7107 3 ; ; : 19613 7107 4 there there EX 19613 7107 5 is be VBZ 19613 7107 6 also also RB 19613 7107 7 no no DT 19613 7107 8 mention mention NN 19613 7107 9 of of IN 19613 7107 10 the the DT 19613 7107 11 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7107 12 in in IN 19613 7107 13 IV IV NNP 19613 7107 14 . . . 19613 7108 1 pref pref NNP 19613 7108 2 . . . 19613 7109 1 4 4 CD 19613 7109 2 fin fin NNP 19613 7109 3 . . . 19613 7109 4 , , , 19613 7109 5 and and CC 19613 7109 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7109 7 . . . 19613 7110 1 1 1 LS 19613 7110 2 . . . 19613 7111 1 1 1 LS 19613 7111 2 , , , 19613 7111 3 though though IN 19613 7111 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7111 5 ought ought MD 19613 7111 6 to to TO 19613 7111 7 have have VB 19613 7111 8 been be VBN 19613 7111 9 named name VBN 19613 7111 10 there there RB 19613 7111 11 . . . 19613 7112 1 Father Father NNP 19613 7112 2 , , , 19613 7112 3 Son Son NNP 19613 7112 4 , , , 19613 7112 5 and and CC 19613 7112 6 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7112 7 , , , 19613 7112 8 or or CC 19613 7112 9 God God NNP 19613 7112 10 , , , 19613 7112 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7112 12 , , , 19613 7112 13 and and CC 19613 7112 14 Sophia Sophia NNP 19613 7112 15 are be VBP 19613 7112 16 frequently frequently RB 19613 7112 17 conjoined conjoin VBN 19613 7112 18 by by IN 19613 7112 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7112 20 , , , 19613 7112 21 but but CC 19613 7112 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7112 23 never never RB 19613 7112 24 uses use VBZ 19613 7112 25 the the DT 19613 7112 26 formula formula NN 19613 7112 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7112 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7112 29 : : : 19613 7112 30 trias tria NNS 19613 7112 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7112 32 , , , 19613 7112 33 to to TO 19613 7112 34 say say VB 19613 7112 35 nothing nothing NN 19613 7112 36 of of IN 19613 7112 37 the the DT 19613 7112 38 abstract abstract JJ 19613 7112 39 formulas formula NNS 19613 7112 40 of of IN 19613 7112 41 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7112 42 . . . 19613 7113 1 In in IN 19613 7113 2 two two CD 19613 7113 3 passages passage NNS 19613 7113 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7113 5 IV IV NNP 19613 7113 6 . . . 19613 7114 1 20 20 CD 19613 7114 2 . . . 19613 7115 1 5 5 LS 19613 7115 2 : : : 19613 7115 3 V. v. NN 19613 7115 4 36 36 CD 19613 7115 5 . . . 19613 7116 1 2 2 LS 19613 7116 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7116 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7116 4 unfolded unfold VBD 19613 7116 5 a a DT 19613 7116 6 sublime sublime JJ 19613 7116 7 speculation speculation NN 19613 7116 8 , , , 19613 7116 9 which which WDT 19613 7116 10 is be VBZ 19613 7116 11 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 19613 7116 12 with with IN 19613 7116 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7116 14 usual usual JJ 19613 7116 15 utterances utterance NNS 19613 7116 16 . . . 19613 7117 1 In in IN 19613 7117 2 the the DT 19613 7117 3 first first JJ 19613 7117 4 passage passage NN 19613 7117 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7117 6 says say VBZ 19613 7117 7 that that IN 19613 7117 8 God God NNP 19613 7117 9 has have VBZ 19613 7117 10 shown show VBN 19613 7117 11 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7117 12 prophetically prophetically RB 19613 7117 13 through through IN 19613 7117 14 the the DT 19613 7117 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7117 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7117 17 in in IN 19613 7117 18 the the DT 19613 7117 19 Old Old NNP 19613 7117 20 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7117 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7117 22 , , , 19613 7117 23 then then RB 19613 7117 24 adoptively adoptively RB 19613 7117 25 through through IN 19613 7117 26 the the DT 19613 7117 27 Son Son NNP 19613 7117 28 , , , 19613 7117 29 and and CC 19613 7117 30 will will MD 19613 7117 31 finally finally RB 19613 7117 32 show show VB 19613 7117 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7117 34 paternally paternally RB 19613 7117 35 in in IN 19613 7117 36 the the DT 19613 7117 37 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 7117 38 of of IN 19613 7117 39 heaven heaven NNP 19613 7117 40 ; ; : 19613 7117 41 the the DT 19613 7117 42 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7117 43 prepares prepare VBZ 19613 7117 44 man man NN 19613 7117 45 for for IN 19613 7117 46 the the DT 19613 7117 47 Son Son NNP 19613 7117 48 of of IN 19613 7117 49 God God NNP 19613 7117 50 , , , 19613 7117 51 the the DT 19613 7117 52 Son Son NNP 19613 7117 53 leads lead VBZ 19613 7117 54 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7117 55 to to IN 19613 7117 56 the the DT 19613 7117 57 Father Father NNP 19613 7117 58 , , , 19613 7117 59 but but CC 19613 7117 60 the the DT 19613 7117 61 Father Father NNP 19613 7117 62 confers confer VBZ 19613 7117 63 on on IN 19613 7117 64 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7117 65 immortality immortality NN 19613 7117 66 . . . 19613 7118 1 In in IN 19613 7118 2 the the DT 19613 7118 3 other other JJ 19613 7118 4 passage passage NN 19613 7118 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7118 6 adopts adopt VBZ 19613 7118 7 the the DT 19613 7118 8 saying saying NN 19613 7118 9 of of IN 19613 7118 10 an an DT 19613 7118 11 old old JJ 19613 7118 12 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 7118 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7118 14 Papias Papias NNP 19613 7118 15 ? ? . 19613 7118 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7119 1 that that IN 19613 7119 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7119 3 ascend ascend VBP 19613 7119 4 gradually gradually RB 19613 7119 5 through through IN 19613 7119 6 the the DT 19613 7119 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7119 8 to to IN 19613 7119 9 the the DT 19613 7119 10 Son Son NNP 19613 7119 11 , , , 19613 7119 12 and and CC 19613 7119 13 through through IN 19613 7119 14 the the DT 19613 7119 15 Son Son NNP 19613 7119 16 to to IN 19613 7119 17 the the DT 19613 7119 18 Father Father NNP 19613 7119 19 , , , 19613 7119 20 and and CC 19613 7119 21 that that IN 19613 7119 22 in in IN 19613 7119 23 the the DT 19613 7119 24 end end NN 19613 7119 25 the the DT 19613 7119 26 Son Son NNP 19613 7119 27 will will MD 19613 7119 28 deliver deliver VB 19613 7119 29 up up RP 19613 7119 30 everything everything NN 19613 7119 31 to to IN 19613 7119 32 the the DT 19613 7119 33 Father Father NNP 19613 7119 34 , , , 19613 7119 35 and and CC 19613 7119 36 God God NNP 19613 7119 37 will will MD 19613 7119 38 be be VB 19613 7119 39 all all DT 19613 7119 40 in in RB 19613 7119 41 all all DT 19613 7119 42 . . . 19613 7120 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7120 2 is be VBZ 19613 7120 3 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 7120 4 that that IN 19613 7120 5 , , , 19613 7120 6 as as IN 19613 7120 7 in in IN 19613 7120 8 the the DT 19613 7120 9 case case NN 19613 7120 10 of of IN 19613 7120 11 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7120 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7120 13 see see VB 19613 7120 14 above above RB 19613 7120 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7120 16 , , , 19613 7120 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7120 18 is be VBZ 19613 7120 19 1 1 CD 19613 7120 20 Cor Cor NNP 19613 7120 21 . . . 19613 7121 1 XV XV NNP 19613 7121 2 . . . 19613 7122 1 23 23 CD 19613 7122 2 - - SYM 19613 7122 3 28 28 CD 19613 7122 4 that that WDT 19613 7122 5 has have VBZ 19613 7122 6 produced produce VBN 19613 7122 7 this this DT 19613 7122 8 speculation speculation NN 19613 7122 9 . . . 19613 7123 1 This this DT 19613 7123 2 is be VBZ 19613 7123 3 another another DT 19613 7123 4 clear clear JJ 19613 7123 5 proof proof NN 19613 7123 6 , , , 19613 7123 7 that that IN 19613 7123 8 in in IN 19613 7123 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7123 10 the the DT 19613 7123 11 equality equality NN 19613 7123 12 of of IN 19613 7123 13 Father Father NNP 19613 7123 14 , , , 19613 7123 15 Son Son NNP 19613 7123 16 , , , 19613 7123 17 and and CC 19613 7123 18 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7123 19 is be VBZ 19613 7123 20 not not RB 19613 7123 21 unconditional unconditional JJ 19613 7123 22 and and CC 19613 7123 23 that that IN 19613 7123 24 the the DT 19613 7123 25 eternity eternity NN 19613 7123 26 of of IN 19613 7123 27 Son Son NNP 19613 7123 28 and and CC 19613 7123 29 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7123 30 is be VBZ 19613 7123 31 not not RB 19613 7123 32 absolute absolute JJ 19613 7123 33 . . . 19613 7124 1 Here here RB 19613 7124 2 also also RB 19613 7124 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7124 4 plainly plainly RB 19613 7124 5 perceive perceive VBP 19613 7124 6 that that IN 19613 7124 7 the the DT 19613 7124 8 several several JJ 19613 7124 9 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 7124 10 in in IN 19613 7124 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7124 12 were be VBD 19613 7124 13 by by IN 19613 7124 14 no no DT 19613 7124 15 means means NN 19613 7124 16 part part NN 19613 7124 17 of of IN 19613 7124 18 a a DT 19613 7124 19 complete complete JJ 19613 7124 20 system system NN 19613 7124 21 . . . 19613 7125 1 Thus thus RB 19613 7125 2 , , , 19613 7125 3 in in IN 19613 7125 4 IV IV NNP 19613 7125 5 . . . 19613 7126 1 38 38 CD 19613 7126 2 . . . 19613 7127 1 2 2 CD 19613 7127 2 , , , 19613 7127 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7127 4 inverts invert VBZ 19613 7127 5 the the DT 19613 7127 6 relationship relationship NN 19613 7127 7 and and CC 19613 7127 8 says say VBZ 19613 7127 9 that that IN 19613 7127 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7127 11 ascend ascend VBP 19613 7127 12 from from IN 19613 7127 13 the the DT 19613 7127 14 Son Son NNP 19613 7127 15 to to IN 19613 7127 16 the the DT 19613 7127 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7127 18 : : : 19613 7127 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7127 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7127 21 : : : 19613 7127 22 Kai Kai NNP 19613 7127 23 dia dia IN 19613 7127 24 touto touto NNP 19613 7127 25 Paulos Paulos NNP 19613 7127 26 Korinthiois Korinthiois NNP 19613 7127 27 phêsi phêsi NN 19613 7127 28 : : : 19613 7127 29 gala gala NNP 19613 7127 30 humas humas NNPS 19613 7127 31 epotisa epotisa NNP 19613 7127 32 , , , 19613 7127 33 ou ou NNP 19613 7127 34 Brôma Brôma NNP 19613 7127 35 , , , 19613 7127 36 oude oude NN 19613 7127 37 gar gar NNP 19613 7127 38 êdunasthe êdunasthe NNP 19613 7127 39 bastazein bastazein NNP 19613 7127 40 ; ; : 19613 7127 41 toutesti toutesti NNP 19613 7127 42 , , , 19613 7127 43 tên tên NNP 19613 7127 44 men man NNS 19613 7127 45 kata kata NNP 19613 7127 46 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 7127 47 parousian parousian NNP 19613 7127 48 tou tou NNP 19613 7127 49 kuriou kuriou NNP 19613 7127 50 emathêteuthête emathêteuthête NNP 19613 7127 51 , , , 19613 7127 52 oudêpou oudêpou NNP 19613 7127 53 de de NNP 19613 7127 54 to to IN 19613 7127 55 tou tou NNP 19613 7127 56 patros patros NNP 19613 7127 57 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 7127 58 epanapauetai epanapauetai NNP 19613 7127 59 eph eph NNP 19613 7127 60 ' ' POS 19613 7127 61 humas humas NNP 19613 7127 62 dia dia NNP 19613 7127 63 tên tên NNP 19613 7127 64 humôn humôn NNP 19613 7127 65 astheneian astheneian NNP 19613 7127 66 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7127 67 . . . 19613 7128 1 Here here RB 19613 7128 2 one one CD 19613 7128 3 of of IN 19613 7128 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 7128 5 's 's POS 19613 7128 6 thoughts thought NNS 19613 7128 7 appears appear VBZ 19613 7128 8 . . . 19613 7128 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7129 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7129 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7129 3 557 557 CD 19613 7129 4 : : : 19613 7129 5 The the DT 19613 7129 6 opinions opinion NNS 19613 7129 7 advanced advance VBN 19613 7129 8 here here RB 19613 7129 9 are be VBP 19613 7129 10 , , , 19613 7129 11 of of IN 19613 7129 12 course course NN 19613 7129 13 , , , 19613 7129 14 adumbrations adumbration NNS 19613 7129 15 of of IN 19613 7129 16 the the DT 19613 7129 17 ideas idea NNS 19613 7129 18 about about IN 19613 7129 19 redemption redemption NN 19613 7129 20 . . . 19613 7130 1 Noldechen Noldechen NNP 19613 7130 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7130 3 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 7130 4 fur fur NN 19613 7130 5 wissenschaftliche wissenschaftliche NN 19613 7130 6 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 7130 7 , , , 19613 7130 8 1885 1885 CD 19613 7130 9 , , , 19613 7130 10 p. p. NN 19613 7130 11 462 462 CD 19613 7130 12 ff ff NN 19613 7130 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7130 14 : : : 19613 7130 15 " " `` 19613 7130 16 Die die VB 19613 7130 17 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 7130 18 vom vom NNS 19613 7130 19 ersten ersten VBN 19613 7130 20 Menschen Menschen NNP 19613 7130 21 bei bei NNP 19613 7130 22 den den VB 19613 7130 23 christlichen christlichen NNP 19613 7130 24 Lehrern Lehrern NNP 19613 7130 25 des des NNP 19613 7130 26 2 2 CD 19613 7130 27 Jahrhunderts jahrhundert NNS 19613 7130 28 . . . 19613 7130 29 " " '' 19613 7130 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7131 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7131 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7131 3 558 558 CD 19613 7131 4 : : : 19613 7131 5 Here here RB 19613 7131 6 the the DT 19613 7131 7 whole whole JJ 19613 7131 8 38th 38th JJ 19613 7131 9 chapter chapter NN 19613 7131 10 of of IN 19613 7131 11 the the DT 19613 7131 12 4th 4th JJ 19613 7131 13 Book Book NNP 19613 7131 14 is be VBZ 19613 7131 15 to to TO 19613 7131 16 be be VB 19613 7131 17 examined examine VBN 19613 7131 18 . . . 19613 7132 1 The the DT 19613 7132 2 following follow VBG 19613 7132 3 sentences sentence NNS 19613 7132 4 are be VBP 19613 7132 5 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 7132 6 the the DT 19613 7132 7 most most RBS 19613 7132 8 important important JJ 19613 7132 9 : : : 19613 7132 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7132 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7132 12 : : : 19613 7132 13 Ei Ei NNP 19613 7132 14 de de NNP 19613 7132 15 legei legei NNP 19613 7132 16 tis tis NNP 19613 7132 17 ouk ouk NNP 19613 7132 18 êdunato êdunato NNP 19613 7132 19 ho ho NNP 19613 7132 20 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7132 21 ap ap NNP 19613 7132 22 ' ' POS 19613 7132 23 archês archês NN 19613 7132 24 teleion teleion NN 19613 7132 25 anadeixai anadeixai IN 19613 7132 26 ton ton NN 19613 7132 27 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNS 19613 7132 28 , , , 19613 7132 29 Gnôtô Gnôtô NNP 19613 7132 30 , , , 19613 7132 31 hoti hoti NNP 19613 7132 32 tô tô NNP 19613 7132 33 men man NNS 19613 7132 34 Theô Theô NNP 19613 7132 35 , , , 19613 7132 36 aei aei NNP 19613 7132 37 kata kata NNP 19613 7132 38 ta ta NNP 19613 7132 39 auta auta NNP 19613 7132 40 onti onti NNP 19613 7132 41 kai kai NNP 19613 7132 42 agennêtô agennêtô NNP 19613 7132 43 huparchonti huparchonti NNP 19613 7132 44 , , , 19613 7132 45 hôs hôs NNP 19613 7132 46 pros pros NNP 19613 7132 47 heauton heauton NNP 19613 7132 48 , , , 19613 7132 49 panta panta NNP 19613 7132 50 dunata dunata NNP 19613 7132 51 ; ; : 19613 7132 52 ta ta NNP 19613 7132 53 de de NNP 19613 7132 54 gegonta gegonta NNP 19613 7132 55 , , , 19613 7132 56 katho katho NNP 19613 7132 57 metepeita metepeita NNP 19613 7132 58 geneseôs geneseôs NN 19613 7132 59 archên archên NNP 19613 7132 60 idian idian NNP 19613 7132 61 esche esche NNP 19613 7132 62 , , , 19613 7132 63 kata kata NNP 19613 7132 64 touto touto NNP 19613 7132 65 kai kai NNP 19613 7132 66 hustereisthai hustereisthai NNP 19613 7132 67 dei dei NNP 19613 7132 68 auta auta NNP 19613 7132 69 tou tou NNP 19613 7132 70 pepoiêkotos pepoiêkotos NNP 19613 7132 71 ; ; : 19613 7132 72 ou ou NNP 19613 7132 73 gar gar NNP 19613 7132 74 êdunanto êdunanto NNP 19613 7132 75 agennêta agennêta NNP 19613 7132 76 einai einai NNP 19613 7132 77 ta ta NNP 19613 7132 78 neôsti neôsti NNP 19613 7132 79 gegennêmena gegennêmena NNP 19613 7132 80 . . . 19613 7133 1 Katho Katho NNP 19613 7133 2 de de NNP 19613 7133 3 mê mê NNP 19613 7133 4 estin estin NNP 19613 7133 5 agennêta agennêta NNP 19613 7133 6 , , , 19613 7133 7 kata kata NNP 19613 7133 8 touto touto NNP 19613 7133 9 kai kai NNP 19613 7133 10 husterountai husterountai NNP 19613 7133 11 tou tou NNP 19613 7133 12 teleiou teleiou NNP 19613 7133 13 . . . 19613 7134 1 Katho Katho NNP 19613 7134 2 de de NNP 19613 7134 3 neôtera neôtera NNP 19613 7134 4 , , , 19613 7134 5 kata kata NNP 19613 7134 6 touto touto NNP 19613 7134 7 kai kai NNP 19613 7134 8 nêpia nêpia NNP 19613 7134 9 , , , 19613 7134 10 kata kata NNP 19613 7134 11 touto touto NNP 19613 7134 12 kai kai NNP 19613 7134 13 asunêthê asunêthê NNP 19613 7134 14 kai kai NNP 19613 7134 15 agumnasta agumnasta NNP 19613 7134 16 pros pros NNP 19613 7134 17 tên tên NNP 19613 7134 18 teleian teleian NNP 19613 7134 19 agôgên agôgên NNP 19613 7134 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7134 21 . . . 19613 7135 1 The the DT 19613 7135 2 mother mother NN 19613 7135 3 can can MD 19613 7135 4 no no RB 19613 7135 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 7135 6 give give VB 19613 7135 7 strong strong JJ 19613 7135 8 food food NN 19613 7135 9 to to IN 19613 7135 10 the the DT 19613 7135 11 child child NN 19613 7135 12 at at IN 19613 7135 13 the the DT 19613 7135 14 very very JJ 19613 7135 15 beginning beginning NN 19613 7135 16 , , , 19613 7135 17 but but CC 19613 7135 18 the the DT 19613 7135 19 child child NN 19613 7135 20 can can MD 19613 7135 21 not not RB 19613 7135 22 stand stand VB 19613 7135 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7135 24 : : : 19613 7135 25 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7135 26 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7135 27 : : : 19613 7135 28 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 7135 29 adunatos adunatos NNP 19613 7135 30 labein labein NNP 19613 7135 31 auto auto NNP 19613 7135 32 ; ; : 19613 7135 33 nêpios nêpio NNS 19613 7135 34 gar gar NNP 19613 7135 35 ên ên NNP 19613 7135 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7135 37 , , , 19613 7135 38 see see VB 19613 7135 39 also also RB 19613 7135 40 § § CD 19613 7135 41 2 2 CD 19613 7135 42 - - SYM 19613 7135 43 4 4 CD 19613 7135 44 : : : 19613 7135 45 " " `` 19613 7135 46 Non Non NNP 19613 7135 47 ab ab NNP 19613 7135 48 initio initio NN 19613 7135 49 dii dii NNP 19613 7135 50 facti facti NNP 19613 7135 51 sumus sumus NNP 19613 7135 52 , , , 19613 7135 53 sed sed NNP 19613 7135 54 primo primo NNP 19613 7135 55 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7135 56 homines homines NNPS 19613 7135 57 , , , 19613 7135 58 tunc tunc NN 19613 7135 59 demum demum NNP 19613 7135 60 dii dii NNP 19613 7135 61 , , , 19613 7135 62 quamvis quamvis NNP 19613 7135 63 deus deus NNP 19613 7135 64 secundum secundum NN 19613 7135 65 simplicitatem simplicitatem NN 19613 7135 66 bonitatis bonitatis NN 19613 7135 67 suæ suæ NNP 19613 7135 68 hoc hoc FW 19613 7135 69 fecerit fecerit NNP 19613 7135 70 , , , 19613 7135 71 nequis nequis NNP 19613 7135 72 eum eum NNP 19613 7135 73 putet putet NNP 19613 7135 74 invidiosum invidiosum NNP 19613 7135 75 aut aut NNP 19613 7135 76 impræstantem impræstantem NNP 19613 7135 77 . . . 19613 7135 78 " " '' 19613 7136 1 " " `` 19613 7136 2 Ego ego NN 19613 7136 3 , , , 19613 7136 4 " " '' 19613 7136 5 inquit inquit NN 19613 7136 6 , , , 19613 7136 7 " " '' 19613 7136 8 dixi dixi NNS 19613 7136 9 , , , 19613 7136 10 dii dii NNP 19613 7136 11 estis estis NNP 19613 7136 12 et et NNP 19613 7136 13 filii filii VBP 19613 7136 14 excelsi excelsi NNP 19613 7136 15 omnes omnes NNP 19613 7136 16 , , , 19613 7136 17 nobis nobis NNP 19613 7136 18 autem autem NNP 19613 7136 19 potestatem potestatem NNP 19613 7136 20 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 7136 21 baiulare baiulare VB 19613 7136 22 non non NNP 19613 7136 23 sustinentibus sustinentibus NNP 19613 7136 24 " " '' 19613 7136 25 ... ... : 19613 7136 26 " " `` 19613 7136 27 Oportuerat Oportuerat NNP 19613 7136 28 autem autem NN 19613 7136 29 primo primo NNP 19613 7136 30 naturam naturam NNP 19613 7136 31 apparere apparere NNP 19613 7136 32 , , , 19613 7136 33 post post NNP 19613 7136 34 deinde deinde NNP 19613 7136 35 vinci vinci NNP 19613 7136 36 et et NNP 19613 7136 37 absorbi absorbi NNP 19613 7136 38 mortale mortale NNP 19613 7136 39 ab ab NNP 19613 7136 40 immortalitate immortalitate IN 19613 7136 41 et et NNP 19613 7136 42 corruptibile corruptibile NNP 19613 7136 43 ab ab NNP 19613 7136 44 incorruptibilitate incorruptibilitate NNP 19613 7136 45 , , , 19613 7136 46 et et NNP 19613 7136 47 fieri fieri NNP 19613 7136 48 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7136 49 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7136 50 imaginem imaginem NNP 19613 7136 51 et et NNP 19613 7136 52 similitudinem similitudinem NNP 19613 7136 53 dei dei NNP 19613 7136 54 , , , 19613 7136 55 agnitione agnitione NNP 19613 7136 56 accepta accepta NNP 19613 7136 57 boni boni NNP 19613 7136 58 et et NNP 19613 7136 59 mali mali NNP 19613 7136 60 . . . 19613 7136 61 " " '' 19613 7137 1 Ibid ibid RB 19613 7137 2 . . . 19613 7138 1 : : : 19613 7138 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7138 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7138 4 : : : 19613 7138 5 hupotagê hupotagê NNP 19613 7138 6 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7138 7 aptharsia aptharsia NNP 19613 7138 8 , , , 19613 7138 9 kai kai NNP 19613 7138 10 paramonê paramonê NNP 19613 7138 11 aptharsias aptharsias NNP 19613 7138 12 doxa doxa NNP 19613 7138 13 agennêtos agennêto NNS 19613 7138 14 ... ... : 19613 7138 15 horasis horasis NN 19613 7138 16 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7138 17 peripoiêtikê peripoiêtikê NNP 19613 7138 18 aptharsias aptharsias NNP 19613 7138 19 ; ; : 19613 7138 20 aptharsia aptharsia NNP 19613 7138 21 de de NNP 19613 7138 22 eggus eggus NNP 19613 7138 23 einai einai NNP 19613 7138 24 poiei poiei NN 19613 7138 25 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7138 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7138 27 . . . 19613 7139 1 In in IN 19613 7139 2 this this DT 19613 7139 3 chapter chapter NN 19613 7139 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7139 5 contemplates contemplate VBZ 19613 7139 6 the the DT 19613 7139 7 manner manner NN 19613 7139 8 of of IN 19613 7139 9 appearance appearance NN 19613 7139 10 of of IN 19613 7139 11 the the DT 19613 7139 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7139 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7139 14 as as IN 19613 7139 15 man man NN 19613 7139 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7139 17 from from IN 19613 7139 18 the the DT 19613 7139 19 point point NN 19613 7139 20 of of IN 19613 7139 21 view view NN 19613 7139 22 of of IN 19613 7139 23 a a DT 19613 7139 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7139 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7139 26 : : : 19613 7139 27 sunnêpiazein sunnêpiazein NN 19613 7139 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7139 29 . . . 19613 7140 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7140 2 conception conception NN 19613 7140 3 of of IN 19613 7140 4 the the DT 19613 7140 5 capacity capacity NN 19613 7140 6 and and CC 19613 7140 7 destination destination NN 19613 7140 8 of of IN 19613 7140 9 man man NN 19613 7140 10 enabled enable VBD 19613 7140 11 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7140 12 to to TO 19613 7140 13 develop develop VB 19613 7140 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7140 15 ideas idea NNS 19613 7140 16 about about IN 19613 7140 17 the the DT 19613 7140 18 progressive progressive JJ 19613 7140 19 training training NN 19613 7140 20 of of IN 19613 7140 21 the the DT 19613 7140 22 human human JJ 19613 7140 23 race race NN 19613 7140 24 and and CC 19613 7140 25 about about IN 19613 7140 26 the the DT 19613 7140 27 different different JJ 19613 7140 28 covenants covenant NNS 19613 7140 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7140 30 see see VB 19613 7140 31 below below RB 19613 7140 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7140 33 . . . 19613 7141 1 On on IN 19613 7141 2 this this DT 19613 7141 3 point point NN 19613 7141 4 cf cf NN 19613 7141 5 . . . 19613 7142 1 also also RB 19613 7142 2 IV IV NNP 19613 7142 3 . . . 19613 7143 1 20 20 CD 19613 7143 2 . . . 19613 7144 1 5 5 CD 19613 7144 2 - - SYM 19613 7144 3 7 7 CD 19613 7144 4 . . . 19613 7145 1 The the DT 19613 7145 2 fact fact NN 19613 7145 3 that that IN 19613 7145 4 , , , 19613 7145 5 according accord VBG 19613 7145 6 to to IN 19613 7145 7 this this DT 19613 7145 8 way way NN 19613 7145 9 of of IN 19613 7145 10 looking look VBG 19613 7145 11 at at IN 19613 7145 12 things thing NNS 19613 7145 13 , , , 19613 7145 14 the the DT 19613 7145 15 Good Good NNP 19613 7145 16 and and CC 19613 7145 17 Divine Divine NNP 19613 7145 18 appeared appear VBD 19613 7145 19 only only RB 19613 7145 20 as as IN 19613 7145 21 the the DT 19613 7145 22 _ _ NNP 19613 7145 23 destination destination NN 19613 7145 24 _ _ NNP 19613 7145 25 of of IN 19613 7145 26 man man NN 19613 7145 27 -- -- : 19613 7145 28 which which WDT 19613 7145 29 was be VBD 19613 7145 30 finally finally RB 19613 7145 31 to to TO 19613 7145 32 be be VB 19613 7145 33 reached reach VBN 19613 7145 34 through through IN 19613 7145 35 divine divine JJ 19613 7145 36 guidance guidance NN 19613 7145 37 -- -- : 19613 7145 38 but but CC 19613 7145 39 not not RB 19613 7145 40 as as IN 19613 7145 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7145 42 _ _ NNP 19613 7145 43 nature nature NN 19613 7145 44 _ _ NNP 19613 7145 45 , , , 19613 7145 46 suggested suggest VBD 19613 7145 47 both both DT 19613 7145 48 to to IN 19613 7145 49 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7145 50 and and CC 19613 7145 51 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7145 52 the the DT 19613 7145 53 distinction distinction NN 19613 7145 54 between between IN 19613 7145 55 " " `` 19613 7145 56 natura natura NNP 19613 7145 57 " " '' 19613 7145 58 and and CC 19613 7145 59 " " `` 19613 7145 60 gratia gratia NN 19613 7145 61 " " '' 19613 7145 62 or or CC 19613 7145 63 between between IN 19613 7145 64 " " `` 19613 7145 65 substantia substantia NNS 19613 7145 66 " " '' 19613 7145 67 and and CC 19613 7145 68 " " `` 19613 7145 69 fides fides NNPS 19613 7145 70 et et FW 19613 7145 71 iustitia iustitia NN 19613 7145 72 . . . 19613 7145 73 " " '' 19613 7146 1 In in IN 19613 7146 2 other other JJ 19613 7146 3 words word NNS 19613 7146 4 , , , 19613 7146 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7146 6 were be VBD 19613 7146 7 led lead VBN 19613 7146 8 to to TO 19613 7146 9 propound propound VB 19613 7146 10 a a DT 19613 7146 11 problem problem NN 19613 7146 12 which which WDT 19613 7146 13 had have VBD 19613 7146 14 occurred occur VBN 19613 7146 15 to to IN 19613 7146 16 the the DT 19613 7146 17 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 7146 18 long long RB 19613 7146 19 before before RB 19613 7146 20 , , , 19613 7146 21 and and CC 19613 7146 22 had have VBD 19613 7146 23 been be VBN 19613 7146 24 solved solve VBN 19613 7146 25 by by IN 19613 7146 26 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7146 27 in in IN 19613 7146 28 a a DT 19613 7146 29 dualistic dualistic JJ 19613 7146 30 sense sense NN 19613 7146 31 . . . 19613 7147 1 See see VB 19613 7147 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7147 3 II II NNP 19613 7147 4 . . . 19613 7148 1 29 29 CD 19613 7148 2 . . . 19613 7149 1 1 1 LS 19613 7149 2 : : : 19613 7149 3 " " `` 19613 7149 4 Si Si NNP 19613 7149 5 propter propter NN 19613 7149 6 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 7149 7 omnes omnes NNP 19613 7149 8 succedunt succedunt NNP 19613 7149 9 animæ animæ NNP 19613 7149 10 in in IN 19613 7149 11 refrigerium refrigerium NN 19613 7149 12 , , , 19613 7149 13 et et NNP 19613 7149 14 superfluum superfluum NNP 19613 7149 15 est est NNP 19613 7149 16 credere credere NNP 19613 7149 17 , , , 19613 7149 18 superflua superflua NNP 19613 7149 19 autem autem NNP 19613 7149 20 et et NNP 19613 7149 21 discessio discessio VBP 19613 7149 22 salvatoris salvatoris NNP 19613 7149 23 ; ; : 19613 7149 24 si si XX 19613 7149 25 autem autem NNP 19613 7149 26 propter propter NNP 19613 7149 27 iustitiam iustitiam NNP 19613 7149 28 , , , 19613 7149 29 iam iam NNP 19613 7149 30 non non AFX 19613 7149 31 propter propter NN 19613 7149 32 i -PRON- PRP 19613 7149 33 d d NN 19613 7149 34 , , , 19613 7149 35 quod quod NN 19613 7149 36 sint sint NNP 19613 7149 37 animæ animæ NNP 19613 7149 38 sed sed NNP 19613 7149 39 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 7149 40 sunt sunt NN 19613 7149 41 iustæ iustæ NN 19613 7149 42 ... ... : 19613 7149 43 Si si NN 19613 7149 44 enim enim NNP 19613 7149 45 natura natura NNP 19613 7149 46 et et NNP 19613 7149 47 substantia substantia NNP 19613 7149 48 salvat salvat NNP 19613 7149 49 , , , 19613 7149 50 omnes omne NNS 19613 7149 51 salvabuntur salvabuntur NNP 19613 7149 52 animæ animæ NNP 19613 7149 53 ; ; : 19613 7149 54 si si NNP 19613 7149 55 autem autem NNP 19613 7149 56 iustitia iustitia NNP 19613 7149 57 et et NNP 19613 7149 58 fides fide NNS 19613 7149 59 etc etc FW 19613 7149 60 . . . 19613 7149 61 " " '' 19613 7150 1 II ii CD 19613 7150 2 . . . 19613 7151 1 34 34 CD 19613 7151 2 . . . 19613 7152 1 3 3 LS 19613 7152 2 : : : 19613 7152 3 " " `` 19613 7152 4 Non Non NNP 19613 7152 5 enim enim NNP 19613 7152 6 ex ex NNP 19613 7152 7 nobis nobis NNP 19613 7152 8 neque neque NNP 19613 7152 9 ex ex NNP 19613 7152 10 nostra nostra NNP 19613 7152 11 natura natura NNP 19613 7152 12 vita vita NNP 19613 7152 13 est est NNP 19613 7152 14 , , , 19613 7152 15 sed sed NNP 19613 7152 16 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7152 17 gratiam gratiam NNP 19613 7152 18 dei dei NNP 19613 7152 19 datur datur NNP 19613 7152 20 , , , 19613 7152 21 " " '' 19613 7152 22 II ii CD 19613 7152 23 . . . 19613 7153 1 34 34 CD 19613 7153 2 . . . 19613 7154 1 4 4 LS 19613 7154 2 . . . 19613 7155 1 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 7155 2 adv adv NN 19613 7155 3 . . . 19613 7156 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7156 2 . . . 19613 7157 1 III iii CD 19613 7157 2 . . . 19613 7158 1 15 15 CD 19613 7158 2 : : : 19613 7158 3 " " `` 19613 7158 4 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7158 5 nomen noman NNS 19613 7158 6 non non AFX 19613 7158 7 ex ex NNP 19613 7158 8 natura natura NNP 19613 7158 9 veniens veniens NNP 19613 7158 10 , , , 19613 7158 11 sed sed NNP 19613 7158 12 ex ex NNP 19613 7158 13 dispositione dispositione NN 19613 7158 14 . . . 19613 7158 15 " " '' 19613 7159 1 In in IN 19613 7159 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7159 3 these these DT 19613 7159 4 ideas idea NNS 19613 7159 5 are be VBP 19613 7159 6 not not RB 19613 7159 7 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 7159 8 opposed oppose VBN 19613 7159 9 to to IN 19613 7159 10 each each DT 19613 7159 11 other other JJ 19613 7159 12 in in IN 19613 7159 13 this this DT 19613 7159 14 way way NN 19613 7159 15 ; ; : 19613 7159 16 but but CC 19613 7159 17 the the DT 19613 7159 18 relationship relationship NN 19613 7159 19 between between IN 19613 7159 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7159 21 has have VBZ 19613 7159 22 by by IN 19613 7159 23 no no DT 19613 7159 24 means means NN 19613 7159 25 been be VBN 19613 7159 26 made make VBN 19613 7159 27 clear clear JJ 19613 7159 28 . . . 19613 7159 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7160 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7160 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7160 3 559 559 CD 19613 7160 4 : : : 19613 7160 5 On on IN 19613 7160 6 the the DT 19613 7160 7 psychology psychology NN 19613 7160 8 of of IN 19613 7160 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7160 10 see see VBP 19613 7160 11 Bohringer Bohringer NNP 19613 7160 12 , , , 19613 7160 13 p. p. NN 19613 7160 14 466 466 CD 19613 7160 15 f. f. NNS 19613 7160 16 , , , 19613 7160 17 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 7160 18 p. p. NN 19613 7160 19 22 22 CD 19613 7160 20 . . . 19613 7161 1 The the DT 19613 7161 2 fact fact NN 19613 7161 3 that that IN 19613 7161 4 in in IN 19613 7161 5 some some DT 19613 7161 6 passages passage NNS 19613 7161 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7161 8 reckoned reckon VBD 19613 7161 9 the the DT 19613 7161 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7161 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7161 12 : : : 19613 7161 13 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 7161 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7161 15 in in IN 19613 7161 16 man man NN 19613 7161 17 as as IN 19613 7161 18 the the DT 19613 7161 19 latter latter NN 19613 7161 20 's 's POS 19613 7161 21 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 7161 22 nature nature NN 19613 7161 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7161 24 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7162 1 II ii CD 19613 7162 2 . . . 19613 7163 1 33 33 CD 19613 7163 2 - - SYM 19613 7163 3 5 5 CD 19613 7163 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7163 5 , , , 19613 7163 6 though though IN 19613 7163 7 as as IN 19613 7163 8 a a DT 19613 7163 9 rule rule NN 19613 7163 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7163 11 like like IN 19613 7163 12 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 7163 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7163 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7163 15 conceives conceive VBZ 19613 7163 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7163 17 as as IN 19613 7163 18 the the DT 19613 7163 19 divine divine JJ 19613 7163 20 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7163 21 , , , 19613 7163 22 is be VBZ 19613 7163 23 an an DT 19613 7163 24 evident evident JJ 19613 7163 25 inconsistency inconsistency NN 19613 7163 26 on on IN 19613 7163 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7163 28 part part NN 19613 7163 29 . . . 19613 7164 1 The the DT 19613 7164 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7164 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7164 4 : : : 19613 7164 5 eikôn eikôn NN 19613 7164 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7164 7 is be VBZ 19613 7164 8 realised realise VBN 19613 7164 9 in in IN 19613 7164 10 the the DT 19613 7164 11 body body NN 19613 7164 12 , , , 19613 7164 13 the the DT 19613 7164 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7164 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7164 16 : : : 19613 7164 17 homoiôsis homoiôsis NN 19613 7164 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7164 19 is be VBZ 19613 7164 20 not not RB 19613 7164 21 given give VBN 19613 7164 22 by by IN 19613 7164 23 nature nature NN 19613 7164 24 , , , 19613 7164 25 but but CC 19613 7164 26 is be VBZ 19613 7164 27 brought bring VBN 19613 7164 28 about about RP 19613 7164 29 by by IN 19613 7164 30 the the DT 19613 7164 31 union union NN 19613 7164 32 with with IN 19613 7164 33 the the DT 19613 7164 34 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7164 35 of of IN 19613 7164 36 God God NNP 19613 7164 37 realised realise VBD 19613 7164 38 through through IN 19613 7164 39 obedience obedience NN 19613 7164 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7164 41 V. V. NNP 19613 7164 42 6 6 CD 19613 7164 43 . . . 19613 7165 1 1 1 LS 19613 7165 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7165 3 . . . 19613 7166 1 The the DT 19613 7166 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7166 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7166 4 : : : 19613 7166 5 homoiôsis homoiôsis NN 19613 7166 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7166 7 is be VBZ 19613 7166 8 therefore therefore RB 19613 7166 9 subject subject JJ 19613 7166 10 to to IN 19613 7166 11 growth growth NN 19613 7166 12 , , , 19613 7166 13 and and CC 19613 7166 14 was be VBD 19613 7166 15 not not RB 19613 7166 16 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7166 17 at at IN 19613 7166 18 the the DT 19613 7166 19 beginning beginning NN 19613 7166 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7166 21 see see VB 19613 7166 22 above above RB 19613 7166 23 , , , 19613 7166 24 IV IV NNP 19613 7166 25 . . . 19613 7167 1 38 38 CD 19613 7167 2 . . . 19613 7168 1 4 4 LS 19613 7168 2 , , , 19613 7168 3 where where WRB 19613 7168 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7168 5 opposes oppose VBZ 19613 7168 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 7168 7 's 's POS 19613 7168 8 opinion opinion NN 19613 7168 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7168 10 . . . 19613 7169 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7169 2 is be VBZ 19613 7169 3 clear clear JJ 19613 7169 4 , , , 19613 7169 5 especially especially RB 19613 7169 6 from from IN 19613 7169 7 V. V. NNP 19613 7169 8 12 12 CD 19613 7169 9 . . . 19613 7170 1 2 2 LS 19613 7170 2 , , , 19613 7170 3 that that IN 19613 7170 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7170 5 is be VBZ 19613 7170 6 only only RB 19613 7170 7 the the DT 19613 7170 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7170 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7170 10 : : : 19613 7170 11 pnoê pnoê NN 19613 7170 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7170 13 , , , 19613 7170 14 not not RB 19613 7170 15 the the DT 19613 7170 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7170 17 Greek greek JJ 19613 7170 18 : : : 19613 7170 19 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 7170 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7170 21 , , , 19613 7170 22 that that DT 19613 7170 23 is be VBZ 19613 7170 24 to to TO 19613 7170 25 be be VB 19613 7170 26 conceived conceive VBN 19613 7170 27 as as IN 19613 7170 28 an an DT 19613 7170 29 original original JJ 19613 7170 30 possession possession NN 19613 7170 31 . . . 19613 7171 1 On on IN 19613 7171 2 this this DT 19613 7171 3 point point NN 19613 7171 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7171 5 appealed appeal VBD 19613 7171 6 to to IN 19613 7171 7 1 1 CD 19613 7171 8 Cor Cor NNP 19613 7171 9 . . . 19613 7172 1 XV XV NNP 19613 7172 2 . . . 19613 7173 1 45 45 CD 19613 7173 2 . . . 19613 7174 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7174 2 is be VBZ 19613 7174 3 plain plain JJ 19613 7174 4 from from IN 19613 7174 5 the the DT 19613 7174 6 37th 37th JJ 19613 7174 7 chapter chapter NN 19613 7174 8 of of IN 19613 7174 9 the the DT 19613 7174 10 4th 4th JJ 19613 7174 11 Book Book NNP 19613 7174 12 , , , 19613 7174 13 that that IN 19613 7174 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7174 15 also also RB 19613 7174 16 views view VBZ 19613 7174 17 everything everything NN 19613 7174 18 as as RB 19613 7174 19 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 7174 20 dependent dependent JJ 19613 7174 21 on on IN 19613 7174 22 man man NN 19613 7174 23 's 's POS 19613 7174 24 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 7174 25 freedom freedom NN 19613 7174 26 . . . 19613 7175 1 Alongside alongside IN 19613 7175 2 of of IN 19613 7175 3 this this DT 19613 7175 4 God God NNP 19613 7175 5 's 's POS 19613 7175 6 goodness goodness NN 19613 7175 7 has have VBZ 19613 7175 8 scope scope NN 19613 7175 9 for for IN 19613 7175 10 displaying display VBG 19613 7175 11 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 7175 12 in in IN 19613 7175 13 addition addition NN 19613 7175 14 to to IN 19613 7175 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7175 16 exercise exercise NN 19613 7175 17 at at IN 19613 7175 18 the the DT 19613 7175 19 creation creation NN 19613 7175 20 , , , 19613 7175 21 because because IN 19613 7175 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7175 23 guides guide VBZ 19613 7175 24 man man NN 19613 7175 25 's 's POS 19613 7175 26 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7175 27 through through IN 19613 7175 28 counsel counsel NN 19613 7175 29 ; ; : 19613 7175 30 see see VB 19613 7175 31 § § CD 19613 7175 32 1 1 CD 19613 7175 33 . . . 19613 7176 1 On on IN 19613 7176 2 Matth Matth NNP 19613 7176 3 . . . 19613 7177 1 XXIII XXIII NNP 19613 7177 2 . . . 19613 7178 1 37 37 CD 19613 7178 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7178 3 remarks remark VBZ 19613 7178 4 : : : 19613 7178 5 " " `` 19613 7178 6 veterem veterem NNP 19613 7178 7 legem legem NNP 19613 7178 8 libertatis libertatis IN 19613 7178 9 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7178 10 manifestavit manifestavit NNP 19613 7178 11 , , , 19613 7178 12 quia quia NNP 19613 7178 13 liberum liberum NNP 19613 7178 14 eum eum NNP 19613 7178 15 deus deus NNP 19613 7178 16 fecit fecit NN 19613 7178 17 ab ab NNP 19613 7178 18 initio initio NN 19613 7178 19 , , , 19613 7178 20 habentem habentem NNP 19613 7178 21 suam suam NNP 19613 7178 22 potestatem potestatem NNP 19613 7178 23 sicut sicut NNP 19613 7178 24 et et NNP 19613 7178 25 suam suam NNP 19613 7178 26 animam animam NNP 19613 7178 27 ad ad NNP 19613 7178 28 utendum utendum NNP 19613 7178 29 sententia sententia NNP 19613 7178 30 dei dei NNP 19613 7178 31 voluntarie voluntarie NNP 19613 7178 32 et et NNP 19613 7178 33 non non AFX 19613 7178 34 coactum coactum NNP 19613 7178 35 a a DT 19613 7178 36 deo deo NN 19613 7178 37 ... ... NFP 19613 7178 38 posuit posuit NN 19613 7178 39 in in IN 19613 7178 40 homine homine NNP 19613 7178 41 potestatem potestatem NNP 19613 7178 42 electionis electionis NNP 19613 7178 43 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 7178 44 in in IN 19613 7178 45 angelis angelis NNP 19613 7178 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7178 47 et et FW 19613 7178 48 enim enim NNP 19613 7178 49 angeli angeli NNP 19613 7178 50 rationabiles rationabiles NNPS 19613 7178 51 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7178 52 , , , 19613 7178 53 ut ut UH 19613 7178 54 hi hi UH 19613 7178 55 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7178 56 qui qui NNP 19613 7178 57 obedissent obedissent JJ 19613 7178 58 iuste iuste NNP 19613 7178 59 bonum bonum NN 19613 7178 60 sint sint NN 19613 7178 61 possidentes possidente NNS 19613 7178 62 , , , 19613 7178 63 _ _ NNP 19613 7178 64 datum datum NN 19613 7178 65 quidem quidem VBP 19613 7178 66 a a DT 19613 7178 67 deo deo NN 19613 7178 68 , , , 19613 7178 69 servatum servatum NN 19613 7178 70 vero vero NNP 19613 7178 71 ab ab NNP 19613 7178 72 ipsis ipsis NNP 19613 7178 73 _ _ NNP 19613 7178 74 . . . 19613 7178 75 " " '' 19613 7179 1 An an DT 19613 7179 2 appeal appeal NN 19613 7179 3 to to IN 19613 7179 4 Rome Rome NNP 19613 7179 5 II II NNP 19613 7179 6 . . . 19613 7180 1 4 4 CD 19613 7180 2 - - SYM 19613 7180 3 7 7 CD 19613 7180 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7180 5 ! ! . 19613 7180 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7181 1 follows follow VBZ 19613 7181 2 . . . 19613 7182 1 In in IN 19613 7182 2 § § CD 19613 7182 3 2 2 CD 19613 7182 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7182 5 inveighs inveigh VBZ 19613 7182 6 violently violently RB 19613 7182 7 against against IN 19613 7182 8 the the DT 19613 7182 9 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 7182 10 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 7182 11 of of IN 19613 7182 12 natural natural JJ 19613 7182 13 goodness goodness NN 19613 7182 14 and and CC 19613 7182 15 wickedness wickedness NN 19613 7182 16 : : : 19613 7182 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7182 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7182 19 : : : 19613 7182 20 pantes pant VBZ 19613 7182 21 tês tês NNP 19613 7182 22 autês autês NN 19613 7182 23 eisi eisi NNP 19613 7182 24 physeôs physeôs NNP 19613 7182 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7182 26 . . . 19613 7183 1 In in IN 19613 7183 2 § § CD 19613 7183 3 4 4 CD 19613 7183 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7183 5 interprets interpret VBZ 19613 7183 6 the the DT 19613 7183 7 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 7183 8 : : : 19613 7183 9 " " `` 19613 7183 10 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7183 11 licent licent NNP 19613 7183 12 , , , 19613 7183 13 sed se VBD 19613 7183 14 non non AFX 19613 7183 15 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7183 16 expediunt expediunt NN 19613 7183 17 , , , 19613 7183 18 " " '' 19613 7183 19 as as IN 19613 7183 20 referring refer VBG 19613 7183 21 to to IN 19613 7183 22 man man NN 19613 7183 23 's 's POS 19613 7183 24 inalienable inalienable JJ 19613 7183 25 freedom freedom NN 19613 7183 26 and and CC 19613 7183 27 to to IN 19613 7183 28 the the DT 19613 7183 29 way way NN 19613 7183 30 in in IN 19613 7183 31 which which WDT 19613 7183 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7183 33 is be VBZ 19613 7183 34 abused abuse VBN 19613 7183 35 in in IN 19613 7183 36 order order NN 19613 7183 37 to to TO 19613 7183 38 work work VB 19613 7183 39 evil evil NN 19613 7183 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7183 41 ! ! . 19613 7184 1 ): ): LS 19613 7184 2 " " `` 19613 7184 3 liberæ liberæ NNP 19613 7184 4 sententiæ sententiæ NNP 19613 7184 5 ab ab NNP 19613 7184 6 initio initio NNP 19613 7184 7 est est NNP 19613 7184 8 homo homo NNP 19613 7184 9 et et NNP 19613 7184 10 liberæ liberæ NNP 19613 7184 11 sententiæ sententiæ NNP 19613 7184 12 est est NNP 19613 7184 13 deus deus NNP 19613 7184 14 , , , 19613 7184 15 cuius cuius NN 19613 7184 16 ad ad NN 19613 7184 17 similitudinem similitudinem NN 19613 7184 18 factus factus NN 19613 7184 19 est est NNP 19613 7184 20 . . . 19613 7184 21 " " '' 19613 7185 1 § § ADD 19613 7185 2 5 5 CD 19613 7185 3 : : : 19613 7185 4 " " `` 19613 7185 5 Et et NN 19613 7185 6 non non JJ 19613 7185 7 tantum tantum NN 19613 7185 8 in in IN 19613 7185 9 operibus operibus NNP 19613 7185 10 , , , 19613 7185 11 sed se VBD 19613 7185 12 etiam etiam NNP 19613 7185 13 in in IN 19613 7185 14 fide fide NNP 19613 7185 15 , , , 19613 7185 16 liberum liberum NNP 19613 7185 17 et et NNP 19613 7185 18 suæ suæ NN 19613 7185 19 potestatis potestatis JJ 19613 7185 20 arbitrium arbitrium NN 19613 7185 21 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7185 22 _ _ NNP 19613 7185 23 servavit servavit NNP 19613 7185 24 _ _ NNP 19613 7185 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7185 26 that that RB 19613 7185 27 is is RB 19613 7185 28 , , , 19613 7185 29 respected respected JJ 19613 7185 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7185 31 dominus dominus NN 19613 7185 32 , , , 19613 7185 33 dicens dicen NNS 19613 7185 34 : : : 19613 7185 35 Secundum secundum NN 19613 7185 36 fidem fidem VBP 19613 7185 37 tuam tuam NN 19613 7185 38 fiat fiat NN 19613 7185 39 tibi tibi NNP 19613 7185 40 . . . 19613 7185 41 " " '' 19613 7186 1 § § ADD 19613 7186 2 4 4 CD 19613 7186 3 : : : 19613 7186 4 " " `` 19613 7186 5 deus deus NNP 19613 7186 6 consilium consilium NN 19613 7186 7 dat dat NNP 19613 7186 8 continere continere NNP 19613 7186 9 bonum bonum NNP 19613 7186 10 , , , 19613 7186 11 quod quod NN 19613 7186 12 perficitur perficitur NNP 19613 7186 13 ex ex NNP 19613 7186 14 obedientia obedientia NNP 19613 7186 15 . . . 19613 7186 16 " " '' 19613 7187 1 § § ADD 19613 7187 2 3 3 CD 19613 7187 3 : : : 19613 7187 4 " " `` 19613 7187 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7187 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7187 7 : : : 19613 7187 8 to to TO 19613 7187 9 autexousion autexousion NNP 19613 7187 10 tou tou NNP 19613 7187 11 anthrôpou anthrôpou NNP 19613 7187 12 kai kai NNP 19613 7187 13 to to TO 19613 7187 14 symbouleutikon symbouleutikon VB 19613 7187 15 tou tou NNP 19613 7187 16 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7187 17 mê mê NNP 19613 7187 18 biazomenou biazomenou NNP 19613 7187 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7187 20 . . . 19613 7187 21 " " '' 19613 7188 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7188 2 . . . 19613 7189 1 4 4 LS 19613 7189 2 . . . 19613 7190 1 3 3 LS 19613 7190 2 : : : 19613 7190 3 " " `` 19613 7190 4 homo homo NNP 19613 7190 5 rationabilis rationabilis NNP 19613 7190 6 et et NNP 19613 7190 7 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7190 8 hoc hoc FW 19613 7190 9 similis similis NNP 19613 7190 10 deo deo NNP 19613 7190 11 liber liber NNP 19613 7190 12 in in IN 19613 7190 13 arbitrio arbitrio NN 19613 7190 14 factus factus NN 19613 7190 15 et et NN 19613 7190 16 suæ suæ NN 19613 7190 17 potestatis potestatis NN 19613 7190 18 , , , 19613 7190 19 ipse ipse NNP 19613 7190 20 sibi sibi NNP 19613 7190 21 causa causa NNP 19613 7190 22 est est NNP 19613 7190 23 , , , 19613 7190 24 ut ut NNP 19613 7190 25 aliquando aliquando NNP 19613 7190 26 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7190 27 frumentum frumentum NNP 19613 7190 28 aliquando aliquando NNP 19613 7190 29 autem autem NNP 19613 7190 30 palea palea NNP 19613 7190 31 fiat fiat NN 19613 7190 32 . . . 19613 7190 33 " " '' 19613 7190 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7191 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7191 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7191 3 560 560 CD 19613 7191 4 : : : 19613 7191 5 As as IN 19613 7191 6 a a DT 19613 7191 7 matter matter NN 19613 7191 8 of of IN 19613 7191 9 fact fact NN 19613 7191 10 this this DT 19613 7191 11 view view NN 19613 7191 12 already already RB 19613 7191 13 belongs belong VBZ 19613 7191 14 to to IN 19613 7191 15 the the DT 19613 7191 16 second second JJ 19613 7191 17 train train NN 19613 7191 18 of of IN 19613 7191 19 thought thought NN 19613 7191 20 ; ; : 19613 7191 21 see see VB 19613 7191 22 particularly particularly RB 19613 7191 23 III III NNP 19613 7191 24 . . . 19613 7192 1 21 21 CD 19613 7192 2 - - SYM 19613 7192 3 23 23 CD 19613 7192 4 . . . 19613 7193 1 Here here RB 19613 7193 2 in in IN 19613 7193 3 reality reality NN 19613 7193 4 this this DT 19613 7193 5 merely merely RB 19613 7193 6 applies apply VBZ 19613 7193 7 to to IN 19613 7193 8 the the DT 19613 7193 9 particular particular JJ 19613 7193 10 individuals individual NNS 19613 7193 11 who who WP 19613 7193 12 chose choose VBD 19613 7193 13 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 7193 14 , , , 19613 7193 15 but but CC 19613 7193 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7193 17 almost almost RB 19613 7193 18 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 7193 19 referred refer VBD 19613 7193 20 back back RB 19613 7193 21 to to IN 19613 7193 22 the the DT 19613 7193 23 fall fall NN 19613 7193 24 of of IN 19613 7193 25 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7193 26 . . . 19613 7194 1 See see VB 19613 7194 2 , , , 19613 7194 3 however however RB 19613 7194 4 , , , 19613 7194 5 V. V. NNP 19613 7194 6 27 27 CD 19613 7194 7 . . . 19613 7195 1 2 2 LS 19613 7195 2 : : : 19613 7195 3 " " `` 19613 7195 4 Quicunque quicunque VB 19613 7195 5 erga erga NN 19613 7195 6 eum eum NN 19613 7195 7 custodiunt custodiunt NN 19613 7195 8 dilectionem dilectionem NNP 19613 7195 9 , , , 19613 7195 10 suam suam NNP 19613 7195 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7195 12 præstat præstat NN 19613 7195 13 communionem communionem NN 19613 7195 14 . . . 19613 7196 1 Communio communio NN 19613 7196 2 autem autem NN 19613 7196 3 dei dei NNP 19613 7196 4 vita vita NNP 19613 7196 5 et et NNP 19613 7196 6 lumen lumen NNP 19613 7196 7 et et NNP 19613 7196 8 fruitio fruitio NNP 19613 7196 9 eorum eorum NNP 19613 7196 10 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7196 11 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7196 12 apud apud NNP 19613 7196 13 deum deum NNP 19613 7196 14 bonorum bonorum NNP 19613 7196 15 . . . 19613 7197 1 Quicumque Quicumque NNP 19613 7197 2 autem autem NNP 19613 7197 3 absistunt absistunt NNP 19613 7197 4 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7197 5 sententiam sententiam NNP 19613 7197 6 suam suam NNP 19613 7197 7 ab ab NNP 19613 7197 8 eo eo NNP 19613 7197 9 , , , 19613 7197 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7197 11 eam eam NN 19613 7197 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7197 13 electa electa NNP 19613 7197 14 est est NNP 19613 7197 15 ab ab NNP 19613 7197 16 ipsis ipsis NNP 19613 7197 17 separationem separationem NNP 19613 7197 18 inducit inducit NNP 19613 7197 19 . . . 19613 7198 1 Separatio separatio VB 19613 7198 2 autem autem JJ 19613 7198 3 dei dei NNP 19613 7198 4 mors mor NNS 19613 7198 5 , , , 19613 7198 6 et et NNP 19613 7198 7 separatio separatio NNP 19613 7198 8 lucis lucis NNP 19613 7198 9 tenebræ tenebræ NN 19613 7198 10 , , , 19613 7198 11 et et NNP 19613 7198 12 separatio separatio NNP 19613 7198 13 dei dei NNP 19613 7198 14 amissio amissio NNP 19613 7198 15 omnium omnium NNP 19613 7198 16 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7198 17 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7198 18 apud apud NNP 19613 7198 19 eum eum NNP 19613 7198 20 bonorum bonorum NNP 19613 7198 21 . . . 19613 7198 22 " " '' 19613 7199 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7199 2 19 19 CD 19613 7199 3 . . . 19613 7200 1 1 1 CD 19613 7200 2 , , , 19613 7200 3 1 1 CD 19613 7200 4 . . . 19613 7201 1 3 3 CD 19613 7201 2 , , , 19613 7201 3 1 1 CD 19613 7201 4 . . . 19613 7202 1 1 1 LS 19613 7202 2 . . . 19613 7203 1 The the DT 19613 7203 2 subjective subjective JJ 19613 7203 3 moralism moralism NN 19613 7203 4 is be VBZ 19613 7203 5 very very RB 19613 7203 6 clearly clearly RB 19613 7203 7 defined define VBN 19613 7203 8 in in IN 19613 7203 9 IV IV NNP 19613 7203 10 . . . 19613 7204 1 15 15 CD 19613 7204 2 . . . 19613 7205 1 2 2 LS 19613 7205 2 : : : 19613 7205 3 " " `` 19613 7205 4 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7205 5 d d VBD 19613 7205 6 quod quod NN 19613 7205 7 erat erat NNP 19613 7205 8 semper semper NN 19613 7205 9 liberum liberum NNP 19613 7205 10 et et NNP 19613 7205 11 suæ suæ NN 19613 7205 12 potestatis potestatis NN 19613 7205 13 in in IN 19613 7205 14 homine homine NNP 19613 7205 15 semper semper NNP 19613 7205 16 servavit servavit NNP 19613 7205 17 deus deus NNP 19613 7205 18 et et NNP 19613 7205 19 sua sua NN 19613 7205 20 exhortatio exhortatio NNP 19613 7205 21 , , , 19613 7205 22 ut ut UH 19613 7205 23 iuste iuste NNP 19613 7205 24 iudicentur iudicentur NNP 19613 7205 25 qui qui VBN 19613 7205 26 non non AFX 19613 7205 27 obediunt obediunt NNP 19613 7205 28 ei ei NNP 19613 7205 29 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 7205 30 non non AFX 19613 7205 31 obedierunt obedierunt NN 19613 7205 32 , , , 19613 7205 33 et et FW 19613 7205 34 qui qui NNP 19613 7205 35 obedierunt obedierunt VBP 19613 7205 36 et et NNP 19613 7205 37 crediderunt crediderunt VBP 19613 7205 38 ei ei NNP 19613 7205 39 , , , 19613 7205 40 honorentur honorentur JJ 19613 7205 41 incorruptibilitate incorruptibilitate NN 19613 7205 42 . . . 19613 7205 43 " " '' 19613 7205 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7206 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7206 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7206 3 561 561 CD 19613 7206 4 : : : 19613 7206 5 Man Man NNP 19613 7206 6 's 's POS 19613 7206 7 sin sin NN 19613 7206 8 is be VBZ 19613 7206 9 thoughtlessness thoughtlessness NN 19613 7206 10 ; ; : 19613 7206 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7206 12 is be VBZ 19613 7206 13 merely merely RB 19613 7206 14 led lead VBN 19613 7206 15 astray astray NNP 19613 7206 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7206 17 IV IV NNP 19613 7206 18 . . . 19613 7207 1 40 40 CD 19613 7207 2 . . . 19613 7208 1 3 3 LS 19613 7208 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7208 3 . . . 19613 7209 1 The the DT 19613 7209 2 fact fact NN 19613 7209 3 that that IN 19613 7209 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7209 5 let let VBD 19613 7209 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7209 7 be be VB 19613 7209 8 seduced seduce VBN 19613 7209 9 under under IN 19613 7209 10 the the DT 19613 7209 11 pretext pretext NN 19613 7209 12 of of IN 19613 7209 13 immortality immortality NN 19613 7209 14 is be VBZ 19613 7209 15 an an DT 19613 7209 16 excuse excuse NN 19613 7209 17 for for IN 19613 7209 18 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7209 19 ; ; : 19613 7209 20 man man NN 19613 7209 21 was be VBD 19613 7209 22 _ _ NNP 19613 7209 23 infans infans NNPS 19613 7209 24 _ _ NNP 19613 7209 25 , , , 19613 7209 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7209 27 See see VB 19613 7209 28 above above RB 19613 7209 29 ; ; : 19613 7209 30 hence hence RB 19613 7209 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7209 32 is be VBZ 19613 7209 33 said say VBN 19613 7209 34 , , , 19613 7209 35 in in IN 19613 7209 36 opposition opposition NN 19613 7209 37 to to IN 19613 7209 38 the the DT 19613 7209 39 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 7209 40 , , , 19613 7209 41 in in IN 19613 7209 42 IV IV NNP 19613 7209 43 . . . 19613 7210 1 38 38 CD 19613 7210 2 . . . 19613 7211 1 4 4 LS 19613 7211 2 : : : 19613 7211 3 " " `` 19613 7211 4 supergredieutes supergredieute NNS 19613 7211 5 legem legem NNP 19613 7211 6 humani humani NNP 19613 7211 7 generis generis NNP 19613 7211 8 et et NNP 19613 7211 9 antequam antequam NNP 19613 7211 10 fiant fiant NNP 19613 7211 11 homines homine NNS 19613 7211 12 , , , 19613 7211 13 iam iam NNP 19613 7211 14 volunt volunt NNP 19613 7211 15 similes simile VBZ 19613 7211 16 esse esse NNP 19613 7211 17 factori factori NNP 19613 7211 18 deo deo NNP 19613 7211 19 et et NNP 19613 7211 20 nullam nullam RB 19613 7211 21 esse esse NNP 19613 7211 22 differentiam differentiam NNP 19613 7211 23 infecti infecti NNP 19613 7211 24 dei dei NNP 19613 7211 25 et et NNP 19613 7211 26 nunc nunc NNP 19613 7211 27 facti facti NNP 19613 7211 28 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7211 29 . . . 19613 7211 30 " " '' 19613 7212 1 The the DT 19613 7212 2 same same JJ 19613 7212 3 idea idea NN 19613 7212 4 is be VBZ 19613 7212 5 once once RB 19613 7212 6 more more RBR 19613 7212 7 very very RB 19613 7212 8 clearly clearly RB 19613 7212 9 expressed express VBN 19613 7212 10 in in IN 19613 7212 11 IV IV NNP 19613 7212 12 . . . 19613 7213 1 39 39 CD 19613 7213 2 . . . 19613 7214 1 3 3 LS 19613 7214 2 ; ; : 19613 7214 3 " " `` 19613 7214 4 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 7214 5 igitur igitur NNP 19613 7214 6 erit erit JJ 19613 7214 7 homo homo NN 19613 7214 8 deus deus NNP 19613 7214 9 , , , 19613 7214 10 qui qui NNP 19613 7214 11 nondum nondum NN 19613 7214 12 factus factus NN 19613 7214 13 est est NNP 19613 7214 14 homo homo NN 19613 7214 15 ? ? . 19613 7214 16 " " '' 19613 7215 1 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 7215 2 , , , 19613 7215 3 how how WRB 19613 7215 4 could could MD 19613 7215 5 newly newly RB 19613 7215 6 created create VBN 19613 7215 7 man man NN 19613 7215 8 be be VB 19613 7215 9 already already RB 19613 7215 10 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7215 11 as as IN 19613 7215 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7215 13 was be VBD 19613 7215 14 not not RB 19613 7215 15 even even RB 19613 7215 16 man man NN 19613 7215 17 , , , 19613 7215 18 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 7215 19 as as IN 19613 7215 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7215 21 did do VBD 19613 7215 22 not not RB 19613 7215 23 yet yet RB 19613 7215 24 know know VB 19613 7215 25 how how WRB 19613 7215 26 to to TO 19613 7215 27 distinguish distinguish VB 19613 7215 28 good good NN 19613 7215 29 and and CC 19613 7215 30 evil evil NN 19613 7215 31 ? ? . 19613 7215 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7215 33 . . . 19613 7216 1 Cf cf NN 19613 7216 2 . . . 19613 7217 1 III iii CD 19613 7217 2 . . . 19613 7218 1 23 23 CD 19613 7218 2 . . . 19613 7219 1 3 3 CD 19613 7219 2 , , , 19613 7219 3 5 5 CD 19613 7219 4 : : : 19613 7219 5 " " `` 19613 7219 6 The the DT 19613 7219 7 fear fear NN 19613 7219 8 of of IN 19613 7219 9 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7219 10 was be VBD 19613 7219 11 the the DT 19613 7219 12 beginning beginning NN 19613 7219 13 of of IN 19613 7219 14 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 7219 15 ; ; : 19613 7219 16 the the DT 19613 7219 17 sense sense NN 19613 7219 18 of of IN 19613 7219 19 transgression transgression NN 19613 7219 20 led lead VBN 19613 7219 21 to to IN 19613 7219 22 repentance repentance NN 19613 7219 23 ; ; : 19613 7219 24 but but CC 19613 7219 25 God God NNP 19613 7219 26 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 7219 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7219 28 grace grace NN 19613 7219 29 on on IN 19613 7219 30 the the DT 19613 7219 31 penitent penitent NN 19613 7219 32 " " '' 19613 7219 33 ... ... : 19613 7219 34 " " `` 19613 7219 35 eum eum NN 19613 7219 36 odivit odivit NN 19613 7219 37 deus deus NNP 19613 7219 38 , , , 19613 7219 39 qui qui NNP 19613 7219 40 seduxit seduxit NNP 19613 7219 41 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7219 42 , , , 19613 7219 43 ei ei NNP 19613 7219 44 vero vero NNP 19613 7219 45 qui qui NNP 19613 7219 46 seductus seductus NNP 19613 7219 47 est est NNP 19613 7219 48 , , , 19613 7219 49 sensim sensim NNP 19613 7219 50 paullatimque paullatimque NNP 19613 7219 51 misertus misertus NNP 19613 7219 52 est est NNP 19613 7219 53 . . . 19613 7219 54 " " '' 19613 7220 1 The the DT 19613 7220 2 " " `` 19613 7220 3 pondus pondus NN 19613 7220 4 peccati peccati NN 19613 7220 5 " " '' 19613 7220 6 in in IN 19613 7220 7 the the DT 19613 7220 8 sense sense NN 19613 7220 9 of of IN 19613 7220 10 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 7220 11 was be VBD 19613 7220 12 by by IN 19613 7220 13 no no DT 19613 7220 14 means means NN 19613 7220 15 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 7220 16 by by IN 19613 7220 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7220 18 , , , 19613 7220 19 and and CC 19613 7220 20 although although IN 19613 7220 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7220 22 makes make VBZ 19613 7220 23 use use NN 19613 7220 24 of of IN 19613 7220 25 Pauline pauline JJ 19613 7220 26 sayings saying NNS 19613 7220 27 , , , 19613 7220 28 and and CC 19613 7220 29 by by IN 19613 7220 30 preference preference NN 19613 7220 31 such such JJ 19613 7220 32 as as IN 19613 7220 33 have have VB 19613 7220 34 a a DT 19613 7220 35 quite quite RB 19613 7220 36 different different JJ 19613 7220 37 sense sense NN 19613 7220 38 , , , 19613 7220 39 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7220 40 is be VBZ 19613 7220 41 very very RB 19613 7220 42 far far RB 19613 7220 43 from from IN 19613 7220 44 sharing share VBG 19613 7220 45 Paul Paul NNP 19613 7220 46 's 's POS 19613 7220 47 view view NN 19613 7220 48 . . . 19613 7220 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7221 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7221 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7221 3 562 562 CD 19613 7221 4 : : : 19613 7221 5 See see VB 19613 7221 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7221 7 . . . 19613 7222 1 37 37 CD 19613 7222 2 . . . 19613 7223 1 7 7 LS 19613 7223 2 : : : 19613 7223 3 " " `` 19613 7223 4 Alias Alias NNP 19613 7223 5 autem autem NNP 19613 7223 6 esset esset NN 19613 7223 7 nostrum nostrum NNP 19613 7223 8 insensatum insensatum NNP 19613 7223 9 bonum bonum NNP 19613 7223 10 , , , 19613 7223 11 quod quod NN 19613 7223 12 esset esset NN 19613 7223 13 inexercitatum inexercitatum NN 19613 7223 14 . . . 19613 7224 1 Sed Sed NNP 19613 7224 2 et et NNP 19613 7224 3 videre videre NNP 19613 7224 4 non non AFX 19613 7224 5 tantum tantum NNP 19613 7224 6 nobis nobis NNP 19613 7224 7 esset esset NN 19613 7224 8 desiderabile desiderabile NN 19613 7224 9 , , , 19613 7224 10 nisi nisi NNP 19613 7224 11 cognovissemus cognovissemus NNP 19613 7224 12 quantum quantum NNP 19613 7224 13 esset esset NNP 19613 7224 14 malum malum NNP 19613 7224 15 non non AFX 19613 7224 16 videre videre NNP 19613 7224 17 ; ; : 19613 7224 18 et et NNP 19613 7224 19 bene bene NN 19613 7224 20 valere valere NNP 19613 7224 21 autem autem NNP 19613 7224 22 male male NNP 19613 7224 23 valentis valentis NNP 19613 7224 24 experientia experientia NNP 19613 7224 25 honorabilius honorabilius NNP 19613 7224 26 efficit efficit NNP 19613 7224 27 , , , 19613 7224 28 et et NNP 19613 7224 29 lucem lucem NNP 19613 7224 30 tenebrarum tenebrarum NNP 19613 7224 31 comparatio comparatio NNP 19613 7224 32 et et NNP 19613 7224 33 vitam vitam NNP 19613 7224 34 mortis mortis NNP 19613 7224 35 . . . 19613 7225 1 Sic sic VB 19613 7225 2 et et NNP 19613 7225 3 coeleste coeleste NN 19613 7225 4 regnum regnum NNP 19613 7225 5 honorabilius honorabilius NNP 19613 7225 6 est est VBD 19613 7225 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7225 8 qui qui NN 19613 7225 9 cognoverunt cognoverunt NN 19613 7225 10 terrenum terrenum NN 19613 7225 11 . . . 19613 7225 12 " " '' 19613 7226 1 The the DT 19613 7226 2 main main JJ 19613 7226 3 passage passage NN 19613 7226 4 is be VBZ 19613 7226 5 III iii CD 19613 7226 6 . . . 19613 7227 1 20 20 CD 19613 7227 2 . . . 19613 7228 1 1 1 CD 19613 7228 2 , , , 19613 7228 3 2 2 CD 19613 7228 4 , , , 19613 7228 5 which which WDT 19613 7228 6 can can MD 19613 7228 7 not not RB 19613 7228 8 be be VB 19613 7228 9 here here RB 19613 7228 10 quoted quote VBN 19613 7228 11 . . . 19613 7229 1 The the DT 19613 7229 2 fall fall NN 19613 7229 3 was be VBD 19613 7229 4 necessary necessary JJ 19613 7229 5 in in IN 19613 7229 6 order order NN 19613 7229 7 that that DT 19613 7229 8 man man NN 19613 7229 9 might may MD 19613 7229 10 not not RB 19613 7229 11 believe believe VB 19613 7229 12 that that IN 19613 7229 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7229 14 was be VBD 19613 7229 15 " " `` 19613 7229 16 naturaliter naturaliter NNP 19613 7229 17 similis similis NNP 19613 7229 18 deo deo NNP 19613 7229 19 . . . 19613 7229 20 " " '' 19613 7230 1 Hence hence RB 19613 7230 2 God God NNP 19613 7230 3 permitted permit VBD 19613 7230 4 the the DT 19613 7230 5 great great JJ 19613 7230 6 whale whale NN 19613 7230 7 to to IN 19613 7230 8 swallow swallow NNP 19613 7230 9 man man NN 19613 7230 10 for for IN 19613 7230 11 a a DT 19613 7230 12 time time NN 19613 7230 13 . . . 19613 7231 1 In in IN 19613 7231 2 several several JJ 19613 7231 3 passages passage NNS 19613 7231 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7231 5 has have VBZ 19613 7231 6 designated designate VBN 19613 7231 7 the the DT 19613 7231 8 permitting permitting NN 19613 7231 9 of of IN 19613 7231 10 evil evil NN 19613 7231 11 as as IN 19613 7231 12 kind kind JJ 19613 7231 13 generosity generosity NN 19613 7231 14 on on IN 19613 7231 15 the the DT 19613 7231 16 part part NN 19613 7231 17 of of IN 19613 7231 18 God God NNP 19613 7231 19 , , , 19613 7231 20 see see VB 19613 7231 21 , , , 19613 7231 22 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7231 23 , , , 19613 7231 24 IV IV NNP 19613 7231 25 . . . 19613 7232 1 39 39 CD 19613 7232 2 . . . 19613 7233 1 1 1 CD 19613 7233 2 , , , 19613 7233 3 37 37 CD 19613 7233 4 . . . 19613 7234 1 7 7 LS 19613 7234 2 . . . 19613 7234 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7235 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7235 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7235 3 563 563 CD 19613 7235 4 : : : 19613 7235 5 See see VB 19613 7235 6 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 7235 7 , , , 19613 7235 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7235 9 . . NNP 19613 7235 10 , , , 19613 7235 11 p. p. NN 19613 7236 1 24 24 CD 19613 7236 2 . . . 19613 7236 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7237 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7237 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7237 3 564 564 CD 19613 7237 4 : : : 19613 7237 5 See see VB 19613 7237 6 III iii CD 19613 7237 7 . . . 19613 7238 1 23 23 CD 19613 7238 2 . . . 19613 7239 1 6 6 LS 19613 7239 2 . . . 19613 7239 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7240 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7240 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7240 3 565 565 CD 19613 7240 4 : : : 19613 7240 5 See see VB 19613 7240 6 V. v. NN 19613 7240 7 I. i. NN 19613 7241 1 1 1 LS 19613 7241 2 : : : 19613 7241 3 " " `` 19613 7241 4 Non Non NNP 19613 7241 5 enim enim NN 19613 7241 6 aliter aliter VBP 19613 7241 7 nos nos NNP 19613 7241 8 discere discere NNP 19613 7241 9 poteramus poteramus NNP 19613 7241 10 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7241 11 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7241 12 dei dei NNP 19613 7241 13 , , , 19613 7241 14 nisi nisi NNP 19613 7241 15 magister magister NNP 19613 7241 16 noster noster NN 19613 7241 17 , , , 19613 7241 18 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7241 19 exsistens exsistens NNP 19613 7241 20 , , , 19613 7241 21 homo homo NN 19613 7241 22 factus factus NN 19613 7241 23 fuisset fuisset NN 19613 7241 24 ... ... : 19613 7241 25 Neque Neque NNP 19613 7241 26 rursus rursus NNP 19613 7241 27 nos nos RB 19613 7241 28 aliter aliter VBP 19613 7241 29 discere discere NNP 19613 7241 30 poteramus poteramus NNP 19613 7241 31 , , , 19613 7241 32 nisi nisi NNP 19613 7241 33 magistrum magistrum NNP 19613 7241 34 nostrum nostrum NNP 19613 7241 35 videntes videntes NNP 19613 7241 36 , , , 19613 7241 37 " " '' 19613 7241 38 etc etc FW 19613 7241 39 . . . 19613 7242 1 ; ; : 19613 7242 2 III iii CD 19613 7242 3 . . . 19613 7243 1 23 23 CD 19613 7243 2 . . . 19613 7244 1 2 2 CD 19613 7244 2 , , , 19613 7244 3 5 5 CD 19613 7244 4 . . . 19613 7245 1 3 3 LS 19613 7245 2 : : : 19613 7245 3 " " `` 19613 7245 4 libertatem libertatem NNP 19613 7245 5 restauravit restauravit NN 19613 7245 6 " " '' 19613 7245 7 ; ; : 19613 7245 8 IV IV NNP 19613 7245 9 . . . 19613 7246 1 24 24 CD 19613 7246 2 . . . 19613 7247 1 1 1 LS 19613 7247 2 : : : 19613 7247 3 " " `` 19613 7247 4 reformavit reformavit NNP 19613 7247 5 humamum humamum NN 19613 7247 6 genus genus NN 19613 7247 7 " " '' 19613 7247 8 ; ; : 19613 7247 9 III iii CD 19613 7247 10 . . . 19613 7248 1 17 17 CD 19613 7248 2 . . . 19613 7249 1 1 1 LS 19613 7249 2 : : : 19613 7249 3 " " `` 19613 7249 4 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 7249 5 sanctus sanctus NN 19613 7249 6 in in IN 19613 7249 7 filium filium NNP 19613 7249 8 dei dei NNP 19613 7249 9 , , , 19613 7249 10 filium filium NN 19613 7249 11 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7249 12 factum factum NNP 19613 7249 13 , , , 19613 7249 14 descendit descendit JJ 19613 7249 15 cum cum NNP 19613 7249 16 ipso ipso NNP 19613 7249 17 assuescens assuescens NNP 19613 7249 18 habitare habitare NNP 19613 7249 19 in in IN 19613 7249 20 genere genere NNP 19613 7249 21 humano humano NNP 19613 7249 22 . . . 19613 7249 23 " " '' 19613 7250 1 III iii CD 19613 7250 2 . . . 19613 7251 1 19 19 CD 19613 7251 2 . . . 19613 7252 1 1 1 LS 19613 7252 2 : : : 19613 7252 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7252 4 . . . 19613 7253 1 38 38 CD 19613 7253 2 . . . 19613 7254 1 3 3 CD 19613 7254 2 : : SYM 19613 7254 3 39 39 CD 19613 7254 4 . . . 19613 7255 1 1 1 CD 19613 7255 2 , , , 19613 7255 3 2 2 CD 19613 7255 4 . . . 19613 7256 1 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 7256 2 's 's POS 19613 7256 3 summary summary NN 19613 7256 4 , , , 19613 7256 5 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7256 6 . . NNP 19613 7256 7 , , , 19613 7256 8 p. p. NN 19613 7256 9 24 24 CD 19613 7256 10 : : : 19613 7256 11 " " `` 19613 7256 12 By by IN 19613 7256 13 the the DT 19613 7256 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7256 15 becoming become VBG 19613 7256 16 man man NN 19613 7256 17 , , , 19613 7256 18 the the DT 19613 7256 19 type type NN 19613 7256 20 of of IN 19613 7256 21 the the DT 19613 7256 22 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7256 23 man man NN 19613 7256 24 made make VBD 19613 7256 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7256 26 appearance appearance NN 19613 7256 27 , , , 19613 7256 28 " " '' 19613 7256 29 formulates formulate VBZ 19613 7256 30 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7256 31 ' ' POS 19613 7256 32 meaning meaning NN 19613 7256 33 correctly correctly RB 19613 7256 34 and and CC 19613 7256 35 excludes exclude VBZ 19613 7256 36 the the DT 19613 7256 37 erroneous erroneous JJ 19613 7256 38 idea idea NN 19613 7256 39 that that IN 19613 7256 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7256 41 viewed view VBD 19613 7256 42 the the DT 19613 7256 43 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7256 44 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7256 45 as as IN 19613 7256 46 the the DT 19613 7256 47 prototype prototype NN 19613 7256 48 of of IN 19613 7256 49 humanity humanity NN 19613 7256 50 . . . 19613 7257 1 A a DT 19613 7257 2 real real JJ 19613 7257 3 divine divine JJ 19613 7257 4 manhood manhood NN 19613 7257 5 is be VBZ 19613 7257 6 not not RB 19613 7257 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 7257 8 within within IN 19613 7257 9 this this DT 19613 7257 10 train train NN 19613 7257 11 of of IN 19613 7257 12 thought thought NN 19613 7257 13 ; ; : 19613 7257 14 only only RB 19613 7257 15 a a DT 19613 7257 16 _ _ NNP 19613 7257 17 homo homo NN 19613 7257 18 inspiratus inspiratus NN 19613 7257 19 _ _ NNP 19613 7257 20 is be VBZ 19613 7257 21 required require VBN 19613 7257 22 . . . 19613 7257 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7258 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7258 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7258 3 566 566 CD 19613 7258 4 : : : 19613 7258 5 See see VB 19613 7258 6 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 7258 7 . . . 19613 7259 1 Philos Philos NNP 19613 7259 2 . . . 19613 7260 1 X. X. NNP 19613 7261 1 33 33 CD 19613 7261 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7261 3 p. p. NN 19613 7261 4 538 538 CD 19613 7261 5 sq sq NN 19613 7261 6 . . . 19613 7262 1 ): ): NNP 19613 7262 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7262 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7262 4 : : : 19613 7262 5 Epi Epi NNP 19613 7262 6 toutois toutois NNP 19613 7262 7 ton ton NNP 19613 7262 8 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 7262 9 archonta archonta NNP 19613 7262 10 dêmiourgôn dêmiourgôn NNP 19613 7262 11 ek ek NNP 19613 7262 12 pasôn pasôn NNP 19613 7262 13 synthetôn synthetôn NNP 19613 7262 14 ousiôn ousiôn VBD 19613 7262 15 eskeuasen eskeuasen NNP 19613 7262 16 , , , 19613 7262 17 ou ou NNP 19613 7262 18 Theôn Theôn NNP 19613 7262 19 thelôn thelôn NN 19613 7262 20 poiein poiein NNP 19613 7262 21 esphêlen esphêlen NNP 19613 7262 22 , , , 19613 7262 23 oude oude NN 19613 7262 24 angelon angelon NN 19613 7262 25 , , , 19613 7262 26 all all DT 19613 7262 27 ' ' '' 19613 7262 28 anthrôpon anthrôpon RB 19613 7262 29 . . . 19613 7263 1 Ei Ei NNP 19613 7263 2 gar gar NNP 19613 7263 3 Theon Theon NNP 19613 7263 4 se se NNP 19613 7263 5 êthelêse êthelêse NNP 19613 7263 6 poiêsai poiêsai NNP 19613 7263 7 , , , 19613 7263 8 edunato edunato NNP 19613 7263 9 ; ; : 19613 7263 10 echeis echeis NNP 19613 7263 11 tou tou NNP 19613 7263 12 logou logou NNP 19613 7263 13 to to IN 19613 7263 14 paradeigma paradeigma NNP 19613 7263 15 ; ; : 19613 7263 16 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 7263 17 thelôn thelôn NN 19613 7263 18 , , , 19613 7263 19 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNPS 19613 7263 20 se se NNP 19613 7263 21 epoiêsen epoiêsen NNP 19613 7263 22 ; ; : 19613 7263 23 ei ei NNP 19613 7263 24 de de NNP 19613 7263 25 theleis theleis NNP 19613 7263 26 kai kai NNP 19613 7263 27 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7263 28 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 7263 29 , , , 19613 7263 30 hupakoue hupakoue NNP 19613 7263 31 tô tô NNP 19613 7263 32 pepoiêkoti pepoiêkoti NNP 19613 7263 33 . . . 19613 7263 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7264 1 The the DT 19613 7264 2 famous famous JJ 19613 7264 3 concluding concluding NN 19613 7264 4 chapter chapter NN 19613 7264 5 of of IN 19613 7264 6 the the DT 19613 7264 7 Philosophoumena Philosophoumena NNP 19613 7264 8 with with IN 19613 7264 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7264 10 prospect prospect NN 19613 7264 11 of of IN 19613 7264 12 deification deification NN 19613 7264 13 is be VBZ 19613 7264 14 to to TO 19613 7264 15 be be VB 19613 7264 16 explained explain VBN 19613 7264 17 from from IN 19613 7264 18 this this DT 19613 7264 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7264 20 X. X. NNP 19613 7265 1 34 34 CD 19613 7265 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7265 3 . . . 19613 7265 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7266 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7266 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7266 3 567 567 CD 19613 7266 4 : : : 19613 7266 5 See see VB 19613 7266 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7266 7 . . . 19613 7267 1 adv adv NNP 19613 7267 2 . . . 19613 7268 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7268 2 . . . 19613 7269 1 II ii CD 19613 7269 2 . . . 19613 7270 1 4 4 CD 19613 7270 2 - - SYM 19613 7270 3 11 11 CD 19613 7270 4 ; ; : 19613 7270 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7270 6 undiluted undiluted JJ 19613 7270 7 moralism moralism NN 19613 7270 8 appears appear VBZ 19613 7270 9 with with IN 19613 7270 10 particular particular JJ 19613 7270 11 clearness clearness NN 19613 7270 12 in in IN 19613 7270 13 chaps chap NNS 19613 7270 14 . . . 19613 7271 1 6 6 CD 19613 7271 2 and and CC 19613 7271 3 8 8 CD 19613 7271 4 . . . 19613 7272 1 No no DT 19613 7272 2 weight weight NN 19613 7272 3 is be VBZ 19613 7272 4 to to TO 19613 7272 5 be be VB 19613 7272 6 attached attach VBN 19613 7272 7 to to IN 19613 7272 8 the the DT 19613 7272 9 phrase phrase NN 19613 7272 10 in in IN 19613 7272 11 chapter chapter NN 19613 7272 12 4 4 CD 19613 7272 13 that that IN 19613 7272 14 God God NNP 19613 7272 15 by by IN 19613 7272 16 placing place VBG 19613 7272 17 man man NN 19613 7272 18 in in IN 19613 7272 19 Paradise Paradise NNP 19613 7272 20 really really RB 19613 7272 21 even even RB 19613 7272 22 then then RB 19613 7272 23 put put VBD 19613 7272 24 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7272 25 from from IN 19613 7272 26 Paradise Paradise NNP 19613 7272 27 into into IN 19613 7272 28 the the DT 19613 7272 29 Church Church NNP 19613 7272 30 . . . 19613 7273 1 This this DT 19613 7273 2 is be VBZ 19613 7273 3 contrary contrary JJ 19613 7273 4 to to IN 19613 7273 5 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 7273 6 's 's POS 19613 7273 7 opinion opinion NN 19613 7273 8 , , , 19613 7273 9 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7273 10 . . NNP 19613 7273 11 , , , 19613 7273 12 p. p. NN 19613 7273 13 67 67 CD 19613 7273 14 . . . 19613 7274 1 ff ff NNP 19613 7274 2 . . NNP 19613 7274 3 , , , 19613 7274 4 where where WRB 19613 7274 5 the the DT 19613 7274 6 exposition exposition NN 19613 7274 7 of of IN 19613 7274 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7274 9 is be VBZ 19613 7274 10 _ _ NNP 19613 7274 11 speciosior speciosior JJ 19613 7274 12 quam quam NNP 19613 7274 13 verior verior NNP 19613 7274 14 _ _ NNP 19613 7274 15 . . . 19613 7275 1 In in IN 19613 7275 2 adv adv NN 19613 7275 3 . . . 19613 7276 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7276 2 . . . 19613 7277 1 II ii CD 19613 7277 2 . . . 19613 7278 1 4 4 CD 19613 7278 2 ff ff NNP 19613 7278 3 . . . 19613 7279 1 Wendt Wendt VBN 19613 7279 2 professes profess VBZ 19613 7279 3 to to TO 19613 7279 4 see see VB 19613 7279 5 the the DT 19613 7279 6 first first JJ 19613 7279 7 traces trace NNS 19613 7279 8 of of IN 19613 7279 9 the the DT 19613 7279 10 scholastic scholastic JJ 19613 7279 11 and and CC 19613 7279 12 Romish romish JJ 19613 7279 13 theory theory NN 19613 7279 14 , , , 19613 7279 15 and and CC 19613 7279 16 in in IN 19613 7279 17 de de NNP 19613 7279 18 anima anima NNP 19613 7279 19 16 16 CD 19613 7279 20 , , , 19613 7279 21 41 41 CD 19613 7279 22 the the DT 19613 7279 23 germ germ NN 19613 7279 24 of of IN 19613 7279 25 the the DT 19613 7279 26 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 7279 27 Protestant Protestant NNP 19613 7279 28 view view NN 19613 7279 29 . . . 19613 7279 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7280 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7280 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7280 3 568 568 CD 19613 7280 4 : : : 19613 7280 5 See see VB 19613 7280 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7280 7 . . . 19613 7281 1 5 5 CD 19613 7281 2 . . . 19613 7282 1 1 1 CD 19613 7282 2 , , , 19613 7282 3 6 6 CD 19613 7282 4 . . . 19613 7283 1 4 4 LS 19613 7283 2 . . . 19613 7283 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7284 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7284 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7284 3 569 569 CD 19613 7284 4 : : : 19613 7284 5 See see VB 19613 7284 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7284 7 14 14 CD 19613 7284 8 . . . 19613 7285 1 1 1 LS 19613 7285 2 : : : 19613 7285 3 " " `` 19613 7285 4 In in IN 19613 7285 5 quantum quantum JJ 19613 7285 6 enim enim NNP 19613 7285 7 deus deus NNP 19613 7285 8 nullius nullius NNP 19613 7285 9 indiget indiget NN 19613 7285 10 , , , 19613 7285 11 in in IN 19613 7285 12 tantum tantum NNP 19613 7285 13 homo homo NNP 19613 7285 14 indiget indiget NNP 19613 7285 15 dei dei NNP 19613 7285 16 communione communione NN 19613 7285 17 . . . 19613 7286 1 Hæc Hæc NNP 19613 7286 2 enim enim NNP 19613 7286 3 gloria gloria NNP 19613 7286 4 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7286 5 , , , 19613 7286 6 perseverare perseverare NNP 19613 7286 7 et et NNP 19613 7286 8 permanere permanere NN 19613 7286 9 in in IN 19613 7286 10 dei dei NNP 19613 7286 11 servitute servitute NNP 19613 7286 12 . . . 19613 7286 13 " " '' 19613 7287 1 This this DT 19613 7287 2 statement statement NN 19613 7287 3 , , , 19613 7287 4 which which WDT 19613 7287 5 , , , 19613 7287 6 like like IN 19613 7287 7 the the DT 19613 7287 8 numerous numerous JJ 19613 7287 9 others other NNS 19613 7287 10 where where WRB 19613 7287 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7287 12 speaks speak VBZ 19613 7287 13 of of IN 19613 7287 14 the the DT 19613 7287 15 adoptio adoptio NN 19613 7287 16 , , , 19613 7287 17 is be VBZ 19613 7287 18 opposed oppose VBN 19613 7287 19 to to TO 19613 7287 20 moralism moralism VB 19613 7287 21 , , , 19613 7287 22 reminds remind VBZ 19613 7287 23 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7287 24 of of IN 19613 7287 25 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 7287 26 . . . 19613 7288 1 In in IN 19613 7288 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7288 3 ' ' POS 19613 7288 4 great great JJ 19613 7288 5 work work NN 19613 7288 6 , , , 19613 7288 7 however however RB 19613 7288 8 , , , 19613 7288 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7288 10 can can MD 19613 7288 11 point point VB 19613 7288 12 out out RP 19613 7288 13 not not RB 19613 7288 14 a a DT 19613 7288 15 few few JJ 19613 7288 16 propositions proposition NNS 19613 7288 17 which which WDT 19613 7288 18 , , , 19613 7288 19 so so RB 19613 7288 20 to to TO 19613 7288 21 speak speak VB 19613 7288 22 , , , 19613 7288 23 bear bear VB 19613 7288 24 the the DT 19613 7288 25 stamp stamp NN 19613 7288 26 of of IN 19613 7288 27 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 7288 28 ; ; : 19613 7288 29 see see VB 19613 7288 30 IV IV NNP 19613 7288 31 . . . 19613 7289 1 38 38 CD 19613 7289 2 . . . 19613 7290 1 3 3 LS 19613 7290 2 : : : 19613 7290 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7290 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7290 5 : : : 19613 7290 6 hupotagê hupotagê NNP 19613 7290 7 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7290 8 aphtharsia aphtharsia NNP 19613 7290 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7290 10 . . . 19613 7290 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7291 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7291 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7291 3 570 570 CD 19613 7291 4 : : : 19613 7291 5 See see VB 19613 7291 6 the the DT 19613 7291 7 passages passage NNS 19613 7291 8 quoted quote VBN 19613 7291 9 above above RB 19613 7291 10 , , , 19613 7291 11 p. p. NN 19613 7291 12 241 241 CD 19613 7291 13 f. f. NN 19613 7291 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7291 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7291 16 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7291 17 571 571 CD 19613 7291 18 : : : 19613 7291 19 See see VB 19613 7291 20 III iii CD 19613 7291 21 . . . 19613 7292 1 18 18 CD 19613 7292 2 . . . 19613 7293 1 1 1 LS 19613 7293 2 . . . 19613 7294 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7294 2 16 16 CD 19613 7294 3 . . . 19613 7295 1 1 1 CD 19613 7295 2 is be VBZ 19613 7295 3 very very RB 19613 7295 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 7295 5 : : : 19613 7295 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7295 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7295 8 : : . 19613 7295 9 En En NNP 19613 7295 10 tois tois NNP 19613 7295 11 prosthen prosthen NNP 19613 7295 12 chronois chronois NNP 19613 7295 13 elegeto elegeto NNP 19613 7295 14 men man NNS 19613 7295 15 kat kat NNP 19613 7295 16 ' ' '' 19613 7295 17 eikona eikona NN 19613 7295 18 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7295 19 gegonenai gegonenai NNP 19613 7295 20 ton ton NN 19613 7295 21 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNS 19613 7295 22 , , , 19613 7295 23 ouk ouk NNP 19613 7295 24 edeiknuto edeiknuto NNP 19613 7295 25 de de NNP 19613 7295 26 , , , 19613 7295 27 eti eti NNP 19613 7295 28 gar gar NNP 19613 7295 29 aoratos aoratos NNP 19613 7295 30 ên ên NNP 19613 7295 31 ho ho NNP 19613 7295 32 logos logos NNP 19613 7295 33 , , , 19613 7295 34 ou ou NNP 19613 7295 35 kat kat NNP 19613 7295 36 ' ' `` 19613 7295 37 eikona eikona NNP 19613 7295 38 ho ho NNP 19613 7295 39 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 7295 40 egegonei egegonei NNP 19613 7295 41 . . . 19613 7296 1 dia dia NNP 19613 7296 2 touto touto NNP 19613 7296 3 dê dê NNP 19613 7296 4 kai kai NNP 19613 7296 5 tên tên NNP 19613 7296 6 homoiôsin homoiôsin NNP 19613 7296 7 iadiôs iadiôs NNP 19613 7296 8 apebalen apebalen NNP 19613 7296 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7296 10 ; ; : 19613 7296 11 see see VB 19613 7296 12 also also RB 19613 7296 13 what what WP 19613 7296 14 follows follow VBZ 19613 7296 15 . . . 19613 7297 1 In in IN 19613 7297 2 V. V. NNP 19613 7297 3 I. i. NN 19613 7298 1 1 1 LS 19613 7298 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7298 3 even even RB 19613 7298 4 says say VBZ 19613 7298 5 : : : 19613 7298 6 " " `` 19613 7298 7 Quoniam quoniam JJ 19613 7298 8 iniuste iniuste JJ 19613 7298 9 dominabatur dominabatur NN 19613 7298 10 nobis nobis NN 19613 7298 11 apostasia apostasia NNP 19613 7298 12 , , , 19613 7298 13 et et NNP 19613 7298 14 cum cum NNP 19613 7298 15 natura natura NNP 19613 7298 16 essemus essemus NNP 19613 7298 17 dei dei NNP 19613 7298 18 omnipotentis omnipotentis NNP 19613 7298 19 , , , 19613 7298 20 alienavit alienavit NNP 19613 7298 21 nos nos NNP 19613 7298 22 contra contra NNP 19613 7298 23 naturam naturam NNP 19613 7298 24 diabolus diabolus NN 19613 7298 25 . . . 19613 7298 26 " " '' 19613 7299 1 Compare compare VB 19613 7299 2 with with IN 19613 7299 3 this this DT 19613 7299 4 the the DT 19613 7299 5 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 7299 6 passage passage NN 19613 7299 7 IV IV NNP 19613 7299 8 . . . 19613 7300 1 38 38 CD 19613 7300 2 : : : 19613 7300 3 " " `` 19613 7300 4 oportuerat oportuerat NNP 19613 7300 5 autem autem NNP 19613 7300 6 primo primo NNP 19613 7300 7 naturam naturam NNP 19613 7300 8 apparere apparere RB 19613 7300 9 " " `` 19613 7300 10 etc etc FW 19613 7300 11 . . . 19613 7301 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7301 2 see see VB 19613 7301 3 above above RB 19613 7301 4 , , , 19613 7301 5 p. p. NN 19613 7301 6 268 268 CD 19613 7301 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7301 8 , , , 19613 7301 9 where where WRB 19613 7301 10 _ _ NNP 19613 7301 11 natura natura NNP 19613 7301 12 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7301 13 _ _ NNP 19613 7301 14 is be VBZ 19613 7301 15 conceived conceive VBN 19613 7301 16 as as IN 19613 7301 17 the the DT 19613 7301 18 opposite opposite NN 19613 7301 19 of of IN 19613 7301 20 the the DT 19613 7301 21 divine divine JJ 19613 7301 22 nature nature NN 19613 7301 23 . . . 19613 7301 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7302 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7302 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7302 3 572 572 CD 19613 7302 4 : : : 19613 7302 5 See See NNP 19613 7302 6 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 7302 7 , , , 19613 7302 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7302 9 . . NNP 19613 7302 10 , , , 19613 7302 11 p. p. NN 19613 7302 12 29 29 CD 19613 7302 13 , , , 19613 7302 14 who who WP 19613 7302 15 first first RB 19613 7302 16 pointed point VBD 19613 7302 17 out out RP 19613 7302 18 the the DT 19613 7302 19 two two CD 19613 7302 20 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 19613 7302 21 trains train NNS 19613 7302 22 of of IN 19613 7302 23 thought thought NN 19613 7302 24 in in IN 19613 7302 25 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7302 26 with with IN 19613 7302 27 regard regard NN 19613 7302 28 to to IN 19613 7302 29 man man NN 19613 7302 30 's 's POS 19613 7302 31 original original JJ 19613 7302 32 state state NN 19613 7302 33 , , , 19613 7302 34 Duncker Duncker NNP 19613 7302 35 having have VBG 19613 7302 36 already already RB 19613 7302 37 done do VBN 19613 7302 38 so so RB 19613 7302 39 in in IN 19613 7302 40 regard regard NN 19613 7302 41 to to IN 19613 7302 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7302 43 Christology christology NN 19613 7302 44 . . . 19613 7303 1 Wendt Wendt NNP 19613 7303 2 has have VBZ 19613 7303 3 rightly rightly RB 19613 7303 4 shown show VBN 19613 7303 5 that that IN 19613 7303 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7303 7 have have VBP 19613 7303 8 here here RB 19613 7303 9 a a DT 19613 7303 10 real real JJ 19613 7303 11 and and CC 19613 7303 12 not not RB 19613 7303 13 a a DT 19613 7303 14 seeming seeming JJ 19613 7303 15 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 7303 16 ; ; : 19613 7303 17 but but CC 19613 7303 18 , , , 19613 7303 19 as as RB 19613 7303 20 far far RB 19613 7303 21 as as IN 19613 7303 22 the the DT 19613 7303 23 explanation explanation NN 19613 7303 24 of of IN 19613 7303 25 the the DT 19613 7303 26 fact fact NN 19613 7303 27 is be VBZ 19613 7303 28 concerned concern VBN 19613 7303 29 , , , 19613 7303 30 the the DT 19613 7303 31 truth truth NN 19613 7303 32 does do VBZ 19613 7303 33 not not RB 19613 7303 34 seem seem VB 19613 7303 35 to to IN 19613 7303 36 me -PRON- PRP 19613 7303 37 to to TO 19613 7303 38 have have VB 19613 7303 39 been be VBN 19613 7303 40 arrived arrive VBN 19613 7303 41 at at IN 19613 7303 42 . . . 19613 7304 1 The the DT 19613 7304 2 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 7304 3 that that WDT 19613 7304 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7304 5 did do VBD 19613 7304 6 not not RB 19613 7304 7 develop develop VB 19613 7304 8 the the DT 19613 7304 9 mystic mystic JJ 19613 7304 10 view view NN 19613 7304 11 in in IN 19613 7304 12 such such PDT 19613 7304 13 a a DT 19613 7304 14 systematic systematic JJ 19613 7304 15 way way NN 19613 7304 16 as as IN 19613 7304 17 the the DT 19613 7304 18 moralistic moralistic JJ 19613 7304 19 by by IN 19613 7304 20 no no DT 19613 7304 21 means means NN 19613 7304 22 justifies justify VBZ 19613 7304 23 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7304 24 in in IN 19613 7304 25 supposing suppose VBG 19613 7304 26 that that IN 19613 7304 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7304 28 merely merely RB 19613 7304 29 adopted adopt VBD 19613 7304 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7304 31 superficially superficially RB 19613 7304 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7304 33 from from IN 19613 7304 34 the the DT 19613 7304 35 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 7304 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7304 37 : : : 19613 7304 38 for for IN 19613 7304 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7304 40 nature nature NN 19613 7304 41 admits admit NNS 19613 7304 42 of of IN 19613 7304 43 no no DT 19613 7304 44 systematic systematic JJ 19613 7304 45 treatment treatment NN 19613 7304 46 , , , 19613 7304 47 but but CC 19613 7304 48 only only RB 19613 7304 49 of of IN 19613 7304 50 a a DT 19613 7304 51 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 19613 7304 52 and and CC 19613 7304 53 contemplative contemplative JJ 19613 7304 54 one one CD 19613 7304 55 . . . 19613 7305 1 No no DT 19613 7305 2 further further JJ 19613 7305 3 explanation explanation NN 19613 7305 4 can can MD 19613 7305 5 be be VB 19613 7305 6 given give VBN 19613 7305 7 of of IN 19613 7305 8 the the DT 19613 7305 9 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 7305 10 , , , 19613 7305 11 because because IN 19613 7305 12 , , , 19613 7305 13 strictly strictly RB 19613 7305 14 speaking speak VBG 19613 7305 15 , , , 19613 7305 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7305 17 has have VBZ 19613 7305 18 only only RB 19613 7305 19 given give VBN 19613 7305 20 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7305 21 fragments fragment NNS 19613 7305 22 . . . 19613 7305 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7306 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7306 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7306 3 573 573 CD 19613 7306 4 : : : 19613 7306 5 See see VB 19613 7306 6 V. V. NNP 19613 7306 7 16 16 CD 19613 7306 8 . . . 19613 7307 1 3 3 LS 19613 7307 2 : : : 19613 7307 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7307 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7307 5 : : : 19613 7307 6 en en VB 19613 7307 7 tô tô NNP 19613 7307 8 prôtô prôtô VB 19613 7307 9 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7307 10 prosekopsamen prosekopsaman NNS 19613 7307 11 , , , 19613 7307 12 mê mê NNP 19613 7307 13 poiêsantes poiêsantes NNP 19613 7307 14 autou autou NNP 19613 7307 15 tên tên NNP 19613 7307 16 entolên entolên NNP 19613 7307 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7307 18 . . . 19613 7308 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7308 2 . . . 19613 7309 1 34 34 CD 19613 7309 2 . . . 19613 7310 1 2 2 LS 19613 7310 2 : : : 19613 7310 3 " " `` 19613 7310 4 homo homo NN 19613 7310 5 initio initio NN 19613 7310 6 in in IN 19613 7310 7 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7310 8 inobediens inobedien VBZ 19613 7310 9 per per IN 19613 7310 10 mortem mortem FW 19613 7310 11 percussus percussus NN 19613 7310 12 est est NNP 19613 7310 13 ; ; : 19613 7310 14 " " `` 19613 7310 15 III iii CD 19613 7310 16 . . . 19613 7311 1 18 18 CD 19613 7311 2 . . . 19613 7312 1 7 7 CD 19613 7312 2 - - SYM 19613 7312 3 23 23 CD 19613 7312 4 : : : 19613 7312 5 V. v. NN 19613 7312 6 19 19 CD 19613 7312 7 . . . 19613 7313 1 1 1 LS 19613 7313 2 : : : 19613 7313 3 V. V. NNP 19613 7313 4 21 21 CD 19613 7313 5 . . . 19613 7314 1 1 1 LS 19613 7314 2 : : : 19613 7314 3 V. V. NNP 19613 7314 4 17 17 CD 19613 7314 5 . . . 19613 7315 1 1 1 CD 19613 7315 2 sq sq NNP 19613 7315 3 . . . 19613 7315 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7316 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7316 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7316 3 574 574 CD 19613 7316 4 : : : 19613 7316 5 Here here RB 19613 7316 6 also also RB 19613 7316 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7316 8 keeps keep VBZ 19613 7316 9 sin sin NN 19613 7316 10 in in IN 19613 7316 11 the the DT 19613 7316 12 background background NN 19613 7316 13 ; ; : 19613 7316 14 death death NN 19613 7316 15 and and CC 19613 7316 16 life life NN 19613 7316 17 are be VBP 19613 7316 18 the the DT 19613 7316 19 essential essential JJ 19613 7316 20 ideas idea NNS 19613 7316 21 . . . 19613 7317 1 Bohringer Bohringer NNP 19613 7317 2 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7317 3 . . NNP 19613 7317 4 , , , 19613 7317 5 p. p. NN 19613 7317 6 484 484 CD 19613 7317 7 has have VBZ 19613 7317 8 very very RB 19613 7317 9 rightly rightly RB 19613 7317 10 remarked remark VBN 19613 7317 11 : : : 19613 7317 12 " " `` 19613 7317 13 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7317 14 can can MD 19613 7317 15 not not RB 19613 7317 16 say say VB 19613 7317 17 that that IN 19613 7317 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7317 19 , , , 19613 7317 20 in in IN 19613 7317 21 making make VBG 19613 7317 22 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7317 23 's 's POS 19613 7317 24 conduct conduct NN 19613 7317 25 and and CC 19613 7317 26 suffering suffering NN 19613 7317 27 apply apply VB 19613 7317 28 to to IN 19613 7317 29 the the DT 19613 7317 30 whole whole JJ 19613 7317 31 human human JJ 19613 7317 32 race race NN 19613 7317 33 had have VBD 19613 7317 34 started start VBN 19613 7317 35 from from IN 19613 7317 36 an an DT 19613 7317 37 inward inward JJ 19613 7317 38 , , , 19613 7317 39 immediate immediate JJ 19613 7317 40 experience experience NN 19613 7317 41 of of IN 19613 7317 42 human human JJ 19613 7317 43 sinfulness sinfulness NN 19613 7317 44 and and CC 19613 7317 45 a a DT 19613 7317 46 feeling feeling NN 19613 7317 47 of of IN 19613 7317 48 the the DT 19613 7317 49 need need NN 19613 7317 50 of of IN 19613 7317 51 salvation salvation NN 19613 7317 52 founded found VBN 19613 7317 53 on on IN 19613 7317 54 this this DT 19613 7317 55 . . . 19613 7317 56 " " '' 19613 7318 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7318 2 is be VBZ 19613 7318 3 the the DT 19613 7318 4 thoughts thought NNS 19613 7318 5 of of IN 19613 7318 6 Paul Paul NNP 19613 7318 7 to to TO 19613 7318 8 which which WDT 19613 7318 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7318 10 tried try VBD 19613 7318 11 to to TO 19613 7318 12 accommodate accommodate VB 19613 7318 13 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7318 14 without without IN 19613 7318 15 having have VBG 19613 7318 16 had have VBN 19613 7318 17 the the DT 19613 7318 18 same same JJ 19613 7318 19 feeling feeling NN 19613 7318 20 about about IN 19613 7318 21 the the DT 19613 7318 22 flesh flesh NN 19613 7318 23 and and CC 19613 7318 24 sin sin NN 19613 7318 25 as as IN 19613 7318 26 this this DT 19613 7318 27 Apostle apostle NN 19613 7318 28 . . . 19613 7319 1 In in IN 19613 7319 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7319 3 the the DT 19613 7319 4 mystic mystic JJ 19613 7319 5 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 7319 6 of of IN 19613 7319 7 salvation salvation NN 19613 7319 8 is be VBZ 19613 7319 9 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 7319 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7319 11 but but CC 19613 7319 12 see see VB 19613 7319 13 , , , 19613 7319 14 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7320 1 de de NNP 19613 7320 2 anima anima NNP 19613 7320 3 40 40 CD 19613 7320 4 : : : 19613 7320 5 " " `` 19613 7320 6 ita ita NNP 19613 7320 7 omnis omnis NNP 19613 7320 8 anima anima NNP 19613 7320 9 eo eo NNP 19613 7320 10 usque usque NNP 19613 7320 11 in in IN 19613 7320 12 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7320 13 censetur censetur NN 19613 7320 14 donec donec NN 19613 7320 15 in in IN 19613 7320 16 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7320 17 recenseatur recenseatur NN 19613 7320 18 , , , 19613 7320 19 " " `` 19613 7320 20 and and CC 19613 7320 21 other other JJ 19613 7320 22 passages passage NNS 19613 7320 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7320 24 ; ; : 19613 7320 25 but but CC 19613 7320 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7320 27 has have VBZ 19613 7320 28 speculations speculation NNS 19613 7320 29 about about IN 19613 7320 30 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7320 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7320 32 for for IN 19613 7320 33 the the DT 19613 7320 34 most most JJS 19613 7320 35 part part NN 19613 7320 36 developments development NNS 19613 7320 37 of of IN 19613 7320 38 hints hint NNS 19613 7320 39 given give VBN 19613 7320 40 in in IN 19613 7320 41 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7320 42 ; ; : 19613 7320 43 see see VB 19613 7320 44 the the DT 19613 7320 45 index index NN 19613 7320 46 in in IN 19613 7320 47 Oehler Oehler NNP 19613 7320 48 's 's POS 19613 7320 49 edition edition NN 19613 7320 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7320 51 , , , 19613 7320 52 and and CC 19613 7320 53 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7320 54 has have VBZ 19613 7320 55 a a DT 19613 7320 56 new new JJ 19613 7320 57 realistic realistic JJ 19613 7320 58 idea idea NN 19613 7320 59 as as IN 19613 7320 60 to to IN 19613 7320 61 a a DT 19613 7320 62 physical physical JJ 19613 7320 63 taint taint NN 19613 7320 64 of of IN 19613 7320 65 sin sin NN 19613 7320 66 propagated propagate VBD 19613 7320 67 through through IN 19613 7320 68 procreation procreation NN 19613 7320 69 . . . 19613 7321 1 Here here RB 19613 7321 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7321 3 have have VBP 19613 7321 4 the the DT 19613 7321 5 first first JJ 19613 7321 6 beginning beginning NN 19613 7321 7 of of IN 19613 7321 8 the the DT 19613 7321 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 7321 10 of of IN 19613 7321 11 original original JJ 19613 7321 12 sin sin NN 19613 7321 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7321 14 de de NNP 19613 7321 15 testim testim NNP 19613 7321 16 . . . 19613 7322 1 3 3 LS 19613 7322 2 : : : 19613 7322 3 " " `` 19613 7322 4 per per IN 19613 7322 5 diabolum diabolum NN 19613 7322 6 homo homo NN 19613 7322 7 a a DT 19613 7322 8 primordio primordio NN 19613 7322 9 circumventus circumventus NN 19613 7322 10 , , , 19613 7322 11 ut ut UH 19613 7322 12 præceptum præceptum NNP 19613 7322 13 dei dei NNP 19613 7322 14 excederet excederet NNP 19613 7322 15 , , , 19613 7322 16 et et NNP 19613 7322 17 propterea propterea NNP 19613 7322 18 in in IN 19613 7322 19 mortem mortem NNP 19613 7322 20 datus datus NNP 19613 7322 21 exinde exinde NNP 19613 7322 22 totum totum NNP 19613 7322 23 genus genus NNP 19613 7322 24 de de FW 19613 7322 25 suo suo NNP 19613 7322 26 semine semine NNP 19613 7322 27 infectum infectum NNP 19613 7322 28 suæ suæ NNP 19613 7322 29 etiam etiam NNP 19613 7322 30 damnationis damnationis NNP 19613 7322 31 traducem traducem NNP 19613 7322 32 fecit fecit NN 19613 7322 33 . . . 19613 7322 34 " " '' 19613 7323 1 Compare compare VB 19613 7323 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7323 3 teachings teaching NNS 19613 7323 4 in in IN 19613 7323 5 de de NNP 19613 7323 6 anima anima NNP 19613 7323 7 40 40 CD 19613 7323 8 , , , 19613 7323 9 41 41 CD 19613 7323 10 , , , 19613 7323 11 16 16 CD 19613 7323 12 about about IN 19613 7323 13 the the DT 19613 7323 14 disease disease NN 19613 7323 15 of of IN 19613 7323 16 sin sin NN 19613 7323 17 that that WDT 19613 7323 18 is be VBZ 19613 7323 19 propagated propagate VBN 19613 7323 20 " " `` 19613 7323 21 ex ex FW 19613 7323 22 originis originis NNP 19613 7323 23 vitio vitio NN 19613 7323 24 " " '' 19613 7323 25 and and CC 19613 7323 26 has have VBZ 19613 7323 27 become become VBN 19613 7323 28 a a DT 19613 7323 29 real real JJ 19613 7323 30 second second JJ 19613 7323 31 nature nature NN 19613 7323 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7323 33 . . . 19613 7324 1 But but CC 19613 7324 2 how how WRB 19613 7324 3 little little JJ 19613 7324 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7324 5 regards regard VBZ 19613 7324 6 this this DT 19613 7324 7 original original JJ 19613 7324 8 sin sin NN 19613 7324 9 as as IN 19613 7324 10 guilt guilt NN 19613 7324 11 is be VBZ 19613 7324 12 shown show VBN 19613 7324 13 by by IN 19613 7324 14 de de NNP 19613 7324 15 bapt bapt NNP 19613 7324 16 . . . 19613 7325 1 18 18 CD 19613 7325 2 : : : 19613 7325 3 " " `` 19613 7325 4 Quaie Quaie NNP 19613 7325 5 innocens innocen VBZ 19613 7325 6 ætas ætas NNPS 19613 7325 7 festinat festinat NNP 19613 7325 8 ad ad NN 19613 7325 9 baptismum baptismum NN 19613 7325 10 . . . 19613 7325 11 " " '' 19613 7326 1 For for IN 19613 7326 2 the the DT 19613 7326 3 rest rest NN 19613 7326 4 , , , 19613 7326 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7326 6 discussed discuss VBD 19613 7326 7 the the DT 19613 7326 8 relationship relationship NN 19613 7326 9 of of IN 19613 7326 10 flesh flesh NN 19613 7326 11 and and CC 19613 7326 12 spirit spirit NN 19613 7326 13 , , , 19613 7326 14 sensuousness sensuousness NN 19613 7326 15 and and CC 19613 7326 16 intellect intellect VB 19613 7326 17 , , , 19613 7326 18 much much RB 19613 7326 19 more more RBR 19613 7326 20 thoroughly thoroughly RB 19613 7326 21 than than IN 19613 7326 22 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7326 23 ; ; : 19613 7326 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7326 25 showed show VBD 19613 7326 26 that that IN 19613 7326 27 flesh flesh NN 19613 7326 28 is be VBZ 19613 7326 29 not not RB 19613 7326 30 the the DT 19613 7326 31 seat seat NN 19613 7326 32 of of IN 19613 7326 33 sin sin NN 19613 7326 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7326 35 de de FW 19613 7326 36 anima anima NNP 19613 7326 37 40 40 CD 19613 7326 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7326 39 . . . 19613 7327 1 In in IN 19613 7327 2 the the DT 19613 7327 3 same same JJ 19613 7327 4 book book NN 19613 7327 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7327 6 but but CC 19613 7327 7 see see VB 19613 7327 8 Bk Bk NNP 19613 7327 9 . . . 19613 7328 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7328 2 c. c. NNP 19613 7328 3 1 1 CD 19613 7328 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7328 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7328 6 expressly expressly RB 19613 7328 7 declared declare VBD 19613 7328 8 that that IN 19613 7328 9 in in IN 19613 7328 10 this this DT 19613 7328 11 question question NN 19613 7328 12 also also RB 19613 7328 13 sure sure JJ 19613 7328 14 results result NNS 19613 7328 15 are be VBP 19613 7328 16 only only RB 19613 7328 17 to to TO 19613 7328 18 be be VB 19613 7328 19 obtained obtain VBN 19613 7328 20 from from IN 19613 7328 21 revelation revelation NN 19613 7328 22 . . . 19613 7329 1 This this DT 19613 7329 2 was be VBD 19613 7329 3 an an DT 19613 7329 4 important important JJ 19613 7329 5 step step NN 19613 7329 6 in in IN 19613 7329 7 the the DT 19613 7329 8 direction direction NN 19613 7329 9 of of IN 19613 7329 10 secularising secularise VBG 19613 7329 11 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 7329 12 through through IN 19613 7329 13 " " `` 19613 7329 14 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 7329 15 " " '' 19613 7329 16 and and CC 19613 7329 17 of of IN 19613 7329 18 emasculating emasculate VBG 19613 7329 19 the the DT 19613 7329 20 understanding understanding NN 19613 7329 21 through through IN 19613 7329 22 " " `` 19613 7329 23 revelation revelation NN 19613 7329 24 . . . 19613 7329 25 " " '' 19613 7330 1 In in IN 19613 7330 2 regard regard NN 19613 7330 3 to to IN 19613 7330 4 the the DT 19613 7330 5 conception conception NN 19613 7330 6 of of IN 19613 7330 7 sin sin NN 19613 7330 8 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 7330 9 followed follow VBD 19613 7330 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7330 11 teacher teacher NN 19613 7330 12 . . . 19613 7331 1 De De NNP 19613 7331 2 op op NNP 19613 7331 3 . . . 19613 7332 1 et et NN 19613 7332 2 eleem eleem NNP 19613 7332 3 . . . 19613 7333 1 1 1 CD 19613 7333 2 reads read NNS 19613 7333 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 7333 4 like like IN 19613 7333 5 an an DT 19613 7333 6 utterance utterance NN 19613 7333 7 of of IN 19613 7333 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7333 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7333 10 " " `` 19613 7333 11 dominus dominus NN 19613 7333 12 sanavit sanavit VBP 19613 7333 13 illa illa RB 19613 7333 14 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7333 15 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7333 16 portaverat portaverat FW 19613 7333 17 vulnera vulnera NN 19613 7333 18 " " '' 19613 7333 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7333 20 ; ; : 19613 7333 21 but but CC 19613 7333 22 the the DT 19613 7333 23 statement statement NN 19613 7333 24 in in IN 19613 7333 25 ep ep NNP 19613 7333 26 . . . 19613 7334 1 64 64 CD 19613 7334 2 . . . 19613 7335 1 5 5 CD 19613 7335 2 : : : 19613 7335 3 " " `` 19613 7335 4 Recens Recens NNP 19613 7335 5 natus natus NN 19613 7335 6 nihil nihil NNP 19613 7335 7 peccavit peccavit NNP 19613 7335 8 , , , 19613 7335 9 nisi nisi NNP 19613 7335 10 quod quod NN 19613 7335 11 secundum secundum NN 19613 7335 12 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7335 13 carnaliter carnaliter NN 19613 7335 14 natus natus NNP 19613 7335 15 contagium contagium NNP 19613 7335 16 mortis mortis NNP 19613 7335 17 antiquæ antiquæ NNP 19613 7335 18 prima prima NNP 19613 7335 19 nativitate nativitate NNP 19613 7335 20 contraxit contraxit NNP 19613 7335 21 " " '' 19613 7335 22 is be VBZ 19613 7335 23 quite quite RB 19613 7335 24 in in IN 19613 7335 25 the the DT 19613 7335 26 manner manner NN 19613 7335 27 of of IN 19613 7335 28 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7335 29 , , , 19613 7335 30 and and CC 19613 7335 31 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 7335 32 the the DT 19613 7335 33 latter latter JJ 19613 7335 34 could could MD 19613 7335 35 also also RB 19613 7335 36 have have VB 19613 7335 37 agreed agree VBN 19613 7335 38 with with IN 19613 7335 39 the the DT 19613 7335 40 continuation continuation NN 19613 7335 41 : : : 19613 7335 42 " " `` 19613 7335 43 infanti infanti NNP 19613 7335 44 remittuntur remittuntur NNP 19613 7335 45 non non AFX 19613 7335 46 propria propria NNP 19613 7335 47 sed sed NNP 19613 7335 48 aliena aliena NNP 19613 7335 49 peccata peccata NNP 19613 7335 50 . . . 19613 7335 51 " " '' 19613 7336 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7336 2 's 's POS 19613 7336 3 proposition proposition NN 19613 7336 4 that that IN 19613 7336 5 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 7336 6 no no DT 19613 7336 7 one one NN 19613 7336 8 but but IN 19613 7336 9 the the DT 19613 7336 10 Son Son NNP 19613 7336 11 of of IN 19613 7336 12 God God NNP 19613 7336 13 could could MD 19613 7336 14 have have VB 19613 7336 15 remained remain VBN 19613 7336 16 without without IN 19613 7336 17 sin sin NN 19613 7336 18 was be VBD 19613 7336 19 repeated repeat VBN 19613 7336 20 by by IN 19613 7336 21 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 7336 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7336 23 see see VB 19613 7336 24 , , , 19613 7336 25 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7336 26 , , , 19613 7336 27 de de FW 19613 7336 28 op op NN 19613 7336 29 . . . 19613 7337 1 et et NN 19613 7337 2 eleem eleem NNP 19613 7337 3 . . . 19613 7338 1 3 3 LS 19613 7338 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7338 3 . . . 19613 7338 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7339 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7339 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7339 3 575 575 CD 19613 7339 4 : : : 19613 7339 5 III iii CD 19613 7339 6 . . . 19613 7340 1 22 22 CD 19613 7340 2 . . . 19613 7341 1 4 4 LS 19613 7341 2 has have VBZ 19613 7341 3 quite quite PDT 19613 7341 4 a a DT 19613 7341 5 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 7341 6 sound sound NN 19613 7341 7 ... ... : 19613 7341 8 " " `` 19613 7341 9 eam eam NNP 19613 7341 10 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7341 11 est est NNP 19613 7341 12 a a DT 19613 7341 13 Maria Maria NNP 19613 7341 14 in in IN 19613 7341 15 Evam Evam NNP 19613 7341 16 recirculationem recirculationem NNP 19613 7341 17 significans significans NNPS 19613 7341 18 ; ; : 19613 7341 19 quia quia NNP 19613 7341 20 non non AFX 19613 7341 21 aliter aliter NN 19613 7341 22 quod quod NN 19613 7341 23 colligatum colligatum NNP 19613 7341 24 est est NNP 19613 7341 25 solveretur solveretur NNP 19613 7341 26 , , , 19613 7341 27 nisi nisi JJ 19613 7341 28 ipsæ ipsæ JJ 19613 7341 29 compagines compagines NNPS 19613 7341 30 alligationis alligationis NNP 19613 7341 31 reflectantur reflectantur NNP 19613 7341 32 retrorsus retrorsus NNP 19613 7341 33 , , , 19613 7341 34 ut ut NNP 19613 7341 35 primæ primæ NN 19613 7341 36 coniunctiones coniunctione NNS 19613 7341 37 solvantur solvantur NNP 19613 7341 38 per per IN 19613 7341 39 secundas secundas NNP 19613 7341 40 , , , 19613 7341 41 secundæ secundæ JJ 19613 7341 42 rursus rursus NN 19613 7341 43 liberent liberent NN 19613 7341 44 primas prima NNS 19613 7341 45 . . . 19613 7342 1 Et et NN 19613 7342 2 evenit evenit NN 19613 7342 3 primam primam NNP 19613 7342 4 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7342 5 compaginem compaginem NNP 19613 7342 6 a a DT 19613 7342 7 secunda secunda NNP 19613 7342 8 colligatione colligatione NN 19613 7342 9 solvere solvere RB 19613 7342 10 , , , 19613 7342 11 secundam secundam NNP 19613 7342 12 vero vero NNP 19613 7342 13 colligationem colligationem NNP 19613 7342 14 primæ primæ NNP 19613 7342 15 solutionis solutionis NNP 19613 7342 16 habere habere NNP 19613 7342 17 locum locum NNP 19613 7342 18 . . . 19613 7343 1 Et et NN 19613 7343 2 propter propter NN 19613 7343 3 hoc hoc FW 19613 7343 4 dominus dominus NNP 19613 7343 5 dicebat dicebat NNP 19613 7343 6 primos primos NNP 19613 7343 7 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7343 8 novissimos novissimos NNP 19613 7343 9 futuros futuros NNP 19613 7343 10 et et NNP 19613 7343 11 novissimos novissimos NNP 19613 7343 12 primos primos NNP 19613 7343 13 . . . 19613 7343 14 " " '' 19613 7344 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7344 2 expresses express VBZ 19613 7344 3 a a DT 19613 7344 4 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 7344 5 idea idea NN 19613 7344 6 when when WRB 19613 7344 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7344 8 on on IN 19613 7344 9 one one CD 19613 7344 10 occasion occasion NN 19613 7344 11 plainly plainly RB 19613 7344 12 says say VBZ 19613 7344 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7344 14 V. V. NNP 19613 7344 15 12 12 CD 19613 7344 16 . . . 19613 7345 1 3 3 LS 19613 7345 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7345 3 : : : 19613 7345 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7345 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7345 6 : : . 19613 7345 7 En en IN 19613 7345 8 tô tô NNP 19613 7345 9 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7345 10 pantes pant VBZ 19613 7345 11 apothnêskomen apothnêskoman NNS 19613 7345 12 , , , 19613 7345 13 hoti hoti NNP 19613 7345 14 psychikoi psychikoi NNP 19613 7345 15 . . . 19613 7345 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7346 1 But but CC 19613 7346 2 Paul Paul NNP 19613 7346 3 , , , 19613 7346 4 too too RB 19613 7346 5 , , , 19613 7346 6 made make VBD 19613 7346 7 an an DT 19613 7346 8 approach approach NN 19613 7346 9 to to IN 19613 7346 10 this this DT 19613 7346 11 thought thought NN 19613 7346 12 . . . 19613 7346 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7347 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7347 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7347 3 576 576 CD 19613 7347 4 : : : 19613 7347 5 See see VB 19613 7347 6 III iii CD 19613 7347 7 . . . 19613 7348 1 23 23 CD 19613 7348 2 . . . 19613 7349 1 1 1 CD 19613 7349 2 , , , 19613 7349 3 2 2 CD 19613 7349 4 , , , 19613 7349 5 a a DT 19613 7349 6 highly highly RB 19613 7349 7 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 7349 8 statement statement NN 19613 7349 9 . . . 19613 7349 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7350 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7350 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7350 3 577 577 CD 19613 7350 4 : : : 19613 7350 5 See see VB 19613 7350 6 , , , 19613 7350 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7350 8 , , , 19613 7350 9 III III NNP 19613 7350 10 . . . 19613 7351 1 9 9 CD 19613 7351 2 . . . 19613 7352 1 3 3 CD 19613 7352 2 , , , 19613 7352 3 12 12 CD 19613 7352 4 . . . 19613 7353 1 2 2 CD 19613 7353 2 , , , 19613 7353 3 16 16 CD 19613 7353 4 . . . 19613 7354 1 6 6 CD 19613 7354 2 - - SYM 19613 7354 3 9 9 CD 19613 7354 4 , , , 19613 7354 5 17 17 CD 19613 7354 6 . . . 19613 7355 1 4 4 LS 19613 7355 2 and and CC 19613 7355 3 repeatedly repeatedly RB 19613 7355 4 8 8 CD 19613 7355 5 . . . 19613 7356 1 2 2 LS 19613 7356 2 : : : 19613 7356 3 " " `` 19613 7356 4 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7356 5 dei dei NNP 19613 7356 6 , , , 19613 7356 7 per per IN 19613 7356 8 quem quem NNP 19613 7356 9 facta facta NNP 19613 7356 10 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7356 11 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7356 12 , , , 19613 7356 13 qui qui NNP 19613 7356 14 est est NNP 19613 7356 15 dominus dominus NN 19613 7356 16 noster noster NN 19613 7356 17 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7356 18 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7356 19 . . . 19613 7356 20 " " '' 19613 7356 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7357 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7357 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7357 3 578 578 CD 19613 7357 4 : : : 19613 7357 5 See see VB 19613 7357 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7357 7 . . . 19613 7358 1 6 6 CD 19613 7358 2 . . . 19613 7359 1 7 7 LS 19613 7359 2 . . . 19613 7359 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7360 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7360 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7360 3 579 579 CD 19613 7360 4 : : : 19613 7360 5 See see VB 19613 7360 6 III iii CD 19613 7360 7 . . . 19613 7361 1 11 11 CD 19613 7361 2 . . . 19613 7362 1 3 3 LS 19613 7362 2 . . . 19613 7362 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7363 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7363 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7363 3 580 580 CD 19613 7363 4 : : : 19613 7363 5 See see VB 19613 7363 6 III iii CD 19613 7363 7 . . . 19613 7364 1 6 6 LS 19613 7364 2 . . . 19613 7364 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7365 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7365 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7365 3 581 581 CD 19613 7365 4 : : : 19613 7365 5 See see VB 19613 7365 6 III iii CD 19613 7365 7 . . . 19613 7366 1 19 19 CD 19613 7366 2 . . . 19613 7367 1 1 1 CD 19613 7367 2 , , , 19613 7367 3 2 2 CD 19613 7367 4 : : : 19613 7367 5 IV IV NNP 19613 7367 6 . . . 19613 7368 1 33 33 CD 19613 7368 2 . . . 19613 7369 1 4 4 LS 19613 7369 2 : : : 19613 7369 3 V. v. NN 19613 7369 4 1 1 CD 19613 7369 5 . . . 19613 7370 1 3 3 LS 19613 7370 2 ; ; : 19613 7370 3 see see VB 19613 7370 4 also also RB 19613 7370 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7370 6 against against IN 19613 7370 7 " " `` 19613 7370 8 Ebion Ebion NNP 19613 7370 9 " " '' 19613 7370 10 de de FW 19613 7370 11 carne carne NNP 19613 7370 12 14 14 CD 19613 7370 13 , , , 19613 7370 14 18 18 CD 19613 7370 15 , , , 19613 7370 16 24 24 CD 19613 7370 17 ; ; : 19613 7370 18 de de NNP 19613 7370 19 præser præser NNP 19613 7370 20 . . . 19613 7371 1 10 10 CD 19613 7371 2 . . . 19613 7372 1 33 33 CD 19613 7372 2 . . . 19613 7372 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7373 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7373 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7373 3 582 582 CD 19613 7373 4 : : : 19613 7373 5 See see VB 19613 7373 6 III iii CD 19613 7373 7 . . . 19613 7374 1 21 21 CD 19613 7374 2 , , , 19613 7374 3 22 22 CD 19613 7374 4 : : : 19613 7374 5 V. V. NNP 19613 7375 1 19 19 CD 19613 7375 2 - - SYM 19613 7375 3 21 21 CD 19613 7375 4 . . . 19613 7375 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7376 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7376 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7376 3 583 583 CD 19613 7376 4 : : : 19613 7376 5 See see VB 19613 7376 6 the the DT 19613 7376 7 arguments argument NNS 19613 7376 8 , , , 19613 7376 9 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7376 10 . . NNP 19613 7376 11 , , , 19613 7376 12 V. V. NNP 19613 7376 13 19 19 CD 19613 7376 14 . . . 19613 7377 1 1 1 LS 19613 7377 2 : : : 19613 7377 3 " " `` 19613 7377 4 Quemadmodum Quemadmodum NNP 19613 7377 5 adstrictum adstrictum NN 19613 7377 6 est est NNP 19613 7377 7 morti morti NNP 19613 7377 8 genus genus NNP 19613 7377 9 humanum humanum NNP 19613 7377 10 per per IN 19613 7377 11 virginem virginem NNP 19613 7377 12 , , , 19613 7377 13 salvatur salvatur NNP 19613 7377 14 per per IN 19613 7377 15 virginem virginem NNP 19613 7377 16 , , , 19613 7377 17 æqua æqua NNP 19613 7377 18 lance lance NNP 19613 7377 19 disposita disposita NNP 19613 7377 20 virginalis virginalis NNP 19613 7377 21 inobedientia inobedientia NNP 19613 7377 22 per per IN 19613 7377 23 virginalem virginalem NNP 19613 7377 24 obedientiam obedientiam NNP 19613 7377 25 , , , 19613 7377 26 " " '' 19613 7377 27 and and CC 19613 7377 28 other other JJ 19613 7377 29 similar similar JJ 19613 7377 30 ones one NNS 19613 7377 31 . . . 19613 7378 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7378 2 find find VBP 19613 7378 3 the the DT 19613 7378 4 same same JJ 19613 7378 5 in in IN 19613 7378 6 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7378 7 . . NNP 19613 7378 8 , , , 19613 7378 9 de de NNP 19613 7378 10 carne carne NNP 19613 7378 11 17 17 CD 19613 7378 12 , , , 19613 7378 13 20 20 CD 19613 7378 14 . . . 19613 7379 1 In in IN 19613 7379 2 this this DT 19613 7379 3 connection connection NN 19613 7379 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7379 5 find find VBP 19613 7379 6 in in IN 19613 7379 7 both both DT 19613 7379 8 very very RB 19613 7379 9 extravagant extravagant JJ 19613 7379 10 expressions expression NNS 19613 7379 11 with with IN 19613 7379 12 regard regard NN 19613 7379 13 to to IN 19613 7379 14 Mary Mary NNP 19613 7379 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7379 16 see see VB 19613 7379 17 , , , 19613 7379 18 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7380 1 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7380 2 . . NNP 19613 7380 3 , , , 19613 7380 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7380 5 . . . 19613 7381 1 20 20 CD 19613 7381 2 fin fin NN 19613 7381 3 . . . 19613 7382 1 : : : 19613 7382 2 " " `` 19613 7382 3 uti uti NNP 19613 7382 4 virgo virgo NNP 19613 7382 5 esset esset NNP 19613 7382 6 regeneratio regeneratio NNP 19613 7382 7 nostra nostra NNP 19613 7382 8 spiritaliter spiritaliter NNP 19613 7382 9 ab ab NNP 19613 7382 10 omnibus omnibus NNP 19613 7382 11 inquinamentis inquinamentis NNP 19613 7382 12 sanctificata sanctificata RB 19613 7382 13 per per IN 19613 7382 14 Christum Christum NNP 19613 7382 15 . . . 19613 7382 16 " " '' 19613 7383 1 Iren iren JJ 19613 7383 2 . . . 19613 7384 1 III iii CD 19613 7384 2 . . . 19613 7385 1 21 21 CD 19613 7385 2 . . . 19613 7386 1 7 7 LS 19613 7386 2 : : : 19613 7386 3 " " `` 19613 7386 4 Maria Maria NNP 19613 7386 5 cooperans cooperan NNS 19613 7386 6 dispositioni dispositioni VBP 19613 7386 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7386 8 dei dei NNP 19613 7386 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7386 10 ; ; : 19613 7386 11 " " `` 19613 7386 12 III iii CD 19613 7386 13 . . . 19613 7387 1 22 22 CD 19613 7387 2 . . . 19613 7388 1 4 4 LS 19613 7388 2 " " `` 19613 7388 3 Maria Maria NNP 19613 7388 4 obediens obedien NNS 19613 7388 5 et et NNP 19613 7388 6 sibi sibi NNP 19613 7388 7 et et NNP 19613 7388 8 universo universo NNP 19613 7388 9 generi generi NNP 19613 7388 10 humano humano NNP 19613 7388 11 causa causa NNP 19613 7388 12 facta facta NNP 19613 7388 13 est est NNP 19613 7388 14 salutis salutis NNP 19613 7388 15 " " `` 19613 7388 16 ... ... : 19613 7388 17 " " '' 19613 7388 18 quod quod NN 19613 7388 19 alligavit alligavit NNP 19613 7388 20 virgo virgo NNP 19613 7388 21 Eva Eva NNP 19613 7388 22 per per IN 19613 7388 23 incredulitatem incredulitatem NN 19613 7388 24 , , , 19613 7388 25 hoc hoc FW 19613 7388 26 virgo virgo JJ 19613 7388 27 Maria Maria NNP 19613 7388 28 solvit solvit NN 19613 7388 29 per per IN 19613 7388 30 fidem fidem NN 19613 7388 31 " " '' 19613 7388 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7388 33 . . . 19613 7389 1 These these DT 19613 7389 2 , , , 19613 7389 3 however however RB 19613 7389 4 , , , 19613 7389 5 have have VBP 19613 7389 6 no no DT 19613 7389 7 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 7389 8 significance significance NN 19613 7389 9 ; ; : 19613 7389 10 in in IN 19613 7389 11 fact fact NN 19613 7389 12 the the DT 19613 7389 13 same same JJ 19613 7389 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7389 15 expressed express VBD 19613 7389 16 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7389 17 in in IN 19613 7389 18 a a DT 19613 7389 19 depreciatory depreciatory JJ 19613 7389 20 way way NN 19613 7389 21 about about IN 19613 7389 22 Mary Mary NNP 19613 7389 23 in in IN 19613 7389 24 _ _ NNP 19613 7389 25 de de NNP 19613 7389 26 carne carne NNP 19613 7389 27 _ _ NNP 19613 7389 28 7 7 CD 19613 7389 29 . . . 19613 7390 1 On on IN 19613 7390 2 the the DT 19613 7390 3 other other JJ 19613 7390 4 hand hand NN 19613 7390 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7390 6 is be VBZ 19613 7390 7 undeniable undeniable JJ 19613 7390 8 that that IN 19613 7390 9 the the DT 19613 7390 10 later later JJ 19613 7390 11 Mariolatry Mariolatry NNP 19613 7390 12 has have VBZ 19613 7390 13 one one CD 19613 7390 14 of of IN 19613 7390 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7390 16 roots root NNS 19613 7390 17 in in IN 19613 7390 18 the the DT 19613 7390 19 parallel parallel NN 19613 7390 20 between between IN 19613 7390 21 Eve Eve NNP 19613 7390 22 and and CC 19613 7390 23 Mary Mary NNP 19613 7390 24 . . . 19613 7391 1 The the DT 19613 7391 2 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 7391 3 invention invention NN 19613 7391 4 of of IN 19613 7391 5 the the DT 19613 7391 6 _ _ NNP 19613 7391 7 virginitas virginita NNS 19613 7391 8 Mariæ Mariæ NNP 19613 7391 9 in in IN 19613 7391 10 partu partu NNP 19613 7391 11 _ _ NNP 19613 7391 12 can can MD 19613 7391 13 hardly hardly RB 19613 7391 14 be be VB 19613 7391 15 traced trace VBN 19613 7391 16 in in IN 19613 7391 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7391 18 III III NNP 19613 7391 19 . . . 19613 7392 1 21 21 CD 19613 7392 2 . . . 19613 7393 1 4 4 LS 19613 7393 2 . . . 19613 7394 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7394 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7394 3 de de FW 19613 7394 4 carne carne NNP 19613 7394 5 23 23 CD 19613 7394 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7394 7 does do VBZ 19613 7394 8 not not RB 19613 7394 9 seem seem VB 19613 7394 10 to to TO 19613 7394 11 know know VB 19613 7394 12 anything anything NN 19613 7394 13 about about IN 19613 7394 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7394 15 as as RB 19613 7394 16 yet yet RB 19613 7394 17 , , , 19613 7394 18 and and CC 19613 7394 19 very very RB 19613 7394 20 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 7394 21 assumed assume VBD 19613 7394 22 the the DT 19613 7394 23 natural natural JJ 19613 7394 24 character character NN 19613 7394 25 of of IN 19613 7394 26 the the DT 19613 7394 27 process process NN 19613 7394 28 . . . 19613 7395 1 The the DT 19613 7395 2 popular popular JJ 19613 7395 3 conception conception NN 19613 7395 4 as as IN 19613 7395 5 to to IN 19613 7395 6 the the DT 19613 7395 7 reason reason NN 19613 7395 8 of of IN 19613 7395 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7395 10 's 's POS 19613 7395 11 birth birth NN 19613 7395 12 from from IN 19613 7395 13 a a DT 19613 7395 14 virgin virgin NN 19613 7395 15 , , , 19613 7395 16 in in IN 19613 7395 17 the the DT 19613 7395 18 form form NN 19613 7395 19 still still RB 19613 7395 20 current current JJ 19613 7395 21 to to IN 19613 7395 22 - - HYPH 19613 7395 23 day day NN 19613 7395 24 , , , 19613 7395 25 but but CC 19613 7395 26 beneath beneath IN 19613 7395 27 all all DT 19613 7395 28 criticism criticism NN 19613 7395 29 , , , 19613 7395 30 is be VBZ 19613 7395 31 already already RB 19613 7395 32 found find VBN 19613 7395 33 in in IN 19613 7395 34 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7395 35 _ _ NNP 19613 7395 36 de de NNP 19613 7395 37 carne carne NNP 19613 7395 38 _ _ NNP 19613 7395 39 18 18 CD 19613 7395 40 : : : 19613 7395 41 " " `` 19613 7395 42 Non non JJ 19613 7395 43 competebat competebat NN 19613 7395 44 ex ex FW 19613 7395 45 semine semine NNP 19613 7395 46 humano humano NNP 19613 7395 47 dei dei NNP 19613 7395 48 filium filium NNP 19613 7395 49 nasci nasci NNP 19613 7395 50 , , , 19613 7395 51 ne ne NNP 19613 7395 52 , , , 19613 7395 53 si si NNP 19613 7395 54 totus totus NNP 19613 7395 55 esset esset NNP 19613 7395 56 filius filius NNP 19613 7395 57 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7395 58 , , , 19613 7395 59 non non AFX 19613 7395 60 esset esset NNP 19613 7395 61 et et NNP 19613 7395 62 dei dei NNP 19613 7395 63 filius filius NNP 19613 7395 64 , , , 19613 7395 65 nihilque nihilque NNP 19613 7395 66 haberet haberet NNP 19613 7395 67 amplius amplius NNP 19613 7395 68 Salomone Salomone NNP 19613 7395 69 , , , 19613 7395 70 ut ut FW 19613 7395 71 de de FW 19613 7395 72 Hebionis Hebionis NNP 19613 7395 73 opinione opinione NNP 19613 7395 74 credendus credendus NNP 19613 7395 75 erat erat NNP 19613 7395 76 Ergo Ergo NNP 19613 7395 77 iam iam NNP 19613 7395 78 dei dei NNP 19613 7395 79 filius filius NNP 19613 7395 80 ex ex NNP 19613 7395 81 patris patris NNP 19613 7395 82 dei dei NNP 19613 7395 83 semine semine NNP 19613 7395 84 , , , 19613 7395 85 i -PRON- PRP 19613 7395 86 d d VBN 19613 7395 87 est est NNP 19613 7395 88 spiritu spiritu VBP 19613 7395 89 , , , 19613 7395 90 ut ut UH 19613 7395 91 esset esset NNP 19613 7395 92 et et NNP 19613 7395 93 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7395 94 filius filius NNP 19613 7395 95 , , , 19613 7395 96 caro caro NNP 19613 7395 97 ei ei NNP 19613 7395 98 sola sola NNP 19613 7395 99 competebat competebat NNP 19613 7395 100 ex ex FW 19613 7395 101 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7395 102 carne carne NNP 19613 7395 103 sumenda sumenda NNP 19613 7395 104 sine sine NNP 19613 7395 105 viri viri NNP 19613 7395 106 semine semine NNP 19613 7395 107 . . . 19613 7396 1 Vacabat Vacabat NNP 19613 7396 2 enim enim NNP 19613 7396 3 semen semen NNP 19613 7396 4 viri viri NNP 19613 7396 5 apud apud NNP 19613 7396 6 habentem habentem NNP 19613 7396 7 dei dei NNP 19613 7396 8 semen semen NNP 19613 7396 9 . . . 19613 7396 10 " " '' 19613 7397 1 The the DT 19613 7397 2 other other JJ 19613 7397 3 theory theory NN 19613 7397 4 existing exist VBG 19613 7397 5 side side NN 19613 7397 6 by by IN 19613 7397 7 side side NN 19613 7397 8 with with IN 19613 7397 9 this this DT 19613 7397 10 , , , 19613 7397 11 viz viz NNP 19613 7397 12 . . NNP 19613 7397 13 , , , 19613 7397 14 that that IN 19613 7397 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7397 16 would would MD 19613 7397 17 have have VB 19613 7397 18 been be VBN 19613 7397 19 a a DT 19613 7397 20 sinner sinner NN 19613 7397 21 if if IN 19613 7397 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7397 23 had have VBD 19613 7397 24 been be VBN 19613 7397 25 begotten beget VBN 19613 7397 26 from from IN 19613 7397 27 the the DT 19613 7397 28 semen semen NN 19613 7397 29 , , , 19613 7397 30 whereas whereas IN 19613 7397 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7397 32 could could MD 19613 7397 33 assume assume VB 19613 7397 34 sinless sinless NNP 19613 7397 35 flesh flesh NN 19613 7397 36 from from IN 19613 7397 37 woman woman NN 19613 7397 38 is be VBZ 19613 7397 39 so so RB 19613 7397 40 far far RB 19613 7397 41 as as IN 19613 7397 42 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7397 43 know know VBP 19613 7397 44 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 7397 45 hinted hint VBN 19613 7397 46 at at IN 19613 7397 47 by by IN 19613 7397 48 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7397 49 and and CC 19613 7397 50 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7397 51 . . . 19613 7398 1 The the DT 19613 7398 2 fact fact NN 19613 7398 3 of of IN 19613 7398 4 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7398 5 's 's POS 19613 7398 6 birth birth NN 19613 7398 7 was be VBD 19613 7398 8 frequently frequently RB 19613 7398 9 referred refer VBN 19613 7398 10 to to IN 19613 7398 11 by by IN 19613 7398 12 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7398 13 in in IN 19613 7398 14 order order NN 19613 7398 15 to to TO 19613 7398 16 prove prove VB 19613 7398 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7398 18 's 's POS 19613 7398 19 kinship kinship NN 19613 7398 20 to to IN 19613 7398 21 God God NNP 19613 7398 22 the the DT 19613 7398 23 Creator Creator NNP 19613 7398 24 , , , 19613 7398 25 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7398 26 , , , 19613 7398 27 adv adv NNP 19613 7398 28 . . . 19613 7399 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7399 2 . . . 19613 7400 1 III iii CD 19613 7400 2 . . . 19613 7401 1 11 11 CD 19613 7401 2 . . . 19613 7402 1 Hence hence RB 19613 7402 2 this this DT 19613 7402 3 article article NN 19613 7402 4 of of IN 19613 7402 5 the the DT 19613 7402 6 _ _ NNP 19613 7402 7 regula regula NN 19613 7402 8 fidei fidei NNP 19613 7402 9 _ _ NNP 19613 7402 10 received receive VBD 19613 7402 11 a a DT 19613 7402 12 significance significance NN 19613 7402 13 from from IN 19613 7402 14 this this DT 19613 7402 15 point point NN 19613 7402 16 of of IN 19613 7402 17 view view NN 19613 7402 18 also also RB 19613 7402 19 . . . 19613 7403 1 An an DT 19613 7403 2 Encratite Encratite NNP 19613 7403 3 explanation explanation NN 19613 7403 4 of of IN 19613 7403 5 the the DT 19613 7403 6 birth birth NN 19613 7403 7 from from IN 19613 7403 8 the the DT 19613 7403 9 Virgin Virgin NNP 19613 7403 10 is be VBZ 19613 7403 11 found find VBN 19613 7403 12 in in IN 19613 7403 13 the the DT 19613 7403 14 old old JJ 19613 7403 15 treatise treatise NN 19613 7403 16 _ _ NNP 19613 7403 17 de de NNP 19613 7403 18 resurr resurr NNP 19613 7403 19 . . . 19613 7403 20 _ _ NNP 19613 7403 21 bearing bear VBG 19613 7403 22 Justin Justin NNP 19613 7403 23 's 's POS 19613 7403 24 name name NN 19613 7403 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7403 26 Otto Otto NNP 19613 7403 27 , , , 19613 7403 28 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 7403 29 Apol Apol NNP 19613 7403 30 . . . 19613 7404 1 III III NNP 19613 7404 2 . . NNP 19613 7404 3 , , , 19613 7404 4 p. p. NN 19613 7405 1 220 220 CD 19613 7405 2 . . . 19613 7405 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7405 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7406 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7406 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7406 3 584 584 CD 19613 7406 4 : : : 19613 7406 5 See see VB 19613 7406 6 , , , 19613 7406 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7406 8 , , , 19613 7406 9 III III NNP 19613 7406 10 . . . 19613 7407 1 18 18 CD 19613 7407 2 . . . 19613 7408 1 1 1 CD 19613 7408 2 and and CC 19613 7408 3 many many JJ 19613 7408 4 other other JJ 19613 7408 5 places place NNS 19613 7408 6 . . . 19613 7409 1 See see VB 19613 7409 2 the the DT 19613 7409 3 passages passage NNS 19613 7409 4 named name VBN 19613 7409 5 in in IN 19613 7409 6 note note NN 19613 7409 7 , , , 19613 7409 8 p. p. NN 19613 7410 1 276 276 CD 19613 7410 2 . . . 19613 7410 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7411 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7411 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7411 3 585 585 CD 19613 7411 4 : : : 19613 7411 5 So so RB 19613 7411 6 also also RB 19613 7411 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7411 8 . . . 19613 7412 1 See see VB 19613 7412 2 adv adv NN 19613 7412 3 . . . 19613 7413 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7413 2 . . . 19613 7414 1 III iii CD 19613 7414 2 . . . 19613 7415 1 8 8 LS 19613 7415 2 : : : 19613 7415 3 The the DT 19613 7415 4 whole whole JJ 19613 7415 5 work work NN 19613 7415 6 of of IN 19613 7415 7 salvation salvation NN 19613 7415 8 is be VBZ 19613 7415 9 destroyed destroy VBN 19613 7415 10 by by IN 19613 7415 11 Docetism docetism NN 19613 7415 12 ; ; : 19613 7415 13 cf cf NN 19613 7415 14 . . . 19613 7416 1 the the DT 19613 7416 2 work work NN 19613 7416 3 _ _ NNP 19613 7416 4 de de NNP 19613 7416 5 carne carne NNP 19613 7416 6 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7416 7 _ _ NNP 19613 7416 8 . . . 19613 7417 1 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 7417 2 exclaims exclaim NNS 19613 7417 3 to to IN 19613 7417 4 the the DT 19613 7417 5 Docetist Docetist NNP 19613 7417 6 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 7417 7 in in IN 19613 7417 8 c. c. NN 19613 7417 9 5 5 CD 19613 7417 10 : : : 19613 7417 11 " " `` 19613 7417 12 Parce Parce NNP 19613 7417 13 unicæ unicæ NN 19613 7417 14 spei spei VBZ 19613 7417 15 totius totius NN 19613 7417 16 orbis orbis NNP 19613 7417 17 . . . 19613 7417 18 " " '' 19613 7418 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7418 2 and and CC 19613 7418 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7418 4 mean mean VBP 19613 7418 5 that that IN 19613 7418 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7418 7 's 's POS 19613 7418 8 assumption assumption NN 19613 7418 9 of of IN 19613 7418 10 humanity humanity NN 19613 7418 11 was be VBD 19613 7418 12 complete complete JJ 19613 7418 13 , , , 19613 7418 14 but but CC 19613 7418 15 not not RB 19613 7418 16 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 7418 17 express express VBP 19613 7418 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 7418 19 in in IN 19613 7418 20 such such PDT 19613 7418 21 a a DT 19613 7418 22 manner manner NN 19613 7418 23 as as IN 19613 7418 24 to to TO 19613 7418 25 convey convey VB 19613 7418 26 the the DT 19613 7418 27 impression impression NN 19613 7418 28 that that IN 19613 7418 29 the the DT 19613 7418 30 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7418 31 only only RB 19613 7418 32 assumed assume VBD 19613 7418 33 flesh flesh NN 19613 7418 34 . . . 19613 7419 1 This this DT 19613 7419 2 is be VBZ 19613 7419 3 particularly particularly RB 19613 7419 4 the the DT 19613 7419 5 case case NN 19613 7419 6 with with IN 19613 7419 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7419 8 , , , 19613 7419 9 who who WP 19613 7419 10 , , , 19613 7419 11 moreover moreover RB 19613 7419 12 , , , 19613 7419 13 in in IN 19613 7419 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7419 15 earlier early JJR 19613 7419 16 time time NN 19613 7419 17 had have VBD 19613 7419 18 probably probably RB 19613 7419 19 quite quite RB 19613 7419 20 naive naive JJ 19613 7419 21 Docetic docetic JJ 19613 7419 22 ideas idea NNS 19613 7419 23 and and CC 19613 7419 24 really really RB 19613 7419 25 looked look VBD 19613 7419 26 upon upon IN 19613 7419 27 the the DT 19613 7419 28 humanity humanity NN 19613 7419 29 of of IN 19613 7419 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7419 31 as as IN 19613 7419 32 only only RB 19613 7419 33 flesh flesh NN 19613 7419 34 . . . 19613 7420 1 See see VB 19613 7420 2 Apolog Apolog NNP 19613 7420 3 . . . 19613 7421 1 21 21 CD 19613 7421 2 : : : 19613 7421 3 " " `` 19613 7421 4 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 7421 5 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7421 6 cum cum NNP 19613 7421 7 verbo verbo VBP 19613 7421 8 sponte sponte NNP 19613 7421 9 dimisit dimisit NNP 19613 7421 10 , , , 19613 7421 11 prævento prævento NNP 19613 7421 12 carnincis carnincis NNP 19613 7421 13 officio officio VBP 19613 7421 14 . . . 19613 7421 15 " " '' 19613 7422 1 Yet yet CC 19613 7422 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7422 3 in in IN 19613 7422 4 several several JJ 19613 7422 5 passages passage NNS 19613 7422 6 spoke speak VBD 19613 7422 7 of of IN 19613 7422 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7422 9 's 's POS 19613 7422 10 human human JJ 19613 7422 11 soul soul NN 19613 7422 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7422 13 III iii CD 19613 7422 14 . . . 19613 7423 1 22 22 CD 19613 7423 2 . . . 19613 7424 1 1 1 LS 19613 7424 2 : : : 19613 7424 3 V. v. NN 19613 7424 4 1 1 CD 19613 7424 5 . . . 19613 7425 1 1 1 LS 19613 7425 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7425 3 as as IN 19613 7425 4 also also RB 19613 7425 5 did do VBD 19613 7425 6 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7425 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7425 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7425 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7425 10 : : : 19613 7425 11 to to IN 19613 7425 12 alêthes alêthes NNP 19613 7425 13 kai kai NNP 19613 7425 14 aphantaston aphantaston NNP 19613 7425 15 tês tês NNP 19613 7425 16 psuchês psuchês NN 19613 7425 17 Christou Christou NNP 19613 7425 18 kai kai NNP 19613 7425 19 tou tou NNP 19613 7425 20 sômatos sômatos NNP 19613 7425 21 , , , 19613 7425 22 tês tês NNP 19613 7425 23 kath kath NNP 19613 7425 24 ' ' POS 19613 7425 25 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 7425 26 anthrôpinês anthrôpinês NNP 19613 7425 27 phuseôs phuseôs NN 19613 7425 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7425 29 Otto Otto NNP 19613 7425 30 , , , 19613 7425 31 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7425 32 . . NNP 19613 7425 33 , , , 19613 7425 34 IX IX NNP 19613 7425 35 . . NNP 19613 7425 36 , , , 19613 7425 37 p. p. NN 19613 7425 38 415 415 CD 19613 7425 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7425 40 and and CC 19613 7425 41 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7425 42 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7425 43 de de FW 19613 7425 44 carne carne NNP 19613 7425 45 10 10 CD 19613 7425 46 ff ff NNS 19613 7425 47 . . . 19613 7426 1 13 13 CD 19613 7426 2 ; ; : 19613 7426 3 de de NNP 19613 7426 4 resurr resurr NNP 19613 7426 5 . . . 19613 7427 1 53 53 CD 19613 7427 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7427 3 . . . 19613 7428 1 What what WP 19613 7428 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7428 3 possess possess VBP 19613 7428 4 in in IN 19613 7428 5 virtue virtue NN 19613 7428 6 of of IN 19613 7428 7 the the DT 19613 7428 8 creation creation NN 19613 7428 9 was be VBD 19613 7428 10 _ _ NNP 19613 7428 11 assumed assume VBN 19613 7428 12 _ _ NNP 19613 7428 13 by by IN 19613 7428 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7428 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7428 16 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7428 17 . . NNP 19613 7428 18 , , , 19613 7428 19 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7428 20 . . NNP 19613 7428 21 , , , 19613 7428 22 III III NNP 19613 7428 23 . . . 19613 7429 1 22 22 CD 19613 7429 2 . . . 19613 7430 1 2 2 LS 19613 7430 2 . . . 19613 7430 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7431 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 7431 2 , , , 19613 7431 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7431 4 already already RB 19613 7431 5 examined examine VBD 19613 7431 6 how how WRB 19613 7431 7 the the DT 19613 7431 8 case case NN 19613 7431 9 stands stand VBZ 19613 7431 10 with with IN 19613 7431 11 sin sin NN 19613 7431 12 in in IN 19613 7431 13 relation relation NN 19613 7431 14 to to IN 19613 7431 15 the the DT 19613 7431 16 flesh flesh NN 19613 7431 17 of of IN 19613 7431 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7431 19 . . . 19613 7432 1 In in IN 19613 7432 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 7432 3 to to IN 19613 7432 4 the the DT 19613 7432 5 opinion opinion NN 19613 7432 6 of of IN 19613 7432 7 the the DT 19613 7432 8 heretic heretic JJ 19613 7432 9 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 7432 10 , , , 19613 7432 11 that that IN 19613 7432 12 the the DT 19613 7432 13 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 7432 14 believe believe VBP 19613 7432 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7432 16 assumed assume VBD 19613 7432 17 earthly earthly JJ 19613 7432 18 flesh flesh NN 19613 7432 19 in in IN 19613 7432 20 order order NN 19613 7432 21 to to TO 19613 7432 22 destroy destroy VB 19613 7432 23 the the DT 19613 7432 24 flesh flesh NN 19613 7432 25 of of IN 19613 7432 26 sin sin NN 19613 7432 27 in in IN 19613 7432 28 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7432 29 , , , 19613 7432 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7432 31 shows show VBZ 19613 7432 32 that that IN 19613 7432 33 the the DT 19613 7432 34 Saviour Saviour NNP 19613 7432 35 's 's POS 19613 7432 36 flesh flesh NN 19613 7432 37 was be VBD 19613 7432 38 without without IN 19613 7432 39 sin sin NN 19613 7432 40 and and CC 19613 7432 41 that that IN 19613 7432 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7432 43 is be VBZ 19613 7432 44 not not RB 19613 7432 45 admissible admissible JJ 19613 7432 46 to to TO 19613 7432 47 teach teach VB 19613 7432 48 the the DT 19613 7432 49 annihilation annihilation NN 19613 7432 50 of of IN 19613 7432 51 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7432 52 's 's POS 19613 7432 53 flesh flesh NN 19613 7432 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7432 55 de de NNP 19613 7432 56 carne carne NNP 19613 7432 57 16 16 CD 19613 7432 58 ; ; : 19613 7432 59 see see VB 19613 7432 60 also also RB 19613 7432 61 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7432 62 V. V. NNP 19613 7432 63 14 14 CD 19613 7432 64 . . . 19613 7433 1 2 2 CD 19613 7433 2 , , , 19613 7433 3 3 3 CD 19613 7433 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7433 5 : : : 19613 7433 6 " " `` 19613 7433 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7433 8 by by IN 19613 7433 9 taking take VBG 19613 7433 10 to to IN 19613 7433 11 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7433 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7433 13 flesh flesh NN 19613 7433 14 has have VBZ 19613 7433 15 made make VBN 19613 7433 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7433 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7433 18 own own JJ 19613 7433 19 , , , 19613 7433 20 that that RB 19613 7433 21 is is RB 19613 7433 22 , , , 19613 7433 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7433 24 has have VBZ 19613 7433 25 made make VBN 19613 7433 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7433 27 sinless sinless JJ 19613 7433 28 . . . 19613 7433 29 " " '' 19613 7434 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7434 2 was be VBD 19613 7434 3 again again RB 19613 7434 4 passages passage NNS 19613 7434 5 from from IN 19613 7434 6 Paul Paul NNP 19613 7434 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7434 8 Rom Rom NNP 19613 7434 9 . . . 19613 7435 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 7435 2 . . . 19613 7436 1 3 3 LS 19613 7436 2 and and CC 19613 7436 3 Ephes ephe NNS 19613 7436 4 . . . 19613 7437 1 II ii CD 19613 7437 2 . . . 19613 7438 1 15 15 LS 19613 7438 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7438 3 that that WDT 19613 7438 4 gave give VBD 19613 7438 5 occasion occasion NN 19613 7438 6 to to IN 19613 7438 7 this this DT 19613 7438 8 discussion discussion NN 19613 7438 9 . . . 19613 7439 1 With with IN 19613 7439 2 respect respect NN 19613 7439 3 to to IN 19613 7439 4 the the DT 19613 7439 5 opinion opinion NN 19613 7439 6 that that IN 19613 7439 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7439 8 may may MD 19613 7439 9 be be VB 19613 7439 10 with with IN 19613 7439 11 the the DT 19613 7439 12 flesh flesh NN 19613 7439 13 of of IN 19613 7439 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7439 15 as as IN 19613 7439 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7439 17 is be VBZ 19613 7439 18 with with IN 19613 7439 19 the the DT 19613 7439 20 flesh flesh NN 19613 7439 21 of of IN 19613 7439 22 angels angel NNS 19613 7439 23 who who WP 19613 7439 24 appear appear VBP 19613 7439 25 , , , 19613 7439 26 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 7439 27 remarks remark NNS 19613 7439 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7439 29 de de NNP 19613 7439 30 carne carne NNP 19613 7439 31 6 6 CD 19613 7439 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7439 33 that that IN 19613 7439 34 no no DT 19613 7439 35 angel angel NN 19613 7439 36 came come VBD 19613 7439 37 to to TO 19613 7439 38 die die VB 19613 7439 39 ; ; : 19613 7439 40 that that DT 19613 7439 41 which which WDT 19613 7439 42 dies die VBZ 19613 7439 43 must must MD 19613 7439 44 be be VB 19613 7439 45 born bear VBN 19613 7439 46 ; ; : 19613 7439 47 the the DT 19613 7439 48 Son Son NNP 19613 7439 49 of of IN 19613 7439 50 God God NNP 19613 7439 51 came come VBD 19613 7439 52 to to TO 19613 7439 53 die die VB 19613 7439 54 . . . 19613 7439 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7440 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7440 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7440 3 586 586 CD 19613 7440 4 : : : 19613 7440 5 This this DT 19613 7440 6 conception conception NN 19613 7440 7 was be VBD 19613 7440 8 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 7440 9 to to IN 19613 7440 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7440 11 , , , 19613 7440 12 and and CC 19613 7440 13 for for IN 19613 7440 14 good good JJ 19613 7440 15 reasons reason NNS 19613 7440 16 was be VBD 19613 7440 17 not not RB 19613 7440 18 repeated repeat VBN 19613 7440 19 in in IN 19613 7440 20 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 7440 21 times time NNS 19613 7440 22 ; ; : 19613 7440 23 see see VB 19613 7440 24 II II NNP 19613 7440 25 . . . 19613 7441 1 22 22 CD 19613 7441 2 : : : 19613 7441 3 III iii CD 19613 7441 4 . . . 19613 7442 1 17 17 CD 19613 7442 2 . . . 19613 7443 1 4 4 LS 19613 7443 2 . . . 19613 7444 1 From from IN 19613 7444 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7444 3 also also RB 19613 7444 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7444 5 already already RB 19613 7444 6 inferred infer VBD 19613 7444 7 the the DT 19613 7444 8 necessity necessity NN 19613 7444 9 of of IN 19613 7444 10 the the DT 19613 7444 11 death death NN 19613 7444 12 of of IN 19613 7444 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7444 14 and and CC 19613 7444 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7444 16 abode abode NN 19613 7444 17 in in IN 19613 7444 18 the the DT 19613 7444 19 lower low JJR 19613 7444 20 world world NN 19613 7444 21 , , , 19613 7444 22 V. V. NNP 19613 7444 23 31 31 CD 19613 7444 24 . . . 19613 7445 1 1 1 CD 19613 7445 2 , , , 19613 7445 3 2 2 CD 19613 7445 4 . . . 19613 7446 1 Here here RB 19613 7446 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7446 3 trace trace VBP 19613 7446 4 the the DT 19613 7446 5 influence influence NN 19613 7446 6 of of IN 19613 7446 7 the the DT 19613 7446 8 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 7446 9 idea idea NN 19613 7446 10 . . . 19613 7447 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7447 2 has have VBZ 19613 7447 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 7447 4 been be VBN 19613 7447 5 asserted assert VBN 19613 7447 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7447 7 very very RB 19613 7447 8 energetically energetically RB 19613 7447 9 by by IN 19613 7447 10 Schultz Schultz NNP 19613 7447 11 , , , 19613 7447 12 Gottheit Gottheit NNP 19613 7447 13 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7447 14 , , , 19613 7447 15 p. p. NN 19613 7447 16 73 73 CD 19613 7447 17 f. f. NN 19613 7447 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7447 19 that that IN 19613 7447 20 the the DT 19613 7447 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7447 22 of of IN 19613 7447 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7447 24 was be VBD 19613 7447 25 not not RB 19613 7447 26 a a DT 19613 7447 27 personal personal JJ 19613 7447 28 man man NN 19613 7447 29 , , , 19613 7447 30 but but CC 19613 7447 31 only only RB 19613 7447 32 possessed possess VBD 19613 7447 33 humanity humanity NN 19613 7447 34 . . . 19613 7448 1 But but CC 19613 7448 2 that that DT 19613 7448 3 is be VBZ 19613 7448 4 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 7448 5 incorrect incorrect JJ 19613 7448 6 , , , 19613 7448 7 the the DT 19613 7448 8 truth truth NN 19613 7448 9 merely merely RB 19613 7448 10 being be VBG 19613 7448 11 that that IN 19613 7448 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7448 13 did do VBD 19613 7448 14 not not RB 19613 7448 15 draw draw VB 19613 7448 16 all all PDT 19613 7448 17 the the DT 19613 7448 18 inferences inference NNS 19613 7448 19 from from IN 19613 7448 20 the the DT 19613 7448 21 personal personal JJ 19613 7448 22 humanity humanity NN 19613 7448 23 of of IN 19613 7448 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7448 25 . . . 19613 7448 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7449 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7449 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7449 3 587 587 CD 19613 7449 4 : : : 19613 7449 5 See see VB 19613 7449 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7449 7 . . . 19613 7450 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7450 2 31 31 CD 19613 7450 3 . . . 19613 7451 1 2 2 LS 19613 7451 2 : : : 19613 7451 3 " " `` 19613 7451 4 Surgens Surgens NNP 19613 7451 5 in in IN 19613 7451 6 carne carne NN 19613 7451 7 sic sic NN 19613 7451 8 ascendit ascendit NN 19613 7451 9 ad ad NN 19613 7451 10 patrem patrem NN 19613 7451 11 . . . 19613 7451 12 " " '' 19613 7452 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7452 2 , , , 19613 7452 3 de de NNP 19613 7452 4 carne carne NNP 19613 7452 5 24 24 CD 19613 7452 6 : : : 19613 7452 7 " " `` 19613 7452 8 Bene Bene NNP 19613 7452 9 quod quod NN 19613 7452 10 idem idem NNP 19613 7452 11 veniet veniet NNP 19613 7452 12 de de FW 19613 7452 13 cælis cælis NNP 19613 7452 14 qui qui NNP 19613 7452 15 est est NNP 19613 7452 16 passus passus NNP 19613 7452 17 ... ... : 19613 7452 18 et et NN 19613 7452 19 agnoscent agnoscent NN 19613 7452 20 qui qui NNP 19613 7452 21 eum eum NNP 19613 7452 22 confixerunt confixerunt NNP 19613 7452 23 , , , 19613 7452 24 utique utique NNP 19613 7452 25 ipsam ipsam NNP 19613 7452 26 carnem carnem NNP 19613 7452 27 in in IN 19613 7452 28 quam quam NNP 19613 7452 29 sævierunt sævierunt NNP 19613 7452 30 , , , 19613 7452 31 sine sine NNP 19613 7452 32 qua qua NNP 19613 7452 33 nee nee NNP 19613 7452 34 ipse ipse NNP 19613 7452 35 esse esse NNP 19613 7452 36 poterit poterit NNP 19613 7452 37 et et NNP 19613 7452 38 agnosci agnosci NNP 19613 7452 39 ; ; : 19613 7452 40 " " `` 19613 7452 41 see see VB 19613 7452 42 also also RB 19613 7452 43 what what WP 19613 7452 44 follows follow VBZ 19613 7452 45 . . . 19613 7452 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7453 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7453 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7453 3 588 588 CD 19613 7453 4 : : : 19613 7453 5 See see VB 19613 7453 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7453 7 . . . 19613 7454 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7454 2 . . . 19613 7455 1 33 33 CD 19613 7455 2 . . . 19613 7456 1 11 11 CD 19613 7456 2 . . . 19613 7456 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7457 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7457 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7457 3 589 589 CD 19613 7457 4 : : : 19613 7457 5 See see VB 19613 7457 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7457 7 . . . 19613 7458 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7458 2 . . . 19613 7459 1 20 20 CD 19613 7459 2 . . . 19613 7460 1 4 4 LS 19613 7460 2 ; ; : 19613 7460 3 see see VB 19613 7460 4 also also RB 19613 7460 5 III III NNP 19613 7460 6 . . . 19613 7461 1 19 19 CD 19613 7461 2 . . . 19613 7462 1 1 1 LS 19613 7462 2 . . . 19613 7462 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7463 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7463 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7463 3 590 590 CD 19613 7463 4 : : : 19613 7463 5 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7463 6 always always RB 19613 7463 7 posits posit VBZ 19613 7463 8 the the DT 19613 7463 9 unity unity NN 19613 7463 10 in in IN 19613 7463 11 the the DT 19613 7463 12 form form NN 19613 7463 13 of of IN 19613 7463 14 a a DT 19613 7463 15 confession confession NN 19613 7463 16 without without IN 19613 7463 17 describing describe VBG 19613 7463 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7463 19 . . . 19613 7464 1 See see VB 19613 7464 2 III iii CD 19613 7464 3 . . . 19613 7465 1 16 16 CD 19613 7465 2 . . . 19613 7466 1 6 6 CD 19613 7466 2 , , , 19613 7466 3 which which WDT 19613 7466 4 passage passage NN 19613 7466 5 may may MD 19613 7466 6 here here RB 19613 7466 7 stand stand VB 19613 7466 8 for for IN 19613 7466 9 many many JJ 19613 7466 10 . . . 19613 7467 1 " " `` 19613 7467 2 Verbum Verbum NNP 19613 7467 3 unigenitus unigenitus NNP 19613 7467 4 , , , 19613 7467 5 qui qui NNP 19613 7467 6 semper semper NNP 19613 7467 7 humano humano NNP 19613 7467 8 generi generi NNP 19613 7467 9 adest adest NNP 19613 7467 10 , , , 19613 7467 11 unitus unitus NNP 19613 7467 12 et et NNP 19613 7467 13 consparsus consparsus NNP 19613 7467 14 suo suo NNP 19613 7467 15 plasmati plasmati NNP 19613 7467 16 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7467 17 placitum placitum NNP 19613 7467 18 patris patris NNP 19613 7467 19 et et NNP 19613 7467 20 caro caro NNP 19613 7467 21 factus factus NN 19613 7467 22 ipse ipse NNP 19613 7467 23 est est NNP 19613 7467 24 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 7467 25 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7467 26 dominus dominus NN 19613 7467 27 noster noster NN 19613 7467 28 , , , 19613 7467 29 qui qui NNP 19613 7467 30 et et NNP 19613 7467 31 passus passus NNP 19613 7467 32 est est NNP 19613 7467 33 pro pro NNP 19613 7467 34 nobis nobis NNP 19613 7467 35 et et NNP 19613 7467 36 ressurrexit ressurrexit NNP 19613 7467 37 propter propter NN 19613 7467 38 nos nos NNP 19613 7467 39 .... .... . 19613 7467 40 Unus unus JJ 19613 7467 41 igitur igitur NN 19613 7467 42 deus deus NN 19613 7467 43 pater pater NN 19613 7467 44 , , , 19613 7467 45 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 7467 46 ostendimus ostendimus NNP 19613 7467 47 , , , 19613 7467 48 et et FW 19613 7467 49 unus unus IN 19613 7467 50 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7467 51 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 7467 52 domiuns domiun VBZ 19613 7467 53 noster noster NN 19613 7467 54 , , , 19613 7467 55 veniens veniens NNP 19613 7467 56 per per IN 19613 7467 57 universam universam NNP 19613 7467 58 dispositionem dispositionem NNP 19613 7467 59 et et NNP 19613 7467 60 omnia omnia NNP 19613 7467 61 in in IN 19613 7467 62 semelipsum semelipsum NNP 19613 7467 63 recapitulans recapitulans NNP 19613 7467 64 . . . 19613 7468 1 In in IN 19613 7468 2 omnibus omnibus JJ 19613 7468 3 autem autem NN 19613 7468 4 est est NNP 19613 7468 5 et et NNP 19613 7468 6 homo homo NNP 19613 7468 7 plasmatio plasmatio NNP 19613 7468 8 del del NNP 19613 7468 9 , , , 19613 7468 10 et et NNP 19613 7468 11 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7468 12 ergo ergo NNP 19613 7468 13 in in IN 19613 7468 14 semetipsum semetipsum NNP 19613 7468 15 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 7468 16 est est NNP 19613 7468 17 , , , 19613 7468 18 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 7468 19 visibilis visibilis NNP 19613 7468 20 factus factus NN 19613 7468 21 , , , 19613 7468 22 et et NNP 19613 7468 23 incomprehensibilis incomprehensibilis NNP 19613 7468 24 factus factus NNP 19613 7468 25 comprehensibilis comprehensibilis NNP 19613 7468 26 et et NNP 19613 7468 27 impassibilis impassibilis NNP 19613 7468 28 passibilis passibilis NNP 19613 7468 29 et et NNP 19613 7468 30 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7468 31 homo homo NNP 19613 7468 32 . . . 19613 7468 33 " " '' 19613 7469 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7469 2 18 18 CD 19613 7469 3 . . . 19613 7470 1 1 1 LS 19613 7470 2 : : : 19613 7470 3 " " `` 19613 7470 4 Ipsum Ipsum NNP 19613 7470 5 verbum verbum NN 19613 7470 6 dei dei NNP 19613 7470 7 incarnatum incarnatum NNP 19613 7470 8 suspensum suspensum NNP 19613 7470 9 est est NNP 19613 7470 10 super super JJ 19613 7470 11 lignum lignum NN 19613 7470 12 . . . 19613 7470 13 " " '' 19613 7470 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7471 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7471 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7471 3 591 591 CD 19613 7471 4 : : : 19613 7471 5 Here here RB 19613 7471 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7471 7 was be VBD 19613 7471 8 able able JJ 19613 7471 9 to to TO 19613 7471 10 adopt adopt VB 19613 7471 11 the the DT 19613 7471 12 old old JJ 19613 7471 13 formula formula NN 19613 7471 14 " " `` 19613 7471 15 God God NNP 19613 7471 16 has have VBZ 19613 7471 17 suffered suffer VBN 19613 7471 18 " " '' 19613 7471 19 and and CC 19613 7471 20 the the DT 19613 7471 21 like like JJ 19613 7471 22 ; ; : 19613 7471 23 so so RB 19613 7471 24 also also RB 19613 7471 25 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7471 26 , , , 19613 7471 27 see see VB 19613 7471 28 Otto Otto NNP 19613 7471 29 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7471 30 . . NNP 19613 7471 31 , , , 19613 7471 32 IX IX NNP 19613 7471 33 . . . 19613 7472 1 p. p. NN 19613 7472 2 416 416 CD 19613 7472 3 : : : 19613 7472 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7472 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7472 6 : : : 19613 7472 7 ho ho NNP 19613 7472 8 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7472 9 peponuen peponuen NNP 19613 7472 10 hupo hupo NN 19613 7472 11 dexias dexias NNP 19613 7472 12 Israêlitidos Israêlitidos NNP 19613 7472 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7472 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7472 15 p. p. NN 19613 7472 16 422 422 CD 19613 7472 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7472 18 : : : 19613 7472 19 " " `` 19613 7472 20 Quidnam Quidnam NNP 19613 7472 21 est est NNP 19613 7472 22 hoc hoc FW 19613 7472 23 novum novum NNP 19613 7472 24 mysterium mysterium NN 19613 7472 25 ? ? . 19613 7473 1 iudex iudex NNP 19613 7473 2 iudicatur iudicatur NNP 19613 7473 3 et et NNP 19613 7473 4 quietus quietus NNP 19613 7473 5 est est NNP 19613 7473 6 ; ; : 19613 7473 7 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 7473 8 videtur videtur NNP 19613 7473 9 neque neque NNP 19613 7473 10 erubescit erubescit NNP 19613 7473 11 : : : 19613 7473 12 incomprehensibilis incomprehensibilis NNP 19613 7473 13 prehenditur prehenditur NNP 19613 7473 14 neque neque NNP 19613 7473 15 indignatur indignatur NNP 19613 7473 16 , , , 19613 7473 17 incommensurabilis incommensurabilis NNP 19613 7473 18 mensuratur mensuratur NNP 19613 7473 19 neque neque NNP 19613 7473 20 repugnat repugnat NNP 19613 7473 21 ; ; : 19613 7473 22 impassibilis impassibilis NNP 19613 7473 23 patitur patitur NNP 19613 7473 24 neque neque NNP 19613 7473 25 ulciscitur ulciscitur NNP 19613 7473 26 ; ; : 19613 7473 27 immortalis immortalis NNP 19613 7473 28 moritur moritur NNP 19613 7473 29 , , , 19613 7473 30 neque neque NNP 19613 7473 31 respondit respondit NNP 19613 7473 32 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7473 33 , , , 19613 7473 34 coelestis coelestis NNP 19613 7473 35 sepelitur sepelitur NNP 19613 7473 36 et et NNP 19613 7473 37 i -PRON- PRP 19613 7473 38 d d VBN 19613 7473 39 fert fert NNP 19613 7473 40 . . . 19613 7473 41 " " '' 19613 7474 1 But but CC 19613 7474 2 let let VB 19613 7474 3 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7474 4 note note VB 19613 7474 5 that that IN 19613 7474 6 these these DT 19613 7474 7 are be VBP 19613 7474 8 not not RB 19613 7474 9 " " `` 19613 7474 10 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 7474 11 , , , 19613 7474 12 " " '' 19613 7474 13 but but CC 19613 7474 14 testimonies testimonie VBZ 19613 7474 15 to to IN 19613 7474 16 the the DT 19613 7474 17 faith faith NN 19613 7474 18 , , , 19613 7474 19 as as IN 19613 7474 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7474 21 were be VBD 19613 7474 22 always always RB 19613 7474 23 worded word VBN 19613 7474 24 from from IN 19613 7474 25 the the DT 19613 7474 26 beginning beginning NN 19613 7474 27 and and CC 19613 7474 28 such such JJ 19613 7474 29 as as IN 19613 7474 30 could could MD 19613 7474 31 , , , 19613 7474 32 if if IN 19613 7474 33 need need NN 19613 7474 34 were be VBD 19613 7474 35 , , , 19613 7474 36 be be VB 19613 7474 37 adapted adapt VBN 19613 7474 38 to to IN 19613 7474 39 any any DT 19613 7474 40 Christology Christology NNP 19613 7474 41 . . . 19613 7475 1 Though though IN 19613 7475 2 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7475 3 in in IN 19613 7475 4 a a DT 19613 7475 5 fragment fragment NN 19613 7475 6 whose whose WP$ 19613 7475 7 genuineness genuineness NN 19613 7475 8 is be VBZ 19613 7475 9 not not RB 19613 7475 10 universally universally RB 19613 7475 11 admitted admit VBN 19613 7475 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7475 13 Otto Otto NNP 19613 7475 14 , , , 19613 7475 15 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7475 16 . . NNP 19613 7475 17 , , , 19613 7475 18 p. p. NN 19613 7475 19 415 415 CD 19613 7475 20 sq sq NNP 19613 7475 21 . . . 19613 7475 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7476 1 declared declare VBN 19613 7476 2 in in IN 19613 7476 3 opposition opposition NN 19613 7476 4 to to IN 19613 7476 5 Marcion Marcion NNP 19613 7476 6 , , , 19613 7476 7 that that IN 19613 7476 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7476 9 proved prove VBD 19613 7476 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7476 11 humanity humanity NN 19613 7476 12 to to IN 19613 7476 13 the the DT 19613 7476 14 world world NN 19613 7476 15 in in IN 19613 7476 16 the the DT 19613 7476 17 30 30 CD 19613 7476 18 years year NNS 19613 7476 19 before before IN 19613 7476 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7476 21 baptism baptism NN 19613 7476 22 ; ; : 19613 7476 23 but but CC 19613 7476 24 showed show VBD 19613 7476 25 the the DT 19613 7476 26 divine divine JJ 19613 7476 27 nature nature NN 19613 7476 28 concealed conceal VBD 19613 7476 29 in in IN 19613 7476 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7476 31 human human JJ 19613 7476 32 nature nature NN 19613 7476 33 during during IN 19613 7476 34 the the DT 19613 7476 35 3 3 CD 19613 7476 36 years year NNS 19613 7476 37 of of IN 19613 7476 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7476 39 ministry ministry NN 19613 7476 40 , , , 19613 7476 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7476 42 did do VBD 19613 7476 43 not not RB 19613 7476 44 for for IN 19613 7476 45 all all DT 19613 7476 46 that that DT 19613 7476 47 mean mean VBP 19613 7476 48 to to TO 19613 7476 49 imply imply VB 19613 7476 50 that that IN 19613 7476 51 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7476 52 ' ' POS 19613 7476 53 divinity divinity NN 19613 7476 54 and and CC 19613 7476 55 humanity humanity NN 19613 7476 56 are be VBP 19613 7476 57 in in IN 19613 7476 58 any any DT 19613 7476 59 way way NN 19613 7476 60 separated separate VBN 19613 7476 61 . . . 19613 7477 1 But but CC 19613 7477 2 , , , 19613 7477 3 though though IN 19613 7477 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7477 5 inveighed inveigh VBD 19613 7477 6 so so RB 19613 7477 7 violently violently RB 19613 7477 8 against against IN 19613 7477 9 the the DT 19613 7477 10 " " `` 19613 7477 11 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 7477 12 " " '' 19613 7477 13 separation separation NN 19613 7477 14 of of IN 19613 7477 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7477 16 and and CC 19613 7477 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7477 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7477 19 see see VB 19613 7477 20 particularly particularly RB 19613 7477 21 III III NNP 19613 7477 22 . . . 19613 7478 1 16 16 CD 19613 7478 2 . . . 19613 7479 1 2 2 LS 19613 7479 2 , , , 19613 7479 3 where where WRB 19613 7479 4 most most JJS 19613 7479 5 weight weight NN 19613 7479 6 is be VBZ 19613 7479 7 laid lay VBN 19613 7479 8 on on IN 19613 7479 9 the the DT 19613 7479 10 fact fact NN 19613 7479 11 that that IN 19613 7479 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7479 13 do do VBP 19613 7479 14 not not RB 19613 7479 15 find find VB 19613 7479 16 in in IN 19613 7479 17 Matth Matth NNP 19613 7479 18 . . . 19613 7480 1 : : : 19613 7480 2 " " `` 19613 7480 3 Iesu Iesu NNP 19613 7480 4 generatio generatio NNP 19613 7480 5 sic sic NN 19613 7480 6 erat erat NN 19613 7480 7 " " '' 19613 7480 8 but but CC 19613 7480 9 " " `` 19613 7480 10 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7480 11 generatio generatio NNP 19613 7480 12 sic sic NN 19613 7480 13 erat erat NN 19613 7480 14 " " '' 19613 7480 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7480 16 , , , 19613 7480 17 there there EX 19613 7480 18 is be VBZ 19613 7480 19 no no DT 19613 7480 20 doubt doubt NN 19613 7480 21 that that IN 19613 7480 22 in in IN 19613 7480 23 some some DT 19613 7480 24 passages passage NNS 19613 7480 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7480 26 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7480 27 could could MD 19613 7480 28 not not RB 19613 7480 29 help help VB 19613 7480 30 unfolding unfold VBG 19613 7480 31 a a DT 19613 7480 32 speculation speculation NN 19613 7480 33 according accord VBG 19613 7480 34 to to IN 19613 7480 35 which which WDT 19613 7480 36 the the DT 19613 7480 37 predicates predicate NNS 19613 7480 38 applying apply VBG 19613 7480 39 to to IN 19613 7480 40 the the DT 19613 7480 41 human human JJ 19613 7480 42 nature nature NN 19613 7480 43 of of IN 19613 7480 44 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7480 45 do do VBP 19613 7480 46 not not RB 19613 7480 47 also also RB 19613 7480 48 hold hold VB 19613 7480 49 good good JJ 19613 7480 50 of of IN 19613 7480 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7480 52 divinity divinity NN 19613 7480 53 , , , 19613 7480 54 in in IN 19613 7480 55 fact fact NN 19613 7480 56 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7480 57 actually actually RB 19613 7480 58 betrayed betray VBD 19613 7480 59 a a DT 19613 7480 60 view view NN 19613 7480 61 of of IN 19613 7480 62 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7480 63 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 19613 7480 64 with with IN 19613 7480 65 the the DT 19613 7480 66 conception conception NN 19613 7480 67 of of IN 19613 7480 68 the the DT 19613 7480 69 Saviour Saviour NNP 19613 7480 70 's 's POS 19613 7480 71 person person NN 19613 7480 72 as as IN 19613 7480 73 a a DT 19613 7480 74 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7480 75 unity unity NN 19613 7480 76 . . . 19613 7481 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7481 2 can can MD 19613 7481 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 7481 4 only only RB 19613 7481 5 trace trace VB 19613 7481 6 this this DT 19613 7481 7 view view NN 19613 7481 8 in in IN 19613 7481 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7481 10 writings writing NNS 19613 7481 11 in in IN 19613 7481 12 the the DT 19613 7481 13 form form NN 19613 7481 14 of of IN 19613 7481 15 an an DT 19613 7481 16 undercurrent undercurrent NN 19613 7481 17 , , , 19613 7481 18 and and CC 19613 7481 19 what what WP 19613 7481 20 led lead VBD 19613 7481 21 to to IN 19613 7481 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7481 23 will will MD 19613 7481 24 be be VB 19613 7481 25 discussed discuss VBN 19613 7481 26 further further RB 19613 7481 27 on on RB 19613 7481 28 . . . 19613 7482 1 Both both CC 19613 7482 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7482 3 and and CC 19613 7482 4 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7482 5 , , , 19613 7482 6 as as IN 19613 7482 7 a a DT 19613 7482 8 rule rule NN 19613 7482 9 adhered adhere VBN 19613 7482 10 to to IN 19613 7482 11 the the DT 19613 7482 12 simple simple NNP 19613 7482 13 " " `` 19613 7482 14 filius filius NNP 19613 7482 15 dei dei NNP 19613 7482 16 filius filius NNP 19613 7482 17 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7482 18 factus factus NN 19613 7482 19 " " '' 19613 7482 20 and and CC 19613 7482 21 did do VBD 19613 7482 22 not not RB 19613 7482 23 perceive perceive VB 19613 7482 24 any any DT 19613 7482 25 problem problem NN 19613 7482 26 here here RB 19613 7482 27 , , , 19613 7482 28 because because IN 19613 7482 29 to to IN 19613 7482 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7482 31 the the DT 19613 7482 32 disunion disunion NN 19613 7482 33 prevailing prevail VBG 19613 7482 34 in in IN 19613 7482 35 the the DT 19613 7482 36 world world NN 19613 7482 37 and and CC 19613 7482 38 in in IN 19613 7482 39 humanity humanity NN 19613 7482 40 was be VBD 19613 7482 41 the the DT 19613 7482 42 difficult difficult JJ 19613 7482 43 question question NN 19613 7482 44 that that WDT 19613 7482 45 appeared appear VBD 19613 7482 46 to to TO 19613 7482 47 be be VB 19613 7482 48 solved solve VBN 19613 7482 49 through through IN 19613 7482 50 this this DT 19613 7482 51 very very RB 19613 7482 52 divine divine JJ 19613 7482 53 manhood manhood NN 19613 7482 54 . . . 19613 7483 1 How how WRB 19613 7483 2 closely closely RB 19613 7483 3 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7483 4 agreed agree VBD 19613 7483 5 with with IN 19613 7483 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7483 7 is be VBZ 19613 7483 8 shown show VBN 19613 7483 9 not not RB 19613 7483 10 only only RB 19613 7483 11 by by IN 19613 7483 12 the the DT 19613 7483 13 proposition proposition NN 19613 7483 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7483 15 p. p. NN 19613 7483 16 419 419 CD 19613 7483 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7483 18 : : : 19613 7483 19 " " `` 19613 7483 20 Propterea Propterea NNP 19613 7483 21 misit misit NN 19613 7483 22 pater pater NNP 19613 7483 23 filium filium NN 19613 7483 24 suum suum NNP 19613 7483 25 e e NNP 19613 7483 26 coelo coelo NNP 19613 7483 27 sine sine NNP 19613 7483 28 corpore corpore NNP 19613 7483 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7483 30 this this DT 19613 7483 31 is be VBZ 19613 7483 32 said say VBN 19613 7483 33 in in IN 19613 7483 34 opposition opposition NN 19613 7483 35 to to IN 19613 7483 36 the the DT 19613 7483 37 Valentinian valentinian JJ 19613 7483 38 view view NN 19613 7483 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7483 40 , , , 19613 7483 41 ut ut UH 19613 7483 42 , , , 19613 7483 43 postquam postquam NNP 19613 7483 44 incarnatus incarnatus NNP 19613 7483 45 esset esset NN 19613 7483 46 in in RP 19613 7483 47 , , , 19613 7483 48 utero utero NNP 19613 7483 49 virginis virginis NNP 19613 7483 50 et et NNP 19613 7483 51 natus natus NNP 19613 7483 52 esset esset NNP 19613 7483 53 homo homo NNP 19613 7483 54 , , , 19613 7483 55 vivificaret vivificaret NNP 19613 7483 56 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7483 57 et et NNP 19613 7483 58 colligeret colligeret NNP 19613 7483 59 membra membra NNP 19613 7483 60 eius eius NNP 19613 7483 61 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7483 62 mors mors NNP 19613 7483 63 disperserat disperserat NNP 19613 7483 64 , , , 19613 7483 65 quum quum NNP 19613 7483 66 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7483 67 divideret divideret NNP 19613 7483 68 , , , 19613 7483 69 " " '' 19613 7483 70 but but CC 19613 7483 71 also also RB 19613 7483 72 by by IN 19613 7483 73 the the DT 19613 7483 74 " " `` 19613 7483 75 propter propter NNP 19613 7483 76 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7483 77 iudicatus iudicatus NNP 19613 7483 78 est est NNP 19613 7483 79 iudex iudex NNP 19613 7483 80 , , , 19613 7483 81 impassibilis impassibilis NNP 19613 7483 82 passus passus NNP 19613 7483 83 est est NNP 19613 7483 84 ? ? . 19613 7483 85 " " '' 19613 7484 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7484 2 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7484 3 . . NNP 19613 7484 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7484 5 . . . 19613 7484 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7485 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7485 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7485 3 592 592 CD 19613 7485 4 : : : 19613 7485 5 The the DT 19613 7485 6 concepts concept NNS 19613 7485 7 employed employ VBN 19613 7485 8 by by IN 19613 7485 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7485 10 are be VBP 19613 7485 11 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 12 deus deus NNP 19613 7485 13 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 14 , , , 19613 7485 15 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 16 verbum verbum NN 19613 7485 17 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 18 , , , 19613 7485 19 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 20 filius filius NNP 19613 7485 21 dei dei NNP 19613 7485 22 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 23 , , , 19613 7485 24 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 25 homo homo NN 19613 7485 26 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 27 , , , 19613 7485 28 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 29 filius filius NNP 19613 7485 30 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7485 31 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 32 , , , 19613 7485 33 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 34 plasma plasma NNP 19613 7485 35 dei dei NNP 19613 7485 36 _ _ NNP 19613 7485 37 . . . 19613 7486 1 What what WP 19613 7486 2 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 7486 3 hindered hinder VBD 19613 7486 4 the the DT 19613 7486 5 development development NN 19613 7486 6 of of IN 19613 7486 7 that that DT 19613 7486 8 formula formula NN 19613 7486 9 in in IN 19613 7486 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7486 11 case case NN 19613 7486 12 was be VBD 19613 7486 13 the the DT 19613 7486 14 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 7486 15 of of IN 19613 7486 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7486 17 viewing view VBG 19613 7486 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7486 19 , , , 19613 7486 20 though though IN 19613 7486 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7486 22 had have VBD 19613 7486 23 assumed assume VBN 19613 7486 24 the the DT 19613 7486 25 _ _ NNP 19613 7486 26 plasma plasma NN 19613 7486 27 dei dei NNP 19613 7486 28 _ _ NNP 19613 7486 29 , , , 19613 7486 30 humanity humanity NN 19613 7486 31 , , , 19613 7486 32 as as IN 19613 7486 33 a a DT 19613 7486 34 personal personal JJ 19613 7486 35 man man NN 19613 7486 36 who who WP 19613 7486 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7486 38 for for IN 19613 7486 39 the the DT 19613 7486 40 sake sake NN 19613 7486 41 of of IN 19613 7486 42 the the DT 19613 7486 43 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 7486 44 theory theory NN 19613 7486 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7486 46 not not RB 19613 7486 47 only only RB 19613 7486 48 had have VBD 19613 7486 49 a a DT 19613 7486 50 human human JJ 19613 7486 51 nature nature NN 19613 7486 52 but but CC 19613 7486 53 was be VBD 19613 7486 54 obliged oblige VBN 19613 7486 55 to to TO 19613 7486 56 live live VB 19613 7486 57 through through IN 19613 7486 58 a a DT 19613 7486 59 complete complete JJ 19613 7486 60 human human JJ 19613 7486 61 life life NN 19613 7486 62 . . . 19613 7487 1 The the DT 19613 7487 2 fragment fragment NN 19613 7487 3 attributed attribute VBD 19613 7487 4 to to IN 19613 7487 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7487 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7487 7 Harvey Harvey NNP 19613 7487 8 II II NNP 19613 7487 9 . . NNP 19613 7487 10 , , , 19613 7487 11 p. p. NN 19613 7487 12 493 493 CD 19613 7487 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7487 14 in in IN 19613 7487 15 which which WDT 19613 7487 16 occur occur VBP 19613 7487 17 the the DT 19613 7487 18 words word NNS 19613 7487 19 , , , 19613 7487 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7487 21 Greek greek JJ 19613 7487 22 : : : 19613 7487 23 tou tou NNP 19613 7487 24 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7487 25 logou logou NNP 19613 7487 26 henôoei henôoei NNP 19613 7487 27 tê tê NNP 19613 7487 28 kath kath NNP 19613 7487 29 ' ' POS 19613 7487 30 hupostasin hupostasin NNP 19613 7487 31 physikê physikê NNP 19613 7487 32 henôthentos henôthentos NNP 19613 7487 33 tê tê NNP 19613 7487 34 sakri sakri NNP 19613 7487 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7487 36 , , , 19613 7487 37 is be VBZ 19613 7487 38 by by IN 19613 7487 39 no no DT 19613 7487 40 means mean NNS 19613 7487 41 genuine genuine JJ 19613 7487 42 . . . 19613 7488 1 How how WRB 19613 7488 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7488 3 are be VBP 19613 7488 4 to to TO 19613 7488 5 understand understand VB 19613 7488 6 the the DT 19613 7488 7 words word NNS 19613 7488 8 : : : 19613 7488 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7488 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7488 11 : : : 19613 7488 12 hina hina NNP 19613 7488 13 ex ex NNP 19613 7488 14 amphoterôn amphoterôn NNP 19613 7488 15 to to IN 19613 7488 16 periphanes periphane NNS 19613 7488 17 tôn tôn NNP 19613 7488 18 physeôn physeôn NNP 19613 7488 19 paradeichthê paradeichthê NNP 19613 7488 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7488 21 in in IN 19613 7488 22 fragment fragment NN 19613 7488 23 VIII viii NN 19613 7488 24 . . . 19613 7489 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7489 2 Harvey Harvey NNP 19613 7489 3 II II NNP 19613 7489 4 . . NNP 19613 7489 5 , , , 19613 7489 6 p. p. NN 19613 7489 7 479 479 CD 19613 7489 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7489 9 , , , 19613 7489 10 and and CC 19613 7489 11 whether whether IN 19613 7489 12 this this DT 19613 7489 13 piece piece NN 19613 7489 14 belongs belong VBZ 19613 7489 15 to to IN 19613 7489 16 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7489 17 , , , 19613 7489 18 is be VBZ 19613 7489 19 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 7489 20 . . . 19613 7490 1 That that IN 19613 7490 2 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7490 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7490 4 assuming assume VBG 19613 7490 5 the the DT 19613 7490 6 genuineness genuineness NN 19613 7490 7 of of IN 19613 7490 8 the the DT 19613 7490 9 fragment fragment NN 19613 7490 10 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7490 11 has have VBZ 19613 7490 12 the the DT 19613 7490 13 formula formula NN 19613 7490 14 of of IN 19613 7490 15 the the DT 19613 7490 16 two two CD 19613 7490 17 natures nature NNS 19613 7490 18 need need VBP 19613 7490 19 excite excite JJ 19613 7490 20 no no DT 19613 7490 21 surprise surprise NN 19613 7490 22 ; ; : 19613 7490 23 for for IN 19613 7490 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7490 25 1 1 LS 19613 7490 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7490 27 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7490 28 was be VBD 19613 7490 29 also also RB 19613 7490 30 a a DT 19613 7490 31 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 7490 32 , , , 19613 7490 33 which which WDT 19613 7490 34 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7490 35 was be VBD 19613 7490 36 not not RB 19613 7490 37 , , , 19613 7490 38 and and CC 19613 7490 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7490 40 2 2 LS 19613 7490 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7490 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7490 43 is be VBZ 19613 7490 44 found find VBN 19613 7490 45 in in IN 19613 7490 46 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7490 47 , , , 19613 7490 48 whose whose WP$ 19613 7490 49 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 7490 50 can can MD 19613 7490 51 be be VB 19613 7490 52 shown show VBN 19613 7490 53 to to TO 19613 7490 54 be be VB 19613 7490 55 closely closely RB 19613 7490 56 connected connect VBN 19613 7490 57 with with IN 19613 7490 58 those those DT 19613 7490 59 of of IN 19613 7490 60 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7490 61 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7490 62 see see VB 19613 7490 63 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7490 64 Texte Texte NNP 19613 7490 65 und und NN 19613 7490 66 Untersuchungen Untersuchungen NNP 19613 7490 67 I. i. NN 19613 7491 1 1 1 CD 19613 7491 2 , , , 19613 7491 3 2 2 CD 19613 7491 4 , , , 19613 7491 5 p. p. NN 19613 7491 6 249 249 CD 19613 7491 7 f. f. NNS 19613 7491 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7491 9 . . . 19613 7492 1 If if IN 19613 7492 2 that that DT 19613 7492 3 fragment fragment NN 19613 7492 4 is be VBZ 19613 7492 5 genuine genuine JJ 19613 7492 6 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7492 7 is be VBZ 19613 7492 8 the the DT 19613 7492 9 first first JJ 19613 7492 10 Church Church NNP 19613 7492 11 teacher teacher NN 19613 7492 12 who who WP 19613 7492 13 has have VBZ 19613 7492 14 spoken speak VBN 19613 7492 15 of of IN 19613 7492 16 two two CD 19613 7492 17 natures nature NNS 19613 7492 18 . . . 19613 7492 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7493 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7493 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7493 3 593 593 CD 19613 7493 4 : : : 19613 7493 5 See see VB 19613 7493 6 Apol Apol NNP 19613 7493 7 . . . 19613 7494 1 21 21 CD 19613 7494 2 : : : 19613 7494 3 " " `` 19613 7494 4 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7494 5 caro caro NNP 19613 7494 6 figuratus figuratus NNP 19613 7494 7 ... ... NFP 19613 7494 8 homo homo NNP 19613 7494 9 deo deo NNP 19613 7494 10 mixtus mixtus NNP 19613 7494 11 ; ; : 19613 7494 12 " " `` 19613 7494 13 adv adv NNP 19613 7494 14 . . . 19613 7495 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7495 2 . . . 19613 7496 1 II ii CD 19613 7496 2 . . . 19613 7497 1 27 27 CD 19613 7497 2 : : : 19613 7497 3 " " `` 19613 7497 4 filius filius NNP 19613 7497 5 dei dei NNP 19613 7497 6 miscens miscens NNP 19613 7497 7 in in IN 19613 7497 8 semetipso semetipso NNP 19613 7497 9 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7497 10 et et NNP 19613 7497 11 deum deum NNP 19613 7497 12 ; ; : 19613 7497 13 " " `` 19613 7497 14 de de NNP 19613 7497 15 carne carne NNP 19613 7497 16 15 15 CD 19613 7497 17 : : : 19613 7497 18 " " `` 19613 7497 19 homo homo NNP 19613 7497 20 deo deo NNP 19613 7497 21 mixtus mixtus NNP 19613 7497 22 ; ; : 19613 7497 23 " " `` 19613 7497 24 18 18 CD 19613 7497 25 : : : 19613 7497 26 " " `` 19613 7497 27 sic sic NNP 19613 7497 28 homo homo NNP 19613 7497 29 cum cum NNP 19613 7497 30 deo deo NNP 19613 7497 31 , , , 19613 7497 32 dum dum NNP 19613 7497 33 caro caro NNP 19613 7497 34 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7497 35 cum cum NNP 19613 7497 36 spiritu spiritu VBD 19613 7497 37 dei dei NNP 19613 7497 38 . . . 19613 7497 39 " " '' 19613 7498 1 On on IN 19613 7498 2 the the DT 19613 7498 3 Christology Christology NNP 19613 7498 4 of of IN 19613 7498 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7498 6 cf cf NNP 19613 7498 7 . . . 19613 7499 1 Schulz Schulz NNP 19613 7499 2 , , , 19613 7499 3 Gottheit Gottheit NNP 19613 7499 4 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7499 5 , , , 19613 7499 6 p. p. NN 19613 7499 7 74 74 CD 19613 7499 8 ff ff NN 19613 7499 9 . . . 19613 7499 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7500 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7500 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7500 3 594 594 CD 19613 7500 4 : : : 19613 7500 5 De De NNP 19613 7500 6 carne carne NNP 19613 7500 7 5 5 CD 19613 7500 8 : : : 19613 7500 9 " " `` 19613 7500 10 Crucifixus Crucifixus NNP 19613 7500 11 est est NNP 19613 7500 12 dei dei NNP 19613 7500 13 filius filius NNP 19613 7500 14 , , , 19613 7500 15 non non AFX 19613 7500 16 pudet pudet NNP 19613 7500 17 quia quia NN 19613 7500 18 pudendum pudendum NNP 19613 7500 19 est est NNP 19613 7500 20 ; ; : 19613 7500 21 et et NNP 19613 7500 22 mortuus mortuus NNP 19613 7500 23 est est NNP 19613 7500 24 dei dei NNP 19613 7500 25 filius filius NNP 19613 7500 26 , , , 19613 7500 27 prorsus prorsus NNP 19613 7500 28 credibile credibile NNP 19613 7500 29 est est NNP 19613 7500 30 , , , 19613 7500 31 quia quia NNP 19613 7500 32 ineptum ineptum NN 19613 7500 33 est est NNP 19613 7500 34 ; ; : 19613 7500 35 et et NNP 19613 7500 36 sepultus sepultus NNP 19613 7500 37 resurrexit resurrexit NNP 19613 7500 38 , , , 19613 7500 39 certum certum NNP 19613 7500 40 est est NNP 19613 7500 41 , , , 19613 7500 42 quia quia NN 19613 7500 43 impossible impossible JJ 19613 7500 44 est est NN 19613 7500 45 ; ; : 19613 7500 46 " " `` 19613 7500 47 but but CC 19613 7500 48 compare compare VB 19613 7500 49 the the DT 19613 7500 50 whole whole JJ 19613 7500 51 book book NN 19613 7500 52 ; ; : 19613 7500 53 c. c. NN 19613 7500 54 5 5 CD 19613 7500 55 init init NN 19613 7500 56 . . . 19613 7501 1 : : : 19613 7501 2 " " `` 19613 7501 3 deus deus NNP 19613 7501 4 crucifixus crucifixus NNP 19613 7501 5 , , , 19613 7501 6 " " '' 19613 7501 7 " " `` 19613 7501 8 nasci nasci NNP 19613 7501 9 se se NNP 19613 7501 10 voluit voluit NNP 19613 7501 11 deus deus NNP 19613 7501 12 " " '' 19613 7501 13 . . . 19613 7502 1 De De NNP 19613 7502 2 pat pat NNP 19613 7502 3 . . . 19613 7503 1 3 3 LS 19613 7503 2 : : : 19613 7503 3 " " `` 19613 7503 4 nasci nasci NNP 19613 7503 5 se se NNP 19613 7503 6 deus deus NNP 19613 7503 7 in in IN 19613 7503 8 utero utero NNP 19613 7503 9 patitur patitur NNP 19613 7503 10 . . . 19613 7503 11 " " '' 19613 7504 1 The the DT 19613 7504 2 formula formula NN 19613 7504 3 : : : 19613 7504 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7504 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7504 6 : : : 19613 7504 7 ho ho NNP 19613 7504 8 gennêtheis gennêtheis NNP 19613 7504 9 , , , 19613 7504 10 ho ho NNP 19613 7504 11 megas megas NNP 19613 7504 12 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7504 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7504 14 is be VBZ 19613 7504 15 also also RB 19613 7504 16 found find VBN 19613 7504 17 in in IN 19613 7504 18 Sibyll Sibyll NNP 19613 7504 19 . . . 19613 7505 1 VII VII NNP 19613 7505 2 . . . 19613 7506 1 24 24 CD 19613 7506 2 . . . 19613 7506 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7507 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7507 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7507 3 595 595 CD 19613 7507 4 : : : 19613 7507 5 De De NNP 19613 7507 6 carne carne VB 19613 7507 7 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7507 8 , , , 19613 7507 9 cf cf NNP 19613 7507 10 . . . 19613 7508 1 ad ad NN 19613 7508 2 nat nat NN 19613 7508 3 . . . 19613 7509 1 II ii CD 19613 7509 2 . . . 19613 7510 1 4 4 LS 19613 7510 2 : : : 19613 7510 3 " " `` 19613 7510 4 ut ut FW 19613 7510 5 iure iure FW 19613 7510 6 consistat consistat NNP 19613 7510 7 collegium collegium NNP 19613 7510 8 nominis nominis NNP 19613 7510 9 communione communione NN 19613 7510 10 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 7510 11 . . . 19613 7510 12 " " '' 19613 7510 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7511 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7511 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7511 3 596 596 CD 19613 7511 4 : : : 19613 7511 5 De De NNP 19613 7511 6 carne carne NNP 19613 7511 7 18 18 CD 19613 7511 8 fin fin NN 19613 7511 9 . . . 19613 7511 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7512 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7512 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7512 3 597 597 CD 19613 7512 4 : : : 19613 7512 5 Adv Adv NNP 19613 7512 6 . . . 19613 7513 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 7513 2 . . . 19613 7514 1 27 27 CD 19613 7514 2 : : : 19613 7514 3 " " `` 19613 7514 4 Sed Sed NNP 19613 7514 5 enim enim NNP 19613 7514 6 invenimus invenimus NNP 19613 7514 7 illum illum NNP 19613 7514 8 diiecto diiecto NNP 19613 7514 9 et et NNP 19613 7514 10 deum deum NNP 19613 7514 11 et et NNP 19613 7514 12 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7514 13 expositum expositum NNP 19613 7514 14 , , , 19613 7514 15 ipso ipso FW 19613 7514 16 hoc hoc FW 19613 7514 17 psalmo psalmo NNP 19613 7514 18 suggerente suggerente NNP 19613 7514 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7514 20 Ps Ps NNP 19613 7514 21 . . . 19613 7515 1 LXXXVII LXXXVII NNP 19613 7515 2 . . . 19613 7516 1 5 5 LS 19613 7516 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7516 3 ... ... . 19613 7516 4 hic hic JJ 19613 7516 5 erit erit NNP 19613 7516 6 homo homo NNP 19613 7516 7 et et NNP 19613 7516 8 filius filius NNP 19613 7516 9 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7516 10 , , , 19613 7516 11 qui qui NNP 19613 7516 12 definitus definitus NNP 19613 7516 13 est est NNP 19613 7516 14 filius filius NNP 19613 7516 15 dei dei NNP 19613 7516 16 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7516 17 spiritum spiritum NNP 19613 7516 18 ... ... : 19613 7516 19 Videmus Videmus NNP 19613 7516 20 duplicem duplicem NNS 19613 7516 21 statum statum NN 19613 7516 22 , , , 19613 7516 23 non non NNP 19613 7516 24 confusum confusum NNP 19613 7516 25 sed se VBD 19613 7516 26 coniunctum coniunctum NN 19613 7516 27 in in IN 19613 7516 28 una una NNP 19613 7516 29 persona persona NNP 19613 7516 30 deum deum NNP 19613 7516 31 et et NNP 19613 7516 32 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7516 33 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 7516 34 . . . 19613 7517 1 De De NNP 19613 7517 2 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7517 3 autem autem NN 19613 7517 4 differo differo NN 19613 7517 5 . . . 19613 7518 1 Et et NN 19613 7518 2 adeo adeo NN 19613 7518 3 salva salva NN 19613 7518 4 est est NNP 19613 7518 5 utriusque utriusque JJ 19613 7518 6 proprietas proprietas NNP 19613 7518 7 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 7518 8 , , , 19613 7518 9 ut ut UH 19613 7518 10 et et NNP 19613 7518 11 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 7518 12 res res NNP 19613 7518 13 suas suas NNP 19613 7518 14 egerit egerit NNP 19613 7518 15 in in IN 19613 7518 16 illo illo NN 19613 7518 17 , , , 19613 7518 18 i -PRON- PRP 19613 7518 19 d d VBD 19613 7518 20 est est NNP 19613 7518 21 virtutes virtutes NNP 19613 7518 22 et et NNP 19613 7518 23 opera opera NNP 19613 7518 24 et et NNP 19613 7518 25 signa signa NNP 19613 7518 26 , , , 19613 7518 27 et et NNP 19613 7518 28 caro caro NNP 19613 7518 29 passiones passiones NNP 19613 7518 30 suas suas NNP 19613 7518 31 functa functa RB 19613 7518 32 sit sit VB 19613 7518 33 , , , 19613 7518 34 esuriens esurien VBZ 19613 7518 35 sub sub VBP 19613 7518 36 diabolo diabolo NN 19613 7518 37 ... ... NFP 19613 7518 38 denique denique NNP 19613 7518 39 et et NNP 19613 7518 40 mortua mortua NNP 19613 7518 41 est est NNP 19613 7518 42 . . . 19613 7519 1 Quodsi quodsi JJ 19613 7519 2 tertium tertium NN 19613 7519 3 quid quid NN 19613 7519 4 esset esset NN 19613 7519 5 , , , 19613 7519 6 ex ex FW 19613 7519 7 utroque utroque NNP 19613 7519 8 confusum confusum NNP 19613 7519 9 , , , 19613 7519 10 ut ut NNP 19613 7519 11 electrum electrum NNP 19613 7519 12 , , , 19613 7519 13 non non NNP 19613 7519 14 tam tam NNP 19613 7519 15 distincta distincta NNP 19613 7519 16 documenta documenta NNP 19613 7519 17 parerent parerent NNP 19613 7519 18 utrinsque utrinsque NNP 19613 7519 19 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 7519 20 . . . 19613 7519 21 " " '' 19613 7520 1 In in IN 19613 7520 2 what what WP 19613 7520 3 follows follow VBZ 19613 7520 4 the the DT 19613 7520 5 _ _ NNP 19613 7520 6 actus actus NN 19613 7520 7 utriusque utriusque JJ 19613 7520 8 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 7520 9 _ _ NNP 19613 7520 10 are be VBP 19613 7520 11 sharply sharply RB 19613 7520 12 demarcated demarcate VBN 19613 7520 13 : : : 19613 7520 14 " " `` 19613 7520 15 ambæ ambæ JJ 19613 7520 16 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 7520 17 in in IN 19613 7520 18 statu statu NNP 19613 7520 19 suo suo NNP 19613 7520 20 quæque quæque NNP 19613 7520 21 distincte distincte NNP 19613 7520 22 agebant agebant NN 19613 7520 23 , , , 19613 7520 24 ideo ideo NN 19613 7520 25 illis illis NNP 19613 7520 26 et et NNP 19613 7520 27 operæ operæ NNP 19613 7520 28 et et NNP 19613 7520 29 exitus exitus NNP 19613 7520 30 sui sui NNP 19613 7520 31 occurrerunt occurrerunt NNP 19613 7520 32 ... ... NFP 19613 7520 33 neque neque NNP 19613 7520 34 caro caro NNP 19613 7520 35 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 7520 36 fit fit NNP 19613 7520 37 neque neque NNP 19613 7520 38 spiritus spiritus NNP 19613 7520 39 caro caro NNP 19613 7520 40 : : : 19613 7520 41 in in IN 19613 7520 42 uno uno NNP 19613 7520 43 plane plane NN 19613 7520 44 esse esse NNP 19613 7520 45 possunt possunt NNP 19613 7520 46 . . . 19613 7520 47 " " '' 19613 7521 1 See see VB 19613 7521 2 also also RB 19613 7521 3 c. c. VB 19613 7521 4 29 29 CD 19613 7521 5 : : : 19613 7521 6 " " `` 19613 7521 7 Quamquam Quamquam NNP 19613 7521 8 cum cum NNP 19613 7521 9 duæ duæ NNP 19613 7521 10 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 7521 11 censeantur censeantur NNP 19613 7521 12 in in IN 19613 7521 13 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7521 14 Iesu Iesu NNP 19613 7521 15 , , , 19613 7521 16 divina divina NNP 19613 7521 17 et et NNP 19613 7521 18 humana humana NNP 19613 7521 19 , , , 19613 7521 20 constet constet NNP 19613 7521 21 autem autem NNP 19613 7521 22 immortalem immortalem NNP 19613 7521 23 esse esse NNP 19613 7521 24 divinam divinam NNP 19613 7521 25 " " '' 19613 7521 26 etc etc FW 19613 7521 27 . . . 19613 7521 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7522 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7522 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7522 3 598 598 CD 19613 7522 4 : : : 19613 7522 5 Of of IN 19613 7522 6 this this DT 19613 7522 7 in in IN 19613 7522 8 a a DT 19613 7522 9 future future JJ 19613 7522 10 volume volume NN 19613 7522 11 . . . 19613 7523 1 Here here RB 19613 7523 2 also also RB 19613 7523 3 two two CD 19613 7523 4 _ _ NNP 19613 7523 5 substances substance NNS 19613 7523 6 _ _ NNP 19613 7523 7 in in IN 19613 7523 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7523 9 are be VBP 19613 7523 10 always always RB 19613 7523 11 spoken speak VBN 19613 7523 12 of of IN 19613 7523 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7523 14 there there EX 19613 7523 15 are be VBP 19613 7523 16 virtually virtually RB 19613 7523 17 three three CD 19613 7523 18 , , , 19613 7523 19 since since IN 19613 7523 20 , , , 19613 7523 21 according accord VBG 19613 7523 22 to to IN 19613 7523 23 _ _ NNP 19613 7523 24 de de NNP 19613 7523 25 anima anima NNP 19613 7523 26 _ _ NNP 19613 7523 27 35 35 CD 19613 7523 28 , , , 19613 7523 29 men man NNS 19613 7523 30 have have VBP 19613 7523 31 already already RB 19613 7523 32 two two CD 19613 7523 33 substances substance NNS 19613 7523 34 in in IN 19613 7523 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 7523 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7523 37 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7523 38 know know VBP 19613 7523 39 only only RB 19613 7523 40 one one CD 19613 7523 41 passage passage NN 19613 7523 42 where where WRB 19613 7523 43 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 7523 44 speaks speak VBZ 19613 7523 45 of of IN 19613 7523 46 _ _ NNP 19613 7523 47 natures nature NNS 19613 7523 48 _ _ NNP 19613 7523 49 in in IN 19613 7523 50 reference reference NN 19613 7523 51 to to IN 19613 7523 52 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7523 53 , , , 19613 7523 54 and and CC 19613 7523 55 this this DT 19613 7523 56 passage passage NN 19613 7523 57 in in IN 19613 7523 58 reality reality NN 19613 7523 59 proves prove VBZ 19613 7523 60 nothing nothing NN 19613 7523 61 ; ; : 19613 7523 62 de de NNP 19613 7523 63 carne carne NNP 19613 7523 64 5 5 CD 19613 7523 65 : : : 19613 7523 66 " " `` 19613 7523 67 Itaque itaque JJ 19613 7523 68 utriusque utriusque JJ 19613 7523 69 substantiæ substantiæ VBZ 19613 7523 70 census census NNP 19613 7523 71 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7523 72 et et NNP 19613 7523 73 deum deum NNP 19613 7523 74 exhibuit exhibuit NNP 19613 7523 75 , , , 19613 7523 76 hinc hinc NNP 19613 7523 77 natum natum NN 19613 7523 78 , , , 19613 7523 79 inde inde NNP 19613 7523 80 non non AFX 19613 7523 81 natum natum NN 19613 7523 82 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7523 83 ! ! . 19613 7524 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7524 2 , , , 19613 7524 3 hinc hinc NN 19613 7524 4 carneum carneum NNP 19613 7524 5 , , , 19613 7524 6 inde inde NNP 19613 7524 7 spiritalem spiritalem NNP 19613 7524 8 " " `` 19613 7524 9 etc etc FW 19613 7524 10 . . . 19613 7525 1 Then then RB 19613 7525 2 : : : 19613 7525 3 " " `` 19613 7525 4 Quæ Quæ NNP 19613 7525 5 proprietas proprietas NNP 19613 7525 6 conditionum conditionum NNP 19613 7525 7 , , , 19613 7525 8 divinæ divinæ NNP 19613 7525 9 et et NNP 19613 7525 10 humanæ humanæ NNP 19613 7525 11 , , , 19613 7525 12 æqua æqua NNP 19613 7525 13 utique utique NNP 19613 7525 14 _ _ NNP 19613 7525 15 naturæ naturæ NNP 19613 7525 16 _ _ NNP 19613 7525 17 cuiusque cuiusque NNP 19613 7525 18 veritate veritate NNP 19613 7525 19 disjuncta disjuncta NNP 19613 7525 20 est est NNP 19613 7525 21 . . . 19613 7525 22 " " '' 19613 7525 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7526 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7526 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7526 3 599 599 CD 19613 7526 4 : : : 19613 7526 5 In in IN 19613 7526 6 the the DT 19613 7526 7 West West NNP 19613 7526 8 up up IN 19613 7526 9 to to IN 19613 7526 10 the the DT 19613 7526 11 time time NN 19613 7526 12 of of IN 19613 7526 13 Leo Leo NNP 19613 7526 14 I. I. NNP 19613 7526 15 the the DT 19613 7526 16 formula formula NN 19613 7526 17 " " '' 19613 7526 18 deus deus NNP 19613 7526 19 et et NNP 19613 7526 20 homo homo NN 19613 7526 21 , , , 19613 7526 22 " " '' 19613 7526 23 or or CC 19613 7526 24 , , , 19613 7526 25 after after IN 19613 7526 26 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7526 27 's 's POS 19613 7526 28 time time NN 19613 7526 29 " " `` 19613 7526 30 duæ duæ NN 19613 7526 31 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 7526 32 , , , 19613 7526 33 " " '' 19613 7526 34 was be VBD 19613 7526 35 always always RB 19613 7526 36 a a DT 19613 7526 37 simple simple JJ 19613 7526 38 expression expression NN 19613 7526 39 of of IN 19613 7526 40 the the DT 19613 7526 41 facts fact NNS 19613 7526 42 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 7526 43 in in IN 19613 7526 44 the the DT 19613 7526 45 Symbol Symbol NNP 19613 7526 46 , , , 19613 7526 47 and and CC 19613 7526 48 not not RB 19613 7526 49 a a DT 19613 7526 50 speculation speculation NN 19613 7526 51 derived derive VBN 19613 7526 52 from from IN 19613 7526 53 the the DT 19613 7526 54 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 7526 55 of of IN 19613 7526 56 redemption redemption NN 19613 7526 57 . . . 19613 7527 1 This this DT 19613 7527 2 is be VBZ 19613 7527 3 shown show VBN 19613 7527 4 just just RB 19613 7527 5 from from IN 19613 7527 6 the the DT 19613 7527 7 fact fact NN 19613 7527 8 of of IN 19613 7527 9 stress stress NN 19613 7527 10 being be VBG 19613 7527 11 laid lay VBN 19613 7527 12 on on IN 19613 7527 13 the the DT 19613 7527 14 unmixedness unmixedness NN 19613 7527 15 . . . 19613 7528 1 With with IN 19613 7528 2 this this DT 19613 7528 3 was be VBD 19613 7528 4 associated associate VBN 19613 7528 5 a a DT 19613 7528 6 theoretic theoretic JJ 19613 7528 7 and and CC 19613 7528 8 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 7528 9 interest interest NN 19613 7528 10 on on IN 19613 7528 11 the the DT 19613 7528 12 part part NN 19613 7528 13 of of IN 19613 7528 14 theologians theologian NNS 19613 7528 15 , , , 19613 7528 16 so so IN 19613 7528 17 that that IN 19613 7528 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7528 19 began begin VBD 19613 7528 20 to to TO 19613 7528 21 dwell dwell VB 19613 7528 22 at at IN 19613 7528 23 greater great JJR 19613 7528 24 length length NN 19613 7528 25 on on IN 19613 7528 26 the the DT 19613 7528 27 unmixedness unmixedness NN 19613 7528 28 after after IN 19613 7528 29 the the DT 19613 7528 30 appearance appearance NN 19613 7528 31 of of IN 19613 7528 32 that that DT 19613 7528 33 Patripassianism Patripassianism NNP 19613 7528 34 , , , 19613 7528 35 which which WDT 19613 7528 36 professed profess VBD 19613 7528 37 to to TO 19613 7528 38 recognise recognise VB 19613 7528 39 the the DT 19613 7528 40 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 41 filius filius NNP 19613 7528 42 dei dei NNP 19613 7528 43 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 44 in in IN 19613 7528 45 the the DT 19613 7528 46 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 47 caro caro NNP 19613 7528 48 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 49 , , , 19613 7528 50 that that DT 19613 7528 51 is be VBZ 19613 7528 52 in in IN 19613 7528 53 the the DT 19613 7528 54 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 55 deus deus NNP 19613 7528 56 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 57 so so RB 19613 7528 58 far far RB 19613 7528 59 as as IN 19613 7528 60 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7528 61 is be VBZ 19613 7528 62 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 63 incarnatus incarnatus NN 19613 7528 64 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 65 or or CC 19613 7528 66 has have VBZ 19613 7528 67 _ _ NNP 19613 7528 68 changed change VBN 19613 7528 69 _ _ IN 19613 7528 70 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7528 71 into into IN 19613 7528 72 flesh flesh NN 19613 7528 73 . . . 19613 7529 1 As as IN 19613 7529 2 to to IN 19613 7529 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7529 4 's 's POS 19613 7529 5 opposition opposition NN 19613 7529 6 to to IN 19613 7529 7 this this DT 19613 7529 8 view view NN 19613 7529 9 see see VB 19613 7529 10 what what WP 19613 7529 11 follows follow VBZ 19613 7529 12 . . . 19613 7530 1 In in IN 19613 7530 2 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 7530 3 to to IN 19613 7530 4 this this DT 19613 7530 5 Western western JJ 19613 7530 6 formula formula NN 19613 7530 7 the the DT 19613 7530 8 monophysite monophysite NN 19613 7530 9 one one CD 19613 7530 10 was be VBD 19613 7530 11 calculated calculate VBN 19613 7530 12 to to TO 19613 7530 13 satisfy satisfy VB 19613 7530 14 both both CC 19613 7530 15 the the DT 19613 7530 16 _ _ NNP 19613 7530 17 salvation salvation NN 19613 7530 18 _ _ NNP 19613 7530 19 interest interest NN 19613 7530 20 and and CC 19613 7530 21 the the DT 19613 7530 22 understanding understanding NN 19613 7530 23 . . . 19613 7531 1 The the DT 19613 7531 2 Chalcedonian chalcedonian JJ 19613 7531 3 creed creed NN 19613 7531 4 , , , 19613 7531 5 as as IN 19613 7531 6 is be VBZ 19613 7531 7 admitted admit VBN 19613 7531 8 by by IN 19613 7531 9 Schulz Schulz NNP 19613 7531 10 , , , 19613 7531 11 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7531 12 . . NNP 19613 7531 13 , , , 19613 7531 14 pp pp NNP 19613 7531 15 . . . 19613 7532 1 64 64 CD 19613 7532 2 ff ff NNP 19613 7532 3 . . NNP 19613 7532 4 , , , 19613 7532 5 71 71 CD 19613 7532 6 ff ff NNP 19613 7532 7 . . NNP 19613 7532 8 , , , 19613 7532 9 is be VBZ 19613 7532 10 consequently consequently RB 19613 7532 11 to to TO 19613 7532 12 be be VB 19613 7532 13 explained explain VBN 19613 7532 14 from from IN 19613 7532 15 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7532 16 's 's POS 19613 7532 17 view view NN 19613 7532 18 , , , 19613 7532 19 not not RB 19613 7532 20 from from IN 19613 7532 21 that that DT 19613 7532 22 of of IN 19613 7532 23 the the DT 19613 7532 24 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 7532 25 . . . 19613 7533 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7533 2 readers reader NNS 19613 7533 3 will will MD 19613 7533 4 excuse excuse VB 19613 7533 5 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7533 6 for for IN 19613 7533 7 thus thus RB 19613 7533 8 anticipating anticipate VBG 19613 7533 9 . . . 19613 7533 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7534 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7534 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7534 3 600 600 CD 19613 7534 4 : : : 19613 7534 5 " " `` 19613 7534 6 Quare Quare NNP 19613 7534 7 , , , 19613 7534 8 " " '' 19613 7534 9 says say VBZ 19613 7534 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7534 11 III III NNP 19613 7534 12 . . . 19613 7535 1 21 21 CD 19613 7535 2 . . . 19613 7536 1 10 10 CD 19613 7536 2 - - HYPH 19613 7536 3 -"igitur -"igitur JJ 19613 7536 4 non non AFX 19613 7536 5 iterum iterum NNP 19613 7536 6 sumpsit sumpsit NNP 19613 7536 7 limum limum NNP 19613 7536 8 deus deus NNP 19613 7536 9 sed se VBD 19613 7536 10 ex ex NNP 19613 7536 11 Maria Maria NNP 19613 7536 12 operatus operatus RB 19613 7536 13 est est NNP 19613 7536 14 plasmationem plasmationem NNP 19613 7536 15 fieri fieri NNP 19613 7536 16 ? ? . 19613 7537 1 Ut Ut NNP 19613 7537 2 non non AFX 19613 7537 3 alia alia NNP 19613 7537 4 plasmatio plasmatio VBP 19613 7537 5 fieret fieret NNP 19613 7537 6 neque neque NNP 19613 7537 7 alia alia NNP 19613 7537 8 , , , 19613 7537 9 esset esset NN 19613 7537 10 plasmatio plasmatio VBZ 19613 7537 11 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7537 12 salvaietur salvaietur NNP 19613 7537 13 , , , 19613 7537 14 sed sed NNP 19613 7537 15 eadem eadem NNP 19613 7537 16 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 7537 17 recapitularetur recapitularetur NNP 19613 7537 18 , , , 19613 7537 19 servata servata NNP 19613 7537 20 similitudine similitudine NNP 19613 7537 21 ? ? . 19613 7537 22 " " '' 19613 7537 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7538 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7538 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7538 3 601 601 CD 19613 7538 4 : : : 19613 7538 5 See see VB 19613 7538 6 de de NNP 19613 7538 7 carne carne NNP 19613 7538 8 18 18 CD 19613 7538 9 . . . 19613 7539 1 Oehler Oehler NNP 19613 7539 2 has have VBZ 19613 7539 3 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 19613 7539 4 the the DT 19613 7539 5 passage passage NN 19613 7539 6 and and CC 19613 7539 7 therefore therefore RB 19613 7539 8 mispointed mispointe VBD 19613 7539 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7539 10 . . . 19613 7540 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7540 2 is be VBZ 19613 7540 3 as as IN 19613 7540 4 follows follow VBZ 19613 7540 5 : : : 19613 7540 6 " " `` 19613 7540 7 Vox vox NN 19613 7540 8 ista ista NN 19613 7540 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7540 10 Joh Joh NNP 19613 7540 11 . . . 19613 7541 1 I. I. NNP 19613 7542 1 14 14 LS 19613 7542 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7542 3 quid quid NNP 19613 7542 4 caro caro NNP 19613 7542 5 factum factum NN 19613 7542 6 sit sit VBP 19613 7542 7 contestatur contestatur NNP 19613 7542 8 , , , 19613 7542 9 nec nec NNP 19613 7542 10 tamen tamen NNPS 19613 7542 11 periclitatur periclitatur NNP 19613 7542 12 , , , 19613 7542 13 quasi quasi NNP 19613 7542 14 statim statim NNP 19613 7542 15 aliud aliud NNS 19613 7542 16 sit sit VBP 19613 7542 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7542 18 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7542 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7542 20 , , , 19613 7542 21 factum factum NNP 19613 7542 22 caro caro NNP 19613 7542 23 , , , 19613 7542 24 et et FW 19613 7542 25 non non JJ 19613 7542 26 verbum verbum NN 19613 7542 27 .... .... . 19613 7542 28 Cum Cum NNP 19613 7542 29 scriptura scriptura NN 19613 7542 30 non non NNP 19613 7542 31 dicat dicat NNP 19613 7542 32 nisi nisi NNP 19613 7542 33 quod quod NNP 19613 7542 34 factum factum NNP 19613 7542 35 sit sit VB 19613 7542 36 , , , 19613 7542 37 non non AFX 19613 7542 38 et et NNP 19613 7542 39 unde unde NNP 19613 7542 40 sit sit VBP 19613 7542 41 factum factum NNP 19613 7542 42 , , , 19613 7542 43 ergo ergo NNP 19613 7542 44 ex ex NNP 19613 7542 45 alio alio NNP 19613 7542 46 , , , 19613 7542 47 non non AFX 19613 7542 48 ex ex FW 19613 7542 49 semetipso semetipso NN 19613 7542 50 suggerit suggerit NN 19613 7542 51 factum factum NN 19613 7542 52 " " '' 19613 7542 53 etc etc FW 19613 7542 54 . . . 19613 7542 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7543 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7543 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7543 3 602 602 CD 19613 7543 4 : : : 19613 7543 5 Adv Adv NNP 19613 7543 6 . . . 19613 7544 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 7544 2 . . . 19613 7545 1 27 27 CD 19613 7545 2 sq sq NN 19613 7545 3 . . . 19613 7546 1 In in IN 19613 7546 2 de de NNP 19613 7546 3 carne carne NNP 19613 7546 4 3 3 CD 19613 7546 5 sq sq NNP 19613 7546 6 . . . 19613 7547 1 and and CC 19613 7547 2 elsewhere elsewhere RB 19613 7547 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7547 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 7547 5 argues argue VBZ 19613 7547 6 against against IN 19613 7547 7 Marcion marcion NN 19613 7547 8 that that IN 19613 7547 9 God God NNP 19613 7547 10 in in IN 19613 7547 11 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 7547 12 to to IN 19613 7547 13 all all DT 19613 7547 14 creatures creature NNS 19613 7547 15 can can MD 19613 7547 16 transform transform VB 19613 7547 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7547 18 into into IN 19613 7547 19 anything anything NN 19613 7547 20 and and CC 19613 7547 21 yet yet RB 19613 7547 22 remain remain VBP 19613 7547 23 God God NNP 19613 7547 24 . . . 19613 7548 1 Hence hence RB 19613 7548 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7548 3 are be VBP 19613 7548 4 not not RB 19613 7548 5 to to TO 19613 7548 6 think think VB 19613 7548 7 of of IN 19613 7548 8 a a DT 19613 7548 9 transformation transformation NN 19613 7548 10 in in IN 19613 7548 11 the the DT 19613 7548 12 strict strict JJ 19613 7548 13 sense sense NN 19613 7548 14 , , , 19613 7548 15 but but CC 19613 7548 16 of of IN 19613 7548 17 an an DT 19613 7548 18 _ _ NNP 19613 7548 19 adunitio adunitio NN 19613 7548 20 _ _ NNP 19613 7548 21 . . . 19613 7548 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7549 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7549 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7549 3 603 603 CD 19613 7549 4 : : : 19613 7549 5 So so RB 19613 7549 6 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7549 7 think think VBP 19613 7549 8 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7549 9 ought ought MD 19613 7549 10 to to TO 19613 7549 11 express express VB 19613 7549 12 myself -PRON- PRP 19613 7549 13 . . . 19613 7550 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7550 2 does do VBZ 19613 7550 3 not not RB 19613 7550 4 seem seem VB 19613 7550 5 to to IN 19613 7550 6 me -PRON- PRP 19613 7550 7 proper proper JJ 19613 7550 8 to to TO 19613 7550 9 read read VB 19613 7550 10 a a DT 19613 7550 11 twofold twofold JJ 19613 7550 12 conception conception NN 19613 7550 13 into into IN 19613 7550 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7550 15 ' ' POS 19613 7550 16 Christological Christological NNP 19613 7550 17 utterances utterance NNS 19613 7550 18 under under IN 19613 7550 19 the the DT 19613 7550 20 pretext pretext NN 19613 7550 21 that that WDT 19613 7550 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7550 23 according accord VBG 19613 7550 24 to to IN 19613 7550 25 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7550 26 was be VBD 19613 7550 27 also also RB 19613 7550 28 the the DT 19613 7550 29 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7550 30 man man NN 19613 7550 31 , , , 19613 7550 32 with with IN 19613 7550 33 all all PDT 19613 7550 34 the the DT 19613 7550 35 modern modern JJ 19613 7550 36 ideas idea NNS 19613 7550 37 that that WDT 19613 7550 38 are be VBP 19613 7550 39 usually usually RB 19613 7550 40 associated associate VBN 19613 7550 41 with with IN 19613 7550 42 this this DT 19613 7550 43 thought thought NN 19613 7550 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7550 45 Bohringer Bohringer NNP 19613 7550 46 , , , 19613 7550 47 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7550 48 . . NNP 19613 7550 49 , , , 19613 7550 50 p. p. NN 19613 7550 51 542 542 CD 19613 7550 52 ff ff NNP 19613 7550 53 . . NNP 19613 7550 54 , , , 19613 7550 55 see see VB 19613 7550 56 Thomasius Thomasius NNP 19613 7550 57 in in IN 19613 7550 58 opposition opposition NN 19613 7550 59 to to IN 19613 7550 60 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7550 61 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7550 62 . . . 19613 7550 63 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7551 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7551 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7551 3 604 604 CD 19613 7551 4 : : : 19613 7551 5 See see VB 19613 7551 6 , , , 19613 7551 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7551 8 , , , 19613 7551 9 V. V. NNP 19613 7551 10 1 1 CD 19613 7551 11 . . . 19613 7552 1 3 3 LS 19613 7552 2 . . . 19613 7553 1 Nitzch Nitzch NNP 19613 7553 2 , , , 19613 7553 3 Dogmengeschichte Dogmengeschichte NNP 19613 7553 4 I. I. NNP 19613 7553 5 p. p. NN 19613 7553 6 309 309 CD 19613 7553 7 . . . 19613 7554 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7554 2 , , , 19613 7554 3 in in IN 19613 7554 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7554 5 own own JJ 19613 7554 6 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 7554 7 fashion fashion NN 19613 7554 8 , , , 19613 7554 9 developed develop VBD 19613 7554 10 still still RB 19613 7554 11 more more RBR 19613 7554 12 clearly clearly RB 19613 7554 13 the the DT 19613 7554 14 thought thought NN 19613 7554 15 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 7554 16 to to IN 19613 7554 17 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7554 18 by by IN 19613 7554 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7554 20 . . . 19613 7555 1 See see VB 19613 7555 2 adv adv NN 19613 7555 3 . . . 19613 7556 1 Prax Prax NNP 19613 7556 2 . . . 19613 7557 1 12 12 CD 19613 7557 2 : : : 19613 7557 3 " " `` 19613 7557 4 Quibus Quibus NNP 19613 7557 5 faciebat faciebat NNP 19613 7557 6 deus deu VBZ 19613 7557 7 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7557 8 similem similem NNP 19613 7557 9 ? ? . 19613 7558 1 Filio Filio NNP 19613 7558 2 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7558 3 , , , 19613 7558 4 qui qui NNP 19613 7558 5 erat erat NN 19613 7558 6 induturus induturus JJ 19613 7558 7 hominem hominem NN 19613 7558 8 .... .... . 19613 7558 9 Erat erat VB 19613 7558 10 autem autem NN 19613 7558 11 ad ad NN 19613 7558 12 cuius cuius NN 19613 7558 13 imaginem imaginem NNP 19613 7558 14 faciebat faciebat NNP 19613 7558 15 , , , 19613 7558 16 ad ad NN 19613 7558 17 filii filii NN 19613 7558 18 scilicet scilicet NN 19613 7558 19 , , , 19613 7558 20 qui qui NNP 19613 7558 21 homo homo NNP 19613 7558 22 futurus futurus NNP 19613 7558 23 certior certior NNP 19613 7558 24 et et NNP 19613 7558 25 verior verior NNP 19613 7558 26 imaginem imaginem NNP 19613 7558 27 suam suam NNP 19613 7558 28 fecerat fecerat NNP 19613 7558 29 dici dici VBD 19613 7558 30 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7558 31 , , , 19613 7558 32 qui qui NNP 19613 7558 33 tunc tunc NNP 19613 7558 34 de de NNP 19613 7558 35 limo limo NNP 19613 7558 36 formari formari NNP 19613 7558 37 habebat habebat NNP 19613 7558 38 , , , 19613 7558 39 imago imago NNP 19613 7558 40 veri veri NNP 19613 7558 41 et et NNP 19613 7558 42 similitudo similitudo NNP 19613 7558 43 . . . 19613 7558 44 " " '' 19613 7559 1 Adv Adv NNP 19613 7559 2 . . . 19613 7560 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7560 2 . . . 19613 7561 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7561 2 8 8 CD 19613 7561 3 : : : 19613 7561 4 " " `` 19613 7561 5 Creator Creator NNP 19613 7561 6 Christum Christum NNP 19613 7561 7 , , , 19613 7561 8 sermonem sermonem NNP 19613 7561 9 suum suum NN 19613 7561 10 , , , 19613 7561 11 intuens intuens NNP 19613 7561 12 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7561 13 futurum futurum NN 19613 7561 14 , , , 19613 7561 15 Faciamus Faciamus NNP 19613 7561 16 , , , 19613 7561 17 inquit inquit NN 19613 7561 18 , , , 19613 7561 19 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7561 20 ad ad NNP 19613 7561 21 imaginem imaginem NNP 19613 7561 22 et et NNP 19613 7561 23 similitudinem similitudinem NNP 19613 7561 24 nostram nostram NNP 19613 7561 25 " " '' 19613 7561 26 ; ; : 19613 7561 27 the the DT 19613 7561 28 same same JJ 19613 7561 29 in in IN 19613 7561 30 de de NNP 19613 7561 31 resurr resurr NNP 19613 7561 32 . . . 19613 7562 1 6 6 CD 19613 7562 2 . . . 19613 7563 1 But but CC 19613 7563 2 with with IN 19613 7563 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7563 4 , , , 19613 7563 5 too too RB 19613 7563 6 , , , 19613 7563 7 this this DT 19613 7563 8 thought thought NN 19613 7563 9 was be VBD 19613 7563 10 a a DT 19613 7563 11 sudden sudden JJ 19613 7563 12 idea idea NN 19613 7563 13 and and CC 19613 7563 14 did do VBD 19613 7563 15 not not RB 19613 7563 16 become become VB 19613 7563 17 the the DT 19613 7563 18 basis basis NN 19613 7563 19 of of IN 19613 7563 20 further further JJ 19613 7563 21 speculation speculation NN 19613 7563 22 . . . 19613 7563 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7564 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7564 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7564 3 605 605 CD 19613 7564 4 : : : 19613 7564 5 Iren iren JJ 19613 7564 6 . . . 19613 7565 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7565 2 . . . 19613 7566 1 14 14 CD 19613 7566 2 . . . 19613 7567 1 2 2 LS 19613 7567 2 ; ; : 19613 7567 3 for for IN 19613 7567 4 further further JJ 19613 7567 5 particulars particular NNS 19613 7567 6 on on IN 19613 7567 7 the the DT 19613 7567 8 point point NN 19613 7567 9 see see VB 19613 7567 10 below below RB 19613 7567 11 , , , 19613 7567 12 where where WRB 19613 7567 13 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7567 14 ' ' POS 19613 7567 15 views view NNS 19613 7567 16 on on IN 19613 7567 17 the the DT 19613 7567 18 preparation preparation NN 19613 7567 19 of of IN 19613 7567 20 salvation salvation NN 19613 7567 21 are be VBP 19613 7567 22 discussed discuss VBN 19613 7567 23 . . . 19613 7568 1 The the DT 19613 7568 2 views view NNS 19613 7568 3 of of IN 19613 7568 4 Dorner Dorner NNP 19613 7568 5 , , , 19613 7568 6 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7568 7 . . NNP 19613 7568 8 , , , 19613 7568 9 492 492 CD 19613 7568 10 f. f. NNS 19613 7568 11 , , , 19613 7568 12 that that IN 19613 7568 13 the the DT 19613 7568 14 union union NN 19613 7568 15 of of IN 19613 7568 16 the the DT 19613 7568 17 Son Son NNP 19613 7568 18 of of IN 19613 7568 19 God God NNP 19613 7568 20 with with IN 19613 7568 21 humanity humanity NN 19613 7568 22 was be VBD 19613 7568 23 a a DT 19613 7568 24 gradual gradual JJ 19613 7568 25 process process NN 19613 7568 26 , , , 19613 7568 27 are be VBP 19613 7568 28 marred mar VBN 19613 7568 29 by by IN 19613 7568 30 some some DT 19613 7568 31 exaggerations exaggeration NNS 19613 7568 32 , , , 19613 7568 33 but but CC 19613 7568 34 are be VBP 19613 7568 35 correct correct JJ 19613 7568 36 in in IN 19613 7568 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7568 38 main main JJ 19613 7568 39 idea idea NN 19613 7568 40 . . . 19613 7568 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7569 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7569 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7569 3 606 606 CD 19613 7569 4 : : : 19613 7569 5 " " `` 19613 7569 6 Secundum secundum VB 19613 7569 7 i -PRON- PRP 19613 7569 8 d d VBN 19613 7569 9 quod quod NN 19613 7569 10 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7569 11 dei dei NNP 19613 7569 12 homo homo NNP 19613 7569 13 erat erat NNP 19613 7569 14 ex ex FW 19613 7569 15 radice radice NNP 19613 7569 16 lesse lesse NNP 19613 7569 17 et et NNP 19613 7569 18 filius filius NNP 19613 7569 19 Abrabæ Abrabæ NNP 19613 7569 20 , , , 19613 7569 21 secunum secunum NNP 19613 7569 22 hoc hoc FW 19613 7569 23 requiescebat requiescebat NN 19613 7569 24 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 7569 25 dei dei NNP 19613 7569 26 super super NNP 19613 7569 27 eum eum NNP 19613 7569 28 ... ... NFP 19613 7569 29 secundum secundum NN 19613 7569 30 autem autem NNP 19613 7569 31 quod quod NN 19613 7569 32 deus deus NNP 19613 7569 33 erat erat NNP 19613 7569 34 , , , 19613 7569 35 non non JJ 19613 7569 36 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7569 37 gloriam gloriam JJ 19613 7569 38 iudicabat iudicabat NN 19613 7569 39 . . . 19613 7569 40 " " '' 19613 7570 1 All all DT 19613 7570 2 that that WDT 19613 7570 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7570 4 said say VBD 19613 7570 5 of of IN 19613 7570 6 the the DT 19613 7570 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7570 8 in in IN 19613 7570 9 reference reference NN 19613 7570 10 to to IN 19613 7570 11 the the DT 19613 7570 12 person person NN 19613 7570 13 of of IN 19613 7570 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7570 15 is be VBZ 19613 7570 16 to to TO 19613 7570 17 be be VB 19613 7570 18 understood understand VBN 19613 7570 19 merely merely RB 19613 7570 20 as as IN 19613 7570 21 an an DT 19613 7570 22 _ _ NNP 19613 7570 23 exegetical exegetical JJ 19613 7570 24 _ _ NNP 19613 7570 25 necessity necessity NN 19613 7570 26 and and CC 19613 7570 27 must must MD 19613 7570 28 not not RB 19613 7570 29 be be VB 19613 7570 30 regarded regard VBN 19613 7570 31 as as IN 19613 7570 32 a a DT 19613 7570 33 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 7570 34 _ _ NNP 19613 7570 35 principle principle NN 19613 7570 36 _ _ NNP 19613 7570 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7570 38 this this DT 19613 7570 39 is be VBZ 19613 7570 40 also also RB 19613 7570 41 the the DT 19613 7570 42 case case NN 19613 7570 43 with with IN 19613 7570 44 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7570 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7570 46 . . . 19613 7571 1 Dorner Dorner NNP 19613 7571 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7571 3 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7571 4 . . NNP 19613 7571 5 , , , 19613 7571 6 p. p. NN 19613 7571 7 492 492 CD 19613 7571 8 f. f. NNP 19613 7571 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7571 10 has have VBZ 19613 7571 11 failed fail VBN 19613 7571 12 to to TO 19613 7571 13 see see VB 19613 7571 14 this this DT 19613 7571 15 , , , 19613 7571 16 and and CC 19613 7571 17 on on IN 19613 7571 18 the the DT 19613 7571 19 basis basis NN 19613 7571 20 of of IN 19613 7571 21 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7571 22 ' ' POS 19613 7571 23 incidental incidental JJ 19613 7571 24 and and CC 19613 7571 25 involuntary involuntary JJ 19613 7571 26 utterances utterance NNS 19613 7571 27 has have VBZ 19613 7571 28 attempted attempt VBN 19613 7571 29 to to TO 19613 7571 30 found find VBN 19613 7571 31 a a DT 19613 7571 32 speculation speculation NN 19613 7571 33 which which WDT 19613 7571 34 represents represent VBZ 19613 7571 35 the the DT 19613 7571 36 latter latter JJ 19613 7571 37 as as IN 19613 7571 38 meaning mean VBG 19613 7571 39 that that IN 19613 7571 40 the the DT 19613 7571 41 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7571 42 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 7571 43 was be VBD 19613 7571 44 the the DT 19613 7571 45 medium medium NN 19613 7571 46 which which WDT 19613 7571 47 gradually gradually RB 19613 7571 48 united unite VBD 19613 7571 49 the the DT 19613 7571 50 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7571 51 , , , 19613 7571 52 who who WP 19613 7571 53 was be VBD 19613 7571 54 exalted exalt VBN 19613 7571 55 above above IN 19613 7571 56 growing grow VBG 19613 7571 57 and and CC 19613 7571 58 suffering suffering NN 19613 7571 59 , , , 19613 7571 60 into into IN 19613 7571 61 one one CD 19613 7571 62 person person NN 19613 7571 63 with with IN 19613 7571 64 the the DT 19613 7571 65 free free JJ 19613 7571 66 and and CC 19613 7571 67 growing grow VBG 19613 7571 68 man man NN 19613 7571 69 in in IN 19613 7571 70 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7571 71 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7571 72 . . . 19613 7572 1 In in IN 19613 7572 2 III III NNP 19613 7572 3 . . . 19613 7573 1 12 12 CD 19613 7573 2 . . . 19613 7574 1 5 5 CD 19613 7574 2 - - SYM 19613 7574 3 7 7 CD 19613 7574 4 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7574 5 , , , 19613 7574 6 in in IN 19613 7574 7 conformity conformity NN 19613 7574 8 with with IN 19613 7574 9 Acts Acts NNP 19613 7574 10 IV IV NNP 19613 7574 11 . . . 19613 7575 1 27 27 CD 19613 7575 2 : : : 19613 7575 3 X. X. NNP 19613 7576 1 38 38 CD 19613 7576 2 , , , 19613 7576 3 used use VBD 19613 7576 4 the the DT 19613 7576 5 following follow VBG 19613 7576 6 other other JJ 19613 7576 7 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 7576 8 about about IN 19613 7576 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7576 10 : : : 19613 7576 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7576 12 Greek greek NN 19613 7576 13 : : : 19613 7576 14 ho ho NNP 19613 7576 15 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7576 16 , , , 19613 7576 17 ho ho NNP 19613 7576 18 poiêsas poiêsas NNP 19613 7576 19 ton ton NNP 19613 7576 20 ouranon ouranon NNP 19613 7576 21 k.t.l k.t.l NNP 19613 7576 22 . . NNP 19613 7576 23 , , , 19613 7576 24 kai kai NNP 19613 7576 25 ho ho NNP 19613 7576 26 toutou toutou NNP 19613 7576 27 pais pais NNP 19613 7576 28 , , , 19613 7576 29 on on IN 19613 7576 30 echrisen echrisen NNP 19613 7576 31 ho ho NNP 19613 7576 32 Theos]--"Petrus Theos]--"Petrus NNP 19613 7576 33 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 7576 34 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 7576 35 esse esse NNP 19613 7576 36 filium filium NNP 19613 7576 37 dei dei NNP 19613 7576 38 testificatus testificatus NNP 19613 7576 39 est est NNP 19613 7576 40 , , , 19613 7576 41 qui qui UH 19613 7576 42 et et NN 19613 7576 43 unctus unctus NN 19613 7576 44 Spiritu Spiritu NNP 19613 7576 45 Sancto Sancto NNP 19613 7576 46 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 7576 47 dicitur dicitur NN 19613 7576 48 . . . 19613 7576 49 " " '' 19613 7577 1 But but CC 19613 7577 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7577 3 only only RB 19613 7577 4 expressed express VBD 19613 7577 5 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7577 6 thus thus RB 19613 7577 7 because because IN 19613 7577 8 of of IN 19613 7577 9 these these DT 19613 7577 10 passages passage NNS 19613 7577 11 , , , 19613 7577 12 whereas whereas IN 19613 7577 13 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7577 14 not not RB 19613 7577 15 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 7577 16 calls call VBZ 19613 7577 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7577 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7577 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7577 20 : : : 19613 7577 21 pais pais NNP 19613 7577 22 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7577 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7577 24 . . . 19613 7577 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7578 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7578 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7578 3 607 607 CD 19613 7578 4 : : : 19613 7578 5 On on IN 19613 7578 6 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7578 7 ' ' POS 19613 7578 8 views view NNS 19613 7578 9 of of IN 19613 7578 10 the the DT 19613 7578 11 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 7578 12 see see VBP 19613 7578 13 Dorner Dorner NNP 19613 7578 14 , , , 19613 7578 15 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7578 16 . . NNP 19613 7578 17 , , , 19613 7578 18 I. I. NNP 19613 7578 19 p. p. NN 19613 7578 20 609 609 CD 19613 7578 21 ff.--an ff.--an NN 19613 7578 22 account account NN 19613 7578 23 to to TO 19613 7578 24 be be VB 19613 7578 25 used use VBN 19613 7578 26 with with IN 19613 7578 27 caution caution NN 19613 7578 28 -- -- : 19613 7578 29 and and CC 19613 7578 30 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 7578 31 , , , 19613 7578 32 Quæst Quæst NNP 19613 7578 33 . . . 19613 7579 1 Hippol hippol NN 19613 7579 2 . . . 19613 7580 1 Specimen Specimen NNP 19613 7580 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7580 3 1864 1864 CD 19613 7580 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7580 5 , , , 19613 7580 6 p. p. NN 19613 7580 7 47 47 CD 19613 7580 8 sq sq NN 19613 7580 9 . . . 19613 7581 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 19613 7581 2 the the DT 19613 7581 3 latter latter NN 19613 7581 4 has have VBZ 19613 7581 5 not not RB 19613 7581 6 carried carry VBN 19613 7581 7 out out RP 19613 7581 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7581 9 intention intention NN 19613 7581 10 to to TO 19613 7581 11 set set VB 19613 7581 12 forth forth RP 19613 7581 13 the the DT 19613 7581 14 Christology Christology NNP 19613 7581 15 of of IN 19613 7581 16 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7581 17 in in IN 19613 7581 18 detail detail NN 19613 7581 19 . . . 19613 7582 1 In in IN 19613 7582 2 the the DT 19613 7582 3 work work NN 19613 7582 4 quoted quote VBD 19613 7582 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7582 6 has have VBZ 19613 7582 7 , , , 19613 7582 8 however however RB 19613 7582 9 , , , 19613 7582 10 shown show VBN 19613 7582 11 how how WRB 19613 7582 12 closely closely RB 19613 7582 13 the the DT 19613 7582 14 latter latter JJ 19613 7582 15 in in IN 19613 7582 16 many many JJ 19613 7582 17 respects respect NNS 19613 7582 18 has have VBZ 19613 7582 19 imitated imitate VBN 19613 7582 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7582 21 in in IN 19613 7582 22 this this DT 19613 7582 23 case case NN 19613 7582 24 also also RB 19613 7582 25 . . . 19613 7583 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7583 2 is be VBZ 19613 7583 3 instructive instructive JJ 19613 7583 4 to to TO 19613 7583 5 see see VB 19613 7583 6 what what WP 19613 7583 7 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7583 8 has have VBZ 19613 7583 9 not not RB 19613 7583 10 adopted adopt VBN 19613 7583 11 from from IN 19613 7583 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7583 13 or or CC 19613 7583 14 what what WP 19613 7583 15 has have VBZ 19613 7583 16 become become VBN 19613 7583 17 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 7583 18 with with IN 19613 7583 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7583 20 . . . 19613 7584 1 As as IN 19613 7584 2 a a DT 19613 7584 3 professional professional JJ 19613 7584 4 and and CC 19613 7584 5 learned learn VBD 19613 7584 6 teacher teacher NN 19613 7584 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7584 8 is be VBZ 19613 7584 9 at at IN 19613 7584 10 bottom bottom NN 19613 7584 11 nearer nearer RB 19613 7584 12 to to IN 19613 7584 13 the the DT 19613 7584 14 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 7584 15 as as IN 19613 7584 16 regards regard VBZ 19613 7584 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7584 18 Christology Christology NNP 19613 7584 19 than than IN 19613 7584 20 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7584 21 . . . 19613 7585 1 As as IN 19613 7585 2 an an DT 19613 7585 3 exegete exegete NN 19613 7585 4 and and CC 19613 7585 5 theological theological JJ 19613 7585 6 author author NN 19613 7585 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7585 8 has have VBZ 19613 7585 9 much much JJ 19613 7585 10 in in IN 19613 7585 11 common common NN 19613 7585 12 with with IN 19613 7585 13 the the DT 19613 7585 14 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 7585 15 , , , 19613 7585 16 just just RB 19613 7585 17 as as IN 19613 7585 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7585 19 is be VBZ 19613 7585 20 in in IN 19613 7585 21 more more JJR 19613 7585 22 than than IN 19613 7585 23 one one CD 19613 7585 24 respect respect NN 19613 7585 25 a a DT 19613 7585 26 connecting connect VBG 19613 7585 27 link link NN 19613 7585 28 between between IN 19613 7585 29 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 7585 30 controversialists controversialist NNS 19613 7585 31 like like IN 19613 7585 32 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7585 33 and and CC 19613 7585 34 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 7585 35 scholars scholar NNS 19613 7585 36 like like IN 19613 7585 37 Origen Origen NNP 19613 7585 38 . . . 19613 7586 1 With with IN 19613 7586 2 the the DT 19613 7586 3 latter latter JJ 19613 7586 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7586 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 7586 6 came come VBD 19613 7586 7 into into IN 19613 7586 8 personal personal JJ 19613 7586 9 contact contact NN 19613 7586 10 . . . 19613 7587 1 See see VB 19613 7587 2 Hieron Hieron NNP 19613 7587 3 . . NNP 19613 7587 4 , , , 19613 7587 5 de de NNP 19613 7587 6 vir vir NNP 19613 7587 7 . . . 19613 7588 1 inl inl UH 19613 7588 2 . . . 19613 7589 1 61 61 CD 19613 7589 2 : : : 19613 7589 3 Hieron Hieron NNP 19613 7589 4 . . NNP 19613 7589 5 , , , 19613 7589 6 ep ep NNP 19613 7589 7 . . . 19613 7590 1 ad ad NN 19613 7590 2 Damas Damas NNP 19613 7590 3 . . . 19613 7591 1 edit edit NN 19613 7591 2 . . . 19613 7592 1 Venet Venet NNP 19613 7592 2 . . . 19613 7593 1 I. I. NNP 19613 7593 2 , , , 19613 7593 3 ep ep NNP 19613 7593 4 . . . 19613 7594 1 36 36 CD 19613 7594 2 is be VBZ 19613 7594 3 also also RB 19613 7594 4 instructive instructive JJ 19613 7594 5 . . . 19613 7595 1 These these DT 19613 7595 2 brief brief JJ 19613 7595 3 remarks remark NNS 19613 7595 4 are be VBP 19613 7595 5 , , , 19613 7595 6 however however RB 19613 7595 7 , , , 19613 7595 8 by by IN 19613 7595 9 no no DT 19613 7595 10 means means NN 19613 7595 11 intended intend VBN 19613 7595 12 to to TO 19613 7595 13 give give VB 19613 7595 14 countenance countenance NN 19613 7595 15 to to IN 19613 7595 16 Kimmel Kimmel NNP 19613 7595 17 's 's POS 19613 7595 18 untenable untenable JJ 19613 7595 19 hypothesis hypothesis NN 19613 7595 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7595 21 de de FW 19613 7595 22 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 7595 23 . . . 19613 7596 1 vita vita NNP 19613 7596 2 et et NNP 19613 7596 3 scriptis scriptis NN 19613 7596 4 , , , 19613 7596 5 1839 1839 CD 19613 7596 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7596 7 that that IN 19613 7596 8 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7596 9 was be VBD 19613 7596 10 an an DT 19613 7596 11 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 7596 12 . . . 19613 7597 1 In in IN 19613 7597 2 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7597 3 ' ' POS 19613 7597 4 treatise treatise NN 19613 7597 5 c. c. NN 19613 7597 6 Noët Noët NNP 19613 7597 7 . . . 19613 7598 1 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7598 2 find find VBP 19613 7598 3 positive positive JJ 19613 7598 4 teachings teaching NNS 19613 7598 5 that that WDT 19613 7598 6 remind remind VBP 19613 7598 7 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7598 8 of of IN 19613 7598 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7598 10 . . . 19613 7599 1 An an DT 19613 7599 2 important important JJ 19613 7599 3 passage passage NN 19613 7599 4 is be VBZ 19613 7599 5 de de NNP 19613 7599 6 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7599 7 et et NNP 19613 7599 8 Antichristo Antichristo NNP 19613 7599 9 3 3 CD 19613 7599 10 f. f. NN 19613 7599 11 : : : 19613 7599 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7599 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7599 14 : : : 19613 7599 15 eis eis NNP 19613 7599 16 gar gar NNP 19613 7599 17 kai kai NNP 19613 7599 18 ho ho NNP 19613 7599 19 tou tou NNP 19613 7599 20 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7599 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7599 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7599 23 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7599 24 . . . 19613 7600 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7600 2 , , , 19613 7600 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7600 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7600 5 : : : 19613 7600 6 di di NNP 19613 7600 7 ' ' '' 19613 7600 8 ou ou NNP 19613 7600 9 kai kai NNP 19613 7600 10 hêmeis hêmeis NNP 19613 7600 11 tuchontes tuchontes NNP 19613 7600 12 tên tên NNP 19613 7600 13 dia dia NNP 19613 7600 14 tou tou NNP 19613 7600 15 hagiou hagiou NNP 19613 7600 16 pneumatos pneumatos NNP 19613 7600 17 anagennesin anagennesin NNP 19613 7600 18 eis eis NNP 19613 7600 19 ena ena NNP 19613 7600 20 teleion teleion NNP 19613 7600 21 kai kai NNP 19613 7600 22 epouranion epouranion NN 19613 7600 23 anthrôpon anthrôpon IN 19613 7600 24 hoi hoi NNP 19613 7600 25 pantes pantes NNP 19613 7600 26 katantêsai katantêsai NNP 19613 7600 27 epithumoumen epithumoumen NNP 19613 7600 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7600 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7600 30 see see VB 19613 7600 31 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7600 32 . . . 19613 7600 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7601 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7601 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7601 3 : : : 19613 7601 4 Epeidê Epeidê NNP 19613 7601 5 gar gar NNP 19613 7601 6 ho ho NNP 19613 7601 7 logos logos NNP 19613 7601 8 tou tou NNP 19613 7601 9 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7601 10 asarkos asarkos NNP 19613 7601 11 ôn ôn NNP 19613 7601 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7601 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7601 14 see see VB 19613 7601 15 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7601 16 , , , 19613 7601 17 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7601 18 . . NNP 19613 7601 19 , , , 19613 7601 20 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7601 21 . . . 19613 7601 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7602 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7602 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7602 3 : : : 19613 7602 4 enedusato enedusato NNP 19613 7602 5 tên tên NNP 19613 7602 6 hagian hagian NNP 19613 7602 7 sarka sarka NNP 19613 7602 8 ek ek NNP 19613 7602 9 tês tês NNP 19613 7602 10 hagias hagias NNP 19613 7602 11 parthenou parthenou NNP 19613 7602 12 ; ; : 19613 7602 13 hôs hôs NNP 19613 7602 14 numphios numphios NNP 19613 7602 15 himation himation NN 19613 7602 16 exuphanas exuphanas NNP 19613 7602 17 heautô heautô NNP 19613 7602 18 ên ên NNP 19613 7602 19 tô tô NNP 19613 7602 20 staurikô staurikô NNP 19613 7602 21 pathei pathei NNP 19613 7602 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7602 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7602 24 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7602 25 and and CC 19613 7602 26 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7602 27 also also RB 19613 7602 28 make make VBP 19613 7602 29 the the DT 19613 7602 30 death death NN 19613 7602 31 on on IN 19613 7602 32 the the DT 19613 7602 33 cross cross NN 19613 7602 34 the the DT 19613 7602 35 object object NN 19613 7602 36 of of IN 19613 7602 37 the the DT 19613 7602 38 assumption assumption NN 19613 7602 39 of of IN 19613 7602 40 the the DT 19613 7602 41 flesh flesh NN 19613 7602 42 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7602 43 , , , 19613 7602 44 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7602 45 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7602 46 : : : 19613 7602 47 hopôs hopôs NN 19613 7602 48 sygkerasas sygkerasas NNP 19613 7602 49 to to IN 19613 7602 50 thnêton thnêton NNP 19613 7602 51 hemôn hemôn NNP 19613 7602 52 sôma sôma NNP 19613 7602 53 tê tê NNP 19613 7602 54 heautou heautou NNP 19613 7602 55 dunamei dunamei NNP 19613 7602 56 kai kai NNP 19613 7602 57 mixas mixas NNP 19613 7602 58 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7602 59 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7602 60 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7602 61 . . . 19613 7602 62 , , , 19613 7602 63 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7602 64 . . . 19613 7602 65 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7603 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7603 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7603 3 : : : 19613 7603 4 tô tô NNP 19613 7603 5 aphthartô aphthartô VB 19613 7603 6 to to TO 19613 7603 7 phtharton phtharton NNP 19613 7603 8 kai kai NNP 19613 7603 9 to to IN 19613 7603 10 asthenes asthenes NNP 19613 7603 11 tô tô NNP 19613 7603 12 ischurô ischurô NNP 19613 7603 13 sôse sôse NNP 19613 7603 14 ton ton NNP 19613 7603 15 apollumenon apollumenon NNP 19613 7603 16 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 7603 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7603 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7603 19 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7603 20 . . . 19613 7603 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7603 22 . . . 19613 7604 1 The the DT 19613 7604 2 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 7604 3 disquisition disquisition NN 19613 7604 4 deserves deserve VBZ 19613 7604 5 particular particular JJ 19613 7604 6 note note NN 19613 7604 7 , , , 19613 7604 8 because because IN 19613 7604 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7604 10 shows show VBZ 19613 7604 11 that that IN 19613 7604 12 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7604 13 has have VBZ 19613 7604 14 also also RB 19613 7604 15 borrowed borrow VBN 19613 7604 16 from from IN 19613 7604 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7604 18 the the DT 19613 7604 19 idea idea NN 19613 7604 20 that that IN 19613 7604 21 the the DT 19613 7604 22 union union NN 19613 7604 23 of of IN 19613 7604 24 the the DT 19613 7604 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7604 26 with with IN 19613 7604 27 humanity humanity NN 19613 7604 28 had have VBD 19613 7604 29 already already RB 19613 7604 30 begun begin VBN 19613 7604 31 in in IN 19613 7604 32 a a DT 19613 7604 33 certain certain JJ 19613 7604 34 way way NN 19613 7604 35 in in IN 19613 7604 36 the the DT 19613 7604 37 prophets prophet NNS 19613 7604 38 . . . 19613 7605 1 Overbeck overbeck NN 19613 7605 2 has have VBZ 19613 7605 3 rightly rightly RB 19613 7605 4 compared compare VBN 19613 7605 5 the the DT 19613 7605 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7605 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7605 8 : : : 19613 7605 9 anaplassein anaplassein NNP 19613 7605 10 di di NNP 19613 7605 11 ' ' `` 19613 7605 12 heutou heutou NNP 19613 7605 13 ton ton NN 19613 7605 14 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7605 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7605 16 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7605 17 . . NNP 19613 7605 18 , , , 19613 7605 19 c. c. NNP 19613 7605 20 26 26 CD 19613 7605 21 , , , 19613 7605 22 with with IN 19613 7605 23 the the DT 19613 7605 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7605 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7605 26 : : : 19613 7605 27 anakephalaioun anakephalaioun NN 19613 7605 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7605 29 of of IN 19613 7605 30 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7605 31 and and CC 19613 7605 32 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7605 33 . . NNP 19613 7605 34 , , , 19613 7605 35 c. c. NNP 19613 7605 36 44 44 CD 19613 7605 37 , , , 19613 7605 38 with with IN 19613 7605 39 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7605 40 . . . 19613 7606 1 II ii CD 19613 7606 2 . . . 19613 7607 1 22 22 CD 19613 7607 2 , , , 19613 7607 3 4 4 CD 19613 7607 4 . . . 19613 7608 1 For for IN 19613 7608 2 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7608 3 ' ' POS 19613 7608 4 Christology Christology NNP 19613 7608 5 Philosoph Philosoph NNPS 19613 7608 6 . . . 19613 7609 1 X. X. NNP 19613 7610 1 33 33 CD 19613 7610 2 , , , 19613 7610 3 p. p. NN 19613 7610 4 542 542 CD 19613 7610 5 and and CC 19613 7610 6 c. c. NNP 19613 7610 7 Noet Noet NNP 19613 7610 8 . . . 19613 7611 1 10 10 CD 19613 7611 2 ff ff NNS 19613 7611 3 . . . 19613 7612 1 are be VBP 19613 7612 2 the the DT 19613 7612 3 chief chief JJ 19613 7612 4 passages passage NNS 19613 7612 5 of of IN 19613 7612 6 additional additional JJ 19613 7612 7 importance importance NN 19613 7612 8 . . . 19613 7613 1 In in IN 19613 7613 2 the the DT 19613 7613 3 latter latter JJ 19613 7613 4 passage passage NN 19613 7613 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7613 6 is be VBZ 19613 7613 7 specially specially RB 19613 7613 8 noteworthy noteworthy JJ 19613 7613 9 that that IN 19613 7613 10 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7613 11 , , , 19613 7613 12 in in IN 19613 7613 13 addition addition NN 19613 7613 14 to to IN 19613 7613 15 many many JJ 19613 7613 16 other other JJ 19613 7613 17 deviations deviation NNS 19613 7613 18 from from IN 19613 7613 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7613 20 and and CC 19613 7613 21 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7613 22 , , , 19613 7613 23 insists insist VBZ 19613 7613 24 on on IN 19613 7613 25 applying apply VBG 19613 7613 26 the the DT 19613 7613 27 full full JJ 19613 7613 28 name name NN 19613 7613 29 of of IN 19613 7613 30 Son Son NNP 19613 7613 31 only only RB 19613 7613 32 to to IN 19613 7613 33 the the DT 19613 7613 34 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 7613 35 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7613 36 . . . 19613 7614 1 In in IN 19613 7614 2 this this DT 19613 7614 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7614 4 have have VBP 19613 7614 5 a a DT 19613 7614 6 remnant remnant NN 19613 7614 7 of of IN 19613 7614 8 the the DT 19613 7614 9 more more RBR 19613 7614 10 ancient ancient JJ 19613 7614 11 idea idea NN 19613 7614 12 and and CC 19613 7614 13 at at IN 19613 7614 14 the the DT 19613 7614 15 same same JJ 19613 7614 16 time time NN 19613 7614 17 a a DT 19613 7614 18 concession concession NN 19613 7614 19 to to IN 19613 7614 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7614 21 opponents opponent NNS 19613 7614 22 who who WP 19613 7614 23 admitted admit VBD 19613 7614 24 an an DT 19613 7614 25 eternal eternal JJ 19613 7614 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7614 27 in in IN 19613 7614 28 God God NNP 19613 7614 29 , , , 19613 7614 30 but but CC 19613 7614 31 not not RB 19613 7614 32 a a DT 19613 7614 33 pre pre JJ 19613 7614 34 - - JJ 19613 7614 35 temporal temporal JJ 19613 7614 36 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 7614 37 of of IN 19613 7614 38 the the DT 19613 7614 39 Son Son NNP 19613 7614 40 . . . 19613 7615 1 See see VB 19613 7615 2 c. c. NNP 19613 7615 3 15 15 CD 19613 7615 4 : : : 19613 7615 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7615 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7615 7 : : : 19613 7615 8 poion poion NN 19613 7615 9 oun oun NNP 19613 7615 10 huion huion NN 19613 7615 11 heautou heautou VBZ 19613 7615 12 ho ho NNP 19613 7615 13 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7615 14 dia dia VB 19613 7615 15 tês tês NNP 19613 7615 16 sarkos sarkos NNP 19613 7615 17 katepempsen katepempsen NNP 19613 7615 18 all all DT 19613 7615 19 ' ' `` 19613 7615 20 hê hê NNP 19613 7615 21 ton ton NN 19613 7615 22 logon logon NN 19613 7615 23 ; ; : 19613 7615 24 hon hon NNP 19613 7615 25 huion huion NNP 19613 7615 26 prosêgoreue prosêgoreue NNP 19613 7615 27 dia dia NNP 19613 7615 28 to to IN 19613 7615 29 mellein mellein NNP 19613 7615 30 auton auton NNP 19613 7615 31 genesthai genesthai NNP 19613 7615 32 , , , 19613 7615 33 kai kai NNP 19613 7615 34 to to TO 19613 7615 35 koinon koinon NNP 19613 7615 36 onoma onoma NNP 19613 7615 37 tês tês NNP 19613 7615 38 eis eis NNP 19613 7615 39 anthrôpous anthrôpous NNP 19613 7615 40 philostorgias philostorgias NNP 19613 7615 41 analambanei analambanei NNP 19613 7615 42 ho ho NNP 19613 7615 43 huios huios NNP 19613 7615 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7615 45 kaitoi kaitoi NNP 19613 7615 46 teleios teleio NNS 19613 7615 47 logos logo VBZ 19613 7615 48 ôn ôn NNP 19613 7615 49 monogenes monogene NNS 19613 7615 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7615 51 . . . 19613 7616 1 oud oud NNP 19613 7616 2 ' ' POS 19613 7616 3 hê hê NN 19613 7616 4 sarx sarx NNP 19613 7616 5 kath kath NNP 19613 7616 6 ' ' POS 19613 7616 7 heautên heautên NNP 19613 7616 8 dicha dicha NNP 19613 7616 9 tou tou NNP 19613 7616 10 logou logou NNP 19613 7616 11 hupostênai hupostênai NNP 19613 7616 12 êdunato êdunato NNP 19613 7616 13 dia dia NNP 19613 7616 14 to to IN 19613 7616 15 en en IN 19613 7616 16 logô logô NNP 19613 7616 17 tên tên NNP 19613 7616 18 sustasin sustasin NNP 19613 7616 19 echein echein NNP 19613 7616 20 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 7616 21 oun oun NNP 19613 7616 22 eis eis NNP 19613 7616 23 huios huio VBZ 19613 7616 24 teleios teleio NNS 19613 7616 25 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7616 26 ephanerôthê ephanerôthê NN 19613 7616 27 . . . 19613 7616 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7617 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7617 2 partook partake VBD 19613 7617 3 to to IN 19613 7617 4 a a DT 19613 7617 5 much much RB 19613 7617 6 greater great JJR 19613 7617 7 extent extent NN 19613 7617 8 than than IN 19613 7617 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7617 10 teacher teacher NN 19613 7617 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7617 12 of of IN 19613 7617 13 the the DT 19613 7617 14 tree tree NN 19613 7617 15 of of IN 19613 7617 16 Greek greek JJ 19613 7617 17 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7617 18 and and CC 19613 7617 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7617 20 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 7617 21 speaks speak VBZ 19613 7617 22 much much RB 19613 7617 23 more more RBR 19613 7617 24 frequently frequently RB 19613 7617 25 than than IN 19613 7617 26 the the DT 19613 7617 27 latter latter NN 19613 7617 28 of of IN 19613 7617 29 the the DT 19613 7617 30 " " `` 19613 7617 31 divine divine JJ 19613 7617 32 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 7617 33 " " '' 19613 7617 34 of of IN 19613 7617 35 the the DT 19613 7617 36 faith faith NN 19613 7617 37 . . . 19613 7618 1 From from IN 19613 7618 2 the the DT 19613 7618 3 fragments fragment NNS 19613 7618 4 and and CC 19613 7618 5 writings writing NNS 19613 7618 6 of of IN 19613 7618 7 this this DT 19613 7618 8 author author NN 19613 7618 9 that that WDT 19613 7618 10 are be VBP 19613 7618 11 preserved preserve VBN 19613 7618 12 to to IN 19613 7618 13 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7618 14 the the DT 19613 7618 15 existence existence NN 19613 7618 16 of of IN 19613 7618 17 very very RB 19613 7618 18 various various JJ 19613 7618 19 Christologies christology NNS 19613 7618 20 can can MD 19613 7618 21 be be VB 19613 7618 22 shown show VBN 19613 7618 23 ; ; : 19613 7618 24 and and CC 19613 7618 25 this this DT 19613 7618 26 proves prove VBZ 19613 7618 27 that that IN 19613 7618 28 the the DT 19613 7618 29 Christology Christology NNP 19613 7618 30 of of IN 19613 7618 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7618 32 teacher teacher NN 19613 7618 33 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7618 34 had have VBD 19613 7618 35 not not RB 19613 7618 36 by by IN 19613 7618 37 any any DT 19613 7618 38 means mean NNS 19613 7618 39 yet yet RB 19613 7618 40 become become VBN 19613 7618 41 predominant predominant JJ 19613 7618 42 in in IN 19613 7618 43 the the DT 19613 7618 44 Church Church NNP 19613 7618 45 , , , 19613 7618 46 as as IN 19613 7618 47 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7618 48 might may MD 19613 7618 49 suppose suppose VB 19613 7618 50 from from IN 19613 7618 51 the the DT 19613 7618 52 latter latter NN 19613 7618 53 's 's POS 19613 7618 54 confident confident JJ 19613 7618 55 tone tone NN 19613 7618 56 . . . 19613 7619 1 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7619 2 is be VBZ 19613 7619 3 an an DT 19613 7619 4 exegete exegete NN 19613 7619 5 and and CC 19613 7619 6 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 7619 7 still still RB 19613 7619 8 yielded yield VBN 19613 7619 9 with with IN 19613 7619 10 comparative comparative JJ 19613 7619 11 impartiality impartiality NN 19613 7619 12 to to IN 19613 7619 13 the the DT 19613 7619 14 impressions impression NNS 19613 7619 15 conveyed convey VBN 19613 7619 16 by by IN 19613 7619 17 the the DT 19613 7619 18 several several JJ 19613 7619 19 passages passage NNS 19613 7619 20 . . . 19613 7620 1 For for IN 19613 7620 2 example example NN 19613 7620 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7620 4 recognised recognise VBD 19613 7620 5 the the DT 19613 7620 6 woman woman NN 19613 7620 7 of of IN 19613 7620 8 Rev. Rev. NNP 19613 7621 1 XII XII NNP 19613 7621 2 . . . 19613 7622 1 as as IN 19613 7622 2 the the DT 19613 7622 3 Church Church NNP 19613 7622 4 and and CC 19613 7622 5 the the DT 19613 7622 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 7622 7 as as IN 19613 7622 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7622 9 child child NN 19613 7622 10 , , , 19613 7622 11 and and CC 19613 7622 12 gave give VBD 19613 7622 13 the the DT 19613 7622 14 following follow VBG 19613 7622 15 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 7622 16 of of IN 19613 7622 17 the the DT 19613 7622 18 passage passage NN 19613 7622 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7622 20 de de FW 19613 7622 21 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7622 22 et et NNP 19613 7622 23 Antichristo Antichristo NNP 19613 7622 24 61 61 CD 19613 7622 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7622 26 : : : 19613 7622 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7622 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7622 29 : : : 19613 7622 30 ou ou NNP 19613 7622 31 pausetai pausetai NNP 19613 7622 32 hê hê NNP 19613 7622 33 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 7622 34 gennôsa gennôsa NNP 19613 7622 35 ek ek NNP 19613 7622 36 kardias kardias NNP 19613 7622 37 ton ton NNP 19613 7622 38 logon logon NNP 19613 7622 39 tou tou NNP 19613 7622 40 en en NNP 19613 7622 41 kosmô kosmô NNP 19613 7622 42 hupo hupo NNP 19613 7622 43 apistôn apistôn NNP 19613 7622 44 diôkomenon diôkomenon NNP 19613 7622 45 . . . 19613 7623 1 " " `` 19613 7623 2 kai kai NNP 19613 7623 3 eteke eteke NNP 19613 7623 4 " " '' 19613 7623 5 , , , 19613 7623 6 phêsin phêsin NNP 19613 7623 7 , , , 19613 7623 8 " " '' 19613 7623 9 huion huion NNP 19613 7623 10 arrena arrena NNP 19613 7623 11 , , , 19613 7623 12 hos hos NNP 19613 7623 13 mellei mellei NNP 19613 7623 14 poimainein poimainein NNP 19613 7623 15 panta panta NNP 19613 7623 16 ta ta NNP 19613 7623 17 ethnê ethnê NNP 19613 7623 18 " " '' 19613 7623 19 , , , 19613 7623 20 ton ton NN 19613 7623 21 arrena arrena NN 19613 7623 22 kai kai NNP 19613 7623 23 teleios teleio NNS 19613 7623 24 Christon Christon NNP 19613 7623 25 , , , 19613 7623 26 paida paida NN 19613 7623 27 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7623 28 , , , 19613 7623 29 Theon Theon NNP 19613 7623 30 kai kai NNP 19613 7623 31 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 7623 32 katangellomenon katangellomenon NNP 19613 7623 33 aei aei NNP 19613 7623 34 tiktousa tiktousa NNP 19613 7623 35 hê hê NNP 19613 7623 36 ekklêsia ekklêsia NNP 19613 7623 37 didaskei didaskei NNP 19613 7623 38 panta panta NNP 19613 7623 39 ta ta NNP 19613 7623 40 ethnê ethnê NNP 19613 7623 41 . . . 19613 7623 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7624 1 If if IN 19613 7624 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7624 3 consider consider VBP 19613 7624 4 how how WRB 19613 7624 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7624 6 ' ' POS 19613 7624 7 pupil pupil NN 19613 7624 8 is be VBZ 19613 7624 9 led lead VBN 19613 7624 10 by by IN 19613 7624 11 the the DT 19613 7624 12 text text NN 19613 7624 13 of of IN 19613 7624 14 the the DT 19613 7624 15 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7624 16 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 7624 17 to to IN 19613 7624 18 the the DT 19613 7624 19 most most RBS 19613 7624 20 diverse diverse JJ 19613 7624 21 " " `` 19613 7624 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 7624 23 , , , 19613 7624 24 " " '' 19613 7624 25 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7624 26 see see VBP 19613 7624 27 how how WRB 19613 7624 28 the the DT 19613 7624 29 " " `` 19613 7624 30 Scripture scripture NN 19613 7624 31 " " '' 19613 7624 32 theologians theologian NNS 19613 7624 33 were be VBD 19613 7624 34 the the DT 19613 7624 35 very very JJ 19613 7624 36 ones one NNS 19613 7624 37 who who WP 19613 7624 38 threatened threaten VBD 19613 7624 39 the the DT 19613 7624 40 faith faith NN 19613 7624 41 with with IN 19613 7624 42 the the DT 19613 7624 43 greatest great JJS 19613 7624 44 corruptions corruption NNS 19613 7624 45 . . . 19613 7625 1 As as IN 19613 7625 2 the the DT 19613 7625 3 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 7625 4 of of IN 19613 7625 5 the the DT 19613 7625 6 Valentinian Valentinian NNP 19613 7625 7 schools school NNS 19613 7625 8 became become VBD 19613 7625 9 the the DT 19613 7625 10 mother mother NN 19613 7625 11 of of IN 19613 7625 12 numerous numerous JJ 19613 7625 13 self self NN 19613 7625 14 - - HYPH 19613 7625 15 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 7625 16 Christologies Christologies NNPS 19613 7625 17 , , , 19613 7625 18 so so CC 19613 7625 19 the the DT 19613 7625 20 same same JJ 19613 7625 21 result result NN 19613 7625 22 was be VBD 19613 7625 23 threatened threaten VBN 19613 7625 24 here--"doctrinæ here--"doctrinæ ADD 19613 7625 25 inolescentes inolescente NNS 19613 7625 26 in in IN 19613 7625 27 silvas silvas NNP 19613 7625 28 iam iam NNP 19613 7625 29 exoleverunt exoleverunt NNP 19613 7625 30 Gnosticorum Gnosticorum NNP 19613 7625 31 . . . 19613 7625 32 " " '' 19613 7626 1 From from IN 19613 7626 2 this this DT 19613 7626 3 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 7626 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 7626 5 's 's POS 19613 7626 6 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 7626 7 to to TO 19613 7626 8 subject subject VB 19613 7626 9 the the DT 19613 7626 10 whole whole JJ 19613 7626 11 material material NN 19613 7626 12 of of IN 19613 7626 13 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 7626 14 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 7626 15 to to IN 19613 7626 16 a a DT 19613 7626 17 fixed fix VBN 19613 7626 18 theory theory NN 19613 7626 19 appears appear VBZ 19613 7626 20 in in IN 19613 7626 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7626 22 historical historical JJ 19613 7626 23 greatness greatness NN 19613 7626 24 and and CC 19613 7626 25 importance importance NN 19613 7626 26 . . . 19613 7626 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7627 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7627 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7627 3 608 608 CD 19613 7627 4 : : : 19613 7627 5 See see VB 19613 7627 6 other other JJ 19613 7627 7 passages passage NNS 19613 7627 8 on on IN 19613 7627 9 p. p. NN 19613 7627 10 241 241 CD 19613 7627 11 , , , 19613 7627 12 note note VBP 19613 7627 13 2 2 CD 19613 7627 14 . . . 19613 7628 1 This this DT 19613 7628 2 is be VBZ 19613 7628 3 also also RB 19613 7628 4 reëchoed reëchoe VBN 19613 7628 5 in in IN 19613 7628 6 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 7628 7 . . . 19613 7629 1 See see VB 19613 7629 2 , , , 19613 7629 3 for for IN 19613 7629 4 example example NN 19613 7629 5 , , , 19613 7629 6 ep ep NNP 19613 7629 7 . . . 19613 7630 1 58 58 CD 19613 7630 2 . . . 19613 7631 1 6 6 CD 19613 7631 2 : : : 19613 7631 3 " " `` 19613 7631 4 filius filius NNP 19613 7631 5 dei dei NNP 19613 7631 6 passus passus NNP 19613 7631 7 est est NNP 19613 7631 8 ut ut PRP$ 19613 7631 9 nos nos NNP 19613 7631 10 filios filios NNP 19613 7631 11 dei dei NNP 19613 7631 12 faceret faceret NNP 19613 7631 13 , , , 19613 7631 14 et et NNP 19613 7631 15 filius filius NNP 19613 7631 16 hominis hominis NNP 19613 7631 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7631 18 scil scil NNP 19613 7631 19 . . . 19613 7632 1 the the DT 19613 7632 2 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 7632 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7632 4 pati pati VBZ 19613 7632 5 non non AFX 19613 7632 6 vult vult NNP 19613 7632 7 esse esse NNP 19613 7632 8 dei dei NNP 19613 7632 9 filius filius NNP 19613 7632 10 possit possit NNP 19613 7632 11 . . . 19613 7632 12 " " '' 19613 7632 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7633 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7633 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7633 3 609 609 CD 19613 7633 4 : : : 19613 7633 5 See see VB 19613 7633 6 III iii CD 19613 7633 7 . . . 19613 7634 1 10 10 CD 19613 7634 2 . . . 19613 7635 1 3 3 LS 19613 7635 2 . . . 19613 7635 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7636 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7636 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7636 3 610 610 CD 19613 7636 4 : : : 19613 7636 5 See see VB 19613 7636 6 the the DT 19613 7636 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 7636 8 passage passage NN 19613 7636 9 in in IN 19613 7636 10 IV IV NNP 19613 7636 11 . . . 19613 7637 1 36 36 CD 19613 7637 2 . . . 19613 7638 1 7 7 LS 19613 7638 2 : : : 19613 7638 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7638 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7638 5 : : : 19613 7638 6 hê hê VB 19613 7638 7 gnôsis gnôsis NNP 19613 7638 8 tou tou NNP 19613 7638 9 huiou huiou NNP 19613 7638 10 tou tou NNP 19613 7638 11 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7638 12 , , , 19613 7638 13 hêtis hêtis NN 19613 7638 14 ên ên NNP 19613 7638 15 aphtharsia aphtharsia NNP 19613 7638 16 . . . 19613 7638 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7639 1 Another another DT 19613 7639 2 result result NN 19613 7639 3 of of IN 19613 7639 4 the the DT 19613 7639 5 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 7639 6 struggle struggle NN 19613 7639 7 is be VBZ 19613 7639 8 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7639 9 ' ' POS 19613 7639 10 raising raise VBG 19613 7639 11 the the DT 19613 7639 12 question question NN 19613 7639 13 as as IN 19613 7639 14 to to IN 19613 7639 15 what what WP 19613 7639 16 new new JJ 19613 7639 17 thing thing NN 19613 7639 18 the the DT 19613 7639 19 Lord Lord NNP 19613 7639 20 has have VBZ 19613 7639 21 brought bring VBN 19613 7639 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7639 23 IV IV NNP 19613 7639 24 . . . 19613 7640 1 34 34 CD 19613 7640 2 . . . 19613 7641 1 1 1 LS 19613 7641 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7641 3 : : : 19613 7641 4 " " `` 19613 7641 5 Si Si NNP 19613 7641 6 autem autem NN 19613 7641 7 subit subit NN 19613 7641 8 vos vos NNP 19613 7641 9 huiusmodi huiusmodi NNP 19613 7641 10 sensus sensus NNP 19613 7641 11 , , , 19613 7641 12 ut ut UH 19613 7641 13 dicatis dicatis NN 19613 7641 14 : : : 19613 7641 15 Quid quid VB 19613 7641 16 igitur igitur NNP 19613 7641 17 novi novi NNS 19613 7641 18 dominus dominus VBP 19613 7641 19 attulit attulit NNP 19613 7641 20 veniens venien NNS 19613 7641 21 ? ? . 19613 7642 1 cognoscite cognoscite JJ 19613 7642 2 , , , 19613 7642 3 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 7642 4 omnem omnem NNP 19613 7642 5 novitatem novitatem NNP 19613 7642 6 attulit attulit NNP 19613 7642 7 semetipsum semetipsum NNP 19613 7642 8 afferens afferen NNS 19613 7642 9 , , , 19613 7642 10 qui qui NNP 19613 7642 11 fuerat fuerat NNP 19613 7642 12 annuntiatus annuntiatus NN 19613 7642 13 . . . 19613 7642 14 " " '' 19613 7643 1 The the DT 19613 7643 2 new new JJ 19613 7643 3 thing thing NN 19613 7643 4 is be VBZ 19613 7643 5 then then RB 19613 7643 6 defined define VBN 19613 7643 7 thus thus RB 19613 7643 8 : : : 19613 7643 9 " " `` 19613 7643 10 Cum Cum NNP 19613 7643 11 perceperunt perceperunt NN 19613 7643 12 eam eam NNP 19613 7643 13 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7643 14 ab ab NNP 19613 7643 15 eo eo NNP 19613 7643 16 est est NNP 19613 7643 17 libertatem libertatem NNP 19613 7643 18 et et NNP 19613 7643 19 participant participant NNP 19613 7643 20 visionem visionem NNP 19613 7643 21 eius eius NNP 19613 7643 22 et et NNP 19613 7643 23 audierunt audierunt NNP 19613 7643 24 sermones sermones NNP 19613 7643 25 eius eius NNP 19613 7643 26 et et NNP 19613 7643 27 fruiti fruiti NNP 19613 7643 28 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7643 29 muneribus muneribus NNP 19613 7643 30 ab ab NNP 19613 7643 31 eo eo NNP 19613 7643 32 , , , 19613 7643 33 non non AFX 19613 7643 34 iam iam NNP 19613 7643 35 requiretur requiretur NNP 19613 7643 36 , , , 19613 7643 37 quid quid NNP 19613 7643 38 novius novius NNP 19613 7643 39 attulit attulit NNP 19613 7643 40 rex rex NNP 19613 7643 41 super super NNP 19613 7643 42 eos eos NNP 19613 7643 43 , , , 19613 7643 44 qui qui NNP 19613 7643 45 annuntiaverunt annuntiaverunt NN 19613 7643 46 advenum advenum NN 19613 7643 47 eius eius NN 19613 7643 48 ... ... : 19613 7643 49 Semetipsum Semetipsum NNP 19613 7643 50 enim enim NNP 19613 7643 51 attulit attulit NNP 19613 7643 52 et et NNP 19613 7643 53 ea ea NNP 19613 7643 54 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7643 55 prædicta prædicta NNP 19613 7643 56 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7643 57 bona bona NNP 19613 7643 58 . . . 19613 7643 59 " " '' 19613 7643 60 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7644 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7644 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7644 3 611 611 CD 19613 7644 4 : : : 19613 7644 5 See see VB 19613 7644 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7644 7 . . . 19613 7645 1 36 36 CD 19613 7645 2 . . . 19613 7646 1 6 6 CD 19613 7646 2 : : : 19613 7646 3 " " `` 19613 7646 4 Adhuc adhuc VB 19613 7646 5 manifestavit manifestavit JJ 19613 7646 6 oportere oportere NN 19613 7646 7 nos nos NNP 19613 7646 8 cum cum NNP 19613 7646 9 vocatione vocatione NN 19613 7646 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7646 11 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 7646 12 , , , 19613 7646 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7646 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7646 15 : : : 19613 7646 16 meta meta NNP 19613 7646 17 tên tên NNP 19613 7646 18 klêsin klêsin NNP 19613 7646 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7646 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7646 21 et et NN 19613 7646 22 iustitiæ iustitiæ NNS 19613 7646 23 operibus operibus NNP 19613 7646 24 adornari adornari NNP 19613 7646 25 , , , 19613 7646 26 uti uti NNP 19613 7646 27 requiescat requiescat VBP 19613 7646 28 super sup AFX 19613 7646 29 nos nos NNP 19613 7646 30 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 7646 31 dei"--we dei"--we NN 19613 7646 32 must must MD 19613 7646 33 provide provide VB 19613 7646 34 _ _ NNP 19613 7646 35 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 7646 36 _ _ NNP 19613 7646 37 with with IN 19613 7646 38 the the DT 19613 7646 39 wedding wedding NN 19613 7646 40 garment garment NN 19613 7646 41 . . . 19613 7646 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7647 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7647 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7647 3 612 612 CD 19613 7647 4 : : : 19613 7647 5 The the DT 19613 7647 6 incapacity incapacity NN 19613 7647 7 of of IN 19613 7647 8 man man NN 19613 7647 9 is be VBZ 19613 7647 10 referred refer VBN 19613 7647 11 to to IN 19613 7647 12 in in IN 19613 7647 13 III III NNP 19613 7647 14 . . . 19613 7648 1 18 18 CD 19613 7648 2 . . . 19613 7649 1 1 1 LS 19613 7649 2 : : : 19613 7649 3 III iii CD 19613 7649 4 . . . 19613 7650 1 21 21 CD 19613 7650 2 . . . 19613 7651 1 10 10 CD 19613 7651 2 ; ; : 19613 7651 3 III iii CD 19613 7651 4 . . . 19613 7652 1 21 21 CD 19613 7652 2 - - SYM 19613 7652 3 23 23 CD 19613 7652 4 shows show NNS 19613 7652 5 that that IN 19613 7652 6 the the DT 19613 7652 7 same same JJ 19613 7652 8 man man NN 19613 7652 9 that that WDT 19613 7652 10 had have VBD 19613 7652 11 fallen fall VBN 19613 7652 12 had have VBD 19613 7652 13 to to TO 19613 7652 14 be be VB 19613 7652 15 led lead VBN 19613 7652 16 to to IN 19613 7652 17 communion communion NN 19613 7652 18 with with IN 19613 7652 19 God God NNP 19613 7652 20 ; ; : 19613 7652 21 V. V. NNP 19613 7652 22 21 21 CD 19613 7652 23 . . . 19613 7653 1 3 3 LS 19613 7653 2 : : : 19613 7653 3 V. V. NNP 19613 7653 4 24 24 CD 19613 7653 5 . . . 19613 7654 1 4 4 CD 19613 7654 2 teach teach VBP 19613 7654 3 that that DT 19613 7654 4 man man NN 19613 7654 5 had have VBD 19613 7654 6 to to TO 19613 7654 7 overcome overcome VB 19613 7654 8 the the DT 19613 7654 9 devil devil NN 19613 7654 10 ; ; : 19613 7654 11 the the DT 19613 7654 12 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 19613 7654 13 necessity necessity NN 19613 7654 14 of of IN 19613 7654 15 God God NNP 19613 7654 16 's 's POS 19613 7654 17 appearing appear VBG 19613 7654 18 as as IN 19613 7654 19 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 7654 20 is be VBZ 19613 7654 21 treated treat VBN 19613 7654 22 of of IN 19613 7654 23 in in IN 19613 7654 24 III III NNP 19613 7654 25 . . . 19613 7655 1 23 23 CD 19613 7655 2 . . . 19613 7656 1 1 1 LS 19613 7656 2 : : : 19613 7656 3 " " `` 19613 7656 4 Si Si NNP 19613 7656 5 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7656 6 iam iam NNP 19613 7656 7 non non AFX 19613 7656 8 reverteretur reverteretur NNP 19613 7656 9 ad ad NN 19613 7656 10 vitam vitam NNP 19613 7656 11 , , , 19613 7656 12 sed se VBN 19613 7656 13 in in IN 19613 7656 14 totum totum NNP 19613 7656 15 proiectus proiectus NNP 19613 7656 16 esset esset NNP 19613 7656 17 morti morti NNP 19613 7656 18 , , , 19613 7656 19 victus victus NNP 19613 7656 20 esset esset NN 19613 7656 21 deus deus NNP 19613 7656 22 et et NN 19613 7656 23 superasset superasset NN 19613 7656 24 serpentis serpentis VBP 19613 7656 25 nequitia nequitia NNP 19613 7656 26 voluntatem voluntatem NNP 19613 7656 27 dei dei NNP 19613 7656 28 . . . 19613 7657 1 Sed Sed NNP 19613 7657 2 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 7657 3 deus deu VBZ 19613 7657 4 invictus invictus NNP 19613 7657 5 et et NNP 19613 7657 6 magnanimis magnanimis NNP 19613 7657 7 est est NNP 19613 7657 8 , , , 19613 7657 9 magnanimem magnanimem NNP 19613 7657 10 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7657 11 se se NNP 19613 7657 12 exhibuit exhibuit NNP 19613 7657 13 etc etc FW 19613 7657 14 . . . 19613 7657 15 " " '' 19613 7658 1 That that IN 19613 7658 2 the the DT 19613 7658 3 accomplishment accomplishment NN 19613 7658 4 of of IN 19613 7658 5 salvation salvation NN 19613 7658 6 must must MD 19613 7658 7 be be VB 19613 7658 8 effected effect VBN 19613 7658 9 in in IN 19613 7658 10 a a DT 19613 7658 11 righteous righteous JJ 19613 7658 12 manner manner NN 19613 7658 13 , , , 19613 7658 14 and and CC 19613 7658 15 therefore therefore RB 19613 7658 16 be be VB 19613 7658 17 as as RB 19613 7658 18 much much JJ 19613 7658 19 a a DT 19613 7658 20 proof proof NN 19613 7658 21 of of IN 19613 7658 22 the the DT 19613 7658 23 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 7658 24 as as IN 19613 7658 25 of of IN 19613 7658 26 the the DT 19613 7658 27 immeasurable immeasurable JJ 19613 7658 28 love love NN 19613 7658 29 and and CC 19613 7658 30 mercy mercy NN 19613 7658 31 of of IN 19613 7658 32 God God NNP 19613 7658 33 , , , 19613 7658 34 is be VBZ 19613 7658 35 shown show VBN 19613 7658 36 in in IN 19613 7658 37 V. V. NNP 19613 7658 38 1 1 CD 19613 7658 39 . . . 19613 7659 1 1 1 LS 19613 7659 2 : : : 19613 7659 3 V. v. NN 19613 7660 1 21 21 CD 19613 7660 2 . . . 19613 7660 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7661 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7661 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7661 3 613 613 CD 19613 7661 4 : : : 19613 7661 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7661 6 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 19613 7661 7 the the DT 19613 7661 8 view view NN 19613 7661 9 in in IN 19613 7661 10 V. V. NNP 19613 7661 11 21 21 CD 19613 7661 12 in in IN 19613 7661 13 great great JJ 19613 7661 14 detail detail NN 19613 7661 15 . . . 19613 7662 1 According accord VBG 19613 7662 2 to to IN 19613 7662 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7662 4 ideas idea NNS 19613 7662 5 in in IN 19613 7662 6 this this DT 19613 7662 7 chapter chapter NN 19613 7662 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7662 9 must must MD 19613 7662 10 include include VB 19613 7662 11 the the DT 19613 7662 12 history history NN 19613 7662 13 of of IN 19613 7662 14 the the DT 19613 7662 15 temptation temptation NN 19613 7662 16 in in IN 19613 7662 17 the the DT 19613 7662 18 _ _ NNP 19613 7662 19 regula regula NN 19613 7662 20 fidei fidei NNP 19613 7662 21 _ _ NNP 19613 7662 22 . . . 19613 7662 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7663 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7663 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7663 3 614 614 CD 19613 7663 4 : : : 19613 7663 5 See see VB 19613 7663 6 particularly particularly RB 19613 7663 7 V. V. NNP 19613 7663 8 1 1 CD 19613 7663 9 . . . 19613 7664 1 1 1 LS 19613 7664 2 : : : 19613 7664 3 " " `` 19613 7664 4 Verbum Verbum NNP 19613 7664 5 potens poten VBZ 19613 7664 6 et et NNP 19613 7664 7 homo homo NNP 19613 7664 8 verus verus NNP 19613 7664 9 sanguine sanguine NNP 19613 7664 10 suo suo NNP 19613 7664 11 rationabiliter rationabiliter NNP 19613 7664 12 redimens redimen VBZ 19613 7664 13 nos nos NNP 19613 7664 14 , , , 19613 7664 15 redemptionem redemptionem NN 19613 7664 16 semetipsum semetipsum VBD 19613 7664 17 dedit dedit NN 19613 7664 18 pro pro NN 19613 7664 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7664 20 , , , 19613 7664 21 qui qui VBN 19613 7664 22 in in IN 19613 7664 23 captivitatem captivitatem NNP 19613 7664 24 ducti ducti NNP 19613 7664 25 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7664 26 ... ... : 19613 7664 27 del del NNP 19613 7664 28 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7664 29 non non AFX 19613 7664 30 deficiens deficien NNS 19613 7664 31 in in IN 19613 7664 32 sua sua NNP 19613 7664 33 iustitia iustitia NNP 19613 7664 34 , , , 19613 7664 35 iuste iuste NNP 19613 7664 36 etiam etiam NNP 19613 7664 37 adversus adversus NNP 19613 7664 38 ipsam ipsam NNP 19613 7664 39 conversus conversus NNP 19613 7664 40 est est NNP 19613 7664 41 apostasiam apostasiam NNP 19613 7664 42 , , , 19613 7664 43 ea ea NNP 19613 7664 44 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7664 45 sunt sunt NNP 19613 7664 46 sua sua NNP 19613 7664 47 redimens redimen VBZ 19613 7664 48 ab ab NNP 19613 7664 49 ea ea NNP 19613 7664 50 , , , 19613 7664 51 non non NNP 19613 7664 52 cum cum NNP 19613 7664 53 vi vi NNP 19613 7664 54 , , , 19613 7664 55 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 7664 56 ilia ilia NNP 19613 7664 57 initio initio NNP 19613 7664 58 dominabatur dominabatur NNP 19613 7664 59 nostri nostri NNP 19613 7664 60 , , , 19613 7664 61 ea ea NNP 19613 7664 62 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7664 63 non non AFX 19613 7664 64 erant erant JJ 19613 7664 65 sua sua NN 19613 7664 66 insatiabiliter insatiabilit JJR 19613 7664 67 rapiens rapiens NNPS 19613 7664 68 , , , 19613 7664 69 sed sed NNP 19613 7664 70 secundum secundum NNP 19613 7664 71 suadelam suadelam NNP 19613 7664 72 , , , 19613 7664 73 quemadmodum quemadmodum NNP 19613 7664 74 decebat decebat NNP 19613 7664 75 deum deum NNP 19613 7664 76 suadentem suadentem NNP 19613 7664 77 et et NNP 19613 7664 78 non non AFX 19613 7664 79 vim vim NNP 19613 7664 80 inferentem inferentem NNP 19613 7664 81 , , , 19613 7664 82 accipere accipere NNP 19613 7664 83 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7664 84 vellet vellet NNP 19613 7664 85 , , , 19613 7664 86 ut ut UH 19613 7664 87 neque neque NNP 19613 7664 88 quod quod NNP 19613 7664 89 est est NNP 19613 7664 90 iustum iustum NNP 19613 7664 91 confringeretur confringeretur NNP 19613 7664 92 neque neque NNP 19613 7664 93 antiqua antiqua NNP 19613 7664 94 plasmatio plasmatio NNP 19613 7664 95 dei dei NNP 19613 7664 96 deperiret deperiret NNP 19613 7664 97 . . . 19613 7664 98 " " '' 19613 7665 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7665 2 see see VBP 19613 7665 3 that that IN 19613 7665 4 the the DT 19613 7665 5 idea idea NN 19613 7665 6 of of IN 19613 7665 7 the the DT 19613 7665 8 blood blood NN 19613 7665 9 of of IN 19613 7665 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7665 11 as as IN 19613 7665 12 ransom ransom NN 19613 7665 13 does do VBZ 19613 7665 14 not not RB 19613 7665 15 possess possess VB 19613 7665 16 with with IN 19613 7665 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7665 18 the the DT 19613 7665 19 value value NN 19613 7665 20 of of IN 19613 7665 21 a a DT 19613 7665 22 fully fully RB 19613 7665 23 developed develop VBN 19613 7665 24 theory theory NN 19613 7665 25 , , , 19613 7665 26 but but CC 19613 7665 27 is be VBZ 19613 7665 28 suggestive suggestive JJ 19613 7665 29 of of IN 19613 7665 30 one one CD 19613 7665 31 . . . 19613 7666 1 But but CC 19613 7666 2 even even RB 19613 7666 3 in in IN 19613 7666 4 this this DT 19613 7666 5 form form NN 19613 7666 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7666 7 appeared appear VBD 19613 7666 8 suspicious suspicious JJ 19613 7666 9 and and CC 19613 7666 10 , , , 19613 7666 11 in in IN 19613 7666 12 fact fact NN 19613 7666 13 , , , 19613 7666 14 a a DT 19613 7666 15 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 7666 16 idea idea NN 19613 7666 17 to to IN 19613 7666 18 a a DT 19613 7666 19 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 7666 20 teacher teacher NN 19613 7666 21 of of IN 19613 7666 22 the the DT 19613 7666 23 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 7666 24 century century NN 19613 7666 25 . . . 19613 7667 1 Pseudo Pseudo NNP 19613 7667 2 - - HYPH 19613 7667 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 7667 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7667 5 Adamantius Adamantius NNP 19613 7667 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7667 7 opposed oppose VBD 19613 7667 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7667 9 by by IN 19613 7667 10 the the DT 19613 7667 11 following follow VBG 19613 7667 12 argument argument NN 19613 7667 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7667 14 De De NNP 19613 7667 15 recta recta NNP 19613 7667 16 in in IN 19613 7667 17 deum deum NN 19613 7667 18 fide fide NN 19613 7667 19 , , , 19613 7667 20 edit edit NN 19613 7667 21 Wetstein Wetstein NNP 19613 7667 22 1673 1673 CD 19613 7667 23 , , , 19613 7667 24 Sectio Sectio NNP 19613 7667 25 I. I. NNP 19613 7667 26 p. p. NN 19613 7667 27 38 38 CD 19613 7667 28 sq sq NN 19613 7667 29 . . . 19613 7668 1 See see VB 19613 7668 2 Rufinus Rufinus NNP 19613 7668 3 ' ' POS 19613 7668 4 translation translation NN 19613 7668 5 in in IN 19613 7668 6 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 7668 7 's 's POS 19613 7668 8 Kirchenhistorische Kirchenhistorische NNP 19613 7668 9 Anecdota Anecdota NNP 19613 7668 10 Vol Vol NNP 19613 7668 11 . . . 19613 7669 1 I. I. NNP 19613 7670 1 1883 1883 CD 19613 7670 2 , , , 19613 7670 3 p. p. NN 19613 7670 4 34 34 CD 19613 7670 5 sq sq NNP 19613 7670 6 . . NNP 19613 7670 7 , , , 19613 7670 8 which which WDT 19613 7670 9 in in IN 19613 7670 10 many many JJ 19613 7670 11 places place NNS 19613 7670 12 has have VBZ 19613 7670 13 preserved preserve VBN 19613 7670 14 the the DT 19613 7670 15 right right JJ 19613 7670 16 sense sense NN 19613 7670 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7670 18 : : : 19613 7670 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7670 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7670 21 : : : 19613 7670 22 Ton ton VB 19613 7670 23 priômenon priômenon NN 19613 7670 24 ephês ephês NN 19613 7670 25 , , , 19613 7670 26 einai einai NNP 19613 7670 27 ton ton NN 19613 7670 28 Christon Christon NNP 19613 7670 29 , , , 19613 7670 30 ho ho NNP 19613 7670 31 peprakôs peprakôs NNP 19613 7670 32 tis tis NNP 19613 7670 33 estin estin NNP 19613 7670 34 ; ; : 19613 7670 35 êlthen êlthen NNP 19613 7670 36 eis eis NNP 19613 7670 37 se se NNP 19613 7670 38 ho ho NNP 19613 7670 39 aplous aplous JJ 19613 7670 40 mythos mythos NNP 19613 7670 41 ; ; : 19613 7670 42 hoti hoti NNP 19613 7670 43 ho ho NNP 19613 7670 44 pôlôn pôlôn NNP 19613 7670 45 kai kai NNP 19613 7670 46 ho ho NNP 19613 7670 47 agorazôn agorazôn NNP 19613 7670 48 adelphoi adelphoi NNP 19613 7670 49 eisin eisin NNP 19613 7670 50 ; ; : 19613 7670 51 ei ei NNP 19613 7670 52 kakos kakos NNP 19613 7670 53 ôn ôn NNP 19613 7670 54 ho ho NNP 19613 7670 55 diabolos diabolos NNP 19613 7670 56 tô tô NNP 19613 7670 57 agathô agathô NNP 19613 7670 58 pepraken pepraken NNP 19613 7670 59 , , , 19613 7670 60 ouk ouk NNP 19613 7670 61 esti esti NNP 19613 7670 62 kakos kakos NNP 19613 7670 63 alla alla NNP 19613 7670 64 agathos agathos NNP 19613 7670 65 ; ; : 19613 7670 66 ho ho NNP 19613 7670 67 gar gar NNP 19613 7670 68 ap ap NNP 19613 7670 69 ' ' POS 19613 7670 70 archês archês NNP 19613 7670 71 phthonêsas phthonêsas NNP 19613 7670 72 tô tô NNP 19613 7670 73 anthrôpô anthrôpô NNP 19613 7670 74 , , , 19613 7670 75 nun nun NNP 19613 7670 76 ouk ouk NNP 19613 7670 77 eti eti NNP 19613 7670 78 hupo hupo NNP 19613 7670 79 phthonou phthonou NNP 19613 7670 80 agetai agetai NNP 19613 7670 81 , , , 19613 7670 82 tô tô NNP 19613 7670 83 agathô agathô NNP 19613 7670 84 tên tên NNP 19613 7670 85 nomên nomên NNP 19613 7670 86 paradous paradous NNP 19613 7670 87 . . . 19613 7671 1 estai estai NNP 19613 7671 2 oun oun NNP 19613 7671 3 dikaios dikaios NNP 19613 7671 4 ho ho NNP 19613 7671 5 tou tou NNP 19613 7671 6 phthonou phthonou NNP 19613 7671 7 kai kai NNP 19613 7671 8 pantos pantos NNP 19613 7671 9 kakou kakou NNP 19613 7671 10 pausamenos pausamenos NNP 19613 7671 11 . . . 19613 7672 1 autos auto NNS 19613 7672 2 goun goun NNP 19613 7672 3 ho ho NNP 19613 7672 4 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7672 5 heurisketai heurisketai NNP 19613 7672 6 pôlêsas pôlêsas NNP 19613 7672 7 ; ; : 19613 7672 8 mallon mallon NNP 19613 7672 9 de de NNP 19613 7672 10 hoi hoi NNP 19613 7672 11 hêmartêkotes hêmartêkote NNS 19613 7672 12 heautous heautous JJ 19613 7672 13 apêllotriôsan apêllotriôsan NNP 19613 7672 14 hoi hoi NNP 19613 7672 15 anthrôpoi anthrôpoi NNP 19613 7672 16 dia dia NNP 19613 7672 17 tas tas NNP 19613 7672 18 hamartias hamartias NNP 19613 7672 19 autôn autôn NNP 19613 7672 20 ; ; : 19613 7672 21 palin palin NNP 19613 7672 22 de de NNP 19613 7672 23 elutrôthêsan elutrôthêsan NNP 19613 7672 24 dia dia NNP 19613 7672 25 tên tên NNP 19613 7672 26 eusplagchnian eusplagchnian NNP 19613 7672 27 autou autou NNS 19613 7672 28 . . . 19613 7673 1 touto touto NNP 19613 7673 2 gar gar NNP 19613 7673 3 phêsin phêsin NNP 19613 7673 4 ho ho NNP 19613 7673 5 prophêtês prophêtês NN 19613 7673 6 ; ; : 19613 7673 7 Tais Tais NNP 19613 7673 8 hamartiais hamartiais NNP 19613 7673 9 humôn humôn NNP 19613 7673 10 eprathête eprathête NNP 19613 7673 11 kai kai NNP 19613 7673 12 tais tais NNP 19613 7673 13 anomiais anomiais NNP 19613 7673 14 exapesteila exapesteila NNP 19613 7673 15 tên tên NNP 19613 7673 16 mêtera mêtera NNP 19613 7673 17 humôn humôn NNP 19613 7673 18 . . . 19613 7674 1 Kai Kai NNP 19613 7674 2 allos allo NNS 19613 7674 3 palin palin NN 19613 7674 4 ; ; : 19613 7674 5 Dôrean Dôrean NNP 19613 7674 6 eprathête eprathête NNP 19613 7674 7 , , , 19613 7674 8 kai kai NNP 19613 7674 9 ou ou NNP 19613 7674 10 meta meta NNP 19613 7674 11 argyriou argyriou NNP 19613 7674 12 lutrôthêsesthe lutrôthêsesthe NNP 19613 7674 13 . . . 19613 7675 1 to to IN 19613 7675 2 , , , 19613 7675 3 oude oude NNP 19613 7675 4 meta meta JJ 19613 7675 5 argyriou argyriou NNP 19613 7675 6 ; ; : 19613 7675 7 dêlonoti dêlonoti NNP 19613 7675 8 , , , 19613 7675 9 tou tou NNP 19613 7675 10 haimatos haimatos NNP 19613 7675 11 tou tou NNP 19613 7675 12 Christou Christou NNP 19613 7675 13 . . . 19613 7676 1 touto touto NNP 19613 7676 2 gar gar NNP 19613 7676 3 phaskei phaskei NNP 19613 7676 4 ho ho NNP 19613 7676 5 prophêtês prophêtês NNP 19613 7676 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7676 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7676 8 Isaiah Isaiah NNP 19613 7676 9 , , , 19613 7676 10 LIII LIII NNP 19613 7676 11 . . . 19613 7677 1 5 5 CD 19613 7677 2 follows follow VBZ 19613 7677 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7677 4 . . . 19613 7678 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7678 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7678 3 : : : 19613 7678 4 Eikos Eikos NNP 19613 7678 5 de de NNP 19613 7678 6 hoti hoti NNP 19613 7678 7 kata kata NNP 19613 7678 8 se se NNP 19613 7678 9 epriato epriato NNP 19613 7678 10 dous dous JJ 19613 7678 11 heautou heautou NN 19613 7678 12 to to IN 19613 7678 13 haima haima VB 19613 7678 14 ; ; : 19613 7678 15 pôs pôs NNP 19613 7678 16 oun oun NNP 19613 7678 17 kai kai NNP 19613 7678 18 ek ek NNP 19613 7678 19 nekrôn nekrôn NNP 19613 7678 20 êgeireto êgeireto NNP 19613 7678 21 ; ; : 19613 7678 22 ei ei NNP 19613 7678 23 gar gar NNP 19613 7678 24 ho ho NNP 19613 7678 25 labôn labôn NNP 19613 7678 26 tên tên NNP 19613 7678 27 timên timên NNP 19613 7678 28 tôn tôn NNP 19613 7678 29 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 7678 30 , , , 19613 7678 31 to to IN 19613 7678 32 haima haima NNP 19613 7678 33 , , , 19613 7678 34 apedôken apedôken NNP 19613 7678 35 , , , 19613 7678 36 ouketi ouketi NNP 19613 7678 37 epôlêsen epôlêsen NNP 19613 7678 38 . . . 19613 7679 1 Ei Ei NNP 19613 7679 2 de de NNP 19613 7679 3 mê mê NNP 19613 7679 4 apedôke apedôke NNP 19613 7679 5 , , , 19613 7679 6 pôs pô VBD 19613 7679 7 anestê anestê NNP 19613 7679 8 Christos Christos NNP 19613 7679 9 , , , 19613 7679 10 ouketi ouketi IN 19613 7679 11 oun oun NN 19613 7679 12 to to IN 19613 7679 13 , , , 19613 7679 14 Exousian exousian JJ 19613 7679 15 echô echô NN 19613 7679 16 theinai theinai NNP 19613 7679 17 kai kai NNP 19613 7679 18 exousian exousian NNP 19613 7679 19 echô echô NNP 19613 7679 20 labein labein NNP 19613 7679 21 , , , 19613 7679 22 histatai histatai NNP 19613 7679 23 ; ; : 19613 7679 24 ho ho NNP 19613 7679 25 goun goun NNP 19613 7679 26 diabolos diabolos NNP 19613 7679 27 katechei katechei NNP 19613 7679 28 to to IN 19613 7679 29 haima haima NNP 19613 7679 30 tou tou NNP 19613 7679 31 Christou Christou NNP 19613 7679 32 anti anti NNP 19613 7679 33 tês tês NNP 19613 7679 34 timês timês NNP 19613 7679 35 tôn tôn NNP 19613 7679 36 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 7679 37 ; ; : 19613 7679 38 pollê pollê NN 19613 7679 39 blasphêmios blasphêmio NNS 19613 7679 40 anoia anoia VBP 19613 7679 41 ! ! . 19613 7680 1 Pheu Pheu NNP 19613 7680 2 tôn tôn NNP 19613 7680 3 kakôn kakôn NN 19613 7680 4 ! ! . 19613 7681 1 Apethanen Apethanen NNP 19613 7681 2 , , , 19613 7681 3 anestê anestê JJ 19613 7681 4 hôs hôs JJ 19613 7681 5 dunatos dunato NNS 19613 7681 6 ; ; : 19613 7681 7 ethêken ethêken VBN 19613 7681 8 ho ho NNP 19613 7681 9 elaben elaben NNP 19613 7681 10 ; ; : 19613 7681 11 autê autê NNP 19613 7681 12 poia poia NNP 19613 7681 13 prasis prasis NNP 19613 7681 14 ; ; : 19613 7681 15 tou tou NNP 19613 7681 16 prophêtou prophêtou NNP 19613 7681 17 legontos legontos NNP 19613 7681 18 ; ; : 19613 7681 19 Anastêtô Anastêtô NNP 19613 7681 20 ho ho NNP 19613 7681 21 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7681 22 kai kai NNP 19613 7681 23 diaskorpisthêtôsan diaskorpisthêtôsan NNP 19613 7681 24 hoi hoi NNP 19613 7681 25 echthroi echthroi NNP 19613 7681 26 autou autou NNP 19613 7681 27 , , , 19613 7681 28 Opou Opou NNP 19613 7681 29 anastasis anastasis NN 19613 7681 30 , , , 19613 7681 31 ekei ekei NNP 19613 7681 32 thanatos thanatos NNP 19613 7681 33 ! ! . 19613 7681 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7682 1 That that DT 19613 7682 2 is be VBZ 19613 7682 3 an an DT 19613 7682 4 argument argument NN 19613 7682 5 as as RB 19613 7682 6 acute acute JJ 19613 7682 7 as as IN 19613 7682 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7682 9 is be VBZ 19613 7682 10 true true JJ 19613 7682 11 and and CC 19613 7682 12 victorious victorious JJ 19613 7682 13 . . . 19613 7682 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7683 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7683 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7683 3 615 615 CD 19613 7683 4 : : : 19613 7683 5 See see VB 19613 7683 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7683 7 . . . 19613 7684 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7684 2 2 2 CD 19613 7684 3 , , , 19613 7684 4 3 3 CD 19613 7684 5 , , , 19613 7684 6 16 16 CD 19613 7684 7 . . . 19613 7685 1 3 3 CD 19613 7685 2 , , , 19613 7685 3 17 17 CD 19613 7685 4 - - SYM 19613 7685 5 4 4 CD 19613 7685 6 . . . 19613 7686 1 In in IN 19613 7686 2 III III NNP 19613 7686 3 . . . 19613 7687 1 16 16 CD 19613 7687 2 . . . 19613 7688 1 9 9 CD 19613 7688 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7688 3 says say VBZ 19613 7688 4 : : : 19613 7688 5 " " `` 19613 7688 6 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7688 7 per per IN 19613 7688 8 passionem passionem NN 19613 7688 9 reconciliavit reconciliavit NN 19613 7688 10 nos nos NNP 19613 7688 11 deo deo NNP 19613 7688 12 . . . 19613 7688 13 " " '' 19613 7689 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7689 2 is be VBZ 19613 7689 3 moreover moreover RB 19613 7689 4 very very RB 19613 7689 5 instructive instructive JJ 19613 7689 6 to to TO 19613 7689 7 compare compare VB 19613 7689 8 the the DT 19613 7689 9 way way NN 19613 7689 10 in in IN 19613 7689 11 which which WDT 19613 7689 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7689 13 worked work VBD 19613 7689 14 out out RP 19613 7689 15 the the DT 19613 7689 16 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 7689 17 theory theory NN 19613 7689 18 with with IN 19613 7689 19 the the DT 19613 7689 20 old old JJ 19613 7689 21 proof proof NN 19613 7689 22 from from IN 19613 7689 23 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 7689 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7689 25 " " `` 19613 7689 26 this this DT 19613 7689 27 happened happen VBD 19613 7689 28 that that IN 19613 7689 29 the the DT 19613 7689 30 Scripture scripture NN 19613 7689 31 might may MD 19613 7689 32 be be VB 19613 7689 33 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 7689 34 " " '' 19613 7689 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7689 36 . . . 19613 7690 1 Here here RB 19613 7690 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7690 3 certainly certainly RB 19613 7690 4 have have VBP 19613 7690 5 an an DT 19613 7690 6 advance advance NN 19613 7690 7 ; ; : 19613 7690 8 but but CC 19613 7690 9 at at IN 19613 7690 10 bottom bottom NN 19613 7690 11 the the DT 19613 7690 12 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 7690 13 theory theory NN 19613 7690 14 may may MD 19613 7690 15 also also RB 19613 7690 16 be be VB 19613 7690 17 conceived conceive VBN 19613 7690 18 as as IN 19613 7690 19 a a DT 19613 7690 20 modification modification NN 19613 7690 21 of of IN 19613 7690 22 that that DT 19613 7690 23 proof proof NN 19613 7690 24 . . . 19613 7690 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7691 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7691 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7691 3 616 616 CD 19613 7691 4 : : : 19613 7691 5 See see VB 19613 7691 6 , , , 19613 7691 7 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7691 8 , , , 19613 7691 9 IV IV NNP 19613 7691 10 . . . 19613 7692 1 5 5 CD 19613 7692 2 . . . 19613 7693 1 4 4 LS 19613 7693 2 : : : 19613 7693 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7693 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7693 5 : : : 19613 7693 6 prothumôs prothumôs JJ 19613 7693 7 Abraam Abraam NNP 19613 7693 8 ton ton NN 19613 7693 9 idion idion NN 19613 7693 10 monogenê monogenê NN 19613 7693 11 kai kai NNP 19613 7693 12 agapêton agapêton NNP 19613 7693 13 parachôrêsas parachôrêsas NNP 19613 7693 14 thusian thusian NNP 19613 7693 15 tô tô NNP 19613 7693 16 Theô Theô NNP 19613 7693 17 , , , 19613 7693 18 hina hina NNP 19613 7693 19 kai kai NNP 19613 7693 20 ho ho NNP 19613 7693 21 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7693 22 eudokêsê eudokêsê VB 19613 7693 23 huper huper NNP 19613 7693 24 tou tou NNP 19613 7693 25 spermatos spermatos NNP 19613 7693 26 autou autou NNP 19613 7693 27 pantos pantos NNP 19613 7693 28 ton ton NNP 19613 7693 29 idion idion NNP 19613 7693 30 monogenê monogenê NNP 19613 7693 31 kai kai NNP 19613 7693 32 agapêton agapêton NNP 19613 7693 33 huion huion NNP 19613 7693 34 thusian thusian NNP 19613 7693 35 paraschein paraschein NNP 19613 7693 36 eis eis NNP 19613 7693 37 lutrôsin lutrôsin NNP 19613 7693 38 hêmeteran hêmeteran NNP 19613 7693 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7693 40 . . . 19613 7693 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7694 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7694 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7694 3 617 617 CD 19613 7694 4 : : : 19613 7694 5 There there EX 19613 7694 6 are be VBP 19613 7694 7 not not RB 19613 7694 8 a a DT 19613 7694 9 few few JJ 19613 7694 10 passages passage NNS 19613 7694 11 where where WRB 19613 7694 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7694 13 said say VBD 19613 7694 14 that that IN 19613 7694 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7694 16 has have VBZ 19613 7694 17 annihilated annihilate VBN 19613 7694 18 sin sin NN 19613 7694 19 , , , 19613 7694 20 abolished abolish VBD 19613 7694 21 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7694 22 's 's POS 19613 7694 23 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 7694 24 , , , 19613 7694 25 and and CC 19613 7694 26 introduced introduce VBD 19613 7694 27 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 7694 28 through through IN 19613 7694 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7694 30 obedience obedience NN 19613 7694 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7694 32 III iii CD 19613 7694 33 . . . 19613 7695 1 18 18 CD 19613 7695 2 . . . 19613 7696 1 6 6 CD 19613 7696 2 , , , 19613 7696 3 7 7 CD 19613 7696 4 : : SYM 19613 7696 5 III iii CD 19613 7696 6 . . . 19613 7697 1 20 20 CD 19613 7697 2 . . . 19613 7698 1 2 2 LS 19613 7698 2 : : : 19613 7698 3 V. V. NNP 19613 7698 4 16 16 CD 19613 7698 5 - - SYM 19613 7698 6 21 21 CD 19613 7698 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7698 8 ; ; : 19613 7698 9 but but CC 19613 7698 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7698 11 only only RB 19613 7698 12 once once RB 19613 7698 13 tried try VBD 19613 7698 14 to to TO 19613 7698 15 explain explain VB 19613 7698 16 how how WRB 19613 7698 17 that that DT 19613 7698 18 is be VBZ 19613 7698 19 to to TO 19613 7698 20 be be VB 19613 7698 21 conceived conceive VBN 19613 7698 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7698 23 III iii CD 19613 7698 24 . . . 19613 7699 1 18 18 CD 19613 7699 2 . . . 19613 7700 1 7 7 LS 19613 7700 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7700 3 , , , 19613 7700 4 and and CC 19613 7700 5 then then RB 19613 7700 6 merely merely RB 19613 7700 7 reproduced reproduce VBD 19613 7700 8 Paul Paul NNP 19613 7700 9 's 's POS 19613 7700 10 thoughts thought NNS 19613 7700 11 . . . 19613 7700 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7701 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7701 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7701 3 618 618 CD 19613 7701 4 : : : 19613 7701 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7701 6 has have VBZ 19613 7701 7 no no DT 19613 7701 8 hesitation hesitation NN 19613 7701 9 in in IN 19613 7701 10 calling call VBG 19613 7701 11 the the DT 19613 7701 12 Christian Christian NNP 19613 7701 13 who who WP 19613 7701 14 has have VBZ 19613 7701 15 received receive VBN 19613 7701 16 the the DT 19613 7701 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7701 18 of of IN 19613 7701 19 God God NNP 19613 7701 20 the the DT 19613 7701 21 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7701 22 , , , 19613 7701 23 the the DT 19613 7701 24 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 7701 25 one one NN 19613 7701 26 , , , 19613 7701 27 and and CC 19613 7701 28 in in IN 19613 7701 29 representing represent VBG 19613 7701 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7701 31 , , , 19613 7701 32 in in IN 19613 7701 33 contrast contrast NN 19613 7701 34 to to IN 19613 7701 35 the the DT 19613 7701 36 false false JJ 19613 7701 37 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 7701 38 , , , 19613 7701 39 as as IN 19613 7701 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7701 41 who who WP 19613 7701 42 in in IN 19613 7701 43 truth truth NN 19613 7701 44 judges judge NNS 19613 7701 45 all all DT 19613 7701 46 men man NNS 19613 7701 47 , , , 19613 7701 48 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 7701 49 , , , 19613 7701 50 heathen heathen NNP 19613 7701 51 , , , 19613 7701 52 Marcionites Marcionites NNP 19613 7701 53 , , , 19613 7701 54 and and CC 19613 7701 55 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 7701 56 , , , 19613 7701 57 but but CC 19613 7701 58 is be VBZ 19613 7701 59 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7701 60 judged judge VBN 19613 7701 61 by by IN 19613 7701 62 no no DT 19613 7701 63 one one NN 19613 7701 64 ; ; : 19613 7701 65 see see VB 19613 7701 66 the the DT 19613 7701 67 great great JJ 19613 7701 68 disquisition disquisition NN 19613 7701 69 in in IN 19613 7701 70 IV IV NNP 19613 7701 71 . . . 19613 7702 1 33 33 CD 19613 7702 2 and and CC 19613 7702 3 V. V. NNP 19613 7702 4 9 9 CD 19613 7702 5 . . . 19613 7703 1 10 10 CD 19613 7703 2 . . . 19613 7704 1 This this DT 19613 7704 2 true true JJ 19613 7704 3 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 7704 4 , , , 19613 7704 5 however however RB 19613 7704 6 , , , 19613 7704 7 is be VBZ 19613 7704 8 only only RB 19613 7704 9 to to TO 19613 7704 10 be be VB 19613 7704 11 found find VBN 19613 7704 12 where where WRB 19613 7704 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7704 14 meet meet VBP 19613 7704 15 with with IN 19613 7704 16 right right JJ 19613 7704 17 faith faith NN 19613 7704 18 in in IN 19613 7704 19 God God NNP 19613 7704 20 the the DT 19613 7704 21 Creator Creator NNP 19613 7704 22 , , , 19613 7704 23 sure sure JJ 19613 7704 24 conviction conviction NN 19613 7704 25 with with IN 19613 7704 26 regard regard NN 19613 7704 27 to to IN 19613 7704 28 the the DT 19613 7704 29 God God NNP 19613 7704 30 - - HYPH 19613 7704 31 man man NN 19613 7704 32 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7704 33 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7704 34 , , , 19613 7704 35 true true JJ 19613 7704 36 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7704 37 as as IN 19613 7704 38 regards regard VBZ 19613 7704 39 the the DT 19613 7704 40 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7704 41 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7704 42 and and CC 19613 7704 43 the the DT 19613 7704 44 economy economy NN 19613 7704 45 of of IN 19613 7704 46 salvation salvation NN 19613 7704 47 , , , 19613 7704 48 the the DT 19613 7704 49 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 7704 50 doctrine doctrine NNP 19613 7704 51 , , , 19613 7704 52 the the DT 19613 7704 53 right right JJ 19613 7704 54 Church Church NNP 19613 7704 55 system system NN 19613 7704 56 in in IN 19613 7704 57 accordance accordance NN 19613 7704 58 with with IN 19613 7704 59 the the DT 19613 7704 60 episcopal episcopal JJ 19613 7704 61 succession succession NN 19613 7704 62 , , , 19613 7704 63 the the DT 19613 7704 64 intact intact JJ 19613 7704 65 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7704 66 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 7704 67 , , , 19613 7704 68 and and CC 19613 7704 69 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7704 70 uncorrupted uncorrupted JJ 19613 7704 71 text text NN 19613 7704 72 and and CC 19613 7704 73 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 7704 74 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7704 75 IV IV NNP 19613 7704 76 . . . 19613 7705 1 33 33 CD 19613 7705 2 . . . 19613 7706 1 7 7 CD 19613 7706 2 , , , 19613 7706 3 8) 8) CD 19613 7706 4 . . . 19613 7707 1 To to IN 19613 7707 2 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7707 3 the the DT 19613 7707 4 true true JJ 19613 7707 5 believer believer NN 19613 7707 6 is be VBZ 19613 7707 7 the the DT 19613 7707 8 real real JJ 19613 7707 9 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 7707 10 . . . 19613 7707 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7708 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7708 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7708 3 619 619 CD 19613 7708 4 : : : 19613 7708 5 See see VB 19613 7708 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7708 7 . . . 19613 7709 1 22 22 CD 19613 7709 2 . . . 19613 7710 1 In in IN 19613 7710 2 accordance accordance NN 19613 7710 3 with with IN 19613 7710 4 the the DT 19613 7710 5 recapitulation recapitulation NN 19613 7710 6 theory theory NN 19613 7710 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7710 8 must must MD 19613 7710 9 also also RB 19613 7710 10 have have VB 19613 7710 11 descended descend VBN 19613 7710 12 to to IN 19613 7710 13 the the DT 19613 7710 14 lower low JJR 19613 7710 15 world world NN 19613 7710 16 . . . 19613 7711 1 There there RB 19613 7711 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7711 3 announced announce VBD 19613 7711 4 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 7711 5 of of IN 19613 7711 6 sins sin NNS 19613 7711 7 to to IN 19613 7711 8 the the DT 19613 7711 9 righteous righteous JJ 19613 7711 10 , , , 19613 7711 11 the the DT 19613 7711 12 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 7711 13 and and CC 19613 7711 14 prophets prophet NNS 19613 7711 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7711 16 IV IV NNP 19613 7711 17 . . . 19613 7712 1 27 27 CD 19613 7712 2 . . . 19613 7713 1 2 2 LS 19613 7713 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7713 3 . . . 19613 7714 1 For for IN 19613 7714 2 this this DT 19613 7714 3 , , , 19613 7714 4 however however RB 19613 7714 5 , , , 19613 7714 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7714 7 was be VBD 19613 7714 8 not not RB 19613 7714 9 able able JJ 19613 7714 10 to to TO 19613 7714 11 appeal appeal VB 19613 7714 12 to to IN 19613 7714 13 Scripture scripture NN 19613 7714 14 texts text NNS 19613 7714 15 , , , 19613 7714 16 but but CC 19613 7714 17 only only RB 19613 7714 18 to to IN 19613 7714 19 statements statement NNS 19613 7714 20 of of IN 19613 7714 21 a a DT 19613 7714 22 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 7714 23 . . . 19613 7715 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7715 2 is be VBZ 19613 7715 3 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 7715 4 expressly expressly RB 19613 7715 5 asserted assert VBN 19613 7715 6 , , , 19613 7715 7 on on IN 19613 7715 8 the the DT 19613 7715 9 authority authority NN 19613 7715 10 of of IN 19613 7715 11 Rom Rom NNP 19613 7715 12 . . . 19613 7716 1 III iii CD 19613 7716 2 . . . 19613 7717 1 23 23 CD 19613 7717 2 , , , 19613 7717 3 that that IN 19613 7717 4 these these DT 19613 7717 5 pre pre JJ 19613 7717 6 - - JJ 19613 7717 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 7717 8 just just JJ 19613 7717 9 men man NNS 19613 7717 10 also also RB 19613 7717 11 could could MD 19613 7717 12 only only RB 19613 7717 13 receive receive VB 19613 7717 14 justification justification NN 19613 7717 15 and and CC 19613 7717 16 the the DT 19613 7717 17 light light NN 19613 7717 18 of of IN 19613 7717 19 salvation salvation NN 19613 7717 20 through through IN 19613 7717 21 the the DT 19613 7717 22 arrival arrival NN 19613 7717 23 of of IN 19613 7717 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7717 25 among among IN 19613 7717 26 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7717 27 . . . 19613 7717 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7718 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7718 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7718 3 620 620 CD 19613 7718 4 : : : 19613 7718 5 See see VB 19613 7718 6 III iii CD 19613 7718 7 . . . 19613 7719 1 16 16 CD 19613 7719 2 . . . 19613 7720 1 6 6 CD 19613 7720 2 : : : 19613 7720 3 " " `` 19613 7720 4 In in IN 19613 7720 5 omnibus omnibus JJ 19613 7720 6 autem autem NN 19613 7720 7 est est NNP 19613 7720 8 et et NNP 19613 7720 9 homo homo NNP 19613 7720 10 plasmatio plasmatio NNP 19613 7720 11 dei dei NNP 19613 7720 12 ; ; : 19613 7720 13 et et NNP 19613 7720 14 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7720 15 ergo ergo NNP 19613 7720 16 in in IN 19613 7720 17 semetipsum semetipsum NNP 19613 7720 18 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 7720 19 est est NNP 19613 7720 20 , , , 19613 7720 21 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 7720 22 visibilis visibilis NNP 19613 7720 23 factus factus NN 19613 7720 24 , , , 19613 7720 25 et et NNP 19613 7720 26 incomprehensibilis incomprehensibilis NNP 19613 7720 27 factus factus NNP 19613 7720 28 comprehensibilis comprehensibilis NNP 19613 7720 29 et et NNP 19613 7720 30 impassibilis impassibilis NNP 19613 7720 31 passibilis passibilis NNP 19613 7720 32 , , , 19613 7720 33 et et NNP 19613 7720 34 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7720 35 homo homo NNP 19613 7720 36 , , , 19613 7720 37 universa universa JJ 19613 7720 38 in in IN 19613 7720 39 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 7720 40 recapitulans recapitulan NNS 19613 7720 41 , , , 19613 7720 42 uti uti NNP 19613 7720 43 sicut sicut NN 19613 7720 44 in in IN 19613 7720 45 supercaelestibus supercaelestibus NNP 19613 7720 46 et et NNP 19613 7720 47 spiritalibus spiritalibus NNP 19613 7720 48 et et NNP 19613 7720 49 invisibilibus invisibilibus NNP 19613 7720 50 princeps princep NNS 19613 7720 51 est est VBD 19613 7720 52 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7720 53 dei dei NNP 19613 7720 54 , , , 19613 7720 55 sic sic NNP 19613 7720 56 et et NNP 19613 7720 57 in in IN 19613 7720 58 visibilibus visibilibus NNP 19613 7720 59 et et NNP 19613 7720 60 corporalibus corporalibus NNP 19613 7720 61 principatum principatum NNP 19613 7720 62 habeat habeat NNP 19613 7720 63 , , , 19613 7720 64 in in IN 19613 7720 65 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 7720 66 primatum primatum NN 19613 7720 67 assumens assumens NNP 19613 7720 68 et et NNP 19613 7720 69 apponens apponen VBZ 19613 7720 70 semetipsum semetipsum VBP 19613 7720 71 caput caput NN 19613 7720 72 ecclesiæ ecclesiæ NN 19613 7720 73 , , , 19613 7720 74 universa universa JJ 19613 7720 75 attrahat attrahat NN 19613 7720 76 ad ad NN 19613 7720 77 semetipsum semetipsum NN 19613 7720 78 apto apto NN 19613 7720 79 in in IN 19613 7720 80 tempore tempore NN 19613 7720 81 . . . 19613 7720 82 " " '' 19613 7720 83 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7721 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7721 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7721 3 621 621 CD 19613 7721 4 : : : 19613 7721 5 There there EX 19613 7721 6 are be VBP 19613 7721 7 innumerable innumerable JJ 19613 7721 8 passages passage NNS 19613 7721 9 where where WRB 19613 7721 10 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7721 11 has have VBZ 19613 7721 12 urged urge VBN 19613 7721 13 that that IN 19613 7721 14 the the DT 19613 7721 15 whole whole JJ 19613 7721 16 work work NN 19613 7721 17 of of IN 19613 7721 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7721 19 is be VBZ 19613 7721 20 comprised comprise VBN 19613 7721 21 in in IN 19613 7721 22 the the DT 19613 7721 23 death death NN 19613 7721 24 on on IN 19613 7721 25 the the DT 19613 7721 26 cross cross NN 19613 7721 27 , , , 19613 7721 28 and and CC 19613 7721 29 indeed indeed RB 19613 7721 30 that that IN 19613 7721 31 this this DT 19613 7721 32 death death NN 19613 7721 33 was be VBD 19613 7721 34 the the DT 19613 7721 35 aim aim NN 19613 7721 36 of of IN 19613 7721 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7721 38 's 's POS 19613 7721 39 mission mission NN 19613 7721 40 . . . 19613 7722 1 See see VB 19613 7722 2 , , , 19613 7722 3 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7722 4 , , , 19613 7722 5 de de FW 19613 7722 6 pat pat NNP 19613 7722 7 . . . 19613 7723 1 3 3 LS 19613 7723 2 : : : 19613 7723 3 " " `` 19613 7723 4 Taceo Taceo NNP 19613 7723 5 quod quod NN 19613 7723 6 figitur figitur NN 19613 7723 7 ; ; : 19613 7723 8 in in IN 19613 7723 9 hoc hoc FW 19613 7723 10 enim enim NNP 19613 7723 11 venerat venerat NNP 19613 7723 12 " " '' 19613 7723 13 ; ; : 19613 7723 14 de de NNP 19613 7723 15 bapt bapt NNP 19613 7723 16 . . . 19613 7724 1 II ii CD 19613 7724 2 : : : 19613 7724 3 " " `` 19613 7724 4 Mors mor NNS 19613 7724 5 nostra nostra NNP 19613 7724 6 dissolvi dissolvi NN 19613 7724 7 non non AFX 19613 7724 8 potuit potuit NN 19613 7724 9 , , , 19613 7724 10 nisi nisi NNP 19613 7724 11 domini domini NNP 19613 7724 12 passione passione NNP 19613 7724 13 , , , 19613 7724 14 nee nee NNP 19613 7724 15 vita vita NNP 19613 7724 16 restitui restitui VBZ 19613 7724 17 sine sine NNP 19613 7724 18 resurrectione resurrectione NN 19613 7724 19 ipsius ipsius NNP 19613 7724 20 " " '' 19613 7724 21 ; ; : 19613 7724 22 adv adv NNP 19613 7724 23 . . . 19613 7725 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7725 2 . . . 19613 7726 1 III iii CD 19613 7726 2 . . . 19613 7727 1 8 8 LS 19613 7727 2 : : : 19613 7727 3 " " `` 19613 7727 4 Si Si NNP 19613 7727 5 mendacium mendacium NN 19613 7727 6 deprehenditur deprehenditur NNP 19613 7727 7 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7727 8 caro caro NNP 19613 7727 9 ... ... NFP 19613 7727 10 nec nec NN 19613 7727 11 passiones passione VBZ 19613 7727 12 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7727 13 fidem fidem NN 19613 7727 14 merebuntur merebuntur NN 19613 7727 15 . . . 19613 7728 1 Eversum eversum NN 19613 7728 2 est est NNP 19613 7728 3 igitur igitur NN 19613 7728 4 totum totum NN 19613 7728 5 dei dei NNP 19613 7728 6 opus opus NNP 19613 7728 7 . . . 19613 7729 1 Totum Totum NNP 19613 7729 2 Christiani Christiani NNP 19613 7729 3 nominis nominis NN 19613 7729 4 et et FW 19613 7729 5 pondus pondus NNP 19613 7729 6 et et NNP 19613 7729 7 fructus fructus NNP 19613 7729 8 , , , 19613 7729 9 mors mor VBZ 19613 7729 10 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7729 11 , , , 19613 7729 12 negatur negatur NNP 19613 7729 13 , , , 19613 7729 14 quam quam NNP 19613 7729 15 iam iam NNP 19613 7729 16 impresse impresse NNP 19613 7729 17 apostolus apostolus NNP 19613 7729 18 demendat demendat NNP 19613 7729 19 , , , 19613 7729 20 utique utique NNP 19613 7729 21 veram veram NNP 19613 7729 22 , , , 19613 7729 23 summum summum NNP 19613 7729 24 eam eam NNP 19613 7729 25 fundamentum fundamentum NNP 19613 7729 26 evangelii evangelii NNP 19613 7729 27 constituens constituen NNS 19613 7729 28 et et NNP 19613 7729 29 salutis salutis NNP 19613 7729 30 nostræ nostræ NNP 19613 7729 31 et et NNP 19613 7729 32 prædictionis prædictionis FW 19613 7729 33 suae suae JJ 19613 7729 34 , , , 19613 7729 35 " " '' 19613 7729 36 1 1 CD 19613 7729 37 Cor Cor NNP 19613 7729 38 . . . 19613 7730 1 XV XV NNP 19613 7730 2 . . . 19613 7731 1 3 3 CD 19613 7731 2 , , , 19613 7731 3 4 4 CD 19613 7731 4 ; ; : 19613 7731 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7731 6 follows follow VBZ 19613 7731 7 Paul Paul NNP 19613 7731 8 here here RB 19613 7731 9 . . . 19613 7732 1 But but CC 19613 7732 2 on on IN 19613 7732 3 the the DT 19613 7732 4 other other JJ 19613 7732 5 hand hand NN 19613 7732 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7732 7 has have VBZ 19613 7732 8 also also RB 19613 7732 9 adopted adopt VBN 19613 7732 10 from from IN 19613 7732 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7732 12 the the DT 19613 7732 13 mystical mystical JJ 19613 7732 14 conception conception NN 19613 7732 15 of of IN 19613 7732 16 redemption redemption NN 19613 7732 17 -- -- : 19613 7732 18 the the DT 19613 7732 19 constitution constitution NN 19613 7732 20 of of IN 19613 7732 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7732 22 is be VBZ 19613 7732 23 the the DT 19613 7732 24 redemption redemption NN 19613 7732 25 -- -- : 19613 7732 26 though though RB 19613 7732 27 with with IN 19613 7732 28 a a DT 19613 7732 29 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 19613 7732 30 explanation explanation NN 19613 7732 31 . . . 19613 7733 1 See see VB 19613 7733 2 adv adv NN 19613 7733 3 . . . 19613 7734 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7734 2 . . . 19613 7735 1 II ii CD 19613 7735 2 . . . 19613 7736 1 27 27 CD 19613 7736 2 : : : 19613 7736 3 " " `` 19613 7736 4 filius filius NNP 19613 7736 5 miscens miscens NNP 19613 7736 6 in in IN 19613 7736 7 semetipso semetipso NNP 19613 7736 8 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7736 9 et et NNP 19613 7736 10 deum deum NNP 19613 7736 11 , , , 19613 7736 12 ut ut UH 19613 7736 13 tantum tantum NNP 19613 7736 14 homini homini NNP 19613 7736 15 conferat conferat NNP 19613 7736 16 , , , 19613 7736 17 quantum quantum NNP 19613 7736 18 deo deo NNP 19613 7736 19 detrahit detrahit NN 19613 7736 20 . . . 19613 7737 1 Conversabatur conversabatur JJ 19613 7737 2 deus deus NN 19613 7737 3 , , , 19613 7737 4 ut ut NNP 19613 7737 5 homo homo NNP 19613 7737 6 divina divina NNP 19613 7737 7 agere agere NNP 19613 7737 8 doceretur doceretur NNP 19613 7737 9 . . . 19613 7738 1 Ex Ex NNP 19613 7738 2 æquo æquo NNP 19613 7738 3 agebat agebat NNP 19613 7738 4 deus deus NNP 19613 7738 5 cum cum NNP 19613 7738 6 homine homine NNP 19613 7738 7 , , , 19613 7738 8 ut ut NNP 19613 7738 9 homo homo NNP 19613 7738 10 ex ex NNP 19613 7738 11 æquo æquo NNP 19613 7738 12 agere agere NNP 19613 7738 13 cum cum NNP 19613 7738 14 deo deo NNP 19613 7738 15 posset posset JJ 19613 7738 16 . . . 19613 7738 17 " " '' 19613 7739 1 Here here RB 19613 7739 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 7739 3 the the DT 19613 7739 4 meaning meaning NN 19613 7739 5 of of IN 19613 7739 6 the the DT 19613 7739 7 divine divine JJ 19613 7739 8 manhood manhood NN 19613 7739 9 of of IN 19613 7739 10 the the DT 19613 7739 11 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 7739 12 virtually virtually RB 19613 7739 13 amounts amount VBZ 19613 7739 14 to to IN 19613 7739 15 divine divine JJ 19613 7739 16 teaching teaching NN 19613 7739 17 . . . 19613 7740 1 In in IN 19613 7740 2 de de NNP 19613 7740 3 resurr resurr NNP 19613 7740 4 . . . 19613 7741 1 63 63 CD 19613 7741 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7741 3 is be VBZ 19613 7741 4 called call VBN 19613 7741 5 " " `` 19613 7741 6 fidelissimus fidelissimus NNP 19613 7741 7 sequester sequester NNP 19613 7741 8 dei dei NNP 19613 7741 9 et et NNP 19613 7741 10 hominum hominum NNP 19613 7741 11 , , , 19613 7741 12 qui qui NNP 19613 7741 13 et et NNP 19613 7741 14 homini homini NNP 19613 7741 15 deum deum NNP 19613 7741 16 et et NNP 19613 7741 17 hominem hominem NNP 19613 7741 18 deo deo NNP 19613 7741 19 reddet reddet NNP 19613 7741 20 . . . 19613 7741 21 " " '' 19613 7742 1 Note note VB 19613 7742 2 the the DT 19613 7742 3 future future JJ 19613 7742 4 tense tense NN 19613 7742 5 . . . 19613 7743 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7743 2 is be VBZ 19613 7743 3 the the DT 19613 7743 4 same same JJ 19613 7743 5 with with IN 19613 7743 6 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7743 7 who who WP 19613 7743 8 in in IN 19613 7743 9 Philos Philos NNP 19613 7743 10 . . . 19613 7744 1 X. X. NNP 19613 7745 1 34 34 CD 19613 7745 2 represents represent VBZ 19613 7745 3 the the DT 19613 7745 4 deification deification NN 19613 7745 5 of of IN 19613 7745 6 men man NNS 19613 7745 7 as as IN 19613 7745 8 the the DT 19613 7745 9 aim aim NN 19613 7745 10 of of IN 19613 7745 11 redemption redemption NN 19613 7745 12 , , , 19613 7745 13 but but CC 19613 7745 14 at at IN 19613 7745 15 the the DT 19613 7745 16 same same JJ 19613 7745 17 time time NN 19613 7745 18 merely merely RB 19613 7745 19 requires require VBZ 19613 7745 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7745 21 as as IN 19613 7745 22 the the DT 19613 7745 23 lawgiver lawgiver NN 19613 7745 24 and and CC 19613 7745 25 teacher teacher NN 19613 7745 26 : : : 19613 7745 27 " " `` 19613 7745 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7745 29 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7745 30 : : : 19613 7745 31 Kai Kai NNP 19613 7745 32 tauta tauta NN 19613 7745 33 men man NNS 19613 7745 34 ekpheuxê ekpheuxê VBP 19613 7745 35 Theon Theon NNP 19613 7745 36 ton ton NN 19613 7745 37 onta onta NNP 19613 7745 38 didachtheis didachtheis NNP 19613 7745 39 , , , 19613 7745 40 exeis exeis NNP 19613 7745 41 de de NNP 19613 7745 42 athanaton athanaton NNP 19613 7745 43 to to TO 19613 7745 44 sôma sôma VB 19613 7745 45 kai kai NNP 19613 7745 46 aphtharton aphtharton NNP 19613 7745 47 hama hama NNP 19613 7745 48 psychê psychê NNP 19613 7745 49 , , , 19613 7745 50 basileian basileian NNP 19613 7745 51 ouranôn ouranôn NNP 19613 7745 52 apolêpsê apolêpsê NNP 19613 7745 53 , , , 19613 7745 54 ho ho NNP 19613 7745 55 en en FW 19613 7745 56 gê gê NNP 19613 7745 57 bious bious NNP 19613 7745 58 kai kai NNP 19613 7745 59 epouranion epouranion NN 19613 7745 60 basilea basilea NN 19613 7745 61 epignous epignous JJ 19613 7745 62 , , , 19613 7745 63 esê esê NNP 19613 7745 64 de de NNP 19613 7745 65 homilêtês homilêtês NNP 19613 7745 66 Theou Theou NNP 19613 7745 67 kai kai NNP 19613 7745 68 sygklêronomos sygklêronomo NNS 19613 7745 69 Christou Christou NNP 19613 7745 70 , , , 19613 7745 71 ouk ouk NNP 19613 7745 72 epithymiais epithymiais NNP 19613 7745 73 ê ê NNP 19613 7745 74 pathesi pathesi NN 19613 7745 75 kai kai NNP 19613 7745 76 nosois nosois NNP 19613 7745 77 douloumenos douloumenos NNP 19613 7745 78 . . . 19613 7746 1 Gegonas Gegonas NNP 19613 7746 2 gar gar VBP 19613 7746 3 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7746 4 hosa hosa NNP 19613 7746 5 gar gar NNP 19613 7746 6 hupemeinas hupemeinas NNP 19613 7746 7 pathê pathê NNP 19613 7746 8 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 7746 9 ôn ôn NNP 19613 7746 10 , , , 19613 7746 11 tauta tauta NN 19613 7746 12 edidou edidou NNP 19613 7746 13 , , , 19613 7746 14 hoti hoti NNP 19613 7746 15 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 7746 16 eis eis NNP 19613 7746 17 , , , 19613 7746 18 hosa hosa NNP 19613 7746 19 de de NNP 19613 7746 20 parakolouthei parakolouthei NNP 19613 7746 21 Theô Theô NNP 19613 7746 22 , , , 19613 7746 23 tauta tauta VB 19613 7746 24 parechein parechein NN 19613 7746 25 epêngeltai epêngeltai NN 19613 7746 26 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7746 27 , , , 19613 7746 28 hoti hoti NNP 19613 7746 29 etheopoiêthês etheopoiêthês NNP 19613 7746 30 , , , 19613 7746 31 athanatos athanatos VBP 19613 7746 32 gennêtheis gennêtheis JJ 19613 7746 33 . . . 19613 7747 1 Toutesti Toutesti NNP 19613 7747 2 to to IN 19613 7747 3 Gnôthi Gnôthi NNP 19613 7747 4 seauton seauton NN 19613 7747 5 , , , 19613 7747 6 epignous epignous JJ 19613 7747 7 tou tou NNP 19613 7747 8 pepoiêkota pepoiêkota NNP 19613 7747 9 Thoen Thoen NNP 19613 7747 10 . . . 19613 7748 1 To to TO 19613 7748 2 gar gar VB 19613 7748 3 epignônai epignônai NNP 19613 7748 4 heauton heauton NNP 19613 7748 5 epignôsthênai epignôsthênai NNP 19613 7748 6 symbebêke symbebêke NNP 19613 7748 7 tô tô IN 19613 7748 8 kaloumenô kaloumenô NNP 19613 7748 9 hup hup NNP 19613 7748 10 ' ' '' 19613 7748 11 autou autou NNS 19613 7748 12 . . . 19613 7749 1 Mê Mê NNP 19613 7749 2 philechthrêsête philechthrêsête NNP 19613 7749 3 toinun toinun NNP 19613 7749 4 heautois heautois NNP 19613 7749 5 , , , 19613 7749 6 anthrôpoi anthrôpoi NNP 19613 7749 7 , , , 19613 7749 8 mêde mêde NNP 19613 7749 9 to to IN 19613 7749 10 palindromein palindromein NN 19613 7749 11 distasête distasête NNP 19613 7749 12 . . . 19613 7750 1 Christos Christos NNP 19613 7750 2 gar gar NNP 19613 7750 3 estin estin NNP 19613 7750 4 ho ho NNP 19613 7750 5 kata kata NNP 19613 7750 6 pantôn pantôn NNP 19613 7750 7 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7750 8 , , , 19613 7750 9 os os NNP 19613 7750 10 tên tên NNP 19613 7750 11 hamartian hamartian JJ 19613 7750 12 ex ex NNP 19613 7750 13 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 7750 14 apoplunein apoplunein NNP 19613 7750 15 proetaxe proetaxe NNP 19613 7750 16 , , , 19613 7750 17 neon neon NNP 19613 7750 18 ton ton NN 19613 7750 19 palaion palaion NN 19613 7750 20 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 7750 21 apotelôn apotelôn NNP 19613 7750 22 , , , 19613 7750 23 eikona eikona NNP 19613 7750 24 touton touton NNP 19613 7750 25 kalesas kalesas NNP 19613 7750 26 ap ap NNP 19613 7750 27 ' ' POS 19613 7750 28 archês archês NN 19613 7750 29 , , , 19613 7750 30 dia dia NNP 19613 7750 31 tupou tupou NNP 19613 7750 32 tên tên NNP 19613 7750 33 eis eis NNP 19613 7750 34 se se NNP 19613 7750 35 epideiknumenos epideiknumenos NNP 19613 7750 36 storgên storgên NNP 19613 7750 37 , , , 19613 7750 38 ou ou NNP 19613 7750 39 prostagmasin prostagmasin NNP 19613 7750 40 hupakousas hupakousas NNP 19613 7750 41 semnois semnois NNP 19613 7750 42 , , , 19613 7750 43 kai kai NNP 19613 7750 44 agathou agathou NNP 19613 7750 45 agathos agathos NNP 19613 7750 46 genomenos genomenos NNP 19613 7750 47 mimêtês mimêtês NNP 19613 7750 48 , , , 19613 7750 49 esê esê NNP 19613 7750 50 homoios homoios NNP 19613 7750 51 hup hup NNP 19613 7750 52 ' ' POS 19613 7750 53 autou autou NNP 19613 7750 54 timêtheis timêtheis NNP 19613 7750 55 . . . 19613 7751 1 Ou ou DT 19613 7751 2 gar gar NN 19613 7751 3 ptôcheuei ptôcheuei NN 19613 7751 4 Theos Theos NNP 19613 7751 5 kai kai NNP 19613 7751 6 se se NNP 19613 7751 7 Theon Theon NNP 19613 7751 8 poiêsas poiêsas NNP 19613 7751 9 eis eis NNP 19613 7751 10 doxan doxan VBD 19613 7751 11 autou autou NNP 19613 7751 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7751 13 . . . 19613 7751 14 " " '' 19613 7752 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7752 2 is be VBZ 19613 7752 3 clear clear JJ 19613 7752 4 that that IN 19613 7752 5 with with IN 19613 7752 6 a a DT 19613 7752 7 conception conception NN 19613 7752 8 like like IN 19613 7752 9 this this DT 19613 7752 10 , , , 19613 7752 11 which which WDT 19613 7752 12 became become VBD 19613 7752 13 prevalent prevalent JJ 19613 7752 14 in in IN 19613 7752 15 the the DT 19613 7752 16 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 7752 17 century century NN 19613 7752 18 , , , 19613 7752 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7752 20 's 's POS 19613 7752 21 death death NN 19613 7752 22 on on IN 19613 7752 23 the the DT 19613 7752 24 cross cross NN 19613 7752 25 could could MD 19613 7752 26 have have VB 19613 7752 27 no no DT 19613 7752 28 proper proper JJ 19613 7752 29 significance significance NN 19613 7752 30 ; ; : 19613 7752 31 nothing nothing NN 19613 7752 32 but but IN 19613 7752 33 the the DT 19613 7752 34 Holy Holy NNP 19613 7752 35 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 7752 36 preserved preserve VBD 19613 7752 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7752 38 importance importance NN 19613 7752 39 . . . 19613 7753 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7753 2 may may MD 19613 7753 3 further further RB 19613 7753 4 remark remark VB 19613 7753 5 that that IN 19613 7753 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7753 7 used use VBD 19613 7753 8 the the DT 19613 7753 9 expression expression NN 19613 7753 10 " " `` 19613 7753 11 satisfacere satisfacere WRB 19613 7753 12 deo deo NN 19613 7753 13 " " '' 19613 7753 14 about about IN 19613 7753 15 men man NNS 19613 7753 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7753 17 see see VB 19613 7753 18 , , , 19613 7753 19 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7753 20 , , , 19613 7753 21 de de NNP 19613 7753 22 bapt bapt NNP 19613 7753 23 . . . 19613 7754 1 20 20 CD 19613 7754 2 ; ; : 19613 7754 3 de de FW 19613 7754 4 pud pud NNP 19613 7754 5 . . . 19613 7755 1 9 9 LS 19613 7755 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7755 3 , , , 19613 7755 4 but but CC 19613 7755 5 , , , 19613 7755 6 so so RB 19613 7755 7 far far RB 19613 7755 8 as as IN 19613 7755 9 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7755 10 know know VBP 19613 7755 11 , , , 19613 7755 12 not not RB 19613 7755 13 about about IN 19613 7755 14 the the DT 19613 7755 15 work work NN 19613 7755 16 of of IN 19613 7755 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7755 18 . . . 19613 7756 1 This this DT 19613 7756 2 expression expression NN 19613 7756 3 is be VBZ 19613 7756 4 very very RB 19613 7756 5 frequent frequent JJ 19613 7756 6 in in IN 19613 7756 7 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 7756 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7756 9 for for IN 19613 7756 10 penances penance NNS 19613 7756 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7756 12 , , , 19613 7756 13 and and CC 19613 7756 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7756 15 also also RB 19613 7756 16 uses use VBZ 19613 7756 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7756 18 about about IN 19613 7756 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7756 20 . . . 19613 7757 1 In in IN 19613 7757 2 both both DT 19613 7757 3 writers writer NNS 19613 7757 4 , , , 19613 7757 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 7757 6 , , , 19613 7757 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7757 8 find find VBP 19613 7757 9 " " `` 19613 7757 10 meritum meritum NN 19613 7757 11 " " '' 19613 7757 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7757 13 _ _ NNP 19613 7757 14 e.g. e.g. NNP 19613 7757 15 _ _ NNP 19613 7757 16 , , , 19613 7757 17 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 7757 18 . . . 19613 7758 1 6 6 LS 19613 7758 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7758 3 and and CC 19613 7758 4 " " `` 19613 7758 5 promereri promereri NNP 19613 7758 6 deum deum NNP 19613 7758 7 " " '' 19613 7758 8 . . . 19613 7759 1 With with IN 19613 7759 2 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7759 3 and and CC 19613 7759 4 with with IN 19613 7759 5 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 7759 6 the the DT 19613 7759 7 idea idea NN 19613 7759 8 of of IN 19613 7759 9 " " `` 19613 7759 10 culpa culpa NN 19613 7759 11 " " '' 19613 7759 12 is be VBZ 19613 7759 13 also also RB 19613 7759 14 more more RBR 19613 7759 15 strongly strongly RB 19613 7759 16 emphasised emphasised JJ 19613 7759 17 than than IN 19613 7759 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7759 19 is be VBZ 19613 7759 20 by by IN 19613 7759 21 the the DT 19613 7759 22 Eastern eastern JJ 19613 7759 23 theologians theologian NNS 19613 7759 24 . . . 19613 7760 1 Cf cf NN 19613 7760 2 . . . 19613 7761 1 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 7761 2 de de NNP 19613 7761 3 trin trin NNP 19613 7761 4 . . . 19613 7762 1 10 10 CD 19613 7762 2 : : : 19613 7762 3 " " `` 19613 7762 4 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 7762 5 cum cum NNP 19613 7762 6 caro caro NNP 19613 7762 7 et et NNP 19613 7762 8 sanguis sanguis NNP 19613 7762 9 non non AFX 19613 7762 10 obtinere obtinere NNP 19613 7762 11 regnum regnum NNP 19613 7762 12 dei dei NNP 19613 7762 13 scribitur scribitur NNP 19613 7762 14 , , , 19613 7762 15 non non JJ 19613 7762 16 carnis carnis NNP 19613 7762 17 substantia substantia NNP 19613 7762 18 damnata damnata NNP 19613 7762 19 est est NNP 19613 7762 20 , , , 19613 7762 21 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7762 22 divinis divinis NNP 19613 7762 23 manibus manibus NNP 19613 7762 24 ne ne NNP 19613 7762 25 periret periret NNP 19613 7762 26 , , , 19613 7762 27 exstructa exstructa NNP 19613 7762 28 est est NNP 19613 7762 29 , , , 19613 7762 30 sed sed NNP 19613 7762 31 sola sola NNP 19613 7762 32 carnis carnis NNP 19613 7762 33 _ _ NNP 19613 7762 34 culpa culpa NN 19613 7762 35 _ _ NNP 19613 7762 36 merito merito NNP 19613 7762 37 reprehensa reprehensa NN 19613 7762 38 est est NNP 19613 7762 39 . . . 19613 7762 40 " " '' 19613 7763 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7763 2 de de NNP 19613 7763 3 bapt bapt NNP 19613 7763 4 . . . 19613 7764 1 5 5 CD 19613 7764 2 says say VBZ 19613 7764 3 : : : 19613 7764 4 " " `` 19613 7764 5 Exempto Exempto NNP 19613 7764 6 reatu reatu NNP 19613 7764 7 eximitur eximitur NNP 19613 7764 8 et et NNP 19613 7764 9 poena poena NNP 19613 7764 10 . . . 19613 7764 11 " " '' 19613 7765 1 On on IN 19613 7765 2 the the DT 19613 7765 3 other other JJ 19613 7765 4 hand hand NN 19613 7765 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7765 6 speaks speak VBZ 19613 7765 7 of of IN 19613 7765 8 fasting fasting NN 19613 7765 9 as as IN 19613 7765 10 " " `` 19613 7765 11 officia officia NNP 19613 7765 12 humiliationis humiliationis NNP 19613 7765 13 " " '' 19613 7765 14 , , , 19613 7765 15 through through IN 19613 7765 16 which which WDT 19613 7765 17 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7765 18 can can MD 19613 7765 19 " " `` 19613 7765 20 inlicere inlicere VB 19613 7765 21 " " '' 19613 7765 22 God God NNP 19613 7765 23 . . . 19613 7766 1 Among among IN 19613 7766 2 these these DT 19613 7766 3 Western western JJ 19613 7766 4 writers writer NNS 19613 7766 5 the the DT 19613 7766 6 thought thought NN 19613 7766 7 that that WDT 19613 7766 8 God God NNP 19613 7766 9 's 's POS 19613 7766 10 anger anger NN 19613 7766 11 must must MD 19613 7766 12 be be VB 19613 7766 13 appeased appease VBN 19613 7766 14 both both CC 19613 7766 15 by by IN 19613 7766 16 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 19613 7766 17 and and CC 19613 7766 18 corresponding correspond VBG 19613 7766 19 acts act NNS 19613 7766 20 appears appear VBZ 19613 7766 21 in in IN 19613 7766 22 a a DT 19613 7766 23 much much RB 19613 7766 24 more more RBR 19613 7766 25 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 7766 26 form form NN 19613 7766 27 than than IN 19613 7766 28 in in IN 19613 7766 29 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7766 30 . . . 19613 7767 1 This this DT 19613 7767 2 is be VBZ 19613 7767 3 explained explain VBN 19613 7767 4 by by IN 19613 7767 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7767 6 ideas idea NNS 19613 7767 7 as as IN 19613 7767 8 practical practical JJ 19613 7767 9 churchmen churchman NNS 19613 7767 10 and and CC 19613 7767 11 by by IN 19613 7767 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7767 13 actual actual JJ 19613 7767 14 experiences experience NNS 19613 7767 15 in in IN 19613 7767 16 communities community NNS 19613 7767 17 that that WDT 19613 7767 18 were be VBD 19613 7767 19 already already RB 19613 7767 20 of of IN 19613 7767 21 a a DT 19613 7767 22 very very RB 19613 7767 23 secular secular JJ 19613 7767 24 character character NN 19613 7767 25 . . . 19613 7768 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7768 2 may may MD 19613 7768 3 , , , 19613 7768 4 moreover moreover RB 19613 7768 5 , , , 19613 7768 6 point point VB 19613 7768 7 out out RP 19613 7768 8 in in IN 19613 7768 9 a a DT 19613 7768 10 general general JJ 19613 7768 11 way way NN 19613 7768 12 that that WDT 19613 7768 13 the the DT 19613 7768 14 views view NNS 19613 7768 15 of of IN 19613 7768 16 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7768 17 are be VBP 19613 7768 18 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 7768 19 more more RBR 19613 7768 20 strictly strictly RB 19613 7768 21 dependent dependent JJ 19613 7768 22 on on IN 19613 7768 23 Scripture scripture NN 19613 7768 24 texts text NNS 19613 7768 25 than than IN 19613 7768 26 those those DT 19613 7768 27 of of IN 19613 7768 28 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7768 29 . . . 19613 7769 1 That that IN 19613 7769 2 many many JJ 19613 7769 3 of of IN 19613 7769 4 the the DT 19613 7769 5 latter latter NN 19613 7769 6 's 's POS 19613 7769 7 speculations speculation NNS 19613 7769 8 are be VBP 19613 7769 9 not not RB 19613 7769 10 found find VBN 19613 7769 11 in in IN 19613 7769 12 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7769 13 is be VBZ 19613 7769 14 simply simply RB 19613 7769 15 explained explain VBN 19613 7769 16 by by IN 19613 7769 17 the the DT 19613 7769 18 fact fact NN 19613 7769 19 that that IN 19613 7769 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7769 21 have have VBP 19613 7769 22 no no DT 19613 7769 23 clear clear JJ 19613 7769 24 scriptural scriptural JJ 19613 7769 25 basis basis NN 19613 7769 26 ; ; : 19613 7769 27 see see VB 19613 7769 28 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 7769 29 , , , 19613 7769 30 Quæst Quæst NNP 19613 7769 31 , , , 19613 7769 32 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 7769 33 . . . 19613 7769 34 , , , 19613 7769 35 Specimen Specimen NNP 19613 7769 36 p. p. NN 19613 7769 37 75 75 CD 19613 7769 38 , , , 19613 7769 39 note note VBP 19613 7769 40 29 29 CD 19613 7769 41 . . . 19613 7770 1 On on IN 19613 7770 2 a a DT 19613 7770 3 superficial superficial JJ 19613 7770 4 reading read VBG 19613 7770 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7770 6 seems seem VBZ 19613 7770 7 to to TO 19613 7770 8 have have VB 19613 7770 9 a a DT 19613 7770 10 greater great JJR 19613 7770 11 variety variety NN 19613 7770 12 of of IN 19613 7770 13 points point NNS 19613 7770 14 of of IN 19613 7770 15 view view NN 19613 7770 16 than than IN 19613 7770 17 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7770 18 ; ; : 19613 7770 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7770 20 has have VBZ 19613 7770 21 in in IN 19613 7770 22 truth truth NN 19613 7770 23 fewer few JJR 19613 7770 24 , , , 19613 7770 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7770 26 contrived contrive VBD 19613 7770 27 to to TO 19613 7770 28 work work VB 19613 7770 29 the the DT 19613 7770 30 grains grain NNS 19613 7770 31 of of IN 19613 7770 32 gold gold NN 19613 7770 33 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 7770 34 to to IN 19613 7770 35 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7770 36 in in IN 19613 7770 37 such such PDT 19613 7770 38 a a DT 19613 7770 39 way way NN 19613 7770 40 as as IN 19613 7770 41 to to TO 19613 7770 42 make make VB 19613 7770 43 the the DT 19613 7770 44 form form NN 19613 7770 45 more more RBR 19613 7770 46 valuable valuable JJ 19613 7770 47 than than IN 19613 7770 48 the the DT 19613 7770 49 substance substance NN 19613 7770 50 . . . 19613 7771 1 But but CC 19613 7771 2 one one CD 19613 7771 3 idea idea NN 19613 7771 4 of of IN 19613 7771 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7771 6 , , , 19613 7771 7 which which WDT 19613 7771 8 is be VBZ 19613 7771 9 not not RB 19613 7771 10 found find VBN 19613 7771 11 in in IN 19613 7771 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7771 13 , , , 19613 7771 14 and and CC 19613 7771 15 which which WDT 19613 7771 16 in in RP 19613 7771 17 after after IN 19613 7771 18 times time NNS 19613 7771 19 was be VBD 19613 7771 20 to to TO 19613 7771 21 attain attain VB 19613 7771 22 great great JJ 19613 7771 23 importance importance NN 19613 7771 24 in in IN 19613 7771 25 the the DT 19613 7771 26 East East NNP 19613 7771 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7771 28 after after IN 19613 7771 29 Origen Origen NNP 19613 7771 30 's 's POS 19613 7771 31 day day NN 19613 7771 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7771 33 and and CC 19613 7771 34 in in IN 19613 7771 35 the the DT 19613 7771 36 West West NNP 19613 7771 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7771 38 after after IN 19613 7771 39 the the DT 19613 7771 40 time time NN 19613 7771 41 of of IN 19613 7771 42 Ambrosius Ambrosius NNP 19613 7771 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7771 44 , , , 19613 7771 45 may may MD 19613 7771 46 be be VB 19613 7771 47 further further RB 19613 7771 48 referred refer VBN 19613 7771 49 to to IN 19613 7771 50 . . . 19613 7772 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 7772 2 mean mean VBP 19613 7772 3 the the DT 19613 7772 4 notion notion NN 19613 7772 5 that that IN 19613 7772 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7772 7 is be VBZ 19613 7772 8 the the DT 19613 7772 9 bridegroom bridegroom NN 19613 7772 10 and and CC 19613 7772 11 the the DT 19613 7772 12 human human JJ 19613 7772 13 soul soul NN 19613 7772 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7772 15 and and CC 19613 7772 16 also also RB 19613 7772 17 the the DT 19613 7772 18 human human JJ 19613 7772 19 body body NN 19613 7772 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7772 21 the the DT 19613 7772 22 bride bride NN 19613 7772 23 . . . 19613 7773 1 This this DT 19613 7773 2 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 7773 3 owes owe VBZ 19613 7773 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7773 5 origin origin NN 19613 7773 6 to to IN 19613 7773 7 a a DT 19613 7773 8 combination combination NN 19613 7773 9 of of IN 19613 7773 10 two two CD 19613 7773 11 older old JJR 19613 7773 12 ones one NNS 19613 7773 13 , , , 19613 7773 14 and and CC 19613 7773 15 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 7773 16 received receive VBD 19613 7773 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7773 18 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 7773 19 basis basis NN 19613 7773 20 from from IN 19613 7773 21 the the DT 19613 7773 22 Song Song NNP 19613 7773 23 of of IN 19613 7773 24 Solomon Solomon NNP 19613 7773 25 . . . 19613 7774 1 The the DT 19613 7774 2 first first JJ 19613 7774 3 of of IN 19613 7774 4 these these DT 19613 7774 5 older old JJR 19613 7774 6 theologoumena theologoumena NNP 19613 7774 7 is be VBZ 19613 7774 8 the the DT 19613 7774 9 Greek greek JJ 19613 7774 10 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 7774 11 notion notion NN 19613 7774 12 that that IN 19613 7774 13 the the DT 19613 7774 14 divine divine JJ 19613 7774 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7774 16 is be VBZ 19613 7774 17 the the DT 19613 7774 18 bridegroom bridegroom NN 19613 7774 19 and and CC 19613 7774 20 husband husband NN 19613 7774 21 of of IN 19613 7774 22 the the DT 19613 7774 23 human human JJ 19613 7774 24 soul soul NN 19613 7774 25 . . . 19613 7775 1 See see VB 19613 7775 2 the the DT 19613 7775 3 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 7775 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7775 5 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7775 6 , , , 19613 7775 7 the the DT 19613 7775 8 sublime sublime JJ 19613 7775 9 description description NN 19613 7775 10 in in IN 19613 7775 11 the the DT 19613 7775 12 Excerpta Excerpta NNP 19613 7775 13 ex ex NNP 19613 7775 14 Theodoto Theodoto NNP 19613 7775 15 27 27 CD 19613 7775 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7775 17 ; ; : 19613 7775 18 Clem Clem NNP 19613 7775 19 . . . 19613 7776 1 ep ep NNP 19613 7776 2 . . . 19613 7777 1 ad ad NN 19613 7777 2 Jacob Jacob NNP 19613 7777 3 . . . 19613 7778 1 4 4 LS 19613 7778 2 . . . 19613 7779 1 6 6 CD 19613 7779 2 ; ; : 19613 7779 3 as as RB 19613 7779 4 well well RB 19613 7779 5 as as IN 19613 7779 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 7779 7 , , , 19613 7779 8 Orat Orat NNP 19613 7779 9 . . . 19613 7780 1 13 13 CD 19613 7780 2 ; ; : 19613 7780 3 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7780 4 . . NNP 19613 7780 5 , , , 19613 7780 6 de de NNP 19613 7780 7 anima anima NNP 19613 7780 8 41 41 CD 19613 7780 9 fin fin NNP 19613 7780 10 . . . 19613 7781 1 : : : 19613 7781 2 " " `` 19613 7781 3 Sequitur sequitur NN 19613 7781 4 animam animam NN 19613 7781 5 nubentem nubentem NN 19613 7781 6 spiritui spiritui NNS 19613 7781 7 caro caro NNP 19613 7781 8 ; ; : 19613 7781 9 o o NN 19613 7781 10 beatum beatum JJ 19613 7781 11 connubium connubium NN 19613 7781 12 " " '' 19613 7781 13 ; ; , 19613 7781 14 and and CC 19613 7781 15 the the DT 19613 7781 16 still still RB 19613 7781 17 earlier early JJR 19613 7781 18 Sap Sap NNP 19613 7781 19 . . . 19613 7782 1 Sal Sal NNP 19613 7782 2 . . . 19613 7783 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 7783 2 . . . 19613 7784 1 2 2 CD 19613 7784 2 sq sq NNP 19613 7784 3 . . . 19613 7785 1 An an DT 19613 7785 2 offensively offensively RB 19613 7785 3 realistic realistic JJ 19613 7785 4 form form NN 19613 7785 5 of of IN 19613 7785 6 this this DT 19613 7785 7 image image NN 19613 7785 8 is be VBZ 19613 7785 9 found find VBN 19613 7785 10 in in IN 19613 7785 11 Clem Clem NNP 19613 7785 12 . . . 19613 7786 1 Horn horn NN 19613 7786 2 . . . 19613 7787 1 III iii CD 19613 7787 2 . . . 19613 7788 1 27 27 CD 19613 7788 2 : : : 19613 7788 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7788 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7788 5 : : : 19613 7788 6 numphê numphê NNP 19613 7788 7 gar gar NNP 19613 7788 8 estin estin NNP 19613 7788 9 ho ho NNP 19613 7788 10 pas pas NNP 19613 7788 11 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 7788 12 , , , 19613 7788 13 hopotan hopotan NNP 19613 7788 14 tou tou NNP 19613 7788 15 alêthous alêthous JJ 19613 7788 16 prophêtou prophêtou NNP 19613 7788 17 leukô leukô NNP 19613 7788 18 logô logô NNP 19613 7788 19 alêtheias alêtheias NNP 19613 7788 20 speiromenos speiromenos NN 19613 7788 21 phôtizêtai phôtizêtai NNP 19613 7788 22 ton ton NN 19613 7788 23 noun noun NNP 19613 7788 24 . . . 19613 7788 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7789 1 The the DT 19613 7789 2 second second JJ 19613 7789 3 is be VBZ 19613 7789 4 the the DT 19613 7789 5 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 7789 6 notion notion NN 19613 7789 7 that that IN 19613 7789 8 the the DT 19613 7789 9 Church Church NNP 19613 7789 10 is be VBZ 19613 7789 11 the the DT 19613 7789 12 bride bride NN 19613 7789 13 and and CC 19613 7789 14 the the DT 19613 7789 15 body body NN 19613 7789 16 of of IN 19613 7789 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7789 18 . . . 19613 7790 1 In in IN 19613 7790 2 the the DT 19613 7790 3 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 7790 4 Epistle Epistle NNP 19613 7790 5 of of IN 19613 7790 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 7790 7 the the DT 19613 7790 8 latter latter JJ 19613 7790 9 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 7790 10 is be VBZ 19613 7790 11 already already RB 19613 7790 12 applied apply VBN 19613 7790 13 in in IN 19613 7790 14 a a DT 19613 7790 15 modified modify VBN 19613 7790 16 form form NN 19613 7790 17 . . . 19613 7791 1 Here here RB 19613 7791 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7791 3 is be VBZ 19613 7791 4 said say VBN 19613 7791 5 that that DT 19613 7791 6 humanity humanity NN 19613 7791 7 as as IN 19613 7791 8 the the DT 19613 7791 9 Church Church NNP 19613 7791 10 , , , 19613 7791 11 that that WDT 19613 7791 12 is be VBZ 19613 7791 13 human human JJ 19613 7791 14 nature nature NN 19613 7791 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7791 16 the the DT 19613 7791 17 flesh flesh NN 19613 7791 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7791 19 , , , 19613 7791 20 belongs belong VBZ 19613 7791 21 to to IN 19613 7791 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7791 23 as as IN 19613 7791 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7791 25 Eve Eve NNP 19613 7791 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7791 27 c. c. NNP 19613 7791 28 14 14 CD 19613 7791 29 ; ; : 19613 7791 30 see see VB 19613 7791 31 also also RB 19613 7791 32 Ignat Ignat NNP 19613 7791 33 . . . 19613 7792 1 ad ad NN 19613 7792 2 Polyc Polyc NNP 19613 7792 3 . . . 19613 7793 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7793 2 2 2 CD 19613 7793 3 ; ; : 19613 7793 4 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7793 5 . . . 19613 7794 1 de de NNP 19613 7794 2 monog monog NNP 19613 7794 3 . . . 19613 7795 1 II II NNP 19613 7795 2 , , , 19613 7795 3 and and CC 19613 7795 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7795 5 notes note NNS 19613 7795 6 on on IN 19613 7795 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7795 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7795 9 : : : 19613 7795 10 Didachê didachê NN 19613 7795 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7795 12 XI XI NNP 19613 7795 13 . . . 19613 7796 1 11 11 CD 19613 7796 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7796 3 . . . 19613 7797 1 The the DT 19613 7797 2 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 7797 3 that that WDT 19613 7797 4 could could MD 19613 7797 5 be be VB 19613 7797 6 drawn draw VBN 19613 7797 7 from from IN 19613 7797 8 this this DT 19613 7797 9 , , , 19613 7797 10 and and CC 19613 7797 11 that that DT 19613 7797 12 seemed seem VBD 19613 7797 13 to to TO 19613 7797 14 have have VB 19613 7797 15 a a DT 19613 7797 16 basis basis NN 19613 7797 17 in in IN 19613 7797 18 certain certain JJ 19613 7797 19 utterances utterance NNS 19613 7797 20 of of IN 19613 7797 21 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 7797 22 , , , 19613 7797 23 viz viz NNP 19613 7797 24 . . NNP 19613 7797 25 , , , 19613 7797 26 that that IN 19613 7797 27 the the DT 19613 7797 28 individual individual JJ 19613 7797 29 human human JJ 19613 7797 30 soul soul NN 19613 7797 31 together together RB 19613 7797 32 with with IN 19613 7797 33 the the DT 19613 7797 34 flesh flesh NN 19613 7797 35 is be VBZ 19613 7797 36 to to TO 19613 7797 37 be be VB 19613 7797 38 designated designate VBN 19613 7797 39 as as IN 19613 7797 40 the the DT 19613 7797 41 bride bride NN 19613 7797 42 of of IN 19613 7797 43 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7797 44 , , , 19613 7797 45 was be VBD 19613 7797 46 , , , 19613 7797 47 so so RB 19613 7797 48 far far RB 19613 7797 49 as as IN 19613 7797 50 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7797 51 know know VBP 19613 7797 52 , , , 19613 7797 53 first first RB 19613 7797 54 arrived arrive VBD 19613 7797 55 at at IN 19613 7797 56 by by IN 19613 7797 57 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7797 58 de de NNP 19613 7797 59 resurr resurr NNP 19613 7797 60 . . . 19613 7798 1 63 63 CD 19613 7798 2 : : : 19613 7798 3 " " `` 19613 7798 4 Carnem Carnem NNP 19613 7798 5 et et NN 19613 7798 6 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 7798 7 iam iam NNP 19613 7798 8 in in IN 19613 7798 9 semetipso semetipso VBN 19613 7798 10 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7798 11 foederavit foederavit NN 19613 7798 12 , , , 19613 7798 13 sponsam sponsam NNP 19613 7798 14 sponso sponso NNP 19613 7798 15 et et NNP 19613 7798 16 sponsum sponsum NNP 19613 7798 17 spousæ spousæ NNP 19613 7798 18 ; ; : 19613 7798 19 comparavit comparavit NN 19613 7798 20 . . . 19613 7799 1 Nam Nam NNP 19613 7799 2 et et NNP 19613 7799 3 si si NN 19613 7799 4 animam animam NNP 19613 7799 5 quis quis NNP 19613 7799 6 contenderit contenderit NNP 19613 7799 7 sponsam sponsam NNP 19613 7799 8 , , , 19613 7799 9 vel vel NNP 19613 7799 10 dotis dotis NNP 19613 7799 11 nomine nomine NNP 19613 7799 12 sequetur sequetur NNP 19613 7799 13 animam animam NN 19613 7799 14 caro caro NNP 19613 7799 15 ... ... : 19613 7799 16 Caro Caro NNP 19613 7799 17 est e JJS 19613 7799 18 sponsa sponsa NN 19613 7799 19 , , , 19613 7799 20 quæ quæ NN 19613 7799 21 in in IN 19613 7799 22 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7799 23 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 7799 24 sponsum sponsum NN 19613 7799 25 per per IN 19613 7799 26 sanguinem sanguinem NNP 19613 7799 27 pacta pacta NNP 19613 7799 28 est est NNP 19613 7799 29 " " '' 19613 7799 30 ; ; : 19613 7799 31 see see VB 19613 7799 32 also also RB 19613 7799 33 de de NNP 19613 7799 34 virg virg NNS 19613 7799 35 . . . 19613 7800 1 vel vel NNP 19613 7800 2 . . . 19613 7801 1 16 16 CD 19613 7801 2 . . . 19613 7802 1 Notice notice NN 19613 7802 2 , , , 19613 7802 3 however however RB 19613 7802 4 , , , 19613 7802 5 that that IN 19613 7802 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7802 7 continually continually RB 19613 7802 8 thinks think VBZ 19613 7802 9 of of IN 19613 7802 10 all all DT 19613 7802 11 souls soul NNS 19613 7802 12 together together RB 19613 7802 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7802 14 all all DT 19613 7802 15 flesh flesh NN 19613 7802 16 together together RB 19613 7802 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7802 18 rather rather RB 19613 7802 19 than than IN 19613 7802 20 of of IN 19613 7802 21 the the DT 19613 7802 22 individual individual JJ 19613 7802 23 soul soul NN 19613 7802 24 . . . 19613 7802 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7803 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7803 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7803 3 622 622 CD 19613 7803 4 : : : 19613 7803 5 By by IN 19613 7803 6 the the DT 19613 7803 7 _ _ NNP 19613 7803 8 regula regula NN 19613 7803 9 _ _ NNP 19613 7803 10 inasmuch inasmuch NN 19613 7803 11 as as IN 19613 7803 12 the the DT 19613 7803 13 words word NNS 19613 7803 14 " " `` 19613 7803 15 from from IN 19613 7803 16 thence thence NN 19613 7803 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7803 18 will will MD 19613 7803 19 come come VB 19613 7803 20 to to TO 19613 7803 21 judge judge VB 19613 7803 22 the the DT 19613 7803 23 quick quick JJ 19613 7803 24 and and CC 19613 7803 25 the the DT 19613 7803 26 dead dead JJ 19613 7803 27 " " `` 19613 7803 28 had have VBD 19613 7803 29 a a DT 19613 7803 30 fixed fix VBN 19613 7803 31 place place NN 19613 7803 32 in in IN 19613 7803 33 the the DT 19613 7803 34 confessions confession NNS 19613 7803 35 , , , 19613 7803 36 and and CC 19613 7803 37 the the DT 19613 7803 38 belief belief NN 19613 7803 39 in in IN 19613 7803 40 the the DT 19613 7803 41 _ _ NNP 19613 7803 42 duplex duplex NN 19613 7803 43 adventus adventus NNP 19613 7803 44 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7803 45 _ _ NNP 19613 7803 46 formed form VBD 19613 7803 47 one one CD 19613 7803 48 of of IN 19613 7803 49 the the DT 19613 7803 50 most most RBS 19613 7803 51 important important JJ 19613 7803 52 articles article NNS 19613 7803 53 of of IN 19613 7803 54 Church Church NNP 19613 7803 55 belief belief NN 19613 7803 56 in in IN 19613 7803 57 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 7803 58 to to IN 19613 7803 59 Judaism Judaism NNP 19613 7803 60 and and CC 19613 7803 61 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 7803 62 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7803 63 see see VB 19613 7803 64 the the DT 19613 7803 65 collection collection NN 19613 7803 66 of of IN 19613 7803 67 passages passage NNS 19613 7803 68 in in IN 19613 7803 69 Hesse Hesse NNP 19613 7803 70 , , , 19613 7803 71 " " '' 19613 7803 72 das das NNP 19613 7803 73 Muratorische Muratorische NNP 19613 7803 74 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 7803 75 " " '' 19613 7803 76 , , , 19613 7803 77 p. p. NN 19613 7803 78 112 112 CD 19613 7803 79 f. f. NNP 19613 7803 80 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7803 81 . . . 19613 7804 1 But but CC 19613 7804 2 the the DT 19613 7804 3 belief belief NN 19613 7804 4 in in IN 19613 7804 5 the the DT 19613 7804 6 return return NN 19613 7804 7 of of IN 19613 7804 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7804 9 to to IN 19613 7804 10 this this DT 19613 7804 11 world world NN 19613 7804 12 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 7804 13 involved involve VBD 19613 7804 14 the the DT 19613 7804 15 hope hope NN 19613 7804 16 of of IN 19613 7804 17 a a DT 19613 7804 18 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 7804 19 of of IN 19613 7804 20 glory glory NN 19613 7804 21 under under IN 19613 7804 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7804 23 upon upon IN 19613 7804 24 earth earth NN 19613 7804 25 , , , 19613 7804 26 and and CC 19613 7804 27 without without IN 19613 7804 28 this this DT 19613 7804 29 hope hope NN 19613 7804 30 is be VBZ 19613 7804 31 merely merely RB 19613 7804 32 a a DT 19613 7804 33 rhetorical rhetorical JJ 19613 7804 34 flourish flourish NN 19613 7804 35 . . . 19613 7804 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7805 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7805 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7805 3 623 623 CD 19613 7805 4 : : : 19613 7805 5 Cf Cf NNP 19613 7805 6 . . . 19613 7806 1 here here RB 19613 7806 2 the the DT 19613 7806 3 account account NN 19613 7806 4 already already RB 19613 7806 5 given give VBN 19613 7806 6 in in IN 19613 7806 7 Book Book NNP 19613 7806 8 I. I. NNP 19613 7806 9 , , , 19613 7806 10 chap chap NNP 19613 7806 11 . . . 19613 7807 1 3 3 LS 19613 7807 2 , , , 19613 7807 3 Vol Vol NNP 19613 7807 4 . . . 19613 7808 1 I. I. NNP 19613 7808 2 , , , 19613 7808 3 p. p. NN 19613 7808 4 167 167 CD 19613 7808 5 ff ff NNP 19613 7808 6 . . NNP 19613 7808 7 , , , 19613 7808 8 Book Book NNP 19613 7808 9 I. I. NNP 19613 7808 10 , , , 19613 7808 11 chap chap NNP 19613 7808 12 . . . 19613 7809 1 4 4 LS 19613 7809 2 , , , 19613 7809 3 Vol Vol NNP 19613 7809 4 . . . 19613 7810 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7810 2 , , , 19613 7810 3 p. p. NN 19613 7810 4 261 261 CD 19613 7810 5 , , , 19613 7810 6 Book Book NNP 19613 7810 7 II II NNP 19613 7810 8 . . NNP 19613 7810 9 , , , 19613 7810 10 chap chap NNP 19613 7810 11 . . . 19613 7811 1 3 3 LS 19613 7811 2 , , , 19613 7811 3 Vol Vol NNP 19613 7811 4 . . . 19613 7812 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 7812 2 , , , 19613 7812 3 p. p. NN 19613 7812 4 105 105 CD 19613 7812 5 f. f. NNS 19613 7812 6 On on IN 19613 7812 7 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7812 8 compare compare VBP 19613 7812 9 the the DT 19613 7812 10 testimony testimony NN 19613 7812 11 of of IN 19613 7812 12 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 19613 7812 13 in in IN 19613 7812 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 7812 15 , , , 19613 7812 16 H. H. NNP 19613 7812 17 E. E. NNP 19613 7812 18 V. V. NNP 19613 7812 19 24 24 CD 19613 7812 20 . . . 19613 7813 1 5 5 CD 19613 7813 2 , , , 19613 7813 3 and and CC 19613 7813 4 the the DT 19613 7813 5 title title NN 19613 7813 6 of of IN 19613 7813 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7813 8 lost lost JJ 19613 7813 9 work work NN 19613 7813 10 " " '' 19613 7813 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7813 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7813 13 : : : 19613 7813 14 peri peri NNP 19613 7813 15 tou tou NNP 19613 7813 16 diabolou diabolou NNP 19613 7813 17 kai kai NNP 19613 7813 18 tês tês NNP 19613 7813 19 apokalupseôs apokalupseôs JJ 19613 7813 20 Iôannou Iôannou NNP 19613 7813 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7813 22 . . . 19613 7813 23 " " '' 19613 7814 1 Chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 7814 2 ideas idea NNS 19613 7814 3 are be VBP 19613 7814 4 also also RB 19613 7814 5 found find VBN 19613 7814 6 in in IN 19613 7814 7 the the DT 19613 7814 8 epistle epistle NN 19613 7814 9 from from IN 19613 7814 10 Lyons Lyons NNP 19613 7814 11 in in IN 19613 7814 12 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 7814 13 , , , 19613 7814 14 H. H. NNP 19613 7814 15 E. E. NNP 19613 7814 16 V. V. NNP 19613 7814 17 1 1 CD 19613 7814 18 sq sq NNP 19613 7814 19 . . . 19613 7815 1 On on IN 19613 7815 2 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7815 3 see see VB 19613 7815 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7815 5 work work NN 19613 7815 6 " " '' 19613 7815 7 de de NNP 19613 7815 8 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7815 9 et et NN 19613 7815 10 Antichristo Antichristo NNP 19613 7815 11 " " '' 19613 7815 12 and and CC 19613 7815 13 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 7815 14 's 's POS 19613 7815 15 careful careful JJ 19613 7815 16 account account NN 19613 7815 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7815 18 l.c l.c NNP 19613 7815 19 . . NNP 19613 7815 20 , , , 19613 7815 21 p. p. NN 19613 7815 22 70 70 CD 19613 7815 23 sq sq NNP 19613 7815 24 . . NNP 19613 7815 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7816 1 of of IN 19613 7816 2 the the DT 19613 7816 3 agreement agreement NN 19613 7816 4 here here RB 19613 7816 5 existing exist VBG 19613 7816 6 between between IN 19613 7816 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7816 8 and and CC 19613 7816 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7816 10 as as RB 19613 7816 11 well well RB 19613 7816 12 as as IN 19613 7816 13 of of IN 19613 7816 14 the the DT 19613 7816 15 latter latter NN 19613 7816 16 's 's POS 19613 7816 17 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 7816 18 on on IN 19613 7816 19 which which WDT 19613 7816 20 unfounded unfounded JJ 19613 7816 21 doubts doubt NNS 19613 7816 22 have have VBP 19613 7816 23 been be VBN 19613 7816 24 cast cast VBN 19613 7816 25 . . . 19613 7817 1 Overbeck overbeck NN 19613 7817 2 has have VBZ 19613 7817 3 also also RB 19613 7817 4 , , , 19613 7817 5 in in IN 19613 7817 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7817 7 opinion opinion NN 19613 7817 8 , , , 19613 7817 9 shown show VBN 19613 7817 10 the the DT 19613 7817 11 probability probability NN 19613 7817 12 of of IN 19613 7817 13 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 7817 14 portions portion NNS 19613 7817 15 having have VBG 19613 7817 16 been be VBN 19613 7817 17 removed remove VBN 19613 7817 18 at at IN 19613 7817 19 a a DT 19613 7817 20 later later JJ 19613 7817 21 period period NN 19613 7817 22 both both CC 19613 7817 23 from from IN 19613 7817 24 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7817 25 ' ' POS 19613 7817 26 book book NN 19613 7817 27 and and CC 19613 7817 28 the the DT 19613 7817 29 great great JJ 19613 7817 30 work work NN 19613 7817 31 of of IN 19613 7817 32 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7817 33 . . . 19613 7818 1 The the DT 19613 7818 2 extensive extensive JJ 19613 7818 3 fragments fragment NNS 19613 7818 4 of of IN 19613 7818 5 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7818 6 ' ' POS 19613 7818 7 commentary commentary NN 19613 7818 8 on on IN 19613 7818 9 Daniel Daniel NNP 19613 7818 10 are be VBP 19613 7818 11 also also RB 19613 7818 12 to to TO 19613 7818 13 be be VB 19613 7818 14 compared compare VBN 19613 7818 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7818 16 and and CC 19613 7818 17 especially especially RB 19613 7818 18 the the DT 19613 7818 19 portions portion NNS 19613 7818 20 full full JJ 19613 7818 21 of of IN 19613 7818 22 glowing glow VBG 19613 7818 23 hatred hatred NN 19613 7818 24 to to IN 19613 7818 25 Rome Rome NNP 19613 7818 26 lately lately RB 19613 7818 27 discovered discover VBN 19613 7818 28 by by IN 19613 7818 29 Georgiades Georgiades NNP 19613 7818 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7818 31 . . . 19613 7819 1 With with IN 19613 7819 2 reference reference NN 19613 7819 3 to to IN 19613 7819 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7819 5 compare compare VB 19613 7819 6 particularly particularly RB 19613 7819 7 the the DT 19613 7819 8 writings writing NNS 19613 7819 9 adv adv NN 19613 7819 10 . . . 19613 7820 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7820 2 . . . 19613 7821 1 III III NNP 19613 7821 2 . . NNP 19613 7821 3 , , , 19613 7821 4 adv adv NNP 19613 7821 5 . . . 19613 7822 1 Jud Jud NNP 19613 7822 2 . . NNP 19613 7822 3 , , , 19613 7822 4 de de FW 19613 7822 5 resurrectione resurrectione NN 19613 7822 6 carnis carnis NNP 19613 7822 7 , , , 19613 7822 8 de de NNP 19613 7822 9 anima anima NNP 19613 7822 10 , , , 19613 7822 11 and and CC 19613 7822 12 the the DT 19613 7822 13 titles title NNS 19613 7822 14 of of IN 19613 7822 15 the the DT 19613 7822 16 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 7822 17 suppressed suppress VBN 19613 7822 18 writings writing NNS 19613 7822 19 de de FW 19613 7822 20 paradiso paradiso NNP 19613 7822 21 and and CC 19613 7822 22 de de NNP 19613 7822 23 spe spe NNP 19613 7822 24 fidelium fidelium NNP 19613 7822 25 . . . 19613 7823 1 Further further RB 19613 7823 2 see see VB 19613 7823 3 Commodian Commodian NNP 19613 7823 4 , , , 19613 7823 5 Carmen Carmen NNP 19613 7823 6 apolog apolog NN 19613 7823 7 . . . 19613 7823 8 , , , 19613 7823 9 Lactantius Lactantius NNP 19613 7823 10 , , , 19613 7823 11 Instit Instit NNP 19613 7823 12 . . . 19613 7824 1 div div NNP 19613 7824 2 . . NNP 19613 7824 3 , , , 19613 7824 4 I. I. NNP 19613 7825 1 VII VII NNP 19613 7825 2 . . NNP 19613 7825 3 , , , 19613 7825 4 Victorinus Victorinus NNP 19613 7825 5 , , , 19613 7825 6 Commentary Commentary NNP 19613 7825 7 on on IN 19613 7825 8 the the DT 19613 7825 9 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 7825 10 . . . 19613 7826 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7826 2 is be VBZ 19613 7826 3 very very RB 19613 7826 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 7826 5 that that IN 19613 7826 6 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 19613 7826 7 already already RB 19613 7826 8 set set VBD 19613 7826 9 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 7826 10 aside aside RB 19613 7826 11 ; ; : 19613 7826 12 cf cf NNP 19613 7826 13 . . . 19613 7827 1 the the DT 19613 7827 2 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 7827 3 of of IN 19613 7827 4 the the DT 19613 7827 5 second second JJ 19613 7827 6 Book Book NNP 19613 7827 7 of of IN 19613 7827 8 the the DT 19613 7827 9 Testimonia Testimonia NNP 19613 7827 10 and and CC 19613 7827 11 the the DT 19613 7827 12 few few JJ 19613 7827 13 passages passage NNS 19613 7827 14 in in IN 19613 7827 15 which which WDT 19613 7827 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7827 17 quoted quote VBD 19613 7827 18 the the DT 19613 7827 19 last last JJ 19613 7827 20 chapters chapter NNS 19613 7827 21 of of IN 19613 7827 22 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 7827 23 . . . 19613 7828 1 The the DT 19613 7828 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 7828 3 were be VBD 19613 7828 4 silent silent JJ 19613 7828 5 about about IN 19613 7828 6 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 7828 7 hopes hope NNS 19613 7828 8 , , , 19613 7828 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 7828 10 even even RB 19613 7828 11 denied deny VBD 19613 7828 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7828 13 in in IN 19613 7828 14 Apol Apol NNP 19613 7828 15 . . . 19613 7829 1 I. I. NNP 19613 7830 1 11 11 CD 19613 7830 2 , , , 19613 7830 3 but but CC 19613 7830 4 , , , 19613 7830 5 as as IN 19613 7830 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7830 7 have have VBP 19613 7830 8 remarked remark VBN 19613 7830 9 , , , 19613 7830 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7830 11 gives give VBZ 19613 7830 12 expression expression NN 19613 7830 13 to to IN 19613 7830 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7830 15 in in IN 19613 7830 16 the the DT 19613 7830 17 Dialogue Dialogue NNP 19613 7830 18 and and CC 19613 7830 19 reckons reckon VBZ 19613 7830 20 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7830 21 necessary necessary JJ 19613 7830 22 to to TO 19613 7830 23 complete complete VB 19613 7830 24 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 19613 7830 25 . . . 19613 7831 1 The the DT 19613 7831 2 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 7831 3 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 7831 4 , , , 19613 7831 5 especially especially RB 19613 7831 6 several several JJ 19613 7831 7 passages passage NNS 19613 7831 8 in in IN 19613 7831 9 1 1 CD 19613 7831 10 Cor Cor NNP 19613 7831 11 . . . 19613 7832 1 XV XV NNP 19613 7832 2 . . . 19613 7833 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7833 2 see see VB 19613 7833 3 particularly particularly RB 19613 7833 4 verse verse VB 19613 7833 5 50 50 CD 19613 7833 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7833 7 , , , 19613 7833 8 caused cause VBD 19613 7833 9 great great JJ 19613 7833 10 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 7833 11 to to IN 19613 7833 12 the the DT 19613 7833 13 Fathers father NNS 19613 7833 14 from from IN 19613 7833 15 Justin Justin NNP 19613 7833 16 downwards downwards RB 19613 7833 17 . . . 19613 7834 1 See see VB 19613 7834 2 Fragm Fragm NNP 19613 7834 3 . . . 19613 7835 1 Justini Justini NNP 19613 7835 2 IV IV NNP 19613 7835 3 . . . 19613 7836 1 a a DT 19613 7836 2 Methodic Methodic NNP 19613 7836 3 supped supped NN 19613 7836 4 . . . 19613 7837 1 in in IN 19613 7837 2 Otto Otto NNP 19613 7837 3 , , , 19613 7837 4 Corp. Corp. NNP 19613 7837 5 Apol Apol NNP 19613 7837 6 . . . 19613 7838 1 III III NNP 19613 7838 2 . . NNP 19613 7838 3 , , , 19613 7838 4 p. p. NN 19613 7838 5 254 254 CD 19613 7838 6 , , , 19613 7838 7 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7838 8 . . . 19613 7839 1 V. V. NNP 19613 7839 2 9 9 CD 19613 7839 3 , , , 19613 7839 4 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7839 5 . . . 19613 7840 1 de de NNP 19613 7840 2 resurr resurr NNP 19613 7840 3 . . . 19613 7841 1 48 48 CD 19613 7841 2 sq sq NN 19613 7841 3 . . . 19613 7842 1 According accord VBG 19613 7842 2 to to IN 19613 7842 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7842 4 the the DT 19613 7842 5 heretics heretic NNS 19613 7842 6 , , , 19613 7842 7 who who WP 19613 7842 8 completely completely RB 19613 7842 9 abandoned abandon VBD 19613 7842 10 the the DT 19613 7842 11 early early JJ 19613 7842 12 - - HYPH 19613 7842 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 7842 14 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 7842 15 , , , 19613 7842 16 appealed appeal VBD 19613 7842 17 to to IN 19613 7842 18 1 1 CD 19613 7842 19 Cor Cor NNP 19613 7842 20 . . . 19613 7843 1 XV XV NNP 19613 7843 2 . . . 19613 7844 1 50 50 CD 19613 7844 2 . . . 19613 7845 1 The the DT 19613 7845 2 idea idea NN 19613 7845 3 of of IN 19613 7845 4 a a DT 19613 7845 5 kind kind NN 19613 7845 6 of of IN 19613 7845 7 purgatory purgatory NN 19613 7845 8 -- -- : 19613 7845 9 a a DT 19613 7845 10 notion notion NN 19613 7845 11 which which WDT 19613 7845 12 does do VBZ 19613 7845 13 not not RB 19613 7845 14 originate originate VB 19613 7845 15 with with IN 19613 7845 16 the the DT 19613 7845 17 realistic realistic JJ 19613 7845 18 but but CC 19613 7845 19 with with IN 19613 7845 20 the the DT 19613 7845 21 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 7845 22 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 7845 23 -- -- : 19613 7845 24 is be VBZ 19613 7845 25 quite quite RB 19613 7845 26 plainly plainly RB 19613 7845 27 found find VBN 19613 7845 28 in in IN 19613 7845 29 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7845 30 , , , 19613 7845 31 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7845 32 , , , 19613 7845 33 in in IN 19613 7845 34 de de FW 19613 7845 35 anima anima NNP 19613 7845 36 57 57 CD 19613 7845 37 and and CC 19613 7845 38 58 58 CD 19613 7845 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7845 40 " " `` 19613 7845 41 modicum modicum NNP 19613 7845 42 delictum delictum NNP 19613 7845 43 illuc illuc NNP 19613 7845 44 luendum luendum NNP 19613 7845 45 " " '' 19613 7845 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7845 47 . . . 19613 7846 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7846 2 speaks speak VBZ 19613 7846 3 in in IN 19613 7846 4 several several JJ 19613 7846 5 passages passage NNS 19613 7846 6 of of IN 19613 7846 7 stages stage NNS 19613 7846 8 and and CC 19613 7846 9 different different JJ 19613 7846 10 places place NNS 19613 7846 11 of of IN 19613 7846 12 bliss bliss NN 19613 7846 13 ; ; : 19613 7846 14 and and CC 19613 7846 15 this this DT 19613 7846 16 was be VBD 19613 7846 17 a a DT 19613 7846 18 universally universally RB 19613 7846 19 diffused diffused JJ 19613 7846 20 idea idea NN 19613 7846 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7846 22 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7846 23 , , , 19613 7846 24 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 7846 25 . . . 19613 7847 1 6 6 LS 19613 7847 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7847 3 . . . 19613 7847 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7848 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7848 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7848 3 624 624 CD 19613 7848 4 : : : 19613 7848 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7848 6 begins begin VBZ 19613 7848 7 with with IN 19613 7848 8 the the DT 19613 7848 9 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 7848 10 of of IN 19613 7848 11 the the DT 19613 7848 12 body body NN 19613 7848 13 and and CC 19613 7848 14 the the DT 19613 7848 15 proofs proof NNS 19613 7848 16 of of IN 19613 7848 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7848 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7848 19 in in IN 19613 7848 20 opposition opposition NN 19613 7848 21 to to IN 19613 7848 22 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 7848 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7848 24 . . . 19613 7849 1 These these DT 19613 7849 2 proofs proof NNS 19613 7849 3 are be VBP 19613 7849 4 taken take VBN 19613 7849 5 from from IN 19613 7849 6 the the DT 19613 7849 7 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 7849 8 and and CC 19613 7849 9 goodness goodness NN 19613 7849 10 of of IN 19613 7849 11 God God NNP 19613 7849 12 , , , 19613 7849 13 the the DT 19613 7849 14 long long JJ 19613 7849 15 life life NN 19613 7849 16 of of IN 19613 7849 17 the the DT 19613 7849 18 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 7849 19 , , , 19613 7849 20 the the DT 19613 7849 21 translation translation NN 19613 7849 22 of of IN 19613 7849 23 Enoch Enoch NNP 19613 7849 24 and and CC 19613 7849 25 Elijah Elijah NNP 19613 7849 26 , , , 19613 7849 27 the the DT 19613 7849 28 preservation preservation NN 19613 7849 29 of of IN 19613 7849 30 Jonah Jonah NNP 19613 7849 31 and and CC 19613 7849 32 of of IN 19613 7849 33 the the DT 19613 7849 34 three three CD 19613 7849 35 men man NNS 19613 7849 36 in in IN 19613 7849 37 the the DT 19613 7849 38 fiery fiery JJ 19613 7849 39 furnace furnace NN 19613 7849 40 , , , 19613 7849 41 the the DT 19613 7849 42 essential essential JJ 19613 7849 43 nature nature NN 19613 7849 44 of of IN 19613 7849 45 man man NN 19613 7849 46 as as IN 19613 7849 47 a a DT 19613 7849 48 temple temple NN 19613 7849 49 of of IN 19613 7849 50 God God NNP 19613 7849 51 to to TO 19613 7849 52 which which WDT 19613 7849 53 the the DT 19613 7849 54 body body NN 19613 7849 55 also also RB 19613 7849 56 belongs belong VBZ 19613 7849 57 , , , 19613 7849 58 and and CC 19613 7849 59 the the DT 19613 7849 60 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 7849 61 of of IN 19613 7849 62 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7849 63 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7849 64 V. V. NNP 19613 7849 65 3 3 CD 19613 7849 66 - - SYM 19613 7849 67 7 7 CD 19613 7849 68 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7849 69 . . . 19613 7850 1 But but CC 19613 7850 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7850 3 sees see VBZ 19613 7850 4 the the DT 19613 7850 5 chief chief JJ 19613 7850 6 proof proof NN 19613 7850 7 in in IN 19613 7850 8 the the DT 19613 7850 9 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 7850 10 of of IN 19613 7850 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7850 12 , , , 19613 7850 13 in in IN 19613 7850 14 the the DT 19613 7850 15 dwelling dwelling NN 19613 7850 16 of of IN 19613 7850 17 the the DT 19613 7850 18 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 7850 19 with with IN 19613 7850 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7850 21 gifts gift NNS 19613 7850 22 in in IN 19613 7850 23 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7850 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7850 25 V. V. NNP 19613 7850 26 8 8 CD 19613 7850 27 - - SYM 19613 7850 28 16 16 CD 19613 7850 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7850 30 , , , 19613 7850 31 and and CC 19613 7850 32 in in IN 19613 7850 33 the the DT 19613 7850 34 feeding feeding NN 19613 7850 35 of of IN 19613 7850 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7850 37 body body NN 19613 7850 38 with with IN 19613 7850 39 the the DT 19613 7850 40 holy holy JJ 19613 7850 41 eucharist eucharist NN 19613 7850 42 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7850 43 V. V. NNP 19613 7850 44 2 2 CD 19613 7850 45 . . . 19613 7851 1 3 3 LS 19613 7851 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7851 3 . . . 19613 7852 1 Then then RB 19613 7852 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7852 3 discusses discuss VBZ 19613 7852 4 the the DT 19613 7852 5 defeat defeat NN 19613 7852 6 of of IN 19613 7852 7 Satan Satan NNP 19613 7852 8 by by IN 19613 7852 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7852 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7852 11 V. V. NNP 19613 7852 12 21 21 CD 19613 7852 13 - - SYM 19613 7852 14 23 23 CD 19613 7852 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7852 16 , , , 19613 7852 17 shows show VBZ 19613 7852 18 that that IN 19613 7852 19 the the DT 19613 7852 20 powers power NNS 19613 7852 21 that that WDT 19613 7852 22 be be VBP 19613 7852 23 are be VBP 19613 7852 24 set set VBN 19613 7852 25 up up RP 19613 7852 26 by by IN 19613 7852 27 God God NNP 19613 7852 28 , , , 19613 7852 29 that that IN 19613 7852 30 the the DT 19613 7852 31 devil devil NN 19613 7852 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 7852 33 manifestly manifestly RB 19613 7852 34 lies lie VBZ 19613 7852 35 in in IN 19613 7852 36 arrogating arrogate VBG 19613 7852 37 to to IN 19613 7852 38 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7852 39 the the DT 19613 7852 40 lordship lordship NN 19613 7852 41 of of IN 19613 7852 42 the the DT 19613 7852 43 world world NN 19613 7852 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7852 45 V. V. NNP 19613 7852 46 24 24 CD 19613 7852 47 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7852 48 , , , 19613 7852 49 but but CC 19613 7852 50 that that IN 19613 7852 51 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7852 52 acts act VBZ 19613 7852 53 as as IN 19613 7852 54 a a DT 19613 7852 55 rebel rebel NN 19613 7852 56 and and CC 19613 7852 57 robber robber VB 19613 7852 58 in in IN 19613 7852 59 attempting attempt VBG 19613 7852 60 to to TO 19613 7852 61 make make VB 19613 7852 62 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7852 63 master master NN 19613 7852 64 of of IN 19613 7852 65 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7852 66 . . . 19613 7853 1 This this DT 19613 7853 2 brings bring VBZ 19613 7853 3 about about RP 19613 7853 4 the the DT 19613 7853 5 transition transition NN 19613 7853 6 to to IN 19613 7853 7 Antichrist Antichrist NNP 19613 7853 8 . . . 19613 7854 1 The the DT 19613 7854 2 latter latter NN 19613 7854 3 is be VBZ 19613 7854 4 possessed possess VBN 19613 7854 5 of of IN 19613 7854 6 the the DT 19613 7854 7 whole whole JJ 19613 7854 8 power power NN 19613 7854 9 of of IN 19613 7854 10 the the DT 19613 7854 11 devil devil NN 19613 7854 12 , , , 19613 7854 13 sums sum VBZ 19613 7854 14 up up RP 19613 7854 15 in in IN 19613 7854 16 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7854 17 therefore therefore RB 19613 7854 18 all all DT 19613 7854 19 sin sin NN 19613 7854 20 and and CC 19613 7854 21 wickedness wickedness NN 19613 7854 22 , , , 19613 7854 23 and and CC 19613 7854 24 pretends pretend NNS 19613 7854 25 to to TO 19613 7854 26 be be VB 19613 7854 27 Lord Lord NNP 19613 7854 28 and and CC 19613 7854 29 God God NNP 19613 7854 30 . . . 19613 7855 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7855 2 is be VBZ 19613 7855 3 described describe VBN 19613 7855 4 in in IN 19613 7855 5 accordance accordance NN 19613 7855 6 with with IN 19613 7855 7 the the DT 19613 7855 8 Apocalypses Apocalypses NNP 19613 7855 9 of of IN 19613 7855 10 Daniel Daniel NNP 19613 7855 11 and and CC 19613 7855 12 John John NNP 19613 7855 13 as as RB 19613 7855 14 well well RB 19613 7855 15 as as IN 19613 7855 16 according accord VBG 19613 7855 17 to to IN 19613 7855 18 Matth Matth NNP 19613 7855 19 . . . 19613 7856 1 XXIV XXIV NNP 19613 7856 2 . . . 19613 7857 1 and and CC 19613 7857 2 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 7857 3 Thessalonians Thessalonians NNPS 19613 7857 4 . . . 19613 7858 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7858 2 is be VBZ 19613 7858 3 the the DT 19613 7858 4 product product NN 19613 7858 5 of of IN 19613 7858 6 the the DT 19613 7858 7 4th 4th JJ 19613 7858 8 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 7858 9 , , , 19613 7858 10 that that RB 19613 7858 11 is is RB 19613 7858 12 , , , 19613 7858 13 the the DT 19613 7858 14 Roman roman JJ 19613 7858 15 empire empire NN 19613 7858 16 ; ; : 19613 7858 17 but but CC 19613 7858 18 at at IN 19613 7858 19 the the DT 19613 7858 20 same same JJ 19613 7858 21 time time NN 19613 7858 22 springs spring NNS 19613 7858 23 from from IN 19613 7858 24 the the DT 19613 7858 25 tribe tribe NN 19613 7858 26 of of IN 19613 7858 27 Dan Dan NNP 19613 7858 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7858 29 V. V. NNP 19613 7858 30 30 30 CD 19613 7858 31 . . . 19613 7859 1 2 2 LS 19613 7859 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7859 3 , , , 19613 7859 4 and and CC 19613 7859 5 will will MD 19613 7859 6 take take VB 19613 7859 7 up up RP 19613 7859 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7859 9 abode abode NN 19613 7859 10 in in IN 19613 7859 11 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 7859 12 etc etc FW 19613 7859 13 . . . 19613 7860 1 The the DT 19613 7860 2 returning return VBG 19613 7860 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7860 4 will will MD 19613 7860 5 destroy destroy VB 19613 7860 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7860 7 , , , 19613 7860 8 and and CC 19613 7860 9 the the DT 19613 7860 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7860 11 will will MD 19613 7860 12 come come VB 19613 7860 13 back back RB 19613 7860 14 when when WRB 19613 7860 15 6000 6000 CD 19613 7860 16 years year NNS 19613 7860 17 of of IN 19613 7860 18 the the DT 19613 7860 19 world world NN 19613 7860 20 's 's POS 19613 7860 21 history history NN 19613 7860 22 have have VBP 19613 7860 23 elapsed elapse VBN 19613 7860 24 ; ; : 19613 7860 25 for for IN 19613 7860 26 " " `` 19613 7860 27 in in IN 19613 7860 28 as as RB 19613 7860 29 many many JJ 19613 7860 30 days day NNS 19613 7860 31 as as IN 19613 7860 32 the the DT 19613 7860 33 world world NN 19613 7860 34 was be VBD 19613 7860 35 made make VBN 19613 7860 36 , , , 19613 7860 37 in in IN 19613 7860 38 so so RB 19613 7860 39 many many JJ 19613 7860 40 thousands thousand NNS 19613 7860 41 of of IN 19613 7860 42 years year NNS 19613 7860 43 will will MD 19613 7860 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7860 45 be be VB 19613 7860 46 ended end VBN 19613 7860 47 " " '' 19613 7860 48 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7860 49 V. V. NNP 19613 7860 50 28 28 CD 19613 7860 51 . . . 19613 7861 1 3 3 LS 19613 7861 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7861 3 . . . 19613 7862 1 The the DT 19613 7862 2 seventh seventh JJ 19613 7862 3 day day NN 19613 7862 4 is be VBZ 19613 7862 5 then then RB 19613 7862 6 the the DT 19613 7862 7 great great JJ 19613 7862 8 world world NN 19613 7862 9 Sabbath Sabbath NNP 19613 7862 10 , , , 19613 7862 11 during during IN 19613 7862 12 which which WDT 19613 7862 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7862 14 will will MD 19613 7862 15 reign reign VB 19613 7862 16 with with IN 19613 7862 17 the the DT 19613 7862 18 saints saint NNS 19613 7862 19 of of IN 19613 7862 20 the the DT 19613 7862 21 first first JJ 19613 7862 22 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 7862 23 after after IN 19613 7862 24 the the DT 19613 7862 25 destruction destruction NN 19613 7862 26 of of IN 19613 7862 27 Antichrist Antichrist NNP 19613 7862 28 . . . 19613 7863 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7863 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 7863 3 argued argue VBD 19613 7863 4 against against IN 19613 7863 5 such such JJ 19613 7863 6 " " `` 19613 7863 7 as as IN 19613 7863 8 pass pass NN 19613 7863 9 for for IN 19613 7863 10 orthodox orthodox NN 19613 7863 11 , , , 19613 7863 12 but but CC 19613 7863 13 disregard disregard VB 19613 7863 14 the the DT 19613 7863 15 order order NN 19613 7863 16 of of IN 19613 7863 17 the the DT 19613 7863 18 progress progress NN 19613 7863 19 of of IN 19613 7863 20 the the DT 19613 7863 21 righteous righteous JJ 19613 7863 22 and and CC 19613 7863 23 know know VBP 19613 7863 24 no no DT 19613 7863 25 stages stage NNS 19613 7863 26 of of IN 19613 7863 27 preparation preparation NN 19613 7863 28 for for IN 19613 7863 29 incorruptibility incorruptibility NN 19613 7863 30 " " '' 19613 7863 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7863 32 V. V. NNP 19613 7863 33 31 31 CD 19613 7863 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7863 35 . . . 19613 7864 1 By by IN 19613 7864 2 this this DT 19613 7864 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7864 4 means mean VBZ 19613 7864 5 such such JJ 19613 7864 6 as as IN 19613 7864 7 assume assume VB 19613 7864 8 that that IN 19613 7864 9 after after IN 19613 7864 10 death death NN 19613 7864 11 souls soul NNS 19613 7864 12 immediately immediately RB 19613 7864 13 pass pass VBP 19613 7864 14 to to IN 19613 7864 15 God God NNP 19613 7864 16 . . . 19613 7865 1 On on IN 19613 7865 2 the the DT 19613 7865 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 7865 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7865 5 argues argue VBZ 19613 7865 6 that that IN 19613 7865 7 these these DT 19613 7865 8 rather rather RB 19613 7865 9 wait wait VBP 19613 7865 10 in in IN 19613 7865 11 a a DT 19613 7865 12 hidden hidden JJ 19613 7865 13 place place NN 19613 7865 14 for for IN 19613 7865 15 the the DT 19613 7865 16 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 7865 17 which which WDT 19613 7865 18 takes take VBZ 19613 7865 19 place place NN 19613 7865 20 on on IN 19613 7865 21 the the DT 19613 7865 22 return return NN 19613 7865 23 of of IN 19613 7865 24 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7865 25 , , , 19613 7865 26 after after IN 19613 7865 27 which which WDT 19613 7865 28 the the DT 19613 7865 29 souls soul NNS 19613 7865 30 receive receive VBP 19613 7865 31 back back RP 19613 7865 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7865 33 bodies body NNS 19613 7865 34 and and CC 19613 7865 35 men man NNS 19613 7865 36 now now RB 19613 7865 37 restored restore VBN 19613 7865 38 participate participate VB 19613 7865 39 in in IN 19613 7865 40 the the DT 19613 7865 41 Saviour Saviour NNP 19613 7865 42 's 's POS 19613 7865 43 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 7865 44 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7865 45 V. V. NNP 19613 7865 46 31 31 CD 19613 7865 47 . . . 19613 7866 1 2 2 LS 19613 7866 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7866 3 . . . 19613 7867 1 This this DT 19613 7867 2 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 7867 3 on on IN 19613 7867 4 earth earth NN 19613 7867 5 precedes precede VBZ 19613 7867 6 the the DT 19613 7867 7 universal universal JJ 19613 7867 8 judgment judgment NN 19613 7867 9 ; ; : 19613 7867 10 " " `` 19613 7867 11 for for IN 19613 7867 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7867 13 is be VBZ 19613 7867 14 just just RB 19613 7867 15 that that IN 19613 7867 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7867 17 should should MD 19613 7867 18 also also RB 19613 7867 19 receive receive VB 19613 7867 20 the the DT 19613 7867 21 fruits fruit NNS 19613 7867 22 of of IN 19613 7867 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7867 24 patience patience NN 19613 7867 25 in in IN 19613 7867 26 the the DT 19613 7867 27 same same JJ 19613 7867 28 creation creation NN 19613 7867 29 in in IN 19613 7867 30 which which WDT 19613 7867 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7867 32 suffered suffer VBD 19613 7867 33 tribulation tribulation NN 19613 7867 34 " " '' 19613 7867 35 ; ; , 19613 7867 36 moreover moreover RB 19613 7867 37 , , , 19613 7867 38 the the DT 19613 7867 39 promise promise NN 19613 7867 40 made make VBN 19613 7867 41 to to IN 19613 7867 42 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 7867 43 that that IN 19613 7867 44 Palestine Palestine NNP 19613 7867 45 would would MD 19613 7867 46 be be VB 19613 7867 47 given give VBN 19613 7867 48 to to IN 19613 7867 49 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7867 50 and and CC 19613 7867 51 to to IN 19613 7867 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7867 53 seed seed NN 19613 7867 54 , , , 19613 7867 55 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 7867 56 , , , 19613 7867 57 the the DT 19613 7867 58 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 7867 59 , , , 19613 7867 60 must must MD 19613 7867 61 be be VB 19613 7867 62 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 7867 63 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7867 64 V. V. NNP 19613 7867 65 32 32 CD 19613 7867 66 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7867 67 . . . 19613 7868 1 There there RB 19613 7868 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7868 3 will will MD 19613 7868 4 eat eat VB 19613 7868 5 and and CC 19613 7868 6 drink drink VB 19613 7868 7 with with IN 19613 7868 8 the the DT 19613 7868 9 Lord Lord NNP 19613 7868 10 in in IN 19613 7868 11 the the DT 19613 7868 12 restored restore VBN 19613 7868 13 body body NN 19613 7868 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7868 15 V. V. NNP 19613 7868 16 33 33 CD 19613 7868 17 . . . 19613 7869 1 1 1 LS 19613 7869 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7869 3 sitting sit VBG 19613 7869 4 at at IN 19613 7869 5 a a DT 19613 7869 6 table table NN 19613 7869 7 covered cover VBN 19613 7869 8 with with IN 19613 7869 9 food food NN 19613 7869 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7869 11 V. V. NNP 19613 7869 12 33 33 CD 19613 7869 13 . . . 19613 7870 1 2 2 LS 19613 7870 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7870 3 and and CC 19613 7870 4 consuming consume VBG 19613 7870 5 the the DT 19613 7870 6 produce produce NN 19613 7870 7 of of IN 19613 7870 8 the the DT 19613 7870 9 land land NN 19613 7870 10 , , , 19613 7870 11 which which WDT 19613 7870 12 the the DT 19613 7870 13 earth earth NN 19613 7870 14 affords afford VBZ 19613 7870 15 in in IN 19613 7870 16 miraculous miraculous JJ 19613 7870 17 fruitfulness fruitfulness NN 19613 7870 18 . . . 19613 7871 1 Here here RB 19613 7871 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7871 3 appeals appeal NNS 19613 7871 4 to to IN 19613 7871 5 alleged alleged JJ 19613 7871 6 utterances utterance NNS 19613 7871 7 of of IN 19613 7871 8 the the DT 19613 7871 9 Lord Lord NNP 19613 7871 10 of of IN 19613 7871 11 which which WDT 19613 7871 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7871 13 had have VBD 19613 7871 14 been be VBN 19613 7871 15 informed inform VBN 19613 7871 16 by by IN 19613 7871 17 Papias Papias NNP 19613 7871 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7871 19 V. V. NNP 19613 7871 20 33 33 CD 19613 7871 21 . . . 19613 7872 1 3 3 CD 19613 7872 2 , , , 19613 7872 3 4 4 CD 19613 7872 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7872 5 . . . 19613 7873 1 The the DT 19613 7873 2 wheat wheat NN 19613 7873 3 will will MD 19613 7873 4 be be VB 19613 7873 5 so so RB 19613 7873 6 fat fat JJ 19613 7873 7 that that IN 19613 7873 8 lions lion NNS 19613 7873 9 lying lie VBG 19613 7873 10 peacefully peacefully RB 19613 7873 11 beside beside IN 19613 7873 12 the the DT 19613 7873 13 cattle cattle NNS 19613 7873 14 will will MD 19613 7873 15 be be VB 19613 7873 16 able able JJ 19613 7873 17 to to TO 19613 7873 18 feed feed VB 19613 7873 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 7873 20 even even RB 19613 7873 21 on on IN 19613 7873 22 the the DT 19613 7873 23 chaff chaff NN 19613 7873 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7873 25 V. V. NNP 19613 7873 26 33 33 CD 19613 7873 27 . . . 19613 7874 1 3 3 CD 19613 7874 2 , , , 19613 7874 3 4 4 CD 19613 7874 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7874 5 . . . 19613 7875 1 Such such JJ 19613 7875 2 and and CC 19613 7875 3 similar similar JJ 19613 7875 4 promises promise NNS 19613 7875 5 are be VBP 19613 7875 6 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 7875 7 to to TO 19613 7875 8 be be VB 19613 7875 9 understood understand VBN 19613 7875 10 in in IN 19613 7875 11 a a DT 19613 7875 12 literal literal JJ 19613 7875 13 sense sense NN 19613 7875 14 . . . 19613 7876 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7876 2 here here RB 19613 7876 3 expressly expressly RB 19613 7876 4 argues argue VBZ 19613 7876 5 against against IN 19613 7876 6 any any DT 19613 7876 7 figurative figurative JJ 19613 7876 8 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 7876 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7876 10 ibid ibid NNP 19613 7876 11 , , , 19613 7876 12 and and CC 19613 7876 13 V. V. NNP 19613 7876 14 35 35 CD 19613 7876 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7876 16 . . . 19613 7877 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 7877 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 7877 3 adopted adopt VBD 19613 7877 4 the the DT 19613 7877 5 whole whole JJ 19613 7877 6 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 7877 7 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 7877 8 , , , 19613 7877 9 the the DT 19613 7877 10 only only JJ 19613 7877 11 difference difference NN 19613 7877 12 being be VBG 19613 7877 13 that that IN 19613 7877 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7877 15 regards regard VBZ 19613 7877 16 the the DT 19613 7877 17 Church Church NNP 19613 7877 18 as as IN 19613 7877 19 the the DT 19613 7877 20 seed seed NN 19613 7877 21 of of IN 19613 7877 22 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 7877 23 . . . 19613 7878 1 The the DT 19613 7878 2 earthly earthly JJ 19613 7878 3 Kingdom Kingdom NNP 19613 7878 4 is be VBZ 19613 7878 5 then then RB 19613 7878 6 followed follow VBN 19613 7878 7 by by IN 19613 7878 8 the the DT 19613 7878 9 second second JJ 19613 7878 10 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 7878 11 , , , 19613 7878 12 the the DT 19613 7878 13 general general JJ 19613 7878 14 judgment judgment NN 19613 7878 15 , , , 19613 7878 16 and and CC 19613 7878 17 the the DT 19613 7878 18 final final JJ 19613 7878 19 end end NN 19613 7878 20 . . . 19613 7878 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7879 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7879 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7879 3 625 625 CD 19613 7879 4 : : : 19613 7879 5 Hippolytus hippolytus VB 19613 7879 6 in in IN 19613 7879 7 the the DT 19613 7879 8 lost lose VBN 19613 7879 9 book book NN 19613 7879 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7879 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 7879 12 : : : 19613 7879 13 hyper hyper NNP 19613 7879 14 tou tou NNP 19613 7879 15 kata kata NNP 19613 7879 16 Iôannên Iôannên NNP 19613 7879 17 euangeliou euangeliou NN 19613 7879 18 kai kai NNP 19613 7879 19 apokalupseôs apokalupseôs NNP 19613 7879 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7879 21 . . . 19613 7880 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 19613 7880 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 7880 3 may may MD 19613 7880 4 also also RB 19613 7880 5 reckon reckon VB 19613 7880 6 Melito Melito NNP 19613 7880 7 among among IN 19613 7880 8 the the DT 19613 7880 9 literary literary JJ 19613 7880 10 defenders defender NNS 19613 7880 11 of of IN 19613 7880 12 Chiliasm Chiliasm NNP 19613 7880 13 . . . 19613 7880 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7881 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7881 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7881 3 626 626 CD 19613 7881 4 : : : 19613 7881 5 See see VB 19613 7881 6 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 7881 7 . . NNP 19613 7881 8 , , , 19613 7881 9 H. H. NNP 19613 7881 10 51 51 CD 19613 7881 11 , , , 19613 7881 12 who who WP 19613 7881 13 here here RB 19613 7881 14 falls fall VBZ 19613 7881 15 back back RB 19613 7881 16 on on IN 19613 7881 17 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 7881 18 . . . 19613 7881 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7882 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7882 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7882 3 627 627 CD 19613 7882 4 : : : 19613 7882 5 In in IN 19613 7882 6 the the DT 19613 7882 7 Christian christian JJ 19613 7882 8 village village NN 19613 7882 9 communities community NNS 19613 7882 10 of of IN 19613 7882 11 the the DT 19613 7882 12 district district NN 19613 7882 13 of of IN 19613 7882 14 Arsinoe Arsinoe NNP 19613 7882 15 the the DT 19613 7882 16 people people NNS 19613 7882 17 would would MD 19613 7882 18 not not RB 19613 7882 19 part part VB 19613 7882 20 with with IN 19613 7882 21 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 7882 22 , , , 19613 7882 23 and and CC 19613 7882 24 matters matter NNS 19613 7882 25 even even RB 19613 7882 26 went go VBD 19613 7882 27 the the DT 19613 7882 28 length length NN 19613 7882 29 of of IN 19613 7882 30 an an DT 19613 7882 31 " " `` 19613 7882 32 apostasy apostasy NN 19613 7882 33 " " '' 19613 7882 34 from from IN 19613 7882 35 the the DT 19613 7882 36 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 7882 37 Church Church NNP 19613 7882 38 . . . 19613 7883 1 A a DT 19613 7883 2 book book NN 19613 7883 3 by by IN 19613 7883 4 an an DT 19613 7883 5 Egyptian egyptian JJ 19613 7883 6 bishop bishop NN 19613 7883 7 , , , 19613 7883 8 Nepos Nepos NNP 19613 7883 9 , , , 19613 7883 10 entitled entitle VBN 19613 7883 11 " " `` 19613 7883 12 Refutation Refutation NNP 19613 7883 13 of of IN 19613 7883 14 the the DT 19613 7883 15 allegorists allegorist NNS 19613 7883 16 " " '' 19613 7883 17 attained attain VBD 19613 7883 18 the the DT 19613 7883 19 highest high JJS 19613 7883 20 repute repute NN 19613 7883 21 . . . 19613 7884 1 " " `` 19613 7884 2 They -PRON- PRP 19613 7884 3 esteem esteem VBP 19613 7884 4 the the DT 19613 7884 5 law law NN 19613 7884 6 and and CC 19613 7884 7 the the DT 19613 7884 8 prophets prophet NNS 19613 7884 9 as as IN 19613 7884 10 nothing nothing NN 19613 7884 11 , , , 19613 7884 12 neglect neglect VB 19613 7884 13 to to TO 19613 7884 14 follow follow VB 19613 7884 15 the the DT 19613 7884 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 7884 17 , , , 19613 7884 18 think think VBP 19613 7884 19 little little JJ 19613 7884 20 of of IN 19613 7884 21 the the DT 19613 7884 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 19613 7884 23 of of IN 19613 7884 24 the the DT 19613 7884 25 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 7884 26 , , , 19613 7884 27 and and CC 19613 7884 28 on on IN 19613 7884 29 the the DT 19613 7884 30 contrary contrary NN 19613 7884 31 declare declare NN 19613 7884 32 the the DT 19613 7884 33 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 7884 34 set set VBN 19613 7884 35 forth forth RP 19613 7884 36 in in IN 19613 7884 37 this this DT 19613 7884 38 book book NN 19613 7884 39 to to TO 19613 7884 40 be be VB 19613 7884 41 a a DT 19613 7884 42 really really RB 19613 7884 43 great great JJ 19613 7884 44 secret secret NN 19613 7884 45 . . . 19613 7885 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 7885 2 do do VBP 19613 7885 3 not not RB 19613 7885 4 permit permit VB 19613 7885 5 the the DT 19613 7885 6 simpler simple JJR 19613 7885 7 brethren brother NNS 19613 7885 8 among among IN 19613 7885 9 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7885 10 to to TO 19613 7885 11 obtain obtain VB 19613 7885 12 a a DT 19613 7885 13 sublime sublime JJ 19613 7885 14 and and CC 19613 7885 15 grand grand JJ 19613 7885 16 idea idea NN 19613 7885 17 of of IN 19613 7885 18 the the DT 19613 7885 19 glorious glorious JJ 19613 7885 20 and and CC 19613 7885 21 truly truly RB 19613 7885 22 divine divine JJ 19613 7885 23 appearance appearance NN 19613 7885 24 of of IN 19613 7885 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7885 26 Lord Lord NNP 19613 7885 27 , , , 19613 7885 28 of of IN 19613 7885 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7885 30 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 7885 31 from from IN 19613 7885 32 the the DT 19613 7885 33 dead dead JJ 19613 7885 34 as as RB 19613 7885 35 well well RB 19613 7885 36 as as IN 19613 7885 37 of of IN 19613 7885 38 the the DT 19613 7885 39 union union NN 19613 7885 40 and and CC 19613 7885 41 assimilation assimilation NN 19613 7885 42 with with IN 19613 7885 43 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7885 44 ; ; : 19613 7885 45 but but CC 19613 7885 46 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7885 47 persuade persuade VBP 19613 7885 48 us -PRON- PRP 19613 7885 49 to to TO 19613 7885 50 hope hope VB 19613 7885 51 for for IN 19613 7885 52 things thing NNS 19613 7885 53 petty petty JJ 19613 7885 54 , , , 19613 7885 55 perishable perishable JJ 19613 7885 56 , , , 19613 7885 57 and and CC 19613 7885 58 similar similar JJ 19613 7885 59 to to IN 19613 7885 60 the the DT 19613 7885 61 present present NN 19613 7885 62 in in IN 19613 7885 63 the the DT 19613 7885 64 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 7885 65 of of IN 19613 7885 66 God God NNP 19613 7885 67 . . . 19613 7885 68 " " '' 19613 7886 1 So so RB 19613 7886 2 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 7886 3 expressed express VBD 19613 7886 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 7886 5 , , , 19613 7886 6 and and CC 19613 7886 7 these these DT 19613 7886 8 words word NNS 19613 7886 9 are be VBP 19613 7886 10 highly highly RB 19613 7886 11 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 7886 12 of of IN 19613 7886 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7886 14 own own JJ 19613 7886 15 position position NN 19613 7886 16 and and CC 19613 7886 17 that that DT 19613 7886 18 of of IN 19613 7886 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7886 20 opponents opponent NNS 19613 7886 21 ; ; : 19613 7886 22 for for IN 19613 7886 23 in in IN 19613 7886 24 fact fact NN 19613 7886 25 the the DT 19613 7886 26 whole whole JJ 19613 7886 27 New New NNP 19613 7886 28 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7886 29 could could MD 19613 7886 30 not not RB 19613 7886 31 but but RB 19613 7886 32 be be VB 19613 7886 33 thrust thrust VBN 19613 7886 34 into into IN 19613 7886 35 the the DT 19613 7886 36 background background NN 19613 7886 37 in in IN 19613 7886 38 cases case NNS 19613 7886 39 where where WRB 19613 7886 40 the the DT 19613 7886 41 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 7886 42 hopes hope NNS 19613 7886 43 were be VBD 19613 7886 44 really really RB 19613 7886 45 adhered adhere VBN 19613 7886 46 to to IN 19613 7886 47 . . . 19613 7887 1 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 19613 7887 2 asserts assert VBZ 19613 7887 3 that that IN 19613 7887 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7887 5 convinced convince VBD 19613 7887 6 these these DT 19613 7887 7 Churches church NNS 19613 7887 8 by by IN 19613 7887 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7887 10 lectures lecture NNS 19613 7887 11 ; ; : 19613 7887 12 but but CC 19613 7887 13 chiliasm chiliasm NN 19613 7887 14 and and CC 19613 7887 15 material material NN 19613 7887 16 religious religious JJ 19613 7887 17 ideas idea NNS 19613 7887 18 were be VBD 19613 7887 19 still still RB 19613 7887 20 long long RB 19613 7887 21 preserved preserve VBN 19613 7887 22 in in IN 19613 7887 23 the the DT 19613 7887 24 deserts desert NNS 19613 7887 25 of of IN 19613 7887 26 Egypt Egypt NNP 19613 7887 27 . . . 19613 7888 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 7888 2 were be VBD 19613 7888 3 cherished cherish VBN 19613 7888 4 by by IN 19613 7888 5 the the DT 19613 7888 6 monks monk NNS 19613 7888 7 ; ; : 19613 7888 8 hence hence RB 19613 7888 9 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 7888 10 Apocalypses apocalypse NNS 19613 7888 11 accepted accept VBN 19613 7888 12 by by IN 19613 7888 13 Christians christian NNS 19613 7888 14 are be VBP 19613 7888 15 preserved preserve VBN 19613 7888 16 in in IN 19613 7888 17 the the DT 19613 7888 18 Coptic coptic JJ 19613 7888 19 and and CC 19613 7888 20 Ethiopian ethiopian JJ 19613 7888 21 languages language NNS 19613 7888 22 . . . 19613 7888 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7889 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7889 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7889 3 628 628 CD 19613 7889 4 : : : 19613 7889 5 See See NNP 19613 7889 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7889 7 lib lib NN 19613 7889 8 . . . 19613 7890 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7890 2 . . . 19613 7891 1 and and CC 19613 7891 2 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 7891 3 . . . 19613 7892 1 adv adv NNP 19613 7892 2 . . . 19613 7893 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 7893 2 . . . 19613 7894 1 lib lib NNP 19613 7894 2 . . . 19613 7895 1 II ii CD 19613 7895 2 . . . 19613 7896 1 and and CC 19613 7896 2 III III NNP 19613 7896 3 . . . 19613 7896 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7897 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7897 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7897 3 629 629 CD 19613 7897 4 : : : 19613 7897 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 7897 6 would would MD 19613 7897 7 be be VB 19613 7897 8 superfluous superfluous JJ 19613 7897 9 to to TO 19613 7897 10 quote quote VB 19613 7897 11 passages passage NNS 19613 7897 12 here here RB 19613 7897 13 ; ; : 19613 7897 14 two two CD 19613 7897 15 may may MD 19613 7897 16 stand stand VB 19613 7897 17 for for IN 19613 7897 18 all all DT 19613 7897 19 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7897 20 . . . 19613 7898 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7898 2 . . . 19613 7899 1 9 9 CD 19613 7899 2 . . . 19613 7900 1 1 1 LS 19613 7900 2 : : : 19613 7900 3 " " `` 19613 7900 4 Utraque Utraque NNP 19613 7900 5 testamenta testamenta NNP 19613 7900 6 unus unus IN 19613 7900 7 et et NNP 19613 7900 8 idem idem NN 19613 7900 9 paterfamilias paterfamilias NNP 19613 7900 10 produxit produxit NNP 19613 7900 11 , , , 19613 7900 12 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7900 13 dei dei NNP 19613 7900 14 , , , 19613 7900 15 dominus dominus NNP 19613 7900 16 noster noster NN 19613 7900 17 Iesus Iesus NNP 19613 7900 18 Christus Christus NNP 19613 7900 19 , , , 19613 7900 20 qui qui UH 19613 7900 21 et et NNP 19613 7900 22 Abrahæ Abrahæ NNP 19613 7900 23 et et FW 19613 7900 24 Moysi Moysi NNP 19613 7900 25 collocutus collocutus NN 19613 7900 26 est est NN 19613 7900 27 . . . 19613 7900 28 " " '' 19613 7901 1 Both both DT 19613 7901 2 Testaments testament NNS 19613 7901 3 are be VBP 19613 7901 4 " " `` 19613 7901 5 unius unius NNP 19613 7901 6 et et NNP 19613 7901 7 emsdem emsdem NNP 19613 7901 8 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 7901 9 . . . 19613 7901 10 " " '' 19613 7902 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7902 2 . . . 19613 7903 1 2 2 LS 19613 7903 2 . . . 19613 7904 1 3 3 LS 19613 7904 2 : : : 19613 7904 3 " " `` 19613 7904 4 Moysis moysis NN 19613 7904 5 literæ literæ NN 19613 7904 6 sunt sunt NN 19613 7904 7 verba verba NNP 19613 7904 8 Christi Christi NNP 19613 7904 9 . . . 19613 7904 10 " " '' 19613 7904 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7905 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7905 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7905 3 630 630 CD 19613 7905 4 : : : 19613 7905 5 See see VB 19613 7905 6 Iren Iren NNP 19613 7905 7 . . . 19613 7906 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7906 2 . . . 19613 7907 1 31 31 CD 19613 7907 2 . . . 19613 7908 1 1 1 LS 19613 7908 2 . . . 19613 7908 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7909 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7909 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7909 3 631 631 CD 19613 7909 4 : : : 19613 7909 5 Iren iren JJ 19613 7909 6 . . . 19613 7910 1 III iii CD 19613 7910 2 . . . 19613 7911 1 12 12 CD 19613 7911 2 . . . 19613 7912 1 15 15 CD 19613 7912 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7912 3 on on IN 19613 7912 4 Gal Gal NNP 19613 7912 5 . . . 19613 7913 1 II ii CD 19613 7913 2 . . . 19613 7914 1 11 11 CD 19613 7914 2 f. f. NNP 19613 7914 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7914 4 : : : 19613 7914 5 " " `` 19613 7914 6 Sic sic VB 19613 7914 7 apostoli apostoli JJ 19613 7914 8 , , , 19613 7914 9 quos quos JJ 19613 7914 10 universi universi JJ 19613 7914 11 actus actus NNP 19613 7914 12 et et NNP 19613 7914 13 universæ universæ NNP 19613 7914 14 doctrinæ doctrinæ NNP 19613 7914 15 dominus dominus NN 19613 7914 16 testes testis NNS 19613 7914 17 fecit fecit NN 19613 7914 18 , , , 19613 7914 19 religiose religiose JJ 19613 7914 20 agebant agebant NNP 19613 7914 21 circa circa NNP 19613 7914 22 dispositionem dispositionem NNP 19613 7914 23 legis legis NNP 19613 7914 24 , , , 19613 7914 25 qnæ qnæ NNP 19613 7914 26 ; ; : 19613 7914 27 est est NNP 19613 7914 28 secundum secundum NN 19613 7914 29 Moysem Moysem NNP 19613 7914 30 , , , 19613 7914 31 ab ab NNP 19613 7914 32 uno uno NNP 19613 7914 33 et et NNP 19613 7914 34 eodem eodem NNP 19613 7914 35 significantes significantes NNP 19613 7914 36 esse esse NNP 19613 7914 37 deo deo NNP 19613 7914 38 " " '' 19613 7914 39 ; ; : 19613 7914 40 see see VB 19613 7914 41 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 7914 42 " " '' 19613 7914 43 Ueber Ueber NNP 19613 7914 44 die die NN 19613 7914 45 Auffassung Auffassung NNP 19613 7914 46 des des FW 19613 7914 47 Streits Streits NNP 19613 7914 48 des des NNP 19613 7914 49 Paulus Paulus NNP 19613 7914 50 mit mit VBP 19613 7914 51 Petrus Petrus NNP 19613 7914 52 bei bei NNP 19613 7914 53 den den VB 19613 7914 54 Kirchenvatern Kirchenvatern NNP 19613 7914 55 , , , 19613 7914 56 " " '' 19613 7914 57 1877 1877 CD 19613 7914 58 , , , 19613 7914 59 p. p. NN 19613 7914 60 8 8 CD 19613 7914 61 f. f. NN 19613 7914 62 Similar similar JJ 19613 7914 63 remarks remark NNS 19613 7914 64 are be VBP 19613 7914 65 frequent frequent JJ 19613 7914 66 in in IN 19613 7914 67 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7914 68 . . . 19613 7914 69 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7915 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7915 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7915 3 632 632 CD 19613 7915 4 : : : 19613 7915 5 Cf Cf NNP 19613 7915 6 . . NNP 19613 7915 7 , , , 19613 7915 8 e.g. e.g. NNP 19613 7915 9 , , , 19613 7915 10 de de NNP 19613 7915 11 monog monog NNP 19613 7915 12 . . . 19613 7916 1 7 7 LS 19613 7916 2 : : : 19613 7916 3 " " `` 19613 7916 4 Certe Certe NNP 19613 7916 5 sacerdotes sacerdote VBZ 19613 7916 6 sumus sumus VBP 19613 7916 7 a a DT 19613 7916 8 Christo Christo NNP 19613 7916 9 vocati vocati NNS 19613 7916 10 , , , 19613 7916 11 monogarniæ monogarniæ NNP 19613 7916 12 debitores debitore VBZ 19613 7916 13 , , , 19613 7916 14 ex ex NNP 19613 7916 15 pristina pristina NNP 19613 7916 16 dei dei NNP 19613 7916 17 lege lege NNP 19613 7916 18 , , , 19613 7916 19 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7916 20 nos nos NNP 19613 7916 21 tune tune NNP 19613 7916 22 in in IN 19613 7916 23 suis suis NNP 19613 7916 24 sacerdotibus sacerdotibus NNP 19613 7916 25 prophetavit prophetavit NNP 19613 7916 26 . . . 19613 7916 27 " " '' 19613 7917 1 Here here RB 19613 7917 2 also also RB 19613 7917 3 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 7917 4 's 's POS 19613 7917 5 Montanism Montanism NNP 19613 7917 6 had have VBD 19613 7917 7 an an DT 19613 7917 8 effect effect NN 19613 7917 9 . . . 19613 7918 1 Though though IN 19613 7918 2 conceiving conceive VBG 19613 7918 3 the the DT 19613 7918 4 directions direction NNS 19613 7918 5 of of IN 19613 7918 6 the the DT 19613 7918 7 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 7918 8 as as IN 19613 7918 9 _ _ NNP 19613 7918 10 new new JJ 19613 7918 11 legislation legislation NN 19613 7918 12 _ _ NNP 19613 7918 13 , , , 19613 7918 14 the the DT 19613 7918 15 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 7918 16 would would MD 19613 7918 17 not not RB 19613 7918 18 renounce renounce VB 19613 7918 19 the the DT 19613 7918 20 view view NN 19613 7918 21 that that IN 19613 7918 22 these these DT 19613 7918 23 laws law NNS 19613 7918 24 were be VBD 19613 7918 25 in in IN 19613 7918 26 some some DT 19613 7918 27 way way NN 19613 7918 28 already already RB 19613 7918 29 indicated indicate VBN 19613 7918 30 in in IN 19613 7918 31 the the DT 19613 7918 32 written write VBN 19613 7918 33 documents document NNS 19613 7918 34 of of IN 19613 7918 35 revelation revelation NN 19613 7918 36 . . . 19613 7918 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7919 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7919 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7919 3 633 633 CD 19613 7919 4 : : : 19613 7919 5 Very very RB 19613 7919 6 much much JJ 19613 7919 7 may may MD 19613 7919 8 be be VB 19613 7919 9 made make VBN 19613 7919 10 out out RP 19613 7919 11 with with IN 19613 7919 12 regard regard NN 19613 7919 13 to to IN 19613 7919 14 this this DT 19613 7919 15 from from IN 19613 7919 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 7919 17 's 's POS 19613 7919 18 works work NNS 19613 7919 19 and and CC 19613 7919 20 the the DT 19613 7919 21 later later JJ 19613 7919 22 literature literature NN 19613 7919 23 , , , 19613 7919 24 particularly particularly RB 19613 7919 25 from from IN 19613 7919 26 Commodian Commodian NNP 19613 7919 27 and and CC 19613 7919 28 the the DT 19613 7919 29 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 19613 7919 30 Constitutions Constitutions NNPS 19613 7919 31 , , , 19613 7919 32 lib lib NNP 19613 7919 33 . . . 19613 7920 1 I.-VI I.-VI NNP 19613 7920 2 . . . 19613 7920 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7921 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7921 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7921 3 634 634 CD 19613 7921 4 : : : 19613 7921 5 Where where WRB 19613 7921 6 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 7921 7 needed need VBD 19613 7921 8 the the DT 19613 7921 9 proof proof NN 19613 7921 10 from from IN 19613 7921 11 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 7921 12 or or CC 19613 7921 13 indulged indulge VBN 19613 7921 14 in in IN 19613 7921 15 a a DT 19613 7921 16 devotional devotional JJ 19613 7921 17 application application NN 19613 7921 18 of of IN 19613 7921 19 the the DT 19613 7921 20 Old Old NNP 19613 7921 21 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7921 22 , , , 19613 7921 23 everything everything NN 19613 7921 24 indeed indeed RB 19613 7921 25 remained remain VBD 19613 7921 26 as as IN 19613 7921 27 before before RB 19613 7921 28 , , , 19613 7921 29 and and CC 19613 7921 30 every every DT 19613 7921 31 Old Old NNP 19613 7921 32 Testament Testament NNP 19613 7921 33 passage passage NN 19613 7921 34 was be VBD 19613 7921 35 taken take VBN 19613 7921 36 for for IN 19613 7921 37 a a DT 19613 7921 38 Christian christian JJ 19613 7921 39 one one NN 19613 7921 40 , , , 19613 7921 41 as as IN 19613 7921 42 has have VBZ 19613 7921 43 remained remain VBN 19613 7921 44 the the DT 19613 7921 45 case case NN 19613 7921 46 even even RB 19613 7921 47 to to IN 19613 7921 48 the the DT 19613 7921 49 present present JJ 19613 7921 50 day day NN 19613 7921 51 . . . 19613 7921 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7922 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7922 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7922 3 635 635 CD 19613 7922 4 : : : 19613 7922 5 With with IN 19613 7922 6 the the DT 19613 7922 7 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 19613 7922 8 view view NN 19613 7922 9 of of IN 19613 7922 10 history history NN 19613 7922 11 this this DT 19613 7922 12 newly newly RB 19613 7922 13 acquired acquire VBN 19613 7922 14 theory theory NN 19613 7922 15 has have VBZ 19613 7922 16 nothing nothing NN 19613 7922 17 in in IN 19613 7922 18 common common JJ 19613 7922 19 . . . 19613 7922 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7923 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7923 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7923 3 636 636 CD 19613 7923 4 : : : 19613 7923 5 Iren iren JJ 19613 7923 6 . . . 19613 7924 1 III iii CD 19613 7924 2 . . . 19613 7925 1 12 12 CD 19613 7925 2 . . . 19613 7926 1 11 11 CD 19613 7926 2 . . . 19613 7926 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7927 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7927 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7927 3 637 637 CD 19613 7927 4 : : : 19613 7927 5 See see VB 19613 7927 6 III iii CD 19613 7927 7 . . . 19613 7928 1 12 12 CD 19613 7928 2 . . . 19613 7929 1 12 12 CD 19613 7929 2 . . . 19613 7929 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7930 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7930 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 7930 3 638 638 CD 19613 7930 4 : : : 19613 7930 5 No no UH 19613 7930 6 _ _ NNP 19613 7930 7 commutatio commutatio NN 19613 7930 8 agnitionis agnitionis NNP 19613 7930 9 _ _ NNP 19613 7930 10 takes take VBZ 19613 7930 11 place place NN 19613 7930 12 , , , 19613 7930 13 says say VBZ 19613 7930 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7930 15 , , , 19613 7930 16 but but CC 19613 7930 17 only only RB 19613 7930 18 an an DT 19613 7930 19 increased increase VBN 19613 7930 20 gift gift NN 19613 7930 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7930 22 IV IV NNP 19613 7930 23 . . . 19613 7931 1 11 11 CD 19613 7931 2 . . . 19613 7932 1 3 3 LS 19613 7932 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7932 3 ; ; : 19613 7932 4 for for IN 19613 7932 5 the the DT 19613 7932 6 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7932 7 of of IN 19613 7932 8 God God NNP 19613 7932 9 the the DT 19613 7932 10 Creator Creator NNP 19613 7932 11 is be VBZ 19613 7932 12 " " `` 19613 7932 13 principium principium NN 19613 7932 14 evangelli evangelli NN 19613 7932 15 . . . 19613 7932 16 " " '' 19613 7933 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7933 2 III iii CD 19613 7933 3 . . . 19613 7934 1 11 11 CD 19613 7934 2 . . . 19613 7935 1 7 7 LS 19613 7935 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7935 3 . . . 19613 7935 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7936 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7936 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7936 3 639 639 CD 19613 7936 4 : : : 19613 7936 5 See see VB 19613 7936 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7936 7 . . . 19613 7937 1 11 11 CD 19613 7937 2 . . . 19613 7938 1 2 2 CD 19613 7938 2 and and CC 19613 7938 3 other other JJ 19613 7938 4 passages passage NNS 19613 7938 5 , , , 19613 7938 6 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7938 7 , , , 19613 7938 8 IV IV NNP 19613 7938 9 . . . 19613 7939 1 20 20 CD 19613 7939 2 7 7 CD 19613 7939 3 : : : 19613 7939 4 IV IV NNP 19613 7939 5 . . . 19613 7940 1 26 26 CD 19613 7940 2 . . . 19613 7941 1 1 1 LS 19613 7941 2 : : : 19613 7941 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7941 4 . . . 19613 7942 1 37 37 CD 19613 7942 2 . . . 19613 7943 1 7 7 LS 19613 7943 2 : : : 19613 7943 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7943 4 . . . 19613 7944 1 38 38 CD 19613 7944 2 . . . 19613 7945 1 1 1 CD 19613 7945 2 - - SYM 19613 7945 3 4 4 CD 19613 7945 4 . . . 19613 7945 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7946 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7946 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7946 3 640 640 CD 19613 7946 4 : : : 19613 7946 5 Several several JJ 19613 7946 6 covenants covenant NNS 19613 7946 7 I. i. NN 19613 7947 1 10 10 CD 19613 7947 2 . . . 19613 7948 1 3 3 LS 19613 7948 2 ; ; : 19613 7948 3 four four CD 19613 7948 4 covenants covenant NNS 19613 7948 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7948 6 Adam Adam NNP 19613 7948 7 , , , 19613 7948 8 Noah Noah NNP 19613 7948 9 , , , 19613 7948 10 Moses Moses NNP 19613 7948 11 , , , 19613 7948 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7948 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7948 14 III iii CD 19613 7948 15 . . . 19613 7949 1 II ii CD 19613 7949 2 . . . 19613 7950 1 8 8 LS 19613 7950 2 ; ; : 19613 7950 3 the the DT 19613 7950 4 two two CD 19613 7950 5 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 7950 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7950 7 Law Law NNP 19613 7950 8 and and CC 19613 7950 9 New New NNP 19613 7950 10 Covenant Covenant NNP 19613 7950 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7950 12 are be VBP 19613 7950 13 very very RB 19613 7950 14 frequently frequently RB 19613 7950 15 mentioned mention VBN 19613 7950 16 . . . 19613 7950 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7951 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7951 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7951 3 641 641 CD 19613 7951 4 : : : 19613 7951 5 This this DT 19613 7951 6 is be VBZ 19613 7951 7 very very RB 19613 7951 8 frequently frequently RB 19613 7951 9 mentioned mention VBN 19613 7951 10 ; ; : 19613 7951 11 see see VB 19613 7951 12 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 7951 13 , , , 19613 7951 14 IV IV NNP 19613 7951 15 . . . 19613 7952 1 13 13 CD 19613 7952 2 . . . 19613 7953 1 1 1 LS 19613 7953 2 : : : 19613 7953 3 " " `` 19613 7953 4 Et et NN 19613 7953 5 quia quia NN 19613 7953 6 dominus dominus VBP 19613 7953 7 naturalia naturalia NNP 19613 7953 8 legis legis NNP 19613 7953 9 , , , 19613 7953 10 per per IN 19613 7953 11 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7953 12 homo homo NNP 19613 7953 13 iustificatur iustificatur NNP 19613 7953 14 , , , 19613 7953 15 quæ quæ NNP 19613 7953 16 etiam etiam NNP 19613 7953 17 ante ante NNP 19613 7953 18 legisdationem legisdationem NNP 19613 7953 19 custodiebant custodiebant NNP 19613 7953 20 qui qui NNP 19613 7953 21 fide fide NNP 19613 7953 22 iustificabantur iustificabantur NNP 19613 7953 23 et et NNP 19613 7953 24 placebant placebant NN 19613 7953 25 deo deo NNP 19613 7953 26 non non AFX 19613 7953 27 dissolvit dissolvit NNP 19613 7953 28 etc etc FW 19613 7953 29 . . . 19613 7953 30 " " '' 19613 7954 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7954 2 . . . 19613 7955 1 15 15 CD 19613 7955 2 , , , 19613 7955 3 1 1 CD 19613 7955 4 . . . 19613 7955 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7956 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7956 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7956 3 642 642 CD 19613 7956 4 : : : 19613 7956 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7956 6 , , , 19613 7956 7 as as IN 19613 7956 8 a a DT 19613 7956 9 rule rule NN 19613 7956 10 , , , 19613 7956 11 views view VBZ 19613 7956 12 the the DT 19613 7956 13 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 7956 14 as as IN 19613 7956 15 perfect perfect JJ 19613 7956 16 saints saint NNS 19613 7956 17 ; ; : 19613 7956 18 see see VB 19613 7956 19 III iii CD 19613 7956 20 . . . 19613 7957 1 II ii CD 19613 7957 2 . . . 19613 7958 1 8 8 LS 19613 7958 2 : : : 19613 7958 3 " " `` 19613 7958 4 Verbum Verbum NNP 19613 7958 5 dei dei NNP 19613 7958 6 illis illis NNP 19613 7958 7 quidem quidem NNP 19613 7958 8 qui qui NNP 19613 7958 9 ante ante NNP 19613 7958 10 Moysem Moysem NNP 19613 7958 11 fuerunt fuerunt NN 19613 7958 12 patriarchis patriarchis NNP 19613 7958 13 secundum secundum NN 19613 7958 14 divinitatem divinitatem NNP 19613 7958 15 et et NNP 19613 7958 16 gloriam gloriam NNP 19613 7958 17 colloquebatur colloquebatur NN 19613 7958 18 " " '' 19613 7958 19 , , , 19613 7958 20 and and CC 19613 7958 21 especially especially RB 19613 7958 22 IV IV NNP 19613 7958 23 . . . 19613 7959 1 16 16 CD 19613 7959 2 . . . 19613 7960 1 3 3 LS 19613 7960 2 . . . 19613 7961 1 As as IN 19613 7961 2 to to IN 19613 7961 3 the the DT 19613 7961 4 Son Son NNP 19613 7961 5 's 's POS 19613 7961 6 having have VBG 19613 7961 7 descended descend VBN 19613 7961 8 from from IN 19613 7961 9 the the DT 19613 7961 10 beginning beginning NN 19613 7961 11 and and CC 19613 7961 12 having have VBG 19613 7961 13 thus thus RB 19613 7961 14 appeared appear VBN 19613 7961 15 to to IN 19613 7961 16 the the DT 19613 7961 17 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 7961 18 also also RB 19613 7961 19 , , , 19613 7961 20 see see VB 19613 7961 21 IV IV NNP 19613 7961 22 . . . 19613 7962 1 6 6 CD 19613 7962 2 . . . 19613 7963 1 7 7 LS 19613 7963 2 . . . 19613 7964 1 Not not RB 19613 7964 2 merely merely RB 19613 7964 3 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 7964 4 but but CC 19613 7964 5 all all PDT 19613 7964 6 the the DT 19613 7964 7 other other JJ 19613 7964 8 exponents exponent NNS 19613 7964 9 of of IN 19613 7964 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 7964 11 knew know VBD 19613 7964 12 both both CC 19613 7964 13 the the DT 19613 7964 14 Father Father NNP 19613 7964 15 and and CC 19613 7964 16 the the DT 19613 7964 17 Son Son NNP 19613 7964 18 . . . 19613 7965 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 7965 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 7965 3 was be VBD 19613 7965 4 also also RB 19613 7965 5 obliged oblige VBN 19613 7965 6 to to TO 19613 7965 7 descend descend VB 19613 7965 8 to to IN 19613 7965 9 the the DT 19613 7965 10 lower low JJR 19613 7965 11 world world NN 19613 7965 12 to to IN 19613 7965 13 the the DT 19613 7965 14 righteous righteous JJ 19613 7965 15 , , , 19613 7965 16 the the DT 19613 7965 17 prophets prophet NNS 19613 7965 18 , , , 19613 7965 19 and and CC 19613 7965 20 the the DT 19613 7965 21 patriarchs patriarch NNS 19613 7965 22 , , , 19613 7965 23 in in IN 19613 7965 24 order order NN 19613 7965 25 to to TO 19613 7965 26 bring bring VB 19613 7965 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 7965 28 forgiveness forgiveness NN 19613 7965 29 of of IN 19613 7965 30 sins sin NNS 19613 7965 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 7965 32 IV IV NNP 19613 7965 33 . . . 19613 7966 1 27 27 CD 19613 7966 2 . . . 19613 7967 1 2 2 LS 19613 7967 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 7967 3 . . . 19613 7967 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7968 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7968 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7968 3 643 643 CD 19613 7968 4 : : : 19613 7968 5 On on IN 19613 7968 6 the the DT 19613 7968 7 contrary contrary NN 19613 7968 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7968 9 agrees agree VBZ 19613 7968 10 with with IN 19613 7968 11 the the DT 19613 7968 12 teachings teaching NNS 19613 7968 13 of of IN 19613 7968 14 a a DT 19613 7968 15 presbyter presbyter NN 19613 7968 16 , , , 19613 7968 17 whom whom WP 19613 7968 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 7968 19 frequently frequently RB 19613 7968 20 quotes quote VBZ 19613 7968 21 in in IN 19613 7968 22 the the DT 19613 7968 23 4th 4th JJ 19613 7968 24 Book book NN 19613 7968 25 . . . 19613 7969 1 To to IN 19613 7969 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7969 3 the the DT 19613 7969 4 heathen heathen NN 19613 7969 5 are be VBP 19613 7969 6 simply simply RB 19613 7969 7 idolaters idolater NNS 19613 7969 8 who who WP 19613 7969 9 have have VBP 19613 7969 10 even even RB 19613 7969 11 forgotten forget VBN 19613 7969 12 the the DT 19613 7969 13 law law NN 19613 7969 14 written write VBN 19613 7969 15 in in IN 19613 7969 16 the the DT 19613 7969 17 heart heart NN 19613 7969 18 ; ; : 19613 7969 19 wherefore wherefore VBD 19613 7969 20 the the DT 19613 7969 21 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 7969 22 stand stand VBP 19613 7969 23 much much RB 19613 7969 24 higher high JJR 19613 7969 25 , , , 19613 7969 26 for for IN 19613 7969 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7969 28 only only RB 19613 7969 29 lacked lack VBD 19613 7969 30 the the DT 19613 7969 31 _ _ NNP 19613 7969 32 agnitio agnitio NN 19613 7969 33 filii filii NNP 19613 7969 34 _ _ NNP 19613 7969 35 . . . 19613 7970 1 See see VB 19613 7970 2 III iii CD 19613 7970 3 . . . 19613 7971 1 5 5 CD 19613 7971 2 . . . 19613 7972 1 3 3 LS 19613 7972 2 : : : 19613 7972 3 III iii CD 19613 7972 4 . . . 19613 7973 1 10 10 CD 19613 7973 2 . . . 19613 7974 1 3 3 LS 19613 7974 2 : : : 19613 7974 3 III iii CD 19613 7974 4 . . . 19613 7975 1 12 12 CD 19613 7975 2 . . . 19613 7976 1 7 7 LS 19613 7976 2 , , , 19613 7976 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7976 4 . . . 19613 7977 1 23 23 CD 19613 7977 2 , , , 19613 7977 3 24 24 CD 19613 7977 4 . . . 19613 7978 1 Yet yet CC 19613 7978 2 there there EX 19613 7978 3 is be VBZ 19613 7978 4 still still RB 19613 7978 5 a a DT 19613 7978 6 great great JJ 19613 7978 7 want want NN 19613 7978 8 of of IN 19613 7978 9 clearness clearness NN 19613 7978 10 here here RB 19613 7978 11 . . . 19613 7979 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7979 2 can can MD 19613 7979 3 not not RB 19613 7979 4 get get VB 19613 7979 5 rid rid VBN 19613 7979 6 of of IN 19613 7979 7 the the DT 19613 7979 8 following follow VBG 19613 7979 9 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 7979 10 . . . 19613 7980 1 The the DT 19613 7980 2 pre pre JJ 19613 7980 3 - - JJ 19613 7980 4 Christian christian JJ 19613 7980 5 righteous righteous JJ 19613 7980 6 know know VBP 19613 7980 7 the the DT 19613 7980 8 Son Son NNP 19613 7980 9 and and CC 19613 7980 10 do do VBP 19613 7980 11 not not RB 19613 7980 12 know know VB 19613 7980 13 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7980 14 ; ; : 19613 7980 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 7980 16 require require VBP 19613 7980 17 the the DT 19613 7980 18 appearance appearance NN 19613 7980 19 of of IN 19613 7980 20 the the DT 19613 7980 21 Son Son NNP 19613 7980 22 and and CC 19613 7980 23 do do VBP 19613 7980 24 not not RB 19613 7980 25 require require VB 19613 7980 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7980 27 ; ; : 19613 7980 28 and and CC 19613 7980 29 the the DT 19613 7980 30 _ _ NNP 19613 7980 31 agnitio agnitio NN 19613 7980 32 filii filii NNP 19613 7980 33 _ _ NNP 19613 7980 34 seems seem VBZ 19613 7980 35 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 7980 36 a a DT 19613 7980 37 new new JJ 19613 7980 38 , , , 19613 7980 39 and and CC 19613 7980 40 in in IN 19613 7980 41 fact fact NN 19613 7980 42 the the DT 19613 7980 43 decisive decisive NN 19613 7980 44 , , , 19613 7980 45 _ _ NNP 19613 7980 46 veritas veritas NNP 19613 7980 47 _ _ NNP 19613 7980 48 , , , 19613 7980 49 and and CC 19613 7980 50 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 7980 51 that that DT 19613 7980 52 involved involved JJ 19613 7980 53 in in IN 19613 7980 54 the the DT 19613 7980 55 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 7980 56 of of IN 19613 7980 57 God God NNP 19613 7980 58 the the DT 19613 7980 59 Creator Creator NNP 19613 7980 60 . . . 19613 7980 61 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7981 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7981 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7981 3 644 644 CD 19613 7981 4 : : : 19613 7981 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 7981 6 IV IV NNP 19613 7981 7 . . . 19613 7982 1 16 16 CD 19613 7982 2 . . . 19613 7983 1 3 3 LS 19613 7983 2 . . . 19613 7984 1 See see VB 19613 7984 2 IV IV NNP 19613 7984 3 . . . 19613 7985 1 15 15 CD 19613 7985 2 . . . 19613 7986 1 1 1 LS 19613 7986 2 : : : 19613 7986 3 " " `` 19613 7986 4 Decalogum Decalogum NNP 19613 7986 5 si si NN 19613 7986 6 quis quis NNP 19613 7986 7 non non AFX 19613 7986 8 fecerit fecerit NNP 19613 7986 9 , , , 19613 7986 10 non non AFX 19613 7986 11 habet habet NNP 19613 7986 12 salutem salutem NNP 19613 7986 13 " " '' 19613 7986 14 . . . 19613 7986 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 7987 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 7987 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 7987 3 645 645 CD 19613 7987 4 : : : 19613 7987 5 As as IN 19613 7987 6 the the DT 19613 7987 7 Son Son NNP 19613 7987 8 has have VBZ 19613 7987 9 manifested manifest VBN 19613 7987 10 the the DT 19613 7987 11 Father Father NNP 19613 7987 12 from from IN 19613 7987 13 of of IN 19613 7987 14 old old JJ 19613 7987 15 , , , 19613 7987 16 so so RB 19613 7987 17 also also RB 19613 7987 18 the the DT 19613 7987 19 law law NN 19613 7987 20 , , , 19613 7987 21 and and CC 19613 7987 22 indeed indeed RB 19613 7987 23 even even RB 19613 7987 24 the the DT 19613 7987 25 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 7987 26 law law NN 19613 7987 27 , , , 19613 7987 28 is be VBZ 19613 7987 29 to to TO 19613 7987 30 be be VB 19613 7987 31 traced trace VBN 19613 7987 32 back back RB 19613 7987 33 to to IN 19613 7987 34 him -PRON- PRP 19613 7987 35 . . . 19613 7988 1 See see VB 19613 7988 2 IV IV NNP 19613 7988 3 . . . 19613 7989 1 6 6 CD 19613 7989 2 . . . 19613 7990 1 7 7 LS 19613 7990 2 : : : 19613 7990 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7990 4 . . . 19613 7991 1 12 12 CD 19613 7991 2 . . . 19613 7992 1 4 4 LS 19613 7992 2 : : : 19613 7992 3 IV IV NNP 19613 7992 4 . . . 19613 7993 1 14 14 CD 19613 7993 2 . . . 19613 7994 1 2 2 LS 19613 7994 2 : : : 19613 7994 3 " " `` 19613 7994 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 7994 5 qui qui NNP 19613 7994 6 inquieti inquieti NN 19613 7994 7 erant erant NN 19613 7994 8 in in IN 19613 7994 9 eremo eremo NNP 19613 7994 10 dans dan NNS 19613 7994 11 aptissimam aptissimam NN 19613 7994 12 legem legem NNS 19613 7994 13 ... ... NFP 19613 7994 14 per per IN 19613 7994 15 omnes omne NNS 19613 7994 16 transiens transiens NNPS 19613 7994 17 verbum verbum NNP 19613 7994 18 omni omni NNP 19613 7994 19 conditioni conditioni NNP 19613 7994 20 congruentem congruentem NNP 19613 7994 21 et et NNP 19613 7994 22 aptam aptam NNP 19613 7994 23 legem legem NNP 19613 7994 24 conscribens conscriben VBZ 19613 7994 25 " " '' 19613 7994 26 . . . 19613 7995 1 IV IV NNP 19613 7995 2 . . . 19613 7996 1 4 4 LS 19613 7996 2 . . . 19613 7997 1 2 2 LS 19613 7997 2 . . . 19613 7998 1 The the DT 19613 7998 2 law law NN 19613 7998 3 is be VBZ 19613 7998 4 a a DT 19613 7998 5 law law NN 19613 7998 6 of of IN 19613 7998 7 bondage bondage NN 19613 7998 8 ; ; : 19613 7998 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7998 10 was be VBD 19613 7998 11 just just RB 19613 7998 12 in in IN 19613 7998 13 that that DT 19613 7998 14 capacity capacity NN 19613 7998 15 that that IN 19613 7998 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 7998 17 was be VBD 19613 7998 18 necessary necessary JJ 19613 7998 19 ; ; : 19613 7998 20 see see VB 19613 7998 21 IV IV NNP 19613 7998 22 . . . 19613 7999 1 4 4 LS 19613 7999 2 . . . 19613 8000 1 1 1 LS 19613 8000 2 : : : 19613 8000 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8000 4 . . . 19613 8001 1 9 9 CD 19613 8001 2 . . . 19613 8002 1 1 1 LS 19613 8002 2 : : : 19613 8002 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8002 4 . . . 19613 8003 1 13 13 CD 19613 8003 2 . . . 19613 8004 1 2 2 CD 19613 8004 2 , , , 19613 8004 3 4 4 CD 19613 8004 4 : : : 19613 8004 5 IV IV NNP 19613 8004 6 . . . 19613 8005 1 14 14 CD 19613 8005 2 . . . 19613 8006 1 3 3 LS 19613 8006 2 : : : 19613 8006 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8006 4 . . . 19613 8007 1 15 15 CD 19613 8007 2 : : : 19613 8007 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8007 4 . . . 19613 8008 1 16 16 CD 19613 8008 2 : : : 19613 8008 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8008 4 . . . 19613 8009 1 32 32 CD 19613 8009 2 : : : 19613 8009 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8009 4 . . . 19613 8010 1 36 36 CD 19613 8010 2 . . . 19613 8011 1 A a DT 19613 8011 2 part part NN 19613 8011 3 of of IN 19613 8011 4 the the DT 19613 8011 5 commandments commandment NNS 19613 8011 6 are be VBP 19613 8011 7 concessions concession NNS 19613 8011 8 on on IN 19613 8011 9 account account NN 19613 8011 10 of of IN 19613 8011 11 hardness hardness NN 19613 8011 12 of of IN 19613 8011 13 heart heart NN 19613 8011 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8011 15 IV IV NNP 19613 8011 16 . . . 19613 8012 1 15 15 CD 19613 8012 2 . . . 19613 8013 1 2 2 LS 19613 8013 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8013 3 . . . 19613 8014 1 But but CC 19613 8014 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8014 3 still still RB 19613 8014 4 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 8014 5 very very RB 19613 8014 6 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 8014 7 between between IN 19613 8014 8 the the DT 19613 8014 9 " " `` 19613 8014 10 people people NNS 19613 8014 11 " " '' 19613 8014 12 and and CC 19613 8014 13 the the DT 19613 8014 14 prophets prophet NNS 19613 8014 15 . . . 19613 8015 1 This this DT 19613 8015 2 is be VBZ 19613 8015 3 a a DT 19613 8015 4 survival survival NN 19613 8015 5 of of IN 19613 8015 6 the the DT 19613 8015 7 old old JJ 19613 8015 8 view view NN 19613 8015 9 . . . 19613 8016 1 The the DT 19613 8016 2 prophets prophet NNS 19613 8016 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8016 4 said say VBD 19613 8016 5 knew know VBD 19613 8016 6 very very RB 19613 8016 7 well well RB 19613 8016 8 of of IN 19613 8016 9 the the DT 19613 8016 10 coming coming NN 19613 8016 11 of of IN 19613 8016 12 the the DT 19613 8016 13 Son Son NNP 19613 8016 14 of of IN 19613 8016 15 God God NNP 19613 8016 16 and and CC 19613 8016 17 the the DT 19613 8016 18 granting granting NN 19613 8016 19 of of IN 19613 8016 20 a a DT 19613 8016 21 new new JJ 19613 8016 22 covenant covenant NN 19613 8016 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8016 24 IV IV NNP 19613 8016 25 . . . 19613 8017 1 9 9 CD 19613 8017 2 . . . 19613 8018 1 3 3 LS 19613 8018 2 : : : 19613 8018 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8018 4 . . . 19613 8019 1 20 20 CD 19613 8019 2 . . . 19613 8020 1 4 4 CD 19613 8020 2 , , , 19613 8020 3 5 5 CD 19613 8020 4 : : : 19613 8020 5 IV IV NNP 19613 8020 6 . . . 19613 8021 1 33 33 CD 19613 8021 2 . . . 19613 8022 1 10 10 CD 19613 8022 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8022 3 ; ; : 19613 8022 4 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8022 5 understood understand VBD 19613 8022 6 what what WP 19613 8022 7 was be VBD 19613 8022 8 typified typify VBN 19613 8022 9 by by IN 19613 8022 10 the the DT 19613 8022 11 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 8022 12 law law NN 19613 8022 13 , , , 19613 8022 14 and and CC 19613 8022 15 to to IN 19613 8022 16 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8022 17 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8022 18 the the DT 19613 8022 19 law law NN 19613 8022 20 had have VBD 19613 8022 21 only only RB 19613 8022 22 a a DT 19613 8022 23 typical typical JJ 19613 8022 24 signification signification NN 19613 8022 25 . . . 19613 8023 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8023 2 , , , 19613 8023 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8023 4 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8023 5 came come VBD 19613 8023 6 to to IN 19613 8023 7 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8023 8 ever ever RB 19613 8023 9 and and CC 19613 8023 10 anon anon VB 19613 8023 11 through through IN 19613 8023 12 the the DT 19613 8023 13 prophetic prophetic JJ 19613 8023 14 spirit spirit NN 19613 8023 15 . . . 19613 8024 1 The the DT 19613 8024 2 preparation preparation NN 19613 8024 3 for for IN 19613 8024 4 the the DT 19613 8024 5 new new JJ 19613 8024 6 covenant covenant NN 19613 8024 7 is be VBZ 19613 8024 8 therefore therefore RB 19613 8024 9 found find VBN 19613 8024 10 in in IN 19613 8024 11 the the DT 19613 8024 12 prophets prophet NNS 19613 8024 13 and and CC 19613 8024 14 in in IN 19613 8024 15 the the DT 19613 8024 16 typical typical JJ 19613 8024 17 character character NN 19613 8024 18 of of IN 19613 8024 19 the the DT 19613 8024 20 old old JJ 19613 8024 21 . . . 19613 8025 1 Abraham Abraham NNP 19613 8025 2 has have VBZ 19613 8025 3 this this DT 19613 8025 4 peculiarity peculiarity NN 19613 8025 5 , , , 19613 8025 6 that that IN 19613 8025 7 both both DT 19613 8025 8 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 8025 9 were be VBD 19613 8025 10 prefigured prefigure VBN 19613 8025 11 in in IN 19613 8025 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8025 13 : : : 19613 8025 14 the the DT 19613 8025 15 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8025 16 of of IN 19613 8025 17 faith faith NN 19613 8025 18 , , , 19613 8025 19 because because IN 19613 8025 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8025 21 was be VBD 19613 8025 22 justified justify VBN 19613 8025 23 before before IN 19613 8025 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8025 25 circumcision circumcision NN 19613 8025 26 , , , 19613 8025 27 and and CC 19613 8025 28 the the DT 19613 8025 29 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8025 30 of of IN 19613 8025 31 the the DT 19613 8025 32 law law NN 19613 8025 33 . . . 19613 8026 1 The the DT 19613 8026 2 latter latter JJ 19613 8026 3 occupied occupy VBD 19613 8026 4 " " `` 19613 8026 5 the the DT 19613 8026 6 middle middle NNP 19613 8026 7 times times NNP 19613 8026 8 " " '' 19613 8026 9 , , , 19613 8026 10 and and CC 19613 8026 11 therefore therefore RB 19613 8026 12 come come VBP 19613 8026 13 in in RP 19613 8026 14 between between IN 19613 8026 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8026 16 IV IV NNP 19613 8026 17 . . . 19613 8027 1 25 25 CD 19613 8027 2 . . . 19613 8028 1 1 1 LS 19613 8028 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8028 3 . . . 19613 8029 1 This this DT 19613 8029 2 is be VBZ 19613 8029 3 a a DT 19613 8029 4 Pauline Pauline NNP 19613 8029 5 thought thought NN 19613 8029 6 , , , 19613 8029 7 though though IN 19613 8029 8 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 8029 9 indeed indeed RB 19613 8029 10 there there EX 19613 8029 11 is be VBZ 19613 8029 12 not not RB 19613 8029 13 much much JJ 19613 8029 14 in in IN 19613 8029 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8029 16 to to TO 19613 8029 17 remind remind VB 19613 8029 18 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8029 19 of of IN 19613 8029 20 Paul Paul NNP 19613 8029 21 , , , 19613 8029 22 because because IN 19613 8029 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8029 24 used use VBD 19613 8029 25 the the DT 19613 8029 26 moral moral JJ 19613 8029 27 categories category NNS 19613 8029 28 , , , 19613 8029 29 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 30 growth growth NN 19613 8029 31 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 32 and and CC 19613 8029 33 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 34 training training NN 19613 8029 35 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 36 , , , 19613 8029 37 instead instead RB 19613 8029 38 of of IN 19613 8029 39 the the DT 19613 8029 40 religious religious JJ 19613 8029 41 ones one NNS 19613 8029 42 , , , 19613 8029 43 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 44 sin sin NN 19613 8029 45 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 46 and and CC 19613 8029 47 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 48 grace grace NN 19613 8029 49 _ _ NNP 19613 8029 50 . . . 19613 8029 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8030 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8030 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8030 3 646 646 CD 19613 8030 4 : : : 19613 8030 5 The the DT 19613 8030 6 law law NN 19613 8030 7 , , , 19613 8030 8 i.e. i.e. FW 19613 8030 9 , , , 19613 8030 10 the the DT 19613 8030 11 ceremonial ceremonial JJ 19613 8030 12 law law NN 19613 8030 13 , , , 19613 8030 14 reaches reach VBZ 19613 8030 15 down down RP 19613 8030 16 to to IN 19613 8030 17 John John NNP 19613 8030 18 , , , 19613 8030 19 IV IV NNP 19613 8030 20 . . . 19613 8031 1 4 4 LS 19613 8031 2 . . . 19613 8032 1 2 2 LS 19613 8032 2 . . . 19613 8033 1 The the DT 19613 8033 2 New New NNP 19613 8033 3 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8033 4 is be VBZ 19613 8033 5 a a DT 19613 8033 6 law law NN 19613 8033 7 of of IN 19613 8033 8 freedom freedom NN 19613 8033 9 , , , 19613 8033 10 because because IN 19613 8033 11 through through IN 19613 8033 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8033 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8033 14 are be VBP 19613 8033 15 adopted adopt VBN 19613 8033 16 as as IN 19613 8033 17 sons son NNS 19613 8033 18 of of IN 19613 8033 19 God God NNP 19613 8033 20 , , , 19613 8033 21 III III NNP 19613 8033 22 . . . 19613 8034 1 5 5 CD 19613 8034 2 . . . 19613 8035 1 3 3 LS 19613 8035 2 : : : 19613 8035 3 III iii CD 19613 8035 4 . . . 19613 8036 1 10 10 CD 19613 8036 2 . . . 19613 8037 1 5 5 CD 19613 8037 2 : : : 19613 8037 3 III iii CD 19613 8037 4 . . . 19613 8038 1 12 12 CD 19613 8038 2 . . . 19613 8039 1 5 5 CD 19613 8039 2 : : : 19613 8039 3 III iii CD 19613 8039 4 . . . 19613 8040 1 12 12 CD 19613 8040 2 . . . 19613 8041 1 14 14 CD 19613 8041 2 : : : 19613 8041 3 III iii CD 19613 8041 4 . . . 19613 8042 1 15 15 CD 19613 8042 2 . . . 19613 8043 1 3 3 LS 19613 8043 2 : : : 19613 8043 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8043 4 . . . 19613 8044 1 9 9 CD 19613 8044 2 . . . 19613 8045 1 1 1 CD 19613 8045 2 , , , 19613 8045 3 2 2 CD 19613 8045 4 : : : 19613 8045 5 IV IV NNP 19613 8045 6 . . . 19613 8046 1 11 11 CD 19613 8046 2 . . . 19613 8047 1 1 1 LS 19613 8047 2 : : : 19613 8047 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8047 4 . . . 19613 8048 1 13 13 CD 19613 8048 2 . . . 19613 8049 1 2 2 CD 19613 8049 2 , , , 19613 8049 3 4 4 CD 19613 8049 4 : : : 19613 8049 5 IV IV NNP 19613 8049 6 . . . 19613 8050 1 15 15 CD 19613 8050 2 . . . 19613 8051 1 1 1 CD 19613 8051 2 , , , 19613 8051 3 2 2 CD 19613 8051 4 : : : 19613 8051 5 IV IV NNP 19613 8051 6 . . . 19613 8052 1 16 16 CD 19613 8052 2 . . . 19613 8053 1 5 5 LS 19613 8053 2 : : : 19613 8053 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8053 4 . . . 19613 8054 1 18 18 CD 19613 8054 2 : : : 19613 8054 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8054 4 . . . 19613 8055 1 32 32 CD 19613 8055 2 : : : 19613 8055 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8055 4 . . . 19613 8056 1 34 34 CD 19613 8056 2 . . . 19613 8057 1 1 1 LS 19613 8057 2 : : : 19613 8057 3 IV IV NNP 19613 8057 4 . . . 19613 8058 1 36 36 CD 19613 8058 2 . . . 19613 8059 1 2 2 LS 19613 8059 2 . . . 19613 8060 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8060 2 did do VBD 19613 8060 3 not not RB 19613 8060 4 abolish abolish VB 19613 8060 5 the the DT 19613 8060 6 _ _ NNP 19613 8060 7 natus natus NN 19613 8060 8 alia alia NNP 19613 8060 9 legis legis NNP 19613 8060 10 _ _ NNP 19613 8060 11 , , , 19613 8060 12 the the DT 19613 8060 13 Decalogue Decalogue NNP 19613 8060 14 , , , 19613 8060 15 but but CC 19613 8060 16 extended extended JJ 19613 8060 17 and and CC 19613 8060 18 fulfilled fulfil VBD 19613 8060 19 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8060 20 ; ; : 19613 8060 21 here here RB 19613 8060 22 the the DT 19613 8060 23 old old JJ 19613 8060 24 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 8060 25 - - HYPH 19613 8060 26 Christian christian JJ 19613 8060 27 moral moral JJ 19613 8060 28 conception conception NN 19613 8060 29 based base VBN 19613 8060 30 on on IN 19613 8060 31 the the DT 19613 8060 32 Sermon Sermon NNP 19613 8060 33 on on IN 19613 8060 34 the the DT 19613 8060 35 Mount Mount NNP 19613 8060 36 , , , 19613 8060 37 prevails prevail VBZ 19613 8060 38 . . . 19613 8061 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8061 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8061 3 now now RB 19613 8061 4 shows show VBZ 19613 8061 5 that that IN 19613 8061 6 in in IN 19613 8061 7 the the DT 19613 8061 8 case case NN 19613 8061 9 of of IN 19613 8061 10 the the DT 19613 8061 11 children child NNS 19613 8061 12 of of IN 19613 8061 13 freedom freedom NN 19613 8061 14 the the DT 19613 8061 15 situation situation NN 19613 8061 16 has have VBZ 19613 8061 17 become become VBN 19613 8061 18 much much RB 19613 8061 19 more more RBR 19613 8061 20 serious serious JJ 19613 8061 21 , , , 19613 8061 22 and and CC 19613 8061 23 that that IN 19613 8061 24 the the DT 19613 8061 25 judgments judgment NNS 19613 8061 26 are be VBP 19613 8061 27 now now RB 19613 8061 28 much much RB 19613 8061 29 more more RBR 19613 8061 30 threatening threatening JJ 19613 8061 31 . . . 19613 8062 1 Finally finally RB 19613 8062 2 , , , 19613 8062 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8062 4 proves prove VBZ 19613 8062 5 that that IN 19613 8062 6 the the DT 19613 8062 7 fulfilling fulfilling NN 19613 8062 8 , , , 19613 8062 9 extending extending NN 19613 8062 10 , , , 19613 8062 11 and and CC 19613 8062 12 sharpening sharpening NN 19613 8062 13 of of IN 19613 8062 14 the the DT 19613 8062 15 law law NN 19613 8062 16 form form VBP 19613 8062 17 a a DT 19613 8062 18 contrast contrast NN 19613 8062 19 to to IN 19613 8062 20 the the DT 19613 8062 21 blunting blunting NN 19613 8062 22 of of IN 19613 8062 23 the the DT 19613 8062 24 natural natural JJ 19613 8062 25 moral moral JJ 19613 8062 26 law law NN 19613 8062 27 by by IN 19613 8062 28 the the DT 19613 8062 29 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 19613 8062 30 and and CC 19613 8062 31 elders elder NNS 19613 8062 32 ; ; : 19613 8062 33 see see VB 19613 8062 34 IV IV NNP 19613 8062 35 . . . 19613 8063 1 12 12 CD 19613 8063 2 . . . 19613 8064 1 1 1 CD 19613 8064 2 ff ff NNP 19613 8064 3 . . . 19613 8065 1 : : : 19613 8065 2 " " `` 19613 8065 3 Austero Austero NNP 19613 8065 4 dei dei NNP 19613 8065 5 præcepto præcepto NN 19613 8065 6 miscent miscent NN 19613 8065 7 seniores seniore VBZ 19613 8065 8 aquatam aquatam NNP 19613 8065 9 traditionem traditionem NNP 19613 8065 10 " " '' 19613 8065 11 . . . 19613 8066 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8066 2 . . . 19613 8067 1 13 13 CD 19613 8067 2 . . . 19613 8068 1 1 1 LS 19613 8068 2 . . . 19613 8068 3 f. f. NNP 19613 8068 4 : : : 19613 8068 5 " " `` 19613 8068 6 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8068 7 naturalia naturalia NN 19613 8068 8 legis legi NNS 19613 8068 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8068 10 which which WDT 19613 8068 11 are be VBP 19613 8068 12 summed sum VBN 19613 8068 13 up up RP 19613 8068 14 in in IN 19613 8068 15 the the DT 19613 8068 16 commandment commandment NN 19613 8068 17 of of IN 19613 8068 18 love love NN 19613 8068 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8068 20 extendit extendit VBP 19613 8068 21 et et FW 19613 8068 22 implevit implevit NNP 19613 8068 23 ... ... : 19613 8068 24 plenitudo plenitudo NNP 19613 8068 25 et et NNP 19613 8068 26 extensio extensio NNP 19613 8068 27 ... ... NFP 19613 8068 28 necesse necesse NNP 19613 8068 29 fuit fuit NNP 19613 8068 30 , , , 19613 8068 31 auferri auferri NNP 19613 8068 32 quidem quidem NNP 19613 8068 33 vincula vincula NNP 19613 8068 34 servitutis servitutis NNP 19613 8068 35 , , , 19613 8068 36 superextendi superextendi NN 19613 8068 37 vero vero NNP 19613 8068 38 decreta decreta NNP 19613 8068 39 libertatis libertatis NNP 19613 8068 40 " " '' 19613 8068 41 . . . 19613 8069 1 That that DT 19613 8069 2 is be VBZ 19613 8069 3 proved prove VBN 19613 8069 4 in in IN 19613 8069 5 the the DT 19613 8069 6 next next JJ 19613 8069 7 passage passage NN 19613 8069 8 from from IN 19613 8069 9 the the DT 19613 8069 10 Sermon Sermon NNP 19613 8069 11 on on IN 19613 8069 12 the the DT 19613 8069 13 Mount Mount NNP 19613 8069 14 : : : 19613 8069 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8069 16 must must MD 19613 8069 17 not not RB 19613 8069 18 only only RB 19613 8069 19 refrain refrain VB 19613 8069 20 from from IN 19613 8069 21 evil evil JJ 19613 8069 22 works work NNS 19613 8069 23 , , , 19613 8069 24 but but CC 19613 8069 25 also also RB 19613 8069 26 from from IN 19613 8069 27 evil evil JJ 19613 8069 28 desire desire NN 19613 8069 29 . . . 19613 8070 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8070 2 . . . 19613 8071 1 16 16 CD 19613 8071 2 . . . 19613 8072 1 5 5 CD 19613 8072 2 : : : 19613 8072 3 " " `` 19613 8072 4 Hæc Hæc NNP 19613 8072 5 ergo ergo NN 19613 8072 6 , , , 19613 8072 7 quæ quæ NN 19613 8072 8 in in IN 19613 8072 9 servitutem servitutem NNP 19613 8072 10 et et NNP 19613 8072 11 in in IN 19613 8072 12 signum signum NNP 19613 8072 13 data datum NNS 19613 8072 14 sunt sunt NN 19613 8072 15 illis illis NNP 19613 8072 16 , , , 19613 8072 17 circumscripsit circumscripsit NNP 19613 8072 18 novo novo NNP 19613 8072 19 libertatis libertatis NNP 19613 8072 20 testamento testamento NNP 19613 8072 21 . . . 19613 8073 1 Quæ Quæ NNP 19613 8073 2 autem autem NNP 19613 8073 3 naturalia naturalia NNP 19613 8073 4 et et NNP 19613 8073 5 liberalia liberalia NNP 19613 8073 6 et et NNP 19613 8073 7 communia communia NNP 19613 8073 8 omnium omnium NNP 19613 8073 9 , , , 19613 8073 10 auxit auxit NNP 19613 8073 11 et et NNP 19613 8073 12 dilatavit dilatavit JJ 19613 8073 13 , , , 19613 8073 14 sine sine NNP 19613 8073 15 invidia invidia NNP 19613 8073 16 largiter largiter NNP 19613 8073 17 donans donans NNPS 19613 8073 18 hominibus hominibus NNP 19613 8073 19 per per IN 19613 8073 20 adoptionem adoptionem NNP 19613 8073 21 , , , 19613 8073 22 patrem patrem NN 19613 8073 23 scire scire NN 19613 8073 24 deum deum NN 19613 8073 25 ... ... : 19613 8073 26 auxit auxit NNP 19613 8073 27 autem autem NNP 19613 8073 28 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8073 29 timorem timorem NN 19613 8073 30 : : : 19613 8073 31 filios filio NNS 19613 8073 32 enim enim NNP 19613 8073 33 plus plus CC 19613 8073 34 timere timere NNP 19613 8073 35 oportet oportet NNP 19613 8073 36 quam quam NNP 19613 8073 37 servos servos NNP 19613 8073 38 " " '' 19613 8073 39 . . . 19613 8074 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8074 2 . . . 19613 8075 1 27 27 CD 19613 8075 2 . . . 19613 8076 1 2 2 LS 19613 8076 2 . . . 19613 8077 1 The the DT 19613 8077 2 new new JJ 19613 8077 3 situation situation NN 19613 8077 4 is be VBZ 19613 8077 5 a a DT 19613 8077 6 more more RBR 19613 8077 7 serious serious JJ 19613 8077 8 one one NN 19613 8077 9 ; ; : 19613 8077 10 the the DT 19613 8077 11 Old Old NNP 19613 8077 12 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8077 13 believers believer NNS 19613 8077 14 have have VBP 19613 8077 15 the the DT 19613 8077 16 death death NN 19613 8077 17 of of IN 19613 8077 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8077 19 as as IN 19613 8077 20 an an DT 19613 8077 21 antidote antidote NN 19613 8077 22 for for IN 19613 8077 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8077 24 sins sin NNS 19613 8077 25 , , , 19613 8077 26 " " '' 19613 8077 27 propter propter NNP 19613 8077 28 eos eos NNP 19613 8077 29 vero vero NNP 19613 8077 30 , , , 19613 8077 31 qui qui VBD 19613 8077 32 nunc nunc JJ 19613 8077 33 peccant peccant NN 19613 8077 34 , , , 19613 8077 35 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8077 36 non non AFX 19613 8077 37 iam iam NNP 19613 8077 38 morietur morietur NN 19613 8077 39 " " '' 19613 8077 40 . . . 19613 8078 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8078 2 . . . 19613 8079 1 28 28 CD 19613 8079 2 . . . 19613 8080 1 1 1 CD 19613 8080 2 f. f. NNP 19613 8080 3 : : : 19613 8080 4 under under IN 19613 8080 5 the the DT 19613 8080 6 old old JJ 19613 8080 7 covenant covenant NN 19613 8080 8 God God NNP 19613 8080 9 punished punish VBD 19613 8080 10 " " `` 19613 8080 11 typice typice NNP 19613 8080 12 et et NNP 19613 8080 13 temporaliter temporaliter NNP 19613 8080 14 et et NNP 19613 8080 15 mediocrius mediocrius NNP 19613 8080 16 " " '' 19613 8080 17 , , , 19613 8080 18 under under IN 19613 8080 19 the the DT 19613 8080 20 new new JJ 19613 8080 21 , , , 19613 8080 22 on on IN 19613 8080 23 the the DT 19613 8080 24 contrary contrary NN 19613 8080 25 , , , 19613 8080 26 " " `` 19613 8080 27 vere vere NNP 19613 8080 28 et et NNP 19613 8080 29 semper semper NNP 19613 8080 30 et et NNP 19613 8080 31 austerius austerius NNP 19613 8080 32 " " '' 19613 8080 33 ... ... : 19613 8080 34 as as IN 19613 8080 35 under under IN 19613 8080 36 the the DT 19613 8080 37 new new JJ 19613 8080 38 covenant covenant NN 19613 8080 39 " " `` 19613 8080 40 fides fide NNS 19613 8080 41 aucta aucta NNP 19613 8080 42 est est NNP 19613 8080 43 " " '' 19613 8080 44 , , , 19613 8080 45 so so RB 19613 8080 46 also also RB 19613 8080 47 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8080 48 is be VBZ 19613 8080 49 true true JJ 19613 8080 50 that that IN 19613 8080 51 " " `` 19613 8080 52 diligentia diligentia NN 19613 8080 53 conversationis conversationis NNP 19613 8080 54 adaucta adaucta NNP 19613 8080 55 est est NNP 19613 8080 56 " " '' 19613 8080 57 . . . 19613 8081 1 The the DT 19613 8081 2 imperfections imperfection NNS 19613 8081 3 of of IN 19613 8081 4 the the DT 19613 8081 5 law law NN 19613 8081 6 , , , 19613 8081 7 the the DT 19613 8081 8 " " `` 19613 8081 9 particularia particularia NN 19613 8081 10 legis legi NNS 19613 8081 11 " " '' 19613 8081 12 , , , 19613 8081 13 the the DT 19613 8081 14 law law NN 19613 8081 15 of of IN 19613 8081 16 bondage bondage NN 19613 8081 17 have have VBP 19613 8081 18 been be VBN 19613 8081 19 abolished abolish VBN 19613 8081 20 by by IN 19613 8081 21 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8081 22 , , , 19613 8081 23 see see VBP 19613 8081 24 specially specially RB 19613 8081 25 IV IV NNP 19613 8081 26 . . . 19613 8082 1 16 16 CD 19613 8082 2 , , , 19613 8082 3 17 17 CD 19613 8082 4 , , , 19613 8082 5 for for IN 19613 8082 6 the the DT 19613 8082 7 types type NNS 19613 8082 8 are be VBP 19613 8082 9 now now RB 19613 8082 10 fulfilled fulfil VBN 19613 8082 11 ; ; : 19613 8082 12 but but CC 19613 8082 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8082 14 and and CC 19613 8082 15 the the DT 19613 8082 16 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 8082 17 did do VBD 19613 8082 18 not not RB 19613 8082 19 transgress transgress VB 19613 8082 20 the the DT 19613 8082 21 law law NN 19613 8082 22 ; ; : 19613 8082 23 freedom freedom NN 19613 8082 24 was be VBD 19613 8082 25 first first RB 19613 8082 26 granted grant VBN 19613 8082 27 to to IN 19613 8082 28 the the DT 19613 8082 29 Gentile Gentile NNP 19613 8082 30 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8082 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8082 32 III iii CD 19613 8082 33 . . . 19613 8083 1 12 12 CD 19613 8083 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8083 3 and and CC 19613 8083 4 circumcision circumcision NN 19613 8083 5 and and CC 19613 8083 6 foreskin foreskin NNP 19613 8083 7 united united NNP 19613 8083 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8083 9 III III NNP 19613 8083 10 . . . 19613 8084 1 5 5 CD 19613 8084 2 . . . 19613 8085 1 3 3 LS 19613 8085 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8085 3 . . . 19613 8086 1 But but CC 19613 8086 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8086 3 also also RB 19613 8086 4 proved prove VBD 19613 8086 5 how how WRB 19613 8086 6 little little JJ 19613 8086 7 the the DT 19613 8086 8 old old JJ 19613 8086 9 and and CC 19613 8086 10 new new JJ 19613 8086 11 covenants covenant NNS 19613 8086 12 contradict contradict VBP 19613 8086 13 each each DT 19613 8086 14 other other JJ 19613 8086 15 by by IN 19613 8086 16 showing show VBG 19613 8086 17 that that IN 19613 8086 18 the the DT 19613 8086 19 latter latter NN 19613 8086 20 also also RB 19613 8086 21 contains contain VBZ 19613 8086 22 concessions concession NNS 19613 8086 23 that that WDT 19613 8086 24 have have VBP 19613 8086 25 been be VBN 19613 8086 26 granted grant VBN 19613 8086 27 to to IN 19613 8086 28 the the DT 19613 8086 29 frailty frailty NN 19613 8086 30 of of IN 19613 8086 31 man man NN 19613 8086 32 ; ; : 19613 8086 33 see see VB 19613 8086 34 IV IV NNP 19613 8086 35 . . . 19613 8087 1 15 15 CD 19613 8087 2 . . . 19613 8088 1 2 2 CD 19613 8088 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8088 3 1 1 CD 19613 8088 4 Cor Cor NNP 19613 8088 5 . . . 19613 8089 1 VII VII NNP 19613 8089 2 . . . 19613 8089 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8089 4 . . . 19613 8089 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8090 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8090 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8090 3 647 647 CD 19613 8090 4 : : : 19613 8090 5 See see VB 19613 8090 6 III iii CD 19613 8090 7 . . . 19613 8091 1 II ii CD 19613 8091 2 . . . 19613 8092 1 4 4 LS 19613 8092 2 . . . 19613 8093 1 There there RB 19613 8093 2 too too RB 19613 8093 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8093 4 find find VBP 19613 8093 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8093 6 argued argue VBD 19613 8093 7 that that IN 19613 8093 8 John John NNP 19613 8093 9 the the DT 19613 8093 10 Baptist Baptist NNP 19613 8093 11 was be VBD 19613 8093 12 not not RB 19613 8093 13 merely merely RB 19613 8093 14 a a DT 19613 8093 15 prophet prophet NN 19613 8093 16 , , , 19613 8093 17 but but CC 19613 8093 18 also also RB 19613 8093 19 an an DT 19613 8093 20 Apostle apostle NN 19613 8093 21 . . . 19613 8093 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8094 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8094 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8094 3 648 648 CD 19613 8094 4 : : : 19613 8094 5 From from IN 19613 8094 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8094 7 ' ' POS 19613 8094 8 statement statement NN 19613 8094 9 in in IN 19613 8094 10 IV IV NNP 19613 8094 11 . . . 19613 8095 1 4 4 CD 19613 8095 2 about about IN 19613 8095 3 the the DT 19613 8095 4 significance significance NN 19613 8095 5 of of IN 19613 8095 6 the the DT 19613 8095 7 city city NN 19613 8095 8 of of IN 19613 8095 9 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 8095 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8095 11 can can MD 19613 8095 12 infer infer VB 19613 8095 13 what what WP 19613 8095 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8095 15 thought think VBD 19613 8095 16 of of IN 19613 8095 17 the the DT 19613 8095 18 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 8095 19 nation nation NN 19613 8095 20 . . . 19613 8096 1 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 8096 2 is be VBZ 19613 8096 3 to to IN 19613 8096 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8096 5 the the DT 19613 8096 6 vine vine NN 19613 8096 7 - - HYPH 19613 8096 8 branch branch NN 19613 8096 9 on on IN 19613 8096 10 which which WDT 19613 8096 11 the the DT 19613 8096 12 fruit fruit NN 19613 8096 13 has have VBZ 19613 8096 14 grown grow VBN 19613 8096 15 ; ; : 19613 8096 16 the the DT 19613 8096 17 latter latter JJ 19613 8096 18 having have VBG 19613 8096 19 reached reach VBN 19613 8096 20 maturity maturity NN 19613 8096 21 , , , 19613 8096 22 the the DT 19613 8096 23 branch branch NN 19613 8096 24 is be VBZ 19613 8096 25 cut cut VBN 19613 8096 26 off off RP 19613 8096 27 and and CC 19613 8096 28 has have VBZ 19613 8096 29 no no DT 19613 8096 30 further further JJ 19613 8096 31 importance importance NN 19613 8096 32 . . . 19613 8096 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8097 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8097 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8097 3 649 649 CD 19613 8097 4 : : : 19613 8097 5 No no DT 19613 8097 6 special special JJ 19613 8097 7 treatment treatment NN 19613 8097 8 of of IN 19613 8097 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8097 10 is be VBZ 19613 8097 11 required require VBN 19613 8097 12 here here RB 19613 8097 13 , , , 19613 8097 14 as as IN 19613 8097 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8097 16 only only RB 19613 8097 17 differs differ VBZ 19613 8097 18 from from IN 19613 8097 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8097 20 in in IN 19613 8097 21 the the DT 19613 8097 22 additions addition NNS 19613 8097 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8097 24 invented invent VBD 19613 8097 25 as as IN 19613 8097 26 a a DT 19613 8097 27 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 8097 28 . . . 19613 8098 1 Yet yet CC 19613 8098 2 this this DT 19613 8098 3 is be VBZ 19613 8098 4 also also RB 19613 8098 5 prefigured prefigure VBN 19613 8098 6 in in IN 19613 8098 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8098 8 ' ' POS 19613 8098 9 view view NN 19613 8098 10 that that IN 19613 8098 11 the the DT 19613 8098 12 concessions concession NNS 19613 8098 13 of of IN 19613 8098 14 the the DT 19613 8098 15 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 8098 16 had have VBD 19613 8098 17 rendered render VBN 19613 8098 18 the the DT 19613 8098 19 execution execution NN 19613 8098 20 of of IN 19613 8098 21 the the DT 19613 8098 22 stern stern JJ 19613 8098 23 new new JJ 19613 8098 24 law law NN 19613 8098 25 more more RBR 19613 8098 26 easy easy JJ 19613 8098 27 . . . 19613 8099 1 A a DT 19613 8099 2 few few JJ 19613 8099 3 passages passage NNS 19613 8099 4 may may MD 19613 8099 5 be be VB 19613 8099 6 quoted quote VBN 19613 8099 7 here here RB 19613 8099 8 . . . 19613 8100 1 De De NNP 19613 8100 2 orat orat NNP 19613 8100 3 . . . 19613 8101 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 8101 2 : : : 19613 8101 3 " " `` 19613 8101 4 Quidquid Quidquid NNP 19613 8101 5 retro retro NN 19613 8101 6 fuerat fuerat NN 19613 8101 7 , , , 19613 8101 8 aut aut NN 19613 8101 9 demutatum demutatum NNP 19613 8101 10 est est NNP 19613 8101 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8101 12 per per IN 19613 8101 13 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8101 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8101 15 , , , 19613 8101 16 ut ut NNP 19613 8101 17 circumcisio circumcisio NNP 19613 8101 18 , , , 19613 8101 19 aut aut NNP 19613 8101 20 suppletum suppletum NNP 19613 8101 21 ut ut UH 19613 8101 22 reliqua reliqua NNP 19613 8101 23 lex lex NNP 19613 8101 24 , , , 19613 8101 25 aut aut NNP 19613 8101 26 impletum impletum NNP 19613 8101 27 ut ut NNP 19613 8101 28 prophetia prophetia NNP 19613 8101 29 , , , 19613 8101 30 aut aut NNP 19613 8101 31 perfectum perfectum NNP 19613 8101 32 ut ut UH 19613 8101 33 fides fide NNS 19613 8101 34 ipsa ipsa VBP 19613 8101 35 . . . 19613 8102 1 Omnia Omnia NNP 19613 8102 2 de de NNP 19613 8102 3 carnalibus carnalibus NNP 19613 8102 4 in in IN 19613 8102 5 spiritalia spiritalia NNP 19613 8102 6 renovavit renovavit NNP 19613 8102 7 nova nova NNP 19613 8102 8 dei dei NNP 19613 8102 9 gratia gratia NNP 19613 8102 10 superducto superducto NNP 19613 8102 11 evangelio evangelio NNP 19613 8102 12 , , , 19613 8102 13 expunctore expunctore JJR 19613 8102 14 totius totius NNP 19613 8102 15 retro retro NNP 19613 8102 16 vetustatis vetustatis NNP 19613 8102 17 . . . 19613 8102 18 " " '' 19613 8103 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8103 2 This this DT 19613 8103 3 differentiation differentiation NN 19613 8103 4 strikingly strikingly RB 19613 8103 5 reminds remind VBZ 19613 8103 6 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8103 7 of of IN 19613 8103 8 the the DT 19613 8103 9 letter letter NN 19613 8103 10 of of IN 19613 8103 11 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 19613 8103 12 to to IN 19613 8103 13 Flora Flora NNP 19613 8103 14 . . . 19613 8104 1 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 19613 8104 2 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 8104 3 those those DT 19613 8104 4 parts part NNS 19613 8104 5 of of IN 19613 8104 6 the the DT 19613 8104 7 law law NN 19613 8104 8 that that WDT 19613 8104 9 originate originate VBP 19613 8104 10 with with IN 19613 8104 11 God God NNP 19613 8104 12 , , , 19613 8104 13 Moses Moses NNP 19613 8104 14 , , , 19613 8104 15 and and CC 19613 8104 16 the the DT 19613 8104 17 elders elder NNS 19613 8104 18 . . . 19613 8105 1 As as RB 19613 8105 2 far far RB 19613 8105 3 as as IN 19613 8105 4 the the DT 19613 8105 5 divine divine JJ 19613 8105 6 law law NN 19613 8105 7 is be VBZ 19613 8105 8 concerned concern VBN 19613 8105 9 , , , 19613 8105 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8105 11 again again RB 19613 8105 12 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 8105 13 what what WP 19613 8105 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8105 15 had have VBD 19613 8105 16 to to TO 19613 8105 17 complete complete VB 19613 8105 18 , , , 19613 8105 19 what what WP 19613 8105 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8105 21 had have VBD 19613 8105 22 to to TO 19613 8105 23 supersede supersede VB 19613 8105 24 and and CC 19613 8105 25 what what WP 19613 8105 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8105 27 had have VBD 19613 8105 28 to to TO 19613 8105 29 spiritualise spiritualise VB 19613 8105 30 , , , 19613 8105 31 that that RB 19613 8105 32 is is RB 19613 8105 33 , , , 19613 8105 34 perficere perficere RB 19613 8105 35 , , , 19613 8105 36 solvere solvere RB 19613 8105 37 , , , 19613 8105 38 demutare demutare NN 19613 8105 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8105 40 . . . 19613 8106 1 In in IN 19613 8106 2 the the DT 19613 8106 3 _ _ NNP 19613 8106 4 regula regula NN 19613 8106 5 fidei fidei NNP 19613 8106 6 _ _ NNP 19613 8106 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8106 8 de de NNP 19613 8106 9 præscr præscr NNS 19613 8106 10 . . . 19613 8107 1 13 13 CD 19613 8107 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8107 3 : : : 19613 8107 4 " " `` 19613 8107 5 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8107 6 prædicavit prædicavit NN 19613 8107 7 novam novam NN 19613 8107 8 legem legem NNP 19613 8107 9 et et NNP 19613 8107 10 novam novam NNP 19613 8107 11 promissionem promissionem NNP 19613 8107 12 regni regni NNP 19613 8107 13 coelorum coelorum NNP 19613 8107 14 " " '' 19613 8107 15 ; ; : 19613 8107 16 see see VB 19613 8107 17 the the DT 19613 8107 18 discussions discussion NNS 19613 8107 19 in in IN 19613 8107 20 adv adv NN 19613 8107 21 . . . 19613 8108 1 Marc Marc NNP 19613 8108 2 . . . 19613 8109 1 II II NNP 19613 8109 2 . . NNP 19613 8109 3 , , , 19613 8109 4 III III NNP 19613 8109 5 . . NNP 19613 8109 6 , , , 19613 8109 7 and and CC 19613 8109 8 adv adv NNP 19613 8109 9 . . . 19613 8110 1 Iud iud UH 19613 8110 2 . . . 19613 8111 1 ; ; : 19613 8111 2 de de NNP 19613 8111 3 pat pat NNP 19613 8111 4 . . . 19613 8112 1 6 6 CD 19613 8112 2 : : : 19613 8112 3 " " `` 19613 8112 4 amplianda amplianda NNP 19613 8112 5 adimplendaque adimplendaque NNP 19613 8112 6 lex lex NNP 19613 8112 7 . . . 19613 8112 8 " " '' 19613 8113 1 Scorp Scorp NNP 19613 8113 2 . . . 19613 8114 1 3 3 CD 19613 8114 2 , , , 19613 8114 3 8 8 CD 19613 8114 4 , , , 19613 8114 5 9 9 CD 19613 8114 6 ; ; : 19613 8114 7 ad ad NN 19613 8114 8 uxor uxor NN 19613 8114 9 . . . 19613 8115 1 2 2 LS 19613 8115 2 ; ; : 19613 8115 3 de de NNP 19613 8115 4 monog monog NNP 19613 8115 5 . . . 19613 8116 1 7 7 LS 19613 8116 2 : : : 19613 8116 3 " " `` 19613 8116 4 Et Et NNP 19613 8116 5 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 8116 6 quidam quidam NNP 19613 8116 7 interdum interdum NNP 19613 8116 8 nihil nihil NNP 19613 8116 9 sihi sihi NNP 19613 8116 10 dicunt dicunt NN 19613 8116 11 esse esse NNP 19613 8116 12 cum cum NNP 19613 8116 13 lege lege NNP 19613 8116 14 , , , 19613 8116 15 quam quam NNP 19613 8116 16 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8116 17 non non AFX 19613 8116 18 dissolvit dissolvit NN 19613 8116 19 , , , 19613 8116 20 sed sed NNP 19613 8116 21 adimplevit adimplevit NNP 19613 8116 22 , , , 19613 8116 23 interdum interdum VBP 19613 8116 24 quæ quæ NNP 19613 8116 25 volunt volunt NNP 19613 8116 26 legis legis NNP 19613 8116 27 arripiunt arripiunt NNP 19613 8116 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8116 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8116 30 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8116 31 did do VBD 19613 8116 32 that that DT 19613 8116 33 continually continually RB 19613 8116 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8116 35 , , , 19613 8116 36 plane plane NN 19613 8116 37 et et NNP 19613 8116 38 nos nos NNP 19613 8116 39 sic sic NNP 19613 8116 40 dicimus dicimus NNP 19613 8116 41 legem legem NNP 19613 8116 42 , , , 19613 8116 43 ut ut NNP 19613 8116 44 onera onera NNP 19613 8116 45 quidem quidem NNP 19613 8116 46 eius eius NNP 19613 8116 47 , , , 19613 8116 48 secundum secundum NNP 19613 8116 49 sententiam sententiam NNP 19613 8116 50 apostolorum apostolorum NNP 19613 8116 51 , , , 19613 8116 52 quæ quæ NNP 19613 8116 53 nec nec NNP 19613 8116 54 patres patre VBZ 19613 8116 55 sustinere sustinere NNP 19613 8116 56 valuerunt valuerunt NNP 19613 8116 57 , , , 19613 8116 58 concesserint concesserint NN 19613 8116 59 , , , 19613 8116 60 quæ quæ NNP 19613 8116 61 vero vero NNP 19613 8116 62 ad ad NN 19613 8116 63 iustitiam iustitiam NNP 19613 8116 64 spectant spectant NN 19613 8116 65 , , , 19613 8116 66 non non JJ 19613 8116 67 tantum tantum JJ 19613 8116 68 reservata reservata JJ 19613 8116 69 permaneant permaneant NNP 19613 8116 70 , , , 19613 8116 71 verum verum NNP 19613 8116 72 et et NNP 19613 8116 73 ampliata ampliata NNP 19613 8116 74 . . . 19613 8116 75 " " '' 19613 8117 1 That that IN 19613 8117 2 the the DT 19613 8117 3 new new JJ 19613 8117 4 law law NN 19613 8117 5 of of IN 19613 8117 6 the the DT 19613 8117 7 new new JJ 19613 8117 8 covenant covenant NN 19613 8117 9 is be VBZ 19613 8117 10 the the DT 19613 8117 11 moral moral JJ 19613 8117 12 law law NN 19613 8117 13 of of IN 19613 8117 14 nature nature NN 19613 8117 15 in in IN 19613 8117 16 a a DT 19613 8117 17 stricter strict JJR 19613 8117 18 form form NN 19613 8117 19 , , , 19613 8117 20 and and CC 19613 8117 21 that that IN 19613 8117 22 the the DT 19613 8117 23 concessions concession NNS 19613 8117 24 of of IN 19613 8117 25 the the DT 19613 8117 26 Apostle Apostle NNP 19613 8117 27 Paul Paul NNP 19613 8117 28 cease cease NN 19613 8117 29 in in IN 19613 8117 30 the the DT 19613 8117 31 age age NN 19613 8117 32 of of IN 19613 8117 33 the the DT 19613 8117 34 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 8117 35 , , , 19613 8117 36 is be VBZ 19613 8117 37 a a DT 19613 8117 38 view view NN 19613 8117 39 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8117 40 find find VBP 19613 8117 41 still still RB 19613 8117 42 more more RBR 19613 8117 43 strongly strongly RB 19613 8117 44 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 8117 45 in in IN 19613 8117 46 the the DT 19613 8117 47 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 8117 48 writings writing NNS 19613 8117 49 than than IN 19613 8117 50 in in IN 19613 8117 51 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8117 52 . . . 19613 8118 1 In in IN 19613 8118 2 ad ad NN 19613 8118 3 uxor uxor NN 19613 8118 4 . . . 19613 8119 1 3 3 CD 19613 8119 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8119 3 had have VBD 19613 8119 4 already already RB 19613 8119 5 said say VBN 19613 8119 6 : : : 19613 8119 7 " " `` 19613 8119 8 Quod quod NN 19613 8119 9 permittitur permittitur NN 19613 8119 10 , , , 19613 8119 11 bonum bonum NN 19613 8119 12 non non AFX 19613 8119 13 est est NNP 19613 8119 14 , , , 19613 8119 15 " " `` 19613 8119 16 and and CC 19613 8119 17 this this DT 19613 8119 18 proposition proposition NN 19613 8119 19 is be VBZ 19613 8119 20 the the DT 19613 8119 21 theme theme NN 19613 8119 22 of of IN 19613 8119 23 many many JJ 19613 8119 24 arguments argument NNS 19613 8119 25 in in IN 19613 8119 26 the the DT 19613 8119 27 Montanist montanist JJ 19613 8119 28 writings writing NNS 19613 8119 29 . . . 19613 8120 1 But but CC 19613 8120 2 the the DT 19613 8120 3 intention intention NN 19613 8120 4 of of IN 19613 8120 5 finding find VBG 19613 8120 6 a a DT 19613 8120 7 basis basis NN 19613 8120 8 for for IN 19613 8120 9 the the DT 19613 8120 10 laws law NNS 19613 8120 11 of of IN 19613 8120 12 the the DT 19613 8120 13 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 8120 14 , , , 19613 8120 15 by by IN 19613 8120 16 showing show VBG 19613 8120 17 that that IN 19613 8120 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8120 19 existed exist VBD 19613 8120 20 in in IN 19613 8120 21 some some DT 19613 8120 22 fashion fashion NN 19613 8120 23 even even RB 19613 8120 24 in in IN 19613 8120 25 earlier early JJR 19613 8120 26 times time NNS 19613 8120 27 , , , 19613 8120 28 involved involve VBD 19613 8120 29 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8120 30 in in IN 19613 8120 31 many many JJ 19613 8120 32 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 8120 33 . . . 19613 8121 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8121 2 is be VBZ 19613 8121 3 evident evident JJ 19613 8121 4 from from IN 19613 8121 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8121 6 writings writing NNS 19613 8121 7 that that WDT 19613 8121 8 Montanists Montanists NNPS 19613 8121 9 and and CC 19613 8121 10 Catholics Catholics NNPS 19613 8121 11 in in IN 19613 8121 12 Carthage Carthage NNP 19613 8121 13 alternately alternately RB 19613 8121 14 reproached reproach VBD 19613 8121 15 each each DT 19613 8121 16 other other JJ 19613 8121 17 with with IN 19613 8121 18 judaising judaise VBG 19613 8121 19 tendencies tendency NNS 19613 8121 20 and and CC 19613 8121 21 an an DT 19613 8121 22 apostasy apostasy NN 19613 8121 23 to to TO 19613 8121 24 heathen heathen VB 19613 8121 25 discipline discipline NN 19613 8121 26 and and CC 19613 8121 27 worship worship NN 19613 8121 28 . . . 19613 8122 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8122 2 , , , 19613 8122 3 in in IN 19613 8122 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8122 5 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 8122 6 for for IN 19613 8122 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8122 8 , , , 19613 8122 9 came come VBD 19613 8122 10 into into IN 19613 8122 11 conflict conflict NN 19613 8122 12 with with IN 19613 8122 13 all all PDT 19613 8122 14 the the DT 19613 8122 15 authorities authority NNS 19613 8122 16 which which WDT 19613 8122 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8122 18 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8122 19 had have VBD 19613 8122 20 set set VBN 19613 8122 21 up up RP 19613 8122 22 . . . 19613 8123 1 In in IN 19613 8123 2 the the DT 19613 8123 3 questions question NNS 19613 8123 4 as as IN 19613 8123 5 to to IN 19613 8123 6 the the DT 19613 8123 7 relationship relationship NN 19613 8123 8 of of IN 19613 8123 9 the the DT 19613 8123 10 Old Old NNP 19613 8123 11 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8123 12 to to IN 19613 8123 13 the the DT 19613 8123 14 New New NNP 19613 8123 15 , , , 19613 8123 16 of of IN 19613 8123 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8123 18 to to IN 19613 8123 19 the the DT 19613 8123 20 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 8123 21 , , , 19613 8123 22 of of IN 19613 8123 23 the the DT 19613 8123 24 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 8123 25 to to IN 19613 8123 26 each each DT 19613 8123 27 other other JJ 19613 8123 28 , , , 19613 8123 29 of of IN 19613 8123 30 the the DT 19613 8123 31 Paraclete Paraclete NNP 19613 8123 32 to to IN 19613 8123 33 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8123 34 and and CC 19613 8123 35 the the DT 19613 8123 36 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 8123 37 , , , 19613 8123 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8123 39 was be VBD 19613 8123 40 also also RB 19613 8123 41 of of IN 19613 8123 42 necessity necessity NN 19613 8123 43 involved involve VBN 19613 8123 44 in in IN 19613 8123 45 the the DT 19613 8123 46 greatest great JJS 19613 8123 47 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 8123 48 . . . 19613 8124 1 This this DT 19613 8124 2 was be VBD 19613 8124 3 the the DT 19613 8124 4 case case NN 19613 8124 5 not not RB 19613 8124 6 only only RB 19613 8124 7 because because IN 19613 8124 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8124 9 went go VBD 19613 8124 10 more more RBR 19613 8124 11 into into IN 19613 8124 12 details detail NNS 19613 8124 13 than than IN 19613 8124 14 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8124 15 ; ; : 19613 8124 16 but but CC 19613 8124 17 , , , 19613 8124 18 above above IN 19613 8124 19 all all DT 19613 8124 20 , , , 19613 8124 21 because because IN 19613 8124 22 the the DT 19613 8124 23 chains chain NNS 19613 8124 24 into into IN 19613 8124 25 which which WDT 19613 8124 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8124 27 had have VBD 19613 8124 28 thrown throw VBN 19613 8124 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8124 30 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8124 31 were be VBD 19613 8124 32 felt feel VBN 19613 8124 33 to to TO 19613 8124 34 be be VB 19613 8124 35 such such JJ 19613 8124 36 by by IN 19613 8124 37 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8124 38 . . . 19613 8125 1 This this DT 19613 8125 2 theologian theologian NN 19613 8125 3 had have VBD 19613 8125 4 no no DT 19613 8125 5 greater great JJR 19613 8125 6 opponent opponent NN 19613 8125 7 than than IN 19613 8125 8 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8125 9 , , , 19613 8125 10 and and CC 19613 8125 11 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 8125 12 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 8125 13 is be VBZ 19613 8125 14 this this DT 19613 8125 15 so so RB 19613 8125 16 plain plain JJ 19613 8125 17 as as IN 19613 8125 18 in in IN 19613 8125 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8125 20 attitude attitude NN 19613 8125 21 to to IN 19613 8125 22 the the DT 19613 8125 23 two two CD 19613 8125 24 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 8125 25 . . . 19613 8126 1 Here here RB 19613 8126 2 , , , 19613 8126 3 in in IN 19613 8126 4 every every DT 19613 8126 5 question question NN 19613 8126 6 of of IN 19613 8126 7 detail detail NN 19613 8126 8 , , , 19613 8126 9 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8126 10 really really RB 19613 8126 11 repudiated repudiate VBD 19613 8126 12 the the DT 19613 8126 13 proposition proposition NN 19613 8126 14 from from IN 19613 8126 15 which which WDT 19613 8126 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8126 17 starts start VBZ 19613 8126 18 . . . 19613 8127 1 In in IN 19613 8127 2 reference reference NN 19613 8127 3 to to IN 19613 8127 4 one one CD 19613 8127 5 point point NN 19613 8127 6 , , , 19613 8127 7 namely namely RB 19613 8127 8 , , , 19613 8127 9 that that IN 19613 8127 10 the the DT 19613 8127 11 Law Law NNP 19613 8127 12 and and CC 19613 8127 13 the the DT 19613 8127 14 prophets prophet NNS 19613 8127 15 extend extend VBP 19613 8127 16 down down RP 19613 8127 17 to to IN 19613 8127 18 John John NNP 19613 8127 19 , , , 19613 8127 20 see see VB 19613 8127 21 Noldechen Noldechen NNP 19613 8127 22 's 's POS 19613 8127 23 article article NN 19613 8127 24 in in IN 19613 8127 25 the the DT 19613 8127 26 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 8127 27 fur fur NN 19613 8127 28 wissenschaftliche wissenschaftliche NN 19613 8127 29 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 8127 30 , , , 19613 8127 31 1885 1885 CD 19613 8127 32 , , , 19613 8127 33 p. p. NN 19613 8127 34 333 333 CD 19613 8127 35 f. f. NNS 19613 8127 36 On on IN 19613 8127 37 the the DT 19613 8127 38 one one CD 19613 8127 39 hand hand NN 19613 8127 40 , , , 19613 8127 41 in in IN 19613 8127 42 order order NN 19613 8127 43 to to TO 19613 8127 44 support support VB 19613 8127 45 certain certain JJ 19613 8127 46 trains train NNS 19613 8127 47 of of IN 19613 8127 48 thought thought NN 19613 8127 49 , , , 19613 8127 50 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8127 51 required require VBD 19613 8127 52 the the DT 19613 8127 53 proposition proposition NN 19613 8127 54 that that WDT 19613 8127 55 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 8127 56 extended extend VBD 19613 8127 57 down down RP 19613 8127 58 to to IN 19613 8127 59 John John NNP 19613 8127 60 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8127 61 see see VB 19613 8127 62 also also RB 19613 8127 63 the the DT 19613 8127 64 Muratorian Muratorian NNP 19613 8127 65 Fragment Fragment NNP 19613 8127 66 : : : 19613 8127 67 " " `` 19613 8127 68 completus completus NNP 19613 8127 69 numerus numerus NNP 19613 8127 70 prophetarum prophetarum NNP 19613 8127 71 " " '' 19613 8127 72 , , , 19613 8127 73 Sibyll Sibyll NNP 19613 8127 74 . . . 19613 8128 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8129 1 386 386 CD 19613 8129 2 : : : 19613 8129 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8129 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8129 5 : : : 19613 8129 6 kai kai NNP 19613 8129 7 tote tote NNP 19613 8129 8 dê dê NNP 19613 8129 9 pausis pausis NNP 19613 8129 10 estai estai NNP 19613 8129 11 metepeita metepeita NNP 19613 8129 12 prophêtôu prophêtôu NNP 19613 8129 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8129 14 , , , 19613 8129 15 scil scil NN 19613 8129 16 . . . 19613 8130 1 after after IN 19613 8130 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8130 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8130 4 , , , 19613 8130 5 and and CC 19613 8130 6 on on IN 19613 8130 7 the the DT 19613 8130 8 other other JJ 19613 8130 9 , , , 19613 8130 10 as as IN 19613 8130 11 a a DT 19613 8130 12 Montanist Montanist NNP 19613 8130 13 , , , 19613 8130 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8130 15 was be VBD 19613 8130 16 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8130 17 to to TO 19613 8130 18 assert assert VB 19613 8130 19 the the DT 19613 8130 20 continued continue VBN 19613 8130 21 existence existence NN 19613 8130 22 of of IN 19613 8130 23 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 8130 24 . . . 19613 8131 1 In in IN 19613 8131 2 like like JJ 19613 8131 3 manner manner NN 19613 8131 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8131 5 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 8131 6 ascribed ascribe VBD 19613 8131 7 to to IN 19613 8131 8 the the DT 19613 8131 9 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 8131 10 a a DT 19613 8131 11 unique unique JJ 19613 8131 12 possession possession NN 19613 8131 13 of of IN 19613 8131 14 the the DT 19613 8131 15 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8131 16 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8131 17 , , , 19613 8131 18 and and CC 19613 8131 19 at at IN 19613 8131 20 other other JJ 19613 8131 21 times time NNS 19613 8131 22 , , , 19613 8131 23 adhering adhere VBG 19613 8131 24 to to IN 19613 8131 25 a a DT 19613 8131 26 primitive primitive JJ 19613 8131 27 Christian christian JJ 19613 8131 28 idea idea NN 19613 8131 29 , , , 19613 8131 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8131 31 denied deny VBD 19613 8131 32 this this DT 19613 8131 33 thesis thesis NN 19613 8131 34 . . . 19613 8132 1 Cf cf NN 19613 8132 2 . . . 19613 8133 1 also also RB 19613 8133 2 Baith Baith NNP 19613 8133 3 " " `` 19613 8133 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8133 5 's 's POS 19613 8133 6 Auffassung Auffassung NNP 19613 8133 7 des des FW 19613 8133 8 Apostels Apostels NNP 19613 8133 9 Paulus Paulus NNP 19613 8133 10 und und NN 19613 8133 11 seines seine NNS 19613 8133 12 Verhaltnisses Verhaltnisses NNP 19613 8133 13 zu zu NNP 19613 8133 14 den den NNP 19613 8133 15 Uraposteln Uraposteln NNP 19613 8133 16 " " '' 19613 8133 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8133 18 Jahrbuch Jahrbuch NNP 19613 8133 19 fur fur NN 19613 8133 20 protestantische protestantische NN 19613 8133 21 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 8133 22 , , , 19613 8133 23 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8133 24 . . . 19613 8134 1 III iii CD 19613 8134 2 . . . 19613 8135 1 p. p. NN 19613 8135 2 706 706 CD 19613 8135 3 ff ff NNP 19613 8135 4 . . . 19613 8135 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8135 6 . . . 19613 8136 1 Tertullian tertullian JJ 19613 8136 2 strove strove NN 19613 8136 3 to to TO 19613 8136 4 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 8136 5 the the DT 19613 8136 6 principles principle NNS 19613 8136 7 of of IN 19613 8136 8 early early JJ 19613 8136 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8136 10 with with IN 19613 8136 11 the the DT 19613 8136 12 authority authority NN 19613 8136 13 of of IN 19613 8136 14 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8136 15 tradition tradition NN 19613 8136 16 and and CC 19613 8136 17 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8136 18 apologetics apologetic NNS 19613 8136 19 . . . 19613 8137 1 Separated separate VBN 19613 8137 2 from from IN 19613 8137 3 the the DT 19613 8137 4 general general JJ 19613 8137 5 body body NN 19613 8137 6 of of IN 19613 8137 7 the the DT 19613 8137 8 Church Church NNP 19613 8137 9 , , , 19613 8137 10 and and CC 19613 8137 11 making make VBG 19613 8137 12 ever ever RB 19613 8137 13 increasing increase VBG 19613 8137 14 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 19613 8137 15 for for IN 19613 8137 16 the the DT 19613 8137 17 early early JJ 19613 8137 18 - - HYPH 19613 8137 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 8137 20 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 19613 8137 21 , , , 19613 8137 22 as as IN 19613 8137 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8137 24 understood understand VBD 19613 8137 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8137 26 , , , 19613 8137 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8137 28 wasted waste VBD 19613 8137 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8137 30 in in IN 19613 8137 31 the the DT 19613 8137 32 solution solution NN 19613 8137 33 of of IN 19613 8137 34 this this DT 19613 8137 35 insoluble insoluble JJ 19613 8137 36 problem problem NN 19613 8137 37 . . . 19613 8137 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8138 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8138 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8138 3 650 650 CD 19613 8138 4 : : : 19613 8138 5 In in IN 19613 8138 6 addition addition NN 19613 8138 7 to to IN 19613 8138 8 this this DT 19613 8138 9 , , , 19613 8138 10 however however RB 19613 8138 11 , , , 19613 8138 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8138 13 definitely definitely RB 19613 8138 14 established establish VBD 19613 8138 15 within within IN 19613 8138 16 the the DT 19613 8138 17 Church Church NNP 19613 8138 18 the the DT 19613 8138 19 idea idea NN 19613 8138 20 that that IN 19613 8138 21 there there EX 19613 8138 22 is be VBZ 19613 8138 23 a a DT 19613 8138 24 " " `` 19613 8138 25 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8138 26 " " '' 19613 8138 27 view view NN 19613 8138 28 in in IN 19613 8138 29 all all DT 19613 8138 30 spheres sphere NNS 19613 8138 31 of of IN 19613 8138 32 life life NN 19613 8138 33 and and CC 19613 8138 34 in in IN 19613 8138 35 all all DT 19613 8138 36 questions question NNS 19613 8138 37 of of IN 19613 8138 38 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8138 39 . . . 19613 8139 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8139 2 appears appear VBZ 19613 8139 3 expanded expand VBN 19613 8139 4 to to IN 19613 8139 5 an an DT 19613 8139 6 immense immense JJ 19613 8139 7 , , , 19613 8139 8 immeasurable immeasurable JJ 19613 8139 9 breadth breadth NN 19613 8139 10 . . . 19613 8140 1 This this DT 19613 8140 2 is be VBZ 19613 8140 3 also also RB 19613 8140 4 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 8140 5 . . . 19613 8141 1 Thus thus RB 19613 8141 2 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8141 3 , , , 19613 8141 4 after after IN 19613 8141 5 expressing express VBG 19613 8141 6 various various JJ 19613 8141 7 opinions opinion NNS 19613 8141 8 about about IN 19613 8141 9 dreams dream NNS 19613 8141 10 , , , 19613 8141 11 opens open VBZ 19613 8141 12 the the DT 19613 8141 13 45th 45th JJ 19613 8141 14 chapter chapter NN 19613 8141 15 of of IN 19613 8141 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8141 17 work work NN 19613 8141 18 " " '' 19613 8141 19 de de FW 19613 8141 20 anima anima FW 19613 8141 21 " " '' 19613 8141 22 with with IN 19613 8141 23 the the DT 19613 8141 24 words word NNS 19613 8141 25 : : : 19613 8141 26 " " `` 19613 8141 27 Tenemur Tenemur NNP 19613 8141 28 hie hie NN 19613 8141 29 de de FW 19613 8141 30 sommis sommis NNP 19613 8141 31 quoque quoque NNP 19613 8141 32 Christianam Christianam NNP 19613 8141 33 sententiam sententiam NN 19613 8141 34 expromere expromere RB 19613 8141 35 " " '' 19613 8141 36 . . . 19613 8142 1 Alongside alongside IN 19613 8142 2 of of IN 19613 8142 3 the the DT 19613 8142 4 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 8142 5 rule rule NN 19613 8142 6 of of IN 19613 8142 7 faith faith NN 19613 8142 8 as as IN 19613 8142 9 the the DT 19613 8142 10 " " `` 19613 8142 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8142 12 " " '' 19613 8142 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8142 14 find find VBP 19613 8142 15 the the DT 19613 8142 16 casuistic casuistic JJ 19613 8142 17 system system NN 19613 8142 18 of of IN 19613 8142 19 morality morality NN 19613 8142 20 and and CC 19613 8142 21 penance penance NN 19613 8142 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8142 23 the the DT 19613 8142 24 Church Church NNP 19613 8142 25 " " `` 19613 8142 26 disciplina disciplina NNP 19613 8142 27 " " '' 19613 8142 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8142 29 with with IN 19613 8142 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8142 31 media medium NNS 19613 8142 32 of of IN 19613 8142 33 almsgiving almsgive VBG 19613 8142 34 , , , 19613 8142 35 fasting fasting NN 19613 8142 36 , , , 19613 8142 37 and and CC 19613 8142 38 prayer prayer NN 19613 8142 39 ; ; : 19613 8142 40 see see VB 19613 8142 41 Cypr Cypr NNPS 19613 8142 42 , , , 19613 8142 43 de de FW 19613 8142 44 op op NNP 19613 8142 45 et et NNP 19613 8142 46 eleemos eleemos NNP 19613 8142 47 . . . 19613 8142 48 , , , 19613 8142 49 but but CC 19613 8142 50 before before IN 19613 8142 51 that that DT 19613 8142 52 Hippol Hippol NNP 19613 8142 53 . . . 19613 8142 54 , , , 19613 8142 55 Comm Comm NNP 19613 8142 56 . . . 19613 8143 1 in in IN 19613 8143 2 Daniel Daniel NNP 19613 8143 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8143 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8143 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8143 6 : : : 19613 8143 7 Ekkl Ekkl NNP 19613 8143 8 Alêth Alêth NNP 19613 8143 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8143 10 . . . 19613 8144 1 1886 1886 CD 19613 8144 2 , , , 19613 8144 3 p. p. NN 19613 8144 4 242 242 CD 19613 8144 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8144 6 : : : 19613 8144 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8144 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8144 9 : : : 19613 8144 10 hoi hoi NNP 19613 8144 11 eis eis NNP 19613 8144 12 tu tu NNP 19613 8144 13 onoma onoma NNP 19613 8144 14 ton ton NN 19613 8144 15 Theou Theou NNP 19613 8144 16 pisteuontes pisteuonte VBZ 19613 8144 17 kai kai NNP 19613 8144 18 di di NNP 19613 8144 19 ' ' `` 19613 8144 20 agathoergias agathoergias NNP 19613 8144 21 to to TO 19613 8144 22 prosôpon prosôpon VB 19613 8144 23 autou autou NNP 19613 8144 24 exilaskomenoi exilaskomenoi NN 19613 8144 25 . . . 19613 8144 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8144 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8145 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8145 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8145 3 651 651 CD 19613 8145 4 : : : 19613 8145 5 In in IN 19613 8145 6 the the DT 19613 8145 7 case case NN 19613 8145 8 of of IN 19613 8145 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8145 10 , , , 19613 8145 11 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 8145 12 , , , 19613 8145 13 and and CC 19613 8145 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8145 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8145 16 already already RB 19613 8145 17 find find VBP 19613 8145 18 that that IN 19613 8145 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8145 20 observe observe VBP 19613 8145 21 a a DT 19613 8145 22 certain certain JJ 19613 8145 23 order order NN 19613 8145 24 and and CC 19613 8145 25 sequence sequence NN 19613 8145 26 of of IN 19613 8145 27 books book NNS 19613 8145 28 when when WRB 19613 8145 29 advancing advance VBG 19613 8145 30 a a DT 19613 8145 31 detailed detailed JJ 19613 8145 32 proof proof NN 19613 8145 33 from from IN 19613 8145 34 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 8145 35 . . . 19613 8145 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8146 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8146 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8146 3 652 652 CD 19613 8146 4 : : : 19613 8146 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8146 6 is be VBZ 19613 8146 7 worthy worthy JJ 19613 8146 8 of of IN 19613 8146 9 note note NN 19613 8146 10 that that IN 19613 8146 11 there there EX 19613 8146 12 was be VBD 19613 8146 13 not not RB 19613 8146 14 a a DT 19613 8146 15 single single JJ 19613 8146 16 Arian arian JJ 19613 8146 17 ecclesiastic ecclesiastic NN 19613 8146 18 of of IN 19613 8146 19 note note NN 19613 8146 20 in in IN 19613 8146 21 the the DT 19613 8146 22 Novatian novatian JJ 19613 8146 23 churches church NNS 19613 8146 24 of of IN 19613 8146 25 the the DT 19613 8146 26 4th 4th JJ 19613 8146 27 century century NN 19613 8146 28 , , , 19613 8146 29 so so RB 19613 8146 30 far far RB 19613 8146 31 as as IN 19613 8146 32 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8146 33 know know VBP 19613 8146 34 . . . 19613 8147 1 All all DT 19613 8147 2 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 8147 3 's 's POS 19613 8147 4 adherents adherent NNS 19613 8147 5 , , , 19613 8147 6 even even RB 19613 8147 7 those those DT 19613 8147 8 in in IN 19613 8147 9 the the DT 19613 8147 10 West West NNP 19613 8147 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8147 12 see see VB 19613 8147 13 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 8147 14 ' ' POS 19613 8147 15 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 8147 16 History History NNP 19613 8147 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8147 18 , , , 19613 8147 19 were be VBD 19613 8147 20 of of IN 19613 8147 21 the the DT 19613 8147 22 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 8147 23 Nicæan Nicæan NNP 19613 8147 24 type type NN 19613 8147 25 . . . 19613 8148 1 This this DT 19613 8148 2 furnishes furnish VBZ 19613 8148 3 material material NN 19613 8148 4 for for IN 19613 8148 5 reflection reflection NN 19613 8148 6 . . . 19613 8148 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8149 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8149 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8149 3 653 653 CD 19613 8149 4 : : : 19613 8149 5 Owing owe VBG 19613 8149 6 to to IN 19613 8149 7 the the DT 19613 8149 8 importance importance NN 19613 8149 9 of of IN 19613 8149 10 the the DT 19613 8149 11 matter matter NN 19613 8149 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8149 13 shall shall MD 19613 8149 14 give give VB 19613 8149 15 several several JJ 19613 8149 16 Christological Christological NNP 19613 8149 17 and and CC 19613 8149 18 trinitarian trinitarian JJ 19613 8149 19 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 8149 20 from from IN 19613 8149 21 the the DT 19613 8149 22 work work NN 19613 8149 23 " " `` 19613 8149 24 de de FW 19613 8149 25 trinitate trinitate NNP 19613 8149 26 " " '' 19613 8149 27 . . . 19613 8150 1 The the DT 19613 8150 2 archaic archaic JJ 19613 8150 3 attitude attitude NN 19613 8150 4 of of IN 19613 8150 5 this this DT 19613 8150 6 Christology Christology NNP 19613 8150 7 and and CC 19613 8150 8 trinitarian trinitarian JJ 19613 8150 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8150 10 is be VBZ 19613 8150 11 evident evident JJ 19613 8150 12 from from IN 19613 8150 13 the the DT 19613 8150 14 following follow VBG 19613 8150 15 considerations consideration NNS 19613 8150 16 . . . 19613 8151 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8151 2 1 1 LS 19613 8151 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8151 4 Like like IN 19613 8151 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8151 6 , , , 19613 8151 7 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 8151 8 asserts assert VBZ 19613 8151 9 that that IN 19613 8151 10 the the DT 19613 8151 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8151 12 was be VBD 19613 8151 13 indeed indeed RB 19613 8151 14 always always RB 19613 8151 15 with with IN 19613 8151 16 the the DT 19613 8151 17 Father Father NNP 19613 8151 18 , , , 19613 8151 19 but but CC 19613 8151 20 that that IN 19613 8151 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8151 22 only only RB 19613 8151 23 went go VBD 19613 8151 24 forth forth RB 19613 8151 25 from from IN 19613 8151 26 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8151 27 at at IN 19613 8151 28 a a DT 19613 8151 29 definite definite JJ 19613 8151 30 period period NN 19613 8151 31 of of IN 19613 8151 32 time time NN 19613 8151 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8151 34 for for IN 19613 8151 35 the the DT 19613 8151 36 purpose purpose NN 19613 8151 37 of of IN 19613 8151 38 creating create VBG 19613 8151 39 the the DT 19613 8151 40 world world NN 19613 8151 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8151 42 . . . 19613 8152 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8152 2 2 2 LS 19613 8152 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8152 4 Like like IN 19613 8152 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8152 6 , , , 19613 8152 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8152 8 declares declare VBZ 19613 8152 9 that that IN 19613 8152 10 Father Father NNP 19613 8152 11 , , , 19613 8152 12 Son Son NNP 19613 8152 13 , , , 19613 8152 14 and and CC 19613 8152 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8152 16 have have VBP 19613 8152 17 one one CD 19613 8152 18 substance substance NN 19613 8152 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8152 20 that that RB 19613 8152 21 is is RB 19613 8152 22 , , , 19613 8152 23 are be VBP 19613 8152 24 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8152 25 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8152 26 : : : 19613 8152 27 homoousioi homoousioi NNP 19613 8152 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8152 29 , , , 19613 8152 30 the the DT 19613 8152 31 _ _ NNP 19613 8152 32 homoousia homoousia NNP 19613 8152 33 _ _ NNP 19613 8152 34 of of IN 19613 8152 35 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8152 36 never never RB 19613 8152 37 decides decide VBZ 19613 8152 38 as as IN 19613 8152 39 to to IN 19613 8152 40 equality equality NN 19613 8152 41 in in IN 19613 8152 42 dignity dignity NN 19613 8152 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8152 44 ; ; : 19613 8152 45 but but CC 19613 8152 46 that that IN 19613 8152 47 the the DT 19613 8152 48 Son Son NNP 19613 8152 49 is be VBZ 19613 8152 50 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 8152 51 and and CC 19613 8152 52 obedient obedient JJ 19613 8152 53 to to IN 19613 8152 54 the the DT 19613 8152 55 Father Father NNP 19613 8152 56 and and CC 19613 8152 57 the the DT 19613 8152 58 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8152 59 to to IN 19613 8152 60 the the DT 19613 8152 61 Son Son NNP 19613 8152 62 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8152 63 cc cc NNP 19613 8152 64 . . . 19613 8153 1 17 17 CD 19613 8153 2 , , , 19613 8153 3 22 22 CD 19613 8153 4 , , , 19613 8153 5 24 24 CD 19613 8153 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8153 7 , , , 19613 8153 8 since since IN 19613 8153 9 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8153 10 derive derive VBP 19613 8153 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8153 12 origin origin NN 19613 8153 13 , , , 19613 8153 14 essence essence NN 19613 8153 15 , , , 19613 8153 16 and and CC 19613 8153 17 function function NN 19613 8153 18 from from IN 19613 8153 19 the the DT 19613 8153 20 Father Father NNP 19613 8153 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8153 22 the the DT 19613 8153 23 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8153 24 from from IN 19613 8153 25 the the DT 19613 8153 26 Son Son NNP 19613 8153 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8153 28 . . . 19613 8154 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8154 2 3 3 LS 19613 8154 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8154 4 Like like IN 19613 8154 5 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8154 6 , , , 19613 8154 7 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 8154 8 teaches teach VBZ 19613 8154 9 that that IN 19613 8154 10 the the DT 19613 8154 11 Son Son NNP 19613 8154 12 , , , 19613 8154 13 after after IN 19613 8154 14 accomplishing accomplish VBG 19613 8154 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8154 16 work work NN 19613 8154 17 , , , 19613 8154 18 will will MD 19613 8154 19 again again RB 19613 8154 20 become become VB 19613 8154 21 intermingled intermingled JJ 19613 8154 22 with with IN 19613 8154 23 the the DT 19613 8154 24 Father Father NNP 19613 8154 25 , , , 19613 8154 26 that that RB 19613 8154 27 is is RB 19613 8154 28 , , , 19613 8154 29 will will MD 19613 8154 30 cease cease VB 19613 8154 31 to to TO 19613 8154 32 have have VB 19613 8154 33 an an DT 19613 8154 34 independent independent JJ 19613 8154 35 existence existence NN 19613 8154 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8154 37 c. c. NNP 19613 8154 38 31 31 CD 19613 8154 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8154 40 ; ; : 19613 8154 41 whence whence NN 19613 8154 42 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8154 43 understand understand VBP 19613 8154 44 why why WRB 19613 8154 45 the the DT 19613 8154 46 West West NNP 19613 8154 47 continued continue VBD 19613 8154 48 so so RB 19613 8154 49 long long RB 19613 8154 50 to to TO 19613 8154 51 be be VB 19613 8154 52 favourable favourable JJ 19613 8154 53 to to IN 19613 8154 54 Marcellus Marcellus NNP 19613 8154 55 of of IN 19613 8154 56 Ancyra Ancyra NNP 19613 8154 57 ; ; : 19613 8154 58 see see VB 19613 8154 59 also also RB 19613 8154 60 the the DT 19613 8154 61 so so RB 19613 8154 62 - - HYPH 19613 8154 63 called call VBN 19613 8154 64 symbol symbol NN 19613 8154 65 of of IN 19613 8154 66 Sardika Sardika NNP 19613 8154 67 . . . 19613 8155 1 Apart apart RB 19613 8155 2 from from IN 19613 8155 3 these these DT 19613 8155 4 points point NNS 19613 8155 5 and and CC 19613 8155 6 a a DT 19613 8155 7 few few JJ 19613 8155 8 others other NNS 19613 8155 9 of of IN 19613 8155 10 less less JJR 19613 8155 11 consequence consequence NN 19613 8155 12 , , , 19613 8155 13 the the DT 19613 8155 14 work work NN 19613 8155 15 , , , 19613 8155 16 in in IN 19613 8155 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8155 18 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 8155 19 , , , 19613 8155 20 exhibits exhibit VBZ 19613 8155 21 a a DT 19613 8155 22 type type NN 19613 8155 23 which which WDT 19613 8155 24 remained remain VBD 19613 8155 25 pretty pretty RB 19613 8155 26 constant constant JJ 19613 8155 27 in in IN 19613 8155 28 the the DT 19613 8155 29 West West NNP 19613 8155 30 down down RP 19613 8155 31 to to IN 19613 8155 32 the the DT 19613 8155 33 time time NN 19613 8155 34 of of IN 19613 8155 35 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 8155 36 , , , 19613 8155 37 or or CC 19613 8155 38 , , , 19613 8155 39 till till IN 19613 8155 40 the the DT 19613 8155 41 adoption adoption NN 19613 8155 42 of of IN 19613 8155 43 Johannes Johannes NNP 19613 8155 44 Damascenus Damascenus NNP 19613 8155 45 ' ' POS 19613 8155 46 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8155 47 . . . 19613 8156 1 The the DT 19613 8156 2 sharp sharp JJ 19613 8156 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 8156 4 between between IN 19613 8156 5 " " `` 19613 8156 6 deus deu NNS 19613 8156 7 " " '' 19613 8156 8 and and CC 19613 8156 9 " " `` 19613 8156 10 homo homo NN 19613 8156 11 " " '' 19613 8156 12 and and CC 19613 8156 13 the the DT 19613 8156 14 use use NN 19613 8156 15 that that WDT 19613 8156 16 is be VBZ 19613 8156 17 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 8156 18 made make VBN 19613 8156 19 of of IN 19613 8156 20 " " `` 19613 8156 21 permixtio permixtio NNP 19613 8156 22 " " '' 19613 8156 23 and and CC 19613 8156 24 synonymous synonymous JJ 19613 8156 25 words word NNS 19613 8156 26 are be VBP 19613 8156 27 also also RB 19613 8156 28 specially specially RB 19613 8156 29 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 8156 30 . . . 19613 8157 1 Cap Cap NNP 19613 8157 2 . . . 19613 8158 1 9 9 LS 19613 8158 2 : : : 19613 8158 3 " " `` 19613 8158 4 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8158 5 deus deu VBZ 19613 8158 6 dominus dominus NN 19613 8158 7 deus deus NNP 19613 8158 8 noster noster NNP 19613 8158 9 , , , 19613 8158 10 sed sed NNP 19613 8158 11 dei dei NNP 19613 8158 12 filius filius NNP 19613 8158 13 " " '' 19613 8158 14 ; ; : 19613 8158 15 c. c. NNP 19613 8158 16 11 11 CD 19613 8158 17 : : : 19613 8158 18 " " `` 19613 8158 19 non non NNP 19613 8158 20 sic sic NNP 19613 8158 21 de de NNP 19613 8158 22 substantia substantia NNP 19613 8158 23 corporis corporis NNP 19613 8158 24 ipsius ipsius NNP 19613 8158 25 exprimimus exprimimus NNP 19613 8158 26 , , , 19613 8158 27 ut ut NNP 19613 8158 28 solum solum NNP 19613 8158 29 tantum tantum NNP 19613 8158 30 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8158 31 illum illum NNP 19613 8158 32 esse esse NNP 19613 8158 33 dicamus dicamus NNP 19613 8158 34 , , , 19613 8158 35 sed sed NNP 19613 8158 36 ut ut UH 19613 8158 37 divinitate divinitate NN 19613 8158 38 sermonis sermonis NNP 19613 8158 39 in in IN 19613 8158 40 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 8158 41 concretione concretione NNP 19613 8158 42 permixta permixta NN 19613 8158 43 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8158 44 deum deum NNP 19613 8158 45 illum illum NNP 19613 8158 46 teneamus teneamus NNP 19613 8158 47 " " '' 19613 8158 48 ; ; : 19613 8158 49 c. c. NN 19613 8158 50 11 11 CD 19613 8158 51 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8158 52 has have VBZ 19613 8158 53 _ _ NNP 19613 8158 54 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 19613 8158 55 divina divina NNP 19613 8158 56 _ _ NNP 19613 8158 57 , , , 19613 8158 58 " " '' 19613 8158 59 tam tam NNP 19613 8158 60 enim enim NNP 19613 8158 61 scriptura scriptura NNP 19613 8158 62 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8158 63 deum deum NNP 19613 8158 64 adnuntiat adnuntiat NNP 19613 8158 65 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8158 66 , , , 19613 8158 67 quam quam NNP 19613 8158 68 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8158 69 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 8158 70 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8158 71 adnuntiat adnuntiat NNP 19613 8158 72 deum deum NNP 19613 8158 73 , , , 19613 8158 74 tam tam NNP 19613 8158 75 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8158 76 descripsit descripsit NNP 19613 8158 77 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 8158 78 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8158 79 , , , 19613 8158 80 quam quam NNP 19613 8158 81 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8158 82 deum deum JJ 19613 8158 83 quoque quoque NNP 19613 8158 84 descripsit descripsit NNP 19613 8158 85 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8158 86 dominum dominum NN 19613 8158 87 . . . 19613 8158 88 " " '' 19613 8159 1 In in IN 19613 8159 2 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 3 12 12 CD 19613 8159 4 the the DT 19613 8159 5 term term NN 19613 8159 6 " " `` 19613 8159 7 Immanuel Immanuel NNP 19613 8159 8 " " '' 19613 8159 9 is be VBZ 19613 8159 10 used use VBN 19613 8159 11 to to TO 19613 8159 12 designate designate VB 19613 8159 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8159 14 as as IN 19613 8159 15 God God NNP 19613 8159 16 in in IN 19613 8159 17 a a DT 19613 8159 18 way way NN 19613 8159 19 that that WDT 19613 8159 20 reminds remind VBZ 19613 8159 21 one one CD 19613 8159 22 of of IN 19613 8159 23 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 19613 8159 24 ; ; : 19613 8159 25 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 26 13 13 CD 19613 8159 27 : : : 19613 8159 28 " " `` 19613 8159 29 præsertim præsertim NNP 19613 8159 30 cum cum NNP 19613 8159 31 animadvertat animadvertat NNP 19613 8159 32 , , , 19613 8159 33 scripturam scripturam NN 19613 8159 34 evangelicam evangelicam NNP 19613 8159 35 utramque utramque NNP 19613 8159 36 istam istam NNP 19613 8159 37 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 8159 38 in in IN 19613 8159 39 unam unam NNP 19613 8159 40 nativitatis nativitatis NNP 19613 8159 41 Christi Christi NNP 19613 8159 42 foederasse foederasse NN 19613 8159 43 concordiam concordiam NN 19613 8159 44 " " '' 19613 8159 45 ; ; : 19613 8159 46 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 47 14 14 CD 19613 8159 48 : : : 19613 8159 49 " " `` 19613 8159 50 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8159 51 ex ex FW 19613 8159 52 verbi verbi VB 19613 8159 53 et et NN 19613 8159 54 carnis carnis NNP 19613 8159 55 coniunctione coniunctione NN 19613 8159 56 concretus concretus NN 19613 8159 57 " " '' 19613 8159 58 ; ; : 19613 8159 59 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 60 16 16 CD 19613 8159 61 : : : 19613 8159 62 " " `` 19613 8159 63 ... ... : 19613 8159 64 ut ut NNP 19613 8159 65 neque neque NNP 19613 8159 66 homo homo NNP 19613 8159 67 Christo Christo NNP 19613 8159 68 subtrahatur subtrahatur NN 19613 8159 69 , , , 19613 8159 70 neque neque NNP 19613 8159 71 divinitas divinitas NNP 19613 8159 72 negetur negetur NNP 19613 8159 73 ... ... : 19613 8159 74 utrumque utrumque NNP 19613 8159 75 in in IN 19613 8159 76 Christo Christo NNP 19613 8159 77 confoederatum confoederatum NN 19613 8159 78 est est NNP 19613 8159 79 , , , 19613 8159 80 utrumque utrumque JJ 19613 8159 81 coniunctum coniunctum NN 19613 8159 82 est est NNP 19613 8159 83 et et NNP 19613 8159 84 utrumque utrumque NNP 19613 8159 85 connexum connexum NNP 19613 8159 86 est est NNP 19613 8159 87 ... ... NFP 19613 8159 88 pignerata pignerata NNS 19613 8159 89 in in IN 19613 8159 90 illo illo NN 19613 8159 91 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 8159 92 et et NNP 19613 8159 93 humilitatis humilitatis NNP 19613 8159 94 videtur videtur NNP 19613 8159 95 esse esse NNP 19613 8159 96 concordia concordia NNP 19613 8159 97 ... ... NFP 19613 8159 98 qui qui NNP 19613 8159 99 mediator mediator NNP 19613 8159 100 dei dei NNP 19613 8159 101 et et NNP 19613 8159 102 hominum hominum NNP 19613 8159 103 effectus effectus NNP 19613 8159 104 exprimitur exprimitur NNP 19613 8159 105 , , , 19613 8159 106 in in IN 19613 8159 107 se se FW 19613 8159 108 deum deum NNP 19613 8159 109 et et NNP 19613 8159 110 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8159 111 sociasse sociasse NNP 19613 8159 112 reperitur reperitur NNP 19613 8159 113 ... ... : 19613 8159 114 nos nos NNP 19613 8159 115 sermonem sermonem NNP 19613 8159 116 dei dei NNP 19613 8159 117 scimus scimus NNP 19613 8159 118 indutum indutum NNP 19613 8159 119 carnis carnis NNP 19613 8159 120 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 8159 121 ... ... : 19613 8159 122 lavit lavit NNP 19613 8159 123 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 8159 124 corporis corporis NNP 19613 8159 125 et et NNP 19613 8159 126 materiam materiam NNP 19613 8159 127 carnis carnis NNP 19613 8159 128 abluens abluens NNP 19613 8159 129 , , , 19613 8159 130 ex ex NNP 19613 8159 131 parte parte NNP 19613 8159 132 suscepti suscepti NNP 19613 8159 133 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8159 134 , , , 19613 8159 135 passione passione NN 19613 8159 136 " " '' 19613 8159 137 ; ; : 19613 8159 138 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 139 17 17 CD 19613 8159 140 : : : 19613 8159 141 " " `` 19613 8159 142 ... ... NFP 19613 8159 143 nisi nisi NNP 19613 8159 144 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 8159 145 auctoritas auctoritas NNP 19613 8159 146 divini divini NNP 19613 8159 147 verbi verbi NNP 19613 8159 148 ad ad NNP 19613 8159 149 suscipiendum suscipiendum NN 19613 8159 150 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8159 151 interim interim NNP 19613 8159 152 conquiescens conquiescens NNP 19613 8159 153 nec nec NNP 19613 8159 154 se se NNP 19613 8159 155 suis suis NNP 19613 8159 156 viribus viribus NNP 19613 8159 157 exercens exercens NNP 19613 8159 158 , , , 19613 8159 159 deiicit deiicit NN 19613 8159 160 se se NNP 19613 8159 161 ad ad FW 19613 8159 162 tempus tempus NNP 19613 8159 163 atque atque NNP 19613 8159 164 deponit deponit NNP 19613 8159 165 , , , 19613 8159 166 dum dum NNP 19613 8159 167 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8159 168 fert fert NNP 19613 8159 169 , , , 19613 8159 170 quem quem NNP 19613 8159 171 suscepit suscepit NNP 19613 8159 172 " " '' 19613 8159 173 ; ; : 19613 8159 174 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 175 18 18 CD 19613 8159 176 : : : 19613 8159 177 " " `` 19613 8159 178 ... ... . 19613 8159 179 ut ut UH 19613 8159 180 in in IN 19613 8159 181 semetipso semetipso NNP 19613 8159 182 concordiam concordiam NNP 19613 8159 183 confibularet confibularet NNP 19613 8159 184 terrenorum terrenorum NNP 19613 8159 185 pariter pariter NNP 19613 8159 186 atque atque NNP 19613 8159 187 cælestium cælestium NNP 19613 8159 188 , , , 19613 8159 189 dum dum NNP 19613 8159 190 utriusque utriusque JJ 19613 8159 191 partis partis NN 19613 8159 192 in in IN 19613 8159 193 se se NNP 19613 8159 194 connectens connectens NNP 19613 8159 195 pignora pignora NNP 19613 8159 196 et et NNP 19613 8159 197 deum deum NNP 19613 8159 198 homini homini NNP 19613 8159 199 et et NNP 19613 8159 200 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8159 201 deo deo NNP 19613 8159 202 copularet copularet NNP 19613 8159 203 , , , 19613 8159 204 ut ut NNP 19613 8159 205 merito merito NNP 19613 8159 206 filius filius NNP 19613 8159 207 dei dei NNP 19613 8159 208 per per IN 19613 8159 209 assumptionem assumptionem NNP 19613 8159 210 carnis carnis NNP 19613 8159 211 filius filius NNP 19613 8159 212 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8159 213 et et NNP 19613 8159 214 filius filius NNP 19613 8159 215 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8159 216 per per IN 19613 8159 217 receptionem receptionem NNP 19613 8159 218 dei dei NNP 19613 8159 219 verbi verbi NNP 19613 8159 220 filius filius NNP 19613 8159 221 dei dei NNP 19613 8159 222 effici effici NNP 19613 8159 223 possit possit NNP 19613 8159 224 " " '' 19613 8159 225 ; ; : 19613 8159 226 c. c. NNP 19613 8159 227 19 19 CD 19613 8159 228 : : : 19613 8159 229 " " `` 19613 8159 230 hic hic JJ 19613 8159 231 est est NNP 19613 8159 232 enim enim NNP 19613 8159 233 legitimus legitimus NNP 19613 8159 234 dei dei NNP 19613 8159 235 filius filius NNP 19613 8159 236 qui qui NNP 19613 8159 237 ex ex NNP 19613 8159 238 ipso ipso NNP 19613 8159 239 deo deo NNP 19613 8159 240 est est NNP 19613 8159 241 , , , 19613 8159 242 qui qui NNP 19613 8159 243 , , , 19613 8159 244 dum dum NNP 19613 8159 245 sanctum sanctum NN 19613 8159 246 illud illud RB 19613 8159 247 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8159 248 Luke Luke NNP 19613 8159 249 I. I. NNP 19613 8160 1 35 35 LS 19613 8160 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8160 3 assumit assumit NN 19613 8160 4 , , , 19613 8160 5 sibi sibi NNP 19613 8160 6 filium filium NNP 19613 8160 7 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8160 8 annectit annectit NNP 19613 8160 9 et et NNP 19613 8160 10 illum illum NNP 19613 8160 11 ad ad NNP 19613 8160 12 se se FW 19613 8160 13 rapit rapit VBD 19613 8160 14 atque atque NNP 19613 8160 15 transducit transducit NN 19613 8160 16 , , , 19613 8160 17 connexione connexione NN 19613 8160 18 sua sua NN 19613 8160 19 et et NNP 19613 8160 20 permixtione permixtione NNP 19613 8160 21 sociata sociata NNP 19613 8160 22 præstat præstat NNP 19613 8160 23 et et NNP 19613 8160 24 filium filium NNP 19613 8160 25 illum illum NNP 19613 8160 26 dei dei NNP 19613 8160 27 facit facit NNP 19613 8160 28 , , , 19613 8160 29 quod quod NN 19613 8160 30 ille ille NNP 19613 8160 31 naturaliter naturaliter NNP 19613 8160 32 non non NNP 19613 8160 33 fuit fuit NN 19613 8160 34 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8160 35 Novatian Novatian NNP 19613 8160 36 's 's POS 19613 8160 37 teaching teaching NN 19613 8160 38 is be VBZ 19613 8160 39 therefore therefore RB 19613 8160 40 like like IN 19613 8160 41 that that DT 19613 8160 42 of of IN 19613 8160 43 the the DT 19613 8160 44 Spanish spanish JJ 19613 8160 45 Adoptionists Adoptionists NNPS 19613 8160 46 of of IN 19613 8160 47 the the DT 19613 8160 48 8th 8th JJ 19613 8160 49 century century NN 19613 8160 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8160 51 , , , 19613 8160 52 ut ut UH 19613 8160 53 principalitas principalitas NNP 19613 8160 54 nominis nominis NNP 19613 8160 55 istius istius NNP 19613 8160 56 ' ' POS 19613 8160 57 filius filius NNP 19613 8160 58 dei dei NNP 19613 8160 59 ' ' '' 19613 8160 60 in in IN 19613 8160 61 spiritu spiritu NN 19613 8160 62 sit sit NN 19613 8160 63 domini domini NNS 19613 8160 64 , , , 19613 8160 65 qui qui VBD 19613 8160 66 descendit descendit FW 19613 8160 67 et et NNP 19613 8160 68 venit venit NN 19613 8160 69 , , , 19613 8160 70 ut ut NNP 19613 8160 71 sequela sequela NNP 19613 8160 72 nominis nominis NNP 19613 8160 73 istius istius NNP 19613 8160 74 in in IN 19613 8160 75 filio filio NNP 19613 8160 76 dei dei NNP 19613 8160 77 et et NNP 19613 8160 78 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8160 79 sit sit NNP 19613 8160 80 , , , 19613 8160 81 et et NNP 19613 8160 82 merito merito NNP 19613 8160 83 consequenter consequenter NN 19613 8160 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8160 85 filius filius NNP 19613 8160 86 dei dei NNP 19613 8160 87 factus factus NNP 19613 8160 88 sit sit NNP 19613 8160 89 , , , 19613 8160 90 dum dum NNP 19613 8160 91 non non NNP 19613 8160 92 principaliter principaliter NN 19613 8160 93 filius filius NNP 19613 8160 94 dei dei NNP 19613 8160 95 est est NNP 19613 8160 96 , , , 19613 8160 97 atque atque NN 19613 8160 98 ideo ideo NN 19613 8160 99 dispositionem dispositionem NNP 19613 8160 100 istam istam NNP 19613 8160 101 anhelus anhelus NNP 19613 8160 102 videns videns NNP 19613 8160 103 et et NNP 19613 8160 104 ordinem ordinem NNP 19613 8160 105 istum istum NNP 19613 8160 106 sacramenti sacramenti NNP 19613 8160 107 expediens expediens NNP 19613 8160 108 non non AFX 19613 8160 109 sic sic NNP 19613 8160 110 cuncta cuncta NNP 19613 8160 111 confundens confundens NNP 19613 8160 112 , , , 19613 8160 113 ut ut NNP 19613 8160 114 nullum nullum NNP 19613 8160 115 vestigium vestigium NNP 19613 8160 116 distinctionis distinctionis NNP 19613 8160 117 collocavit collocavit NNP 19613 8160 118 , , , 19613 8160 119 distinctionem distinctionem NNP 19613 8160 120 posuit posuit NNP 19613 8160 121 dicendo dicendo NNP 19613 8160 122 . . . 19613 8161 1 ' ' `` 19613 8161 2 Propterea Propterea NNP 19613 8161 3 et et NNP 19613 8161 4 quod quod NN 19613 8161 5 nascetur nascetur NNP 19613 8161 6 ex ex NNP 19613 8161 7 te te NNP 19613 8161 8 sanctum sanctum NNP 19613 8161 9 vocabitur vocabitur NNP 19613 8161 10 filius filius NNP 19613 8161 11 dei dei NNP 19613 8161 12 ' ' '' 19613 8161 13 . . . 19613 8162 1 Ne Ne NNP 19613 8162 2 si si IN 19613 8162 3 distributionem distributionem NNP 19613 8162 4 istam istam NNP 19613 8162 5 cum cum NNP 19613 8162 6 libramentis libramentis NNP 19613 8162 7 suis suis NNP 19613 8162 8 non non NNP 19613 8162 9 dispensasset dispensasset NNP 19613 8162 10 , , , 19613 8162 11 sed se VBN 19613 8162 12 in in IN 19613 8162 13 confuso confuso NNP 19613 8162 14 permixtum permixtum NNP 19613 8162 15 reliquisset reliquisset NNP 19613 8162 16 , , , 19613 8162 17 vere vere NNP 19613 8162 18 occasionem occasionem NNP 19613 8162 19 hæreticis hæreticis NNP 19613 8162 20 contulisset contulisset NNP 19613 8162 21 , , , 19613 8162 22 ut ut NNP 19613 8162 23 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8162 24 filium filium NNP 19613 8162 25 qua qua NNP 19613 8162 26 homo homo NNP 19613 8162 27 est est NNP 19613 8162 28 , , , 19613 8162 29 eundum eundum NNP 19613 8162 30 et et NNP 19613 8162 31 dei dei NNP 19613 8162 32 et et NNP 19613 8162 33 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8162 34 filium filium NNP 19613 8162 35 pronuntiare pronuntiare NNP 19613 8162 36 deberent deberent NNP 19613 8162 37 .... .... NFP 19613 8162 38 Filius Filius NNP 19613 8162 39 dei dei NNP 19613 8162 40 , , , 19613 8162 41 dum dum NNP 19613 8162 42 filium filium NNP 19613 8162 43 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8162 44 in in IN 19613 8162 45 se se FW 19613 8162 46 suscepit suscepit NNP 19613 8162 47 , , , 19613 8162 48 consequenter consequenter NNP 19613 8162 49 illum illum NNP 19613 8162 50 filium filium NNP 19613 8162 51 dei dei NNP 19613 8162 52 fecit fecit NNP 19613 8162 53 , , , 19613 8162 54 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 8162 55 illum illum NNP 19613 8162 56 filius filius NNP 19613 8162 57 sibi sibi NNP 19613 8162 58 dei dei NNP 19613 8162 59 sociavit sociavit NNP 19613 8162 60 et et NNP 19613 8162 61 iunxit iunxit NNP 19613 8162 62 , , , 19613 8162 63 ut ut UH 19613 8162 64 , , , 19613 8162 65 dum dum NNP 19613 8162 66 filius filius NNP 19613 8162 67 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8162 68 adhæret adhæret NNP 19613 8162 69 in in IN 19613 8162 70 nativitate nativitate NNP 19613 8162 71 filio filio NNP 19613 8162 72 dei dei NNP 19613 8162 73 , , , 19613 8162 74 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 8162 75 permixtionem permixtionem NNP 19613 8162 76 foeneratum foeneratum NNP 19613 8162 77 et et NNP 19613 8162 78 mutuatum mutuatum NN 19613 8162 79 teneret teneret NNP 19613 8162 80 , , , 19613 8162 81 quod quod NNP 19613 8162 82 ex ex NNP 19613 8162 83 natura natura NNP 19613 8162 84 propria propria NNP 19613 8162 85 possidere possidere RB 19613 8162 86 non non AFX 19613 8162 87 posset posset JJ 19613 8162 88 . . . 19613 8163 1 Ac Ac NNP 19613 8163 2 si si NNP 19613 8163 3 facta facta NNP 19613 8163 4 est est NNP 19613 8163 5 angeli angeli NNP 19613 8163 6 voce voce NNP 19613 8163 7 , , , 19613 8163 8 quod quod NN 19613 8163 9 nolunt nolunt NNP 19613 8163 10 hæretici hæretici NNP 19613 8163 11 , , , 19613 8163 12 inter inter NNP 19613 8163 13 filium filium NNP 19613 8163 14 dei dei NNP 19613 8163 15 hominisque hominisque NNP 19613 8163 16 cum cum NNP 19613 8163 17 sua sua NNP 19613 8163 18 tamen tamen NNP 19613 8163 19 sociatione sociatione NNP 19613 8163 20 distinctio distinctio NNP 19613 8163 21 , , , 19613 8163 22 urgendo urgendo IN 19613 8163 23 illos illos NNP 19613 8163 24 , , , 19613 8163 25 uti uti NNP 19613 8163 26 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8163 27 hominis hominis NNP 19613 8163 28 filium filium NN 19613 8163 29 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8163 30 intelligant intelligant NNP 19613 8163 31 quoque quoque NNP 19613 8163 32 dei dei NNP 19613 8163 33 filium filium NNP 19613 8163 34 et et NNP 19613 8163 35 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8163 36 dei dei NNP 19613 8163 37 filium filium NNP 19613 8163 38 i -PRON- PRP 19613 8163 39 d d NNP 19613 8163 40 est est NNP 19613 8163 41 dei dei NNP 19613 8163 42 verbum verbum NNP 19613 8163 43 deum deum NNP 19613 8163 44 accipiant accipiant NNP 19613 8163 45 , , , 19613 8163 46 atque atque NN 19613 8163 47 ideo ideo NN 19613 8163 48 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8163 49 Iesum Iesum NNP 19613 8163 50 dominum dominum FW 19613 8163 51 ex ex NNP 19613 8163 52 utroque utroque JJ 19613 8163 53 connexum connexum NNP 19613 8163 54 , , , 19613 8163 55 et et NNP 19613 8163 56 utroque utroque JJ 19613 8163 57 contextum contextum NNP 19613 8163 58 atque atque NNP 19613 8163 59 concretum concretum NNP 19613 8163 60 et et NNP 19613 8163 61 in in IN 19613 8163 62 eadem eadem NNP 19613 8163 63 utriusque utriusque JJ 19613 8163 64 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 8163 65 concordia concordia NNP 19613 8163 66 mutui mutui NNP 19613 8163 67 ad ad NNP 19613 8163 68 invicem invicem NNP 19613 8163 69 foederis foederis NNP 19613 8163 70 confibulatione confibulatione NNP 19613 8163 71 sociatum sociatum NNP 19613 8163 72 , , , 19613 8163 73 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8163 74 et et NNP 19613 8163 75 deum deum NNP 19613 8163 76 , , , 19613 8163 77 scripturæ scripturæ NNP 19613 8163 78 hoc hoc NNP 19613 8163 79 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 8163 80 dicentis dicentis NNP 19613 8163 81 veritate veritate NNP 19613 8163 82 cognoscant cognoscant NNP 19613 8163 83 " " '' 19613 8163 84 . . . 19613 8164 1 c. c. NNP 19613 8164 2 21 21 CD 19613 8164 3 : : : 19613 8164 4 " " `` 19613 8164 5 hæretici hæretici NNP 19613 8164 6 nolunt nolunt NN 19613 8164 7 Christum Christum NNP 19613 8164 8 secundam secundam NNP 19613 8164 9 esse esse NNP 19613 8164 10 personam personam NNP 19613 8164 11 post post NNP 19613 8164 12 patrem patrem NNP 19613 8164 13 , , , 19613 8164 14 sed sed NNP 19613 8164 15 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 8164 16 patrem patrem NN 19613 8164 17 ; ; : 19613 8164 18 " " `` 19613 8164 19 c. c. NNP 19613 8164 20 22 22 CD 19613 8164 21 : : : 19613 8164 22 " " `` 19613 8164 23 Cum Cum NNP 19613 8164 24 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8164 25 ' ' POS 19613 8164 26 Ego Ego NNP 19613 8164 27 ' ' '' 19613 8164 28 dicit dicit NN 19613 8164 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8164 30 John John NNP 19613 8164 31 X. X. NNP 19613 8165 1 30 30 CD 19613 8165 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8165 3 , , , 19613 8165 4 deinde deinde NNP 19613 8165 5 patrem patrem NNP 19613 8165 6 infert infert NNP 19613 8165 7 dicendo dicendo NNP 19613 8165 8 , , , 19613 8165 9 ' ' '' 19613 8165 10 Ego Ego NNP 19613 8165 11 et et NNP 19613 8165 12 pater pater NN 19613 8165 13 ' ' '' 19613 8165 14 , , , 19613 8165 15 proprietatem proprietatem NN 19613 8165 16 personæ personæ NN 19613 8165 17 suæ suæ NNP 19613 8165 18 i -PRON- PRP 19613 8165 19 d d VBN 19613 8165 20 est e JJS 19613 8165 21 filii filii VBP 19613 8165 22 a a DT 19613 8165 23 paterna paterna NN 19613 8165 24 auctoritate auctoritate NN 19613 8165 25 discernit discernit NN 19613 8165 26 atque atque NNP 19613 8165 27 distinguit distinguit NN 19613 8165 28 , , , 19613 8165 29 non non NNP 19613 8165 30 tantummodo tantummodo NNP 19613 8165 31 de de FW 19613 8165 32 sono sono NNP 19613 8165 33 nominis nominis NNP 19613 8165 34 , , , 19613 8165 35 sed sed NNP 19613 8165 36 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8165 37 de de NNP 19613 8165 38 ordine ordine NNP 19613 8165 39 dispositæ dispositæ NN 19613 8165 40 potestatis potestatis NN 19613 8165 41 ... ... NFP 19613 8165 42 unum unum NNP 19613 8165 43 enim enim NNP 19613 8165 44 neutraliter neutraliter NNP 19613 8165 45 positum positum NN 19613 8165 46 , , , 19613 8165 47 societatis societatis NN 19613 8165 48 concordiam concordiam NN 19613 8165 49 , , , 19613 8165 50 non non NNP 19613 8165 51 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 8165 52 personæ personæ NNP 19613 8165 53 sonat sonat NNP 19613 8165 54 ... ... NFP 19613 8165 55 unum unum NNP 19613 8165 56 autem autem NNP 19613 8165 57 quod quod NN 19613 8165 58 ait ait CC 19613 8165 59 , , , 19613 8165 60 ad ad NN 19613 8165 61 concordiam concordiam NN 19613 8165 62 et et NNP 19613 8165 63 eandem eandem NNP 19613 8165 64 sententiam sententiam NNP 19613 8165 65 et et FW 19613 8165 66 ad ad NN 19613 8165 67 ipsam ipsam NNP 19613 8165 68 charitatis charitatis NNP 19613 8165 69 societatem societatem NN 19613 8165 70 pertinet pertinet NNP 19613 8165 71 , , , 19613 8165 72 ut ut NNP 19613 8165 73 merito merito NNP 19613 8165 74 unum unum NNP 19613 8165 75 sit sit NNP 19613 8165 76 pater pater NNP 19613 8165 77 et et NN 19613 8165 78 filius filius NN 19613 8165 79 per per IN 19613 8165 80 concordiam concordiam NN 19613 8165 81 et et NN 19613 8165 82 per per IN 19613 8165 83 amorem amorem NN 19613 8165 84 et et FW 19613 8165 85 per per IN 19613 8165 86 dilectionem dilectionem NNP 19613 8165 87 . . . 19613 8166 1 Et Et NNP 19613 8166 2 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 8166 3 ex ex VBD 19613 8166 4 patre patre NNP 19613 8166 5 est est NNP 19613 8166 6 , , , 19613 8166 7 quicquid quicquid JJ 19613 8166 8 illud illud RB 19613 8166 9 est est NNP 19613 8166 10 , , , 19613 8166 11 filius filius NNP 19613 8166 12 est est NNP 19613 8166 13 , , , 19613 8166 14 manente manente NNP 19613 8166 15 tamen tamen NNPS 19613 8166 16 distinctione distinctione NNP 19613 8166 17 ... ... : 19613 8166 18 denique denique NNP 19613 8166 19 novit novit NNP 19613 8166 20 hanc hanc NNP 19613 8166 21 concordiæ concordiæ NNP 19613 8166 22 unitatem unitatem NNP 19613 8166 23 est est NNP 19613 8166 24 apostolus apostolus VB 19613 8166 25 Paulus Paulus NNP 19613 8166 26 cum cum NNP 19613 8166 27 personarum personarum NN 19613 8166 28 tamen tamen VBZ 19613 8166 29 distinctione distinctione NN 19613 8166 30 . . . 19613 8166 31 " " '' 19613 8167 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8167 2 Comparison comparison NN 19613 8167 3 with with IN 19613 8167 4 the the DT 19613 8167 5 relationship relationship NN 19613 8167 6 between between IN 19613 8167 7 Paul Paul NNP 19613 8167 8 and and CC 19613 8167 9 Apollos Apollos NNP 19613 8167 10 ! ! . 19613 8168 1 " " `` 19613 8168 2 Quos quos JJ 19613 8168 3 personæ personæ NN 19613 8168 4 ratio ratio NN 19613 8168 5 invicem invicem NNP 19613 8168 6 dividit dividit NN 19613 8168 7 , , , 19613 8168 8 eosdem eosdem NNP 19613 8168 9 rursus rursus NNP 19613 8168 10 invicem invicem NNP 19613 8168 11 religionis religionis NN 19613 8168 12 ratio ratio NN 19613 8168 13 conducit conducit NN 19613 8168 14 ; ; : 19613 8168 15 et et NNP 19613 8168 16 quamvis quamvis NNP 19613 8168 17 idem idem NNP 19613 8168 18 atque atque NNP 19613 8168 19 ipsi ipsi NNP 19613 8168 20 non non NNP 19613 8168 21 sint sint NNP 19613 8168 22 , , , 19613 8168 23 dum dum NNP 19613 8168 24 idem idem NN 19613 8168 25 sentiunt sentiunt NNP 19613 8168 26 , , , 19613 8168 27 ipsum ipsum NN 19613 8168 28 sunt sunt NNP 19613 8168 29 , , , 19613 8168 30 et et NNP 19613 8168 31 cum cum NNP 19613 8168 32 duo duo NNP 19613 8168 33 sint sint NNP 19613 8168 34 , , , 19613 8168 35 unum unum NNP 19613 8168 36 sunt sunt NNP 19613 8168 37 " " '' 19613 8168 38 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8168 39 ; ; : 19613 8168 40 c. c. NNP 19613 8168 41 23 23 CD 19613 8168 42 : : : 19613 8168 43 " " `` 19613 8168 44 constat constat NNP 19613 8168 45 hominem hominem NNP 19613 8168 46 a a DT 19613 8168 47 deo deo NNP 19613 8168 48 factum factum NNP 19613 8168 49 esse esse NNP 19613 8168 50 , , , 19613 8168 51 non non AFX 19613 8168 52 ex ex NNP 19613 8168 53 deo deo NNP 19613 8168 54 processisse processisse NN 19613 8168 55 ; ; : 19613 8168 56 ex ex NNP 19613 8168 57 deo deo NNP 19613 8168 58 autem autem NNP 19613 8168 59 homo homo NNP 19613 8168 60 quomodo quomodo NNP 19613 8168 61 nou nou NNP 19613 8168 62 processit processit NNP 19613 8168 63 , , , 19613 8168 64 sic sic NNP 19613 8168 65 dei dei NNP 19613 8168 66 verbum verbum NNP 19613 8168 67 processit processit NN 19613 8168 68 " " '' 19613 8168 69 . . . 19613 8169 1 In in IN 19613 8169 2 c. c. NNP 19613 8169 3 24 24 CD 19613 8169 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8169 5 is be VBZ 19613 8169 6 argued argue VBN 19613 8169 7 that that IN 19613 8169 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8169 9 existed exist VBD 19613 8169 10 before before IN 19613 8169 11 the the DT 19613 8169 12 creation creation NN 19613 8169 13 of of IN 19613 8169 14 the the DT 19613 8169 15 world world NN 19613 8169 16 and and CC 19613 8169 17 that that IN 19613 8169 18 not not RB 19613 8169 19 merely merely RB 19613 8169 20 " " `` 19613 8169 21 predestinatione predestinatione NN 19613 8169 22 " " '' 19613 8169 23 , , , 19613 8169 24 for for IN 19613 8169 25 then then RB 19613 8169 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8169 27 would would MD 19613 8169 28 be be VB 19613 8169 29 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 8169 30 and and CC 19613 8169 31 therefore therefore RB 19613 8169 32 inferior inferior JJ 19613 8169 33 to to IN 19613 8169 34 Adam Adam NNP 19613 8169 35 , , , 19613 8169 36 Abel Abel NNP 19613 8169 37 , , , 19613 8169 38 Enoch Enoch NNP 19613 8169 39 etc etc FW 19613 8169 40 . . . 19613 8170 1 " " `` 19613 8170 2 Sublata Sublata NNP 19613 8170 3 ergo ergo NNP 19613 8170 4 prædestinatione prædestinatione NN 19613 8170 5 quæ quæ NNP 19613 8170 6 non non AFX 19613 8170 7 est est NNP 19613 8170 8 posita posita NNP 19613 8170 9 , , , 19613 8170 10 in in IN 19613 8170 11 substantia substantia NNP 19613 8170 12 fuit fuit NNP 19613 8170 13 Christus Christus NNP 19613 8170 14 ante ante NNP 19613 8170 15 mundi mundi NN 19613 8170 16 institutionem institutionem NNP 19613 8170 17 " " '' 19613 8170 18 ; ; : 19613 8170 19 c. c. NNP 19613 8170 20 31 31 CD 19613 8170 21 : : : 19613 8170 22 " " `` 19613 8170 23 Est Est NNP 19613 8170 24 ergo ergo NN 19613 8170 25 deus deus NNP 19613 8170 26 pater pater NN 19613 8170 27 omnium omnium NN 19613 8170 28 institutor institutor NN 19613 8170 29 et et NN 19613 8170 30 creator creator NN 19613 8170 31 , , , 19613 8170 32 solus solus NNP 19613 8170 33 originem originem NNP 19613 8170 34 nesciens nesciens NNP 19613 8170 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8170 36 ! ! . 19613 8171 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8171 2 , , , 19613 8171 3 invisibilis invisibilis NNP 19613 8171 4 , , , 19613 8171 5 immensus immensus NNP 19613 8171 6 , , , 19613 8171 7 immortalis immortalis NNP 19613 8171 8 , , , 19613 8171 9 æternus æternus NN 19613 8171 10 , , , 19613 8171 11 unus unus JJ 19613 8171 12 deus deus NNP 19613 8171 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8171 14 ! ! . 19613 8172 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8172 2 , , , 19613 8172 3 ... ... NFP 19613 8172 4 ex ex NNP 19613 8172 5 quo quo NNP 19613 8172 6 quando quando NNP 19613 8172 7 ipse ipse NNP 19613 8172 8 voluit voluit NNP 19613 8172 9 , , , 19613 8172 10 sermo sermo NNP 19613 8172 11 filius filius NNP 19613 8172 12 natus natus NNP 19613 8172 13 est est NNP 19613 8172 14 , , , 19613 8172 15 qui qui VBD 19613 8172 16 non non JJ 19613 8172 17 in in IN 19613 8172 18 sono sono NNP 19613 8172 19 percussi percussi NNP 19613 8172 20 aeris aeris NNP 19613 8172 21 aut aut NNP 19613 8172 22 tono tono NNP 19613 8172 23 coactæ coactæ NNP 19613 8172 24 de de NNP 19613 8172 25 visceribus visceribus NNP 19613 8172 26 vocis vocis NNP 19613 8172 27 accipitur accipitur NNP 19613 8172 28 , , , 19613 8172 29 sed se VBN 19613 8172 30 in in IN 19613 8172 31 substantia substantia NNP 19613 8172 32 prolatæ prolatæ VBD 19613 8172 33 a a DT 19613 8172 34 deo deo NNP 19613 8172 35 virtutis virtutis NN 19613 8172 36 agnoscitur agnoscitur NN 19613 8172 37 , , , 19613 8172 38 cuius cuius NNP 19613 8172 39 sacræ sacræ NNP 19613 8172 40 et et NNP 19613 8172 41 divinas divinas NNP 19613 8172 42 nativitatis nativitatis NNP 19613 8172 43 arcana arcana NNP 19613 8172 44 nec nec NNP 19613 8172 45 apostolus apostolus NNP 19613 8172 46 didicit didicit NNP 19613 8172 47 ... ... : 19613 8172 48 , , , 19613 8172 49 filio filio NNP 19613 8172 50 soli soli NNP 19613 8172 51 nota nota NNP 19613 8172 52 sunt sunt NNP 19613 8172 53 , , , 19613 8172 54 qui qui NNP 19613 8172 55 patris patris NNP 19613 8172 56 secreta secreta NNP 19613 8172 57 cognovit cognovit NNP 19613 8172 58 . . . 19613 8173 1 Hic Hic NNP 19613 8173 2 ergo ergo FW 19613 8173 3 cum cum NNP 19613 8173 4 sit sit VB 19613 8173 5 genitus genitus NNP 19613 8173 6 a a DT 19613 8173 7 patre patre NN 19613 8173 8 , , , 19613 8173 9 semper semper NNP 19613 8173 10 est est NNP 19613 8173 11 in in IN 19613 8173 12 patre patre NNP 19613 8173 13 . . . 19613 8174 1 Semper semper JJ 19613 8174 2 autem autem JJ 19613 8174 3 sic sic NN 19613 8174 4 dico dico NN 19613 8174 5 , , , 19613 8174 6 ut ut UH 19613 8174 7 non non AFX 19613 8174 8 innatum innatum NNP 19613 8174 9 , , , 19613 8174 10 sed sed NNP 19613 8174 11 natum natum NNP 19613 8174 12 probem probem NNP 19613 8174 13 ; ; , 19613 8174 14 sed sed NNP 19613 8174 15 qui qui NNP 19613 8174 16 ante ante NNP 19613 8174 17 omne omne NNP 19613 8174 18 tempus tempus NNP 19613 8174 19 est est NNP 19613 8174 20 , , , 19613 8174 21 semper semper NN 19613 8174 22 in in IN 19613 8174 23 patre patre NNP 19613 8174 24 fuisse fuisse NNP 19613 8174 25 discendus discendus NNP 19613 8174 26 est est NNP 19613 8174 27 , , , 19613 8174 28 nec nec NNP 19613 8174 29 enim enim NNP 19613 8174 30 tempus tempus NNP 19613 8174 31 illi illi NNP 19613 8174 32 assignari assignari NNP 19613 8174 33 potest potest NNP 19613 8174 34 , , , 19613 8174 35 qui qui NNP 19613 8174 36 ante ante NNP 19613 8174 37 tempus tempus NNP 19613 8174 38 est est NNP 19613 8174 39 ; ; : 19613 8174 40 semper semper NNP 19613 8174 41 enim enim NNP 19613 8174 42 in in IN 19613 8174 43 patre patre NNP 19613 8174 44 , , , 19613 8174 45 ne ne NNP 19613 8174 46 pater pater NN 19613 8174 47 non non AFX 19613 8174 48 semper semper NNP 19613 8174 49 sit sit VBP 19613 8174 50 pater pater NNP 19613 8174 51 : : : 19613 8174 52 quia quia NNP 19613 8174 53 et et NNP 19613 8174 54 pater pater NN 19613 8174 55 illum illum NNP 19613 8174 56 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8174 57 præcedit præcedit NNP 19613 8174 58 , , , 19613 8174 59 quod quod NN 19613 8174 60 necesse necesse NNP 19613 8174 61 est est NNP 19613 8174 62 , , , 19613 8174 63 prior prior RB 19613 8174 64 sit sit VB 19613 8174 65 qua qua NNP 19613 8174 66 pater pater NN 19613 8174 67 sit sit VBP 19613 8174 68 . . . 19613 8175 1 Quoniam quoniam JJ 19613 8175 2 antecedat antecedat NN 19613 8175 3 necesse necesse NNP 19613 8175 4 est est NNP 19613 8175 5 eum eum NNP 19613 8175 6 , , , 19613 8175 7 qui qui NNP 19613 8175 8 habet habet NNP 19613 8175 9 originem originem NNP 19613 8175 10 , , , 19613 8175 11 ille ille NNP 19613 8175 12 qui qui NNP 19613 8175 13 originem originem NNP 19613 8175 14 nescit nescit NNP 19613 8175 15 . . . 19613 8176 1 Simul Simul NNS 19613 8176 2 ut ut UH 19613 8176 3 hic hic JJ 19613 8176 4 minor minor JJ 19613 8176 5 sit sit NN 19613 8176 6 , , , 19613 8176 7 dum dum NN 19613 8176 8 in in IN 19613 8176 9 illo illo NNP 19613 8176 10 esse esse NNP 19613 8176 11 se se NNP 19613 8176 12 scit scit NNP 19613 8176 13 habens habens NNP 19613 8176 14 originem originem NNP 19613 8176 15 quia quia NNP 19613 8176 16 nascitur nascitur NNP 19613 8176 17 , , , 19613 8176 18 et et FW 19613 8176 19 per per IN 19613 8176 20 patrem patrem NN 19613 8176 21 quamvis quamvis NNP 19613 8176 22 originem originem NNP 19613 8176 23 habet habet NNP 19613 8176 24 qua qua NNP 19613 8176 25 nascitur nascitur NNP 19613 8176 26 , , , 19613 8176 27 vicinus vicinus NN 19613 8176 28 in in IN 19613 8176 29 nativitate nativitate NNP 19613 8176 30 , , , 19613 8176 31 dum dum NNP 19613 8176 32 ex ex NNP 19613 8176 33 eo eo NNP 19613 8176 34 patre patre NN 19613 8176 35 , , , 19613 8176 36 qui qui NNP 19613 8176 37 solus solus NNP 19613 8176 38 originem originem NNP 19613 8176 39 non non NNP 19613 8176 40 habet habet NNP 19613 8176 41 , , , 19613 8176 42 nascitur nascitur NNP 19613 8176 43 ... ... NFP 19613 8176 44 , , , 19613 8176 45 substantia substantia NNP 19613 8176 46 scilicet scilicet NNP 19613 8176 47 divina divina NNP 19613 8176 48 , , , 19613 8176 49 cuius cuius NNP 19613 8176 50 nomen noman NNS 19613 8176 51 est est NNP 19613 8176 52 verbum verbum NN 19613 8176 53 ... ... NFP 19613 8176 54 , , , 19613 8176 55 deus deus NNP 19613 8176 56 utique utique NNP 19613 8176 57 procedens procedens NNP 19613 8176 58 ex ex NNP 19613 8176 59 deo deo NNP 19613 8176 60 secundam secundam NNP 19613 8176 61 personam personam NNP 19613 8176 62 efficiens efficiens NNP 19613 8176 63 , , , 19613 8176 64 sed se VBD 19613 8176 65 non non NNP 19613 8176 66 eripiens eripien NNS 19613 8176 67 illud illud VBP 19613 8176 68 patri patri NN 19613 8176 69 quod quod NN 19613 8176 70 unus unus JJ 19613 8176 71 est est NNP 19613 8176 72 deus deus NNP 19613 8176 73 .... .... NFP 19613 8176 74 Cuius cuius NN 19613 8176 75 sic sic NN 19613 8176 76 divinitas divinitas JJ 19613 8176 77 traditur traditur NN 19613 8176 78 , , , 19613 8176 79 ut ut UH 19613 8176 80 non non AFX 19613 8176 81 aut aut NNP 19613 8176 82 dissonantia dissonantia NNP 19613 8176 83 aut aut NNP 19613 8176 84 inæqualitate inæqualitate NNP 19613 8176 85 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 8176 86 duos duos NNP 19613 8176 87 deos deos NNP 19613 8176 88 reddidisse reddidisse NNP 19613 8176 89 videatur videatur NNP 19613 8176 90 .... .... . 19613 8176 91 Dum Dum NNP 19613 8176 92 huic huic NNS 19613 8176 93 , , , 19613 8176 94 qui qui NNP 19613 8176 95 est est NNP 19613 8176 96 deus deus NNP 19613 8176 97 , , , 19613 8176 98 omnia omnia NNP 19613 8176 99 substrata substrata NNP 19613 8176 100 traduntur traduntur NNP 19613 8176 101 et et NNP 19613 8176 102 cuncta cuncta NNP 19613 8176 103 sibi sibi NNP 19613 8176 104 subiecta subiecta NNP 19613 8176 105 filius filius NNP 19613 8176 106 accepta accepta NNP 19613 8176 107 refert refert NNP 19613 8176 108 patri patri NNP 19613 8176 109 , , , 19613 8176 110 totam totam NNP 19613 8176 111 divinitatis divinitatis VBP 19613 8176 112 auctoritatem auctoritatem NNP 19613 8176 113 rursus rursus NNP 19613 8176 114 patri patri NNP 19613 8176 115 remittit remittit NNP 19613 8176 116 , , , 19613 8176 117 unus unus NNP 19613 8176 118 deus deus NNP 19613 8176 119 ostenditur ostenditur NNP 19613 8176 120 verus verus NNP 19613 8176 121 et et NNP 19613 8176 122 æternus æternus NNP 19613 8176 123 pater pater NNP 19613 8176 124 , , , 19613 8176 125 a a DT 19613 8176 126 quo quo NNP 19613 8176 127 solo solo NN 19613 8176 128 hæc hæc NNP 19613 8176 129 vis vis FW 19613 8176 130 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 8176 131 emissa emissa NNP 19613 8176 132 , , , 19613 8176 133 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8176 134 in in IN 19613 8176 135 filium filium NNP 19613 8176 136 tradita tradita NNP 19613 8176 137 et et NNP 19613 8176 138 directa directa NN 19613 8176 139 rursus rursus NNP 19613 8176 140 per per IN 19613 8176 141 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 8176 142 ; ; : 19613 8176 143 communionem communionem NN 19613 8176 144 ad ad NN 19613 8176 145 patrem patrem NN 19613 8176 146 revolvitur revolvitur NNP 19613 8176 147 . . . 19613 8176 148 " " '' 19613 8176 149 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8177 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8177 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8177 3 654 654 CD 19613 8177 4 : : : 19613 8177 5 If if IN 19613 8177 6 I -PRON- PRP 19613 8177 7 am be VBP 19613 8177 8 not not RB 19613 8177 9 mistaken mistaken JJ 19613 8177 10 , , , 19613 8177 11 the the DT 19613 8177 12 production production NN 19613 8177 13 or or CC 19613 8177 14 adaptation adaptation NN 19613 8177 15 of of IN 19613 8177 16 Apocalypses apocalypse NNS 19613 8177 17 did do VBD 19613 8177 18 indeed indeed RB 19613 8177 19 abate abate VB 19613 8177 20 in in IN 19613 8177 21 the the DT 19613 8177 22 third third JJ 19613 8177 23 century century NN 19613 8177 24 , , , 19613 8177 25 but but CC 19613 8177 26 acquired acquire VBD 19613 8177 27 fresh fresh JJ 19613 8177 28 vigour vigour NN 19613 8177 29 in in IN 19613 8177 30 the the DT 19613 8177 31 4th 4th NN 19613 8177 32 , , , 19613 8177 33 though though IN 19613 8177 34 at at IN 19613 8177 35 the the DT 19613 8177 36 same same JJ 19613 8177 37 time time NN 19613 8177 38 allowing allow VBG 19613 8177 39 greater great JJR 19613 8177 40 scope scope NN 19613 8177 41 to to IN 19613 8177 42 the the DT 19613 8177 43 influence influence NN 19613 8177 44 of of IN 19613 8177 45 heathen heathen NNP 19613 8177 46 literature literature NNP 19613 8177 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8177 48 including include VBG 19613 8177 49 romances romance NNS 19613 8177 50 as as RB 19613 8177 51 well well RB 19613 8177 52 as as IN 19613 8177 53 hagiographical hagiographical JJ 19613 8177 54 literature literature NN 19613 8177 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8177 56 . . . 19613 8177 57 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8178 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8178 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8178 3 655 655 CD 19613 8178 4 : : : 19613 8178 5 I -PRON- PRP 19613 8178 6 did do VBD 19613 8178 7 not not RB 19613 8178 8 care care VB 19613 8178 9 to to TO 19613 8178 10 appeal appeal VB 19613 8178 11 more more RBR 19613 8178 12 frequently frequently RB 19613 8178 13 to to IN 19613 8178 14 the the DT 19613 8178 15 Sibylline Sibylline NNP 19613 8178 16 oracles oracle NNS 19613 8178 17 either either CC 19613 8178 18 in in IN 19613 8178 19 this this DT 19613 8178 20 or or CC 19613 8178 21 the the DT 19613 8178 22 preceding precede VBG 19613 8178 23 chapter chapter NN 19613 8178 24 , , , 19613 8178 25 because because IN 19613 8178 26 the the DT 19613 8178 27 literary literary JJ 19613 8178 28 and and CC 19613 8178 29 historical historical JJ 19613 8178 30 investigation investigation NN 19613 8178 31 of of IN 19613 8178 32 these these DT 19613 8178 33 writings writing NNS 19613 8178 34 has have VBZ 19613 8178 35 not not RB 19613 8178 36 yet yet RB 19613 8178 37 made make VBN 19613 8178 38 such such JJ 19613 8178 39 progress progress NN 19613 8178 40 as as IN 19613 8178 41 to to TO 19613 8178 42 justify justify VB 19613 8178 43 one one CD 19613 8178 44 in in IN 19613 8178 45 using use VBG 19613 8178 46 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8178 47 for for IN 19613 8178 48 the the DT 19613 8178 49 history history NN 19613 8178 50 of of IN 19613 8178 51 dogma dogma NN 19613 8178 52 . . . 19613 8179 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8179 2 is be VBZ 19613 8179 3 well well RB 19613 8179 4 known know VBN 19613 8179 5 that that IN 19613 8179 6 the the DT 19613 8179 7 oracles oracle NNS 19613 8179 8 contain contain VBP 19613 8179 9 rich rich JJ 19613 8179 10 materials material NNS 19613 8179 11 in in IN 19613 8179 12 regard regard NN 19613 8179 13 to to IN 19613 8179 14 the the DT 19613 8179 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8179 16 of of IN 19613 8179 17 God God NNP 19613 8179 18 , , , 19613 8179 19 Christology Christology NNP 19613 8179 20 , , , 19613 8179 21 conceptions conception NNS 19613 8179 22 of of IN 19613 8179 23 the the DT 19613 8179 24 history history NN 19613 8179 25 of of IN 19613 8179 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8179 27 , , , 19613 8179 28 and and CC 19613 8179 29 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 8179 30 ; ; : 19613 8179 31 but but CC 19613 8179 32 , , , 19613 8179 33 apart apart RB 19613 8179 34 from from IN 19613 8179 35 the the DT 19613 8179 36 old old JJ 19613 8179 37 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 8179 38 oracles oracle NNS 19613 8179 39 , , , 19613 8179 40 this this DT 19613 8179 41 material material NN 19613 8179 42 belongs belong VBZ 19613 8179 43 to to IN 19613 8179 44 several several JJ 19613 8179 45 centuries century NNS 19613 8179 46 and and CC 19613 8179 47 has have VBZ 19613 8179 48 not not RB 19613 8179 49 yet yet RB 19613 8179 50 been be VBN 19613 8179 51 reliably reliably RB 19613 8179 52 sifted sift VBN 19613 8179 53 . . . 19613 8179 54 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8180 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 19613 8180 2 VI VI NNP 19613 8180 3 . . . 19613 8181 1 THE the DT 19613 8181 2 TRANSFORMATION TRANSFORMATION NNP 19613 8181 3 OF of IN 19613 8181 4 THE the DT 19613 8181 5 ECCLESIASTICAL ecclesiastical NN 19613 8181 6 TRADITION tradition NN 19613 8181 7 INTO into VBP 19613 8181 8 A a DT 19613 8181 9 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 19613 8181 10 OF of IN 19613 8181 11 RELIGION religion NN 19613 8181 12 , , , 19613 8181 13 OR or CC 19613 8181 14 THE the DT 19613 8181 15 ORIGIN origin NN 19613 8181 16 OF of IN 19613 8181 17 THE the DT 19613 8181 18 SCIENTIFIC scientific JJ 19613 8181 19 THEOLOGY theology NN 19613 8181 20 AND and CC 19613 8181 21 DOGMATIC dogmatic NN 19613 8181 22 OF of IN 19613 8181 23 THE the DT 19613 8181 24 CHURCH CHURCH NNS 19613 8181 25 . . . 19613 8182 1 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8182 2 and and CC 19613 8182 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8182 4 . . . 19613 8183 1 The the DT 19613 8183 2 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 8183 3 school school NN 19613 8183 4 of of IN 19613 8183 5 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8183 6 was be VBD 19613 8183 7 of of IN 19613 8183 8 inestimable inestimable JJ 19613 8183 9 importance importance NN 19613 8183 10 for for IN 19613 8183 11 the the DT 19613 8183 12 transformation transformation NN 19613 8183 13 of of IN 19613 8183 14 the the DT 19613 8183 15 heathen heathen NNP 19613 8183 16 empire empire NNP 19613 8183 17 into into IN 19613 8183 18 a a DT 19613 8183 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 8183 20 one one NN 19613 8183 21 , , , 19613 8183 22 and and CC 19613 8183 23 of of IN 19613 8183 24 Greek greek JJ 19613 8183 25 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8183 26 into into IN 19613 8183 27 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8183 28 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8183 29 . . . 19613 8184 1 In in IN 19613 8184 2 the the DT 19613 8184 3 third third JJ 19613 8184 4 century century NN 19613 8184 5 this this DT 19613 8184 6 school school NN 19613 8184 7 overthrew overthrew JJ 19613 8184 8 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 8184 9 by by IN 19613 8184 10 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8184 11 means mean NNS 19613 8184 12 whilst whilst VBN 19613 8184 13 at at IN 19613 8184 14 the the DT 19613 8184 15 same same JJ 19613 8184 16 time time NN 19613 8184 17 preserving preserve VBG 19613 8184 18 everything everything NN 19613 8184 19 of of IN 19613 8184 20 any any DT 19613 8184 21 value value NN 19613 8184 22 in in IN 19613 8184 23 Greek greek JJ 19613 8184 24 science science NN 19613 8184 25 and and CC 19613 8184 26 culture culture NN 19613 8184 27 . . . 19613 8185 1 These these DT 19613 8185 2 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 8185 3 wrote write VBD 19613 8185 4 for for IN 19613 8185 5 the the DT 19613 8185 6 educated educated JJ 19613 8185 7 people people NNS 19613 8185 8 of of IN 19613 8185 9 the the DT 19613 8185 10 whole whole JJ 19613 8185 11 earth earth NN 19613 8185 12 ; ; : 19613 8185 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8185 14 made make VBD 19613 8185 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8185 16 a a DT 19613 8185 17 part part NN 19613 8185 18 of of IN 19613 8185 19 the the DT 19613 8185 20 civilisation civilisation NN 19613 8185 21 of of IN 19613 8185 22 the the DT 19613 8185 23 world world NN 19613 8185 24 . . . 19613 8186 1 The the DT 19613 8186 2 saying saying NN 19613 8186 3 that that IN 19613 8186 4 the the DT 19613 8186 5 Christian christian JJ 19613 8186 6 missionary missionary NN 19613 8186 7 to to IN 19613 8186 8 the the DT 19613 8186 9 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 8186 10 must must MD 19613 8186 11 be be VB 19613 8186 12 a a DT 19613 8186 13 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8186 14 was be VBD 19613 8186 15 first first RB 19613 8186 16 completely completely RB 19613 8186 17 verified verify VBN 19613 8186 18 within within IN 19613 8186 19 the the DT 19613 8186 20 Catholic Catholic NNP 19613 8186 21 Church Church NNP 19613 8186 22 in in IN 19613 8186 23 the the DT 19613 8186 24 person person NN 19613 8186 25 of of IN 19613 8186 26 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8186 27 , , , 19613 8186 28 who who WP 19613 8186 29 at at IN 19613 8186 30 the the DT 19613 8186 31 same same JJ 19613 8186 32 time time NN 19613 8186 33 produced produce VBD 19613 8186 34 the the DT 19613 8186 35 only only JJ 19613 8186 36 system system NN 19613 8186 37 of of IN 19613 8186 38 Christian christian JJ 19613 8186 39 dogma dogma NN 19613 8186 40 possessed possess VBN 19613 8186 41 by by IN 19613 8186 42 the the DT 19613 8186 43 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8186 44 Church Church NNP 19613 8186 45 before before IN 19613 8186 46 John John NNP 19613 8186 47 Damascenus Damascenus NNP 19613 8186 48 . . . 19613 8187 1 1 1 LS 19613 8187 2 . . . 19613 8188 1 _ _ NNP 19613 8188 2 The the DT 19613 8188 3 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 19613 8188 4 Catechetical Catechetical NNP 19613 8188 5 School School NNP 19613 8188 6 . . . 19613 8189 1 Clement clement NN 19613 8189 2 of of IN 19613 8189 3 Alexandria._[656 alexandria._[656 NN 19613 8189 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8189 5 " " `` 19613 8189 6 The the DT 19613 8189 7 work work NN 19613 8189 8 of of IN 19613 8189 9 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8189 10 still still RB 19613 8189 11 leaves leave VBZ 19613 8189 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8189 13 undecided undecide VBD 19613 8189 14 whether whether IN 19613 8189 15 the the DT 19613 8189 16 form form NN 19613 8189 17 of of IN 19613 8189 18 the the DT 19613 8189 19 world world NN 19613 8189 20 's 's POS 19613 8189 21 literature literature NN 19613 8189 22 , , , 19613 8189 23 as as IN 19613 8189 24 found find VBN 19613 8189 25 in in IN 19613 8189 26 the the DT 19613 8189 27 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8189 28 Church Church NNP 19613 8189 29 , , , 19613 8189 30 is be VBZ 19613 8189 31 destined destine VBN 19613 8189 32 only only RB 19613 8189 33 to to TO 19613 8189 34 remain remain VB 19613 8189 35 a a DT 19613 8189 36 weapon weapon NN 19613 8189 37 to to TO 19613 8189 38 combat combat VB 19613 8189 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8189 40 enemies enemy NNS 19613 8189 41 , , , 19613 8189 42 or or CC 19613 8189 43 is be VBZ 19613 8189 44 to to TO 19613 8189 45 become become VB 19613 8189 46 an an DT 19613 8189 47 instrument instrument NN 19613 8189 48 of of IN 19613 8189 49 peaceful peaceful JJ 19613 8189 50 labour labour NN 19613 8189 51 within within IN 19613 8189 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8189 53 own own JJ 19613 8189 54 territory territory NN 19613 8189 55 . . . 19613 8189 56 " " '' 19613 8190 1 With with IN 19613 8190 2 these these DT 19613 8190 3 words word NNS 19613 8190 4 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 8190 5 has have VBZ 19613 8190 6 introduced introduce VBN 19613 8190 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8190 8 examination examination NN 19613 8190 9 of of IN 19613 8190 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8190 11 of of IN 19613 8190 12 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8190 13 's 's POS 19613 8190 14 great great JJ 19613 8190 15 masterpiece masterpiece NN 19613 8190 16 from from IN 19613 8190 17 the the DT 19613 8190 18 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 8190 19 of of IN 19613 8190 20 the the DT 19613 8190 21 historian historian NN 19613 8190 22 of of IN 19613 8190 23 literature literature NN 19613 8190 24 . . . 19613 8191 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 8191 2 may may MD 19613 8191 3 be be VB 19613 8191 4 also also RB 19613 8191 5 applied apply VBN 19613 8191 6 to to IN 19613 8191 7 the the DT 19613 8191 8 history history NN 19613 8191 9 of of IN 19613 8191 10 theology theology NN 19613 8191 11 . . . 19613 8192 1 As as IN 19613 8192 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8192 3 have have VBP 19613 8192 4 shown show VBN 19613 8192 5 , , , 19613 8192 6 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8192 7 , , , 19613 8192 8 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8192 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8192 10 and and CC 19613 8192 11 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 8192 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8192 13 made make VBD 19613 8192 14 use use NN 19613 8192 15 of of IN 19613 8192 16 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8192 17 theology theology NN 19613 8192 18 to to TO 19613 8192 19 expel expel VB 19613 8192 20 heretical heretical JJ 19613 8192 21 elements element NNS 19613 8192 22 ; ; : 19613 8192 23 but but CC 19613 8192 24 all all PDT 19613 8192 25 the the DT 19613 8192 26 theological theological JJ 19613 8192 27 expositions exposition NNS 19613 8192 28 that that IN 19613 8192 29 this this DT 19613 8192 30 interest interest NN 19613 8192 31 suggested suggest VBD 19613 8192 32 to to IN 19613 8192 33 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8192 34 as as IN 19613 8192 35 necessary necessary JJ 19613 8192 36 , , , 19613 8192 37 were be VBD 19613 8192 38 in in IN 19613 8192 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8192 40 view view NN 19613 8192 41 part part NN 19613 8192 42 of of IN 19613 8192 43 the the DT 19613 8192 44 faith faith NN 19613 8192 45 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8192 46 . . . 19613 8193 1 At at IN 19613 8193 2 least least JJS 19613 8193 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8193 4 find find VBP 19613 8193 5 in in IN 19613 8193 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8193 7 works work NNS 19613 8193 8 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 8193 9 no no DT 19613 8193 10 clear clear JJ 19613 8193 11 expression expression NN 19613 8193 12 of of IN 19613 8193 13 the the DT 19613 8193 14 fact fact NN 19613 8193 15 that that IN 19613 8193 16 faith faith NN 19613 8193 17 is be VBZ 19613 8193 18 one one CD 19613 8193 19 thing thing NN 19613 8193 20 and and CC 19613 8193 21 theology theology VB 19613 8193 22 another another DT 19613 8193 23 , , , 19613 8193 24 though though IN 19613 8193 25 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 8193 26 indications indication NNS 19613 8193 27 of of IN 19613 8193 28 such such JJ 19613 8193 29 distinctions distinction NNS 19613 8193 30 are be VBP 19613 8193 31 found find VBN 19613 8193 32 . . . 19613 8194 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8194 2 , , , 19613 8194 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8194 4 adherence adherence NN 19613 8194 5 to to IN 19613 8194 6 the the DT 19613 8194 7 early early JJ 19613 8194 8 - - HYPH 19613 8194 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 8194 10 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 8194 11 in in IN 19613 8194 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8194 13 entirety entirety NN 19613 8194 14 , , , 19613 8194 15 as as RB 19613 8194 16 well well RB 19613 8194 17 as as IN 19613 8194 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8194 19 rejection rejection NN 19613 8194 20 of of IN 19613 8194 21 a a DT 19613 8194 22 qualitative qualitative JJ 19613 8194 23 distinction distinction NN 19613 8194 24 between between IN 19613 8194 25 simple simple JJ 19613 8194 26 believers believer NNS 19613 8194 27 and and CC 19613 8194 28 " " `` 19613 8194 29 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8194 30 , , , 19613 8194 31 " " '' 19613 8194 32 proved prove VBD 19613 8194 33 that that IN 19613 8194 34 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8194 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8194 36 were be VBD 19613 8194 37 deceived deceive VBN 19613 8194 38 as as IN 19613 8194 39 to to IN 19613 8194 40 the the DT 19613 8194 41 scope scope NN 19613 8194 42 of of IN 19613 8194 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8194 44 theological theological JJ 19613 8194 45 speculations speculation NNS 19613 8194 46 , , , 19613 8194 47 and and CC 19613 8194 48 that that IN 19613 8194 49 moreover moreover RB 19613 8194 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8194 51 Christian christian JJ 19613 8194 52 interest interest NN 19613 8194 53 was be VBD 19613 8194 54 virtually virtually RB 19613 8194 55 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 8194 56 with with IN 19613 8194 57 subjection subjection NN 19613 8194 58 to to IN 19613 8194 59 the the DT 19613 8194 60 authority authority NN 19613 8194 61 of of IN 19613 8194 62 tradition tradition NN 19613 8194 63 , , , 19613 8194 64 with with IN 19613 8194 65 the the DT 19613 8194 66 early early JJ 19613 8194 67 - - HYPH 19613 8194 68 Christian christian JJ 19613 8194 69 hopes hope NNS 19613 8194 70 , , , 19613 8194 71 and and CC 19613 8194 72 with with IN 19613 8194 73 the the DT 19613 8194 74 rules rule NNS 19613 8194 75 for for IN 19613 8194 76 a a DT 19613 8194 77 holy holy JJ 19613 8194 78 life life NN 19613 8194 79 . . . 19613 8195 1 But but CC 19613 8195 2 since since IN 19613 8195 3 about about RB 19613 8195 4 the the DT 19613 8195 5 time time NN 19613 8195 6 of of IN 19613 8195 7 Commodus Commodus NNP 19613 8195 8 , , , 19613 8195 9 and and CC 19613 8195 10 in in IN 19613 8195 11 some some DT 19613 8195 12 cases case NNS 19613 8195 13 even even RB 19613 8195 14 earlier early RBR 19613 8195 15 , , , 19613 8195 16 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8195 17 can can MD 19613 8195 18 observe observe VB 19613 8195 19 , , , 19613 8195 20 even even RB 19613 8195 21 in in IN 19613 8195 22 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8195 23 circles circle NNS 19613 8195 24 , , , 19613 8195 25 the the DT 19613 8195 26 growing grow VBG 19613 8195 27 independence independence NN 19613 8195 28 and and CC 19613 8195 29 might might NN 19613 8195 30 of of IN 19613 8195 31 the the DT 19613 8195 32 aspiration aspiration NN 19613 8195 33 for for IN 19613 8195 34 a a DT 19613 8195 35 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8195 36 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8195 37 and and CC 19613 8195 38 treatment treatment NN 19613 8195 39 of of IN 19613 8195 40 the the DT 19613 8195 41 Christian christian JJ 19613 8195 42 religion religion NN 19613 8195 43 , , , 19613 8195 44 that that DT 19613 8195 45 is be VBZ 19613 8195 46 of of IN 19613 8195 47 Christian christian JJ 19613 8195 48 tradition tradition NN 19613 8195 49 . . . 19613 8196 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8196 2 657 657 CD 19613 8196 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8196 4 There there EX 19613 8196 5 is be VBZ 19613 8196 6 a a DT 19613 8196 7 wish wish NN 19613 8196 8 to to TO 19613 8196 9 maintain maintain VB 19613 8196 10 this this DT 19613 8196 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 8196 12 in in IN 19613 8196 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8196 14 entirety entirety NN 19613 8196 15 and and CC 19613 8196 16 hence hence RB 19613 8196 17 the the DT 19613 8196 18 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8196 19 these these DT 19613 8196 20 s s NNS 19613 8196 21 are be VBP 19613 8196 22 rejected reject VBN 19613 8196 23 . . . 19613 8197 1 The the DT 19613 8197 2 selection selection NN 19613 8197 3 from from IN 19613 8197 4 tradition tradition NN 19613 8197 5 , , , 19613 8197 6 made make VBN 19613 8197 7 in in IN 19613 8197 8 opposition opposition NN 19613 8197 9 to to IN 19613 8197 10 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 8197 11 -- -- : 19613 8197 12 though though IN 19613 8197 13 indeed indeed RB 19613 8197 14 in in IN 19613 8197 15 accordance accordance NN 19613 8197 16 with with IN 19613 8197 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8197 18 methods method NNS 19613 8197 19 -- -- : 19613 8197 20 and and CC 19613 8197 21 declared declare VBD 19613 8197 22 to to TO 19613 8197 23 be be VB 19613 8197 24 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 8197 25 , , , 19613 8197 26 is be VBZ 19613 8197 27 accepted accept VBN 19613 8197 28 . . . 19613 8198 1 But but CC 19613 8198 2 there there EX 19613 8198 3 is be VBZ 19613 8198 4 a a DT 19613 8198 5 desire desire NN 19613 8198 6 to to TO 19613 8198 7 treat treat VB 19613 8198 8 the the DT 19613 8198 9 given give VBN 19613 8198 10 material material NN 19613 8198 11 in in IN 19613 8198 12 a a DT 19613 8198 13 strictly strictly RB 19613 8198 14 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8198 15 manner manner NN 19613 8198 16 , , , 19613 8198 17 just just RB 19613 8198 18 as as IN 19613 8198 19 the the DT 19613 8198 20 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8198 21 had have VBD 19613 8198 22 formerly formerly RB 19613 8198 23 done do VBN 19613 8198 24 , , , 19613 8198 25 that that RB 19613 8198 26 is is RB 19613 8198 27 , , , 19613 8198 28 on on IN 19613 8198 29 the the DT 19613 8198 30 one one CD 19613 8198 31 hand hand NN 19613 8198 32 to to TO 19613 8198 33 establish establish VB 19613 8198 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8198 35 by by IN 19613 8198 36 a a DT 19613 8198 37 critical critical JJ 19613 8198 38 and and CC 19613 8198 39 historical historical JJ 19613 8198 40 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8198 41 , , , 19613 8198 42 and and CC 19613 8198 43 on on IN 19613 8198 44 the the DT 19613 8198 45 other other JJ 19613 8198 46 to to TO 19613 8198 47 give give VB 19613 8198 48 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8198 49 a a DT 19613 8198 50 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8198 51 form form NN 19613 8198 52 and and CC 19613 8198 53 bring bring VB 19613 8198 54 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8198 55 into into IN 19613 8198 56 harmony harmony NN 19613 8198 57 with with IN 19613 8198 58 the the DT 19613 8198 59 spirit spirit NN 19613 8198 60 of of IN 19613 8198 61 the the DT 19613 8198 62 times time NNS 19613 8198 63 . . . 19613 8199 1 Along along IN 19613 8199 2 with with IN 19613 8199 3 this this DT 19613 8199 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8199 5 also also RB 19613 8199 6 find find VBP 19613 8199 7 the the DT 19613 8199 8 wish wish NN 19613 8199 9 to to TO 19613 8199 10 incorporate incorporate VB 19613 8199 11 the the DT 19613 8199 12 thoughts thought NNS 19613 8199 13 of of IN 19613 8199 14 Paul Paul NNP 19613 8199 15 which which WDT 19613 8199 16 now now RB 19613 8199 17 possessed possess VBD 19613 8199 18 divine divine JJ 19613 8199 19 authority authority NN 19613 8199 20 . . . 19613 8200 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8200 2 658 658 CD 19613 8200 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8200 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8200 5 schools school NNS 19613 8200 6 and and CC 19613 8200 7 scholastic scholastic JJ 19613 8200 8 unions union NNS 19613 8200 9 now now RB 19613 8200 10 make make VBP 19613 8200 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8200 12 appearance appearance NN 19613 8200 13 afresh afresh JJ 19613 8200 14 , , , 19613 8200 15 the the DT 19613 8200 16 old old JJ 19613 8200 17 schools school NNS 19613 8200 18 having have VBG 19613 8200 19 been be VBN 19613 8200 20 expelled expel VBN 19613 8200 21 from from IN 19613 8200 22 the the DT 19613 8200 23 Church Church NNP 19613 8200 24 . . . 19613 8201 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8201 2 659 659 CD 19613 8201 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8201 4 In in IN 19613 8201 5 Asia Asia NNP 19613 8201 6 Minor minor JJ 19613 8201 7 such such JJ 19613 8201 8 efforts effort NNS 19613 8201 9 had have VBD 19613 8201 10 already already RB 19613 8201 11 begun begin VBN 19613 8201 12 shortly shortly RB 19613 8201 13 before before IN 19613 8201 14 the the DT 19613 8201 15 time time NN 19613 8201 16 when when WRB 19613 8201 17 the the DT 19613 8201 18 canon canon NN 19613 8201 19 of of IN 19613 8201 20 holy holy NNP 19613 8201 21 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 8201 22 tradition tradition NN 19613 8201 23 was be VBD 19613 8201 24 fixed fix VBN 19613 8201 25 by by IN 19613 8201 26 the the DT 19613 8201 27 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8201 28 authorities authority NNS 19613 8201 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8201 30 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 8201 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8201 32 . . . 19613 8202 1 From from IN 19613 8202 2 the the DT 19613 8202 3 history history NN 19613 8202 4 of of IN 19613 8202 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8202 6 of of IN 19613 8202 7 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8202 8 , , , 19613 8202 9 the the DT 19613 8202 10 life life NN 19613 8202 11 of of IN 19613 8202 12 bishop bishop NNP 19613 8202 13 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8202 14 , , , 19613 8202 15 afterwards afterwards RB 19613 8202 16 bishop bishop NN 19613 8202 17 of of IN 19613 8202 18 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 8202 19 , , , 19613 8202 20 and and CC 19613 8202 21 subsequently subsequently RB 19613 8202 22 from from IN 19613 8202 23 the the DT 19613 8202 24 history history NN 19613 8202 25 of of IN 19613 8202 26 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8202 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8202 28 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8202 29 may may MD 19613 8202 30 also also RB 19613 8202 31 mention mention VB 19613 8202 32 Firmilian firmilian JJ 19613 8202 33 of of IN 19613 8202 34 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 19613 8202 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8202 36 , , , 19613 8202 37 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8202 38 learn learn VBP 19613 8202 39 that that IN 19613 8202 40 there there EX 19613 8202 41 was be VBD 19613 8202 42 in in IN 19613 8202 43 Cappadocia Cappadocia NNP 19613 8202 44 about about IN 19613 8202 45 the the DT 19613 8202 46 year year NN 19613 8202 47 200 200 CD 19613 8202 48 a a DT 19613 8202 49 circle circle NN 19613 8202 50 of of IN 19613 8202 51 ecclesiastics ecclesiastic NNS 19613 8202 52 who who WP 19613 8202 53 zealously zealously RB 19613 8202 54 applied apply VBD 19613 8202 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8202 56 to to IN 19613 8202 57 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8202 58 pursuits pursuit NNS 19613 8202 59 . . . 19613 8203 1 Bardesanes Bardesanes NNP 19613 8203 2 , , , 19613 8203 3 a a DT 19613 8203 4 man man NN 19613 8203 5 of of IN 19613 8203 6 high high JJ 19613 8203 7 repute repute NN 19613 8203 8 , , , 19613 8203 9 laboured labour VBN 19613 8203 10 in in IN 19613 8203 11 the the DT 19613 8203 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 8203 13 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 8203 14 of of IN 19613 8203 15 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 8203 16 about about IN 19613 8203 17 the the DT 19613 8203 18 same same JJ 19613 8203 19 time time NN 19613 8203 20 . . . 19613 8204 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8204 2 wrote write VBD 19613 8204 3 treatises treatise NNS 19613 8204 4 on on IN 19613 8204 5 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8204 6 theology theology NN 19613 8204 7 , , , 19613 8204 8 which which WDT 19613 8204 9 indeed indeed RB 19613 8204 10 , , , 19613 8204 11 judged judge VBN 19613 8204 12 by by IN 19613 8204 13 a a DT 19613 8204 14 Western western JJ 19613 8204 15 standard standard NN 19613 8204 16 , , , 19613 8204 17 could could MD 19613 8204 18 not not RB 19613 8204 19 be be VB 19613 8204 20 accounted account VBN 19613 8204 21 orthodox orthodox RB 19613 8204 22 , , , 19613 8204 23 and and CC 19613 8204 24 directed direct VBD 19613 8204 25 a a DT 19613 8204 26 theological theological JJ 19613 8204 27 school school NN 19613 8204 28 which which WDT 19613 8204 29 maintained maintain VBD 19613 8204 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8204 31 ground ground NN 19613 8204 32 in in IN 19613 8204 33 the the DT 19613 8204 34 third third JJ 19613 8204 35 century century NN 19613 8204 36 and and CC 19613 8204 37 attained attain VBD 19613 8204 38 great great JJ 19613 8204 39 importance importance NN 19613 8204 40 . . . 19613 8205 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8205 2 660 660 CD 19613 8205 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8205 4 In in IN 19613 8205 5 Palestine Palestine NNP 19613 8205 6 , , , 19613 8205 7 during during IN 19613 8205 8 the the DT 19613 8205 9 time time NN 19613 8205 10 of of IN 19613 8205 11 Heliogabalus Heliogabalus NNP 19613 8205 12 and and CC 19613 8205 13 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8205 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8205 15 Severus Severus NNP 19613 8205 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8205 17 , , , 19613 8205 18 Julius Julius NNP 19613 8205 19 Africanus Africanus NNP 19613 8205 20 composed compose VBD 19613 8205 21 a a DT 19613 8205 22 series series NN 19613 8205 23 of of IN 19613 8205 24 books book NNS 19613 8205 25 on on IN 19613 8205 26 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8205 27 theology theology NN 19613 8205 28 , , , 19613 8205 29 which which WDT 19613 8205 30 were be VBD 19613 8205 31 specifically specifically RB 19613 8205 32 different different JJ 19613 8205 33 from from IN 19613 8205 34 the the DT 19613 8205 35 writings writing NNS 19613 8205 36 of of IN 19613 8205 37 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8205 38 and and CC 19613 8205 39 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8205 40 ; ; : 19613 8205 41 but but CC 19613 8205 42 which which WDT 19613 8205 43 on on IN 19613 8205 44 the the DT 19613 8205 45 other other JJ 19613 8205 46 hand hand NN 19613 8205 47 show show VBP 19613 8205 48 the the DT 19613 8205 49 closest close JJS 19613 8205 50 relationship relationship NN 19613 8205 51 in in IN 19613 8205 52 point point NN 19613 8205 53 of of IN 19613 8205 54 form form NN 19613 8205 55 to to IN 19613 8205 56 the the DT 19613 8205 57 treatises treatise NNS 19613 8205 58 of of IN 19613 8205 59 the the DT 19613 8205 60 so so RB 19613 8205 61 - - HYPH 19613 8205 62 called call VBN 19613 8205 63 Gnostics gnostic NNS 19613 8205 64 . . . 19613 8206 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8206 2 inquiries inquiry NNS 19613 8206 3 into into IN 19613 8206 4 the the DT 19613 8206 5 relationship relationship NN 19613 8206 6 of of IN 19613 8206 7 the the DT 19613 8206 8 genealogies genealogy NNS 19613 8206 9 of of IN 19613 8206 10 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8206 11 and and CC 19613 8206 12 into into IN 19613 8206 13 certain certain JJ 19613 8206 14 parts part NNS 19613 8206 15 of of IN 19613 8206 16 the the DT 19613 8206 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8206 18 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 19613 8206 19 of of IN 19613 8206 20 Daniel Daniel NNP 19613 8206 21 showed show VBD 19613 8206 22 that that IN 19613 8206 23 the the DT 19613 8206 24 Church Church NNP 19613 8206 25 's 's POS 19613 8206 26 attention attention NN 19613 8206 27 had have VBD 19613 8206 28 been be VBN 19613 8206 29 drawn draw VBN 19613 8206 30 to to IN 19613 8206 31 problems problem NNS 19613 8206 32 of of IN 19613 8206 33 historical historical JJ 19613 8206 34 criticism criticism NN 19613 8206 35 . . . 19613 8207 1 In in IN 19613 8207 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8207 3 chronography chronography NN 19613 8207 4 the the DT 19613 8207 5 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 8207 6 interest interest NN 19613 8207 7 is be VBZ 19613 8207 8 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 8207 9 to to IN 19613 8207 10 the the DT 19613 8207 11 historical historical JJ 19613 8207 12 , , , 19613 8207 13 and and CC 19613 8207 14 in in IN 19613 8207 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8207 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8207 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8207 18 : : : 19613 8207 19 Kestoi Kestoi NNP 19613 8207 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8207 21 , , , 19613 8207 22 dedicated dedicated JJ 19613 8207 23 to to IN 19613 8207 24 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8207 25 Severus Severus NNP 19613 8207 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8207 27 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 8207 28 had have VBD 19613 8207 29 already already RB 19613 8207 30 dedicated dedicate VBN 19613 8207 31 a a DT 19613 8207 32 treatise treatise NN 19613 8207 33 on on IN 19613 8207 34 the the DT 19613 8207 35 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 8207 36 to to IN 19613 8207 37 the the DT 19613 8207 38 wife wife NN 19613 8207 39 of of IN 19613 8207 40 Heliogabalus Heliogabalus NNP 19613 8207 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8207 42 , , , 19613 8207 43 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8207 44 see see VBP 19613 8207 45 fewer few JJR 19613 8207 46 traces trace NNS 19613 8207 47 of of IN 19613 8207 48 the the DT 19613 8207 49 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8207 50 than than IN 19613 8207 51 of of IN 19613 8207 52 the the DT 19613 8207 53 Greek greek JJ 19613 8207 54 scholar scholar NN 19613 8207 55 . . . 19613 8208 1 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8208 2 of of IN 19613 8208 3 Ælia Ælia NNP 19613 8208 4 and and CC 19613 8208 5 Theoktistus Theoktistus NNP 19613 8208 6 of of IN 19613 8208 7 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 19613 8208 8 , , , 19613 8208 9 the the DT 19613 8208 10 occupants occupant NNS 19613 8208 11 of of IN 19613 8208 12 the the DT 19613 8208 13 two two CD 19613 8208 14 most most RBS 19613 8208 15 important important JJ 19613 8208 16 sees see NNS 19613 8208 17 in in IN 19613 8208 18 Palestine Palestine NNP 19613 8208 19 , , , 19613 8208 20 were be VBD 19613 8208 21 , , , 19613 8208 22 contemporaneously contemporaneously RB 19613 8208 23 with with IN 19613 8208 24 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8208 25 , , , 19613 8208 26 zealous zealous JJ 19613 8208 27 patrons patron NNS 19613 8208 28 of of IN 19613 8208 29 an an DT 19613 8208 30 independent independent JJ 19613 8208 31 science science NN 19613 8208 32 of of IN 19613 8208 33 theology theology NN 19613 8208 34 . . . 19613 8209 1 Even even RB 19613 8209 2 at at IN 19613 8209 3 that that DT 19613 8209 4 early early JJ 19613 8209 5 time time NN 19613 8209 6 the the DT 19613 8209 7 former former JJ 19613 8209 8 founded found VBD 19613 8209 9 an an DT 19613 8209 10 important important JJ 19613 8209 11 theological theological JJ 19613 8209 12 library library NN 19613 8209 13 ; ; : 19613 8209 14 and and CC 19613 8209 15 the the DT 19613 8209 16 fragments fragment NNS 19613 8209 17 of of IN 19613 8209 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8209 19 letters letter NNS 19613 8209 20 preserved preserve VBN 19613 8209 21 to to IN 19613 8209 22 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8209 23 prove prove VB 19613 8209 24 that that IN 19613 8209 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8209 26 had have VBD 19613 8209 27 caught catch VBN 19613 8209 28 not not RB 19613 8209 29 only only RB 19613 8209 30 the the DT 19613 8209 31 language language NN 19613 8209 32 , , , 19613 8209 33 but but CC 19613 8209 34 also also RB 19613 8209 35 the the DT 19613 8209 36 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8209 37 spirit spirit NN 19613 8209 38 of of IN 19613 8209 39 the the DT 19613 8209 40 age age NN 19613 8209 41 . . . 19613 8210 1 In in IN 19613 8210 2 Rome Rome NNP 19613 8210 3 , , , 19613 8210 4 at at IN 19613 8210 5 the the DT 19613 8210 6 beginning beginning NN 19613 8210 7 of of IN 19613 8210 8 the the DT 19613 8210 9 third third JJ 19613 8210 10 century century NN 19613 8210 11 , , , 19613 8210 12 there there EX 19613 8210 13 was be VBD 19613 8210 14 a a DT 19613 8210 15 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8210 16 school school NN 19613 8210 17 where where WRB 19613 8210 18 textual textual JJ 19613 8210 19 criticism criticism NN 19613 8210 20 of of IN 19613 8210 21 the the DT 19613 8210 22 Bible Bible NNP 19613 8210 23 was be VBD 19613 8210 24 pursued pursue VBN 19613 8210 25 and and CC 19613 8210 26 where where WRB 19613 8210 27 the the DT 19613 8210 28 works work NNS 19613 8210 29 of of IN 19613 8210 30 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 19613 8210 31 , , , 19613 8210 32 Theophrastus Theophrastus NNP 19613 8210 33 , , , 19613 8210 34 Euclid Euclid NNP 19613 8210 35 , , , 19613 8210 36 and and CC 19613 8210 37 Galen Galen NNP 19613 8210 38 were be VBD 19613 8210 39 zealously zealously RB 19613 8210 40 read read VBN 19613 8210 41 and and CC 19613 8210 42 utilised utilise VBD 19613 8210 43 . . . 19613 8211 1 Finally finally RB 19613 8211 2 , , , 19613 8211 3 the the DT 19613 8211 4 works work NNS 19613 8211 5 of of IN 19613 8211 6 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8211 7 show show VBP 19613 8211 8 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8211 9 that that DT 19613 8211 10 , , , 19613 8211 11 even even RB 19613 8211 12 among among IN 19613 8211 13 the the DT 19613 8211 14 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8211 15 of of IN 19613 8211 16 Carthage carthage NN 19613 8211 17 , , , 19613 8211 18 there there EX 19613 8211 19 was be VBD 19613 8211 20 no no DT 19613 8211 21 lack lack NN 19613 8211 22 of of IN 19613 8211 23 such such JJ 19613 8211 24 as as IN 19613 8211 25 wished wish VBD 19613 8211 26 to to TO 19613 8211 27 naturalise naturalise VB 19613 8211 28 the the DT 19613 8211 29 pursuit pursuit NN 19613 8211 30 of of IN 19613 8211 31 science science NN 19613 8211 32 within within IN 19613 8211 33 the the DT 19613 8211 34 Church Church NNP 19613 8211 35 ; ; : 19613 8211 36 and and CC 19613 8211 37 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 8211 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8211 39 H. H. NNP 19613 8211 40 E. E. NNP 19613 8211 41 V. V. NNP 19613 8211 42 27 27 CD 19613 8211 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8211 44 has have VBZ 19613 8211 45 transmitted transmit VBN 19613 8211 46 to to IN 19613 8211 47 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8211 48 the the DT 19613 8211 49 titles title NNS 19613 8211 50 of of IN 19613 8211 51 a a DT 19613 8211 52 series series NN 19613 8211 53 of of IN 19613 8211 54 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8211 55 works work NNS 19613 8211 56 dating date VBG 19613 8211 57 as as RB 19613 8211 58 far far RB 19613 8211 59 back back RB 19613 8211 60 as as IN 19613 8211 61 the the DT 19613 8211 62 year year NN 19613 8211 63 200 200 CD 19613 8211 64 and and CC 19613 8211 65 ascribed ascribe VBN 19613 8211 66 to to IN 19613 8211 67 ecclesiastics ecclesiastic NNS 19613 8211 68 of of IN 19613 8211 69 that that DT 19613 8211 70 period period NN 19613 8211 71 . . . 19613 8212 1 Whilst whilst IN 19613 8212 2 all all PDT 19613 8212 3 these these DT 19613 8212 4 phenomena phenomenon NNS 19613 8212 5 , , , 19613 8212 6 which which WDT 19613 8212 7 collectively collectively RB 19613 8212 8 belong belong VBP 19613 8212 9 to to IN 19613 8212 10 the the DT 19613 8212 11 close close NN 19613 8212 12 of of IN 19613 8212 13 the the DT 19613 8212 14 second second JJ 19613 8212 15 and and CC 19613 8212 16 beginning beginning NN 19613 8212 17 of of IN 19613 8212 18 the the DT 19613 8212 19 third third JJ 19613 8212 20 century century NN 19613 8212 21 , , , 19613 8212 22 show show VBP 19613 8212 23 that that IN 19613 8212 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8212 25 was be VBD 19613 8212 26 indeed indeed RB 19613 8212 27 possible possible JJ 19613 8212 28 to to TO 19613 8212 29 suppress suppress VB 19613 8212 30 heresy heresy NN 19613 8212 31 in in IN 19613 8212 32 the the DT 19613 8212 33 Church Church NNP 19613 8212 34 , , , 19613 8212 35 but but CC 19613 8212 36 not not RB 19613 8212 37 the the DT 19613 8212 38 impulse impulse NN 19613 8212 39 from from IN 19613 8212 40 which which WDT 19613 8212 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8212 42 sprang spring VBD 19613 8212 43 , , , 19613 8212 44 the the DT 19613 8212 45 most most RBS 19613 8212 46 striking striking JJ 19613 8212 47 proof proof NN 19613 8212 48 of of IN 19613 8212 49 this this DT 19613 8212 50 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 8212 51 is be VBZ 19613 8212 52 the the DT 19613 8212 53 existence existence NN 19613 8212 54 of of IN 19613 8212 55 the the DT 19613 8212 56 so so RB 19613 8212 57 - - HYPH 19613 8212 58 called call VBN 19613 8212 59 school school NN 19613 8212 60 of of IN 19613 8212 61 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8212 62 in in IN 19613 8212 63 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8212 64 . . . 19613 8213 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8213 2 can can MD 19613 8213 3 not not RB 19613 8213 4 now now RB 19613 8213 5 trace trace VB 19613 8213 6 the the DT 19613 8213 7 origin origin NN 19613 8213 8 of of IN 19613 8213 9 this this DT 19613 8213 10 school school NN 19613 8213 11 , , , 19613 8213 12 which which WDT 19613 8213 13 first first RB 19613 8213 14 comes come VBZ 19613 8213 15 under under IN 19613 8213 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8213 17 notice notice NN 19613 8213 18 in in IN 19613 8213 19 the the DT 19613 8213 20 year year NN 19613 8213 21 190,[661 190,[661 CD 19613 8213 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8213 23 but but CC 19613 8213 24 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8213 25 know know VBP 19613 8213 26 that that IN 19613 8213 27 the the DT 19613 8213 28 struggle struggle NN 19613 8213 29 of of IN 19613 8213 30 the the DT 19613 8213 31 Church Church NNP 19613 8213 32 with with IN 19613 8213 33 heresy heresy NN 19613 8213 34 was be VBD 19613 8213 35 concluded conclude VBN 19613 8213 36 in in IN 19613 8213 37 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8213 38 at at IN 19613 8213 39 a a DT 19613 8213 40 later later JJ 19613 8213 41 period period NN 19613 8213 42 than than IN 19613 8213 43 in in IN 19613 8213 44 the the DT 19613 8213 45 West West NNP 19613 8213 46 . . . 19613 8214 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8214 2 know know VBP 19613 8214 3 further further RB 19613 8214 4 that that IN 19613 8214 5 the the DT 19613 8214 6 school school NN 19613 8214 7 of of IN 19613 8214 8 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8214 9 extended extend VBD 19613 8214 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8214 11 labours labour NNS 19613 8214 12 to to IN 19613 8214 13 Palestine Palestine NNP 19613 8214 14 and and CC 19613 8214 15 Cappadocia Cappadocia NNP 19613 8214 16 as as RB 19613 8214 17 early early RB 19613 8214 18 as as IN 19613 8214 19 the the DT 19613 8214 20 year year NN 19613 8214 21 200 200 CD 19613 8214 22 , , , 19613 8214 23 and and CC 19613 8214 24 , , , 19613 8214 25 to to IN 19613 8214 26 all all DT 19613 8214 27 appearance appearance NN 19613 8214 28 , , , 19613 8214 29 originated originate VBD 19613 8214 30 or or CC 19613 8214 31 encouraged encourage VBN 19613 8214 32 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8214 33 pursuits pursuit NNS 19613 8214 34 there there RB 19613 8214 35 . . . 19613 8215 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8215 2 662 662 CD 19613 8215 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8215 4 Finally finally RB 19613 8215 5 , , , 19613 8215 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8215 7 know know VBP 19613 8215 8 that that IN 19613 8215 9 the the DT 19613 8215 10 existence existence NN 19613 8215 11 of of IN 19613 8215 12 this this DT 19613 8215 13 school school NN 19613 8215 14 was be VBD 19613 8215 15 threatened threaten VBN 19613 8215 16 in in IN 19613 8215 17 the the DT 19613 8215 18 fourth fourth JJ 19613 8215 19 decade decade NN 19613 8215 20 of of IN 19613 8215 21 the the DT 19613 8215 22 third third JJ 19613 8215 23 century century NN 19613 8215 24 ; ; : 19613 8215 25 but but CC 19613 8215 26 Heraclas Heraclas NNP 19613 8215 27 was be VBD 19613 8215 28 shrewd shrewd JJ 19613 8215 29 enough enough RB 19613 8215 30 to to TO 19613 8215 31 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 8215 32 the the DT 19613 8215 33 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8215 34 and and CC 19613 8215 35 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8215 36 interests interest NNS 19613 8215 37 . . . 19613 8216 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8216 2 663 663 CD 19613 8216 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8216 4 In in IN 19613 8216 5 the the DT 19613 8216 6 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 8216 7 school school NN 19613 8216 8 of of IN 19613 8216 9 catechists catechist VBZ 19613 8216 10 the the DT 19613 8216 11 whole whole NN 19613 8216 12 of of IN 19613 8216 13 Greek greek JJ 19613 8216 14 science science NN 19613 8216 15 was be VBD 19613 8216 16 taught teach VBN 19613 8216 17 and and CC 19613 8216 18 made make VBN 19613 8216 19 to to TO 19613 8216 20 serve serve VB 19613 8216 21 the the DT 19613 8216 22 purpose purpose NN 19613 8216 23 of of IN 19613 8216 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 8216 25 apologetics apologetic NNS 19613 8216 26 . . . 19613 8217 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8217 2 first first JJ 19613 8217 3 teacher teacher NN 19613 8217 4 , , , 19613 8217 5 who who WP 19613 8217 6 is be VBZ 19613 8217 7 well well RB 19613 8217 8 known known JJ 19613 8217 9 to to IN 19613 8217 10 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8217 11 from from IN 19613 8217 12 the the DT 19613 8217 13 writings writing NNS 19613 8217 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8217 15 has have VBZ 19613 8217 16 left leave VBN 19613 8217 17 , , , 19613 8217 18 is be VBZ 19613 8217 19 _ _ NNP 19613 8217 20 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8217 21 of of IN 19613 8217 22 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8217 23 _ _ NNP 19613 8217 24 . . . 19613 8218 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8218 2 664 664 CD 19613 8218 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8218 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8218 5 main main JJ 19613 8218 6 work work NN 19613 8218 7 is be VBZ 19613 8218 8 epoch epoch NN 19613 8218 9 - - HYPH 19613 8218 10 making making NN 19613 8218 11 . . . 19613 8219 1 " " `` 19613 8219 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8219 3 's 's POS 19613 8219 4 intention intention NN 19613 8219 5 is be VBZ 19613 8219 6 nothing nothing NN 19613 8219 7 less less JJR 19613 8219 8 than than IN 19613 8219 9 an an DT 19613 8219 10 introduction introduction NN 19613 8219 11 to to IN 19613 8219 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8219 13 , , , 19613 8219 14 or or CC 19613 8219 15 , , , 19613 8219 16 speaking speak VBG 19613 8219 17 more more RBR 19613 8219 18 correctly correctly RB 19613 8219 19 and and CC 19613 8219 20 in in IN 19613 8219 21 accordance accordance NN 19613 8219 22 with with IN 19613 8219 23 the the DT 19613 8219 24 spirit spirit NN 19613 8219 25 of of IN 19613 8219 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8219 27 work work NN 19613 8219 28 , , , 19613 8219 29 an an DT 19613 8219 30 initiation initiation NN 19613 8219 31 into into IN 19613 8219 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8219 33 . . . 19613 8220 1 The the DT 19613 8220 2 task task NN 19613 8220 3 that that WDT 19613 8220 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8220 5 sets set VBZ 19613 8220 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8220 7 is be VBZ 19613 8220 8 an an DT 19613 8220 9 introduction introduction NN 19613 8220 10 to to IN 19613 8220 11 what what WP 19613 8220 12 is be VBZ 19613 8220 13 inmost inmost JJ 19613 8220 14 and and CC 19613 8220 15 highest high JJS 19613 8220 16 in in IN 19613 8220 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8220 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8220 19 . . . 19613 8221 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8221 2 aims aim VBZ 19613 8221 3 , , , 19613 8221 4 so so RB 19613 8221 5 to to TO 19613 8221 6 speak speak VB 19613 8221 7 , , , 19613 8221 8 at at IN 19613 8221 9 first first RB 19613 8221 10 making make VBG 19613 8221 11 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8221 12 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8221 13 Christians christian NNS 19613 8221 14 by by IN 19613 8221 15 means mean NNS 19613 8221 16 of of IN 19613 8221 17 a a DT 19613 8221 18 work work NN 19613 8221 19 of of IN 19613 8221 20 literature literature NN 19613 8221 21 . . . 19613 8222 1 By by IN 19613 8222 2 means mean NNS 19613 8222 3 of of IN 19613 8222 4 such such PDT 19613 8222 5 a a DT 19613 8222 6 work work NN 19613 8222 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8222 8 wished wish VBD 19613 8222 9 not not RB 19613 8222 10 merely merely RB 19613 8222 11 to to TO 19613 8222 12 repeat repeat VB 19613 8222 13 to to IN 19613 8222 14 the the DT 19613 8222 15 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8222 16 what what WP 19613 8222 17 life life NN 19613 8222 18 has have VBZ 19613 8222 19 already already RB 19613 8222 20 done do VBN 19613 8222 21 for for IN 19613 8222 22 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8222 23 as as IN 19613 8222 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8222 25 is be VBZ 19613 8222 26 , , , 19613 8222 27 but but CC 19613 8222 28 to to TO 19613 8222 29 elevate elevate VB 19613 8222 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8222 31 to to IN 19613 8222 32 something something NN 19613 8222 33 still still RB 19613 8222 34 higher high JJR 19613 8222 35 than than IN 19613 8222 36 what what WP 19613 8222 37 has have VBZ 19613 8222 38 been be VBN 19613 8222 39 revealed reveal VBN 19613 8222 40 to to IN 19613 8222 41 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8222 42 by by IN 19613 8222 43 the the DT 19613 8222 44 forms form NNS 19613 8222 45 of of IN 19613 8222 46 initiation initiation NN 19613 8222 47 that that IN 19613 8222 48 the the DT 19613 8222 49 Church Church NNP 19613 8222 50 has have VBZ 19613 8222 51 created create VBN 19613 8222 52 for for IN 19613 8222 53 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 8222 54 in in IN 19613 8222 55 the the DT 19613 8222 56 course course NN 19613 8222 57 of of IN 19613 8222 58 a a DT 19613 8222 59 history history NN 19613 8222 60 already already RB 19613 8222 61 dating date VBG 19613 8222 62 back back RB 19613 8222 63 a a DT 19613 8222 64 century century NN 19613 8222 65 and and CC 19613 8222 66 a a DT 19613 8222 67 half half NN 19613 8222 68 . . . 19613 8222 69 " " '' 19613 8223 1 To to IN 19613 8223 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8223 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 8223 4 Gnosis gnosis NN 19613 8223 5 , , , 19613 8223 6 that that RB 19613 8223 7 is is RB 19613 8223 8 , , , 19613 8223 9 the the DT 19613 8223 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8223 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 8223 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8223 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8223 14 of of IN 19613 8223 15 religion religion NN 19613 8223 16 , , , 19613 8223 17 is be VBZ 19613 8223 18 not not RB 19613 8223 19 only only RB 19613 8223 20 a a DT 19613 8223 21 means means NN 19613 8223 22 of of IN 19613 8223 23 refuting refute VBG 19613 8223 24 heathenism heathenism NN 19613 8223 25 and and CC 19613 8223 26 heresy heresy NN 19613 8223 27 , , , 19613 8223 28 but but CC 19613 8223 29 at at IN 19613 8223 30 the the DT 19613 8223 31 same same JJ 19613 8223 32 time time NN 19613 8223 33 of of IN 19613 8223 34 ascertaining ascertaining NN 19613 8223 35 and and CC 19613 8223 36 setting set VBG 19613 8223 37 forth forth RP 19613 8223 38 what what WP 19613 8223 39 is be VBZ 19613 8223 40 highest high JJS 19613 8223 41 and and CC 19613 8223 42 inmost inmost JJ 19613 8223 43 in in IN 19613 8223 44 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8223 45 . . . 19613 8224 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 2 views view VBZ 19613 8224 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 4 as as IN 19613 8224 5 such such JJ 19613 8224 6 , , , 19613 8224 7 however however RB 19613 8224 8 , , , 19613 8224 9 because because IN 19613 8224 10 , , , 19613 8224 11 apart apart RB 19613 8224 12 from from IN 19613 8224 13 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 8224 14 sayings saying NNS 19613 8224 15 , , , 19613 8224 16 the the DT 19613 8224 17 Church Church NNP 19613 8224 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 8224 19 , , , 19613 8224 20 both both CC 19613 8224 21 collectively collectively RB 19613 8224 22 and and CC 19613 8224 23 in in IN 19613 8224 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8224 25 details detail NNS 19613 8224 26 , , , 19613 8224 27 is be VBZ 19613 8224 28 something something NN 19613 8224 29 foreign foreign JJ 19613 8224 30 to to IN 19613 8224 31 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 32 ; ; : 19613 8224 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 34 has have VBZ 19613 8224 35 subjected subject VBN 19613 8224 36 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 37 to to IN 19613 8224 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8224 39 authority authority NN 19613 8224 40 , , , 19613 8224 41 but but CC 19613 8224 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 43 can can MD 19613 8224 44 only only RB 19613 8224 45 make make VB 19613 8224 46 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 47 intellectually intellectually RB 19613 8224 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8224 49 own own JJ 19613 8224 50 after after IN 19613 8224 51 subjecting subject VBG 19613 8224 52 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8224 53 to to IN 19613 8224 54 a a DT 19613 8224 55 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8224 56 and and CC 19613 8224 57 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8224 58 treatment treatment NN 19613 8224 59 . . . 19613 8225 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8225 2 665 665 CD 19613 8225 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8225 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8225 5 great great JJ 19613 8225 6 work work NN 19613 8225 7 , , , 19613 8225 8 which which WDT 19613 8225 9 has have VBZ 19613 8225 10 rightly rightly RB 19613 8225 11 been be VBN 19613 8225 12 called call VBN 19613 8225 13 the the DT 19613 8225 14 boldest bold JJS 19613 8225 15 literary literary JJ 19613 8225 16 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 8225 17 in in IN 19613 8225 18 the the DT 19613 8225 19 history history NN 19613 8225 20 of of IN 19613 8225 21 the the DT 19613 8225 22 Church,[666 church,[666 NN 19613 8225 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8225 24 is be VBZ 19613 8225 25 consequently consequently RB 19613 8225 26 the the DT 19613 8225 27 first first JJ 19613 8225 28 attempt attempt NN 19613 8225 29 to to TO 19613 8225 30 use use VB 19613 8225 31 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8225 32 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 8225 33 and and CC 19613 8225 34 the the DT 19613 8225 35 Church Church NNP 19613 8225 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 8225 37 together together RB 19613 8225 38 with with IN 19613 8225 39 the the DT 19613 8225 40 assumption assumption NN 19613 8225 41 that that IN 19613 8225 42 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8225 43 as as IN 19613 8225 44 the the DT 19613 8225 45 Reason reason NN 19613 8225 46 of of IN 19613 8225 47 the the DT 19613 8225 48 world world NN 19613 8225 49 is be VBZ 19613 8225 50 the the DT 19613 8225 51 source source NN 19613 8225 52 of of IN 19613 8225 53 all all DT 19613 8225 54 truth truth NN 19613 8225 55 , , , 19613 8225 56 as as IN 19613 8225 57 the the DT 19613 8225 58 basis basis NN 19613 8225 59 of of IN 19613 8225 60 a a DT 19613 8225 61 presentation presentation NN 19613 8225 62 of of IN 19613 8225 63 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8225 64 which which WDT 19613 8225 65 at at IN 19613 8225 66 once once RB 19613 8225 67 addresses address VBZ 19613 8225 68 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8225 69 to to IN 19613 8225 70 the the DT 19613 8225 71 cultured cultured JJ 19613 8225 72 by by IN 19613 8225 73 satisfying satisfy VBG 19613 8225 74 the the DT 19613 8225 75 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8225 76 demand demand NN 19613 8225 77 for for IN 19613 8225 78 a a DT 19613 8225 79 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8225 80 ethic ethic NN 19613 8225 81 and and CC 19613 8225 82 theory theory NN 19613 8225 83 of of IN 19613 8225 84 the the DT 19613 8225 85 world world NN 19613 8225 86 , , , 19613 8225 87 and and CC 19613 8225 88 at at IN 19613 8225 89 the the DT 19613 8225 90 same same JJ 19613 8225 91 time time NN 19613 8225 92 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 8225 93 to to IN 19613 8225 94 the the DT 19613 8225 95 believer believer NN 19613 8225 96 the the DT 19613 8225 97 rich rich JJ 19613 8225 98 content content NN 19613 8225 99 of of IN 19613 8225 100 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8225 101 faith faith NN 19613 8225 102 . . . 19613 8226 1 Here here RB 19613 8226 2 then then RB 19613 8226 3 is be VBZ 19613 8226 4 found find VBN 19613 8226 5 , , , 19613 8226 6 in in IN 19613 8226 7 form form NN 19613 8226 8 and and CC 19613 8226 9 content content NN 19613 8226 10 , , , 19613 8226 11 the the DT 19613 8226 12 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8226 13 Christian christian JJ 19613 8226 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8226 15 of of IN 19613 8226 16 religion religion NN 19613 8226 17 which which WDT 19613 8226 18 , , , 19613 8226 19 while while IN 19613 8226 20 not not RB 19613 8226 21 contradicting contradict VBG 19613 8226 22 the the DT 19613 8226 23 faith faith NN 19613 8226 24 , , , 19613 8226 25 does do VBZ 19613 8226 26 not not RB 19613 8226 27 merely merely RB 19613 8226 28 support support VB 19613 8226 29 or or CC 19613 8226 30 explain explain VB 19613 8226 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8226 32 in in IN 19613 8226 33 a a DT 19613 8226 34 few few JJ 19613 8226 35 places place NNS 19613 8226 36 , , , 19613 8226 37 but but CC 19613 8226 38 raises raise VBZ 19613 8226 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8226 40 to to IN 19613 8226 41 another another DT 19613 8226 42 and and CC 19613 8226 43 higher high JJR 19613 8226 44 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 8226 45 sphere sphere NN 19613 8226 46 , , , 19613 8226 47 namely namely RB 19613 8226 48 , , , 19613 8226 49 out out IN 19613 8226 50 of of IN 19613 8226 51 the the DT 19613 8226 52 province province NN 19613 8226 53 of of IN 19613 8226 54 authority authority NN 19613 8226 55 and and CC 19613 8226 56 obedience obedience NN 19613 8226 57 into into IN 19613 8226 58 that that DT 19613 8226 59 of of IN 19613 8226 60 clear clear JJ 19613 8226 61 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8226 62 and and CC 19613 8226 63 inward inward RB 19613 8226 64 , , , 19613 8226 65 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 8226 66 assent assent NN 19613 8226 67 emanating emanate VBG 19613 8226 68 from from IN 19613 8226 69 love love NN 19613 8226 70 to to IN 19613 8226 71 God God NNP 19613 8226 72 . . . 19613 8227 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8227 2 667 667 CD 19613 8227 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8227 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8227 5 can can MD 19613 8227 6 not not RB 19613 8227 7 imagine imagine VB 19613 8227 8 that that IN 19613 8227 9 the the DT 19613 8227 10 Christian christian JJ 19613 8227 11 faith faith NN 19613 8227 12 , , , 19613 8227 13 as as IN 19613 8227 14 found find VBN 19613 8227 15 in in IN 19613 8227 16 tradition tradition NN 19613 8227 17 , , , 19613 8227 18 can can MD 19613 8227 19 of of IN 19613 8227 20 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8227 21 produce produce VB 19613 8227 22 the the DT 19613 8227 23 union union NN 19613 8227 24 of of IN 19613 8227 25 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 8227 26 independence independence NN 19613 8227 27 and and CC 19613 8227 28 devotion devotion NN 19613 8227 29 to to IN 19613 8227 30 God God NNP 19613 8227 31 which which WDT 19613 8227 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8227 33 regards regard VBZ 19613 8227 34 as as IN 19613 8227 35 moral moral JJ 19613 8227 36 perfection perfection NN 19613 8227 37 . . . 19613 8228 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8228 2 is be VBZ 19613 8228 3 too too RB 19613 8228 4 much much JJ 19613 8228 5 of of IN 19613 8228 6 a a DT 19613 8228 7 Greek greek JJ 19613 8228 8 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 8228 9 for for IN 19613 8228 10 that that DT 19613 8228 11 , , , 19613 8228 12 and and CC 19613 8228 13 believes believe VBZ 19613 8228 14 that that IN 19613 8228 15 this this DT 19613 8228 16 aim aim NN 19613 8228 17 is be VBZ 19613 8228 18 only only RB 19613 8228 19 reached reach VBN 19613 8228 20 through through IN 19613 8228 21 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8228 22 . . . 19613 8229 1 But but CC 19613 8229 2 in in IN 19613 8229 3 so so RB 19613 8229 4 far far RB 19613 8229 5 as as IN 19613 8229 6 this this DT 19613 8229 7 is be VBZ 19613 8229 8 only only RB 19613 8229 9 the the DT 19613 8229 10 deciphering deciphering NN 19613 8229 11 of of IN 19613 8229 12 the the DT 19613 8229 13 secrets secret NNS 19613 8229 14 revealed reveal VBN 19613 8229 15 in in IN 19613 8229 16 the the DT 19613 8229 17 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8229 18 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8229 19 through through IN 19613 8229 20 the the DT 19613 8229 21 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8229 22 , , , 19613 8229 23 secrets secret NNS 19613 8229 24 which which WDT 19613 8229 25 the the DT 19613 8229 26 believer believer NN 19613 8229 27 also also RB 19613 8229 28 gains gain VBZ 19613 8229 29 possession possession NN 19613 8229 30 of of IN 19613 8229 31 by by IN 19613 8229 32 subjecting subject VBG 19613 8229 33 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8229 34 to to IN 19613 8229 35 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8229 36 , , , 19613 8229 37 all all DT 19613 8229 38 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8229 39 is be VBZ 19613 8229 40 a a DT 19613 8229 41 reflection reflection NN 19613 8229 42 of of IN 19613 8229 43 the the DT 19613 8229 44 divine divine JJ 19613 8229 45 revelation revelation NN 19613 8229 46 . . . 19613 8230 1 The the DT 19613 8230 2 lofty lofty JJ 19613 8230 3 ethical ethical JJ 19613 8230 4 and and CC 19613 8230 5 religious religious JJ 19613 8230 6 ideal ideal NN 19613 8230 7 of of IN 19613 8230 8 the the DT 19613 8230 9 man man NN 19613 8230 10 made make VBN 19613 8230 11 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8230 12 in in IN 19613 8230 13 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 8230 14 with with IN 19613 8230 15 God God NNP 19613 8230 16 , , , 19613 8230 17 which which WDT 19613 8230 18 Greek greek JJ 19613 8230 19 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8230 20 had have VBD 19613 8230 21 developed develop VBN 19613 8230 22 since since IN 19613 8230 23 the the DT 19613 8230 24 time time NN 19613 8230 25 of of IN 19613 8230 26 Plato Plato NNP 19613 8230 27 and and CC 19613 8230 28 to to TO 19613 8230 29 which which WDT 19613 8230 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8230 31 had have VBD 19613 8230 32 subordinated subordinate VBN 19613 8230 33 the the DT 19613 8230 34 whole whole JJ 19613 8230 35 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8230 36 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8230 37 of of IN 19613 8230 38 the the DT 19613 8230 39 world world NN 19613 8230 40 , , , 19613 8230 41 was be VBD 19613 8230 42 adopted adopt VBN 19613 8230 43 and and CC 19613 8230 44 heightened heighten VBN 19613 8230 45 by by IN 19613 8230 46 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8230 47 , , , 19613 8230 48 and and CC 19613 8230 49 associated associate VBD 19613 8230 50 not not RB 19613 8230 51 only only RB 19613 8230 52 with with IN 19613 8230 53 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8230 54 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8230 55 but but CC 19613 8230 56 also also RB 19613 8230 57 with with IN 19613 8230 58 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8230 59 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8230 60 . . . 19613 8231 1 But but CC 19613 8231 2 , , , 19613 8231 3 whilst whilst IN 19613 8231 4 connecting connect VBG 19613 8231 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8231 6 with with IN 19613 8231 7 the the DT 19613 8231 8 Church Church NNP 19613 8231 9 tradition tradition NN 19613 8231 10 , , , 19613 8231 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8231 12 did do VBD 19613 8231 13 not not RB 19613 8231 14 shrink shrink VB 19613 8231 15 from from IN 19613 8231 16 the the DT 19613 8231 17 boldest bold JJS 19613 8231 18 remodelling remodelling NN 19613 8231 19 of of IN 19613 8231 20 the the DT 19613 8231 21 latter latter JJ 19613 8231 22 , , , 19613 8231 23 because because IN 19613 8231 24 the the DT 19613 8231 25 preservation preservation NN 19613 8231 26 of of IN 19613 8231 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8231 28 wording wording NN 19613 8231 29 was be VBD 19613 8231 30 to to IN 19613 8231 31 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8231 32 a a DT 19613 8231 33 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8231 34 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 8231 35 of of IN 19613 8231 36 the the DT 19613 8231 37 Christian christian JJ 19613 8231 38 character character NN 19613 8231 39 of of IN 19613 8231 40 the the DT 19613 8231 41 speculation speculation NN 19613 8231 42 . . . 19613 8232 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8232 2 668 668 CD 19613 8232 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8232 4 In in IN 19613 8232 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8232 6 , , , 19613 8232 7 then then RB 19613 8232 8 , , , 19613 8232 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8232 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8232 11 reached reach VBD 19613 8232 12 the the DT 19613 8232 13 stage stage NN 19613 8232 14 that that WDT 19613 8232 15 Judaism Judaism NNP 19613 8232 16 had have VBD 19613 8232 17 attained attain VBN 19613 8232 18 in in IN 19613 8232 19 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8232 20 , , , 19613 8232 21 and and CC 19613 8232 22 no no RB 19613 8232 23 doubt doubt RB 19613 8232 24 the the DT 19613 8232 25 latter latter JJ 19613 8232 26 exercised exercise VBN 19613 8232 27 great great JJ 19613 8232 28 influence influence NN 19613 8232 29 over over IN 19613 8232 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8232 31 . . . 19613 8233 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8233 2 669 669 CD 19613 8233 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8233 4 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8233 5 , , , 19613 8233 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8233 7 stands stand VBZ 19613 8233 8 on on IN 19613 8233 9 the the DT 19613 8233 10 ground ground NN 19613 8233 11 that that IN 19613 8233 12 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8233 13 had have VBD 19613 8233 14 already already RB 19613 8233 15 trodden tread VBN 19613 8233 16 , , , 19613 8233 17 but but CC 19613 8233 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8233 19 has have VBZ 19613 8233 20 advanced advance VBN 19613 8233 21 far far RB 19613 8233 22 beyond beyond IN 19613 8233 23 this this DT 19613 8233 24 Apologist Apologist NNP 19613 8233 25 . . . 19613 8234 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8234 2 superiority superiority NN 19613 8234 3 to to IN 19613 8234 4 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8234 5 not not RB 19613 8234 6 only only RB 19613 8234 7 consists consist VBZ 19613 8234 8 in in IN 19613 8234 9 the the DT 19613 8234 10 fact fact NN 19613 8234 11 that that IN 19613 8234 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8234 13 changed change VBD 19613 8234 14 the the DT 19613 8234 15 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 8234 16 task task NN 19613 8234 17 that that WDT 19613 8234 18 the the DT 19613 8234 19 latter latter JJ 19613 8234 20 had have VBD 19613 8234 21 in in IN 19613 8234 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8234 23 mind mind NN 19613 8234 24 into into IN 19613 8234 25 a a DT 19613 8234 26 systematic systematic JJ 19613 8234 27 and and CC 19613 8234 28 positive positive JJ 19613 8234 29 one one CD 19613 8234 30 ; ; : 19613 8234 31 but but CC 19613 8234 32 above above IN 19613 8234 33 all all DT 19613 8234 34 in in IN 19613 8234 35 the the DT 19613 8234 36 circumstance circumstance NN 19613 8234 37 that that WDT 19613 8234 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8234 39 transformed transform VBD 19613 8234 40 the the DT 19613 8234 41 tradition tradition NN 19613 8234 42 of of IN 19613 8234 43 the the DT 19613 8234 44 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8234 45 Church Church NNP 19613 8234 46 , , , 19613 8234 47 which which WDT 19613 8234 48 in in IN 19613 8234 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8234 50 days day NNS 19613 8234 51 was be VBD 19613 8234 52 far far RB 19613 8234 53 more more RBR 19613 8234 54 extensive extensive JJ 19613 8234 55 and and CC 19613 8234 56 more more RBR 19613 8234 57 firmly firmly RB 19613 8234 58 established establish VBN 19613 8234 59 than than IN 19613 8234 60 in in IN 19613 8234 61 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8234 62 's 's POS 19613 8234 63 time time NN 19613 8234 64 , , , 19613 8234 65 into into IN 19613 8234 66 a a DT 19613 8234 67 real real RB 19613 8234 68 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8234 69 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8234 70 ; ; : 19613 8234 71 whereas whereas IN 19613 8234 72 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8234 73 neutralised neutralise VBD 19613 8234 74 the the DT 19613 8234 75 greater great JJR 19613 8234 76 part part NN 19613 8234 77 of of IN 19613 8234 78 this this DT 19613 8234 79 tradition tradition NN 19613 8234 80 by by IN 19613 8234 81 including include VBG 19613 8234 82 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8234 83 in in IN 19613 8234 84 the the DT 19613 8234 85 scheme scheme NN 19613 8234 86 of of IN 19613 8234 87 the the DT 19613 8234 88 proof proof NN 19613 8234 89 from from IN 19613 8234 90 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 8234 91 . . . 19613 8235 1 By by IN 19613 8235 2 elevating elevate VBG 19613 8235 3 the the DT 19613 8235 4 idea idea NN 19613 8235 5 of of IN 19613 8235 6 the the DT 19613 8235 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8235 8 who who WP 19613 8235 9 is be VBZ 19613 8235 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8235 11 into into IN 19613 8235 12 the the DT 19613 8235 13 highest high JJS 19613 8235 14 principle principle NN 19613 8235 15 in in IN 19613 8235 16 the the DT 19613 8235 17 religious religious JJ 19613 8235 18 explanation explanation NN 19613 8235 19 of of IN 19613 8235 20 the the DT 19613 8235 21 world world NN 19613 8235 22 and and CC 19613 8235 23 in in IN 19613 8235 24 the the DT 19613 8235 25 exposition exposition NN 19613 8235 26 of of IN 19613 8235 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8235 28 , , , 19613 8235 29 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8235 30 gave give VBD 19613 8235 31 to to IN 19613 8235 32 this this DT 19613 8235 33 idea idea NN 19613 8235 34 a a DT 19613 8235 35 much much RB 19613 8235 36 more more JJR 19613 8235 37 concrete concrete JJ 19613 8235 38 and and CC 19613 8235 39 copious copious JJ 19613 8235 40 content content NN 19613 8235 41 than than IN 19613 8235 42 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8235 43 did do VBD 19613 8235 44 . . . 19613 8236 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8236 2 is be VBZ 19613 8236 3 the the DT 19613 8236 4 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8236 5 of of IN 19613 8236 6 the the DT 19613 8236 7 creation creation NN 19613 8236 8 , , , 19613 8236 9 training training NN 19613 8236 10 , , , 19613 8236 11 and and CC 19613 8236 12 redemption redemption NN 19613 8236 13 of of IN 19613 8236 14 mankind mankind NN 19613 8236 15 by by IN 19613 8236 16 the the DT 19613 8236 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8236 18 , , , 19613 8236 19 whose whose WP$ 19613 8236 20 work work NN 19613 8236 21 culminates culminate VBZ 19613 8236 22 in in IN 19613 8236 23 the the DT 19613 8236 24 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8236 25 Gnostics gnostic NNS 19613 8236 26 . . . 19613 8237 1 The the DT 19613 8237 2 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8237 3 of of IN 19613 8237 4 the the DT 19613 8237 5 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 8237 6 , , , 19613 8237 7 in in IN 19613 8237 8 so so RB 19613 8237 9 far far RB 19613 8237 10 as as IN 19613 8237 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8237 12 possessed possess VBD 19613 8237 13 the the DT 19613 8237 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8237 15 , , , 19613 8237 16 is be VBZ 19613 8237 17 declared declare VBN 19613 8237 18 to to TO 19613 8237 19 be be VB 19613 8237 20 a a DT 19613 8237 21 counterpart counterpart NN 19613 8237 22 of of IN 19613 8237 23 the the DT 19613 8237 24 Old Old NNP 19613 8237 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8237 26 law;[670 law;[670 NNPS 19613 8237 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8237 28 and and CC 19613 8237 29 the the DT 19613 8237 30 facts fact NNS 19613 8237 31 contained contain VBN 19613 8237 32 in in IN 19613 8237 33 the the DT 19613 8237 34 Church Church NNP 19613 8237 35 tradition tradition NN 19613 8237 36 are be VBP 19613 8237 37 either either RB 19613 8237 38 subordinated subordinate VBN 19613 8237 39 to to IN 19613 8237 40 the the DT 19613 8237 41 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8237 42 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8237 43 or or CC 19613 8237 44 receive receive VBP 19613 8237 45 a a DT 19613 8237 46 new new JJ 19613 8237 47 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 8237 48 expressly expressly RB 19613 8237 49 suited suit VBN 19613 8237 50 to to IN 19613 8237 51 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8237 52 . . . 19613 8238 1 The the DT 19613 8238 2 idea idea NN 19613 8238 3 of of IN 19613 8238 4 the the DT 19613 8238 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8238 6 has have VBZ 19613 8238 7 a a DT 19613 8238 8 content content NN 19613 8238 9 which which WDT 19613 8238 10 is be VBZ 19613 8238 11 on on IN 19613 8238 12 the the DT 19613 8238 13 one one CD 19613 8238 14 hand hand NN 19613 8238 15 so so RB 19613 8238 16 wide wide RB 19613 8238 17 that that IN 19613 8238 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8238 19 is be VBZ 19613 8238 20 found find VBN 19613 8238 21 wherever wherever WRB 19613 8238 22 man man NN 19613 8238 23 rises rise VBZ 19613 8238 24 above above IN 19613 8238 25 the the DT 19613 8238 26 level level NN 19613 8238 27 of of IN 19613 8238 28 nature nature NN 19613 8238 29 , , , 19613 8238 30 and and CC 19613 8238 31 on on IN 19613 8238 32 the the DT 19613 8238 33 other other JJ 19613 8238 34 so so RB 19613 8238 35 concrete concrete JJ 19613 8238 36 that that IN 19613 8238 37 an an DT 19613 8238 38 authentic authentic JJ 19613 8238 39 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8238 40 of of IN 19613 8238 41 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8238 42 can can MD 19613 8238 43 only only RB 19613 8238 44 be be VB 19613 8238 45 obtained obtain VBN 19613 8238 46 from from IN 19613 8238 47 historical historical JJ 19613 8238 48 revelation revelation NN 19613 8238 49 . . . 19613 8239 1 The the DT 19613 8239 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8239 3 is be VBZ 19613 8239 4 essentially essentially RB 19613 8239 5 the the DT 19613 8239 6 rational rational JJ 19613 8239 7 law law NN 19613 8239 8 of of IN 19613 8239 9 the the DT 19613 8239 10 world world NN 19613 8239 11 and and CC 19613 8239 12 the the DT 19613 8239 13 teacher teacher NN 19613 8239 14 ; ; : 19613 8239 15 but but CC 19613 8239 16 in in IN 19613 8239 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8239 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8239 19 is be VBZ 19613 8239 20 at at IN 19613 8239 21 the the DT 19613 8239 22 same same JJ 19613 8239 23 time time NN 19613 8239 24 officiating officiate VBG 19613 8239 25 priest priest NN 19613 8239 26 , , , 19613 8239 27 and and CC 19613 8239 28 the the DT 19613 8239 29 blessings blessing NNS 19613 8239 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8239 31 bestows bestow VBZ 19613 8239 32 are be VBP 19613 8239 33 a a DT 19613 8239 34 series series NN 19613 8239 35 of of IN 19613 8239 36 holy holy JJ 19613 8239 37 initiations initiation NNS 19613 8239 38 which which WDT 19613 8239 39 alone alone RB 19613 8239 40 contain contain VBP 19613 8239 41 the the DT 19613 8239 42 possibility possibility NN 19613 8239 43 of of IN 19613 8239 44 man man NN 19613 8239 45 's 's POS 19613 8239 46 raising raise VBG 19613 8239 47 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8239 48 to to IN 19613 8239 49 the the DT 19613 8239 50 divine divine JJ 19613 8239 51 life life NN 19613 8239 52 . . . 19613 8240 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8240 2 671 671 CD 19613 8240 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8240 4 While while IN 19613 8240 5 this this DT 19613 8240 6 is be VBZ 19613 8240 7 already already RB 19613 8240 8 clear clear JJ 19613 8240 9 evidence evidence NN 19613 8240 10 of of IN 19613 8240 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8240 12 's 's POS 19613 8240 13 affinity affinity NN 19613 8240 14 to to IN 19613 8240 15 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8240 16 teachers teacher NNS 19613 8240 17 , , , 19613 8240 18 especially especially RB 19613 8240 19 the the DT 19613 8240 20 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 8240 21 , , , 19613 8240 22 the the DT 19613 8240 23 same same JJ 19613 8240 24 similarity similarity NN 19613 8240 25 may may MD 19613 8240 26 also also RB 19613 8240 27 be be VB 19613 8240 28 traced trace VBN 19613 8240 29 in in IN 19613 8240 30 the the DT 19613 8240 31 whole whole JJ 19613 8240 32 conception conception NN 19613 8240 33 of of IN 19613 8240 34 the the DT 19613 8240 35 task task NN 19613 8240 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8240 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8240 38 as as IN 19613 8240 39 theology theology NN 19613 8240 40 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8240 41 , , , 19613 8240 42 in in IN 19613 8240 43 the the DT 19613 8240 44 determination determination NN 19613 8240 45 of of IN 19613 8240 46 the the DT 19613 8240 47 formal formal JJ 19613 8240 48 principle principle NN 19613 8240 49 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8240 50 inclusive inclusive JJ 19613 8240 51 of of IN 19613 8240 52 the the DT 19613 8240 53 recourse recourse NN 19613 8240 54 to to IN 19613 8240 55 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 8240 56 tradition tradition NN 19613 8240 57 ; ; : 19613 8240 58 see see VB 19613 8240 59 above above RB 19613 8240 60 , , , 19613 8240 61 p. p. NN 19613 8240 62 35 35 CD 19613 8240 63 f.),[672 f.),[672 NNP 19613 8240 64 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8240 65 and and CC 19613 8240 66 in in IN 19613 8240 67 the the DT 19613 8240 68 solution solution NN 19613 8240 69 of of IN 19613 8240 70 the the DT 19613 8240 71 problems problem NNS 19613 8240 72 . . . 19613 8241 1 But but CC 19613 8241 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8241 3 's 's POS 19613 8241 4 great great JJ 19613 8241 5 superiority superiority NN 19613 8241 6 to to IN 19613 8241 7 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8241 8 is be VBZ 19613 8241 9 shown show VBN 19613 8241 10 not not RB 19613 8241 11 only only RB 19613 8241 12 in in IN 19613 8241 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8241 14 contriving contriving NN 19613 8241 15 to to TO 19613 8241 16 preserve preserve VB 19613 8241 17 in in IN 19613 8241 18 all all DT 19613 8241 19 points point NNS 19613 8241 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8241 21 connection connection NN 19613 8241 22 with with IN 19613 8241 23 the the DT 19613 8241 24 faith faith NN 19613 8241 25 of of IN 19613 8241 26 the the DT 19613 8241 27 main main JJ 19613 8241 28 body body NN 19613 8241 29 of of IN 19613 8241 30 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 8241 31 , , , 19613 8241 32 but but CC 19613 8241 33 still still RB 19613 8241 34 more more JJR 19613 8241 35 in in IN 19613 8241 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8241 37 power power NN 19613 8241 38 of of IN 19613 8241 39 mastering master VBG 19613 8241 40 so so RB 19613 8241 41 many many JJ 19613 8241 42 problems problem NNS 19613 8241 43 by by IN 19613 8241 44 the the DT 19613 8241 45 aid aid NN 19613 8241 46 of of IN 19613 8241 47 a a DT 19613 8241 48 single single JJ 19613 8241 49 principle principle NN 19613 8241 50 , , , 19613 8241 51 that that RB 19613 8241 52 is is RB 19613 8241 53 , , , 19613 8241 54 in in IN 19613 8241 55 the the DT 19613 8241 56 art art NN 19613 8241 57 of of IN 19613 8241 58 giving give VBG 19613 8241 59 the the DT 19613 8241 60 most most RBS 19613 8241 61 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 8241 62 presentation presentation NN 19613 8241 63 with with IN 19613 8241 64 the the DT 19613 8241 65 most most RBS 19613 8241 66 insignificant insignificant JJ 19613 8241 67 means mean NNS 19613 8241 68 . . . 19613 8242 1 Both both DT 19613 8242 2 facts fact NNS 19613 8242 3 are be VBP 19613 8242 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 8242 5 most most RBS 19613 8242 6 closely closely RB 19613 8242 7 connected connected JJ 19613 8242 8 . . . 19613 8243 1 The the DT 19613 8243 2 rejection rejection NN 19613 8243 3 of of IN 19613 8243 4 all all DT 19613 8243 5 conceptions conception NNS 19613 8243 6 that that WDT 19613 8243 7 could could MD 19613 8243 8 not not RB 19613 8243 9 be be VB 19613 8243 10 verified verify VBN 19613 8243 11 from from IN 19613 8243 12 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8243 13 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 8243 14 , , , 19613 8243 15 or or CC 19613 8243 16 at at IN 19613 8243 17 least least JJS 19613 8243 18 easily easily RB 19613 8243 19 reconciled reconcile VBN 19613 8243 20 with with IN 19613 8243 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8243 22 , , , 19613 8243 23 as as RB 19613 8243 24 well well RB 19613 8243 25 as as IN 19613 8243 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8243 27 optimism optimism NN 19613 8243 28 , , , 19613 8243 29 opposed oppose VBD 19613 8243 30 as as IN 19613 8243 31 this this DT 19613 8243 32 was be VBD 19613 8243 33 to to IN 19613 8243 34 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8243 35 pessimism pessimism NN 19613 8243 36 , , , 19613 8243 37 proved prove VBD 19613 8243 38 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 8243 39 the the DT 19613 8243 40 most most RBS 19613 8243 41 effective effective JJ 19613 8243 42 means mean NNS 19613 8243 43 of of IN 19613 8243 44 persuading persuade VBG 19613 8243 45 the the DT 19613 8243 46 Church Church NNP 19613 8243 47 to to TO 19613 8243 48 recognise recognise VB 19613 8243 49 the the DT 19613 8243 50 Christian christian JJ 19613 8243 51 character character NN 19613 8243 52 of of IN 19613 8243 53 a a DT 19613 8243 54 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8243 55 that that WDT 19613 8243 56 was be VBD 19613 8243 57 at at RB 19613 8243 58 least least RBS 19613 8243 59 half half RB 19613 8243 60 inimical inimical JJ 19613 8243 61 to to IN 19613 8243 62 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8243 63 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8243 64 . . . 19613 8244 1 Through through IN 19613 8244 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8244 3 theology theology NN 19613 8244 4 became become VBD 19613 8244 5 the the DT 19613 8244 6 crowning crowning JJ 19613 8244 7 stage stage NN 19613 8244 8 of of IN 19613 8244 9 piety piety NN 19613 8244 10 , , , 19613 8244 11 the the DT 19613 8244 12 highest high JJS 19613 8244 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8244 14 of of IN 19613 8244 15 the the DT 19613 8244 16 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 8244 17 was be VBD 19613 8244 18 placed place VBN 19613 8244 19 under under IN 19613 8244 20 the the DT 19613 8244 21 protection protection NN 19613 8244 22 and and CC 19613 8244 23 guarantee guarantee NN 19613 8244 24 of of IN 19613 8244 25 the the DT 19613 8244 26 Church Church NNP 19613 8244 27 , , , 19613 8244 28 and and CC 19613 8244 29 the the DT 19613 8244 30 whole whole JJ 19613 8244 31 Hellenic hellenic JJ 19613 8244 32 civilisation civilisation NN 19613 8244 33 was be VBD 19613 8244 34 thus thus RB 19613 8244 35 at at IN 19613 8244 36 the the DT 19613 8244 37 same same JJ 19613 8244 38 time time NN 19613 8244 39 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 8244 40 within within IN 19613 8244 41 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8244 42 . . . 19613 8245 1 The the DT 19613 8245 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8245 3 is be VBZ 19613 8245 4 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8245 5 , , , 19613 8245 6 but but CC 19613 8245 7 the the DT 19613 8245 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8245 9 is be VBZ 19613 8245 10 at at IN 19613 8245 11 the the DT 19613 8245 12 same same JJ 19613 8245 13 time time NN 19613 8245 14 the the DT 19613 8245 15 moral moral JJ 19613 8245 16 and and CC 19613 8245 17 rational rational JJ 19613 8245 18 in in IN 19613 8245 19 all all DT 19613 8245 20 stages stage NNS 19613 8245 21 of of IN 19613 8245 22 development development NN 19613 8245 23 . . . 19613 8246 1 The the DT 19613 8246 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8246 3 is be VBZ 19613 8246 4 the the DT 19613 8246 5 teacher teacher NN 19613 8246 6 , , , 19613 8246 7 not not RB 19613 8246 8 only only RB 19613 8246 9 in in IN 19613 8246 10 cases case NNS 19613 8246 11 where where WRB 19613 8246 12 an an DT 19613 8246 13 intelligent intelligent JJ 19613 8246 14 self self NN 19613 8246 15 - - HYPH 19613 8246 16 restraint restraint NN 19613 8246 17 , , , 19613 8246 18 as as IN 19613 8246 19 understood understand VBN 19613 8246 20 by by IN 19613 8246 21 the the DT 19613 8246 22 ancients ancient NNS 19613 8246 23 , , , 19613 8246 24 bridles bridle VBZ 19613 8246 25 the the DT 19613 8246 26 passions passion NNS 19613 8246 27 and and CC 19613 8246 28 instincts instinct NNS 19613 8246 29 and and CC 19613 8246 30 wards ward NNS 19613 8246 31 off off RP 19613 8246 32 excesses excess NNS 19613 8246 33 of of IN 19613 8246 34 all all DT 19613 8246 35 sorts sort NNS 19613 8246 36 ; ; : 19613 8246 37 but but CC 19613 8246 38 also also RB 19613 8246 39 , , , 19613 8246 40 and and CC 19613 8246 41 here here RB 19613 8246 42 of of IN 19613 8246 43 course course NN 19613 8246 44 the the DT 19613 8246 45 revelation revelation NN 19613 8246 46 is be VBZ 19613 8246 47 of of IN 19613 8246 48 a a DT 19613 8246 49 higher high JJR 19613 8246 50 kind kind NN 19613 8246 51 , , , 19613 8246 52 wherever wherever WRB 19613 8246 53 love love NN 19613 8246 54 to to IN 19613 8246 55 God God NNP 19613 8246 56 alone alone RB 19613 8246 57 determines determine VBZ 19613 8246 58 the the DT 19613 8246 59 whole whole JJ 19613 8246 60 life life NN 19613 8246 61 and and CC 19613 8246 62 exalts exalt VBZ 19613 8246 63 man man NN 19613 8246 64 above above IN 19613 8246 65 everything everything NN 19613 8246 66 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 8246 67 and and CC 19613 8246 68 finite finite JJ 19613 8246 69 . . . 19613 8247 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8247 2 673 673 CD 19613 8247 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8247 4 What what WP 19613 8247 5 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8247 6 moralists moralist NNS 19613 8247 7 merely merely RB 19613 8247 8 regarded regard VBD 19613 8247 9 as as IN 19613 8247 10 contrasts contrast VBZ 19613 8247 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8247 12 , , , 19613 8247 13 the the DT 19613 8247 14 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8247 15 and and CC 19613 8247 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8247 17 , , , 19613 8247 18 was be VBD 19613 8247 19 able able JJ 19613 8247 20 to to TO 19613 8247 21 view view VB 19613 8247 22 as as IN 19613 8247 23 stages stage NNS 19613 8247 24 ; ; : 19613 8247 25 and and CC 19613 8247 26 thus thus RB 19613 8247 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8247 28 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 8247 29 in in IN 19613 8247 30 conceiving conceive VBG 19613 8247 31 the the DT 19613 8247 32 motley motley NNP 19613 8247 33 society society NN 19613 8247 34 that that WDT 19613 8247 35 already already RB 19613 8247 36 represented represent VBD 19613 8247 37 the the DT 19613 8247 38 Church Church NNP 19613 8247 39 of of IN 19613 8247 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8247 41 time time NN 19613 8247 42 as as IN 19613 8247 43 a a DT 19613 8247 44 unity unity NN 19613 8247 45 , , , 19613 8247 46 as as IN 19613 8247 47 the the DT 19613 8247 48 humanity humanity NN 19613 8247 49 trained train VBN 19613 8247 50 by by IN 19613 8247 51 one one CD 19613 8247 52 and and CC 19613 8247 53 the the DT 19613 8247 54 same same JJ 19613 8247 55 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8247 56 , , , 19613 8247 57 the the DT 19613 8247 58 Pedagogue Pedagogue NNP 19613 8247 59 . . . 19613 8248 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8248 2 speculation speculation NN 19613 8248 3 did do VBD 19613 8248 4 not not RB 19613 8248 5 drive drive VB 19613 8248 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 7 out out IN 19613 8248 8 of of IN 19613 8248 9 the the DT 19613 8248 10 Church church NN 19613 8248 11 ; ; : 19613 8248 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 13 rather rather RB 19613 8248 14 enabled enable VBD 19613 8248 15 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 16 to to TO 19613 8248 17 understand understand VB 19613 8248 18 the the DT 19613 8248 19 multiplicity multiplicity NN 19613 8248 20 of of IN 19613 8248 21 forms form NNS 19613 8248 22 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 23 contained contain VBD 19613 8248 24 and and CC 19613 8248 25 to to TO 19613 8248 26 estimate estimate VB 19613 8248 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8248 28 relative relative JJ 19613 8248 29 justification justification NN 19613 8248 30 ; ; : 19613 8248 31 nay nay NN 19613 8248 32 , , , 19613 8248 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 34 finally finally RB 19613 8248 35 led lead VBD 19613 8248 36 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 37 to to TO 19613 8248 38 include include VB 19613 8248 39 the the DT 19613 8248 40 history history NN 19613 8248 41 of of IN 19613 8248 42 pre pre JJ 19613 8248 43 - - JJ 19613 8248 44 Christian christian JJ 19613 8248 45 humanity humanity NN 19613 8248 46 in in IN 19613 8248 47 the the DT 19613 8248 48 system system NN 19613 8248 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8248 50 regarded regard VBD 19613 8248 51 as as IN 19613 8248 52 a a DT 19613 8248 53 unity unity NN 19613 8248 54 , , , 19613 8248 55 and and CC 19613 8248 56 to to TO 19613 8248 57 form form VB 19613 8248 58 a a DT 19613 8248 59 theory theory NN 19613 8248 60 of of IN 19613 8248 61 universal universal JJ 19613 8248 62 history history NN 19613 8248 63 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 19613 8248 64 to to IN 19613 8248 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8248 66 mind mind NN 19613 8248 67 . . . 19613 8249 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8249 2 674 674 CD 19613 8249 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8249 4 If if IN 19613 8249 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8249 6 compare compare VBP 19613 8249 7 this this DT 19613 8249 8 theory theory NN 19613 8249 9 with with IN 19613 8249 10 the the DT 19613 8249 11 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 19613 8249 12 ideas idea NNS 19613 8249 13 of of IN 19613 8249 14 a a DT 19613 8249 15 similar similar JJ 19613 8249 16 kind kind NN 19613 8249 17 in in IN 19613 8249 18 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8249 19 , , , 19613 8249 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8249 21 see see VBP 19613 8249 22 clearly clearly RB 19613 8249 23 the the DT 19613 8249 24 meagreness meagreness NN 19613 8249 25 and and CC 19613 8249 26 want want NN 19613 8249 27 of of IN 19613 8249 28 freedom freedom NN 19613 8249 29 , , , 19613 8249 30 the the DT 19613 8249 31 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 8249 32 and and CC 19613 8249 33 narrowness narrowness NN 19613 8249 34 , , , 19613 8249 35 in in IN 19613 8249 36 the the DT 19613 8249 37 case case NN 19613 8249 38 of of IN 19613 8249 39 the the DT 19613 8249 40 latter latter JJ 19613 8249 41 . . . 19613 8250 1 In in IN 19613 8250 2 the the DT 19613 8250 3 Christian christian JJ 19613 8250 4 faith faith NN 19613 8250 5 as as IN 19613 8250 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8250 7 understood understand VBD 19613 8250 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8250 9 and and CC 19613 8250 10 as as IN 19613 8250 11 amalgamated amalgamate VBN 19613 8250 12 by by IN 19613 8250 13 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8250 14 with with IN 19613 8250 15 Greek greek JJ 19613 8250 16 culture culture NN 19613 8250 17 , , , 19613 8250 18 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8250 19 found find VBD 19613 8250 20 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 8250 21 freedom freedom NN 19613 8250 22 and and CC 19613 8250 23 independence independence NN 19613 8250 24 , , , 19613 8250 25 deliverance deliverance NN 19613 8250 26 from from IN 19613 8250 27 all all DT 19613 8250 28 external external JJ 19613 8250 29 authority authority NN 19613 8250 30 . . . 19613 8251 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8251 2 need need VBP 19613 8251 3 not not RB 19613 8251 4 here here RB 19613 8251 5 directly directly RB 19613 8251 6 discuss discuss VB 19613 8251 7 what what WP 19613 8251 8 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 8251 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8251 10 used use VBD 19613 8251 11 for for IN 19613 8251 12 this this DT 19613 8251 13 end end NN 19613 8251 14 . . . 19613 8252 1 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8252 2 again again RB 19613 8252 3 remained remain VBD 19613 8252 4 entangled entangled JJ 19613 8252 5 in in IN 19613 8252 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8252 7 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 8252 8 , , , 19613 8252 9 and and CC 19613 8252 10 much much RB 19613 8252 11 as as IN 19613 8252 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8252 13 speaks speak VBZ 19613 8252 14 of of IN 19613 8252 15 the the DT 19613 8252 16 _ _ NNP 19613 8252 17 novum novum NN 19613 8252 18 testamentum testamentum NN 19613 8252 19 libertatis libertatis IN 19613 8252 20 _ _ NNP 19613 8252 21 , , , 19613 8252 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8252 23 great great JJ 19613 8252 24 work work NN 19613 8252 25 little little JJ 19613 8252 26 conveys convey NNS 19613 8252 27 the the DT 19613 8252 28 impression impression NN 19613 8252 29 that that IN 19613 8252 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8252 31 author author NN 19613 8252 32 has have VBZ 19613 8252 33 really really RB 19613 8252 34 attained attain VBN 19613 8252 35 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 8252 36 freedom freedom NN 19613 8252 37 . . . 19613 8253 1 Clement clement NN 19613 8253 2 was be VBD 19613 8253 3 the the DT 19613 8253 4 first first JJ 19613 8253 5 to to TO 19613 8253 6 grasp grasp VB 19613 8253 7 the the DT 19613 8253 8 task task NN 19613 8253 9 of of IN 19613 8253 10 future future JJ 19613 8253 11 theology theology NN 19613 8253 12 . . . 19613 8254 1 According accord VBG 19613 8254 2 to to IN 19613 8254 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8254 4 this this DT 19613 8254 5 task task NN 19613 8254 6 consists consist VBZ 19613 8254 7 in in IN 19613 8254 8 utilising utilise VBG 19613 8254 9 the the DT 19613 8254 10 historical historical JJ 19613 8254 11 traditions tradition NNS 19613 8254 12 , , , 19613 8254 13 through through IN 19613 8254 14 which which WDT 19613 8254 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8254 16 have have VBP 19613 8254 17 become become VBN 19613 8254 18 what what WP 19613 8254 19 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8254 20 are be VBP 19613 8254 21 , , , 19613 8254 22 and and CC 19613 8254 23 the the DT 19613 8254 24 Christian christian JJ 19613 8254 25 communion communion NN 19613 8254 26 , , , 19613 8254 27 which which WDT 19613 8254 28 is be VBZ 19613 8254 29 imperative imperative JJ 19613 8254 30 upon upon IN 19613 8254 31 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8254 32 as as IN 19613 8254 33 being be VBG 19613 8254 34 the the DT 19613 8254 35 only only JJ 19613 8254 36 moral moral JJ 19613 8254 37 and and CC 19613 8254 38 religious religious JJ 19613 8254 39 one one NN 19613 8254 40 , , , 19613 8254 41 in in IN 19613 8254 42 order order NN 19613 8254 43 to to TO 19613 8254 44 attain attain VB 19613 8254 45 freedom freedom NN 19613 8254 46 and and CC 19613 8254 47 independence independence NN 19613 8254 48 of of IN 19613 8254 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8254 50 own own JJ 19613 8254 51 life life NN 19613 8254 52 by by IN 19613 8254 53 the the DT 19613 8254 54 aid aid NN 19613 8254 55 of of IN 19613 8254 56 the the DT 19613 8254 57 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8254 58 ; ; : 19613 8254 59 and and CC 19613 8254 60 in in IN 19613 8254 61 showing show VBG 19613 8254 62 this this DT 19613 8254 63 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8254 64 to to TO 19613 8254 65 be be VB 19613 8254 66 the the DT 19613 8254 67 highest high JJS 19613 8254 68 revelation revelation NN 19613 8254 69 by by IN 19613 8254 70 the the DT 19613 8254 71 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8254 72 , , , 19613 8254 73 who who WP 19613 8254 74 has have VBZ 19613 8254 75 given give VBN 19613 8254 76 evidence evidence NN 19613 8254 77 of of IN 19613 8254 78 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8254 79 whenever whenever WRB 19613 8254 80 man man NN 19613 8254 81 rises rise VBZ 19613 8254 82 above above IN 19613 8254 83 the the DT 19613 8254 84 level level NN 19613 8254 85 of of IN 19613 8254 86 nature nature NN 19613 8254 87 and and CC 19613 8254 88 who who WP 19613 8254 89 is be VBZ 19613 8254 90 consequently consequently RB 19613 8254 91 to to TO 19613 8254 92 be be VB 19613 8254 93 traced trace VBN 19613 8254 94 throughout throughout IN 19613 8254 95 the the DT 19613 8254 96 whole whole JJ 19613 8254 97 history history NN 19613 8254 98 of of IN 19613 8254 99 humanity humanity NN 19613 8254 100 . . . 19613 8255 1 But but CC 19613 8255 2 does do VBZ 19613 8255 3 the the DT 19613 8255 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8255 5 of of IN 19613 8255 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8255 7 correspond correspond NN 19613 8255 8 to to IN 19613 8255 9 the the DT 19613 8255 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8255 11 ? ? . 19613 8256 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8256 2 can can MD 19613 8256 3 only only RB 19613 8256 4 give give VB 19613 8256 5 a a DT 19613 8256 6 qualified qualified JJ 19613 8256 7 affirmation affirmation NN 19613 8256 8 to to IN 19613 8256 9 this this DT 19613 8256 10 question question NN 19613 8256 11 . . . 19613 8257 1 For for IN 19613 8257 2 the the DT 19613 8257 3 danger danger NN 19613 8257 4 of of IN 19613 8257 5 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 8257 6 is be VBZ 19613 8257 7 evident evident JJ 19613 8257 8 , , , 19613 8257 9 since since IN 19613 8257 10 apostasy apostasy NNP 19613 8257 11 from from IN 19613 8257 12 the the DT 19613 8257 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8257 14 would would MD 19613 8257 15 be be VB 19613 8257 16 completely completely RB 19613 8257 17 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 8257 18 as as RB 19613 8257 19 soon soon RB 19613 8257 20 as as IN 19613 8257 21 the the DT 19613 8257 22 ideal ideal NN 19613 8257 23 of of IN 19613 8257 24 the the DT 19613 8257 25 self self NN 19613 8257 26 - - HYPH 19613 8257 27 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8257 28 Greek greek JJ 19613 8257 29 sage sage NN 19613 8257 30 came come VBD 19613 8257 31 to to TO 19613 8257 32 supplant supplant VB 19613 8257 33 the the DT 19613 8257 34 feeling feeling NN 19613 8257 35 that that DT 19613 8257 36 man man NN 19613 8257 37 lives live VBZ 19613 8257 38 by by IN 19613 8257 39 the the DT 19613 8257 40 grace grace NN 19613 8257 41 of of IN 19613 8257 42 God God NNP 19613 8257 43 . . . 19613 8258 1 But but CC 19613 8258 2 the the DT 19613 8258 3 danger danger NN 19613 8258 4 of of IN 19613 8258 5 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 8258 6 lies lie VBZ 19613 8258 7 in in IN 19613 8258 8 the the DT 19613 8258 9 cramped cramped JJ 19613 8258 10 conception conception NN 19613 8258 11 of of IN 19613 8258 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8258 13 , , , 19613 8258 14 who who WP 19613 8258 15 sets set VBZ 19613 8258 16 up up RP 19613 8258 17 authorities authority NNS 19613 8258 18 which which WDT 19613 8258 19 have have VBP 19613 8258 20 nothing nothing NN 19613 8258 21 to to TO 19613 8258 22 do do VB 19613 8258 23 with with IN 19613 8258 24 the the DT 19613 8258 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8258 26 , , , 19613 8258 27 and and CC 19613 8258 28 creates create VBZ 19613 8258 29 facts fact NNS 19613 8258 30 of of IN 19613 8258 31 salvation salvation NN 19613 8258 32 which which WDT 19613 8258 33 have have VBP 19613 8258 34 a a DT 19613 8258 35 no no RB 19613 8258 36 less less RBR 19613 8258 37 deadening deadening JJ 19613 8258 38 effect effect NN 19613 8258 39 though though IN 19613 8258 40 in in IN 19613 8258 41 a a DT 19613 8258 42 different different JJ 19613 8258 43 way way NN 19613 8258 44 . . . 19613 8259 1 If if IN 19613 8259 2 the the DT 19613 8259 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8259 4 is be VBZ 19613 8259 5 meant mean VBN 19613 8259 6 to to TO 19613 8259 7 give give VB 19613 8259 8 freedom freedom NN 19613 8259 9 and and CC 19613 8259 10 peace peace NN 19613 8259 11 in in IN 19613 8259 12 God God NNP 19613 8259 13 , , , 19613 8259 14 and and CC 19613 8259 15 to to TO 19613 8259 16 accustom accustom VB 19613 8259 17 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8259 18 to to IN 19613 8259 19 an an DT 19613 8259 20 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8259 21 life life NN 19613 8259 22 in in IN 19613 8259 23 union union NN 19613 8259 24 with with IN 19613 8259 25 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8259 26 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8259 27 understood understand VBD 19613 8259 28 this this DT 19613 8259 29 meaning meaning NN 19613 8259 30 . . . 19613 8260 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8260 2 could could MD 19613 8260 3 justly justly RB 19613 8260 4 say say VB 19613 8260 5 to to IN 19613 8260 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8260 7 opponents opponent NNS 19613 8260 8 : : : 19613 8260 9 " " `` 19613 8260 10 If if IN 19613 8260 11 the the DT 19613 8260 12 things thing NNS 19613 8260 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8260 14 say say VBP 19613 8260 15 appear appear VB 19613 8260 16 to to IN 19613 8260 17 some some DT 19613 8260 18 people people NNS 19613 8260 19 diverse diverse JJ 19613 8260 20 from from IN 19613 8260 21 the the DT 19613 8260 22 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 8260 23 of of IN 19613 8260 24 the the DT 19613 8260 25 Lord Lord NNP 19613 8260 26 , , , 19613 8260 27 let let VB 19613 8260 28 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8260 29 know know VB 19613 8260 30 that that IN 19613 8260 31 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8260 32 draw draw VBP 19613 8260 33 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 8260 34 and and CC 19613 8260 35 life life NN 19613 8260 36 therefrom therefrom NN 19613 8260 37 and and CC 19613 8260 38 , , , 19613 8260 39 making make VBG 19613 8260 40 these these DT 19613 8260 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8260 42 starting starting NN 19613 8260 43 - - HYPH 19613 8260 44 point point NN 19613 8260 45 give give VBP 19613 8260 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8260 47 meaning meaning NN 19613 8260 48 only only RB 19613 8260 49 , , , 19613 8260 50 not not RB 19613 8260 51 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8260 52 letter letter NN 19613 8260 53 " " '' 19613 8260 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8260 55 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8260 56 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8260 57 : : : 19613 8260 58 kan kan NNP 19613 8260 59 heteroia heteroia NNP 19613 8260 60 tisi tisi NNP 19613 8260 61 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8260 62 pollôn pollôn NNP 19613 8260 63 kataphainêtai kataphainêtai NNP 19613 8260 64 ta ta NNP 19613 8260 65 hyph hyph NNP 19613 8260 66 ' ' '' 19613 8260 67 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 8260 68 legomena legomena NNP 19613 8260 69 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8260 70 kyriakôn kyriakôn NNP 19613 8260 71 graphôn graphôn NNP 19613 8260 72 , , , 19613 8260 73 isteon isteon NNP 19613 8260 74 hoti hoti NNP 19613 8260 75 ekeithen ekeithen NNP 19613 8260 76 anapnei anapnei NNP 19613 8260 77 te te NNP 19613 8260 78 kai kai NNP 19613 8260 79 zê zê NNP 19613 8260 80 kai kai NNP 19613 8260 81 tas tas NNP 19613 8260 82 aphormas aphormas NNP 19613 8260 83 ap ap NNP 19613 8260 84 ' ' `` 19613 8260 85 autôn autôn NNP 19613 8260 86 echonta echonta NNP 19613 8260 87 ton ton NN 19613 8260 88 noun noun NNP 19613 8260 89 monon monon NNP 19613 8260 90 , , , 19613 8260 91 ou ou NNP 19613 8260 92 tên tên NNP 19613 8260 93 lexin lexin NNP 19613 8260 94 , , , 19613 8260 95 paristan paristan NNP 19613 8260 96 epangelletai epangelletai NNP 19613 8260 97 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8260 98 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8260 99 . . . 19613 8261 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8261 2 675 675 CD 19613 8261 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8261 4 No no RB 19613 8261 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 8261 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8261 7 conceives conceive VBZ 19613 8261 8 the the DT 19613 8261 9 aim aim NN 19613 8261 10 of of IN 19613 8261 11 the the DT 19613 8261 12 whole whole JJ 19613 8261 13 traditionary traditionary JJ 19613 8261 14 material material NN 19613 8261 15 to to TO 19613 8261 16 be be VB 19613 8261 17 that that DT 19613 8261 18 of of IN 19613 8261 19 Greek greek JJ 19613 8261 20 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8261 21 , , , 19613 8261 22 but but CC 19613 8261 23 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8261 24 can can MD 19613 8261 25 not not RB 19613 8261 26 fail fail VB 19613 8261 27 to to TO 19613 8261 28 perceive perceive VB 19613 8261 29 that that IN 19613 8261 30 this this DT 19613 8261 31 aim aim NN 19613 8261 32 is be VBZ 19613 8261 33 blended blend VBN 19613 8261 34 with with IN 19613 8261 35 the the DT 19613 8261 36 object object NN 19613 8261 37 which which WDT 19613 8261 38 the the DT 19613 8261 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8261 40 puts put VBZ 19613 8261 41 before before IN 19613 8261 42 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8261 43 , , , 19613 8261 44 namely namely RB 19613 8261 45 , , , 19613 8261 46 to to TO 19613 8261 47 be be VB 19613 8261 48 rich rich JJ 19613 8261 49 in in IN 19613 8261 50 God God NNP 19613 8261 51 and and CC 19613 8261 52 to to TO 19613 8261 53 receive receive VB 19613 8261 54 strength strength NN 19613 8261 55 and and CC 19613 8261 56 life life NN 19613 8261 57 from from IN 19613 8261 58 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8261 59 . . . 19613 8262 1 The the DT 19613 8262 2 goodness goodness NN 19613 8262 3 of of IN 19613 8262 4 God God NNP 19613 8262 5 and and CC 19613 8262 6 the the DT 19613 8262 7 responsibility responsibility NN 19613 8262 8 of of IN 19613 8262 9 man man NN 19613 8262 10 are be VBP 19613 8262 11 the the DT 19613 8262 12 central central JJ 19613 8262 13 ideas idea NNS 19613 8262 14 of of IN 19613 8262 15 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8262 16 and and CC 19613 8262 17 the the DT 19613 8262 18 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 8262 19 ; ; : 19613 8262 20 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8262 21 also also RB 19613 8262 22 occupy occupy VBP 19613 8262 23 the the DT 19613 8262 24 foremost foremost JJ 19613 8262 25 place place NN 19613 8262 26 in in IN 19613 8262 27 the the DT 19613 8262 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8262 29 of of IN 19613 8262 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8262 31 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8262 32 . . . 19613 8263 1 If if IN 19613 8263 2 this this DT 19613 8263 3 is be VBZ 19613 8263 4 certain certain JJ 19613 8263 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8263 6 must must MD 19613 8263 7 avoid avoid VB 19613 8263 8 that that DT 19613 8263 9 searching search VBG 19613 8263 10 of of IN 19613 8263 11 the the DT 19613 8263 12 heart heart NN 19613 8263 13 which which WDT 19613 8263 14 undertakes undertake VBZ 19613 8263 15 to to TO 19613 8263 16 fix fix VB 19613 8263 17 how how WRB 19613 8263 18 far far RB 19613 8263 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8263 20 was be VBD 19613 8263 21 influenced influence VBN 19613 8263 22 by by IN 19613 8263 23 the the DT 19613 8263 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8263 25 and and CC 19613 8263 26 how how WRB 19613 8263 27 far far RB 19613 8263 28 by by IN 19613 8263 29 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8263 30 . . . 19613 8264 1 But but CC 19613 8264 2 , , , 19613 8264 3 while while IN 19613 8264 4 so so RB 19613 8264 5 judging judge VBG 19613 8264 6 , , , 19613 8264 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8264 8 can can MD 19613 8264 9 not not RB 19613 8264 10 deny deny VB 19613 8264 11 that that IN 19613 8264 12 the the DT 19613 8264 13 Church Church NNP 19613 8264 14 tradition tradition NN 19613 8264 15 was be VBD 19613 8264 16 here here RB 19613 8264 17 completely completely RB 19613 8264 18 transformed transform VBN 19613 8264 19 into into IN 19613 8264 20 a a DT 19613 8264 21 Greek greek JJ 19613 8264 22 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8264 23 of of IN 19613 8264 24 religion religion NN 19613 8264 25 on on IN 19613 8264 26 a a DT 19613 8264 27 historical historical JJ 19613 8264 28 basis basis NN 19613 8264 29 , , , 19613 8264 30 nor nor CC 19613 8264 31 do do VBP 19613 8264 32 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8264 33 certify certify VB 19613 8264 34 the the DT 19613 8264 35 Christian christian JJ 19613 8264 36 character character NN 19613 8264 37 of of IN 19613 8264 38 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8264 39 's 's POS 19613 8264 40 " " `` 19613 8264 41 dogmas dogmas NN 19613 8264 42 " " '' 19613 8264 43 in in IN 19613 8264 44 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 19613 8264 45 the the DT 19613 8264 46 evangelical evangelical JJ 19613 8264 47 spirit spirit NN 19613 8264 48 of of IN 19613 8264 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8264 50 practical practical JJ 19613 8264 51 position position NN 19613 8264 52 . . . 19613 8265 1 What what WP 19613 8265 2 would would MD 19613 8265 3 be be VB 19613 8265 4 left leave VBN 19613 8265 5 of of IN 19613 8265 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8265 7 , , , 19613 8265 8 if if IN 19613 8265 9 the the DT 19613 8265 10 practical practical JJ 19613 8265 11 aim aim NN 19613 8265 12 , , , 19613 8265 13 given give VBN 19613 8265 14 by by IN 19613 8265 15 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8265 16 to to IN 19613 8265 17 this this DT 19613 8265 18 religious religious JJ 19613 8265 19 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8265 20 , , , 19613 8265 21 were be VBD 19613 8265 22 lost lose VBN 19613 8265 23 ? ? . 19613 8266 1 A a DT 19613 8266 2 depotentiated depotentiated JJ 19613 8266 3 system system NN 19613 8266 4 which which WDT 19613 8266 5 could could MD 19613 8266 6 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 8266 7 no no RB 19613 8266 8 longer longer RB 19613 8266 9 be be VB 19613 8266 10 called call VBN 19613 8266 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8266 12 . . . 19613 8267 1 On on IN 19613 8267 2 the the DT 19613 8267 3 other other JJ 19613 8267 4 hand hand NN 19613 8267 5 there there EX 19613 8267 6 were be VBD 19613 8267 7 many many JJ 19613 8267 8 valuable valuable JJ 19613 8267 9 features feature NNS 19613 8267 10 in in IN 19613 8267 11 the the DT 19613 8267 12 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8267 13 _ _ NNP 19613 8267 14 regula regula NN 19613 8267 15 _ _ NNP 19613 8267 16 literally literally RB 19613 8267 17 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 8267 18 ; ; : 19613 8267 19 and and CC 19613 8267 20 the the DT 19613 8267 21 attempts attempt NNS 19613 8267 22 of of IN 19613 8267 23 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8267 24 to to TO 19613 8267 25 extract extract VB 19613 8267 26 an an DT 19613 8267 27 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 8267 28 religious religious JJ 19613 8267 29 meaning meaning NN 19613 8267 30 from from IN 19613 8267 31 the the DT 19613 8267 32 literal literal JJ 19613 8267 33 sense sense NN 19613 8267 34 of of IN 19613 8267 35 Church church NN 19613 8267 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 8267 37 and and CC 19613 8267 38 of of IN 19613 8267 39 New New NNP 19613 8267 40 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8267 41 passages passage NNS 19613 8267 42 must must MD 19613 8267 43 be be VB 19613 8267 44 regarded regard VBN 19613 8267 45 as as IN 19613 8267 46 conservative conservative JJ 19613 8267 47 efforts effort NNS 19613 8267 48 of of IN 19613 8267 49 the the DT 19613 8267 50 most most RBS 19613 8267 51 valuable valuable JJ 19613 8267 52 kind kind NN 19613 8267 53 . . . 19613 8268 1 No no RB 19613 8268 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 8268 3 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8268 4 and and CC 19613 8268 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8268 6 theological theological JJ 19613 8268 7 _ _ NNP 19613 8268 8 confrères confrère NNS 19613 8268 9 _ _ NNP 19613 8268 10 did do VBD 19613 8268 11 not not RB 19613 8268 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8268 13 find find VB 19613 8268 14 in in IN 19613 8268 15 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8268 16 that that DT 19613 8268 17 freedom freedom NN 19613 8268 18 which which WDT 19613 8268 19 is be VBZ 19613 8268 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8268 21 highest high JJS 19613 8268 22 aim aim NN 19613 8268 23 ; ; : 19613 8268 24 but but CC 19613 8268 25 on on IN 19613 8268 26 the the DT 19613 8268 27 other other JJ 19613 8268 28 hand hand NN 19613 8268 29 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8268 30 preserved preserve VBD 19613 8268 31 and and CC 19613 8268 32 rescued rescue VBD 19613 8268 33 valuable valuable JJ 19613 8268 34 material material NN 19613 8268 35 for for IN 19613 8268 36 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 8268 37 times time NNS 19613 8268 38 . . . 19613 8269 1 If if IN 19613 8269 2 some some DT 19613 8269 3 day day NN 19613 8269 4 trust trust NN 19613 8269 5 in in IN 19613 8269 6 the the DT 19613 8269 7 methods method NNS 19613 8269 8 of of IN 19613 8269 9 religious religious JJ 19613 8269 10 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8269 11 vanishes vanishe NNS 19613 8269 12 , , , 19613 8269 13 men man NNS 19613 8269 14 will will MD 19613 8269 15 revert revert VB 19613 8269 16 to to IN 19613 8269 17 history history NN 19613 8269 18 , , , 19613 8269 19 which which WDT 19613 8269 20 will will MD 19613 8269 21 still still RB 19613 8269 22 be be VB 19613 8269 23 recognisable recognisable JJ 19613 8269 24 in in IN 19613 8269 25 the the DT 19613 8269 26 preserved preserve VBN 19613 8269 27 tradition tradition NN 19613 8269 28 , , , 19613 8269 29 as as IN 19613 8269 30 prized prize VBN 19613 8269 31 by by IN 19613 8269 32 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8269 33 and and CC 19613 8269 34 the the DT 19613 8269 35 rest rest NN 19613 8269 36 , , , 19613 8269 37 whereas whereas IN 19613 8269 38 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8269 39 will will MD 19613 8269 40 have have VB 19613 8269 41 almost almost RB 19613 8269 42 perished perish VBN 19613 8269 43 in in IN 19613 8269 44 the the DT 19613 8269 45 artificial artificial JJ 19613 8269 46 interpretations interpretation NNS 19613 8269 47 due due IN 19613 8269 48 to to IN 19613 8269 49 the the DT 19613 8269 50 speculations speculation NNS 19613 8269 51 of of IN 19613 8269 52 religious religious JJ 19613 8269 53 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8269 54 . . . 19613 8270 1 The the DT 19613 8270 2 importance importance NN 19613 8270 3 that that IN 19613 8270 4 the the DT 19613 8270 5 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 8270 6 school school NN 19613 8270 7 was be VBD 19613 8270 8 to to TO 19613 8270 9 attain attain VB 19613 8270 10 in in IN 19613 8270 11 the the DT 19613 8270 12 history history NN 19613 8270 13 of of IN 19613 8270 14 dogma dogma NN 19613 8270 15 is be VBZ 19613 8270 16 not not RB 19613 8270 17 associated associate VBN 19613 8270 18 with with IN 19613 8270 19 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8270 20 , , , 19613 8270 21 but but CC 19613 8270 22 with with IN 19613 8270 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8270 24 disciple disciple JJ 19613 8270 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8270 26 . . . 19613 8271 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8271 2 676 676 CD 19613 8271 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8271 4 This this DT 19613 8271 5 was be VBD 19613 8271 6 not not RB 19613 8271 7 because because IN 19613 8271 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8271 9 was be VBD 19613 8271 10 more more JJR 19613 8271 11 heterodox heterodox JJ 19613 8271 12 than than IN 19613 8271 13 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8271 14 , , , 19613 8271 15 for for IN 19613 8271 16 that that DT 19613 8271 17 is be VBZ 19613 8271 18 not not RB 19613 8271 19 the the DT 19613 8271 20 case case NN 19613 8271 21 , , , 19613 8271 22 so so RB 19613 8271 23 far far RB 19613 8271 24 as as IN 19613 8271 25 the the DT 19613 8271 26 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 8271 27 is be VBZ 19613 8271 28 concerned concern VBN 19613 8271 29 at at IN 19613 8271 30 least;[677 least;[677 CD 19613 8271 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8271 32 but but CC 19613 8271 33 because because IN 19613 8271 34 the the DT 19613 8271 35 latter latter NN 19613 8271 36 exerted exert VBD 19613 8271 37 an an DT 19613 8271 38 incomparably incomparably RB 19613 8271 39 greater great JJR 19613 8271 40 influence influence NN 19613 8271 41 than than IN 19613 8271 42 the the DT 19613 8271 43 former former JJ 19613 8271 44 ; ; : 19613 8271 45 and and CC 19613 8271 46 , , , 19613 8271 47 with with IN 19613 8271 48 an an DT 19613 8271 49 energy energy NN 19613 8271 50 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 8271 51 unexampled unexampled JJ 19613 8271 52 in in IN 19613 8271 53 the the DT 19613 8271 54 history history NN 19613 8271 55 of of IN 19613 8271 56 the the DT 19613 8271 57 Church Church NNP 19613 8271 58 , , , 19613 8271 59 already already RB 19613 8271 60 mapped map VBD 19613 8271 61 out out RP 19613 8271 62 all all PDT 19613 8271 63 the the DT 19613 8271 64 provinces province NNS 19613 8271 65 of of IN 19613 8271 66 theology theology NN 19613 8271 67 by by IN 19613 8271 68 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8271 69 own own JJ 19613 8271 70 unaided unaided JJ 19613 8271 71 efforts effort NNS 19613 8271 72 . . . 19613 8272 1 Another another DT 19613 8272 2 reason reason NN 19613 8272 3 is be VBZ 19613 8272 4 that that IN 19613 8272 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8272 6 did do VBD 19613 8272 7 not not RB 19613 8272 8 possess possess VB 19613 8272 9 the the DT 19613 8272 10 Church Church NNP 19613 8272 11 tradition tradition NN 19613 8272 12 in in IN 19613 8272 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8272 14 fixed fix VBN 19613 8272 15 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 8272 16 forms form NNS 19613 8272 17 as as IN 19613 8272 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8272 19 did do VBD 19613 8272 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8272 21 see see VB 19613 8272 22 above above RB 19613 8272 23 , , , 19613 8272 24 chapter chapter NN 19613 8272 25 2 2 CD 19613 8272 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8272 27 , , , 19613 8272 28 and and CC 19613 8272 29 , , , 19613 8272 30 as as IN 19613 8272 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8272 32 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 8272 33 shows show NNS 19613 8272 34 , , , 19613 8272 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8272 36 was be VBD 19613 8272 37 as as RB 19613 8272 38 yet yet RB 19613 8272 39 incapable incapable JJ 19613 8272 40 of of IN 19613 8272 41 forming form VBG 19613 8272 42 a a DT 19613 8272 43 theological theological JJ 19613 8272 44 system system NN 19613 8272 45 . . . 19613 8273 1 What what WP 19613 8273 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8273 3 offers offer VBZ 19613 8273 4 is be VBZ 19613 8273 5 portions portion NNS 19613 8273 6 of of IN 19613 8273 7 a a DT 19613 8273 8 theological theological JJ 19613 8273 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 8273 10 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8273 11 and and CC 19613 8273 12 speculative speculative JJ 19613 8273 13 ethic ethic NN 19613 8273 14 . . . 19613 8274 1 These these DT 19613 8274 2 indeed indeed RB 19613 8274 3 are be VBP 19613 8274 4 no no DT 19613 8274 5 fragments fragment NNS 19613 8274 6 in in IN 19613 8274 7 so so RB 19613 8274 8 far far RB 19613 8274 9 as as IN 19613 8274 10 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8274 11 are be VBP 19613 8274 12 all all RB 19613 8274 13 produced produce VBN 19613 8274 14 according accord VBG 19613 8274 15 to to IN 19613 8274 16 a a DT 19613 8274 17 definite definite JJ 19613 8274 18 method method NN 19613 8274 19 and and CC 19613 8274 20 have have VBP 19613 8274 21 the the DT 19613 8274 22 same same JJ 19613 8274 23 object object NN 19613 8274 24 in in IN 19613 8274 25 view view NN 19613 8274 26 , , , 19613 8274 27 but but CC 19613 8274 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8274 29 still still RB 19613 8274 30 want want VBP 19613 8274 31 unity unity NN 19613 8274 32 . . . 19613 8275 1 On on IN 19613 8275 2 the the DT 19613 8275 3 other other JJ 19613 8275 4 hand hand NN 19613 8275 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8275 6 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 8275 7 in in IN 19613 8275 8 forming form VBG 19613 8275 9 a a DT 19613 8275 10 complete complete JJ 19613 8275 11 system system NN 19613 8275 12 inasmuch inasmuch NN 19613 8275 13 as as IN 19613 8275 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8275 15 not not RB 19613 8275 16 only only RB 19613 8275 17 had have VBD 19613 8275 18 a a DT 19613 8275 19 Catholic catholic JJ 19613 8275 20 tradition tradition NN 19613 8275 21 of of IN 19613 8275 22 fixed fix VBN 19613 8275 23 limits limit NNS 19613 8275 24 and and CC 19613 8275 25 definite definite JJ 19613 8275 26 type type NN 19613 8275 27 to to TO 19613 8275 28 fall fall VB 19613 8275 29 back back RB 19613 8275 30 upon upon IN 19613 8275 31 as as IN 19613 8275 32 a a DT 19613 8275 33 basis basis NN 19613 8275 34 ; ; : 19613 8275 35 but but CC 19613 8275 36 was be VBD 19613 8275 37 also also RB 19613 8275 38 enabled enable VBN 19613 8275 39 by by IN 19613 8275 40 the the DT 19613 8275 41 previous previous JJ 19613 8275 42 efforts effort NNS 19613 8275 43 of of IN 19613 8275 44 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8275 45 to to TO 19613 8275 46 furnish furnish VB 19613 8275 47 a a DT 19613 8275 48 methodical methodical JJ 19613 8275 49 treatment treatment NN 19613 8275 50 of of IN 19613 8275 51 this this DT 19613 8275 52 tradition tradition NN 19613 8275 53 . . . 19613 8276 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8276 2 678 678 CD 19613 8276 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8276 4 Now now RB 19613 8276 5 a a DT 19613 8276 6 sharp sharp JJ 19613 8276 7 eye eye NN 19613 8276 8 indeed indeed RB 19613 8276 9 perceives perceive VBZ 19613 8276 10 that that IN 19613 8276 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8276 12 personally personally RB 19613 8276 13 no no RB 19613 8276 14 longer long RBR 19613 8276 15 possessed possess VBD 19613 8276 16 such such PDT 19613 8276 17 a a DT 19613 8276 18 complete complete JJ 19613 8276 19 and and CC 19613 8276 20 bold bold JJ 19613 8276 21 religious religious JJ 19613 8276 22 theory theory NN 19613 8276 23 of of IN 19613 8276 24 the the DT 19613 8276 25 world world NN 19613 8276 26 as as IN 19613 8276 27 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8276 28 did do VBD 19613 8276 29 , , , 19613 8276 30 for for IN 19613 8276 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8276 32 was be VBD 19613 8276 33 already already RB 19613 8276 34 more more RBR 19613 8276 35 tightly tightly RB 19613 8276 36 fettered fetter VBN 19613 8276 37 by by IN 19613 8276 38 the the DT 19613 8276 39 Church Church NNP 19613 8276 40 tradition tradition NN 19613 8276 41 , , , 19613 8276 42 some some DT 19613 8276 43 details detail NNS 19613 8276 44 of of IN 19613 8276 45 which which WDT 19613 8276 46 here here RB 19613 8276 47 and and CC 19613 8276 48 there there RB 19613 8276 49 led lead VBD 19613 8276 50 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8276 51 into into IN 19613 8276 52 compromises compromise NNS 19613 8276 53 that that WDT 19613 8276 54 remind remind VBP 19613 8276 55 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8276 56 of of IN 19613 8276 57 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8276 58 ; ; : 19613 8276 59 but but CC 19613 8276 60 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8276 61 was be VBD 19613 8276 62 in in IN 19613 8276 63 connection connection NN 19613 8276 64 with with IN 19613 8276 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8276 66 work work NN 19613 8276 67 that that WDT 19613 8276 68 the the DT 19613 8276 69 development development NN 19613 8276 70 of of IN 19613 8276 71 the the DT 19613 8276 72 following follow VBG 19613 8276 73 period period NN 19613 8276 74 took take VBD 19613 8276 75 place place NN 19613 8276 76 . . . 19613 8277 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8277 2 is be VBZ 19613 8277 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 8277 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8277 5 , , , 19613 8277 6 within within IN 19613 8277 7 the the DT 19613 8277 8 framework framework NN 19613 8277 9 of of IN 19613 8277 10 the the DT 19613 8277 11 history history NN 19613 8277 12 of of IN 19613 8277 13 dogma dogma NN 19613 8277 14 , , , 19613 8277 15 to to TO 19613 8277 16 refer refer VB 19613 8277 17 to to IN 19613 8277 18 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8277 19 as as IN 19613 8277 20 the the DT 19613 8277 21 bold bold JJ 19613 8277 22 forerunner forerunner NN 19613 8277 23 of of IN 19613 8277 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8277 25 , , , 19613 8277 26 and and CC 19613 8277 27 , , , 19613 8277 28 in in IN 19613 8277 29 setting set VBG 19613 8277 30 forth forth RB 19613 8277 31 the the DT 19613 8277 32 theology theology NN 19613 8277 33 of of IN 19613 8277 34 the the DT 19613 8277 35 latter latter JJ 19613 8277 36 , , , 19613 8277 37 to to TO 19613 8277 38 compare compare VB 19613 8277 39 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8277 40 in in IN 19613 8277 41 important important JJ 19613 8277 42 points point NNS 19613 8277 43 with with IN 19613 8277 44 the the DT 19613 8277 45 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 8277 46 of of IN 19613 8277 47 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8277 48 . . . 19613 8278 1 2 2 LS 19613 8278 2 . . . 19613 8279 1 _ _ NNP 19613 8279 2 The the DT 19613 8279 3 system system NN 19613 8279 4 of of IN 19613 8279 5 Origen._[679 Origen._[679 NNP 19613 8279 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8279 7 Among among IN 19613 8279 8 the the DT 19613 8279 9 theologians theologian NNS 19613 8279 10 of of IN 19613 8279 11 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8279 12 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 8279 13 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8279 14 was be VBD 19613 8279 15 the the DT 19613 8279 16 most most RBS 19613 8279 17 important important JJ 19613 8279 18 and and CC 19613 8279 19 influential influential JJ 19613 8279 20 alongside alongside NN 19613 8279 21 of of IN 19613 8279 22 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 8279 23 . . . 19613 8280 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8280 2 proved prove VBD 19613 8280 3 the the DT 19613 8280 4 father father NN 19613 8280 5 of of IN 19613 8280 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8280 7 science science NN 19613 8280 8 in in IN 19613 8280 9 the the DT 19613 8280 10 widest wide JJS 19613 8280 11 sense sense NN 19613 8280 12 of of IN 19613 8280 13 the the DT 19613 8280 14 word word NN 19613 8280 15 , , , 19613 8280 16 and and CC 19613 8280 17 at at IN 19613 8280 18 the the DT 19613 8280 19 same same JJ 19613 8280 20 time time NN 19613 8280 21 became become VBD 19613 8280 22 the the DT 19613 8280 23 founder founder NN 19613 8280 24 of of IN 19613 8280 25 that that DT 19613 8280 26 theology theology NN 19613 8280 27 which which WDT 19613 8280 28 reached reach VBD 19613 8280 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8280 30 complete complete JJ 19613 8280 31 development development NN 19613 8280 32 in in IN 19613 8280 33 the the DT 19613 8280 34 fourth fourth JJ 19613 8280 35 and and CC 19613 8280 36 fifth fifth JJ 19613 8280 37 centuries century NNS 19613 8280 38 , , , 19613 8280 39 and and CC 19613 8280 40 which which WDT 19613 8280 41 in in IN 19613 8280 42 the the DT 19613 8280 43 sixth sixth JJ 19613 8280 44 definitely definitely RB 19613 8280 45 denied deny VBD 19613 8280 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8280 47 author author NN 19613 8280 48 , , , 19613 8280 49 without without IN 19613 8280 50 , , , 19613 8280 51 however however RB 19613 8280 52 , , , 19613 8280 53 losing lose VBG 19613 8280 54 the the DT 19613 8280 55 form form NN 19613 8280 56 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8280 57 had have VBD 19613 8280 58 impressed impress VBN 19613 8280 59 on on IN 19613 8280 60 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8280 61 . . . 19613 8281 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8281 2 created create VBD 19613 8281 3 the the DT 19613 8281 4 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8281 5 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8281 6 and and CC 19613 8281 7 made make VBD 19613 8281 8 the the DT 19613 8281 9 sources source NNS 19613 8281 10 of of IN 19613 8281 11 the the DT 19613 8281 12 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 8281 13 and and CC 19613 8281 14 Christian christian JJ 19613 8281 15 religion religion NN 19613 8281 16 the the DT 19613 8281 17 foundation foundation NN 19613 8281 18 of of IN 19613 8281 19 that that DT 19613 8281 20 science science NN 19613 8281 21 . . . 19613 8282 1 The the DT 19613 8282 2 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 8282 3 , , , 19613 8282 4 in in IN 19613 8282 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8282 6 day day NN 19613 8282 7 , , , 19613 8282 8 had have VBD 19613 8282 9 found find VBN 19613 8282 10 everything everything NN 19613 8282 11 clear clear JJ 19613 8282 12 in in IN 19613 8282 13 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8282 14 ; ; : 19613 8282 15 the the DT 19613 8282 16 antignostic antignostic JJ 19613 8282 17 Fathers father NNS 19613 8282 18 had have VBD 19613 8282 19 confused confuse VBN 19613 8282 20 the the DT 19613 8282 21 Church Church NNP 19613 8282 22 's 's POS 19613 8282 23 faith faith NN 19613 8282 24 and and CC 19613 8282 25 the the DT 19613 8282 26 science science NN 19613 8282 27 that that WDT 19613 8282 28 treats treat VBZ 19613 8282 29 of of IN 19613 8282 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8282 31 . . . 19613 8283 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8283 2 recognised recognise VBD 19613 8283 3 the the DT 19613 8283 4 problem problem NN 19613 8283 5 and and CC 19613 8283 6 the the DT 19613 8283 7 problems problem NNS 19613 8283 8 , , , 19613 8283 9 and and CC 19613 8283 10 elevated elevate VBD 19613 8283 11 the the DT 19613 8283 12 pursuit pursuit NN 19613 8283 13 of of IN 19613 8283 14 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8283 15 theology theology NN 19613 8283 16 to to IN 19613 8283 17 the the DT 19613 8283 18 rank rank NN 19613 8283 19 of of IN 19613 8283 20 an an DT 19613 8283 21 independent independent JJ 19613 8283 22 task task NN 19613 8283 23 by by IN 19613 8283 24 freeing free VBG 19613 8283 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8283 26 from from IN 19613 8283 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8283 28 polemical polemical JJ 19613 8283 29 aim aim NN 19613 8283 30 . . . 19613 8284 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8284 2 could could MD 19613 8284 3 not not RB 19613 8284 4 have have VB 19613 8284 5 become become VBN 19613 8284 6 what what WP 19613 8284 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8284 8 did do VBD 19613 8284 9 , , , 19613 8284 10 if if IN 19613 8284 11 two two CD 19613 8284 12 generations generation NNS 19613 8284 13 had have VBD 19613 8284 14 not not RB 19613 8284 15 preceded precede VBN 19613 8284 16 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8284 17 in in IN 19613 8284 18 paving pave VBG 19613 8284 19 the the DT 19613 8284 20 way way NN 19613 8284 21 to to TO 19613 8284 22 form form VB 19613 8284 23 a a DT 19613 8284 24 mental mental JJ 19613 8284 25 conception conception NN 19613 8284 26 of of IN 19613 8284 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8284 28 and and CC 19613 8284 29 give give VB 19613 8284 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8284 31 a a DT 19613 8284 32 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8284 33 foundation foundation NN 19613 8284 34 . . . 19613 8285 1 Like like IN 19613 8285 2 all all DT 19613 8285 3 epoch epoch NN 19613 8285 4 - - HYPH 19613 8285 5 making make VBG 19613 8285 6 personalities personality NNS 19613 8285 7 , , , 19613 8285 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8285 9 was be VBD 19613 8285 10 also also RB 19613 8285 11 favoured favour VBN 19613 8285 12 by by IN 19613 8285 13 the the DT 19613 8285 14 conditions condition NNS 19613 8285 15 in in IN 19613 8285 16 which which WDT 19613 8285 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8285 18 lived live VBD 19613 8285 19 , , , 19613 8285 20 though though IN 19613 8285 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8285 22 had have VBD 19613 8285 23 to to TO 19613 8285 24 endure endure VB 19613 8285 25 violent violent JJ 19613 8285 26 attacks attack NNS 19613 8285 27 . . . 19613 8286 1 Born bear VBN 19613 8286 2 of of IN 19613 8286 3 a a DT 19613 8286 4 Christian christian JJ 19613 8286 5 family family NN 19613 8286 6 which which WDT 19613 8286 7 was be VBD 19613 8286 8 faithfully faithfully RB 19613 8286 9 attached attach VBN 19613 8286 10 to to IN 19613 8286 11 the the DT 19613 8286 12 Church Church NNP 19613 8286 13 , , , 19613 8286 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8286 15 lived live VBD 19613 8286 16 at at IN 19613 8286 17 a a DT 19613 8286 18 time time NN 19613 8286 19 when when WRB 19613 8286 20 the the DT 19613 8286 21 Christian christian JJ 19613 8286 22 communities community NNS 19613 8286 23 enjoyed enjoy VBD 19613 8286 24 almost almost RB 19613 8286 25 uninterrupted uninterrupted JJ 19613 8286 26 peace peace NN 19613 8286 27 and and CC 19613 8286 28 were be VBD 19613 8286 29 being be VBG 19613 8286 30 naturalised naturalise VBN 19613 8286 31 in in IN 19613 8286 32 the the DT 19613 8286 33 world world NN 19613 8286 34 ; ; : 19613 8286 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8286 36 was be VBD 19613 8286 37 a a DT 19613 8286 38 member member NN 19613 8286 39 of of IN 19613 8286 40 a a DT 19613 8286 41 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8286 42 Church Church NNP 19613 8286 43 where where WRB 19613 8286 44 the the DT 19613 8286 45 right right NN 19613 8286 46 of of IN 19613 8286 47 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8286 48 study study NN 19613 8286 49 was be VBD 19613 8286 50 already already RB 19613 8286 51 recognised recognise VBN 19613 8286 52 and and CC 19613 8286 53 where where WRB 19613 8286 54 this this DT 19613 8286 55 had have VBD 19613 8286 56 attained attain VBN 19613 8286 57 a a DT 19613 8286 58 fixed fix VBN 19613 8286 59 position position NN 19613 8286 60 in in IN 19613 8286 61 an an DT 19613 8286 62 organised organise VBN 19613 8286 63 school school NN 19613 8286 64 . . . 19613 8287 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8287 2 680 680 CD 19613 8287 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8287 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8287 5 proclaimed proclaim VBD 19613 8287 6 the the DT 19613 8287 7 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 8287 8 of of IN 19613 8287 9 science science NN 19613 8287 10 with with IN 19613 8287 11 the the DT 19613 8287 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 8287 13 faith faith NN 19613 8287 14 and and CC 19613 8287 15 the the DT 19613 8287 16 compatibility compatibility NN 19613 8287 17 of of IN 19613 8287 18 the the DT 19613 8287 19 highest high JJS 19613 8287 20 culture culture NN 19613 8287 21 with with IN 19613 8287 22 the the DT 19613 8287 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8287 24 within within IN 19613 8287 25 the the DT 19613 8287 26 bosom bosom NN 19613 8287 27 of of IN 19613 8287 28 the the DT 19613 8287 29 Church Church NNP 19613 8287 30 , , , 19613 8287 31 thus thus RB 19613 8287 32 contributing contribute VBG 19613 8287 33 more more JJR 19613 8287 34 than than IN 19613 8287 35 any any DT 19613 8287 36 other other JJ 19613 8287 37 to to TO 19613 8287 38 convert convert VB 19613 8287 39 the the DT 19613 8287 40 ancient ancient JJ 19613 8287 41 world world NN 19613 8287 42 to to IN 19613 8287 43 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8287 44 . . . 19613 8288 1 But but CC 19613 8288 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8288 3 made make VBD 19613 8288 4 no no DT 19613 8288 5 compromises compromise NNS 19613 8288 6 from from IN 19613 8288 7 shrewd shrewd JJ 19613 8288 8 calculation calculation NN 19613 8288 9 : : : 19613 8288 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8288 11 was be VBD 19613 8288 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8288 13 inmost inmost NN 19613 8288 14 and and CC 19613 8288 15 holiest holy JJS 19613 8288 16 conviction conviction NN 19613 8288 17 that that IN 19613 8288 18 the the DT 19613 8288 19 sacred sacred JJ 19613 8288 20 documents document NNS 19613 8288 21 of of IN 19613 8288 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8288 23 contained contain VBD 19613 8288 24 all all PDT 19613 8288 25 the the DT 19613 8288 26 ideals ideal NNS 19613 8288 27 of of IN 19613 8288 28 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 8288 29 , , , 19613 8288 30 and and CC 19613 8288 31 that that IN 19613 8288 32 the the DT 19613 8288 33 speculative speculative JJ 19613 8288 34 conception conception NN 19613 8288 35 of of IN 19613 8288 36 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8288 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8288 38 was be VBD 19613 8288 39 the the DT 19613 8288 40 only only JJ 19613 8288 41 true true JJ 19613 8288 42 and and CC 19613 8288 43 right right JJ 19613 8288 44 one one CD 19613 8288 45 . . . 19613 8289 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8289 2 character character NN 19613 8289 3 was be VBD 19613 8289 4 pure pure JJ 19613 8289 5 , , , 19613 8289 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8289 7 life life NN 19613 8289 8 blameless blameless NN 19613 8289 9 ; ; : 19613 8289 10 in in IN 19613 8289 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8289 12 work work NN 19613 8289 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8289 14 was be VBD 19613 8289 15 not not RB 19613 8289 16 only only RB 19613 8289 17 unwearied unwearied JJ 19613 8289 18 , , , 19613 8289 19 but but CC 19613 8289 20 also also RB 19613 8289 21 unselfish unselfish JJ 19613 8289 22 . . . 19613 8290 1 There there EX 19613 8290 2 have have VBP 19613 8290 3 been be VBN 19613 8290 4 few few JJ 19613 8290 5 Fathers father NNS 19613 8290 6 of of IN 19613 8290 7 the the DT 19613 8290 8 Church Church NNP 19613 8290 9 whose whose WP$ 19613 8290 10 life life NN 19613 8290 11 - - HYPH 19613 8290 12 story story NN 19613 8290 13 leaves leave VBZ 19613 8290 14 such such PDT 19613 8290 15 an an DT 19613 8290 16 impression impression NN 19613 8290 17 of of IN 19613 8290 18 purity purity NN 19613 8290 19 behind behind IN 19613 8290 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8290 21 as as IN 19613 8290 22 that that DT 19613 8290 23 of of IN 19613 8290 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8290 25 . . . 19613 8291 1 The the DT 19613 8291 2 atmosphere atmosphere NN 19613 8291 3 which which WDT 19613 8291 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8291 5 breathed breathe VBD 19613 8291 6 as as IN 19613 8291 7 a a DT 19613 8291 8 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8291 9 and and CC 19613 8291 10 as as IN 19613 8291 11 a a DT 19613 8291 12 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 8291 13 was be VBD 19613 8291 14 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 8291 15 ; ; : 19613 8291 16 but but CC 19613 8291 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8291 18 mind mind NN 19613 8291 19 remained remain VBD 19613 8291 20 sound sound JJ 19613 8291 21 , , , 19613 8291 22 and and CC 19613 8291 23 even even RB 19613 8291 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8291 25 feeling feeling NN 19613 8291 26 for for IN 19613 8291 27 truth truth NN 19613 8291 28 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 8291 29 ever ever RB 19613 8291 30 forsook forsook VBP 19613 8291 31 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8291 32 . . . 19613 8292 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8292 2 681 681 CD 19613 8292 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8292 4 To to IN 19613 8292 5 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8292 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8292 7 theory theory NN 19613 8292 8 of of IN 19613 8292 9 the the DT 19613 8292 10 world world NN 19613 8292 11 , , , 19613 8292 12 surveyed survey VBN 19613 8292 13 in in IN 19613 8292 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8292 15 details detail NNS 19613 8292 16 , , , 19613 8292 17 presents present VBZ 19613 8292 18 various various JJ 19613 8292 19 changing changing JJ 19613 8292 20 hues hue NNS 19613 8292 21 , , , 19613 8292 22 like like IN 19613 8292 23 that that DT 19613 8292 24 of of IN 19613 8292 25 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8292 26 , , , 19613 8292 27 and and CC 19613 8292 28 at at IN 19613 8292 29 the the DT 19613 8292 30 present present JJ 19613 8292 31 day day NN 19613 8292 32 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8292 33 can can MD 19613 8292 34 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 8292 35 any any DT 19613 8292 36 longer long RBR 19613 8292 37 understand understand VB 19613 8292 38 how how WRB 19613 8292 39 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8292 40 was be VBD 19613 8292 41 able able JJ 19613 8292 42 to to TO 19613 8292 43 unite unite VB 19613 8292 44 the the DT 19613 8292 45 different different JJ 19613 8292 46 materials material NNS 19613 8292 47 ; ; : 19613 8292 48 but but CC 19613 8292 49 , , , 19613 8292 50 considering consider VBG 19613 8292 51 the the DT 19613 8292 52 solidity solidity NN 19613 8292 53 of of IN 19613 8292 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8292 55 character character NN 19613 8292 56 and and CC 19613 8292 57 the the DT 19613 8292 58 confidence confidence NN 19613 8292 59 of of IN 19613 8292 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8292 61 decisions decision NNS 19613 8292 62 , , , 19613 8292 63 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8292 64 can can MD 19613 8292 65 not not RB 19613 8292 66 doubt doubt VB 19613 8292 67 that that IN 19613 8292 68 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8292 69 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8292 70 felt feel VBD 19613 8292 71 the the DT 19613 8292 72 agreement agreement NN 19613 8292 73 of of IN 19613 8292 74 all all DT 19613 8292 75 essential essential JJ 19613 8292 76 parts part NNS 19613 8292 77 of of IN 19613 8292 78 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8292 79 system system NN 19613 8292 80 . . . 19613 8293 1 No no RB 19613 8293 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 8293 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8293 4 spoke speak VBD 19613 8293 5 in in IN 19613 8293 6 one one CD 19613 8293 7 way way NN 19613 8293 8 to to IN 19613 8293 9 the the DT 19613 8293 10 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8293 11 and and CC 19613 8293 12 in in IN 19613 8293 13 another another DT 19613 8293 14 to to IN 19613 8293 15 the the DT 19613 8293 16 mass mass NN 19613 8293 17 of of IN 19613 8293 18 Christian christian JJ 19613 8293 19 people people NNS 19613 8293 20 . . . 19613 8294 1 The the DT 19613 8294 2 narrow narrow JJ 19613 8294 3 - - HYPH 19613 8294 4 minded minded JJ 19613 8294 5 or or CC 19613 8294 6 the the DT 19613 8294 7 immature immature NN 19613 8294 8 will will MD 19613 8294 9 at at IN 19613 8294 10 all all DT 19613 8294 11 times time NNS 19613 8294 12 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8294 13 consider consider VBP 19613 8294 14 such such JJ 19613 8294 15 proceedings proceeding NNS 19613 8294 16 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 19613 8294 17 , , , 19613 8294 18 but but CC 19613 8294 19 the the DT 19613 8294 20 outcome outcome NN 19613 8294 21 of of IN 19613 8294 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8294 23 religious religious JJ 19613 8294 24 and and CC 19613 8294 25 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8294 26 conception conception NN 19613 8294 27 of of IN 19613 8294 28 the the DT 19613 8294 29 world world NN 19613 8294 30 required require VBD 19613 8294 31 the the DT 19613 8294 32 twofold twofold JJ 19613 8294 33 language language NN 19613 8294 34 . . . 19613 8295 1 Orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 8295 2 theology theology NN 19613 8295 3 of of IN 19613 8295 4 all all DT 19613 8295 5 creeds creed NNS 19613 8295 6 has have VBZ 19613 8295 7 never never RB 19613 8295 8 yet yet RB 19613 8295 9 advanced advance VBN 19613 8295 10 beyond beyond IN 19613 8295 11 the the DT 19613 8295 12 circle circle NN 19613 8295 13 first first RB 19613 8295 14 mapped map VBN 19613 8295 15 out out RP 19613 8295 16 by by IN 19613 8295 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8295 18 mind mind NN 19613 8295 19 . . . 19613 8296 1 She -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 2 has have VBZ 19613 8296 3 suspected suspect VBN 19613 8296 4 and and CC 19613 8296 5 corrected correct VBN 19613 8296 6 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8296 7 founder founder NN 19613 8296 8 , , , 19613 8296 9 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 10 has have VBZ 19613 8296 11 thought think VBN 19613 8296 12 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 13 could could MD 19613 8296 14 lop lop VB 19613 8296 15 off off RP 19613 8296 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8296 17 heterodox heterodox JJ 19613 8296 18 opinions opinion NNS 19613 8296 19 as as IN 19613 8296 20 if if IN 19613 8296 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 22 were be VBD 19613 8296 23 accidental accidental JJ 19613 8296 24 excrescences excrescence NNS 19613 8296 25 , , , 19613 8296 26 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 27 has have VBZ 19613 8296 28 incorporated incorporate VBN 19613 8296 29 with with IN 19613 8296 30 the the DT 19613 8296 31 simple simple JJ 19613 8296 32 faith faith NN 19613 8296 33 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 34 the the DT 19613 8296 35 measure measure NN 19613 8296 36 of of IN 19613 8296 37 speculation speculation NN 19613 8296 38 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 39 was be VBD 19613 8296 40 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8296 41 to to TO 19613 8296 42 admit admit VB 19613 8296 43 , , , 19613 8296 44 and and CC 19613 8296 45 continued continue VBD 19613 8296 46 to to TO 19613 8296 47 give give VB 19613 8296 48 the the DT 19613 8296 49 rule rule NN 19613 8296 50 of of IN 19613 8296 51 faith faith NN 19613 8296 52 a a DT 19613 8296 53 more more RBR 19613 8296 54 philosophic philosophic JJ 19613 8296 55 form form NN 19613 8296 56 , , , 19613 8296 57 fragment fragment NN 19613 8296 58 by by IN 19613 8296 59 fragment fragment NN 19613 8296 60 , , , 19613 8296 61 in in IN 19613 8296 62 order order NN 19613 8296 63 that that IN 19613 8296 64 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8296 65 might may MD 19613 8296 66 thus thus RB 19613 8296 67 be be VB 19613 8296 68 able able JJ 19613 8296 69 to to TO 19613 8296 70 remove remove VB 19613 8296 71 the the DT 19613 8296 72 gap gap NN 19613 8296 73 between between IN 19613 8296 74 Faith Faith NNP 19613 8296 75 and and CC 19613 8296 76 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8296 77 and and CC 19613 8296 78 to to TO 19613 8296 79 banish banish VB 19613 8296 80 free free JJ 19613 8296 81 theology theology NN 19613 8296 82 through through IN 19613 8296 83 the the DT 19613 8296 84 formula formula NN 19613 8296 85 of of IN 19613 8296 86 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8296 87 dogma dogma NN 19613 8296 88 . . . 19613 8297 1 But but CC 19613 8297 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8297 3 may may MD 19613 8297 4 reasonably reasonably RB 19613 8297 5 be be VB 19613 8297 6 questioned question VBN 19613 8297 7 whether whether IN 19613 8297 8 all all PDT 19613 8297 9 this this DT 19613 8297 10 is be VBZ 19613 8297 11 progress progress NN 19613 8297 12 , , , 19613 8297 13 and and CC 19613 8297 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8297 15 is be VBZ 19613 8297 16 well well RB 19613 8297 17 worth worth JJ 19613 8297 18 investigating investigate VBG 19613 8297 19 whether whether IN 19613 8297 20 the the DT 19613 8297 21 gap gap NN 19613 8297 22 between between IN 19613 8297 23 half half NN 19613 8297 24 theological theological JJ 19613 8297 25 , , , 19613 8297 26 clerical clerical JJ 19613 8297 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8297 28 and and CC 19613 8297 29 a a DT 19613 8297 30 lay lie VBN 19613 8297 31 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8297 32 held hold VBN 19613 8297 33 in in IN 19613 8297 34 tutelage tutelage NN 19613 8297 35 is be VBZ 19613 8297 36 more more RBR 19613 8297 37 endurable endurable JJ 19613 8297 38 than than IN 19613 8297 39 that that DT 19613 8297 40 between between IN 19613 8297 41 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8297 42 and and CC 19613 8297 43 Pistis Pistis NNP 19613 8297 44 , , , 19613 8297 45 which which WDT 19613 8297 46 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8297 47 preserved preserve VBD 19613 8297 48 and and CC 19613 8297 49 bridged bridge VBD 19613 8297 50 over over RB 19613 8297 51 . . . 19613 8298 1 The the DT 19613 8298 2 Christian christian JJ 19613 8298 3 system system NN 19613 8298 4 of of IN 19613 8298 5 Origen[682 Origen[682 NNP 19613 8298 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8298 7 is be VBZ 19613 8298 8 worked work VBN 19613 8298 9 out out RP 19613 8298 10 in in IN 19613 8298 11 opposition opposition NN 19613 8298 12 to to IN 19613 8298 13 the the DT 19613 8298 14 systems system NNS 19613 8298 15 of of IN 19613 8298 16 the the DT 19613 8298 17 Greek greek JJ 19613 8298 18 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8298 19 and and CC 19613 8298 20 of of IN 19613 8298 21 the the DT 19613 8298 22 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8298 23 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8298 24 . . . 19613 8299 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8299 2 is be VBZ 19613 8299 3 moreover moreover RB 19613 8299 4 opposed opposed JJ 19613 8299 5 to to IN 19613 8299 6 the the DT 19613 8299 7 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8299 8 enemies enemy NNS 19613 8299 9 of of IN 19613 8299 10 science science NN 19613 8299 11 , , , 19613 8299 12 the the DT 19613 8299 13 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8299 14 Unitarians Unitarians NNPS 19613 8299 15 , , , 19613 8299 16 and and CC 19613 8299 17 the the DT 19613 8299 18 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 8299 19 . . . 19613 8300 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8300 2 683 683 CD 19613 8300 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8300 4 But but CC 19613 8300 5 the the DT 19613 8300 6 science science NN 19613 8300 7 of of IN 19613 8300 8 the the DT 19613 8300 9 faith faith NN 19613 8300 10 , , , 19613 8300 11 as as IN 19613 8300 12 developed develop VBN 19613 8300 13 by by IN 19613 8300 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8300 15 , , , 19613 8300 16 being be VBG 19613 8300 17 built build VBN 19613 8300 18 up up RP 19613 8300 19 with with IN 19613 8300 20 the the DT 19613 8300 21 appliances appliance NNS 19613 8300 22 of of IN 19613 8300 23 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8300 24 's 's POS 19613 8300 25 science science NN 19613 8300 26 , , , 19613 8300 27 bears bear VBZ 19613 8300 28 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 19613 8300 29 marks mark NNS 19613 8300 30 of of IN 19613 8300 31 Neoplatonism Neoplatonism NNP 19613 8300 32 and and CC 19613 8300 33 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 8300 34 . . . 19613 8301 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8301 2 speculated speculate VBD 19613 8301 3 not not RB 19613 8301 4 only only RB 19613 8301 5 in in IN 19613 8301 6 the the DT 19613 8301 7 manner manner NN 19613 8301 8 of of IN 19613 8301 9 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8301 10 , , , 19613 8301 11 but but CC 19613 8301 12 also also RB 19613 8301 13 in in IN 19613 8301 14 that that DT 19613 8301 15 of of IN 19613 8301 16 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8301 17 and and CC 19613 8301 18 therefore therefore RB 19613 8301 19 likewise likewise RB 19613 8301 20 after after IN 19613 8301 21 the the DT 19613 8301 22 fashion fashion NN 19613 8301 23 of of IN 19613 8301 24 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 19613 8301 25 ; ; : 19613 8301 26 in in IN 19613 8301 27 fact fact NN 19613 8301 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8301 29 is be VBZ 19613 8301 30 characterised characterise VBN 19613 8301 31 by by IN 19613 8301 32 the the DT 19613 8301 33 adoption adoption NN 19613 8301 34 of of IN 19613 8301 35 the the DT 19613 8301 36 methods method NNS 19613 8301 37 and and CC 19613 8301 38 , , , 19613 8301 39 in in IN 19613 8301 40 a a DT 19613 8301 41 certain certain JJ 19613 8301 42 sense sense NN 19613 8301 43 , , , 19613 8301 44 of of IN 19613 8301 45 the the DT 19613 8301 46 axioms axiom NNS 19613 8301 47 current current JJ 19613 8301 48 in in IN 19613 8301 49 the the DT 19613 8301 50 schools school NNS 19613 8301 51 of of IN 19613 8301 52 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8301 53 and and CC 19613 8301 54 traceable traceable JJ 19613 8301 55 in in IN 19613 8301 56 Neoplatonism Neoplatonism NNP 19613 8301 57 . . . 19613 8302 1 But but CC 19613 8302 2 , , , 19613 8302 3 as as IN 19613 8302 4 this this DT 19613 8302 5 method method NN 19613 8302 6 implied imply VBD 19613 8302 7 the the DT 19613 8302 8 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 8302 9 of of IN 19613 8302 10 a a DT 19613 8302 11 sacred sacred JJ 19613 8302 12 literature literature NN 19613 8302 13 , , , 19613 8302 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8302 15 was be VBD 19613 8302 16 an an DT 19613 8302 17 exegete exegete NN 19613 8302 18 who who WP 19613 8302 19 believed believe VBD 19613 8302 20 in in IN 19613 8302 21 the the DT 19613 8302 22 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8302 23 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8302 24 and and CC 19613 8302 25 indeed indeed RB 19613 8302 26 , , , 19613 8302 27 at at IN 19613 8302 28 bottom bottom NN 19613 8302 29 , , , 19613 8302 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8302 31 viewed view VBD 19613 8302 32 all all DT 19613 8302 33 theology theology NN 19613 8302 34 as as IN 19613 8302 35 a a DT 19613 8302 36 methodical methodical JJ 19613 8302 37 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8302 38 of of IN 19613 8302 39 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8302 40 Writ Writ NNP 19613 8302 41 . . . 19613 8303 1 Finally finally RB 19613 8303 2 , , , 19613 8303 3 however however RB 19613 8303 4 , , , 19613 8303 5 since since IN 19613 8303 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8303 7 , , , 19613 8303 8 as as IN 19613 8303 9 an an DT 19613 8303 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8303 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8303 12 , , , 19613 8303 13 was be VBD 19613 8303 14 convinced convince VBN 19613 8303 15 that that IN 19613 8303 16 the the DT 19613 8303 17 Church Church NNP 19613 8303 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8303 19 by by IN 19613 8303 20 which which WDT 19613 8303 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8303 22 means mean VBZ 19613 8303 23 only only RB 19613 8303 24 the the DT 19613 8303 25 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8303 26 and and CC 19613 8303 27 pure pure JJ 19613 8303 28 Church Church NNP 19613 8303 29 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8303 30 is be VBZ 19613 8303 31 the the DT 19613 8303 32 sole sole JJ 19613 8303 33 possessor possessor NN 19613 8303 34 of of IN 19613 8303 35 God God NNP 19613 8303 36 's 's POS 19613 8303 37 holy holy JJ 19613 8303 38 revelations revelation NNS 19613 8303 39 with with IN 19613 8303 40 whose whose WP$ 19613 8303 41 authority authority NN 19613 8303 42 the the DT 19613 8303 43 faith faith NN 19613 8303 44 may may MD 19613 8303 45 be be VB 19613 8303 46 justly justly RB 19613 8303 47 satisfied satisfied JJ 19613 8303 48 , , , 19613 8303 49 nothing nothing NN 19613 8303 50 but but IN 19613 8303 51 the the DT 19613 8303 52 two two CD 19613 8303 53 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 8303 54 , , , 19613 8303 55 as as IN 19613 8303 56 preserved preserve VBN 19613 8303 57 by by IN 19613 8303 58 her -PRON- PRP 19613 8303 59 , , , 19613 8303 60 was be VBD 19613 8303 61 regarded regard VBN 19613 8303 62 by by IN 19613 8303 63 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8303 64 as as IN 19613 8303 65 the the DT 19613 8303 66 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 8303 67 reliable reliable JJ 19613 8303 68 divine divine JJ 19613 8303 69 revelation revelation NN 19613 8303 70 . . . 19613 8304 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8304 2 684 684 CD 19613 8304 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8304 4 But but CC 19613 8304 5 , , , 19613 8304 6 in in IN 19613 8304 7 addition addition NN 19613 8304 8 to to IN 19613 8304 9 these these DT 19613 8304 10 , , , 19613 8304 11 every every DT 19613 8304 12 possession possession NN 19613 8304 13 of of IN 19613 8304 14 the the DT 19613 8304 15 Church Church NNP 19613 8304 16 , , , 19613 8304 17 and and CC 19613 8304 18 , , , 19613 8304 19 above above IN 19613 8304 20 all all DT 19613 8304 21 , , , 19613 8304 22 the the DT 19613 8304 23 rule rule NN 19613 8304 24 of of IN 19613 8304 25 faith faith NN 19613 8304 26 , , , 19613 8304 27 was be VBD 19613 8304 28 authoritative authoritative JJ 19613 8304 29 and and CC 19613 8304 30 holy holy JJ 19613 8304 31 . . . 19613 8305 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8305 2 685 685 CD 19613 8305 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8305 4 By by IN 19613 8305 5 acknowledging acknowledge VBG 19613 8305 6 not not RB 19613 8305 7 only only RB 19613 8305 8 the the DT 19613 8305 9 relative relative JJ 19613 8305 10 correctness correctness NN 19613 8305 11 of of IN 19613 8305 12 the the DT 19613 8305 13 beliefs belief NNS 19613 8305 14 held hold VBN 19613 8305 15 by by IN 19613 8305 16 the the DT 19613 8305 17 great great JJ 19613 8305 18 mass mass NN 19613 8305 19 of of IN 19613 8305 20 simple simple JJ 19613 8305 21 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8305 22 , , , 19613 8305 23 as as IN 19613 8305 24 the the DT 19613 8305 25 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 8305 26 did do VBD 19613 8305 27 , , , 19613 8305 28 but but CC 19613 8305 29 also also RB 19613 8305 30 the the DT 19613 8305 31 indispensableness indispensableness NN 19613 8305 32 of of IN 19613 8305 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8305 34 faith faith NN 19613 8305 35 as as IN 19613 8305 36 the the DT 19613 8305 37 foundation foundation NN 19613 8305 38 of of IN 19613 8305 39 speculation speculation NN 19613 8305 40 , , , 19613 8305 41 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8305 42 like like IN 19613 8305 43 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8305 44 avoided avoid VBD 19613 8305 45 the the DT 19613 8305 46 dilemma dilemma NN 19613 8305 47 of of IN 19613 8305 48 becoming become VBG 19613 8305 49 a a DT 19613 8305 50 heterodox heterodox NN 19613 8305 51 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8305 52 or or CC 19613 8305 53 an an DT 19613 8305 54 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8305 55 traditionalist traditionalist NN 19613 8305 56 . . . 19613 8306 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8306 2 was be VBD 19613 8306 3 able able JJ 19613 8306 4 to to TO 19613 8306 5 maintain maintain VB 19613 8306 6 this this DT 19613 8306 7 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 8306 8 , , , 19613 8306 9 because because IN 19613 8306 10 in in IN 19613 8306 11 the the DT 19613 8306 12 first first JJ 19613 8306 13 place place NN 19613 8306 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8306 15 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8306 16 required require VBD 19613 8306 17 a a DT 19613 8306 18 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 8306 19 sacred sacred JJ 19613 8306 20 literature literature NN 19613 8306 21 which which WDT 19613 8306 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8306 23 only only RB 19613 8306 24 found find VBD 19613 8306 25 in in IN 19613 8306 26 the the DT 19613 8306 27 Church Church NNP 19613 8306 28 , , , 19613 8306 29 and and CC 19613 8306 30 because because IN 19613 8306 31 in in IN 19613 8306 32 the the DT 19613 8306 33 second second JJ 19613 8306 34 place place NN 19613 8306 35 this this DT 19613 8306 36 same same JJ 19613 8306 37 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8306 38 had have VBD 19613 8306 39 extended extend VBN 19613 8306 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8306 41 horizon horizon NN 19613 8306 42 far far RB 19613 8306 43 enough enough RB 19613 8306 44 to to TO 19613 8306 45 see see VB 19613 8306 46 that that IN 19613 8306 47 what what WP 19613 8306 48 the the DT 19613 8306 49 heretical heretical JJ 19613 8306 50 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8306 51 had have VBD 19613 8306 52 regarded regard VBN 19613 8306 53 as as IN 19613 8306 54 contrasts contrast NNS 19613 8306 55 were be VBD 19613 8306 56 different different JJ 19613 8306 57 aspects aspect NNS 19613 8306 58 of of IN 19613 8306 59 the the DT 19613 8306 60 same same JJ 19613 8306 61 thing thing NN 19613 8306 62 . . . 19613 8307 1 The the DT 19613 8307 2 relative relative JJ 19613 8307 3 way way NN 19613 8307 4 of of IN 19613 8307 5 looking look VBG 19613 8307 6 at at IN 19613 8307 7 things thing NNS 19613 8307 8 , , , 19613 8307 9 an an DT 19613 8307 10 inheritance inheritance NN 19613 8307 11 from from IN 19613 8307 12 the the DT 19613 8307 13 best good JJS 19613 8307 14 time time NN 19613 8307 15 of of IN 19613 8307 16 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 8307 17 , , , 19613 8307 18 is be VBZ 19613 8307 19 familiar familiar JJ 19613 8307 20 to to IN 19613 8307 21 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8307 22 , , , 19613 8307 23 as as IN 19613 8307 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8307 25 was be VBD 19613 8307 26 to to IN 19613 8307 27 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8307 28 ; ; : 19613 8307 29 and and CC 19613 8307 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8307 31 contrived contrive VBD 19613 8307 32 never never RB 19613 8307 33 to to TO 19613 8307 34 lose lose VB 19613 8307 35 sight sight NN 19613 8307 36 of of IN 19613 8307 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8307 38 , , , 19613 8307 39 in in IN 19613 8307 40 spite spite NN 19613 8307 41 of of IN 19613 8307 42 the the DT 19613 8307 43 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8307 44 attitude attitude NN 19613 8307 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8307 46 had have VBD 19613 8307 47 arrived arrive VBN 19613 8307 48 at at IN 19613 8307 49 through through IN 19613 8307 50 the the DT 19613 8307 51 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8307 52 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8307 53 and and CC 19613 8307 54 the the DT 19613 8307 55 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8307 56 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8307 57 . . . 19613 8308 1 This this DT 19613 8308 2 relative relative JJ 19613 8308 3 view view NN 19613 8308 4 taught teach VBD 19613 8308 5 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8308 6 and and CC 19613 8308 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8308 8 toleration toleration NN 19613 8308 9 and and CC 19613 8308 10 discretion discretion NN 19613 8308 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8308 12 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8308 13 . . . 19613 8309 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8309 2 . . . 19613 8310 1 22 22 CD 19613 8310 2 . . . 19613 8311 1 139 139 CD 19613 8311 2 : : : 19613 8311 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8311 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8311 5 : : : 19613 8311 6 hê hê VB 19613 8311 7 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 8311 8 agapa agapa NNP 19613 8311 9 kai kai NNP 19613 8311 10 tous tous JJ 19613 8311 11 agnoountas agnoountas NNP 19613 8311 12 didaskei didaskei VBZ 19613 8311 13 te te NNP 19613 8311 14 kai kai NNP 19613 8311 15 paideuei paideuei NNP 19613 8311 16 tên tên NNP 19613 8311 17 pasan pasan NNP 19613 8311 18 ktisin ktisin NNP 19613 8311 19 tou tou NNP 19613 8311 20 pantokratoros pantokratoro NNS 19613 8311 21 Theou Theou NNP 19613 8311 22 timan timan NNP 19613 8311 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8311 24 , , , 19613 8311 25 " " `` 19613 8311 26 Gnosis gnosis NN 19613 8311 27 loves love VBZ 19613 8311 28 and and CC 19613 8311 29 instructs instruct VBZ 19613 8311 30 the the DT 19613 8311 31 ignorant ignorant JJ 19613 8311 32 and and CC 19613 8311 33 teaches teach VBZ 19613 8311 34 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8311 35 to to TO 19613 8311 36 honour honour VB 19613 8311 37 the the DT 19613 8311 38 whole whole JJ 19613 8311 39 creation creation NN 19613 8311 40 of of IN 19613 8311 41 God God NNP 19613 8311 42 Almighty Almighty NNP 19613 8311 43 " " '' 19613 8311 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8311 45 ; ; : 19613 8311 46 and and CC 19613 8311 47 enabled enable VBD 19613 8311 48 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8311 49 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8311 50 to to TO 19613 8311 51 discover discover VB 19613 8311 52 , , , 19613 8311 53 hold hold VB 19613 8311 54 fast fast RB 19613 8311 55 , , , 19613 8311 56 and and CC 19613 8311 57 further further RB 19613 8311 58 the the DT 19613 8311 59 good good NN 19613 8311 60 in in IN 19613 8311 61 that that DT 19613 8311 62 which which WDT 19613 8311 63 was be VBD 19613 8311 64 meagre meagre NNP 19613 8311 65 and and CC 19613 8311 66 narrow narrow JJ 19613 8311 67 , , , 19613 8311 68 in in IN 19613 8311 69 that that DT 19613 8311 70 which which WDT 19613 8311 71 was be VBD 19613 8311 72 undeveloped undeveloped JJ 19613 8311 73 and and CC 19613 8311 74 as as IN 19613 8311 75 yet yet RB 19613 8311 76 intrinsically intrinsically RB 19613 8311 77 obscure obscure JJ 19613 8311 78 . . . 19613 8312 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8312 2 686 686 CD 19613 8312 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8312 4 As as IN 19613 8312 5 an an DT 19613 8312 6 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 8312 7 traditionalist traditionalist NN 19613 8312 8 and and CC 19613 8312 9 decided decide VBD 19613 8312 10 opponent opponent NN 19613 8312 11 of of IN 19613 8312 12 all all DT 19613 8312 13 heresy heresy VB 19613 8312 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8312 15 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 19613 8312 16 that that IN 19613 8312 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8312 18 embraces embrace VBZ 19613 8312 19 a a DT 19613 8312 20 salvation salvation NN 19613 8312 21 which which WDT 19613 8312 22 is be VBZ 19613 8312 23 offered offer VBN 19613 8312 24 to to IN 19613 8312 25 all all DT 19613 8312 26 men man NNS 19613 8312 27 and and CC 19613 8312 28 attained attain VBN 19613 8312 29 by by IN 19613 8312 30 faith faith NN 19613 8312 31 , , , 19613 8312 32 that that IN 19613 8312 33 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8312 34 is be VBZ 19613 8312 35 the the DT 19613 8312 36 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8312 37 of of IN 19613 8312 38 historical historical JJ 19613 8312 39 facts fact NNS 19613 8312 40 to to TO 19613 8312 41 which which WDT 19613 8312 42 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8312 43 must must MD 19613 8312 44 adhere adhere VB 19613 8312 45 , , , 19613 8312 46 that that IN 19613 8312 47 the the DT 19613 8312 48 content content NN 19613 8312 49 of of IN 19613 8312 50 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8312 51 has have VBZ 19613 8312 52 been be VBN 19613 8312 53 appropriately appropriately RB 19613 8312 54 summarised summarise VBN 19613 8312 55 by by IN 19613 8312 56 the the DT 19613 8312 57 Church Church NNP 19613 8312 58 in in IN 19613 8312 59 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8312 60 rule rule NN 19613 8312 61 of of IN 19613 8312 62 faith,[687 faith,[687 NN 19613 8312 63 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8312 64 and and CC 19613 8312 65 that that DT 19613 8312 66 belief belief NN 19613 8312 67 is be VBZ 19613 8312 68 of of IN 19613 8312 69 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8312 70 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8312 71 for for IN 19613 8312 72 the the DT 19613 8312 73 renewal renewal NN 19613 8312 74 and and CC 19613 8312 75 salvation salvation NN 19613 8312 76 of of IN 19613 8312 77 man man NN 19613 8312 78 . . . 19613 8313 1 But but CC 19613 8313 2 , , , 19613 8313 3 as as IN 19613 8313 4 an an DT 19613 8313 5 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 8313 6 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 8313 7 , , , 19613 8313 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8313 9 transformed transform VBD 19613 8313 10 the the DT 19613 8313 11 whole whole JJ 19613 8313 12 content content NN 19613 8313 13 of of IN 19613 8313 14 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8313 15 faith faith NN 19613 8313 16 into into IN 19613 8313 17 ideas idea NNS 19613 8313 18 . . . 19613 8314 1 Here here RB 19613 8314 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8314 3 adhered adhere VBD 19613 8314 4 to to IN 19613 8314 5 no no DT 19613 8314 6 fixed fix VBN 19613 8314 7 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8314 8 system system NN 19613 8314 9 , , , 19613 8314 10 but but CC 19613 8314 11 , , , 19613 8314 12 like like IN 19613 8314 13 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8314 14 , , , 19613 8314 15 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8314 16 , , , 19613 8314 17 and and CC 19613 8314 18 the the DT 19613 8314 19 Neoplatonists Neoplatonists NNPS 19613 8314 20 , , , 19613 8314 21 adopted adopt VBN 19613 8314 22 and and CC 19613 8314 23 adapted adapt VBN 19613 8314 24 all all DT 19613 8314 25 that that WDT 19613 8314 26 had have VBD 19613 8314 27 been be VBN 19613 8314 28 effected effect VBN 19613 8314 29 by by IN 19613 8314 30 the the DT 19613 8314 31 labours labour NNS 19613 8314 32 of of IN 19613 8314 33 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 8314 34 Greek greek JJ 19613 8314 35 moralists moralist NNS 19613 8314 36 since since IN 19613 8314 37 the the DT 19613 8314 38 time time NN 19613 8314 39 of of IN 19613 8314 40 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 8314 41 . . . 19613 8315 1 These these DT 19613 8315 2 , , , 19613 8315 3 however however RB 19613 8315 4 , , , 19613 8315 5 had have VBD 19613 8315 6 long long RB 19613 8315 7 before before RB 19613 8315 8 transformed transform VBN 19613 8315 9 the the DT 19613 8315 10 Socratic socratic JJ 19613 8315 11 saying saying NN 19613 8315 12 " " `` 19613 8315 13 know know VB 19613 8315 14 thyself thyself PRP 19613 8315 15 " " '' 19613 8315 16 into into IN 19613 8315 17 manifold manifold JJ 19613 8315 18 rules rule NNS 19613 8315 19 for for IN 19613 8315 20 the the DT 19613 8315 21 right right JJ 19613 8315 22 conduct conduct NN 19613 8315 23 of of IN 19613 8315 24 life life NN 19613 8315 25 , , , 19613 8315 26 and and CC 19613 8315 27 associated associate VBN 19613 8315 28 with with IN 19613 8315 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8315 30 a a DT 19613 8315 31 theosophy theosophy NN 19613 8315 32 , , , 19613 8315 33 in in IN 19613 8315 34 which which WDT 19613 8315 35 man man NN 19613 8315 36 was be VBD 19613 8315 37 first first JJ 19613 8315 38 to to TO 19613 8315 39 attain attain VB 19613 8315 40 to to IN 19613 8315 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8315 42 true true JJ 19613 8315 43 self self NN 19613 8315 44 . . . 19613 8316 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8316 2 688 688 CD 19613 8316 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8316 4 These these DT 19613 8316 5 rules rule NNS 19613 8316 6 made make VBD 19613 8316 7 the the DT 19613 8316 8 true true JJ 19613 8316 9 " " `` 19613 8316 10 sage sage NN 19613 8316 11 " " '' 19613 8316 12 abstain abstain NN 19613 8316 13 from from IN 19613 8316 14 occupying occupy VBG 19613 8316 15 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8316 16 in in IN 19613 8316 17 the the DT 19613 8316 18 service service NN 19613 8316 19 of of IN 19613 8316 20 daily daily JJ 19613 8316 21 life life NN 19613 8316 22 and and CC 19613 8316 23 " " `` 19613 8316 24 from from IN 19613 8316 25 burdensome burdensome JJ 19613 8316 26 appearance appearance NN 19613 8316 27 in in IN 19613 8316 28 public public NNP 19613 8316 29 " " '' 19613 8316 30 . . . 19613 8317 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 8317 2 asserted assert VBD 19613 8317 3 that that IN 19613 8317 4 the the DT 19613 8317 5 mind mind NN 19613 8317 6 " " `` 19613 8317 7 can can MD 19613 8317 8 have have VB 19613 8317 9 no no DT 19613 8317 10 more more RBR 19613 8317 11 peculiar peculiar JJ 19613 8317 12 duty duty NN 19613 8317 13 than than IN 19613 8317 14 caring care VBG 19613 8317 15 for for IN 19613 8317 16 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8317 17 . . . 19613 8317 18 " " '' 19613 8318 1 This this DT 19613 8318 2 is be VBZ 19613 8318 3 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 8318 4 by by IN 19613 8318 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8318 6 not not RB 19613 8318 7 looking look VBG 19613 8318 8 without without IN 19613 8318 9 nor nor CC 19613 8318 10 occupying occupy VBG 19613 8318 11 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8318 12 with with IN 19613 8318 13 foreign foreign JJ 19613 8318 14 things thing NNS 19613 8318 15 , , , 19613 8318 16 but but CC 19613 8318 17 , , , 19613 8318 18 turning turn VBG 19613 8318 19 inwardly inwardly RB 19613 8318 20 to to IN 19613 8318 21 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8318 22 , , , 19613 8318 23 restoring restore VBG 19613 8318 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8318 25 own own JJ 19613 8318 26 nature nature NN 19613 8318 27 to to IN 19613 8318 28 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8318 29 and and CC 19613 8318 30 thus thus RB 19613 8318 31 practising practise VBG 19613 8318 32 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 8318 33 . . . 19613 8319 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8319 2 689 689 CD 19613 8319 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8319 4 Here here RB 19613 8319 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8319 6 was be VBD 19613 8319 7 taught teach VBN 19613 8319 8 that that IN 19613 8319 9 the the DT 19613 8319 10 wise wise JJ 19613 8319 11 man man NN 19613 8319 12 who who WP 19613 8319 13 no no RB 19613 8319 14 longer long RBR 19613 8319 15 requires require VBZ 19613 8319 16 anything anything NN 19613 8319 17 is be VBZ 19613 8319 18 nearest near JJS 19613 8319 19 the the DT 19613 8319 20 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8319 21 , , , 19613 8319 22 because because IN 19613 8319 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8319 24 is be VBZ 19613 8319 25 a a DT 19613 8319 26 partaker partaker NN 19613 8319 27 of of IN 19613 8319 28 the the DT 19613 8319 29 highest high JJS 19613 8319 30 good good NN 19613 8319 31 through through IN 19613 8319 32 possession possession NN 19613 8319 33 of of IN 19613 8319 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8319 35 rich rich JJ 19613 8319 36 Ego Ego NNP 19613 8319 37 and and CC 19613 8319 38 through through IN 19613 8319 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8319 40 calm calm JJ 19613 8319 41 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 8319 42 of of IN 19613 8319 43 the the DT 19613 8319 44 world world NN 19613 8319 45 ; ; : 19613 8319 46 here here RB 19613 8319 47 moreover moreover RB 19613 8319 48 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8319 49 was be VBD 19613 8319 50 proclaimed proclaim VBN 19613 8319 51 that that IN 19613 8319 52 the the DT 19613 8319 53 mind mind NN 19613 8319 54 that that WDT 19613 8319 55 has have VBZ 19613 8319 56 freed free VBN 19613 8319 57 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8319 58 from from IN 19613 8319 59 the the DT 19613 8319 60 sensuous[690 sensuous[690 NN 19613 8319 61 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8319 62 and and CC 19613 8319 63 lives live VBZ 19613 8319 64 in in IN 19613 8319 65 constant constant JJ 19613 8319 66 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 8319 67 of of IN 19613 8319 68 the the DT 19613 8319 69 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8319 70 is be VBZ 19613 8319 71 also also RB 19613 8319 72 in in IN 19613 8319 73 the the DT 19613 8319 74 end end NN 19613 8319 75 vouchsafed vouchsafe VBD 19613 8319 76 a a DT 19613 8319 77 view view NN 19613 8319 78 of of IN 19613 8319 79 the the DT 19613 8319 80 invisible invisible JJ 19613 8319 81 and and CC 19613 8319 82 is be VBZ 19613 8319 83 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8319 84 deified deify VBN 19613 8319 85 . . . 19613 8320 1 No no DT 19613 8320 2 one one NN 19613 8320 3 can can MD 19613 8320 4 deny deny VB 19613 8320 5 that that IN 19613 8320 6 this this DT 19613 8320 7 sort sort NN 19613 8320 8 of of IN 19613 8320 9 flight flight NN 19613 8320 10 from from IN 19613 8320 11 the the DT 19613 8320 12 world world NN 19613 8320 13 and and CC 19613 8320 14 possession possession NN 19613 8320 15 of of IN 19613 8320 16 God God NNP 19613 8320 17 involves involve VBZ 19613 8320 18 a a DT 19613 8320 19 specific specific JJ 19613 8320 20 secularisation secularisation NN 19613 8320 21 of of IN 19613 8320 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8320 23 , , , 19613 8320 24 and and CC 19613 8320 25 that that IN 19613 8320 26 the the DT 19613 8320 27 isolated isolated JJ 19613 8320 28 and and CC 19613 8320 29 self self NN 19613 8320 30 - - HYPH 19613 8320 31 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8320 32 sage sage NN 19613 8320 33 is be VBZ 19613 8320 34 pretty pretty RB 19613 8320 35 much much RB 19613 8320 36 the the DT 19613 8320 37 opposite opposite NN 19613 8320 38 of of IN 19613 8320 39 the the DT 19613 8320 40 poor poor JJ 19613 8320 41 soul soul NN 19613 8320 42 that that WDT 19613 8320 43 hungers hunger NNS 19613 8320 44 after after IN 19613 8320 45 righteousness righteousness NN 19613 8320 46 . . . 19613 8321 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8321 2 691 691 CD 19613 8321 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8321 4 Nor nor CC 19613 8321 5 , , , 19613 8321 6 on on IN 19613 8321 7 the the DT 19613 8321 8 other other JJ 19613 8321 9 hand hand NN 19613 8321 10 , , , 19613 8321 11 can can MD 19613 8321 12 any any DT 19613 8321 13 one one CD 19613 8321 14 deny deny NN 19613 8321 15 that that IN 19613 8321 16 concrete concrete JJ 19613 8321 17 examples example NNS 19613 8321 18 of of IN 19613 8321 19 both both DT 19613 8321 20 types type NNS 19613 8321 21 are be VBP 19613 8321 22 found find VBN 19613 8321 23 in in IN 19613 8321 24 infinite infinite JJ 19613 8321 25 multiplicity multiplicity NN 19613 8321 26 and and CC 19613 8321 27 might may MD 19613 8321 28 shade shade VB 19613 8321 29 off off RP 19613 8321 30 into into IN 19613 8321 31 each each DT 19613 8321 32 other other JJ 19613 8321 33 in in IN 19613 8321 34 this this DT 19613 8321 35 multiplicity multiplicity NN 19613 8321 36 . . . 19613 8322 1 This this DT 19613 8322 2 was be VBD 19613 8322 3 the the DT 19613 8322 4 case case NN 19613 8322 5 with with IN 19613 8322 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8322 7 and and CC 19613 8322 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8322 9 . . . 19613 8323 1 To to IN 19613 8323 2 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8323 3 the the DT 19613 8323 4 ethical ethical JJ 19613 8323 5 and and CC 19613 8323 6 religious religious JJ 19613 8323 7 ideal ideal NN 19613 8323 8 is be VBZ 19613 8323 9 the the DT 19613 8323 10 state state NN 19613 8323 11 without without IN 19613 8323 12 sorrow sorrow NN 19613 8323 13 , , , 19613 8323 14 the the DT 19613 8323 15 state state NN 19613 8323 16 of of IN 19613 8323 17 insensibility insensibility NN 19613 8323 18 to to IN 19613 8323 19 all all DT 19613 8323 20 evils evil NNS 19613 8323 21 , , , 19613 8323 22 of of IN 19613 8323 23 order order NN 19613 8323 24 and and CC 19613 8323 25 peace peace NN 19613 8323 26 -- -- : 19613 8323 27 but but CC 19613 8323 28 peace peace NN 19613 8323 29 in in IN 19613 8323 30 God God NNP 19613 8323 31 . . . 19613 8324 1 Reconciled reconcile VBN 19613 8324 2 to to IN 19613 8324 3 the the DT 19613 8324 4 course course NN 19613 8324 5 of of IN 19613 8324 6 the the DT 19613 8324 7 world world NN 19613 8324 8 , , , 19613 8324 9 trusting trust VBG 19613 8324 10 in in IN 19613 8324 11 the the DT 19613 8324 12 divine divine JJ 19613 8324 13 Logos,[692 logos,[692 NN 19613 8324 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8324 15 rich rich JJ 19613 8324 16 in in IN 19613 8324 17 disinterested disinterested JJ 19613 8324 18 love love NN 19613 8324 19 to to IN 19613 8324 20 God God NNP 19613 8324 21 and and CC 19613 8324 22 the the DT 19613 8324 23 brethren brother NNS 19613 8324 24 , , , 19613 8324 25 reproducing reproduce VBG 19613 8324 26 the the DT 19613 8324 27 divine divine JJ 19613 8324 28 thoughts thought NNS 19613 8324 29 , , , 19613 8324 30 looking look VBG 19613 8324 31 up up RP 19613 8324 32 with with IN 19613 8324 33 longing longing NN 19613 8324 34 to to IN 19613 8324 35 heaven heaven VB 19613 8324 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8324 37 native native JJ 19613 8324 38 city,[693 city,[693 NN 19613 8324 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8324 40 the the DT 19613 8324 41 created create VBN 19613 8324 42 spirit spirit NN 19613 8324 43 attains attain VBZ 19613 8324 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8324 45 likeness likeness NN 19613 8324 46 to to IN 19613 8324 47 God God NNP 19613 8324 48 and and CC 19613 8324 49 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8324 50 bliss bliss NN 19613 8324 51 . . . 19613 8325 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8325 2 reaches reach VBZ 19613 8325 3 this this DT 19613 8325 4 by by IN 19613 8325 5 the the DT 19613 8325 6 victory victory NN 19613 8325 7 over over IN 19613 8325 8 sensuousness sensuousness JJ 19613 8325 9 , , , 19613 8325 10 by by IN 19613 8325 11 constantly constantly RB 19613 8325 12 occupying occupy VBG 19613 8325 13 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8325 14 with with IN 19613 8325 15 the the DT 19613 8325 16 divine--"Go divine--"go NN 19613 8325 17 ye ye NNP 19613 8325 18 believing believe VBG 19613 8325 19 thoughts thought NNS 19613 8325 20 into into IN 19613 8325 21 the the DT 19613 8325 22 wide wide JJ 19613 8325 23 field field NN 19613 8325 24 of of IN 19613 8325 25 eternity"--by eternity"--by NN 19613 8325 26 self self NN 19613 8325 27 - - HYPH 19613 8325 28 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8325 29 and and CC 19613 8325 30 contemplative contemplative JJ 19613 8325 31 isolation isolation NN 19613 8325 32 , , , 19613 8325 33 which which WDT 19613 8325 34 , , , 19613 8325 35 however however RB 19613 8325 36 , , , 19613 8325 37 does do VBZ 19613 8325 38 not not RB 19613 8325 39 exclude exclude VB 19613 8325 40 work work NN 19613 8325 41 in in IN 19613 8325 42 the the DT 19613 8325 43 kingdom kingdom NN 19613 8325 44 of of IN 19613 8325 45 God God NNP 19613 8325 46 , , , 19613 8325 47 that that DT 19613 8325 48 is be VBZ 19613 8325 49 in in IN 19613 8325 50 the the DT 19613 8325 51 Church Church NNP 19613 8325 52 . . . 19613 8326 1 This this DT 19613 8326 2 is be VBZ 19613 8326 3 the the DT 19613 8326 4 divine divine JJ 19613 8326 5 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8326 6 : : : 19613 8326 7 " " `` 19613 8326 8 The the DT 19613 8326 9 soul soul NN 19613 8326 10 practises practise VBZ 19613 8326 11 viewing view VBG 19613 8326 12 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 8326 13 as as IN 19613 8326 14 in in IN 19613 8326 15 a a DT 19613 8326 16 mirror mirror NN 19613 8326 17 : : : 19613 8326 18 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8326 19 displays display VBZ 19613 8326 20 the the DT 19613 8326 21 divine divine JJ 19613 8326 22 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8326 23 in in IN 19613 8326 24 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 8326 25 as as IN 19613 8326 26 in in IN 19613 8326 27 a a DT 19613 8326 28 mirror mirror NN 19613 8326 29 , , , 19613 8326 30 if if IN 19613 8326 31 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8326 32 is be VBZ 19613 8326 33 to to TO 19613 8326 34 be be VB 19613 8326 35 found find VBN 19613 8326 36 worthy worthy JJ 19613 8326 37 of of IN 19613 8326 38 this this DT 19613 8326 39 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 8326 40 ; ; : 19613 8326 41 and and CC 19613 8326 42 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8326 43 thus thus RB 19613 8326 44 discovers discover VBZ 19613 8326 45 the the DT 19613 8326 46 traces trace NNS 19613 8326 47 of of IN 19613 8326 48 a a DT 19613 8326 49 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 8326 50 way way NN 19613 8326 51 to to IN 19613 8326 52 deification deification NN 19613 8326 53 . . . 19613 8327 1 " " `` 19613 8327 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8327 3 694 694 CD 19613 8327 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8327 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8327 6 employed employ VBD 19613 8327 7 the the DT 19613 8327 8 Stoic Stoic NNP 19613 8327 9 and and CC 19613 8327 10 Platonic Platonic NNP 19613 8327 11 systems system NNS 19613 8327 12 of of IN 19613 8327 13 ethics ethic NNS 19613 8327 14 as as IN 19613 8327 15 an an DT 19613 8327 16 instrument instrument NN 19613 8327 17 for for IN 19613 8327 18 the the DT 19613 8327 19 gradual gradual JJ 19613 8327 20 realisation realisation NN 19613 8327 21 of of IN 19613 8327 22 this this DT 19613 8327 23 ideal ideal NN 19613 8327 24 . . . 19613 8328 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8328 2 695 695 CD 19613 8328 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8328 4 With with IN 19613 8328 5 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8328 6 the the DT 19613 8328 7 mystic mystic JJ 19613 8328 8 and and CC 19613 8328 9 ecstatic ecstatic JJ 19613 8328 10 as as RB 19613 8328 11 well well RB 19613 8328 12 as as IN 19613 8328 13 the the DT 19613 8328 14 magic magic JJ 19613 8328 15 and and CC 19613 8328 16 sacramental sacramental JJ 19613 8328 17 element element NN 19613 8328 18 is be VBZ 19613 8328 19 still still RB 19613 8328 20 in in IN 19613 8328 21 the the DT 19613 8328 22 background background NN 19613 8328 23 , , , 19613 8328 24 though though IN 19613 8328 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8328 26 is be VBZ 19613 8328 27 not not RB 19613 8328 28 wanting want VBG 19613 8328 29 . . . 19613 8329 1 To to IN 19613 8329 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8329 3 's 's POS 19613 8329 4 mind mind NN 19613 8329 5 , , , 19613 8329 6 however however RB 19613 8329 7 , , , 19613 8329 8 the the DT 19613 8329 9 inadequacy inadequacy NN 19613 8329 10 of of IN 19613 8329 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8329 12 injunctions injunction NNS 19613 8329 13 was be VBD 19613 8329 14 constantly constantly RB 19613 8329 15 made make VBN 19613 8329 16 plain plain JJ 19613 8329 17 by by IN 19613 8329 18 the the DT 19613 8329 19 following follow VBG 19613 8329 20 considerations consideration NNS 19613 8329 21 . . . 19613 8330 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8330 2 1 1 LS 19613 8330 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8330 4 The the DT 19613 8330 5 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8330 6 , , , 19613 8330 7 in in IN 19613 8330 8 spite spite NN 19613 8330 9 of of IN 19613 8330 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8330 11 noble noble JJ 19613 8330 12 thoughts thought NNS 19613 8330 13 of of IN 19613 8330 14 God God NNP 19613 8330 15 , , , 19613 8330 16 tolerated tolerate VBD 19613 8330 17 the the DT 19613 8330 18 existence existence NN 19613 8330 19 of of IN 19613 8330 20 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 8330 21 ; ; , 19613 8330 22 and and CC 19613 8330 23 this this DT 19613 8330 24 was be VBD 19613 8330 25 really really RB 19613 8330 26 the the DT 19613 8330 27 only only JJ 19613 8330 28 fault fault NN 19613 8330 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8330 30 had have VBD 19613 8330 31 to to TO 19613 8330 32 find find VB 19613 8330 33 with with IN 19613 8330 34 Plato Plato NNP 19613 8330 35 . . . 19613 8331 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8331 2 2 2 LS 19613 8331 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8331 4 The the DT 19613 8331 5 truth truth NN 19613 8331 6 did do VBD 19613 8331 7 not not RB 19613 8331 8 become become VB 19613 8331 9 universally universally RB 19613 8331 10 accessible accessible JJ 19613 8331 11 through through IN 19613 8331 12 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8331 13 . . . 19613 8332 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8332 2 696 696 CD 19613 8332 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8332 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8332 5 3 3 LS 19613 8332 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8332 7 As as IN 19613 8332 8 the the DT 19613 8332 9 result result NN 19613 8332 10 of of IN 19613 8332 11 these these DT 19613 8332 12 facts fact NNS 19613 8332 13 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8332 14 did do VBD 19613 8332 15 not not RB 19613 8332 16 possess possess VB 19613 8332 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8332 18 power power NN 19613 8332 19 . . . 19613 8333 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8333 2 697 697 CD 19613 8333 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8333 4 In in IN 19613 8333 5 contrast contrast NN 19613 8333 6 to to IN 19613 8333 7 this this DT 19613 8333 8 the the DT 19613 8333 9 divine divine JJ 19613 8333 10 revelation revelation NN 19613 8333 11 had have VBD 19613 8333 12 already already RB 19613 8333 13 mastered master VBN 19613 8333 14 a a DT 19613 8333 15 whole whole JJ 19613 8333 16 people people NNS 19613 8333 17 through through IN 19613 8333 18 Moses--"Would Moses--"Would NNP 19613 8333 19 to to IN 19613 8333 20 God God NNP 19613 8333 21 the the DT 19613 8333 22 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 8333 23 had have VBD 19613 8333 24 not not RB 19613 8333 25 transgressed transgress VBN 19613 8333 26 the the DT 19613 8333 27 law law NN 19613 8333 28 , , , 19613 8333 29 and and CC 19613 8333 30 had have VBD 19613 8333 31 not not RB 19613 8333 32 slain slay VBN 19613 8333 33 the the DT 19613 8333 34 prophets prophet NNS 19613 8333 35 and and CC 19613 8333 36 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8333 37 ; ; : 19613 8333 38 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8333 39 would would MD 19613 8333 40 then then RB 19613 8333 41 have have VB 19613 8333 42 had have VBN 19613 8333 43 a a DT 19613 8333 44 model model NN 19613 8333 45 of of IN 19613 8333 46 that that DT 19613 8333 47 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 8333 48 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 8333 49 which which WDT 19613 8333 50 Plato Plato NNP 19613 8333 51 has have VBZ 19613 8333 52 sought seek VBN 19613 8333 53 to to IN 19613 8333 54 describe"[698]--and describe"[698]--and NNP 19613 8333 55 the the DT 19613 8333 56 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8333 57 shows show VBZ 19613 8333 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8333 59 universal universal JJ 19613 8333 60 power power NN 19613 8333 61 in in IN 19613 8333 62 the the DT 19613 8333 63 Church Church NNP 19613 8333 64 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8333 65 1 1 CD 19613 8333 66 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8333 67 by by IN 19613 8333 68 putting put VBG 19613 8333 69 an an DT 19613 8333 70 end end NN 19613 8333 71 to to IN 19613 8333 72 all all DT 19613 8333 73 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 8333 74 , , , 19613 8333 75 and and CC 19613 8333 76 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8333 77 2 2 LS 19613 8333 78 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8333 79 by by IN 19613 8333 80 improving improve VBG 19613 8333 81 everyone everyone NN 19613 8333 82 to to IN 19613 8333 83 the the DT 19613 8333 84 extent extent NN 19613 8333 85 that that IN 19613 8333 86 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8333 87 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8333 88 and and CC 19613 8333 89 capacity capacity NN 19613 8333 90 admit admit NN 19613 8333 91 , , , 19613 8333 92 and and CC 19613 8333 93 in in IN 19613 8333 94 proportion proportion NN 19613 8333 95 as as IN 19613 8333 96 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8333 97 will will NN 19613 8333 98 is be VBZ 19613 8333 99 inclined inclined JJ 19613 8333 100 to to IN 19613 8333 101 , , , 19613 8333 102 and and CC 19613 8333 103 susceptible susceptible JJ 19613 8333 104 of of IN 19613 8333 105 , , , 19613 8333 106 that that WDT 19613 8333 107 which which WDT 19613 8333 108 is be VBZ 19613 8333 109 good good JJ 19613 8333 110 . . . 19613 8334 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8334 2 699 699 CD 19613 8334 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8334 4 Not not RB 19613 8334 5 only only RB 19613 8334 6 , , , 19613 8334 7 however however RB 19613 8334 8 , , , 19613 8334 9 did do VBD 19613 8334 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8334 11 employ employ VB 19613 8334 12 the the DT 19613 8334 13 Greek greek JJ 19613 8334 14 ethic ethic NN 19613 8334 15 in in IN 19613 8334 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8334 17 varied varied JJ 19613 8334 18 types type NNS 19613 8334 19 , , , 19613 8334 20 but but CC 19613 8334 21 the the DT 19613 8334 22 Greek greek JJ 19613 8334 23 cosmological cosmological JJ 19613 8334 24 speculation speculation NN 19613 8334 25 also also RB 19613 8334 26 formed form VBD 19613 8334 27 the the DT 19613 8334 28 complicated complicated JJ 19613 8334 29 substructure substructure NN 19613 8334 30 of of IN 19613 8334 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8334 32 religious religious JJ 19613 8334 33 system system NN 19613 8334 34 of of IN 19613 8334 35 morals moral NNS 19613 8334 36 . . . 19613 8335 1 The the DT 19613 8335 2 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8335 3 is be VBZ 19613 8335 4 formally formally RB 19613 8335 5 a a DT 19613 8335 6 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8335 7 of of IN 19613 8335 8 revelation revelation NN 19613 8335 9 , , , 19613 8335 10 that that DT 19613 8335 11 is be VBZ 19613 8335 12 a a DT 19613 8335 13 Scripture scripture NN 19613 8335 14 theology,[700 theology,[700 NN 19613 8335 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8335 16 and and CC 19613 8335 17 materially materially RB 19613 8335 18 a a DT 19613 8335 19 cosmological cosmological JJ 19613 8335 20 speculation speculation NN 19613 8335 21 . . . 19613 8336 1 On on IN 19613 8336 2 the the DT 19613 8336 3 basis basis NN 19613 8336 4 of of IN 19613 8336 5 a a DT 19613 8336 6 detailed detailed JJ 19613 8336 7 theory theory NN 19613 8336 8 of of IN 19613 8336 9 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 8336 10 , , , 19613 8336 11 which which WDT 19613 8336 12 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8336 13 , , , 19613 8336 14 moreover moreover RB 19613 8336 15 , , , 19613 8336 16 originates originate VBZ 19613 8336 17 with with IN 19613 8336 18 the the DT 19613 8336 19 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8336 20 , , , 19613 8336 21 the the DT 19613 8336 22 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8336 23 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8336 24 are be VBP 19613 8336 25 so so RB 19613 8336 26 treated treat VBN 19613 8336 27 that that IN 19613 8336 28 all all DT 19613 8336 29 facts fact NNS 19613 8336 30 appear appear VBP 19613 8336 31 as as IN 19613 8336 32 the the DT 19613 8336 33 vehicles vehicle NNS 19613 8336 34 of of IN 19613 8336 35 ideas idea NNS 19613 8336 36 and and CC 19613 8336 37 only only RB 19613 8336 38 attain attain VBP 19613 8336 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8336 40 highest high JJS 19613 8336 41 value value NN 19613 8336 42 in in IN 19613 8336 43 this this DT 19613 8336 44 aspect aspect NN 19613 8336 45 . . . 19613 8337 1 Systematic systematic JJ 19613 8337 2 theology theology NN 19613 8337 3 , , , 19613 8337 4 in in IN 19613 8337 5 undertaking undertake VBG 19613 8337 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8337 7 task task NN 19613 8337 8 , , , 19613 8337 9 always always RB 19613 8337 10 starts start VBZ 19613 8337 11 , , , 19613 8337 12 as as IN 19613 8337 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8337 14 and and CC 19613 8337 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8337 16 also also RB 19613 8337 17 did do VBD 19613 8337 18 , , , 19613 8337 19 with with IN 19613 8337 20 the the DT 19613 8337 21 conscious conscious JJ 19613 8337 22 or or CC 19613 8337 23 unconscious unconscious JJ 19613 8337 24 thought thought NN 19613 8337 25 of of IN 19613 8337 26 emancipating emancipate VBG 19613 8337 27 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8337 28 from from IN 19613 8337 29 the the DT 19613 8337 30 outward outward JJ 19613 8337 31 revelation revelation NN 19613 8337 32 and and CC 19613 8337 33 community community NN 19613 8337 34 of of IN 19613 8337 35 cultus cultus NN 19613 8337 36 that that WDT 19613 8337 37 are be VBP 19613 8337 38 the the DT 19613 8337 39 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 8337 40 marks mark NNS 19613 8337 41 of of IN 19613 8337 42 positive positive JJ 19613 8337 43 religion religion NN 19613 8337 44 . . . 19613 8338 1 The the DT 19613 8338 2 place place NN 19613 8338 3 of of IN 19613 8338 4 these these DT 19613 8338 5 is be VBZ 19613 8338 6 taken take VBN 19613 8338 7 by by IN 19613 8338 8 the the DT 19613 8338 9 results result NNS 19613 8338 10 of of IN 19613 8338 11 speculative speculative JJ 19613 8338 12 cosmology cosmology NN 19613 8338 13 , , , 19613 8338 14 which which WDT 19613 8338 15 , , , 19613 8338 16 though though IN 19613 8338 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8338 18 practically practically RB 19613 8338 19 conditioned condition VBN 19613 8338 20 , , , 19613 8338 21 do do VBP 19613 8338 22 not not RB 19613 8338 23 seem seem VB 19613 8338 24 to to TO 19613 8338 25 be be VB 19613 8338 26 of of IN 19613 8338 27 this this DT 19613 8338 28 character character NN 19613 8338 29 . . . 19613 8339 1 This this DT 19613 8339 2 also also RB 19613 8339 3 applies apply VBZ 19613 8339 4 to to IN 19613 8339 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8339 6 's 's POS 19613 8339 7 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8339 8 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8339 9 or or CC 19613 8339 10 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8339 11 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8339 12 , , , 19613 8339 13 which which WDT 19613 8339 14 is be VBZ 19613 8339 15 simply simply RB 19613 8339 16 the the DT 19613 8339 17 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 19613 8339 18 of of IN 19613 8339 19 the the DT 19613 8339 20 age age NN 19613 8339 21 . . . 19613 8340 1 However however RB 19613 8340 2 , , , 19613 8340 3 as as IN 19613 8340 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8340 5 was be VBD 19613 8340 6 the the DT 19613 8340 7 equal equal JJ 19613 8340 8 of of IN 19613 8340 9 the the DT 19613 8340 10 foremost foremost JJ 19613 8340 11 minds mind NNS 19613 8340 12 of of IN 19613 8340 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8340 14 time time NN 19613 8340 15 , , , 19613 8340 16 this this DT 19613 8340 17 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8340 18 was be VBD 19613 8340 19 no no DT 19613 8340 20 schoolboy schoolboy NN 19613 8340 21 imitation imitation NN 19613 8340 22 on on IN 19613 8340 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8340 24 part part NN 19613 8340 25 , , , 19613 8340 26 but but CC 19613 8340 27 was be VBD 19613 8340 28 to to IN 19613 8340 29 some some DT 19613 8340 30 extent extent NN 19613 8340 31 independently independently RB 19613 8340 32 developed develop VBN 19613 8340 33 and and CC 19613 8340 34 was be VBD 19613 8340 35 worked work VBN 19613 8340 36 out out RP 19613 8340 37 both both CC 19613 8340 38 in in IN 19613 8340 39 opposition opposition NN 19613 8340 40 to to IN 19613 8340 41 pantheistic pantheistic JJ 19613 8340 42 Stoicism Stoicism NNP 19613 8340 43 and and CC 19613 8340 44 to to IN 19613 8340 45 theoretical theoretical JJ 19613 8340 46 dualism dualism NN 19613 8340 47 . . . 19613 8341 1 That that IN 19613 8341 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8341 3 are be VBP 19613 8341 4 not not RB 19613 8341 5 mistaken mistake VBN 19613 8341 6 in in IN 19613 8341 7 this this DT 19613 8341 8 opinion opinion NN 19613 8341 9 is be VBZ 19613 8341 10 shown show VBN 19613 8341 11 by by IN 19613 8341 12 a a DT 19613 8341 13 document document NN 19613 8341 14 ranking rank VBG 19613 8341 15 among among IN 19613 8341 16 the the DT 19613 8341 17 most most RBS 19613 8341 18 valuable valuable JJ 19613 8341 19 things thing NNS 19613 8341 20 preserved preserve VBN 19613 8341 21 to to IN 19613 8341 22 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8341 23 from from IN 19613 8341 24 the the DT 19613 8341 25 third third JJ 19613 8341 26 century century NN 19613 8341 27 ; ; : 19613 8341 28 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8341 29 mean mean VBP 19613 8341 30 the the DT 19613 8341 31 judgment judgment NN 19613 8341 32 passed pass VBN 19613 8341 33 on on IN 19613 8341 34 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8341 35 by by IN 19613 8341 36 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 8341 37 in in IN 19613 8341 38 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 8341 39 . . NNP 19613 8341 40 , , , 19613 8341 41 H. H. NNP 19613 8341 42 E. E. NNP 19613 8341 43 VI VI NNP 19613 8341 44 . . . 19613 8342 1 19 19 CD 19613 8342 2 . . . 19613 8343 1 Every every DT 19613 8343 2 sentence sentence NN 19613 8343 3 is be VBZ 19613 8343 4 instructive,[701 instructive,[701 JJ 19613 8343 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8343 6 but but CC 19613 8343 7 the the DT 19613 8343 8 culminating culminate VBG 19613 8343 9 point point NN 19613 8343 10 is be VBZ 19613 8343 11 the the DT 19613 8343 12 judgment judgment NN 19613 8343 13 contained contain VBN 19613 8343 14 in in IN 19613 8343 15 § § CD 19613 8343 16 7 7 CD 19613 8343 17 : : : 19613 8343 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8343 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8343 20 : : : 19613 8343 21 kata kata NNP 19613 8343 22 men man NNS 19613 8343 23 ton ton VB 19613 8343 24 Bion Bion NNP 19613 8343 25 Christianôs Christianôs NNP 19613 8343 26 zôn zôn NNP 19613 8343 27 kai kai NNP 19613 8343 28 paranomôs paranomôs NNP 19613 8343 29 , , , 19613 8343 30 kata kata NNP 19613 8343 31 de de NNP 19613 8343 32 tas tas NNP 19613 8343 33 peri peri NNP 19613 8343 34 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8343 35 pragmatôn pragmatôn NNP 19613 8343 36 kai kai NNP 19613 8343 37 tou tou NNP 19613 8343 38 theou theou NNP 19613 8343 39 doxas doxas NNP 19613 8343 40 Hellênizôn Hellênizôn NNP 19613 8343 41 kai kai NNP 19613 8343 42 ta ta NNP 19613 8343 43 Hellênôn Hellênôn NNP 19613 8343 44 tois tois NNP 19613 8343 45 othneiois othneiois NNP 19613 8343 46 hupoballomenos hupoballomenos NNP 19613 8343 47 mythois mythois NNP 19613 8343 48 . . . 19613 8343 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8344 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8344 2 " " `` 19613 8344 3 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8344 4 outward outward JJ 19613 8344 5 life life NN 19613 8344 6 was be VBD 19613 8344 7 that that DT 19613 8344 8 of of IN 19613 8344 9 a a DT 19613 8344 10 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8344 11 and and CC 19613 8344 12 opposed oppose VBN 19613 8344 13 to to IN 19613 8344 14 the the DT 19613 8344 15 law law NN 19613 8344 16 , , , 19613 8344 17 but but CC 19613 8344 18 in in IN 19613 8344 19 regard regard NN 19613 8344 20 to to IN 19613 8344 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8344 22 views view NNS 19613 8344 23 of of IN 19613 8344 24 things thing NNS 19613 8344 25 and and CC 19613 8344 26 of of IN 19613 8344 27 the the DT 19613 8344 28 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8344 29 , , , 19613 8344 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8344 31 thought think VBD 19613 8344 32 like like IN 19613 8344 33 the the DT 19613 8344 34 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 8344 35 , , , 19613 8344 36 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 8344 37 as as IN 19613 8344 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8344 39 introduced introduce VBD 19613 8344 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8344 41 ideas idea NNS 19613 8344 42 into into IN 19613 8344 43 the the DT 19613 8344 44 myths myth NNS 19613 8344 45 of of IN 19613 8344 46 other other JJ 19613 8344 47 peoples people NNS 19613 8344 48 . . . 19613 8344 49 " " '' 19613 8344 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8345 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8345 2 can can MD 19613 8345 3 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8345 4 verify verify VB 19613 8345 5 this this DT 19613 8345 6 observation observation NN 19613 8345 7 from from IN 19613 8345 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8345 9 's 's POS 19613 8345 10 works work NNS 19613 8345 11 and and CC 19613 8345 12 particularly particularly RB 19613 8345 13 from from IN 19613 8345 14 the the DT 19613 8345 15 books book NNS 19613 8345 16 written write VBN 19613 8345 17 against against IN 19613 8345 18 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8345 19 , , , 19613 8345 20 where where WRB 19613 8345 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8345 22 is be VBZ 19613 8345 23 continually continually RB 19613 8345 24 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8345 25 to to TO 19613 8345 26 mask mask VB 19613 8345 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8345 28 essential essential JJ 19613 8345 29 agreement agreement NN 19613 8345 30 in in IN 19613 8345 31 principles principle NNS 19613 8345 32 and and CC 19613 8345 33 method method NN 19613 8345 34 with with IN 19613 8345 35 the the DT 19613 8345 36 enemy enemy NN 19613 8345 37 of of IN 19613 8345 38 the the DT 19613 8345 39 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8345 40 . . . 19613 8346 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8346 2 702 702 CD 19613 8346 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8346 4 The the DT 19613 8346 5 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8346 6 is be VBZ 19613 8346 7 in in IN 19613 8346 8 fact fact NN 19613 8346 9 the the DT 19613 8346 10 Hellenic Hellenic NNP 19613 8346 11 one one NN 19613 8346 12 and and CC 19613 8346 13 results result NNS 19613 8346 14 in in IN 19613 8346 15 that that DT 19613 8346 16 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 8346 17 picture picture NN 19613 8346 18 of of IN 19613 8346 19 the the DT 19613 8346 20 world world NN 19613 8346 21 which which WDT 19613 8346 22 , , , 19613 8346 23 though though IN 19613 8346 24 apparently apparently RB 19613 8346 25 a a DT 19613 8346 26 drama drama NN 19613 8346 27 , , , 19613 8346 28 is be VBZ 19613 8346 29 in in IN 19613 8346 30 reality reality NN 19613 8346 31 immovable immovable JJ 19613 8346 32 , , , 19613 8346 33 and and CC 19613 8346 34 only only RB 19613 8346 35 assumes assume VBZ 19613 8346 36 such such PDT 19613 8346 37 a a DT 19613 8346 38 complicated complicated JJ 19613 8346 39 form form NN 19613 8346 40 here here RB 19613 8346 41 from from IN 19613 8346 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8346 43 relation relation NN 19613 8346 44 to to IN 19613 8346 45 the the DT 19613 8346 46 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8346 47 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8346 48 and and CC 19613 8346 49 the the DT 19613 8346 50 history history NN 19613 8346 51 of of IN 19613 8346 52 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8346 53 . . . 19613 8347 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8347 2 703 703 CD 19613 8347 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8347 4 The the DT 19613 8347 5 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8347 6 neutralises neutralise VBZ 19613 8347 7 everything everything NN 19613 8347 8 connected connect VBN 19613 8347 9 with with IN 19613 8347 10 empiric empiric NN 19613 8347 11 history history NN 19613 8347 12 ; ; , 19613 8347 13 and and CC 19613 8347 14 if if IN 19613 8347 15 this this DT 19613 8347 16 does do VBZ 19613 8347 17 not not RB 19613 8347 18 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8347 19 hold hold VB 19613 8347 20 good good JJ 19613 8347 21 with with IN 19613 8347 22 regard regard NN 19613 8347 23 to to IN 19613 8347 24 the the DT 19613 8347 25 actual actual JJ 19613 8347 26 occurrence occurrence NN 19613 8347 27 of of IN 19613 8347 28 facts fact NNS 19613 8347 29 , , , 19613 8347 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8347 31 is be VBZ 19613 8347 32 at at IN 19613 8347 33 least least JJS 19613 8347 34 invariably invariably RB 19613 8347 35 the the DT 19613 8347 36 case case NN 19613 8347 37 in in IN 19613 8347 38 respect respect NN 19613 8347 39 to to IN 19613 8347 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8347 41 significance significance NN 19613 8347 42 . . . 19613 8348 1 The the DT 19613 8348 2 clearest clear JJS 19613 8348 3 proof proof NN 19613 8348 4 of of IN 19613 8348 5 this this DT 19613 8348 6 is be VBZ 19613 8348 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8348 8 1 1 LS 19613 8348 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8348 10 that that IN 19613 8348 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8348 12 raised raise VBD 19613 8348 13 the the DT 19613 8348 14 thought thought NN 19613 8348 15 of of IN 19613 8348 16 the the DT 19613 8348 17 unchangeability unchangeability NN 19613 8348 18 of of IN 19613 8348 19 God God NNP 19613 8348 20 to to TO 19613 8348 21 be be VB 19613 8348 22 the the DT 19613 8348 23 norm norm NN 19613 8348 24 of of IN 19613 8348 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8348 26 system system NN 19613 8348 27 and and CC 19613 8348 28 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8348 29 2 2 LS 19613 8348 30 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8348 31 that that IN 19613 8348 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8348 33 denied deny VBD 19613 8348 34 the the DT 19613 8348 35 historical historical JJ 19613 8348 36 , , , 19613 8348 37 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 8348 38 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8348 39 any any DT 19613 8348 40 significance significance NN 19613 8348 41 for for IN 19613 8348 42 " " `` 19613 8348 43 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8348 44 . . . 19613 8348 45 " " '' 19613 8349 1 To to IN 19613 8349 2 these these DT 19613 8349 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8349 4 merely merely RB 19613 8349 5 appears appear VBZ 19613 8349 6 as as IN 19613 8349 7 the the DT 19613 8349 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8349 9 who who WP 19613 8349 10 has have VBZ 19613 8349 11 been be VBN 19613 8349 12 from from IN 19613 8349 13 eternity eternity NN 19613 8349 14 with with IN 19613 8349 15 the the DT 19613 8349 16 Father Father NNP 19613 8349 17 and and CC 19613 8349 18 has have VBZ 19613 8349 19 always always RB 19613 8349 20 acted act VBN 19613 8349 21 from from IN 19613 8349 22 the the DT 19613 8349 23 beginning beginning NN 19613 8349 24 . . . 19613 8350 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8350 2 alone alone RB 19613 8350 3 is be VBZ 19613 8350 4 the the DT 19613 8350 5 object object NN 19613 8350 6 of of IN 19613 8350 7 the the DT 19613 8350 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8350 9 of of IN 19613 8350 10 the the DT 19613 8350 11 wise wise JJ 19613 8350 12 man man NN 19613 8350 13 , , , 19613 8350 14 who who WP 19613 8350 15 merely merely RB 19613 8350 16 requires require VBZ 19613 8350 17 a a DT 19613 8350 18 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8350 19 or or CC 19613 8350 20 , , , 19613 8350 21 in in IN 19613 8350 22 other other JJ 19613 8350 23 words word NNS 19613 8350 24 , , , 19613 8350 25 a a DT 19613 8350 26 divine divine JJ 19613 8350 27 teacher teacher NN 19613 8350 28 . . . 19613 8351 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8351 2 704 704 CD 19613 8351 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8351 4 The the DT 19613 8351 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8351 6 too too RB 19613 8351 7 only only RB 19613 8351 8 teaches teach VBZ 19613 8351 9 the the DT 19613 8351 10 " " `` 19613 8351 11 shadow shadow NN 19613 8351 12 of of IN 19613 8351 13 the the DT 19613 8351 14 secrets secret NNS 19613 8351 15 of of IN 19613 8351 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8351 17 ; ; : 19613 8351 18 " " `` 19613 8351 19 but but CC 19613 8351 20 the the DT 19613 8351 21 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8351 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8351 23 , , , 19613 8351 24 which which WDT 19613 8351 25 is be VBZ 19613 8351 26 also also RB 19613 8351 27 the the DT 19613 8351 28 pneumatic pneumatic JJ 19613 8351 29 one one NN 19613 8351 30 , , , 19613 8351 31 " " '' 19613 8351 32 clearly clearly RB 19613 8351 33 places place NNS 19613 8351 34 before before IN 19613 8351 35 men man NNS 19613 8351 36 's 's POS 19613 8351 37 minds mind NNS 19613 8351 38 all all DT 19613 8351 39 things thing NNS 19613 8351 40 concerning concern VBG 19613 8351 41 the the DT 19613 8351 42 Son Son NNP 19613 8351 43 of of IN 19613 8351 44 God God NNP 19613 8351 45 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8351 46 , , , 19613 8351 47 both both CC 19613 8351 48 the the DT 19613 8351 49 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 8351 50 shown show VBN 19613 8351 51 by by IN 19613 8351 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8351 53 words word NNS 19613 8351 54 , , , 19613 8351 55 and and CC 19613 8351 56 the the DT 19613 8351 57 things thing NNS 19613 8351 58 of of IN 19613 8351 59 which which WDT 19613 8351 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8351 61 acts act NNS 19613 8351 62 were be VBD 19613 8351 63 the the DT 19613 8351 64 riddles riddle NNS 19613 8351 65 " " '' 19613 8351 66 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8351 67 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8351 68 Greek greek JJ 19613 8351 69 : : : 19613 8351 70 saphôs saphôs JJ 19613 8351 71 paristêsi paristêsi NNP 19613 8351 72 tois tois NNP 19613 8351 73 noousi noousi NNP 19613 8351 74 ta ta NNP 19613 8351 75 panta panta NNP 19613 8351 76 enôpion enôpion NNP 19613 8351 77 peri peri NNP 19613 8351 78 autou autou NNP 19613 8351 79 tou tou NNP 19613 8351 80 huiou huiou NNP 19613 8351 81 tou tou NNP 19613 8351 82 Theou Theou NNP 19613 8351 83 , , , 19613 8351 84 kai kai NNP 19613 8351 85 ta ta NNP 19613 8351 86 paristamena paristamena NNP 19613 8351 87 mustêria mustêria NNP 19613 8351 88 hupo hupo NNP 19613 8351 89 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8351 90 logôn logôn NNP 19613 8351 91 autou autou NNP 19613 8351 92 , , , 19613 8351 93 ta ta NNP 19613 8351 94 te te NNP 19613 8351 95 pragmata pragmata NNP 19613 8351 96 , , , 19613 8351 97 ôn ôn NNP 19613 8351 98 ainigmata ainigmata NNP 19613 8351 99 êsan êsan NNP 19613 8351 100 hai hai NNP 19613 8351 101 praxeis praxeis NNP 19613 8351 102 autou autou NNP 19613 8351 103 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8351 104 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8351 105 . . . 19613 8352 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8352 2 705 705 CD 19613 8352 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8352 4 No no RB 19613 8352 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 8352 6 the the DT 19613 8352 7 true true JJ 19613 8352 8 theology theology NN 19613 8352 9 based base VBN 19613 8352 10 on on IN 19613 8352 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 8352 12 makes make VBZ 19613 8352 13 pantheism pantheism NN 19613 8352 14 appear appear VB 19613 8352 15 overthrown overthrow VBN 19613 8352 16 as as RB 19613 8352 17 well well RB 19613 8352 18 as as IN 19613 8352 19 dualism dualism NN 19613 8352 20 , , , 19613 8352 21 and and CC 19613 8352 22 here here RB 19613 8352 23 the the DT 19613 8352 24 influence influence NN 19613 8352 25 of of IN 19613 8352 26 the the DT 19613 8352 27 two two CD 19613 8352 28 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 8352 29 can can MD 19613 8352 30 not not RB 19613 8352 31 be be VB 19613 8352 32 mistaken mistaken JJ 19613 8352 33 ; ; : 19613 8352 34 but but CC 19613 8352 35 a a DT 19613 8352 36 subtle subtle JJ 19613 8352 37 form form NN 19613 8352 38 of of IN 19613 8352 39 the the DT 19613 8352 40 latter latter JJ 19613 8352 41 recurs recur NNS 19613 8352 42 in in IN 19613 8352 43 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8352 44 's 's POS 19613 8352 45 system system NN 19613 8352 46 , , , 19613 8352 47 whilst whilst IN 19613 8352 48 the the DT 19613 8352 49 manner manner NN 19613 8352 50 in in IN 19613 8352 51 which which WDT 19613 8352 52 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8352 53 rejected reject VBD 19613 8352 54 both both DT 19613 8352 55 made make VBD 19613 8352 56 the the DT 19613 8352 57 Greek greek JJ 19613 8352 58 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8352 59 of of IN 19613 8352 60 the the DT 19613 8352 61 age age NN 19613 8352 62 feel feel VBP 19613 8352 63 that that IN 19613 8352 64 there there EX 19613 8352 65 was be VBD 19613 8352 66 something something NN 19613 8352 67 akin akin JJ 19613 8352 68 to to IN 19613 8352 69 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8352 70 here here RB 19613 8352 71 . . . 19613 8353 1 In in IN 19613 8353 2 the the DT 19613 8353 3 final final JJ 19613 8353 4 utterances utterance NNS 19613 8353 5 of of IN 19613 8353 6 religious religious JJ 19613 8353 7 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 19613 8353 8 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8353 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8353 10 , , , 19613 8353 11 with with IN 19613 8353 12 the the DT 19613 8353 13 exception exception NN 19613 8353 14 of of IN 19613 8353 15 a a DT 19613 8353 16 few few JJ 19613 8353 17 compromises compromise NNS 19613 8353 18 , , , 19613 8353 19 is be VBZ 19613 8353 20 thrown throw VBN 19613 8353 21 off off RP 19613 8353 22 as as IN 19613 8353 23 a a DT 19613 8353 24 husk husk NN 19613 8353 25 . . . 19613 8354 1 The the DT 19613 8354 2 objects object NNS 19613 8354 3 of of IN 19613 8354 4 religious religious JJ 19613 8354 5 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8354 6 have have VBP 19613 8354 7 no no DT 19613 8354 8 history history NN 19613 8354 9 or or CC 19613 8354 10 rather rather RB 19613 8354 11 , , , 19613 8354 12 and and CC 19613 8354 13 this this DT 19613 8354 14 is be VBZ 19613 8354 15 a a DT 19613 8354 16 genuinely genuinely RB 19613 8354 17 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8354 18 and and CC 19613 8354 19 Neoplatonic neoplatonic JJ 19613 8354 20 idea idea NN 19613 8354 21 , , , 19613 8354 22 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8354 23 have have VBP 19613 8354 24 only only RB 19613 8354 25 a a DT 19613 8354 26 supramundane supramundane NN 19613 8354 27 one one NN 19613 8354 28 . . . 19613 8355 1 This this DT 19613 8355 2 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8355 3 gave give VBD 19613 8355 4 rise rise NN 19613 8355 5 to to IN 19613 8355 6 the the DT 19613 8355 7 assumption assumption NN 19613 8355 8 of of IN 19613 8355 9 an an DT 19613 8355 10 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 8355 11 and and CC 19613 8355 12 exoteric exoteric JJ 19613 8355 13 form form NN 19613 8355 14 of of IN 19613 8355 15 the the DT 19613 8355 16 Christian christian JJ 19613 8355 17 religion religion NN 19613 8355 18 , , , 19613 8355 19 for for IN 19613 8355 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8355 21 is be VBZ 19613 8355 22 only only RB 19613 8355 23 behind behind IN 19613 8355 24 the the DT 19613 8355 25 statutory statutory JJ 19613 8355 26 , , , 19613 8355 27 positive positive JJ 19613 8355 28 religion religion NN 19613 8355 29 of of IN 19613 8355 30 the the DT 19613 8355 31 Church Church NNP 19613 8355 32 that that WDT 19613 8355 33 religion religion NN 19613 8355 34 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8355 35 is be VBZ 19613 8355 36 found find VBN 19613 8355 37 . . . 19613 8356 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8356 2 gave give VBD 19613 8356 3 the the DT 19613 8356 4 clearest clear JJS 19613 8356 5 expression expression NN 19613 8356 6 to to IN 19613 8356 7 this this DT 19613 8356 8 assumption assumption NN 19613 8356 9 , , , 19613 8356 10 which which WDT 19613 8356 11 must must MD 19613 8356 12 have have VB 19613 8356 13 been be VBN 19613 8356 14 already already RB 19613 8356 15 familiar familiar JJ 19613 8356 16 in in IN 19613 8356 17 the the DT 19613 8356 18 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 8356 19 school school NN 19613 8356 20 of of IN 19613 8356 21 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8356 22 , , , 19613 8356 23 and and CC 19613 8356 24 convinced convince VBD 19613 8356 25 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8356 26 that that IN 19613 8356 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8356 28 was be VBD 19613 8356 29 correct correct JJ 19613 8356 30 , , , 19613 8356 31 because because IN 19613 8356 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8356 33 saw see VBD 19613 8356 34 that that IN 19613 8356 35 the the DT 19613 8356 36 mass mass NN 19613 8356 37 of of IN 19613 8356 38 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8356 39 were be VBD 19613 8356 40 unable unable JJ 19613 8356 41 to to TO 19613 8356 42 grasp grasp VB 19613 8356 43 the the DT 19613 8356 44 deeper deep JJR 19613 8356 45 sense sense NN 19613 8356 46 of of IN 19613 8356 47 Scripture scripture NN 19613 8356 48 , , , 19613 8356 49 and and CC 19613 8356 50 because because IN 19613 8356 51 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8356 52 realised realise VBD 19613 8356 53 the the DT 19613 8356 54 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 8356 55 of of IN 19613 8356 56 the the DT 19613 8356 57 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8356 58 . . . 19613 8357 1 On on IN 19613 8357 2 the the DT 19613 8357 3 other other JJ 19613 8357 4 hand hand NN 19613 8357 5 , , , 19613 8357 6 in in IN 19613 8357 7 solving solve VBG 19613 8357 8 the the DT 19613 8357 9 problem problem NN 19613 8357 10 of of IN 19613 8357 11 adapting adapt VBG 19613 8357 12 the the DT 19613 8357 13 different different JJ 19613 8357 14 points point NNS 19613 8357 15 of of IN 19613 8357 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8357 17 heterodox heterodox NN 19613 8357 18 system system NN 19613 8357 19 of of IN 19613 8357 20 thought thought NN 19613 8357 21 to to IN 19613 8357 22 the the DT 19613 8357 23 _ _ NNP 19613 8357 24 regula regula NN 19613 8357 25 fidei fidei NNP 19613 8357 26 _ _ NNP 19613 8357 27 , , , 19613 8357 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8357 29 displayed display VBD 19613 8357 30 the the DT 19613 8357 31 most most RBS 19613 8357 32 masterly masterly JJ 19613 8357 33 skill skill NN 19613 8357 34 . . . 19613 8358 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8358 2 succeeded succeed VBD 19613 8358 3 in in IN 19613 8358 4 finding find VBG 19613 8358 5 an an DT 19613 8358 6 external external JJ 19613 8358 7 connection connection NN 19613 8358 8 , , , 19613 8358 9 because because IN 19613 8358 10 , , , 19613 8358 11 though though IN 19613 8358 12 the the DT 19613 8358 13 construction construction NN 19613 8358 14 of of IN 19613 8358 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8358 16 theory theory NN 19613 8358 17 proceeded proceed VBN 19613 8358 18 from from IN 19613 8358 19 the the DT 19613 8358 20 top top NN 19613 8358 21 downwards downwards RB 19613 8358 22 , , , 19613 8358 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8358 24 could could MD 19613 8358 25 find find VB 19613 8358 26 support support NN 19613 8358 27 for for IN 19613 8358 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8358 29 on on IN 19613 8358 30 the the DT 19613 8358 31 steps step NNS 19613 8358 32 of of IN 19613 8358 33 the the DT 19613 8358 34 _ _ NNP 19613 8358 35 regula regula NN 19613 8358 36 fidei fidei NNP 19613 8358 37 _ _ NNP 19613 8358 38 , , , 19613 8358 39 already already RB 19613 8358 40 developed develop VBN 19613 8358 41 by by IN 19613 8358 42 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8358 43 into into IN 19613 8358 44 the the DT 19613 8358 45 history history NN 19613 8358 46 of of IN 19613 8358 47 salvation salvation NN 19613 8358 48 . . . 19613 8359 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8359 2 706 706 CD 19613 8359 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8359 4 The the DT 19613 8359 5 system system NN 19613 8359 6 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8359 7 is be VBZ 19613 8359 8 to to TO 19613 8359 9 be be VB 19613 8359 10 , , , 19613 8359 11 in in IN 19613 8359 12 principle principle NN 19613 8359 13 and and CC 19613 8359 14 in in IN 19613 8359 15 every every DT 19613 8359 16 respect respect NN 19613 8359 17 , , , 19613 8359 18 monistic monistic JJ 19613 8359 19 , , , 19613 8359 20 but but CC 19613 8359 21 , , , 19613 8359 22 as as IN 19613 8359 23 the the DT 19613 8359 24 material material NN 19613 8359 25 world world NN 19613 8359 26 , , , 19613 8359 27 though though IN 19613 8359 28 created create VBN 19613 8359 29 by by IN 19613 8359 30 God God NNP 19613 8359 31 out out IN 19613 8359 32 of of IN 19613 8359 33 nothing nothing NN 19613 8359 34 , , , 19613 8359 35 merely merely RB 19613 8359 36 appears appear VBZ 19613 8359 37 as as IN 19613 8359 38 a a DT 19613 8359 39 place place NN 19613 8359 40 of of IN 19613 8359 41 punishment punishment NN 19613 8359 42 and and CC 19613 8359 43 purification purification NN 19613 8359 44 for for IN 19613 8359 45 souls soul NNS 19613 8359 46 , , , 19613 8359 47 a a DT 19613 8359 48 strong strong JJ 19613 8359 49 element element NN 19613 8359 50 of of IN 19613 8359 51 dualism dualism NN 19613 8359 52 is be VBZ 19613 8359 53 inherent inherent JJ 19613 8359 54 in in IN 19613 8359 55 the the DT 19613 8359 56 system system NN 19613 8359 57 , , , 19613 8359 58 as as RB 19613 8359 59 far far RB 19613 8359 60 as as IN 19613 8359 61 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8359 62 practical practical JJ 19613 8359 63 application application NN 19613 8359 64 is be VBZ 19613 8359 65 concerned concern VBN 19613 8359 66 . . . 19613 8360 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8360 2 707 707 CD 19613 8360 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8360 4 The the DT 19613 8360 5 prevailing prevailing JJ 19613 8360 6 contrast contrast NN 19613 8360 7 is be VBZ 19613 8360 8 that that IN 19613 8360 9 between between IN 19613 8360 10 the the DT 19613 8360 11 one one CD 19613 8360 12 transcendent transcendent NN 19613 8360 13 essence essence NN 19613 8360 14 and and CC 19613 8360 15 the the DT 19613 8360 16 multiplicity multiplicity NN 19613 8360 17 of of IN 19613 8360 18 all all DT 19613 8360 19 created create VBN 19613 8360 20 things thing NNS 19613 8360 21 . . . 19613 8361 1 The the DT 19613 8361 2 pervading pervading JJ 19613 8361 3 ambiguity ambiguity NN 19613 8361 4 lies lie VBZ 19613 8361 5 in in IN 19613 8361 6 the the DT 19613 8361 7 twofold twofold JJ 19613 8361 8 view view NN 19613 8361 9 of of IN 19613 8361 10 the the DT 19613 8361 11 spiritual spiritual NN 19613 8361 12 in in IN 19613 8361 13 so so RB 19613 8361 14 far far RB 19613 8361 15 as as IN 19613 8361 16 , , , 19613 8361 17 on on IN 19613 8361 18 the the DT 19613 8361 19 one one CD 19613 8361 20 hand hand NN 19613 8361 21 , , , 19613 8361 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8361 23 belongs belong VBZ 19613 8361 24 to to IN 19613 8361 25 God God NNP 19613 8361 26 as as IN 19613 8361 27 the the DT 19613 8361 28 unfolding unfolding NN 19613 8361 29 of of IN 19613 8361 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8361 31 essence essence NN 19613 8361 32 , , , 19613 8361 33 and and CC 19613 8361 34 , , , 19613 8361 35 on on IN 19613 8361 36 the the DT 19613 8361 37 other other JJ 19613 8361 38 , , , 19613 8361 39 as as IN 19613 8361 40 being be VBG 19613 8361 41 created create VBN 19613 8361 42 , , , 19613 8361 43 is be VBZ 19613 8361 44 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 8361 45 with with IN 19613 8361 46 God God NNP 19613 8361 47 . . . 19613 8362 1 This this DT 19613 8362 2 ambiguity ambiguity NN 19613 8362 3 , , , 19613 8362 4 which which WDT 19613 8362 5 recurs recur VBZ 19613 8362 6 in in IN 19613 8362 7 all all PDT 19613 8362 8 the the DT 19613 8362 9 Neoplatonic Neoplatonic NNP 19613 8362 10 systems system NNS 19613 8362 11 and and CC 19613 8362 12 has have VBZ 19613 8362 13 continued continue VBN 19613 8362 14 to to TO 19613 8362 15 characterise characterise VB 19613 8362 16 all all DT 19613 8362 17 mysticism mysticism NN 19613 8362 18 down down RP 19613 8362 19 to to IN 19613 8362 20 the the DT 19613 8362 21 present present JJ 19613 8362 22 day day NN 19613 8362 23 , , , 19613 8362 24 originates originate VBZ 19613 8362 25 in in IN 19613 8362 26 the the DT 19613 8362 27 attempt attempt NN 19613 8362 28 to to TO 19613 8362 29 repel repel VB 19613 8362 30 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 8362 31 pantheism pantheism NN 19613 8362 32 and and CC 19613 8362 33 yet yet RB 19613 8362 34 to to TO 19613 8362 35 preserve preserve VB 19613 8362 36 the the DT 19613 8362 37 transcendental transcendental JJ 19613 8362 38 nature nature NN 19613 8362 39 of of IN 19613 8362 40 the the DT 19613 8362 41 human human JJ 19613 8362 42 spirit spirit NN 19613 8362 43 , , , 19613 8362 44 and and CC 19613 8362 45 to to TO 19613 8362 46 maintain maintain VB 19613 8362 47 the the DT 19613 8362 48 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8362 49 causality causality NN 19613 8362 50 of of IN 19613 8362 51 God God NNP 19613 8362 52 without without IN 19613 8362 53 allowing allow VBG 19613 8362 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8362 55 goodness goodness NN 19613 8362 56 to to TO 19613 8362 57 be be VB 19613 8362 58 called call VBN 19613 8362 59 in in IN 19613 8362 60 question question NN 19613 8362 61 . . . 19613 8363 1 The the DT 19613 8363 2 assumption assumption NN 19613 8363 3 that that WDT 19613 8363 4 created create VBD 19613 8363 5 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8363 6 can can MD 19613 8363 7 freely freely RB 19613 8363 8 determine determine VB 19613 8363 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8363 10 own own JJ 19613 8363 11 course course NN 19613 8363 12 is be VBZ 19613 8363 13 therefore therefore RB 19613 8363 14 a a DT 19613 8363 15 necessity necessity NN 19613 8363 16 of of IN 19613 8363 17 the the DT 19613 8363 18 system system NN 19613 8363 19 ; ; : 19613 8363 20 in in IN 19613 8363 21 fact fact NN 19613 8363 22 this this DT 19613 8363 23 assumption assumption NN 19613 8363 24 is be VBZ 19613 8363 25 one one CD 19613 8363 26 of of IN 19613 8363 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8363 28 main main JJ 19613 8363 29 presuppositions[708 presuppositions[708 NN 19613 8363 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8363 31 and and CC 19613 8363 32 is be VBZ 19613 8363 33 so so RB 19613 8363 34 boldly boldly RB 19613 8363 35 developed develop VBN 19613 8363 36 as as IN 19613 8363 37 to to TO 19613 8363 38 limit limit VB 19613 8363 39 the the DT 19613 8363 40 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 8363 41 and and CC 19613 8363 42 omniscience omniscience NN 19613 8363 43 of of IN 19613 8363 44 God God NNP 19613 8363 45 . . . 19613 8364 1 But but CC 19613 8364 2 , , , 19613 8364 3 as as IN 19613 8364 4 from from IN 19613 8364 5 the the DT 19613 8364 6 empirical empirical JJ 19613 8364 7 point point NN 19613 8364 8 of of IN 19613 8364 9 view view NN 19613 8364 10 the the DT 19613 8364 11 knot knot NN 19613 8364 12 is be VBZ 19613 8364 13 tied tie VBN 19613 8364 14 for for IN 19613 8364 15 every every DT 19613 8364 16 man man NN 19613 8364 17 at at IN 19613 8364 18 the the DT 19613 8364 19 very very JJ 19613 8364 20 moment moment NN 19613 8364 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8364 22 appears appear VBZ 19613 8364 23 on on IN 19613 8364 24 earth earth NN 19613 8364 25 , , , 19613 8364 26 and and CC 19613 8364 27 since since IN 19613 8364 28 the the DT 19613 8364 29 problem problem NN 19613 8364 30 is be VBZ 19613 8364 31 not not RB 19613 8364 32 created create VBN 19613 8364 33 by by IN 19613 8364 34 each each DT 19613 8364 35 human human NN 19613 8364 36 being being NN 19613 8364 37 as as IN 19613 8364 38 the the DT 19613 8364 39 result result NN 19613 8364 40 of of IN 19613 8364 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8364 42 own own JJ 19613 8364 43 independent independent NN 19613 8364 44 will will NN 19613 8364 45 , , , 19613 8364 46 but but CC 19613 8364 47 lies lie VBZ 19613 8364 48 in in IN 19613 8364 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8364 50 organisation organisation NN 19613 8364 51 , , , 19613 8364 52 speculation speculation NN 19613 8364 53 must must MD 19613 8364 54 retreat retreat VB 19613 8364 55 behind behind IN 19613 8364 56 history history NN 19613 8364 57 . . . 19613 8365 1 So so RB 19613 8365 2 the the DT 19613 8365 3 system system NN 19613 8365 4 , , , 19613 8365 5 in in IN 19613 8365 6 accordance accordance NN 19613 8365 7 with with IN 19613 8365 8 certain certain JJ 19613 8365 9 hints hint NNS 19613 8365 10 of of IN 19613 8365 11 Plato Plato NNP 19613 8365 12 , , , 19613 8365 13 is be VBZ 19613 8365 14 constructed construct VBN 19613 8365 15 on on IN 19613 8365 16 the the DT 19613 8365 17 same same JJ 19613 8365 18 plan plan NN 19613 8365 19 as as IN 19613 8365 20 that that DT 19613 8365 21 of of IN 19613 8365 22 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8365 23 , , , 19613 8365 24 for for IN 19613 8365 25 example example NN 19613 8365 26 , , , 19613 8365 27 to to TO 19613 8365 28 which which WDT 19613 8365 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8365 30 has have VBZ 19613 8365 31 an an DT 19613 8365 32 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 19613 8365 33 affinity affinity NN 19613 8365 34 . . . 19613 8366 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8366 2 contains contain VBZ 19613 8366 3 three three CD 19613 8366 4 parts part NNS 19613 8366 5 : : : 19613 8366 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8366 7 1 1 LS 19613 8366 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8366 9 The the DT 19613 8366 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8366 11 of of IN 19613 8366 12 God God NNP 19613 8366 13 and and CC 19613 8366 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8366 15 unfoldings unfolding NNS 19613 8366 16 or or CC 19613 8366 17 creations creation NNS 19613 8366 18 , , , 19613 8366 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8366 20 2 2 LS 19613 8366 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8366 22 the the DT 19613 8366 23 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8366 24 of of IN 19613 8366 25 the the DT 19613 8366 26 Fall Fall NNP 19613 8366 27 and and CC 19613 8366 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8366 29 consequences consequence NNS 19613 8366 30 , , , 19613 8366 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8366 32 3 3 LS 19613 8366 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8366 34 the the DT 19613 8366 35 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8366 36 of of IN 19613 8366 37 redemption redemption NN 19613 8366 38 and and CC 19613 8366 39 restoration restoration NN 19613 8366 40 . . . 19613 8367 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8367 2 709 709 CD 19613 8367 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8367 4 Like like IN 19613 8367 5 Denis Denis NNP 19613 8367 6 , , , 19613 8367 7 however however RB 19613 8367 8 , , , 19613 8367 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8367 10 may may MD 19613 8367 11 also also RB 19613 8367 12 , , , 19613 8367 13 in in IN 19613 8367 14 accordance accordance NN 19613 8367 15 with with IN 19613 8367 16 a a DT 19613 8367 17 premised premise VBN 19613 8367 18 theory theory NN 19613 8367 19 of of IN 19613 8367 20 method method NN 19613 8367 21 , , , 19613 8367 22 set set VBN 19613 8367 23 forth forth RP 19613 8367 24 the the DT 19613 8367 25 system system NN 19613 8367 26 in in IN 19613 8367 27 four four CD 19613 8367 28 sections section NNS 19613 8367 29 , , , 19613 8367 30 viz viz NNP 19613 8367 31 . . NNP 19613 8367 32 , , , 19613 8367 33 Theology Theology NNP 19613 8367 34 , , , 19613 8367 35 Cosmology Cosmology NNP 19613 8367 36 , , , 19613 8367 37 Anthropology Anthropology NNP 19613 8367 38 , , , 19613 8367 39 Teleology teleology NN 19613 8367 40 . . . 19613 8368 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8368 2 's 's POS 19613 8368 3 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 8368 4 idea idea NN 19613 8368 5 is be VBZ 19613 8368 6 " " `` 19613 8368 7 the the DT 19613 8368 8 original original JJ 19613 8368 9 indestructible indestructible JJ 19613 8368 10 unity unity NN 19613 8368 11 of of IN 19613 8368 12 God God NNP 19613 8368 13 and and CC 19613 8368 14 all all DT 19613 8368 15 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8368 16 essence essence NN 19613 8368 17 . . . 19613 8368 18 " " '' 19613 8369 1 From from IN 19613 8369 2 this this DT 19613 8369 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8369 4 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8369 5 follows follow VBZ 19613 8369 6 that that IN 19613 8369 7 the the DT 19613 8369 8 created create VBN 19613 8369 9 spirit spirit NN 19613 8369 10 after after IN 19613 8369 11 fall fall NN 19613 8369 12 , , , 19613 8369 13 error error NN 19613 8369 14 , , , 19613 8369 15 and and CC 19613 8369 16 sin sin NN 19613 8369 17 must must MD 19613 8369 18 ever ever RB 19613 8369 19 return return VB 19613 8369 20 to to IN 19613 8369 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8369 22 origin origin NN 19613 8369 23 , , , 19613 8369 24 to to IN 19613 8369 25 being be VBG 19613 8369 26 in in IN 19613 8369 27 God God NNP 19613 8369 28 . . . 19613 8370 1 In in IN 19613 8370 2 this this DT 19613 8370 3 idea idea NN 19613 8370 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8370 5 have have VBP 19613 8370 6 the the DT 19613 8370 7 key key NN 19613 8370 8 to to IN 19613 8370 9 the the DT 19613 8370 10 religious religious JJ 19613 8370 11 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8370 12 of of IN 19613 8370 13 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8370 14 . . . 19613 8371 1 The the DT 19613 8371 2 only only JJ 19613 8371 3 sources source NNS 19613 8371 4 for for IN 19613 8371 5 obtaining obtain VBG 19613 8371 6 a a DT 19613 8371 7 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8371 8 of of IN 19613 8371 9 the the DT 19613 8371 10 truth truth NN 19613 8371 11 are be VBP 19613 8371 12 the the DT 19613 8371 13 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8371 14 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8371 15 of of IN 19613 8371 16 both both DT 19613 8371 17 Testaments testament NNS 19613 8371 18 . . . 19613 8372 1 No no RB 19613 8372 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 8372 3 the the DT 19613 8372 4 speculations speculation NNS 19613 8372 5 of of IN 19613 8372 6 Greek greek JJ 19613 8372 7 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8372 8 also also RB 19613 8372 9 contain contain VBP 19613 8372 10 truths truth NNS 19613 8372 11 , , , 19613 8372 12 but but CC 19613 8372 13 these these DT 19613 8372 14 have have VBP 19613 8372 15 only only RB 19613 8372 16 a a DT 19613 8372 17 propædeutic propædeutic JJ 19613 8372 18 value value NN 19613 8372 19 and and CC 19613 8372 20 , , , 19613 8372 21 moreover moreover RB 19613 8372 22 , , , 19613 8372 23 have have VBP 19613 8372 24 no no DT 19613 8372 25 certainty certainty NN 19613 8372 26 to to TO 19613 8372 27 offer offer VB 19613 8372 28 , , , 19613 8372 29 as as IN 19613 8372 30 have have VBP 19613 8372 31 the the DT 19613 8372 32 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8372 33 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8372 34 , , , 19613 8372 35 which which WDT 19613 8372 36 are be VBP 19613 8372 37 a a DT 19613 8372 38 witness witness NN 19613 8372 39 to to IN 19613 8372 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8372 41 in in IN 19613 8372 42 the the DT 19613 8372 43 fulfilment fulfilment NN 19613 8372 44 of of IN 19613 8372 45 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 8372 46 . . . 19613 8373 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8373 2 710 710 CD 19613 8373 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8373 4 On on IN 19613 8373 5 the the DT 19613 8373 6 other other JJ 19613 8373 7 hand hand NN 19613 8373 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8373 9 assumes assume VBZ 19613 8373 10 that that IN 19613 8373 11 there there EX 19613 8373 12 was be VBD 19613 8373 13 an an DT 19613 8373 14 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 8373 15 deeper deep JJR 19613 8373 16 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8373 17 in in IN 19613 8373 18 addition addition NN 19613 8373 19 to to IN 19613 8373 20 the the DT 19613 8373 21 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8373 22 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8373 23 , , , 19613 8373 24 and and CC 19613 8373 25 that that IN 19613 8373 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8373 27 in in IN 19613 8373 28 particular particular JJ 19613 8373 29 imparted impart VBD 19613 8373 30 this this DT 19613 8373 31 deeper deep JJR 19613 8373 32 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8373 33 to to IN 19613 8373 34 a a DT 19613 8373 35 few;[711 few;[711 NN 19613 8373 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8373 37 but but CC 19613 8373 38 , , , 19613 8373 39 as as IN 19613 8373 40 a a DT 19613 8373 41 correct correct JJ 19613 8373 42 Church Church NNP 19613 8373 43 theologian theologian NN 19613 8373 44 , , , 19613 8373 45 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8373 46 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 8373 47 made make VBD 19613 8373 48 use use NN 19613 8373 49 of of IN 19613 8373 50 this this DT 19613 8373 51 assumption assumption NN 19613 8373 52 . . . 19613 8374 1 The the DT 19613 8374 2 first first JJ 19613 8374 3 methodical methodical JJ 19613 8374 4 principle principle NN 19613 8374 5 of of IN 19613 8374 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8374 7 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8374 8 is be VBZ 19613 8374 9 that that IN 19613 8374 10 the the DT 19613 8374 11 faith faith NN 19613 8374 12 , , , 19613 8374 13 as as IN 19613 8374 14 professed profess VBN 19613 8374 15 in in IN 19613 8374 16 the the DT 19613 8374 17 Church Church NNP 19613 8374 18 in in IN 19613 8374 19 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 8374 20 to to TO 19613 8374 21 heresy heresy VB 19613 8374 22 , , , 19613 8374 23 must must MD 19613 8374 24 not not RB 19613 8374 25 be be VB 19613 8374 26 tampered tamper VBN 19613 8374 27 with with IN 19613 8374 28 . . . 19613 8375 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8375 2 712 712 CD 19613 8375 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8375 4 But but CC 19613 8375 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8375 6 is be VBZ 19613 8375 7 the the DT 19613 8375 8 carrying carrying NN 19613 8375 9 out out IN 19613 8375 10 of of IN 19613 8375 11 this this DT 19613 8375 12 rule rule NN 19613 8375 13 that that WDT 19613 8375 14 really really RB 19613 8375 15 forms form VBZ 19613 8375 16 the the DT 19613 8375 17 task task NN 19613 8375 18 of of IN 19613 8375 19 the the DT 19613 8375 20 theologian theologian NN 19613 8375 21 . . . 19613 8376 1 For for IN 19613 8376 2 the the DT 19613 8376 3 faith faith NN 19613 8376 4 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8376 5 is be VBZ 19613 8376 6 fixed fix VBN 19613 8376 7 and and CC 19613 8376 8 requires require VBZ 19613 8376 9 no no DT 19613 8376 10 particular particular JJ 19613 8376 11 presentation presentation NN 19613 8376 12 ; ; : 19613 8376 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8376 14 never never RB 19613 8376 15 occurred occur VBD 19613 8376 16 to to IN 19613 8376 17 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8376 18 to to TO 19613 8376 19 assume assume VB 19613 8376 20 that that IN 19613 8376 21 the the DT 19613 8376 22 fixing fixing NN 19613 8376 23 of of IN 19613 8376 24 the the DT 19613 8376 25 faith faith NN 19613 8376 26 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8376 27 could could MD 19613 8376 28 present present VB 19613 8376 29 problems problem NNS 19613 8376 30 . . . 19613 8377 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8377 2 is be VBZ 19613 8377 3 complete complete JJ 19613 8377 4 , , , 19613 8377 5 clear clear JJ 19613 8377 6 , , , 19613 8377 7 easily easily RB 19613 8377 8 teachable teachable JJ 19613 8377 9 , , , 19613 8377 10 and and CC 19613 8377 11 really really RB 19613 8377 12 leads lead VBZ 19613 8377 13 to to IN 19613 8377 14 victory victory NN 19613 8377 15 over over IN 19613 8377 16 sensuality sensuality NN 19613 8377 17 and and CC 19613 8377 18 sin sin NN 19613 8377 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8377 20 see see VB 19613 8377 21 c. c. NNP 19613 8377 22 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8377 23 . . . 19613 8378 1 VII VII NNP 19613 8378 2 . . . 19613 8379 1 48 48 CD 19613 8379 2 and and CC 19613 8379 3 cf cf NN 19613 8379 4 . . . 19613 8380 1 other other JJ 19613 8380 2 passages passage NNS 19613 8380 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8380 4 , , , 19613 8380 5 as as RB 19613 8380 6 well well RB 19613 8380 7 as as IN 19613 8380 8 to to IN 19613 8380 9 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 8380 10 with with IN 19613 8380 11 God God NNP 19613 8380 12 , , , 19613 8380 13 since since IN 19613 8380 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8380 15 rests rest VBZ 19613 8380 16 on on IN 19613 8380 17 the the DT 19613 8380 18 revelation revelation NN 19613 8380 19 of of IN 19613 8380 20 the the DT 19613 8380 21 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8380 22 . . . 19613 8381 1 But but CC 19613 8381 2 , , , 19613 8381 3 as as IN 19613 8381 4 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8381 5 remains remain VBZ 19613 8381 6 determined determine VBN 19613 8381 7 by by IN 19613 8381 8 fear fear NN 19613 8381 9 and and CC 19613 8381 10 hope hope NN 19613 8381 11 of of IN 19613 8381 12 reward reward NN 19613 8381 13 so so RB 19613 8381 14 , , , 19613 8381 15 as as IN 19613 8381 16 " " `` 19613 8381 17 uninformed uninformed JJ 19613 8381 18 and and CC 19613 8381 19 irrational irrational JJ 19613 8381 20 faith faith NN 19613 8381 21 " " '' 19613 8381 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8381 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8381 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8381 25 : : : 19613 8381 26 pistis pistis NN 19613 8381 27 idiôtikê idiôtikê NNS 19613 8381 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8381 29 and and CC 19613 8381 30 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8381 31 Greek greek JJ 19613 8381 32 : : : 19613 8381 33 alogos alogo NNS 19613 8381 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8381 35 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8381 36 , , , 19613 8381 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8381 38 only only RB 19613 8381 39 leads lead VBZ 19613 8381 40 to to IN 19613 8381 41 a a DT 19613 8381 42 " " `` 19613 8381 43 somatic somatic JJ 19613 8381 44 Christianity christianity NN 19613 8381 45 " " '' 19613 8381 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8381 47 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8381 48 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8381 49 : : : 19613 8381 50 Christianismos Christianismos NNP 19613 8381 51 sômatikos sômatikos NN 19613 8381 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8381 53 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8381 54 . . . 19613 8382 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8382 2 is be VBZ 19613 8382 3 the the DT 19613 8382 4 task task NN 19613 8382 5 of of IN 19613 8382 6 theology theology NN 19613 8382 7 , , , 19613 8382 8 however however RB 19613 8382 9 , , , 19613 8382 10 to to TO 19613 8382 11 decipher decipher VB 19613 8382 12 " " `` 19613 8382 13 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8382 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8382 15 " " '' 19613 8382 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8382 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8382 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8382 19 : : : 19613 8382 20 Christianismos Christianismos NNP 19613 8382 21 pneumatikos pneumatikos NN 19613 8382 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8382 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8382 24 from from IN 19613 8382 25 the the DT 19613 8382 26 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8382 27 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8382 28 , , , 19613 8382 29 and and CC 19613 8382 30 to to TO 19613 8382 31 elevate elevate VB 19613 8382 32 faith faith NN 19613 8382 33 to to TO 19613 8382 34 knowledge knowledge VB 19613 8382 35 and and CC 19613 8382 36 clear clear JJ 19613 8382 37 vision vision NN 19613 8382 38 . . . 19613 8383 1 This this DT 19613 8383 2 is be VBZ 19613 8383 3 effected effect VBN 19613 8383 4 by by IN 19613 8383 5 the the DT 19613 8383 6 method method NN 19613 8383 7 of of IN 19613 8383 8 Scripture scripture NN 19613 8383 9 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8383 10 which which WDT 19613 8383 11 ascertains ascertain VBZ 19613 8383 12 the the DT 19613 8383 13 highest high JJS 19613 8383 14 revelations revelation NNS 19613 8383 15 of of IN 19613 8383 16 God God NNP 19613 8383 17 . . . 19613 8384 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8384 2 713 713 CD 19613 8384 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8384 4 The the DT 19613 8384 5 Scripture scripture NN 19613 8384 6 has have VBZ 19613 8384 7 a a DT 19613 8384 8 threefold threefold JJ 19613 8384 9 sense sense NN 19613 8384 10 because because IN 19613 8384 11 , , , 19613 8384 12 like like IN 19613 8384 13 the the DT 19613 8384 14 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 8384 15 , , , 19613 8384 16 alongside alongside IN 19613 8384 17 of of IN 19613 8384 18 which which WDT 19613 8384 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8384 20 stands stand VBZ 19613 8384 21 like like IN 19613 8384 22 a a DT 19613 8384 23 second second JJ 19613 8384 24 revelation revelation NN 19613 8384 25 , , , 19613 8384 26 as as IN 19613 8384 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8384 28 were be VBD 19613 8384 29 , , , 19613 8384 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8384 31 must must MD 19613 8384 32 contain contain VB 19613 8384 33 a a DT 19613 8384 34 pneumatic pneumatic JJ 19613 8384 35 , , , 19613 8384 36 psychic psychic JJ 19613 8384 37 , , , 19613 8384 38 and and CC 19613 8384 39 somatic somatic JJ 19613 8384 40 element element NN 19613 8384 41 . . . 19613 8385 1 The the DT 19613 8385 2 somatic somatic JJ 19613 8385 3 or or CC 19613 8385 4 historical historical JJ 19613 8385 5 sense sense NN 19613 8385 6 is be VBZ 19613 8385 7 in in IN 19613 8385 8 every every DT 19613 8385 9 case case NN 19613 8385 10 the the DT 19613 8385 11 first first JJ 19613 8385 12 that that WDT 19613 8385 13 must must MD 19613 8385 14 be be VB 19613 8385 15 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 8385 16 . . . 19613 8386 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8386 2 corresponds correspond VBZ 19613 8386 3 to to IN 19613 8386 4 the the DT 19613 8386 5 stage stage NN 19613 8386 6 of of IN 19613 8386 7 mere mere JJ 19613 8386 8 faith faith NN 19613 8386 9 and and CC 19613 8386 10 has have VBZ 19613 8386 11 consequently consequently RB 19613 8386 12 the the DT 19613 8386 13 same same JJ 19613 8386 14 dignity dignity NN 19613 8386 15 as as IN 19613 8386 16 the the DT 19613 8386 17 latter latter JJ 19613 8386 18 . . . 19613 8387 1 But but CC 19613 8387 2 there there EX 19613 8387 3 are be VBP 19613 8387 4 instances instance NNS 19613 8387 5 where where WRB 19613 8387 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8387 7 is be VBZ 19613 8387 8 to to TO 19613 8387 9 be be VB 19613 8387 10 given give VBN 19613 8387 11 up up RP 19613 8387 12 and and CC 19613 8387 13 designated designate VBN 19613 8387 14 as as IN 19613 8387 15 a a DT 19613 8387 16 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 8387 17 and and CC 19613 8387 18 fleshly fleshly JJ 19613 8387 19 sense sense NN 19613 8387 20 . . . 19613 8388 1 This this DT 19613 8388 2 is be VBZ 19613 8388 3 to to TO 19613 8388 4 be be VB 19613 8388 5 assumed assume VBN 19613 8388 6 in in IN 19613 8388 7 all all DT 19613 8388 8 cases case NNS 19613 8388 9 where where WRB 19613 8388 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8388 11 leads lead VBZ 19613 8388 12 to to IN 19613 8388 13 ideas idea NNS 19613 8388 14 opposed oppose VBN 19613 8388 15 to to IN 19613 8388 16 the the DT 19613 8388 17 nature nature NN 19613 8388 18 of of IN 19613 8388 19 God God NNP 19613 8388 20 , , , 19613 8388 21 morality morality NN 19613 8388 22 , , , 19613 8388 23 the the DT 19613 8388 24 law law NN 19613 8388 25 of of IN 19613 8388 26 nature nature NN 19613 8388 27 , , , 19613 8388 28 or or CC 19613 8388 29 reason reason NN 19613 8388 30 . . . 19613 8389 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8389 2 714 714 CD 19613 8389 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8389 4 Here here RB 19613 8389 5 one one PRP 19613 8389 6 must must MD 19613 8389 7 judge judge VB 19613 8389 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8389 9 see see VB 19613 8389 10 above above RB 19613 8389 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8389 12 that that IN 19613 8389 13 such such JJ 19613 8389 14 objectionable objectionable JJ 19613 8389 15 passages passage NNS 19613 8389 16 were be VBD 19613 8389 17 meant mean VBN 19613 8389 18 to to TO 19613 8389 19 incite incite VB 19613 8389 20 the the DT 19613 8389 21 searcher searcher NN 19613 8389 22 to to IN 19613 8389 23 a a DT 19613 8389 24 deeper deep JJR 19613 8389 25 investigation investigation NN 19613 8389 26 . . . 19613 8390 1 The the DT 19613 8390 2 psychic psychic JJ 19613 8390 3 sense sense NN 19613 8390 4 is be VBZ 19613 8390 5 of of IN 19613 8390 6 a a DT 19613 8390 7 moral moral JJ 19613 8390 8 nature nature NN 19613 8390 9 : : : 19613 8390 10 in in IN 19613 8390 11 the the DT 19613 8390 12 Old Old NNP 19613 8390 13 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8390 14 more more RBR 19613 8390 15 especially especially RB 19613 8390 16 most most JJS 19613 8390 17 narratives narrative NNS 19613 8390 18 have have VBP 19613 8390 19 a a DT 19613 8390 20 moral moral JJ 19613 8390 21 content content NN 19613 8390 22 , , , 19613 8390 23 which which WDT 19613 8390 24 one one PRP 19613 8390 25 can can MD 19613 8390 26 easily easily RB 19613 8390 27 find find VB 19613 8390 28 by by IN 19613 8390 29 stripping strip VBG 19613 8390 30 off off RP 19613 8390 31 the the DT 19613 8390 32 history history NN 19613 8390 33 as as IN 19613 8390 34 a a DT 19613 8390 35 covering covering NN 19613 8390 36 ; ; : 19613 8390 37 and and CC 19613 8390 38 in in IN 19613 8390 39 certain certain JJ 19613 8390 40 passages passage NNS 19613 8390 41 one one PRP 19613 8390 42 may may MD 19613 8390 43 content content VB 19613 8390 44 oneself oneself PRP 19613 8390 45 with with IN 19613 8390 46 this this DT 19613 8390 47 meaning meaning NN 19613 8390 48 . . . 19613 8391 1 The the DT 19613 8391 2 pneumatic pneumatic JJ 19613 8391 3 sense sense NN 19613 8391 4 , , , 19613 8391 5 which which WDT 19613 8391 6 is be VBZ 19613 8391 7 the the DT 19613 8391 8 only only JJ 19613 8391 9 meaning meaning NN 19613 8391 10 borne bear VBN 19613 8391 11 by by IN 19613 8391 12 many many JJ 19613 8391 13 passages passage NNS 19613 8391 14 , , , 19613 8391 15 an an DT 19613 8391 16 assertion assertion NN 19613 8391 17 which which WDT 19613 8391 18 neither neither CC 19613 8391 19 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8391 20 nor nor CC 19613 8391 21 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8391 22 ventured venture VBD 19613 8391 23 to to TO 19613 8391 24 make make VB 19613 8391 25 in in RP 19613 8391 26 plain plain JJ 19613 8391 27 terms term NNS 19613 8391 28 , , , 19613 8391 29 has have VBZ 19613 8391 30 with with IN 19613 8391 31 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8391 32 a a DT 19613 8391 33 negatively negatively RB 19613 8391 34 apologetic apologetic JJ 19613 8391 35 and and CC 19613 8391 36 a a DT 19613 8391 37 positively positively RB 19613 8391 38 didactic didactic JJ 19613 8391 39 aim aim NN 19613 8391 40 . . . 19613 8392 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8392 2 leads lead VBZ 19613 8392 3 to to IN 19613 8392 4 the the DT 19613 8392 5 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 8392 6 ideas idea NNS 19613 8392 7 which which WDT 19613 8392 8 , , , 19613 8392 9 once once RB 19613 8392 10 attained attain VBD 19613 8392 11 , , , 19613 8392 12 are be VBP 19613 8392 13 self self NN 19613 8392 14 - - HYPH 19613 8392 15 evident evident JJ 19613 8392 16 , , , 19613 8392 17 and and CC 19613 8392 18 , , , 19613 8392 19 so so RB 19613 8392 20 to to TO 19613 8392 21 speak speak VB 19613 8392 22 , , , 19613 8392 23 pass pass VB 19613 8392 24 completely completely RB 19613 8392 25 over over RB 19613 8392 26 into into IN 19613 8392 27 the the DT 19613 8392 28 mind mind NN 19613 8392 29 of of IN 19613 8392 30 the the DT 19613 8392 31 theologian theologian NN 19613 8392 32 , , , 19613 8392 33 because because IN 19613 8392 34 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8392 35 finally finally RB 19613 8392 36 obtain obtain VBP 19613 8392 37 for for IN 19613 8392 38 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8392 39 clear clear JJ 19613 8392 40 vision vision NN 19613 8392 41 and and CC 19613 8392 42 independent independent JJ 19613 8392 43 possession possession NN 19613 8392 44 . . . 19613 8393 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8393 2 715 715 CD 19613 8393 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8393 4 When when WRB 19613 8393 5 the the DT 19613 8393 6 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8393 7 has have VBZ 19613 8393 8 attained attain VBN 19613 8393 9 this this DT 19613 8393 10 stage stage NN 19613 8393 11 , , , 19613 8393 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8393 13 may may MD 19613 8393 14 throw throw VB 19613 8393 15 away away RB 19613 8393 16 the the DT 19613 8393 17 ladders ladder NNS 19613 8393 18 by by IN 19613 8393 19 which which WDT 19613 8393 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8393 21 has have VBZ 19613 8393 22 reached reach VBN 19613 8393 23 this this DT 19613 8393 24 height height NN 19613 8393 25 . . . 19613 8394 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8394 2 716 716 CD 19613 8394 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8394 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8394 5 is be VBZ 19613 8394 6 then then RB 19613 8394 7 inwardly inwardly RB 19613 8394 8 united united JJ 19613 8394 9 with with IN 19613 8394 10 God God NNP 19613 8394 11 's 's POS 19613 8394 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8394 13 , , , 19613 8394 14 and and CC 19613 8394 15 from from IN 19613 8394 16 this this DT 19613 8394 17 union union NN 19613 8394 18 obtains obtain VBZ 19613 8394 19 all all DT 19613 8394 20 that that WDT 19613 8394 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8394 22 requires require VBZ 19613 8394 23 . . . 19613 8395 1 In in IN 19613 8395 2 most most JJS 19613 8395 3 passages passage NNS 19613 8395 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8395 5 presupposed presuppose VBD 19613 8395 6 the the DT 19613 8395 7 similarity similarity NN 19613 8395 8 and and CC 19613 8395 9 equal equal JJ 19613 8395 10 value value NN 19613 8395 11 of of IN 19613 8395 12 all all DT 19613 8395 13 parts part NNS 19613 8395 14 of of IN 19613 8395 15 the the DT 19613 8395 16 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8395 17 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8395 18 ; ; : 19613 8395 19 but but CC 19613 8395 20 in in IN 19613 8395 21 some some DT 19613 8395 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8395 23 showed show VBD 19613 8395 24 that that IN 19613 8395 25 even even RB 19613 8395 26 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 8395 27 has have VBZ 19613 8395 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8395 29 stages stage NNS 19613 8395 30 and and CC 19613 8395 31 grades grade NNS 19613 8395 32 , , , 19613 8395 33 according accord VBG 19613 8395 34 to to IN 19613 8395 35 the the DT 19613 8395 36 receptivity receptivity NN 19613 8395 37 and and CC 19613 8395 38 worthiness worthiness NN 19613 8395 39 of of IN 19613 8395 40 each each DT 19613 8395 41 prophet prophet NN 19613 8395 42 , , , 19613 8395 43 thus thus RB 19613 8395 44 applying apply VBG 19613 8395 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8395 46 relative relative JJ 19613 8395 47 view view NN 19613 8395 48 of of IN 19613 8395 49 all all DT 19613 8395 50 matters matter NNS 19613 8395 51 of of IN 19613 8395 52 fact fact NN 19613 8395 53 in in IN 19613 8395 54 such such JJ 19613 8395 55 cases case NNS 19613 8395 56 also also RB 19613 8395 57 . . . 19613 8396 1 In in IN 19613 8396 2 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8396 3 the the DT 19613 8396 4 full full JJ 19613 8396 5 revelation revelation NN 19613 8396 6 of of IN 19613 8396 7 the the DT 19613 8396 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8396 9 was be VBD 19613 8396 10 first first RB 19613 8396 11 expressed express VBN 19613 8396 12 ; ; : 19613 8396 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8396 14 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 8396 15 did do VBD 19613 8396 16 not not RB 19613 8396 17 possess possess VB 19613 8396 18 the the DT 19613 8396 19 same same JJ 19613 8396 20 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 8396 21 as as IN 19613 8396 22 he,[717 he,[717 NN 19613 8396 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8396 24 and and CC 19613 8396 25 among among IN 19613 8396 26 the the DT 19613 8396 27 Apostles Apostles NNP 19613 8396 28 and and CC 19613 8396 29 apostolic apostolic JJ 19613 8396 30 men man NNS 19613 8396 31 differences difference NNS 19613 8396 32 in in IN 19613 8396 33 the the DT 19613 8396 34 degrees degree NNS 19613 8396 35 of of IN 19613 8396 36 inspiration inspiration NN 19613 8396 37 are be VBP 19613 8396 38 again again RB 19613 8396 39 to to TO 19613 8396 40 be be VB 19613 8396 41 assumed assume VBN 19613 8396 42 . . . 19613 8397 1 Here here RB 19613 8397 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8397 3 set set VBD 19613 8397 4 the the DT 19613 8397 5 example example NN 19613 8397 6 of of IN 19613 8397 7 making make VBG 19613 8397 8 a a DT 19613 8397 9 definite definite JJ 19613 8397 10 distinction distinction NN 19613 8397 11 between between IN 19613 8397 12 a a DT 19613 8397 13 heroic heroic JJ 19613 8397 14 age age NN 19613 8397 15 of of IN 19613 8397 16 the the DT 19613 8397 17 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 8397 18 and and CC 19613 8397 19 the the DT 19613 8397 20 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 8397 21 period period NN 19613 8397 22 . . . 19613 8398 1 This this DT 19613 8398 2 laid lay VBD 19613 8398 3 the the DT 19613 8398 4 foundation foundation NN 19613 8398 5 for for IN 19613 8398 6 an an DT 19613 8398 7 assumption assumption NN 19613 8398 8 through through IN 19613 8398 9 which which WDT 19613 8398 10 the the DT 19613 8398 11 later later JJ 19613 8398 12 Church church NN 19613 8398 13 down down RP 19613 8398 14 to to IN 19613 8398 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8398 16 time time NN 19613 8398 17 has have VBZ 19613 8398 18 appeased appease VBN 19613 8398 19 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8398 20 conscience conscience NN 19613 8398 21 and and CC 19613 8398 22 freed free VBD 19613 8398 23 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 8398 24 from from IN 19613 8398 25 demands demand NNS 19613 8398 26 that that IN 19613 8398 27 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8398 28 could could MD 19613 8398 29 not not RB 19613 8398 30 satisfy satisfy VB 19613 8398 31 . . . 19613 8399 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8399 2 718 718 CD 19613 8399 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8399 4 THE the DT 19613 8399 5 DOCTRINE DOCTRINE NNP 19613 8399 6 OF of IN 19613 8399 7 GOD GOD NNP 19613 8399 8 AND and CC 19613 8399 9 HIS his PRP$ 19613 8399 10 SELF SELF NNP 19613 8399 11 - - HYPH 19613 8399 12 UNFOLDINGS unfoldings NN 19613 8399 13 OR or CC 19613 8399 14 CREATIONS creations NN 19613 8399 15 . . . 19613 8400 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8400 2 719 719 LS 19613 8400 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8400 4 The the DT 19613 8400 5 world world NN 19613 8400 6 points point VBZ 19613 8400 7 back back RB 19613 8400 8 to to IN 19613 8400 9 an an DT 19613 8400 10 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 8400 11 cause cause NN 19613 8400 12 and and CC 19613 8400 13 the the DT 19613 8400 14 created create VBN 19613 8400 15 spirit spirit NN 19613 8400 16 to to IN 19613 8400 17 an an DT 19613 8400 18 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8400 19 , , , 19613 8400 20 pure pure JJ 19613 8400 21 , , , 19613 8400 22 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 8400 23 simple simple JJ 19613 8400 24 , , , 19613 8400 25 and and CC 19613 8400 26 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 8400 27 spirit spirit NN 19613 8400 28 , , , 19613 8400 29 who who WP 19613 8400 30 is be VBZ 19613 8400 31 the the DT 19613 8400 32 original original JJ 19613 8400 33 source source NN 19613 8400 34 of of IN 19613 8400 35 all all DT 19613 8400 36 existence existence NN 19613 8400 37 and and CC 19613 8400 38 goodness goodness NN 19613 8400 39 , , , 19613 8400 40 so so IN 19613 8400 41 that that IN 19613 8400 42 everything everything NN 19613 8400 43 that that WDT 19613 8400 44 exists exist VBZ 19613 8400 45 only only RB 19613 8400 46 does do VBZ 19613 8400 47 so so RB 19613 8400 48 in in IN 19613 8400 49 virtue virtue NN 19613 8400 50 of of IN 19613 8400 51 being be VBG 19613 8400 52 caused cause VBN 19613 8400 53 by by IN 19613 8400 54 that that DT 19613 8400 55 One one CD 19613 8400 56 , , , 19613 8400 57 and and CC 19613 8400 58 is be VBZ 19613 8400 59 good good JJ 19613 8400 60 in in IN 19613 8400 61 so so RB 19613 8400 62 far far RB 19613 8400 63 as as IN 19613 8400 64 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8400 65 derives derive VBZ 19613 8400 66 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8400 67 essence essence NN 19613 8400 68 from from IN 19613 8400 69 the the DT 19613 8400 70 One one NN 19613 8400 71 who who WP 19613 8400 72 is be VBZ 19613 8400 73 perfection perfection NN 19613 8400 74 and and CC 19613 8400 75 goodness goodness NN 19613 8400 76 . . . 19613 8401 1 This this DT 19613 8401 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 8401 3 idea idea NN 19613 8401 4 is be VBZ 19613 8401 5 the the DT 19613 8401 6 source source NN 19613 8401 7 of of IN 19613 8401 8 all all PDT 19613 8401 9 the the DT 19613 8401 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 8401 11 drawn draw VBN 19613 8401 12 by by IN 19613 8401 13 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8401 14 as as IN 19613 8401 15 to to IN 19613 8401 16 the the DT 19613 8401 17 essence essence NN 19613 8401 18 , , , 19613 8401 19 attributes attribute NNS 19613 8401 20 , , , 19613 8401 21 and and CC 19613 8401 22 knowableness knowableness NN 19613 8401 23 of of IN 19613 8401 24 God God NNP 19613 8401 25 . . . 19613 8402 1 As as IN 19613 8402 2 the the DT 19613 8402 3 One one CD 19613 8402 4 , , , 19613 8402 5 God God NNP 19613 8402 6 is be VBZ 19613 8402 7 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 8402 8 with with IN 19613 8402 9 the the DT 19613 8402 10 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8402 11 ; ; : 19613 8402 12 but but CC 19613 8402 13 the the DT 19613 8402 14 order order NN 19613 8402 15 in in IN 19613 8402 16 the the DT 19613 8402 17 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8402 18 points point NNS 19613 8402 19 back back RB 19613 8402 20 to to IN 19613 8402 21 the the DT 19613 8402 22 One one CD 19613 8402 23 . . . 19613 8403 1 As as IN 19613 8403 2 the the DT 19613 8403 3 real real JJ 19613 8403 4 Essence Essence NNP 19613 8403 5 , , , 19613 8403 6 God God NNP 19613 8403 7 is be VBZ 19613 8403 8 opposed opposed JJ 19613 8403 9 to to IN 19613 8403 10 the the DT 19613 8403 11 essences essence NNS 19613 8403 12 that that WDT 19613 8403 13 appear appear VBP 19613 8403 14 and and CC 19613 8403 15 seem seem VBP 19613 8403 16 to to TO 19613 8403 17 vanish vanish VB 19613 8403 18 , , , 19613 8403 19 and and CC 19613 8403 20 that that IN 19613 8403 21 therefore therefore RB 19613 8403 22 have have VBP 19613 8403 23 no no DT 19613 8403 24 real real JJ 19613 8403 25 existence existence NN 19613 8403 26 , , , 19613 8403 27 because because IN 19613 8403 28 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8403 29 have have VBP 19613 8403 30 not not RB 19613 8403 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8403 32 principle principle NN 19613 8403 33 in in IN 19613 8403 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8403 35 , , , 19613 8403 36 but but CC 19613 8403 37 testify testify VB 19613 8403 38 : : : 19613 8403 39 " " `` 19613 8403 40 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8403 41 have have VBP 19613 8403 42 not not RB 19613 8403 43 made make VBN 19613 8403 44 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8403 45 . . . 19613 8403 46 " " '' 19613 8404 1 As as IN 19613 8404 2 the the DT 19613 8404 3 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 8404 4 immaterial immaterial JJ 19613 8404 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8404 6 , , , 19613 8404 7 God God NNP 19613 8404 8 is be VBZ 19613 8404 9 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 8404 10 with with IN 19613 8404 11 the the DT 19613 8404 12 spirit spirit NN 19613 8404 13 that that WDT 19613 8404 14 is be VBZ 19613 8404 15 clogged clog VBN 19613 8404 16 with with IN 19613 8404 17 matter matter NN 19613 8404 18 , , , 19613 8404 19 but but CC 19613 8404 20 which which WDT 19613 8404 21 strives strive VBZ 19613 8404 22 to to TO 19613 8404 23 get get VB 19613 8404 24 back back RB 19613 8404 25 to to IN 19613 8404 26 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8404 27 from from IN 19613 8404 28 whom whom WP 19613 8404 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8404 30 received receive VBD 19613 8404 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8404 32 origin origin NN 19613 8404 33 . . . 19613 8405 1 The the DT 19613 8405 2 One one CD 19613 8405 3 is be VBZ 19613 8405 4 something something NN 19613 8405 5 different different JJ 19613 8405 6 from from IN 19613 8405 7 the the DT 19613 8405 8 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8405 9 ; ; : 19613 8405 10 but but CC 19613 8405 11 the the DT 19613 8405 12 order order NN 19613 8405 13 , , , 19613 8405 14 the the DT 19613 8405 15 dependence dependence NN 19613 8405 16 , , , 19613 8405 17 and and CC 19613 8405 18 the the DT 19613 8405 19 longing longing NN 19613 8405 20 of of IN 19613 8405 21 that that DT 19613 8405 22 which which WDT 19613 8405 23 is be VBZ 19613 8405 24 created create VBN 19613 8405 25 point point NN 19613 8405 26 back back RB 19613 8405 27 to to IN 19613 8405 28 the the DT 19613 8405 29 One one CD 19613 8405 30 , , , 19613 8405 31 who who WP 19613 8405 32 can can MD 19613 8405 33 therefore therefore RB 19613 8405 34 be be VB 19613 8405 35 known know VBN 19613 8405 36 relatively relatively RB 19613 8405 37 from from IN 19613 8405 38 the the DT 19613 8405 39 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8405 40 . . . 19613 8406 1 In in IN 19613 8406 2 sharpest sharp JJS 19613 8406 3 contrast contrast NN 19613 8406 4 to to IN 19613 8406 5 the the DT 19613 8406 6 heretical heretical JJ 19613 8406 7 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8406 8 , , , 19613 8406 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8406 10 maintained maintain VBD 19613 8406 11 the the DT 19613 8406 12 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8406 13 causality causality NN 19613 8406 14 of of IN 19613 8406 15 God God NNP 19613 8406 16 , , , 19613 8406 17 and and CC 19613 8406 18 , , , 19613 8406 19 in in IN 19613 8406 20 spite spite NN 19613 8406 21 of of IN 19613 8406 22 all all DT 19613 8406 23 abstractions abstraction NNS 19613 8406 24 in in IN 19613 8406 25 determining determine VBG 19613 8406 26 the the DT 19613 8406 27 essence essence NN 19613 8406 28 of of IN 19613 8406 29 God God NNP 19613 8406 30 , , , 19613 8406 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8406 32 attributed attribute VBD 19613 8406 33 self self NN 19613 8406 34 - - HYPH 19613 8406 35 consciousness consciousness NN 19613 8406 36 and and CC 19613 8406 37 will will NN 19613 8406 38 to to IN 19613 8406 39 this this DT 19613 8406 40 superessential superessential JJ 19613 8406 41 Essence Essence NNP 19613 8406 42 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8406 43 in in IN 19613 8406 44 opposition opposition NN 19613 8406 45 to to IN 19613 8406 46 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8406 47 , , , 19613 8406 48 Basilides Basilides NNP 19613 8406 49 , , , 19613 8406 50 and and CC 19613 8406 51 the the DT 19613 8406 52 later later JJ 19613 8406 53 Neoplatonists Neoplatonists NNP 19613 8406 54 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8406 55 . . . 19613 8407 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8407 2 720 720 CD 19613 8407 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8407 4 The the DT 19613 8407 5 created create VBN 19613 8407 6 is be VBZ 19613 8407 7 one one CD 19613 8407 8 thing thing NN 19613 8407 9 and and CC 19613 8407 10 the the DT 19613 8407 11 Self Self NNP 19613 8407 12 - - HYPH 19613 8407 13 existent existent NN 19613 8407 14 is be VBZ 19613 8407 15 another another DT 19613 8407 16 , , , 19613 8407 17 but but CC 19613 8407 18 both both DT 19613 8407 19 are be VBP 19613 8407 20 connected connect VBN 19613 8407 21 together together RB 19613 8407 22 ; ; , 19613 8407 23 as as IN 19613 8407 24 the the DT 19613 8407 25 created create VBN 19613 8407 26 can can MD 19613 8407 27 only only RB 19613 8407 28 be be VB 19613 8407 29 understood understand VBN 19613 8407 30 from from IN 19613 8407 31 something something NN 19613 8407 32 self self NN 19613 8407 33 - - HYPH 19613 8407 34 existent existent NN 19613 8407 35 , , , 19613 8407 36 so so CC 19613 8407 37 the the DT 19613 8407 38 self self NN 19613 8407 39 - - HYPH 19613 8407 40 existent existent NN 19613 8407 41 is be VBZ 19613 8407 42 not not RB 19613 8407 43 without without IN 19613 8407 44 analogy analogy NN 19613 8407 45 to to IN 19613 8407 46 the the DT 19613 8407 47 created create VBN 19613 8407 48 . . . 19613 8408 1 The the DT 19613 8408 2 Self Self NNP 19613 8408 3 - - HYPH 19613 8408 4 existent existent NN 19613 8408 5 is be VBZ 19613 8408 6 in in IN 19613 8408 7 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8408 8 a a DT 19613 8408 9 living live VBG 19613 8408 10 thing thing NN 19613 8408 11 ; ; : 19613 8408 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8408 13 is be VBZ 19613 8408 14 beyond beyond IN 19613 8408 15 dispute dispute NN 19613 8408 16 that that IN 19613 8408 17 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8408 18 with with IN 19613 8408 19 all all PDT 19613 8408 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8408 21 abstractions abstraction NNS 19613 8408 22 represented represent VBD 19613 8408 23 the the DT 19613 8408 24 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8408 25 , , , 19613 8408 26 whom whom WP 19613 8408 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8408 28 primarily primarily RB 19613 8408 29 conceived conceive VBD 19613 8408 30 as as IN 19613 8408 31 a a DT 19613 8408 32 constant constant JJ 19613 8408 33 substance substance NN 19613 8408 34 , , , 19613 8408 35 in in IN 19613 8408 36 a a DT 19613 8408 37 more more RBR 19613 8408 38 living living NN 19613 8408 39 , , , 19613 8408 40 and and CC 19613 8408 41 , , , 19613 8408 42 so so RB 19613 8408 43 to to TO 19613 8408 44 speak speak VB 19613 8408 45 , , , 19613 8408 46 in in IN 19613 8408 47 a a DT 19613 8408 48 more more RBR 19613 8408 49 personal personal JJ 19613 8408 50 way way NN 19613 8408 51 than than IN 19613 8408 52 the the DT 19613 8408 53 Greek greek JJ 19613 8408 54 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8408 55 . . . 19613 8409 1 Hence hence RB 19613 8409 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8409 3 was be VBD 19613 8409 4 possible possible JJ 19613 8409 5 for for IN 19613 8409 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8409 7 to to TO 19613 8409 8 produce produce VB 19613 8409 9 a a DT 19613 8409 10 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8409 11 of of IN 19613 8409 12 the the DT 19613 8409 13 attributes attribute NNS 19613 8409 14 of of IN 19613 8409 15 God God NNP 19613 8409 16 . . . 19613 8410 1 Here here RB 19613 8410 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8410 3 did do VBD 19613 8410 4 not not RB 19613 8410 5 even even RB 19613 8410 6 shrink shrink VB 19613 8410 7 from from IN 19613 8410 8 applying apply VBG 19613 8410 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8410 10 relative relative JJ 19613 8410 11 view view NN 19613 8410 12 to to IN 19613 8410 13 the the DT 19613 8410 14 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8410 15 , , , 19613 8410 16 because because IN 19613 8410 17 , , , 19613 8410 18 as as IN 19613 8410 19 will will MD 19613 8410 20 be be VB 19613 8410 21 seen see VBN 19613 8410 22 , , , 19613 8410 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8410 24 never never RB 19613 8410 25 thinks think VBZ 19613 8410 26 of of IN 19613 8410 27 God God NNP 19613 8410 28 without without IN 19613 8410 29 revelation revelation NN 19613 8410 30 , , , 19613 8410 31 and and CC 19613 8410 32 because because IN 19613 8410 33 all all DT 19613 8410 34 revelation revelation NN 19613 8410 35 must must MD 19613 8410 36 be be VB 19613 8410 37 something something NN 19613 8410 38 limited limited JJ 19613 8410 39 . . . 19613 8411 1 The the DT 19613 8411 2 omnipresence omnipresence NN 19613 8411 3 of of IN 19613 8411 4 God God NNP 19613 8411 5 indeed indeed RB 19613 8411 6 suffers suffer VBZ 19613 8411 7 from from IN 19613 8411 8 no no DT 19613 8411 9 limitation limitation NN 19613 8411 10 . . . 19613 8412 1 God God NNP 19613 8412 2 is be VBZ 19613 8412 3 potentially potentially RB 19613 8412 4 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8412 5 ; ; : 19613 8412 6 but but CC 19613 8412 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8412 8 is be VBZ 19613 8412 9 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8412 10 only only RB 19613 8412 11 potentially potentially RB 19613 8412 12 ; ; : 19613 8412 13 that that RB 19613 8412 14 is is RB 19613 8412 15 , , , 19613 8412 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8412 17 neither neither CC 19613 8412 18 encompasses encompass VBZ 19613 8412 19 nor nor CC 19613 8412 20 is be VBZ 19613 8412 21 encompassed encompass VBN 19613 8412 22 . . . 19613 8413 1 Nor nor CC 19613 8413 2 is be VBZ 19613 8413 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8413 4 diffused diffuse VBN 19613 8413 5 through through IN 19613 8413 6 the the DT 19613 8413 7 universe universe NN 19613 8413 8 , , , 19613 8413 9 but but CC 19613 8413 10 , , , 19613 8413 11 as as IN 19613 8413 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8413 13 is be VBZ 19613 8413 14 removed remove VBN 19613 8413 15 from from IN 19613 8413 16 the the DT 19613 8413 17 limits limit NNS 19613 8413 18 of of IN 19613 8413 19 space space NN 19613 8413 20 , , , 19613 8413 21 so so RB 19613 8413 22 also also RB 19613 8413 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8413 24 is be VBZ 19613 8413 25 removed remove VBN 19613 8413 26 from from IN 19613 8413 27 space space NN 19613 8413 28 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8413 29 . . . 19613 8414 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8414 2 721 721 CD 19613 8414 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8414 4 But but CC 19613 8414 5 the the DT 19613 8414 6 omniscience omniscience NN 19613 8414 7 and and CC 19613 8414 8 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 8414 9 of of IN 19613 8414 10 God God NNP 19613 8414 11 have have VBP 19613 8414 12 a a DT 19613 8414 13 limit limit NN 19613 8414 14 , , , 19613 8414 15 which which WDT 19613 8414 16 indeed indeed RB 19613 8414 17 , , , 19613 8414 18 according accord VBG 19613 8414 19 to to IN 19613 8414 20 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8414 21 , , , 19613 8414 22 lies lie VBZ 19613 8414 23 in in IN 19613 8414 24 the the DT 19613 8414 25 nature nature NN 19613 8414 26 of of IN 19613 8414 27 the the DT 19613 8414 28 case case NN 19613 8414 29 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8414 30 . . . 19613 8415 1 In in IN 19613 8415 2 the the DT 19613 8415 3 first first JJ 19613 8415 4 place place NN 19613 8415 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8415 6 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 8415 7 is be VBZ 19613 8415 8 limited limit VBN 19613 8415 9 through through IN 19613 8415 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8415 11 essence essence NN 19613 8415 12 , , , 19613 8415 13 for for IN 19613 8415 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8415 15 can can MD 19613 8415 16 only only RB 19613 8415 17 do do VB 19613 8415 18 what what WP 19613 8415 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8415 20 wills;[722 wills;[722 VBZ 19613 8415 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8415 22 secondly secondly RB 19613 8415 23 by by IN 19613 8415 24 logic logic NN 19613 8415 25 , , , 19613 8415 26 for for IN 19613 8415 27 omnipotence omnipotence NN 19613 8415 28 can can MD 19613 8415 29 not not RB 19613 8415 30 produce produce VB 19613 8415 31 things thing NNS 19613 8415 32 containing contain VBG 19613 8415 33 an an DT 19613 8415 34 inward inward JJ 19613 8415 35 contradiction contradiction NN 19613 8415 36 : : : 19613 8415 37 God God NNP 19613 8415 38 can can MD 19613 8415 39 do do VB 19613 8415 40 nothing nothing NN 19613 8415 41 contrary contrary JJ 19613 8415 42 to to IN 19613 8415 43 nature nature NN 19613 8415 44 , , , 19613 8415 45 all all DT 19613 8415 46 miracles miracle NNS 19613 8415 47 being be VBG 19613 8415 48 natural natural JJ 19613 8415 49 in in IN 19613 8415 50 the the DT 19613 8415 51 highest high JJS 19613 8415 52 sense[723]--thirdly sense[723]--thirdly RB 19613 8415 53 , , , 19613 8415 54 by by IN 19613 8415 55 the the DT 19613 8415 56 impossibility impossibility NN 19613 8415 57 of of IN 19613 8415 58 that that DT 19613 8415 59 which which WDT 19613 8415 60 is be VBZ 19613 8415 61 in in IN 19613 8415 62 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8415 63 unlimited unlimited JJ 19613 8415 64 being being NN 19613 8415 65 comprehended comprehend VBN 19613 8415 66 , , , 19613 8415 67 whence whence IN 19613 8415 68 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8415 69 follows follow VBZ 19613 8415 70 that that IN 19613 8415 71 the the DT 19613 8415 72 extent extent NN 19613 8415 73 of of IN 19613 8415 74 everything everything NN 19613 8415 75 created create VBN 19613 8415 76 must must MD 19613 8415 77 be be VB 19613 8415 78 limited[724]--fourthly limited[724]--fourthly RB 19613 8415 79 , , , 19613 8415 80 by by IN 19613 8415 81 the the DT 19613 8415 82 impossibility impossibility NN 19613 8415 83 of of IN 19613 8415 84 realising realise VBG 19613 8415 85 an an DT 19613 8415 86 aim aim NN 19613 8415 87 completely completely RB 19613 8415 88 and and CC 19613 8415 89 without without IN 19613 8415 90 disturbing disturb VBG 19613 8415 91 elements element NNS 19613 8415 92 . . . 19613 8416 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8416 2 725 725 CD 19613 8416 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8416 4 Omniscience Omniscience NNP 19613 8416 5 has have VBZ 19613 8416 6 also also RB 19613 8416 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8416 8 corresponding corresponding JJ 19613 8416 9 limits limit NNS 19613 8416 10 ; ; : 19613 8416 11 this this DT 19613 8416 12 is be VBZ 19613 8416 13 specially specially RB 19613 8416 14 proved prove VBN 19613 8416 15 from from IN 19613 8416 16 the the DT 19613 8416 17 freedom freedom NN 19613 8416 18 of of IN 19613 8416 19 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8416 20 bestowed bestow VBN 19613 8416 21 by by IN 19613 8416 22 God God NNP 19613 8416 23 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8416 24 . . . 19613 8417 1 God God NNP 19613 8417 2 has have VBZ 19613 8417 3 indeed indeed RB 19613 8417 4 the the DT 19613 8417 5 capacity capacity NN 19613 8417 6 of of IN 19613 8417 7 foreknowledge foreknowledge NN 19613 8417 8 , , , 19613 8417 9 but but CC 19613 8417 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8417 11 knows know VBZ 19613 8417 12 transactions transaction NNS 19613 8417 13 beforehand beforehand RB 19613 8417 14 because because IN 19613 8417 15 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8417 16 happen happen VBP 19613 8417 17 ; ; : 19613 8417 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8417 19 do do VBP 19613 8417 20 not not RB 19613 8417 21 happen happen VB 19613 8417 22 because because IN 19613 8417 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8417 24 knows know VBZ 19613 8417 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8417 26 . . . 19613 8418 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8418 2 726 726 CD 19613 8418 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8418 4 That that IN 19613 8418 5 the the DT 19613 8418 6 divine divine JJ 19613 8418 7 purpose purpose NN 19613 8418 8 should should MD 19613 8418 9 be be VB 19613 8418 10 realised realise VBN 19613 8418 11 in in IN 19613 8418 12 the the DT 19613 8418 13 end end NN 19613 8418 14 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8418 15 follows follow VBZ 19613 8418 16 from from IN 19613 8418 17 the the DT 19613 8418 18 nature nature NN 19613 8418 19 of of IN 19613 8418 20 the the DT 19613 8418 21 created create VBN 19613 8418 22 spirit spirit NN 19613 8418 23 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8418 24 , , , 19613 8418 25 apart apart RB 19613 8418 26 from from IN 19613 8418 27 the the DT 19613 8418 28 supporting support VBG 19613 8418 29 activity activity NN 19613 8418 30 of of IN 19613 8418 31 God God NNP 19613 8418 32 . . . 19613 8419 1 Like like IN 19613 8419 2 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8419 3 and and CC 19613 8419 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8419 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8419 6 very very RB 19613 8419 7 carefully carefully RB 19613 8419 8 discussed discuss VBD 19613 8419 9 the the DT 19613 8419 10 attributes attribute NNS 19613 8419 11 of of IN 19613 8419 12 goodness goodness NN 19613 8419 13 and and CC 19613 8419 14 justice justice NN 19613 8419 15 in in IN 19613 8419 16 God God NNP 19613 8419 17 in in IN 19613 8419 18 opposition opposition NN 19613 8419 19 to to IN 19613 8419 20 the the DT 19613 8419 21 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 8419 22 . . . 19613 8420 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8420 2 727 727 CD 19613 8420 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8420 4 But but CC 19613 8420 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8420 6 exposition exposition NN 19613 8420 7 is be VBZ 19613 8420 8 different different JJ 19613 8420 9 . . . 19613 8421 1 In in IN 19613 8421 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8421 3 eyes eye NNS 19613 8421 4 goodness goodness NN 19613 8421 5 and and CC 19613 8421 6 justice justice NN 19613 8421 7 are be VBP 19613 8421 8 not not RB 19613 8421 9 two two CD 19613 8421 10 opposite opposite JJ 19613 8421 11 attributes attribute NNS 19613 8421 12 , , , 19613 8421 13 which which WDT 19613 8421 14 can can MD 19613 8421 15 and and CC 19613 8421 16 must must MD 19613 8421 17 exist exist VB 19613 8421 18 in in IN 19613 8421 19 God God NNP 19613 8421 20 side side NN 19613 8421 21 by by IN 19613 8421 22 side side NN 19613 8421 23 ; ; : 19613 8421 24 but but CC 19613 8421 25 as as IN 19613 8421 26 virtues virtue NNS 19613 8421 27 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8421 28 are be VBP 19613 8421 29 to to IN 19613 8421 30 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8421 31 identical identical JJ 19613 8421 32 . . . 19613 8422 1 God God NNP 19613 8422 2 rewards reward VBZ 19613 8422 3 in in IN 19613 8422 4 justice justice NN 19613 8422 5 and and CC 19613 8422 6 punishes punishe NNS 19613 8422 7 in in IN 19613 8422 8 kindness kindness NN 19613 8422 9 . . . 19613 8423 1 That that IN 19613 8423 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8423 3 should should MD 19613 8423 4 go go VB 19613 8423 5 well well RB 19613 8423 6 with with IN 19613 8423 7 all all DT 19613 8423 8 , , , 19613 8423 9 no no RB 19613 8423 10 matter matter RB 19613 8423 11 how how WRB 19613 8423 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8423 13 conduct conduct VBP 19613 8423 14 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8423 15 , , , 19613 8423 16 would would MD 19613 8423 17 be be VB 19613 8423 18 no no DT 19613 8423 19 kindness kindness NN 19613 8423 20 ; ; : 19613 8423 21 but but CC 19613 8423 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8423 23 is be VBZ 19613 8423 24 kindness kindness NN 19613 8423 25 when when WRB 19613 8423 26 God God NNP 19613 8423 27 punishes punish VBZ 19613 8423 28 to to TO 19613 8423 29 improve improve VB 19613 8423 30 , , , 19613 8423 31 deter deter VB 19613 8423 32 , , , 19613 8423 33 and and CC 19613 8423 34 prevent prevent VB 19613 8423 35 . . . 19613 8424 1 Passions passion NNS 19613 8424 2 , , , 19613 8424 3 anger anger NN 19613 8424 4 , , , 19613 8424 5 and and CC 19613 8424 6 the the DT 19613 8424 7 like like JJ 19613 8424 8 do do VBP 19613 8424 9 not not RB 19613 8424 10 exist exist VB 19613 8424 11 in in IN 19613 8424 12 God God NNP 19613 8424 13 , , , 19613 8424 14 nor nor CC 19613 8424 15 any any DT 19613 8424 16 plurality plurality NN 19613 8424 17 of of IN 19613 8424 18 virtues virtue NNS 19613 8424 19 ; ; : 19613 8424 20 but but CC 19613 8424 21 , , , 19613 8424 22 as as IN 19613 8424 23 the the DT 19613 8424 24 Perfect Perfect NNP 19613 8424 25 One One NNP 19613 8424 26 , , , 19613 8424 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8424 28 is be VBZ 19613 8424 29 all all DT 19613 8424 30 kindness kindness NN 19613 8424 31 . . . 19613 8425 1 In in IN 19613 8425 2 other other JJ 19613 8425 3 places place NNS 19613 8425 4 , , , 19613 8425 5 however however RB 19613 8425 6 , , , 19613 8425 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8425 8 did do VBD 19613 8425 9 not not RB 19613 8425 10 content content VB 19613 8425 11 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8425 12 with with IN 19613 8425 13 this this DT 19613 8425 14 presentation presentation NN 19613 8425 15 . . . 19613 8426 1 In in IN 19613 8426 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 8426 3 to to IN 19613 8426 4 the the DT 19613 8426 5 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 8426 6 , , , 19613 8426 7 who who WP 19613 8426 8 declared declare VBD 19613 8426 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8426 10 and and CC 19613 8426 11 the the DT 19613 8426 12 Father Father NNP 19613 8426 13 of of IN 19613 8426 14 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8426 15 to to TO 19613 8426 16 be be VB 19613 8426 17 good good JJ 19613 8426 18 , , , 19613 8426 19 and and CC 19613 8426 20 the the DT 19613 8426 21 creator creator NN 19613 8426 22 of of IN 19613 8426 23 the the DT 19613 8426 24 world world NN 19613 8426 25 to to TO 19613 8426 26 be be VB 19613 8426 27 just just RB 19613 8426 28 , , , 19613 8426 29 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8426 30 argued argue VBD 19613 8426 31 that that IN 19613 8426 32 , , , 19613 8426 33 on on IN 19613 8426 34 the the DT 19613 8426 35 contrary contrary NN 19613 8426 36 , , , 19613 8426 37 God God NNP 19613 8426 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8426 39 the the DT 19613 8426 40 foundation foundation NN 19613 8426 41 of of IN 19613 8426 42 the the DT 19613 8426 43 world world NN 19613 8426 44 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8426 45 is be VBZ 19613 8426 46 good good JJ 19613 8426 47 , , , 19613 8426 48 but but CC 19613 8426 49 that that IN 19613 8426 50 the the DT 19613 8426 51 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8426 52 - - HYPH 19613 8426 53 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8426 54 , , , 19613 8426 55 in in IN 19613 8426 56 so so RB 19613 8426 57 far far RB 19613 8426 58 as as IN 19613 8426 59 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8426 60 is be VBZ 19613 8426 61 the the DT 19613 8426 62 pedagogus pedagogus NN 19613 8426 63 , , , 19613 8426 64 is be VBZ 19613 8426 65 just just RB 19613 8426 66 . . . 19613 8427 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8427 2 728 728 CD 19613 8427 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8427 4 From from IN 19613 8427 5 the the DT 19613 8427 6 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8427 7 goodness goodness NN 19613 8427 8 of of IN 19613 8427 9 God God NNP 19613 8427 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8427 11 infers infer VBZ 19613 8427 12 that that IN 19613 8427 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8427 14 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 8427 15 or or CC 19613 8427 16 communicates communicate VBZ 19613 8427 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8427 18 , , , 19613 8427 19 from from IN 19613 8427 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8427 21 immutability immutability NN 19613 8427 22 that that IN 19613 8427 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8427 24 _ _ NNP 19613 8427 25 always always RB 19613 8427 26 _ _ NNP 19613 8427 27 reveals reveal VBZ 19613 8427 28 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8427 29 . . . 19613 8428 1 The the DT 19613 8428 2 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8428 3 or or CC 19613 8428 4 never never RB 19613 8428 5 beginning begin VBG 19613 8428 6 communication communication NN 19613 8428 7 of of IN 19613 8428 8 perfection perfection NN 19613 8428 9 to to IN 19613 8428 10 other other JJ 19613 8428 11 beings being NNS 19613 8428 12 is be VBZ 19613 8428 13 a a DT 19613 8428 14 postulate postulate NN 19613 8428 15 of of IN 19613 8428 16 the the DT 19613 8428 17 concept concept NN 19613 8428 18 " " `` 19613 8428 19 God God NNP 19613 8428 20 " " '' 19613 8428 21 . . . 19613 8429 1 But but CC 19613 8429 2 , , , 19613 8429 3 along along IN 19613 8429 4 with with IN 19613 8429 5 the the DT 19613 8429 6 whole whole JJ 19613 8429 7 fraternity fraternity NN 19613 8429 8 of of IN 19613 8429 9 those those DT 19613 8429 10 professing profess VBG 19613 8429 11 the the DT 19613 8429 12 same same JJ 19613 8429 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8429 14 , , , 19613 8429 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8429 16 assumed assume VBD 19613 8429 17 that that IN 19613 8429 18 the the DT 19613 8429 19 One one CD 19613 8429 20 , , , 19613 8429 21 in in IN 19613 8429 22 becoming become VBG 19613 8429 23 the the DT 19613 8429 24 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8429 25 and and CC 19613 8429 26 acting act VBG 19613 8429 27 in in IN 19613 8429 28 the the DT 19613 8429 29 interests interest NNS 19613 8429 30 of of IN 19613 8429 31 the the DT 19613 8429 32 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8429 33 , , , 19613 8429 34 can can MD 19613 8429 35 only only RB 19613 8429 36 effect effect VB 19613 8429 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8429 38 purpose purpose NN 19613 8429 39 by by IN 19613 8429 40 divesting divest VBG 19613 8429 41 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8429 42 of of IN 19613 8429 43 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8429 44 apathy apathy NNP 19613 8429 45 and and CC 19613 8429 46 once once RB 19613 8429 47 more more RBR 19613 8429 48 assuming assume VBG 19613 8429 49 a a DT 19613 8429 50 form form NN 19613 8429 51 in in IN 19613 8429 52 which which WDT 19613 8429 53 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8429 54 can can MD 19613 8429 55 act act VB 19613 8429 56 , , , 19613 8429 57 that that RB 19613 8429 58 is is RB 19613 8429 59 , , , 19613 8429 60 procuring procure VBG 19613 8429 61 for for IN 19613 8429 62 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8429 63 an an DT 19613 8429 64 adequate adequate NN 19613 8429 65 organ--_the organ--_the NNP 19613 8429 66 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8429 67 _ _ NNP 19613 8429 68 . . . 19613 8430 1 The the DT 19613 8430 2 content content NN 19613 8430 3 of of IN 19613 8430 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8430 5 's 's POS 19613 8430 6 teaching teaching NN 19613 8430 7 about about IN 19613 8430 8 this this DT 19613 8430 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8430 10 was be VBD 19613 8430 11 not not RB 19613 8430 12 essentially essentially RB 19613 8430 13 different different JJ 19613 8430 14 from from IN 19613 8430 15 that that DT 19613 8430 16 of of IN 19613 8430 17 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8430 18 and and CC 19613 8430 19 was be VBD 19613 8430 20 therefore therefore RB 19613 8430 21 quite quite RB 19613 8430 22 as as IN 19613 8430 23 contradictory contradictory JJ 19613 8430 24 ; ; : 19613 8430 25 only only RB 19613 8430 26 in in IN 19613 8430 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8430 28 case case NN 19613 8430 29 everything everything NN 19613 8430 30 is be VBZ 19613 8430 31 more more RBR 19613 8430 32 sharply sharply RB 19613 8430 33 defined define VBN 19613 8430 34 and and CC 19613 8430 35 the the DT 19613 8430 36 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 8430 37 of of IN 19613 8430 38 the the DT 19613 8430 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8430 40 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8430 41 in in IN 19613 8430 42 opposition opposition NN 19613 8430 43 to to IN 19613 8430 44 the the DT 19613 8430 45 Monarchians Monarchians NNPS 19613 8430 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8430 47 more more RBR 19613 8430 48 clearly clearly RB 19613 8430 49 and and CC 19613 8430 50 precisely precisely RB 19613 8430 51 stated state VBN 19613 8430 52 . . . 19613 8431 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8431 2 729 729 CD 19613 8431 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8431 4 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 8431 5 the the DT 19613 8431 6 personal personal JJ 19613 8431 7 independence independence NN 19613 8431 8 of of IN 19613 8431 9 the the DT 19613 8431 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8431 11 is be VBZ 19613 8431 12 as as RB 19613 8431 13 yet yet RB 19613 8431 14 by by IN 19613 8431 15 no no DT 19613 8431 16 means means NN 19613 8431 17 so so RB 19613 8431 18 sharply sharply RB 19613 8431 19 defined define VBN 19613 8431 20 as as IN 19613 8431 21 in in IN 19613 8431 22 the the DT 19613 8431 23 case case NN 19613 8431 24 of of IN 19613 8431 25 the the DT 19613 8431 26 later later JJ 19613 8431 27 Arians Arians NNPS 19613 8431 28 . . . 19613 8432 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8432 2 is be VBZ 19613 8432 3 still still RB 19613 8432 4 the the DT 19613 8432 5 Consciousness Consciousness NNP 19613 8432 6 of of IN 19613 8432 7 God God NNP 19613 8432 8 , , , 19613 8432 9 the the DT 19613 8432 10 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8432 11 Activity Activity NNP 19613 8432 12 of of IN 19613 8432 13 God God NNP 19613 8432 14 . . . 19613 8433 1 Hence hence RB 19613 8433 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8433 3 is be VBZ 19613 8433 4 on on IN 19613 8433 5 the the DT 19613 8433 6 one one CD 19613 8433 7 hand hand NN 19613 8433 8 the the DT 19613 8433 9 idea idea NN 19613 8433 10 of of IN 19613 8433 11 the the DT 19613 8433 12 world world NN 19613 8433 13 existing exist VBG 19613 8433 14 in in IN 19613 8433 15 God God NNP 19613 8433 16 , , , 19613 8433 17 and and CC 19613 8433 18 on on IN 19613 8433 19 the the DT 19613 8433 20 other other JJ 19613 8433 21 the the DT 19613 8433 22 product product NN 19613 8433 23 of of IN 19613 8433 24 divine divine JJ 19613 8433 25 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8433 26 originating originate VBG 19613 8433 27 with with IN 19613 8433 28 the the DT 19613 8433 29 will will NN 19613 8433 30 of of IN 19613 8433 31 God God NNP 19613 8433 32 . . . 19613 8434 1 The the DT 19613 8434 2 following follow VBG 19613 8434 3 are be VBP 19613 8434 4 the the DT 19613 8434 5 most most RBS 19613 8434 6 important important JJ 19613 8434 7 propositions proposition NNS 19613 8434 8 . . . 19613 8435 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8435 2 730 730 CD 19613 8435 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8435 4 The the DT 19613 8435 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8435 6 who who WP 19613 8435 7 appeared appear VBD 19613 8435 8 in in IN 19613 8435 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8435 10 , , , 19613 8435 11 as as IN 19613 8435 12 is be VBZ 19613 8435 13 specially specially RB 19613 8435 14 shown show VBN 19613 8435 15 from from IN 19613 8435 16 Joh Joh NNP 19613 8435 17 . . . 19613 8436 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8437 1 1 1 LS 19613 8437 2 and and CC 19613 8437 3 Heb Heb NNP 19613 8437 4 . . . 19613 8438 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8439 1 1 1 CD 19613 8439 2 , , , 19613 8439 3 is be VBZ 19613 8439 4 the the DT 19613 8439 5 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8439 6 image[731 image[731 NN 19613 8439 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8439 8 of of IN 19613 8439 9 God God NNP 19613 8439 10 . . . 19613 8440 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8440 2 is be VBZ 19613 8440 3 the the DT 19613 8440 4 Wisdom Wisdom NNP 19613 8440 5 of of IN 19613 8440 6 God God NNP 19613 8440 7 , , , 19613 8440 8 the the DT 19613 8440 9 reflection reflection NN 19613 8440 10 of of IN 19613 8440 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8440 12 perfection perfection NN 19613 8440 13 and and CC 19613 8440 14 glory glory NN 19613 8440 15 , , , 19613 8440 16 the the DT 19613 8440 17 invisible invisible JJ 19613 8440 18 image image NN 19613 8440 19 of of IN 19613 8440 20 God God NNP 19613 8440 21 . . . 19613 8441 1 For for IN 19613 8441 2 that that DT 19613 8441 3 very very JJ 19613 8441 4 reason reason NN 19613 8441 5 there there EX 19613 8441 6 is be VBZ 19613 8441 7 nothing nothing NN 19613 8441 8 corporeal corporeal JJ 19613 8441 9 in in IN 19613 8441 10 him[732 him[732 NNP 19613 8441 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8441 12 and and CC 19613 8441 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8441 14 is be VBZ 19613 8441 15 therefore therefore RB 19613 8441 16 really really RB 19613 8441 17 God God NNP 19613 8441 18 , , , 19613 8441 19 not not RB 19613 8441 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8441 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8441 22 : : : 19613 8441 23 autotheos autotheos NNP 19613 8441 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8441 25 , , , 19613 8441 26 nor nor CC 19613 8441 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8441 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8441 29 : : : 19613 8441 30 ho ho NNP 19613 8441 31 Theos Theos NNP 19613 8441 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8441 33 , , , 19613 8441 34 nor nor CC 19613 8441 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8441 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8441 37 : : : 19613 8441 38 anarchos anarchos NNP 19613 8441 39 archê archê NNP 19613 8441 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8441 41 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8441 42 " " `` 19613 8441 43 beginningless beginningless NN 19613 8441 44 beginning beginning NN 19613 8441 45 " " '' 19613 8441 46 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8441 47 , , , 19613 8441 48 but but CC 19613 8441 49 the the DT 19613 8441 50 second second JJ 19613 8441 51 God God NNP 19613 8441 52 . . . 19613 8442 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8442 2 733 733 CD 19613 8442 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8442 4 But but CC 19613 8442 5 , , , 19613 8442 6 as as IN 19613 8442 7 such such JJ 19613 8442 8 , , , 19613 8442 9 immutability immutability NN 19613 8442 10 is be VBZ 19613 8442 11 one one CD 19613 8442 12 of of IN 19613 8442 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8442 14 attributes attribute NNS 19613 8442 15 , , , 19613 8442 16 that that RB 19613 8442 17 is is RB 19613 8442 18 , , , 19613 8442 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8442 20 can can MD 19613 8442 21 never never RB 19613 8442 22 lose lose VB 19613 8442 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8442 24 divine divine JJ 19613 8442 25 essence essence NN 19613 8442 26 , , , 19613 8442 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8442 28 can can MD 19613 8442 29 also also RB 19613 8442 30 in in IN 19613 8442 31 this this DT 19613 8442 32 respect respect NN 19613 8442 33 neither neither CC 19613 8442 34 increase increase NN 19613 8442 35 nor nor CC 19613 8442 36 decrease decrease VB 19613 8442 37 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8442 38 this this DT 19613 8442 39 immutability immutability NN 19613 8442 40 , , , 19613 8442 41 however however RB 19613 8442 42 , , , 19613 8442 43 is be VBZ 19613 8442 44 not not RB 19613 8442 45 an an DT 19613 8442 46 independent independent JJ 19613 8442 47 attribute attribute NN 19613 8442 48 , , , 19613 8442 49 but but CC 19613 8442 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8442 51 is be VBZ 19613 8442 52 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8442 53 as as IN 19613 8442 54 being be VBG 19613 8442 55 an an DT 19613 8442 56 image image NN 19613 8442 57 of of IN 19613 8442 58 the the DT 19613 8442 59 Father Father NNP 19613 8442 60 's 's POS 19613 8442 61 perfection perfection NN 19613 8442 62 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8442 63 . . . 19613 8443 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8443 2 734 734 CD 19613 8443 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8443 4 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8443 5 this this DT 19613 8443 6 deity deity NN 19613 8443 7 is be VBZ 19613 8443 8 not not RB 19613 8443 9 a a DT 19613 8443 10 communicated communicate VBN 19613 8443 11 one one CD 19613 8443 12 in in IN 19613 8443 13 the the DT 19613 8443 14 sense sense NN 19613 8443 15 of of IN 19613 8443 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8443 17 having have VBG 19613 8443 18 another another DT 19613 8443 19 independent independent JJ 19613 8443 20 essence essence NN 19613 8443 21 in in IN 19613 8443 22 addition addition NN 19613 8443 23 to to IN 19613 8443 24 this this DT 19613 8443 25 divine divine JJ 19613 8443 26 nature nature NN 19613 8443 27 ; ; : 19613 8443 28 but but CC 19613 8443 29 deity deity NN 19613 8443 30 rather rather RB 19613 8443 31 constitutes constitute VBZ 19613 8443 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8443 33 essence essence NN 19613 8443 34 : : : 19613 8443 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8443 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8443 37 : : : 19613 8443 38 ho ho NNP 19613 8443 39 sotêr sotêr NNP 19613 8443 40 ou ou NNP 19613 8443 41 kata kata NNP 19613 8443 42 metousian metousian NNP 19613 8443 43 , , , 19613 8443 44 alla alla NNP 19613 8443 45 kat kat NNP 19613 8443 46 ' ' `` 19613 8443 47 ousian ousian JJ 19613 8443 48 esti esti NN 19613 8443 49 Theos][735 Theos][735 NNP 19613 8443 50 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8443 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8443 52 " " `` 19613 8443 53 the the DT 19613 8443 54 Saviour Saviour NNP 19613 8443 55 is be VBZ 19613 8443 56 not not RB 19613 8443 57 God God NNP 19613 8443 58 by by IN 19613 8443 59 communication communication NN 19613 8443 60 , , , 19613 8443 61 but but CC 19613 8443 62 in in IN 19613 8443 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8443 64 essence essence NN 19613 8443 65 " " '' 19613 8443 66 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8443 67 . . . 19613 8444 1 From from IN 19613 8444 2 this this DT 19613 8444 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8444 4 follows follow VBZ 19613 8444 5 that that IN 19613 8444 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8444 7 shares share VBZ 19613 8444 8 in in IN 19613 8444 9 the the DT 19613 8444 10 essence essence NN 19613 8444 11 of of IN 19613 8444 12 God God NNP 19613 8444 13 , , , 19613 8444 14 therefore therefore RB 19613 8444 15 of of IN 19613 8444 16 the the DT 19613 8444 17 Father Father NNP 19613 8444 18 , , , 19613 8444 19 and and CC 19613 8444 20 is be VBZ 19613 8444 21 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8444 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8444 23 Greek greek JJ 19613 8444 24 : : : 19613 8444 25 homoousios homoousio NNS 19613 8444 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8444 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8444 28 " " `` 19613 8444 29 the the DT 19613 8444 30 same same JJ 19613 8444 31 in in IN 19613 8444 32 substance substance NN 19613 8444 33 with with IN 19613 8444 34 the the DT 19613 8444 35 Father Father NNP 19613 8444 36 " " '' 19613 8444 37 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8444 38 or or CC 19613 8444 39 , , , 19613 8444 40 seeing see VBG 19613 8444 41 that that DT 19613 8444 42 , , , 19613 8444 43 as as IN 19613 8444 44 Son Son NNP 19613 8444 45 , , , 19613 8444 46 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8444 47 has have VBZ 19613 8444 48 come come VBN 19613 8444 49 forth forth RB 19613 8444 50 from from IN 19613 8444 51 the the DT 19613 8444 52 Father Father NNP 19613 8444 53 , , , 19613 8444 54 is be VBZ 19613 8444 55 engendered engender VBN 19613 8444 56 from from IN 19613 8444 57 the the DT 19613 8444 58 essence essence NN 19613 8444 59 of of IN 19613 8444 60 the the DT 19613 8444 61 Father Father NNP 19613 8444 62 . . . 19613 8445 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8445 2 736 736 CD 19613 8445 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8445 4 But but CC 19613 8445 5 having have VBG 19613 8445 6 proceeded proceed VBN 19613 8445 7 , , , 19613 8445 8 like like IN 19613 8445 9 the the DT 19613 8445 10 will will NN 19613 8445 11 , , , 19613 8445 12 from from IN 19613 8445 13 the the DT 19613 8445 14 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8445 15 , , , 19613 8445 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8445 17 was be VBD 19613 8445 18 always always RB 19613 8445 19 with with IN 19613 8445 20 God God NNP 19613 8445 21 ; ; : 19613 8445 22 there there EX 19613 8445 23 was be VBD 19613 8445 24 not not RB 19613 8445 25 a a DT 19613 8445 26 time time NN 19613 8445 27 when when WRB 19613 8445 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8445 29 was be VBD 19613 8445 30 not,[737 not,[737 NNS 19613 8445 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8445 32 nay nay NN 19613 8445 33 , , , 19613 8445 34 even even RB 19613 8445 35 this this DT 19613 8445 36 expression expression NN 19613 8445 37 is be VBZ 19613 8445 38 still still RB 19613 8445 39 too too RB 19613 8445 40 weak weak JJ 19613 8445 41 . . . 19613 8446 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8446 2 would would MD 19613 8446 3 be be VB 19613 8446 4 an an DT 19613 8446 5 unworthy unworthy JJ 19613 8446 6 idea idea NN 19613 8446 7 to to TO 19613 8446 8 think think VB 19613 8446 9 of of IN 19613 8446 10 God God NNP 19613 8446 11 without without IN 19613 8446 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8446 13 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8446 14 or or CC 19613 8446 15 to to TO 19613 8446 16 assume assume VB 19613 8446 17 a a DT 19613 8446 18 beginning beginning NN 19613 8446 19 of of IN 19613 8446 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8446 21 begetting begetting NN 19613 8446 22 . . . 19613 8447 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8447 2 , , , 19613 8447 3 this this DT 19613 8447 4 begetting begetting NN 19613 8447 5 is be VBZ 19613 8447 6 not not RB 19613 8447 7 an an DT 19613 8447 8 act act NN 19613 8447 9 that that WDT 19613 8447 10 has have VBZ 19613 8447 11 only only RB 19613 8447 12 once once RB 19613 8447 13 taken take VBN 19613 8447 14 place place NN 19613 8447 15 , , , 19613 8447 16 but but CC 19613 8447 17 a a DT 19613 8447 18 process process NN 19613 8447 19 lasting last VBG 19613 8447 20 from from IN 19613 8447 21 all all DT 19613 8447 22 eternity eternity NN 19613 8447 23 ; ; : 19613 8447 24 the the DT 19613 8447 25 Son Son NNP 19613 8447 26 is be VBZ 19613 8447 27 always always RB 19613 8447 28 being be VBG 19613 8447 29 begotten beget VBN 19613 8447 30 of of IN 19613 8447 31 the the DT 19613 8447 32 Father Father NNP 19613 8447 33 . . . 19613 8448 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8448 2 738 738 CD 19613 8448 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8448 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8448 5 is be VBZ 19613 8448 6 the the DT 19613 8448 7 theology theology NN 19613 8448 8 of of IN 19613 8448 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8448 10 which which WDT 19613 8448 11 Gregory Gregory NNP 19613 8448 12 Thaumaturgus Thaumaturgus NNP 19613 8448 13 has have VBZ 19613 8448 14 thus thus RB 19613 8448 15 summed sum VBN 19613 8448 16 up:[739 up:[739 NN 19613 8448 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8448 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8448 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8448 20 : : : 19613 8448 21 eis eis NNP 19613 8448 22 kurios kurio VBZ 19613 8448 23 , , , 19613 8448 24 monos monos NNP 19613 8448 25 ek ek NNP 19613 8448 26 monou monou NN 19613 8448 27 , , , 19613 8448 28 theos theos NNP 19613 8448 29 ek ek NNP 19613 8448 30 theou theou NNP 19613 8448 31 , , , 19613 8448 32 charaktêr charaktêr NNP 19613 8448 33 kai kai NNP 19613 8448 34 eikôn eikôn NNP 19613 8448 35 tês tês NNP 19613 8448 36 theotêtos theotêtos NNP 19613 8448 37 , , , 19613 8448 38 logos logos NNP 19613 8448 39 energos energos NNP 19613 8448 40 , , , 19613 8448 41 sophia sophia NNP 19613 8448 42 tês tês NNP 19613 8448 43 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8448 44 holôn holôn NNP 19613 8448 45 sustaseôs sustaseôs NNP 19613 8448 46 periektikê periektikê NNP 19613 8448 47 kai kai NNP 19613 8448 48 dunamis dunamis NNP 19613 8448 49 tês tês NNP 19613 8448 50 holês holês NNP 19613 8448 51 ktiseôs ktiseôs NNP 19613 8448 52 poiêtikê poiêtikê NNP 19613 8448 53 , , , 19613 8448 54 huios huio VBZ 19613 8448 55 alêthinos alêthinos NNP 19613 8448 56 alêthinou alêthinou NNP 19613 8448 57 patros patro NNS 19613 8448 58 , , , 19613 8448 59 aoratos aoratos NNP 19613 8448 60 aoratou aoratou NNP 19613 8448 61 kai kai NNP 19613 8448 62 aphthartos aphthartos NNP 19613 8448 63 aphthartou aphthartou NNP 19613 8448 64 kai kai NNP 19613 8448 65 athanatos athanatos NNP 19613 8448 66 athanatou athanatou NNP 19613 8448 67 kai kai NNP 19613 8448 68 aidios aidios NNP 19613 8448 69 aidiou aidiou NNP 19613 8448 70 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8448 71 . . . 19613 8449 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8449 2 " " `` 19613 8449 3 One one CD 19613 8449 4 Lord Lord NNP 19613 8449 5 , , , 19613 8449 6 one one CD 19613 8449 7 from from IN 19613 8449 8 one one CD 19613 8449 9 , , , 19613 8449 10 God God NNP 19613 8449 11 from from IN 19613 8449 12 God God NNP 19613 8449 13 , , , 19613 8449 14 impress impress NN 19613 8449 15 and and CC 19613 8449 16 image image NN 19613 8449 17 of of IN 19613 8449 18 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 8449 19 , , , 19613 8449 20 energetic energetic JJ 19613 8449 21 word word NN 19613 8449 22 , , , 19613 8449 23 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8449 24 embracing embrace VBG 19613 8449 25 the the DT 19613 8449 26 entire entire JJ 19613 8449 27 system system NN 19613 8449 28 of of IN 19613 8449 29 the the DT 19613 8449 30 universe universe NN 19613 8449 31 and and CC 19613 8449 32 power power NN 19613 8449 33 producing produce VBG 19613 8449 34 all all DT 19613 8449 35 creation creation NN 19613 8449 36 , , , 19613 8449 37 true true JJ 19613 8449 38 Son Son NNP 19613 8449 39 of of IN 19613 8449 40 a a DT 19613 8449 41 true true JJ 19613 8449 42 Father Father NNP 19613 8449 43 , , , 19613 8449 44 the the DT 19613 8449 45 invisible invisible JJ 19613 8449 46 of of IN 19613 8449 47 the the DT 19613 8449 48 invisible invisible JJ 19613 8449 49 and and CC 19613 8449 50 incorruptible incorruptible JJ 19613 8449 51 of of IN 19613 8449 52 the the DT 19613 8449 53 incorruptible incorruptible JJ 19613 8449 54 , , , 19613 8449 55 the the DT 19613 8449 56 immortal immortal JJ 19613 8449 57 of of IN 19613 8449 58 the the DT 19613 8449 59 immortal immortal JJ 19613 8449 60 , , , 19613 8449 61 the the DT 19613 8449 62 eternal eternal NN 19613 8449 63 of of IN 19613 8449 64 the the DT 19613 8449 65 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8449 66 " " '' 19613 8449 67 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8449 68 . . . 19613 8450 1 The the DT 19613 8450 2 begetting begetting NN 19613 8450 3 is be VBZ 19613 8450 4 an an DT 19613 8450 5 indescribable indescribable JJ 19613 8450 6 act act NN 19613 8450 7 which which WDT 19613 8450 8 can can MD 19613 8450 9 only only RB 19613 8450 10 be be VB 19613 8450 11 represented represent VBN 19613 8450 12 by by IN 19613 8450 13 inadequate inadequate JJ 19613 8450 14 images image NNS 19613 8450 15 : : : 19613 8450 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8450 17 is be VBZ 19613 8450 18 no no DT 19613 8450 19 emanation emanation NN 19613 8450 20 -- -- : 19613 8450 21 the the DT 19613 8450 22 expression expression NN 19613 8450 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8450 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8450 25 : : : 19613 8450 26 probolê probolê NN 19613 8450 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8450 28 is be VBZ 19613 8450 29 not not RB 19613 8450 30 found find VBN 19613 8450 31 , , , 19613 8450 32 so so RB 19613 8450 33 far far RB 19613 8450 34 as as IN 19613 8450 35 I -PRON- PRP 19613 8450 36 know[740]--but know[740]--but VBP 19613 8450 37 is be VBZ 19613 8450 38 rather rather RB 19613 8450 39 to to TO 19613 8450 40 be be VB 19613 8450 41 designated designate VBN 19613 8450 42 as as IN 19613 8450 43 an an DT 19613 8450 44 act act NN 19613 8450 45 of of IN 19613 8450 46 the the DT 19613 8450 47 will will NN 19613 8450 48 arising arise VBG 19613 8450 49 from from IN 19613 8450 50 an an DT 19613 8450 51 inner inner JJ 19613 8450 52 necessity necessity NN 19613 8450 53 , , , 19613 8450 54 an an DT 19613 8450 55 act act NN 19613 8450 56 which which WDT 19613 8450 57 for for IN 19613 8450 58 that that DT 19613 8450 59 very very JJ 19613 8450 60 reason reason NN 19613 8450 61 is be VBZ 19613 8450 62 an an DT 19613 8450 63 emanation emanation NN 19613 8450 64 of of IN 19613 8450 65 the the DT 19613 8450 66 essence essence NN 19613 8450 67 . . . 19613 8451 1 But but CC 19613 8451 2 the the DT 19613 8451 3 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8451 4 thus thus RB 19613 8451 5 produced produce VBD 19613 8451 6 is be VBZ 19613 8451 7 really really RB 19613 8451 8 a a DT 19613 8451 9 personally personally RB 19613 8451 10 existing existing JJ 19613 8451 11 being being NN 19613 8451 12 ; ; : 19613 8451 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8451 14 is be VBZ 19613 8451 15 not not RB 19613 8451 16 an an DT 19613 8451 17 impersonal impersonal JJ 19613 8451 18 force force NN 19613 8451 19 of of IN 19613 8451 20 the the DT 19613 8451 21 Father Father NNP 19613 8451 22 , , , 19613 8451 23 though though IN 19613 8451 24 this this DT 19613 8451 25 still still RB 19613 8451 26 appears appear VBZ 19613 8451 27 to to TO 19613 8451 28 be be VB 19613 8451 29 the the DT 19613 8451 30 case case NN 19613 8451 31 in in IN 19613 8451 32 some some DT 19613 8451 33 passages passage NNS 19613 8451 34 of of IN 19613 8451 35 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8451 36 , , , 19613 8451 37 but but CC 19613 8451 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8451 39 is be VBZ 19613 8451 40 the the DT 19613 8451 41 " " `` 19613 8451 42 sapientia sapientia NN 19613 8451 43 dei dei NNP 19613 8451 44 substantialiter substantialiter NN 19613 8451 45 subsistens"[741 subsistens"[741 NNS 19613 8451 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8451 47 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8451 48 " " `` 19613 8451 49 the the DT 19613 8451 50 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8451 51 of of IN 19613 8451 52 God God NNP 19613 8451 53 substantially substantially RB 19613 8451 54 existing exist VBG 19613 8451 55 " " '' 19613 8451 56 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8451 57 " " `` 19613 8451 58 figura figura NNP 19613 8451 59 expressa expressa NNP 19613 8451 60 substantial substantial NNP 19613 8451 61 patris patris NNP 19613 8451 62 " " '' 19613 8451 63 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8451 64 " " `` 19613 8451 65 express express JJ 19613 8451 66 image image NN 19613 8451 67 of of IN 19613 8451 68 the the DT 19613 8451 69 Father Father NNP 19613 8451 70 's 's POS 19613 8451 71 substance substance NN 19613 8451 72 " " '' 19613 8451 73 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8451 74 , , , 19613 8451 75 " " '' 19613 8451 76 virtus virtus NNP 19613 8451 77 altera altera NNP 19613 8451 78 in in IN 19613 8451 79 sua sua NNP 19613 8451 80 proprietate proprietate NNP 19613 8451 81 subsistens subsisten NNS 19613 8451 82 " " '' 19613 8451 83 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8451 84 " " `` 19613 8451 85 a a DT 19613 8451 86 second second JJ 19613 8451 87 force force NN 19613 8451 88 existing exist VBG 19613 8451 89 in in IN 19613 8451 90 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8451 91 own own JJ 19613 8451 92 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 8451 93 fashion fashion NN 19613 8451 94 " " '' 19613 8451 95 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8451 96 . . . 19613 8452 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8452 2 is be VBZ 19613 8452 3 , , , 19613 8452 4 and and CC 19613 8452 5 here here RB 19613 8452 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8452 7 appeals appeal NNS 19613 8452 8 to to IN 19613 8452 9 the the DT 19613 8452 10 old old JJ 19613 8452 11 Acts act NNS 19613 8452 12 of of IN 19613 8452 13 Paul Paul NNP 19613 8452 14 , , , 19613 8452 15 an an DT 19613 8452 16 " " `` 19613 8452 17 animal animal NN 19613 8452 18 vivens viven NNS 19613 8452 19 " " '' 19613 8452 20 with with IN 19613 8452 21 an an DT 19613 8452 22 independent independent JJ 19613 8452 23 existence existence NN 19613 8452 24 . . . 19613 8453 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8453 2 742 742 CD 19613 8453 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8453 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8453 5 is be VBZ 19613 8453 6 another another DT 19613 8453 7 person,[743 person,[743 NNP 19613 8453 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8453 9 namely namely RB 19613 8453 10 , , , 19613 8453 11 the the DT 19613 8453 12 second second JJ 19613 8453 13 person person NN 19613 8453 14 in in IN 19613 8453 15 number number NN 19613 8453 16 . . . 19613 8454 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8454 2 744 744 CD 19613 8454 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8454 4 But but CC 19613 8454 5 here here RB 19613 8454 6 already already RB 19613 8454 7 begins begin VBZ 19613 8454 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8454 9 's 's POS 19613 8454 10 second second JJ 19613 8454 11 train train NN 19613 8454 12 of of IN 19613 8454 13 thought thought NN 19613 8454 14 which which WDT 19613 8454 15 limits limit VBZ 19613 8454 16 the the DT 19613 8454 17 first first JJ 19613 8454 18 that that WDT 19613 8454 19 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8454 20 have have VBP 19613 8454 21 set set VBN 19613 8454 22 forth forth RB 19613 8454 23 . . . 19613 8455 1 As as IN 19613 8455 2 a a DT 19613 8455 3 particular particular JJ 19613 8455 4 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 8455 5 , , , 19613 8455 6 which which WDT 19613 8455 7 has have VBZ 19613 8455 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8455 9 " " `` 19613 8455 10 first first JJ 19613 8455 11 cause cause NN 19613 8455 12 " " '' 19613 8455 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8455 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8455 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8455 16 : : : 19613 8455 17 prôton prôton NNP 19613 8455 18 aition aition NN 19613 8455 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8455 20 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8455 21 in in IN 19613 8455 22 God God NNP 19613 8455 23 , , , 19613 8455 24 the the DT 19613 8455 25 Son Son NNP 19613 8455 26 is be VBZ 19613 8455 27 " " `` 19613 8455 28 that that WDT 19613 8455 29 which which WDT 19613 8455 30 is be VBZ 19613 8455 31 caused cause VBN 19613 8455 32 " " '' 19613 8455 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8455 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8455 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8455 36 : : : 19613 8455 37 aitiaton aitiaton NN 19613 8455 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8455 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8455 40 , , , 19613 8455 41 moreover moreover RB 19613 8455 42 as as IN 19613 8455 43 the the DT 19613 8455 44 fulness fulness NN 19613 8455 45 of of IN 19613 8455 46 ideas idea NNS 19613 8455 47 , , , 19613 8455 48 as as IN 19613 8455 49 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8455 50 who who WP 19613 8455 51 comprehends comprehend VBZ 19613 8455 52 in in IN 19613 8455 53 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8455 54 all all PDT 19613 8455 55 the the DT 19613 8455 56 forms form NNS 19613 8455 57 that that WDT 19613 8455 58 are be VBP 19613 8455 59 to to TO 19613 8455 60 have have VB 19613 8455 61 an an DT 19613 8455 62 active active JJ 19613 8455 63 existence existence NN 19613 8455 64 , , , 19613 8455 65 the the DT 19613 8455 66 Son Son NNP 19613 8455 67 is be VBZ 19613 8455 68 no no RB 19613 8455 69 longer long RBR 19613 8455 70 an an DT 19613 8455 71 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8455 72 _ _ NNP 19613 8455 73 simplex simplex NN 19613 8455 74 _ _ NNP 19613 8455 75 like like IN 19613 8455 76 the the DT 19613 8455 77 Father Father NNP 19613 8455 78 . . . 19613 8456 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8456 2 745 745 CD 19613 8456 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8456 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8456 5 is be VBZ 19613 8456 6 already already RB 19613 8456 7 the the DT 19613 8456 8 first first JJ 19613 8456 9 stage stage NN 19613 8456 10 of of IN 19613 8456 11 the the DT 19613 8456 12 transition transition NN 19613 8456 13 from from IN 19613 8456 14 the the DT 19613 8456 15 One one CD 19613 8456 16 to to IN 19613 8456 17 the the DT 19613 8456 18 Manifold Manifold NNP 19613 8456 19 , , , 19613 8456 20 and and CC 19613 8456 21 , , , 19613 8456 22 as as IN 19613 8456 23 the the DT 19613 8456 24 medium medium NN 19613 8456 25 of of IN 19613 8456 26 the the DT 19613 8456 27 world world NN 19613 8456 28 - - HYPH 19613 8456 29 idea idea NN 19613 8456 30 , , , 19613 8456 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8456 32 essence essence NN 19613 8456 33 has have VBZ 19613 8456 34 an an DT 19613 8456 35 inward inward JJ 19613 8456 36 relation relation NN 19613 8456 37 to to IN 19613 8456 38 the the DT 19613 8456 39 world world NN 19613 8456 40 , , , 19613 8456 41 which which WDT 19613 8456 42 is be VBZ 19613 8456 43 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8456 44 without without IN 19613 8456 45 beginning begin VBG 19613 8456 46 . . . 19613 8457 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8457 2 746 746 CD 19613 8457 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8457 4 As as RB 19613 8457 5 soon soon RB 19613 8457 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 8457 7 as as IN 19613 8457 8 the the DT 19613 8457 9 category category NN 19613 8457 10 of of IN 19613 8457 11 causality causality NN 19613 8457 12 is be VBZ 19613 8457 13 applied apply VBN 19613 8457 14 -- -- : 19613 8457 15 which which WDT 19613 8457 16 moreover moreover RB 19613 8457 17 dominates dominate VBZ 19613 8457 18 the the DT 19613 8457 19 system system NN 19613 8457 20 -- -- : 19613 8457 21 and and CC 19613 8457 22 the the DT 19613 8457 23 particular particular JJ 19613 8457 24 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 8457 25 of of IN 19613 8457 26 the the DT 19613 8457 27 Son Son NNP 19613 8457 28 in in IN 19613 8457 29 relation relation NN 19613 8457 30 to to IN 19613 8457 31 the the DT 19613 8457 32 Father Father NNP 19613 8457 33 gives give VBZ 19613 8457 34 way way NN 19613 8457 35 to to IN 19613 8457 36 the the DT 19613 8457 37 general general JJ 19613 8457 38 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 8457 39 of of IN 19613 8457 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8457 41 task task NN 19613 8457 42 and and CC 19613 8457 43 destination destination NN 19613 8457 44 , , , 19613 8457 45 the the DT 19613 8457 46 Son Son NNP 19613 8457 47 is be VBZ 19613 8457 48 not not RB 19613 8457 49 only only RB 19613 8457 50 called call VBN 19613 8457 51 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8457 52 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8457 53 : : : 19613 8457 54 ktisma ktisma NN 19613 8457 55 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8457 56 and and CC 19613 8457 57 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8457 58 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8457 59 : : : 19613 8457 60 dêmiourgêma dêmiourgêma NN 19613 8457 61 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8457 62 , , , 19613 8457 63 but but CC 19613 8457 64 all all PDT 19613 8457 65 the the DT 19613 8457 66 utterances utterance NNS 19613 8457 67 about about IN 19613 8457 68 the the DT 19613 8457 69 quality quality NN 19613 8457 70 of of IN 19613 8457 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8457 72 essence essence NN 19613 8457 73 receive receive VBP 19613 8457 74 a a DT 19613 8457 75 limitation limitation NN 19613 8457 76 . . . 19613 8458 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8458 2 nowhere nowhere RB 19613 8458 3 find find VBP 19613 8458 4 the the DT 19613 8458 5 express express JJ 19613 8458 6 assertion assertion NN 19613 8458 7 that that IN 19613 8458 8 this this DT 19613 8458 9 quality quality NN 19613 8458 10 is be VBZ 19613 8458 11 inferior inferior JJ 19613 8458 12 or or CC 19613 8458 13 of of IN 19613 8458 14 a a DT 19613 8458 15 different different JJ 19613 8458 16 kind kind NN 19613 8458 17 when when WRB 19613 8458 18 compared compare VBN 19613 8458 19 with with IN 19613 8458 20 that that DT 19613 8458 21 of of IN 19613 8458 22 God God NNP 19613 8458 23 ; ; : 19613 8458 24 but but CC 19613 8458 25 these these DT 19613 8458 26 utterances utterance NNS 19613 8458 27 lose lose VBP 19613 8458 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8458 29 force force NN 19613 8458 30 when when WRB 19613 8458 31 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8458 32 is be VBZ 19613 8458 33 asserted assert VBN 19613 8458 34 that that IN 19613 8458 35 complete complete JJ 19613 8458 36 similarity similarity NN 19613 8458 37 between between IN 19613 8458 38 Father Father NNP 19613 8458 39 and and CC 19613 8458 40 Son Son NNP 19613 8458 41 only only RB 19613 8458 42 exists exist VBZ 19613 8458 43 in in IN 19613 8458 44 relation relation NN 19613 8458 45 to to IN 19613 8458 46 the the DT 19613 8458 47 world world NN 19613 8458 48 . . . 19613 8459 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8459 2 have have VBP 19613 8459 3 to to TO 19613 8459 4 acknowledge acknowledge VB 19613 8459 5 the the DT 19613 8459 6 divine divine JJ 19613 8459 7 being being NN 19613 8459 8 that that WDT 19613 8459 9 appeared appear VBD 19613 8459 10 in in IN 19613 8459 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8459 12 to to TO 19613 8459 13 be be VB 19613 8459 14 the the DT 19613 8459 15 manifestation manifestation NN 19613 8459 16 of of IN 19613 8459 17 the the DT 19613 8459 18 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8459 19 ; ; : 19613 8459 20 but but CC 19613 8459 21 , , , 19613 8459 22 from from IN 19613 8459 23 God God NNP 19613 8459 24 's 's POS 19613 8459 25 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 8459 26 , , , 19613 8459 27 the the DT 19613 8459 28 Son Son NNP 19613 8459 29 is be VBZ 19613 8459 30 the the DT 19613 8459 31 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 8459 32 appointed appoint VBN 19613 8459 33 by by IN 19613 8459 34 and and CC 19613 8459 35 _ _ NNP 19613 8459 36 subordinated subordinate VBN 19613 8459 37 _ _ NNP 19613 8459 38 to to IN 19613 8459 39 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8459 40 . . . 19613 8460 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8460 2 747 747 CD 19613 8460 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8460 4 The the DT 19613 8460 5 Son Son NNP 19613 8460 6 stands stand VBZ 19613 8460 7 between between IN 19613 8460 8 the the DT 19613 8460 9 uncreated uncreated JJ 19613 8460 10 One one CD 19613 8460 11 and and CC 19613 8460 12 the the DT 19613 8460 13 created create VBN 19613 8460 14 Many many JJ 19613 8460 15 ; ; : 19613 8460 16 in in IN 19613 8460 17 so so RB 19613 8460 18 far far RB 19613 8460 19 as as IN 19613 8460 20 unchangeableness unchangeableness NN 19613 8460 21 is be VBZ 19613 8460 22 an an DT 19613 8460 23 attribute attribute NN 19613 8460 24 of of IN 19613 8460 25 self self NN 19613 8460 26 - - HYPH 19613 8460 27 existence existence NN 19613 8460 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8460 29 does do VBZ 19613 8460 30 not not RB 19613 8460 31 possess possess VB 19613 8460 32 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8460 33 . . . 19613 8461 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8461 2 748 748 CD 19613 8461 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8461 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8461 5 is be VBZ 19613 8461 6 evident evident JJ 19613 8461 7 why why WRB 19613 8461 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8461 9 was be VBD 19613 8461 10 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8461 11 to to TO 19613 8461 12 conceive conceive VB 19613 8461 13 the the DT 19613 8461 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8461 15 exactly exactly RB 19613 8461 16 as as IN 19613 8461 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8461 18 did do VBD 19613 8461 19 ; ; : 19613 8461 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8461 21 was be VBD 19613 8461 22 only only RB 19613 8461 23 in in IN 19613 8461 24 this this DT 19613 8461 25 form form NN 19613 8461 26 that that WDT 19613 8461 27 the the DT 19613 8461 28 idea idea NN 19613 8461 29 answered answer VBD 19613 8461 30 the the DT 19613 8461 31 purpose purpose NN 19613 8461 32 for for IN 19613 8461 33 which which WDT 19613 8461 34 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8461 35 was be VBD 19613 8461 36 intended intend VBN 19613 8461 37 . . . 19613 8462 1 In in IN 19613 8462 2 the the DT 19613 8462 3 description description NN 19613 8462 4 of of IN 19613 8462 5 the the DT 19613 8462 6 essence essence NN 19613 8462 7 of of IN 19613 8462 8 the the DT 19613 8462 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8462 10 much much RB 19613 8462 11 more more JJR 19613 8462 12 heed heed NN 19613 8462 13 continues continue VBZ 19613 8462 14 to to TO 19613 8462 15 be be VB 19613 8462 16 given give VBN 19613 8462 17 to to IN 19613 8462 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8462 19 creative creative JJ 19613 8462 20 than than IN 19613 8462 21 to to IN 19613 8462 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8462 23 redeeming redeem VBG 19613 8462 24 significance significance NN 19613 8462 25 . . . 19613 8463 1 Since since IN 19613 8463 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8463 3 was be VBD 19613 8463 4 only only RB 19613 8463 5 a a DT 19613 8463 6 teacher teacher NN 19613 8463 7 that that WDT 19613 8463 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8463 9 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 8463 10 required require VBD 19613 8463 11 for for IN 19613 8463 12 the the DT 19613 8463 13 purpose purpose NN 19613 8463 14 of of IN 19613 8463 15 redemption redemption NN 19613 8463 16 , , , 19613 8463 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8463 18 could could MD 19613 8463 19 unfold unfold VB 19613 8463 20 the the DT 19613 8463 21 nature nature NN 19613 8463 22 and and CC 19613 8463 23 task task NN 19613 8463 24 of of IN 19613 8463 25 the the DT 19613 8463 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8463 27 without without IN 19613 8463 28 thinking think VBG 19613 8463 29 of of IN 19613 8463 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8463 31 , , , 19613 8463 32 whose whose WP$ 19613 8463 33 name name NN 19613 8463 34 indeed indeed RB 19613 8463 35 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8463 36 frequently frequently RB 19613 8463 37 mentions mention VBZ 19613 8463 38 in in IN 19613 8463 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8463 40 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 8463 41 , , , 19613 8463 42 but but CC 19613 8463 43 whose whose WP$ 19613 8463 44 person person NN 19613 8463 45 is be VBZ 19613 8463 46 really really RB 19613 8463 47 not not RB 19613 8463 48 of of IN 19613 8463 49 the the DT 19613 8463 50 slightest slight JJS 19613 8463 51 importance importance NN 19613 8463 52 there there RB 19613 8463 53 . . . 19613 8464 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8464 2 749 749 CD 19613 8464 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8464 4 In in IN 19613 8464 5 order order NN 19613 8464 6 to to TO 19613 8464 7 comply comply VB 19613 8464 8 with with IN 19613 8464 9 the the DT 19613 8464 10 rule rule NN 19613 8464 11 of of IN 19613 8464 12 faith faith NN 19613 8464 13 , , , 19613 8464 14 and and CC 19613 8464 15 for for IN 19613 8464 16 this this DT 19613 8464 17 reason reason NN 19613 8464 18 alone alone RB 19613 8464 19 , , , 19613 8464 20 for for IN 19613 8464 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8464 22 speculation speculation NN 19613 8464 23 did do VBD 19613 8464 24 not not RB 19613 8464 25 require require VB 19613 8464 26 a a DT 19613 8464 27 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8464 28 in in IN 19613 8464 29 addition addition NN 19613 8464 30 to to IN 19613 8464 31 the the DT 19613 8464 32 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8464 33 , , , 19613 8464 34 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8464 35 also also RB 19613 8464 36 placed place VBD 19613 8464 37 the the DT 19613 8464 38 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8464 39 alongside alongside IN 19613 8464 40 of of IN 19613 8464 41 Father Father NNP 19613 8464 42 and and CC 19613 8464 43 Son Son NNP 19613 8464 44 . . . 19613 8465 1 All all DT 19613 8465 2 that that WDT 19613 8465 3 is be VBZ 19613 8465 4 predicated predicate VBN 19613 8465 5 about about IN 19613 8465 6 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 7 by by IN 19613 8465 8 the the DT 19613 8465 9 Church Church NNP 19613 8465 10 is be VBZ 19613 8465 11 that that IN 19613 8465 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 13 is be VBZ 19613 8465 14 equal equal JJ 19613 8465 15 to to IN 19613 8465 16 the the DT 19613 8465 17 other other JJ 19613 8465 18 persons person NNS 19613 8465 19 in in IN 19613 8465 20 honour honour NN 19613 8465 21 and and CC 19613 8465 22 dignity dignity NN 19613 8465 23 , , , 19613 8465 24 and and CC 19613 8465 25 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 26 was be VBD 19613 8465 27 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 28 that that WDT 19613 8465 29 inspired inspire VBD 19613 8465 30 both both CC 19613 8465 31 Prophets Prophets NNPS 19613 8465 32 and and CC 19613 8465 33 Apostles Apostles NNPS 19613 8465 34 ; ; : 19613 8465 35 but but CC 19613 8465 36 that that IN 19613 8465 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 38 is be VBZ 19613 8465 39 still still RB 19613 8465 40 undecided undecided JJ 19613 8465 41 whether whether IN 19613 8465 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 43 be be VB 19613 8465 44 created create VBN 19613 8465 45 or or CC 19613 8465 46 uncreated uncreate VBN 19613 8465 47 , , , 19613 8465 48 and and CC 19613 8465 49 whether whether IN 19613 8465 50 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8465 51 too too RB 19613 8465 52 is be VBZ 19613 8465 53 to to TO 19613 8465 54 be be VB 19613 8465 55 considered consider VBN 19613 8465 56 the the DT 19613 8465 57 Son Son NNP 19613 8465 58 of of IN 19613 8465 59 God God NNP 19613 8465 60 or or CC 19613 8465 61 not not RB 19613 8465 62 . . . 19613 8466 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8466 2 750 750 CD 19613 8466 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8466 4 As as IN 19613 8466 5 the the DT 19613 8466 6 third third JJ 19613 8466 7 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 8466 8 , , , 19613 8466 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8466 10 reckoned reckon VBD 19613 8466 11 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8466 12 part part NN 19613 8466 13 of of IN 19613 8466 14 the the DT 19613 8466 15 constant constant JJ 19613 8466 16 divine divine JJ 19613 8466 17 essence essence NN 19613 8466 18 and and CC 19613 8466 19 so so RB 19613 8466 20 treated treat VBD 19613 8466 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8466 22 after after IN 19613 8466 23 the the DT 19613 8466 24 analogy analogy NN 19613 8466 25 of of IN 19613 8466 26 the the DT 19613 8466 27 Son Son NNP 19613 8466 28 , , , 19613 8466 29 without without IN 19613 8466 30 producing produce VBG 19613 8466 31 an an DT 19613 8466 32 impressive impressive JJ 19613 8466 33 proof proof NN 19613 8466 34 of of IN 19613 8466 35 the the DT 19613 8466 36 necessity necessity NN 19613 8466 37 of of IN 19613 8466 38 this this DT 19613 8466 39 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 8466 40 . . . 19613 8467 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8467 2 , , , 19613 8467 3 however however RB 19613 8467 4 , , , 19613 8467 5 became become VBD 19613 8467 6 the the DT 19613 8467 7 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8467 8 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8467 9 through through IN 19613 8467 10 the the DT 19613 8467 11 Son Son NNP 19613 8467 12 , , , 19613 8467 13 and and CC 19613 8467 14 is be VBZ 19613 8467 15 related relate VBN 19613 8467 16 to to IN 19613 8467 17 the the DT 19613 8467 18 latter latter JJ 19613 8467 19 as as IN 19613 8467 20 the the DT 19613 8467 21 latter latter NN 19613 8467 22 is be VBZ 19613 8467 23 related relate VBN 19613 8467 24 to to IN 19613 8467 25 the the DT 19613 8467 26 Father Father NNP 19613 8467 27 ; ; : 19613 8467 28 in in IN 19613 8467 29 other other JJ 19613 8467 30 words word NNS 19613 8467 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8467 32 is be VBZ 19613 8467 33 subordinate subordinate JJ 19613 8467 34 to to IN 19613 8467 35 the the DT 19613 8467 36 Son Son NNP 19613 8467 37 ; ; : 19613 8467 38 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8467 39 is be VBZ 19613 8467 40 the the DT 19613 8467 41 first first JJ 19613 8467 42 creation creation NN 19613 8467 43 of of IN 19613 8467 44 the the DT 19613 8467 45 Father Father NNP 19613 8467 46 through through IN 19613 8467 47 the the DT 19613 8467 48 Son Son NNP 19613 8467 49 . . . 19613 8468 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8468 2 751 751 CD 19613 8468 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8468 4 Here here RB 19613 8468 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8468 6 was be VBD 19613 8468 7 following follow VBG 19613 8468 8 an an DT 19613 8468 9 old old JJ 19613 8468 10 tradition tradition NN 19613 8468 11 . . . 19613 8469 1 Considered consider VBN 19613 8469 2 quantitatively quantitatively RB 19613 8469 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 8469 4 , , , 19613 8469 5 and and CC 19613 8469 6 this this DT 19613 8469 7 according accord VBG 19613 8469 8 to to IN 19613 8469 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8469 10 is be VBZ 19613 8469 11 the the DT 19613 8469 12 most most RBS 19613 8469 13 important important JJ 19613 8469 14 consideration consideration NN 19613 8469 15 , , , 19613 8469 16 the the DT 19613 8469 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8469 18 's 's POS 19613 8469 19 sphere sphere NN 19613 8469 20 of of IN 19613 8469 21 action action NN 19613 8469 22 is be VBZ 19613 8469 23 the the DT 19613 8469 24 smallest small JJS 19613 8469 25 . . . 19613 8470 1 All all DT 19613 8470 2 being be VBG 19613 8470 3 has have VBZ 19613 8470 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8470 5 principle principle NN 19613 8470 6 in in IN 19613 8470 7 the the DT 19613 8470 8 Father Father NNP 19613 8470 9 , , , 19613 8470 10 the the DT 19613 8470 11 Son Son NNP 19613 8470 12 has have VBZ 19613 8470 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8470 14 sphere sphere NN 19613 8470 15 in in IN 19613 8470 16 the the DT 19613 8470 17 rational rational JJ 19613 8470 18 , , , 19613 8470 19 the the DT 19613 8470 20 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8470 21 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8470 22 in in IN 19613 8470 23 the the DT 19613 8470 24 sanctified sanctify VBN 19613 8470 25 , , , 19613 8470 26 that that RB 19613 8470 27 is be VBZ 19613 8470 28 in in IN 19613 8470 29 the the DT 19613 8470 30 Church Church NNP 19613 8470 31 ; ; : 19613 8470 32 this this DT 19613 8470 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8470 34 has have VBZ 19613 8470 35 to to TO 19613 8470 36 rule rule VB 19613 8470 37 over over RB 19613 8470 38 and and CC 19613 8470 39 perfect perfect VB 19613 8470 40 . . . 19613 8471 1 Father Father NNP 19613 8471 2 , , , 19613 8471 3 Son Son NNP 19613 8471 4 , , , 19613 8471 5 and and CC 19613 8471 6 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8471 7 form form VB 19613 8471 8 a a DT 19613 8471 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8471 10 Greek greek JJ 19613 8471 11 : : : 19613 8471 12 trias tria NNS 19613 8471 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8471 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8471 15 " " `` 19613 8471 16 triad")[752 triad")[752 NN 19613 8471 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8471 18 to to TO 19613 8471 19 which which WDT 19613 8471 20 nothing nothing NN 19613 8471 21 may may MD 19613 8471 22 be be VB 19613 8471 23 compared compare VBN 19613 8471 24 ; ; : 19613 8471 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8471 26 are be VBP 19613 8471 27 equal equal JJ 19613 8471 28 in in IN 19613 8471 29 dignity dignity NN 19613 8471 30 and and CC 19613 8471 31 honour honour NN 19613 8471 32 , , , 19613 8471 33 and and CC 19613 8471 34 the the DT 19613 8471 35 substance substance NN 19613 8471 36 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8471 37 possess possess VBP 19613 8471 38 is be VBZ 19613 8471 39 one one CD 19613 8471 40 . . . 19613 8472 1 If if IN 19613 8472 2 the the DT 19613 8472 3 following following NN 19613 8472 4 is be VBZ 19613 8472 5 not not RB 19613 8472 6 one one CD 19613 8472 7 of of IN 19613 8472 8 Rufinus Rufinus NNP 19613 8472 9 ' ' POS 19613 8472 10 corrections correction NNS 19613 8472 11 , , , 19613 8472 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8472 13 said[753 said[753 NNP 19613 8472 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8472 15 : : : 19613 8472 16 " " `` 19613 8472 17 Nihil Nihil NNP 19613 8472 18 in in IN 19613 8472 19 trinitate trinitate NNP 19613 8472 20 maius maius NNP 19613 8472 21 minusve minusve NNP 19613 8472 22 dicendum dicendum NNP 19613 8472 23 est est NNP 19613 8472 24 cum cum NNP 19613 8472 25 unius unius NNP 19613 8472 26 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 8472 27 fons fon NNS 19613 8472 28 verbo verbo VBP 19613 8472 29 ac ac RB 19613 8472 30 ratione ratione JJ 19613 8472 31 sua sua NNP 19613 8472 32 teneat teneat VBP 19613 8472 33 universa"[754 universa"[754 NN 19613 8472 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8472 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8472 36 " " `` 19613 8472 37 nothing nothing NN 19613 8472 38 in in IN 19613 8472 39 the the DT 19613 8472 40 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 8472 41 is be VBZ 19613 8472 42 to to TO 19613 8472 43 be be VB 19613 8472 44 called call VBN 19613 8472 45 greater great JJR 19613 8472 46 or or CC 19613 8472 47 less less RBR 19613 8472 48 , , , 19613 8472 49 since since IN 19613 8472 50 the the DT 19613 8472 51 fountain fountain NN 19613 8472 52 of of IN 19613 8472 53 one one CD 19613 8472 54 divinity divinity NN 19613 8472 55 holds hold VBZ 19613 8472 56 all all PDT 19613 8472 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8472 58 parts part NNS 19613 8472 59 by by IN 19613 8472 60 word word NN 19613 8472 61 and and CC 19613 8472 62 reason reason NN 19613 8472 63 " " '' 19613 8472 64 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8472 65 . . . 19613 8473 1 But but CC 19613 8473 2 , , , 19613 8473 3 as as IN 19613 8473 4 in in IN 19613 8473 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8473 6 's 's POS 19613 8473 7 sense sense NN 19613 8473 8 the the DT 19613 8473 9 union union NN 19613 8473 10 of of IN 19613 8473 11 these these DT 19613 8473 12 only only RB 19613 8473 13 exists exist VBZ 19613 8473 14 because because IN 19613 8473 15 the the DT 19613 8473 16 Father Father NNP 19613 8473 17 alone alone RB 19613 8473 18 is be VBZ 19613 8473 19 the the DT 19613 8473 20 " " `` 19613 8473 21 source source NN 19613 8473 22 of of IN 19613 8473 23 deity deity NN 19613 8473 24 " " '' 19613 8473 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8473 26 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8473 27 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8473 28 : : : 19613 8473 29 pêgê pêgê VB 19613 8473 30 tês tês NNP 19613 8473 31 theotêtos theotêto NNS 19613 8473 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8473 33 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8473 34 and and CC 19613 8473 35 principle principle NN 19613 8473 36 of of IN 19613 8473 37 the the DT 19613 8473 38 other other JJ 19613 8473 39 two two CD 19613 8473 40 hypostases hypostasis NNS 19613 8473 41 , , , 19613 8473 42 the the DT 19613 8473 43 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 8473 44 is be VBZ 19613 8473 45 in in IN 19613 8473 46 truth truth NN 19613 8473 47 no no DT 19613 8473 48 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 19613 8473 49 one one NN 19613 8473 50 , , , 19613 8473 51 but but CC 19613 8473 52 one one CD 19613 8473 53 which which WDT 19613 8473 54 , , , 19613 8473 55 in in IN 19613 8473 56 accordance accordance NN 19613 8473 57 with with IN 19613 8473 58 a a DT 19613 8473 59 " " `` 19613 8473 60 subtle subtle JJ 19613 8473 61 emanation emanation NN 19613 8473 62 idea idea NN 19613 8473 63 " " '' 19613 8473 64 , , , 19613 8473 65 has have VBZ 19613 8473 66 degrees degree NNS 19613 8473 67 within within IN 19613 8473 68 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8473 69 . . . 19613 8474 1 This this DT 19613 8474 2 Trinity Trinity NNP 19613 8474 3 , , , 19613 8474 4 which which WDT 19613 8474 5 in in IN 19613 8474 6 the the DT 19613 8474 7 strict strict JJ 19613 8474 8 sense sense NN 19613 8474 9 remains remain VBZ 19613 8474 10 a a DT 19613 8474 11 Trinity trinity NN 19613 8474 12 of of IN 19613 8474 13 revelation revelation NN 19613 8474 14 , , , 19613 8474 15 except except IN 19613 8474 16 that that IN 19613 8474 17 revelation revelation NN 19613 8474 18 belongs belong VBZ 19613 8474 19 to to IN 19613 8474 20 the the DT 19613 8474 21 essence essence NN 19613 8474 22 of of IN 19613 8474 23 God God NNP 19613 8474 24 , , , 19613 8474 25 is be VBZ 19613 8474 26 with with IN 19613 8474 27 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8474 28 the the DT 19613 8474 29 real real JJ 19613 8474 30 secret secret NN 19613 8474 31 of of IN 19613 8474 32 the the DT 19613 8474 33 faith faith NN 19613 8474 34 , , , 19613 8474 35 the the DT 19613 8474 36 mystery mystery NN 19613 8474 37 beyond beyond IN 19613 8474 38 all all DT 19613 8474 39 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 8474 40 . . . 19613 8475 1 To to TO 19613 8475 2 deny deny VB 19613 8475 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8475 4 shows show VBZ 19613 8475 5 a a DT 19613 8475 6 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 8475 7 , , , 19613 8475 8 carnal carnal JJ 19613 8475 9 feeling feeling NN 19613 8475 10 or or CC 19613 8475 11 at at IN 19613 8475 12 least least JJS 19613 8475 13 the the DT 19613 8475 14 greatest great JJS 19613 8475 15 narrowness narrowness NN 19613 8475 16 of of IN 19613 8475 17 conception conception NN 19613 8475 18 . . . 19613 8476 1 The the DT 19613 8476 2 idea idea NN 19613 8476 3 of of IN 19613 8476 4 createdness createdness NN 19613 8476 5 was be VBD 19613 8476 6 already already RB 19613 8476 7 more more RBR 19613 8476 8 closely closely RB 19613 8476 9 associated associate VBN 19613 8476 10 with with IN 19613 8476 11 the the DT 19613 8476 12 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8476 13 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 8476 14 than than IN 19613 8476 15 with with IN 19613 8476 16 the the DT 19613 8476 17 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8476 18 . . . 19613 8477 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8477 2 is be VBZ 19613 8477 3 in in IN 19613 8477 4 a a DT 19613 8477 5 still still RB 19613 8477 6 clearer clear JJR 19613 8477 7 fashion fashion NN 19613 8477 8 than than IN 19613 8477 9 the the DT 19613 8477 10 Son Son NNP 19613 8477 11 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8477 12 the the DT 19613 8477 13 transition transition NN 19613 8477 14 to to IN 19613 8477 15 the the DT 19613 8477 16 series series NN 19613 8477 17 of of IN 19613 8477 18 ideas idea NNS 19613 8477 19 and and CC 19613 8477 20 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8477 21 that that WDT 19613 8477 22 having have VBG 19613 8477 23 been be VBN 19613 8477 24 created create VBN 19613 8477 25 by by IN 19613 8477 26 the the DT 19613 8477 27 Son Son NNP 19613 8477 28 , , , 19613 8477 29 are be VBP 19613 8477 30 in in IN 19613 8477 31 truth truth NN 19613 8477 32 the the DT 19613 8477 33 unfolding unfolding NN 19613 8477 34 of of IN 19613 8477 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8477 36 fulness fulness NN 19613 8477 37 . . . 19613 8478 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 8478 2 form form VBP 19613 8478 3 the the DT 19613 8478 4 next next JJ 19613 8478 5 stage stage NN 19613 8478 6 after after IN 19613 8478 7 the the DT 19613 8478 8 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8478 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 8478 10 . . . 19613 8479 1 In in IN 19613 8479 2 assuming assume VBG 19613 8479 3 the the DT 19613 8479 4 existence existence NN 19613 8479 5 of of IN 19613 8479 6 such such JJ 19613 8479 7 beings being NNS 19613 8479 8 as as IN 19613 8479 9 were be VBD 19613 8479 10 required require VBN 19613 8479 11 by by IN 19613 8479 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8479 13 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8479 14 system system NN 19613 8479 15 , , , 19613 8479 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8479 17 appealed appeal VBD 19613 8479 18 to to IN 19613 8479 19 the the DT 19613 8479 20 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 8479 21 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8479 22 of of IN 19613 8479 23 angels angel NNS 19613 8479 24 , , , 19613 8479 25 which which WDT 19613 8479 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8479 27 says say VBZ 19613 8479 28 is be VBZ 19613 8479 29 expressly expressly RB 19613 8479 30 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 8479 31 in in IN 19613 8479 32 the the DT 19613 8479 33 Church Church NNP 19613 8479 34 . . . 19613 8480 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8480 2 755 755 CD 19613 8480 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8480 4 With with IN 19613 8480 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8480 6 even even RB 19613 8480 7 the the DT 19613 8480 8 association association NN 19613 8480 9 of of IN 19613 8480 10 the the DT 19613 8480 11 Son Son NNP 19613 8480 12 and and CC 19613 8480 13 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8480 14 Ghost Ghost NNP 19613 8480 15 with with IN 19613 8480 16 the the DT 19613 8480 17 great great JJ 19613 8480 18 angelic angelic JJ 19613 8480 19 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8480 20 is be VBZ 19613 8480 21 as as RB 19613 8480 22 yet yet RB 19613 8480 23 not not RB 19613 8480 24 altogether altogether RB 19613 8480 25 avoided avoid VBN 19613 8480 26 , , , 19613 8480 27 at at IN 19613 8480 28 least least JJS 19613 8480 29 in in IN 19613 8480 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8480 31 expressions expression NNS 19613 8480 32 . . . 19613 8481 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8481 2 756 756 CD 19613 8481 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8481 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8481 5 was be VBD 19613 8481 6 more more RBR 19613 8481 7 cautious cautious JJ 19613 8481 8 in in IN 19613 8481 9 this this DT 19613 8481 10 respect respect NN 19613 8481 11 . . . 19613 8482 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8482 2 757 757 CD 19613 8482 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8482 4 The the DT 19613 8482 5 world world NN 19613 8482 6 of of IN 19613 8482 7 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8482 8 appears appear VBZ 19613 8482 9 to to IN 19613 8482 10 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8482 11 as as IN 19613 8482 12 a a DT 19613 8482 13 series series NN 19613 8482 14 of of IN 19613 8482 15 well well RB 19613 8482 16 - - HYPH 19613 8482 17 arranged arrange VBN 19613 8482 18 , , , 19613 8482 19 graded grade VBD 19613 8482 20 energies energy NNS 19613 8482 21 , , , 19613 8482 22 as as IN 19613 8482 23 the the DT 19613 8482 24 representative representative NN 19613 8482 25 of of IN 19613 8482 26 created create VBN 19613 8482 27 reason reason NN 19613 8482 28 . . . 19613 8483 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8483 2 characteristic characteristic NN 19613 8483 3 is be VBZ 19613 8483 4 growth growth NN 19613 8483 5 , , , 19613 8483 6 that that RB 19613 8483 7 is is RB 19613 8483 8 , , , 19613 8483 9 progress progress NN 19613 8483 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8483 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8483 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8483 13 : : : 19613 8483 14 prokopê prokopê NN 19613 8483 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8483 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8483 17 . . . 19613 8484 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8484 2 758 758 CD 19613 8484 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8484 4 Growth growth NN 19613 8484 5 is be VBZ 19613 8484 6 conditioned condition VBN 19613 8484 7 by by IN 19613 8484 8 freedom freedom NN 19613 8484 9 : : : 19613 8484 10 " " `` 19613 8484 11 _ _ NNP 19613 8484 12 omnis omnis NNP 19613 8484 13 creatura creatura NNP 19613 8484 14 rationabilis rationabilis NNP 19613 8484 15 laudis laudis NNP 19613 8484 16 et et NNP 19613 8484 17 culpæ culpæ NNP 19613 8484 18 capax capax NNP 19613 8484 19 : : : 19613 8484 20 laudis laudis NNP 19613 8484 21 , , , 19613 8484 22 si si NNP 19613 8484 23 secundum secundum NNP 19613 8484 24 rationem rationem NNP 19613 8484 25 , , , 19613 8484 26 quam quam NNP 19613 8484 27 in in IN 19613 8484 28 se se NNP 19613 8484 29 habet habet NNP 19613 8484 30 , , , 19613 8484 31 ad ad NNP 19613 8484 32 meliora meliora NNP 19613 8484 33 proficiat proficiat NNP 19613 8484 34 , , , 19613 8484 35 culpæ culpæ NNP 19613 8484 36 , , , 19613 8484 37 si si NNP 19613 8484 38 rationem rationem NNP 19613 8484 39 recti recti NN 19613 8484 40 declinet_"[759 declinet_"[759 NNP 19613 8484 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8484 42 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8484 43 " " `` 19613 8484 44 every every DT 19613 8484 45 rational rational JJ 19613 8484 46 creature creature NN 19613 8484 47 is be VBZ 19613 8484 48 capable capable JJ 19613 8484 49 of of IN 19613 8484 50 meriting merit VBG 19613 8484 51 praise praise NN 19613 8484 52 or or CC 19613 8484 53 blame blame NN 19613 8484 54 -- -- : 19613 8484 55 praise praise NN 19613 8484 56 , , , 19613 8484 57 if if IN 19613 8484 58 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8484 59 advance advance VBP 19613 8484 60 to to IN 19613 8484 61 better well JJR 19613 8484 62 things thing NNS 19613 8484 63 according accord VBG 19613 8484 64 to to IN 19613 8484 65 the the DT 19613 8484 66 reason reason NN 19613 8484 67 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8484 68 possesses possess VBZ 19613 8484 69 in in IN 19613 8484 70 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8484 71 , , , 19613 8484 72 blame blame VBP 19613 8484 73 , , , 19613 8484 74 if if IN 19613 8484 75 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8484 76 avoid avoid VBP 19613 8484 77 the the DT 19613 8484 78 right right JJ 19613 8484 79 course course NN 19613 8484 80 " " '' 19613 8484 81 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8484 82 . . . 19613 8485 1 As as IN 19613 8485 2 unchangeableness unchangeableness NN 19613 8485 3 and and CC 19613 8485 4 permanence permanence NN 19613 8485 5 are be VBP 19613 8485 6 characteristic characteristic JJ 19613 8485 7 of of IN 19613 8485 8 the the DT 19613 8485 9 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8485 10 , , , 19613 8485 11 so so CC 19613 8485 12 freedom freedom NN 19613 8485 13 is be VBZ 19613 8485 14 the the DT 19613 8485 15 mark mark NN 19613 8485 16 of of IN 19613 8485 17 the the DT 19613 8485 18 created create VBN 19613 8485 19 spirit spirit NN 19613 8485 20 . . . 19613 8486 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8486 2 760 760 CD 19613 8486 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8486 4 In in IN 19613 8486 5 this this DT 19613 8486 6 thesis thesis NN 19613 8486 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8486 8 goes go VBZ 19613 8486 9 beyond beyond IN 19613 8486 10 the the DT 19613 8486 11 assumption assumption NN 19613 8486 12 of of IN 19613 8486 13 the the DT 19613 8486 14 heretical heretical JJ 19613 8486 15 Gnostics gnostic NNS 19613 8486 16 just just RB 19613 8486 17 as as RB 19613 8486 18 much much RB 19613 8486 19 as as IN 19613 8486 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8486 21 does do VBZ 19613 8486 22 in in IN 19613 8486 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8486 24 other other JJ 19613 8486 25 proposition proposition NN 19613 8486 26 that that IN 19613 8486 27 the the DT 19613 8486 28 creaturely creaturely RB 19613 8486 29 spirit spirit NN 19613 8486 30 is be VBZ 19613 8486 31 in in IN 19613 8486 32 no no DT 19613 8486 33 sense sense NN 19613 8486 34 a a DT 19613 8486 35 portion portion NN 19613 8486 36 of of IN 19613 8486 37 the the DT 19613 8486 38 divine divine JJ 19613 8486 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8486 40 because because IN 19613 8486 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8486 42 is be VBZ 19613 8486 43 changeable[761 changeable[761 NN 19613 8486 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8486 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8486 46 ; ; : 19613 8486 47 but but CC 19613 8486 48 in in IN 19613 8486 49 reality reality NN 19613 8486 50 freedom freedom NN 19613 8486 51 , , , 19613 8486 52 as as IN 19613 8486 53 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8486 54 understands understand VBZ 19613 8486 55 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8486 56 , , , 19613 8486 57 is be VBZ 19613 8486 58 only only RB 19613 8486 59 the the DT 19613 8486 60 capacity capacity NN 19613 8486 61 of of IN 19613 8486 62 created create VBN 19613 8486 63 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8486 64 to to TO 19613 8486 65 determine determine VB 19613 8486 66 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8486 67 own own JJ 19613 8486 68 destiny destiny NN 19613 8486 69 _ _ NNP 19613 8486 70 for for IN 19613 8486 71 a a DT 19613 8486 72 time time NN 19613 8486 73 _ _ NNP 19613 8486 74 . . . 19613 8487 1 In in IN 19613 8487 2 the the DT 19613 8487 3 end end NN 19613 8487 4 , , , 19613 8487 5 however however RB 19613 8487 6 , , , 19613 8487 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8487 8 must must MD 19613 8487 9 turn turn VB 19613 8487 10 to to IN 19613 8487 11 that that DT 19613 8487 12 which which WDT 19613 8487 13 is be VBZ 19613 8487 14 good good JJ 19613 8487 15 , , , 19613 8487 16 because because IN 19613 8487 17 everything everything NN 19613 8487 18 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8487 19 is be VBZ 19613 8487 20 indestructible indestructible JJ 19613 8487 21 . . . 19613 8488 1 _ _ NNP 19613 8488 2 Sub Sub NNP 19613 8488 3 specie specie VBD 19613 8488 4 æternitatis æternitatis NN 19613 8488 5 _ _ NNP 19613 8488 6 , , , 19613 8488 7 then then RB 19613 8488 8 , , , 19613 8488 9 the the DT 19613 8488 10 mere mere JJ 19613 8488 11 communication communication NN 19613 8488 12 of of IN 19613 8488 13 the the DT 19613 8488 14 divine divine JJ 19613 8488 15 element element NN 19613 8488 16 to to IN 19613 8488 17 the the DT 19613 8488 18 created create VBN 19613 8488 19 spirit[762 spirit[762 NN 19613 8488 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8488 21 is be VBZ 19613 8488 22 _ _ NNP 19613 8488 23 not not RB 19613 8488 24 _ _ IN 19613 8488 25 a a DT 19613 8488 26 mere mere JJ 19613 8488 27 communication communication NN 19613 8488 28 , , , 19613 8488 29 and and CC 19613 8488 30 freedom freedom NN 19613 8488 31 is be VBZ 19613 8488 32 no no DT 19613 8488 33 freedom freedom NN 19613 8488 34 ; ; : 19613 8488 35 but but CC 19613 8488 36 the the DT 19613 8488 37 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8488 38 necessity necessity NN 19613 8488 39 of of IN 19613 8488 40 the the DT 19613 8488 41 created create VBN 19613 8488 42 spirit spirit NN 19613 8488 43 's 's POS 19613 8488 44 developing develop VBG 19613 8488 45 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8488 46 merely merely RB 19613 8488 47 appears appear VBZ 19613 8488 48 as as IN 19613 8488 49 freedom freedom NN 19613 8488 50 . . . 19613 8489 1 Yet yet RB 19613 8489 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8489 3 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8489 4 did do VBD 19613 8489 5 not not RB 19613 8489 6 draw draw VB 19613 8489 7 this this DT 19613 8489 8 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 8489 9 , , , 19613 8489 10 but but CC 19613 8489 11 rather rather RB 19613 8489 12 based base VBD 19613 8489 13 everything everything NN 19613 8489 14 on on IN 19613 8489 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8489 16 conception conception NN 19613 8489 17 that that IN 19613 8489 18 the the DT 19613 8489 19 freedom freedom NN 19613 8489 20 of of IN 19613 8489 21 _ _ NNP 19613 8489 22 naturæ naturæ NNP 19613 8489 23 rationabiles rationabiles NNPS 19613 8489 24 _ _ NNP 19613 8489 25 consisted consist VBD 19613 8489 26 in in IN 19613 8489 27 the the DT 19613 8489 28 _ _ NNP 19613 8489 29 possibilitas possibilitas NNP 19613 8489 30 utriusque utriusque JJ 19613 8489 31 _ _ NNP 19613 8489 32 , , , 19613 8489 33 and and CC 19613 8489 34 sought seek VBD 19613 8489 35 to to TO 19613 8489 36 understand understand VB 19613 8489 37 the the DT 19613 8489 38 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 8489 39 , , , 19613 8489 40 as as IN 19613 8489 41 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8489 42 is be VBZ 19613 8489 43 , , , 19613 8489 44 from from IN 19613 8489 45 this this DT 19613 8489 46 freedom freedom NN 19613 8489 47 . . . 19613 8490 1 To to IN 19613 8490 2 the the DT 19613 8490 3 _ _ NNP 19613 8490 4 naturæ naturæ NNS 19613 8490 5 rationabiles rationabiles NNPS 19613 8490 6 _ _ NNP 19613 8490 7 , , , 19613 8490 8 which which WDT 19613 8490 9 have have VBP 19613 8490 10 different different JJ 19613 8490 11 _ _ NNP 19613 8490 12 species specie NNS 19613 8490 13 _ _ NNP 19613 8490 14 and and CC 19613 8490 15 _ _ NNP 19613 8490 16 ordines ordine NNS 19613 8490 17 _ _ NNP 19613 8490 18 , , , 19613 8490 19 human human JJ 19613 8490 20 souls soul NNS 19613 8490 21 also also RB 19613 8490 22 belong belong VBP 19613 8490 23 . . . 19613 8491 1 The the DT 19613 8491 2 whole whole NN 19613 8491 3 of of IN 19613 8491 4 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8491 5 were be VBD 19613 8491 6 created create VBN 19613 8491 7 from from IN 19613 8491 8 all all DT 19613 8491 9 eternity eternity NN 19613 8491 10 ; ; : 19613 8491 11 for for IN 19613 8491 12 God God NNP 19613 8491 13 would would MD 19613 8491 14 not not RB 19613 8491 15 be be VB 19613 8491 16 almighty almighty JJ 19613 8491 17 unless unless IN 19613 8491 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8491 19 had have VBD 19613 8491 20 always always RB 19613 8491 21 produced produce VBN 19613 8491 22 everything[763 everything[763 . 19613 8491 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8491 24 ; ; : 19613 8491 25 in in IN 19613 8491 26 virtue virtue NN 19613 8491 27 of of IN 19613 8491 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8491 29 origin origin NN 19613 8491 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8491 31 are be VBP 19613 8491 32 equal equal JJ 19613 8491 33 , , , 19613 8491 34 for for IN 19613 8491 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8491 36 original original JJ 19613 8491 37 community community NN 19613 8491 38 with with IN 19613 8491 39 the the DT 19613 8491 40 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8491 41 permits permit NNS 19613 8491 42 of of IN 19613 8491 43 no no UH 19613 8491 44 diversity[764 diversity[764 NN 19613 8491 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8491 46 ; ; : 19613 8491 47 but but CC 19613 8491 48 , , , 19613 8491 49 on on IN 19613 8491 50 the the DT 19613 8491 51 other other JJ 19613 8491 52 hand hand NN 19613 8491 53 , , , 19613 8491 54 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8491 55 have have VBP 19613 8491 56 received receive VBN 19613 8491 57 different different JJ 19613 8491 58 tasks task NNS 19613 8491 59 and and CC 19613 8491 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8491 61 development development NN 19613 8491 62 is be VBZ 19613 8491 63 consequently consequently RB 19613 8491 64 different different JJ 19613 8491 65 . . . 19613 8492 1 In in IN 19613 8492 2 so so RB 19613 8492 3 far far RB 19613 8492 4 as as IN 19613 8492 5 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8492 6 are be VBP 19613 8492 7 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8492 8 subject subject JJ 19613 8492 9 to to IN 19613 8492 10 change change NN 19613 8492 11 , , , 19613 8492 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8492 13 are be VBP 19613 8492 14 burdened burden VBN 19613 8492 15 with with IN 19613 8492 16 a a DT 19613 8492 17 kind kind NN 19613 8492 18 of of IN 19613 8492 19 bodily bodily NNP 19613 8492 20 nature,[765 nature,[765 NNP 19613 8492 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8492 22 for for IN 19613 8492 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8492 24 is be VBZ 19613 8492 25 only only RB 19613 8492 26 the the DT 19613 8492 27 Deity deity NN 19613 8492 28 that that WDT 19613 8492 29 is be VBZ 19613 8492 30 without without IN 19613 8492 31 a a DT 19613 8492 32 body body NN 19613 8492 33 . . . 19613 8493 1 The the DT 19613 8493 2 element element NN 19613 8493 3 of of IN 19613 8493 4 materiality materiality NN 19613 8493 5 is be VBZ 19613 8493 6 a a DT 19613 8493 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 8493 8 result result NN 19613 8493 9 of of IN 19613 8493 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8493 11 finite finite JJ 19613 8493 12 nature nature NN 19613 8493 13 , , , 19613 8493 14 that that RB 19613 8493 15 is is RB 19613 8493 16 , , , 19613 8493 17 of of IN 19613 8493 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8493 19 being be VBG 19613 8493 20 created create VBN 19613 8493 21 ; ; : 19613 8493 22 and and CC 19613 8493 23 this this DT 19613 8493 24 applies apply VBZ 19613 8493 25 both both DT 19613 8493 26 to to IN 19613 8493 27 angels angel NNS 19613 8493 28 and and CC 19613 8493 29 human human JJ 19613 8493 30 souls soul NNS 19613 8493 31 . . . 19613 8494 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8494 2 766 766 CD 19613 8494 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8494 4 Now now RB 19613 8494 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8494 6 did do VBD 19613 8494 7 not not RB 19613 8494 8 speculate speculate VB 19613 8494 9 at at RB 19613 8494 10 all all RB 19613 8494 11 as as IN 19613 8494 12 to to IN 19613 8494 13 how how WRB 19613 8494 14 the the DT 19613 8494 15 spirit spirit NNP 19613 8494 16 world world NN 19613 8494 17 might may MD 19613 8494 18 have have VB 19613 8494 19 developed develop VBN 19613 8494 20 in in IN 19613 8494 21 ideal ideal JJ 19613 8494 22 fashion fashion NN 19613 8494 23 , , , 19613 8494 24 a a DT 19613 8494 25 fact fact NN 19613 8494 26 which which WDT 19613 8494 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8494 28 is be VBZ 19613 8494 29 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 8494 30 important important JJ 19613 8494 31 to to TO 19613 8494 32 recognise recognise VB 19613 8494 33 ; ; : 19613 8494 34 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8494 35 knows know VBZ 19613 8494 36 nothing nothing NN 19613 8494 37 at at RB 19613 8494 38 all all RB 19613 8494 39 about about IN 19613 8494 40 an an DT 19613 8494 41 ideal ideal JJ 19613 8494 42 development development NN 19613 8494 43 for for IN 19613 8494 44 all all DT 19613 8494 45 , , , 19613 8494 46 and and CC 19613 8494 47 does do VBZ 19613 8494 48 not not RB 19613 8494 49 even even RB 19613 8494 50 view view VB 19613 8494 51 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8494 52 as as IN 19613 8494 53 a a DT 19613 8494 54 possibility possibility NN 19613 8494 55 . . . 19613 8495 1 The the DT 19613 8495 2 truth truth NN 19613 8495 3 rather rather RB 19613 8495 4 is be VBZ 19613 8495 5 that that IN 19613 8495 6 as as RB 19613 8495 7 soon soon RB 19613 8495 8 as as IN 19613 8495 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8495 10 mentions mention VBZ 19613 8495 11 the the DT 19613 8495 12 _ _ NNP 19613 8495 13 naturæ naturæ NNS 19613 8495 14 rationabiles rationabiles NNPS 19613 8495 15 _ _ NNP 19613 8495 16 , , , 19613 8495 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8495 18 immediately immediately RB 19613 8495 19 proceeds proceed VBZ 19613 8495 20 to to TO 19613 8495 21 speak speak VB 19613 8495 22 of of IN 19613 8495 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8495 24 fall fall NN 19613 8495 25 , , , 19613 8495 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8495 27 growth growth NN 19613 8495 28 , , , 19613 8495 29 and and CC 19613 8495 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8495 31 diversities diversity NNS 19613 8495 32 . . . 19613 8496 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8496 2 merely merely RB 19613 8496 3 contemplates contemplate VBZ 19613 8496 4 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8496 5 in in IN 19613 8496 6 the the DT 19613 8496 7 given give VBN 19613 8496 8 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 8496 9 in in IN 19613 8496 10 which which WDT 19613 8496 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8496 12 are be VBP 19613 8496 13 placed place VBN 19613 8496 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8496 15 see see VB 19613 8496 16 the the DT 19613 8496 17 exposition exposition NN 19613 8496 18 in in IN 19613 8496 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8496 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8496 21 : : : 19613 8496 22 peri peri NN 19613 8496 23 archôn archôn NN 19613 8496 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8496 25 II II NNP 19613 8496 26 . . . 19613 8497 1 9 9 CD 19613 8497 2 . . . 19613 8498 1 2 2 LS 19613 8498 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8498 3 . . . 19613 8499 1 THE the DT 19613 8499 2 DOCTRINE DOCTRINE NNP 19613 8499 3 OF of IN 19613 8499 4 THE the DT 19613 8499 5 FALL FALL NNP 19613 8499 6 AND and CC 19613 8499 7 ITS its PRP$ 19613 8499 8 CONSEQUENCES consequence NNS 19613 8499 9 . . . 19613 8500 1 All all DT 19613 8500 2 created create VBN 19613 8500 3 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8500 4 must must MD 19613 8500 5 develop develop VB 19613 8500 6 . . . 19613 8501 1 When when WRB 19613 8501 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8501 3 have have VBP 19613 8501 4 done do VBN 19613 8501 5 so so RB 19613 8501 6 , , , 19613 8501 7 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8501 8 attain attain VBP 19613 8501 9 perfection perfection NN 19613 8501 10 and and CC 19613 8501 11 make make VB 19613 8501 12 way way NN 19613 8501 13 for for IN 19613 8501 14 new new JJ 19613 8501 15 dispensations dispensation NNS 19613 8501 16 and and CC 19613 8501 17 worlds world NNS 19613 8501 18 . . . 19613 8502 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8502 2 767 767 CD 19613 8502 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8502 4 In in IN 19613 8502 5 the the DT 19613 8502 6 exercise exercise NN 19613 8502 7 of of IN 19613 8502 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8502 9 freedom freedom NN 19613 8502 10 , , , 19613 8502 11 however however RB 19613 8502 12 , , , 19613 8502 13 disobedience disobedience NN 19613 8502 14 , , , 19613 8502 15 laxity laxity NN 19613 8502 16 , , , 19613 8502 17 laziness laziness NN 19613 8502 18 , , , 19613 8502 19 and and CC 19613 8502 20 failure failure NN 19613 8502 21 make make VBP 19613 8502 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8502 23 appearance appearance NN 19613 8502 24 among among IN 19613 8502 25 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8502 26 in in IN 19613 8502 27 an an DT 19613 8502 28 endless endless JJ 19613 8502 29 multiplicity multiplicity NN 19613 8502 30 of of IN 19613 8502 31 ways way NNS 19613 8502 32 . . . 19613 8503 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8503 2 768 768 CD 19613 8503 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8503 4 The the DT 19613 8503 5 disciplining discipline VBG 19613 8503 6 and and CC 19613 8503 7 purifying purifying NN 19613 8503 8 of of IN 19613 8503 9 these these DT 19613 8503 10 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8503 11 was be VBD 19613 8503 12 the the DT 19613 8503 13 purpose purpose NN 19613 8503 14 for for IN 19613 8503 15 which which WDT 19613 8503 16 the the DT 19613 8503 17 material material NN 19613 8503 18 world world NN 19613 8503 19 was be VBD 19613 8503 20 created create VBN 19613 8503 21 by by IN 19613 8503 22 God God NNP 19613 8503 23 . . . 19613 8504 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8504 2 769 769 CD 19613 8504 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8504 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8504 5 is be VBZ 19613 8504 6 therefore therefore RB 19613 8504 7 a a DT 19613 8504 8 place place NN 19613 8504 9 of of IN 19613 8504 10 purification purification NN 19613 8504 11 , , , 19613 8504 12 ruled rule VBD 19613 8504 13 and and CC 19613 8504 14 harmoniously harmoniously RB 19613 8504 15 arranged arrange VBN 19613 8504 16 by by IN 19613 8504 17 God God NNP 19613 8504 18 's 's POS 19613 8504 19 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8504 20 . . . 19613 8505 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8505 2 770 770 CD 19613 8505 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8505 4 Each each DT 19613 8505 5 member member NN 19613 8505 6 of of IN 19613 8505 7 the the DT 19613 8505 8 world world NN 19613 8505 9 of of IN 19613 8505 10 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8505 11 has have VBZ 19613 8505 12 received receive VBN 19613 8505 13 a a DT 19613 8505 14 different different JJ 19613 8505 15 kind kind NN 19613 8505 16 of of IN 19613 8505 17 material material JJ 19613 8505 18 nature nature NN 19613 8505 19 in in IN 19613 8505 20 proportion proportion NN 19613 8505 21 to to IN 19613 8505 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8505 23 degree degree NN 19613 8505 24 of of IN 19613 8505 25 removal removal NN 19613 8505 26 from from IN 19613 8505 27 the the DT 19613 8505 28 Creator Creator NNP 19613 8505 29 . . . 19613 8506 1 The the DT 19613 8506 2 highest high JJS 19613 8506 3 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8506 4 , , , 19613 8506 5 who who WP 19613 8506 6 have have VBP 19613 8506 7 virtually virtually RB 19613 8506 8 held hold VBN 19613 8506 9 fast fast RB 19613 8506 10 by by IN 19613 8506 11 that that DT 19613 8506 12 which which WDT 19613 8506 13 is be VBZ 19613 8506 14 good good JJ 19613 8506 15 , , , 19613 8506 16 though though IN 19613 8506 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8506 18 too too RB 19613 8506 19 stand stand VBP 19613 8506 20 in in IN 19613 8506 21 need need NN 19613 8506 22 of of IN 19613 8506 23 restitution restitution NN 19613 8506 24 , , , 19613 8506 25 guide guide VB 19613 8506 26 the the DT 19613 8506 27 world world NN 19613 8506 28 , , , 19613 8506 29 are be VBP 19613 8506 30 servants servant NNS 19613 8506 31 of of IN 19613 8506 32 God God NNP 19613 8506 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8506 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8506 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8506 36 : : : 19613 8506 37 angeloi angeloi NN 19613 8506 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8506 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8506 40 , , , 19613 8506 41 and and CC 19613 8506 42 have have VBP 19613 8506 43 bodies body NNS 19613 8506 44 of of IN 19613 8506 45 an an DT 19613 8506 46 exceedingly exceedingly RB 19613 8506 47 subtle subtle JJ 19613 8506 48 kind kind NN 19613 8506 49 in in IN 19613 8506 50 the the DT 19613 8506 51 form form NN 19613 8506 52 of of IN 19613 8506 53 a a DT 19613 8506 54 globe globe NN 19613 8506 55 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8506 56 stars star NNS 19613 8506 57 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8506 58 . . . 19613 8507 1 The the DT 19613 8507 2 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8507 3 that that WDT 19613 8507 4 have have VBP 19613 8507 5 fallen fall VBN 19613 8507 6 very very RB 19613 8507 7 deeply deeply RB 19613 8507 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8507 9 the the DT 19613 8507 10 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8507 11 of of IN 19613 8507 12 men man NNS 19613 8507 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8507 14 are be VBP 19613 8507 15 banished banish VBN 19613 8507 16 into into IN 19613 8507 17 material material JJ 19613 8507 18 bodies body NNS 19613 8507 19 . . . 19613 8508 1 Those those DT 19613 8508 2 that that WDT 19613 8508 3 have have VBP 19613 8508 4 altogether altogether RB 19613 8508 5 turned turn VBN 19613 8508 6 against against IN 19613 8508 7 God God NNP 19613 8508 8 have have VBP 19613 8508 9 received receive VBN 19613 8508 10 very very RB 19613 8508 11 dark dark JJ 19613 8508 12 bodies body NNS 19613 8508 13 , , , 19613 8508 14 indescribably indescribably RB 19613 8508 15 ugly ugly JJ 19613 8508 16 , , , 19613 8508 17 though though IN 19613 8508 18 not not RB 19613 8508 19 visible visible JJ 19613 8508 20 . . . 19613 8509 1 Men man NNS 19613 8509 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 8509 3 are be VBP 19613 8509 4 placed place VBN 19613 8509 5 between between IN 19613 8509 6 the the DT 19613 8509 7 angels angel NNS 19613 8509 8 and and CC 19613 8509 9 demons demon NNS 19613 8509 10 , , , 19613 8509 11 both both DT 19613 8509 12 of of IN 19613 8509 13 whom whom WP 19613 8509 14 try try VBP 19613 8509 15 to to TO 19613 8509 16 influence influence VB 19613 8509 17 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8509 18 . . . 19613 8510 1 The the DT 19613 8510 2 moral moral JJ 19613 8510 3 struggle struggle NN 19613 8510 4 that that WDT 19613 8510 5 man man NN 19613 8510 6 has have VBZ 19613 8510 7 to to TO 19613 8510 8 undergo undergo VB 19613 8510 9 within within IN 19613 8510 10 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8510 11 is be VBZ 19613 8510 12 made make VBN 19613 8510 13 harder hard RBR 19613 8510 14 by by IN 19613 8510 15 the the DT 19613 8510 16 demons demon NNS 19613 8510 17 , , , 19613 8510 18 but but CC 19613 8510 19 lightened lighten VBN 19613 8510 20 by by IN 19613 8510 21 the the DT 19613 8510 22 angels,[771 angels,[771 NN 19613 8510 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8510 24 for for IN 19613 8510 25 these these DT 19613 8510 26 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8510 27 powers power NNS 19613 8510 28 are be VBP 19613 8510 29 at at IN 19613 8510 30 all all DT 19613 8510 31 times time NNS 19613 8510 32 and and CC 19613 8510 33 places place NNS 19613 8510 34 acting act VBG 19613 8510 35 both both CC 19613 8510 36 upon upon IN 19613 8510 37 the the DT 19613 8510 38 physical physical NN 19613 8510 39 and and CC 19613 8510 40 the the DT 19613 8510 41 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8510 42 world world NN 19613 8510 43 . . . 19613 8511 1 But but CC 19613 8511 2 everything everything NN 19613 8511 3 is be VBZ 19613 8511 4 subject subject JJ 19613 8511 5 to to IN 19613 8511 6 the the DT 19613 8511 7 permission permission NN 19613 8511 8 of of IN 19613 8511 9 the the DT 19613 8511 10 divine divine JJ 19613 8511 11 goodness goodness NN 19613 8511 12 and and CC 19613 8511 13 finally finally RB 19613 8511 14 also also RB 19613 8511 15 to to IN 19613 8511 16 the the DT 19613 8511 17 guidance guidance NN 19613 8511 18 of of IN 19613 8511 19 divine divine NNP 19613 8511 20 providence providence NN 19613 8511 21 , , , 19613 8511 22 though though IN 19613 8511 23 the the DT 19613 8511 24 latter latter NN 19613 8511 25 has have VBZ 19613 8511 26 created create VBN 19613 8511 27 for for IN 19613 8511 28 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8511 29 a a DT 19613 8511 30 limit limit NN 19613 8511 31 in in IN 19613 8511 32 freedom freedom NN 19613 8511 33 . . . 19613 8512 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8512 2 772 772 CD 19613 8512 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8512 4 Evil Evil NNP 19613 8512 5 , , , 19613 8512 6 however however RB 19613 8512 7 , , , 19613 8512 8 and and CC 19613 8512 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8512 10 is be VBZ 19613 8512 11 in in IN 19613 8512 12 this this DT 19613 8512 13 idea idea NN 19613 8512 14 that that IN 19613 8512 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8512 16 's 's POS 19613 8512 17 great great JJ 19613 8512 18 optimism optimism NN 19613 8512 19 consists consist VBZ 19613 8512 20 , , , 19613 8512 21 can can MD 19613 8512 22 not not RB 19613 8512 23 conquer conquer VB 19613 8512 24 in in IN 19613 8512 25 the the DT 19613 8512 26 end end NN 19613 8512 27 . . . 19613 8513 1 As as IN 19613 8513 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8513 3 is be VBZ 19613 8513 4 nothing nothing NN 19613 8513 5 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8513 6 , , , 19613 8513 7 so so RB 19613 8513 8 also also RB 19613 8513 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8513 10 is be VBZ 19613 8513 11 at at IN 19613 8513 12 bottom bottom NN 19613 8513 13 nothing nothing NN 19613 8513 14 real real RB 19613 8513 15 ; ; : 19613 8513 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8513 17 is be VBZ 19613 8513 18 " " `` 19613 8513 19 nonexistent nonexistent JJ 19613 8513 20 " " '' 19613 8513 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8513 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8513 23 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8513 24 : : : 19613 8513 25 ouch ouch NN 19613 8513 26 on on RP 19613 8513 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8513 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8513 29 and and CC 19613 8513 30 " " `` 19613 8513 31 unreal unreal JJ 19613 8513 32 " " '' 19613 8513 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8513 34 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8513 35 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8513 36 : : : 19613 8513 37 anupostaton anupostaton NNP 19613 8513 38 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8513 39 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8513 40 . . . 19613 8514 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8514 2 773 773 CD 19613 8514 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8514 4 For for IN 19613 8514 5 this this DT 19613 8514 6 very very JJ 19613 8514 7 reason reason NN 19613 8514 8 the the DT 19613 8514 9 estrangement estrangement NN 19613 8514 10 of of IN 19613 8514 11 the the DT 19613 8514 12 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8514 13 from from IN 19613 8514 14 God God NNP 19613 8514 15 must must MD 19613 8514 16 finally finally RB 19613 8514 17 cease cease VB 19613 8514 18 ; ; : 19613 8514 19 even even RB 19613 8514 20 the the DT 19613 8514 21 devil devil NN 19613 8514 22 , , , 19613 8514 23 who who WP 19613 8514 24 , , , 19613 8514 25 as as RB 19613 8514 26 far far RB 19613 8514 27 as as IN 19613 8514 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8514 29 _ _ NNP 19613 8514 30 being be VBG 19613 8514 31 _ _ NNP 19613 8514 32 is be VBZ 19613 8514 33 concerned concern VBN 19613 8514 34 , , , 19613 8514 35 resulted result VBD 19613 8514 36 from from IN 19613 8514 37 God God NNP 19613 8514 38 's 's POS 19613 8514 39 will will NN 19613 8514 40 , , , 19613 8514 41 can can MD 19613 8514 42 not not RB 19613 8514 43 always always RB 19613 8514 44 remain remain VB 19613 8514 45 a a DT 19613 8514 46 devil devil NN 19613 8514 47 . . . 19613 8515 1 The the DT 19613 8515 2 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8515 3 must must MD 19613 8515 4 return return VB 19613 8515 5 to to IN 19613 8515 6 God God NNP 19613 8515 7 , , , 19613 8515 8 and and CC 19613 8515 9 this this DT 19613 8515 10 moment moment NN 19613 8515 11 is be VBZ 19613 8515 12 also also RB 19613 8515 13 the the DT 19613 8515 14 end end NN 19613 8515 15 of of IN 19613 8515 16 the the DT 19613 8515 17 material material NN 19613 8515 18 world world NN 19613 8515 19 , , , 19613 8515 20 which which WDT 19613 8515 21 is be VBZ 19613 8515 22 merely merely RB 19613 8515 23 an an DT 19613 8515 24 intermediate intermediate JJ 19613 8515 25 phase phase NN 19613 8515 26 . . . 19613 8516 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8516 2 774 774 CD 19613 8516 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8516 4 According accord VBG 19613 8516 5 to to IN 19613 8516 6 this this DT 19613 8516 7 conception conception NN 19613 8516 8 the the DT 19613 8516 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8516 10 of of IN 19613 8516 11 man man NN 19613 8516 12 , , , 19613 8516 13 who who WP 19613 8516 14 in in IN 19613 8516 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8516 16 's 's POS 19613 8516 17 view view NN 19613 8516 18 is be VBZ 19613 8516 19 no no RB 19613 8516 20 longer long RBR 19613 8516 21 the the DT 19613 8516 22 sole sole JJ 19613 8516 23 aim aim NN 19613 8516 24 of of IN 19613 8516 25 creation creation NN 19613 8516 26 to to IN 19613 8516 27 the the DT 19613 8516 28 same same JJ 19613 8516 29 extent extent NN 19613 8516 30 as as IN 19613 8516 31 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8516 32 is be VBZ 19613 8516 33 with with IN 19613 8516 34 the the DT 19613 8516 35 other other JJ 19613 8516 36 Fathers,[775 fathers,[775 CD 19613 8516 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8516 38 assumes assume VBZ 19613 8516 39 the the DT 19613 8516 40 following follow VBG 19613 8516 41 form form NN 19613 8516 42 : : : 19613 8516 43 The the DT 19613 8516 44 essence essence NN 19613 8516 45 of of IN 19613 8516 46 man man NN 19613 8516 47 is be VBZ 19613 8516 48 formed form VBN 19613 8516 49 by by IN 19613 8516 50 the the DT 19613 8516 51 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 8516 52 soul soul NN 19613 8516 53 , , , 19613 8516 54 which which WDT 19613 8516 55 has have VBZ 19613 8516 56 fallen fall VBN 19613 8516 57 from from IN 19613 8516 58 the the DT 19613 8516 59 world world NN 19613 8516 60 above above RB 19613 8516 61 . . . 19613 8517 1 This this DT 19613 8517 2 is be VBZ 19613 8517 3 united united JJ 19613 8517 4 with with IN 19613 8517 5 the the DT 19613 8517 6 body body NN 19613 8517 7 by by IN 19613 8517 8 means mean NNS 19613 8517 9 of of IN 19613 8517 10 the the DT 19613 8517 11 animal animal NN 19613 8517 12 soul soul NN 19613 8517 13 . . . 19613 8518 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8518 2 thus thus RB 19613 8518 3 believes believe VBZ 19613 8518 4 in in IN 19613 8518 5 a a DT 19613 8518 6 threefold threefold JJ 19613 8518 7 nature nature NN 19613 8518 8 of of IN 19613 8518 9 man man NN 19613 8518 10 . . . 19613 8519 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8519 2 does do VBZ 19613 8519 3 so so RB 19613 8519 4 in in IN 19613 8519 5 the the DT 19613 8519 6 first first JJ 19613 8519 7 place place NN 19613 8519 8 , , , 19613 8519 9 because because IN 19613 8519 10 Plato Plato NNP 19613 8519 11 holds hold VBZ 19613 8519 12 this this DT 19613 8519 13 theory theory NN 19613 8519 14 , , , 19613 8519 15 and and CC 19613 8519 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8519 17 always always RB 19613 8519 18 embraced embrace VBD 19613 8519 19 the the DT 19613 8519 20 most most RBS 19613 8519 21 complicated complicated JJ 19613 8519 22 view view NN 19613 8519 23 in in IN 19613 8519 24 matters matter NNS 19613 8519 25 of of IN 19613 8519 26 tradition tradition NN 19613 8519 27 , , , 19613 8519 28 and and CC 19613 8519 29 secondly secondly RB 19613 8519 30 , , , 19613 8519 31 because because IN 19613 8519 32 the the DT 19613 8519 33 rational rational JJ 19613 8519 34 soul soul NN 19613 8519 35 can can MD 19613 8519 36 never never RB 19613 8519 37 in in IN 19613 8519 38 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8519 39 be be VB 19613 8519 40 the the DT 19613 8519 41 principle principle NN 19613 8519 42 of of IN 19613 8519 43 action action NN 19613 8519 44 opposed oppose VBN 19613 8519 45 to to IN 19613 8519 46 God God NNP 19613 8519 47 , , , 19613 8519 48 and and CC 19613 8519 49 yet yet RB 19613 8519 50 something something NN 19613 8519 51 relatively relatively RB 19613 8519 52 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8519 53 must must MD 19613 8519 54 be be VB 19613 8519 55 cited cite VBN 19613 8519 56 as as IN 19613 8519 57 the the DT 19613 8519 58 cause cause NN 19613 8519 59 of of IN 19613 8519 60 this this DT 19613 8519 61 action action NN 19613 8519 62 . . . 19613 8520 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8520 2 is be VBZ 19613 8520 3 true true JJ 19613 8520 4 that that IN 19613 8520 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8520 6 also also RB 19613 8520 7 find find VBP 19613 8520 8 in in IN 19613 8520 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8520 10 the the DT 19613 8520 11 view view NN 19613 8520 12 that that IN 19613 8520 13 the the DT 19613 8520 14 spirit spirit NNP 19613 8520 15 in in IN 19613 8520 16 man man NN 19613 8520 17 has have VBZ 19613 8520 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8520 19 been be VBN 19613 8520 20 cooled cool VBN 19613 8520 21 down down RP 19613 8520 22 into into IN 19613 8520 23 a a DT 19613 8520 24 soul soul NN 19613 8520 25 , , , 19613 8520 26 has have VBZ 19613 8520 27 been be VBN 19613 8520 28 , , , 19613 8520 29 as as IN 19613 8520 30 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8520 31 were be VBD 19613 8520 32 , , , 19613 8520 33 transformed transform VBN 19613 8520 34 into into IN 19613 8520 35 a a DT 19613 8520 36 soul soul NN 19613 8520 37 ; ; : 19613 8520 38 but but CC 19613 8520 39 there there EX 19613 8520 40 is be VBZ 19613 8520 41 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8520 42 an an DT 19613 8520 43 ambiguity ambiguity NN 19613 8520 44 here here RB 19613 8520 45 , , , 19613 8520 46 because because IN 19613 8520 47 on on IN 19613 8520 48 the the DT 19613 8520 49 one one CD 19613 8520 50 hand hand NN 19613 8520 51 the the DT 19613 8520 52 spirit spirit NNP 19613 8520 53 of of IN 19613 8520 54 man man NNP 19613 8520 55 is be VBZ 19613 8520 56 said say VBN 19613 8520 57 to to TO 19613 8520 58 have have VB 19613 8520 59 chosen choose VBN 19613 8520 60 a a DT 19613 8520 61 course course NN 19613 8520 62 opposed oppose VBN 19613 8520 63 to to IN 19613 8520 64 God God NNP 19613 8520 65 , , , 19613 8520 66 and and CC 19613 8520 67 , , , 19613 8520 68 on on IN 19613 8520 69 the the DT 19613 8520 70 other other JJ 19613 8520 71 , , , 19613 8520 72 that that DT 19613 8520 73 which which WDT 19613 8520 74 is be VBZ 19613 8520 75 rational rational JJ 19613 8520 76 and and CC 19613 8520 77 free free JJ 19613 8520 78 in in IN 19613 8520 79 man man NN 19613 8520 80 must must MD 19613 8520 81 be be VB 19613 8520 82 shown show VBN 19613 8520 83 to to TO 19613 8520 84 be be VB 19613 8520 85 something something NN 19613 8520 86 remaining remain VBG 19613 8520 87 intact intact JJ 19613 8520 88 . . . 19613 8521 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8521 2 776 776 CD 19613 8521 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8521 4 Man Man NNP 19613 8521 5 's 's POS 19613 8521 6 struggle struggle NN 19613 8521 7 consists consist VBZ 19613 8521 8 in in IN 19613 8521 9 the the DT 19613 8521 10 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 8521 11 of of IN 19613 8521 12 the the DT 19613 8521 13 two two CD 19613 8521 14 factors factor NNS 19613 8521 15 forming form VBG 19613 8521 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8521 17 constitution constitution NN 19613 8521 18 to to TO 19613 8521 19 gain gain VB 19613 8521 20 control control NN 19613 8521 21 of of IN 19613 8521 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8521 23 sphere sphere NN 19613 8521 24 of of IN 19613 8521 25 action action NN 19613 8521 26 . . . 19613 8522 1 If if IN 19613 8522 2 man man NN 19613 8522 3 conquers conquer VBZ 19613 8522 4 in in IN 19613 8522 5 this this DT 19613 8522 6 struggle struggle NN 19613 8522 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8522 8 attains attain VBZ 19613 8522 9 _ _ NNP 19613 8522 10 likeness likeness NN 19613 8522 11 _ _ NNP 19613 8522 12 to to IN 19613 8522 13 God God NNP 19613 8522 14 ; ; : 19613 8522 15 the the DT 19613 8522 16 image image NN 19613 8522 17 of of IN 19613 8522 18 God God NNP 19613 8522 19 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8522 20 bears bear VBZ 19613 8522 21 beyond beyond IN 19613 8522 22 danger danger NN 19613 8522 23 of of IN 19613 8522 24 loss loss NN 19613 8522 25 in in IN 19613 8522 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8522 27 indestructible indestructible JJ 19613 8522 28 , , , 19613 8522 29 rational rational JJ 19613 8522 30 , , , 19613 8522 31 and and CC 19613 8522 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 8522 33 immortal immortal JJ 19613 8522 34 spirit spirit NN 19613 8522 35 . . . 19613 8523 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8523 2 777 777 CD 19613 8523 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8523 4 Victory victory NN 19613 8523 5 , , , 19613 8523 6 however however RB 19613 8523 7 , , , 19613 8523 8 denotes denote VBZ 19613 8523 9 nothing nothing NN 19613 8523 10 else else RB 19613 8523 11 than than IN 19613 8523 12 the the DT 19613 8523 13 subjugation subjugation NN 19613 8523 14 of of IN 19613 8523 15 the the DT 19613 8523 16 instincts instinct NNS 19613 8523 17 and and CC 19613 8523 18 passions passion NNS 19613 8523 19 . . . 19613 8524 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8524 2 778 778 CD 19613 8524 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8524 4 No no RB 19613 8524 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 8524 6 God God NNP 19613 8524 7 affords afford VBZ 19613 8524 8 help help NN 19613 8524 9 in in IN 19613 8524 10 the the DT 19613 8524 11 struggle struggle NN 19613 8524 12 , , , 19613 8524 13 for for IN 19613 8524 14 nothing nothing NN 19613 8524 15 good good JJ 19613 8524 16 is be VBZ 19613 8524 17 without without IN 19613 8524 18 God,[779 God,[779 NNP 19613 8524 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8524 20 but but CC 19613 8524 21 in in IN 19613 8524 22 such such PDT 19613 8524 23 a a DT 19613 8524 24 way way NN 19613 8524 25 as as IN 19613 8524 26 not not RB 19613 8524 27 to to TO 19613 8524 28 interfere interfere VB 19613 8524 29 with with IN 19613 8524 30 freedom freedom NN 19613 8524 31 . . . 19613 8525 1 According accord VBG 19613 8525 2 to to IN 19613 8525 3 this this DT 19613 8525 4 conception conception NN 19613 8525 5 sin sin NN 19613 8525 6 is be VBZ 19613 8525 7 a a DT 19613 8525 8 matter matter NN 19613 8525 9 of of IN 19613 8525 10 necessity necessity NN 19613 8525 11 in in IN 19613 8525 12 the the DT 19613 8525 13 case case NN 19613 8525 14 of of IN 19613 8525 15 fallen fall VBN 19613 8525 16 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8525 17 ; ; : 19613 8525 18 all all DT 19613 8525 19 men man NNS 19613 8525 20 are be VBP 19613 8525 21 met meet VBN 19613 8525 22 with with IN 19613 8525 23 as as IN 19613 8525 24 sinners sinner NNS 19613 8525 25 and and CC 19613 8525 26 are be VBP 19613 8525 27 so so RB 19613 8525 28 , , , 19613 8525 29 for for IN 19613 8525 30 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8525 31 were be VBD 19613 8525 32 already already RB 19613 8525 33 sinners sinner NNS 19613 8525 34 . . . 19613 8526 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8526 2 780 780 CD 19613 8526 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8526 4 Sin sin NN 19613 8526 5 is be VBZ 19613 8526 6 rooted root VBN 19613 8526 7 in in IN 19613 8526 8 the the DT 19613 8526 9 whole whole JJ 19613 8526 10 earthly earthly JJ 19613 8526 11 condition condition NN 19613 8526 12 of of IN 19613 8526 13 men man NNS 19613 8526 14 ; ; : 19613 8526 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8526 16 is be VBZ 19613 8526 17 the the DT 19613 8526 18 weakness weakness NN 19613 8526 19 and and CC 19613 8526 20 error error NN 19613 8526 21 of of IN 19613 8526 22 the the DT 19613 8526 23 spirit spirit NNP 19613 8526 24 parted part VBN 19613 8526 25 from from IN 19613 8526 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8526 27 origin origin NN 19613 8526 28 . . . 19613 8527 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8527 2 781 781 CD 19613 8527 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8527 4 The the DT 19613 8527 5 idea idea NN 19613 8527 6 of of IN 19613 8527 7 freedom freedom NN 19613 8527 8 , , , 19613 8527 9 indeed indeed RB 19613 8527 10 , , , 19613 8527 11 is be VBZ 19613 8527 12 supposed suppose VBN 19613 8527 13 to to TO 19613 8527 14 be be VB 19613 8527 15 a a DT 19613 8527 16 feature feature NN 19613 8527 17 which which WDT 19613 8527 18 always always RB 19613 8527 19 preserves preserve VBZ 19613 8527 20 the the DT 19613 8527 21 guilty guilty JJ 19613 8527 22 character character NN 19613 8527 23 of of IN 19613 8527 24 sin sin NN 19613 8527 25 ; ; : 19613 8527 26 but but CC 19613 8527 27 in in IN 19613 8527 28 truth truth NN 19613 8527 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8527 30 becomes become VBZ 19613 8527 31 a a DT 19613 8527 32 mere mere JJ 19613 8527 33 appearance,[782 appearance,[782 NN 19613 8527 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8527 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8527 36 does do VBZ 19613 8527 37 not not RB 19613 8527 38 avail avail VB 19613 8527 39 against against IN 19613 8527 40 the the DT 19613 8527 41 constitution constitution NNP 19613 8527 42 of of IN 19613 8527 43 man man NNP 19613 8527 44 and and CC 19613 8527 45 the the DT 19613 8527 46 sinful sinful JJ 19613 8527 47 habit habit NN 19613 8527 48 propagated propagate VBN 19613 8527 49 in in IN 19613 8527 50 human human JJ 19613 8527 51 society society NN 19613 8527 52 . . . 19613 8528 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8528 2 783 783 CD 19613 8528 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8528 4 All all DT 19613 8528 5 must must MD 19613 8528 6 be be VB 19613 8528 7 sinners sinner NNS 19613 8528 8 at at IN 19613 8528 9 first,[784 first,[784 NN 19613 8528 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8528 11 for for IN 19613 8528 12 that that DT 19613 8528 13 is be VBZ 19613 8528 14 as as RB 19613 8528 15 much much JJ 19613 8528 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8528 17 destiny destiny NN 19613 8528 18 as as IN 19613 8528 19 is be VBZ 19613 8528 20 the the DT 19613 8528 21 doom doom NN 19613 8528 22 of of IN 19613 8528 23 death death NN 19613 8528 24 which which WDT 19613 8528 25 is be VBZ 19613 8528 26 a a DT 19613 8528 27 necessary necessary JJ 19613 8528 28 consequence consequence NN 19613 8528 29 of of IN 19613 8528 30 man man NNP 19613 8528 31 's 's POS 19613 8528 32 material material NN 19613 8528 33 nature nature NN 19613 8528 34 . . . 19613 8529 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8529 2 785 785 CD 19613 8529 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8529 4 _ _ NNP 19613 8529 5 The the DT 19613 8529 6 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 19613 8529 7 of of IN 19613 8529 8 Redemption Redemption NNP 19613 8529 9 and and CC 19613 8529 10 Restoration Restoration NNP 19613 8529 11 . . . 19613 8529 12 _ _ NNP 19613 8529 13 In in IN 19613 8529 14 the the DT 19613 8529 15 view view NN 19613 8529 16 of of IN 19613 8529 17 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8529 18 and and CC 19613 8529 19 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8529 20 the the DT 19613 8529 21 proposition proposition NN 19613 8529 22 : : : 19613 8529 23 " " `` 19613 8529 24 God God NNP 19613 8529 25 wishes wish VBZ 19613 8529 26 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8529 27 to to TO 19613 8529 28 be be VB 19613 8529 29 saved save VBN 19613 8529 30 by by IN 19613 8529 31 means mean NNS 19613 8529 32 of of IN 19613 8529 33 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8529 34 " " '' 19613 8529 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8529 36 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8529 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8529 38 : : : 19613 8529 39 o o NNP 19613 8529 40 Theos Theos NNP 19613 8529 41 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 8529 42 ex ex FW 19613 8529 43 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 8529 44 autôn autôn NNP 19613 8529 45 bouletai bouletai NNP 19613 8529 46 sôzesthai sôzesthai NNP 19613 8529 47 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8529 48 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8529 49 is be VBZ 19613 8529 50 quite quite RB 19613 8529 51 as as RB 19613 8529 52 true true JJ 19613 8529 53 as as IN 19613 8529 54 the the DT 19613 8529 55 other other JJ 19613 8529 56 statement statement NN 19613 8529 57 that that WDT 19613 8529 58 no no DT 19613 8529 59 spirit spirit NN 19613 8529 60 can can MD 19613 8529 61 be be VB 19613 8529 62 saved save VBN 19613 8529 63 without without IN 19613 8529 64 entering enter VBG 19613 8529 65 into into IN 19613 8529 66 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 8529 67 with with IN 19613 8529 68 the the DT 19613 8529 69 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8529 70 and and CC 19613 8529 71 submitting submit VBG 19613 8529 72 to to IN 19613 8529 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8529 74 instruction instruction NN 19613 8529 75 . . . 19613 8530 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8530 2 786 786 CD 19613 8530 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8530 4 They -PRON- PRP 19613 8530 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 8530 6 hold hold VBP 19613 8530 7 that that IN 19613 8530 8 the the DT 19613 8530 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8530 10 , , , 19613 8530 11 after after IN 19613 8530 12 passing pass VBG 19613 8530 13 through through IN 19613 8530 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8530 15 various various JJ 19613 8530 16 stages stage NNS 19613 8530 17 of of IN 19613 8530 18 revealing reveal VBG 19613 8530 19 activity activity NN 19613 8530 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8530 21 law law NN 19613 8530 22 of of IN 19613 8530 23 nature nature NN 19613 8530 24 , , , 19613 8530 25 Mosaic Mosaic NNP 19613 8530 26 law law NN 19613 8530 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8530 28 , , , 19613 8530 29 disclosed disclose VBD 19613 8530 30 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8530 31 in in IN 19613 8530 32 the the DT 19613 8530 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8530 34 in in IN 19613 8530 35 a a DT 19613 8530 36 manner manner NN 19613 8530 37 complete complete JJ 19613 8530 38 and and CC 19613 8530 39 accessible accessible JJ 19613 8530 40 to to IN 19613 8530 41 all all DT 19613 8530 42 , , , 19613 8530 43 so so IN 19613 8530 44 that that IN 19613 8530 45 this this DT 19613 8530 46 revelation revelation NN 19613 8530 47 imparts impart VBZ 19613 8530 48 redemption redemption NN 19613 8530 49 and and CC 19613 8530 50 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8530 51 happiness happiness NN 19613 8530 52 to to IN 19613 8530 53 all all DT 19613 8530 54 men man NNS 19613 8530 55 , , , 19613 8530 56 however however RB 19613 8530 57 different different JJ 19613 8530 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8530 59 capacities capacity NNS 19613 8530 60 may may MD 19613 8530 61 be be VB 19613 8530 62 . . . 19613 8531 1 Finally finally RB 19613 8531 2 , , , 19613 8531 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8531 4 is be VBZ 19613 8531 5 assumed assume VBN 19613 8531 6 that that IN 19613 8531 7 not not RB 19613 8531 8 only only RB 19613 8531 9 men man NNS 19613 8531 10 but but CC 19613 8531 11 all all DT 19613 8531 12 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8531 13 creatures creature NNS 19613 8531 14 , , , 19613 8531 15 from from IN 19613 8531 16 the the DT 19613 8531 17 radiant radiant JJ 19613 8531 18 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8531 19 of of IN 19613 8531 20 heaven heaven NNP 19613 8531 21 down down RP 19613 8531 22 to to IN 19613 8531 23 the the DT 19613 8531 24 dusky dusky JJ 19613 8531 25 demons demon NNS 19613 8531 26 , , , 19613 8531 27 have have VBP 19613 8531 28 the the DT 19613 8531 29 capacity capacity NN 19613 8531 30 and and CC 19613 8531 31 need need NN 19613 8531 32 of of IN 19613 8531 33 redemption redemption NN 19613 8531 34 ; ; : 19613 8531 35 while while IN 19613 8531 36 for for IN 19613 8531 37 the the DT 19613 8531 38 highest high JJS 19613 8531 39 stage stage NN 19613 8531 40 , , , 19613 8531 41 the the DT 19613 8531 42 " " `` 19613 8531 43 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8531 44 Church Church NNP 19613 8531 45 " " '' 19613 8531 46 , , , 19613 8531 47 there there EX 19613 8531 48 is be VBZ 19613 8531 49 an an DT 19613 8531 50 _ _ NNP 19613 8531 51 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8531 52 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8531 53 _ _ NNP 19613 8531 54 which which WDT 19613 8531 55 is be VBZ 19613 8531 56 related relate VBN 19613 8531 57 to to IN 19613 8531 58 the the DT 19613 8531 59 written write VBN 19613 8531 60 one one NN 19613 8531 61 as as IN 19613 8531 62 the the DT 19613 8531 63 latter latter NN 19613 8531 64 is be VBZ 19613 8531 65 to to IN 19613 8531 66 the the DT 19613 8531 67 law law NN 19613 8531 68 . . . 19613 8532 1 This this DT 19613 8532 2 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8532 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8532 4 is be VBZ 19613 8532 5 the the DT 19613 8532 6 first first JJ 19613 8532 7 complete complete JJ 19613 8532 8 revelation revelation NN 19613 8532 9 of of IN 19613 8532 10 God God NNP 19613 8532 11 's 's POS 19613 8532 12 highest high JJS 19613 8532 13 intentions intention NNS 19613 8532 14 , , , 19613 8532 15 and and CC 19613 8532 16 lies lie NNS 19613 8532 17 hidden hide VBN 19613 8532 18 in in IN 19613 8532 19 the the DT 19613 8532 20 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8532 21 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8532 22 . . . 19613 8533 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8533 2 787 787 CD 19613 8533 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8533 4 These these DT 19613 8533 5 elements element NNS 19613 8533 6 compose compose VBP 19613 8533 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8533 8 's 's POS 19613 8533 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8533 10 of of IN 19613 8533 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 8533 12 in in IN 19613 8533 13 general general JJ 19613 8533 14 and and CC 19613 8533 15 of of IN 19613 8533 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8533 17 in in IN 19613 8533 18 particular particular JJ 19613 8533 19 . . . 19613 8534 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8534 2 788 788 CD 19613 8534 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8534 4 They -PRON- PRP 19613 8534 5 presuppose presuppose VBP 19613 8534 6 the the DT 19613 8534 7 sighing sighing NN 19613 8534 8 of of IN 19613 8534 9 the the DT 19613 8534 10 creature creature NN 19613 8534 11 and and CC 19613 8534 12 the the DT 19613 8534 13 great great JJ 19613 8534 14 struggle struggle NN 19613 8534 15 which which WDT 19613 8534 16 is be VBZ 19613 8534 17 more more RBR 19613 8534 18 especially especially RB 19613 8534 19 carried carry VBN 19613 8534 20 on on RP 19613 8534 21 upon upon IN 19613 8534 22 earth earth NN 19613 8534 23 , , , 19613 8534 24 within within IN 19613 8534 25 the the DT 19613 8534 26 human human JJ 19613 8534 27 breast breast NN 19613 8534 28 , , , 19613 8534 29 by by IN 19613 8534 30 the the DT 19613 8534 31 angels angel NNS 19613 8534 32 and and CC 19613 8534 33 demons demon NNS 19613 8534 34 , , , 19613 8534 35 virtues virtue NNS 19613 8534 36 and and CC 19613 8534 37 vices vice NNS 19613 8534 38 , , , 19613 8534 39 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8534 40 and and CC 19613 8534 41 passion passion NN 19613 8534 42 , , , 19613 8534 43 that that WDT 19613 8534 44 dispute dispute VBP 19613 8534 45 the the DT 19613 8534 46 possession possession NN 19613 8534 47 of of IN 19613 8534 48 man man NN 19613 8534 49 . . . 19613 8535 1 Man man NN 19613 8535 2 must must MD 19613 8535 3 conquer conquer VB 19613 8535 4 and and CC 19613 8535 5 yet yet RB 19613 8535 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8535 7 can can MD 19613 8535 8 not not RB 19613 8535 9 do do VB 19613 8535 10 so so RB 19613 8535 11 without without IN 19613 8535 12 help help NN 19613 8535 13 . . . 19613 8536 1 But but CC 19613 8536 2 help help NN 19613 8536 3 has have VBZ 19613 8536 4 never never RB 19613 8536 5 been be VBN 19613 8536 6 wanting want VBG 19613 8536 7 . . . 19613 8537 1 The the DT 19613 8537 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8537 3 has have VBZ 19613 8537 4 been be VBN 19613 8537 5 revealing reveal VBG 19613 8537 6 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8537 7 from from IN 19613 8537 8 the the DT 19613 8537 9 beginning beginning NN 19613 8537 10 . . . 19613 8538 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8538 2 's 's POS 19613 8538 3 teaching teaching NN 19613 8538 4 concerning concern VBG 19613 8538 5 the the DT 19613 8538 6 preparatory preparatory JJ 19613 8538 7 history history NN 19613 8538 8 of of IN 19613 8538 9 redemption redemption NN 19613 8538 10 is be VBZ 19613 8538 11 founded found VBN 19613 8538 12 on on IN 19613 8538 13 the the DT 19613 8538 14 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 8538 15 of of IN 19613 8538 16 the the DT 19613 8538 17 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 8538 18 ; ; : 19613 8538 19 but but CC 19613 8538 20 with with IN 19613 8538 21 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8538 22 everything everything NN 19613 8538 23 takes take VBZ 19613 8538 24 a a DT 19613 8538 25 more more RBR 19613 8538 26 vivid vivid JJ 19613 8538 27 form form NN 19613 8538 28 , , , 19613 8538 29 and and CC 19613 8538 30 influences influence NNS 19613 8538 31 on on IN 19613 8538 32 the the DT 19613 8538 33 part part NN 19613 8538 34 of of IN 19613 8538 35 the the DT 19613 8538 36 heretical heretical JJ 19613 8538 37 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8538 38 are be VBP 19613 8538 39 also also RB 19613 8538 40 not not RB 19613 8538 41 lacking lack VBG 19613 8538 42 . . . 19613 8539 1 Pure pure JJ 19613 8539 2 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8539 3 , , , 19613 8539 4 whom whom WP 19613 8539 5 no no DT 19613 8539 6 fault fault NN 19613 8539 7 of of IN 19613 8539 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8539 9 own own JJ 19613 8539 10 had have VBD 19613 8539 11 caused cause VBN 19613 8539 12 to to TO 19613 8539 13 be be VB 19613 8539 14 invested invest VBN 19613 8539 15 with with IN 19613 8539 16 bodies body NNS 19613 8539 17 , , , 19613 8539 18 namely namely RB 19613 8539 19 , , , 19613 8539 20 the the DT 19613 8539 21 prophets prophet NNS 19613 8539 22 , , , 19613 8539 23 were be VBD 19613 8539 24 sent send VBN 19613 8539 25 to to IN 19613 8539 26 men man NNS 19613 8539 27 by by IN 19613 8539 28 the the DT 19613 8539 29 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8539 30 in in IN 19613 8539 31 order order NN 19613 8539 32 to to TO 19613 8539 33 support support VB 19613 8539 34 the the DT 19613 8539 35 struggling struggling NN 19613 8539 36 and and CC 19613 8539 37 to to TO 19613 8539 38 increase increase VB 19613 8539 39 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8539 40 . . . 19613 8540 1 To to TO 19613 8540 2 prepare prepare VB 19613 8540 3 the the DT 19613 8540 4 way way NN 19613 8540 5 of of IN 19613 8540 6 salvation salvation NN 19613 8540 7 the the DT 19613 8540 8 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8540 9 chose choose VBD 19613 8540 10 for for IN 19613 8540 11 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8540 12 a a DT 19613 8540 13 whole whole JJ 19613 8540 14 people people NNS 19613 8540 15 , , , 19613 8540 16 and and CC 19613 8540 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8540 18 revealed reveal VBD 19613 8540 19 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8540 20 among among IN 19613 8540 21 all all DT 19613 8540 22 men man NNS 19613 8540 23 . . . 19613 8541 1 But but CC 19613 8541 2 all all PDT 19613 8541 3 these these DT 19613 8541 4 undertakings undertaking NNS 19613 8541 5 did do VBD 19613 8541 6 not not RB 19613 8541 7 yet yet RB 19613 8541 8 lead lead VB 19613 8541 9 to to IN 19613 8541 10 the the DT 19613 8541 11 goal goal NN 19613 8541 12 . . . 19613 8542 1 The the DT 19613 8542 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8542 3 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8542 4 was be VBD 19613 8542 5 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8542 6 to to TO 19613 8542 7 appear appear VB 19613 8542 8 and and CC 19613 8542 9 lead lead VB 19613 8542 10 men man NNS 19613 8542 11 back back RB 19613 8542 12 . . . 19613 8543 1 But but CC 19613 8543 2 by by IN 19613 8543 3 reason reason NN 19613 8543 4 of of IN 19613 8543 5 the the DT 19613 8543 6 diverse diverse JJ 19613 8543 7 nature nature NN 19613 8543 8 of of IN 19613 8543 9 the the DT 19613 8543 10 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8543 11 , , , 19613 8543 12 and and CC 19613 8543 13 especially especially RB 19613 8543 14 of of IN 19613 8543 15 men man NNS 19613 8543 16 , , , 19613 8543 17 the the DT 19613 8543 18 redeeming redeem VBG 19613 8543 19 work work NN 19613 8543 20 of of IN 19613 8543 21 the the DT 19613 8543 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8543 23 that that WDT 19613 8543 24 appeared appear VBD 19613 8543 25 could could MD 19613 8543 26 not not RB 19613 8543 27 fail fail VB 19613 8543 28 to to TO 19613 8543 29 be be VB 19613 8543 30 a a DT 19613 8543 31 complicated complicated JJ 19613 8543 32 one one NN 19613 8543 33 . . . 19613 8544 1 In in IN 19613 8544 2 the the DT 19613 8544 3 case case NN 19613 8544 4 of of IN 19613 8544 5 some some DT 19613 8544 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8544 7 had have VBD 19613 8544 8 really really RB 19613 8544 9 to to TO 19613 8544 10 show show VB 19613 8544 11 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8544 12 the the DT 19613 8544 13 victory victory NN 19613 8544 14 over over IN 19613 8544 15 the the DT 19613 8544 16 demons demon NNS 19613 8544 17 and and CC 19613 8544 18 sin sin NN 19613 8544 19 , , , 19613 8544 20 a a DT 19613 8544 21 view view NN 19613 8544 22 which which WDT 19613 8544 23 beyond beyond IN 19613 8544 24 dispute dispute NN 19613 8544 25 is be VBZ 19613 8544 26 derived derive VBN 19613 8544 27 from from IN 19613 8544 28 that that DT 19613 8544 29 of of IN 19613 8544 30 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8544 31 . . . 19613 8545 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8545 2 had have VBD 19613 8545 3 , , , 19613 8545 4 as as IN 19613 8545 5 the the DT 19613 8545 6 " " `` 19613 8545 7 Godman Godman NNP 19613 8545 8 , , , 19613 8545 9 " " '' 19613 8545 10 to to TO 19613 8545 11 make make VB 19613 8545 12 a a DT 19613 8545 13 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 8545 14 which which WDT 19613 8545 15 represented represent VBD 19613 8545 16 the the DT 19613 8545 17 expiation expiation NN 19613 8545 18 of of IN 19613 8545 19 sin sin NN 19613 8545 20 , , , 19613 8545 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8545 22 had have VBD 19613 8545 23 to to TO 19613 8545 24 pay pay VB 19613 8545 25 a a DT 19613 8545 26 ransom ransom NN 19613 8545 27 which which WDT 19613 8545 28 put put VBD 19613 8545 29 an an DT 19613 8545 30 end end NN 19613 8545 31 to to IN 19613 8545 32 the the DT 19613 8545 33 devil devil NN 19613 8545 34 's 's POS 19613 8545 35 sovereignty sovereignty NN 19613 8545 36 over over IN 19613 8545 37 men man NNS 19613 8545 38 's 's POS 19613 8545 39 souls soul NNS 19613 8545 40 , , , 19613 8545 41 and and CC 19613 8545 42 in in IN 19613 8545 43 short short JJ 19613 8545 44 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8545 45 had have VBD 19613 8545 46 to to TO 19613 8545 47 bring bring VB 19613 8545 48 a a DT 19613 8545 49 redemption redemption NN 19613 8545 50 visible visible JJ 19613 8545 51 and and CC 19613 8545 52 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 8545 53 to to IN 19613 8545 54 all all DT 19613 8545 55 . . . 19613 8546 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8546 2 789 789 CD 19613 8546 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8546 4 To to IN 19613 8546 5 the the DT 19613 8546 6 rest rest NN 19613 8546 7 , , , 19613 8546 8 however however RB 19613 8546 9 , , , 19613 8546 10 as as IN 19613 8546 11 divine divine JJ 19613 8546 12 teacher teacher NN 19613 8546 13 and and CC 19613 8546 14 hierophant hierophant NNP 19613 8546 15 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8546 16 had have VBD 19613 8546 17 to to TO 19613 8546 18 reveal reveal VB 19613 8546 19 the the DT 19613 8546 20 depths depth NNS 19613 8546 21 of of IN 19613 8546 22 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8546 23 , , , 19613 8546 24 and and CC 19613 8546 25 to to TO 19613 8546 26 impart impart VB 19613 8546 27 in in IN 19613 8546 28 this this DT 19613 8546 29 very very JJ 19613 8546 30 process process NN 19613 8546 31 a a DT 19613 8546 32 new new JJ 19613 8546 33 principle principle NN 19613 8546 34 of of IN 19613 8546 35 life life NN 19613 8546 36 , , , 19613 8546 37 so so IN 19613 8546 38 that that IN 19613 8546 39 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8546 40 might may MD 19613 8546 41 now now RB 19613 8546 42 partake partake VB 19613 8546 43 of of IN 19613 8546 44 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8546 45 life life NN 19613 8546 46 and and CC 19613 8546 47 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8546 48 become become VBP 19613 8546 49 divine divine JJ 19613 8546 50 through through IN 19613 8546 51 being be VBG 19613 8546 52 interwoven interwoven JJ 19613 8546 53 with with IN 19613 8546 54 the the DT 19613 8546 55 divine divine JJ 19613 8546 56 essence essence NN 19613 8546 57 . . . 19613 8547 1 Here here RB 19613 8547 2 , , , 19613 8547 3 as as IN 19613 8547 4 in in IN 19613 8547 5 the the DT 19613 8547 6 former former JJ 19613 8547 7 case case NN 19613 8547 8 , , , 19613 8547 9 restoration restoration NN 19613 8547 10 to to IN 19613 8547 11 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 8547 12 with with IN 19613 8547 13 God God NNP 19613 8547 14 is be VBZ 19613 8547 15 the the DT 19613 8547 16 goal goal NN 19613 8547 17 ; ; : 19613 8547 18 but but CC 19613 8547 19 , , , 19613 8547 20 as as IN 19613 8547 21 in in IN 19613 8547 22 the the DT 19613 8547 23 lower low JJR 19613 8547 24 stage stage NN 19613 8547 25 , , , 19613 8547 26 this this DT 19613 8547 27 restoration restoration NN 19613 8547 28 is be VBZ 19613 8547 29 effected effect VBN 19613 8547 30 through through IN 19613 8547 31 faith faith NN 19613 8547 32 and and CC 19613 8547 33 sure sure JJ 19613 8547 34 conviction conviction NN 19613 8547 35 of of IN 19613 8547 36 the the DT 19613 8547 37 reality reality NN 19613 8547 38 of of IN 19613 8547 39 a a DT 19613 8547 40 historical historical JJ 19613 8547 41 fact fact NN 19613 8547 42 -- -- : 19613 8547 43 namely namely RB 19613 8547 44 , , , 19613 8547 45 the the DT 19613 8547 46 redeeming redeem VBG 19613 8547 47 death death NN 19613 8547 48 of of IN 19613 8547 49 Christ,--so Christ,--so NNP 19613 8547 50 , , , 19613 8547 51 in in IN 19613 8547 52 the the DT 19613 8547 53 higher high JJR 19613 8547 54 stage stage NN 19613 8547 55 , , , 19613 8547 56 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8547 57 is be VBZ 19613 8547 58 accomplished accomplish VBN 19613 8547 59 through through IN 19613 8547 60 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8547 61 and and CC 19613 8547 62 love love NN 19613 8547 63 , , , 19613 8547 64 which which WDT 19613 8547 65 , , , 19613 8547 66 soaring soar VBG 19613 8547 67 upward upward RB 19613 8547 68 beyond beyond IN 19613 8547 69 the the DT 19613 8547 70 Crucified Crucified NNP 19613 8547 71 One one CD 19613 8547 72 , , , 19613 8547 73 grasp grasp VB 19613 8547 74 the the DT 19613 8547 75 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8547 76 essence essence NN 19613 8547 77 of of IN 19613 8547 78 the the DT 19613 8547 79 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8547 80 , , , 19613 8547 81 revealed reveal VBD 19613 8547 82 to to IN 19613 8547 83 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8547 84 through through IN 19613 8547 85 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8547 86 teaching teaching NN 19613 8547 87 in in IN 19613 8547 88 the the DT 19613 8547 89 eternal eternal JJ 19613 8547 90 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8547 91 . . . 19613 8548 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8548 2 790 790 CD 19613 8548 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8548 4 What what WP 19613 8548 5 the the DT 19613 8548 6 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8548 7 merely merely RB 19613 8548 8 represented represent VBD 19613 8548 9 as as IN 19613 8548 10 a a DT 19613 8548 11 more more RBR 19613 8548 12 or or CC 19613 8548 13 less less RBR 19613 8548 14 valuable valuable JJ 19613 8548 15 appearance-- appearance-- RB 19613 8548 16 namely namely RB 19613 8548 17 , , , 19613 8548 18 the the DT 19613 8548 19 historical historical JJ 19613 8548 20 work work NN 19613 8548 21 of of IN 19613 8548 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8548 23 -- -- : 19613 8548 24 was be VBD 19613 8548 25 to to IN 19613 8548 26 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8548 27 no no DT 19613 8548 28 appearance appearance NN 19613 8548 29 but but IN 19613 8548 30 truth truth NN 19613 8548 31 . . . 19613 8549 1 But but CC 19613 8549 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8549 3 did do VBD 19613 8549 4 not not RB 19613 8549 5 view view VB 19613 8549 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8549 7 as as IN 19613 8549 8 _ _ NNP 19613 8549 9 the the DT 19613 8549 10 _ _ NNP 19613 8549 11 truth truth NN 19613 8549 12 , , , 19613 8549 13 and and CC 19613 8549 14 in in IN 19613 8549 15 this this DT 19613 8549 16 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8549 17 agrees agree VBZ 19613 8549 18 with with IN 19613 8549 19 the the DT 19613 8549 20 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8549 21 , , , 19613 8549 22 but but CC 19613 8549 23 as as IN 19613 8549 24 _ _ NNP 19613 8549 25 a a DT 19613 8549 26 _ _ NNP 19613 8549 27 truth truth NN 19613 8549 28 , , , 19613 8549 29 beyond beyond IN 19613 8549 30 which which WDT 19613 8549 31 lies lie VBZ 19613 8549 32 a a DT 19613 8549 33 higher high JJR 19613 8549 34 . . . 19613 8550 1 That that DT 19613 8550 2 historical historical JJ 19613 8550 3 work work NN 19613 8550 4 of of IN 19613 8550 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8550 6 was be VBD 19613 8550 7 a a DT 19613 8550 8 reality reality NN 19613 8550 9 ; ; : 19613 8550 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8550 11 is be VBZ 19613 8550 12 also also RB 19613 8550 13 indispensable indispensable JJ 19613 8550 14 for for IN 19613 8550 15 men man NNS 19613 8550 16 of of IN 19613 8550 17 more more JJR 19613 8550 18 limited limited JJ 19613 8550 19 endowments endowment NNS 19613 8550 20 , , , 19613 8550 21 and and CC 19613 8550 22 not not RB 19613 8550 23 a a DT 19613 8550 24 matter matter NN 19613 8550 25 of of IN 19613 8550 26 indifference indifference NN 19613 8550 27 to to IN 19613 8550 28 the the DT 19613 8550 29 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8550 30 ; ; : 19613 8550 31 but but CC 19613 8550 32 the the DT 19613 8550 33 latter latter JJ 19613 8550 34 no no RB 19613 8550 35 longer long RBR 19613 8550 36 require require VB 19613 8550 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8550 38 for for IN 19613 8550 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8550 40 personal personal JJ 19613 8550 41 life life NN 19613 8550 42 . . . 19613 8551 1 Here here RB 19613 8551 2 also also RB 19613 8551 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8551 4 again again RB 19613 8551 5 contrived contrive VBD 19613 8551 6 to to TO 19613 8551 7 reconcile reconcile JJ 19613 8551 8 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 8551 9 and and CC 19613 8551 10 thus thus RB 19613 8551 11 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 19613 8551 12 , , , 19613 8551 13 outdid outdid NNP 19613 8551 14 , , , 19613 8551 15 reconciled reconcile VBD 19613 8551 16 , , , 19613 8551 17 and and CC 19613 8551 18 united united NNP 19613 8551 19 both both CC 19613 8551 20 the the DT 19613 8551 21 these these DT 19613 8551 22 s s NNS 19613 8551 23 of of IN 19613 8551 24 the the DT 19613 8551 25 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8551 26 and and CC 19613 8551 27 those those DT 19613 8551 28 of of IN 19613 8551 29 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 8551 30 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8551 31 . . . 19613 8552 1 The the DT 19613 8552 2 object object NN 19613 8552 3 and and CC 19613 8552 4 goal goal NN 19613 8552 5 of of IN 19613 8552 6 redemption redemption NN 19613 8552 7 are be VBP 19613 8552 8 the the DT 19613 8552 9 same same JJ 19613 8552 10 for for IN 19613 8552 11 all all DT 19613 8552 12 , , , 19613 8552 13 namely namely RB 19613 8552 14 , , , 19613 8552 15 the the DT 19613 8552 16 restoration restoration NN 19613 8552 17 of of IN 19613 8552 18 the the DT 19613 8552 19 created create VBN 19613 8552 20 spirit spirit NN 19613 8552 21 to to IN 19613 8552 22 God God NNP 19613 8552 23 and and CC 19613 8552 24 participation participation NN 19613 8552 25 in in IN 19613 8552 26 the the DT 19613 8552 27 divine divine JJ 19613 8552 28 life life NN 19613 8552 29 . . . 19613 8553 1 In in IN 19613 8553 2 so so RB 19613 8553 3 far far RB 19613 8553 4 as as IN 19613 8553 5 history history NN 19613 8553 6 is be VBZ 19613 8553 7 a a DT 19613 8553 8 struggle struggle NN 19613 8553 9 between between IN 19613 8553 10 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8553 11 and and CC 19613 8553 12 demons demon NNS 19613 8553 13 , , , 19613 8553 14 the the DT 19613 8553 15 death death NN 19613 8553 16 of of IN 19613 8553 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8553 18 on on IN 19613 8553 19 the the DT 19613 8553 20 cross cross NN 19613 8553 21 is be VBZ 19613 8553 22 the the DT 19613 8553 23 turning turning NN 19613 8553 24 - - HYPH 19613 8553 25 point point NN 19613 8553 26 of of IN 19613 8553 27 history history NN 19613 8553 28 , , , 19613 8553 29 and and CC 19613 8553 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8553 31 effects effect NNS 19613 8553 32 extend extend VBP 19613 8553 33 even even RB 19613 8553 34 into into IN 19613 8553 35 heaven heaven NNP 19613 8553 36 and and CC 19613 8553 37 hell hell NNP 19613 8553 38 . . . 19613 8554 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8554 2 791 791 CD 19613 8554 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8554 4 On on IN 19613 8554 5 the the DT 19613 8554 6 basis basis NN 19613 8554 7 of of IN 19613 8554 8 this this DT 19613 8554 9 conception conception NN 19613 8554 10 of of IN 19613 8554 11 redemption redemption NN 19613 8554 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8554 13 developed develop VBD 19613 8554 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8554 15 idea idea NN 19613 8554 16 of of IN 19613 8554 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8554 18 . . . 19613 8555 1 Inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 8555 2 as as IN 19613 8555 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8555 4 recognised recognise VBD 19613 8555 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8555 6 as as IN 19613 8555 7 the the DT 19613 8555 8 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 8555 9 , , , 19613 8555 10 this this DT 19613 8555 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8555 12 , , , 19613 8555 13 the the DT 19613 8555 14 God God NNP 19613 8555 15 - - HYPH 19613 8555 16 man man NNP 19613 8555 17 , , , 19613 8555 18 could could MD 19613 8555 19 not not RB 19613 8555 20 but but RB 19613 8555 21 be be VB 19613 8555 22 as as RB 19613 8555 23 many many JJ 19613 8555 24 - - HYPH 19613 8555 25 sided sided JJ 19613 8555 26 as as IN 19613 8555 27 redemption redemption NN 19613 8555 28 is be VBZ 19613 8555 29 . . . 19613 8556 1 Only only RB 19613 8556 2 through through IN 19613 8556 3 that that DT 19613 8556 4 masterly masterly JJ 19613 8556 5 art art NN 19613 8556 6 of of IN 19613 8556 7 reconciling reconcile VBG 19613 8556 8 contradictions contradiction NNS 19613 8556 9 , , , 19613 8556 10 and and CC 19613 8556 11 by by IN 19613 8556 12 the the DT 19613 8556 13 aid aid NN 19613 8556 14 of of IN 19613 8556 15 that that DT 19613 8556 16 fantastic fantastic JJ 19613 8556 17 idea idea NN 19613 8556 18 which which WDT 19613 8556 19 conceives conceive VBZ 19613 8556 20 one one CD 19613 8556 21 real real JJ 19613 8556 22 being being NN 19613 8556 23 as as IN 19613 8556 24 dwelling dwell VBG 19613 8556 25 in in IN 19613 8556 26 another another DT 19613 8556 27 , , , 19613 8556 28 could could MD 19613 8556 29 there there EX 19613 8556 30 be be VB 19613 8556 31 any any DT 19613 8556 32 apparent apparent JJ 19613 8556 33 success success NN 19613 8556 34 in in IN 19613 8556 35 the the DT 19613 8556 36 attempt attempt NN 19613 8556 37 to to TO 19613 8556 38 depict depict VB 19613 8556 39 a a DT 19613 8556 40 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 19613 8556 41 person person NN 19613 8556 42 who who WP 19613 8556 43 in in IN 19613 8556 44 truth truth NN 19613 8556 45 is be VBZ 19613 8556 46 no no RB 19613 8556 47 longer long RBR 19613 8556 48 a a DT 19613 8556 49 person person NN 19613 8556 50 , , , 19613 8556 51 but but CC 19613 8556 52 the the DT 19613 8556 53 symbol symbol NN 19613 8556 54 of of IN 19613 8556 55 the the DT 19613 8556 56 various various JJ 19613 8556 57 redemptions redemption NNS 19613 8556 58 . . . 19613 8557 1 That that IN 19613 8557 2 such such PDT 19613 8557 3 an an DT 19613 8557 4 acute acute JJ 19613 8557 5 thinker thinker NN 19613 8557 6 , , , 19613 8557 7 however however RB 19613 8557 8 , , , 19613 8557 9 did do VBD 19613 8557 10 not not RB 19613 8557 11 shrink shrink VB 19613 8557 12 from from IN 19613 8557 13 the the DT 19613 8557 14 monstrosity monstrosity NN 19613 8557 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8557 16 speculation speculation NN 19613 8557 17 produced produce VBN 19613 8557 18 is be VBZ 19613 8557 19 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 8557 20 to to TO 19613 8557 21 be be VB 19613 8557 22 accounted account VBN 19613 8557 23 for for IN 19613 8557 24 by by IN 19613 8557 25 the the DT 19613 8557 26 fact fact NN 19613 8557 27 that that IN 19613 8557 28 this this DT 19613 8557 29 very very JJ 19613 8557 30 speculation speculation NN 19613 8557 31 afforded afford VBD 19613 8557 32 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8557 33 the the DT 19613 8557 34 means mean NNS 19613 8557 35 of of IN 19613 8557 36 nullifying nullify VBG 19613 8557 37 all all PDT 19613 8557 38 the the DT 19613 8557 39 utterances utterance NNS 19613 8557 40 about about IN 19613 8557 41 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8557 42 and and CC 19613 8557 43 falling fall VBG 19613 8557 44 back back RB 19613 8557 45 on on IN 19613 8557 46 the the DT 19613 8557 47 idea idea NN 19613 8557 48 of of IN 19613 8557 49 the the DT 19613 8557 50 divine divine JJ 19613 8557 51 teacher teacher NN 19613 8557 52 as as IN 19613 8557 53 being be VBG 19613 8557 54 the the DT 19613 8557 55 highest high JJS 19613 8557 56 one one CD 19613 8557 57 . . . 19613 8558 1 The the DT 19613 8558 2 whole whole JJ 19613 8558 3 " " `` 19613 8558 4 humanity humanity NN 19613 8558 5 " " '' 19613 8558 6 of of IN 19613 8558 7 the the DT 19613 8558 8 Redeemer Redeemer NNP 19613 8558 9 together together RB 19613 8558 10 with with IN 19613 8558 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8558 12 history history NN 19613 8558 13 finally finally RB 19613 8558 14 disappears disappear VBZ 19613 8558 15 from from IN 19613 8558 16 the the DT 19613 8558 17 eyes eye NNS 19613 8558 18 of of IN 19613 8558 19 the the DT 19613 8558 20 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8558 21 one one CD 19613 8558 22 . . . 19613 8559 1 What what WP 19613 8559 2 remains remain VBZ 19613 8559 3 is be VBZ 19613 8559 4 the the DT 19613 8559 5 principle principle NN 19613 8559 6 , , , 19613 8559 7 the the DT 19613 8559 8 divine divine JJ 19613 8559 9 Reason reason NN 19613 8559 10 , , , 19613 8559 11 which which WDT 19613 8559 12 became become VBD 19613 8559 13 known known JJ 19613 8559 14 and and CC 19613 8559 15 recognisable recognisable JJ 19613 8559 16 through through IN 19613 8559 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8559 18 . . . 19613 8560 1 The the DT 19613 8560 2 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8560 3 one one CD 19613 8560 4 , , , 19613 8560 5 and and CC 19613 8560 6 this this DT 19613 8560 7 remark remark NN 19613 8560 8 also also RB 19613 8560 9 applies apply VBZ 19613 8560 10 to to IN 19613 8560 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8560 12 's 's POS 19613 8560 13 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8560 14 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8560 15 , , , 19613 8560 16 thus thus RB 19613 8560 17 knows know VBZ 19613 8560 18 no no DT 19613 8560 19 " " `` 19613 8560 20 Christology Christology NNP 19613 8560 21 " " '' 19613 8560 22 , , , 19613 8560 23 but but CC 19613 8560 24 only only RB 19613 8560 25 an an DT 19613 8560 26 indwelling indwelling NN 19613 8560 27 of of IN 19613 8560 28 the the DT 19613 8560 29 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8560 30 in in IN 19613 8560 31 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8560 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8560 33 , , , 19613 8560 34 with with IN 19613 8560 35 which which WDT 19613 8560 36 the the DT 19613 8560 37 indwellings indwelling NNS 19613 8560 38 of of IN 19613 8560 39 this this DT 19613 8560 40 same same JJ 19613 8560 41 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8560 42 in in IN 19613 8560 43 men man NNS 19613 8560 44 began begin VBD 19613 8560 45 . . . 19613 8561 1 To to IN 19613 8561 2 the the DT 19613 8561 3 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8561 4 the the DT 19613 8561 5 question question NN 19613 8561 6 of of IN 19613 8561 7 the the DT 19613 8561 8 divinity divinity NN 19613 8561 9 of of IN 19613 8561 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8561 11 is be VBZ 19613 8561 12 of of IN 19613 8561 13 as as RB 19613 8561 14 little little JJ 19613 8561 15 importance importance NN 19613 8561 16 as as IN 19613 8561 17 that that DT 19613 8561 18 of of IN 19613 8561 19 the the DT 19613 8561 20 humanity humanity NN 19613 8561 21 . . . 19613 8562 1 The the DT 19613 8562 2 former former JJ 19613 8562 3 is be VBZ 19613 8562 4 no no DT 19613 8562 5 question question NN 19613 8562 6 , , , 19613 8562 7 because because IN 19613 8562 8 speculation speculation NN 19613 8562 9 , , , 19613 8562 10 starting start VBG 19613 8562 11 above above RB 19613 8562 12 and and CC 19613 8562 13 proceeding proceed VBG 19613 8562 14 downwards downwards RB 19613 8562 15 , , , 19613 8562 16 is be VBZ 19613 8562 17 already already RB 19613 8562 18 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 8562 19 with with IN 19613 8562 20 the the DT 19613 8562 21 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8562 22 and and CC 19613 8562 23 knows know VBZ 19613 8562 24 that that IN 19613 8562 25 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8562 26 has have VBZ 19613 8562 27 become become VBN 19613 8562 28 completely completely RB 19613 8562 29 comprehensible comprehensible JJ 19613 8562 30 in in IN 19613 8562 31 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8562 32 ; ; : 19613 8562 33 the the DT 19613 8562 34 latter latter NN 19613 8562 35 is be VBZ 19613 8562 36 no no DT 19613 8562 37 question question NN 19613 8562 38 , , , 19613 8562 39 because because IN 19613 8562 40 the the DT 19613 8562 41 humanity humanity NN 19613 8562 42 is be VBZ 19613 8562 43 a a DT 19613 8562 44 matter matter NN 19613 8562 45 of of IN 19613 8562 46 indifference indifference NN 19613 8562 47 , , , 19613 8562 48 being be VBG 19613 8562 49 the the DT 19613 8562 50 form form NN 19613 8562 51 in in IN 19613 8562 52 which which WDT 19613 8562 53 the the DT 19613 8562 54 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8562 55 made make VBD 19613 8562 56 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8562 57 recognisable recognisable JJ 19613 8562 58 . . . 19613 8563 1 But but CC 19613 8563 2 to to IN 19613 8563 3 the the DT 19613 8563 4 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8563 5 who who WP 19613 8563 6 is be VBZ 19613 8563 7 not not RB 19613 8563 8 yet yet RB 19613 8563 9 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8563 10 the the DT 19613 8563 11 divinity divinity NN 19613 8563 12 as as RB 19613 8563 13 well well RB 19613 8563 14 as as IN 19613 8563 15 the the DT 19613 8563 16 humanity humanity NN 19613 8563 17 of of IN 19613 8563 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8563 19 is be VBZ 19613 8563 20 a a DT 19613 8563 21 problem problem NN 19613 8563 22 , , , 19613 8563 23 and and CC 19613 8563 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8563 25 is be VBZ 19613 8563 26 the the DT 19613 8563 27 duty duty NN 19613 8563 28 of of IN 19613 8563 29 the the DT 19613 8563 30 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8563 31 one one NN 19613 8563 32 to to TO 19613 8563 33 solve solve VB 19613 8563 34 and and CC 19613 8563 35 explain explain VB 19613 8563 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8563 37 , , , 19613 8563 38 and and CC 19613 8563 39 to to TO 19613 8563 40 guard guard VB 19613 8563 41 this this DT 19613 8563 42 solution solution NN 19613 8563 43 against against IN 19613 8563 44 errors error NNS 19613 8563 45 on on IN 19613 8563 46 all all DT 19613 8563 47 sides side NNS 19613 8563 48 . . . 19613 8564 1 To to IN 19613 8564 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8564 3 , , , 19613 8564 4 however however RB 19613 8564 5 , , , 19613 8564 6 the the DT 19613 8564 7 errors error NNS 19613 8564 8 are be VBP 19613 8564 9 already already RB 19613 8564 10 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8564 11 Docetism docetism NN 19613 8564 12 on on IN 19613 8564 13 the the DT 19613 8564 14 one one CD 19613 8564 15 hand hand NN 19613 8564 16 , , , 19613 8564 17 and and CC 19613 8564 18 the the DT 19613 8564 19 " " `` 19613 8564 20 Ebionite Ebionite NNP 19613 8564 21 " " '' 19613 8564 22 view view NN 19613 8564 23 on on IN 19613 8564 24 the the DT 19613 8564 25 other other JJ 19613 8564 26 . . . 19613 8565 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8565 2 792 792 CD 19613 8565 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8565 4 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8565 5 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8565 6 was be VBD 19613 8565 7 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8565 8 as as IN 19613 8565 9 follows follow VBZ 19613 8565 10 : : : 19613 8565 11 As as IN 19613 8565 12 a a DT 19613 8565 13 pure pure JJ 19613 8565 14 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 8565 15 spirit spirit NN 19613 8565 16 , , , 19613 8565 17 the the DT 19613 8565 18 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8565 19 could could MD 19613 8565 20 not not RB 19613 8565 21 unite unite VB 19613 8565 22 with with IN 19613 8565 23 matter matter NN 19613 8565 24 , , , 19613 8565 25 because because IN 19613 8565 26 this this DT 19613 8565 27 as as IN 19613 8565 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8565 29 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8565 30 : : : 19613 8565 31 mê mê NN 19613 8565 32 on on RP 19613 8565 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8565 34 would would MD 19613 8565 35 have have VB 19613 8565 36 depotentiated depotentiate VBN 19613 8565 37 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8565 38 . . . 19613 8566 1 A a DT 19613 8566 2 medium medium NN 19613 8566 3 was be VBD 19613 8566 4 required require VBN 19613 8566 5 . . . 19613 8567 1 The the DT 19613 8567 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8567 3 did do VBD 19613 8567 4 not not RB 19613 8567 5 unite unite VB 19613 8567 6 with with IN 19613 8567 7 the the DT 19613 8567 8 body body NN 19613 8567 9 , , , 19613 8567 10 but but CC 19613 8567 11 with with IN 19613 8567 12 a a DT 19613 8567 13 soul soul NN 19613 8567 14 , , , 19613 8567 15 and and CC 19613 8567 16 only only RB 19613 8567 17 through through IN 19613 8567 18 the the DT 19613 8567 19 soul soul NN 19613 8567 20 with with IN 19613 8567 21 the the DT 19613 8567 22 body body NN 19613 8567 23 . . . 19613 8568 1 This this DT 19613 8568 2 soul soul NN 19613 8568 3 was be VBD 19613 8568 4 a a DT 19613 8568 5 pure pure JJ 19613 8568 6 one one NN 19613 8568 7 ; ; : 19613 8568 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8568 9 was be VBD 19613 8568 10 a a DT 19613 8568 11 created create VBN 19613 8568 12 spirit spirit NN 19613 8568 13 that that WDT 19613 8568 14 had have VBD 19613 8568 15 never never RB 19613 8568 16 fallen fall VBN 19613 8568 17 from from IN 19613 8568 18 God God NNP 19613 8568 19 , , , 19613 8568 20 but but CC 19613 8568 21 always always RB 19613 8568 22 remained remain VBD 19613 8568 23 in in IN 19613 8568 24 faithful faithful JJ 19613 8568 25 obedience obedience NN 19613 8568 26 to to IN 19613 8568 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8568 28 , , , 19613 8568 29 and and CC 19613 8568 30 that that DT 19613 8568 31 had have VBD 19613 8568 32 chosen choose VBN 19613 8568 33 to to TO 19613 8568 34 become become VB 19613 8568 35 a a DT 19613 8568 36 soul soul NN 19613 8568 37 in in IN 19613 8568 38 order order NN 19613 8568 39 to to TO 19613 8568 40 serve serve VB 19613 8568 41 the the DT 19613 8568 42 purposes purpose NNS 19613 8568 43 of of IN 19613 8568 44 redemption redemption NN 19613 8568 45 . . . 19613 8569 1 This this DT 19613 8569 2 soul soul NN 19613 8569 3 then then RB 19613 8569 4 was be VBD 19613 8569 5 always always RB 19613 8569 6 devoted devoted JJ 19613 8569 7 to to IN 19613 8569 8 the the DT 19613 8569 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8569 10 from from IN 19613 8569 11 the the DT 19613 8569 12 first first JJ 19613 8569 13 and and CC 19613 8569 14 had have VBD 19613 8569 15 never never RB 19613 8569 16 renounced renounce VBN 19613 8569 17 fellowship fellowship NN 19613 8569 18 with with IN 19613 8569 19 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8569 20 . . . 19613 8570 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8570 2 was be VBD 19613 8570 3 selected select VBN 19613 8570 4 by by IN 19613 8570 5 the the DT 19613 8570 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8570 7 for for IN 19613 8570 8 the the DT 19613 8570 9 purpose purpose NN 19613 8570 10 of of IN 19613 8570 11 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 8570 12 and and CC 19613 8570 13 that that IN 19613 8570 14 because because IN 19613 8570 15 of of IN 19613 8570 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8570 17 moral moral JJ 19613 8570 18 dignity dignity NN 19613 8570 19 . . . 19613 8571 1 The the DT 19613 8571 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8571 3 became become VBD 19613 8571 4 united united JJ 19613 8571 5 with with IN 19613 8571 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8571 7 in in IN 19613 8571 8 the the DT 19613 8571 9 closest close JJS 19613 8571 10 way way NN 19613 8571 11 ; ; : 19613 8571 12 but but CC 19613 8571 13 this this DT 19613 8571 14 connection connection NN 19613 8571 15 , , , 19613 8571 16 though though IN 19613 8571 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8571 18 is be VBZ 19613 8571 19 to to TO 19613 8571 20 be be VB 19613 8571 21 viewed view VBN 19613 8571 22 as as IN 19613 8571 23 a a DT 19613 8571 24 mysteriously mysteriously RB 19613 8571 25 real real JJ 19613 8571 26 union union NN 19613 8571 27 , , , 19613 8571 28 continues continue VBZ 19613 8571 29 to to TO 19613 8571 30 remain remain VB 19613 8571 31 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8571 32 only only RB 19613 8571 33 because because IN 19613 8571 34 of of IN 19613 8571 35 the the DT 19613 8571 36 unceasing unceasing NN 19613 8571 37 effort effort NN 19613 8571 38 of of IN 19613 8571 39 will will NN 19613 8571 40 by by IN 19613 8571 41 which which WDT 19613 8571 42 the the DT 19613 8571 43 soul soul NN 19613 8571 44 clings cling VBZ 19613 8571 45 to to IN 19613 8571 46 the the DT 19613 8571 47 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8571 48 . . . 19613 8572 1 Thus thus RB 19613 8572 2 , , , 19613 8572 3 then then RB 19613 8572 4 , , , 19613 8572 5 no no DT 19613 8572 6 intermixture intermixture NN 19613 8572 7 has have VBZ 19613 8572 8 taken take VBN 19613 8572 9 place place NN 19613 8572 10 . . . 19613 8573 1 On on IN 19613 8573 2 the the DT 19613 8573 3 contrary contrary NN 19613 8573 4 the the DT 19613 8573 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8573 6 preserves preserve VBZ 19613 8573 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8573 8 impassibility impassibility NN 19613 8573 9 , , , 19613 8573 10 and and CC 19613 8573 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8573 12 is be VBZ 19613 8573 13 only only RB 19613 8573 14 the the DT 19613 8573 15 soul soul NN 19613 8573 16 that that WDT 19613 8573 17 hungers hunger NNS 19613 8573 18 and and CC 19613 8573 19 thirsts thirst NNS 19613 8573 20 , , , 19613 8573 21 struggles struggle NNS 19613 8573 22 and and CC 19613 8573 23 suffers suffer NNS 19613 8573 24 . . . 19613 8574 1 In in IN 19613 8574 2 this this DT 19613 8574 3 , , , 19613 8574 4 too too RB 19613 8574 5 , , , 19613 8574 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8574 7 appears appear VBZ 19613 8574 8 as as IN 19613 8574 9 a a DT 19613 8574 10 real real JJ 19613 8574 11 human human JJ 19613 8574 12 soul soul NN 19613 8574 13 , , , 19613 8574 14 and and CC 19613 8574 15 in in IN 19613 8574 16 the the DT 19613 8574 17 same same JJ 19613 8574 18 way way NN 19613 8574 19 the the DT 19613 8574 20 body body NN 19613 8574 21 is be VBZ 19613 8574 22 sinless sinless JJ 19613 8574 23 and and CC 19613 8574 24 unpolluted unpolluted JJ 19613 8574 25 , , , 19613 8574 26 as as IN 19613 8574 27 being be VBG 19613 8574 28 derived derive VBN 19613 8574 29 from from IN 19613 8574 30 a a DT 19613 8574 31 virgin virgin NN 19613 8574 32 ; ; : 19613 8574 33 but but CC 19613 8574 34 yet yet RB 19613 8574 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8574 36 is be VBZ 19613 8574 37 a a DT 19613 8574 38 human human JJ 19613 8574 39 one one NN 19613 8574 40 . . . 19613 8575 1 This this DT 19613 8575 2 humanity humanity NN 19613 8575 3 of of IN 19613 8575 4 the the DT 19613 8575 5 body body NN 19613 8575 6 , , , 19613 8575 7 however however RB 19613 8575 8 , , , 19613 8575 9 does do VBZ 19613 8575 10 not not RB 19613 8575 11 exclude exclude VB 19613 8575 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8575 13 capacity capacity NN 19613 8575 14 of of IN 19613 8575 15 assuming assume VBG 19613 8575 16 all all DT 19613 8575 17 possible possible JJ 19613 8575 18 qualities quality NNS 19613 8575 19 the the DT 19613 8575 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8575 21 wishes wish VBZ 19613 8575 22 to to TO 19613 8575 23 give give VB 19613 8575 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8575 25 ; ; : 19613 8575 26 for for IN 19613 8575 27 matter matter NN 19613 8575 28 of of IN 19613 8575 29 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8575 30 possesses possess VBZ 19613 8575 31 no no DT 19613 8575 32 qualities quality NNS 19613 8575 33 . . . 19613 8576 1 The the DT 19613 8576 2 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8576 3 was be VBD 19613 8576 4 able able JJ 19613 8576 5 at at IN 19613 8576 6 any any DT 19613 8576 7 moment moment NN 19613 8576 8 to to TO 19613 8576 9 give give VB 19613 8576 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8576 11 body body NN 19613 8576 12 the the DT 19613 8576 13 form form NN 19613 8576 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8576 15 required require VBD 19613 8576 16 , , , 19613 8576 17 in in IN 19613 8576 18 order order NN 19613 8576 19 to to TO 19613 8576 20 make make VB 19613 8576 21 the the DT 19613 8576 22 proper proper JJ 19613 8576 23 impression impression NN 19613 8576 24 on on IN 19613 8576 25 the the DT 19613 8576 26 various various JJ 19613 8576 27 sorts sort NNS 19613 8576 28 of of IN 19613 8576 29 men man NNS 19613 8576 30 . . . 19613 8577 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8577 2 , , , 19613 8577 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8577 4 was be VBD 19613 8577 5 not not RB 19613 8577 6 enclosed enclose VBN 19613 8577 7 in in IN 19613 8577 8 the the DT 19613 8577 9 soul soul NN 19613 8577 10 and and CC 19613 8577 11 body body NN 19613 8577 12 of of IN 19613 8577 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8577 14 ; ; : 19613 8577 15 on on IN 19613 8577 16 the the DT 19613 8577 17 contrary contrary NN 19613 8577 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8577 19 acted act VBD 19613 8577 20 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8577 21 as as IN 19613 8577 22 before before RB 19613 8577 23 and and CC 19613 8577 24 united unite VBD 19613 8577 25 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8577 26 , , , 19613 8577 27 as as RB 19613 8577 28 formerly formerly RB 19613 8577 29 , , , 19613 8577 30 with with IN 19613 8577 31 all all PDT 19613 8577 32 the the DT 19613 8577 33 souls soul NNS 19613 8577 34 that that WDT 19613 8577 35 opened open VBD 19613 8577 36 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8577 37 to to IN 19613 8577 38 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8577 39 . . . 19613 8578 1 But but CC 19613 8578 2 with with IN 19613 8578 3 none none NN 19613 8578 4 did do VBD 19613 8578 5 the the DT 19613 8578 6 union union NN 19613 8578 7 become become VBN 19613 8578 8 so so RB 19613 8578 9 close close JJ 19613 8578 10 as as IN 19613 8578 11 with with IN 19613 8578 12 the the DT 19613 8578 13 soul soul NN 19613 8578 14 , , , 19613 8578 15 and and CC 19613 8578 16 consequently consequently RB 19613 8578 17 also also RB 19613 8578 18 with with IN 19613 8578 19 the the DT 19613 8578 20 body body NN 19613 8578 21 of of IN 19613 8578 22 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8578 23 . . . 19613 8579 1 During during IN 19613 8579 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8579 3 earthly earthly JJ 19613 8579 4 life life NN 19613 8579 5 the the DT 19613 8579 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8579 7 glorified glorify VBD 19613 8579 8 and and CC 19613 8579 9 deified deify VBD 19613 8579 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8579 11 soul soul NN 19613 8579 12 by by IN 19613 8579 13 degrees degree NNS 19613 8579 14 and and CC 19613 8579 15 the the DT 19613 8579 16 latter latter JJ 19613 8579 17 acted act VBD 19613 8579 18 in in IN 19613 8579 19 the the DT 19613 8579 20 same same JJ 19613 8579 21 way way NN 19613 8579 22 on on IN 19613 8579 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8579 24 body body NN 19613 8579 25 . . . 19613 8580 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8580 2 contrived contrive VBD 19613 8580 3 to to TO 19613 8580 4 arrange arrange VB 19613 8580 5 the the DT 19613 8580 6 different different JJ 19613 8580 7 functions function NNS 19613 8580 8 and and CC 19613 8580 9 predicates predicate NNS 19613 8580 10 of of IN 19613 8580 11 the the DT 19613 8580 12 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 8580 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8580 14 in in IN 19613 8580 15 such such PDT 19613 8580 16 a a DT 19613 8580 17 way way NN 19613 8580 18 that that WDT 19613 8580 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8580 20 formed form VBD 19613 8580 21 a a DT 19613 8580 22 series series NN 19613 8580 23 of of IN 19613 8580 24 stages stage NNS 19613 8580 25 which which WDT 19613 8580 26 the the DT 19613 8580 27 believer believer NN 19613 8580 28 becomes become VBZ 19613 8580 29 successively successively RB 19613 8580 30 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 8580 31 with with IN 19613 8580 32 as as IN 19613 8580 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8580 34 advances advance VBZ 19613 8580 35 in in IN 19613 8580 36 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8580 37 . . . 19613 8581 1 But but CC 19613 8581 2 everything everything NN 19613 8581 3 is be VBZ 19613 8581 4 most most RBS 19613 8581 5 closely closely RB 19613 8581 6 united united JJ 19613 8581 7 together together RB 19613 8581 8 in in IN 19613 8581 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8581 10 . . . 19613 8582 1 This this DT 19613 8582 2 union union NN 19613 8582 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8582 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8582 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8582 6 : : : 19613 8582 7 koinônia koinônia NNP 19613 8582 8 enôsis enôsis NN 19613 8582 9 , , , 19613 8582 10 anakrasis anakrasis NN 19613 8582 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8582 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8582 13 was be VBD 19613 8582 14 so so RB 19613 8582 15 intimate intimate JJ 19613 8582 16 that that IN 19613 8582 17 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8582 18 Writ Writ NNP 19613 8582 19 has have VBZ 19613 8582 20 named name VBN 19613 8582 21 the the DT 19613 8582 22 created create VBN 19613 8582 23 man man NN 19613 8582 24 , , , 19613 8582 25 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8582 26 , , , 19613 8582 27 the the DT 19613 8582 28 Son Son NNP 19613 8582 29 of of IN 19613 8582 30 God God NNP 19613 8582 31 ; ; : 19613 8582 32 and and CC 19613 8582 33 on on IN 19613 8582 34 the the DT 19613 8582 35 other other JJ 19613 8582 36 hand hand NN 19613 8582 37 has have VBZ 19613 8582 38 called call VBN 19613 8582 39 the the DT 19613 8582 40 Son Son NNP 19613 8582 41 of of IN 19613 8582 42 God God NNP 19613 8582 43 the the DT 19613 8582 44 Son Son NNP 19613 8582 45 of of IN 19613 8582 46 Man Man NNP 19613 8582 47 . . . 19613 8583 1 After after IN 19613 8583 2 the the DT 19613 8583 3 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 8583 4 and and CC 19613 8583 5 ascension ascension NN 19613 8583 6 the the DT 19613 8583 7 whole whole JJ 19613 8583 8 man man NN 19613 8583 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8583 10 appears appear VBZ 19613 8583 11 transformed transform VBN 19613 8583 12 into into IN 19613 8583 13 a a DT 19613 8583 14 spirit spirit NN 19613 8583 15 , , , 19613 8583 16 is be VBZ 19613 8583 17 completely completely RB 19613 8583 18 received receive VBN 19613 8583 19 into into IN 19613 8583 20 the the DT 19613 8583 21 Godhead Godhead NNP 19613 8583 22 , , , 19613 8583 23 and and CC 19613 8583 24 is be VBZ 19613 8583 25 thus thus RB 19613 8583 26 identical identical JJ 19613 8583 27 with with IN 19613 8583 28 the the DT 19613 8583 29 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8583 30 . . . 19613 8584 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8584 2 793 793 CD 19613 8584 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8584 4 In in IN 19613 8584 5 this this DT 19613 8584 6 conception conception NN 19613 8584 7 one one CD 19613 8584 8 may may MD 19613 8584 9 be be VB 19613 8584 10 tempted tempt VBN 19613 8584 11 to to TO 19613 8584 12 point point VB 19613 8584 13 out out RP 19613 8584 14 all all DT 19613 8584 15 possible possible JJ 19613 8584 16 " " `` 19613 8584 17 heresies":--the heresies":--the NN 19613 8584 18 conception conception NN 19613 8584 19 of of IN 19613 8584 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8584 21 as as IN 19613 8584 22 a a DT 19613 8584 23 heavenly heavenly JJ 19613 8584 24 man man NN 19613 8584 25 -- -- : 19613 8584 26 but but CC 19613 8584 27 all all DT 19613 8584 28 men man NNS 19613 8584 29 are be VBP 19613 8584 30 heavenly;--the heavenly;--the NN 19613 8584 31 Adoptianist adoptianist JJ 19613 8584 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8584 33 " " `` 19613 8584 34 Ebionite Ebionite NNP 19613 8584 35 " " '' 19613 8584 36 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8584 37 Christology christology NN 19613 8584 38 -- -- : 19613 8584 39 but but CC 19613 8584 40 the the DT 19613 8584 41 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8584 42 as as IN 19613 8584 43 a a DT 19613 8584 44 person person NN 19613 8584 45 stands stand VBZ 19613 8584 46 behind behind IN 19613 8584 47 it;--the it;--the DT 19613 8584 48 conception conception NN 19613 8584 49 of of IN 19613 8584 50 two two CD 19613 8584 51 Logoi Logoi NNP 19613 8584 52 , , , 19613 8584 53 a a DT 19613 8584 54 personal personal JJ 19613 8584 55 and and CC 19613 8584 56 an an DT 19613 8584 57 impersonal impersonal JJ 19613 8584 58 ; ; : 19613 8584 59 the the DT 19613 8584 60 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8584 61 separation separation NN 19613 8584 62 of of IN 19613 8584 63 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8584 64 and and CC 19613 8584 65 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8584 66 ; ; : 19613 8584 67 and and CC 19613 8584 68 Docetism docetism NN 19613 8584 69 . . . 19613 8585 1 As as IN 19613 8585 2 a a DT 19613 8585 3 matter matter NN 19613 8585 4 of of IN 19613 8585 5 fact fact NN 19613 8585 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8585 7 united unite VBD 19613 8585 8 all all PDT 19613 8585 9 these these DT 19613 8585 10 ideas idea NNS 19613 8585 11 , , , 19613 8585 12 but but CC 19613 8585 13 modified modify VBD 19613 8585 14 the the DT 19613 8585 15 whole whole NN 19613 8585 16 of of IN 19613 8585 17 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8585 18 in in IN 19613 8585 19 such such PDT 19613 8585 20 a a DT 19613 8585 21 way way NN 19613 8585 22 that that WDT 19613 8585 23 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8585 24 no no RB 19613 8585 25 longer longer RB 19613 8585 26 seem seem VBP 19613 8585 27 , , , 19613 8585 28 and and CC 19613 8585 29 to to IN 19613 8585 30 some some DT 19613 8585 31 extent extent NN 19613 8585 32 are be VBP 19613 8585 33 not not RB 19613 8585 34 , , , 19613 8585 35 what what WP 19613 8585 36 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8585 37 turn turn VBP 19613 8585 38 out out RP 19613 8585 39 to to TO 19613 8585 40 be be VB 19613 8585 41 when when WRB 19613 8585 42 subjected subject VBN 19613 8585 43 to to IN 19613 8585 44 the the DT 19613 8585 45 slightest slight JJS 19613 8585 46 logical logical JJ 19613 8585 47 analysis analysis NN 19613 8585 48 . . . 19613 8586 1 This this DT 19613 8586 2 structure structure NN 19613 8586 3 is be VBZ 19613 8586 4 so so RB 19613 8586 5 constituted constituted JJ 19613 8586 6 that that IN 19613 8586 7 not not RB 19613 8586 8 a a DT 19613 8586 9 stone stone NN 19613 8586 10 of of IN 19613 8586 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8586 12 admits admit VBZ 19613 8586 13 of of IN 19613 8586 14 being be VBG 19613 8586 15 a a DT 19613 8586 16 hair's hair's JJ 19613 8586 17 - - HYPH 19613 8586 18 breadth breadth NN 19613 8586 19 broader broader RBR 19613 8586 20 or or CC 19613 8586 21 narrower narrow JJR 19613 8586 22 . . . 19613 8587 1 There there EX 19613 8587 2 is be VBZ 19613 8587 3 only only RB 19613 8587 4 one one CD 19613 8587 5 conception conception NN 19613 8587 6 that that WDT 19613 8587 7 has have VBZ 19613 8587 8 been be VBN 19613 8587 9 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 8587 10 unemployed unemployed JJ 19613 8587 11 by by IN 19613 8587 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8587 13 , , , 19613 8587 14 that that RB 19613 8587 15 is is RB 19613 8587 16 , , , 19613 8587 17 the the DT 19613 8587 18 modalistic modalistic JJ 19613 8587 19 view view NN 19613 8587 20 . . . 19613 8588 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8588 2 is be VBZ 19613 8588 3 the the DT 19613 8588 4 great great JJ 19613 8588 5 opponent opponent NN 19613 8588 6 of of IN 19613 8588 7 Sabellianism Sabellianism NNP 19613 8588 8 , , , 19613 8588 9 a a DT 19613 8588 10 theory theory NN 19613 8588 11 which which WDT 19613 8588 12 in in IN 19613 8588 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8588 14 simplicity simplicity NN 19613 8588 15 frequently frequently RB 19613 8588 16 elicited elicit VBD 19613 8588 17 from from IN 19613 8588 18 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8588 19 words word NNS 19613 8588 20 of of IN 19613 8588 21 pity pity NN 19613 8588 22 ; ; : 19613 8588 23 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 8588 24 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8588 25 made make VBD 19613 8588 26 use use NN 19613 8588 27 of of IN 19613 8588 28 all all PDT 19613 8588 29 the the DT 19613 8588 30 ideas idea NNS 19613 8588 31 about about IN 19613 8588 32 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8588 33 that that WDT 19613 8588 34 had have VBD 19613 8588 35 been be VBN 19613 8588 36 formed form VBN 19613 8588 37 in in IN 19613 8588 38 the the DT 19613 8588 39 course course NN 19613 8588 40 of of IN 19613 8588 41 two two CD 19613 8588 42 hundred hundred CD 19613 8588 43 years year NNS 19613 8588 44 . . . 19613 8589 1 This this DT 19613 8589 2 becomes become VBZ 19613 8589 3 more more JJR 19613 8589 4 and and CC 19613 8589 5 more more RBR 19613 8589 6 manifest manifest JJ 19613 8589 7 the the DT 19613 8589 8 more more RBR 19613 8589 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8589 10 penetrate penetrate VBP 19613 8589 11 into into IN 19613 8589 12 the the DT 19613 8589 13 details detail NNS 19613 8589 14 of of IN 19613 8589 15 this this DT 19613 8589 16 Christology Christology NNP 19613 8589 17 . . . 19613 8590 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8590 2 can can MD 19613 8590 3 not not RB 19613 8590 4 , , , 19613 8590 5 however however RB 19613 8590 6 , , , 19613 8590 7 attribute attribute VB 19613 8590 8 to to IN 19613 8590 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8590 10 a a DT 19613 8590 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8590 12 of of IN 19613 8590 13 two two CD 19613 8590 14 natures nature NNS 19613 8590 15 , , , 19613 8590 16 but but CC 19613 8590 17 rather rather RB 19613 8590 18 the the DT 19613 8590 19 notion notion NN 19613 8590 20 of of IN 19613 8590 21 two two CD 19613 8590 22 subjects subject NNS 19613 8590 23 that that WDT 19613 8590 24 become become VBP 19613 8590 25 gradually gradually RB 19613 8590 26 amalgamated amalgamate VBN 19613 8590 27 with with IN 19613 8590 28 each each DT 19613 8590 29 other other JJ 19613 8590 30 , , , 19613 8590 31 although although IN 19613 8590 32 the the DT 19613 8590 33 expression expression NN 19613 8590 34 " " `` 19613 8590 35 two two CD 19613 8590 36 natures nature NNS 19613 8590 37 " " '' 19613 8590 38 is be VBZ 19613 8590 39 not not RB 19613 8590 40 quite quite RB 19613 8590 41 foreign foreign JJ 19613 8590 42 to to IN 19613 8590 43 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8590 44 . . . 19613 8591 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8591 2 794 794 CD 19613 8591 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8591 4 The the DT 19613 8591 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8591 6 retains retain VBZ 19613 8591 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8591 8 human human JJ 19613 8591 9 nature nature NN 19613 8591 10 eternally,[795 eternally,[795 NNS 19613 8591 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8591 12 but but CC 19613 8591 13 only only RB 19613 8591 14 in in IN 19613 8591 15 the the DT 19613 8591 16 same same JJ 19613 8591 17 sense sense NN 19613 8591 18 in in IN 19613 8591 19 which which WDT 19613 8591 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8591 21 preserve preserve VBP 19613 8591 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8591 23 nature nature NN 19613 8591 24 after after IN 19613 8591 25 the the DT 19613 8591 26 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 8591 27 . . . 19613 8592 1 The the DT 19613 8592 2 significance significance NN 19613 8592 3 which which WDT 19613 8592 4 this this DT 19613 8592 5 Christological christological JJ 19613 8592 6 attempt attempt NN 19613 8592 7 possessed possess VBN 19613 8592 8 for for IN 19613 8592 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8592 10 time time NN 19613 8592 11 consists consist VBZ 19613 8592 12 first first RB 19613 8592 13 in in IN 19613 8592 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8592 15 complexity complexity NN 19613 8592 16 , , , 19613 8592 17 secondly secondly RB 19613 8592 18 in in IN 19613 8592 19 the the DT 19613 8592 20 energetic energetic JJ 19613 8592 21 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 8592 22 to to TO 19613 8592 23 give give VB 19613 8592 24 an an DT 19613 8592 25 adequate adequate JJ 19613 8592 26 conception conception NN 19613 8592 27 of of IN 19613 8592 28 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8592 29 's 's POS 19613 8592 30 _ _ NNP 19613 8592 31 humanity humanity NN 19613 8592 32 _ _ NNP 19613 8592 33 , , , 19613 8592 34 that that RB 19613 8592 35 is is RB 19613 8592 36 , , , 19613 8592 37 of of IN 19613 8592 38 the the DT 19613 8592 39 moral moral JJ 19613 8592 40 freedom freedom NN 19613 8592 41 pertaining pertain VBG 19613 8592 42 to to IN 19613 8592 43 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8592 44 as as IN 19613 8592 45 a a DT 19613 8592 46 creature creature NN 19613 8592 47 . . . 19613 8593 1 This this DT 19613 8593 2 effort effort NN 19613 8593 3 was be VBD 19613 8593 4 indeed indeed RB 19613 8593 5 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8593 6 to to TO 19613 8593 7 content content VB 19613 8593 8 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8593 9 with with IN 19613 8593 10 a a DT 19613 8593 11 meagre meagre JJ 19613 8593 12 result result NN 19613 8593 13 : : : 19613 8593 14 but but CC 19613 8593 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8593 16 are be VBP 19613 8593 17 only only RB 19613 8593 18 justified justify VBN 19613 8593 19 in in IN 19613 8593 20 measuring measure VBG 19613 8593 21 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8593 22 's 's POS 19613 8593 23 Christology Christology NNP 19613 8593 24 by by IN 19613 8593 25 that that DT 19613 8593 26 of of IN 19613 8593 27 the the DT 19613 8593 28 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 8593 29 and and CC 19613 8593 30 Basilidians Basilidians NNPS 19613 8593 31 , , , 19613 8593 32 that that RB 19613 8593 33 is is RB 19613 8593 34 , , , 19613 8593 35 by by IN 19613 8593 36 the the DT 19613 8593 37 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8593 38 one one NN 19613 8593 39 that that WDT 19613 8593 40 had have VBD 19613 8593 41 preceded precede VBN 19613 8593 42 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8593 43 . . . 19613 8594 1 The the DT 19613 8594 2 most most RBS 19613 8594 3 important important JJ 19613 8594 4 advance advance NN 19613 8594 5 lies lie VBZ 19613 8594 6 in in IN 19613 8594 7 the the DT 19613 8594 8 fact fact NN 19613 8594 9 that that IN 19613 8594 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8594 11 set set VBD 19613 8594 12 forth forth RP 19613 8594 13 a a DT 19613 8594 14 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8594 15 Christology christology NN 19613 8594 16 in in IN 19613 8594 17 which which WDT 19613 8594 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8594 19 was be VBD 19613 8594 20 able able JJ 19613 8594 21 to to TO 19613 8594 22 find find VB 19613 8594 23 so so RB 19613 8594 24 much much JJ 19613 8594 25 scope scope NN 19613 8594 26 for for IN 19613 8594 27 the the DT 19613 8594 28 humanity humanity NN 19613 8594 29 of of IN 19613 8594 30 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8594 31 . . . 19613 8595 1 Whilst whilst IN 19613 8595 2 within within IN 19613 8595 3 the the DT 19613 8595 4 framework framework NN 19613 8595 5 of of IN 19613 8595 6 the the DT 19613 8595 7 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8595 8 Christologies Christologies NNPS 19613 8595 9 this this DT 19613 8595 10 humanity humanity NN 19613 8595 11 had have VBD 19613 8595 12 hitherto hitherto VBN 19613 8595 13 been be VBN 19613 8595 14 conceived conceive VBN 19613 8595 15 as as IN 19613 8595 16 something something NN 19613 8595 17 indifferent indifferent JJ 19613 8595 18 or or CC 19613 8595 19 merely merely RB 19613 8595 20 apparent apparent JJ 19613 8595 21 , , , 19613 8595 22 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8595 23 made make VBD 19613 8595 24 the the DT 19613 8595 25 first first JJ 19613 8595 26 attempt attempt NN 19613 8595 27 to to TO 19613 8595 28 incorporate incorporate VB 19613 8595 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8595 30 with with IN 19613 8595 31 the the DT 19613 8595 32 various various JJ 19613 8595 33 speculations speculation NNS 19613 8595 34 without without IN 19613 8595 35 prejudice prejudice NN 19613 8595 36 to to IN 19613 8595 37 the the DT 19613 8595 38 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8595 39 , , , 19613 8595 40 God God NNP 19613 8595 41 in in IN 19613 8595 42 nature nature NN 19613 8595 43 and and CC 19613 8595 44 person person NN 19613 8595 45 . . . 19613 8596 1 No no DT 19613 8596 2 Greek greek JJ 19613 8596 3 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 8596 4 probably probably RB 19613 8596 5 heeded heed VBD 19613 8596 6 what what WP 19613 8596 7 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8596 8 set set VBD 19613 8596 9 forth forth RB 19613 8596 10 respecting respect VBG 19613 8596 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8596 12 as as IN 19613 8596 13 the the DT 19613 8596 14 second second JJ 19613 8596 15 Adam Adam NNP 19613 8596 16 , , , 19613 8596 17 the the DT 19613 8596 18 _ _ NNP 19613 8596 19 recapitulatur recapitulatur NNP 19613 8596 20 generis generis NNP 19613 8596 21 humani humani NNP 19613 8596 22 _ _ NNP 19613 8596 23 ; ; : 19613 8596 24 whereas whereas IN 19613 8596 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8596 26 's 's POS 19613 8596 27 speculation speculation NN 19613 8596 28 could could MD 19613 8596 29 not not RB 19613 8596 30 be be VB 19613 8596 31 overlooked overlook VBN 19613 8596 32 . . . 19613 8597 1 In in IN 19613 8597 2 this this DT 19613 8597 3 case case NN 19613 8597 4 the the DT 19613 8597 5 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8597 6 really really RB 19613 8597 7 adopted adopt VBD 19613 8597 8 the the DT 19613 8597 9 idea idea NN 19613 8597 10 of of IN 19613 8597 11 the the DT 19613 8597 12 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 8597 13 , , , 19613 8597 14 and and CC 19613 8597 15 at at IN 19613 8597 16 the the DT 19613 8597 17 same same JJ 19613 8597 18 time time NN 19613 8597 19 tried try VBD 19613 8597 20 to to TO 19613 8597 21 demonstrate demonstrate VB 19613 8597 22 the the DT 19613 8597 23 conception conception NN 19613 8597 24 of of IN 19613 8597 25 the the DT 19613 8597 26 God God NNP 19613 8597 27 - - HYPH 19613 8597 28 man man NN 19613 8597 29 from from IN 19613 8597 30 the the DT 19613 8597 31 notions notion NNS 19613 8597 32 of of IN 19613 8597 33 unity unity NN 19613 8597 34 of of IN 19613 8597 35 will will NN 19613 8597 36 and and CC 19613 8597 37 love love VB 19613 8597 38 . . . 19613 8598 1 In in IN 19613 8598 2 the the DT 19613 8598 3 treatise treatise NN 19613 8598 4 against against IN 19613 8598 5 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8598 6 , , , 19613 8598 7 moreover moreover RB 19613 8598 8 , , , 19613 8598 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8598 10 went go VBD 19613 8598 11 the the DT 19613 8598 12 reverse reverse JJ 19613 8598 13 way way NN 19613 8598 14 to to IN 19613 8598 15 work work VB 19613 8598 16 and and CC 19613 8598 17 undertook undertake VBD 19613 8598 18 to to TO 19613 8598 19 show show VB 19613 8598 20 , , , 19613 8598 21 and and CC 19613 8598 22 this this DT 19613 8598 23 not not RB 19613 8598 24 merely merely RB 19613 8598 25 by by IN 19613 8598 26 help help NN 19613 8598 27 of of IN 19613 8598 28 the the DT 19613 8598 29 proof proof NN 19613 8598 30 from from IN 19613 8598 31 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 8598 32 , , , 19613 8598 33 that that IN 19613 8598 34 the the DT 19613 8598 35 predicate predicate NN 19613 8598 36 deity deity NN 19613 8598 37 applied apply VBD 19613 8598 38 to to IN 19613 8598 39 the the DT 19613 8598 40 historical historical JJ 19613 8598 41 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8598 42 . . . 19613 8599 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8599 2 796 796 CD 19613 8599 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8599 4 But but CC 19613 8599 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8599 6 's 's POS 19613 8599 7 conception conception NN 19613 8599 8 of of IN 19613 8599 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8599 10 's 's POS 19613 8599 11 person person NN 19613 8599 12 as as IN 19613 8599 13 a a DT 19613 8599 14 model model NN 19613 8599 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8599 16 for for IN 19613 8599 17 the the DT 19613 8599 18 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8599 19 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8599 20 and and CC 19613 8599 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8599 22 repudiation repudiation NN 19613 8599 23 of of IN 19613 8599 24 all all DT 19613 8599 25 magical magical JJ 19613 8599 26 theories theory NNS 19613 8599 27 of of IN 19613 8599 28 redemption redemption NN 19613 8599 29 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 8599 30 explain explain VBP 19613 8599 31 why why WRB 19613 8599 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8599 33 did do VBD 19613 8599 34 not not RB 19613 8599 35 , , , 19613 8599 36 like like IN 19613 8599 37 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8599 38 , , , 19613 8599 39 set set VBD 19613 8599 40 forth forth RP 19613 8599 41 a a DT 19613 8599 42 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8599 43 of of IN 19613 8599 44 two two CD 19613 8599 45 natures nature NNS 19613 8599 46 , , , 19613 8599 47 but but CC 19613 8599 48 sought seek VBD 19613 8599 49 to to TO 19613 8599 50 show show VB 19613 8599 51 that that IN 19613 8599 52 in in IN 19613 8599 53 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8599 54 's 's POS 19613 8599 55 case case NN 19613 8599 56 a a DT 19613 8599 57 human human JJ 19613 8599 58 subject subject NN 19613 8599 59 with with IN 19613 8599 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8599 61 will will NN 19613 8599 62 and and CC 19613 8599 63 feelings feeling NNS 19613 8599 64 became become VBD 19613 8599 65 completely completely RB 19613 8599 66 merged merge VBN 19613 8599 67 in in IN 19613 8599 68 the the DT 19613 8599 69 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8599 70 . . . 19613 8600 1 No no RB 19613 8600 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 8600 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8600 4 can can MD 19613 8600 5 say say VB 19613 8600 6 that that IN 19613 8600 7 the the DT 19613 8600 8 union union NN 19613 8600 9 of of IN 19613 8600 10 the the DT 19613 8600 11 divine divine JJ 19613 8600 12 and and CC 19613 8600 13 human human JJ 19613 8600 14 natures nature NNS 19613 8600 15 had have VBD 19613 8600 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8600 17 beginning beginning NN 19613 8600 18 in in IN 19613 8600 19 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8600 20 , , , 19613 8600 21 but but CC 19613 8600 22 here here RB 19613 8600 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8600 24 virtually virtually RB 19613 8600 25 means mean VBZ 19613 8600 26 that that IN 19613 8600 27 this this DT 19613 8600 28 beginning beginning NN 19613 8600 29 is be VBZ 19613 8600 30 continued continue VBN 19613 8600 31 in in IN 19613 8600 32 the the DT 19613 8600 33 sense sense NN 19613 8600 34 of of IN 19613 8600 35 souls soul NNS 19613 8600 36 imitating imitate VBG 19613 8600 37 the the DT 19613 8600 38 example example NN 19613 8600 39 of of IN 19613 8600 40 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8600 41 . . . 19613 8601 1 What what WP 19613 8601 2 is be VBZ 19613 8601 3 called call VBN 19613 8601 4 the the DT 19613 8601 5 real real JJ 19613 8601 6 redemption redemption NN 19613 8601 7 supposed suppose VBN 19613 8601 8 to to TO 19613 8601 9 be be VB 19613 8601 10 given give VBN 19613 8601 11 in in IN 19613 8601 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8601 13 is be VBZ 19613 8601 14 certainly certainly RB 19613 8601 15 mediated mediate VBN 19613 8601 16 in in IN 19613 8601 17 the the DT 19613 8601 18 Psychic Psychic NNP 19613 8601 19 through through IN 19613 8601 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8601 21 _ _ NNP 19613 8601 22 work work NN 19613 8601 23 _ _ NNP 19613 8601 24 , , , 19613 8601 25 but but CC 19613 8601 26 the the DT 19613 8601 27 _ _ NNP 19613 8601 28 person person NN 19613 8601 29 _ _ XX 19613 8601 30 of of IN 19613 8601 31 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8601 32 which which WDT 19613 8601 33 can can MD 19613 8601 34 not not RB 19613 8601 35 be be VB 19613 8601 36 known know VBN 19613 8601 37 to to IN 19613 8601 38 any any DT 19613 8601 39 but but IN 19613 8601 40 the the DT 19613 8601 41 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8601 42 man man NN 19613 8601 43 is be VBZ 19613 8601 44 by by IN 19613 8601 45 no no DT 19613 8601 46 means means NN 19613 8601 47 identified identify VBN 19613 8601 48 with with IN 19613 8601 49 that that DT 19613 8601 50 real real JJ 19613 8601 51 redemption redemption NN 19613 8601 52 , , , 19613 8601 53 but but CC 19613 8601 54 appears appear VBZ 19613 8601 55 as as IN 19613 8601 56 a a DT 19613 8601 57 free free JJ 19613 8601 58 moral moral JJ 19613 8601 59 personality personality NN 19613 8601 60 , , , 19613 8601 61 inwardly inwardly RB 19613 8601 62 blended blend VBN 19613 8601 63 with with IN 19613 8601 64 the the DT 19613 8601 65 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8601 66 , , , 19613 8601 67 a a DT 19613 8601 68 personality personality NN 19613 8601 69 which which WDT 19613 8601 70 can can MD 19613 8601 71 not not RB 19613 8601 72 mechanically mechanically RB 19613 8601 73 transfer transfer VB 19613 8601 74 the the DT 19613 8601 75 content content NN 19613 8601 76 of of IN 19613 8601 77 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8601 78 essence essence NN 19613 8601 79 , , , 19613 8601 80 though though IN 19613 8601 81 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8601 82 can can MD 19613 8601 83 indeed indeed RB 19613 8601 84 exercise exercise VB 19613 8601 85 the the DT 19613 8601 86 strongest strong JJS 19613 8601 87 impression impression NN 19613 8601 88 on on IN 19613 8601 89 mind mind NN 19613 8601 90 and and CC 19613 8601 91 heart heart NN 19613 8601 92 . . . 19613 8602 1 To to IN 19613 8602 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8602 3 the the DT 19613 8602 4 highest high JJS 19613 8602 5 value value NN 19613 8602 6 of of IN 19613 8602 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8602 8 's 's POS 19613 8602 9 person person NN 19613 8602 10 lies lie VBZ 19613 8602 11 in in IN 19613 8602 12 the the DT 19613 8602 13 fact fact NN 19613 8602 14 that that IN 19613 8602 15 the the DT 19613 8602 16 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8602 17 has have VBZ 19613 8602 18 here here RB 19613 8602 19 condescended condescend VBN 19613 8602 20 to to TO 19613 8602 21 reveal reveal VB 19613 8602 22 to to IN 19613 8602 23 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8602 24 the the DT 19613 8602 25 whole whole JJ 19613 8602 26 fulness fulness NN 19613 8602 27 of of IN 19613 8602 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8602 29 essence essence NN 19613 8602 30 , , , 19613 8602 31 in in IN 19613 8602 32 the the DT 19613 8602 33 person person NN 19613 8602 34 of of IN 19613 8602 35 a a DT 19613 8602 36 man man NN 19613 8602 37 , , , 19613 8602 38 as as RB 19613 8602 39 well well RB 19613 8602 40 as as IN 19613 8602 41 in in IN 19613 8602 42 the the DT 19613 8602 43 fact fact NN 19613 8602 44 that that IN 19613 8602 45 a a DT 19613 8602 46 man man NN 19613 8602 47 is be VBZ 19613 8602 48 given give VBN 19613 8602 49 to to IN 19613 8602 50 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8602 51 who who WP 19613 8602 52 shows show VBZ 19613 8602 53 that that IN 19613 8602 54 the the DT 19613 8602 55 human human JJ 19613 8602 56 spirit spirit NN 19613 8602 57 is be VBZ 19613 8602 58 capable capable JJ 19613 8602 59 of of IN 19613 8602 60 becoming become VBG 19613 8602 61 entirely entirely RB 19613 8602 62 God God NNP 19613 8602 63 's 's POS 19613 8602 64 . . . 19613 8603 1 At at IN 19613 8603 2 bottom bottom NN 19613 8603 3 there there EX 19613 8603 4 is be VBZ 19613 8603 5 nothing nothing NN 19613 8603 6 obscure obscure JJ 19613 8603 7 and and CC 19613 8603 8 mystical mystical JJ 19613 8603 9 here here RB 19613 8603 10 ; ; : 19613 8603 11 the the DT 19613 8603 12 whole whole JJ 19613 8603 13 process process NN 19613 8603 14 takes take VBZ 19613 8603 15 place place NN 19613 8603 16 in in IN 19613 8603 17 the the DT 19613 8603 18 will will NN 19613 8603 19 and and CC 19613 8603 20 in in IN 19613 8603 21 the the DT 19613 8603 22 feelings feeling NNS 19613 8603 23 through through IN 19613 8603 24 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8603 25 . . . 19613 8604 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8604 2 797 797 CD 19613 8604 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8604 4 This this DT 19613 8604 5 is be VBZ 19613 8604 6 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8604 7 to to TO 19613 8604 8 settle settle VB 19613 8604 9 the the DT 19613 8604 10 nature nature NN 19613 8604 11 of of IN 19613 8604 12 what what WP 19613 8604 13 is be VBZ 19613 8604 14 called call VBN 19613 8604 15 personal personal JJ 19613 8604 16 attainment attainment NN 19613 8604 17 of of IN 19613 8604 18 salvation salvation NN 19613 8604 19 . . . 19613 8605 1 Freedom freedom NN 19613 8605 2 precedes precede NNS 19613 8605 3 and and CC 19613 8605 4 supporting support VBG 19613 8605 5 grace grace NN 19613 8605 6 follows follow VBZ 19613 8605 7 . . . 19613 8606 1 As as IN 19613 8606 2 in in IN 19613 8606 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8606 4 's 's POS 19613 8606 5 case case NN 19613 8606 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8606 7 human human JJ 19613 8606 8 soul soul NN 19613 8606 9 gradually gradually RB 19613 8606 10 united unite VBD 19613 8606 11 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8606 12 with with IN 19613 8606 13 the the DT 19613 8606 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8606 15 in in IN 19613 8606 16 proportion proportion NN 19613 8606 17 as as IN 19613 8606 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8606 19 voluntarily voluntarily RB 19613 8606 20 subjected subject VBD 19613 8606 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8606 22 will will NN 19613 8606 23 to to IN 19613 8606 24 God God NNP 19613 8606 25 , , , 19613 8606 26 so so RB 19613 8606 27 also also RB 19613 8606 28 every every DT 19613 8606 29 man man NN 19613 8606 30 receives receive VBZ 19613 8606 31 grace grace NN 19613 8606 32 according accord VBG 19613 8606 33 to to IN 19613 8606 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8606 35 progress progress NN 19613 8606 36 . . . 19613 8607 1 Though though IN 19613 8607 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8607 3 and and CC 19613 8607 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8607 5 did do VBD 19613 8607 6 not not RB 19613 8607 7 yet yet RB 19613 8607 8 recommend recommend VB 19613 8607 9 actual actual JJ 19613 8607 10 exercises exercise NNS 19613 8607 11 according accord VBG 19613 8607 12 to to IN 19613 8607 13 definite definite JJ 19613 8607 14 rules rule NNS 19613 8607 15 , , , 19613 8607 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8607 17 description description NN 19613 8607 18 of of IN 19613 8607 19 the the DT 19613 8607 20 gradations gradation NNS 19613 8607 21 by by IN 19613 8607 22 which which WDT 19613 8607 23 the the DT 19613 8607 24 soul soul NN 19613 8607 25 rises rise VBZ 19613 8607 26 to to IN 19613 8607 27 God God NNP 19613 8607 28 already already RB 19613 8607 29 resembles resemble VBZ 19613 8607 30 that that DT 19613 8607 31 of of IN 19613 8607 32 the the DT 19613 8607 33 Neoplatonists Neoplatonists NNPS 19613 8607 34 , , , 19613 8607 35 except except IN 19613 8607 36 that that IN 19613 8607 37 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8607 38 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 8607 39 begin begin VBP 19613 8607 40 with with IN 19613 8607 41 faith faith NN 19613 8607 42 as as IN 19613 8607 43 the the DT 19613 8607 44 first first JJ 19613 8607 45 stage stage NN 19613 8607 46 . . . 19613 8608 1 Faith faith NN 19613 8608 2 is be VBZ 19613 8608 3 the the DT 19613 8608 4 first first JJ 19613 8608 5 step step NN 19613 8608 6 and and CC 19613 8608 7 is be VBZ 19613 8608 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8608 9 own own JJ 19613 8608 10 work work NN 19613 8608 11 . . . 19613 8609 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8609 2 798 798 CD 19613 8609 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8609 4 Then then RB 19613 8609 5 follows follow VBZ 19613 8609 6 the the DT 19613 8609 7 religious religious JJ 19613 8609 8 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 8609 9 of of IN 19613 8609 10 visible visible JJ 19613 8609 11 things thing NNS 19613 8609 12 , , , 19613 8609 13 and and CC 19613 8609 14 from from IN 19613 8609 15 this this DT 19613 8609 16 the the DT 19613 8609 17 soul soul NN 19613 8609 18 advances advance VBZ 19613 8609 19 , , , 19613 8609 20 as as IN 19613 8609 21 on on IN 19613 8609 22 the the DT 19613 8609 23 steps step NNS 19613 8609 24 of of IN 19613 8609 25 a a DT 19613 8609 26 ladder ladder NN 19613 8609 27 , , , 19613 8609 28 to to IN 19613 8609 29 the the DT 19613 8609 30 contemplation contemplation NN 19613 8609 31 of of IN 19613 8609 32 the the DT 19613 8609 33 _ _ NNP 19613 8609 34 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 8609 35 rationabiles rationabile NNS 19613 8609 36 _ _ NNP 19613 8609 37 , , , 19613 8609 38 the the DT 19613 8609 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8609 40 , , , 19613 8609 41 the the DT 19613 8609 42 knowable knowable JJ 19613 8609 43 essence essence NN 19613 8609 44 of of IN 19613 8609 45 God God NNP 19613 8609 46 , , , 19613 8609 47 and and CC 19613 8609 48 the the DT 19613 8609 49 whole whole JJ 19613 8609 50 fulness fulness NN 19613 8609 51 of of IN 19613 8609 52 the the DT 19613 8609 53 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8609 54 . . . 19613 8610 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8610 2 799 799 CD 19613 8610 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8610 4 She -PRON- PRP 19613 8610 5 retraces retrace VBZ 19613 8610 6 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8610 7 steps step NNS 19613 8610 8 upwards upwards RB 19613 8610 9 along along IN 19613 8610 10 the the DT 19613 8610 11 path path NN 19613 8610 12 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8610 13 formerly formerly RB 19613 8610 14 passed pass VBD 19613 8610 15 over over RP 19613 8610 16 as as IN 19613 8610 17 a a DT 19613 8610 18 fallen fall VBN 19613 8610 19 spirit spirit NN 19613 8610 20 . . . 19613 8611 1 But but CC 19613 8611 2 , , , 19613 8611 3 when when WRB 19613 8611 4 left leave VBD 19613 8611 5 to to IN 19613 8611 6 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8611 7 own own JJ 19613 8611 8 resources resource NNS 19613 8611 9 , , , 19613 8611 10 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8611 11 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 8611 12 is be VBZ 19613 8611 13 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8611 14 weak weak JJ 19613 8611 15 and and CC 19613 8611 16 powerless powerless JJ 19613 8611 17 ; ; : 19613 8611 18 she -PRON- PRP 19613 8611 19 requires require VBZ 19613 8611 20 at at IN 19613 8611 21 every every DT 19613 8611 22 stage stage NN 19613 8611 23 the the DT 19613 8611 24 divine divine JJ 19613 8611 25 grace grace NN 19613 8611 26 , , , 19613 8611 27 that that RB 19613 8611 28 is is RB 19613 8611 29 , , , 19613 8611 30 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 8611 31 . . . 19613 8612 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8612 2 800 800 CD 19613 8612 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8612 4 Thus thus RB 19613 8612 5 a a DT 19613 8612 6 union union NN 19613 8612 7 of of IN 19613 8612 8 grace grace NN 19613 8612 9 and and CC 19613 8612 10 freedom freedom NN 19613 8612 11 takes take VBZ 19613 8612 12 place place NN 19613 8612 13 within within IN 19613 8612 14 the the DT 19613 8612 15 sphere sphere NN 19613 8612 16 of of IN 19613 8612 17 the the DT 19613 8612 18 latter latter JJ 19613 8612 19 , , , 19613 8612 20 till till IN 19613 8612 21 the the DT 19613 8612 22 " " `` 19613 8612 23 contemplative contemplative JJ 19613 8612 24 life life NN 19613 8612 25 " " '' 19613 8612 26 is be VBZ 19613 8612 27 reached reach VBN 19613 8612 28 , , , 19613 8612 29 that that DT 19613 8612 30 joyous joyous JJ 19613 8612 31 ascetic ascetic JJ 19613 8612 32 contemplativeness contemplativeness NN 19613 8612 33 , , , 19613 8612 34 in in IN 19613 8612 35 which which WDT 19613 8612 36 the the DT 19613 8612 37 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8612 38 is be VBZ 19613 8612 39 the the DT 19613 8612 40 friend friend NN 19613 8612 41 , , , 19613 8612 42 associate associate NN 19613 8612 43 , , , 19613 8612 44 and and CC 19613 8612 45 bridegroom bridegroom NN 19613 8612 46 of of IN 19613 8612 47 the the DT 19613 8612 48 soul soul NN 19613 8612 49 , , , 19613 8612 50 which which WDT 19613 8612 51 now now RB 19613 8612 52 , , , 19613 8612 53 having have VBG 19613 8612 54 become become VBN 19613 8612 55 a a DT 19613 8612 56 pure pure JJ 19613 8612 57 spirit spirit NN 19613 8612 58 , , , 19613 8612 59 and and CC 19613 8612 60 being be VBG 19613 8612 61 herself -PRON- PRP 19613 8612 62 deified deify VBN 19613 8612 63 , , , 19613 8612 64 clings cling NNS 19613 8612 65 in in IN 19613 8612 66 love love NN 19613 8612 67 to to IN 19613 8612 68 the the DT 19613 8612 69 Deity Deity NNP 19613 8612 70 . . . 19613 8613 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8613 2 801 801 CD 19613 8613 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8613 4 In in IN 19613 8613 5 this this DT 19613 8613 6 view view NN 19613 8613 7 the the DT 19613 8613 8 thought thought NN 19613 8613 9 of of IN 19613 8613 10 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 8613 11 in in IN 19613 8613 12 the the DT 19613 8613 13 sense sense NN 19613 8613 14 of of IN 19613 8613 15 a a DT 19613 8613 16 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 8613 17 renewal renewal NN 19613 8613 18 of of IN 19613 8613 19 the the DT 19613 8613 20 Ego Ego NNP 19613 8613 21 has have VBZ 19613 8613 22 no no DT 19613 8613 23 place;[802 place;[802 NNS 19613 8613 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8613 25 still still RB 19613 8613 26 baptism baptism NN 19613 8613 27 is be VBZ 19613 8613 28 designated designate VBN 19613 8613 29 the the DT 19613 8613 30 bath bath NN 19613 8613 31 of of IN 19613 8613 32 regeneration regeneration NN 19613 8613 33 . . . 19613 8614 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8614 2 , , , 19613 8614 3 in in IN 19613 8614 4 connection connection NN 19613 8614 5 with with IN 19613 8614 6 the the DT 19613 8614 7 consideration consideration NN 19613 8614 8 of of IN 19613 8614 9 main main JJ 19613 8614 10 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 8614 11 thoughts thought NNS 19613 8614 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8614 13 God God NNP 19613 8614 14 as as IN 19613 8614 15 love love NN 19613 8614 16 , , , 19613 8614 17 God God NNP 19613 8614 18 as as IN 19613 8614 19 the the DT 19613 8614 20 Father Father NNP 19613 8614 21 , , , 19613 8614 22 Regeneration Regeneration NNP 19613 8614 23 , , , 19613 8614 24 Adoption Adoption NNP 19613 8614 25 , , , 19613 8614 26 etc etc FW 19613 8614 27 . . . 19613 8614 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8615 1 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8615 2 find find VBP 19613 8615 3 in in IN 19613 8615 4 both both CC 19613 8615 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8615 6 and and CC 19613 8615 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8615 8 passages passage NNS 19613 8615 9 which which WDT 19613 8615 10 , , , 19613 8615 11 free free JJ 19613 8615 12 from from IN 19613 8615 13 the the DT 19613 8615 14 trammels trammel NNS 19613 8615 15 of of IN 19613 8615 16 the the DT 19613 8615 17 system system NN 19613 8615 18 , , , 19613 8615 19 reproduce reproduce VB 19613 8615 20 and and CC 19613 8615 21 set set VB 19613 8615 22 forth forth RP 19613 8615 23 the the DT 19613 8615 24 preaching preaching NN 19613 8615 25 of of IN 19613 8615 26 the the DT 19613 8615 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8615 28 in in IN 19613 8615 29 a a DT 19613 8615 30 surprisingly surprisingly RB 19613 8615 31 appropriate appropriate JJ 19613 8615 32 way way NN 19613 8615 33 . . . 19613 8616 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8616 2 803 803 CD 19613 8616 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8616 4 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8616 5 is be VBZ 19613 8616 6 evident evident JJ 19613 8616 7 that that IN 19613 8616 8 in in IN 19613 8616 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8616 10 's 's POS 19613 8616 11 view view NN 19613 8616 12 there there EX 19613 8616 13 can can MD 19613 8616 14 be be VB 19613 8616 15 no no DT 19613 8616 16 visible visible JJ 19613 8616 17 means mean NNS 19613 8616 18 of of IN 19613 8616 19 grace grace NN 19613 8616 20 ; ; : 19613 8616 21 but but CC 19613 8616 22 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8616 23 likewise likewise RB 19613 8616 24 follows follow VBZ 19613 8616 25 from from IN 19613 8616 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8616 27 whole whole JJ 19613 8616 28 way way NN 19613 8616 29 of of IN 19613 8616 30 thinking thinking NN 19613 8616 31 that that IN 19613 8616 32 the the DT 19613 8616 33 symbols symbol NNS 19613 8616 34 attending attend VBG 19613 8616 35 the the DT 19613 8616 36 enlightening enlighten VBG 19613 8616 37 operation operation NN 19613 8616 38 of of IN 19613 8616 39 grace grace NN 19613 8616 40 are be VBP 19613 8616 41 not not RB 19613 8616 42 a a DT 19613 8616 43 matter matter NN 19613 8616 44 of of IN 19613 8616 45 indifference indifference NN 19613 8616 46 to to IN 19613 8616 47 the the DT 19613 8616 48 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8616 49 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8616 50 , , , 19613 8616 51 whilst whilst IN 19613 8616 52 to to IN 19613 8616 53 the the DT 19613 8616 54 common common JJ 19613 8616 55 man man NN 19613 8616 56 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8616 57 are be VBP 19613 8616 58 indispensable indispensable JJ 19613 8616 59 . . . 19613 8617 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8617 2 804 804 CD 19613 8617 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8617 4 In in IN 19613 8617 5 the the DT 19613 8617 6 same same JJ 19613 8617 7 way way NN 19613 8617 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8617 9 brought bring VBD 19613 8617 10 into into IN 19613 8617 11 play play NN 19613 8617 12 the the DT 19613 8617 13 system system NN 19613 8617 14 of of IN 19613 8617 15 numerous numerous JJ 19613 8617 16 mediators mediator NNS 19613 8617 17 and and CC 19613 8617 18 intercessors intercessor NNS 19613 8617 19 with with IN 19613 8617 20 God God NNP 19613 8617 21 , , , 19613 8617 22 viz viz NNP 19613 8617 23 . . NNP 19613 8617 24 , , , 19613 8617 25 angels angel NNS 19613 8617 26 and and CC 19613 8617 27 dead dead JJ 19613 8617 28 and and CC 19613 8617 29 living living JJ 19613 8617 30 saints saint NNS 19613 8617 31 , , , 19613 8617 32 and and CC 19613 8617 33 counselled counsel VBD 19613 8617 34 an an DT 19613 8617 35 appeal appeal NN 19613 8617 36 to to IN 19613 8617 37 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8617 38 . . . 19613 8618 1 In in IN 19613 8618 2 this this DT 19613 8618 3 respect respect NN 19613 8618 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8618 5 preserved preserve VBD 19613 8618 6 a a DT 19613 8618 7 heathen heathen NNP 19613 8618 8 custom custom NN 19613 8618 9 . . . 19613 8619 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8619 2 , , , 19613 8619 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8619 4 regards regard VBZ 19613 8619 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8619 6 as as IN 19613 8619 7 playing play VBG 19613 8619 8 an an DT 19613 8619 9 important important JJ 19613 8619 10 part part NN 19613 8619 11 in in IN 19613 8619 12 prayer prayer NN 19613 8619 13 , , , 19613 8619 14 particularly particularly RB 19613 8619 15 as as IN 19613 8619 16 mediator mediator NN 19613 8619 17 and and CC 19613 8619 18 high high JJ 19613 8619 19 priest priest NN 19613 8619 20 . . . 19613 8620 1 On on IN 19613 8620 2 prayer prayer NN 19613 8620 3 to to IN 19613 8620 4 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8620 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8620 6 expressed express VBD 19613 8620 7 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8620 8 with with IN 19613 8620 9 great great NNP 19613 8620 10 reserve reserve NN 19613 8620 11 . . . 19613 8621 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8621 2 's 's POS 19613 8621 3 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 8621 4 occupies occupy VBZ 19613 8621 5 a a DT 19613 8621 6 middle middle JJ 19613 8621 7 position position NN 19613 8621 8 between between IN 19613 8621 9 that that DT 19613 8621 10 of of IN 19613 8621 11 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8621 12 and and CC 19613 8621 13 the the DT 19613 8621 14 theory theory NN 19613 8621 15 of of IN 19613 8621 16 the the DT 19613 8621 17 Valentinian Valentinian NNP 19613 8621 18 Gnostics Gnostics NNP 19613 8621 19 , , , 19613 8621 20 but but CC 19613 8621 21 is be VBZ 19613 8621 22 more more RBR 19613 8621 23 akin akin JJ 19613 8621 24 to to IN 19613 8621 25 the the DT 19613 8621 26 latter latter JJ 19613 8621 27 view view NN 19613 8621 28 . . . 19613 8622 1 Whilst whilst RB 19613 8622 2 , , , 19613 8622 3 according accord VBG 19613 8622 4 to to IN 19613 8622 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8622 6 , , , 19613 8622 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8622 8 reunites reunite VBZ 19613 8622 9 and and CC 19613 8622 10 glorifies glorify VBZ 19613 8622 11 all all DT 19613 8622 12 that that WDT 19613 8622 13 had have VBD 19613 8622 14 been be VBN 19613 8622 15 severed sever VBN 19613 8622 16 , , , 19613 8622 17 though though IN 19613 8622 18 in in IN 19613 8622 19 such such PDT 19613 8622 20 a a DT 19613 8622 21 way way NN 19613 8622 22 that that IN 19613 8622 23 there there EX 19613 8622 24 is be VBZ 19613 8622 25 still still RB 19613 8622 26 a a DT 19613 8622 27 remnant remnant JJ 19613 8622 28 eternally eternally RB 19613 8622 29 damned damn VBN 19613 8622 30 ; ; : 19613 8622 31 and and CC 19613 8622 32 , , , 19613 8622 33 according accord VBG 19613 8622 34 to to IN 19613 8622 35 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 8622 36 , , , 19613 8622 37 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8622 38 separates separate VBZ 19613 8622 39 what what WP 19613 8622 40 is be VBZ 19613 8622 41 illegitimately illegitimately RB 19613 8622 42 united united JJ 19613 8622 43 and and CC 19613 8622 44 saves save VBZ 19613 8622 45 the the DT 19613 8622 46 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8622 47 alone alone RB 19613 8622 48 , , , 19613 8622 49 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8622 50 believes believe VBZ 19613 8622 51 that that IN 19613 8622 52 all all DT 19613 8622 53 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8622 54 will will MD 19613 8622 55 be be VB 19613 8622 56 finally finally RB 19613 8622 57 rescued rescue VBN 19613 8622 58 and and CC 19613 8622 59 glorified glorify VBN 19613 8622 60 , , , 19613 8622 61 each each DT 19613 8622 62 in in IN 19613 8622 63 the the DT 19613 8622 64 form form NN 19613 8622 65 of of IN 19613 8622 66 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8622 67 individual individual JJ 19613 8622 68 life life NN 19613 8622 69 , , , 19613 8622 70 in in IN 19613 8622 71 order order NN 19613 8622 72 to to TO 19613 8622 73 serve serve VB 19613 8622 74 a a DT 19613 8622 75 new new JJ 19613 8622 76 epoch epoch NN 19613 8622 77 of of IN 19613 8622 78 the the DT 19613 8622 79 world world NN 19613 8622 80 when when WRB 19613 8622 81 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 8622 82 matter matter NN 19613 8622 83 disappears disappear VBZ 19613 8622 84 of of IN 19613 8622 85 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8622 86 . . . 19613 8623 1 Here here RB 19613 8623 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8623 3 rejects reject VBZ 19613 8623 4 all all DT 19613 8623 5 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 8623 6 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 8623 7 expectations expectation NNS 19613 8623 8 . . . 19613 8624 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8624 2 805 805 CD 19613 8624 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8624 4 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8624 5 accepted accept VBD 19613 8624 6 the the DT 19613 8624 7 formula formula NN 19613 8624 8 , , , 19613 8624 9 " " '' 19613 8624 10 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 8624 11 of of IN 19613 8624 12 the the DT 19613 8624 13 flesh flesh NN 19613 8624 14 " " '' 19613 8624 15 , , , 19613 8624 16 only only RB 19613 8624 17 because because IN 19613 8624 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8624 19 was be VBD 19613 8624 20 contained contain VBN 19613 8624 21 in in IN 19613 8624 22 the the DT 19613 8624 23 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8624 24 of of IN 19613 8624 25 the the DT 19613 8624 26 Church Church NNP 19613 8624 27 ; ; : 19613 8624 28 but but CC 19613 8624 29 , , , 19613 8624 30 on on IN 19613 8624 31 the the DT 19613 8624 32 strength strength NN 19613 8624 33 of of IN 19613 8624 34 1 1 CD 19613 8624 35 Cor Cor NNP 19613 8624 36 . . . 19613 8625 1 XV XV NNP 19613 8625 2 . . . 19613 8626 1 44 44 CD 19613 8626 2 , , , 19613 8626 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8626 4 interpreted interpret VBD 19613 8626 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8626 6 as as IN 19613 8626 7 the the DT 19613 8626 8 rising rise VBG 19613 8626 9 of of IN 19613 8626 10 a a DT 19613 8626 11 " " `` 19613 8626 12 corpus corpus NNP 19613 8626 13 spiritale spiritale NN 19613 8626 14 " " '' 19613 8626 15 , , , 19613 8626 16 which which WDT 19613 8626 17 will will MD 19613 8626 18 lack lack VB 19613 8626 19 all all DT 19613 8626 20 material material NN 19613 8626 21 attributes attribute NNS 19613 8626 22 and and CC 19613 8626 23 even even RB 19613 8626 24 all all PDT 19613 8626 25 the the DT 19613 8626 26 members member NNS 19613 8626 27 that that WDT 19613 8626 28 have have VBP 19613 8626 29 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 8626 30 functions function NNS 19613 8626 31 , , , 19613 8626 32 and and CC 19613 8626 33 which which WDT 19613 8626 34 will will MD 19613 8626 35 beam beam VB 19613 8626 36 with with IN 19613 8626 37 radiant radiant JJ 19613 8626 38 light light NN 19613 8626 39 like like IN 19613 8626 40 the the DT 19613 8626 41 angels angel NNS 19613 8626 42 and and CC 19613 8626 43 stars star NNS 19613 8626 44 . . . 19613 8627 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8627 2 806 806 CD 19613 8627 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8627 4 Rejecting reject VBG 19613 8627 5 the the DT 19613 8627 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8627 7 that that WDT 19613 8627 8 souls soul VBZ 19613 8627 9 sleep,[807 sleep,[807 NN 19613 8627 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8627 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8627 12 assumed assume VBD 19613 8627 13 that that IN 19613 8627 14 the the DT 19613 8627 15 souls soul NNS 19613 8627 16 of of IN 19613 8627 17 the the DT 19613 8627 18 departed depart VBN 19613 8627 19 immediately immediately RB 19613 8627 20 enter enter VBP 19613 8627 21 Paradise,[808 paradise,[808 NN 19613 8627 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8627 23 and and CC 19613 8627 24 that that IN 19613 8627 25 souls soul VBZ 19613 8627 26 not not RB 19613 8627 27 yet yet RB 19613 8627 28 purified purify VBN 19613 8627 29 pass pass VBP 19613 8627 30 into into IN 19613 8627 31 a a DT 19613 8627 32 state state NN 19613 8627 33 of of IN 19613 8627 34 punishment punishment NN 19613 8627 35 , , , 19613 8627 36 a a DT 19613 8627 37 penal penal JJ 19613 8627 38 fire fire NN 19613 8627 39 , , , 19613 8627 40 which which WDT 19613 8627 41 , , , 19613 8627 42 however however RB 19613 8627 43 , , , 19613 8627 44 like like IN 19613 8627 45 the the DT 19613 8627 46 whole whole JJ 19613 8627 47 world world NN 19613 8627 48 , , , 19613 8627 49 is be VBZ 19613 8627 50 to to TO 19613 8627 51 be be VB 19613 8627 52 conceived conceive VBN 19613 8627 53 as as IN 19613 8627 54 a a DT 19613 8627 55 place place NN 19613 8627 56 of of IN 19613 8627 57 purification purification NN 19613 8627 58 . . . 19613 8628 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8628 2 809 809 CD 19613 8628 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8628 4 In in IN 19613 8628 5 this this DT 19613 8628 6 way way NN 19613 8628 7 also also RB 19613 8628 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8628 9 contrived contrive VBD 19613 8628 10 to to TO 19613 8628 11 reconcile reconcile VB 19613 8628 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8628 13 position position NN 19613 8628 14 with with IN 19613 8628 15 the the DT 19613 8628 16 Church Church NNP 19613 8628 17 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 8628 18 of of IN 19613 8628 19 the the DT 19613 8628 20 judgment judgment NN 19613 8628 21 and and CC 19613 8628 22 the the DT 19613 8628 23 punishments punishment NNS 19613 8628 24 in in IN 19613 8628 25 hell hell NN 19613 8628 26 ; ; : 19613 8628 27 but but CC 19613 8628 28 , , , 19613 8628 29 like like IN 19613 8628 30 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8628 31 , , , 19613 8628 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8628 33 viewed view VBD 19613 8628 34 the the DT 19613 8628 35 purifying purifying NN 19613 8628 36 fire fire NN 19613 8628 37 as as IN 19613 8628 38 a a DT 19613 8628 39 temporary temporary JJ 19613 8628 40 and and CC 19613 8628 41 figurative figurative JJ 19613 8628 42 one one CD 19613 8628 43 ; ; : 19613 8628 44 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8628 45 consists consist VBZ 19613 8628 46 in in IN 19613 8628 47 the the DT 19613 8628 48 torments torment NNS 19613 8628 49 of of IN 19613 8628 50 conscience conscience NN 19613 8628 51 . . . 19613 8629 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8629 2 810 810 CD 19613 8629 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8629 4 In in IN 19613 8629 5 the the DT 19613 8629 6 end end NN 19613 8629 7 all all PDT 19613 8629 8 the the DT 19613 8629 9 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8629 10 in in IN 19613 8629 11 heaven heaven NNP 19613 8629 12 and and CC 19613 8629 13 earth earth NN 19613 8629 14 , , , 19613 8629 15 nay nay NN 19613 8629 16 , , , 19613 8629 17 even even RB 19613 8629 18 the the DT 19613 8629 19 demons demon NNS 19613 8629 20 , , , 19613 8629 21 are be VBP 19613 8629 22 purified purify VBN 19613 8629 23 and and CC 19613 8629 24 brought bring VBN 19613 8629 25 back back RB 19613 8629 26 to to IN 19613 8629 27 God God NNP 19613 8629 28 by by IN 19613 8629 29 the the DT 19613 8629 30 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8629 31 - - HYPH 19613 8629 32 Christ,[811 Christ,[811 NNP 19613 8629 33 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8629 34 after after IN 19613 8629 35 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8629 36 have have VBP 19613 8629 37 ascended ascend VBN 19613 8629 38 from from IN 19613 8629 39 stage stage NN 19613 8629 40 to to TO 19613 8629 41 stage stage NN 19613 8629 42 through through IN 19613 8629 43 seven seven CD 19613 8629 44 heavens heaven NNS 19613 8629 45 . . . 19613 8630 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8630 2 812 812 CD 19613 8630 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8630 4 Hence Hence NNP 19613 8630 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8630 6 treated treat VBD 19613 8630 7 this this DT 19613 8630 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8630 9 as as IN 19613 8630 10 an an DT 19613 8630 11 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 8630 12 one one NN 19613 8630 13 : : : 19613 8630 14 " " `` 19613 8630 15 for for IN 19613 8630 16 the the DT 19613 8630 17 common common JJ 19613 8630 18 man man NN 19613 8630 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8630 20 is be VBZ 19613 8630 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8630 22 to to TO 19613 8630 23 know know VB 19613 8630 24 that that IN 19613 8630 25 the the DT 19613 8630 26 sinner sinner NN 19613 8630 27 is be VBZ 19613 8630 28 punished punish VBN 19613 8630 29 . . . 19613 8631 1 " " `` 19613 8631 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8631 3 813 813 CD 19613 8631 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8631 5 This this DT 19613 8631 6 system system NN 19613 8631 7 overthrew overthrow VBD 19613 8631 8 those those DT 19613 8631 9 of of IN 19613 8631 10 the the DT 19613 8631 11 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8631 12 , , , 19613 8631 13 attracted attract VBD 19613 8631 14 Greek greek JJ 19613 8631 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8631 16 , , , 19613 8631 17 and and CC 19613 8631 18 justified justify VBN 19613 8631 19 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8631 20 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8631 21 . . . 19613 8632 1 If if IN 19613 8632 2 one one CD 19613 8632 3 undertook undertake VBD 19613 8632 4 to to TO 19613 8632 5 subject subject VB 19613 8632 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8632 7 to to IN 19613 8632 8 a a DT 19613 8632 9 new new JJ 19613 8632 10 process process NN 19613 8632 11 of of IN 19613 8632 12 sublimation sublimation NN 19613 8632 13 from from IN 19613 8632 14 the the DT 19613 8632 15 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 8632 16 given give VBN 19613 8632 17 in in IN 19613 8632 18 the the DT 19613 8632 19 " " `` 19613 8632 20 contemplative contemplative JJ 19613 8632 21 life life NN 19613 8632 22 " " '' 19613 8632 23 , , , 19613 8632 24 little little JJ 19613 8632 25 else else RB 19613 8632 26 would would MD 19613 8632 27 be be VB 19613 8632 28 left leave VBN 19613 8632 29 than than IN 19613 8632 30 the the DT 19613 8632 31 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 8632 32 spirit spirit NN 19613 8632 33 , , , 19613 8632 34 the the DT 19613 8632 35 created create VBN 19613 8632 36 spirit spirit NN 19613 8632 37 , , , 19613 8632 38 and and CC 19613 8632 39 the the DT 19613 8632 40 ethic ethic NN 19613 8632 41 . . . 19613 8633 1 But but CC 19613 8633 2 no no DT 19613 8633 3 one one NN 19613 8633 4 is be VBZ 19613 8633 5 justified justify VBN 19613 8633 6 in in IN 19613 8633 7 subjecting subject VBG 19613 8633 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8633 9 to to IN 19613 8633 10 this this DT 19613 8633 11 process process NN 19613 8633 12 . . . 19613 8634 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8634 2 814 814 CD 19613 8634 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8634 4 The the DT 19613 8634 5 method method NN 19613 8634 6 according accord VBG 19613 8634 7 to to IN 19613 8634 8 which which WDT 19613 8634 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8634 10 preserved preserve VBD 19613 8634 11 whatever whatever WDT 19613 8634 12 appeared appear VBD 19613 8634 13 valuable valuable JJ 19613 8634 14 in in IN 19613 8634 15 the the DT 19613 8634 16 content content NN 19613 8634 17 of of IN 19613 8634 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 8634 19 is be VBZ 19613 8634 20 no no DT 19613 8634 21 less less RBR 19613 8634 22 significant significant JJ 19613 8634 23 than than IN 19613 8634 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8634 25 system system NN 19613 8634 26 of of IN 19613 8634 27 ethics ethic NNS 19613 8634 28 and and CC 19613 8634 29 the the DT 19613 8634 30 great great JJ 19613 8634 31 principle principle NN 19613 8634 32 of of IN 19613 8634 33 viewing view VBG 19613 8634 34 everything everything NN 19613 8634 35 created create VBN 19613 8634 36 in in IN 19613 8634 37 a a DT 19613 8634 38 relative relative JJ 19613 8634 39 sense sense NN 19613 8634 40 . . . 19613 8635 1 Supposing suppose VBG 19613 8635 2 minds mind NNS 19613 8635 3 of of IN 19613 8635 4 a a DT 19613 8635 5 radical radical JJ 19613 8635 6 cast cast NN 19613 8635 7 , , , 19613 8635 8 to to TO 19613 8635 9 have have VB 19613 8635 10 existed exist VBN 19613 8635 11 at at IN 19613 8635 12 the the DT 19613 8635 13 close close NN 19613 8635 14 of of IN 19613 8635 15 the the DT 19613 8635 16 history history NN 19613 8635 17 of of IN 19613 8635 18 ancient ancient JJ 19613 8635 19 civilisation civilisation NN 19613 8635 20 , , , 19613 8635 21 what what WP 19613 8635 22 would would MD 19613 8635 23 have have VB 19613 8635 24 been be VBN 19613 8635 25 left leave VBN 19613 8635 26 to to IN 19613 8635 27 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8635 28 ? ? . 19613 8636 1 The the DT 19613 8636 2 fact fact NN 19613 8636 3 of of IN 19613 8636 4 a a DT 19613 8636 5 strong strong JJ 19613 8636 6 and and CC 19613 8636 7 undivided undivided JJ 19613 8636 8 religious religious JJ 19613 8636 9 interest interest NN 19613 8636 10 attaching attach VBG 19613 8636 11 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8636 12 to to IN 19613 8636 13 the the DT 19613 8636 14 traditions tradition NNS 19613 8636 15 of of IN 19613 8636 16 the the DT 19613 8636 17 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8636 18 and and CC 19613 8636 19 of of IN 19613 8636 20 the the DT 19613 8636 21 two two CD 19613 8636 22 Testaments Testaments NNPS 19613 8636 23 was be VBD 19613 8636 24 the the DT 19613 8636 25 condition condition NN 19613 8636 26 -- -- : 19613 8636 27 to to TO 19613 8636 28 use use VB 19613 8636 29 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8636 30 's 's POS 19613 8636 31 own own JJ 19613 8636 32 language language NN 19613 8636 33 -- -- : 19613 8636 34 that that WDT 19613 8636 35 enabled enable VBD 19613 8636 36 a a DT 19613 8636 37 new new JJ 19613 8636 38 world world NN 19613 8636 39 of of IN 19613 8636 40 spirits spirit NNS 19613 8636 41 to to TO 19613 8636 42 arise arise VB 19613 8636 43 after after IN 19613 8636 44 the the DT 19613 8636 45 old old JJ 19613 8636 46 one one CD 19613 8636 47 had have VBD 19613 8636 48 finished finish VBN 19613 8636 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8636 50 course course NN 19613 8636 51 . . . 19613 8637 1 During during IN 19613 8637 2 the the DT 19613 8637 3 following follow VBG 19613 8637 4 century century NN 19613 8637 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8637 6 's 's POS 19613 8637 7 theology theology NN 19613 8637 8 at at IN 19613 8637 9 first first RB 19613 8637 10 acted act VBN 19613 8637 11 in in IN 19613 8637 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8637 13 entirety entirety NN 19613 8637 14 . . . 19613 8638 1 But but CC 19613 8638 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8638 3 likewise likewise RB 19613 8638 4 attained attain VBD 19613 8638 5 this this DT 19613 8638 6 position position NN 19613 8638 7 of of IN 19613 8638 8 influence influence NN 19613 8638 9 , , , 19613 8638 10 because because IN 19613 8638 11 some some DT 19613 8638 12 important important JJ 19613 8638 13 propositions proposition NNS 19613 8638 14 could could MD 19613 8638 15 be be VB 19613 8638 16 detached detach VBN 19613 8638 17 from from IN 19613 8638 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8638 19 original original JJ 19613 8638 20 connection connection NN 19613 8638 21 and and CC 19613 8638 22 fitted fit VBD 19613 8638 23 into into IN 19613 8638 24 a a DT 19613 8638 25 new new JJ 19613 8638 26 one one NN 19613 8638 27 . . . 19613 8639 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 8639 2 is be VBZ 19613 8639 3 one one CD 19613 8639 4 of of IN 19613 8639 5 the the DT 19613 8639 6 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 19613 8639 7 of of IN 19613 8639 8 this this DT 19613 8639 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8639 10 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8639 11 of of IN 19613 8639 12 religion religion NN 19613 8639 13 that that IN 19613 8639 14 the the DT 19613 8639 15 most most JJS 19613 8639 16 of of IN 19613 8639 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8639 18 formulæ formulæ NN 19613 8639 19 could could MD 19613 8639 20 be be VB 19613 8639 21 interpreted interpret VBN 19613 8639 22 and and CC 19613 8639 23 employed employ VBN 19613 8639 24 _ _ NNP 19613 8639 25 in in IN 19613 8639 26 utramque utramque NNP 19613 8639 27 partem partem NNP 19613 8639 28 _ _ NNP 19613 8639 29 . . . 19613 8640 1 The the DT 19613 8640 2 several several JJ 19613 8640 3 propositions proposition NNS 19613 8640 4 could could MD 19613 8640 5 be be VB 19613 8640 6 made make VBN 19613 8640 7 to to TO 19613 8640 8 serve serve VB 19613 8640 9 very very RB 19613 8640 10 different different JJ 19613 8640 11 purposes purpose NNS 19613 8640 12 not not RB 19613 8640 13 only only RB 19613 8640 14 by by IN 19613 8640 15 being be VBG 19613 8640 16 halved halve VBN 19613 8640 17 , , , 19613 8640 18 but but CC 19613 8640 19 also also RB 19613 8640 20 by by IN 19613 8640 21 being be VBG 19613 8640 22 grouped group VBN 19613 8640 23 . . . 19613 8641 1 With with IN 19613 8641 2 this this DT 19613 8641 3 the the DT 19613 8641 4 relative relative JJ 19613 8641 5 unity unity NN 19613 8641 6 that that WDT 19613 8641 7 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 8641 8 the the DT 19613 8641 9 system system NN 19613 8641 10 no no RB 19613 8641 11 doubt doubt RB 19613 8641 12 vanished vanish VBD 19613 8641 13 ; ; : 19613 8641 14 but but CC 19613 8641 15 how how WRB 19613 8641 16 many many JJ 19613 8641 17 are be VBP 19613 8641 18 there there EX 19613 8641 19 who who WP 19613 8641 20 strive strive VBP 19613 8641 21 after after IN 19613 8641 22 unity unity NN 19613 8641 23 and and CC 19613 8641 24 completeness completeness VB 19613 8641 25 in in IN 19613 8641 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8641 27 theory theory NN 19613 8641 28 of of IN 19613 8641 29 the the DT 19613 8641 30 world world NN 19613 8641 31 ? ? . 19613 8642 1 Above above IN 19613 8642 2 all all DT 19613 8642 3 , , , 19613 8642 4 however however RB 19613 8642 5 , , , 19613 8642 6 there there EX 19613 8642 7 was be VBD 19613 8642 8 something something NN 19613 8642 9 else else RB 19613 8642 10 that that WDT 19613 8642 11 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8642 12 vanished vanish VBD 19613 8642 13 , , , 19613 8642 14 as as RB 19613 8642 15 soon soon RB 19613 8642 16 as as IN 19613 8642 17 people people NNS 19613 8642 18 meddled meddle VBD 19613 8642 19 with with IN 19613 8642 20 the the DT 19613 8642 21 individual individual JJ 19613 8642 22 propositions proposition NNS 19613 8642 23 , , , 19613 8642 24 and and CC 19613 8642 25 enlarged enlarge VBD 19613 8642 26 or or CC 19613 8642 27 abridged abridge VBD 19613 8642 28 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8642 29 . . . 19613 8643 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8643 2 mean mean VBP 19613 8643 3 the the DT 19613 8643 4 frame frame NN 19613 8643 5 of of IN 19613 8643 6 mind mind NN 19613 8643 7 which which WDT 19613 8643 8 produced produce VBD 19613 8643 9 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8643 10 , , , 19613 8643 11 that that DT 19613 8643 12 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 8643 13 unity unity NN 19613 8643 14 between between IN 19613 8643 15 the the DT 19613 8643 16 relative relative JJ 19613 8643 17 view view NN 19613 8643 18 of of IN 19613 8643 19 things thing NNS 19613 8643 20 and and CC 19613 8643 21 the the DT 19613 8643 22 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8643 23 estimate estimate NN 19613 8643 24 of of IN 19613 8643 25 the the DT 19613 8643 26 highest high JJS 19613 8643 27 good good JJ 19613 8643 28 attainable attainable JJ 19613 8643 29 by by IN 19613 8643 30 the the DT 19613 8643 31 free free JJ 19613 8643 32 spirit spirit NN 19613 8643 33 that that WDT 19613 8643 34 is be VBZ 19613 8643 35 certain certain JJ 19613 8643 36 of of IN 19613 8643 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8643 38 God God NNP 19613 8643 39 . . . 19613 8644 1 But but CC 19613 8644 2 a a DT 19613 8644 3 time time NN 19613 8644 4 came come VBD 19613 8644 5 , , , 19613 8644 6 nay nay NNP 19613 8644 7 , , , 19613 8644 8 had have VBD 19613 8644 9 already already RB 19613 8644 10 come come VBN 19613 8644 11 , , , 19613 8644 12 when when WRB 19613 8644 13 a a DT 19613 8644 14 sense sense NN 19613 8644 15 of of IN 19613 8644 16 proportion proportion NN 19613 8644 17 and and CC 19613 8644 18 relation relation NN 19613 8644 19 was be VBD 19613 8644 20 no no RB 19613 8644 21 longer long JJR 19613 8644 22 to to TO 19613 8644 23 be be VB 19613 8644 24 found find VBN 19613 8644 25 . . . 19613 8645 1 In in IN 19613 8645 2 the the DT 19613 8645 3 East East NNP 19613 8645 4 the the DT 19613 8645 5 history history NN 19613 8645 6 of of IN 19613 8645 7 dogma dogma NN 19613 8645 8 and and CC 19613 8645 9 of of IN 19613 8645 10 the the DT 19613 8645 11 Church Church NNP 19613 8645 12 during during IN 19613 8645 13 the the DT 19613 8645 14 succeeding succeed VBG 19613 8645 15 centuries century NNS 19613 8645 16 is be VBZ 19613 8645 17 the the DT 19613 8645 18 history history NN 19613 8645 19 of of IN 19613 8645 20 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8645 21 's 's POS 19613 8645 22 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8645 23 . . . 19613 8646 1 Arians arian NNS 19613 8646 2 and and CC 19613 8646 3 orthodox orthodox NN 19613 8646 4 , , , 19613 8646 5 critics critic NNS 19613 8646 6 and and CC 19613 8646 7 mystics mystic NNS 19613 8646 8 , , , 19613 8646 9 priests priest NNS 19613 8646 10 who who WP 19613 8646 11 overcame overcome VBD 19613 8646 12 the the DT 19613 8646 13 world world NN 19613 8646 14 and and CC 19613 8646 15 monks monk NNS 19613 8646 16 who who WP 19613 8646 17 shunned shun VBD 19613 8646 18 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8646 19 but but CC 19613 8646 20 were be VBD 19613 8646 21 eager eager JJ 19613 8646 22 for for IN 19613 8646 23 knowledge[815 knowledge[815 NNP 19613 8646 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8646 25 could could MD 19613 8646 26 appeal appeal VB 19613 8646 27 to to IN 19613 8646 28 this this DT 19613 8646 29 system system NN 19613 8646 30 and and CC 19613 8646 31 did do VBD 19613 8646 32 not not RB 19613 8646 33 fail fail VB 19613 8646 34 to to TO 19613 8646 35 do do VB 19613 8646 36 so so RB 19613 8646 37 . . . 19613 8647 1 But but CC 19613 8647 2 , , , 19613 8647 3 in in IN 19613 8647 4 the the DT 19613 8647 5 main main JJ 19613 8647 6 problem problem NN 19613 8647 7 that that WDT 19613 8647 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8647 9 set set VBD 19613 8647 10 for for IN 19613 8647 11 the the DT 19613 8647 12 Church Church NNP 19613 8647 13 in in IN 19613 8647 14 this this DT 19613 8647 15 religious religious JJ 19613 8647 16 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8647 17 of of IN 19613 8647 18 his -PRON- PRP 19613 8647 19 , , , 19613 8647 20 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8647 21 find find VBP 19613 8647 22 a a DT 19613 8647 23 recurrence recurrence NN 19613 8647 24 of of IN 19613 8647 25 that that DT 19613 8647 26 propounded propound VBN 19613 8647 27 by by IN 19613 8647 28 the the DT 19613 8647 29 so so RB 19613 8647 30 - - HYPH 19613 8647 31 called call VBN 19613 8647 32 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 8647 33 two two CD 19613 8647 34 generations generation NNS 19613 8647 35 earlier early RBR 19613 8647 36 . . . 19613 8648 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8648 2 solved solve VBD 19613 8648 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8648 4 by by IN 19613 8648 5 producing produce VBG 19613 8648 6 a a DT 19613 8648 7 system system NN 19613 8648 8 which which WDT 19613 8648 9 reconciled reconcile VBD 19613 8648 10 the the DT 19613 8648 11 faith faith NN 19613 8648 12 of of IN 19613 8648 13 the the DT 19613 8648 14 Church Church NNP 19613 8648 15 with with IN 19613 8648 16 Greek greek JJ 19613 8648 17 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8648 18 ; ; : 19613 8648 19 and and CC 19613 8648 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8648 21 dealt deal VBD 19613 8648 22 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 19613 8648 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8648 24 death death NN 19613 8648 25 - - HYPH 19613 8648 26 blow blow NN 19613 8648 27 . . . 19613 8649 1 This this DT 19613 8649 2 solution solution NN 19613 8649 3 , , , 19613 8649 4 however however RB 19613 8649 5 , , , 19613 8649 6 was be VBD 19613 8649 7 by by IN 19613 8649 8 no no DT 19613 8649 9 means mean NNS 19613 8649 10 intended intend VBN 19613 8649 11 as as IN 19613 8649 12 the the DT 19613 8649 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8649 14 of of IN 19613 8649 15 the the DT 19613 8649 16 Church Church NNP 19613 8649 17 , , , 19613 8649 18 since since IN 19613 8649 19 indeed indeed RB 19613 8649 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8649 21 was be VBD 19613 8649 22 rather rather RB 19613 8649 23 based base VBN 19613 8649 24 on on IN 19613 8649 25 the the DT 19613 8649 26 distinction distinction NN 19613 8649 27 between between IN 19613 8649 28 Church Church NNP 19613 8649 29 belief belief NN 19613 8649 30 and and CC 19613 8649 31 theology theology NN 19613 8649 32 , , , 19613 8649 33 and and CC 19613 8649 34 consequently consequently RB 19613 8649 35 on on IN 19613 8649 36 the the DT 19613 8649 37 distinction distinction NN 19613 8649 38 between between IN 19613 8649 39 the the DT 19613 8649 40 common common JJ 19613 8649 41 man man NN 19613 8649 42 and and CC 19613 8649 43 the the DT 19613 8649 44 theologian theologian NN 19613 8649 45 . . . 19613 8650 1 But but CC 19613 8650 2 such such PDT 19613 8650 3 a a DT 19613 8650 4 distinction distinction NN 19613 8650 5 was be VBD 19613 8650 6 not not RB 19613 8650 7 permanently permanently RB 19613 8650 8 tenable tenable JJ 19613 8650 9 in in IN 19613 8650 10 a a DT 19613 8650 11 Church Church NNP 19613 8650 12 that that WDT 19613 8650 13 had have VBD 19613 8650 14 to to TO 19613 8650 15 preserve preserve VB 19613 8650 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8650 17 strength strength NN 19613 8650 18 by by IN 19613 8650 19 the the DT 19613 8650 20 unity unity NN 19613 8650 21 and and CC 19613 8650 22 finality finality NN 19613 8650 23 of of IN 19613 8650 24 a a DT 19613 8650 25 revealed reveal VBN 19613 8650 26 faith faith NN 19613 8650 27 , , , 19613 8650 28 and and CC 19613 8650 29 no no RB 19613 8650 30 longer long RBR 19613 8650 31 tolerated tolerate VBD 19613 8650 32 fresh fresh JJ 19613 8650 33 changes change NNS 19613 8650 34 in in IN 19613 8650 35 the the DT 19613 8650 36 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 8650 37 of of IN 19613 8650 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8650 39 possession possession NN 19613 8650 40 . . . 19613 8651 1 Hence hence RB 19613 8651 2 a a DT 19613 8651 3 further further JJ 19613 8651 4 compromise compromise NN 19613 8651 5 was be VBD 19613 8651 6 necessary necessary JJ 19613 8651 7 . . . 19613 8652 1 The the DT 19613 8652 2 Greek greek JJ 19613 8652 3 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8652 4 , , , 19613 8652 5 or or CC 19613 8652 6 speculation speculation NN 19613 8652 7 , , , 19613 8652 8 did do VBD 19613 8652 9 not not RB 19613 8652 10 attain attain VB 19613 8652 11 real real JJ 19613 8652 12 and and CC 19613 8652 13 permanent permanent JJ 19613 8652 14 recognition recognition NN 19613 8652 15 within within IN 19613 8652 16 the the DT 19613 8652 17 Church Church NNP 19613 8652 18 till till IN 19613 8652 19 a a DT 19613 8652 20 new new JJ 19613 8652 21 accommodation accommodation NN 19613 8652 22 , , , 19613 8652 23 capable capable JJ 19613 8652 24 of of IN 19613 8652 25 being be VBG 19613 8652 26 accounted account VBN 19613 8652 27 both both CC 19613 8652 28 Pistis Pistis NNP 19613 8652 29 and and CC 19613 8652 30 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8652 31 , , , 19613 8652 32 was be VBD 19613 8652 33 found find VBN 19613 8652 34 between between IN 19613 8652 35 what what WP 19613 8652 36 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8652 37 looked look VBD 19613 8652 38 on on RP 19613 8652 39 as as IN 19613 8652 40 Church Church NNP 19613 8652 41 belief belief NN 19613 8652 42 and and CC 19613 8652 43 what what WP 19613 8652 44 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8652 45 regarded regard VBD 19613 8652 46 as as IN 19613 8652 47 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8652 48 . . . 19613 8653 1 In in IN 19613 8653 2 the the DT 19613 8653 3 endeavours endeavour NNS 19613 8653 4 of of IN 19613 8653 5 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8653 6 , , , 19613 8653 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8653 8 , , , 19613 8653 9 and and CC 19613 8653 10 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 8653 11 were be VBD 19613 8653 12 already already RB 19613 8653 13 found find VBN 19613 8653 14 hesitating hesitating NN 19613 8653 15 , , , 19613 8653 16 nay nay NN 19613 8653 17 , , , 19613 8653 18 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8653 19 may may MD 19613 8653 20 almost almost RB 19613 8653 21 say say VB 19613 8653 22 naïve naïve NNP 19613 8653 23 , , , 19613 8653 24 attempts attempt NNS 19613 8653 25 at at IN 19613 8653 26 such such PDT 19613 8653 27 an an DT 19613 8653 28 accommodation accommodation NN 19613 8653 29 ; ; : 19613 8653 30 but but CC 19613 8653 31 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8653 32 traditionalism traditionalism NN 19613 8653 33 was be VBD 19613 8653 34 unable unable JJ 19613 8653 35 to to TO 19613 8653 36 attain attain VB 19613 8653 37 complete complete JJ 19613 8653 38 clearness clearness NN 19613 8653 39 as as IN 19613 8653 40 to to IN 19613 8653 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8653 42 own own JJ 19613 8653 43 position position NN 19613 8653 44 till till IN 19613 8653 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8653 46 was be VBD 19613 8653 47 confronted confront VBN 19613 8653 48 with with IN 19613 8653 49 a a DT 19613 8653 50 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8653 51 of of IN 19613 8653 52 religion religion NN 19613 8653 53 that that WDT 19613 8653 54 was be VBD 19613 8653 55 no no RB 19613 8653 56 longer long RBR 19613 8653 57 heathen heathen NNP 19613 8653 58 or or CC 19613 8653 59 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8653 60 , , , 19613 8653 61 but but CC 19613 8653 62 had have VBD 19613 8653 63 an an DT 19613 8653 64 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8653 65 colouring colouring NN 19613 8653 66 . . . 19613 8654 1 But but CC 19613 8654 2 , , , 19613 8654 3 with with IN 19613 8654 4 this this DT 19613 8654 5 prospect prospect NN 19613 8654 6 , , , 19613 8654 7 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8654 8 have have VBP 19613 8654 9 already already RB 19613 8654 10 crossed cross VBN 19613 8654 11 the the DT 19613 8654 12 border border NN 19613 8654 13 of of IN 19613 8654 14 the the DT 19613 8654 15 third third JJ 19613 8654 16 century century NN 19613 8654 17 . . . 19613 8655 1 At at IN 19613 8655 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8655 3 beginning beginning NN 19613 8655 4 there there EX 19613 8655 5 were be VBD 19613 8655 6 but but CC 19613 8655 7 few few JJ 19613 8655 8 theologians theologian NNS 19613 8655 9 in in IN 19613 8655 10 Christendom Christendom NNP 19613 8655 11 who who WP 19613 8655 12 were be VBD 19613 8655 13 acquainted acquaint VBN 19613 8655 14 with with IN 19613 8655 15 speculation speculation NN 19613 8655 16 , , , 19613 8655 17 even even RB 19613 8655 18 in in IN 19613 8655 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8655 20 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 19613 8655 21 form form NN 19613 8655 22 . . . 19613 8656 1 In in IN 19613 8656 2 the the DT 19613 8656 3 course course NN 19613 8656 4 of of IN 19613 8656 5 the the DT 19613 8656 6 century century NN 19613 8656 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8656 8 became become VBD 19613 8656 9 a a DT 19613 8656 10 recognised recognise VBN 19613 8656 11 part part NN 19613 8656 12 of of IN 19613 8656 13 the the DT 19613 8656 14 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 8656 15 faith faith NN 19613 8656 16 , , , 19613 8656 17 in in IN 19613 8656 18 so so RB 19613 8656 19 far far RB 19613 8656 20 as as IN 19613 8656 21 the the DT 19613 8656 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8656 23 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8656 24 triumphed triumph VBN 19613 8656 25 in in IN 19613 8656 26 the the DT 19613 8656 27 Church Church NNP 19613 8656 28 . . . 19613 8657 1 This this DT 19613 8657 2 development development NN 19613 8657 3 is be VBZ 19613 8657 4 the the DT 19613 8657 5 most most RBS 19613 8657 6 important important JJ 19613 8657 7 that that WDT 19613 8657 8 took take VBD 19613 8657 9 place place NN 19613 8657 10 in in IN 19613 8657 11 the the DT 19613 8657 12 third third JJ 19613 8657 13 century century NN 19613 8657 14 ; ; : 19613 8657 15 for for IN 19613 8657 16 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8657 17 denoted denote VBD 19613 8657 18 the the DT 19613 8657 19 definite definite JJ 19613 8657 20 transformation transformation NN 19613 8657 21 of of IN 19613 8657 22 the the DT 19613 8657 23 rule rule NN 19613 8657 24 of of IN 19613 8657 25 faith faith NN 19613 8657 26 into into IN 19613 8657 27 the the DT 19613 8657 28 compendium compendium NN 19613 8657 29 of of IN 19613 8657 30 a a DT 19613 8657 31 Greek greek JJ 19613 8657 32 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8657 33 system system NN 19613 8657 34 , , , 19613 8657 35 and and CC 19613 8657 36 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8657 37 is be VBZ 19613 8657 38 the the DT 19613 8657 39 parallel parallel NN 19613 8657 40 of of IN 19613 8657 41 a a DT 19613 8657 42 contemporaneous contemporaneous JJ 19613 8657 43 transformation transformation NN 19613 8657 44 of of IN 19613 8657 45 the the DT 19613 8657 46 Church Church NNP 19613 8657 47 into into IN 19613 8657 48 a a DT 19613 8657 49 holy holy NNP 19613 8657 50 commonwealth commonwealth NN 19613 8657 51 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8657 52 see see VB 19613 8657 53 above above RB 19613 8657 54 , , , 19613 8657 55 chapter chapter NN 19613 8657 56 3 3 CD 19613 8657 57 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8657 58 . . . 19613 8658 1 Footnotes footnote NNS 19613 8658 2 : : : 19613 8658 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8658 4 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8658 5 656 656 CD 19613 8658 6 : : : 19613 8658 7 Guericke Guericke NNP 19613 8658 8 , , , 19613 8658 9 De De NNP 19613 8658 10 schola schola NN 19613 8658 11 , , , 19613 8658 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 8658 13 Alex Alex NNP 19613 8658 14 . . . 19613 8659 1 floruit floruit NNP 19613 8659 2 catechetica catechetica NNP 19613 8659 3 1824 1824 CD 19613 8659 4 , , , 19613 8659 5 1825 1825 CD 19613 8659 6 . . . 19613 8660 1 Vacherot Vacherot NNP 19613 8660 2 , , , 19613 8660 3 Hist Hist NNP 19613 8660 4 . . . 19613 8661 1 crit crit NN 19613 8661 2 . . . 19613 8662 1 de de FW 19613 8662 2 l'école l'école NNP 19613 8662 3 d'Alex d'Alex NNP 19613 8662 4 . . NNP 19613 8662 5 , , , 19613 8662 6 1846 1846 CD 19613 8662 7 - - SYM 19613 8662 8 51 51 CD 19613 8662 9 . . . 19613 8663 1 Reinkens Reinkens NNP 19613 8663 2 , , , 19613 8663 3 De De NNP 19613 8663 4 Clemente Clemente NNP 19613 8663 5 Alex Alex NNP 19613 8663 6 . . NNP 19613 8663 7 , , , 19613 8663 8 1850 1850 CD 19613 8663 9 . . . 19613 8664 1 Redepenning redepenning NN 19613 8664 2 , , , 19613 8664 3 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 8664 4 Thl Thl NNP 19613 8664 5 . . . 19613 8665 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8665 2 p. p. NN 19613 8665 3 57 57 CD 19613 8665 4 ff ff NN 19613 8665 5 . . . 19613 8666 1 Læmmer Læmmer NNP 19613 8666 2 , , , 19613 8666 3 Clem Clem NNP 19613 8666 4 . . . 19613 8667 1 Al Al NNP 19613 8667 2 . . . 19613 8668 1 de de NNP 19613 8668 2 Logo Logo NNP 19613 8668 3 doctrina doctrina NNP 19613 8668 4 , , , 19613 8668 5 1855 1855 CD 19613 8668 6 . . . 19613 8669 1 Reuter reuter NN 19613 8669 2 , , , 19613 8669 3 Clem Clem NNP 19613 8669 4 . . . 19613 8670 1 theolog theolog NNP 19613 8670 2 . . . 19613 8671 1 moralis moralis NNP 19613 8671 2 , , , 19613 8671 3 1853 1853 CD 19613 8671 4 . . . 19613 8672 1 Cognat Cognat NNP 19613 8672 2 , , , 19613 8672 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8672 4 d'Alex d'Alex NNP 19613 8672 5 . . . 19613 8673 1 Paris Paris NNP 19613 8673 2 , , , 19613 8673 3 1859 1859 CD 19613 8673 4 . . . 19613 8674 1 Westcott Westcott NNP 19613 8674 2 , , , 19613 8674 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8674 4 and and CC 19613 8674 5 the the DT 19613 8674 6 beginnings beginning NNS 19613 8674 7 of of IN 19613 8674 8 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8674 9 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 19613 8674 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8674 11 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 19613 8674 12 Review Review NNP 19613 8674 13 , , , 19613 8674 14 May May NNP 19613 8674 15 1879 1879 CD 19613 8674 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8674 17 . . . 19613 8675 1 Winter winter NN 19613 8675 2 , , , 19613 8675 3 Die die VB 19613 8675 4 Ethik Ethik NNP 19613 8675 5 des des NNP 19613 8675 6 Clemens Clemens NNP 19613 8675 7 von von NNP 19613 8675 8 Alex Alex NNP 19613 8675 9 . . NNP 19613 8675 10 , , , 19613 8675 11 1882 1882 CD 19613 8675 12 . . . 19613 8676 1 Merk Merk NNP 19613 8676 2 , , , 19613 8676 3 Cl Cl NNP 19613 8676 4 . . . 19613 8677 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 8677 2 , , , 19613 8677 3 in in IN 19613 8677 4 seiner seiner NN 19613 8677 5 Abhängigkeit Abhängigkeit NNP 19613 8677 6 von von NNP 19613 8677 7 der der NNP 19613 8677 8 griech griech NNP 19613 8677 9 . . . 19613 8678 1 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 19613 8678 2 , , , 19613 8678 3 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 19613 8678 4 , , , 19613 8678 5 1879 1879 CD 19613 8678 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8678 7 see see VB 19613 8678 8 besides besides IN 19613 8678 9 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 8678 10 , , , 19613 8678 11 Theol Theol NNP 19613 8678 12 . . . 19613 8679 1 Lit Lit NNP 19613 8679 2 . . . 19613 8680 1 Ztg Ztg NNP 19613 8680 2 . . NNP 19613 8680 3 , , , 19613 8680 4 1879 1879 CD 19613 8680 5 . . . 19613 8681 1 No no UH 19613 8681 2 . . . 19613 8682 1 20 20 CD 19613 8682 2 and and CC 19613 8682 3 cf cf NN 19613 8682 4 . . . 19613 8683 1 above above IN 19613 8683 2 all all DT 19613 8683 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8683 4 disquisitions disquisition NNS 19613 8683 5 in in IN 19613 8683 6 the the DT 19613 8683 7 treatise treatise NN 19613 8683 8 " " '' 19613 8683 9 Ueber Ueber NNP 19613 8683 10 . . . 19613 8684 1 die die VBP 19613 8684 2 Anfänge anfänge NN 19613 8684 3 der der NN 19613 8684 4 patristischen patristischen NNP 19613 8684 5 Litteratur Litteratur NNP 19613 8684 6 , , , 19613 8684 7 " " '' 19613 8684 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8684 9 Hist Hist NNP 19613 8684 10 . . . 19613 8685 1 Ztschr Ztschr NNP 19613 8685 2 . . . 19613 8686 1 N.F. N.F. NNP 19613 8686 2 , , , 19613 8686 3 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8686 4 . . . 19613 8687 1 XII XII NNP 19613 8687 2 . . NNP 19613 8687 3 , , , 19613 8687 4 pp pp NNP 19613 8687 5 . . . 19613 8688 1 455 455 CD 19613 8688 2 - - SYM 19613 8688 3 472 472 CD 19613 8688 4 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 8688 5 , , , 19613 8688 6 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 8688 7 , , , 19613 8688 8 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8688 9 . . . 19613 8689 1 III iii CD 19613 8689 2 . . . 19613 8690 1 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 8690 2 , , , 19613 8690 3 The the DT 19613 8690 4 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8690 5 Platonists Platonists NNPS 19613 8690 6 of of IN 19613 8690 7 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 19613 8690 8 , , , 19613 8690 9 Oxford Oxford NNP 19613 8690 10 , , , 19613 8690 11 1886 1886 CD 19613 8690 12 . . . 19613 8691 1 Kremmer Kremmer NNP 19613 8691 2 , , , 19613 8691 3 De De NNP 19613 8691 4 catal catal NNP 19613 8691 5 . . . 19613 8692 1 heurematum heurematum NNP 19613 8692 2 , , , 19613 8692 3 Lips Lips NNP 19613 8692 4 . . . 19613 8693 1 1890 1890 CD 19613 8693 2 . . . 19613 8694 1 Wendland Wendland NNP 19613 8694 2 , , , 19613 8694 3 Quæst Quæst NNP 19613 8694 4 . . . 19613 8695 1 Musonianæ Musonianæ NNP 19613 8695 2 , , , 19613 8695 3 Berol Berol NNP 19613 8695 4 . . . 19613 8696 1 1886 1886 CD 19613 8696 2 . . . 19613 8697 1 Bratke Bratke NNP 19613 8697 2 , , , 19613 8697 3 Die Die NNP 19613 8697 4 Stellung Stellung NNP 19613 8697 5 des des FW 19613 8697 6 Clem Clem NNP 19613 8697 7 . . . 19613 8698 1 Alex Alex NNP 19613 8698 2 . . . 19613 8699 1 z. z. NNP 19613 8699 2 antiken antiken NNP 19613 8699 3 Mysterienwesen Mysterienwesen NNP 19613 8699 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8699 5 Stud Stud NNP 19613 8699 6 . . . 19613 8700 1 u. u. NNP 19613 8700 2 Krit Krit NNP 19613 8700 3 . . . 19613 8701 1 1888 1888 CD 19613 8701 2 , , , 19613 8701 3 p. p. NN 19613 8701 4 647 647 CD 19613 8701 5 ff ff NN 19613 8701 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8701 7 . . . 19613 8702 1 On on IN 19613 8702 2 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8702 3 of of IN 19613 8702 4 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 8702 5 see see VB 19613 8702 6 Routh Routh NNP 19613 8702 7 , , , 19613 8702 8 Reliq Reliq NNP 19613 8702 9 . . . 19613 8703 1 Sacr Sacr NNP 19613 8703 2 . . . 19613 8704 1 T. T. NNP 19613 8704 2 II II NNP 19613 8704 3 . . . 19613 8705 1 p. p. NN 19613 8705 2 161 161 CD 19613 8705 3 sq sq NN 19613 8705 4 . . . 19613 8706 1 ; ; : 19613 8706 2 on on IN 19613 8706 3 Julius Julius NNP 19613 8706 4 Africanus Africanus NNP 19613 8706 5 see see VB 19613 8706 6 Gelzer Gelzer NNP 19613 8706 7 , , , 19613 8706 8 Sextus Sextus NNP 19613 8706 9 Jul. July NNP 19613 8707 1 Afr Afr NNP 19613 8707 2 . . . 19613 8708 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8709 1 Thl Thl NNP 19613 8709 2 . . NNP 19613 8709 3 , , , 19613 8709 4 1880 1880 CD 19613 8709 5 , , , 19613 8709 6 p. p. NN 19613 8709 7 1 1 CD 19613 8709 8 ff ff NNP 19613 8709 9 . . NNP 19613 8709 10 , , , 19613 8709 11 Spitta Spitta NNP 19613 8709 12 , , , 19613 8709 13 Der Der NNP 19613 8709 14 Brief Brief NNP 19613 8709 15 des des NNP 19613 8709 16 Jul. July NNP 19613 8710 1 Afr Afr NNP 19613 8710 2 . . . 19613 8711 1 an an DT 19613 8711 2 Aristides Aristides NNP 19613 8711 3 , , , 19613 8711 4 Halle Halle NNP 19613 8711 5 1877 1877 CD 19613 8711 6 , , , 19613 8711 7 and and CC 19613 8711 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8711 9 article article NN 19613 8711 10 in in IN 19613 8711 11 the the DT 19613 8711 12 Real Real NNP 19613 8711 13 - - HYPH 19613 8711 14 Encykl Encykl NNP 19613 8711 15 . . . 19613 8712 1 On on IN 19613 8712 2 Bardesanes Bardesanes NNPS 19613 8712 3 see see VBP 19613 8712 4 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 19613 8712 5 , , , 19613 8712 6 B. B. NNP 19613 8712 7 , , , 19613 8712 8 der der NN 19613 8712 9 letzte letzte NNP 19613 8712 10 Gnostiker Gnostiker NNP 19613 8712 11 , , , 19613 8712 12 1864 1864 CD 19613 8712 13 , , , 19613 8712 14 and and CC 19613 8712 15 Hort Hort NNP 19613 8712 16 's 's POS 19613 8712 17 article article NN 19613 8712 18 in in IN 19613 8712 19 the the DT 19613 8712 20 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 19613 8712 21 of of IN 19613 8712 22 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8712 23 Biography Biography NNP 19613 8712 24 . . . 19613 8713 1 On on IN 19613 8713 2 the the DT 19613 8713 3 labours labour NNS 19613 8713 4 in in IN 19613 8713 5 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8713 6 theology theology NN 19613 8713 7 on on IN 19613 8713 8 the the DT 19613 8713 9 part part NN 19613 8713 10 of of IN 19613 8713 11 the the DT 19613 8713 12 so so RB 19613 8713 13 - - HYPH 19613 8713 14 called call VBN 19613 8713 15 Alogi Alogi NNP 19613 8713 16 in in IN 19613 8713 17 Asia Asia NNP 19613 8713 18 Minor Minor NNP 19613 8713 19 and and CC 19613 8713 20 of of IN 19613 8713 21 the the DT 19613 8713 22 Roman roman JJ 19613 8713 23 Theodotianists Theodotianists NNPS 19613 8713 24 see see VB 19613 8713 25 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 8713 26 . . . 19613 8714 1 hær hær NNP 19613 8714 2 . . . 19613 8715 1 51 51 CD 19613 8715 2 , , , 19613 8715 3 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 8715 4 . . NNP 19613 8715 5 , , , 19613 8715 6 H. H. NNP 19613 8715 7 E. E. NNP 19613 8715 8 V. V. NNP 19613 8715 9 28 28 CD 19613 8715 10 and and CC 19613 8715 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8715 12 article article NN 19613 8715 13 " " `` 19613 8715 14 Monarchianismus Monarchianismus NNP 19613 8715 15 " " '' 19613 8715 16 in in IN 19613 8715 17 the the DT 19613 8715 18 R.-Encykl r.-encykl NN 19613 8715 19 . . . 19613 8716 1 f. f. NNP 19613 8716 2 protest protest NNP 19613 8716 3 . . . 19613 8717 1 Theol Theol NNP 19613 8717 2 . . . 19613 8718 1 2nd 2nd NNP 19613 8718 2 . . . 19613 8719 1 ed ed NNP 19613 8719 2 . . NNP 19613 8719 3 , , , 19613 8719 4 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8719 5 . . . 19613 8720 1 X. X. NNP 19613 8720 2 , , , 19613 8720 3 pp pp NNP 19613 8720 4 . . . 19613 8721 1 183 183 CD 19613 8721 2 ff ff NNP 19613 8721 3 . . NNP 19613 8721 4 , , , 19613 8721 5 188 188 CD 19613 8721 6 ff ff NN 19613 8721 7 . . . 19613 8722 1 On on IN 19613 8722 2 the the DT 19613 8722 3 tendencies tendency NNS 19613 8722 4 even even RB 19613 8722 5 of of IN 19613 8722 6 orthodox orthodox JJ 19613 8722 7 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8722 8 to to IN 19613 8722 9 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8722 10 theology theology NN 19613 8722 11 see see VB 19613 8722 12 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 8722 13 . . NNP 19613 8722 14 , , , 19613 8722 15 de de NNP 19613 8722 16 præscr præscr NNP 19613 8722 17 . . . 19613 8723 1 hær hær NNP 19613 8723 2 . . . 19613 8724 1 8 8 CD 19613 8724 2 ff ff NN 19613 8724 3 . . . 19613 8725 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8725 2 cf cf NN 19613 8725 3 . . . 19613 8726 1 the the DT 19613 8726 2 first first JJ 19613 8726 3 words word NNS 19613 8726 4 of of IN 19613 8726 5 c. c. NN 19613 8726 6 8 8 CD 19613 8726 7 : : : 19613 8726 8 " " `` 19613 8726 9 Venio Venio NNP 19613 8726 10 itaque itaque NN 19613 8726 11 ad ad NN 19613 8726 12 illum illum NNP 19613 8726 13 articulum articulum NNP 19613 8726 14 , , , 19613 8726 15 quem quem NNP 19613 8726 16 et et NNP 19613 8726 17 nostri nostri NNP 19613 8726 18 prætendunt prætendunt NNP 19613 8726 19 ad ad NN 19613 8726 20 ineundam ineundam NNP 19613 8726 21 curiositatem curiositatem NNP 19613 8726 22 . . . 19613 8727 1 Scriptum scriptum JJ 19613 8727 2 est est NN 19613 8727 3 , , , 19613 8727 4 inquiunt inquiunt NN 19613 8727 5 , , , 19613 8727 6 Quærite Quærite NNP 19613 8727 7 et et NN 19613 8727 8 invenietis invenietis NN 19613 8727 9 " " '' 19613 8727 10 etc etc FW 19613 8727 11 . . . 19613 8727 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8727 13 . . . 19613 8727 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8728 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8728 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8728 3 657 657 CD 19613 8728 4 : : : 19613 8728 5 This this DT 19613 8728 6 manner manner NN 19613 8728 7 of of IN 19613 8728 8 expression expression NN 19613 8728 9 is be VBZ 19613 8728 10 indeed indeed RB 19613 8728 11 liable liable JJ 19613 8728 12 to to TO 19613 8728 13 be be VB 19613 8728 14 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 19613 8728 15 , , , 19613 8728 16 because because IN 19613 8728 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8728 18 suggests suggest VBZ 19613 8728 19 the the DT 19613 8728 20 idea idea NN 19613 8728 21 that that IN 19613 8728 22 something something NN 19613 8728 23 new new JJ 19613 8728 24 was be VBD 19613 8728 25 taking take VBG 19613 8728 26 place place NN 19613 8728 27 . . . 19613 8729 1 As as IN 19613 8729 2 a a DT 19613 8729 3 matter matter NN 19613 8729 4 of of IN 19613 8729 5 fact fact NN 19613 8729 6 the the DT 19613 8729 7 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8729 8 labours labour NNS 19613 8729 9 in in IN 19613 8729 10 the the DT 19613 8729 11 Church Church NNP 19613 8729 12 were be VBD 19613 8729 13 merely merely RB 19613 8729 14 a a DT 19613 8729 15 continuation continuation NN 19613 8729 16 of of IN 19613 8729 17 the the DT 19613 8729 18 Gnostic gnostic JJ 19613 8729 19 schools school NNS 19613 8729 20 under under IN 19613 8729 21 altered altered JJ 19613 8729 22 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 8729 23 , , , 19613 8729 24 that that RB 19613 8729 25 is is RB 19613 8729 26 , , , 19613 8729 27 under under IN 19613 8729 28 the the DT 19613 8729 29 sway sway NN 19613 8729 30 of of IN 19613 8729 31 a a DT 19613 8729 32 tradition tradition NN 19613 8729 33 which which WDT 19613 8729 34 was be VBD 19613 8729 35 now now RB 19613 8729 36 more more RBR 19613 8729 37 clearly clearly RB 19613 8729 38 defined define VBN 19613 8729 39 and and CC 19613 8729 40 more more RBR 19613 8729 41 firmly firmly RB 19613 8729 42 fenced fenced JJ 19613 8729 43 round round RB 19613 8729 44 as as IN 19613 8729 45 a a DT 19613 8729 46 _ _ NNP 19613 8729 47 noli noli VBD 19613 8729 48 me -PRON- PRP 19613 8729 49 tangere tangere RB 19613 8729 50 _ _ NNP 19613 8729 51 . . . 19613 8729 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8730 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8730 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8730 3 658 658 CD 19613 8730 4 : : : 19613 8730 5 This this DT 19613 8730 6 was be VBD 19613 8730 7 begun begin VBN 19613 8730 8 in in IN 19613 8730 9 the the DT 19613 8730 10 Church Church NNP 19613 8730 11 by by IN 19613 8730 12 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 8730 13 and and CC 19613 8730 14 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 8730 15 and and CC 19613 8730 16 continued continue VBN 19613 8730 17 by by IN 19613 8730 18 the the DT 19613 8730 19 Alexandrians Alexandrians NNPS 19613 8730 20 . . . 19613 8731 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 8731 2 , , , 19613 8731 3 however however RB 19613 8731 4 , , , 19613 8731 5 not not RB 19613 8731 6 only only RB 19613 8731 7 adopted adopt VBD 19613 8731 8 theologoumena theologoumena NNP 19613 8731 9 from from IN 19613 8731 10 Paulinism Paulinism NNP 19613 8731 11 , , , 19613 8731 12 but but CC 19613 8731 13 also also RB 19613 8731 14 acquired acquire VBD 19613 8731 15 from from IN 19613 8731 16 Paul Paul NNP 19613 8731 17 a a DT 19613 8731 18 more more RBR 19613 8731 19 ardent ardent JJ 19613 8731 20 feeling feeling NN 19613 8731 21 of of IN 19613 8731 22 religious religious JJ 19613 8731 23 freedom freedom NN 19613 8731 24 as as RB 19613 8731 25 well well RB 19613 8731 26 as as IN 19613 8731 27 a a DT 19613 8731 28 deeper deep JJR 19613 8731 29 reverence reverence NN 19613 8731 30 for for IN 19613 8731 31 love love NN 19613 8731 32 and and CC 19613 8731 33 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8731 34 as as IN 19613 8731 35 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 8731 36 with with IN 19613 8731 37 lower low JJR 19613 8731 38 morality morality NN 19613 8731 39 . . . 19613 8731 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8732 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8732 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8732 3 659 659 CD 19613 8732 4 : : : 19613 8732 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8732 6 are be VBP 19613 8732 7 not not RB 19613 8732 8 able able JJ 19613 8732 9 to to TO 19613 8732 10 form form VB 19613 8732 11 a a DT 19613 8732 12 clear clear JJ 19613 8732 13 idea idea NN 19613 8732 14 of of IN 19613 8732 15 the the DT 19613 8732 16 school school NN 19613 8732 17 of of IN 19613 8732 18 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8732 19 . . . 19613 8733 1 In in IN 19613 8733 2 the the DT 19613 8733 3 year year NN 19613 8733 4 180 180 CD 19613 8733 5 the the DT 19613 8733 6 schools school NNS 19613 8733 7 of of IN 19613 8733 8 the the DT 19613 8733 9 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 8733 10 , , , 19613 8733 11 Carpocratians Carpocratians NNPS 19613 8733 12 , , , 19613 8733 13 Tatian tatian JJ 19613 8733 14 etc etc FW 19613 8733 15 . . . 19613 8734 1 were be VBD 19613 8734 2 all all DT 19613 8734 3 outside outside IN 19613 8734 4 the the DT 19613 8734 5 Church Church NNP 19613 8734 6 . . . 19613 8734 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8735 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8735 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8735 3 660 660 CD 19613 8735 4 : : : 19613 8735 5 On on IN 19613 8735 6 the the DT 19613 8735 7 school school NN 19613 8735 8 of of IN 19613 8735 9 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 8735 10 see see VBP 19613 8735 11 Assemani Assemani NNP 19613 8735 12 , , , 19613 8735 13 Bibl Bibl NNP 19613 8735 14 . . . 19613 8736 1 orient orient NNP 19613 8736 2 . . NNP 19613 8736 3 , , , 19613 8736 4 T. t. NN 19613 8737 1 III III NNP 19613 8737 2 . . NNP 19613 8737 3 , , , 19613 8737 4 P. P. NNP 19613 8738 1 II II NNP 19613 8738 2 . . NNP 19613 8738 3 , , , 19613 8738 4 p. p. NN 19613 8738 5 924 924 CD 19613 8738 6 ; ; : 19613 8738 7 Von Von NNP 19613 8738 8 Lengerke Lengerke NNP 19613 8738 9 , , , 19613 8738 10 De De NNP 19613 8738 11 Ephraemi Ephraemi NNP 19613 8738 12 arte arte NNP 19613 8738 13 hermen hermen NNP 19613 8738 14 . . NNP 19613 8738 15 , , , 19613 8738 16 p. p. NN 19613 8738 17 86 86 CD 19613 8738 18 sq sq NN 19613 8738 19 . . . 19613 8739 1 ; ; : 19613 8739 2 Kihn Kihn NNP 19613 8739 3 , , , 19613 8739 4 Die Die NNP 19613 8739 5 Bedeutung Bedeutung NNP 19613 8739 6 der der NN 19613 8739 7 antiochenischen antiochenischen RB 19613 8739 8 Schule Schule NNP 19613 8739 9 etc etc FW 19613 8739 10 . . . 19613 8739 11 , , , 19613 8739 12 pp pp NNP 19613 8739 13 . . . 19613 8740 1 32 32 CD 19613 8740 2 f. f. NNP 19613 8740 3 79 79 CD 19613 8740 4 f. f. NNP 19613 8740 5 , , , 19613 8740 6 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 8740 7 , , , 19613 8740 8 Tatian Tatian NNP 19613 8740 9 's 's POS 19613 8740 10 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 19613 8740 11 , , , 19613 8740 12 p. p. NN 19613 8740 13 54 54 CD 19613 8740 14 . . . 19613 8741 1 About about IN 19613 8741 2 the the DT 19613 8741 3 middle middle NN 19613 8741 4 of of IN 19613 8741 5 the the DT 19613 8741 6 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 8741 7 century century NN 19613 8741 8 Macarius Macarius NNP 19613 8741 9 , , , 19613 8741 10 of of IN 19613 8741 11 whom whom WP 19613 8741 12 Lucian lucian VBP 19613 8741 13 the the DT 19613 8741 14 Martyr Martyr NNP 19613 8741 15 was be VBD 19613 8741 16 a a DT 19613 8741 17 disciple disciple NN 19613 8741 18 , , , 19613 8741 19 taught teach VBN 19613 8741 20 at at IN 19613 8741 21 this this DT 19613 8741 22 school school NN 19613 8741 23 . . . 19613 8742 1 Special special JJ 19613 8742 2 attention attention NN 19613 8742 3 was be VBD 19613 8742 4 given give VBN 19613 8742 5 to to IN 19613 8742 6 the the DT 19613 8742 7 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8742 8 of of IN 19613 8742 9 the the DT 19613 8742 10 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8742 11 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8742 12 . . . 19613 8742 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8743 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8743 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8743 3 661 661 CD 19613 8743 4 : : : 19613 8743 5 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 8743 6 , , , 19613 8743 7 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8743 8 . . NNP 19613 8743 9 , , , 19613 8743 10 p. p. NN 19613 8743 11 455 455 CD 19613 8743 12 , , , 19613 8743 13 has have VBZ 19613 8743 14 very very RB 19613 8743 15 rightly rightly RB 19613 8743 16 remarked remark VBN 19613 8743 17 : : : 19613 8743 18 " " `` 19613 8743 19 The the DT 19613 8743 20 origin origin NN 19613 8743 21 of of IN 19613 8743 22 the the DT 19613 8743 23 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 8743 24 school school NN 19613 8743 25 of of IN 19613 8743 26 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8743 27 is be VBZ 19613 8743 28 not not RB 19613 8743 29 a a DT 19613 8743 30 portion portion NN 19613 8743 31 of of IN 19613 8743 32 the the DT 19613 8743 33 Church Church NNP 19613 8743 34 history history NN 19613 8743 35 of of IN 19613 8743 36 the the DT 19613 8743 37 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 8743 38 century century NN 19613 8743 39 , , , 19613 8743 40 that that WDT 19613 8743 41 has have VBZ 19613 8743 42 somehow somehow RB 19613 8743 43 been be VBN 19613 8743 44 left leave VBN 19613 8743 45 in in IN 19613 8743 46 the the DT 19613 8743 47 dark dark NN 19613 8743 48 by by IN 19613 8743 49 a a DT 19613 8743 50 mere mere JJ 19613 8743 51 accident accident NN 19613 8743 52 ; ; : 19613 8743 53 but but CC 19613 8743 54 a a DT 19613 8743 55 part part NN 19613 8743 56 of of IN 19613 8743 57 the the DT 19613 8743 58 well well RB 19613 8743 59 - - HYPH 19613 8743 60 defined define VBN 19613 8743 61 dark dark JJ 19613 8743 62 region region NN 19613 8743 63 on on IN 19613 8743 64 the the DT 19613 8743 65 map map NN 19613 8743 66 of of IN 19613 8743 67 the the DT 19613 8743 68 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8743 69 historian historian NN 19613 8743 70 of of IN 19613 8743 71 this this DT 19613 8743 72 period period NN 19613 8743 73 , , , 19613 8743 74 which which WDT 19613 8743 75 contains contain VBZ 19613 8743 76 the the DT 19613 8743 77 beginnings beginning NNS 19613 8743 78 of of IN 19613 8743 79 all all PDT 19613 8743 80 the the DT 19613 8743 81 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 8743 82 institutions institution NNS 19613 8743 83 of of IN 19613 8743 84 the the DT 19613 8743 85 Church Church NNP 19613 8743 86 as as RB 19613 8743 87 well well RB 19613 8743 88 as as IN 19613 8743 89 those those DT 19613 8743 90 of of IN 19613 8743 91 the the DT 19613 8743 92 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 19613 8743 93 school school NN 19613 8743 94 of of IN 19613 8743 95 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8743 96 , , , 19613 8743 97 a a DT 19613 8743 98 school school NN 19613 8743 99 which which WDT 19613 8743 100 was be VBD 19613 8743 101 the the DT 19613 8743 102 first first JJ 19613 8743 103 attempt attempt NN 19613 8743 104 to to TO 19613 8743 105 formulate formulate VB 19613 8743 106 the the DT 19613 8743 107 relationship relationship NN 19613 8743 108 of of IN 19613 8743 109 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8743 110 to to IN 19613 8743 111 secular secular JJ 19613 8743 112 science science NN 19613 8743 113 . . . 19613 8743 114 " " '' 19613 8744 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8744 2 are be VBP 19613 8744 3 , , , 19613 8744 4 moreover moreover RB 19613 8744 5 , , , 19613 8744 6 still still RB 19613 8744 7 in in IN 19613 8744 8 a a DT 19613 8744 9 state state NN 19613 8744 10 of of IN 19613 8744 11 complete complete JJ 19613 8744 12 uncertainty uncertainty NN 19613 8744 13 as as IN 19613 8744 14 to to IN 19613 8744 15 the the DT 19613 8744 16 personality personality NN 19613 8744 17 and and CC 19613 8744 18 teaching teaching NN 19613 8744 19 of of IN 19613 8744 20 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 19613 8744 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8744 22 with with IN 19613 8744 23 regard regard NN 19613 8744 24 to to IN 19613 8744 25 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8744 26 see see VBP 19613 8744 27 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 8744 28 , , , 19613 8744 29 " " `` 19613 8744 30 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 8744 31 " " '' 19613 8744 32 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8744 33 . . . 19613 8745 1 III III NNP 19613 8745 2 . . NNP 19613 8745 3 , , , 19613 8745 4 pp pp NNP 19613 8745 5 . . . 19613 8746 1 64 64 CD 19613 8746 2 ff ff NNS 19613 8746 3 . . . 19613 8747 1 77 77 CD 19613 8747 2 ff ff NNP 19613 8747 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8747 4 . . . 19613 8748 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8748 2 can can MD 19613 8748 3 form form VB 19613 8748 4 an an DT 19613 8748 5 idea idea NN 19613 8748 6 of of IN 19613 8748 7 the the DT 19613 8748 8 school school NN 19613 8748 9 of of IN 19613 8748 10 catechists catechist NNS 19613 8748 11 from from IN 19613 8748 12 the the DT 19613 8748 13 6th 6th JJ 19613 8748 14 Book Book NNP 19613 8748 15 of of IN 19613 8748 16 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 8748 17 ' ' POS 19613 8748 18 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 8748 19 History history NN 19613 8748 20 and and CC 19613 8748 21 from from IN 19613 8748 22 the the DT 19613 8748 23 works work NNS 19613 8748 24 of of IN 19613 8748 25 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8748 26 and and CC 19613 8748 27 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8748 28 . . . 19613 8748 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8749 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8749 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8749 3 662 662 CD 19613 8749 4 : : : 19613 8749 5 On on IN 19613 8749 6 the the DT 19613 8749 7 connection connection NN 19613 8749 8 of of IN 19613 8749 9 Julius Julius NNP 19613 8749 10 Africanus Africanus NNP 19613 8749 11 with with IN 19613 8749 12 this this DT 19613 8749 13 school school NN 19613 8749 14 see see VBP 19613 8749 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 8749 16 , , , 19613 8749 17 VI VI NNP 19613 8749 18 . . . 19613 8750 1 31 31 CD 19613 8750 2 . . . 19613 8751 1 As as IN 19613 8751 2 to to IN 19613 8751 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8751 4 relations relation NNS 19613 8751 5 with with IN 19613 8751 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8751 7 see see VBP 19613 8751 8 the the DT 19613 8751 9 correspondence correspondence NN 19613 8751 10 . . . 19613 8752 1 Julius Julius NNP 19613 8752 2 Africanus Africanus NNP 19613 8752 3 had have VBD 19613 8752 4 , , , 19613 8752 5 moreover moreover RB 19613 8752 6 , , , 19613 8752 7 relations relation NNS 19613 8752 8 with with IN 19613 8752 9 Edessa Edessa NNP 19613 8752 10 . . . 19613 8753 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8753 2 mentions mention VBZ 19613 8753 3 Clement clement NN 19613 8753 4 in in IN 19613 8753 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8753 6 chronicles chronicle NNS 19613 8753 7 . . . 19613 8754 1 On on IN 19613 8754 2 the the DT 19613 8754 3 connection connection NN 19613 8754 4 of of IN 19613 8754 5 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8754 6 and and CC 19613 8754 7 the the DT 19613 8754 8 Cappadocian cappadocian JJ 19613 8754 9 circle circle NN 19613 8754 10 with with IN 19613 8754 11 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 19613 8754 12 , , , 19613 8754 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8754 14 , , , 19613 8754 15 and and CC 19613 8754 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8754 17 , , , 19613 8754 18 see see VB 19613 8754 19 the the DT 19613 8754 20 6th 6th JJ 19613 8754 21 Book Book NNP 19613 8754 22 of of IN 19613 8754 23 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 8754 24 ' ' POS 19613 8754 25 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 19613 8754 26 History history NN 19613 8754 27 . . . 19613 8755 1 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8755 2 and and CC 19613 8755 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8755 4 were be VBD 19613 8755 5 disciples disciple NNS 19613 8755 6 of of IN 19613 8755 7 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 19613 8755 8 . . . 19613 8755 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8756 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8756 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8756 3 663 663 CD 19613 8756 4 : : : 19613 8756 5 See see VB 19613 8756 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8756 7 article article NN 19613 8756 8 " " `` 19613 8756 9 Heraklas Heraklas NNP 19613 8756 10 " " '' 19613 8756 11 in in IN 19613 8756 12 the the DT 19613 8756 13 Real Real NNP 19613 8756 14 - - HYPH 19613 8756 15 Encyklopadie Encyklopadie NNP 19613 8756 16 . . . 19613 8756 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8757 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8757 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8757 3 664 664 CD 19613 8757 4 : : : 19613 8757 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8757 6 have have VBP 19613 8757 7 the the DT 19613 8757 8 most most RBS 19613 8757 9 complete complete JJ 19613 8757 10 materials material NNS 19613 8757 11 in in IN 19613 8757 12 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 8757 13 , , , 19613 8757 14 " " `` 19613 8757 15 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 8757 16 " " '' 19613 8757 17 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8757 18 . . . 19613 8758 1 III iii CD 19613 8758 2 . . . 19613 8759 1 pp pp NNP 19613 8759 2 . . . 19613 8760 1 17 17 CD 19613 8760 2 - - SYM 19613 8760 3 176 176 CD 19613 8760 4 . . . 19613 8761 1 The the DT 19613 8761 2 best good JJS 19613 8761 3 estimate estimate NN 19613 8761 4 of of IN 19613 8761 5 the the DT 19613 8761 6 great great JJ 19613 8761 7 tripartite tripartite JJ 19613 8761 8 work work NN 19613 8761 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8761 10 Protrepticus Protrepticus NNP 19613 8761 11 , , , 19613 8761 12 Pædagogus Pædagogus NNP 19613 8761 13 , , , 19613 8761 14 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 8761 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8761 16 is be VBZ 19613 8761 17 found find VBN 19613 8761 18 in in IN 19613 8761 19 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 8761 20 , , , 19613 8761 21 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8761 22 . . . 19613 8762 1 The the DT 19613 8762 2 titles title NNS 19613 8762 3 of of IN 19613 8762 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8762 5 's 's POS 19613 8762 6 remaining remain VBG 19613 8762 7 works work NNS 19613 8762 8 , , , 19613 8762 9 which which WDT 19613 8762 10 are be VBP 19613 8762 11 lost lose VBN 19613 8762 12 to to IN 19613 8762 13 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8762 14 or or CC 19613 8762 15 only only RB 19613 8762 16 preserved preserve VBN 19613 8762 17 in in IN 19613 8762 18 fragments fragment NNS 19613 8762 19 , , , 19613 8762 20 show show VB 19613 8762 21 how how WRB 19613 8762 22 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 8762 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8762 24 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8762 25 labours labour NNS 19613 8762 26 were be VBD 19613 8762 27 . . . 19613 8762 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8763 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8763 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8763 3 665 665 CD 19613 8763 4 : : : 19613 8763 5 This this DT 19613 8763 6 applies apply VBZ 19613 8763 7 quite quite RB 19613 8763 8 as as RB 19613 8763 9 much much JJ 19613 8763 10 to to IN 19613 8763 11 the the DT 19613 8763 12 old old JJ 19613 8763 13 principles principle NNS 19613 8763 14 of of IN 19613 8763 15 Christian christian JJ 19613 8763 16 morality morality NN 19613 8763 17 as as IN 19613 8763 18 to to IN 19613 8763 19 the the DT 19613 8763 20 traditional traditional JJ 19613 8763 21 faith faith NN 19613 8763 22 . . . 19613 8764 1 With with IN 19613 8764 2 respect respect NN 19613 8764 3 to to IN 19613 8764 4 the the DT 19613 8764 5 first first JJ 19613 8764 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8764 7 may may MD 19613 8764 8 refer refer VB 19613 8764 9 to to IN 19613 8764 10 the the DT 19613 8764 11 treatise treatise NN 19613 8764 12 : : : 19613 8764 13 " " `` 19613 8764 14 Quis Quis NNP 19613 8764 15 dives dive VBZ 19613 8764 16 salvetur salvetur VBP 19613 8764 17 " " '' 19613 8764 18 , , , 19613 8764 19 and and CC 19613 8764 20 to to IN 19613 8764 21 the the DT 19613 8764 22 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 8764 23 and and CC 19613 8764 24 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 8764 25 Books Books NNPS 19613 8764 26 of of IN 19613 8764 27 the the DT 19613 8764 28 Pædagogus Pædagogus NNP 19613 8764 29 . . . 19613 8764 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8765 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8765 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8765 3 666 666 CD 19613 8765 4 : : : 19613 8765 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8765 6 was be VBD 19613 8765 7 also also RB 19613 8765 8 conscious conscious JJ 19613 8765 9 of of IN 19613 8765 10 the the DT 19613 8765 11 novelty novelty NN 19613 8765 12 of of IN 19613 8765 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8765 14 undertaking undertaking NN 19613 8765 15 ; ; : 19613 8765 16 see see VB 19613 8765 17 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 8765 18 , , , 19613 8765 19 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8765 20 . . NNP 19613 8765 21 , , , 19613 8765 22 p. p. NN 19613 8765 23 464 464 CD 19613 8765 24 f. f. NN 19613 8765 25 The the DT 19613 8765 26 respect respect NN 19613 8765 27 enjoyed enjoy VBN 19613 8765 28 by by IN 19613 8765 29 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8765 30 as as IN 19613 8765 31 a a DT 19613 8765 32 master master NN 19613 8765 33 is be VBZ 19613 8765 34 shown show VBN 19613 8765 35 by by IN 19613 8765 36 the the DT 19613 8765 37 letters letter NNS 19613 8765 38 of of IN 19613 8765 39 Alexander Alexander NNP 19613 8765 40 of of IN 19613 8765 41 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 19613 8765 42 . . . 19613 8766 1 See see VB 19613 8766 2 Euseb Euseb NNP 19613 8766 3 . . NNP 19613 8766 4 , , , 19613 8766 5 H. H. NNP 19613 8766 6 E. E. NNP 19613 8766 7 VI VI NNP 19613 8766 8 . . . 19613 8767 1 11 11 CD 19613 8767 2 and and CC 19613 8767 3 specially specially RB 19613 8767 4 VI VI NNP 19613 8767 5 . . . 19613 8768 1 14 14 CD 19613 8768 2 . . . 19613 8769 1 Here here RB 19613 8769 2 both both DT 19613 8769 3 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 19613 8769 4 and and CC 19613 8769 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8769 6 are be VBP 19613 8769 7 called call VBN 19613 8769 8 " " `` 19613 8769 9 Father Father NNP 19613 8769 10 " " '' 19613 8769 11 , , , 19613 8769 12 but but CC 19613 8769 13 whilst whilst IN 19613 8769 14 the the DT 19613 8769 15 former former JJ 19613 8769 16 receives receive VBZ 19613 8769 17 the the DT 19613 8769 18 title title NN 19613 8769 19 , , , 19613 8769 20 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8769 21 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8769 22 : : : 19613 8769 23 ho ho NNP 19613 8769 24 makarios makario VBZ 19613 8769 25 hôs hôs NNP 19613 8769 26 alêthôs alêthôs IN 19613 8769 27 kai kai NNP 19613 8769 28 kurios kurios NNP 19613 8769 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8769 30 , , , 19613 8769 31 the the DT 19613 8769 32 latter latter NN 19613 8769 33 is be VBZ 19613 8769 34 called call VBN 19613 8769 35 : : : 19613 8769 36 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8769 37 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8769 38 : : : 19613 8769 39 ho ho NNP 19613 8769 40 hieros hieros NNP 19613 8769 41 Klêmês Klêmês NNP 19613 8769 42 , , , 19613 8769 43 kurios kurio VBZ 19613 8769 44 mou mou NN 19613 8769 45 genomenos genomeno NNS 19613 8769 46 kai kai NNP 19613 8769 47 ôphelêsas ôphelêsas NN 19613 8769 48 me -PRON- PRP 19613 8769 49 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8769 50 . . . 19613 8769 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8770 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8770 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8770 3 667 667 CD 19613 8770 4 : : : 19613 8770 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8770 6 . . . 19613 8771 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8771 2 . . . 19613 8772 1 14 14 CD 19613 8772 2 , , , 19613 8772 3 109 109 CD 19613 8772 4 : : : 19613 8772 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8772 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8772 7 : : : 19613 8772 8 pleon pleon NNP 19613 8772 9 estin estin NNP 19613 8772 10 tou tou NNP 19613 8772 11 pisteusai pisteusai NNP 19613 8772 12 to to IN 19613 8772 13 gnônai gnônai NNP 19613 8772 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8772 15 , , , 19613 8772 16 Pistis Pistis NNP 19613 8772 17 is be VBZ 19613 8772 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8772 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8772 20 : : : 19613 8772 21 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 8772 22 suntomos suntomos NNP 19613 8772 23 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8772 24 katepeigontôn katepeigontôn NNP 19613 8772 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8772 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8772 27 VII VII NNP 19613 8772 28 . . . 19613 8773 1 10 10 CD 19613 8773 2 . . . 19613 8774 1 57 57 CD 19613 8774 2 , , , 19613 8774 3 see see VB 19613 8774 4 the the DT 19613 8774 5 whole whole JJ 19613 8774 6 chapter chapter NN 19613 8774 7 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8774 8 , , , 19613 8774 9 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8774 10 is be VBZ 19613 8774 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8774 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8774 13 : : : 19613 8774 14 apodeixis apodeixis NNP 19613 8774 15 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8774 16 dia dia NNP 19613 8774 17 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 8774 18 pareilêmmenôn pareilêmmenôn NNP 19613 8774 19 tê tê FW 19613 8774 20 pistei pistei NNP 19613 8774 21 epoikodomoumenê epoikodomoumenê NNP 19613 8774 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8774 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8774 24 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8774 25 . . . 19613 8775 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8775 2 , , , 19613 8775 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8775 4 Greek greek JJ 19613 8775 5 : : : 19613 8775 6 teleiôsis teleiôsis NN 19613 8775 7 anthrôpou anthrôpou NNP 19613 8775 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8775 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8775 10 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8775 11 . . . 19613 8776 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8776 2 , , , 19613 8776 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8776 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8776 5 : : : 19613 8776 6 pistis pistis NN 19613 8776 7 epistêmonikê epistêmonikê VBZ 19613 8776 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8776 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8776 10 II ii CD 19613 8776 11 . . . 19613 8777 1 II ii CD 19613 8777 2 . . . 19613 8778 1 48 48 CD 19613 8778 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8778 3 . . . 19613 8778 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8779 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8779 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8779 3 668 668 CD 19613 8779 4 : : : 19613 8779 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8779 6 have have VBP 19613 8779 7 here here RB 19613 8779 8 more more RBR 19613 8779 9 particularly particularly RB 19613 8779 10 to to TO 19613 8779 11 consider consider VB 19613 8779 12 those those DT 19613 8779 13 paragraphs paragraph NNS 19613 8779 14 of of IN 19613 8779 15 the the DT 19613 8779 16 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 8779 17 where where WRB 19613 8779 18 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8779 19 describes describe VBZ 19613 8779 20 the the DT 19613 8779 21 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8779 22 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8779 23 : : : 19613 8779 24 the the DT 19613 8779 25 latter latter JJ 19613 8779 26 elevates elevate VBZ 19613 8779 27 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8779 28 by by IN 19613 8779 29 dispassionate dispassionate NN 19613 8779 30 love love NN 19613 8779 31 to to IN 19613 8779 32 God God NNP 19613 8779 33 , , , 19613 8779 34 is be VBZ 19613 8779 35 raised raise VBN 19613 8779 36 above above IN 19613 8779 37 everything everything NN 19613 8779 38 earthly earthly RB 19613 8779 39 , , , 19613 8779 40 has have VBZ 19613 8779 41 rid rid VBN 19613 8779 42 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8779 43 of of IN 19613 8779 44 ignorance ignorance NN 19613 8779 45 , , , 19613 8779 46 the the DT 19613 8779 47 root root NN 19613 8779 48 of of IN 19613 8779 49 all all DT 19613 8779 50 evil evil NN 19613 8779 51 , , , 19613 8779 52 and and CC 19613 8779 53 already already RB 19613 8779 54 lives live VBZ 19613 8779 55 a a DT 19613 8779 56 life life NN 19613 8779 57 like like IN 19613 8779 58 that that DT 19613 8779 59 of of IN 19613 8779 60 the the DT 19613 8779 61 angels angel NNS 19613 8779 62 . . . 19613 8780 1 See see VB 19613 8780 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8780 3 . . . 19613 8781 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8781 2 . . . 19613 8782 1 9 9 CD 19613 8782 2 . . . 19613 8783 1 71 71 CD 19613 8783 2 , , , 19613 8783 3 72 72 CD 19613 8783 4 : : : 19613 8783 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8783 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8783 7 : : : 19613 8783 8 Oude oude NN 19613 8783 9 gar gar NN 19613 8783 10 endei endei FW 19613 8783 11 ti ti NNP 19613 8783 12 autô autô NNP 19613 8783 13 pros pros NNP 19613 8783 14 exomôiosin exomôiosin NNP 19613 8783 15 tô tô NNP 19613 8783 16 kalô kalô NNP 19613 8783 17 kai kai NNP 19613 8783 18 agathô agathô NNP 19613 8783 19 einai einai NNP 19613 8783 20 oude oude NNP 19613 8783 21 ara ara NNP 19613 8783 22 philei philei NNP 19613 8783 23 tina tina NNP 19613 8783 24 tên tên NNP 19613 8783 25 koinên koinên NNP 19613 8783 26 tautên tautên NNP 19613 8783 27 philian philian NNP 19613 8783 28 , , , 19613 8783 29 all all DT 19613 8783 30 ' ' `` 19613 8783 31 agapa agapa NNP 19613 8783 32 ton ton NNP 19613 8783 33 ktistên ktistên NNP 19613 8783 34 dia dia NNP 19613 8783 35 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8783 36 ktismatôn ktismatôn NNP 19613 8783 37 . . . 19613 8784 1 Out out IN 19613 8784 2 ' ' `` 19613 8784 3 oun oun NNP 19613 8784 4 epithumia epithumia NNP 19613 8784 5 kai kai NNP 19613 8784 6 orexei orexei NNP 19613 8784 7 tini tini NNP 19613 8784 8 peripiptei peripiptei NNP 19613 8784 9 oute oute NNP 19613 8784 10 endeês endeês NNP 19613 8784 11 esti esti NNP 19613 8784 12 kata kata NNP 19613 8784 13 ge ge NNP 19613 8784 14 tên tên NNP 19613 8784 15 psuchên psuchên NNP 19613 8784 16 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8784 17 allôn allôn NNP 19613 8784 18 tinos tinos NNP 19613 8784 19 sunôn sunôn NNP 19613 8784 20 êdê êdê NNP 19613 8784 21 di di NNP 19613 8784 22 ' ' '' 19613 8784 23 agapês agapês NNP 19613 8784 24 tô tô NNP 19613 8784 25 erastô erastô NNP 19613 8784 26 , , , 19613 8784 27 ô ô NNP 19613 8784 28 dê dê NNP 19613 8784 29 ôkeiôtai ôkeiôtai NNP 19613 8784 30 kata kata NNP 19613 8784 31 tên tên NNP 19613 8784 32 hairesin hairesin NNP 19613 8784 33 kai kai NNP 19613 8784 34 tê tê DT 19613 8784 35 ex ex NNP 19613 8784 36 askêseos askêseos NNP 19613 8784 37 hexei hexei NNP 19613 8784 38 , , , 19613 8784 39 toutô toutô NN 19613 8784 40 prosechesteron prosechesteron NN 19613 8784 41 sunengizôn sunengizôn NNP 19613 8784 42 , , , 19613 8784 43 makarios makario VBZ 19613 8784 44 ôn ôn NNP 19613 8784 45 dia dia NNP 19613 8784 46 tên tên NNP 19613 8784 47 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8784 48 agathôn agathôn NNP 19613 8784 49 periousian periousian NNP 19613 8784 50 , , , 19613 8784 51 ôste ôste VB 19613 8784 52 heneka heneka NNP 19613 8784 53 ge ge NNP 19613 8784 54 toutôn toutôn NNP 19613 8784 55 exomoiousthai exomoiousthai NNP 19613 8784 56 biazetai biazetai NNP 19613 8784 57 tô tô NNP 19613 8784 58 didaskalô didaskalô NNP 19613 8784 59 eis eis NNP 19613 8784 60 apatheian apatheian NNP 19613 8784 61 . . . 19613 8784 62 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8785 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8785 2 . . . 19613 8786 1 VII VII NNP 19613 8786 2 . . . 19613 8787 1 69 69 CD 19613 8787 2 - - SYM 19613 8787 3 83 83 CD 19613 8787 4 : : : 19613 8787 5 VI VI NNP 19613 8787 6 . . . 19613 8788 1 14 14 CD 19613 8788 2 , , , 19613 8788 3 113 113 CD 19613 8788 4 : : : 19613 8788 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8788 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8788 7 : : : 19613 8788 8 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 8788 9 dunamin dunamin NNP 19613 8788 10 labousa labousa NNP 19613 8788 11 kuriakên kuriakên NNP 19613 8788 12 hê hê NNP 19613 8788 13 psuchê psuchê NNP 19613 8788 14 meleta meleta NNP 19613 8788 15 einai einai NNP 19613 8788 16 Theos Theos NNP 19613 8788 17 , , , 19613 8788 18 kakon kakon NN 19613 8788 19 men man NNS 19613 8788 20 ouden ouden VBD 19613 8788 21 allo allo NNP 19613 8788 22 plên plên NNP 19613 8788 23 agnoias agnoias NNP 19613 8788 24 einai einai NNP 19613 8788 25 nomizousa nomizousa VBN 19613 8788 26 . . . 19613 8788 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8789 1 The the DT 19613 8789 2 whole whole JJ 19613 8789 3 7th 7th JJ 19613 8789 4 Book Book NNP 19613 8789 5 should should MD 19613 8789 6 be be VB 19613 8789 7 read read VBN 19613 8789 8 . . . 19613 8789 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8790 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8790 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8790 3 669 669 CD 19613 8790 4 : : : 19613 8790 5 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8790 6 is be VBZ 19613 8790 7 quoted quote VBN 19613 8790 8 by by IN 19613 8790 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8790 10 several several JJ 19613 8790 11 times time NNS 19613 8790 12 and and CC 19613 8790 13 still still RB 19613 8790 14 more more RBR 19613 8790 15 frequently frequently RB 19613 8790 16 made make VBN 19613 8790 17 use use NN 19613 8790 18 of of IN 19613 8790 19 without without IN 19613 8790 20 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 8790 21 . . . 19613 8791 1 See see VB 19613 8791 2 the the DT 19613 8791 3 copious copious JJ 19613 8791 4 citations citation NNS 19613 8791 5 in in IN 19613 8791 6 Siegfried Siegfried NNP 19613 8791 7 , , , 19613 8791 8 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8791 9 von von NNP 19613 8791 10 Alexandrien Alexandrien NNP 19613 8791 11 , , , 19613 8791 12 pp pp NNP 19613 8791 13 . . . 19613 8792 1 343 343 CD 19613 8792 2 - - SYM 19613 8792 3 351 351 CD 19613 8792 4 . . . 19613 8793 1 In in IN 19613 8793 2 addition addition NN 19613 8793 3 to to IN 19613 8793 4 this this DT 19613 8793 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8793 6 made make VBD 19613 8793 7 use use NN 19613 8793 8 of of IN 19613 8793 9 many many JJ 19613 8793 10 Greek greek JJ 19613 8793 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8793 12 or or CC 19613 8793 13 quoted quote VBD 19613 8793 14 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8793 15 without without IN 19613 8793 16 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 8793 17 , , , 19613 8793 18 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 8793 19 , , , 19613 8793 20 Musonius Musonius NNP 19613 8793 21 . . . 19613 8793 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8794 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8794 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8794 3 670 670 CD 19613 8794 4 : : : 19613 8794 5 Like like IN 19613 8794 6 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8794 7 and and CC 19613 8794 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 8794 9 , , , 19613 8794 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8794 11 also also RB 19613 8794 12 no no DT 19613 8794 13 doubt doubt NN 19613 8794 14 at at IN 19613 8794 15 times time NNS 19613 8794 16 asserts assert VBZ 19613 8794 17 that that IN 19613 8794 18 the the DT 19613 8794 19 Greek greek JJ 19613 8794 20 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8794 21 pilfered pilfer VBD 19613 8794 22 from from IN 19613 8794 23 the the DT 19613 8794 24 Old Old NNP 19613 8794 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 8794 26 ; ; : 19613 8794 27 but but CC 19613 8794 28 see see VB 19613 8794 29 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8794 30 . . . 19613 8795 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8796 1 5 5 CD 19613 8796 2 . . . 19613 8797 1 28 28 CD 19613 8797 2 sq sq NN 19613 8797 3 . . . 19613 8798 1 : : : 19613 8798 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8798 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8798 4 : : : 19613 8798 5 pantôn pantôn NN 19613 8798 6 men man NNS 19613 8798 7 aitios aitio VBZ 19613 8798 8 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8798 9 kalôn kalôn NNP 19613 8798 10 ho ho NNP 19613 8798 11 Theos Theos NNP 19613 8798 12 , , , 19613 8798 13 alla alla NN 19613 8798 14 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8798 15 men man NNS 19613 8798 16 kata kata VBP 19613 8798 17 proêgoumenon proêgoumenon NNP 19613 8798 18 hôs hôs NNP 19613 8798 19 tês tês NNP 19613 8798 20 te te NNP 19613 8798 21 diathêkês diathêkês NNP 19613 8798 22 tês tês NNP 19613 8798 23 palaias palaias NNP 19613 8798 24 kai kai NNP 19613 8798 25 tês tês NNP 19613 8798 26 neas neas NNP 19613 8798 27 , , , 19613 8798 28 tôn tôn NNP 19613 8798 29 de de NNP 19613 8798 30 kat kat NNP 19613 8798 31 ' ' POS 19613 8798 32 epakolouthêma epakolouthêma NNP 19613 8798 33 hôs hôs NNP 19613 8798 34 tês tês NNP 19613 8798 35 philosophias philosophia NNS 19613 8798 36 . . . 19613 8799 1 tacha tacha NNP 19613 8799 2 de de NNP 19613 8799 3 kai kai NNP 19613 8799 4 proêgoumenôs proêgoumenôs NNP 19613 8799 5 tois tois NNP 19613 8799 6 Hellêsin Hellêsin NNP 19613 8799 7 edothê edothê VBP 19613 8799 8 tote tote NNP 19613 8799 9 prin prin NNP 19613 8799 10 ê ê NNP 19613 8799 11 ton ton NNP 19613 8799 12 kyrion kyrion NN 19613 8799 13 kalesai kalesai NNP 19613 8799 14 kai kai NNP 19613 8799 15 tous tous JJ 19613 8799 16 Hellênas Hellênas NNP 19613 8799 17 . . . 19613 8800 1 epaidagôgei epaidagôgei NNP 19613 8800 2 gar gar NNP 19613 8800 3 kai kai NNP 19613 8800 4 autê autê NNP 19613 8800 5 to to IN 19613 8800 6 Hellênikon Hellênikon NNP 19613 8800 7 hôs hôs NNP 19613 8800 8 ho ho NNP 19613 8800 9 nomos nomos NNP 19613 8800 10 tous tous JJ 19613 8800 11 Hebraious Hebraious NNP 19613 8800 12 eis eis NNP 19613 8800 13 Christon Christon NNP 19613 8800 14 . . . 19613 8800 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8800 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8801 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8801 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8801 3 671 671 CD 19613 8801 4 : : : 19613 8801 5 See see VB 19613 8801 6 Bratke Bratke NNP 19613 8801 7 's 's POS 19613 8801 8 instructive instructive JJ 19613 8801 9 treatise treatise NN 19613 8801 10 cited cite VBN 19613 8801 11 above above RB 19613 8801 12 . . . 19613 8801 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8802 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8802 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8802 3 672 672 CD 19613 8802 4 : : : 19613 8802 5 The the DT 19613 8802 6 fact fact NN 19613 8802 7 that that IN 19613 8802 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8802 9 appeals appeal NNS 19613 8802 10 in in IN 19613 8802 11 support support NN 19613 8802 12 of of IN 19613 8802 13 the the DT 19613 8802 14 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8802 15 to to IN 19613 8802 16 an an DT 19613 8802 17 esoteric esoteric JJ 19613 8802 18 tradition tradition NN 19613 8802 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8802 20 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8802 21 . . . 19613 8803 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8803 2 . . . 19613 8804 1 7 7 LS 19613 8804 2 . . . 19613 8805 1 61 61 CD 19613 8805 2 : : : 19613 8805 3 VI VI NNP 19613 8805 4 . . . 19613 8806 1 8 8 LS 19613 8806 2 . . . 19613 8807 1 68 68 CD 19613 8807 2 : : : 19613 8807 3 VII VII NNP 19613 8807 4 . . . 19613 8808 1 10 10 CD 19613 8808 2 . . . 19613 8809 1 55 55 CD 19613 8809 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8809 3 proves prove VBZ 19613 8809 4 how how WRB 19613 8809 5 much much RB 19613 8809 6 this this DT 19613 8809 7 writer writer NN 19613 8809 8 , , , 19613 8809 9 belonging belong VBG 19613 8809 10 as as IN 19613 8809 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8809 12 did do VBD 19613 8809 13 to to IN 19613 8809 14 a a DT 19613 8809 15 sceptical sceptical JJ 19613 8809 16 age age NN 19613 8809 17 , , , 19613 8809 18 underestimated underestimate VBD 19613 8809 19 the the DT 19613 8809 20 efficacy efficacy NN 19613 8809 21 of of IN 19613 8809 22 all all DT 19613 8809 23 human human JJ 19613 8809 24 thought thought NN 19613 8809 25 in in IN 19613 8809 26 determining determine VBG 19613 8809 27 the the DT 19613 8809 28 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 8809 29 truth truth NN 19613 8809 30 of of IN 19613 8809 31 things thing NNS 19613 8809 32 . . . 19613 8810 1 The the DT 19613 8810 2 existence existence NN 19613 8810 3 of of IN 19613 8810 4 sacred sacred JJ 19613 8810 5 writings writing NNS 19613 8810 6 containing contain VBG 19613 8810 7 all all DT 19613 8810 8 truth truth NN 19613 8810 9 was be VBD 19613 8810 10 not not RB 19613 8810 11 even even RB 19613 8810 12 enough enough JJ 19613 8810 13 for for IN 19613 8810 14 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8810 15 ; ; : 19613 8810 16 the the DT 19613 8810 17 content content NN 19613 8810 18 of of IN 19613 8810 19 these these DT 19613 8810 20 writings writing NNS 19613 8810 21 had have VBD 19613 8810 22 also also RB 19613 8810 23 to to TO 19613 8810 24 be be VB 19613 8810 25 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 8810 26 by by IN 19613 8810 27 divine divine JJ 19613 8810 28 communication communication NN 19613 8810 29 . . . 19613 8811 1 But but CC 19613 8811 2 no no DT 19613 8811 3 doubt doubt RB 19613 8811 4 the the DT 19613 8811 5 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 8811 6 cause cause NN 19613 8811 7 of of IN 19613 8811 8 this this DT 19613 8811 9 , , , 19613 8811 10 as as IN 19613 8811 11 of of IN 19613 8811 12 all all DT 19613 8811 13 similar similar JJ 19613 8811 14 cases case NNS 19613 8811 15 of of IN 19613 8811 16 scepticism scepticism NN 19613 8811 17 , , , 19613 8811 18 was be VBD 19613 8811 19 the the DT 19613 8811 20 dim dim JJ 19613 8811 21 perception perception NN 19613 8811 22 that that IN 19613 8811 23 ethics ethic NNS 19613 8811 24 and and CC 19613 8811 25 religion religion NN 19613 8811 26 do do VBP 19613 8811 27 not not RB 19613 8811 28 at at RB 19613 8811 29 all all RB 19613 8811 30 come come VB 19613 8811 31 within within IN 19613 8811 32 the the DT 19613 8811 33 sphere sphere NN 19613 8811 34 of of IN 19613 8811 35 the the DT 19613 8811 36 intellectual intellectual NN 19613 8811 37 , , , 19613 8811 38 and and CC 19613 8811 39 that that IN 19613 8811 40 the the DT 19613 8811 41 intellect intellect NN 19613 8811 42 can can MD 19613 8811 43 produce produce VB 19613 8811 44 nothing nothing NN 19613 8811 45 of of IN 19613 8811 46 religious religious JJ 19613 8811 47 value value NN 19613 8811 48 . . . 19613 8812 1 As as IN 19613 8812 2 , , , 19613 8812 3 however however RB 19613 8812 4 , , , 19613 8812 5 in in IN 19613 8812 6 consequence consequence NN 19613 8812 7 of of IN 19613 8812 8 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8812 9 tradition tradition NN 19613 8812 10 , , , 19613 8812 11 neither neither CC 19613 8812 12 Philo Philo NNP 19613 8812 13 , , , 19613 8812 14 nor nor CC 19613 8812 15 the the DT 19613 8812 16 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 8812 17 , , , 19613 8812 18 nor nor CC 19613 8812 19 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8812 20 , , , 19613 8812 21 nor nor CC 19613 8812 22 the the DT 19613 8812 23 Neoplatonists Neoplatonists NNPS 19613 8812 24 were be VBD 19613 8812 25 able able JJ 19613 8812 26 to to TO 19613 8812 27 shake shake VB 19613 8812 28 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8812 29 free free JJ 19613 8812 30 from from IN 19613 8812 31 the the DT 19613 8812 32 intellectual intellectual JJ 19613 8812 33 _ _ NNP 19613 8812 34 scheme scheme NN 19613 8812 35 _ _ NNP 19613 8812 36 , , , 19613 8812 37 those those DT 19613 8812 38 things thing NNS 19613 8812 39 which which WDT 19613 8812 40 -- -- : 19613 8812 41 as as IN 19613 8812 42 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8812 43 instinctively instinctively RB 19613 8812 44 felt feel VBD 19613 8812 45 , , , 19613 8812 46 but but CC 19613 8812 47 did do VBD 19613 8812 48 not not RB 19613 8812 49 recognise recognise VB 19613 8812 50 -- -- : 19613 8812 51 could could MD 19613 8812 52 really really RB 19613 8812 53 not not RB 19613 8812 54 be be VB 19613 8812 55 ascertained ascertain VBN 19613 8812 56 by by IN 19613 8812 57 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8812 58 at at RB 19613 8812 59 all all RB 19613 8812 60 received receive VBN 19613 8812 61 from from IN 19613 8812 62 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8812 63 the the DT 19613 8812 64 name name NN 19613 8812 65 of of IN 19613 8812 66 _ _ NNP 19613 8812 67 suprarational suprarational JJ 19613 8812 68 _ _ NNP 19613 8812 69 and and CC 19613 8812 70 were be VBD 19613 8812 71 traced trace VBN 19613 8812 72 to to TO 19613 8812 73 divine divine JJ 19613 8812 74 revelation revelation NN 19613 8812 75 . . . 19613 8813 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8813 2 may may MD 19613 8813 3 say say VB 19613 8813 4 that that IN 19613 8813 5 the the DT 19613 8813 6 extinction extinction NN 19613 8813 7 or or CC 19613 8813 8 pernicious pernicious JJ 19613 8813 9 extravagancies extravagancy NNS 19613 8813 10 to to TO 19613 8813 11 which which WDT 19613 8813 12 Greek greek JJ 19613 8813 13 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8813 14 was be VBD 19613 8813 15 subjected subject VBN 19613 8813 16 in in IN 19613 8813 17 Neoplatonism Neoplatonism NNP 19613 8813 18 , , , 19613 8813 19 and and CC 19613 8813 20 the the DT 19613 8813 21 absurdities absurdity NNS 19613 8813 22 into into IN 19613 8813 23 which which WDT 19613 8813 24 the the DT 19613 8813 25 Christian christian JJ 19613 8813 26 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8813 27 was be VBD 19613 8813 28 led lead VBN 19613 8813 29 , , , 19613 8813 30 arose arise VBD 19613 8813 31 from from IN 19613 8813 32 the the DT 19613 8813 33 fact fact NN 19613 8813 34 that that IN 19613 8813 35 the the DT 19613 8813 36 tradition tradition NN 19613 8813 37 of of IN 19613 8813 38 placing place VBG 19613 8813 39 the the DT 19613 8813 40 ethical ethical JJ 19613 8813 41 and and CC 19613 8813 42 religious religious JJ 19613 8813 43 feelings feeling NNS 19613 8813 44 and and CC 19613 8813 45 the the DT 19613 8813 46 development development NN 19613 8813 47 of of IN 19613 8813 48 character character NN 19613 8813 49 within within IN 19613 8813 50 the the DT 19613 8813 51 sphere sphere NN 19613 8813 52 of of IN 19613 8813 53 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8813 54 , , , 19613 8813 55 as as IN 19613 8813 56 had have VBD 19613 8813 57 been be VBN 19613 8813 58 the the DT 19613 8813 59 case case NN 19613 8813 60 for for IN 19613 8813 61 nearly nearly RB 19613 8813 62 a a DT 19613 8813 63 thousand thousand CD 19613 8813 64 years year NNS 19613 8813 65 , , , 19613 8813 66 could could MD 19613 8813 67 not not RB 19613 8813 68 be be VB 19613 8813 69 got get VBN 19613 8813 70 rid rid VBN 19613 8813 71 of of IN 19613 8813 72 , , , 19613 8813 73 though though IN 19613 8813 74 the the DT 19613 8813 75 incongruity incongruity NN 19613 8813 76 was be VBD 19613 8813 77 no no RB 19613 8813 78 doubt doubt RB 19613 8813 79 felt feel VBN 19613 8813 80 . . . 19613 8814 1 Contempt contempt NN 19613 8814 2 for for IN 19613 8814 3 empiricism empiricism NN 19613 8814 4 , , , 19613 8814 5 scepticism scepticism NN 19613 8814 6 , , , 19613 8814 7 the the DT 19613 8814 8 extravagancies extravagancy NNS 19613 8814 9 of of IN 19613 8814 10 religious religious JJ 19613 8814 11 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 19613 8814 12 which which WDT 19613 8814 13 finally finally RB 19613 8814 14 become become VBP 19613 8814 15 mythology mythology NN 19613 8814 16 , , , 19613 8814 17 have have VBP 19613 8814 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8814 19 origin origin NN 19613 8814 20 here here RB 19613 8814 21 . . . 19613 8815 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8815 2 still still RB 19613 8815 3 continues continue VBZ 19613 8815 4 to to TO 19613 8815 5 be be VB 19613 8815 6 viewed view VBN 19613 8815 7 as as IN 19613 8815 8 the the DT 19613 8815 9 highest high JJS 19613 8815 10 possession possession NN 19613 8815 11 ; ; : 19613 8815 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8815 13 is be VBZ 19613 8815 14 , , , 19613 8815 15 however however RB 19613 8815 16 , , , 19613 8815 17 no no DT 19613 8815 18 longer long JJR 19613 8815 19 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8815 20 , , , 19613 8815 21 but but CC 19613 8815 22 character character NN 19613 8815 23 and and CC 19613 8815 24 feeling feeling NN 19613 8815 25 ; ; : 19613 8815 26 and and CC 19613 8815 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8815 28 must must MD 19613 8815 29 be be VB 19613 8815 30 nourished nourish VBN 19613 8815 31 by by IN 19613 8815 32 the the DT 19613 8815 33 fancy fancy NN 19613 8815 34 in in IN 19613 8815 35 order order NN 19613 8815 36 to to TO 19613 8815 37 be be VB 19613 8815 38 able able JJ 19613 8815 39 to to TO 19613 8815 40 assert assert VB 19613 8815 41 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8815 42 as as IN 19613 8815 43 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8815 44 . . . 19613 8815 45 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8816 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8816 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8816 3 673 673 CD 19613 8816 4 : : : 19613 8816 5 Clement clement NN 19613 8816 6 was be VBD 19613 8816 7 not not RB 19613 8816 8 a a DT 19613 8816 9 Neoplatonic neoplatonic JJ 19613 8816 10 mystic mystic NN 19613 8816 11 in in IN 19613 8816 12 the the DT 19613 8816 13 strict strict JJ 19613 8816 14 sense sense NN 19613 8816 15 of of IN 19613 8816 16 the the DT 19613 8816 17 word word NN 19613 8816 18 . . . 19613 8817 1 When when WRB 19613 8817 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8817 3 describes describe VBZ 19613 8817 4 the the DT 19613 8817 5 highest high JJS 19613 8817 6 ethical ethical JJ 19613 8817 7 ideal ideal NN 19613 8817 8 , , , 19613 8817 9 ecstasy ecstasy NN 19613 8817 10 is be VBZ 19613 8817 11 wanting want VBG 19613 8817 12 ; ; : 19613 8817 13 and and CC 19613 8817 14 the the DT 19613 8817 15 freshness freshness NN 19613 8817 16 with with IN 19613 8817 17 which which WDT 19613 8817 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8817 19 describes describe VBZ 19613 8817 20 Quietism Quietism NNP 19613 8817 21 shows show VBZ 19613 8817 22 that that IN 19613 8817 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8817 24 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8817 25 was be VBD 19613 8817 26 no no UH 19613 8817 27 Quietist quietist NN 19613 8817 28 . . . 19613 8818 1 See see VB 19613 8818 2 on on IN 19613 8818 3 this this DT 19613 8818 4 point point NN 19613 8818 5 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 8818 6 's 's POS 19613 8818 7 third third JJ 19613 8818 8 lecture lecture NN 19613 8818 9 , , , 19613 8818 10 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8818 11 . . NNP 19613 8818 12 , , , 19613 8818 13 particularly particularly RB 19613 8818 14 p. p. NN 19613 8818 15 98 98 CD 19613 8818 16 f. f. NNS 19613 8818 17 " " '' 19613 8818 18 ... ... . 19613 8819 1 The the DT 19613 8819 2 silent silent JJ 19613 8819 3 prayer prayer NN 19613 8819 4 of of IN 19613 8819 5 the the DT 19613 8819 6 Quietist Quietist NNP 19613 8819 7 is be VBZ 19613 8819 8 in in IN 19613 8819 9 fact fact NN 19613 8819 10 ecstasy ecstasy NN 19613 8819 11 , , , 19613 8819 12 of of IN 19613 8819 13 which which WDT 19613 8819 14 there there EX 19613 8819 15 is be VBZ 19613 8819 16 not not RB 19613 8819 17 a a DT 19613 8819 18 trace trace NN 19613 8819 19 in in IN 19613 8819 20 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8819 21 . . . 19613 8820 1 For for IN 19613 8820 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8820 3 shrank shrink VBD 19613 8820 4 from from IN 19613 8820 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8820 6 own own JJ 19613 8820 7 conclusions conclusion NNS 19613 8820 8 . . . 19613 8821 1 Though though IN 19613 8821 2 the the DT 19613 8821 3 father father NN 19613 8821 4 of of IN 19613 8821 5 all all PDT 19613 8821 6 the the DT 19613 8821 7 Mystics Mystics NNPS 19613 8821 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8821 9 is be VBZ 19613 8821 10 no no DT 19613 8821 11 Mystic Mystic NNP 19613 8821 12 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8821 13 . . . 19613 8822 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8822 2 did do VBD 19613 8822 3 not not RB 19613 8822 4 enter enter VB 19613 8822 5 the the DT 19613 8822 6 ' ' `` 19613 8822 7 enchanted enchant VBN 19613 8822 8 garden garden NN 19613 8822 9 , , , 19613 8822 10 ' ' '' 19613 8822 11 which which WDT 19613 8822 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8822 13 opened open VBD 19613 8822 14 for for IN 19613 8822 15 others other NNS 19613 8822 16 . . . 19613 8823 1 If if IN 19613 8823 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8823 3 talks talk VBZ 19613 8823 4 of of IN 19613 8823 5 ' ' `` 19613 8823 6 flaying flay VBG 19613 8823 7 the the DT 19613 8823 8 sacrifice sacrifice NN 19613 8823 9 , , , 19613 8823 10 ' ' '' 19613 8823 11 of of IN 19613 8823 12 leaving leave VBG 19613 8823 13 sense sense NN 19613 8823 14 behind behind RB 19613 8823 15 , , , 19613 8823 16 of of IN 19613 8823 17 Epopteia Epopteia NNP 19613 8823 18 , , , 19613 8823 19 this this DT 19613 8823 20 is be VBZ 19613 8823 21 but but CC 19613 8823 22 the the DT 19613 8823 23 parlance parlance NN 19613 8823 24 of of IN 19613 8823 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8823 26 school school NN 19613 8823 27 . . . 19613 8824 1 The the DT 19613 8824 2 instrument instrument NN 19613 8824 3 to to TO 19613 8824 4 which which WDT 19613 8824 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8824 6 looks look VBZ 19613 8824 7 for for IN 19613 8824 8 growth growth NN 19613 8824 9 in in IN 19613 8824 10 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8824 11 is be VBZ 19613 8824 12 not not RB 19613 8824 13 trance trance NN 19613 8824 14 , , , 19613 8824 15 but but CC 19613 8824 16 disciplined discipline VBD 19613 8824 17 reason reason NN 19613 8824 18 . . . 19613 8825 1 Hence hence RB 19613 8825 2 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 8825 3 , , , 19613 8825 4 when when WRB 19613 8825 5 once once RB 19613 8825 6 obtained obtain VBN 19613 8825 7 , , , 19613 8825 8 is be VBZ 19613 8825 9 indefectible indefectible JJ 19613 8825 10 , , , 19613 8825 11 not not RB 19613 8825 12 like like IN 19613 8825 13 the the DT 19613 8825 14 rapture rapture NN 19613 8825 15 which which WDT 19613 8825 16 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 19613 8825 17 enjoyed enjoy VBD 19613 8825 18 but but CC 19613 8825 19 four four CD 19613 8825 20 times time NNS 19613 8825 21 during during IN 19613 8825 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8825 23 acquaintance acquaintance NN 19613 8825 24 with with IN 19613 8825 25 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 8825 26 , , , 19613 8825 27 which which WDT 19613 8825 28 in in IN 19613 8825 29 the the DT 19613 8825 30 experience experience NN 19613 8825 31 of of IN 19613 8825 32 Theresa Theresa NNP 19613 8825 33 never never RB 19613 8825 34 lasted last VBD 19613 8825 35 more more JJR 19613 8825 36 than than IN 19613 8825 37 half half PDT 19613 8825 38 an an DT 19613 8825 39 hour hour NN 19613 8825 40 . . . 19613 8826 1 The the DT 19613 8826 2 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8826 3 is be VBZ 19613 8826 4 no no DT 19613 8826 5 Visionary Visionary NNP 19613 8826 6 , , , 19613 8826 7 no no DT 19613 8826 8 Theurgist Theurgist NNP 19613 8826 9 , , , 19613 8826 10 no no DT 19613 8826 11 Antinomian Antinomian NNP 19613 8826 12 . . . 19613 8826 13 " " '' 19613 8826 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8827 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8827 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8827 3 674 674 CD 19613 8827 4 : : : 19613 8827 5 What what WDT 19613 8827 6 a a DT 19613 8827 7 bold bold JJ 19613 8827 8 and and CC 19613 8827 9 joyous joyous JJ 19613 8827 10 thinker thinker NN 19613 8827 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8827 12 was be VBD 19613 8827 13 is be VBZ 19613 8827 14 shown show VBN 19613 8827 15 by by IN 19613 8827 16 the the DT 19613 8827 17 almost almost RB 19613 8827 18 audacious audacious JJ 19613 8827 19 remark remark NN 19613 8827 20 in in IN 19613 8827 21 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8827 22 . . . 19613 8828 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8828 2 . . . 19613 8829 1 22 22 CD 19613 8829 2 . . . 19613 8830 1 136 136 CD 19613 8830 2 : : : 19613 8830 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8830 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8830 5 : : : 19613 8830 6 ei ei UH 19613 8830 7 goun goun NNP 19613 8830 8 tis tis NNP 19613 8830 9 kath kath NNP 19613 8830 10 ' ' POS 19613 8830 11 hypothesin hypothesin NNP 19613 8830 12 protheiê protheiê NN 19613 8830 13 tô tô NNP 19613 8830 14 gnôstikô gnôstikô NNP 19613 8830 15 poteron poteron NN 19613 8830 16 helesthai helesthai NNP 19613 8830 17 bouloito bouloito NNP 19613 8830 18 tên tên NNP 19613 8830 19 gnôsin gnôsin NNP 19613 8830 20 tou tou NNP 19613 8830 21 Theou Theou NNP 19613 8830 22 ê ê NNP 19613 8830 23 tên tên NNP 19613 8830 24 sôtêrian sôtêrian NNP 19613 8830 25 tên tên NNP 19613 8830 26 aiônian aiônian NNP 19613 8830 27 , , , 19613 8830 28 ein ein NNP 19613 8830 29 de de FW 19613 8830 30 tauta tauta NNP 19613 8830 31 kechôrismena kechôrismena NNP 19613 8830 32 pantos pantos NNP 19613 8830 33 mallon mallon NNP 19613 8830 34 en en NNP 19613 8830 35 tautotête tautotête NNP 19613 8830 36 onta onta NNP 19613 8830 37 , , , 19613 8830 38 oude oude NN 19613 8830 39 kath kath NNP 19613 8830 40 ' ' POS 19613 8830 41 otioun otioun NNP 19613 8830 42 distasas distasas NNP 19613 8830 43 heloit heloit NNP 19613 8830 44 an an DT 19613 8830 45 tên tên NNP 19613 8830 46 gnôsin gnôsin NNP 19613 8830 47 tou tou NNP 19613 8830 48 Theou Theou NNP 19613 8830 49 . . . 19613 8830 50 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8830 51 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8831 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8831 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8831 3 675 675 CD 19613 8831 4 : : : 19613 8831 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8831 6 . . . 19613 8832 1 VII VII NNP 19613 8832 2 . . . 19613 8833 1 1 1 LS 19613 8833 2 . . . 19613 8834 1 1 1 LS 19613 8834 2 . . . 19613 8835 1 In in IN 19613 8835 2 several several JJ 19613 8835 3 passages passage NNS 19613 8835 4 of of IN 19613 8835 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8835 6 main main JJ 19613 8835 7 work work NN 19613 8835 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8835 9 refers refer VBZ 19613 8835 10 to to IN 19613 8835 11 those those DT 19613 8835 12 churchmen churchman NNS 19613 8835 13 who who WP 19613 8835 14 viewed view VBD 19613 8835 15 the the DT 19613 8835 16 practical practical JJ 19613 8835 17 and and CC 19613 8835 18 speculative speculative JJ 19613 8835 19 concentration concentration NN 19613 8835 20 of of IN 19613 8835 21 Church Church NNP 19613 8835 22 tradition tradition NN 19613 8835 23 as as IN 19613 8835 24 dangerous dangerous JJ 19613 8835 25 and and CC 19613 8835 26 questioned question VBD 19613 8835 27 the the DT 19613 8835 28 use use NN 19613 8835 29 of of IN 19613 8835 30 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8835 31 at at RB 19613 8835 32 all all RB 19613 8835 33 . . . 19613 8836 1 See see VB 19613 8836 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8836 3 . . . 19613 8837 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8837 2 . . . 19613 8838 1 10 10 CD 19613 8838 2 . . . 19613 8839 1 80 80 CD 19613 8839 2 : : : 19613 8839 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8839 4 Greek greek JJ 19613 8839 5 : : : 19613 8839 6 polloi polloi NN 19613 8839 7 kathaper kathaper NNP 19613 8839 8 hoi hoi NNP 19613 8839 9 paides paide VBZ 19613 8839 10 ta ta NNP 19613 8839 11 mormolukeia mormolukeia NNP 19613 8839 12 , , , 19613 8839 13 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 8839 14 dediasi dediasi NNP 19613 8839 15 tên tên NNP 19613 8839 16 hellênikên hellênikên NNP 19613 8839 17 philosophian philosophian NNP 19613 8839 18 , , , 19613 8839 19 phoboumenoi phoboumenoi NNP 19613 8839 20 mê mê NNP 19613 8839 21 apagagê apagagê NNP 19613 8839 22 autous autous JJ 19613 8839 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8839 24 . . . 19613 8840 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8840 2 . . . 19613 8841 1 11 11 CD 19613 8841 2 . . . 19613 8842 1 93 93 CD 19613 8842 2 . . . 19613 8842 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8843 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8843 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8843 3 676 676 CD 19613 8843 4 : : : 19613 8843 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 19613 8843 6 , , , 19613 8843 7 H. H. NNP 19613 8843 8 E. E. NNP 19613 8843 9 VI VI NNP 19613 8843 10 . . . 19613 8844 1 14 14 CD 19613 8844 2 . . . 19613 8845 1 8 8 CD 19613 8845 2 , , , 19613 8845 3 tells tell VBZ 19613 8845 4 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8845 5 that that IN 19613 8845 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8845 7 was be VBD 19613 8845 8 a a DT 19613 8845 9 disciple disciple NN 19613 8845 10 of of IN 19613 8845 11 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8845 12 . . . 19613 8845 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8846 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8846 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8846 3 677 677 CD 19613 8846 4 : : : 19613 8846 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8846 6 's 's POS 19613 8846 7 authority authority NN 19613 8846 8 in in IN 19613 8846 9 the the DT 19613 8846 10 Church Church NNP 19613 8846 11 continued continue VBD 19613 8846 12 much much RB 19613 8846 13 longer long RBR 19613 8846 14 than than IN 19613 8846 15 that that DT 19613 8846 16 of of IN 19613 8846 17 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8846 18 . . . 19613 8847 1 See see VB 19613 8847 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 8847 3 , , , 19613 8847 4 " " `` 19613 8847 5 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 8847 6 " " '' 19613 8847 7 III III NNP 19613 8847 8 . . . 19613 8848 1 p. p. NN 19613 8848 2 140 140 CD 19613 8848 3 f. f. NN 19613 8848 4 The the DT 19613 8848 5 heterodox heterodox JJ 19613 8848 6 opinions opinion NNS 19613 8848 7 advanced advance VBN 19613 8848 8 by by IN 19613 8848 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8848 10 in in IN 19613 8848 11 the the DT 19613 8848 12 Hypotyposes hypotypose NNS 19613 8848 13 are be VBP 19613 8848 14 for for IN 19613 8848 15 the the DT 19613 8848 16 most most JJS 19613 8848 17 part part NN 19613 8848 18 only only RB 19613 8848 19 known know VBN 19613 8848 20 to to IN 19613 8848 21 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8848 22 in in IN 19613 8848 23 an an DT 19613 8848 24 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 19613 8848 25 form form NN 19613 8848 26 from from IN 19613 8848 27 the the DT 19613 8848 28 report report NN 19613 8848 29 of of IN 19613 8848 30 Photius Photius NNP 19613 8848 31 . . . 19613 8848 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8849 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8849 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8849 3 678 678 CD 19613 8849 4 : : : 19613 8849 5 In in IN 19613 8849 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 8849 7 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 8849 8 all all DT 19613 8849 9 systematising systematising JJ 19613 8849 10 was be VBD 19613 8849 11 merely merely RB 19613 8849 12 relative relative JJ 19613 8849 13 and and CC 19613 8849 14 limited limited JJ 19613 8849 15 , , , 19613 8849 16 because because IN 19613 8849 17 the the DT 19613 8849 18 complex complex NN 19613 8849 19 of of IN 19613 8849 20 sacred sacred JJ 19613 8849 21 writings writing NNS 19613 8849 22 enjoyed enjoy VBD 19613 8849 23 a a DT 19613 8849 24 different different JJ 19613 8849 25 authority authority NN 19613 8849 26 from from IN 19613 8849 27 that that DT 19613 8849 28 which which WDT 19613 8849 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8849 30 possessed possess VBD 19613 8849 31 in in IN 19613 8849 32 the the DT 19613 8849 33 following following JJ 19613 8849 34 period period NN 19613 8849 35 . . . 19613 8850 1 Here here RB 19613 8850 2 the the DT 19613 8850 3 reference reference NN 19613 8850 4 of of IN 19613 8850 5 a a DT 19613 8850 6 theologoumenon theologoumenon NN 19613 8850 7 to to IN 19613 8850 8 a a DT 19613 8850 9 passage passage NN 19613 8850 10 of of IN 19613 8850 11 Scripture scripture NN 19613 8850 12 was be VBD 19613 8850 13 of of IN 19613 8850 14 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 8850 15 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 8850 16 , , , 19613 8850 17 and and CC 19613 8850 18 the the DT 19613 8850 19 manifold manifold JJ 19613 8850 20 and and CC 19613 8850 21 incongruous incongruous JJ 19613 8850 22 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 8850 23 were be VBD 19613 8850 24 felt feel VBN 19613 8850 25 as as IN 19613 8850 26 a a DT 19613 8850 27 unity unity NN 19613 8850 28 in in IN 19613 8850 29 so so RB 19613 8850 30 far far RB 19613 8850 31 as as IN 19613 8850 32 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8850 33 could could MD 19613 8850 34 all all RB 19613 8850 35 be be VB 19613 8850 36 verified verify VBN 19613 8850 37 from from IN 19613 8850 38 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8850 39 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8850 40 . . . 19613 8851 1 Thus thus RB 19613 8851 2 the the DT 19613 8851 3 fact fact NN 19613 8851 4 that that IN 19613 8851 5 the the DT 19613 8851 6 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8851 7 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8851 8 were be VBD 19613 8851 9 regarded regard VBN 19613 8851 10 as as IN 19613 8851 11 a a DT 19613 8851 12 series series NN 19613 8851 13 of of IN 19613 8851 14 divine divine JJ 19613 8851 15 oracles oracle NNS 19613 8851 16 guaranteed guarantee VBN 19613 8851 17 , , , 19613 8851 18 as as IN 19613 8851 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8851 20 were be VBD 19613 8851 21 , , , 19613 8851 22 a a DT 19613 8851 23 transcendental transcendental JJ 19613 8851 24 unity unity NN 19613 8851 25 of of IN 19613 8851 26 the the DT 19613 8851 27 doctrines doctrine NNS 19613 8851 28 , , , 19613 8851 29 and and CC 19613 8851 30 , , , 19613 8851 31 in in IN 19613 8851 32 certain certain JJ 19613 8851 33 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 8851 34 , , , 19613 8851 35 relieved relieve VBD 19613 8851 36 the the DT 19613 8851 37 framer framer NN 19613 8851 38 of of IN 19613 8851 39 the the DT 19613 8851 40 system system NN 19613 8851 41 of of IN 19613 8851 42 a a DT 19613 8851 43 great great JJ 19613 8851 44 part part NN 19613 8851 45 of of IN 19613 8851 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8851 47 task task NN 19613 8851 48 . . . 19613 8852 1 Hitherto hitherto JJ 19613 8852 2 little little JJ 19613 8852 3 justice justice NN 19613 8852 4 has have VBZ 19613 8852 5 been be VBN 19613 8852 6 done do VBN 19613 8852 7 to to IN 19613 8852 8 this this DT 19613 8852 9 view view NN 19613 8852 10 of of IN 19613 8852 11 the the DT 19613 8852 12 history history NN 19613 8852 13 of of IN 19613 8852 14 dogma dogma NN 19613 8852 15 , , , 19613 8852 16 though though IN 19613 8852 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8852 18 is be VBZ 19613 8852 19 the the DT 19613 8852 20 only only JJ 19613 8852 21 solution solution NN 19613 8852 22 of of IN 19613 8852 23 a a DT 19613 8852 24 series series NN 19613 8852 25 of of IN 19613 8852 26 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 8852 27 insoluble insoluble JJ 19613 8852 28 problems problem NNS 19613 8852 29 . . . 19613 8853 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8853 2 can can MD 19613 8853 3 not not RB 19613 8853 4 for for IN 19613 8853 5 example example NN 19613 8853 6 understand understand VBP 19613 8853 7 the the DT 19613 8853 8 theology theology NN 19613 8853 9 of of IN 19613 8853 10 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 8853 11 , , , 19613 8853 12 and and CC 19613 8853 13 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 8853 14 create create VB 19613 8853 15 for for IN 19613 8853 16 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8853 17 the the DT 19613 8853 18 most most RBS 19613 8853 19 difficult difficult JJ 19613 8853 20 problems problem NNS 19613 8853 21 by by IN 19613 8853 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8853 23 own own JJ 19613 8853 24 fault fault NN 19613 8853 25 , , , 19613 8853 26 if if IN 19613 8853 27 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8853 28 make make VBP 19613 8853 29 no no DT 19613 8853 30 use use NN 19613 8853 31 of of IN 19613 8853 32 that that DT 19613 8853 33 theory theory NN 19613 8853 34 . . . 19613 8854 1 In in IN 19613 8854 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8854 3 's 's POS 19613 8854 4 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8854 5 and and CC 19613 8854 6 that that DT 19613 8854 7 of of IN 19613 8854 8 subsequent subsequent JJ 19613 8854 9 Church Church NNP 19613 8854 10 Fathers father NNS 19613 8854 11 -- -- : 19613 8854 12 so so RB 19613 8854 13 far far RB 19613 8854 14 as as IN 19613 8854 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8854 16 can can MD 19613 8854 17 speak speak VB 19613 8854 18 of of IN 19613 8854 19 a a DT 19613 8854 20 dogmatic dogmatic NN 19613 8854 21 in in IN 19613 8854 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8854 23 case case NN 19613 8854 24 -- -- : 19613 8854 25 the the DT 19613 8854 26 unity unity NN 19613 8854 27 lies lie VBZ 19613 8854 28 partly partly RB 19613 8854 29 in in IN 19613 8854 30 the the DT 19613 8854 31 canon canon NN 19613 8854 32 of of IN 19613 8854 33 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8854 34 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 8854 35 and and CC 19613 8854 36 partly partly RB 19613 8854 37 in in IN 19613 8854 38 the the DT 19613 8854 39 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 8854 40 aim aim NN 19613 8854 41 ; ; : 19613 8854 42 but but CC 19613 8854 43 these these DT 19613 8854 44 two two CD 19613 8854 45 principles principle NNS 19613 8854 46 interfere interfere VBP 19613 8854 47 with with IN 19613 8854 48 each each DT 19613 8854 49 other other JJ 19613 8854 50 . . . 19613 8855 1 As as RB 19613 8855 2 far far RB 19613 8855 3 as as IN 19613 8855 4 the the DT 19613 8855 5 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 8855 6 of of IN 19613 8855 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8855 8 is be VBZ 19613 8855 9 concerned concern VBN 19613 8855 10 , , , 19613 8855 11 Overbeek Overbeek NNP 19613 8855 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8855 13 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8855 14 . . NNP 19613 8855 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8856 1 has have VBZ 19613 8856 2 furnished furnish VBN 19613 8856 3 the the DT 19613 8856 4 explanation explanation NN 19613 8856 5 of of IN 19613 8856 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8856 7 striking striking JJ 19613 8856 8 plan plan NN 19613 8856 9 . . . 19613 8857 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8857 2 , , , 19613 8857 3 how how WRB 19613 8857 4 would would MD 19613 8857 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8857 6 have have VB 19613 8857 7 been be VBN 19613 8857 8 conceivable conceivable JJ 19613 8857 9 that that IN 19613 8857 10 the the DT 19613 8857 11 riches rich NNS 19613 8857 12 of of IN 19613 8857 13 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8857 14 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 8857 15 , , , 19613 8857 16 as as IN 19613 8857 17 presented present VBN 19613 8857 18 to to IN 19613 8857 19 the the DT 19613 8857 20 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8857 21 who who WP 19613 8857 22 allegorised allegorise VBD 19613 8857 23 the the DT 19613 8857 24 books book NNS 19613 8857 25 , , , 19613 8857 26 could could MD 19613 8857 27 have have VB 19613 8857 28 been be VBN 19613 8857 29 mastered master VBN 19613 8857 30 , , , 19613 8857 31 problems problem NNS 19613 8857 32 and and CC 19613 8857 33 all all DT 19613 8857 34 , , , 19613 8857 35 at at IN 19613 8857 36 the the DT 19613 8857 37 first first JJ 19613 8857 38 attempt attempt NN 19613 8857 39 . . . 19613 8857 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8858 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8858 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8858 3 679 679 CD 19613 8858 4 : : : 19613 8858 5 See see VB 19613 8858 6 the the DT 19613 8858 7 treatises treatise NNS 19613 8858 8 of of IN 19613 8858 9 Huetius Huetius NNP 19613 8858 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8858 11 1668 1668 CD 19613 8858 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8858 13 reprinted reprint VBN 19613 8858 14 by by IN 19613 8858 15 Lommatzsch Lommatzsch NNP 19613 8858 16 . . . 19613 8859 1 Thomasius Thomasius NNP 19613 8859 2 , , , 19613 8859 3 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 8859 4 1837 1837 CD 19613 8859 5 . . . 19613 8860 1 Redepenning redepenning NN 19613 8860 2 , , , 19613 8860 3 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 8860 4 , , , 19613 8860 5 2 2 CD 19613 8860 6 Vols vol NNS 19613 8860 7 . . . 19613 8861 1 1841 1841 CD 19613 8861 2 - - SYM 19613 8861 3 46 46 CD 19613 8861 4 . . . 19613 8862 1 Denis Denis NNP 19613 8862 2 , , , 19613 8862 3 de de NNP 19613 8862 4 la la NNP 19613 8862 5 philosophie philosophie NNP 19613 8862 6 d'Origène d'Origène NNP 19613 8862 7 , , , 19613 8862 8 Paris Paris NNP 19613 8862 9 1884 1884 CD 19613 8862 10 . . . 19613 8863 1 Lang Lang NNP 19613 8863 2 , , , 19613 8863 3 Die Die NNP 19613 8863 4 Leiblichkeit Leiblichkeit NNP 19613 8863 5 der der NN 19613 8863 6 Vernunftwesen Vernunftwesen NNP 19613 8863 7 bei bei NNP 19613 8863 8 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 8863 9 , , , 19613 8863 10 Leipzig Leipzig NNP 19613 8863 11 , , , 19613 8863 12 1892 1892 CD 19613 8863 13 . . . 19613 8864 1 Mehlhorn mehlhorn JJ 19613 8864 2 , , , 19613 8864 3 Die die VB 19613 8864 4 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 8864 5 von von NNP 19613 8864 6 der der VBD 19613 8864 7 menschlichen menschlichen NN 19613 8864 8 Freiheit Freiheit NNP 19613 8864 9 nach nach NN 19613 8864 10 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 8864 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8864 12 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 8864 13 für für NN 19613 8864 14 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 8864 15 , , , 19613 8864 16 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8864 17 . . . 19613 8865 1 II II NNP 19613 8865 2 . . NNP 19613 8865 3 , , , 19613 8865 4 p. p. NN 19613 8865 5 234 234 CD 19613 8865 6 ff ff NNP 19613 8865 7 . . . 19613 8865 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8865 9 . . . 19613 8866 1 Westcott Westcott NNP 19613 8866 2 , , , 19613 8866 3 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 8866 4 , , , 19613 8866 5 in in IN 19613 8866 6 the the DT 19613 8866 7 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 19613 8866 8 of of IN 19613 8866 9 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8866 10 Biography Biography NNP 19613 8866 11 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8866 12 . . . 19613 8867 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8867 2 . . . 19613 8868 1 Moller Moller NNP 19613 8868 2 in in IN 19613 8868 3 Herzog Herzog NNP 19613 8868 4 's 's POS 19613 8868 5 Real Real NNP 19613 8868 6 - - HYPH 19613 8868 7 Encyklopädie Encyklopädie NNP 19613 8868 8 , , , 19613 8868 9 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 8868 10 ed ed NNP 19613 8868 11 . . NNP 19613 8868 12 , , , 19613 8868 13 Vol Vol NNP 19613 8868 14 . . . 19613 8869 1 XI XI NNP 19613 8869 2 . . . 19613 8869 3 , , , 19613 8869 4 pp pp NNP 19613 8869 5 . . . 19613 8870 1 92 92 CD 19613 8870 2 - - HYPH 19613 8870 3 109 109 CD 19613 8870 4 . . . 19613 8871 1 The the DT 19613 8871 2 special special JJ 19613 8871 3 literature literature NN 19613 8871 4 is be VBZ 19613 8871 5 to to TO 19613 8871 6 be be VB 19613 8871 7 found find VBN 19613 8871 8 there there RB 19613 8871 9 as as RB 19613 8871 10 well well RB 19613 8871 11 as as IN 19613 8871 12 in in IN 19613 8871 13 Nitzsch Nitzsch NNP 19613 8871 14 , , , 19613 8871 15 Dogmengeschichte Dogmengeschichte NNP 19613 8871 16 I. I. NNP 19613 8871 17 , , , 19613 8871 18 p. p. NN 19613 8871 19 151 151 CD 19613 8871 20 , , , 19613 8871 21 and and CC 19613 8871 22 Ueberweg Ueberweg NNP 19613 8871 23 , , , 19613 8871 24 Grundriss Grundriss NNP 19613 8871 25 der der VBD 19613 8871 26 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 19613 8871 27 der der NNP 19613 8871 28 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 19613 8871 29 , , , 19613 8871 30 5th 5th JJ 19613 8871 31 ed ed NN 19613 8871 32 , , , 19613 8871 33 p. p. NN 19613 8871 34 62 62 CD 19613 8871 35 f. f. NN 19613 8871 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8871 37 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8871 38 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8871 39 680 680 CD 19613 8871 40 : : : 19613 8871 41 See see VB 19613 8871 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8871 43 letter letter NN 19613 8871 44 in in IN 19613 8871 45 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 8871 46 , , , 19613 8871 47 H. H. NNP 19613 8871 48 E. E. NNP 19613 8871 49 VI VI NNP 19613 8871 50 . . . 19613 8872 1 19 19 CD 19613 8872 2 . . . 19613 8873 1 11 11 CD 19613 8873 2 ff ff NN 19613 8873 3 . . . 19613 8873 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8874 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8874 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8874 3 681 681 CD 19613 8874 4 : : : 19613 8874 5 In in IN 19613 8874 6 the the DT 19613 8874 7 polemic polemic NN 19613 8874 8 against against IN 19613 8874 9 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8874 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8874 11 seems seem VBZ 19613 8874 12 to to IN 19613 8874 13 us -PRON- PRP 19613 8874 14 in in IN 19613 8874 15 not not RB 19613 8874 16 a a DT 19613 8874 17 few few JJ 19613 8874 18 passages passage NNS 19613 8874 19 as as IN 19613 8874 20 if if IN 19613 8874 21 the the DT 19613 8874 22 feeling feeling NN 19613 8874 23 for for IN 19613 8874 24 truth truth NN 19613 8874 25 had have VBD 19613 8874 26 forsaken forsake VBN 19613 8874 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8874 28 . . . 19613 8875 1 If if IN 19613 8875 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8875 3 consider consider VBP 19613 8875 4 , , , 19613 8875 5 however however RB 19613 8875 6 , , , 19613 8875 7 that that IN 19613 8875 8 in in IN 19613 8875 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8875 10 's 's POS 19613 8875 11 idea idea NN 19613 8875 12 the the DT 19613 8875 13 premises premise NNS 19613 8875 14 of of IN 19613 8875 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8875 16 speculation speculation NN 19613 8875 17 were be VBD 19613 8875 18 unassailable unassailable JJ 19613 8875 19 , , , 19613 8875 20 and and CC 19613 8875 21 if if IN 19613 8875 22 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8875 23 further further RB 19613 8875 24 consider consider VBP 19613 8875 25 into into IN 19613 8875 26 what what WP 19613 8875 27 straits strait NNS 19613 8875 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8875 29 was be VBD 19613 8875 30 driven drive VBN 19613 8875 31 by by IN 19613 8875 32 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8875 33 , , , 19613 8875 34 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8875 35 will will MD 19613 8875 36 conclude conclude VB 19613 8875 37 that that IN 19613 8875 38 no no DT 19613 8875 39 proof proof NN 19613 8875 40 has have VBZ 19613 8875 41 been be VBN 19613 8875 42 advanced advance VBN 19613 8875 43 of of IN 19613 8875 44 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8875 45 's 's POS 19613 8875 46 having have VBG 19613 8875 47 sinned sin VBN 19613 8875 48 against against IN 19613 8875 49 the the DT 19613 8875 50 current current JJ 19613 8875 51 rules rule NNS 19613 8875 52 of of IN 19613 8875 53 truth truth NN 19613 8875 54 . . . 19613 8876 1 These these DT 19613 8876 2 , , , 19613 8876 3 however however RB 19613 8876 4 , , , 19613 8876 5 did do VBD 19613 8876 6 not not RB 19613 8876 7 include include VB 19613 8876 8 the the DT 19613 8876 9 commandment commandment NN 19613 8876 10 to to TO 19613 8876 11 use use VB 19613 8876 12 in in IN 19613 8876 13 disputation disputation NN 19613 8876 14 only only RB 19613 8876 15 such such JJ 19613 8876 16 arguments argument NNS 19613 8876 17 as as IN 19613 8876 18 could could MD 19613 8876 19 be be VB 19613 8876 20 employed employ VBN 19613 8876 21 in in IN 19613 8876 22 a a DT 19613 8876 23 positive positive JJ 19613 8876 24 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 19613 8876 25 presentation presentation NN 19613 8876 26 . . . 19613 8877 1 Basilius Basilius NNP 19613 8877 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8877 3 Ep Ep NNP 19613 8877 4 . . . 19613 8878 1 210 210 CD 19613 8878 2 ad ad NN 19613 8878 3 prim prim NN 19613 8878 4 . . . 19613 8879 1 Neocæs Neocæs NNP 19613 8879 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8879 3 was be VBD 19613 8879 4 quite quite RB 19613 8879 5 ready ready JJ 19613 8879 6 to to TO 19613 8879 7 excuse excuse VB 19613 8879 8 an an DT 19613 8879 9 utterance utterance NN 19613 8879 10 of of IN 19613 8879 11 Gregory Gregory NNP 19613 8879 12 Thaumaturgus Thaumaturgus NNP 19613 8879 13 , , , 19613 8879 14 that that WDT 19613 8879 15 sounded sound VBD 19613 8879 16 suspiciously suspiciously RB 19613 8879 17 like like IN 19613 8879 18 Sabellianism Sabellianism NNP 19613 8879 19 , , , 19613 8879 20 by by IN 19613 8879 21 saying say VBG 19613 8879 22 that that IN 19613 8879 23 the the DT 19613 8879 24 latter latter JJ 19613 8879 25 was be VBD 19613 8879 26 not not RB 19613 8879 27 speaking speak VBG 19613 8879 28 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8879 29 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8879 30 : : : 19613 8879 31 dogmatikôs dogmatikôs NN 19613 8879 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8879 33 , , , 19613 8879 34 but but CC 19613 8879 35 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8879 36 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8879 37 : : : 19613 8879 38 agônistikôs agônistikôs NN 19613 8879 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8879 40 . . . 19613 8880 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 8880 2 also also RB 19613 8880 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8880 4 ad ad NN 19613 8880 5 Pammach Pammach NNP 19613 8880 6 . . . 19613 8881 1 ep ep NNP 19613 8881 2 48 48 CD 19613 8881 3 , , , 19613 8881 4 c. c. NNP 19613 8881 5 13 13 CD 19613 8881 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8881 7 , , , 19613 8881 8 after after IN 19613 8881 9 defending defend VBG 19613 8881 10 the the DT 19613 8881 11 right right NN 19613 8881 12 of of IN 19613 8881 13 writing write VBG 19613 8881 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8881 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8881 16 : : : 19613 8881 17 gymnastikôs gymnastikôs NN 19613 8881 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8881 19 , , , 19613 8881 20 expressly expressly RB 19613 8881 21 said say VBD 19613 8881 22 that that IN 19613 8881 23 all all DT 19613 8881 24 Greek greek JJ 19613 8881 25 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8881 26 " " '' 19613 8881 27 have have VBP 19613 8881 28 used use VBN 19613 8881 29 many many JJ 19613 8881 30 words word NNS 19613 8881 31 to to TO 19613 8881 32 conceal conceal VB 19613 8881 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8881 34 thoughts thought NNS 19613 8881 35 , , , 19613 8881 36 threaten threaten VBP 19613 8881 37 in in IN 19613 8881 38 one one CD 19613 8881 39 place place NN 19613 8881 40 , , , 19613 8881 41 and and CC 19613 8881 42 deal deal VB 19613 8881 43 the the DT 19613 8881 44 blow blow NN 19613 8881 45 in in IN 19613 8881 46 another another DT 19613 8881 47 . . . 19613 8881 48 " " '' 19613 8882 1 In in IN 19613 8882 2 the the DT 19613 8882 3 same same JJ 19613 8882 4 way way NN 19613 8882 5 , , , 19613 8882 6 according accord VBG 19613 8882 7 to to IN 19613 8882 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8882 9 , , , 19613 8882 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8882 11 , , , 19613 8882 12 Methodius Methodius NNP 19613 8882 13 , , , 19613 8882 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 8882 15 , , , 19613 8882 16 and and CC 19613 8882 17 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 19613 8882 18 had have VBD 19613 8882 19 acted act VBN 19613 8882 20 in in IN 19613 8882 21 the the DT 19613 8882 22 dispute dispute NN 19613 8882 23 with with IN 19613 8882 24 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8882 25 and and CC 19613 8882 26 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 8882 27 . . . 19613 8883 1 " " `` 19613 8883 2 Because because IN 19613 8883 3 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8883 4 are be VBP 19613 8883 5 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 8883 6 compelled compel VBN 19613 8883 7 to to TO 19613 8883 8 say say VB 19613 8883 9 , , , 19613 8883 10 not not RB 19613 8883 11 what what WP 19613 8883 12 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8883 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8883 14 think think VBP 19613 8883 15 , , , 19613 8883 16 but but CC 19613 8883 17 what what WP 19613 8883 18 is be VBZ 19613 8883 19 necessary necessary JJ 19613 8883 20 for for IN 19613 8883 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8883 22 purpose purpose NN 19613 8883 23 ; ; : 19613 8883 24 they -PRON- PRP 19613 8883 25 do do VBP 19613 8883 26 this this DT 19613 8883 27 only only RB 19613 8883 28 in in IN 19613 8883 29 the the DT 19613 8883 30 struggle struggle NN 19613 8883 31 with with IN 19613 8883 32 the the DT 19613 8883 33 heathen heathen NN 19613 8883 34 . . . 19613 8883 35 " " '' 19613 8883 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8884 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8884 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8884 3 682 682 CD 19613 8884 4 : : : 19613 8884 5 See see VB 19613 8884 6 , , , 19613 8884 7 above above IN 19613 8884 8 all all DT 19613 8884 9 , , , 19613 8884 10 the the DT 19613 8884 11 systematic systematic JJ 19613 8884 12 main main JJ 19613 8884 13 work work NN 19613 8884 14 " " '' 19613 8884 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8884 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8884 17 : : : 19613 8884 18 peri peri NN 19613 8884 19 archôn archôn NN 19613 8884 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8884 21 " " `` 19613 8884 22 . . . 19613 8884 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8885 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8885 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8885 3 683 683 CD 19613 8885 4 : : : 19613 8885 5 Many many JJ 19613 8885 6 writings writing NNS 19613 8885 7 of of IN 19613 8885 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8885 9 are be VBP 19613 8885 10 pervaded pervade VBN 19613 8885 11 by by IN 19613 8885 12 arguments argument NNS 19613 8885 13 , , , 19613 8885 14 evincing evince VBG 19613 8885 15 equal equal JJ 19613 8885 16 discretion discretion NN 19613 8885 17 and and CC 19613 8885 18 patience patience NN 19613 8885 19 , , , 19613 8885 20 against against IN 19613 8885 21 the the DT 19613 8885 22 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8885 23 who who WP 19613 8885 24 contest contest VBP 19613 8885 25 the the DT 19613 8885 26 right right NN 19613 8885 27 of of IN 19613 8885 28 science science NN 19613 8885 29 in in IN 19613 8885 30 the the DT 19613 8885 31 Church Church NNP 19613 8885 32 . . . 19613 8886 1 In in IN 19613 8886 2 the the DT 19613 8886 3 work work NN 19613 8886 4 against against IN 19613 8886 5 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8886 6 , , , 19613 8886 7 however however RB 19613 8886 8 , , , 19613 8886 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8886 10 was be VBD 19613 8886 11 not not RB 19613 8886 12 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 8886 13 obliged oblige VBN 19613 8886 14 to to TO 19613 8886 15 abandon abandon VB 19613 8886 16 the the DT 19613 8886 17 simple simple JJ 19613 8886 18 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8886 19 . . . 19613 8887 1 C. C. NNP 19613 8887 2 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8887 3 III III NNP 19613 8887 4 . . . 19613 8888 1 78 78 CD 19613 8888 2 : : : 19613 8888 3 V. V. NNP 19613 8888 4 14 14 CD 19613 8888 5 - - SYM 19613 8888 6 24 24 CD 19613 8888 7 are be VBP 19613 8888 8 particularly particularly RB 19613 8888 9 instructive instructive JJ 19613 8888 10 . . . 19613 8888 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8889 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8889 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8889 3 684 684 CD 19613 8889 4 : : : 19613 8889 5 In in IN 19613 8889 6 this this DT 19613 8889 7 point point NN 19613 8889 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8889 9 is be VBZ 19613 8889 10 already already RB 19613 8889 11 narrower narrow JJR 19613 8889 12 than than IN 19613 8889 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8889 14 . . . 19613 8890 1 Free free JJ 19613 8890 2 judgments judgment NNS 19613 8890 3 , , , 19613 8890 4 such such JJ 19613 8890 5 as as IN 19613 8890 6 were be VBD 19613 8890 7 passed pass VBN 19613 8890 8 by by IN 19613 8890 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8890 10 on on IN 19613 8890 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 8890 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8890 13 , , , 19613 8890 14 were be VBD 19613 8890 15 not not RB 19613 8890 16 , , , 19613 8890 17 so so RB 19613 8890 18 far far RB 19613 8890 19 as as IN 19613 8890 20 I -PRON- PRP 19613 8890 21 know know VBP 19613 8890 22 , , , 19613 8890 23 repeated repeat VBN 19613 8890 24 by by IN 19613 8890 25 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8890 26 . . . 19613 8891 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8891 2 See see VB 19613 8891 3 especially especially RB 19613 8891 4 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8891 5 , , , 19613 8891 6 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8891 7 . . . 19613 8892 1 I. I. NNP 19613 8893 1 5 5 CD 19613 8893 2 . . . 19613 8894 1 28 28 CD 19613 8894 2 - - SYM 19613 8894 3 32 32 CD 19613 8894 4 : : SYM 19613 8894 5 13 13 CD 19613 8894 6 . . . 19613 8895 1 57 57 CD 19613 8895 2 , , , 19613 8895 3 58 58 CD 19613 8895 4 etc etc FW 19613 8895 5 . . . 19613 8896 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8896 2 ; ; : 19613 8896 3 yet yet CC 19613 8896 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8896 5 also also RB 19613 8896 6 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 19613 8896 7 revelations revelation NNS 19613 8896 8 of of IN 19613 8896 9 God God NNP 19613 8896 10 in in IN 19613 8896 11 Greek greek JJ 19613 8896 12 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8896 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8896 14 see see VB 19613 8896 15 , , , 19613 8896 16 _ _ NNP 19613 8896 17 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 8896 18 _ _ NNP 19613 8896 19 , , , 19613 8896 20 c. c. NN 19613 8896 21 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8896 22 . . . 19613 8897 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8897 2 . . . 19613 8898 1 3 3 LS 19613 8898 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8898 3 , , , 19613 8898 4 and and CC 19613 8898 5 the the DT 19613 8898 6 Christian christian JJ 19613 8898 7 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8898 8 is be VBZ 19613 8898 9 to to IN 19613 8898 10 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8898 11 the the DT 19613 8898 12 completion completion NN 19613 8898 13 of of IN 19613 8898 14 Greek greek JJ 19613 8898 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8898 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8898 17 see see VB 19613 8898 18 the the DT 19613 8898 19 remains remain NNS 19613 8898 20 of of IN 19613 8898 21 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8898 22 's 's POS 19613 8898 23 lost lose VBN 19613 8898 24 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 8898 25 and and CC 19613 8898 26 Hom Hom NNP 19613 8898 27 . . . 19613 8899 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 8899 2 . . . 19613 8900 1 in in IN 19613 8900 2 Genes Genes NNP 19613 8900 3 . . . 19613 8901 1 § § ADD 19613 8901 2 3 3 CD 19613 8901 3 ; ; : 19613 8901 4 other other JJ 19613 8901 5 passages passage NNS 19613 8901 6 in in IN 19613 8901 7 Redepenning Redepenning NNP 19613 8901 8 II II NNP 19613 8901 9 . . NNP 19613 8901 10 , , , 19613 8901 11 p. p. NN 19613 8901 12 324 324 CD 19613 8901 13 ff ff NNP 19613 8901 14 . . NNP 19613 8901 15 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8901 16 . . . 19613 8901 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8902 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8902 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8902 3 685 685 CD 19613 8902 4 : : : 19613 8902 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 8902 6 must must MD 19613 8902 7 here here RB 19613 8902 8 content content VB 19613 8902 9 ourselves -PRON- PRP 19613 8902 10 with with IN 19613 8902 11 merely merely RB 19613 8902 12 pointing point VBG 19613 8902 13 out out RP 19613 8902 14 that that IN 19613 8902 15 the the DT 19613 8902 16 method method NN 19613 8902 17 of of IN 19613 8902 18 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8902 19 Scriptural Scriptural NNP 19613 8902 20 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 8902 21 also also RB 19613 8902 22 led lead VBD 19613 8902 23 to to IN 19613 8902 24 historico historico JJ 19613 8902 25 - - HYPH 19613 8902 26 critical critical JJ 19613 8902 27 investigations investigation NNS 19613 8902 28 , , , 19613 8902 29 that that IN 19613 8902 30 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 8902 31 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8902 32 and and CC 19613 8902 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8902 34 disciples disciple NNS 19613 8902 35 were be VBD 19613 8902 36 also also RB 19613 8902 37 critics critic NNS 19613 8902 38 of of IN 19613 8902 39 the the DT 19613 8902 40 tradition tradition NN 19613 8902 41 , , , 19613 8902 42 and and CC 19613 8902 43 that that IN 19613 8902 44 scientific scientific JJ 19613 8902 45 theology theology NN 19613 8902 46 , , , 19613 8902 47 in in IN 19613 8902 48 addition addition NN 19613 8902 49 to to IN 19613 8902 50 the the DT 19613 8902 51 task task NN 19613 8902 52 of of IN 19613 8902 53 remodelling remodelle VBG 19613 8902 54 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8902 55 , , , 19613 8902 56 thus thus RB 19613 8902 57 began begin VBD 19613 8902 58 at at IN 19613 8902 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8902 60 very very RB 19613 8902 61 origin origin NN 19613 8902 62 the the DT 19613 8902 63 solution solution NN 19613 8902 64 of of IN 19613 8902 65 another another DT 19613 8902 66 problem problem NN 19613 8902 67 , , , 19613 8902 68 namely namely RB 19613 8902 69 , , , 19613 8902 70 the the DT 19613 8902 71 critical critical JJ 19613 8902 72 restoration restoration NN 19613 8902 73 of of IN 19613 8902 74 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8902 75 from from IN 19613 8902 76 the the DT 19613 8902 77 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 8902 78 and and CC 19613 8902 79 tradition tradition NN 19613 8902 80 and and CC 19613 8902 81 the the DT 19613 8902 82 removal removal NN 19613 8902 83 of of IN 19613 8902 84 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8902 85 excrescences excrescence NNS 19613 8902 86 : : : 19613 8902 87 for for IN 19613 8902 88 these these DT 19613 8902 89 efforts effort NNS 19613 8902 90 , , , 19613 8902 91 strictly strictly RB 19613 8902 92 speaking speak VBG 19613 8902 93 , , , 19613 8902 94 do do VBP 19613 8902 95 not not RB 19613 8902 96 come come VB 19613 8902 97 up up RP 19613 8902 98 for for IN 19613 8902 99 consideration consideration NN 19613 8902 100 in in IN 19613 8902 101 the the DT 19613 8902 102 history history NN 19613 8902 103 of of IN 19613 8902 104 dogma dogma NN 19613 8902 105 . . . 19613 8902 106 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8903 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8903 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8903 3 686 686 CD 19613 8903 4 : : : 19613 8903 5 The the DT 19613 8903 6 theory theory NN 19613 8903 7 that that WDT 19613 8903 8 justified justify VBD 19613 8903 9 a a DT 19613 8903 10 twofold twofold JJ 19613 8903 11 morality morality NN 19613 8903 12 in in IN 19613 8903 13 the the DT 19613 8903 14 Church Church NNP 19613 8903 15 is be VBZ 19613 8903 16 now now RB 19613 8903 17 completely completely RB 19613 8903 18 legitimised legitimise VBN 19613 8903 19 , , , 19613 8903 20 but but CC 19613 8903 21 the the DT 19613 8903 22 higher high JJR 19613 8903 23 form form NN 19613 8903 24 no no RB 19613 8903 25 longer long RBR 19613 8903 26 appears appear VBZ 19613 8903 27 as as IN 19613 8903 28 Encratite Encratite NNP 19613 8903 29 and and CC 19613 8903 30 eschatological eschatological JJ 19613 8903 31 , , , 19613 8903 32 but but CC 19613 8903 33 as as IN 19613 8903 34 Encratite Encratite NNP 19613 8903 35 and and CC 19613 8903 36 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 8903 37 . . . 19613 8904 1 See see VB 19613 8904 2 , , , 19613 8904 3 for for IN 19613 8904 4 example example NN 19613 8904 5 , , , 19613 8904 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8904 7 , , , 19613 8904 8 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8904 9 . . . 19613 8905 1 III iii CD 19613 8905 2 . . . 19613 8906 1 12 12 CD 19613 8906 2 . . . 19613 8907 1 82 82 CD 19613 8907 2 : : : 19613 8907 3 VI VI NNP 19613 8907 4 . . . 19613 8908 1 13 13 CD 19613 8908 2 . . . 19613 8909 1 106 106 CD 19613 8909 2 etc etc FW 19613 8909 3 . . . 19613 8910 1 Gnosis gnosis NN 19613 8910 2 is be VBZ 19613 8910 3 the the DT 19613 8910 4 principle principle NN 19613 8910 5 of of IN 19613 8910 6 perfection perfection NN 19613 8910 7 . . . 19613 8911 1 See see VB 19613 8911 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8911 3 . . . 19613 8912 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8912 2 . . . 19613 8913 1 7 7 LS 19613 8913 2 . . . 19613 8914 1 54 54 CD 19613 8914 2 : : : 19613 8914 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8914 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8914 5 : : : 19613 8914 6 prokeitai prokeitai NNP 19613 8914 7 de de FW 19613 8914 8 tois tois NNP 19613 8914 9 eis eis NNP 19613 8914 10 teleiôsin teleiôsin NNP 19613 8914 11 speudousin speudousin NNP 19613 8914 12 hê hê NNP 19613 8914 13 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 8914 14 hê hê NNP 19613 8914 15 logikê logikê NNP 19613 8914 16 hês hês NNP 19613 8914 17 themelios themelios NNP 19613 8914 18 hê hê PRP$ 19613 8914 19 agia agia NNP 19613 8914 20 trias trias NNP 19613 8914 21 pistis pistis NN 19613 8914 22 , , , 19613 8914 23 agapê agapê NNP 19613 8914 24 , , , 19613 8914 25 elpis elpis NN 19613 8914 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8914 27 . . . 19613 8914 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8915 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8915 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8915 3 687 687 CD 19613 8915 4 : : : 19613 8915 5 See see VB 19613 8915 6 the the DT 19613 8915 7 preface preface NN 19613 8915 8 to to IN 19613 8915 9 the the DT 19613 8915 10 work work NN 19613 8915 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8915 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8915 13 : : : 19613 8915 14 peri peri NN 19613 8915 15 archôn archôn NN 19613 8915 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8915 17 . . . 19613 8915 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8916 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8916 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8916 3 688 688 CD 19613 8916 4 : : : 19613 8916 5 From from IN 19613 8916 6 the the DT 19613 8916 7 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 8916 8 of of IN 19613 8916 9 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 19613 8916 10 ' ' '' 19613 8916 11 Philosophoumena philosophoumena VB 19613 8916 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8916 13 is be VBZ 19613 8916 14 also also RB 19613 8916 15 evident evident JJ 19613 8916 16 how how WRB 19613 8916 17 the the DT 19613 8916 18 Socratic socratic JJ 19613 8916 19 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8916 20 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8916 21 : : : 19613 8916 22 Gnôthi Gnôthi NNP 19613 8916 23 seauton seauton NN 19613 8916 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8916 25 was be VBD 19613 8916 26 in in IN 19613 8916 27 that that DT 19613 8916 28 age age NN 19613 8916 29 based base VBN 19613 8916 30 on on IN 19613 8916 31 a a DT 19613 8916 32 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8916 33 of of IN 19613 8916 34 religion religion NN 19613 8916 35 and and CC 19613 8916 36 was be VBD 19613 8916 37 regarded regard VBN 19613 8916 38 as as IN 19613 8916 39 a a DT 19613 8916 40 watchword watchword NN 19613 8916 41 in in IN 19613 8916 42 wide wide JJ 19613 8916 43 circles circle NNS 19613 8916 44 . . . 19613 8917 1 See see VB 19613 8917 2 Clem Clem NNP 19613 8917 3 . . . 19613 8918 1 Pædag Pædag NNP 19613 8918 2 . . . 19613 8919 1 III iii CD 19613 8919 2 . . . 19613 8920 1 11 11 CD 19613 8920 2 . . . 19613 8921 1 1 1 LS 19613 8921 2 . . . 19613 8921 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8922 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8922 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8922 3 689 689 CD 19613 8922 4 : : : 19613 8922 5 See see VB 19613 8922 6 Gregory Gregory NNP 19613 8922 7 Thaumaturgus Thaumaturgus NNP 19613 8922 8 ' ' '' 19613 8922 9 panegyric panegyric NN 19613 8922 10 on on IN 19613 8922 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8922 12 , , , 19613 8922 13 one one CD 19613 8922 14 of of IN 19613 8922 15 the the DT 19613 8922 16 most most RBS 19613 8922 17 instructive instructive JJ 19613 8922 18 writings writing NNS 19613 8922 19 of of IN 19613 8922 20 the the DT 19613 8922 21 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 8922 22 century century NN 19613 8922 23 , , , 19613 8922 24 especially especially RB 19613 8922 25 cc cc NNP 19613 8922 26 . . . 19613 8923 1 11 11 CD 19613 8923 2 - - SYM 19613 8923 3 18 18 CD 19613 8923 4 . . . 19613 8923 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8924 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8924 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8924 3 690 690 CD 19613 8924 4 : : : 19613 8924 5 Yet yet CC 19613 8924 6 all all DT 19613 8924 7 excesses excess NNS 19613 8924 8 are be VBP 19613 8924 9 repudiated repudiate VBN 19613 8924 10 . . . 19613 8925 1 See see VB 19613 8925 2 Clem Clem NNP 19613 8925 3 . . . 19613 8926 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8926 2 . . . 19613 8927 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8927 2 . . . 19613 8928 1 22 22 CD 19613 8928 2 . . . 19613 8929 1 138 138 CD 19613 8929 2 : : : 19613 8929 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8929 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8929 5 : : : 19613 8929 6 Ouk ouk VB 19613 8929 7 egkratês egkratês NN 19613 8929 8 outos outos NN 19613 8929 9 eti eti NNP 19613 8929 10 , , , 19613 8929 11 all all DT 19613 8929 12 ' ' '' 19613 8929 13 en en IN 19613 8929 14 hexei hexei NNP 19613 8929 15 gegonen gegonen NNP 19613 8929 16 apatheias apatheias NNP 19613 8929 17 schêma schêma NNP 19613 8929 18 theion theion NNP 19613 8929 19 ependusasthai ependusasthai NNP 19613 8929 20 anamenôn anamenôn NNP 19613 8929 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8929 22 . . . 19613 8930 1 Similar similar JJ 19613 8930 2 remarks remark NNS 19613 8930 3 are be VBP 19613 8930 4 found find VBN 19613 8930 5 in in IN 19613 8930 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8930 7 . . . 19613 8930 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8931 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8931 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8931 3 691 691 CD 19613 8931 4 : : : 19613 8931 5 In in IN 19613 8931 6 many many JJ 19613 8931 7 passages passage NNS 19613 8931 8 of of IN 19613 8931 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8931 10 the the DT 19613 8931 11 satisfaction satisfaction NN 19613 8931 12 in in IN 19613 8931 13 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8931 14 appears appear VBZ 19613 8931 15 in in IN 19613 8931 16 a a DT 19613 8931 17 still still RB 19613 8931 18 more more RBR 19613 8931 19 pronounced pronounced JJ 19613 8931 20 form form NN 19613 8931 21 than than IN 19613 8931 22 in in IN 19613 8931 23 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8931 24 . . . 19613 8932 1 The the DT 19613 8932 2 boldest bold JJS 19613 8932 3 expression expression NN 19613 8932 4 of of IN 19613 8932 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8932 6 is be VBZ 19613 8932 7 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8932 8 . . . 19613 8933 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8933 2 . . . 19613 8934 1 22 22 CD 19613 8934 2 . . . 19613 8935 1 136 136 CD 19613 8935 2 . . . 19613 8936 1 This this DT 19613 8936 2 passage passage NN 19613 8936 3 is be VBZ 19613 8936 4 quoted quote VBN 19613 8936 5 above above RB 19613 8936 6 on on IN 19613 8936 7 p. p. NN 19613 8937 1 328 328 CD 19613 8937 2 . . . 19613 8937 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8938 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8938 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8938 3 692 692 CD 19613 8938 4 : : : 19613 8938 5 See see VB 19613 8938 6 the the DT 19613 8938 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 19613 8938 8 prayer prayer NN 19613 8938 9 of of IN 19613 8938 10 the the DT 19613 8938 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 8938 12 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 8938 13 in in IN 19613 8938 14 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8938 15 . . . 19613 8939 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8939 2 . . . 19613 8940 1 23 23 CD 19613 8940 2 . . . 19613 8941 1 148 148 CD 19613 8941 2 . . . 19613 8941 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8942 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8942 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8942 3 693 693 CD 19613 8942 4 : : : 19613 8942 5 See see VB 19613 8942 6 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8942 7 . . . 19613 8943 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8943 2 . . . 19613 8944 1 26 26 CD 19613 8944 2 . . . 19613 8945 1 172 172 CD 19613 8945 2 : : : 19613 8945 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8945 4 's 's POS 19613 8945 5 commentaries commentary NNS 19613 8945 6 are be VBP 19613 8945 7 continually continually RB 19613 8945 8 interrupted interrupt VBN 19613 8945 9 by by IN 19613 8945 10 similar similar JJ 19613 8945 11 outbursts outburst NNS 19613 8945 12 of of IN 19613 8945 13 feeling feeling NN 19613 8945 14 . . . 19613 8945 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8946 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8946 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 8946 3 694 694 CD 19613 8946 4 : : : 19613 8946 5 On on IN 19613 8946 6 deification deification NN 19613 8946 7 as as IN 19613 8946 8 the the DT 19613 8946 9 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 8946 10 aim aim NN 19613 8946 11 see see VB 19613 8946 12 Clem Clem NNP 19613 8946 13 . . . 19613 8946 14 , , , 19613 8946 15 Strom Strom NNP 19613 8946 16 . . . 19613 8947 1 IV IV NNP 19613 8947 2 . . . 19613 8948 1 23 23 CD 19613 8948 2 . . . 19613 8949 1 149 149 CD 19613 8949 2 - - SYM 19613 8949 3 155 155 CD 19613 8949 4 : : : 19613 8949 5 VII VII NNP 19613 8949 6 . . . 19613 8950 1 10 10 CD 19613 8950 2 . . . 19613 8951 1 56 56 CD 19613 8951 2 , , , 19613 8951 3 13 13 CD 19613 8951 4 . . . 19613 8952 1 82 82 CD 19613 8952 2 , , , 19613 8952 3 16 16 CD 19613 8952 4 . . . 19613 8953 1 95 95 CD 19613 8953 2 : : : 19613 8953 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8953 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8953 5 : : : 19613 8953 6 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 8953 7 ho ho NNP 19613 8953 8 tô tô NNP 19613 8953 9 kuriô kuriô NNP 19613 8953 10 peithomenos peithomenos NNP 19613 8953 11 kai kai NNP 19613 8953 12 tê tê DT 19613 8953 13 dotheisê dotheisê NNP 19613 8953 14 di di NNP 19613 8953 15 ' ' '' 19613 8953 16 autou autou NNP 19613 8953 17 katakolouthêsas katakolouthêsas NNP 19613 8953 18 prophêteia prophêteia NNP 19613 8953 19 teleôs teleôs NNP 19613 8953 20 ekteleitai ekteleitai NNP 19613 8953 21 kat kat NNP 19613 8953 22 ' ' POS 19613 8953 23 eikona eikona NNP 19613 8953 24 tou tou NNP 19613 8953 25 didaskalou didaskalou NNP 19613 8953 26 en en FW 19613 8953 27 sarki sarki NNP 19613 8953 28 peripolôn peripolôn NN 19613 8953 29 Theos Theos NNP 19613 8953 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8953 31 . . . 19613 8954 1 But but CC 19613 8954 2 note note VB 19613 8954 3 what what WP 19613 8954 4 a a DT 19613 8954 5 distinction distinction NN 19613 8954 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8954 7 makes make VBZ 19613 8954 8 between between IN 19613 8954 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8954 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8954 11 : : : 19613 8954 12 ho ho NNP 19613 8954 13 Theos Theos NNP 19613 8954 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8954 15 and and CC 19613 8954 16 the the DT 19613 8954 17 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8954 18 man man NN 19613 8954 19 in in IN 19613 8954 20 VII VII NNP 19613 8954 21 . . . 19613 8955 1 15 15 CD 19613 8955 2 . . . 19613 8956 1 88 88 CD 19613 8956 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8956 3 in in IN 19613 8956 4 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 8956 5 to to IN 19613 8956 6 the the DT 19613 8956 7 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 8956 8 identification identification NN 19613 8956 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8956 10 ; ; : 19613 8956 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8956 12 does do VBZ 19613 8956 13 this this DT 19613 8956 14 also also RB 19613 8956 15 . . . 19613 8956 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8957 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8957 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8957 3 695 695 CD 19613 8957 4 : : : 19613 8957 5 Gregory Gregory NNP 19613 8957 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8957 7 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8957 8 . . NNP 19613 8957 9 , , , 19613 8957 10 c. c. NNP 19613 8957 11 13 13 CD 19613 8957 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8957 13 relates relate VBZ 19613 8957 14 that that IN 19613 8957 15 all all PDT 19613 8957 16 the the DT 19613 8957 17 works work NNS 19613 8957 18 of of IN 19613 8957 19 the the DT 19613 8957 20 poets poet NNS 19613 8957 21 and and CC 19613 8957 22 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8957 23 were be VBD 19613 8957 24 read read VBN 19613 8957 25 in in IN 19613 8957 26 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8957 27 's 's POS 19613 8957 28 school school NN 19613 8957 29 , , , 19613 8957 30 and and CC 19613 8957 31 that that IN 19613 8957 32 every every DT 19613 8957 33 part part NN 19613 8957 34 of of IN 19613 8957 35 these these DT 19613 8957 36 works work NNS 19613 8957 37 that that WDT 19613 8957 38 would would MD 19613 8957 39 stand stand VB 19613 8957 40 the the DT 19613 8957 41 test test NN 19613 8957 42 was be VBD 19613 8957 43 admitted admit VBN 19613 8957 44 . . . 19613 8958 1 Only only RB 19613 8958 2 the the DT 19613 8958 3 works work NNS 19613 8958 4 of of IN 19613 8958 5 atheists atheist NNS 19613 8958 6 were be VBD 19613 8958 7 excluded exclude VBN 19613 8958 8 , , , 19613 8958 9 " " '' 19613 8958 10 because because IN 19613 8958 11 these these DT 19613 8958 12 overpass overpass NN 19613 8958 13 the the DT 19613 8958 14 limits limit NNS 19613 8958 15 of of IN 19613 8958 16 human human JJ 19613 8958 17 thought thought NN 19613 8958 18 . . . 19613 8958 19 " " '' 19613 8959 1 However however RB 19613 8959 2 , , , 19613 8959 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8959 4 did do VBD 19613 8959 5 not not RB 19613 8959 6 judge judge VB 19613 8959 7 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8959 8 in in IN 19613 8959 9 such such PDT 19613 8959 10 an an DT 19613 8959 11 unprejudiced unprejudiced JJ 19613 8959 12 manner manner NN 19613 8959 13 as as IN 19613 8959 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 8959 15 , , , 19613 8959 16 or or CC 19613 8959 17 , , , 19613 8959 18 to to TO 19613 8959 19 speak speak VB 19613 8959 20 more more RBR 19613 8959 21 correctly correctly RB 19613 8959 22 , , , 19613 8959 23 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8959 24 no no RB 19613 8959 25 longer long RBR 19613 8959 26 valued value VBD 19613 8959 27 them -PRON- PRP 19613 8959 28 so so RB 19613 8959 29 highly highly RB 19613 8959 30 . . . 19613 8960 1 See See NNP 19613 8960 2 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 8960 3 , , , 19613 8960 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8960 5 . . NNP 19613 8960 6 , , , 19613 8960 7 p. p. NN 19613 8960 8 133 133 CD 19613 8960 9 , , , 19613 8960 10 Denis Denis NNP 19613 8960 11 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8960 12 . . . 19613 8961 1 Introd Introd NNP 19613 8961 2 . . . 19613 8961 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8962 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8962 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8962 3 696 696 CD 19613 8962 4 : : : 19613 8962 5 See see VB 19613 8962 6 , , , 19613 8962 7 for for IN 19613 8962 8 example example NN 19613 8962 9 , , , 19613 8962 10 c. c. NNP 19613 8962 11 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8962 12 . . . 19613 8963 1 V. V. NNP 19613 8963 2 43 43 CD 19613 8963 3 : : : 19613 8963 4 VII VII NNP 19613 8963 5 . . . 19613 8964 1 47 47 CD 19613 8964 2 , , , 19613 8964 3 59 59 CD 19613 8964 4 sq sq NN 19613 8964 5 . . . 19613 8965 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8965 2 compared compare VBD 19613 8965 3 Plato Plato NNP 19613 8965 4 and and CC 19613 8965 5 other other JJ 19613 8965 6 wise wise JJ 19613 8965 7 men man NNS 19613 8965 8 to to IN 19613 8965 9 those those DT 19613 8965 10 doctors doctor NNS 19613 8965 11 who who WP 19613 8965 12 give give VBP 19613 8965 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8965 14 attention attention NN 19613 8965 15 only only RB 19613 8965 16 to to IN 19613 8965 17 cultured cultured JJ 19613 8965 18 patients patient NNS 19613 8965 19 . . . 19613 8965 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8966 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8966 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8966 3 697 697 CD 19613 8966 4 : : : 19613 8966 5 See see VB 19613 8966 6 , , , 19613 8966 7 for for IN 19613 8966 8 example example NN 19613 8966 9 , , , 19613 8966 10 c. c. NNP 19613 8966 11 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8966 12 . . . 19613 8967 1 VI VI NNP 19613 8967 2 . . . 19613 8968 1 2 2 LS 19613 8968 2 . . . 19613 8968 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8969 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8969 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8969 3 698 698 CD 19613 8969 4 : : : 19613 8969 5 C. C. NNP 19613 8969 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8969 7 . . . 19613 8970 1 V. V. NNP 19613 8971 1 43 43 CD 19613 8971 2 . . . 19613 8971 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8972 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8972 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 8972 3 699 699 CD 19613 8972 4 : : : 19613 8972 5 One one CD 19613 8972 6 of of IN 19613 8972 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8972 8 's 's POS 19613 8972 9 main main JJ 19613 8972 10 ideas idea NNS 19613 8972 11 , , , 19613 8972 12 which which WDT 19613 8972 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8972 14 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 8972 15 meet meet VBP 19613 8972 16 with with IN 19613 8972 17 , , , 19613 8972 18 particularly particularly RB 19613 8972 19 in in IN 19613 8972 20 the the DT 19613 8972 21 work work NN 19613 8972 22 against against IN 19613 8972 23 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8972 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8972 25 see see VB 19613 8972 26 , , , 19613 8972 27 for for IN 19613 8972 28 example example NN 19613 8972 29 , , , 19613 8972 30 VI VI NNP 19613 8972 31 . . . 19613 8973 1 2 2 LS 19613 8973 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8973 3 is be VBZ 19613 8973 4 the the DT 19613 8973 5 thought thought NN 19613 8973 6 that that WDT 19613 8973 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8973 8 has have VBZ 19613 8973 9 come come VBN 19613 8973 10 to to TO 19613 8973 11 improve improve VB 19613 8973 12 all all DT 19613 8973 13 men man NNS 19613 8973 14 according accord VBG 19613 8973 15 to to IN 19613 8973 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8973 17 several several JJ 19613 8973 18 capacities capacity NNS 19613 8973 19 , , , 19613 8973 20 and and CC 19613 8973 21 to to TO 19613 8973 22 lead lead VB 19613 8973 23 some some DT 19613 8973 24 to to IN 19613 8973 25 the the DT 19613 8973 26 highest high JJS 19613 8973 27 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8973 28 . . . 19613 8974 1 This this DT 19613 8974 2 conception conception NN 19613 8974 3 appears appear VBZ 19613 8974 4 to to TO 19613 8974 5 fall fall VB 19613 8974 6 short short RB 19613 8974 7 of of IN 19613 8974 8 the the DT 19613 8974 9 Christian christian JJ 19613 8974 10 ideal ideal NN 19613 8974 11 and and CC 19613 8974 12 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 8974 13 really really RB 19613 8974 14 does do VBZ 19613 8974 15 so so RB 19613 8974 16 ; ; : 19613 8974 17 but but CC 19613 8974 18 as as RB 19613 8974 19 soon soon RB 19613 8974 20 as as IN 19613 8974 21 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8974 22 measure measure VBP 19613 8974 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 8974 24 not not RB 19613 8974 25 by by IN 19613 8974 26 the the DT 19613 8974 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8974 28 but but CC 19613 8974 29 by by IN 19613 8974 30 the the DT 19613 8974 31 aims aim NNS 19613 8974 32 of of IN 19613 8974 33 Greek greek JJ 19613 8974 34 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 8974 35 , , , 19613 8974 36 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8974 37 see see VBP 19613 8974 38 very very RB 19613 8974 39 clearly clearly RB 19613 8974 40 the the DT 19613 8974 41 progress progress NN 19613 8974 42 that that WDT 19613 8974 43 has have VBZ 19613 8974 44 been be VBN 19613 8974 45 attained attain VBN 19613 8974 46 through through IN 19613 8974 47 this this DT 19613 8974 48 same same JJ 19613 8974 49 Gospel Gospel NNP 19613 8974 50 . . . 19613 8975 1 What what WP 19613 8975 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8975 3 has have VBZ 19613 8975 4 in in IN 19613 8975 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8975 6 eye eye NN 19613 8975 7 is be VBZ 19613 8975 8 mankind mankind NN 19613 8975 9 , , , 19613 8975 10 and and CC 19613 8975 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8975 12 is be VBZ 19613 8975 13 anxious anxious JJ 19613 8975 14 for for IN 19613 8975 15 the the DT 19613 8975 16 amendment amendment NN 19613 8975 17 not not RB 19613 8975 18 merely merely RB 19613 8975 19 of of IN 19613 8975 20 a a DT 19613 8975 21 few few JJ 19613 8975 22 , , , 19613 8975 23 but but CC 19613 8975 24 of of IN 19613 8975 25 all all DT 19613 8975 26 . . . 19613 8976 1 The the DT 19613 8976 2 actual actual JJ 19613 8976 3 state state NN 19613 8976 4 of of IN 19613 8976 5 things thing NNS 19613 8976 6 in in IN 19613 8976 7 the the DT 19613 8976 8 Church Church NNP 19613 8976 9 no no RB 19613 8976 10 longer long RBR 19613 8976 11 allowed allow VBD 19613 8976 12 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8976 13 to to TO 19613 8976 14 repeat repeat VB 19613 8976 15 the the DT 19613 8976 16 exclamations exclamation NNS 19613 8976 17 of of IN 19613 8976 18 the the DT 19613 8976 19 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 8976 20 that that WDT 19613 8976 21 all all DT 19613 8976 22 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 8976 23 were be VBD 19613 8976 24 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8976 25 and and CC 19613 8976 26 that that IN 19613 8976 27 all all DT 19613 8976 28 were be VBD 19613 8976 29 filled fill VBN 19613 8976 30 with with IN 19613 8976 31 the the DT 19613 8976 32 same same JJ 19613 8976 33 wisdom wisdom NN 19613 8976 34 and and CC 19613 8976 35 virtue virtue NN 19613 8976 36 . . . 19613 8977 1 These these DT 19613 8977 2 exclamations exclamation NNS 19613 8977 3 were be VBD 19613 8977 4 naïve naïve JJ 19613 8977 5 and and CC 19613 8977 6 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 19613 8977 7 even even RB 19613 8977 8 for for IN 19613 8977 9 that that DT 19613 8977 10 time time NN 19613 8977 11 . . . 19613 8978 1 But but CC 19613 8978 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8978 3 could could MD 19613 8978 4 already already RB 19613 8978 5 estimate estimate VB 19613 8978 6 the the DT 19613 8978 7 relative relative JJ 19613 8978 8 progress progress NN 19613 8978 9 made make VBN 19613 8978 10 by by IN 19613 8978 11 mankind mankind NN 19613 8978 12 within within IN 19613 8978 13 the the DT 19613 8978 14 Church Church NNP 19613 8978 15 as as IN 19613 8978 16 compared compare VBN 19613 8978 17 with with IN 19613 8978 18 those those DT 19613 8978 19 outside outside IN 19613 8978 20 her -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8978 21 pale pale NN 19613 8978 22 , , , 19613 8978 23 saw see VBD 19613 8978 24 no no DT 19613 8978 25 gulf gulf NN 19613 8978 26 between between IN 19613 8978 27 the the DT 19613 8978 28 growing grow VBG 19613 8978 29 and and CC 19613 8978 30 the the DT 19613 8978 31 perfect perfect JJ 19613 8978 32 , , , 19613 8978 33 and and CC 19613 8978 34 traced trace VBD 19613 8978 35 the the DT 19613 8978 36 whole whole JJ 19613 8978 37 advance advance NN 19613 8978 38 to to IN 19613 8978 39 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8978 40 . . . 19613 8979 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8979 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 8979 3 declared declare VBD 19613 8979 4 , , , 19613 8979 5 c. c. NN 19613 8979 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8979 7 . . . 19613 8980 1 III iii CD 19613 8980 2 . . . 19613 8981 1 78 78 CD 19613 8981 2 , , , 19613 8981 3 that that IN 19613 8981 4 the the DT 19613 8981 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8981 6 which which WDT 19613 8981 7 is be VBZ 19613 8981 8 fitted fit VBN 19613 8981 9 for for IN 19613 8981 10 the the DT 19613 8981 11 comprehension comprehension NN 19613 8981 12 of of IN 19613 8981 13 the the DT 19613 8981 14 multitude multitude NN 19613 8981 15 is be VBZ 19613 8981 16 not not RB 19613 8981 17 the the DT 19613 8981 18 best good JJS 19613 8981 19 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 8981 20 in in IN 19613 8981 21 an an DT 19613 8981 22 absolute absolute JJ 19613 8981 23 , , , 19613 8981 24 but but CC 19613 8981 25 only only RB 19613 8981 26 in in IN 19613 8981 27 a a DT 19613 8981 28 relative relative JJ 19613 8981 29 , , , 19613 8981 30 sense sense NN 19613 8981 31 ; ; : 19613 8981 32 that that IN 19613 8981 33 the the DT 19613 8981 34 " " `` 19613 8981 35 common common JJ 19613 8981 36 man man NN 19613 8981 37 " " '' 19613 8981 38 , , , 19613 8981 39 as as IN 19613 8981 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8981 41 expresses express VBZ 19613 8981 42 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 8981 43 , , , 19613 8981 44 must must MD 19613 8981 45 be be VB 19613 8981 46 reformed reform VBN 19613 8981 47 by by IN 19613 8981 48 the the DT 19613 8981 49 prospect prospect NN 19613 8981 50 of of IN 19613 8981 51 rewards reward NNS 19613 8981 52 and and CC 19613 8981 53 punishments punishment NNS 19613 8981 54 ; ; : 19613 8981 55 and and CC 19613 8981 56 that that IN 19613 8981 57 the the DT 19613 8981 58 truth truth NN 19613 8981 59 can can MD 19613 8981 60 only only RB 19613 8981 61 be be VB 19613 8981 62 communicated communicate VBN 19613 8981 63 to to IN 19613 8981 64 him -PRON- PRP 19613 8981 65 in in IN 19613 8981 66 veiled veiled JJ 19613 8981 67 forms form NNS 19613 8981 68 and and CC 19613 8981 69 images image NNS 19613 8981 70 , , , 19613 8981 71 as as IN 19613 8981 72 to to IN 19613 8981 73 a a DT 19613 8981 74 child child NN 19613 8981 75 . . . 19613 8982 1 The the DT 19613 8982 2 very very JJ 19613 8982 3 fact fact NN 19613 8982 4 , , , 19613 8982 5 however however RB 19613 8982 6 , , , 19613 8982 7 that that IN 19613 8982 8 the the DT 19613 8982 9 Logos Logos NNP 19613 8982 10 in in IN 19613 8982 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 8982 12 Christ Christ NNP 19613 8982 13 has have VBZ 19613 8982 14 condescended condescend VBN 19613 8982 15 so so RB 19613 8982 16 to to TO 19613 8982 17 act act VB 19613 8982 18 is be VBZ 19613 8982 19 to to TO 19613 8982 20 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8982 21 a a DT 19613 8982 22 proof proof NN 19613 8982 23 of of IN 19613 8982 24 the the DT 19613 8982 25 universality universality NN 19613 8982 26 of of IN 19613 8982 27 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 8982 28 . . . 19613 8983 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 8983 2 , , , 19613 8983 3 many many JJ 19613 8983 4 of of IN 19613 8983 5 the the DT 19613 8983 6 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 8983 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 19613 8983 8 reported report VBN 19613 8983 9 in in IN 19613 8983 10 the the DT 19613 8983 11 Holy Holy NNP 19613 8983 12 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 8983 13 belong belong VBP 19613 8983 14 in in IN 19613 8983 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8983 16 opinion opinion NN 19613 8983 17 to to IN 19613 8983 18 the the DT 19613 8983 19 veiled veiled JJ 19613 8983 20 forms form NNS 19613 8983 21 and and CC 19613 8983 22 images image NNS 19613 8983 23 . . . 19613 8984 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8984 2 is be VBZ 19613 8984 3 very very RB 19613 8984 4 far far RB 19613 8984 5 from from IN 19613 8984 6 doing do VBG 19613 8984 7 violence violence NN 19613 8984 8 to to IN 19613 8984 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8984 10 reason reason NN 19613 8984 11 here here RB 19613 8984 12 ; ; : 19613 8984 13 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8984 14 rather rather RB 19613 8984 15 appeals appeal VBZ 19613 8984 16 to to IN 19613 8984 17 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 8984 18 powers power NNS 19613 8984 19 of of IN 19613 8984 20 the the DT 19613 8984 21 soul soul NN 19613 8984 22 , , , 19613 8984 23 to to IN 19613 8984 24 powers power NNS 19613 8984 25 of of IN 19613 8984 26 divination divination NN 19613 8984 27 , , , 19613 8984 28 visionary visionary JJ 19613 8984 29 states state NNS 19613 8984 30 etc etc FW 19613 8984 31 . . . 19613 8985 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8985 2 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 8985 3 in in IN 19613 8985 4 this this DT 19613 8985 5 case case NN 19613 8985 6 is be VBZ 19613 8985 7 wholly wholly RB 19613 8985 8 that that DT 19613 8985 9 of of IN 19613 8985 10 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 8985 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8985 12 see see VB 19613 8985 13 particularly particularly RB 19613 8985 14 the the DT 19613 8985 15 instructive instructive JJ 19613 8985 16 disquisition disquisition NN 19613 8985 17 in in IN 19613 8985 18 I. I. NNP 19613 8986 1 48 48 CD 19613 8986 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8986 3 , , , 19613 8986 4 in in IN 19613 8986 5 so so RB 19613 8986 6 far far RB 19613 8986 7 as as IN 19613 8986 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 8986 9 is be VBZ 19613 8986 10 convinced convince VBN 19613 8986 11 that that IN 19613 8986 12 many many JJ 19613 8986 13 unusual unusual JJ 19613 8986 14 things thing NNS 19613 8986 15 take take VB 19613 8986 16 place place NN 19613 8986 17 between between IN 19613 8986 18 heaven heaven NNP 19613 8986 19 and and CC 19613 8986 20 earth earth NN 19613 8986 21 , , , 19613 8986 22 and and CC 19613 8986 23 that that IN 19613 8986 24 individual individual JJ 19613 8986 25 names name NNS 19613 8986 26 , , , 19613 8986 27 symbols symbol NNS 19613 8986 28 etc etc FW 19613 8986 29 . . . 19613 8987 1 possess possess VB 19613 8987 2 a a DT 19613 8987 3 mysterious mysterious JJ 19613 8987 4 power power NN 19613 8987 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8987 6 see see VB 19613 8987 7 , , , 19613 8987 8 for for IN 19613 8987 9 example example NN 19613 8987 10 , , , 19613 8987 11 c. c. NNP 19613 8987 12 Cels Cels NNP 19613 8987 13 . . . 19613 8988 1 V. V. NNP 19613 8988 2 45 45 CD 19613 8988 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8988 4 . . . 19613 8989 1 The the DT 19613 8989 2 views view NNS 19613 8989 3 as as IN 19613 8989 4 to to IN 19613 8989 5 the the DT 19613 8989 6 relationship relationship NN 19613 8989 7 between between IN 19613 8989 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 8989 9 and and CC 19613 8989 10 holy holy JJ 19613 8989 11 initiation initiation NN 19613 8989 12 or or CC 19613 8989 13 _ _ NNP 19613 8989 14 sacramentum sacramentum NN 19613 8989 15 _ _ NNP 19613 8989 16 are be VBP 19613 8989 17 those those DT 19613 8989 18 of of IN 19613 8989 19 the the DT 19613 8989 20 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 8989 21 of of IN 19613 8989 22 the the DT 19613 8989 23 age age NN 19613 8989 24 . . . 19613 8990 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 8990 2 thinks think VBZ 19613 8990 3 , , , 19613 8990 4 however however RB 19613 8990 5 , , , 19613 8990 6 that that IN 19613 8990 7 each each DT 19613 8990 8 individual individual JJ 19613 8990 9 case case NN 19613 8990 10 requires require VBZ 19613 8990 11 to to TO 19613 8990 12 be be VB 19613 8990 13 examined examine VBN 19613 8990 14 , , , 19613 8990 15 that that IN 19613 8990 16 there there EX 19613 8990 17 can can MD 19613 8990 18 be be VB 19613 8990 19 no no DT 19613 8990 20 miracles miracle NNS 19613 8990 21 not not RB 19613 8990 22 in in IN 19613 8990 23 accordance accordance NN 19613 8990 24 with with IN 19613 8990 25 nature nature NN 19613 8990 26 , , , 19613 8990 27 but but CC 19613 8990 28 that that IN 19613 8990 29 on on IN 19613 8990 30 the the DT 19613 8990 31 contrary contrary JJ 19613 8990 32 everything everything NN 19613 8990 33 must must MD 19613 8990 34 fit fit VB 19613 8990 35 into into IN 19613 8990 36 a a DT 19613 8990 37 higher high JJR 19613 8990 38 order order NN 19613 8990 39 . . . 19613 8991 1 As as IN 19613 8991 2 the the DT 19613 8991 3 letter letter NN 19613 8991 4 of of IN 19613 8991 5 the the DT 19613 8991 6 precepts precept NNS 19613 8991 7 in in IN 19613 8991 8 both both DT 19613 8991 9 Testaments Testaments NNP 19613 8991 10 frequently frequently RB 19613 8991 11 contains contain VBZ 19613 8991 12 things thing NNS 19613 8991 13 contrary contrary JJ 19613 8991 14 to to IN 19613 8991 15 reason reason NN 19613 8991 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8991 17 see see VB 19613 8991 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 8991 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 8991 20 : : : 19613 8991 21 peri peri NN 19613 8991 22 archôn archôn NN 19613 8991 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 8991 24 IV IV NNP 19613 8991 25 . . . 19613 8992 1 2 2 LS 19613 8992 2 . . . 19613 8993 1 8 8 CD 19613 8993 2 - - SYM 19613 8993 3 27 27 CD 19613 8993 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8993 5 in in IN 19613 8993 6 order order NN 19613 8993 7 to to TO 19613 8993 8 lead lead VB 19613 8993 9 men man NNS 19613 8993 10 to to IN 19613 8993 11 the the DT 19613 8993 12 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8993 13 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 8993 14 , , , 19613 8993 15 and and CC 19613 8993 16 as as IN 19613 8993 17 many many JJ 19613 8993 18 passages passage NNS 19613 8993 19 contain contain VBP 19613 8993 20 no no DT 19613 8993 21 literal literal JJ 19613 8993 22 sense sense NN 19613 8993 23 at at RB 19613 8993 24 all all RB 19613 8993 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8993 26 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8993 27 . . . 19613 8994 1 § § ADD 19613 8994 2 12 12 CD 19613 8994 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8994 4 , , , 19613 8994 5 so so RB 19613 8994 6 also also RB 19613 8994 7 , , , 19613 8994 8 in in IN 19613 8994 9 the the DT 19613 8994 10 historical historical JJ 19613 8994 11 narratives narrative NNS 19613 8994 12 , , , 19613 8994 13 we -PRON- PRP 19613 8994 14 frequently frequently RB 19613 8994 15 discover discover VBP 19613 8994 16 a a DT 19613 8994 17 mythical mythical JJ 19613 8994 18 element element NN 19613 8994 19 from from IN 19613 8994 20 which which WDT 19613 8994 21 consequently consequently RB 19613 8994 22 nothing nothing NN 19613 8994 23 but but IN 19613 8994 24 the the DT 19613 8994 25 idea idea NN 19613 8994 26 is be VBZ 19613 8994 27 to to TO 19613 8994 28 be be VB 19613 8994 29 evolved evolve VBN 19613 8994 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 8994 31 l.c l.c NNP 19613 8994 32 . . . 19613 8995 1 § § ADD 19613 8995 2 16 16 CD 19613 8995 3 sq sq NN 19613 8995 4 . . . 19613 8996 1 : : : 19613 8996 2 " " `` 19613 8996 3 Non Non NNP 19613 8996 4 solum solum NN 19613 8996 5 de de VBD 19613 8996 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 8996 7 , , , 19613 8996 8 quæ quæ NNP 19613 8996 9 usque usque NNP 19613 8996 10 ad ad NN 19613 8996 11 adventum adventum NN 19613 8996 12 Christi Christi NNP 19613 8996 13 scripta scripta NNP 19613 8996 14 sunt sunt NN 19613 8996 15 , , , 19613 8996 16 hæc hæc NNP 19613 8996 17 Spiritus Spiritus NNP 19613 8996 18 sanctus sanctus NN 19613 8996 19 procuravit procuravit NNP 19613 8996 20 , , , 19613 8996 21 sed sed NNP 19613 8996 22 ... ... NFP 19613 8996 23 eadem eadem NN 19613 8996 24 similiter similiter NN 19613 8996 25 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8996 26 in in IN 19613 8996 27 evangelistis evangelistis NNP 19613 8996 28 et et FW 19613 8996 29 apostolis apostolis NNP 19613 8996 30 fecit fecit NN 19613 8996 31 . . . 19613 8997 1 Nam Nam NNP 19613 8997 2 ne ne NNP 19613 8997 3 illas illas NNP 19613 8997 4 quidem quidem VBP 19613 8997 5 narrationes narratione NNS 19613 8997 6 , , , 19613 8997 7 quas qua VBN 19613 8997 8 per per IN 19613 8997 9 eos eos NNP 19613 8997 10 inspiravit inspiravit NNP 19613 8997 11 , , , 19613 8997 12 absque absque NNP 19613 8997 13 huiuscemodi huiuscemodi NNP 19613 8997 14 , , , 19613 8997 15 quam quam NNP 19613 8997 16 supra supra NNP 19613 8997 17 exposuimus exposuimus NNP 19613 8997 18 , , , 19613 8997 19 sapientiæ sapientiæ NNP 19613 8997 20 suæ suæ NNP 19613 8997 21 arte arte NNP 19613 8997 22 contexuit contexuit NN 19613 8997 23 . . . 19613 8998 1 Unde Unde NNP 19613 8998 2 etiam etiam NNP 19613 8998 3 in in IN 19613 8998 4 ipsis ipsis NN 19613 8998 5 non non NNP 19613 8998 6 parva parva NNP 19613 8998 7 promiscuit promiscuit NN 19613 8998 8 , , , 19613 8998 9 quibus quibus NNP 19613 8998 10 historialis historialis NNP 19613 8998 11 narrandi narrandi NNP 19613 8998 12 ordo ordo NNP 19613 8998 13 interpolates interpolates NNP 19613 8998 14 , , , 19613 8998 15 vel vel NNP 19613 8998 16 intercisus intercisus NNP 19613 8998 17 per per IN 19613 8998 18 impossibilitatem impossibilitatem NNP 19613 8998 19 sui sui NNP 19613 8998 20 reflecteret reflecteret NNP 19613 8998 21 atque atque NNP 19613 8998 22 revocaret revocaret NNP 19613 8998 23 intentionem intentionem NNP 19613 8998 24 legentis legentis NNP 19613 8998 25 ad ad NN 19613 8998 26 intelligentiæ intelligentiæ NNP 19613 8998 27 interioris interioris NNP 19613 8998 28 examen examan NNS 19613 8998 29 . . . 19613 8998 30 " " '' 19613 8998 31 ) ) -RRB- 19613 8999 1 In in IN 19613 8999 2 all all DT 19613 8999 3 such such JJ 19613 8999 4 cases case NNS 19613 8999 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 8999 6 makes make VBZ 19613 8999 7 uniform uniform JJ 19613 8999 8 use use NN 19613 8999 9 of of IN 19613 8999 10 the the DT 19613 8999 11 two two CD 19613 8999 12 points point NNS 19613 8999 13 of of IN 19613 8999 14 view view NN 19613 8999 15 , , , 19613 8999 16 that that IN 19613 8999 17 God God NNP 19613 8999 18 wished wish VBD 19613 8999 19 to to TO 19613 8999 20 present present VB 19613 8999 21 something something NN 19613 8999 22 even even RB 19613 8999 23 to to IN 19613 8999 24 the the DT 19613 8999 25 simple simple NN 19613 8999 26 and and CC 19613 8999 27 to to TO 19613 8999 28 incite incite VB 19613 8999 29 the the DT 19613 8999 30 more more RBR 19613 8999 31 advanced advanced JJ 19613 8999 32 to to IN 19613 8999 33 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 8999 34 investigations investigation NNS 19613 8999 35 . . . 19613 9000 1 In in IN 19613 9000 2 some some DT 19613 9000 3 passages passage NNS 19613 9000 4 , , , 19613 9000 5 however however RB 19613 9000 6 , , , 19613 9000 7 the the DT 19613 9000 8 former former JJ 19613 9000 9 point point NN 19613 9000 10 of of IN 19613 9000 11 view view NN 19613 9000 12 fails fail VBZ 19613 9000 13 , , , 19613 9000 14 because because IN 19613 9000 15 the the DT 19613 9000 16 content content NN 19613 9000 17 of of IN 19613 9000 18 the the DT 19613 9000 19 text text NN 19613 9000 20 is be VBZ 19613 9000 21 offensive offensive JJ 19613 9000 22 ; ; : 19613 9000 23 in in IN 19613 9000 24 that that DT 19613 9000 25 case case NN 19613 9000 26 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9000 27 is be VBZ 19613 9000 28 only only RB 19613 9000 29 the the DT 19613 9000 30 second second JJ 19613 9000 31 that that WDT 19613 9000 32 applies apply VBZ 19613 9000 33 . . . 19613 9001 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9001 2 therefore therefore RB 19613 9001 3 was be VBD 19613 9001 4 very very RB 19613 9001 5 far far RB 19613 9001 6 from from IN 19613 9001 7 finding find VBG 19613 9001 8 the the DT 19613 9001 9 literal literal JJ 19613 9001 10 content content NN 19613 9001 11 of of IN 19613 9001 12 Scripture scripture NN 19613 9001 13 edifying edifying NN 19613 9001 14 in in IN 19613 9001 15 every every DT 19613 9001 16 instance instance NN 19613 9001 17 , , , 19613 9001 18 indeed indeed RB 19613 9001 19 , , , 19613 9001 20 in in IN 19613 9001 21 the the DT 19613 9001 22 highest high JJS 19613 9001 23 sense sense NN 19613 9001 24 , , , 19613 9001 25 the the DT 19613 9001 26 letter letter NN 19613 9001 27 is be VBZ 19613 9001 28 not not RB 19613 9001 29 edifying edify VBG 19613 9001 30 at at RB 19613 9001 31 all all RB 19613 9001 32 . . . 19613 9002 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9002 2 rather rather RB 19613 9002 3 adopted adopt VBD 19613 9002 4 , , , 19613 9002 5 to to IN 19613 9002 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9002 7 widest wide JJS 19613 9002 8 extent extent NN 19613 9002 9 , , , 19613 9002 10 the the DT 19613 9002 11 critical critical JJ 19613 9002 12 method method NN 19613 9002 13 employed employ VBN 19613 9002 14 by by IN 19613 9002 15 the the DT 19613 9002 16 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 9002 17 particularly particularly RB 19613 9002 18 when when WRB 19613 9002 19 dealing deal VBG 19613 9002 20 with with IN 19613 9002 21 the the DT 19613 9002 22 Old Old NNP 19613 9002 23 Testament Testament NNP 19613 9002 24 ; ; : 19613 9002 25 but but CC 19613 9002 26 the the DT 19613 9002 27 distinction distinction NN 19613 9002 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9002 29 made make VBD 19613 9002 30 between between IN 19613 9002 31 the the DT 19613 9002 32 different different JJ 19613 9002 33 senses sense NNS 19613 9002 34 of of IN 19613 9002 35 Scripture scripture NN 19613 9002 36 and and CC 19613 9002 37 between between IN 19613 9002 38 the the DT 19613 9002 39 various various JJ 19613 9002 40 legitimate legitimate JJ 19613 9002 41 human human JJ 19613 9002 42 needs need NNS 19613 9002 43 enabled enable VBD 19613 9002 44 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9002 45 to to TO 19613 9002 46 preserve preserve VB 19613 9002 47 both both CC 19613 9002 48 the the DT 19613 9002 49 unity unity NN 19613 9002 50 of of IN 19613 9002 51 God God NNP 19613 9002 52 and and CC 19613 9002 53 the the DT 19613 9002 54 harmony harmony NN 19613 9002 55 of of IN 19613 9002 56 revelation revelation NN 19613 9002 57 . . . 19613 9003 1 Herein Herein NNP 19613 9003 2 , , , 19613 9003 3 both both CC 19613 9003 4 in in IN 19613 9003 5 this this DT 19613 9003 6 case case NN 19613 9003 7 and and CC 19613 9003 8 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 9003 9 else else RB 19613 9003 10 , , , 19613 9003 11 lies lie VBZ 19613 9003 12 the the DT 19613 9003 13 superiority superiority NN 19613 9003 14 of of IN 19613 9003 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9003 16 theology theology NN 19613 9003 17 . . . 19613 9004 1 Read read VB 19613 9004 2 especially especially RB 19613 9004 3 c. c. NN 19613 9004 4 Celsum Celsum NNP 19613 9004 5 I. I. NNP 19613 9005 1 9 9 CD 19613 9005 2 - - SYM 19613 9005 3 12 12 CD 19613 9005 4 . . . 19613 9006 1 After after IN 19613 9006 2 appealing appeal VBG 19613 9006 3 to to IN 19613 9006 4 the the DT 19613 9006 5 twofold twofold JJ 19613 9006 6 religion religion NN 19613 9006 7 among among IN 19613 9006 8 the the DT 19613 9006 9 Egyptians Egyptians NNPS 19613 9006 10 , , , 19613 9006 11 Persians Persians NNPS 19613 9006 12 , , , 19613 9006 13 Syrians Syrians NNPS 19613 9006 14 , , , 19613 9006 15 and and CC 19613 9006 16 Indians Indians NNPS 19613 9006 17 -- -- : 19613 9006 18 the the DT 19613 9006 19 mythical mythical JJ 19613 9006 20 religion religion NN 19613 9006 21 of of IN 19613 9006 22 the the DT 19613 9006 23 multitude multitude NN 19613 9006 24 and and CC 19613 9006 25 the the DT 19613 9006 26 mystery mystery NN 19613 9006 27 - - HYPH 19613 9006 28 religion religion NN 19613 9006 29 of of IN 19613 9006 30 the the DT 19613 9006 31 initiated initiate VBN 19613 9006 32 -- -- : 19613 9006 33 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9006 34 lays lay VBZ 19613 9006 35 down down RP 19613 9006 36 exactly exactly RB 19613 9006 37 the the DT 19613 9006 38 same same JJ 19613 9006 39 distinction distinction NN 19613 9006 40 within within IN 19613 9006 41 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 9006 42 , , , 19613 9006 43 and and CC 19613 9006 44 thus thus RB 19613 9006 45 repels repel VBZ 19613 9006 46 the the DT 19613 9006 47 reproach reproach NN 19613 9006 48 of of IN 19613 9006 49 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9006 50 that that IN 19613 9006 51 the the DT 19613 9006 52 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 9006 53 were be VBD 19613 9006 54 obliged oblige VBN 19613 9006 55 to to TO 19613 9006 56 accept accept VB 19613 9006 57 everything everything NN 19613 9006 58 without without IN 19613 9006 59 examination examination NN 19613 9006 60 . . . 19613 9007 1 With with IN 19613 9007 2 regard regard NN 19613 9007 3 to to IN 19613 9007 4 the the DT 19613 9007 5 mythical mythical JJ 19613 9007 6 form form NN 19613 9007 7 of of IN 19613 9007 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 9007 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9007 10 merely merely RB 19613 9007 11 claims claim VBZ 19613 9007 12 that that IN 19613 9007 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9007 14 is be VBZ 19613 9007 15 the the DT 19613 9007 16 most most RBS 19613 9007 17 suitable suitable JJ 19613 9007 18 among among IN 19613 9007 19 religions religion NNS 19613 9007 20 of of IN 19613 9007 21 this this DT 19613 9007 22 type type NN 19613 9007 23 . . . 19613 9008 1 Since since IN 19613 9008 2 , , , 19613 9008 3 as as IN 19613 9008 4 a a DT 19613 9008 5 matter matter NN 19613 9008 6 of of IN 19613 9008 7 fact fact NN 19613 9008 8 , , , 19613 9008 9 the the DT 19613 9008 10 great great JJ 19613 9008 11 majority majority NN 19613 9008 12 of of IN 19613 9008 13 men man NNS 19613 9008 14 have have VBP 19613 9008 15 neither neither CC 19613 9008 16 time time NN 19613 9008 17 nor nor CC 19613 9008 18 talent talent NN 19613 9008 19 for for IN 19613 9008 20 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 9008 21 , , , 19613 9008 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9008 23 Greek greek JJ 19613 9008 24 : : : 19613 9008 25 poia poia VB 19613 9008 26 an an DT 19613 9008 27 allê allê NN 19613 9008 28 beltiôn beltiôn NNP 19613 9008 29 methodos methodos NNP 19613 9008 30 pros pro NNS 19613 9008 31 to to IN 19613 9008 32 tois tois NNP 19613 9008 33 pollois pollois NNP 19613 9008 34 boêthêsai boêthêsai NNP 19613 9008 35 heuretheiê heuretheiê NNP 19613 9008 36 , , , 19613 9008 37 tês tês NNP 19613 9008 38 apo apo NNP 19613 9008 39 tou tou NNP 19613 9008 40 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 9008 41 tois tois NN 19613 9008 42 ethnesi ethnesi JJ 19613 9008 43 paradotheisês paradotheisês NN 19613 9008 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9008 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9008 46 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9008 47 . . NNP 19613 9008 48 , , , 19613 9008 49 9 9 CD 19613 9008 50 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9008 51 . . . 19613 9009 1 This this DT 19613 9009 2 thought thought NN 19613 9009 3 is be VBZ 19613 9009 4 quite quite RB 19613 9009 5 in in IN 19613 9009 6 the the DT 19613 9009 7 spirit spirit NN 19613 9009 8 of of IN 19613 9009 9 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 9009 10 , , , 19613 9009 11 and and CC 19613 9009 12 neither neither CC 19613 9009 13 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9009 14 nor nor CC 19613 9009 15 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 9009 16 could could MD 19613 9009 17 have have VB 19613 9009 18 any any DT 19613 9009 19 fault fault NN 19613 9009 20 to to TO 19613 9009 21 find find VB 19613 9009 22 with with IN 19613 9009 23 these these DT 19613 9009 24 arguments argument NNS 19613 9009 25 in in IN 19613 9009 26 point point NN 19613 9009 27 of of IN 19613 9009 28 form form NN 19613 9009 29 : : : 19613 9009 30 all all DT 19613 9009 31 positive positive JJ 19613 9009 32 religions religion NNS 19613 9009 33 have have VBP 19613 9009 34 a a DT 19613 9009 35 mythical mythical JJ 19613 9009 36 element element NN 19613 9009 37 ; ; : 19613 9009 38 the the DT 19613 9009 39 true true JJ 19613 9009 40 religion religion NN 19613 9009 41 therefore therefore RB 19613 9009 42 lies lie VBZ 19613 9009 43 behind behind IN 19613 9009 44 the the DT 19613 9009 45 religions religion NNS 19613 9009 46 . . . 19613 9010 1 But but CC 19613 9010 2 the the DT 19613 9010 3 novelty novelty NN 19613 9010 4 which which WDT 19613 9010 5 neither neither CC 19613 9010 6 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9010 7 nor nor CC 19613 9010 8 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 9010 9 could could MD 19613 9010 10 recognise recognise VB 19613 9010 11 lies lie NNS 19613 9010 12 in in IN 19613 9010 13 the the DT 19613 9010 14 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 19613 9010 15 that that IN 19613 9010 16 the the DT 19613 9010 17 one one CD 19613 9010 18 religion religion NN 19613 9010 19 , , , 19613 9010 20 even even RB 19613 9010 21 in in IN 19613 9010 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9010 23 mythical mythical JJ 19613 9010 24 form form NN 19613 9010 25 , , , 19613 9010 26 is be VBZ 19613 9010 27 unique unique JJ 19613 9010 28 and and CC 19613 9010 29 divine divine JJ 19613 9010 30 , , , 19613 9010 31 and and CC 19613 9010 32 in in IN 19613 9010 33 the the DT 19613 9010 34 demand demand NN 19613 9010 35 that that IN 19613 9010 36 all all DT 19613 9010 37 men man NNS 19613 9010 38 , , , 19613 9010 39 so so RB 19613 9010 40 far far RB 19613 9010 41 as as IN 19613 9010 42 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9010 43 can can MD 19613 9010 44 not not RB 19613 9010 45 attain attain VB 19613 9010 46 the the DT 19613 9010 47 highest high JJS 19613 9010 48 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 9010 49 , , , 19613 9010 50 must must MD 19613 9010 51 subject subject VB 19613 9010 52 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 9010 53 to to IN 19613 9010 54 this this DT 19613 9010 55 mythical mythical JJ 19613 9010 56 religion religion NN 19613 9010 57 and and CC 19613 9010 58 no no DT 19613 9010 59 other other JJ 19613 9010 60 . . . 19613 9011 1 In in IN 19613 9011 2 this this DT 19613 9011 3 claim claim NN 19613 9011 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9011 5 rejected reject VBD 19613 9011 6 the the DT 19613 9011 7 ancient ancient JJ 19613 9011 8 contrast contrast NN 19613 9011 9 between between IN 19613 9011 10 the the DT 19613 9011 11 multitude multitude NNP 19613 9011 12 and and CC 19613 9011 13 the the DT 19613 9011 14 initiated initiate VBN 19613 9011 15 just just RB 19613 9011 16 as as IN 19613 9011 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9011 18 repudiated repudiate VBD 19613 9011 19 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 9011 20 ; ; , 19613 9011 21 and and CC 19613 9011 22 in in IN 19613 9011 23 this this DT 19613 9011 24 , , , 19613 9011 25 if if IN 19613 9011 26 I -PRON- PRP 19613 9011 27 see see VBP 19613 9011 28 rightly rightly RB 19613 9011 29 , , , 19613 9011 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9011 31 historical historical JJ 19613 9011 32 greatness greatness NN 19613 9011 33 consists consist VBZ 19613 9011 34 . . . 19613 9012 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9012 2 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 9012 3 recognised recognise VBD 19613 9012 4 gradations gradation NNS 19613 9012 5 tending tend VBG 19613 9012 6 in in IN 19613 9012 7 the the DT 19613 9012 8 same same JJ 19613 9012 9 direction direction NN 19613 9012 10 and and CC 19613 9012 11 rejected reject VBN 19613 9012 12 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 9012 13 . . . 19613 9012 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9013 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9013 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9013 3 700 700 CD 19613 9013 4 : : : 19613 9013 5 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9013 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9013 7 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9013 8 . . NNP 19613 9013 9 , , , 19613 9013 10 p. p. NN 19613 9013 11 154 154 CD 19613 9013 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9013 13 has have VBZ 19613 9013 14 rightly rightly RB 19613 9013 15 remarked remark VBN 19613 9013 16 : : : 19613 9013 17 " " `` 19613 9013 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9013 19 in in IN 19613 9013 20 point point NN 19613 9013 21 of of IN 19613 9013 22 method method NN 19613 9013 23 differs differ NNS 19613 9013 24 most most RBS 19613 9013 25 from from IN 19613 9013 26 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9013 27 , , , 19613 9013 28 who who WP 19613 9013 29 not not RB 19613 9013 30 unfrequently unfrequently RB 19613 9013 31 leaves leave VBZ 19613 9013 32 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9013 33 in in IN 19613 9013 34 doubt doubt NN 19613 9013 35 as as IN 19613 9013 36 to to IN 19613 9013 37 the the DT 19613 9013 38 precise precise JJ 19613 9013 39 Scriptural Scriptural NNP 19613 9013 40 basis basis NN 19613 9013 41 of of IN 19613 9013 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9013 43 ideas idea NNS 19613 9013 44 . . . 19613 9013 45 " " '' 19613 9013 46 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9014 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9014 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9014 3 701 701 CD 19613 9014 4 : : : 19613 9014 5 Note note VB 19613 9014 6 , , , 19613 9014 7 for for IN 19613 9014 8 example example NN 19613 9014 9 , , , 19613 9014 10 § § ADD 19613 9014 11 8 8 CD 19613 9014 12 , , , 19613 9014 13 where where WRB 19613 9014 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9014 15 is be VBZ 19613 9014 16 said say VBN 19613 9014 17 that that IN 19613 9014 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9014 19 adopted adopt VBD 19613 9014 20 the the DT 19613 9014 21 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 9014 22 method method NN 19613 9014 23 from from IN 19613 9014 24 the the DT 19613 9014 25 Stoic stoic JJ 19613 9014 26 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 9014 27 and and CC 19613 9014 28 applied apply VBD 19613 9014 29 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9014 30 to to IN 19613 9014 31 the the DT 19613 9014 32 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 9014 33 writings writing NNS 19613 9014 34 . . . 19613 9015 1 On on IN 19613 9015 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9015 3 's 's POS 19613 9015 4 hermeneutic hermeneutic JJ 19613 9015 5 principles principle NNS 19613 9015 6 in in IN 19613 9015 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9015 8 relation relation NN 19613 9015 9 to to IN 19613 9015 10 those those DT 19613 9015 11 of of IN 19613 9015 12 Philo Philo NNP 19613 9015 13 see see VBP 19613 9015 14 Siegfried Siegfried NNP 19613 9015 15 , , , 19613 9015 16 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9015 17 . . NNP 19613 9015 18 , , , 19613 9015 19 pp pp NNP 19613 9015 20 . . . 19613 9016 1 351 351 CD 19613 9016 2 - - SYM 19613 9016 3 62 62 CD 19613 9016 4 . . . 19613 9017 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9017 2 has have VBZ 19613 9017 3 developed develop VBN 19613 9017 4 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9017 5 fully fully RB 19613 9017 6 and and CC 19613 9017 7 clearly clearly RB 19613 9017 8 in in IN 19613 9017 9 the the DT 19613 9017 10 4th 4th JJ 19613 9017 11 Book book NN 19613 9017 12 of of IN 19613 9017 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9017 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9017 15 : : : 19613 9017 16 peri peri NNP 19613 9017 17 archôn archôn NN 19613 9017 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9017 19 . . . 19613 9017 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9018 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9018 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9018 3 702 702 CD 19613 9018 4 : : : 19613 9018 5 See see VB 19613 9018 6 Overbeck Overbeck NNP 19613 9018 7 , , , 19613 9018 8 Theologische Theologische NNP 19613 9018 9 Literatur Literatur NNP 19613 9018 10 - - HYPH 19613 9018 11 Zeitung Zeitung NNP 19613 9018 12 , , , 19613 9018 13 1878 1878 CD 19613 9018 14 , , , 19613 9018 15 Col Col NNP 19613 9018 16 . . . 19613 9019 1 535 535 CD 19613 9019 2 . . . 19613 9019 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9020 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9020 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9020 3 703 703 CD 19613 9020 4 : : : 19613 9020 5 A a DT 19613 9020 6 full full JJ 19613 9020 7 presentation presentation NN 19613 9020 8 of of IN 19613 9020 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9020 10 's 's POS 19613 9020 11 theology theology NN 19613 9020 12 would would MD 19613 9020 13 require require VB 19613 9020 14 many many JJ 19613 9020 15 hundreds hundred NNS 19613 9020 16 of of IN 19613 9020 17 pages page NNS 19613 9020 18 , , , 19613 9020 19 because because IN 19613 9020 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9020 21 introduced introduce VBD 19613 9020 22 everything everything NN 19613 9020 23 worth worth JJ 19613 9020 24 knowing know VBG 19613 9020 25 into into IN 19613 9020 26 the the DT 19613 9020 27 sphere sphere NN 19613 9020 28 of of IN 19613 9020 29 theology theology NN 19613 9020 30 , , , 19613 9020 31 and and CC 19613 9020 32 associated associate VBN 19613 9020 33 with with IN 19613 9020 34 the the DT 19613 9020 35 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9020 36 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 9020 37 , , , 19613 9020 38 verse verse NN 19613 9020 39 by by IN 19613 9020 40 verse verse NN 19613 9020 41 , , , 19613 9020 42 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 9020 43 maxims maxim NNS 19613 9020 44 , , , 19613 9020 45 ethical ethical JJ 19613 9020 46 reflexions reflexion NNS 19613 9020 47 , , , 19613 9020 48 and and CC 19613 9020 49 results result NNS 19613 9020 50 of of IN 19613 9020 51 physical physical JJ 19613 9020 52 science science NN 19613 9020 53 , , , 19613 9020 54 which which WDT 19613 9020 55 would would MD 19613 9020 56 require require VB 19613 9020 57 to to TO 19613 9020 58 be be VB 19613 9020 59 drawn draw VBN 19613 9020 60 on on IN 19613 9020 61 the the DT 19613 9020 62 widest wide JJS 19613 9020 63 canvas canvas NN 19613 9020 64 , , , 19613 9020 65 because because IN 19613 9020 66 the the DT 19613 9020 67 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 9020 68 selected select VBN 19613 9020 69 by by IN 19613 9020 70 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9020 71 allowed allow VBD 19613 9020 72 the the DT 19613 9020 73 most most RBS 19613 9020 74 extensive extensive JJ 19613 9020 75 view view NN 19613 9020 76 and and CC 19613 9020 77 the the DT 19613 9020 78 most most RBS 19613 9020 79 varied varied JJ 19613 9020 80 judgments judgment NNS 19613 9020 81 . . . 19613 9021 1 The the DT 19613 9021 2 case case NN 19613 9021 3 was be VBD 19613 9021 4 similar similar JJ 19613 9021 5 with with IN 19613 9021 6 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9021 7 before before IN 19613 9021 8 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9021 9 , , , 19613 9021 10 and and CC 19613 9021 11 also also RB 19613 9021 12 with with IN 19613 9021 13 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 9021 14 . . . 19613 9022 1 This this DT 19613 9022 2 is be VBZ 19613 9022 3 a a DT 19613 9022 4 necessary necessary JJ 19613 9022 5 result result NN 19613 9022 6 of of IN 19613 9022 7 " " `` 19613 9022 8 Scripture scripture NN 19613 9022 9 theology theology NN 19613 9022 10 " " '' 19613 9022 11 when when WRB 19613 9022 12 one one PRP 19613 9022 13 takes take VBZ 19613 9022 14 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9022 15 up up RP 19613 9022 16 in in IN 19613 9022 17 earnest earnest NN 19613 9022 18 . . . 19613 9023 1 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 9023 2 assumes assume VBZ 19613 9023 3 , , , 19613 9023 4 for for IN 19613 9023 5 example example NN 19613 9023 6 , , , 19613 9023 7 that that IN 19613 9023 8 there there EX 19613 9023 9 must must MD 19613 9023 10 be be VB 19613 9023 11 a a DT 19613 9023 12 Christian christian JJ 19613 9023 13 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9023 14 of of IN 19613 9023 15 dreams dream NNS 19613 9023 16 . . . 19613 9024 1 Why why WRB 19613 9024 2 ? ? . 19613 9025 1 Because because IN 19613 9025 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9025 3 read read VBP 19613 9025 4 of of IN 19613 9025 5 dreams dream NNS 19613 9025 6 in in IN 19613 9025 7 the the DT 19613 9025 8 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9025 9 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 9025 10 . . . 19613 9025 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9026 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9026 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9026 3 704 704 CD 19613 9026 4 : : : 19613 9026 5 In in IN 19613 9026 6 c. c. NNP 19613 9026 7 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9026 8 . . . 19613 9027 1 III iii CD 19613 9027 2 . . . 19613 9028 1 61 61 CD 19613 9028 2 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9028 3 is be VBZ 19613 9028 4 said say VBN 19613 9028 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9028 6 Lommatzsch Lommatzsch NNP 19613 9028 7 XVIII XVIII NNP 19613 9028 8 . . . 19613 9028 9 , , , 19613 9028 10 p. p. NN 19613 9028 11 337 337 CD 19613 9028 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9028 13 : : : 19613 9028 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9028 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9028 16 : : : 19613 9028 17 epemphthê epemphthê VB 19613 9028 18 oun oun NNP 19613 9028 19 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9028 20 logos logo VBZ 19613 9028 21 katho katho JJ 19613 9028 22 men man NNS 19613 9028 23 iatros iatros NNP 19613 9028 24 tois tois NNP 19613 9028 25 hamartôlois hamartôlois NNP 19613 9028 26 , , , 19613 9028 27 katho katho NNP 19613 9028 28 de de NNP 19613 9028 29 didaskalos didaskalos NNP 19613 9028 30 theiôn theiôn NNP 19613 9028 31 mustêrion mustêrion NNP 19613 9028 32 tois tois NNP 19613 9028 33 êdê êdê NNP 19613 9028 34 katharois katharois NNP 19613 9028 35 kai kai NNP 19613 9028 36 mêketi mêketi NNP 19613 9028 37 hamartanousin hamartanousin NNP 19613 9028 38 . . . 19613 9028 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9029 1 See see VB 19613 9029 2 also also RB 19613 9029 3 what what WP 19613 9029 4 follows follow VBZ 19613 9029 5 . . . 19613 9030 1 In in IN 19613 9030 2 Comment Comment NNP 19613 9030 3 . . . 19613 9031 1 in in IN 19613 9031 2 John John NNP 19613 9031 3 I. I. NNP 19613 9032 1 20 20 CD 19613 9032 2 sq sq NN 19613 9032 3 . . . 19613 9033 1 the the DT 19613 9033 2 crucified crucified JJ 19613 9033 3 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9033 4 , , , 19613 9033 5 as as IN 19613 9033 6 the the DT 19613 9033 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9033 8 of of IN 19613 9033 9 faith faith NN 19613 9033 10 , , , 19613 9033 11 is be VBZ 19613 9033 12 distinguished distinguish VBN 19613 9033 13 from from IN 19613 9033 14 the the DT 19613 9033 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9033 16 who who WP 19613 9033 17 takes take VBZ 19613 9033 18 up up RP 19613 9033 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9033 20 abode abode NN 19613 9033 21 in in IN 19613 9033 22 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9033 23 , , , 19613 9033 24 as as IN 19613 9033 25 the the DT 19613 9033 26 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9033 27 of of IN 19613 9033 28 the the DT 19613 9033 29 perfect perfect NN 19613 9033 30 . . . 19613 9034 1 See see VB 19613 9034 2 22 22 CD 19613 9034 3 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9034 4 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9034 5 . . . 19613 9035 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9035 2 p. p. NN 19613 9035 3 43 43 CD 19613 9035 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9035 5 : : : 19613 9035 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9035 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9035 8 : : : 19613 9035 9 kai kai NNP 19613 9035 10 makarioi makarioi NNP 19613 9035 11 ge ge NNP 19613 9035 12 hosoi hosoi NNP 19613 9035 13 deomenoi deomenoi NNP 19613 9035 14 tou tou NNP 19613 9035 15 huiou huiou NNP 19613 9035 16 tou tou NNP 19613 9035 17 Theou Theou NNP 19613 9035 18 toioutoi toioutoi NNP 19613 9035 19 gegonasin gegonasin NN 19613 9035 20 , , , 19613 9035 21 hôs hôs NNP 19613 9035 22 mêketi mêketi NNP 19613 9035 23 autou autou NNP 19613 9035 24 chrazein chrazein NNP 19613 9035 25 iatrou iatrou NNP 19613 9035 26 tous tous NNP 19613 9035 27 kakôs kakôs NNP 19613 9035 28 hechontas hechontas NNP 19613 9035 29 therapeuontos therapeuontos NNP 19613 9035 30 , , , 19613 9035 31 mêde mêde NNP 19613 9035 32 poimenos poimenos NNP 19613 9035 33 , , , 19613 9035 34 mêde mêde NNP 19613 9035 35 apolutrôseôs apolutrôseôs NN 19613 9035 36 , , , 19613 9035 37 alla alla NN 19613 9035 38 sophias sophias NNP 19613 9035 39 kai kai NNP 19613 9035 40 logou logou NNP 19613 9035 41 kai kai NNP 19613 9035 42 dikaiosunês dikaiosunês NNP 19613 9035 43 , , , 19613 9035 44 hê hê NNP 19613 9035 45 ei ei NNP 19613 9035 46 ti ti NNP 19613 9035 47 allo allo NNP 19613 9035 48 tois tois NNP 19613 9035 49 dia dia NNP 19613 9035 50 teleiotêta teleiotêta NNP 19613 9035 51 chôrein chôrein NNP 19613 9035 52 autou autou NNP 19613 9035 53 ta ta NNP 19613 9035 54 kallista kallista NNP 19613 9035 55 dunamenois dunamenois NNP 19613 9035 56 . . . 19613 9035 57 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9036 1 Read read VB 19613 9036 2 also also RB 19613 9036 3 c. c. NN 19613 9036 4 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9036 5 . . . 19613 9037 1 II ii CD 19613 9037 2 . . . 19613 9038 1 66 66 CD 19613 9038 2 , , , 19613 9038 3 69 69 CD 19613 9038 4 : : : 19613 9038 5 IV IV NNP 19613 9038 6 . . . 19613 9039 1 15 15 CD 19613 9039 2 , , , 19613 9039 3 18 18 CD 19613 9039 4 : : : 19613 9039 5 VI VI NNP 19613 9039 6 . . . 19613 9040 1 68 68 CD 19613 9040 2 . . . 19613 9041 1 These these DT 19613 9041 2 passages passage NNS 19613 9041 3 show show VBP 19613 9041 4 that that IN 19613 9041 5 the the DT 19613 9041 6 crucified crucify VBN 19613 9041 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9041 8 is be VBZ 19613 9041 9 no no RB 19613 9041 10 longer long JJR 19613 9041 11 of of IN 19613 9041 12 any any DT 19613 9041 13 account account NN 19613 9041 14 to to IN 19613 9041 15 the the DT 19613 9041 16 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 9041 17 , , , 19613 9041 18 and and CC 19613 9041 19 that that IN 19613 9041 20 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9041 21 therefore therefore RB 19613 9041 22 allegorises allegorise VBZ 19613 9041 23 all all PDT 19613 9041 24 the the DT 19613 9041 25 incidents incident NNS 19613 9041 26 described describe VBN 19613 9041 27 in in IN 19613 9041 28 the the DT 19613 9041 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 19613 9041 30 . . . 19613 9042 1 Clement clement NN 19613 9042 2 , , , 19613 9042 3 too too RB 19613 9042 4 , , , 19613 9042 5 really really RB 19613 9042 6 regards regard VBZ 19613 9042 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9042 8 as as IN 19613 9042 9 of of IN 19613 9042 10 no no DT 19613 9042 11 importance importance NN 19613 9042 12 to to IN 19613 9042 13 Gnostics Gnostics NNP 19613 9042 14 except except IN 19613 9042 15 as as IN 19613 9042 16 a a DT 19613 9042 17 teacher teacher NN 19613 9042 18 . . . 19613 9042 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9043 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9043 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9043 3 705 705 CD 19613 9043 4 : : : 19613 9043 5 Comment comment NN 19613 9043 6 , , , 19613 9043 7 in in IN 19613 9043 8 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9043 9 . . . 19613 9044 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9045 1 9 9 LS 19613 9045 2 , , , 19613 9045 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9045 4 . . . 19613 9046 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9046 2 p p NNP 19613 9046 3 , , , 19613 9046 4 20 20 CD 19613 9046 5 . . . 19613 9047 1 The the DT 19613 9047 2 " " `` 19613 9047 3 mysteries mystery NNS 19613 9047 4 " " '' 19613 9047 5 of of IN 19613 9047 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9047 7 is be VBZ 19613 9047 8 the the DT 19613 9047 9 technical technical JJ 19613 9047 10 term term NN 19613 9047 11 for for IN 19613 9047 12 this this DT 19613 9047 13 theology theology NN 19613 9047 14 and and CC 19613 9047 15 , , , 19613 9047 16 at at IN 19613 9047 17 bottom bottom NN 19613 9047 18 , , , 19613 9047 19 for for IN 19613 9047 20 all all DT 19613 9047 21 theology theology NN 19613 9047 22 . . . 19613 9048 1 For for IN 19613 9048 2 , , , 19613 9048 3 in in IN 19613 9048 4 respect respect NN 19613 9048 5 of of IN 19613 9048 6 the the DT 19613 9048 7 form form NN 19613 9048 8 given give VBN 19613 9048 9 to to IN 19613 9048 10 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9048 11 , , , 19613 9048 12 revelation revelation NN 19613 9048 13 always always RB 19613 9048 14 appears appear VBZ 19613 9048 15 as as IN 19613 9048 16 a a DT 19613 9048 17 problem problem NN 19613 9048 18 that that WDT 19613 9048 19 theology theology NN 19613 9048 20 has have VBZ 19613 9048 21 to to TO 19613 9048 22 solve solve VB 19613 9048 23 . . . 19613 9049 1 What what WP 19613 9049 2 is be VBZ 19613 9049 3 revealed reveal VBN 19613 9049 4 is be VBZ 19613 9049 5 therefore therefore RB 19613 9049 6 either either CC 19613 9049 7 to to TO 19613 9049 8 be be VB 19613 9049 9 taken take VBN 19613 9049 10 as as IN 19613 9049 11 immediate immediate JJ 19613 9049 12 authority authority NN 19613 9049 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9049 14 by by IN 19613 9049 15 the the DT 19613 9049 16 believer believer NN 19613 9049 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9049 18 or or CC 19613 9049 19 as as IN 19613 9049 20 a a DT 19613 9049 21 soluble soluble JJ 19613 9049 22 problem problem NN 19613 9049 23 . . . 19613 9050 1 One one CD 19613 9050 2 thing thing NN 19613 9050 3 , , , 19613 9050 4 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 9050 5 , , , 19613 9050 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9050 7 is be VBZ 19613 9050 8 not not RB 19613 9050 9 , , , 19613 9050 10 namely namely RB 19613 9050 11 , , , 19613 9050 12 something something NN 19613 9050 13 in in IN 19613 9050 14 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 9050 15 evident evident JJ 19613 9050 16 and and CC 19613 9050 17 intelligible intelligible JJ 19613 9050 18 . . . 19613 9050 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9051 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9051 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9051 3 706 706 CD 19613 9051 4 : : : 19613 9051 5 See See NNP 19613 9051 6 Nitzsch Nitzsch NNP 19613 9051 7 , , , 19613 9051 8 Dogmengeschichte Dogmengeschichte NNP 19613 9051 9 , , , 19613 9051 10 p. p. NN 19613 9052 1 136 136 CD 19613 9052 2 . . . 19613 9052 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9053 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9053 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9053 3 707 707 CD 19613 9053 4 : : : 19613 9053 5 To to TO 19613 9053 6 Origen origen VB 19613 9053 7 the the DT 19613 9053 8 problem problem NN 19613 9053 9 of of IN 19613 9053 10 evil evil NN 19613 9053 11 was be VBD 19613 9053 12 one one CD 19613 9053 13 of of IN 19613 9053 14 the the DT 19613 9053 15 most most RBS 19613 9053 16 important important JJ 19613 9053 17 ; ; : 19613 9053 18 see see VB 19613 9053 19 Book Book NNP 19613 9053 20 III III NNP 19613 9053 21 . . . 19613 9054 1 of of IN 19613 9054 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9054 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9054 4 : : : 19613 9054 5 peri peri NNP 19613 9054 6 archôn archôn NN 19613 9054 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9054 8 and and CC 19613 9054 9 c. c. NNP 19613 9054 10 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9054 11 . . . 19613 9055 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9055 2 . . . 19613 9056 1 53 53 CD 19613 9056 2 - - SYM 19613 9056 3 59 59 CD 19613 9056 4 . . . 19613 9057 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9057 2 is be VBZ 19613 9057 3 convinced convinced JJ 19613 9057 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9057 5 1 1 CD 19613 9057 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9057 7 that that IN 19613 9057 8 the the DT 19613 9057 9 world world NN 19613 9057 10 is be VBZ 19613 9057 11 not not RB 19613 9057 12 the the DT 19613 9057 13 work work NN 19613 9057 14 of of IN 19613 9057 15 a a DT 19613 9057 16 second second JJ 19613 9057 17 , , , 19613 9057 18 hostile hostile JJ 19613 9057 19 God God NNP 19613 9057 20 ; ; : 19613 9057 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9057 22 2 2 LS 19613 9057 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9057 24 that that WDT 19613 9057 25 virtues virtue NNS 19613 9057 26 and and CC 19613 9057 27 the the DT 19613 9057 28 works work NNS 19613 9057 29 arising arise VBG 19613 9057 30 from from IN 19613 9057 31 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9057 32 are be VBP 19613 9057 33 alone alone RB 19613 9057 34 good good JJ 19613 9057 35 in in IN 19613 9057 36 the the DT 19613 9057 37 proper proper JJ 19613 9057 38 sense sense NN 19613 9057 39 of of IN 19613 9057 40 the the DT 19613 9057 41 word word NN 19613 9057 42 , , , 19613 9057 43 and and CC 19613 9057 44 that that IN 19613 9057 45 nothing nothing NN 19613 9057 46 but but IN 19613 9057 47 the the DT 19613 9057 48 opposite opposite NN 19613 9057 49 of of IN 19613 9057 50 these these DT 19613 9057 51 is be VBZ 19613 9057 52 bad bad JJ 19613 9057 53 ; ; : 19613 9057 54 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9057 55 3 3 LS 19613 9057 56 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9057 57 that that WDT 19613 9057 58 evil evil NN 19613 9057 59 in in IN 19613 9057 60 the the DT 19613 9057 61 proper proper JJ 19613 9057 62 sense sense NN 19613 9057 63 of of IN 19613 9057 64 the the DT 19613 9057 65 word word NN 19613 9057 66 is be VBZ 19613 9057 67 only only RB 19613 9057 68 evil evil JJ 19613 9057 69 will will MD 19613 9057 70 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9057 71 see see VB 19613 9057 72 c. c. NNP 19613 9057 73 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9057 74 . . . 19613 9058 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9058 2 . . . 19613 9059 1 66 66 CD 19613 9059 2 : : : 19613 9059 3 VI VI NNP 19613 9059 4 . . . 19613 9060 1 54 54 LS 19613 9060 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9060 3 . . . 19613 9061 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 9061 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9061 3 makes make VBZ 19613 9061 4 a a DT 19613 9061 5 very very RB 19613 9061 6 decided decide VBN 19613 9061 7 distinction distinction NN 19613 9061 8 between between IN 19613 9061 9 that that DT 19613 9061 10 which which WDT 19613 9061 11 is be VBZ 19613 9061 12 bad bad JJ 19613 9061 13 and and CC 19613 9061 14 evils evil NNS 19613 9061 15 . . . 19613 9062 1 As as IN 19613 9062 2 for for IN 19613 9062 3 the the DT 19613 9062 4 latter latter JJ 19613 9062 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9062 6 admits admit VBZ 19613 9062 7 that that IN 19613 9062 8 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9062 9 partly partly RB 19613 9062 10 originate originate VBP 19613 9062 11 from from IN 19613 9062 12 God God NNP 19613 9062 13 , , , 19613 9062 14 in in IN 19613 9062 15 which which WDT 19613 9062 16 case case NN 19613 9062 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9062 18 are be VBP 19613 9062 19 designed design VBN 19613 9062 20 as as IN 19613 9062 21 means mean NNS 19613 9062 22 of of IN 19613 9062 23 training training NN 19613 9062 24 and and CC 19613 9062 25 punishment punishment NN 19613 9062 26 . . . 19613 9063 1 But but CC 19613 9063 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9063 3 saw see VBD 19613 9063 4 that that IN 19613 9063 5 this this DT 19613 9063 6 conception conception NN 19613 9063 7 is be VBZ 19613 9063 8 insufficient insufficient JJ 19613 9063 9 , , , 19613 9063 10 both both CC 19613 9063 11 in in IN 19613 9063 12 view view NN 19613 9063 13 of of IN 19613 9063 14 individual individual JJ 19613 9063 15 passages passage NNS 19613 9063 16 of of IN 19613 9063 17 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9063 18 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 9063 19 and and CC 19613 9063 20 of of IN 19613 9063 21 natural natural JJ 19613 9063 22 experience experience NN 19613 9063 23 . . . 19613 9064 1 There there EX 19613 9064 2 are be VBP 19613 9064 3 evils evil NNS 19613 9064 4 in in IN 19613 9064 5 the the DT 19613 9064 6 world world NN 19613 9064 7 that that WDT 19613 9064 8 can can MD 19613 9064 9 be be VB 19613 9064 10 understood understand VBN 19613 9064 11 neither neither CC 19613 9064 12 as as IN 19613 9064 13 the the DT 19613 9064 14 result result NN 19613 9064 15 of of IN 19613 9064 16 sin sin NN 19613 9064 17 nor nor CC 19613 9064 18 as as IN 19613 9064 19 means mean NNS 19613 9064 20 of of IN 19613 9064 21 training training NN 19613 9064 22 . . . 19613 9065 1 Here here RB 19613 9065 2 then then RB 19613 9065 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9065 4 relative relative JJ 19613 9065 5 , , , 19613 9065 6 rational rational JJ 19613 9065 7 view view NN 19613 9065 8 of of IN 19613 9065 9 things thing NNS 19613 9065 10 comes come VBZ 19613 9065 11 in in RB 19613 9065 12 , , , 19613 9065 13 even even RB 19613 9065 14 with with IN 19613 9065 15 respect respect NN 19613 9065 16 to to IN 19613 9065 17 the the DT 19613 9065 18 power power NN 19613 9065 19 of of IN 19613 9065 20 God God NNP 19613 9065 21 . . . 19613 9066 1 There there EX 19613 9066 2 are be VBP 19613 9066 3 evils evil NNS 19613 9066 4 which which WDT 19613 9066 5 are be VBP 19613 9066 6 a a DT 19613 9066 7 necessary necessary JJ 19613 9066 8 consequence consequence NN 19613 9066 9 of of IN 19613 9066 10 carrying carry VBG 19613 9066 11 out out RP 19613 9066 12 even even RB 19613 9066 13 the the DT 19613 9066 14 best good JJS 19613 9066 15 intentions intention NNS 19613 9066 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9066 17 c. c. NNP 19613 9066 18 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9066 19 . . . 19613 9067 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9067 2 . . . 19613 9068 1 53 53 CD 19613 9068 2 : : : 19613 9068 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9068 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9068 5 : : : 19613 9068 6 ta ta NNP 19613 9068 7 kaka kaka NNP 19613 9068 8 ek ek NNP 19613 9068 9 parakolouthêseôs parakolouthêseôs NNP 19613 9068 10 gegenêtai gegenêtai NNP 19613 9068 11 tês tês NNP 19613 9068 12 pros pro NNS 19613 9068 13 ta ta NNP 19613 9068 14 proêgoumena proêgoumena NNP 19613 9068 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9068 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9068 17 : : : 19613 9068 18 " " `` 19613 9068 19 Evils evil NNS 19613 9068 20 , , , 19613 9068 21 in in IN 19613 9068 22 the the DT 19613 9068 23 strict strict JJ 19613 9068 24 sense sense NN 19613 9068 25 , , , 19613 9068 26 are be VBP 19613 9068 27 not not RB 19613 9068 28 created create VBN 19613 9068 29 by by IN 19613 9068 30 God God NNP 19613 9068 31 ; ; : 19613 9068 32 yet yet CC 19613 9068 33 some some DT 19613 9068 34 , , , 19613 9068 35 though though RB 19613 9068 36 but but CC 19613 9068 37 few few JJ 19613 9068 38 in in IN 19613 9068 39 comparison comparison NN 19613 9068 40 with with IN 19613 9068 41 the the DT 19613 9068 42 great great JJ 19613 9068 43 , , , 19613 9068 44 well well RB 19613 9068 45 - - HYPH 19613 9068 46 ordered order VBN 19613 9068 47 whole whole NN 19613 9068 48 of of IN 19613 9068 49 the the DT 19613 9068 50 world world NN 19613 9068 51 , , , 19613 9068 52 have have VBP 19613 9068 53 of of IN 19613 9068 54 necessity necessity NN 19613 9068 55 adhered adhere VBN 19613 9068 56 to to IN 19613 9068 57 the the DT 19613 9068 58 objects object NNS 19613 9068 59 realised realise VBN 19613 9068 60 ; ; : 19613 9068 61 as as IN 19613 9068 62 the the DT 19613 9068 63 carpenter carpenter NN 19613 9068 64 who who WP 19613 9068 65 executes execute VBZ 19613 9068 66 the the DT 19613 9068 67 plan plan NN 19613 9068 68 of of IN 19613 9068 69 a a DT 19613 9068 70 building building NN 19613 9068 71 does do VBZ 19613 9068 72 not not RB 19613 9068 73 manage manage VB 19613 9068 74 without without IN 19613 9068 75 chips chip NNS 19613 9068 76 and and CC 19613 9068 77 similar similar JJ 19613 9068 78 rubbish rubbish NN 19613 9068 79 , , , 19613 9068 80 or or CC 19613 9068 81 as as IN 19613 9068 82 architects architect NNS 19613 9068 83 can can MD 19613 9068 84 not not RB 19613 9068 85 be be VB 19613 9068 86 made make VBN 19613 9068 87 responsible responsible JJ 19613 9068 88 for for IN 19613 9068 89 the the DT 19613 9068 90 dirty dirty JJ 19613 9068 91 heaps heap NNS 19613 9068 92 of of IN 19613 9068 93 broken broken JJ 19613 9068 94 stones stone NNS 19613 9068 95 and and CC 19613 9068 96 filth filth NN 19613 9068 97 one one NN 19613 9068 98 sees see VBZ 19613 9068 99 at at IN 19613 9068 100 the the DT 19613 9068 101 sites site NNS 19613 9068 102 of of IN 19613 9068 103 buildings building NNS 19613 9068 104 ; ; : 19613 9068 105 " " '' 19613 9068 106 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9068 107 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9068 108 . . NNP 19613 9068 109 , , , 19613 9068 110 c. c. NNP 19613 9068 111 55 55 CD 19613 9068 112 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9068 113 . . . 19613 9069 1 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9069 2 also also RB 19613 9069 3 might may MD 19613 9069 4 have have VB 19613 9069 5 written write VBN 19613 9069 6 in in IN 19613 9069 7 this this DT 19613 9069 8 strain strain NN 19613 9069 9 . . . 19613 9070 1 The the DT 19613 9070 2 religious religious JJ 19613 9070 3 , , , 19613 9070 4 absolute absolute JJ 19613 9070 5 view view NN 19613 9070 6 is be VBZ 19613 9070 7 here here RB 19613 9070 8 replaced replace VBN 19613 9070 9 by by IN 19613 9070 10 a a DT 19613 9070 11 rational rational JJ 19613 9070 12 , , , 19613 9070 13 and and CC 19613 9070 14 the the DT 19613 9070 15 world world NN 19613 9070 16 is be VBZ 19613 9070 17 therefore therefore RB 19613 9070 18 not not RB 19613 9070 19 the the DT 19613 9070 20 best good JJS 19613 9070 21 absolutely absolutely RB 19613 9070 22 , , , 19613 9070 23 but but CC 19613 9070 24 the the DT 19613 9070 25 best good JJS 19613 9070 26 possible possible JJ 19613 9070 27 . . . 19613 9071 1 See see VB 19613 9071 2 the the DT 19613 9071 3 Theodicy theodicy NN 19613 9071 4 in in IN 19613 9071 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9071 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9071 7 : : : 19613 9071 8 peri peri NN 19613 9071 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9071 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9071 11 III III NNP 19613 9071 12 . . . 19613 9072 1 17 17 CD 19613 9072 2 - - SYM 19613 9072 3 22 22 CD 19613 9072 4 . . . 19613 9073 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9073 2 Here here RB 19613 9073 3 , , , 19613 9073 4 and and CC 19613 9073 5 also also RB 19613 9073 6 in in IN 19613 9073 7 other other JJ 19613 9073 8 parts part NNS 19613 9073 9 , , , 19613 9073 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9073 11 's 's POS 19613 9073 12 Theodicy Theodicy NNP 19613 9073 13 reminds remind VBZ 19613 9073 14 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9073 15 of of IN 19613 9073 16 that that DT 19613 9073 17 of of IN 19613 9073 18 Leibnitz Leibnitz NNP 19613 9073 19 ; ; : 19613 9073 20 see see VB 19613 9073 21 Denis Denis NNP 19613 9073 22 , , , 19613 9073 23 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9073 24 . . NNP 19613 9073 25 , , , 19613 9073 26 p. p. NN 19613 9073 27 626 626 CD 19613 9073 28 sq sq NN 19613 9073 29 . . . 19613 9074 1 The the DT 19613 9074 2 two two CD 19613 9074 3 great great JJ 19613 9074 4 thinkers thinker NNS 19613 9074 5 have have VBP 19613 9074 6 a a DT 19613 9074 7 very very RB 19613 9074 8 great great JJ 19613 9074 9 deal deal NN 19613 9074 10 in in IN 19613 9074 11 common common JJ 19613 9074 12 , , , 19613 9074 13 because because IN 19613 9074 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9074 15 philosophy philosophy NN 19613 9074 16 was be VBD 19613 9074 17 not not RB 19613 9074 18 of of IN 19613 9074 19 a a DT 19613 9074 20 radical radical JJ 19613 9074 21 kind kind NN 19613 9074 22 , , , 19613 9074 23 but but CC 19613 9074 24 an an DT 19613 9074 25 attempt attempt NN 19613 9074 26 to to TO 19613 9074 27 give give VB 19613 9074 28 a a DT 19613 9074 29 rational rational JJ 19613 9074 30 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 9074 31 to to IN 19613 9074 32 tradition tradition NN 19613 9074 33 . . . 19613 9074 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9075 1 But but CC 19613 9075 2 " " `` 19613 9075 3 for for IN 19613 9075 4 the the DT 19613 9075 5 great great JJ 19613 9075 6 mass mass NN 19613 9075 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9075 8 is be VBZ 19613 9075 9 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 9075 10 when when WRB 19613 9075 11 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9075 12 are be VBP 19613 9075 13 told tell VBN 19613 9075 14 that that IN 19613 9075 15 evil evil NN 19613 9075 16 has have VBZ 19613 9075 17 not not RB 19613 9075 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9075 19 origin origin NN 19613 9075 20 in in IN 19613 9075 21 God God NNP 19613 9075 22 " " '' 19613 9075 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9075 24 IV IV NNP 19613 9075 25 . . . 19613 9076 1 66 66 CD 19613 9076 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9076 3 . . . 19613 9077 1 The the DT 19613 9077 2 case case NN 19613 9077 3 is be VBZ 19613 9077 4 similar similar JJ 19613 9077 5 with with IN 19613 9077 6 that that DT 19613 9077 7 which which WDT 19613 9077 8 is be VBZ 19613 9077 9 really really RB 19613 9077 10 bad bad JJ 19613 9077 11 . . . 19613 9078 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9078 2 is be VBZ 19613 9078 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 9078 4 for for IN 19613 9078 5 the the DT 19613 9078 6 multitude multitude NNP 19613 9078 7 to to TO 19613 9078 8 know know VB 19613 9078 9 that that IN 19613 9078 10 that that DT 19613 9078 11 which which WDT 19613 9078 12 is be VBZ 19613 9078 13 bad bad JJ 19613 9078 14 springs spring NNS 19613 9078 15 from from IN 19613 9078 16 the the DT 19613 9078 17 freedom freedom NN 19613 9078 18 of of IN 19613 9078 19 the the DT 19613 9078 20 creature creature NN 19613 9078 21 , , , 19613 9078 22 and and CC 19613 9078 23 that that DT 19613 9078 24 matter matter NN 19613 9078 25 which which WDT 19613 9078 26 is be VBZ 19613 9078 27 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 9078 28 from from IN 19613 9078 29 things thing NNS 19613 9078 30 mortal mortal JJ 19613 9078 31 is be VBZ 19613 9078 32 not not RB 19613 9078 33 the the DT 19613 9078 34 source source NN 19613 9078 35 and and CC 19613 9078 36 cause cause NN 19613 9078 37 of of IN 19613 9078 38 sin sin NN 19613 9078 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9078 40 IV IV NNP 19613 9078 41 . . . 19613 9079 1 66 66 CD 19613 9079 2 , , , 19613 9079 3 see see VB 19613 9079 4 also also RB 19613 9079 5 III III NNP 19613 9079 6 , , , 19613 9079 7 42 42 CD 19613 9079 8 : : : 19613 9079 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9079 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9079 11 : : : 19613 9079 12 to to TO 19613 9079 13 kuriôs kuriôs VB 19613 9079 14 miaron miaron NNP 19613 9079 15 apo apo NNP 19613 9079 16 kakias kakias NNP 19613 9079 17 toiouton toiouton NNP 19613 9079 18 esti esti NNP 19613 9079 19 . . . 19613 9080 1 Phusis Phusis NNP 19613 9080 2 de de NNP 19613 9080 3 sômatos sômato NNS 19613 9080 4 ou ou NNP 19613 9080 5 miara miara NNP 19613 9080 6 ou ou NNP 19613 9080 7 gar gar NNP 19613 9080 8 hê hê NNP 19613 9080 9 phusis phusis NN 19613 9080 10 sômatos sômato NNS 19613 9080 11 esti esti NNP 19613 9080 12 , , , 19613 9080 13 to to TO 19613 9080 14 gennêtikon gennêtikon NNP 19613 9080 15 tês tês NNP 19613 9080 16 miarotêtos miarotêtos NNP 19613 9080 17 echei echei NNP 19613 9080 18 tên tên NNP 19613 9080 19 kakian kakian NNP 19613 9080 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9080 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9080 22 ; ; : 19613 9080 23 but but CC 19613 9080 24 a a DT 19613 9080 25 closer close JJR 19613 9080 26 examination examination NN 19613 9080 27 shows show VBZ 19613 9080 28 that that IN 19613 9080 29 there there EX 19613 9080 30 can can MD 19613 9080 31 be be VB 19613 9080 32 no no DT 19613 9080 33 man man NN 19613 9080 34 without without IN 19613 9080 35 sin sin NN 19613 9080 36 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9080 37 III iii CD 19613 9080 38 . . . 19613 9081 1 6l 6l LS 19613 9081 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9081 3 because because IN 19613 9081 4 error error NN 19613 9081 5 is be VBZ 19613 9081 6 inseparable inseparable JJ 19613 9081 7 from from IN 19613 9081 8 growth growth NN 19613 9081 9 and and CC 19613 9081 10 because because IN 19613 9081 11 the the DT 19613 9081 12 constitution constitution NNP 19613 9081 13 of of IN 19613 9081 14 man man NN 19613 9081 15 in in IN 19613 9081 16 the the DT 19613 9081 17 flesh flesh NN 19613 9081 18 makes make VBZ 19613 9081 19 evil evil NN 19613 9081 20 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 19613 9081 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9081 22 VII VII NNP 19613 9081 23 . . . 19613 9082 1 50 50 CD 19613 9082 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9082 3 . . . 19613 9083 1 Sinfulness sinfulness NN 19613 9083 2 is be VBZ 19613 9083 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 9083 4 natural natural JJ 19613 9083 5 and and CC 19613 9083 6 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9083 7 is be VBZ 19613 9083 8 the the DT 19613 9083 9 necessary necessary JJ 19613 9083 10 _ _ NNP 19613 9083 11 prius prius NNP 19613 9083 12 _ _ NNP 19613 9083 13 . . . 19613 9084 1 This this DT 19613 9084 2 thought thought NN 19613 9084 3 , , , 19613 9084 4 which which WDT 19613 9084 5 is be VBZ 19613 9084 6 also also RB 19613 9084 7 not not RB 19613 9084 8 foreign foreign JJ 19613 9084 9 to to IN 19613 9084 10 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 9084 11 , , , 19613 9084 12 is be VBZ 19613 9084 13 developed develop VBN 19613 9084 14 by by IN 19613 9084 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9084 16 with with IN 19613 9084 17 the the DT 19613 9084 18 utmost utmost JJ 19613 9084 19 clearness clearness NN 19613 9084 20 . . . 19613 9085 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9085 2 was be VBD 19613 9085 3 not not RB 19613 9085 4 content content JJ 19613 9085 5 with with IN 19613 9085 6 proving prove VBG 19613 9085 7 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9085 8 , , , 19613 9085 9 however however RB 19613 9085 10 , , , 19613 9085 11 but but CC 19613 9085 12 in in IN 19613 9085 13 order order NN 19613 9085 14 to to TO 19613 9085 15 justify justify VB 19613 9085 16 God God NNP 19613 9085 17 's 's POS 19613 9085 18 ways way NNS 19613 9085 19 proceeded proceed VBD 19613 9085 20 to to IN 19613 9085 21 the the DT 19613 9085 22 assumption assumption NN 19613 9085 23 of of IN 19613 9085 24 a a DT 19613 9085 25 Fall Fall NNP 19613 9085 26 before before IN 19613 9085 27 time time NN 19613 9085 28 began begin VBD 19613 9085 29 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9085 30 see see VB 19613 9085 31 below below RB 19613 9085 32 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9085 33 . . . 19613 9085 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9086 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9086 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9086 3 708 708 CD 19613 9086 4 : : : 19613 9086 5 See see VB 19613 9086 6 Mehlhorn Mehlhorn NNP 19613 9086 7 , , , 19613 9086 8 Die die VB 19613 9086 9 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 9086 10 von von NNP 19613 9086 11 der der VBD 19613 9086 12 menschlichen menschlichen NN 19613 9086 13 Freiheit Freiheit NNP 19613 9086 14 nach nach NN 19613 9086 15 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 9086 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9086 17 Zeitschrift Zeitschrift NNP 19613 9086 18 fur fur NN 19613 9086 19 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 19613 9086 20 , , , 19613 9086 21 Vol Vol NNP 19613 9086 22 . . . 19613 9087 1 II II NNP 19613 9087 2 . . NNP 19613 9087 3 , , , 19613 9087 4 p. p. NN 19613 9087 5 234 234 CD 19613 9087 6 ff ff NNP 19613 9087 7 . . . 19613 9087 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9087 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9088 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9088 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9088 3 709 709 CD 19613 9088 4 : : : 19613 9088 5 The the DT 19613 9088 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 9088 7 between between IN 19613 9088 8 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 9088 9 and and CC 19613 9088 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9088 11 consists consist VBZ 19613 9088 12 in in IN 19613 9088 13 the the DT 19613 9088 14 fact fact NN 19613 9088 15 that that IN 19613 9088 16 the the DT 19613 9088 17 former former JJ 19613 9088 18 makes make VBZ 19613 9088 19 an an DT 19613 9088 20 æon æon NN 19613 9088 21 or or CC 19613 9088 22 , , , 19613 9088 23 in in IN 19613 9088 24 other other JJ 19613 9088 25 words word NNS 19613 9088 26 , , , 19613 9088 27 a a DT 19613 9088 28 part part NN 19613 9088 29 of of IN 19613 9088 30 the the DT 19613 9088 31 divine divine JJ 19613 9088 32 _ _ NNP 19613 9088 33 pleroma pleroma NN 19613 9088 34 _ _ NNP 19613 9088 35 , , , 19613 9088 36 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 9088 37 fall fall VBP 19613 9088 38 , , , 19613 9088 39 and and CC 19613 9088 40 that that IN 19613 9088 41 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9088 42 does do VBZ 19613 9088 43 not not RB 19613 9088 44 utilise utilise VB 19613 9088 45 the the DT 19613 9088 46 idea idea NN 19613 9088 47 of of IN 19613 9088 48 freedom freedom NN 19613 9088 49 . . . 19613 9089 1 The the DT 19613 9089 2 outline outline NN 19613 9089 3 of of IN 19613 9089 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9089 5 's 's POS 19613 9089 6 system system NN 19613 9089 7 can can MD 19613 9089 8 not not RB 19613 9089 9 be be VB 19613 9089 10 made make VBN 19613 9089 11 out out RP 19613 9089 12 with with IN 19613 9089 13 complete complete JJ 19613 9089 14 clearness clearness NN 19613 9089 15 from from IN 19613 9089 16 the the DT 19613 9089 17 work work NN 19613 9089 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9089 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9089 20 : : : 19613 9089 21 peri peri NN 19613 9089 22 archôn archôn NN 19613 9089 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9089 24 , , , 19613 9089 25 because because IN 19613 9089 26 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9089 27 endeavoured endeavour VBD 19613 9089 28 to to TO 19613 9089 29 treat treat VB 19613 9089 30 each each DT 19613 9089 31 of of IN 19613 9089 32 the the DT 19613 9089 33 first first JJ 19613 9089 34 three three CD 19613 9089 35 parts part NNS 19613 9089 36 as as IN 19613 9089 37 a a DT 19613 9089 38 whole whole NN 19613 9089 39 . . . 19613 9090 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9090 2 's 's POS 19613 9090 3 four four CD 19613 9090 4 principles principle NNS 19613 9090 5 are be VBP 19613 9090 6 God God NNP 19613 9090 7 , , , 19613 9090 8 the the DT 19613 9090 9 World World NNP 19613 9090 10 , , , 19613 9090 11 Freedom Freedom NNP 19613 9090 12 , , , 19613 9090 13 Revelation Revelation NNP 19613 9090 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9090 15 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9090 16 Scripture Scripture NNP 19613 9090 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9090 18 . . . 19613 9091 1 Each each DT 19613 9091 2 principle principle NN 19613 9091 3 , , , 19613 9091 4 however however RB 19613 9091 5 , , , 19613 9091 6 is be VBZ 19613 9091 7 brought bring VBN 19613 9091 8 into into IN 19613 9091 9 relation relation NN 19613 9091 10 with with IN 19613 9091 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9091 12 . . . 19613 9092 1 The the DT 19613 9092 2 first first JJ 19613 9092 3 part part NN 19613 9092 4 treats treat NNS 19613 9092 5 of of IN 19613 9092 6 God God NNP 19613 9092 7 and and CC 19613 9092 8 the the DT 19613 9092 9 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9092 10 , , , 19613 9092 11 and and CC 19613 9092 12 follows follow VBZ 19613 9092 13 the the DT 19613 9092 14 history history NN 19613 9092 15 of of IN 19613 9092 16 the the DT 19613 9092 17 latter latter JJ 19613 9092 18 down down RP 19613 9092 19 to to IN 19613 9092 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9092 21 restoration restoration NN 19613 9092 22 . . . 19613 9093 1 The the DT 19613 9093 2 second second JJ 19613 9093 3 part part NN 19613 9093 4 treats treat NNS 19613 9093 5 of of IN 19613 9093 6 the the DT 19613 9093 7 world world NN 19613 9093 8 and and CC 19613 9093 9 humanity humanity NN 19613 9093 10 , , , 19613 9093 11 and and CC 19613 9093 12 likewise likewise RB 19613 9093 13 closes close NNS 19613 9093 14 with with IN 19613 9093 15 the the DT 19613 9093 16 prospect prospect NN 19613 9093 17 of of IN 19613 9093 18 the the DT 19613 9093 19 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 9093 20 , , , 19613 9093 21 punishment punishment NN 19613 9093 22 in in IN 19613 9093 23 hell hell NN 19613 9093 24 , , , 19613 9093 25 and and CC 19613 9093 26 eternal eternal JJ 19613 9093 27 life life NN 19613 9093 28 . . . 19613 9094 1 Here here RB 19613 9094 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9094 3 makes make VBZ 19613 9094 4 a a DT 19613 9094 5 magnificent magnificent JJ 19613 9094 6 attempt attempt NN 19613 9094 7 to to TO 19613 9094 8 give give VB 19613 9094 9 a a DT 19613 9094 10 conception conception NN 19613 9094 11 of of IN 19613 9094 12 bliss bliss NN 19613 9094 13 and and CC 19613 9094 14 yet yet RB 19613 9094 15 to to TO 19613 9094 16 exclude exclude VB 19613 9094 17 all all DT 19613 9094 18 sensuous sensuous JJ 19613 9094 19 joys joy NNS 19613 9094 20 . . . 19613 9095 1 The the DT 19613 9095 2 third third JJ 19613 9095 3 book book NN 19613 9095 4 treats treat NNS 19613 9095 5 of of IN 19613 9095 6 sin sin NN 19613 9095 7 and and CC 19613 9095 8 redemption redemption NN 19613 9095 9 , , , 19613 9095 10 that that RB 19613 9095 11 is is RB 19613 9095 12 , , , 19613 9095 13 of of IN 19613 9095 14 freedom freedom NN 19613 9095 15 of of IN 19613 9095 16 will will NN 19613 9095 17 , , , 19613 9095 18 temptation temptation NN 19613 9095 19 , , , 19613 9095 20 the the DT 19613 9095 21 struggle struggle NN 19613 9095 22 with with IN 19613 9095 23 the the DT 19613 9095 24 powers power NNS 19613 9095 25 of of IN 19613 9095 26 evil evil JJ 19613 9095 27 , , , 19613 9095 28 internal internal JJ 19613 9095 29 struggles struggle NNS 19613 9095 30 , , , 19613 9095 31 the the DT 19613 9095 32 moral moral JJ 19613 9095 33 aim aim NN 19613 9095 34 of of IN 19613 9095 35 the the DT 19613 9095 36 world world NN 19613 9095 37 , , , 19613 9095 38 and and CC 19613 9095 39 the the DT 19613 9095 40 restoration restoration NN 19613 9095 41 of of IN 19613 9095 42 all all DT 19613 9095 43 things thing NNS 19613 9095 44 . . . 19613 9096 1 A a DT 19613 9096 2 special special JJ 19613 9096 3 book book NN 19613 9096 4 on on IN 19613 9096 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9096 6 is be VBZ 19613 9096 7 wanting want VBG 19613 9096 8 , , , 19613 9096 9 for for IN 19613 9096 10 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9096 11 is be VBZ 19613 9096 12 no no DT 19613 9096 13 " " `` 19613 9096 14 principle principle NN 19613 9096 15 " " '' 19613 9096 16 ; ; : 19613 9096 17 but but CC 19613 9096 18 the the DT 19613 9096 19 incarnation incarnation NN 19613 9096 20 is be VBZ 19613 9096 21 treated treat VBN 19613 9096 22 of of IN 19613 9096 23 in in IN 19613 9096 24 II II NNP 19613 9096 25 . . . 19613 9097 1 6 6 CD 19613 9097 2 . . . 19613 9098 1 The the DT 19613 9098 2 teachers teacher NNS 19613 9098 3 of of IN 19613 9098 4 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 19613 9098 5 ' ' POS 19613 9098 6 school school NN 19613 9098 7 accordingly accordingly RB 19613 9098 8 appear appear VBP 19613 9098 9 more more JJR 19613 9098 10 Christian Christian NNP 19613 9098 11 when when WRB 19613 9098 12 contrasted contrast VBN 19613 9098 13 with with IN 19613 9098 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9098 15 . . . 19613 9099 1 If if IN 19613 9099 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9099 3 read read VBP 19613 9099 4 the the DT 19613 9099 5 great great JJ 19613 9099 6 work work NN 19613 9099 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9099 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9099 9 : : : 19613 9099 10 peri peri NN 19613 9099 11 archôn archôn NN 19613 9099 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9099 13 , , , 19613 9099 14 or or CC 19613 9099 15 the the DT 19613 9099 16 treatise treatise NN 19613 9099 17 against against IN 19613 9099 18 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9099 19 , , , 19613 9099 20 or or CC 19613 9099 21 the the DT 19613 9099 22 commentaries commentary NNS 19613 9099 23 connectedly connectedly RB 19613 9099 24 , , , 19613 9099 25 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9099 26 never never RB 19613 9099 27 cease cease VBP 19613 9099 28 to to TO 19613 9099 29 wonder wonder VB 19613 9099 30 how how WRB 19613 9099 31 a a DT 19613 9099 32 mind mind NN 19613 9099 33 so so RB 19613 9099 34 clear clear JJ 19613 9099 35 , , , 19613 9099 36 so so RB 19613 9099 37 sure sure JJ 19613 9099 38 of of IN 19613 9099 39 the the DT 19613 9099 40 ultimate ultimate JJ 19613 9099 41 aim aim NN 19613 9099 42 of of IN 19613 9099 43 all all DT 19613 9099 44 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 9099 45 , , , 19613 9099 46 and and CC 19613 9099 47 occupying occupy VBG 19613 9099 48 such such PDT 19613 9099 49 a a DT 19613 9099 50 high high JJ 19613 9099 51 standpoint standpoint NN 19613 9099 52 , , , 19613 9099 53 has have VBZ 19613 9099 54 admitted admit VBN 19613 9099 55 in in IN 19613 9099 56 details detail NNS 19613 9099 57 all all DT 19613 9099 58 possible possible JJ 19613 9099 59 views view NNS 19613 9099 60 down down RP 19613 9099 61 to to IN 19613 9099 62 the the DT 19613 9099 63 most most RBS 19613 9099 64 naive naive JJ 19613 9099 65 myths myth NNS 19613 9099 66 , , , 19613 9099 67 and and CC 19613 9099 68 how how WRB 19613 9099 69 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9099 70 on on IN 19613 9099 71 the the DT 19613 9099 72 one one CD 19613 9099 73 hand hand NN 19613 9099 74 believes believe VBZ 19613 9099 75 in in IN 19613 9099 76 holy holy NNP 19613 9099 77 magic magic NNP 19613 9099 78 , , , 19613 9099 79 sacramental sacramental JJ 19613 9099 80 vehicles vehicle NNS 19613 9099 81 and and CC 19613 9099 82 the the DT 19613 9099 83 like like JJ 19613 9099 84 , , , 19613 9099 85 and and CC 19613 9099 86 on on IN 19613 9099 87 the the DT 19613 9099 88 other other JJ 19613 9099 89 , , , 19613 9099 90 in in IN 19613 9099 91 spite spite NN 19613 9099 92 of of IN 19613 9099 93 all all DT 19613 9099 94 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9099 95 rational rational JJ 19613 9099 96 and and CC 19613 9099 97 even even RB 19613 9099 98 empirical empirical JJ 19613 9099 99 views view NNS 19613 9099 100 , , , 19613 9099 101 betrays betray VBZ 19613 9099 102 no no DT 19613 9099 103 doubt doubt NN 19613 9099 104 of of IN 19613 9099 105 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9099 106 abstract abstract JJ 19613 9099 107 creations creation NNS 19613 9099 108 . . . 19613 9100 1 But but CC 19613 9100 2 the the DT 19613 9100 3 problem problem NN 19613 9100 4 that that WDT 19613 9100 5 confronts confront VBZ 19613 9100 6 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9100 7 in in IN 19613 9100 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9100 9 is be VBZ 19613 9100 10 that that IN 19613 9100 11 presented present VBN 19613 9100 12 by by IN 19613 9100 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9100 14 age age NN 19613 9100 15 . . . 19613 9101 1 This this DT 19613 9101 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9101 3 realise realise VBP 19613 9101 4 on on IN 19613 9101 5 reading read VBG 19613 9101 6 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9101 7 or or CC 19613 9101 8 Porphyry Porphyry NNP 19613 9101 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9101 10 see see VB 19613 9101 11 Denis Denis NNP 19613 9101 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9101 13 . . NNP 19613 9101 14 , , , 19613 9101 15 p. p. NN 19613 9101 16 613 613 CD 19613 9101 17 : : : 19613 9101 18 " " `` 19613 9101 19 Toutes toute NNS 19613 9101 20 les les VBP 19613 9101 21 théories théorie NNS 19613 9101 22 d'Origène d'Origène NNP 19613 9101 23 , , , 19613 9101 24 même même JJ 19613 9101 25 les les NNP 19613 9101 26 plus plus CC 19613 9101 27 imaginaires imaginaires NNP 19613 9101 28 , , , 19613 9101 29 représent représent NNP 19613 9101 30 l'état l'état NNP 19613 9101 31 intellectuel intellectuel NNP 19613 9101 32 et et NNP 19613 9101 33 moral moral JJ 19613 9101 34 du du NNP 19613 9101 35 siècle siècle NNP 19613 9101 36 où où IN 19613 9101 37 il il NNP 19613 9101 38 a a DT 19613 9101 39 paru paru NN 19613 9101 40 " " '' 19613 9101 41 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9101 42 . . . 19613 9102 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 9102 2 , , , 19613 9102 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9102 4 is be VBZ 19613 9102 5 not not RB 19613 9102 6 a a DT 19613 9102 7 teacher teacher NN 19613 9102 8 who who WP 19613 9102 9 , , , 19613 9102 10 like like IN 19613 9102 11 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 9102 12 , , , 19613 9102 13 was be VBD 19613 9102 14 in in IN 19613 9102 15 advance advance NN 19613 9102 16 of of IN 19613 9102 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9102 18 time time NN 19613 9102 19 , , , 19613 9102 20 though though IN 19613 9102 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9102 22 no no RB 19613 9102 23 doubt doubt RB 19613 9102 24 anticipated anticipate VBD 19613 9102 25 the the DT 19613 9102 26 course course NN 19613 9102 27 of of IN 19613 9102 28 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 9102 29 development development NN 19613 9102 30 . . . 19613 9103 1 This this DT 19613 9103 2 age age NN 19613 9103 3 , , , 19613 9103 4 as as IN 19613 9103 5 represented represent VBN 19613 9103 6 by by IN 19613 9103 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9103 8 greatest great JJS 19613 9103 9 men man NNS 19613 9103 10 , , , 19613 9103 11 sought seek VBD 19613 9103 12 to to TO 19613 9103 13 gain gain VB 19613 9103 14 a a DT 19613 9103 15 substructure substructure NN 19613 9103 16 for for IN 19613 9103 17 something something NN 19613 9103 18 new new JJ 19613 9103 19 , , , 19613 9103 20 not not RB 19613 9103 21 by by IN 19613 9103 22 a a DT 19613 9103 23 critical critical JJ 19613 9103 24 examination examination NN 19613 9103 25 of of IN 19613 9103 26 the the DT 19613 9103 27 old old JJ 19613 9103 28 ideas idea NNS 19613 9103 29 , , , 19613 9103 30 but but CC 19613 9103 31 by by IN 19613 9103 32 incorporating incorporate VBG 19613 9103 33 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9103 34 all all DT 19613 9103 35 into into IN 19613 9103 36 one one CD 19613 9103 37 whole whole NN 19613 9103 38 . . . 19613 9104 1 People People NNS 19613 9104 2 were be VBD 19613 9104 3 anxious anxious JJ 19613 9104 4 to to TO 19613 9104 5 have have VB 19613 9104 6 assurance assurance NN 19613 9104 7 , , , 19613 9104 8 and and CC 19613 9104 9 , , , 19613 9104 10 in in IN 19613 9104 11 the the DT 19613 9104 12 endeavour endeavour NN 19613 9104 13 to to TO 19613 9104 14 find find VB 19613 9104 15 this this DT 19613 9104 16 , , , 19613 9104 17 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9104 18 were be VBD 19613 9104 19 nervous nervous JJ 19613 9104 20 about about IN 19613 9104 21 giving give VBG 19613 9104 22 up up RP 19613 9104 23 any any DT 19613 9104 24 article article NN 19613 9104 25 of of IN 19613 9104 26 tradition tradition NN 19613 9104 27 . . . 19613 9105 1 The the DT 19613 9105 2 boldness boldness NN 19613 9105 3 of of IN 19613 9105 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9105 5 , , , 19613 9105 6 judged judge VBD 19613 9105 7 as as IN 19613 9105 8 a a DT 19613 9105 9 Greek greek JJ 19613 9105 10 philosopher philosopher NN 19613 9105 11 , , , 19613 9105 12 lies lie VBZ 19613 9105 13 in in IN 19613 9105 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9105 15 rejection rejection NN 19613 9105 16 of of IN 19613 9105 17 all all DT 19613 9105 18 polytheistic polytheistic JJ 19613 9105 19 religions religion NNS 19613 9105 20 . . . 19613 9106 1 This this DT 19613 9106 2 made make VBD 19613 9106 3 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9106 4 all all PDT 19613 9106 5 the the DT 19613 9106 6 more more RBR 19613 9106 7 conservative conservative JJ 19613 9106 8 in in IN 19613 9106 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9106 10 endeavours endeavour NNS 19613 9106 11 to to TO 19613 9106 12 protect protect VB 19613 9106 13 and and CC 19613 9106 14 incorporate incorporate VB 19613 9106 15 everything everything NN 19613 9106 16 else else RB 19613 9106 17 . . . 19613 9107 1 This this DT 19613 9107 2 conservatism conservatism NN 19613 9107 3 welded weld VBD 19613 9107 4 together together RB 19613 9107 5 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 19613 9107 6 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 9107 7 and and CC 19613 9107 8 Greek greek JJ 19613 9107 9 culture culture NN 19613 9107 10 into into IN 19613 9107 11 a a DT 19613 9107 12 system system NN 19613 9107 13 of of IN 19613 9107 14 theology theology NN 19613 9107 15 which which WDT 19613 9107 16 was be VBD 19613 9107 17 indeed indeed RB 19613 9107 18 completely completely RB 19613 9107 19 heterodox heterodox JJ 19613 9107 20 . . . 19613 9107 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9108 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9108 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9108 3 710 710 CD 19613 9108 4 : : : 19613 9108 5 The the DT 19613 9108 6 proof proof NN 19613 9108 7 from from IN 19613 9108 8 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 9108 9 was be VBD 19613 9108 10 reckoned reckon VBN 19613 9108 11 by by IN 19613 9108 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9108 13 among among IN 19613 9108 14 the the DT 19613 9108 15 articles article NNS 19613 9108 16 belonging belong VBG 19613 9108 17 to to IN 19613 9108 18 faith faith NN 19613 9108 19 , , , 19613 9108 20 but but CC 19613 9108 21 not not RB 19613 9108 22 to to IN 19613 9108 23 Gnosis Gnosis NNP 19613 9108 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9108 25 see see VB 19613 9108 26 for for IN 19613 9108 27 ex ex NNP 19613 9108 28 . . . 19613 9109 1 c. c. NNP 19613 9109 2 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9109 3 . . . 19613 9110 1 II ii CD 19613 9110 2 . . . 19613 9111 1 37 37 CD 19613 9111 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9111 3 ; ; : 19613 9111 4 but but CC 19613 9111 5 , , , 19613 9111 6 like like IN 19613 9111 7 the the DT 19613 9111 8 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 9111 9 , , , 19613 9111 10 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9111 11 found find VBD 19613 9111 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9111 13 of of IN 19613 9111 14 great great JJ 19613 9111 15 value value NN 19613 9111 16 . . . 19613 9112 1 As as RB 19613 9112 2 far far RB 19613 9112 3 as as IN 19613 9112 4 the the DT 19613 9112 5 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 9112 6 are be VBP 19613 9112 7 concerned concern VBN 19613 9112 8 , , , 19613 9112 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9112 10 always always RB 19613 9112 11 bore bear VBD 19613 9112 12 in in IN 19613 9112 13 mind mind NN 19613 9112 14 the the DT 19613 9112 15 principle principle NN 19613 9112 16 expressed express VBN 19613 9112 17 in in IN 19613 9112 18 c. c. NNP 19613 9112 19 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9112 20 . . . 19613 9113 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9113 2 . . . 19613 9114 1 46 46 CD 19613 9114 2 : : : 19613 9114 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9114 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9114 5 : : : 19613 9114 6 pros pro NNS 19613 9114 7 tauta tauta VBP 19613 9114 8 d'êmeis d'êmeis NNP 19613 9114 9 phêsomen phêsoman NNS 19613 9114 10 hoi hoi NNP 19613 9114 11 meletêsantes meletêsantes NNP 19613 9114 12 mêdeni mêdeni NNP 19613 9114 13 apechthanesthai apechthanesthai NNP 19613 9114 14 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9114 15 kalôs kalôs NNP 19613 9114 16 legomenôn legomenôn NNP 19613 9114 17 ; ; : 19613 9114 18 kan kan NNP 19613 9114 19 hoi hoi NNP 19613 9114 20 hexô hexô NNP 19613 9114 21 tês tês NNP 19613 9114 22 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 9114 23 legôusi legôusi NNP 19613 9114 24 kalôs kalôs NNP 19613 9114 25 . . . 19613 9114 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9115 1 In in IN 19613 9115 2 that that DT 19613 9115 3 same same JJ 19613 9115 4 place place NN 19613 9115 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9115 6 is be VBZ 19613 9115 7 asserted assert VBN 19613 9115 8 that that IN 19613 9115 9 God God NNP 19613 9115 10 in in IN 19613 9115 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9115 12 love love NN 19613 9115 13 has have VBZ 19613 9115 14 not not RB 19613 9115 15 only only RB 19613 9115 16 revealed reveal VBN 19613 9115 17 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9115 18 to to IN 19613 9115 19 such such JJ 19613 9115 20 as as IN 19613 9115 21 entirely entirely RB 19613 9115 22 consecrate consecrate VB 19613 9115 23 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 9115 24 to to IN 19613 9115 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9115 26 service service NN 19613 9115 27 , , , 19613 9115 28 but but CC 19613 9115 29 also also RB 19613 9115 30 to to IN 19613 9115 31 such such JJ 19613 9115 32 as as IN 19613 9115 33 do do VBP 19613 9115 34 not not RB 19613 9115 35 know know VB 19613 9115 36 the the DT 19613 9115 37 true true JJ 19613 9115 38 adoration adoration NN 19613 9115 39 and and CC 19613 9115 40 reverence reverence NN 19613 9115 41 which which WDT 19613 9115 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9115 43 requires require VBZ 19613 9115 44 . . . 19613 9116 1 But but CC 19613 9116 2 as as IN 19613 9116 3 remarked remark VBN 19613 9116 4 above above RB 19613 9116 5 , , , 19613 9116 6 p. p. NN 19613 9116 7 338 338 CD 19613 9116 8 , , , 19613 9116 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9116 10 's 's POS 19613 9116 11 attitude attitude NN 19613 9116 12 to to IN 19613 9116 13 the the DT 19613 9116 14 Greek greek JJ 19613 9116 15 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 9116 16 is be VBZ 19613 9116 17 much much RB 19613 9116 18 more more RBR 19613 9116 19 reserved reserved JJ 19613 9116 20 than than IN 19613 9116 21 that that DT 19613 9116 22 of of IN 19613 9116 23 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9116 24 . . . 19613 9116 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9117 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9117 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9117 3 711 711 CD 19613 9117 4 : : : 19613 9117 5 See see VB 19613 9117 6 , , , 19613 9117 7 for for IN 19613 9117 8 ex ex NNP 19613 9117 9 . . NNP 19613 9117 10 , , , 19613 9117 11 c. c. NNP 19613 9117 12 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9117 13 . . . 19613 9118 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9118 2 . . . 19613 9119 1 6 6 LS 19613 9119 2 , , , 19613 9119 3 Comment Comment NNP 19613 9119 4 in in IN 19613 9119 5 Johann Johann NNP 19613 9119 6 . . . 19613 9120 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9120 2 . . . 19613 9121 1 59 59 LS 19613 9121 2 , , , 19613 9121 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9121 4 . . . 19613 9122 1 II II NNP 19613 9122 2 . . NNP 19613 9122 3 , , , 19613 9122 4 p. p. NN 19613 9122 5 9 9 CD 19613 9122 6 sq sq NNP 19613 9122 7 . . . 19613 9122 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9123 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9123 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9123 3 712 712 CD 19613 9123 4 : : : 19613 9123 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9123 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9123 7 : : : 19613 9123 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9123 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9123 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9123 11 preface preface NN 19613 9123 12 . . . 19613 9123 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9124 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9124 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9124 3 713 713 CD 19613 9124 4 : : : 19613 9124 5 On on IN 19613 9124 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9124 7 's 's POS 19613 9124 8 exegetical exegetical JJ 19613 9124 9 method method NN 19613 9124 10 see see VBP 19613 9124 11 Kihn Kihn NNP 19613 9124 12 , , , 19613 9124 13 Theodor Theodor NNP 19613 9124 14 v. v. IN 19613 9124 15 Mopsu Mopsu NNP 19613 9124 16 . . . 19613 9125 1 p. p. NN 19613 9125 2 20 20 CD 19613 9125 3 ff ff NN 19613 9125 4 . . NNP 19613 9125 5 , , , 19613 9125 6 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9125 7 , , , 19613 9125 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9125 9 . . . 19613 9126 1 p. p. NN 19613 9126 2 131 131 CD 19613 9126 3 ff ff NNP 19613 9126 4 . . . 19613 9127 1 On on IN 19613 9127 2 the the DT 19613 9127 3 distinction distinction NN 19613 9127 4 between between IN 19613 9127 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9127 6 application application NN 19613 9127 7 of of IN 19613 9127 8 the the DT 19613 9127 9 allegorical allegorical JJ 19613 9127 10 method method NN 19613 9127 11 and and CC 19613 9127 12 that that DT 19613 9127 13 of of IN 19613 9127 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9127 15 see see VBP 19613 9127 16 specially specially RB 19613 9127 17 p. p. NN 19613 9127 18 134 134 CD 19613 9127 19 f. f. NNS 19613 9127 20 of of IN 19613 9127 21 the the DT 19613 9127 22 latter latter JJ 19613 9127 23 work work NN 19613 9127 24 . . . 19613 9127 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9128 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9128 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9128 3 714 714 CD 19613 9128 4 : : : 19613 9128 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9128 6 noted note VBD 19613 9128 7 several several JJ 19613 9128 8 such such JJ 19613 9128 9 passages passage NNS 19613 9128 10 in in IN 19613 9128 11 the the DT 19613 9128 12 very very RB 19613 9128 13 first first JJ 19613 9128 14 chapter chapter NN 19613 9128 15 of of IN 19613 9128 16 Genesis Genesis NNP 19613 9128 17 . . . 19613 9129 1 Examples example NNS 19613 9129 2 are be VBP 19613 9129 3 given give VBN 19613 9129 4 in in IN 19613 9129 5 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9129 6 , , , 19613 9129 7 p. p. NN 19613 9129 8 137 137 CD 19613 9129 9 f. f. NN 19613 9129 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9129 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9129 12 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9129 13 715 715 CD 19613 9129 14 : : : 19613 9129 15 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9129 16 , , , 19613 9129 17 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9129 18 . . NNP 19613 9129 19 , , , 19613 9129 20 has have VBZ 19613 9129 21 very very RB 19613 9129 22 appropriately appropriately RB 19613 9129 23 named name VBN 19613 9129 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9129 25 's 's POS 19613 9129 26 allegorism allegorism NN 19613 9129 27 " " `` 19613 9129 28 Biblical biblical JJ 19613 9129 29 alchemy alchemy NN 19613 9129 30 " " '' 19613 9129 31 . . . 19613 9129 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9130 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9130 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9130 3 716 716 CD 19613 9130 4 : : : 19613 9130 5 To to TO 19613 9130 6 ascertain ascertain VB 19613 9130 7 the the DT 19613 9130 8 pneumatic pneumatic JJ 19613 9130 9 sense sense NN 19613 9130 10 , , , 19613 9130 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9130 12 frequently frequently RB 19613 9130 13 drew draw VBD 19613 9130 14 analogies analogy NNS 19613 9130 15 between between IN 19613 9130 16 the the DT 19613 9130 17 domain domain NN 19613 9130 18 of of IN 19613 9130 19 the the DT 19613 9130 20 cosmic cosmic JJ 19613 9130 21 and and CC 19613 9130 22 that that DT 19613 9130 23 of of IN 19613 9130 24 the the DT 19613 9130 25 spiritual spiritual NN 19613 9130 26 . . . 19613 9131 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9131 2 is be VBZ 19613 9131 3 thus thus RB 19613 9131 4 a a DT 19613 9131 5 forerunner forerunner NN 19613 9131 6 of of IN 19613 9131 7 modern modern JJ 19613 9131 8 idealistic idealistic JJ 19613 9131 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 19613 9131 10 , , , 19613 9131 11 for for IN 19613 9131 12 example example NN 19613 9131 13 , , , 19613 9131 14 Drummond drummond NN 19613 9131 15 : : : 19613 9131 16 " " `` 19613 9131 17 To to IN 19613 9131 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9131 19 allegorism allegorism NN 19613 9131 20 is be VBZ 19613 9131 21 only only RB 19613 9131 22 one one CD 19613 9131 23 manifestation manifestation NN 19613 9131 24 of of IN 19613 9131 25 the the DT 19613 9131 26 sacramental sacramental JJ 19613 9131 27 mystery mystery NN 19613 9131 28 of of IN 19613 9131 29 nature nature NN 19613 9131 30 " " '' 19613 9131 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9131 32 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9131 33 , , , 19613 9131 34 p. p. NN 19613 9132 1 134 134 CD 19613 9132 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9132 3 . . . 19613 9132 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9133 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9133 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9133 3 717 717 CD 19613 9133 4 : : : 19613 9133 5 See see VB 19613 9133 6 Hom Hom NNP 19613 9133 7 in in IN 19613 9133 8 Luc Luc NNP 19613 9133 9 . . . 19613 9134 1 XXIX XXIX NNP 19613 9134 2 . . . 19613 9134 3 , , , 19613 9134 4 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9134 5 . . . 19613 9135 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9135 2 , , , 19613 9135 3 p. p. NN 19613 9135 4 193 193 CD 19613 9135 5 sq sq NNP 19613 9135 6 . . NNP 19613 9135 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9136 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9136 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9136 3 718 718 CD 19613 9136 4 : : : 19613 9136 5 Since since IN 19613 9136 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9136 7 does do VBZ 19613 9136 8 not not RB 19613 9136 9 , , , 19613 9136 10 as as IN 19613 9136 11 a a DT 19613 9136 12 rule rule NN 19613 9136 13 , , , 19613 9136 14 dispute dispute VB 19613 9136 15 the the DT 19613 9136 16 literal literal JJ 19613 9136 17 meaning meaning NN 19613 9136 18 of of IN 19613 9136 19 the the DT 19613 9136 20 Scriptures scripture NNS 19613 9136 21 , , , 19613 9136 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9136 23 has have VBZ 19613 9136 24 also also RB 19613 9136 25 a a DT 19613 9136 26 much much RB 19613 9136 27 more more RBR 19613 9136 28 favourable favourable JJ 19613 9136 29 opinion opinion NN 19613 9136 30 of of IN 19613 9136 31 the the DT 19613 9136 32 Jewish jewish JJ 19613 9136 33 people people NNS 19613 9136 34 and and CC 19613 9136 35 of of IN 19613 9136 36 the the DT 19613 9136 37 observance observance NN 19613 9136 38 of of IN 19613 9136 39 the the DT 19613 9136 40 law law NN 19613 9136 41 than than IN 19613 9136 42 the the DT 19613 9136 43 earlier early JJR 19613 9136 44 Christian christian JJ 19613 9136 45 authors author NNS 19613 9136 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9136 47 but but CC 19613 9136 48 see see VB 19613 9136 49 Iren Iren NNP 19613 9136 50 . . . 19613 9137 1 and and CC 19613 9137 2 Tertull Tertull NNP 19613 9137 3 . . . 19613 9137 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9137 5 . . . 19613 9138 1 At at IN 19613 9138 2 bottom bottom NN 19613 9138 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9138 4 places place VBZ 19613 9138 5 the the DT 19613 9138 6 observance observance NN 19613 9138 7 of of IN 19613 9138 8 the the DT 19613 9138 9 law law NN 19613 9138 10 quite quite RB 19613 9138 11 on on IN 19613 9138 12 the the DT 19613 9138 13 same same JJ 19613 9138 14 level level NN 19613 9138 15 as as IN 19613 9138 16 the the DT 19613 9138 17 faith faith NN 19613 9138 18 of of IN 19613 9138 19 the the DT 19613 9138 20 simple simple JJ 19613 9138 21 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 9138 22 . . . 19613 9139 1 The the DT 19613 9139 2 Apostles apostle NNS 19613 9139 3 also also RB 19613 9139 4 kept keep VBD 19613 9139 5 the the DT 19613 9139 6 law law NN 19613 9139 7 for for IN 19613 9139 8 a a DT 19613 9139 9 time time NN 19613 9139 10 , , , 19613 9139 11 and and CC 19613 9139 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9139 13 was be VBD 19613 9139 14 only only RB 19613 9139 15 by by IN 19613 9139 16 degrees degree NNS 19613 9139 17 that that WDT 19613 9139 18 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9139 19 came come VBD 19613 9139 20 to to TO 19613 9139 21 understand understand VB 19613 9139 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9139 23 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 9139 24 meaning meaning NN 19613 9139 25 . . . 19613 9140 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 9140 2 were be VBD 19613 9140 3 also also RB 19613 9140 4 right right JJ 19613 9140 5 to to TO 19613 9140 6 continue continue VB 19613 9140 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9140 8 observance observance NN 19613 9140 9 during during IN 19613 9140 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9140 11 mission mission NN 19613 9140 12 among among IN 19613 9140 13 the the DT 19613 9140 14 Jews Jews NNPS 19613 9140 15 . . . 19613 9141 1 On on IN 19613 9141 2 the the DT 19613 9141 3 other other JJ 19613 9141 4 hand hand NN 19613 9141 5 , , , 19613 9141 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9141 7 considers consider VBZ 19613 9141 8 the the DT 19613 9141 9 New New NNP 19613 9141 10 Testament Testament NNP 19613 9141 11 a a DT 19613 9141 12 higher high JJR 19613 9141 13 stage stage NN 19613 9141 14 than than IN 19613 9141 15 the the DT 19613 9141 16 Old Old NNP 19613 9141 17 both both DT 19613 9141 18 in in IN 19613 9141 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9141 20 literal literal JJ 19613 9141 21 and and CC 19613 9141 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9141 23 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 9141 24 sense sense NN 19613 9141 25 . . . 19613 9142 1 See see VB 19613 9142 2 c. c. NN 19613 9142 3 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9142 4 . . . 19613 9143 1 II ii CD 19613 9143 2 . . . 19613 9144 1 1 1 CD 19613 9144 2 - - SYM 19613 9144 3 4 4 CD 19613 9144 4 , , , 19613 9144 5 7 7 CD 19613 9144 6 , , , 19613 9144 7 75 75 CD 19613 9144 8 : : : 19613 9144 9 IV IV NNP 19613 9144 10 . . . 19613 9145 1 31 31 CD 19613 9145 2 sq sq NN 19613 9145 3 : : : 19613 9145 4 V. V. NNP 19613 9145 5 10 10 CD 19613 9145 6 , , , 19613 9145 7 30 30 CD 19613 9145 8 , , , 19613 9145 9 31 31 CD 19613 9145 10 , , , 19613 9145 11 42 42 CD 19613 9145 12 sq sq NNP 19613 9145 13 . . NNP 19613 9145 14 , , , 19613 9145 15 66 66 CD 19613 9145 16 : : : 19613 9145 17 VII VII NNP 19613 9145 18 . . . 19613 9146 1 26 26 CD 19613 9146 2 . . . 19613 9146 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9147 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9147 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9147 3 719 719 CD 19613 9147 4 : : : 19613 9147 5 In in IN 19613 9147 6 opposition opposition NN 19613 9147 7 to to IN 19613 9147 8 the the DT 19613 9147 9 method method NN 19613 9147 10 for for IN 19613 9147 11 obtaining obtain VBG 19613 9147 12 a a DT 19613 9147 13 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 9147 14 of of IN 19613 9147 15 God God NNP 19613 9147 16 , , , 19613 9147 17 recommended recommend VBN 19613 9147 18 by by IN 19613 9147 19 Alcinous Alcinous NNP 19613 9147 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9147 21 c. c. NNP 19613 9147 22 12 12 CD 19613 9147 23 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9147 24 , , , 19613 9147 25 Maximus Maximus NNP 19613 9147 26 Tyr Tyr NNP 19613 9147 27 . . . 19613 9148 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9148 2 XVII XVII NNP 19613 9148 3 . . . 19613 9149 1 8) 8) CD 19613 9149 2 , , , 19613 9149 3 and and CC 19613 9149 4 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9149 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9149 6 by by IN 19613 9149 7 analysis analysis NN 19613 9149 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9149 9 apophat apophat IN 19613 9149 10 . . . 19613 9150 1 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9150 2 , , , 19613 9150 3 synthesis synthesis NN 19613 9150 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9150 5 kataphat kataphat NN 19613 9150 6 . . . 19613 9151 1 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9151 2 , , , 19613 9151 3 and and CC 19613 9151 4 analogy analogy NN 19613 9151 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9151 6 , , , 19613 9151 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9151 8 , , , 19613 9151 9 c. c. NN 19613 9151 10 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9151 11 . . . 19613 9152 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9152 2 . . . 19613 9153 1 42 42 CD 19613 9153 2 , , , 19613 9153 3 44 44 CD 19613 9153 4 , , , 19613 9153 5 appeals appeal NNS 19613 9153 6 to to IN 19613 9153 7 the the DT 19613 9153 8 fact fact NN 19613 9153 9 that that IN 19613 9153 10 the the DT 19613 9153 11 Christian Christian NNP 19613 9153 12 knows know VBZ 19613 9153 13 God God NNP 19613 9153 14 better well RBR 19613 9153 15 , , , 19613 9153 16 namely namely RB 19613 9153 17 , , , 19613 9153 18 in in IN 19613 9153 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9153 20 incarnate incarnate JJ 19613 9153 21 Son Son NNP 19613 9153 22 . . . 19613 9154 1 But but CC 19613 9154 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9154 3 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9154 4 , , , 19613 9154 5 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 9154 6 , , , 19613 9154 7 also also RB 19613 9154 8 follows follow VBZ 19613 9154 9 the the DT 19613 9154 10 synthetic synthetic JJ 19613 9154 11 method method NN 19613 9154 12 . . . 19613 9154 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9155 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9155 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9155 3 720 720 CD 19613 9155 4 : : : 19613 9155 5 In in IN 19613 9155 6 defining define VBG 19613 9155 7 the the DT 19613 9155 8 superessential superessential JJ 19613 9155 9 nature nature NN 19613 9155 10 of of IN 19613 9155 11 the the DT 19613 9155 12 One one CD 19613 9155 13 , , , 19613 9155 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9155 15 did do VBD 19613 9155 16 not not RB 19613 9155 17 go go VB 19613 9155 18 so so RB 19613 9155 19 far far RB 19613 9155 20 as as IN 19613 9155 21 the the DT 19613 9155 22 Basilidians Basilidians NNPS 19613 9155 23 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9155 24 Philosoph Philosoph NNP 19613 9155 25 . . . 19613 9156 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9156 2 . . . 19613 9157 1 20 20 CD 19613 9157 2 , , , 19613 9157 3 21 21 CD 19613 9157 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9157 5 or or CC 19613 9157 6 as as IN 19613 9157 7 Plotinus Plotinus NNP 19613 9157 8 . . . 19613 9158 1 No no RB 19613 9158 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 9158 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9158 4 also also RB 19613 9158 5 regards regard VBZ 19613 9158 6 the the DT 19613 9158 7 Deity deity NN 19613 9158 8 as as IN 19613 9158 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9158 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9158 11 : : : 19613 9158 12 epekeina epekeina NNP 19613 9158 13 tês tês NNP 19613 9158 14 ousias ousias NNP 19613 9158 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9158 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9158 17 c. c. NN 19613 9158 18 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9158 19 . . . 19613 9159 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9159 2 . . . 19613 9160 1 42 42 CD 19613 9160 2 - - SYM 19613 9160 3 51 51 CD 19613 9160 4 ; ; : 19613 9160 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9160 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9160 7 : : : 19613 9160 8 peri peri NN 19613 9160 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9160 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9160 11 I. I. NNP 19613 9161 1 1 1 LS 19613 9161 2 ; ; : 19613 9161 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9161 4 made make VBD 19613 9161 5 a a DT 19613 9161 6 closer close JJR 19613 9161 7 approach approach NN 19613 9161 8 to to IN 19613 9161 9 the the DT 19613 9161 10 heretical heretical JJ 19613 9161 11 abstractions abstraction NNS 19613 9161 12 of of IN 19613 9161 13 the the DT 19613 9161 14 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 9161 15 inasmuch inasmuch VBP 19613 9161 16 as as IN 19613 9161 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9161 18 still still RB 19613 9161 19 more more RBR 19613 9161 20 expressly expressly RB 19613 9161 21 renounced renounce VBN 19613 9161 22 any any DT 19613 9161 23 designation designation NN 19613 9161 24 of of IN 19613 9161 25 God God NNP 19613 9161 26 ; ; : 19613 9161 27 see see VB 19613 9161 28 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9161 29 . . . 19613 9162 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9162 2 12 12 CD 19613 9162 3 , , , 19613 9162 4 13 13 CD 19613 9162 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9162 6 , , , 19613 9162 7 but but CC 19613 9162 8 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9162 9 is be VBZ 19613 9162 10 not not RB 19613 9162 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9162 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9162 13 : : : 19613 9162 14 buthos buthos NN 19613 9162 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9162 16 and and CC 19613 9162 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9162 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9162 19 : : : 19613 9162 20 sigê sigê NNP 19613 9162 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9162 22 , , , 19613 9162 23 being be VBG 19613 9162 24 rather rather RB 19613 9162 25 a a DT 19613 9162 26 self self NN 19613 9162 27 - - HYPH 19613 9162 28 comprehending comprehend VBG 19613 9162 29 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9162 30 , , , 19613 9162 31 and and CC 19613 9162 32 therefore therefore RB 19613 9162 33 does do VBZ 19613 9162 34 not not RB 19613 9162 35 require require VB 19613 9162 36 a a DT 19613 9162 37 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 9162 38 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9162 39 the the DT 19613 9162 40 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9162 41 Greek greek JJ 19613 9162 42 : : : 19613 9162 43 nous nous JJ 19613 9162 44 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9162 45 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9162 46 before before IN 19613 9162 47 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9162 48 can can MD 19613 9162 49 come come VB 19613 9162 50 to to IN 19613 9162 51 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9162 52 . . . 19613 9163 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 9163 2 the the DT 19613 9163 3 human human JJ 19613 9163 4 intellect intellect NN 19613 9163 5 is be VBZ 19613 9163 6 not not RB 19613 9163 7 incapable incapable JJ 19613 9163 8 of of IN 19613 9163 9 soaring soar VBG 19613 9163 10 up up RP 19613 9163 11 to to IN 19613 9163 12 God God NNP 19613 9163 13 as as IN 19613 9163 14 the the DT 19613 9163 15 later later JJ 19613 9163 16 Neoplatonists Neoplatonists NNPS 19613 9163 17 assert assert VBP 19613 9163 18 ; ; : 19613 9163 19 at at IN 19613 9163 20 least least JJS 19613 9163 21 vision vision NN 19613 9163 22 is be VBZ 19613 9163 23 by by IN 19613 9163 24 no no DT 19613 9163 25 means means NN 19613 9163 26 so so RB 19613 9163 27 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 9163 28 opposed opposed JJ 19613 9163 29 to to IN 19613 9163 30 thought thought NN 19613 9163 31 , , , 19613 9163 32 that that RB 19613 9163 33 is is RB 19613 9163 34 , , , 19613 9163 35 elevated elevate VBN 19613 9163 36 above above IN 19613 9163 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9163 38 as as IN 19613 9163 39 something something NN 19613 9163 40 new new JJ 19613 9163 41 , , , 19613 9163 42 as as IN 19613 9163 43 is be VBZ 19613 9163 44 held hold VBN 19613 9163 45 by by IN 19613 9163 46 the the DT 19613 9163 47 Neoplatonists Neoplatonists NNPS 19613 9163 48 and and CC 19613 9163 49 Philo Philo NNP 19613 9163 50 before before IN 19613 9163 51 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9163 52 . . . 19613 9164 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9164 2 is be VBZ 19613 9164 3 no no DT 19613 9164 4 mystic mystic JJ 19613 9164 5 . . . 19613 9165 1 In in IN 19613 9165 2 accordance accordance NN 19613 9165 3 with with IN 19613 9165 4 this this DT 19613 9165 5 conception conception NN 19613 9165 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9165 7 and and CC 19613 9165 8 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9165 9 say say VBP 19613 9165 10 that that IN 19613 9165 11 the the DT 19613 9165 12 perfect perfect JJ 19613 9165 13 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 9165 14 of of IN 19613 9165 15 God God NNP 19613 9165 16 can can MD 19613 9165 17 indeed indeed RB 19613 9165 18 be be VB 19613 9165 19 derived derive VBN 19613 9165 20 from from IN 19613 9165 21 the the DT 19613 9165 22 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9165 23 alone alone RB 19613 9165 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9165 25 c. c. NN 19613 9165 26 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9165 27 VII VII NNP 19613 9165 28 . . . 19613 9166 1 48 48 CD 19613 9166 2 , , , 19613 9166 3 49 49 CD 19613 9166 4 : : : 19613 9166 5 VI VI NNP 19613 9166 6 . . . 19613 9167 1 65 65 CD 19613 9167 2 - - SYM 19613 9167 3 73 73 CD 19613 9167 4 ; ; : 19613 9167 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9167 6 . . . 19613 9168 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9168 2 12 12 CD 19613 9168 3 . . . 19613 9169 1 85 85 CD 19613 9169 2 : : : 19613 9169 3 VI VI NNP 19613 9169 4 . . . 19613 9170 1 15 15 CD 19613 9170 2 . . . 19613 9171 1 122 122 CD 19613 9171 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9171 3 , , , 19613 9171 4 but but CC 19613 9171 5 that that IN 19613 9171 6 a a DT 19613 9171 7 relative relative JJ 19613 9171 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 9171 9 may may MD 19613 9171 10 be be VB 19613 9171 11 deduced deduce VBN 19613 9171 12 from from IN 19613 9171 13 creation creation NN 19613 9171 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9171 15 c. c. NN 19613 9171 16 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9171 17 . . . 19613 9172 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9172 2 . . . 19613 9173 1 46 46 CD 19613 9173 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9173 3 . . . 19613 9174 1 Hence hence RB 19613 9174 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9174 3 also also RB 19613 9174 4 spoke speak VBD 19613 9174 5 of of IN 19613 9174 6 an an DT 19613 9174 7 innate innate JJ 19613 9174 8 knowledge knowledge NN 19613 9174 9 of of IN 19613 9174 10 God God NNP 19613 9174 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9174 12 Protrept Protrept NNP 19613 9174 13 . . . 19613 9175 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9175 2 . . . 19613 9176 1 68 68 LS 19613 9176 2 ; ; : 19613 9176 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9176 4 . . . 19613 9177 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9177 2 13 13 CD 19613 9177 3 . . . 19613 9178 1 78 78 CD 19613 9178 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9178 3 , , , 19613 9178 4 and and CC 19613 9178 5 extended extend VBD 19613 9178 6 the the DT 19613 9178 7 teleological teleological JJ 19613 9178 8 proof proof NN 19613 9178 9 of of IN 19613 9178 10 God God NNP 19613 9178 11 furnished furnish VBN 19613 9178 12 by by IN 19613 9178 13 Philo Philo NNP 19613 9178 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9178 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9178 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9178 17 : : : 19613 9178 18 peri peri NN 19613 9178 19 archôn archôn NN 19613 9178 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9178 21 I. I. NNP 19613 9179 1 1 1 LS 19613 9179 2 . . . 19613 9180 1 6 6 CD 19613 9180 2 ; ; : 19613 9180 3 c. c. NN 19613 9180 4 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9180 5 I. I. NNP 19613 9181 1 23 23 CD 19613 9181 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9181 3 . . . 19613 9182 1 The the DT 19613 9182 2 relatively relatively RB 19613 9182 3 correct correct JJ 19613 9182 4 predicates predicate NNS 19613 9182 5 of of IN 19613 9182 6 God God NNP 19613 9182 7 to to TO 19613 9182 8 be be VB 19613 9182 9 determined determine VBN 19613 9182 10 from from IN 19613 9182 11 revelation revelation NN 19613 9182 12 are be VBP 19613 9182 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9182 14 unity unity NN 19613 9182 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9182 16 c. c. NN 19613 9182 17 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9182 18 I. I. NNP 19613 9183 1 23 23 CD 19613 9183 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9183 3 , , , 19613 9183 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9183 5 absolute absolute JJ 19613 9183 6 spirituality spirituality NN 19613 9183 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9183 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9183 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9183 10 : : : 19613 9183 11 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 9183 12 asômatos asômatos NNP 19613 9183 13 , , , 19613 9183 14 aulos aulos NNP 19613 9183 15 , , , 19613 9183 16 aschêmatistos])--this aschêmatistos])--this DT 19613 9183 17 is be VBZ 19613 9183 18 maintained maintain VBN 19613 9183 19 both both CC 19613 9183 20 in in IN 19613 9183 21 opposition opposition NN 19613 9183 22 to to IN 19613 9183 23 Stoicism stoicism NN 19613 9183 24 and and CC 19613 9183 25 anthropomorphism anthropomorphism NN 19613 9183 26 ; ; : 19613 9183 27 see see VB 19613 9183 28 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9183 29 . . . 19613 9184 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9184 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9184 3 : : : 19613 9184 4 peri peri NN 19613 9184 5 archôn archôn NN 19613 9184 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9184 7 I. I. NNP 19613 9185 1 1 1 LS 19613 9185 2 , , , 19613 9185 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9185 4 's 's POS 19613 9185 5 polemic polemic NN 19613 9185 6 against against IN 19613 9185 7 Melito Melito NNP 19613 9185 8 's 's POS 19613 9185 9 conception conception NN 19613 9185 10 of of IN 19613 9185 11 God God NNP 19613 9185 12 , , , 19613 9185 13 and and CC 19613 9185 14 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9185 15 . . . 19613 9185 16 , , , 19613 9185 17 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9185 18 . . . 19613 9186 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9186 2 11 11 CD 19613 9186 3 . . . 19613 9187 1 68 68 CD 19613 9187 2 : : : 19613 9187 3 V. v. NN 19613 9187 4 12 12 CD 19613 9187 5 . . . 19613 9188 1 82,--his 82,--his CD 19613 9188 2 unbegottenness unbegottenness NN 19613 9188 3 , , , 19613 9188 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9188 5 immortality immortality NN 19613 9188 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9188 7 this this DT 19613 9188 8 is be VBZ 19613 9188 9 eternity eternity NN 19613 9188 10 conceived conceive VBN 19613 9188 11 as as IN 19613 9188 12 enjoyment enjoyment NN 19613 9188 13 ; ; : 19613 9188 14 the the DT 19613 9188 15 eternity eternity NN 19613 9188 16 of of IN 19613 9188 17 God God NNP 19613 9188 18 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 9188 19 , , , 19613 9188 20 however however RB 19613 9188 21 , , , 19613 9188 22 is be VBZ 19613 9188 23 to to TO 19613 9188 24 be be VB 19613 9188 25 conceived conceive VBN 19613 9188 26 , , , 19613 9188 27 according accord VBG 19613 9188 28 to to IN 19613 9188 29 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9188 30 , , , 19613 9188 31 as as IN 19613 9188 32 that that DT 19613 9188 33 which which WDT 19613 9188 34 is be VBZ 19613 9188 35 above above IN 19613 9188 36 time time NN 19613 9188 37 ; ; : 19613 9188 38 see see VB 19613 9188 39 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9188 40 . . . 19613 9189 1 II ii CD 19613 9189 2 . . . 19613 9190 1 2 2 LS 19613 9190 2 . . . 19613 9191 1 6 6 LS 19613 9191 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9191 3 , , , 19613 9191 4 and and CC 19613 9191 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9191 6 absolute absolute JJ 19613 9191 7 causality causality NN 19613 9191 8 . . . 19613 9192 1 All all PDT 19613 9192 2 these these DT 19613 9192 3 concepts concept NNS 19613 9192 4 together together RB 19613 9192 5 constitute constitute VBP 19613 9192 6 the the DT 19613 9192 7 conception conception NN 19613 9192 8 of of IN 19613 9192 9 perfection perfection NN 19613 9192 10 . . . 19613 9193 1 See see VB 19613 9193 2 Fischer Fischer NNP 19613 9193 3 , , , 19613 9193 4 De De NNP 19613 9193 5 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9193 6 . . . 19613 9194 1 theologia theologia NNP 19613 9194 2 et et NNP 19613 9194 3 cosmologia cosmologia NNP 19613 9194 4 , , , 19613 9194 5 1840 1840 CD 19613 9194 6 . . . 19613 9194 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9195 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9195 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9195 3 721 721 CD 19613 9195 4 : : : 19613 9195 5 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9195 6 . . . 19613 9196 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9196 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9196 3 : : : 19613 9196 4 peri peri NN 19613 9196 5 archôn archôn NN 19613 9196 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9196 7 II II NNP 19613 9196 8 . . . 19613 9197 1 1 1 LS 19613 9197 2 . . . 19613 9198 1 3 3 LS 19613 9198 2 . . . 19613 9198 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9199 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9199 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9199 3 722 722 CD 19613 9199 4 : : : 19613 9199 5 C. C. NNP 19613 9199 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9199 7 V. V. NNP 19613 9200 1 23 23 CD 19613 9200 2 . . . 19613 9200 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9201 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9201 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9201 3 723 723 CD 19613 9201 4 : : : 19613 9201 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 9201 6 . . . 19613 9201 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9202 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9202 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9202 3 724 724 CD 19613 9202 4 : : : 19613 9202 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9202 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9202 7 : : : 19613 9202 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9202 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9202 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9202 11 II II NNP 19613 9202 12 . . . 19613 9203 1 9 9 CD 19613 9203 2 . . . 19613 9204 1 1 1 LS 19613 9204 2 : : : 19613 9204 3 " " `` 19613 9204 4 Certum Certum NNP 19613 9204 5 est est NNP 19613 9204 6 , , , 19613 9204 7 quippe quippe NNP 19613 9204 8 quod quod NNP 19613 9204 9 præfinito præfinito NNP 19613 9204 10 aliquo aliquo NNP 19613 9204 11 apud apud NNP 19613 9204 12 se se NNP 19613 9204 13 numero numero NNP 19613 9204 14 creaturas creaturas NNP 19613 9204 15 fecit fecit NN 19613 9204 16 : : : 19613 9204 17 non non NNP 19613 9204 18 enim enim NNP 19613 9204 19 , , , 19613 9204 20 ut ut UH 19613 9204 21 quidam quidam NNP 19613 9204 22 volunt volunt NNP 19613 9204 23 , , , 19613 9204 24 finem finem NNP 19613 9204 25 putandum putandum NN 19613 9204 26 est est NNP 19613 9204 27 non non AFX 19613 9204 28 habere habere NNP 19613 9204 29 creaturas creaturas NNP 19613 9204 30 ; ; : 19613 9204 31 quia quia NNP 19613 9204 32 ubi ubi NNP 19613 9204 33 finis finis NNP 19613 9204 34 non non NNP 19613 9204 35 est est NNP 19613 9204 36 , , , 19613 9204 37 nec nec NNP 19613 9204 38 comprehensio comprehensio NNP 19613 9204 39 ulla ulla NNP 19613 9204 40 nec nec NNP 19613 9204 41 circumscriptio circumscriptio NNP 19613 9204 42 esse esse NNP 19613 9204 43 potest potest NNP 19613 9204 44 . . . 19613 9205 1 Quod quod NN 19613 9205 2 si si VBP 19613 9205 3 fuerit fuerit VB 19613 9205 4 utique utique NNP 19613 9205 5 nee nee NNP 19613 9205 6 contineri contineri NNP 19613 9205 7 vel vel NNP 19613 9205 8 dispensari dispensari VBP 19613 9205 9 a a DT 19613 9205 10 deo deo NNP 19613 9205 11 , , , 19613 9205 12 quæ quæ NNP 19613 9205 13 facta facta NNP 19613 9205 14 sunt sunt NNP 19613 9205 15 , , , 19613 9205 16 poterunt poterunt NN 19613 9205 17 . . . 19613 9206 1 Naturaliter Naturaliter NNP 19613 9206 2 nempe nempe FW 19613 9206 3 quicquid quicquid JJ 19613 9206 4 infinitum infinitum JJ 19613 9206 5 fuerit fuerit NN 19613 9206 6 , , , 19613 9206 7 et et FW 19613 9206 8 incomprehensibile incomprehensibile NN 19613 9206 9 erit erit RB 19613 9206 10 . . . 19613 9206 11 " " '' 19613 9207 1 In in IN 19613 9207 2 Matth Matth NNP 19613 9207 3 . . NNP 19613 9207 4 , , , 19613 9207 5 t. t. NNP 19613 9207 6 13 13 CD 19613 9207 7 . . CD 19613 9207 8 , , , 19613 9207 9 c. c. NNP 19613 9207 10 1 1 CD 19613 9207 11 fin fin NNP 19613 9207 12 . . . 19613 9207 13 , , , 19613 9207 14 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9207 15 . . . 19613 9208 1 III III NNP 19613 9208 2 . . NNP 19613 9208 3 , , , 19613 9208 4 p. p. NN 19613 9208 5 209 209 CD 19613 9208 6 sq sq NNP 19613 9208 7 . . NNP 19613 9208 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9209 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9209 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9209 3 725 725 CD 19613 9209 4 : : : 19613 9209 5 See see VB 19613 9209 6 above above RB 19613 9209 7 , , , 19613 9209 8 p. p. NN 19613 9209 9 343 343 CD 19613 9209 10 , , , 19613 9209 11 note note VBP 19613 9209 12 2 2 CD 19613 9209 13 . . . 19613 9209 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9210 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9210 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9210 3 726 726 CD 19613 9210 4 : : : 19613 9210 5 See see VB 19613 9210 6 c. c. NN 19613 9210 7 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9210 8 . . . 19613 9211 1 II ii CD 19613 9211 2 . . . 19613 9212 1 20 20 CD 19613 9212 2 . . . 19613 9212 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9213 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9213 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9213 3 727 727 CD 19613 9213 4 : : : 19613 9213 5 Clement clement NN 19613 9213 6 also also RB 19613 9213 7 did do VBD 19613 9213 8 so so RB 19613 9213 9 ; ; : 19613 9213 10 see see VB 19613 9213 11 with with IN 19613 9213 12 respect respect NN 19613 9213 13 to to IN 19613 9213 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9213 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9213 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9213 17 : : : 19613 9213 18 peri peri NN 19613 9213 19 archôn archôn NN 19613 9213 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9213 21 II II NNP 19613 9213 22 . . . 19613 9214 1 5 5 CD 19613 9214 2 , , , 19613 9214 3 especially especially RB 19613 9214 4 § § CD 19613 9214 5 3 3 CD 19613 9214 6 sq sq NNP 19613 9214 7 . . . 19613 9214 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9215 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9215 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9215 3 728 728 CD 19613 9215 4 : : : 19613 9215 5 See see VB 19613 9215 6 Comment comment NN 19613 9215 7 . . . 19613 9216 1 in in IN 19613 9216 2 Johann Johann NNP 19613 9216 3 . . . 19613 9217 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9218 1 40 40 CD 19613 9218 2 , , , 19613 9218 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9218 4 . . . 19613 9219 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9219 2 p. p. NN 19613 9219 3 77 77 CD 19613 9219 4 sq sq NN 19613 9219 5 . . . 19613 9220 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 9220 2 can can MD 19613 9220 3 not not RB 19613 9220 4 agree agree VB 19613 9220 5 that that IN 19613 9220 6 this this DT 19613 9220 7 view view NN 19613 9220 8 is be VBZ 19613 9220 9 a a DT 19613 9220 10 _ _ NNP 19613 9220 11 rapprochement rapprochement NN 19613 9220 12 _ _ NNP 19613 9220 13 to to IN 19613 9220 14 the the DT 19613 9220 15 Marcionites Marcionites NNPS 19613 9220 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9220 17 contrary contrary JJ 19613 9220 18 to to IN 19613 9220 19 Nitzsch Nitzsch NNP 19613 9220 20 's 's POS 19613 9220 21 opinion opinion NN 19613 9220 22 , , , 19613 9220 23 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9220 24 . . NNP 19613 9220 25 , , , 19613 9220 26 p. p. NN 19613 9220 27 285 285 CD 19613 9220 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9220 29 . . . 19613 9221 1 The the DT 19613 9221 2 confused confused JJ 19613 9221 3 accounts account NNS 19613 9221 4 in in IN 19613 9221 5 Epiph Epiph NNP 19613 9221 6 . . NNP 19613 9221 7 , , , 19613 9221 8 H. H. NNP 19613 9221 9 43 43 CD 19613 9221 10 . . . 19613 9222 1 13 13 CD 19613 9222 2 are be VBP 19613 9222 3 at at IN 19613 9222 4 any any DT 19613 9222 5 rate rate NN 19613 9222 6 not not RB 19613 9222 7 to to TO 19613 9222 8 be be VB 19613 9222 9 taken take VBN 19613 9222 10 into into IN 19613 9222 11 account account NN 19613 9222 12 . . . 19613 9222 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9223 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9223 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9223 3 729 729 CD 19613 9223 4 : : : 19613 9223 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9223 6 's 's POS 19613 9223 7 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9223 8 of of IN 19613 9223 9 the the DT 19613 9223 10 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9223 11 , , , 19613 9223 12 to to TO 19613 9223 13 judge judge VB 19613 9223 14 from from IN 19613 9223 15 the the DT 19613 9223 16 Hypotyposes Hypotyposes NNP 19613 9223 17 , , , 19613 9223 18 was be VBD 19613 9223 19 perhaps perhaps RB 19613 9223 20 different different JJ 19613 9223 21 from from IN 19613 9223 22 that that DT 19613 9223 23 of of IN 19613 9223 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9223 25 . . . 19613 9224 1 According accord VBG 19613 9224 2 to to IN 19613 9224 3 Photius Photius NNP 19613 9224 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9224 5 Biblioth biblioth RB 19613 9224 6 . . . 19613 9225 1 109 109 LS 19613 9225 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9225 3 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9225 4 assumed assume VBD 19613 9225 5 two two CD 19613 9225 6 Logoi Logoi NNP 19613 9225 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9225 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9225 9 indeed indeed RB 19613 9225 10 was be VBD 19613 9225 11 also also RB 19613 9225 12 reproached reproach VBN 19613 9225 13 with with IN 19613 9225 14 the the DT 19613 9225 15 same same JJ 19613 9225 16 ; ; : 19613 9225 17 see see VB 19613 9225 18 Pamphili Pamphili NNP 19613 9225 19 Apol Apol NNP 19613 9225 20 . . . 19613 9225 21 , , , 19613 9225 22 Routh Routh NNP 19613 9225 23 , , , 19613 9225 24 Reliq Reliq NNP 19613 9225 25 . . . 19613 9226 1 S. S. NNP 19613 9226 2 , , , 19613 9226 3 IV IV NNP 19613 9226 4 . . NNP 19613 9226 5 , , , 19613 9226 6 p. p. NN 19613 9226 7 367 367 CD 19613 9226 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9226 9 , , , 19613 9226 10 and and CC 19613 9226 11 did do VBD 19613 9226 12 not not RB 19613 9226 13 even even RB 19613 9226 14 allow allow VB 19613 9226 15 the the DT 19613 9226 16 second second JJ 19613 9226 17 and and CC 19613 9226 18 weaker weak JJR 19613 9226 19 one one PRP 19613 9226 20 to to TO 19613 9226 21 make make VB 19613 9226 22 a a DT 19613 9226 23 real real JJ 19613 9226 24 appearance appearance NN 19613 9226 25 on on IN 19613 9226 26 earth earth NN 19613 9226 27 ; ; : 19613 9226 28 but but CC 19613 9226 29 this this DT 19613 9226 30 is be VBZ 19613 9226 31 a a DT 19613 9226 32 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 19613 9226 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9226 34 see see VB 19613 9226 35 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9226 36 , , , 19613 9226 37 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 9226 38 III III NNP 19613 9226 39 . . NNP 19613 9226 40 , , , 19613 9226 41 p. p. NN 19613 9226 42 144 144 CD 19613 9226 43 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9226 44 . . . 19613 9227 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9227 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9227 3 : : : 19613 9227 4 Legetai Legetai NNP 19613 9227 5 men]--these men]--these NNP 19613 9227 6 are be VBP 19613 9227 7 said say VBN 19613 9227 8 to to TO 19613 9227 9 have have VB 19613 9227 10 been be VBN 19613 9227 11 the the DT 19613 9227 12 words word NNS 19613 9227 13 of of IN 19613 9227 14 a a DT 19613 9227 15 passage passage NN 19613 9227 16 in in IN 19613 9227 17 the the DT 19613 9227 18 Hypotyposes--[Greek hypotyposes--[greek NN 19613 9227 19 : : : 19613 9227 20 kai kai NNP 19613 9227 21 ho ho NNP 19613 9227 22 huios huios NNP 19613 9227 23 logos logos NNP 19613 9227 24 homônumôs homônumôs NNP 19613 9227 25 tô tô NNP 19613 9227 26 patrikô patrikô NNP 19613 9227 27 logô logô NNP 19613 9227 28 , , , 19613 9227 29 all all DT 19613 9227 30 ' ' '' 19613 9227 31 ouch ouch NNP 19613 9227 32 outos outo NNS 19613 9227 33 estin estin NNP 19613 9227 34 ho ho NNP 19613 9227 35 sarx sarx NNP 19613 9227 36 genomenos genomenos NNP 19613 9227 37 , , , 19613 9227 38 oude oude NN 19613 9227 39 men man NNS 19613 9227 40 ho ho VBD 19613 9227 41 patrôos patrôos NNP 19613 9227 42 logos logos NNP 19613 9227 43 , , , 19613 9227 44 alla alla NNP 19613 9227 45 dynamis dynamis NNP 19613 9227 46 tis tis NNP 19613 9227 47 tou tou NNP 19613 9227 48 Theou Theou NNP 19613 9227 49 , , , 19613 9227 50 oion oion NN 19613 9227 51 apporoia apporoia NN 19613 9227 52 tou tou NNP 19613 9227 53 logou logou NNP 19613 9227 54 autou autou NNP 19613 9227 55 nous nous JJ 19613 9227 56 genomenos genomenos NNP 19613 9227 57 tas tas NNP 19613 9227 58 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9227 59 anthrôpôn anthrôpôn NNP 19613 9227 60 kardias kardias NNP 19613 9227 61 diapephoitêke diapephoitêke NNP 19613 9227 62 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9227 63 . . . 19613 9228 1 The the DT 19613 9228 2 distinction distinction NN 19613 9228 3 between between IN 19613 9228 4 an an DT 19613 9228 5 impersonal impersonal JJ 19613 9228 6 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9228 7 - - HYPH 19613 9228 8 God God NNP 19613 9228 9 and and CC 19613 9228 10 the the DT 19613 9228 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9228 12 - - HYPH 19613 9228 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9228 14 necessarily necessarily RB 19613 9228 15 appeared appear VBD 19613 9228 16 as as RB 19613 9228 17 soon soon RB 19613 9228 18 as as IN 19613 9228 19 the the DT 19613 9228 20 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9228 21 was be VBD 19613 9228 22 definitely definitely RB 19613 9228 23 hypostatised hypostatise VBN 19613 9228 24 . . . 19613 9229 1 In in IN 19613 9229 2 the the DT 19613 9229 3 so so RB 19613 9229 4 - - HYPH 19613 9229 5 called call VBN 19613 9229 6 Monarchian monarchian JJ 19613 9229 7 struggles struggle NNS 19613 9229 8 of of IN 19613 9229 9 the the DT 19613 9229 10 3rd 3rd JJ 19613 9229 11 century century NN 19613 9229 12 the the DT 19613 9229 13 disputants disputant NNS 19613 9229 14 made make VBD 19613 9229 15 use use NN 19613 9229 16 of of IN 19613 9229 17 these these DT 19613 9229 18 two two CD 19613 9229 19 Logoi Logoi NNP 19613 9229 20 , , , 19613 9229 21 who who WP 19613 9229 22 formed form VBD 19613 9229 23 excellent excellent JJ 19613 9229 24 material material NN 19613 9229 25 for for IN 19613 9229 26 sophistical sophistical JJ 19613 9229 27 discussions discussion NNS 19613 9229 28 . . . 19613 9230 1 In in IN 19613 9230 2 the the DT 19613 9230 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9230 4 . . . 19613 9231 1 Clement clement NN 19613 9231 2 did do VBD 19613 9231 3 not not RB 19613 9231 4 reject reject VB 19613 9231 5 the the DT 19613 9231 6 distinction distinction NN 19613 9231 7 between between IN 19613 9231 8 a a DT 19613 9231 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9231 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9231 11 : : : 19613 9231 12 logos logos NNP 19613 9231 13 endiathetos endiathetos NNP 19613 9231 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9231 15 and and CC 19613 9231 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9231 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9231 18 : : : 19613 9231 19 prophorikos prophorikos NN 19613 9231 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9231 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9231 22 on on IN 19613 9231 23 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9231 24 . . . 19613 9232 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9232 2 1 1 CD 19613 9232 3 . . . 19613 9233 1 6 6 LS 19613 9233 2 . . . 19613 9233 3 see see NNP 19613 9233 4 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9233 5 , , , 19613 9233 6 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9233 7 . . NNP 19613 9233 8 , , , 19613 9233 9 p. p. NN 19613 9233 10 145 145 CD 19613 9233 11 against against IN 19613 9233 12 Nitzsch Nitzsch NNP 19613 9233 13 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9233 14 , , , 19613 9233 15 and and CC 19613 9233 16 in in IN 19613 9233 17 many many JJ 19613 9233 18 passages passage NNS 19613 9233 19 expresses express VBZ 19613 9233 20 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9233 21 in in IN 19613 9233 22 such such PDT 19613 9233 23 a a DT 19613 9233 24 way way NN 19613 9233 25 that that WDT 19613 9233 26 one one PRP 19613 9233 27 can can MD 19613 9233 28 scarcely scarcely RB 19613 9233 29 fail fail VB 19613 9233 30 to to TO 19613 9233 31 notice notice VB 19613 9233 32 a a DT 19613 9233 33 distinction distinction NN 19613 9233 34 between between IN 19613 9233 35 the the DT 19613 9233 36 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9233 37 of of IN 19613 9233 38 the the DT 19613 9233 39 Father Father NNP 19613 9233 40 and and CC 19613 9233 41 that that DT 19613 9233 42 of of IN 19613 9233 43 the the DT 19613 9233 44 Son Son NNP 19613 9233 45 . . . 19613 9234 1 " " `` 19613 9234 2 The the DT 19613 9234 3 Son Son NNP 19613 9234 4 - - HYPH 19613 9234 5 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9234 6 is be VBZ 19613 9234 7 an an DT 19613 9234 8 emanation emanation NN 19613 9234 9 of of IN 19613 9234 10 the the DT 19613 9234 11 Reason Reason NNP 19613 9234 12 of of IN 19613 9234 13 God God NNP 19613 9234 14 , , , 19613 9234 15 which which WDT 19613 9234 16 unalterably unalterably RB 19613 9234 17 remains remain VBZ 19613 9234 18 in in IN 19613 9234 19 God God NNP 19613 9234 20 and and CC 19613 9234 21 is be VBZ 19613 9234 22 the the DT 19613 9234 23 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9234 24 proper proper JJ 19613 9234 25 . . . 19613 9234 26 " " '' 19613 9235 1 If if IN 19613 9235 2 the the DT 19613 9235 3 Adumbrationes Adumbrationes NNPS 19613 9235 4 are be VBP 19613 9235 5 to to TO 19613 9235 6 be be VB 19613 9235 7 regarded regard VBN 19613 9235 8 as as IN 19613 9235 9 parts part NNS 19613 9235 10 of of IN 19613 9235 11 the the DT 19613 9235 12 Hypotyposes Hypotyposes NNPS 19613 9235 13 , , , 19613 9235 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9235 15 used use VBD 19613 9235 16 the the DT 19613 9235 17 expression expression NN 19613 9235 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9235 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9235 20 : : : 19613 9235 21 homoousios homoousio NNS 19613 9235 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9235 23 for for IN 19613 9235 24 the the DT 19613 9235 25 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9235 26 , , , 19613 9235 27 or or CC 19613 9235 28 at at IN 19613 9235 29 least least JJS 19613 9235 30 an an DT 19613 9235 31 identical identical JJ 19613 9235 32 one one NN 19613 9235 33 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9235 34 See See NNP 19613 9235 35 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9235 36 , , , 19613 9235 37 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 9235 38 III III NNP 19613 9235 39 . . NNP 19613 9235 40 , , , 19613 9235 41 pp pp NNP 19613 9235 42 . . . 19613 9236 1 87 87 CD 19613 9236 2 - - SYM 19613 9236 3 138 138 CD 19613 9236 4 f. f. NNS 19613 9236 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9236 6 . . . 19613 9237 1 This this DT 19613 9237 2 is be VBZ 19613 9237 3 the the DT 19613 9237 4 more more RBR 19613 9237 5 probable probable JJ 19613 9237 6 because because IN 19613 9237 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9237 8 , , , 19613 9237 9 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9237 10 . . . 19613 9238 1 16 16 CD 19613 9238 2 . . . 19613 9239 1 74 74 CD 19613 9239 2 , , , 19613 9239 3 expressly expressly RB 19613 9239 4 remarked remark VBD 19613 9239 5 that that IN 19613 9239 6 men man NNS 19613 9239 7 are be VBP 19613 9239 8 not not RB 19613 9239 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9239 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9239 11 : : : 19613 9239 12 meros mero NNS 19613 9239 13 theou theou IN 19613 9239 14 kai kai NNP 19613 9239 15 tô tô NNP 19613 9239 16 Theô Theô NNP 19613 9239 17 homoousioi homoousioi NNP 19613 9239 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9239 19 , , , 19613 9239 20 and and CC 19613 9239 21 because because IN 19613 9239 22 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9239 23 says say VBZ 19613 9239 24 in in IN 19613 9239 25 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9239 26 . . . 19613 9240 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9240 2 . . . 19613 9241 1 13 13 CD 19613 9241 2 . . . 19613 9242 1 91 91 CD 19613 9242 2 : : : 19613 9242 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9242 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9242 5 : : : 19613 9242 6 ei ei NNP 19613 9242 7 epi epi NNP 19613 9242 8 to to IN 19613 9242 9 katalusai katalusai NNP 19613 9242 10 thanaton thanaton NNP 19613 9242 11 aphikneitai aphikneitai NNP 19613 9242 12 to to IN 19613 9242 13 diapheron diapheron NNP 19613 9242 14 genos genos NNP 19613 9242 15 , , , 19613 9242 16 ouch ouch NN 19613 9242 17 ho ho NNP 19613 9242 18 Christos Christos NNP 19613 9242 19 ton ton NN 19613 9242 20 thanaton thanaton NNP 19613 9242 21 katêrgêsen katêrgêsen NNP 19613 9242 22 , , , 19613 9242 23 ei ei NNP 19613 9242 24 mê mê NNP 19613 9242 25 kai kai NNP 19613 9242 26 autos auto NNS 19613 9242 27 autois autois NNP 19613 9242 28 homoousios homoousios NNP 19613 9242 29 lechtheiê lechtheiê NNP 19613 9242 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9242 31 . . . 19613 9243 1 One one PRP 19613 9243 2 must must MD 19613 9243 3 assume assume VB 19613 9243 4 from from IN 19613 9243 5 this this DT 19613 9243 6 that that IN 19613 9243 7 the the DT 19613 9243 8 word word NN 19613 9243 9 was be VBD 19613 9243 10 really really RB 19613 9243 11 familiar familiar JJ 19613 9243 12 to to IN 19613 9243 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9243 14 as as IN 19613 9243 15 a a DT 19613 9243 16 designation designation NN 19613 9243 17 of of IN 19613 9243 18 the the DT 19613 9243 19 community community NN 19613 9243 20 of of IN 19613 9243 21 nature nature NN 19613 9243 22 , , , 19613 9243 23 possessed possess VBN 19613 9243 24 by by IN 19613 9243 25 the the DT 19613 9243 26 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9243 27 , , , 19613 9243 28 both both CC 19613 9243 29 with with IN 19613 9243 30 God God NNP 19613 9243 31 and and CC 19613 9243 32 with with IN 19613 9243 33 men man NNS 19613 9243 34 . . . 19613 9244 1 See see VB 19613 9244 2 Protrept Protrept NNP 19613 9244 3 . . . 19613 9245 1 10 10 CD 19613 9245 2 . . . 19613 9246 1 110 110 CD 19613 9246 2 : : : 19613 9246 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9246 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9246 5 : : : 19613 9246 6 ho ho NNP 19613 9246 7 theios theios NNP 19613 9246 8 logos logos NNP 19613 9246 9 , , , 19613 9246 10 ho ho NNP 19613 9246 11 phanerôtatos phanerôtatos NNP 19613 9246 12 ontôs ontôs NNP 19613 9246 13 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9246 14 , , , 19613 9246 15 ho ho NNP 19613 9246 16 tô tô NNP 19613 9246 17 despotê despotê NNP 19613 9246 18 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9246 19 holôn holôn NNP 19613 9246 20 exisôtheis exisôtheis NNP 19613 9246 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9246 22 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9246 23 . . . 19613 9247 1 In in IN 19613 9247 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9247 3 . . . 19613 9248 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9248 2 I. I. NNP 19613 9249 1 1 1 CD 19613 9249 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9249 3 emphatically emphatically RB 19613 9249 4 declared declare VBD 19613 9249 5 that that IN 19613 9249 6 the the DT 19613 9249 7 Son Son NNP 19613 9249 8 was be VBD 19613 9249 9 equally equally RB 19613 9249 10 eternal eternal JJ 19613 9249 11 with with IN 19613 9249 12 the the DT 19613 9249 13 Father Father NNP 19613 9249 14 : : : 19613 9249 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9249 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9249 17 : : : 19613 9249 18 ou ou NNP 19613 9249 19 mên mên NN 19613 9249 20 oude oude NNP 19613 9249 21 ho ho NNP 19613 9249 22 patêr patêr NNP 19613 9249 23 aneu aneu NNP 19613 9249 24 huiou huiou NNP 19613 9249 25 hama hama NNP 19613 9249 26 gar gar NNP 19613 9249 27 tô tô NNP 19613 9249 28 patêr patêr NNP 19613 9249 29 huiou huiou NNP 19613 9249 30 patêr patêr NNP 19613 9249 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9249 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9249 33 see see VB 19613 9249 34 also also RB 19613 9249 35 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9249 36 . . . 19613 9250 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9250 2 . . . 19613 9251 1 7 7 LS 19613 9251 2 . . . 19613 9252 1 58 58 CD 19613 9252 2 : : : 19613 9252 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9252 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9252 5 : : : 19613 9252 6 hen hen NNP 19613 9252 7 mên mên NNP 19613 9252 8 to to IN 19613 9252 9 agennêton agennêton NNP 19613 9252 10 ho ho NNP 19613 9252 11 pantokratôr pantokratôr NNP 19613 9252 12 , , , 19613 9252 13 en en NNP 19613 9252 14 de de NNP 19613 9252 15 kai kai NNP 19613 9252 16 to to TO 19613 9252 17 progennêthen progennêthen NNP 19613 9252 18 di di NNP 19613 9252 19 ' ' '' 19613 9252 20 ou ou NNP 19613 9252 21 ta ta NNP 19613 9252 22 panta panta NNP 19613 9252 23 egeneto egeneto NNP 19613 9252 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9252 25 , , , 19613 9252 26 and and CC 19613 9252 27 Adumbrat Adumbrat NNP 19613 9252 28 . . . 19613 9253 1 in in IN 19613 9253 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9253 3 , , , 19613 9253 4 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9253 5 . . NNP 19613 9253 6 , , , 19613 9253 7 p. p. NN 19613 9253 8 87 87 CD 19613 9253 9 , , , 19613 9253 10 where where WRB 19613 9253 11 1 1 CD 19613 9253 12 John John NNP 19613 9253 13 I. I. NNP 19613 9254 1 1 1 CD 19613 9254 2 is be VBZ 19613 9254 3 explained explain VBN 19613 9254 4 : : : 19613 9254 5 " " `` 19613 9254 6 principium principium NN 19613 9254 7 generationis generationis NNPS 19613 9254 8 separatum separatum NNP 19613 9254 9 ab ab NNP 19613 9254 10 opificis opificis NNP 19613 9254 11 principio principio NNP 19613 9254 12 non non AFX 19613 9254 13 est est NNP 19613 9254 14 . . . 19613 9255 1 Cum Cum NNP 19613 9255 2 enim enim NNP 19613 9255 3 dicit dicit VBP 19613 9255 4 ' ' '' 19613 9255 5 quod quod NN 19613 9255 6 erat erat NNP 19613 9255 7 ab ab NNP 19613 9255 8 initio initio NNP 19613 9255 9 ' ' POS 19613 9255 10 generationem generationem NNP 19613 9255 11 tangit tangit NNP 19613 9255 12 sine sine NNP 19613 9255 13 principio principio NNP 19613 9255 14 filii filii VBP 19613 9255 15 cum cum NNP 19613 9255 16 patre patre NNP 19613 9255 17 simul simul VBZ 19613 9255 18 exstantis exstantis RB 19613 9255 19 . . . 19613 9255 20 " " '' 19613 9256 1 See see VB 19613 9256 2 besides besides IN 19613 9256 3 the the DT 19613 9256 4 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 9256 5 passage passage NN 19613 9256 6 , , , 19613 9256 7 Quis Quis NNP 19613 9256 8 dives dive VBZ 19613 9256 9 salv salv JJ 19613 9256 10 . . . 19613 9257 1 37 37 CD 19613 9257 2 : : : 19613 9257 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9257 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9257 5 : : : 19613 9257 6 Theô Theô NNS 19613 9257 7 ta ta PRP$ 19613 9257 8 tês tês NNP 19613 9257 9 agapês agapês NNP 19613 9257 10 mystêria mystêria NNP 19613 9257 11 , , , 19613 9257 12 kai kai NNP 19613 9257 13 tote tote NNP 19613 9257 14 epopteuseis epopteuseis NNP 19613 9257 15 ton ton NNP 19613 9257 16 kolpon kolpon NNP 19613 9257 17 tou tou NNP 19613 9257 18 patros patros NNP 19613 9257 19 , , , 19613 9257 20 hon hon NNP 19613 9257 21 ho ho NNP 19613 9257 22 monogenês monogenês NNP 19613 9257 23 huios huios NNP 19613 9257 24 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9257 25 monos monos JJ 19613 9257 26 exêgêsato exêgêsato JJ 19613 9257 27 esti esti NN 19613 9257 28 de de NNP 19613 9257 29 kai kai NNP 19613 9257 30 autos auto NNS 19613 9257 31 ho ho NNP 19613 9257 32 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9257 33 agapê agapê JJ 19613 9257 34 kai kai NNP 19613 9257 35 di di NNP 19613 9257 36 ' ' `` 19613 9257 37 agapên agapên NNP 19613 9257 38 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 9257 39 anekrathê anekrathê NNP 19613 9257 40 kai kai NNP 19613 9257 41 to to IN 19613 9257 42 men men NNP 19613 9257 43 arrêton arrêton NNP 19613 9257 44 autou autou NNP 19613 9257 45 patêr patêr NNP 19613 9257 46 , , , 19613 9257 47 to to IN 19613 9257 48 de de NNP 19613 9257 49 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 9257 50 sympathes sympathes NNP 19613 9257 51 gegone gegone NNP 19613 9257 52 mêtêr mêtêr NNP 19613 9257 53 agapêsas agapêsas NNP 19613 9257 54 ho ho NNP 19613 9257 55 patêr patêr NNP 19613 9257 56 ethêlunthê ethêlunthê NNP 19613 9257 57 , , , 19613 9257 58 kai kai NNP 19613 9257 59 toutou toutou NNP 19613 9257 60 mega mega NNP 19613 9257 61 sêmeion sêmeion NNP 19613 9257 62 , , , 19613 9257 63 hon hon NNP 19613 9257 64 autos autos NNPS 19613 9257 65 egennêsen egennêsen NNP 19613 9257 66 ex ex NNP 19613 9257 67 autou autou NNP 19613 9257 68 kai kai NNP 19613 9257 69 ho ho NNP 19613 9257 70 techtheis techtheis NNP 19613 9257 71 ex ex NNP 19613 9257 72 agapês agapês NNP 19613 9257 73 karpos karpos NNP 19613 9257 74 agapê agapê NNP 19613 9257 75 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9257 76 . . . 19613 9258 1 But but CC 19613 9258 2 that that DT 19613 9258 3 does do VBZ 19613 9258 4 not not RB 19613 9258 5 exclude exclude VB 19613 9258 6 the the DT 19613 9258 7 fact fact NN 19613 9258 8 that that IN 19613 9258 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9258 10 , , , 19613 9258 11 like like IN 19613 9258 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9258 13 , , , 19613 9258 14 named name VBD 19613 9258 15 the the DT 19613 9258 16 Son Son NNP 19613 9258 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9258 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9258 19 : : : 19613 9258 20 ktisma ktisma NN 19613 9258 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9258 22 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9258 23 Phot Phot NNP 19613 9258 24 . . . 19613 9258 25 , , , 19613 9258 26 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9258 27 . . NNP 19613 9258 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9258 29 . . . 19613 9259 1 In in IN 19613 9259 2 the the DT 19613 9259 3 Adumbrat Adumbrat NNP 19613 9259 4 . . . 19613 9260 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9260 2 p. p. NN 19613 9260 3 88 88 CD 19613 9260 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9260 5 Son Son NNP 19613 9260 6 and and CC 19613 9260 7 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9260 8 are be VBP 19613 9260 9 called call VBN 19613 9260 10 " " `` 19613 9260 11 primitivæ primitivæ NNP 19613 9260 12 virtutes virtute NNS 19613 9260 13 ac ac IN 19613 9260 14 primo primo NNP 19613 9260 15 creatæ creatæ NNP 19613 9260 16 , , , 19613 9260 17 immobiles immobiles NNP 19613 9260 18 exsistentes exsistentes NNP 19613 9260 19 secundum secundum NNP 19613 9260 20 substantiam substantiam NNP 19613 9260 21 " " '' 19613 9260 22 . . . 19613 9261 1 That that DT 19613 9261 2 is be VBZ 19613 9261 3 exactly exactly RB 19613 9261 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9261 5 's 's POS 19613 9261 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9261 7 , , , 19613 9261 8 and and CC 19613 9261 9 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9261 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9261 11 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9261 12 . . NNP 19613 9261 13 , , , 19613 9261 14 p. p. NN 19613 9261 15 99 99 CD 19613 9261 16 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9261 17 has have VBZ 19613 9261 18 rightly rightly RB 19613 9261 19 compared compare VBN 19613 9261 20 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9261 21 . . . 19613 9262 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9262 2 14 14 CD 19613 9262 3 . . . 19613 9263 1 89 89 CD 19613 9263 2 : : : 19613 9263 3 VI VI NNP 19613 9263 4 . . . 19613 9264 1 7 7 LS 19613 9264 2 . . . 19613 9265 1 58 58 CD 19613 9265 2 ; ; : 19613 9265 3 and and CC 19613 9265 4 Epit Epit NNP 19613 9265 5 . . . 19613 9266 1 ex ex NNP 19613 9266 2 Theod Theod NNP 19613 9266 3 . . . 19613 9267 1 20 20 CD 19613 9267 2 . . . 19613 9268 1 The the DT 19613 9268 2 Son Son NNP 19613 9268 3 stands stand VBZ 19613 9268 4 at at IN 19613 9268 5 the the DT 19613 9268 6 head head NN 19613 9268 7 of of IN 19613 9268 8 the the DT 19613 9268 9 series series NN 19613 9268 10 of of IN 19613 9268 11 created create VBN 19613 9268 12 beings being NNS 19613 9268 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9268 14 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9268 15 . . . 19613 9269 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9269 2 . . . 19613 9270 1 2 2 LS 19613 9270 2 . . . 19613 9271 1 5 5 LS 19613 9271 2 ; ; : 19613 9271 3 see see VB 19613 9271 4 also also RB 19613 9271 5 below below RB 19613 9271 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9271 7 , , , 19613 9271 8 but but CC 19613 9271 9 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9271 10 is be VBZ 19613 9271 11 nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 9271 12 specifically specifically RB 19613 9271 13 different different JJ 19613 9271 14 from from IN 19613 9271 15 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9271 16 by by IN 19613 9271 17 reason reason NN 19613 9271 18 of of IN 19613 9271 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9271 20 origin origin NN 19613 9271 21 . . . 19613 9272 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9272 2 may may MD 19613 9272 3 be be VB 19613 9272 4 said say VBN 19613 9272 5 in in IN 19613 9272 6 general general JJ 19613 9272 7 that that IN 19613 9272 8 the the DT 19613 9272 9 fine fine JJ 19613 9272 10 distinctions distinction NNS 19613 9272 11 of of IN 19613 9272 12 the the DT 19613 9272 13 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9272 14 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9272 15 in in IN 19613 9272 16 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9272 17 and and CC 19613 9272 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9272 19 are be VBP 19613 9272 20 to to TO 19613 9272 21 be be VB 19613 9272 22 traced trace VBN 19613 9272 23 to to IN 19613 9272 24 the the DT 19613 9272 25 still still RB 19613 9272 26 more more RBR 19613 9272 27 abstract abstract JJ 19613 9272 28 conception conception NN 19613 9272 29 of of IN 19613 9272 30 God God NNP 19613 9272 31 found find VBD 19613 9272 32 in in IN 19613 9272 33 the the DT 19613 9272 34 former former JJ 19613 9272 35 . . . 19613 9273 1 A a DT 19613 9273 2 sentence sentence NN 19613 9273 3 like like IN 19613 9273 4 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9273 5 . . . 19613 9274 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9274 2 . . . 19613 9275 1 25 25 CD 19613 9275 2 . . . 19613 9276 1 156 156 CD 19613 9276 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9276 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9276 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9276 5 : : : 19613 9276 6 ho ho NNP 19613 9276 7 men man NNS 19613 9276 8 oun oun NNP 19613 9276 9 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9276 10 anapodeiktos anapodeiktos NNP 19613 9276 11 ôn ôn NNP 19613 9276 12 ouk ouk NNP 19613 9276 13 estin estin NNP 19613 9276 14 epistêmonikos epistêmonikos NNP 19613 9276 15 , , , 19613 9276 16 ho ho NNP 19613 9276 17 de de NNP 19613 9276 18 huios huios NNP 19613 9276 19 sophia sophia NNP 19613 9276 20 te te NNP 19613 9276 21 esti esti NNP 19613 9276 22 kai kai NNP 19613 9276 23 epistêmê epistêmê NNP 19613 9276 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9276 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9276 26 will will MD 19613 9276 27 hardly hardly RB 19613 9276 28 be be VB 19613 9276 29 found find VBN 19613 9276 30 in in IN 19613 9276 31 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9276 32 I -PRON- PRP 19613 9276 33 think think VBP 19613 9276 34 . . . 19613 9277 1 Cf cf NN 19613 9277 2 . . . 19613 9278 1 Schultz Schultz NNP 19613 9278 2 , , , 19613 9278 3 Gottheit Gottheit NNP 19613 9278 4 Christi Christi NNP 19613 9278 5 , , , 19613 9278 6 p. p. NN 19613 9278 7 45 45 CD 19613 9278 8 ff ff NN 19613 9278 9 . . . 19613 9278 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9279 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9279 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9279 3 730 730 CD 19613 9279 4 : : : 19613 9279 5 See see VB 19613 9279 6 Schultz Schultz NNP 19613 9279 7 , , , 19613 9279 8 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9279 9 . . NNP 19613 9279 10 , , , 19613 9279 11 p. p. NN 19613 9279 12 51 51 CD 19613 9279 13 ff ff NN 19613 9279 14 . . . 19613 9280 1 and and CC 19613 9280 2 Jahrbuch Jahrbuch NNP 19613 9280 3 fur fur NN 19613 9280 4 protestantische protestantische NN 19613 9280 5 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 9280 6 I. I. NNP 19613 9280 7 pp pp NN 19613 9280 8 . . . 19613 9281 1 193 193 CD 19613 9281 2 ff ff NNS 19613 9281 3 . . . 19613 9282 1 369 369 CD 19613 9282 2 ff ff NNP 19613 9282 3 . . . 19613 9282 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9283 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9283 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9283 3 731 731 CD 19613 9283 4 : : : 19613 9283 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9283 6 is be VBZ 19613 9283 7 very very RB 19613 9283 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 9283 9 that that IN 19613 9283 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9283 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9283 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9283 13 : : : 19613 9283 14 peri peri NN 19613 9283 15 archôn archôn NN 19613 9283 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9283 17 I. I. NNP 19613 9284 1 2 2 LS 19613 9284 2 . . . 19613 9285 1 1 1 CD 19613 9285 2 in in IN 19613 9285 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9285 4 presentation presentation NN 19613 9285 5 of of IN 19613 9285 6 the the DT 19613 9285 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9285 8 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9285 9 , , , 19613 9285 10 started start VBD 19613 9285 11 with with IN 19613 9285 12 the the DT 19613 9285 13 person person NN 19613 9285 14 of of IN 19613 9285 15 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9285 16 , , , 19613 9285 17 though though IN 19613 9285 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9285 19 immediately immediately RB 19613 9285 20 abandoned abandon VBD 19613 9285 21 this this DT 19613 9285 22 starting starting NN 19613 9285 23 - - HYPH 19613 9285 24 point point NN 19613 9285 25 " " `` 19613 9285 26 Primo Primo NNP 19613 9285 27 illud illud RB 19613 9285 28 nos nos NNP 19613 9285 29 oportere oportere NN 19613 9285 30 scire scire NN 19613 9285 31 " " '' 19613 9285 32 , , , 19613 9285 33 so so RB 19613 9285 34 this this DT 19613 9285 35 chapter chapter NN 19613 9285 36 begins begin VBZ 19613 9285 37 , , , 19613 9285 38 " " `` 19613 9285 39 Quod quod NN 19613 9285 40 aliud aliud NNS 19613 9285 41 est est NNP 19613 9285 42 in in IN 19613 9285 43 Christo Christo NNP 19613 9285 44 deitatis deitatis NNP 19613 9285 45 eius eius NNP 19613 9285 46 natura natura NNP 19613 9285 47 , , , 19613 9285 48 quod quod NN 19613 9285 49 est est NNP 19613 9285 50 unigenitus unigenitus NNP 19613 9285 51 filius filius NNP 19613 9285 52 patris patris NNP 19613 9285 53 , , , 19613 9285 54 et et NNP 19613 9285 55 alia alia NNP 19613 9285 56 humana humana NNP 19613 9285 57 natura natura NNP 19613 9285 58 , , , 19613 9285 59 quam quam NNP 19613 9285 60 in in IN 19613 9285 61 novissimis novissimis NNP 19613 9285 62 temporibus temporibus NNP 19613 9285 63 pro pro FW 19613 9285 64 dispensatione dispensatione NNP 19613 9285 65 suscepit suscepit NN 19613 9285 66 . . . 19613 9286 1 Propter Propter NNP 19613 9286 2 quod quod NN 19613 9286 3 videndum videndum NNP 19613 9286 4 primo primo NNP 19613 9286 5 est est NNP 19613 9286 6 , , , 19613 9286 7 quid quid NNP 19613 9286 8 sit sit VBP 19613 9286 9 unigenitus unigenitus NNP 19613 9286 10 filius filius NNP 19613 9286 11 dei dei NNP 19613 9286 12 . . . 19613 9286 13 " " '' 19613 9286 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9287 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9287 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9287 3 732 732 CD 19613 9287 4 : : : 19613 9287 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9287 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9287 7 : : : 19613 9287 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9287 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9287 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9287 11 I. i. NN 19613 9288 1 2 2 LS 19613 9288 2 . . . 19613 9289 1 2 2 CD 19613 9289 2 , , , 19613 9289 3 6 6 CD 19613 9289 4 . . . 19613 9289 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9290 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9290 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9290 3 733 733 CD 19613 9290 4 : : : 19613 9290 5 The the DT 19613 9290 6 expression expression NN 19613 9290 7 was be VBD 19613 9290 8 familiar familiar JJ 19613 9290 9 to to IN 19613 9290 10 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9290 11 as as IN 19613 9290 12 to to IN 19613 9290 13 Justin Justin NNP 19613 9290 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9290 15 see see VB 19613 9290 16 Dial Dial NNP 19613 9290 17 . . . 19613 9291 1 c. c. NN 19613 9291 2 Tryph Tryph NNP 19613 9291 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9291 4 . . . 19613 9292 1 See see VB 19613 9292 2 c. c. NN 19613 9292 3 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9292 4 . . . 19613 9293 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9293 2 39 39 CD 19613 9293 3 : : : 19613 9293 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9293 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9293 6 : : : 19613 9293 7 Kai Kai NNP 19613 9293 8 deuteron deuteron NNP 19613 9293 9 oun oun NNP 19613 9293 10 legômen legôman NNS 19613 9293 11 Theon Theon NNP 19613 9293 12 istôsan istôsan NNP 19613 9293 13 , , , 19613 9293 14 hoti hoti NNP 19613 9293 15 ton ton NN 19613 9293 16 deuteron deuteron NNP 19613 9293 17 Theon Theon NNP 19613 9293 18 ouk ouk NNP 19613 9293 19 allo allo VB 19613 9293 20 ti ti IN 19613 9293 21 legomen legoman NNS 19613 9293 22 , , , 19613 9293 23 hê hê NNP 19613 9293 24 tên tên NNP 19613 9293 25 periektikên periektikên NNP 19613 9293 26 pasôn pasôn NNP 19613 9293 27 aretôn aretôn NNP 19613 9293 28 aretên aretên NNP 19613 9293 29 kai kai NNP 19613 9293 30 ton ton NNP 19613 9293 31 periektikon periektikon NNP 19613 9293 32 pantos pantos NNP 19613 9293 33 houtinosoun houtinosoun NNP 19613 9293 34 logou logou NNP 19613 9293 35 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9293 36 kata kata NNP 19613 9293 37 physin physin NNP 19613 9293 38 kai kai NNP 19613 9293 39 proêgoumenôs proêgoumenôs NNP 19613 9293 40 gegenêmenôn gegenêmenôn NN 19613 9293 41 . . . 19613 9293 42 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9293 43 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9294 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9294 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9294 3 734 734 CD 19613 9294 4 : : : 19613 9294 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9294 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9294 7 : : : 19613 9294 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9294 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9294 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9294 11 I. i. NN 19613 9295 1 2 2 LS 19613 9295 2 . . . 19613 9296 1 13 13 CD 19613 9296 2 has have VBZ 19613 9296 3 been be VBN 19613 9296 4 much much RB 19613 9296 5 corrupted corrupt VBN 19613 9296 6 by by IN 19613 9296 7 Rufinus Rufinus NNP 19613 9296 8 . . . 19613 9297 1 The the DT 19613 9297 2 passage passage NN 19613 9297 3 must must MD 19613 9297 4 have have VB 19613 9297 5 been be VBN 19613 9297 6 to to IN 19613 9297 7 the the DT 19613 9297 8 effect effect NN 19613 9297 9 that that WDT 19613 9297 10 the the DT 19613 9297 11 Son Son NNP 19613 9297 12 is be VBZ 19613 9297 13 indeed indeed RB 19613 9297 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9297 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9297 16 : : : 19613 9297 17 agathos agathos NN 19613 9297 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9297 19 , , , 19613 9297 20 but but CC 19613 9297 21 not not RB 19613 9297 22 , , , 19613 9297 23 like like IN 19613 9297 24 the the DT 19613 9297 25 Father Father NNP 19613 9297 26 , , , 19613 9297 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9297 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9297 29 : : : 19613 9297 30 aparallaktôs aparallaktôs NNP 19613 9297 31 agathos agathos NNP 19613 9297 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9297 33 . . . 19613 9297 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9298 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9298 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9298 3 735 735 CD 19613 9298 4 : : : 19613 9298 5 Selecta Selecta NNP 19613 9298 6 in in IN 19613 9298 7 Psalm Psalm NNP 19613 9298 8 . . . 19613 9298 9 , , , 19613 9298 10 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9298 11 . . . 19613 9299 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9299 2 . . . 19613 9299 3 , , , 19613 9299 4 p. p. NN 19613 9299 5 134 134 CD 19613 9299 6 ; ; : 19613 9299 7 see see VBP 19613 9299 8 also also RB 19613 9299 9 Fragm Fragm NNP 19613 9299 10 . . . 19613 9300 1 comm comm NNP 19613 9300 2 . . . 19613 9301 1 in in IN 19613 9301 2 ep ep NNP 19613 9301 3 . . . 19613 9302 1 ad ad NNP 19613 9302 2 Hebr Hebr NNP 19613 9302 3 . . . 19613 9302 4 , , , 19613 9302 5 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9302 6 . . . 19613 9303 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9303 2 , , , 19613 9303 3 p. p. NN 19613 9303 4 299 299 CD 19613 9303 5 sq sq NNP 19613 9303 6 . . . 19613 9303 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9304 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9304 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9304 3 736 736 CD 19613 9304 4 : : : 19613 9304 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 9304 6 . . . 19613 9305 1 : : : 19613 9305 2 " " `` 19613 9305 3 Sic Sic NNP 19613 9305 4 et et NNP 19613 9305 5 sapientia sapientia NN 19613 9305 6 ex ex NNP 19613 9305 7 deo deo NNP 19613 9305 8 procedens procedens NNP 19613 9305 9 , , , 19613 9305 10 ex ex NNP 19613 9305 11 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 9305 12 substantia substantia NNP 19613 9305 13 dei dei NNP 19613 9305 14 generatur generatur NNP 19613 9305 15 . . . 19613 9306 1 Sic sic VB 19613 9306 2 nihilominus nihilominus NNP 19613 9306 3 et et FW 19613 9306 4 secundum secundum NN 19613 9306 5 similitudinem similitudinem NNP 19613 9306 6 corporalis corporalis NNP 19613 9306 7 aporrhoeæ aporrhoeæ NNP 19613 9306 8 esse esse NNP 19613 9306 9 dicitur dicitur NNP 19613 9306 10 aporrhoea aporrhoea NNP 19613 9306 11 gloriæ gloriæ NNP 19613 9306 12 omnipotentis omnipotentis NNP 19613 9306 13 pura pura NNP 19613 9306 14 quædam quædam NNP 19613 9306 15 et et NNP 19613 9306 16 sincera sincera NNP 19613 9306 17 . . . 19613 9307 1 Quæ Quæ NNP 19613 9307 2 utræque utræque JJ 19613 9307 3 similitudines similitudine NNS 19613 9307 4 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9307 5 see see VB 19613 9307 6 the the DT 19613 9307 7 beginning beginning NN 19613 9307 8 of of IN 19613 9307 9 the the DT 19613 9307 10 passage passage NN 19613 9307 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9307 12 manifestissime manifestissime NN 19613 9307 13 ostendunt ostendunt NN 19613 9307 14 communionem communionem NNP 19613 9307 15 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 9307 16 esse esse NNP 19613 9307 17 filio filio NNP 19613 9307 18 cum cum NNP 19613 9307 19 patre patre NNP 19613 9307 20 . . . 19613 9308 1 Aporrhoea Aporrhoea NNP 19613 9308 2 enim enim NNP 19613 9308 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9308 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9308 5 : : : 19613 9308 6 homoousios homoousio NNS 19613 9308 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9308 8 videtur videtur NNP 19613 9308 9 , , , 19613 9308 10 i -PRON- PRP 19613 9308 11 d d VBD 19613 9308 12 est est NNP 19613 9308 13 , , , 19613 9308 14 unius unius NNP 19613 9308 15 substantiæ substantiæ NNP 19613 9308 16 cum cum NNP 19613 9308 17 illo illo NNP 19613 9308 18 corpore corpore NNP 19613 9308 19 , , , 19613 9308 20 ex ex NNP 19613 9308 21 quo quo NNP 19613 9308 22 est est NNP 19613 9308 23 vel vel NNP 19613 9308 24 aporrhoea aporrhoea NNP 19613 9308 25 vel vel NNP 19613 9308 26 vapor vapor NNP 19613 9308 27 . . . 19613 9308 28 " " '' 19613 9309 1 In in IN 19613 9309 2 opposition opposition NN 19613 9309 3 to to IN 19613 9309 4 Heracleon Heracleon NNP 19613 9309 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9309 6 argues argue VBZ 19613 9309 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9309 8 in in IN 19613 9309 9 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9309 10 . . . 19613 9310 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9310 2 . . . 19613 9311 1 25 25 CD 19613 9311 2 . . . 19613 9311 3 , , , 19613 9311 4 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9311 5 . . . 19613 9312 1 II II NNP 19613 9312 2 . . NNP 19613 9312 3 , , , 19613 9312 4 p. p. NN 19613 9312 5 43 43 CD 19613 9312 6 sq sq NNP 19613 9312 7 . . . 19613 9312 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9313 1 that that IN 19613 9313 2 _ _ NNP 19613 9313 3 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9313 4 _ _ NNP 19613 9313 5 are be VBP 19613 9313 6 not not RB 19613 9313 7 homousios homousio NNS 19613 9313 8 with with IN 19613 9313 9 God God NNP 19613 9313 10 : : : 19613 9313 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9313 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9313 13 : : : 19613 9313 14 epistêsômen epistêsômen NNP 19613 9313 15 de de NNP 19613 9313 16 , , , 19613 9313 17 ei ei VBD 19613 9313 18 me -PRON- PRP 19613 9313 19 sphodra sphodra VBZ 19613 9313 20 estin estin NNP 19613 9313 21 asebes asebes NNP 19613 9313 22 homoousios homoousios NNPS 19613 9313 23 tê tê VBP 19613 9313 24 agennêtô agennêtô NNP 19613 9313 25 physei physei NNP 19613 9313 26 kai kai NNP 19613 9313 27 pammakaria pammakaria NNP 19613 9313 28 einai einai NNP 19613 9313 29 legein legein NNP 19613 9313 30 tous tous NNP 19613 9313 31 proskunountas proskunountas NNP 19613 9313 32 en en IN 19613 9313 33 pneumati pneumati RB 19613 9313 34 tô tô NNP 19613 9313 35 Theô Theô NNP 19613 9313 36 . . . 19613 9313 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9314 1 On on IN 19613 9314 2 the the DT 19613 9314 3 meaning meaning NN 19613 9314 4 of of IN 19613 9314 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9314 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9314 7 : : : 19613 9314 8 homoousios homoousio NNS 19613 9314 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9314 10 see see VBP 19613 9314 11 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9314 12 , , , 19613 9314 13 Marcell Marcell NNP 19613 9314 14 . . NNP 19613 9314 15 , , , 19613 9314 16 pp pp NNP 19613 9314 17 . . . 19613 9315 1 11 11 CD 19613 9315 2 - - SYM 19613 9315 3 32 32 CD 19613 9315 4 . . . 19613 9316 1 The the DT 19613 9316 2 conception conception NN 19613 9316 3 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 9316 4 excludes exclude VBZ 19613 9316 5 the the DT 19613 9316 6 possibility possibility NN 19613 9316 7 of of IN 19613 9316 8 the the DT 19613 9316 9 two two CD 19613 9316 10 subjects subject NNS 19613 9316 11 connected connect VBN 19613 9316 12 by by IN 19613 9316 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9316 14 having have VBG 19613 9316 15 a a DT 19613 9316 16 different different JJ 19613 9316 17 essence essence NN 19613 9316 18 ; ; : 19613 9316 19 but but CC 19613 9316 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9316 21 says say VBZ 19613 9316 22 nothing nothing NN 19613 9316 23 about about IN 19613 9316 24 how how WRB 19613 9316 25 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9316 26 came come VBD 19613 9316 27 to to TO 19613 9316 28 have have VB 19613 9316 29 one one CD 19613 9316 30 essence essence NN 19613 9316 31 and and CC 19613 9316 32 in in IN 19613 9316 33 what what WDT 19613 9316 34 measure measure NN 19613 9316 35 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9316 36 possess possess VBP 19613 9316 37 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9316 38 . . . 19613 9317 1 On on IN 19613 9317 2 the the DT 19613 9317 3 other other JJ 19613 9317 4 hand hand NN 19613 9317 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9317 6 abolishes abolish VBZ 19613 9317 7 the the DT 19613 9317 8 distinction distinction NN 19613 9317 9 of of IN 19613 9317 10 persons person NNS 19613 9317 11 the the DT 19613 9317 12 moment moment NN 19613 9317 13 the the DT 19613 9317 14 essence essence NN 19613 9317 15 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 9317 16 is be VBZ 19613 9317 17 identified identify VBN 19613 9317 18 with with IN 19613 9317 19 the the DT 19613 9317 20 one one CD 19613 9317 21 person person NN 19613 9317 22 . . . 19613 9318 1 Here here RB 19613 9318 2 then then RB 19613 9318 3 is be VBZ 19613 9318 4 found find VBN 19613 9318 5 the the DT 19613 9318 6 Unitarian unitarian JJ 19613 9318 7 danger danger NN 19613 9318 8 , , , 19613 9318 9 which which WDT 19613 9318 10 could could MD 19613 9318 11 only only RB 19613 9318 12 be be VB 19613 9318 13 averted avert VBN 19613 9318 14 by by IN 19613 9318 15 assertions assertion NNS 19613 9318 16 . . . 19613 9319 1 In in IN 19613 9319 2 some some DT 19613 9319 3 of of IN 19613 9319 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9319 5 's 's POS 19613 9319 6 teachings teaching NNS 19613 9319 7 a a DT 19613 9319 8 modalistic modalistic JJ 19613 9319 9 aspect aspect NN 19613 9319 10 is be VBZ 19613 9319 11 also also RB 19613 9319 12 not not RB 19613 9319 13 quite quite RB 19613 9319 14 wanting wanting JJ 19613 9319 15 . . . 19613 9320 1 See see VB 19613 9320 2 Hom Hom NNP 19613 9320 3 . . . 19613 9321 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 9321 2 . . . 19613 9322 1 in in IN 19613 9322 2 Jerem Jerem NNP 19613 9322 3 . . . 19613 9323 1 no no UH 19613 9323 2 . . . 19613 9324 1 2 2 LS 19613 9324 2 : : : 19613 9324 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9324 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9324 5 : : : 19613 9324 6 To to IN 19613 9324 7 men man NNS 19613 9324 8 hupokeimenon hupokeimenon NNP 19613 9324 9 hen hen NNP 19613 9324 10 esti esti NNP 19613 9324 11 , , , 19613 9324 12 tais tais NNP 19613 9324 13 de de FW 19613 9324 14 epinoiais epinoiais NNP 19613 9324 15 ta ta NNP 19613 9324 16 polla polla NNP 19613 9324 17 onomata onomata NNP 19613 9324 18 epi epi NNP 19613 9324 19 diaphorôn diaphorôn NNP 19613 9324 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9324 21 . . . 19613 9325 1 Conversely conversely RB 19613 9325 2 , , , 19613 9325 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9325 4 is be VBZ 19613 9325 5 also also RB 19613 9325 6 nothing nothing NN 19613 9325 7 but but IN 19613 9325 8 an an DT 19613 9325 9 appearance appearance NN 19613 9325 10 when when WRB 19613 9325 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9325 12 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9325 13 for for IN 19613 9325 14 ex ex NNP 19613 9325 15 . . . 19613 9326 1 in in IN 19613 9326 2 c. c. NNP 19613 9326 3 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9326 4 . . . 19613 9327 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 9327 2 . . . 19613 9328 1 12 12 LS 19613 9328 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9328 3 merely merely RB 19613 9328 4 traces trace VBZ 19613 9328 5 the the DT 19613 9328 6 unity unity NN 19613 9328 7 of of IN 19613 9328 8 Father Father NNP 19613 9328 9 and and CC 19613 9328 10 Son Son NNP 19613 9328 11 to to TO 19613 9328 12 unity unity VB 19613 9328 13 in in IN 19613 9328 14 feeling feeling NN 19613 9328 15 and and CC 19613 9328 16 in in IN 19613 9328 17 will will NN 19613 9328 18 . . . 19613 9329 1 The the DT 19613 9329 2 charge charge NN 19613 9329 3 of of IN 19613 9329 4 Ebionitism Ebionitism NNP 19613 9329 5 made make VBD 19613 9329 6 against against IN 19613 9329 7 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9329 8 is be VBZ 19613 9329 9 quite quite RB 19613 9329 10 unfounded unfounded JJ 19613 9329 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9329 12 see see VB 19613 9329 13 Pamphili Pamphili NNP 19613 9329 14 Apol Apol NNP 19613 9329 15 . . . 19613 9329 16 , , , 19613 9329 17 Routh Routh NNP 19613 9329 18 IV IV NNP 19613 9329 19 . . . 19613 9330 1 p. p. NN 19613 9331 1 367 367 CD 19613 9331 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9331 3 . . . 19613 9331 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9332 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9332 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9332 3 737 737 CD 19613 9332 4 : : : 19613 9332 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9332 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9332 7 : : : 19613 9332 8 Ouk Ouk NNP 19613 9332 9 estin estin NNP 19613 9332 10 ote ote NNP 19613 9332 11 ouk ouk NNP 19613 9332 12 ên ên NNP 19613 9332 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9332 14 , , , 19613 9332 15 de de FW 19613 9332 16 princip princip RB 19613 9332 17 . . . 19613 9333 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9334 1 2 2 LS 19613 9334 2 . . . 19613 9335 1 9 9 LS 19613 9335 2 ; ; : 19613 9335 3 in in IN 19613 9335 4 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9335 5 . . . 19613 9336 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9337 1 5 5 CD 19613 9337 2 . . . 19613 9337 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9338 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9338 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9338 3 738 738 CD 19613 9338 4 : : : 19613 9338 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9338 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9338 7 : : : 19613 9338 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9338 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9338 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9338 11 I. i. NN 19613 9339 1 2 2 LS 19613 9339 2 . . . 19613 9340 1 2 2 CD 19613 9340 2 - - SYM 19613 9340 3 9 9 CD 19613 9340 4 . . . 19613 9341 1 Comm Comm NNP 19613 9341 2 . . . 19613 9342 1 in in IN 19613 9342 2 ep ep NNP 19613 9342 3 . . . 19613 9343 1 ad ad NN 19613 9343 2 . . . 19613 9344 1 Hebr Hebr NNP 19613 9344 2 . . . 19613 9345 1 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9345 2 . . . 19613 9346 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9346 2 , , , 19613 9346 3 p. p. NN 19613 9346 4 296 296 CD 19613 9346 5 : : : 19613 9346 6 " " `` 19613 9346 7 Nunquam Nunquam NNP 19613 9346 8 est est NNP 19613 9346 9 , , , 19613 9346 10 quando quando NNP 19613 9346 11 filius filius NNP 19613 9346 12 non non NNP 19613 9346 13 fuit fuit NN 19613 9346 14 . . . 19613 9347 1 Erat erat VB 19613 9347 2 autem autem NN 19613 9347 3 non non NN 19613 9347 4 , , , 19613 9347 5 sicut sicut NNP 19613 9347 6 de de NNP 19613 9347 7 æterna æterna NNP 19613 9347 8 luce luce NNP 19613 9347 9 diximus diximus NNP 19613 9347 10 , , , 19613 9347 11 innatus innatus NNP 19613 9347 12 , , , 19613 9347 13 ne ne NNP 19613 9347 14 duo duo NNP 19613 9347 15 principia principia NNP 19613 9347 16 lucis lucis NNP 19613 9347 17 videamur videamur NNP 19613 9347 18 inducere inducere NNP 19613 9347 19 , , , 19613 9347 20 sed sed NNP 19613 9347 21 sicut sicut NNP 19613 9347 22 ingenitæ ingenitæ NNP 19613 9347 23 lucis lucis NNP 19613 9347 24 splendor splendor NNP 19613 9347 25 , , , 19613 9347 26 ipsam ipsam NNP 19613 9347 27 illam illam NNP 19613 9347 28 lucem lucem NNP 19613 9347 29 initium initium NNP 19613 9347 30 habens habens NNP 19613 9347 31 ac ac NNP 19613 9347 32 fontem fontem NNP 19613 9347 33 , , , 19613 9347 34 natus natus NNP 19613 9347 35 quidem quidem NNP 19613 9347 36 ex ex NNP 19613 9347 37 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 9347 38 ; ; , 19613 9347 39 sed se VBD 19613 9347 40 non non AFX 19613 9347 41 erat erat NNP 19613 9347 42 quando quando NNP 19613 9347 43 noa noa NNP 19613 9347 44 erat erat NNP 19613 9347 45 . . . 19613 9347 46 " " '' 19613 9348 1 See see VB 19613 9348 2 the the DT 19613 9348 3 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 9348 4 disquisition disquisition NN 19613 9348 5 in in IN 19613 9348 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9348 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9348 8 : : : 19613 9348 9 peri peri NN 19613 9348 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9348 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9348 12 IV IV NNP 19613 9348 13 . . . 19613 9349 1 28 28 CD 19613 9349 2 , , , 19613 9349 3 where where WRB 19613 9349 4 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9349 5 find find VBP 19613 9349 6 the the DT 19613 9349 7 sentence sentence NN 19613 9349 8 : : : 19613 9349 9 " " `` 19613 9349 10 hoc hoc FW 19613 9349 11 autem autem NNP 19613 9349 12 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 9349 13 , , , 19613 9349 14 quod quod NNP 19613 9349 15 dicimus dicimus NNP 19613 9349 16 , , , 19613 9349 17 quia quia NNP 19613 9349 18 nunquam nunquam NNP 19613 9349 19 fuit fuit NNP 19613 9349 20 , , , 19613 9349 21 quando quando NNP 19613 9349 22 non non NNP 19613 9349 23 fuit fuit NNP 19613 9349 24 , , , 19613 9349 25 cum cum NNP 19613 9349 26 venia venia NNP 19613 9349 27 audiendum audiendum NNP 19613 9349 28 est est NNP 19613 9349 29 " " `` 19613 9349 30 etc etc FW 19613 9349 31 . . . 19613 9350 1 See see VB 19613 9350 2 further further RB 19613 9350 3 in in IN 19613 9350 4 Jerem Jerem NNP 19613 9350 5 . . . 19613 9351 1 IX ix NN 19613 9351 2 . . . 19613 9352 1 4 4 LS 19613 9352 2 , , , 19613 9352 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9352 4 . . . 19613 9353 1 XV XV NNP 19613 9353 2 . . NNP 19613 9353 3 , , , 19613 9353 4 p. p. NN 19613 9353 5 212 212 CD 19613 9353 6 : : : 19613 9353 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9353 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9353 9 : : : 19613 9353 10 to to TO 19613 9353 11 apaugasma apaugasma VB 19613 9353 12 tês tês NNP 19613 9353 13 doxês doxês NNP 19613 9353 14 ouchi ouchi NNP 19613 9353 15 hapax hapax NNP 19613 9353 16 gegennêtai gegennêtai NNP 19613 9353 17 , , , 19613 9353 18 kai kai NNP 19613 9353 19 ouchi ouchi NNP 19613 9353 20 gennatai gennatai NNP 19613 9353 21 ... ... : 19613 9353 22 kai kai NNP 19613 9353 23 aei aei NNP 19613 9353 24 gennatai gennatai NNP 19613 9353 25 ho ho NNP 19613 9353 26 sôtêr sôtêr NNP 19613 9353 27 hupo hupo NNP 19613 9353 28 tou tou NNP 19613 9353 29 patros patros NNP 19613 9353 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9353 31 ; ; : 19613 9353 32 see see VB 19613 9353 33 also also RB 19613 9353 34 other other JJ 19613 9353 35 passages passage NNS 19613 9353 36 . . . 19613 9353 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9354 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9354 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9354 3 739 739 CD 19613 9354 4 : : : 19613 9354 5 See see VB 19613 9354 6 Caspari Caspari NNP 19613 9354 7 , , , 19613 9354 8 Quellen Quellen NNP 19613 9354 9 , , , 19613 9354 10 Vol Vol NNP 19613 9354 11 . . . 19613 9355 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9355 2 . . NNP 19613 9355 3 , , , 19613 9355 4 p. p. NN 19613 9356 1 10 10 CD 19613 9356 2 . . . 19613 9356 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9357 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9357 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9357 3 740 740 CD 19613 9357 4 : : : 19613 9357 5 In in IN 19613 9357 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9357 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9357 8 : : : 19613 9357 9 peri peri NN 19613 9357 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9357 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9357 12 IV IV NNP 19613 9357 13 . . . 19613 9358 1 28 28 CD 19613 9358 2 the the DT 19613 9358 3 _ _ NNP 19613 9358 4 prolatio prolatio NN 19613 9358 5 _ _ NNP 19613 9358 6 is be VBZ 19613 9358 7 expressly expressly RB 19613 9358 8 rejected reject VBN 19613 9358 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9358 10 see see VB 19613 9358 11 also also RB 19613 9358 12 I. I. NNP 19613 9359 1 2 2 CD 19613 9359 2 , , , 19613 9359 3 4 4 CD 19613 9359 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9359 5 as as RB 19613 9359 6 well well RB 19613 9359 7 as as IN 19613 9359 8 the the DT 19613 9359 9 " " `` 19613 9359 10 conversio conversio NNP 19613 9359 11 partis partis NN 19613 9359 12 alicuius alicuius NNP 19613 9359 13 substantiæ substantiæ NNS 19613 9359 14 dei dei NNP 19613 9359 15 in in IN 19613 9359 16 filium filium NN 19613 9359 17 " " '' 19613 9359 18 and and CC 19613 9359 19 the the DT 19613 9359 20 " " `` 19613 9359 21 procreatio procreatio NNP 19613 9359 22 ex ex NNP 19613 9359 23 nullis nullis NNP 19613 9359 24 substantibus substantibus NN 19613 9359 25 . . . 19613 9359 26 " " '' 19613 9359 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9360 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9360 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9360 3 741 741 CD 19613 9360 4 : : : 19613 9360 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 9360 6 . . . 19613 9361 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9362 1 2 2 LS 19613 9362 2 . . . 19613 9363 1 2 2 LS 19613 9363 2 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9363 3 . . . 19613 9364 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9364 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9364 3 742 742 CD 19613 9364 4 : : : 19613 9364 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 9364 6 . . . 19613 9365 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9366 1 2 2 LS 19613 9366 2 . . . 19613 9367 1 3 3 LS 19613 9367 2 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9367 3 . . . 19613 9368 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9368 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9368 3 743 743 CD 19613 9368 4 : : : 19613 9368 5 De De NNP 19613 9368 6 orat orat NNP 19613 9368 7 . . . 19613 9369 1 15 15 CD 19613 9369 2 : : : 19613 9369 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9369 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9369 5 : : : 19613 9369 6 Eteros Eteros NNP 19613 9369 7 kat kat NNP 19613 9369 8 ' ' '' 19613 9369 9 ousian ousian JJ 19613 9369 10 kai kai NNP 19613 9369 11 hupokeimenon hupokeimenon NNP 19613 9369 12 ho ho NNP 19613 9369 13 huios huios NNP 19613 9369 14 esti esti NNP 19613 9369 15 tou tou NNP 19613 9369 16 patros patros NNP 19613 9369 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9369 18 . . . 19613 9370 1 This this DT 19613 9370 2 , , , 19613 9370 3 however however RB 19613 9370 4 , , , 19613 9370 5 is be VBZ 19613 9370 6 not not RB 19613 9370 7 meant mean VBN 19613 9370 8 to to TO 19613 9370 9 designate designate VB 19613 9370 10 a a DT 19613 9370 11 deity deity NN 19613 9370 12 of of IN 19613 9370 13 a a DT 19613 9370 14 hybrid hybrid JJ 19613 9370 15 nature nature NN 19613 9370 16 , , , 19613 9370 17 but but CC 19613 9370 18 to to TO 19613 9370 19 mark mark VB 19613 9370 20 the the DT 19613 9370 21 parsonal parsonal JJ 19613 9370 22 distinction distinction NN 19613 9370 23 . . . 19613 9370 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9371 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9371 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9371 3 744 744 CD 19613 9371 4 : : : 19613 9371 5 C. C. NNP 19613 9371 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9371 7 . . . 19613 9372 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 9372 2 . . . 19613 9373 1 12 12 CD 19613 9373 2 . . . 19613 9373 3 : : : 19613 9373 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9373 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9373 6 : : : 19613 9373 7 duo duo NN 19613 9373 8 tê tê NNP 19613 9373 9 hypostasei hypostasei NNP 19613 9373 10 pragmata pragmata NNP 19613 9373 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9373 12 . . . 19613 9374 1 This this DT 19613 9374 2 was be VBD 19613 9374 3 frequently frequently RB 19613 9374 4 urged urge VBN 19613 9374 5 against against IN 19613 9374 6 the the DT 19613 9374 7 Monarchians Monarchians NNPS 19613 9374 8 in in IN 19613 9374 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9374 10 's 's POS 19613 9374 11 commentaries commentary NNS 19613 9374 12 ; ; : 19613 9374 13 see see VB 19613 9374 14 in in IN 19613 9374 15 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9374 16 . . . 19613 9375 1 X. X. NNP 19613 9376 1 21 21 CD 19613 9376 2 : : : 19613 9376 3 II ii CD 19613 9376 4 . . . 19613 9377 1 6 6 CD 19613 9377 2 etc etc NN 19613 9377 3 . . . 19613 9378 1 The the DT 19613 9378 2 Son Son NNP 19613 9378 3 exists exist VBZ 19613 9378 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9378 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9378 6 : : : 19613 9378 7 kat kat NNP 19613 9378 8 ' ' `` 19613 9378 9 idian idian JJ 19613 9378 10 tês tês NNP 19613 9378 11 ousias ousias NNP 19613 9378 12 perigraphên perigraphên NNP 19613 9378 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9378 14 . . . 19613 9379 1 Not not RB 19613 9379 2 that that IN 19613 9379 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9379 4 has have VBZ 19613 9379 5 not not RB 19613 9379 6 yet yet RB 19613 9379 7 the the DT 19613 9379 8 later later JJ 19613 9379 9 terminology terminology NN 19613 9379 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9379 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9379 12 : : : 19613 9379 13 ousia ousia NNP 19613 9379 14 , , , 19613 9379 15 hypostasis hypostasis NN 19613 9379 16 , , , 19613 9379 17 hypokeimenon hypokeimenon NN 19613 9379 18 , , , 19613 9379 19 prosôpon prosôpon NNP 19613 9379 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9379 21 . . . 19613 9380 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 9380 2 find find VBP 19613 9380 3 three three CD 19613 9380 4 hypostases hypostasis NNS 19613 9380 5 in in IN 19613 9380 6 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9380 7 . . . 19613 9381 1 II ii CD 19613 9381 2 . . . 19613 9382 1 6 6 CD 19613 9382 2 . . . 19613 9383 1 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9383 2 . . . 19613 9384 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9384 2 , , , 19613 9384 3 p. p. NN 19613 9384 4 109 109 CD 19613 9384 5 , , , 19613 9384 6 and and CC 19613 9384 7 this this DT 19613 9384 8 is be VBZ 19613 9384 9 repeatedly repeatedly RB 19613 9384 10 the the DT 19613 9384 11 case case NN 19613 9384 12 in in IN 19613 9384 13 c. c. NNP 19613 9385 1 Cels cel NNS 19613 9385 2 . . . 19613 9385 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9386 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9386 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9386 3 745 745 CD 19613 9386 4 : : : 19613 9386 5 In in IN 19613 9386 6 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9386 7 . . . 19613 9387 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9388 1 22 22 CD 19613 9388 2 , , , 19613 9388 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9388 4 . . . 19613 9389 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9389 2 , , , 19613 9389 3 p. p. NN 19613 9389 4 41 41 CD 19613 9389 5 sq sq NN 19613 9389 6 . . . 19613 9390 1 : : : 19613 9390 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9390 3 Greek greek NN 19613 9390 4 : : : 19613 9390 5 ho ho NNP 19613 9390 6 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9390 7 men man NNS 19613 9390 8 oun oun NNP 19613 9390 9 pantê pantê NN 19613 9390 10 hen hen NNP 19613 9390 11 esti esti NNP 19613 9390 12 kai kai NNP 19613 9390 13 aploun aploun NNP 19613 9390 14 ho ho NNP 19613 9390 15 de de NNP 19613 9390 16 sôtêr sôtêr NNP 19613 9390 17 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 9390 18 dia dia NNP 19613 9390 19 ta ta NNP 19613 9390 20 polla polla NN 19613 9390 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9390 22 . . . 19613 9391 1 The the DT 19613 9391 2 Son Son NNP 19613 9391 3 is be VBZ 19613 9391 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9391 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9391 6 : : : 19613 9391 7 idea idea NN 19613 9391 8 ideôn ideôn NNP 19613 9391 9 , , , 19613 9391 10 systêma systêma NN 19613 9391 11 theôrêmatôn theôrêmatôn NNS 19613 9391 12 en en IN 19613 9391 13 autô](Lomm autô](Lomm NNP 19613 9391 14 . . . 19613 9392 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9392 2 , , , 19613 9392 3 p. p. NN 19613 9393 1 127 127 CD 19613 9393 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9393 3 . . . 19613 9393 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9394 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9394 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9394 3 746 746 CD 19613 9394 4 : : : 19613 9394 5 See see VB 19613 9394 6 the the DT 19613 9394 7 remarks remark NNS 19613 9394 8 on on IN 19613 9394 9 the the DT 19613 9394 10 saying saying NN 19613 9394 11 : : : 19613 9394 12 " " `` 19613 9394 13 The the DT 19613 9394 14 Father Father NNP 19613 9394 15 is be VBZ 19613 9394 16 greater great JJR 19613 9394 17 than than IN 19613 9394 18 I -PRON- PRP 19613 9394 19 , , , 19613 9394 20 " " '' 19613 9394 21 in in IN 19613 9394 22 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9394 23 . . . 19613 9395 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9395 2 . . . 19613 9396 1 25 25 CD 19613 9396 2 , , , 19613 9396 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9396 4 . . . 19613 9397 1 II II NNP 19613 9397 2 . . NNP 19613 9397 3 , , , 19613 9397 4 p. p. NN 19613 9397 5 45 45 CD 19613 9397 6 sq sq NN 19613 9397 7 . . . 19613 9398 1 and and CC 19613 9398 2 other other JJ 19613 9398 3 passages passage NNS 19613 9398 4 . . . 19613 9399 1 Here here RB 19613 9399 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9399 3 shows show VBZ 19613 9399 4 that that IN 19613 9399 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9399 6 considers consider VBZ 19613 9399 7 the the DT 19613 9399 8 homoousia homoousia NN 19613 9399 9 of of IN 19613 9399 10 the the DT 19613 9399 11 Son Son NNP 19613 9399 12 and and CC 19613 9399 13 the the DT 19613 9399 14 Father Father NNP 19613 9399 15 just just RB 19613 9399 16 as as RB 19613 9399 17 relative relative JJ 19613 9399 18 as as IN 19613 9399 19 the the DT 19613 9399 20 unchangeability unchangeability NN 19613 9399 21 of of IN 19613 9399 22 the the DT 19613 9399 23 Son Son NNP 19613 9399 24 . . . 19613 9399 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9400 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9400 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9400 3 747 747 CD 19613 9400 4 : : : 19613 9400 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9400 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9400 7 : : : 19613 9400 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9400 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9400 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9400 11 II II NNP 19613 9400 12 . . . 19613 9401 1 2 2 LS 19613 9401 2 . . . 19613 9402 1 6 6 CD 19613 9402 2 has have VBZ 19613 9402 3 been be VBN 19613 9402 4 corrupted corrupt VBN 19613 9402 5 by by IN 19613 9402 6 Rufinus Rufinus NNP 19613 9402 7 ; ; : 19613 9402 8 see see VB 19613 9402 9 Jerome Jerome NNP 19613 9402 10 ep ep NNP 19613 9402 11 . . . 19613 9403 1 ad ad NNP 19613 9403 2 Avitum Avitum NNP 19613 9403 3 . . . 19613 9403 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9404 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9404 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9404 3 748 748 CD 19613 9404 4 : : : 19613 9404 5 See see VB 19613 9404 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9404 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9404 8 : : : 19613 9404 9 Peri peri NN 19613 9404 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9404 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9404 12 I. i. NN 19613 9405 1 2 2 LS 19613 9405 2 . . . 19613 9406 1 13 13 CD 19613 9406 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9406 3 see see VB 19613 9406 4 above above RB 19613 9406 5 , , , 19613 9406 6 p. p. NN 19613 9406 7 354 354 CD 19613 9406 8 , , , 19613 9406 9 note note VBP 19613 9406 10 3 3 CD 19613 9406 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9406 12 . . . 19613 9406 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9407 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9407 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9407 3 749 749 CD 19613 9407 4 : : : 19613 9407 5 Athanasius Athanasius NNP 19613 9407 6 supplemented supplement VBD 19613 9407 7 this this DT 19613 9407 8 by by IN 19613 9407 9 determining determine VBG 19613 9407 10 the the DT 19613 9407 11 essence essence NN 19613 9407 12 of of IN 19613 9407 13 the the DT 19613 9407 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9407 15 from from IN 19613 9407 16 the the DT 19613 9407 17 redeeming redeem VBG 19613 9407 18 work work NN 19613 9407 19 of of IN 19613 9407 20 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9407 21 . . . 19613 9407 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9408 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9408 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9408 3 750 750 CD 19613 9408 4 : : : 19613 9408 5 See see VB 19613 9408 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9408 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9408 8 : : : 19613 9408 9 peri peri NN 19613 9408 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9408 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9408 12 præf præf NNP 19613 9408 13 . . . 19613 9409 1 and and CC 19613 9409 2 in in IN 19613 9409 3 addition addition NN 19613 9409 4 to to IN 19613 9409 5 this this DT 19613 9409 6 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 9409 7 ' ' POS 19613 9409 8 view view NN 19613 9409 9 of of IN 19613 9409 10 the the DT 19613 9409 11 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9409 12 . . . 19613 9409 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9410 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9410 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9410 3 751 751 CD 19613 9410 4 : : : 19613 9410 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9410 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9410 7 : : : 19613 9410 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9410 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9410 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9410 11 I. i. NN 19613 9411 1 3 3 LS 19613 9411 2 . . . 19613 9412 1 The the DT 19613 9412 2 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9412 3 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9412 4 is be VBZ 19613 9412 5 eternal eternal JJ 19613 9412 6 , , , 19613 9412 7 is be VBZ 19613 9412 8 ever ever RB 19613 9412 9 being be VBG 19613 9412 10 breathed breathe VBN 19613 9412 11 out out RP 19613 9412 12 , , , 19613 9412 13 but but CC 19613 9412 14 is be VBZ 19613 9412 15 to to TO 19613 9412 16 be be VB 19613 9412 17 termed term VBN 19613 9412 18 a a DT 19613 9412 19 creature creature NN 19613 9412 20 . . . 19613 9413 1 See see VB 19613 9413 2 also also RB 19613 9413 3 in in IN 19613 9413 4 Job Job NNP 19613 9413 5 . . . 19613 9414 1 II ii CD 19613 9414 2 . . . 19613 9415 1 6 6 LS 19613 9415 2 , , , 19613 9415 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9415 4 . . . 19613 9416 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9416 2 , , , 19613 9416 3 p. p. NN 19613 9416 4 109 109 CD 19613 9416 5 sq sq NN 19613 9416 6 . . . 19613 9417 1 : : : 19613 9417 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9417 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9417 4 : : : 19613 9417 5 to to TO 19613 9417 6 hagion hagion NNP 19613 9417 7 pneuma pneuma NNP 19613 9417 8 dia dia NNP 19613 9417 9 tou tou NNP 19613 9417 10 logou logou NNP 19613 9417 11 egeneto egeneto NNP 19613 9417 12 , , , 19613 9417 13 presbuterou presbuterou NN 19613 9417 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9417 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9417 16 logically logically RB 19613 9417 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9417 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9417 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9417 20 : : : 19613 9417 21 par par NNP 19613 9417 22 ' ' `` 19613 9417 23 auto auto NN 19613 9417 24 tou tou NNP 19613 9417 25 logou logou NNP 19613 9417 26 tugchanontos tugchanontos NNP 19613 9417 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9417 28 . . . 19613 9418 1 Yet yet RB 19613 9418 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9418 3 is be VBZ 19613 9418 4 not not RB 19613 9418 5 so so RB 19613 9418 6 confident confident JJ 19613 9418 7 here here RB 19613 9418 8 as as IN 19613 9418 9 in in IN 19613 9418 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9418 11 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9418 12 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9418 13 . . . 19613 9418 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9419 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9419 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9419 3 752 752 CD 19613 9419 4 : : : 19613 9419 5 See see VB 19613 9419 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9419 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9419 8 : : : 19613 9419 9 peri peri NN 19613 9419 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9419 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9419 12 I. I. NNP 19613 9420 1 3 3 CD 19613 9420 2 , , , 19613 9420 3 5 5 CD 19613 9420 4 - - SYM 19613 9420 5 8 8 CD 19613 9420 6 . . . 19613 9421 1 Hence hence RB 19613 9421 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9421 3 says say VBZ 19613 9421 4 the the DT 19613 9421 5 heathen heathen NN 19613 9421 6 had have VBD 19613 9421 7 known know VBN 19613 9421 8 the the DT 19613 9421 9 Father Father NNP 19613 9421 10 and and CC 19613 9421 11 Son Son NNP 19613 9421 12 , , , 19613 9421 13 but but CC 19613 9421 14 not not RB 19613 9421 15 the the DT 19613 9421 16 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9421 17 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9421 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9421 19 de de FW 19613 9421 20 princip princip NN 19613 9421 21 . . . 19613 9422 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9423 1 3 3 LS 19613 9423 2 : : : 19613 9423 3 II ii CD 19613 9423 4 . . . 19613 9424 1 7 7 LS 19613 9424 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9424 3 . . . 19613 9424 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9425 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9425 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9425 3 753 753 CD 19613 9425 4 : : : 19613 9425 5 L.c L.c NNP 19613 9425 6 . . . 19613 9426 1 § § ADD 19613 9426 2 7 7 CD 19613 9426 3 . . . 19613 9426 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9427 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9427 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9427 3 754 754 CD 19613 9427 4 : : : 19613 9427 5 See see VB 19613 9427 6 Hom Hom NNP 19613 9427 7 . . . 19613 9428 1 in in IN 19613 9428 2 Num Num NNP 19613 9428 3 . . . 19613 9429 1 XII XII NNP 19613 9429 2 . . . 19613 9430 1 I -PRON- PRP 19613 9430 2 , , , 19613 9430 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9430 4 . . . 19613 9431 1 X X NNP 19613 9431 2 , , , 19613 9431 3 p. p. NN 19613 9431 4 127 127 CD 19613 9431 5 : : : 19613 9431 6 " " `` 19613 9431 7 Est Est NNP 19613 9431 8 hæc hæc NNP 19613 9431 9 trium trium NN 19613 9431 10 distinctio distinctio NNP 19613 9431 11 personarum personarum NNP 19613 9431 12 in in IN 19613 9431 13 patre patre NNP 19613 9431 14 et et NNP 19613 9431 15 filio filio NNP 19613 9431 16 et et NNP 19613 9431 17 spiritu spiritu VBD 19613 9431 18 sancto sancto NNP 19613 9431 19 , , , 19613 9431 20 quæ quæ NNP 19613 9431 21 ad ad NN 19613 9431 22 pluralem pluralem NNP 19613 9431 23 puteorum puteorum NNP 19613 9431 24 numerum numerum NNP 19613 9431 25 revocatur revocatur NNP 19613 9431 26 . . . 19613 9432 1 Sed Sed NNP 19613 9432 2 horum horum NNP 19613 9432 3 puteorum puteorum NNP 19613 9432 4 unum unum NNP 19613 9432 5 est est NNP 19613 9432 6 fons fon NNS 19613 9432 7 . . . 19613 9433 1 Una Una NNP 19613 9433 2 enim enim NNP 19613 9433 3 substantia substantia NNS 19613 9433 4 est est NNP 19613 9433 5 et et NNP 19613 9433 6 natura natura NNP 19613 9433 7 trinitatis trinitatis NNP 19613 9433 8 . . . 19613 9433 9 " " '' 19613 9433 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9434 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9434 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9434 3 755 755 CD 19613 9434 4 : : : 19613 9434 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9434 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9434 7 : : : 19613 9434 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9434 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9434 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9434 11 præf præf NNP 19613 9434 12 . . . 19613 9434 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9435 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9435 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9435 3 756 756 CD 19613 9435 4 : : : 19613 9435 5 From from IN 19613 9435 6 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 9435 7 , , , 19613 9435 8 Justin Justin NNP 19613 9435 9 , , , 19613 9435 10 and and CC 19613 9435 11 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 19613 9435 12 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9435 13 learn learn VBP 19613 9435 14 how how WRB 19613 9435 15 , , , 19613 9435 16 in in IN 19613 9435 17 the the DT 19613 9435 18 2nd 2nd JJ 19613 9435 19 century century NN 19613 9435 20 , , , 19613 9435 21 both both CC 19613 9435 22 in in IN 19613 9435 23 the the DT 19613 9435 24 belief belief NN 19613 9435 25 of of IN 19613 9435 26 uneducated uneducated JJ 19613 9435 27 lay lay NN 19613 9435 28 - - HYPH 19613 9435 29 Christians Christians NNPS 19613 9435 30 and and CC 19613 9435 31 of of IN 19613 9435 32 the the DT 19613 9435 33 Apologists Apologists NNPS 19613 9435 34 , , , 19613 9435 35 Son Son NNP 19613 9435 36 , , , 19613 9435 37 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9435 38 , , , 19613 9435 39 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9435 40 , , , 19613 9435 41 and and CC 19613 9435 42 angels angel NNS 19613 9435 43 under under IN 19613 9435 44 certain certain JJ 19613 9435 45 circumstances circumstance NNS 19613 9435 46 shaded shade VBD 19613 9435 47 off off RP 19613 9435 48 into into IN 19613 9435 49 one one CD 19613 9435 50 another another DT 19613 9435 51 . . . 19613 9436 1 To to IN 19613 9436 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9436 3 , , , 19613 9436 4 no no RB 19613 9436 5 doubt doubt RB 19613 9436 6 , , , 19613 9436 7 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9436 8 and and CC 19613 9436 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9436 10 are be VBP 19613 9436 11 the the DT 19613 9436 12 only only JJ 19613 9436 13 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 9436 14 beings being NNS 19613 9436 15 besides besides IN 19613 9436 16 God God NNP 19613 9436 17 . . . 19613 9437 1 But but CC 19613 9437 2 , , , 19613 9437 3 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 9437 4 as as IN 19613 9437 5 there there EX 19613 9437 6 is be VBZ 19613 9437 7 a a DT 19613 9437 8 series series NN 19613 9437 9 which which WDT 19613 9437 10 descends descend VBZ 19613 9437 11 from from IN 19613 9437 12 God God NNP 19613 9437 13 to to IN 19613 9437 14 men man NNS 19613 9437 15 living live VBG 19613 9437 16 in in IN 19613 9437 17 the the DT 19613 9437 18 flesh flesh NN 19613 9437 19 , , , 19613 9437 20 there there EX 19613 9437 21 can can MD 19613 9437 22 not not RB 19613 9437 23 fail fail VB 19613 9437 24 to to TO 19613 9437 25 be be VB 19613 9437 26 elements element NNS 19613 9437 27 of of IN 19613 9437 28 affinity affinity NN 19613 9437 29 between between IN 19613 9437 30 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9437 31 and and CC 19613 9437 32 Spirit Spirit NNP 19613 9437 33 on on IN 19613 9437 34 the the DT 19613 9437 35 one one CD 19613 9437 36 hand hand NN 19613 9437 37 and and CC 19613 9437 38 the the DT 19613 9437 39 highest high JJS 19613 9437 40 angels angel NNS 19613 9437 41 on on IN 19613 9437 42 the the DT 19613 9437 43 other other JJ 19613 9437 44 , , , 19613 9437 45 all all DT 19613 9437 46 of of IN 19613 9437 47 whom whom WP 19613 9437 48 indeed indeed RB 19613 9437 49 have have VBP 19613 9437 50 the the DT 19613 9437 51 capacity capacity NN 19613 9437 52 and and CC 19613 9437 53 need need NN 19613 9437 54 of of IN 19613 9437 55 development development NN 19613 9437 56 . . . 19613 9438 1 Hence hence RB 19613 9438 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9438 3 have have VBP 19613 9438 4 certain certain JJ 19613 9438 5 names name NNS 19613 9438 6 and and CC 19613 9438 7 predicates predicate NNS 19613 9438 8 in in IN 19613 9438 9 common common JJ 19613 9438 10 , , , 19613 9438 11 and and CC 19613 9438 12 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9438 13 frequently frequently RB 19613 9438 14 remains remain VBZ 19613 9438 15 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 9438 16 , , , 19613 9438 17 especially especially RB 19613 9438 18 as as IN 19613 9438 19 regards regard VBZ 19613 9438 20 the the DT 19613 9438 21 theophanies theophany NNS 19613 9438 22 in in IN 19613 9438 23 the the DT 19613 9438 24 Old Old NNP 19613 9438 25 Testament Testament NNP 19613 9438 26 , , , 19613 9438 27 whether whether IN 19613 9438 28 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9438 29 was be VBD 19613 9438 30 a a DT 19613 9438 31 high high JJ 19613 9438 32 angel angel NN 19613 9438 33 that that WDT 19613 9438 34 spoke speak VBD 19613 9438 35 , , , 19613 9438 36 or or CC 19613 9438 37 the the DT 19613 9438 38 Son Son NNP 19613 9438 39 through through IN 19613 9438 40 the the DT 19613 9438 41 angel angel NN 19613 9438 42 . . . 19613 9439 1 See see VB 19613 9439 2 the the DT 19613 9439 3 full full JJ 19613 9439 4 discussion discussion NN 19613 9439 5 in in IN 19613 9439 6 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9439 7 , , , 19613 9439 8 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 9439 9 , , , 19613 9439 10 III III NNP 19613 9439 11 . . NNP 19613 9439 12 , , , 19613 9439 13 p. p. NN 19613 9439 14 98 98 CD 19613 9439 15 f. f. NN 19613 9439 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9439 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9439 18 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9439 19 757 757 CD 19613 9439 20 : : : 19613 9439 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9439 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9439 23 : : : 19613 9439 24 Peri peri NN 19613 9439 25 archôn archôn NN 19613 9439 26 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9439 27 I. i. NN 19613 9440 1 5 5 CD 19613 9440 2 . . . 19613 9440 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9441 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9441 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9441 3 758 758 CD 19613 9441 4 : : : 19613 9441 5 So so RB 19613 9441 6 also also RB 19613 9441 7 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9441 8 , , , 19613 9441 9 see see VB 19613 9441 10 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9441 11 , , , 19613 9441 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9441 13 . . NNP 19613 9441 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9442 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9442 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9442 3 759 759 CD 19613 9442 4 : : : 19613 9442 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9442 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9442 7 : : : 19613 9442 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9442 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9442 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9442 11 I. i. NN 19613 9443 1 5 5 CD 19613 9443 2 . . . 19613 9444 1 2 2 LS 19613 9444 2 . . . 19613 9444 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9445 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9445 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9445 3 760 760 CD 19613 9445 4 : : : 19613 9445 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9445 6 was be VBD 19613 9445 7 of of RB 19613 9445 8 course course NN 19613 9445 9 created create VBN 19613 9445 10 before before IN 19613 9445 11 the the DT 19613 9445 12 world world NN 19613 9445 13 , , , 19613 9445 14 as as IN 19613 9445 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9445 16 determines determine VBZ 19613 9445 17 the the DT 19613 9445 18 course course NN 19613 9445 19 of of IN 19613 9445 20 the the DT 19613 9445 21 world world NN 19613 9445 22 . . . 19613 9446 1 See see VB 19613 9446 2 Comm Comm NNP 19613 9446 3 . . . 19613 9447 1 in in IN 19613 9447 2 Matth Matth NNP 19613 9447 3 . . . 19613 9448 1 XV XV NNP 19613 9448 2 . . . 19613 9449 1 27 27 CD 19613 9449 2 , , , 19613 9449 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9449 4 . . . 19613 9450 1 III III NNP 19613 9450 2 . . NNP 19613 9450 3 , , , 19613 9450 4 p. p. NN 19613 9450 5 384 384 CD 19613 9450 6 sq sq NNP 19613 9450 7 . . NNP 19613 9450 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9451 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9451 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9451 3 761 761 CD 19613 9451 4 : : : 19613 9451 5 See see VB 19613 9451 6 Comm Comm NNP 19613 9451 7 . . . 19613 9452 1 in in IN 19613 9452 2 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9452 3 . . . 19613 9453 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9453 2 . . . 19613 9454 1 25 25 CD 19613 9454 2 , , , 19613 9454 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9454 4 . . . 19613 9455 1 II II NNP 19613 9455 2 , , , 19613 9455 3 p. p. NN 19613 9455 4 45 45 CD 19613 9455 5 : : : 19613 9455 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9455 7 must must MD 19613 9455 8 not not RB 19613 9455 9 look look VB 19613 9455 10 on on IN 19613 9455 11 the the DT 19613 9455 12 human human JJ 19613 9455 13 spirit spirit NN 19613 9455 14 as as IN 19613 9455 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9455 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9455 17 : : : 19613 9455 18 homoousios homoousio NNS 19613 9455 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9455 20 with with IN 19613 9455 21 the the DT 19613 9455 22 divine divine JJ 19613 9455 23 one one CD 19613 9455 24 . . . 19613 9456 1 The the DT 19613 9456 2 same same JJ 19613 9456 3 had have VBD 19613 9456 4 already already RB 19613 9456 5 been be VBN 19613 9456 6 expressly expressly RB 19613 9456 7 taught teach VBN 19613 9456 8 by by IN 19613 9456 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9456 10 . . . 19613 9457 1 See see VB 19613 9457 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9457 3 . . NNP 19613 9457 4 , , , 19613 9457 5 II II NNP 19613 9457 6 . . . 19613 9458 1 16 16 CD 19613 9458 2 . . . 19613 9459 1 74 74 CD 19613 9459 2 : : : 19613 9459 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9459 4 Greek greek NN 19613 9459 5 : : : 19613 9459 6 ho ho NNP 19613 9459 7 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9459 8 oudemian oudemian NNP 19613 9459 9 echei echei NNP 19613 9459 10 pros pros NNP 19613 9459 11 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 9459 12 physikên physikên NNP 19613 9459 13 schesin schesin NNP 19613 9459 14 hôs hôs NNP 19613 9459 15 hoi hoi NNP 19613 9459 16 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9459 17 haireseôn haireseôn NNP 19613 9459 18 ktistai ktistai NNP 19613 9459 19 thelousin thelousin NNP 19613 9459 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9459 21 . . . 19613 9460 1 Adumbr Adumbr NNP 19613 9460 2 . . . 19613 9460 3 , , , 19613 9460 4 p. p. NN 19613 9460 5 91 91 CD 19613 9460 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9460 7 ed ed NN 19613 9460 8 . . . 19613 9461 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9461 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9461 3 . . . 19613 9462 1 This this DT 19613 9462 2 does do VBZ 19613 9462 3 not not RB 19613 9462 4 exclude exclude VB 19613 9462 5 God God NNP 19613 9462 6 and and CC 19613 9462 7 souls soul NNS 19613 9462 8 having have VBG 19613 9462 9 _ _ NNP 19613 9462 10 quodammodo quodammodo NNP 19613 9462 11 _ _ NNP 19613 9462 12 one one CD 19613 9462 13 substance substance NN 19613 9462 14 . . . 19613 9462 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9463 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9463 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9463 3 762 762 CD 19613 9463 4 : : : 19613 9463 5 Such such JJ 19613 9463 6 is be VBZ 19613 9463 7 the the DT 19613 9463 8 teaching teaching NN 19613 9463 9 of of IN 19613 9463 10 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9463 11 and and CC 19613 9463 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9463 13 . . . 19613 9464 1 They -PRON- PRP 19613 9464 2 repudiated repudiate VBD 19613 9464 3 the the DT 19613 9464 4 possession possession NN 19613 9464 5 of of IN 19613 9464 6 any any DT 19613 9464 7 natural natural JJ 19613 9464 8 , , , 19613 9464 9 essential essential JJ 19613 9464 10 goodness goodness NN 19613 9464 11 in in IN 19613 9464 12 the the DT 19613 9464 13 case case NN 19613 9464 14 of of IN 19613 9464 15 created create VBN 19613 9464 16 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9464 17 . . . 19613 9465 1 If if IN 19613 9465 2 such such JJ 19613 9465 3 lay lay NN 19613 9465 4 in in IN 19613 9465 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9465 6 essence essence NN 19613 9465 7 , , , 19613 9465 8 these these DT 19613 9465 9 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9465 10 would would MD 19613 9465 11 be be VB 19613 9465 12 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 9465 13 . . . 19613 9465 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9466 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9466 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9466 3 763 763 CD 19613 9466 4 : : : 19613 9466 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9466 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9466 7 : : : 19613 9466 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9466 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9466 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9466 11 I. i. NN 19613 9467 1 2 2 LS 19613 9467 2 . . . 19613 9468 1 10 10 CD 19613 9468 2 : : : 19613 9468 3 " " `` 19613 9468 4 Quemadmodum Quemadmodum NNP 19613 9468 5 pater pater NN 19613 9468 6 non non PRP$ 19613 9468 7 potest potest NNP 19613 9468 8 esse esse NNP 19613 9468 9 quis quis NNP 19613 9468 10 , , , 19613 9468 11 si si NNP 19613 9468 12 filius filius NNP 19613 9468 13 non non AFX 19613 9468 14 sit sit VB 19613 9468 15 , , , 19613 9468 16 neque neque NNP 19613 9468 17 dominus dominus NNP 19613 9468 18 quis quis NNP 19613 9468 19 esse esse NNP 19613 9468 20 potest potest NNP 19613 9468 21 sine sine NNP 19613 9468 22 possessione possessione NNP 19613 9468 23 , , , 19613 9468 24 sine sine NNP 19613 9468 25 servo servo NNP 19613 9468 26 , , , 19613 9468 27 ita ita NNP 19613 9468 28 ne ne NNP 19613 9468 29 omnipotens omnipotens NNP 19613 9468 30 quidem quidem VBP 19613 9468 31 deus deus NNP 19613 9468 32 dici dici VBZ 19613 9468 33 potest potest RB 19613 9468 34 , , , 19613 9468 35 si si VBP 19613 9468 36 non non JJ 19613 9468 37 sint sint NN 19613 9468 38 , , , 19613 9468 39 in in IN 19613 9468 40 quos quos NNP 19613 9468 41 exerceat exerceat NN 19613 9468 42 potentatum potentatum NN 19613 9468 43 , , , 19613 9468 44 et et NNP 19613 9468 45 deo deo NNP 19613 9468 46 ut ut UH 19613 9468 47 omnipotens omnipotens NNP 19613 9468 48 ostendatur ostendatur JJ 19613 9468 49 deus deu NNS 19613 9468 50 , , , 19613 9468 51 omnia omnia NNP 19613 9468 52 subsistere subsistere NNP 19613 9468 53 necesse necesse NNP 19613 9468 54 est est NNP 19613 9468 55 . . . 19613 9468 56 " " '' 19613 9469 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9469 2 So so RB 19613 9469 3 the the DT 19613 9469 4 Hermogenes Hermogenes NNP 19613 9469 5 against against IN 19613 9469 6 whom whom WP 19613 9469 7 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 9469 8 wrote write VBD 19613 9469 9 had have VBD 19613 9469 10 already already RB 19613 9469 11 argued argue VBN 19613 9469 12 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9469 13 . . . 19613 9470 1 " " `` 19613 9470 2 Nam Nam NNP 19613 9470 3 si si NNP 19613 9470 4 quis quis NNP 19613 9470 5 est est NNP 19613 9470 6 , , , 19613 9470 7 qui qui NNP 19613 9470 8 velit velit NNP 19613 9470 9 vel vel NNP 19613 9470 10 sæcula sæcula NNP 19613 9470 11 aliqua aliqua NNP 19613 9470 12 vel vel NNP 19613 9470 13 spatia spatia NNP 19613 9470 14 transisse transisse NNP 19613 9470 15 , , , 19613 9470 16 vel vel NNP 19613 9470 17 quodcunque quodcunque NNP 19613 9470 18 aliud aliud NNP 19613 9470 19 nominare nominare NNP 19613 9470 20 vult vult NNP 19613 9470 21 , , , 19613 9470 22 cum cum NNP 19613 9470 23 nondum nondum NNP 19613 9470 24 facta facta NNP 19613 9470 25 essent essent NNP 19613 9470 26 , , , 19613 9470 27 quæ quæ NNP 19613 9470 28 facta facta NNP 19613 9470 29 sunt sunt NNP 19613 9470 30 , , , 19613 9470 31 sine sine NNP 19613 9470 32 dubio dubio NNP 19613 9470 33 hoc hoc NNP 19613 9470 34 ostendet ostendet NNP 19613 9470 35 , , , 19613 9470 36 quod quod NN 19613 9470 37 in in IN 19613 9470 38 illis illis NNP 19613 9470 39 sæculis sæculis NNP 19613 9470 40 vel vel NNP 19613 9470 41 spatiis spatiis NNP 19613 9470 42 omnipotens omnipoten NNS 19613 9470 43 non non AFX 19613 9470 44 erat erat NN 19613 9470 45 deus deus NNP 19613 9470 46 et et NNP 19613 9470 47 postmodum postmodum NN 19613 9470 48 omnipotens omnipotens NNP 19613 9470 49 factus factus NN 19613 9470 50 est est NNP 19613 9470 51 . . . 19613 9470 52 " " '' 19613 9471 1 God God NNP 19613 9471 2 would would MD 19613 9471 3 therefore therefore RB 19613 9471 4 , , , 19613 9471 5 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9471 6 is be VBZ 19613 9471 7 said say VBN 19613 9471 8 in in IN 19613 9471 9 what what WP 19613 9471 10 follows follow VBZ 19613 9471 11 , , , 19613 9471 12 be be VB 19613 9471 13 subjected subject VBN 19613 9471 14 to to IN 19613 9471 15 a a DT 19613 9471 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9471 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9471 18 : : : 19613 9471 19 prokopê prokopê NN 19613 9471 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9471 21 , , , 19613 9471 22 and and CC 19613 9471 23 thus thus RB 19613 9471 24 be be VB 19613 9471 25 proved prove VBN 19613 9471 26 to to TO 19613 9471 27 be be VB 19613 9471 28 a a DT 19613 9471 29 finite finite JJ 19613 9471 30 being being NN 19613 9471 31 . . . 19613 9472 1 III iii CD 19613 9472 2 . . . 19613 9473 1 5 5 CD 19613 9473 2 . . . 19613 9474 1 3 3 LS 19613 9474 2 . . . 19613 9474 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9475 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9475 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9475 3 764 764 CD 19613 9475 4 : : : 19613 9475 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9475 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9475 7 : : : 19613 9475 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9475 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9475 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9475 11 I. i. NN 19613 9476 1 8 8 LS 19613 9476 2 . . . 19613 9476 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9477 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9477 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9477 3 765 765 CD 19613 9477 4 : : : 19613 9477 5 Here here RB 19613 9477 6 , , , 19613 9477 7 however however RB 19613 9477 8 , , , 19613 9477 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9477 10 is be VBZ 19613 9477 11 already already RB 19613 9477 12 thinking think VBG 19613 9477 13 of of IN 19613 9477 14 the the DT 19613 9477 15 temporary temporary JJ 19613 9477 16 wrong wrong JJ 19613 9477 17 development development NN 19613 9477 18 that that WDT 19613 9477 19 is be VBZ 19613 9477 20 of of IN 19613 9477 21 growth growth NN 19613 9477 22 . . . 19613 9478 1 See see VB 19613 9478 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9478 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9478 4 : : : 19613 9478 5 peri peri NN 19613 9478 6 archôn archôn NN 19613 9478 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9478 8 I. I. NNP 19613 9479 1 7 7 LS 19613 9479 2 . . . 19613 9480 1 Created create VBN 19613 9480 2 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9480 3 are be VBP 19613 9480 4 also also RB 19613 9480 5 of of IN 19613 9480 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 19613 9480 7 immaterial immaterial JJ 19613 9480 8 , , , 19613 9480 9 though though IN 19613 9480 10 indeed indeed RB 19613 9480 11 not not RB 19613 9480 12 in in IN 19613 9480 13 the the DT 19613 9480 14 sense sense NN 19613 9480 15 that that IN 19613 9480 16 this this DT 19613 9480 17 can can MD 19613 9480 18 be be VB 19613 9480 19 said say VBN 19613 9480 20 of of IN 19613 9480 21 God God NNP 19613 9480 22 who who WP 19613 9480 23 can can MD 19613 9480 24 never never RB 19613 9480 25 attach attach VB 19613 9480 26 anything anything NN 19613 9480 27 material material JJ 19613 9480 28 to to IN 19613 9480 29 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9480 30 . . . 19613 9480 31 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9481 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9481 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9481 3 766 766 CD 19613 9481 4 : : : 19613 9481 5 Angels angel NNS 19613 9481 6 , , , 19613 9481 7 ideas idea NNS 19613 9481 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9481 9 see see VB 19613 9481 10 Phot Phot NNP 19613 9481 11 . . . 19613 9482 1 Biblioth biblioth NN 19613 9482 2 . . . 19613 9483 1 109 109 CD 19613 9483 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9483 3 , , , 19613 9483 4 and and CC 19613 9483 5 human human JJ 19613 9483 6 souls soul NNS 19613 9483 7 are be VBP 19613 9483 8 most most RBS 19613 9483 9 closely closely RB 19613 9483 10 connected connect VBN 19613 9483 11 together together RB 19613 9483 12 , , , 19613 9483 13 both both CC 19613 9483 14 according accord VBG 19613 9483 15 to to IN 19613 9483 16 the the DT 19613 9483 17 theory theory NN 19613 9483 18 of of IN 19613 9483 19 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9483 20 and and CC 19613 9483 21 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9483 22 and and CC 19613 9483 23 also also RB 19613 9483 24 to to IN 19613 9483 25 that that DT 19613 9483 26 of of IN 19613 9483 27 Pantænus Pantænus NNP 19613 9483 28 before before IN 19613 9483 29 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9483 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9483 31 see see VB 19613 9483 32 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9483 33 . . . 19613 9484 1 eclog eclog NN 19613 9484 2 . . . 19613 9485 1 56 56 CD 19613 9485 2 , , , 19613 9485 3 57 57 CD 19613 9485 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9485 5 ; ; : 19613 9485 6 and and CC 19613 9485 7 so so RB 19613 9485 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9485 9 was be VBD 19613 9485 10 taught teach VBN 19613 9485 11 that that IN 19613 9485 12 men man NNS 19613 9485 13 become become VBP 19613 9485 14 angels angel NNS 19613 9485 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9485 16 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9485 17 . . . 19613 9486 1 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9486 2 . . . 19613 9487 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9487 2 . . . 19613 9488 1 13 13 CD 19613 9488 2 . . . 19613 9489 1 107 107 LS 19613 9489 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9489 3 . . . 19613 9490 1 But but CC 19613 9490 2 the the DT 19613 9490 3 stars star NNS 19613 9490 4 also also RB 19613 9490 5 , , , 19613 9490 6 which which WDT 19613 9490 7 are be VBP 19613 9490 8 treated treat VBN 19613 9490 9 in in IN 19613 9490 10 great great JJ 19613 9490 11 detail detail NN 19613 9490 12 in in IN 19613 9490 13 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9490 14 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9490 15 : : : 19613 9490 16 peri peri NN 19613 9490 17 archôn archôn NN 19613 9490 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9490 19 I. I. NNP 19613 9491 1 7 7 LS 19613 9491 2 , , , 19613 9491 3 belong belong VB 19613 9491 4 to to IN 19613 9491 5 the the DT 19613 9491 6 number number NN 19613 9491 7 of of IN 19613 9491 8 the the DT 19613 9491 9 angels angel NNS 19613 9491 10 . . . 19613 9492 1 This this DT 19613 9492 2 is be VBZ 19613 9492 3 a a DT 19613 9492 4 genuinely genuinely RB 19613 9492 5 Greek greek JJ 19613 9492 6 idea idea NN 19613 9492 7 . . . 19613 9493 1 The the DT 19613 9493 2 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9493 3 of of IN 19613 9493 4 the the DT 19613 9493 5 preëxistence preëxistence NN 19613 9493 6 of of IN 19613 9493 7 human human JJ 19613 9493 8 souls soul NNS 19613 9493 9 was be VBD 19613 9493 10 probably probably RB 19613 9493 11 set set VBN 19613 9493 12 forth forth RP 19613 9493 13 by by IN 19613 9493 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9493 15 in in IN 19613 9493 16 the the DT 19613 9493 17 Hypotyposes hypotypose NNS 19613 9493 18 . . . 19613 9494 1 The the DT 19613 9494 2 theory theory NN 19613 9494 3 of of IN 19613 9494 4 the the DT 19613 9494 5 transmigration transmigration NN 19613 9494 6 of of IN 19613 9494 7 souls soul NNS 19613 9494 8 was be VBD 19613 9494 9 probably probably RB 19613 9494 10 found find VBN 19613 9494 11 there there EX 19613 9494 12 also also RB 19613 9494 13 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9494 14 Phot phot NN 19613 9494 15 . . . 19613 9495 1 Biblioth biblioth NN 19613 9495 2 . . . 19613 9496 1 109 109 CD 19613 9496 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9496 3 . . . 19613 9497 1 In in IN 19613 9497 2 the the DT 19613 9497 3 Adumbrat Adumbrat NNP 19613 9497 4 . . . 19613 9497 5 , , , 19613 9497 6 which which WDT 19613 9497 7 has have VBZ 19613 9497 8 been be VBN 19613 9497 9 preserved preserve VBN 19613 9497 10 to to IN 19613 9497 11 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9497 12 , , , 19613 9497 13 the the DT 19613 9497 14 former former JJ 19613 9497 15 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9497 16 is be VBZ 19613 9497 17 , , , 19613 9497 18 however however RB 19613 9497 19 , , , 19613 9497 20 contested contest VBN 19613 9497 21 and and CC 19613 9497 22 is be VBZ 19613 9497 23 not not RB 19613 9497 24 found find VBN 19613 9497 25 in in IN 19613 9497 26 the the DT 19613 9497 27 Stromateis Stromateis NNP 19613 9497 28 VI VI NNP 19613 9497 29 . . . 19613 9498 1 16 16 CD 19613 9498 2 . . . 19613 9499 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9500 1 sq sq NNP 19613 9500 2 . . . 19613 9500 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9501 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9501 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9501 3 767 767 CD 19613 9501 4 : : : 19613 9501 5 Phot phot NN 19613 9501 6 . . . 19613 9502 1 Biblioth biblioth NN 19613 9502 2 . . . 19613 9503 1 109 109 CD 19613 9503 2 : : : 19613 9503 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9503 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9503 5 : : : 19613 9503 6 Klêmês Klêmês NNP 19613 9503 7 pollous pollous JJ 19613 9503 8 pro pro NN 19613 9503 9 tou tou NNP 19613 9503 10 Adam Adam NNP 19613 9503 11 kosmous kosmous JJ 19613 9503 12 terateuetai terateuetai NN 19613 9503 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9503 14 . . . 19613 9504 1 This this DT 19613 9504 2 can can MD 19613 9504 3 not not RB 19613 9504 4 be be VB 19613 9504 5 verified verify VBN 19613 9504 6 from from IN 19613 9504 7 the the DT 19613 9504 8 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9504 9 . . . 19613 9505 1 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9505 2 . . . 19613 9505 3 , , , 19613 9505 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9505 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9505 6 : : : 19613 9505 7 peri peri NN 19613 9505 8 archôn archôn NN 19613 9505 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9505 10 II II NNP 19613 9505 11 . . . 19613 9506 1 3 3 LS 19613 9506 2 . . . 19613 9506 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9507 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9507 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9507 3 768 768 CD 19613 9507 4 : : : 19613 9507 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9507 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9507 7 : : : 19613 9507 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9507 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9507 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9507 11 I. i. NN 19613 9508 1 5 5 CD 19613 9508 2 and and CC 19613 9508 3 the the DT 19613 9508 4 whole whole JJ 19613 9508 5 3rd 3rd NNP 19613 9508 6 Book Book NNP 19613 9508 7 . . . 19613 9509 1 The the DT 19613 9509 2 Fall Fall NNP 19613 9509 3 is be VBZ 19613 9509 4 something something NN 19613 9509 5 that that WDT 19613 9509 6 happened happen VBD 19613 9509 7 before before IN 19613 9509 8 time time NN 19613 9509 9 began begin VBD 19613 9509 10 . . . 19613 9509 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9510 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9510 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9510 3 769 769 CD 19613 9510 4 : : : 19613 9510 5 The the DT 19613 9510 6 assumption assumption NN 19613 9510 7 of of IN 19613 9510 8 uncreated uncreated JJ 19613 9510 9 matter matter NN 19613 9510 10 was be VBD 19613 9510 11 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 9510 12 rejected reject VBN 19613 9510 13 by by IN 19613 9510 14 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9510 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9510 16 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9510 17 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9510 18 : : : 19613 9510 19 peri peri NN 19613 9510 20 archôn archôn NN 19613 9510 21 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9510 22 II II NNP 19613 9510 23 . . . 19613 9511 1 1 1 CD 19613 9511 2 , , , 19613 9511 3 2 2 CD 19613 9511 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9511 5 . . . 19613 9512 1 On on IN 19613 9512 2 the the DT 19613 9512 3 other other JJ 19613 9512 4 hand hand NN 19613 9512 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9512 6 is be VBZ 19613 9512 7 said say VBN 19613 9512 8 to to TO 19613 9512 9 have have VB 19613 9512 10 taught teach VBN 19613 9512 11 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9512 12 in in IN 19613 9512 13 the the DT 19613 9512 14 Hypotyposes Hypotyposes NNPS 19613 9512 15 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9512 16 Phot Phot NNP 19613 9512 17 . . . 19613 9512 18 , , , 19613 9512 19 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9512 20 . . . 19613 9513 1 : : : 19613 9513 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9513 3 Greek greek JJ 19613 9513 4 : : : 19613 9513 5 hulên hulên NN 19613 9513 6 archronon archronon NNP 19613 9513 7 doxazei doxazei NNP 19613 9513 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9513 9 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9513 10 ; ; : 19613 9513 11 this this DT 19613 9513 12 can can MD 19613 9513 13 not not RB 19613 9513 14 be be VB 19613 9513 15 noticed notice VBN 19613 9513 16 in in IN 19613 9513 17 the the DT 19613 9513 18 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9513 19 . . . 19613 9514 1 ; ; : 19613 9514 2 in in IN 19613 9514 3 fact fact NN 19613 9514 4 in in IN 19613 9514 5 VI VI NNP 19613 9514 6 . . . 19613 9515 1 16 16 CD 19613 9515 2 . . . 19613 9516 1 147 147 CD 19613 9516 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9516 3 vigorously vigorously RB 19613 9516 4 contested contest VBD 19613 9516 5 the the DT 19613 9516 6 view view NN 19613 9516 7 of of IN 19613 9516 8 the the DT 19613 9516 9 uncreatedness uncreatedness NN 19613 9516 10 of of IN 19613 9516 11 the the DT 19613 9516 12 world world NN 19613 9516 13 . . . 19613 9517 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9517 2 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 9517 3 the the DT 19613 9517 4 agreement agreement NN 19613 9517 5 between between IN 19613 9517 6 Plato Plato NNP 19613 9517 7 and and CC 19613 9517 8 Moses Moses NNP 19613 9517 9 in in IN 19613 9517 10 the the DT 19613 9517 11 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9517 12 of of IN 19613 9517 13 creation creation NN 19613 9517 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9517 15 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9517 16 . . . 19613 9518 1 II ii CD 19613 9518 2 . . . 19613 9519 1 16 16 CD 19613 9519 2 . . . 19613 9520 1 74 74 CD 19613 9520 2 has have VBZ 19613 9520 3 nothing nothing NN 19613 9520 4 to to TO 19613 9520 5 do do VB 19613 9520 6 with with IN 19613 9520 7 this this DT 19613 9520 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9520 9 . . . 19613 9521 1 According accord VBG 19613 9521 2 to to IN 19613 9521 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9521 4 , , , 19613 9521 5 matter matter NN 19613 9521 6 has have VBZ 19613 9521 7 no no DT 19613 9521 8 qualities quality NNS 19613 9521 9 and and CC 19613 9521 10 may may MD 19613 9521 11 assume assume VB 19613 9521 12 the the DT 19613 9521 13 most most RBS 19613 9521 14 diverse diverse JJ 19613 9521 15 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 19613 9521 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9521 17 see see VB 19613 9521 18 , , , 19613 9521 19 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 9521 20 , , , 19613 9521 21 c. c. NNP 19613 9521 22 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9521 23 . . . 19613 9522 1 III iii CD 19613 9522 2 . . . 19613 9523 1 41 41 CD 19613 9523 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9523 3 . . . 19613 9523 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9524 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9524 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9524 3 770 770 CD 19613 9524 4 : : : 19613 9524 5 This this DT 19613 9524 6 conception conception NN 19613 9524 7 has have VBZ 19613 9524 8 given give VBN 19613 9524 9 occasion occasion NN 19613 9524 10 to to TO 19613 9524 11 compare compare VB 19613 9524 12 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9524 13 's 's POS 19613 9524 14 system system NN 19613 9524 15 with with IN 19613 9524 16 Buddhism Buddhism NNP 19613 9524 17 . . . 19613 9525 1 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9525 2 . . . 19613 9526 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9526 2 p. p. NN 19613 9526 3 193 193 CD 19613 9526 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9526 5 has have VBZ 19613 9526 6 very very RB 19613 9526 7 beautifully beautifully RB 19613 9526 8 said say VBN 19613 9526 9 : : : 19613 9526 10 " " `` 19613 9526 11 Creation creation NN 19613 9526 12 , , , 19613 9526 13 as as IN 19613 9526 14 the the DT 19613 9526 15 word word NN 19613 9526 16 is be VBZ 19613 9526 17 commonly commonly RB 19613 9526 18 understood understand VBN 19613 9526 19 , , , 19613 9526 20 was be VBD 19613 9526 21 in in IN 19613 9526 22 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9526 23 's 's POS 19613 9526 24 views view NNS 19613 9526 25 not not RB 19613 9526 26 the the DT 19613 9526 27 beginning beginning NN 19613 9526 28 , , , 19613 9526 29 but but CC 19613 9526 30 an an DT 19613 9526 31 intermediate intermediate JJ 19613 9526 32 phase phase NN 19613 9526 33 in in IN 19613 9526 34 human human JJ 19613 9526 35 history history NN 19613 9526 36 . . . 19613 9527 1 Æons æon NNS 19613 9527 2 rolled roll VBN 19613 9527 3 away away RP 19613 9527 4 before before IN 19613 9527 5 this this DT 19613 9527 6 world world NN 19613 9527 7 was be VBD 19613 9527 8 made make VBN 19613 9527 9 ; ; : 19613 9527 10 æons æon NNS 19613 9527 11 upon upon IN 19613 9527 12 æons æon NNS 19613 9527 13 , , , 19613 9527 14 days day NNS 19613 9527 15 , , , 19613 9527 16 weeks week NNS 19613 9527 17 , , , 19613 9527 18 months month NNS 19613 9527 19 and and CC 19613 9527 20 years year NNS 19613 9527 21 , , , 19613 9527 22 sabbatical sabbatical JJ 19613 9527 23 years year NNS 19613 9527 24 , , , 19613 9527 25 jubilee jubilee NNP 19613 9527 26 years year NNS 19613 9527 27 of of IN 19613 9527 28 æons æon NNS 19613 9527 29 will will MD 19613 9527 30 run run VB 19613 9527 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9527 32 course course NN 19613 9527 33 , , , 19613 9527 34 before before IN 19613 9527 35 the the DT 19613 9527 36 end end NN 19613 9527 37 is be VBZ 19613 9527 38 attained attain VBN 19613 9527 39 . . . 19613 9528 1 The the DT 19613 9528 2 one one CD 19613 9528 3 fixed fix VBN 19613 9528 4 point point NN 19613 9528 5 in in IN 19613 9528 6 this this DT 19613 9528 7 gigantic gigantic JJ 19613 9528 8 drama drama NN 19613 9528 9 is be VBZ 19613 9528 10 the the DT 19613 9528 11 end end NN 19613 9528 12 , , , 19613 9528 13 for for IN 19613 9528 14 this this DT 19613 9528 15 alone alone RB 19613 9528 16 has have VBZ 19613 9528 17 been be VBN 19613 9528 18 clearly clearly RB 19613 9528 19 revealed reveal VBN 19613 9528 20 , , , 19613 9528 21 " " '' 19613 9528 22 " " `` 19613 9528 23 God God NNP 19613 9528 24 shall shall MD 19613 9528 25 be be VB 19613 9528 26 all all DT 19613 9528 27 in in RB 19613 9528 28 all all DT 19613 9528 29 . . . 19613 9528 30 " " '' 19613 9529 1 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9529 2 also also RB 19613 9529 3 rightly rightly RB 19613 9529 4 points point VBZ 19613 9529 5 out out RP 19613 9529 6 that that IN 19613 9529 7 Rom rom NN 19613 9529 8 . . . 19613 9530 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 9530 2 . . . 19613 9531 1 and and CC 19613 9531 2 1 1 CD 19613 9531 3 Cor Cor NNP 19613 9531 4 . . . 19613 9532 1 XV XV NNP 19613 9532 2 . . . 19613 9533 1 were be VBD 19613 9533 2 for for IN 19613 9533 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9533 4 the the DT 19613 9533 5 key key NN 19613 9533 6 to to IN 19613 9533 7 the the DT 19613 9533 8 solution solution NN 19613 9533 9 of of IN 19613 9533 10 the the DT 19613 9533 11 problems problem NNS 19613 9533 12 presented present VBN 19613 9533 13 by by IN 19613 9533 14 creation creation NN 19613 9533 15 . . . 19613 9533 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9534 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9534 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9534 3 771 771 CD 19613 9534 4 : : : 19613 9534 5 The the DT 19613 9534 6 popular popular JJ 19613 9534 7 idea idea NN 19613 9534 8 of of IN 19613 9534 9 demons demon NNS 19613 9534 10 and and CC 19613 9534 11 angels angel NNS 19613 9534 12 was be VBD 19613 9534 13 employed employ VBN 19613 9534 14 by by IN 19613 9534 15 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9534 16 in in IN 19613 9534 17 the the DT 19613 9534 18 most most RBS 19613 9534 19 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 19613 9534 20 way way NN 19613 9534 21 , , , 19613 9534 22 and and CC 19613 9534 23 dominates dominate VBZ 19613 9534 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9534 25 whole whole JJ 19613 9534 26 view view NN 19613 9534 27 of of IN 19613 9534 28 the the DT 19613 9534 29 present present JJ 19613 9534 30 course course NN 19613 9534 31 of of IN 19613 9534 32 the the DT 19613 9534 33 world world NN 19613 9534 34 . . . 19613 9535 1 See see VB 19613 9535 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9535 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9535 4 : : : 19613 9535 5 peri peri NN 19613 9535 6 archôn archôn NN 19613 9535 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9535 8 III III NNP 19613 9535 9 . . . 19613 9536 1 2 2 LS 19613 9536 2 . . . 19613 9536 3 and and CC 19613 9536 4 numerous numerous JJ 19613 9536 5 passages passage NNS 19613 9536 6 in in IN 19613 9536 7 the the DT 19613 9536 8 Commentaries Commentaries NNPS 19613 9536 9 and and CC 19613 9536 10 Homilies Homilies NNPS 19613 9536 11 , , , 19613 9536 12 in in IN 19613 9536 13 which which WDT 19613 9536 14 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9536 15 approves approve VBZ 19613 9536 16 the the DT 19613 9536 17 kindred kindred JJ 19613 9536 18 views view NNS 19613 9536 19 of of IN 19613 9536 20 the the DT 19613 9536 21 Greeks Greeks NNPS 19613 9536 22 as as RB 19613 9536 23 well well RB 19613 9536 24 as as IN 19613 9536 25 of of IN 19613 9536 26 Hermas Hermas NNP 19613 9536 27 and and CC 19613 9536 28 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 19613 9536 29 . . . 19613 9537 1 The the DT 19613 9537 2 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9537 3 ascend ascend VBP 19613 9537 4 and and CC 19613 9537 5 descend descend VBP 19613 9537 6 ; ; : 19613 9537 7 each each DT 19613 9537 8 man man NN 19613 9537 9 has have VBZ 19613 9537 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9537 11 guardian guardian NN 19613 9537 12 spirit spirit NN 19613 9537 13 , , , 19613 9537 14 and and CC 19613 9537 15 the the DT 19613 9537 16 superior superior JJ 19613 9537 17 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9537 18 support support VBP 19613 9537 19 the the DT 19613 9537 20 inferior inferior JJ 19613 9537 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9537 22 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9537 23 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9537 24 : : : 19613 9537 25 peri peri NN 19613 9537 26 archôn archôn NN 19613 9537 27 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9537 28 I. I. NNP 19613 9538 1 6 6 LS 19613 9538 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9538 3 . . . 19613 9539 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 9539 2 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9539 3 are be VBP 19613 9539 4 also also RB 19613 9539 5 to to TO 19613 9539 6 be be VB 19613 9539 7 reverenced reverence VBN 19613 9539 8 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9539 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9539 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9539 11 : : : 19613 9539 12 therapeuesthai therapeuesthai NNP 19613 9539 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9539 14 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9539 15 ; ; : 19613 9539 16 yet yet CC 19613 9539 17 such such JJ 19613 9539 18 reverence reverence NN 19613 9539 19 as as IN 19613 9539 20 belongs belong VBZ 19613 9539 21 to to IN 19613 9539 22 a a DT 19613 9539 23 Gabriel Gabriel NNP 19613 9539 24 , , , 19613 9539 25 a a DT 19613 9539 26 Michael Michael NNP 19613 9539 27 , , , 19613 9539 28 etc etc FW 19613 9539 29 . . NN 19613 9539 30 , , , 19613 9539 31 is be VBZ 19613 9539 32 far far RB 19613 9539 33 different different JJ 19613 9539 34 from from IN 19613 9539 35 the the DT 19613 9539 36 adoration adoration NN 19613 9539 37 of of IN 19613 9539 38 God God NNP 19613 9539 39 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9539 40 c. c. NNP 19613 9539 41 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9539 42 . . . 19613 9540 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 9540 2 . . . 19613 9541 1 13 13 CD 19613 9541 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9541 3 . . . 19613 9541 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9542 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9542 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9542 3 772 772 CD 19613 9542 4 : : : 19613 9542 5 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9542 6 wrote write VBD 19613 9542 7 a a DT 19613 9542 8 special special JJ 19613 9542 9 work work NN 19613 9542 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9542 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9542 12 : : : 19613 9542 13 peri peri NN 19613 9542 14 pronoias pronoias NNP 19613 9542 15 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9542 16 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9542 17 see see VB 19613 9542 18 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9542 19 , , , 19613 9542 20 Forschungen Forschungen NNP 19613 9542 21 III III NNP 19613 9542 22 . . NNP 19613 9542 23 , , , 19613 9542 24 p. p. NN 19613 9542 25 39 39 CD 19613 9542 26 ff ff NN 19613 9542 27 . . . 19613 9543 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9543 2 , , , 19613 9543 3 and and CC 19613 9543 4 treated treat VBN 19613 9543 5 at at IN 19613 9543 6 length length NN 19613 9543 7 of of IN 19613 9543 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9543 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9543 10 : : : 19613 9543 11 pronoia pronoia NN 19613 9543 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9543 13 in in IN 19613 9543 14 the the DT 19613 9543 15 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9543 16 . . . 19613 9544 1 ; ; : 19613 9544 2 see see VB 19613 9544 3 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9544 4 . . . 19613 9545 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9545 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9545 3 : : : 19613 9545 4 peri peri NN 19613 9545 5 archôn archôn NN 19613 9545 6 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9545 7 III III NNP 19613 9545 8 . . . 19613 9546 1 1 1 LS 19613 9546 2 ; ; : 19613 9546 3 de de FW 19613 9546 4 orat orat NNP 19613 9546 5 . . . 19613 9547 1 6 6 CD 19613 9547 2 etc etc NN 19613 9547 3 . . . 19613 9548 1 Evil evil NN 19613 9548 2 is be VBZ 19613 9548 3 also also RB 19613 9548 4 subject subject JJ 19613 9548 5 to to IN 19613 9548 6 divine divine JJ 19613 9548 7 guidance guidance NN 19613 9548 8 ; ; : 19613 9548 9 see see VB 19613 9548 10 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9548 11 . . . 19613 9548 12 , , , 19613 9548 13 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9548 14 . . . 19613 9549 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9550 1 17 17 CD 19613 9550 2 . . . 19613 9551 1 81 81 CD 19613 9551 2 - - SYM 19613 9551 3 87 87 CD 19613 9551 4 : : : 19613 9551 5 IV IV NNP 19613 9551 6 . . . 19613 9552 1 12 12 CD 19613 9552 2 . . . 19613 9553 1 86 86 CD 19613 9553 2 sq sq NN 19613 9553 3 . . . 19613 9554 1 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9554 2 . . . 19613 9555 1 Hom hom UH 19613 9555 2 . . . 19613 9556 1 in in IN 19613 9556 2 Num Num NNP 19613 9556 3 . . . 19613 9557 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 9557 2 . . NNP 19613 9557 3 , , , 19613 9557 4 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9557 5 . . . 19613 9558 1 X. X. NNP 19613 9558 2 , , , 19613 9558 3 p. p. NN 19613 9558 4 163 163 CD 19613 9558 5 : : : 19613 9558 6 " " `` 19613 9558 7 Nihil nihil JJ 19613 9558 8 otiosum otiosum NN 19613 9558 9 , , , 19613 9558 10 nihil nihil NNP 19613 9558 11 inane inane NNP 19613 9558 12 est est NNP 19613 9558 13 apud apud NNP 19613 9558 14 deum deum NNP 19613 9558 15 , , , 19613 9558 16 quia quia NNP 19613 9558 17 sive sive JJ 19613 9558 18 bono bono FW 19613 9558 19 proposito proposito NNP 19613 9558 20 hominis hominis NNP 19613 9558 21 utitur utitur NNP 19613 9558 22 ad ad NN 19613 9558 23 bona bona NN 19613 9558 24 sive sive JJ 19613 9558 25 malo malo NNP 19613 9558 26 ad ad NN 19613 9558 27 necessaria necessaria NN 19613 9558 28 . . . 19613 9558 29 " " '' 19613 9559 1 Here here RB 19613 9559 2 and and CC 19613 9559 3 there there RB 19613 9559 4 , , , 19613 9559 5 however however RB 19613 9559 6 , , , 19613 9559 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9559 8 has have VBZ 19613 9559 9 qualified qualify VBN 19613 9559 10 the the DT 19613 9559 11 belief belief NN 19613 9559 12 in in IN 19613 9559 13 Providence Providence NNP 19613 9559 14 , , , 19613 9559 15 after after IN 19613 9559 16 the the DT 19613 9559 17 genuine genuine JJ 19613 9559 18 fashion fashion NN 19613 9559 19 of of IN 19613 9559 20 antiquity antiquity NN 19613 9559 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9559 22 see see VB 19613 9559 23 c. c. NNP 19613 9559 24 Gels Gels NNP 19613 9559 25 . . . 19613 9560 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9560 2 . . . 19613 9561 1 74 74 CD 19613 9561 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9561 3 . . . 19613 9561 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9562 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9562 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9562 3 773 773 CD 19613 9562 4 : : : 19613 9562 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9562 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9562 7 : : : 19613 9562 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9562 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9562 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9562 11 II II NNP 19613 9562 12 . . . 19613 9563 1 9 9 CD 19613 9563 2 . . . 19613 9564 1 2 2 LS 19613 9564 2 : : : 19613 9564 3 " " `` 19613 9564 4 Recedere Recedere NNP 19613 9564 5 a a DT 19613 9564 6 bono bono FW 19613 9564 7 , , , 19613 9564 8 non non JJ 19613 9564 9 aliud aliud NNS 19613 9564 10 est est NNP 19613 9564 11 quam quam NNP 19613 9564 12 effici effici VBZ 19613 9564 13 in in IN 19613 9564 14 malo malo NNP 19613 9564 15 . . . 19613 9565 1 Ceterum Ceterum NNP 19613 9565 2 namque namque JJ 19613 9565 3 est est NN 19613 9565 4 , , , 19613 9565 5 malum malum NNP 19613 9565 6 esse esse NNP 19613 9565 7 bono bono FW 19613 9565 8 canere canere NNP 19613 9565 9 . . . 19613 9566 1 Ex Ex NNP 19613 9566 2 quo quo NNP 19613 9566 3 accidit accidit NN 19613 9566 4 , , , 19613 9566 5 ut ut NNP 19613 9566 6 in in IN 19613 9566 7 quanta quanta NNP 19613 9566 8 mensura mensura NNP 19613 9566 9 quis quis NNP 19613 9566 10 devolveretur devolveretur NNP 19613 9566 11 a a DT 19613 9566 12 bono bono FW 19613 9566 13 , , , 19613 9566 14 in in IN 19613 9566 15 tantam tantam NNP 19613 9566 16 mensuram mensuram NNP 19613 9566 17 malitiæ malitiæ NNP 19613 9566 18 deveniret deveniret NNP 19613 9566 19 . . . 19613 9566 20 " " '' 19613 9567 1 In in IN 19613 9567 2 the the DT 19613 9567 3 passage passage NN 19613 9567 4 in in IN 19613 9567 5 Johann Johann NNP 19613 9567 6 . . . 19613 9568 1 II ii CD 19613 9568 2 . . . 19613 9569 1 7 7 LS 19613 9569 2 , , , 19613 9569 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9569 4 . . . 19613 9570 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9570 2 , , , 19613 9570 3 p. p. NN 19613 9570 4 115 115 CD 19613 9570 5 , , , 19613 9570 6 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9570 7 find find VBP 19613 9570 8 a a DT 19613 9570 9 closely closely RB 19613 9570 10 reasoned reason VBN 19613 9570 11 exposition exposition NN 19613 9570 12 of of IN 19613 9570 13 evil evil NN 19613 9570 14 as as IN 19613 9570 15 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9570 16 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9570 17 : : : 19613 9570 18 anupostaton anupostaton NNP 19613 9570 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9570 20 and and CC 19613 9570 21 an an DT 19613 9570 22 argument argument NN 19613 9570 23 to to IN 19613 9570 24 the the DT 19613 9570 25 effect effect NN 19613 9570 26 that that WDT 19613 9570 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9570 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9570 29 : : : 19613 9570 30 ta ta NNP 19613 9570 31 ponêra ponêra NNP 19613 9570 32 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9570 33 are--[Greek are--[Greek NNP 19613 9570 34 : : : 19613 9570 35 mê mê NNP 19613 9570 36 onta onta NNP 19613 9570 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9570 38 . . . 19613 9570 39 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9571 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9571 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9571 3 774 774 CD 19613 9571 4 : : : 19613 9571 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9571 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9571 7 : : : 19613 9571 8 Peri peri NN 19613 9571 9 archôn archôn NN 19613 9571 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9571 11 I. i. NN 19613 9572 1 5 5 CD 19613 9572 2 . . . 19613 9573 1 3 3 LS 19613 9573 2 : : : 19613 9573 3 III iii CD 19613 9573 4 . . . 19613 9574 1 6 6 CD 19613 9574 2 . . . 19613 9575 1 The the DT 19613 9575 2 devil devil NN 19613 9575 3 is be VBZ 19613 9575 4 the the DT 19613 9575 5 chief chief NN 19613 9575 6 of of IN 19613 9575 7 the the DT 19613 9575 8 apostate apostate JJ 19613 9575 9 angels angel NNS 19613 9575 10 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9575 11 c. c. NNP 19613 9575 12 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9575 13 . . . 19613 9576 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9576 2 . . . 19613 9577 1 65 65 CD 19613 9577 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9577 3 . . . 19613 9578 1 As as IN 19613 9578 2 a a DT 19613 9578 3 reasonable reasonable JJ 19613 9578 4 being being NN 19613 9578 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9578 6 is be VBZ 19613 9578 7 a a DT 19613 9578 8 creature creature NN 19613 9578 9 of of IN 19613 9578 10 God God NNP 19613 9578 11 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9578 12 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9578 13 . . NNP 19613 9578 14 , , , 19613 9578 15 and and CC 19613 9578 16 in in IN 19613 9578 17 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9578 18 . . . 19613 9579 1 II ii CD 19613 9579 2 . . . 19613 9580 1 7 7 LS 19613 9580 2 , , , 19613 9580 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9580 4 . . NNP 19613 9580 5 , , , 19613 9580 6 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9580 7 . . NNP 19613 9580 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9580 9 . . . 19613 9580 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9581 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9581 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9581 3 775 775 CD 19613 9581 4 : : : 19613 9581 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9581 6 defended defend VBD 19613 9581 7 the the DT 19613 9581 8 teleology teleology NN 19613 9581 9 culminating culminate VBG 19613 9581 10 in in IN 19613 9581 11 man man NN 19613 9581 12 against against IN 19613 9581 13 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9581 14 ' ' POS 19613 9581 15 attacks attack NNS 19613 9581 16 on on IN 19613 9581 17 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9581 18 ; ; : 19613 9581 19 but but CC 19613 9581 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9581 21 assumption assumption NN 19613 9581 22 that that IN 19613 9581 23 the the DT 19613 9581 24 spirits spirit NNS 19613 9581 25 of of IN 19613 9581 26 men man NNS 19613 9581 27 are be VBP 19613 9581 28 only only RB 19613 9581 29 a a DT 19613 9581 30 part part NN 19613 9581 31 of of IN 19613 9581 32 the the DT 19613 9581 33 universal universal JJ 19613 9581 34 spirit spirit NNP 19613 9581 35 world world NNP 19613 9581 36 is be VBZ 19613 9581 37 , , , 19613 9581 38 as as IN 19613 9581 39 a a DT 19613 9581 40 matter matter NN 19613 9581 41 of of IN 19613 9581 42 fact fact NN 19613 9581 43 , , , 19613 9581 44 quite quite RB 19613 9581 45 akin akin JJ 19613 9581 46 to to IN 19613 9581 47 Celsus Celsus NNP 19613 9581 48 ' ' POS 19613 9581 49 view view NN 19613 9581 50 . . . 19613 9582 1 If if IN 19613 9582 2 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9582 3 consider consider VBP 19613 9582 4 the the DT 19613 9582 5 plan plan NN 19613 9582 6 of of IN 19613 9582 7 the the DT 19613 9582 8 work work NN 19613 9582 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9582 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9582 11 : : : 19613 9582 12 peri peri NN 19613 9582 13 archôn archôn NN 19613 9582 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9582 15 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9582 16 easily easily RB 19613 9582 17 see see VBP 19613 9582 18 that that DT 19613 9582 19 to to IN 19613 9582 20 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9582 21 humanity humanity NN 19613 9582 22 was be VBD 19613 9582 23 merely merely RB 19613 9582 24 an an DT 19613 9582 25 element element NN 19613 9582 26 in in IN 19613 9582 27 the the DT 19613 9582 28 cosmos cosmo NNS 19613 9582 29 . . . 19613 9582 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9583 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9583 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9583 3 776 776 CD 19613 9583 4 : : : 19613 9583 5 The the DT 19613 9583 6 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9583 7 of of IN 19613 9583 8 man man NN 19613 9583 9 's 's POS 19613 9583 10 threefold threefold JJ 19613 9583 11 constitution constitution NN 19613 9583 12 is be VBZ 19613 9583 13 also also RB 19613 9583 14 found find VBN 19613 9583 15 in in IN 19613 9583 16 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9583 17 . . . 19613 9584 1 See see VB 19613 9584 2 Pædag Pædag NNP 19613 9584 3 . . . 19613 9585 1 III iii CD 19613 9585 2 . . . 19613 9586 1 1 1 LS 19613 9586 2 . . . 19613 9587 1 1 1 LS 19613 9587 2 ; ; : 19613 9587 3 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9587 4 V. V. NNP 19613 9587 5 14 14 CD 19613 9587 6 . . . 19613 9588 1 94 94 CD 19613 9588 2 : : : 19613 9588 3 VI VI NNP 19613 9588 4 . . . 19613 9589 1 16 16 CD 19613 9589 2 . . . 19613 9590 1 134 134 CD 19613 9590 2 . . . 19613 9591 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9591 2 quite quite RB 19613 9591 3 in in IN 19613 9591 4 the the DT 19613 9591 5 manner manner NN 19613 9591 6 of of IN 19613 9591 7 Plato Plato NNP 19613 9591 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9591 9 . . . 19613 9592 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9592 2 , , , 19613 9592 3 who who WP 19613 9592 4 has have VBZ 19613 9592 5 given give VBN 19613 9592 6 evidence evidence NN 19613 9592 7 of of IN 19613 9592 8 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9592 9 in in IN 19613 9592 10 all all DT 19613 9592 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9592 12 main main JJ 19613 9592 13 writings writing NNS 19613 9592 14 , , , 19613 9592 15 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 9592 16 calls call VBZ 19613 9592 17 the the DT 19613 9592 18 rational rational JJ 19613 9592 19 part part NN 19613 9592 20 spirit spirit NN 19613 9592 21 , , , 19613 9592 22 sometimes sometimes RB 19613 9592 23 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9592 24 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9592 25 : : : 19613 9592 26 psychê psychê NNP 19613 9592 27 logikê logikê NNP 19613 9592 28 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9592 29 , , , 19613 9592 30 and and CC 19613 9592 31 at at IN 19613 9592 32 other other JJ 19613 9592 33 times time NNS 19613 9592 34 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 19613 9592 35 two two CD 19613 9592 36 parts part NNS 19613 9592 37 in in IN 19613 9592 38 the the DT 19613 9592 39 one one CD 19613 9592 40 soul soul NN 19613 9592 41 . . . 19613 9593 1 Of of RB 19613 9593 2 course course RB 19613 9593 3 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9593 4 also also RB 19613 9593 5 professes profess VBZ 19613 9593 6 to to TO 19613 9593 7 derive derive VB 19613 9593 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9593 9 psychology psychology NN 19613 9593 10 from from IN 19613 9593 11 the the DT 19613 9593 12 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9593 13 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 9593 14 . . . 19613 9594 1 The the DT 19613 9594 2 chief chief JJ 19613 9594 3 peculiarity peculiarity NN 19613 9594 4 of of IN 19613 9594 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9594 6 speculation speculation NN 19613 9594 7 consists consist VBZ 19613 9594 8 in in IN 19613 9594 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9594 10 assumption assumption NN 19613 9594 11 that that IN 19613 9594 12 the the DT 19613 9594 13 human human JJ 19613 9594 14 spirit spirit NN 19613 9594 15 , , , 19613 9594 16 as as IN 19613 9594 17 a a DT 19613 9594 18 fallen fall VBN 19613 9594 19 one one NN 19613 9594 20 , , , 19613 9594 21 became become VBD 19613 9594 22 as as IN 19613 9594 23 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9594 24 were be VBD 19613 9594 25 a a DT 19613 9594 26 soul soul NN 19613 9594 27 , , , 19613 9594 28 and and CC 19613 9594 29 can can MD 19613 9594 30 develop develop VB 19613 9594 31 from from IN 19613 9594 32 that that DT 19613 9594 33 condition condition NN 19613 9594 34 partly partly RB 19613 9594 35 into into IN 19613 9594 36 a a DT 19613 9594 37 spirit spirit NN 19613 9594 38 as as IN 19613 9594 39 before before RB 19613 9594 40 and and CC 19613 9594 41 partly partly RB 19613 9594 42 into into IN 19613 9594 43 the the DT 19613 9594 44 flesh flesh NN 19613 9594 45 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9594 46 see see VB 19613 9594 47 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9594 48 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9594 49 : : : 19613 9594 50 peri peri NN 19613 9594 51 archôn archôn NN 19613 9594 52 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9594 53 III III NNP 19613 9594 54 . . . 19613 9595 1 4 4 LS 19613 9595 2 . . . 19613 9596 1 1 1 CD 19613 9596 2 sq sq NNP 19613 9596 3 . . . 19613 9597 1 : : : 19613 9597 2 II ii CD 19613 9597 3 . . . 19613 9598 1 8 8 LS 19613 9598 2 . . . 19613 9599 1 1 1 CD 19613 9599 2 - - SYM 19613 9599 3 5 5 CD 19613 9599 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9599 5 . . . 19613 9600 1 By by IN 19613 9600 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9600 3 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9600 4 of of IN 19613 9600 5 the the DT 19613 9600 6 preëxistence preëxistence NN 19613 9600 7 of of IN 19613 9600 8 souls soul NNS 19613 9600 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9600 10 excluded exclude VBD 19613 9600 11 both both CC 19613 9600 12 the the DT 19613 9600 13 creation creation NN 19613 9600 14 and and CC 19613 9600 15 traducian traducian JJ 19613 9600 16 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 19613 9600 17 of of IN 19613 9600 18 the the DT 19613 9600 19 origin origin NN 19613 9600 20 of of IN 19613 9600 21 the the DT 19613 9600 22 soul soul NN 19613 9600 23 . . . 19613 9600 24 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9601 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9601 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9601 3 777 777 CD 19613 9601 4 : : : 19613 9601 5 Clement clement NN 19613 9601 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9601 7 see see VB 19613 9601 8 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9601 9 . . . 19613 9602 1 II ii CD 19613 9602 2 . . . 19613 9603 1 22 22 CD 19613 9603 2 . . . 19613 9604 1 131 131 LS 19613 9604 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9604 3 gives give VBZ 19613 9604 4 the the DT 19613 9604 5 following following NN 19613 9604 6 as as IN 19613 9604 7 the the DT 19613 9604 8 opinion opinion NN 19613 9604 9 of of IN 19613 9604 10 some some DT 19613 9604 11 Christian christian JJ 19613 9604 12 teachers teacher NNS 19613 9604 13 : : : 19613 9604 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9604 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9604 16 : : : 19613 9604 17 to to IN 19613 9604 18 men man NNS 19613 9604 19 kat kat NNP 19613 9604 20 ' ' '' 19613 9604 21 eikona eikona NNP 19613 9604 22 eutheôs eutheôs NNP 19613 9604 23 kata kata NNP 19613 9604 24 tên tên NNP 19613 9604 25 genesin genesin NNP 19613 9604 26 eilêphenai eilêphenai NNP 19613 9604 27 ton ton NN 19613 9604 28 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 9604 29 , , , 19613 9604 30 to to TO 19613 9604 31 kath kath NNP 19613 9604 32 ' ' POS 19613 9604 33 homoiôsin homoiôsin NNP 19613 9604 34 de de NNP 19613 9604 35 usteron usteron NNP 19613 9604 36 kata kata NNP 19613 9604 37 tên tên NNP 19613 9604 38 peleiôsin peleiôsin NNP 19613 9604 39 mellein mellein NNP 19613 9604 40 apolambanein apolambanein NNP 19613 9604 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9604 42 . . . 19613 9605 1 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9605 2 . . . 19613 9606 1 c. c. NNP 19613 9606 2 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9606 3 . . . 19613 9607 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9607 2 . . . 19613 9608 1 30 30 CD 19613 9608 2 : : : 19613 9608 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9608 4 Greek greek NN 19613 9608 5 : : : 19613 9608 6 epoiête epoiête NN 19613 9608 7 d'o d'o NNP 19613 9608 8 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9608 9 ton ton NN 19613 9608 10 anthrôpon anthrôpon NNP 19613 9608 11 kat kat NNP 19613 9608 12 ' ' `` 19613 9608 13 eikona eikona NNP 19613 9608 14 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9608 15 , , , 19613 9608 16 all all DT 19613 9608 17 ' ' `` 19613 9608 18 ouchi ouchi NNP 19613 9608 19 kath kath NNP 19613 9608 20 ' ' '' 19613 9608 21 homoiôsin homoiôsin NNP 19613 9608 22 êdê êdê NNP 19613 9608 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9608 24 . . . 19613 9608 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9609 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9609 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9609 3 778 778 CD 19613 9609 4 : : : 19613 9609 5 This this DT 19613 9609 6 follows follow VBZ 19613 9609 7 from from IN 19613 9609 8 the the DT 19613 9609 9 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 9609 10 psychological psychological JJ 19613 9609 11 view view NN 19613 9609 12 and and CC 19613 9609 13 is be VBZ 19613 9609 14 frequently frequently RB 19613 9609 15 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 9609 16 . . . 19613 9610 1 One one PRP 19613 9610 2 must must MD 19613 9610 3 attain attain VB 19613 9610 4 the the DT 19613 9610 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9610 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9610 7 : : : 19613 9610 8 sôphorsynê sôphorsynê NNP 19613 9610 9 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9610 10 . . . 19613 9610 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9611 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9611 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9611 3 779 779 CD 19613 9611 4 : : : 19613 9611 5 This this DT 19613 9611 6 is be VBZ 19613 9611 7 emphasised emphasise VBN 19613 9611 8 throughout throughout IN 19613 9611 9 . . . 19613 9612 1 The the DT 19613 9612 2 goodness goodness NN 19613 9612 3 of of IN 19613 9612 4 God God NNP 19613 9612 5 is be VBZ 19613 9612 6 shown show VBN 19613 9612 7 first first RB 19613 9612 8 in in IN 19613 9612 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9612 10 having have VBG 19613 9612 11 given give VBN 19613 9612 12 the the DT 19613 9612 13 creature creature NN 19613 9612 14 reason reason NN 19613 9612 15 and and CC 19613 9612 16 freedom freedom NN 19613 9612 17 , , , 19613 9612 18 and and CC 19613 9612 19 secondly secondly RB 19613 9612 20 in in IN 19613 9612 21 acts act NNS 19613 9612 22 of of IN 19613 9612 23 assistance assistance NN 19613 9612 24 , , , 19613 9612 25 which which WDT 19613 9612 26 , , , 19613 9612 27 however however RB 19613 9612 28 , , , 19613 9612 29 do do VBP 19613 9612 30 not not RB 19613 9612 31 endanger endanger VB 19613 9612 32 freedom freedom NN 19613 9612 33 . . . 19613 9613 1 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9613 2 . . . 19613 9614 1 ; ; : 19613 9614 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9614 3 . . . 19613 9615 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9615 2 . . . 19613 9616 1 12 12 CD 19613 9616 2 , , , 19613 9616 3 96 96 CD 19613 9616 4 : : : 19613 9616 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9616 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9616 7 : : : 19613 9616 8 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 9616 9 ex ex NNP 19613 9616 10 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 9616 11 autôn autôn NNP 19613 9616 12 bouletai bouletai NNP 19613 9616 13 sôzesthai sôzesthai NNP 19613 9616 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9616 15 . . . 19613 9616 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9617 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9617 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9617 3 780 780 CD 19613 9617 4 : : : 19613 9617 5 See see VB 19613 9617 6 above above RB 19613 9617 7 , , , 19613 9617 8 p. p. NN 19613 9617 9 344 344 CD 19613 9617 10 , , , 19613 9617 11 and and CC 19613 9617 12 p. p. NN 19613 9617 13 361 361 CD 19613 9617 14 , , , 19613 9617 15 note note VB 19613 9617 16 5 5 CD 19613 9617 17 . . . 19613 9618 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9618 2 continually continually RB 19613 9618 3 emphasised emphasise VBD 19613 9618 4 the the DT 19613 9618 5 universality universality NN 19613 9618 6 of of IN 19613 9618 7 sin sin NN 19613 9618 8 in in IN 19613 9618 9 the the DT 19613 9618 10 strongest strong JJS 19613 9618 11 expressions expression NNS 19613 9618 12 : : : 19613 9618 13 c. c. NNP 19613 9618 14 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9618 15 . . . 19613 9619 1 III iii CD 19613 9619 2 . . . 19613 9620 1 61 61 CD 19613 9620 2 - - SYM 19613 9620 3 66 66 CD 19613 9620 4 : : : 19613 9620 5 VII VII NNP 19613 9620 6 . . . 19613 9621 1 50 50 CD 19613 9621 2 ; ; : 19613 9621 3 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9621 4 . . . 19613 9621 5 , , , 19613 9621 6 Pæd pæd NN 19613 9621 7 . . . 19613 9622 1 III iii CD 19613 9622 2 . . . 19613 9623 1 12 12 CD 19613 9623 2 . . . 19613 9624 1 93 93 CD 19613 9624 2 : : : 19613 9624 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9624 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9624 5 : : : 19613 9624 6 to to TO 19613 9624 7 examartanein examartanein NNP 19613 9624 8 pasin pasin NNP 19613 9624 9 emphyton emphyton NNP 19613 9624 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9624 11 . . . 19613 9624 12 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9625 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9625 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9625 3 781 781 CD 19613 9625 4 : : : 19613 9625 5 See see VB 19613 9625 6 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9625 7 . . . 19613 9625 8 , , , 19613 9625 9 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9625 10 . . . 19613 9626 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9626 2 . . . 19613 9627 1 16 16 CD 19613 9627 2 . . . 19613 9628 1 101 101 CD 19613 9628 2 : : : 19613 9628 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9628 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9628 5 : : : 19613 9628 6 myriôn myriôn NNP 19613 9628 7 goun goun NNP 19613 9628 8 ontôn ontôn NNP 19613 9628 9 kat kat NNP 19613 9628 10 ' ' '' 19613 9628 11 arithmon arithmon NN 19613 9628 12 ha ha UH 19613 9628 13 prassousin prassousin NNP 19613 9628 14 anthrôpoi anthrôpoi NNP 19613 9628 15 schedon schedon NNP 19613 9628 16 duo duo NNP 19613 9628 17 eisin eisin NNP 19613 9628 18 archai archai NNP 19613 9628 19 pasês pasês NNP 19613 9628 20 hamartias hamartias NNP 19613 9628 21 , , , 19613 9628 22 agnoia agnoia NNP 19613 9628 23 kai kai NNP 19613 9628 24 astheneia astheneia NNP 19613 9628 25 , , , 19613 9628 26 amphô amphô NNP 19613 9628 27 de de NNP 19613 9628 28 eph eph NNP 19613 9628 29 ' ' POS 19613 9628 30 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 9628 31 , , , 19613 9628 32 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9628 33 mête mête NNP 19613 9628 34 ethelontôn ethelontôn NNP 19613 9628 35 manthanein manthanein NNP 19613 9628 36 mête mête NNP 19613 9628 37 au au NNP 19613 9628 38 tês tês NNP 19613 9628 39 epithymias epithymias NNP 19613 9628 40 kratein kratein NNP 19613 9628 41 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9628 42 . . . 19613 9629 1 Two two CD 19613 9629 2 remedies remedy NNS 19613 9629 3 correspond correspond VBP 19613 9629 4 to to IN 19613 9629 5 this this DT 19613 9629 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9629 7 102 102 CD 19613 9629 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9629 9 : : : 19613 9629 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9629 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9629 12 : : : 19613 9629 13 hê hê VB 19613 9629 14 gnôsis gnôsis NN 19613 9629 15 te te NNP 19613 9629 16 kai kai NNP 19613 9629 17 hê hê NNP 19613 9629 18 tês tês NNP 19613 9629 19 ek ek NNP 19613 9629 20 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9629 21 graphôn graphôn NNP 19613 9629 22 martyrias martyrias NNP 19613 9629 23 enargês enargês NNP 19613 9629 24 apodeixis apodeixis NNP 19613 9629 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9629 26 and and CC 19613 9629 27 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9629 28 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9629 29 : : : 19613 9629 30 hê hê NNP 19613 9629 31 kata kata NNP 19613 9629 32 logon logon NNP 19613 9629 33 askêsis askêsis NNP 19613 9629 34 ek ek NNP 19613 9629 35 pisteôs pisteôs NNP 19613 9629 36 te te NNP 19613 9629 37 kai kai NNP 19613 9629 38 phobou phobou NNP 19613 9629 39 paidagôgoumenê paidagôgoumenê NNP 19613 9629 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9629 41 , , , 19613 9629 42 or or CC 19613 9629 43 otherwise otherwise RB 19613 9629 44 expressed express VBN 19613 9629 45 : : : 19613 9629 46 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9629 47 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9629 48 : : : 19613 9629 49 hê hê VB 19613 9629 50 theôria theôria FW 19613 9629 51 hê hê NN 19613 9629 52 epistêmonikê epistêmonikê NNS 19613 9629 53 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9629 54 and and CC 19613 9629 55 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9629 56 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9629 57 : : : 19613 9629 58 hê hê VB 19613 9629 59 praxis praxis NN 19613 9629 60 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9629 61 which which WDT 19613 9629 62 lead lead VBP 19613 9629 63 to to IN 19613 9629 64 perfect perfect JJ 19613 9629 65 love love NN 19613 9629 66 . . . 19613 9629 67 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9630 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9630 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9630 3 782 782 CD 19613 9630 4 : : : 19613 9630 5 Freedom freedom NN 19613 9630 6 is be VBZ 19613 9630 7 not not RB 19613 9630 8 prejudiced prejudice VBN 19613 9630 9 by by IN 19613 9630 10 the the DT 19613 9630 11 idea idea NN 19613 9630 12 of of IN 19613 9630 13 election election NN 19613 9630 14 that that WDT 19613 9630 15 is be VBZ 19613 9630 16 found find VBN 19613 9630 17 here here RB 19613 9630 18 and and CC 19613 9630 19 there there RB 19613 9630 20 , , , 19613 9630 21 for for IN 19613 9630 22 this this DT 19613 9630 23 idea idea NN 19613 9630 24 is be VBZ 19613 9630 25 not not RB 19613 9630 26 worked work VBN 19613 9630 27 out out RP 19613 9630 28 . . . 19613 9631 1 In in IN 19613 9631 2 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9631 3 . . . 19613 9631 4 , , , 19613 9631 5 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9631 6 . . . 19613 9632 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9632 2 . . . 19613 9633 1 9 9 CD 19613 9633 2 . . . 19613 9634 1 76 76 CD 19613 9634 2 , , , 19613 9634 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9634 4 is be VBZ 19613 9634 5 said say VBN 19613 9634 6 of of IN 19613 9634 7 the the DT 19613 9634 8 friend friend NN 19613 9634 9 of of IN 19613 9634 10 God God NNP 19613 9634 11 , , , 19613 9634 12 the the DT 19613 9634 13 true true JJ 19613 9634 14 Gnostic Gnostic NNP 19613 9634 15 , , , 19613 9634 16 that that IN 19613 9634 17 God God NNP 19613 9634 18 has have VBZ 19613 9634 19 destined destine VBN 19613 9634 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9634 21 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9634 22 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9634 23 : : : 19613 9634 24 proôrisen proôrisen NN 19613 9634 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9634 26 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9634 27 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9634 28 to to TO 19613 9634 29 sonship sonship VB 19613 9634 30 before before IN 19613 9634 31 the the DT 19613 9634 32 foundation foundation NN 19613 9634 33 of of IN 19613 9634 34 the the DT 19613 9634 35 world world NN 19613 9634 36 . . . 19613 9635 1 See see VB 19613 9635 2 VII vii NN 19613 9635 3 . . . 19613 9636 1 17 17 CD 19613 9636 2 . . . 19613 9637 1 107 107 LS 19613 9637 2 . . . 19613 9637 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9638 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9638 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9638 3 783 783 CD 19613 9638 4 : : : 19613 9638 5 C. C. NNP 19613 9638 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9638 7 . . . 19613 9639 1 III iii CD 19613 9639 2 . . . 19613 9640 1 69 69 CD 19613 9640 2 . . . 19613 9640 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9641 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9641 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9641 3 784 784 CD 19613 9641 4 : : : 19613 9641 5 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9641 6 is be VBZ 19613 9641 7 both both CC 19613 9641 8 true true JJ 19613 9641 9 that that IN 19613 9641 10 men man NNS 19613 9641 11 have have VBP 19613 9641 12 the the DT 19613 9641 13 same same JJ 19613 9641 14 freedom freedom NN 19613 9641 15 as as IN 19613 9641 16 Adam Adam NNP 19613 9641 17 and and CC 19613 9641 18 that that IN 19613 9641 19 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9641 20 have have VBP 19613 9641 21 the the DT 19613 9641 22 same same JJ 19613 9641 23 evil evil JJ 19613 9641 24 instincts instinct NNS 19613 9641 25 . . . 19613 9642 1 Moreover moreover RB 19613 9642 2 , , , 19613 9642 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9642 4 conceived conceive VBD 19613 9642 5 the the DT 19613 9642 6 story story NN 19613 9642 7 of of IN 19613 9642 8 Adam Adam NNP 19613 9642 9 symbolically symbolically RB 19613 9642 10 . . . 19613 9643 1 See see VB 19613 9643 2 c. c. NN 19613 9643 3 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9643 4 . . . 19613 9644 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9644 2 . . . 19613 9645 1 40 40 CD 19613 9645 2 ; ; : 19613 9645 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9645 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9645 5 : : : 19613 9645 6 peri peri NN 19613 9645 7 archôn archôn NN 19613 9645 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9645 9 IV IV NNP 19613 9645 10 . . . 19613 9646 1 16 16 CD 19613 9646 2 ; ; : 19613 9646 3 in in IN 19613 9646 4 Levit Levit NNP 19613 9646 5 . . . 19613 9647 1 hom hom NNP 19613 9647 2 . . . 19613 9648 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9648 2 . . . 19613 9649 1 2 2 LS 19613 9649 2 . . . 19613 9650 1 In in IN 19613 9650 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9650 3 later later JJ 19613 9650 4 writings writing NNS 19613 9650 5 , , , 19613 9650 6 after after IN 19613 9650 7 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9650 8 had have VBD 19613 9650 9 met meet VBN 19613 9650 10 with with IN 19613 9650 11 the the DT 19613 9650 12 practice practice NN 19613 9650 13 of of IN 19613 9650 14 child child NN 19613 9650 15 baptism baptism NN 19613 9650 16 in in IN 19613 9650 17 Cæsarea Cæsarea NNP 19613 9650 18 and and CC 19613 9650 19 prevailed prevail VBD 19613 9650 20 on on IN 19613 9650 21 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9650 22 to to TO 19613 9650 23 regard regard VB 19613 9650 24 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9650 25 as as IN 19613 9650 26 apostolic apostolic NNP 19613 9650 27 , , , 19613 9650 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9650 29 also also RB 19613 9650 30 assumed assume VBD 19613 9650 31 the the DT 19613 9650 32 existence existence NN 19613 9650 33 of of IN 19613 9650 34 a a DT 19613 9650 35 sort sort NN 19613 9650 36 of of IN 19613 9650 37 hereditary hereditary JJ 19613 9650 38 sin sin NN 19613 9650 39 originating originate VBG 19613 9650 40 with with IN 19613 9650 41 Adam Adam NNP 19613 9650 42 , , , 19613 9650 43 and and CC 19613 9650 44 added add VBD 19613 9650 45 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9650 46 to to IN 19613 9650 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9650 48 idea idea NN 19613 9650 49 of of IN 19613 9650 50 the the DT 19613 9650 51 preëxisting preëxisting NN 19613 9650 52 Fall Fall NNP 19613 9650 53 . . . 19613 9651 1 Like like IN 19613 9651 2 Augustine Augustine NNP 19613 9651 3 after after IN 19613 9651 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9651 5 , , , 19613 9651 6 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9651 7 also also RB 19613 9651 8 supposed suppose VBD 19613 9651 9 that that IN 19613 9651 10 there there EX 19613 9651 11 was be VBD 19613 9651 12 an an DT 19613 9651 13 inherent inherent JJ 19613 9651 14 pollution pollution NN 19613 9651 15 in in IN 19613 9651 16 sexual sexual JJ 19613 9651 17 union union NN 19613 9651 18 ; ; : 19613 9651 19 see see VB 19613 9651 20 in in IN 19613 9651 21 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9651 22 . . . 19613 9652 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9652 2 9 9 CD 19613 9652 3 : : : 19613 9652 4 VII VII NNP 19613 9652 5 . . . 19613 9653 1 4 4 LS 19613 9653 2 ; ; : 19613 9653 3 in in IN 19613 9653 4 Lev Lev NNP 19613 9653 5 . . . 19613 9654 1 hom hom NNP 19613 9654 2 . . . 19613 9655 1 VIII VIII NNP 19613 9655 2 . . . 19613 9656 1 3 3 LS 19613 9656 2 ; ; : 19613 9656 3 in in IN 19613 9656 4 Num Num NNP 19613 9656 5 . . . 19613 9657 1 hom hom NNP 19613 9657 2 . . . 19613 9658 1 2 2 LS 19613 9658 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9658 3 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9658 4 , , , 19613 9658 5 p. p. NN 19613 9658 6 202 202 CD 19613 9658 7 f. f. NN 19613 9658 8 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9658 9 . . . 19613 9658 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9659 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9659 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9659 3 785 785 CD 19613 9659 4 : : : 19613 9659 5 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 19613 9659 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9659 7 assumes assume VBZ 19613 9659 8 that that IN 19613 9659 9 some some DT 19613 9659 10 souls soul NNS 19613 9659 11 are be VBP 19613 9659 12 invested invest VBN 19613 9659 13 with with IN 19613 9659 14 flesh flesh NN 19613 9659 15 , , , 19613 9659 16 not not RB 19613 9659 17 for for IN 19613 9659 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9659 19 own own JJ 19613 9659 20 sins sin NNS 19613 9659 21 , , , 19613 9659 22 but but CC 19613 9659 23 in in IN 19613 9659 24 order order NN 19613 9659 25 to to TO 19613 9659 26 be be VB 19613 9659 27 of of IN 19613 9659 28 use use NN 19613 9659 29 to to IN 19613 9659 30 others other NNS 19613 9659 31 . . . 19613 9660 1 See see VB 19613 9660 2 in in IN 19613 9660 3 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9660 4 . . . 19613 9661 1 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9661 2 . . . 19613 9662 1 43 43 CD 19613 9662 2 ad ad NN 19613 9662 3 fin fin NN 19613 9662 4 ; ; : 19613 9662 5 II II NNP 19613 9662 6 . . . 19613 9663 1 24 24 CD 19613 9663 2 , , , 19613 9663 3 25 25 CD 19613 9663 4 ; ; : 19613 9663 5 in in IN 19613 9663 6 Matth Matth NNP 19613 9663 7 . . . 19613 9664 1 XII XII NNP 19613 9664 2 . . . 19613 9665 1 30 30 CD 19613 9665 2 . . . 19613 9665 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9666 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9666 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9666 3 786 786 CD 19613 9666 4 : : : 19613 9666 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9666 6 again again RB 19613 9666 7 and and CC 19613 9666 8 again again RB 19613 9666 9 strongly strongly RB 19613 9666 10 urged urge VBD 19613 9666 11 the the DT 19613 9666 12 necessity necessity NN 19613 9666 13 of of IN 19613 9666 14 divine divine JJ 19613 9666 15 grace grace NN 19613 9666 16 . . . 19613 9666 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9667 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9667 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9667 3 787 787 CD 19613 9667 4 : : : 19613 9667 5 See see VB 19613 9667 6 on on IN 19613 9667 7 this this DT 19613 9667 8 point point NN 19613 9667 9 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9667 10 , , , 19613 9667 11 pp pp NNP 19613 9667 12 . . . 19613 9668 1 207 207 CD 19613 9668 2 ff ff NNP 19613 9668 3 . . NNP 19613 9668 4 , , , 19613 9668 5 223 223 CD 19613 9668 6 f. f. NNP 19613 9668 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9668 8 is be VBZ 19613 9668 9 the the DT 19613 9668 10 father father NN 19613 9668 11 of of IN 19613 9668 12 Joachim Joachim NNP 19613 9668 13 and and CC 19613 9668 14 all all DT 19613 9668 15 spiritualists spiritualist NNS 19613 9668 16 . . . 19613 9668 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9669 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9669 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9669 3 788 788 CD 19613 9669 4 : : : 19613 9669 5 See see VB 19613 9669 6 Knittel Knittel NNP 19613 9669 7 , , , 19613 9669 8 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9669 9 . . . 19613 9670 1 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 9670 2 von von NNP 19613 9670 3 der der IN 19613 9670 4 Menschwerdung Menschwerdung NNP 19613 9670 5 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9670 6 Tübinger Tübinger NNP 19613 9670 7 Theologische Theologische NNP 19613 9670 8 Quartalschrift Quartalschrift NNP 19613 9670 9 , , , 19613 9670 10 1872 1872 CD 19613 9670 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9670 12 . . . 19613 9671 1 Ramers ramer NNS 19613 9671 2 , , , 19613 9671 3 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9671 4 . . . 19613 9672 1 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 9672 2 von von NNP 19613 9672 3 der der IN 19613 9672 4 Auferstehung Auferstehung NNP 19613 9672 5 des des NNP 19613 9672 6 Fleisches Fleisches NNP 19613 9672 7 , , , 19613 9672 8 1851 1851 CD 19613 9672 9 . . . 19613 9673 1 Schultz Schultz NNP 19613 9673 2 , , , 19613 9673 3 Gottheit Gottheit NNP 19613 9673 4 Christi Christi NNP 19613 9673 5 , , , 19613 9673 6 pp pp NNP 19613 9673 7 . . . 19613 9674 1 51 51 CD 19613 9674 2 - - SYM 19613 9674 3 62 62 CD 19613 9674 4 . . . 19613 9674 5 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9675 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9675 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9675 3 789 789 CD 19613 9675 4 : : : 19613 9675 5 With with IN 19613 9675 6 regard regard NN 19613 9675 7 to to IN 19613 9675 8 this this DT 19613 9675 9 point point NN 19613 9675 10 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9675 11 find find VBP 19613 9675 12 the the DT 19613 9675 13 same same JJ 19613 9675 14 explanation explanation NN 19613 9675 15 in in IN 19613 9675 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9675 17 as as IN 19613 9675 18 in in IN 19613 9675 19 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 9675 20 and and CC 19613 9675 21 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 19613 9675 22 , , , 19613 9675 23 and and CC 19613 9675 24 also also RB 19613 9675 25 among among IN 19613 9675 26 the the DT 19613 9675 27 Valentinians Valentinians NNPS 19613 9675 28 , , , 19613 9675 29 in in IN 19613 9675 30 so so RB 19613 9675 31 far far RB 19613 9675 32 as as IN 19613 9675 33 the the DT 19613 9675 34 latter latter JJ 19613 9675 35 describe describe VBP 19613 9675 36 the the DT 19613 9675 37 redemption redemption NN 19613 9675 38 necessary necessary JJ 19613 9675 39 for for IN 19613 9675 40 the the DT 19613 9675 41 Psychici Psychici NNP 19613 9675 42 . . . 19613 9676 1 Only only RB 19613 9676 2 , , , 19613 9676 3 in in IN 19613 9676 4 this this DT 19613 9676 5 instance instance NN 19613 9676 6 also also RB 19613 9676 7 , , , 19613 9676 8 everything everything NN 19613 9676 9 is be VBZ 19613 9676 10 more more RBR 19613 9676 11 copious copious JJ 19613 9676 12 in in IN 19613 9676 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9676 14 case case NN 19613 9676 15 , , , 19613 9676 16 because because IN 19613 9676 17 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9676 18 availed avail VBD 19613 9676 19 himself -PRON- PRP 19613 9676 20 of of IN 19613 9676 21 the the DT 19613 9676 22 Holy Holy NNP 19613 9676 23 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 19613 9676 24 still still RB 19613 9676 25 more more JJR 19613 9676 26 than than IN 19613 9676 27 these these DT 19613 9676 28 did do VBD 19613 9676 29 , , , 19613 9676 30 and and CC 19613 9676 31 because because IN 19613 9676 32 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9676 33 left leave VBD 19613 9676 34 out out RP 19613 9676 35 no no DT 19613 9676 36 popular popular JJ 19613 9676 37 conception conception NN 19613 9676 38 that that WDT 19613 9676 39 seemed seem VBD 19613 9676 40 to to TO 19613 9676 41 have have VB 19613 9676 42 any any DT 19613 9676 43 moral moral JJ 19613 9676 44 value value NN 19613 9676 45 . . . 19613 9677 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 19613 9677 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9677 3 propounded propound VBD 19613 9677 4 views view NNS 19613 9677 5 as as IN 19613 9677 6 to to IN 19613 9677 7 the the DT 19613 9677 8 value value NN 19613 9677 9 of of IN 19613 9677 10 salvation salvation NN 19613 9677 11 and and CC 19613 9677 12 as as IN 19613 9677 13 to to IN 19613 9677 14 the the DT 19613 9677 15 significance significance NN 19613 9677 16 of of IN 19613 9677 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9677 18 's 's POS 19613 9677 19 death death NN 19613 9677 20 on on IN 19613 9677 21 the the DT 19613 9677 22 cross cross NN 19613 9677 23 , , , 19613 9677 24 with with IN 19613 9677 25 a a DT 19613 9677 26 variety variety NN 19613 9677 27 and and CC 19613 9677 28 detail detail NN 19613 9677 29 rivalled rival VBN 19613 9677 30 by by IN 19613 9677 31 no no DT 19613 9677 32 theologian theologian NN 19613 9677 33 before before IN 19613 9677 34 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9677 35 . . . 19613 9678 1 He -PRON- PRP 19613 9678 2 was be VBD 19613 9678 3 , , , 19613 9678 4 as as IN 19613 9678 5 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9678 6 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9678 7 p. p. NN 19613 9678 8 209 209 CD 19613 9678 9 ff ff NN 19613 9678 10 . . . 19613 9678 11 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9679 1 has have VBZ 19613 9679 2 rightly rightly RB 19613 9679 3 noticed notice VBN 19613 9679 4 , , , 19613 9679 5 the the DT 19613 9679 6 first first JJ 19613 9679 7 Church Church NNP 19613 9679 8 theologian theologian NN 19613 9679 9 after after IN 19613 9679 10 Paul Paul NNP 19613 9679 11 's 's POS 19613 9679 12 time time NN 19613 9679 13 that that WDT 19613 9679 14 gave give VBD 19613 9679 15 a a DT 19613 9679 16 detailed detailed JJ 19613 9679 17 theology theology NN 19613 9679 18 of of IN 19613 9679 19 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 19613 9679 20 . . . 19613 9680 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 9680 2 may may MD 19613 9680 3 mention mention VB 19613 9680 4 here here RB 19613 9680 5 the the DT 19613 9680 6 most most RBS 19613 9680 7 important important JJ 19613 9680 8 of of IN 19613 9680 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9680 10 views view NNS 19613 9680 11 . . . 19613 9681 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9681 2 1 1 LS 19613 9681 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9681 4 The the DT 19613 9681 5 death death NN 19613 9681 6 on on IN 19613 9681 7 the the DT 19613 9681 8 cross cross NN 19613 9681 9 along along IN 19613 9681 10 with with IN 19613 9681 11 the the DT 19613 9681 12 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 9681 13 is be VBZ 19613 9681 14 to to TO 19613 9681 15 be be VB 19613 9681 16 considered consider VBN 19613 9681 17 as as IN 19613 9681 18 a a DT 19613 9681 19 real real JJ 19613 9681 20 , , , 19613 9681 21 recognisable recognisable JJ 19613 9681 22 victory victory NN 19613 9681 23 over over IN 19613 9681 24 the the DT 19613 9681 25 demons demon NNS 19613 9681 26 , , , 19613 9681 27 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 9681 28 as as IN 19613 9681 29 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9681 30 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9681 31 Col Col NNP 19613 9681 32 . . NNP 19613 9681 33 II ii CD 19613 9681 34 . . . 19613 9682 1 14 14 CD 19613 9682 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9682 3 exposed expose VBD 19613 9682 4 the the DT 19613 9682 5 weakness weakness NN 19613 9682 6 of of IN 19613 9682 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9682 8 enemies enemy NNS 19613 9682 9 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9682 10 a a DT 19613 9682 11 very very RB 19613 9682 12 frequent frequent JJ 19613 9682 13 aspect aspect NN 19613 9682 14 of of IN 19613 9682 15 the the DT 19613 9682 16 matter matter NN 19613 9682 17 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9682 18 . . . 19613 9683 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9683 2 2 2 LS 19613 9683 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9683 4 The the DT 19613 9683 5 death death NN 19613 9683 6 on on IN 19613 9683 7 the the DT 19613 9683 8 cross cross NN 19613 9683 9 is be VBZ 19613 9683 10 to to TO 19613 9683 11 be be VB 19613 9683 12 considered consider VBN 19613 9683 13 as as IN 19613 9683 14 an an DT 19613 9683 15 expiation expiation NN 19613 9683 16 offered offer VBN 19613 9683 17 to to IN 19613 9683 18 God God NNP 19613 9683 19 . . . 19613 9684 1 Here here RB 19613 9684 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9684 3 argued argue VBD 19613 9684 4 that that IN 19613 9684 5 all all DT 19613 9684 6 sins sin NNS 19613 9684 7 require require VBP 19613 9684 8 expiation expiation NN 19613 9684 9 , , , 19613 9684 10 and and CC 19613 9684 11 , , , 19613 9684 12 conversely conversely RB 19613 9684 13 , , , 19613 9684 14 that that IN 19613 9684 15 all all DT 19613 9684 16 innocent innocent JJ 19613 9684 17 blood blood NN 19613 9684 18 has have VBZ 19613 9684 19 a a DT 19613 9684 20 greater great JJR 19613 9684 21 or or CC 19613 9684 22 less less JJR 19613 9684 23 importance importance NN 19613 9684 24 according accord VBG 19613 9684 25 to to IN 19613 9684 26 the the DT 19613 9684 27 value value NN 19613 9684 28 of of IN 19613 9684 29 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9684 30 who who WP 19613 9684 31 gives give VBZ 19613 9684 32 up up RP 19613 9684 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9684 34 life life NN 19613 9684 35 . . . 19613 9685 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9685 2 3 3 LS 19613 9685 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9685 4 In in IN 19613 9685 5 accordance accordance NN 19613 9685 6 with with IN 19613 9685 7 this this DT 19613 9685 8 the the DT 19613 9685 9 death death NN 19613 9685 10 of of IN 19613 9685 11 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9685 12 has have VBZ 19613 9685 13 also also RB 19613 9685 14 a a DT 19613 9685 15 vicarious vicarious JJ 19613 9685 16 signification signification NN 19613 9685 17 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9685 18 see see VB 19613 9685 19 with with IN 19613 9685 20 regard regard NN 19613 9685 21 to to IN 19613 9685 22 both both PDT 19613 9685 23 these these DT 19613 9685 24 conceptions conception NNS 19613 9685 25 the the DT 19613 9685 26 treatise treatise NN 19613 9685 27 Exhort Exhort NNP 19613 9685 28 , , , 19613 9685 29 ad ad NN 19613 9685 30 martyr martyr NN 19613 9685 31 . . . 19613 9685 32 , , , 19613 9685 33 as as RB 19613 9685 34 well well RB 19613 9685 35 as as IN 19613 9685 36 c. c. NNP 19613 9685 37 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9685 38 . . . 19613 9686 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9686 2 . . . 19613 9687 1 17 17 CD 19613 9687 2 : : : 19613 9687 3 I. i. NN 19613 9688 1 31 31 CD 19613 9688 2 ; ; : 19613 9688 3 in in IN 19613 9688 4 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9688 5 . . . 19613 9689 1 t. t. NNP 19613 9689 2 III III NNP 19613 9689 3 . . . 19613 9690 1 7 7 CD 19613 9690 2 , , , 19613 9690 3 8 8 CD 19613 9690 4 , , , 19613 9690 5 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9690 6 . . . 19613 9691 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9691 2 . . NNP 19613 9691 3 , , , 19613 9691 4 pp pp NNP 19613 9691 5 . . . 19613 9692 1 196 196 CD 19613 9692 2 - - SYM 19613 9692 3 216 216 CD 19613 9692 4 etc etc NN 19613 9692 5 . . . 19613 9692 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9692 7 . . . 19613 9693 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9693 2 4 4 LS 19613 9693 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9693 4 The the DT 19613 9693 5 death death NN 19613 9693 6 of of IN 19613 9693 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9693 8 is be VBZ 19613 9693 9 to to TO 19613 9693 10 be be VB 19613 9693 11 considered consider VBN 19613 9693 12 as as IN 19613 9693 13 a a DT 19613 9693 14 ransom ransom NN 19613 9693 15 paid pay VBN 19613 9693 16 to to IN 19613 9693 17 the the DT 19613 9693 18 devil devil NN 19613 9693 19 . . . 19613 9694 1 This this DT 19613 9694 2 view view NN 19613 9694 3 must must MD 19613 9694 4 have have VB 19613 9694 5 been be VBN 19613 9694 6 widely widely RB 19613 9694 7 diffused diffuse VBN 19613 9694 8 in in IN 19613 9694 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9694 10 's 's POS 19613 9694 11 time time NN 19613 9694 12 ; ; : 19613 9694 13 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9694 14 readily readily RB 19613 9694 15 suggested suggest VBD 19613 9694 16 itself -PRON- PRP 19613 9694 17 to to IN 19613 9694 18 the the DT 19613 9694 19 popular popular JJ 19613 9694 20 idea idea NN 19613 9694 21 and and CC 19613 9694 22 was be VBD 19613 9694 23 further further RB 19613 9694 24 supported support VBN 19613 9694 25 by by IN 19613 9694 26 Marcionite Marcionite NNP 19613 9694 27 these these DT 19613 9694 28 s s NNS 19613 9694 29 . . . 19613 9695 1 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9695 2 was be VBD 19613 9695 3 also also RB 19613 9695 4 accepted accept VBN 19613 9695 5 by by IN 19613 9695 6 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9695 7 who who WP 19613 9695 8 united unite VBD 19613 9695 9 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9695 10 with with IN 19613 9695 11 the the DT 19613 9695 12 notion notion NN 19613 9695 13 of of IN 19613 9695 14 a a DT 19613 9695 15 deception deception NN 19613 9695 16 practised practise VBN 19613 9695 17 on on IN 19613 9695 18 the the DT 19613 9695 19 devil devil NN 19613 9695 20 , , , 19613 9695 21 a a DT 19613 9695 22 conception conception NN 19613 9695 23 first first RB 19613 9695 24 found find VBN 19613 9695 25 among among IN 19613 9695 26 the the DT 19613 9695 27 Basilidians Basilidians NNPS 19613 9695 28 . . . 19613 9696 1 By by IN 19613 9696 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9696 3 successful successful JJ 19613 9696 4 temptation temptation NN 19613 9696 5 the the DT 19613 9696 6 devil devil NN 19613 9696 7 acquired acquire VBD 19613 9696 8 a a DT 19613 9696 9 right right NN 19613 9696 10 over over IN 19613 9696 11 men man NNS 19613 9696 12 . . . 19613 9697 1 This this DT 19613 9697 2 right right NN 19613 9697 3 can can MD 19613 9697 4 not not RB 19613 9697 5 be be VB 19613 9697 6 destroyed destroy VBN 19613 9697 7 , , , 19613 9697 8 but but CC 19613 9697 9 only only RB 19613 9697 10 bought buy VBD 19613 9697 11 off off RP 19613 9697 12 . . . 19613 9698 1 God God NNP 19613 9698 2 offers offer VBZ 19613 9698 3 the the DT 19613 9698 4 devil devil NN 19613 9698 5 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9698 6 's 's POS 19613 9698 7 soul soul NN 19613 9698 8 in in IN 19613 9698 9 exchange exchange NN 19613 9698 10 for for IN 19613 9698 11 the the DT 19613 9698 12 souls soul NNS 19613 9698 13 of of IN 19613 9698 14 men man NNS 19613 9698 15 . . . 19613 9699 1 This this DT 19613 9699 2 proposal proposal NN 19613 9699 3 of of IN 19613 9699 4 exchange exchange NN 19613 9699 5 was be VBD 19613 9699 6 , , , 19613 9699 7 however however RB 19613 9699 8 , , , 19613 9699 9 insincere insincere NNP 19613 9699 10 , , , 19613 9699 11 as as IN 19613 9699 12 God God NNP 19613 9699 13 knew know VBD 19613 9699 14 that that IN 19613 9699 15 the the DT 19613 9699 16 devil devil NN 19613 9699 17 could could MD 19613 9699 18 not not RB 19613 9699 19 keep keep VB 19613 9699 20 hold hold NN 19613 9699 21 of of IN 19613 9699 22 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9699 23 's 's POS 19613 9699 24 soul soul NN 19613 9699 25 , , , 19613 9699 26 because because IN 19613 9699 27 a a DT 19613 9699 28 sinless sinless JJ 19613 9699 29 soul soul NN 19613 9699 30 could could MD 19613 9699 31 not not RB 19613 9699 32 but but RB 19613 9699 33 cause cause VB 19613 9699 34 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9699 35 torture torture NN 19613 9699 36 . . . 19613 9700 1 The the DT 19613 9700 2 devil devil NN 19613 9700 3 agreed agree VBD 19613 9700 4 to to IN 19613 9700 5 the the DT 19613 9700 6 bargain bargain NN 19613 9700 7 and and CC 19613 9700 8 was be VBD 19613 9700 9 duped dupe VBN 19613 9700 10 . . . 19613 9701 1 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9701 2 did do VBD 19613 9701 3 not not RB 19613 9701 4 fall fall VB 19613 9701 5 into into IN 19613 9701 6 the the DT 19613 9701 7 power power NN 19613 9701 8 of of IN 19613 9701 9 death death NN 19613 9701 10 and and CC 19613 9701 11 the the DT 19613 9701 12 devil devil NN 19613 9701 13 , , , 19613 9701 14 but but CC 19613 9701 15 overcame overcome VBD 19613 9701 16 both both DT 19613 9701 17 . . . 19613 9702 1 This this DT 19613 9702 2 theory theory NN 19613 9702 3 , , , 19613 9702 4 which which WDT 19613 9702 5 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9702 6 propounded propound VBD 19613 9702 7 in in IN 19613 9702 8 somewhat somewhat RB 19613 9702 9 different different JJ 19613 9702 10 fashion fashion NN 19613 9702 11 in in IN 19613 9702 12 different different JJ 19613 9702 13 places place NNS 19613 9702 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9702 15 see see VB 19613 9702 16 Exhort Exhort NNP 19613 9702 17 ad ad NN 19613 9702 18 martyr martyr NN 19613 9702 19 . . . 19613 9703 1 12 12 CD 19613 9703 2 ; ; : 19613 9703 3 in in IN 19613 9703 4 Matth Matth NNP 19613 9703 5 . . . 19613 9704 1 t. t. NNP 19613 9704 2 XVI XVI NNP 19613 9704 3 . . . 19613 9705 1 8 8 LS 19613 9705 2 , , , 19613 9705 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9705 4 . . . 19613 9706 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9706 2 . . NNP 19613 9706 3 , , , 19613 9706 4 p. p. NN 19613 9706 5 27 27 CD 19613 9706 6 ; ; : 19613 9706 7 t. t. NNP 19613 9706 8 XII XII NNP 19613 9706 9 . . . 19613 9707 1 28 28 CD 19613 9707 2 , , , 19613 9707 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9707 4 . . . 19613 9708 1 III III NNP 19613 9708 2 . . NNP 19613 9708 3 , , , 19613 9708 4 p. p. NN 19613 9708 5 175 175 CD 19613 9708 6 ; ; : 19613 9708 7 t. t. NNP 19613 9708 8 XIII XIII NNP 19613 9708 9 . . . 19613 9709 1 8 8 CD 19613 9709 2 , , , 19613 9709 3 9 9 CD 19613 9709 4 , , , 19613 9709 5 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9709 6 . . . 19613 9710 1 III III NNP 19613 9710 2 . . NNP 19613 9710 3 , , , 19613 9710 4 pp pp NNP 19613 9710 5 . . . 19613 9711 1 224 224 CD 19613 9711 2 - - SYM 19613 9711 3 229 229 CD 19613 9711 4 ; ; : 19613 9711 5 in in IN 19613 9711 6 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9711 7 . . . 19613 9712 1 II ii CD 19613 9712 2 . . . 19613 9713 1 13 13 CD 19613 9713 2 , , , 19613 9713 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9713 4 . . . 19613 9714 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9714 2 . . NNP 19613 9714 3 , , , 19613 9714 4 p. p. NN 19613 9714 5 139 139 CD 19613 9714 6 sq sq NN 19613 9714 7 . . . 19613 9715 1 etc etc FW 19613 9715 2 . . . 19613 9716 1 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9716 2 , , , 19613 9716 3 shows show VBZ 19613 9716 4 in in IN 19613 9716 5 a a DT 19613 9716 6 specially specially RB 19613 9716 7 clear clear JJ 19613 9716 8 way way NN 19613 9716 9 the the DT 19613 9716 10 conservative conservative JJ 19613 9716 11 method method NN 19613 9716 12 of of IN 19613 9716 13 this this DT 19613 9716 14 theologian theologian NN 19613 9716 15 , , , 19613 9716 16 who who WP 19613 9716 17 would would MD 19613 9716 18 not not RB 19613 9716 19 positively positively RB 19613 9716 20 abandon abandon VB 19613 9716 21 any any DT 19613 9716 22 idea idea NN 19613 9716 23 . . . 19613 9717 1 No no RB 19613 9717 2 doubt doubt RB 19613 9717 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9717 4 shows show VBZ 19613 9717 5 at at IN 19613 9717 6 the the DT 19613 9717 7 same same JJ 19613 9717 8 time time NN 19613 9717 9 how how WRB 19613 9717 10 uncertain uncertain JJ 19613 9717 11 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9717 12 was be VBD 19613 9717 13 as as IN 19613 9717 14 to to IN 19613 9717 15 the the DT 19613 9717 16 applicability applicability NN 19613 9717 17 of of IN 19613 9717 18 popular popular JJ 19613 9717 19 conceptions conception NNS 19613 9717 20 when when WRB 19613 9717 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9717 22 was be VBD 19613 9717 23 dealing deal VBG 19613 9717 24 with with IN 19613 9717 25 the the DT 19613 9717 26 sphere sphere NN 19613 9717 27 of of IN 19613 9717 28 the the DT 19613 9717 29 Psychici Psychici NNP 19613 9717 30 . . . 19613 9718 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 9718 2 must must MD 19613 9718 3 here here RB 19613 9718 4 remember remember VB 19613 9718 5 the the DT 19613 9718 6 ancient ancient JJ 19613 9718 7 idea idea NN 19613 9718 8 that that IN 19613 9718 9 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9718 10 are be VBP 19613 9718 11 not not RB 19613 9718 12 bound bind VBN 19613 9718 13 to to IN 19613 9718 14 sincerity sincerity NN 19613 9718 15 towards towards IN 19613 9718 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9718 17 enemies enemy NNS 19613 9718 18 . . . 19613 9719 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9719 2 5 5 LS 19613 9719 3 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9719 4 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9719 5 , , , 19613 9719 6 the the DT 19613 9719 7 God God NNP 19613 9719 8 who who WP 19613 9719 9 became become VBD 19613 9719 10 flesh flesh NN 19613 9719 11 , , , 19613 9719 12 is be VBZ 19613 9719 13 to to TO 19613 9719 14 be be VB 19613 9719 15 considered consider VBN 19613 9719 16 as as IN 19613 9719 17 high high JJ 19613 9719 18 priest priest NN 19613 9719 19 and and CC 19613 9719 20 mediator mediator NN 19613 9719 21 between between IN 19613 9719 22 God God NNP 19613 9719 23 and and CC 19613 9719 24 man man NN 19613 9719 25 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9719 26 see see VB 19613 9719 27 de de FW 19613 9719 28 Orat Orat NNP 19613 9719 29 . . . 19613 9720 1 10 10 CD 19613 9720 2 , , , 19613 9720 3 15 15 CD 19613 9720 4 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9720 5 . . . 19613 9721 1 All all PDT 19613 9721 2 the the DT 19613 9721 3 above above RB 19613 9721 4 - - HYPH 19613 9721 5 mentioned mention VBN 19613 9721 6 conceptions conception NNS 19613 9721 7 of of IN 19613 9721 8 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9721 9 's 's POS 19613 9721 10 work work NN 19613 9721 11 were be VBD 19613 9721 12 , , , 19613 9721 13 moreover moreover RB 19613 9721 14 , , , 19613 9721 15 worked work VBD 19613 9721 16 out out RP 19613 9721 17 by by IN 19613 9721 18 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9721 19 in in IN 19613 9721 20 such such PDT 19613 9721 21 a a DT 19613 9721 22 way way NN 19613 9721 23 that that WDT 19613 9721 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9721 25 humanity humanity NN 19613 9721 26 and and CC 19613 9721 27 divinity divinity NN 19613 9721 28 are be VBP 19613 9721 29 necessary necessary JJ 19613 9721 30 inferences inference NNS 19613 9721 31 from from IN 19613 9721 32 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9721 33 . . . 19613 9722 1 In in IN 19613 9722 2 this this DT 19613 9722 3 case case NN 19613 9722 4 also also RB 19613 9722 5 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9722 6 is be VBZ 19613 9722 7 characterised characterise VBN 19613 9722 8 by by IN 19613 9722 9 the the DT 19613 9722 10 same same JJ 19613 9722 11 mode mode NN 19613 9722 12 of of IN 19613 9722 13 thought thought NN 19613 9722 14 as as IN 19613 9722 15 Irenæus Irenæus NNP 19613 9722 16 . . . 19613 9723 1 Finally finally RB 19613 9723 2 , , , 19613 9723 3 let let VB 19613 9723 4 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9723 5 remember remember VB 19613 9723 6 that that IN 19613 9723 7 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9723 8 adhered adhere VBD 19613 9723 9 as as RB 19613 9723 10 strongly strongly RB 19613 9723 11 as as IN 19613 9723 12 ever ever RB 19613 9723 13 to to IN 19613 9723 14 the the DT 19613 9723 15 proof proof NN 19613 9723 16 from from IN 19613 9723 17 prophecy prophecy NN 19613 9723 18 , , , 19613 9723 19 and and CC 19613 9723 20 that that IN 19613 9723 21 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9723 22 also also RB 19613 9723 23 , , , 19613 9723 24 in in IN 19613 9723 25 not not RB 19613 9723 26 a a DT 19613 9723 27 few few JJ 19613 9723 28 instances instance NNS 19613 9723 29 , , , 19613 9723 30 regarded regard VBD 19613 9723 31 the the DT 19613 9723 32 phrase phrase NN 19613 9723 33 , , , 19613 9723 34 " " `` 19613 9723 35 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9723 36 is be VBZ 19613 9723 37 written write VBN 19613 9723 38 " " '' 19613 9723 39 , , , 19613 9723 40 as as IN 19613 9723 41 a a DT 19613 9723 42 sufficient sufficient JJ 19613 9723 43 court court NN 19613 9723 44 of of IN 19613 9723 45 appeal appeal NN 19613 9723 46 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9723 47 see see VB 19613 9723 48 , , , 19613 9723 49 for for IN 19613 9723 50 example example NN 19613 9723 51 , , , 19613 9723 52 c. c. NNP 19613 9723 53 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9723 54 . . . 19613 9724 1 II ii CD 19613 9724 2 . . . 19613 9725 1 37 37 CD 19613 9725 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9725 3 . . . 19613 9726 1 Yet yet RB 19613 9726 2 , , , 19613 9726 3 on on IN 19613 9726 4 the the DT 19613 9726 5 other other JJ 19613 9726 6 hand hand NN 19613 9726 7 , , , 19613 9726 8 behind behind IN 19613 9726 9 all all PDT 19613 9726 10 this this DT 19613 9726 11 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9726 12 has have VBZ 19613 9726 13 a a DT 19613 9726 14 method method NN 19613 9726 15 of of IN 19613 9726 16 viewing view VBG 19613 9726 17 things thing NNS 19613 9726 18 which which WDT 19613 9726 19 considerably considerably RB 19613 9726 20 weakens weaken VBZ 19613 9726 21 the the DT 19613 9726 22 significance significance NN 19613 9726 23 of of IN 19613 9726 24 miracles miracle NNS 19613 9726 25 and and CC 19613 9726 26 prophecies prophecy NNS 19613 9726 27 . . . 19613 9727 1 In in IN 19613 9727 2 general general JJ 19613 9727 3 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9727 4 must must MD 19613 9727 5 be be VB 19613 9727 6 said say VBN 19613 9727 7 that that IN 19613 9727 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9727 9 helped help VBD 19613 9727 10 to to TO 19613 9727 11 drag drag VB 19613 9727 12 into into IN 19613 9727 13 the the DT 19613 9727 14 Church Church NNP 19613 9727 15 a a DT 19613 9727 16 great great JJ 19613 9727 17 many many JJ 19613 9727 18 ancient ancient NN 19613 9727 19 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9727 20 heathen heathen NNP 19613 9727 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9727 22 ideas idea NNS 19613 9727 23 about about IN 19613 9727 24 expiation expiation NN 19613 9727 25 and and CC 19613 9727 26 redemption redemption NN 19613 9727 27 , , , 19613 9727 28 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 19613 9727 29 as as IN 19613 9727 30 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9727 31 everywhere everywhere RB 19613 9727 32 found find VBD 19613 9727 33 some some DT 19613 9727 34 Bible Bible NNP 19613 9727 35 passage passage NN 19613 9727 36 or or CC 19613 9727 37 other other JJ 19613 9727 38 with with IN 19613 9727 39 which which WDT 19613 9727 40 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9727 41 associated associate VBD 19613 9727 42 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9727 43 . . . 19613 9728 1 While while IN 19613 9728 2 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9728 3 rejected reject VBD 19613 9728 4 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 9728 5 and and CC 19613 9728 6 gave give VBD 19613 9728 7 little little JJ 19613 9728 8 countenance countenance NN 19613 9728 9 to to IN 19613 9728 10 people people NNS 19613 9728 11 who who WP 19613 9728 12 declared declare VBD 19613 9728 13 : : : 19613 9728 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9728 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9728 16 : : : 19613 9728 17 eusebesteroi eusebesteroi JJ 19613 9728 18 esmen esman NNS 19613 9728 19 kai kai NNP 19613 9728 20 Theon Theon NNP 19613 9728 21 kai kai NNP 19613 9728 22 ta ta NNP 19613 9728 23 agalmata agalmata NNP 19613 9728 24 sebontes sebonte NNS 19613 9728 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9728 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9728 27 Clemens Clemens NNP 19613 9728 28 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9728 29 . . NNP 19613 9728 30 , , , 19613 9728 31 Hom Hom NNP 19613 9728 32 . . . 19613 9729 1 XI XI NNP 19613 9729 2 . . . 19613 9730 1 12 12 CD 19613 9730 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9730 3 , , , 19613 9730 4 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9730 5 had have VBD 19613 9730 6 for for IN 19613 9730 7 all all DT 19613 9730 8 that that WDT 19613 9730 9 a a DT 19613 9730 10 principal principal JJ 19613 9730 11 share share NN 19613 9730 12 in in IN 19613 9730 13 introducing introduce VBG 19613 9730 14 the the DT 19613 9730 15 apparatus apparatus NN 19613 9730 16 of of IN 19613 9730 17 polytheism polytheism NN 19613 9730 18 into into IN 19613 9730 19 the the DT 19613 9730 20 Church Church NNP 19613 9730 21 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9730 22 see see VB 19613 9730 23 also also RB 19613 9730 24 the the DT 19613 9730 25 way way NN 19613 9730 26 in in IN 19613 9730 27 which which WDT 19613 9730 28 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9730 29 strengthened strengthen VBD 19613 9730 30 angel angel NN 19613 9730 31 and and CC 19613 9730 32 hero hero NN 19613 9730 33 worship worship NNP 19613 9730 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9730 35 . . . 19613 9730 36 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9731 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9731 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9731 3 790 790 CD 19613 9731 4 : : : 19613 9731 5 See see VB 19613 9731 6 above above RB 19613 9731 7 , , , 19613 9731 8 p. p. NN 19613 9731 9 342 342 CD 19613 9731 10 . . . 19613 9731 11 note note NN 19613 9731 12 1 1 CD 19613 9731 13 , , , 19613 9731 14 on on IN 19613 9731 15 the the DT 19613 9731 16 idea idea NN 19613 9731 17 that that IN 19613 9731 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9731 19 , , , 19613 9731 20 the the DT 19613 9731 21 Crucified Crucified NNP 19613 9731 22 One One NNP 19613 9731 23 , , , 19613 9731 24 is be VBZ 19613 9731 25 of of IN 19613 9731 26 no no DT 19613 9731 27 importance importance NN 19613 9731 28 to to IN 19613 9731 29 the the DT 19613 9731 30 perfect perfect JJ 19613 9731 31 . . . 19613 9732 1 Only only RB 19613 9732 2 the the DT 19613 9732 3 teacher teacher NN 19613 9732 4 is be VBZ 19613 9732 5 of of IN 19613 9732 6 account account NN 19613 9732 7 in in IN 19613 9732 8 this this DT 19613 9732 9 case case NN 19613 9732 10 . . . 19613 9733 1 To to IN 19613 9733 2 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9733 3 and and CC 19613 9733 4 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9733 5 , , , 19613 9733 6 however however RB 19613 9733 7 , , , 19613 9733 8 teacher teacher NN 19613 9733 9 and and CC 19613 9733 10 mystagogue mystagogue NN 19613 9733 11 are be VBP 19613 9733 12 as as RB 19613 9733 13 closely closely RB 19613 9733 14 connected connected JJ 19613 9733 15 as as IN 19613 9733 16 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9733 17 are be VBP 19613 9733 18 to to IN 19613 9733 19 most most JJS 19613 9733 20 Gnostics Gnostics NNPS 19613 9733 21 . . . 19613 9734 1 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 9734 2 is be VBZ 19613 9734 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9734 4 Greek greek JJ 19613 9734 5 : : : 19613 9734 6 mathêsis mathêsis NN 19613 9734 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9734 8 and and CC 19613 9734 9 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9734 10 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9734 11 : : : 19613 9734 12 mystagôgia mystagôgia NN 19613 9734 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9734 14 and and CC 19613 9734 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9734 16 is be VBZ 19613 9734 17 the the DT 19613 9734 18 one one NN 19613 9734 19 because because IN 19613 9734 20 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9734 21 is be VBZ 19613 9734 22 the the DT 19613 9734 23 other other JJ 19613 9734 24 . . . 19613 9735 1 But but CC 19613 9735 2 in in IN 19613 9735 3 all all DT 19613 9735 4 stages stage NNS 19613 9735 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 19613 9735 6 has have VBZ 19613 9735 7 ultimately ultimately RB 19613 9735 8 the the DT 19613 9735 9 same same JJ 19613 9735 10 object object NN 19613 9735 11 , , , 19613 9735 12 namely namely RB 19613 9735 13 , , , 19613 9735 14 to to TO 19613 9735 15 effect effect VB 19613 9735 16 a a DT 19613 9735 17 reconciliation reconciliation NN 19613 9735 18 with with IN 19613 9735 19 God God NNP 19613 9735 20 , , , 19613 9735 21 and and CC 19613 9735 22 deify deify VB 19613 9735 23 man man NN 19613 9735 24 . . . 19613 9736 1 See see VB 19613 9736 2 c. c. NN 19613 9736 3 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9736 4 . . . 19613 9737 1 III iii CD 19613 9737 2 . . . 19613 9738 1 28 28 CD 19613 9738 2 : : : 19613 9738 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9738 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9738 5 : : : 19613 9738 6 Alla Alla NNP 19613 9738 7 gar gar NNP 19613 9738 8 kai kai NNP 19613 9738 9 tên tên NNP 19613 9738 10 katabasan katabasan NNP 19613 9738 11 eis eis NNP 19613 9738 12 anthrôpinên anthrôpinên NNP 19613 9738 13 physin physin NNP 19613 9738 14 kai kai NNP 19613 9738 15 eis eis NNP 19613 9738 16 anthrôpinas anthrôpinas NNP 19613 9738 17 peristaseis peristaseis NNP 19613 9738 18 dynamin dynamin NNP 19613 9738 19 , , , 19613 9738 20 kai kai NNP 19613 9738 21 analabousan analabousan NNP 19613 9738 22 psychên psychên NNP 19613 9738 23 kai kai NNP 19613 9738 24 sôma sôma NNP 19613 9738 25 anthrôpinon anthrôpinon NNP 19613 9738 26 , , , 19613 9738 27 heôrôn heôrôn NNP 19613 9738 28 ek ek NNP 19613 9738 29 tou tou NNP 19613 9738 30 pisteuesthai pisteuesthai NNP 19613 9738 31 meta meta NNP 19613 9738 32 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9738 33 theioterôn theioterôn NNP 19613 9738 34 symballomenên symballomenên NNP 19613 9738 35 eis eis NNP 19613 9738 36 sôtêrian sôtêrian NNP 19613 9738 37 tois tois NNP 19613 9738 38 pisteuousin pisteuousin NNP 19613 9738 39 orôsin orôsin NNP 19613 9738 40 , , , 19613 9738 41 ap ap NNP 19613 9738 42 ' ' POS 19613 9738 43 ekeinou ekeinou NNP 19613 9738 44 êrxato êrxato NNP 19613 9738 45 theia theia NNP 19613 9738 46 kai kai NNP 19613 9738 47 anthrôpinê anthrôpinê NNP 19613 9738 48 sunuphainesthai sunuphainesthai NNP 19613 9738 49 physis physis NNP 19613 9738 50 en en IN 19613 9738 51 ê ê NNP 19613 9738 52 anthrôpinê anthrôpinê NNS 19613 9738 53 tê tê DT 19613 9738 54 pros pro NNS 19613 9738 55 to to IN 19613 9738 56 theioteron theioteron NNP 19613 9738 57 koinônia koinônia NNP 19613 9738 58 genêtai genêtai NNP 19613 9738 59 theia theia NNP 19613 9738 60 ouk ouk NNP 19613 9738 61 en en IN 19613 9738 62 monô monô NNP 19613 9738 63 tô tô NNP 19613 9738 64 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 9738 65 , , , 19613 9738 66 alla alla NN 19613 9738 67 kai kai NNP 19613 9738 68 pasi pasi NNP 19613 9738 69 tois tois NNP 19613 9738 70 meta meta NNP 19613 9738 71 too too RB 19613 9738 72 pisteuein pisteuein NNP 19613 9738 73 analambanousi analambanousi NNP 19613 9738 74 bion bion NNP 19613 9738 75 , , , 19613 9738 76 hon hon NNP 19613 9738 77 Iêsous iêsous JJ 19613 9738 78 edidaxena edidaxena NN 19613 9738 79 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9738 80 . . . 19613 9738 81 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9739 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9739 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9739 3 791 791 CD 19613 9739 4 : : : 19613 9739 5 From from IN 19613 9739 6 this this DT 19613 9739 7 also also RB 19613 9739 8 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9739 9 can can MD 19613 9739 10 very very RB 19613 9739 11 clearly clearly RB 19613 9739 12 understand understand VB 19613 9739 13 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9739 14 's 's POS 19613 9739 15 aversion aversion NN 19613 9739 16 to to IN 19613 9739 17 the the DT 19613 9739 18 early early JJ 19613 9739 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 9739 20 eschatology eschatology NN 19613 9739 21 . . . 19613 9740 1 In in IN 19613 9740 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9740 3 view view NN 19613 9740 4 the the DT 19613 9740 5 demons demon NNS 19613 9740 6 are be VBP 19613 9740 7 already already RB 19613 9740 8 overcome overcome VBN 19613 9740 9 by by IN 19613 9740 10 the the DT 19613 9740 11 work work NN 19613 9740 12 of of IN 19613 9740 13 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9740 14 . . . 19613 9741 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 9741 2 need need VBP 19613 9741 3 only only RB 19613 9741 4 point point VB 19613 9741 5 out out RP 19613 9741 6 that that IN 19613 9741 7 this this DT 19613 9741 8 conception conception NN 19613 9741 9 must must MD 19613 9741 10 have have VB 19613 9741 11 exercised exercise VBN 19613 9741 12 a a DT 19613 9741 13 most most RBS 19613 9741 14 important important JJ 19613 9741 15 influence influence NN 19613 9741 16 on on IN 19613 9741 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9741 18 frame frame NN 19613 9741 19 of of IN 19613 9741 20 mind mind NN 19613 9741 21 and and CC 19613 9741 22 on on IN 19613 9741 23 politics politic NNS 19613 9741 24 . . . 19613 9741 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9742 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9742 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9742 3 792 792 CD 19613 9742 4 : : : 19613 9742 5 Clement clement NN 19613 9742 6 still still RB 19613 9742 7 advocated advocate VBD 19613 9742 8 docetic docetic JJ 19613 9742 9 views view NNS 19613 9742 10 without without IN 19613 9742 11 reservation reservation NN 19613 9742 12 . . . 19613 9743 1 Photius Photius NNP 19613 9743 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9743 3 Biblioth Biblioth NNP 19613 9743 4 . . . 19613 9744 1 109 109 LS 19613 9744 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9744 3 reproached reproach VBD 19613 9744 4 him -PRON- PRP 19613 9744 5 with with IN 19613 9744 6 these these DT 19613 9744 7 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9744 8 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9744 9 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9744 10 : : : 19613 9744 11 mê mê NNP 19613 9744 12 sarkôthênai sarkôthênai NNP 19613 9744 13 ton ton NNP 19613 9744 14 logon logon NNP 19613 9744 15 alla alla NNP 19613 9744 16 doxai doxai NNP 19613 9744 17 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9744 18 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9744 19 , , , 19613 9744 20 and and CC 19613 9744 21 they -PRON- PRP 19613 9744 22 may may MD 19613 9744 23 be be VB 19613 9744 24 proved prove VBN 19613 9744 25 from from IN 19613 9744 26 the the DT 19613 9744 27 Adumbrat Adumbrat NNP 19613 9744 28 , , , 19613 9744 29 p. p. NN 19613 9744 30 87 87 CD 19613 9744 31 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9744 32 ed ed NNP 19613 9744 33 Zahn Zahn NNP 19613 9744 34 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9744 35 : : : 19613 9744 36 " " `` 19613 9744 37 fertur fertur JJ 19613 9744 38 in in IN 19613 9744 39 traditionibus traditionibus NNP 19613 9744 40 -- -- : 19613 9744 41 namely namely RB 19613 9744 42 , , , 19613 9744 43 in in IN 19613 9744 44 the the DT 19613 9744 45 Acta Acta NNP 19613 9744 46 of of IN 19613 9744 47 Lucius Lucius NNP 19613 9744 48 -- -- : 19613 9744 49 quoniam quoniam NNP 19613 9744 50 Iohannes Iohannes NNP 19613 9744 51 ipsum ipsum NN 19613 9744 52 corpus corpus NNP 19613 9744 53 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9744 54 Christi Christi NNP 19613 9744 55 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9744 56 , , , 19613 9744 57 quod quod NN 19613 9744 58 erat erat NNP 19613 9744 59 extrinsecus extrinsecus NN 19613 9744 60 , , , 19613 9744 61 tangens tangen VBZ 19613 9744 62 manum manum NNP 19613 9744 63 suam suam NNP 19613 9744 64 in in IN 19613 9744 65 profunda profunda NNP 19613 9744 66 misisse misisse NNP 19613 9744 67 et et NNP 19613 9744 68 duritiam duritiam NNP 19613 9744 69 carnis carnis NNP 19613 9744 70 nullo nullo NNP 19613 9744 71 modo modo NNP 19613 9744 72 reluctatam reluctatam NNP 19613 9744 73 esse esse NNP 19613 9744 74 , , , 19613 9744 75 sed sed NNP 19613 9744 76 locum locum NNP 19613 9744 77 manui manui NNP 19613 9744 78 præbuisse præbuisse NNP 19613 9744 79 discipuli discipuli NNP 19613 9744 80 , , , 19613 9744 81 " " '' 19613 9744 82 and and CC 19613 9744 83 likewise likewise RB 19613 9744 84 from from IN 19613 9744 85 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9744 86 . . . 19613 9745 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9745 2 . . . 19613 9746 1 9 9 CD 19613 9746 2 . . . 19613 9747 1 71 71 CD 19613 9747 2 and and CC 19613 9747 3 III iii CD 19613 9747 4 . . . 19613 9748 1 7 7 LS 19613 9748 2 . . . 19613 9749 1 59 59 CD 19613 9749 2 . . . 19613 9750 1 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9750 2 's 's POS 19613 9750 3 repudiation repudiation NN 19613 9750 4 of of IN 19613 9750 5 the the DT 19613 9750 6 Docetists Docetists NNPS 19613 9750 7 in in IN 19613 9750 8 VII VII NNP 19613 9750 9 . . . 19613 9751 1 17 17 CD 19613 9751 2 . . . 19613 9752 1 108 108 CD 19613 9752 2 does do VBZ 19613 9752 3 not not RB 19613 9752 4 affect affect VB 19613 9752 5 the the DT 19613 9752 6 case case NN 19613 9752 7 , , , 19613 9752 8 and and CC 19613 9752 9 the the DT 19613 9752 10 fact fact NN 19613 9752 11 that that IN 19613 9752 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9752 13 here here RB 19613 9752 14 and and CC 19613 9752 15 there there EX 19613 9752 16 plainly plainly RB 19613 9752 17 called call VBD 19613 9752 18 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 9752 19 a a DT 19613 9752 20 man man NN 19613 9752 21 , , , 19613 9752 22 and and CC 19613 9752 23 spoke speak VBD 19613 9752 24 of of IN 19613 9752 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9752 26 flesh flesh NN 19613 9752 27 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9752 28 Pæd pæd NN 19613 9752 29 . . . 19613 9753 1 II ii CD 19613 9753 2 . . . 19613 9754 1 2 2 LS 19613 9754 2 . . . 19613 9755 1 32 32 LS 19613 9755 2 : : : 19613 9755 3 Protrept Protrept NNP 19613 9755 4 . . . 19613 9756 1 X. X. NNP 19613 9757 1 110 110 LS 19613 9757 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9757 3 matters matter VBZ 19613 9757 4 just just RB 19613 9757 5 as as RB 19613 9757 6 little little JJ 19613 9757 7 . . . 19613 9758 1 This this DT 19613 9758 2 teacher teacher NN 19613 9758 3 simply simply RB 19613 9758 4 continued continue VBD 19613 9758 5 to to TO 19613 9758 6 follow follow VB 19613 9758 7 the the DT 19613 9758 8 old old JJ 19613 9758 9 undisguised undisguised JJ 19613 9758 10 Docetism docetism NN 19613 9758 11 which which WDT 19613 9758 12 only only RB 19613 9758 13 admitted admit VBD 19613 9758 14 the the DT 19613 9758 15 apparent apparent JJ 19613 9758 16 reality reality NN 19613 9758 17 of of IN 19613 9758 18 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9758 19 's 's POS 19613 9758 20 body body NN 19613 9758 21 . . . 19613 9759 1 Clement clement NN 19613 9759 2 expressly expressly RB 19613 9759 3 declared declare VBD 19613 9759 4 that that IN 19613 9759 5 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 9759 6 knew know VBD 19613 9759 7 neither neither CC 19613 9759 8 pain pain NN 19613 9759 9 , , , 19613 9759 10 nor nor CC 19613 9759 11 sorrow sorrow NN 19613 9759 12 , , , 19613 9759 13 nor nor CC 19613 9759 14 emotions emotion NNS 19613 9759 15 , , , 19613 9759 16 and and CC 19613 9759 17 only only RB 19613 9759 18 took take VBD 19613 9759 19 food food NN 19613 9759 20 in in IN 19613 9759 21 order order NN 19613 9759 22 to to TO 19613 9759 23 refute refute VB 19613 9759 24 the the DT 19613 9759 25 Docetists docetist NNS 19613 9759 26 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9759 27 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9759 28 . . . 19613 9760 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9760 2 . . . 19613 9761 1 9 9 CD 19613 9761 2 . . . 19613 9762 1 71 71 CD 19613 9762 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9762 3 . . . 19613 9763 1 As as IN 19613 9763 2 compared compare VBN 19613 9763 3 with with IN 19613 9763 4 this this DT 19613 9763 5 , , , 19613 9763 6 Docetism docetism NN 19613 9763 7 in in IN 19613 9763 8 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9763 9 's 's POS 19613 9763 10 case case NN 19613 9763 11 appears appear VBZ 19613 9763 12 throughout throughout IN 19613 9763 13 in in IN 19613 9763 14 a a DT 19613 9763 15 weakened weaken VBN 19613 9763 16 form form NN 19613 9763 17 ; ; : 19613 9763 18 see see VB 19613 9763 19 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9763 20 , , , 19613 9763 21 p. p. NN 19613 9764 1 191 191 CD 19613 9764 2 . . . 19613 9764 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9765 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9765 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9765 3 793 793 CD 19613 9765 4 : : : 19613 9765 5 See see VB 19613 9765 6 the the DT 19613 9765 7 full full JJ 19613 9765 8 exposition exposition NN 19613 9765 9 in in IN 19613 9765 10 Thomasius Thomasius NNP 19613 9765 11 , , , 19613 9765 12 Origenes Origenes NNP 19613 9765 13 , , , 19613 9765 14 p. p. NN 19613 9765 15 203 203 CD 19613 9765 16 ff ff NN 19613 9765 17 . . . 19613 9766 1 The the DT 19613 9766 2 principal principal JJ 19613 9766 3 passages passage NNS 19613 9766 4 referring refer VBG 19613 9766 5 to to IN 19613 9766 6 the the DT 19613 9766 7 soul soul NN 19613 9766 8 of of IN 19613 9766 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 9766 10 are be VBP 19613 9766 11 de de IN 19613 9766 12 princip princip NN 19613 9766 13 . . . 19613 9767 1 II ii CD 19613 9767 2 . . . 19613 9768 1 6 6 LS 19613 9768 2 : : : 19613 9768 3 IV IV NNP 19613 9768 4 . . . 19613 9769 1 31 31 CD 19613 9769 2 ; ; : 19613 9769 3 c. c. NN 19613 9769 4 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9769 5 . . . 19613 9770 1 II ii CD 19613 9770 2 . . . 19613 9771 1 9 9 CD 19613 9771 2 . . . 19613 9772 1 20 20 CD 19613 9772 2 - - SYM 19613 9772 3 25 25 CD 19613 9772 4 . . . 19613 9773 1 Socrates Socrates NNP 19613 9773 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9773 3 H. H. NNP 19613 9773 4 E. E. NNP 19613 9773 5 III III NNP 19613 9773 6 . . . 19613 9774 1 7 7 LS 19613 9774 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9774 3 says say VBZ 19613 9774 4 that that IN 19613 9774 5 the the DT 19613 9774 6 conviction conviction NN 19613 9774 7 as as IN 19613 9774 8 to to IN 19613 9774 9 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 9774 10 having have VBG 19613 9774 11 a a DT 19613 9774 12 human human JJ 19613 9774 13 soul soul NN 19613 9774 14 was be VBD 19613 9774 15 founded found VBN 19613 9774 16 on on IN 19613 9774 17 a a DT 19613 9774 18 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9774 19 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9774 20 : : : 19613 9774 21 mysticê mysticê NNP 19613 9774 22 paradosis paradosis NN 19613 9774 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9774 24 of of IN 19613 9774 25 the the DT 19613 9774 26 Church Church NNP 19613 9774 27 , , , 19613 9774 28 and and CC 19613 9774 29 was be VBD 19613 9774 30 not not RB 19613 9774 31 first first RB 19613 9774 32 broached broach VBN 19613 9774 33 by by IN 19613 9774 34 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9774 35 . . . 19613 9775 1 The the DT 19613 9775 2 special special JJ 19613 9775 3 problem problem NN 19613 9775 4 of of IN 19613 9775 5 conceiving conceive VBG 19613 9775 6 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9775 7 as as IN 19613 9775 8 a a DT 19613 9775 9 real real JJ 19613 9775 10 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9775 11 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9775 12 : : : 19613 9775 13 theanthrôpos theanthrôpos NN 19613 9775 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9775 15 in in IN 19613 9775 16 contradistinction contradistinction NN 19613 9775 17 to to IN 19613 9775 18 all all PDT 19613 9775 19 the the DT 19613 9775 20 men man NNS 19613 9775 21 who who WP 19613 9775 22 only only RB 19613 9775 23 possess possess VBP 19613 9775 24 the the DT 19613 9775 25 presence presence NN 19613 9775 26 of of IN 19613 9775 27 the the DT 19613 9775 28 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9775 29 within within IN 19613 9775 30 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9775 31 in in IN 19613 9775 32 proportion proportion NN 19613 9775 33 to to IN 19613 9775 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9775 35 merits merit NNS 19613 9775 36 , , , 19613 9775 37 was be VBD 19613 9775 38 precisely precisely RB 19613 9775 39 formulated formulate VBN 19613 9775 40 by by IN 19613 9775 41 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9775 42 on on IN 19613 9775 43 many many JJ 19613 9775 44 occasions occasion NNS 19613 9775 45 . . . 19613 9776 1 See see VB 19613 9776 2 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9776 3 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9776 4 : : : 19613 9776 5 peri peri NN 19613 9776 6 archôn archôn NN 19613 9776 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9776 8 IV IV NNP 19613 9776 9 . . . 19613 9777 1 29 29 CD 19613 9777 2 sq sq NN 19613 9777 3 . . . 19613 9778 1 The the DT 19613 9778 2 full full JJ 19613 9778 3 divine divine JJ 19613 9778 4 nature nature NN 19613 9778 5 existed exist VBD 19613 9778 6 in in IN 19613 9778 7 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9778 8 and and CC 19613 9778 9 yet yet RB 19613 9778 10 , , , 19613 9778 11 as as IN 19613 9778 12 before before RB 19613 9778 13 , , , 19613 9778 14 the the DT 19613 9778 15 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9778 16 operated operate VBD 19613 9778 17 wherever wherever WRB 19613 9778 18 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9778 19 wished wish VBD 19613 9778 20 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9778 21 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9778 22 . . NNP 19613 9778 23 , , , 19613 9778 24 30 30 CD 19613 9778 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9778 26 : : : 19613 9778 27 " " `` 19613 9778 28 non non NNP 19613 9778 29 ita ita NNP 19613 9778 30 sentiendum sentiendum NN 19613 9778 31 est est NNP 19613 9778 32 , , , 19613 9778 33 quod quod NNP 19613 9778 34 omnis omnis NNP 19613 9778 35 divinitatis divinitatis NNP 19613 9778 36 eius eius NNP 19613 9778 37 maiestas maiestas NNP 19613 9778 38 intra intra NNP 19613 9778 39 brevissimi brevissimi NNP 19613 9778 40 corporis corporis NNP 19613 9778 41 claustra claustra NNP 19613 9778 42 conclusa conclusa NNP 19613 9778 43 est est NNP 19613 9778 44 , , , 19613 9778 45 ita ita NNP 19613 9778 46 ut ut UH 19613 9778 47 omne omne NNP 19613 9778 48 verbum verbum NNP 19613 9778 49 dei dei NNP 19613 9778 50 et et NNP 19613 9778 51 sapientia sapientia NNP 19613 9778 52 eius eius NNP 19613 9778 53 ac ac NNP 19613 9778 54 substantialis substantialis NNP 19613 9778 55 veritas veritas NNP 19613 9778 56 ac ac NNP 19613 9778 57 vita vita NNP 19613 9778 58 vel vel NNP 19613 9778 59 a a DT 19613 9778 60 patre patre NNP 19613 9778 61 divulsa divulsa NNP 19613 9778 62 sit sit NNP 19613 9778 63 vel vel NNP 19613 9778 64 intra intra NNP 19613 9778 65 corporis corporis NNP 19613 9778 66 eius eius NNP 19613 9778 67 coercita coercita NNP 19613 9778 68 et et NNP 19613 9778 69 conscripta conscripta NNP 19613 9778 70 brevitatem brevitatem NNP 19613 9778 71 nec nec NNP 19613 9778 72 usquam usquam NNP 19613 9778 73 præterea præterea NNP 19613 9778 74 putetur putetur NNP 19613 9778 75 operata operata NNP 19613 9778 76 ; ; : 19613 9778 77 sed sed NNP 19613 9778 78 inter inter NNP 19613 9778 79 utrumque utrumque NNP 19613 9778 80 cauta cauta NNP 19613 9778 81 pietatis pietatis NN 19613 9778 82 debet debet NNP 19613 9778 83 esse esse NNP 19613 9778 84 confessio confessio NNP 19613 9778 85 , , , 19613 9778 86 ut ut FW 19613 9778 87 neque neque NNP 19613 9778 88 aliquid aliquid JJ 19613 9778 89 divinitatis divinitatis NN 19613 9778 90 in in IN 19613 9778 91 Christo Christo NNP 19613 9778 92 defuisse defuisse NN 19613 9778 93 credatur credatur NNP 19613 9778 94 et et NNP 19613 9778 95 nulla nulla NN 19613 9778 96 penitus penitus NNP 19613 9778 97 a a DT 19613 9778 98 paterna paterna NNP 19613 9778 99 substantia substantia NN 19613 9778 100 , , , 19613 9778 101 quæ quæ NNP 19613 9778 102 ubique ubique NNP 19613 9778 103 est est NNP 19613 9778 104 , , , 19613 9778 105 facta facta NNP 19613 9778 106 putetur putetur NNP 19613 9778 107 esse esse NNP 19613 9778 108 divisio divisio NNP 19613 9778 109 . . . 19613 9778 110 " " '' 19613 9779 1 On on IN 19613 9779 2 the the DT 19613 9779 3 perfect perfect JJ 19613 9779 4 ethical ethical JJ 19613 9779 5 union union NN 19613 9779 6 of of IN 19613 9779 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 19613 9779 8 ' ' POS 19613 9779 9 soul soul NN 19613 9779 10 with with IN 19613 9779 11 the the DT 19613 9779 12 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9779 13 see see VBP 19613 9779 14 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9779 15 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9779 16 : : : 19613 9779 17 peri peri NN 19613 9779 18 archôn archôn NN 19613 9779 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9779 20 II II NNP 19613 9779 21 . . . 19613 9780 1 6 6 CD 19613 9780 2 . . . 19613 9781 1 3 3 LS 19613 9781 2 : : : 19613 9781 3 " " `` 19613 9781 4 anima anima NNP 19613 9781 5 Iesu Iesu NNP 19613 9781 6 ab ab NNP 19613 9781 7 initio initio NNP 19613 9781 8 creaturæ creaturæ NNP 19613 9781 9 et et NNP 19613 9781 10 deinceps deinceps NNP 19613 9781 11 inseparabiliter inseparabiliter NNP 19613 9781 12 ei ei NNP 19613 9781 13 atque atque NNP 19613 9781 14 indissociabiliter indissociabiliter NNP 19613 9781 15 inhærens inhærens NNP 19613 9781 16 et et NNP 19613 9781 17 tota tota NNP 19613 9781 18 totum totum NNP 19613 9781 19 recipiens recipiens NNP 19613 9781 20 atque atque NNP 19613 9781 21 in in IN 19613 9781 22 eius eius NNP 19613 9781 23 lucem lucem NNP 19613 9781 24 splendoremque splendoremque NNP 19613 9781 25 ipsa ipsa NNP 19613 9781 26 cedens cedens NNP 19613 9781 27 facta facta NNP 19613 9781 28 est est NNP 19613 9781 29 cum cum NNP 19613 9781 30 ipso ipso NNP 19613 9781 31 principaliter principaliter NN 19613 9781 32 unus unus NNP 19613 9781 33 spiritus spiritus NN 19613 9781 34 ; ; : 19613 9781 35 " " `` 19613 9781 36 II ii CD 19613 9781 37 . . . 19613 9782 1 6 6 CD 19613 9782 2 . . . 19613 9783 1 5 5 CD 19613 9783 2 : : : 19613 9783 3 " " `` 19613 9783 4 anima anima NNP 19613 9783 5 Christi Christi NNP 19613 9783 6 ita ita NNP 19613 9783 7 elegit elegit NN 19613 9783 8 diligere diligere NNP 19613 9783 9 iustitiam iustitiam NNP 19613 9783 10 , , , 19613 9783 11 ut ut UH 19613 9783 12 pro pro FW 19613 9783 13 immensitate immensitate JJ 19613 9783 14 dilectionis dilectionis NNP 19613 9783 15 inconvertibiliter inconvertibiliter IN 19613 9783 16 ei ei NNP 19613 9783 17 atque atque NNP 19613 9783 18 inseparabiliter inseparabiliter NNP 19613 9783 19 inhæreret inhæreret NNP 19613 9783 20 , , , 19613 9783 21 ita ita NNP 19613 9783 22 ut ut UH 19613 9783 23 propositi propositi NNP 19613 9783 24 firmitas firmitas NNPS 19613 9783 25 et et NNP 19613 9783 26 affectus affectus NNP 19613 9783 27 immensitas immensitas NNP 19613 9783 28 et et NNP 19613 9783 29 dilectionis dilectionis NNP 19613 9783 30 inexstinguibilis inexstinguibilis NNP 19613 9783 31 calor calor NNP 19613 9783 32 omnem omnem NNP 19613 9783 33 sensum sensum NNP 19613 9783 34 conversionis conversionis NNP 19613 9783 35 atque atque NNP 19613 9783 36 immutationis immutationis NNP 19613 9783 37 abscinderet abscinderet NNP 19613 9783 38 , , , 19613 9783 39 et et NNP 19613 9783 40 quod quod NN 19613 9783 41 in in IN 19613 9783 42 arbitrio arbitrio NNP 19613 9783 43 erat erat NNP 19613 9783 44 positum positum NN 19613 9783 45 , , , 19613 9783 46 longi longi NNP 19613 9783 47 usus usus NNP 19613 9783 48 affectu affectu NNP 19613 9783 49 iam iam NNP 19613 9783 50 versum versum NNP 19613 9783 51 sit sit NNP 19613 9783 52 in in IN 19613 9783 53 naturam naturam NNP 19613 9783 54 . . . 19613 9783 55 " " '' 19613 9784 1 The the DT 19613 9784 2 sinlessness sinlessness NN 19613 9784 3 of of IN 19613 9784 4 this this DT 19613 9784 5 soul soul NN 19613 9784 6 thus thus RB 19613 9784 7 became become VBD 19613 9784 8 transformed transform VBN 19613 9784 9 from from IN 19613 9784 10 a a DT 19613 9784 11 fact fact NN 19613 9784 12 into into IN 19613 9784 13 a a DT 19613 9784 14 necessity necessity NN 19613 9784 15 , , , 19613 9784 16 and and CC 19613 9784 17 the the DT 19613 9784 18 real real JJ 19613 9784 19 God God NNP 19613 9784 20 - - HYPH 19613 9784 21 man man NNP 19613 9784 22 arose arise VBD 19613 9784 23 , , , 19613 9784 24 in in IN 19613 9784 25 whom whom WP 19613 9784 26 divinity divinity NN 19613 9784 27 and and CC 19613 9784 28 humanity humanity NN 19613 9784 29 are be VBP 19613 9784 30 no no RB 19613 9784 31 longer long RBR 19613 9784 32 separated separate VBN 19613 9784 33 . . . 19613 9785 1 The the DT 19613 9785 2 latter latter JJ 19613 9785 3 lies lie VBZ 19613 9785 4 in in IN 19613 9785 5 the the DT 19613 9785 6 former former JJ 19613 9785 7 as as IN 19613 9785 8 iron iron NN 19613 9785 9 in in IN 19613 9785 10 the the DT 19613 9785 11 fire fire NN 19613 9785 12 II ii CD 19613 9785 13 . . . 19613 9786 1 6 6 CD 19613 9786 2 . . . 19613 9787 1 6 6 CD 19613 9787 2 . . . 19613 9788 1 As as IN 19613 9788 2 the the DT 19613 9788 3 metal metal NN 19613 9788 4 _ _ NNP 19613 9788 5 capax capax NNP 19613 9788 6 est est NNP 19613 9788 7 frigoris frigoris NNP 19613 9788 8 et et NNP 19613 9788 9 caloris caloris NNP 19613 9788 10 _ _ NNP 19613 9788 11 so so IN 19613 9788 12 the the DT 19613 9788 13 soul soul NN 19613 9788 14 is be VBZ 19613 9788 15 capable capable JJ 19613 9788 16 of of IN 19613 9788 17 deification deification NN 19613 9788 18 . . . 19613 9789 1 " " `` 19613 9789 2 Omne omne JJ 19613 9789 3 quod quod NN 19613 9789 4 agit agit NN 19613 9789 5 , , , 19613 9789 6 quod quod NNP 19613 9789 7 sentit sentit NNP 19613 9789 8 , , , 19613 9789 9 quod quod NNP 19613 9789 10 intelligit intelligit NNP 19613 9789 11 , , , 19613 9789 12 deus deus NNP 19613 9789 13 est est NNP 19613 9789 14 , , , 19613 9789 15 " " '' 19613 9789 16 " " `` 19613 9789 17 nec nec NNP 19613 9789 18 convertibilis convertibilis NNP 19613 9789 19 aut aut NNP 19613 9789 20 mutabilis mutabilis NNP 19613 9789 21 dici dici VBD 19613 9789 22 potest potest NNP 19613 9789 23 " " '' 19613 9789 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9789 25 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9789 26 . . NNP 19613 9789 27 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9789 28 . . . 19613 9790 1 " " `` 19613 9790 2 Dilectionis Dilectionis NNP 19613 9790 3 merito merito NNP 19613 9790 4 anima anima NNP 19613 9790 5 Christi Christi NNP 19613 9790 6 cum cum NNP 19613 9790 7 verbo verbo NN 19613 9790 8 dei dei NNP 19613 9790 9 Christus Christus NNP 19613 9790 10 efficitur efficitur NN 19613 9790 11 . . . 19613 9790 12 " " '' 19613 9791 1 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9791 2 II ii CD 19613 9791 3 . . . 19613 9792 1 6 6 CD 19613 9792 2 . . . 19613 9793 1 4 4 LS 19613 9793 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9793 3 . . . 19613 9794 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9794 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9794 3 : : : 19613 9794 4 Tis Tis NNP 19613 9794 5 mallon mallon NN 19613 9794 6 tês tês NNP 19613 9794 7 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 9794 8 psychês psychês NNP 19613 9794 9 ê ê NNP 19613 9794 10 kan kan NNP 19613 9794 11 paraplêsiôs paraplêsiôs NNP 19613 9794 12 kekollêtai kekollêtai NNP 19613 9794 13 tô tô NNP 19613 9794 14 kyriô kyriô NNP 19613 9794 15 ; ; : 19613 9794 16 hoper hoper NNP 19613 9794 17 ei ei NNP 19613 9794 18 houtôs houtôs NNP 19613 9794 19 echei echei NNP 19613 9794 20 ouk ouk NNP 19613 9794 21 eisi eisi NNP 19613 9794 22 duo duo NNP 19613 9794 23 hê hê NNP 19613 9794 24 psychê psychê NNP 19613 9794 25 tou tou NNP 19613 9794 26 Iêsou Iêsou NNP 19613 9794 27 pros pro NNS 19613 9794 28 ton ton VBP 19613 9794 29 pasês pasês NNP 19613 9794 30 ktiseôs ktiseôs JJ 19613 9794 31 prôtotokon prôtotokon VB 19613 9794 32 Theon Theon NNP 19613 9794 33 logon logon NNP 19613 9794 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9794 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9794 36 c. c. NN 19613 9794 37 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9794 38 . . . 19613 9795 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9795 2 . . . 19613 9796 1 47 47 CD 19613 9796 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9796 3 . . . 19613 9797 1 The the DT 19613 9797 2 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 19613 9797 3 foundation foundation NN 19613 9797 4 of of IN 19613 9797 5 the the DT 19613 9797 6 union union NN 19613 9797 7 is be VBZ 19613 9797 8 set set VBN 19613 9797 9 forth forth RP 19613 9797 10 in in IN 19613 9797 11 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9797 12 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9797 13 : : : 19613 9797 14 peri peri NN 19613 9797 15 archôn archôn NN 19613 9797 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9797 17 II II NNP 19613 9797 18 . . . 19613 9798 1 6 6 CD 19613 9798 2 . . . 19613 9799 1 2 2 LS 19613 9799 2 : : : 19613 9799 3 " " `` 19613 9799 4 Substantia Substantia NNP 19613 9799 5 animæ animæ VBP 19613 9799 6 inter inter NNP 19613 9799 7 deum deum JJ 19613 9799 8 carnemque carnemque NNP 19613 9799 9 mediante mediante NNP 19613 9799 10 -- -- : 19613 9799 11 non non AFX 19613 9799 12 enim enim NNP 19613 9799 13 possibile possibile NNP 19613 9799 14 erat erat NNP 19613 9799 15 dei dei NNP 19613 9799 16 naturam naturam NNP 19613 9799 17 corpori corpori NNP 19613 9799 18 sine sine NNP 19613 9799 19 mediatore mediatore NNP 19613 9799 20 miscere miscere JJ 19613 9799 21 -- -- : 19613 9799 22 nascitur nascitur NNP 19613 9799 23 deus deus NNP 19613 9799 24 homo homo NNP 19613 9799 25 , , , 19613 9799 26 illa illa NNP 19613 9799 27 substantia substantia NNP 19613 9799 28 media media NNP 19613 9799 29 exsistente exsistente NNP 19613 9799 30 , , , 19613 9799 31 cui cui NNP 19613 9799 32 utique utique NNP 19613 9799 33 contra contra NNP 19613 9799 34 naturam naturam NNP 19613 9799 35 non non AFX 19613 9799 36 erat erat NNP 19613 9799 37 corpus corpus NNP 19613 9799 38 assumere assumere NNP 19613 9799 39 . . . 19613 9800 1 Sed Sed NNP 19613 9800 2 neque neque NNP 19613 9800 3 rursus rursus NNP 19613 9800 4 anima anima NNP 19613 9800 5 illa illa NNP 19613 9800 6 , , , 19613 9800 7 utpote utpote NNP 19613 9800 8 substantia substantia NNP 19613 9800 9 rationabilis rationabilis NNP 19613 9800 10 , , , 19613 9800 11 contra contra NNP 19613 9800 12 naturam naturam NNP 19613 9800 13 habuit habuit NNP 19613 9800 14 , , , 19613 9800 15 capere capere NNP 19613 9800 16 deum deum NN 19613 9800 17 . . . 19613 9800 18 " " '' 19613 9801 1 Even even RB 19613 9801 2 during during IN 19613 9801 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9801 4 historical historical JJ 19613 9801 5 life life NN 19613 9801 6 the the DT 19613 9801 7 body body NN 19613 9801 8 of of IN 19613 9801 9 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9801 10 was be VBD 19613 9801 11 ever ever RB 19613 9801 12 more more RBR 19613 9801 13 and and CC 19613 9801 14 more more RBR 19613 9801 15 glorified glorify VBN 19613 9801 16 , , , 19613 9801 17 acquired acquire VBD 19613 9801 18 therefore therefore RB 19613 9801 19 wonderful wonderful JJ 19613 9801 20 powers power NNS 19613 9801 21 , , , 19613 9801 22 and and CC 19613 9801 23 appeared appear VBD 19613 9801 24 differently differently RB 19613 9801 25 to to IN 19613 9801 26 men man NNS 19613 9801 27 according accord VBG 19613 9801 28 to to IN 19613 9801 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9801 30 several several JJ 19613 9801 31 capacities capacity NNS 19613 9801 32 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9801 33 that that DT 19613 9801 34 is be VBZ 19613 9801 35 a a DT 19613 9801 36 Valentinian valentinian JJ 19613 9801 37 idea idea NN 19613 9801 38 , , , 19613 9801 39 see see VB 19613 9801 40 Exc Exc NNP 19613 9801 41 . . . 19613 9802 1 ex ex NNP 19613 9802 2 Theod Theod NNP 19613 9802 3 . . . 19613 9803 1 7 7 LS 19613 9803 2 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9803 3 ; ; : 19613 9803 4 cf cf NN 19613 9803 5 . . . 19613 9804 1 c. c. NNP 19613 9804 2 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9804 3 . . . 19613 9805 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9806 1 32 32 CD 19613 9806 2 - - SYM 19613 9806 3 38 38 CD 19613 9806 4 : : : 19613 9806 5 II ii CD 19613 9806 6 . . . 19613 9807 1 23 23 CD 19613 9807 2 , , , 19613 9807 3 64 64 CD 19613 9807 4 : : : 19613 9807 5 IV IV NNP 19613 9807 6 . . . 19613 9808 1 15 15 CD 19613 9808 2 sq sq NN 19613 9808 3 . . . 19613 9809 1 : : : 19613 9809 2 V. V. NNP 19613 9809 3 8 8 CD 19613 9809 4 , , , 19613 9809 5 9 9 CD 19613 9809 6 , , , 19613 9809 7 23 23 CD 19613 9809 8 . . . 19613 9810 1 All all DT 19613 9810 2 this this DT 19613 9810 3 is be VBZ 19613 9810 4 summarised summarise VBN 19613 9810 5 in in IN 19613 9810 6 III III NNP 19613 9810 7 . . . 19613 9811 1 41 41 CD 19613 9811 2 : : : 19613 9811 3 " " `` 19613 9811 4 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9811 5 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9811 6 : : : 19613 9811 7 On on IN 19613 9811 8 men man NNS 19613 9811 9 nomizomen nomizomen VBZ 19613 9811 10 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 11 pepeismetha pepeismetha NNP 19613 9811 12 archêthen archêthen NNP 19613 9811 13 einai einai NNP 19613 9811 14 Theon Theon NNP 19613 9811 15 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 16 huion huion NN 19613 9811 17 Theou Theou NNP 19613 9811 18 , , , 19613 9811 19 outos outos NNP 19613 9811 20 ho ho NNP 19613 9811 21 autologos autologos NNP 19613 9811 22 esti esti NNP 19613 9811 23 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 24 hê hê NNP 19613 9811 25 autosophia autosophia NNP 19613 9811 26 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 27 hê hê NNP 19613 9811 28 autoalêtheia autoalêtheia NNP 19613 9811 29 to to IN 19613 9811 30 de de NNP 19613 9811 31 thnêton thnêton NNP 19613 9811 32 autou autou NNP 19613 9811 33 sôma sôma NNP 19613 9811 34 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 35 tên tên NNP 19613 9811 36 anthrôpinên anthrôpinên NNP 19613 9811 37 en en NNP 19613 9811 38 autô autô NN 19613 9811 39 psychên psychên NN 19613 9811 40 tê tê DT 19613 9811 41 pros pro NNS 19613 9811 42 ekeinon ekeinon VBP 19613 9811 43 ou ou NNP 19613 9811 44 monon monon NNP 19613 9811 45 koinônia koinônia NNP 19613 9811 46 , , , 19613 9811 47 alla alla NNP 19613 9811 48 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 49 henôsei henôsei NNP 19613 9811 50 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 51 anakrasei anakrasei NNP 19613 9811 52 , , , 19613 9811 53 ta ta NNP 19613 9811 54 megista megista NNP 19613 9811 55 phamen phaman NNS 19613 9811 56 proseilêphenai proseilêphenai NNP 19613 9811 57 kai kai NNP 19613 9811 58 tês tês NNP 19613 9811 59 ekeinou ekeinou NNP 19613 9811 60 thetêtos thetêtos NNP 19613 9811 61 kekoinônêkota kekoinônêkota NNP 19613 9811 62 eis eis NNP 19613 9811 63 Theon Theon NNP 19613 9811 64 metabebêkenai metabebêkenai NNP 19613 9811 65 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9811 66 . . . 19613 9811 67 " " '' 19613 9812 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9812 2 then then RB 19613 9812 3 continues continue VBZ 19613 9812 4 and and CC 19613 9812 5 appeals appeal NNS 19613 9812 6 to to IN 19613 9812 7 the the DT 19613 9812 8 philosophical philosophical JJ 19613 9812 9 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9812 10 that that DT 19613 9812 11 matter matter NN 19613 9812 12 has have VBZ 19613 9812 13 no no DT 19613 9812 14 qualities quality NNS 19613 9812 15 and and CC 19613 9812 16 can can MD 19613 9812 17 assume assume VB 19613 9812 18 all all PDT 19613 9812 19 the the DT 19613 9812 20 qualities quality NNS 19613 9812 21 which which WDT 19613 9812 22 the the DT 19613 9812 23 Creator Creator NNP 19613 9812 24 wishes wish VBZ 19613 9812 25 to to TO 19613 9812 26 give give VB 19613 9812 27 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9812 28 . . . 19613 9813 1 Then then RB 19613 9813 2 follows follow VBZ 19613 9813 3 the the DT 19613 9813 4 conclusion conclusion NN 19613 9813 5 : : : 19613 9813 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9813 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9813 8 : : : 19613 9813 9 ei ei NNP 19613 9813 10 hugiê hugiê NNP 19613 9813 11 ta ta NNP 19613 9813 12 toiauta toiauta NNP 19613 9813 13 , , , 19613 9813 14 ti ti NNP 19613 9813 15 thaumaston thaumaston NNP 19613 9813 16 , , , 19613 9813 17 tên tên NNP 19613 9813 18 poiotêta poiotêta NNP 19613 9813 19 tou tou NNP 19613 9813 20 thnêtou thnêtou NNP 19613 9813 21 kata kata NNP 19613 9813 22 ton ton NN 19613 9813 23 Iêsoun iêsoun JJ 19613 9813 24 sômatos sômato NNS 19613 9813 25 pronoia pronoia NN 19613 9813 26 Theou Theou NNP 19613 9813 27 boulêthentos boulêthento VBZ 19613 9813 28 metabalein metabalein NNP 19613 9813 29 eis eis NNP 19613 9813 30 aitherion aitherion NNP 19613 9813 31 kai kai NNP 19613 9813 32 theian theian NNP 19613 9813 33 poiotêta poiotêta NNP 19613 9813 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9813 35 ; ; : 19613 9813 36 The the DT 19613 9813 37 man man NN 19613 9813 38 is be VBZ 19613 9813 39 now now RB 19613 9813 40 the the DT 19613 9813 41 same same JJ 19613 9813 42 as as IN 19613 9813 43 the the DT 19613 9813 44 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9813 45 . . . 19613 9814 1 See see VB 19613 9814 2 in in IN 19613 9814 3 Joh Joh NNP 19613 9814 4 . . . 19613 9815 1 XXXII XXXII NNP 19613 9815 2 . . . 19613 9816 1 17 17 CD 19613 9816 2 , , , 19613 9816 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9816 4 . . . 19613 9817 1 II II NNP 19613 9817 2 . . NNP 19613 9817 3 , , , 19613 9817 4 p. p. NN 19613 9817 5 461 461 CD 19613 9817 6 sq sq NN 19613 9817 7 . . . 19613 9818 1 ; ; : 19613 9818 2 Hom Hom NNP 19613 9818 3 . . . 19613 9819 1 in in IN 19613 9819 2 Jerem Jerem NNP 19613 9819 3 . . . 19613 9820 1 XV XV NNP 19613 9820 2 . . . 19613 9821 1 6 6 LS 19613 9821 2 , , , 19613 9821 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9821 4 . . . 19613 9822 1 XV XV NNP 19613 9822 2 . . NNP 19613 9822 3 , , , 19613 9822 4 p. p. NN 19613 9822 5 288 288 CD 19613 9822 6 : : : 19613 9822 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9822 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9822 9 : : : 19613 9822 10 ei ei NNP 19613 9822 11 kai kai NNP 19613 9822 12 ên ên NNP 19613 9822 13 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 9822 14 , , , 19613 9822 15 alla alla NN 19613 9822 16 nun nun NNP 19613 9822 17 oudamôs oudamôs NNP 19613 9822 18 estin estin NNP 19613 9822 19 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 9822 20 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9822 21 . . . 19613 9822 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9823 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9823 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9823 3 794 794 CD 19613 9823 4 : : : 19613 9823 5 In in IN 19613 9823 6 c. c. NNP 19613 9823 7 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9823 8 . . . 19613 9824 1 III iii CD 19613 9824 2 . . . 19613 9825 1 28 28 CD 19613 9825 2 , , , 19613 9825 3 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9825 4 spoke speak VBD 19613 9825 5 of of IN 19613 9825 6 an an DT 19613 9825 7 intermingling intermingling NN 19613 9825 8 of of IN 19613 9825 9 the the DT 19613 9825 10 divine divine JJ 19613 9825 11 and and CC 19613 9825 12 human human JJ 19613 9825 13 natures nature NNS 19613 9825 14 , , , 19613 9825 15 commencing commence VBG 19613 9825 16 in in IN 19613 9825 17 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9825 18 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9825 19 see see VB 19613 9825 20 page page NN 19613 9825 21 368 368 CD 19613 9825 22 , , , 19613 9825 23 note note VB 19613 9825 24 1 1 CD 19613 9825 25 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9825 26 . . . 19613 9826 1 See see VB 19613 9826 2 I. i. NN 19613 9827 1 66 66 CD 19613 9827 2 fin fin NN 19613 9827 3 . . . 19613 9828 1 ; ; : 19613 9828 2 IV IV NNP 19613 9828 3 . . . 19613 9829 1 15 15 CD 19613 9829 2 , , , 19613 9829 3 where where WRB 19613 9829 4 any any DT 19613 9829 5 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9829 6 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9829 7 : : : 19613 9829 8 allattesthai allattesthai NNP 19613 9829 9 kai kai NNP 19613 9829 10 metaplattesthai metaplattesthai NNP 19613 9829 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9829 12 of of IN 19613 9829 13 the the DT 19613 9829 14 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9829 15 is be VBZ 19613 9829 16 decidedly decidedly RB 19613 9829 17 rejected reject VBN 19613 9829 18 ; ; : 19613 9829 19 for for IN 19613 9829 20 the the DT 19613 9829 21 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9829 22 does do VBZ 19613 9829 23 not not RB 19613 9829 24 suffer suffer VB 19613 9829 25 at at RB 19613 9829 26 all all RB 19613 9829 27 . . . 19613 9830 1 In in IN 19613 9830 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9830 3 's 's POS 19613 9830 4 case case NN 19613 9830 5 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9830 6 may may MD 19613 9830 7 speak speak VB 19613 9830 8 of of IN 19613 9830 9 a a DT 19613 9830 10 _ _ NNP 19613 9830 11 communicatio communicatio VBG 19613 9830 12 idiomatum idiomatum JJ 19613 9830 13 _ _ NNP 19613 9830 14 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9830 15 see see VB 19613 9830 16 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9830 17 , , , 19613 9830 18 p. p. NN 19613 9830 19 190 190 CD 19613 9830 20 f. f. NNS 19613 9830 21 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9830 22 . . . 19613 9830 23 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9831 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9831 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9831 3 795 795 CD 19613 9831 4 : : : 19613 9831 5 In in IN 19613 9831 6 opposition opposition NN 19613 9831 7 to to IN 19613 9831 8 Redepenning Redepenning NNP 19613 9831 9 . . . 19613 9831 10 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9832 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9832 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9832 3 796 796 CD 19613 9832 4 : : : 19613 9832 5 This this DT 19613 9832 6 idea idea NN 19613 9832 7 is be VBZ 19613 9832 8 found find VBN 19613 9832 9 in in IN 19613 9832 10 many many JJ 19613 9832 11 passages passage NNS 19613 9832 12 , , , 19613 9832 13 especial especial JJ 19613 9832 14 in in IN 19613 9832 15 Book Book NNP 19613 9832 16 III III NNP 19613 9832 17 , , , 19613 9832 18 c. c. NNP 19613 9832 19 22 22 CD 19613 9832 20 - - SYM 19613 9832 21 43 43 CD 19613 9832 22 , , , 19613 9832 23 where where WRB 19613 9832 24 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9832 25 , , , 19613 9832 26 in in IN 19613 9832 27 opposition opposition NN 19613 9832 28 to to IN 19613 9832 29 the the DT 19613 9832 30 fables fable NNS 19613 9832 31 about about IN 19613 9832 32 deification deification NN 19613 9832 33 , , , 19613 9832 34 sought seek VBD 19613 9832 35 to to TO 19613 9832 36 prove prove VB 19613 9832 37 that that IN 19613 9832 38 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9832 39 is be VBZ 19613 9832 40 divine divine JJ 19613 9832 41 because because IN 19613 9832 42 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9832 43 realised realise VBD 19613 9832 44 the the DT 19613 9832 45 aim aim NN 19613 9832 46 of of IN 19613 9832 47 founding found VBG 19613 9832 48 a a DT 19613 9832 49 holy holy JJ 19613 9832 50 community community NN 19613 9832 51 in in IN 19613 9832 52 humanity humanity NN 19613 9832 53 . . . 19613 9833 1 See see VB 19613 9833 2 , , , 19613 9833 3 besides besides RB 19613 9833 4 , , , 19613 9833 5 the the DT 19613 9833 6 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 9833 7 statement statement NN 19613 9833 8 in in IN 19613 9833 9 III III NNP 19613 9833 10 . . . 19613 9834 1 38 38 CD 19613 9834 2 init init NN 19613 9834 3 . . . 19613 9834 4 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9835 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9835 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9835 3 797 797 CD 19613 9835 4 : : : 19613 9835 5 A a DT 19613 9835 6 very very RB 19613 9835 7 remarkable remarkable JJ 19613 9835 8 distinction distinction NN 19613 9835 9 between between IN 19613 9835 10 the the DT 19613 9835 11 divine divine JJ 19613 9835 12 and and CC 19613 9835 13 human human JJ 19613 9835 14 element element NN 19613 9835 15 in in IN 19613 9835 16 Christ Christ NNP 19613 9835 17 is be VBZ 19613 9835 18 found find VBN 19613 9835 19 in in IN 19613 9835 20 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9835 21 Pæd Pæd NNP 19613 9835 22 . . . 19613 9836 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9837 1 3 3 LS 19613 9837 2 . . . 19613 9838 1 7 7 LS 19613 9838 2 : : : 19613 9838 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9838 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9838 5 : : : 19613 9838 6 panta panta NNP 19613 9838 7 oninêsin oninêsin NNP 19613 9838 8 ho ho NNP 19613 9838 9 kurios kurio VBZ 19613 9838 10 kai kai NNP 19613 9838 11 panta panta NNP 19613 9838 12 ôphelei ôphelei NNP 19613 9838 13 kai kai NNP 19613 9838 14 hôs hôs NNP 19613 9838 15 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 9838 16 kai kai NNP 19613 9838 17 hôs hôs NNP 19613 9838 18 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9838 19 , , , 19613 9838 20 ta ta NNP 19613 9838 21 men man NNS 19613 9838 22 hamartêmata hamartêmata NNP 19613 9838 23 hôs hôs NNP 19613 9838 24 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9838 25 aphieis aphieis NNP 19613 9838 26 , , , 19613 9838 27 eis eis NNP 19613 9838 28 de de NNP 19613 9838 29 to to NNP 19613 9838 30 mê mê NNP 19613 9838 31 examartanein examartanein NNP 19613 9838 32 paidagôgôn paidagôgôn NNP 19613 9838 33 hôs hôs NNP 19613 9838 34 anthrôpos anthrôpos NNP 19613 9838 35 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9838 36 . . . 19613 9838 37 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9839 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9839 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9839 3 798 798 CD 19613 9839 4 : : : 19613 9839 5 " " `` 19613 9839 6 Fides fide NNS 19613 9839 7 in in IN 19613 9839 8 nobis nobis NNP 19613 9839 9 ; ; : 19613 9839 10 mensura mensura NNP 19613 9839 11 fidei fidei NNP 19613 9839 12 causa causa NNP 19613 9839 13 accipiendarum accipiendarum NNP 19613 9839 14 gratiarum gratiarum NNP 19613 9839 15 " " '' 19613 9839 16 is be VBZ 19613 9839 17 the the DT 19613 9839 18 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 9839 19 idea idea NN 19613 9839 20 of of IN 19613 9839 21 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9839 22 and and CC 19613 9839 23 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9839 24 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9839 25 as as IN 19613 9839 26 of of IN 19613 9839 27 Justin Justin NNP 19613 9839 28 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9839 29 ; ; : 19613 9839 30 " " `` 19613 9839 31 voluntas voluntas NNP 19613 9839 32 humana humana NNP 19613 9839 33 præcedit præcedit FW 19613 9839 34 " " '' 19613 9839 35 . . . 19613 9840 1 In in IN 19613 9840 2 Ezech Ezech NNP 19613 9840 3 . . . 19613 9841 1 hom hom NNP 19613 9841 2 . . . 19613 9842 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9842 2 c. c. NNP 19613 9842 3 II II NNP 19613 9842 4 : : : 19613 9842 5 " " `` 19613 9842 6 In in IN 19613 9842 7 tua tua NNP 19613 9842 8 potestate potestate JJ 19613 9842 9 positum positum NN 19613 9842 10 est est NNP 19613 9842 11 , , , 19613 9842 12 ut ut UH 19613 9842 13 sis sis NNP 19613 9842 14 palea palea NNP 19613 9842 15 vel vel NNP 19613 9842 16 frumentum frumentum NNP 19613 9842 17 " " '' 19613 9842 18 . . . 19613 9843 1 But but CC 19613 9843 2 all all DT 19613 9843 3 growth growth NN 19613 9843 4 in in IN 19613 9843 5 faith faith NN 19613 9843 6 must must MD 19613 9843 7 depend depend VB 19613 9843 8 on on IN 19613 9843 9 divine divine JJ 19613 9843 10 help help NN 19613 9843 11 . . . 19613 9844 1 See see VB 19613 9844 2 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9844 3 . . . 19613 9845 1 in in IN 19613 9845 2 Matth Matth NNP 19613 9845 3 . . . 19613 9846 1 series series NNP 19613 9846 2 69 69 CD 19613 9846 3 , , , 19613 9846 4 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9846 5 . . . 19613 9847 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9847 2 . . NNP 19613 9847 3 , , , 19613 9847 4 p. p. NN 19613 9847 5 372 372 CD 19613 9847 6 : : : 19613 9847 7 " " `` 19613 9847 8 Fidem Fidem NNP 19613 9847 9 habenti habenti NN 19613 9847 10 , , , 19613 9847 11 quæ quæ NNP 19613 9847 12 est est NNP 19613 9847 13 ex ex NNP 19613 9847 14 nobis nobis NNP 19613 9847 15 , , , 19613 9847 16 dabitur dabitur NNP 19613 9847 17 gratia gratia NNP 19613 9847 18 fidei fidei NNP 19613 9847 19 quæ quæ NNP 19613 9847 20 est est NNP 19613 9847 21 per per IN 19613 9847 22 spiritum spiritum NN 19613 9847 23 fidei fidei NNP 19613 9847 24 , , , 19613 9847 25 et et FW 19613 9847 26 abundabit abundabit NN 19613 9847 27 ; ; : 19613 9847 28 et et NNP 19613 9847 29 quidquid quidquid NNP 19613 9847 30 habuerit habuerit NNP 19613 9847 31 quis quis NNP 19613 9847 32 ex ex NNP 19613 9847 33 naturali naturali NNP 19613 9847 34 creatione creatione NNP 19613 9847 35 , , , 19613 9847 36 cum cum NNP 19613 9847 37 exercuerit exercuerit NNP 19613 9847 38 illud illud NNP 19613 9847 39 , , , 19613 9847 40 accipit accipit NNP 19613 9847 41 i -PRON- PRP 19613 9847 42 d d NNP 19613 9847 43 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 9847 44 et et NNP 19613 9847 45 ex ex NNP 19613 9847 46 gratia gratia NNP 19613 9847 47 dei dei NNP 19613 9847 48 , , , 19613 9847 49 ut ut FW 19613 9847 50 abundet abundet NNP 19613 9847 51 et et NNP 19613 9847 52 firmior firmior NNP 19613 9847 53 sit sit NNP 19613 9847 54 in in IN 19613 9847 55 eo eo NNP 19613 9847 56 ipso ipso NNP 19613 9847 57 quod quod NNP 19613 9847 58 habet habet NNP 19613 9847 59 " " '' 19613 9847 60 ; ; : 19613 9847 61 in in IN 19613 9847 62 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9847 63 . . . 19613 9848 1 IV IV NNP 19613 9848 2 . . . 19613 9849 1 5 5 LS 19613 9849 2 , , , 19613 9849 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9849 4 . . . 19613 9850 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9850 2 . . NNP 19613 9850 3 , , , 19613 9850 4 p. p. NN 19613 9850 5 258 258 CD 19613 9850 6 sq sq NN 19613 9850 7 . . . 19613 9851 1 ; ; : 19613 9851 2 in in IN 19613 9851 3 Rom Rom NNP 19613 9851 4 . . . 19613 9852 1 IX ix NN 19613 9852 2 . . . 19613 9853 1 3 3 LS 19613 9853 2 , , , 19613 9853 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9853 4 VII VII NNP 19613 9853 5 . . NNP 19613 9853 6 , , , 19613 9853 7 p. p. NN 19613 9853 8 300 300 CD 19613 9853 9 sq sq NN 19613 9853 10 . . . 19613 9854 1 The the DT 19613 9854 2 fundamental fundamental JJ 19613 9854 3 idea idea NN 19613 9854 4 remains remain VBZ 19613 9854 5 : : : 19613 9854 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9854 7 Greek greek NN 19613 9854 8 : : : 19613 9854 9 ho ho NNP 19613 9854 10 Theos Theos NNP 19613 9854 11 hêmas hêmas NNP 19613 9854 12 ex ex NNP 19613 9854 13 hêmôn hêmôn NNP 19613 9854 14 autôn autôn NNP 19613 9854 15 bouletai bouletai NNP 19613 9854 16 sôzesthai sôzesthai NNP 19613 9854 17 . . . 19613 9854 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9854 19 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9855 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9855 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9855 3 799 799 CD 19613 9855 4 : : : 19613 9855 5 This this DT 19613 9855 6 is be VBZ 19613 9855 7 frequent frequent JJ 19613 9855 8 in in IN 19613 9855 9 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9855 10 ; ; : 19613 9855 11 see see VB 19613 9855 12 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9855 13 . . . 19613 9856 1 c. c. NNP 19613 9856 2 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9856 3 . . . 19613 9857 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9857 2 . . . 19613 9858 1 46 46 CD 19613 9858 2 . . . 19613 9858 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9859 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9859 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9859 3 800 800 CD 19613 9859 4 : : : 19613 9859 5 See see VB 19613 9859 6 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9859 7 , , , 19613 9859 8 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9859 9 . . . 19613 9860 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9860 2 I. I. NNP 19613 9861 1 7 7 LS 19613 9861 2 : : : 19613 9861 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9861 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9861 5 : : : 19613 9861 6 chariti chariti NNP 19613 9861 7 sôzometha sôzometha NN 19613 9861 8 , , , 19613 9861 9 ouk ouk NNP 19613 9861 10 aneu aneu NNP 19613 9861 11 mentoi mentoi NNP 19613 9861 12 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9861 13 kalôn kalôn NNP 19613 9861 14 ergôn ergôn NNP 19613 9861 15 . . . 19613 9861 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9861 17 . . . 19613 9862 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9862 2 . . . 19613 9863 1 7 7 LS 19613 9863 2 . . . 19613 9864 1 48 48 CD 19613 9864 2 : : : 19613 9864 3 V. v. NN 19613 9864 4 12 12 CD 19613 9864 5 . . . 19613 9865 1 82 82 CD 19613 9865 2 , , , 19613 9865 3 13 13 CD 19613 9865 4 . . . 19613 9866 1 83 83 CD 19613 9866 2 : : : 19613 9866 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9866 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9866 5 : : : 19613 9866 6 eite eite JJ 19613 9866 7 to to TO 19613 9866 8 en en IN 19613 9866 9 hêmin hêmin NNP 19613 9866 10 autexousiou autexousiou NNP 19613 9866 11 eis eis NNP 19613 9866 12 gnôsin gnôsin NNP 19613 9866 13 aphikomenon aphikomenon NNP 19613 9866 14 tagathou tagathou NNP 19613 9866 15 skirta skirta NNP 19613 9866 16 te te NNP 19613 9866 17 kai kai NNP 19613 9866 18 pêda pêda NNP 19613 9866 19 huper huper NNP 19613 9866 20 ta ta NNP 19613 9866 21 eskammena eskammena NNP 19613 9866 22 , , , 19613 9866 23 plên plên NNP 19613 9866 24 ou ou NNP 19613 9866 25 charitos charitos NNP 19613 9866 26 aneu aneu NNP 19613 9866 27 tês tês NNP 19613 9866 28 exairetou exairetou NNP 19613 9866 29 pteroutai pteroutai NNP 19613 9866 30 te te NNP 19613 9866 31 kai kai NNP 19613 9866 32 anistatai anistatai NNP 19613 9866 33 kai kai NNP 19613 9866 34 anô anô NNP 19613 9866 35 tôn tôn NNP 19613 9866 36 huperkeimenôn huperkeimenôn NNP 19613 9866 37 airetai airetai NNP 19613 9866 38 hê hê NNP 19613 9866 39 psychê psychê NNP 19613 9866 40 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9866 41 ; ; : 19613 9866 42 The the DT 19613 9866 43 amalgamation amalgamation NN 19613 9866 44 of of IN 19613 9866 45 freedom freedom NN 19613 9866 46 and and CC 19613 9866 47 grace grace NN 19613 9866 48 . . . 19613 9867 1 Quis Quis NNP 19613 9867 2 cliv cliv NNP 19613 9867 3 . . . 19613 9868 1 salv salv NNP 19613 9868 2 . . . 19613 9869 1 21 21 CD 19613 9869 2 . . . 19613 9870 1 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9870 2 . . . 19613 9871 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9871 2 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9871 3 : : : 19613 9871 4 peri peri NN 19613 9871 5 archôn archôn NN 19613 9871 6 . . . 19613 9871 7 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9872 1 III iii CD 19613 9872 2 . . . 19613 9873 1 2 2 LS 19613 9873 2 . . . 19613 9874 1 2 2 LS 19613 9874 2 : : : 19613 9874 3 In in IN 19613 9874 4 bonis bonis NNP 19613 9874 5 rebus rebus NNP 19613 9874 6 humanum humanum NNP 19613 9874 7 propositum propositum NNP 19613 9874 8 solum solum NNP 19613 9874 9 per per FW 19613 9874 10 se se FW 19613 9874 11 ipsum ipsum NNP 19613 9874 12 imperfectum imperfectum NNP 19613 9874 13 est est NNP 19613 9874 14 ad ad NNP 19613 9874 15 consummationem consummationem NNP 19613 9874 16 boni boni NNP 19613 9874 17 , , , 19613 9874 18 adiutorio adiutorio NNP 19613 9874 19 namque namque NNP 19613 9874 20 divino divino NNP 19613 9874 21 ad ad NNP 19613 9874 22 perfecta perfecta NN 19613 9874 23 quæque quæque NN 19613 9874 24 peracitur peracitur RB 19613 9874 25 . . . 19613 9875 1 III iii CD 19613 9875 2 . . . 19613 9876 1 2 2 LS 19613 9876 2 . . . 19613 9877 1 5 5 CD 19613 9877 2 , , , 19613 9877 3 I. I. NNP 19613 9878 1 18 18 CD 19613 9878 2 ; ; : 19613 9878 3 Selecta Selecta NNP 19613 9878 4 in in IN 19613 9878 5 Ps Ps NNP 19613 9878 6 . . . 19613 9879 1 4 4 LS 19613 9879 2 , , , 19613 9879 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9879 4 . . . 19613 9880 1 XI XI NNP 19613 9880 2 . . NNP 19613 9880 3 , , , 19613 9880 4 p. p. NN 19613 9880 5 450 450 CD 19613 9880 6 : : : 19613 9880 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9880 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9880 9 : : : 19613 9880 10 to to IN 19613 9880 11 tou tou NNP 19613 9880 12 logikou logikou NNP 19613 9880 13 agathon agathon NNP 19613 9880 14 mikton mikton NNP 19613 9880 15 estin estin NNP 19613 9880 16 ek ek NNP 19613 9880 17 te te NNP 19613 9880 18 tês tês NNP 19613 9880 19 proaireseôs proaireseôs NNP 19613 9880 20 autou autou NNP 19613 9880 21 kai kai NNP 19613 9880 22 tês tês NNP 19613 9880 23 sumpneousês sumpneousês NNP 19613 9880 24 theias theias NNP 19613 9880 25 dunameôs dunameôs NNP 19613 9880 26 tô tô NNP 19613 9880 27 ta ta NNP 19613 9880 28 allista allista NNP 19613 9880 29 proelomenô proelomenô NNP 19613 9880 30 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9880 31 . . . 19613 9881 1 The the DT 19613 9881 2 support support NN 19613 9881 3 of of IN 19613 9881 4 grace grace NN 19613 9881 5 is be VBZ 19613 9881 6 invariably invariably RB 19613 9881 7 conceived conceive VBN 19613 9881 8 as as IN 19613 9881 9 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 9881 10 ; ; : 19613 9881 11 but but CC 19613 9881 12 this this DT 19613 9881 13 enlightenment enlightenment NN 19613 9881 14 enables enable VBZ 19613 9881 15 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9881 16 to to TO 19613 9881 17 act act VB 19613 9881 18 on on IN 19613 9881 19 the the DT 19613 9881 20 whole whole JJ 19613 9881 21 life life NN 19613 9881 22 . . . 19613 9882 1 For for IN 19613 9882 2 a a DT 19613 9882 3 more more RBR 19613 9882 4 detailed detailed JJ 19613 9882 5 account account NN 19613 9882 6 see see VBP 19613 9882 7 Landerer Landerer NNP 19613 9882 8 in in IN 19613 9882 9 the the DT 19613 9882 10 Jahrbucher Jahrbucher NNP 19613 9882 11 fur fur NN 19613 9882 12 deutsche deutsche NN 19613 9882 13 Theologie Theologie NNP 19613 9882 14 , , , 19613 9882 15 Vol Vol NNP 19613 9882 16 . . . 19613 9883 1 II II NNP 19613 9883 2 , , , 19613 9883 3 Part Part NNP 19613 9883 4 3 3 CD 19613 9883 5 , , , 19613 9883 6 p. p. NN 19613 9883 7 500 500 CD 19613 9883 8 ff ff NNP 19613 9883 9 . . NNP 19613 9883 10 , , , 19613 9883 11 and and CC 19613 9883 12 Worter Worter NNP 19613 9883 13 , , , 19613 9883 14 _ _ NNP 19613 9883 15 Die Die NNP 19613 9883 16 christliche christliche NN 19613 9883 17 Lehre Lehre NNP 19613 9883 18 von von NNP 19613 9883 19 Gnade Gnade NNP 19613 9883 20 und und VB 19613 9883 21 Freiheit Freiheit NNP 19613 9883 22 bis bi VBD 19613 9883 23 auf auf NNP 19613 9883 24 Augustin Augustin NNP 19613 9883 25 _ _ NNP 19613 9883 26 , , , 19613 9883 27 1860 1860 CD 19613 9883 28 . . . 19613 9883 29 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9884 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9884 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9884 3 801 801 CD 19613 9884 4 : : : 19613 9884 5 This this DT 19613 9884 6 goal goal NN 19613 9884 7 was be VBD 19613 9884 8 much much RB 19613 9884 9 more more RBR 19613 9884 10 clearly clearly RB 19613 9884 11 described describe VBN 19613 9884 12 by by IN 19613 9884 13 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9884 14 than than IN 19613 9884 15 by by IN 19613 9884 16 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9884 17 ; ; : 19613 9884 18 but but CC 19613 9884 19 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9884 20 was be VBD 19613 9884 21 the the DT 19613 9884 22 latter latter JJ 19613 9884 23 who who WP 19613 9884 24 , , , 19613 9884 25 in in IN 19613 9884 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9884 27 commentary commentary NN 19613 9884 28 on on IN 19613 9884 29 the the DT 19613 9884 30 Song Song NNP 19613 9884 31 of of IN 19613 9884 32 Solomon Solomon NNP 19613 9884 33 , , , 19613 9884 34 gave give VBD 19613 9884 35 currency currency NN 19613 9884 36 to to IN 19613 9884 37 the the DT 19613 9884 38 image image NN 19613 9884 39 of of IN 19613 9884 40 the the DT 19613 9884 41 soul soul NN 19613 9884 42 as as IN 19613 9884 43 the the DT 19613 9884 44 bride bride NN 19613 9884 45 of of IN 19613 9884 46 the the DT 19613 9884 47 Logos Logos NNP 19613 9884 48 . . . 19613 9885 1 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9885 2 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9885 3 p. p. NN 19613 9885 4 188 188 CD 19613 9885 5 f. f. NNP 19613 9885 6 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9885 7 : : : 19613 9885 8 " " `` 19613 9885 9 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9885 10 , , , 19613 9885 11 the the DT 19613 9885 12 first first JJ 19613 9885 13 pioneer pioneer NN 19613 9885 14 in in IN 19613 9885 15 so so RB 19613 9885 16 many many JJ 19613 9885 17 fields field NNS 19613 9885 18 of of IN 19613 9885 19 Christian christian JJ 19613 9885 20 thought thought NN 19613 9885 21 , , , 19613 9885 22 the the DT 19613 9885 23 father father NN 19613 9885 24 in in IN 19613 9885 25 one one CD 19613 9885 26 of of IN 19613 9885 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9885 28 many many JJ 19613 9885 29 aspects aspect NNS 19613 9885 30 of of IN 19613 9885 31 the the DT 19613 9885 32 English English NNP 19613 9885 33 Latitudinarians Latitudinarians NNPS 19613 9885 34 , , , 19613 9885 35 became become VBD 19613 9885 36 also also RB 19613 9885 37 the the DT 19613 9885 38 spiritual spiritual JJ 19613 9885 39 ancestor ancestor NN 19613 9885 40 of of IN 19613 9885 41 Bernard Bernard NNP 19613 9885 42 , , , 19613 9885 43 the the DT 19613 9885 44 Victorines Victorines NNPS 19613 9885 45 , , , 19613 9885 46 and and CC 19613 9885 47 the the DT 19613 9885 48 author author NN 19613 9885 49 of of IN 19613 9885 50 the the DT 19613 9885 51 ' ' `` 19613 9885 52 De De NNP 19613 9885 53 imitatione imitatione NNP 19613 9885 54 , , , 19613 9885 55 ' ' '' 19613 9885 56 of of IN 19613 9885 57 Tauler Tauler NNP 19613 9885 58 and and CC 19613 9885 59 Molinos Molinos NNP 19613 9885 60 and and CC 19613 9885 61 Madame Madame NNP 19613 9885 62 de de NNP 19613 9885 63 Guyon Guyon NNP 19613 9885 64 . . . 19613 9885 65 " " '' 19613 9885 66 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9886 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9886 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9886 3 802 802 CD 19613 9886 4 : : : 19613 9886 5 See see VB 19613 9886 6 Thomasius Thomasius NNP 19613 9886 7 , , , 19613 9886 8 Dogmengeschichte Dogmengeschichte NNP 19613 9886 9 I. I. NNP 19613 9886 10 , , , 19613 9886 11 p. p. NN 19613 9887 1 467 467 CD 19613 9887 2 . . . 19613 9887 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9888 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9888 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9888 3 803 803 CD 19613 9888 4 : : : 19613 9888 5 See see VB 19613 9888 6 e.g. e.g. RB 19613 9888 7 , , , 19613 9888 8 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9888 9 . . . 19613 9889 1 Quis Quis NNP 19613 9889 2 dives dive VBZ 19613 9889 3 salv salv JJ 19613 9889 4 . . . 19613 9890 1 37 37 CD 19613 9890 2 and and CC 19613 9890 3 especially especially RB 19613 9890 4 Pædag Pædag NNP 19613 9890 5 . . . 19613 9891 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9892 1 6 6 CD 19613 9892 2 . . . 19613 9893 1 25 25 CD 19613 9893 2 - - SYM 19613 9893 3 32 32 CD 19613 9893 4 ; ; : 19613 9893 5 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9893 6 . . . 19613 9894 1 de de NNP 19613 9894 2 orat orat NNP 19613 9894 3 . . . 19613 9895 1 22 22 CD 19613 9895 2 sq.--the sq.--the DT 19613 9895 3 interpretation interpretation NN 19613 9895 4 of of IN 19613 9895 5 the the DT 19613 9895 6 Lord Lord NNP 19613 9895 7 's 's POS 19613 9895 8 Prayer prayer NN 19613 9895 9 . . . 19613 9896 1 This this DT 19613 9896 2 exegesis exegesis NN 19613 9896 3 begins begin VBZ 19613 9896 4 with with IN 19613 9896 5 the the DT 19613 9896 6 words word NNS 19613 9896 7 : : : 19613 9896 8 " " `` 19613 9896 9 It -PRON- PRP 19613 9896 10 would would MD 19613 9896 11 be be VB 19613 9896 12 worth worth JJ 19613 9896 13 while while IN 19613 9896 14 to to TO 19613 9896 15 examine examine VB 19613 9896 16 more more RBR 19613 9896 17 carefully carefully RB 19613 9896 18 whether whether IN 19613 9896 19 the the DT 19613 9896 20 so so RB 19613 9896 21 - - HYPH 19613 9896 22 called call VBN 19613 9896 23 Old Old NNP 19613 9896 24 Testament Testament NNP 19613 9896 25 anywhere anywhere RB 19613 9896 26 contains contain VBZ 19613 9896 27 a a DT 19613 9896 28 prayer prayer NN 19613 9896 29 in in IN 19613 9896 30 which which WDT 19613 9896 31 God God NNP 19613 9896 32 is be VBZ 19613 9896 33 called call VBN 19613 9896 34 Father Father NNP 19613 9896 35 by by IN 19613 9896 36 anyone anyone NN 19613 9896 37 ; ; : 19613 9896 38 for for IN 19613 9896 39 till till IN 19613 9896 40 now now RB 19613 9896 41 we -PRON- PRP 19613 9896 42 have have VBP 19613 9896 43 found find VBN 19613 9896 44 none none NN 19613 9896 45 in in IN 19613 9896 46 spite spite NN 19613 9896 47 of of IN 19613 9896 48 all all DT 19613 9896 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 19613 9896 50 seeking seeking NN 19613 9896 51 ... ... . 19613 9897 1 Constant constant JJ 19613 9897 2 and and CC 19613 9897 3 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 19613 9897 4 sonship sonship NN 19613 9897 5 is be VBZ 19613 9897 6 first first RB 19613 9897 7 given give VBN 19613 9897 8 in in IN 19613 9897 9 the the DT 19613 9897 10 new new JJ 19613 9897 11 covenant covenant NN 19613 9897 12 . . . 19613 9897 13 " " '' 19613 9897 14 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9898 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9898 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9898 3 804 804 CD 19613 9898 4 : : : 19613 9898 5 See see VB 19613 9898 6 above above RB 19613 9898 7 , , , 19613 9898 8 p. p. NN 19613 9898 9 339 339 CD 19613 9898 10 f. f. NN 19613 9898 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9898 12 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9898 13 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9898 14 805 805 CD 19613 9898 15 : : : 19613 9898 16 See see VB 19613 9898 17 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9898 18 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9898 19 : : : 19613 9898 20 peri peri NN 19613 9898 21 archôn archôn NN 19613 9898 22 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9898 23 II II NNP 19613 9898 24 . . . 19613 9899 1 11 11 CD 19613 9899 2 . . . 19613 9899 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9900 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9900 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9900 3 806 806 CD 19613 9900 4 : : : 19613 9900 5 See see VB 19613 9900 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9900 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9900 8 : : : 19613 9900 9 peri peri NN 19613 9900 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9900 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9900 12 II II NNP 19613 9900 13 . . . 19613 9901 1 10 10 CD 19613 9901 2 . . . 19613 9902 1 1 1 CD 19613 9902 2 - - SYM 19613 9902 3 3 3 CD 19613 9902 4 . . . 19613 9903 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9903 2 wrote write VBD 19613 9903 3 a a DT 19613 9903 4 treatise treatise NN 19613 9903 5 on on IN 19613 9903 6 the the DT 19613 9903 7 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 9903 8 , , , 19613 9903 9 which which WDT 19613 9903 10 , , , 19613 9903 11 however however RB 19613 9903 12 , , , 19613 9903 13 has have VBZ 19613 9903 14 not not RB 19613 9903 15 come come VBN 19613 9903 16 down down RP 19613 9903 17 to to IN 19613 9903 18 us -PRON- PRP 19613 9903 19 , , , 19613 9903 20 because because IN 19613 9903 21 it -PRON- PRP 19613 9903 22 was be VBD 19613 9903 23 very very RB 19613 9903 24 soon soon RB 19613 9903 25 accounted account VBN 19613 9903 26 heretical heretical JJ 19613 9903 27 . . . 19613 9904 1 We -PRON- PRP 19613 9904 2 see see VBP 19613 9904 3 from from IN 19613 9904 4 c. c. NNP 19613 9904 5 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9904 6 V. V. NNP 19613 9904 7 14 14 CD 19613 9904 8 - - SYM 19613 9904 9 24 24 CD 19613 9904 10 the the DT 19613 9904 11 difficulties difficulty NNS 19613 9904 12 he -PRON- PRP 19613 9904 13 felt feel VBD 19613 9904 14 about about IN 19613 9904 15 the the DT 19613 9904 16 Church Church NNP 19613 9904 17 doctrine doctrine NN 19613 9904 18 of of IN 19613 9904 19 the the DT 19613 9904 20 resurrection resurrection NN 19613 9904 21 of of IN 19613 9904 22 the the DT 19613 9904 23 flesh flesh NN 19613 9904 24 . . . 19613 9904 25 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9905 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9905 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9905 3 807 807 CD 19613 9905 4 : : : 19613 9905 5 See see VB 19613 9905 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 19613 9905 7 , , , 19613 9905 8 H. H. NNP 19613 9905 9 E. E. NNP 19613 9905 10 VI VI NNP 19613 9905 11 . . . 19613 9906 1 37 37 CD 19613 9906 2 . . . 19613 9906 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9907 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9907 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9907 3 808 808 CD 19613 9907 4 : : : 19613 9907 5 Orig Orig NNP 19613 9907 6 . . . 19613 9907 7 , , , 19613 9907 8 Hom Hom NNP 19613 9907 9 . . . 19613 9908 1 II ii CD 19613 9908 2 . . . 19613 9909 1 in in IN 19613 9909 2 Reg Reg NNP 19613 9909 3 . . . 19613 9910 1 I. I. NNP 19613 9910 2 , , , 19613 9910 3 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9910 4 . . . 19613 9911 1 XI XI NNP 19613 9911 2 . . NNP 19613 9911 3 , , , 19613 9911 4 p. p. NN 19613 9911 5 317 317 CD 19613 9911 6 sq sq NNP 19613 9911 7 . . . 19613 9911 8 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9912 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9912 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9912 3 809 809 CD 19613 9912 4 : : : 19613 9912 5 C. C. NNP 19613 9912 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9912 7 . . . 19613 9913 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9913 2 15 15 CD 19613 9913 3 : : : 19613 9913 4 VI VI NNP 19613 9913 5 . . . 19613 9914 1 26 26 CD 19613 9914 2 ; ; : 19613 9914 3 in in IN 19613 9914 4 Lc Lc NNP 19613 9914 5 . . . 19613 9915 1 Hom hom UH 19613 9915 2 . . . 19613 9916 1 XIV XIV NNP 19613 9916 2 . . NNP 19613 9916 3 , , , 19613 9916 4 Lomm Lomm NNP 19613 9916 5 . . . 19613 9917 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9917 2 , , , 19613 9917 3 p. p. NN 19613 9917 4 136 136 CD 19613 9917 5 : : : 19613 9917 6 " " `` 19613 9917 7 Ego Ego NNP 19613 9917 8 puto puto NN 19613 9917 9 , , , 19613 9917 10 quod quod NN 19613 9917 11 et et NNP 19613 9917 12 post post NNP 19613 9917 13 resurrectionem resurrectionem NNP 19613 9917 14 ex ex NNP 19613 9917 15 mortuis mortuis NNP 19613 9917 16 indigeamus indigeamus NNP 19613 9917 17 sacramento sacramento NNP 19613 9917 18 eluente eluente NNP 19613 9917 19 nos nos NNP 19613 9917 20 atque atque NNP 19613 9917 21 purgante purgante NNP 19613 9917 22 " " '' 19613 9917 23 . . . 19613 9918 1 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9918 2 . . . 19613 9918 3 , , , 19613 9918 4 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9918 5 . . . 19613 9919 1 VII VII NNP 19613 9919 2 . . . 19613 9920 1 6 6 CD 19613 9920 2 . . . 19613 9921 1 34 34 CD 19613 9921 2 : : : 19613 9921 3 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9921 4 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9921 5 : : : 19613 9921 6 phamen phaman NNS 19613 9921 7 d d NNP 19613 9921 8 ' ' POS 19613 9921 9 êmeis êmeis NN 19613 9921 10 agiazein agiazein NNP 19613 9921 11 to to IN 19613 9921 12 pur pur NNP 19613 9921 13 , , , 19613 9921 14 ou ou NNP 19613 9921 15 ta ta NNP 19613 9921 16 krea krea NNP 19613 9921 17 , , , 19613 9921 18 alla alla NNP 19613 9921 19 tas tas NNP 19613 9921 20 amartôlous amartôlous JJ 19613 9921 21 psychas psychas NNP 19613 9921 22 , , , 19613 9921 23 pur pur NNP 19613 9921 24 ou ou NNP 19613 9921 25 to to IN 19613 9921 26 pamphagon pamphagon NNP 19613 9921 27 kai kai NNP 19613 9921 28 banauson banauson NNP 19613 9921 29 , , , 19613 9921 30 alla alla NN 19613 9921 31 to to IN 19613 9921 32 phronimon phronimon NN 19613 9921 33 legontes legonte NNS 19613 9921 34 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9921 35 ( ( -LRB- 19613 9921 36 cf cf NN 19613 9921 37 . . . 19613 9922 1 Heraclitus Heraclitus NNP 19613 9922 2 and and CC 19613 9922 3 the the DT 19613 9922 4 Stoa Stoa NNP 19613 9922 5 ) ) -RRB- 19613 9922 6 , , , 19613 9922 7 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9922 8 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9922 9 : : : 19613 9922 10 to to TO 19613 9922 11 duknoumenon duknoumenon VB 19613 9922 12 dia dia NNP 19613 9922 13 psychêa psychêa NNP 19613 9922 14 tês tês NNP 19613 9922 15 dierchomenês dierchomenês NNP 19613 9922 16 to to TO 19613 9922 17 pur pur NNP 19613 9922 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9922 19 . . . 19613 9923 1 For for IN 19613 9923 2 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9923 3 cf cf NNP 19613 9923 4 . . . 19613 9924 1 Bigg Bigg NNP 19613 9924 2 , , , 19613 9924 3 p. p. NN 19613 9924 4 229 229 CD 19613 9924 5 ff ff NN 19613 9924 6 . . . 19613 9925 1 There there EX 19613 9925 2 is be VBZ 19613 9925 3 another another DT 19613 9925 4 and and CC 19613 9925 5 intermediate intermediate JJ 19613 9925 6 stage stage NN 19613 9925 7 between between IN 19613 9925 8 the the DT 19613 9925 9 punishments punishment NNS 19613 9925 10 in in IN 19613 9925 11 hell hell NNP 19613 9925 12 and and CC 19613 9925 13 _ _ NNP 19613 9925 14 regnum regnum NN 19613 9925 15 dei dei NNP 19613 9925 16 _ _ NNP 19613 9925 17 . . . 19613 9925 18 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9926 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9926 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9926 3 810 810 CD 19613 9926 4 : : : 19613 9926 5 See see VB 19613 9926 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9926 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9926 8 : : : 19613 9926 9 peri peri NN 19613 9926 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9926 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9926 12 II II NNP 19613 9926 13 . . . 19613 9927 1 10 10 CD 19613 9927 2 . . . 19613 9928 1 4 4 CD 19613 9928 2 - - SYM 19613 9928 3 7 7 CD 19613 9928 4 ; ; : 19613 9928 5 c. c. NN 19613 9928 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9928 7 . . . 19613 9929 1 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9929 2 . . NNP 19613 9929 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9930 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9930 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9930 3 811 811 CD 19613 9930 4 : : : 19613 9930 5 See see VB 19613 9930 6 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9930 7 Greek Greek NNP 19613 9930 8 : : : 19613 9930 9 peri peri NN 19613 9930 10 archôn archôn NN 19613 9930 11 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9930 12 I. I. NNP 19613 9931 1 6 6 CD 19613 9931 2 . . . 19613 9932 1 1 1 CD 19613 9932 2 - - SYM 19613 9932 3 4 4 CD 19613 9932 4 : : : 19613 9932 5 III iii CD 19613 9932 6 . . . 19613 9933 1 6 6 CD 19613 9933 2 . . . 19613 9934 1 1 1 CD 19613 9934 2 - - SYM 19613 9934 3 8 8 CD 19613 9934 4 ; ; : 19613 9934 5 c. c. NN 19613 9934 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9934 7 . . . 19613 9935 1 VI VI NNP 19613 9935 2 . . . 19613 9936 1 26 26 CD 19613 9936 2 . . . 19613 9936 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9937 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9937 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9937 3 812 812 CD 19613 9937 4 : : : 19613 9937 5 On on IN 19613 9937 6 the the DT 19613 9937 7 seven seven CD 19613 9937 8 heavens heaven NNS 19613 9937 9 in in IN 19613 9937 10 Clem Clem NNP 19613 9937 11 . . . 19613 9938 1 see see VB 19613 9938 2 Strom Strom NNP 19613 9938 3 . . . 19613 9939 1 V. V. NNP 19613 9939 2 II II NNP 19613 9939 3 . . . 19613 9940 1 77 77 CD 19613 9940 2 and and CC 19613 9940 3 other other JJ 19613 9940 4 passages passage NNS 19613 9940 5 . . . 19613 9941 1 Origen Origen NNP 19613 9941 2 does do VBZ 19613 9941 3 not not RB 19613 9941 4 mention mention VB 19613 9941 5 them -PRON- PRP 19613 9941 6 , , , 19613 9941 7 so so RB 19613 9941 8 far far RB 19613 9941 9 as as IN 19613 9941 10 I -PRON- PRP 19613 9941 11 know know VBP 19613 9941 12 . . . 19613 9941 13 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9942 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9942 2 Footnote Footnote NNP 19613 9942 3 813 813 CD 19613 9942 4 : : : 19613 9942 5 c. c. NNP 19613 9942 6 Cels Cels NNP 19613 9942 7 . . . 19613 9943 1 l.c l.c NNP 19613 9943 2 . . NNP 19613 9943 3 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9944 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9944 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9944 3 814 814 CD 19613 9944 4 : : : 19613 9944 5 We -PRON- PRP 19613 9944 6 would would MD 19613 9944 7 be be VB 19613 9944 8 more more RBR 19613 9944 9 justified justified JJ 19613 9944 10 in in IN 19613 9944 11 trying try VBG 19613 9944 12 this this DT 19613 9944 13 with with IN 19613 9944 14 Clement Clement NNP 19613 9944 15 . . . 19613 9944 16 ] ] -RRB- 19613 9945 1 [ [ -LRB- 19613 9945 2 Footnote footnote NN 19613 9945 3 815 815 CD 19613 9945 4 : : : 19613 9945 5 See see VB 19613 9945 6 Bornemann Bornemann NNP 19613 9945 7 , , , 19613 9945 8 In in IN 19613 9945 9 investiganda investiganda NNP 19613 9945 10 monachatus monachatus NNP 19613 9945 11 origine origine NNP 19613 9945 12 quibus quibus NNP 19613 9945 13 de de NNP 19613 9945 14 causis causis NNP 19613 9945 15 ratio ratio NNP 19613 9945 16 habenda habenda NNP 19613 9945 17 sit sit VBP 19613 9945 18 Origenis Origenis NNP 19613 9945 19 . . . 19613 9946 1 Gottingæ Gottingæ NNP 19613 9946 2 1885 1885 CD 19613 9946 3 . . . 19613 9946 4 ] ] -RRB-